id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
5180	1	1	IN	in	IN
5180	1	2	THE	the	DT
5180	1	3	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
5180	1	4	STATES	STATES	NNP
5180	1	5	DISTRICT	district	NN
5180	1	6	COURT	court	NN
5180	1	7	FOR	for	IN
5180	1	8	THE	the	DT
5180	1	9	EASTERN	EASTERN	NNP
5180	1	10	DISTRICT	DISTRICT	NNP
5180	1	11	OF	of	IN
5180	1	12	PENNSYLVANIA	PENNSYLVANIA	NNP
5180	1	13	AMERICAN	AMERICAN	NNP
5180	1	14	LIBRARY	LIBRARY	NNP
5180	1	15	ASSOCIATION	ASSOCIATION	NNP
5180	1	16	,	,	,
5180	1	17	:	:	:
5180	1	18	CIVIL	CIVIL	NNP
5180	1	19	ACTION	ACTION	NNP
5180	1	20	INC	INC	NNP
5180	1	21	.	.	NNP
5180	1	22	,	,	,
5180	1	23	et	et	NNP
5180	1	24	al	al	NNP
5180	1	25	.	.	.
5180	2	1	:	:	:
5180	2	2	:	:	:
5180	2	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	2	4	:	:	:
5180	2	5	:	:	:
5180	2	6	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
5180	2	7	STATES	STATES	NNP
5180	2	8	,	,	,
5180	2	9	et	et	NNP
5180	2	10	al	al	NNP
5180	2	11	.	.	.
5180	3	1	:	:	:
5180	3	2	NO	no	UH
5180	3	3	.	.	.
5180	4	1	01	01	CD
5180	4	2	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	3	1303	1303	CD
5180	4	4	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	5	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	6	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	7	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	8	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	9	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	10	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	11	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	12	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	13	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	14	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	15	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	17	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	19	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	20	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	21	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	22	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	23	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	24	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	25	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	26	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	27	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	28	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	29	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	30	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	31	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	32	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	33	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	34	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	35	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	36	-	-	HYPH
5180	4	37	MULTNOMAH	multnomah	JJ
5180	4	38	COUNTY	COUNTY	NNP
5180	4	39	PUBLIC	PUBLIC	NNS
5180	4	40	:	:	:
5180	4	41	CIVIL	civil	NN
5180	4	42	ACTION	action	NN
5180	4	43	LIBRARY	LIBRARY	NNP
5180	4	44	,	,	,
5180	4	45	et	et	NNP
5180	4	46	al	al	NNP
5180	4	47	.	.	.
5180	5	1	:	:	:
5180	5	2	:	:	:
5180	5	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	5	4	:	:	:
5180	5	5	:	:	:
5180	5	6	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
5180	5	7	STATES	state	NNS
5180	5	8	OF	of	IN
5180	5	9	AMERICA	AMERICA	NNP
5180	5	10	,	,	,
5180	5	11	et	et	NNP
5180	5	12	al	al	NNP
5180	5	13	.	.	.
5180	6	1	:	:	:
5180	6	2	NO	no	UH
5180	6	3	.	.	.
5180	7	1	01	01	CD
5180	7	2	-	-	SYM
5180	7	3	1322	1322	CD
5180	7	4	Before	before	IN
5180	7	5	:	:	:
5180	7	6	BECKER	BECKER	NNP
5180	7	7	,	,	,
5180	7	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
5180	7	9	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
5180	7	10	Judge	Judge	NNP
5180	7	11	,	,	,
5180	7	12	FULLAM	FULLAM	NNP
5180	7	13	and	and	CC
5180	7	14	BARTLE	BARTLE	NNP
5180	7	15	,	,	,
5180	7	16	District	District	NNP
5180	7	17	Judges	Judges	NNPS
5180	7	18	.	.	.
5180	8	1	OPINION	opinion	NN
5180	8	2	OF	of	IN
5180	8	3	THE	the	DT
5180	8	4	COURT	COURT	NNP
5180	8	5	May	May	NNP
5180	8	6	31	31	CD
5180	8	7	,	,	,
5180	8	8	2002	2002	CD
5180	8	9	Becker	Becker	NNP
5180	8	10	,	,	,
5180	8	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
5180	8	12	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
5180	8	13	Judge	Judge	NNP
5180	8	14	CONTENTS	CONTENTS	NNP
5180	8	15	I.	i.	NN
5180	9	1	Preliminary	Preliminary	NNP
5180	9	2	Statement	Statement	NNP
5180	9	3	II	II	NNP
5180	9	4	.	.	.
5180	10	1	Findings	finding	NNS
5180	10	2	of	of	IN
5180	10	3	Fact	Fact	NNP
5180	10	4	A.	a.	NN
5180	10	5	Statutory	Statutory	NNP
5180	10	6	Framework	Framework	NNP
5180	10	7	1	1	CD
5180	10	8	.	.	.
5180	11	1	Nature	nature	NN
5180	11	2	and	and	CC
5180	11	3	Operation	operation	NN
5180	11	4	of	of	IN
5180	11	5	the	the	DT
5180	11	6	E	e	NN
5180	11	7	-	-	NN
5180	11	8	rate	rate	NN
5180	11	9	and	and	CC
5180	11	10	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	11	11	Programs	Programs	NNPS
5180	11	12	2	2	CD
5180	11	13	.	.	.
5180	12	1	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	12	2	a.	a.	NN
5180	12	3	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	12	4	's	's	POS
5180	12	5	Amendments	amendment	NNS
5180	12	6	to	to	IN
5180	12	7	the	the	DT
5180	12	8	E	e	NN
5180	12	9	-	-	NN
5180	12	10	rate	rate	NN
5180	12	11	Program	Program	NNP
5180	12	12	b.	b.	NN
5180	12	13	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	12	14	's	's	POS
5180	12	15	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
5180	12	16	to	to	IN
5180	12	17	the	the	DT
5180	12	18	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	12	19	Program	Program	NNP
5180	12	20	B.	B.	NNP
5180	13	1	Identity	identity	NN
5180	13	2	of	of	IN
5180	13	3	the	the	DT
5180	13	4	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNPS
5180	13	5	1	1	CD
5180	13	6	.	.	.
5180	14	1	Library	Library	NNP
5180	14	2	and	and	CC
5180	14	3	Library	Library	NNP
5180	14	4	Association	Association	NNP
5180	14	5	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNPS
5180	14	6	2	2	CD
5180	14	7	.	.	.
5180	15	1	Patron	Patron	NNP
5180	15	2	and	and	CC
5180	15	3	Patron	Patron	NNP
5180	15	4	Association	Association	NNP
5180	15	5	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNPS
5180	15	6	3	3	CD
5180	15	7	.	.	.
5180	16	1	Web	web	NN
5180	16	2	Publisher	Publisher	NNP
5180	16	3	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNPS
5180	16	4	C.	C.	NNP
5180	16	5	The	the	DT
5180	16	6	Internet	internet	NN
5180	16	7	1	1	CD
5180	16	8	.	.	.
5180	17	1	Background	Background	NNP
5180	17	2	2	2	CD
5180	17	3	.	.	.
5180	18	1	The	the	DT
5180	18	2	Indexable	Indexable	NNP
5180	18	3	Web	Web	NNP
5180	18	4	,	,	,
5180	18	5	the	the	DT
5180	18	6	"	"	``
5180	18	7	Deep	deep	JJ
5180	18	8	Web	web	NN
5180	18	9	"	"	''
5180	18	10	;	;	:
5180	18	11	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	18	12	Size	size	NN
5180	18	13	and	and	CC
5180	18	14	Rates	Rates	NNPS
5180	18	15	of	of	IN
5180	18	16	Growth	Growth	NNP
5180	18	17	and	and	CC
5180	18	18	Change	Change	NNP
5180	18	19	3	3	CD
5180	18	20	.	.	.
5180	19	1	The	the	DT
5180	19	2	Amount	Amount	NNP
5180	19	3	of	of	IN
5180	19	4	Sexually	Sexually	NNP
5180	19	5	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	19	6	Material	Material	NNP
5180	19	7	on	on	IN
5180	19	8	the	the	DT
5180	19	9	Web	Web	NNP
5180	19	10	D.	D.	NNP
5180	19	11	American	American	NNP
5180	19	12	Public	Public	NNP
5180	19	13	Libraries	Libraries	NNP
5180	19	14	1	1	CD
5180	19	15	.	.	.
5180	20	1	The	the	DT
5180	20	2	Mission	Mission	NNP
5180	20	3	of	of	IN
5180	20	4	Public	Public	NNP
5180	20	5	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	20	6	,	,	,
5180	20	7	and	and	CC
5180	20	8	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	20	9	Reference	Reference	NNP
5180	20	10	and	and	CC
5180	20	11	Collection	Collection	NNP
5180	20	12	Development	Development	NNP
5180	20	13	Practices	Practices	NNPS
5180	20	14	2	2	CD
5180	20	15	.	.	.
5180	21	1	The	the	DT
5180	21	2	Internet	internet	NN
5180	21	3	in	in	IN
5180	21	4	Public	Public	NNP
5180	21	5	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	21	6	a.	a.	NN
5180	21	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	21	8	Use	use	VBP
5180	21	9	Policies	policy	NNS
5180	21	10	in	in	IN
5180	21	11	Public	Public	NNP
5180	21	12	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	21	13	b.	b.	NN
5180	22	1	Methods	method	NNS
5180	22	2	for	for	IN
5180	22	3	Regulating	Regulating	NNP
5180	22	4	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	22	5	Use	Use	NNP
5180	22	6	E.	E.	NNP
5180	22	7	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	22	8	Filtering	Filtering	NNP
5180	22	9	Technology	Technology	NNP
5180	22	10	1	1	CD
5180	22	11	.	.	.
5180	23	1	What	what	WP
5180	23	2	Is	be	VBZ
5180	23	3	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	23	4	Software	software	NN
5180	23	5	,	,	,
5180	23	6	Who	who	WP
5180	23	7	Makes	make	VBZ
5180	23	8	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	23	9	,	,	,
5180	23	10	and	and	CC
5180	23	11	What	what	WP
5180	23	12	Does	do	VBZ
5180	23	13	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	23	14	Do	do	VB
5180	23	15	?	?	.
5180	24	1	2	2	LS
5180	24	2	.	.	.
5180	25	1	The	the	DT
5180	25	2	Methods	Methods	NNPS
5180	25	3	that	that	IN
5180	25	4	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	25	5	Companies	company	NNS
5180	25	6	Use	use	VBP
5180	25	7	to	to	IN
5180	25	8	Compile	Compile	NNP
5180	25	9	Category	Category	NNP
5180	25	10	Lists	Lists	NNPS
5180	25	11	a.	a.	NN
5180	26	1	The	the	DT
5180	26	2	"	"	``
5180	26	3	Harvesting	Harvesting	NNP
5180	26	4	"	"	''
5180	26	5	Phase	phase	NN
5180	26	6	b.	b.	NN
5180	27	1	The	the	DT
5180	27	2	"	"	``
5180	27	3	Winnowing	winnowing	NN
5180	27	4	"	"	''
5180	27	5	or	or	CC
5180	27	6	Categorization	Categorization	NNP
5180	27	7	Phase	Phase	NNP
5180	27	8	c.	c.	NN
5180	27	9	The	the	DT
5180	27	10	Process	Process	NNP
5180	27	11	for	for	IN
5180	27	12	"	"	``
5180	27	13	Re	Re	NNP
5180	27	14	-	-	NN
5180	27	15	Reviewing	reviewing	NN
5180	27	16	"	"	''
5180	27	17	Web	web	NN
5180	27	18	Pages	page	NNS
5180	27	19	After	after	IN
5180	27	20	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	27	21	Initial	Initial	NNP
5180	27	22	Categorization	categorization	NN
5180	27	23	3	3	CD
5180	27	24	.	.	.
5180	28	1	The	the	DT
5180	28	2	Inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	28	3	Tradeoff	tradeoff	NN
5180	28	4	Between	between	IN
5180	28	5	Overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	28	6	and	and	CC
5180	28	7	Underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	28	8	4	4	CD
5180	28	9	.	.	.
5180	29	1	Attempts	attempt	NNS
5180	29	2	to	to	TO
5180	29	3	Quantify	quantify	VB
5180	29	4	Filtering	Filtering	NNP
5180	29	5	Programs	Programs	NNPS
5180	29	6	'	'	POS
5180	29	7	Rates	Rates	NNPS
5180	29	8	of	of	IN
5180	29	9	Over-	Over-	NNP
5180	29	10	and	and	CC
5180	29	11	Underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	29	12	5	5	CD
5180	29	13	.	.	.
5180	30	1	Methods	method	NNS
5180	30	2	of	of	IN
5180	30	3	Obtaining	obtain	VBG
5180	30	4	Examples	Examples	NNPS
5180	30	5	of	of	IN
5180	30	6	Erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	30	7	Blocked	block	VBN
5180	30	8	Web	Web	NNP
5180	30	9	Sites	Sites	NNPS
5180	30	10	6	6	CD
5180	30	11	.	.	.
5180	31	1	Examples	example	NNS
5180	31	2	of	of	IN
5180	31	3	Erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	31	4	Blocked	block	VBN
5180	31	5	Web	Web	NNP
5180	31	6	Sites	Sites	NNPS
5180	31	7	7	7	CD
5180	31	8	.	.	.
5180	32	1	Conclusion	conclusion	NN
5180	32	2	:	:	:
5180	32	3	The	the	DT
5180	32	4	Effectiveness	Effectiveness	NNP
5180	32	5	of	of	IN
5180	32	6	Filtering	Filtering	NNP
5180	32	7	Programs	Programs	NNPS
5180	32	8	III	III	NNP
5180	32	9	.	.	.
5180	33	1	Analytic	Analytic	NNP
5180	33	2	Framework	Framework	NNP
5180	33	3	for	for	IN
5180	33	4	the	the	DT
5180	33	5	Opinion	opinion	NN
5180	33	6	:	:	:
5180	33	7	The	the	DT
5180	33	8	Centrality	Centrality	NNP
5180	33	9	of	of	IN
5180	33	10	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	33	11	and	and	CC
5180	33	12	the	the	DT
5180	33	13	Role	role	NN
5180	33	14	of	of	IN
5180	33	15	the	the	DT
5180	33	16	Facial	Facial	NNP
5180	33	17	Challenge	Challenge	NNP
5180	33	18	IV	IV	NNP
5180	33	19	.	.	.
5180	34	1	Level	level	NN
5180	34	2	of	of	IN
5180	34	3	Scrutiny	Scrutiny	NNP
5180	34	4	Applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	34	5	to	to	IN
5180	34	6	Content	content	NN
5180	34	7	-	-	HYPH
5180	34	8	based	base	VBN
5180	34	9	Restrictions	Restrictions	NNPS
5180	34	10	on	on	IN
5180	34	11	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	34	12	Access	Access	NNP
5180	34	13	in	in	IN
5180	34	14	Public	Public	NNP
5180	34	15	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	34	16	A.	A.	NNP
5180	34	17	Overview	Overview	NNP
5180	34	18	of	of	IN
5180	34	19	Public	Public	NNP
5180	34	20	Forum	Forum	NNP
5180	34	21	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
5180	34	22	B.	B.	NNP
5180	34	23	Contours	Contours	NNP
5180	34	24	of	of	IN
5180	34	25	the	the	DT
5180	34	26	Relevant	Relevant	NNP
5180	34	27	Forum	Forum	NNP
5180	34	28	:	:	:
5180	34	29	the	the	DT
5180	34	30	Library	Library	NNP
5180	34	31	's	's	POS
5180	34	32	Collection	Collection	NNP
5180	34	33	as	as	IN
5180	34	34	a	a	DT
5180	34	35	Whole	Whole	NNP
5180	34	36	or	or	CC
5180	34	37	the	the	DT
5180	34	38	Provision	Provision	NNP
5180	34	39	of	of	IN
5180	34	40	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	34	41	Access	Access	NNP
5180	34	42	?	?	.
5180	35	1	C.	C.	NNP
5180	35	2	Content	Content	NNP
5180	35	3	-	-	HYPH
5180	35	4	based	base	VBN
5180	35	5	Restrictions	Restrictions	NNPS
5180	35	6	in	in	IN
5180	35	7	Designated	Designated	NNP
5180	35	8	Public	Public	NNP
5180	35	9	Fora	Fora	NNP
5180	35	10	D.	D.	NNP
5180	35	11	Reasons	Reasons	NNP
5180	35	12	for	for	IN
5180	35	13	Applying	apply	VBG
5180	35	14	Strict	Strict	NNP
5180	35	15	Scrutiny	Scrutiny	NNP
5180	35	16	1	1	CD
5180	35	17	.	.	.
5180	36	1	Selective	Selective	NNP
5180	36	2	Exclusion	exclusion	NN
5180	36	3	From	from	IN
5180	36	4	a	a	DT
5180	36	5	"	"	``
5180	36	6	Vast	Vast	NNP
5180	36	7	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
5180	36	8	Forum	Forum	NNP
5180	36	9	"	"	''
5180	36	10	2	2	CD
5180	36	11	.	.	.
5180	37	1	Analogy	analogy	NN
5180	37	2	to	to	IN
5180	37	3	Traditional	Traditional	NNP
5180	37	4	Public	Public	NNP
5180	37	5	Fora	Fora	NNP
5180	37	6	V.	V.	NNP
5180	37	7	Application	Application	NNP
5180	37	8	of	of	IN
5180	37	9	Strict	Strict	NNP
5180	37	10	Scrutiny	Scrutiny	NNP
5180	37	11	A.	a.	NN
5180	38	1	State	State	NNP
5180	38	2	Interests	Interests	NNP
5180	38	3	1	1	CD
5180	38	4	.	.	.
5180	39	1	Preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	39	2	the	the	DT
5180	39	3	Dissemination	Dissemination	NNP
5180	39	4	of	of	IN
5180	39	5	Obscenity	Obscenity	NNP
5180	39	6	,	,	,
5180	39	7	Child	Child	NNP
5180	39	8	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	39	9	,	,	,
5180	39	10	and	and	CC
5180	39	11	Material	Material	NNP
5180	39	12	Harmful	Harmful	NNP
5180	39	13	to	to	IN
5180	39	14	Minors	Minors	NNP
5180	39	15	2	2	CD
5180	39	16	.	.	.
5180	40	1	Protecting	protect	VBG
5180	40	2	the	the	DT
5180	40	3	Unwilling	Unwilling	NNP
5180	40	4	Viewer	Viewer	NNP
5180	40	5	3	3	CD
5180	40	6	.	.	.
5180	41	1	Preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	41	2	Unlawful	unlawful	JJ
5180	41	3	or	or	CC
5180	41	4	Inappropriate	Inappropriate	NNP
5180	41	5	Conduct	Conduct	NNP
5180	41	6	4	4	CD
5180	41	7	.	.	.
5180	42	1	Summary	Summary	NNP
5180	42	2	B.	B.	NNP
5180	43	1	Narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	43	2	Tailoring	tailoring	NN
5180	43	3	C.	C.	NNP
5180	43	4	Less	Less	NNP
5180	43	5	Restrictive	Restrictive	NNP
5180	43	6	Alternatives	Alternatives	NNP
5180	43	7	D.	D.	NNP
5180	43	8	Do	do	VBP
5180	43	9	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	43	10	's	's	POS
5180	43	11	Disabling	Disabling	NNP
5180	43	12	Provisions	Provisions	NNPS
5180	43	13	Cure	Cure	NNP
5180	43	14	the	the	DT
5180	43	15	Defect	defect	NN
5180	43	16	?	?	.
5180	44	1	VI	VI	NNP
5180	44	2	.	.	.
5180	45	1	Conclusion	conclusion	NN
5180	45	2	;	;	:
5180	45	3	Severability	severability	NN
5180	45	4	FOOTNOTES	footnote	NNS
5180	45	5	1	1	CD
5180	45	6	.	.	.
5180	46	1	Preliminary	Preliminary	NNP
5180	46	2	Statement	Statement	NNP
5180	46	3	This	this	DT
5180	46	4	case	case	NN
5180	46	5	challenges	challenge	VBZ
5180	46	6	an	an	DT
5180	46	7	act	act	NN
5180	46	8	of	of	IN
5180	46	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	46	10	that	that	WDT
5180	46	11	makes	make	VBZ
5180	46	12	the	the	DT
5180	46	13	use	use	NN
5180	46	14	of	of	IN
5180	46	15	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	46	16	software	software	NN
5180	46	17	by	by	IN
5180	46	18	public	public	JJ
5180	46	19	libraries	library	NNS
5180	46	20	a	a	DT
5180	46	21	condition	condition	NN
5180	46	22	of	of	IN
5180	46	23	the	the	DT
5180	46	24	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	46	25	of	of	IN
5180	46	26	federal	federal	JJ
5180	46	27	funding	funding	NN
5180	46	28	.	.	.
5180	47	1	The	the	DT
5180	47	2	Internet	internet	NN
5180	47	3	,	,	,
5180	47	4	as	as	IN
5180	47	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	47	6	well	well	RB
5180	47	7	known	know	VBN
5180	47	8	,	,	,
5180	47	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	47	10	a	a	DT
5180	47	11	vast	vast	JJ
5180	47	12	,	,	,
5180	47	13	interactive	interactive	JJ
5180	47	14	medium	medium	NN
5180	47	15	based	base	VBN
5180	47	16	on	on	IN
5180	47	17	a	a	DT
5180	47	18	decentralized	decentralized	JJ
5180	47	19	network	network	NN
5180	47	20	of	of	IN
5180	47	21	computers	computer	NNS
5180	47	22	around	around	IN
5180	47	23	the	the	DT
5180	47	24	world	world	NN
5180	47	25	.	.	.
5180	48	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	48	2	most	most	RBS
5180	48	3	familiar	familiar	JJ
5180	48	4	feature	feature	NN
5180	48	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	48	6	the	the	DT
5180	48	7	World	World	NNP
5180	48	8	Wide	Wide	NNP
5180	48	9	Web	web	NN
5180	48	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	48	11	the	the	DT
5180	48	12	"	"	``
5180	48	13	Web	web	NN
5180	48	14	"	"	''
5180	48	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	48	16	,	,	,
5180	48	17	a	a	DT
5180	48	18	network	network	NN
5180	48	19	of	of	IN
5180	48	20	computers	computer	NNS
5180	48	21	known	know	VBN
5180	48	22	as	as	IN
5180	48	23	servers	server	NNS
5180	48	24	that	that	WDT
5180	48	25	provide	provide	VBP
5180	48	26	content	content	NN
5180	48	27	to	to	IN
5180	48	28	users	user	NNS
5180	48	29	.	.	.
5180	49	1	The	the	DT
5180	49	2	Internet	internet	NN
5180	49	3	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	49	4	easy	easy	JJ
5180	49	5	access	access	NN
5180	49	6	to	to	IN
5180	49	7	anyone	anyone	NN
5180	49	8	who	who	WP
5180	49	9	wishes	wish	VBZ
5180	49	10	to	to	TO
5180	49	11	provide	provide	VB
5180	49	12	or	or	CC
5180	49	13	distribute	distribute	VB
5180	49	14	information	information	NN
5180	49	15	to	to	IN
5180	49	16	a	a	DT
5180	49	17	worldwide	worldwide	JJ
5180	49	18	audience	audience	NN
5180	49	19	;	;	:
5180	49	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	49	21	is	be	VBZ
5180	49	22	used	use	VBN
5180	49	23	by	by	IN
5180	49	24	more	more	JJR
5180	49	25	than	than	IN
5180	49	26	143	143	CD
5180	49	27	million	million	CD
5180	49	28	Americans	Americans	NNPS
5180	49	29	.	.	.
5180	50	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	50	2	,	,	,
5180	50	3	much	much	JJ
5180	50	4	of	of	IN
5180	50	5	the	the	DT
5180	50	6	world	world	NN
5180	50	7	's	's	POS
5180	50	8	knowledge	knowledge	NN
5180	50	9	accumulated	accumulate	VBN
5180	50	10	over	over	IN
5180	50	11	centuries	century	NNS
5180	50	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	50	13	available	available	JJ
5180	50	14	to	to	IN
5180	50	15	Internet	internet	NN
5180	50	16	users	user	NNS
5180	50	17	almost	almost	RB
5180	50	18	instantly	instantly	RB
5180	50	19	.	.	.
5180	51	1	Approximately	approximately	RB
5180	51	2	10	10	CD
5180	51	3	%	%	NN
5180	51	4	of	of	IN
5180	51	5	the	the	DT
5180	51	6	Americans	Americans	NNPS
5180	51	7	who	who	WP
5180	51	8	use	use	VBP
5180	51	9	the	the	DT
5180	51	10	Internet	internet	NN
5180	51	11	access	access	NN
5180	51	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	51	13	at	at	IN
5180	51	14	public	public	JJ
5180	51	15	libraries	library	NNS
5180	51	16	.	.	.
5180	52	1	And	and	CC
5180	52	2	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	52	3	95	95	CD
5180	52	4	%	%	NN
5180	52	5	of	of	IN
5180	52	6	all	all	DT
5180	52	7	public	public	JJ
5180	52	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	52	9	in	in	IN
5180	52	10	the	the	DT
5180	52	11	United	United	NNP
5180	52	12	States	States	NNP
5180	52	13	provide	provide	VBP
5180	52	14	public	public	JJ
5180	52	15	access	access	NN
5180	52	16	to	to	IN
5180	52	17	the	the	DT
5180	52	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	52	19	.	.	.
5180	53	1	While	while	IN
5180	53	2	the	the	DT
5180	53	3	beneficial	beneficial	JJ
5180	53	4	effect	effect	NN
5180	53	5	of	of	IN
5180	53	6	the	the	DT
5180	53	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	53	8	in	in	IN
5180	53	9	expanding	expand	VBG
5180	53	10	the	the	DT
5180	53	11	amount	amount	NN
5180	53	12	of	of	IN
5180	53	13	information	information	NN
5180	53	14	available	available	JJ
5180	53	15	to	to	IN
5180	53	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	53	17	users	user	NNS
5180	53	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	53	19	self	self	NN
5180	53	20	-	-	HYPH
5180	53	21	evident	evident	JJ
5180	53	22	,	,	,
5180	53	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	53	24	low	low	JJ
5180	53	25	entry	entry	NN
5180	53	26	barriers	barrier	NNS
5180	53	27	have	have	VBP
5180	53	28	also	also	RB
5180	53	29	led	lead	VBN
5180	53	30	to	to	IN
5180	53	31	a	a	DT
5180	53	32	perverse	perverse	JJ
5180	53	33	result	result	NN
5180	53	34	–	–	:
5180	53	35	facilitation	facilitation	NN
5180	53	36	of	of	IN
5180	53	37	the	the	DT
5180	53	38	widespread	widespread	JJ
5180	53	39	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	53	40	of	of	IN
5180	53	41	hardcore	hardcore	JJ
5180	53	42	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	53	43	within	within	IN
5180	53	44	the	the	DT
5180	53	45	easy	easy	JJ
5180	53	46	reach	reach	NN
5180	53	47	not	not	RB
5180	53	48	only	only	RB
5180	53	49	of	of	IN
5180	53	50	adults	adult	NNS
5180	53	51	who	who	WP
5180	53	52	have	have	VBP
5180	53	53	every	every	DT
5180	53	54	right	right	NN
5180	53	55	to	to	TO
5180	53	56	access	access	VB
5180	53	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	53	58	(	(	-LRB-
5180	53	59	so	so	RB
5180	53	60	long	long	RB
5180	53	61	as	as	IN
5180	53	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	53	63	is	be	VBZ
5180	53	64	not	not	RB
5180	53	65	legally	legally	RB
5180	53	66	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	53	67	or	or	CC
5180	53	68	child	child	NN
5180	53	69	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	53	70	)	)	-RRB-
5180	53	71	,	,	,
5180	53	72	but	but	CC
5180	53	73	also	also	RB
5180	53	74	of	of	IN
5180	53	75	children	child	NNS
5180	53	76	and	and	CC
5180	53	77	adolescents	adolescent	NNS
5180	53	78	to	to	TO
5180	53	79	whom	whom	WP
5180	53	80	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	53	81	may	may	MD
5180	53	82	be	be	VB
5180	53	83	quite	quite	RB
5180	53	84	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	53	85	.	.	.
5180	54	1	The	the	DT
5180	54	2	volume	volume	NN
5180	54	3	of	of	IN
5180	54	4	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	54	5	on	on	IN
5180	54	6	the	the	DT
5180	54	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	54	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	54	9	huge	huge	JJ
5180	54	10	,	,	,
5180	54	11	and	and	CC
5180	54	12	the	the	DT
5180	54	13	record	record	NN
5180	54	14	before	before	IN
5180	54	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	54	16	demonstrates	demonstrate	VBZ
5180	54	17	that	that	IN
5180	54	18	public	public	JJ
5180	54	19	library	library	NN
5180	54	20	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	54	21	of	of	IN
5180	54	22	all	all	DT
5180	54	23	ages	age	NNS
5180	54	24	,	,	,
5180	54	25	many	many	JJ
5180	54	26	from	from	IN
5180	54	27	ages	age	NNS
5180	54	28	11	11	CD
5180	54	29	to	to	IN
5180	54	30	15	15	CD
5180	54	31	,	,	,
5180	54	32	have	have	VBP
5180	54	33	regularly	regularly	RB
5180	54	34	sought	seek	VBN
5180	54	35	to	to	TO
5180	54	36	access	access	VB
5180	54	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	54	38	in	in	IN
5180	54	39	public	public	JJ
5180	54	40	library	library	NN
5180	54	41	settings	setting	NNS
5180	54	42	.	.	.
5180	55	1	There	there	EX
5180	55	2	are	be	VBP
5180	55	3	more	more	JJR
5180	55	4	than	than	IN
5180	55	5	100,000	100,000	CD
5180	55	6	pornographic	pornographic	JJ
5180	55	7	Web	web	NN
5180	55	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	55	9	that	that	WDT
5180	55	10	can	can	MD
5180	55	11	be	be	VB
5180	55	12	accessed	access	VBN
5180	55	13	for	for	IN
5180	55	14	free	free	JJ
5180	55	15	and	and	CC
5180	55	16	without	without	IN
5180	55	17	providing	provide	VBG
5180	55	18	any	any	DT
5180	55	19	registration	registration	NN
5180	55	20	information	information	NN
5180	55	21	,	,	,
5180	55	22	and	and	CC
5180	55	23	tens	ten	NNS
5180	55	24	of	of	IN
5180	55	25	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	55	26	of	of	IN
5180	55	27	Web	web	NN
5180	55	28	sites	site	NNS
5180	55	29	contain	contain	VBP
5180	55	30	child	child	NN
5180	55	31	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	55	32	.	.	.
5180	56	1	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	56	2	have	have	VBP
5180	56	3	reacted	react	VBN
5180	56	4	to	to	IN
5180	56	5	this	this	DT
5180	56	6	situation	situation	NN
5180	56	7	by	by	IN
5180	56	8	utilizing	utilize	VBG
5180	56	9	a	a	DT
5180	56	10	number	number	NN
5180	56	11	of	of	IN
5180	56	12	means	mean	NNS
5180	56	13	designed	design	VBN
5180	56	14	to	to	TO
5180	56	15	insure	insure	VB
5180	56	16	that	that	IN
5180	56	17	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	56	18	avoid	avoid	VBP
5180	56	19	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	56	20	(	(	-LRB-
5180	56	21	and	and	CC
5180	56	22	unwanted	unwanted	JJ
5180	56	23	)	)	-RRB-
5180	56	24	content	content	NN
5180	56	25	while	while	IN
5180	56	26	also	also	RB
5180	56	27	enabling	enable	VBG
5180	56	28	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	56	29	to	to	TO
5180	56	30	find	find	VB
5180	56	31	the	the	DT
5180	56	32	content	content	NN
5180	56	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	56	34	desire	desire	VBP
5180	56	35	.	.	.
5180	57	1	Some	some	DT
5180	57	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	57	3	have	have	VBP
5180	57	4	trained	train	VBN
5180	57	5	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	57	6	in	in	IN
5180	57	7	how	how	WRB
5180	57	8	to	to	TO
5180	57	9	use	use	VB
5180	57	10	the	the	DT
5180	57	11	Internet	internet	NN
5180	57	12	while	while	IN
5180	57	13	avoiding	avoid	VBG
5180	57	14	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	57	15	content	content	NN
5180	57	16	,	,	,
5180	57	17	or	or	CC
5180	57	18	have	have	VBP
5180	57	19	directed	direct	VBN
5180	57	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	57	21	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	57	22	to	to	IN
5180	57	23	"	"	``
5180	57	24	preferred	prefer	VBN
5180	57	25	"	"	''
5180	57	26	Web	web	NN
5180	57	27	sites	site	NNS
5180	57	28	that	that	IN
5180	57	29	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	57	30	have	have	VBP
5180	57	31	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	57	32	.	.	.
5180	58	1	Other	other	JJ
5180	58	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	58	3	have	have	VBP
5180	58	4	utilized	utilize	VBN
5180	58	5	such	such	JJ
5180	58	6	devices	device	NNS
5180	58	7	as	as	IN
5180	58	8	recessing	recess	VBG
5180	58	9	the	the	DT
5180	58	10	computer	computer	NN
5180	58	11	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	58	12	,	,	,
5180	58	13	installing	instal	VBG
5180	58	14	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	58	15	screens	screen	NNS
5180	58	16	,	,	,
5180	58	17	and	and	CC
5180	58	18	monitoring	monitoring	NN
5180	58	19	implemented	implement	VBN
5180	58	20	by	by	IN
5180	58	21	a	a	DT
5180	58	22	"	"	``
5180	58	23	tap	tap	NN
5180	58	24	on	on	IN
5180	58	25	the	the	DT
5180	58	26	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	58	27	"	"	''
5180	58	28	of	of	IN
5180	58	29	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	58	30	perceived	perceive	VBN
5180	58	31	to	to	TO
5180	58	32	be	be	VB
5180	58	33	offending	offend	VBG
5180	58	34	library	library	NN
5180	58	35	policy	policy	NN
5180	58	36	.	.	.
5180	59	1	Still	still	RB
5180	59	2	others	other	NNS
5180	59	3	,	,	,
5180	59	4	viewing	view	VBG
5180	59	5	the	the	DT
5180	59	6	foregoing	forego	VBG
5180	59	7	approaches	approach	NNS
5180	59	8	as	as	IN
5180	59	9	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
5180	59	10	or	or	CC
5180	59	11	uncomfortable	uncomfortable	JJ
5180	59	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	59	13	some	some	DT
5180	59	14	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	59	15	do	do	VBP
5180	59	16	not	not	RB
5180	59	17	wish	wish	VB
5180	59	18	to	to	TO
5180	59	19	confront	confront	VB
5180	59	20	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	59	21	)	)	-RRB-
5180	59	22	,	,	,
5180	59	23	have	have	VBP
5180	59	24	purchased	purchase	VBN
5180	59	25	commercially	commercially	RB
5180	59	26	available	available	JJ
5180	59	27	software	software	NN
5180	59	28	that	that	WDT
5180	59	29	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	59	30	certain	certain	JJ
5180	59	31	categories	category	NNS
5180	59	32	of	of	IN
5180	59	33	material	material	NN
5180	59	34	deemed	deem	VBN
5180	59	35	by	by	IN
5180	59	36	the	the	DT
5180	59	37	library	library	NN
5180	59	38	board	board	NN
5180	59	39	as	as	IN
5180	59	40	unsuitable	unsuitable	JJ
5180	59	41	for	for	IN
5180	59	42	use	use	NN
5180	59	43	in	in	IN
5180	59	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	59	45	facilities	facility	NNS
5180	59	46	.	.	.
5180	60	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	60	2	,	,	,
5180	60	3	7	7	CD
5180	60	4	%	%	NN
5180	60	5	of	of	IN
5180	60	6	American	american	JJ
5180	60	7	public	public	JJ
5180	60	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	60	9	use	use	VBP
5180	60	10	blocking	block	VBG
5180	60	11	software	software	NN
5180	60	12	for	for	IN
5180	60	13	adults	adult	NNS
5180	60	14	.	.	.
5180	61	1	Although	although	IN
5180	61	2	such	such	JJ
5180	61	3	programs	program	NNS
5180	61	4	are	be	VBP
5180	61	5	somewhat	somewhat	RB
5180	61	6	effective	effective	JJ
5180	61	7	in	in	IN
5180	61	8	blocking	block	VBG
5180	61	9	large	large	JJ
5180	61	10	quantities	quantity	NNS
5180	61	11	of	of	IN
5180	61	12	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	61	13	,	,	,
5180	61	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	61	15	are	be	VBP
5180	61	16	blunt	blunt	JJ
5180	61	17	instruments	instrument	NNS
5180	61	18	that	that	WDT
5180	61	19	not	not	RB
5180	61	20	only	only	RB
5180	61	21	"	"	``
5180	61	22	underblock	underblock	NN
5180	61	23	,	,	,
5180	61	24	"	"	''
5180	61	25	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	61	26	,	,	,
5180	61	27	fail	fail	VB
5180	61	28	to	to	TO
5180	61	29	block	block	VB
5180	61	30	access	access	NN
5180	61	31	to	to	IN
5180	61	32	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	61	33	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	61	34	of	of	IN
5180	61	35	content	content	NN
5180	61	36	that	that	IN
5180	61	37	the	the	DT
5180	61	38	library	library	NN
5180	61	39	boards	board	NNS
5180	61	40	wish	wish	VBP
5180	61	41	to	to	TO
5180	61	42	exclude	exclude	VB
5180	61	43	,	,	,
5180	61	44	but	but	CC
5180	61	45	also	also	RB
5180	61	46	,	,	,
5180	61	47	central	central	JJ
5180	61	48	to	to	IN
5180	61	49	this	this	DT
5180	61	50	litigation	litigation	NN
5180	61	51	,	,	,
5180	61	52	"	"	``
5180	61	53	overblock	overblock	NN
5180	61	54	,	,	,
5180	61	55	"	"	''
5180	61	56	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	61	57	,	,	,
5180	61	58	block	block	NN
5180	61	59	access	access	NN
5180	61	60	to	to	IN
5180	61	61	large	large	JJ
5180	61	62	quantities	quantity	NNS
5180	61	63	of	of	IN
5180	61	64	material	material	NN
5180	61	65	that	that	WDT
5180	61	66	library	library	NN
5180	61	67	boards	board	NNS
5180	61	68	do	do	VBP
5180	61	69	not	not	RB
5180	61	70	wish	wish	VB
5180	61	71	to	to	TO
5180	61	72	exclude	exclude	VB
5180	61	73	and	and	CC
5180	61	74	that	that	DT
5180	61	75	is	be	VBZ
5180	61	76	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	61	77	protected	protect	VBN
5180	61	78	.	.	.
5180	62	1	Most	Most	JJS
5180	62	2	of	of	IN
5180	62	3	the	the	DT
5180	62	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	62	5	that	that	WDT
5180	62	6	use	use	VBP
5180	62	7	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	62	8	software	software	NN
5180	62	9	seek	seek	VBP
5180	62	10	to	to	TO
5180	62	11	block	block	VB
5180	62	12	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	62	13	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	62	14	speech	speech	NN
5180	62	15	.	.	.
5180	63	1	While	while	IN
5180	63	2	most	most	JJS
5180	63	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	63	4	include	include	VBP
5180	63	5	in	in	IN
5180	63	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	63	7	physical	physical	JJ
5180	63	8	collection	collection	NN
5180	63	9	copies	copy	NNS
5180	63	10	of	of	IN
5180	63	11	volumes	volume	NNS
5180	63	12	such	such	JJ
5180	63	13	as	as	IN
5180	63	14	The	the	DT
5180	63	15	Joy	Joy	NNP
5180	63	16	of	of	IN
5180	63	17	Sex	Sex	NNP
5180	63	18	and	and	CC
5180	63	19	The	the	DT
5180	63	20	Joy	Joy	NNP
5180	63	21	of	of	IN
5180	63	22	Gay	Gay	NNP
5180	63	23	Sex	Sex	NNP
5180	63	24	,	,	,
5180	63	25	which	which	WDT
5180	63	26	contain	contain	VBP
5180	63	27	quite	quite	RB
5180	63	28	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	63	29	photographs	photograph	NNS
5180	63	30	and	and	CC
5180	63	31	descriptions	description	NNS
5180	63	32	,	,	,
5180	63	33	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	63	34	software	software	NN
5180	63	35	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	63	36	large	large	JJ
5180	63	37	quantities	quantity	NNS
5180	63	38	of	of	IN
5180	63	39	other	other	JJ
5180	63	40	,	,	,
5180	63	41	comparable	comparable	JJ
5180	63	42	information	information	NN
5180	63	43	about	about	IN
5180	63	44	health	health	NN
5180	63	45	and	and	CC
5180	63	46	sexuality	sexuality	NN
5180	63	47	that	that	WDT
5180	63	48	adults	adult	NNS
5180	63	49	and	and	CC
5180	63	50	teenagers	teenager	NNS
5180	63	51	seek	seek	VBP
5180	63	52	on	on	IN
5180	63	53	the	the	DT
5180	63	54	Web	web	NN
5180	63	55	.	.	.
5180	64	1	One	one	CD
5180	64	2	teenager	teenager	NN
5180	64	3	testified	testify	VBD
5180	64	4	that	that	IN
5180	64	5	the	the	DT
5180	64	6	Internet	internet	NN
5180	64	7	access	access	NN
5180	64	8	in	in	IN
5180	64	9	a	a	DT
5180	64	10	public	public	JJ
5180	64	11	library	library	NN
5180	64	12	was	be	VBD
5180	64	13	the	the	DT
5180	64	14	only	only	JJ
5180	64	15	venue	venue	NN
5180	64	16	in	in	IN
5180	64	17	which	which	WDT
5180	64	18	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	64	19	could	could	MD
5180	64	20	obtain	obtain	VB
5180	64	21	information	information	NN
5180	64	22	important	important	JJ
5180	64	23	to	to	IN
5180	64	24	her	-PRON-	PRP
5180	64	25	about	about	IN
5180	64	26	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	64	27	own	own	JJ
5180	64	28	sexuality	sexuality	NN
5180	64	29	.	.	.
5180	65	1	Another	another	DT
5180	65	2	library	library	NN
5180	65	3	patron	patron	NN
5180	65	4	witness	witness	NN
5180	65	5	described	describe	VBN
5180	65	6	using	use	VBG
5180	65	7	the	the	DT
5180	65	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	65	9	to	to	TO
5180	65	10	research	research	VB
5180	65	11	breast	breast	NN
5180	65	12	cancer	cancer	NN
5180	65	13	and	and	CC
5180	65	14	reconstructive	reconstructive	JJ
5180	65	15	surgery	surgery	NN
5180	65	16	for	for	IN
5180	65	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	65	18	mother	mother	NN
5180	65	19	who	who	WP
5180	65	20	had	have	VBD
5180	65	21	breast	breast	NN
5180	65	22	surgery	surgery	NN
5180	65	23	.	.	.
5180	66	1	Even	even	RB
5180	66	2	though	though	IN
5180	66	3	some	some	DT
5180	66	4	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	66	5	programs	program	NNS
5180	66	6	contain	contain	VBP
5180	66	7	exceptions	exception	NNS
5180	66	8	for	for	IN
5180	66	9	health	health	NN
5180	66	10	and	and	CC
5180	66	11	education	education	NN
5180	66	12	,	,	,
5180	66	13	the	the	DT
5180	66	14	exceptions	exception	NNS
5180	66	15	do	do	VBP
5180	66	16	not	not	RB
5180	66	17	solve	solve	VB
5180	66	18	the	the	DT
5180	66	19	problem	problem	NN
5180	66	20	of	of	IN
5180	66	21	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	66	22	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	66	23	protected	protect	VBN
5180	66	24	material	material	NN
5180	66	25	.	.	.
5180	67	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	67	2	,	,	,
5180	67	3	as	as	IN
5180	67	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	67	5	explain	explain	VBP
5180	67	6	below	below	IN
5180	67	7	,	,	,
5180	67	8	the	the	DT
5180	67	9	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	67	10	software	software	NN
5180	67	11	on	on	IN
5180	67	12	which	which	WDT
5180	67	13	the	the	DT
5180	67	14	parties	party	NNS
5180	67	15	presented	present	VBD
5180	67	16	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	67	17	in	in	IN
5180	67	18	this	this	DT
5180	67	19	case	case	NN
5180	67	20	overblocks	overblock	VBZ
5180	67	21	not	not	RB
5180	67	22	only	only	RB
5180	67	23	information	information	NN
5180	67	24	relating	relate	VBG
5180	67	25	to	to	IN
5180	67	26	health	health	NN
5180	67	27	and	and	CC
5180	67	28	sexuality	sexuality	NN
5180	67	29	that	that	WDT
5180	67	30	might	may	MD
5180	67	31	be	be	VB
5180	67	32	mistaken	mistake	VBN
5180	67	33	for	for	IN
5180	67	34	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	67	35	or	or	CC
5180	67	36	erotica	erotica	NN
5180	67	37	,	,	,
5180	67	38	but	but	CC
5180	67	39	also	also	RB
5180	67	40	vast	vast	JJ
5180	67	41	numbers	number	NNS
5180	67	42	of	of	IN
5180	67	43	Web	web	NN
5180	67	44	pages	page	NNS
5180	67	45	and	and	CC
5180	67	46	sites	site	NNS
5180	67	47	that	that	WDT
5180	67	48	could	could	MD
5180	67	49	not	not	RB
5180	67	50	even	even	RB
5180	67	51	arguably	arguably	RB
5180	67	52	be	be	VB
5180	67	53	construed	construe	VBN
5180	67	54	as	as	IN
5180	67	55	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	67	56	or	or	CC
5180	67	57	inappropriate	inappropriate	JJ
5180	67	58	for	for	IN
5180	67	59	adults	adult	NNS
5180	67	60	or	or	CC
5180	67	61	minors	minor	NNS
5180	67	62	.	.	.
5180	68	1	The	the	DT
5180	68	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	68	3	,	,	,
5180	68	4	sharing	share	VBG
5180	68	5	the	the	DT
5180	68	6	concerns	concern	NNS
5180	68	7	of	of	IN
5180	68	8	many	many	JJ
5180	68	9	library	library	NN
5180	68	10	boards	board	NNS
5180	68	11	,	,	,
5180	68	12	enacted	enact	VBD
5180	68	13	the	the	DT
5180	68	14	Children	Children	NNPS
5180	68	15	's	's	POS
5180	68	16	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	68	17	Protection	Protection	NNP
5180	68	18	Act	Act	NNP
5180	68	19	(	(	-LRB-
5180	68	20	"	"	``
5180	68	21	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	68	22	"	"	''
5180	68	23	)	)	-RRB-
5180	68	24	,	,	,
5180	68	25	Pub	Pub	NNP
5180	68	26	.	.	.
5180	69	1	L.	L.	NNP
5180	69	2	No	no	UH
5180	69	3	.	.	.
5180	70	1	106	106	CD
5180	70	2	-	-	SYM
5180	70	3	554	554	CD
5180	70	4	,	,	,
5180	70	5	which	which	WDT
5180	70	6	makes	make	VBZ
5180	70	7	the	the	DT
5180	70	8	use	use	NN
5180	70	9	of	of	IN
5180	70	10	filters	filter	NNS
5180	70	11	by	by	IN
5180	70	12	a	a	DT
5180	70	13	public	public	JJ
5180	70	14	library	library	NN
5180	70	15	a	a	DT
5180	70	16	condition	condition	NN
5180	70	17	of	of	IN
5180	70	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	70	19	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	70	20	of	of	IN
5180	70	21	two	two	CD
5180	70	22	kinds	kind	NNS
5180	70	23	of	of	IN
5180	70	24	subsidies	subsidy	NNS
5180	70	25	that	that	WDT
5180	70	26	are	be	VBP
5180	70	27	important	important	JJ
5180	70	28	(	(	-LRB-
5180	70	29	or	or	CC
5180	70	30	even	even	RB
5180	70	31	critical	critical	JJ
5180	70	32	)	)	-RRB-
5180	70	33	to	to	IN
5180	70	34	the	the	DT
5180	70	35	budgets	budget	NNS
5180	70	36	of	of	IN
5180	70	37	many	many	JJ
5180	70	38	public	public	JJ
5180	70	39	libraries	library	NNS
5180	70	40	–	–	:
5180	70	41	grants	grant	NNS
5180	70	42	under	under	IN
5180	70	43	the	the	DT
5180	70	44	Library	Library	NNP
5180	70	45	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	70	46	and	and	CC
5180	70	47	Technology	Technology	NNP
5180	70	48	Act	Act	NNP
5180	70	49	,	,	,
5180	70	50	20	20	CD
5180	70	51	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	71	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	71	2	.	.	.
5180	72	1	9101	9101	CD
5180	72	2	et	et	NN
5180	72	3	seq	seq	NN
5180	72	4	.	.	.
5180	73	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	73	2	"	"	``
5180	73	3	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	73	4	"	"	''
5180	73	5	)	)	-RRB-
5180	73	6	,	,	,
5180	73	7	and	and	CC
5180	73	8	so	so	RB
5180	73	9	-	-	HYPH
5180	73	10	called	call	VBN
5180	73	11	"	"	``
5180	73	12	E	e	NN
5180	73	13	-	-	NN
5180	73	14	rate	rate	NN
5180	73	15	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	73	16	"	"	''
5180	73	17	for	for	IN
5180	73	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	73	19	access	access	NN
5180	73	20	and	and	CC
5180	73	21	support	support	NN
5180	73	22	under	under	IN
5180	73	23	the	the	DT
5180	73	24	Telecommunications	Telecommunications	NNPS
5180	73	25	Act	Act	NNP
5180	73	26	,	,	,
5180	73	27	47	47	CD
5180	73	28	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	74	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	74	2	.	.	.
5180	75	1	254	254	CD
5180	75	2	.	.	.
5180	76	1	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	76	2	grant	grant	NN
5180	76	3	funds	fund	NNS
5180	76	4	are	be	VBP
5180	76	5	awarded	award	VBN
5180	76	6	,	,	,
5180	76	7	inter	inter	NNP
5180	76	8	alia	alia	NNP
5180	76	9	,	,	,
5180	76	10	in	in	IN
5180	76	11	order	order	NN
5180	76	12	to	to	TO
5180	76	13	:	:	:
5180	76	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	76	15	1	1	LS
5180	76	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	76	17	assist	assist	VB
5180	76	18	libraries	library	NNS
5180	76	19	in	in	IN
5180	76	20	accessing	access	VBG
5180	76	21	information	information	NN
5180	76	22	through	through	IN
5180	76	23	electronic	electronic	JJ
5180	76	24	networks	network	NNS
5180	76	25	,	,	,
5180	76	26	and	and	CC
5180	76	27	(	(	-LRB-
5180	76	28	2	2	LS
5180	76	29	)	)	-RRB-
5180	76	30	provide	provide	VB
5180	76	31	targeted	targeted	JJ
5180	76	32	library	library	NN
5180	76	33	and	and	CC
5180	76	34	information	information	NN
5180	76	35	services	service	NNS
5180	76	36	to	to	IN
5180	76	37	persons	person	NNS
5180	76	38	having	have	VBG
5180	76	39	difficulty	difficulty	NN
5180	76	40	using	use	VBG
5180	76	41	a	a	DT
5180	76	42	library	library	NN
5180	76	43	and	and	CC
5180	76	44	to	to	IN
5180	76	45	underserved	underserved	JJ
5180	76	46	and	and	CC
5180	76	47	rural	rural	JJ
5180	76	48	communities	community	NNS
5180	76	49	,	,	,
5180	76	50	including	include	VBG
5180	76	51	children	child	NNS
5180	76	52	from	from	IN
5180	76	53	families	family	NNS
5180	76	54	with	with	IN
5180	76	55	incomes	income	NNS
5180	76	56	below	below	IN
5180	76	57	the	the	DT
5180	76	58	poverty	poverty	NN
5180	76	59	line	line	NN
5180	76	60	.	.	.
5180	77	1	E	e	NN
5180	77	2	-	-	NN
5180	77	3	rate	rate	NN
5180	77	4	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	77	5	serve	serve	VBP
5180	77	6	the	the	DT
5180	77	7	similar	similar	JJ
5180	77	8	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	77	9	of	of	IN
5180	77	10	extending	extend	VBG
5180	77	11	Internet	internet	NN
5180	77	12	access	access	NN
5180	77	13	to	to	IN
5180	77	14	schools	school	NNS
5180	77	15	and	and	CC
5180	77	16	libraries	library	NNS
5180	77	17	in	in	IN
5180	77	18	low	low	JJ
5180	77	19	-	-	HYPH
5180	77	20	income	income	NN
5180	77	21	communities	community	NNS
5180	77	22	.	.	.
5180	78	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	78	2	requires	require	VBZ
5180	78	3	that	that	IN
5180	78	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	78	5	,	,	,
5180	78	6	in	in	IN
5180	78	7	order	order	NN
5180	78	8	to	to	TO
5180	78	9	receive	receive	VB
5180	78	10	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	78	11	funds	fund	NNS
5180	78	12	or	or	CC
5180	78	13	E	e	NN
5180	78	14	-	-	NN
5180	78	15	rate	rate	NN
5180	78	16	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	78	17	,	,	,
5180	78	18	certify	certify	VB
5180	78	19	that	that	IN
5180	78	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	78	21	are	be	VBP
5180	78	22	using	use	VBG
5180	78	23	a	a	DT
5180	78	24	"	"	``
5180	78	25	technology	technology	NN
5180	78	26	protection	protection	NN
5180	78	27	measure	measure	NN
5180	78	28	"	"	''
5180	78	29	that	that	WDT
5180	78	30	prevents	prevent	VBZ
5180	78	31	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	78	32	from	from	IN
5180	78	33	accessing	access	VBG
5180	78	34	"	"	``
5180	78	35	visual	visual	JJ
5180	78	36	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	78	37	"	"	''
5180	78	38	that	that	WDT
5180	78	39	are	be	VBP
5180	78	40	"	"	``
5180	78	41	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	78	42	,	,	,
5180	78	43	"	"	''
5180	78	44	"	"	``
5180	78	45	child	child	NN
5180	78	46	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	78	47	,	,	,
5180	78	48	"	"	''
5180	78	49	or	or	CC
5180	78	50	in	in	IN
5180	78	51	the	the	DT
5180	78	52	case	case	NN
5180	78	53	of	of	IN
5180	78	54	minors	minor	NNS
5180	78	55	,	,	,
5180	78	56	"	"	''
5180	78	57	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	78	58	to	to	IN
5180	78	59	minors	minor	NNS
5180	78	60	.	.	.
5180	78	61	"	"	''
5180	79	1	20	20	CD
5180	79	2	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	80	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	80	2	.	.	.
5180	81	1	9134(f)(1)(A	9134(f)(1)(a	LS
5180	81	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	81	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	81	4	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	81	5	)	)	-RRB-
5180	81	6	;	;	:
5180	81	7	47	47	CD
5180	81	8	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	82	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	82	2	.	.	.
5180	83	1	254(h)(6)(B	254(h)(6)(b	LS
5180	83	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	83	3	&	&	CC
5180	83	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	83	5	C	C	NNP
5180	83	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	83	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	83	8	E-	e-	NN
5180	83	9	rate	rate	NN
5180	83	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	83	11	.	.	.
5180	84	1	The	the	DT
5180	84	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	84	3	,	,	,
5180	84	4	a	a	DT
5180	84	5	group	group	NN
5180	84	6	of	of	IN
5180	84	7	libraries	library	NNS
5180	84	8	,	,	,
5180	84	9	library	library	JJ
5180	84	10	associations	association	NNS
5180	84	11	,	,	,
5180	84	12	library	library	NN
5180	84	13	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	84	14	,	,	,
5180	84	15	and	and	CC
5180	84	16	Web	web	NN
5180	84	17	site	site	NN
5180	84	18	publishers	publisher	NNS
5180	84	19	,	,	,
5180	84	20	brought	bring	VBD
5180	84	21	this	this	DT
5180	84	22	suit	suit	NN
5180	84	23	against	against	IN
5180	84	24	the	the	DT
5180	84	25	United	United	NNP
5180	84	26	States	States	NNP
5180	84	27	and	and	CC
5180	84	28	others	other	NNS
5180	84	29	alleging	allege	VBG
5180	84	30	that	that	IN
5180	84	31	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	84	32	is	be	VBZ
5180	84	33	facially	facially	RB
5180	84	34	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	84	35	because	because	IN
5180	84	36	:	:	:
5180	84	37	(	(	-LRB-
5180	84	38	1	1	LS
5180	84	39	)	)	-RRB-
5180	84	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	84	41	induces	induce	VBZ
5180	84	42	public	public	JJ
5180	84	43	libraries	library	NNS
5180	84	44	to	to	TO
5180	84	45	violate	violate	VB
5180	84	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	84	47	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	84	48	'	'	POS
5180	84	49	First	First	NNP
5180	84	50	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	84	51	rights	right	NNS
5180	84	52	contrary	contrary	RB
5180	84	53	to	to	IN
5180	84	54	the	the	DT
5180	84	55	requirements	requirement	NNS
5180	84	56	of	of	IN
5180	84	57	South	South	NNP
5180	84	58	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
5180	84	59	v.	v.	IN
5180	84	60	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	84	61	,	,	,
5180	84	62	483	483	CD
5180	84	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	84	64	203	203	CD
5180	84	65	(	(	-LRB-
5180	84	66	1987	1987	CD
5180	84	67	)	)	-RRB-
5180	84	68	;	;	:
5180	84	69	and	and	CC
5180	84	70	(	(	-LRB-
5180	84	71	2	2	LS
5180	84	72	)	)	-RRB-
5180	84	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	84	74	requires	require	VBZ
5180	84	75	libraries	library	NNS
5180	84	76	to	to	TO
5180	84	77	relinquish	relinquish	VB
5180	84	78	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	84	79	First	First	NNP
5180	84	80	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	84	81	rights	right	NNS
5180	84	82	as	as	IN
5180	84	83	a	a	DT
5180	84	84	condition	condition	NN
5180	84	85	on	on	IN
5180	84	86	the	the	DT
5180	84	87	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	84	88	of	of	IN
5180	84	89	federal	federal	JJ
5180	84	90	funds	fund	NNS
5180	84	91	and	and	CC
5180	84	92	is	be	VBZ
5180	84	93	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	84	94	impermissible	impermissible	JJ
5180	84	95	under	under	IN
5180	84	96	the	the	DT
5180	84	97	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	84	98	of	of	IN
5180	84	99	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	84	100	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	84	101	.	.	.
5180	85	1	In	in	IN
5180	85	2	arguing	argue	VBG
5180	85	3	that	that	IN
5180	85	4	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	85	5	will	will	MD
5180	85	6	induce	induce	VB
5180	85	7	public	public	JJ
5180	85	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	85	9	to	to	TO
5180	85	10	violate	violate	VB
5180	85	11	the	the	DT
5180	85	12	First	First	NNP
5180	85	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	85	14	,	,	,
5180	85	15	the	the	DT
5180	85	16	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	85	17	contend	contend	VBP
5180	85	18	that	that	IN
5180	85	19	given	give	VBN
5180	85	20	the	the	DT
5180	85	21	limits	limit	NNS
5180	85	22	of	of	IN
5180	85	23	the	the	DT
5180	85	24	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	85	25	technology	technology	NN
5180	85	26	,	,	,
5180	85	27	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	85	28	's	's	POS
5180	85	29	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	85	30	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	85	31	require	require	VBP
5180	85	32	libraries	library	NNS
5180	85	33	to	to	TO
5180	85	34	impose	impose	VB
5180	85	35	content	content	NN
5180	85	36	-	-	HYPH
5180	85	37	based	base	VBN
5180	85	38	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	85	39	on	on	IN
5180	85	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	85	41	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	85	42	'	'	POS
5180	85	43	access	access	NN
5180	85	44	to	to	TO
5180	85	45	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	85	46	protected	protect	VBN
5180	85	47	speech	speech	NN
5180	85	48	.	.	.
5180	86	1	According	accord	VBG
5180	86	2	to	to	IN
5180	86	3	the	the	DT
5180	86	4	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	86	5	,	,	,
5180	86	6	these	these	DT
5180	86	7	content-	content-	XX
5180	86	8	based	base	VBN
5180	86	9	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	86	10	are	be	VBP
5180	86	11	subject	subject	JJ
5180	86	12	to	to	IN
5180	86	13	strict	strict	JJ
5180	86	14	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	86	15	under	under	IN
5180	86	16	public	public	JJ
5180	86	17	forum	forum	NN
5180	86	18	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	86	19	,	,	,
5180	86	20	see	see	VB
5180	86	21	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
5180	86	22	v.	v.	IN
5180	86	23	Rector	Rector	NNP
5180	86	24	&	&	CC
5180	86	25	Visitors	Visitors	NNPS
5180	86	26	of	of	IN
5180	86	27	Univ	Univ	NNP
5180	86	28	.	.	.
5180	87	1	of	of	IN
5180	87	2	Va.	Virginia	NNP
5180	87	3	,	,	,
5180	87	4	515	515	CD
5180	87	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	87	6	819	819	CD
5180	87	7	,	,	,
5180	87	8	837	837	CD
5180	87	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	87	10	1995	1995	CD
5180	87	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	87	12	,	,	,
5180	87	13	and	and	CC
5180	87	14	are	be	VBP
5180	87	15	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	87	16	permissible	permissible	JJ
5180	87	17	only	only	RB
5180	87	18	if	if	IN
5180	87	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	87	20	are	be	VBP
5180	87	21	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	87	22	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	87	23	to	to	TO
5180	87	24	further	further	RB
5180	87	25	a	a	DT
5180	87	26	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	87	27	state	state	NN
5180	87	28	interest	interest	NN
5180	87	29	and	and	CC
5180	87	30	no	no	DT
5180	87	31	less	less	RBR
5180	87	32	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	87	33	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	87	34	would	would	MD
5180	87	35	further	far	RBR
5180	87	36	that	that	DT
5180	87	37	interest	interest	NN
5180	87	38	,	,	,
5180	87	39	see	see	VB
5180	87	40	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	87	41	v.	v.	IN
5180	87	42	ACLU	ACLU	NNP
5180	87	43	,	,	,
5180	87	44	521	521	CD
5180	87	45	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	87	46	844	844	CD
5180	87	47	,	,	,
5180	87	48	874	874	CD
5180	87	49	(	(	-LRB-
5180	87	50	1997	1997	CD
5180	87	51	)	)	-RRB-
5180	87	52	.	.	.
5180	88	1	The	the	DT
5180	88	2	government	government	NN
5180	88	3	responds	respond	VBZ
5180	88	4	that	that	IN
5180	88	5	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	88	6	will	will	MD
5180	88	7	not	not	RB
5180	88	8	induce	induce	VB
5180	88	9	public	public	JJ
5180	88	10	libraries	library	NNS
5180	88	11	to	to	TO
5180	88	12	violate	violate	VB
5180	88	13	the	the	DT
5180	88	14	First	First	NNP
5180	88	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	88	16	,	,	,
5180	88	17	since	since	IN
5180	88	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	88	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	88	20	possible	possible	JJ
5180	88	21	for	for	IN
5180	88	22	at	at	IN
5180	88	23	least	least	JJS
5180	88	24	some	some	DT
5180	88	25	public	public	JJ
5180	88	26	libraries	library	NNS
5180	88	27	to	to	TO
5180	88	28	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	88	29	comply	comply	VB
5180	88	30	with	with	IN
5180	88	31	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	88	32	's	's	POS
5180	88	33	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	88	34	.	.	.
5180	89	1	Even	even	RB
5180	89	2	if	if	IN
5180	89	3	some	some	DT
5180	89	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	89	5	'	'	POS
5180	89	6	use	use	NN
5180	89	7	of	of	IN
5180	89	8	filters	filter	NNS
5180	89	9	might	may	MD
5180	89	10	violate	violate	VB
5180	89	11	the	the	DT
5180	89	12	First	First	NNP
5180	89	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	89	14	,	,	,
5180	89	15	the	the	DT
5180	89	16	government	government	NN
5180	89	17	submits	submit	VBZ
5180	89	18	that	that	IN
5180	89	19	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	89	20	can	can	MD
5180	89	21	be	be	VB
5180	89	22	facially	facially	RB
5180	89	23	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
5180	89	24	only	only	RB
5180	89	25	if	if	IN
5180	89	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	89	27	is	be	VBZ
5180	89	28	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	89	29	for	for	IN
5180	89	30	any	any	DT
5180	89	31	public	public	JJ
5180	89	32	library	library	NN
5180	89	33	to	to	TO
5180	89	34	comply	comply	VB
5180	89	35	with	with	IN
5180	89	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	89	37	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	89	38	without	without	IN
5180	89	39	violating	violate	VBG
5180	89	40	the	the	DT
5180	89	41	First	First	NNP
5180	89	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	89	43	.	.	.
5180	90	1	Pursuant	pursuant	JJ
5180	90	2	to	to	IN
5180	90	3	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	90	4	,	,	,
5180	90	5	a	a	DT
5180	90	6	three	three	CD
5180	90	7	-	-	HYPH
5180	90	8	judge	judge	NN
5180	90	9	Court	Court	NNP
5180	90	10	was	be	VBD
5180	90	11	convened	convene	VBN
5180	90	12	to	to	TO
5180	90	13	try	try	VB
5180	90	14	the	the	DT
5180	90	15	issues	issue	NNS
5180	90	16	.	.	.
5180	91	1	Pub	pub	RB
5180	91	2	.	.	.
5180	92	1	L.	L.	NNP
5180	92	2	No	no	UH
5180	92	3	.	.	.
5180	93	1	106	106	CD
5180	93	2	-	-	SYM
5180	93	3	554	554	CD
5180	93	4	.	.	.
5180	94	1	Following	follow	VBG
5180	94	2	an	an	DT
5180	94	3	intensive	intensive	JJ
5180	94	4	period	period	NN
5180	94	5	of	of	IN
5180	94	6	discovery	discovery	NN
5180	94	7	on	on	IN
5180	94	8	an	an	DT
5180	94	9	expedited	expedited	JJ
5180	94	10	schedule	schedule	NN
5180	94	11	to	to	TO
5180	94	12	allow	allow	VB
5180	94	13	public	public	JJ
5180	94	14	libraries	library	NNS
5180	94	15	to	to	TO
5180	94	16	know	know	VB
5180	94	17	whether	whether	IN
5180	94	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	94	19	need	need	VBP
5180	94	20	to	to	TO
5180	94	21	certify	certify	VB
5180	94	22	compliance	compliance	NN
5180	94	23	with	with	IN
5180	94	24	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	94	25	by	by	IN
5180	94	26	July	July	NNP
5180	94	27	1	1	CD
5180	94	28	,	,	,
5180	94	29	2002	2002	CD
5180	94	30	,	,	,
5180	94	31	to	to	TO
5180	94	32	receive	receive	VB
5180	94	33	subsidies	subsidy	NNS
5180	94	34	for	for	IN
5180	94	35	the	the	DT
5180	94	36	upcoming	upcoming	JJ
5180	94	37	year	year	NN
5180	94	38	,	,	,
5180	94	39	the	the	DT
5180	94	40	Court	Court	NNP
5180	94	41	conducted	conduct	VBD
5180	94	42	an	an	DT
5180	94	43	eight	eight	CD
5180	94	44	-	-	HYPH
5180	94	45	day	day	NN
5180	94	46	trial	trial	NN
5180	94	47	at	at	IN
5180	94	48	which	which	WDT
5180	94	49	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	94	50	heard	hear	VBD
5180	94	51	20	20	CD
5180	94	52	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	94	53	,	,	,
5180	94	54	and	and	CC
5180	94	55	received	receive	VBD
5180	94	56	numerous	numerous	JJ
5180	94	57	depositions	deposition	NNS
5180	94	58	,	,	,
5180	94	59	stipulations	stipulation	NNS
5180	94	60	and	and	CC
5180	94	61	documents	document	NNS
5180	94	62	.	.	.
5180	95	1	The	the	DT
5180	95	2	principal	principal	JJ
5180	95	3	focus	focus	NN
5180	95	4	of	of	IN
5180	95	5	the	the	DT
5180	95	6	trial	trial	NN
5180	95	7	was	be	VBD
5180	95	8	on	on	IN
5180	95	9	the	the	DT
5180	95	10	capacity	capacity	NN
5180	95	11	of	of	IN
5180	95	12	currently	currently	RB
5180	95	13	available	available	JJ
5180	95	14	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	95	15	software	software	NN
5180	95	16	.	.	.
