id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
29633	1	1	CONTRIBUTIONS	contributions	NN
29633	1	2	FROM	from	IN
29633	1	3	THE	the	DT
29633	1	4	MUSEUM	MUSEUM	NNP
29633	1	5	OF	of	IN
29633	1	6	HISTORY	HISTORY	NNP
29633	1	7	AND	and	CC
29633	1	8	TECHNOLOGY	TECHNOLOGY	NNP
29633	1	9	:	:	:
29633	1	10	PAPER	paper	NN
29633	1	11	3	3	CD
29633	1	12	THE	the	DT
29633	1	13	BEGINNINGS	BEGINNINGS	NNP
29633	1	14	OF	of	IN
29633	1	15	CHEAP	CHEAP	NNP
29633	1	16	STEEL	STEEL	NNP
29633	1	17	_	_	NNP
29633	1	18	Philip	Philip	NNP
29633	1	19	W.	W.	NNP
29633	1	20	Bishop	Bishop	NNP
29633	1	21	_	_	NNP
29633	1	22	STEEL	STEEL	NNP
29633	1	23	BEFORE	before	IN
29633	1	24	THE	the	DT
29633	1	25	1850	1850	CD
29633	1	26	's	's	POS
29633	1	27	29	29	CD
29633	1	28	BESSEMER	BESSEMER	NNP
29633	1	29	AND	and	CC
29633	1	30	HIS	his	PRP$
29633	1	31	COMPETITORS	COMPETITORS	NNP
29633	1	32	30	30	CD
29633	1	33	ROBERT	ROBERT	NNP
29633	1	34	MUSHET	MUSHET	NNP
29633	1	35	33	33	CD
29633	1	36	EBBW	EBBW	NNP
29633	1	37	VALE	vale	NN
29633	1	38	AND	and	CC
29633	1	39	THE	the	DT
29633	1	40	BESSEMER	BESSEMER	NNP
29633	1	41	PROCESS	process	NN
29633	1	42	35	35	CD
29633	1	43	MUSHET	MUSHET	NNS
29633	1	44	AND	and	CC
29633	1	45	BESSEMER	BESSEMER	NNP
29633	1	46	37	37	CD
29633	1	47	WILLIAM	WILLIAM	NNPS
29633	1	48	KELLY	KELLY	NNP
29633	1	49	'S	's	POS
29633	1	50	AIR	AIR	NNP
29633	1	51	-	-	HYPH
29633	1	52	BOILING	BOILING	NNP
29633	1	53	PROCESS	PROCESS	NNP
29633	1	54	42	42	CD
29633	1	55	CONCLUSIONS	conclusion	NNS
29633	1	56	46	46	CD
29633	1	57	THE	the	DT
29633	1	58	BEGINNINGS	beginning	NNS
29633	1	59	OF	of	IN
29633	1	60	CHEAP	cheap	JJ
29633	1	61	STEEL	steel	NN
29633	1	62	By	by	IN
29633	1	63	Philip	Philip	NNP
29633	1	64	W.	W.	NNP
29633	1	65	Bishop	Bishop	NNP
29633	1	66	_	_	NNP
29633	1	67	Other	other	JJ
29633	1	68	inventors	inventor	NNS
29633	1	69	claimed	claim	VBD
29633	1	70	a	a	DT
29633	1	71	part	part	NN
29633	1	72	in	in	IN
29633	1	73	the	the	DT
29633	1	74	invention	invention	NN
29633	1	75	of	of	IN
29633	1	76	the	the	DT
29633	1	77	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	1	78	process	process	NN
29633	1	79	of	of	IN
29633	1	80	making	make	VBG
29633	1	81	steel	steel	NN
29633	1	82	.	.	.
29633	2	1	Here	here	RB
29633	2	2	,	,	,
29633	2	3	the	the	DT
29633	2	4	contemporary	contemporary	JJ
29633	2	5	discussion	discussion	NN
29633	2	6	in	in	IN
29633	2	7	the	the	DT
29633	2	8	technical	technical	JJ
29633	2	9	press	press	NN
29633	2	10	is	be	VBZ
29633	2	11	re	re	VBN
29633	2	12	-	-	VBN
29633	2	13	examined	examine	VBN
29633	2	14	to	to	TO
29633	2	15	throw	throw	VB
29633	2	16	light	light	NN
29633	2	17	on	on	IN
29633	2	18	the	the	DT
29633	2	19	relations	relation	NNS
29633	2	20	of	of	IN
29633	2	21	these	these	DT
29633	2	22	various	various	JJ
29633	2	23	claimants	claimant	NNS
29633	2	24	to	to	IN
29633	2	25	the	the	DT
29633	2	26	iron	iron	NN
29633	2	27	and	and	CC
29633	2	28	steel	steel	NN
29633	2	29	industry	industry	NN
29633	2	30	of	of	IN
29633	2	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	2	32	time	time	NN
29633	2	33	,	,	,
29633	2	34	as	as	IN
29633	2	35	having	have	VBG
29633	2	36	a	a	DT
29633	2	37	possible	possible	JJ
29633	2	38	connection	connection	NN
29633	2	39	with	with	IN
29633	2	40	the	the	DT
29633	2	41	antagonism	antagonism	NN
29633	2	42	shown	show	VBN
29633	2	43	by	by	IN
29633	2	44	the	the	DT
29633	2	45	ironmasters	ironmaster	NNS
29633	2	46	toward	toward	IN
29633	2	47	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	2	48	's	's	POS
29633	2	49	ideas	idea	NNS
29633	2	50	.	.	.
29633	2	51	_	_	NNP
29633	2	52	THE	the	DT
29633	2	53	AUTHOR	AUTHOR	NNP
29633	2	54	:	:	:
29633	2	55	_	_	NNP
29633	2	56	Philip	Philip	NNP
29633	2	57	W.	W.	NNP
29633	2	58	Bishop	Bishop	NNP
29633	2	59	is	be	VBZ
29633	2	60	curator	curator	NN
29633	2	61	of	of	IN
29633	2	62	arts	art	NNS
29633	2	63	and	and	CC
29633	2	64	manufactures	manufacture	NNS
29633	2	65	,	,	,
29633	2	66	Museum	Museum	NNP
29633	2	67	of	of	IN
29633	2	68	History	History	NNP
29633	2	69	and	and	CC
29633	2	70	Technology	Technology	NNP
29633	2	71	,	,	,
29633	2	72	in	in	IN
29633	2	73	the	the	DT
29633	2	74	Smithsonian	Smithsonian	NNP
29633	2	75	Institution	Institution	NNP
29633	2	76	's	's	POS
29633	2	77	United	United	NNP
29633	2	78	States	States	NNP
29633	2	79	National	National	NNP
29633	2	80	Museum	Museum	NNP
29633	2	81	.	.	.
29633	2	82	_	_	NNP
29633	2	83	The	the	DT
29633	2	84	development	development	NN
29633	2	85	of	of	IN
29633	2	86	the	the	DT
29633	2	87	world	world	NN
29633	2	88	's	's	POS
29633	2	89	productive	productive	JJ
29633	2	90	resources	resource	NNS
29633	2	91	during	during	IN
29633	2	92	the	the	DT
29633	2	93	19th	19th	JJ
29633	2	94	century	century	NN
29633	2	95	,	,	,
29633	2	96	accelerated	accelerate	VBN
29633	2	97	in	in	IN
29633	2	98	general	general	JJ
29633	2	99	by	by	IN
29633	2	100	major	major	JJ
29633	2	101	innovations	innovation	NNS
29633	2	102	in	in	IN
29633	2	103	the	the	DT
29633	2	104	field	field	NN
29633	2	105	of	of	IN
29633	2	106	power	power	NN
29633	2	107	,	,	,
29633	2	108	transportation	transportation	NN
29633	2	109	,	,	,
29633	2	110	and	and	CC
29633	2	111	textiles	textile	NNS
29633	2	112	,	,	,
29633	2	113	was	be	VBD
29633	2	114	retarded	retard	VBN
29633	2	115	by	by	IN
29633	2	116	the	the	DT
29633	2	117	occurrence	occurrence	NN
29633	2	118	of	of	IN
29633	2	119	certain	certain	JJ
29633	2	120	bottlenecks	bottleneck	NNS
29633	2	121	.	.	.
29633	3	1	One	one	CD
29633	3	2	of	of	IN
29633	3	3	these	these	DT
29633	3	4	affected	affect	VBD
29633	3	5	the	the	DT
29633	3	6	flow	flow	NN
29633	3	7	of	of	IN
29633	3	8	suitable	suitable	JJ
29633	3	9	and	and	CC
29633	3	10	economical	economical	JJ
29633	3	11	raw	raw	JJ
29633	3	12	materials	material	NNS
29633	3	13	to	to	IN
29633	3	14	the	the	DT
29633	3	15	machine	machine	NN
29633	3	16	tool	tool	NN
29633	3	17	and	and	CC
29633	3	18	transportation	transportation	NN
29633	3	19	industries	industry	NNS
29633	3	20	:	:	:
29633	3	21	in	in	IN
29633	3	22	spite	spite	NN
29633	3	23	of	of	IN
29633	3	24	a	a	DT
29633	3	25	rapid	rapid	JJ
29633	3	26	growth	growth	NN
29633	3	27	of	of	IN
29633	3	28	iron	iron	NN
29633	3	29	production	production	NN
29633	3	30	,	,	,
29633	3	31	the	the	DT
29633	3	32	methods	method	NNS
29633	3	33	of	of	IN
29633	3	34	making	make	VBG
29633	3	35	steel	steel	NN
29633	3	36	remained	remain	VBD
29633	3	37	as	as	IN
29633	3	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	3	39	were	be	VBD
29633	3	40	in	in	IN
29633	3	41	the	the	DT
29633	3	42	previous	previous	JJ
29633	3	43	century	century	NN
29633	3	44	;	;	:
29633	3	45	and	and	CC
29633	3	46	outputs	output	NNS
29633	3	47	remained	remain	VBD
29633	3	48	negligible	negligible	JJ
29633	3	49	.	.	.
29633	4	1	In	in	IN
29633	4	2	the	the	DT
29633	4	3	decade	decade	NN
29633	4	4	1855	1855	CD
29633	4	5	-	-	SYM
29633	4	6	1865	1865	CD
29633	4	7	,	,	,
29633	4	8	this	this	DT
29633	4	9	situation	situation	NN
29633	4	10	was	be	VBD
29633	4	11	completely	completely	RB
29633	4	12	changed	change	VBN
29633	4	13	in	in	IN
29633	4	14	Great	Great	NNP
29633	4	15	Britain	Britain	NNP
29633	4	16	and	and	CC
29633	4	17	in	in	IN
29633	4	18	Europe	Europe	NNP
29633	4	19	generally	generally	RB
29633	4	20	;	;	:
29633	4	21	and	and	CC
29633	4	22	when	when	WRB
29633	4	23	the	the	DT
29633	4	24	United	United	NNP
29633	4	25	States	States	NNP
29633	4	26	emerged	emerge	VBD
29633	4	27	from	from	IN
29633	4	28	the	the	DT
29633	4	29	Civil	Civil	NNP
29633	4	30	War	War	NNP
29633	4	31	,	,	,
29633	4	32	that	that	DT
29633	4	33	country	country	NN
29633	4	34	found	find	VBD
29633	4	35	itself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	4	36	in	in	IN
29633	4	37	a	a	DT
29633	4	38	position	position	NN
29633	4	39	to	to	TO
29633	4	40	take	take	VB
29633	4	41	advantage	advantage	NN
29633	4	42	of	of	IN
29633	4	43	the	the	DT
29633	4	44	European	european	JJ
29633	4	45	innovations	innovation	NNS
29633	4	46	and	and	CC
29633	4	47	to	to	TO
29633	4	48	start	start	VB
29633	4	49	a	a	DT
29633	4	50	period	period	NN
29633	4	51	of	of	IN
29633	4	52	growth	growth	NN
29633	4	53	which	which	WDT
29633	4	54	,	,	,
29633	4	55	in	in	IN
29633	4	56	the	the	DT
29633	4	57	next	next	JJ
29633	4	58	50	50	CD
29633	4	59	years	year	NNS
29633	4	60	,	,	,
29633	4	61	was	be	VBD
29633	4	62	to	to	TO
29633	4	63	establish	establish	VB
29633	4	64	her	-PRON-	PRP
29633	4	65	as	as	IN
29633	4	66	the	the	DT
29633	4	67	world	world	NN
29633	4	68	's	's	POS
29633	4	69	largest	large	JJS
29633	4	70	producer	producer	NN
29633	4	71	of	of	IN
29633	4	72	steel	steel	NN
29633	4	73	.	.	.
29633	5	1	This	this	DT
29633	5	2	study	study	NN
29633	5	3	reviews	review	VBZ
29633	5	4	the	the	DT
29633	5	5	controversy	controversy	NN
29633	5	6	as	as	IN
29633	5	7	to	to	IN
29633	5	8	the	the	DT
29633	5	9	origin	origin	NN
29633	5	10	of	of	IN
29633	5	11	the	the	DT
29633	5	12	process	process	NN
29633	5	13	which	which	WDT
29633	5	14	,	,	,
29633	5	15	for	for	IN
29633	5	16	more	more	JJR
29633	5	17	than	than	IN
29633	5	18	35	35	CD
29633	5	19	years[1	years[1	NNP
29633	5	20	]	]	-RRB-
29633	5	21	provided	provide	VBD
29633	5	22	the	the	DT
29633	5	23	greater	great	JJR
29633	5	24	part	part	NN
29633	5	25	of	of	IN
29633	5	26	the	the	DT
29633	5	27	steel	steel	NN
29633	5	28	production	production	NN
29633	5	29	of	of	IN
29633	5	30	the	the	DT
29633	5	31	United	United	NNP
29633	5	32	States	States	NNP
29633	5	33	.	.	.
29633	6	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	6	2	concerns	concern	VBZ
29633	6	3	four	four	CD
29633	6	4	men	man	NNS
29633	6	5	for	for	IN
29633	6	6	whom	whom	WP
29633	6	7	priority	priority	NN
29633	6	8	of	of	IN
29633	6	9	invention	invention	NN
29633	6	10	in	in	IN
29633	6	11	one	one	CD
29633	6	12	or	or	CC
29633	6	13	more	more	JJR
29633	6	14	aspects	aspect	NNS
29633	6	15	of	of	IN
29633	6	16	the	the	DT
29633	6	17	process	process	NN
29633	6	18	has	have	VBZ
29633	6	19	been	be	VBN
29633	6	20	claimed	claim	VBN
29633	6	21	.	.	.
29633	7	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	7	2	1	1	LS
29633	7	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	7	4	From	from	IN
29633	7	5	1870	1870	CD
29633	7	6	through	through	IN
29633	7	7	1907	1907	CD
29633	7	8	,	,	,
29633	7	9	"	"	``
29633	7	10	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	7	11	"	"	''
29633	7	12	production	production	NN
29633	7	13	accounted	account	VBD
29633	7	14	for	for	IN
29633	7	15	not	not	RB
29633	7	16	less	less	JJR
29633	7	17	than	than	IN
29633	7	18	50	50	CD
29633	7	19	percent	percent	NN
29633	7	20	of	of	IN
29633	7	21	United	United	NNP
29633	7	22	States	States	NNP
29633	7	23	steel	steel	NN
29633	7	24	production	production	NN
29633	7	25	.	.	.
29633	8	1	From	from	IN
29633	8	2	1880	1880	CD
29633	8	3	through	through	IN
29633	8	4	1895	1895	CD
29633	8	5	,	,	,
29633	8	6	80	80	CD
29633	8	7	percent	percent	NN
29633	8	8	of	of	IN
29633	8	9	all	all	DT
29633	8	10	steel	steel	NN
29633	8	11	came	come	VBD
29633	8	12	from	from	IN
29633	8	13	this	this	DT
29633	8	14	source	source	NN
29633	8	15	:	:	:
29633	8	16	Historical	historical	JJ
29633	8	17	Statistics	Statistics	NNPS
29633	8	18	of	of	IN
29633	8	19	the	the	DT
29633	8	20	United	United	NNP
29633	8	21	States	States	NNP
29633	8	22	1789	1789	CD
29633	8	23	-	-	SYM
29633	8	24	1945	1945	CD
29633	8	25	(	(	-LRB-
29633	8	26	Washington	Washington	NNP
29633	8	27	,	,	,
29633	8	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	8	29	Department	Department	NNP
29633	8	30	of	of	IN
29633	8	31	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
29633	8	32	,	,	,
29633	8	33	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
29633	8	34	of	of	IN
29633	8	35	the	the	DT
29633	8	36	Census	Census	NNP
29633	8	37	,	,	,
29633	8	38	1949	1949	CD
29633	8	39	)	)	-RRB-
29633	8	40	,	,	,
29633	8	41	Tables	Tables	NNP
29633	8	42	J.	J.	NNP
29633	9	1	165	165	CD
29633	9	2	-	-	SYM
29633	9	3	170	170	CD
29633	9	4	at	at	IN
29633	9	5	p.	p.	NN
29633	9	6	187	187	CD
29633	9	7	.	.	.
29633	10	1	The	the	DT
29633	10	2	process	process	NN
29633	10	3	consists	consist	VBZ
29633	10	4	in	in	IN
29633	10	5	forcing	force	VBG
29633	10	6	through	through	IN
29633	10	7	molten	molten	JJ
29633	10	8	cast	cast	NN
29633	10	9	iron	iron	NN
29633	10	10	,	,	,
29633	10	11	held	hold	VBN
29633	10	12	in	in	IN
29633	10	13	a	a	DT
29633	10	14	vessel	vessel	NN
29633	10	15	called	call	VBN
29633	10	16	a	a	DT
29633	10	17	converter	converter	NN
29633	10	18	,	,	,
29633	10	19	a	a	DT
29633	10	20	stream	stream	NN
29633	10	21	of	of	IN
29633	10	22	cold	cold	JJ
29633	10	23	air	air	NN
29633	10	24	under	under	IN
29633	10	25	pressure	pressure	NN
29633	10	26	.	.	.
29633	11	1	The	the	DT
29633	11	2	combination	combination	NN
29633	11	3	of	of	IN
29633	11	4	the	the	DT
29633	11	5	oxygen	oxygen	NN
29633	11	6	in	in	IN
29633	11	7	the	the	DT
29633	11	8	air	air	NN
29633	11	9	with	with	IN
29633	11	10	the	the	DT
29633	11	11	silicon	silicon	NN
29633	11	12	and	and	CC
29633	11	13	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	11	14	in	in	IN
29633	11	15	the	the	DT
29633	11	16	metal	metal	NN
29633	11	17	raises	raise	VBZ
29633	11	18	the	the	DT
29633	11	19	temperature	temperature	NN
29633	11	20	of	of	IN
29633	11	21	the	the	DT
29633	11	22	latter	latter	JJ
29633	11	23	in	in	IN
29633	11	24	a	a	DT
29633	11	25	spectacular	spectacular	JJ
29633	11	26	way	way	NN
29633	11	27	and	and	CC
29633	11	28	after	after	IN
29633	11	29	"	"	``
29633	11	30	blowing	blow	VBG
29633	11	31	"	"	''
29633	11	32	for	for	IN
29633	11	33	a	a	DT
29633	11	34	certain	certain	JJ
29633	11	35	period	period	NN
29633	11	36	,	,	,
29633	11	37	eliminates	eliminate	VBZ
29633	11	38	the	the	DT
29633	11	39	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	11	40	from	from	IN
29633	11	41	the	the	DT
29633	11	42	metal	metal	NN
29633	11	43	.	.	.
29633	12	1	Since	since	IN
29633	12	2	steel	steel	NN
29633	12	3	of	of	IN
29633	12	4	various	various	JJ
29633	12	5	qualities	quality	NNS
29633	12	6	demands	demand	VBZ
29633	12	7	the	the	DT
29633	12	8	inclusion	inclusion	NN
29633	12	9	of	of	IN
29633	12	10	from	from	IN
29633	12	11	0.15	0.15	CD
29633	12	12	to	to	TO
29633	12	13	1.70	1.70	CD
29633	12	14	percent	percent	NN
29633	12	15	of	of	IN
29633	12	16	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	12	17	,	,	,
29633	12	18	the	the	DT
29633	12	19	blow	blow	NN
29633	12	20	has	have	VBZ
29633	12	21	to	to	TO
29633	12	22	be	be	VB
29633	12	23	terminated	terminate	VBN
29633	12	24	before	before	IN
29633	12	25	the	the	DT
29633	12	26	elimination	elimination	NN
29633	12	27	of	of	IN
29633	12	28	the	the	DT
29633	12	29	whole	whole	JJ
29633	12	30	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	12	31	content	content	NN
29633	12	32	;	;	:
29633	12	33	or	or	CC
29633	12	34	if	if	IN
29633	12	35	the	the	DT
29633	12	36	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	12	37	content	content	NN
29633	12	38	has	have	VBZ
29633	12	39	been	be	VBN
29633	12	40	eliminated	eliminate	VBN
29633	12	41	the	the	DT
29633	12	42	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
29633	12	43	percentage	percentage	NN
29633	12	44	of	of	IN
29633	12	45	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	12	46	has	have	VBZ
29633	12	47	to	to	TO
29633	12	48	be	be	VB
29633	12	49	put	put	VBN
29633	12	50	back	back	RB
29633	12	51	.	.	.
29633	13	1	This	this	DT
29633	13	2	latter	latter	JJ
29633	13	3	operation	operation	NN
29633	13	4	is	be	VBZ
29633	13	5	carried	carry	VBN
29633	13	6	out	out	RP
29633	13	7	by	by	IN
29633	13	8	adding	add	VBG
29633	13	9	a	a	DT
29633	13	10	precise	precise	JJ
29633	13	11	quantity	quantity	NN
29633	13	12	of	of	IN
29633	13	13	manganiferous	manganiferous	JJ
29633	13	14	pig	pig	NN
29633	13	15	-	-	HYPH
29633	13	16	iron	iron	NN
29633	13	17	(	(	-LRB-
29633	13	18	spiegeleisen	spiegeleisen	NN
29633	13	19	)	)	-RRB-
29633	13	20	or	or	CC
29633	13	21	ferromanganese	ferromanganese	NNP
29633	13	22	,	,	,
29633	13	23	the	the	DT
29633	13	24	manganese	manganese	JJ
29633	13	25	serving	serve	VBG
29633	13	26	to	to	TO
29633	13	27	remove	remove	VB
29633	13	28	the	the	DT
29633	13	29	oxygen	oxygen	NN
29633	13	30	,	,	,
29633	13	31	which	which	WDT
29633	13	32	has	have	VBZ
29633	13	33	combined	combine	VBN
29633	13	34	with	with	IN
29633	13	35	the	the	DT
29633	13	36	iron	iron	NN
29633	13	37	during	during	IN
29633	13	38	the	the	DT
29633	13	39	blow	blow	NN
29633	13	40	.	.	.
29633	14	1	The	the	DT
29633	14	2	controversy	controversy	NN
29633	14	3	which	which	WDT
29633	14	4	surrounded	surround	VBD
29633	14	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	14	6	development	development	NN
29633	14	7	concerned	concern	VBD
29633	14	8	two	two	CD
29633	14	9	aspects	aspect	NNS
29633	14	10	of	of	IN
29633	14	11	the	the	DT
29633	14	12	process	process	NN
29633	14	13	:	:	:
29633	14	14	The	the	DT
29633	14	15	use	use	NN
29633	14	16	of	of	IN
29633	14	17	the	the	DT
29633	14	18	cold	cold	JJ
29633	14	19	air	air	NN
29633	14	20	blast	blast	NN
29633	14	21	to	to	TO
29633	14	22	raise	raise	VB
29633	14	23	the	the	DT
29633	14	24	temperature	temperature	NN
29633	14	25	of	of	IN
29633	14	26	the	the	DT
29633	14	27	molten	molten	JJ
29633	14	28	metal	metal	NN
29633	14	29	,	,	,
29633	14	30	and	and	CC
29633	14	31	the	the	DT
29633	14	32	application	application	NN
29633	14	33	of	of	IN
29633	14	34	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	14	35	to	to	TO
29633	14	36	overcome	overcome	VB
29633	14	37	the	the	DT
29633	14	38	problem	problem	NN
29633	14	39	of	of	IN
29633	14	40	control	control	NN
29633	14	41	of	of	IN
29633	14	42	the	the	DT
29633	14	43	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	14	44	and	and	CC
29633	14	45	oxygen	oxygen	NN
29633	14	46	content	content	NN
29633	14	47	.	.	.
29633	15	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	15	2	,	,	,
29633	15	3	who	who	WP
29633	15	4	began	begin	VBD
29633	15	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	15	6	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	15	7	in	in	IN
29633	15	8	the	the	DT
29633	15	9	making	making	NN
29633	15	10	of	of	IN
29633	15	11	iron	iron	NN
29633	15	12	and	and	CC
29633	15	13	steel	steel	NN
29633	15	14	in	in	IN
29633	15	15	1854	1854	CD
29633	15	16	,	,	,
29633	15	17	secured	secure	VBD
29633	15	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	15	19	first	first	JJ
29633	15	20	patent	patent	NN
29633	15	21	in	in	IN
29633	15	22	Great	Great	NNP
29633	15	23	Britain	Britain	NNP
29633	15	24	in	in	IN
29633	15	25	January	January	NNP
29633	15	26	1855	1855	CD
29633	15	27	,	,	,
29633	15	28	and	and	CC
29633	15	29	was	be	VBD
29633	15	30	persuaded	persuade	VBN
29633	15	31	to	to	TO
29633	15	32	present	present	VB
29633	15	33	information	information	NN
29633	15	34	about	about	IN
29633	15	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	15	36	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	15	37	to	to	IN
29633	15	38	a	a	DT
29633	15	39	meeting	meeting	NN
29633	15	40	of	of	IN
29633	15	41	the	the	DT
29633	15	42	British	British	NNP
29633	15	43	Association	Association	NNP
29633	15	44	for	for	IN
29633	15	45	the	the	DT
29633	15	46	Advancement	Advancement	NNP
29633	15	47	of	of	IN
29633	15	48	Science	Science	NNP
29633	15	49	held	hold	VBN
29633	15	50	at	at	IN
29633	15	51	Cheltenham	Cheltenham	NNP
29633	15	52	,	,	,
29633	15	53	Gloucestershire	Gloucestershire	NNP
29633	15	54	,	,	,
29633	15	55	in	in	IN
29633	15	56	August	August	NNP
29633	15	57	1856	1856	CD
29633	15	58	.	.	.
29633	16	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	16	2	title	title	NN
29633	16	3	"	"	``
29633	16	4	The	the	DT
29633	16	5	Manufacture	Manufacture	NNP
29633	16	6	of	of	IN
29633	16	7	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	16	8	without	without	IN
29633	16	9	Fuel	Fuel	NNP
29633	16	10	"	"	''
29633	16	11	was	be	VBD
29633	16	12	given	give	VBN
29633	16	13	wide	wide	JJ
29633	16	14	publicity	publicity	NN
29633	16	15	in	in	IN
29633	16	16	Great	Great	NNP
29633	16	17	Britain	Britain	NNP
29633	16	18	and	and	CC
29633	16	19	in	in	IN
29633	16	20	the	the	DT
29633	16	21	United	United	NNP
29633	16	22	States	States	NNP
29633	16	23	.	.	.
29633	17	1	Among	among	IN
29633	17	2	those	those	DT
29633	17	3	who	who	WP
29633	17	4	wrote	write	VBD
29633	17	5	to	to	IN
29633	17	6	the	the	DT
29633	17	7	papers	paper	NNS
29633	17	8	to	to	TO
29633	17	9	contest	contest	VB
29633	17	10	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	17	11	's	's	POS
29633	17	12	theories	theory	NNS
29633	17	13	were	be	VBD
29633	17	14	several	several	JJ
29633	17	15	claimants	claimant	NNS
29633	17	16	to	to	IN
29633	17	17	priority	priority	NN
29633	17	18	of	of	IN
29633	17	19	invention	invention	NN
29633	17	20	.	.	.
29633	18	1	Two	two	CD
29633	18	2	men	man	NNS
29633	18	3	claimed	claim	VBD
29633	18	4	that	that	IN
29633	18	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	18	6	had	have	VBD
29633	18	7	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
29633	18	8	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	18	9	in	in	IN
29633	18	10	the	the	DT
29633	18	11	invention	invention	NN
29633	18	12	of	of	IN
29633	18	13	a	a	DT
29633	18	14	method	method	NN
29633	18	15	of	of	IN
29633	18	16	treating	treat	VBG
29633	18	17	molten	molten	JJ
29633	18	18	metal	metal	NN
29633	18	19	with	with	IN
29633	18	20	air	air	NN
29633	18	21	-	-	HYPH
29633	18	22	blasts	blast	NNS
29633	18	23	for	for	IN
29633	18	24	the	the	DT
29633	18	25	purpose	purpose	NN
29633	18	26	of	of	IN
29633	18	27	"	"	``
29633	18	28	purifying	purifying	NN
29633	18	29	"	"	''
29633	18	30	or	or	CC
29633	18	31	decarbonizing	decarbonize	VBG
29633	18	32	iron	iron	NN
29633	18	33	.	.	.
29633	19	1	Both	both	DT
29633	19	2	were	be	VBD
29633	19	3	Americans	Americans	NNPS
29633	19	4	.	.	.
29633	20	1	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
29633	20	2	Gilbert	Gilbert	NNP
29633	20	3	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	20	4	,	,	,
29633	20	5	of	of	IN
29633	20	6	Newark	Newark	NNP
29633	20	7	,	,	,
29633	20	8	New	New	NNP
29633	20	9	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
29633	20	10	,	,	,
29633	20	11	who	who	WP
29633	20	12	at	at	IN
29633	20	13	the	the	DT
29633	20	14	time	time	NN
29633	20	15	of	of	IN
29633	20	16	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	20	17	's	's	POS
29633	20	18	address	address	NN
29633	20	19	was	be	VBD
29633	20	20	working	work	VBG
29633	20	21	at	at	IN
29633	20	22	the	the	DT
29633	20	23	plant	plant	NN
29633	20	24	of	of	IN
29633	20	25	the	the	DT
29633	20	26	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	20	27	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	20	28	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	20	29	Works	Works	NNP
29633	20	30	,	,	,
29633	20	31	in	in	IN
29633	20	32	South	South	NNP
29633	20	33	Wales	Wales	NNP
29633	20	34	,	,	,
29633	20	35	secured	secure	VBD
29633	20	36	a	a	DT
29633	20	37	provisional	provisional	JJ
29633	20	38	patent	patent	NN
29633	20	39	a	a	DT
29633	20	40	few	few	JJ
29633	20	41	days	day	NNS
29633	20	42	before	before	IN
29633	20	43	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	20	44	obtained	obtain	VBD
29633	20	45	one	one	CD
29633	20	46	of	of	IN
29633	20	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	20	48	series	series	NN
29633	20	49	of	of	IN
29633	20	50	patents	patent	NNS
29633	20	51	for	for	IN
29633	20	52	making	make	VBG
29633	20	53	cast	cast	VBN
29633	20	54	steel	steel	NN
29633	20	55	,	,	,
29633	20	56	a	a	DT
29633	20	57	circumstance	circumstance	NN
29633	20	58	which	which	WDT
29633	20	59	provided	provide	VBD
29633	20	60	ammunition	ammunition	NN
29633	20	61	for	for	IN
29633	20	62	those	those	DT
29633	20	63	who	who	WP
29633	20	64	wished	wish	VBD
29633	20	65	to	to	TO
29633	20	66	dispute	dispute	VB
29633	20	67	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	20	68	's	's	POS
29633	20	69	somewhat	somewhat	RB
29633	20	70	spectacular	spectacular	JJ
29633	20	71	claims	claim	NNS
29633	20	72	.	.	.
29633	21	1	William	William	NNP
29633	21	2	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	21	3	,	,	,
29633	21	4	an	an	DT
29633	21	5	ironmaster	ironmaster	NN
29633	21	6	of	of	IN
29633	21	7	Eddyville	Eddyville	NNP
29633	21	8	,	,	,
29633	21	9	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
29633	21	10	,	,	,
29633	21	11	brought	bring	VBN
29633	21	12	into	into	IN
29633	21	13	action	action	NN
29633	21	14	by	by	IN
29633	21	15	an	an	DT
29633	21	16	American	american	JJ
29633	21	17	report	report	NN
29633	21	18	of	of	IN
29633	21	19	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	21	20	's	's	POS
29633	21	21	British	British	NNP
29633	21	22	Association	Association	NNP
29633	21	23	paper	paper	NN
29633	21	24	,	,	,
29633	21	25	opposed	oppose	VBD
29633	21	26	the	the	DT
29633	21	27	granting	granting	NN
29633	21	28	of	of	IN
29633	21	29	a	a	DT
29633	21	30	United	United	NNP
29633	21	31	States	States	NNP
29633	21	32	patent	patent	NN
29633	21	33	to	to	IN
29633	21	34	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	21	35	and	and	CC
29633	21	36	substantiated	substantiate	VBD
29633	21	37	,	,	,
29633	21	38	to	to	IN
29633	21	39	the	the	DT
29633	21	40	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
29633	21	41	of	of	IN
29633	21	42	the	the	DT
29633	21	43	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	21	44	of	of	IN
29633	21	45	Patents	Patents	NNP
29633	21	46	,	,	,
29633	21	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	21	48	claim	claim	NN
29633	21	49	to	to	IN
29633	21	50	priority	priority	NN
29633	21	51	in	in	IN
29633	21	52	the	the	DT
29633	21	53	"	"	``
29633	21	54	air	air	NN
29633	21	55	boiling	boiling	NN
29633	21	56	"	"	''
29633	21	57	process	process	NN
29633	21	58	.	.	.
29633	22	1	A	a	DT
29633	22	2	third	third	JJ
29633	22	3	man	man	NN
29633	22	4	,	,	,
29633	22	5	this	this	DT
29633	22	6	one	one	NN
29633	22	7	a	a	DT
29633	22	8	Scot	Scot	NNP
29633	22	9	resident	resident	NN
29633	22	10	in	in	IN
29633	22	11	England	England	NNP
29633	22	12	,	,	,
29633	22	13	intervened	intervene	VBD
29633	22	14	to	to	TO
29633	22	15	claim	claim	VB
29633	22	16	that	that	IN
29633	22	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	22	18	had	have	VBD
29633	22	19	devised	devise	VBN
29633	22	20	the	the	DT
29633	22	21	means	mean	NNS
29633	22	22	whereby	whereby	WRB
29633	22	23	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	22	24	's	's	POS
29633	22	25	and	and	CC
29633	22	26	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	22	27	's	's	POS
29633	22	28	ideas	idea	NNS
29633	22	29	could	could	MD
29633	22	30	be	be	VB
29633	22	31	made	make	VBN
29633	22	32	practical	practical	JJ
29633	22	33	.	.	.
29633	23	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	23	2	was	be	VBD
29633	23	3	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	23	4	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	23	5	of	of	IN
29633	23	6	Coleford	Coleford	NNP
29633	23	7	,	,	,
29633	23	8	Gloucestershire	Gloucestershire	NNP
29633	23	9	,	,	,
29633	23	10	a	a	DT
29633	23	11	metallurgist	metallurgist	NN
29633	23	12	and	and	CC
29633	23	13	self	self	NN
29633	23	14	-	-	HYPH
29633	23	15	appointed	appoint	VBN
29633	23	16	"	"	``
29633	23	17	sage	sage	NN
29633	23	18	"	"	''
29633	23	19	of	of	IN
29633	23	20	the	the	DT
29633	23	21	British	british	JJ
29633	23	22	iron	iron	NN
29633	23	23	and	and	CC
29633	23	24	steel	steel	NN
29633	23	25	industry	industry	NN
29633	23	26	who	who	WP
29633	23	27	also	also	RB
29633	23	28	was	be	VBD
29633	23	29	associated	associate	VBN
29633	23	30	with	with	IN
29633	23	31	the	the	DT
29633	23	32	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	23	33	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	23	34	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	23	35	Works	Works	NNP
29633	23	36	as	as	IN
29633	23	37	a	a	DT
29633	23	38	consultant	consultant	NN
29633	23	39	.	.	.
29633	24	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	24	2	,	,	,
29633	24	3	like	like	IN
29633	24	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	24	5	American	american	JJ
29633	24	6	contemporaries	contemporary	NNS
29633	24	7	,	,	,
29633	24	8	has	have	VBZ
29633	24	9	become	become	VBN
29633	24	10	established	establish	VBN
29633	24	11	in	in	IN
29633	24	12	the	the	DT
29633	24	13	public	public	JJ
29633	24	14	mind	mind	NN
29633	24	15	as	as	IN
29633	24	16	one	one	CD
29633	24	17	upon	upon	IN
29633	24	18	whom	whom	WP
29633	24	19	Henry	Henry	NNP
29633	24	20	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	24	21	was	be	VBD
29633	24	22	dependent	dependent	JJ
29633	24	23	for	for	IN
29633	24	24	the	the	DT
29633	24	25	origin	origin	NN
29633	24	26	and	and	CC
29633	24	27	success	success	NN
29633	24	28	of	of	IN
29633	24	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	24	30	process	process	NN
29633	24	31	.	.	.
29633	25	1	Since	since	IN
29633	25	2	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	25	3	was	be	VBD
29633	25	4	the	the	DT
29633	25	5	only	only	JJ
29633	25	6	one	one	CD
29633	25	7	of	of	IN
29633	25	8	the	the	DT
29633	25	9	group	group	NN
29633	25	10	to	to	TO
29633	25	11	make	make	VB
29633	25	12	money	money	NN
29633	25	13	from	from	IN
29633	25	14	the	the	DT
29633	25	15	expansion	expansion	NN
29633	25	16	of	of	IN
29633	25	17	the	the	DT
29633	25	18	steel	steel	NN
29633	25	19	industry	industry	NN
29633	25	20	consequent	consequent	NN
29633	25	21	upon	upon	IN
29633	25	22	the	the	DT
29633	25	23	introduction	introduction	NN
29633	25	24	of	of	IN
29633	25	25	the	the	DT
29633	25	26	new	new	JJ
29633	25	27	technique	technique	NN
29633	25	28	,	,	,
29633	25	29	the	the	DT
29633	25	30	suspicion	suspicion	NN
29633	25	31	has	have	VBZ
29633	25	32	remained	remain	VBN
29633	25	33	that	that	IN
29633	25	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	25	35	exploited	exploit	VBD
29633	25	36	the	the	DT
29633	25	37	inventions	invention	NNS
29633	25	38	of	of	IN
29633	25	39	the	the	DT
29633	25	40	others	other	NNS
29633	25	41	,	,	,
29633	25	42	if	if	IN
29633	25	43	indeed	indeed	RB
29633	25	44	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	25	45	did	do	VBD
29633	25	46	not	not	RB
29633	25	47	steal	steal	VB
29633	25	48	them	-PRON-	PRP
29633	25	49	.	.	.
29633	26	1	In	in	IN
29633	26	2	this	this	DT
29633	26	3	study	study	NN
29633	26	4	,	,	,
29633	26	5	based	base	VBN
29633	26	6	largely	largely	RB
29633	26	7	upon	upon	IN
29633	26	8	the	the	DT
29633	26	9	contemporary	contemporary	JJ
29633	26	10	discussion	discussion	NN
29633	26	11	in	in	IN
29633	26	12	the	the	DT
29633	26	13	technical	technical	JJ
29633	26	14	press	press	NN
29633	26	15	,	,	,
29633	26	16	the	the	DT
29633	26	17	relation	relation	NN
29633	26	18	of	of	IN
29633	26	19	the	the	DT
29633	26	20	four	four	CD
29633	26	21	men	man	NNS
29633	26	22	to	to	IN
29633	26	23	each	each	DT
29633	26	24	other	other	JJ
29633	26	25	is	be	VBZ
29633	26	26	re	re	VBN
29633	26	27	-	-	VBN
29633	26	28	examined	examine	VBN
29633	26	29	and	and	CC
29633	26	30	an	an	DT
29633	26	31	attempt	attempt	NN
29633	26	32	is	be	VBZ
29633	26	33	made	make	VBN
29633	26	34	to	to	TO
29633	26	35	place	place	VB
29633	26	36	the	the	DT
29633	26	37	controversy	controversy	NN
29633	26	38	of	of	IN
29633	26	39	1855	1855	CD
29633	26	40	-	-	SYM
29633	26	41	1865	1865	CD
29633	26	42	in	in	IN
29633	26	43	focus	focus	NN
29633	26	44	.	.	.
29633	27	1	The	the	DT
29633	27	2	necessity	necessity	NN
29633	27	3	for	for	IN
29633	27	4	a	a	DT
29633	27	5	reappraisal	reappraisal	NN
29633	27	6	arises	arise	VBZ
29633	27	7	from	from	IN
29633	27	8	the	the	DT
29633	27	9	fact	fact	NN
29633	27	10	that	that	IN
29633	27	11	today	today	NN
29633	27	12	's	's	POS
29633	27	13	references	reference	NNS
29633	27	14	to	to	IN
29633	27	15	the	the	DT
29633	27	16	origin	origin	NN
29633	27	17	of	of	IN
29633	27	18	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	27	19	steel[2	steel[2	,
29633	27	20	]	]	-RRB-
29633	27	21	often	often	RB
29633	27	22	contain	contain	VBP
29633	27	23	chronological	chronological	JJ
29633	27	24	and	and	CC
29633	27	25	other	other	JJ
29633	27	26	inaccuracies	inaccuracy	NNS
29633	27	27	arising	arise	VBG
29633	27	28	in	in	IN
29633	27	29	many	many	JJ
29633	27	30	cases	case	NNS
29633	27	31	from	from	IN
29633	27	32	a	a	DT
29633	27	33	dependence	dependence	NN
29633	27	34	on	on	IN
29633	27	35	secondary	secondary	JJ
29633	27	36	and	and	CC
29633	27	37	sometimes	sometimes	RB
29633	27	38	unreliable	unreliable	JJ
29633	27	39	sources	source	NNS
29633	27	40	.	.	.
29633	28	1	As	as	IN
29633	28	2	a	a	DT
29633	28	3	result	result	NN
29633	28	4	,	,	,
29633	28	5	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	28	6	's	's	POS
29633	28	7	contribution	contribution	NN
29633	28	8	has	have	VBZ
29633	28	9	,	,	,
29633	28	10	perhaps	perhaps	RB
29633	28	11	,	,	,
29633	28	12	been	be	VBN
29633	28	13	overemphasized	overemphasize	VBN
29633	28	14	,	,	,
29633	28	15	with	with	IN
29633	28	16	the	the	DT
29633	28	17	effect	effect	NN
29633	28	18	of	of	IN
29633	28	19	derogating	derogate	VBG
29633	28	20	from	from	IN
29633	28	21	the	the	DT
29633	28	22	work	work	NN
29633	28	23	of	of	IN
29633	28	24	another	another	DT
29633	28	25	American	American	NNP
29633	28	26	,	,	,
29633	28	27	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
29633	28	28	Lyman	Lyman	NNP
29633	28	29	Holley	Holley	NNP
29633	28	30	,	,	,
29633	28	31	who	who	WP
29633	28	32	more	more	RBR
29633	28	33	than	than	IN
29633	28	34	any	any	DT
29633	28	35	man	man	NN
29633	28	36	is	be	VBZ
29633	28	37	entitled	entitle	VBN
29633	28	38	to	to	IN
29633	28	39	credit	credit	NN
29633	28	40	for	for	IN
29633	28	41	establishing	establish	VBG
29633	28	42	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	28	43	steel	steel	NN
29633	28	44	in	in	IN
29633	28	45	America	America	NNP
29633	28	46	.	.	.
29633	29	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	29	2	3	3	CD
29633	29	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	29	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	29	5	2	2	CD
29633	29	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	29	7	See	see	VB
29633	29	8	especially	especially	RB
29633	29	9	material	material	NN
29633	29	10	distributed	distribute	VBN
29633	29	11	by	by	IN
29633	29	12	the	the	DT
29633	29	13	American	American	NNP
29633	29	14	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	29	15	and	and	CC
29633	29	16	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	29	17	Institute	Institute	NNP
29633	29	18	in	in	IN
29633	29	19	connection	connection	NN
29633	29	20	with	with	IN
29633	29	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	29	22	celebration	celebration	NN
29633	29	23	of	of	IN
29633	29	24	the	the	DT
29633	29	25	centennial	centennial	NN
29633	29	26	of	of	IN
29633	29	27	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	29	28	:	:	:
29633	29	29	"	"	``
29633	29	30	Steel	steel	NN
29633	29	31	centennial	centennial	NN
29633	29	32	(	(	-LRB-
29633	29	33	1957	1957	CD
29633	29	34	)	)	-RRB-
29633	29	35	,	,	,
29633	29	36	press	press	NN
29633	29	37	information	information	NN
29633	29	38	,	,	,
29633	29	39	"	"	''
29633	29	40	prepared	prepare	VBN
29633	29	41	by	by	IN
29633	29	42	Hill	Hill	NNP
29633	29	43	and	and	CC
29633	29	44	Knowlton	Knowlton	NNP
29633	29	45	,	,	,
29633	29	46	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
29633	29	47	,	,	,
29633	29	48	and	and	CC
29633	29	49	released	release	VBN
29633	29	50	by	by	IN
29633	29	51	the	the	DT
29633	29	52	Institute	Institute	NNP
29633	29	53	as	as	IN
29633	29	54	of	of	IN
29633	29	55	May	May	NNP
29633	29	56	1	1	CD
29633	29	57	,	,	,
29633	29	58	1957	1957	CD
29633	29	59	.	.	.
29633	30	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	30	2	3	3	LS
29633	30	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	30	4	Holley	Holley	NNP
29633	30	5	's	's	POS
29633	30	6	work	work	NN
29633	30	7	is	be	VBZ
29633	30	8	outside	outside	IN
29633	30	9	the	the	DT
29633	30	10	scope	scope	NN
29633	30	11	of	of	IN
29633	30	12	this	this	DT
29633	30	13	paper	paper	NN
29633	30	14	.	.	.
29633	31	1	Belatedly	belatedly	RB
29633	31	2	,	,	,
29633	31	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	31	4	biography	biography	NN
29633	31	5	is	be	VBZ
29633	31	6	now	now	RB
29633	31	7	being	be	VBG
29633	31	8	written	write	VBN
29633	31	9	.	.	.
29633	32	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	32	2	can	can	MD
29633	32	3	hardly	hardly	RB
29633	32	4	fail	fail	VB
29633	32	5	to	to	TO
29633	32	6	substantiate	substantiate	VB
29633	32	7	the	the	DT
29633	32	8	contention	contention	NN
29633	32	9	that	that	IN
29633	32	10	during	during	IN
29633	32	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	32	12	short	short	JJ
29633	32	13	life	life	NN
29633	32	14	(	(	-LRB-
29633	32	15	1832	1832	CD
29633	32	16	-	-	SYM
29633	32	17	1882	1882	CD
29633	32	18	)	)	-RRB-
29633	32	19	Holley	Holley	NNP
29633	32	20	,	,	,
29633	32	21	who	who	WP
29633	32	22	negotiated	negotiate	VBD
29633	32	23	the	the	DT
29633	32	24	purchase	purchase	NN
29633	32	25	of	of	IN
29633	32	26	the	the	DT
29633	32	27	American	american	JJ
29633	32	28	rights	right	NNS
29633	32	29	to	to	IN
29633	32	30	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	32	31	's	's	POS
29633	32	32	process	process	NN
29633	32	33	,	,	,
29633	32	34	also	also	RB
29633	32	35	adapted	adapt	VBD
29633	32	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	32	37	methods	method	NNS
29633	32	38	to	to	IN
29633	32	39	the	the	DT
29633	32	40	American	american	JJ
29633	32	41	scene	scene	NN
29633	32	42	and	and	CC
29633	32	43	laid	lay	VBD
29633	32	44	a	a	DT
29633	32	45	substantial	substantial	JJ
29633	32	46	part	part	NN
29633	32	47	of	of	IN
29633	32	48	the	the	DT
29633	32	49	foundation	foundation	NN
29633	32	50	for	for	IN
29633	32	51	the	the	DT
29633	32	52	modern	modern	JJ
29633	32	53	American	american	JJ
29633	32	54	steel	steel	NN
29633	32	55	industry	industry	NN
29633	32	56	.	.	.
29633	33	1	Steel	steel	NN
29633	33	2	Before	before	IN
29633	33	3	the	the	DT
29633	33	4	1850	1850	CD
29633	33	5	's	's	POS
29633	33	6	In	in	IN
29633	33	7	spite	spite	NN
29633	33	8	of	of	IN
29633	33	9	a	a	DT
29633	33	10	rapid	rapid	JJ
29633	33	11	increase	increase	NN
29633	33	12	in	in	IN
29633	33	13	the	the	DT
29633	33	14	use	use	NN
29633	33	15	of	of	IN
29633	33	16	machines	machine	NNS
29633	33	17	and	and	CC
29633	33	18	the	the	DT
29633	33	19	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
29633	33	20	demand	demand	NN
29633	33	21	for	for	IN
29633	33	22	iron	iron	NN
29633	33	23	products	product	NNS
29633	33	24	for	for	IN
29633	33	25	the	the	DT
29633	33	26	expanding	expand	VBG
29633	33	27	railroads	railroad	NNS
29633	33	28	,	,	,
29633	33	29	the	the	DT
29633	33	30	use	use	NN
29633	33	31	of	of	IN
29633	33	32	steel	steel	NN
29633	33	33	had	have	VBD
29633	33	34	expanded	expand	VBN
29633	33	35	little	little	RB
29633	33	36	prior	prior	RB
29633	33	37	to	to	IN
29633	33	38	1855	1855	CD
29633	33	39	.	.	.
29633	34	1	The	the	DT
29633	34	2	methods	method	NNS
29633	34	3	of	of	IN
29633	34	4	production	production	NN
29633	34	5	were	be	VBD
29633	34	6	still	still	RB
29633	34	7	largely	largely	RB
29633	34	8	those	those	DT
29633	34	9	of	of	IN
29633	34	10	a	a	DT
29633	34	11	century	century	NN
29633	34	12	earlier	early	RBR
29633	34	13	.	.	.
29633	35	1	Slow	slow	JJ
29633	35	2	preparation	preparation	NN
29633	35	3	of	of	IN
29633	35	4	the	the	DT
29633	35	5	steel	steel	NN
29633	35	6	by	by	IN
29633	35	7	cementation	cementation	NN
29633	35	8	or	or	CC
29633	35	9	in	in	IN
29633	35	10	crucibles	crucible	NNS
29633	35	11	meant	mean	VBD
29633	35	12	a	a	DT
29633	35	13	disproportionate	disproportionate	JJ
29633	35	14	consumption	consumption	NN
29633	35	15	of	of	IN
29633	35	16	fuel	fuel	NN
29633	35	17	and	and	CC
29633	35	18	a	a	DT
29633	35	19	resulting	result	VBG
29633	35	20	high	high	JJ
29633	35	21	cost	cost	NN
29633	35	22	.	.	.
29633	36	1	Production	production	NN
29633	36	2	in	in	IN
29633	36	3	small	small	JJ
29633	36	4	quantities	quantity	NNS
29633	36	5	prevented	prevent	VBD
29633	36	6	the	the	DT
29633	36	7	adoption	adoption	NN
29633	36	8	of	of	IN
29633	36	9	steel	steel	NN
29633	36	10	in	in	IN
29633	36	11	uses	use	NNS
29633	36	12	which	which	WDT
29633	36	13	required	require	VBD
29633	36	14	large	large	JJ
29633	36	15	initial	initial	JJ
29633	36	16	masses	masse	NNS
29633	36	17	of	of	IN
29633	36	18	metal	metal	NN
29633	36	19	.	.	.
29633	37	1	Steel	steel	NN
29633	37	2	was	be	VBD
29633	37	3	,	,	,
29633	37	4	in	in	IN
29633	37	5	fact	fact	NN
29633	37	6	,	,	,
29633	37	7	a	a	DT
29633	37	8	luxury	luxury	NN
29633	37	9	product	product	NN
29633	37	10	.	.	.
29633	38	1	The	the	DT
29633	38	2	work	work	NN
29633	38	3	of	of	IN
29633	38	4	Réaumur	Réaumur	NNP
29633	38	5	and	and	CC
29633	38	6	,	,	,
29633	38	7	especially	especially	RB
29633	38	8	,	,	,
29633	38	9	of	of	IN
29633	38	10	Huntsman	Huntsman	NNP
29633	38	11	,	,	,
29633	38	12	whose	whose	WP$
29633	38	13	development	development	NN
29633	38	14	of	of	IN
29633	38	15	cast	cast	VBN
29633	38	16	steel	steel	NN
29633	38	17	after	after	IN
29633	38	18	1740	1740	CD
29633	38	19	secured	secure	VBD
29633	38	20	an	an	DT
29633	38	21	international	international	JJ
29633	38	22	reputation	reputation	NN
29633	38	23	for	for	IN
29633	38	24	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	38	25	,	,	,
29633	38	26	had	have	VBD
29633	38	27	established	establish	VBN
29633	38	28	the	the	DT
29633	38	29	cementation	cementation	NN
29633	38	30	and	and	CC
29633	38	31	crucible	crucible	JJ
29633	38	32	processes	process	NNS
29633	38	33	as	as	IN
29633	38	34	the	the	DT
29633	38	35	primary	primary	JJ
29633	38	36	source	source	NN
29633	38	37	of	of	IN
29633	38	38	cast	cast	VBN
29633	38	39	steel	steel	NN
29633	38	40	,	,	,
29633	38	41	for	for	IN
29633	38	42	nearly	nearly	RB
29633	38	43	100	100	CD
29633	38	44	years	year	NNS
29633	38	45	.	.	.
29633	39	1	Josiah	Josiah	NNP
29633	39	2	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
29633	39	3	Heath	Heath	NNP
29633	39	4	's	's	POS
29633	39	5	patents	patent	NNS
29633	39	6	of	of	IN
29633	39	7	1839	1839	CD
29633	39	8	,	,	,
29633	39	9	were	be	VBD
29633	39	10	the	the	DT
29633	39	11	first	first	JJ
29633	39	12	developments	development	NNS
29633	39	13	in	in	IN
29633	39	14	the	the	DT
29633	39	15	direction	direction	NN
29633	39	16	of	of	IN
29633	39	17	cheaper	cheap	JJR
29633	39	18	steel	steel	NN
29633	39	19	,	,	,
29633	39	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	39	21	process	process	NN
29633	39	22	leading	lead	VBG
29633	39	23	to	to	IN
29633	39	24	a	a	DT
29633	39	25	reduction	reduction	NN
29633	39	26	of	of	IN
29633	39	27	from	from	IN
29633	39	28	30	30	CD
29633	39	29	to	to	TO
29633	39	30	40	40	CD
29633	39	31	percent	percent	NN
29633	39	32	in	in	IN
29633	39	33	the	the	DT
29633	39	34	price	price	NN
29633	39	35	of	of	IN
29633	39	36	good	good	JJ
29633	39	37	steel	steel	NN
29633	39	38	in	in	IN
29633	39	39	the	the	DT
29633	39	40	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	39	41	market	market	NN
29633	39	42	.	.	.
29633	40	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	40	2	4	4	LS
29633	40	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	40	4	Heath	Heath	NNP
29633	40	5	's	's	POS
29633	40	6	secret	secret	NN
29633	40	7	was	be	VBD
29633	40	8	the	the	DT
29633	40	9	addition	addition	NN
29633	40	10	to	to	IN
29633	40	11	the	the	DT
29633	40	12	charge	charge	NN
29633	40	13	of	of	IN
29633	40	14	from	from	IN
29633	40	15	1	1	CD
29633	40	16	to	to	IN
29633	40	17	3	3	CD
29633	40	18	percent	percent	NN
29633	40	19	of	of	IN
29633	40	20	carburet	carburet	NN
29633	40	21	of	of	IN
29633	40	22	manganese[5	manganese[5	NNP
29633	40	23	]	]	-RRB-
29633	40	24	as	as	IN
29633	40	25	a	a	DT
29633	40	26	deoxidizer	deoxidizer	NN
29633	40	27	.	.	.
29633	41	1	Heath	Heath	NNP
29633	41	2	's	's	POS
29633	41	3	failure	failure	NN
29633	41	4	to	to	TO
29633	41	5	word	word	VB
29633	41	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	41	7	patent	patent	NN
29633	41	8	so	so	IN
29633	41	9	as	as	IN
29633	41	10	to	to	TO
29633	41	11	cover	cover	VB
29633	41	12	also	also	RB
29633	41	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	41	14	method	method	NN
29633	41	15	of	of	IN
29633	41	16	producing	produce	VBG
29633	41	17	carburet	carburet	NN
29633	41	18	of	of	IN
29633	41	19	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	41	20	led	lead	VBD
29633	41	21	to	to	IN
29633	41	22	the	the	DT
29633	41	23	effective	effective	JJ
29633	41	24	breakdown	breakdown	NN
29633	41	25	of	of	IN
29633	41	26	that	that	DT
29633	41	27	patent	patent	NN
29633	41	28	and	and	CC
29633	41	29	to	to	IN
29633	41	30	the	the	DT
29633	41	31	general	general	JJ
29633	41	32	adoption	adoption	NN
29633	41	33	of	of	IN
29633	41	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	41	35	process	process	NN
29633	41	36	without	without	IN
29633	41	37	payment	payment	NN
29633	41	38	of	of	IN
29633	41	39	license	license	NN
29633	41	40	or	or	CC
29633	41	41	royalty	royalty	NN
29633	41	42	.	.	.
29633	42	1	In	in	IN
29633	42	2	spite	spite	NN
29633	42	3	of	of	IN
29633	42	4	this	this	DT
29633	42	5	reduction	reduction	NN
29633	42	6	in	in	IN
29633	42	7	the	the	DT
29633	42	8	cost	cost	NN
29633	42	9	of	of	IN
29633	42	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	42	11	production	production	NN
29633	42	12	,	,	,
29633	42	13	steel	steel	NN
29633	42	14	remained	remain	VBD
29633	42	15	,	,	,
29633	42	16	until	until	IN
29633	42	17	after	after	IN
29633	42	18	the	the	DT
29633	42	19	midpoint	midpoint	NN
29633	42	20	of	of	IN
29633	42	21	the	the	DT
29633	42	22	century	century	NN
29633	42	23	,	,	,
29633	42	24	an	an	DT
29633	42	25	insignificant	insignificant	JJ
29633	42	26	item	item	NN
29633	42	27	in	in	IN
29633	42	28	the	the	DT
29633	42	29	output	output	NN
29633	42	30	of	of	IN
29633	42	31	the	the	DT
29633	42	32	iron	iron	NN
29633	42	33	and	and	CC
29633	42	34	steel	steel	NN
29633	42	35	industry	industry	NN
29633	42	36	,	,	,
29633	42	37	being	be	VBG
29633	42	38	used	use	VBN
29633	42	39	principally	principally	RB
29633	42	40	in	in	IN
29633	42	41	the	the	DT
29633	42	42	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	42	43	of	of	IN
29633	42	44	cutlery	cutlery	NN
29633	42	45	and	and	CC
29633	42	46	edge	edge	NN
29633	42	47	tools	tool	NNS
29633	42	48	.	.	.
29633	43	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	43	2	4	4	LS
29633	43	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	43	4	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
29633	43	5	Ure	Ure	NNP
29633	43	6	,	,	,
29633	43	7	_	_	NNP
29633	43	8	Dictionary	Dictionary	NNP
29633	43	9	of	of	IN
29633	43	10	arts	art	NNS
29633	43	11	,	,	,
29633	43	12	manufactures	manufacture	NNS
29633	43	13	and	and	CC
29633	43	14	mines	mine	NNS
29633	43	15	_	_	NNP
29633	43	16	,	,	,
29633	43	17	New	New	NNP
29633	43	18	York	York	NNP
29633	43	19	,	,	,
29633	43	20	1856	1856	CD
29633	43	21	,	,	,
29633	43	22	p.	p.	NN
29633	43	23	735	735	CD
29633	43	24	.	.	.
29633	44	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	44	2	5	5	LS
29633	44	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	44	4	See	see	VB
29633	44	5	abridgement	abridgement	NN
29633	44	6	of	of	IN
29633	44	7	British	british	JJ
29633	44	8	patent	patent	NN
29633	44	9	8021	8021	CD
29633	44	10	of	of	IN
29633	44	11	1839	1839	CD
29633	44	12	quoted	quote	VBN
29633	44	13	by	by	IN
29633	44	14	James	James	NNP
29633	44	15	S.	S.	NNP
29633	44	16	Jeans	Jeans	NNP
29633	44	17	,	,	,
29633	44	18	_	_	NNP
29633	44	19	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	44	20	_	_	NNP
29633	44	21	,	,	,
29633	44	22	London	London	NNP
29633	44	23	,	,	,
29633	44	24	1880	1880	CD
29633	44	25	,	,	,
29633	44	26	p.	p.	NN
29633	44	27	28	28	CD
29633	44	28	ff	ff	NN
29633	44	29	.	.	.
29633	45	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	45	2	is	be	VBZ
29633	45	3	not	not	RB
29633	45	4	clear	clear	JJ
29633	45	5	that	that	IN
29633	45	6	Heath	Heath	NNP
29633	45	7	was	be	VBD
29633	45	8	aware	aware	JJ
29633	45	9	of	of	IN
29633	45	10	the	the	DT
29633	45	11	precise	precise	JJ
29633	45	12	chemical	chemical	NN
29633	45	13	effect	effect	NN
29633	45	14	of	of	IN
29633	45	15	the	the	DT
29633	45	16	use	use	NN
29633	45	17	of	of	IN
29633	45	18	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	45	19	in	in	IN
29633	45	20	this	this	DT
29633	45	21	way	way	NN
29633	45	22	.	.	.
29633	46	1	The	the	DT
29633	46	2	stimulus	stimulus	NN
29633	46	3	towards	towards	IN
29633	46	4	new	new	JJ
29633	46	5	methods	method	NNS
29633	46	6	of	of	IN
29633	46	7	making	make	VBG
29633	46	8	steel	steel	NN
29633	46	9	and	and	CC
29633	46	10	,	,	,
29633	46	11	indeed	indeed	RB
29633	46	12	,	,	,
29633	46	13	of	of	IN
29633	46	14	making	make	VBG
29633	46	15	new	new	JJ
29633	46	16	steels	steel	NNS
29633	46	17	came	come	VBD
29633	46	18	curiously	curiously	RB
29633	46	19	enough	enough	RB
29633	46	20	from	from	IN
29633	46	21	outside	outside	IN
29633	46	22	the	the	DT
29633	46	23	established	established	JJ
29633	46	24	industry	industry	NN
29633	46	25	,	,	,
29633	46	26	from	from	IN
29633	46	27	a	a	DT
29633	46	28	man	man	NN
29633	46	29	who	who	WP
29633	46	30	was	be	VBD
29633	46	31	not	not	RB
29633	46	32	an	an	DT
29633	46	33	ironmaster	ironmaster	NN
29633	46	34	--	--	:
29633	46	35	Henry	Henry	NNP
29633	46	36	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	46	37	.	.	.
29633	47	1	The	the	DT
29633	47	2	way	way	NN
29633	47	3	in	in	IN
29633	47	4	which	which	WDT
29633	47	5	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	47	6	challenged	challenge	VBD
29633	47	7	the	the	DT
29633	47	8	trade	trade	NN
29633	47	9	was	be	VBD
29633	47	10	itself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	47	11	unusual	unusual	JJ
29633	47	12	.	.	.
29633	48	1	There	there	EX
29633	48	2	are	be	VBP
29633	48	3	few	few	JJ
29633	48	4	cases	case	NNS
29633	48	5	in	in	IN
29633	48	6	which	which	WDT
29633	48	7	a	a	DT
29633	48	8	stranger	stranger	NN
29633	48	9	to	to	IN
29633	48	10	an	an	DT
29633	48	11	industry	industry	NN
29633	48	12	has	have	VBZ
29633	48	13	taken	take	VBN
29633	48	14	the	the	DT
29633	48	15	risk	risk	NN
29633	48	16	of	of	IN
29633	48	17	giving	give	VBG
29633	48	18	a	a	DT
29633	48	19	description	description	NN
29633	48	20	of	of	IN
29633	48	21	a	a	DT
29633	48	22	new	new	JJ
29633	48	23	process	process	NN
29633	48	24	in	in	IN
29633	48	25	a	a	DT
29633	48	26	public	public	JJ
29633	48	27	forum	forum	NN
29633	48	28	like	like	IN
29633	48	29	a	a	DT
29633	48	30	meeting	meeting	NN
29633	48	31	of	of	IN
29633	48	32	the	the	DT
29633	48	33	British	British	NNP
29633	48	34	Association	Association	NNP
29633	48	35	for	for	IN
29633	48	36	the	the	DT
29633	48	37	Advancement	Advancement	NNP
29633	48	38	of	of	IN
29633	48	39	Science	Science	NNP
29633	48	40	.	.	.
29633	49	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	49	2	challenged	challenge	VBD
29633	49	3	the	the	DT
29633	49	4	trade	trade	NN
29633	49	5	,	,	,
29633	49	6	not	not	RB
29633	49	7	only	only	RB
29633	49	8	to	to	TO
29633	49	9	attack	attack	VB
29633	49	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	49	11	theories	theory	NNS
29633	49	12	but	but	CC
29633	49	13	to	to	TO
29633	49	14	produce	produce	VB
29633	49	15	evidence	evidence	NN
29633	49	16	from	from	IN
29633	49	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	49	18	own	own	JJ
29633	49	19	plants	plant	NNS
29633	49	20	that	that	WDT
29633	49	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	49	22	could	could	MD
29633	49	23	provide	provide	VB
29633	49	24	an	an	DT
29633	49	25	alternative	alternative	JJ
29633	49	26	means	mean	NNS
29633	49	27	of	of	IN
29633	49	28	satisfying	satisfy	VBG
29633	49	29	an	an	DT
29633	49	30	emergent	emergent	JJ
29633	49	31	demand	demand	NN
29633	49	32	.	.	.
29633	50	1	Whether	whether	IN
29633	50	2	or	or	CC
29633	50	3	not	not	RB
29633	50	4	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	50	5	is	be	VBZ
29633	50	6	entitled	entitle	VBN
29633	50	7	to	to	TO
29633	50	8	claim	claim	VB
29633	50	9	priority	priority	NN
29633	50	10	of	of	IN
29633	50	11	invention	invention	NN
29633	50	12	,	,	,
29633	50	13	one	one	PRP
29633	50	14	can	can	MD
29633	50	15	but	but	CC
29633	50	16	agree	agree	VB
29633	50	17	with	with	IN
29633	50	18	the	the	DT
29633	50	19	ironmaster	ironmaster	NN
29633	50	20	who	who	WP
29633	50	21	said:[6	said:[6	VBZ
29633	50	22	]	]	-RRB-
29633	50	23	"	"	``
29633	50	24	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	50	25	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	50	26	has	have	VBZ
29633	50	27	raised	raise	VBN
29633	50	28	such	such	PDT
29633	50	29	a	a	DT
29633	50	30	spirit	spirit	NN
29633	50	31	of	of	IN
29633	50	32	enquiry	enquiry	NN
29633	50	33	throughout	throughout	IN
29633	50	34	...	...	NFP
29633	50	35	the	the	DT
29633	50	36	land	land	NN
29633	50	37	as	as	IN
29633	50	38	must	must	MD
29633	50	39	lead	lead	VB
29633	50	40	to	to	IN
29633	50	41	an	an	DT
29633	50	42	improved	improved	JJ
29633	50	43	system	system	NN
29633	50	44	of	of	IN
29633	50	45	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	50	46	.	.	.
29633	50	47	"	"	''
29633	51	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	51	2	6	6	CD
29633	51	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	51	4	_	_	NNP
29633	51	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	51	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	51	7	_	_	NNP
29633	51	8	,	,	,
29633	51	9	1857	1857	CD
29633	51	10	,	,	,
29633	51	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	51	12	.	.	.
29633	52	1	27	27	CD
29633	52	2	,	,	,
29633	52	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	52	4	465	465	CD
29633	52	5	.	.	.
29633	53	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	53	2	and	and	CC
29633	53	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	53	4	Competitors	Competitors	NNP
29633	53	5	Henry	Henry	NNP
29633	53	6	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	53	7	(	(	-LRB-
29633	53	8	1813	1813	CD
29633	53	9	-	-	SYM
29633	53	10	1898	1898	CD
29633	53	11	)	)	-RRB-
29633	53	12	,	,	,
29633	53	13	an	an	DT
29633	53	14	Englishman	Englishman	NNP
29633	53	15	of	of	IN
29633	53	16	French	french	JJ
29633	53	17	extraction	extraction	NN
29633	53	18	,	,	,
29633	53	19	was	be	VBD
29633	53	20	the	the	DT
29633	53	21	son	son	NN
29633	53	22	of	of	IN
29633	53	23	a	a	DT
29633	53	24	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
29633	53	25	engineer	engineer	NN
29633	53	26	with	with	IN
29633	53	27	a	a	DT
29633	53	28	special	special	JJ
29633	53	29	interest	interest	NN
29633	53	30	in	in	IN
29633	53	31	metallurgy	metallurgy	NN
29633	53	32	.	.	.
29633	54	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	54	2	environment	environment	NN
29633	54	3	and	and	CC
29633	54	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	54	5	unusual	unusual	JJ
29633	54	6	ability	ability	NN
29633	54	7	to	to	TO
29633	54	8	synthesize	synthesize	VB
29633	54	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	54	10	observation	observation	NN
29633	54	11	and	and	CC
29633	54	12	experience	experience	NN
29633	54	13	enabled	enable	VBD
29633	54	14	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	54	15	to	to	TO
29633	54	16	begin	begin	VB
29633	54	17	a	a	DT
29633	54	18	career	career	NN
29633	54	19	of	of	IN
29633	54	20	invention	invention	NN
29633	54	21	by	by	IN
29633	54	22	registering	register	VBG
29633	54	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	54	24	first	first	JJ
29633	54	25	patent	patent	NN
29633	54	26	at	at	IN
29633	54	27	the	the	DT
29633	54	28	age	age	NN
29633	54	29	of	of	IN
29633	54	30	25	25	CD
29633	54	31	.	.	.
29633	55	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	55	2	active	active	JJ
29633	55	3	experimenting	experimenting	NN
29633	55	4	continued	continue	VBD
29633	55	5	until	until	IN
29633	55	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	55	7	death	death	NN
29633	55	8	,	,	,
29633	55	9	although	although	IN
29633	55	10	the	the	DT
29633	55	11	public	public	JJ
29633	55	12	record	record	NN
29633	55	13	of	of	IN
29633	55	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	55	15	results	result	NNS
29633	55	16	ended	end	VBD
29633	55	17	with	with	IN
29633	55	18	a	a	DT
29633	55	19	patent	patent	NN
29633	55	20	issued	issue	VBN
29633	55	21	on	on	IN
29633	55	22	the	the	DT
29633	55	23	day	day	NN
29633	55	24	before	before	IN
29633	55	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	55	26	seventieth	seventieth	JJ
29633	55	27	birthday	birthday	NN
29633	55	28	.	.	.
29633	56	1	A	a	DT
29633	56	2	total	total	NN
29633	56	3	of	of	IN
29633	56	4	117	117	CD
29633	56	5	British	British	NNP
29633	56	6	patents[7	patents[7	NNS
29633	56	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	56	8	bear	bear	VB
29633	56	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	56	10	name	name	NN
29633	56	11	,	,	,
29633	56	12	not	not	RB
29633	56	13	all	all	DT
29633	56	14	of	of	IN
29633	56	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
29633	56	16	,	,	,
29633	56	17	by	by	IN
29633	56	18	any	any	DT
29633	56	19	means	mean	NNS
29633	56	20	,	,	,
29633	56	21	successful	successful	JJ
29633	56	22	in	in	IN
29633	56	23	the	the	DT
29633	56	24	sense	sense	NN
29633	56	25	of	of	IN
29633	56	26	producing	produce	VBG
29633	56	27	a	a	DT
29633	56	28	substantial	substantial	JJ
29633	56	29	income	income	NN
29633	56	30	.	.	.
29633	57	1	Curiously	Curiously	NNP
29633	57	2	,	,	,
29633	57	3	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	57	4	's	's	POS
29633	57	5	financial	financial	JJ
29633	57	6	stability	stability	NN
29633	57	7	was	be	VBD
29633	57	8	assured	assure	VBN
29633	57	9	by	by	IN
29633	57	10	the	the	DT
29633	57	11	success	success	NN
29633	57	12	of	of	IN
29633	57	13	an	an	DT
29633	57	14	invention	invention	NN
29633	57	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	57	16	did	do	VBD
29633	57	17	not	not	RB
29633	57	18	patent	patent	VB
29633	57	19	.	.	.
29633	58	1	This	this	DT
29633	58	2	was	be	VBD
29633	58	3	a	a	DT
29633	58	4	process	process	NN
29633	58	5	of	of	IN
29633	58	6	making	make	VBG
29633	58	7	bronze	bronze	NN
29633	58	8	powder	powder	NN
29633	58	9	and	and	CC
29633	58	10	gold	gold	NN
29633	58	11	paint	paint	NN
29633	58	12	,	,	,
29633	58	13	until	until	IN
29633	58	14	the	the	DT
29633	58	15	1830	1830	CD
29633	58	16	's	's	POS
29633	58	17	a	a	DT
29633	58	18	secret	secret	NN
29633	58	19	held	hold	VBN
29633	58	20	in	in	IN
29633	58	21	Germany	Germany	NNP
29633	58	22	.	.	.
29633	59	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	59	2	's	's	POS
29633	59	3	substitute	substitute	NN
29633	59	4	for	for	IN
29633	59	5	an	an	DT
29633	59	6	expensive	expensive	JJ
29633	59	7	imported	import	VBN
29633	59	8	product	product	NN
29633	59	9	,	,	,
29633	59	10	in	in	IN
29633	59	11	the	the	DT
29633	59	12	then	then	RB
29633	59	13	state	state	NN
29633	59	14	of	of	IN
29633	59	15	the	the	DT
29633	59	16	patent	patent	NN
29633	59	17	laws	law	NNS
29633	59	18	,	,	,
29633	59	19	would	would	MD
29633	59	20	have	have	VB
29633	59	21	failed	fail	VBN
29633	59	22	to	to	TO
29633	59	23	give	give	VB
29633	59	24	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	59	25	an	an	DT
29633	59	26	adequate	adequate	JJ
29633	59	27	reward	reward	NN
29633	59	28	if	if	IN
29633	59	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	59	30	had	have	VBD
29633	59	31	been	be	VBN
29633	59	32	unable	unable	JJ
29633	59	33	to	to	TO
29633	59	34	keep	keep	VB
29633	59	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	59	36	process	process	NN
29633	59	37	secret	secret	JJ
29633	59	38	.	.	.
29633	60	1	To	to	TO
29633	60	2	assure	assure	VB
29633	60	3	this	this	DT
29633	60	4	reward	reward	NN
29633	60	5	,	,	,
29633	60	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	60	7	had	have	VBD
29633	60	8	to	to	TO
29633	60	9	design	design	VB
29633	60	10	,	,	,
29633	60	11	assemble	assemble	VB
29633	60	12	,	,	,
29633	60	13	and	and	CC
29633	60	14	organize	organize	VB
29633	60	15	a	a	DT
29633	60	16	plant	plant	NN
29633	60	17	capable	capable	JJ
29633	60	18	of	of	IN
29633	60	19	operation	operation	NN
29633	60	20	with	with	IN
29633	60	21	a	a	DT
29633	60	22	minimum	minimum	NN
29633	60	23	of	of	IN
29633	60	24	hired	hire	VBN
29633	60	25	labor	labor	NN
29633	60	26	and	and	CC
29633	60	27	with	with	IN
29633	60	28	close	close	JJ
29633	60	29	security	security	NN
29633	60	30	control	control	NN
29633	60	31	.	.	.
29633	61	1	The	the	DT
29633	61	2	fact	fact	NN
29633	61	3	that	that	IN
29633	61	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	61	5	kept	keep	VBD
29633	61	6	the	the	DT
29633	61	7	method	method	NN
29633	61	8	secret	secret	NN
29633	61	9	for	for	IN
29633	61	10	40	40	CD
29633	61	11	years	year	NNS
29633	61	12	,	,	,
29633	61	13	suggests	suggest	VBZ
29633	61	14	that	that	IN
29633	61	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	61	16	machinery[8	machinery[8	NNP
29633	61	17	]	]	-RRB-
29633	61	18	(	(	-LRB-
29633	61	19	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	61	20	describes	describe	VBZ
29633	61	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	61	22	as	as	IN
29633	61	23	virtually	virtually	RB
29633	61	24	automatic	automatic	JJ
29633	61	25	in	in	IN
29633	61	26	operation	operation	NN
29633	61	27	)	)	-RRB-
29633	61	28	represented	represent	VBD
29633	61	29	an	an	DT
29633	61	30	appreciation	appreciation	NN
29633	61	31	of	of	IN
29633	61	32	coordinated	coordinated	JJ
29633	61	33	design	design	NN
29633	61	34	greatly	greatly	RB
29633	61	35	in	in	IN
29633	61	36	advance	advance	NN
29633	61	37	of	of	IN
29633	61	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	61	39	time	time	NN
29633	61	40	.	.	.
29633	62	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	62	2	experience	experience	NN
29633	62	3	must	must	MD
29633	62	4	have	have	VB
29633	62	5	directly	directly	RB
29633	62	6	contributed	contribute	VBN
29633	62	7	to	to	IN
29633	62	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	62	9	conception	conception	NN
29633	62	10	of	of	IN
29633	62	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	62	12	steel	steel	NN
29633	62	13	process	process	NN
29633	62	14	not	not	RB
29633	62	15	as	as	IN
29633	62	16	a	a	DT
29633	62	17	metallurgical	metallurgical	JJ
29633	62	18	trick	trick	NN
29633	62	19	but	but	CC
29633	62	20	as	as	IN
29633	62	21	an	an	DT
29633	62	22	industrial	industrial	JJ
29633	62	23	process	process	NN
29633	62	24	;	;	:
29633	62	25	for	for	IN
29633	62	26	when	when	WRB
29633	62	27	the	the	DT
29633	62	28	time	time	NN
29633	62	29	came	come	VBD
29633	62	30	,	,	,
29633	62	31	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	62	32	patented	patent	VBD
29633	62	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	62	34	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	62	35	as	as	IN
29633	62	36	a	a	DT
29633	62	37	process	process	NN
29633	62	38	rather	rather	RB
29633	62	39	than	than	IN
29633	62	40	as	as	IN
29633	62	41	a	a	DT
29633	62	42	formula	formula	NN
29633	62	43	.	.	.
29633	63	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	63	2	7	7	CD
29633	63	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	63	4	_	_	NNP
29633	63	5	Sir	Sir	NNP
29633	63	6	Henry	Henry	NNP
29633	63	7	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	63	8	,	,	,
29633	63	9	F.R.S.	F.R.S.	NNP
29633	63	10	,	,	,
29633	63	11	an	an	DT
29633	63	12	autobiography	autobiography	NN
29633	63	13	_	_	NNP
29633	63	14	,	,	,
29633	63	15	London	London	NNP
29633	63	16	,	,	,
29633	63	17	1905	1905	CD
29633	63	18	,	,	,
29633	63	19	p.	p.	NN
29633	63	20	332	332	CD
29633	63	21	.	.	.
29633	64	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	64	2	8	8	CD
29633	64	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	64	4	_	_	NNP
29633	64	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	64	6	.	.	.
29633	64	7	_	_	NNP
29633	64	8	,	,	,
29633	64	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	64	10	59	59	CD
29633	64	11	ff	ff	NN
29633	64	12	.	.	.
29633	65	1	In	in	IN
29633	65	2	the	the	DT
29633	65	3	light	light	NN
29633	65	4	of	of	IN
29633	65	5	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
29633	65	6	developments	development	NNS
29633	65	7	,	,	,
29633	65	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	65	9	is	be	VBZ
29633	65	10	necessary	necessary	JJ
29633	65	11	to	to	TO
29633	65	12	consider	consider	VB
29633	65	13	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	65	14	's	's	POS
29633	65	15	attitude	attitude	NN
29633	65	16	toward	toward	IN
29633	65	17	the	the	DT
29633	65	18	patent	patent	NN
29633	65	19	privilege	privilege	NN
29633	65	20	.	.	.
29633	66	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	66	2	describes	describe	VBZ
29633	66	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	66	4	secret	secret	JJ
29633	66	5	gold	gold	NN
29633	66	6	paint	paint	NN
29633	66	7	as	as	IN
29633	66	8	an	an	DT
29633	66	9	example	example	NN
29633	66	10	of	of	IN
29633	66	11	"	"	``
29633	66	12	what	what	WP
29633	66	13	the	the	DT
29633	66	14	public	public	NN
29633	66	15	has	have	VBZ
29633	66	16	had	have	VBN
29633	66	17	to	to	TO
29633	66	18	pay	pay	VB
29633	66	19	for	for	IN
29633	66	20	not	not	RB
29633	66	21	being	be	VBG
29633	66	22	able	able	JJ
29633	66	23	to	to	TO
29633	66	24	give	give	VB
29633	66	25	...	...	:
29633	66	26	security	security	NN
29633	66	27	to	to	IN
29633	66	28	the	the	DT
29633	66	29	inventor	inventor	NN
29633	66	30	"	"	''
29633	66	31	in	in	IN
29633	66	32	a	a	DT
29633	66	33	situation	situation	NN
29633	66	34	where	where	WRB
29633	66	35	the	the	DT
29633	66	36	production	production	NN
29633	66	37	of	of	IN
29633	66	38	the	the	DT
29633	66	39	material	material	NN
29633	66	40	"	"	``
29633	66	41	could	could	MD
29633	66	42	not	not	RB
29633	66	43	be	be	VB
29633	66	44	identified	identify	VBN
29633	66	45	as	as	IN
29633	66	46	having	have	VBG
29633	66	47	been	be	VBN
29633	66	48	made	make	VBN
29633	66	49	by	by	IN
29633	66	50	any	any	DT
29633	66	51	particular	particular	JJ
29633	66	52	form	form	NN
29633	66	53	of	of	IN
29633	66	54	mechanism	mechanism	NN
29633	66	55	.	.	.
29633	67	1	"	"	``
29633	67	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	67	3	9	9	CD
29633	67	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	67	5	The	the	DT
29633	67	6	inability	inability	NN
29633	67	7	to	to	TO
29633	67	8	obtain	obtain	VB
29633	67	9	a	a	DT
29633	67	10	patent	patent	NN
29633	67	11	over	over	IN
29633	67	12	the	the	DT
29633	67	13	method	method	NN
29633	67	14	of	of	IN
29633	67	15	production	production	NN
29633	67	16	meant	mean	VBD
29633	67	17	that	that	IN
29633	67	18	the	the	DT
29633	67	19	disclosure	disclosure	NN
29633	67	20	of	of	IN
29633	67	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	67	22	formula	formula	NN
29633	67	23	,	,	,
29633	67	24	necessary	necessary	JJ
29633	67	25	for	for	IN
29633	67	26	patent	patent	NN
29633	67	27	specification	specification	NN
29633	67	28	,	,	,
29633	67	29	would	would	MD
29633	67	30	openly	openly	RB
29633	67	31	invite	invite	VB
29633	67	32	competitors	competitor	NNS
29633	67	33	,	,	,
29633	67	34	including	include	VBG
29633	67	35	the	the	DT
29633	67	36	Germans	Germans	NNPS
29633	67	37	,	,	,
29633	67	38	to	to	TO
29633	67	39	evolve	evolve	VB
29633	67	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	67	41	own	own	JJ
29633	67	42	techniques	technique	NNS
29633	67	43	.	.	.
29633	68	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	68	2	concludes:[10	concludes:[10	,
29633	68	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	68	4	Had	have	VBD
29633	68	5	the	the	DT
29633	68	6	invention	invention	NN
29633	68	7	been	be	VBN
29633	68	8	patented	patent	VBN
29633	68	9	,	,	,
29633	68	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	68	11	would	would	MD
29633	68	12	have	have	VB
29633	68	13	become	become	VBN
29633	68	14	public	public	JJ
29633	68	15	property	property	NN
29633	68	16	in	in	IN
29633	68	17	fourteen	fourteen	CD
29633	68	18	years	year	NNS
29633	68	19	from	from	IN
29633	68	20	the	the	DT
29633	68	21	date	date	NN
29633	68	22	of	of	IN
29633	68	23	the	the	DT
29633	68	24	patent	patent	NN
29633	68	25	,	,	,
29633	68	26	after	after	IN
29633	68	27	which	which	WDT
29633	68	28	period	period	NN
29633	68	29	the	the	DT
29633	68	30	public	public	NN
29633	68	31	would	would	MD
29633	68	32	have	have	VB
29633	68	33	been	be	VBN
29633	68	34	able	able	JJ
29633	68	35	to	to	TO
29633	68	36	buy	buy	VB
29633	68	37	bronze	bronze	NN
29633	68	38	powder	powder	NN
29633	68	39	at	at	IN
29633	68	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	68	41	present	present	NN
29633	68	42	[	[	-LRB-
29633	68	43	_	_	NNP
29633	68	44	i.e.	i.e.	FW
29633	68	45	_	_	NNP
29633	68	46	,	,	,
29633	68	47	_	_	NNP
29633	68	48	ca	ca	NNP
29633	68	49	.	.	.
29633	68	50	_	_	NNP
29633	68	51	1890	1890	CD
29633	68	52	]	]	-RRB-
29633	68	53	market	market	NN
29633	68	54	price	price	NN
29633	68	55	,	,	,
29633	68	56	viz	viz	NN
29633	68	57	.	.	.
29633	69	1	from	from	IN
29633	69	2	two	two	CD
29633	69	3	shillings	shilling	NNS
29633	69	4	and	and	CC
29633	69	5	three	three	CD
29633	69	6	pence	penny	NNS
29633	69	7	to	to	IN
29633	69	8	two	two	CD
29633	69	9	shillings	shilling	NNS
29633	69	10	and	and	CC
29633	69	11	nine	nine	CD
29633	69	12	pence	penny	NNS
29633	69	13	per	per	IN
29633	69	14	pound	pound	NN
29633	69	15	.	.	.
29633	70	1	But	but	CC
29633	70	2	this	this	DT
29633	70	3	important	important	JJ
29633	70	4	secret	secret	NN
29633	70	5	was	be	VBD
29633	70	6	kept	keep	VBN
29633	70	7	for	for	IN
29633	70	8	about	about	RB
29633	70	9	thirty	thirty	CD
29633	70	10	-	-	HYPH
29633	70	11	five	five	CD
29633	70	12	years	year	NNS
29633	70	13	and	and	CC
29633	70	14	the	the	DT
29633	70	15	public	public	NN
29633	70	16	had	have	VBD
29633	70	17	to	to	TO
29633	70	18	pay	pay	VB
29633	70	19	excessively	excessively	RB
29633	70	20	high	high	JJ
29633	70	21	prices	price	NNS
29633	70	22	for	for	IN
29633	70	23	twenty	twenty	CD
29633	70	24	-	-	HYPH
29633	70	25	one	one	CD
29633	70	26	years	year	NNS
29633	70	27	longer	long	RBR
29633	70	28	than	than	IN
29633	70	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	70	30	would	would	MD
29633	70	31	have	have	VB
29633	70	32	done	do	VBN
29633	70	33	had	have	VBD
29633	70	34	the	the	DT
29633	70	35	invention	invention	NN
29633	70	36	become	become	VB
29633	70	37	public	public	JJ
29633	70	38	property	property	NN
29633	70	39	in	in	IN
29633	70	40	fourteen	fourteen	CD
29633	70	41	years	year	NNS
29633	70	42	,	,	,
29633	70	43	as	as	IN
29633	70	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	70	45	would	would	MD
29633	70	46	have	have	VB
29633	70	47	been	be	VBN
29633	70	48	if	if	IN
29633	70	49	patented	patent	VBN
29633	70	50	.	.	.
29633	71	1	Even	even	RB
29633	71	2	this	this	DT
29633	71	3	does	do	VBZ
29633	71	4	not	not	RB
29633	71	5	represent	represent	VB
29633	71	6	all	all	PDT
29633	71	7	the	the	DT
29633	71	8	disadvantages	disadvantage	NNS
29633	71	9	resulting	result	VBG
29633	71	10	from	from	IN
29633	71	11	secret	secret	JJ
29633	71	12	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	71	13	.	.	.
29633	72	1	While	while	IN
29633	72	2	every	every	DT
29633	72	3	detail	detail	NN
29633	72	4	of	of	IN
29633	72	5	production	production	NN
29633	72	6	was	be	VBD
29633	72	7	a	a	DT
29633	72	8	profound	profound	JJ
29633	72	9	secret	secret	NN
29633	72	10	,	,	,
29633	72	11	there	there	EX
29633	72	12	were	be	VBD
29633	72	13	no	no	DT
29633	72	14	improvements	improvement	NNS
29633	72	15	made	make	VBN
29633	72	16	by	by	IN
29633	72	17	the	the	DT
29633	72	18	outside	outside	JJ
29633	72	19	public	public	NN
29633	72	20	in	in	IN
29633	72	21	any	any	DT
29633	72	22	one	one	CD
29633	72	23	of	of	IN
29633	72	24	the	the	DT
29633	72	25	machines	machine	NNS
29633	72	26	employed	employ	VBN
29633	72	27	during	during	IN
29633	72	28	the	the	DT
29633	72	29	whole	whole	JJ
29633	72	30	thirty	thirty	CD
29633	72	31	-	-	HYPH
29633	72	32	five	five	CD
29633	72	33	years	year	NNS
29633	72	34	;	;	:
29633	72	35	whereas	whereas	IN
29633	72	36	during	during	IN
29633	72	37	the	the	DT
29633	72	38	fourteen	fourteen	CD
29633	72	39	years	year	NNS
29633	72	40	,	,	,
29633	72	41	if	if	IN
29633	72	42	the	the	DT
29633	72	43	invention	invention	NN
29633	72	44	had	have	VBD
29633	72	45	been	be	VBN
29633	72	46	patented	patent	VBN
29633	72	47	,	,	,
29633	72	48	there	there	EX
29633	72	49	would	would	MD
29633	72	50	,	,	,
29633	72	51	in	in	IN
29633	72	52	all	all	DT
29633	72	53	probability	probability	NN
29633	72	54	have	have	VBP
29633	72	55	been	be	VBN
29633	72	56	many	many	JJ
29633	72	57	improved	improve	VBN
29633	72	58	machines	machine	NNS
29633	72	59	invented	invent	VBN
29633	72	60	and	and	CC
29633	72	61	many	many	JJ
29633	72	62	novel	novel	NN
29633	72	63	features	feature	NNS
29633	72	64	applied	apply	VBN
29633	72	65	to	to	IN
29633	72	66	totally	totally	RB
29633	72	67	different	different	JJ
29633	72	68	manufactures	manufacture	NNS
29633	72	69	.	.	.
29633	73	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	73	2	9	9	CD
29633	73	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	73	4	_	_	NNP
29633	73	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	73	6	.	.	.
29633	73	7	_	_	NNP
29633	73	8	,	,	,
29633	73	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	73	10	82	82	CD
29633	73	11	.	.	.
29633	74	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	74	2	10	10	CD
29633	74	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	74	4	_	_	NNP
29633	74	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	74	6	.	.	.
29633	74	7	_	_	NNP
29633	74	8	,	,	,
29633	74	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	74	10	83	83	CD
29633	74	11	.	.	.
29633	75	1	While	while	IN
29633	75	2	these	these	DT
29633	75	3	words	word	NNS
29633	75	4	,	,	,
29633	75	5	to	to	IN
29633	75	6	some	some	DT
29633	75	7	extent	extent	NN
29633	75	8	,	,	,
29633	75	9	were	be	VBD
29633	75	10	the	the	DT
29633	75	11	rationalizations	rationalization	NNS
29633	75	12	of	of	IN
29633	75	13	an	an	DT
29633	75	14	old	old	JJ
29633	75	15	man	man	NN
29633	75	16	,	,	,
29633	75	17	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	75	18	's	's	POS
29633	75	19	career	career	NN
29633	75	20	showed	show	VBD
29633	75	21	that	that	IN
29633	75	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	75	23	philosophy	philosophy	NN
29633	75	24	had	have	VBD
29633	75	25	a	a	DT
29633	75	26	practical	practical	JJ
29633	75	27	foundation	foundation	NN
29633	75	28	;	;	:
29633	75	29	and	and	CC
29633	75	30	,	,	,
29633	75	31	if	if	IN
29633	75	32	this	this	DT
29633	75	33	was	be	VBD
29633	75	34	indeed	indeed	RB
29633	75	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	75	36	belief	belief	NN
29633	75	37	,	,	,
29633	75	38	the	the	DT
29633	75	39	episode	episode	NN
29633	75	40	explains	explain	VBZ
29633	75	41	in	in	IN
29633	75	42	large	large	JJ
29633	75	43	measure	measure	NN
29633	75	44	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	75	45	's	's	POS
29633	75	46	later	later	JJ
29633	75	47	insistence	insistence	NN
29633	75	48	on	on	IN
29633	75	49	the	the	DT
29633	75	50	legal	legal	JJ
29633	75	51	niceties	nicety	NNS
29633	75	52	of	of	IN
29633	75	53	the	the	DT
29633	75	54	patent	patent	NN
29633	75	55	procedure	procedure	NN
29633	75	56	.	.	.
29633	76	1	The	the	DT
29633	76	2	effect	effect	NN
29633	76	3	of	of	IN
29633	76	4	this	this	DT
29633	76	5	will	will	MD
29633	76	6	be	be	VB
29633	76	7	seen	see	VBN
29633	76	8	.	.	.
29633	77	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	77	2	's	's	POS
29633	77	3	intervention	intervention	NN
29633	77	4	in	in	IN
29633	77	5	the	the	DT
29633	77	6	field	field	NN
29633	77	7	of	of	IN
29633	77	8	iron	iron	NN
29633	77	9	and	and	CC
29633	77	10	steel	steel	NN
29633	77	11	was	be	VBD
29633	77	12	preceded	precede	VBN
29633	77	13	by	by	IN
29633	77	14	a	a	DT
29633	77	15	period	period	NN
29633	77	16	of	of	IN
29633	77	17	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	77	18	in	in	IN
29633	77	19	the	the	DT
29633	77	20	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	77	21	of	of	IN
29633	77	22	glass	glass	NN
29633	77	23	.	.	.
29633	78	1	Here	here	RB
29633	78	2	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	78	3	claims	claim	VBZ
29633	78	4	to	to	TO
29633	78	5	have	have	VB
29633	78	6	made	make	VBN
29633	78	7	glass	glass	NN
29633	78	8	for	for	IN
29633	78	9	the	the	DT
29633	78	10	first	first	JJ
29633	78	11	time	time	NN
29633	78	12	in	in	IN
29633	78	13	the	the	DT
29633	78	14	open	open	JJ
29633	78	15	hearth	hearth	NN
29633	78	16	of	of	IN
29633	78	17	a	a	DT
29633	78	18	reverberatory	reverberatory	NN
29633	78	19	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	78	20	.	.	.
29633	79	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	79	2	11	11	CD
29633	79	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	79	4	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	79	5	work	work	NN
29633	79	6	in	in	IN
29633	79	7	glass	glass	NN
29633	79	8	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	79	9	at	at	IN
29633	79	10	least	least	JJS
29633	79	11	gave	give	VBD
29633	79	12	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	79	13	considerable	considerable	JJ
29633	79	14	experience	experience	NN
29633	79	15	in	in	IN
29633	79	16	the	the	DT
29633	79	17	problems	problem	NNS
29633	79	18	of	of	IN
29633	79	19	fusion	fusion	NN
29633	79	20	under	under	IN
29633	79	21	high	high	JJ
29633	79	22	temperatures	temperature	NNS
29633	79	23	and	and	CC
29633	79	24	provided	provide	VBN
29633	79	25	some	some	DT
29633	79	26	support	support	NN
29633	79	27	for	for	IN
29633	79	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	79	29	later	later	JJ
29633	79	30	claim	claim	NN
29633	79	31	that	that	IN
29633	79	32	in	in	IN
29633	79	33	applying	apply	VBG
29633	79	34	the	the	DT
29633	79	35	reverberatory	reverberatory	NN
29633	79	36	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	79	37	to	to	IN
29633	79	38	the	the	DT
29633	79	39	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	79	40	of	of	IN
29633	79	41	malleable	malleable	JJ
29633	79	42	iron	iron	NN
29633	79	43	as	as	IN
29633	79	44	described	describe	VBN
29633	79	45	in	in	IN
29633	79	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	79	47	first	first	JJ
29633	79	48	patent	patent	NN
29633	79	49	of	of	IN
29633	79	50	January	January	NNP
29633	79	51	1855	1855	CD
29633	79	52	,	,	,
29633	79	53	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	79	54	had	have	VBD
29633	79	55	in	in	IN
29633	79	56	some	some	DT
29633	79	57	manner	manner	NN
29633	79	58	anticipated	anticipate	VBD
29633	79	59	the	the	DT
29633	79	60	work	work	NN
29633	79	61	of	of	IN
29633	79	62	C.	C.	NNP
29633	79	63	W.	W.	NNP
29633	79	64	Siemens	Siemens	NNP
29633	79	65	and	and	CC
29633	79	66	Emil	Emil	NNP
29633	79	67	Martin	Martin	NNP
29633	79	68	.	.	.
29633	80	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	80	2	12	12	CD
29633	80	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	80	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	80	5	11	11	CD
29633	80	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	80	7	_	_	NNP
29633	80	8	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	80	9	.	.	.
29633	80	10	_	_	NNP
29633	80	11	,	,	,
29633	80	12	p.	p.	NN
29633	80	13	108	108	CD
29633	80	14	ff	ff	NN
29633	80	15	.	.	.
29633	81	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	81	2	12	12	CD
29633	81	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	81	4	_	_	NNP
29633	81	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	81	6	.	.	.
29633	81	7	_	_	NNP
29633	81	8	,	,	,
29633	81	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	81	10	141	141	CD
29633	81	11	.	.	.
29633	82	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	82	2	's	's	POS
29633	82	3	assertion	assertion	NN
29633	82	4	that	that	IN
29633	82	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	82	6	had	have	VBD
29633	82	7	approached	approach	VBN
29633	82	8	"	"	``
29633	82	9	within	within	IN
29633	82	10	measurable	measurable	JJ
29633	82	11	distance	distance	NN
29633	82	12	"	"	''
29633	82	13	of	of	IN
29633	82	14	anticipating	anticipate	VBG
29633	82	15	the	the	DT
29633	82	16	Siemens	Siemens	NNP
29633	82	17	-	-	HYPH
29633	82	18	Martin	Martin	NNP
29633	82	19	process	process	NN
29633	82	20	,	,	,
29633	82	21	made	make	VBN
29633	82	22	in	in	IN
29633	82	23	a	a	DT
29633	82	24	paper	paper	NN
29633	82	25	presented	present	VBN
29633	82	26	at	at	IN
29633	82	27	a	a	DT
29633	82	28	meeting	meeting	NN
29633	82	29	of	of	IN
29633	82	30	the	the	DT
29633	82	31	American	American	NNP
29633	82	32	Society	Society	NNP
29633	82	33	of	of	IN
29633	82	34	Mechanical	Mechanical	NNP
29633	82	35	Engineers	Engineers	NNPS
29633	82	36	(	(	-LRB-
29633	82	37	_	_	NNP
29633	82	38	Transactions	Transactions	NNPS
29633	82	39	of	of	IN
29633	82	40	the	the	DT
29633	82	41	American	American	NNP
29633	82	42	Society	Society	NNP
29633	82	43	of	of	IN
29633	82	44	Mechanical	Mechanical	NNP
29633	82	45	Engineers	Engineers	NNPS
29633	82	46	_	_	NNP
29633	82	47	,	,	,
29633	82	48	1897	1897	CD
29633	82	49	,	,	,
29633	82	50	vol	vol	NNP
29633	82	51	.	.	.
29633	83	1	28	28	CD
29633	83	2	,	,	,
29633	83	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	83	4	459	459	CD
29633	83	5	)	)	-RRB-
29633	83	6	,	,	,
29633	83	7	evoked	evoke	VBD
29633	83	8	strong	strong	JJ
29633	83	9	criticism	criticism	NN
29633	83	10	of	of	IN
29633	83	11	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	83	12	's	's	POS
29633	83	13	lack	lack	NN
29633	83	14	of	of	IN
29633	83	15	generosity	generosity	NN
29633	83	16	(	(	-LRB-
29633	83	17	_	_	NNP
29633	83	18	ibid	ibid	NN
29633	83	19	.	.	.
29633	83	20	_	_	NNP
29633	83	21	,	,	,
29633	83	22	p.	p.	NN
29633	83	23	482	482	CD
29633	83	24	)	)	-RRB-
29633	83	25	.	.	.
29633	84	1	One	one	CD
29633	84	2	commentator	commentator	NN
29633	84	3	,	,	,
29633	84	4	friendly	friendly	JJ
29633	84	5	to	to	IN
29633	84	6	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	84	7	,	,	,
29633	84	8	put	put	VB
29633	84	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	84	10	that	that	IN
29633	84	11	"	"	``
29633	84	12	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	84	13	's	's	POS
29633	84	14	relation	relation	NN
29633	84	15	to	to	IN
29633	84	16	the	the	DT
29633	84	17	open	open	JJ
29633	84	18	-	-	HYPH
29633	84	19	hearth	hearth	JJ
29633	84	20	process	process	NN
29633	84	21	was	be	VBD
29633	84	22	very	very	RB
29633	84	23	much	much	RB
29633	84	24	like	like	IN
29633	84	25	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	84	26	's	's	POS
29633	84	27	to	to	IN
29633	84	28	the	the	DT
29633	84	29	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	84	30	process	process	NN
29633	84	31	....	....	.
29633	85	1	Although	although	IN
29633	85	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	85	3	was	be	VBD
29633	85	4	measurably	measurably	RB
29633	85	5	near	near	JJ
29633	85	6	to	to	IN
29633	85	7	the	the	DT
29633	85	8	open	open	JJ
29633	85	9	-	-	HYPH
29633	85	10	hearth	hearth	JJ
29633	85	11	process	process	NN
29633	85	12	,	,	,
29633	85	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	85	14	did	do	VBD
29633	85	15	not	not	RB
29633	85	16	follow	follow	VB
29633	85	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	85	18	up	up	RP
29633	85	19	and	and	CC
29633	85	20	make	make	VB
29633	85	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	85	22	a	a	DT
29633	85	23	commercial	commercial	JJ
29633	85	24	success	success	NN
29633	85	25	....	....	.
29633	85	26	"	"	''
29633	85	27	(	(	-LRB-
29633	85	28	_	_	NNP
29633	85	29	ibid	ibid	NN
29633	85	30	.	.	.
29633	85	31	_	_	NNP
29633	85	32	,	,	,
29633	85	33	p.	p.	NN
29633	85	34	491	491	CD
29633	85	35	)	)	-RRB-
29633	85	36	.	.	.
29633	86	1	The	the	DT
29633	86	2	general	general	JJ
29633	86	3	interest	interest	NN
29633	86	4	in	in	IN
29633	86	5	problems	problem	NNS
29633	86	6	of	of	IN
29633	86	7	ordnance	ordnance	NN
29633	86	8	and	and	CC
29633	86	9	armor	armor	NN
29633	86	10	,	,	,
29633	86	11	stimulated	stimulate	VBN
29633	86	12	by	by	IN
29633	86	13	the	the	DT
29633	86	14	Crimean	Crimean	NNP
29633	86	15	War	War	NNP
29633	86	16	(	(	-LRB-
29633	86	17	1854	1854	CD
29633	86	18	-	-	SYM
29633	86	19	1856	1856	CD
29633	86	20	)	)	-RRB-
29633	86	21	,	,	,
29633	86	22	was	be	VBD
29633	86	23	shared	share	VBN
29633	86	24	by	by	IN
29633	86	25	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	86	26	,	,	,
29633	86	27	whose	whose	WP$
29633	86	28	ingenuity	ingenuity	NN
29633	86	29	soon	soon	RB
29633	86	30	produced	produce	VBD
29633	86	31	a	a	DT
29633	86	32	design	design	NN
29633	86	33	for	for	IN
29633	86	34	a	a	DT
29633	86	35	projectile	projectile	NN
29633	86	36	which	which	WDT
29633	86	37	could	could	MD
29633	86	38	provide	provide	VB
29633	86	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	86	40	own	own	JJ
29633	86	41	rotation	rotation	NN
29633	86	42	when	when	WRB
29633	86	43	fired	fire	VBD
29633	86	44	from	from	IN
29633	86	45	a	a	DT
29633	86	46	smooth	smooth	JJ
29633	86	47	-	-	HYPH
29633	86	48	bore	bore	JJ
29633	86	49	gun	gun	NN
29633	86	50	.	.	.
29633	87	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	87	2	13	13	CD
29633	87	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	87	4	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	87	5	's	's	POS
29633	87	6	failure	failure	NN
29633	87	7	to	to	TO
29633	87	8	interest	interest	NN
29633	87	9	the	the	DT
29633	87	10	British	British	NNP
29633	87	11	War	War	NNP
29633	87	12	Office	Office	NNP
29633	87	13	in	in	IN
29633	87	14	the	the	DT
29633	87	15	idea	idea	NN
29633	87	16	led	lead	VBD
29633	87	17	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	87	18	to	to	TO
29633	87	19	submit	submit	VB
29633	87	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	87	21	design	design	NN
29633	87	22	to	to	IN
29633	87	23	the	the	DT
29633	87	24	Emperor	Emperor	NNP
29633	87	25	Napoleon	Napoleon	NNP
29633	87	26	III	III	NNP
29633	87	27	.	.	.
29633	88	1	Trials	trial	NNS
29633	88	2	made	make	VBN
29633	88	3	with	with	IN
29633	88	4	the	the	DT
29633	88	5	encouragement	encouragement	NN
29633	88	6	of	of	IN
29633	88	7	the	the	DT
29633	88	8	Emperor	Emperor	NNP
29633	88	9	showed	show	VBD
29633	88	10	the	the	DT
29633	88	11	inadequacy	inadequacy	NN
29633	88	12	of	of	IN
29633	88	13	the	the	DT
29633	88	14	cast	cast	NN
29633	88	15	-	-	HYPH
29633	88	16	iron	iron	NN
29633	88	17	guns	gun	NNS
29633	88	18	of	of	IN
29633	88	19	the	the	DT
29633	88	20	period	period	NN
29633	88	21	to	to	TO
29633	88	22	deal	deal	VB
29633	88	23	with	with	IN
29633	88	24	the	the	DT
29633	88	25	heavier	heavy	JJR
29633	88	26	shot	shot	NN
29633	88	27	;	;	,
29633	88	28	and	and	CC
29633	88	29	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	88	30	was	be	VBD
29633	88	31	presented	present	VBN
29633	88	32	with	with	IN
29633	88	33	a	a	DT
29633	88	34	new	new	JJ
29633	88	35	problem	problem	NN
29633	88	36	which	which	WDT
29633	88	37	,	,	,
29633	88	38	with	with	IN
29633	88	39	"	"	``
29633	88	40	the	the	DT
29633	88	41	open	open	JJ
29633	88	42	mind	mind	NN
29633	88	43	which	which	WDT
29633	88	44	derived	derive	VBD
29633	88	45	from	from	IN
29633	88	46	a	a	DT
29633	88	47	limited	limited	JJ
29633	88	48	knowledge	knowledge	NN
29633	88	49	of	of	IN
29633	88	50	the	the	DT
29633	88	51	metallurgy	metallurgy	NN
29633	88	52	of	of	IN
29633	88	53	war	war	NN
29633	88	54	,	,	,
29633	88	55	"	"	''
29633	88	56	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	88	57	attacked	attack	VBD
29633	88	58	with	with	IN
29633	88	59	impetuosity	impetuosity	NN
29633	88	60	.	.	.
29633	89	1	Within	within	IN
29633	89	2	three	three	CD
29633	89	3	weeks	week	NNS
29633	89	4	of	of	IN
29633	89	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	89	6	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	89	7	in	in	IN
29633	89	8	France	France	NNP
29633	89	9	,	,	,
29633	89	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	89	11	had	have	VBD
29633	89	12	applied	apply	VBN
29633	89	13	for	for	IN
29633	89	14	a	a	DT
29633	89	15	patent	patent	NN
29633	89	16	for	for	IN
29633	89	17	"	"	``
29633	89	18	Improvements	Improvements	NNP
29633	89	19	in	in	IN
29633	89	20	the	the	DT
29633	89	21	Manufacture	Manufacture	NNP
29633	89	22	of	of	IN
29633	89	23	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	89	24	and	and	CC
29633	89	25	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	89	26	.	.	.
29633	90	1	"	"	``
29633	90	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	90	3	14	14	CD
29633	90	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	90	5	This	this	DT
29633	90	6	covered	cover	VBD
29633	90	7	the	the	DT
29633	90	8	fusion	fusion	NN
29633	90	9	of	of	IN
29633	90	10	steel	steel	NN
29633	90	11	with	with	IN
29633	90	12	pig	pig	NN
29633	90	13	or	or	CC
29633	90	14	cast	cast	VBN
29633	90	15	iron	iron	NN
29633	90	16	and	and	CC
29633	90	17	,	,	,
29633	90	18	though	though	IN
29633	90	19	this	this	DT
29633	90	20	must	must	MD
29633	90	21	be	be	VB
29633	90	22	regarded	regard	VBN
29633	90	23	as	as	IN
29633	90	24	only	only	RB
29633	90	25	the	the	DT
29633	90	26	first	first	JJ
29633	90	27	practical	practical	JJ
29633	90	28	step	step	NN
29633	90	29	toward	toward	IN
29633	90	30	the	the	DT
29633	90	31	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	90	32	process,[15	process,[15	CD
29633	90	33	]	]	-RRB-
29633	90	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	90	35	was	be	VBD
29633	90	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	90	37	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	90	38	with	with	IN
29633	90	39	the	the	DT
29633	90	40	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	90	41	which	which	WDT
29633	90	42	provided	provide	VBD
29633	90	43	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	90	44	with	with	IN
29633	90	45	the	the	DT
29633	90	46	idea	idea	NN
29633	90	47	for	for	IN
29633	90	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	90	49	later	later	JJ
29633	90	50	developments	development	NNS
29633	90	51	.	.	.
29633	91	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	91	2	13	13	CD
29633	91	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	91	4	British	british	JJ
29633	91	5	patent	patent	NN
29633	91	6	2489	2489	CD
29633	91	7	,	,	,
29633	91	8	November	November	NNP
29633	91	9	24	24	CD
29633	91	10	,	,	,
29633	91	11	1854	1854	CD
29633	91	12	.	.	.
29633	92	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	92	2	14	14	CD
29633	92	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	92	4	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	92	5	,	,	,
29633	92	6	_	_	NNP
29633	92	7	op	op	NN
29633	92	8	.	.	.
29633	93	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	93	2	.	.	.
29633	93	3	_	_	NNP
29633	93	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	93	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	93	6	7	7	CD
29633	93	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	93	8	,	,	,
29633	93	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	93	10	137	137	CD
29633	93	11	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	93	12	received	receive	VBD
29633	93	13	British	british	JJ
29633	93	14	patent	patent	NN
29633	93	15	66	66	CD
29633	93	16	,	,	,
29633	93	17	dated	date	VBN
29633	93	18	January	January	NNP
29633	93	19	10	10	CD
29633	93	20	,	,	,
29633	93	21	1855	1855	CD
29633	93	22	.	.	.
29633	94	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	94	2	15	15	CD
29633	94	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	94	4	See	See	NNP
29633	94	5	James	James	NNP
29633	94	6	W.	W.	NNP
29633	94	7	Dredge	Dredge	NNP
29633	94	8	,	,	,
29633	94	9	"	"	''
29633	94	10	Henry	Henry	NNP
29633	94	11	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	94	12	1813	1813	CD
29633	94	13	-	-	SYM
29633	94	14	1898	1898	CD
29633	94	15	,	,	,
29633	94	16	"	"	``
29633	94	17	_	_	NNP
29633	94	18	Transactions	Transactions	NNPS
29633	94	19	of	of	IN
29633	94	20	the	the	DT
29633	94	21	American	American	NNP
29633	94	22	Society	Society	NNP
29633	94	23	of	of	IN
29633	94	24	Mechanical	Mechanical	NNP
29633	94	25	Engineers	Engineers	NNPS
29633	94	26	_	_	NNP
29633	94	27	,	,	,
29633	94	28	1898	1898	CD
29633	94	29	,	,	,
29633	94	30	vol	vol	NNP
29633	94	31	.	.	.
29633	95	1	19	19	CD
29633	95	2	,	,	,
29633	95	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	95	4	911	911	CD
29633	95	5	.	.	.
29633	96	1	These	these	DT
29633	96	2	were	be	VBD
29633	96	3	described	describe	VBN
29633	96	4	in	in	IN
29633	96	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	96	6	patent	patent	NN
29633	96	7	dated	date	VBN
29633	96	8	October	October	NNP
29633	96	9	17	17	CD
29633	96	10	,	,	,
29633	96	11	1855	1855	CD
29633	96	12	(	(	-LRB-
29633	96	13	British	british	JJ
29633	96	14	patent	patent	NN
29633	96	15	2321	2321	CD
29633	96	16	)	)	-RRB-
29633	96	17	.	.	.
29633	97	1	This	this	DT
29633	97	2	patent	patent	NN
29633	97	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	97	4	significant	significant	JJ
29633	97	5	to	to	IN
29633	97	6	the	the	DT
29633	97	7	present	present	JJ
29633	97	8	study	study	NN
29633	97	9	because	because	IN
29633	97	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	97	11	application	application	NN
29633	97	12	for	for	IN
29633	97	13	an	an	DT
29633	97	14	American	american	JJ
29633	97	15	patent	patent	NN
29633	97	16	,	,	,
29633	97	17	based	base	VBN
29633	97	18	on	on	IN
29633	97	19	similar	similar	JJ
29633	97	20	specifications	specification	NNS
29633	97	21	,	,	,
29633	97	22	led	lead	VBD
29633	97	23	to	to	IN
29633	97	24	the	the	DT
29633	97	25	interference	interference	NN
29633	97	26	of	of	IN
29633	97	27	William	William	NNP
29633	97	28	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	97	29	and	and	CC
29633	97	30	to	to	IN
29633	97	31	the	the	DT
29633	97	32	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
29633	97	33	denial	denial	NN
29633	97	34	of	of	IN
29633	97	35	the	the	DT
29633	97	36	American	american	JJ
29633	97	37	patent	patent	NN
29633	97	38	.	.	.
29633	98	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	98	2	16	16	CD
29633	98	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	98	4	In	in	IN
29633	98	5	British	british	JJ
29633	98	6	patent	patent	NN
29633	98	7	2321	2321	CD
29633	98	8	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	98	9	proposed	propose	VBD
29633	98	10	to	to	TO
29633	98	11	convert	convert	VB
29633	98	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	98	13	steel	steel	NN
29633	98	14	in	in	IN
29633	98	15	crucibles	crucible	NNS
29633	98	16	,	,	,
29633	98	17	arranged	arrange	VBN
29633	98	18	in	in	IN
29633	98	19	a	a	DT
29633	98	20	suitable	suitable	JJ
29633	98	21	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	98	22	and	and	CC
29633	98	23	each	each	DT
29633	98	24	having	have	VBG
29633	98	25	a	a	DT
29633	98	26	vertical	vertical	JJ
29633	98	27	tuyère	tuyère	NN
29633	98	28	,	,	,
29633	98	29	through	through	IN
29633	98	30	which	which	WDT
29633	98	31	air	air	NN
29633	98	32	under	under	IN
29633	98	33	pressure	pressure	NN
29633	98	34	was	be	VBD
29633	98	35	forced	force	VBN
29633	98	36	through	through	IN
29633	98	37	the	the	DT
29633	98	38	molten	molten	JJ
29633	98	39	metal	metal	NN
29633	98	40	.	.	.
29633	99	1	As	as	IN
29633	99	2	Dredge[17	dredge[17	DT
29633	99	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	99	4	points	point	VBZ
29633	99	5	out	out	RP
29633	99	6	,	,	,
29633	99	7	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	99	8	's	's	POS
29633	99	9	association	association	NN
29633	99	10	of	of	IN
29633	99	11	the	the	DT
29633	99	12	air	air	NN
29633	99	13	blast	blast	NN
29633	99	14	with	with	IN
29633	99	15	the	the	DT
29633	99	16	increase	increase	NN
29633	99	17	in	in	IN
29633	99	18	the	the	DT
29633	99	19	temperature	temperature	NN
29633	99	20	of	of	IN
29633	99	21	the	the	DT
29633	99	22	metal	metal	NN
29633	99	23	"	"	''
29633	99	24	showed	show	VBD
29633	99	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	99	26	appreciation	appreciation	NN
29633	99	27	of	of	IN
29633	99	28	the	the	DT
29633	99	29	end	end	NN
29633	99	30	in	in	IN
29633	99	31	view	view	NN
29633	99	32	,	,	,
29633	99	33	and	and	CC
29633	99	34	the	the	DT
29633	99	35	general	general	JJ
29633	99	36	way	way	NN
29633	99	37	of	of	IN
29633	99	38	attaining	attain	VBG
29633	99	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	99	40	,	,	,
29633	99	41	though	though	IN
29633	99	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	99	43	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
29633	99	44	details	detail	NNS
29633	99	45	were	be	VBD
29633	99	46	still	still	RB
29633	99	47	crude	crude	JJ
29633	99	48	and	and	CC
29633	99	49	imperfect	imperfect	JJ
29633	99	50	.	.	.
29633	99	51	"	"	''
29633	100	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	100	2	16	16	CD
29633	100	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	100	4	See	see	VB
29633	100	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	100	6	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	100	7	Office	Office	NNP
29633	100	8	,	,	,
29633	100	9	Decision	Decision	NNP
29633	100	10	of	of	IN
29633	100	11	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	100	12	of	of	IN
29633	100	13	Patents	Patents	NNPS
29633	100	14	,	,	,
29633	100	15	dated	date	VBN
29633	100	16	April	April	NNP
29633	100	17	13	13	CD
29633	100	18	,	,	,
29633	100	19	1857	1857	CD
29633	100	20	,	,	,
29633	100	21	in	in	IN
29633	100	22	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	100	23	vs.	vs.	IN
29633	100	24	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	100	25	Interference	Interference	NNP
29633	100	26	.	.	.
29633	101	1	This	this	DT
29633	101	2	is	be	VBZ
29633	101	3	further	further	RB
29633	101	4	discussed	discuss	VBN
29633	101	5	below	below	IN
29633	101	6	(	(	-LRB-
29633	101	7	p.	p.	NN
29633	101	8	42	42	CD
29633	101	9	)	)	-RRB-
29633	101	10	.	.	.
29633	102	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	102	2	17	17	CD
29633	102	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	102	4	Dredge	Dredge	NNP
29633	102	5	,	,	,
29633	102	6	_	_	NNP
29633	102	7	op	op	NN
29633	102	8	.	.	.
29633	103	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	103	2	.	.	.
29633	103	3	_	_	NNP
29633	103	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	103	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	103	6	15	15	CD
29633	103	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	103	8	,	,	,
29633	103	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	103	10	912	912	CD
29633	103	11	.	.	.
29633	104	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	104	2	Illustration	illustration	NN
29633	104	3	:	:	:
29633	104	4	Figure	figure	VB
29633	104	5	1.--BESSEMER	1.--bessemer	CD
29633	104	6	'S	's	NN
29633	104	7	DESIGN	design	NN
29633	104	8	FOR	for	IN
29633	104	9	A	a	DT
29633	104	10	CONVERTER	CONVERTER	NNP
29633	104	11	,	,	,
29633	104	12	AS	as	IN
29633	104	13	SHOWN	SHOWN	NNP
29633	104	14	IN	in	IN
29633	104	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	104	16	PATENT	patent	NN
29633	104	17	16082	16082	CD
29633	104	18	.	.	.
29633	105	1	This	this	DT
29633	105	2	patent	patent	NN
29633	105	3	,	,	,
29633	105	4	dated	date	VBN
29633	105	5	November	November	NNP
29633	105	6	11	11	CD
29633	105	7	,	,	,
29633	105	8	1856	1856	CD
29633	105	9	,	,	,
29633	105	10	corresponds	correspond	VBZ
29633	105	11	with	with	IN
29633	105	12	British	british	JJ
29633	105	13	patent	patent	NN
29633	105	14	356	356	CD
29633	105	15	,	,	,
29633	105	16	dated	date	VBN
29633	105	17	February	February	NNP
29633	105	18	12	12	CD
29633	105	19	,	,	,
29633	105	20	1856	1856	CD
29633	105	21	.	.	.
29633	106	1	The	the	DT
29633	106	2	more	more	RBR
29633	106	3	familiar	familiar	JJ
29633	106	4	design	design	NN
29633	106	5	of	of	IN
29633	106	6	converter	converter	NN
29633	106	7	appeared	appear	VBD
29633	106	8	first	first	RB
29633	106	9	in	in	IN
29633	106	10	British	british	JJ
29633	106	11	patent	patent	NN
29633	106	12	578	578	CD
29633	106	13	,	,	,
29633	106	14	March	March	NNP
29633	106	15	1	1	CD
29633	106	16	,	,	,
29633	106	17	1860	1860	CD
29633	106	18	.	.	.
29633	107	1	The	the	DT
29633	107	2	contrast	contrast	NN
29633	107	3	with	with	IN
29633	107	4	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	107	5	's	's	POS
29633	107	6	schematic	schematic	JJ
29633	107	7	drawing	drawing	NN
29633	107	8	in	in	IN
29633	107	9	Fig	Fig	NNP
29633	107	10	.	.	.
29633	108	1	2	2	LS
29633	108	2	(	(	-LRB-
29633	108	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	108	4	42	42	CD
29633	108	5	)	)	-RRB-
29633	108	6	is	be	VBZ
29633	108	7	noticeable	noticeable	JJ
29633	108	8	.	.	.
29633	108	9	]	]	-RRB-
29633	109	1	Experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	109	2	were	be	VBD
29633	109	3	continued	continue	VBN
29633	109	4	and	and	CC
29633	109	5	several	several	JJ
29633	109	6	more	more	RBR
29633	109	7	British	british	JJ
29633	109	8	patents	patent	NNS
29633	109	9	were	be	VBD
29633	109	10	applied	apply	VBN
29633	109	11	for	for	IN
29633	109	12	before	before	IN
29633	109	13	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	109	14	made	make	VBD
29633	109	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	109	16	appearance	appearance	NN
29633	109	17	before	before	IN
29633	109	18	the	the	DT
29633	109	19	British	British	NNP
29633	109	20	Association	Association	NNP
29633	109	21	on	on	IN
29633	109	22	August	August	NNP
29633	109	23	13	13	CD
29633	109	24	,	,	,
29633	109	25	1856	1856	CD
29633	109	26	.	.	.
29633	110	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	110	2	18	18	CD
29633	110	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	110	4	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	110	5	described	describe	VBD
29633	110	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	110	7	first	first	JJ
29633	110	8	converter	converter	NN
29633	110	9	and	and	CC
29633	110	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	110	11	operation	operation	NN
29633	110	12	in	in	IN
29633	110	13	some	some	DT
29633	110	14	detail	detail	NN
29633	110	15	.	.	.
29633	111	1	Although	although	IN
29633	111	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	111	3	was	be	VBD
29633	111	4	soon	soon	RB
29633	111	5	to	to	TO
29633	111	6	realize	realize	VB
29633	111	7	that	that	IN
29633	111	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	111	9	"	"	``
29633	111	10	too	too	RB
29633	111	11	readily	readily	RB
29633	111	12	allowed	allow	VBD
29633	111	13	myself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	111	14	to	to	TO
29633	111	15	bring	bring	VB
29633	111	16	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	111	17	inventions	invention	NNS
29633	111	18	under	under	IN
29633	111	19	public	public	JJ
29633	111	20	notice,"[19	notice,"[19	ADD
29633	111	21	]	]	-RRB-
29633	111	22	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	111	23	had	have	VBD
29633	111	24	now	now	RB
29633	111	25	thrown	throw	VBN
29633	111	26	out	out	RP
29633	111	27	a	a	DT
29633	111	28	challenge	challenge	NN
29633	111	29	which	which	WDT
29633	111	30	eventually	eventually	RB
29633	111	31	had	have	VBD
29633	111	32	to	to	TO
29633	111	33	be	be	VB
29633	111	34	taken	take	VBN
29633	111	35	up	up	RP
29633	111	36	,	,	,
29633	111	37	regardless	regardless	RB
29633	111	38	of	of	IN
29633	111	39	the	the	DT
29633	111	40	strength	strength	NN
29633	111	41	of	of	IN
29633	111	42	the	the	DT
29633	111	43	vested	vested	JJ
29633	111	44	interests	interest	NNS
29633	111	45	involved	involve	VBN
29633	111	46	.	.	.
29633	112	1	The	the	DT
29633	112	2	provocation	provocation	NN
29633	112	3	came	come	VBD
29633	112	4	from	from	IN
29633	112	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	112	6	claims	claim	NNS
29633	112	7	that	that	IN
29633	112	8	the	the	DT
29633	112	9	product	product	NN
29633	112	10	of	of	IN
29633	112	11	the	the	DT
29633	112	12	first	first	JJ
29633	112	13	stage	stage	NN
29633	112	14	of	of	IN
29633	112	15	the	the	DT
29633	112	16	conversion	conversion	NN
29633	112	17	was	be	VBD
29633	112	18	the	the	DT
29633	112	19	equivalent	equivalent	NN
29633	112	20	of	of	IN
29633	112	21	charcoal	charcoal	NN
29633	112	22	iron	iron	NN
29633	112	23	,	,	,
29633	112	24	the	the	DT
29633	112	25	processes	process	NNS
29633	112	26	following	follow	VBG
29633	112	27	the	the	DT
29633	112	28	smelting	smelting	NN
29633	112	29	being	being	NN
29633	112	30	conducted	conduct	VBN
29633	112	31	without	without	IN
29633	112	32	contact	contact	NN
29633	112	33	with	with	IN
29633	112	34	,	,	,
29633	112	35	or	or	CC
29633	112	36	the	the	DT
29633	112	37	use	use	NN
29633	112	38	of	of	IN
29633	112	39	,	,	,
29633	112	40	any	any	DT
29633	112	41	mineral	mineral	NN
29633	112	42	fuel	fuel	NN
29633	112	43	;	;	:
29633	112	44	and	and	CC
29633	112	45	that	that	IN
29633	112	46	further	further	JJ
29633	112	47	blowing	blowing	NN
29633	112	48	could	could	MD
29633	112	49	be	be	VB
29633	112	50	used	use	VBN
29633	112	51	to	to	TO
29633	112	52	produce	produce	VB
29633	112	53	any	any	DT
29633	112	54	quality	quality	NN
29633	112	55	of	of	IN
29633	112	56	metal	metal	NN
29633	112	57	,	,	,
29633	112	58	that	that	RB
29633	112	59	is	is	RB
29633	112	60	,	,	,
29633	112	61	a	a	DT
29633	112	62	steel	steel	NN
29633	112	63	with	with	IN
29633	112	64	any	any	DT
29633	112	65	desired	desire	VBN
29633	112	66	percentage	percentage	NN
29633	112	67	of	of	IN
29633	112	68	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	112	69	.	.	.
29633	113	1	Yet	yet	RB
29633	113	2	,	,	,
29633	113	3	the	the	DT
29633	113	4	principal	principal	JJ
29633	113	5	irritant	irritant	NN
29633	113	6	to	to	IN
29633	113	7	the	the	DT
29633	113	8	complacency	complacency	NN
29633	113	9	of	of	IN
29633	113	10	the	the	DT
29633	113	11	ironmaster	ironmaster	NN
29633	113	12	must	must	MD
29633	113	13	have	have	VB
29633	113	14	been	be	VBN
29633	113	15	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	113	16	's	's	POS
29633	113	17	attack	attack	NN
29633	113	18	on	on	IN
29633	113	19	an	an	DT
29633	113	20	industry	industry	NN
29633	113	21	which	which	WDT
29633	113	22	had	have	VBD
29633	113	23	gone	go	VBN
29633	113	24	on	on	RP
29633	113	25	increasing	increase	VBG
29633	113	26	the	the	DT
29633	113	27	size	size	NN
29633	113	28	of	of	IN
29633	113	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	113	30	smelting	smelting	NN
29633	113	31	furnaces	furnace	NNS
29633	113	32	,	,	,
29633	113	33	thus	thus	RB
29633	113	34	improving	improve	VBG
29633	113	35	the	the	DT
29633	113	36	uniformity	uniformity	NN
29633	113	37	of	of	IN
29633	113	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	113	39	pig	pig	NN
29633	113	40	-	-	HYPH
29633	113	41	iron	iron	NN
29633	113	42	,	,	,
29633	113	43	without	without	IN
29633	113	44	modifying	modify	VBG
29633	113	45	the	the	DT
29633	113	46	puddling	puddling	NN
29633	113	47	process	process	NN
29633	113	48	,	,	,
29633	113	49	which	which	WDT
29633	113	50	at	at	IN
29633	113	51	best	good	JJS
29633	113	52	could	could	MD
29633	113	53	handle	handle	VB
29633	113	54	no	no	RB
29633	113	55	more	more	JJR
29633	113	56	than	than	IN
29633	113	57	400	400	CD
29633	113	58	to	to	TO
29633	113	59	500	500	CD
29633	113	60	pounds	pound	NNS
29633	113	61	of	of	IN
29633	113	62	iron	iron	NN
29633	113	63	at	at	IN
29633	113	64	a	a	DT
29633	113	65	time	time	NN
29633	113	66	,	,	,
29633	113	67	divided	divide	VBN
29633	113	68	into	into	IN
29633	113	69	the	the	DT
29633	113	70	"	"	``
29633	113	71	homeopathic	homeopathic	JJ
29633	113	72	doses	dose	NNS
29633	113	73	"	"	''
29633	113	74	of	of	IN
29633	113	75	70	70	CD
29633	113	76	or	or	CC
29633	113	77	80	80	CD
29633	113	78	pounds	pound	NNS
29633	113	79	capable	capable	JJ
29633	113	80	of	of	IN
29633	113	81	being	be	VBG
29633	113	82	handled	handle	VBN
29633	113	83	by	by	IN
29633	113	84	human	human	JJ
29633	113	85	labor	labor	NN
29633	113	86	.	.	.
29633	114	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	114	2	20	20	CD
29633	114	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	114	4	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	114	5	's	's	POS
29633	114	6	claim	claim	NN
29633	114	7	to	to	TO
29633	114	8	"	"	``
29633	114	9	do	do	VB
29633	114	10	"	"	''
29633	114	11	800	800	CD
29633	114	12	pounds	pound	NNS
29633	114	13	of	of	IN
29633	114	14	metal	metal	NN
29633	114	15	in	in	IN
29633	114	16	30	30	CD
29633	114	17	minutes	minute	NNS
29633	114	18	against	against	IN
29633	114	19	the	the	DT
29633	114	20	puddling	puddling	NN
29633	114	21	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	114	22	's	's	POS
29633	114	23	output	output	NN
29633	114	24	of	of	IN
29633	114	25	500	500	CD
29633	114	26	pounds	pound	NNS
29633	114	27	in	in	IN
29633	114	28	two	two	CD
29633	114	29	hours	hour	NNS
29633	114	30	was	be	VBD
29633	114	31	calculated	calculate	VBN
29633	114	32	to	to	TO
29633	114	33	arouse	arouse	VB
29633	114	34	the	the	DT
29633	114	35	opposition	opposition	NN
29633	114	36	of	of	IN
29633	114	37	those	those	DT
29633	114	38	who	who	WP
29633	114	39	feared	fear	VBD
29633	114	40	the	the	DT
29633	114	41	loss	loss	NN
29633	114	42	of	of	IN
29633	114	43	capital	capital	NN
29633	114	44	invested	invest	VBN
29633	114	45	in	in	IN
29633	114	46	puddling	puddle	VBG
29633	114	47	furnaces	furnace	NNS
29633	114	48	and	and	CC
29633	114	49	of	of	IN
29633	114	50	those	those	DT
29633	114	51	who	who	WP
29633	114	52	suspected	suspect	VBD
29633	114	53	that	that	IN
29633	114	54	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	114	55	jobs	job	NNS
29633	114	56	might	may	MD
29633	114	57	be	be	VB
29633	114	58	in	in	IN
29633	114	59	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
29633	114	60	.	.	.
29633	115	1	The	the	DT
29633	115	2	ensuing	ensue	VBG
29633	115	3	criticism	criticism	NN
29633	115	4	of	of	IN
29633	115	5	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	115	6	has	have	VBZ
29633	115	7	to	to	TO
29633	115	8	be	be	VB
29633	115	9	interpreted	interpret	VBN
29633	115	10	,	,	,
29633	115	11	therefore	therefore	RB
29633	115	12	,	,	,
29633	115	13	with	with	IN
29633	115	14	this	this	DT
29633	115	15	in	in	IN
29633	115	16	mind	mind	NN
29633	115	17	;	;	:
29633	115	18	not	not	RB
29633	115	19	by	by	IN
29633	115	20	any	any	DT
29633	115	21	means	mean	NNS
29633	115	22	was	be	VBD
29633	115	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	115	24	entirely	entirely	RB
29633	115	25	based	base	VBN
29633	115	26	on	on	IN
29633	115	27	objective	objective	JJ
29633	115	28	consideration	consideration	NN
29633	115	29	of	of	IN
29633	115	30	the	the	DT
29633	115	31	method	method	NN
29633	115	32	or	or	CC
29633	115	33	the	the	DT
29633	115	34	product	product	NN
29633	115	35	.	.	.
29633	116	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	116	2	21	21	CD
29633	116	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	116	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	116	5	18	18	CD
29633	116	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	116	7	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	116	8	's	's	POS
29633	116	9	paper	paper	NN
29633	116	10	was	be	VBD
29633	116	11	reported	report	VBN
29633	116	12	in	in	IN
29633	116	13	_	_	NNP
29633	116	14	The	the	DT
29633	116	15	Times	Times	NNP
29633	116	16	_	_	NNP
29633	116	17	,	,	,
29633	116	18	London	London	NNP
29633	116	19	,	,	,
29633	116	20	August	August	NNP
29633	116	21	14	14	CD
29633	116	22	,	,	,
29633	116	23	1856	1856	CD
29633	116	24	.	.	.
29633	117	1	By	by	IN
29633	117	2	the	the	DT
29633	117	3	time	time	NN
29633	117	4	the	the	DT
29633	117	5	Transactions	Transactions	NNPS
29633	117	6	of	of	IN
29633	117	7	the	the	DT
29633	117	8	British	British	NNP
29633	117	9	Association	Association	NNP
29633	117	10	were	be	VBD
29633	117	11	prepared	prepare	VBN
29633	117	12	for	for	IN
29633	117	13	publication	publication	NN
29633	117	14	,	,	,
29633	117	15	the	the	DT
29633	117	16	controversy	controversy	NN
29633	117	17	aroused	arouse	VBN
29633	117	18	by	by	IN
29633	117	19	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	117	20	's	's	POS
29633	117	21	claim	claim	NN
29633	117	22	to	to	TO
29633	117	23	manufacture	manufacture	VB
29633	117	24	"	"	``
29633	117	25	malleable	malleable	JJ
29633	117	26	iron	iron	NN
29633	117	27	and	and	CC
29633	117	28	steel	steel	NN
29633	117	29	without	without	IN
29633	117	30	fuel	fuel	NN
29633	117	31	"	"	''
29633	117	32	had	have	VBD
29633	117	33	broken	break	VBN
29633	117	34	out	out	RP
29633	117	35	and	and	CC
29633	117	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	117	37	was	be	VBD
29633	117	38	decided	decide	VBN
29633	117	39	not	not	RB
29633	117	40	to	to	TO
29633	117	41	report	report	VB
29633	117	42	the	the	DT
29633	117	43	paper	paper	NN
29633	117	44	.	.	.
29633	118	1	Dredge	Dredge	NNP
29633	118	2	(	(	-LRB-
29633	118	3	_	_	NNP
29633	118	4	op	op	NN
29633	118	5	.	.	.
29633	119	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	119	2	.	.	.
29633	119	3	_	_	NNP
29633	119	4	,	,	,
29633	119	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	119	6	15	15	CD
29633	119	7	,	,	,
29633	119	8	p.	p.	NN
29633	119	9	915	915	CD
29633	119	10	)	)	-RRB-
29633	119	11	describes	describe	VBZ
29633	119	12	this	this	DT
29633	119	13	decision	decision	NN
29633	119	14	as	as	IN
29633	119	15	"	"	``
29633	119	16	sagacious	sagacious	JJ
29633	119	17	.	.	.
29633	119	18	"	"	''
29633	120	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	120	2	19	19	CD
29633	120	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	120	4	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	120	5	,	,	,
29633	120	6	_	_	NNP
29633	120	7	op	op	NN
29633	120	8	.	.	.
29633	121	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	121	2	.	.	.
29633	121	3	_	_	NNP
29633	121	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	121	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	121	6	7	7	CD
29633	121	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	121	8	,	,	,
29633	121	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	121	10	164	164	CD
29633	121	11	.	.	.
29633	122	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	122	2	20	20	CD
29633	122	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	122	4	_	_	NNP
29633	122	5	The	the	DT
29633	122	6	Times	Times	NNP
29633	122	7	_	_	NNP
29633	122	8	,	,	,
29633	122	9	London	London	NNP
29633	122	10	,	,	,
29633	122	11	August	August	NNP
29633	122	12	14	14	CD
29633	122	13	,	,	,
29633	122	14	1856	1856	CD
29633	122	15	.	.	.
29633	123	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	123	2	21	21	CD
29633	123	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	123	4	David	David	NNP
29633	123	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	123	6	recognized	recognize	VBD
29633	123	7	that	that	IN
29633	123	8	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	123	9	's	's	POS
29633	123	10	great	great	JJ
29633	123	11	feature	feature	NN
29633	123	12	was	be	VBD
29633	123	13	this	this	DT
29633	123	14	effort	effort	NN
29633	123	15	to	to	TO
29633	123	16	"	"	``
29633	123	17	raise	raise	VB
29633	123	18	the	the	DT
29633	123	19	after	after	IN
29633	123	20	processes	process	NNS
29633	123	21	...	...	:
29633	123	22	to	to	IN
29633	123	23	a	a	DT
29633	123	24	level	level	NN
29633	123	25	commensurate	commensurate	JJ
29633	123	26	with	with	IN
29633	123	27	the	the	DT
29633	123	28	preceding	precede	VBG
29633	123	29	case	case	NN
29633	123	30	"	"	''
29633	123	31	(	(	-LRB-
29633	123	32	_	_	NNP
29633	123	33	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	123	34	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	123	35	_	_	NNP
29633	123	36	,	,	,
29633	123	37	1856	1856	CD
29633	123	38	,	,	,
29633	123	39	p.	p.	NN
29633	123	40	599	599	CD
29633	123	41	)	)	-RRB-
29633	123	42	.	.	.
29633	124	1	Within	within	IN
29633	124	2	a	a	DT
29633	124	3	month	month	NN
29633	124	4	of	of	IN
29633	124	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	124	6	address	address	NN
29633	124	7	,	,	,
29633	124	8	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	124	9	had	have	VBD
29633	124	10	sold	sell	VBN
29633	124	11	licenses	license	NNS
29633	124	12	to	to	IN
29633	124	13	several	several	JJ
29633	124	14	ironmasters	ironmaster	NNS
29633	124	15	(	(	-LRB-
29633	124	16	outside	outside	IN
29633	124	17	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	124	18	)	)	-RRB-
29633	124	19	and	and	CC
29633	124	20	so	so	RB
29633	124	21	provided	provide	VBD
29633	124	22	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	124	23	with	with	IN
29633	124	24	capital	capital	NN
29633	124	25	with	with	IN
29633	124	26	which	which	WDT
29633	124	27	to	to	TO
29633	124	28	continue	continue	VB
29633	124	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	124	30	development	development	NN
29633	124	31	work	work	NN
29633	124	32	;	;	:
29633	124	33	but	but	CC
29633	124	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	124	35	refused	refuse	VBD
29633	124	36	to	to	TO
29633	124	37	sell	sell	VB
29633	124	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	124	39	patents	patent	NNS
29633	124	40	outright	outright	RB
29633	124	41	to	to	IN
29633	124	42	the	the	DT
29633	124	43	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	124	44	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	124	45	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	124	46	Works	Works	NNP
29633	124	47	and	and	CC
29633	124	48	by	by	IN
29633	124	49	this	this	DT
29633	124	50	action	action	NN
29633	124	51	,	,	,
29633	124	52	as	as	IN
29633	124	53	will	will	MD
29633	124	54	be	be	VB
29633	124	55	seen	see	VBN
29633	124	56	,	,	,
29633	124	57	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	124	58	created	create	VBD
29633	124	59	an	an	DT
29633	124	60	enemy	enemy	NN
29633	124	61	for	for	IN
29633	124	62	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	124	63	.	.	.
29633	125	1	The	the	DT
29633	125	2	three	three	CD
29633	125	3	years	year	NNS
29633	125	4	between	between	IN
29633	125	5	1856	1856	CD
29633	125	6	and	and	CC
29633	125	7	1859	1859	CD
29633	125	8	,	,	,
29633	125	9	when	when	WRB
29633	125	10	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	125	11	opened	open	VBD
29633	125	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	125	13	own	own	JJ
29633	125	14	steel	steel	NN
29633	125	15	works	work	NNS
29633	125	16	in	in	IN
29633	125	17	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	125	18	,	,	,
29633	125	19	were	be	VBD
29633	125	20	occupied	occupy	VBN
29633	125	21	in	in	IN
29633	125	22	tracing	trace	VBG
29633	125	23	the	the	DT
29633	125	24	causes	cause	NNS
29633	125	25	of	of	IN
29633	125	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	125	27	initial	initial	JJ
29633	125	28	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
29633	125	29	.	.	.
29633	126	1	There	there	EX
29633	126	2	was	be	VBD
29633	126	3	continued	continue	VBN
29633	126	4	controversy	controversy	NN
29633	126	5	in	in	IN
29633	126	6	the	the	DT
29633	126	7	technical	technical	JJ
29633	126	8	press	press	NN
29633	126	9	.	.	.
29633	127	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	127	2	(	(	-LRB-
29633	127	3	unless	unless	IN
29633	127	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	127	5	used	use	VBD
29633	127	6	a	a	DT
29633	127	7	_	_	NNP
29633	127	8	nom	nom	NNP
29633	127	9	-	-	HYPH
29633	127	10	de	de	NN
29633	127	11	-	-	NN
29633	127	12	plume	plume	JJ
29633	127	13	_	_	NNP
29633	127	14	)	)	-RRB-
29633	127	15	took	take	VBD
29633	127	16	no	no	DT
29633	127	17	part	part	NN
29633	127	18	in	in	IN
29633	127	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	127	20	and	and	CC
29633	127	21	remained	remain	VBD
29633	127	22	silent	silent	JJ
29633	127	23	until	until	IN
29633	127	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	127	25	made	make	VBD
29633	127	26	another	another	DT
29633	127	27	public	public	JJ
29633	127	28	appearance	appearance	NN
29633	127	29	before	before	IN
29633	127	30	the	the	DT
29633	127	31	Institution	Institution	NNP
29633	127	32	of	of	IN
29633	127	33	Civil	Civil	NNP
29633	127	34	Engineers	Engineers	NNPS
29633	127	35	in	in	IN
29633	127	36	London	London	NNP
29633	127	37	(	(	-LRB-
29633	127	38	May	May	NNP
29633	127	39	1859	1859	CD
29633	127	40	)	)	-RRB-
29633	127	41	.	.	.
29633	128	1	By	by	IN
29633	128	2	this	this	DT
29633	128	3	time	time	NN
29633	128	4	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	128	5	's	's	POS
29633	128	6	process	process	NN
29633	128	7	was	be	VBD
29633	128	8	accepted	accept	VBN
29633	128	9	as	as	IN
29633	128	10	a	a	DT
29633	128	11	practical	practical	JJ
29633	128	12	one	one	NN
29633	128	13	,	,	,
29633	128	14	and	and	CC
29633	128	15	the	the	DT
29633	128	16	claims	claim	NNS
29633	128	17	of	of	IN
29633	128	18	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	128	19	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	128	20	to	to	TO
29633	128	21	share	share	VB
29633	128	22	in	in	IN
29633	128	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	128	24	achievement	achievement	NN
29633	128	25	was	be	VBD
29633	128	26	becoming	become	VBG
29633	128	27	clamorous	clamorous	JJ
29633	128	28	.	.	.
29633	129	1	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	129	2	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	129	3	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	129	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	129	5	Forester	Forester	NNP
29633	129	6	)	)	-RRB-
29633	129	7	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	129	8	(	(	-LRB-
29633	129	9	1811	1811	CD
29633	129	10	-	-	SYM
29633	129	11	1891	1891	CD
29633	129	12	)	)	-RRB-
29633	129	13	,	,	,
29633	129	14	born	bear	VBN
29633	129	15	in	in	IN
29633	129	16	the	the	DT
29633	129	17	Forest	Forest	NNP
29633	129	18	of	of	IN
29633	129	19	Dean	Dean	NNP
29633	129	20	,	,	,
29633	129	21	Gloucestershire	Gloucestershire	NNP
29633	129	22	,	,	,
29633	129	23	of	of	IN
29633	129	24	a	a	DT
29633	129	25	Scots	Scots	NNP
29633	129	26	father	father	NN
29633	129	27	(	(	-LRB-
29633	129	28	David	David	NNP
29633	129	29	,	,	,
29633	129	30	1772	1772	CD
29633	129	31	-	-	SYM
29633	129	32	1847	1847	CD
29633	129	33	)	)	-RRB-
29633	129	34	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	129	35	a	a	DT
29633	129	36	noted	note	VBN
29633	129	37	contributor	contributor	NN
29633	129	38	to	to	IN
29633	129	39	the	the	DT
29633	129	40	metallurgy	metallurgy	NN
29633	129	41	of	of	IN
29633	129	42	iron	iron	NN
29633	129	43	and	and	CC
29633	129	44	steel	steel	NN
29633	129	45	,	,	,
29633	129	46	is	be	VBZ
29633	129	47	,	,	,
29633	129	48	like	like	IN
29633	129	49	the	the	DT
29633	129	50	American	American	NNP
29633	129	51	William	William	NNP
29633	129	52	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	129	53	,	,	,
29633	129	54	considered	consider	VBN
29633	129	55	by	by	IN
29633	129	56	many	many	JJ
29633	129	57	to	to	TO
29633	129	58	have	have	VB
29633	129	59	been	be	VBN
29633	129	60	a	a	DT
29633	129	61	victim	victim	NN
29633	129	62	of	of	IN
29633	129	63	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	129	64	's	's	POS
29633	129	65	astuteness	astuteness	NN
29633	129	66	--	--	:
29633	129	67	or	or	CC
29633	129	68	villainy	villainy	NN
29633	129	69	.	.	.
29633	130	1	Because	because	IN
29633	130	2	of	of	IN
29633	130	3	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	130	4	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	130	5	's	's	POS
29633	130	6	preference	preference	NN
29633	130	7	for	for	IN
29633	130	8	the	the	DT
29633	130	9	quiet	quiet	NN
29633	130	10	of	of	IN
29633	130	11	Coleford	Coleford	NNP
29633	130	12	,	,	,
29633	130	13	many	many	JJ
29633	130	14	important	important	JJ
29633	130	15	facts	fact	NNS
29633	130	16	about	about	IN
29633	130	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	130	18	career	career	NN
29633	130	19	are	be	VBP
29633	130	20	lacking	lack	VBG
29633	130	21	;	;	:
29633	130	22	but	but	CC
29633	130	23	even	even	RB
29633	130	24	if	if	IN
29633	130	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	130	26	physical	physical	JJ
29633	130	27	life	life	NN
29633	130	28	was	be	VBD
29633	130	29	that	that	DT
29633	130	30	of	of	IN
29633	130	31	a	a	DT
29633	130	32	recluse	recluse	NN
29633	130	33	,	,	,
29633	130	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	130	35	frequent	frequent	NN
29633	130	36	and	and	CC
29633	130	37	verbose	verbose	VB
29633	130	38	contributions	contribution	NNS
29633	130	39	to	to	IN
29633	130	40	the	the	DT
29633	130	41	correspondence	correspondence	NN
29633	130	42	columns	column	NNS
29633	130	43	of	of	IN
29633	130	44	the	the	DT
29633	130	45	technical	technical	JJ
29633	130	46	press	press	NN
29633	130	47	made	make	VBD
29633	130	48	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	130	49	well	well	RB
29633	130	50	-	-	HYPH
29633	130	51	known	know	VBN
29633	130	52	to	to	IN
29633	130	53	the	the	DT
29633	130	54	iron	iron	NN
29633	130	55	trade	trade	NN
29633	130	56	.	.	.
29633	131	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	131	2	is	be	VBZ
29633	131	3	from	from	IN
29633	131	4	these	these	DT
29633	131	5	letters	letter	NNS
29633	131	6	that	that	IN
29633	131	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	131	8	must	must	MD
29633	131	9	be	be	VB
29633	131	10	judged	judge	VBN
29633	131	11	.	.	.
29633	132	1	In	in	IN
29633	132	2	view	view	NN
29633	132	3	of	of	IN
29633	132	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	132	5	propensity	propensity	NN
29633	132	6	to	to	TO
29633	132	7	intervene	intervene	VB
29633	132	8	pontifically	pontifically	RB
29633	132	9	in	in	IN
29633	132	10	every	every	DT
29633	132	11	discussion	discussion	NN
29633	132	12	concerning	concern	VBG
29633	132	13	the	the	DT
29633	132	14	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	132	15	of	of	IN
29633	132	16	iron	iron	NN
29633	132	17	and	and	CC
29633	132	18	steel	steel	NN
29633	132	19	,	,	,
29633	132	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	132	21	is	be	VBZ
29633	132	22	somewhat	somewhat	RB
29633	132	23	surprising	surprising	JJ
29633	132	24	that	that	IN
29633	132	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	132	26	refrained	refrain	VBD
29633	132	27	from	from	IN
29633	132	28	comment	comment	NN
29633	132	29	on	on	IN
29633	132	30	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	132	31	's	's	POS
29633	132	32	British	British	NNP
29633	132	33	Association	Association	NNP
29633	132	34	address	address	NN
29633	132	35	of	of	IN
29633	132	36	August	August	NNP
29633	132	37	1856	1856	CD
29633	132	38	for	for	IN
29633	132	39	more	more	JJR
29633	132	40	than	than	IN
29633	132	41	fourteen	fourteen	CD
29633	132	42	months	month	NNS
29633	132	43	.	.	.
29633	133	1	The	the	DT
29633	133	2	debate	debate	NN
29633	133	3	was	be	VBD
29633	133	4	opened	open	VBN
29633	133	5	over	over	IN
29633	133	6	the	the	DT
29633	133	7	signature	signature	NN
29633	133	8	of	of	IN
29633	133	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	133	10	brother	brother	NN
29633	133	11	David	David	NNP
29633	133	12	who	who	WP
29633	133	13	shared	share	VBD
29633	133	14	the	the	DT
29633	133	15	family	family	NN
29633	133	16	facility	facility	NN
29633	133	17	with	with	IN
29633	133	18	the	the	DT
29633	133	19	pen	pen	NN
29633	133	20	.	.	.
29633	134	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	134	2	22	22	CD
29633	134	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	134	4	Recognizing	Recognizing	NNP
29633	134	5	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	134	6	's	's	POS
29633	134	7	invention	invention	NN
29633	134	8	as	as	IN
29633	134	9	a	a	DT
29633	134	10	"	"	``
29633	134	11	congruous	congruous	JJ
29633	134	12	appendage	appendage	NN
29633	134	13	to	to	IN
29633	134	14	[	[	-LRB-
29633	134	15	the	the	DT
29633	134	16	]	]	-RRB-
29633	134	17	now	now	RB
29633	134	18	highly	highly	RB
29633	134	19	developed	develop	VBN
29633	134	20	powers	power	NNS
29633	134	21	of	of	IN
29633	134	22	the	the	DT
29633	134	23	blast	blast	NN
29633	134	24	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	134	25	"	"	''
29633	134	26	which	which	WDT
29633	134	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	134	28	describes	describe	VBZ
29633	134	29	as	as	IN
29633	134	30	"	"	``
29633	134	31	too	too	RB
29633	134	32	convenient	convenient	JJ
29633	134	33	,	,	,
29633	134	34	too	too	RB
29633	134	35	powerful	powerful	JJ
29633	134	36	and	and	CC
29633	134	37	too	too	RB
29633	134	38	capable	capable	JJ
29633	134	39	of	of	IN
29633	134	40	further	further	JJ
29633	134	41	development	development	NN
29633	134	42	to	to	TO
29633	134	43	be	be	VB
29633	134	44	superseded	supersede	VBN
29633	134	45	by	by	IN
29633	134	46	any	any	DT
29633	134	47	retrograde	retrograde	NN
29633	134	48	process	process	NN
29633	134	49	,	,	,
29633	134	50	"	"	''
29633	134	51	David	David	NNP
29633	134	52	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	134	53	greeted	greet	VBD
29633	134	54	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	134	55	's	's	POS
29633	134	56	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	134	57	as	as	IN
29633	134	58	"	"	``
29633	134	59	one	one	CD
29633	134	60	of	of	IN
29633	134	61	the	the	DT
29633	134	62	greatest	great	JJS
29633	134	63	operations	operation	NNS
29633	134	64	ever	ever	RB
29633	134	65	devised	devise	VBN
29633	134	66	in	in	IN
29633	134	67	metallurgy	metallurgy	NN
29633	134	68	.	.	.
29633	135	1	"	"	``
29633	135	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	135	3	23	23	CD
29633	135	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	135	5	A	a	DT
29633	135	6	month	month	NN
29633	135	7	later	later	RB
29633	135	8	,	,	,
29633	135	9	however	however	RB
29633	135	10	,	,	,
29633	135	11	David	David	NNP
29633	135	12	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	135	13	had	have	VBD
29633	135	14	so	so	RB
29633	135	15	modified	modify	VBN
29633	135	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	135	17	opinion	opinion	NN
29633	135	18	of	of	IN
29633	135	19	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	135	20	as	as	IN
29633	135	21	to	to	TO
29633	135	22	come	come	VB
29633	135	23	to	to	IN
29633	135	24	the	the	DT
29633	135	25	conclusion	conclusion	NN
29633	135	26	that	that	IN
29633	135	27	the	the	DT
29633	135	28	latter	latter	JJ
29633	135	29	"	"	''
29633	135	30	must	must	MD
29633	135	31	indeed	indeed	RB
29633	135	32	be	be	VB
29633	135	33	classed	class	VBN
29633	135	34	with	with	IN
29633	135	35	the	the	DT
29633	135	36	most	most	RBS
29633	135	37	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
29633	135	38	inventors	inventor	NNS
29633	135	39	.	.	.
29633	135	40	"	"	''
29633	136	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	136	2	gave	give	VBD
29633	136	3	as	as	IN
29633	136	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	136	5	reason	reason	NN
29633	136	6	for	for	IN
29633	136	7	this	this	DT
29633	136	8	turnabout	turnabout	RB
29633	136	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	136	10	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	136	11	that	that	IN
29633	136	12	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
29633	136	13	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	136	14	had	have	VBD
29633	136	15	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBN
29633	136	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	136	17	process	process	NN
29633	136	18	of	of	IN
29633	136	19	"	"	``
29633	136	20	purifying	purify	VBG
29633	136	21	"	"	''
29633	136	22	metal	metal	NN
29633	136	23	successfully	successfully	RB
29633	136	24	and	and	CC
29633	136	25	had	have	VBD
29633	136	26	indeed	indeed	RB
29633	136	27	been	be	VBN
29633	136	28	granted	grant	VBN
29633	136	29	a	a	DT
29633	136	30	provisional	provisional	JJ
29633	136	31	patent	patent	NN
29633	136	32	a	a	DT
29633	136	33	month	month	NN
29633	136	34	before	before	IN
29633	136	35	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	136	36	.	.	.