5180	96	1	The	the	DT
5180	96	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	96	3	adduced	adduce	VBD
5180	96	4	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	96	5	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	96	6	not	not	RB
5180	96	7	only	only	RB
5180	96	8	that	that	IN
5180	96	9	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	96	10	programs	program	NNS
5180	96	11	bar	bar	NN
5180	96	12	access	access	NN
5180	96	13	to	to	IN
5180	96	14	a	a	DT
5180	96	15	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	96	16	amount	amount	NN
5180	96	17	of	of	IN
5180	96	18	speech	speech	NN
5180	96	19	on	on	IN
5180	96	20	the	the	DT
5180	96	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	96	22	that	that	WDT
5180	96	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	96	24	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	96	25	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	96	26	protected	protect	VBN
5180	96	27	for	for	IN
5180	96	28	adults	adult	NNS
5180	96	29	and	and	CC
5180	96	30	minors	minor	NNS
5180	96	31	,	,	,
5180	96	32	but	but	CC
5180	96	33	also	also	RB
5180	96	34	that	that	IN
5180	96	35	these	these	DT
5180	96	36	programs	program	NNS
5180	96	37	are	be	VBP
5180	96	38	intrinsically	intrinsically	RB
5180	96	39	unable	unable	JJ
5180	96	40	to	to	TO
5180	96	41	block	block	VB
5180	96	42	only	only	RB
5180	96	43	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	96	44	Internet	internet	NN
5180	96	45	content	content	NN
5180	96	46	while	while	IN
5180	96	47	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
5180	96	48	allowing	allow	VBG
5180	96	49	access	access	NN
5180	96	50	to	to	IN
5180	96	51	all	all	DT
5180	96	52	protected	protect	VBN
5180	96	53	speech	speech	NN
5180	96	54	.	.	.
5180	97	1	As	as	IN
5180	97	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	97	3	extensive	extensive	JJ
5180	97	4	findings	finding	NNS
5180	97	5	of	of	IN
5180	97	6	fact	fact	NN
5180	97	7	reflect	reflect	VBP
5180	97	8	,	,	,
5180	97	9	the	the	DT
5180	97	10	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	97	11	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBD
5180	97	12	that	that	IN
5180	97	13	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	97	14	of	of	IN
5180	97	15	Web	web	NN
5180	97	16	pages	page	NNS
5180	97	17	containing	contain	VBG
5180	97	18	protected	protect	VBN
5180	97	19	speech	speech	NN
5180	97	20	are	be	VBP
5180	97	21	wrongly	wrongly	RB
5180	97	22	blocked	block	VBN
5180	97	23	by	by	IN
5180	97	24	the	the	DT
5180	97	25	four	four	CD
5180	97	26	leading	lead	VBG
5180	97	27	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	97	28	programs	program	NNS
5180	97	29	,	,	,
5180	97	30	and	and	CC
5180	97	31	these	these	DT
5180	97	32	pages	page	NNS
5180	97	33	represent	represent	VBP
5180	97	34	only	only	RB
5180	97	35	a	a	DT
5180	97	36	fraction	fraction	NN
5180	97	37	of	of	IN
5180	97	38	Web	web	NN
5180	97	39	pages	page	NNS
5180	97	40	wrongly	wrongly	RB
5180	97	41	blocked	block	VBN
5180	97	42	by	by	IN
5180	97	43	the	the	DT
5180	97	44	programs	program	NNS
5180	97	45	.	.	.
5180	98	1	The	the	DT
5180	98	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	98	3	'	'	POS
5180	98	4	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	98	5	explained	explain	VBD
5180	98	6	that	that	IN
5180	98	7	the	the	DT
5180	98	8	problems	problem	NNS
5180	98	9	faced	face	VBN
5180	98	10	by	by	IN
5180	98	11	the	the	DT
5180	98	12	manufacturers	manufacturer	NNS
5180	98	13	and	and	CC
5180	98	14	vendors	vendor	NNS
5180	98	15	of	of	IN
5180	98	16	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	98	17	software	software	NN
5180	98	18	are	be	VBP
5180	98	19	legion	legion	NNP
5180	98	20	.	.	.
5180	99	1	The	the	DT
5180	99	2	Web	web	NN
5180	99	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	99	4	extremely	extremely	RB
5180	99	5	dynamic	dynamic	JJ
5180	99	6	,	,	,
5180	99	7	with	with	IN
5180	99	8	an	an	DT
5180	99	9	estimated	estimate	VBN
5180	99	10	1.5	1.5	CD
5180	99	11	million	million	CD
5180	99	12	new	new	JJ
5180	99	13	pages	page	NNS
5180	99	14	added	add	VBD
5180	99	15	every	every	DT
5180	99	16	day	day	NN
5180	99	17	and	and	CC
5180	99	18	the	the	DT
5180	99	19	contents	content	NNS
5180	99	20	of	of	IN
5180	99	21	existing	exist	VBG
5180	99	22	Web	web	NN
5180	99	23	pages	page	NNS
5180	99	24	changing	change	VBG
5180	99	25	very	very	RB
5180	99	26	rapidly	rapidly	RB
5180	99	27	.	.	.
5180	100	1	The	the	DT
5180	100	2	category	category	NN
5180	100	3	lists	list	NNS
5180	100	4	maintained	maintain	VBN
5180	100	5	by	by	IN
5180	100	6	the	the	DT
5180	100	7	blocking	block	VBG
5180	100	8	programs	program	NNS
5180	100	9	are	be	VBP
5180	100	10	considered	consider	VBN
5180	100	11	to	to	TO
5180	100	12	be	be	VB
5180	100	13	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
5180	100	14	information	information	NN
5180	100	15	,	,	,
5180	100	16	and	and	CC
5180	100	17	hence	hence	RB
5180	100	18	are	be	VBP
5180	100	19	unavailable	unavailable	JJ
5180	100	20	to	to	IN
5180	100	21	customers	customer	NNS
5180	100	22	or	or	CC
5180	100	23	the	the	DT
5180	100	24	general	general	JJ
5180	100	25	public	public	NN
5180	100	26	for	for	IN
5180	100	27	review	review	NN
5180	100	28	,	,	,
5180	100	29	so	so	IN
5180	100	30	that	that	IN
5180	100	31	public	public	JJ
5180	100	32	libraries	library	NNS
5180	100	33	that	that	WDT
5180	100	34	select	select	VBP
5180	100	35	categories	category	NNS
5180	100	36	when	when	WRB
5180	100	37	implementing	implement	VBG
5180	100	38	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	100	39	software	software	NN
5180	100	40	do	do	VBP
5180	100	41	not	not	RB
5180	100	42	really	really	RB
5180	100	43	know	know	VB
5180	100	44	what	what	WP
5180	100	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	100	46	are	be	VBP
5180	100	47	blocking	block	VBG
5180	100	48	.	.	.
5180	101	1	There	there	EX
5180	101	2	are	be	VBP
5180	101	3	many	many	JJ
5180	101	4	reasons	reason	NNS
5180	101	5	why	why	WRB
5180	101	6	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	101	7	software	software	NN
5180	101	8	suffers	suffer	VBZ
5180	101	9	from	from	IN
5180	101	10	extensive	extensive	JJ
5180	101	11	over-	over-	NN
5180	101	12	and	and	CC
5180	101	13	underblocking	underblocking	NN
5180	101	14	,	,	,
5180	101	15	which	which	WDT
5180	101	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	101	17	will	will	MD
5180	101	18	explain	explain	VB
5180	101	19	below	below	RB
5180	101	20	in	in	IN
5180	101	21	great	great	JJ
5180	101	22	detail	detail	NN
5180	101	23	.	.	.
5180	102	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
5180	102	2	center	center	VBP
5180	102	3	on	on	IN
5180	102	4	the	the	DT
5180	102	5	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	102	6	on	on	IN
5180	102	7	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	102	8	companies	company	NNS
5180	102	9	'	'	POS
5180	102	10	ability	ability	NN
5180	102	11	to	to	TO
5180	102	12	:	:	:
5180	102	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	102	14	1	1	LS
5180	102	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	102	16	accurately	accurately	RB
5180	102	17	collect	collect	VB
5180	102	18	Web	web	NN
5180	102	19	pages	page	NNS
5180	102	20	that	that	WDT
5180	102	21	potentially	potentially	RB
5180	102	22	fall	fall	VBP
5180	102	23	into	into	IN
5180	102	24	a	a	DT
5180	102	25	blocked	block	VBN
5180	102	26	category	category	NN
5180	102	27	(	(	-LRB-
5180	102	28	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	102	29	,	,	,
5180	102	30	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	102	31	)	)	-RRB-
5180	102	32	;	;	,
5180	102	33	(	(	-LRB-
5180	102	34	2	2	LS
5180	102	35	)	)	-RRB-
5180	102	36	review	review	NN
5180	102	37	and	and	CC
5180	102	38	categorize	categorize	VB
5180	102	39	Web	web	NN
5180	102	40	pages	page	NNS
5180	102	41	that	that	IN
5180	102	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	102	43	have	have	VBP
5180	102	44	collected	collect	VBN
5180	102	45	;	;	:
5180	102	46	and	and	CC
5180	102	47	(	(	-LRB-
5180	102	48	3	3	LS
5180	102	49	)	)	-RRB-
5180	102	50	engage	engage	VB
5180	102	51	in	in	IN
5180	102	52	regular	regular	JJ
5180	102	53	re	re	NN
5180	102	54	-	-	NN
5180	102	55	review	review	NN
5180	102	56	of	of	IN
5180	102	57	Web	web	NN
5180	102	58	pages	page	NNS
5180	102	59	that	that	IN
5180	102	60	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	102	61	have	have	VBP
5180	102	62	previously	previously	RB
5180	102	63	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	102	64	.	.	.
5180	103	1	These	these	DT
5180	103	2	failures	failure	NNS
5180	103	3	spring	spring	VBP
5180	103	4	from	from	IN
5180	103	5	constraints	constraint	NNS
5180	103	6	on	on	IN
5180	103	7	the	the	DT
5180	103	8	technology	technology	NN
5180	103	9	of	of	IN
5180	103	10	automated	automate	VBN
5180	103	11	classification	classification	NN
5180	103	12	systems	system	NNS
5180	103	13	,	,	,
5180	103	14	and	and	CC
5180	103	15	the	the	DT
5180	103	16	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	103	17	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	103	18	in	in	IN
5180	103	19	human	human	JJ
5180	103	20	review	review	NN
5180	103	21	,	,	,
5180	103	22	including	include	VBG
5180	103	23	error	error	NN
5180	103	24	,	,	,
5180	103	25	misjudgment	misjudgment	NN
5180	103	26	,	,	,
5180	103	27	and	and	CC
5180	103	28	scarce	scarce	JJ
5180	103	29	resources	resource	NNS
5180	103	30	,	,	,
5180	103	31	which	which	WDT
5180	103	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	103	33	describe	describe	VBP
5180	103	34	in	in	IN
5180	103	35	detail	detail	NN
5180	103	36	infra	infra	NN
5180	103	37	at	at	IN
5180	103	38	58	58	CD
5180	103	39	-	-	SYM
5180	103	40	74	74	CD
5180	103	41	.	.	.
5180	104	1	One	one	CD
5180	104	2	failure	failure	NN
5180	104	3	of	of	IN
5180	104	4	critical	critical	JJ
5180	104	5	importance	importance	NN
5180	104	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	104	7	that	that	IN
5180	104	8	the	the	DT
5180	104	9	automated	automate	VBN
5180	104	10	systems	system	NNS
5180	104	11	that	that	IN
5180	104	12	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	104	13	companies	company	NNS
5180	104	14	use	use	VBP
5180	104	15	to	to	TO
5180	104	16	collect	collect	VB
5180	104	17	Web	web	NN
5180	104	18	pages	page	NNS
5180	104	19	for	for	IN
5180	104	20	classification	classification	NN
5180	104	21	are	be	VBP
5180	104	22	able	able	JJ
5180	104	23	to	to	TO
5180	104	24	search	search	VB
5180	104	25	only	only	RB
5180	104	26	text	text	NN
5180	104	27	,	,	,
5180	104	28	not	not	RB
5180	104	29	images	image	NNS
5180	104	30	.	.	.
5180	105	1	This	this	DT
5180	105	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	105	3	crippling	crippling	JJ
5180	105	4	to	to	IN
5180	105	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	105	6	companies	company	NNS
5180	105	7	'	'	POS
5180	105	8	ability	ability	NN
5180	105	9	to	to	TO
5180	105	10	collect	collect	VB
5180	105	11	pages	page	NNS
5180	105	12	containing	contain	VBG
5180	105	13	"	"	``
5180	105	14	visual	visual	JJ
5180	105	15	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	105	16	"	"	''
5180	105	17	that	that	WDT
5180	105	18	are	be	VBP
5180	105	19	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	105	20	,	,	,
5180	105	21	child	child	NN
5180	105	22	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	105	23	,	,	,
5180	105	24	or	or	CC
5180	105	25	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	105	26	to	to	IN
5180	105	27	minors	minor	NNS
5180	105	28	,	,	,
5180	105	29	as	as	IN
5180	105	30	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	105	31	requires	require	VBZ
5180	105	32	.	.	.
5180	106	1	As	as	IN
5180	106	2	will	will	MD
5180	106	3	appear	appear	VB
5180	106	4	,	,	,
5180	106	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	106	6	find	find	VBP
5180	106	7	that	that	IN
5180	106	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	106	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	106	10	currently	currently	RB
5180	106	11	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	106	12	,	,	,
5180	106	13	given	give	VBN
5180	106	14	the	the	DT
5180	106	15	Internet	internet	NN
5180	106	16	's	's	POS
5180	106	17	size	size	NN
5180	106	18	,	,	,
5180	106	19	rate	rate	NN
5180	106	20	of	of	IN
5180	106	21	growth	growth	NN
5180	106	22	,	,	,
5180	106	23	rate	rate	NN
5180	106	24	of	of	IN
5180	106	25	change	change	NN
5180	106	26	,	,	,
5180	106	27	and	and	CC
5180	106	28	architecture	architecture	NN
5180	106	29	,	,	,
5180	106	30	and	and	CC
5180	106	31	given	give	VBN
5180	106	32	the	the	DT
5180	106	33	state	state	NN
5180	106	34	of	of	IN
5180	106	35	the	the	DT
5180	106	36	art	art	NN
5180	106	37	of	of	IN
5180	106	38	automated	automate	VBN
5180	106	39	classification	classification	NN
5180	106	40	systems	system	NNS
5180	106	41	,	,	,
5180	106	42	to	to	TO
5180	106	43	develop	develop	VB
5180	106	44	a	a	DT
5180	106	45	filter	filter	NN
5180	106	46	that	that	IN
5180	106	47	neither	neither	CC
5180	106	48	underblocks	underblock	NNS
5180	106	49	nor	nor	CC
5180	106	50	overblocks	overblock	VBZ
5180	106	51	a	a	DT
5180	106	52	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	106	53	amount	amount	NN
5180	106	54	of	of	IN
5180	106	55	speech	speech	NN
5180	106	56	.	.	.
5180	107	1	The	the	DT
5180	107	2	government	government	NN
5180	107	3	,	,	,
5180	107	4	while	while	IN
5180	107	5	acknowledging	acknowledge	VBG
5180	107	6	that	that	IN
5180	107	7	the	the	DT
5180	107	8	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	107	9	software	software	NN
5180	107	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	107	11	imperfect	imperfect	JJ
5180	107	12	,	,	,
5180	107	13	maintains	maintain	VBZ
5180	107	14	that	that	IN
5180	107	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	107	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	107	17	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	107	18	quite	quite	RB
5180	107	19	effective	effective	JJ
5180	107	20	,	,	,
5180	107	21	and	and	CC
5180	107	22	that	that	IN
5180	107	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	107	24	successfully	successfully	RB
5180	107	25	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	107	26	the	the	DT
5180	107	27	vast	vast	JJ
5180	107	28	majority	majority	NN
5180	107	29	of	of	IN
5180	107	30	the	the	DT
5180	107	31	Web	web	NN
5180	107	32	pages	page	NNS
5180	107	33	that	that	WDT
5180	107	34	meet	meet	VBP
5180	107	35	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	107	36	companies	company	NNS
5180	107	37	'	'	POS
5180	107	38	category	category	NN
5180	107	39	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	107	40	(	(	-LRB-
5180	107	41	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	107	42	,	,	,
5180	107	43	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	107	44	)	)	-RRB-
5180	107	45	.	.	.
5180	108	1	The	the	DT
5180	108	2	government	government	NN
5180	108	3	contends	contend	VBZ
5180	108	4	that	that	IN
5180	108	5	no	no	DT
5180	108	6	more	more	RBR
5180	108	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	108	8	required	require	VBN
5180	108	9	.	.	.
5180	109	1	In	in	IN
5180	109	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	109	3	view	view	NN
5180	109	4	,	,	,
5180	109	5	so	so	RB
5180	109	6	long	long	RB
5180	109	7	as	as	IN
5180	109	8	the	the	DT
5180	109	9	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	109	10	software	software	NN
5180	109	11	selected	select	VBN
5180	109	12	by	by	IN
5180	109	13	the	the	DT
5180	109	14	libraries	library	NNS
5180	109	15	screens	screen	VBZ
5180	109	16	out	out	RP
5180	109	17	the	the	DT
5180	109	18	bulk	bulk	NN
5180	109	19	of	of	IN
5180	109	20	the	the	DT
5180	109	21	Web	web	NN
5180	109	22	pages	page	NNS
5180	109	23	proscribed	proscribe	VBN
5180	109	24	by	by	IN
5180	109	25	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	109	26	,	,	,
5180	109	27	the	the	DT
5180	109	28	libraries	library	NNS
5180	109	29	have	have	VBP
5180	109	30	made	make	VBN
5180	109	31	a	a	DT
5180	109	32	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
5180	109	33	choice	choice	NN
5180	109	34	which	which	WDT
5180	109	35	suffices	suffice	VBZ
5180	109	36	,	,	,
5180	109	37	under	under	IN
5180	109	38	the	the	DT
5180	109	39	applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	109	40	legal	legal	JJ
5180	109	41	principles	principle	NNS
5180	109	42	,	,	,
5180	109	43	to	to	TO
5180	109	44	pass	pass	VB
5180	109	45	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	109	46	muster	muster	NN
5180	109	47	in	in	IN
5180	109	48	the	the	DT
5180	109	49	context	context	NN
5180	109	50	of	of	IN
5180	109	51	a	a	DT
5180	109	52	facial	facial	JJ
5180	109	53	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	109	54	.	.	.
5180	110	1	Central	central	JJ
5180	110	2	to	to	IN
5180	110	3	the	the	DT
5180	110	4	government	government	NN
5180	110	5	's	's	POS
5180	110	6	position	position	NN
5180	110	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	110	8	the	the	DT
5180	110	9	analogy	analogy	NN
5180	110	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	110	11	advances	advance	VBZ
5180	110	12	between	between	IN
5180	110	13	Internet	internet	NN
5180	110	14	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	110	15	and	and	CC
5180	110	16	the	the	DT
5180	110	17	initial	initial	JJ
5180	110	18	decision	decision	NN
5180	110	19	of	of	IN
5180	110	20	a	a	DT
5180	110	21	library	library	NN
5180	110	22	to	to	TO
5180	110	23	determine	determine	VB
5180	110	24	which	which	WDT
5180	110	25	materials	material	NNS
5180	110	26	to	to	TO
5180	110	27	purchase	purchase	VB
5180	110	28	for	for	IN
5180	110	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	110	30	print	print	NN
5180	110	31	collection	collection	NN
5180	110	32	.	.	.
5180	111	1	Public	public	JJ
5180	111	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	111	3	have	have	VBP
5180	111	4	finite	finite	JJ
5180	111	5	budgets	budget	NNS
5180	111	6	and	and	CC
5180	111	7	must	must	MD
5180	111	8	make	make	VB
5180	111	9	choices	choice	NNS
5180	111	10	as	as	IN
5180	111	11	to	to	IN
5180	111	12	whether	whether	IN
5180	111	13	to	to	TO
5180	111	14	purchase	purchase	VB
5180	111	15	,	,	,
5180	111	16	for	for	IN
5180	111	17	example	example	NN
5180	111	18	,	,	,
5180	111	19	books	book	NNS
5180	111	20	on	on	IN
5180	111	21	gardening	gardening	NN
5180	111	22	or	or	CC
5180	111	23	books	book	NNS
5180	111	24	on	on	IN
5180	111	25	golf	golf	NN
5180	111	26	.	.	.
5180	112	1	Such	such	JJ
5180	112	2	content	content	NN
5180	112	3	-	-	HYPH
5180	112	4	based	base	VBN
5180	112	5	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	112	6	,	,	,
5180	112	7	even	even	RB
5180	112	8	the	the	DT
5180	112	9	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	112	10	concede	concede	VBP
5180	112	11	,	,	,
5180	112	12	are	be	VBP
5180	112	13	subject	subject	JJ
5180	112	14	to	to	IN
5180	112	15	rational	rational	JJ
5180	112	16	basis	basis	NN
5180	112	17	review	review	NN
5180	112	18	and	and	CC
5180	112	19	not	not	RB
5180	112	20	a	a	DT
5180	112	21	stricter	strict	JJR
5180	112	22	form	form	NN
5180	112	23	of	of	IN
5180	112	24	First	First	NNP
5180	112	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	112	26	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	112	27	.	.	.
5180	113	1	In	in	IN
5180	113	2	the	the	DT
5180	113	3	government	government	NN
5180	113	4	's	's	POS
5180	113	5	view	view	NN
5180	113	6	,	,	,
5180	113	7	the	the	DT
5180	113	8	fact	fact	NN
5180	113	9	that	that	IN
5180	113	10	the	the	DT
5180	113	11	Internet	internet	NN
5180	113	12	reverses	reverse	VBZ
5180	113	13	the	the	DT
5180	113	14	acquisition	acquisition	NN
5180	113	15	process	process	NN
5180	113	16	and	and	CC
5180	113	17	requires	require	VBZ
5180	113	18	the	the	DT
5180	113	19	libraries	library	NNS
5180	113	20	to	to	IN
5180	113	21	,	,	,
5180	113	22	in	in	IN
5180	113	23	effect	effect	NN
5180	113	24	,	,	,
5180	113	25	purchase	purchase	VB
5180	113	26	the	the	DT
5180	113	27	entire	entire	JJ
5180	113	28	Internet	internet	NN
5180	113	29	,	,	,
5180	113	30	some	some	DT
5180	113	31	of	of	IN
5180	113	32	which	which	WDT
5180	113	33	(	(	-LRB-
5180	113	34	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	113	35	,	,	,
5180	113	36	hardcore	hardcore	JJ
5180	113	37	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	113	38	)	)	-RRB-
5180	113	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	113	40	does	do	VBZ
5180	113	41	not	not	RB
5180	113	42	want	want	VB
5180	113	43	,	,	,
5180	113	44	should	should	MD
5180	113	45	not	not	RB
5180	113	46	mean	mean	VB
5180	113	47	that	that	IN
5180	113	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	113	49	is	be	VBZ
5180	113	50	chargeable	chargeable	JJ
5180	113	51	with	with	IN
5180	113	52	censorship	censorship	NN
5180	113	53	when	when	WRB
5180	113	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	113	55	filters	filter	VBZ
5180	113	56	out	out	RP
5180	113	57	offending	offend	VBG
5180	113	58	material	material	NN
5180	113	59	.	.	.
5180	114	1	The	the	DT
5180	114	2	legal	legal	JJ
5180	114	3	context	context	NN
5180	114	4	in	in	IN
5180	114	5	which	which	WDT
5180	114	6	this	this	DT
5180	114	7	extensive	extensive	JJ
5180	114	8	factual	factual	JJ
5180	114	9	record	record	NN
5180	114	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	114	11	set	set	VBN
5180	114	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	114	13	complex	complex	JJ
5180	114	14	,	,	,
5180	114	15	implicating	implicate	VBG
5180	114	16	a	a	DT
5180	114	17	number	number	NN
5180	114	18	of	of	IN
5180	114	19	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	114	20	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
5180	114	21	,	,	,
5180	114	22	including	include	VBG
5180	114	23	the	the	DT
5180	114	24	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	114	25	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	114	26	on	on	IN
5180	114	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	114	28	's	's	POS
5180	114	29	spending	spending	NN
5180	114	30	clause	clause	NN
5180	114	31	power	power	NN
5180	114	32	,	,	,
5180	114	33	the	the	DT
5180	114	34	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	114	35	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	114	36	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	114	37	,	,	,
5180	114	38	and	and	CC
5180	114	39	subsidiary	subsidiary	NN
5180	114	40	to	to	IN
5180	114	41	these	these	DT
5180	114	42	issues	issue	NNS
5180	114	43	,	,	,
5180	114	44	the	the	DT
5180	114	45	First	First	NNP
5180	114	46	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	114	47	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
5180	114	48	of	of	IN
5180	114	49	prior	prior	JJ
5180	114	50	restraint	restraint	NN
5180	114	51	,	,	,
5180	114	52	vagueness	vagueness	NN
5180	114	53	,	,	,
5180	114	54	and	and	CC
5180	114	55	overbreadth	overbreadth	NN
5180	114	56	.	.	.
5180	115	1	There	there	EX
5180	115	2	are	be	VBP
5180	115	3	a	a	DT
5180	115	4	number	number	NN
5180	115	5	of	of	IN
5180	115	6	potential	potential	JJ
5180	115	7	entry	entry	NN
5180	115	8	points	point	NNS
5180	115	9	into	into	IN
5180	115	10	the	the	DT
5180	115	11	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	115	12	,	,	,
5180	115	13	but	but	CC
5180	115	14	the	the	DT
5180	115	15	most	most	RBS
5180	115	16	logical	logical	JJ
5180	115	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	115	18	the	the	DT
5180	115	19	spending	spending	NN
5180	115	20	clause	clause	NN
5180	115	21	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
5180	115	22	in	in	IN
5180	115	23	which	which	WDT
5180	115	24	the	the	DT
5180	115	25	seminal	seminal	JJ
5180	115	26	case	case	NN
5180	115	27	is	be	VBZ
5180	115	28	South	South	NNP
5180	115	29	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
5180	115	30	v.	v.	IN
5180	115	31	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	115	32	,	,	,
5180	115	33	483	483	CD
5180	115	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	115	35	203	203	CD
5180	115	36	(	(	-LRB-
5180	115	37	1987	1987	CD
5180	115	38	)	)	-RRB-
5180	115	39	.	.	.
5180	116	1	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	116	2	outlines	outline	VBZ
5180	116	3	four	four	CD
5180	116	4	categories	category	NNS
5180	116	5	of	of	IN
5180	116	6	constraints	constraint	NNS
5180	116	7	on	on	IN
5180	116	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	116	9	's	's	POS
5180	116	10	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	116	11	of	of	IN
5180	116	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	116	13	power	power	NN
5180	116	14	under	under	IN
5180	116	15	the	the	DT
5180	116	16	Spending	Spending	NNP
5180	116	17	Clause	Clause	NNP
5180	116	18	,	,	,
5180	116	19	but	but	CC
5180	116	20	the	the	DT
5180	116	21	only	only	JJ
5180	116	22	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	116	23	condition	condition	NN
5180	116	24	disputed	dispute	VBN
5180	116	25	here	here	RB
5180	116	26	is	be	VBZ
5180	116	27	the	the	DT
5180	116	28	fourth	fourth	JJ
5180	116	29	and	and	CC
5180	116	30	last	last	JJ
5180	116	31	,	,	,
5180	116	32	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	116	33	,	,	,
5180	116	34	whether	whether	IN
5180	116	35	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	116	36	requires	require	VBZ
5180	116	37	libraries	library	NNS
5180	116	38	that	that	WDT
5180	116	39	receive	receive	VBP
5180	116	40	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	116	41	funds	fund	NNS
5180	116	42	or	or	CC
5180	116	43	E	e	NN
5180	116	44	-	-	NN
5180	116	45	rate	rate	NN
5180	116	46	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	116	47	to	to	TO
5180	116	48	violate	violate	VB
5180	116	49	the	the	DT
5180	116	50	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	116	51	rights	right	NNS
5180	116	52	of	of	IN
5180	116	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	116	54	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	116	55	.	.	.
5180	117	1	As	as	IN
5180	117	2	will	will	MD
5180	117	3	appear	appear	VB
5180	117	4	,	,	,
5180	117	5	the	the	DT
5180	117	6	question	question	NN
5180	117	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	117	8	not	not	RB
5180	117	9	a	a	DT
5180	117	10	simple	simple	JJ
5180	117	11	one	one	NN
5180	117	12	,	,	,
5180	117	13	and	and	CC
5180	117	14	turns	turn	VBZ
5180	117	15	on	on	IN
5180	117	16	the	the	DT
5180	117	17	level	level	NN
5180	117	18	of	of	IN
5180	117	19	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	117	20	applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	117	21	to	to	IN
5180	117	22	a	a	DT
5180	117	23	public	public	JJ
5180	117	24	library	library	NN
5180	117	25	's	's	POS
5180	117	26	content	content	NN
5180	117	27	-	-	HYPH
5180	117	28	based	base	VBN
5180	117	29	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	117	30	on	on	IN
5180	117	31	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	117	32	'	'	POS
5180	117	33	Internet	internet	NN
5180	117	34	access	access	NN
5180	117	35	.	.	.
5180	118	1	Whether	whether	IN
5180	118	2	such	such	JJ
5180	118	3	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	118	4	are	be	VBP
5180	118	5	subject	subject	JJ
5180	118	6	to	to	IN
5180	118	7	strict	strict	JJ
5180	118	8	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	118	9	,	,	,
5180	118	10	as	as	IN
5180	118	11	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	118	12	contend	contend	VBP
5180	118	13	,	,	,
5180	118	14	or	or	CC
5180	118	15	only	only	RB
5180	118	16	rational	rational	JJ
5180	118	17	basis	basis	NN
5180	118	18	review	review	NN
5180	118	19	,	,	,
5180	118	20	as	as	IN
5180	118	21	the	the	DT
5180	118	22	government	government	NN
5180	118	23	contends	contend	VBZ
5180	118	24	,	,	,
5180	118	25	depends	depend	VBZ
5180	118	26	on	on	IN
5180	118	27	public	public	JJ
5180	118	28	forum	forum	NN
5180	118	29	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	118	30	.	.	.
5180	119	1	The	the	DT
5180	119	2	government	government	NN
5180	119	3	argues	argue	VBZ
5180	119	4	that	that	IN
5180	119	5	,	,	,
5180	119	6	in	in	IN
5180	119	7	providing	provide	VBG
5180	119	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	119	9	access	access	NN
5180	119	10	,	,	,
5180	119	11	public	public	JJ
5180	119	12	libraries	library	NNS
5180	119	13	do	do	VBP
5180	119	14	not	not	RB
5180	119	15	create	create	VB
5180	119	16	a	a	DT
5180	119	17	public	public	JJ
5180	119	18	forum	forum	NN
5180	119	19	,	,	,
5180	119	20	since	since	IN
5180	119	21	public	public	JJ
5180	119	22	libraries	library	NNS
5180	119	23	may	may	MD
5180	119	24	reserve	reserve	VB
5180	119	25	the	the	DT
5180	119	26	right	right	NN
5180	119	27	to	to	TO
5180	119	28	exclude	exclude	VB
5180	119	29	certain	certain	JJ
5180	119	30	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	119	31	from	from	IN
5180	119	32	availing	avail	VBG
5180	119	33	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	119	34	of	of	IN
5180	119	35	the	the	DT
5180	119	36	forum	forum	NN
5180	119	37	.	.	.
5180	120	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
5180	120	2	,	,	,
5180	120	3	the	the	DT
5180	120	4	government	government	NN
5180	120	5	contends	contend	VBZ
5180	120	6	that	that	IN
5180	120	7	public	public	JJ
5180	120	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	120	9	'	'	POS
5180	120	10	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	120	11	on	on	IN
5180	120	12	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	120	13	'	'	POS
5180	120	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	120	15	access	access	NN
5180	120	16	are	be	VBP
5180	120	17	subject	subject	JJ
5180	120	18	only	only	RB
5180	120	19	to	to	IN
5180	120	20	rational	rational	JJ
5180	120	21	basis	basis	NN
5180	120	22	review	review	NN
5180	120	23	.	.	.
5180	121	1	Plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	121	2	respond	respond	VBP
5180	121	3	that	that	IN
5180	121	4	the	the	DT
5180	121	5	government	government	NN
5180	121	6	's	's	POS
5180	121	7	ability	ability	NN
5180	121	8	to	to	TO
5180	121	9	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	121	10	speech	speech	NN
5180	121	11	on	on	IN
5180	121	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	121	13	own	own	JJ
5180	121	14	property	property	NN
5180	121	15	,	,	,
5180	121	16	as	as	IN
5180	121	17	in	in	IN
5180	121	18	the	the	DT
5180	121	19	case	case	NN
5180	121	20	of	of	IN
5180	121	21	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	121	22	on	on	IN
5180	121	23	Internet	internet	NN
5180	121	24	access	access	NN
5180	121	25	in	in	IN
5180	121	26	public	public	JJ
5180	121	27	libraries	library	NNS
5180	121	28	,	,	,
5180	121	29	is	be	VBZ
5180	121	30	not	not	RB
5180	121	31	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	121	32	,	,	,
5180	121	33	and	and	CC
5180	121	34	that	that	IN
5180	121	35	the	the	DT
5180	121	36	more	more	RBR
5180	121	37	widely	widely	RB
5180	121	38	the	the	DT
5180	121	39	state	state	NN
5180	121	40	facilitates	facilitate	VBZ
5180	121	41	the	the	DT
5180	121	42	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	121	43	of	of	IN
5180	121	44	private	private	JJ
5180	121	45	speech	speech	NN
5180	121	46	in	in	IN
5180	121	47	a	a	DT
5180	121	48	given	give	VBN
5180	121	49	forum	forum	NN
5180	121	50	,	,	,
5180	121	51	the	the	DT
5180	121	52	more	more	RBR
5180	121	53	vulnerable	vulnerable	JJ
5180	121	54	the	the	DT
5180	121	55	state	state	NN
5180	121	56	's	's	POS
5180	121	57	decision	decision	NN
5180	121	58	is	be	VBZ
5180	121	59	to	to	TO
5180	121	60	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	121	61	access	access	NN
5180	121	62	to	to	IN
5180	121	63	speech	speech	NN
5180	121	64	in	in	IN
5180	121	65	that	that	DT
5180	121	66	forum	forum	NN
5180	121	67	.	.	.
5180	122	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	122	2	agree	agree	VBP
5180	122	3	with	with	IN
5180	122	4	the	the	DT
5180	122	5	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	122	6	that	that	WDT
5180	122	7	public	public	JJ
5180	122	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	122	9	'	'	POS
5180	122	10	content	content	NN
5180	122	11	-	-	HYPH
5180	122	12	based	base	VBN
5180	122	13	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	122	14	on	on	IN
5180	122	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	122	16	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	122	17	'	'	POS
5180	122	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	122	19	access	access	NN
5180	122	20	are	be	VBP
5180	122	21	subject	subject	JJ
5180	122	22	to	to	IN
5180	122	23	strict	strict	JJ
5180	122	24	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	122	25	.	.	.
5180	123	1	In	in	IN
5180	123	2	providing	provide	VBG
5180	123	3	even	even	RB
5180	123	4	filtered	filter	VBN
5180	123	5	Internet	internet	NN
5180	123	6	access	access	NN
5180	123	7	,	,	,
5180	123	8	public	public	JJ
5180	123	9	libraries	library	NNS
5180	123	10	create	create	VBP
5180	123	11	a	a	DT
5180	123	12	public	public	JJ
5180	123	13	forum	forum	NN
5180	123	14	open	open	JJ
5180	123	15	to	to	IN
5180	123	16	any	any	DT
5180	123	17	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	123	18	around	around	IN
5180	123	19	the	the	DT
5180	123	20	world	world	NN
5180	123	21	to	to	TO
5180	123	22	communicate	communicate	VB
5180	123	23	with	with	IN
5180	123	24	library	library	JJ
5180	123	25	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	123	26	via	via	IN
5180	123	27	the	the	DT
5180	123	28	Internet	internet	NN
5180	123	29	on	on	IN
5180	123	30	a	a	DT
5180	123	31	virtually	virtually	RB
5180	123	32	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	123	33	number	number	NN
5180	123	34	of	of	IN
5180	123	35	topics	topic	NNS
5180	123	36	.	.	.
5180	124	1	Where	where	WRB
5180	124	2	the	the	DT
5180	124	3	state	state	NN
5180	124	4	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	124	5	access	access	NN
5180	124	6	to	to	IN
5180	124	7	a	a	DT
5180	124	8	"	"	``
5180	124	9	vast	vast	JJ
5180	124	10	democratic	democratic	JJ
5180	124	11	forum	forum	NN
5180	124	12	[	[	-LRB-
5180	124	13	]	]	-RRB-
5180	124	14	,	,	,
5180	124	15	"	"	``
5180	124	16	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	124	17	v.	v.	IN
5180	124	18	ACLU	ACLU	NNP
5180	124	19	,	,	,
5180	124	20	521	521	CD
5180	124	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	124	22	844	844	CD
5180	124	23	,	,	,
5180	124	24	868	868	CD
5180	124	25	(	(	-LRB-
5180	124	26	1997	1997	CD
5180	124	27	)	)	-RRB-
5180	124	28	,	,	,
5180	124	29	open	open	JJ
5180	124	30	to	to	IN
5180	124	31	any	any	DT
5180	124	32	member	member	NN
5180	124	33	of	of	IN
5180	124	34	the	the	DT
5180	124	35	public	public	NN
5180	124	36	to	to	TO
5180	124	37	speak	speak	VB
5180	124	38	on	on	IN
5180	124	39	subjects	subject	NNS
5180	124	40	"	"	''
5180	124	41	as	as	RB
5180	124	42	diverse	diverse	JJ
5180	124	43	as	as	IN
5180	124	44	human	human	JJ
5180	124	45	thought	thought	NN
5180	124	46	,	,	,
5180	124	47	"	"	''
5180	124	48	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	124	49	d	d	VBN
5180	124	50	.	.	.
5180	125	1	at	at	IN
5180	125	2	870	870	CD
5180	125	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	125	4	internal	internal	JJ
5180	125	5	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	125	6	marks	mark	NNS
5180	125	7	and	and	CC
5180	125	8	citation	citation	NN
5180	125	9	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	125	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	125	11	,	,	,
5180	125	12	the	the	DT
5180	125	13	state	state	NN
5180	125	14	's	's	POS
5180	125	15	decision	decision	NN
5180	125	16	selectively	selectively	RB
5180	125	17	to	to	TO
5180	125	18	exclude	exclude	VB
5180	125	19	from	from	IN
5180	125	20	the	the	DT
5180	125	21	forum	forum	NN
5180	125	22	speech	speech	NN
5180	125	23	whose	whose	WP$
5180	125	24	content	content	NN
5180	125	25	the	the	DT
5180	125	26	state	state	NN
5180	125	27	disfavors	disfavor	NNS
5180	125	28	is	be	VBZ
5180	125	29	subject	subject	JJ
5180	125	30	to	to	IN
5180	125	31	strict	strict	JJ
5180	125	32	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	125	33	,	,	,
5180	125	34	as	as	IN
5180	125	35	such	such	JJ
5180	125	36	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
5180	125	37	risk	risk	NN
5180	125	38	distorting	distort	VBG
5180	125	39	the	the	DT
5180	125	40	marketplace	marketplace	NN
5180	125	41	of	of	IN
5180	125	42	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	125	43	that	that	WDT
5180	125	44	the	the	DT
5180	125	45	state	state	NN
5180	125	46	has	have	VBZ
5180	125	47	facilitated	facilitate	VBN
5180	125	48	.	.	.
5180	126	1	Application	application	NN
5180	126	2	of	of	IN
5180	126	3	strict	strict	JJ
5180	126	4	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	126	5	finds	find	VBZ
5180	126	6	further	further	JJ
5180	126	7	support	support	NN
5180	126	8	in	in	IN
5180	126	9	the	the	DT
5180	126	10	extent	extent	NN
5180	126	11	to	to	TO
5180	126	12	which	which	WDT
5180	126	13	public	public	JJ
5180	126	14	libraries	library	NNS
5180	126	15	'	'	POS
5180	126	16	provision	provision	NN
5180	126	17	of	of	IN
5180	126	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	126	19	access	access	NN
5180	126	20	uniquely	uniquely	RB
5180	126	21	promotes	promote	VBZ
5180	126	22	First	First	NNP
5180	126	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	126	24	values	value	NNS
5180	126	25	in	in	IN
5180	126	26	a	a	DT
5180	126	27	manner	manner	NN
5180	126	28	analogous	analogous	JJ
5180	126	29	to	to	IN
5180	126	30	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	126	31	public	public	JJ
5180	126	32	fora	fora	NN
5180	126	33	such	such	JJ
5180	126	34	as	as	IN
5180	126	35	streets	street	NNS
5180	126	36	,	,	,
5180	126	37	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	126	38	,	,	,
5180	126	39	and	and	CC
5180	126	40	parks	park	NNS
5180	126	41	,	,	,
5180	126	42	in	in	IN
5180	126	43	which	which	WDT
5180	126	44	content	content	NN
5180	126	45	-	-	HYPH
5180	126	46	based	base	VBN
5180	126	47	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	126	48	are	be	VBP
5180	126	49	always	always	RB
5180	126	50	subject	subject	JJ
5180	126	51	to	to	IN
5180	126	52	strict	strict	JJ
5180	126	53	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	126	54	.	.	.
5180	127	1	Under	under	IN
5180	127	2	strict	strict	JJ
5180	127	3	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	127	4	,	,	,
5180	127	5	a	a	DT
5180	127	6	public	public	JJ
5180	127	7	library	library	NN
5180	127	8	's	's	POS
5180	127	9	use	use	NN
5180	127	10	of	of	IN
5180	127	11	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	127	12	software	software	NN
5180	127	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	127	14	permissible	permissible	JJ
5180	127	15	only	only	RB
5180	127	16	if	if	IN
5180	127	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	127	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	127	19	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	127	20	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	127	21	to	to	TO
5180	127	22	further	further	RB
5180	127	23	a	a	DT
5180	127	24	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	127	25	government	government	NN
5180	127	26	interest	interest	NN
5180	127	27	and	and	CC
5180	127	28	no	no	DT
5180	127	29	less	less	RBR
5180	127	30	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	127	31	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	127	32	would	would	MD
5180	127	33	serve	serve	VB
5180	127	34	that	that	DT
5180	127	35	interest	interest	NN
5180	127	36	.	.	.
5180	128	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	128	2	acknowledge	acknowledge	VBP
5180	128	3	that	that	IN
5180	128	4	use	use	NN
5180	128	5	of	of	IN
5180	128	6	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	128	7	software	software	NN
5180	128	8	furthers	further	VBZ
5180	128	9	public	public	JJ
5180	128	10	libraries	library	NNS
5180	128	11	'	'	POS
5180	128	12	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	128	13	interests	interest	NNS
5180	128	14	in	in	IN
5180	128	15	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	128	16	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	128	17	from	from	IN
5180	128	18	accessing	access	VBG
5180	128	19	visual	visual	JJ
5180	128	20	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	128	21	of	of	IN
5180	128	22	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	128	23	,	,	,
5180	128	24	child	child	NN
5180	128	25	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	128	26	,	,	,
5180	128	27	or	or	CC
5180	128	28	in	in	IN
5180	128	29	the	the	DT
5180	128	30	case	case	NN
5180	128	31	of	of	IN
5180	128	32	minors	minor	NNS
5180	128	33	,	,	,
5180	128	34	material	material	NN
5180	128	35	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	128	36	to	to	IN
5180	128	37	minors	minor	NNS
5180	128	38	.	.	.
5180	129	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	129	2	,	,	,
5180	129	3	use	use	NN
5180	129	4	of	of	IN
5180	129	5	filters	filter	NNS
5180	129	6	also	also	RB
5180	129	7	helps	help	VBZ
5180	129	8	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	129	9	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	129	10	from	from	IN
5180	129	11	being	be	VBG
5180	129	12	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	129	13	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	129	14	to	to	IN
5180	129	15	patently	patently	RB
5180	129	16	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	129	17	,	,	,
5180	129	18	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	129	19	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	129	20	content	content	NN
5180	129	21	on	on	IN
5180	129	22	the	the	DT
5180	129	23	Internet	internet	NN
5180	129	24	.	.	.
5180	130	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	130	2	are	be	VBP
5180	130	3	sympathetic	sympathetic	JJ
5180	130	4	to	to	IN
5180	130	5	the	the	DT
5180	130	6	position	position	NN
5180	130	7	of	of	IN
5180	130	8	the	the	DT
5180	130	9	government	government	NN
5180	130	10	,	,	,
5180	130	11	believing	believe	VBG
5180	130	12	that	that	IN
5180	130	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	130	14	would	would	MD
5180	130	15	be	be	VB
5180	130	16	desirable	desirable	JJ
5180	130	17	if	if	IN
5180	130	18	there	there	EX
5180	130	19	were	be	VBD
5180	130	20	a	a	DT
5180	130	21	means	means	NN
5180	130	22	to	to	TO
5180	130	23	ensure	ensure	VB
5180	130	24	that	that	IN
5180	130	25	public	public	JJ
5180	130	26	library	library	NN
5180	130	27	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	130	28	could	could	MD
5180	130	29	share	share	VB
5180	130	30	in	in	IN
5180	130	31	the	the	DT
5180	130	32	informational	informational	JJ
5180	130	33	bonanza	bonanza	NN
5180	130	34	of	of	IN
5180	130	35	the	the	DT
5180	130	36	Internet	internet	NN
5180	130	37	while	while	IN
5180	130	38	being	be	VBG
5180	130	39	insulated	insulate	VBN
5180	130	40	from	from	IN
5180	130	41	materials	material	NNS
5180	130	42	that	that	WDT
5180	130	43	meet	meet	VBP
5180	130	44	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	130	45	's	's	POS
5180	130	46	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	130	47	,	,	,
5180	130	48	that	that	RB
5180	130	49	is	is	RB
5180	130	50	,	,	,
5180	130	51	visual	visual	JJ
5180	130	52	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	130	53	that	that	WDT
5180	130	54	are	be	VBP
5180	130	55	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	130	56	,	,	,
5180	130	57	child	child	NN
5180	130	58	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	130	59	,	,	,
5180	130	60	or	or	CC
5180	130	61	in	in	IN
5180	130	62	the	the	DT
5180	130	63	case	case	NN
5180	130	64	of	of	IN
5180	130	65	minors	minor	NNS
5180	130	66	,	,	,
5180	130	67	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	130	68	to	to	IN
5180	130	69	minors	minor	NNS
5180	130	70	.	.	.
5180	131	1	Unfortunately	unfortunately	RB
5180	131	2	this	this	DT
5180	131	3	outcome	outcome	NN
5180	131	4	,	,	,
5180	131	5	devoutly	devoutly	RB
5180	131	6	to	to	TO
5180	131	7	be	be	VB
5180	131	8	wished	wish	VBN
5180	131	9	,	,	,
5180	131	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	131	11	not	not	RB
5180	131	12	available	available	JJ
5180	131	13	in	in	IN
5180	131	14	this	this	DT
5180	131	15	less	less	JJR
5180	131	16	than	than	IN
5180	131	17	best	good	JJS
5180	131	18	of	of	IN
5180	131	19	all	all	DT
5180	131	20	possible	possible	JJ
5180	131	21	worlds	world	NNS
5180	131	22	.	.	.
5180	132	1	No	no	DT
5180	132	2	category	category	NN
5180	132	3	definition	definition	NN
5180	132	4	used	use	VBN
5180	132	5	by	by	IN
5180	132	6	the	the	DT
5180	132	7	blocking	block	VBG
5180	132	8	programs	program	NNS
5180	132	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	132	10	identical	identical	JJ
5180	132	11	to	to	IN
5180	132	12	the	the	DT
5180	132	13	legal	legal	JJ
5180	132	14	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	132	15	of	of	IN
5180	132	16	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	132	17	,	,	,
5180	132	18	child	child	NN
5180	132	19	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	132	20	,	,	,
5180	132	21	or	or	CC
5180	132	22	material	material	NN
5180	132	23	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	132	24	to	to	IN
5180	132	25	minors	minor	NNS
5180	132	26	,	,	,
5180	132	27	and	and	CC
5180	132	28	,	,	,
5180	132	29	at	at	IN
5180	132	30	all	all	DT
5180	132	31	events	event	NNS
5180	132	32	,	,	,
5180	132	33	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	132	34	programs	program	NNS
5180	132	35	fail	fail	VBP
5180	132	36	to	to	TO
5180	132	37	block	block	VB
5180	132	38	access	access	NN
5180	132	39	to	to	IN
5180	132	40	a	a	DT
5180	132	41	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	132	42	amount	amount	NN
5180	132	43	of	of	IN
5180	132	44	content	content	NN
5180	132	45	on	on	IN
5180	132	46	the	the	DT
5180	132	47	Internet	internet	NN
5180	132	48	that	that	WDT
5180	132	49	falls	fall	VBZ
5180	132	50	into	into	IN
5180	132	51	the	the	DT
5180	132	52	categories	category	NNS
5180	132	53	defined	define	VBN
5180	132	54	by	by	IN
5180	132	55	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	132	56	.	.	.
5180	133	1	As	as	IN
5180	133	2	will	will	MD
5180	133	3	appear	appear	VB
5180	133	4	,	,	,
5180	133	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	133	6	credit	credit	VBP
5180	133	7	the	the	DT
5180	133	8	testimony	testimony	NN
5180	133	9	of	of	IN
5180	133	10	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	133	11	'	'	POS
5180	133	12	expert	expert	NN
5180	133	13	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
5180	133	14	Geoffrey	Geoffrey	NNP
5180	133	15	Nunberg	Nunberg	NNP
5180	133	16	that	that	IN
5180	133	17	the	the	DT
5180	133	18	blocking	block	VBG
5180	133	19	software	software	NN
5180	133	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	133	21	(	(	-LRB-
5180	133	22	at	at	IN
5180	133	23	least	least	JJS
5180	133	24	for	for	IN
5180	133	25	the	the	DT
5180	133	26	foreseeable	foreseeable	JJ
5180	133	27	future	future	NN
5180	133	28	)	)	-RRB-
5180	133	29	incapable	incapable	JJ
5180	133	30	of	of	IN
5180	133	31	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	133	32	blocking	block	VBG
5180	133	33	the	the	DT
5180	133	34	majority	majority	NN
5180	133	35	of	of	IN
5180	133	36	materials	material	NNS
5180	133	37	in	in	IN
5180	133	38	the	the	DT
5180	133	39	categories	category	NNS
5180	133	40	defined	define	VBN
5180	133	41	by	by	IN
5180	133	42	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	133	43	without	without	IN
5180	133	44	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	133	45	a	a	DT
5180	133	46	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	133	47	amount	amount	NN
5180	133	48	of	of	IN
5180	133	49	materials	material	NNS
5180	133	50	.	.	.
5180	134	1	Nunberg	Nunberg	NNP
5180	134	2	's	's	POS
5180	134	3	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	134	4	was	be	VBD
5180	134	5	supported	support	VBN
5180	134	6	by	by	IN
5180	134	7	extensive	extensive	JJ
5180	134	8	record	record	NN
5180	134	9	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	134	10	.	.	.
5180	135	1	As	as	IN
5180	135	2	noted	note	VBN
5180	135	3	above	above	IN
5180	135	4	,	,	,
5180	135	5	this	this	DT
5180	135	6	inability	inability	NN
5180	135	7	to	to	TO
5180	135	8	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	135	9	both	both	DT
5180	135	10	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	135	11	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	135	12	of	of	IN
5180	135	13	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	135	14	and	and	CC
5180	135	15	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	135	16	stems	stem	NNS
5180	135	17	from	from	IN
5180	135	18	several	several	JJ
5180	135	19	sources	source	NNS
5180	135	20	,	,	,
5180	135	21	including	include	VBG
5180	135	22	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	135	23	on	on	IN
5180	135	24	the	the	DT
5180	135	25	technology	technology	NN
5180	135	26	that	that	IN
5180	135	27	software	software	NN
5180	135	28	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	135	29	companies	company	NNS
5180	135	30	use	use	VBP
5180	135	31	to	to	TO
5180	135	32	gather	gather	VB
5180	135	33	and	and	CC
5180	135	34	review	review	VB
5180	135	35	Web	web	NN
5180	135	36	pages	page	NNS
5180	135	37	,	,	,
5180	135	38	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	135	39	on	on	IN
5180	135	40	resources	resource	NNS
5180	135	41	for	for	IN
5180	135	42	human	human	JJ
5180	135	43	review	review	NN
5180	135	44	of	of	IN
5180	135	45	Web	web	NN
5180	135	46	pages	page	NNS
5180	135	47	,	,	,
5180	135	48	and	and	CC
5180	135	49	the	the	DT
5180	135	50	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	135	51	error	error	NN
5180	135	52	that	that	WDT
5180	135	53	results	result	VBZ
5180	135	54	from	from	IN
5180	135	55	human	human	JJ
5180	135	56	review	review	NN
5180	135	57	processes	process	NNS
5180	135	58	.	.	.
5180	136	1	Because	because	IN
5180	136	2	the	the	DT
5180	136	3	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	136	4	software	software	NN
5180	136	5	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	136	6	by	by	IN
5180	136	7	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	136	8	will	will	MD
5180	136	9	block	block	VB
5180	136	10	access	access	NN
5180	136	11	to	to	IN
5180	136	12	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	136	13	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	136	14	of	of	IN
5180	136	15	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	136	16	protected	protect	VBN
5180	136	17	speech	speech	NN
5180	136	18	whose	whose	WP$
5180	136	19	suppression	suppression	NN
5180	136	20	serves	serve	VBZ
5180	136	21	no	no	DT
5180	136	22	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	136	23	government	government	NN
5180	136	24	interest	interest	NN
5180	136	25	,	,	,
5180	136	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	136	27	are	be	VBP
5180	136	28	persuaded	persuade	VBN
5180	136	29	that	that	IN
5180	136	30	a	a	DT
5180	136	31	public	public	JJ
5180	136	32	library	library	NN
5180	136	33	's	's	POS
5180	136	34	use	use	NN
5180	136	35	of	of	IN
5180	136	36	software	software	NN
5180	136	37	filters	filter	NNS
5180	136	38	is	be	VBZ
5180	136	39	not	not	RB
5180	136	40	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	136	41	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	136	42	to	to	TO
5180	136	43	further	further	RB
5180	136	44	any	any	DT
5180	136	45	of	of	IN
5180	136	46	these	these	DT
5180	136	47	interests	interest	NNS
5180	136	48	.	.	.
5180	137	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	137	2	,	,	,
5180	137	3	less	less	RBR
5180	137	4	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	137	5	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	137	6	exist	exist	VBP
5180	137	7	that	that	IN
5180	137	8	further	further	RB
5180	137	9	the	the	DT
5180	137	10	government	government	NN
5180	137	11	's	's	POS
5180	137	12	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	137	13	interest	interest	NN
5180	137	14	in	in	IN
5180	137	15	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	137	16	the	the	DT
5180	137	17	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	137	18	of	of	IN
5180	137	19	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	137	20	,	,	,
5180	137	21	child	child	NN
5180	137	22	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	137	23	,	,	,
5180	137	24	and	and	CC
5180	137	25	material	material	NN
5180	137	26	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	137	27	to	to	IN
5180	137	28	minors	minor	NNS
5180	137	29	,	,	,
5180	137	30	and	and	CC
5180	137	31	in	in	IN
5180	137	32	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	137	33	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	137	34	from	from	IN
5180	137	35	being	be	VBG
5180	137	36	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	137	37	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	137	38	to	to	IN
5180	137	39	patently	patently	RB
5180	137	40	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	137	41	,	,	,
5180	137	42	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	137	43	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	137	44	content	content	NN
5180	137	45	.	.	.
5180	138	1	To	to	TO
5180	138	2	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	138	3	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	138	4	from	from	IN
5180	138	5	accessing	access	VBG
5180	138	6	visual	visual	JJ
5180	138	7	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	138	8	that	that	WDT
5180	138	9	are	be	VBP
5180	138	10	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	138	11	and	and	CC
5180	138	12	child	child	NN
5180	138	13	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	138	14	,	,	,
5180	138	15	public	public	JJ
5180	138	16	libraries	library	NNS
5180	138	17	may	may	MD
5180	138	18	enforce	enforce	VB
5180	138	19	Internet	internet	NN
5180	138	20	use	use	VB
5180	138	21	policies	policy	NNS
5180	138	22	that	that	WDT
5180	138	23	make	make	VBP
5180	138	24	clear	clear	JJ
5180	138	25	to	to	IN
5180	138	26	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	138	27	that	that	IN
5180	138	28	the	the	DT
5180	138	29	library	library	NN
5180	138	30	's	's	POS
5180	138	31	Internet	internet	NN
5180	138	32	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	138	33	may	may	MD
5180	138	34	not	not	RB
5180	138	35	be	be	VB
5180	138	36	used	use	VBN
5180	138	37	to	to	TO
5180	138	38	access	access	VB
5180	138	39	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	138	40	speech	speech	NN
5180	138	41	.	.	.
5180	139	1	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	139	2	may	may	MD
5180	139	3	then	then	RB
5180	139	4	impose	impose	VB
5180	139	5	penalties	penalty	NNS
5180	139	6	on	on	IN
5180	139	7	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	139	8	who	who	WP
5180	139	9	violate	violate	VBP
5180	139	10	these	these	DT
5180	139	11	policies	policy	NNS
5180	139	12	,	,	,
5180	139	13	ranging	range	VBG
5180	139	14	from	from	IN
5180	139	15	a	a	DT
5180	139	16	warning	warning	NN
5180	139	17	to	to	IN
5180	139	18	notification	notification	NN
5180	139	19	of	of	IN
5180	139	20	law	law	NN
5180	139	21	enforcement	enforcement	NN
5180	139	22	,	,	,
5180	139	23	in	in	IN
5180	139	24	the	the	DT
5180	139	25	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	139	26	case	case	NN
5180	139	27	.	.	.
5180	140	1	Less	less	RBR
5180	140	2	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	140	3	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	140	4	to	to	IN
5180	140	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	140	6	that	that	IN
5180	140	7	further	further	JJ
5180	140	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	140	9	'	'	POS
5180	140	10	interest	interest	NN
5180	140	11	in	in	IN
5180	140	12	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	140	13	minors	minor	NNS
5180	140	14	from	from	IN
5180	140	15	exposure	exposure	NN
5180	140	16	to	to	IN
5180	140	17	visual	visual	JJ
5180	140	18	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	140	19	that	that	WDT
5180	140	20	are	be	VBP
5180	140	21	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	140	22	to	to	IN
5180	140	23	minors	minor	NNS
5180	140	24	include	include	VBP
5180	140	25	requiring	require	VBG
5180	140	26	parental	parental	JJ
5180	140	27	consent	consent	NN
5180	140	28	to	to	IN
5180	140	29	or	or	CC
5180	140	30	presence	presence	NN
5180	140	31	during	during	IN
5180	140	32	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	140	33	access	access	NN
5180	140	34	,	,	,
5180	140	35	or	or	CC
5180	140	36	restricting	restrict	VBG
5180	140	37	minors	minor	NNS
5180	140	38	'	'	POS
5180	140	39	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	140	40	access	access	NN
5180	140	41	to	to	IN
5180	140	42	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	140	43	within	within	IN
5180	140	44	view	view	NN
5180	140	45	of	of	IN
5180	140	46	library	library	NN
5180	140	47	staff	staff	NN
5180	140	48	.	.	.
5180	141	1	Finally	finally	RB
5180	141	2	,	,	,
5180	141	3	optional	optional	JJ
5180	141	4	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	141	5	,	,	,
5180	141	6	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	141	7	screens	screen	NNS
5180	141	8	,	,	,
5180	141	9	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	141	10	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	141	11	,	,	,
5180	141	12	and	and	CC
5180	141	13	placement	placement	NN
5180	141	14	of	of	IN
5180	141	15	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	141	16	Internet	internet	NN
5180	141	17	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	141	18	outside	outside	RB
5180	141	19	of	of	IN
5180	141	20	sight-	sight-	JJ
5180	141	21	lines	line	NNS
5180	141	22	provide	provide	VBP
5180	141	23	less	less	RBR
5180	141	24	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	141	25	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	141	26	for	for	IN
5180	141	27	libraries	library	NNS
5180	141	28	to	to	TO
5180	141	29	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	141	30	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	141	31	from	from	IN
5180	141	32	being	be	VBG
5180	141	33	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	141	34	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	141	35	to	to	IN
5180	141	36	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	141	37	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	141	38	content	content	NN
5180	141	39	on	on	IN
5180	141	40	the	the	DT
5180	141	41	Internet	internet	NN
5180	141	42	.	.	.
5180	142	1	In	in	IN
5180	142	2	an	an	DT
5180	142	3	effort	effort	NN
5180	142	4	to	to	TO
5180	142	5	avoid	avoid	VB
5180	142	6	the	the	DT
5180	142	7	potentially	potentially	RB
5180	142	8	fatal	fatal	JJ
5180	142	9	legal	legal	JJ
5180	142	10	implications	implication	NNS
5180	142	11	of	of	IN
5180	142	12	the	the	DT
5180	142	13	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	142	14	problem	problem	NN
5180	142	15	,	,	,
5180	142	16	the	the	DT
5180	142	17	government	government	NN
5180	142	18	falls	fall	VBZ
5180	142	19	back	back	RB
5180	142	20	on	on	IN
5180	142	21	the	the	DT
5180	142	22	ability	ability	NN
5180	142	23	of	of	IN
5180	142	24	the	the	DT
5180	142	25	libraries	library	NNS
5180	142	26	,	,	,
5180	142	27	under	under	IN
5180	142	28	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	142	29	's	's	POS
5180	142	30	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	142	31	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	142	32	,	,	,
5180	142	33	see	see	VB
5180	142	34	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	142	35	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	142	36	.	.	.
5180	143	1	1712	1712	CD
5180	143	2	(	(	-LRB-
5180	143	3	codified	codify	VBN
5180	143	4	at	at	IN
5180	143	5	20	20	CD
5180	143	6	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	144	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	144	2	.	.	.
5180	145	1	9134(f)(3	9134(f)(3	LS
5180	145	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	145	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	145	4	,	,	,
5180	145	5	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	145	6	Sec.1721(b	Sec.1721(b	NNP
5180	145	7	)	)	-RRB-
5180	145	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	145	9	codified	codify	VBN
5180	145	10	at	at	IN
5180	145	11	47	47	CD
5180	145	12	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	146	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	146	2	.	.	.
5180	147	1	254(h)(6)(D	254(h)(6)(d	LS
5180	147	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	147	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	147	4	,	,	,
5180	147	5	to	to	TO
5180	147	6	unblock	unblock	VB
5180	147	7	a	a	DT
5180	147	8	site	site	NN
5180	147	9	that	that	WDT
5180	147	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	147	11	patently	patently	RB
5180	147	12	proper	proper	JJ
5180	147	13	yet	yet	RB
5180	147	14	improperly	improperly	RB
5180	147	15	blocked	block	VBN
5180	147	16	.	.	.
5180	148	1	The	the	DT
5180	148	2	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	148	3	reflects	reflect	VBZ
5180	148	4	that	that	IN
5180	148	5	libraries	library	NNS
5180	148	6	can	can	MD
5180	148	7	and	and	CC
5180	148	8	do	do	VB
5180	148	9	unblock	unblock	VB
5180	148	10	the	the	DT
5180	148	11	filters	filter	NNS
5180	148	12	when	when	WRB
5180	148	13	a	a	DT
5180	148	14	patron	patron	NN
5180	148	15	so	so	RB
5180	148	16	requests	request	VBZ
5180	148	17	.	.	.
5180	149	1	But	but	CC
5180	149	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	149	3	also	also	RB
5180	149	4	reflects	reflect	VBZ
5180	149	5	that	that	IN
5180	149	6	requiring	require	VBG
5180	149	7	library	library	NN
5180	149	8	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	149	9	to	to	TO
5180	149	10	ask	ask	VB
5180	149	11	for	for	IN
5180	149	12	a	a	DT
5180	149	13	Web	web	NN
5180	149	14	site	site	NN
5180	149	15	to	to	TO
5180	149	16	be	be	VB
5180	149	17	unblocked	unblocked	JJ
5180	149	18	will	will	MD
5180	149	19	deter	deter	VB
5180	149	20	many	many	JJ
5180	149	21	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	149	22	because	because	IN
5180	149	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	149	24	are	be	VBP
5180	149	25	embarrassed	embarrassed	JJ
5180	149	26	,	,	,
5180	149	27	or	or	CC
5180	149	28	desire	desire	NN
5180	149	29	to	to	TO
5180	149	30	protect	protect	VB
5180	149	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	149	32	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	149	33	or	or	CC
5180	149	34	remain	remain	VB
5180	149	35	anonymous	anonymous	JJ
5180	149	36	.	.	.
5180	150	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	150	2	,	,	,
5180	150	3	the	the	DT
5180	150	4	unblocking	unblocking	NN
5180	150	5	may	may	MD
5180	150	6	take	take	VB
5180	150	7	days	day	NNS
5180	150	8	,	,	,
5180	150	9	and	and	CC
5180	150	10	may	may	MD
5180	150	11	be	be	VB
5180	150	12	unavailable	unavailable	JJ
5180	150	13	,	,	,
5180	150	14	especially	especially	RB
5180	150	15	in	in	IN
5180	150	16	branch	branch	NN
5180	150	17	libraries	library	NNS
5180	150	18	,	,	,
5180	150	19	which	which	WDT
5180	150	20	are	be	VBP
5180	150	21	often	often	RB
5180	150	22	less	less	RBR
5180	150	23	well	well	RB
5180	150	24	staffed	staff	VBN
5180	150	25	than	than	IN
5180	150	26	main	main	JJ
5180	150	27	libraries	library	NNS
5180	150	28	.	.	.
5180	151	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
5180	151	2	,	,	,
5180	151	3	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	151	4	's	's	POS
5180	151	5	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	151	6	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	151	7	do	do	VBP
5180	151	8	not	not	RB
5180	151	9	cure	cure	VB
5180	151	10	the	the	DT
5180	151	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	151	12	deficiencies	deficiency	NNS
5180	151	13	in	in	IN
5180	151	14	public	public	JJ
5180	151	15	libraries	library	NNS
5180	151	16	'	'	POS
5180	151	17	use	use	NN
5180	151	18	of	of	IN
5180	151	19	Internet	internet	NN
5180	151	20	filters	filter	NNS
5180	151	21	.	.	.
5180	152	1	Under	under	IN
5180	152	2	these	these	DT
5180	152	3	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
5180	152	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	152	5	are	be	VBP
5180	152	6	constrained	constrain	VBN
5180	152	7	to	to	TO
5180	152	8	conclude	conclude	VB
5180	152	9	that	that	IN
5180	152	10	the	the	DT
5180	152	11	library	library	NN
5180	152	12	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	152	13	must	must	MD
5180	152	14	prevail	prevail	VB
5180	152	15	in	in	IN
5180	152	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	152	17	contention	contention	NN
5180	152	18	that	that	IN
5180	152	19	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	152	20	requires	require	VBZ
5180	152	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	152	22	to	to	TO
5180	152	23	violate	violate	VB
5180	152	24	the	the	DT
5180	152	25	First	First	NNP
5180	152	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	152	27	rights	right	NNS
5180	152	28	of	of	IN
5180	152	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	152	30	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	152	31	,	,	,
5180	152	32	and	and	CC
5180	152	33	accordingly	accordingly	RB
5180	152	34	is	be	VBZ
5180	152	35	facially	facially	RB
5180	152	36	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	152	37	,	,	,
5180	152	38	even	even	RB
5180	152	39	under	under	IN
5180	152	40	the	the	DT
5180	152	41	standard	standard	NN
5180	152	42	urged	urge	VBN
5180	152	43	on	on	IN
5180	152	44	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	152	45	by	by	IN
5180	152	46	the	the	DT
5180	152	47	government	government	NN
5180	152	48	,	,	,
5180	152	49	which	which	WDT
5180	152	50	would	would	MD
5180	152	51	permit	permit	VB
5180	152	52	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	152	53	to	to	IN
5180	152	54	facially	facially	RB
5180	152	55	invalidate	invalidate	VB
5180	152	56	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	152	57	only	only	RB
5180	152	58	if	if	IN
5180	152	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	152	60	is	be	VBZ
5180	152	61	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	152	62	for	for	IN
5180	152	63	a	a	DT
5180	152	64	single	single	JJ
5180	152	65	public	public	JJ
5180	152	66	library	library	NN
5180	152	67	to	to	TO
5180	152	68	comply	comply	VB
5180	152	69	with	with	IN
5180	152	70	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	152	71	's	's	POS
5180	152	72	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	152	73	without	without	IN
5180	152	74	violating	violate	VBG
5180	152	75	the	the	DT
5180	152	76	First	First	NNP
5180	152	77	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	152	78	.	.	.
5180	153	1	In	in	IN
5180	153	2	view	view	NN
5180	153	3	of	of	IN
5180	153	4	the	the	DT
5180	153	5	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	153	6	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	153	7	in	in	IN
5180	153	8	the	the	DT
5180	153	9	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	153	10	technology	technology	NN
5180	153	11	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	153	12	by	by	IN
5180	153	13	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	153	14	,	,	,
5180	153	15	any	any	DT
5180	153	16	public	public	JJ
5180	153	17	library	library	NN
5180	153	18	that	that	WDT
5180	153	19	adheres	adhere	VBZ
5180	153	20	to	to	IN
5180	153	21	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	153	22	's	's	POS
5180	153	23	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	153	24	will	will	MD
5180	153	25	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	153	26	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	153	27	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	153	28	'	'	POS
5180	153	29	access	access	NN
5180	153	30	to	to	IN
5180	153	31	a	a	DT
5180	153	32	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	153	33	amount	amount	NN
5180	153	34	of	of	IN
5180	153	35	protected	protect	VBN
5180	153	36	speech	speech	NN
5180	153	37	,	,	,
5180	153	38	in	in	IN
5180	153	39	violation	violation	NN
5180	153	40	of	of	IN
5180	153	41	the	the	DT
5180	153	42	First	First	NNP
5180	153	43	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	153	44	.	.	.