29633	137	1	The	the	DT
29633	137	2	sharp	sharp	JJ
29633	137	3	practice	practice	NN
29633	137	4	of	of	IN
29633	137	5	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	137	6	's	's	POS
29633	137	7	patent	patent	NN
29633	137	8	lawyer	lawyer	NN
29633	137	9	,	,	,
29633	137	10	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	137	11	claimed	claim	VBD
29633	137	12	,	,	,
29633	137	13	had	have	VBD
29633	137	14	deprived	deprive	VBN
29633	137	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	137	16	of	of	IN
29633	137	17	an	an	DT
29633	137	18	opportunity	opportunity	NN
29633	137	19	of	of	IN
29633	137	20	proving	prove	VBG
29633	137	21	priority	priority	NN
29633	137	22	of	of	IN
29633	137	23	invention	invention	NN
29633	137	24	against	against	IN
29633	137	25	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	137	26	.	.	.
29633	138	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	138	2	was	be	VBD
29633	138	3	convinced	convince	VBN
29633	138	4	that	that	IN
29633	138	5	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	138	6	's	's	POS
29633	138	7	was	be	VBD
29633	138	8	the	the	DT
29633	138	9	first	first	JJ
29633	138	10	in	in	IN
29633	138	11	the	the	DT
29633	138	12	field	field	NN
29633	138	13	.	.	.
29633	139	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	139	2	24	24	CD
29633	139	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	139	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	139	5	22	22	CD
29633	139	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	139	7	See	see	VB
29633	139	8	_	_	NNP
29633	139	9	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	139	10	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	139	11	_	_	NNP
29633	139	12	,	,	,
29633	139	13	1857	1857	CD
29633	139	14	,	,	,
29633	139	15	vol	vol	NNP
29633	139	16	.	.	.
29633	140	1	27	27	CD
29633	140	2	,	,	,
29633	140	3	pp	pp	NNP
29633	140	4	.	.	.
29633	141	1	839	839	CD
29633	141	2	and	and	CC
29633	141	3	855	855	CD
29633	141	4	.	.	.
29633	142	1	David	David	NNP
29633	142	2	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	142	3	withdrew	withdraw	VBD
29633	142	4	from	from	IN
29633	142	5	the	the	DT
29633	142	6	discussion	discussion	NN
29633	142	7	after	after	IN
29633	142	8	1858	1858	CD
29633	142	9	and	and	CC
29633	142	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	142	11	relapse	relapse	NN
29633	142	12	into	into	IN
29633	142	13	obscurity	obscurity	NN
29633	142	14	is	be	VBZ
29633	142	15	only	only	RB
29633	142	16	broken	break	VBN
29633	142	17	by	by	IN
29633	142	18	an	an	DT
29633	142	19	appeal	appeal	NN
29633	142	20	for	for	IN
29633	142	21	funds	fund	NNS
29633	142	22	for	for	IN
29633	142	23	the	the	DT
29633	142	24	family	family	NN
29633	142	25	of	of	IN
29633	142	26	Henry	Henry	NNP
29633	142	27	Cort	Cort	NNP
29633	142	28	.	.	.
29633	143	1	A	a	DT
29633	143	2	biographer	biographer	NN
29633	143	3	of	of	IN
29633	143	4	the	the	DT
29633	143	5	Mushets	Mushets	NNPS
29633	143	6	is	be	VBZ
29633	143	7	of	of	IN
29633	143	8	the	the	DT
29633	143	9	opinion	opinion	NN
29633	143	10	that	that	IN
29633	143	11	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	143	12	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	143	13	wrote	write	VBD
29633	143	14	these	these	DT
29633	143	15	letters	letter	NNS
29633	143	16	and	and	CC
29633	143	17	obtained	obtain	VBD
29633	143	18	David	David	NNP
29633	143	19	's	's	POS
29633	143	20	signature	signature	NN
29633	143	21	to	to	IN
29633	143	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
29633	143	23	(	(	-LRB-
29633	143	24	Fred	Fred	NNP
29633	143	25	M.	M.	NNP
29633	143	26	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
29633	143	27	,	,	,
29633	143	28	_	_	NNP
29633	143	29	The	the	DT
29633	143	30	story	story	NN
29633	143	31	of	of	IN
29633	143	32	the	the	DT
29633	143	33	Mushets	Mushets	NNPS
29633	143	34	_	_	NNP
29633	143	35	,	,	,
29633	143	36	London	London	NNP
29633	143	37	,	,	,
29633	143	38	1952	1952	CD
29633	143	39	,	,	,
29633	143	40	p.	p.	NN
29633	143	41	44	44	CD
29633	143	42	,	,	,
29633	143	43	footnote	footnote	NN
29633	143	44	)	)	-RRB-
29633	143	45	.	.	.
29633	144	1	The	the	DT
29633	144	2	similarity	similarity	NN
29633	144	3	in	in	IN
29633	144	4	the	the	DT
29633	144	5	style	style	NN
29633	144	6	of	of	IN
29633	144	7	the	the	DT
29633	144	8	two	two	CD
29633	144	9	brothers	brother	NNS
29633	144	10	is	be	VBZ
29633	144	11	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
29633	144	12	enough	enough	RB
29633	144	13	to	to	TO
29633	144	14	support	support	VB
29633	144	15	this	this	DT
29633	144	16	idea	idea	NN
29633	144	17	.	.	.
29633	145	1	If	if	IN
29633	145	2	this	this	DT
29633	145	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	145	4	so	so	RB
29633	145	5	,	,	,
29633	145	6	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	145	7	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	145	8	who	who	WP
29633	145	9	disagreed	disagree	VBD
29633	145	10	with	with	IN
29633	145	11	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	145	12	as	as	IN
29633	145	13	"	"	``
29633	145	14	Sideros	Sideros	NNP
29633	145	15	"	"	''
29633	145	16	was	be	VBD
29633	145	17	also	also	RB
29633	145	18	in	in	IN
29633	145	19	controversy	controversy	NN
29633	145	20	with	with	IN
29633	145	21	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	145	22	writing	write	VBG
29633	145	23	as	as	IN
29633	145	24	"	"	``
29633	145	25	David	David	NNP
29633	145	26	.	.	.
29633	145	27	"	"	''
29633	146	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	146	2	23	23	CD
29633	146	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	146	4	_	_	NNP
29633	146	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	146	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	146	7	_	_	NNP
29633	146	8	,	,	,
29633	146	9	1856	1856	CD
29633	146	10	,	,	,
29633	146	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	146	12	.	.	.
29633	147	1	26	26	CD
29633	147	2	,	,	,
29633	147	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	147	4	567	567	CD
29633	147	5	.	.	.
29633	148	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	148	2	24	24	CD
29633	148	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	148	4	_	_	NNP
29633	148	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	148	6	.	.	.
29633	148	7	_	_	NNP
29633	148	8	,	,	,
29633	148	9	pp	pp	NNP
29633	148	10	.	.	.
29633	149	1	631	631	CD
29633	149	2	and	and	CC
29633	149	3	647	647	CD
29633	149	4	.	.	.
29633	150	1	The	the	DT
29633	150	2	case	case	NN
29633	150	3	of	of	IN
29633	150	4	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	150	5	will	will	MD
29633	150	6	be	be	VB
29633	150	7	discussed	discuss	VBN
29633	150	8	below	below	IN
29633	150	9	(	(	-LRB-
29633	150	10	p.	p.	NN
29633	150	11	36	36	CD
29633	150	12	)	)	-RRB-
29633	150	13	.	.	.
29633	151	1	David	David	NNP
29633	151	2	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	151	3	had	have	VBD
29633	151	4	overlooked	overlook	VBN
29633	151	5	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	151	6	's	's	POS
29633	151	7	patent	patent	NN
29633	151	8	of	of	IN
29633	151	9	January	January	NNP
29633	151	10	10	10	CD
29633	151	11	,	,	,
29633	151	12	1855	1855	CD
29633	151	13	.	.	.
29633	152	1	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	152	2	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	152	3	's	's	POS
29633	152	4	campaign	campaign	NN
29633	152	5	on	on	IN
29633	152	6	behalf	behalf	NN
29633	152	7	of	of	IN
29633	152	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	152	9	own	own	JJ
29633	152	10	claims	claim	NNS
29633	152	11	to	to	TO
29633	152	12	have	have	VB
29633	152	13	made	make	VBN
29633	152	14	the	the	DT
29633	152	15	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	152	16	process	process	NN
29633	152	17	effective	effective	JJ
29633	152	18	was	be	VBD
29633	152	19	introduced	introduce	VBN
29633	152	20	in	in	IN
29633	152	21	October	October	NNP
29633	152	22	1857	1857	CD
29633	152	23	,	,	,
29633	152	24	two	two	CD
29633	152	25	years	year	NNS
29633	152	26	after	after	IN
29633	152	27	the	the	DT
29633	152	28	beginning	beginning	NN
29633	152	29	of	of	IN
29633	152	30	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	152	31	's	's	POS
29633	152	32	experiment	experiment	NN
29633	152	33	and	and	CC
29633	152	34	after	after	IN
29633	152	35	one	one	CD
29633	152	36	year	year	NN
29633	152	37	of	of	IN
29633	152	38	silence	silence	NN
29633	152	39	on	on	IN
29633	152	40	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	152	41	's	's	POS
29633	152	42	part	part	NN
29633	152	43	.	.	.
29633	153	1	Writing	write	VBG
29633	153	2	as	as	IN
29633	153	3	"	"	``
29633	153	4	Sideros"[25	Sideros"[25	NNP
29633	153	5	]	]	-RRB-
29633	153	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	153	7	gave	give	VBD
29633	153	8	credit	credit	NN
29633	153	9	to	to	IN
29633	153	10	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	153	11	for	for	IN
29633	153	12	"	"	``
29633	153	13	the	the	DT
29633	153	14	great	great	JJ
29633	153	15	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	153	16	that	that	IN
29633	153	17	pig	pig	NN
29633	153	18	-	-	HYPH
29633	153	19	iron	iron	NN
29633	153	20	can	can	MD
29633	153	21	,	,	,
29633	153	22	whilst	whilst	IN
29633	153	23	in	in	IN
29633	153	24	the	the	DT
29633	153	25	fluid	fluid	JJ
29633	153	26	state	state	NN
29633	153	27	,	,	,
29633	153	28	be	be	VB
29633	153	29	purified	purify	VBN
29633	153	30	...	...	:
29633	153	31	by	by	IN
29633	153	32	forcing	force	VBG
29633	153	33	currents	current	NNS
29633	153	34	of	of	IN
29633	153	35	air	air	NN
29633	153	36	under	under	IN
29633	153	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	153	38	...	...	NFP
29633	153	39	,	,	,
29633	153	40	"	"	''
29633	153	41	though	though	IN
29633	153	42	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	153	43	had	have	VBD
29633	153	44	failed	fail	VBN
29633	153	45	to	to	TO
29633	153	46	observe	observe	VB
29633	153	47	the	the	DT
29633	153	48	use	use	NN
29633	153	49	of	of	IN
29633	153	50	temperature	temperature	NN
29633	153	51	by	by	IN
29633	153	52	the	the	DT
29633	153	53	"	"	``
29633	153	54	deflation	deflation	NN
29633	153	55	of	of	IN
29633	153	56	the	the	DT
29633	153	57	iron	iron	NN
29633	153	58	itself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	153	59	"	"	''
29633	153	60	;	;	:
29633	153	61	and	and	CC
29633	153	62	for	for	IN
29633	153	63	discovering	discover	VBG
29633	153	64	that--	that--	NNP
29633	153	65	when	when	WRB
29633	153	66	the	the	DT
29633	153	67	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	153	68	has	have	VBZ
29633	153	69	been	be	VBN
29633	153	70	all	all	DT
29633	153	71	,	,	,
29633	153	72	or	or	CC
29633	153	73	nearly	nearly	RB
29633	153	74	all	all	DT
29633	153	75	,	,	,
29633	153	76	dissipated	dissipate	VBN
29633	153	77	,	,	,
29633	153	78	the	the	DT
29633	153	79	temperature	temperature	NN
29633	153	80	increases	increase	VBZ
29633	153	81	to	to	IN
29633	153	82	an	an	DT
29633	153	83	almost	almost	RB
29633	153	84	inconceivable	inconceivable	JJ
29633	153	85	extent	extent	NN
29633	153	86	,	,	,
29633	153	87	so	so	IN
29633	153	88	that	that	IN
29633	153	89	the	the	DT
29633	153	90	mass	mass	NN
29633	153	91	,	,	,
29633	153	92	when	when	WRB
29633	153	93	containing	contain	VBG
29633	153	94	only	only	RB
29633	153	95	as	as	IN
29633	153	96	much	much	JJ
29633	153	97	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	153	98	as	as	IN
29633	153	99	is	be	VBZ
29633	153	100	requisite	requisite	JJ
29633	153	101	to	to	TO
29633	153	102	constitute	constitute	VB
29633	153	103	with	with	IN
29633	153	104	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	153	105	cast	cast	VBD
29633	153	106	steel	steel	NN
29633	153	107	...	...	NFP
29633	153	108	still	still	RB
29633	153	109	retains	retain	VBZ
29633	153	110	a	a	DT
29633	153	111	perfect	perfect	JJ
29633	153	112	degree	degree	NN
29633	153	113	of	of	IN
29633	153	114	fluidity	fluidity	NN
29633	153	115	.	.	.
29633	154	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	154	2	25	25	CD
29633	154	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	154	4	_	_	NNP
29633	154	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	154	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	154	7	_	_	NNP
29633	154	8	,	,	,
29633	154	9	1857	1857	CD
29633	154	10	,	,	,
29633	154	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	154	12	.	.	.
29633	155	1	27	27	CD
29633	155	2	,	,	,
29633	155	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	155	4	723	723	CD
29633	155	5	.	.	.
29633	156	1	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	156	2	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	156	3	was	be	VBD
29633	156	4	a	a	DT
29633	156	5	constant	constant	JJ
29633	156	6	correspondent	correspondent	NN
29633	156	7	of	of	IN
29633	156	8	the	the	DT
29633	156	9	_	_	NNP
29633	156	10	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	156	11	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	156	12	_	_	NNP
29633	156	13	from	from	IN
29633	156	14	1848	1848	CD
29633	156	15	.	.	.
29633	157	1	The	the	DT
29633	157	2	adoption	adoption	NN
29633	157	3	of	of	IN
29633	157	4	a	a	DT
29633	157	5	pseudonym	pseudonym	JJ
29633	157	6	,	,	,
29633	157	7	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
29633	157	8	apparently	apparently	RB
29633	157	9	to	to	IN
29633	157	10	1857	1857	CD
29633	157	11	-	-	SYM
29633	157	12	1858	1858	CD
29633	157	13	(	(	-LRB-
29633	157	14	see	see	VB
29633	157	15	_	_	NNP
29633	157	16	Dictionary	Dictionary	NNP
29633	157	17	of	of	IN
29633	157	18	national	national	JJ
29633	157	19	biography	biography	NNP
29633	157	20	_	_	NNP
29633	157	21	,	,	,
29633	157	22	vol	vol	NNP
29633	157	23	.	.	.
29633	158	1	39	39	CD
29633	158	2	,	,	,
29633	158	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	158	4	429	429	CD
29633	158	5	)	)	-RRB-
29633	158	6	,	,	,
29633	158	7	enabled	enable	VBD
29633	158	8	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	158	9	to	to	TO
29633	158	10	carry	carry	VB
29633	158	11	on	on	RP
29633	158	12	two	two	CD
29633	158	13	debates	debate	NNS
29633	158	14	at	at	IN
29633	158	15	a	a	DT
29633	158	16	time	time	NN
29633	158	17	and	and	CC
29633	158	18	also	also	RB
29633	158	19	to	to	TO
29633	158	20	sing	sing	VB
29633	158	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	158	22	own	own	JJ
29633	158	23	praises	praise	NNS
29633	158	24	.	.	.
29633	159	1	This	this	DT
29633	159	2	,	,	,
29633	159	3	says	say	VBZ
29633	159	4	"	"	``
29633	159	5	Sideros	Sideros	NNP
29633	159	6	,	,	,
29633	159	7	"	"	''
29633	159	8	was	be	VBD
29633	159	9	no	no	DT
29633	159	10	new	new	JJ
29633	159	11	observation	observation	NN
29633	159	12	;	;	:
29633	159	13	"	"	``
29633	159	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	159	15	had	have	VBD
29633	159	16	been	be	VBN
29633	159	17	before	before	IN
29633	159	18	the	the	DT
29633	159	19	metallurgical	metallurgical	JJ
29633	159	20	world	world	NN
29633	159	21	,	,	,
29633	159	22	both	both	DT
29633	159	23	practical	practical	JJ
29633	159	24	and	and	CC
29633	159	25	scientific	scientific	JJ
29633	159	26	,	,	,
29633	159	27	for	for	IN
29633	159	28	centuries	century	NNS
29633	159	29	,	,	,
29633	159	30	"	"	''
29633	159	31	but	but	CC
29633	159	32	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	159	33	was	be	VBD
29633	159	34	the	the	DT
29633	159	35	first	first	JJ
29633	159	36	to	to	TO
29633	159	37	show	show	VB
29633	159	38	that	that	IN
29633	159	39	this	this	DT
29633	159	40	generation	generation	NN
29633	159	41	of	of	IN
29633	159	42	heat	heat	NN
29633	159	43	could	could	MD
29633	159	44	be	be	VB
29633	159	45	attained	attain	VBN
29633	159	46	by	by	IN
29633	159	47	blowing	blow	VBG
29633	159	48	cold	cold	JJ
29633	159	49	air	air	NN
29633	159	50	through	through	IN
29633	159	51	the	the	DT
29633	159	52	melted	melt	VBN
29633	159	53	iron	iron	NN
29633	159	54	.	.	.
29633	160	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	160	2	goes	go	VBZ
29633	160	3	on	on	RP
29633	160	4	to	to	TO
29633	160	5	show	show	VB
29633	160	6	,	,	,
29633	160	7	however	however	RB
29633	160	8	,	,	,
29633	160	9	that	that	IN
29633	160	10	the	the	DT
29633	160	11	steel	steel	NN
29633	160	12	thus	thus	RB
29633	160	13	produced	produce	VBN
29633	160	14	by	by	IN
29633	160	15	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	160	16	was	be	VBD
29633	160	17	not	not	RB
29633	160	18	commercially	commercially	RB
29633	160	19	valuable	valuable	JJ
29633	160	20	because	because	IN
29633	160	21	the	the	DT
29633	160	22	sulphur	sulphur	NN
29633	160	23	and	and	CC
29633	160	24	phosphorous	phosphorous	JJ
29633	160	25	remained	remain	VBD
29633	160	26	,	,	,
29633	160	27	and	and	CC
29633	160	28	the	the	DT
29633	160	29	dispersion	dispersion	NN
29633	160	30	of	of	IN
29633	160	31	oxide	oxide	NN
29633	160	32	of	of	IN
29633	160	33	iron	iron	NN
29633	160	34	through	through	IN
29633	160	35	the	the	DT
29633	160	36	mass	mass	NN
29633	160	37	"	"	``
29633	160	38	imported	import	VBN
29633	160	39	to	to	IN
29633	160	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	160	41	the	the	DT
29633	160	42	inveterate	inveterate	JJ
29633	160	43	hot	hot	JJ
29633	160	44	-	-	HYPH
29633	160	45	short	short	JJ
29633	160	46	quality	quality	NN
29633	160	47	which	which	WDT
29633	160	48	no	no	DT
29633	160	49	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
29633	160	50	operation	operation	NN
29633	160	51	could	could	MD
29633	160	52	expel	expel	VB
29633	160	53	.	.	.
29633	160	54	"	"	''
29633	161	1	"	"	``
29633	161	2	Sideros	Sideros	NNP
29633	161	3	"	"	''
29633	161	4	concludes	conclude	VBZ
29633	161	5	that	that	IN
29633	161	6	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	161	7	's	's	POS
29633	161	8	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	161	9	was	be	VBD
29633	161	10	"	"	``
29633	161	11	at	at	IN
29633	161	12	least	least	JJS
29633	161	13	for	for	IN
29633	161	14	a	a	DT
29633	161	15	time	time	NN
29633	161	16	"	"	``
29633	161	17	now	now	RB
29633	161	18	shelved	shelve	VBN
29633	161	19	and	and	CC
29633	161	20	arrested	arrest	VBN
29633	161	21	in	in	IN
29633	161	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	161	23	progress	progress	NN
29633	161	24	;	;	:
29633	161	25	and	and	CC
29633	161	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	161	27	had	have	VBD
29633	161	28	been	be	VBN
29633	161	29	left	leave	VBN
29633	161	30	"	"	''
29633	161	31	to	to	IN
29633	161	32	an	an	DT
29633	161	33	individual	individual	NN
29633	161	34	of	of	IN
29633	161	35	the	the	DT
29633	161	36	name	name	NN
29633	161	37	of	of	IN
29633	161	38	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	161	39	"	"	''
29633	161	40	to	to	TO
29633	161	41	show	show	VB
29633	161	42	that	that	IN
29633	161	43	if	if	IN
29633	161	44	"	"	``
29633	161	45	fluid	fluid	JJ
29633	161	46	metallic	metallic	JJ
29633	161	47	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	161	48	"	"	''
29633	161	49	were	be	VBD
29633	161	50	combined	combine	VBN
29633	161	51	with	with	IN
29633	161	52	the	the	DT
29633	161	53	fluid	fluid	JJ
29633	161	54	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	161	55	iron	iron	NN
29633	161	56	,	,	,
29633	161	57	the	the	DT
29633	161	58	portion	portion	NN
29633	161	59	of	of	IN
29633	161	60	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	161	61	thus	thus	RB
29633	161	62	alloyed	alloy	VBN
29633	161	63	would	would	MD
29633	161	64	unite	unite	VB
29633	161	65	with	with	IN
29633	161	66	the	the	DT
29633	161	67	oxygen	oxygen	NN
29633	161	68	of	of	IN
29633	161	69	the	the	DT
29633	161	70	oxide	oxide	NN
29633	161	71	and	and	CC
29633	161	72	pass	pass	VB
29633	161	73	off	off	RP
29633	161	74	as	as	IN
29633	161	75	slag	slag	NN
29633	161	76	,	,	,
29633	161	77	removing	remove	VBG
29633	161	78	the	the	DT
29633	161	79	hot	hot	JJ
29633	161	80	-	-	HYPH
29633	161	81	short	short	JJ
29633	161	82	quality	quality	NN
29633	161	83	of	of	IN
29633	161	84	the	the	DT
29633	161	85	iron	iron	NN
29633	161	86	.	.	.
29633	162	1	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	162	2	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	162	3	had	have	VBD
29633	162	4	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBN
29633	162	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	162	6	product	product	NN
29633	162	7	to	to	IN
29633	162	8	"	"	``
29633	162	9	Sideros	Sideros	NNP
29633	162	10	"	"	''
29633	162	11	and	and	CC
29633	162	12	had	have	VBD
29633	162	13	patented	patent	VBN
29633	162	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	162	15	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	162	16	,	,	,
29633	162	17	though	though	IN
29633	162	18	"	"	``
29633	162	19	not	not	RB
29633	162	20	one	one	CD
29633	162	21	print	print	NN
29633	162	22	,	,	,
29633	162	23	literary	literary	JJ
29633	162	24	or	or	CC
29633	162	25	scientific	scientific	JJ
29633	162	26	,	,	,
29633	162	27	had	have	VBD
29633	162	28	condescended	condescend	VBN
29633	162	29	to	to	TO
29633	162	30	notice	notice	VB
29633	162	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	162	32	.	.	.
29633	162	33	"	"	''
29633	163	1	"	"	``
29633	163	2	Sideros	Sideros	NNP
29633	163	3	"	"	''
29633	163	4	viewed	view	VBD
29633	163	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	163	6	's	's	POS
29633	163	7	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	163	8	as	as	IN
29633	163	9	a	a	DT
29633	163	10	"	"	``
29633	163	11	spark	spark	NN
29633	163	12	amongst	amongst	IN
29633	163	13	dry	dry	JJ
29633	163	14	faggots	faggot	NNS
29633	163	15	that	that	WDT
29633	163	16	will	will	MD
29633	163	17	one	one	CD
29633	163	18	day	day	NN
29633	163	19	light	light	VB
29633	163	20	up	up	RP
29633	163	21	a	a	DT
29633	163	22	blaze	blaze	NN
29633	163	23	which	which	WDT
29633	163	24	will	will	MD
29633	163	25	astonish	astonish	VB
29633	163	26	the	the	DT
29633	163	27	world	world	NN
29633	163	28	when	when	WRB
29633	163	29	the	the	DT
29633	163	30	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
29633	163	31	inventor	inventor	NN
29633	163	32	can	can	MD
29633	163	33	no	no	RB
29633	163	34	longer	longer	RB
29633	163	35	reap	reap	VB
29633	163	36	the	the	DT
29633	163	37	fruits	fruit	NNS
29633	163	38	of	of	IN
29633	163	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	163	40	life	life	NN
29633	163	41	-	-	HYPH
29633	163	42	long	long	JJ
29633	163	43	toil	toil	NN
29633	163	44	and	and	CC
29633	163	45	unflinching	unflinche	VBG
29633	163	46	perseverance	perseverance	NN
29633	163	47	.	.	.
29633	163	48	"	"	''
29633	164	1	In	in	IN
29633	164	2	an	an	DT
29633	164	3	ensuing	ensue	VBG
29633	164	4	letter	letter	NN
29633	164	5	he[26	he[26	NNP
29633	164	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	164	7	summed	sum	VBD
29633	164	8	up	up	RP
29633	164	9	the	the	DT
29633	164	10	situation	situation	NN
29633	164	11	as	as	IN
29633	164	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	164	13	saw	see	VBD
29633	164	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	164	15	:	:	:
29633	164	16	Nothing	nothing	NN
29633	164	17	that	that	IN
29633	164	18	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	164	19	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	164	20	can	can	MD
29633	164	21	hereafter	hereafter	RB
29633	164	22	invent	invent	NN
29633	164	23	can	can	MD
29633	164	24	entitle	entitle	VB
29633	164	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	164	26	to	to	IN
29633	164	27	the	the	DT
29633	164	28	merit	merit	NN
29633	164	29	of	of	IN
29633	164	30	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	164	31	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	164	32	's	's	POS
29633	164	33	great	great	JJ
29633	164	34	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	164	35	...	...	NFP
29633	164	36	and	and	CC
29633	164	37	...	...	:
29633	164	38	nothing	nothing	NN
29633	164	39	that	that	IN
29633	164	40	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	164	41	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	164	42	may	may	MD
29633	164	43	hereafter	hereafter	RB
29633	164	44	patent	patent	NN
29633	164	45	can	can	MD
29633	164	46	deprive	deprive	VB
29633	164	47	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	164	48	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	164	49	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	164	50	of	of	IN
29633	164	51	having	have	VBG
29633	164	52	been	be	VBN
29633	164	53	the	the	DT
29633	164	54	first	first	JJ
29633	164	55	to	to	TO
29633	164	56	remove	remove	VB
29633	164	57	the	the	DT
29633	164	58	obstacles	obstacle	NNS
29633	164	59	to	to	IN
29633	164	60	the	the	DT
29633	164	61	success	success	NN
29633	164	62	of	of	IN
29633	164	63	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	164	64	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	164	65	's	's	POS
29633	164	66	process	process	NN
29633	164	67	.	.	.
29633	165	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	165	2	26	26	CD
29633	165	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	165	4	_	_	NNP
29633	165	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	165	6	.	.	.
29633	165	7	_	_	NNP
29633	165	8	,	,	,
29633	165	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	165	10	823	823	CD
29633	165	11	.	.	.
29633	166	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	166	2	's	's	POS
29633	166	3	distinction	distinction	NN
29633	166	4	between	between	IN
29633	166	5	an	an	DT
29633	166	6	inventor	inventor	NN
29633	166	7	and	and	CC
29633	166	8	a	a	DT
29633	166	9	patentee	patentee	NN
29633	166	10	is	be	VBZ
29633	166	11	indicative	indicative	JJ
29633	166	12	of	of	IN
29633	166	13	the	the	DT
29633	166	14	disdain	disdain	NN
29633	166	15	of	of	IN
29633	166	16	a	a	DT
29633	166	17	son	son	NN
29633	166	18	of	of	IN
29633	166	19	David	David	NNP
29633	166	20	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	166	21	for	for	IN
29633	166	22	an	an	DT
29633	166	23	amateur	amateur	NN
29633	166	24	(	(	-LRB-
29633	166	25	see	see	VB
29633	166	26	also	also	RB
29633	166	27	p.	p.	NN
29633	166	28	886	886	CD
29633	166	29	)	)	-RRB-
29633	166	30	.	.	.
29633	167	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	167	2	still	still	RB
29633	167	3	did	do	VBD
29633	167	4	not	not	RB
29633	167	5	intervene	intervene	VB
29633	167	6	in	in	IN
29633	167	7	the	the	DT
29633	167	8	newspaper	newspaper	NN
29633	167	9	discussion	discussion	NN
29633	167	10	;	;	:
29633	167	11	nor	nor	CC
29633	167	12	had	have	VBD
29633	167	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	167	14	had	have	VBN
29633	167	15	any	any	DT
29633	167	16	serious	serious	JJ
29633	167	17	supporters	supporter	NNS
29633	167	18	,	,	,
29633	167	19	at	at	IN
29633	167	20	least	least	JJS
29633	167	21	in	in	IN
29633	167	22	the	the	DT
29633	167	23	early	early	JJ
29633	167	24	stage	stage	NN
29633	167	25	.	.	.
29633	168	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	168	2	27	27	CD
29633	168	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	168	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	168	5	27	27	CD
29633	168	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	168	7	One	one	CD
29633	168	8	William	William	NNP
29633	168	9	Green	Green	NNP
29633	168	10	had	have	VBD
29633	168	11	commented	comment	VBN
29633	168	12	extensively	extensively	RB
29633	168	13	on	on	IN
29633	168	14	David	David	NNP
29633	168	15	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	168	16	's	's	POS
29633	168	17	early	early	JJ
29633	168	18	praise	praise	NN
29633	168	19	of	of	IN
29633	168	20	the	the	DT
29633	168	21	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	168	22	process	process	NN
29633	168	23	and	and	CC
29633	168	24	on	on	IN
29633	168	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	168	26	sudden	sudden	JJ
29633	168	27	reversal	reversal	NN
29633	168	28	in	in	IN
29633	168	29	favor	favor	NN
29633	168	30	of	of	IN
29633	168	31	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	168	32	soon	soon	RB
29633	168	33	after	after	IN
29633	168	34	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	168	35	's	's	POS
29633	168	36	British	British	NNP
29633	168	37	Association	Association	NNP
29633	168	38	address	address	NN
29633	168	39	(	(	-LRB-
29633	168	40	_	_	NNP
29633	168	41	Mechanics	Mechanics	NNP
29633	168	42	'	'	POS
29633	168	43	Magazine	Magazine	NNP
29633	168	44	_	_	NNP
29633	168	45	,	,	,
29633	168	46	1856	1856	CD
29633	168	47	,	,	,
29633	168	48	vol	vol	NNP
29633	168	49	.	.	.
29633	169	1	65	65	CD
29633	169	2	,	,	,
29633	169	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	169	4	373	373	CD
29633	169	5	ff	ff	NNP
29633	169	6	.	.	.
29633	169	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	169	8	.	.	.
29633	170	1	Green	Green	NNP
29633	170	2	wrote	write	VBD
29633	170	3	from	from	IN
29633	170	4	Caledonian	Caledonian	NNP
29633	170	5	Road	Road	NNP
29633	170	6	,	,	,
29633	170	7	and	and	CC
29633	170	8	the	the	DT
29633	170	9	proximity	proximity	NN
29633	170	10	to	to	IN
29633	170	11	Baxter	Baxter	NNP
29633	170	12	House	House	NNP
29633	170	13	,	,	,
29633	170	14	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	170	15	's	's	POS
29633	170	16	London	London	NNP
29633	170	17	headquarters	headquarters	NN
29633	170	18	,	,	,
29633	170	19	suggests	suggest	VBZ
29633	170	20	the	the	DT
29633	170	21	possibility	possibility	NN
29633	170	22	that	that	IN
29633	170	23	Green	Green	NNP
29633	170	24	was	be	VBD
29633	170	25	writing	write	VBG
29633	170	26	for	for	IN
29633	170	27	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	170	28	.	.	.
29633	171	1	Publication	publication	NN
29633	171	2	in	in	IN
29633	171	3	the	the	DT
29633	171	4	_	_	NNP
29633	171	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	171	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	171	7	_	_	NNP
29633	171	8	of	of	IN
29633	171	9	a	a	DT
29633	171	10	list	list	NN
29633	171	11	of	of	IN
29633	171	12	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	171	13	's	's	POS
29633	171	14	patents,[28	patents,[28	NN
29633	171	15	]	]	-RRB-
29633	171	16	evidently	evidently	RB
29633	171	17	in	in	IN
29633	171	18	response	response	NN
29633	171	19	to	to	IN
29633	171	20	Sideros	Sideros	NNP
29633	171	21	'	'	POS
29633	171	22	complaint	complaint	NN
29633	171	23	,	,	,
29633	171	24	now	now	RB
29633	171	25	presented	present	VBD
29633	171	26	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	171	27	with	with	IN
29633	171	28	notice	notice	NN
29633	171	29	of	of	IN
29633	171	30	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	171	31	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	171	32	's	's	POS
29633	171	33	activity	activity	NN
29633	171	34	,	,	,
29633	171	35	even	even	RB
29633	171	36	if	if	IN
29633	171	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	171	38	had	have	VBD
29633	171	39	not	not	RB
29633	171	40	already	already	RB
29633	171	41	observed	observe	VBN
29633	171	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	171	43	claims	claim	NNS
29633	171	44	as	as	IN
29633	171	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	171	46	were	be	VBD
29633	171	47	presented	present	VBN
29633	171	48	to	to	IN
29633	171	49	the	the	DT
29633	171	50	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	171	51	Office	Office	NNP
29633	171	52	.	.	.
29633	172	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	172	2	,	,	,
29633	172	3	said	say	VBD
29633	172	4	the	the	DT
29633	172	5	_	_	NNP
29633	172	6	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	172	7	Journal_--	Journal_--	NNP
29633	172	8	appears	appear	VBZ
29633	172	9	to	to	TO
29633	172	10	intend	intend	VB
29633	172	11	to	to	TO
29633	172	12	carry	carry	VB
29633	172	13	on	on	RP
29633	172	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	172	15	researches	research	NNS
29633	172	16	from	from	IN
29633	172	17	the	the	DT
29633	172	18	point	point	NN
29633	172	19	where	where	WRB
29633	172	20	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	172	21	J.	J.	NNP
29633	172	22	G.	G.	NNP
29633	172	23	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	172	24	left	leave	VBD
29633	172	25	off	off	RP
29633	172	26	and	and	CC
29633	172	27	is	be	VBZ
29633	172	28	proceeding	proceed	VBG
29633	172	29	on	on	IN
29633	172	30	the	the	DT
29633	172	31	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	172	32	plan	plan	NN
29633	172	33	of	of	IN
29633	172	34	patenting	patent	VBG
29633	172	35	each	each	DT
29633	172	36	idea	idea	NN
29633	172	37	as	as	IN
29633	172	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	172	39	occurs	occur	VBZ
29633	172	40	to	to	IN
29633	172	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	172	42	imaginative	imaginative	JJ
29633	172	43	brain	brain	NN
29633	172	44	.	.	.
29633	173	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	173	2	proposes	propose	VBZ
29633	173	3	to	to	TO
29633	173	4	make	make	VB
29633	173	5	both	both	DT
29633	173	6	iron	iron	NN
29633	173	7	and	and	CC
29633	173	8	steel	steel	NN
29633	173	9	but	but	CC
29633	173	10	does	do	VBZ
29633	173	11	not	not	RB
29633	173	12	appear	appear	VB
29633	173	13	to	to	TO
29633	173	14	have	have	VB
29633	173	15	quite	quite	RB
29633	173	16	decided	decide	VBN
29633	173	17	as	as	IN
29633	173	18	to	to	IN
29633	173	19	the	the	DT
29633	173	20	course	course	NN
29633	173	21	of	of	IN
29633	173	22	action	action	NN
29633	173	23	...	...	:
29633	173	24	to	to	TO
29633	173	25	accomplish	accomplish	VB
29633	173	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	173	27	object	object	NN
29633	173	28	,	,	,
29633	173	29	and	and	CC
29633	173	30	therefore	therefore	RB
29633	173	31	claims	claim	VBZ
29633	173	32	various	various	JJ
29633	173	33	processes	process	NNS
29633	173	34	,	,	,
29633	173	35	some	some	DT
29633	173	36	of	of	IN
29633	173	37	which	which	WDT
29633	173	38	are	be	VBP
29633	173	39	never	never	RB
29633	173	40	likely	likely	JJ
29633	173	41	to	to	TO
29633	173	42	realize	realize	VB
29633	173	43	the	the	DT
29633	173	44	inventor	inventor	NN
29633	173	45	's	's	POS
29633	173	46	expectations	expectation	NNS
29633	173	47	,	,	,
29633	173	48	although	although	IN
29633	173	49	decidedly	decidedly	RB
29633	173	50	novel	novel	JJ
29633	173	51	,	,	,
29633	173	52	whilst	whilst	IN
29633	173	53	others	other	NNS
29633	173	54	are	be	VBP
29633	173	55	but	but	CC
29633	173	56	slight	slight	JJ
29633	173	57	modification	modification	NN
29633	173	58	of	of	IN
29633	173	59	inventions	invention	NNS
29633	173	60	which	which	WDT
29633	173	61	have	have	VBP
29633	173	62	already	already	RB
29633	173	63	been	be	VBN
29633	173	64	tried	try	VBN
29633	173	65	and	and	CC
29633	173	66	failed	fail	VBN
29633	173	67	.	.	.
29633	174	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	174	2	28	28	CD
29633	174	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	174	4	_	_	NNP
29633	174	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	174	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	174	7	_	_	NNP
29633	174	8	,	,	,
29633	174	9	1857	1857	CD
29633	174	10	,	,	,
29633	174	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	174	12	.	.	.
29633	175	1	27	27	CD
29633	175	2	,	,	,
29633	175	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	175	4	764	764	CD
29633	175	5	.	.	.
29633	176	1	The	the	DT
29633	176	2	contemporary	contemporary	JJ
29633	176	3	attitude	attitude	NN
29633	176	4	is	be	VBZ
29633	176	5	reflected	reflect	VBN
29633	176	6	in	in	IN
29633	176	7	another	another	DT
29633	176	8	comment	comment	NN
29633	176	9	by	by	IN
29633	176	10	the	the	DT
29633	176	11	_	_	NNP
29633	176	12	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	176	13	Journal_:[29	Journal_:[29	NNP
29633	176	14	]	]	-RRB-
29633	176	15	Although	although	IN
29633	176	16	the	the	DT
29633	176	17	application	application	NN
29633	176	18	of	of	IN
29633	176	19	chemical	chemical	JJ
29633	176	20	knowledge	knowledge	NN
29633	176	21	to	to	IN
29633	176	22	the	the	DT
29633	176	23	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	176	24	of	of	IN
29633	176	25	malleable	malleable	JJ
29633	176	26	iron	iron	NN
29633	176	27	can	can	MD
29633	176	28	not	not	RB
29633	176	29	fail	fail	VB
29633	176	30	to	to	TO
29633	176	31	produce	produce	VB
29633	176	32	beneficial	beneficial	JJ
29633	176	33	results	result	NNS
29633	176	34	,	,	,
29633	176	35	the	the	DT
29633	176	36	quality	quality	NN
29633	176	37	of	of	IN
29633	176	38	the	the	DT
29633	176	39	metal	metal	NN
29633	176	40	depends	depend	VBZ
29633	176	41	more	more	JJR
29633	176	42	upon	upon	IN
29633	176	43	the	the	DT
29633	176	44	mechanical	mechanical	JJ
29633	176	45	than	than	IN
29633	176	46	the	the	DT
29633	176	47	chemical	chemical	NN
29633	176	48	processes	process	NNS
29633	176	49	....	....	.
29633	177	1	Without	without	IN
29633	177	2	wishing	wish	VBG
29633	177	3	in	in	IN
29633	177	4	any	any	DT
29633	177	5	way	way	NN
29633	177	6	to	to	TO
29633	177	7	discourage	discourage	VB
29633	177	8	the	the	DT
29633	177	9	iron	iron	NN
29633	177	10	chemists	chemist	NNS
29633	177	11	,	,	,
29633	177	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
29633	177	13	have	have	VBP
29633	177	14	no	no	DT
29633	177	15	hesitation	hesitation	NN
29633	177	16	in	in	IN
29633	177	17	giving	give	VBG
29633	177	18	this	this	DT
29633	177	19	as	as	IN
29633	177	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	177	21	opinion	opinion	NN
29633	177	22	which	which	WDT
29633	177	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
29633	177	24	shall	shall	MD
29633	177	25	maintain	maintain	VB
29633	177	26	until	until	IN
29633	177	27	the	the	DT
29633	177	28	contrary	contrary	NN
29633	177	29	be	be	VB
29633	177	30	actually	actually	RB
29633	177	31	proved	prove	VBN
29633	177	32	.	.	.
29633	178	1	With	with	IN
29633	178	2	regard	regard	NN
29633	178	3	to	to	IN
29633	178	4	steel	steel	NN
29633	178	5	,	,	,
29633	178	6	there	there	EX
29633	178	7	may	may	MD
29633	178	8	be	be	VB
29633	178	9	a	a	DT
29633	178	10	large	large	JJ
29633	178	11	field	field	NN
29633	178	12	for	for	IN
29633	178	13	chemical	chemical	NN
29633	178	14	research	research	NN
29633	178	15	...	...	NFP
29633	178	16	however	however	RB
29633	178	17	,	,	,
29633	178	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
29633	178	19	believe	believe	VBP
29633	178	20	that	that	IN
29633	178	21	unless	unless	IN
29633	178	22	the	the	DT
29633	178	23	iron	iron	NN
29633	178	24	be	be	VBP
29633	178	25	of	of	IN
29633	178	26	a	a	DT
29633	178	27	nature	nature	NN
29633	178	28	adapted	adapt	VBN
29633	178	29	for	for	IN
29633	178	30	the	the	DT
29633	178	31	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	178	32	of	of	IN
29633	178	33	steel	steel	NN
29633	178	34	by	by	IN
29633	178	35	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
29633	178	36	processes	process	NNS
29633	178	37	,	,	,
29633	178	38	the	the	DT
29633	178	39	purely	purely	RB
29633	178	40	chemical	chemical	JJ
29633	178	41	inventions	invention	NNS
29633	178	42	will	will	MD
29633	178	43	only	only	RB
29633	178	44	give	give	VB
29633	178	45	a	a	DT
29633	178	46	metal	metal	NN
29633	178	47	of	of	IN
29633	178	48	a	a	DT
29633	178	49	very	very	RB
29633	178	50	uniform	uniform	JJ
29633	178	51	quality	quality	NN
29633	178	52	.	.	.
29633	179	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	179	2	29	29	CD
29633	179	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	179	4	_	_	NNP
29633	179	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	179	6	.	.	.
29633	179	7	_	_	NNP
29633	179	8	,	,	,
29633	179	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	179	10	764	764	CD
29633	179	11	.	.	.
29633	180	1	Another	another	DT
29633	180	2	correspondent	correspondent	NN
29633	180	3	,	,	,
29633	180	4	William	William	NNP
29633	180	5	Green	Green	NNP
29633	180	6	,	,	,
29633	180	7	was	be	VBD
29633	180	8	of	of	IN
29633	180	9	the	the	DT
29633	180	10	opinion	opinion	NN
29633	180	11	that	that	IN
29633	180	12	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	180	13	's	's	POS
29633	180	14	"	"	``
29633	180	15	new	new	JJ
29633	180	16	compounds	compound	NNS
29633	180	17	and	and	CC
29633	180	18	alloys	alloy	NNS
29633	180	19	,	,	,
29633	180	20	"	"	''
29633	180	21	promised	promise	VBD
29633	180	22	well	well	RB
29633	180	23	as	as	IN
29633	180	24	an	an	DT
29633	180	25	auxiliary	auxiliary	NN
29633	180	26	to	to	IN
29633	180	27	the	the	DT
29633	180	28	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	180	29	process	process	NN
29633	180	30	but	but	CC
29633	180	31	that	that	IN
29633	180	32	"	"	``
29633	180	33	the	the	DT
29633	180	34	evil	evil	NN
29633	180	35	which	which	WDT
29633	180	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	180	37	was	be	VBD
29633	180	38	intended	intend	VBN
29633	180	39	to	to	TO
29633	180	40	remove	remove	VB
29633	180	41	was	be	VBD
29633	180	42	more	more	RBR
29633	180	43	visionary	visionary	JJ
29633	180	44	than	than	IN
29633	180	45	real	real	JJ
29633	180	46	.	.	.
29633	180	47	"	"	''
29633	181	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	181	2	's	's	POS
29633	181	3	chief	chief	JJ
29633	181	4	difficulty	difficulty	NN
29633	181	5	was	be	VBD
29633	181	6	the	the	DT
29633	181	7	phosphorus	phosphorus	NN
29633	181	8	,	,	,
29633	181	9	not	not	RB
29633	181	10	the	the	DT
29633	181	11	oxide	oxide	NN
29633	181	12	of	of	IN
29633	181	13	iron	iron	NN
29633	181	14	"	"	''
29633	181	15	as	as	IN
29633	181	16	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	181	17	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	181	18	assumes	assume	VBZ
29633	181	19	.	.	.
29633	181	20	"	"	''
29633	182	1	This	this	DT
29633	182	2	,	,	,
29633	182	3	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	182	4	no	no	DT
29633	182	5	doubt	doubt	NN
29633	182	6	would	would	MD
29633	182	7	deal	deal	VB
29633	182	8	with	with	IN
29633	182	9	in	in	IN
29633	182	10	due	due	JJ
29633	182	11	course	course	NN
29633	182	12	,	,	,
29633	182	13	but	but	CC
29633	182	14	meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
29633	182	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	182	16	did	do	VBD
29633	182	17	well	well	RB
29633	182	18	"	"	''
29633	182	19	to	to	TO
29633	182	20	concentrate	concentrate	VB
29633	182	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	182	22	energies	energy	NNS
29633	182	23	upon	upon	IN
29633	182	24	the	the	DT
29633	182	25	steel	steel	NN
29633	182	26	operations	operation	NNS
29633	182	27	,	,	,
29633	182	28	"	"	''
29633	182	29	after	after	IN
29633	182	30	which	which	WDT
29633	182	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	182	32	would	would	MD
29633	182	33	have	have	VB
29633	182	34	time	time	NN
29633	182	35	to	to	TO
29633	182	36	tackle	tackle	VB
29633	182	37	"	"	``
29633	182	38	the	the	DT
29633	182	39	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
29633	182	40	which	which	WDT
29633	182	41	have	have	VBP
29633	182	42	so	so	RB
29633	182	43	far	far	RB
29633	182	44	retarded	retard	VBN
29633	182	45	the	the	DT
29633	182	46	iron	iron	NN
29633	182	47	operations	operation	NNS
29633	182	48	.	.	.
29633	183	1	"	"	``
29633	183	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	183	3	30	30	CD
29633	183	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	183	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	183	6	30	30	CD
29633	183	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	183	8	_	_	NNP
29633	183	9	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	183	10	.	.	.
29633	183	11	_	_	NNP
29633	183	12	,	,	,
29633	183	13	p.	p.	NN
29633	183	14	791	791	CD
29633	183	15	.	.	.
29633	184	1	Mushet[31	mushet[31	ADD
29633	184	2	]	]	-RRB-
29633	184	3	claims	claim	VBZ
29633	184	4	to	to	TO
29633	184	5	have	have	VB
29633	184	6	taken	take	VBN
29633	184	7	out	out	RP
29633	184	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	184	9	patent	patent	NN
29633	184	10	of	of	IN
29633	184	11	September	September	NNP
29633	184	12	22	22	CD
29633	184	13	,	,	,
29633	184	14	1856	1856	CD
29633	184	15	,	,	,
29633	184	16	covering	cover	VBG
29633	184	17	the	the	DT
29633	184	18	famous	famous	JJ
29633	184	19	"	"	``
29633	184	20	triple	triple	JJ
29633	184	21	compound	compound	NN
29633	184	22	,	,	,
29633	184	23	"	"	''
29633	184	24	after	after	IN
29633	184	25	he--	he--	NNP
29633	184	26	had	have	VBD
29633	184	27	fully	fully	RB
29633	184	28	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
29633	184	29	,	,	,
29633	184	30	upon	upon	IN
29633	184	31	the	the	DT
29633	184	32	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
29633	184	33	scale	scale	NN
29633	184	34	of	of	IN
29633	184	35	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	184	36	that	that	IN
29633	184	37	air	air	NN
29633	184	38	-	-	HYPH
29633	184	39	purified	purify	VBN
29633	184	40	cast	cast	NN
29633	184	41	-	-	HYPH
29633	184	42	iron	iron	NN
29633	184	43	,	,	,
29633	184	44	when	when	WRB
29633	184	45	treated	treat	VBN
29633	184	46	as	as	IN
29633	184	47	set	set	VBN
29633	184	48	forth	forth	RP
29633	184	49	in	in	IN
29633	184	50	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	184	51	specifications	specification	NNS
29633	184	52	,	,	,
29633	184	53	would	would	MD
29633	184	54	afford	afford	VB
29633	184	55	tough	tough	JJ
29633	184	56	malleable	malleable	JJ
29633	184	57	iron	iron	NN
29633	184	58	...	...	.
29633	185	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	185	2	found	find	VBD
29633	185	3	,	,	,
29633	185	4	however	however	RB
29633	185	5	,	,	,
29633	185	6	that	that	IN
29633	185	7	the	the	DT
29633	185	8	remelting	remelting	NN
29633	185	9	of	of	IN
29633	185	10	the	the	DT
29633	185	11	coke	coke	NNP
29633	185	12	pig	pig	NN
29633	185	13	-	-	HYPH
29633	185	14	iron	iron	NN
29633	185	15	,	,	,
29633	185	16	in	in	IN
29633	185	17	contact	contact	NN
29633	185	18	with	with	IN
29633	185	19	coke	coke	NN
29633	185	20	fuel	fuel	NN
29633	185	21	,	,	,
29633	185	22	hardened	harden	VBD
29633	185	23	the	the	DT
29633	185	24	iron	iron	NN
29633	185	25	too	too	RB
29633	185	26	much	much	RB
29633	185	27	,	,	,
29633	185	28	and	and	CC
29633	185	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	185	30	became	become	VBD
29633	185	31	evident	evident	JJ
29633	185	32	that	that	IN
29633	185	33	an	an	DT
29633	185	34	air	air	NN
29633	185	35	-	-	HYPH
29633	185	36	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	185	37	was	be	VBD
29633	185	38	more	more	RBR
29633	185	39	proper	proper	JJ
29633	185	40	for	for	IN
29633	185	41	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	185	42	purpose	purpose	NN
29633	185	43	...	...	NFP
29633	185	44	[	[	-LRB-
29633	185	45	the	the	DT
29633	185	46	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
29633	185	47	]	]	-RRB-
29633	185	48	arose	arise	VBD
29633	185	49	,	,	,
29633	185	50	not	not	RB
29633	185	51	from	from	IN
29633	185	52	any	any	DT
29633	185	53	defect	defect	NN
29633	185	54	in	in	IN
29633	185	55	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	185	56	process	process	NN
29633	185	57	,	,	,
29633	185	58	but	but	CC
29633	185	59	were	be	VBD
29633	185	60	owing	owe	VBG
29633	185	61	to	to	IN
29633	185	62	the	the	DT
29633	185	63	small	small	JJ
29633	185	64	quantity	quantity	NN
29633	185	65	of	of	IN
29633	185	66	the	the	DT
29633	185	67	metal	metal	NN
29633	185	68	operated	operate	VBN
29633	185	69	upon	upon	IN
29633	185	70	and	and	CC
29633	185	71	the	the	DT
29633	185	72	imperfect	imperfect	JJ
29633	185	73	arrangement	arrangement	NN
29633	185	74	of	of	IN
29633	185	75	the	the	DT
29633	185	76	purifying	purifying	NN
29633	185	77	vessel	vessel	NN
29633	185	78	,	,	,
29633	185	79	which	which	WDT
29633	185	80	ought	ought	MD
29633	185	81	to	to	TO
29633	185	82	be	be	VB
29633	185	83	so	so	RB
29633	185	84	constituted	constituted	JJ
29633	185	85	that	that	IN
29633	185	86	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	185	87	may	may	MD
29633	185	88	be	be	VB
29633	185	89	turned	turn	VBN
29633	185	90	upon	upon	RP
29633	185	91	an	an	DT
29633	185	92	axis	axis	NN
29633	185	93	,	,	,
29633	185	94	the	the	DT
29633	185	95	blast	blast	NN
29633	185	96	taken	take	VBN
29633	185	97	off	off	RP
29633	185	98	,	,	,
29633	185	99	the	the	DT
29633	185	100	alloy	alloy	NN
29633	185	101	added	add	VBD
29633	185	102	and	and	CC
29633	185	103	the	the	DT
29633	185	104	steel	steel	NN
29633	185	105	poured	pour	VBD
29633	185	106	out	out	RP
29633	185	107	through	through	IN
29633	185	108	a	a	DT
29633	185	109	spout	spout	NN
29633	185	110	...	...	:
29633	185	111	_	_	XX
29633	185	112	Such	such	PDT
29633	185	113	a	a	DT
29633	185	114	purifying	purifying	NN
29633	185	115	vessel	vessel	NN
29633	185	116	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	185	117	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	185	118	has	have	VBZ
29633	185	119	delineated	delineate	VBN
29633	185	120	in	in	IN
29633	185	121	one	one	CD
29633	185	122	of	of	IN
29633	185	123	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	185	124	patents	patent	NNS
29633	185	125	.	.	.
29633	185	126	_	_	NNP
29633	185	127	[	[	-LRB-
29633	185	128	31	31	CD
29633	185	129	]	]	-RRB-
29633	185	130	_	_	NNP
29633	185	131	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	185	132	.	.	.
29633	185	133	_	_	NNP
29633	185	134	,	,	,
29633	185	135	p.	p.	NN
29633	185	136	770	770	CD
29633	185	137	(	(	-LRB-
29633	185	138	italics	italic	NNS
29633	185	139	supplied	supply	VBN
29633	185	140	)	)	-RRB-
29633	185	141	.	.	.
29633	186	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	186	2	also	also	RB
29633	186	3	claimed	claim	VBD
29633	186	4	to	to	TO
29633	186	5	have	have	VB
29633	186	6	designed	design	VBN
29633	186	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	186	8	own	own	JJ
29633	186	9	"	"	``
29633	186	10	purifying	purifying	NN
29633	186	11	and	and	CC
29633	186	12	mixing	mix	VBG
29633	186	13	"	"	``
29633	186	14	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	186	15	,	,	,
29633	186	16	of	of	IN
29633	186	17	20-ton	20-ton	CD
29633	186	18	capacity	capacity	NN
29633	186	19	,	,	,
29633	186	20	which	which	WDT
29633	186	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	186	22	had	have	VBD
29633	186	23	submitted	submit	VBN
29633	186	24	to	to	IN
29633	186	25	the	the	DT
29633	186	26	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	186	27	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	186	28	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	186	29	Works	Works	NNP
29633	186	30	"	"	''
29633	186	31	many	many	JJ
29633	186	32	months	month	NNS
29633	186	33	ago	ago	RB
29633	186	34	,	,	,
29633	186	35	"	"	''
29633	186	36	without	without	IN
29633	186	37	comment	comment	NN
29633	186	38	from	from	IN
29633	186	39	them	-PRON-	PRP
29633	186	40	.	.	.
29633	187	1	There	there	EX
29633	187	2	is	be	VBZ
29633	187	3	an	an	DT
29633	187	4	intriguing	intriguing	JJ
29633	187	5	reference	reference	NN
29633	187	6	to	to	IN
29633	187	7	the	the	DT
29633	187	8	painful	painful	JJ
29633	187	9	subject	subject	NN
29633	187	10	of	of	IN
29633	187	11	two	two	CD
29633	187	12	patents	patent	NNS
29633	187	13	not	not	RB
29633	187	14	proceeded	proceed	VBN
29633	187	15	with	with	IN
29633	187	16	,	,	,
29633	187	17	and	and	CC
29633	187	18	not	not	RB
29633	187	19	discussed	discuss	VBN
29633	187	20	"	"	''
29633	187	21	in	in	IN
29633	187	22	the	the	DT
29633	187	23	avaricious	avaricious	JJ
29633	187	24	hope	hope	NN
29633	187	25	that	that	IN
29633	187	26	the	the	DT
29633	187	27	parties	party	NNS
29633	187	28	connected	connect	VBN
29633	187	29	with	with	IN
29633	187	30	the	the	DT
29633	187	31	patents	patent	NNS
29633	187	32	will	will	MD
29633	187	33	make	make	VB
29633	187	34	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	187	35	honorable	honorable	JJ
29633	187	36	amends	amend	NNS
29633	187	37	...	...	NFP
29633	187	38	these	these	DT
29633	187	39	patents	patent	NNS
29633	187	40	were	be	VBD
29633	187	41	suppressed	suppress	VBN
29633	187	42	without	without	IN
29633	187	43	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	187	44	knowledge	knowledge	NN
29633	187	45	or	or	CC
29633	187	46	consent	consent	NN
29633	187	47	.	.	.
29633	187	48	"	"	''
29633	188	1	Lest	lest	IN
29633	188	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	188	3	qualifications	qualification	NNS
29633	188	4	should	should	MD
29633	188	5	be	be	VB
29633	188	6	questioned	question	VBN
29633	188	7	,	,	,
29633	188	8	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	188	9	concludes	conclude	VBZ
29633	188	10	:	:	:
29633	188	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	188	12	do	do	VBP
29633	188	13	not	not	RB
29633	188	14	profess	profess	VB
29633	188	15	to	to	TO
29633	188	16	be	be	VB
29633	188	17	an	an	DT
29633	188	18	iron	iron	NN
29633	188	19	chemist	chemist	NN
29633	188	20	,	,	,
29633	188	21	but	but	CC
29633	188	22	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	188	23	have	have	VBP
29633	188	24	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
29633	188	25	made	make	VBN
29633	188	26	more	more	JJR
29633	188	27	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	188	28	upon	upon	IN
29633	188	29	the	the	DT
29633	188	30	subject	subject	NN
29633	188	31	of	of	IN
29633	188	32	iron	iron	NN
29633	188	33	and	and	CC
29633	188	34	steel	steel	NN
29633	188	35	than	than	IN
29633	188	36	any	any	DT
29633	188	37	man	man	NN
29633	188	38	now	now	RB
29633	188	39	living	live	VBG
29633	188	40	and	and	CC
29633	188	41	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	188	42	am	be	VBP
29633	188	43	thereby	thereby	RB
29633	188	44	enabled	enable	VBN
29633	188	45	to	to	TO
29633	188	46	say	say	VB
29633	188	47	that	that	IN
29633	188	48	all	all	DT
29633	188	49	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	188	50	know	know	VBP
29633	188	51	is	be	VBZ
29633	188	52	but	but	CC
29633	188	53	little	little	JJ
29633	188	54	in	in	IN
29633	188	55	comparison	comparison	NN
29633	188	56	with	with	IN
29633	188	57	what	what	WP
29633	188	58	has	have	VBZ
29633	188	59	yet	yet	RB
29633	188	60	to	to	TO
29633	188	61	be	be	VB
29633	188	62	discovered	discover	VBN
29633	188	63	.	.	.
29633	189	1	So	so	CC
29633	189	2	began	begin	VBD
29633	189	3	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	189	4	's	's	POS
29633	189	5	claim	claim	NN
29633	189	6	to	to	TO
29633	189	7	have	have	VB
29633	189	8	solved	solve	VBN
29633	189	9	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	189	10	's	's	POS
29633	189	11	problem	problem	NN
29633	189	12	,	,	,
29633	189	13	a	a	DT
29633	189	14	claim	claim	NN
29633	189	15	which	which	WDT
29633	189	16	was	be	VBD
29633	189	17	to	to	TO
29633	189	18	fill	fill	VB
29633	189	19	the	the	DT
29633	189	20	correspondence	correspondence	NN
29633	189	21	columns	column	NNS
29633	189	22	of	of	IN
29633	189	23	the	the	DT
29633	189	24	engineering	engineering	NN
29633	189	25	journals	journal	NNS
29633	189	26	for	for	IN
29633	189	27	the	the	DT
29633	189	28	next	next	JJ
29633	189	29	ten	ten	CD
29633	189	30	years	year	NNS
29633	189	31	.	.	.
29633	190	1	Interpretation	interpretation	NN
29633	190	2	of	of	IN
29633	190	3	this	this	DT
29633	190	4	correspondence	correspondence	NN
29633	190	5	is	be	VBZ
29633	190	6	made	make	VBN
29633	190	7	difficult	difficult	JJ
29633	190	8	by	by	IN
29633	190	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	190	10	ignorance	ignorance	NN
29633	190	11	of	of	IN
29633	190	12	the	the	DT
29633	190	13	facts	fact	NNS
29633	190	14	concerning	concern	VBG
29633	190	15	the	the	DT
29633	190	16	control	control	NN
29633	190	17	of	of	IN
29633	190	18	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	190	19	's	's	POS
29633	190	20	patents	patent	NNS
29633	190	21	.	.	.
29633	191	1	These	these	DT
29633	191	2	have	have	VBP
29633	191	3	to	to	TO
29633	191	4	be	be	VB
29633	191	5	pieced	piece	VBN
29633	191	6	together	together	RB
29633	191	7	from	from	IN
29633	191	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	191	9	scattered	scatter	VBN
29633	191	10	references	reference	NNS
29633	191	11	to	to	IN
29633	191	12	the	the	DT
29633	191	13	subject	subject	NN
29633	191	14	.	.	.
29633	192	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	192	2	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	192	3	were	be	VBD
29633	192	4	conducted	conduct	VBN
29633	192	5	,	,	,
29633	192	6	at	at	IN
29633	192	7	least	least	JJS
29633	192	8	nearly	nearly	RB
29633	192	9	up	up	IN
29633	192	10	to	to	IN
29633	192	11	the	the	DT
29633	192	12	close	close	NN
29633	192	13	of	of	IN
29633	192	14	the	the	DT
29633	192	15	year	year	NN
29633	192	16	1856	1856	CD
29633	192	17	,	,	,
29633	192	18	with	with	IN
29633	192	19	the	the	DT
29633	192	20	cooperation	cooperation	NN
29633	192	21	of	of	IN
29633	192	22	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
29633	192	23	Brown	Brown	NNP
29633	192	24	of	of	IN
29633	192	25	the	the	DT
29633	192	26	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	192	27	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	192	28	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	192	29	Works	Works	NNP
29633	192	30	.	.	.
29633	193	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	193	2	32	32	CD
29633	193	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	193	4	The	the	DT
29633	193	5	price	price	NN
29633	193	6	of	of	IN
29633	193	7	this	this	DT
29633	193	8	assistance	assistance	NN
29633	193	9	was	be	VBD
29633	193	10	apparently	apparently	RB
29633	193	11	half	half	JJ
29633	193	12	interest	interest	NN
29633	193	13	in	in	IN
29633	193	14	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	193	15	's	's	POS
29633	193	16	patents	patent	NNS
29633	193	17	,	,	,
29633	193	18	though	though	IN
29633	193	19	for	for	IN
29633	193	20	reasons	reason	NNS
29633	193	21	which	which	WDT
29633	193	22	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	193	23	does	do	VBZ
29633	193	24	not	not	RB
29633	193	25	explain	explain	VB
29633	193	26	the	the	DT
29633	193	27	deed	deed	NN
29633	193	28	prepared	prepare	VBD
29633	193	29	to	to	TO
29633	193	30	effect	effect	VB
29633	193	31	the	the	DT
29633	193	32	transfer	transfer	NN
29633	193	33	was	be	VBD
29633	193	34	never	never	RB
29633	193	35	executed	execute	VBN
29633	193	36	.	.	.
29633	194	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	194	2	33	33	CD
29633	194	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	194	4	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	194	5	continued	continue	VBD
29633	194	6	,	,	,
29633	194	7	however	however	RB
29633	194	8	,	,	,
29633	194	9	to	to	TO
29633	194	10	regard	regard	VB
29633	194	11	the	the	DT
29633	194	12	patents	patent	NNS
29633	194	13	as	as	IN
29633	194	14	"	"	``
29633	194	15	wholly	wholly	RB
29633	194	16	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	194	17	own	own	JJ
29633	194	18	,	,	,
29633	194	19	though	though	IN
29633	194	20	at	at	IN
29633	194	21	the	the	DT
29633	194	22	same	same	JJ
29633	194	23	time	time	NN
29633	194	24	,	,	,
29633	194	25	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	194	26	am	be	VBP
29633	194	27	bound	bind	VBN
29633	194	28	in	in	IN
29633	194	29	honor	honor	NN
29633	194	30	to	to	TO
29633	194	31	take	take	VB
29633	194	32	no	no	DT
29633	194	33	unfair	unfair	JJ
29633	194	34	advantage	advantage	NN
29633	194	35	of	of	IN
29633	194	36	the	the	DT
29633	194	37	non	non	JJ
29633	194	38	-	-	NN
29633	194	39	execution	execution	NN
29633	194	40	of	of	IN
29633	194	41	that	that	DT
29633	194	42	deed	deed	NN
29633	194	43	.	.	.
29633	194	44	"	"	''
29633	195	1	A	a	DT
29633	195	2	possible	possible	JJ
29633	195	3	explanation	explanation	NN
29633	195	4	of	of	IN
29633	195	5	this	this	DT
29633	195	6	situation	situation	NN
29633	195	7	may	may	MD
29633	195	8	be	be	VB
29633	195	9	found	find	VBN
29633	195	10	in	in	IN
29633	195	11	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	195	12	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	195	13	's	's	POS
29633	195	14	activities	activity	NNS
29633	195	15	in	in	IN
29633	195	16	connection	connection	NN
29633	195	17	with	with	IN
29633	195	18	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	195	19	and	and	CC
29633	195	20	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	195	21	,	,	,
29633	195	22	as	as	RB
29633	195	23	well	well	RB
29633	195	24	as	as	IN
29633	195	25	with	with	IN
29633	195	26	an	an	DT
29633	195	27	Austrian	austrian	JJ
29633	195	28	inventor	inventor	NN
29633	195	29	,	,	,
29633	195	30	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	195	31	.	.	.
29633	196	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	196	2	32	32	CD
29633	196	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	196	4	_	_	NNP
29633	196	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	196	6	.	.	.
29633	196	7	_	_	NNP
29633	196	8	,	,	,
29633	196	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	196	10	770	770	CD
29633	196	11	.	.	.
29633	197	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	197	2	33	33	CD
29633	197	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	197	4	_	_	NNP
29633	197	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	197	6	.	.	.
29633	197	7	_	_	NNP
29633	197	8	,	,	,
29633	197	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	197	10	823	823	CD
29633	197	11	.	.	.
29633	198	1	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	198	2	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	198	3	and	and	CC
29633	198	4	the	the	DT
29633	198	5	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	198	6	Process	Process	NNP
29633	198	7	After	after	IN
29633	198	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	198	9	British	British	NNP
29633	198	10	Association	Association	NNP
29633	198	11	address	address	NN
29633	198	12	in	in	IN
29633	198	13	August	August	NNP
29633	198	14	1856	1856	CD
29633	198	15	,	,	,
29633	198	16	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	198	17	had	have	VBD
29633	198	18	received	receive	VBN
29633	198	19	applications	application	NNS
29633	198	20	from	from	IN
29633	198	21	several	several	JJ
29633	198	22	ironmasters	ironmaster	NNS
29633	198	23	for	for	IN
29633	198	24	licenses	license	NNS
29633	198	25	,	,	,
29633	198	26	which	which	WDT
29633	198	27	were	be	VBD
29633	198	28	issued	issue	VBN
29633	198	29	in	in	IN
29633	198	30	return	return	NN
29633	198	31	for	for	IN
29633	198	32	a	a	DT
29633	198	33	down	down	JJ
29633	198	34	payment	payment	NN
29633	198	35	and	and	CC
29633	198	36	a	a	DT
29633	198	37	nominal	nominal	JJ
29633	198	38	royalty	royalty	NN
29633	198	39	of	of	IN
29633	198	40	25	25	CD
29633	198	41	pence	penny	NNS
29633	198	42	per	per	IN
29633	198	43	ton	ton	NN
29633	198	44	.	.	.
29633	199	1	Among	among	IN
29633	199	2	those	those	DT
29633	199	3	who	who	WP
29633	199	4	started	start	VBD
29633	199	5	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
29633	199	6	was	be	VBD
29633	199	7	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	199	8	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
29633	199	9	Brown	Brown	NNP
29633	199	10	of	of	IN
29633	199	11	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	199	12	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	199	13	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	199	14	Works	Works	NNP
29633	199	15	,	,	,
29633	199	16	one	one	CD
29633	199	17	of	of	IN
29633	199	18	the	the	DT
29633	199	19	largest	large	JJS
29633	199	20	of	of	IN
29633	199	21	the	the	DT
29633	199	22	South	South	NNP
29633	199	23	Wales	Wales	NNP
29633	199	24	plants	plant	NNS
29633	199	25	.	.	.
29633	200	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	200	2	proposed	propose	VBD
29633	200	3	,	,	,
29633	200	4	however	however	RB
29633	200	5	,	,	,
29633	200	6	instead	instead	RB
29633	200	7	of	of	IN
29633	200	8	a	a	DT
29633	200	9	license	license	NN
29633	200	10	,	,	,
29633	200	11	an	an	DT
29633	200	12	outright	outright	JJ
29633	200	13	purchase	purchase	NN
29633	200	14	of	of	IN
29633	200	15	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	200	16	's	's	POS
29633	200	17	patents	patent	NNS
29633	200	18	for	for	IN
29633	200	19	£	£	$
29633	200	20	50,000	50,000	CD
29633	200	21	.	.	.
29633	201	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	201	2	refused	refuse	VBD
29633	201	3	to	to	TO
29633	201	4	sell	sell	VB
29633	201	5	,	,	,
29633	201	6	and	and	CC
29633	201	7	according	accord	VBG
29633	201	8	to	to	IN
29633	201	9	his[34	his[34	NNP
29633	201	10	]	]	-RRB-
29633	201	11	account--	account--	JJ
29633	201	12	intense	intense	JJ
29633	201	13	disappointment	disappointment	NN
29633	201	14	and	and	CC
29633	201	15	anger	anger	NN
29633	201	16	quite	quite	RB
29633	201	17	got	get	VBD
29633	201	18	the	the	DT
29633	201	19	better	well	JJR
29633	201	20	of	of	IN
29633	201	21	[	[	-LRB-
29633	201	22	Brown	Brown	NNP
29633	201	23	]	]	-RRB-
29633	201	24	and	and	CC
29633	201	25	for	for	IN
29633	201	26	the	the	DT
29633	201	27	moment	moment	NN
29633	201	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	201	29	could	could	MD
29633	201	30	not	not	RB
29633	201	31	realize	realize	VB
29633	201	32	the	the	DT
29633	201	33	fact	fact	NN
29633	201	34	of	of	IN
29633	201	35	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	201	36	refusal	refusal	NN
29633	201	37	....	....	.
29633	201	38	[	[	-LRB-
29633	201	39	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	201	40	then	then	RB
29633	201	41	]	]	-RRB-
29633	201	42	left	leave	VBD
29633	201	43	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	201	44	very	very	RB
29633	201	45	abruptly	abruptly	RB
29633	201	46	,	,	,
29633	201	47	saying	say	VBG
29633	201	48	in	in	IN
29633	201	49	an	an	DT
29633	201	50	irritated	irritated	JJ
29633	201	51	tone	tone	NN
29633	201	52	...	...	:
29633	201	53	"	"	``
29633	201	54	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	201	55	'll	will	MD
29633	201	56	make	make	VB
29633	201	57	you	-PRON-	PRP
29633	201	58	see	see	VB
29633	201	59	the	the	DT
29633	201	60	matter	matter	NN
29633	201	61	differently	differently	RB
29633	201	62	yet	yet	RB
29633	201	63	"	"	''
29633	201	64	and	and	CC
29633	201	65	slammed	slam	VBD
29633	201	66	the	the	DT
29633	201	67	door	door	NN
29633	201	68	after	after	IN
29633	201	69	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	201	70	.	.	.
29633	202	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	202	2	34	34	CD
29633	202	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	202	4	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	202	5	,	,	,
29633	202	6	_	_	NNP
29633	202	7	op	op	NN
29633	202	8	.	.	.
29633	203	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	203	2	.	.	.
29633	203	3	_	_	NNP
29633	203	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	203	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	203	6	7	7	CD
29633	203	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	203	8	,	,	,
29633	203	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	203	10	169	169	CD
29633	203	11	.	.	.
29633	204	1	David	David	NNP
29633	204	2	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	204	3	's	's	POS
29633	204	4	advocacy	advocacy	NN
29633	204	5	of	of	IN
29633	204	6	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	204	7	's	's	POS
29633	204	8	claim	claim	NN
29633	204	9	to	to	TO
29633	204	10	priority	priority	NN
29633	204	11	over	over	IN
29633	204	12	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	204	13	has	have	VBZ
29633	204	14	already	already	RB
29633	204	15	been	be	VBN
29633	204	16	noticed	notice	VBN
29633	204	17	(	(	-LRB-
29633	204	18	p.	p.	NN
29633	204	19	33	33	CD
29633	204	20	)	)	-RRB-
29633	204	21	.	.	.
29633	205	1	From	from	IN
29633	205	2	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	205	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
29633	205	4	learn[35	learn[35	XX
29633	205	5	]	]	-RRB-
29633	205	6	that	that	IN
29633	205	7	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	205	8	's	's	POS
29633	205	9	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	205	10	leading	lead	VBG
29633	205	11	to	to	IN
29633	205	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	205	13	patent	patent	NN
29633	205	14	of	of	IN
29633	205	15	September	September	NNP
29633	205	16	15	15	CD
29633	205	17	,	,	,
29633	205	18	1855	1855	CD
29633	205	19	,	,	,
29633	205	20	had	have	VBD
29633	205	21	been	be	VBN
29633	205	22	carried	carry	VBN
29633	205	23	out	out	RP
29633	205	24	at	at	IN
29633	205	25	the	the	DT
29633	205	26	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	205	27	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	205	28	Works	Works	NNP
29633	205	29	in	in	IN
29633	205	30	South	South	NNP
29633	205	31	Wales	Wales	NNP
29633	205	32	,	,	,
29633	205	33	where	where	WRB
29633	205	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	205	35	engaged	engage	VBD
29633	205	36	in	in	IN
29633	205	37	"	"	``
29633	205	38	perfecting	perfect	VBG
29633	205	39	the	the	DT
29633	205	40	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	205	41	process	process	NN
29633	205	42	.	.	.
29633	206	1	"	"	``
29633	206	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	206	3	36	36	CD
29633	206	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	206	5	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	206	6	's	's	POS
29633	206	7	own	own	JJ
29633	206	8	process	process	NN
29633	206	9	consisted	consist	VBD
29633	206	10	in	in	IN
29633	206	11	passing	pass	VBG
29633	206	12	air	air	NN
29633	206	13	through	through	IN
29633	206	14	metal	metal	NN
29633	206	15	as	as	IN
29633	206	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	206	17	was	be	VBD
29633	206	18	run	run	VBN
29633	206	19	in	in	IN
29633	206	20	a	a	DT
29633	206	21	trough	trough	NN
29633	206	22	from	from	IN
29633	206	23	the	the	DT
29633	206	24	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	206	25	and	and	CC
29633	206	26	before	before	IN
29633	206	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	206	28	passed	pass	VBD
29633	206	29	into	into	IN
29633	206	30	the	the	DT
29633	206	31	puddling	puddle	VBG
29633	206	32	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	206	33	.	.	.
29633	207	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	207	2	35	35	CD
29633	207	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	207	4	_	_	NNP
29633	207	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	207	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	207	7	_	_	NNP
29633	207	8	,	,	,
29633	207	9	1856	1856	CD
29633	207	10	,	,	,
29633	207	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	207	12	.	.	.
29633	208	1	26	26	CD
29633	208	2	,	,	,
29633	208	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	208	4	631	631	CD
29633	208	5	.	.	.
29633	209	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	209	2	36	36	CD
29633	209	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	209	4	James	James	NNP
29633	209	5	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	209	6	's	's	POS
29633	209	7	process	process	NN
29633	209	8	(	(	-LRB-
29633	209	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	209	10	patent	patent	NN
29633	209	11	8613	8613	CD
29633	209	12	,	,	,
29633	209	13	December	December	NNP
29633	209	14	23	23	CD
29633	209	15	,	,	,
29633	209	16	1851	1851	CD
29633	209	17	)	)	-RRB-
29633	209	18	had	have	VBD
29633	209	19	been	be	VBN
29633	209	20	developed	develop	VBN
29633	209	21	at	at	IN
29633	209	22	Newark	Newark	NNP
29633	209	23	,	,	,
29633	209	24	New	New	NNP
29633	209	25	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
29633	209	26	,	,	,
29633	209	27	in	in	IN
29633	209	28	1854	1854	CD
29633	209	29	.	.	.
29633	210	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	210	2	was	be	VBD
29633	210	3	a	a	DT
29633	210	4	modification	modification	NN
29633	210	5	of	of	IN
29633	210	6	the	the	DT
29633	210	7	puddling	puddling	NN
29633	210	8	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	210	9	,	,	,
29633	210	10	in	in	IN
29633	210	11	which	which	WDT
29633	210	12	the	the	DT
29633	210	13	ore	ore	NN
29633	210	14	and	and	CC
29633	210	15	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	210	16	were	be	VBD
29633	210	17	heated	heat	VBN
29633	210	18	in	in	IN
29633	210	19	tubs	tub	NNS
29633	210	20	,	,	,
29633	210	21	utilizing	utilize	VBG
29633	210	22	the	the	DT
29633	210	23	waste	waste	NN
29633	210	24	heat	heat	NN
29633	210	25	of	of	IN
29633	210	26	the	the	DT
29633	210	27	reverberatory	reverberatory	NN
29633	210	28	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	210	29	(	(	-LRB-
29633	210	30	see	see	VB
29633	210	31	the	the	DT
29633	210	32	_	_	NNP
29633	210	33	Mechanics	Mechanics	NNP
29633	210	34	'	'	POS
29633	210	35	Magazine	Magazine	NNP
29633	210	36	_	_	NNP
29633	210	37	,	,	,
29633	210	38	vol	vol	NNP
29633	210	39	.	.	.
29633	211	1	62	62	CD
29633	211	2	,	,	,
29633	211	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	211	4	246	246	CD
29633	211	5	,	,	,
29633	211	6	1855	1855	CD
29633	211	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	211	8	.	.	.
29633	212	1	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	212	2	died	die	VBD
29633	212	3	at	at	IN
29633	212	4	Newark	Newark	NNP
29633	212	5	in	in	IN
29633	212	6	September	September	NNP
29633	212	7	1856	1856	CD
29633	212	8	(	(	-LRB-
29633	212	9	_	_	NNP
29633	212	10	Mechanics	Mechanics	NNP
29633	212	11	'	'	POS
29633	212	12	Magazine	Magazine	NNP
29633	212	13	_	_	NNP
29633	212	14	,	,	,
29633	212	15	1856	1856	CD
29633	212	16	,	,	,
29633	212	17	vol	vol	NNP
29633	212	18	.	.	.
29633	213	1	65	65	CD
29633	213	2	,	,	,
29633	213	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	213	4	422	422	CD
29633	213	5	)	)	-RRB-
29633	213	6	.	.	.
29633	214	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	214	2	is	be	VBZ
29633	214	3	known	know	VBN
29633	214	4	that	that	IN
29633	214	5	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	214	6	's	's	POS
29633	214	7	patent	patent	NN
29633	214	8	was	be	VBD
29633	214	9	in	in	IN
29633	214	10	the	the	DT
29633	214	11	hands	hand	NNS
29633	214	12	of	of	IN
29633	214	13	the	the	DT
29633	214	14	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	214	15	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	214	16	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	214	17	Works	Works	NNP
29633	214	18	by	by	IN
29633	214	19	March	March	NNP
29633	214	20	1857	1857	CD
29633	214	21	.	.	.
29633	215	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	215	2	37	37	CD
29633	215	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	215	4	This	this	DT
29633	215	5	fact	fact	NN
29633	215	6	must	must	MD
29633	215	7	be	be	VB
29633	215	8	added	add	VBN
29633	215	9	to	to	IN
29633	215	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	215	11	knowledge	knowledge	NN
29633	215	12	that	that	IN
29633	215	13	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	215	14	's	's	POS
29633	215	15	patent	patent	NN
29633	215	16	of	of	IN
29633	215	17	September	September	NNP
29633	215	18	22	22	CD
29633	215	19	,	,	,
29633	215	20	1856	1856	CD
29633	215	21	was	be	VBD
29633	215	22	drawn	draw	VBN
29633	215	23	up	up	RP
29633	215	24	with	with	IN
29633	215	25	a	a	DT
29633	215	26	specific	specific	JJ
29633	215	27	reference	reference	NN
29633	215	28	to	to	IN
29633	215	29	the	the	DT
29633	215	30	application	application	NN
29633	215	31	of	of	IN
29633	215	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	215	33	"	"	``
29633	215	34	triple	triple	JJ
29633	215	35	compound	compound	NN
29633	215	36	"	"	''
29633	215	37	to	to	IN
29633	215	38	"	"	``
29633	215	39	iron	iron	VB
29633	215	40	...	...	NFP
29633	215	41	purified	purify	VBN
29633	215	42	by	by	IN
29633	215	43	the	the	DT
29633	215	44	action	action	NN
29633	215	45	of	of	IN
29633	215	46	air	air	NN
29633	215	47	,	,	,
29633	215	48	in	in	IN
29633	215	49	the	the	DT
29633	215	50	manner	manner	NN
29633	215	51	invented	invent	VBN
29633	215	52	by	by	IN
29633	215	53	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
29633	215	54	Gilbert	Gilbert	NNP
29633	215	55	Martien,"[38	Martien,"[38	NNP
29633	215	56	]	]	-RRB-
29633	215	57	and	and	CC
29633	215	58	that	that	IN
29633	215	59	this	this	DT
29633	215	60	and	and	CC
29633	215	61	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	215	62	other	other	JJ
29633	215	63	manganese	manganese	JJ
29633	215	64	patents	patent	NNS
29633	215	65	were	be	VBD
29633	215	66	under	under	IN
29633	215	67	the	the	DT
29633	215	68	effective	effective	JJ
29633	215	69	control	control	NN
29633	215	70	of	of	IN
29633	215	71	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	215	72	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	215	73	.	.	.
29633	216	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	216	2	seems	seem	VBZ
29633	216	3	a	a	DT
29633	216	4	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
29633	216	5	deduction	deduction	NN
29633	216	6	from	from	IN
29633	216	7	these	these	DT
29633	216	8	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
29633	216	9	that	that	WDT
29633	216	10	Brown	Brown	NNP
29633	216	11	's	's	POS
29633	216	12	offer	offer	NN
29633	216	13	to	to	TO
29633	216	14	buy	buy	VB
29633	216	15	out	out	RP
29633	216	16	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	216	17	and	and	CC
29633	216	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	216	19	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
29633	216	20	threat	threat	NN
29633	216	21	were	be	VBD
29633	216	22	the	the	DT
29633	216	23	consequences	consequence	NNS
29633	216	24	of	of	IN
29633	216	25	a	a	DT
29633	216	26	determination	determination	NN
29633	216	27	by	by	IN
29633	216	28	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	216	29	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	216	30	to	to	TO
29633	216	31	attack	attack	VB
29633	216	32	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	216	33	by	by	IN
29633	216	34	means	mean	NNS
29633	216	35	of	of	IN
29633	216	36	patent	patent	NN
29633	216	37	infringement	infringement	NN
29633	216	38	suits	suit	NNS
29633	216	39	.	.	.
29633	217	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	217	2	37	37	CD
29633	217	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	217	4	_	_	NNP
29633	217	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	217	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	217	7	_	_	NNP
29633	217	8	,	,	,
29633	217	9	1857	1857	CD
29633	217	10	,	,	,
29633	217	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	217	12	.	.	.
29633	218	1	27	27	CD
29633	218	2	,	,	,
29633	218	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	218	4	193	193	CD
29633	218	5	.	.	.
29633	219	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	219	2	38	38	CD
29633	219	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	219	4	British	british	JJ
29633	219	5	patent	patent	NN
29633	219	6	2219	2219	CD
29633	219	7	,	,	,
29633	219	8	September	September	NNP
29633	219	9	22	22	CD
29633	219	10	,	,	,
29633	219	11	1856	1856	CD
29633	219	12	.	.	.
29633	220	1	Some	some	DT
29633	220	2	aspects	aspect	NNS
29633	220	3	of	of	IN
29633	220	4	the	the	DT
29633	220	5	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	220	6	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	220	7	situation	situation	NN
29633	220	8	are	be	VBP
29633	220	9	not	not	RB
29633	220	10	yet	yet	RB
29633	220	11	explained	explain	VBN
29633	220	12	.	.	.
29633	221	1	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	221	2	came	come	VBD
29633	221	3	to	to	IN
29633	221	4	South	South	NNP
29633	221	5	Wales	Wales	NNP
29633	221	6	from	from	IN
29633	221	7	Newark	Newark	NNP
29633	221	8	,	,	,
29633	221	9	New	New	NNP
29633	221	10	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
29633	221	11	,	,	,
29633	221	12	where	where	WRB
29633	221	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	221	14	had	have	VBD
29633	221	15	been	be	VBN
29633	221	16	manager	manager	NN
29633	221	17	of	of	IN
29633	221	18	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	221	19	's	's	POS
29633	221	20	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	221	21	Semi	Semi	NNP
29633	221	22	-	-	NNP
29633	221	23	Bituminous	Bituminous	NNP
29633	221	24	Coal	Coal	NNP
29633	221	25	Furnace	Furnace	NNP
29633	221	26	,	,	,
29633	221	27	owned	own	VBN
29633	221	28	by	by	IN
29633	221	29	James	James	NNP
29633	221	30	Quimby	Quimby	NNP
29633	221	31	,	,	,
29633	221	32	and	and	CC
29633	221	33	where	where	WRB
29633	221	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	221	35	had	have	VBD
29633	221	36	something	something	NN
29633	221	37	to	to	TO
29633	221	38	do	do	VB
29633	221	39	with	with	IN
29633	221	40	the	the	DT
29633	221	41	installation	installation	NN
29633	221	42	of	of	IN
29633	221	43	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	221	44	's	's	POS
29633	221	45	first	first	JJ
29633	221	46	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	221	47	in	in	IN
29633	221	48	1854	1854	CD
29633	221	49	.	.	.
29633	222	1	The	the	DT
29633	222	2	first	first	JJ
29633	222	3	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	222	4	was	be	VBD
29633	222	5	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
29633	222	6	.	.	.
29633	223	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	223	2	39	39	CD
29633	223	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	223	4	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	223	5	next	next	JJ
29633	223	6	appears	appear	VBZ
29633	223	7	in	in	IN
29633	223	8	Britain	Britain	NNP
29633	223	9	,	,	,
29633	223	10	at	at	IN
29633	223	11	the	the	DT
29633	223	12	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	223	13	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	223	14	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	223	15	Works	Works	NNP
29633	223	16	.	.	.
29633	224	1	No	no	DT
29633	224	2	information	information	NN
29633	224	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	224	4	available	available	JJ
29633	224	5	as	as	IN
29633	224	6	to	to	IN
29633	224	7	whether	whether	IN
29633	224	8	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	224	9	's	's	POS
29633	224	10	own	own	JJ
29633	224	11	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	224	12	was	be	VBD
29633	224	13	actually	actually	RB
29633	224	14	installed	instal	VBN
29633	224	15	at	at	IN
29633	224	16	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	224	17	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	224	18	,	,	,
29633	224	19	although	although	IN
29633	224	20	as	as	IN
29633	224	21	noted	note	VBN
29633	224	22	above	above	RB
29633	224	23	,	,	,
29633	224	24	David	David	NNP
29633	224	25	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	224	26	claims	claim	VBZ
29633	224	27	to	to	TO
29633	224	28	have	have	VB
29633	224	29	been	be	VBN
29633	224	30	invited	invite	VBN
29633	224	31	to	to	TO
29633	224	32	see	see	VB
29633	224	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	224	34	there	there	RB
29633	224	35	.	.	.
29633	225	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	225	2	39	39	CD
29633	225	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	225	4	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
29633	225	5	P.	P.	NNP
29633	225	6	Lesley	Lesley	NNP
29633	225	7	,	,	,
29633	225	8	_	_	NNP
29633	225	9	The	the	DT
29633	225	10	iron	iron	NN
29633	225	11	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
29633	225	12	's	's	POS
29633	225	13	guide	guide	NN
29633	225	14	_	_	NNP
29633	225	15	,	,	,
29633	225	16	New	New	NNP
29633	225	17	York	York	NNP
29633	225	18	,	,	,
29633	225	19	1859	1859	CD
29633	225	20	,	,	,
29633	225	21	p.	p.	NN
29633	225	22	34	34	CD
29633	225	23	.	.	.
29633	226	1	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	226	2	's	's	POS
29633	226	3	name	name	NN
29633	226	4	is	be	VBZ
29633	226	5	spelled	spell	VBN
29633	226	6	Marteen	Marteen	NNP
29633	226	7	.	.	.
29633	227	1	A	a	DT
29633	227	2	description	description	NN
29633	227	3	of	of	IN
29633	227	4	the	the	DT
29633	227	5	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	227	6	is	be	VBZ
29633	227	7	given	give	VBN
29633	227	8	in	in	IN
29633	227	9	_	_	NNP
29633	227	10	Scientific	Scientific	NNP
29633	227	11	American	American	NNP
29633	227	12	_	_	NNP
29633	227	13	of	of	IN
29633	227	14	February	February	NNP
29633	227	15	11	11	CD
29633	227	16	,	,	,
29633	227	17	1854	1854	CD
29633	227	18	,	,	,
29633	227	19	(	(	-LRB-
29633	227	20	vol	vol	NNP
29633	227	21	.	.	.
29633	228	1	9	9	CD
29633	228	2	,	,	,
29633	228	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	228	4	169	169	CD
29633	228	5	)	)	-RRB-
29633	228	6	.	.	.
29633	229	1	In	in	IN
29633	229	2	the	the	DT
29633	229	3	patent	patent	NN
29633	229	4	interference	interference	NN
29633	229	5	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
29633	229	6	referred	refer	VBN
29633	229	7	to	to	IN
29633	229	8	below	below	RB
29633	229	9	,	,	,
29633	229	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	229	11	was	be	VBD
29633	229	12	stated	state	VBN
29633	229	13	that	that	IN
29633	229	14	the	the	DT
29633	229	15	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	229	16	was	be	VBD
29633	229	17	in	in	IN
29633	229	18	successful	successful	JJ
29633	229	19	operation	operation	NN
29633	229	20	in	in	IN
29633	229	21	1854	1854	CD
29633	229	22	.	.	.
29633	230	1	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	230	2	secured	secure	VBD
29633	230	3	an	an	DT
29633	230	4	American	american	JJ
29633	230	5	patent	patent	NN
29633	230	6	for	for	IN
29633	230	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	230	8	process	process	NN
29633	230	9	in	in	IN
29633	230	10	1857	1857	CD
29633	230	11	and	and	CC
29633	230	12	to	to	TO
29633	230	13	file	file	VB
29633	230	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	230	15	application	application	NN
29633	230	16	appears	appear	VBZ
29633	230	17	to	to	TO
29633	230	18	have	have	VB
29633	230	19	gone	go	VBN
29633	230	20	to	to	IN
29633	230	21	the	the	DT
29633	230	22	United	United	NNP
29633	230	23	States	States	NNP
29633	230	24	,	,	,
29633	230	25	where	where	WRB
29633	230	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	230	27	remained	remain	VBD
29633	230	28	at	at	IN
29633	230	29	least	least	JJS
29633	230	30	until	until	IN
29633	230	31	October	October	NNP
29633	230	32	1858	1858	CD
29633	230	33	.	.	.
29633	231	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	231	2	40	40	CD
29633	231	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	231	4	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	231	5	seems	seem	VBZ
29633	231	6	to	to	TO
29633	231	7	have	have	VB
29633	231	8	taken	take	VBN
29633	231	9	the	the	DT
29633	231	10	opportunity	opportunity	NN
29633	231	11	to	to	TO
29633	231	12	apply	apply	VB
29633	231	13	for	for	IN
29633	231	14	another	another	DT
29633	231	15	patent	patent	NN
29633	231	16	for	for	IN
29633	231	17	a	a	DT
29633	231	18	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	231	19	similar	similar	JJ
29633	231	20	to	to	IN
29633	231	21	that	that	DT
29633	231	22	of	of	IN
29633	231	23	James	James	NNP
29633	231	24	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	231	25	.	.	.
29633	232	1	This	this	DT
29633	232	2	led	lead	VBD
29633	232	3	to	to	IN
29633	232	4	interferences	interference	NNS
29633	232	5	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
29633	232	6	in	in	IN
29633	232	7	which	which	WDT
29633	232	8	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	232	9	showed	show	VBD
29633	232	10	that	that	IN
29633	232	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	232	12	had	have	VBD
29633	232	13	worked	work	VBN
29633	232	14	on	on	IN
29633	232	15	this	this	DT
29633	232	16	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	232	17	at	at	IN
29633	232	18	Bridgend	Bridgend	NNP
29633	232	19	,	,	,
29633	232	20	Glamorganshire	Glamorganshire	NNP
29633	232	21	(	(	-LRB-
29633	232	22	one	one	CD
29633	232	23	of	of	IN
29633	232	24	the	the	DT
29633	232	25	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	232	26	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	232	27	plants	plant	NNS
29633	232	28	)	)	-RRB-
29633	232	29	,	,	,
29633	232	30	improving	improve	VBG
29633	232	31	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	232	32	's	's	POS
29633	232	33	design	design	NN
29633	232	34	by	by	IN
29633	232	35	increasing	increase	VBG
29633	232	36	the	the	DT
29633	232	37	number	number	NN
29633	232	38	of	of	IN
29633	232	39	"	"	``
29633	232	40	deoxydizing	deoxydize	VBG
29633	232	41	tubes	tube	NNS
29633	232	42	.	.	.
29633	232	43	"	"	''
29633	233	1	This	this	DT
29633	233	2	variation	variation	NN
29633	233	3	in	in	IN
29633	233	4	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	233	5	's	's	POS
29633	233	6	design	design	NN
29633	233	7	was	be	VBD
29633	233	8	held	hold	VBN
29633	233	9	not	not	RB
29633	233	10	patentable	patentable	JJ
29633	233	11	,	,	,
29633	233	12	and	and	CC
29633	233	13	in	in	IN
29633	233	14	any	any	DT
29633	233	15	case	case	NN
29633	233	16	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	233	17	's	's	POS
29633	233	18	firm	firm	NN
29633	233	19	was	be	VBD
29633	233	20	able	able	JJ
29633	233	21	to	to	TO
29633	233	22	show	show	VB
29633	233	23	that	that	IN
29633	233	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	233	25	had	have	VBD
29633	233	26	successfully	successfully	RB
29633	233	27	installed	instal	VBN
29633	233	28	the	the	DT
29633	233	29	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	233	30	at	at	IN
29633	233	31	Newark	Newark	NNP
29633	233	32	in	in	IN
29633	233	33	1852	1852	CD
29633	233	34	-	-	SYM
29633	233	35	1853	1853	CD
29633	233	36	,	,	,
29633	233	37	while	while	IN
29633	233	38	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	233	39	could	could	MD
29633	233	40	not	not	RB
29633	233	41	satisfy	satisfy	VB
29633	233	42	the	the	DT
29633	233	43	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	233	44	that	that	IN
29633	233	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	233	46	installation	installation	NN
29633	233	47	had	have	VBD
29633	233	48	been	be	VBN
29633	233	49	made	make	VBN
29633	233	50	before	before	IN
29633	233	51	September	September	NNP
29633	233	52	1854	1854	CD
29633	233	53	.	.	.
29633	234	1	Priority	priority	NN
29633	234	2	was	be	VBD
29633	234	3	therefore	therefore	RB
29633	234	4	awarded	award	VBN
29633	234	5	to	to	IN
29633	234	6	Quimby	Quimby	NNP
29633	234	7	,	,	,
29633	234	8	Brown	Brown	NNP
29633	234	9	,	,	,
29633	234	10	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	234	11	,	,	,
29633	234	12	and	and	CC
29633	234	13	Creswell	Creswell	NNP
29633	234	14	.	.	.
29633	235	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	235	2	41	41	CD
29633	235	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	235	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	235	5	40	40	CD
29633	235	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	235	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	235	8	patent	patent	NN
29633	235	9	16690	16690	CD
29633	235	10	,	,	,
29633	235	11	February	February	NNP
29633	235	12	22	22	CD
29633	235	13	,	,	,
29633	235	14	1857	1857	CD
29633	235	15	.	.	.
29633	236	1	A	a	DT
29633	236	2	correspondent	correspondent	NN
29633	236	3	of	of	IN
29633	236	4	the	the	DT
29633	236	5	_	_	NNP
29633	236	6	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	236	7	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	236	8	_	_	NNP
29633	236	9	(	(	-LRB-
29633	236	10	1858	1858	CD
29633	236	11	,	,	,
29633	236	12	vol	vol	NNP
29633	236	13	.	.	.
29633	237	1	28	28	CD
29633	237	2	,	,	,
29633	237	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	237	4	713	713	CD
29633	237	5	)	)	-RRB-
29633	237	6	states	state	VBZ
29633	237	7	that	that	IN
29633	237	8	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	237	9	had	have	VBD
29633	237	10	not	not	RB
29633	237	11	returned	return	VBN
29633	237	12	to	to	IN
29633	237	13	England	England	NNP
29633	237	14	by	by	IN
29633	237	15	October	October	NNP
29633	237	16	1858	1858	CD
29633	237	17	.	.	.
29633	238	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	238	2	41	41	CD
29633	238	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	238	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	238	5	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	238	6	Office	Office	NNP
29633	238	7	,	,	,
29633	238	8	Decision	Decision	NNP
29633	238	9	of	of	IN
29633	238	10	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	238	11	of	of	IN
29633	238	12	Patents	Patents	NNPS
29633	238	13	,	,	,
29633	238	14	dated	date	VBN
29633	238	15	May	May	NNP
29633	238	16	26	26	CD
29633	238	17	,	,	,
29633	238	18	1859	1859	CD
29633	238	19	in	in	IN
29633	238	20	the	the	DT
29633	238	21	matter	matter	NN
29633	238	22	of	of	IN
29633	238	23	interference	interference	NN
29633	238	24	between	between	IN
29633	238	25	the	the	DT
29633	238	26	application	application	NN
29633	238	27	of	of	IN
29633	238	28	James	James	NNP
29633	238	29	M.	M.	NNP
29633	238	30	Quimby	Quimby	NNP
29633	238	31	and	and	CC
29633	238	32	others	other	NNS
29633	238	33	...	...	NFP
29633	238	34	and	and	CC
29633	238	35	of	of	IN
29633	238	36	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
29633	238	37	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	238	38	.	.	.
29633	239	1	Since	since	IN
29633	239	2	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	239	3	had	have	VBD
29633	239	4	not	not	RB
29633	239	5	patented	patent	VBN
29633	239	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	239	7	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	239	8	in	in	IN
29633	239	9	Great	Great	NNP
29633	239	10	Britain	Britain	NNP
29633	239	11	,	,	,
29633	239	12	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	239	13	's	's	POS
29633	239	14	use	use	NN
29633	239	15	of	of	IN
29633	239	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	239	17	earlier	early	JJR
29633	239	18	knowledge	knowledge	NN
29633	239	19	of	of	IN
29633	239	20	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	239	21	's	's	POS
29633	239	22	work	work	NN
29633	239	23	and	and	CC
29633	239	24	of	of	IN
29633	239	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	239	26	experience	experience	NN
29633	239	27	at	at	IN
29633	239	28	Bridgend	bridgend	NN
29633	239	29	in	in	IN
29633	239	30	an	an	DT
29633	239	31	attempt	attempt	NN
29633	239	32	to	to	TO
29633	239	33	upset	upset	VB
29633	239	34	Renton	Renton	NNP
29633	239	35	's	's	POS
29633	239	36	priority	priority	NN
29633	239	37	is	be	VBZ
29633	239	38	a	a	DT
29633	239	39	curious	curious	JJ
29633	239	40	and	and	CC
29633	239	41	at	at	IN
29633	239	42	present	present	JJ
29633	239	43	unexplainable	unexplainable	JJ
29633	239	44	episode	episode	NN
29633	239	45	.	.	.
29633	240	1	Perhaps	perhaps	RB
29633	240	2	the	the	DT
29633	240	3	early	early	JJ
29633	240	4	records	record	NNS
29633	240	5	of	of	IN
29633	240	6	the	the	DT
29633	240	7	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	240	8	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	240	9	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	240	10	Works	Works	NNP
29633	240	11	,	,	,
29633	240	12	if	if	IN
29633	240	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	240	14	exist	exist	VBP
29633	240	15	,	,	,
29633	240	16	will	will	MD
29633	240	17	show	show	VB
29633	240	18	whether	whether	IN
29633	240	19	this	this	DT
29633	240	20	episode	episode	NN
29633	240	21	was	be	VBD
29633	240	22	in	in	IN
29633	240	23	some	some	DT
29633	240	24	way	way	NN
29633	240	25	linked	link	VBN
29633	240	26	to	to	IN
29633	240	27	the	the	DT
29633	240	28	firm	firm	NN
29633	240	29	's	's	POS
29633	240	30	optimistic	optimistic	JJ
29633	240	31	combination	combination	NN
29633	240	32	of	of	IN
29633	240	33	the	the	DT
29633	240	34	British	british	JJ
29633	240	35	patents	patent	NNS
29633	240	36	of	of	IN
29633	240	37	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	240	38	and	and	CC
29633	240	39	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	240	40	.	.	.
29633	241	1	That	that	IN
29633	241	2	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	241	3	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	241	4	exerted	exert	VBD
29633	241	5	every	every	DT
29633	241	6	effort	effort	NN
29633	241	7	to	to	TO
29633	241	8	find	find	VB
29633	241	9	an	an	DT
29633	241	10	alternative	alternative	NN
29633	241	11	to	to	IN
29633	241	12	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	241	13	's	's	POS
29633	241	14	process	process	NN
29633	241	15	is	be	VBZ
29633	241	16	suggested	suggest	VBN
29633	241	17	,	,	,
29633	241	18	also	also	RB
29633	241	19	,	,	,
29633	241	20	by	by	IN
29633	241	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	241	22	purchase	purchase	NN
29633	241	23	in	in	IN
29633	241	24	1856	1856	CD
29633	241	25	of	of	IN
29633	241	26	the	the	DT
29633	241	27	British	british	JJ
29633	241	28	rights	right	NNS
29633	241	29	to	to	IN
29633	241	30	the	the	DT
29633	241	31	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	241	32	process	process	NN
29633	241	33	,	,	,
29633	241	34	invented	invent	VBN
29633	241	35	by	by	IN
29633	241	36	an	an	DT
29633	241	37	Austrian	austrian	JJ
29633	241	38	Army	Army	NNP
29633	241	39	officer	officer	NN
29633	241	40	.	.	.
29633	242	1	The	the	DT
29633	242	2	provisional	provisional	JJ
29633	242	3	patent	patent	NN
29633	242	4	specifications	specification	NNS
29633	242	5	,	,	,
29633	242	6	dated	date	VBN
29633	242	7	October	October	NNP
29633	242	8	1	1	CD
29633	242	9	,	,	,
29633	242	10	1855	1855	CD
29633	242	11	,	,	,
29633	242	12	showed	show	VBD
29633	242	13	that	that	IN
29633	242	14	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	242	15	proposed	propose	VBD
29633	242	16	to	to	TO
29633	242	17	make	make	VB
29633	242	18	cast	cast	VBN
29633	242	19	steel	steel	NN
29633	242	20	directly	directly	RB
29633	242	21	from	from	IN
29633	242	22	pig	pig	NN
29633	242	23	-	-	HYPH
29633	242	24	iron	iron	NN
29633	242	25	by	by	IN
29633	242	26	melting	melt	VBG
29633	242	27	granulated	granulate	VBN
29633	242	28	pig	pig	NN
29633	242	29	-	-	HYPH
29633	242	30	iron	iron	NN
29633	242	31	in	in	IN
29633	242	32	a	a	DT
29633	242	33	crucible	crucible	NN
29633	242	34	with	with	IN
29633	242	35	pulverized	pulverize	VBN
29633	242	36	"	"	``
29633	242	37	sparry	sparry	NN
29633	242	38	iron	iron	NN
29633	242	39	"	"	''
29633	242	40	(	(	-LRB-
29633	242	41	siderite	siderite	NN
29633	242	42	)	)	-RRB-
29633	242	43	and	and	CC
29633	242	44	fine	fine	JJ
29633	242	45	clay	clay	NN
29633	242	46	or	or	CC
29633	242	47	with	with	IN
29633	242	48	gray	gray	JJ
29633	242	49	oxide	oxide	NN
29633	242	50	of	of	IN
29633	242	51	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	242	52	,	,	,
29633	242	53	which	which	WDT
29633	242	54	would	would	MD
29633	242	55	determine	determine	VB
29633	242	56	the	the	DT
29633	242	57	amount	amount	NN
29633	242	58	of	of	IN
29633	242	59	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	242	60	combining	combine	VBG
29633	242	61	with	with	IN
29633	242	62	the	the	DT
29633	242	63	iron	iron	NN
29633	242	64	.	.	.
29633	243	1	This	this	DT
29633	243	2	process	process	NN
29633	243	3	,	,	,
29633	243	4	which	which	WDT
29633	243	5	was	be	VBD
29633	243	6	to	to	TO
29633	243	7	prove	prove	VB
29633	243	8	commercially	commercially	RB
29633	243	9	successful	successful	JJ
29633	243	10	in	in	IN
29633	243	11	Great	Great	NNP
29633	243	12	Britain	Britain	NNP
29633	243	13	and	and	CC
29633	243	14	in	in	IN
29633	243	15	Sweden	Sweden	NNP
29633	243	16	but	but	CC
29633	243	17	was	be	VBD
29633	243	18	not	not	RB
29633	243	19	used	use	VBN
29633	243	20	in	in	IN
29633	243	21	America,[42	america,[42	NN
29633	243	22	]	]	-RRB-
29633	243	23	appeared	appear	VBD
29633	243	24	to	to	IN
29633	243	25	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	243	26	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	243	27	to	to	TO
29633	243	28	be	be	VB
29633	243	29	something	something	NN
29633	243	30	from	from	IN
29633	243	31	which	which	WDT
29633	243	32	,	,	,
29633	243	33	"	"	``
29633	243	34	we	-PRON-	PRP
29633	243	35	can	can	MD
29633	243	36	have	have	VB
29633	243	37	steel	steel	NN
29633	243	38	produced	produce	VBN
29633	243	39	at	at	IN
29633	243	40	the	the	DT
29633	243	41	price	price	NN
29633	243	42	proposed	propose	VBN
29633	243	43	by	by	IN
29633	243	44	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	243	45	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	243	46	,	,	,
29633	243	47	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
29633	243	48	the	the	DT
29633	243	49	failure	failure	NN
29633	243	50	of	of	IN
29633	243	51	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	243	52	process	process	NN
29633	243	53	to	to	TO
29633	243	54	fulfil	fulfil	VB
29633	243	55	the	the	DT
29633	243	56	promise	promise	NN
29633	243	57	.	.	.
29633	244	1	"	"	``
29633	244	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	244	3	43	43	CD
29633	244	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	244	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	244	6	42	42	CD
29633	244	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	244	8	J.	J.	NNP
29633	244	9	S.	S.	NNP
29633	244	10	Jeans	Jeans	NNP
29633	244	11	,	,	,
29633	244	12	_	_	NNP
29633	244	13	op	op	NN
29633	244	14	.	.	.
29633	245	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	245	2	.	.	.
29633	245	3	_	_	NNP
29633	245	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	245	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	245	6	5	5	CD
29633	245	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	245	8	,	,	,
29633	245	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	245	10	108	108	CD
29633	245	11	.	.	.
29633	246	1	The	the	DT
29633	246	2	process	process	NN
29633	246	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	246	4	not	not	RB
29633	246	5	mentioned	mention	VBN
29633	246	6	by	by	IN
29633	246	7	James	James	NNP
29633	246	8	M.	M.	NNP
29633	246	9	Swank	Swank	NNP
29633	246	10	,	,	,
29633	246	11	_	_	NNP
29633	246	12	History	history	NN
29633	246	13	of	of	IN
29633	246	14	the	the	DT
29633	246	15	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	246	16	of	of	IN
29633	246	17	iron	iron	NN
29633	246	18	in	in	IN
29633	246	19	all	all	DT
29633	246	20	ages	age	NNS
29633	246	21	_	_	NNP
29633	246	22	,	,	,
29633	246	23	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
29633	246	24	,	,	,
29633	246	25	American	American	NNP
29633	246	26	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	246	27	and	and	CC
29633	246	28	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	246	29	Association	Association	NNP
29633	246	30	,	,	,
29633	246	31	1892	1892	CD
29633	246	32	.	.	.
29633	247	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	247	2	43	43	CD
29633	247	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	247	4	_	_	NNP
29633	247	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	247	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	247	7	_	_	NNP
29633	247	8	,	,	,
29633	247	9	1856	1856	CD
29633	247	10	,	,	,
29633	247	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	247	12	.	.	.
29633	248	1	26	26	CD
29633	248	2	,	,	,
29633	248	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	248	4	707	707	CD
29633	248	5	.	.	.
29633	249	1	So	so	RB
29633	249	2	far	far	RB
29633	249	3	as	as	IN
29633	249	4	is	be	VBZ
29633	249	5	known	know	VBN
29633	249	6	only	only	RB
29633	249	7	one	one	CD
29633	249	8	direct	direct	JJ
29633	249	9	attempt	attempt	NN
29633	249	10	was	be	VBD
29633	249	11	made	make	VBN
29633	249	12	,	,	,
29633	249	13	presumably	presumably	RB
29633	249	14	instigated	instigate	VBN
29633	249	15	by	by	IN
29633	249	16	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	249	17	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	249	18	,	,	,
29633	249	19	to	to	TO
29633	249	20	enforce	enforce	VB
29633	249	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	249	22	patents	patent	NNS
29633	249	23	against	against	IN
29633	249	24	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	249	25	,	,	,
29633	249	26	who	who	WP
29633	249	27	records[44	records[44	VBZ
29633	249	28	]	]	-RRB-
29633	249	29	a	a	DT
29633	249	30	visit	visit	NN
29633	249	31	by	by	IN
29633	249	32	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	249	33	's	's	POS
29633	249	34	agent	agent	NN
29633	249	35	some	some	DT
29633	249	36	two	two	CD
29633	249	37	or	or	CC
29633	249	38	three	three	CD
29633	249	39	months	month	NNS
29633	249	40	before	before	IN
29633	249	41	a	a	DT
29633	249	42	renewal	renewal	NN
29633	249	43	fee	fee	NN
29633	249	44	on	on	IN
29633	249	45	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	249	46	's	's	POS
29633	249	47	basic	basic	JJ
29633	249	48	manganese	manganese	JJ
29633	249	49	patents	patent	NNS
29633	249	50	became	become	VBD
29633	249	51	payable	payable	JJ
29633	249	52	in	in	IN
29633	249	53	1859	1859	CD
29633	249	54	.	.	.
29633	250	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	250	2	"	"	``
29633	250	3	entirely	entirely	RB
29633	250	4	repudiated	repudiate	VBD
29633	250	5	"	"	``
29633	250	6	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	250	7	's	's	POS
29633	250	8	patents	patent	NNS
29633	250	9	and	and	CC
29633	250	10	offered	offer	VBD
29633	250	11	to	to	TO
29633	250	12	perform	perform	VB
29633	250	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	250	14	operations	operation	NNS
29633	250	15	in	in	IN
29633	250	16	the	the	DT
29633	250	17	presence	presence	NN
29633	250	18	of	of	IN
29633	250	19	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	250	20	's	's	POS
29633	250	21	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
29633	250	22	and	and	CC
29633	250	23	witnesses	witness	NNS
29633	250	24	at	at	IN
29633	250	25	the	the	DT
29633	250	26	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	250	27	Works	Works	NNPS
29633	250	28	so	so	IN
29633	250	29	that	that	IN
29633	250	30	a	a	DT
29633	250	31	prosecution	prosecution	NN
29633	250	32	for	for	IN
29633	250	33	infringement	infringement	NN
29633	250	34	"	"	``
29633	250	35	would	would	MD
29633	250	36	be	be	VB
29633	250	37	a	a	DT
29633	250	38	very	very	RB
29633	250	39	simple	simple	JJ
29633	250	40	matter	matter	NN
29633	250	41	.	.	.
29633	250	42	"	"	''
29633	251	1	That	that	DT
29633	251	2	,	,	,
29633	251	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	251	4	says	say	VBZ
29633	251	5	,	,	,
29633	251	6	was	be	VBD
29633	251	7	the	the	DT
29633	251	8	last	last	JJ
29633	251	9	heard	hear	VBN
29633	251	10	from	from	IN
29633	251	11	the	the	DT
29633	251	12	agent	agent	NN
29633	251	13	or	or	CC
29633	251	14	from	from	IN
29633	251	15	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	251	16	on	on	IN
29633	251	17	the	the	DT
29633	251	18	subject	subject	NN
29633	251	19	.	.	.
29633	252	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	252	2	45	45	CD
29633	252	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	252	4	The	the	DT
29633	252	5	renewal	renewal	NN
29633	252	6	fee	fee	NN
29633	252	7	was	be	VBD
29633	252	8	not	not	RB
29633	252	9	paid	pay	VBN
29633	252	10	and	and	CC
29633	252	11	the	the	DT
29633	252	12	patents	patent	NNS
29633	252	13	were	be	VBD
29633	252	14	therefore	therefore	RB
29633	252	15	abandoned	abandon	VBN
29633	252	16	by	by	IN
29633	252	17	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	252	18	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	252	19	and	and	CC
29633	252	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	252	21	associates	associate	NNS
29633	252	22	,	,	,
29633	252	23	a	a	DT
29633	252	24	fact	fact	NN
29633	252	25	which	which	WDT
29633	252	26	did	do	VBD
29633	252	27	not	not	RB
29633	252	28	come	come	VB
29633	252	29	to	to	IN
29633	252	30	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	252	31	's	's	POS
29633	252	32	knowledge	knowledge	NN
29633	252	33	until	until	IN
29633	252	34	1861	1861	CD
29633	252	35	,	,	,
29633	252	36	when	when	WRB
29633	252	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	252	38	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	252	39	declared	declare	VBD
29633	252	40	that	that	IN
29633	252	41	the	the	DT
29633	252	42	patent	patent	NN
29633	252	43	"	"	``
29633	252	44	was	be	VBD
29633	252	45	never	never	RB
29633	252	46	in	in	IN
29633	252	47	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	252	48	hands	hand	NNS
29633	252	49	at	at	RB
29633	252	50	all	all	RB
29633	252	51	[	[	-LRB-
29633	252	52	so	so	RB
29633	252	53	]	]	-RRB-
29633	252	54	that	that	IN
29633	252	55	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	252	56	could	could	MD
29633	252	57	not	not	RB
29633	252	58	enforce	enforce	VB
29633	252	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	252	60	.	.	.
29633	253	1	"	"	``
29633	253	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	253	3	46	46	CD
29633	253	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	253	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	253	6	44	44	CD
29633	253	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	253	8	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	253	9	,	,	,
29633	253	10	_	_	NNP
29633	253	11	op	op	NN
29633	253	12	.	.	.
29633	254	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	254	2	.	.	.
29633	254	3	_	_	NNP
29633	254	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	254	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	254	6	7	7	CD
29633	254	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	254	8	,	,	,
29633	254	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	254	10	290	290	CD
29633	254	11	.	.	.
29633	255	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	255	2	45	45	CD
29633	255	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	255	4	The	the	DT
29633	255	5	American	American	NNP
29633	255	6	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	255	7	and	and	CC
29633	255	8	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	255	9	Institute	Institute	NNP
29633	255	10	's	's	POS
29633	255	11	"	"	``
29633	255	12	Steel	steel	NN
29633	255	13	centennial	centennial	NN
29633	255	14	(	(	-LRB-
29633	255	15	1957	1957	CD
29633	255	16	)	)	-RRB-
29633	255	17	press	press	NN
29633	255	18	information	information	NN
29633	255	19	"	"	''
29633	255	20	(	(	-LRB-
29633	255	21	see	see	VB
29633	255	22	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	255	23	2	2	CD
29633	255	24	)	)	-RRB-
29633	255	25	,	,	,
29633	255	26	includes	include	VBZ
29633	255	27	a	a	DT
29633	255	28	pamphlet	pamphlet	NN
29633	255	29	,	,	,
29633	255	30	"	"	''
29633	255	31	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	255	32	lighted	light	VBD
29633	255	33	the	the	DT
29633	255	34	fireworks	firework	NNS
29633	255	35	...	...	:
29633	255	36	"	"	''
29633	255	37	by	by	IN
29633	255	38	Vaughn	Vaughn	NNP
29633	255	39	Shelton	Shelton	NNP
29633	255	40	(	(	-LRB-
29633	255	41	New	New	NNP
29633	255	42	York	York	NNP
29633	255	43	,	,	,
29633	255	44	1956	1956	CD
29633	255	45	)	)	-RRB-
29633	255	46	,	,	,
29633	255	47	which	which	WDT
29633	255	48	asserts	assert	VBZ
29633	255	49	(	(	-LRB-
29633	255	50	p.	p.	NN
29633	255	51	12	12	CD
29633	255	52	)	)	-RRB-
29633	255	53	that	that	WDT
29633	255	54	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	255	55	paid	pay	VBD
29633	255	56	the	the	DT
29633	255	57	renewal	renewal	NN
29633	255	58	fee	fee	NN
29633	255	59	and	and	CC
29633	255	60	became	become	VBD
29633	255	61	the	the	DT
29633	255	62	owner	owner	NN
29633	255	63	of	of	IN
29633	255	64	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	255	65	's	's	POS
29633	255	66	"	"	``
29633	255	67	vital	vital	JJ
29633	255	68	"	"	''
29633	255	69	patent	patent	NN
29633	255	70	.	.	.
29633	256	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	256	2	46	46	CD
29633	256	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	256	4	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	256	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	256	6	,	,	,
29633	256	7	_	_	NNP
29633	256	8	The	the	DT
29633	256	9	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	256	10	-	-	HYPH
29633	256	11	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	256	12	process	process	NN
29633	256	13	_	_	NNP
29633	256	14	,	,	,
29633	256	15	Cheltenham	Cheltenham	NNP
29633	256	16	,	,	,
29633	256	17	1883	1883	CD
29633	256	18	,	,	,
29633	256	19	p.	p.	NN
29633	256	20	24	24	CD
29633	256	21	;	;	:
29633	256	22	_	_	NNP
29633	256	23	The	the	DT
29633	256	24	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	256	25	_	_	NNP
29633	256	26	,	,	,
29633	256	27	1861	1861	CD
29633	256	28	,	,	,
29633	256	29	vol	vol	NNP
29633	256	30	.	.	.
29633	257	1	12	12	CD
29633	257	2	,	,	,
29633	257	3	pp	pp	NNP
29633	257	4	.	.	.
29633	258	1	177	177	CD
29633	258	2	and	and	CC
29633	258	3	189	189	CD
29633	258	4	.	.	.
29633	259	1	Further	further	JJ
29633	259	2	support	support	NN
29633	259	3	for	for	IN
29633	259	4	the	the	DT
29633	259	5	thesis	thesis	NN
29633	259	6	that	that	IN
29633	259	7	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	259	8	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	259	9	's	's	POS
29633	259	10	policy	policy	NN
29633	259	11	was	be	VBD
29633	259	12	in	in	IN
29633	259	13	part	part	NN
29633	259	14	dictated	dictate	VBN
29633	259	15	by	by	IN
29633	259	16	a	a	DT
29633	259	17	desire	desire	NN
29633	259	18	to	to	TO
29633	259	19	make	make	VB
29633	259	20	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	259	21	"	"	``
29633	259	22	see	see	VB
29633	259	23	the	the	DT
29633	259	24	matter	matter	NN
29633	259	25	differently	differently	RB
29633	259	26	"	"	''
29633	259	27	is	be	VBZ
29633	259	28	to	to	TO
29633	259	29	be	be	VB
29633	259	30	found	find	VBN
29633	259	31	in	in	IN
29633	259	32	the	the	DT
29633	259	33	climatic	climatic	JJ
29633	259	34	episode	episode	NN
29633	259	35	.	.	.
29633	260	1	Work	work	VB
29633	260	2	on	on	IN
29633	260	3	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	260	4	's	's	POS
29633	260	5	patents	patent	NNS
29633	260	6	had	have	VBD
29633	260	7	not	not	RB
29633	260	8	been	be	VBN
29633	260	9	abandoned	abandon	VBN
29633	260	10	and	and	CC
29633	260	11	in	in	IN
29633	260	12	1861	1861	CD
29633	260	13	certain	certain	JJ
29633	260	14	patents	patent	NNS
29633	260	15	were	be	VBD
29633	260	16	taken	take	VBN
29633	260	17	out	out	RP
29633	260	18	by	by	IN
29633	260	19	George	George	NNP
29633	260	20	Parry	Parry	NNP
29633	260	21	,	,	,
29633	260	22	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	260	23	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	260	24	's	's	POS
29633	260	25	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	260	26	manager	manager	NN
29633	260	27	.	.	.
29633	261	1	These	these	DT
29633	261	2	,	,	,
29633	261	3	represented	represent	VBN
29633	261	4	as	as	IN
29633	261	5	improvements	improvement	NNS
29633	261	6	of	of	IN
29633	261	7	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	261	8	's	's	POS
29633	261	9	designs	design	NNS
29633	261	10	,	,	,
29633	261	11	were	be	VBD
29633	261	12	regarded	regard	VBN
29633	261	13	by	by	IN
29633	261	14	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	261	15	as	as	IN
29633	261	16	clear	clear	JJ
29633	261	17	infringements	infringement	NNS
29633	261	18	of	of	IN
29633	261	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	261	20	own	own	JJ
29633	261	21	patents	patent	NNS
29633	261	22	.	.	.
29633	262	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	262	2	47	47	CD
29633	262	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	262	4	When	when	WRB
29633	262	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	262	6	came	come	VBD
29633	262	7	to	to	IN
29633	262	8	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	262	9	's	's	POS
29633	262	10	knowledge	knowledge	NN
29633	262	11	that	that	WDT
29633	262	12	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	262	13	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	262	14	was	be	VBD
29633	262	15	proposing	propose	VBG
29633	262	16	to	to	TO
29633	262	17	"	"	``
29633	262	18	go	go	VB
29633	262	19	to	to	IN
29633	262	20	the	the	DT
29633	262	21	public	public	NN
29633	262	22	"	"	``
29633	262	23	for	for	IN
29633	262	24	additional	additional	JJ
29633	262	25	capital	capital	NN
29633	262	26	with	with	IN
29633	262	27	which	which	WDT
29633	262	28	to	to	TO
29633	262	29	finance	finance	VB
29633	262	30	,	,	,
29633	262	31	in	in	IN
29633	262	32	part	part	NN
29633	262	33	,	,	,
29633	262	34	a	a	DT
29633	262	35	large	large	JJ
29633	262	36	scale	scale	NN
29633	262	37	working	working	NN
29633	262	38	of	of	IN
29633	262	39	Parry	Parry	NNP
29633	262	40	's	's	POS
29633	262	41	process	process	NN
29633	262	42	,	,	,
29633	262	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	262	44	threatened	threaten	VBD
29633	262	45	the	the	DT
29633	262	46	financial	financial	JJ
29633	262	47	promoter	promoter	NN
29633	262	48	with	with	IN
29633	262	49	injunctions	injunction	NNS
29633	262	50	and	and	CC
29633	262	51	succeeded	succeed	VBD
29633	262	52	in	in	IN
29633	262	53	opening	open	VBG
29633	262	54	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
29633	262	55	for	for	IN
29633	262	56	a	a	DT
29633	262	57	settlement	settlement	NN
29633	262	58	.	.	.
29633	263	1	All	all	PDT
29633	263	2	the	the	DT
29633	263	3	patents	patent	NNS
29633	263	4	"	"	''
29633	263	5	which	which	WDT
29633	263	6	had	have	VBD
29633	263	7	been	be	VBN
29633	263	8	for	for	IN
29633	263	9	years	year	NNS
29633	263	10	suspended	suspend	VBN
29633	263	11	"	"	''
29633	263	12	over	over	IN
29633	263	13	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	263	14	were	be	VBD
29633	263	15	turned	turn	VBN
29633	263	16	over	over	RP
29633	263	17	to	to	IN
29633	263	18	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	263	19	for	for	IN
29633	263	20	£	£	$
29633	263	21	30,000	30,000	CD
29633	263	22	.	.	.
29633	264	1	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	264	2	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	264	3	,	,	,
29633	264	4	thereupon	thereupon	RB
29633	264	5	,	,	,
29633	264	6	issued	issue	VBD
29633	264	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	264	8	prospectus[48	prospectus[48	NN
29633	264	9	]	]	-RRB-
29633	264	10	with	with	IN
29633	264	11	the	the	DT
29633	264	12	significant	significant	JJ
29633	264	13	statement	statement	NN
29633	264	14	that	that	IN
29633	264	15	the	the	DT
29633	264	16	directors	director	NNS
29633	264	17	"	"	``
29633	264	18	have	have	VBP
29633	264	19	agreed	agree	VBN
29633	264	20	for	for	IN
29633	264	21	a	a	DT
29633	264	22	license	license	NN
29633	264	23	for	for	IN
29633	264	24	the	the	DT
29633	264	25	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	264	26	of	of	IN
29633	264	27	steel	steel	NN
29633	264	28	by	by	IN
29633	264	29	the	the	DT
29633	264	30	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	264	31	process	process	NN
29633	264	32	which	which	WDT
29633	264	33	,	,	,
29633	264	34	from	from	IN
29633	264	35	the	the	DT
29633	264	36	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
29633	264	37	resources	resource	NNS
29633	264	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	264	39	possess	possess	VBP
29633	264	40	,	,	,
29633	264	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	264	42	will	will	MD
29633	264	43	be	be	VB
29633	264	44	enabled	enable	VBN
29633	264	45	to	to	TO
29633	264	46	produce	produce	VB
29633	264	47	in	in	IN
29633	264	48	very	very	RB
29633	264	49	large	large	JJ
29633	264	50	quantities	quantity	NNS
29633	264	51	....	....	.
29633	264	52	"	"	''
29633	264	53	So	so	RB
29633	264	54	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	264	55	became	become	VBD
29633	264	56	the	the	DT
29633	264	57	owner	owner	NN
29633	264	58	of	of	IN
29633	264	59	the	the	DT
29633	264	60	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	264	61	and	and	CC
29633	264	62	Parry	Parry	NNP
29633	264	63	patents	patent	NNS
29633	264	64	.	.	.
29633	265	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	265	2	's	's	POS
29633	265	3	basic	basic	JJ
29633	265	4	patents	patent	NNS
29633	265	5	no	no	RB
29633	265	6	longer	long	RBR
29633	265	7	existed	exist	VBD
29633	265	8	.	.	.
29633	266	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	266	2	47	47	CD
29633	266	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	266	4	_	_	NNP
29633	266	5	The	the	DT
29633	266	6	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	266	7	_	_	NNP
29633	266	8	,	,	,
29633	266	9	1862	1862	CD
29633	266	10	,	,	,
29633	266	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	266	12	.	.	.
29633	267	1	14	14	CD
29633	267	2	,	,	,
29633	267	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	267	4	3	3	CD
29633	267	5	.	.	.
29633	268	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	268	2	,	,	,
29633	268	3	_	_	NNP
29633	268	4	op	op	NN
29633	268	5	.	.	.
29633	269	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	269	2	.	.	.
29633	269	3	_	_	NNP
29633	269	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	269	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	269	6	7	7	CD
29633	269	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	269	8	,	,	,
29633	269	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	269	10	296	296	CD
29633	269	11	.	.	.
29633	270	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	270	2	48	48	CD
29633	270	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	270	4	_	_	NNP
29633	270	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	270	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	270	7	_	_	NNP
29633	270	8	,	,	,
29633	270	9	1864	1864	CD
29633	270	10	,	,	,
29633	270	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	270	12	.	.	.
29633	271	1	34	34	CD
29633	271	2	,	,	,
29633	271	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	271	4	478	478	CD
29633	271	5	.	.	.
29633	272	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	272	2	and	and	CC
29633	272	3	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	272	4	That	that	IN
29633	272	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	272	6	was	be	VBD
29633	272	7	"	"	``
29633	272	8	used	use	VBN
29633	272	9	"	"	''
29633	272	10	by	by	IN
29633	272	11	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	272	12	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	272	13	against	against	IN
29633	272	14	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	272	15	is	be	VBZ
29633	272	16	,	,	,
29633	272	17	perhaps	perhaps	RB
29633	272	18	,	,	,
29633	272	19	only	only	RB
29633	272	20	an	an	DT
29633	272	21	assumption	assumption	NN
29633	272	22	;	;	:
29633	272	23	but	but	CC
29633	272	24	that	that	IN
29633	272	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	272	26	was	be	VBD
29633	272	27	badly	badly	RB
29633	272	28	treated	treat	VBN
29633	272	29	by	by	IN
29633	272	30	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	272	31	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	272	32	is	be	VBZ
29633	272	33	subject	subject	JJ
29633	272	34	to	to	IN
29633	272	35	no	no	DT
29633	272	36	doubt	doubt	NN
29633	272	37	.	.	.
29633	273	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	273	2	's	's	POS
29633	273	3	business	business	NN
29633	273	4	capacity	capacity	NN
29633	273	5	was	be	VBD
29633	273	6	small	small	JJ
29633	273	7	but	but	CC
29633	273	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	273	9	is	be	VBZ
29633	273	10	difficult	difficult	JJ
29633	273	11	to	to	TO
29633	273	12	believe	believe	VB
29633	273	13	that	that	IN
29633	273	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	273	15	could	could	MD
29633	273	16	have	have	VB
29633	273	17	been	be	VBN
29633	273	18	so	so	RB
29633	273	19	foolish	foolish	JJ
29633	273	20	as	as	IN
29633	273	21	to	to	TO
29633	273	22	assign	assign	VB
29633	273	23	an	an	DT
29633	273	24	interest	interest	NN
29633	273	25	in	in	IN
29633	273	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	273	27	patents	patent	NNS
29633	273	28	to	to	IN
29633	273	29	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	273	30	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	273	31	without	without	IN
29633	273	32	in	in	IN
29633	273	33	some	some	DT
29633	273	34	way	way	NN
29633	273	35	insuring	insure	VBG
29633	273	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	273	37	right	right	NN
29633	273	38	of	of	IN
29633	273	39	consultation	consultation	NN
29633	273	40	about	about	IN
29633	273	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	273	42	disposition	disposition	NN
29633	273	43	.	.	.
29633	274	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	274	2	claims	claim	VBZ
29633	274	3	that	that	IN
29633	274	4	even	even	RB
29633	274	5	in	in	IN
29633	274	6	the	the	DT
29633	274	7	drafting	drafting	NN
29633	274	8	of	of	IN
29633	274	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	274	10	specifications	specification	NNS
29633	274	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	274	12	was	be	VBD
29633	274	13	obliged	oblige	VBN
29633	274	14	to	to	TO
29633	274	15	follow	follow	VB
29633	274	16	die	die	VB
29633	274	17	demands	demand	NNS
29633	274	18	of	of	IN
29633	274	19	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	274	20	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	274	21	,	,	,
29633	274	22	which	which	WDT
29633	274	23	firm	firm	NN
29633	274	24	,	,	,
29633	274	25	believing	believe	VBG
29633	274	26	,	,	,
29633	274	27	"	"	''
29633	274	28	on	on	IN
29633	274	29	the	the	DT
29633	274	30	advice	advice	NN
29633	274	31	of	of	IN
29633	274	32	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	274	33	Hindmarsh	Hindmarsh	NNP
29633	274	34	,	,	,
29633	274	35	the	the	DT
29633	274	36	most	most	RBS
29633	274	37	eminent	eminent	JJ
29633	274	38	patent	patent	NN
29633	274	39	counsel	counsel	NN
29633	274	40	of	of	IN
29633	274	41	the	the	DT
29633	274	42	day,"[49	day,"[49	NN
29633	274	43	]	]	-RRB-
29633	274	44	that	that	IN
29633	274	45	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	274	46	's	's	POS
29633	274	47	patent	patent	NN
29633	274	48	outranked	outrank	VBD
29633	274	49	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	274	50	's	's	POS
29633	274	51	,	,	,
29633	274	52	insisted	insist	VBD
29633	274	53	that	that	IN
29633	274	54	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	274	55	link	link	VB
29633	274	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	274	57	process	process	NN
29633	274	58	to	to	IN
29633	274	59	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	274	60	's	's	POS
29633	274	61	.	.	.
29633	275	1	This	this	DT
29633	275	2	,	,	,
29633	275	3	as	as	RB
29633	275	4	late	late	JJ
29633	275	5	as	as	IN
29633	275	6	1861	1861	CD
29633	275	7	,	,	,
29633	275	8	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	275	9	believed	believe	VBD
29633	275	10	to	to	TO
29633	275	11	be	be	VB
29633	275	12	in	in	IN
29633	275	13	effective	effective	JJ
29633	275	14	operation	operation	NN
29633	275	15	.	.	.
29633	276	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	276	2	50	50	CD
29633	276	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	276	4	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	276	5	later	later	JJ
29633	276	6	repudiation	repudiation	NN
29633	276	7	of	of	IN
29633	276	8	the	the	DT
29633	276	9	process	process	NN
29633	276	10	as	as	IN
29633	276	11	an	an	DT
29633	276	12	absurd	absurd	JJ
29633	276	13	and	and	CC
29633	276	14	impracticable	impracticable	JJ
29633	276	15	patent	patent	NN
29633	276	16	process	process	NN
29633	276	17	"	"	''
29633	276	18	possessing	possess	VBG
29633	276	19	neither	neither	CC
29633	276	20	value	value	NN
29633	276	21	nor	nor	CC
29633	276	22	utility"[51	utility"[51	NNP
29633	276	23	]	]	-RRB-
29633	276	24	may	may	MD
29633	276	25	more	more	RBR
29633	276	26	truly	truly	RB
29633	276	27	represent	represent	VB
29633	276	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	276	29	opinion	opinion	NN
29633	276	30	,	,	,
29633	276	31	especially	especially	RB
29633	276	32	as	as	IN
29633	276	33	,	,	,
29633	276	34	when	when	WRB
29633	276	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	276	36	wrote	write	VBD
29633	276	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	276	38	1861	1861	CD
29633	276	39	comment	comment	NN
29633	276	40	,	,	,
29633	276	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	276	42	still	still	RB
29633	276	43	did	do	VBD
29633	276	44	not	not	RB
29633	276	45	know	know	VB
29633	276	46	of	of	IN
29633	276	47	the	the	DT
29633	276	48	disappearance	disappearance	NN
29633	276	49	of	of	IN
29633	276	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	276	51	patents	patent	NNS
29633	276	52	.	.	.
29633	277	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	277	2	49	49	CD
29633	277	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	277	4	_	_	NNP
29633	277	5	The	the	DT
29633	277	6	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	277	7	_	_	NNP
29633	277	8	,	,	,
29633	277	9	1861	1861	CD
29633	277	10	,	,	,
29633	277	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	277	12	.	.	.
29633	278	1	12	12	CD
29633	278	2	,	,	,
29633	278	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	278	4	189	189	CD
29633	278	5	.	.	.
29633	279	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	279	2	50	50	CD
29633	279	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	279	4	_	_	NNP
29633	279	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	279	6	.	.	.
29633	279	7	_	_	NNP
29633	279	8	,	,	,
29633	279	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	279	10	78	78	CD
29633	279	11	.	.	.
29633	280	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	280	2	51	51	CD
29633	280	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	280	4	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	280	5	,	,	,
29633	280	6	_	_	NNP
29633	280	7	op	op	NN
29633	280	8	.	.	.
29633	281	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	281	2	.	.	.
29633	281	3	_	_	NNP
29633	281	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	281	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	281	6	46	46	CD
29633	281	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	281	8	,	,	,
29633	281	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	281	10	9	9	CD
29633	281	11	.	.	.
29633	282	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	282	2	's	's	POS
29633	282	3	boast[52	boast[52	NN
29633	282	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	282	5	that	that	IN
29633	282	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	282	7	had	have	VBD
29633	282	8	never	never	RB
29633	282	9	been	be	VBN
29633	282	10	into	into	IN
29633	282	11	an	an	DT
29633	282	12	ironworks	ironwork	NNS
29633	282	13	other	other	JJ
29633	282	14	than	than	IN
29633	282	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	282	16	own	own	JJ
29633	282	17	in	in	IN
29633	282	18	Coleford	Coleford	NNP
29633	282	19	is	be	VBZ
29633	282	20	a	a	DT
29633	282	21	clue	clue	NN
29633	282	22	to	to	IN
29633	282	23	the	the	DT
29633	282	24	interpretation	interpretation	NN
29633	282	25	of	of	IN
29633	282	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	282	27	behavior	behavior	NN
29633	282	28	in	in	IN
29633	282	29	general	general	JJ
29633	282	30	and	and	CC
29633	282	31	also	also	RB
29633	282	32	of	of	IN
29633	282	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	282	34	frequent	frequent	JJ
29633	282	35	presumptuous	presumptuous	JJ
29633	282	36	claims	claim	NNS
29633	282	37	.	.	.
29633	283	1	When	when	WRB
29633	283	2	,	,	,
29633	283	3	for	for	IN
29633	283	4	instance	instance	NN
29633	283	5	,	,	,
29633	283	6	the	the	DT
29633	283	7	development	development	NN
29633	283	8	of	of	IN
29633	283	9	the	the	DT
29633	283	10	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	283	11	process	process	NN
29633	283	12	was	be	VBD
29633	283	13	publicized	publicize	VBN
29633	283	14	,	,	,
29633	283	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	283	16	gave	give	VBD
29633	283	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	283	18	opinion[53	opinion[53	NN
29633	283	19	]	]	-RRB-
29633	283	20	that	that	IN
29633	283	21	the	the	DT
29633	283	22	process	process	NN
29633	283	23	was	be	VBD
29633	283	24	a	a	DT
29633	283	25	useless	useless	JJ
29633	283	26	one	one	NN
29633	283	27	and	and	CC
29633	283	28	had	have	VBD
29633	283	29	been	be	VBN
29633	283	30	patented	patent	VBN
29633	283	31	before	before	IN
29633	283	32	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	283	33	"	"	''
29633	283	34	understood	understand	VBD
29633	283	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	283	36	nature	nature	NN
29633	283	37	"	"	''
29633	283	38	;	;	:
29633	283	39	yet	yet	CC
29633	283	40	later[54	later[54	NN
29633	283	41	]	]	-RRB-
29633	283	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	283	43	could	could	MD
29633	283	44	claim	claim	VB
29633	283	45	that	that	IN
29633	283	46	the	the	DT
29633	283	47	process	process	NN
29633	283	48	was	be	VBD
29633	283	49	"	"	``
29633	283	50	in	in	IN
29633	283	51	fact	fact	NN
29633	283	52	,	,	,
29633	283	53	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	283	54	own	own	JJ
29633	283	55	invention	invention	NN
29633	283	56	and	and	CC
29633	283	57	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	283	58	had	have	VBD
29633	283	59	made	make	VBN
29633	283	60	and	and	CC
29633	283	61	sold	sell	VBN
29633	283	62	the	the	DT
29633	283	63	steel	steel	NN
29633	283	64	thus	thus	RB
29633	283	65	produced	produce	VBN
29633	283	66	for	for	IN
29633	283	67	some	some	DT
29633	283	68	years	year	NNS
29633	283	69	previously	previously	RB
29633	283	70	to	to	IN
29633	283	71	the	the	DT
29633	283	72	date	date	NN
29633	283	73	of	of	IN
29633	283	74	Captain	Captain	NNP
29633	283	75	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	283	76	'	'	POS
29633	283	77	patent	patent	NN
29633	283	78	"	"	''
29633	283	79	.	.	.
29633	284	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
29633	284	2	,	,	,
29633	284	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	284	4	claims	claim	VBZ
29633	284	5	to	to	TO
29633	284	6	have	have	VB
29633	284	7	instructed	instruct	VBN
29633	284	8	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	284	9	'	'	POS
29633	284	10	agents	agent	NNS
29633	284	11	in	in	IN
29633	284	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	284	13	operation	operation	NN
29633	284	14	!	!	.
29633	285	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	285	2	may	may	MD
29633	285	3	,	,	,
29633	285	4	at	at	IN
29633	285	5	this	this	DT
29633	285	6	later	later	JJ
29633	285	7	date	date	NN
29633	285	8	,	,	,
29633	285	9	have	have	VBP
29633	285	10	recalled	recall	VBN
29633	285	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	285	12	challenge	challenge	NN
29633	285	13	(	(	-LRB-
29633	285	14	the	the	DT
29633	285	15	first	first	JJ
29633	285	16	of	of	IN
29633	285	17	many	many	JJ
29633	285	18	such	such	JJ
29633	285	19	)	)	-RRB-
29633	285	20	in	in	IN
29633	285	21	which	which	WDT
29633	285	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	285	23	offered	offer	VBD
29633	285	24	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	285	25	'	'	POS
29633	285	26	agent	agent	NN
29633	285	27	in	in	IN
29633	285	28	England	England	NNP
29633	285	29	to	to	TO
29633	285	30	pay	pay	VB
29633	285	31	a	a	DT
29633	285	32	monetary	monetary	JJ
29633	285	33	penalty	penalty	NN
29633	285	34	if	if	IN
29633	285	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	285	36	could	could	MD
29633	285	37	not	not	RB
29633	285	38	show	show	VB
29633	285	39	a	a	DT
29633	285	40	superior	superior	JJ
29633	285	41	method	method	NN
29633	285	42	of	of	IN
29633	285	43	producing	produce	VBG
29633	285	44	"	"	``
29633	285	45	sound	sound	JJ
29633	285	46	serviceable	serviceable	JJ
29633	285	47	cast	cast	VBN
29633	285	48	steel	steel	NN
29633	285	49	from	from	IN
29633	285	50	British	british	JJ
29633	285	51	coke	coke	NNP
29633	285	52	pig	pig	NN
29633	285	53	-	-	HYPH
29633	285	54	iron	iron	NN
29633	285	55	,	,	,
29633	285	56	_	_	NNP
29633	285	57	on	on	IN
29633	285	58	the	the	DT
29633	285	59	stomic	stomic	JJ
29633	285	60	plan	plan	NN
29633	285	61	_	_	NNP
29633	285	62	and	and	CC
29633	285	63	without	without	IN
29633	285	64	any	any	DT
29633	285	65	mixture	mixture	NN
29633	285	66	of	of	IN
29633	285	67	clay	clay	NN
29633	285	68	,	,	,
29633	285	69	oxide	oxide	NN
29633	285	70	of	of	IN
29633	285	71	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	285	72	or	or	CC
29633	285	73	any	any	DT
29633	285	74	of	of	IN
29633	285	75	these	these	DT
29633	285	76	pot	pot	NN
29633	285	77	destroying	destroy	VBG
29633	285	78	ingredients	ingredient	NNS
29633	285	79	.	.	.
29633	286	1	"	"	``
29633	286	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	286	3	55	55	CD
29633	286	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	286	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	286	6	52	52	CD
29633	286	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	286	8	_	_	NNP
29633	286	9	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	286	10	.	.	.
29633	286	11	_	_	NNP
29633	286	12	,	,	,
29633	286	13	p.	p.	NN
29633	286	14	25	25	CD
29633	286	15	.	.	.
29633	287	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	287	2	53	53	CD
29633	287	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	287	4	_	_	NNP
29633	287	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	287	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	287	7	_	_	NNP
29633	287	8	,	,	,
29633	287	9	1857	1857	CD
29633	287	10	,	,	,
29633	287	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	287	12	.	.	.
29633	288	1	27	27	CD
29633	288	2	,	,	,
29633	288	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	288	4	755	755	CD
29633	288	5	.	.	.
29633	289	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	289	2	54	54	CD
29633	289	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	289	4	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	289	5	,	,	,
29633	289	6	_	_	NNP
29633	289	7	op	op	NN
29633	289	8	.	.	.
29633	290	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	290	2	.	.	.
29633	290	3	_	_	NNP
29633	290	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	290	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	290	6	46	46	CD
29633	290	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	290	8	,	,	,
29633	290	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	290	10	28	28	CD
29633	290	11	.	.	.
29633	291	1	The	the	DT
29633	291	2	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	291	3	process	process	NN
29633	291	4	became	become	VBD
29633	291	5	the	the	DT
29633	291	6	"	"	``
29633	291	7	You	You	NNP
29633	291	8	-	-	HYPH
29633	291	9	cheat	cheat	VB
29633	291	10	-	-	HYPH
29633	291	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
29633	291	12	"	"	''
29633	291	13	process	process	NN
29633	291	14	to	to	IN
29633	291	15	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	291	16	(	(	-LRB-
29633	291	17	_	_	NNP
29633	291	18	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	291	19	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	291	20	_	_	NNP
29633	291	21	,	,	,
29633	291	22	1858	1858	CD
29633	291	23	,	,	,
29633	291	24	vol	vol	NNP
29633	291	25	.	.	.
29633	292	1	28	28	CD
29633	292	2	,	,	,
29633	292	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	292	4	34	34	CD
29633	292	5	)	)	-RRB-
29633	292	6	.	.	.
29633	293	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	293	2	55	55	CD
29633	293	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	293	4	_	_	NNP
29633	293	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	293	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	293	7	_	_	NNP
29633	293	8	,	,	,
29633	293	9	1857	1857	CD
29633	293	10	,	,	,
29633	293	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	293	12	.	.	.
29633	294	1	27	27	CD
29633	294	2	,	,	,
29633	294	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	294	4	755	755	CD
29633	294	5	(	(	-LRB-
29633	294	6	italics	italic	NNS
29633	294	7	supplied	supply	VBN
29633	294	8	)	)	-RRB-
29633	294	9	.	.	.
29633	295	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	295	2	was	be	VBD
29633	295	3	David	David	NNP
29633	295	4	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	295	5	(	(	-LRB-
29633	295	6	or	or	CC
29633	295	7	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	295	8	,	,	,
29633	295	9	using	use	VBG
29633	295	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	295	11	brother	brother	NN
29633	295	12	's	's	POS
29633	295	13	name)[56	name)[56	NN
29633	295	14	]	]	-RRB-
29633	295	15	who	who	WP
29633	295	16	accused	accuse	VBD
29633	295	17	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	295	18	,	,	,
29633	295	19	or	or	CC
29633	295	20	rather	rather	RB
29633	295	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	295	22	patent	patent	NN
29633	295	23	agent	agent	NN
29633	295	24	,	,	,
29633	295	25	Carpmael	Carpmael	NNP
29633	295	26	,	,	,
29633	295	27	of	of	IN
29633	295	28	sharp	sharp	JJ
29633	295	29	practice	practice	NN
29633	295	30	in	in	IN
29633	295	31	connection	connection	NN
29633	295	32	with	with	IN
29633	295	33	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	295	34	's	's	POS
29633	295	35	specification	specification	NN
29633	295	36	,	,	,
29633	295	37	an	an	DT
29633	295	38	allegation	allegation	NN
29633	295	39	later	later	RB
29633	295	40	supported	support	VBN
29633	295	41	by	by	IN
29633	295	42	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	295	43	's	's	POS
29633	295	44	first	first	JJ
29633	295	45	patent	patent	NN
29633	295	46	agent	agent	NN
29633	295	47	,	,	,
29633	295	48	Avery	Avery	NNP
29633	295	49	.	.	.
29633	296	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	296	2	57	57	CD
29633	296	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	296	4	The	the	DT
29633	296	5	story	story	NN
29633	296	6	was	be	VBD
29633	296	7	that	that	IN
29633	296	8	for	for	IN
29633	296	9	the	the	DT
29633	296	10	drafting	drafting	NN
29633	296	11	of	of	IN
29633	296	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	296	13	final	final	JJ
29633	296	14	specification	specification	NN
29633	296	15	,	,	,
29633	296	16	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	296	17	,	,	,
29633	296	18	presumably	presumably	RB
29633	296	19	with	with	IN
29633	296	20	the	the	DT
29633	296	21	advice	advice	NN
29633	296	22	of	of	IN
29633	296	23	the	the	DT
29633	296	24	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	296	25	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	296	26	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	296	27	Works	Works	NNP
29633	296	28	,	,	,
29633	296	29	consulted	consult	VBD
29633	296	30	the	the	DT
29633	296	31	same	same	JJ
29633	296	32	Carpmael	Carpmael	NNP
29633	296	33	,	,	,
29633	296	34	as	as	IN
29633	296	35	"	"	``
29633	296	36	the	the	DT
29633	296	37	leading	lead	VBG
29633	296	38	man	man	NN
29633	296	39	"	"	''
29633	296	40	in	in	IN
29633	296	41	the	the	DT
29633	296	42	field	field	NN
29633	296	43	.	.	.
29633	297	1	The	the	DT
29633	297	2	latter	latter	JJ
29633	297	3	advised	advise	VBD
29633	297	4	that	that	IN
29633	297	5	the	the	DT
29633	297	6	provisional	provisional	JJ
29633	297	7	specification	specification	NN
29633	297	8	restricted	restrict	VBD
29633	297	9	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	297	10	to	to	IN
29633	297	11	the	the	DT
29633	297	12	application	application	NN
29633	297	13	of	of	IN
29633	297	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	297	15	method	method	NN
29633	297	16	to	to	IN
29633	297	17	iron	iron	NN
29633	297	18	flowing	flow	VBG
29633	297	19	in	in	IN
29633	297	20	a	a	DT
29633	297	21	channel	channel	NN
29633	297	22	or	or	CC
29633	297	23	gutter	gutter	NN
29633	297	24	from	from	IN
29633	297	25	the	the	DT
29633	297	26	blast	blast	NN
29633	297	27	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	297	28	,	,	,
29633	297	29	and	and	CC
29633	297	30	so	so	RB
29633	297	31	prevented	prevent	VBD
29633	297	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	297	33	from	from	IN
29633	297	34	applying	apply	VBG
29633	297	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	297	36	aeration	aeration	NN
29633	297	37	principle	principle	NN
29633	297	38	in	in	IN
29633	297	39	any	any	DT
29633	297	40	kind	kind	NN
29633	297	41	of	of	IN
29633	297	42	receptacle	receptacle	NN
29633	297	43	.	.	.
29633	298	1	In	in	IN
29633	298	2	effect	effect	NN
29633	298	3	,	,	,
29633	298	4	Carpmael	Carpmael	NNP
29633	298	5	was	be	VBD
29633	298	6	acting	act	VBG
29633	298	7	unprofessionally	unprofessionally	RB
29633	298	8	by	by	IN
29633	298	9	giving	give	VBG
29633	298	10	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	298	11	the	the	DT
29633	298	12	prior	prior	JJ
29633	298	13	claim	claim	NN
29633	298	14	to	to	IN
29633	298	15	the	the	DT
29633	298	16	use	use	NN
29633	298	17	of	of	IN
29633	298	18	a	a	DT
29633	298	19	receptacle	receptacle	NN
29633	298	20	.	.	.
29633	299	1	According	accord	VBG
29633	299	2	to	to	IN
29633	299	3	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	299	4	,	,	,
29633	299	5	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	299	6	had	have	VBD
29633	299	7	in	in	IN
29633	299	8	fact	fact	NN
29633	299	9	"	"	``
29633	299	10	actually	actually	RB
29633	299	11	and	and	CC
29633	299	12	publicly	publicly	RB
29633	299	13	proved	prove	VBD
29633	299	14	"	"	''
29633	299	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	299	16	process	process	NN
29633	299	17	in	in	IN
29633	299	18	a	a	DT
29633	299	19	receptacle	receptacle	NN
29633	299	20	and	and	CC
29633	299	21	not	not	RB
29633	299	22	in	in	IN
29633	299	23	a	a	DT
29633	299	24	gutter	gutter	NN
29633	299	25	,	,	,
29633	299	26	so	so	IN
29633	299	27	that	that	IN
29633	299	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	299	29	claim	claim	NN
29633	299	30	to	to	IN
29633	299	31	priority	priority	NN
29633	299	32	could	could	MD
29633	299	33	be	be	VB
29633	299	34	maintained	maintain	VBN
29633	299	35	on	on	IN
29633	299	36	the	the	DT
29633	299	37	basis	basis	NN
29633	299	38	of	of	IN
29633	299	39	the	the	DT
29633	299	40	provisional	provisional	JJ
29633	299	41	specification	specification	NN
29633	299	42	.	.	.
29633	300	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	300	2	56	56	CD
29633	300	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	300	4	See	see	VB
29633	300	5	footnote	footnote	NN
29633	300	6	22	22	CD
29633	300	7	.	.	.
29633	301	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	301	2	57	57	CD
29633	301	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	301	4	_	_	NNP
29633	301	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	301	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	301	7	_	_	NNP
29633	301	8	,	,	,
29633	301	9	1856	1856	CD
29633	301	10	,	,	,
29633	301	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	301	12	.	.	.
29633	302	1	26	26	CD
29633	302	2	,	,	,
29633	302	3	pp	pp	NNP
29633	302	4	.	.	.
29633	303	1	583	583	CD
29633	303	2	,	,	,
29633	303	3	631	631	CD
29633	303	4	.	.	.
29633	304	1	This	this	DT
29633	304	2	,	,	,
29633	304	3	like	like	IN
29633	304	4	other	other	JJ
29633	304	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	304	6	allegations	allegation	NNS
29633	304	7	,	,	,
29633	304	8	was	be	VBD
29633	304	9	ignored	ignore	VBN
29633	304	10	by	by	IN
29633	304	11	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	304	12	,	,	,
29633	304	13	and	and	CC
29633	304	14	probably	probably	RB
29633	304	15	with	with	IN
29633	304	16	good	good	JJ
29633	304	17	reason	reason	NN
29633	304	18	.	.	.
29633	305	1	At	at	IN
29633	305	2	any	any	DT
29633	305	3	rate	rate	NN
29633	305	4	,	,	,
29633	305	5	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	305	6	's	's	POS
29633	305	7	American	american	JJ
29633	305	8	patent	patent	NN
29633	305	9	is	be	VBZ
29633	305	10	in	in	IN
29633	305	11	terms	term	NNS
29633	305	12	similar	similar	JJ
29633	305	13	to	to	IN
29633	305	14	those	those	DT
29633	305	15	of	of	IN
29633	305	16	the	the	DT
29633	305	17	British	british	JJ
29633	305	18	specification	specification	NN
29633	305	19	;	;	:
29633	305	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	305	21	or	or	CC
29633	305	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	305	23	advisers	adviser	NNS
29633	305	24	seem	seem	VBP
29633	305	25	to	to	TO
29633	305	26	have	have	VB
29633	305	27	attached	attach	VBN
29633	305	28	no	no	DT
29633	305	29	significance	significance	NN
29633	305	30	to	to	IN
29633	305	31	the	the	DT
29633	305	32	distinction	distinction	NN
29633	305	33	between	between	IN
29633	305	34	a	a	DT
29633	305	35	gutter	gutter	NN
29633	305	36	and	and	CC
29633	305	37	a	a	DT
29633	305	38	receptacle	receptacle	NN
29633	305	39	.	.	.