5180	154	1	Given	give	VBN
5180	154	2	this	this	DT
5180	154	3	conclusion	conclusion	NN
5180	154	4	,	,	,
5180	154	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	154	6	need	need	VBP
5180	154	7	not	not	RB
5180	154	8	reach	reach	VB
5180	154	9	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	154	10	'	'	POS
5180	154	11	arguments	argument	NNS
5180	154	12	that	that	IN
5180	154	13	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	154	14	effects	effect	VBZ
5180	154	15	a	a	DT
5180	154	16	prior	prior	JJ
5180	154	17	restraint	restraint	NN
5180	154	18	on	on	IN
5180	154	19	speech	speech	NN
5180	154	20	and	and	CC
5180	154	21	is	be	VBZ
5180	154	22	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
5180	154	23	vague	vague	JJ
5180	154	24	.	.	.
5180	155	1	Nor	nor	CC
5180	155	2	do	do	VBP
5180	155	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	155	4	decide	decide	VB
5180	155	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	155	6	cognate	cognate	VB
5180	155	7	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	155	8	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	155	9	theory	theory	NN
5180	155	10	,	,	,
5180	155	11	though	though	IN
5180	155	12	for	for	IN
5180	155	13	reasons	reason	NNS
5180	155	14	explained	explain	VBD
5180	155	15	infra	infra	NN
5180	155	16	at	at	IN
5180	155	17	note	note	NN
5180	155	18	36	36	CD
5180	155	19	,	,	,
5180	155	20	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	155	21	discuss	discuss	VBP
5180	155	22	the	the	DT
5180	155	23	issues	issue	NNS
5180	155	24	raised	raise	VBN
5180	155	25	by	by	IN
5180	155	26	that	that	DT
5180	155	27	claim	claim	NN
5180	155	28	at	at	IN
5180	155	29	some	some	DT
5180	155	30	length	length	NN
5180	155	31	.	.	.
5180	156	1	For	for	IN
5180	156	2	these	these	DT
5180	156	3	reasons	reason	NNS
5180	156	4	,	,	,
5180	156	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	156	6	will	will	MD
5180	156	7	enter	enter	VB
5180	156	8	an	an	DT
5180	156	9	Order	order	NN
5180	156	10	declaring	declare	VBG
5180	156	11	Sections	section	NNS
5180	156	12	1712(a)(2	1712(a)(2	CD
5180	156	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	156	14	and	and	CC
5180	156	15	1721(b	1721(b	CD
5180	156	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	156	17	of	of	IN
5180	156	18	the	the	DT
5180	156	19	Children	Children	NNPS
5180	156	20	's	's	POS
5180	156	21	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	156	22	Protection	Protection	NNP
5180	156	23	Act	Act	NNP
5180	156	24	,	,	,
5180	156	25	codified	codify	VBD
5180	156	26	at	at	IN
5180	156	27	20	20	CD
5180	156	28	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	157	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	157	2	.	.	.
5180	158	1	9134(f	9134(f	LS
5180	158	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	158	3	and	and	CC
5180	158	4	47	47	CD
5180	158	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	159	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	159	2	.	.	.
5180	160	1	254(h)(6	254(h)(6	LS
5180	160	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	160	3	,	,	,
5180	160	4	respectively	respectively	RB
5180	160	5	,	,	,
5180	160	6	to	to	TO
5180	160	7	be	be	VB
5180	160	8	facially	facially	RB
5180	160	9	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	160	10	under	under	IN
5180	160	11	the	the	DT
5180	160	12	First	First	NNP
5180	160	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	160	14	and	and	CC
5180	160	15	permanently	permanently	RB
5180	160	16	enjoining	enjoin	VBG
5180	160	17	the	the	DT
5180	160	18	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	160	19	from	from	IN
5180	160	20	enforcing	enforce	VBG
5180	160	21	those	those	DT
5180	160	22	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	160	23	.	.	.
5180	160	24	II	ii	CD
5180	160	25	.	.	.
5180	161	1	Findings	finding	NNS
5180	161	2	of	of	IN
5180	161	3	Fact	Fact	NNP
5180	161	4	1	1	CD
5180	161	5	.	.	.
5180	162	1	Statutory	Statutory	NNP
5180	162	2	Framework	Framework	NNP
5180	162	3	1	1	CD
5180	162	4	.	.	.
5180	163	1	Nature	nature	NN
5180	163	2	and	and	CC
5180	163	3	Operation	operation	NN
5180	163	4	of	of	IN
5180	163	5	the	the	DT
5180	163	6	E	e	NN
5180	163	7	-	-	NN
5180	163	8	rate	rate	NN
5180	163	9	and	and	CC
5180	163	10	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	163	11	Programs	Programs	NNPS
5180	163	12	In	in	IN
5180	163	13	the	the	DT
5180	163	14	Telecommunications	Telecommunications	NNPS
5180	163	15	Act	Act	NNP
5180	163	16	of	of	IN
5180	163	17	1996	1996	CD
5180	163	18	(	(	-LRB-
5180	163	19	"	"	``
5180	163	20	1996	1996	CD
5180	163	21	Act	Act	NNP
5180	163	22	"	"	''
5180	163	23	)	)	-RRB-
5180	163	24	,	,	,
5180	163	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	163	26	directed	direct	VBD
5180	163	27	the	the	DT
5180	163	28	Federal	Federal	NNP
5180	163	29	Communications	Communications	NNPS
5180	163	30	Commission	Commission	NNP
5180	163	31	(	(	-LRB-
5180	163	32	"	"	``
5180	163	33	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	163	34	"	"	''
5180	163	35	)	)	-RRB-
5180	163	36	to	to	TO
5180	163	37	take	take	VB
5180	163	38	the	the	DT
5180	163	39	steps	step	NNS
5180	163	40	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	163	41	to	to	TO
5180	163	42	establish	establish	VB
5180	163	43	a	a	DT
5180	163	44	system	system	NN
5180	163	45	of	of	IN
5180	163	46	support	support	NN
5180	163	47	mechanisms	mechanism	NNS
5180	163	48	to	to	TO
5180	163	49	ensure	ensure	VB
5180	163	50	the	the	DT
5180	163	51	delivery	delivery	NN
5180	163	52	of	of	IN
5180	163	53	affordable	affordable	JJ
5180	163	54	telecommunications	telecommunication	NNS
5180	163	55	service	service	NN
5180	163	56	to	to	IN
5180	163	57	all	all	DT
5180	163	58	Americans	Americans	NNPS
5180	163	59	.	.	.
5180	164	1	This	this	DT
5180	164	2	system	system	NN
5180	164	3	,	,	,
5180	164	4	referred	refer	VBD
5180	164	5	to	to	IN
5180	164	6	as	as	IN
5180	164	7	"	"	``
5180	164	8	universal	universal	JJ
5180	164	9	service	service	NN
5180	164	10	,	,	,
5180	164	11	"	"	''
5180	164	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	164	13	codified	codify	VBN
5180	164	14	in	in	IN
5180	164	15	section	section	NN
5180	164	16	254	254	CD
5180	164	17	of	of	IN
5180	164	18	the	the	DT
5180	164	19	Communications	Communications	NNPS
5180	164	20	Act	Act	NNP
5180	164	21	of	of	IN
5180	164	22	1934	1934	CD
5180	164	23	,	,	,
5180	164	24	as	as	IN
5180	164	25	amended	amend	VBN
5180	164	26	by	by	IN
5180	164	27	the	the	DT
5180	164	28	1996	1996	CD
5180	164	29	Act	Act	NNP
5180	164	30	.	.	.
5180	165	1	See	see	VB
5180	165	2	47	47	CD
5180	165	3	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	166	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	166	2	.	.	.
5180	167	1	254	254	CD
5180	167	2	.	.	.
5180	168	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	168	2	specified	specify	VBD
5180	168	3	several	several	JJ
5180	168	4	groups	group	NNS
5180	168	5	as	as	IN
5180	168	6	beneficiaries	beneficiary	NNS
5180	168	7	of	of	IN
5180	168	8	the	the	DT
5180	168	9	universal	universal	JJ
5180	168	10	service	service	NN
5180	168	11	support	support	NN
5180	168	12	mechanism	mechanism	NN
5180	168	13	,	,	,
5180	168	14	including	include	VBG
5180	168	15	consumers	consumer	NNS
5180	168	16	in	in	IN
5180	168	17	high	high	JJ
5180	168	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	168	19	cost	cost	NN
5180	168	20	areas	area	NNS
5180	168	21	,	,	,
5180	168	22	low	low	JJ
5180	168	23	-	-	HYPH
5180	168	24	income	income	NN
5180	168	25	consumers	consumer	NNS
5180	168	26	,	,	,
5180	168	27	schools	school	NNS
5180	168	28	and	and	CC
5180	168	29	libraries	library	NNS
5180	168	30	,	,	,
5180	168	31	and	and	CC
5180	168	32	rural	rural	JJ
5180	168	33	health	health	NN
5180	168	34	care	care	NN
5180	168	35	providers	provider	NNS
5180	168	36	.	.	.
5180	169	1	See	see	VB
5180	169	2	47	47	CD
5180	169	3	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	170	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	170	2	.	.	.
5180	171	1	254(h)(1	254(h)(1	NNP
5180	171	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	171	3	.	.	.
5180	172	1	The	the	DT
5180	172	2	extension	extension	NN
5180	172	3	of	of	IN
5180	172	4	universal	universal	JJ
5180	172	5	service	service	NN
5180	172	6	to	to	IN
5180	172	7	schools	school	NNS
5180	172	8	and	and	CC
5180	172	9	libraries	library	NNS
5180	172	10	in	in	IN
5180	172	11	section	section	NN
5180	172	12	254(h	254(h	CD
5180	172	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	172	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	172	15	commonly	commonly	RB
5180	172	16	referred	refer	VBN
5180	172	17	to	to	IN
5180	172	18	as	as	IN
5180	172	19	the	the	DT
5180	172	20	Schools	Schools	NNPS
5180	172	21	and	and	CC
5180	172	22	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	172	23	Program	Program	NNP
5180	172	24	,	,	,
5180	172	25	or	or	CC
5180	172	26	"	"	``
5180	172	27	E	e	NN
5180	172	28	-	-	NN
5180	172	29	rate	rate	NN
5180	172	30	"	"	''
5180	172	31	Program	program	NN
5180	172	32	.	.	.
5180	173	1	Under	under	IN
5180	173	2	the	the	DT
5180	173	3	E	e	JJ
5180	173	4	-	-	NN
5180	173	5	rate	rate	NN
5180	173	6	Program	program	NN
5180	173	7	,	,	,
5180	173	8	"	"	''
5180	173	9	[	[	-LRB-
5180	173	10	a]ll	a]ll	NN
5180	173	11	telecommunications	telecommunications	NN
5180	173	12	carriers	carrier	NNS
5180	173	13	serving	serve	VBG
5180	173	14	a	a	DT
5180	173	15	geographic	geographic	JJ
5180	173	16	area	area	NN
5180	173	17	shall	shall	MD
5180	173	18	,	,	,
5180	173	19	upon	upon	IN
5180	173	20	a	a	DT
5180	173	21	bona	bona	JJ
5180	173	22	fide	fide	JJ
5180	173	23	request	request	NN
5180	173	24	for	for	IN
5180	173	25	any	any	DT
5180	173	26	of	of	IN
5180	173	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	173	28	services	service	NNS
5180	173	29	that	that	WDT
5180	173	30	are	be	VBP
5180	173	31	within	within	IN
5180	173	32	the	the	DT
5180	173	33	definition	definition	NN
5180	173	34	of	of	IN
5180	173	35	universal	universal	JJ
5180	173	36	service	service	NN
5180	173	37	.	.	.
5180	174	1	.	.	.
5180	175	1	.	.	.
5180	175	2	,	,	,
5180	175	3	provide	provide	VB
5180	175	4	such	such	JJ
5180	175	5	services	service	NNS
5180	175	6	to	to	IN
5180	175	7	elementary	elementary	JJ
5180	175	8	schools	school	NNS
5180	175	9	,	,	,
5180	175	10	secondary	secondary	JJ
5180	175	11	schools	school	NNS
5180	175	12	,	,	,
5180	175	13	and	and	CC
5180	175	14	libraries	library	NNS
5180	175	15	for	for	IN
5180	175	16	educational	educational	JJ
5180	175	17	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	175	18	at	at	IN
5180	175	19	rates	rate	NNS
5180	175	20	less	less	JJR
5180	175	21	than	than	IN
5180	175	22	the	the	DT
5180	175	23	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	175	24	charged	charge	VBN
5180	175	25	for	for	IN
5180	175	26	similar	similar	JJ
5180	175	27	services	service	NNS
5180	175	28	to	to	IN
5180	175	29	other	other	JJ
5180	175	30	parties	party	NNS
5180	175	31	.	.	.
5180	175	32	"	"	''
5180	176	1	47	47	CD
5180	176	2	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	177	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	177	2	.	.	.
5180	178	1	254(h)(1)(B	254(h)(1)(b	CD
5180	178	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	178	3	.	.	.
5180	179	1	Under	under	IN
5180	179	2	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	179	3	regulations	regulation	NNS
5180	179	4	,	,	,
5180	179	5	providers	provider	NNS
5180	179	6	of	of	IN
5180	179	7	"	"	``
5180	179	8	interstate	interstate	JJ
5180	179	9	telecommunications	telecommunication	NNS
5180	179	10	"	"	''
5180	179	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	179	12	with	with	IN
5180	179	13	certain	certain	JJ
5180	179	14	exceptions	exception	NNS
5180	179	15	,	,	,
5180	179	16	see	see	VB
5180	179	17	47	47	CD
5180	179	18	C.F.R.	C.F.R.	NNS
5180	180	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	180	2	.	.	.
5180	181	1	54.706(d	54.706(d	LS
5180	181	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	181	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	181	4	,	,	,
5180	181	5	must	must	MD
5180	181	6	contribute	contribute	VB
5180	181	7	a	a	DT
5180	181	8	portion	portion	NN
5180	181	9	of	of	IN
5180	181	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	181	11	revenue	revenue	NN
5180	181	12	for	for	IN
5180	181	13	disbursement	disbursement	NN
5180	181	14	among	among	IN
5180	181	15	eligible	eligible	JJ
5180	181	16	carriers	carrier	NNS
5180	181	17	that	that	WDT
5180	181	18	are	be	VBP
5180	181	19	providing	provide	VBG
5180	181	20	services	service	NNS
5180	181	21	to	to	IN
5180	181	22	those	those	DT
5180	181	23	groups	group	NNS
5180	181	24	or	or	CC
5180	181	25	areas	area	NNS
5180	181	26	specified	specify	VBN
5180	181	27	by	by	IN
5180	181	28	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	181	29	in	in	IN
5180	181	30	section	section	NN
5180	181	31	254	254	CD
5180	181	32	.	.	.
5180	182	1	To	to	TO
5180	182	2	be	be	VB
5180	182	3	eligible	eligible	JJ
5180	182	4	for	for	IN
5180	182	5	the	the	DT
5180	182	6	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	182	7	,	,	,
5180	182	8	a	a	DT
5180	182	9	library	library	NN
5180	182	10	must	must	MD
5180	182	11	:	:	:
5180	182	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	182	13	1	1	LS
5180	182	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	182	15	be	be	VB
5180	182	16	eligible	eligible	JJ
5180	182	17	for	for	IN
5180	182	18	assistance	assistance	NN
5180	182	19	from	from	IN
5180	182	20	a	a	DT
5180	182	21	State	State	NNP
5180	182	22	library	library	NN
5180	182	23	administrative	administrative	JJ
5180	182	24	agency	agency	NN
5180	182	25	under	under	IN
5180	182	26	the	the	DT
5180	182	27	Library	Library	NNP
5180	182	28	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	182	29	and	and	CC
5180	182	30	Technology	Technology	NNP
5180	182	31	Act	Act	NNP
5180	182	32	,	,	,
5180	182	33	see	see	VB
5180	182	34	infra	infra	FW
5180	182	35	;	;	:
5180	182	36	(	(	-LRB-
5180	182	37	2	2	LS
5180	182	38	)	)	-RRB-
5180	182	39	be	be	VB
5180	182	40	funded	fund	VBN
5180	182	41	as	as	IN
5180	182	42	an	an	DT
5180	182	43	independent	independent	JJ
5180	182	44	entity	entity	NN
5180	182	45	,	,	,
5180	182	46	completely	completely	RB
5180	182	47	separate	separate	JJ
5180	182	48	from	from	IN
5180	182	49	any	any	DT
5180	182	50	schools	school	NNS
5180	182	51	;	;	:
5180	182	52	and	and	CC
5180	182	53	(	(	-LRB-
5180	182	54	3	3	LS
5180	182	55	)	)	-RRB-
5180	182	56	not	not	RB
5180	182	57	be	be	VB
5180	182	58	operating	operate	VBG
5180	182	59	as	as	IN
5180	182	60	a	a	DT
5180	182	61	for	for	IN
5180	182	62	-	-	HYPH
5180	182	63	profit	profit	NN
5180	182	64	business	business	NN
5180	182	65	.	.	.
5180	183	1	See	see	VB
5180	183	2	47	47	CD
5180	183	3	C.F.R.	C.F.R.	NNS
5180	184	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	184	2	.	.	.
5180	185	1	54.501(c	54.501(c	LS
5180	185	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	185	3	.	.	.
5180	186	1	Discounts	discount	NNS
5180	186	2	on	on	IN
5180	186	3	services	service	NNS
5180	186	4	for	for	IN
5180	186	5	eligible	eligible	JJ
5180	186	6	libraries	library	NNS
5180	186	7	are	be	VBP
5180	186	8	set	set	VBN
5180	186	9	as	as	IN
5180	186	10	a	a	DT
5180	186	11	percentage	percentage	NN
5180	186	12	of	of	IN
5180	186	13	the	the	DT
5180	186	14	pre	pre	JJ
5180	186	15	-	-	JJ
5180	186	16	discount	discount	JJ
5180	186	17	price	price	NN
5180	186	18	,	,	,
5180	186	19	and	and	CC
5180	186	20	range	range	VB
5180	186	21	from	from	IN
5180	186	22	20	20	CD
5180	186	23	%	%	NN
5180	186	24	to	to	TO
5180	186	25	90	90	CD
5180	186	26	%	%	NN
5180	186	27	,	,	,
5180	186	28	depending	depend	VBG
5180	186	29	on	on	IN
5180	186	30	a	a	DT
5180	186	31	library	library	NN
5180	186	32	's	's	POS
5180	186	33	level	level	NN
5180	186	34	of	of	IN
5180	186	35	economic	economic	JJ
5180	186	36	disadvantage	disadvantage	NN
5180	186	37	and	and	CC
5180	186	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	186	39	location	location	NN
5180	186	40	in	in	IN
5180	186	41	an	an	DT
5180	186	42	urban	urban	JJ
5180	186	43	or	or	CC
5180	186	44	rural	rural	JJ
5180	186	45	area	area	NN
5180	186	46	.	.	.
5180	187	1	See	see	VB
5180	187	2	47	47	CD
5180	187	3	C.F.R.	C.F.R.	NNS
5180	188	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	188	2	.	.	.
5180	189	1	54.505	54.505	CD
5180	189	2	.	.	.
5180	190	1	Currently	currently	RB
5180	190	2	,	,	,
5180	190	3	a	a	DT
5180	190	4	library	library	NN
5180	190	5	's	's	POS
5180	190	6	level	level	NN
5180	190	7	of	of	IN
5180	190	8	economic	economic	JJ
5180	190	9	disadvantage	disadvantage	NN
5180	190	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	190	11	based	base	VBN
5180	190	12	on	on	IN
5180	190	13	the	the	DT
5180	190	14	percentage	percentage	NN
5180	190	15	of	of	IN
5180	190	16	students	student	NNS
5180	190	17	eligible	eligible	JJ
5180	190	18	for	for	IN
5180	190	19	the	the	DT
5180	190	20	national	national	NNP
5180	190	21	school	school	NNP
5180	190	22	lunch	lunch	NN
5180	190	23	program	program	NN
5180	190	24	in	in	IN
5180	190	25	the	the	DT
5180	190	26	school	school	NN
5180	190	27	district	district	NN
5180	190	28	in	in	IN
5180	190	29	which	which	WDT
5180	190	30	the	the	DT
5180	190	31	library	library	NN
5180	190	32	is	be	VBZ
5180	190	33	located	locate	VBN
5180	190	34	.	.	.
5180	191	1	The	the	DT
5180	191	2	Library	Library	NNP
5180	191	3	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	191	4	and	and	CC
5180	191	5	Technology	Technology	NNP
5180	191	6	Act	Act	NNP
5180	191	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	191	8	"	"	``
5180	191	9	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	191	10	"	"	''
5180	191	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	191	12	,	,	,
5180	191	13	Subchapter	Subchapter	NNP
5180	191	14	II	II	NNP
5180	191	15	of	of	IN
5180	191	16	the	the	DT
5180	191	17	Museum	Museum	NNP
5180	191	18	and	and	CC
5180	191	19	Library	Library	NNP
5180	191	20	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	191	21	Act	Act	NNP
5180	191	22	,	,	,
5180	191	23	20	20	CD
5180	191	24	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	192	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	192	2	.	.	.
5180	193	1	9101	9101	CD
5180	193	2	et	et	NNP
5180	193	3	seq	seq	NN
5180	193	4	.	.	.
5180	193	5	,	,	,
5180	193	6	was	be	VBD
5180	193	7	enacted	enact	VBN
5180	193	8	by	by	IN
5180	193	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	193	10	in	in	IN
5180	193	11	1996	1996	CD
5180	193	12	as	as	IN
5180	193	13	part	part	NN
5180	193	14	of	of	IN
5180	193	15	the	the	DT
5180	193	16	Omnibus	Omnibus	NNP
5180	193	17	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
5180	193	18	Appropriations	Appropriations	NNP
5180	193	19	Act	Act	NNP
5180	193	20	of	of	IN
5180	193	21	1997	1997	CD
5180	193	22	,	,	,
5180	193	23	Pub	Pub	NNP
5180	193	24	.	.	.
5180	194	1	L.	L.	NNP
5180	194	2	No	no	UH
5180	194	3	.	.	.
5180	195	1	104	104	CD
5180	195	2	-	-	SYM
5180	195	3	208	208	CD
5180	195	4	.	.	.
5180	196	1	The	the	DT
5180	196	2	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	196	3	establishes	establish	VBZ
5180	196	4	three	three	CD
5180	196	5	grant	grant	NN
5180	196	6	programs	program	NNS
5180	196	7	to	to	TO
5180	196	8	achieve	achieve	VB
5180	196	9	the	the	DT
5180	196	10	goal	goal	NN
5180	196	11	of	of	IN
5180	196	12	improving	improve	VBG
5180	196	13	library	library	NN
5180	196	14	services	service	NNS
5180	196	15	across	across	IN
5180	196	16	the	the	DT
5180	196	17	nation	nation	NN
5180	196	18	.	.	.
5180	197	1	Under	under	IN
5180	197	2	the	the	DT
5180	197	3	Grants	Grants	NNPS
5180	197	4	to	to	IN
5180	197	5	States	States	NNP
5180	197	6	Program	Program	NNP
5180	197	7	,	,	,
5180	197	8	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	197	9	grant	grant	NN
5180	197	10	funds	fund	NNS
5180	197	11	are	be	VBP
5180	197	12	awarded	award	VBN
5180	197	13	,	,	,
5180	197	14	inter	inter	NNP
5180	197	15	alia	alia	NNP
5180	197	16	,	,	,
5180	197	17	in	in	IN
5180	197	18	order	order	NN
5180	197	19	to	to	TO
5180	197	20	assist	assist	VB
5180	197	21	libraries	library	NNS
5180	197	22	in	in	IN
5180	197	23	accessing	access	VBG
5180	197	24	information	information	NN
5180	197	25	through	through	IN
5180	197	26	electronic	electronic	JJ
5180	197	27	networks	network	NNS
5180	197	28	and	and	CC
5180	197	29	pay	pay	VB
5180	197	30	for	for	IN
5180	197	31	the	the	DT
5180	197	32	costs	cost	NNS
5180	197	33	of	of	IN
5180	197	34	acquiring	acquire	VBG
5180	197	35	or	or	CC
5180	197	36	sharing	share	VBG
5180	197	37	computer	computer	NN
5180	197	38	systems	system	NNS
5180	197	39	and	and	CC
5180	197	40	telecommunications	telecommunication	NNS
5180	197	41	technologies	technology	NNS
5180	197	42	.	.	.
5180	198	1	See	see	VB
5180	198	2	20	20	CD
5180	198	3	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	199	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	199	2	.	.	.
5180	200	1	9141(a	9141(a	LS
5180	200	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	200	3	.	.	.
5180	201	1	Through	through	IN
5180	201	2	the	the	DT
5180	201	3	Grants	Grants	NNPS
5180	201	4	to	to	IN
5180	201	5	States	States	NNP
5180	201	6	program	program	NN
5180	201	7	,	,	,
5180	201	8	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	201	9	funds	fund	NNS
5180	201	10	have	have	VBP
5180	201	11	been	be	VBN
5180	201	12	used	use	VBN
5180	201	13	to	to	TO
5180	201	14	acquire	acquire	VB
5180	201	15	and	and	CC
5180	201	16	pay	pay	VB
5180	201	17	costs	cost	NNS
5180	201	18	associated	associate	VBN
5180	201	19	with	with	IN
5180	201	20	Internet	internet	NN
5180	201	21	-	-	HYPH
5180	201	22	accessible	accessible	JJ
5180	201	23	computers	computer	NNS
5180	201	24	located	locate	VBN
5180	201	25	in	in	IN
5180	201	26	libraries	library	NNS
5180	201	27	.	.	.
5180	202	1	2	2	LS
5180	202	2	.	.	.
5180	203	1	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	203	2	The	the	DT
5180	203	3	Children	Children	NNPS
5180	203	4	's	's	POS
5180	203	5	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	203	6	Protection	Protection	NNP
5180	203	7	Act	Act	NNP
5180	203	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	203	9	"	"	``
5180	203	10	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	203	11	"	"	''
5180	203	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	203	13	was	be	VBD
5180	203	14	enacted	enact	VBN
5180	203	15	as	as	IN
5180	203	16	part	part	NN
5180	203	17	of	of	IN
5180	203	18	the	the	DT
5180	203	19	Consolidated	Consolidated	NNP
5180	203	20	Appropriations	Appropriations	NNPS
5180	203	21	Act	Act	NNP
5180	203	22	of	of	IN
5180	203	23	2001	2001	CD
5180	203	24	,	,	,
5180	203	25	which	which	WDT
5180	203	26	consolidated	consolidate	VBD
5180	203	27	and	and	CC
5180	203	28	enacted	enact	VBD
5180	203	29	several	several	JJ
5180	203	30	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
5180	203	31	bills	bill	NNS
5180	203	32	,	,	,
5180	203	33	including	include	VBG
5180	203	34	the	the	DT
5180	203	35	Miscellaneous	Miscellaneous	NNP
5180	203	36	Appropriations	Appropriations	NNPS
5180	203	37	Act	Act	NNP
5180	203	38	,	,	,
5180	203	39	of	of	IN
5180	203	40	which	which	WDT
5180	203	41	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	203	42	was	be	VBD
5180	203	43	a	a	DT
5180	203	44	part	part	NN
5180	203	45	.	.	.
5180	204	1	See	see	VB
5180	204	2	Pub	Pub	NNP
5180	204	3	.	.	.
5180	205	1	L.	L.	NNP
5180	205	2	No	no	UH
5180	205	3	.	.	.
5180	206	1	106	106	CD
5180	206	2	-	-	SYM
5180	206	3	554	554	CD
5180	206	4	.	.	.
5180	207	1	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	207	2	addresses	address	VBZ
5180	207	3	three	three	CD
5180	207	4	distinct	distinct	JJ
5180	207	5	types	type	NNS
5180	207	6	of	of	IN
5180	207	7	federal	federal	JJ
5180	207	8	funding	funding	NN
5180	207	9	programs	program	NNS
5180	207	10	:	:	:
5180	207	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	207	12	1	1	LS
5180	207	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	207	14	aid	aid	NN
5180	207	15	to	to	IN
5180	207	16	elementary	elementary	JJ
5180	207	17	and	and	CC
5180	207	18	secondary	secondary	JJ
5180	207	19	schools	school	NNS
5180	207	20	pursuant	pursuant	JJ
5180	207	21	to	to	IN
5180	207	22	Title	Title	NNP
5180	207	23	III	III	NNP
5180	207	24	of	of	IN
5180	207	25	the	the	DT
5180	207	26	Elementary	Elementary	NNP
5180	207	27	and	and	CC
5180	207	28	Secondary	Secondary	NNP
5180	207	29	Education	Education	NNP
5180	207	30	Act	Act	NNP
5180	207	31	of	of	IN
5180	207	32	1965	1965	CD
5180	207	33	,	,	,
5180	207	34	see	see	VB
5180	207	35	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	207	36	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	207	37	.	.	.
5180	208	1	1711	1711	CD
5180	208	2	(	(	-LRB-
5180	208	3	amending	amend	VBG
5180	208	4	Title	Title	NNP
5180	208	5	20	20	CD
5180	208	6	to	to	TO
5180	208	7	add	add	VB
5180	208	8	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	208	9	.	.	.
5180	209	1	3601	3601	CD
5180	209	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	209	3	;	;	:
5180	209	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	209	5	2	2	LS
5180	209	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	209	7	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	209	8	grants	grant	NNS
5180	209	9	to	to	IN
5180	209	10	states	state	NNS
5180	209	11	for	for	IN
5180	209	12	support	support	NN
5180	209	13	of	of	IN
5180	209	14	libraries	library	NNS
5180	209	15	,	,	,
5180	209	16	see	see	VB
5180	209	17	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	209	18	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	209	19	.	.	.
5180	210	1	1712	1712	CD
5180	210	2	(	(	-LRB-
5180	210	3	amending	amend	VBG
5180	210	4	the	the	DT
5180	210	5	Museum	Museum	NNP
5180	210	6	and	and	CC
5180	210	7	Library	Library	NNP
5180	210	8	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	210	9	Act	Act	NNP
5180	210	10	,	,	,
5180	210	11	20	20	CD
5180	210	12	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	211	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	211	2	.	.	.
5180	212	1	9134	9134	CD
5180	212	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	212	3	;	;	:
5180	212	4	and	and	CC
5180	212	5	(	(	-LRB-
5180	212	6	3	3	LS
5180	212	7	)	)	-RRB-
5180	212	8	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	212	9	under	under	IN
5180	212	10	the	the	DT
5180	212	11	E	e	JJ
5180	212	12	-	-	NN
5180	212	13	rate	rate	NN
5180	212	14	program	program	NN
5180	212	15	,	,	,
5180	212	16	see	see	VB
5180	212	17	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	212	18	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	212	19	.	.	.
5180	213	1	1721(a	1721(a	LS
5180	213	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	213	3	&	&	CC
5180	213	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	213	5	b	b	NNP
5180	213	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	213	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	213	8	both	both	DT
5180	213	9	amending	amend	VBG
5180	213	10	the	the	DT
5180	213	11	Communications	Communications	NNPS
5180	213	12	Act	Act	NNP
5180	213	13	of	of	IN
5180	213	14	1934	1934	CD
5180	213	15	,	,	,
5180	213	16	47	47	CD
5180	213	17	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	214	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	214	2	.	.	.
5180	215	1	254(h	254(h	CD
5180	215	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	215	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	215	4	.	.	.
5180	216	1	Only	only	RB
5180	216	2	sections	section	NNS
5180	216	3	1712	1712	CD
5180	216	4	and	and	CC
5180	216	5	1721(b	1721(b	CD
5180	216	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	216	7	of	of	IN
5180	216	8	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	216	9	,	,	,
5180	216	10	which	which	WDT
5180	216	11	apply	apply	VBP
5180	216	12	to	to	IN
5180	216	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	216	14	,	,	,
5180	216	15	are	be	VBP
5180	216	16	at	at	IN
5180	216	17	issue	issue	NN
5180	216	18	in	in	IN
5180	216	19	this	this	DT
5180	216	20	case	case	NN
5180	216	21	.	.	.
5180	217	1	As	as	IN
5180	217	2	explained	explain	VBN
5180	217	3	in	in	IN
5180	217	4	more	more	JJR
5180	217	5	detail	detail	NN
5180	217	6	below	below	RB
5180	217	7	,	,	,
5180	217	8	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	217	9	requires	require	VBZ
5180	217	10	libraries	library	NNS
5180	217	11	that	that	WDT
5180	217	12	participate	participate	VBP
5180	217	13	in	in	IN
5180	217	14	the	the	DT
5180	217	15	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	217	16	and	and	CC
5180	217	17	E	e	NN
5180	217	18	-	-	NN
5180	217	19	rate	rate	NN
5180	217	20	programs	program	NNS
5180	217	21	to	to	TO
5180	217	22	certify	certify	VB
5180	217	23	that	that	IN
5180	217	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	217	25	are	be	VBP
5180	217	26	using	use	VBG
5180	217	27	software	software	NN
5180	217	28	filters	filter	NNS
5180	217	29	on	on	IN
5180	217	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	217	31	computers	computer	NNS
5180	217	32	to	to	TO
5180	217	33	protect	protect	VB
5180	217	34	against	against	IN
5180	217	35	visual	visual	JJ
5180	217	36	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	217	37	that	that	WDT
5180	217	38	are	be	VBP
5180	217	39	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	217	40	,	,	,
5180	217	41	child	child	NN
5180	217	42	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	217	43	,	,	,
5180	217	44	or	or	CC
5180	217	45	in	in	IN
5180	217	46	the	the	DT
5180	217	47	case	case	NN
5180	217	48	of	of	IN
5180	217	49	minors	minor	NNS
5180	217	50	,	,	,
5180	217	51	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	217	52	to	to	IN
5180	217	53	minors	minor	NNS
5180	217	54	.	.	.
5180	218	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	218	2	permits	permit	VBZ
5180	218	3	library	library	JJ
5180	218	4	officials	official	NNS
5180	218	5	to	to	TO
5180	218	6	disable	disable	VB
5180	218	7	the	the	DT
5180	218	8	filters	filter	NNS
5180	218	9	for	for	IN
5180	218	10	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	218	11	for	for	IN
5180	218	12	bona	bona	FW
5180	218	13	fide	fide	JJ
5180	218	14	research	research	NN
5180	218	15	or	or	CC
5180	218	16	other	other	JJ
5180	218	17	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	218	18	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	218	19	,	,	,
5180	218	20	but	but	CC
5180	218	21	disabling	disabling	NN
5180	218	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	218	23	not	not	RB
5180	218	24	permitted	permit	VBN
5180	218	25	for	for	IN
5180	218	26	minor	minor	JJ
5180	218	27	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	218	28	if	if	IN
5180	218	29	the	the	DT
5180	218	30	library	library	NN
5180	218	31	receives	receive	VBZ
5180	218	32	E	e	NN
5180	218	33	-	-	NN
5180	218	34	rate	rate	NN
5180	218	35	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	218	36	.	.	.
5180	219	1	1	1	LS
5180	219	2	.	.	.
5180	220	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	220	2	's	's	POS
5180	220	3	Amendments	amendment	NNS
5180	220	4	to	to	IN
5180	220	5	the	the	DT
5180	220	6	E	e	JJ
5180	220	7	-	-	NN
5180	220	8	rate	rate	NN
5180	220	9	Program	Program	NNP
5180	220	10	Section	Section	NNP
5180	220	11	1721(b	1721(b	CD
5180	220	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	220	13	of	of	IN
5180	220	14	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	220	15	imposes	impose	VBZ
5180	220	16	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	220	17	on	on	IN
5180	220	18	a	a	DT
5180	220	19	library	library	NN
5180	220	20	's	's	POS
5180	220	21	participation	participation	NN
5180	220	22	in	in	IN
5180	220	23	the	the	DT
5180	220	24	E	e	JJ
5180	220	25	-	-	NN
5180	220	26	rate	rate	NN
5180	220	27	program	program	NN
5180	220	28	.	.	.
5180	221	1	A	a	DT
5180	221	2	library	library	NN
5180	221	3	"	"	``
5180	221	4	having	have	VBG
5180	221	5	one	one	CD
5180	221	6	or	or	CC
5180	221	7	more	more	JJR
5180	221	8	computers	computer	NNS
5180	221	9	with	with	IN
5180	221	10	Internet	internet	NN
5180	221	11	access	access	NN
5180	221	12	may	may	MD
5180	221	13	not	not	RB
5180	221	14	receive	receive	VB
5180	221	15	services	service	NNS
5180	221	16	at	at	IN
5180	221	17	discount	discount	NN
5180	221	18	rates	rate	NNS
5180	221	19	,	,	,
5180	221	20	"	"	''
5180	221	21	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	221	22	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	221	23	.	.	.
5180	222	1	1721(b	1721(b	LS
5180	222	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	222	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	222	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	222	5	at	at	IN
5180	222	6	47	47	CD
5180	222	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	223	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	223	2	.	.	.
5180	224	1	254(h)(6)(A)(i	254(h)(6)(a)(i	LS
5180	224	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	224	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	224	4	,	,	,
5180	224	5	unless	unless	IN
5180	224	6	the	the	DT
5180	224	7	library	library	NN
5180	224	8	certifies	certifie	NNS
5180	224	9	that	that	IN
5180	224	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	224	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	224	12	"	"	``
5180	224	13	enforcing	enforce	VBG
5180	224	14	a	a	DT
5180	224	15	policy	policy	NN
5180	224	16	of	of	IN
5180	224	17	Internet	internet	NN
5180	224	18	safety	safety	NN
5180	224	19	that	that	WDT
5180	224	20	includes	include	VBZ
5180	224	21	the	the	DT
5180	224	22	operation	operation	NN
5180	224	23	of	of	IN
5180	224	24	a	a	DT
5180	224	25	technology	technology	NN
5180	224	26	protection	protection	NN
5180	224	27	measure	measure	NN
5180	224	28	with	with	IN
5180	224	29	respect	respect	NN
5180	224	30	to	to	IN
5180	224	31	any	any	DT
5180	224	32	of	of	IN
5180	224	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	224	34	computers	computer	NNS
5180	224	35	with	with	IN
5180	224	36	Internet	internet	NN
5180	224	37	access	access	NN
5180	224	38	that	that	WDT
5180	224	39	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	224	40	against	against	IN
5180	224	41	access	access	NN
5180	224	42	through	through	IN
5180	224	43	such	such	JJ
5180	224	44	computers	computer	NNS
5180	224	45	to	to	IN
5180	224	46	visual	visual	JJ
5180	224	47	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	224	48	that	that	WDT
5180	224	49	are	be	VBP
5180	224	50	–	–	:
5180	224	51	(	(	-LRB-
5180	224	52	I	i	NN
5180	224	53	)	)	-RRB-
5180	224	54	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	224	55	;	;	:
5180	224	56	(	(	-LRB-
5180	224	57	II	II	NNP
5180	224	58	)	)	-RRB-
5180	224	59	child	child	NN
5180	224	60	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	224	61	;	;	:
5180	224	62	or	or	CC
5180	224	63	(	(	-LRB-
5180	224	64	III	III	NNP
5180	224	65	)	)	-RRB-
5180	224	66	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	224	67	to	to	IN
5180	224	68	minors	minor	NNS
5180	224	69	,	,	,
5180	224	70	"	"	''
5180	224	71	and	and	CC
5180	224	72	that	that	IN
5180	224	73	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	224	74	is	be	VBZ
5180	224	75	"	"	``
5180	224	76	enforcing	enforce	VBG
5180	224	77	the	the	DT
5180	224	78	operation	operation	NN
5180	224	79	of	of	IN
5180	224	80	such	such	JJ
5180	224	81	technology	technology	NN
5180	224	82	protection	protection	NN
5180	224	83	measure	measure	NN
5180	224	84	during	during	IN
5180	224	85	any	any	DT
5180	224	86	use	use	NN
5180	224	87	of	of	IN
5180	224	88	such	such	JJ
5180	224	89	computers	computer	NNS
5180	224	90	by	by	IN
5180	224	91	minors	minor	NNS
5180	224	92	.	.	.
5180	224	93	"	"	''
5180	225	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	225	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	225	3	.	.	.
5180	226	1	1721(b	1721(b	LS
5180	226	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	226	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	226	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	226	5	at	at	IN
5180	226	6	47	47	CD
5180	226	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	227	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	227	2	.	.	.
5180	228	1	254(h)(6)(B	254(h)(6)(b	LS
5180	228	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	228	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	228	4	.	.	.
5180	229	1	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	229	2	defines	define	VBZ
5180	229	3	a	a	DT
5180	229	4	"	"	``
5180	229	5	technology	technology	NN
5180	229	6	protection	protection	NN
5180	229	7	measure	measure	NN
5180	229	8	"	"	''
5180	229	9	as	as	IN
5180	229	10	"	"	``
5180	229	11	a	a	DT
5180	229	12	specific	specific	JJ
5180	229	13	technology	technology	NN
5180	229	14	that	that	WDT
5180	229	15	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	229	16	or	or	CC
5180	229	17	filters	filter	VBZ
5180	229	18	access	access	NN
5180	229	19	to	to	IN
5180	229	20	visual	visual	JJ
5180	229	21	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	229	22	that	that	WDT
5180	229	23	are	be	VBP
5180	229	24	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	229	25	,	,	,
5180	229	26	.	.	.
5180	230	1	.	.	.
5180	231	1	.	.	.
5180	232	1	child	child	NN
5180	232	2	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	232	3	,	,	,
5180	232	4	.	.	.
5180	233	1	.	.	.
5180	234	1	.	.	.
5180	235	1	or	or	CC
5180	235	2	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	235	3	to	to	IN
5180	235	4	minors	minor	NNS
5180	235	5	.	.	.
5180	235	6	"	"	''
5180	236	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	236	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	236	3	.	.	.
5180	237	1	1703(b)(1	1703(b)(1	LS
5180	237	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	237	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	237	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	237	5	at	at	IN
5180	237	6	47	47	CD
5180	237	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	238	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	238	2	.	.	.
5180	239	1	254(h)(7)(I	254(h)(7)(i	LS
5180	239	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	239	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	239	4	.	.	.
5180	240	1	To	to	TO
5180	240	2	receive	receive	VB
5180	240	3	E	e	NN
5180	240	4	-	-	NN
5180	240	5	rate	rate	NN
5180	240	6	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	240	7	,	,	,
5180	240	8	a	a	DT
5180	240	9	library	library	NN
5180	240	10	must	must	MD
5180	240	11	also	also	RB
5180	240	12	certify	certify	VB
5180	240	13	that	that	IN
5180	240	14	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	240	15	software	software	NN
5180	240	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	240	17	in	in	IN
5180	240	18	operation	operation	NN
5180	240	19	during	during	IN
5180	240	20	adult	adult	NN
5180	240	21	use	use	NN
5180	240	22	of	of	IN
5180	240	23	the	the	DT
5180	240	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	240	25	.	.	.
5180	241	1	More	more	RBR
5180	241	2	specifically	specifically	RB
5180	241	3	,	,	,
5180	241	4	with	with	IN
5180	241	5	respect	respect	NN
5180	241	6	to	to	IN
5180	241	7	adults	adult	NNS
5180	241	8	,	,	,
5180	241	9	a	a	DT
5180	241	10	library	library	NN
5180	241	11	must	must	MD
5180	241	12	certify	certify	VB
5180	241	13	that	that	IN
5180	241	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	241	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	241	16	"	"	``
5180	241	17	enforcing	enforce	VBG
5180	241	18	a	a	DT
5180	241	19	policy	policy	NN
5180	241	20	of	of	IN
5180	241	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	241	22	safety	safety	NN
5180	241	23	that	that	WDT
5180	241	24	includes	include	VBZ
5180	241	25	the	the	DT
5180	241	26	operation	operation	NN
5180	241	27	of	of	IN
5180	241	28	a	a	DT
5180	241	29	technology	technology	NN
5180	241	30	protection	protection	NN
5180	241	31	measure	measure	NN
5180	241	32	with	with	IN
5180	241	33	respect	respect	NN
5180	241	34	to	to	IN
5180	241	35	any	any	DT
5180	241	36	of	of	IN
5180	241	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	241	38	computers	computer	NNS
5180	241	39	with	with	IN
5180	241	40	Internet	internet	NN
5180	241	41	access	access	NN
5180	241	42	that	that	WDT
5180	241	43	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	241	44	against	against	IN
5180	241	45	access	access	NN
5180	241	46	through	through	IN
5180	241	47	such	such	JJ
5180	241	48	computers	computer	NNS
5180	241	49	to	to	IN
5180	241	50	visual	visual	JJ
5180	241	51	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	241	52	that	that	WDT
5180	241	53	are	be	VBP
5180	241	54	–	–	:
5180	241	55	(	(	-LRB-
5180	241	56	I	i	NN
5180	241	57	)	)	-RRB-
5180	241	58	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	241	59	;	;	:
5180	241	60	or	or	CC
5180	241	61	(	(	-LRB-
5180	241	62	II	II	NNP
5180	241	63	)	)	-RRB-
5180	241	64	child	child	NN
5180	241	65	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	241	66	,	,	,
5180	241	67	"	"	''
5180	241	68	and	and	CC
5180	241	69	that	that	IN
5180	241	70	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	241	71	is	be	VBZ
5180	241	72	"	"	``
5180	241	73	enforcing	enforce	VBG
5180	241	74	the	the	DT
5180	241	75	operation	operation	NN
5180	241	76	of	of	IN
5180	241	77	such	such	JJ
5180	241	78	technology	technology	NN
5180	241	79	protection	protection	NN
5180	241	80	measure	measure	NN
5180	241	81	during	during	IN
5180	241	82	any	any	DT
5180	241	83	use	use	NN
5180	241	84	of	of	IN
5180	241	85	such	such	JJ
5180	241	86	computers	computer	NNS
5180	241	87	.	.	.
5180	241	88	"	"	''
5180	242	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	242	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	242	3	.	.	.
5180	243	1	1721(b	1721(b	LS
5180	243	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	243	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	243	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	243	5	at	at	IN
5180	243	6	47	47	CD
5180	243	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	244	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	244	2	.	.	.
5180	245	1	254(h)(6)(C	254(h)(6)(c	LS
5180	245	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	245	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	245	4	.	.	.
5180	246	1	Interpreting	interpret	VBG
5180	246	2	the	the	DT
5180	246	3	statutory	statutory	JJ
5180	246	4	terms	term	NNS
5180	246	5	"	"	``
5180	246	6	any	any	DT
5180	246	7	use	use	NN
5180	246	8	,	,	,
5180	246	9	"	"	''
5180	246	10	the	the	DT
5180	246	11	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	246	12	has	have	VBZ
5180	246	13	concluded	conclude	VBN
5180	246	14	that	that	IN
5180	246	15	"	"	``
5180	246	16	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	246	17	makes	make	VBZ
5180	246	18	no	no	DT
5180	246	19	distinction	distinction	NN
5180	246	20	between	between	IN
5180	246	21	computers	computer	NNS
5180	246	22	used	use	VBN
5180	246	23	only	only	RB
5180	246	24	by	by	IN
5180	246	25	staff	staff	NN
5180	246	26	and	and	CC
5180	246	27	those	those	DT
5180	246	28	accessible	accessible	JJ
5180	246	29	to	to	IN
5180	246	30	the	the	DT
5180	246	31	public	public	NN
5180	246	32	.	.	.
5180	246	33	"	"	''
5180	247	1	In	in	IN
5180	247	2	re	re	JJ
5180	247	3	Federal	Federal	NNP
5180	247	4	-	-	HYPH
5180	247	5	State	State	NNP
5180	247	6	Joint	Joint	NNP
5180	247	7	Board	Board	NNP
5180	247	8	on	on	IN
5180	247	9	Universal	Universal	NNP
5180	247	10	Service	Service	NNP
5180	247	11	:	:	:
5180	247	12	Children	Children	NNP
5180	247	13	's	's	POS
5180	247	14	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	247	15	Protection	Protection	NNP
5180	247	16	Act	Act	NNP
5180	247	17	,	,	,
5180	247	18	CC	CC	NNP
5180	247	19	Docket	Docket	NNP
5180	247	20	No	no	UH
5180	247	21	.	.	.
5180	248	1	96	96	CD
5180	248	2	-	-	SYM
5180	248	3	45	45	CD
5180	248	4	,	,	,
5180	248	5	Report	Report	NNP
5180	248	6	and	and	CC
5180	248	7	Order	Order	NNP
5180	248	8	,	,	,
5180	248	9	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	248	10	01	01	CD
5180	248	11	-	-	SYM
5180	248	12	120	120	CD
5180	248	13	,	,	,
5180	248	14	30	30	CD
5180	248	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	248	16	Apr.	April	NNP
5180	249	1	5	5	CD
5180	249	2	,	,	,
5180	249	3	2001	2001	CD
5180	249	4	)	)	-RRB-
5180	249	5	.	.	.
5180	250	1	With	with	IN
5180	250	2	respect	respect	NN
5180	250	3	to	to	IN
5180	250	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	250	5	receiving	receive	VBG
5180	250	6	E	e	NN
5180	250	7	-	-	NN
5180	250	8	rate	rate	NN
5180	250	9	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	250	10	,	,	,
5180	250	11	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	250	12	further	further	RB
5180	250	13	specifies	specify	VBZ
5180	250	14	that	that	IN
5180	250	15	"	"	``
5180	250	16	[	[	-LRB-
5180	250	17	a]n	a]n	NNP
5180	250	18	administrator	administrator	NN
5180	250	19	,	,	,
5180	250	20	supervisor	supervisor	NN
5180	250	21	,	,	,
5180	250	22	or	or	CC
5180	250	23	other	other	JJ
5180	250	24	person	person	NN
5180	250	25	authorized	authorize	VBN
5180	250	26	by	by	IN
5180	250	27	the	the	DT
5180	250	28	certifying	certify	VBG
5180	250	29	authority	authority	NN
5180	250	30	.	.	.
5180	251	1	.	.	.
5180	252	1	.	.	.
5180	253	1	may	may	MD
5180	253	2	disable	disable	VB
5180	253	3	the	the	DT
5180	253	4	technology	technology	NN
5180	253	5	protection	protection	NN
5180	253	6	measure	measure	NN
5180	253	7	concerned	concern	VBN
5180	253	8	,	,	,
5180	253	9	during	during	IN
5180	253	10	use	use	NN
5180	253	11	by	by	IN
5180	253	12	an	an	DT
5180	253	13	adult	adult	NN
5180	253	14	,	,	,
5180	253	15	to	to	TO
5180	253	16	enable	enable	VB
5180	253	17	access	access	NN
5180	253	18	for	for	IN
5180	253	19	bona	bona	FW
5180	253	20	fide	fide	JJ
5180	253	21	research	research	NN
5180	253	22	or	or	CC
5180	253	23	other	other	JJ
5180	253	24	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	253	25	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	253	26	.	.	.
5180	253	27	"	"	''
5180	254	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	254	2	Sec.1721(b	Sec.1721(b	NNP
5180	254	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	254	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	254	5	codified	codify	VBN
5180	254	6	at	at	IN
5180	254	7	47	47	CD
5180	254	8	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	255	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	255	2	.	.	.
5180	256	1	254(h)(6)(D	254(h)(6)(d	LS
5180	256	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	256	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	256	4	.	.	.
5180	257	1	2	2	LS
5180	257	2	.	.	.
5180	258	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	258	2	's	's	POS
5180	258	3	Amendments	amendment	NNS
5180	258	4	to	to	IN
5180	258	5	the	the	DT
5180	258	6	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	258	7	Program	Program	NNP
5180	258	8	Section	Section	NNP
5180	258	9	1712	1712	CD
5180	258	10	of	of	IN
5180	258	11	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	258	12	amends	amend	VBZ
5180	258	13	the	the	DT
5180	258	14	Museum	Museum	NNP
5180	258	15	and	and	CC
5180	258	16	Library	Library	NNP
5180	258	17	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	258	18	Act	Act	NNP
5180	258	19	(	(	-LRB-
5180	258	20	20	20	CD
5180	258	21	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	259	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	259	2	.	.	.
5180	260	1	9134(f	9134(f	LS
5180	260	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	260	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	260	4	to	to	TO
5180	260	5	provide	provide	VB
5180	260	6	that	that	IN
5180	260	7	no	no	DT
5180	260	8	funds	fund	NNS
5180	260	9	made	make	VBN
5180	260	10	available	available	JJ
5180	260	11	under	under	IN
5180	260	12	the	the	DT
5180	260	13	Act	Act	NNP
5180	260	14	"	"	''
5180	260	15	may	may	MD
5180	260	16	be	be	VB
5180	260	17	used	use	VBN
5180	260	18	to	to	TO
5180	260	19	purchase	purchase	VB
5180	260	20	computers	computer	NNS
5180	260	21	used	use	VBN
5180	260	22	to	to	TO
5180	260	23	access	access	VB
5180	260	24	the	the	DT
5180	260	25	Internet	internet	NN
5180	260	26	,	,	,
5180	260	27	or	or	CC
5180	260	28	to	to	TO
5180	260	29	pay	pay	VB
5180	260	30	for	for	IN
5180	260	31	direct	direct	JJ
5180	260	32	costs	cost	NNS
5180	260	33	associated	associate	VBN
5180	260	34	with	with	IN
5180	260	35	accessing	access	VBG
5180	260	36	the	the	DT
5180	260	37	Internet	internet	NN
5180	260	38	,	,	,
5180	260	39	"	"	''
5180	260	40	unless	unless	IN
5180	260	41	such	such	JJ
5180	260	42	library	library	NN
5180	260	43	"	"	``
5180	260	44	has	have	VBZ
5180	260	45	in	in	IN
5180	260	46	place	place	NN
5180	260	47	"	"	''
5180	260	48	and	and	CC
5180	260	49	is	be	VBZ
5180	260	50	enforcing	enforce	VBG
5180	260	51	"	"	``
5180	260	52	a	a	DT
5180	260	53	policy	policy	NN
5180	260	54	of	of	IN
5180	260	55	Internet	internet	NN
5180	260	56	safety	safety	NN
5180	260	57	that	that	WDT
5180	260	58	includes	include	VBZ
5180	260	59	the	the	DT
5180	260	60	operation	operation	NN
5180	260	61	of	of	IN
5180	260	62	a	a	DT
5180	260	63	technology	technology	NN
5180	260	64	protection	protection	NN
5180	260	65	measure	measure	NN
5180	260	66	with	with	IN
5180	260	67	respect	respect	NN
5180	260	68	to	to	IN
5180	260	69	any	any	DT
5180	260	70	of	of	IN
5180	260	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	260	72	computers	computer	NNS
5180	260	73	with	with	IN
5180	260	74	Internet	internet	NN
5180	260	75	access	access	NN
5180	260	76	that	that	WDT
5180	260	77	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	260	78	against	against	IN
5180	260	79	access	access	NN
5180	260	80	through	through	IN
5180	260	81	such	such	JJ
5180	260	82	computers	computer	NNS
5180	260	83	to	to	IN
5180	260	84	visual	visual	JJ
5180	260	85	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	260	86	"	"	''
5180	260	87	that	that	WDT
5180	260	88	are	be	VBP
5180	260	89	"	"	``
5180	260	90	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	260	91	"	"	''
5180	260	92	or	or	CC
5180	260	93	"	"	``
5180	260	94	child	child	NN
5180	260	95	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	260	96	,	,	,
5180	260	97	"	"	''
5180	260	98	and	and	CC
5180	260	99	,	,	,
5180	260	100	when	when	WRB
5180	260	101	the	the	DT
5180	260	102	computers	computer	NNS
5180	260	103	are	be	VBP
5180	260	104	in	in	IN
5180	260	105	use	use	NN
5180	260	106	by	by	IN
5180	260	107	minors	minor	NNS
5180	260	108	,	,	,
5180	260	109	also	also	RB
5180	260	110	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	260	111	against	against	IN
5180	260	112	access	access	NN
5180	260	113	to	to	IN
5180	260	114	visual	visual	JJ
5180	260	115	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	260	116	that	that	WDT
5180	260	117	are	be	VBP
5180	260	118	"	"	``
5180	260	119	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	260	120	to	to	IN
5180	260	121	minors	minor	NNS
5180	260	122	.	.	.
5180	260	123	"	"	''
5180	261	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	261	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	261	3	.	.	.
5180	262	1	1712	1712	CD
5180	262	2	(	(	-LRB-
5180	262	3	codified	codify	VBN
5180	262	4	at	at	IN
5180	262	5	20	20	CD
5180	262	6	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	263	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	263	2	.	.	.
5180	264	1	9134(f)(1	9134(f)(1	CD
5180	264	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	264	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	264	4	.	.	.
5180	265	1	Section	section	NN
5180	265	2	1712	1712	CD
5180	265	3	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	265	4	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	265	5	of	of	IN
5180	265	6	"	"	``
5180	265	7	technology	technology	NN
5180	265	8	protection	protection	NN
5180	265	9	measure	measure	NN
5180	265	10	,	,	,
5180	265	11	"	"	''
5180	265	12	"	"	``
5180	265	13	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	265	14	,	,	,
5180	265	15	"	"	''
5180	265	16	"	"	``
5180	265	17	child	child	NN
5180	265	18	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	265	19	,	,	,
5180	265	20	"	"	''
5180	265	21	and	and	CC
5180	265	22	"	"	``
5180	265	23	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	265	24	to	to	IN
5180	265	25	minors	minor	NNS
5180	265	26	,	,	,
5180	265	27	"	"	''
5180	265	28	that	that	WDT
5180	265	29	are	be	VBP
5180	265	30	substantially	substantially	RB
5180	265	31	similar	similar	JJ
5180	265	32	to	to	IN
5180	265	33	those	those	DT
5180	265	34	found	find	VBN
5180	265	35	in	in	IN
5180	265	36	the	the	DT
5180	265	37	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	265	38	governing	govern	VBG
5180	265	39	the	the	DT
5180	265	40	E	e	JJ
5180	265	41	-	-	NN
5180	265	42	rate	rate	NN
5180	265	43	program	program	NN
5180	265	44	.	.	.
5180	266	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	266	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	266	3	.	.	.
5180	267	1	1712	1712	CD
5180	267	2	(	(	-LRB-
5180	267	3	codified	codify	VBN
5180	267	4	at	at	IN
5180	267	5	20	20	CD
5180	267	6	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	268	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	268	2	.	.	.
5180	269	1	9134(f)(7	9134(f)(7	LS
5180	269	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	269	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	269	4	;	;	:
5180	269	5	see	see	VB
5180	269	6	also	also	RB
5180	269	7	supra	supra	NNP
5180	269	8	note	note	NNP
5180	269	9	2	2	CD
5180	269	10	.	.	.
5180	270	1	As	as	IN
5180	270	2	under	under	IN
5180	270	3	the	the	DT
5180	270	4	E	e	NN
5180	270	5	-	-	NN
5180	270	6	rate	rate	NN
5180	270	7	program	program	NN
5180	270	8	,	,	,
5180	270	9	"	"	''
5180	270	10	an	an	DT
5180	270	11	administrator	administrator	NN
5180	270	12	,	,	,
5180	270	13	supervisor	supervisor	NN
5180	270	14	or	or	CC
5180	270	15	other	other	JJ
5180	270	16	authority	authority	NN
5180	270	17	may	may	MD
5180	270	18	disable	disable	VB
5180	270	19	a	a	DT
5180	270	20	technology	technology	NN
5180	270	21	protection	protection	NN
5180	270	22	measure	measure	NN
5180	270	23	.	.	.
5180	271	1	.	.	.
5180	272	1	.	.	.
5180	273	1	to	to	TO
5180	273	2	enable	enable	VB
5180	273	3	access	access	NN
5180	273	4	for	for	IN
5180	273	5	bona	bona	FW
5180	273	6	fide	fide	JJ
5180	273	7	research	research	NN
5180	273	8	or	or	CC
5180	273	9	other	other	JJ
5180	273	10	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	273	11	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	273	12	.	.	.
5180	273	13	"	"	''
5180	274	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	274	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	274	3	.	.	.
5180	275	1	1712	1712	CD
5180	275	2	(	(	-LRB-
5180	275	3	codified	codify	VBN
5180	275	4	at	at	IN
5180	275	5	20	20	CD
5180	275	6	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	276	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	276	2	.	.	.
5180	277	1	9134(f)(3	9134(f)(3	LS
5180	277	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	277	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	277	4	.	.	.
5180	278	1	Whereas	whereas	IN
5180	278	2	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	278	3	's	's	POS
5180	278	4	amendments	amendment	NNS
5180	278	5	to	to	IN
5180	278	6	the	the	DT
5180	278	7	E	e	JJ
5180	278	8	-	-	HYPH
5180	278	9	rate	rate	NN
5180	278	10	program	program	NN
5180	278	11	permit	permit	NN
5180	278	12	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	278	13	for	for	IN
5180	278	14	bona	bona	FW
5180	278	15	fide	fide	JJ
5180	278	16	research	research	NN
5180	278	17	or	or	CC
5180	278	18	other	other	JJ
5180	278	19	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	278	20	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	278	21	only	only	RB
5180	278	22	during	during	IN
5180	278	23	adult	adult	NN
5180	278	24	use	use	NN
5180	278	25	,	,	,
5180	278	26	the	the	DT
5180	278	27	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	278	28	provision	provision	NN
5180	278	29	permits	permit	VBZ
5180	278	30	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	278	31	for	for	IN
5180	278	32	both	both	DT
5180	278	33	adults	adult	NNS
5180	278	34	and	and	CC
5180	278	35	minors	minor	NNS
5180	278	36	.	.	.
5180	279	1	2	2	LS
5180	279	2	.	.	.
5180	280	1	Identity	identity	NN
5180	280	2	of	of	IN
5180	280	3	the	the	DT
5180	280	4	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNPS
5180	280	5	1	1	CD
5180	280	6	.	.	.
5180	281	1	Library	Library	NNP
5180	281	2	and	and	CC
5180	281	3	Library	Library	NNP
5180	281	4	Association	Association	NNP
5180	281	5	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNPS
5180	281	6	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNP
5180	281	7	American	American	NNP
5180	281	8	Library	Library	NNP
5180	281	9	Association	Association	NNP
5180	281	10	,	,	,
5180	281	11	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
5180	281	12	Library	Library	NNP
5180	281	13	Association	Association	NNP
5180	281	14	,	,	,
5180	281	15	California	California	NNP
5180	281	16	Library	Library	NNP
5180	281	17	Association	Association	NNP
5180	281	18	,	,	,
5180	281	19	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
5180	281	20	Library	Library	NNP
5180	281	21	Association	Association	NNP
5180	281	22	,	,	,
5180	281	23	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
5180	281	24	to	to	TO
5180	281	25	Read	read	VB
5180	281	26	Foundation	Foundation	NNP
5180	281	27	,	,	,
5180	281	28	Maine	Maine	NNP
5180	281	29	Library	Library	NNP
5180	281	30	Association	Association	NNP
5180	281	31	,	,	,
5180	281	32	New	New	NNP
5180	281	33	England	England	NNP
5180	281	34	Library	Library	NNP
5180	281	35	Association	Association	NNP
5180	281	36	,	,	,
5180	281	37	New	New	NNP
5180	281	38	York	York	NNP
5180	281	39	Library	Library	NNP
5180	281	40	Association	Association	NNP
5180	281	41	,	,	,
5180	281	42	and	and	CC
5180	281	43	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
5180	281	44	Library	Library	NNP
5180	281	45	Association	Association	NNP
5180	281	46	are	be	VBP
5180	281	47	non	non	JJ
5180	281	48	-	-	JJ
5180	281	49	profit	profit	JJ
5180	281	50	organizations	organization	NNS
5180	281	51	whose	whose	WP$
5180	281	52	members	member	NNS
5180	281	53	include	include	VBP
5180	281	54	public	public	JJ
5180	281	55	libraries	library	NNS
5180	281	56	that	that	WDT
5180	281	57	receive	receive	VBP
5180	281	58	either	either	DT
5180	281	59	E	e	NN
5180	281	60	-	-	NN
5180	281	61	rate	rate	NN
5180	281	62	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	281	63	or	or	CC
5180	281	64	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	281	65	funds	fund	NNS
5180	281	66	for	for	IN
5180	281	67	the	the	DT
5180	281	68	provision	provision	NN
5180	281	69	of	of	IN
5180	281	70	Internet	internet	NN
5180	281	71	access	access	NN
5180	281	72	.	.	.
5180	282	1	Because	because	IN
5180	282	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	282	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	282	4	a	a	DT
5180	282	5	prerequisite	prerequisite	NN
5180	282	6	to	to	IN
5180	282	7	associational	associational	JJ
5180	282	8	standing	standing	NN
5180	282	9	,	,	,
5180	282	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	282	11	note	note	VBP
5180	282	12	that	that	IN
5180	282	13	the	the	DT
5180	282	14	interests	interest	NNS
5180	282	15	that	that	WDT
5180	282	16	these	these	DT
5180	282	17	organizations	organization	NNS
5180	282	18	seek	seek	VBP
5180	282	19	to	to	TO
5180	282	20	protect	protect	VB
5180	282	21	in	in	IN
5180	282	22	this	this	DT
5180	282	23	litigation	litigation	NN
5180	282	24	are	be	VBP
5180	282	25	central	central	JJ
5180	282	26	to	to	IN
5180	282	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	282	28	raison	raison	NNP
5180	282	29	d'être	d'être	NNP
5180	282	30	.	.	.
5180	283	1	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNPS
5180	283	2	Fort	Fort	NNP
5180	283	3	Vancouver	Vancouver	NNP
5180	283	4	Regional	Regional	NNP
5180	283	5	Library	Library	NNP
5180	283	6	District	District	NNP
5180	283	7	,	,	,
5180	283	8	in	in	IN
5180	283	9	southwest	southwest	JJ
5180	283	10	Washington	Washington	NNP
5180	283	11	state	state	NN
5180	283	12	;	;	:
5180	283	13	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
5180	283	14	County	County	NNP
5180	283	15	Public	Public	NNP
5180	283	16	Library	Library	NNP
5180	283	17	,	,	,
5180	283	18	in	in	IN
5180	283	19	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
5180	283	20	County	County	NNP
5180	283	21	,	,	,
5180	283	22	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
5180	283	23	;	;	:
5180	283	24	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
5180	283	25	Public	Public	NNP
5180	283	26	Library	Library	NNP
5180	283	27	System	System	NNP
5180	283	28	,	,	,
5180	283	29	in	in	IN
5180	283	30	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
5180	283	31	,	,	,
5180	283	32	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
5180	283	33	;	;	:
5180	283	34	Santa	Santa	NNP
5180	283	35	Cruz	Cruz	NNP
5180	283	36	Public	Public	NNP
5180	283	37	Library	Library	NNP
5180	283	38	Joint	Joint	NNP
5180	283	39	Powers	Powers	NNPS
5180	283	40	Authority	Authority	NNP
5180	283	41	,	,	,
5180	283	42	in	in	IN
5180	283	43	Santa	Santa	NNP
5180	283	44	Cruz	Cruz	NNP
5180	283	45	,	,	,
5180	283	46	California	California	NNP
5180	283	47	;	;	:
5180	283	48	South	South	NNP
5180	283	49	Central	Central	NNP
5180	283	50	Library	Library	NNP
5180	283	51	System	System	NNP
5180	283	52	(	(	-LRB-
5180	283	53	"	"	``
5180	283	54	SCLS	SCLS	NNP
5180	283	55	"	"	''
5180	283	56	)	)	-RRB-
5180	283	57	,	,	,
5180	283	58	centered	center	VBN
5180	283	59	in	in	IN
5180	283	60	Madison	Madison	NNP
5180	283	61	,	,	,
5180	283	62	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
5180	283	63	;	;	:
5180	283	64	and	and	CC
5180	283	65	the	the	DT
5180	283	66	Westchester	Westchester	NNP
5180	283	67	Library	Library	NNP
5180	283	68	System	System	NNP
5180	283	69	,	,	,
5180	283	70	in	in	IN
5180	283	71	Westchester	Westchester	NNP
5180	283	72	County	County	NNP
5180	283	73	,	,	,
5180	283	74	New	New	NNP
5180	283	75	York	York	NNP
5180	283	76	,	,	,
5180	283	77	are	be	VBP
5180	283	78	public	public	JJ
5180	283	79	library	library	NN
5180	283	80	systems	system	NNS
5180	283	81	with	with	IN
5180	283	82	branch	branch	NN
5180	283	83	offices	office	NNS
5180	283	84	in	in	IN
5180	283	85	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	283	86	respective	respective	JJ
5180	283	87	localities	locality	NNS
5180	283	88	that	that	WDT
5180	283	89	provide	provide	VBP
5180	283	90	Internet	internet	NN
5180	283	91	access	access	NN
5180	283	92	to	to	IN
5180	283	93	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	283	94	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	283	95	.	.	.