29633	306	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	306	2	's	's	POS
29633	306	3	claim	claim	NN
29633	306	4	to	to	TO
29633	306	5	have	have	VB
29633	306	6	afforded	afford	VBN
29633	306	7	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	306	8	the	the	DT
29633	306	9	means	mean	NNS
29633	306	10	of	of	IN
29633	306	11	making	make	VBG
29633	306	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	306	13	own	own	JJ
29633	306	14	process	process	NN
29633	306	15	useful	useful	JJ
29633	306	16	is	be	VBZ
29633	306	17	still	still	RB
29633	306	18	subject	subject	JJ
29633	306	19	to	to	IN
29633	306	20	debate	debate	NN
29633	306	21	.	.	.
29633	307	1	Unfortunately	unfortunately	RB
29633	307	2	,	,	,
29633	307	3	documentation	documentation	NN
29633	307	4	of	of	IN
29633	307	5	the	the	DT
29633	307	6	case	case	NN
29633	307	7	is	be	VBZ
29633	307	8	almost	almost	RB
29633	307	9	wholly	wholly	RB
29633	307	10	one	one	CD
29633	307	11	sided	side	VBD
29633	307	12	,	,	,
29633	307	13	since	since	IN
29633	307	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	307	15	biggest	big	JJS
29633	307	16	publicizer	publicizer	NN
29633	307	17	was	be	VBD
29633	307	18	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	307	19	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	307	20	.	.	.
29633	308	1	An	an	DT
29633	308	2	occasional	occasional	JJ
29633	308	3	editorial	editorial	NN
29633	308	4	in	in	IN
29633	308	5	the	the	DT
29633	308	6	technical	technical	JJ
29633	308	7	press	press	NN
29633	308	8	and	and	CC
29633	308	9	a	a	DT
29633	308	10	few	few	JJ
29633	308	11	replies	reply	NNS
29633	308	12	to	to	IN
29633	308	13	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	308	14	's	's	POS
29633	308	15	"	"	``
29633	308	16	lucubrations	lucubration	NNS
29633	308	17	"	"	''
29633	308	18	are	be	VBP
29633	308	19	all	all	PDT
29633	308	20	the	the	DT
29633	308	21	material	material	NN
29633	308	22	which	which	WDT
29633	308	23	exists	exist	VBZ
29633	308	24	,	,	,
29633	308	25	apart	apart	RB
29633	308	26	from	from	IN
29633	308	27	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	308	28	's	's	POS
29633	308	29	own	own	JJ
29633	308	30	story	story	NN
29633	308	31	.	.	.
29633	309	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	309	2	and	and	CC
29633	309	3	at	at	RB
29633	309	4	least	least	JJS
29633	309	5	five	five	CD
29633	309	6	other	other	JJ
29633	309	7	men	man	NNS
29633	309	8	patented	patent	VBD
29633	309	9	the	the	DT
29633	309	10	use	use	NN
29633	309	11	of	of	IN
29633	309	12	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	309	13	in	in	IN
29633	309	14	steel	steel	NN
29633	309	15	making	make	VBG
29633	309	16	in	in	IN
29633	309	17	1856	1856	CD
29633	309	18	;	;	:
29633	309	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	309	20	own	own	JJ
29633	309	21	provisional	provisional	JJ
29633	309	22	specification	specification	NN
29633	309	23	was	be	VBD
29633	309	24	filed	file	VBN
29633	309	25	within	within	IN
29633	309	26	a	a	DT
29633	309	27	month	month	NN
29633	309	28	of	of	IN
29633	309	29	the	the	DT
29633	309	30	publication	publication	NN
29633	309	31	of	of	IN
29633	309	32	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	309	33	's	's	POS
29633	309	34	British	British	NNP
29633	309	35	Association	Association	NNP
29633	309	36	address	address	NN
29633	309	37	in	in	IN
29633	309	38	August	August	NNP
29633	309	39	1856	1856	CD
29633	309	40	.	.	.
29633	310	1	So	so	CC
29633	310	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	310	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	310	4	strange	strange	JJ
29633	310	5	that	that	IN
29633	310	6	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	310	7	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	310	8	did	do	VBD
29633	310	9	not	not	RB
29633	310	10	until	until	IN
29633	310	11	more	more	JJR
29633	310	12	than	than	IN
29633	310	13	a	a	DT
29633	310	14	year	year	NN
29633	310	15	later	later	RB
29633	310	16	join	join	VBP
29633	310	17	in	in	IN
29633	310	18	the	the	DT
29633	310	19	controversy	controversy	NN
29633	310	20	which	which	WDT
29633	310	21	followed	follow	VBD
29633	310	22	that	that	DT
29633	310	23	address	address	NN
29633	310	24	.	.	.
29633	311	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	311	2	58	58	CD
29633	311	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	311	4	In	in	IN
29633	311	5	one	one	CD
29633	311	6	of	of	IN
29633	311	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	311	8	early	early	JJ
29633	311	9	letters	letter	NNS
29633	311	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	311	11	claims	claim	VBZ
29633	311	12	to	to	TO
29633	311	13	have	have	VB
29633	311	14	made	make	VBN
29633	311	15	of	of	IN
29633	311	16	"	"	``
29633	311	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	311	18	"	"	``
29633	311	19	steel	steel	NN
29633	311	20	a	a	DT
29633	311	21	bridge	bridge	NN
29633	311	22	rail	rail	NN
29633	311	23	of	of	IN
29633	311	24	750	750	CD
29633	311	25	pounds	pound	NNS
29633	311	26	weight	weight	NN
29633	311	27	;	;	:
29633	311	28	although	although	IN
29633	311	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	311	30	brother	brother	NN
29633	311	31	insists	insist	VBZ
29633	311	32	that	that	IN
29633	311	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	311	34	saw	see	VBD
29633	311	35	the	the	DT
29633	311	36	same	same	JJ
29633	311	37	rail	rail	NN
29633	311	38	in	in	IN
29633	311	39	the	the	DT
29633	311	40	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	311	41	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	311	42	offices	office	NNS
29633	311	43	in	in	IN
29633	311	44	London	London	NNP
29633	311	45	in	in	IN
29633	311	46	the	the	DT
29633	311	47	spring	spring	NN
29633	311	48	of	of	IN
29633	311	49	1857	1857	CD
29633	311	50	,	,	,
29633	311	51	when	when	WRB
29633	311	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	311	53	was	be	VBD
29633	311	54	presented	present	VBN
29633	311	55	as	as	IN
29633	311	56	a	a	DT
29633	311	57	specimen	speciman	NNS
29633	311	58	of	of	IN
29633	311	59	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	311	60	steel	steel	NN
29633	311	61	!	!	.
29633	312	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	312	2	59	59	CD
29633	312	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	312	4	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	312	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	312	6	's	's	POS
29633	312	7	indignant	indignant	JJ
29633	312	8	"	"	``
29633	312	9	advertisement	advertisement	NN
29633	312	10	"	"	''
29633	312	11	of	of	IN
29633	312	12	January	January	NNP
29633	312	13	5	5	CD
29633	312	14	,	,	,
29633	312	15	1858,[60	1858,[60	CD
29633	312	16	]	]	-RRB-
29633	312	17	reiterating	reiterate	VBG
29633	312	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	312	19	parentage	parentage	NN
29633	312	20	of	of	IN
29633	312	21	this	this	DT
29633	312	22	sample	sample	NN
29633	312	23	,	,	,
29633	312	24	also	also	RB
29633	312	25	claimed	claim	VBD
29633	312	26	a	a	DT
29633	312	27	double	double	RB
29633	312	28	-	-	HYPH
29633	312	29	headed	head	VBN
29633	312	30	steel	steel	NN
29633	312	31	rail	rail	NN
29633	312	32	"	"	''
29633	312	33	made	make	VBN
29633	312	34	by	by	IN
29633	312	35	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	312	36	under	under	IN
29633	312	37	another	another	DT
29633	312	38	of	of	IN
29633	312	39	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	312	40	patent	patent	NN
29633	312	41	processes	process	NNS
29633	312	42	,	,	,
29633	312	43	"	"	''
29633	312	44	and	and	CC
29633	312	45	sent	send	VBN
29633	312	46	to	to	IN
29633	312	47	Derby	Derby	NNP
29633	312	48	to	to	TO
29633	312	49	be	be	VB
29633	312	50	laid	lay	VBN
29633	312	51	down	down	RP
29633	312	52	there	there	RB
29633	312	53	to	to	TO
29633	312	54	be	be	VB
29633	312	55	"	"	``
29633	312	56	subjected	subject	VBN
29633	312	57	to	to	IN
29633	312	58	intense	intense	JJ
29633	312	59	vertricular	vertricular	JJ
29633	312	60	triturations	trituration	NNS
29633	312	61	.	.	.
29633	312	62	"	"	''
29633	313	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	313	2	's	's	POS
29633	313	3	description	description	NN
29633	313	4	of	of	IN
29633	313	5	the	the	DT
29633	313	6	preparation	preparation	NN
29633	313	7	of	of	IN
29633	313	8	this	this	DT
29633	313	9	ingot[61	ingot[61	NN
29633	313	10	]	]	-RRB-
29633	313	11	shows	show	VBZ
29633	313	12	that	that	IN
29633	313	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	313	14	was	be	VBD
29633	313	15	derived	derive	VBN
29633	313	16	from	from	IN
29633	313	17	"	"	``
29633	313	18	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	313	19	scrap	scrap	NN
29633	313	20	"	"	''
29633	313	21	made	make	VBN
29633	313	22	by	by	IN
29633	313	23	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	313	24	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	313	25	in	in	IN
29633	313	26	the	the	DT
29633	313	27	first	first	JJ
29633	313	28	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
29633	313	29	attempts	attempt	NNS
29633	313	30	of	of	IN
29633	313	31	that	that	DT
29633	313	32	firm	firm	NN
29633	313	33	to	to	TO
29633	313	34	simulate	simulate	VB
29633	313	35	the	the	DT
29633	313	36	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	313	37	process	process	NN
29633	313	38	.	.	.
29633	314	1	This	this	DT
29633	314	2	scrap	scrap	NN
29633	314	3	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	314	4	had	have	VBD
29633	314	5	remelted	remelte	VBN
29633	314	6	in	in	IN
29633	314	7	pots	pot	NNS
29633	314	8	with	with	IN
29633	314	9	spiegel	spiegel	NNP
29633	314	10	in	in	IN
29633	314	11	the	the	DT
29633	314	12	proportions	proportion	NNS
29633	314	13	of	of	IN
29633	314	14	44	44	CD
29633	314	15	pounds	pound	NNS
29633	314	16	of	of	IN
29633	314	17	scrap	scrap	NN
29633	314	18	to	to	IN
29633	314	19	3	3	CD
29633	314	20	of	of	IN
29633	314	21	melted	melt	VBN
29633	314	22	spiegel	spiegel	NN
29633	314	23	.	.	.
29633	315	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	315	2	was	be	VBD
29633	315	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	315	4	claim	claim	NN
29633	315	5	that	that	IN
29633	315	6	the	the	DT
29633	315	7	rail	rail	NN
29633	315	8	was	be	VBD
29633	315	9	rolled	roll	VBN
29633	315	10	direct	direct	RB
29633	315	11	from	from	IN
29633	315	12	the	the	DT
29633	315	13	ingot	ingot	NN
29633	315	14	,	,	,
29633	315	15	something	something	NN
29633	315	16	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	315	17	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	315	18	could	could	MD
29633	315	19	not	not	RB
29633	315	20	do	do	VB
29633	315	21	at	at	IN
29633	315	22	that	that	DT
29633	315	23	time	time	NN
29633	315	24	.	.	.
29633	316	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	316	2	58	58	CD
29633	316	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	316	4	October	October	NNP
29633	316	5	17	17	CD
29633	316	6	,	,	,
29633	316	7	1857	1857	CD
29633	316	8	,	,	,
29633	316	9	writing	write	VBG
29633	316	10	as	as	IN
29633	316	11	"	"	``
29633	316	12	Sideros	Sideros	NNP
29633	316	13	"	"	''
29633	316	14	(	(	-LRB-
29633	316	15	_	_	NNP
29633	316	16	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	316	17	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	316	18	_	_	NNP
29633	316	19	,	,	,
29633	316	20	1857	1857	CD
29633	316	21	,	,	,
29633	316	22	vol	vol	NNP
29633	316	23	.	.	.
29633	317	1	27	27	CD
29633	317	2	,	,	,
29633	317	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	317	4	723	723	CD
29633	317	5	)	)	-RRB-
29633	317	6	.	.	.
29633	318	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	318	2	59	59	CD
29633	318	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	318	4	_	_	NNP
29633	318	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	318	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	318	7	_	_	NNP
29633	318	8	,	,	,
29633	318	9	1857	1857	CD
29633	318	10	,	,	,
29633	318	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	318	12	.	.	.
29633	319	1	27	27	CD
29633	319	2	,	,	,
29633	319	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	319	4	871	871	CD
29633	319	5	,	,	,
29633	319	6	and	and	CC
29633	319	7	1858	1858	CD
29633	319	8	,	,	,
29633	319	9	vol	vol	NNP
29633	319	10	.	.	.
29633	320	1	28	28	CD
29633	320	2	,	,	,
29633	320	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	320	4	12	12	CD
29633	320	5	.	.	.
29633	321	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	321	2	60	60	CD
29633	321	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	321	4	_	_	NNP
29633	321	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	321	6	.	.	.
29633	321	7	_	_	NNP
29633	321	8	(	(	-LRB-
29633	321	9	1858	1858	CD
29633	321	10	)	)	-RRB-
29633	321	11	,	,	,
29633	321	12	p.	p.	NN
29633	321	13	34	34	CD
29633	321	14	.	.	.
29633	322	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	322	2	61	61	CD
29633	322	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	322	4	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	322	5	,	,	,
29633	322	6	_	_	NNP
29633	322	7	op	op	NN
29633	322	8	.	.	.
29633	323	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	323	2	.	.	.
29633	323	3	_	_	NNP
29633	323	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	323	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	323	6	46	46	CD
29633	323	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	323	8	,	,	,
29633	323	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	323	10	12	12	CD
29633	323	11	.	.	.
29633	324	1	The	the	DT
29633	324	2	phrase	phrase	NN
29633	324	3	quoted	quote	VBN
29633	324	4	is	be	VBZ
29633	324	5	typical	typical	JJ
29633	324	6	of	of	IN
29633	324	7	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	324	8	's	's	POS
29633	324	9	style	style	NN
29633	324	10	.	.	.
29633	325	1	This	this	DT
29633	325	2	was	be	VBD
29633	325	3	the	the	DT
29633	325	4	beginning	beginning	NN
29633	325	5	of	of	IN
29633	325	6	a	a	DT
29633	325	7	series	series	NN
29633	325	8	of	of	IN
29633	325	9	claims	claim	NNS
29633	325	10	by	by	IN
29633	325	11	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	325	12	as	as	IN
29633	325	13	to	to	IN
29633	325	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	325	15	essential	essential	JJ
29633	325	16	contributions	contribution	NNS
29633	325	17	to	to	IN
29633	325	18	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	325	19	's	's	POS
29633	325	20	invention	invention	NN
29633	325	21	.	.	.
29633	326	1	The	the	DT
29633	326	2	silence	silence	NN
29633	326	3	of	of	IN
29633	326	4	the	the	DT
29633	326	5	latter	latter	JJ
29633	326	6	during	during	IN
29633	326	7	this	this	DT
29633	326	8	period	period	NN
29633	326	9	is	be	VBZ
29633	326	10	impressive	impressive	JJ
29633	326	11	,	,	,
29633	326	12	for	for	IN
29633	326	13	according	accord	VBG
29633	326	14	to	to	IN
29633	326	15	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	326	16	's	's	POS
29633	326	17	own	own	JJ
29633	326	18	account[62	account[62	NN
29633	326	19	]	]	-RRB-
29633	326	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	326	21	British	British	NNP
29633	326	22	Association	Association	NNP
29633	326	23	address	address	NN
29633	326	24	was	be	VBD
29633	326	25	premature	premature	JJ
29633	326	26	,	,	,
29633	326	27	and	and	CC
29633	326	28	although	although	IN
29633	326	29	the	the	DT
29633	326	30	sale	sale	NN
29633	326	31	of	of	IN
29633	326	32	licenses	license	NNS
29633	326	33	actually	actually	RB
29633	326	34	provided	provide	VBD
29633	326	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	326	36	with	with	IN
29633	326	37	working	work	VBG
29633	326	38	funds	fund	NNS
29633	326	39	,	,	,
29633	326	40	the	the	DT
29633	326	41	impatience	impatience	NN
29633	326	42	of	of	IN
29633	326	43	those	those	DT
29633	326	44	experimenting	experiment	VBG
29633	326	45	with	with	IN
29633	326	46	the	the	DT
29633	326	47	process	process	NN
29633	326	48	and	and	CC
29633	326	49	the	the	DT
29633	326	50	flood	flood	NN
29633	326	51	of	of	IN
29633	326	52	competing	compete	VBG
29633	326	53	"	"	``
29633	326	54	inventions	invention	NNS
29633	326	55	"	"	''
29633	326	56	all	all	DT
29633	326	57	embarrassed	embarrass	VBD
29633	326	58	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	326	59	at	at	IN
29633	326	60	the	the	DT
29633	326	61	most	most	RBS
29633	326	62	critical	critical	JJ
29633	326	63	stage	stage	NN
29633	326	64	of	of	IN
29633	326	65	this	this	DT
29633	326	66	development	development	NN
29633	326	67	of	of	IN
29633	326	68	the	the	DT
29633	326	69	process	process	NN
29633	326	70	:	:	:
29633	326	71	"	"	``
29633	326	72	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	326	73	was	be	VBD
29633	326	74	,	,	,
29633	326	75	however	however	RB
29633	326	76	,	,	,
29633	326	77	no	no	DT
29633	326	78	use	use	NN
29633	326	79	for	for	IN
29633	326	80	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	326	81	to	to	TO
29633	326	82	argue	argue	VB
29633	326	83	the	the	DT
29633	326	84	matter	matter	NN
29633	326	85	in	in	IN
29633	326	86	the	the	DT
29633	326	87	press	press	NN
29633	326	88	.	.	.
29633	327	1	All	all	DT
29633	327	2	that	that	WDT
29633	327	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	327	4	could	could	MD
29633	327	5	say	say	VB
29633	327	6	would	would	MD
29633	327	7	be	be	VB
29633	327	8	mere	mere	JJ
29633	327	9	talk	talk	NN
29633	327	10	and	and	CC
29633	327	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	327	12	felt	feel	VBD
29633	327	13	that	that	IN
29633	327	14	action	action	NN
29633	327	15	was	be	VBD
29633	327	16	necessary	necessary	JJ
29633	327	17	,	,	,
29633	327	18	and	and	CC
29633	327	19	not	not	RB
29633	327	20	words	word	NNS
29633	327	21	.	.	.
29633	328	1	"	"	``
29633	328	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	328	3	63	63	CD
29633	328	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	328	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	328	6	62	62	CD
29633	328	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	328	8	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	328	9	,	,	,
29633	328	10	_	_	NNP
29633	328	11	op	op	NN
29633	328	12	.	.	.
29633	329	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	329	2	.	.	.
29633	329	3	_	_	NNP
29633	329	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	329	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	329	6	7	7	CD
29633	329	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	329	8	,	,	,
29633	329	9	pp	pp	NNP
29633	329	10	.	.	.
29633	330	1	161	161	CD
29633	330	2	ff	ff	NN
29633	330	3	.	.	.
29633	331	1	and	and	CC
29633	331	2	256	256	CD
29633	331	3	ff	ff	NNS
29633	331	4	.	.	.
29633	332	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	332	2	63	63	CD
29633	332	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	332	4	_	_	NNP
29633	332	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	332	6	.	.	.
29633	332	7	_	_	NNP
29633	332	8	,	,	,
29633	332	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	332	10	171	171	CD
29633	332	11	.	.	.
29633	333	1	Action	action	NN
29633	333	2	took	take	VBD
29633	333	3	the	the	DT
29633	333	4	form	form	NN
29633	333	5	of	of	IN
29633	333	6	continued	continued	JJ
29633	333	7	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	333	8	and	and	CC
29633	333	9	,	,	,
29633	333	10	by	by	IN
29633	333	11	the	the	DT
29633	333	12	end	end	NN
29633	333	13	of	of	IN
29633	333	14	1857	1857	CD
29633	333	15	,	,	,
29633	333	16	a	a	DT
29633	333	17	decision	decision	NN
29633	333	18	to	to	TO
29633	333	19	build	build	VB
29633	333	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	333	21	own	own	JJ
29633	333	22	plant	plant	NN
29633	333	23	at	at	IN
29633	333	24	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	333	25	.	.	.
29633	334	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	334	2	64	64	CD
29633	334	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	334	4	An	an	DT
29633	334	5	important	important	JJ
29633	334	6	collateral	collateral	JJ
29633	334	7	development	development	NN
29633	334	8	resulted	result	VBD
29633	334	9	from	from	IN
29633	334	10	the	the	DT
29633	334	11	visit	visit	NN
29633	334	12	to	to	IN
29633	334	13	London	London	NNP
29633	334	14	in	in	IN
29633	334	15	May	May	NNP
29633	334	16	1857	1857	CD
29633	334	17	of	of	IN
29633	334	18	G.	G.	NNP
29633	334	19	F.	F.	NNP
29633	334	20	Goransson	Goransson	NNP
29633	334	21	of	of	IN
29633	334	22	Gefle	Gefle	NNP
29633	334	23	,	,	,
29633	334	24	Sweden	Sweden	NNP
29633	334	25	.	.	.
29633	335	1	Using	use	VBG
29633	335	2	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	335	3	equipment	equipment	NN
29633	335	4	,	,	,
29633	335	5	Goransson	Goransson	NNP
29633	335	6	began	begin	VBD
29633	335	7	trials	trial	NNS
29633	335	8	of	of	IN
29633	335	9	the	the	DT
29633	335	10	process	process	NN
29633	335	11	in	in	IN
29633	335	12	November	November	NNP
29633	335	13	1857	1857	CD
29633	335	14	and	and	CC
29633	335	15	by	by	IN
29633	335	16	October	October	NNP
29633	335	17	1858	1858	CD
29633	335	18	was	be	VBD
29633	335	19	able	able	JJ
29633	335	20	to	to	TO
29633	335	21	report	report	VB
29633	335	22	:	:	:
29633	335	23	"	"	``
29633	335	24	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	335	25	firm	firm	NN
29633	335	26	has	have	VBZ
29633	335	27	now	now	RB
29633	335	28	entirely	entirely	RB
29633	335	29	given	give	VBN
29633	335	30	up	up	RP
29633	335	31	the	the	DT
29633	335	32	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	335	33	of	of	IN
29633	335	34	bar	bar	NN
29633	335	35	iron	iron	NN
29633	335	36	,	,	,
29633	335	37	and	and	CC
29633	335	38	our	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	335	39	blast	blast	NN
29633	335	40	furnaces	furnace	NNS
29633	335	41	and	and	CC
29633	335	42	tilt	tilt	NN
29633	335	43	mills	mill	NNS
29633	335	44	are	be	VBP
29633	335	45	now	now	RB
29633	335	46	wholly	wholly	RB
29633	335	47	employed	employ	VBN
29633	335	48	in	in	IN
29633	335	49	making	make	VBG
29633	335	50	steel	steel	NN
29633	335	51	by	by	IN
29633	335	52	the	the	DT
29633	335	53	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	335	54	process	process	NN
29633	335	55	,	,	,
29633	335	56	which	which	WDT
29633	335	57	may	may	MD
29633	335	58	,	,	,
29633	335	59	therefore	therefore	RB
29633	335	60	,	,	,
29633	335	61	be	be	VB
29633	335	62	now	now	RB
29633	335	63	considered	consider	VBN
29633	335	64	an	an	DT
29633	335	65	accomplished	accomplished	JJ
29633	335	66	commercial	commercial	JJ
29633	335	67	fact	fact	NN
29633	335	68	.	.	.
29633	336	1	"	"	``
29633	336	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	336	3	65	65	CD
29633	336	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	336	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	336	6	64	64	CD
29633	336	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	336	8	This	this	DT
29633	336	9	enterprise	enterprise	NN
29633	336	10	,	,	,
29633	336	11	started	start	VBD
29633	336	12	in	in	IN
29633	336	13	conjunction	conjunction	NN
29633	336	14	with	with	IN
29633	336	15	Galloway	Galloway	NNP
29633	336	16	's	's	POS
29633	336	17	of	of	IN
29633	336	18	Manchester	Manchester	NNP
29633	336	19	,	,	,
29633	336	20	one	one	CD
29633	336	21	of	of	IN
29633	336	22	the	the	DT
29633	336	23	firms	firm	NNS
29633	336	24	licensed	license	VBN
29633	336	25	by	by	IN
29633	336	26	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	336	27	to	to	TO
29633	336	28	make	make	VB
29633	336	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	336	30	equipment	equipment	NN
29633	336	31	,	,	,
29633	336	32	was	be	VBD
29633	336	33	under	under	IN
29633	336	34	way	way	NN
29633	336	35	by	by	IN
29633	336	36	April	April	NNP
29633	336	37	1858	1858	CD
29633	336	38	(	(	-LRB-
29633	336	39	see	see	VB
29633	336	40	_	_	NNP
29633	336	41	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	336	42	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	336	43	_	_	NNP
29633	336	44	,	,	,
29633	336	45	1858	1858	CD
29633	336	46	,	,	,
29633	336	47	vol	vol	NNP
29633	336	48	.	.	.
29633	337	1	28	28	CD
29633	337	2	,	,	,
29633	337	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	337	4	259	259	CD
29633	337	5	)	)	-RRB-
29633	337	6	.	.	.
29633	338	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	338	2	65	65	CD
29633	338	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	338	4	_	_	NNP
29633	338	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	338	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	338	7	_	_	NNP
29633	338	8	,	,	,
29633	338	9	1858	1858	CD
29633	338	10	,	,	,
29633	338	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	338	12	.	.	.
29633	339	1	28	28	CD
29633	339	2	,	,	,
29633	339	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	339	4	696	696	CD
29633	339	5	.	.	.
29633	340	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	340	2	commented	comment	VBD
29633	340	3	(	(	-LRB-
29633	340	4	p.	p.	NN
29633	340	5	713	713	CD
29633	340	6	)	)	-RRB-
29633	340	7	that	that	IN
29633	340	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	340	9	had	have	VBD
29633	340	10	done	do	VBN
29633	340	11	the	the	DT
29633	340	12	same	same	JJ
29633	340	13	thing	thing	NN
29633	340	14	"	"	``
29633	340	15	eighteen	eighteen	CD
29633	340	16	months	month	NNS
29633	340	17	ago	ago	RB
29633	340	18	.	.	.
29633	340	19	"	"	''
29633	341	1	Goransson	Goransson	NNP
29633	341	2	was	be	VBD
29633	341	3	later	later	RB
29633	341	4	to	to	TO
29633	341	5	claim	claim	VB
29633	341	6	considerable	considerable	JJ
29633	341	7	improvements	improvement	NNS
29633	341	8	on	on	IN
29633	341	9	the	the	DT
29633	341	10	method	method	NN
29633	341	11	of	of	IN
29633	341	12	introducing	introduce	VBG
29633	341	13	the	the	DT
29633	341	14	blast	blast	NN
29633	341	15	,	,	,
29633	341	16	and	and	CC
29633	341	17	,	,	,
29633	341	18	in	in	IN
29633	341	19	consequence	consequence	NNP
29633	341	20	,	,	,
29633	341	21	the	the	DT
29633	341	22	first	first	JJ
29633	341	23	effective	effective	JJ
29633	341	24	demonstration	demonstration	NN
29633	341	25	of	of	IN
29633	341	26	the	the	DT
29633	341	27	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	341	28	method[66]--this	method[66]--this	NNP
29633	341	29	at	at	IN
29633	341	30	a	a	DT
29633	341	31	time	time	NN
29633	341	32	when	when	WRB
29633	341	33	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	341	34	was	be	VBD
29633	341	35	still	still	RB
29633	341	36	remelting	remelte	VBG
29633	341	37	the	the	DT
29633	341	38	product	product	NN
29633	341	39	of	of	IN
29633	341	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	341	41	converter	converter	NN
29633	341	42	in	in	IN
29633	341	43	crucibles	crucible	NNS
29633	341	44	,	,	,
29633	341	45	after	after	IN
29633	341	46	granulating	granulate	VBG
29633	341	47	the	the	DT
29633	341	48	steel	steel	NN
29633	341	49	in	in	IN
29633	341	50	water	water	NN
29633	341	51	.	.	.
29633	342	1	If	if	IN
29633	342	2	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	342	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	342	4	to	to	TO
29633	342	5	be	be	VB
29633	342	6	believed	believe	VBN
29633	342	7	,	,	,
29633	342	8	this	this	DT
29633	342	9	success	success	NN
29633	342	10	of	of	IN
29633	342	11	Goransson	Goransson	NNP
29633	342	12	's	's	POS
29633	342	13	was	be	VBD
29633	342	14	wholly	wholly	RB
29633	342	15	due	due	JJ
29633	342	16	to	to	IN
29633	342	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	342	18	ore	ore	NN
29633	342	19	being	be	VBG
29633	342	20	"	"	``
29633	342	21	totally	totally	RB
29633	342	22	free	free	JJ
29633	342	23	from	from	IN
29633	342	24	phosphorous	phosphorous	JJ
29633	342	25	and	and	CC
29633	342	26	sulphur	sulphur	NNP
29633	342	27	.	.	.
29633	343	1	"	"	``
29633	343	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	343	3	67	67	CD
29633	343	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	343	5	However	however	RB
29633	343	6	,	,	,
29633	343	7	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	343	8	's	's	POS
29633	343	9	own	own	JJ
29633	343	10	progress	progress	NN
29633	343	11	was	be	VBD
29633	343	12	substantial	substantial	JJ
29633	343	13	,	,	,
29633	343	14	for	for	IN
29633	343	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	343	16	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	343	17	works	work	NNS
29633	343	18	were	be	VBD
29633	343	19	reported	report	VBN
29633	343	20	as	as	IN
29633	343	21	being	be	VBG
29633	343	22	in	in	IN
29633	343	23	active	active	JJ
29633	343	24	operation	operation	NN
29633	343	25	in	in	IN
29633	343	26	April	April	NNP
29633	343	27	1859	1859	CD
29633	343	28	,	,	,
29633	343	29	and	and	CC
29633	343	30	a	a	DT
29633	343	31	price	price	NN
29633	343	32	for	for	IN
29633	343	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	343	34	engineers	engineer	NNS
29633	343	35	'	'	POS
29633	343	36	tool	tool	NN
29633	343	37	and	and	CC
29633	343	38	spindle	spindle	JJ
29633	343	39	steel	steel	NN
29633	343	40	was	be	VBD
29633	343	41	included	include	VBN
29633	343	42	in	in	IN
29633	343	43	the	the	DT
29633	343	44	_	_	NNP
29633	343	45	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	343	46	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	343	47	_	_	NNP
29633	343	48	"	"	``
29633	343	49	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	343	50	Market	Market	NNP
29633	343	51	"	"	''
29633	343	52	weekly	weekly	JJ
29633	343	53	quotations	quotation	NNS
29633	343	54	for	for	IN
29633	343	55	the	the	DT
29633	343	56	first	first	JJ
29633	343	57	time[68	time[68	NNP
29633	343	58	]	]	-RRB-
29633	343	59	on	on	IN
29633	343	60	June	June	NNP
29633	343	61	4	4	CD
29633	343	62	,	,	,
29633	343	63	1859	1859	CD
29633	343	64	.	.	.
29633	344	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	344	2	66	66	CD
29633	344	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	344	4	Swank	Swank	NNP
29633	344	5	,	,	,
29633	344	6	_	_	NNP
29633	344	7	op	op	NN
29633	344	8	.	.	.
29633	345	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	345	2	.	.	.
29633	345	3	_	_	NNP
29633	345	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	345	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	345	6	42	42	CD
29633	345	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	345	8	,	,	,
29633	345	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	345	10	405	405	CD
29633	345	11	.	.	.
29633	346	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	346	2	67	67	CD
29633	346	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	346	4	_	_	NNP
29633	346	5	The	the	DT
29633	346	6	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	346	7	_	_	NNP
29633	346	8	,	,	,
29633	346	9	1859	1859	CD
29633	346	10	,	,	,
29633	346	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	346	12	.	.	.
29633	347	1	7	7	CD
29633	347	2	,	,	,
29633	347	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	347	4	350	350	CD
29633	347	5	.	.	.
29633	348	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	348	2	68	68	CD
29633	348	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	348	4	_	_	NNP
29633	348	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	348	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	348	7	_	_	NNP
29633	348	8	,	,	,
29633	348	9	1859	1859	CD
29633	348	10	,	,	,
29633	348	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	348	12	.	.	.
29633	349	1	29	29	CD
29633	349	2	,	,	,
29633	349	3	pp	pp	NNP
29633	349	4	.	.	.
29633	350	1	396	396	CD
29633	350	2	and	and	CC
29633	350	3	401	401	CD
29633	350	4	.	.	.
29633	351	1	The	the	DT
29633	351	2	price	price	NN
29633	351	3	quotation	quotation	NN
29633	351	4	was	be	VBD
29633	351	5	continued	continue	VBN
29633	351	6	until	until	IN
29633	351	7	April	April	NNP
29633	351	8	1865	1865	CD
29633	351	9	.	.	.
29633	352	1	In	in	IN
29633	352	2	May	May	NNP
29633	352	3	1859	1859	CD
29633	352	4	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	352	5	gave	give	VBD
29633	352	6	a	a	DT
29633	352	7	paper	paper	NN
29633	352	8	,	,	,
29633	352	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	352	10	first	first	JJ
29633	352	11	public	public	JJ
29633	352	12	pronouncement	pronouncement	NN
29633	352	13	since	since	IN
29633	352	14	August	August	NNP
29633	352	15	1856	1856	CD
29633	352	16	,	,	,
29633	352	17	before	before	IN
29633	352	18	the	the	DT
29633	352	19	Institution	Institution	NNP
29633	352	20	of	of	IN
29633	352	21	Civil	Civil	NNP
29633	352	22	Engineers	Engineers	NNPS
29633	352	23	.	.	.
29633	353	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	353	2	69	69	CD
29633	353	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	353	4	The	the	DT
29633	353	5	early	early	JJ
29633	353	6	process	process	NN
29633	353	7	,	,	,
29633	353	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	353	9	admitted	admit	VBD
29633	353	10	,	,	,
29633	353	11	had	have	VBD
29633	353	12	led	lead	VBN
29633	353	13	to	to	IN
29633	353	14	failure	failure	NN
29633	353	15	because	because	IN
29633	353	16	the	the	DT
29633	353	17	process	process	NN
29633	353	18	had	have	VBD
29633	353	19	not	not	RB
29633	353	20	reduced	reduce	VBN
29633	353	21	the	the	DT
29633	353	22	quantity	quantity	NN
29633	353	23	of	of	IN
29633	353	24	sulphur	sulphur	NNP
29633	353	25	and	and	CC
29633	353	26	phosphorous	phosphorous	JJ
29633	353	27	,	,	,
29633	353	28	but	but	CC
29633	353	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	353	30	account	account	NN
29633	353	31	is	be	VBZ
29633	353	32	vague	vague	JJ
29633	353	33	as	as	IN
29633	353	34	to	to	IN
29633	353	35	the	the	DT
29633	353	36	manner	manner	NN
29633	353	37	in	in	IN
29633	353	38	which	which	WDT
29633	353	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	353	40	dealt	deal	VBD
29633	353	41	with	with	IN
29633	353	42	this	this	DT
29633	353	43	problem	problem	NN
29633	353	44	:	:	:
29633	353	45	Steam	steam	NN
29633	353	46	and	and	CC
29633	353	47	pure	pure	JJ
29633	353	48	hydrogen	hydrogen	NN
29633	353	49	gas	gas	NN
29633	353	50	were	be	VBD
29633	353	51	tried	try	VBN
29633	353	52	,	,	,
29633	353	53	with	with	IN
29633	353	54	more	more	JJR
29633	353	55	or	or	CC
29633	353	56	less	less	JJR
29633	353	57	success	success	NN
29633	353	58	in	in	IN
29633	353	59	the	the	DT
29633	353	60	removal	removal	NN
29633	353	61	of	of	IN
29633	353	62	sulphur	sulphur	NNP
29633	353	63	,	,	,
29633	353	64	and	and	CC
29633	353	65	various	various	JJ
29633	353	66	flues	flue	NNS
29633	353	67	,	,	,
29633	353	68	composed	compose	VBN
29633	353	69	chiefly	chiefly	RB
29633	353	70	of	of	IN
29633	353	71	silicates	silicate	NNS
29633	353	72	of	of	IN
29633	353	73	the	the	DT
29633	353	74	oxide	oxide	NN
29633	353	75	of	of	IN
29633	353	76	iron	iron	NN
29633	353	77	and	and	CC
29633	353	78	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	353	79	were	be	VBD
29633	353	80	brought	bring	VBN
29633	353	81	in	in	IN
29633	353	82	contact	contact	NN
29633	353	83	with	with	IN
29633	353	84	the	the	DT
29633	353	85	fluid	fluid	JJ
29633	353	86	metal	metal	NN
29633	353	87	,	,	,
29633	353	88	during	during	IN
29633	353	89	the	the	DT
29633	353	90	process	process	NN
29633	353	91	and	and	CC
29633	353	92	the	the	DT
29633	353	93	quantity	quantity	NN
29633	353	94	of	of	IN
29633	353	95	phosphorous	phosphorous	JJ
29633	353	96	was	be	VBD
29633	353	97	thereby	thereby	RB
29633	353	98	reduced	reduce	VBN
29633	353	99	.	.	.
29633	354	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	354	2	69	69	CD
29633	354	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	354	4	_	_	NNP
29633	354	5	The	the	DT
29633	354	6	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	354	7	_	_	NNP
29633	354	8	,	,	,
29633	354	9	1859	1859	CD
29633	354	10	,	,	,
29633	354	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	354	12	.	.	.
29633	355	1	7	7	CD
29633	355	2	,	,	,
29633	355	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	355	4	437	437	CD
29633	355	5	.	.	.
29633	356	1	But	but	CC
29633	356	2	the	the	DT
29633	356	3	clear	clear	JJ
29633	356	4	implication	implication	NN
29633	356	5	is	be	VBZ
29633	356	6	that	that	IN
29633	356	7	the	the	DT
29633	356	8	commercial	commercial	JJ
29633	356	9	operation	operation	NN
29633	356	10	at	at	IN
29633	356	11	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	356	12	was	be	VBD
29633	356	13	based	base	VBN
29633	356	14	on	on	IN
29633	356	15	the	the	DT
29633	356	16	use	use	NN
29633	356	17	of	of	IN
29633	356	18	the	the	DT
29633	356	19	best	good	JJS
29633	356	20	Swedish	swedish	JJ
29633	356	21	pig	pig	NN
29633	356	22	iron	iron	NN
29633	356	23	and	and	CC
29633	356	24	the	the	DT
29633	356	25	hematite	hematite	JJ
29633	356	26	pig	pig	NN
29633	356	27	from	from	IN
29633	356	28	Workington	Workington	NNP
29633	356	29	.	.	.
29633	357	1	The	the	DT
29633	357	2	use	use	NN
29633	357	3	of	of	IN
29633	357	4	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	357	5	as	as	IN
29633	357	6	standard	standard	JJ
29633	357	7	practice	practice	NN
29633	357	8	at	at	IN
29633	357	9	this	this	DT
29633	357	10	time	time	NN
29633	357	11	is	be	VBZ
29633	357	12	not	not	RB
29633	357	13	referred	refer	VBN
29633	357	14	to,[70	to,[70	NNP
29633	357	15	]	]	-RRB-
29633	357	16	but	but	CC
29633	357	17	the	the	DT
29633	357	18	rotary	rotary	JJ
29633	357	19	converter	converter	NN
29633	357	20	and	and	CC
29633	357	21	the	the	DT
29633	357	22	use	use	NN
29633	357	23	of	of	IN
29633	357	24	ganister	ganister	NN
29633	357	25	linings	lining	NNS
29633	357	26	are	be	VBP
29633	357	27	mentioned	mention	VBN
29633	357	28	for	for	IN
29633	357	29	the	the	DT
29633	357	30	first	first	JJ
29633	357	31	time	time	NN
29633	357	32	.	.	.
29633	358	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	358	2	70	70	CD
29633	358	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	358	4	Jeans	Jeans	NNPS
29633	358	5	,	,	,
29633	358	6	_	_	NNP
29633	358	7	op	op	NN
29633	358	8	.	.	.
29633	359	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	359	2	.	.	.
29633	359	3	_	_	NNP
29633	359	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	359	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	359	6	5	5	CD
29633	359	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	359	8	,	,	,
29633	359	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	359	10	349	349	CD
29633	359	11	refers	refer	VBZ
29633	359	12	to	to	IN
29633	359	13	the	the	DT
29633	359	14	hematite	hematite	JJ
29633	359	15	ores	ore	NNS
29633	359	16	of	of	IN
29633	359	17	Lancashire	Lancashire	NNP
29633	359	18	and	and	CC
29633	359	19	Cumberland	Cumberland	NNP
29633	359	20	as	as	IN
29633	359	21	"	"	``
29633	359	22	the	the	DT
29633	359	23	ores	ore	NNS
29633	359	24	hitherto	hitherto	VBD
29633	359	25	almost	almost	RB
29633	359	26	exclusively	exclusively	RB
29633	359	27	used	use	VBN
29633	359	28	in	in	IN
29633	359	29	the	the	DT
29633	359	30	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	359	31	process	process	NN
29633	359	32	.	.	.
29633	359	33	"	"	''
29633	360	1	A	a	DT
29633	360	2	definitive	definitive	JJ
29633	360	3	account	account	NN
29633	360	4	of	of	IN
29633	360	5	the	the	DT
29633	360	6	Swedish	swedish	JJ
29633	360	7	development	development	NN
29633	360	8	of	of	IN
29633	360	9	the	the	DT
29633	360	10	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	360	11	process	process	NN
29633	360	12	,	,	,
29633	360	13	leading	lead	VBG
29633	360	14	to	to	IN
29633	360	15	a	a	DT
29633	360	16	well	well	RB
29633	360	17	-	-	HYPH
29633	360	18	documented	document	VBN
29633	360	19	claim	claim	NN
29633	360	20	that	that	IN
29633	360	21	the	the	DT
29633	360	22	first	first	JJ
29633	360	23	practical	practical	JJ
29633	360	24	realization	realization	NN
29633	360	25	of	of	IN
29633	360	26	the	the	DT
29633	360	27	process	process	NN
29633	360	28	was	be	VBD
29633	360	29	achieved	achieve	VBN
29633	360	30	in	in	IN
29633	360	31	Sweden	Sweden	NNP
29633	360	32	in	in	IN
29633	360	33	July	July	NNP
29633	360	34	1858	1858	CD
29633	360	35	,	,	,
29633	360	36	was	be	VBD
29633	360	37	recently	recently	RB
29633	360	38	published	publish	VBN
29633	360	39	(	(	-LRB-
29633	360	40	Per	per	IN
29633	360	41	Carlberg	Carlberg	NNP
29633	360	42	,	,	,
29633	360	43	"	"	``
29633	360	44	Early	early	JJ
29633	360	45	Production	production	NN
29633	360	46	of	of	IN
29633	360	47	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	360	48	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	360	49	at	at	IN
29633	360	50	Edsken	Edsken	NNP
29633	360	51	,	,	,
29633	360	52	"	"	''
29633	360	53	_	_	NNP
29633	360	54	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	360	55	of	of	IN
29633	360	56	the	the	DT
29633	360	57	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	360	58	and	and	CC
29633	360	59	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	360	60	Institute	Institute	NNP
29633	360	61	,	,	,
29633	360	62	Great	Great	NNP
29633	360	63	Britain	Britain	NNP
29633	360	64	_	_	NNP
29633	360	65	,	,	,
29633	360	66	July	July	NNP
29633	360	67	1958	1958	CD
29633	360	68	,	,	,
29633	360	69	vol	vol	NNP
29633	360	70	.	.	.
29633	361	1	189	189	CD
29633	361	2	,	,	,
29633	361	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	361	4	201	201	CD
29633	361	5	)	)	-RRB-
29633	361	6	.	.	.
29633	362	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	362	2	had	have	VBD
29633	362	3	,	,	,
29633	362	4	with	with	IN
29633	362	5	some	some	DT
29633	362	6	intuition	intuition	NN
29633	362	7	,	,	,
29633	362	8	found	find	VBD
29633	362	9	opportunity	opportunity	NN
29633	362	10	to	to	TO
29633	362	11	reassert	reassert	VB
29633	362	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	362	13	contributions	contribution	NNS
29633	362	14	to	to	IN
29633	362	15	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	362	16	a	a	DT
29633	362	17	few	few	JJ
29633	362	18	days	day	NNS
29633	362	19	before	before	IN
29633	362	20	this	this	DT
29633	362	21	address	address	NN
29633	362	22	,	,	,
29633	362	23	describing	describe	VBG
29633	362	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	362	25	process	process	NN
29633	362	26	as	as	IN
29633	362	27	perhaps	perhaps	RB
29633	362	28	lacking	lack	VBG
29633	362	29	"	"	``
29633	362	30	the	the	DT
29633	362	31	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
29633	362	32	merit	merit	NN
29633	362	33	of	of	IN
29633	362	34	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	362	35	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	362	36	,	,	,
29633	362	37	"	"	``
29633	362	38	being	be	VBG
29633	362	39	"	"	``
29633	362	40	merely	merely	RB
29633	362	41	a	a	DT
29633	362	42	vigorous	vigorous	JJ
29633	362	43	offshoot	offshoot	NN
29633	362	44	proceeding	proceeding	NN
29633	362	45	from	from	IN
29633	362	46	that	that	DT
29633	362	47	great	great	JJ
29633	362	48	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	362	49	;	;	:
29633	362	50	but	but	CC
29633	362	51	,	,	,
29633	362	52	combined	combine	VBN
29633	362	53	with	with	IN
29633	362	54	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	362	55	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	362	56	's	's	POS
29633	362	57	process	process	NN
29633	362	58	,	,	,
29633	362	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	362	60	places	place	VBZ
29633	362	61	within	within	IN
29633	362	62	the	the	DT
29633	362	63	reach	reach	NN
29633	362	64	of	of	IN
29633	362	65	every	every	DT
29633	362	66	iron	iron	NN
29633	362	67	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
29633	362	68	to	to	TO
29633	362	69	produce	produce	VB
29633	362	70	cast	cast	VBN
29633	362	71	steel	steel	NN
29633	362	72	at	at	IN
29633	362	73	the	the	DT
29633	362	74	same	same	JJ
29633	362	75	cost	cost	NN
29633	362	76	for	for	IN
29633	362	77	which	which	WDT
29633	362	78	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	362	79	can	can	MD
29633	362	80	now	now	RB
29633	362	81	make	make	VB
29633	362	82	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	362	83	best	good	JJS
29633	362	84	iron	iron	NN
29633	362	85	.	.	.
29633	363	1	"	"	``
29633	363	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	363	3	71	71	CD
29633	363	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	363	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	363	6	71	71	CD
29633	363	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	363	8	_	_	NNP
29633	363	9	The	the	DT
29633	363	10	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	363	11	_	_	NNP
29633	363	12	,	,	,
29633	363	13	1859	1859	CD
29633	363	14	,	,	,
29633	363	15	vol	vol	NNP
29633	363	16	.	.	.
29633	364	1	7	7	CD
29633	364	2	,	,	,
29633	364	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	364	4	314	314	CD
29633	364	5	.	.	.
29633	365	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	365	2	's	's	POS
29633	365	3	intention	intention	NN
29633	365	4	to	to	TO
29633	365	5	present	present	VB
29633	365	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	365	7	paper	paper	NN
29633	365	8	had	have	VBD
29633	365	9	been	be	VBN
29633	365	10	announced	announce	VBN
29633	365	11	in	in	IN
29633	365	12	April	April	NNP
29633	365	13	.	.	.
29633	366	1	One	one	CD
29633	366	2	of	of	IN
29633	366	3	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	366	4	's	's	POS
29633	366	5	replies	reply	NNS
29633	366	6	to	to	IN
29633	366	7	the	the	DT
29633	366	8	paper	paper	NN
29633	366	9	itself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	366	10	took	take	VBD
29633	366	11	the	the	DT
29633	366	12	form	form	NN
29633	366	13	of	of	IN
29633	366	14	the	the	DT
29633	366	15	announcement	announcement	NN
29633	366	16	of	of	IN
29633	366	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	366	18	provisional	provisional	JJ
29633	366	19	patent	patent	NN
29633	366	20	for	for	IN
29633	366	21	the	the	DT
29633	366	22	use	use	NN
29633	366	23	of	of	IN
29633	366	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	366	25	triple	triple	JJ
29633	366	26	compound	compound	NN
29633	366	27	which	which	WDT
29633	366	28	,	,	,
29633	366	29	in	in	IN
29633	366	30	the	the	DT
29633	366	31	opinion	opinion	NN
29633	366	32	of	of	IN
29633	366	33	_	_	NNP
29633	366	34	The	the	DT
29633	366	35	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	366	36	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	366	37	_	_	NNP
29633	366	38	appeared	appear	VBD
29633	366	39	to	to	TO
29633	366	40	be	be	VB
29633	366	41	"	"	``
29633	366	42	but	but	CC
29633	366	43	a	a	DT
29633	366	44	very	very	RB
29633	366	45	slight	slight	JJ
29633	366	46	modification	modification	NN
29633	366	47	of	of	IN
29633	366	48	several	several	JJ
29633	366	49	of	of	IN
29633	366	50	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	366	51	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	366	52	's	's	POS
29633	366	53	inventions	invention	NNS
29633	366	54	.	.	.
29633	366	55	"	"	''
29633	367	1	Another	another	DT
29633	367	2	half	half	JJ
29633	367	3	dozen	dozen	NN
29633	367	4	patents	patent	NNS
29633	367	5	appeared	appear	VBD
29633	367	6	within	within	IN
29633	367	7	two	two	CD
29633	367	8	months	month	NNS
29633	367	9	,	,	,
29633	367	10	"	"	''
29633	367	11	so	so	IN
29633	367	12	that	that	IN
29633	367	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	367	14	is	be	VBZ
29633	367	15	apparent	apparent	JJ
29633	367	16	that	that	IN
29633	367	17	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	367	18	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	367	19	's	's	POS
29633	367	20	failure	failure	NN
29633	367	21	to	to	TO
29633	367	22	make	make	VB
29633	367	23	the	the	DT
29633	367	24	public	public	NN
29633	367	25	appreciate	appreciate	VB
29633	367	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	367	27	theories	theory	NNS
29633	367	28	has	have	VBZ
29633	367	29	not	not	RB
29633	367	30	injured	injure	VBN
29633	367	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	367	32	inventive	inventive	JJ
29633	367	33	faculties	faculty	NNS
29633	367	34	.	.	.
29633	368	1	"	"	``
29633	368	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	368	3	72	72	CD
29633	368	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	368	5	These	these	DT
29633	368	6	patents	patent	NNS
29633	368	7	include	include	VBP
29633	368	8	,	,	,
29633	368	9	besides	besides	IN
29633	368	10	variations	variation	NNS
29633	368	11	on	on	IN
29633	368	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	368	13	"	"	``
29633	368	14	triple	triple	JJ
29633	368	15	compound	compound	NN
29633	368	16	"	"	''
29633	368	17	theme	theme	NN
29633	368	18	,	,	,
29633	368	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	368	20	important	important	JJ
29633	368	21	patent	patent	NN
29633	368	22	on	on	IN
29633	368	23	the	the	DT
29633	368	24	use	use	NN
29633	368	25	of	of	IN
29633	368	26	tungsten	tungsten	NN
29633	368	27	for	for	IN
29633	368	28	cutting	cut	VBG
29633	368	29	tools	tool	NNS
29633	368	30	,	,	,
29633	368	31	later	later	RB
29633	368	32	to	to	TO
29633	368	33	be	be	VB
29633	368	34	known	know	VBN
29633	368	35	as	as	IN
29633	368	36	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	368	37	steel	steel	NN
29633	368	38	.	.	.
29633	369	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	369	2	73	73	CD
29633	369	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	369	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	369	5	72	72	CD
29633	369	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	369	7	_	_	NNP
29633	369	8	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	369	9	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	369	10	_	_	NNP
29633	369	11	,	,	,
29633	369	12	1859	1859	CD
29633	369	13	,	,	,
29633	369	14	vol	vol	NNP
29633	369	15	.	.	.
29633	370	1	29	29	CD
29633	370	2	,	,	,
29633	370	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	370	4	539	539	CD
29633	370	5	and	and	CC
29633	370	6	640	640	CD
29633	370	7	.	.	.
29633	371	1	Another	another	DT
29633	371	2	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	371	3	patent	patent	NN
29633	371	4	is	be	VBZ
29633	371	5	described	describe	VBN
29633	371	6	as	as	IN
29633	371	7	so	so	RB
29633	371	8	much	much	RB
29633	371	9	like	like	IN
29633	371	10	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	371	11	'	'	POS
29633	371	12	process	process	NN
29633	371	13	that	that	IN
29633	371	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	371	15	would	would	MD
29633	371	16	seem	seem	VB
29633	371	17	to	to	TO
29633	371	18	be	be	VB
29633	371	19	almost	almost	RB
29633	371	20	unpatentable	unpatentable	JJ
29633	371	21	.	.	.
29633	372	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	372	2	73	73	CD
29633	372	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	372	4	See	See	NNP
29633	372	5	Jeans	Jeans	NNPS
29633	372	6	,	,	,
29633	372	7	_	_	NNP
29633	372	8	op	op	NN
29633	372	9	.	.	.
29633	373	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	373	2	.	.	.
29633	373	3	_	_	NNP
29633	373	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	373	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	373	6	5	5	CD
29633	373	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	373	8	,	,	,
29633	373	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	373	10	532	532	CD
29633	373	11	.	.	.
29633	374	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	374	2	's	's	POS
29633	374	3	formal	formal	JJ
29633	374	4	pronouncement	pronouncement	NN
29633	374	5	on	on	IN
29633	374	6	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	374	7	's	's	POS
29633	374	8	paper	paper	NN
29633	374	9	,	,	,
29633	374	10	dated	date	VBN
29633	374	11	June	June	NNP
29633	374	12	28	28	CD
29633	374	13	,	,	,
29633	374	14	1859	1859	CD
29633	374	15	,	,	,
29633	374	16	is	be	VBZ
29633	374	17	perhaps	perhaps	RB
29633	374	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	374	19	most	most	RBS
29633	374	20	intelligible	intelligible	JJ
29633	374	21	communication	communication	NN
29633	374	22	on	on	IN
29633	374	23	the	the	DT
29633	374	24	subject	subject	NN
29633	374	25	.	.	.
29633	375	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	375	2	alone	alone	RB
29633	375	3	"	"	''
29633	375	4	from	from	IN
29633	375	5	the	the	DT
29633	375	6	first	first	JJ
29633	375	7	consistently	consistently	RB
29633	375	8	advocated	advocate	VBD
29633	375	9	the	the	DT
29633	375	10	merits	merit	NNS
29633	375	11	and	and	CC
29633	375	12	pointed	point	VBD
29633	375	13	out	out	RP
29633	375	14	the	the	DT
29633	375	15	defects	defect	NNS
29633	375	16	of	of	IN
29633	375	17	the	the	DT
29633	375	18	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	375	19	process	process	NN
29633	375	20	,	,	,
29633	375	21	"	"	''
29633	375	22	and	and	CC
29633	375	23	within	within	IN
29633	375	24	a	a	DT
29633	375	25	few	few	JJ
29633	375	26	days	day	NNS
29633	375	27	of	of	IN
29633	375	28	the	the	DT
29633	375	29	British	British	NNP
29633	375	30	Association	Association	NNP
29633	375	31	address	address	NN
29633	375	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	375	33	had	have	VBD
29633	375	34	shown	show	VBN
29633	375	35	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	375	36	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	375	37	"	"	''
29633	375	38	where	where	WRB
29633	375	39	the	the	DT
29633	375	40	defect	defect	NN
29633	375	41	would	would	MD
29633	375	42	be	be	VB
29633	375	43	found	find	VBN
29633	375	44	and	and	CC
29633	375	45	what	what	WP
29633	375	46	would	would	MD
29633	375	47	remedy	remedy	VB
29633	375	48	"	"	``
29633	375	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	375	50	.	.	.
29633	376	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	376	2	was	be	VBD
29633	376	3	not	not	RB
29633	376	4	,	,	,
29633	376	5	in	in	IN
29633	376	6	fact	fact	NN
29633	376	7	,	,	,
29633	376	8	the	the	DT
29633	376	9	presence	presence	NN
29633	376	10	of	of	IN
29633	376	11	one	one	CD
29633	376	12	-	-	HYPH
29633	376	13	tenth	tenth	NN
29633	376	14	of	of	IN
29633	376	15	a	a	DT
29633	376	16	percent	percent	NN
29633	376	17	of	of	IN
29633	376	18	sulphur	sulphur	NNP
29633	376	19	or	or	CC
29633	376	20	phosphorous	phosphorous	JJ
29633	376	21	which	which	WDT
29633	376	22	affected	affect	VBD
29633	376	23	the	the	DT
29633	376	24	result	result	NN
29633	376	25	if	if	IN
29633	376	26	the	the	DT
29633	376	27	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	376	28	process	process	NN
29633	376	29	were	be	VBD
29633	376	30	combined	combine	VBN
29633	376	31	with	with	IN
29633	376	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	376	33	process	process	NN
29633	376	34	by	by	IN
29633	376	35	adding	add	VBG
29633	376	36	a	a	DT
29633	376	37	triple	triple	JJ
29633	376	38	compound	compound	NN
29633	376	39	of	of	IN
29633	376	40	iron	iron	NN
29633	376	41	,	,	,
29633	376	42	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	376	43	,	,	,
29633	376	44	and	and	CC
29633	376	45	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	376	46	to	to	IN
29633	376	47	the	the	DT
29633	376	48	pig	pig	NN
29633	376	49	.	.	.
29633	377	1	"	"	``
29633	377	2	There	there	EX
29633	377	3	never	never	RB
29633	377	4	was	be	VBD
29633	377	5	a	a	DT
29633	377	6	bar	bar	NN
29633	377	7	of	of	IN
29633	377	8	first	first	JJ
29633	377	9	-	-	HYPH
29633	377	10	rate	rate	NN
29633	377	11	cast	cast	VBN
29633	377	12	steel	steel	NN
29633	377	13	made	make	VBN
29633	377	14	by	by	IN
29633	377	15	the	the	DT
29633	377	16	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	377	17	process	process	NN
29633	377	18	alone	alone	RB
29633	377	19	"	"	''
29633	377	20	;	;	,
29633	377	21	(	(	-LRB-
29633	377	22	and	and	CC
29633	377	23	that	that	DT
29633	377	24	included	include	VBD
29633	377	25	Goransson	Goransson	NNP
29633	377	26	's	's	POS
29633	377	27	product	product	NN
29633	377	28	)	)	-RRB-
29633	377	29	"	"	''
29633	377	30	and	and	CC
29633	377	31	there	there	EX
29633	377	32	never	never	RB
29633	377	33	can	can	MD
29633	377	34	be	be	VB
29633	377	35	,	,	,
29633	377	36	but	but	CC
29633	377	37	a	a	DT
29633	377	38	cheap	cheap	JJ
29633	377	39	kind	kind	NN
29633	377	40	of	of	IN
29633	377	41	steel	steel	NN
29633	377	42	applicable	applicable	JJ
29633	377	43	to	to	IN
29633	377	44	several	several	JJ
29633	377	45	purposes	purpose	NNS
29633	377	46	may	may	MD
29633	377	47	be	be	VB
29633	377	48	thus	thus	RB
29633	377	49	produced	produce	VBN
29633	377	50	.	.	.
29633	377	51	"	"	''
29633	378	1	After	after	IN
29633	378	2	emphasizing	emphasize	VBG
29633	378	3	the	the	DT
29633	378	4	uniqueness	uniqueness	NN
29633	378	5	of	of	IN
29633	378	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	378	7	attempt	attempt	NN
29633	378	8	to	to	TO
29633	378	9	make	make	VB
29633	378	10	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	378	11	's	's	POS
29633	378	12	process	process	NN
29633	378	13	successful	successful	JJ
29633	378	14	,	,	,
29633	378	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	378	16	asserts:[74	asserts:[74	ADD
29633	378	17	]	]	-RRB-
29633	378	18	In	in	IN
29633	378	19	short	short	JJ
29633	378	20	,	,	,
29633	378	21	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	378	22	merely	merely	RB
29633	378	23	availed	avail	VBD
29633	378	24	myself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	378	25	of	of	IN
29633	378	26	a	a	DT
29633	378	27	great	great	JJ
29633	378	28	metallurgical	metallurgical	JJ
29633	378	29	fact	fact	NN
29633	378	30	,	,	,
29633	378	31	_	_	NNP
29633	378	32	which	which	WDT
29633	378	33	has	have	VBZ
29633	378	34	been	be	VBN
29633	378	35	for	for	IN
29633	378	36	years	year	NNS
29633	378	37	_	_	NNP
29633	378	38	before	before	IN
29633	378	39	the	the	DT
29633	378	40	eyes	eye	NNS
29633	378	41	of	of	IN
29633	378	42	the	the	DT
29633	378	43	metallurgical	metallurgical	JJ
29633	378	44	world	world	NN
29633	378	45	,	,	,
29633	378	46	namely	namely	RB
29633	378	47	that	that	IN
29633	378	48	the	the	DT
29633	378	49	presence	presence	NN
29633	378	50	of	of	IN
29633	378	51	metallic	metallic	JJ
29633	378	52	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	378	53	in	in	IN
29633	378	54	iron	iron	NN
29633	378	55	and	and	CC
29633	378	56	steel	steel	NN
29633	378	57	conferred	confer	VBN
29633	378	58	upon	upon	IN
29633	378	59	both	both	CC
29633	378	60	an	an	DT
29633	378	61	amount	amount	NN
29633	378	62	of	of	IN
29633	378	63	toughness	toughness	NN
29633	378	64	either	either	CC
29633	378	65	when	when	WRB
29633	378	66	cold	cold	JJ
29633	378	67	or	or	CC
29633	378	68	when	when	WRB
29633	378	69	heated	heat	VBN
29633	378	70	,	,	,
29633	378	71	which	which	WDT
29633	378	72	the	the	DT
29633	378	73	presence	presence	NN
29633	378	74	at	at	IN
29633	378	75	the	the	DT
29633	378	76	same	same	JJ
29633	378	77	time	time	NN
29633	378	78	of	of	IN
29633	378	79	a	a	DT
29633	378	80	notable	notable	JJ
29633	378	81	amount	amount	NN
29633	378	82	of	of	IN
29633	378	83	sulphur	sulphur	NN
29633	378	84	and	and	CC
29633	378	85	phosphorous	phosphorous	JJ
29633	378	86	could	could	MD
29633	378	87	not	not	RB
29633	378	88	overcome	overcome	VB
29633	378	89	.	.	.
29633	379	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	379	2	74	74	CD
29633	379	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	379	4	_	_	NNP
29633	379	5	The	the	DT
29633	379	6	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	379	7	_	_	NNP
29633	379	8	,	,	,
29633	379	9	1859	1859	CD
29633	379	10	,	,	,
29633	379	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	379	12	.	.	.
29633	380	1	8	8	CD
29633	380	2	,	,	,
29633	380	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	380	4	13	13	CD
29633	380	5	(	(	-LRB-
29633	380	6	italics	italic	NNS
29633	380	7	supplied	supply	VBN
29633	380	8	)	)	-RRB-
29633	380	9	.	.	.
29633	381	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	381	2	is	be	VBZ
29633	381	3	noted	note	VBN
29633	381	4	that	that	IN
29633	381	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	381	6	's	's	POS
29633	381	7	American	american	JJ
29633	381	8	patent	patent	NN
29633	381	9	(	(	-LRB-
29633	381	10	17389	17389	CD
29633	381	11	,	,	,
29633	381	12	of	of	IN
29633	381	13	May	May	NNP
29633	381	14	26	26	CD
29633	381	15	,	,	,
29633	381	16	1857	1857	CD
29633	381	17	)	)	-RRB-
29633	381	18	prefers	prefer	VBZ
29633	381	19	the	the	DT
29633	381	20	use	use	NN
29633	381	21	of	of	IN
29633	381	22	iron	iron	NN
29633	381	23	"	"	''
29633	381	24	as	as	RB
29633	381	25	free	free	JJ
29633	381	26	as	as	IN
29633	381	27	possible	possible	JJ
29633	381	28	from	from	IN
29633	381	29	Sulphur	Sulphur	NNP
29633	381	30	and	and	CC
29633	381	31	Phosphorous	Phosphorous	NNP
29633	381	32	.	.	.
29633	381	33	"	"	''
29633	382	1	The	the	DT
29633	382	2	succeeding	succeed	VBG
29633	382	3	years	year	NNS
29633	382	4	were	be	VBD
29633	382	5	enlivened	enliven	VBN
29633	382	6	,	,	,
29633	382	7	one	one	CD
29633	382	8	by	by	IN
29633	382	9	one	one	CD
29633	382	10	,	,	,
29633	382	11	by	by	IN
29633	382	12	some	some	DT
29633	382	13	controversy	controversy	NN
29633	382	14	in	in	IN
29633	382	15	which	which	WDT
29633	382	16	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	382	17	invoked	invoke	VBD
29633	382	18	the	the	DT
29633	382	19	shadow	shadow	NN
29633	382	20	of	of	IN
29633	382	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	382	22	late	late	JJ
29633	382	23	father	father	NN
29633	382	24	as	as	IN
29633	382	25	support	support	NN
29633	382	26	for	for	IN
29633	382	27	some	some	DT
29633	382	28	pronouncement	pronouncement	NN
29633	382	29	,	,	,
29633	382	30	or	or	CC
29633	382	31	"	"	``
29633	382	32	edict	edict	NNP
29633	382	33	,	,	,
29633	382	34	"	"	''
29633	382	35	as	as	IN
29633	382	36	some	some	DT
29633	382	37	said	say	VBD
29633	382	38	,	,	,
29633	382	39	on	on	IN
29633	382	40	the	the	DT
29633	382	41	subject	subject	NN
29633	382	42	of	of	IN
29633	382	43	making	make	VBG
29633	382	44	iron	iron	NN
29633	382	45	and	and	CC
29633	382	46	steel	steel	NN
29633	382	47	.	.	.
29633	383	1	In	in	IN
29633	383	2	1860	1860	CD
29633	383	3	,	,	,
29633	383	4	on	on	IN
29633	383	5	the	the	DT
29633	383	6	question	question	NN
29633	383	7	of	of	IN
29633	383	8	suitable	suitable	JJ
29633	383	9	metal	metal	NN
29633	383	10	for	for	IN
29633	383	11	artillery	artillery	NN
29633	383	12	,	,	,
29633	383	13	later	later	RB
29633	383	14	to	to	TO
29633	383	15	be	be	VB
29633	383	16	the	the	DT
29633	383	17	subject	subject	NN
29633	383	18	of	of	IN
29633	383	19	high	high	JJ
29633	383	20	controversy	controversy	NN
29633	383	21	among	among	IN
29633	383	22	the	the	DT
29633	383	23	leading	lead	VBG
29633	383	24	experts	expert	NNS
29633	383	25	of	of	IN
29633	383	26	the	the	DT
29633	383	27	day	day	NN
29633	383	28	,	,	,
29633	383	29	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	383	30	found	find	VBD
29633	383	31	a	a	DT
29633	383	32	ready	ready	JJ
29633	383	33	solution	solution	NN
29633	383	34	in	in	IN
29633	383	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	383	36	own	own	JJ
29633	383	37	gun	gun	NN
29633	383	38	metal	metal	NN
29633	383	39	.	.	.
29633	384	1	This	this	DT
29633	384	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	384	3	had	have	VBD
29633	384	4	developed	develop	VBN
29633	384	5	fifteen	fifteen	CD
29633	384	6	years	year	NNS
29633	384	7	before	before	RB
29633	384	8	.	.	.
29633	385	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	385	2	was	be	VBD
29633	385	3	of	of	IN
29633	385	4	a	a	DT
29633	385	5	tensile	tensile	JJ
29633	385	6	strength	strength	NN
29633	385	7	better	well	RBR
29633	385	8	even	even	RB
29633	385	9	than	than	IN
29633	385	10	that	that	DT
29633	385	11	of	of	IN
29633	385	12	Krupp	Krupp	NNP
29633	385	13	of	of	IN
29633	385	14	Essen	Essen	NNP
29633	385	15	who	who	WP
29633	385	16	was	be	VBD
29633	385	17	then	then	RB
29633	385	18	specializing	specialize	VBG
29633	385	19	in	in	IN
29633	385	20	the	the	DT
29633	385	21	making	making	NN
29633	385	22	of	of	IN
29633	385	23	large	large	JJ
29633	385	24	blocks	block	NNS
29633	385	25	of	of	IN
29633	385	26	cast	cast	VBN
29633	385	27	steel	steel	NN
29633	385	28	for	for	IN
29633	385	29	heavy	heavy	JJ
29633	385	30	forgings	forging	NNS
29633	385	31	,	,	,
29633	385	32	and	and	CC
29633	385	33	particularly	particularly	RB
29633	385	34	for	for	IN
29633	385	35	guns	gun	NNS
29633	385	36	.	.	.
29633	386	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
29633	386	2	,	,	,
29633	386	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	386	4	was	be	VBD
29633	386	5	able	able	JJ
29633	386	6	publicly	publicly	RB
29633	386	7	to	to	TO
29633	386	8	challenge	challenge	VB
29633	386	9	Krupp	Krupp	NNP
29633	386	10	to	to	TO
29633	386	11	produce	produce	VB
29633	386	12	a	a	DT
29633	386	13	cast	cast	NN
29633	386	14	gun	gun	NN
29633	386	15	metal	metal	NN
29633	386	16	or	or	CC
29633	386	17	cast	cast	VBN
29633	386	18	steel	steel	NN
29633	386	19	to	to	TO
29633	386	20	stand	stand	VB
29633	386	21	test	test	NN
29633	386	22	against	against	IN
29633	386	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	386	24	.	.	.
29633	387	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	387	2	75	75	CD
29633	387	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	387	4	A	a	DT
29633	387	5	year	year	NN
29633	387	6	later	later	RB
29633	387	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	387	8	attack	attack	NN
29633	387	9	on	on	IN
29633	387	10	the	the	DT
29633	387	11	distinguished	distinguished	JJ
29633	387	12	French	french	JJ
29633	387	13	metallurgist	metallurgist	NN
29633	387	14	Fremy	Fremy	NNP
29633	387	15	,	,	,
29633	387	16	whom	whom	WP
29633	387	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	387	18	describes	describe	VBZ
29633	387	19	as	as	IN
29633	387	20	an	an	DT
29633	387	21	"	"	``
29633	387	22	ass	ass	NN
29633	387	23	"	"	''
29633	387	24	for	for	IN
29633	387	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	387	26	interest	interest	NN
29633	387	27	in	in	IN
29633	387	28	the	the	DT
29633	387	29	so	so	RB
29633	387	30	-	-	HYPH
29633	387	31	called	call	VBN
29633	387	32	cyanogen	cyanogen	NN
29633	387	33	process	process	NN
29633	387	34	of	of	IN
29633	387	35	steel	steel	NN
29633	387	36	making	making	NN
29633	387	37	,	,	,
29633	387	38	did	do	VBD
29633	387	39	little	little	JJ
29633	387	40	to	to	TO
29633	387	41	enhance	enhance	VB
29633	387	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	387	43	reputation	reputation	NN
29633	387	44	,	,	,
29633	387	45	whatever	whatever	WDT
29633	387	46	the	the	DT
29633	387	47	scientific	scientific	JJ
29633	387	48	justification	justification	NN
29633	387	49	for	for	IN
29633	387	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	387	51	attack	attack	NN
29633	387	52	.	.	.
29633	388	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	388	2	attitude	attitude	NN
29633	388	3	toward	toward	IN
29633	388	4	the	the	DT
29633	388	5	use	use	NN
29633	388	6	of	of	IN
29633	388	7	New	New	NNP
29633	388	8	Zealand	Zealand	NNP
29633	388	9	(	(	-LRB-
29633	388	10	Taranaki	Taranaki	NNP
29633	388	11	)	)	-RRB-
29633	388	12	metalliferous	metalliferous	JJ
29633	388	13	sand	sand	NN
29633	388	14	,	,	,
29633	388	15	which	which	WDT
29633	388	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	388	17	had	have	VBD
29633	388	18	previously	previously	RB
29633	388	19	favored	favor	VBN
29633	388	20	and	and	CC
29633	388	21	then	then	RB
29633	388	22	condemned	condemn	VBN
29633	388	23	in	in	IN
29633	388	24	such	such	PDT
29633	388	25	a	a	DT
29633	388	26	way	way	NN
29633	388	27	as	as	IN
29633	388	28	to	to	TO
29633	388	29	"	"	``
29633	388	30	injure	injure	VB
29633	388	31	a	a	DT
29633	388	32	project	project	NN
29633	388	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	388	34	can	can	MD
29633	388	35	no	no	RB
29633	388	36	longer	long	RBR
29633	388	37	control,"[76	control,"[76	NNP
29633	388	38	]	]	-RRB-
29633	388	39	was	be	VBD
29633	388	40	another	another	DT
29633	388	41	example	example	NN
29633	388	42	of	of	IN
29633	388	43	a	a	DT
29633	388	44	public	public	JJ
29633	388	45	behavior	behavior	NN
29633	388	46	evidently	evidently	RB
29633	388	47	resented	resent	VBD
29633	388	48	.	.	.
29633	389	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	389	2	75	75	CD
29633	389	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	389	4	_	_	NNP
29633	389	5	The	the	DT
29633	389	6	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	389	7	_	_	NNP
29633	389	8	,	,	,
29633	389	9	1860	1860	CD
29633	389	10	,	,	,
29633	389	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	389	12	.	.	.
29633	390	1	9	9	CD
29633	390	2	,	,	,
29633	390	3	pp	pp	NNP
29633	390	4	.	.	.
29633	391	1	366	366	CD
29633	391	2	,	,	,
29633	391	3	416	416	CD
29633	391	4	,	,	,
29633	391	5	and	and	CC
29633	391	6	_	_	NNP
29633	391	7	passim	passim	NN
29633	391	8	_	_	NNP
29633	391	9	.	.	.
29633	392	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	392	2	76	76	CD
29633	392	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	392	4	_	_	NNP
29633	392	5	The	the	DT
29633	392	6	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	392	7	_	_	NNP
29633	392	8	,	,	,
29633	392	9	1861	1861	CD
29633	392	10	,	,	,
29633	392	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	392	12	.	.	.
29633	393	1	11	11	CD
29633	393	2	,	,	,
29633	393	3	pp	pp	NNP
29633	393	4	.	.	.
29633	394	1	189	189	CD
29633	394	2	,	,	,
29633	394	3	202	202	CD
29633	394	4	,	,	,
29633	394	5	290	290	CD
29633	394	6	,	,	,
29633	394	7	304	304	CD
29633	394	8	.	.	.
29633	395	1	By	by	IN
29633	395	2	mid-1861	mid-1861	NNS
29633	395	3	,	,	,
29633	395	4	on	on	IN
29633	395	5	the	the	DT
29633	395	6	other	other	JJ
29633	395	7	hand	hand	NN
29633	395	8	,	,	,
29633	395	9	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	395	10	was	be	VBD
29633	395	11	beginning	begin	VBG
29633	395	12	to	to	TO
29633	395	13	meet	meet	VB
29633	395	14	with	with	IN
29633	395	15	increasing	increase	VBG
29633	395	16	respect	respect	NN
29633	395	17	from	from	IN
29633	395	18	the	the	DT
29633	395	19	trade	trade	NN
29633	395	20	.	.	.
29633	396	1	The	the	DT
29633	396	2	Society	Society	NNP
29633	396	3	of	of	IN
29633	396	4	Engineers	Engineers	NNPS
29633	396	5	received	receive	VBD
29633	396	6	a	a	DT
29633	396	7	dispassionate	dispassionate	NN
29633	396	8	account	account	NN
29633	396	9	of	of	IN
29633	396	10	the	the	DT
29633	396	11	achievement	achievement	NN
29633	396	12	at	at	IN
29633	396	13	the	the	DT
29633	396	14	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	396	15	Works	Works	NNPS
29633	396	16	from	from	IN
29633	396	17	E.	E.	NNP
29633	396	18	Riley	Riley	NNP
29633	396	19	,	,	,
29633	396	20	whose	whose	WP$
29633	396	21	firm	firm	NN
29633	396	22	(	(	-LRB-
29633	396	23	Dowlais	Dowlais	NNP
29633	396	24	)	)	-RRB-
29633	396	25	was	be	VBD
29633	396	26	among	among	IN
29633	396	27	the	the	DT
29633	396	28	earlier	early	JJR
29633	396	29	and	and	CC
29633	396	30	disappointed	disappointed	JJ
29633	396	31	licensees	licensee	NNS
29633	396	32	of	of	IN
29633	396	33	the	the	DT
29633	396	34	process	process	NN
29633	396	35	.	.	.
29633	397	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	397	2	77	77	CD
29633	397	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	397	4	In	in	IN
29633	397	5	August	August	NNP
29633	397	6	1861	1861	CD
29633	397	7	,	,	,
29633	397	8	five	five	CD
29633	397	9	years	year	NNS
29633	397	10	after	after	IN
29633	397	11	the	the	DT
29633	397	12	ill	ill	RB
29633	397	13	-	-	HYPH
29633	397	14	fated	fate	VBN
29633	397	15	address	address	NN
29633	397	16	before	before	IN
29633	397	17	the	the	DT
29633	397	18	British	British	NNP
29633	397	19	Association	Association	NNP
29633	397	20	,	,	,
29633	397	21	the	the	DT
29633	397	22	Institution	Institution	NNP
29633	397	23	of	of	IN
29633	397	24	Mechanical	Mechanical	NNP
29633	397	25	Engineers	Engineers	NNPS
29633	397	26	,	,	,
29633	397	27	meeting	meet	VBG
29633	397	28	in	in	IN
29633	397	29	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	397	30	,	,	,
29633	397	31	the	the	DT
29633	397	32	center	center	NN
29633	397	33	of	of	IN
29633	397	34	the	the	DT
29633	397	35	British	british	JJ
29633	397	36	steel	steel	NN
29633	397	37	trade	trade	NN
29633	397	38	,	,	,
29633	397	39	heard	hear	VBD
29633	397	40	papers	paper	NNS
29633	397	41	from	from	IN
29633	397	42	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	397	43	and	and	CC
29633	397	44	from	from	IN
29633	397	45	John	John	NNP
29633	397	46	Brown	Brown	NNP
29633	397	47	,	,	,
29633	397	48	a	a	DT
29633	397	49	famous	famous	JJ
29633	397	50	ironmaster	ironmaster	NN
29633	397	51	.	.	.
29633	398	1	The	the	DT
29633	398	2	latter	latter	NN
29633	398	3	described	describe	VBD
29633	398	4	the	the	DT
29633	398	5	making	making	NN
29633	398	6	of	of	IN
29633	398	7	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	398	8	rails	rail	NNS
29633	398	9	,	,	,
29633	398	10	the	the	DT
29633	398	11	product	product	NN
29633	398	12	which	which	WDT
29633	398	13	above	above	IN
29633	398	14	all	all	DT
29633	398	15	was	be	VBD
29633	398	16	to	to	TO
29633	398	17	absorb	absorb	VB
29633	398	18	the	the	DT
29633	398	19	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	398	20	plants	plant	NNS
29633	398	21	in	in	IN
29633	398	22	America	America	NNP
29633	398	23	after	after	IN
29633	398	24	1865	1865	CD
29633	398	25	.	.	.
29633	399	1	After	after	IN
29633	399	2	the	the	DT
29633	399	3	meeting	meeting	NN
29633	399	4	,	,	,
29633	399	5	the	the	DT
29633	399	6	engineers	engineer	NNS
29633	399	7	visited	visit	VBD
29633	399	8	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	399	9	's	's	POS
29633	399	10	works	work	NNS
29633	399	11	;	;	:
29633	399	12	and	and	CC
29633	399	13	later	later	RB
29633	399	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	399	15	was	be	VBD
29633	399	16	reported,[78	reported,[78	CD
29633	399	17	]	]	-RRB-
29633	399	18	"	"	``
29633	399	19	at	at	IN
29633	399	20	Messrs.	Messrs.	NNPS
29633	399	21	John	John	NNP
29633	399	22	Brown	Brown	NNP
29633	399	23	and	and	CC
29633	399	24	Company	Company	NNP
29633	399	25	's	's	POS
29633	399	26	works	work	NNS
29633	399	27	,	,	,
29633	399	28	the	the	DT
29633	399	29	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	399	30	process	process	NN
29633	399	31	was	be	VBD
29633	399	32	repeated	repeat	VBN
29633	399	33	on	on	IN
29633	399	34	a	a	DT
29633	399	35	still	still	RB
29633	399	36	larger	large	JJR
29633	399	37	scale	scale	NN
29633	399	38	and	and	CC
29633	399	39	a	a	DT
29633	399	40	heavy	heavy	JJ
29633	399	41	armor	armor	NN
29633	399	42	plate	plate	NN
29633	399	43	rolled	roll	VBN
29633	399	44	in	in	IN
29633	399	45	the	the	DT
29633	399	46	presence	presence	NN
29633	399	47	of	of	IN
29633	399	48	some	some	DT
29633	399	49	250	250	CD
29633	399	50	visitors	visitor	NNS
29633	399	51	....	....	.
29633	399	52	"	"	''
29633	399	53	[	[	-LRB-
29633	399	54	77	77	CD
29633	399	55	]	]	-RRB-
29633	399	56	_	_	NNP
29633	399	57	The	the	DT
29633	399	58	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	399	59	_	_	NNP
29633	399	60	,	,	,
29633	399	61	1861	1861	CD
29633	399	62	,	,	,
29633	399	63	vol	vol	NNP
29633	399	64	.	.	.
29633	400	1	12	12	CD
29633	400	2	,	,	,
29633	400	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	400	4	10	10	CD
29633	400	5	.	.	.
29633	401	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	401	2	78	78	CD
29633	401	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	401	4	_	_	NNP
29633	401	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	401	6	.	.	.
29633	401	7	_	_	NNP
29633	401	8	,	,	,
29633	401	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	401	10	63	63	CD
29633	401	11	.	.	.
29633	402	1	These	these	DT
29633	402	2	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
29633	402	3	invited	invite	VBD
29633	402	4	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	402	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	402	6	's	's	POS
29633	402	7	intervention	intervention	NN
29633	402	8	.	.	.
29633	403	1	Still	still	RB
29633	403	2	under	under	IN
29633	403	3	the	the	DT
29633	403	4	impression	impression	NN
29633	403	5	that	that	IN
29633	403	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	403	7	patent	patent	NN
29633	403	8	was	be	VBD
29633	403	9	still	still	RB
29633	403	10	alive	alive	JJ
29633	403	11	and	and	CC
29633	403	12	,	,	,
29633	403	13	with	with	IN
29633	403	14	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	403	15	's	's	POS
29633	403	16	,	,	,
29633	403	17	in	in	IN
29633	403	18	the	the	DT
29633	403	19	"	"	``
29633	403	20	able	able	JJ
29633	403	21	hands	hand	NNS
29633	403	22	"	"	''
29633	403	23	of	of	IN
29633	403	24	the	the	DT
29633	403	25	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	403	26	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	403	27	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	403	28	Company	Company	NNP
29633	403	29	,	,	,
29633	403	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	403	31	condemned	condemn	VBD
29633	403	32	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	403	33	for	for	IN
29633	403	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	403	35	"	"	``
29633	403	36	lack	lack	NN
29633	403	37	of	of	IN
29633	403	38	grace	grace	NN
29633	403	39	"	"	''
29633	403	40	to	to	TO
29633	403	41	do	do	VB
29633	403	42	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	403	43	justice	justice	NN
29633	403	44	,	,	,
29633	403	45	and	and	CC
29633	403	46	took	take	VBD
29633	403	47	the	the	DT
29633	403	48	occasion	occasion	NN
29633	403	49	to	to	TO
29633	403	50	indict	indict	VB
29633	403	51	the	the	DT
29633	403	52	patent	patent	NN
29633	403	53	system	system	NN
29633	403	54	which	which	WDT
29633	403	55	denied	deny	VBD
29633	403	56	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	403	57	and	and	CC
29633	403	58	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	403	59	the	the	DT
29633	403	60	fruits	fruit	NNS
29633	403	61	of	of	IN
29633	403	62	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	403	63	labors	labor	NNS
29633	403	64	.	.	.
29633	404	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	404	2	79	79	CD
29633	404	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	404	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	404	5	79	79	CD
29633	404	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	404	7	_	_	NNP
29633	404	8	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	404	9	.	.	.
29633	404	10	_	_	NNP
29633	404	11	,	,	,
29633	404	12	pp	pp	NNP
29633	404	13	.	.	.
29633	405	1	78	78	CD
29633	405	2	and	and	CC
29633	405	3	177	177	CD
29633	405	4	.	.	.
29633	406	1	_	_	NNP
29633	406	2	The	the	DT
29633	406	3	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	406	4	_	_	NNP
29633	406	5	found	find	VBD
29633	406	6	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	406	7	's	's	POS
29633	406	8	position	position	NN
29633	406	9	untenable	untenable	JJ
29633	406	10	on	on	IN
29633	406	11	the	the	DT
29633	406	12	very	very	JJ
29633	406	13	grounds	ground	NNS
29633	406	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	406	15	was	be	VBD
29633	406	16	pleading	plead	VBG
29633	406	17	--	--	:
29633	406	18	that	that	IN
29633	406	19	patents	patent	NNS
29633	406	20	should	should	MD
29633	406	21	not	not	RB
29633	406	22	be	be	VB
29633	406	23	issued	issue	VBN
29633	406	24	to	to	IN
29633	406	25	different	different	JJ
29633	406	26	men	man	NNS
29633	406	27	at	at	IN
29633	406	28	different	different	JJ
29633	406	29	times	time	NNS
29633	406	30	for	for	IN
29633	406	31	the	the	DT
29633	406	32	same	same	JJ
29633	406	33	thing	thing	NN
29633	406	34	;	;	:
29633	406	35	and	and	CC
29633	406	36	showed	show	VBD
29633	406	37	that	that	IN
29633	406	38	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	406	39	in	in	IN
29633	406	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	406	41	patents	patent	NNS
29633	406	42	of	of	IN
29633	406	43	January	January	NNP
29633	406	44	4	4	CD
29633	406	45	,	,	,
29633	406	46	1856	1856	CD
29633	406	47	,	,	,
29633	406	48	and	and	CC
29633	406	49	later	later	RB
29633	406	50	,	,	,
29633	406	51	had	have	VBD
29633	406	52	clearly	clearly	RB
29633	406	53	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
29633	406	54	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	406	55	.	.	.
29633	407	1	In	in	IN
29633	407	2	a	a	DT
29633	407	3	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
29633	407	4	article	article	NN
29633	407	5	,	,	,
29633	407	6	_	_	NNP
29633	407	7	The	the	DT
29633	407	8	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	407	9	_	_	NNP
29633	407	10	disposed	dispose	VBD
29633	407	11	of	of	IN
29633	407	12	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	407	13	's	's	POS
29633	407	14	and	and	CC
29633	407	15	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	407	16	's	's	POS
29633	407	17	claims	claim	NNS
29633	407	18	with	with	IN
29633	407	19	a	a	DT
29633	407	20	certain	certain	JJ
29633	407	21	finality	finality	NN
29633	407	22	.	.	.
29633	408	1	The	the	DT
29633	408	2	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	408	3	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	408	4	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	408	5	Works	Works	NNP
29633	408	6	had	have	VBD
29633	408	7	spent	spend	VBN
29633	408	8	£	£	$
29633	408	9	7,000	7,000	CD
29633	408	10	trying	try	VBG
29633	408	11	to	to	TO
29633	408	12	carry	carry	VB
29633	408	13	out	out	RP
29633	408	14	the	the	DT
29633	408	15	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	408	16	process	process	NN
29633	408	17	and	and	CC
29633	408	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	408	19	was	be	VBD
29633	408	20	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
29633	408	21	that	that	IN
29633	408	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	408	23	would	would	MD
29633	408	24	have	have	VB
29633	408	25	allowed	allow	VBN
29633	408	26	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	408	27	to	to	TO
29633	408	28	infringe	infringe	VB
29633	408	29	upon	upon	IN
29633	408	30	that	that	DT
29633	408	31	patent	patent	NN
29633	408	32	if	if	IN
29633	408	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	408	34	had	have	VBD
29633	408	35	any	any	DT
29633	408	36	grounds	ground	NNS
29633	408	37	for	for	IN
29633	408	38	a	a	DT
29633	408	39	case	case	NN
29633	408	40	.	.	.
29633	409	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	409	2	was	be	VBD
29633	409	3	not	not	RB
29633	409	4	imitating	imitate	VBG
29633	409	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	409	6	.	.	.
29633	410	1	The	the	DT
29633	410	2	latter	latter	NN
29633	410	3	's	's	POS
29633	410	4	"	"	``
29633	410	5	triple	triple	JJ
29633	410	6	compound	compound	NN
29633	410	7	"	"	''
29633	410	8	required	require	VBN
29633	410	9	manganese	manganese	JJ
29633	410	10	pig	pig	NN
29633	410	11	-	-	HYPH
29633	410	12	iron	iron	NN
29633	410	13	(	(	-LRB-
29633	410	14	with	with	IN
29633	410	15	a	a	DT
29633	410	16	content	content	NN
29633	410	17	of	of	IN
29633	410	18	2	2	CD
29633	410	19	to	to	TO
29633	410	20	5	5	CD
29633	410	21	percent	percent	NN
29633	410	22	of	of	IN
29633	410	23	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	410	24	)	)	-RRB-
29633	410	25	at	at	IN
29633	410	26	£	£	$
29633	410	27	13	13	CD
29633	410	28	per	per	IN
29633	410	29	ton	ton	NN
29633	410	30	while	while	IN
29633	410	31	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	410	32	used	use	VBD
29633	410	33	an	an	DT
29633	410	34	oxide	oxide	NN
29633	410	35	of	of	IN
29633	410	36	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	410	37	(	(	-LRB-
29633	410	38	at	at	IN
29633	410	39	a	a	DT
29633	410	40	50	50	CD
29633	410	41	percent	percent	NN
29633	410	42	concentration	concentration	NN
29633	410	43	)	)	-RRB-
29633	410	44	:	:	:
29633	410	45	at	at	IN
29633	410	46	£	£	$
29633	410	47	7	7	CD
29633	410	48	per	per	IN
29633	410	49	ton	ton	NN
29633	410	50	.	.	.
29633	411	1	The	the	DT
29633	411	2	alloy	alloy	NN
29633	411	3	of	of	IN
29633	411	4	manganese	manganese	JJ
29633	411	5	and	and	CC
29633	411	6	other	other	JJ
29633	411	7	materials	material	NNS
29633	411	8	now	now	RB
29633	411	9	used	use	VBN
29633	411	10	in	in	IN
29633	411	11	the	the	DT
29633	411	12	atmospheric	atmospheric	JJ
29633	411	13	process	process	NN
29633	411	14	contains	contain	VBZ
29633	411	15	50	50	CD
29633	411	16	percent	percent	NN
29633	411	17	of	of	IN
29633	411	18	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	411	19	a	a	DT
29633	411	20	proportion	proportion	NN
29633	411	21	which	which	WDT
29633	411	22	could	could	MD
29633	411	23	never	never	RB
29633	411	24	be	be	VB
29633	411	25	obtained	obtain	VBN
29633	411	26	from	from	IN
29633	411	27	the	the	DT
29633	411	28	blast	blast	NN
29633	411	29	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	411	30	,	,	,
29633	411	31	owing	owe	VBG
29633	411	32	to	to	IN
29633	411	33	the	the	DT
29633	411	34	highly	highly	RB
29633	411	35	oxidisable	oxidisable	JJ
29633	411	36	nature	nature	NN
29633	411	37	of	of	IN
29633	411	38	that	that	DT
29633	411	39	metal	metal	NN
29633	411	40	.	.	.
29633	412	1	And	and	CC
29633	412	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	412	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	412	4	absolutely	absolutely	RB
29633	412	5	necessary	necessary	JJ
29633	412	6	,	,	,
29633	412	7	in	in	IN
29633	412	8	order	order	NN
29633	412	9	to	to	TO
29633	412	10	apply	apply	VB
29633	412	11	any	any	DT
29633	412	12	useful	useful	JJ
29633	412	13	alloy	alloy	NN
29633	412	14	of	of	IN
29633	412	15	iron	iron	NN
29633	412	16	,	,	,
29633	412	17	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	412	18	and	and	CC
29633	412	19	manganese	manganese	NN
29633	412	20	,	,	,
29633	412	21	in	in	IN
29633	412	22	the	the	DT
29633	412	23	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	412	24	of	of	IN
29633	412	25	malleable	malleable	JJ
29633	412	26	iron	iron	NN
29633	412	27	and	and	CC
29633	412	28	very	very	RB
29633	412	29	soft	soft	JJ
29633	412	30	steel	steel	NN
29633	412	31	that	that	WDT
29633	412	32	the	the	DT
29633	412	33	manganese	manganese	NNPS
29633	412	34	should	should	MD
29633	412	35	be	be	VB
29633	412	36	largely	largely	RB
29633	412	37	in	in	IN
29633	412	38	excess	excess	NN
29633	412	39	of	of	IN
29633	412	40	the	the	DT
29633	412	41	carbon	carbon	NN
29633	412	42	present	present	NN
29633	412	43	.	.	.
29633	413	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	413	2	80	80	CD
29633	413	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	413	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	413	5	80	80	CD
29633	413	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	413	7	_	_	NNP
29633	413	8	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	413	9	.	.	.
29633	413	10	_	_	NNP
29633	413	11	,	,	,
29633	413	12	p.	p.	NN
29633	413	13	208	208	CD
29633	413	14	.	.	.
29633	414	1	There	there	EX
29633	414	2	is	be	VBZ
29633	414	3	an	an	DT
29633	414	4	intriguing	intriguing	JJ
29633	414	5	reference	reference	NN
29633	414	6	in	in	IN
29633	414	7	this	this	DT
29633	414	8	editorial	editorial	NN
29633	414	9	to	to	IN
29633	414	10	an	an	DT
29633	414	11	interference	interference	NN
29633	414	12	on	on	IN
29633	414	13	behalf	behalf	NN
29633	414	14	of	of	IN
29633	414	15	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	414	16	against	against	IN
29633	414	17	a	a	DT
29633	414	18	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	414	19	application	application	NN
29633	414	20	for	for	IN
29633	414	21	a	a	DT
29633	414	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	414	23	patent	patent	NN
29633	414	24	.	.	.
29633	415	1	No	no	DT
29633	415	2	dates	date	NNS
29633	415	3	are	be	VBP
29633	415	4	given	give	VBN
29633	415	5	and	and	CC
29633	415	6	the	the	DT
29633	415	7	case	case	NN
29633	415	8	has	have	VBZ
29633	415	9	not	not	RB
29633	415	10	been	be	VBN
29633	415	11	located	locate	VBN
29633	415	12	in	in	IN
29633	415	13	the	the	DT
29633	415	14	record	record	NN
29633	415	15	of	of	IN
29633	415	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	415	17	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	415	18	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	415	19	's	's	POS
29633	415	20	decision	decision	NN
29633	415	21	.	.	.
29633	416	1	Sufficient	sufficient	JJ
29633	416	2	answer	answer	NN
29633	416	3	to	to	IN
29633	416	4	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	416	5	was	be	VBD
29633	416	6	at	at	IN
29633	416	7	any	any	DT
29633	416	8	rate	rate	NN
29633	416	9	available	available	JJ
29633	416	10	in	in	IN
29633	416	11	the	the	DT
29633	416	12	fact	fact	NN
29633	416	13	that	that	IN
29633	416	14	many	many	JJ
29633	416	15	hundreds	hundred	NNS
29633	416	16	of	of	IN
29633	416	17	tons	ton	NNS
29633	416	18	of	of	IN
29633	416	19	excellent	excellent	JJ
29633	416	20	"	"	``
29633	416	21	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	416	22	metal	metal	NN
29633	416	23	"	"	''
29633	416	24	made	make	VBN
29633	416	25	without	without	IN
29633	416	26	any	any	DT
29633	416	27	mixture	mixture	NN
29633	416	28	of	of	IN
29633	416	29	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	416	30	or	or	CC
29633	416	31	spiegeleisen	spiegeleisen	VBD
29633	416	32	in	in	IN
29633	416	33	any	any	DT
29633	416	34	form	form	NN
29633	416	35	were	be	VBD
29633	416	36	in	in	IN
29633	416	37	successful	successful	JJ
29633	416	38	use	use	NN
29633	416	39	.	.	.
29633	417	1	And	and	CC
29633	417	2	,	,	,
29633	417	3	moreover	moreover	RB
29633	417	4	,	,	,
29633	417	5	spiegeleisen	spiegeleisen	NNP
29633	417	6	was	be	VBD
29633	417	7	not	not	RB
29633	417	8	a	a	DT
29633	417	9	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	417	10	of	of	IN
29633	417	11	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	417	12	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	417	13	or	or	CC
29633	417	14	an	an	DT
29633	417	15	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
29633	417	16	product	product	NN
29633	417	17	of	of	IN
29633	417	18	Germany	Germany	NNP
29633	417	19	since	since	IN
29633	417	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	417	21	had	have	VBD
29633	417	22	been	be	VBN
29633	417	23	made	make	VBN
29633	417	24	for	for	IN
29633	417	25	twenty	twenty	CD
29633	417	26	years	year	NNS
29633	417	27	at	at	IN
29633	417	28	least	least	JJS
29633	417	29	from	from	IN
29633	417	30	Tow	Tow	NNP
29633	417	31	Law	Law	NNP
29633	417	32	(	(	-LRB-
29633	417	33	Durham	Durham	NNP
29633	417	34	)	)	-RRB-
29633	417	35	ores	ore	NNS
29633	417	36	.	.	.
29633	418	1	If	if	IN
29633	418	2	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	418	3	had	have	VBD
29633	418	4	refused	refuse	VBN
29633	418	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	418	6	a	a	DT
29633	418	7	license	license	NN
29633	418	8	(	(	-LRB-
29633	418	9	and	and	CC
29633	418	10	this	this	DT
29633	418	11	was	be	VBD
29633	418	12	an	an	DT
29633	418	13	admitted	admit	VBN
29633	418	14	fact	fact	NN
29633	418	15	)	)	-RRB-
29633	418	16	,	,	,
29633	418	17	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	418	18	's	's	POS
29633	418	19	refusal	refusal	NN
29633	418	20	must	must	MD
29633	418	21	have	have	VB
29633	418	22	been	be	VBN
29633	418	23	made	make	VBN
29633	418	24	in	in	IN
29633	418	25	self	self	NN
29633	418	26	-	-	HYPH
29633	418	27	defense	defense	NN
29633	418	28	:	:	:
29633	418	29	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	418	30	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	418	31	having	have	VBG
29633	418	32	set	set	VBN
29633	418	33	up	up	RP
29633	418	34	a	a	DT
29633	418	35	number	number	NN
29633	418	36	of	of	IN
29633	418	37	claims	claim	NNS
29633	418	38	for	for	IN
29633	418	39	"	"	``
29633	418	40	improvements	improvement	NNS
29633	418	41	"	"	''
29633	418	42	upon	upon	IN
29633	418	43	which	which	WDT
29633	418	44	claims	claim	NNS
29633	418	45	,	,	,
29633	418	46	we	-PRON-	PRP
29633	418	47	have	have	VBP
29633	418	48	a	a	DT
29633	418	49	right	right	NN
29633	418	50	to	to	TO
29633	418	51	suppose	suppose	VB
29633	418	52	,	,	,
29633	418	53	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	418	54	was	be	VBD
29633	418	55	preparing	prepare	VBG
29633	418	56	to	to	TO
29633	418	57	take	take	VB
29633	418	58	toll	toll	NN
29633	418	59	from	from	IN
29633	418	60	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	418	61	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	418	62	,	,	,
29633	418	63	but	but	CC
29633	418	64	which	which	WDT
29633	418	65	claims	claim	VBZ
29633	418	66	,	,	,
29633	418	67	the	the	DT
29633	418	68	latter	latter	JJ
29633	418	69	gentleman	gentleman	NN
29633	418	70	discovered	discover	VBD
29633	418	71	,	,	,
29633	418	72	in	in	IN
29633	418	73	time	time	NN
29633	418	74	,	,	,
29633	418	75	were	be	VBD
29633	418	76	worthless	worthless	JJ
29633	418	77	and	and	CC
29633	418	78	accordingly	accordingly	RB
29633	418	79	declined	decline	VBD
29633	418	80	any	any	DT
29633	418	81	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
29633	418	82	with	with	IN
29633	418	83	the	the	DT
29633	418	84	individual	individual	NN
29633	418	85	making	make	VBG
29633	418	86	them	-PRON-	PRP
29633	418	87	.	.	.
29633	419	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	419	2	81	81	CD
29633	419	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	419	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	419	5	81	81	CD
29633	419	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	419	7	_	_	NNP
29633	419	8	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	419	9	.	.	.
29633	419	10	_	_	NNP
29633	419	11	,	,	,
29633	419	12	p.	p.	NN
29633	419	13	254	254	CD
29633	419	14	.	.	.
29633	420	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	420	2	's	's	POS
29633	420	3	claims	claim	NNS
29633	420	4	were	be	VBD
29633	420	5	by	by	IN
29633	420	6	this	this	DT
29633	420	7	time	time	NN
29633	420	8	rarely	rarely	RB
29633	420	9	supported	support	VBD
29633	420	10	in	in	IN
29633	420	11	the	the	DT
29633	420	12	periodicals	periodical	NNS
29633	420	13	.	.	.
29633	421	1	One	one	CD
29633	421	2	interesting	interesting	JJ
29633	421	3	article	article	NN
29633	421	4	in	in	IN
29633	421	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	421	6	favor	favor	NN
29633	421	7	came	come	VBD
29633	421	8	in	in	IN
29633	421	9	1864	1864	CD
29633	421	10	from	from	IN
29633	421	11	a	a	DT
29633	421	12	source	source	NN
29633	421	13	of	of	IN
29633	421	14	special	special	JJ
29633	421	15	interest	interest	NN
29633	421	16	to	to	IN
29633	421	17	the	the	DT
29633	421	18	American	american	JJ
29633	421	19	situation	situation	NN
29633	421	20	.	.	.
29633	422	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	422	2	's	's	POS
29633	422	3	American	American	NNP
29633	422	4	patent[82	patent[82	NNP
29633	422	5	]	]	-RRB-
29633	422	6	had	have	VBD
29633	422	7	been	be	VBN
29633	422	8	bought	buy	VBN
29633	422	9	by	by	IN
29633	422	10	an	an	DT
29633	422	11	American	american	JJ
29633	422	12	group	group	NN
29633	422	13	interested	interest	VBN
29633	422	14	in	in	IN
29633	422	15	the	the	DT
29633	422	16	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	422	17	process	process	NN
29633	422	18	at	at	IN
29633	422	19	about	about	IN
29633	422	20	this	this	DT
29633	422	21	time,[83	time,[83	CD
29633	422	22	]	]	-RRB-
29633	422	23	and	and	CC
29633	422	24	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	422	25	's	's	POS
29633	422	26	American	american	JJ
29633	422	27	rights	right	NNS
29633	422	28	had	have	VBD
29633	422	29	also	also	RB
29633	422	30	been	be	VBN
29633	422	31	sold	sell	VBN
29633	422	32	to	to	IN
29633	422	33	an	an	DT
29633	422	34	American	american	JJ
29633	422	35	group	group	NN
29633	422	36	that	that	WDT
29633	422	37	included	include	VBD
29633	422	38	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
29633	422	39	Lyman	Lyman	NNP
29633	422	40	Holley,[84	Holley,[84	VBZ
29633	422	41	]	]	-RRB-
29633	422	42	who	who	WP
29633	422	43	had	have	VBD
29633	422	44	long	long	RB
29633	422	45	been	be	VBN
29633	422	46	associated	associate	VBN
29633	422	47	with	with	IN
29633	422	48	Zerah	Zerah	NNP
29633	422	49	Colburn	Colburn	NNP
29633	422	50	,	,	,
29633	422	51	another	another	DT
29633	422	52	American	american	JJ
29633	422	53	engineer	engineer	NN
29633	422	54	.	.	.
29633	423	1	Colburn	Colburn	NNP
29633	423	2	,	,	,
29633	423	3	who	who	WP
29633	423	4	subsequently	subsequently	RB
29633	423	5	(	(	-LRB-
29633	423	6	1866	1866	CD
29633	423	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	423	8	established	establish	VBD
29633	423	9	the	the	DT
29633	423	10	London	London	NNP
29633	423	11	periodical	periodical	NN
29633	423	12	_	_	NNP
29633	423	13	Engineering	Engineering	NNP
29633	423	14	_	_	NNP
29633	423	15	and	and	CC
29633	423	16	is	be	VBZ
29633	423	17	regarded	regard	VBN
29633	423	18	as	as	IN
29633	423	19	one	one	CD
29633	423	20	of	of	IN
29633	423	21	the	the	DT
29633	423	22	founders	founder	NNS
29633	423	23	of	of	IN
29633	423	24	engineering	engineering	NN
29633	423	25	journalism	journalism	NN
29633	423	26	,	,	,
29633	423	27	was	be	VBD
29633	423	28	from	from	IN
29633	423	29	1862	1862	CD
29633	423	30	onward	onward	RB
29633	423	31	a	a	DT
29633	423	32	frequent	frequent	JJ
29633	423	33	contributor	contributor	NN
29633	423	34	to	to	IN
29633	423	35	other	other	JJ
29633	423	36	trade	trade	NN
29633	423	37	papers	paper	NNS
29633	423	38	in	in	IN
29633	423	39	London	London	NNP
29633	423	40	.	.	.
29633	424	1	Colburn	Colburn	NNP
29633	424	2	's	's	POS
29633	424	3	article	article	NN
29633	424	4	of	of	IN
29633	424	5	1864[85	1864[85	NNS
29633	424	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	424	7	seems	seem	VBZ
29633	424	8	to	to	TO
29633	424	9	have	have	VB
29633	424	10	been	be	VBN
29633	424	11	of	of	IN
29633	424	12	some	some	DT
29633	424	13	importance	importance	NN
29633	424	14	to	to	IN
29633	424	15	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	424	16	,	,	,
29633	424	17	who	who	WP
29633	424	18	,	,	,
29633	424	19	in	in	IN
29633	424	20	the	the	DT
29633	424	21	prospectus	prospectus	NN
29633	424	22	of	of	IN
29633	424	23	the	the	DT
29633	424	24	Titanic	Titanic	NNP
29633	424	25	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	424	26	and	and	CC
29633	424	27	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	424	28	Company	Company	NNP
29633	424	29	,	,	,
29633	424	30	Ltd.	Ltd.	NNP
29633	424	31	,	,	,
29633	424	32	issued	issue	VBN
29633	424	33	soon	soon	RB
29633	424	34	after	after	RB
29633	424	35	,	,	,
29633	424	36	brazenly	brazenly	RB
29633	424	37	asserted[86	asserted[86	NNP
29633	424	38	]	]	-RRB-
29633	424	39	that	that	IN
29633	424	40	,	,	,
29633	424	41	"	"	``
29633	424	42	by	by	IN
29633	424	43	the	the	DT
29633	424	44	process	process	NN
29633	424	45	of	of	IN
29633	424	46	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	424	47	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	424	48	_	_	NNP
29633	424	49	especially	especially	RB
29633	424	50	when	when	WRB
29633	424	51	in	in	IN
29633	424	52	combination	combination	NN
29633	424	53	with	with	IN
29633	424	54	the	the	DT
29633	424	55	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	424	56	process	process	NN
29633	424	57	_	_	NNP
29633	424	58	,	,	,
29633	424	59	steel	steel	NN
29633	424	60	as	as	RB
29633	424	61	good	good	JJ
29633	424	62	as	as	IN
29633	424	63	Swedish	swedish	JJ
29633	424	64	steel	steel	NN
29633	424	65	"	"	''
29633	424	66	would	would	MD
29633	424	67	be	be	VB
29633	424	68	produced	produce	VBN
29633	424	69	at	at	IN
29633	424	70	£	£	$
29633	424	71	6	6	CD
29633	424	72	per	per	IN
29633	424	73	ton	ton	NN
29633	424	74	.	.	.
29633	425	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	425	2	may	may	MD
29633	425	3	have	have	VB
29633	425	4	intended	intend	VBN
29633	425	5	to	to	TO
29633	425	6	invite	invite	VB
29633	425	7	a	a	DT
29633	425	8	patent	patent	NN
29633	425	9	action	action	NN
29633	425	10	,	,	,
29633	425	11	but	but	CC
29633	425	12	evidently	evidently	RB
29633	425	13	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	425	14	could	could	MD
29633	425	15	now	now	RB
29633	425	16	more	more	RBR
29633	425	17	than	than	IN
29633	425	18	ever	ever	RB
29633	425	19	afford	afford	VB
29633	425	20	to	to	TO
29633	425	21	ignore	ignore	VB
29633	425	22	the	the	DT
29633	425	23	"	"	``
29633	425	24	sage	sage	NN
29633	425	25	of	of	IN
29633	425	26	Coleford	Coleford	NNP
29633	425	27	.	.	.
29633	425	28	"	"	''
29633	426	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	426	2	82	82	CD
29633	426	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	426	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	426	5	patent	patent	NN
29633	426	6	17389	17389	CD
29633	426	7	,	,	,
29633	426	8	dated	date	VBN
29633	426	9	May	May	NNP
29633	426	10	26	26	CD
29633	426	11	,	,	,
29633	426	12	1857	1857	CD
29633	426	13	.	.	.
29633	427	1	The	the	DT
29633	427	2	patent	patent	NN
29633	427	3	was	be	VBD
29633	427	4	not	not	RB
29633	427	5	renewed	renew	VBN
29633	427	6	when	when	WRB
29633	427	7	application	application	NN
29633	427	8	was	be	VBD
29633	427	9	made	make	VBN
29633	427	10	in	in	IN
29633	427	11	1870	1870	CD
29633	427	12	,	,	,
29633	427	13	on	on	IN
29633	427	14	the	the	DT
29633	427	15	grounds	ground	NNS
29633	427	16	that	that	IN
29633	427	17	the	the	DT
29633	427	18	original	original	JJ
29633	427	19	patent	patent	NN
29633	427	20	had	have	VBD
29633	427	21	been	be	VBN
29633	427	22	made	make	VBN
29633	427	23	co	co	JJ
29633	427	24	-	-	NN
29633	427	25	terminal	terminal	JJ
29633	427	26	with	with	IN
29633	427	27	the	the	DT
29633	427	28	British	british	JJ
29633	427	29	patent	patent	NN
29633	427	30	.	.	.
29633	428	1	The	the	DT
29633	428	2	latter	latter	JJ
29633	428	3	had	have	VBD
29633	428	4	been	be	VBN
29633	428	5	abandoned	abandon	VBN
29633	428	6	"	"	''
29633	428	7	by	by	IN
29633	428	8	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	428	9	's	's	POS
29633	428	10	own	own	JJ
29633	428	11	fault	fault	NN
29633	428	12	"	"	''
29633	428	13	so	so	IN
29633	428	14	that	that	IN
29633	428	15	no	no	UH
29633	428	16	right	right	RB
29633	428	17	existed	exist	VBD
29633	428	18	to	to	IN
29633	428	19	an	an	DT
29633	428	20	American	american	JJ
29633	428	21	renewal	renewal	NN
29633	428	22	(	(	-LRB-
29633	428	23	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	428	24	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	428	25	Office	Office	NNP
29633	428	26	,	,	,
29633	428	27	Decision	Decision	NNP
29633	428	28	of	of	IN
29633	428	29	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	428	30	of	of	IN
29633	428	31	Patents	Patents	NNPS
29633	428	32	,	,	,
29633	428	33	dated	date	VBN
29633	428	34	September	September	NNP
29633	428	35	19	19	CD
29633	428	36	,	,	,
29633	428	37	1870	1870	CD
29633	428	38	)	)	-RRB-
29633	428	39	.	.	.
29633	429	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	429	2	83	83	CD
29633	429	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	429	4	See	see	VB
29633	429	5	below	below	RB
29633	429	6	,	,	,
29633	429	7	p.	p.	NN
29633	429	8	45	45	CD
29633	429	9	.	.	.
29633	430	1	The	the	DT
29633	430	2	exact	exact	JJ
29633	430	3	date	date	NN
29633	430	4	of	of	IN
29633	430	5	the	the	DT
29633	430	6	purchase	purchase	NN
29633	430	7	of	of	IN
29633	430	8	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	430	9	's	's	POS
29633	430	10	patent	patent	NN
29633	430	11	is	be	VBZ
29633	430	12	not	not	RB
29633	430	13	known	know	VBN
29633	430	14	.	.	.
29633	431	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	431	2	84	84	CD
29633	431	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	431	4	_	_	NNP
29633	431	5	Engineering	Engineering	NNP
29633	431	6	_	_	NNP
29633	431	7	,	,	,
29633	431	8	1882	1882	CD
29633	431	9	,	,	,
29633	431	10	vol	vol	NNP
29633	431	11	.	.	.
29633	432	1	33	33	CD
29633	432	2	,	,	,
29633	432	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	432	4	114	114	CD
29633	432	5	.	.	.
29633	433	1	The	the	DT
29633	433	2	deal	deal	NN
29633	433	3	was	be	VBD
29633	433	4	completed	complete	VBN
29633	433	5	in	in	IN
29633	433	6	1863	1863	CD
29633	433	7	.	.	.
29633	434	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	434	2	85	85	CD
29633	434	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	434	4	_	_	NNP
29633	434	5	The	the	DT
29633	434	6	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	434	7	_	_	NNP
29633	434	8	,	,	,
29633	434	9	1864	1864	CD
29633	434	10	,	,	,
29633	434	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	434	12	.	.	.
29633	435	1	18	18	CD
29633	435	2	,	,	,
29633	435	3	pp	pp	NNP
29633	435	4	.	.	.
29633	436	1	405	405	CD
29633	436	2	,	,	,
29633	436	3	406	406	CD
29633	436	4	.	.	.
29633	437	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	437	2	86	86	CD
29633	437	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	437	4	_	_	NNP
29633	437	5	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	437	6	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	437	7	_	_	NNP
29633	437	8	,	,	,
29633	437	9	1864	1864	CD
29633	437	10	,	,	,
29633	437	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	437	12	.	.	.
29633	438	1	34	34	CD
29633	438	2	,	,	,
29633	438	3	pp	pp	NNP
29633	438	4	.	.	.
29633	439	1	77	77	CD
29633	439	2	and	and	CC
29633	439	3	94	94	CD
29633	439	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	439	5	italics	italic	NNS
29633	439	6	supplied	supply	VBN
29633	439	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	439	8	.	.	.
29633	440	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	440	2	has	have	VBZ
29633	440	3	not	not	RB
29633	440	4	yet	yet	RB
29633	440	5	been	be	VBN
29633	440	6	possible	possible	JJ
29633	440	7	to	to	TO
29633	440	8	ascertain	ascertain	VB
29633	440	9	if	if	IN
29633	440	10	this	this	DT
29633	440	11	company	company	NN
29633	440	12	was	be	VBD
29633	440	13	successful	successful	JJ
29633	440	14	.	.	.
29633	441	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	441	2	writes	write	VBZ
29633	441	3	from	from	IN
29633	441	4	this	this	DT
29633	441	5	time	time	NN
29633	441	6	on	on	RP
29633	441	7	from	from	IN
29633	441	8	Cheltenham	Cheltenham	NNP
29633	441	9	,	,	,
29633	441	10	where	where	WRB
29633	441	11	the	the	DT
29633	441	12	company	company	NN
29633	441	13	had	have	VBD
29633	441	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	441	15	offices	office	NNS
29633	441	16	.	.	.
29633	442	1	Research	research	NN
29633	442	2	continues	continue	VBZ
29633	442	3	in	in	IN
29633	442	4	this	this	DT
29633	442	5	interesting	interesting	JJ
29633	442	6	aspect	aspect	NN
29633	442	7	of	of	IN
29633	442	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	442	9	career	career	NN
29633	442	10	.	.	.
29633	443	1	The	the	DT
29633	443	2	year	year	NN
29633	443	3	1865	1865	CD
29633	443	4	saw	see	VBD
29633	443	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	443	6	less	less	RBR
29633	443	7	provocative	provocative	JJ
29633	443	8	and	and	CC
29633	443	9	more	more	RBR
29633	443	10	appealing	appealing	JJ
29633	443	11	;	;	:
29633	443	12	as	as	IN
29633	443	13	for	for	IN
29633	443	14	instance	instance	NN
29633	443	15	:	:	:
29633	443	16	"	"	``
29633	443	17	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	443	18	was	be	VBD
29633	443	19	no	no	DT
29633	443	20	fault	fault	NN
29633	443	21	of	of	IN
29633	443	22	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	443	23	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	443	24	's	's	POS
29633	443	25	that	that	IN
29633	443	26	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	443	27	patent	patent	NN
29633	443	28	was	be	VBD
29633	443	29	lost	lose	VBN
29633	443	30	,	,	,
29633	443	31	but	but	CC
29633	443	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	443	33	ought	ought	MD
29633	443	34	to	to	TO
29633	443	35	acknowledge	acknowledge	VB
29633	443	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	443	37	obligations	obligation	NNS
29633	443	38	to	to	IN
29633	443	39	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	443	40	in	in	IN
29633	443	41	a	a	DT
29633	443	42	manly	manly	JJ
29633	443	43	,	,	,
29633	443	44	straightforward	straightforward	JJ
29633	443	45	manner	manner	NN
29633	443	46	and	and	CC
29633	443	47	this	this	DT
29633	443	48	would	would	MD
29633	443	49	stamp	stamp	VB
29633	443	50	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	443	51	as	as	IN
29633	443	52	a	a	DT
29633	443	53	great	great	JJ
29633	443	54	man	man	NN
29633	443	55	as	as	RB
29633	443	56	well	well	RB
29633	443	57	as	as	IN
29633	443	58	a	a	DT
29633	443	59	great	great	JJ
29633	443	60	inventor	inventor	NN
29633	443	61	.	.	.
29633	444	1	"	"	``
29633	444	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	444	3	87	87	CD
29633	444	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	444	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	444	6	87	87	CD
29633	444	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	444	8	_	_	NNP
29633	444	9	Mining	Mining	NNP
29633	444	10	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	444	11	_	_	NNP
29633	444	12	,	,	,
29633	444	13	1865	1865	CD
29633	444	14	,	,	,
29633	444	15	vol	vol	NNP
29633	444	16	.	.	.
29633	445	1	35	35	CD
29633	445	2	,	,	,
29633	445	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	445	4	86	86	CD
29633	445	5	.	.	.
29633	446	1	But	but	CC
29633	446	2	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	446	3	evidently	evidently	RB
29633	446	4	remained	remain	VBD
29633	446	5	convinced	convinced	JJ
29633	446	6	of	of	IN
29633	446	7	the	the	DT
29633	446	8	security	security	NN
29633	446	9	of	of	IN
29633	446	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	446	11	own	own	JJ
29633	446	12	patent	patent	NN
29633	446	13	position	position	NN
29633	446	14	.	.	.
29633	447	1	In	in	IN
29633	447	2	an	an	DT
29633	447	3	address	address	NN
29633	447	4	before	before	IN
29633	447	5	the	the	DT
29633	447	6	British	British	NNP
29633	447	7	Association	Association	NNP
29633	447	8	at	at	IN
29633	447	9	Birmingham	Birmingham	NNP
29633	447	10	in	in	IN
29633	447	11	September	September	NNP
29633	447	12	1865	1865	CD
29633	447	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	447	14	made	make	VBD
29633	447	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	447	16	first	first	JJ
29633	447	17	public	public	JJ
29633	447	18	reply	reply	NN
29633	447	19	to	to	IN
29633	447	20	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	447	21	.	.	.
29633	448	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	448	2	88	88	CD
29633	448	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	448	4	In	in	IN
29633	448	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	448	6	long	long	JJ
29633	448	7	series	series	NN
29633	448	8	of	of	IN
29633	448	9	patents	patent	NNS
29633	448	10	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	448	11	had	have	VBD
29633	448	12	attempted	attempt	VBN
29633	448	13	to	to	TO
29633	448	14	secure--	secure--	VB
29633	448	15	almost	almost	RB
29633	448	16	every	every	DT
29633	448	17	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
29633	448	18	mode	mode	NN
29633	448	19	of	of	IN
29633	448	20	introducing	introduce	VBG
29633	448	21	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	448	22	into	into	IN
29633	448	23	the	the	DT
29633	448	24	metal	metal	NN
29633	448	25	....	....	.
29633	448	26	Manganese	Manganese	NNP
29633	448	27	and	and	CC
29633	448	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	448	29	compounds	compound	NNS
29633	448	30	were	be	VBD
29633	448	31	so	so	RB
29633	448	32	claimed	claim	VBN
29633	448	33	under	under	IN
29633	448	34	all	all	DT
29633	448	35	imaginable	imaginable	JJ
29633	448	36	conditions	condition	NNS
29633	448	37	that	that	IN
29633	448	38	if	if	IN
29633	448	39	this	this	DT
29633	448	40	series	series	NN
29633	448	41	of	of	IN
29633	448	42	patents	patent	NNS
29633	448	43	could	could	MD
29633	448	44	have	have	VB
29633	448	45	been	be	VBN
29633	448	46	sustained	sustain	VBN
29633	448	47	in	in	IN
29633	448	48	law	law	NN
29633	448	49	,	,	,
29633	448	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	448	51	would	would	MD
29633	448	52	have	have	VB
29633	448	53	been	be	VBN
29633	448	54	utterly	utterly	RB
29633	448	55	impossible	impossible	JJ
29633	448	56	for	for	IN
29633	448	57	[	[	-LRB-
29633	448	58	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	448	59	]	]	-RRB-
29633	448	60	to	to	TO
29633	448	61	have	have	VB
29633	448	62	employed	employ	VBN
29633	448	63	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	448	64	with	with	IN
29633	448	65	steel	steel	NN
29633	448	66	made	make	VBN
29633	448	67	by	by	IN
29633	448	68	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	448	69	process	process	NN
29633	448	70	,	,	,
29633	448	71	although	although	IN
29633	448	72	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	448	73	was	be	VBD
29633	448	74	considered	consider	VBN
29633	448	75	by	by	IN
29633	448	76	the	the	DT
29633	448	77	trade	trade	NN
29633	448	78	to	to	TO
29633	448	79	be	be	VB
29633	448	80	impossible	impossible	JJ
29633	448	81	to	to	TO
29633	448	82	make	make	VB
29633	448	83	steel	steel	NN
29633	448	84	from	from	IN
29633	448	85	coke	coke	NN
29633	448	86	-	-	HYPH
29633	448	87	made	make	VBN
29633	448	88	iron	iron	NN
29633	448	89	without	without	IN
29633	448	90	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	448	91	.	.	.
29633	449	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	449	2	88	88	CD
29633	449	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	449	4	_	_	NNP
29633	449	5	The	the	DT
29633	449	6	Engineer	Engineer	NNP
29633	449	7	_	_	NNP
29633	449	8	,	,	,
29633	449	9	1865	1865	CD
29633	449	10	,	,	,
29633	449	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	449	12	.	.	.
29633	450	1	20	20	CD
29633	450	2	,	,	,
29633	450	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	450	4	174	174	CD
29633	450	5	.	.	.
29633	451	1	The	the	DT
29633	451	2	failure	failure	NN
29633	451	3	of	of	IN
29633	451	4	those	those	DT
29633	451	5	who	who	WP
29633	451	6	controlled	control	VBD
29633	451	7	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	451	8	's	's	POS
29633	451	9	batch	batch	NN
29633	451	10	of	of	IN
29633	451	11	patents	patent	NNS
29633	451	12	to	to	TO
29633	451	13	renew	renew	VB
29633	451	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
29633	451	15	at	at	IN
29633	451	16	the	the	DT
29633	451	17	end	end	NN
29633	451	18	of	of	IN
29633	451	19	three	three	CD
29633	451	20	years	year	NNS
29633	451	21	,	,	,
29633	451	22	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	451	23	ascribed	ascribe	VBN
29633	451	24	to	to	IN
29633	451	25	the	the	DT
29633	451	26	low	low	JJ
29633	451	27	public	public	JJ
29633	451	28	estimation	estimation	NN
29633	451	29	to	to	TO
29633	451	30	which	which	WDT
29633	451	31	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	451	32	's	's	POS
29633	451	33	process	process	NN
29633	451	34	had	have	VBD
29633	451	35	sunk	sink	VBN
29633	451	36	in	in	IN
29633	451	37	1859	1859	CD
29633	451	38	,	,	,
29633	451	39	and	and	CC
29633	451	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	451	41	had	have	VBD
29633	451	42	therefore	therefore	RB
29633	451	43	,	,	,
29633	451	44	"	"	''
29633	451	45	used	use	VBN
29633	451	46	without	without	IN
29633	451	47	scruple	scruple	NNP
29633	451	48	any	any	DT
29633	451	49	of	of	IN
29633	451	50	these	these	DT
29633	451	51	numerous	numerous	JJ
29633	451	52	patents	patent	NNS
29633	451	53	for	for	IN
29633	451	54	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	451	55	without	without	IN
29633	451	56	feeling	feel	VBG
29633	451	57	an	an	DT
29633	451	58	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
29633	451	59	sense	sense	NN
29633	451	60	of	of	IN
29633	451	61	obligation	obligation	NN
29633	451	62	to	to	IN
29633	451	63	the	the	DT
29633	451	64	patentee	patentee	NN
29633	451	65	.	.	.
29633	451	66	"	"	''
29633	452	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	452	2	was	be	VBD
29633	452	3	now	now	RB
29633	452	4	using	use	VBG
29633	452	5	ferromanganese	ferromanganese	NNP
29633	452	6	made	make	VBN
29633	452	7	in	in	IN
29633	452	8	Glasgow	Glasgow	NNP
29633	452	9	.	.	.
29633	453	1	Another	another	DT
29633	453	2	alloy	alloy	NN
29633	453	3	,	,	,
29633	453	4	consisting	consist	VBG
29633	453	5	of	of	IN
29633	453	6	60	60	CD
29633	453	7	to	to	TO
29633	453	8	80	80	CD
29633	453	9	percent	percent	NN
29633	453	10	of	of	IN
29633	453	11	metallic	metallic	JJ
29633	453	12	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	453	13	was	be	VBD
29633	453	14	also	also	RB
29633	453	15	available	available	JJ
29633	453	16	to	to	IN
29633	453	17	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	453	18	from	from	IN
29633	453	19	Germany	Germany	NNP
29633	453	20	.	.	.
29633	454	1	This	this	DT
29633	454	2	renewed	renew	VBN
29633	454	3	publicity	publicity	NN
29633	454	4	brought	bring	VBN
29633	454	5	forth	forth	RP
29633	454	6	no	no	DT
29633	454	7	immediate	immediate	JJ
29633	454	8	reply	reply	NN
29633	454	9	from	from	IN
29633	454	10	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	454	11	,	,	,
29633	454	12	but	but	CC
29633	454	13	a	a	DT
29633	454	14	year	year	NN
29633	454	15	later	later	RB
29633	454	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	454	17	was	be	VBD
29633	454	18	invited	invite	VBN
29633	454	19	to	to	TO
29633	454	20	read	read	VB
29633	454	21	a	a	DT
29633	454	22	paper	paper	NN
29633	454	23	before	before	IN
29633	454	24	the	the	DT
29633	454	25	British	British	NNP
29633	454	26	Association	Association	NNP
29633	454	27	.	.	.
29633	455	1	A	a	DT
29633	455	2	report	report	NN
29633	455	3	on	on	IN
29633	455	4	the	the	DT
29633	455	5	meeting	meeting	NN
29633	455	6	stated	state	VBD
29633	455	7	that	that	IN
29633	455	8	in	in	IN
29633	455	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	455	10	paper	paper	NN
29633	455	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	455	12	repeated	repeat	VBD
29633	455	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	455	14	oft	oft	RB
29633	455	15	-	-	HYPH
29633	455	16	told	tell	VBN
29633	455	17	story	story	NN
29633	455	18	,	,	,
29633	455	19	and	and	CC
29633	455	20	that	that	IN
29633	455	21	"	"	``
29633	455	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	455	23	still	still	RB
29633	455	24	thought	think	VBD
29633	455	25	that	that	IN
29633	455	26	the	the	DT
29633	455	27	accident	accident	NN
29633	455	28	(	(	-LRB-
29633	455	29	of	of	IN
29633	455	30	the	the	DT
29633	455	31	non	non	JJ
29633	455	32	-	-	JJ
29633	455	33	payment	payment	NN
29633	455	34	of	of	IN
29633	455	35	the	the	DT
29633	455	36	patent	patent	NN
29633	455	37	stamp	stamp	NN
29633	455	38	duties	duty	NNS
29633	455	39	)	)	-RRB-
29633	455	40	ought	ought	MD
29633	455	41	not	not	RB
29633	455	42	to	to	TO
29633	455	43	debar	debar	VB
29633	455	44	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	455	45	from	from	IN
29633	455	46	receiving	receive	VBG
29633	455	47	the	the	DT
29633	455	48	reward	reward	NN
29633	455	49	to	to	TO
29633	455	50	which	which	WDT
29633	455	51	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	455	52	was	be	VBD
29633	455	53	justly	justly	RB
29633	455	54	entitled	entitle	VBN
29633	455	55	.	.	.
29633	455	56	"	"	''
29633	456	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	456	2	,	,	,
29633	456	3	who	who	WP
29633	456	4	was	be	VBD
29633	456	5	present	present	JJ
29633	456	6	,	,	,
29633	456	7	reiterated	reiterate	VBD
29633	456	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	456	9	constant	constant	JJ
29633	456	10	willingness	willingness	NN
29633	456	11	to	to	TO
29633	456	12	submit	submit	VB
29633	456	13	the	the	DT
29633	456	14	matter	matter	NN
29633	456	15	to	to	IN
29633	456	16	the	the	DT
29633	456	17	courts	court	NNS
29633	456	18	of	of	IN
29633	456	19	law	law	NN
29633	456	20	,	,	,
29633	456	21	but	but	CC
29633	456	22	pointed	point	VBD
29633	456	23	out	out	RP
29633	456	24	that	that	IN
29633	456	25	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	456	26	had	have	VBD
29633	456	27	not	not	RB
29633	456	28	accepted	accept	VBN
29633	456	29	the	the	DT
29633	456	30	challenge	challenge	NN
29633	456	31	.	.	.
29633	457	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	457	2	89	89	CD
29633	457	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	457	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	457	5	89	89	CD
29633	457	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	457	7	_	_	NNP
29633	457	8	Mechanics	Mechanics	NNP
29633	457	9	'	'	POS
29633	457	10	Magazine	Magazine	NNP
29633	457	11	_	_	NNP
29633	457	12	,	,	,
29633	457	13	1866	1866	CD
29633	457	14	,	,	,
29633	457	15	vol	vol	NNP
29633	457	16	.	.	.
29633	458	1	16	16	CD
29633	458	2	,	,	,
29633	458	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	458	4	147	147	CD
29633	458	5	.	.	.
29633	459	1	Three	three	CD
29633	459	2	months	month	NNS
29633	459	3	later	later	RB
29633	459	4	,	,	,
29633	459	5	in	in	IN
29633	459	6	December	December	NNP
29633	459	7	1866	1866	CD
29633	459	8	,	,	,
29633	459	9	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	459	10	's	's	POS
29633	459	11	daughter	daughter	NN
29633	459	12	called	call	VBD
29633	459	13	on	on	IN
29633	459	14	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	459	15	and	and	CC
29633	459	16	asked	ask	VBD
29633	459	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	459	18	help	help	NN
29633	459	19	to	to	TO
29633	459	20	prevent	prevent	VB
29633	459	21	the	the	DT
29633	459	22	loss	loss	NN
29633	459	23	of	of	IN
29633	459	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	459	25	home	home	NN
29633	459	26	:	:	:
29633	459	27	"	"	``
29633	459	28	They	-PRON-	PRP
29633	459	29	tell	tell	VBP
29633	459	30	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	459	31	you	-PRON-	PRP
29633	459	32	use	use	VBP
29633	459	33	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	459	34	father	father	NN
29633	459	35	's	's	POS
29633	459	36	inventions	invention	NNS
29633	459	37	and	and	CC
29633	459	38	are	be	VBP
29633	459	39	indebted	indebted	JJ
29633	459	40	to	to	IN
29633	459	41	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	459	42	for	for	IN
29633	459	43	your	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	459	44	success	success	NN
29633	459	45	.	.	.
29633	459	46	"	"	''
29633	460	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	460	2	replied	reply	VBD
29633	460	3	characteristically	characteristically	RB
29633	460	4	:	:	:
29633	460	5	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	460	6	use	use	VBP
29633	460	7	what	what	WP
29633	460	8	your	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	460	9	father	father	NN
29633	460	10	has	have	VBZ
29633	460	11	no	no	DT
29633	460	12	right	right	NN
29633	460	13	to	to	TO
29633	460	14	claim	claim	VB
29633	460	15	;	;	:
29633	460	16	and	and	CC
29633	460	17	if	if	IN
29633	460	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	460	19	had	have	VBD
29633	460	20	the	the	DT
29633	460	21	legal	legal	JJ
29633	460	22	position	position	NN
29633	460	23	you	-PRON-	PRP
29633	460	24	seem	seem	VBP
29633	460	25	to	to	TO
29633	460	26	suppose	suppose	VB
29633	460	27	,	,	,
29633	460	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	460	29	could	could	MD
29633	460	30	stop	stop	VB
29633	460	31	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	460	32	business	business	NN
29633	460	33	by	by	IN
29633	460	34	an	an	DT
29633	460	35	injunction	injunction	NN
29633	460	36	tomorrow	tomorrow	NN
29633	460	37	and	and	CC
29633	460	38	get	get	VB
29633	460	39	many	many	JJ
29633	460	40	thousands	thousand	NNS
29633	460	41	of	of	IN
29633	460	42	pounds	pound	NNS
29633	460	43	compensation	compensation	NN
29633	460	44	for	for	IN
29633	460	45	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	460	46	infringement	infringement	NN
29633	460	47	of	of	IN
29633	460	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	460	49	rights	right	NNS
29633	460	50	.	.	.
29633	461	1	The	the	DT
29633	461	2	only	only	JJ
29633	461	3	result	result	NN
29633	461	4	which	which	WDT
29633	461	5	followed	follow	VBD
29633	461	6	from	from	IN
29633	461	7	your	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	461	8	father	father	NN
29633	461	9	taking	take	VBG
29633	461	10	out	out	RP
29633	461	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	461	12	patents	patent	NNS
29633	461	13	was	be	VBD
29633	461	14	that	that	IN
29633	461	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	461	16	pointed	point	VBD
29633	461	17	out	out	RP
29633	461	18	to	to	IN
29633	461	19	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	461	20	some	some	DT
29633	461	21	rights	right	NNS
29633	461	22	which	which	WDT
29633	461	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	461	24	already	already	RB
29633	461	25	possessed	possess	VBD
29633	461	26	,	,	,
29633	461	27	but	but	CC
29633	461	28	of	of	IN
29633	461	29	which	which	WDT
29633	461	30	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	461	31	was	be	VBD
29633	461	32	not	not	RB
29633	461	33	availing	avail	VBG
29633	461	34	myself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	461	35	.	.	.
29633	462	1	Thus	thus	RB
29633	462	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	462	3	did	do	VBD
29633	462	4	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	462	5	some	some	DT
29633	462	6	service	service	NN
29633	462	7	and	and	CC
29633	462	8	even	even	RB
29633	462	9	for	for	IN
29633	462	10	this	this	DT
29633	462	11	unintentional	unintentional	JJ
29633	462	12	service	service	NN
29633	462	13	,	,	,
29633	462	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	462	15	can	can	MD
29633	462	16	not	not	RB
29633	462	17	live	live	VB
29633	462	18	in	in	IN
29633	462	19	a	a	DT
29633	462	20	state	state	NN
29633	462	21	of	of	IN
29633	462	22	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
29633	462	23	....	....	.
29633	462	24	With	with	IN
29633	462	25	that	that	DT
29633	462	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	462	27	gave	give	VBD
29633	462	28	Miss	Miss	NNP
29633	462	29	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	462	30	money	money	NN
29633	462	31	to	to	TO
29633	462	32	cover	cover	VB
29633	462	33	a	a	DT
29633	462	34	debt	debt	NN
29633	462	35	for	for	IN
29633	462	36	which	which	WDT
29633	462	37	distraint	distraint	NN
29633	462	38	was	be	VBD
29633	462	39	threatened	threaten	VBN
29633	462	40	.	.	.
29633	463	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	463	2	90	90	CD
29633	463	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	463	4	Soon	soon	RB
29633	463	5	after	after	IN
29633	463	6	this	this	DT
29633	463	7	action	action	NN
29633	463	8	,	,	,
29633	463	9	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	463	10	made	make	VBD
29633	463	11	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	463	12	a	a	DT
29633	463	13	"	"	``
29633	463	14	small	small	JJ
29633	463	15	allowance	allowance	NN
29633	463	16	"	"	''
29633	463	17	of	of	IN
29633	463	18	£	£	$
29633	463	19	300	300	CD
29633	463	20	a	a	DT
29633	463	21	year	year	NN
29633	463	22	.	.	.
29633	464	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	464	2	's	's	POS
29633	464	3	reasons	reason	NNS
29633	464	4	for	for	IN
29633	464	5	making	make	VBG
29633	464	6	this	this	DT
29633	464	7	payment	payment	NN
29633	464	8	,	,	,
29633	464	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	464	10	describes	describe	VBZ
29633	464	11	as	as	IN
29633	464	12	follows	follow	VBZ
29633	464	13	:	:	:
29633	464	14	"	"	``
29633	464	15	There	there	EX
29633	464	16	was	be	VBD
29633	464	17	a	a	DT
29633	464	18	strong	strong	JJ
29633	464	19	desire	desire	NN
29633	464	20	on	on	IN
29633	464	21	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	464	22	part	part	NN
29633	464	23	to	to	TO
29633	464	24	make	make	VB
29633	464	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	464	26	(	(	-LRB-
29633	464	27	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	464	28	)	)	-RRB-
29633	464	29	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	464	30	debtor	debtor	NN
29633	464	31	rather	rather	RB
29633	464	32	than	than	IN
29633	464	33	the	the	DT
29633	464	34	reverse	reverse	NN
29633	464	35	,	,	,
29633	464	36	and	and	CC
29633	464	37	the	the	DT
29633	464	38	payment	payment	NN
29633	464	39	had	have	VBD
29633	464	40	other	other	JJ
29633	464	41	advantages	advantage	NNS
29633	464	42	:	:	:
29633	464	43	the	the	DT
29633	464	44	press	press	NN
29633	464	45	at	at	IN
29633	464	46	that	that	DT
29633	464	47	time	time	NN
29633	464	48	was	be	VBD
29633	464	49	violently	violently	RB
29633	464	50	attacking	attack	VBG
29633	464	51	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	464	52	patent	patent	NN
29633	464	53	and	and	CC
29633	464	54	there	there	EX
29633	464	55	was	be	VBD
29633	464	56	the	the	DT
29633	464	57	chance	chance	NN
29633	464	58	that	that	IN
29633	464	59	if	if	IN
29633	464	60	any	any	DT
29633	464	61	of	of	IN
29633	464	62	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	464	63	licensees	licensee	NNS
29633	464	64	were	be	VBD
29633	464	65	thus	thus	RB
29633	464	66	induced	induce	VBN
29633	464	67	to	to	TO
29633	464	68	resist	resist	VB
29633	464	69	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	464	70	claims	claim	NNS
29633	464	71	,	,	,
29633	464	72	all	all	PDT
29633	464	73	the	the	DT
29633	464	74	rest	rest	NN
29633	464	75	might	may	MD
29633	464	76	follow	follow	VB
29633	464	77	the	the	DT
29633	464	78	example	example	NN
29633	464	79	.	.	.
29633	465	1	"	"	``
29633	465	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	465	3	91	91	CD
29633	465	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	465	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	465	6	90	90	CD
29633	465	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	465	8	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	465	9	,	,	,
29633	465	10	_	_	NNP
29633	465	11	op	op	NN
29633	465	12	.	.	.
29633	466	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	466	2	.	.	.
29633	466	3	_	_	NNP
29633	466	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	466	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	466	6	7	7	CD
29633	466	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	466	8	,	,	,
29633	466	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	466	10	294	294	CD
29633	466	11	.	.	.
29633	467	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	467	2	91	91	CD
29633	467	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	467	4	_	_	NNP
29633	467	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	467	6	.	.	.
29633	467	7	_	_	NNP
29633	467	8	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	467	9	's	's	POS
29633	467	10	Titanic	Titanic	NNP
29633	467	11	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	467	12	and	and	CC
29633	467	13	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	467	14	Company	Company	NNP
29633	467	15	was	be	VBD
29633	467	16	liquidated	liquidate	VBN
29633	467	17	in	in	IN
29633	467	18	1871	1871	CD
29633	467	19	and	and	CC
29633	467	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	467	21	principal	principal	JJ
29633	467	22	asset	asset	NN
29633	467	23	,	,	,
29633	467	24	"	"	''
29633	467	25	R.	R.	NNP
29633	467	26	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	467	27	's	's	POS
29633	467	28	special	special	JJ
29633	467	29	steel	steel	NN
29633	467	30	,	,	,
29633	467	31	"	"	''
29633	467	32	that	that	RB
29633	467	33	is	is	RB
29633	467	34	,	,	,
29633	467	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	467	36	tungsten	tungsten	NN
29633	467	37	alloy	alloy	NN
29633	467	38	tool	tool	NN
29633	467	39	metal	metal	NN
29633	467	40	,	,	,
29633	467	41	was	be	VBD
29633	467	42	taken	take	VBN
29633	467	43	over	over	RP
29633	467	44	by	by	IN
29633	467	45	the	the	DT
29633	467	46	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	467	47	firm	firm	NN
29633	467	48	of	of	IN
29633	467	49	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
29633	467	50	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
29633	467	51	and	and	CC
29633	467	52	Company	Company	NNP
29633	467	53	.	.	.
29633	468	1	The	the	DT
29633	468	2	royalties	royalty	NNS
29633	468	3	from	from	IN
29633	468	4	this	this	DT
29633	468	5	,	,	,
29633	468	6	with	with	IN
29633	468	7	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	468	8	's	's	POS
29633	468	9	pension	pension	NN
29633	468	10	seem	seem	VBP
29633	468	11	to	to	TO
29633	468	12	have	have	VB
29633	468	13	left	leave	VBN
29633	468	14	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	468	15	in	in	IN
29633	468	16	a	a	DT
29633	468	17	reasonably	reasonably	RB
29633	468	18	comfortable	comfortable	JJ
29633	468	19	condition	condition	NN
29633	468	20	until	until	IN
29633	468	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	468	22	death	death	NN
29633	468	23	in	in	IN
29633	468	24	1891;[92	1891;[92	CD
29633	468	25	]	]	-RRB-
29633	468	26	but	but	CC
29633	468	27	even	even	RB
29633	468	28	the	the	DT
29633	468	29	award	award	NN
29633	468	30	of	of	IN
29633	468	31	the	the	DT
29633	468	32	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	468	33	medal	medal	NN
29633	468	34	by	by	IN
29633	468	35	the	the	DT
29633	468	36	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	468	37	and	and	CC
29633	468	38	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	468	39	Institute	Institute	NNP
29633	468	40	in	in	IN
29633	468	41	1876	1876	CD
29633	468	42	failed	fail	VBD
29633	468	43	to	to	TO
29633	468	44	remove	remove	VB
29633	468	45	the	the	DT
29633	468	46	conviction	conviction	NN
29633	468	47	that	that	IN
29633	468	48	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	468	49	had	have	VBD
29633	468	50	been	be	VBN
29633	468	51	badly	badly	RB
29633	468	52	treated	treat	VBN
29633	468	53	.	.	.
29633	469	1	One	one	PRP
29633	469	2	would	would	MD
29633	469	3	like	like	VB
29633	469	4	to	to	TO
29633	469	5	know	know	VB
29633	469	6	more	more	JJR
29633	469	7	about	about	IN
29633	469	8	the	the	DT
29633	469	9	politics	politic	NNS
29633	469	10	which	which	WDT
29633	469	11	preceded	precede	VBD
29633	469	12	the	the	DT
29633	469	13	award	award	NN
29633	469	14	of	of	IN
29633	469	15	the	the	DT
29633	469	16	trade	trade	NN
29633	469	17	's	's	POS
29633	469	18	highest	high	JJS
29633	469	19	honor	honor	NN
29633	469	20	.	.	.
29633	470	1	Bessemer	bessemer	NN
29633	470	2	at	at	IN
29633	470	3	any	any	DT
29633	470	4	rate	rate	NN
29633	470	5	was	be	VBD
29633	470	6	persuaded	persuade	VBN
29633	470	7	to	to	TO
29633	470	8	approve	approve	VB
29633	470	9	of	of	IN
29633	470	10	the	the	DT
29633	470	11	presentation	presentation	NN
29633	470	12	and	and	CC
29633	470	13	attended	attend	VBD
29633	470	14	the	the	DT
29633	470	15	meeting	meeting	NN
29633	470	16	.	.	.
29633	471	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	471	2	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	471	3	did	do	VBD
29633	471	4	not	not	RB
29633	471	5	accept	accept	VB
29633	471	6	the	the	DT
29633	471	7	invitation	invitation	NN
29633	471	8	,	,	,
29633	471	9	"	"	``
29633	471	10	as	as	IN
29633	471	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	471	12	may	may	MD
29633	471	13	probably	probably	RB
29633	471	14	not	not	RB
29633	471	15	be	be	VB
29633	471	16	then	then	RB
29633	471	17	alive	alive	JJ
29633	471	18	.	.	.
29633	472	1	"	"	``
29633	472	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	472	3	93	93	CD
29633	472	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	472	5	The	the	DT
29633	472	6	President	President	NNP
29633	472	7	of	of	IN
29633	472	8	the	the	DT
29633	472	9	Institute	Institute	NNP
29633	472	10	emphasized	emphasize	VBD
29633	472	11	the	the	DT
29633	472	12	present	present	JJ
29633	472	13	good	good	JJ
29633	472	14	relations	relation	NNS
29633	472	15	between	between	IN
29633	472	16	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	472	17	and	and	CC
29633	472	18	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	472	19	and	and	CC
29633	472	20	the	the	DT
29633	472	21	latter	latter	JJ
29633	472	22	recorded	record	VBD
29633	472	23	that	that	IN
29633	472	24	the	the	DT
29633	472	25	hatchet	hatchet	NN
29633	472	26	had	have	VBD
29633	472	27	"	"	``
29633	472	28	long	long	RB
29633	472	29	since	since	IN
29633	472	30	"	"	''
29633	472	31	been	be	VBN
29633	472	32	buried	bury	VBN
29633	472	33	.	.	.
29633	473	1	Yet	yet	CC
29633	473	2	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	473	3	continued	continue	VBD
29633	473	4	to	to	TO
29633	473	5	brood	brood	VB
29633	473	6	over	over	IN
29633	473	7	the	the	DT
29633	473	8	injustice	injustice	NN
29633	473	9	done	do	VBN
29633	473	10	to	to	IN
29633	473	11	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	473	12	and	and	CC
29633	473	13	eventually	eventually	RB
29633	473	14	recorded	record	VBD
29633	473	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	473	16	story	story	NN
29633	473	17	of	of	IN
29633	473	18	the	the	DT
29633	473	19	rise	rise	NN
29633	473	20	and	and	CC
29633	473	21	progress	progress	NN
29633	473	22	of	of	IN
29633	473	23	the	the	DT
29633	473	24	"	"	``
29633	473	25	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	473	26	-	-	HYPH
29633	473	27	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	473	28	"	"	''
29633	473	29	process	process	NN
29633	473	30	in	in	IN
29633	473	31	a	a	DT
29633	473	32	pamphlet[94	pamphlet[94	NN
29633	473	33	]	]	-RRB-
29633	473	34	written	write	VBN
29633	473	35	apparently	apparently	RB
29633	473	36	without	without	IN
29633	473	37	reference	reference	NN
29633	473	38	to	to	IN
29633	473	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	473	40	earlier	early	JJR
29633	473	41	statements	statement	NNS
29633	473	42	and	and	CC
29633	473	43	so	so	RB
29633	473	44	committing	commit	VBG
29633	473	45	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	473	46	to	to	IN
29633	473	47	many	many	JJ
29633	473	48	inconsistencies	inconsistency	NNS
29633	473	49	.	.	.
29633	474	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	474	2	92	92	CD
29633	474	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	474	4	See	see	VB
29633	474	5	Fred	Fred	NNP
29633	474	6	M.	M.	NNP
29633	474	7	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
29633	474	8	,	,	,
29633	474	9	_	_	NNP
29633	474	10	The	the	DT
29633	474	11	story	story	NN
29633	474	12	of	of	IN
29633	474	13	the	the	DT
29633	474	14	Mushets	Mushets	NNPS
29633	474	15	_	_	NNP
29633	474	16	,	,	,
29633	474	17	London	London	NNP
29633	474	18	,	,	,
29633	474	19	1852	1852	CD
29633	474	20	.	.	.
29633	475	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	475	2	93	93	CD
29633	475	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	475	4	_	_	NNP
29633	475	5	Journal	Journal	NNP
29633	475	6	of	of	IN
29633	475	7	the	the	DT
29633	475	8	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	475	9	and	and	CC
29633	475	10	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	475	11	Institute	Institute	NNP
29633	475	12	_	_	NNP
29633	475	13	,	,	,
29633	475	14	1876	1876	CD
29633	475	15	,	,	,
29633	475	16	p.	p.	NN
29633	475	17	3	3	CD
29633	475	18	.	.	.
29633	476	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	476	2	94	94	CD
29633	476	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	476	4	Robert	Robert	NNP
29633	476	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	476	6	,	,	,
29633	476	7	_	_	NNP
29633	476	8	The	the	DT
29633	476	9	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	476	10	-	-	HYPH
29633	476	11	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	476	12	process	process	NN
29633	476	13	_	_	NNP
29633	476	14	,	,	,
29633	476	15	Cheltenham	Cheltenham	NNP
29633	476	16	,	,	,
29633	476	17	1883	1883	CD
29633	476	18	.	.	.
29633	477	1	William	William	NNP
29633	477	2	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	477	3	's	's	POS
29633	477	4	"	"	``
29633	477	5	Air	air	NN
29633	477	6	-	-	HYPH
29633	477	7	boiling	boil	VBG
29633	477	8	"	"	''
29633	477	9	Process	Process	NNP
29633	477	10	An	an	DT
29633	477	11	account	account	NN
29633	477	12	of	of	IN
29633	477	13	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	477	14	's	's	POS
29633	477	15	address	address	NN
29633	477	16	to	to	IN
29633	477	17	the	the	DT
29633	477	18	British	British	NNP
29633	477	19	Association	Association	NNP
29633	477	20	was	be	VBD
29633	477	21	published	publish	VBN
29633	477	22	in	in	IN
29633	477	23	the	the	DT
29633	477	24	_	_	NNP
29633	477	25	Scientific	Scientific	NNP
29633	477	26	American	American	NNP
29633	477	27	_	_	NNP
29633	477	28	on	on	IN
29633	477	29	September	September	NNP
29633	477	30	13	13	CD
29633	477	31	,	,	,
29633	477	32	1856	1856	CD
29633	477	33	.	.	.
29633	478	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	478	2	95	95	CD
29633	478	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	478	4	On	on	IN
29633	478	5	September	September	NNP
29633	478	6	16	16	CD
29633	478	7	,	,	,
29633	478	8	1856	1856	CD
29633	478	9	,	,	,
29633	478	10	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	478	11	filed	file	VBD
29633	478	12	application	application	NN
29633	478	13	for	for	IN
29633	478	14	a	a	DT
29633	478	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	478	16	patent	patent	NN
29633	478	17	on	on	IN
29633	478	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	478	19	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	478	20	and	and	CC
29633	478	21	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	478	22	for	for	IN
29633	478	23	one	one	CD
29633	478	24	on	on	IN
29633	478	25	the	the	DT
29633	478	26	application	application	NN
29633	478	27	of	of	IN
29633	478	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	478	29	triple	triple	JJ
29633	478	30	compound	compound	NN
29633	478	31	to	to	TO
29633	478	32	cast	cast	VB
29633	478	33	iron	iron	NN
29633	478	34	"	"	''
29633	478	35	purified	purify	VBN
29633	478	36	or	or	CC
29633	478	37	decarbonized	decarbonize	VBN
29633	478	38	by	by	IN
29633	478	39	the	the	DT
29633	478	40	action	action	NN
29633	478	41	of	of	IN
29633	478	42	air	air	NN
29633	478	43	blown	blow	VBN
29633	478	44	or	or	CC
29633	478	45	forced	force	VBN
29633	478	46	into	into	IN
29633	478	47	...	...	NFP
29633	478	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	478	49	particles	particle	NNS
29633	478	50	while	while	IN
29633	478	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	478	52	is	be	VBZ
29633	478	53	in	in	IN
29633	478	54	a	a	DT
29633	478	55	molten	molten	NN
29633	478	56	...	...	.
29633	479	1	state	state	NN
29633	479	2	.	.	.
29633	480	1	"	"	``
29633	480	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	480	3	96	96	CD
29633	480	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	480	5	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	480	6	,	,	,
29633	480	7	by	by	IN
29633	480	8	this	this	DT
29633	480	9	time	time	NN
29633	480	10	,	,	,
29633	480	11	had	have	VBD
29633	480	12	apparently	apparently	RB
29633	480	13	decided	decide	VBN
29633	480	14	to	to	TO
29633	480	15	generalize	generalize	VB
29633	480	16	the	the	DT
29633	480	17	application	application	NN
29633	480	18	of	of	IN
29633	480	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	480	20	compound	compound	NN
29633	480	21	instead	instead	RB
29633	480	22	of	of	IN
29633	480	23	citing	cite	VBG
29633	480	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	480	25	use	use	NN
29633	480	26	in	in	IN
29633	480	27	conjunction	conjunction	NN
29633	480	28	with	with	IN
29633	480	29	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	480	30	's	's	POS
29633	480	31	process	process	NN
29633	480	32	,	,	,
29633	480	33	or	or	CC
29633	480	34	,	,	,
29633	480	35	as	as	IN
29633	480	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	480	37	put	put	VBD
29633	480	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	480	39	,	,	,
29633	480	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	480	41	had	have	VBD
29633	480	42	been	be	VBN
29633	480	43	obliged	oblige	VBN
29633	480	44	to	to	TO
29633	480	45	do	do	VB
29633	480	46	for	for	IN
29633	480	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	480	48	English	english	JJ
29633	480	49	specification	specification	NN
29633	480	50	by	by	IN
29633	480	51	the	the	DT
29633	480	52	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	480	53	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	480	54	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	480	55	Works	Works	NNP
29633	480	56	.	.	.
29633	481	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	481	2	95	95	CD
29633	481	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	481	4	_	_	NNP
29633	481	5	Scientific	Scientific	NNP
29633	481	6	American	American	NNP
29633	481	7	_	_	NNP
29633	481	8	,	,	,
29633	481	9	1856	1856	CD
29633	481	10	,	,	,
29633	481	11	vol	vol	NNP
29633	481	12	.	.	.
29633	482	1	12	12	CD
29633	482	2	,	,	,
29633	482	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	482	4	6	6	CD
29633	482	5	.	.	.
29633	483	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	483	2	96	96	CD
29633	483	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	483	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	483	5	patent	patent	NN
29633	483	6	17389	17389	CD
29633	483	7	,	,	,
29633	483	8	dated	date	VBN
29633	483	9	May	May	NNP
29633	483	10	26	26	CD
29633	483	11	,	,	,
29633	483	12	1857	1857	CD
29633	483	13	.	.	.