5180	284	1	The	the	DT
5180	284	2	Fort	Fort	NNP
5180	284	3	Vancouver	Vancouver	NNP
5180	284	4	Regional	Regional	NNP
5180	284	5	Library	Library	NNP
5180	284	6	District	District	NNP
5180	284	7	,	,	,
5180	284	8	for	for	IN
5180	284	9	over	over	IN
5180	284	10	three	three	CD
5180	284	11	years	year	NNS
5180	284	12	from	from	IN
5180	284	13	1999	1999	CD
5180	284	14	-	-	SYM
5180	284	15	2001	2001	CD
5180	284	16	,	,	,
5180	284	17	received	receive	VBD
5180	284	18	$	$	$
5180	284	19	135,000	135,000	CD
5180	284	20	in	in	IN
5180	284	21	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	284	22	grants	grant	NNS
5180	284	23	and	and	CC
5180	284	24	$	$	$
5180	284	25	19,500	19,500	CD
5180	284	26	in	in	IN
5180	284	27	E	e	NN
5180	284	28	-	-	NN
5180	284	29	rate	rate	NN
5180	284	30	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	284	31	for	for	IN
5180	284	32	Internet	internet	NN
5180	284	33	access	access	NN
5180	284	34	.	.	.
5180	285	1	The	the	DT
5180	285	2	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
5180	285	3	County	County	NNP
5180	285	4	Public	Public	NNP
5180	285	5	Library	Library	NNP
5180	285	6	received	receive	VBD
5180	285	7	$	$	$
5180	285	8	70,000	70,000	CD
5180	285	9	in	in	IN
5180	285	10	E	e	NN
5180	285	11	-	-	NN
5180	285	12	rate	rate	NN
5180	285	13	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	285	14	for	for	IN
5180	285	15	Internet	internet	NN
5180	285	16	access	access	NN
5180	285	17	this	this	DT
5180	285	18	year	year	NN
5180	285	19	,	,	,
5180	285	20	and	and	CC
5180	285	21	has	have	VBZ
5180	285	22	applied	apply	VBN
5180	285	23	for	for	IN
5180	285	24	$	$	$
5180	285	25	100,000	100,000	CD
5180	285	26	in	in	IN
5180	285	27	E	e	NN
5180	285	28	-	-	NN
5180	285	29	rate	rate	NN
5180	285	30	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	285	31	for	for	IN
5180	285	32	the	the	DT
5180	285	33	upcoming	upcoming	JJ
5180	285	34	year	year	NN
5180	285	35	.	.	.
5180	286	1	The	the	DT
5180	286	2	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
5180	286	3	Public	Public	NNP
5180	286	4	Library	Library	NNP
5180	286	5	System	System	NNP
5180	286	6	received	receive	VBD
5180	286	7	$	$	$
5180	286	8	90,000	90,000	CD
5180	286	9	in	in	IN
5180	286	10	E	e	NN
5180	286	11	-	-	NN
5180	286	12	rate	rate	NN
5180	286	13	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	286	14	for	for	IN
5180	286	15	Internet	internet	NN
5180	286	16	access	access	NN
5180	286	17	this	this	DT
5180	286	18	year	year	NN
5180	286	19	,	,	,
5180	286	20	and	and	CC
5180	286	21	has	have	VBZ
5180	286	22	received	receive	VBN
5180	286	23	a	a	DT
5180	286	24	$	$	$
5180	286	25	200,000	200,000	CD
5180	286	26	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	286	27	grant	grant	NN
5180	286	28	to	to	TO
5180	286	29	put	put	VB
5180	286	30	computer	computer	NN
5180	286	31	labs	lab	NNS
5180	286	32	in	in	IN
5180	286	33	eight	eight	CD
5180	286	34	of	of	IN
5180	286	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	286	36	libraries	library	NNS
5180	286	37	.	.	.
5180	287	1	The	the	DT
5180	287	2	Santa	Santa	NNP
5180	287	3	Cruz	Cruz	NNP
5180	287	4	Public	Public	NNP
5180	287	5	Library	Library	NNP
5180	287	6	Joint	Joint	NNP
5180	287	7	Powers	Powers	NNPS
5180	287	8	Authority	Authority	NNP
5180	287	9	received	receive	VBD
5180	287	10	$	$	$
5180	287	11	20,560	20,560	CD
5180	287	12	in	in	IN
5180	287	13	E	e	NN
5180	287	14	-	-	NN
5180	287	15	rate	rate	NN
5180	287	16	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	287	17	for	for	IN
5180	287	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	287	19	access	access	NN
5180	287	20	in	in	IN
5180	287	21	2001	2001	CD
5180	287	22	-	-	SYM
5180	287	23	02	02	CD
5180	287	24	.	.	.
5180	288	1	The	the	DT
5180	288	2	SCLS	SCLS	NNP
5180	288	3	received	receive	VBD
5180	288	4	between	between	IN
5180	288	5	$	$	$
5180	288	6	3,000	3,000	CD
5180	288	7	and	and	CC
5180	288	8	$	$	$
5180	288	9	5,000	5,000	CD
5180	288	10	this	this	DT
5180	288	11	year	year	NN
5180	288	12	in	in	IN
5180	288	13	E	e	NN
5180	288	14	-	-	NN
5180	288	15	rate	rate	NN
5180	288	16	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	288	17	for	for	IN
5180	288	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	288	19	access	access	NN
5180	288	20	.	.	.
5180	289	1	The	the	DT
5180	289	2	Fort	Fort	NNP
5180	289	3	Vancouver	Vancouver	NNP
5180	289	4	Regional	Regional	NNP
5180	289	5	Library	Library	NNP
5180	289	6	District	District	NNP
5180	289	7	Board	Board	NNP
5180	289	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	289	9	a	a	DT
5180	289	10	public	public	JJ
5180	289	11	board	board	NN
5180	289	12	whose	whose	WP$
5180	289	13	members	member	NNS
5180	289	14	are	be	VBP
5180	289	15	appointed	appoint	VBN
5180	289	16	by	by	IN
5180	289	17	elected	elect	VBN
5180	289	18	county	county	NN
5180	289	19	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
5180	289	20	.	.	.
5180	290	1	The	the	DT
5180	290	2	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
5180	290	3	County	County	NNP
5180	290	4	Library	Library	NNP
5180	290	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	290	6	a	a	DT
5180	290	7	county	county	NN
5180	290	8	department	department	NN
5180	290	9	,	,	,
5180	290	10	whose	whose	WP$
5180	290	11	board	board	NN
5180	290	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	290	13	appointed	appoint	VBN
5180	290	14	by	by	IN
5180	290	15	the	the	DT
5180	290	16	county	county	NN
5180	290	17	chair	chair	NN
5180	290	18	and	and	CC
5180	290	19	confirmed	confirm	VBD
5180	290	20	by	by	IN
5180	290	21	the	the	DT
5180	290	22	other	other	JJ
5180	290	23	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
5180	290	24	.	.	.
5180	291	1	The	the	DT
5180	291	2	SCLS	SCLS	NNP
5180	291	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	291	4	an	an	DT
5180	291	5	aggregation	aggregation	NN
5180	291	6	of	of	IN
5180	291	7	51	51	CD
5180	291	8	independently	independently	RB
5180	291	9	governed	govern	VBN
5180	291	10	statutory	statutory	JJ
5180	291	11	member	member	NN
5180	291	12	public	public	JJ
5180	291	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	291	14	,	,	,
5180	291	15	whose	whose	WP$
5180	291	16	relationship	relationship	NN
5180	291	17	to	to	IN
5180	291	18	SCLS	SCLS	NNP
5180	291	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	291	20	defined	define	VBN
5180	291	21	by	by	IN
5180	291	22	state	state	NN
5180	291	23	law	law	NN
5180	291	24	.	.	.
5180	292	1	The	the	DT
5180	292	2	governing	govern	VBG
5180	292	3	body	body	NN
5180	292	4	of	of	IN
5180	292	5	the	the	DT
5180	292	6	SCLS	SCLS	NNP
5180	292	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	292	8	the	the	DT
5180	292	9	Library	Library	NNP
5180	292	10	Board	Board	NNP
5180	292	11	of	of	IN
5180	292	12	Trustees	Trustees	NNPS
5180	292	13	,	,	,
5180	292	14	which	which	WDT
5180	292	15	consists	consist	VBZ
5180	292	16	of	of	IN
5180	292	17	20	20	CD
5180	292	18	members	member	NNS
5180	292	19	nominated	nominate	VBN
5180	292	20	by	by	IN
5180	292	21	county	county	NN
5180	292	22	executives	executive	NNS
5180	292	23	and	and	CC
5180	292	24	ratified	ratify	VBN
5180	292	25	by	by	IN
5180	292	26	county	county	NN
5180	292	27	boards	board	NNS
5180	292	28	of	of	IN
5180	292	29	supervisors	supervisor	NNS
5180	292	30	.	.	.
5180	293	1	2	2	LS
5180	293	2	.	.	.
5180	294	1	Patron	Patron	NNP
5180	294	2	and	and	CC
5180	294	3	Patron	Patron	NNP
5180	294	4	Association	Association	NNP
5180	294	5	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNPS
5180	294	6	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNPS
5180	294	7	Association	Association	NNP
5180	294	8	of	of	IN
5180	294	9	Community	Community	NNP
5180	294	10	Organizations	Organizations	NNP
5180	294	11	for	for	IN
5180	294	12	Reform	Reform	NNP
5180	294	13	Now	now	RB
5180	294	14	,	,	,
5180	294	15	Friends	Friends	NNPS
5180	294	16	of	of	IN
5180	294	17	the	the	DT
5180	294	18	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
5180	294	19	City	City	NNP
5180	294	20	Institute	Institute	NNP
5180	294	21	Library	Library	NNP
5180	294	22	,	,	,
5180	294	23	and	and	CC
5180	294	24	the	the	DT
5180	294	25	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
5180	294	26	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
5180	294	27	for	for	IN
5180	294	28	Democracy	Democracy	NNP
5180	294	29	are	be	VBP
5180	294	30	nonprofit	nonprofit	JJ
5180	294	31	organizations	organization	NNS
5180	294	32	whose	whose	WP$
5180	294	33	members	member	NNS
5180	294	34	include	include	VBP
5180	294	35	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	294	36	who	who	WP
5180	294	37	access	access	VBP
5180	294	38	the	the	DT
5180	294	39	Internet	internet	NN
5180	294	40	at	at	IN
5180	294	41	public	public	JJ
5180	294	42	libraries	library	NNS
5180	294	43	that	that	WDT
5180	294	44	receive	receive	VBP
5180	294	45	E	e	NN
5180	294	46	-	-	NN
5180	294	47	rate	rate	NN
5180	294	48	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	294	49	or	or	CC
5180	294	50	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	294	51	funds	fund	NNS
5180	294	52	for	for	IN
5180	294	53	the	the	DT
5180	294	54	provision	provision	NN
5180	294	55	of	of	IN
5180	294	56	public	public	JJ
5180	294	57	Internet	internet	NN
5180	294	58	access	access	NN
5180	294	59	.	.	.
5180	295	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	295	2	note	note	VBP
5180	295	3	for	for	IN
5180	295	4	the	the	DT
5180	295	5	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	295	6	of	of	IN
5180	295	7	associational	associational	JJ
5180	295	8	standing	standing	NN
5180	295	9	that	that	IN
5180	295	10	the	the	DT
5180	295	11	interests	interest	NNS
5180	295	12	that	that	WDT
5180	295	13	these	these	DT
5180	295	14	organizations	organization	NNS
5180	295	15	seek	seek	VBP
5180	295	16	to	to	TO
5180	295	17	protect	protect	VB
5180	295	18	in	in	IN
5180	295	19	this	this	DT
5180	295	20	litigation	litigation	NN
5180	295	21	are	be	VBP
5180	295	22	germane	germane	NN
5180	295	23	to	to	IN
5180	295	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	295	25	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	295	26	.	.	.
5180	296	1	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNP
5180	296	2	Emmalyn	Emmalyn	NNP
5180	296	3	Rood	Rood	NNP
5180	296	4	,	,	,
5180	296	5	Mark	Mark	NNP
5180	296	6	Brown	Brown	NNP
5180	296	7	,	,	,
5180	296	8	Elizabeth	Elizabeth	NNP
5180	296	9	Hrenda	Hrenda	NNP
5180	296	10	,	,	,
5180	296	11	C.	C.	NNP
5180	296	12	Donald	Donald	NNP
5180	296	13	Weinberg	Weinberg	NNP
5180	296	14	,	,	,
5180	296	15	Sherron	Sherron	NNP
5180	296	16	Dixon	Dixon	NNP
5180	296	17	,	,	,
5180	296	18	by	by	IN
5180	296	19	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	296	20	father	father	NN
5180	296	21	and	and	CC
5180	296	22	next	next	JJ
5180	296	23	friend	friend	NN
5180	296	24	Gordon	Gordon	NNP
5180	296	25	Dixon	Dixon	NNP
5180	296	26	,	,	,
5180	296	27	James	James	NNP
5180	296	28	Geringer	Geringer	NNP
5180	296	29	,	,	,
5180	296	30	Marnique	Marnique	NNP
5180	296	31	Tynesha	Tynesha	NNP
5180	296	32	Overby	Overby	NNP
5180	296	33	,	,	,
5180	296	34	by	by	IN
5180	296	35	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	296	36	next	next	JJ
5180	296	37	friend	friend	NN
5180	296	38	Carolyn	Carolyn	NNP
5180	296	39	C.	C.	NNP
5180	296	40	Williams	Williams	NNP
5180	296	41	,	,	,
5180	296	42	William	William	NNP
5180	296	43	J.	J.	NNP
5180	296	44	Rosenbaum	Rosenbaum	NNP
5180	296	45	,	,	,
5180	296	46	Carolyn	Carolyn	NNP
5180	296	47	C.	C.	NNP
5180	296	48	Williams	Williams	NNP
5180	296	49	,	,	,
5180	296	50	and	and	CC
5180	296	51	Quiana	Quiana	NNP
5180	296	52	Williams	Williams	NNP
5180	296	53	,	,	,
5180	296	54	by	by	IN
5180	296	55	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	296	56	mother	mother	NN
5180	296	57	and	and	CC
5180	296	58	next	next	JJ
5180	296	59	friend	friend	NN
5180	296	60	Sharon	Sharon	NNP
5180	296	61	Bernard	Bernard	NNP
5180	296	62	,	,	,
5180	296	63	are	be	VBP
5180	296	64	adults	adult	NNS
5180	296	65	and	and	CC
5180	296	66	minors	minor	NNS
5180	296	67	who	who	WP
5180	296	68	use	use	VBP
5180	296	69	the	the	DT
5180	296	70	Internet	internet	NN
5180	296	71	at	at	IN
5180	296	72	public	public	JJ
5180	296	73	libraries	library	NNS
5180	296	74	that	that	WDT
5180	296	75	,	,	,
5180	296	76	to	to	IN
5180	296	77	the	the	DT
5180	296	78	best	good	JJS
5180	296	79	of	of	IN
5180	296	80	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	296	81	knowledge	knowledge	NN
5180	296	82	,	,	,
5180	296	83	do	do	VB
5180	296	84	not	not	RB
5180	296	85	filter	filter	VB
5180	296	86	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	296	87	'	'	POS
5180	296	88	access	access	NN
5180	296	89	to	to	IN
5180	296	90	the	the	DT
5180	296	91	Internet	internet	NN
5180	296	92	.	.	.
5180	297	1	Several	several	JJ
5180	297	2	of	of	IN
5180	297	3	these	these	DT
5180	297	4	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	297	5	do	do	VBP
5180	297	6	not	not	RB
5180	297	7	have	have	VB
5180	297	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	297	9	access	access	NN
5180	297	10	from	from	IN
5180	297	11	home	home	NN
5180	297	12	.	.	.
5180	298	1	Emmalyn	Emmalyn	NNP
5180	298	2	Rood	Rood	NNP
5180	298	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	298	4	a	a	DT
5180	298	5	sixteen	sixteen	CD
5180	298	6	-	-	HYPH
5180	298	7	year	year	NN
5180	298	8	-	-	HYPH
5180	298	9	old	old	JJ
5180	298	10	who	who	WP
5180	298	11	uses	use	VBZ
5180	298	12	the	the	DT
5180	298	13	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
5180	298	14	County	County	NNP
5180	298	15	Public	Public	NNP
5180	298	16	Library	Library	NNP
5180	298	17	.	.	.
5180	299	1	When	when	WRB
5180	299	2	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	299	3	was	be	VBD
5180	299	4	13	13	CD
5180	299	5	,	,	,
5180	299	6	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	299	7	used	use	VBD
5180	299	8	the	the	DT
5180	299	9	Internet	internet	NN
5180	299	10	at	at	IN
5180	299	11	the	the	DT
5180	299	12	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
5180	299	13	County	County	NNP
5180	299	14	Public	Public	NNP
5180	299	15	Library	Library	NNP
5180	299	16	to	to	TO
5180	299	17	research	research	VB
5180	299	18	issues	issue	NNS
5180	299	19	relating	relate	VBG
5180	299	20	to	to	IN
5180	299	21	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	299	22	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	299	23	identity	identity	NN
5180	299	24	.	.	.
5180	300	1	Ms.	Ms.	NNP
5180	300	2	Rood	Rood	NNP
5180	300	3	did	do	VBD
5180	300	4	not	not	RB
5180	300	5	use	use	VB
5180	300	6	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	300	7	home	home	NN
5180	300	8	or	or	CC
5180	300	9	school	school	NN
5180	300	10	computer	computer	NN
5180	300	11	for	for	IN
5180	300	12	this	this	DT
5180	300	13	research	research	NN
5180	300	14	,	,	,
5180	300	15	in	in	IN
5180	300	16	part	part	NN
5180	300	17	because	because	IN
5180	300	18	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	300	19	wished	wish	VBD
5180	300	20	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	300	21	searching	search	VBG
5180	300	22	to	to	TO
5180	300	23	be	be	VB
5180	300	24	private	private	JJ
5180	300	25	.	.	.
5180	301	1	Although	although	IN
5180	301	2	the	the	DT
5180	301	3	library	library	NN
5180	301	4	offered	offer	VBD
5180	301	5	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	301	6	the	the	DT
5180	301	7	option	option	NN
5180	301	8	of	of	IN
5180	301	9	using	use	VBG
5180	301	10	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	301	11	software	software	NN
5180	301	12	,	,	,
5180	301	13	Ms.	Ms.	NNP
5180	301	14	Rood	Rood	NNP
5180	301	15	did	do	VBD
5180	301	16	not	not	RB
5180	301	17	use	use	VB
5180	301	18	that	that	DT
5180	301	19	option	option	NN
5180	301	20	because	because	IN
5180	301	21	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	301	22	had	have	VBD
5180	301	23	had	have	VBN
5180	301	24	previous	previous	JJ
5180	301	25	experience	experience	NN
5180	301	26	with	with	IN
5180	301	27	such	such	JJ
5180	301	28	programs	program	NNS
5180	301	29	blocking	block	VBG
5180	301	30	information	information	NN
5180	301	31	that	that	WDT
5180	301	32	was	be	VBD
5180	301	33	valuable	valuable	JJ
5180	301	34	to	to	IN
5180	301	35	her	-PRON-	PRP
5180	301	36	,	,	,
5180	301	37	including	include	VBG
5180	301	38	information	information	NN
5180	301	39	relating	relate	VBG
5180	301	40	to	to	IN
5180	301	41	gay	gay	JJ
5180	301	42	and	and	CC
5180	301	43	lesbian	lesbian	JJ
5180	301	44	issues	issue	NNS
5180	301	45	.	.	.
5180	302	1	Plaintiff	Plaintiff	NNP
5180	302	2	Mark	Mark	NNP
5180	302	3	Brown	Brown	NNP
5180	302	4	used	use	VBD
5180	302	5	the	the	DT
5180	302	6	Internet	internet	NN
5180	302	7	at	at	IN
5180	302	8	the	the	DT
5180	302	9	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
5180	302	10	Free	Free	NNP
5180	302	11	Library	Library	NNP
5180	302	12	to	to	TO
5180	302	13	research	research	VB
5180	302	14	breast	breast	NN
5180	302	15	cancer	cancer	NN
5180	302	16	and	and	CC
5180	302	17	reconstructive	reconstructive	JJ
5180	302	18	surgery	surgery	NN
5180	302	19	for	for	IN
5180	302	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	302	21	mother	mother	NN
5180	302	22	who	who	WP
5180	302	23	had	have	VBD
5180	302	24	breast	breast	NN
5180	302	25	surgery	surgery	NN
5180	302	26	.	.	.
5180	303	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
5180	303	2	Brown	Brown	NNP
5180	303	3	's	's	POS
5180	303	4	research	research	NN
5180	303	5	at	at	IN
5180	303	6	the	the	DT
5180	303	7	library	library	NN
5180	303	8	provided	provide	VBD
5180	303	9	him	-PRON-	PRP
5180	303	10	and	and	CC
5180	303	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	303	12	mother	mother	NN
5180	303	13	with	with	IN
5180	303	14	essential	essential	JJ
5180	303	15	information	information	NN
5180	303	16	about	about	IN
5180	303	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	303	18	mother	mother	NN
5180	303	19	's	's	POS
5180	303	20	medical	medical	JJ
5180	303	21	condition	condition	NN
5180	303	22	and	and	CC
5180	303	23	potential	potential	JJ
5180	303	24	treatments	treatment	NNS
5180	303	25	.	.	.
5180	304	1	3	3	LS
5180	304	2	.	.	.
5180	305	1	Web	web	NN
5180	305	2	Publisher	publisher	NN
5180	305	3	Plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	305	4	Plaintiff	Plaintiff	NNP
5180	305	5	Afraid	Afraid	NNP
5180	305	6	to	to	TO
5180	305	7	Ask	Ask	NNP
5180	305	8	,	,	,
5180	305	9	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	305	10	,	,	,
5180	305	11	based	base	VBN
5180	305	12	in	in	IN
5180	305	13	Saunderstown	Saunderstown	NNP
5180	305	14	,	,	,
5180	305	15	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
5180	305	16	Island	Island	NNP
5180	305	17	,	,	,
5180	305	18	publishes	publish	VBZ
5180	305	19	a	a	DT
5180	305	20	health	health	NN
5180	305	21	education	education	NN
5180	305	22	Web	web	NN
5180	305	23	site	site	NN
5180	305	24	,	,	,
5180	305	25	www.AfraidtoAsk.com	www.AfraidtoAsk.com	NNP
5180	305	26	.	.	.
5180	306	1	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
5180	306	2	Jonathan	Jonathan	NNP
5180	306	3	Bertman	Bertman	NNP
5180	306	4	,	,	,
5180	306	5	the	the	DT
5180	306	6	president	president	NN
5180	306	7	and	and	CC
5180	306	8	medical	medical	JJ
5180	306	9	director	director	NN
5180	306	10	of	of	IN
5180	306	11	Afraid	Afraid	NNP
5180	306	12	to	to	TO
5180	306	13	Ask	ask	VB
5180	306	14	,	,	,
5180	306	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	306	16	a	a	DT
5180	306	17	family	family	NN
5180	306	18	practice	practice	NN
5180	306	19	physician	physician	NN
5180	306	20	in	in	IN
5180	306	21	rural	rural	JJ
5180	306	22	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
5180	306	23	Island	Island	NNP
5180	306	24	and	and	CC
5180	306	25	a	a	DT
5180	306	26	clinical	clinical	JJ
5180	306	27	assistant	assistant	NN
5180	306	28	professor	professor	NN
5180	306	29	of	of	IN
5180	306	30	family	family	NN
5180	306	31	medicine	medicine	NN
5180	306	32	at	at	IN
5180	306	33	Brown	Brown	NNP
5180	306	34	University	University	NNP
5180	306	35	.	.	.
5180	307	1	AfraidtoAsk.com	AfraidtoAsk.com	NNP
5180	307	2	's	's	POS
5180	307	3	mission	mission	NN
5180	307	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	307	5	to	to	TO
5180	307	6	provide	provide	VB
5180	307	7	detailed	detailed	JJ
5180	307	8	information	information	NN
5180	307	9	on	on	IN
5180	307	10	sensitive	sensitive	JJ
5180	307	11	health	health	NN
5180	307	12	issues	issue	NNS
5180	307	13	,	,	,
5180	307	14	often	often	RB
5180	307	15	of	of	IN
5180	307	16	a	a	DT
5180	307	17	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	307	18	nature	nature	NN
5180	307	19	,	,	,
5180	307	20	such	such	JJ
5180	307	21	as	as	IN
5180	307	22	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	307	23	transmitted	transmit	VBN
5180	307	24	diseases	disease	NNS
5180	307	25	,	,	,
5180	307	26	male	male	JJ
5180	307	27	and	and	CC
5180	307	28	female	female	JJ
5180	307	29	genitalia	genitalia	NNS
5180	307	30	,	,	,
5180	307	31	and	and	CC
5180	307	32	birth	birth	NN
5180	307	33	control	control	NN
5180	307	34	,	,	,
5180	307	35	sought	seek	VBN
5180	307	36	by	by	IN
5180	307	37	people	people	NNS
5180	307	38	of	of	IN
5180	307	39	all	all	DT
5180	307	40	ages	age	NNS
5180	307	41	who	who	WP
5180	307	42	would	would	MD
5180	307	43	prefer	prefer	VB
5180	307	44	to	to	TO
5180	307	45	learn	learn	VB
5180	307	46	about	about	IN
5180	307	47	sensitive	sensitive	JJ
5180	307	48	health	health	NN
5180	307	49	issues	issue	NNS
5180	307	50	anonymously	anonymously	RB
5180	307	51	,	,	,
5180	307	52	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	307	53	,	,	,
5180	307	54	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	307	55	are	be	VBP
5180	307	56	"	"	``
5180	307	57	afraid	afraid	JJ
5180	307	58	to	to	TO
5180	307	59	ask	ask	VB
5180	307	60	.	.	.
5180	307	61	"	"	''
5180	308	1	As	as	IN
5180	308	2	part	part	NN
5180	308	3	of	of	IN
5180	308	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	308	5	educational	educational	JJ
5180	308	6	mission	mission	NN
5180	308	7	,	,	,
5180	308	8	AfraidtoAsk.com	AfraidtoAsk.com	NNP
5180	308	9	often	often	RB
5180	308	10	uses	use	VBZ
5180	308	11	graphic	graphic	JJ
5180	308	12	images	image	NNS
5180	308	13	of	of	IN
5180	308	14	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	308	15	anatomy	anatomy	NN
5180	308	16	to	to	TO
5180	308	17	convey	convey	VB
5180	308	18	information	information	NN
5180	308	19	.	.	.
5180	309	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	309	2	primary	primary	JJ
5180	309	3	audience	audience	NN
5180	309	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	309	5	teens	teen	NNS
5180	309	6	and	and	CC
5180	309	7	young	young	JJ
5180	309	8	adults	adult	NNS
5180	309	9	.	.	.
5180	310	1	Based	base	VBN
5180	310	2	on	on	IN
5180	310	3	survey	survey	NN
5180	310	4	data	datum	NNS
5180	310	5	collected	collect	VBN
5180	310	6	on	on	IN
5180	310	7	the	the	DT
5180	310	8	site	site	NN
5180	310	9	,	,	,
5180	310	10	half	half	NN
5180	310	11	of	of	IN
5180	310	12	the	the	DT
5180	310	13	people	people	NNS
5180	310	14	visiting	visit	VBG
5180	310	15	the	the	DT
5180	310	16	site	site	NN
5180	310	17	are	be	VBP
5180	310	18	under	under	IN
5180	310	19	24	24	CD
5180	310	20	years	year	NNS
5180	310	21	old	old	JJ
5180	310	22	and	and	CC
5180	310	23	a	a	DT
5180	310	24	quarter	quarter	NN
5180	310	25	are	be	VBP
5180	310	26	under	under	IN
5180	310	27	18	18	CD
5180	310	28	.	.	.
5180	311	1	AfraidtoAsk.com	AfraidtoAsk.com	NNP
5180	311	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	311	3	blocked	block	VBN
5180	311	4	by	by	IN
5180	311	5	several	several	JJ
5180	311	6	leading	lead	VBG
5180	311	7	blocking	blocking	NN
5180	311	8	products	product	NNS
5180	311	9	as	as	IN
5180	311	10	containing	contain	VBG
5180	311	11	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	311	12	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	311	13	content	content	NN
5180	311	14	.	.	.
5180	312	1	Plaintiff	Plaintiff	NNP
5180	312	2	Alan	Alan	NNP
5180	312	3	Guttmacher	Guttmacher	NNP
5180	312	4	Institute	Institute	NNP
5180	312	5	has	have	VBZ
5180	312	6	a	a	DT
5180	312	7	Web	web	NN
5180	312	8	site	site	NN
5180	312	9	that	that	WDT
5180	312	10	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	312	11	information	information	NN
5180	312	12	about	about	IN
5180	312	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	312	14	activities	activity	NNS
5180	312	15	and	and	CC
5180	312	16	objectives	objective	NNS
5180	312	17	,	,	,
5180	312	18	including	include	VBG
5180	312	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	312	20	mission	mission	NN
5180	312	21	to	to	TO
5180	312	22	protect	protect	VB
5180	312	23	the	the	DT
5180	312	24	reproductive	reproductive	JJ
5180	312	25	choices	choice	NNS
5180	312	26	of	of	IN
5180	312	27	women	woman	NNS
5180	312	28	and	and	CC
5180	312	29	men	man	NNS
5180	312	30	.	.	.
5180	313	1	Plaintiff	Plaintiff	NNP
5180	313	2	Planned	Planned	NNP
5180	313	3	Parenthood	Parenthood	NNP
5180	313	4	Federation	Federation	NNP
5180	313	5	of	of	IN
5180	313	6	America	America	NNP
5180	313	7	,	,	,
5180	313	8	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	313	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	313	10	"	"	``
5180	313	11	Planned	Planned	NNP
5180	313	12	Parenthood	Parenthood	NNP
5180	313	13	"	"	''
5180	313	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	313	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	313	16	a	a	DT
5180	313	17	national	national	JJ
5180	313	18	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
5180	313	19	organization	organization	NN
5180	313	20	in	in	IN
5180	313	21	the	the	DT
5180	313	22	field	field	NN
5180	313	23	of	of	IN
5180	313	24	reproductive	reproductive	JJ
5180	313	25	health	health	NN
5180	313	26	care	care	NN
5180	313	27	.	.	.
5180	314	1	Planned	Planned	NNP
5180	314	2	Parenthood	Parenthood	NNP
5180	314	3	owns	own	VBZ
5180	314	4	and	and	CC
5180	314	5	operates	operate	VBZ
5180	314	6	several	several	JJ
5180	314	7	Web	web	NN
5180	314	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	314	9	that	that	WDT
5180	314	10	provide	provide	VBP
5180	314	11	a	a	DT
5180	314	12	range	range	NN
5180	314	13	of	of	IN
5180	314	14	information	information	NN
5180	314	15	about	about	IN
5180	314	16	reproductive	reproductive	JJ
5180	314	17	health	health	NNP
5180	314	18	,	,	,
5180	314	19	from	from	IN
5180	314	20	contraception	contraception	NN
5180	314	21	to	to	IN
5180	314	22	prevention	prevention	NN
5180	314	23	of	of	IN
5180	314	24	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	314	25	transmitted	transmit	VBN
5180	314	26	diseases	disease	NNS
5180	314	27	,	,	,
5180	314	28	to	to	IN
5180	314	29	finding	find	VBG
5180	314	30	an	an	DT
5180	314	31	abortion	abortion	NN
5180	314	32	provider	provider	NN
5180	314	33	,	,	,
5180	314	34	and	and	CC
5180	314	35	to	to	IN
5180	314	36	information	information	NN
5180	314	37	about	about	IN
5180	314	38	the	the	DT
5180	314	39	drug	drug	NN
5180	314	40	Mifepristone	Mifepristone	NNP
5180	314	41	.	.	.
5180	315	1	Plaintiff	Plaintiff	NNP
5180	315	2	Safersex.org	Safersex.org	NNP
5180	315	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	315	4	a	a	DT
5180	315	5	Web	web	NN
5180	315	6	site	site	NN
5180	315	7	that	that	WDT
5180	315	8	offers	offer	VBZ
5180	315	9	free	free	JJ
5180	315	10	educational	educational	JJ
5180	315	11	information	information	NN
5180	315	12	on	on	IN
5180	315	13	how	how	WRB
5180	315	14	to	to	TO
5180	315	15	practice	practice	VB
5180	315	16	safer	safe	JJR
5180	315	17	sex	sex	NN
5180	315	18	.	.	.
5180	316	1	Plaintiff	Plaintiff	NNP
5180	316	2	Ethan	Ethan	NNP
5180	316	3	Interactive	Interactive	NNP
5180	316	4	,	,	,
5180	316	5	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	316	6	,	,	,
5180	316	7	d	d	NNP
5180	316	8	/	/	SYM
5180	316	9	b	b	NNP
5180	316	10	/	/	SYM
5180	316	11	a	a	NN
5180	316	12	Out	Out	NNP
5180	316	13	In	in	IN
5180	316	14	America	America	NNP
5180	316	15	,	,	,
5180	316	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	316	17	an	an	DT
5180	316	18	online	online	JJ
5180	316	19	content	content	NN
5180	316	20	provider	provider	NN
5180	316	21	that	that	WDT
5180	316	22	owns	own	VBZ
5180	316	23	and	and	CC
5180	316	24	operates	operate	VBZ
5180	316	25	64	64	CD
5180	316	26	free	free	JJ
5180	316	27	Web	web	NN
5180	316	28	sites	site	NNS
5180	316	29	for	for	IN
5180	316	30	gay	gay	JJ
5180	316	31	,	,	,
5180	316	32	lesbian	lesbian	JJ
5180	316	33	,	,	,
5180	316	34	bisexual	bisexual	JJ
5180	316	35	and	and	CC
5180	316	36	transgendered	transgendered	JJ
5180	316	37	persons	person	NNS
5180	316	38	worldwide	worldwide	RB
5180	316	39	.	.	.
5180	317	1	Plaintiff	Plaintiff	NNP
5180	317	2	PlanetOut	PlanetOut	NNP
5180	317	3	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
5180	317	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	317	5	an	an	DT
5180	317	6	online	online	JJ
5180	317	7	content	content	NN
5180	317	8	provider	provider	NN
5180	317	9	for	for	IN
5180	317	10	gay	gay	NNP
5180	317	11	,	,	,
5180	317	12	lesbian	lesbian	JJ
5180	317	13	,	,	,
5180	317	14	bisexual	bisexual	JJ
5180	317	15	and	and	CC
5180	317	16	transgendered	transgendered	JJ
5180	317	17	persons	person	NNS
5180	317	18	.	.	.
5180	318	1	Plaintiff	plaintiff	VB
5180	318	2	the	the	DT
5180	318	3	Naturist	Naturist	NNP
5180	318	4	Action	Action	NNP
5180	318	5	Committee	Committee	NNP
5180	318	6	(	(	-LRB-
5180	318	7	"	"	``
5180	318	8	NAC	NAC	NNP
5180	318	9	"	"	''
5180	318	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	318	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	318	12	the	the	DT
5180	318	13	nonprofit	nonprofit	JJ
5180	318	14	political	political	JJ
5180	318	15	arm	arm	NN
5180	318	16	of	of	IN
5180	318	17	the	the	DT
5180	318	18	Naturist	Naturist	NNP
5180	318	19	Society	Society	NNP
5180	318	20	,	,	,
5180	318	21	a	a	DT
5180	318	22	private	private	JJ
5180	318	23	organization	organization	NN
5180	318	24	that	that	WDT
5180	318	25	promotes	promote	VBZ
5180	318	26	a	a	DT
5180	318	27	way	way	NN
5180	318	28	of	of	IN
5180	318	29	life	life	NN
5180	318	30	characterized	characterize	VBN
5180	318	31	by	by	IN
5180	318	32	the	the	DT
5180	318	33	practice	practice	NN
5180	318	34	of	of	IN
5180	318	35	nudity	nudity	NN
5180	318	36	.	.	.
5180	319	1	The	the	DT
5180	319	2	NAC	NAC	NNP
5180	319	3	Web	web	NN
5180	319	4	site	site	NN
5180	319	5	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	319	6	information	information	NN
5180	319	7	about	about	IN
5180	319	8	Naturist	Naturist	NNP
5180	319	9	Society	Society	NNP
5180	319	10	activities	activity	NNS
5180	319	11	and	and	CC
5180	319	12	about	about	IN
5180	319	13	state	state	NN
5180	319	14	and	and	CC
5180	319	15	local	local	JJ
5180	319	16	laws	law	NNS
5180	319	17	that	that	WDT
5180	319	18	may	may	MD
5180	319	19	affect	affect	VB
5180	319	20	the	the	DT
5180	319	21	rights	right	NNS
5180	319	22	of	of	IN
5180	319	23	Naturists	Naturists	NNPS
5180	319	24	or	or	CC
5180	319	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	319	26	ability	ability	NN
5180	319	27	to	to	TO
5180	319	28	practice	practice	VB
5180	319	29	Naturism	naturism	NN
5180	319	30	,	,	,
5180	319	31	and	and	CC
5180	319	32	includes	include	VBZ
5180	319	33	nude	nude	JJ
5180	319	34	photographs	photograph	NNS
5180	319	35	of	of	IN
5180	319	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	319	37	members	member	NNS
5180	319	38	.	.	.
5180	320	1	Plaintiff	Plaintiff	NNP
5180	320	2	Wayne	Wayne	NNP
5180	320	3	L.	L.	NNP
5180	320	4	Parker	Parker	NNP
5180	320	5	was	be	VBD
5180	320	6	the	the	DT
5180	320	7	Libertarian	libertarian	JJ
5180	320	8	candidate	candidate	NN
5180	320	9	in	in	IN
5180	320	10	the	the	DT
5180	320	11	2000	2000	CD
5180	320	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	320	13	Congressional	congressional	JJ
5180	320	14	election	election	NN
5180	320	15	for	for	IN
5180	320	16	the	the	DT
5180	320	17	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
5180	320	18	District	District	NNP
5180	320	19	of	of	IN
5180	320	20	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
5180	320	21	(	(	-LRB-
5180	320	22	and	and	CC
5180	320	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	320	24	running	run	VBG
5180	320	25	again	again	RB
5180	320	26	in	in	IN
5180	320	27	2002	2002	CD
5180	320	28	)	)	-RRB-
5180	320	29	.	.	.
5180	321	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	321	2	publishes	publish	VBZ
5180	321	3	a	a	DT
5180	321	4	Web	web	NN
5180	321	5	site	site	NN
5180	321	6	that	that	WDT
5180	321	7	communicates	communicate	VBZ
5180	321	8	information	information	NN
5180	321	9	about	about	IN
5180	321	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	321	11	campaign	campaign	NN
5180	321	12	and	and	CC
5180	321	13	that	that	DT
5180	321	14	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	321	15	information	information	NN
5180	321	16	about	about	IN
5180	321	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	321	18	political	political	JJ
5180	321	19	views	view	NNS
5180	321	20	and	and	CC
5180	321	21	the	the	DT
5180	321	22	Libertarian	Libertarian	NNP
5180	321	23	Party	Party	NNP
5180	321	24	to	to	IN
5180	321	25	the	the	DT
5180	321	26	public	public	NN
5180	321	27	.	.	.
5180	322	1	Plaintiff	Plaintiff	NNP
5180	322	2	Jeffrey	Jeffrey	NNP
5180	322	3	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
5180	322	4	was	be	VBD
5180	322	5	the	the	DT
5180	322	6	Republican	republican	JJ
5180	322	7	candidate	candidate	NN
5180	322	8	in	in	IN
5180	322	9	the	the	DT
5180	322	10	2000	2000	CD
5180	322	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	322	12	Congressional	congressional	JJ
5180	322	13	election	election	NN
5180	322	14	for	for	IN
5180	322	15	the	the	DT
5180	322	16	Third	Third	NNP
5180	322	17	District	District	NNP
5180	322	18	of	of	IN
5180	322	19	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
5180	322	20	.	.	.
5180	323	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	323	2	operates	operate	VBZ
5180	323	3	a	a	DT
5180	323	4	Web	web	NN
5180	323	5	site	site	NN
5180	323	6	that	that	WDT
5180	323	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	323	8	now	now	RB
5180	323	9	promoting	promote	VBG
5180	323	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	323	11	candidacy	candidacy	NN
5180	323	12	for	for	IN
5180	323	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	323	14	in	in	IN
5180	323	15	2002	2002	CD
5180	323	16	.	.	.
5180	324	1	3	3	LS
5180	324	2	.	.	.
5180	325	1	The	the	DT
5180	325	2	Internet	internet	NN
5180	325	3	1	1	CD
5180	325	4	.	.	.
5180	326	1	Background	Background	NNP
5180	326	2	As	as	IN
5180	326	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	326	4	noted	note	VBD
5180	326	5	at	at	IN
5180	326	6	the	the	DT
5180	326	7	outset	outset	NN
5180	326	8	,	,	,
5180	326	9	the	the	DT
5180	326	10	Internet	internet	NN
5180	326	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	326	12	a	a	DT
5180	326	13	vast	vast	JJ
5180	326	14	,	,	,
5180	326	15	interactive	interactive	JJ
5180	326	16	medium	medium	NN
5180	326	17	consisting	consist	VBG
5180	326	18	of	of	IN
5180	326	19	a	a	DT
5180	326	20	decentralized	decentralized	JJ
5180	326	21	network	network	NN
5180	326	22	of	of	IN
5180	326	23	computers	computer	NNS
5180	326	24	around	around	IN
5180	326	25	the	the	DT
5180	326	26	world	world	NN
5180	326	27	.	.	.
5180	327	1	The	the	DT
5180	327	2	Internet	internet	NN
5180	327	3	presents	present	VBZ
5180	327	4	low	low	JJ
5180	327	5	entry	entry	NN
5180	327	6	barriers	barrier	NNS
5180	327	7	to	to	IN
5180	327	8	anyone	anyone	NN
5180	327	9	who	who	WP
5180	327	10	wishes	wish	VBZ
5180	327	11	to	to	TO
5180	327	12	provide	provide	VB
5180	327	13	or	or	CC
5180	327	14	distribute	distribute	VB
5180	327	15	information	information	NN
5180	327	16	.	.	.
5180	328	1	Unlike	unlike	IN
5180	328	2	television	television	NN
5180	328	3	,	,	,
5180	328	4	cable	cable	NN
5180	328	5	,	,	,
5180	328	6	radio	radio	NN
5180	328	7	,	,	,
5180	328	8	newspapers	newspaper	NNS
5180	328	9	,	,	,
5180	328	10	magazines	magazine	NNS
5180	328	11	or	or	CC
5180	328	12	books	book	NNS
5180	328	13	,	,	,
5180	328	14	the	the	DT
5180	328	15	Internet	internet	NN
5180	328	16	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	328	17	an	an	DT
5180	328	18	opportunity	opportunity	NN
5180	328	19	for	for	IN
5180	328	20	those	those	DT
5180	328	21	with	with	IN
5180	328	22	access	access	NN
5180	328	23	to	to	IN
5180	328	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	328	25	to	to	TO
5180	328	26	communicate	communicate	VB
5180	328	27	with	with	IN
5180	328	28	a	a	DT
5180	328	29	worldwide	worldwide	JJ
5180	328	30	audience	audience	NN
5180	328	31	at	at	IN
5180	328	32	little	little	JJ
5180	328	33	cost	cost	NN
5180	328	34	.	.	.
5180	329	1	At	at	RB
5180	329	2	least	least	JJS
5180	329	3	400	400	CD
5180	329	4	million	million	CD
5180	329	5	people	people	NNS
5180	329	6	use	use	VBP
5180	329	7	the	the	DT
5180	329	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	329	9	worldwide	worldwide	RB
5180	329	10	,	,	,
5180	329	11	and	and	CC
5180	329	12	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	329	13	143	143	CD
5180	329	14	million	million	CD
5180	329	15	Americans	Americans	NNPS
5180	329	16	were	be	VBD
5180	329	17	using	use	VBG
5180	329	18	the	the	DT
5180	329	19	Internet	internet	NN
5180	329	20	as	as	IN
5180	329	21	of	of	IN
5180	329	22	September	September	NNP
5180	329	23	2001	2001	CD
5180	329	24	.	.	.
5180	330	1	Nat'l	Nat'l	NNP
5180	330	2	Telecomm	Telecomm	NNP
5180	330	3	.	.	.
5180	331	1	&	&	CC
5180	331	2	Info	Info	NNP
5180	331	3	.	.	.
5180	332	1	Admin	Admin	NNP
5180	332	2	.	.	.
5180	332	3	,	,	,
5180	332	4	A	a	DT
5180	332	5	Nation	Nation	NNP
5180	332	6	Online	online	RB
5180	332	7	:	:	:
5180	332	8	How	how	WRB
5180	332	9	Americans	Americans	NNPS
5180	332	10	Are	be	VBP
5180	332	11	Expanding	expand	VBG
5180	332	12	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	332	13	Use	use	NN
5180	332	14	of	of	IN
5180	332	15	the	the	DT
5180	332	16	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	332	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	332	18	February	February	NNP
5180	332	19	2002	2002	CD
5180	332	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	332	21	,	,	,
5180	332	22	available	available	JJ
5180	332	23	at	at	IN
5180	332	24	http://www.ntia.doc.gov/ntiahome/dn/.	http://www.ntia.doc.gov/ntiahome/dn/.	CD
5180	333	1	The	the	DT
5180	333	2	World	World	NNP
5180	333	3	Wide	Wide	NNP
5180	333	4	Web	Web	NNP
5180	333	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	333	6	a	a	DT
5180	333	7	part	part	NN
5180	333	8	of	of	IN
5180	333	9	the	the	DT
5180	333	10	Internet	internet	NN
5180	333	11	that	that	WDT
5180	333	12	consists	consist	VBZ
5180	333	13	of	of	IN
5180	333	14	a	a	DT
5180	333	15	network	network	NN
5180	333	16	of	of	IN
5180	333	17	computers	computer	NNS
5180	333	18	,	,	,
5180	333	19	called	call	VBN
5180	333	20	"	"	``
5180	333	21	Web	web	NN
5180	333	22	servers	server	NNS
5180	333	23	,	,	,
5180	333	24	"	"	''
5180	333	25	that	that	DT
5180	333	26	host	host	NN
5180	333	27	"	"	``
5180	333	28	pages	page	NNS
5180	333	29	"	"	''
5180	333	30	of	of	IN
5180	333	31	content	content	NN
5180	333	32	accessible	accessible	JJ
5180	333	33	via	via	IN
5180	333	34	the	the	DT
5180	333	35	Hypertext	Hypertext	NNP
5180	333	36	Transfer	Transfer	NNP
5180	333	37	Protocol	Protocol	NNP
5180	333	38	or	or	CC
5180	333	39	"	"	``
5180	333	40	HTTP	HTTP	VBN
5180	333	41	.	.	.
5180	333	42	"	"	''
5180	334	1	Anyone	anyone	NN
5180	334	2	with	with	IN
5180	334	3	a	a	DT
5180	334	4	computer	computer	NN
5180	334	5	connected	connect	VBN
5180	334	6	to	to	IN
5180	334	7	the	the	DT
5180	334	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	334	9	can	can	MD
5180	334	10	search	search	VB
5180	334	11	for	for	IN
5180	334	12	and	and	CC
5180	334	13	retrieve	retrieve	VB
5180	334	14	information	information	NN
5180	334	15	stored	store	VBN
5180	334	16	on	on	IN
5180	334	17	Web	web	NN
5180	334	18	servers	server	NNS
5180	334	19	located	locate	VBN
5180	334	20	around	around	IN
5180	334	21	the	the	DT
5180	334	22	world	world	NN
5180	334	23	.	.	.
5180	335	1	Computer	computer	NN
5180	335	2	users	user	NNS
5180	335	3	typically	typically	RB
5180	335	4	access	access	VBP
5180	335	5	the	the	DT
5180	335	6	Web	web	NN
5180	335	7	by	by	IN
5180	335	8	running	run	VBG
5180	335	9	a	a	DT
5180	335	10	program	program	NN
5180	335	11	called	call	VBN
5180	335	12	a	a	DT
5180	335	13	"	"	``
5180	335	14	browser	browser	NN
5180	335	15	"	"	''
5180	335	16	on	on	IN
5180	335	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	335	18	computers	computer	NNS
5180	335	19	.	.	.
5180	336	1	The	the	DT
5180	336	2	browser	browser	NN
5180	336	3	displays	display	NNS
5180	336	4	,	,	,
5180	336	5	as	as	IN
5180	336	6	individual	individual	JJ
5180	336	7	pages	page	NNS
5180	336	8	on	on	IN
5180	336	9	the	the	DT
5180	336	10	computer	computer	NN
5180	336	11	screen	screen	NN
5180	336	12	,	,	,
5180	336	13	the	the	DT
5180	336	14	various	various	JJ
5180	336	15	types	type	NNS
5180	336	16	of	of	IN
5180	336	17	content	content	NN
5180	336	18	found	find	VBN
5180	336	19	on	on	IN
5180	336	20	the	the	DT
5180	336	21	Web	web	NN
5180	336	22	and	and	CC
5180	336	23	lets	let	VBZ
5180	336	24	the	the	DT
5180	336	25	user	user	NN
5180	336	26	follow	follow	VB
5180	336	27	the	the	DT
5180	336	28	connections	connection	NNS
5180	336	29	built	build	VBN
5180	336	30	into	into	IN
5180	336	31	Web	web	NN
5180	336	32	pages	page	NNS
5180	336	33	–	–	:
5180	336	34	called	call	VBN
5180	336	35	"	"	``
5180	336	36	hypertext	hypertext	NN
5180	336	37	links	link	NNS
5180	336	38	,	,	,
5180	336	39	"	"	''
5180	336	40	"	"	``
5180	336	41	hyperlinks	hyperlinks	NN
5180	336	42	,	,	,
5180	336	43	"	"	''
5180	336	44	or	or	CC
5180	336	45	"	"	``
5180	336	46	links	link	NNS
5180	336	47	"	"	''
5180	336	48	–	–	:
5180	336	49	to	to	IN
5180	336	50	additional	additional	JJ
5180	336	51	content	content	NN
5180	336	52	.	.	.
5180	337	1	Two	two	CD
5180	337	2	popular	popular	JJ
5180	337	3	browsers	browser	NNS
5180	337	4	are	be	VBP
5180	337	5	Microsoft	Microsoft	NNP
5180	337	6	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	337	7	Explorer	Explorer	NNP
5180	337	8	and	and	CC
5180	337	9	Netscape	Netscape	NNP
5180	337	10	Navigator	Navigator	NNP
5180	337	11	.	.	.
5180	338	1	A	a	DT
5180	338	2	"	"	``
5180	338	3	Web	web	NN
5180	338	4	page	page	NN
5180	338	5	"	"	''
5180	338	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	338	7	one	one	CD
5180	338	8	or	or	CC
5180	338	9	more	more	JJR
5180	338	10	files	file	NNS
5180	338	11	a	a	DT
5180	338	12	browser	browser	NN
5180	338	13	graphically	graphically	NN
5180	338	14	assembles	assemble	NNS
5180	338	15	to	to	TO
5180	338	16	make	make	VB
5180	338	17	a	a	DT
5180	338	18	viewable	viewable	JJ
5180	338	19	whole	whole	NN
5180	338	20	when	when	WRB
5180	338	21	a	a	DT
5180	338	22	user	user	NN
5180	338	23	requests	request	VBZ
5180	338	24	content	content	NN
5180	338	25	over	over	IN
5180	338	26	the	the	DT
5180	338	27	Internet	internet	NN
5180	338	28	.	.	.
5180	339	1	A	a	DT
5180	339	2	Web	web	NN
5180	339	3	page	page	NN
5180	339	4	may	may	MD
5180	339	5	contain	contain	VB
5180	339	6	a	a	DT
5180	339	7	variety	variety	NN
5180	339	8	of	of	IN
5180	339	9	different	different	JJ
5180	339	10	elements	element	NNS
5180	339	11	,	,	,
5180	339	12	including	include	VBG
5180	339	13	text	text	NN
5180	339	14	,	,	,
5180	339	15	images	image	NNS
5180	339	16	,	,	,
5180	339	17	buttons	button	NNS
5180	339	18	,	,	,
5180	339	19	form	form	NN
5180	339	20	fields	field	NNS
5180	339	21	that	that	IN
5180	339	22	the	the	DT
5180	339	23	user	user	NN
5180	339	24	can	can	MD
5180	339	25	fill	fill	VB
5180	339	26	in	in	RP
5180	339	27	,	,	,
5180	339	28	and	and	CC
5180	339	29	links	link	NNS
5180	339	30	to	to	IN
5180	339	31	other	other	JJ
5180	339	32	Web	web	NN
5180	339	33	pages	page	NNS
5180	339	34	.	.	.
5180	340	1	A	a	DT
5180	340	2	"	"	``
5180	340	3	Web	web	NN
5180	340	4	site	site	NN
5180	340	5	"	"	''
5180	340	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	340	7	a	a	DT
5180	340	8	term	term	NN
5180	340	9	that	that	WDT
5180	340	10	can	can	MD
5180	340	11	be	be	VB
5180	340	12	used	use	VBN
5180	340	13	in	in	IN
5180	340	14	several	several	JJ
5180	340	15	different	different	JJ
5180	340	16	ways	way	NNS
5180	340	17	.	.	.
5180	341	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	341	2	may	may	MD
5180	341	3	refer	refer	VB
5180	341	4	to	to	IN
5180	341	5	all	all	DT
5180	341	6	of	of	IN
5180	341	7	the	the	DT
5180	341	8	pages	page	NNS
5180	341	9	and	and	CC
5180	341	10	resources	resource	NNS
5180	341	11	available	available	JJ
5180	341	12	on	on	IN
5180	341	13	a	a	DT
5180	341	14	particular	particular	JJ
5180	341	15	Web	web	NN
5180	341	16	server	server	NN
5180	341	17	.	.	.
5180	342	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	342	2	may	may	MD
5180	342	3	also	also	RB
5180	342	4	refer	refer	VB
5180	342	5	to	to	IN
5180	342	6	all	all	PDT
5180	342	7	the	the	DT
5180	342	8	pages	page	NNS
5180	342	9	and	and	CC
5180	342	10	resources	resource	NNS
5180	342	11	associated	associate	VBN
5180	342	12	with	with	IN
5180	342	13	a	a	DT
5180	342	14	particular	particular	JJ
5180	342	15	organization	organization	NN
5180	342	16	,	,	,
5180	342	17	company	company	NN
5180	342	18	or	or	CC
5180	342	19	person	person	NN
5180	342	20	,	,	,
5180	342	21	even	even	RB
5180	342	22	if	if	IN
5180	342	23	these	these	DT
5180	342	24	are	be	VBP
5180	342	25	located	locate	VBN
5180	342	26	on	on	IN
5180	342	27	different	different	JJ
5180	342	28	servers	server	NNS
5180	342	29	,	,	,
5180	342	30	or	or	CC
5180	342	31	in	in	IN
5180	342	32	a	a	DT
5180	342	33	subdirectory	subdirectory	NN
5180	342	34	on	on	IN
5180	342	35	a	a	DT
5180	342	36	single	single	JJ
5180	342	37	server	server	NN
5180	342	38	shared	share	VBN
5180	342	39	with	with	IN
5180	342	40	other	other	JJ
5180	342	41	,	,	,
5180	342	42	unrelated	unrelated	JJ
5180	342	43	sites	site	NNS
5180	342	44	.	.	.
5180	343	1	Typically	typically	RB
5180	343	2	,	,	,
5180	343	3	a	a	DT
5180	343	4	Web	web	NN
5180	343	5	site	site	NN
5180	343	6	has	have	VBZ
5180	343	7	as	as	IN
5180	343	8	an	an	DT
5180	343	9	intended	intend	VBN
5180	343	10	point	point	NN
5180	343	11	of	of	IN
5180	343	12	entry	entry	NN
5180	343	13	,	,	,
5180	343	14	a	a	DT
5180	343	15	"	"	``
5180	343	16	home	home	NN
5180	343	17	page	page	NN
5180	343	18	,	,	,
5180	343	19	"	"	''
5180	343	20	which	which	WDT
5180	343	21	includes	include	VBZ
5180	343	22	links	link	NNS
5180	343	23	to	to	IN
5180	343	24	other	other	JJ
5180	343	25	pages	page	NNS
5180	343	26	on	on	IN
5180	343	27	the	the	DT
5180	343	28	same	same	JJ
5180	343	29	Web	web	NN
5180	343	30	site	site	NN
5180	343	31	or	or	CC
5180	343	32	to	to	IN
5180	343	33	pages	page	NNS
5180	343	34	on	on	IN
5180	343	35	other	other	JJ
5180	343	36	sites	site	NNS
5180	343	37	.	.	.
5180	344	1	Online	online	JJ
5180	344	2	discussion	discussion	NN
5180	344	3	groups	group	NNS
5180	344	4	and	and	CC
5180	344	5	chat	chat	VB
5180	344	6	rooms	room	NNS
5180	344	7	relating	relate	VBG
5180	344	8	to	to	IN
5180	344	9	a	a	DT
5180	344	10	variety	variety	NN
5180	344	11	of	of	IN
5180	344	12	subjects	subject	NNS
5180	344	13	are	be	VBP
5180	344	14	available	available	JJ
5180	344	15	through	through	IN
5180	344	16	many	many	JJ
5180	344	17	Web	web	NN
5180	344	18	sites	site	NNS
5180	344	19	.	.	.
5180	345	1	Users	user	NNS
5180	345	2	may	may	MD
5180	345	3	find	find	VB
5180	345	4	content	content	NN
5180	345	5	on	on	IN
5180	345	6	the	the	DT
5180	345	7	Web	web	NN
5180	345	8	using	use	VBG
5180	345	9	engines	engine	NNS
5180	345	10	that	that	WDT
5180	345	11	search	search	VBP
5180	345	12	for	for	IN
5180	345	13	requested	requested	JJ
5180	345	14	keywords	keyword	NNS
5180	345	15	.	.	.
5180	346	1	In	in	IN
5180	346	2	response	response	NN
5180	346	3	to	to	IN
5180	346	4	a	a	DT
5180	346	5	keyword	keyword	NN
5180	346	6	request	request	NN
5180	346	7	,	,	,
5180	346	8	a	a	DT
5180	346	9	search	search	NN
5180	346	10	engine	engine	NN
5180	346	11	will	will	MD
5180	346	12	display	display	VB
5180	346	13	a	a	DT
5180	346	14	list	list	NN
5180	346	15	of	of	IN
5180	346	16	Web	web	NN
5180	346	17	sites	site	NNS
5180	346	18	that	that	WDT
5180	346	19	may	may	MD
5180	346	20	contain	contain	VB
5180	346	21	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	346	22	content	content	NN
5180	346	23	and	and	CC
5180	346	24	provide	provide	VB
5180	346	25	links	link	NNS
5180	346	26	to	to	IN
5180	346	27	those	those	DT
5180	346	28	sites	site	NNS
5180	346	29	.	.	.
5180	347	1	Search	search	NN
5180	347	2	engines	engine	NNS
5180	347	3	and	and	CC
5180	347	4	directories	directory	NNS
5180	347	5	often	often	RB
5180	347	6	return	return	VBP
5180	347	7	a	a	DT
5180	347	8	limited	limited	JJ
5180	347	9	number	number	NN
5180	347	10	of	of	IN
5180	347	11	sites	site	NNS
5180	347	12	in	in	IN
5180	347	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	347	14	search	search	NN
5180	347	15	results	result	NNS
5180	347	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	347	17	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	347	18	,	,	,
5180	347	19	the	the	DT
5180	347	20	Google	Google	NNP
5180	347	21	search	search	NN
5180	347	22	engine	engine	NN
5180	347	23	will	will	MD
5180	347	24	return	return	VB
5180	347	25	only	only	RB
5180	347	26	2,000	2,000	CD
5180	347	27	sites	site	NNS
5180	347	28	in	in	IN
5180	347	29	response	response	NN
5180	347	30	to	to	IN
5180	347	31	a	a	DT
5180	347	32	search	search	NN
5180	347	33	,	,	,
5180	347	34	even	even	RB
5180	347	35	if	if	IN
5180	347	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	347	37	has	have	VBZ
5180	347	38	found	find	VBN
5180	347	39	,	,	,
5180	347	40	for	for	IN
5180	347	41	example	example	NN
5180	347	42	,	,	,
5180	347	43	530,000	530,000	CD
5180	347	44	sites	site	NNS
5180	347	45	in	in	IN
5180	347	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	347	47	index	index	NN
5180	347	48	that	that	WDT
5180	347	49	meet	meet	VBP
5180	347	50	the	the	DT
5180	347	51	search	search	NN
5180	347	52	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	347	53	)	)	-RRB-
5180	347	54	.	.	.
5180	348	1	A	a	DT
5180	348	2	user	user	NN
5180	348	3	may	may	MD
5180	348	4	also	also	RB
5180	348	5	access	access	VB
5180	348	6	content	content	NN
5180	348	7	on	on	IN
5180	348	8	the	the	DT
5180	348	9	Web	web	NN
5180	348	10	by	by	IN
5180	348	11	typing	type	VBG
5180	348	12	a	a	DT
5180	348	13	URL	url	NN
5180	348	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	348	15	Uniform	Uniform	NNP
5180	348	16	Resource	Resource	NNP
5180	348	17	Locator	Locator	NNP
5180	348	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	348	19	into	into	IN
5180	348	20	the	the	DT
5180	348	21	address	address	NN
5180	348	22	line	line	NN
5180	348	23	of	of	IN
5180	348	24	the	the	DT
5180	348	25	browser	browser	NN
5180	348	26	.	.	.
5180	349	1	A	a	DT
5180	349	2	URL	url	NN
5180	349	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	349	4	an	an	DT
5180	349	5	address	address	NN
5180	349	6	that	that	WDT
5180	349	7	points	point	VBZ
5180	349	8	to	to	IN
5180	349	9	some	some	DT
5180	349	10	resource	resource	NN
5180	349	11	located	locate	VBN
5180	349	12	on	on	IN
5180	349	13	a	a	DT
5180	349	14	Web	web	NN
5180	349	15	server	server	NN
5180	349	16	that	that	WDT
5180	349	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	349	18	accessible	accessible	JJ
5180	349	19	over	over	IN
5180	349	20	the	the	DT
5180	349	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	349	22	.	.	.
5180	350	1	This	this	DT
5180	350	2	resource	resource	NN
5180	350	3	may	may	MD
5180	350	4	be	be	VB
5180	350	5	a	a	DT
5180	350	6	Web	web	NN
5180	350	7	site	site	NN
5180	350	8	,	,	,
5180	350	9	a	a	DT
5180	350	10	Web	web	NN
5180	350	11	page	page	NN
5180	350	12	,	,	,
5180	350	13	an	an	DT
5180	350	14	image	image	NN
5180	350	15	,	,	,
5180	350	16	a	a	DT
5180	350	17	sound	sound	NN
5180	350	18	or	or	CC
5180	350	19	video	video	NN
5180	350	20	file	file	NN
5180	350	21	,	,	,
5180	350	22	or	or	CC
5180	350	23	other	other	JJ
5180	350	24	resource	resource	NN
5180	350	25	.	.	.
5180	351	1	A	a	DT
5180	351	2	URL	url	NN
5180	351	3	can	can	MD
5180	351	4	be	be	VB
5180	351	5	either	either	CC
5180	351	6	a	a	DT
5180	351	7	numeric	numeric	JJ
5180	351	8	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	351	9	Protocol	Protocol	NNP
5180	351	10	or	or	CC
5180	351	11	"	"	``
5180	351	12	IP	IP	NNP
5180	351	13	"	"	''
5180	351	14	address	address	NN
5180	351	15	,	,	,
5180	351	16	or	or	CC
5180	351	17	an	an	DT
5180	351	18	alphanumeric	alphanumeric	JJ
5180	351	19	"	"	``
5180	351	20	domain	domain	NN
5180	351	21	name	name	NN
5180	351	22	"	"	''
5180	351	23	address	address	NN
5180	351	24	.	.	.
5180	352	1	Every	every	DT
5180	352	2	Web	web	NN
5180	352	3	server	server	NN
5180	352	4	connected	connect	VBN
5180	352	5	to	to	IN
5180	352	6	the	the	DT
5180	352	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	352	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	352	9	assigned	assign	VBN
5180	352	10	an	an	DT
5180	352	11	IP	IP	NNP
5180	352	12	address	address	NN
5180	352	13	.	.	.
5180	353	1	A	a	DT
5180	353	2	typical	typical	JJ
5180	353	3	IP	IP	NNP
5180	353	4	address	address	NN
5180	353	5	looks	look	VBZ
5180	353	6	like	like	IN
5180	353	7	"	"	``
5180	353	8	13.1.64.14	13.1.64.14	NNS
5180	353	9	.	.	.
5180	353	10	"	"	''
5180	354	1	Typing	type	VBG
5180	354	2	the	the	DT
5180	354	3	URL	url	NN
5180	354	4	"	"	``
5180	354	5	http://13.1.64.14/	http://13.1.64.14/	NNS
5180	354	6	"	"	''
5180	354	7	into	into	IN
5180	354	8	a	a	DT
5180	354	9	browser	browser	NN
5180	354	10	will	will	MD
5180	354	11	bring	bring	VB
5180	354	12	the	the	DT
5180	354	13	user	user	NN
5180	354	14	to	to	IN
5180	354	15	the	the	DT
5180	354	16	Web	web	NN
5180	354	17	server	server	NN
5180	354	18	that	that	WDT
5180	354	19	corresponds	correspond	VBZ
5180	354	20	to	to	IN
5180	354	21	that	that	DT
5180	354	22	address	address	NN
5180	354	23	.	.	.
5180	355	1	For	for	IN
5180	355	2	convenience	convenience	NN
5180	355	3	,	,	,
5180	355	4	most	most	JJS
5180	355	5	Web	web	NN
5180	355	6	servers	server	NNS
5180	355	7	have	have	VBP
5180	355	8	alphanumeric	alphanumeric	JJ
5180	355	9	domain	domain	NN
5180	355	10	name	name	NN
5180	355	11	addresses	address	NNS
5180	355	12	in	in	IN
5180	355	13	addition	addition	NN
5180	355	14	to	to	IN
5180	355	15	IP	IP	NNP
5180	355	16	addresses	address	NNS
5180	355	17	.	.	.
5180	356	1	For	for	IN
5180	356	2	example	example	NN
5180	356	3	,	,	,
5180	356	4	typing	type	VBG
5180	356	5	in	in	IN
5180	356	6	"	"	``
5180	356	7	http://www.paed.uscourts.gov	http://www.paed.uscourts.gov	NNP
5180	356	8	"	"	''
5180	356	9	will	will	MD
5180	356	10	bring	bring	VB
5180	356	11	the	the	DT
5180	356	12	user	user	NN
5180	356	13	to	to	IN
5180	356	14	the	the	DT
5180	356	15	same	same	JJ
5180	356	16	Web	web	NN
5180	356	17	server	server	NN
5180	356	18	as	as	IN
5180	356	19	typing	type	VBG
5180	356	20	in	in	IN
5180	356	21	"	"	``
5180	356	22	http://204.170.64.143	http://204.170.64.143	NNP
5180	356	23	.	.	.
5180	356	24	"	"	''
5180	357	1	Every	every	DT
5180	357	2	time	time	NN
5180	357	3	a	a	DT
5180	357	4	user	user	NN
5180	357	5	attempts	attempt	NNS
5180	357	6	to	to	TO
5180	357	7	access	access	VB
5180	357	8	material	material	NN
5180	357	9	located	locate	VBN
5180	357	10	on	on	IN
5180	357	11	a	a	DT
5180	357	12	Web	web	NN
5180	357	13	server	server	NN
5180	357	14	by	by	IN
5180	357	15	entering	enter	VBG
5180	357	16	a	a	DT
5180	357	17	domain	domain	NN
5180	357	18	name	name	NN
5180	357	19	address	address	NN
5180	357	20	into	into	IN
5180	357	21	a	a	DT
5180	357	22	Web	web	NN
5180	357	23	browser	browser	NN
5180	357	24	,	,	,
5180	357	25	a	a	DT
5180	357	26	request	request	NN
5180	357	27	is	be	VBZ
5180	357	28	made	make	VBN
5180	357	29	to	to	IN
5180	357	30	a	a	DT
5180	357	31	Domain	Domain	NNP
5180	357	32	Name	Name	NNP
5180	357	33	Server	Server	NNP
5180	357	34	,	,	,
5180	357	35	which	which	WDT
5180	357	36	is	be	VBZ
5180	357	37	a	a	DT
5180	357	38	directory	directory	NN
5180	357	39	of	of	IN
5180	357	40	domain	domain	NN
5180	357	41	names	name	NNS
5180	357	42	and	and	CC
5180	357	43	IP	IP	NNP
5180	357	44	addresses	address	NNS
5180	357	45	,	,	,
5180	357	46	to	to	TO
5180	357	47	"	"	``
5180	357	48	resolve	resolve	VB
5180	357	49	,	,	,
5180	357	50	"	"	''
5180	357	51	or	or	CC
5180	357	52	translate	translate	VB
5180	357	53	,	,	,
5180	357	54	the	the	DT
5180	357	55	domain	domain	NN
5180	357	56	name	name	NN
5180	357	57	address	address	NN
5180	357	58	into	into	IN
5180	357	59	an	an	DT
5180	357	60	IP	IP	NNP
5180	357	61	address	address	NN
5180	357	62	.	.	.