29633	484	1	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	484	2	's	's	POS
29633	484	3	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	484	4	patent	patent	NN
29633	484	5	was	be	VBD
29633	484	6	granted	grant	VBN
29633	484	7	as	as	IN
29633	484	8	16690	16690	CD
29633	484	9	,	,	,
29633	484	10	dated	date	VBN
29633	484	11	February	February	NNP
29633	484	12	24	24	CD
29633	484	13	,	,	,
29633	484	14	1857	1857	CD
29633	484	15	.	.	.
29633	485	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	485	2	Illustration	illustration	NN
29633	485	3	:	:	:
29633	485	4	Figure	figure	NN
29633	485	5	2.--ONLY	2.--only	CD
29633	485	6	KNOWN	known	NN
29633	485	7	DESIGN	design	NN
29633	485	8	FOR	for	IN
29633	485	9	KELLY	KELLY	NNP
29633	485	10	'S	's	POS
29633	485	11	AIR	AIR	NNP
29633	485	12	-	-	HYPH
29633	485	13	BOILING	BOILING	NNP
29633	485	14	FURNACE	FURNACE	NNS
29633	485	15	,	,	,
29633	485	16	FROM	from	IN
29633	485	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	485	18	PATENT	patent	NN
29633	485	19	17628	17628	CD
29633	485	20	.	.	.
29633	486	1	_	_	NNP
29633	486	2	A	a	DT
29633	486	3	_	_	NNP
29633	486	4	is	be	VBZ
29633	486	5	"	"	``
29633	486	6	the	the	DT
29633	486	7	flue	flue	NN
29633	486	8	to	to	TO
29633	486	9	carry	carry	VB
29633	486	10	off	off	RP
29633	486	11	the	the	DT
29633	486	12	carbonic	carbonic	JJ
29633	486	13	gas	gas	NN
29633	486	14	formed	form	VBN
29633	486	15	in	in	IN
29633	486	16	decarbonizing	decarbonize	VBG
29633	486	17	the	the	DT
29633	486	18	iron	iron	NN
29633	486	19	,	,	,
29633	486	20	"	"	''
29633	486	21	_	_	NNP
29633	486	22	B	B	NNP
29633	486	23	_	_	NNP
29633	486	24	is	be	VBZ
29633	486	25	the	the	DT
29633	486	26	port	port	NN
29633	486	27	through	through	IN
29633	486	28	which	which	WDT
29633	486	29	the	the	DT
29633	486	30	charge	charge	NN
29633	486	31	of	of	IN
29633	486	32	fluid	fluid	JJ
29633	486	33	iron	iron	NN
29633	486	34	is	be	VBZ
29633	486	35	received	receive	VBN
29633	486	36	,	,	,
29633	486	37	_	_	NNP
29633	486	38	C	C	NNP
29633	486	39	_	_	NNP
29633	486	40	and	and	CC
29633	486	41	_	_	NNP
29633	486	42	C	C	NNP
29633	486	43	'	'	''
29633	486	44	_	_	NNP
29633	486	45	are	be	VBP
29633	486	46	the	the	DT
29633	486	47	tuyères	tuyère	NNS
29633	486	48	,	,	,
29633	486	49	and	and	CC
29633	486	50	_	_	NNP
29633	486	51	D	D	NNP
29633	486	52	_	_	NNP
29633	486	53	is	be	VBZ
29633	486	54	the	the	DT
29633	486	55	tap	tap	NN
29633	486	56	hole	hole	NN
29633	486	57	for	for	IN
29633	486	58	letting	let	VBG
29633	486	59	out	out	RP
29633	486	60	the	the	DT
29633	486	61	refined	refined	JJ
29633	486	62	metal	metal	NN
29633	486	63	.	.	.
29633	486	64	]	]	-RRB-
29633	487	1	The	the	DT
29633	487	2	discussion	discussion	NN
29633	487	3	in	in	IN
29633	487	4	the	the	DT
29633	487	5	_	_	NNP
29633	487	6	Scientific	Scientific	NNP
29633	487	7	American	American	NNP
29633	487	8	_	_	NNP
29633	487	9	,	,	,
29633	487	10	which	which	WDT
29633	487	11	was	be	VBD
29633	487	12	mostly	mostly	RB
29633	487	13	concerned	concern	VBN
29633	487	14	with	with	IN
29633	487	15	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	487	16	's	's	POS
29633	487	17	claim	claim	NN
29633	487	18	to	to	IN
29633	487	19	priority	priority	NN
29633	487	20	,	,	,
29633	487	21	soon	soon	RB
29633	487	22	evoked	evoke	VBD
29633	487	23	a	a	DT
29633	487	24	letter	letter	NN
29633	487	25	from	from	IN
29633	487	26	William	William	NNP
29633	487	27	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	487	28	.	.	.
29633	488	1	Writing	write	VBG
29633	488	2	under	under	IN
29633	488	3	date	date	NN
29633	488	4	of	of	IN
29633	488	5	September	September	NNP
29633	488	6	30	30	CD
29633	488	7	,	,	,
29633	488	8	1856	1856	CD
29633	488	9	,	,	,
29633	488	10	from	from	IN
29633	488	11	the	the	DT
29633	488	12	Suwanee	Suwanee	NNP
29633	488	13	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	488	14	Works	Works	NNP
29633	488	15	,	,	,
29633	488	16	Eddyville	Eddyville	NNP
29633	488	17	,	,	,
29633	488	18	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
29633	488	19	,	,	,
29633	488	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	488	21	claimed	claim	VBD
29633	488	22	to	to	TO
29633	488	23	have	have	VB
29633	488	24	started	start	VBN
29633	488	25	"	"	``
29633	488	26	a	a	DT
29633	488	27	series	series	NN
29633	488	28	of	of	IN
29633	488	29	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	488	30	"	"	''
29633	488	31	in	in	IN
29633	488	32	November	November	NNP
29633	488	33	1851	1851	CD
29633	488	34	which	which	WDT
29633	488	35	had	have	VBD
29633	488	36	been	be	VBN
29633	488	37	witnessed	witness	VBN
29633	488	38	by	by	IN
29633	488	39	hundreds	hundred	NNS
29633	488	40	of	of	IN
29633	488	41	persons	person	NNS
29633	488	42	and	and	CC
29633	488	43	"	"	``
29633	488	44	discussed	discuss	VBN
29633	488	45	amongst	amongst	IN
29633	488	46	the	the	DT
29633	488	47	ironmasters	ironmaster	NNS
29633	488	48	,	,	,
29633	488	49	etc	etc	FW
29633	488	50	.	.	.
29633	488	51	,	,	,
29633	488	52	of	of	IN
29633	488	53	this	this	DT
29633	488	54	section	section	NN
29633	488	55	,	,	,
29633	488	56	all	all	DT
29633	488	57	of	of	IN
29633	488	58	whom	whom	WP
29633	488	59	are	be	VBP
29633	488	60	perfectly	perfectly	RB
29633	488	61	familiar	familiar	JJ
29633	488	62	with	with	IN
29633	488	63	the	the	DT
29633	488	64	whole	whole	JJ
29633	488	65	principle	principle	NN
29633	488	66	...	...	:
29633	488	67	as	as	IN
29633	488	68	discovered	discover	VBN
29633	488	69	by	by	IN
29633	488	70	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	488	71	nearly	nearly	RB
29633	488	72	five	five	CD
29633	488	73	years	year	NNS
29633	488	74	ago	ago	RB
29633	488	75	.	.	.
29633	488	76	"	"	''
29633	489	1	A	a	DT
29633	489	2	number	number	NN
29633	489	3	of	of	IN
29633	489	4	English	english	JJ
29633	489	5	puddlers	puddler	NNS
29633	489	6	had	have	VBD
29633	489	7	visited	visit	VBN
29633	489	8	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	489	9	to	to	TO
29633	489	10	see	see	VB
29633	489	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	489	12	new	new	JJ
29633	489	13	process	process	NN
29633	489	14	.	.	.
29633	490	1	"	"	``
29633	490	2	Several	several	JJ
29633	490	3	of	of	IN
29633	490	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
29633	490	5	have	have	VBP
29633	490	6	since	since	IN
29633	490	7	returned	return	VBN
29633	490	8	to	to	IN
29633	490	9	England	England	NNP
29633	490	10	and	and	CC
29633	490	11	may	may	MD
29633	490	12	have	have	VB
29633	490	13	spoken	speak	VBN
29633	490	14	of	of	IN
29633	490	15	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	490	16	invention	invention	NN
29633	490	17	there	there	RB
29633	490	18	.	.	.
29633	490	19	"	"	''
29633	491	1	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	491	2	expected	expect	VBD
29633	491	3	"	"	``
29633	491	4	shortly	shortly	RB
29633	491	5	to	to	TO
29633	491	6	have	have	VB
29633	491	7	the	the	DT
29633	491	8	invention	invention	NN
29633	491	9	perfected	perfect	VBD
29633	491	10	and	and	CC
29633	491	11	bring	bring	VB
29633	491	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	491	13	before	before	IN
29633	491	14	the	the	DT
29633	491	15	public	public	NN
29633	491	16	.	.	.
29633	492	1	"	"	``
29633	492	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	492	3	97	97	CD
29633	492	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	492	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	492	6	97	97	CD
29633	492	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	492	8	_	_	NNP
29633	492	9	Scientific	Scientific	NNP
29633	492	10	American	American	NNP
29633	492	11	_	_	NNP
29633	492	12	,	,	,
29633	492	13	1856	1856	CD
29633	492	14	,	,	,
29633	492	15	vol	vol	NNP
29633	492	16	.	.	.
29633	493	1	12	12	CD
29633	493	2	,	,	,
29633	493	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	493	4	43	43	CD
29633	493	5	,	,	,
29633	493	6	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	493	7	's	's	POS
29633	493	8	suggestion	suggestion	NN
29633	493	9	of	of	IN
29633	493	10	piracy	piracy	NN
29633	493	11	of	of	IN
29633	493	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	493	13	ideas	idea	NNS
29633	493	14	was	be	VBD
29633	493	15	later	later	RB
29633	493	16	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
29633	493	17	upon	upon	IN
29633	493	18	by	by	IN
29633	493	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	493	20	biographer	biographer	NN
29633	493	21	John	John	NNP
29633	493	22	Newton	Newton	NNP
29633	493	23	Boucher	Boucher	NNP
29633	493	24	,	,	,
29633	493	25	_	_	NNP
29633	493	26	William	William	NNP
29633	493	27	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	493	28	:	:	:
29633	493	29	A	a	DT
29633	493	30	true	true	JJ
29633	493	31	history	history	NN
29633	493	32	of	of	IN
29633	493	33	the	the	DT
29633	493	34	so	so	RB
29633	493	35	-	-	HYPH
29633	493	36	called	call	VBN
29633	493	37	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	493	38	process	process	NN
29633	493	39	_	_	NNP
29633	493	40	,	,	,
29633	493	41	Greensburg	Greensburg	NNP
29633	493	42	,	,	,
29633	493	43	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
29633	493	44	,	,	,
29633	493	45	1924	1924	CD
29633	493	46	.	.	.
29633	494	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	494	2	's	's	POS
29633	494	3	application	application	NN
29633	494	4	for	for	IN
29633	494	5	an	an	DT
29633	494	6	American	american	JJ
29633	494	7	patent	patent	NN
29633	494	8	was	be	VBD
29633	494	9	granted	grant	VBN
29633	494	10	during	during	IN
29633	494	11	the	the	DT
29633	494	12	week	week	NN
29633	494	13	ending	end	VBG
29633	494	14	November	November	NNP
29633	494	15	18	18	CD
29633	494	16	,	,	,
29633	494	17	1856	1856	CD
29633	494	18	,	,	,
29633	494	19	and	and	CC
29633	494	20	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	494	21	began	begin	VBD
29633	494	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	494	23	interference	interference	NN
29633	494	24	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
29633	494	25	sometime	sometime	RB
29633	494	26	before	before	IN
29633	494	27	January	January	NNP
29633	494	28	1857	1857	CD
29633	494	29	.	.	.
29633	495	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	495	2	98	98	CD
29633	495	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	495	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	495	5	98	98	CD
29633	495	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	495	7	_	_	NNP
29633	495	8	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	495	9	.	.	.
29633	495	10	_	_	NNP
29633	495	11	,	,	,
29633	495	12	p.	p.	NN
29633	495	13	82	82	CD
29633	495	14	.	.	.
29633	496	1	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	496	2	's	's	POS
29633	496	3	notice	notice	NN
29633	496	4	of	of	IN
29633	496	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	496	6	intention	intention	NN
29633	496	7	to	to	TO
29633	496	8	take	take	VB
29633	496	9	testimony	testimony	NN
29633	496	10	was	be	VBD
29633	496	11	addressed	address	VBN
29633	496	12	to	to	IN
29633	496	13	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	496	14	on	on	IN
29633	496	15	January	January	NNP
29633	496	16	12	12	CD
29633	496	17	,	,	,
29633	496	18	1857	1857	CD
29633	496	19	.	.	.
29633	497	1	See	see	VB
29633	497	2	papers	paper	NNS
29633	497	3	on	on	IN
29633	497	4	"	"	``
29633	497	5	Interference	Interference	NNP
29633	497	6	,	,	,
29633	497	7	William	William	NNP
29633	497	8	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	497	9	vs.	vs.	IN
29633	497	10	Henry	Henry	NNP
29633	497	11	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	497	12	Decision	Decision	NNP
29633	497	13	April	April	NNP
29633	497	14	13	13	CD
29633	497	15	,	,	,
29633	497	16	1857	1857	CD
29633	497	17	.	.	.
29633	497	18	"	"	''
29633	498	1	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	498	2	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	498	3	Office	Office	NNP
29633	498	4	Records	Records	NNPS
29633	498	5	.	.	.
29633	499	1	Quotations	quotation	NNS
29633	499	2	below	below	RB
29633	499	3	are	be	VBP
29633	499	4	from	from	IN
29633	499	5	this	this	DT
29633	499	6	file	file	NN
29633	499	7	,	,	,
29633	499	8	which	which	WDT
29633	499	9	is	be	VBZ
29633	499	10	now	now	RB
29633	499	11	permanently	permanently	RB
29633	499	12	preserved	preserve	VBN
29633	499	13	in	in	IN
29633	499	14	the	the	DT
29633	499	15	library	library	NN
29633	499	16	of	of	IN
29633	499	17	the	the	DT
29633	499	18	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	499	19	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	499	20	Office	Office	NNP
29633	499	21	.	.	.
29633	500	1	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	500	2	's	's	POS
29633	500	3	witnesses	witness	NNS
29633	500	4	were	be	VBD
29633	500	5	almost	almost	RB
29633	500	6	wholly	wholly	RB
29633	500	7	from	from	IN
29633	500	8	the	the	DT
29633	500	9	ranks	rank	NNS
29633	500	10	of	of	IN
29633	500	11	employees	employee	NNS
29633	500	12	or	or	CC
29633	500	13	former	former	JJ
29633	500	14	employees	employee	NNS
29633	500	15	.	.	.
29633	501	1	The	the	DT
29633	501	2	only	only	JJ
29633	501	3	exception	exception	NN
29633	501	4	was	be	VBD
29633	501	5	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
29633	501	6	Alfred	Alfred	NNP
29633	501	7	H.	H.	NNP
29633	501	8	Champion	Champion	NNP
29633	501	9	,	,	,
29633	501	10	a	a	DT
29633	501	11	physician	physician	NN
29633	501	12	of	of	IN
29633	501	13	Eddyville	Eddyville	NNP
29633	501	14	.	.	.
29633	502	1	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
29633	502	2	Champion	Champion	NNP
29633	502	3	describes	describe	VBZ
29633	502	4	a	a	DT
29633	502	5	meeting	meeting	NN
29633	502	6	in	in	IN
29633	502	7	the	the	DT
29633	502	8	fall	fall	NN
29633	502	9	of	of	IN
29633	502	10	1851	1851	CD
29633	502	11	with	with	IN
29633	502	12	"	"	``
29633	502	13	two	two	CD
29633	502	14	or	or	CC
29633	502	15	three	three	CD
29633	502	16	practical	practical	JJ
29633	502	17	Ironmasters	ironmaster	NNS
29633	502	18	and	and	CC
29633	502	19	others	other	NNS
29633	502	20	"	"	''
29633	502	21	at	at	IN
29633	502	22	which	which	WDT
29633	502	23	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	502	24	described	describe	VBD
29633	502	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	502	26	process	process	NN
29633	502	27	and	and	CC
29633	502	28	invited	invite	VBD
29633	502	29	all	all	DT
29633	502	30	present	present	JJ
29633	502	31	to	to	TO
29633	502	32	see	see	VB
29633	502	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	502	34	in	in	IN
29633	502	35	operation	operation	NN
29633	502	36	.	.	.
29633	503	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	503	2	stated	state	VBD
29633	503	3	:	:	:
29633	503	4	The	the	DT
29633	503	5	company	company	NN
29633	503	6	present	present	NN
29633	503	7	all	all	DT
29633	503	8	differed	differ	VBN
29633	503	9	in	in	IN
29633	503	10	opinion	opinion	NN
29633	503	11	from	from	IN
29633	503	12	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	503	13	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	503	14	and	and	CC
29633	503	15	appealed	appeal	VBD
29633	503	16	to	to	IN
29633	503	17	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	503	18	as	as	IN
29633	503	19	a	a	DT
29633	503	20	chemist	chemist	NN
29633	503	21	in	in	IN
29633	503	22	confirmation	confirmation	NN
29633	503	23	of	of	IN
29633	503	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	503	25	doubts	doubt	NNS
29633	503	26	.	.	.
29633	504	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	504	2	at	at	IN
29633	504	3	once	once	RB
29633	504	4	decided	decide	VBD
29633	504	5	that	that	IN
29633	504	6	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	504	7	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	504	8	was	be	VBD
29633	504	9	correct	correct	JJ
29633	504	10	in	in	IN
29633	504	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	504	12	Theory	Theory	NNP
29633	504	13	and	and	CC
29633	504	14	then	then	RB
29633	504	15	went	go	VBD
29633	504	16	on	on	RP
29633	504	17	to	to	TO
29633	504	18	explain	explain	VB
29633	504	19	the	the	DT
29633	504	20	received	received	JJ
29633	504	21	opinion	opinion	NN
29633	504	22	of	of	IN
29633	504	23	chemists	chemist	NNS
29633	504	24	a	a	DT
29633	504	25	century	century	NN
29633	504	26	ago	ago	RB
29633	504	27	on	on	IN
29633	504	28	this	this	DT
29633	504	29	subject	subject	NN
29633	504	30	,	,	,
29633	504	31	and	and	CC
29633	504	32	the	the	DT
29633	504	33	present	present	JJ
29633	504	34	received	received	JJ
29633	504	35	opinion	opinion	NN
29633	504	36	which	which	WDT
29633	504	37	was	be	VBD
29633	504	38	in	in	IN
29633	504	39	direct	direct	JJ
29633	504	40	confirmation	confirmation	NN
29633	504	41	of	of	IN
29633	504	42	the	the	DT
29633	504	43	novel	novel	JJ
29633	504	44	theory	theory	NN
29633	504	45	of	of	IN
29633	504	46	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	504	47	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	504	48	.	.	.
29633	505	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	505	2	also	also	RB
29633	505	3	mentioned	mention	VBD
29633	505	4	the	the	DT
29633	505	5	analogy	analogy	NN
29633	505	6	of	of	IN
29633	505	7	said	say	VBD
29633	505	8	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	505	9	's	's	POS
29633	505	10	process	process	NN
29633	505	11	in	in	IN
29633	505	12	decarbonising	decarbonise	VBG
29633	505	13	iron	iron	NN
29633	505	14	to	to	IN
29633	505	15	the	the	DT
29633	505	16	process	process	NN
29633	505	17	of	of	IN
29633	505	18	decarbonising	decarbonise	VBG
29633	505	19	blood	blood	NN
29633	505	20	in	in	IN
29633	505	21	the	the	DT
29633	505	22	human	human	JJ
29633	505	23	lungs	lung	NNS
29633	505	24	.	.	.
29633	506	1	The	the	DT
29633	506	2	Doctor	Doctor	NNP
29633	506	3	does	do	VBZ
29633	506	4	not	not	RB
29633	506	5	say	say	VB
29633	506	6	,	,	,
29633	506	7	specifically	specifically	RB
29633	506	8	,	,	,
29633	506	9	if	if	IN
29633	506	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	506	11	or	or	CC
29633	506	12	any	any	DT
29633	506	13	of	of	IN
29633	506	14	the	the	DT
29633	506	15	"	"	``
29633	506	16	company	company	NN
29633	506	17	"	"	''
29633	506	18	went	go	VBD
29633	506	19	to	to	TO
29633	506	20	see	see	VB
29633	506	21	the	the	DT
29633	506	22	process	process	NN
29633	506	23	in	in	IN
29633	506	24	operation	operation	NN
29633	506	25	.	.	.
29633	507	1	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	507	2	obtained	obtain	VBD
29633	507	3	affidavits	affidavit	NNS
29633	507	4	from	from	IN
29633	507	5	another	another	DT
29633	507	6	seventeen	seventeen	CD
29633	507	7	witnesses	witness	NNS
29633	507	8	.	.	.
29633	508	1	Ten	ten	CD
29633	508	2	of	of	IN
29633	508	3	these	these	DT
29633	508	4	recorded	record	VBD
29633	508	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	508	6	recollections	recollection	NNS
29633	508	7	of	of	IN
29633	508	8	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	508	9	conducted	conduct	VBN
29633	508	10	in	in	IN
29633	508	11	1847	1847	CD
29633	508	12	.	.	.
29633	509	1	Five	five	CD
29633	509	2	described	describe	VBD
29633	509	3	the	the	DT
29633	509	4	1851	1851	CD
29633	509	5	work	work	NN
29633	509	6	.	.	.
29633	510	1	Two	two	CD
29633	510	2	knew	know	VBD
29633	510	3	of	of	IN
29633	510	4	or	or	CC
29633	510	5	had	have	VBD
29633	510	6	seen	see	VBN
29633	510	7	both	both	DT
29633	510	8	.	.	.
29633	511	1	One	one	CD
29633	511	2	of	of	IN
29633	511	3	the	the	DT
29633	511	4	last	last	JJ
29633	511	5	group	group	NN
29633	511	6	was	be	VBD
29633	511	7	John	John	NNP
29633	511	8	B.	B.	NNP
29633	511	9	Evans	Evans	NNP
29633	511	10	who	who	WP
29633	511	11	became	become	VBD
29633	511	12	forge	forge	NN
29633	511	13	manager	manager	NN
29633	511	14	of	of	IN
29633	511	15	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	511	16	's	's	POS
29633	511	17	Union	Union	NNP
29633	511	18	Forge	Forge	NNP
29633	511	19	,	,	,
29633	511	20	a	a	DT
29633	511	21	few	few	JJ
29633	511	22	miles	mile	NNS
29633	511	23	from	from	IN
29633	511	24	Suwanee	Suwanee	NNP
29633	511	25	.	.	.
29633	512	1	This	this	DT
29633	512	2	evidence	evidence	NN
29633	512	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	512	4	of	of	IN
29633	512	5	interest	interest	NN
29633	512	6	since	since	IN
29633	512	7	a	a	DT
29633	512	8	man	man	NN
29633	512	9	in	in	IN
29633	512	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	512	11	position	position	NN
29633	512	12	should	should	MD
29633	512	13	have	have	VB
29633	512	14	been	be	VBN
29633	512	15	in	in	IN
29633	512	16	a	a	DT
29633	512	17	position	position	NN
29633	512	18	to	to	TO
29633	512	19	tell	tell	VB
29633	512	20	something	something	NN
29633	512	21	about	about	IN
29633	512	22	the	the	DT
29633	512	23	results	result	NNS
29633	512	24	of	of	IN
29633	512	25	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	512	26	's	's	POS
29633	512	27	operations	operation	NNS
29633	512	28	in	in	IN
29633	512	29	terms	term	NNS
29633	512	30	of	of	IN
29633	512	31	usable	usable	JJ
29633	512	32	metal	metal	NN
29633	512	33	.	.	.
29633	513	1	Unfortunately	unfortunately	RB
29633	513	2	,	,	,
29633	513	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	513	4	limits	limit	VBZ
29633	513	5	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	513	6	to	to	IN
29633	513	7	a	a	DT
29633	513	8	comment	comment	NN
29633	513	9	on	on	IN
29633	513	10	the	the	DT
29633	513	11	metal	metal	NN
29633	513	12	which	which	WDT
29633	513	13	had	have	VBD
29633	513	14	chilled	chill	VBN
29633	513	15	around	around	IN
29633	513	16	a	a	DT
29633	513	17	tuyère	tuyère	NN
29633	513	18	which	which	WDT
29633	513	19	had	have	VBD
29633	513	20	been	be	VBN
29633	513	21	sent	send	VBN
29633	513	22	back	back	RB
29633	513	23	to	to	IN
29633	513	24	the	the	DT
29633	513	25	Forge	Forge	NNP
29633	513	26	(	(	-LRB-
29633	513	27	"	"	``
29633	513	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	513	29	was	be	VBD
29633	513	30	partly	partly	RB
29633	513	31	malleable	malleable	JJ
29633	513	32	and	and	CC
29633	513	33	partly	partly	RB
29633	513	34	refined	refine	VBN
29633	513	35	pig	pig	NN
29633	513	36	-	-	HYPH
29633	513	37	iron	iron	NN
29633	513	38	"	"	''
29633	513	39	)	)	-RRB-
29633	513	40	and	and	CC
29633	513	41	to	to	IN
29633	513	42	an	an	DT
29633	513	43	account	account	NN
29633	513	44	of	of	IN
29633	513	45	a	a	DT
29633	513	46	conversation	conversation	NN
29633	513	47	with	with	IN
29633	513	48	others	other	NNS
29633	513	49	who	who	WP
29633	513	50	had	have	VBD
29633	513	51	worked	work	VBN
29633	513	52	some	some	DT
29633	513	53	of	of	IN
29633	513	54	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	513	55	's	's	POS
29633	513	56	"	"	``
29633	513	57	good	good	JJ
29633	513	58	wrought	wrought	NN
29633	513	59	iron	iron	NN
29633	513	60	"	"	''
29633	513	61	made	make	VBN
29633	513	62	by	by	IN
29633	513	63	the	the	DT
29633	513	64	new	new	JJ
29633	513	65	process	process	NN
29633	513	66	.	.	.
29633	514	1	Only	only	RB
29633	514	2	one	one	CD
29633	514	3	of	of	IN
29633	514	4	the	the	DT
29633	514	5	witnesses	witness	NNS
29633	514	6	(	(	-LRB-
29633	514	7	William	William	NNP
29633	514	8	Soden	Soden	NNP
29633	514	9	)	)	-RRB-
29633	514	10	makes	make	VBZ
29633	514	11	a	a	DT
29633	514	12	reference	reference	NN
29633	514	13	to	to	IN
29633	514	14	the	the	DT
29633	514	15	phenomenon	phenomenon	NN
29633	514	16	which	which	WDT
29633	514	17	is	be	VBZ
29633	514	18	an	an	DT
29633	514	19	accompaniment	accompaniment	NN
29633	514	20	of	of	IN
29633	514	21	the	the	DT
29633	514	22	blowing	blowing	NN
29633	514	23	of	of	IN
29633	514	24	a	a	DT
29633	514	25	converter	converter	NN
29633	514	26	:	:	:
29633	514	27	the	the	DT
29633	514	28	prolonged	prolonged	JJ
29633	514	29	and	and	CC
29633	514	30	violent	violent	JJ
29633	514	31	emission	emission	NN
29633	514	32	of	of	IN
29633	514	33	sparks	spark	NNS
29633	514	34	and	and	CC
29633	514	35	flames	flame	NNS
29633	514	36	which	which	WDT
29633	514	37	startled	startle	VBD
29633	514	38	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	514	39	in	in	IN
29633	514	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	514	41	first	first	JJ
29633	514	42	use	use	NN
29633	514	43	of	of	IN
29633	514	44	the	the	DT
29633	514	45	process[99	process[99	NN
29633	514	46	]	]	-RRB-
29633	514	47	and	and	CC
29633	514	48	which	which	WDT
29633	514	49	still	still	RB
29633	514	50	provides	provide	VBZ
29633	514	51	an	an	DT
29633	514	52	exciting	exciting	JJ
29633	514	53	,	,	,
29633	514	54	if	if	IN
29633	514	55	not	not	RB
29633	514	56	awe	awe	NN
29633	514	57	-	-	HYPH
29633	514	58	inspiring	inspire	VBG
29633	514	59	,	,	,
29633	514	60	interlude	interlude	JJ
29633	514	61	in	in	IN
29633	514	62	a	a	DT
29633	514	63	visit	visit	NN
29633	514	64	to	to	IN
29633	514	65	a	a	DT
29633	514	66	steel	steel	NN
29633	514	67	mill	mill	NN
29633	514	68	.	.	.
29633	515	1	Soden	Soden	NNP
29633	515	2	refers	refer	VBZ
29633	515	3	,	,	,
29633	515	4	without	without	IN
29633	515	5	much	much	JJ
29633	515	6	excitement	excitement	NN
29633	515	7	,	,	,
29633	515	8	to	to	IN
29633	515	9	a	a	DT
29633	515	10	boiling	boiling	NN
29633	515	11	commotion	commotion	NN
29633	515	12	,	,	,
29633	515	13	but	but	CC
29633	515	14	the	the	DT
29633	515	15	results	result	NNS
29633	515	16	of	of	IN
29633	515	17	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	515	18	's	's	POS
29633	515	19	"	"	``
29633	515	20	air	air	NN
29633	515	21	-	-	HYPH
29633	515	22	boiling	boiling	NN
29633	515	23	"	"	''
29633	515	24	were	be	VBD
29633	515	25	,	,	,
29633	515	26	evidently	evidently	RB
29633	515	27	,	,	,
29633	515	28	not	not	RB
29633	515	29	such	such	JJ
29633	515	30	as	as	IN
29633	515	31	to	to	TO
29633	515	32	impress	impress	VB
29633	515	33	the	the	DT
29633	515	34	rest	rest	NN
29633	515	35	of	of	IN
29633	515	36	those	those	DT
29633	515	37	who	who	WP
29633	515	38	claimed	claim	VBD
29633	515	39	to	to	TO
29633	515	40	have	have	VB
29633	515	41	seen	see	VBN
29633	515	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	515	43	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	515	44	in	in	IN
29633	515	45	operation	operation	NN
29633	515	46	.	.	.
29633	516	1	Only	only	RB
29633	516	2	five	five	CD
29633	516	3	of	of	IN
29633	516	4	the	the	DT
29633	516	5	total	total	NN
29633	516	6	of	of	IN
29633	516	7	eighteen	eighteen	CD
29633	516	8	of	of	IN
29633	516	9	the	the	DT
29633	516	10	witnesses	witness	NNS
29633	516	11	say	say	VBP
29633	516	12	that	that	IN
29633	516	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
29633	516	14	witnessed	witness	VBD
29633	516	15	the	the	DT
29633	516	16	operations	operation	NNS
29633	516	17	.	.	.
29633	517	1	Soden	Soden	NNP
29633	517	2	,	,	,
29633	517	3	incidentally	incidentally	RB
29633	517	4	,	,	,
29633	517	5	knew	know	VBD
29633	517	6	of	of	IN
29633	517	7	seven	seven	CD
29633	517	8	different	different	JJ
29633	517	9	"	"	``
29633	517	10	air	air	NN
29633	517	11	-	-	HYPH
29633	517	12	boiling	boil	VBG
29633	517	13	"	"	''
29633	517	14	furnaces	furnace	NNS
29633	517	15	,	,	,
29633	517	16	some	some	DT
29633	517	17	with	with	IN
29633	517	18	four	four	CD
29633	517	19	and	and	CC
29633	517	20	some	some	DT
29633	517	21	with	with	IN
29633	517	22	eight	eight	CD
29633	517	23	tuyères	tuyère	NNS
29633	517	24	,	,	,
29633	517	25	but	but	CC
29633	517	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	517	27	also	also	RB
29633	517	28	neglected	neglect	VBD
29633	517	29	to	to	TO
29633	517	30	report	report	VB
29633	517	31	on	on	IN
29633	517	32	the	the	DT
29633	517	33	use	use	NN
29633	517	34	of	of	IN
29633	517	35	the	the	DT
29633	517	36	metal	metal	NN
29633	517	37	.	.	.
29633	518	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	518	2	99	99	CD
29633	518	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	518	4	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	518	5	,	,	,
29633	518	6	_	_	NNP
29633	518	7	op	op	NN
29633	518	8	.	.	.
29633	519	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	519	2	.	.	.
29633	519	3	_	_	NNP
29633	519	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	519	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	519	6	7	7	CD
29633	519	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	519	8	,	,	,
29633	519	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	519	10	144	144	CD
29633	519	11	.	.	.
29633	520	1	As	as	IN
29633	520	2	is	be	VBZ
29633	520	3	well	well	RB
29633	520	4	known	know	VBN
29633	520	5	,	,	,
29633	520	6	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	520	7	satisfied	satisfy	VBD
29633	520	8	the	the	DT
29633	520	9	Acting	Acting	NNP
29633	520	10	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	520	11	that	that	IN
29633	520	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	520	13	had	have	VBD
29633	520	14	"	"	``
29633	520	15	made	make	VBN
29633	520	16	this	this	DT
29633	520	17	invention	invention	NN
29633	520	18	and	and	CC
29633	520	19	showed	show	VBD
29633	520	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	520	21	by	by	IN
29633	520	22	drawings	drawing	NNS
29633	520	23	and	and	CC
29633	520	24	experiment	experiment	NN
29633	520	25	as	as	RB
29633	520	26	early	early	RB
29633	520	27	as	as	IN
29633	520	28	1847	1847	CD
29633	520	29	,	,	,
29633	520	30	"	"	``
29633	520	31	and	and	CC
29633	520	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	520	33	was	be	VBD
29633	520	34	awarded	award	VBN
29633	520	35	priority	priority	NN
29633	520	36	by	by	IN
29633	520	37	the	the	DT
29633	520	38	Acting	Acting	NNP
29633	520	39	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	520	40	's	's	POS
29633	520	41	decision	decision	NN
29633	520	42	of	of	IN
29633	520	43	April	April	NNP
29633	520	44	13	13	CD
29633	520	45	,	,	,
29633	520	46	1857	1857	CD
29633	520	47	,	,	,
29633	520	48	and	and	CC
29633	520	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	520	50	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	520	51	17628	17628	CD
29633	520	52	was	be	VBD
29633	520	53	granted	grant	VBN
29633	520	54	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	520	55	as	as	IN
29633	520	56	of	of	IN
29633	520	57	June	June	NNP
29633	520	58	23	23	CD
29633	520	59	,	,	,
29633	520	60	1857	1857	CD
29633	520	61	.	.	.
29633	521	1	The	the	DT
29633	521	2	_	_	NNP
29633	521	3	Scientific	Scientific	NNP
29633	521	4	American	American	NNP
29633	521	5	_	_	NNP
29633	521	6	sympathized	sympathize	VBD
29633	521	7	with	with	IN
29633	521	8	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	521	9	's	's	POS
29633	521	10	realization	realization	NN
29633	521	11	that	that	IN
29633	521	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	521	13	American	american	JJ
29633	521	14	patent	patent	NN
29633	521	15	was	be	VBD
29633	521	16	"	"	``
29633	521	17	of	of	IN
29633	521	18	no	no	DT
29633	521	19	more	more	JJR
29633	521	20	value	value	NN
29633	521	21	to	to	IN
29633	521	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	521	23	than	than	IN
29633	521	24	so	so	RB
29633	521	25	much	much	JJ
29633	521	26	waste	waste	NN
29633	521	27	paper	paper	NN
29633	521	28	"	"	''
29633	521	29	but	but	CC
29633	521	30	took	take	VBD
29633	521	31	the	the	DT
29633	521	32	opportunity	opportunity	NN
29633	521	33	of	of	IN
29633	521	34	chastising	chastise	VBG
29633	521	35	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	521	36	for	for	IN
29633	521	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	521	38	negligence	negligence	NN
29633	521	39	in	in	IN
29633	521	40	not	not	RB
29633	521	41	securing	secure	VBG
29633	521	42	a	a	DT
29633	521	43	patent	patent	NN
29633	521	44	at	at	IN
29633	521	45	a	a	DT
29633	521	46	much	much	RB
29633	521	47	earlier	early	JJR
29633	521	48	date	date	NN
29633	521	49	and	and	CC
29633	521	50	complained	complain	VBD
29633	521	51	of	of	IN
29633	521	52	a	a	DT
29633	521	53	patent	patent	NN
29633	521	54	system	system	NN
29633	521	55	which	which	WDT
29633	521	56	did	do	VBD
29633	521	57	not	not	RB
29633	521	58	require	require	VB
29633	521	59	an	an	DT
29633	521	60	inventor	inventor	NN
29633	521	61	to	to	TO
29633	521	62	make	make	VB
29633	521	63	known	known	JJ
29633	521	64	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	521	65	discovery	discovery	NN
29633	521	66	promptly	promptly	RB
29633	521	67	.	.	.
29633	522	1	The	the	DT
29633	522	2	journal	journal	NN
29633	522	3	advocated	advocate	VBD
29633	522	4	a	a	DT
29633	522	5	"	"	``
29633	522	6	certain	certain	JJ
29633	522	7	fixed	fix	VBN
29633	522	8	time	time	NN
29633	522	9	"	"	''
29633	522	10	after	after	IN
29633	522	11	which	which	WDT
29633	522	12	such	such	PDT
29633	522	13	an	an	DT
29633	522	14	inventor	inventor	NN
29633	522	15	"	"	``
29633	522	16	should	should	MD
29633	522	17	not	not	RB
29633	522	18	be	be	VB
29633	522	19	allowed	allow	VBN
29633	522	20	to	to	TO
29633	522	21	subvert	subvert	VB
29633	522	22	a	a	DT
29633	522	23	patent	patent	NN
29633	522	24	granted	grant	VBN
29633	522	25	to	to	IN
29633	522	26	another	another	DT
29633	522	27	who	who	WP
29633	522	28	has	have	VBZ
29633	522	29	taken	take	VBN
29633	522	30	proper	proper	JJ
29633	522	31	measures	measure	NNS
29633	522	32	to	to	TO
29633	522	33	put	put	VB
29633	522	34	the	the	DT
29633	522	35	public	public	NN
29633	522	36	in	in	IN
29633	522	37	possession	possession	NN
29633	522	38	of	of	IN
29633	522	39	the	the	DT
29633	522	40	invention	invention	NN
29633	522	41	.	.	.
29633	523	1	"	"	``
29633	523	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	523	3	100	100	CD
29633	523	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	523	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	523	6	100	100	CD
29633	523	7	]	]	-RRB-
29633	523	8	_	_	NNP
29633	523	9	Scientific	Scientific	NNP
29633	523	10	American	American	NNP
29633	523	11	_	_	NNP
29633	523	12	,	,	,
29633	523	13	1857	1857	CD
29633	523	14	,	,	,
29633	523	15	vol	vol	NNP
29633	523	16	.	.	.
29633	524	1	12	12	CD
29633	524	2	,	,	,
29633	524	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	524	4	341	341	CD
29633	524	5	.	.	.
29633	525	1	Little	little	JJ
29633	525	2	authentic	authentic	NN
29633	525	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	525	4	known	know	VBN
29633	525	5	about	about	IN
29633	525	6	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	525	7	's	's	POS
29633	525	8	activities	activity	NNS
29633	525	9	following	follow	VBG
29633	525	10	the	the	DT
29633	525	11	grant	grant	NN
29633	525	12	of	of	IN
29633	525	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	525	14	patent	patent	NN
29633	525	15	.	.	.
29633	526	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	526	2	biographer[101	biographer[101	NN
29633	526	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	526	4	does	do	VBZ
29633	526	5	not	not	RB
29633	526	6	document	document	VB
29633	526	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	526	8	statements	statement	NNS
29633	526	9	,	,	,
29633	526	10	many	many	JJ
29633	526	11	of	of	IN
29633	526	12	which	which	WDT
29633	526	13	appear	appear	VBP
29633	526	14	to	to	TO
29633	526	15	be	be	VB
29633	526	16	based	base	VBN
29633	526	17	on	on	IN
29633	526	18	the	the	DT
29633	526	19	recollections	recollection	NNS
29633	526	20	of	of	IN
29633	526	21	members	member	NNS
29633	526	22	of	of	IN
29633	526	23	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	526	24	's	's	POS
29633	526	25	family	family	NN
29633	526	26	,	,	,
29633	526	27	and	and	CC
29633	526	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	526	29	is	be	VBZ
29633	526	30	difficult	difficult	JJ
29633	526	31	to	to	TO
29633	526	32	reconcile	reconcile	VB
29633	526	33	some	some	DT
29633	526	34	of	of	IN
29633	526	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
29633	526	36	with	with	IN
29633	526	37	what	what	WP
29633	526	38	few	few	JJ
29633	526	39	facts	fact	NNS
29633	526	40	are	be	VBP
29633	526	41	available	available	JJ
29633	526	42	.	.	.
29633	527	1	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	527	2	's	's	POS
29633	527	3	own	own	JJ
29633	527	4	account	account	NN
29633	527	5	of	of	IN
29633	527	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	527	7	invention,[102	invention,[102	NN
29633	527	8	]	]	-RRB-
29633	527	9	itself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	527	10	undated	undate	VBD
29633	527	11	,	,	,
29633	527	12	asserts	assert	VBZ
29633	527	13	that	that	IN
29633	527	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	527	15	could	could	MD
29633	527	16	"	"	``
29633	527	17	refine	refine	VB
29633	527	18	fifteen	fifteen	CD
29633	527	19	hundredweight	hundredweight	NN
29633	527	20	of	of	IN
29633	527	21	metal	metal	NN
29633	527	22	in	in	RB
29633	527	23	from	from	IN
29633	527	24	five	five	CD
29633	527	25	to	to	TO
29633	527	26	ten	ten	CD
29633	527	27	minutes	minute	NNS
29633	527	28	,	,	,
29633	527	29	"	"	''
29633	527	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	527	31	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	527	32	"	"	``
29633	527	33	supplying	supply	VBG
29633	527	34	a	a	DT
29633	527	35	cheap	cheap	JJ
29633	527	36	method	method	NN
29633	527	37	of	of	IN
29633	527	38	making	make	VBG
29633	527	39	run	run	VB
29633	527	40	-	-	HYPH
29633	527	41	out	out	RP
29633	527	42	metal	metal	NN
29633	527	43	"	"	''
29633	527	44	so	so	IN
29633	527	45	that	that	IN
29633	527	46	"	"	``
29633	527	47	after	after	IN
29633	527	48	trying	try	VBG
29633	527	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	527	50	a	a	DT
29633	527	51	few	few	JJ
29633	527	52	days	day	NNS
29633	527	53	we	-PRON-	PRP
29633	527	54	entirely	entirely	RB
29633	527	55	dispensed	dispense	VBD
29633	527	56	with	with	IN
29633	527	57	the	the	DT
29633	527	58	old	old	JJ
29633	527	59	and	and	CC
29633	527	60	troublesome	troublesome	JJ
29633	527	61	run	run	NN
29633	527	62	-	-	HYPH
29633	527	63	out	out	RP
29633	527	64	fires	fire	NNS
29633	527	65	.	.	.
29633	528	1	"	"	``
29633	528	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	528	3	103	103	CD
29633	528	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	528	5	This	this	DT
29633	528	6	statement	statement	NN
29633	528	7	suggests	suggest	VBZ
29633	528	8	that	that	IN
29633	528	9	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	528	10	's	's	POS
29633	528	11	method	method	NN
29633	528	12	was	be	VBD
29633	528	13	intended	intend	VBN
29633	528	14	to	to	TO
29633	528	15	do	do	VB
29633	528	16	just	just	RB
29633	528	17	this	this	DT
29633	528	18	;	;	:
29633	528	19	and	and	CC
29633	528	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	528	21	is	be	VBZ
29633	528	22	not	not	RB
29633	528	23	without	without	IN
29633	528	24	interest	interest	NN
29633	528	25	to	to	TO
29633	528	26	note	note	VB
29633	528	27	that	that	IN
29633	528	28	several	several	JJ
29633	528	29	of	of	IN
29633	528	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	528	31	witnesses	witness	NNS
29633	528	32	in	in	IN
29633	528	33	the	the	DT
29633	528	34	Interference	Interference	NNP
29633	528	35	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
29633	528	36	,	,	,
29633	528	37	refer	refer	VBP
29633	528	38	to	to	IN
29633	528	39	bringing	bring	VBG
29633	528	40	the	the	DT
29633	528	41	metal	metal	NN
29633	528	42	"	"	''
29633	528	43	to	to	IN
29633	528	44	nature	nature	NN
29633	528	45	,	,	,
29633	528	46	"	"	''
29633	528	47	a	a	DT
29633	528	48	term	term	NN
29633	528	49	often	often	RB
29633	528	50	used	use	VBN
29633	528	51	in	in	IN
29633	528	52	connection	connection	NN
29633	528	53	with	with	IN
29633	528	54	the	the	DT
29633	528	55	finery	finery	JJ
29633	528	56	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	528	57	.	.	.
29633	529	1	If	if	IN
29633	529	2	this	this	DT
29633	529	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	529	4	so	so	RB
29633	529	5	,	,	,
29633	529	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	529	7	assumption	assumption	NN
29633	529	8	that	that	IN
29633	529	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	529	10	had	have	VBD
29633	529	11	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
29633	529	12	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	529	13	was	be	VBD
29633	529	14	based	base	VBN
29633	529	15	on	on	IN
29633	529	16	a	a	DT
29633	529	17	misapprehension	misapprehension	NN
29633	529	18	of	of	IN
29633	529	19	what	what	WP
29633	529	20	the	the	DT
29633	529	21	latter	latter	JJ
29633	529	22	was	be	VBD
29633	529	23	intending	intend	VBG
29633	529	24	to	to	TO
29633	529	25	do	do	VB
29633	529	26	,	,	,
29633	529	27	that	that	RB
29633	529	28	is	is	RB
29633	529	29	,	,	,
29633	529	30	to	to	TO
29633	529	31	make	make	VB
29633	529	32	steel	steel	NN
29633	529	33	.	.	.
29633	530	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	530	2	101	101	CD
29633	530	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	530	4	Boucher	Boucher	NNP
29633	530	5	,	,	,
29633	530	6	_	_	NNP
29633	530	7	op	op	NN
29633	530	8	.	.	.
29633	531	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	531	2	.	.	.
29633	531	3	_	_	NNP
29633	531	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	531	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	531	6	97	97	CD
29633	531	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	531	8	.	.	.
29633	532	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	532	2	102	102	CD
29633	532	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	532	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	532	5	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
29633	532	6	of	of	IN
29633	532	7	the	the	DT
29633	532	8	Census	Census	NNP
29633	532	9	,	,	,
29633	532	10	_	_	NNP
29633	532	11	Report	Report	NNP
29633	532	12	on	on	IN
29633	532	13	the	the	DT
29633	532	14	manufacturers	manufacturer	NNS
29633	532	15	of	of	IN
29633	532	16	the	the	DT
29633	532	17	United	United	NNP
29633	532	18	States	States	NNP
29633	532	19	at	at	IN
29633	532	20	the	the	DT
29633	532	21	tenth	tenth	JJ
29633	532	22	census	census	NN
29633	532	23	(	(	-LRB-
29633	532	24	June	June	NNP
29633	532	25	1	1	CD
29633	532	26	,	,	,
29633	532	27	1880	1880	CD
29633	532	28	)	)	-RRB-
29633	532	29	...	...	NFP
29633	532	30	,	,	,
29633	532	31	Manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	532	32	of	of	IN
29633	532	33	iron	iron	NN
29633	532	34	and	and	CC
29633	532	35	steel	steel	NN
29633	532	36	_	_	NNP
29633	532	37	,	,	,
29633	532	38	report	report	NN
29633	532	39	prepared	prepare	VBN
29633	532	40	by	by	IN
29633	532	41	James	James	NNP
29633	532	42	M.	M.	NNP
29633	532	43	Swank	Swank	NNP
29633	532	44	,	,	,
29633	532	45	special	special	JJ
29633	532	46	agent	agent	NN
29633	532	47	,	,	,
29633	532	48	Washington	Washington	NNP
29633	532	49	,	,	,
29633	532	50	1883	1883	CD
29633	532	51	,	,	,
29633	532	52	p.	p.	NN
29633	532	53	124	124	CD
29633	532	54	.	.	.
29633	533	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	533	2	Swank	Swank	NNP
29633	533	3	was	be	VBD
29633	533	4	secretary	secretary	NN
29633	533	5	of	of	IN
29633	533	6	the	the	DT
29633	533	7	American	American	NNP
29633	533	8	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	533	9	and	and	CC
29633	533	10	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	533	11	Association	Association	NNP
29633	533	12	.	.	.
29633	534	1	This	this	DT
29633	534	2	material	material	NN
29633	534	3	was	be	VBD
29633	534	4	included	include	VBN
29633	534	5	in	in	IN
29633	534	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	534	7	_	_	NNP
29633	534	8	History	history	NN
29633	534	9	of	of	IN
29633	534	10	the	the	DT
29633	534	11	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	534	12	of	of	IN
29633	534	13	iron	iron	NN
29633	534	14	in	in	IN
29633	534	15	all	all	DT
29633	534	16	ages	age	NNS
29633	534	17	_	_	NNP
29633	534	18	,	,	,
29633	534	19	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
29633	534	20	,	,	,
29633	534	21	1892	1892	CD
29633	534	22	,	,	,
29633	534	23	p.	p.	NN
29633	534	24	397	397	CD
29633	534	25	.	.	.
29633	535	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	535	2	103	103	CD
29633	535	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	535	4	_	_	NNP
29633	535	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	535	6	.	.	.
29633	535	7	_	_	NNP
29633	535	8	,	,	,
29633	535	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	535	10	125	125	CD
29633	535	11	.	.	.
29633	536	1	The	the	DT
29633	536	2	run	run	VB
29633	536	3	-	-	HYPH
29633	536	4	out	out	RP
29633	536	5	fire	fire	NN
29633	536	6	(	(	-LRB-
29633	536	7	or	or	CC
29633	536	8	"	"	``
29633	536	9	finery	finery	NN
29633	536	10	"	"	''
29633	536	11	fire	fire	NN
29633	536	12	)	)	-RRB-
29633	536	13	was	be	VBD
29633	536	14	a	a	DT
29633	536	15	charcoal	charcoal	NN
29633	536	16	fire	fire	NN
29633	536	17	"	"	''
29633	536	18	into	into	IN
29633	536	19	which	which	WDT
29633	536	20	pig	pig	NN
29633	536	21	-	-	HYPH
29633	536	22	iron	iron	NN
29633	536	23	,	,	,
29633	536	24	having	have	VBG
29633	536	25	been	be	VBN
29633	536	26	melted	melt	VBN
29633	536	27	and	and	CC
29633	536	28	partially	partially	RB
29633	536	29	refined	refine	VBN
29633	536	30	in	in	IN
29633	536	31	one	one	CD
29633	536	32	fire	fire	NN
29633	536	33	,	,	,
29633	536	34	was	be	VBD
29633	536	35	run	run	VBN
29633	536	36	and	and	CC
29633	536	37	further	further	RB
29633	536	38	refined	refine	VBN
29633	536	39	to	to	TO
29633	536	40	convert	convert	VB
29633	536	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	536	42	to	to	IN
29633	536	43	wrought	wrought	VB
29633	536	44	iron	iron	NN
29633	536	45	by	by	IN
29633	536	46	the	the	DT
29633	536	47	Lancashire	Lancashire	NNP
29633	536	48	hearth	hearth	NN
29633	536	49	process	process	NN
29633	536	50	,	,	,
29633	536	51	"	"	''
29633	536	52	according	accord	VBG
29633	536	53	to	to	IN
29633	536	54	A.	A.	NNP
29633	536	55	K.	K.	NNP
29633	536	56	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
29633	536	57	,	,	,
29633	536	58	_	_	NNP
29633	536	59	An	an	DT
29633	536	60	encyclopaedia	encyclopaedia	NN
29633	536	61	of	of	IN
29633	536	62	the	the	DT
29633	536	63	iron	iron	NN
29633	536	64	and	and	CC
29633	536	65	steel	steel	NN
29633	536	66	industry	industry	NN
29633	536	67	_	_	NNP
29633	536	68	,	,	,
29633	536	69	New	New	NNP
29633	536	70	York	York	NNP
29633	536	71	,	,	,
29633	536	72	1956	1956	CD
29633	536	73	.	.	.
29633	537	1	This	this	DT
29633	537	2	statement	statement	NN
29633	537	3	leaves	leave	VBZ
29633	537	4	the	the	DT
29633	537	5	reader	reader	NN
29633	537	6	under	under	IN
29633	537	7	the	the	DT
29633	537	8	impression	impression	NN
29633	537	9	that	that	IN
29633	537	10	the	the	DT
29633	537	11	process	process	NN
29633	537	12	was	be	VBD
29633	537	13	in	in	IN
29633	537	14	successful	successful	JJ
29633	537	15	use	use	NN
29633	537	16	.	.	.
29633	538	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	538	2	is	be	VBZ
29633	538	3	to	to	TO
29633	538	4	be	be	VB
29633	538	5	contrasted	contrast	VBN
29633	538	6	with	with	IN
29633	538	7	the	the	DT
29633	538	8	statement	statement	NN
29633	538	9	quoted	quote	VBN
29633	538	10	above	above	IN
29633	538	11	(	(	-LRB-
29633	538	12	page	page	NN
29633	538	13	43	43	CD
29633	538	14	)	)	-RRB-
29633	538	15	,	,	,
29633	538	16	dated	date	VBN
29633	538	17	September	September	NNP
29633	538	18	1856	1856	CD
29633	538	19	,	,	,
29633	538	20	when	when	WRB
29633	538	21	the	the	DT
29633	538	22	process	process	NN
29633	538	23	had	have	VBD
29633	538	24	,	,	,
29633	538	25	clearly	clearly	RB
29633	538	26	,	,	,
29633	538	27	not	not	RB
29633	538	28	been	be	VBN
29633	538	29	perfected	perfect	VBN
29633	538	30	.	.	.
29633	539	1	In	in	IN
29633	539	2	this	this	DT
29633	539	3	connection	connection	NN
29633	539	4	,	,	,
29633	539	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	539	6	should	should	MD
29633	539	7	be	be	VB
29633	539	8	noted	note	VBN
29633	539	9	that	that	IN
29633	539	10	in	in	IN
29633	539	11	the	the	DT
29633	539	12	report	report	NN
29633	539	13	on	on	IN
29633	539	14	the	the	DT
29633	539	15	Suwanee	Suwanee	NNP
29633	539	16	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	539	17	Works	Works	NNP
29633	539	18	,	,	,
29633	539	19	included	include	VBN
29633	539	20	in	in	IN
29633	539	21	_	_	NNP
29633	539	22	The	the	DT
29633	539	23	iron	iron	NN
29633	539	24	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
29633	539	25	's	's	POS
29633	539	26	guide_,[104	guide_,[104	NN
29633	539	27	]	]	-RRB-
29633	539	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	539	29	is	be	VBZ
29633	539	30	stated	state	VBN
29633	539	31	that	that	IN
29633	539	32	"	"	``
29633	539	33	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	539	34	is	be	VBZ
29633	539	35	at	at	IN
29633	539	36	this	this	DT
29633	539	37	furnace	furnace	NN
29633	539	38	that	that	WDT
29633	539	39	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	539	40	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	539	41	's	's	POS
29633	539	42	process	process	NN
29633	539	43	for	for	IN
29633	539	44	refining	refining	NN
29633	539	45	iron	iron	NN
29633	539	46	in	in	IN
29633	539	47	the	the	DT
29633	539	48	hearth	hearth	NN
29633	539	49	has	have	VBZ
29633	539	50	been	be	VBN
29633	539	51	most	most	RBS
29633	539	52	fully	fully	RB
29633	539	53	experimented	experiment	VBN
29633	539	54	upon	upon	IN
29633	539	55	.	.	.
29633	539	56	"	"	''
29633	540	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	540	2	104	104	NNP
29633	540	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	540	4	J.	J.	NNP
29633	540	5	P.	P.	NNP
29633	540	6	Lesley	Lesley	NNP
29633	540	7	,	,	,
29633	540	8	_	_	NNP
29633	540	9	op	op	NN
29633	540	10	.	.	.
29633	541	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	541	2	.	.	.
29633	541	3	_	_	NNP
29633	541	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	541	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	541	6	39	39	CD
29633	541	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	541	8	,	,	,
29633	541	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	541	10	129	129	CD
29633	541	11	.	.	.
29633	542	1	The	the	DT
29633	542	2	preface	preface	NN
29633	542	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	542	4	dated	date	VBN
29633	542	5	April	April	NNP
29633	542	6	6	6	CD
29633	542	7	,	,	,
29633	542	8	1859	1859	CD
29633	542	9	.	.	.
29633	543	1	The	the	DT
29633	543	2	data	datum	NNS
29633	543	3	was	be	VBD
29633	543	4	largely	largely	RB
29633	543	5	collected	collect	VBN
29633	543	6	by	by	IN
29633	543	7	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
29633	543	8	Lesley	Lesley	NNP
29633	543	9	of	of	IN
29633	543	10	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
29633	543	11	,	,	,
29633	543	12	brother	brother	NN
29633	543	13	of	of	IN
29633	543	14	the	the	DT
29633	543	15	author	author	NN
29633	543	16	,	,	,
29633	543	17	during	during	IN
29633	543	18	a	a	DT
29633	543	19	tour	tour	NN
29633	543	20	of	of	IN
29633	543	21	several	several	JJ
29633	543	22	months	month	NNS
29633	543	23	.	.	.
29633	544	1	Since	since	IN
29633	544	2	Suwanee	Suwanee	NNP
29633	544	3	production	production	NN
29633	544	4	is	be	VBZ
29633	544	5	given	give	VBN
29633	544	6	for	for	IN
29633	544	7	44	44	CD
29633	544	8	weeks	week	NNS
29633	544	9	only	only	RB
29633	544	10	of	of	IN
29633	544	11	1857	1857	CD
29633	544	12	(	(	-LRB-
29633	544	13	_	_	NNP
29633	544	14	i.e.	i.e.	FW
29633	544	15	_	_	NNP
29633	544	16	,	,	,
29633	544	17	through	through	IN
29633	544	18	November	November	NNP
29633	544	19	4	4	CD
29633	544	20	or	or	CC
29633	544	21	5	5	CD
29633	544	22	,	,	,
29633	544	23	1857	1857	CD
29633	544	24	)	)	-RRB-
29633	544	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	544	26	is	be	VBZ
29633	544	27	concluded	conclude	VBN
29633	544	28	that	that	IN
29633	544	29	Lesley	Lesley	NNP
29633	544	30	's	's	POS
29633	544	31	visit	visit	NN
29633	544	32	was	be	VBD
29633	544	33	in	in	IN
29633	544	34	the	the	DT
29633	544	35	last	last	JJ
29633	544	36	few	few	JJ
29633	544	37	weeks	week	NNS
29633	544	38	of	of	IN
29633	544	39	1857	1857	CD
29633	544	40	.	.	.
29633	545	1	A	a	DT
29633	545	2	major	major	JJ
29633	545	3	financial	financial	JJ
29633	545	4	crisis	crisis	NN
29633	545	5	affected	affect	VBD
29633	545	6	United	United	NNP
29633	545	7	States	States	NNP
29633	545	8	business	business	NN
29633	545	9	in	in	IN
29633	545	10	the	the	DT
29633	545	11	fall	fall	NN
29633	545	12	of	of	IN
29633	545	13	1857	1857	CD
29633	545	14	.	.	.
29633	546	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	546	2	began	begin	VBD
29633	546	3	in	in	IN
29633	546	4	the	the	DT
29633	546	5	first	first	JJ
29633	546	6	week	week	NN
29633	546	7	of	of	IN
29633	546	8	October	October	NNP
29633	546	9	and	and	CC
29633	546	10	by	by	IN
29633	546	11	October	October	NNP
29633	546	12	31	31	CD
29633	546	13	the	the	DT
29633	546	14	_	_	NNP
29633	546	15	Economist	Economist	NNP
29633	546	16	_	_	NNP
29633	546	17	(	(	-LRB-
29633	546	18	London	London	NNP
29633	546	19	)	)	-RRB-
29633	546	20	reported	report	VBD
29633	546	21	that	that	IN
29633	546	22	the	the	DT
29633	546	23	banks	bank	NNS
29633	546	24	of	of	IN
29633	546	25	the	the	DT
29633	546	26	United	United	NNP
29633	546	27	States	States	NNP
29633	546	28	had	have	VBD
29633	546	29	"	"	``
29633	546	30	almost	almost	RB
29633	546	31	universally	universally	RB
29633	546	32	suspended	suspend	VBN
29633	546	33	specie	specie	JJ
29633	546	34	payment	payment	NN
29633	546	35	.	.	.
29633	547	1	"	"	``
29633	547	2	[	[	-LRB-
29633	547	3	105	105	CD
29633	547	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	547	5	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	547	6	was	be	VBD
29633	547	7	involved	involve	VBN
29633	547	8	in	in	IN
29633	547	9	this	this	DT
29633	547	10	crisis	crisis	NN
29633	547	11	and	and	CC
29633	547	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	547	13	plant	plant	NN
29633	547	14	was	be	VBD
29633	547	15	closed	close	VBN
29633	547	16	down	down	RP
29633	547	17	.	.	.
29633	548	1	According	accord	VBG
29633	548	2	to	to	IN
29633	548	3	Swank,[106	Swank,[106	NNP
29633	548	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	548	5	some	some	DT
29633	548	6	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	548	7	were	be	VBD
29633	548	8	made	make	VBN
29633	548	9	to	to	TO
29633	548	10	adapt	adapt	VB
29633	548	11	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	548	12	's	's	POS
29633	548	13	process	process	NN
29633	548	14	to	to	TO
29633	548	15	need	need	NN
29633	548	16	of	of	IN
29633	548	17	rolling	rolling	JJ
29633	548	18	mills	mill	NNS
29633	548	19	at	at	IN
29633	548	20	the	the	DT
29633	548	21	Cambria	Cambria	NNP
29633	548	22	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	548	23	Works	Works	NNP
29633	548	24	in	in	IN
29633	548	25	1857	1857	CD
29633	548	26	and	and	CC
29633	548	27	1858	1858	CD
29633	548	28	,	,	,
29633	548	29	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	548	30	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	548	31	being	be	VBG
29633	548	32	at	at	IN
29633	548	33	Johnstown	Johnstown	NNP
29633	548	34	,	,	,
29633	548	35	at	at	IN
29633	548	36	least	least	JJS
29633	548	37	in	in	IN
29633	548	38	June	June	NNP
29633	548	39	1858	1858	CD
29633	548	40	.	.	.
29633	549	1	That	that	IN
29633	549	2	the	the	DT
29633	549	3	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	549	4	were	be	VBD
29633	549	5	not	not	RB
29633	549	6	particularly	particularly	RB
29633	549	7	successful	successful	JJ
29633	549	8	is	be	VBZ
29633	549	9	suggested	suggest	VBN
29633	549	10	by	by	IN
29633	549	11	the	the	DT
29633	549	12	lack	lack	NN
29633	549	13	of	of	IN
29633	549	14	any	any	DT
29633	549	15	American	american	JJ
29633	549	16	contributions	contribution	NNS
29633	549	17	to	to	IN
29633	549	18	the	the	DT
29633	549	19	correspondence	correspondence	NN
29633	549	20	in	in	IN
29633	549	21	the	the	DT
29633	549	22	English	english	JJ
29633	549	23	technical	technical	JJ
29633	549	24	journals	journal	NNS
29633	549	25	.	.	.
29633	550	1	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	550	2	was	be	VBD
29633	550	3	not	not	RB
29633	550	4	mentioned	mention	VBN
29633	550	5	as	as	IN
29633	550	6	having	have	VBG
29633	550	7	done	do	VBN
29633	550	8	more	more	RBR
29633	550	9	than	than	IN
29633	550	10	interfere	interfere	VB
29633	550	11	with	with	IN
29633	550	12	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	550	13	's	's	POS
29633	550	14	first	first	JJ
29633	550	15	patent	patent	NN
29633	550	16	application	application	NN
29633	550	17	.	.	.
29633	551	1	The	the	DT
29633	551	2	success	success	NN
29633	551	3	of	of	IN
29633	551	4	the	the	DT
29633	551	5	latter	latter	JJ
29633	551	6	in	in	IN
29633	551	7	obtaining	obtain	VBG
29633	551	8	patents[107	patents[107	NN
29633	551	9	]	]	-RRB-
29633	551	10	in	in	IN
29633	551	11	the	the	DT
29633	551	12	United	United	NNP
29633	551	13	States	States	NNP
29633	551	14	in	in	IN
29633	551	15	November	November	NNP
29633	551	16	1856	1856	CD
29633	551	17	,	,	,
29633	551	18	covering	cover	VBG
29633	551	19	"	"	``
29633	551	20	the	the	DT
29633	551	21	conversion	conversion	NN
29633	551	22	of	of	IN
29633	551	23	molten	molten	JJ
29633	551	24	crude	crude	JJ
29633	551	25	iron	iron	NN
29633	551	26	...	...	NFP
29633	551	27	into	into	IN
29633	551	28	steel	steel	NN
29633	551	29	or	or	CC
29633	551	30	malleable	malleable	JJ
29633	551	31	iron	iron	NN
29633	551	32	,	,	,
29633	551	33	without	without	IN
29633	551	34	the	the	DT
29633	551	35	use	use	NN
29633	551	36	of	of	IN
29633	551	37	fuel	fuel	NN
29633	551	38	...	...	:
29633	551	39	"	"	''
29633	551	40	also	also	RB
29633	551	41	escaped	escape	VBD
29633	551	42	the	the	DT
29633	551	43	attention	attention	NN
29633	551	44	of	of	IN
29633	551	45	both	both	CC
29633	551	46	English	english	JJ
29633	551	47	and	and	CC
29633	551	48	American	american	JJ
29633	551	49	writers	writer	NNS
29633	551	50	.	.	.
29633	552	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	552	2	105	105	CD
29633	552	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	552	4	_	_	NNP
29633	552	5	Economist	Economist	NNP
29633	552	6	_	_	NNP
29633	552	7	(	(	-LRB-
29633	552	8	London	London	NNP
29633	552	9	)	)	-RRB-
29633	552	10	,	,	,
29633	552	11	1857	1857	CD
29633	552	12	,	,	,
29633	552	13	vol	vol	NNP
29633	552	14	.	.	.
29633	553	1	15	15	CD
29633	553	2	,	,	,
29633	553	3	pp	pp	NNP
29633	553	4	.	.	.
29633	554	1	1129	1129	CD
29633	554	2	,	,	,
29633	554	3	1209	1209	CD
29633	554	4	.	.	.
29633	555	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	555	2	106	106	CD
29633	555	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	555	4	Swank	Swank	NNP
29633	555	5	,	,	,
29633	555	6	_	_	NNP
29633	555	7	op	op	NN
29633	555	8	.	.	.
29633	556	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	556	2	.	.	.
29633	556	3	_	_	NNP
29633	556	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	556	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	556	6	42	42	CD
29633	556	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	556	8	,	,	,
29633	556	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	556	10	125	125	CD
29633	556	11	.	.	.
29633	557	1	John	John	NNP
29633	557	2	Fritz	Fritz	NNP
29633	557	3	,	,	,
29633	557	4	in	in	IN
29633	557	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	557	6	_	_	NNP
29633	557	7	Autobiography	Autobiography	NNP
29633	557	8	_	_	NNP
29633	557	9	(	(	-LRB-
29633	557	10	New	New	NNP
29633	557	11	York	York	NNP
29633	557	12	,	,	,
29633	557	13	1912	1912	CD
29633	557	14	,	,	,
29633	557	15	p.	p.	NN
29633	557	16	162	162	CD
29633	557	17	)	)	-RRB-
29633	557	18	,	,	,
29633	557	19	refers	refer	VBZ
29633	557	20	to	to	IN
29633	557	21	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	557	22	during	during	IN
29633	557	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	557	24	time	time	NN
29633	557	25	at	at	IN
29633	557	26	Johnstown	Johnstown	NNP
29633	557	27	,	,	,
29633	557	28	_	_	NNP
29633	557	29	i.e.	i.e.	FW
29633	557	30	_	_	NNP
29633	557	31	,	,	,
29633	557	32	between	between	IN
29633	557	33	June	June	NNP
29633	557	34	1854	1854	CD
29633	557	35	and	and	CC
29633	557	36	July	July	NNP
29633	557	37	1860	1860	CD
29633	557	38	.	.	.
29633	558	1	_	_	NNP
29633	558	2	The	the	DT
29633	558	3	iron	iron	NN
29633	558	4	manufacturer	manufacturer	NN
29633	558	5	's	's	POS
29633	558	6	guide	guide	NN
29633	558	7	_	_	NNP
29633	558	8	(	(	-LRB-
29633	558	9	see	see	VB
29633	558	10	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	558	11	104	104	CD
29633	558	12	)	)	-RRB-
29633	558	13	also	also	RB
29633	558	14	refers	refer	VBZ
29633	558	15	to	to	IN
29633	558	16	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	558	17	's	's	POS
29633	558	18	process	process	NN
29633	558	19	as	as	IN
29633	558	20	having	have	VBG
29633	558	21	"	"	``
29633	558	22	just	just	RB
29633	558	23	been	be	VBN
29633	558	24	tried	try	VBN
29633	558	25	with	with	IN
29633	558	26	great	great	JJ
29633	558	27	success	success	NN
29633	558	28	"	"	''
29633	558	29	at	at	IN
29633	558	30	Cambria	Cambria	NNP
29633	558	31	.	.	.
29633	559	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	559	2	107	107	CD
29633	559	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	559	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	559	5	patents	patent	NNS
29633	559	6	16082	16082	CD
29633	559	7	,	,	,
29633	559	8	dated	date	VBN
29633	559	9	November	November	NNP
29633	559	10	11	11	CD
29633	559	11	,	,	,
29633	559	12	1856	1856	CD
29633	559	13	,	,	,
29633	559	14	and	and	CC
29633	559	15	16083	16083	CD
29633	559	16	,	,	,
29633	559	17	dated	date	VBN
29633	559	18	November	November	NNP
29633	559	19	18	18	CD
29633	559	20	,	,	,
29633	559	21	1856	1856	CD
29633	559	22	.	.	.
29633	560	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	560	2	's	's	POS
29633	560	3	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
29633	560	4	application	application	NN
29633	560	5	corresponded	correspond	VBD
29633	560	6	with	with	IN
29633	560	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	560	8	British	british	JJ
29633	560	9	patent	patent	NN
29633	560	10	2321	2321	CD
29633	560	11	,	,	,
29633	560	12	of	of	IN
29633	560	13	1855	1855	CD
29633	560	14	(	(	-LRB-
29633	560	15	see	see	VB
29633	560	16	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	560	17	98	98	CD
29633	560	18	)	)	-RRB-
29633	560	19	.	.	.
29633	561	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	561	2	was	be	VBD
29633	561	3	not	not	RB
29633	561	4	until	until	IN
29633	561	5	1861	1861	CD
29633	561	6	that	that	IN
29633	561	7	the	the	DT
29633	561	8	question	question	NN
29633	561	9	arose	arise	VBD
29633	561	10	as	as	IN
29633	561	11	to	to	IN
29633	561	12	what	what	WP
29633	561	13	happened	happen	VBD
29633	561	14	to	to	IN
29633	561	15	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	561	16	's	's	POS
29633	561	17	process	process	NN
29633	561	18	.	.	.
29633	562	1	The	the	DT
29633	562	2	occasion	occasion	NN
29633	562	3	was	be	VBD
29633	562	4	the	the	DT
29633	562	5	publication	publication	NN
29633	562	6	of	of	IN
29633	562	7	an	an	DT
29633	562	8	account	account	NN
29633	562	9	of	of	IN
29633	562	10	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	562	11	's	's	POS
29633	562	12	paper	paper	NN
29633	562	13	at	at	IN
29633	562	14	the	the	DT
29633	562	15	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	562	16	meeting	meeting	NN
29633	562	17	of	of	IN
29633	562	18	the	the	DT
29633	562	19	(	(	-LRB-
29633	562	20	British	british	JJ
29633	562	21	)	)	-RRB-
29633	562	22	Society	Society	NNP
29633	562	23	of	of	IN
29633	562	24	Mechanical	Mechanical	NNP
29633	562	25	Engineers	Engineers	NNP
29633	562	26	on	on	IN
29633	562	27	August	August	NNP
29633	562	28	1	1	CD
29633	562	29	,	,	,
29633	562	30	1861	1861	CD
29633	562	31	.	.	.
29633	563	1	Accepting	accept	VBG
29633	563	2	the	the	DT
29633	563	3	evidence	evidence	NN
29633	563	4	of	of	IN
29633	563	5	"	"	``
29633	563	6	the	the	DT
29633	563	7	complete	complete	JJ
29633	563	8	industrial	industrial	JJ
29633	563	9	success	success	NN
29633	563	10	"	"	''
29633	563	11	of	of	IN
29633	563	12	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	563	13	's	's	POS
29633	563	14	process	process	NN
29633	563	15	,	,	,
29633	563	16	the	the	DT
29633	563	17	_	_	NNP
29633	563	18	Scientific	Scientific	NNP
29633	563	19	American_[108	American_[108	NNP
29633	563	20	]	]	-RRB-
29633	563	21	asked	ask	VBD
29633	563	22	:	:	:
29633	563	23	"	"	``
29633	563	24	Would	Would	MD
29633	563	25	not	not	RB
29633	563	26	some	some	DT
29633	563	27	of	of	IN
29633	563	28	our	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	563	29	enterprising	enterprising	JJ
29633	563	30	manufacturers	manufacturer	NNS
29633	563	31	make	make	VBP
29633	563	32	a	a	DT
29633	563	33	good	good	JJ
29633	563	34	operation	operation	NN
29633	563	35	by	by	IN
29633	563	36	getting	get	VBG
29633	563	37	hold	hold	NN
29633	563	38	of	of	IN
29633	563	39	the	the	DT
29633	563	40	[	[	-LRB-
29633	563	41	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	563	42	]	]	-RRB-
29633	563	43	patent	patent	NN
29633	563	44	and	and	CC
29633	563	45	starting	start	VBG
29633	563	46	the	the	DT
29633	563	47	manufacture	manufacture	NN
29633	563	48	of	of	IN
29633	563	49	steel	steel	NN
29633	563	50	in	in	IN
29633	563	51	this	this	DT
29633	563	52	country	country	NN
29633	563	53	?	?	.
29633	563	54	"	"	''
29633	564	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	564	2	108	108	CD
29633	564	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	564	4	_	_	NNP
29633	564	5	Scientific	Scientific	NNP
29633	564	6	American	American	NNP
29633	564	7	_	_	NNP
29633	564	8	,	,	,
29633	564	9	1861	1861	CD
29633	564	10	,	,	,
29633	564	11	new	new	NNP
29633	564	12	ser	ser	NNP
29633	564	13	.	.	.
29633	564	14	,	,	,
29633	564	15	vol	vol	NNP
29633	564	16	.	.	.
29633	565	1	5	5	CD
29633	565	2	,	,	,
29633	565	3	pp	pp	NNP
29633	565	4	.	.	.
29633	566	1	148	148	CD
29633	566	2	-	-	SYM
29633	566	3	153	153	CD
29633	566	4	.	.	.
29633	567	1	There	there	EX
29633	567	2	was	be	VBD
29633	567	3	no	no	DT
29633	567	4	response	response	NN
29633	567	5	to	to	IN
29633	567	6	this	this	DT
29633	567	7	rhetorical	rhetorical	JJ
29633	567	8	question	question	NN
29633	567	9	,	,	,
29633	567	10	but	but	CC
29633	567	11	a	a	DT
29633	567	12	further	further	JJ
29633	567	13	inquiry	inquiry	NN
29633	567	14	as	as	IN
29633	567	15	to	to	IN
29633	567	16	whether	whether	IN
29633	567	17	the	the	DT
29633	567	18	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	567	19	patent	patent	NN
29633	567	20	"	"	``
29633	567	21	could	could	MD
29633	567	22	be	be	VB
29633	567	23	bought"[109	bought"[109	NN
29633	567	24	]	]	-RRB-
29633	567	25	elicited	elicit	VBD
29633	567	26	a	a	DT
29633	567	27	response	response	NN
29633	567	28	from	from	IN
29633	567	29	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	567	30	.	.	.
29633	568	1	Writing	write	VBG
29633	568	2	from	from	IN
29633	568	3	Hammondsville	Hammondsville	NNP
29633	568	4	,	,	,
29633	568	5	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
29633	568	6	,	,	,
29633	568	7	Kelly[110	Kelly[110	NNP
29633	568	8	]	]	-RRB-
29633	568	9	said	say	VBD
29633	568	10	,	,	,
29633	568	11	in	in	IN
29633	568	12	part	part	NN
29633	568	13	:	:	:
29633	568	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	568	15	would	would	MD
29633	568	16	say	say	VB
29633	568	17	that	that	IN
29633	568	18	the	the	DT
29633	568	19	New	New	NNP
29633	568	20	England	England	NNP
29633	568	21	states	state	NNS
29633	568	22	and	and	CC
29633	568	23	New	New	NNP
29633	568	24	York	York	NNP
29633	568	25	would	would	MD
29633	568	26	be	be	VB
29633	568	27	sold	sell	VBN
29633	568	28	at	at	IN
29633	568	29	a	a	DT
29633	568	30	fair	fair	JJ
29633	568	31	rate	rate	NN
29633	568	32	....	....	.