5180	358	1	That	that	IN
5180	358	2	IP	IP	NNP
5180	358	3	address	address	NN
5180	358	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	358	5	then	then	RB
5180	358	6	used	use	VBN
5180	358	7	to	to	TO
5180	358	8	locate	locate	VB
5180	358	9	the	the	DT
5180	358	10	Web	web	NN
5180	358	11	server	server	NN
5180	358	12	from	from	IN
5180	358	13	which	which	WDT
5180	358	14	content	content	NN
5180	358	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	358	16	being	be	VBG
5180	358	17	requested	request	VBN
5180	358	18	.	.	.
5180	359	1	A	a	DT
5180	359	2	Web	web	NN
5180	359	3	site	site	NN
5180	359	4	may	may	MD
5180	359	5	be	be	VB
5180	359	6	accessed	access	VBN
5180	359	7	by	by	IN
5180	359	8	using	use	VBG
5180	359	9	either	either	CC
5180	359	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	359	11	domain	domain	NN
5180	359	12	name	name	NN
5180	359	13	address	address	NN
5180	359	14	or	or	CC
5180	359	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	359	16	IP	IP	NNP
5180	359	17	address	address	NN
5180	359	18	.	.	.
5180	360	1	A	a	DT
5180	360	2	domain	domain	NN
5180	360	3	name	name	NN
5180	360	4	address	address	NN
5180	360	5	typically	typically	RB
5180	360	6	consists	consist	VBZ
5180	360	7	of	of	IN
5180	360	8	several	several	JJ
5180	360	9	parts	part	NNS
5180	360	10	.	.	.
5180	361	1	For	for	IN
5180	361	2	example	example	NN
5180	361	3	,	,	,
5180	361	4	the	the	DT
5180	361	5	alphanumeric	alphanumeric	JJ
5180	361	6	URL	url	NN
5180	361	7	http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions	http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents/opinions	NNPS
5180	361	8	can	can	MD
5180	361	9	be	be	VB
5180	361	10	broken	break	VBN
5180	361	11	down	down	RP
5180	361	12	into	into	IN
5180	361	13	three	three	CD
5180	361	14	parts	part	NNS
5180	361	15	.	.	.
5180	362	1	The	the	DT
5180	362	2	first	first	JJ
5180	362	3	part	part	NN
5180	362	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	362	5	the	the	DT
5180	362	6	transfer	transfer	NN
5180	362	7	protocol	protocol	NN
5180	362	8	the	the	DT
5180	362	9	computer	computer	NN
5180	362	10	will	will	MD
5180	362	11	use	use	VB
5180	362	12	in	in	IN
5180	362	13	accessing	access	VBG
5180	362	14	the	the	DT
5180	362	15	content	content	NN
5180	362	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	362	17	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	362	18	,	,	,
5180	362	19	"	"	``
5180	362	20	http	http	VBZ
5180	362	21	"	"	''
5180	362	22	for	for	IN
5180	362	23	Hypertext	Hypertext	NNP
5180	362	24	Transfer	Transfer	NNP
5180	362	25	Protocol	Protocol	NNP
5180	362	26	)	)	-RRB-
5180	362	27	;	;	:
5180	362	28	next	next	JJ
5180	362	29	is	be	VBZ
5180	362	30	the	the	DT
5180	362	31	name	name	NN
5180	362	32	of	of	IN
5180	362	33	the	the	DT
5180	362	34	host	host	NN
5180	362	35	server	server	NN
5180	362	36	on	on	IN
5180	362	37	which	which	WDT
5180	362	38	the	the	DT
5180	362	39	information	information	NN
5180	362	40	is	be	VBZ
5180	362	41	stored	store	VBN
5180	362	42	(	(	-LRB-
5180	362	43	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	362	44	,	,	,
5180	362	45	www.paed.uscourts.gov	www.paed.uscourts.gov	CD
5180	362	46	)	)	-RRB-
5180	362	47	;	;	:
5180	362	48	and	and	CC
5180	362	49	then	then	RB
5180	362	50	the	the	DT
5180	362	51	name	name	NN
5180	362	52	of	of	IN
5180	362	53	the	the	DT
5180	362	54	particular	particular	JJ
5180	362	55	file	file	NN
5180	362	56	or	or	CC
5180	362	57	directory	directory	NN
5180	362	58	on	on	IN
5180	362	59	that	that	DT
5180	362	60	server	server	NN
5180	362	61	(	(	-LRB-
5180	362	62	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	362	63	,	,	,
5180	362	64	/documents	/documents	.
5180	362	65	/	/	SYM
5180	362	66	opinions	opinion	NNS
5180	362	67	)	)	-RRB-
5180	362	68	.	.	.
5180	363	1	A	a	DT
5180	363	2	single	single	JJ
5180	363	3	Web	web	NN
5180	363	4	page	page	NN
5180	363	5	may	may	MD
5180	363	6	be	be	VB
5180	363	7	associated	associate	VBN
5180	363	8	with	with	IN
5180	363	9	more	more	JJR
5180	363	10	than	than	IN
5180	363	11	one	one	CD
5180	363	12	URL	url	NN
5180	363	13	.	.	.
5180	364	1	For	for	IN
5180	364	2	example	example	NN
5180	364	3	,	,	,
5180	364	4	the	the	DT
5180	364	5	URLs	url	NNS
5180	364	6	http://www.newyorktimes.com	http://www.newyorktimes.com	ADD
5180	364	7	and	and	CC
5180	364	8	http://www.nytimes.com	http://www.nytimes.com	ADD
5180	364	9	will	will	MD
5180	364	10	both	both	DT
5180	364	11	take	take	VB
5180	364	12	the	the	DT
5180	364	13	user	user	NN
5180	364	14	to	to	IN
5180	364	15	the	the	DT
5180	364	16	New	New	NNP
5180	364	17	York	York	NNP
5180	364	18	Times	Times	NNP
5180	364	19	home	home	NN
5180	364	20	page	page	NN
5180	364	21	.	.	.
5180	365	1	The	the	DT
5180	365	2	topmost	topmost	JJS
5180	365	3	directory	directory	NN
5180	365	4	in	in	IN
5180	365	5	a	a	DT
5180	365	6	Web	web	NN
5180	365	7	site	site	NN
5180	365	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	365	9	often	often	RB
5180	365	10	referred	refer	VBN
5180	365	11	to	to	IN
5180	365	12	as	as	IN
5180	365	13	that	that	DT
5180	365	14	Web	web	NN
5180	365	15	site	site	NN
5180	365	16	's	's	POS
5180	365	17	root	root	NN
5180	365	18	directory	directory	NN
5180	365	19	or	or	CC
5180	365	20	root	root	NN
5180	365	21	URL	url	NN
5180	365	22	.	.	.
5180	366	1	For	for	IN
5180	366	2	example	example	NN
5180	366	3	,	,	,
5180	366	4	in	in	IN
5180	366	5	http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents	http://www.paed.uscourts.gov/documents	NNP
5180	366	6	,	,	,
5180	366	7	the	the	DT
5180	366	8	root	root	NN
5180	366	9	URL	URL	NNP
5180	366	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	366	11	http://www.paed.uscourts.gov	http://www.paed.uscourts.gov	NNP
5180	366	12	.	.	.
5180	367	1	There	there	EX
5180	367	2	may	may	MD
5180	367	3	be	be	VB
5180	367	4	hundreds	hundred	NNS
5180	367	5	or	or	CC
5180	367	6	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	367	7	of	of	IN
5180	367	8	pages	page	NNS
5180	367	9	under	under	IN
5180	367	10	a	a	DT
5180	367	11	single	single	JJ
5180	367	12	root	root	NN
5180	367	13	URL	url	NN
5180	367	14	,	,	,
5180	367	15	or	or	CC
5180	367	16	there	there	EX
5180	367	17	may	may	MD
5180	367	18	be	be	VB
5180	367	19	one	one	CD
5180	367	20	or	or	CC
5180	367	21	only	only	RB
5180	367	22	a	a	DT
5180	367	23	few	few	JJ
5180	367	24	.	.	.
5180	368	1	There	there	EX
5180	368	2	are	be	VBP
5180	368	3	a	a	DT
5180	368	4	number	number	NN
5180	368	5	of	of	IN
5180	368	6	Web	web	NN
5180	368	7	hosting	host	VBG
5180	368	8	companies	company	NNS
5180	368	9	that	that	WDT
5180	368	10	maintain	maintain	VBP
5180	368	11	Web	web	NN
5180	368	12	sites	site	NNS
5180	368	13	for	for	IN
5180	368	14	other	other	JJ
5180	368	15	businesses	business	NNS
5180	368	16	and	and	CC
5180	368	17	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	368	18	,	,	,
5180	368	19	which	which	WDT
5180	368	20	can	can	MD
5180	368	21	lead	lead	VB
5180	368	22	to	to	IN
5180	368	23	vast	vast	JJ
5180	368	24	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	368	25	of	of	IN
5180	368	26	diverse	diverse	JJ
5180	368	27	content	content	NN
5180	368	28	being	be	VBG
5180	368	29	located	locate	VBN
5180	368	30	at	at	IN
5180	368	31	the	the	DT
5180	368	32	same	same	JJ
5180	368	33	IP	IP	NNP
5180	368	34	address	address	NN
5180	368	35	.	.	.
5180	369	1	Hosting	host	VBG
5180	369	2	services	service	NNS
5180	369	3	are	be	VBP
5180	369	4	offered	offer	VBN
5180	369	5	either	either	CC
5180	369	6	for	for	IN
5180	369	7	a	a	DT
5180	369	8	fee	fee	NN
5180	369	9	,	,	,
5180	369	10	or	or	CC
5180	369	11	in	in	IN
5180	369	12	some	some	DT
5180	369	13	cases	case	NNS
5180	369	14	,	,	,
5180	369	15	for	for	IN
5180	369	16	free	free	JJ
5180	369	17	,	,	,
5180	369	18	allowing	allow	VBG
5180	369	19	any	any	DT
5180	369	20	individual	individual	NN
5180	369	21	with	with	IN
5180	369	22	Internet	internet	NN
5180	369	23	access	access	NN
5180	369	24	to	to	TO
5180	369	25	create	create	VB
5180	369	26	a	a	DT
5180	369	27	Web	web	NN
5180	369	28	site	site	NN
5180	369	29	.	.	.
5180	370	1	Some	some	DT
5180	370	2	hosting	host	VBG
5180	370	3	services	service	NNS
5180	370	4	are	be	VBP
5180	370	5	provided	provide	VBN
5180	370	6	through	through	IN
5180	370	7	the	the	DT
5180	370	8	process	process	NN
5180	370	9	of	of	IN
5180	370	10	"	"	``
5180	370	11	IP	IP	NNP
5180	370	12	-	-	HYPH
5180	370	13	based	base	VBN
5180	370	14	hosting	hosting	NN
5180	370	15	,	,	,
5180	370	16	"	"	``
5180	370	17	where	where	WRB
5180	370	18	each	each	DT
5180	370	19	domain	domain	NN
5180	370	20	name	name	NN
5180	370	21	is	be	VBZ
5180	370	22	assigned	assign	VBN
5180	370	23	a	a	DT
5180	370	24	unique	unique	JJ
5180	370	25	IP	IP	NNP
5180	370	26	number	number	NN
5180	370	27	.	.	.
5180	371	1	For	for	IN
5180	371	2	example	example	NN
5180	371	3	,	,	,
5180	371	4	www.baseball.com	www.baseball.com	NNP
5180	371	5	might	may	MD
5180	371	6	map	map	VB
5180	371	7	to	to	IN
5180	371	8	the	the	DT
5180	371	9	IP	IP	NNP
5180	371	10	address	address	NN
5180	371	11	"	"	``
5180	371	12	10.3.5.9	10.3.5.9	CD
5180	371	13	"	"	''
5180	371	14	and	and	CC
5180	371	15	www.XXX.com	www.XXX.com	NNP
5180	371	16	might	may	MD
5180	371	17	map	map	VB
5180	371	18	to	to	IN
5180	371	19	the	the	DT
5180	371	20	IP	IP	NNP
5180	371	21	address	address	NN
5180	371	22	"	"	``
5180	371	23	10.0.42.5	10.0.42.5	CD
5180	371	24	.	.	.
5180	371	25	"	"	''
5180	372	1	Other	other	JJ
5180	372	2	hosting	host	VBG
5180	372	3	services	service	NNS
5180	372	4	are	be	VBP
5180	372	5	provided	provide	VBN
5180	372	6	through	through	IN
5180	372	7	the	the	DT
5180	372	8	process	process	NN
5180	372	9	of	of	IN
5180	372	10	"	"	``
5180	372	11	name	name	NN
5180	372	12	-	-	HYPH
5180	372	13	based	base	VBN
5180	372	14	hosting	hosting	NN
5180	372	15	,	,	,
5180	372	16	"	"	``
5180	372	17	where	where	WRB
5180	372	18	multiple	multiple	JJ
5180	372	19	domain	domain	NN
5180	372	20	name	name	NN
5180	372	21	addresses	address	NNS
5180	372	22	are	be	VBP
5180	372	23	mapped	map	VBN
5180	372	24	to	to	IN
5180	372	25	a	a	DT
5180	372	26	single	single	JJ
5180	372	27	IP	IP	NNP
5180	372	28	address	address	NN
5180	372	29	.	.	.
5180	373	1	If	if	IN
5180	373	2	the	the	DT
5180	373	3	hosting	host	VBG
5180	373	4	company	company	NN
5180	373	5	were	be	VBD
5180	373	6	using	use	VBG
5180	373	7	this	this	DT
5180	373	8	method	method	NN
5180	373	9	,	,	,
5180	373	10	both	both	DT
5180	373	11	www.baseball.com	www.baseball.com	NNP
5180	373	12	and	and	CC
5180	373	13	www.XXX.com	www.XXX.com	NNP
5180	373	14	could	could	MD
5180	373	15	map	map	VB
5180	373	16	to	to	IN
5180	373	17	a	a	DT
5180	373	18	single	single	JJ
5180	373	19	IP	IP	NNP
5180	373	20	address	address	NN
5180	373	21	,	,	,
5180	373	22	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	373	23	,	,	,
5180	373	24	"	"	``
5180	373	25	10.3.5.9	10.3.5.9	CD
5180	373	26	.	.	.
5180	373	27	"	"	''
5180	374	1	As	as	IN
5180	374	2	a	a	DT
5180	374	3	result	result	NN
5180	374	4	of	of	IN
5180	374	5	the	the	DT
5180	374	6	"	"	``
5180	374	7	name	name	NN
5180	374	8	-	-	HYPH
5180	374	9	based	base	VBN
5180	374	10	hosting	host	VBG
5180	374	11	"	"	''
5180	374	12	process	process	NN
5180	374	13	,	,	,
5180	374	14	up	up	RB
5180	374	15	to	to	IN
5180	374	16	tens	ten	NNS
5180	374	17	of	of	IN
5180	374	18	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	374	19	of	of	IN
5180	374	20	pages	page	NNS
5180	374	21	with	with	IN
5180	374	22	heterogeneous	heterogeneous	JJ
5180	374	23	content	content	NN
5180	374	24	may	may	MD
5180	374	25	share	share	VB
5180	374	26	a	a	DT
5180	374	27	single	single	JJ
5180	374	28	IP	IP	NNP
5180	374	29	address	address	NN
5180	374	30	.	.	.
5180	375	1	2	2	LS
5180	375	2	.	.	.
5180	376	1	The	the	DT
5180	376	2	Indexable	Indexable	NNP
5180	376	3	Web	Web	NNP
5180	376	4	,	,	,
5180	376	5	the	the	DT
5180	376	6	"	"	``
5180	376	7	Deep	deep	JJ
5180	376	8	Web	web	NN
5180	376	9	"	"	''
5180	376	10	;	;	:
5180	376	11	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	376	12	Size	size	NN
5180	376	13	and	and	CC
5180	376	14	Rates	Rates	NNPS
5180	376	15	of	of	IN
5180	376	16	Growth	Growth	NNP
5180	376	17	and	and	CC
5180	376	18	Change	change	VB
5180	376	19	The	the	DT
5180	376	20	universe	universe	NN
5180	376	21	of	of	IN
5180	376	22	content	content	NN
5180	376	23	on	on	IN
5180	376	24	the	the	DT
5180	376	25	Web	web	NN
5180	376	26	that	that	WDT
5180	376	27	could	could	MD
5180	376	28	be	be	VB
5180	376	29	indexed	index	VBN
5180	376	30	,	,	,
5180	376	31	in	in	IN
5180	376	32	theory	theory	NN
5180	376	33	,	,	,
5180	376	34	by	by	IN
5180	376	35	standard	standard	JJ
5180	376	36	search	search	NN
5180	376	37	engines	engine	NNS
5180	376	38	is	be	VBZ
5180	376	39	known	know	VBN
5180	376	40	as	as	IN
5180	376	41	the	the	DT
5180	376	42	"	"	``
5180	376	43	publicly	publicly	RB
5180	376	44	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	376	45	Web	web	NN
5180	376	46	.	.	.
5180	376	47	"	"	''
5180	377	1	The	the	DT
5180	377	2	publicly	publicly	RB
5180	377	3	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	377	4	Web	web	NN
5180	377	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	377	6	limited	limit	VBN
5180	377	7	to	to	IN
5180	377	8	those	those	DT
5180	377	9	pages	page	NNS
5180	377	10	that	that	WDT
5180	377	11	are	be	VBP
5180	377	12	accessible	accessible	JJ
5180	377	13	by	by	IN
5180	377	14	following	follow	VBG
5180	377	15	a	a	DT
5180	377	16	link	link	NN
5180	377	17	from	from	IN
5180	377	18	another	another	DT
5180	377	19	Web	web	NN
5180	377	20	page	page	NN
5180	377	21	that	that	WDT
5180	377	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	377	23	recognized	recognize	VBN
5180	377	24	by	by	IN
5180	377	25	a	a	DT
5180	377	26	search	search	NN
5180	377	27	engine	engine	NN
5180	377	28	.	.	.
5180	378	1	This	this	DT
5180	378	2	limitation	limitation	NN
5180	378	3	exists	exist	VBZ
5180	378	4	because	because	IN
5180	378	5	online	online	JJ
5180	378	6	indexing	indexing	NN
5180	378	7	techniques	technique	NNS
5180	378	8	used	use	VBN
5180	378	9	by	by	IN
5180	378	10	popular	popular	JJ
5180	378	11	search	search	NN
5180	378	12	engines	engine	NNS
5180	378	13	and	and	CC
5180	378	14	directories	directory	NNS
5180	378	15	such	such	JJ
5180	378	16	as	as	IN
5180	378	17	Yahoo	Yahoo	NNP
5180	378	18	,	,	,
5180	378	19	Lycos	Lycos	NNP
5180	378	20	and	and	CC
5180	378	21	AltaVista	AltaVista	NNP
5180	378	22	,	,	,
5180	378	23	are	be	VBP
5180	378	24	based	base	VBN
5180	378	25	on	on	IN
5180	378	26	"	"	``
5180	378	27	spidering	spidering	JJ
5180	378	28	"	"	''
5180	378	29	technology	technology	NN
5180	378	30	,	,	,
5180	378	31	which	which	WDT
5180	378	32	finds	find	VBZ
5180	378	33	sites	site	NNS
5180	378	34	to	to	IN
5180	378	35	index	index	NN
5180	378	36	by	by	IN
5180	378	37	following	follow	VBG
5180	378	38	links	link	NNS
5180	378	39	from	from	IN
5180	378	40	site	site	NN
5180	378	41	to	to	IN
5180	378	42	site	site	VB
5180	378	43	in	in	IN
5180	378	44	a	a	DT
5180	378	45	continuous	continuous	JJ
5180	378	46	search	search	NN
5180	378	47	for	for	IN
5180	378	48	new	new	JJ
5180	378	49	content	content	NN
5180	378	50	.	.	.
5180	379	1	If	if	IN
5180	379	2	a	a	DT
5180	379	3	Web	web	NN
5180	379	4	page	page	NN
5180	379	5	or	or	CC
5180	379	6	site	site	NN
5180	379	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	379	8	not	not	RB
5180	379	9	linked	link	VBN
5180	379	10	by	by	IN
5180	379	11	others	other	NNS
5180	379	12	,	,	,
5180	379	13	then	then	RB
5180	379	14	spidering	spidere	VBG
5180	379	15	will	will	MD
5180	379	16	not	not	RB
5180	379	17	discover	discover	VB
5180	379	18	that	that	DT
5180	379	19	page	page	NN
5180	379	20	or	or	CC
5180	379	21	site	site	NN
5180	379	22	.	.	.
5180	380	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
5180	380	2	,	,	,
5180	380	3	many	many	JJ
5180	380	4	larger	large	JJR
5180	380	5	Web	web	NN
5180	380	6	sites	site	NNS
5180	380	7	contain	contain	VBP
5180	380	8	instructions	instruction	NNS
5180	380	9	,	,	,
5180	380	10	through	through	IN
5180	380	11	software	software	NN
5180	380	12	,	,	,
5180	380	13	that	that	WDT
5180	380	14	prevent	prevent	VBP
5180	380	15	spiders	spider	NNS
5180	380	16	from	from	IN
5180	380	17	investigating	investigate	VBG
5180	380	18	that	that	DT
5180	380	19	site	site	NN
5180	380	20	,	,	,
5180	380	21	and	and	CC
5180	380	22	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	380	23	the	the	DT
5180	380	24	contents	content	NNS
5180	380	25	of	of	IN
5180	380	26	such	such	JJ
5180	380	27	sites	site	NNS
5180	380	28	also	also	RB
5180	380	29	can	can	MD
5180	380	30	not	not	RB
5180	380	31	be	be	VB
5180	380	32	indexed	index	VBN
5180	380	33	using	use	VBG
5180	380	34	spidering	spidere	VBG
5180	380	35	technology	technology	NN
5180	380	36	.	.	.
5180	381	1	Because	because	IN
5180	381	2	of	of	IN
5180	381	3	the	the	DT
5180	381	4	vast	vast	JJ
5180	381	5	size	size	NN
5180	381	6	and	and	CC
5180	381	7	decentralized	decentralize	VBD
5180	381	8	structure	structure	NN
5180	381	9	of	of	IN
5180	381	10	the	the	DT
5180	381	11	Web	web	NN
5180	381	12	,	,	,
5180	381	13	no	no	DT
5180	381	14	search	search	NN
5180	381	15	engine	engine	NN
5180	381	16	or	or	CC
5180	381	17	directory	directory	NN
5180	381	18	indexes	index	NNS
5180	381	19	all	all	DT
5180	381	20	of	of	IN
5180	381	21	the	the	DT
5180	381	22	content	content	NN
5180	381	23	on	on	IN
5180	381	24	the	the	DT
5180	381	25	publicly	publicly	RB
5180	381	26	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	381	27	Web	web	NN
5180	381	28	.	.	.
5180	382	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	382	2	credit	credit	VBP
5180	382	3	current	current	JJ
5180	382	4	estimates	estimate	NNS
5180	382	5	that	that	IN
5180	382	6	no	no	DT
5180	382	7	more	more	JJR
5180	382	8	than	than	IN
5180	382	9	50	50	CD
5180	382	10	%	%	NN
5180	382	11	of	of	IN
5180	382	12	the	the	DT
5180	382	13	content	content	NN
5180	382	14	currently	currently	RB
5180	382	15	on	on	IN
5180	382	16	the	the	DT
5180	382	17	publicly	publicly	RB
5180	382	18	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	382	19	Web	web	NN
5180	382	20	has	have	VBZ
5180	382	21	been	be	VBN
5180	382	22	indexed	index	VBN
5180	382	23	by	by	IN
5180	382	24	all	all	DT
5180	382	25	search	search	NN
5180	382	26	engines	engine	NNS
5180	382	27	and	and	CC
5180	382	28	directories	directory	NNS
5180	382	29	combined	combine	VBN
5180	382	30	.	.	.
5180	383	1	No	no	DT
5180	383	2	currently	currently	RB
5180	383	3	available	available	JJ
5180	383	4	method	method	NN
5180	383	5	or	or	CC
5180	383	6	combination	combination	NN
5180	383	7	of	of	IN
5180	383	8	methods	method	NNS
5180	383	9	for	for	IN
5180	383	10	collecting	collect	VBG
5180	383	11	URLs	url	NNS
5180	383	12	can	can	MD
5180	383	13	collect	collect	VB
5180	383	14	the	the	DT
5180	383	15	addresses	address	NNS
5180	383	16	of	of	IN
5180	383	17	all	all	DT
5180	383	18	URLs	url	NNS
5180	383	19	on	on	IN
5180	383	20	the	the	DT
5180	383	21	Web	web	NN
5180	383	22	.	.	.
5180	384	1	The	the	DT
5180	384	2	portion	portion	NN
5180	384	3	of	of	IN
5180	384	4	the	the	DT
5180	384	5	Web	web	NN
5180	384	6	that	that	WDT
5180	384	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	384	8	not	not	RB
5180	384	9	theoretically	theoretically	RB
5180	384	10	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	384	11	through	through	IN
5180	384	12	the	the	DT
5180	384	13	use	use	NN
5180	384	14	of	of	IN
5180	384	15	"	"	``
5180	384	16	spidering	spidering	JJ
5180	384	17	"	"	''
5180	384	18	technology	technology	NN
5180	384	19	,	,	,
5180	384	20	because	because	IN
5180	384	21	other	other	JJ
5180	384	22	Web	web	NN
5180	384	23	pages	page	NNS
5180	384	24	do	do	VBP
5180	384	25	not	not	RB
5180	384	26	link	link	VB
5180	384	27	to	to	IN
5180	384	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	384	29	,	,	,
5180	384	30	is	be	VBZ
5180	384	31	called	call	VBN
5180	384	32	the	the	DT
5180	384	33	"	"	``
5180	384	34	Deep	Deep	NNP
5180	384	35	Web	web	NN
5180	384	36	.	.	.
5180	384	37	"	"	''
5180	385	1	Such	such	JJ
5180	385	2	sites	site	NNS
5180	385	3	or	or	CC
5180	385	4	pages	page	NNS
5180	385	5	can	can	MD
5180	385	6	still	still	RB
5180	385	7	be	be	VB
5180	385	8	made	make	VBN
5180	385	9	publicly	publicly	RB
5180	385	10	accessible	accessible	JJ
5180	385	11	without	without	IN
5180	385	12	being	be	VBG
5180	385	13	made	make	VBN
5180	385	14	publicly	publicly	RB
5180	385	15	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	385	16	by	by	IN
5180	385	17	,	,	,
5180	385	18	for	for	IN
5180	385	19	example	example	NN
5180	385	20	,	,	,
5180	385	21	using	use	VBG
5180	385	22	individual	individual	JJ
5180	385	23	or	or	CC
5180	385	24	mass	mass	JJ
5180	385	25	emailings	emailing	NNS
5180	385	26	(	(	-LRB-
5180	385	27	also	also	RB
5180	385	28	known	know	VBN
5180	385	29	as	as	IN
5180	385	30	"	"	``
5180	385	31	spam	spam	NNP
5180	385	32	"	"	''
5180	385	33	)	)	-RRB-
5180	385	34	to	to	TO
5180	385	35	distribute	distribute	VB
5180	385	36	the	the	DT
5180	385	37	URL	url	NN
5180	385	38	to	to	IN
5180	385	39	potential	potential	JJ
5180	385	40	readers	reader	NNS
5180	385	41	or	or	CC
5180	385	42	customers	customer	NNS
5180	385	43	,	,	,
5180	385	44	or	or	CC
5180	385	45	by	by	IN
5180	385	46	using	use	VBG
5180	385	47	types	type	NNS
5180	385	48	of	of	IN
5180	385	49	Web	web	NN
5180	385	50	links	link	NNS
5180	385	51	that	that	WDT
5180	385	52	can	can	MD
5180	385	53	not	not	RB
5180	385	54	be	be	VB
5180	385	55	found	find	VBN
5180	385	56	by	by	IN
5180	385	57	spiders	spider	NNS
5180	385	58	but	but	CC
5180	385	59	can	can	MD
5180	385	60	be	be	VB
5180	385	61	seen	see	VBN
5180	385	62	and	and	CC
5180	385	63	used	use	VBN
5180	385	64	by	by	IN
5180	385	65	readers	reader	NNS
5180	385	66	.	.	.
5180	386	1	"	"	``
5180	386	2	Spamming	spamme	VBG
5180	386	3	"	"	''
5180	386	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	386	5	a	a	DT
5180	386	6	common	common	JJ
5180	386	7	method	method	NN
5180	386	8	of	of	IN
5180	386	9	distributing	distribute	VBG
5180	386	10	to	to	IN
5180	386	11	potential	potential	JJ
5180	386	12	customers	customer	NNS
5180	386	13	links	link	NNS
5180	386	14	to	to	IN
5180	386	15	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	386	16	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	386	17	content	content	NN
5180	386	18	that	that	WDT
5180	386	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	386	20	not	not	RB
5180	386	21	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	386	22	.	.	.
5180	387	1	Because	because	IN
5180	387	2	the	the	DT
5180	387	3	Web	web	NN
5180	387	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	387	5	decentralized	decentralize	VBN
5180	387	6	,	,	,
5180	387	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	387	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	387	9	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	387	10	to	to	TO
5180	387	11	say	say	VB
5180	387	12	exactly	exactly	RB
5180	387	13	how	how	WRB
5180	387	14	large	large	JJ
5180	387	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	387	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	387	17	.	.	.
5180	388	1	A	a	DT
5180	388	2	2000	2000	CD
5180	388	3	study	study	NN
5180	388	4	estimated	estimate	VBD
5180	388	5	a	a	DT
5180	388	6	total	total	NN
5180	388	7	of	of	IN
5180	388	8	7.1	7.1	CD
5180	388	9	million	million	CD
5180	388	10	unique	unique	JJ
5180	388	11	Web	web	NN
5180	388	12	sites	site	NNS
5180	388	13	,	,	,
5180	388	14	which	which	WDT
5180	388	15	at	at	IN
5180	388	16	the	the	DT
5180	388	17	Web	web	NN
5180	388	18	's	's	POS
5180	388	19	historical	historical	JJ
5180	388	20	rate	rate	NN
5180	388	21	of	of	IN
5180	388	22	growth	growth	NN
5180	388	23	,	,	,
5180	388	24	would	would	MD
5180	388	25	have	have	VB
5180	388	26	increased	increase	VBN
5180	388	27	to	to	IN
5180	388	28	11	11	CD
5180	388	29	million	million	CD
5180	388	30	unique	unique	JJ
5180	388	31	sites	site	NNS
5180	388	32	as	as	IN
5180	388	33	of	of	IN
5180	388	34	September	September	NNP
5180	388	35	2001	2001	CD
5180	388	36	.	.	.
5180	389	1	Estimates	estimate	NNS
5180	389	2	of	of	IN
5180	389	3	the	the	DT
5180	389	4	total	total	JJ
5180	389	5	number	number	NN
5180	389	6	of	of	IN
5180	389	7	Web	web	NN
5180	389	8	pages	page	NNS
5180	389	9	vary	vary	VBP
5180	389	10	,	,	,
5180	389	11	but	but	CC
5180	389	12	a	a	DT
5180	389	13	figure	figure	NN
5180	389	14	of	of	IN
5180	389	15	2	2	CD
5180	389	16	billion	billion	CD
5180	389	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	389	18	a	a	DT
5180	389	19	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
5180	389	20	estimate	estimate	NN
5180	389	21	of	of	IN
5180	389	22	the	the	DT
5180	389	23	number	number	NN
5180	389	24	of	of	IN
5180	389	25	Web	web	NN
5180	389	26	pages	page	NNS
5180	389	27	that	that	WDT
5180	389	28	can	can	MD
5180	389	29	be	be	VB
5180	389	30	reached	reach	VBN
5180	389	31	,	,	,
5180	389	32	in	in	IN
5180	389	33	theory	theory	NN
5180	389	34	,	,	,
5180	389	35	by	by	IN
5180	389	36	standard	standard	JJ
5180	389	37	search	search	NN
5180	389	38	engines	engine	NNS
5180	389	39	.	.	.
5180	390	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	390	2	need	need	VBP
5180	390	3	not	not	RB
5180	390	4	make	make	VB
5180	390	5	a	a	DT
5180	390	6	specific	specific	JJ
5180	390	7	finding	finding	NN
5180	390	8	as	as	IN
5180	390	9	to	to	IN
5180	390	10	a	a	DT
5180	390	11	figure	figure	NN
5180	390	12	,	,	,
5180	390	13	for	for	IN
5180	390	14	by	by	IN
5180	390	15	any	any	DT
5180	390	16	measure	measure	NN
5180	390	17	the	the	DT
5180	390	18	Web	web	NN
5180	390	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	390	20	extremely	extremely	RB
5180	390	21	vast	vast	JJ
5180	390	22	,	,	,
5180	390	23	and	and	CC
5180	390	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	390	25	is	be	VBZ
5180	390	26	constantly	constantly	RB
5180	390	27	growing	grow	VBG
5180	390	28	.	.	.
5180	391	1	The	the	DT
5180	391	2	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	391	3	Web	web	NN
5180	391	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	391	5	growing	grow	VBG
5180	391	6	at	at	IN
5180	391	7	a	a	DT
5180	391	8	rate	rate	NN
5180	391	9	of	of	IN
5180	391	10	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	391	11	1.5	1.5	CD
5180	391	12	million	million	CD
5180	391	13	pages	page	NNS
5180	391	14	per	per	IN
5180	391	15	day	day	NN
5180	391	16	.	.	.
5180	392	1	The	the	DT
5180	392	2	size	size	NN
5180	392	3	of	of	IN
5180	392	4	the	the	DT
5180	392	5	un	un	NNP
5180	392	6	-	-	HYPH
5180	392	7	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	392	8	Web	web	NN
5180	392	9	,	,	,
5180	392	10	or	or	CC
5180	392	11	the	the	DT
5180	392	12	"	"	``
5180	392	13	Deep	deep	JJ
5180	392	14	Web	web	NN
5180	392	15	,	,	,
5180	392	16	"	"	''
5180	392	17	while	while	IN
5180	392	18	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	392	19	to	to	TO
5180	392	20	determine	determine	VB
5180	392	21	precisely	precisely	RB
5180	392	22	,	,	,
5180	392	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	392	24	estimated	estimate	VBN
5180	392	25	to	to	TO
5180	392	26	be	be	VB
5180	392	27	two	two	CD
5180	392	28	to	to	TO
5180	392	29	ten	ten	CD
5180	392	30	times	time	NNS
5180	392	31	that	that	DT
5180	392	32	of	of	IN
5180	392	33	the	the	DT
5180	392	34	publicly	publicly	RB
5180	392	35	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	392	36	Web	web	NN
5180	392	37	.	.	.
5180	393	1	In	in	IN
5180	393	2	addition	addition	NN
5180	393	3	to	to	IN
5180	393	4	growing	grow	VBG
5180	393	5	rapidly	rapidly	RB
5180	393	6	,	,	,
5180	393	7	Web	web	NN
5180	393	8	pages	page	NNS
5180	393	9	and	and	CC
5180	393	10	sites	site	NNS
5180	393	11	are	be	VBP
5180	393	12	constantly	constantly	RB
5180	393	13	being	be	VBG
5180	393	14	removed	remove	VBN
5180	393	15	,	,	,
5180	393	16	or	or	CC
5180	393	17	changing	change	VBG
5180	393	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	393	19	content	content	NN
5180	393	20	.	.	.
5180	394	1	Web	web	NN
5180	394	2	sites	site	NNS
5180	394	3	or	or	CC
5180	394	4	pages	page	NNS
5180	394	5	can	can	MD
5180	394	6	change	change	VB
5180	394	7	content	content	NN
5180	394	8	without	without	IN
5180	394	9	changing	change	VBG
5180	394	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	394	11	domain	domain	NN
5180	394	12	name	name	NN
5180	394	13	addresses	address	NNS
5180	394	14	or	or	CC
5180	394	15	IP	IP	NNP
5180	394	16	addresses	address	NNS
5180	394	17	.	.	.
5180	395	1	Individual	individual	JJ
5180	395	2	Web	web	NN
5180	395	3	pages	page	NNS
5180	395	4	have	have	VBP
5180	395	5	an	an	DT
5180	395	6	average	average	JJ
5180	395	7	life	life	NN
5180	395	8	span	span	NN
5180	395	9	of	of	IN
5180	395	10	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	395	11	90	90	CD
5180	395	12	days	day	NNS
5180	395	13	.	.	.
5180	396	1	3	3	LS
5180	396	2	.	.	.
5180	397	1	The	the	DT
5180	397	2	Amount	Amount	NNP
5180	397	3	of	of	IN
5180	397	4	Sexually	Sexually	NNP
5180	397	5	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	397	6	Material	Material	NNP
5180	397	7	on	on	IN
5180	397	8	the	the	DT
5180	397	9	Web	web	NN
5180	397	10	There	there	EX
5180	397	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	397	12	a	a	DT
5180	397	13	vast	vast	JJ
5180	397	14	amount	amount	NN
5180	397	15	of	of	IN
5180	397	16	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	397	17	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	397	18	material	material	NN
5180	397	19	available	available	JJ
5180	397	20	via	via	IN
5180	397	21	the	the	DT
5180	397	22	Internet	internet	NN
5180	397	23	and	and	CC
5180	397	24	the	the	DT
5180	397	25	Web	web	NN
5180	397	26	.	.	.
5180	398	1	Sexually	sexually	RB
5180	398	2	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	398	3	material	material	NN
5180	398	4	on	on	IN
5180	398	5	the	the	DT
5180	398	6	Internet	internet	NN
5180	398	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	398	8	easy	easy	JJ
5180	398	9	to	to	TO
5180	398	10	access	access	VB
5180	398	11	using	use	VBG
5180	398	12	any	any	DT
5180	398	13	public	public	JJ
5180	398	14	search	search	NN
5180	398	15	engine	engine	NN
5180	398	16	,	,	,
5180	398	17	such	such	JJ
5180	398	18	as	as	IN
5180	398	19	,	,	,
5180	398	20	for	for	IN
5180	398	21	example	example	NN
5180	398	22	,	,	,
5180	398	23	Google	Google	NNP
5180	398	24	or	or	CC
5180	398	25	AltaVista	AltaVista	NNP
5180	398	26	.	.	.
5180	399	1	Although	although	IN
5180	399	2	much	much	JJ
5180	399	3	of	of	IN
5180	399	4	the	the	DT
5180	399	5	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	399	6	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	399	7	material	material	NN
5180	399	8	available	available	JJ
5180	399	9	on	on	IN
5180	399	10	the	the	DT
5180	399	11	Web	web	NN
5180	399	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	399	13	posted	post	VBN
5180	399	14	on	on	IN
5180	399	15	commercial	commercial	JJ
5180	399	16	sites	site	NNS
5180	399	17	that	that	WDT
5180	399	18	require	require	VBP
5180	399	19	viewers	viewer	NNS
5180	399	20	to	to	TO
5180	399	21	pay	pay	VB
5180	399	22	in	in	IN
5180	399	23	order	order	NN
5180	399	24	to	to	TO
5180	399	25	gain	gain	VB
5180	399	26	access	access	NN
5180	399	27	to	to	IN
5180	399	28	the	the	DT
5180	399	29	site	site	NN
5180	399	30	,	,	,
5180	399	31	a	a	DT
5180	399	32	large	large	JJ
5180	399	33	number	number	NN
5180	399	34	of	of	IN
5180	399	35	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	399	36	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	399	37	sites	site	NNS
5180	399	38	may	may	MD
5180	399	39	be	be	VB
5180	399	40	accessed	access	VBN
5180	399	41	for	for	IN
5180	399	42	free	free	JJ
5180	399	43	and	and	CC
5180	399	44	without	without	IN
5180	399	45	providing	provide	VBG
5180	399	46	any	any	DT
5180	399	47	registration	registration	NN
5180	399	48	information	information	NN
5180	399	49	.	.	.
5180	400	1	Most	most	RBS
5180	400	2	importantly	importantly	RB
5180	400	3	,	,	,
5180	400	4	some	some	DT
5180	400	5	Web	web	NN
5180	400	6	sites	site	NNS
5180	400	7	that	that	WDT
5180	400	8	contain	contain	VBP
5180	400	9	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	400	10	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	400	11	content	content	NN
5180	400	12	have	have	VBP
5180	400	13	innocuous	innocuous	JJ
5180	400	14	domain	domain	NN
5180	400	15	names	name	NNS
5180	400	16	and	and	CC
5180	400	17	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	400	18	can	can	MD
5180	400	19	be	be	VB
5180	400	20	reached	reach	VBN
5180	400	21	accidentally	accidentally	RB
5180	400	22	.	.	.
5180	401	1	A	a	DT
5180	401	2	commonly	commonly	RB
5180	401	3	cited	cite	VBN
5180	401	4	example	example	NN
5180	401	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	401	6	http://www.whitehouse.com	http://www.whitehouse.com	ADD
5180	401	7	.	.	.
5180	402	1	Other	other	JJ
5180	402	2	innocent	innocent	JJ
5180	402	3	-	-	HYPH
5180	402	4	sounding	sound	VBG
5180	402	5	URLs	url	NNS
5180	402	6	that	that	WDT
5180	402	7	retrieve	retrieve	VBP
5180	402	8	graphic	graphic	JJ
5180	402	9	,	,	,
5180	402	10	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	402	11	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	402	12	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	402	13	include	include	VBP
5180	402	14	http://www.boys.com	http://www.boys.com	ADD
5180	402	15	,	,	,
5180	402	16	http://www.girls.com	http://www.girls.com	ADD
5180	402	17	,	,	,
5180	402	18	http://www.coffeebeansupply.com	http://www.coffeebeansupply.com	ADD
5180	402	19	,	,	,
5180	402	20	and	and	CC
5180	402	21	http://www.BookstoreUSA.com	http://www.bookstoreusa.com	ADD
5180	402	22	.	.	.
5180	403	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	403	2	,	,	,
5180	403	3	commercial	commercial	JJ
5180	403	4	Web	web	NN
5180	403	5	sites	site	NNS
5180	403	6	that	that	WDT
5180	403	7	contain	contain	VBP
5180	403	8	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	403	9	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	403	10	material	material	NN
5180	403	11	often	often	RB
5180	403	12	use	use	VBP
5180	403	13	a	a	DT
5180	403	14	technique	technique	NN
5180	403	15	of	of	IN
5180	403	16	attaching	attach	VBG
5180	403	17	pop	pop	VB
5180	403	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	403	19	up	up	RP
5180	403	20	windows	window	NNS
5180	403	21	to	to	IN
5180	403	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	403	23	sites	site	NNS
5180	403	24	,	,	,
5180	403	25	which	which	WDT
5180	403	26	open	open	VBP
5180	403	27	new	new	JJ
5180	403	28	windows	window	NNS
5180	403	29	advertising	advertising	NN
5180	403	30	other	other	JJ
5180	403	31	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	403	32	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	403	33	sites	site	NNS
5180	403	34	without	without	IN
5180	403	35	any	any	DT
5180	403	36	prompting	prompting	NN
5180	403	37	by	by	IN
5180	403	38	the	the	DT
5180	403	39	user	user	NN
5180	403	40	.	.	.
5180	404	1	This	this	DT
5180	404	2	technique	technique	NN
5180	404	3	makes	make	VBZ
5180	404	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	404	5	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	404	6	for	for	IN
5180	404	7	a	a	DT
5180	404	8	user	user	NN
5180	404	9	quickly	quickly	RB
5180	404	10	to	to	TO
5180	404	11	exit	exit	VB
5180	404	12	all	all	DT
5180	404	13	of	of	IN
5180	404	14	the	the	DT
5180	404	15	pages	page	NNS
5180	404	16	containing	contain	VBG
5180	404	17	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	404	18	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	404	19	material	material	NN
5180	404	20	,	,	,
5180	404	21	whether	whether	IN
5180	404	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	404	23	or	or	CC
5180	404	24	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	404	25	initially	initially	RB
5180	404	26	accessed	access	VBD
5180	404	27	such	such	JJ
5180	404	28	material	material	NN
5180	404	29	intentionally	intentionally	RB
5180	404	30	or	or	CC
5180	404	31	not	not	RB
5180	404	32	.	.	.
5180	405	1	The	the	DT
5180	405	2	percentage	percentage	NN
5180	405	3	of	of	IN
5180	405	4	Web	web	NN
5180	405	5	pages	page	NNS
5180	405	6	on	on	IN
5180	405	7	the	the	DT
5180	405	8	indexed	indexed	JJ
5180	405	9	Web	web	NN
5180	405	10	containing	contain	VBG
5180	405	11	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	405	12	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	405	13	content	content	NN
5180	405	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	405	15	relatively	relatively	RB
5180	405	16	small	small	JJ
5180	405	17	.	.	.
5180	406	1	Recent	recent	JJ
5180	406	2	estimates	estimate	NNS
5180	406	3	indicate	indicate	VBP
5180	406	4	that	that	IN
5180	406	5	no	no	DT
5180	406	6	more	more	JJR
5180	406	7	than	than	IN
5180	406	8	1	1	CD
5180	406	9	-	-	SYM
5180	406	10	2	2	CD
5180	406	11	%	%	NN
5180	406	12	of	of	IN
5180	406	13	the	the	DT
5180	406	14	content	content	NN
5180	406	15	on	on	IN
5180	406	16	the	the	DT
5180	406	17	Web	web	NN
5180	406	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	406	19	pornographic	pornographic	JJ
5180	406	20	or	or	CC
5180	406	21	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	406	22	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	406	23	.	.	.
5180	407	1	However	however	RB
5180	407	2	,	,	,
5180	407	3	the	the	DT
5180	407	4	absolute	absolute	JJ
5180	407	5	number	number	NN
5180	407	6	of	of	IN
5180	407	7	Web	web	NN
5180	407	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	407	9	offering	offer	VBG
5180	407	10	free	free	JJ
5180	407	11	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	407	12	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	407	13	material	material	NN
5180	407	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	407	15	extremely	extremely	RB
5180	407	16	large	large	JJ
5180	407	17	,	,	,
5180	407	18	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	407	19	100,000	100,000	CD
5180	407	20	sites	site	NNS
5180	407	21	.	.	.
5180	408	1	4	4	LS
5180	408	2	.	.	.
5180	409	1	American	American	NNP
5180	409	2	Public	Public	NNP
5180	409	3	Libraries	librarie	VBZ
5180	409	4	The	the	DT
5180	409	5	more	more	JJR
5180	409	6	than	than	IN
5180	409	7	9,000	9,000	CD
5180	409	8	public	public	JJ
5180	409	9	libraries	library	NNS
5180	409	10	in	in	IN
5180	409	11	the	the	DT
5180	409	12	United	United	NNP
5180	409	13	States	States	NNP
5180	409	14	are	be	VBP
5180	409	15	typically	typically	RB
5180	409	16	funded	fund	VBN
5180	409	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	409	18	at	at	IN
5180	409	19	least	least	JJS
5180	409	20	in	in	IN
5180	409	21	large	large	JJ
5180	409	22	part	part	NN
5180	409	23	)	)	-RRB-
5180	409	24	by	by	IN
5180	409	25	state	state	NN
5180	409	26	or	or	CC
5180	409	27	local	local	JJ
5180	409	28	governments	government	NNS
5180	409	29	.	.	.
5180	410	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
5180	410	2	are	be	VBP
5180	410	3	frequently	frequently	RB
5180	410	4	overseen	oversee	VBN
5180	410	5	by	by	IN
5180	410	6	a	a	DT
5180	410	7	board	board	NN
5180	410	8	of	of	IN
5180	410	9	directors	director	NNS
5180	410	10	that	that	WDT
5180	410	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	410	12	either	either	CC
5180	410	13	elected	elect	VBN
5180	410	14	or	or	CC
5180	410	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	410	16	appointed	appoint	VBN
5180	410	17	by	by	IN
5180	410	18	an	an	DT
5180	410	19	elected	elect	VBN
5180	410	20	official	official	NN
5180	410	21	or	or	CC
5180	410	22	a	a	DT
5180	410	23	body	body	NN
5180	410	24	of	of	IN
5180	410	25	elected	elect	VBN
5180	410	26	officials	official	NNS
5180	410	27	.	.	.
5180	411	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	411	2	heard	hear	VBD
5180	411	3	testimony	testimony	NN
5180	411	4	from	from	IN
5180	411	5	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	411	6	and	and	CC
5180	411	7	library	library	JJ
5180	411	8	board	board	NN
5180	411	9	members	member	NNS
5180	411	10	working	work	VBG
5180	411	11	in	in	IN
5180	411	12	eight	eight	CD
5180	411	13	public	public	JJ
5180	411	14	library	library	NN
5180	411	15	systems	system	NNS
5180	411	16	in	in	IN
5180	411	17	different	different	JJ
5180	411	18	communities	community	NNS
5180	411	19	across	across	IN
5180	411	20	the	the	DT
5180	411	21	country	country	NN
5180	411	22	,	,	,
5180	411	23	some	some	DT
5180	411	24	of	of	IN
5180	411	25	whom	whom	WP
5180	411	26	are	be	VBP
5180	411	27	also	also	RB
5180	411	28	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	411	29	in	in	IN
5180	411	30	this	this	DT
5180	411	31	case	case	NN
5180	411	32	.	.	.
5180	412	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
5180	412	2	hailed	hail	VBD
5180	412	3	from	from	IN
5180	412	4	the	the	DT
5180	412	5	following	follow	VBG
5180	412	6	library	library	NN
5180	412	7	systems	system	NNS
5180	412	8	:	:	:
5180	412	9	Fort	Fort	NNP
5180	412	10	Vancouver	Vancouver	NNP
5180	412	11	,	,	,
5180	412	12	Washington	Washington	NNP
5180	412	13	;	;	:
5180	412	14	Fulton	Fulton	NNP
5180	412	15	County	County	NNP
5180	412	16	,	,	,
5180	412	17	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
5180	412	18	;	;	:
5180	412	19	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	412	20	,	,	,
5180	412	21	South	South	NNP
5180	412	22	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
5180	412	23	;	;	:
5180	412	24	a	a	DT
5180	412	25	regional	regional	JJ
5180	412	26	consortium	consortium	NN
5180	412	27	of	of	IN
5180	412	28	libraries	library	NNS
5180	412	29	centered	center	VBN
5180	412	30	in	in	IN
5180	412	31	Madison	Madison	NNP
5180	412	32	,	,	,
5180	412	33	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
5180	412	34	;	;	:
5180	412	35	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
5180	412	36	County	County	NNP
5180	412	37	,	,	,
5180	412	38	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
5180	412	39	;	;	:
5180	412	40	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
5180	412	41	,	,	,
5180	412	42	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
5180	412	43	;	;	:
5180	412	44	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	412	45	,	,	,
5180	412	46	Washington	Washington	NNP
5180	412	47	;	;	:
5180	412	48	and	and	CC
5180	412	49	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	412	50	,	,	,
5180	412	51	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
5180	412	52	.	.	.
5180	413	1	The	the	DT
5180	413	2	parties	party	NNS
5180	413	3	also	also	RB
5180	413	4	took	take	VBD
5180	413	5	depositions	deposition	NNS
5180	413	6	from	from	IN
5180	413	7	several	several	JJ
5180	413	8	other	other	JJ
5180	413	9	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	413	10	and	and	CC
5180	413	11	library	library	JJ
5180	413	12	board	board	NN
5180	413	13	members	member	NNS
5180	413	14	who	who	WP
5180	413	15	did	do	VBD
5180	413	16	not	not	RB
5180	413	17	testify	testify	VB
5180	413	18	during	during	IN
5180	413	19	the	the	DT
5180	413	20	trial	trial	NN
5180	413	21	,	,	,
5180	413	22	and	and	CC
5180	413	23	submitted	submit	VBD
5180	413	24	a	a	DT
5180	413	25	number	number	NN
5180	413	26	of	of	IN
5180	413	27	other	other	JJ
5180	413	28	documents	document	NNS
5180	413	29	regarding	regard	VBG
5180	413	30	individual	individual	JJ
5180	413	31	libraries	library	NNS
5180	413	32	'	'	POS
5180	413	33	policies	policy	NNS
5180	413	34	.	.	.
5180	414	1	1	1	LS
5180	414	2	.	.	.
5180	415	1	The	the	DT
5180	415	2	Mission	Mission	NNP
5180	415	3	of	of	IN
5180	415	4	Public	Public	NNP
5180	415	5	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	415	6	,	,	,
5180	415	7	and	and	CC
5180	415	8	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	415	9	Reference	Reference	NNP
5180	415	10	and	and	CC
5180	415	11	Collection	Collection	NNP
5180	415	12	Development	Development	NNP
5180	415	13	Practices	Practices	NNPS
5180	415	14	American	american	JJ
5180	415	15	public	public	JJ
5180	415	16	libraries	library	NNS
5180	415	17	operate	operate	VBP
5180	415	18	in	in	IN
5180	415	19	a	a	DT
5180	415	20	wide	wide	JJ
5180	415	21	variety	variety	NN
5180	415	22	of	of	IN
5180	415	23	communities	community	NNS
5180	415	24	,	,	,
5180	415	25	and	and	CC
5180	415	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	415	27	is	be	VBZ
5180	415	28	not	not	RB
5180	415	29	surprising	surprising	JJ
5180	415	30	that	that	IN
5180	415	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	415	32	do	do	VBP
5180	415	33	not	not	RB
5180	415	34	all	all	RB
5180	415	35	view	view	VB
5180	415	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	415	37	mission	mission	NN
5180	415	38	identically	identically	RB
5180	415	39	.	.	.
5180	416	1	Nor	nor	CC
5180	416	2	are	be	VBP
5180	416	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	416	4	practices	practice	NNS
5180	416	5	uniform	uniform	JJ
5180	416	6	.	.	.
5180	417	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
5180	417	2	,	,	,
5180	417	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	417	4	generally	generally	RB
5180	417	5	share	share	VBP
5180	417	6	a	a	DT
5180	417	7	common	common	JJ
5180	417	8	mission	mission	NN
5180	417	9	–	–	:
5180	417	10	to	to	TO
5180	417	11	provide	provide	VB
5180	417	12	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	417	13	with	with	IN
5180	417	14	a	a	DT
5180	417	15	wide	wide	JJ
5180	417	16	range	range	NN
5180	417	17	of	of	IN
5180	417	18	information	information	NN
5180	417	19	and	and	CC
5180	417	20	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	417	21	.	.	.
5180	418	1	Public	public	JJ
5180	418	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	418	3	across	across	IN
5180	418	4	the	the	DT
5180	418	5	country	country	NN
5180	418	6	have	have	VBP
5180	418	7	endorsed	endorse	VBN
5180	418	8	the	the	DT
5180	418	9	American	American	NNP
5180	418	10	Library	Library	NNP
5180	418	11	Association	Association	NNP
5180	418	12	's	's	POS
5180	418	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	418	14	"	"	``
5180	418	15	ALA	ALA	NNP
5180	418	16	"	"	''
5180	418	17	)	)	-RRB-
5180	418	18	"	"	``
5180	418	19	Library	Library	NNP
5180	418	20	Bill	Bill	NNP
5180	418	21	of	of	IN
5180	418	22	Rights	Rights	NNPS
5180	418	23	"	"	''
5180	418	24	and/or	and/or	CC
5180	418	25	"	"	``
5180	418	26	Freedom	freedom	NN
5180	418	27	to	to	TO
5180	418	28	Read	read	VB
5180	418	29	Statement	Statement	NNP
5180	418	30	,	,	,
5180	418	31	"	"	''
5180	418	32	including	include	VBG
5180	418	33	every	every	DT
5180	418	34	library	library	NN
5180	418	35	testifying	testify	VBG
5180	418	36	on	on	IN
5180	418	37	behalf	behalf	NN
5180	418	38	of	of	IN
5180	418	39	the	the	DT
5180	418	40	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	418	41	in	in	IN
5180	418	42	this	this	DT
5180	418	43	case	case	NN
5180	418	44	.	.	.
5180	419	1	The	the	DT
5180	419	2	"	"	``
5180	419	3	Library	Library	NNP
5180	419	4	Bill	Bill	NNP
5180	419	5	of	of	IN
5180	419	6	Rights	Rights	NNPS
5180	419	7	,	,	,
5180	419	8	"	"	''
5180	419	9	first	first	RB
5180	419	10	adopted	adopt	VBN
5180	419	11	by	by	IN
5180	419	12	the	the	DT
5180	419	13	ALA	ALA	NNP
5180	419	14	in	in	IN
5180	419	15	1948	1948	CD
5180	419	16	,	,	,
5180	419	17	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	419	18	,	,	,
5180	419	19	among	among	IN
5180	419	20	other	other	JJ
5180	419	21	things	thing	NNS
5180	419	22	,	,	,
5180	419	23	that	that	IN
5180	419	24	"	"	``
5180	419	25	[	[	-LRB-
5180	419	26	b]ooks	b]ook	NNS
5180	419	27	and	and	CC
5180	419	28	other	other	JJ
5180	419	29	library	library	JJ
5180	419	30	resources	resource	NNS
5180	419	31	should	should	MD
5180	419	32	be	be	VB
5180	419	33	provided	provide	VBN
5180	419	34	for	for	IN
5180	419	35	the	the	DT
5180	419	36	interest	interest	NN
5180	419	37	,	,	,
5180	419	38	information	information	NN
5180	419	39	,	,	,
5180	419	40	and	and	CC
5180	419	41	enlightenment	enlightenment	NN
5180	419	42	of	of	IN
5180	419	43	all	all	DT
5180	419	44	people	people	NNS
5180	419	45	of	of	IN
5180	419	46	the	the	DT
5180	419	47	community	community	NN
5180	419	48	the	the	DT
5180	419	49	library	library	NN
5180	419	50	serves	serve	VBZ
5180	419	51	.	.	.
5180	419	52	"	"	''
5180	420	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	420	2	also	also	RB
5180	420	3	states	state	VBZ
5180	420	4	that	that	IN
5180	420	5	libraries	library	NNS
5180	420	6	"	"	``
5180	420	7	should	should	MD
5180	420	8	provide	provide	VB
5180	420	9	materials	material	NNS
5180	420	10	and	and	CC
5180	420	11	information	information	NN
5180	420	12	presenting	present	VBG
5180	420	13	all	all	DT
5180	420	14	points	point	NNS
5180	420	15	of	of	IN
5180	420	16	view	view	NN
5180	420	17	on	on	IN
5180	420	18	current	current	JJ
5180	420	19	and	and	CC
5180	420	20	historical	historical	JJ
5180	420	21	issues	issue	NNS
5180	420	22	"	"	''
5180	420	23	and	and	CC
5180	420	24	that	that	IN
5180	420	25	library	library	JJ
5180	420	26	materials	material	NNS
5180	420	27	"	"	``
5180	420	28	should	should	MD
5180	420	29	not	not	RB
5180	420	30	be	be	VB
5180	420	31	proscribed	proscribe	VBN
5180	420	32	or	or	CC
5180	420	33	removed	remove	VBN
5180	420	34	because	because	RB
5180	420	35	of	of	IN
5180	420	36	partisan	partisan	JJ
5180	420	37	or	or	CC
5180	420	38	doctrinal	doctrinal	JJ
5180	420	39	disapproval	disapproval	NN
5180	420	40	.	.	.
5180	420	41	"	"	''
5180	421	1	The	the	DT
5180	421	2	ALA	ALA	NNP
5180	421	3	's	's	POS
5180	421	4	"	"	``
5180	421	5	Freedom	freedom	NN
5180	421	6	to	to	TO
5180	421	7	Read	read	VB
5180	421	8	"	"	''
5180	421	9	statement	statement	NN
5180	421	10	,	,	,
5180	421	11	adopted	adopt	VBN
5180	421	12	in	in	IN
5180	421	13	1953	1953	CD
5180	421	14	and	and	CC
5180	421	15	most	most	RBS
5180	421	16	recently	recently	RB
5180	421	17	updated	update	VBN
5180	421	18	in	in	IN
5180	421	19	July	July	NNP
5180	421	20	2000	2000	CD
5180	421	21	,	,	,
5180	421	22	states	state	NNS
5180	421	23	,	,	,
5180	421	24	among	among	IN
5180	421	25	other	other	JJ
5180	421	26	things	thing	NNS
5180	421	27	,	,	,
5180	421	28	that	that	IN
5180	421	29	"	"	``
5180	421	30	[	[	-LRB-
5180	421	31	i]t	i]t	NN
5180	421	32	is	be	VBZ
5180	421	33	in	in	IN
5180	421	34	the	the	DT
5180	421	35	public	public	JJ
5180	421	36	interest	interest	NN
5180	421	37	for	for	IN
5180	421	38	publishers	publisher	NNS
5180	421	39	and	and	CC
5180	421	40	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	421	41	to	to	TO
5180	421	42	make	make	VB
5180	421	43	available	available	JJ
5180	421	44	the	the	DT
5180	421	45	widest	wide	JJS
5180	421	46	diversity	diversity	NN
5180	421	47	of	of	IN
5180	421	48	views	view	NNS
5180	421	49	and	and	CC
5180	421	50	expressions	expression	NNS
5180	421	51	,	,	,
5180	421	52	including	include	VBG
5180	421	53	those	those	DT
5180	421	54	that	that	WDT
5180	421	55	are	be	VBP
5180	421	56	unorthodox	unorthodox	JJ
5180	421	57	or	or	CC
5180	421	58	unpopular	unpopular	JJ
5180	421	59	with	with	IN
5180	421	60	the	the	DT
5180	421	61	majority	majority	NN
5180	421	62	.	.	.
5180	421	63	"	"	''
5180	422	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	422	2	also	also	RB
5180	422	3	states	state	VBZ
5180	422	4	that	that	IN
5180	422	5	"	"	``
5180	422	6	[	[	-LRB-
5180	422	7	i]t	i]t	NN
5180	422	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	422	9	the	the	DT
5180	422	10	responsibility	responsibility	NN
5180	422	11	of	of	IN
5180	422	12	.	.	.
5180	423	1	.	.	.
5180	424	1	.	.	.
5180	425	1	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	425	2	.	.	.
5180	426	1	.	.	.
5180	427	1	.	.	.
5180	428	1	to	to	TO
5180	428	2	contest	contest	VB
5180	428	3	encroachments	encroachment	NNS
5180	428	4	upon	upon	IN
5180	428	5	th[e	th[e	NNP
5180	428	6	]	]	-RRB-
5180	428	7	freedom	freedom	NN
5180	428	8	[	[	-LRB-
5180	428	9	to	to	TO
5180	428	10	read	read	VB
5180	428	11	]	]	-RRB-
5180	428	12	by	by	IN
5180	428	13	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	428	14	or	or	CC
5180	428	15	groups	group	NNS
5180	428	16	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	428	17	to	to	TO
5180	428	18	impose	impose	VB
5180	428	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	428	20	own	own	JJ
5180	428	21	standards	standard	NNS
5180	428	22	or	or	CC
5180	428	23	tastes	taste	NNS
5180	428	24	upon	upon	IN
5180	428	25	the	the	DT
5180	428	26	community	community	NN
5180	428	27	at	at	IN
5180	428	28	large	large	JJ
5180	428	29	.	.	.
5180	428	30	"	"	''
5180	429	1	Public	public	JJ
5180	429	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	429	3	provide	provide	VBP
5180	429	4	information	information	NN
5180	429	5	not	not	RB
5180	429	6	only	only	RB
5180	429	7	for	for	IN
5180	429	8	educational	educational	JJ
5180	429	9	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	429	10	,	,	,
5180	429	11	but	but	CC
5180	429	12	also	also	RB
5180	429	13	for	for	IN
5180	429	14	recreational	recreational	JJ
5180	429	15	,	,	,
5180	429	16	professional	professional	JJ
5180	429	17	,	,	,
5180	429	18	and	and	CC
5180	429	19	other	other	JJ
5180	429	20	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	429	21	.	.	.
5180	430	1	For	for	IN
5180	430	2	example	example	NN
5180	430	3	,	,	,
5180	430	4	Ginnie	Ginnie	NNP
5180	430	5	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
5180	430	6	,	,	,
5180	430	7	Director	Director	NNP
5180	430	8	of	of	IN
5180	430	9	the	the	DT
5180	430	10	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
5180	430	11	County	County	NNP
5180	430	12	Library	Library	NNP
5180	430	13	,	,	,
5180	430	14	testified	testify	VBD
5180	430	15	that	that	IN
5180	430	16	some	some	DT
5180	430	17	of	of	IN
5180	430	18	the	the	DT
5180	430	19	library	library	NN
5180	430	20	's	's	POS
5180	430	21	most	most	RBS
5180	430	22	popular	popular	JJ
5180	430	23	items	item	NNS
5180	430	24	include	include	VBP
5180	430	25	video	video	NN
5180	430	26	tapes	tape	NNS
5180	430	27	of	of	IN
5180	430	28	the	the	DT
5180	430	29	British	British	NNP
5180	430	30	Broadcasting	Broadcasting	NNP
5180	430	31	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
5180	430	32	's	's	POS
5180	430	33	"	"	``
5180	430	34	Fawlty	Fawlty	NNP
5180	430	35	Towers	Towers	NNP
5180	430	36	"	"	''
5180	430	37	series	series	NN
5180	430	38	,	,	,
5180	430	39	and	and	CC
5180	430	40	also	also	RB
5180	430	41	print	print	VB
5180	430	42	and	and	CC
5180	430	43	"	"	``
5180	430	44	books	book	NNS
5180	430	45	on	on	IN
5180	430	46	tape	tape	NN
5180	430	47	"	"	''
5180	430	48	versions	version	NNS
5180	430	49	of	of	IN
5180	430	50	science	science	NN
5180	430	51	fiction	fiction	NN
5180	430	52	,	,	,
5180	430	53	romance	romance	NN
5180	430	54	,	,	,
5180	430	55	and	and	CC
5180	430	56	mystery	mystery	NN
5180	430	57	novels	novel	NNS
5180	430	58	.	.	.
5180	431	1	Many	many	JJ
5180	431	2	public	public	JJ
5180	431	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	431	4	include	include	VBP
5180	431	5	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	431	6	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	431	7	materials	material	NNS
5180	431	8	in	in	IN
5180	431	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	431	10	print	print	NN
5180	431	11	collection	collection	NN
5180	431	12	,	,	,
5180	431	13	such	such	JJ
5180	431	14	as	as	IN
5180	431	15	The	the	DT
5180	431	16	Joy	Joy	NNP
5180	431	17	of	of	IN
5180	431	18	Sex	Sex	NNP
5180	431	19	and	and	CC
5180	431	20	The	the	DT
5180	431	21	Joy	Joy	NNP
5180	431	22	of	of	IN
5180	431	23	Gay	Gay	NNP
5180	431	24	Sex	Sex	NNP
5180	431	25	.	.	.
5180	432	1	Very	very	RB
5180	432	2	few	few	JJ
5180	432	3	public	public	JJ
5180	432	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	432	5	,	,	,
5180	432	6	however	however	RB
5180	432	7	,	,	,
5180	432	8	collect	collect	VB
5180	432	9	more	more	RBR
5180	432	10	graphic	graphic	JJ
5180	432	11	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	432	12	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	432	13	materials	material	NNS
5180	432	14	,	,	,
5180	432	15	such	such	JJ
5180	432	16	as	as	IN
5180	432	17	XXX	XXX	NNP
5180	432	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	432	19	rated	rate	VBN
5180	432	20	videos	video	NNS
5180	432	21	,	,	,
5180	432	22	or	or	CC
5180	432	23	Hustler	Hustler	NNP
5180	432	24	magazine	magazine	NN
5180	432	25	.	.	.
5180	433	1	The	the	DT
5180	433	2	mission	mission	NN
5180	433	3	of	of	IN
5180	433	4	public	public	JJ
5180	433	5	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	433	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	433	7	to	to	TO
5180	433	8	provide	provide	VB
5180	433	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	433	10	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	433	11	with	with	IN
5180	433	12	a	a	DT
5180	433	13	wide	wide	JJ
5180	433	14	array	array	NN
5180	433	15	of	of	IN
5180	433	16	information	information	NN
5180	433	17	,	,	,
5180	433	18	and	and	CC
5180	433	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	433	20	surely	surely	RB
5180	433	21	do	do	VBP
5180	433	22	so	so	RB
5180	433	23	.	.	.
5180	434	1	Reference	reference	NN
5180	434	2	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	434	3	across	across	IN
5180	434	4	America	America	NNP
5180	434	5	answer	answer	VBP
5180	434	6	more	more	JJR
5180	434	7	than	than	IN
5180	434	8	7	7	CD
5180	434	9	million	million	CD
5180	434	10	questions	question	NNS
5180	434	11	weekly	weekly	JJ
5180	434	12	.	.	.