29633	569	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
29633	569	2	removed	remove	VBD
29633	569	3	from	from	IN
29633	569	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
29633	569	5	about	about	IN
29633	569	6	three	three	CD
29633	569	7	years	year	NNS
29633	569	8	ago	ago	RB
29633	569	9	,	,	,
29633	569	10	and	and	CC
29633	569	11	now	now	RB
29633	569	12	reside	reside	VB
29633	569	13	at	at	IN
29633	569	14	New	New	NNP
29633	569	15	Salisbury	Salisbury	NNP
29633	569	16	about	about	RB
29633	569	17	three	three	CD
29633	569	18	miles	mile	NNS
29633	569	19	from	from	IN
29633	569	20	Hammondsville	Hammondsville	NNP
29633	569	21	and	and	CC
29633	569	22	sixty	sixty	CD
29633	569	23	miles	mile	NNS
29633	569	24	from	from	IN
29633	569	25	Pittsburg	Pittsburg	NNP
29633	569	26	.	.	.
29633	570	1	Accept	accept	VB
29633	570	2	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	570	3	thanks	thank	NNS
29633	570	4	for	for	IN
29633	570	5	your	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	570	6	kind	kind	JJ
29633	570	7	efforts	effort	NNS
29633	570	8	in	in	IN
29633	570	9	endeavoring	endeavor	VBG
29633	570	10	to	to	TO
29633	570	11	draw	draw	VB
29633	570	12	the	the	DT
29633	570	13	attention	attention	NN
29633	570	14	of	of	IN
29633	570	15	the	the	DT
29633	570	16	community	community	NN
29633	570	17	to	to	IN
29633	570	18	the	the	DT
29633	570	19	advantages	advantage	NNS
29633	570	20	of	of	IN
29633	570	21	my	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	570	22	process	process	NN
29633	570	23	.	.	.
29633	571	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	571	2	109	109	CD
29633	571	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	571	4	_	_	NNP
29633	571	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	571	6	.	.	.
29633	571	7	_	_	NNP
29633	571	8	,	,	,
29633	571	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	571	10	310	310	CD
29633	571	11	.	.	.
29633	572	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	572	2	110	110	CD
29633	572	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	572	4	_	_	NNP
29633	572	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
29633	572	6	.	.	.
29633	572	7	_	_	NNP
29633	572	8	,	,	,
29633	572	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	572	10	343	343	CD
29633	572	11	.	.	.
29633	573	1	This	this	DT
29633	573	2	letter	letter	NN
29633	573	3	suggests	suggest	VBZ
29633	573	4	that	that	IN
29633	573	5	the	the	DT
29633	573	6	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	573	7	process	process	NN
29633	573	8	had	have	VBD
29633	573	9	been	be	VBN
29633	573	10	dormant	dormant	JJ
29633	573	11	since	since	IN
29633	573	12	1858	1858	CD
29633	573	13	.	.	.
29633	574	1	Whether	whether	IN
29633	574	2	or	or	CC
29633	574	3	not	not	RB
29633	574	4	as	as	IN
29633	574	5	a	a	DT
29633	574	6	result	result	NN
29633	574	7	of	of	IN
29633	574	8	the	the	DT
29633	574	9	publication	publication	NN
29633	574	10	of	of	IN
29633	574	11	this	this	DT
29633	574	12	letter	letter	NN
29633	574	13	,	,	,
29633	574	14	interest	interest	NN
29633	574	15	was	be	VBD
29633	574	16	resumed	resume	VBN
29633	574	17	in	in	IN
29633	574	18	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	574	19	's	's	POS
29633	574	20	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	574	21	.	.	.
29633	575	1	Captain	Captain	NNP
29633	575	2	Eber	Eber	NNP
29633	575	3	Brock	Brock	NNP
29633	575	4	Ward	Ward	NNP
29633	575	5	of	of	IN
29633	575	6	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
29633	575	7	and	and	CC
29633	575	8	Z.	Z.	NNP
29633	575	9	S.	S.	NNP
29633	575	10	Durfee	Durfee	NNP
29633	575	11	of	of	IN
29633	575	12	New	New	NNP
29633	575	13	Bedford	Bedford	NNP
29633	575	14	,	,	,
29633	575	15	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
29633	575	16	,	,	,
29633	575	17	obtained	obtain	VBD
29633	575	18	control	control	NN
29633	575	19	of	of	IN
29633	575	20	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	575	21	's	's	POS
29633	575	22	patent	patent	NN
29633	575	23	.	.	.
29633	576	1	Durfee	Durfee	NNP
29633	576	2	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	576	3	went	go	VBD
29633	576	4	to	to	IN
29633	576	5	England	England	NNP
29633	576	6	in	in	IN
29633	576	7	the	the	DT
29633	576	8	fall	fall	NN
29633	576	9	of	of	IN
29633	576	10	1861	1861	CD
29633	576	11	in	in	IN
29633	576	12	an	an	DT
29633	576	13	attempt	attempt	NN
29633	576	14	to	to	TO
29633	576	15	secure	secure	VB
29633	576	16	a	a	DT
29633	576	17	license	license	NN
29633	576	18	from	from	IN
29633	576	19	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	576	20	.	.	.
29633	577	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
29633	577	2	returned	return	VBD
29633	577	3	to	to	IN
29633	577	4	the	the	DT
29633	577	5	United	United	NNP
29633	577	6	States	States	NNP
29633	577	7	in	in	IN
29633	577	8	the	the	DT
29633	577	9	early	early	JJ
29633	577	10	fall	fall	NN
29633	577	11	of	of	IN
29633	577	12	1862	1862	CD
29633	577	13	,	,	,
29633	577	14	assuming	assume	VBG
29633	577	15	that	that	IN
29633	577	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	577	17	was	be	VBD
29633	577	18	the	the	DT
29633	577	19	only	only	JJ
29633	577	20	"	"	``
29633	577	21	citizen	citizen	NN
29633	577	22	of	of	IN
29633	577	23	the	the	DT
29633	577	24	United	United	NNP
29633	577	25	States	States	NNP
29633	577	26	"	"	''
29633	577	27	who	who	WP
29633	577	28	had	have	VBD
29633	577	29	even	even	RB
29633	577	30	seen	see	VBN
29633	577	31	the	the	DT
29633	577	32	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	577	33	apparatus	apparatus	NN
29633	577	34	.	.	.
29633	578	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	578	2	111	111	CD
29633	578	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	578	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	578	5	111	111	CD
29633	578	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	578	7	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	578	8	claim	claim	NN
29633	578	9	is	be	VBZ
29633	578	10	somewhat	somewhat	RB
29633	578	11	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
29633	578	12	.	.	.
29633	579	1	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
29633	579	2	Lyman	Lyman	NNP
29633	579	3	Holley	Holley	NNP
29633	579	4	,	,	,
29633	579	5	who	who	WP
29633	579	6	was	be	VBD
29633	579	7	later	later	RB
29633	579	8	to	to	TO
29633	579	9	be	be	VB
29633	579	10	responsible	responsible	JJ
29633	579	11	for	for	IN
29633	579	12	the	the	DT
29633	579	13	design	design	NN
29633	579	14	of	of	IN
29633	579	15	most	most	JJS
29633	579	16	of	of	IN
29633	579	17	the	the	DT
29633	579	18	first	first	JJ
29633	579	19	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	579	20	plants	plant	NNS
29633	579	21	in	in	IN
29633	579	22	the	the	DT
29633	579	23	United	United	NNP
29633	579	24	States	States	NNP
29633	579	25	had	have	VBD
29633	579	26	been	be	VBN
29633	579	27	in	in	IN
29633	579	28	England	England	NNP
29633	579	29	in	in	IN
29633	579	30	1859	1859	CD
29633	579	31	,	,	,
29633	579	32	1860	1860	CD
29633	579	33	,	,	,
29633	579	34	and	and	CC
29633	579	35	1862	1862	CD
29633	579	36	.	.	.
29633	580	1	In	in	IN
29633	580	2	view	view	NN
29633	580	3	of	of	IN
29633	580	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	580	5	interest	interest	NN
29633	580	6	in	in	IN
29633	580	7	ordnance	ordnance	NN
29633	580	8	and	and	CC
29633	580	9	armor	armor	NN
29633	580	10	,	,	,
29633	580	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	580	12	is	be	VBZ
29633	580	13	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
29633	580	14	that	that	IN
29633	580	15	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	580	16	could	could	MD
29633	580	17	have	have	VB
29633	580	18	escaped	escape	VBN
29633	580	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	580	20	alert	alert	JJ
29633	580	21	observation	observation	NN
29633	580	22	.	.	.
29633	581	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	581	2	first	first	JJ
29633	581	3	visit	visit	NN
29633	581	4	specifically	specifically	RB
29633	581	5	in	in	IN
29633	581	6	connection	connection	NN
29633	581	7	with	with	IN
29633	581	8	the	the	DT
29633	581	9	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	581	10	process	process	NN
29633	581	11	appears	appear	VBZ
29633	581	12	to	to	TO
29633	581	13	have	have	VB
29633	581	14	been	be	VBN
29633	581	15	in	in	IN
29633	581	16	1863	1863	CD
29633	581	17	,	,	,
29633	581	18	but	but	CC
29633	581	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	581	20	is	be	VBZ
29633	581	21	said	say	VBN
29633	581	22	to	to	TO
29633	581	23	have	have	VB
29633	581	24	begun	begin	VBN
29633	581	25	to	to	TO
29633	581	26	interest	interest	NN
29633	581	27	financiers	financier	NNS
29633	581	28	and	and	CC
29633	581	29	ironmasters	ironmaster	NNS
29633	581	30	in	in	IN
29633	581	31	the	the	DT
29633	581	32	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	581	33	process	process	NN
29633	581	34	after	after	IN
29633	581	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	581	36	visit	visit	NN
29633	581	37	in	in	IN
29633	581	38	1862	1862	CD
29633	581	39	(	(	-LRB-
29633	581	40	_	_	NNP
29633	581	41	Engineering	Engineering	NNP
29633	581	42	_	_	NNP
29633	581	43	,	,	,
29633	581	44	1882	1882	CD
29633	581	45	,	,	,
29633	581	46	vol	vol	NNP
29633	581	47	.	.	.
29633	582	1	33	33	CD
29633	582	2	,	,	,
29633	582	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	582	4	115	115	CD
29633	582	5	)	)	-RRB-
29633	582	6	.	.	.
29633	583	1	In	in	IN
29633	583	2	June	June	NNP
29633	583	3	,	,	,
29633	583	4	1862	1862	CD
29633	583	5	,	,	,
29633	583	6	W.	W.	NNP
29633	583	7	F.	F.	NNP
29633	583	8	Durfee	Durfee	NNP
29633	583	9	,	,	,
29633	583	10	a	a	DT
29633	583	11	cousin	cousin	NN
29633	583	12	of	of	IN
29633	583	13	Z.	Z.	NNP
29633	583	14	S.	S.	NNP
29633	583	15	Durfee	Durfee	NNP
29633	583	16	,	,	,
29633	583	17	was	be	VBD
29633	583	18	asked	ask	VBN
29633	583	19	by	by	IN
29633	583	20	Ward	Ward	NNP
29633	583	21	to	to	TO
29633	583	22	report	report	VB
29633	583	23	on	on	IN
29633	583	24	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	583	25	's	's	POS
29633	583	26	process	process	NN
29633	583	27	.	.	.
29633	584	1	The	the	DT
29633	584	2	report[112	report[112	NNP
29633	584	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	584	4	was	be	VBD
29633	584	5	unfavorable	unfavorable	JJ
29633	584	6	.	.	.
29633	585	1	"	"	``
29633	585	2	The	the	DT
29633	585	3	description	description	NN
29633	585	4	of	of	IN
29633	585	5	[	[	-LRB-
29633	585	6	the	the	DT
29633	585	7	apparatus	apparatus	NN
29633	585	8	]	]	-RRB-
29633	585	9	used	use	VBN
29633	585	10	by	by	IN
29633	585	11	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	585	12	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	585	13	at	at	IN
29633	585	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	585	15	abandoned	abandon	VBN
29633	585	16	works	work	NNS
29633	585	17	in	in	IN
29633	585	18	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
29633	585	19	satisfied	satisfy	VBD
29633	585	20	me	-PRON-	PRP
29633	585	21	that	that	IN
29633	585	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	585	23	was	be	VBD
29633	585	24	not	not	RB
29633	585	25	suited	suit	VBN
29633	585	26	for	for	IN
29633	585	27	an	an	DT
29633	585	28	experiment	experiment	NN
29633	585	29	on	on	IN
29633	585	30	so	so	RB
29633	585	31	large	large	JJ
29633	585	32	a	a	DT
29633	585	33	scale	scale	NN
29633	585	34	as	as	IN
29633	585	35	was	be	VBD
29633	585	36	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
29633	585	37	at	at	IN
29633	585	38	Wyandotte	Wyandotte	NNP
29633	585	39	[	[	-LRB-
29633	585	40	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
29633	585	41	]	]	-RRB-
29633	585	42	.	.	.
29633	585	43	"	"	''
29633	586	1	Since	since	IN
29633	586	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	586	3	was	be	VBD
29633	586	4	"	"	``
29633	586	5	confidently	confidently	RB
29633	586	6	expected	expect	VBN
29633	586	7	that	that	IN
29633	586	8	Z.	Z.	NNP
29633	586	9	S.	S.	NNP
29633	586	10	Durfee	Durfee	NNP
29633	586	11	would	would	MD
29633	586	12	be	be	VB
29633	586	13	successful	successful	JJ
29633	586	14	in	in	IN
29633	586	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	586	16	efforts	effort	NNS
29633	586	17	to	to	TO
29633	586	18	purchase	purchase	VB
29633	586	19	[	[	-LRB-
29633	586	20	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	586	21	's	's	POS
29633	586	22	patents	patent	NNS
29633	586	23	]	]	-RRB-
29633	586	24	,	,	,
29633	586	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	586	26	was	be	VBD
29633	586	27	thought	think	VBN
29633	586	28	only	only	RB
29633	586	29	to	to	TO
29633	586	30	be	be	VB
29633	586	31	anticipating	anticipate	VBG
29633	586	32	the	the	DT
29633	586	33	acquisition	acquisition	NN
29633	586	34	of	of	IN
29633	586	35	property	property	NN
29633	586	36	rights	right	NNS
29633	586	37	...	...	NFP
29633	586	38	to	to	TO
29633	586	39	use	use	VB
29633	586	40	such	such	JJ
29633	586	41	of	of	IN
29633	586	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	586	43	inventions	invention	NNS
29633	586	44	as	as	IN
29633	586	45	best	well	RBS
29633	586	46	suited	suit	VBD
29633	586	47	the	the	DT
29633	586	48	purpose	purpose	NN
29633	586	49	in	in	IN
29633	586	50	view	view	NN
29633	586	51	.	.	.
29633	586	52	"	"	''
29633	587	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	587	2	112	112	CD
29633	587	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	587	4	W.	W.	NNP
29633	587	5	F.	F.	NNP
29633	587	6	Durfee	Durfee	NNP
29633	587	7	:	:	:
29633	587	8	"	"	``
29633	587	9	An	an	DT
29633	587	10	account	account	NN
29633	587	11	of	of	IN
29633	587	12	the	the	DT
29633	587	13	experimental	experimental	JJ
29633	587	14	steel	steel	NN
29633	587	15	works	work	VBZ
29633	587	16	at	at	IN
29633	587	17	Wyandotte	Wyandotte	NNP
29633	587	18	,	,	,
29633	587	19	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
29633	587	20	,	,	,
29633	587	21	"	"	``
29633	587	22	_	_	NNP
29633	587	23	Transactions	Transactions	NNPS
29633	587	24	of	of	IN
29633	587	25	the	the	DT
29633	587	26	American	American	NNP
29633	587	27	Society	Society	NNP
29633	587	28	of	of	IN
29633	587	29	Mechanical	Mechanical	NNP
29633	587	30	Engineers	Engineers	NNPS
29633	587	31	_	_	NNP
29633	587	32	,	,	,
29633	587	33	1884	1884	CD
29633	587	34	,	,	,
29633	587	35	vol	vol	NNP
29633	587	36	.	.	.
29633	588	1	6	6	CD
29633	588	2	,	,	,
29633	588	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	588	4	40	40	CD
29633	588	5	ff	ff	NN
29633	588	6	.	.	.
29633	589	1	Thus	thus	RB
29633	589	2	the	the	DT
29633	589	3	first	first	JJ
29633	589	4	"	"	``
29633	589	5	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	589	6	"	"	''
29633	589	7	plant	plant	NN
29633	589	8	in	in	IN
29633	589	9	the	the	DT
29633	589	10	United	United	NNP
29633	589	11	States	States	NNP
29633	589	12	came	come	VBD
29633	589	13	into	into	IN
29633	589	14	being	being	NN
29633	589	15	without	without	IN
29633	589	16	benefit	benefit	NN
29633	589	17	of	of	IN
29633	589	18	a	a	DT
29633	589	19	license	license	NN
29633	589	20	and	and	CC
29633	589	21	supported	support	VBD
29633	589	22	only	only	RB
29633	589	23	by	by	IN
29633	589	24	a	a	DT
29633	589	25	patent	patent	NN
29633	589	26	"	"	``
29633	589	27	not	not	RB
29633	589	28	suited	suit	VBN
29633	589	29	"	"	''
29633	589	30	for	for	IN
29633	589	31	a	a	DT
29633	589	32	large	large	JJ
29633	589	33	experiment	experiment	NN
29633	589	34	.	.	.
29633	590	1	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	590	2	seems	seem	VBZ
29633	590	3	to	to	TO
29633	590	4	have	have	VB
29633	590	5	had	have	VBN
29633	590	6	no	no	DT
29633	590	7	part	part	NN
29633	590	8	in	in	IN
29633	590	9	these	these	DT
29633	590	10	developments	development	NNS
29633	590	11	.	.	.
29633	591	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
29633	591	2	took	take	VBD
29633	591	3	some	some	DT
29633	591	4	time	time	NN
29633	591	5	to	to	TO
29633	591	6	come	come	VB
29633	591	7	to	to	IN
29633	591	8	formation	formation	NN
29633	591	9	.	.	.
29633	592	1	Although	although	IN
29633	592	2	the	the	DT
29633	592	3	converter	converter	NN
29633	592	4	was	be	VBD
29633	592	5	ready	ready	JJ
29633	592	6	by	by	IN
29633	592	7	September	September	NNP
29633	592	8	1862	1862	CD
29633	592	9	,	,	,
29633	592	10	the	the	DT
29633	592	11	blowing	blow	VBG
29633	592	12	engine	engine	NN
29633	592	13	was	be	VBD
29633	592	14	not	not	RB
29633	592	15	completed	complete	VBN
29633	592	16	until	until	IN
29633	592	17	the	the	DT
29633	592	18	spring	spring	NN
29633	592	19	of	of	IN
29633	592	20	1864	1864	CD
29633	592	21	and	and	CC
29633	592	22	the	the	DT
29633	592	23	first	first	JJ
29633	592	24	"	"	``
29633	592	25	blow	blow	NN
29633	592	26	"	"	''
29633	592	27	successfully	successfully	RB
29633	592	28	made	make	VBN
29633	592	29	in	in	IN
29633	592	30	1864	1864	CD
29633	592	31	.	.	.
29633	593	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	593	2	may	may	MD
29633	593	3	be	be	VB
29633	593	4	no	no	DT
29633	593	5	more	more	JJR
29633	593	6	than	than	IN
29633	593	7	a	a	DT
29633	593	8	coincidence	coincidence	NN
29633	593	9	that	that	IN
29633	593	10	the	the	DT
29633	593	11	start	start	NN
29633	593	12	of	of	IN
29633	593	13	production	production	NN
29633	593	14	seems	seem	VBZ
29633	593	15	to	to	TO
29633	593	16	have	have	VB
29633	593	17	been	be	VBN
29633	593	18	impossible	impossible	JJ
29633	593	19	before	before	IN
29633	593	20	the	the	DT
29633	593	21	arrival	arrival	NN
29633	593	22	in	in	IN
29633	593	23	this	this	DT
29633	593	24	country	country	NN
29633	593	25	of	of	IN
29633	593	26	a	a	DT
29633	593	27	young	young	JJ
29633	593	28	man	man	NN
29633	593	29	,	,	,
29633	593	30	L.	L.	NNP
29633	593	31	M.	M.	NNP
29633	593	32	Hart	Hart	NNP
29633	593	33	,	,	,
29633	593	34	who	who	WP
29633	593	35	had	have	VBD
29633	593	36	been	be	VBN
29633	593	37	trained	train	VBN
29633	593	38	in	in	IN
29633	593	39	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	593	40	operations	operation	NNS
29633	593	41	at	at	IN
29633	593	42	the	the	DT
29633	593	43	plant	plant	NN
29633	593	44	of	of	IN
29633	593	45	the	the	DT
29633	593	46	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
29633	593	47	Brothers	Brothers	NNPS
29633	593	48	at	at	IN
29633	593	49	St.	St.	NNP
29633	593	50	Seurin	Seurin	NNP
29633	593	51	(	(	-LRB-
29633	593	52	near	near	IN
29633	593	53	Bordeaux	Bordeaux	NNP
29633	593	54	)	)	-RRB-
29633	593	55	France	France	NNP
29633	593	56	.	.	.
29633	594	1	The	the	DT
29633	594	2	Jacksons	Jacksons	NNPS
29633	594	3	had	have	VBD
29633	594	4	become	become	VBN
29633	594	5	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	594	6	's	's	POS
29633	594	7	partners	partner	NNS
29633	594	8	in	in	IN
29633	594	9	respect	respect	NN
29633	594	10	of	of	IN
29633	594	11	the	the	DT
29633	594	12	French	french	JJ
29633	594	13	rights	right	NNS
29633	594	14	;	;	:
29633	594	15	and	and	CC
29633	594	16	the	the	DT
29633	594	17	recruitment	recruitment	NN
29633	594	18	of	of	IN
29633	594	19	Hart	Hart	NNP
29633	594	20	suggests	suggest	VBZ
29633	594	21	the	the	DT
29633	594	22	possibility	possibility	NN
29633	594	23	that	that	IN
29633	594	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	594	25	was	be	VBD
29633	594	26	from	from	IN
29633	594	27	this	this	DT
29633	594	28	French	french	JJ
29633	594	29	source	source	NN
29633	594	30	that	that	WDT
29633	594	31	Z.	Z.	NNP
29633	594	32	S.	S.	NNP
29633	594	33	Durfee	Durfee	NNP
29633	594	34	obtained	obtain	VBD
29633	594	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	594	36	initial	initial	JJ
29633	594	37	technical	technical	JJ
29633	594	38	data	datum	NNS
29633	594	39	on	on	IN
29633	594	40	the	the	DT
29633	594	41	operation	operation	NN
29633	594	42	of	of	IN
29633	594	43	the	the	DT
29633	594	44	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	594	45	process	process	NN
29633	594	46	.	.	.
29633	595	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	595	2	113	113	CD
29633	595	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	595	4	[	[	-LRB-
29633	595	5	113	113	CD
29633	595	6	]	]	-RRB-
29633	595	7	Research	research	NN
29633	595	8	in	in	IN
29633	595	9	the	the	DT
29633	595	10	French	french	JJ
29633	595	11	sources	source	NNS
29633	595	12	continues	continue	VBZ
29633	595	13	.	.	.
29633	596	1	The	the	DT
29633	596	2	arrival	arrival	NN
29633	596	3	of	of	IN
29633	596	4	L.	L.	NNP
29633	596	5	M.	M.	NNP
29633	596	6	Hart	Hart	NNP
29633	596	7	at	at	IN
29633	596	8	Boston	Boston	NNP
29633	596	9	is	be	VBZ
29633	596	10	recorded	record	VBN
29633	596	11	as	as	IN
29633	596	12	of	of	IN
29633	596	13	April	April	NNP
29633	596	14	1	1	CD
29633	596	15	,	,	,
29633	596	16	1864	1864	CD
29633	596	17	,	,	,
29633	596	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	596	19	ship	ship	NN
29633	596	20	being	be	VBG
29633	596	21	the	the	DT
29633	596	22	SS	SS	NNP
29633	596	23	_	_	NNP
29633	596	24	Africa	Africa	NNP
29633	596	25	_	_	NNP
29633	596	26	out	out	IN
29633	596	27	of	of	IN
29633	596	28	Liverpool	Liverpool	NNP
29633	596	29	,	,	,
29633	596	30	England	England	NNP
29633	596	31	(	(	-LRB-
29633	596	32	Archives	Archives	NNPS
29633	596	33	of	of	IN
29633	596	34	the	the	DT
29633	596	35	United	United	NNP
29633	596	36	States	States	NNP
29633	596	37	,	,	,
29633	596	38	card	card	NN
29633	596	39	index	index	NN
29633	596	40	of	of	IN
29633	596	41	passenger	passenger	NN
29633	596	42	arrivals	arrival	NNS
29633	596	43	1849	1849	CD
29633	596	44	-	-	SYM
29633	596	45	1891	1891	CD
29633	596	46	list	list	NN
29633	596	47	No	no	UH
29633	596	48	.	.	.
29633	597	1	39	39	CD
29633	597	2	)	)	-RRB-
29633	597	3	.	.	.
29633	598	1	During	during	IN
29633	598	2	the	the	DT
29633	598	3	organization	organization	NN
29633	598	4	of	of	IN
29633	598	5	the	the	DT
29633	598	6	plant	plant	NN
29633	598	7	at	at	IN
29633	598	8	Wyandotte	Wyandotte	NNP
29633	598	9	,	,	,
29633	598	10	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	598	11	was	be	VBD
29633	598	12	called	call	VBN
29633	598	13	back	back	RB
29633	598	14	to	to	IN
29633	598	15	Cambria	Cambria	NNP
29633	598	16	,	,	,
29633	598	17	probably	probably	RB
29633	598	18	by	by	IN
29633	598	19	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
29633	598	20	J.	J.	NNP
29633	598	21	Morrell	Morrell	NNP
29633	598	22	,	,	,
29633	598	23	who	who	WP
29633	598	24	,	,	,
29633	598	25	later	later	RB
29633	598	26	,	,	,
29633	598	27	became	become	VBD
29633	598	28	a	a	DT
29633	598	29	partner	partner	NN
29633	598	30	with	with	IN
29633	598	31	Ward	Ward	NNP
29633	598	32	and	and	CC
29633	598	33	Z.	Z.	NNP
29633	598	34	S.	S.	NNP
29633	598	35	Durfee	Durfee	NNP
29633	598	36	in	in	IN
29633	598	37	the	the	DT
29633	598	38	formation	formation	NN
29633	598	39	of	of	IN
29633	598	40	the	the	DT
29633	598	41	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	598	42	Pneumatic	Pneumatic	NNP
29633	598	43	Process	Process	NNP
29633	598	44	Company	Company	NNP
29633	598	45	.	.	.
29633	599	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	599	2	114	114	CD
29633	599	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	599	4	We	-PRON-	PRP
29633	599	5	learn	learn	VBP
29633	599	6	from	from	IN
29633	599	7	John	John	NNP
29633	599	8	E.	E.	NNP
29633	599	9	Fry,[115	Fry,[115	NNP
29633	599	10	]	]	-RRB-
29633	599	11	the	the	DT
29633	599	12	iron	iron	NN
29633	599	13	moulder	moulder	NN
29633	599	14	who	who	WP
29633	599	15	was	be	VBD
29633	599	16	assigned	assign	VBN
29633	599	17	to	to	TO
29633	599	18	help	help	VB
29633	599	19	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	599	20	,	,	,
29633	599	21	that--	that--	XX
29633	599	22	in	in	IN
29633	599	23	1862	1862	CD
29633	599	24	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	599	25	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	599	26	returned	return	VBD
29633	599	27	to	to	IN
29633	599	28	Johnstown	Johnstown	NNP
29633	599	29	for	for	IN
29633	599	30	a	a	DT
29633	599	31	crucial	crucial	NN
29633	599	32	,	,	,
29633	599	33	and	and	CC
29633	599	34	as	as	IN
29633	599	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	599	36	turned	turn	VBD
29633	599	37	out	out	RP
29633	599	38	,	,	,
29633	599	39	a	a	DT
29633	599	40	final	final	JJ
29633	599	41	series	series	NN
29633	599	42	of	of	IN
29633	599	43	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	599	44	by	by	IN
29633	599	45	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	599	46	with	with	IN
29633	599	47	a	a	DT
29633	599	48	rotative	rotative	JJ
29633	599	49	[	[	-LRB-
29633	599	50	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	599	51	converter	converter	NN
29633	599	52	]	]	-RRB-
29633	599	53	_	_	NNP
29633	599	54	made	make	VBD
29633	599	55	abroad	abroad	RB
29633	599	56	and	and	CC
29633	599	57	imported	import	VBN
29633	599	58	for	for	IN
29633	599	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	599	60	purpose	purpose	NN
29633	599	61	_	_	NNP
29633	599	62	.	.	.
29633	600	1	This	this	DT
29633	600	2	converter	converter	NN
29633	600	3	embodied	embody	VBD
29633	600	4	in	in	IN
29633	600	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	600	6	materials	material	NNS
29633	600	7	and	and	CC
29633	600	8	construction	construction	NN
29633	600	9	several	several	JJ
29633	600	10	of	of	IN
29633	600	11	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	600	12	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	600	13	's	's	POS
29633	600	14	patented	patent	VBN
29633	600	15	factors	factor	NNS
29633	600	16	,	,	,
29633	600	17	of	of	IN
29633	600	18	which	which	WDT
29633	600	19	,	,	,
29633	600	20	up	up	IN
29633	600	21	to	to	IN
29633	600	22	the	the	DT
29633	600	23	close	close	NN
29633	600	24	of	of	IN
29633	600	25	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	600	26	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	600	27	's	's	POS
29633	600	28	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	600	29	above	above	IN
29633	600	30	noted	note	VBD
29633	600	31	,	,	,
29633	600	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	600	33	seemed	seem	VBD
29633	600	34	to	to	TO
29633	600	35	have	have	VB
29633	600	36	no	no	DT
29633	600	37	knowledge	knowledge	NN
29633	600	38	or	or	CC
29633	600	39	conception	conception	NN
29633	600	40	.	.	.
29633	601	1	And	and	CC
29633	601	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	601	3	was	be	VBD
29633	601	4	as	as	RB
29633	601	5	late	late	JJ
29633	601	6	as	as	IN
29633	601	7	on	on	IN
29633	601	8	the	the	DT
29633	601	9	occasion	occasion	NN
29633	601	10	of	of	IN
29633	601	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	601	12	return	return	NN
29633	601	13	in	in	IN
29633	601	14	1862	1862	CD
29633	601	15	,	,	,
29633	601	16	to	to	TO
29633	601	17	operate	operate	VB
29633	601	18	the	the	DT
29633	601	19	experimental	experimental	JJ
29633	601	20	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	601	21	converter	converter	NN
29633	601	22	,	,	,
29633	601	23	that	that	IN
29633	601	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	601	25	first	first	RB
29633	601	26	recognized	recognize	VBD
29633	601	27	,	,	,
29633	601	28	by	by	IN
29633	601	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	601	30	adoption	adoption	NN
29633	601	31	,	,	,
29633	601	32	the	the	DT
29633	601	33	necessity	necessity	NN
29633	601	34	for	for	IN
29633	601	35	or	or	CC
29633	601	36	the	the	DT
29633	601	37	importance	importance	NN
29633	601	38	of	of	IN
29633	601	39	any	any	DT
29633	601	40	after	after	IN
29633	601	41	treatment	treatment	NN
29633	601	42	of	of	IN
29633	601	43	,	,	,
29633	601	44	or	or	CC
29633	601	45	additions	addition	NNS
29633	601	46	required	require	VBN
29633	601	47	by	by	IN
29633	601	48	the	the	DT
29633	601	49	blown	blow	VBN
29633	601	50	metal	metal	NN
29633	601	51	to	to	TO
29633	601	52	convert	convert	VB
29633	601	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	601	54	into	into	IN
29633	601	55	steel	steel	NN
29633	601	56	.	.	.
29633	602	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	602	2	114	114	CD
29633	602	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	602	4	Swank	Swank	NNP
29633	602	5	,	,	,
29633	602	6	_	_	NNP
29633	602	7	op	op	NN
29633	602	8	.	.	.
29633	603	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	603	2	.	.	.
29633	603	3	_	_	NNP
29633	603	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	603	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	603	6	42	42	CD
29633	603	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	603	8	,	,	,
29633	603	9	p.	p.	NN
29633	603	10	409	409	CD
29633	603	11	.	.	.
29633	604	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	604	2	115	115	CD
29633	604	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	604	4	_	_	NNP
29633	604	5	Johnstown	Johnstown	NNP
29633	604	6	Daily	Daily	NNP
29633	604	7	Democrat	Democrat	NNP
29633	604	8	_	_	NNP
29633	604	9	,	,	,
29633	604	10	souvenir	souvenir	NN
29633	604	11	edition	edition	NN
29633	604	12	,	,	,
29633	604	13	autumn	autumn	NNP
29633	604	14	1894	1894	CD
29633	604	15	(	(	-LRB-
29633	604	16	italics	italic	NNS
29633	604	17	supplied	supply	VBN
29633	604	18	)	)	-RRB-
29633	604	19	.	.	.
29633	605	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
29633	605	2	Fry	Fry	NNP
29633	605	3	was	be	VBD
29633	605	4	at	at	IN
29633	605	5	the	the	DT
29633	605	6	Cambria	Cambria	NNP
29633	605	7	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	605	8	Works	Works	NNP
29633	605	9	from	from	IN
29633	605	10	1858	1858	CD
29633	605	11	until	until	IN
29633	605	12	after	after	IN
29633	605	13	1882	1882	CD
29633	605	14	.	.	.
29633	606	1	Fry	Fry	NNP
29633	606	2	later	later	RB
29633	606	3	asserted[116	asserted[116	RB
29633	606	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	606	5	that	that	IN
29633	606	6	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	606	7	's	's	POS
29633	606	8	experiments	experiment	NNS
29633	606	9	in	in	IN
29633	606	10	1862	1862	CD
29633	606	11	were	be	VBD
29633	606	12	simply	simply	RB
29633	606	13	attempts	attempt	NNS
29633	606	14	to	to	TO
29633	606	15	copy	copy	VB
29633	606	16	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	606	17	's	's	POS
29633	606	18	methods	method	NNS
29633	606	19	.	.	.
29633	607	1	(	(	-LRB-
29633	607	2	The	the	DT
29633	607	3	possibility	possibility	NN
29633	607	4	is	be	VBZ
29633	607	5	under	under	IN
29633	607	6	investigation	investigation	NN
29633	607	7	that	that	IN
29633	607	8	the	the	DT
29633	607	9	so	so	RB
29633	607	10	-	-	HYPH
29633	607	11	called	call	VBN
29633	607	12	"	"	``
29633	607	13	pioneer	pioneer	NN
29633	607	14	converter	converter	NN
29633	607	15	"	"	''
29633	607	16	now	now	RB
29633	607	17	on	on	IN
29633	607	18	loan	loan	NN
29633	607	19	to	to	IN
29633	607	20	the	the	DT
29633	607	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	607	22	National	National	NNP
29633	607	23	Museum	Museum	NNP
29633	607	24	from	from	IN
29633	607	25	the	the	DT
29633	607	26	Bethlehem	Bethlehem	NNP
29633	607	27	Steel	Steel	NNP
29633	607	28	Company	Company	NNP
29633	607	29	,	,	,
29633	607	30	is	be	VBZ
29633	607	31	the	the	DT
29633	607	32	converter	converter	NN
29633	607	33	referred	refer	VBN
29633	607	34	to	to	IN
29633	607	35	by	by	IN
29633	607	36	Fry	Fry	NNP
29633	607	37	.	.	.
29633	607	38	)	)	-RRB-
29633	608	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	608	2	116	116	CD
29633	608	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	608	4	_	_	NNP
29633	608	5	Engineering	Engineering	NNP
29633	608	6	_	_	NNP
29633	608	7	,	,	,
29633	608	8	1896	1896	CD
29633	608	9	,	,	,
29633	608	10	vol	vol	NNP
29633	608	11	.	.	.
29633	609	1	61	61	CD
29633	609	2	,	,	,
29633	609	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	609	4	615	615	CD
29633	609	5	.	.	.
29633	610	1	William	William	NNP
29633	610	2	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	610	3	,	,	,
29633	610	4	in	in	IN
29633	610	5	effect	effect	NN
29633	610	6	,	,	,
29633	610	7	disappeared	disappear	VBD
29633	610	8	from	from	IN
29633	610	9	the	the	DT
29633	610	10	record	record	NN
29633	610	11	until	until	IN
29633	610	12	1871	1871	CD
29633	610	13	when	when	WRB
29633	610	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	610	15	applied	apply	VBD
29633	610	16	for	for	IN
29633	610	17	an	an	DT
29633	610	18	extension	extension	NN
29633	610	19	of	of	IN
29633	610	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	610	21	patent	patent	NN
29633	610	22	of	of	IN
29633	610	23	June	June	NNP
29633	610	24	23	23	CD
29633	610	25	,	,	,
29633	610	26	1857	1857	CD
29633	610	27	.	.	.
29633	611	1	The	the	DT
29633	611	2	application	application	NN
29633	611	3	was	be	VBD
29633	611	4	opposed	oppose	VBN
29633	611	5	(	(	-LRB-
29633	611	6	by	by	IN
29633	611	7	whom	whom	WP
29633	611	8	,	,	,
29633	611	9	the	the	DT
29633	611	10	record	record	NN
29633	611	11	does	do	VBZ
29633	611	12	not	not	RB
29633	611	13	state	state	VB
29633	611	14	)	)	-RRB-
29633	611	15	on	on	IN
29633	611	16	the	the	DT
29633	611	17	grounds	ground	NNS
29633	611	18	that	that	IN
29633	611	19	the	the	DT
29633	611	20	invention	invention	NN
29633	611	21	was	be	VBD
29633	611	22	not	not	RB
29633	611	23	novel	novel	JJ
29633	611	24	when	when	WRB
29633	611	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	611	26	was	be	VBD
29633	611	27	originally	originally	RB
29633	611	28	issued	issue	VBN
29633	611	29	,	,	,
29633	611	30	and	and	CC
29633	611	31	that	that	IN
29633	611	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	611	33	would	would	MD
29633	611	34	be	be	VB
29633	611	35	against	against	IN
29633	611	36	the	the	DT
29633	611	37	public	public	JJ
29633	611	38	interest	interest	NN
29633	611	39	to	to	TO
29633	611	40	extend	extend	VB
29633	611	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	611	42	term	term	NN
29633	611	43	.	.	.
29633	612	1	The	the	DT
29633	612	2	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	612	3	ruled	rule	VBD
29633	612	4	that,[117	that,[117	RB
29633	612	5	]	]	-RRB-
29633	612	6	on	on	IN
29633	612	7	the	the	DT
29633	612	8	first	first	JJ
29633	612	9	question	question	NN
29633	612	10	,	,	,
29633	612	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	612	12	was	be	VBD
29633	612	13	settled	settle	VBN
29633	612	14	practice	practice	NN
29633	612	15	of	of	IN
29633	612	16	the	the	DT
29633	612	17	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	612	18	Office	Office	NNP
29633	612	19	not	not	RB
29633	612	20	to	to	TO
29633	612	21	reconsider	reconsider	VB
29633	612	22	former	former	JJ
29633	612	23	decisions	decision	NNS
29633	612	24	on	on	IN
29633	612	25	questions	question	NNS
29633	612	26	of	of	IN
29633	612	27	fact	fact	NN
29633	612	28	;	;	:
29633	612	29	the	the	DT
29633	612	30	novelty	novelty	NN
29633	612	31	of	of	IN
29633	612	32	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	612	33	's	's	POS
29633	612	34	invention	invention	NN
29633	612	35	had	have	VBD
29633	612	36	been	be	VBN
29633	612	37	re	re	VBN
29633	612	38	-	-	VBN
29633	612	39	examined	examine	VBN
29633	612	40	when	when	WRB
29633	612	41	the	the	DT
29633	612	42	patent	patent	NN
29633	612	43	was	be	VBD
29633	612	44	reissued	reissue	VBN
29633	612	45	in	in	IN
29633	612	46	November	November	NNP
29633	612	47	1857	1857	CD
29633	612	48	.	.	.
29633	613	1	Testimony	testimony	NN
29633	613	2	showed	show	VBD
29633	613	3	that	that	IN
29633	613	4	the	the	DT
29633	613	5	patent	patent	NN
29633	613	6	was	be	VBD
29633	613	7	very	very	RB
29633	613	8	valuable	valuable	JJ
29633	613	9	;	;	:
29633	613	10	and	and	CC
29633	613	11	that	that	IN
29633	613	12	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	613	13	"	"	``
29633	613	14	had	have	VBD
29633	613	15	been	be	VBN
29633	613	16	untiring	untire	VBG
29633	613	17	in	in	IN
29633	613	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	613	19	efforts	effort	NNS
29633	613	20	to	to	TO
29633	613	21	introduce	introduce	VB
29633	613	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	613	23	into	into	IN
29633	613	24	use	use	NN
29633	613	25	but	but	CC
29633	613	26	the	the	DT
29633	613	27	opposition	opposition	NN
29633	613	28	of	of	IN
29633	613	29	iron	iron	NN
29633	613	30	manufacturers	manufacturer	NNS
29633	613	31	and	and	CC
29633	613	32	the	the	DT
29633	613	33	amount	amount	NN
29633	613	34	of	of	IN
29633	613	35	capital	capital	NN
29633	613	36	required	require	VBN
29633	613	37	prevented	prevent	VBD
29633	613	38	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	613	39	from	from	IN
29633	613	40	receiving	receive	VBG
29633	613	41	anything	anything	NN
29633	613	42	from	from	IN
29633	613	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	613	44	patent	patent	NN
29633	613	45	until	until	IN
29633	613	46	within	within	IN
29633	613	47	very	very	RB
29633	613	48	few	few	JJ
29633	613	49	years	year	NNS
29633	613	50	past	past	JJ
29633	613	51	.	.	.
29633	613	52	"	"	''
29633	614	1	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	614	2	's	's	POS
29633	614	3	expenditures	expenditure	NNS
29633	614	4	were	be	VBD
29633	614	5	shown	show	VBN
29633	614	6	to	to	TO
29633	614	7	have	have	VB
29633	614	8	amounted	amount	VBN
29633	614	9	to	to	IN
29633	614	10	$	$	$
29633	614	11	11,500	11,500	CD
29633	614	12	,	,	,
29633	614	13	whereas	whereas	IN
29633	614	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	614	15	had	have	VBD
29633	614	16	received	receive	VBN
29633	614	17	only	only	RB
29633	614	18	$	$	$
29633	614	19	2,400	2,400	CD
29633	614	20	.	.	.
29633	615	1	Since	since	IN
29633	615	2	no	no	DT
29633	615	3	evidence	evidence	NN
29633	615	4	was	be	VBD
29633	615	5	filed	file	VBN
29633	615	6	in	in	IN
29633	615	7	support	support	NN
29633	615	8	of	of	IN
29633	615	9	the	the	DT
29633	615	10	public	public	JJ
29633	615	11	interest	interest	NN
29633	615	12	aspect	aspect	NN
29633	615	13	of	of	IN
29633	615	14	the	the	DT
29633	615	15	case	case	NN
29633	615	16	,	,	,
29633	615	17	the	the	DT
29633	615	18	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	615	19	found	find	VBD
29633	615	20	no	no	DT
29633	615	21	substantial	substantial	JJ
29633	615	22	reason	reason	NN
29633	615	23	for	for	IN
29633	615	24	denying	deny	VBG
29633	615	25	the	the	DT
29633	615	26	extension	extension	NN
29633	615	27	;	;	:
29633	615	28	indeed	indeed	RB
29633	615	29	"	"	``
29633	615	30	very	very	RB
29633	615	31	few	few	JJ
29633	615	32	patentees	patentee	NNS
29633	615	33	are	be	VBP
29633	615	34	able	able	JJ
29633	615	35	to	to	TO
29633	615	36	present	present	VB
29633	615	37	so	so	RB
29633	615	38	strong	strong	JJ
29633	615	39	grounds	ground	NNS
29633	615	40	for	for	IN
29633	615	41	extension	extension	NN
29633	615	42	as	as	IN
29633	615	43	the	the	DT
29633	615	44	applicant	applicant	NN
29633	615	45	in	in	IN
29633	615	46	the	the	DT
29633	615	47	case	case	NN
29633	615	48	.	.	.
29633	615	49	"	"	''
29633	616	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	616	2	117	117	CD
29633	616	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	616	4	See	see	VB
29633	616	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	616	6	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	616	7	Office	Office	NNP
29633	616	8	,	,	,
29633	616	9	Decision	Decision	NNP
29633	616	10	of	of	IN
29633	616	11	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	616	12	of	of	IN
29633	616	13	Patents	Patents	NNPS
29633	616	14	,	,	,
29633	616	15	dated	date	VBN
29633	616	16	June	June	NNP
29633	616	17	15	15	CD
29633	616	18	,	,	,
29633	616	19	1871	1871	CD
29633	616	20	.	.	.
29633	617	1	In	in	IN
29633	617	2	a	a	DT
29633	617	3	similar	similar	JJ
29633	617	4	application	application	NN
29633	617	5	in	in	IN
29633	617	6	the	the	DT
29633	617	7	previous	previous	JJ
29633	617	8	year	year	NN
29633	617	9	,	,	,
29633	617	10	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	617	11	had	have	VBD
29633	617	12	failed	fail	VBN
29633	617	13	to	to	TO
29633	617	14	win	win	VB
29633	617	15	an	an	DT
29633	617	16	extension	extension	NN
29633	617	17	of	of	IN
29633	617	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	617	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	617	20	patent	patent	NN
29633	617	21	16082	16082	CD
29633	617	22	,	,	,
29633	617	23	of	of	IN
29633	617	24	November	November	NNP
29633	617	25	11	11	CD
29633	617	26	,	,	,
29633	617	27	1856	1856	CD
29633	617	28	,	,	,
29633	617	29	for	for	IN
29633	617	30	the	the	DT
29633	617	31	sole	sole	JJ
29633	617	32	reason	reason	NN
29633	617	33	that	that	IN
29633	617	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	617	35	British	british	JJ
29633	617	36	patent	patent	NN
29633	617	37	with	with	IN
29633	617	38	which	which	WDT
29633	617	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	617	40	had	have	VBD
29633	617	41	been	be	VBN
29633	617	42	made	make	VBN
29633	617	43	co	co	JJ
29633	617	44	-	-	JJ
29633	617	45	terminal	terminal	JJ
29633	617	46	had	have	VBD
29633	617	47	duly	duly	RB
29633	617	48	expired	expire	VBN
29633	617	49	at	at	IN
29633	617	50	the	the	DT
29633	617	51	end	end	NN
29633	617	52	of	of	IN
29633	617	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	617	54	fourteen	fourteen	CD
29633	617	55	years	year	NNS
29633	617	56	of	of	IN
29633	617	57	life	life	NN
29633	617	58	,	,	,
29633	617	59	and	and	CC
29633	617	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	617	61	would	would	MD
29633	617	62	have	have	VB
29633	617	63	been	be	VBN
29633	617	64	inequitable	inequitable	JJ
29633	617	65	to	to	TO
29633	617	66	give	give	VB
29633	617	67	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	617	68	protection	protection	NN
29633	617	69	in	in	IN
29633	617	70	the	the	DT
29633	617	71	United	United	NNP
29633	617	72	States	States	NNP
29633	617	73	while	while	IN
29633	617	74	British	british	JJ
29633	617	75	iron	iron	NN
29633	617	76	-	-	HYPH
29633	617	77	masters	master	NNS
29633	617	78	were	be	VBD
29633	617	79	not	not	RB
29633	617	80	under	under	IN
29633	617	81	similar	similar	JJ
29633	617	82	restraint	restraint	NN
29633	617	83	.	.	.
29633	618	1	But	but	CC
29633	618	2	if	if	IN
29633	618	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	618	4	had	have	VBD
29633	618	5	not	not	RB
29633	618	6	been	be	VBN
29633	618	7	for	for	IN
29633	618	8	this	this	DT
29633	618	9	consideration	consideration	NN
29633	618	10	,	,	,
29633	618	11	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	618	12	"	"	``
29633	618	13	would	would	MD
29633	618	14	be	be	VB
29633	618	15	justly	justly	RB
29633	618	16	entitled	entitle	VBN
29633	618	17	to	to	IN
29633	618	18	what	what	WP
29633	618	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	618	20	asks	ask	VBZ
29633	618	21	on	on	IN
29633	618	22	this	this	DT
29633	618	23	occasion	occasion	NN
29633	618	24	.	.	.
29633	618	25	"	"	''
29633	619	1	The	the	DT
29633	619	2	Commissioner[118	commissioner[118	NN
29633	619	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	619	4	observed	observe	VBD
29633	619	5	:	:	:
29633	619	6	"	"	``
29633	619	7	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	619	8	may	may	MD
29633	619	9	be	be	VB
29633	619	10	questioned	question	VBN
29633	619	11	whether	whether	IN
29633	619	12	[	[	-LRB-
29633	619	13	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	619	14	]	]	-RRB-
29633	619	15	was	be	VBD
29633	619	16	first	first	JJ
29633	619	17	to	to	TO
29633	619	18	discover	discover	VB
29633	619	19	the	the	DT
29633	619	20	principle	principle	NN
29633	619	21	upon	upon	IN
29633	619	22	which	which	WDT
29633	619	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	619	24	process	process	NN
29633	619	25	was	be	VBD
29633	619	26	founded	found	VBN
29633	619	27	.	.	.
29633	620	1	But	but	CC
29633	620	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
29633	620	3	owe	owe	VBP
29633	620	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	620	5	reduction	reduction	NN
29633	620	6	to	to	TO
29633	620	7	practice	practice	VB
29633	620	8	to	to	IN
29633	620	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	620	10	untiring	untire	VBG
29633	620	11	industry	industry	NN
29633	620	12	and	and	CC
29633	620	13	perseverance	perseverance	NN
29633	620	14	,	,	,
29633	620	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	620	16	superior	superior	JJ
29633	620	17	skill	skill	NN
29633	620	18	and	and	CC
29633	620	19	science	science	NN
29633	620	20	and	and	CC
29633	620	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	620	22	great	great	JJ
29633	620	23	outlay	outlay	NN
29633	620	24	.	.	.
29633	620	25	"	"	''
29633	621	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	621	2	118	118	CD
29633	621	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	621	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
29633	621	5	Patent	Patent	NNP
29633	621	6	Office	Office	NNP
29633	621	7	,	,	,
29633	621	8	Decision	Decision	NNP
29633	621	9	of	of	IN
29633	621	10	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
29633	621	11	of	of	IN
29633	621	12	Patents	Patents	NNPS
29633	621	13	dated	date	VBD
29633	621	14	February	February	NNP
29633	621	15	12	12	CD
29633	621	16	,	,	,
29633	621	17	1870	1870	CD
29633	621	18	.	.	.
29633	622	1	Conclusions	Conclusions	NNPS
29633	622	2	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	622	3	was	be	VBD
29633	622	4	probably	probably	RB
29633	622	5	never	never	RB
29633	622	6	a	a	DT
29633	622	7	serious	serious	JJ
29633	622	8	contender	contender	NN
29633	622	9	for	for	IN
29633	622	10	the	the	DT
29633	622	11	honor	honor	NN
29633	622	12	of	of	IN
29633	622	13	discovering	discover	VBG
29633	622	14	the	the	DT
29633	622	15	atmospheric	atmospheric	JJ
29633	622	16	process	process	NN
29633	622	17	of	of	IN
29633	622	18	making	make	VBG
29633	622	19	steel	steel	NN
29633	622	20	.	.	.
29633	623	1	In	in	IN
29633	623	2	the	the	DT
29633	623	3	present	present	JJ
29633	623	4	state	state	NN
29633	623	5	of	of	IN
29633	623	6	the	the	DT
29633	623	7	record	record	NN
29633	623	8	,	,	,
29633	623	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	623	10	is	be	VBZ
29633	623	11	not	not	RB
29633	623	12	an	an	DT
29633	623	13	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
29633	623	14	assumption	assumption	NN
29633	623	15	that	that	IN
29633	623	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	623	17	patent	patent	NN
29633	623	18	was	be	VBD
29633	623	19	never	never	RB
29633	623	20	seriously	seriously	RB
29633	623	21	exploited	exploit	VBN
29633	623	22	and	and	CC
29633	623	23	that	that	IN
29633	623	24	the	the	DT
29633	623	25	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	623	26	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	623	27	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	623	28	Works	Works	NNP
29633	623	29	hoped	hope	VBD
29633	623	30	to	to	TO
29633	623	31	use	use	VB
29633	623	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	623	33	,	,	,
29633	623	34	in	in	IN
29633	623	35	conjunction	conjunction	NN
29633	623	36	with	with	IN
29633	623	37	the	the	DT
29633	623	38	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	623	39	patents	patent	NNS
29633	623	40	,	,	,
29633	623	41	to	to	TO
29633	623	42	upset	upset	VB
29633	623	43	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	623	44	's	's	POS
29633	623	45	patents	patent	NNS
29633	623	46	.	.	.
29633	624	1	The	the	DT
29633	624	2	position	position	NN
29633	624	3	of	of	IN
29633	624	4	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	624	5	is	be	VBZ
29633	624	6	not	not	RB
29633	624	7	so	so	RB
29633	624	8	clear	clear	JJ
29633	624	9	,	,	,
29633	624	10	and	and	CC
29633	624	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	624	12	is	be	VBZ
29633	624	13	hoped	hope	VBN
29633	624	14	that	that	IN
29633	624	15	further	further	JJ
29633	624	16	research	research	NN
29633	624	17	can	can	MD
29633	624	18	eventually	eventually	RB
29633	624	19	throw	throw	VB
29633	624	20	a	a	DT
29633	624	21	clearer	clear	JJR
29633	624	22	light	light	NN
29633	624	23	on	on	IN
29633	624	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	624	25	relationship	relationship	NN
29633	624	26	with	with	IN
29633	624	27	the	the	DT
29633	624	28	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	624	29	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	624	30	Iron	Iron	NNP
29633	624	31	Works	Works	NNP
29633	624	32	.	.	.
29633	625	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	625	2	may	may	MD
29633	625	3	well	well	RB
29633	625	4	be	be	VB
29633	625	5	that	that	IN
29633	625	6	the	the	DT
29633	625	7	"	"	``
29633	625	8	opinion	opinion	NN
29633	625	9	of	of	IN
29633	625	10	metallurgists	metallurgist	NNS
29633	625	11	in	in	IN
29633	625	12	later	later	JJ
29633	625	13	years"[119	years"[119	NNP
29633	625	14	]	]	-RRB-
29633	625	15	is	be	VBZ
29633	625	16	sound	sound	JJ
29633	625	17	,	,	,
29633	625	18	and	and	CC
29633	625	19	that	that	IN
29633	625	20	both	both	DT
29633	625	21	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	625	22	and	and	CC
29633	625	23	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	625	24	had	have	VBD
29633	625	25	successfully	successfully	RB
29633	625	26	worked	work	VBN
29633	625	27	at	at	IN
29633	625	28	the	the	DT
29633	625	29	same	same	JJ
29633	625	30	problem	problem	NN
29633	625	31	.	.	.
29633	626	1	The	the	DT
29633	626	2	study	study	NN
29633	626	3	of	of	IN
29633	626	4	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	626	5	's	's	POS
29633	626	6	letters	letter	NNS
29633	626	7	to	to	IN
29633	626	8	the	the	DT
29633	626	9	technical	technical	JJ
29633	626	10	press	press	NN
29633	626	11	and	and	CC
29633	626	12	of	of	IN
29633	626	13	the	the	DT
29633	626	14	attitude	attitude	NN
29633	626	15	of	of	IN
29633	626	16	the	the	DT
29633	626	17	editors	editor	NNS
29633	626	18	of	of	IN
29633	626	19	those	those	DT
29633	626	20	papers	paper	NNS
29633	626	21	to	to	IN
29633	626	22	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	626	23	suggests	suggest	VBZ
29633	626	24	the	the	DT
29633	626	25	possibility	possibility	NN
29633	626	26	that	that	IN
29633	626	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	626	28	,	,	,
29633	626	29	too	too	RB
29633	626	30	,	,	,
29633	626	31	was	be	VBD
29633	626	32	used	use	VBN
29633	626	33	by	by	IN
29633	626	34	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	626	35	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	626	36	for	for	IN
29633	626	37	the	the	DT
29633	626	38	purposes	purpose	NNS
29633	626	39	of	of	IN
29633	626	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	626	41	attacks	attack	NNS
29633	626	42	on	on	IN
29633	626	43	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	626	44	.	.	.
29633	627	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	627	2	admits	admit	VBZ
29633	627	3	that	that	IN
29633	627	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	627	5	was	be	VBD
29633	627	6	not	not	RB
29633	627	7	a	a	DT
29633	627	8	free	free	JJ
29633	627	9	agent	agent	NN
29633	627	10	in	in	IN
29633	627	11	respect	respect	NN
29633	627	12	of	of	IN
29633	627	13	these	these	DT
29633	627	14	patents	patent	NNS
29633	627	15	,	,	,
29633	627	16	and	and	CC
29633	627	17	the	the	DT
29633	627	18	failure	failure	NN
29633	627	19	of	of	IN
29633	627	20	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	627	21	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	627	22	to	to	TO
29633	627	23	ensure	ensure	VB
29633	627	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	627	25	full	full	JJ
29633	627	26	life	life	NN
29633	627	27	under	under	IN
29633	627	28	English	english	JJ
29633	627	29	patent	patent	NN
29633	627	30	law	law	NN
29633	627	31	indicates	indicate	VBZ
29633	627	32	clearly	clearly	RB
29633	627	33	enough	enough	RB
29633	627	34	that	that	IN
29633	627	35	by	by	IN
29633	627	36	1859	1859	CD
29633	627	37	the	the	DT
29633	627	38	firm	firm	NN
29633	627	39	had	have	VBD
29633	627	40	realized	realize	VBN
29633	627	41	that	that	IN
29633	627	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	627	43	position	position	NN
29633	627	44	was	be	VBD
29633	627	45	not	not	RB
29633	627	46	strong	strong	JJ
29633	627	47	enough	enough	RB
29633	627	48	to	to	TO
29633	627	49	warrant	warrant	VB
29633	627	50	a	a	DT
29633	627	51	legal	legal	JJ
29633	627	52	suit	suit	NN
29633	627	53	for	for	IN
29633	627	54	infringement	infringement	NN
29633	627	55	against	against	IN
29633	627	56	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	627	57	.	.	.
29633	628	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	628	2	purchase	purchase	NN
29633	628	3	of	of	IN
29633	628	4	the	the	DT
29633	628	5	Uchatius	Uchatius	NNP
29633	628	6	process	process	NN
29633	628	7	and	and	CC
29633	628	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	628	9	final	final	JJ
29633	628	10	attempt	attempt	NN
29633	628	11	to	to	TO
29633	628	12	develop	develop	VB
29633	628	13	Martien	Martien	NNP
29633	628	14	's	's	POS
29633	628	15	ideas	idea	NNS
29633	628	16	through	through	IN
29633	628	17	the	the	DT
29633	628	18	Parry	Parry	NNP
29633	628	19	patents	patent	NNS
29633	628	20	,	,	,
29633	628	21	which	which	WDT
29633	628	22	exposed	expose	VBD
29633	628	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
29633	628	24	to	to	IN
29633	628	25	a	a	DT
29633	628	26	very	very	RB
29633	628	27	real	real	JJ
29633	628	28	risk	risk	NN
29633	628	29	of	of	IN
29633	628	30	a	a	DT
29633	628	31	suit	suit	NN
29633	628	32	by	by	IN
29633	628	33	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	628	34	,	,	,
29633	628	35	are	be	VBP
29633	628	36	also	also	RB
29633	628	37	indications	indication	NNS
29633	628	38	of	of	IN
29633	628	39	the	the	DT
29633	628	40	politics	politic	NNS
29633	628	41	in	in	IN
29633	628	42	the	the	DT
29633	628	43	case	case	NN
29633	628	44	.	.	.
29633	629	1	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	629	2	seems	seem	VBZ
29633	629	3	to	to	TO
29633	629	4	have	have	VB
29633	629	5	been	be	VBN
29633	629	6	a	a	DT
29633	629	7	willing	willing	JJ
29633	629	8	enough	enough	JJ
29633	629	9	victim	victim	NN
29633	629	10	of	of	IN
29633	629	11	Ebbw	Ebbw	NNP
29633	629	12	Vale	Vale	NNP
29633	629	13	's	's	POS
29633	629	14	scheming	scheming	NN
29633	629	15	.	.	.
29633	630	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	630	2	letters	letter	NNS
29633	630	3	show	show	VBP
29633	630	4	an	an	DT
29633	630	5	almost	almost	RB
29633	630	6	presumptuous	presumptuous	JJ
29633	630	7	assumption	assumption	NN
29633	630	8	of	of	IN
29633	630	9	the	the	DT
29633	630	10	mantle	mantle	NN
29633	630	11	of	of	IN
29633	630	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	630	13	father	father	NN
29633	630	14	;	;	:
29633	630	15	while	while	IN
29633	630	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	630	17	sometimes	sometimes	RB
29633	630	18	absurd	absurd	JJ
29633	630	19	claims	claim	NNS
29633	630	20	to	to	IN
29633	630	21	priority	priority	NN
29633	630	22	of	of	IN
29633	630	23	invention	invention	NN
29633	630	24	(	(	-LRB-
29633	630	25	and	and	CC
29633	630	26	demonstration	demonstration	NN
29633	630	27	)	)	-RRB-
29633	630	28	of	of	IN
29633	630	29	practically	practically	RB
29633	630	30	every	every	DT
29633	630	31	new	new	JJ
29633	630	32	idea	idea	NN
29633	630	33	in	in	IN
29633	630	34	the	the	DT
29633	630	35	manufacturing	manufacturing	NN
29633	630	36	of	of	IN
29633	630	37	iron	iron	NN
29633	630	38	and	and	CC
29633	630	39	steel	steel	NN
29633	630	40	progressively	progressively	RB
29633	630	41	reduced	reduce	VBD
29633	630	42	the	the	DT
29633	630	43	respect	respect	NN
29633	630	44	for	for	IN
29633	630	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	630	46	name	name	NN
29633	630	47	.	.	.
29633	631	1	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	631	2	claims	claim	VBZ
29633	631	3	an	an	DT
29633	631	4	impressive	impressive	JJ
29633	631	5	array	array	NN
29633	631	6	of	of	IN
29633	631	7	precedents	precedent	NNS
29633	631	8	for	for	IN
29633	631	9	the	the	DT
29633	631	10	use	use	NN
29633	631	11	of	of	IN
29633	631	12	manganese	manganese	NNP
29633	631	13	in	in	IN
29633	631	14	steel	steel	NN
29633	631	15	making	making	NN
29633	631	16	and	and	CC
29633	631	17	,	,	,
29633	631	18	given	give	VBN
29633	631	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	631	20	attitude	attitude	NN
29633	631	21	to	to	IN
29633	631	22	patents	patent	NNS
29633	631	23	and	and	CC
29633	631	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	631	25	reliance	reliance	NN
29633	631	26	on	on	IN
29633	631	27	professional	professional	JJ
29633	631	28	advice	advice	NN
29633	631	29	in	in	IN
29633	631	30	this	this	DT
29633	631	31	respect	respect	NN
29633	631	32	,	,	,
29633	631	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	631	34	should	should	MD
29633	631	35	perhaps	perhaps	RB
29633	631	36	,	,	,
29633	631	37	be	be	VB
29633	631	38	given	give	VBN
29633	631	39	the	the	DT
29633	631	40	benefit	benefit	NN
29633	631	41	of	of	IN
29633	631	42	the	the	DT
29633	631	43	doubt	doubt	NN
29633	631	44	.	.	.
29633	632	1	A	a	DT
29633	632	2	dispassionate	dispassionate	NN
29633	632	3	judgment	judgment	NN
29633	632	4	would	would	MD
29633	632	5	be	be	VB
29633	632	6	that	that	IN
29633	632	7	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	632	8	owed	owe	VBD
29633	632	9	more	more	JJR
29633	632	10	to	to	IN
29633	632	11	the	the	DT
29633	632	12	development	development	NN
29633	632	13	work	work	NN
29633	632	14	of	of	IN
29633	632	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	632	16	Swedish	swedish	JJ
29633	632	17	licensees	licensee	NNS
29633	632	18	than	than	IN
29633	632	19	to	to	IN
29633	632	20	Mushet	Mushet	NNP
29633	632	21	.	.	.
29633	633	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	633	2	119	119	CD
29633	633	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	633	4	William	William	NNP
29633	633	5	T.	T.	NNP
29633	633	6	Jeans	Jeans	NNPS
29633	633	7	,	,	,
29633	633	8	_	_	NNP
29633	633	9	The	the	DT
29633	633	10	creators	creator	NNS
29633	633	11	of	of	IN
29633	633	12	the	the	DT
29633	633	13	age	age	NN
29633	633	14	of	of	IN
29633	633	15	steel	steel	NN
29633	633	16	_	_	NNP
29633	633	17	,	,	,
29633	633	18	London	London	NNP
29633	633	19	,	,	,
29633	633	20	1884	1884	CD
29633	633	21	.	.	.
29633	634	1	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	634	2	's	be	VBZ
29633	634	3	right	right	NN
29633	634	4	to	to	TO
29633	634	5	be	be	VB
29633	634	6	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
29633	634	7	the	the	DT
29633	634	8	joint	joint	JJ
29633	634	9	inventor	inventor	NN
29633	634	10	of	of	IN
29633	634	11	what	what	WP
29633	634	12	is	be	VBZ
29633	634	13	now	now	RB
29633	634	14	often	often	RB
29633	634	15	called	call	VBN
29633	634	16	the	the	DT
29633	634	17	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	634	18	-	-	HYPH
29633	634	19	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	634	20	process	process	NN
29633	634	21	is	be	VBZ
29633	634	22	questionable	questionable	JJ
29633	634	23	.	.	.
29633	635	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	635	2	120	120	CD
29633	635	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	635	4	Admittedly	admittedly	RB
29633	635	5	,	,	,
29633	635	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	635	7	experimented	experiment	VBD
29633	635	8	in	in	IN
29633	635	9	the	the	DT
29633	635	10	treatment	treatment	NN
29633	635	11	of	of	IN
29633	635	12	molten	molten	JJ
29633	635	13	metal	metal	NN
29633	635	14	with	with	IN
29633	635	15	air	air	NN
29633	635	16	blasts	blast	NNS
29633	635	17	,	,	,
29633	635	18	but	but	CC
29633	635	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	635	20	is	be	VBZ
29633	635	21	by	by	IN
29633	635	22	no	no	DT
29633	635	23	means	means	NN
29633	635	24	clear	clear	JJ
29633	635	25	,	,	,
29633	635	26	on	on	IN
29633	635	27	the	the	DT
29633	635	28	evidence	evidence	NN
29633	635	29	,	,	,
29633	635	30	that	that	IN
29633	635	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	635	32	got	get	VBD
29633	635	33	beyond	beyond	IN
29633	635	34	the	the	DT
29633	635	35	experimental	experimental	JJ
29633	635	36	stage	stage	NN
29633	635	37	.	.	.
29633	636	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
29633	636	2	is	be	VBZ
29633	636	3	certain	certain	JJ
29633	636	4	that	that	IN
29633	636	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	636	6	never	never	RB
29633	636	7	had	have	VBD
29633	636	8	the	the	DT
29633	636	9	objective	objective	NN
29633	636	10	of	of	IN
29633	636	11	making	make	VBG
29633	636	12	steel	steel	NN
29633	636	13	,	,	,
29633	636	14	which	which	WDT
29633	636	15	was	be	VBD
29633	636	16	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	636	17	's	's	POS
29633	636	18	primary	primary	JJ
29633	636	19	aim	aim	NN
29633	636	20	.	.	.
29633	637	1	Nor	nor	CC
29633	637	2	is	be	VBZ
29633	637	3	there	there	EX
29633	637	4	evidence	evidence	NN
29633	637	5	that	that	IN
29633	637	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	637	7	process	process	NN
29633	637	8	was	be	VBD
29633	637	9	taken	take	VBN
29633	637	10	beyond	beyond	IN
29633	637	11	the	the	DT
29633	637	12	experimental	experimental	JJ
29633	637	13	stage	stage	NN
29633	637	14	by	by	IN
29633	637	15	the	the	DT
29633	637	16	Cambria	Cambria	NNP
29633	637	17	Works	Works	NNP
29633	637	18	.	.	.
29633	638	1	The	the	DT
29633	638	2	rejection	rejection	NN
29633	638	3	of	of	IN
29633	638	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	638	5	"	"	``
29633	638	6	apparatus	apparatus	NN
29633	638	7	"	"	''
29633	638	8	by	by	IN
29633	638	9	W.	W.	NNP
29633	638	10	F.	F.	NNP
29633	638	11	Durfee	Durfee	NNP
29633	638	12	must	must	MD
29633	638	13	have	have	VB
29633	638	14	been	be	VBN
29633	638	15	based	base	VBN
29633	638	16	,	,	,
29633	638	17	to	to	IN
29633	638	18	some	some	DT
29633	638	19	extent	extent	NN
29633	638	20	at	at	IN
29633	638	21	least	least	JJS
29633	638	22	,	,	,
29633	638	23	upon	upon	IN
29633	638	24	the	the	DT
29633	638	25	Johnstown	Johnstown	NNP
29633	638	26	trials	trial	NNS
29633	638	27	.	.	.
29633	639	1	There	there	EX
29633	639	2	are	be	VBP
29633	639	3	strong	strong	JJ
29633	639	4	grounds	ground	NNS
29633	639	5	then	then	RB
29633	639	6	,	,	,
29633	639	7	for	for	IN
29633	639	8	agreeing	agree	VBG
29633	639	9	with	with	IN
29633	639	10	one	one	CD
29633	639	11	historian[121	historian[121	NNP
29633	639	12	]	]	-RRB-
29633	639	13	who	who	WP
29633	639	14	concludes	conclude	VBZ
29633	639	15	:	:	:
29633	639	16	The	the	DT
29633	639	17	fact	fact	NN
29633	639	18	that	that	IN
29633	639	19	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	639	20	was	be	VBD
29633	639	21	an	an	DT
29633	639	22	American	American	NNP
29633	639	23	is	be	VBZ
29633	639	24	evidently	evidently	RB
29633	639	25	the	the	DT
29633	639	26	principal	principal	JJ
29633	639	27	reason	reason	NN
29633	639	28	why	why	WRB
29633	639	29	certain	certain	JJ
29633	639	30	popular	popular	JJ
29633	639	31	writers	writer	NNS
29633	639	32	have	have	VBP
29633	639	33	made	make	VBN
29633	639	34	much	much	JJ
29633	639	35	of	of	IN
29633	639	36	an	an	DT
29633	639	37	invention	invention	NN
29633	639	38	that	that	WDT
29633	639	39	,	,	,
29633	639	40	had	have	VBD
29633	639	41	not	not	RB
29633	639	42	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	639	43	developed	develop	VBD
29633	639	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	639	45	process	process	NN
29633	639	46	,	,	,
29633	639	47	would	would	MD
29633	639	48	never	never	RB
29633	639	49	have	have	VB
29633	639	50	attracted	attract	VBN
29633	639	51	notice	notice	NN
29633	639	52	.	.	.
29633	640	1	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	640	2	's	's	POS
29633	640	3	patent	patent	NN
29633	640	4	proved	prove	VBD
29633	640	5	very	very	RB
29633	640	6	useful	useful	JJ
29633	640	7	to	to	IN
29633	640	8	industrial	industrial	JJ
29633	640	9	interests	interest	NNS
29633	640	10	in	in	IN
29633	640	11	this	this	DT
29633	640	12	country	country	NN
29633	640	13	as	as	IN
29633	640	14	a	a	DT
29633	640	15	bargaining	bargaining	NN
29633	640	16	weapon	weapon	NN
29633	640	17	in	in	IN
29633	640	18	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
29633	640	19	with	with	IN
29633	640	20	the	the	DT
29633	640	21	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	640	22	group	group	NN
29633	640	23	for	for	IN
29633	640	24	the	the	DT
29633	640	25	exchange	exchange	NN
29633	640	26	of	of	IN
29633	640	27	patent	patent	NN
29633	640	28	rights	right	NNS
29633	640	29	.	.	.
29633	641	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	641	2	120	120	CD
29633	641	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	641	4	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	641	5	dealt	deal	VBD
29633	641	6	with	with	IN
29633	641	7	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	641	8	's	's	POS
29633	641	9	claim	claim	NN
29633	641	10	to	to	IN
29633	641	11	priority	priority	NN
29633	641	12	in	in	IN
29633	641	13	a	a	DT
29633	641	14	letter	letter	NN
29633	641	15	to	to	IN
29633	641	16	_	_	NNP
29633	641	17	Engineering	Engineering	NNP
29633	641	18	_	_	NNP
29633	641	19	,	,	,
29633	641	20	1896	1896	CD
29633	641	21	,	,	,
29633	641	22	vol	vol	NNP
29633	641	23	.	.	.
29633	642	1	61	61	CD
29633	642	2	,	,	,
29633	642	3	p.	p.	NN
29633	642	4	367	367	CD
29633	642	5	.	.	.
29633	643	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	643	2	121	121	CD
29633	643	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	643	4	Louis	Louis	NNP
29633	643	5	C.	C.	NNP
29633	643	6	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
29633	643	7	,	,	,
29633	643	8	"	"	``
29633	643	9	The	the	DT
29633	643	10	heavy	heavy	JJ
29633	643	11	industries	industry	NNS
29633	643	12	since	since	IN
29633	643	13	1860	1860	CD
29633	643	14	,	,	,
29633	643	15	"	"	``
29633	643	16	in	in	IN
29633	643	17	H.	H.	NNP
29633	643	18	F.	F.	NNP
29633	643	19	Williamson	Williamson	NNP
29633	643	20	(	(	-LRB-
29633	643	21	editor	editor	NN
29633	643	22	)	)	-RRB-
29633	643	23	,	,	,
29633	643	24	_	_	NNP
29633	643	25	The	the	DT
29633	643	26	growth	growth	NN
29633	643	27	of	of	IN
29633	643	28	the	the	DT
29633	643	29	American	american	JJ
29633	643	30	economy	economy	NN
29633	643	31	_	_	NNP
29633	643	32	,	,	,
29633	643	33	New	New	NNP
29633	643	34	York	York	NNP
29633	643	35	,	,	,
29633	643	36	1944	1944	CD
29633	643	37	,	,	,
29633	643	38	p.	p.	NN
29633	643	39	469	469	CD
29633	643	40	.	.	.
29633	644	1	Kelly	Kelly	NNP
29633	644	2	's	's	POS
29633	644	3	suggestion[122	suggestion[122	NN
29633	644	4	]	]	-RRB-
29633	644	5	that	that	IN
29633	644	6	some	some	DT
29633	644	7	British	british	JJ
29633	644	8	puddlers	puddler	NNS
29633	644	9	may	may	MD
29633	644	10	have	have	VB
29633	644	11	communicated	communicate	VBN
29633	644	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	644	13	secret	secret	NN
29633	644	14	to	to	IN
29633	644	15	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	644	16	can	can	MD
29633	644	17	,	,	,
29633	644	18	probably	probably	RB
29633	644	19	,	,	,
29633	644	20	never	never	RB
29633	644	21	be	be	VB
29633	644	22	verified	verify	VBN
29633	644	23	.	.	.
29633	645	1	All	all	DT
29633	645	2	that	that	WDT
29633	645	3	can	can	MD
29633	645	4	be	be	VB
29633	645	5	said	say	VBN
29633	645	6	is	be	VBZ
29633	645	7	that	that	IN
29633	645	8	Bessemer	Bessemer	NNP
29633	645	9	was	be	VBD
29633	645	10	not	not	RB
29633	645	11	an	an	DT
29633	645	12	ironman	ironman	NN
29633	645	13	;	;	:
29633	645	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
29633	645	15	contacts	contact	NNS
29633	645	16	with	with	IN
29633	645	17	the	the	DT
29633	645	18	iron	iron	NN
29633	645	19	trade	trade	NN
29633	645	20	were	be	VBD
29633	645	21	,	,	,
29633	645	22	so	so	RB
29633	645	23	far	far	RB
29633	645	24	as	as	IN
29633	645	25	can	can	MD
29633	645	26	be	be	VB
29633	645	27	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
29633	645	28	,	,	,
29633	645	29	nonexistent	nonexistent	JJ
29633	645	30	until	until	IN
29633	645	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	645	32	himself	-PRON-	PRP
29633	645	33	invaded	invade	VBD
29633	645	34	Sheffield	Sheffield	NNP
29633	645	35	.	.	.
29633	646	1	So	so	CC
29633	646	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
29633	646	3	is	be	VBZ
29633	646	4	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
29633	646	5	that	that	IN
29633	646	6	such	such	PDT
29633	646	7	a	a	DT
29633	646	8	secret	secret	NN
29633	646	9	would	would	MD
29633	646	10	have	have	VB
29633	646	11	been	be	VBN
29633	646	12	taken	take	VBN
29633	646	13	to	to	IN
29633	646	14	him	-PRON-	PRP
29633	646	15	,	,	,
29633	646	16	even	even	RB
29633	646	17	if	if	IN
29633	646	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
29633	646	19	were	be	VBD
29633	646	20	a	a	DT
29633	646	21	well	well	RB
29633	646	22	-	-	HYPH
29633	646	23	known	know	VBN
29633	646	24	inventor	inventor	NN
29633	646	25	.	.	.
29633	647	1	[	[	-LRB-
29633	647	2	122	122	CD
29633	647	3	]	]	-RRB-
29633	647	4	Later	later	RB
29633	647	5	developed	develop	VBD
29633	647	6	into	into	IN
29633	647	7	a	a	DT
29633	647	8	dramatic	dramatic	JJ
29633	647	9	story	story	NN
29633	647	10	by	by	IN
29633	647	11	Boucher	Boucher	NNP
29633	647	12	,	,	,
29633	647	13	_	_	NNP
29633	647	14	op	op	NN
29633	647	15	.	.	.
29633	648	1	cit	cit	NNP
29633	648	2	.	.	.
29633	648	3	_	_	NNP
29633	648	4	(	(	-LRB-
29633	648	5	footnote	footnote	NNP
29633	648	6	97	97	CD
29633	648	7	)	)	-RRB-
29633	648	8	.	.	.