5180	435	1	If	if	IN
5180	435	2	a	a	DT
5180	435	3	patron	patron	NN
5180	435	4	has	have	VBZ
5180	435	5	a	a	DT
5180	435	6	specialized	specialized	JJ
5180	435	7	need	need	NN
5180	435	8	for	for	IN
5180	435	9	information	information	NN
5180	435	10	not	not	RB
5180	435	11	available	available	JJ
5180	435	12	in	in	IN
5180	435	13	the	the	DT
5180	435	14	public	public	JJ
5180	435	15	library	library	NN
5180	435	16	,	,	,
5180	435	17	the	the	DT
5180	435	18	professional	professional	JJ
5180	435	19	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	435	20	will	will	MD
5180	435	21	use	use	VB
5180	435	22	a	a	DT
5180	435	23	reference	reference	NN
5180	435	24	interview	interview	NN
5180	435	25	to	to	TO
5180	435	26	find	find	VB
5180	435	27	out	out	RP
5180	435	28	what	what	WP
5180	435	29	information	information	NN
5180	435	30	is	be	VBZ
5180	435	31	needed	need	VBN
5180	435	32	to	to	TO
5180	435	33	help	help	VB
5180	435	34	the	the	DT
5180	435	35	user	user	NN
5180	435	36	,	,	,
5180	435	37	including	include	VBG
5180	435	38	the	the	DT
5180	435	39	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	435	40	for	for	IN
5180	435	41	which	which	WDT
5180	435	42	an	an	DT
5180	435	43	item	item	NN
5180	435	44	will	will	MD
5180	435	45	be	be	VB
5180	435	46	used	use	VBN
5180	435	47	.	.	.
5180	436	1	Reference	reference	NN
5180	436	2	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	436	3	are	be	VBP
5180	436	4	trained	train	VBN
5180	436	5	to	to	TO
5180	436	6	assist	assist	VB
5180	436	7	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	436	8	without	without	IN
5180	436	9	judging	judge	VBG
5180	436	10	the	the	DT
5180	436	11	patron	patron	NN
5180	436	12	's	's	POS
5180	436	13	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	436	14	in	in	IN
5180	436	15	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	436	16	information	information	NN
5180	436	17	,	,	,
5180	436	18	or	or	CC
5180	436	19	the	the	DT
5180	436	20	content	content	NN
5180	436	21	of	of	IN
5180	436	22	the	the	DT
5180	436	23	information	information	NN
5180	436	24	that	that	WDT
5180	436	25	the	the	DT
5180	436	26	patron	patron	NN
5180	436	27	is	be	VBZ
5180	436	28	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	436	29	.	.	.
5180	437	1	Many	many	JJ
5180	437	2	public	public	JJ
5180	437	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	437	4	routinely	routinely	RB
5180	437	5	provide	provide	VBP
5180	437	6	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	437	7	with	with	IN
5180	437	8	access	access	NN
5180	437	9	to	to	IN
5180	437	10	materials	material	NNS
5180	437	11	not	not	RB
5180	437	12	in	in	IN
5180	437	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	437	14	collections	collection	NNS
5180	437	15	through	through	IN
5180	437	16	the	the	DT
5180	437	17	use	use	NN
5180	437	18	of	of	IN
5180	437	19	bibliographic	bibliographic	JJ
5180	437	20	access	access	NN
5180	437	21	tools	tool	NNS
5180	437	22	and	and	CC
5180	437	23	interlibrary	interlibrary	JJ
5180	437	24	loan	loan	NN
5180	437	25	programs	program	NNS
5180	437	26	.	.	.
5180	438	1	Public	public	JJ
5180	438	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	438	3	typically	typically	RB
5180	438	4	will	will	MD
5180	438	5	assist	assist	VB
5180	438	6	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	438	7	in	in	IN
5180	438	8	obtaining	obtain	VBG
5180	438	9	access	access	NN
5180	438	10	to	to	IN
5180	438	11	all	all	DT
5180	438	12	materials	material	NNS
5180	438	13	except	except	IN
5180	438	14	those	those	DT
5180	438	15	that	that	WDT
5180	438	16	are	be	VBP
5180	438	17	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	438	18	,	,	,
5180	438	19	even	even	RB
5180	438	20	if	if	IN
5180	438	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	438	22	do	do	VBP
5180	438	23	not	not	RB
5180	438	24	collect	collect	VB
5180	438	25	those	those	DT
5180	438	26	materials	material	NNS
5180	438	27	in	in	IN
5180	438	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	438	29	physical	physical	JJ
5180	438	30	collection	collection	NN
5180	438	31	.	.	.
5180	439	1	In	in	IN
5180	439	2	order	order	NN
5180	439	3	to	to	TO
5180	439	4	provide	provide	VB
5180	439	5	this	this	DT
5180	439	6	access	access	NN
5180	439	7	,	,	,
5180	439	8	a	a	DT
5180	439	9	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	439	10	may	may	MD
5180	439	11	attempt	attempt	VB
5180	439	12	to	to	TO
5180	439	13	find	find	VB
5180	439	14	material	material	NN
5180	439	15	not	not	RB
5180	439	16	included	include	VBN
5180	439	17	in	in	IN
5180	439	18	the	the	DT
5180	439	19	library	library	NN
5180	439	20	's	's	POS
5180	439	21	own	own	JJ
5180	439	22	collection	collection	NN
5180	439	23	in	in	IN
5180	439	24	other	other	JJ
5180	439	25	libraries	library	NNS
5180	439	26	in	in	IN
5180	439	27	the	the	DT
5180	439	28	system	system	NN
5180	439	29	,	,	,
5180	439	30	through	through	IN
5180	439	31	interlibrary	interlibrary	JJ
5180	439	32	loan	loan	NN
5180	439	33	,	,	,
5180	439	34	or	or	CC
5180	439	35	through	through	IN
5180	439	36	a	a	DT
5180	439	37	referral	referral	NN
5180	439	38	,	,	,
5180	439	39	perhaps	perhaps	RB
5180	439	40	to	to	IN
5180	439	41	a	a	DT
5180	439	42	government	government	NN
5180	439	43	agency	agency	NN
5180	439	44	or	or	CC
5180	439	45	a	a	DT
5180	439	46	commercial	commercial	JJ
5180	439	47	bookstore	bookstore	NN
5180	439	48	.	.	.
5180	440	1	Interlibrary	interlibrary	JJ
5180	440	2	loan	loan	NN
5180	440	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	440	4	expensive	expensive	JJ
5180	440	5	,	,	,
5180	440	6	however	however	RB
5180	440	7	,	,	,
5180	440	8	and	and	CC
5180	440	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	440	10	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	440	11	used	use	VBN
5180	440	12	infrequently	infrequently	RB
5180	440	13	.	.	.
5180	441	1	Public	public	JJ
5180	441	2	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	441	3	also	also	RB
5180	441	4	apply	apply	VBP
5180	441	5	professional	professional	JJ
5180	441	6	standards	standard	NNS
5180	441	7	to	to	IN
5180	441	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	441	9	collection	collection	NN
5180	441	10	development	development	NN
5180	441	11	practices	practice	NNS
5180	441	12	.	.	.
5180	442	1	Public	public	JJ
5180	442	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	442	3	generally	generally	RB
5180	442	4	make	make	VBP
5180	442	5	material	material	NN
5180	442	6	selection	selection	NN
5180	442	7	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	442	8	and	and	CC
5180	442	9	frame	frame	NN
5180	442	10	policies	policy	NNS
5180	442	11	governing	govern	VBG
5180	442	12	collection	collection	NN
5180	442	13	development	development	NN
5180	442	14	at	at	IN
5180	442	15	the	the	DT
5180	442	16	local	local	JJ
5180	442	17	level	level	NN
5180	442	18	.	.	.
5180	443	1	Collection	collection	NN
5180	443	2	development	development	NN
5180	443	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	443	4	a	a	DT
5180	443	5	key	key	JJ
5180	443	6	subject	subject	NN
5180	443	7	in	in	IN
5180	443	8	the	the	DT
5180	443	9	curricula	curriculum	NNS
5180	443	10	of	of	IN
5180	443	11	Masters	Masters	NNP
5180	443	12	of	of	IN
5180	443	13	Library	Library	NNP
5180	443	14	Science	Science	NNP
5180	443	15	programs	program	NNS
5180	443	16	and	and	CC
5180	443	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	443	18	defined	define	VBN
5180	443	19	by	by	IN
5180	443	20	certain	certain	JJ
5180	443	21	practices	practice	NNS
5180	443	22	.	.	.
5180	444	1	In	in	IN
5180	444	2	general	general	JJ
5180	444	3	,	,	,
5180	444	4	professional	professional	JJ
5180	444	5	standards	standard	NNS
5180	444	6	guide	guide	VBP
5180	444	7	public	public	JJ
5180	444	8	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	444	9	to	to	TO
5180	444	10	build	build	VB
5180	444	11	,	,	,
5180	444	12	develop	develop	VB
5180	444	13	and	and	CC
5180	444	14	create	create	VB
5180	444	15	collections	collection	NNS
5180	444	16	that	that	WDT
5180	444	17	have	have	VBP
5180	444	18	certain	certain	JJ
5180	444	19	characteristics	characteristic	NNS
5180	444	20	,	,	,
5180	444	21	such	such	JJ
5180	444	22	as	as	IN
5180	444	23	balance	balance	NN
5180	444	24	in	in	IN
5180	444	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	444	26	coverage	coverage	NN
5180	444	27	and	and	CC
5180	444	28	requisite	requisite	JJ
5180	444	29	and	and	CC
5180	444	30	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	444	31	quality	quality	NN
5180	444	32	.	.	.
5180	445	1	To	to	IN
5180	445	2	this	this	DT
5180	445	3	end	end	NN
5180	445	4	,	,	,
5180	445	5	the	the	DT
5180	445	6	goal	goal	NN
5180	445	7	of	of	IN
5180	445	8	library	library	NN
5180	445	9	collections	collection	NNS
5180	445	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	445	11	not	not	RB
5180	445	12	universal	universal	JJ
5180	445	13	coverage	coverage	NN
5180	445	14	,	,	,
5180	445	15	but	but	CC
5180	445	16	rather	rather	RB
5180	445	17	to	to	TO
5180	445	18	find	find	VB
5180	445	19	those	those	DT
5180	445	20	materials	material	NNS
5180	445	21	that	that	WDT
5180	445	22	would	would	MD
5180	445	23	be	be	VB
5180	445	24	of	of	IN
5180	445	25	the	the	DT
5180	445	26	greatest	great	JJS
5180	445	27	direct	direct	JJ
5180	445	28	benefit	benefit	NN
5180	445	29	or	or	CC
5180	445	30	interest	interest	NN
5180	445	31	to	to	IN
5180	445	32	the	the	DT
5180	445	33	community	community	NN
5180	445	34	.	.	.
5180	446	1	In	in	IN
5180	446	2	making	make	VBG
5180	446	3	selection	selection	NN
5180	446	4	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	446	5	,	,	,
5180	446	6	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	446	7	consider	consider	VBP
5180	446	8	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	446	9	including	include	VBG
5180	446	10	the	the	DT
5180	446	11	content	content	NN
5180	446	12	of	of	IN
5180	446	13	the	the	DT
5180	446	14	material	material	NN
5180	446	15	,	,	,
5180	446	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	446	17	accuracy	accuracy	NN
5180	446	18	,	,	,
5180	446	19	the	the	DT
5180	446	20	title	title	NN
5180	446	21	's	's	POS
5180	446	22	niche	niche	NN
5180	446	23	in	in	IN
5180	446	24	relation	relation	NN
5180	446	25	to	to	IN
5180	446	26	the	the	DT
5180	446	27	rest	rest	NN
5180	446	28	of	of	IN
5180	446	29	the	the	DT
5180	446	30	collection	collection	NN
5180	446	31	,	,	,
5180	446	32	the	the	DT
5180	446	33	authority	authority	NN
5180	446	34	of	of	IN
5180	446	35	the	the	DT
5180	446	36	author	author	NN
5180	446	37	,	,	,
5180	446	38	the	the	DT
5180	446	39	publisher	publisher	NN
5180	446	40	,	,	,
5180	446	41	the	the	DT
5180	446	42	work	work	NN
5180	446	43	's	's	POS
5180	446	44	presentation	presentation	NN
5180	446	45	,	,	,
5180	446	46	and	and	CC
5180	446	47	how	how	WRB
5180	446	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	446	49	compares	compare	VBZ
5180	446	50	with	with	IN
5180	446	51	other	other	JJ
5180	446	52	material	material	NN
5180	446	53	available	available	JJ
5180	446	54	in	in	IN
5180	446	55	the	the	DT
5180	446	56	same	same	JJ
5180	446	57	genre	genre	NN
5180	446	58	or	or	CC
5180	446	59	on	on	IN
5180	446	60	the	the	DT
5180	446	61	same	same	JJ
5180	446	62	subject	subject	NN
5180	446	63	.	.	.
5180	447	1	In	in	IN
5180	447	2	pursuing	pursue	VBG
5180	447	3	the	the	DT
5180	447	4	goal	goal	NN
5180	447	5	of	of	IN
5180	447	6	achieving	achieve	VBG
5180	447	7	a	a	DT
5180	447	8	balanced	balanced	JJ
5180	447	9	collection	collection	NN
5180	447	10	that	that	WDT
5180	447	11	serves	serve	VBZ
5180	447	12	the	the	DT
5180	447	13	needs	need	NNS
5180	447	14	and	and	CC
5180	447	15	interests	interest	NNS
5180	447	16	of	of	IN
5180	447	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	447	18	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	447	19	,	,	,
5180	447	20	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	447	21	generally	generally	RB
5180	447	22	have	have	VBP
5180	447	23	a	a	DT
5180	447	24	fair	fair	JJ
5180	447	25	amount	amount	NN
5180	447	26	of	of	IN
5180	447	27	autonomy	autonomy	NN
5180	447	28	,	,	,
5180	447	29	but	but	CC
5180	447	30	may	may	MD
5180	447	31	also	also	RB
5180	447	32	be	be	VB
5180	447	33	guided	guide	VBN
5180	447	34	by	by	IN
5180	447	35	a	a	DT
5180	447	36	library	library	NN
5180	447	37	's	's	POS
5180	447	38	collection	collection	NN
5180	447	39	development	development	NN
5180	447	40	policy	policy	NN
5180	447	41	.	.	.
5180	448	1	These	these	DT
5180	448	2	collection	collection	NN
5180	448	3	development	development	NN
5180	448	4	policies	policy	NNS
5180	448	5	are	be	VBP
5180	448	6	often	often	RB
5180	448	7	drawn	draw	VBN
5180	448	8	up	up	RP
5180	448	9	in	in	IN
5180	448	10	conjunction	conjunction	NN
5180	448	11	with	with	IN
5180	448	12	the	the	DT
5180	448	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	448	14	'	'	POS
5180	448	15	governing	governing	NN
5180	448	16	boards	board	NNS
5180	448	17	and	and	CC
5180	448	18	with	with	IN
5180	448	19	representatives	representative	NNS
5180	448	20	from	from	IN
5180	448	21	the	the	DT
5180	448	22	community	community	NN
5180	448	23	,	,	,
5180	448	24	and	and	CC
5180	448	25	may	may	MD
5180	448	26	be	be	VB
5180	448	27	the	the	DT
5180	448	28	result	result	NN
5180	448	29	of	of	IN
5180	448	30	public	public	JJ
5180	448	31	hearings	hearing	NNS
5180	448	32	,	,	,
5180	448	33	discussions	discussion	NNS
5180	448	34	and	and	CC
5180	448	35	other	other	JJ
5180	448	36	input	input	NN
5180	448	37	.	.	.
5180	449	1	Although	although	IN
5180	449	2	many	many	JJ
5180	449	3	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	449	4	use	use	VBP
5180	449	5	selection	selection	NN
5180	449	6	aids	aid	NNS
5180	449	7	,	,	,
5180	449	8	such	such	JJ
5180	449	9	as	as	IN
5180	449	10	review	review	NN
5180	449	11	journals	journal	NNS
5180	449	12	and	and	CC
5180	449	13	bibliographies	bibliography	NNS
5180	449	14	,	,	,
5180	449	15	as	as	IN
5180	449	16	a	a	DT
5180	449	17	guide	guide	NN
5180	449	18	to	to	IN
5180	449	19	the	the	DT
5180	449	20	quality	quality	NN
5180	449	21	of	of	IN
5180	449	22	potential	potential	JJ
5180	449	23	acquisitions	acquisition	NNS
5180	449	24	,	,	,
5180	449	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	449	26	do	do	VBP
5180	449	27	not	not	RB
5180	449	28	generally	generally	RB
5180	449	29	delegate	delegate	VB
5180	449	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	449	31	selection	selection	NN
5180	449	32	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	449	33	to	to	IN
5180	449	34	parties	party	NNS
5180	449	35	outside	outside	IN
5180	449	36	of	of	IN
5180	449	37	the	the	DT
5180	449	38	public	public	JJ
5180	449	39	library	library	NN
5180	449	40	or	or	CC
5180	449	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	449	42	governing	govern	VBG
5180	449	43	body	body	NN
5180	449	44	.	.	.
5180	450	1	One	one	CD
5180	450	2	limited	limited	JJ
5180	450	3	exception	exception	NN
5180	450	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	450	5	the	the	DT
5180	450	6	use	use	NN
5180	450	7	of	of	IN
5180	450	8	third-	third-	JJ
5180	450	9	party	party	NN
5180	450	10	vendors	vendor	NNS
5180	450	11	or	or	CC
5180	450	12	approval	approval	NN
5180	450	13	plans	plan	NNS
5180	450	14	to	to	TO
5180	450	15	acquire	acquire	VB
5180	450	16	print	print	NN
5180	450	17	and	and	CC
5180	450	18	video	video	NN
5180	450	19	resources	resource	NNS
5180	450	20	.	.	.
5180	451	1	In	in	IN
5180	451	2	such	such	JJ
5180	451	3	arrangements	arrangement	NNS
5180	451	4	,	,	,
5180	451	5	third	third	JJ
5180	451	6	-	-	HYPH
5180	451	7	party	party	NN
5180	451	8	vendors	vendor	NNS
5180	451	9	provide	provide	VBP
5180	451	10	materials	material	NNS
5180	451	11	based	base	VBN
5180	451	12	on	on	IN
5180	451	13	the	the	DT
5180	451	14	library	library	NN
5180	451	15	's	's	POS
5180	451	16	description	description	NN
5180	451	17	of	of	IN
5180	451	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	451	19	collection	collection	NN
5180	451	20	development	development	NN
5180	451	21	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	451	22	.	.	.
5180	452	1	The	the	DT
5180	452	2	vendor	vendor	NN
5180	452	3	sends	send	VBZ
5180	452	4	materials	material	NNS
5180	452	5	to	to	IN
5180	452	6	the	the	DT
5180	452	7	library	library	NN
5180	452	8	,	,	,
5180	452	9	and	and	CC
5180	452	10	the	the	DT
5180	452	11	library	library	NN
5180	452	12	retains	retain	VBZ
5180	452	13	the	the	DT
5180	452	14	materials	material	NNS
5180	452	15	that	that	WDT
5180	452	16	meet	meet	VBP
5180	452	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	452	18	collection	collection	NN
5180	452	19	development	development	NN
5180	452	20	needs	need	VBZ
5180	452	21	and	and	CC
5180	452	22	returns	return	VBZ
5180	452	23	the	the	DT
5180	452	24	materials	material	NNS
5180	452	25	that	that	WDT
5180	452	26	do	do	VBP
5180	452	27	not	not	RB
5180	452	28	.	.	.
5180	453	1	Even	even	RB
5180	453	2	in	in	IN
5180	453	3	this	this	DT
5180	453	4	arrangement	arrangement	NN
5180	453	5	,	,	,
5180	453	6	however	however	RB
5180	453	7	,	,	,
5180	453	8	the	the	DT
5180	453	9	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	453	10	still	still	RB
5180	453	11	retain	retain	VBP
5180	453	12	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
5180	453	13	control	control	NN
5180	453	14	over	over	IN
5180	453	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	453	16	collection	collection	NN
5180	453	17	development	development	NN
5180	453	18	and	and	CC
5180	453	19	review	review	VB
5180	453	20	all	all	DT
5180	453	21	of	of	IN
5180	453	22	the	the	DT
5180	453	23	materials	material	NNS
5180	453	24	that	that	WDT
5180	453	25	enter	enter	VBP
5180	453	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	453	27	library	library	NN
5180	453	28	's	's	POS
5180	453	29	collection	collection	NN
5180	453	30	.	.	.
5180	454	1	2	2	LS
5180	454	2	.	.	.
5180	455	1	The	the	DT
5180	455	2	Internet	internet	NN
5180	455	3	in	in	IN
5180	455	4	Public	public	JJ
5180	455	5	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	455	6	The	the	DT
5180	455	7	vast	vast	JJ
5180	455	8	majority	majority	NN
5180	455	9	of	of	IN
5180	455	10	public	public	JJ
5180	455	11	libraries	library	NNS
5180	455	12	offer	offer	VBP
5180	455	13	Internet	internet	NN
5180	455	14	access	access	NN
5180	455	15	to	to	IN
5180	455	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	455	17	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	455	18	.	.	.
5180	456	1	According	accord	VBG
5180	456	2	to	to	IN
5180	456	3	a	a	DT
5180	456	4	recent	recent	JJ
5180	456	5	report	report	NN
5180	456	6	by	by	IN
5180	456	7	the	the	DT
5180	456	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	456	9	National	National	NNP
5180	456	10	Commission	Commission	NNP
5180	456	11	on	on	IN
5180	456	12	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	456	13	and	and	CC
5180	456	14	Information	Information	NNP
5180	456	15	Science	Science	NNP
5180	456	16	,	,	,
5180	456	17	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	456	18	95	95	CD
5180	456	19	%	%	NN
5180	456	20	of	of	IN
5180	456	21	all	all	DT
5180	456	22	public	public	JJ
5180	456	23	libraries	library	NNS
5180	456	24	provide	provide	VBP
5180	456	25	public	public	JJ
5180	456	26	access	access	NN
5180	456	27	to	to	IN
5180	456	28	the	the	DT
5180	456	29	Internet	internet	NN
5180	456	30	.	.	.
5180	457	1	John	John	NNP
5180	457	2	C.	C.	NNP
5180	457	3	Bertot	Bertot	NNP
5180	457	4	&	&	CC
5180	457	5	Charles	Charles	NNP
5180	457	6	R.	R.	NNP
5180	457	7	McClure	McClure	NNP
5180	457	8	,	,	,
5180	457	9	Public	Public	NNP
5180	457	10	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	457	11	and	and	CC
5180	457	12	the	the	DT
5180	457	13	Internet	internet	NN
5180	457	14	2000	2000	CD
5180	457	15	:	:	:
5180	457	16	Summary	Summary	NNP
5180	457	17	Findings	Findings	NNPS
5180	457	18	and	and	CC
5180	457	19	Data	Data	NNPS
5180	457	20	Tables	Tables	NNPS
5180	457	21	,	,	,
5180	457	22	Report	Report	NNP
5180	457	23	to	to	IN
5180	457	24	National	National	NNP
5180	457	25	Commission	Commission	NNP
5180	457	26	on	on	IN
5180	457	27	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	457	28	and	and	CC
5180	457	29	Information	Information	NNP
5180	457	30	Science	Science	NNP
5180	457	31	,	,	,
5180	457	32	at	at	IN
5180	457	33	3	3	CD
5180	457	34	.	.	.
5180	458	1	The	the	DT
5180	458	2	Internet	internet	NN
5180	458	3	vastly	vastly	RB
5180	458	4	expands	expand	VBZ
5180	458	5	the	the	DT
5180	458	6	amount	amount	NN
5180	458	7	of	of	IN
5180	458	8	information	information	NN
5180	458	9	available	available	JJ
5180	458	10	to	to	IN
5180	458	11	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	458	12	of	of	IN
5180	458	13	public	public	JJ
5180	458	14	libraries	library	NNS
5180	458	15	.	.	.
5180	459	1	The	the	DT
5180	459	2	widespread	widespread	JJ
5180	459	3	availability	availability	NN
5180	459	4	of	of	IN
5180	459	5	Internet	internet	NN
5180	459	6	access	access	NN
5180	459	7	in	in	IN
5180	459	8	public	public	JJ
5180	459	9	libraries	library	NNS
5180	459	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	459	11	due	due	JJ
5180	459	12	,	,	,
5180	459	13	in	in	IN
5180	459	14	part	part	NN
5180	459	15	,	,	,
5180	459	16	to	to	IN
5180	459	17	the	the	DT
5180	459	18	availability	availability	NN
5180	459	19	of	of	IN
5180	459	20	public	public	JJ
5180	459	21	funding	funding	NN
5180	459	22	,	,	,
5180	459	23	including	include	VBG
5180	459	24	state	state	NN
5180	459	25	and	and	CC
5180	459	26	local	local	JJ
5180	459	27	funding	funding	NN
5180	459	28	and	and	CC
5180	459	29	the	the	DT
5180	459	30	federal	federal	JJ
5180	459	31	funding	funding	NN
5180	459	32	programs	program	NNS
5180	459	33	regulated	regulate	VBN
5180	459	34	by	by	IN
5180	459	35	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	459	36	.	.	.
5180	460	1	Many	many	JJ
5180	460	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	460	3	face	face	VBP
5180	460	4	a	a	DT
5180	460	5	large	large	JJ
5180	460	6	amount	amount	NN
5180	460	7	of	of	IN
5180	460	8	patron	patron	NN
5180	460	9	demand	demand	NN
5180	460	10	for	for	IN
5180	460	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	460	12	Internet	internet	NN
5180	460	13	services	service	NNS
5180	460	14	.	.	.
5180	461	1	At	at	IN
5180	461	2	some	some	DT
5180	461	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	461	4	,	,	,
5180	461	5	patron	patron	NN
5180	461	6	demand	demand	NN
5180	461	7	for	for	IN
5180	461	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	461	9	access	access	NN
5180	461	10	during	during	IN
5180	461	11	a	a	DT
5180	461	12	given	give	VBN
5180	461	13	day	day	NN
5180	461	14	exceeds	exceed	VBZ
5180	461	15	the	the	DT
5180	461	16	supply	supply	NN
5180	461	17	of	of	IN
5180	461	18	computer	computer	NN
5180	461	19	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	461	20	with	with	IN
5180	461	21	access	access	NN
5180	461	22	to	to	IN
5180	461	23	the	the	DT
5180	461	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	461	25	.	.	.
5180	462	1	These	these	DT
5180	462	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	462	3	use	use	VBP
5180	462	4	sign-	sign-	JJ
5180	462	5	in	in	IN
5180	462	6	and	and	CC
5180	462	7	time	time	NN
5180	462	8	limit	limit	NN
5180	462	9	procedures	procedure	NNS
5180	462	10	and/or	and/or	CC
5180	462	11	establish	establish	VB
5180	462	12	rules	rule	NNS
5180	462	13	regarding	regard	VBG
5180	462	14	the	the	DT
5180	462	15	allowable	allowable	JJ
5180	462	16	uses	use	NNS
5180	462	17	of	of	IN
5180	462	18	the	the	DT
5180	462	19	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	462	20	,	,	,
5180	462	21	in	in	IN
5180	462	22	an	an	DT
5180	462	23	effort	effort	NN
5180	462	24	to	to	TO
5180	462	25	ration	ration	VB
5180	462	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	462	27	computer	computer	NN
5180	462	28	resources	resource	NNS
5180	462	29	.	.	.
5180	463	1	For	for	IN
5180	463	2	example	example	NN
5180	463	3	,	,	,
5180	463	4	some	some	DT
5180	463	5	of	of	IN
5180	463	6	the	the	DT
5180	463	7	libraries	library	NNS
5180	463	8	whose	whose	WP$
5180	463	9	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	463	10	testified	testify	VBD
5180	463	11	at	at	IN
5180	463	12	trial	trial	NN
5180	463	13	prohibit	prohibit	NN
5180	463	14	the	the	DT
5180	463	15	use	use	NN
5180	463	16	of	of	IN
5180	463	17	email	email	NN
5180	463	18	and	and	CC
5180	463	19	chat	chat	VB
5180	463	20	functions	function	NNS
5180	463	21	on	on	IN
5180	463	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	463	23	public	public	JJ
5180	463	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	463	25	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	463	26	.	.	.
5180	464	1	Public	public	JJ
5180	464	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	464	3	play	play	VBP
5180	464	4	an	an	DT
5180	464	5	important	important	JJ
5180	464	6	role	role	NN
5180	464	7	in	in	IN
5180	464	8	providing	provide	VBG
5180	464	9	Internet	internet	NN
5180	464	10	access	access	NN
5180	464	11	to	to	IN
5180	464	12	citizens	citizen	NNS
5180	464	13	who	who	WP
5180	464	14	would	would	MD
5180	464	15	not	not	RB
5180	464	16	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	464	17	possess	possess	VB
5180	464	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	464	19	.	.	.
5180	465	1	Of	of	IN
5180	465	2	the	the	DT
5180	465	3	143	143	CD
5180	465	4	million	million	CD
5180	465	5	Americans	Americans	NNPS
5180	465	6	using	use	VBG
5180	465	7	the	the	DT
5180	465	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	465	9	,	,	,
5180	465	10	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	465	11	10	10	CD
5180	465	12	%	%	NN
5180	465	13	,	,	,
5180	465	14	or	or	CC
5180	465	15	14.3	14.3	CD
5180	465	16	million	million	CD
5180	465	17	people	people	NNS
5180	465	18	,	,	,
5180	465	19	access	access	VB
5180	465	20	the	the	DT
5180	465	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	465	22	at	at	IN
5180	465	23	a	a	DT
5180	465	24	public	public	JJ
5180	465	25	library	library	NN
5180	465	26	.	.	.
5180	466	1	Internet	internet	NN
5180	466	2	access	access	NN
5180	466	3	at	at	IN
5180	466	4	public	public	JJ
5180	466	5	libraries	library	NNS
5180	466	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	466	7	more	more	RBR
5180	466	8	often	often	RB
5180	466	9	used	use	VBN
5180	466	10	by	by	IN
5180	466	11	those	those	DT
5180	466	12	with	with	IN
5180	466	13	lower	low	JJR
5180	466	14	incomes	income	NNS
5180	466	15	than	than	IN
5180	466	16	those	those	DT
5180	466	17	with	with	IN
5180	466	18	higher	high	JJR
5180	466	19	incomes	income	NNS
5180	466	20	.	.	.
5180	467	1	About	about	IN
5180	467	2	20.3	20.3	CD
5180	467	3	%	%	NN
5180	467	4	of	of	IN
5180	467	5	Internet	internet	NN
5180	467	6	users	user	NNS
5180	467	7	with	with	IN
5180	467	8	household	household	NN
5180	467	9	family	family	NN
5180	467	10	income	income	NN
5180	467	11	of	of	IN
5180	467	12	less	less	JJR
5180	467	13	than	than	IN
5180	467	14	$	$	$
5180	467	15	15,000	15,000	CD
5180	467	16	per	per	IN
5180	467	17	year	year	NN
5180	467	18	use	use	VBP
5180	467	19	public	public	JJ
5180	467	20	libraries	library	NNS
5180	467	21	for	for	IN
5180	467	22	Internet	internet	NN
5180	467	23	access	access	NN
5180	467	24	.	.	.
5180	468	1	Approximately	approximately	RB
5180	468	2	70	70	CD
5180	468	3	%	%	NN
5180	468	4	of	of	IN
5180	468	5	libraries	library	NNS
5180	468	6	serving	serve	VBG
5180	468	7	communities	community	NNS
5180	468	8	with	with	IN
5180	468	9	poverty	poverty	NN
5180	468	10	levels	level	NNS
5180	468	11	in	in	IN
5180	468	12	excess	excess	NN
5180	468	13	of	of	IN
5180	468	14	40	40	CD
5180	468	15	%	%	NN
5180	468	16	receive	receive	JJ
5180	468	17	E	e	NN
5180	468	18	-	-	NN
5180	468	19	rate	rate	NN
5180	468	20	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	468	21	.	.	.
5180	469	1	1	1	LS
5180	469	2	.	.	.
5180	470	1	Internet	internet	NN
5180	470	2	Use	Use	NNP
5180	470	3	Policies	policy	NNS
5180	470	4	in	in	IN
5180	470	5	Public	Public	NNP
5180	470	6	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	470	7	Approximately	approximately	RB
5180	470	8	95	95	CD
5180	470	9	%	%	NN
5180	470	10	of	of	IN
5180	470	11	libraries	library	NNS
5180	470	12	with	with	IN
5180	470	13	public	public	JJ
5180	470	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	470	15	access	access	NN
5180	470	16	have	have	VBP
5180	470	17	some	some	DT
5180	470	18	form	form	NN
5180	470	19	of	of	IN
5180	470	20	"	"	``
5180	470	21	acceptable	acceptable	JJ
5180	470	22	use	use	NN
5180	470	23	"	"	''
5180	470	24	policy	policy	NN
5180	470	25	or	or	CC
5180	470	26	"	"	``
5180	470	27	Internet	internet	NN
5180	470	28	use	use	NN
5180	470	29	"	"	''
5180	470	30	policy	policy	NN
5180	470	31	governing	governing	NN
5180	470	32	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	470	33	'	'	POS
5180	470	34	use	use	NN
5180	470	35	of	of	IN
5180	470	36	the	the	DT
5180	470	37	Internet	internet	NN
5180	470	38	.	.	.
5180	471	1	These	these	DT
5180	471	2	policies	policy	NNS
5180	471	3	set	set	VBD
5180	471	4	forth	forth	RP
5180	471	5	the	the	DT
5180	471	6	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	471	7	under	under	IN
5180	471	8	which	which	WDT
5180	471	9	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	471	10	are	be	VBP
5180	471	11	permitted	permit	VBN
5180	471	12	to	to	TO
5180	471	13	access	access	NN
5180	471	14	and	and	CC
5180	471	15	use	use	VB
5180	471	16	the	the	DT
5180	471	17	library	library	NN
5180	471	18	's	's	POS
5180	471	19	Internet	internet	NN
5180	471	20	resources	resource	NNS
5180	471	21	.	.	.
5180	472	1	These	these	DT
5180	472	2	policies	policy	NNS
5180	472	3	vary	vary	VBP
5180	472	4	widely	widely	RB
5180	472	5	.	.	.
5180	473	1	Some	some	DT
5180	473	2	of	of	IN
5180	473	3	the	the	DT
5180	473	4	less	less	RBR
5180	473	5	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	473	6	policies	policy	NNS
5180	473	7	,	,	,
5180	473	8	like	like	IN
5180	473	9	those	those	DT
5180	473	10	held	hold	VBN
5180	473	11	by	by	IN
5180	473	12	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
5180	473	13	County	County	NNP
5180	473	14	Library	Library	NNP
5180	473	15	and	and	CC
5180	473	16	Fort	Fort	NNP
5180	473	17	Vancouver	Vancouver	NNP
5180	473	18	Regional	Regional	NNP
5180	473	19	Library	Library	NNP
5180	473	20	,	,	,
5180	473	21	do	do	VB
5180	473	22	not	not	RB
5180	473	23	prohibit	prohibit	VB
5180	473	24	adult	adult	NN
5180	473	25	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	473	26	from	from	IN
5180	473	27	viewing	view	VBG
5180	473	28	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	473	29	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	473	30	materials	material	NNS
5180	473	31	on	on	IN
5180	473	32	the	the	DT
5180	473	33	Web	web	NN
5180	473	34	,	,	,
5180	473	35	as	as	RB
5180	473	36	long	long	RB
5180	473	37	as	as	IN
5180	473	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	473	39	do	do	VBP
5180	473	40	so	so	RB
5180	473	41	at	at	IN
5180	473	42	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	473	43	with	with	IN
5180	473	44	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	473	45	screens	screen	NNS
5180	473	46	or	or	CC
5180	473	47	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	473	48	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	473	49	,	,	,
5180	473	50	which	which	WDT
5180	473	51	are	be	VBP
5180	473	52	designed	design	VBN
5180	473	53	to	to	TO
5180	473	54	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	473	55	other	other	JJ
5180	473	56	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	473	57	from	from	IN
5180	473	58	seeing	see	VBG
5180	473	59	the	the	DT
5180	473	60	material	material	NN
5180	473	61	that	that	IN
5180	473	62	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	473	63	are	be	VBP
5180	473	64	viewing	view	VBG
5180	473	65	,	,	,
5180	473	66	and	and	CC
5180	473	67	as	as	RB
5180	473	68	long	long	RB
5180	473	69	as	as	IN
5180	473	70	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	473	71	does	do	VBZ
5180	473	72	not	not	RB
5180	473	73	violate	violate	VB
5180	473	74	state	state	NN
5180	473	75	or	or	CC
5180	473	76	federal	federal	JJ
5180	473	77	law	law	NN
5180	473	78	to	to	TO
5180	473	79	do	do	VB
5180	473	80	so	so	RB
5180	473	81	.	.	.
5180	474	1	Other	other	JJ
5180	474	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	474	3	prohibit	prohibit	VBP
5180	474	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	474	5	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	474	6	from	from	IN
5180	474	7	viewing	view	VBG
5180	474	8	all	all	DT
5180	474	9	"	"	``
5180	474	10	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	474	11	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	474	12	"	"	''
5180	474	13	or	or	CC
5180	474	14	"	"	``
5180	474	15	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	474	16	graphic	graphic	JJ
5180	474	17	"	"	''
5180	474	18	materials	material	NNS
5180	474	19	.	.	.
5180	475	1	Some	some	DT
5180	475	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	475	3	prohibit	prohibit	VBP
5180	475	4	the	the	DT
5180	475	5	viewing	viewing	NN
5180	475	6	of	of	IN
5180	475	7	materials	material	NNS
5180	475	8	that	that	WDT
5180	475	9	are	be	VBP
5180	475	10	not	not	RB
5180	475	11	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	475	12	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	475	13	,	,	,
5180	475	14	such	such	JJ
5180	475	15	as	as	IN
5180	475	16	Web	web	NN
5180	475	17	pages	page	NNS
5180	475	18	that	that	WDT
5180	475	19	are	be	VBP
5180	475	20	"	"	``
5180	475	21	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	475	22	to	to	IN
5180	475	23	minors	minor	NNS
5180	475	24	,	,	,
5180	475	25	"	"	''
5180	475	26	"	"	``
5180	475	27	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	475	28	to	to	IN
5180	475	29	the	the	DT
5180	475	30	public	public	NN
5180	475	31	,	,	,
5180	475	32	"	"	''
5180	475	33	"	"	``
5180	475	34	objectionable	objectionable	JJ
5180	475	35	,	,	,
5180	475	36	"	"	''
5180	475	37	"	"	``
5180	475	38	racially	racially	RB
5180	475	39	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	475	40	,	,	,
5180	475	41	"	"	''
5180	475	42	or	or	CC
5180	475	43	simply	simply	RB
5180	475	44	"	"	``
5180	475	45	inappropriate	inappropriate	JJ
5180	475	46	.	.	.
5180	475	47	"	"	''
5180	476	1	Other	other	JJ
5180	476	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	476	3	restrict	restrict	VBP
5180	476	4	access	access	NN
5180	476	5	to	to	IN
5180	476	6	Web	web	NN
5180	476	7	sites	site	NNS
5180	476	8	that	that	IN
5180	476	9	the	the	DT
5180	476	10	library	library	NN
5180	476	11	just	just	RB
5180	476	12	does	do	VBZ
5180	476	13	not	not	RB
5180	476	14	want	want	VB
5180	476	15	to	to	TO
5180	476	16	provide	provide	VB
5180	476	17	,	,	,
5180	476	18	even	even	RB
5180	476	19	though	though	IN
5180	476	20	the	the	DT
5180	476	21	sites	site	NNS
5180	476	22	are	be	VBP
5180	476	23	not	not	RB
5180	476	24	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	476	25	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	476	26	.	.	.
5180	477	1	For	for	IN
5180	477	2	example	example	NN
5180	477	3	,	,	,
5180	477	4	the	the	DT
5180	477	5	Fulton	Fulton	NNP
5180	477	6	County	County	NNP
5180	477	7	Public	Public	NNP
5180	477	8	Library	Library	NNP
5180	477	9	restricts	restrict	NNS
5180	477	10	access	access	NN
5180	477	11	to	to	IN
5180	477	12	the	the	DT
5180	477	13	Web	web	NN
5180	477	14	sites	site	NNS
5180	477	15	of	of	IN
5180	477	16	dating	date	VBG
5180	477	17	services	service	NNS
5180	477	18	.	.	.
5180	478	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	478	2	,	,	,
5180	478	3	the	the	DT
5180	478	4	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	478	5	Public	Public	NNP
5180	478	6	Library	Library	NNP
5180	478	7	's	's	POS
5180	478	8	policy	policy	NN
5180	478	9	does	do	VBZ
5180	478	10	not	not	RB
5180	478	11	allow	allow	VB
5180	478	12	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	478	13	to	to	TO
5180	478	14	use	use	VB
5180	478	15	the	the	DT
5180	478	16	library	library	NN
5180	478	17	's	's	POS
5180	478	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	478	19	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	478	20	for	for	IN
5180	478	21	personal	personal	JJ
5180	478	22	email	email	NN
5180	478	23	,	,	,
5180	478	24	for	for	IN
5180	478	25	online	online	JJ
5180	478	26	chat	chat	NN
5180	478	27	,	,	,
5180	478	28	or	or	CC
5180	478	29	for	for	IN
5180	478	30	playing	play	VBG
5180	478	31	games	game	NNS
5180	478	32	.	.	.
5180	479	1	In	in	IN
5180	479	2	some	some	DT
5180	479	3	cases	case	NNS
5180	479	4	,	,	,
5180	479	5	libraries	library	NNS
5180	479	6	instituted	institute	VBN
5180	479	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	479	8	use	use	NN
5180	479	9	policies	policy	NNS
5180	479	10	after	after	IN
5180	479	11	having	have	VBG
5180	479	12	experienced	experience	VBN
5180	479	13	specific	specific	JJ
5180	479	14	problems	problem	NNS
5180	479	15	,	,	,
5180	479	16	whereas	whereas	IN
5180	479	17	in	in	IN
5180	479	18	other	other	JJ
5180	479	19	cases	case	NNS
5180	479	20	,	,	,
5180	479	21	libraries	library	NNS
5180	479	22	developed	develop	VBD
5180	479	23	detailed	detailed	JJ
5180	479	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	479	25	use	use	NN
5180	479	26	policies	policy	NNS
5180	479	27	and	and	CC
5180	479	28	regulatory	regulatory	JJ
5180	479	29	measures	measure	NNS
5180	479	30	(	(	-LRB-
5180	479	31	such	such	JJ
5180	479	32	as	as	IN
5180	479	33	using	use	VBG
5180	479	34	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	479	35	software	software	NN
5180	479	36	)	)	-RRB-
5180	479	37	before	before	IN
5180	479	38	ever	ever	RB
5180	479	39	offering	offer	VBG
5180	479	40	public	public	JJ
5180	479	41	Internet	internet	NN
5180	479	42	access	access	NN
5180	479	43	.	.	.
5180	480	1	Essentially	essentially	RB
5180	480	2	four	four	CD
5180	480	3	interests	interest	NNS
5180	480	4	motivate	motivate	VBP
5180	480	5	libraries	library	NNS
5180	480	6	to	to	TO
5180	480	7	institute	institute	VB
5180	480	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	480	9	use	use	NN
5180	480	10	policies	policy	NNS
5180	480	11	and	and	CC
5180	480	12	to	to	TO
5180	480	13	apply	apply	VB
5180	480	14	the	the	DT
5180	480	15	methods	method	NNS
5180	480	16	described	describe	VBN
5180	480	17	above	above	RB
5180	480	18	to	to	TO
5180	480	19	regulate	regulate	VB
5180	480	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	480	21	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	480	22	'	'	POS
5180	480	23	use	use	NN
5180	480	24	of	of	IN
5180	480	25	the	the	DT
5180	480	26	Internet	internet	NN
5180	480	27	.	.	.
5180	481	1	First	first	RB
5180	481	2	,	,	,
5180	481	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	481	4	have	have	VBP
5180	481	5	sought	seek	VBN
5180	481	6	to	to	TO
5180	481	7	protect	protect	VB
5180	481	8	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	481	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	481	10	especially	especially	RB
5180	481	11	children	child	NNS
5180	481	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	481	13	and	and	CC
5180	481	14	staff	staff	NN
5180	481	15	members	member	NNS
5180	481	16	from	from	IN
5180	481	17	accidentally	accidentally	RB
5180	481	18	viewing	view	VBG
5180	481	19	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	481	20	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	481	21	images	image	NNS
5180	481	22	,	,	,
5180	481	23	or	or	CC
5180	481	24	other	other	JJ
5180	481	25	Web	web	NN
5180	481	26	pages	page	NNS
5180	481	27	containing	contain	VBG
5180	481	28	content	content	NN
5180	481	29	deemed	deem	VBN
5180	481	30	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	481	31	,	,	,
5180	481	32	that	that	IN
5180	481	33	other	other	JJ
5180	481	34	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	481	35	are	be	VBP
5180	481	36	viewing	view	VBG
5180	481	37	on	on	IN
5180	481	38	the	the	DT
5180	481	39	Internet	internet	NN
5180	481	40	.	.	.
5180	482	1	For	for	IN
5180	482	2	example	example	NN
5180	482	3	,	,	,
5180	482	4	some	some	DT
5180	482	5	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	482	6	who	who	WP
5180	482	7	testified	testify	VBD
5180	482	8	described	describe	VBN
5180	482	9	situations	situation	NNS
5180	482	10	in	in	IN
5180	482	11	which	which	WDT
5180	482	12	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	482	13	left	leave	VBD
5180	482	14	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	482	15	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	482	16	images	image	NNS
5180	482	17	minimized	minimize	VBN
5180	482	18	on	on	IN
5180	482	19	an	an	DT
5180	482	20	Internet	internet	NN
5180	482	21	terminal	terminal	NN
5180	482	22	so	so	IN
5180	482	23	that	that	IN
5180	482	24	the	the	DT
5180	482	25	next	next	JJ
5180	482	26	patron	patron	NN
5180	482	27	would	would	MD
5180	482	28	see	see	VB
5180	482	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	482	30	when	when	WRB
5180	482	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	482	32	began	begin	VBD
5180	482	33	using	use	VBG
5180	482	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	482	35	,	,	,
5180	482	36	or	or	CC
5180	482	37	in	in	IN
5180	482	38	which	which	WDT
5180	482	39	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	482	40	printed	print	VBN
5180	482	41	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	482	42	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	482	43	images	image	NNS
5180	482	44	from	from	IN
5180	482	45	a	a	DT
5180	482	46	Web	web	NN
5180	482	47	site	site	NN
5180	482	48	and	and	CC
5180	482	49	left	leave	VBD
5180	482	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	482	51	at	at	IN
5180	482	52	a	a	DT
5180	482	53	public	public	JJ
5180	482	54	printer	printer	NN
5180	482	55	.	.	.
5180	483	1	Second	second	RB
5180	483	2	,	,	,
5180	483	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	483	4	have	have	VBP
5180	483	5	attempted	attempt	VBN
5180	483	6	to	to	TO
5180	483	7	protect	protect	VB
5180	483	8	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	483	9	from	from	IN
5180	483	10	unwittingly	unwittingly	RB
5180	483	11	or	or	CC
5180	483	12	accidentally	accidentally	RB
5180	483	13	accessing	access	VBG
5180	483	14	Web	web	NN
5180	483	15	pages	page	NNS
5180	483	16	that	that	IN
5180	483	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	483	18	do	do	VBP
5180	483	19	not	not	RB
5180	483	20	wish	wish	VB
5180	483	21	to	to	TO
5180	483	22	see	see	VB
5180	483	23	while	while	IN
5180	483	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	483	25	are	be	VBP
5180	483	26	using	use	VBG
5180	483	27	the	the	DT
5180	483	28	Internet	internet	NN
5180	483	29	.	.	.
5180	484	1	For	for	IN
5180	484	2	example	example	NN
5180	484	3	,	,	,
5180	484	4	the	the	DT
5180	484	5	Memphis	Memphis	NNP
5180	484	6	-	-	HYPH
5180	484	7	Shelby	Shelby	NNP
5180	484	8	County	County	NNP
5180	484	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	484	10	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
5180	484	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	484	12	Public	Public	NNP
5180	484	13	Library	Library	NNP
5180	484	14	's	's	POS
5180	484	15	Internet	internet	NN
5180	484	16	use	use	NN
5180	484	17	policy	policy	NN
5180	484	18	states	state	NNS
5180	484	19	that	that	IN
5180	484	20	the	the	DT
5180	484	21	library	library	NN
5180	484	22	"	"	``
5180	484	23	employs	employ	VBZ
5180	484	24	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	484	25	technology	technology	NN
5180	484	26	to	to	TO
5180	484	27	reduce	reduce	VB
5180	484	28	the	the	DT
5180	484	29	possibility	possibility	NN
5180	484	30	that	that	IN
5180	484	31	customers	customer	NNS
5180	484	32	may	may	MD
5180	484	33	encounter	encounter	VB
5180	484	34	objectionable	objectionable	JJ
5180	484	35	content	content	NN
5180	484	36	in	in	IN
5180	484	37	the	the	DT
5180	484	38	form	form	NN
5180	484	39	of	of	IN
5180	484	40	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	484	41	of	of	IN
5180	484	42	full	full	JJ
5180	484	43	nudity	nudity	NN
5180	484	44	and	and	CC
5180	484	45	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	484	46	acts	act	NNS
5180	484	47	.	.	.
5180	484	48	"	"	''
5180	485	1	Third	third	JJ
5180	485	2	,	,	,
5180	485	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	485	4	have	have	VBP
5180	485	5	sought	seek	VBN
5180	485	6	to	to	TO
5180	485	7	keep	keep	VB
5180	485	8	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	485	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	485	10	again	again	RB
5180	485	11	,	,	,
5180	485	12	especially	especially	RB
5180	485	13	children	child	NNS
5180	485	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	485	15	from	from	IN
5180	485	16	intentionally	intentionally	RB
5180	485	17	accessing	access	VBG
5180	485	18	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	485	19	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	485	20	materials	material	NNS
5180	485	21	or	or	CC
5180	485	22	other	other	JJ
5180	485	23	materials	material	NNS
5180	485	24	that	that	WDT
5180	485	25	the	the	DT
5180	485	26	library	library	NN
5180	485	27	deems	deem	NNS
5180	485	28	inappropriate	inappropriate	JJ
5180	485	29	.	.	.
5180	486	1	For	for	IN
5180	486	2	example	example	NN
5180	486	3	,	,	,
5180	486	4	a	a	DT
5180	486	5	study	study	NN
5180	486	6	of	of	IN
5180	486	7	the	the	DT
5180	486	8	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	486	9	Public	Public	NNP
5180	486	10	Library	Library	NNP
5180	486	11	's	's	POS
5180	486	12	Internet	internet	NN
5180	486	13	use	use	NN
5180	486	14	logs	log	NNS
5180	486	15	for	for	IN
5180	486	16	the	the	DT
5180	486	17	year	year	NN
5180	486	18	2000	2000	CD
5180	486	19	showed	show	VBD
5180	486	20	that	that	IN
5180	486	21	users	user	NNS
5180	486	22	between	between	IN
5180	486	23	the	the	DT
5180	486	24	ages	age	NNS
5180	486	25	of	of	IN
5180	486	26	11	11	CD
5180	486	27	and	and	CC
5180	486	28	15	15	CD
5180	486	29	accounted	account	VBD
5180	486	30	for	for	IN
5180	486	31	41	41	CD
5180	486	32	%	%	NN
5180	486	33	of	of	IN
5180	486	34	the	the	DT
5180	486	35	filter	filter	NN
5180	486	36	blocks	block	NNS
5180	486	37	that	that	WDT
5180	486	38	occurred	occur	VBD
5180	486	39	on	on	IN
5180	486	40	library	library	JJ
5180	486	41	computers	computer	NNS
5180	486	42	.	.	.
5180	487	1	The	the	DT
5180	487	2	study	study	NN
5180	487	3	,	,	,
5180	487	4	which	which	WDT
5180	487	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	487	6	credit	credit	NN
5180	487	7	,	,	,
5180	487	8	concluded	conclude	VBD
5180	487	9	that	that	IN
5180	487	10	children	child	NNS
5180	487	11	and	and	CC
5180	487	12	young	young	JJ
5180	487	13	teens	teen	NNS
5180	487	14	were	be	VBD
5180	487	15	actively	actively	RB
5180	487	16	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	487	17	to	to	TO
5180	487	18	access	access	VB
5180	487	19	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	487	20	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	487	21	images	image	NNS
5180	487	22	in	in	IN
5180	487	23	the	the	DT
5180	487	24	library	library	NN
5180	487	25	.	.	.
5180	488	1	The	the	DT
5180	488	2	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	488	3	Library	Library	NNP
5180	488	4	's	's	POS
5180	488	5	Board	Board	NNP
5180	488	6	of	of	IN
5180	488	7	Directors	Directors	NNPS
5180	488	8	was	be	VBD
5180	488	9	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	488	10	concerned	concern	VBN
5180	488	11	that	that	IN
5180	488	12	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	488	13	were	be	VBD
5180	488	14	accessing	access	VBG
5180	488	15	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	488	16	materials	material	NNS
5180	488	17	in	in	IN
5180	488	18	the	the	DT
5180	488	19	public	public	JJ
5180	488	20	library	library	NN
5180	488	21	in	in	IN
5180	488	22	violation	violation	NN
5180	488	23	of	of	IN
5180	488	24	South	South	NNP
5180	488	25	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
5180	488	26	's	's	POS
5180	488	27	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	488	28	statute	statute	NN
5180	488	29	.	.	.
5180	489	1	Finally	finally	RB
5180	489	2	,	,	,
5180	489	3	some	some	DT
5180	489	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	489	5	have	have	VBP
5180	489	6	regulated	regulate	VBN
5180	489	7	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	489	8	'	'	POS
5180	489	9	Internet	internet	NN
5180	489	10	use	use	NN
5180	489	11	to	to	TO
5180	489	12	attempt	attempt	VB
5180	489	13	to	to	TO
5180	489	14	control	control	VB
5180	489	15	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	489	16	'	'	POS
5180	489	17	inappropriate	inappropriate	JJ
5180	489	18	(	(	-LRB-
5180	489	19	or	or	CC
5180	489	20	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	489	21	)	)	-RRB-
5180	489	22	behavior	behavior	NN
5180	489	23	that	that	WDT
5180	489	24	is	be	VBZ
5180	489	25	thought	think	VBN
5180	489	26	to	to	TO
5180	489	27	stem	stem	VB
5180	489	28	from	from	IN
5180	489	29	viewing	view	VBG
5180	489	30	Web	web	NN
5180	489	31	pages	page	NNS
5180	489	32	that	that	WDT
5180	489	33	contain	contain	VBP
5180	489	34	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	489	35	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	489	36	materials	material	NNS
5180	489	37	or	or	CC
5180	489	38	content	content	NN
5180	489	39	that	that	WDT
5180	489	40	is	be	VBZ
5180	489	41	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	489	42	deemed	deem	VBN
5180	489	43	unacceptable	unacceptable	JJ
5180	489	44	.	.	.
5180	490	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	490	2	recognize	recognize	VBP
5180	490	3	the	the	DT
5180	490	4	concerns	concern	NNS
5180	490	5	that	that	WDT
5180	490	6	led	lead	VBD
5180	490	7	several	several	JJ
5180	490	8	of	of	IN
5180	490	9	the	the	DT
5180	490	10	public	public	JJ
5180	490	11	libraries	library	NNS
5180	490	12	whose	whose	WP$
5180	490	13	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	490	14	and	and	CC
5180	490	15	board	board	NN
5180	490	16	members	member	NNS
5180	490	17	testified	testify	VBD
5180	490	18	in	in	IN
5180	490	19	this	this	DT
5180	490	20	case	case	NN
5180	490	21	to	to	TO
5180	490	22	start	start	VB
5180	490	23	using	use	VBG
5180	490	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	490	25	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	490	26	software	software	NN
5180	490	27	.	.	.
5180	491	1	The	the	DT
5180	491	2	testimony	testimony	NN
5180	491	3	of	of	IN
5180	491	4	the	the	DT
5180	491	5	Chairman	Chairman	NNP
5180	491	6	of	of	IN
5180	491	7	the	the	DT
5180	491	8	Board	Board	NNP
5180	491	9	of	of	IN
5180	491	10	the	the	DT
5180	491	11	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	491	12	Public	Public	NNP
5180	491	13	Library	Library	NNP
5180	491	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	491	15	illustrative	illustrative	JJ
5180	491	16	.	.	.
5180	492	1	In	in	IN
5180	492	2	December	December	NNP
5180	492	3	1999	1999	CD
5180	492	4	,	,	,
5180	492	5	there	there	EX
5180	492	6	was	be	VBD
5180	492	7	considerable	considerable	JJ
5180	492	8	local	local	JJ
5180	492	9	press	press	NN
5180	492	10	coverage	coverage	NN
5180	492	11	in	in	IN
5180	492	12	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	492	13	concerning	concern	VBG
5180	492	14	adult	adult	NN
5180	492	15	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	492	16	who	who	WP
5180	492	17	routinely	routinely	RB
5180	492	18	used	use	VBD
5180	492	19	the	the	DT
5180	492	20	library	library	NN
5180	492	21	to	to	TO
5180	492	22	surf	surf	VB
5180	492	23	the	the	DT
5180	492	24	Web	web	NN
5180	492	25	for	for	IN
5180	492	26	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	492	27	.	.	.
5180	493	1	In	in	IN
5180	493	2	response	response	NN
5180	493	3	to	to	IN
5180	493	4	public	public	JJ
5180	493	5	outcry	outcry	NN
5180	493	6	stemming	stem	VBG
5180	493	7	from	from	IN
5180	493	8	the	the	DT
5180	493	9	newspaper	newspaper	NN
5180	493	10	report	report	NN
5180	493	11	,	,	,
5180	493	12	the	the	DT
5180	493	13	Board	Board	NNP
5180	493	14	of	of	IN
5180	493	15	Trustees	Trustees	NNPS
5180	493	16	held	hold	VBD
5180	493	17	a	a	DT
5180	493	18	special	special	JJ
5180	493	19	board	board	NN
5180	493	20	meeting	meeting	NN
5180	493	21	to	to	TO
5180	493	22	obtain	obtain	VB
5180	493	23	information	information	NN
5180	493	24	and	and	CC
5180	493	25	to	to	TO
5180	493	26	communicate	communicate	VB
5180	493	27	with	with	IN
5180	493	28	the	the	DT
5180	493	29	public	public	NN
5180	493	30	concerning	concern	VBG
5180	493	31	the	the	DT
5180	493	32	library	library	NN
5180	493	33	's	's	POS
5180	493	34	provision	provision	NN
5180	493	35	of	of	IN
5180	493	36	Internet	internet	NN
5180	493	37	access	access	NN
5180	493	38	.	.	.
5180	494	1	At	at	IN
5180	494	2	this	this	DT
5180	494	3	meeting	meeting	NN
5180	494	4	,	,	,
5180	494	5	the	the	DT
5180	494	6	Board	Board	NNP
5180	494	7	learned	learn	VBD
5180	494	8	for	for	IN
5180	494	9	the	the	DT
5180	494	10	first	first	JJ
5180	494	11	time	time	NN
5180	494	12	of	of	IN
5180	494	13	complaints	complaint	NNS
5180	494	14	about	about	IN
5180	494	15	children	child	NNS
5180	494	16	being	be	VBG
5180	494	17	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	494	18	to	to	IN
5180	494	19	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	494	20	that	that	WDT
5180	494	21	was	be	VBD
5180	494	22	displayed	display	VBN
5180	494	23	on	on	IN
5180	494	24	the	the	DT
5180	494	25	library	library	NN
5180	494	26	's	's	POS
5180	494	27	Internet	internet	NN
5180	494	28	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	494	29	.	.	.
5180	495	1	In	in	IN
5180	495	2	late	late	JJ
5180	495	3	January	January	NNP
5180	495	4	to	to	IN
5180	495	5	early	early	JJ
5180	495	6	February	February	NNP
5180	495	7	of	of	IN
5180	495	8	2000	2000	CD
5180	495	9	,	,	,
5180	495	10	the	the	DT
5180	495	11	library	library	NN
5180	495	12	installed	instal	VBD
5180	495	13	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	495	14	screens	screen	NNS
5180	495	15	and	and	CC
5180	495	16	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	495	17	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	495	18	in	in	IN
5180	495	19	an	an	DT
5180	495	20	effort	effort	NN
5180	495	21	to	to	TO
5180	495	22	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	495	23	the	the	DT
5180	495	24	display	display	NN
5180	495	25	of	of	IN
5180	495	26	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	495	27	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	495	28	Web	web	NN
5180	495	29	sites	site	NNS
5180	495	30	at	at	IN
5180	495	31	the	the	DT
5180	495	32	library	library	NN
5180	495	33	.	.	.
5180	496	1	In	in	IN
5180	496	2	February	February	NNP
5180	496	3	,	,	,
5180	496	4	2000	2000	CD
5180	496	5	,	,	,
5180	496	6	the	the	DT
5180	496	7	Board	Board	NNP
5180	496	8	informed	inform	VBD
5180	496	9	the	the	DT
5180	496	10	library	library	NN
5180	496	11	staff	staff	NN
5180	496	12	that	that	IN
5180	496	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	496	14	were	be	VBD
5180	496	15	expected	expect	VBN
5180	496	16	to	to	TO
5180	496	17	be	be	VB
5180	496	18	familiar	familiar	JJ
5180	496	19	with	with	IN
5180	496	20	the	the	DT
5180	496	21	South	South	NNP
5180	496	22	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
5180	496	23	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	496	24	statute	statute	NN
5180	496	25	and	and	CC
5180	496	26	to	to	TO
5180	496	27	enforce	enforce	VB
5180	496	28	the	the	DT
5180	496	29	policy	policy	NN
5180	496	30	prohibition	prohibition	NN
5180	496	31	on	on	IN
5180	496	32	access	access	NN
5180	496	33	to	to	IN
5180	496	34	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	496	35	materials	material	NNS
5180	496	36	,	,	,
5180	496	37	child	child	NN
5180	496	38	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	496	39	,	,	,
5180	496	40	or	or	CC
5180	496	41	other	other	JJ
5180	496	42	materials	material	NNS
5180	496	43	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
5180	496	44	under	under	IN
5180	496	45	applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	496	46	local	local	JJ
5180	496	47	,	,	,
5180	496	48	state	state	NN
5180	496	49	,	,	,
5180	496	50	and	and	CC
5180	496	51	federal	federal	JJ
5180	496	52	laws	law	NNS
5180	496	53	.	.	.
5180	497	1	Staff	staff	NN
5180	497	2	were	be	VBD
5180	497	3	told	tell	VBN
5180	497	4	that	that	IN
5180	497	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	497	6	were	be	VBD
5180	497	7	to	to	TO
5180	497	8	enforce	enforce	VB
5180	497	9	the	the	DT
5180	497	10	policy	policy	NN
5180	497	11	by	by	IN
5180	497	12	means	mean	NNS
5180	497	13	of	of	IN
5180	497	14	a	a	DT
5180	497	15	"	"	``
5180	497	16	tap	tap	NN
5180	497	17	on	on	IN
5180	497	18	the	the	DT
5180	497	19	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	497	20	.	.	.
5180	497	21	"	"	''
5180	498	1	Prior	prior	RB
5180	498	2	to	to	IN
5180	498	3	adopting	adopt	VBG
5180	498	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	498	5	current	current	JJ
5180	498	6	Internet	internet	NN
5180	498	7	Use	Use	NNP
5180	498	8	Policy	Policy	NNP
5180	498	9	,	,	,
5180	498	10	the	the	DT
5180	498	11	Board	board	NN
5180	498	12	adopted	adopt	VBD
5180	498	13	an	an	DT
5180	498	14	"	"	``
5180	498	15	Addendum	Addendum	NNP
5180	498	16	to	to	IN
5180	498	17	Current	current	JJ
5180	498	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	498	19	Use	Use	NNP
5180	498	20	Policy	Policy	NNP
5180	498	21	.	.	.
5180	498	22	"	"	''
5180	499	1	Under	under	IN
5180	499	2	the	the	DT
5180	499	3	policy	policy	NN
5180	499	4	,	,	,
5180	499	5	the	the	DT
5180	499	6	Board	Board	NNP
5180	499	7	temporarily	temporarily	RB
5180	499	8	instituted	institute	VBD
5180	499	9	a	a	DT
5180	499	10	two	two	CD
5180	499	11	-	-	HYPH
5180	499	12	hour	hour	NN
5180	499	13	time	time	NN
5180	499	14	limit	limit	NN
5180	499	15	per	per	IN
5180	499	16	day	day	NN
5180	499	17	for	for	IN
5180	499	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	499	19	use	use	NN
5180	499	20	;	;	,
5180	499	21	reduced	reduce	VBN
5180	499	22	substantially	substantially	RB
5180	499	23	the	the	DT
5180	499	24	number	number	NN
5180	499	25	of	of	IN
5180	499	26	computers	computer	NNS
5180	499	27	with	with	IN
5180	499	28	Internet	internet	NN
5180	499	29	access	access	NN
5180	499	30	in	in	IN
5180	499	31	the	the	DT
5180	499	32	library	library	NN
5180	499	33	;	;	,
5180	499	34	reconfigured	reconfigure	VBD
5180	499	35	the	the	DT
5180	499	36	location	location	NN
5180	499	37	of	of	IN
5180	499	38	the	the	DT
5180	499	39	computers	computer	NNS
5180	499	40	so	so	IN
5180	499	41	that	that	IN
5180	499	42	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	499	43	had	have	VBD
5180	499	44	visual	visual	JJ
5180	499	45	contact	contact	NN
5180	499	46	with	with	IN
5180	499	47	all	all	DT
5180	499	48	Internet	internet	NN
5180	499	49	-	-	HYPH
5180	499	50	accessible	accessible	JJ
5180	499	51	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	499	52	;	;	:
5180	499	53	and	and	CC
5180	499	54	removed	remove	VBD
5180	499	55	the	the	DT
5180	499	56	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	499	57	screens	screen	NNS
5180	499	58	from	from	IN
5180	499	59	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	499	60	with	with	IN
5180	499	61	Internet	internet	NN
5180	499	62	access	access	NN
5180	499	63	.	.	.
5180	500	1	Even	even	RB
5180	500	2	after	after	IN
5180	500	3	the	the	DT
5180	500	4	Board	Board	NNP
5180	500	5	implemented	implement	VBD
5180	500	6	the	the	DT
5180	500	7	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	500	8	screens	screen	NNS
5180	500	9	and	and	CC
5180	500	10	later	later	RBR
5180	500	11	the	the	DT
5180	500	12	"	"	``
5180	500	13	tap	tap	NN
5180	500	14	-	-	HYPH
5180	500	15	on	on	IN
5180	500	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	500	17	the	the	DT
5180	500	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	500	19	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	500	20	"	"	''
5180	500	21	policy	policy	NN
5180	500	22	combined	combine	VBN
5180	500	23	with	with	IN
5180	500	24	placing	place	VBG
5180	500	25	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	500	26	in	in	IN
5180	500	27	view	view	NN
5180	500	28	of	of	IN
5180	500	29	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	500	30	,	,	,
5180	500	31	the	the	DT
5180	500	32	library	library	NN
5180	500	33	experienced	experience	VBD
5180	500	34	a	a	DT
5180	500	35	high	high	JJ
5180	500	36	turnover	turnover	NN
5180	500	37	rate	rate	NN
5180	500	38	among	among	IN
5180	500	39	reference	reference	NN
5180	500	40	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	500	41	who	who	WP
5180	500	42	worked	work	VBD
5180	500	43	in	in	IN
5180	500	44	view	view	NN
5180	500	45	of	of	IN
5180	500	46	Internet	internet	NN
5180	500	47	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	500	48	.	.	.
5180	501	1	Finding	find	VBG
5180	501	2	that	that	IN
5180	501	3	the	the	DT
5180	501	4	policies	policy	NNS
5180	501	5	that	that	WDT
5180	501	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	501	7	had	have	VBD
5180	501	8	tried	try	VBN
5180	501	9	did	do	VBD
5180	501	10	not	not	RB
5180	501	11	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	501	12	the	the	DT
5180	501	13	viewing	viewing	NN
5180	501	14	of	of	IN
5180	501	15	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	501	16	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	501	17	materials	material	NNS
5180	501	18	in	in	IN
5180	501	19	the	the	DT
5180	501	20	library	library	NN
5180	501	21	,	,	,
5180	501	22	the	the	DT
5180	501	23	Board	Board	NNP
5180	501	24	at	at	IN
5180	501	25	one	one	CD
5180	501	26	point	point	NN
5180	501	27	considered	consider	VBD
5180	501	28	discontinuing	discontinue	VBG
5180	501	29	Internet	internet	NN
5180	501	30	access	access	NN
5180	501	31	in	in	IN
5180	501	32	the	the	DT
5180	501	33	library	library	NN
5180	501	34	.	.	.
5180	502	1	The	the	DT
5180	502	2	Board	Board	NNP
5180	502	3	finally	finally	RB
5180	502	4	concluded	conclude	VBD
5180	502	5	that	that	IN
5180	502	6	the	the	DT
5180	502	7	methods	method	NNS
5180	502	8	that	that	IN
5180	502	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	502	10	had	have	VBD
5180	502	11	used	use	VBN
5180	502	12	to	to	TO
5180	502	13	regulate	regulate	VB
5180	502	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	502	15	use	use	NN
5180	502	16	were	be	VBD
5180	502	17	not	not	RB
5180	502	18	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
5180	502	19	to	to	TO
5180	502	20	stem	stem	VB
5180	502	21	the	the	DT
5180	502	22	behavioral	behavioral	JJ
5180	502	23	problems	problem	NNS
5180	502	24	that	that	WDT
5180	502	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	502	26	thought	think	VBD
5180	502	27	were	be	VBD
5180	502	28	linked	link	VBN
5180	502	29	to	to	IN
5180	502	30	the	the	DT
5180	502	31	availability	availability	NN
5180	502	32	of	of	IN
5180	502	33	pornographic	pornographic	JJ
5180	502	34	materials	material	NNS
5180	502	35	in	in	IN
5180	502	36	the	the	DT
5180	502	37	library	library	NN
5180	502	38	.	.	.
5180	503	1	As	as	IN
5180	503	2	a	a	DT
5180	503	3	result	result	NN
5180	503	4	,	,	,
5180	503	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	503	6	implemented	implement	VBD
5180	503	7	a	a	DT
5180	503	8	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
5180	503	9	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	503	10	policy	policy	NN
5180	503	11	.	.	.
5180	504	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	504	2	note	note	VBP
5180	504	3	,	,	,
5180	504	4	however	however	RB
5180	504	5	,	,	,
5180	504	6	that	that	IN
5180	504	7	none	none	NN
5180	504	8	of	of	IN
5180	504	9	the	the	DT
5180	504	10	libraries	library	NNS
5180	504	11	proffered	proffer	VBN
5180	504	12	by	by	IN
5180	504	13	the	the	DT
5180	504	14	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	504	15	presented	present	VBD
5180	504	16	any	any	DT
5180	504	17	systematic	systematic	JJ
5180	504	18	records	record	NNS
5180	504	19	or	or	CC
5180	504	20	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
5180	504	21	comparison	comparison	NN
5180	504	22	of	of	IN
5180	504	23	the	the	DT
5180	504	24	amount	amount	NN
5180	504	25	of	of	IN
5180	504	26	criminal	criminal	JJ
5180	504	27	or	or	CC
5180	504	28	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	504	29	inappropriate	inappropriate	JJ
5180	504	30	behavior	behavior	NN
5180	504	31	that	that	WDT
5180	504	32	occurred	occur	VBD
5180	504	33	in	in	IN
5180	504	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	504	35	libraries	library	NNS
5180	504	36	before	before	IN
5180	504	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	504	38	began	begin	VBD
5180	504	39	using	use	VBG
5180	504	40	Internet	internet	NN
5180	504	41	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	504	42	software	software	NN
5180	504	43	compared	compare	VBN
5180	504	44	to	to	IN
5180	504	45	the	the	DT
5180	504	46	amount	amount	NN
5180	504	47	that	that	WDT
5180	504	48	happened	happen	VBD
5180	504	49	after	after	IN
5180	504	50	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	504	51	installed	instal	VBD
5180	504	52	the	the	DT
5180	504	53	software	software	NN
5180	504	54	.	.	.
5180	505	1	The	the	DT
5180	505	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	505	3	'	'	POS
5180	505	4	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	505	5	also	also	RB
5180	505	6	testified	testify	VBD
5180	505	7	that	that	IN
5180	505	8	because	because	IN
5180	505	9	public	public	JJ
5180	505	10	libraries	library	NNS
5180	505	11	are	be	VBP
5180	505	12	public	public	JJ
5180	505	13	places	place	NNS
5180	505	14	,	,	,
5180	505	15	incidents	incident	NNS
5180	505	16	involving	involve	VBG
5180	505	17	inappropriate	inappropriate	JJ
5180	505	18	behavior	behavior	NN
5180	505	19	in	in	IN
5180	505	20	libraries	library	NNS
5180	505	21	(	(	-LRB-
5180	505	22	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	505	23	and	and	CC
5180	505	24	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	505	25	)	)	-RRB-
5180	505	26	existed	exist	VBD
5180	505	27	long	long	RB
5180	505	28	before	before	IN
5180	505	29	libraries	library	NNS
5180	505	30	provided	provide	VBD
5180	505	31	access	access	NN
5180	505	32	to	to	IN
5180	505	33	the	the	DT
5180	505	34	Internet	internet	NN
5180	505	35	.	.	.
5180	506	1	2	2	LS
5180	506	2	.	.	.
5180	507	1	Methods	method	NNS
5180	507	2	for	for	IN
5180	507	3	Regulating	regulate	VBG
5180	507	4	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	507	5	Use	Use	NNP
5180	507	6	The	the	DT
5180	507	7	methods	method	NNS
5180	507	8	that	that	WDT
5180	507	9	public	public	JJ
5180	507	10	libraries	library	NNS
5180	507	11	use	use	VBP
5180	507	12	to	to	TO
5180	507	13	regulate	regulate	VB
5180	507	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	507	15	use	use	NN
5180	507	16	vary	vary	VBP
5180	507	17	greatly	greatly	RB
5180	507	18	.	.	.
5180	508	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
5180	508	2	can	can	MD
5180	508	3	be	be	VB
5180	508	4	organized	organize	VBN
5180	508	5	into	into	IN
5180	508	6	four	four	CD
5180	508	7	categories	category	NNS
5180	508	8	:	:	:
5180	508	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	508	10	1	1	LS
5180	508	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	508	12	channeling	channel	VBG
5180	508	13	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	508	14	'	'	POS
5180	508	15	Internet	internet	NN
5180	508	16	use	use	NN
5180	508	17	;	;	,
5180	508	18	(	(	-LRB-
5180	508	19	2	2	LS
5180	508	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	508	21	separating	separate	VBG
5180	508	22	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	508	23	so	so	IN
5180	508	24	that	that	IN
5180	508	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	508	26	will	will	MD
5180	508	27	not	not	RB
5180	508	28	see	see	VB
5180	508	29	what	what	WP
5180	508	30	other	other	JJ
5180	508	31	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	508	32	are	be	VBP
5180	508	33	viewing	view	VBG
5180	508	34	;	;	:
5180	508	35	(	(	-LRB-
5180	508	36	3	3	LS
5180	508	37	)	)	-RRB-
5180	508	38	placing	place	VBG
5180	508	39	Internet	internet	NN
5180	508	40	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	508	41	in	in	IN
5180	508	42	public	public	JJ
5180	508	43	view	view	NN
5180	508	44	and	and	CC
5180	508	45	having	have	VBG
5180	508	46	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	508	47	observe	observe	VBP
5180	508	48	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	508	49	to	to	TO
5180	508	50	make	make	VB
5180	508	51	sure	sure	JJ
5180	508	52	that	that	IN
5180	508	53	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	508	54	are	be	VBP
5180	508	55	complying	comply	VBG
5180	508	56	with	with	IN
5180	508	57	the	the	DT
5180	508	58	library	library	NN
5180	508	59	's	's	POS
5180	508	60	Internet	internet	NN
5180	508	61	use	use	NN
5180	508	62	policy	policy	NN
5180	508	63	;	;	:
5180	508	64	and	and	CC
5180	508	65	(	(	-LRB-
5180	508	66	4	4	LS
5180	508	67	)	)	-RRB-
5180	508	68	using	use	VBG
5180	508	69	Internet	internet	NN
5180	508	70	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	508	71	software	software	NN
5180	508	72	.	.	.
5180	509	1	The	the	DT
5180	509	2	first	first	JJ
5180	509	3	category	category	NN
5180	509	4	–	–	:
5180	509	5	channeling	channel	VBG
5180	509	6	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	509	7	'	'	POS
5180	509	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	509	9	use	use	NN
5180	509	10	–	–	:
5180	509	11	frequently	frequently	RB
5180	509	12	includes	include	VBZ
5180	509	13	offering	offer	VBG
5180	509	14	training	training	NN
5180	509	15	to	to	IN
5180	509	16	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	509	17	on	on	IN
5180	509	18	how	how	WRB
5180	509	19	to	to	TO
5180	509	20	use	use	VB
5180	509	21	the	the	DT
5180	509	22	Internet	internet	NN
5180	509	23	,	,	,
5180	509	24	including	include	VBG
5180	509	25	how	how	WRB
5180	509	26	to	to	TO
5180	509	27	access	access	VB
5180	509	28	the	the	DT
5180	509	29	information	information	NN
5180	509	30	that	that	WDT
5180	509	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	509	32	want	want	VBP
5180	509	33	and	and	CC
5180	509	34	to	to	TO
5180	509	35	avoid	avoid	VB
5180	509	36	the	the	DT
5180	509	37	materials	material	NNS
5180	509	38	that	that	IN
5180	509	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	509	40	do	do	VBP
5180	509	41	not	not	RB
5180	509	42	want	want	VB
5180	509	43	.	.	.
5180	510	1	Another	another	DT
5180	510	2	technique	technique	NN
5180	510	3	that	that	WDT
5180	510	4	some	some	DT
5180	510	5	public	public	JJ
5180	510	6	libraries	library	NNS
5180	510	7	use	use	VBP
5180	510	8	to	to	TO
5180	510	9	direct	direct	VB
5180	510	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	510	11	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	510	12	to	to	IN
5180	510	13	pages	page	NNS
5180	510	14	that	that	IN
5180	510	15	the	the	DT
5180	510	16	libraries	library	NNS
5180	510	17	have	have	VBP
5180	510	18	determined	determine	VBN
5180	510	19	to	to	TO
5180	510	20	be	be	VB
5180	510	21	accurate	accurate	JJ
5180	510	22	and	and	CC
5180	510	23	valuable	valuable	JJ
5180	510	24	is	be	VBZ
5180	510	25	to	to	TO
5180	510	26	establish	establish	VB
5180	510	27	links	link	NNS
5180	510	28	to	to	TO
5180	510	29	"	"	``
5180	510	30	recommended	recommend	VBN
5180	510	31	Web	web	NN
5180	510	32	sites	site	NNS
5180	510	33	"	"	''
5180	510	34	from	from	IN
5180	510	35	the	the	DT
5180	510	36	public	public	JJ
5180	510	37	library	library	NN
5180	510	38	's	's	POS
5180	510	39	home	home	NN
5180	510	40	page	page	NN
5180	510	41	(	(	-LRB-
5180	510	42	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	510	43	,	,	,
5180	510	44	the	the	DT
5180	510	45	page	page	NN
5180	510	46	that	that	WDT
5180	510	47	appears	appear	VBZ
5180	510	48	when	when	WRB
5180	510	49	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	510	50	begin	begin	VBP
5180	510	51	a	a	DT
5180	510	52	session	session	NN
5180	510	53	at	at	IN
5180	510	54	one	one	CD
5180	510	55	of	of	IN
5180	510	56	the	the	DT
5180	510	57	library	library	NN
5180	510	58	's	's	POS
5180	510	59	public	public	JJ
5180	510	60	Internet	internet	NN
5180	510	61	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	510	62	)	)	-RRB-
5180	510	63	.	.	.
5180	511	1	Librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	511	2	select	select	VBP
5180	511	3	these	these	DT
5180	511	4	recommended	recommend	VBN
5180	511	5	Web	web	NN
5180	511	6	sites	site	NNS
5180	511	7	by	by	IN
5180	511	8	using	use	VBG
5180	511	9	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	511	10	similar	similar	JJ
5180	511	11	to	to	IN
5180	511	12	those	those	DT
5180	511	13	employed	employ	VBN
5180	511	14	in	in	IN
5180	511	15	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	511	16	collection	collection	NN
5180	511	17	development	development	NN
5180	511	18	.	.	.
5180	512	1	However	however	RB
5180	512	2	,	,	,
5180	512	3	unless	unless	IN
5180	512	4	the	the	DT
5180	512	5	library	library	NN
5180	512	6	determines	determine	VBZ
5180	512	7	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	512	8	,	,	,
5180	512	9	selection	selection	NN
5180	512	10	of	of	IN
5180	512	11	these	these	DT
5180	512	12	specific	specific	JJ
5180	512	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	512	14	does	do	VBZ
5180	512	15	not	not	RB
5180	512	16	preclude	preclude	VB
5180	512	17	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	512	18	from	from	IN
5180	512	19	attempting	attempt	VBG
5180	512	20	to	to	TO
5180	512	21	access	access	VB
5180	512	22	other	other	JJ
5180	512	23	Internet	internet	NN
5180	512	24	Web	web	NN
5180	512	25	sites	site	NNS
5180	512	26	.	.	.
5180	513	1	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	513	2	may	may	MD
5180	513	3	extend	extend	VB
5180	513	4	the	the	DT
5180	513	5	"	"	``
5180	513	6	recommended	recommend	VBN
5180	513	7	Web	web	NN
5180	513	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	513	9	"	"	''
5180	513	10	method	method	NN
5180	513	11	further	further	RB
5180	513	12	by	by	IN
5180	513	13	limiting	limit	VBG
5180	513	14	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	513	15	'	'	POS
5180	513	16	access	access	NN
5180	513	17	to	to	IN
5180	513	18	only	only	RB
5180	513	19	those	those	DT
5180	513	20	Web	web	NN
5180	513	21	sites	site	NNS
5180	513	22	that	that	WDT
5180	513	23	are	be	VBP
5180	513	24	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	513	25	and	and	CC
5180	513	26	selected	select	VBN
5180	513	27	by	by	IN
5180	513	28	the	the	DT
5180	513	29	library	library	NN
5180	513	30	's	's	POS
5180	513	31	staff	staff	NN
5180	513	32	.	.	.
5180	514	1	For	for	IN
5180	514	2	example	example	NN
5180	514	3	,	,	,
5180	514	4	in	in	IN
5180	514	5	1996	1996	CD
5180	514	6	,	,	,
5180	514	7	the	the	DT
5180	514	8	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	514	9	,	,	,
5180	514	10	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
5180	514	11	Library	Library	NNP
5180	514	12	offered	offer	VBD
5180	514	13	Internet	internet	NN
5180	514	14	access	access	NN
5180	514	15	to	to	IN
5180	514	16	children	child	NNS
5180	514	17	through	through	IN
5180	514	18	a	a	DT
5180	514	19	service	service	NN
5180	514	20	called	call	VBN
5180	514	21	the	the	DT
5180	514	22	"	"	``
5180	514	23	Library	Library	NNP
5180	514	24	Channel	Channel	NNP
5180	514	25	.	.	.
5180	514	26	"	"	''
5180	515	1	This	this	DT
5180	515	2	service	service	NN
5180	515	3	was	be	VBD
5180	515	4	intended	intend	VBN
5180	515	5	to	to	TO
5180	515	6	be	be	VB
5180	515	7	a	a	DT
5180	515	8	means	means	NN
5180	515	9	by	by	IN
5180	515	10	which	which	WDT
5180	515	11	the	the	DT
5180	515	12	library	library	NN
5180	515	13	could	could	MD
5180	515	14	organize	organize	VB
5180	515	15	the	the	DT
5180	515	16	Internet	internet	NN
5180	515	17	in	in	IN
5180	515	18	some	some	DT
5180	515	19	fashion	fashion	NN
5180	515	20	for	for	IN
5180	515	21	presentation	presentation	NN
5180	515	22	to	to	IN
5180	515	23	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	515	24	.	.	.
5180	516	1	Through	through	IN
5180	516	2	the	the	DT
5180	516	3	Library	Library	NNP
5180	516	4	Channel	Channel	NNP
5180	516	5	,	,	,
5180	516	6	the	the	DT
5180	516	7	computers	computer	NNS
5180	516	8	in	in	IN
5180	516	9	the	the	DT
5180	516	10	children	child	NNS
5180	516	11	's	's	POS
5180	516	12	section	section	NN
5180	516	13	of	of	IN
5180	516	14	the	the	DT
5180	516	15	library	library	NN
5180	516	16	were	be	VBD
5180	516	17	restricted	restrict	VBN
5180	516	18	to	to	IN
5180	516	19	2,000	2,000	CD
5180	516	20	to	to	TO
5180	516	21	3,000	3,000	CD
5180	516	22	sites	site	NNS
5180	516	23	selected	select	VBN
5180	516	24	by	by	IN
5180	516	25	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	516	26	.	.	.
5180	517	1	After	after	IN
5180	517	2	three	three	CD
5180	517	3	years	year	NNS
5180	517	4	,	,	,
5180	517	5	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	517	6	stopped	stop	VBD
5180	517	7	using	use	VBG
5180	517	8	the	the	DT
5180	517	9	Library	Library	NNP
5180	517	10	Channel	Channel	NNP
5180	517	11	system	system	NN
5180	517	12	because	because	IN
5180	517	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	517	14	overly	overly	RB
5180	517	15	constrained	constrain	VBD
5180	517	16	the	the	DT
5180	517	17	children	child	NNS
5180	517	18	's	's	POS
5180	517	19	ability	ability	NN
5180	517	20	to	to	TO
5180	517	21	access	access	VB
5180	517	22	materials	material	NNS
5180	517	23	on	on	IN
5180	517	24	the	the	DT
5180	517	25	Internet	internet	NN
5180	517	26	,	,	,
5180	517	27	and	and	CC
5180	517	28	because	because	IN
5180	517	29	the	the	DT
5180	517	30	library	library	NN
5180	517	31	experienced	experience	VBD
5180	517	32	several	several	JJ
5180	517	33	technical	technical	JJ
5180	517	34	problems	problem	NNS
5180	517	35	with	with	IN
5180	517	36	the	the	DT
5180	517	37	system	system	NN
5180	517	38	.	.	.
5180	518	1	Public	public	JJ
5180	518	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	518	3	also	also	RB
5180	518	4	use	use	VBP
5180	518	5	several	several	JJ
5180	518	6	different	different	JJ
5180	518	7	techniques	technique	NNS
5180	518	8	to	to	TO
5180	518	9	separate	separate	VB
5180	518	10	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	518	11	during	during	IN
5180	518	12	Internet	internet	NN
5180	518	13	sessions	session	NNS
5180	518	14	so	so	IN
5180	518	15	that	that	IN
5180	518	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	518	17	will	will	MD
5180	518	18	not	not	RB
5180	518	19	see	see	VB
5180	518	20	what	what	WP
5180	518	21	other	other	JJ
5180	518	22	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	518	23	are	be	VBP
5180	518	24	viewing	view	VBG
5180	518	25	.	.	.
5180	519	1	The	the	DT
5180	519	2	simplest	simple	JJS
5180	519	3	way	way	NN
5180	519	4	to	to	TO
5180	519	5	achieve	achieve	VB
5180	519	6	this	this	DT
5180	519	7	result	result	NN
5180	519	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	519	9	to	to	TO
5180	519	10	position	position	VB
5180	519	11	the	the	DT
5180	519	12	library	library	NN
5180	519	13	's	's	POS
5180	519	14	public	public	JJ
5180	519	15	Internet	internet	NN
5180	519	16	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	519	17	so	so	IN
5180	519	18	that	that	IN
5180	519	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	519	20	are	be	VBP
5180	519	21	located	locate	VBN
5180	519	22	away	away	RB
5180	519	23	from	from	IN
5180	519	24	traffic	traffic	NN
5180	519	25	patterns	pattern	NNS
5180	519	26	in	in	IN
5180	519	27	the	the	DT
5180	519	28	library	library	NN
5180	519	29	(	(	-LRB-
5180	519	30	and	and	CC
5180	519	31	from	from	IN
5180	519	32	other	other	JJ
5180	519	33	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	519	34	)	)	-RRB-
5180	519	35	,	,	,
5180	519	36	for	for	IN
5180	519	37	example	example	NN
5180	519	38	,	,	,
5180	519	39	by	by	IN
5180	519	40	placing	place	VBG
5180	519	41	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	519	42	so	so	IN
5180	519	43	that	that	IN
5180	519	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	519	45	face	face	VBP
5180	519	46	a	a	DT
5180	519	47	wall	wall	NN
5180	519	48	.	.	.
5180	520	1	This	this	DT
5180	520	2	method	method	NN
5180	520	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	520	4	obviously	obviously	RB
5180	520	5	constrained	constrain	VBN
5180	520	6	by	by	IN
5180	520	7	libraries	library	NNS
5180	520	8	'	'	POS
5180	520	9	space	space	NN
5180	520	10	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	520	11	and	and	CC
5180	520	12	physical	physical	JJ
5180	520	13	layout	layout	NN
5180	520	14	.	.	.
5180	521	1	Some	some	DT
5180	521	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	521	3	have	have	VBP
5180	521	4	also	also	RB
5180	521	5	installed	instal	VBN
5180	521	6	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	521	7	screens	screen	NNS
5180	521	8	on	on	IN
5180	521	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	521	10	public	public	JJ
5180	521	11	Internet	internet	NN
5180	521	12	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	521	13	.	.	.
5180	522	1	These	these	DT
5180	522	2	screens	screen	NNS
5180	522	3	make	make	VBP
5180	522	4	a	a	DT
5180	522	5	monitor	monitor	NN
5180	522	6	appear	appear	VB
5180	522	7	blank	blank	JJ
5180	522	8	unless	unless	IN
5180	522	9	the	the	DT
5180	522	10	viewer	viewer	NN
5180	522	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	522	12	looking	look	VBG
5180	522	13	at	at	IN
5180	522	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	522	15	head	head	NN
5180	522	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	522	17	on	on	RB
5180	522	18	.	.	.
5180	523	1	Although	although	IN
5180	523	2	the	the	DT
5180	523	3	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
5180	523	4	and	and	CC
5180	523	5	Fort	Fort	NNP
5180	523	6	Vancouver	Vancouver	NNP
5180	523	7	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	523	8	submitted	submit	VBD
5180	523	9	records	record	NNS
5180	523	10	showing	show	VBG
5180	523	11	that	that	IN
5180	523	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	523	13	have	have	VBP
5180	523	14	received	receive	VBN
5180	523	15	few	few	JJ
5180	523	16	complaints	complaint	NNS
5180	523	17	regarding	regard	VBG
5180	523	18	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	523	19	'	'	POS
5180	523	20	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	523	21	exposure	exposure	NN
5180	523	22	to	to	IN
5180	523	23	materials	material	NNS
5180	523	24	on	on	IN
5180	523	25	the	the	DT
5180	523	26	Internet	internet	NN
5180	523	27	,	,	,
5180	523	28	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	523	29	screens	screen	NNS
5180	523	30	do	do	VBP
5180	523	31	not	not	RB
5180	523	32	always	always	RB
5180	523	33	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	523	34	library	library	NN
5180	523	35	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	523	36	or	or	CC
5180	523	37	employees	employee	NNS
5180	523	38	from	from	IN
5180	523	39	inadvertently	inadvertently	RB
5180	523	40	seeing	see	VBG
5180	523	41	the	the	DT
5180	523	42	materials	material	NNS
5180	523	43	that	that	WDT
5180	523	44	another	another	DT
5180	523	45	patron	patron	NN
5180	523	46	is	be	VBZ
5180	523	47	viewing	view	VBG
5180	523	48	when	when	WRB
5180	523	49	passing	pass	VBG
5180	523	50	directly	directly	RB
5180	523	51	behind	behind	IN
5180	523	52	a	a	DT
5180	523	53	terminal	terminal	NN
5180	523	54	.	.	.
5180	524	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
5180	524	2	also	also	RB
5180	524	3	have	have	VBP
5180	524	4	the	the	DT
5180	524	5	drawback	drawback	NN
5180	524	6	of	of	IN
5180	524	7	making	make	VBG
5180	524	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	524	9	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	524	10	for	for	IN
5180	524	11	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	524	12	to	to	TO
5180	524	13	work	work	VB
5180	524	14	together	together	RB
5180	524	15	at	at	IN
5180	524	16	a	a	DT
5180	524	17	single	single	JJ
5180	524	18	terminal	terminal	NN
5180	524	19	,	,	,
5180	524	20	or	or	CC
5180	524	21	for	for	IN
5180	524	22	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	524	23	to	to	TO
5180	524	24	assist	assist	VB
5180	524	25	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	524	26	at	at	IN
5180	524	27	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	524	28	,	,	,
5180	524	29	because	because	IN
5180	524	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	524	31	is	be	VBZ
5180	524	32	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	524	33	for	for	IN
5180	524	34	two	two	CD
5180	524	35	people	people	NNS
5180	524	36	to	to	TO
5180	524	37	stand	stand	VB
5180	524	38	side	side	NN
5180	524	39	by	by	IN
5180	524	40	side	side	NN
5180	524	41	and	and	CC
5180	524	42	view	view	VB
5180	524	43	a	a	DT
5180	524	44	screen	screen	NN
5180	524	45	at	at	IN
5180	524	46	the	the	DT
5180	524	47	same	same	JJ
5180	524	48	time	time	NN
5180	524	49	.	.	.
5180	525	1	Some	some	DT
5180	525	2	library	library	NN
5180	525	3	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	525	4	also	also	RB
5180	525	5	find	find	VBP
5180	525	6	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	525	7	screens	screen	NNS
5180	525	8	to	to	TO
5180	525	9	be	be	VB
5180	525	10	a	a	DT
5180	525	11	hindrance	hindrance	NN
5180	525	12	and	and	CC
5180	525	13	have	have	VBP
5180	525	14	attempted	attempt	VBN
5180	525	15	to	to	TO
5180	525	16	remove	remove	VB
5180	525	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	525	18	in	in	IN
5180	525	19	order	order	NN
5180	525	20	to	to	TO
5180	525	21	improve	improve	VB
5180	525	22	the	the	DT
5180	525	23	brightness	brightness	NN
5180	525	24	of	of	IN
5180	525	25	the	the	DT
5180	525	26	screen	screen	NN
5180	525	27	or	or	CC
5180	525	28	to	to	TO
5180	525	29	make	make	VB
5180	525	30	the	the	DT
5180	525	31	view	view	NN
5180	525	32	better	well	RBR
5180	525	33	.	.	.
5180	526	1	Another	another	DT
5180	526	2	method	method	NN
5180	526	3	that	that	WDT
5180	526	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	526	5	use	use	VBP
5180	526	6	to	to	TO
5180	526	7	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	526	8	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	526	9	from	from	IN
5180	526	10	seeing	see	VBG
5180	526	11	what	what	WP
5180	526	12	other	other	JJ
5180	526	13	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	526	14	are	be	VBP
5180	526	15	viewing	view	VBG
5180	526	16	on	on	IN
5180	526	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	526	18	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	526	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	526	20	the	the	DT
5180	526	21	installation	installation	NN
5180	526	22	of	of	IN
5180	526	23	"	"	``
5180	526	24	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	526	25	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	526	26	.	.	.
5180	526	27	"	"	''
5180	527	1	Recessed	recess	VBN
5180	527	2	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	527	3	are	be	VBP
5180	527	4	computer	computer	NN
5180	527	5	screens	screen	NNS
5180	527	6	that	that	WDT
5180	527	7	sit	sit	VBP
5180	527	8	below	below	IN
5180	527	9	the	the	DT
5180	527	10	level	level	NN
5180	527	11	of	of	IN
5180	527	12	a	a	DT
5180	527	13	desk	desk	NN
5180	527	14	top	top	NN
5180	527	15	and	and	CC
5180	527	16	are	be	VBP
5180	527	17	viewed	view	VBN
5180	527	18	from	from	IN
5180	527	19	above	above	RB
5180	527	20	.	.	.
5180	528	1	Although	although	IN
5180	528	2	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	528	3	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	528	4	,	,	,
5180	528	5	especially	especially	RB
5180	528	6	when	when	WRB
5180	528	7	combined	combine	VBN
5180	528	8	with	with	IN
5180	528	9	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	528	10	screens	screen	NNS
5180	528	11	,	,	,
5180	528	12	eliminate	eliminate	VB
5180	528	13	almost	almost	RB
5180	528	14	all	all	DT
5180	528	15	of	of	IN
5180	528	16	the	the	DT
5180	528	17	possibility	possibility	NN
5180	528	18	of	of	IN
5180	528	19	a	a	DT
5180	528	20	patron	patron	NN
5180	528	21	accidentally	accidentally	RB
5180	528	22	viewing	view	VBG
5180	528	23	the	the	DT
5180	528	24	contents	content	NNS
5180	528	25	on	on	IN
5180	528	26	another	another	DT
5180	528	27	patron	patron	NN
5180	528	28	's	's	POS
5180	528	29	screen	screen	NN
5180	528	30	,	,	,
5180	528	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	528	32	suffer	suffer	VBP
5180	528	33	from	from	IN
5180	528	34	the	the	DT
5180	528	35	same	same	JJ
5180	528	36	drawbacks	drawback	NNS
5180	528	37	as	as	IN
5180	528	38	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	528	39	screens	screen	NNS
5180	528	40	,	,	,
5180	528	41	that	that	RB
5180	528	42	is	is	RB
5180	528	43	,	,	,
5180	528	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	528	45	make	make	VBP
5180	528	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	528	47	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	528	48	for	for	IN
5180	528	49	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	528	50	to	to	TO
5180	528	51	work	work	VB
5180	528	52	together	together	RB
5180	528	53	or	or	CC
5180	528	54	with	with	IN
5180	528	55	a	a	DT
5180	528	56	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	528	57	at	at	IN
5180	528	58	a	a	DT
5180	528	59	single	single	JJ
5180	528	60	terminal	terminal	NN
5180	528	61	.	.	.
5180	529	1	Some	some	DT
5180	529	2	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	529	3	also	also	RB
5180	529	4	testified	testify	VBD
5180	529	5	that	that	IN
5180	529	6	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	529	7	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	529	8	are	be	VBP
5180	529	9	costly	costly	JJ
5180	529	10	,	,	,
5180	529	11	but	but	CC
5180	529	12	did	do	VBD
5180	529	13	not	not	RB
5180	529	14	indicate	indicate	VB
5180	529	15	how	how	WRB
5180	529	16	expensive	expensive	JJ
5180	529	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	529	18	are	be	VBP
5180	529	19	compared	compare	VBN
5180	529	20	to	to	IN
5180	529	21	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	529	22	screens	screen	NNS
5180	529	23	or	or	CC
5180	529	24	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	529	25	software	software	NN
5180	529	26	.	.	.
5180	530	1	A	a	DT
5180	530	2	related	related	JJ
5180	530	3	technique	technique	NN
5180	530	4	that	that	IN
5180	530	5	some	some	DT
5180	530	6	public	public	JJ
5180	530	7	libraries	library	NNS
5180	530	8	use	use	VBP
5180	530	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	530	10	to	to	TO
5180	530	11	create	create	VB
5180	530	12	a	a	DT
5180	530	13	separate	separate	JJ
5180	530	14	children	child	NNS
5180	530	15	's	's	POS
5180	530	16	Internet	internet	NN
5180	530	17	viewing	view	VBG
5180	530	18	area	area	NN
5180	530	19	,	,	,
5180	530	20	where	where	WRB
5180	530	21	no	no	DT
5180	530	22	adults	adult	NNS
5180	530	23	except	except	IN
5180	530	24	those	those	DT
5180	530	25	accompanying	accompany	VBG
5180	530	26	children	child	NNS
5180	530	27	in	in	IN
5180	530	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	530	29	care	care	NN
5180	530	30	may	may	MD
5180	530	31	use	use	VB
5180	530	32	the	the	DT
5180	530	33	Internet	internet	NN
5180	530	34	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	530	35	.	.	.
5180	531	1	This	this	DT
5180	531	2	serves	serve	VBZ
5180	531	3	the	the	DT
5180	531	4	objective	objective	NN
5180	531	5	of	of	IN
5180	531	6	keeping	keep	VBG
5180	531	7	children	child	NNS
5180	531	8	from	from	IN
5180	531	9	inadvertently	inadvertently	RB
5180	531	10	viewing	view	VBG
5180	531	11	materials	material	NNS
5180	531	12	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	531	13	only	only	RB
5180	531	14	for	for	IN
5180	531	15	adults	adult	NNS
5180	531	16	that	that	IN
5180	531	17	adults	adult	NNS
5180	531	18	may	may	MD
5180	531	19	be	be	VB
5180	531	20	viewing	view	VBG
5180	531	21	on	on	IN
5180	531	22	nearby	nearby	JJ
5180	531	23	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	531	24	.	.	.
5180	532	1	A	a	DT
5180	532	2	third	third	JJ
5180	532	3	set	set	NN
5180	532	4	of	of	IN
5180	532	5	techniques	technique	NNS
5180	532	6	that	that	WDT
5180	532	7	public	public	JJ
5180	532	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	532	9	have	have	VBP
5180	532	10	used	use	VBN
5180	532	11	to	to	TO
5180	532	12	enforce	enforce	VB
5180	532	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	532	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	532	15	use	use	NN
5180	532	16	policies	policy	NNS
5180	532	17	takes	take	VBZ
5180	532	18	the	the	DT
5180	532	19	opposite	opposite	JJ
5180	532	20	tack	tack	NN
5180	532	21	from	from	IN
5180	532	22	the	the	DT
5180	532	23	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	532	24	screens	screen	NNS
5180	532	25	/	/	SYM
5180	532	26	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	532	27	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	532	28	approach	approach	VBP
5180	532	29	by	by	IN
5180	532	30	placing	place	VBG
5180	532	31	all	all	DT
5180	532	32	of	of	IN
5180	532	33	the	the	DT
5180	532	34	library	library	NN
5180	532	35	's	's	POS
5180	532	36	public	public	JJ
5180	532	37	Internet	internet	NN
5180	532	38	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	532	39	in	in	IN
5180	532	40	prominent	prominent	JJ
5180	532	41	and	and	CC
5180	532	42	visible	visible	JJ
5180	532	43	locations	location	NNS
5180	532	44	,	,	,
5180	532	45	such	such	JJ
5180	532	46	as	as	IN
5180	532	47	near	near	IN
5180	532	48	the	the	DT
5180	532	49	library	library	NN
5180	532	50	's	's	POS
5180	532	51	reference	reference	NN
5180	532	52	desk	desk	NN
5180	532	53	.	.	.
5180	533	1	This	this	DT
5180	533	2	approach	approach	NN
5180	533	3	allows	allow	VBZ
5180	533	4	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	533	5	to	to	TO
5180	533	6	enforce	enforce	VB
5180	533	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	533	8	library	library	NN
5180	533	9	's	's	POS
5180	533	10	Internet	internet	NN
5180	533	11	use	use	NN
5180	533	12	policy	policy	NN
5180	533	13	by	by	IN
5180	533	14	observing	observe	VBG
5180	533	15	what	what	WP
5180	533	16	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	533	17	are	be	VBP
5180	533	18	viewing	view	VBG
5180	533	19	and	and	CC
5180	533	20	employing	employ	VBG
5180	533	21	the	the	DT
5180	533	22	tap	tap	NN
5180	533	23	-	-	HYPH
5180	533	24	on	on	IN
5180	533	25	-	-	HYPH
5180	533	26	the	the	DT
5180	533	27	-	-	HYPH
5180	533	28	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	533	29	policy	policy	NN
5180	533	30	.	.	.
5180	534	1	Under	under	IN
5180	534	2	this	this	DT
5180	534	3	approach	approach	NN
5180	534	4	,	,	,
5180	534	5	when	when	WRB
5180	534	6	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	534	7	are	be	VBP
5180	534	8	viewing	view	VBG
5180	534	9	materials	material	NNS
5180	534	10	that	that	WDT
5180	534	11	are	be	VBP
5180	534	12	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
5180	534	13	with	with	IN
5180	534	14	the	the	DT
5180	534	15	library	library	NN
5180	534	16	's	's	POS
5180	534	17	policies	policy	NNS
5180	534	18	,	,	,
5180	534	19	a	a	DT
5180	534	20	library	library	NN
5180	534	21	staff	staff	NN
5180	534	22	member	member	NN
5180	534	23	approaches	approach	VBZ
5180	534	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	534	25	and	and	CC
5180	534	26	asks	ask	VBZ
5180	534	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	534	28	to	to	TO
5180	534	29	view	view	VB
5180	534	30	something	something	NN
5180	534	31	else	else	RB
5180	534	32	,	,	,
5180	534	33	or	or	CC
5180	534	34	may	may	MD
5180	534	35	ask	ask	VB
5180	534	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	534	37	to	to	TO
5180	534	38	end	end	VB
5180	534	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	534	40	Internet	internet	NN
5180	534	41	session	session	NN
5180	534	42	.	.	.
5180	535	1	A	a	DT
5180	535	2	patron	patron	NN
5180	535	3	who	who	WP
5180	535	4	does	do	VBZ
5180	535	5	not	not	RB
5180	535	6	comply	comply	VB
5180	535	7	with	with	IN
5180	535	8	these	these	DT
5180	535	9	requests	request	NNS
5180	535	10	,	,	,
5180	535	11	or	or	CC
5180	535	12	who	who	WP
5180	535	13	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
5180	535	14	views	view	VBZ
5180	535	15	materials	material	NNS
5180	535	16	not	not	RB
5180	535	17	permitted	permit	VBN
5180	535	18	under	under	IN
5180	535	19	the	the	DT
5180	535	20	library	library	NN
5180	535	21	's	's	POS
5180	535	22	Internet	internet	NN
5180	535	23	use	use	NN
5180	535	24	policy	policy	NN
5180	535	25	,	,	,
5180	535	26	may	may	MD
5180	535	27	have	have	VB
5180	535	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	535	29	or	or	CC
5180	535	30	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	535	31	Internet	internet	NN
5180	535	32	or	or	CC
5180	535	33	library	library	NN
5180	535	34	privileges	privilege	NNS
5180	535	35	suspended	suspend	VBN
5180	535	36	or	or	CC
5180	535	37	revoked	revoke	VBN
5180	535	38	.	.	.
5180	536	1	But	but	CC
5180	536	2	many	many	JJ
5180	536	3	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	536	4	are	be	VBP
5180	536	5	uncomfortable	uncomfortable	JJ
5180	536	6	with	with	IN
5180	536	7	approaching	approach	VBG
5180	536	8	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	536	9	who	who	WP
5180	536	10	are	be	VBP
5180	536	11	viewing	view	VBG
5180	536	12	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	536	13	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	536	14	images	image	NNS
5180	536	15	,	,	,
5180	536	16	finding	find	VBG
5180	536	17	confrontation	confrontation	NN
5180	536	18	unpleasant	unpleasant	JJ
5180	536	19	.	.	.
5180	537	1	Hence	hence	RB
5180	537	2	some	some	DT
5180	537	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	537	4	are	be	VBP
5180	537	5	reluctant	reluctant	JJ
5180	537	6	to	to	TO
5180	537	7	apply	apply	VB
5180	537	8	the	the	DT
5180	537	9	tap	tap	NN
5180	537	10	-	-	HYPH
5180	537	11	on	on	IN
5180	537	12	-	-	HYPH
5180	537	13	the-	the-	NN
5180	537	14	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	537	15	policy	policy	NN
5180	537	16	.	.	.
5180	538	1	The	the	DT
5180	538	2	fourth	fourth	JJ
5180	538	3	category	category	NN
5180	538	4	of	of	IN
5180	538	5	methods	method	NNS
5180	538	6	that	that	WDT
5180	538	7	public	public	JJ
5180	538	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	538	9	employ	employ	VBP
5180	538	10	to	to	TO
5180	538	11	enforce	enforce	VB
5180	538	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	538	13	Internet	internet	NN
5180	538	14	use	use	NN
5180	538	15	policies	policy	NNS
5180	538	16	,	,	,
5180	538	17	and	and	CC
5180	538	18	the	the	DT
5180	538	19	one	one	NN
5180	538	20	that	that	WDT
5180	538	21	gives	give	VBZ
5180	538	22	rise	rise	VB
5180	538	23	to	to	IN
5180	538	24	this	this	DT
5180	538	25	case	case	NN
5180	538	26	,	,	,
5180	538	27	is	be	VBZ
5180	538	28	the	the	DT
5180	538	29	use	use	NN
5180	538	30	of	of	IN
5180	538	31	Internet	internet	NN
5180	538	32	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	538	33	software	software	NN
5180	538	34	.	.	.
5180	539	1	According	accord	VBG
5180	539	2	to	to	IN
5180	539	3	the	the	DT
5180	539	4	June	June	NNP
5180	539	5	2000	2000	CD
5180	539	6	Survey	Survey	NNP
5180	539	7	of	of	IN
5180	539	8	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	539	9	Access	Access	NNP
5180	539	10	Management	Management	NNP
5180	539	11	in	in	IN
5180	539	12	Public	Public	NNP
5180	539	13	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	539	14	,	,	,
5180	539	15	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	539	16	7	7	CD
5180	539	17	%	%	NN
5180	539	18	of	of	IN
5180	539	19	libraries	library	NNS
5180	539	20	with	with	IN
5180	539	21	public	public	JJ
5180	539	22	Internet	internet	NN
5180	539	23	access	access	NN
5180	539	24	had	have	VBD
5180	539	25	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	539	26	the	the	DT
5180	539	27	use	use	NN
5180	539	28	of	of	IN
5180	539	29	blocking	block	VBG
5180	539	30	programs	program	NNS
5180	539	31	by	by	IN
5180	539	32	adult	adult	NN
5180	539	33	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	539	34	.	.	.
5180	540	1	Some	some	DT
5180	540	2	public	public	JJ
5180	540	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	540	4	provide	provide	VBP
5180	540	5	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	540	6	with	with	IN
5180	540	7	the	the	DT
5180	540	8	option	option	NN
5180	540	9	of	of	IN
5180	540	10	using	use	VBG
5180	540	11	a	a	DT
5180	540	12	blocking	block	VBG
5180	540	13	program	program	NN
5180	540	14	,	,	,
5180	540	15	allowing	allow	VBG
5180	540	16	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	540	17	to	to	TO
5180	540	18	decide	decide	VB
5180	540	19	whether	whether	IN
5180	540	20	to	to	TO
5180	540	21	engage	engage	VB
5180	540	22	the	the	DT
5180	540	23	program	program	NN
5180	540	24	when	when	WRB
5180	540	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	540	26	or	or	CC
5180	540	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	540	28	children	child	NNS
5180	540	29	access	access	VBP
5180	540	30	the	the	DT
5180	540	31	Internet	internet	NN
5180	540	32	.	.	.
5180	541	1	Other	other	JJ
5180	541	2	public	public	JJ
5180	541	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	541	4	require	require	VBP
5180	541	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	541	6	child	child	NN
5180	541	7	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	541	8	to	to	TO
5180	541	9	use	use	VB
5180	541	10	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	541	11	software	software	NN
5180	541	12	,	,	,
5180	541	13	but	but	CC
5180	541	14	not	not	RB
5180	541	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	541	16	adult	adult	NN
5180	541	17	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	541	18	.	.	.
5180	542	1	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	542	2	software	software	NN
5180	542	3	vendors	vendor	NNS
5180	542	4	sell	sell	VBP
5180	542	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	542	6	products	product	NNS
5180	542	7	on	on	IN
5180	542	8	a	a	DT
5180	542	9	subscription	subscription	NN
5180	542	10	basis	basis	NN
5180	542	11	.	.	.
5180	543	1	The	the	DT
5180	543	2	cost	cost	NN
5180	543	3	of	of	IN
5180	543	4	a	a	DT
5180	543	5	subscription	subscription	NN
5180	543	6	varies	vary	VBZ
5180	543	7	with	with	IN
5180	543	8	the	the	DT
5180	543	9	number	number	NN
5180	543	10	of	of	IN
5180	543	11	computers	computer	NNS
5180	543	12	on	on	IN
5180	543	13	which	which	WDT
5180	543	14	the	the	DT
5180	543	15	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	543	16	software	software	NN
5180	543	17	will	will	MD
5180	543	18	be	be	VB
5180	543	19	used	use	VBN
5180	543	20	.	.	.
5180	544	1	In	in	IN
5180	544	2	2001	2001	CD
5180	544	3	,	,	,
5180	544	4	the	the	DT
5180	544	5	cost	cost	NN
5180	544	6	of	of	IN
5180	544	7	the	the	DT
5180	544	8	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	544	9	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	544	10	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	544	11	software	software	NN
5180	544	12	was	be	VBD
5180	544	13	$	$	$
5180	544	14	1,950	1,950	CD
5180	544	15	for	for	IN
5180	544	16	100	100	CD
5180	544	17	terminal	terminal	JJ
5180	544	18	licenses	license	NNS
5180	544	19	.	.	.
5180	545	1	The	the	DT
5180	545	2	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	545	3	County	County	NNP
5180	545	4	Library	Library	NNP
5180	545	5	System	System	NNP
5180	545	6	pays	pay	VBZ
5180	545	7	$	$	$
5180	545	8	2,500	2,500	CD
5180	545	9	per	per	IN
5180	545	10	year	year	NN
5180	545	11	for	for	IN
5180	545	12	the	the	DT
5180	545	13	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	545	14	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	545	15	software	software	NN
5180	545	16	,	,	,
5180	545	17	and	and	CC
5180	545	18	a	a	DT
5180	545	19	subscription	subscription	NN
5180	545	20	to	to	IN
5180	545	21	the	the	DT
5180	545	22	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	545	23	filter	filter	NN
5180	545	24	costs	cost	VBZ
5180	545	25	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	545	26	Public	Public	NNP
5180	545	27	Library	Library	NNP
5180	545	28	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	545	29	$	$	$
5180	545	30	1,200	1,200	CD
5180	545	31	per	per	IN
5180	545	32	year	year	NN
5180	545	33	.	.	.
5180	546	1	No	no	DT
5180	546	2	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	546	3	was	be	VBD
5180	546	4	presented	present	VBN
5180	546	5	on	on	IN
5180	546	6	the	the	DT
5180	546	7	cost	cost	NN
5180	546	8	of	of	IN
5180	546	9	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	546	10	screens	screen	NNS
5180	546	11	,	,	,
5180	546	12	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	546	13	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	546	14	,	,	,
5180	546	15	and	and	CC
5180	546	16	the	the	DT
5180	546	17	tap	tap	NN
5180	546	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	546	19	on	on	IN
5180	546	20	-	-	HYPH
5180	546	21	the	the	DT
5180	546	22	-	-	HYPH
5180	546	23	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	546	24	policy	policy	NN
5180	546	25	,	,	,
5180	546	26	relative	relative	JJ
5180	546	27	to	to	IN
5180	546	28	the	the	DT
5180	546	29	costs	cost	NNS
5180	546	30	of	of	IN
5180	546	31	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	546	32	software	software	NN
5180	546	33	.	.	.
5180	547	1	Nor	nor	CC
5180	547	2	did	do	VBD
5180	547	3	any	any	DT
5180	547	4	of	of	IN
5180	547	5	the	the	DT
5180	547	6	libraries	library	NNS
5180	547	7	proffered	proffer	VBN
5180	547	8	by	by	IN
5180	547	9	the	the	DT
5180	547	10	government	government	NN
5180	547	11	present	present	VB
5180	547	12	any	any	DT
5180	547	13	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
5180	547	14	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	547	15	on	on	IN
5180	547	16	the	the	DT
5180	547	17	relative	relative	JJ
5180	547	18	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
5180	547	19	of	of	IN
5180	547	20	use	use	NN
5180	547	21	of	of	IN
5180	547	22	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	547	23	screens	screen	NNS
5180	547	24	to	to	TO
5180	547	25	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	547	26	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	547	27	from	from	IN
5180	547	28	being	be	VBG
5180	547	29	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	547	30	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	547	31	to	to	IN
5180	547	32	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	547	33	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	547	34	material	material	NN
5180	547	35	,	,	,
5180	547	36	and	and	CC
5180	547	37	the	the	DT
5180	547	38	use	use	NN
5180	547	39	of	of	IN
5180	547	40	filters	filter	NNS
5180	547	41	,	,	,
5180	547	42	discussed	discuss	VBN
5180	547	43	below	below	RB
5180	547	44	.	.	.
5180	548	1	No	no	DT
5180	548	2	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	548	3	was	be	VBD
5180	548	4	presented	present	VBN
5180	548	5	,	,	,
5180	548	6	for	for	IN
5180	548	7	example	example	NN
5180	548	8	,	,	,
5180	548	9	comparing	compare	VBG
5180	548	10	the	the	DT
5180	548	11	number	number	NN
5180	548	12	of	of	IN
5180	548	13	patron	patron	NN
5180	548	14	complaints	complaint	NNS
5180	548	15	in	in	IN
5180	548	16	those	those	DT
5180	548	17	libraries	library	NNS
5180	548	18	that	that	WDT
5180	548	19	have	have	VBP
5180	548	20	tried	try	VBN
5180	548	21	both	both	DT
5180	548	22	methods	method	NNS
5180	548	23	.	.	.
5180	549	1	The	the	DT
5180	549	2	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	549	3	who	who	WP
5180	549	4	testified	testify	VBD
5180	549	5	at	at	IN
5180	549	6	trial	trial	NN
5180	549	7	whose	whose	WP$
5180	549	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	549	9	use	use	VBP
5180	549	10	Internet	internet	NN
5180	549	11	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	549	12	software	software	NN
5180	549	13	all	all	DT
5180	549	14	provide	provide	VBP
5180	549	15	methods	method	NNS
5180	549	16	by	by	IN
5180	549	17	which	which	WDT
5180	549	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	549	19	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	549	20	may	may	MD
5180	549	21	ask	ask	VB
5180	549	22	the	the	DT
5180	549	23	library	library	NN
5180	549	24	to	to	TO
5180	549	25	unblock	unblock	VB
5180	549	26	specific	specific	JJ
5180	549	27	Web	web	NN
5180	549	28	sites	site	NNS
5180	549	29	or	or	CC
5180	549	30	pages	page	NNS
5180	549	31	.	.	.
5180	550	1	Of	of	IN
5180	550	2	these	these	DT
5180	550	3	,	,	,
5180	550	4	only	only	RB
5180	550	5	the	the	DT
5180	550	6	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	550	7	Public	Public	NNP
5180	550	8	Library	Library	NNP
5180	550	9	allows	allow	VBZ
5180	550	10	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	550	11	to	to	TO
5180	550	12	request	request	VB
5180	550	13	that	that	IN
5180	550	14	a	a	DT
5180	550	15	URL	url	NN
5180	550	16	be	be	VB
5180	550	17	unblocked	unblocked	JJ
5180	550	18	without	without	IN
5180	550	19	providing	provide	VBG
5180	550	20	any	any	DT
5180	550	21	identifying	identify	VBG
5180	550	22	information	information	NN
5180	550	23	;	;	:
5180	550	24	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	550	25	allows	allow	VBZ
5180	550	26	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	550	27	to	to	TO
5180	550	28	request	request	VB
5180	550	29	a	a	DT
5180	550	30	URL	url	NN
5180	550	31	by	by	IN
5180	550	32	sending	send	VBG
5180	550	33	an	an	DT
5180	550	34	email	email	NN
5180	550	35	from	from	IN
5180	550	36	the	the	DT
5180	550	37	Internet	internet	NN
5180	550	38	terminal	terminal	NN
5180	550	39	that	that	IN
5180	550	40	the	the	DT
5180	550	41	patron	patron	NN
5180	550	42	is	be	VBZ
5180	550	43	using	use	VBG
5180	550	44	that	that	WDT
5180	550	45	does	do	VBZ
5180	550	46	not	not	RB
5180	550	47	contain	contain	VB
5180	550	48	a	a	DT
5180	550	49	return	return	NN
5180	550	50	email	email	NN
5180	550	51	address	address	NN
5180	550	52	for	for	IN
5180	550	53	the	the	DT
5180	550	54	user	user	NN
5180	550	55	.	.	.
5180	551	1	David	David	NNP
5180	551	2	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	551	3	,	,	,
5180	551	4	the	the	DT
5180	551	5	head	head	NN
5180	551	6	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	551	7	at	at	IN
5180	551	8	the	the	DT
5180	551	9	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	551	10	Library	Library	NNP
5180	551	11	's	's	POS
5180	551	12	main	main	JJ
5180	551	13	branch	branch	NN
5180	551	14	,	,	,
5180	551	15	testified	testify	VBD
5180	551	16	at	at	IN
5180	551	17	trial	trial	NN
5180	551	18	that	that	IN
5180	551	19	the	the	DT
5180	551	20	library	library	NN
5180	551	21	keeps	keep	VBZ
5180	551	22	records	record	NNS
5180	551	23	that	that	WDT
5180	551	24	would	would	MD
5180	551	25	enable	enable	VB
5180	551	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	551	27	to	to	TO
5180	551	28	know	know	VB
5180	551	29	which	which	WDT
5180	551	30	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	551	31	made	make	VBD
5180	551	32	unblocking	unblock	VBG
5180	551	33	requests	request	NNS
5180	551	34	,	,	,
5180	551	35	but	but	CC
5180	551	36	does	do	VBZ
5180	551	37	not	not	RB
5180	551	38	use	use	VB
5180	551	39	that	that	DT
5180	551	40	information	information	NN
5180	551	41	to	to	TO
5180	551	42	connect	connect	VB
5180	551	43	users	user	NNS
5180	551	44	with	with	IN
5180	551	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	551	46	requests	request	NNS
5180	551	47	.	.	.
5180	552	1	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	552	2	also	also	RB
5180	552	3	testified	testify	VBD
5180	552	4	that	that	IN
5180	552	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	552	6	periodically	periodically	RB
5180	552	7	scans	scan	VBZ
5180	552	8	the	the	DT
5180	552	9	library	library	NN
5180	552	10	's	's	POS
5180	552	11	Internet	internet	NN
5180	552	12	use	use	NN
5180	552	13	logs	log	NNS
5180	552	14	to	to	TO
5180	552	15	search	search	VB
5180	552	16	for	for	IN
5180	552	17	:	:	:
5180	552	18	(	(	-LRB-
5180	552	19	1	1	LS
5180	552	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	552	21	URLs	url	NNS
5180	552	22	that	that	WDT
5180	552	23	were	be	VBD
5180	552	24	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	552	25	blocked	block	VBN
5180	552	26	,	,	,
5180	552	27	so	so	IN
5180	552	28	that	that	IN
5180	552	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	552	30	may	may	MD
5180	552	31	unblock	unblock	VB
5180	552	32	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	552	33	;	;	:
5180	552	34	or	or	CC
5180	552	35	(	(	-LRB-
5180	552	36	2	2	LS
5180	552	37	)	)	-RRB-
5180	552	38	URLs	url	NNS
5180	552	39	that	that	WDT
5180	552	40	should	should	MD
5180	552	41	have	have	VB
5180	552	42	been	be	VBN
5180	552	43	blocked	block	VBN
5180	552	44	,	,	,
5180	552	45	but	but	CC
5180	552	46	were	be	VBD
5180	552	47	not	not	RB
5180	552	48	,	,	,
5180	552	49	in	in	IN
5180	552	50	order	order	NN
5180	552	51	to	to	TO
5180	552	52	add	add	VB
5180	552	53	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	552	54	to	to	IN
5180	552	55	a	a	DT
5180	552	56	blocked	block	VBN
5180	552	57	category	category	NN
5180	552	58	list	list	NN
5180	552	59	.	.	.
5180	553	1	In	in	IN
5180	553	2	the	the	DT
5180	553	3	course	course	NN
5180	553	4	of	of	IN
5180	553	5	scanning	scan	VBG
5180	553	6	the	the	DT
5180	553	7	use	use	NN
5180	553	8	logs	log	VBZ
5180	553	9	,	,	,
5180	553	10	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	553	11	has	have	VBZ
5180	553	12	also	also	RB
5180	553	13	found	find	VBN
5180	553	14	what	what	WP
5180	553	15	looked	look	VBD
5180	553	16	like	like	IN
5180	553	17	attempts	attempt	NNS
5180	553	18	to	to	TO
5180	553	19	access	access	VB
5180	553	20	child	child	NN
5180	553	21	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	553	22	.	.	.
5180	554	1	In	in	IN
5180	554	2	two	two	CD
5180	554	3	cases	case	NNS
5180	554	4	,	,	,
5180	554	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	554	6	communicated	communicate	VBD
5180	554	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	554	8	findings	finding	NNS
5180	554	9	to	to	IN
5180	554	10	law	law	NN
5180	554	11	enforcement	enforcement	NN
5180	554	12	and	and	CC
5180	554	13	turned	turn	VBD
5180	554	14	over	over	RP
5180	554	15	the	the	DT
5180	554	16	logs	log	NNS
5180	554	17	in	in	IN
5180	554	18	response	response	NN
5180	554	19	to	to	IN
5180	554	20	a	a	DT
5180	554	21	subpoena	subpoena	NN
5180	554	22	.	.	.
5180	555	1	At	at	IN
5180	555	2	all	all	DT
5180	555	3	events	event	NNS
5180	555	4	,	,	,
5180	555	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	555	6	takes	take	VBZ
5180	555	7	time	time	NN
5180	555	8	for	for	IN
5180	555	9	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	555	10	to	to	TO
5180	555	11	make	make	VB
5180	555	12	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	555	13	about	about	IN
5180	555	14	whether	whether	IN
5180	555	15	to	to	TO
5180	555	16	honor	honor	VB
5180	555	17	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	555	18	'	'	POS
5180	555	19	requests	request	NNS
5180	555	20	to	to	IN
5180	555	21	unblock	unblock	VB
5180	555	22	Web	web	NN
5180	555	23	pages	page	NNS
5180	555	24	.	.	.
5180	556	1	In	in	IN
5180	556	2	the	the	DT
5180	556	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	556	4	proffered	proffer	VBN
5180	556	5	by	by	IN
5180	556	6	the	the	DT
5180	556	7	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	556	8	,	,	,
5180	556	9	unblocking	unblock	VBG
5180	556	10	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	556	11	sometimes	sometimes	RB
5180	556	12	take	take	VBP
5180	556	13	between	between	IN
5180	556	14	24	24	CD
5180	556	15	hours	hour	NNS
5180	556	16	and	and	CC
5180	556	17	a	a	DT
5180	556	18	week	week	NN
5180	556	19	.	.	.
5180	557	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	557	2	,	,	,
5180	557	3	none	none	NN
5180	557	4	of	of	IN
5180	557	5	these	these	DT
5180	557	6	libraries	library	NNS
5180	557	7	allows	allow	VBZ
5180	557	8	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
5180	557	9	access	access	NN
5180	557	10	to	to	IN
5180	557	11	the	the	DT
5180	557	12	Internet	internet	NN
5180	557	13	pending	pende	VBG
5180	557	14	a	a	DT
5180	557	15	determination	determination	NN
5180	557	16	of	of	IN
5180	557	17	the	the	DT
5180	557	18	validity	validity	NN
5180	557	19	of	of	IN
5180	557	20	a	a	DT
5180	557	21	Web	web	NN
5180	557	22	site	site	NN
5180	557	23	blocked	block	VBN
5180	557	24	by	by	IN
5180	557	25	the	the	DT
5180	557	26	blocking	block	VBG
5180	557	27	programs	program	NNS
5180	557	28	.	.	.
5180	558	1	A	a	DT
5180	558	2	few	few	JJ
5180	558	3	of	of	IN
5180	558	4	the	the	DT
5180	558	5	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	558	6	'	'	POS
5180	558	7	proffered	proffer	VBN
5180	558	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	558	9	represented	represent	VBD
5180	558	10	that	that	IN
5180	558	11	individual	individual	JJ
5180	558	12	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	558	13	would	would	MD
5180	558	14	have	have	VB
5180	558	15	the	the	DT
5180	558	16	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	558	17	to	to	TO
5180	558	18	allow	allow	VB
5180	558	19	a	a	DT
5180	558	20	patron	patron	NN
5180	558	21	to	to	TO
5180	558	22	have	have	VB
5180	558	23	full	full	JJ
5180	558	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	558	25	access	access	NN
5180	558	26	on	on	IN
5180	558	27	a	a	DT
5180	558	28	staff	staff	NN
5180	558	29	computer	computer	NN
5180	558	30	upon	upon	IN
5180	558	31	request	request	NN
5180	558	32	,	,	,
5180	558	33	but	but	CC
5180	558	34	none	none	NN
5180	558	35	claimed	claim	VBD
5180	558	36	that	that	IN
5180	558	37	allowing	allow	VBG
5180	558	38	such	such	JJ
5180	558	39	access	access	NN
5180	558	40	was	be	VBD
5180	558	41	mandatory	mandatory	JJ
5180	558	42	,	,	,
5180	558	43	and	and	CC
5180	558	44	patron	patron	NN
5180	558	45	access	access	NN
5180	558	46	is	be	VBZ
5180	558	47	supervised	supervise	VBN
5180	558	48	in	in	IN
5180	558	49	every	every	DT
5180	558	50	instance	instance	NN
5180	558	51	.	.	.
5180	559	1	None	none	NN
5180	559	2	of	of	IN
5180	559	3	these	these	DT
5180	559	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	559	5	makes	make	VBZ
5180	559	6	differential	differential	NN
5180	559	7	unblocking	unblocking	NN
5180	559	8	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	559	9	based	base	VBN
5180	559	10	on	on	IN
5180	559	11	the	the	DT
5180	559	12	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	559	13	'	'	POS
5180	559	14	age	age	NN
5180	559	15	.	.	.
5180	560	1	Unblocking	unblock	VBG
5180	560	2	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	560	3	are	be	VBP
5180	560	4	usually	usually	RB
5180	560	5	made	make	VBN
5180	560	6	identically	identically	RB
5180	560	7	for	for	IN
5180	560	8	adults	adult	NNS
5180	560	9	and	and	CC
5180	560	10	minors	minor	NNS
5180	560	11	.	.	.
5180	561	1	Unblocking	unblock	VBG
5180	561	2	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	561	3	even	even	RB
5180	561	4	for	for	IN
5180	561	5	adults	adult	NNS
5180	561	6	are	be	VBP
5180	561	7	usually	usually	RB
5180	561	8	based	base	VBN
5180	561	9	on	on	IN
5180	561	10	suitability	suitability	NN
5180	561	11	of	of	IN
5180	561	12	the	the	DT
5180	561	13	Web	web	NN
5180	561	14	site	site	NN
5180	561	15	for	for	IN
5180	561	16	minors	minor	NNS
5180	561	17	.	.	.
5180	562	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	562	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	562	3	apparent	apparent	JJ
5180	562	4	that	that	IN
5180	562	5	many	many	JJ
5180	562	6	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	562	7	are	be	VBP
5180	562	8	reluctant	reluctant	JJ
5180	562	9	or	or	CC
5180	562	10	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	562	11	to	to	TO
5180	562	12	ask	ask	VB
5180	562	13	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	562	14	to	to	TO
5180	562	15	unblock	unblock	VB
5180	562	16	Web	web	NN
5180	562	17	pages	page	NNS
5180	562	18	or	or	CC
5180	562	19	sites	site	NNS
5180	562	20	that	that	WDT
5180	562	21	contain	contain	VBP
5180	562	22	only	only	RB
5180	562	23	materials	material	NNS
5180	562	24	that	that	WDT
5180	562	25	might	may	MD
5180	562	26	be	be	VB
5180	562	27	deemed	deem	VBN
5180	562	28	personal	personal	JJ
5180	562	29	or	or	CC
5180	562	30	embarrassing	embarrassing	JJ
5180	562	31	,	,	,
5180	562	32	even	even	RB
5180	562	33	if	if	IN
5180	562	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	562	35	are	be	VBP
5180	562	36	not	not	RB
5180	562	37	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	562	38	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	562	39	or	or	CC
5180	562	40	pornographic	pornographic	JJ
5180	562	41	.	.	.
5180	563	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	563	2	credit	credit	VBP
5180	563	3	the	the	DT
5180	563	4	testimony	testimony	NN
5180	563	5	of	of	IN
5180	563	6	Emmalyn	Emmalyn	NNP
5180	563	7	Rood	Rood	NNP
5180	563	8	,	,	,
5180	563	9	discussed	discuss	VBN
5180	563	10	above	above	RB
5180	563	11	,	,	,
5180	563	12	that	that	IN
5180	563	13	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	563	14	would	would	MD
5180	563	15	have	have	VB
5180	563	16	been	be	VBN
5180	563	17	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	563	18	as	as	IN
5180	563	19	a	a	DT
5180	563	20	young	young	JJ
5180	563	21	teen	teen	NN
5180	563	22	to	to	TO
5180	563	23	ask	ask	VB
5180	563	24	a	a	DT
5180	563	25	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	563	26	to	to	TO
5180	563	27	disable	disable	VB
5180	563	28	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	563	29	software	software	NN
5180	563	30	so	so	IN
5180	563	31	that	that	IN
5180	563	32	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	563	33	could	could	MD
5180	563	34	view	view	VB
5180	563	35	materials	material	NNS
5180	563	36	concerning	concern	VBG
5180	563	37	gay	gay	NN
5180	563	38	and	and	CC
5180	563	39	lesbian	lesbian	JJ
5180	563	40	issues	issue	NNS
5180	563	41	.	.	.
5180	564	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	564	2	also	also	RB
5180	564	3	credit	credit	VBP
5180	564	4	the	the	DT
5180	564	5	testimony	testimony	NN
5180	564	6	of	of	IN
5180	564	7	Mark	Mark	NNP
5180	564	8	Brown	Brown	NNP
5180	564	9	,	,	,
5180	564	10	who	who	WP
5180	564	11	stated	state	VBD
5180	564	12	that	that	IN
5180	564	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	564	14	would	would	MD
5180	564	15	have	have	VB
5180	564	16	been	be	VBN
5180	564	17	too	too	RB
5180	564	18	embarrassed	embarrassed	JJ
5180	564	19	to	to	TO
5180	564	20	ask	ask	VB
5180	564	21	a	a	DT
5180	564	22	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	564	23	to	to	TO
5180	564	24	disable	disable	VB
5180	564	25	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	564	26	software	software	NN
5180	564	27	if	if	IN
5180	564	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	564	29	had	have	VBD
5180	564	30	impeded	impede	VBN
5180	564	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	564	32	ability	ability	NN
5180	564	33	to	to	TO
5180	564	34	research	research	VB
5180	564	35	treatments	treatment	NNS
5180	564	36	and	and	CC
5180	564	37	cosmetic	cosmetic	JJ
5180	564	38	surgery	surgery	NN
5180	564	39	options	option	NNS
5180	564	40	for	for	IN
5180	564	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	564	42	mother	mother	NN
5180	564	43	when	when	WRB
5180	564	44	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	564	45	was	be	VBD
5180	564	46	diagnosed	diagnose	VBN
5180	564	47	with	with	IN
5180	564	48	breast	breast	NN
5180	564	49	cancer	cancer	NN
5180	564	50	.	.	.
5180	565	1	The	the	DT
5180	565	2	pattern	pattern	NN
5180	565	3	of	of	IN
5180	565	4	patron	patron	NN
5180	565	5	requests	request	NNS
5180	565	6	to	to	TO
5180	565	7	unblock	unblock	VB
5180	565	8	specific	specific	JJ
5180	565	9	URLs	url	NNS
5180	565	10	in	in	IN
5180	565	11	the	the	DT
5180	565	12	various	various	JJ
5180	565	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	565	14	involved	involve	VBN
5180	565	15	in	in	IN
5180	565	16	this	this	DT
5180	565	17	case	case	NN
5180	565	18	also	also	RB
5180	565	19	confirms	confirm	VBZ
5180	565	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	565	21	finding	finding	NN
5180	565	22	that	that	IN
5180	565	23	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	565	24	are	be	VBP
5180	565	25	largely	largely	RB
5180	565	26	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	565	27	to	to	TO
5180	565	28	make	make	VB
5180	565	29	unblocking	unblocking	JJ
5180	565	30	requests	request	NNS
5180	565	31	unless	unless	IN
5180	565	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	565	33	are	be	VBP
5180	565	34	permitted	permit	VBN
5180	565	35	to	to	TO
5180	565	36	do	do	VB
5180	565	37	so	so	RB
5180	565	38	anonymously	anonymously	RB
5180	565	39	.	.	.
5180	566	1	For	for	IN
5180	566	2	example	example	NN
5180	566	3	,	,	,
5180	566	4	the	the	DT
5180	566	5	Fulton	Fulton	NNP
5180	566	6	County	County	NNP
5180	566	7	Library	Library	NNP
5180	566	8	receives	receive	VBZ
5180	566	9	only	only	RB
5180	566	10	about	about	RB
5180	566	11	6	6	CD
5180	566	12	unblocking	unblock	VBG
5180	566	13	requests	request	NNS
5180	566	14	each	each	DT
5180	566	15	year	year	NN
5180	566	16	,	,	,
5180	566	17	the	the	DT
5180	566	18	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	566	19	Public	Public	NNP
5180	566	20	Library	Library	NNP
5180	566	21	has	have	VBZ
5180	566	22	received	receive	VBN
5180	566	23	only	only	RB
5180	566	24	28	28	CD
5180	566	25	unblocking	unblocking	NN
5180	566	26	requests	request	NNS
5180	566	27	since	since	IN
5180	566	28	August	August	NNP
5180	566	29	21	21	CD
5180	566	30	,	,	,
5180	566	31	2000	2000	CD
5180	566	32	,	,	,
5180	566	33	and	and	CC
5180	566	34	the	the	DT
5180	566	35	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	566	36	,	,	,
5180	566	37	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
5180	566	38	Library	Library	NNP
5180	566	39	has	have	VBZ
5180	566	40	received	receive	VBN
5180	566	41	fewer	few	JJR
5180	566	42	than	than	IN
5180	566	43	10	10	CD
5180	566	44	unblocking	unblocking	NN
5180	566	45	requests	request	NNS
5180	566	46	since	since	IN
5180	566	47	1999	1999	CD
5180	566	48	.	.	.
5180	567	1	In	in	IN
5180	567	2	light	light	NN
5180	567	3	of	of	IN
5180	567	4	the	the	DT
5180	567	5	fact	fact	NN
5180	567	6	that	that	IN
5180	567	7	a	a	DT
5180	567	8	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	567	9	amount	amount	NN
5180	567	10	of	of	IN
5180	567	11	overblocking	overblocking	NN
5180	567	12	occurs	occur	VBZ
5180	567	13	in	in	IN
5180	567	14	these	these	DT
5180	567	15	very	very	JJ
5180	567	16	libraries	library	NNS
5180	567	17	,	,	,
5180	567	18	see	see	VB
5180	567	19	infra	infra	NNP
5180	567	20	Subsection	Subsection	NNP
5180	567	21	II.E.4	II.E.4	NNP
5180	567	22	,	,	,
5180	567	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	567	24	find	find	VBP
5180	567	25	that	that	IN
5180	567	26	the	the	DT
5180	567	27	lack	lack	NN
5180	567	28	of	of	IN
5180	567	29	unblocking	unblock	VBG
5180	567	30	requests	request	NNS
5180	567	31	in	in	IN
5180	567	32	these	these	DT
5180	567	33	libraries	library	NNS
5180	567	34	does	do	VBZ
5180	567	35	not	not	RB
5180	567	36	reflect	reflect	VB
5180	567	37	the	the	DT
5180	567	38	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
5180	567	39	of	of	IN
5180	567	40	the	the	DT
5180	567	41	filters	filter	NNS
5180	567	42	,	,	,
5180	567	43	but	but	CC
5180	567	44	rather	rather	RB
5180	567	45	reflects	reflect	VBZ
5180	567	46	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	567	47	'	'	POS
5180	567	48	reluctance	reluctance	NN
5180	567	49	to	to	TO
5180	567	50	ask	ask	VB
5180	567	51	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	567	52	to	to	IN
5180	567	53	unblock	unblock	VB
5180	567	54	sites	site	NNS
5180	567	55	.	.	.
5180	568	1	5	5	CD
5180	568	2	.	.	.
5180	569	1	Internet	internet	NN
5180	569	2	Filtering	Filtering	NNP
5180	569	3	Technology	Technology	NNP
5180	569	4	1	1	CD
5180	569	5	.	.	.
5180	570	1	What	what	WP
5180	570	2	Is	be	VBZ
5180	570	3	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	570	4	Software	software	NN
5180	570	5	,	,	,
5180	570	6	Who	who	WP
5180	570	7	Makes	make	VBZ
5180	570	8	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	570	9	,	,	,
5180	570	10	and	and	CC
5180	570	11	What	what	WP
5180	570	12	Does	do	VBZ
5180	570	13	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	570	14	Do	do	VB
5180	570	15	?	?	.
5180	571	1	Commercially	commercially	RB
5180	571	2	available	available	JJ
5180	571	3	products	product	NNS
5180	571	4	that	that	WDT
5180	571	5	can	can	MD
5180	571	6	be	be	VB
5180	571	7	configured	configure	VBN
5180	571	8	to	to	TO
5180	571	9	block	block	VB
5180	571	10	or	or	CC
5180	571	11	filter	filter	VB
5180	571	12	access	access	NN
5180	571	13	to	to	IN
5180	571	14	certain	certain	JJ
5180	571	15	material	material	NN
5180	571	16	on	on	IN
5180	571	17	the	the	DT
5180	571	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	571	19	are	be	VBP
5180	571	20	among	among	IN
5180	571	21	the	the	DT
5180	571	22	"	"	``
5180	571	23	technology	technology	NN
5180	571	24	protection	protection	NN
5180	571	25	measures	measure	NNS
5180	571	26	"	"	''
5180	571	27	that	that	WDT
5180	571	28	may	may	MD
5180	571	29	be	be	VB
5180	571	30	used	use	VBN
5180	571	31	to	to	TO
5180	571	32	attempt	attempt	VB
5180	571	33	to	to	TO
5180	571	34	comply	comply	VB
5180	571	35	with	with	IN
5180	571	36	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	571	37	.	.	.
5180	572	1	There	there	EX
5180	572	2	are	be	VBP
5180	572	3	numerous	numerous	JJ
5180	572	4	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	572	5	software	software	NN
5180	572	6	products	product	NNS
5180	572	7	available	available	JJ
5180	572	8	commercially	commercially	RB
5180	572	9	.	.	.
5180	573	1	Three	three	CD
5180	573	2	network	network	NN
5180	573	3	-	-	HYPH
5180	573	4	based	base	VBN
5180	573	5	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	573	6	products	product	NNS
5180	573	7	–	–	:
5180	573	8	SurfControl	SurfControl	NNP
5180	573	9	's	's	POS
5180	573	10	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	573	11	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	573	12	,	,	,
5180	573	13	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	573	14	's	's	POS
5180	573	15	Bess	Bess	NNP
5180	573	16	/	/	SYM
5180	573	17	i2100	i2100	NNP
5180	573	18	,	,	,
5180	573	19	and	and	CC
5180	573	20	Secure	Secure	NNP
5180	573	21	Computing	Computing	NNP
5180	573	22	's	's	POS
5180	573	23	SmartFilter	SmartFilter	NNP
5180	573	24	–	–	:
5180	573	25	currently	currently	RB
5180	573	26	have	have	VBP
5180	573	27	the	the	DT
5180	573	28	lion	lion	NN
5180	573	29	's	's	POS
5180	573	30	share	share	NN
5180	573	31	of	of	IN
5180	573	32	the	the	DT
5180	573	33	public	public	JJ
5180	573	34	library	library	NN
5180	573	35	market	market	NN
5180	573	36	.	.	.
5180	574	1	The	the	DT
5180	574	2	parties	party	NNS
5180	574	3	in	in	IN
5180	574	4	this	this	DT
5180	574	5	case	case	NN
5180	574	6	deposed	depose	VBD
5180	574	7	representatives	representative	NNS
5180	574	8	from	from	IN
5180	574	9	these	these	DT
5180	574	10	three	three	CD
5180	574	11	companies	company	NNS
5180	574	12	.	.	.
5180	575	1	Websense	websense	NN
5180	575	2	,	,	,
5180	575	3	another	another	DT
5180	575	4	network	network	NN
5180	575	5	-	-	HYPH
5180	575	6	based	base	VBN
5180	575	7	blocking	block	VBG
5180	575	8	product	product	NN
5180	575	9	,	,	,
5180	575	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	575	11	also	also	RB
5180	575	12	currently	currently	RB
5180	575	13	used	use	VBN
5180	575	14	in	in	IN
5180	575	15	the	the	DT
5180	575	16	public	public	JJ
5180	575	17	library	library	NN
5180	575	18	market	market	NN
5180	575	19	,	,	,
5180	575	20	and	and	CC
5180	575	21	was	be	VBD
5180	575	22	discussed	discuss	VBN
5180	575	23	at	at	IN
5180	575	24	trial	trial	NN
5180	575	25	.	.	.
5180	576	1	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	576	2	software	software	NN
5180	576	3	may	may	MD
5180	576	4	be	be	VB
5180	576	5	installed	instal	VBN
5180	576	6	either	either	CC
5180	576	7	on	on	IN
5180	576	8	an	an	DT
5180	576	9	individual	individual	JJ
5180	576	10	computer	computer	NN
5180	576	11	or	or	CC
5180	576	12	on	on	IN
5180	576	13	a	a	DT
5180	576	14	computer	computer	NN
5180	576	15	network	network	NN
5180	576	16	.	.	.
5180	577	1	Network	network	NN
5180	577	2	-	-	HYPH
5180	577	3	based	base	VBN
5180	577	4	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	577	5	software	software	NN
5180	577	6	products	product	NNS
5180	577	7	are	be	VBP
5180	577	8	designed	design	VBN
5180	577	9	for	for	IN
5180	577	10	use	use	NN
5180	577	11	on	on	IN
5180	577	12	a	a	DT
5180	577	13	network	network	NN
5180	577	14	of	of	IN
5180	577	15	computers	computer	NNS
5180	577	16	and	and	CC
5180	577	17	funnel	funnel	NN
5180	577	18	requests	request	NNS
5180	577	19	for	for	IN
5180	577	20	Internet	internet	NN
5180	577	21	content	content	NN
5180	577	22	through	through	IN
5180	577	23	a	a	DT
5180	577	24	centralized	centralized	JJ
5180	577	25	network	network	NN
5180	577	26	device	device	NN
5180	577	27	.	.	.
5180	578	1	Of	of	IN
5180	578	2	the	the	DT
5180	578	3	various	various	JJ
5180	578	4	commercially	commercially	RB
5180	578	5	available	available	JJ
5180	578	6	blocking	blocking	NN
5180	578	7	products	product	NNS
5180	578	8	,	,	,
5180	578	9	network	network	NN
5180	578	10	-	-	HYPH
5180	578	11	based	base	VBN
5180	578	12	products	product	NNS
5180	578	13	are	be	VBP
5180	578	14	the	the	DT
5180	578	15	ones	one	NNS
5180	578	16	generally	generally	RB
5180	578	17	marketed	market	VBN
5180	578	18	to	to	IN
5180	578	19	institutions	institution	NNS
5180	578	20	,	,	,
5180	578	21	such	such	JJ
5180	578	22	as	as	IN
5180	578	23	public	public	JJ
5180	578	24	libraries	library	NNS
5180	578	25	,	,	,
5180	578	26	that	that	WDT
5180	578	27	provide	provide	VBP
5180	578	28	Internet	internet	NN
5180	578	29	access	access	NN
5180	578	30	through	through	IN
5180	578	31	multiple	multiple	JJ
5180	578	32	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	578	33	.	.	.
5180	579	1	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	579	2	programs	program	NNS
5180	579	3	function	function	VBP
5180	579	4	in	in	IN
5180	579	5	a	a	DT
5180	579	6	fairly	fairly	RB
5180	579	7	simple	simple	JJ
5180	579	8	way	way	NN
5180	579	9	.	.	.
5180	580	1	When	when	WRB
5180	580	2	an	an	DT
5180	580	3	Internet	internet	NN
5180	580	4	user	user	NN
5180	580	5	requests	request	NNS
5180	580	6	access	access	NN
5180	580	7	to	to	IN
5180	580	8	a	a	DT
5180	580	9	certain	certain	JJ
5180	580	10	Web	web	NN
5180	580	11	site	site	NN
5180	580	12	or	or	CC
5180	580	13	page	page	NN
5180	580	14	,	,	,
5180	580	15	either	either	CC
5180	580	16	by	by	IN
5180	580	17	entering	enter	VBG
5180	580	18	a	a	DT
5180	580	19	domain	domain	NN
5180	580	20	name	name	NN
5180	580	21	or	or	CC
5180	580	22	IP	IP	NNP
5180	580	23	address	address	NN
5180	580	24	into	into	IN
5180	580	25	a	a	DT
5180	580	26	Web	web	NN
5180	580	27	browser	browser	NN
5180	580	28	,	,	,
5180	580	29	or	or	CC
5180	580	30	by	by	IN
5180	580	31	clicking	click	VBG
5180	580	32	on	on	IN
5180	580	33	a	a	DT
5180	580	34	link	link	NN
5180	580	35	,	,	,
5180	580	36	the	the	DT
5180	580	37	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	580	38	software	software	NN
5180	580	39	checks	check	NNS
5180	580	40	that	that	WDT
5180	580	41	domain	domain	VBP
5180	580	42	name	name	NN
5180	580	43	or	or	CC
5180	580	44	IP	IP	NNP
5180	580	45	address	address	NN
5180	580	46	against	against	IN
5180	580	47	a	a	DT
5180	580	48	previously	previously	RB
5180	580	49	compiled	compile	VBN
5180	580	50	"	"	``
5180	580	51	control	control	NN
5180	580	52	list	list	NN
5180	580	53	"	"	''
5180	580	54	that	that	WDT
5180	580	55	may	may	MD
5180	580	56	contain	contain	VB
5180	580	57	up	up	RP
5180	580	58	to	to	IN
5180	580	59	hundreds	hundred	NNS
5180	580	60	of	of	IN
5180	580	61	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	580	62	of	of	IN
5180	580	63	URLs	url	NNS
5180	580	64	.	.	.
5180	581	1	The	the	DT
5180	581	2	three	three	CD
5180	581	3	companies	company	NNS
5180	581	4	deposed	depose	VBN
5180	581	5	in	in	IN
5180	581	6	this	this	DT
5180	581	7	case	case	NN
5180	581	8	have	have	VBP
5180	581	9	control	control	NN
5180	581	10	lists	list	NNS
5180	581	11	containing	contain	VBG
5180	581	12	between	between	IN
5180	581	13	200,000	200,000	CD
5180	581	14	and	and	CC
5180	581	15	600,000	600,000	CD
5180	581	16	URLs	url	NNS
5180	581	17	.	.	.
5180	582	1	These	these	DT
5180	582	2	lists	list	NNS
5180	582	3	determine	determine	VBP
5180	582	4	which	which	WDT
5180	582	5	URLs	URLs	NNP
5180	582	6	will	will	MD
5180	582	7	be	be	VB
5180	582	8	blocked	block	VBN
5180	582	9	.	.	.
5180	583	1	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	583	2	software	software	NN
5180	583	3	companies	company	NNS
5180	583	4	divide	divide	VBP
5180	583	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	583	6	control	control	NN
5180	583	7	lists	list	NNS
5180	583	8	into	into	IN
5180	583	9	multiple	multiple	JJ
5180	583	10	categories	category	NNS
5180	583	11	for	for	IN
5180	583	12	which	which	WDT
5180	583	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	583	14	have	have	VBP
5180	583	15	created	create	VBN
5180	583	16	unique	unique	JJ
5180	583	17	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	583	18	.	.	.
5180	584	1	SurfControl	SurfControl	NNP
5180	584	2	uses	use	VBZ
5180	584	3	40	40	CD
5180	584	4	such	such	JJ
5180	584	5	categories	category	NNS
5180	584	6	,	,	,
5180	584	7	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	584	8	uses	use	VBZ
5180	584	9	35	35	CD
5180	584	10	categories	category	NNS
5180	584	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	584	12	and	and	CC
5180	584	13	seven	seven	CD
5180	584	14	"	"	``
5180	584	15	exception	exception	NN
5180	584	16	"	"	''
5180	584	17	categories	category	NNS
5180	584	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	584	19	,	,	,
5180	584	20	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	584	21	uses	use	VBZ
5180	584	22	30	30	CD
5180	584	23	categories	category	NNS
5180	584	24	,	,	,
5180	584	25	and	and	CC
5180	584	26	Secure	Secure	NNP
5180	584	27	Computing	Computing	NNP
5180	584	28	uses	use	VBZ
5180	584	29	30	30	CD
5180	584	30	categories	category	NNS
5180	584	31	.	.	.
5180	585	1	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	585	2	software	software	NN
5180	585	3	customers	customer	NNS
5180	585	4	choose	choose	VB
5180	585	5	which	which	WDT
5180	585	6	categories	category	NNS
5180	585	7	of	of	IN
5180	585	8	URLs	url	NNS
5180	585	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	585	10	wish	wish	VBP
5180	585	11	to	to	TO
5180	585	12	enable	enable	VB
5180	585	13	.	.	.
5180	586	1	A	a	DT
5180	586	2	user	user	NN
5180	586	3	"	"	``
5180	586	4	enables	enable	VBZ
5180	586	5	"	"	''
5180	586	6	a	a	DT
5180	586	7	category	category	NN
5180	586	8	in	in	IN
5180	586	9	a	a	DT
5180	586	10	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	586	11	program	program	NN
5180	586	12	by	by	IN
5180	586	13	configuring	configure	VBG
5180	586	14	the	the	DT
5180	586	15	program	program	NN
5180	586	16	to	to	TO
5180	586	17	block	block	VB
5180	586	18	all	all	DT
5180	586	19	of	of	IN
5180	586	20	the	the	DT
5180	586	21	Web	web	NN
5180	586	22	pages	page	NNS
5180	586	23	listed	list	VBN
5180	586	24	in	in	IN
5180	586	25	that	that	DT
5180	586	26	category	category	NN
5180	586	27	.	.	.
5180	587	1	The	the	DT
5180	587	2	following	follow	VBG
5180	587	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	587	4	a	a	DT
5180	587	5	list	list	NN
5180	587	6	of	of	IN
5180	587	7	the	the	DT
5180	587	8	categories	category	NNS
5180	587	9	offered	offer	VBN
5180	587	10	by	by	IN
5180	587	11	each	each	DT
5180	587	12	of	of	IN
5180	587	13	these	these	DT
5180	587	14	four	four	CD
5180	587	15	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	587	16	programs	program	NNS
5180	587	17	.	.	.
5180	588	1	SurfControl	SurfControl	NNP
5180	588	2	's	's	POS
5180	588	3	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	588	4	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	588	5	offers	offer	VBZ
5180	588	6	the	the	DT
5180	588	7	following	follow	VBG
5180	588	8	categories	category	NNS
5180	588	9	:	:	:
5180	588	10	Adult	adult	NN
5180	588	11	/	/	SYM
5180	588	12	Sexually	sexually	RB
5180	588	13	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	588	14	;	;	,
5180	588	15	Advertisements	advertisement	NNS
5180	588	16	;	;	:
5180	588	17	Arts	Arts	NNP
5180	588	18	&	&	CC
5180	588	19	Entertainment	Entertainment	NNP
5180	588	20	;	;	:
5180	588	21	Chat	Chat	NNP
5180	588	22	;	;	:
5180	588	23	Computing	Computing	NNP
5180	588	24	&	&	CC
5180	588	25	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	588	26	;	;	:
5180	588	27	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
5180	588	28	Skills	Skills	NNPS
5180	588	29	;	;	:
5180	588	30	Drugs	Drugs	NNP
5180	588	31	,	,	,
5180	588	32	Alcohol	Alcohol	NNP
5180	588	33	&	&	CC
5180	588	34	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
5180	588	35	;	;	:
5180	588	36	Education	Education	NNP
5180	588	37	;	;	:
5180	588	38	Finance	Finance	NNP
5180	588	39	&	&	CC
5180	588	40	Investment	Investment	NNP
5180	588	41	;	;	:
5180	588	42	Food	Food	NNP
5180	588	43	&	&	CC
5180	588	44	Drink	Drink	NNP
5180	588	45	;	;	:
5180	588	46	Gambling	gambling	NN
5180	588	47	;	;	:
5180	588	48	Games	Games	NNPS
5180	588	49	;	;	:
5180	588	50	Glamour	Glamour	NNP
5180	588	51	&	&	CC
5180	588	52	Intimate	Intimate	NNP
5180	588	53	Apparel	Apparel	NNP
5180	588	54	;	;	:
5180	588	55	Government	Government	NNP
5180	588	56	&	&	CC
5180	588	57	Politics	Politics	NNPS
5180	588	58	;	;	:
5180	588	59	Hacking	Hacking	NNP
5180	588	60	;	;	:
5180	588	61	Hate	Hate	NNP
5180	588	62	Speech	Speech	NNP
5180	588	63	;	;	:
5180	588	64	Health	Health	NNP
5180	588	65	&	&	CC
5180	588	66	Medicine	Medicine	NNP
5180	588	67	;	;	:
5180	588	68	Hobbies	Hobbies	NNP
5180	588	69	&	&	CC
5180	588	70	Recreation	Recreation	NNP
5180	588	71	;	;	:
5180	588	72	Hosting	host	VBG
5180	588	73	Sites	site	NNS
5180	588	74	;	;	:
5180	588	75	Job	Job	NNP
5180	588	76	Search	Search	NNP
5180	588	77	&	&	CC
5180	588	78	Career	Career	NNP
5180	588	79	Development	Development	NNP
5180	588	80	;	;	:
5180	588	81	Kids	Kids	NNPS
5180	588	82	'	'	POS
5180	588	83	Sites	site	NNS
5180	588	84	;	;	:
5180	588	85	Lifestyle	Lifestyle	NNP
5180	588	86	&	&	CC
5180	588	87	Culture	Culture	NNP
5180	588	88	;	;	,
5180	588	89	Motor	Motor	NNP
5180	588	90	Vehicles	Vehicles	NNPS
5180	588	91	;	;	:
5180	588	92	News	news	NN
5180	588	93	;	;	:
5180	588	94	Personals	Personals	NNPS
5180	588	95	&	&	CC
5180	588	96	Dating	Dating	NNP
5180	588	97	;	;	:
5180	588	98	Photo	Photo	NNP
5180	588	99	Searches	Searches	NNPS
5180	588	100	;	;	:
5180	588	101	Real	real	JJ
5180	588	102	Estate	estate	NN
5180	588	103	;	;	:
5180	588	104	Reference	reference	NN
5180	588	105	;	;	:
5180	588	106	Religion	religion	NN
5180	588	107	;	;	:
5180	588	108	Remote	Remote	NNP
5180	588	109	Proxies	Proxies	NNPS
5180	588	110	;	;	:
5180	588	111	Sex	Sex	NNP
5180	588	112	Education	education	NN
5180	588	113	;	;	:
5180	588	114	Search	Search	NNP
5180	588	115	Engines	engine	NNS
5180	588	116	;	;	:
5180	588	117	Shopping	shopping	NN
5180	588	118	;	;	:
5180	588	119	Sports	sport	NNS
5180	588	120	;	;	:
5180	588	121	Streaming	streaming	NN
5180	588	122	Media	medium	NNS
5180	588	123	;	;	:
5180	588	124	Travel	travel	NN
5180	588	125	;	;	:
5180	588	126	Usenet	Usenet	NNP
5180	588	127	News	News	NNP
5180	588	128	;	;	:
5180	588	129	Violence	violence	NN
5180	588	130	;	;	:
5180	588	131	Weapons	weapon	NNS
5180	588	132	;	;	:
5180	588	133	and	and	CC
5180	588	134	Web	web	NN
5180	588	135	-	-	HYPH
5180	588	136	based	base	VBN
5180	588	137	Email	Email	NNP
5180	588	138	.	.	.
5180	589	1	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	589	2	offers	offer	VBZ
5180	589	3	the	the	DT
5180	589	4	following	follow	VBG
5180	589	5	categories	category	NNS
5180	589	6	:	:	:
5180	589	7	Adults	adult	NNS
5180	589	8	Only	only	RB
5180	589	9	;	;	:
5180	589	10	Alcohol	alcohol	NN
5180	589	11	;	;	:
5180	589	12	Auction	auction	NN
5180	589	13	;	;	:
5180	589	14	Chat	Chat	NNP
5180	589	15	;	;	:
5180	589	16	Drugs	drug	NNS
5180	589	17	;	;	:
5180	589	18	Electronic	Electronic	NNP
5180	589	19	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
5180	589	20	;	;	:
5180	589	21	Employment	Employment	NNP
5180	589	22	Search	Search	NNP
5180	589	23	;	;	:
5180	589	24	Free	free	JJ
5180	589	25	Mail	Mail	NNP
5180	589	26	;	;	:
5180	589	27	Free	free	JJ
5180	589	28	Pages	Pages	NNPS
5180	589	29	;	;	:
5180	589	30	Gambling	gambling	NN
5180	589	31	;	;	:
5180	589	32	Games	Games	NNPS
5180	589	33	;	;	:
5180	589	34	Hate	hate	NN
5180	589	35	/	/	SYM
5180	589	36	Discrimination	discrimination	NN
5180	589	37	;	;	:
5180	589	38	Illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	589	39	;	;	:
5180	589	40	Jokes	joke	NNS
5180	589	41	;	;	:
5180	589	42	Lingerie	Lingerie	NNP
5180	589	43	;	;	:
5180	589	44	Message	message	NN
5180	589	45	/	/	SYM
5180	589	46	Bulletin	Bulletin	NNP
5180	589	47	Boards	Boards	NNPS
5180	589	48	;	;	:
5180	589	49	Murder	murder	NN
5180	589	50	/	/	SYM
5180	589	51	Suicide	Suicide	NNP
5180	589	52	;	;	:
5180	589	53	News	news	NN
5180	589	54	;	;	:
5180	589	55	Nudity	nudity	NN
5180	589	56	;	;	,
5180	589	57	Personal	personal	JJ
5180	589	58	Information	information	NN
5180	589	59	;	;	:
5180	589	60	Personals	personal	NNS
5180	589	61	;	;	:
5180	589	62	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	589	63	;	;	:
5180	589	64	Profanity	Profanity	NNP
5180	589	65	;	;	:
5180	589	66	Recreation	Recreation	NNP
5180	589	67	/	/	SYM
5180	589	68	Entertainment	Entertainment	NNP
5180	589	69	;	;	:
5180	589	70	School	School	NNP
5180	589	71	Cheating	Cheating	NNP
5180	589	72	Information	Information	NNP
5180	589	73	;	;	:
5180	589	74	Search	Search	NNP
5180	589	75	Engines	engine	NNS
5180	589	76	;	;	:
5180	589	77	Search	Search	NNP
5180	589	78	Terms	term	NNS
5180	589	79	;	;	:
5180	589	80	Sex	sex	NN
5180	589	81	;	;	:
5180	589	82	Sports	sport	NNS
5180	589	83	;	;	:
5180	589	84	Stocks	stock	NNS
5180	589	85	;	;	:
5180	589	86	Swimsuits	swimsuit	NNS
5180	589	87	;	;	:
5180	589	88	Tasteless	tasteless	NN
5180	589	89	/	/	SYM
5180	589	90	Gross	gross	JJ
5180	589	91	;	;	:
5180	589	92	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
5180	589	93	;	;	:
5180	589	94	Violence	violence	NN
5180	589	95	;	;	:
5180	589	96	and	and	CC
5180	589	97	Weapons	weapon	NNS
5180	589	98	.	.	.
5180	590	1	The	the	DT
5180	590	2	"	"	``
5180	590	3	Nudity	Nudity	NNP
5180	590	4	"	"	''
5180	590	5	category	category	NN
5180	590	6	purports	purport	NNS
5180	590	7	to	to	TO
5180	590	8	block	block	VB
5180	590	9	only	only	RB
5180	590	10	"	"	``
5180	590	11	non	non	JJ
5180	590	12	-	-	JJ
5180	590	13	pornographic	pornographic	JJ
5180	590	14	"	"	''
5180	590	15	images	image	NNS
5180	590	16	.	.	.
5180	591	1	The	the	DT
5180	591	2	"	"	``
5180	591	3	Sex	sex	NN
5180	591	4	"	"	''
5180	591	5	category	category	NN
5180	591	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	591	7	intended	intend	VBN
5180	591	8	to	to	TO
5180	591	9	block	block	VB
5180	591	10	only	only	RB
5180	591	11	those	those	DT
5180	591	12	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	591	13	of	of	IN
5180	591	14	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	591	15	activity	activity	NN
5180	591	16	that	that	WDT
5180	591	17	are	be	VBP
5180	591	18	not	not	RB
5180	591	19	intended	intend	VBN
5180	591	20	to	to	TO
5180	591	21	arouse	arouse	VB
5180	591	22	.	.	.
5180	592	1	The	the	DT
5180	592	2	"	"	``
5180	592	3	Tasteless	Tasteless	NNP
5180	592	4	/	/	SYM
5180	592	5	Gross	Gross	NNP
5180	592	6	"	"	''
5180	592	7	category	category	NN
5180	592	8	includes	include	VBZ
5180	592	9	contents	content	NNS
5180	592	10	such	such	JJ
5180	592	11	as	as	IN
5180	592	12	"	"	``
5180	592	13	tasteless	tasteless	JJ
5180	592	14	humor	humor	NN
5180	592	15	"	"	''
5180	592	16	and	and	CC
5180	592	17	"	"	``
5180	592	18	graphic	graphic	JJ
5180	592	19	medical	medical	JJ
5180	592	20	or	or	CC
5180	592	21	accident	accident	NN
5180	592	22	scene	scene	NN
5180	592	23	photos	photo	NNS
5180	592	24	.	.	.
5180	592	25	"	"	''
5180	593	1	Additionally	additionally	RB
5180	593	2	,	,	,
5180	593	3	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	593	4	offers	offer	VBZ
5180	593	5	seven	seven	CD
5180	593	6	"	"	``
5180	593	7	exception	exception	NN
5180	593	8	categories	category	NNS
5180	593	9	.	.	.
5180	593	10	"	"	''
5180	594	1	These	these	DT
5180	594	2	exception	exception	NN
5180	594	3	categories	category	NNS
5180	594	4	include	include	VBP
5180	594	5	Education	Education	NNP
5180	594	6	,	,	,
5180	594	7	Filtered	Filtered	NNP
5180	594	8	Search	Search	NNP
5180	594	9	Engine	Engine	NNP
5180	594	10	,	,	,
5180	594	11	For	for	IN
5180	594	12	Kids	Kids	NNPS
5180	594	13	,	,	,
5180	594	14	History	history	NN
5180	594	15	,	,	,
5180	594	16	Medical	Medical	NNP
5180	594	17	,	,	,
5180	594	18	Moderated	Moderated	NNP
5180	594	19	,	,	,
5180	594	20	and	and	CC
5180	594	21	Text	Text	NNP
5180	594	22	/	/	SYM
5180	594	23	Spoken	Spoken	NNP
5180	594	24	Only	only	RB
5180	594	25	.	.	.
5180	595	1	When	when	WRB
5180	595	2	an	an	DT
5180	595	3	exception	exception	NN
5180	595	4	category	category	NN
5180	595	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	595	6	enabled	enable	VBN
5180	595	7	,	,	,
5180	595	8	access	access	NN
5180	595	9	to	to	IN
5180	595	10	any	any	DT
5180	595	11	Web	web	NN
5180	595	12	site	site	NN
5180	595	13	or	or	CC
5180	595	14	page	page	NN
5180	595	15	via	via	IN
5180	595	16	a	a	DT
5180	595	17	URL	url	NN
5180	595	18	associated	associate	VBN
5180	595	19	with	with	IN
5180	595	20	both	both	CC
5180	595	21	a	a	DT
5180	595	22	category	category	NN
5180	595	23	and	and	CC
5180	595	24	an	an	DT
5180	595	25	exception	exception	NN
5180	595	26	,	,	,
5180	595	27	for	for	IN
5180	595	28	example	example	NN
5180	595	29	,	,	,
5180	595	30	both	both	CC
5180	595	31	"	"	``
5180	595	32	Sex	sex	NN
5180	595	33	"	"	''
5180	595	34	and	and	CC
5180	595	35	"	"	``
5180	595	36	Education	Education	NNP
5180	595	37	,	,	,
5180	595	38	"	"	''
5180	595	39	will	will	MD
5180	595	40	be	be	VB
5180	595	41	allowed	allow	VBN
5180	595	42	,	,	,
5180	595	43	even	even	RB
5180	595	44	if	if	IN
5180	595	45	the	the	DT
5180	595	46	customer	customer	NN
5180	595	47	has	have	VBZ
5180	595	48	enabled	enable	VBN
5180	595	49	the	the	DT
5180	595	50	product	product	NN
5180	595	51	to	to	TO
5180	595	52	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	595	53	block	block	VB
5180	595	54	the	the	DT
5180	595	55	category	category	NN
5180	595	56	"	"	``
5180	595	57	Sex	sex	NN
5180	595	58	.	.	.
5180	595	59	"	"	''
5180	596	1	As	as	IN
5180	596	2	of	of	IN
5180	596	3	November	November	NNP
5180	596	4	15	15	CD
5180	596	5	,	,	,
5180	596	6	2001	2001	CD
5180	596	7	,	,	,
5180	596	8	of	of	IN
5180	596	9	those	those	DT
5180	596	10	Web	web	NN
5180	596	11	sites	site	NNS
5180	596	12	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	596	13	by	by	IN
5180	596	14	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	596	15	as	as	IN
5180	596	16	"	"	``
5180	596	17	Sex	sex	NN
5180	596	18	,	,	,
5180	596	19	"	"	''
5180	596	20	3.6	3.6	CD
5180	596	21	%	%	NN
5180	596	22	were	be	VBD
5180	596	23	also	also	RB
5180	596	24	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	596	25	as	as	IN
5180	596	26	"	"	``
5180	596	27	Education	Education	NNP
5180	596	28	,	,	,
5180	596	29	"	"	''
5180	596	30	2.9	2.9	CD
5180	596	31	%	%	NN
5180	596	32	as	as	IN
5180	596	33	"	"	``
5180	596	34	Medical	medical	JJ
5180	596	35	,	,	,
5180	596	36	"	"	''
5180	596	37	and	and	CC
5180	596	38	1.6	1.6	CD
5180	596	39	%	%	NN
5180	596	40	as	as	IN
5180	596	41	"	"	``
5180	596	42	History	history	NN
5180	596	43	.	.	.
5180	596	44	"	"	''
5180	597	1	Websense	websense	NN
5180	597	2	offers	offer	VBZ
5180	597	3	the	the	DT
5180	597	4	following	follow	VBG
5180	597	5	categories	category	NNS
5180	597	6	:	:	:
5180	597	7	Abortion	Abortion	NNP
5180	597	8	Advocacy	Advocacy	NNP
5180	597	9	;	;	:
5180	597	10	Advocacy	Advocacy	NNP
5180	597	11	Groups	Groups	NNPS
5180	597	12	;	;	:
5180	597	13	Adult	Adult	NNP
5180	597	14	Material	material	NN
5180	597	15	;	;	:
5180	597	16	Business	Business	NNP
5180	597	17	&	&	CC
5180	597	18	Economy	Economy	NNP
5180	597	19	;	;	:
5180	597	20	Drugs	Drugs	NNP
5180	597	21	;	;	:
5180	597	22	Education	Education	NNP
5180	597	23	;	;	:
5180	597	24	Entertainment	entertainment	NN
5180	597	25	;	;	:
5180	597	26	Gambling	gambling	NN
5180	597	27	;	;	:
5180	597	28	Games	Games	NNPS
5180	597	29	;	;	:
5180	597	30	Government	Government	NNP
5180	597	31	;	;	:
5180	597	32	Health	Health	NNP
5180	597	33	;	;	:
5180	597	34	Illegal	Illegal	NNP
5180	597	35	/	/	SYM
5180	597	36	Questionable	questionable	JJ
5180	597	37	;	;	:
5180	597	38	Information	Information	NNP
5180	597	39	Technology	Technology	NNP
5180	597	40	;	;	:
5180	597	41	Internet	internet	NN
5180	597	42	Communication	communication	NN
5180	597	43	;	;	:
5180	597	44	Job	Job	NNP
5180	597	45	Search	Search	NNP
5180	597	46	;	;	:
5180	597	47	Militancy	Militancy	NNP
5180	597	48	/	/	SYM
5180	597	49	Extremist	Extremist	NNP
5180	597	50	;	;	:
5180	597	51	News	News	NNP
5180	597	52	&	&	CC
5180	597	53	Media	Media	NNP
5180	597	54	;	;	:
5180	597	55	Productivity	Productivity	NNP
5180	597	56	Management	Management	NNP
5180	597	57	;	;	:
5180	597	58	Bandwidth	Bandwidth	NNP
5180	597	59	Management	Management	NNP
5180	597	60	;	;	:
5180	597	61	Racism	Racism	NNP
5180	597	62	/	/	SYM
5180	597	63	Hate	Hate	NNP
5180	597	64	;	;	:
5180	597	65	Religion	religion	NN
5180	597	66	;	;	:
5180	597	67	Shopping	shopping	NN
5180	597	68	;	;	:
5180	597	69	Society	Society	NNP
5180	597	70	&	&	CC
5180	597	71	Lifestyle	Lifestyle	NNP
5180	597	72	;	;	,
5180	597	73	Special	special	JJ
5180	597	74	Events	event	NNS
5180	597	75	;	;	:
5180	597	76	Sports	sport	NNS
5180	597	77	;	;	:
5180	597	78	Tasteless	tasteless	JJ
5180	597	79	;	;	:
5180	597	80	Travel	travel	NN
5180	597	81	;	;	:
5180	597	82	Vehicles	vehicle	NNS
5180	597	83	;	;	:
5180	597	84	Violence	violence	NN
5180	597	85	;	;	:
5180	597	86	and	and	CC
5180	597	87	Weapons	weapon	NNS
5180	597	88	.	.	.
5180	598	1	The	the	DT
5180	598	2	"	"	``
5180	598	3	Adult	Adult	NNP
5180	598	4	"	"	''
5180	598	5	category	category	NN
5180	598	6	includes	include	VBZ
5180	598	7	"	"	``
5180	598	8	full	full	JJ
5180	598	9	or	or	CC
5180	598	10	partial	partial	JJ
5180	598	11	nudity	nudity	NN
5180	598	12	of	of	IN
5180	598	13	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	598	14	,	,	,
5180	598	15	"	"	''
5180	598	16	as	as	RB
5180	598	17	well	well	RB
5180	598	18	as	as	IN
5180	598	19	sites	site	NNS
5180	598	20	offering	offer	VBG
5180	598	21	"	"	``
5180	598	22	light	light	JJ
5180	598	23	adult	adult	NN
5180	598	24	humor	humor	NN
5180	598	25	and	and	CC
5180	598	26	literature	literature	NN
5180	598	27	"	"	''
5180	598	28	and	and	CC
5180	598	29	"	"	``
5180	598	30	[	[	-LRB-
5180	598	31	s]exually	s]exually	NNP
5180	598	32	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	598	33	language	language	NN
5180	598	34	.	.	.
5180	598	35	"	"	''
5180	599	1	The	the	DT
5180	599	2	"	"	``
5180	599	3	Sexuality	Sexuality	NNP
5180	599	4	/	/	SYM
5180	599	5	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	599	6	"	"	''
5180	599	7	category	category	NN
5180	599	8	includes	include	VBZ
5180	599	9	,	,	,
5180	599	10	inter	inter	NNP
5180	599	11	alia	alia	NNP
5180	599	12	,	,	,
5180	599	13	"	"	``
5180	599	14	hard	hard	JJ
5180	599	15	-	-	HYPH
5180	599	16	core	core	NN
5180	599	17	adult	adult	NN
5180	599	18	humor	humor	NN
5180	599	19	and	and	CC
5180	599	20	literature	literature	NN
5180	599	21	"	"	''
5180	599	22	and	and	CC
5180	599	23	"	"	``
5180	599	24	[	[	-LRB-
5180	599	25	s]exually	s]exually	NNP
5180	599	26	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	599	27	language	language	NN
5180	599	28	.	.	.
5180	599	29	"	"	''
5180	600	1	The	the	DT
5180	600	2	"	"	``
5180	600	3	Tasteless	Tasteless	NNP
5180	600	4	"	"	''
5180	600	5	category	category	NN
5180	600	6	includes	include	VBZ
5180	600	7	"	"	``
5180	600	8	hard	hard	RB
5180	600	9	-	-	HYPH
5180	600	10	to	to	IN
5180	600	11	-	-	HYPH
5180	600	12	stomach	stomach	NN
5180	600	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	600	14	,	,	,
5180	600	15	including	include	VBG
5180	600	16	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	600	17	,	,	,
5180	600	18	worthless	worthless	JJ
5180	600	19	or	or	CC
5180	600	20	useless	useless	JJ
5180	600	21	sites	site	NNS
5180	600	22	,	,	,
5180	600	23	grotesque	grotesque	NN
5180	600	24	or	or	CC
5180	600	25	lurid	lurid	NNP
5180	600	26	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	600	27	of	of	IN
5180	600	28	bodily	bodily	JJ
5180	600	29	harm	harm	NN
5180	600	30	.	.	.
5180	600	31	"	"	''
5180	601	1	The	the	DT
5180	601	2	"	"	``
5180	601	3	Hacking	Hacking	NNP
5180	601	4	"	"	''
5180	601	5	category	category	NN
5180	601	6	blocks	block	NNS
5180	601	7	"	"	''
5180	601	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	601	9	providing	provide	VBG
5180	601	10	information	information	NN
5180	601	11	on	on	IN
5180	601	12	or	or	CC
5180	601	13	promoting	promote	VBG
5180	601	14	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	601	15	or	or	CC
5180	601	16	questionable	questionable	JJ
5180	601	17	access	access	NN
5180	601	18	to	to	IN
5180	601	19	or	or	CC
5180	601	20	use	use	NN
5180	601	21	of	of	IN
5180	601	22	communications	communication	NNS
5180	601	23	equipment	equipment	NN
5180	601	24	and/or	and/or	CC
5180	601	25	software	software	NN
5180	601	26	.	.	.
5180	601	27	"	"	''
5180	602	1	SmartFilter	SmartFilter	NNP
5180	602	2	offers	offer	VBZ
5180	602	3	the	the	DT
5180	602	4	following	follow	VBG
5180	602	5	categories	category	NNS
5180	602	6	:	:	:
5180	602	7	Anonymizers	anonymizer	NNS
5180	602	8	/	/	SYM
5180	602	9	Translators	Translators	NNPS
5180	602	10	;	;	:
5180	602	11	Art	Art	NNP
5180	602	12	&	&	CC
5180	602	13	Culture	culture	NN
5180	602	14	;	;	:
5180	602	15	Chat	Chat	NNP
5180	602	16	;	;	:
5180	602	17	Criminal	criminal	JJ
5180	602	18	Skills	Skills	NNPS
5180	602	19	;	;	:
5180	602	20	Cults	Cults	NNP
5180	602	21	/	/	SYM
5180	602	22	Occult	Occult	NNP
5180	602	23	;	;	:
5180	602	24	Dating	dating	NN
5180	602	25	;	;	:
5180	602	26	Drugs	drug	NNS
5180	602	27	;	;	:
5180	602	28	Entertainment	entertainment	NN
5180	602	29	;	;	:
5180	602	30	Extreme	Extreme	NNP
5180	602	31	/	/	SYM
5180	602	32	Obscene	Obscene	NNP
5180	602	33	/	/	SYM
5180	602	34	Violence	Violence	NNP
5180	602	35	;	;	:
5180	602	36	Gambling	gambling	NN
5180	602	37	;	;	:
5180	602	38	Games	Games	NNPS
5180	602	39	;	;	:
5180	602	40	General	General	NNP
5180	602	41	News	News	NNP
5180	602	42	;	;	:
5180	602	43	Hate	Hate	NNP
5180	602	44	Speech	Speech	NNP
5180	602	45	;	;	:
5180	602	46	Humor	humor	NN
5180	602	47	;	;	:
5180	602	48	Investing	investing	NN
5180	602	49	;	;	:
5180	602	50	Job	Job	NNP
5180	602	51	Search	Search	NNP
5180	602	52	;	;	:
5180	602	53	Lifestyle	lifestyle	NN
5180	602	54	;	;	:
5180	602	55	Mature	mature	VB
5180	602	56	;	;	:
5180	602	57	MP3	mp3	NN
5180	602	58	Sites	site	NNS
5180	602	59	;	;	:
5180	602	60	Nudity	nudity	NN
5180	602	61	;	;	:
5180	602	62	On	on	IN
5180	602	63	-	-	HYPH
5180	602	64	line	line	NN
5180	602	65	Sales	sale	NNS
5180	602	66	;	;	:
5180	602	67	Personal	Personal	NNP
5180	602	68	Pages	Pages	NNPS
5180	602	69	;	;	:
5180	602	70	Politics	Politics	NNP
5180	602	71	,	,	,
5180	602	72	Opinion	Opinion	NNP
5180	602	73	&	&	CC
5180	602	74	Religion	Religion	NNP
5180	602	75	;	;	:
5180	602	76	Portal	Portal	NNP
5180	602	77	Sites	Sites	NNPS
5180	602	78	;	;	:
5180	602	79	Self	self	NN
5180	602	80	-	-	HYPH
5180	602	81	Help	Help	NNP
5180	602	82	/	/	SYM
5180	602	83	Health	Health	NNP
5180	602	84	;	;	:
5180	602	85	Sex	sex	NN
5180	602	86	;	;	:
5180	602	87	Sports	sport	NNS
5180	602	88	;	;	:
5180	602	89	Travel	travel	NN
5180	602	90	;	;	:
5180	602	91	Usenet	Usenet	NNP
5180	602	92	News	news	NN
5180	602	93	;	;	:
5180	602	94	and	and	CC
5180	602	95	Webmail	Webmail	NNP
5180	602	96	.	.	.
5180	603	1	Most	most	RBS
5180	603	2	importantly	importantly	RB
5180	603	3	,	,	,
5180	603	4	no	no	DT
5180	603	5	category	category	NN
5180	603	6	definition	definition	NN
5180	603	7	used	use	VBN
5180	603	8	by	by	IN
5180	603	9	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	603	10	software	software	NN
5180	603	11	companies	company	NNS
5180	603	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	603	13	identical	identical	JJ
5180	603	14	to	to	IN
5180	603	15	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	603	16	's	's	POS
5180	603	17	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	603	18	of	of	IN
5180	603	19	visual	visual	JJ
5180	603	20	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	603	21	that	that	WDT
5180	603	22	are	be	VBP
5180	603	23	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	603	24	,	,	,
5180	603	25	child	child	NN
5180	603	26	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	603	27	,	,	,
5180	603	28	or	or	CC
5180	603	29	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	603	30	to	to	IN
5180	603	31	minors	minor	NNS
5180	603	32	.	.	.
5180	604	1	And	and	CC
5180	604	2	category	category	NN
5180	604	3	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	604	4	and	and	CC
5180	604	5	categorization	categorization	NN
5180	604	6	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	604	7	are	be	VBP
5180	604	8	made	make	VBN
5180	604	9	without	without	IN
5180	604	10	reference	reference	NN
5180	604	11	to	to	IN
5180	604	12	local	local	JJ
5180	604	13	community	community	NN
5180	604	14	standards	standard	NNS
5180	604	15	.	.	.
5180	605	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	605	2	,	,	,
5180	605	3	there	there	EX
5180	605	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	605	5	no	no	DT
5180	605	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
5180	605	7	involvement	involvement	NN
5180	605	8	in	in	IN
5180	605	9	the	the	DT
5180	605	10	creation	creation	NN
5180	605	11	of	of	IN
5180	605	12	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	605	13	software	software	NN
5180	605	14	companies	company	NNS
5180	605	15	'	'	POS
5180	605	16	category	category	NN
5180	605	17	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	605	18	and	and	CC
5180	605	19	no	no	DT
5180	605	20	judicial	judicial	JJ
5180	605	21	determination	determination	NN
5180	605	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	605	23	made	make	VBN
5180	605	24	before	before	IN
5180	605	25	these	these	DT
5180	605	26	companies	company	NNS
5180	605	27	categorize	categorize	VBP
5180	605	28	a	a	DT
5180	605	29	Web	web	NN
5180	605	30	page	page	NN
5180	605	31	or	or	CC
5180	605	32	site	site	NN
5180	605	33	.	.	.
5180	606	1	Each	each	DT
5180	606	2	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	606	3	software	software	NN
5180	606	4	company	company	NN
5180	606	5	associates	associate	VBZ
5180	606	6	each	each	DT
5180	606	7	URL	url	NN
5180	606	8	in	in	IN
5180	606	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	606	10	control	control	NN
5180	606	11	list	list	NN
5180	606	12	with	with	IN
5180	606	13	a	a	DT
5180	606	14	"	"	``
5180	606	15	tag	tag	NN
5180	606	16	"	"	''
5180	606	17	or	or	CC
5180	606	18	other	other	JJ
5180	606	19	identifier	identifier	NN
5180	606	20	that	that	WDT
5180	606	21	indicates	indicate	VBZ
5180	606	22	the	the	DT
5180	606	23	company	company	NN
5180	606	24	's	's	POS
5180	606	25	evaluation	evaluation	NN
5180	606	26	of	of	IN
5180	606	27	whether	whether	IN
5180	606	28	the	the	DT
5180	606	29	content	content	NN
5180	606	30	or	or	CC
5180	606	31	features	feature	NNS
5180	606	32	of	of	IN
5180	606	33	the	the	DT
5180	606	34	Web	web	NN
5180	606	35	site	site	NN
5180	606	36	or	or	CC
5180	606	37	page	page	NN
5180	606	38	accessed	access	VBN
5180	606	39	via	via	IN
5180	606	40	that	that	DT
5180	606	41	URL	URL	NNP
5180	606	42	meets	meet	VBZ
5180	606	43	one	one	CD
5180	606	44	or	or	CC
5180	606	45	more	more	JJR
5180	606	46	of	of	IN
5180	606	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	606	48	category	category	NN
5180	606	49	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	606	50	.	.	.
5180	607	1	If	if	IN
5180	607	2	a	a	DT
5180	607	3	user	user	NN
5180	607	4	attempts	attempt	VBZ
5180	607	5	to	to	TO
5180	607	6	access	access	VB
5180	607	7	a	a	DT
5180	607	8	Web	web	NN
5180	607	9	site	site	NN
5180	607	10	or	or	CC
5180	607	11	page	page	NN
5180	607	12	that	that	WDT
5180	607	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	607	14	blocked	block	VBN
5180	607	15	by	by	IN
5180	607	16	the	the	DT
5180	607	17	filter	filter	NN
5180	607	18	,	,	,
5180	607	19	the	the	DT
5180	607	20	user	user	NN
5180	607	21	is	be	VBZ
5180	607	22	immediately	immediately	RB
5180	607	23	presented	present	VBN
5180	607	24	with	with	IN
5180	607	25	a	a	DT
5180	607	26	screen	screen	NN
5180	607	27	that	that	WDT
5180	607	28	indicates	indicate	VBZ
5180	607	29	that	that	IN
5180	607	30	a	a	DT
5180	607	31	block	block	NN
5180	607	32	has	have	VBZ
5180	607	33	occurred	occur	VBN
5180	607	34	as	as	IN
5180	607	35	a	a	DT
5180	607	36	result	result	NN
5180	607	37	of	of	IN
5180	607	38	the	the	DT
5180	607	39	operation	operation	NN
5180	607	40	of	of	IN
5180	607	41	the	the	DT
5180	607	42	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	607	43	software	software	NN
5180	607	44	.	.	.
5180	608	1	These	these	DT
5180	608	2	"	"	``
5180	608	3	denial	denial	JJ
5180	608	4	screens	screen	NNS
5180	608	5	"	"	''
5180	608	6	appear	appear	VBP
5180	608	7	only	only	RB
5180	608	8	at	at	IN
5180	608	9	the	the	DT
5180	608	10	point	point	NN
5180	608	11	that	that	IN
5180	608	12	a	a	DT
5180	608	13	user	user	NN
5180	608	14	attempts	attempt	VBZ
5180	608	15	to	to	TO
5180	608	16	access	access	VB
5180	608	17	a	a	DT
5180	608	18	site	site	NN
5180	608	19	or	or	CC
5180	608	20	page	page	NN
5180	608	21	in	in	IN
5180	608	22	an	an	DT
5180	608	23	enabled	enable	VBN
5180	608	24	category	category	NN
5180	608	25	.	.	.
5180	609	1	All	all	DT
5180	609	2	four	four	CD
5180	609	3	of	of	IN
5180	609	4	the	the	DT
5180	609	5	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	609	6	programs	program	NNS
5180	609	7	on	on	IN
5180	609	8	which	which	WDT
5180	609	9	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	609	10	was	be	VBD
5180	609	11	presented	present	VBN
5180	609	12	allow	allow	VBP
5180	609	13	users	user	NNS
5180	609	14	to	to	TO
5180	609	15	customize	customize	VB
5180	609	16	the	the	DT
5180	609	17	category	category	NN
5180	609	18	lists	list	NNS
5180	609	19	that	that	WDT
5180	609	20	exist	exist	VBP
5180	609	21	on	on	IN
5180	609	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	609	23	own	own	JJ
5180	609	24	PCs	pc	NNS
5180	609	25	or	or	CC
5180	609	26	servers	server	NNS
5180	609	27	by	by	IN
5180	609	28	adding	add	VBG
5180	609	29	or	or	CC
5180	609	30	removing	remove	VBG
5180	609	31	specific	specific	JJ
5180	609	32	URLs	url	NNS
5180	609	33	.	.	.
5180	610	1	For	for	IN
5180	610	2	example	example	NN
5180	610	3	,	,	,
5180	610	4	if	if	IN
5180	610	5	a	a	DT
5180	610	6	public	public	JJ
5180	610	7	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	610	8	charged	charge	VBN
5180	610	9	with	with	IN
5180	610	10	administering	administer	VBG
5180	610	11	a	a	DT
5180	610	12	library	library	NN
5180	610	13	's	's	POS
5180	610	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	610	15	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	610	16	comes	come	VBZ
5180	610	17	across	across	IN
5180	610	18	a	a	DT
5180	610	19	Web	web	NN
5180	610	20	site	site	NN
5180	610	21	that	that	IN
5180	610	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	610	23	or	or	CC
5180	610	24	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	610	25	finds	find	VBZ
5180	610	26	objectionable	objectionable	JJ
5180	610	27	that	that	WDT
5180	610	28	is	be	VBZ
5180	610	29	not	not	RB
5180	610	30	blocked	block	VBN
5180	610	31	by	by	IN
5180	610	32	the	the	DT
5180	610	33	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	610	34	program	program	NN
5180	610	35	that	that	IN
5180	610	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	610	37	or	or	CC
5180	610	38	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	610	39	library	library	NN
5180	610	40	is	be	VBZ
5180	610	41	using	use	VBG
5180	610	42	,	,	,
5180	610	43	then	then	RB
5180	610	44	the	the	DT
5180	610	45	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	610	46	may	may	MD
5180	610	47	add	add	VB
5180	610	48	that	that	IN
5180	610	49	URL	url	NN
5180	610	50	to	to	IN
5180	610	51	a	a	DT
5180	610	52	category	category	NN
5180	610	53	list	list	NN
5180	610	54	that	that	WDT
5180	610	55	exists	exist	VBZ
5180	610	56	only	only	RB
5180	610	57	on	on	IN
5180	610	58	the	the	DT
5180	610	59	library	library	NN
5180	610	60	's	's	POS
5180	610	61	network	network	NN
5180	610	62	,	,	,
5180	610	63	and	and	CC
5180	610	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	610	65	would	would	MD
5180	610	66	thereafter	thereafter	RB
5180	610	67	be	be	VB
5180	610	68	blocked	block	VBN
5180	610	69	under	under	IN
5180	610	70	that	that	DT
5180	610	71	category	category	NN
5180	610	72	.	.	.
5180	611	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	611	2	,	,	,
5180	611	3	a	a	DT
5180	611	4	customer	customer	NN
5180	611	5	may	may	MD
5180	611	6	remove	remove	VB
5180	611	7	individual	individual	JJ
5180	611	8	URLs	url	NNS
5180	611	9	from	from	IN
5180	611	10	category	category	NN
5180	611	11	lists	list	NNS
5180	611	12	.	.	.
5180	612	1	Importantly	importantly	RB
5180	612	2	,	,	,
5180	612	3	however	however	RB
5180	612	4	,	,	,
5180	612	5	no	no	DT
5180	612	6	one	one	NN
5180	612	7	but	but	IN
5180	612	8	the	the	DT
5180	612	9	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	612	10	companies	company	NNS
5180	612	11	has	have	VBZ
5180	612	12	access	access	NN
5180	612	13	to	to	IN
5180	612	14	the	the	DT
5180	612	15	complete	complete	JJ
5180	612	16	list	list	NN
5180	612	17	of	of	IN
5180	612	18	URLs	url	NNS
5180	612	19	in	in	IN
5180	612	20	any	any	DT
5180	612	21	category	category	NN
5180	612	22	.	.	.
5180	613	1	The	the	DT
5180	613	2	actual	actual	JJ
5180	613	3	URLs	url	NNS
5180	613	4	or	or	CC
5180	613	5	IP	IP	NNP
5180	613	6	addresses	address	NNS
5180	613	7	of	of	IN
5180	613	8	the	the	DT
5180	613	9	Web	web	NN
5180	613	10	sites	site	NNS
5180	613	11	or	or	CC
5180	613	12	pages	page	NNS
5180	613	13	contained	contain	VBN
5180	613	14	in	in	IN
5180	613	15	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	613	16	software	software	NN
5180	613	17	vendors	vendor	NNS
5180	613	18	'	'	POS
5180	613	19	category	category	NN
5180	613	20	lists	list	NNS
5180	613	21	are	be	VBP
5180	613	22	considered	consider	VBN
5180	613	23	to	to	TO
5180	613	24	be	be	VB
5180	613	25	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
5180	613	26	information	information	NN
5180	613	27	,	,	,
5180	613	28	and	and	CC
5180	613	29	are	be	VBP
5180	613	30	unavailable	unavailable	JJ
5180	613	31	for	for	IN
5180	613	32	review	review	NN
5180	613	33	by	by	IN
5180	613	34	customers	customer	NNS
5180	613	35	or	or	CC
5180	613	36	the	the	DT
5180	613	37	general	general	JJ
5180	613	38	public	public	NN
5180	613	39	,	,	,
5180	613	40	including	include	VBG
5180	613	41	the	the	DT
5180	613	42	proprietors	proprietor	NNS
5180	613	43	of	of	IN
5180	613	44	Web	web	NN
5180	613	45	sites	site	NNS
5180	613	46	that	that	WDT
5180	613	47	are	be	VBP
5180	613	48	blocked	block	VBN
5180	613	49	by	by	IN
5180	613	50	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	613	51	software	software	NN
5180	613	52	.	.	.
5180	614	1	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	614	2	software	software	NN
5180	614	3	companies	company	NNS
5180	614	4	do	do	VBP
5180	614	5	not	not	RB
5180	614	6	generally	generally	RB
5180	614	7	notify	notify	VB
5180	614	8	the	the	DT
5180	614	9	proprietors	proprietor	NNS
5180	614	10	of	of	IN
5180	614	11	Web	web	NN
5180	614	12	sites	site	NNS
5180	614	13	when	when	WRB
5180	614	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	614	15	block	block	VBP
5180	614	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	614	17	sites	site	NNS
5180	614	18	.	.	.
5180	615	1	The	the	DT
5180	615	2	only	only	JJ
5180	615	3	way	way	NN
5180	615	4	to	to	TO
5180	615	5	discover	discover	VB
5180	615	6	which	which	WDT
5180	615	7	URLs	URLs	NNPS
5180	615	8	are	be	VBP
5180	615	9	blocked	block	VBN
5180	615	10	and	and	CC
5180	615	11	which	which	WDT
5180	615	12	are	be	VBP
5180	615	13	not	not	RB
5180	615	14	blocked	block	VBN
5180	615	15	by	by	IN
5180	615	16	any	any	DT
5180	615	17	particular	particular	JJ
5180	615	18	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	615	19	company	company	NN
5180	615	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	615	21	by	by	IN
5180	615	22	testing	test	VBG
5180	615	23	individual	individual	JJ
5180	615	24	URLs	url	NNS
5180	615	25	with	with	IN
5180	615	26	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	615	27	software	software	NN
5180	615	28	,	,	,
5180	615	29	or	or	CC
5180	615	30	by	by	IN
5180	615	31	entering	enter	VBG
5180	615	32	URLs	url	NNS
5180	615	33	one	one	CD
5180	615	34	by	by	IN
5180	615	35	one	one	CD
5180	615	36	into	into	IN
5180	615	37	the	the	DT
5180	615	38	"	"	``
5180	615	39	URL	URL	NNP
5180	615	40	checker	checker	NN
5180	615	41	"	"	''
5180	615	42	that	that	WDT
5180	615	43	most	most	RBS
5180	615	44	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	615	45	software	software	NN
5180	615	46	companies	company	NNS
5180	615	47	provide	provide	VBP
5180	615	48	on	on	IN
5180	615	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	615	50	Web	web	NN
5180	615	51	sites	site	NNS
5180	615	52	.	.	.
5180	616	1	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	616	2	software	software	NN
5180	616	3	companies	company	NNS
5180	616	4	will	will	MD
5180	616	5	entertain	entertain	VB
5180	616	6	requests	request	NNS
5180	616	7	for	for	IN
5180	616	8	recategorization	recategorization	NN
5180	616	9	from	from	IN
5180	616	10	proprietors	proprietor	NNS
5180	616	11	of	of	IN
5180	616	12	Web	web	NN
5180	616	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	616	14	that	that	WDT
5180	616	15	discover	discover	VBP
5180	616	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	616	17	sites	site	NNS
5180	616	18	are	be	VBP
5180	616	19	blocked	block	VBN
5180	616	20	.	.	.
5180	617	1	Because	because	IN
5180	617	2	new	new	JJ
5180	617	3	pages	page	NNS
5180	617	4	are	be	VBP
5180	617	5	constantly	constantly	RB
5180	617	6	being	be	VBG
5180	617	7	added	add	VBN
5180	617	8	to	to	IN
5180	617	9	the	the	DT
5180	617	10	Web	web	NN
5180	617	11	,	,	,
5180	617	12	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	617	13	companies	company	NNS
5180	617	14	provide	provide	VBP
5180	617	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	617	16	customers	customer	NNS
5180	617	17	with	with	IN
5180	617	18	periodic	periodic	JJ
5180	617	19	updates	update	NNS
5180	617	20	of	of	IN
5180	617	21	category	category	NN
5180	617	22	lists	list	NNS
5180	617	23	.	.	.
5180	618	1	Once	once	RB
5180	618	2	a	a	DT
5180	618	3	particular	particular	JJ
5180	618	4	Web	web	NN
5180	618	5	page	page	NN
5180	618	6	or	or	CC
5180	618	7	site	site	NN
5180	618	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	618	9	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	618	10	,	,	,
5180	618	11	however	however	RB
5180	618	12	,	,	,
5180	618	13	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	618	14	companies	company	NNS
5180	618	15	generally	generally	RB
5180	618	16	do	do	VBP
5180	618	17	not	not	RB
5180	618	18	re	re	VB
5180	618	19	-	-	VB
5180	618	20	review	review	VB
5180	618	21	the	the	DT
5180	618	22	contents	content	NNS
5180	618	23	of	of	IN
5180	618	24	that	that	DT
5180	618	25	page	page	NN
5180	618	26	or	or	CC
5180	618	27	site	site	NN
5180	618	28	unless	unless	IN
5180	618	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	618	30	receive	receive	VBP
5180	618	31	a	a	DT
5180	618	32	request	request	NN
5180	618	33	to	to	TO
5180	618	34	do	do	VB
5180	618	35	so	so	RB
5180	618	36	,	,	,
5180	618	37	even	even	RB
5180	618	38	though	though	IN
5180	618	39	the	the	DT
5180	618	40	content	content	NN
5180	618	41	on	on	IN
5180	618	42	individual	individual	JJ
5180	618	43	Web	web	NN
5180	618	44	pages	page	NNS
5180	618	45	and	and	CC
5180	618	46	sites	site	NNS
5180	618	47	changes	change	NNS
5180	618	48	frequently	frequently	RB
5180	618	49	.	.	.
5180	619	1	2	2	LS
5180	619	2	.	.	.
5180	620	1	The	the	DT
5180	620	2	Methods	Methods	NNPS
5180	620	3	that	that	IN
5180	620	4	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	620	5	Companies	company	NNS
5180	620	6	Use	use	VBP
5180	620	7	to	to	IN
5180	620	8	Compile	Compile	NNP
5180	620	9	Category	Category	NNP
5180	620	10	Lists	Lists	NNPS
5180	620	11	While	while	IN
5180	620	12	the	the	DT
5180	620	13	way	way	NN
5180	620	14	in	in	IN
5180	620	15	which	which	WDT
5180	620	16	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	620	17	programs	program	NNS
5180	620	18	operate	operate	VBP
5180	620	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	620	20	conceptually	conceptually	RB
5180	620	21	straightforward	straightforward	JJ
5180	620	22	–	–	:
5180	620	23	by	by	IN
5180	620	24	comparing	compare	VBG
5180	620	25	a	a	DT
5180	620	26	requested	request	VBN
5180	620	27	URL	url	NN
5180	620	28	to	to	IN
5180	620	29	a	a	DT
5180	620	30	previously	previously	RB
5180	620	31	compiled	compile	VBN
5180	620	32	list	list	NN
5180	620	33	of	of	IN
5180	620	34	URLs	url	NNS
5180	620	35	and	and	CC
5180	620	36	blocking	block	VBG
5180	620	37	access	access	NN
5180	620	38	to	to	IN
5180	620	39	the	the	DT
5180	620	40	content	content	NN
5180	620	41	at	at	IN
5180	620	42	that	that	DT
5180	620	43	URL	url	NN
5180	620	44	if	if	IN
5180	620	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	620	46	appears	appear	VBZ
5180	620	47	on	on	IN
5180	620	48	the	the	DT
5180	620	49	list	list	NN
5180	620	50	–	–	:
5180	620	51	accurately	accurately	RB
5180	620	52	compiling	compile	VBG
5180	620	53	and	and	CC
5180	620	54	categorizing	categorize	VBG
5180	620	55	URLs	url	NNS
5180	620	56	to	to	TO
5180	620	57	form	form	VB
5180	620	58	the	the	DT
5180	620	59	category	category	NN
5180	620	60	lists	list	NNS
5180	620	61	is	be	VBZ
5180	620	62	a	a	DT
5180	620	63	more	more	RBR
5180	620	64	complex	complex	JJ
5180	620	65	process	process	NN
5180	620	66	that	that	WDT
5180	620	67	is	be	VBZ
5180	620	68	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	620	69	to	to	TO
5180	620	70	conduct	conduct	VB
5180	620	71	with	with	IN
5180	620	72	any	any	DT
5180	620	73	high	high	JJ
5180	620	74	degree	degree	NN
5180	620	75	of	of	IN
5180	620	76	accuracy	accuracy	NN
5180	620	77	.	.	.
5180	621	1	The	the	DT
5180	621	2	specific	specific	JJ
5180	621	3	methods	method	NNS
5180	621	4	that	that	IN
5180	621	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	621	6	software	software	NN
5180	621	7	companies	company	NNS
5180	621	8	use	use	VBP
5180	621	9	to	to	TO
5180	621	10	compile	compile	VB
5180	621	11	and	and	CC
5180	621	12	categorize	categorize	VB
5180	621	13	control	control	NN
5180	621	14	lists	list	NNS
5180	621	15	are	be	VBP
5180	621	16	,	,	,
5180	621	17	like	like	IN
5180	621	18	the	the	DT
5180	621	19	lists	list	NNS
5180	621	20	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	621	21	,	,	,
5180	621	22	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
5180	621	23	information	information	NN
5180	621	24	.	.	.
5180	622	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	622	2	will	will	MD
5180	622	3	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	622	4	set	set	VB
5180	622	5	forth	forth	RP
5180	622	6	only	only	RB
5180	622	7	general	general	JJ
5180	622	8	information	information	NN
5180	622	9	on	on	IN
5180	622	10	the	the	DT
5180	622	11	various	various	JJ
5180	622	12	types	type	NNS
5180	622	13	of	of	IN
5180	622	14	methods	method	NNS
5180	622	15	that	that	WDT
5180	622	16	all	all	DT
5180	622	17	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	622	18	companies	company	NNS
5180	622	19	deposed	depose	VBN
5180	622	20	in	in	IN
5180	622	21	this	this	DT
5180	622	22	case	case	NN
5180	622	23	use	use	NN
5180	622	24	,	,	,
5180	622	25	and	and	CC
5180	622	26	the	the	DT
5180	622	27	sources	source	NNS
5180	622	28	of	of	IN
5180	622	29	error	error	NN
5180	622	30	that	that	WDT
5180	622	31	are	be	VBP
5180	622	32	at	at	IN
5180	622	33	once	once	RB
5180	622	34	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	622	35	in	in	IN
5180	622	36	those	those	DT
5180	622	37	methods	method	NNS
5180	622	38	and	and	CC
5180	622	39	unavoidable	unavoidable	JJ
5180	622	40	given	give	VBN
5180	622	41	the	the	DT
5180	622	42	current	current	JJ
5180	622	43	architecture	architecture	NN
5180	622	44	of	of	IN
5180	622	45	the	the	DT
5180	622	46	Internet	internet	NN
5180	622	47	and	and	CC
5180	622	48	the	the	DT
5180	622	49	current	current	JJ
5180	622	50	state	state	NN
5180	622	51	of	of	IN
5180	622	52	the	the	DT
5180	622	53	art	art	NN
5180	622	54	in	in	IN
5180	622	55	automated	automate	VBN
5180	622	56	classification	classification	NN
5180	622	57	systems	system	NNS
5180	622	58	.	.	.
5180	623	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	623	2	base	base	VBP
5180	623	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	623	4	understanding	understanding	NN
5180	623	5	of	of	IN
5180	623	6	these	these	DT
5180	623	7	methods	method	NNS
5180	623	8	largely	largely	RB
5180	623	9	on	on	IN
5180	623	10	the	the	DT
5180	623	11	detailed	detailed	JJ
5180	623	12	testimony	testimony	NN
5180	623	13	and	and	CC
5180	623	14	expert	expert	NN
5180	623	15	report	report	NN
5180	623	16	of	of	IN
5180	623	17	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
5180	623	18	Geoffrey	Geoffrey	NNP
5180	623	19	Nunberg	Nunberg	NNP
5180	623	20	,	,	,
5180	623	21	which	which	WDT
5180	623	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	623	23	credit	credit	VBP
5180	623	24	.	.	.
5180	624	1	The	the	DT
5180	624	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	624	3	offered	offer	VBD
5180	624	4	,	,	,
5180	624	5	and	and	CC
5180	624	6	the	the	DT
5180	624	7	Court	Court	NNP
5180	624	8	qualified	qualify	VBD
5180	624	9	,	,	,
5180	624	10	Nunberg	Nunberg	NNP
5180	624	11	as	as	IN
5180	624	12	an	an	DT
5180	624	13	expert	expert	JJ
5180	624	14	witness	witness	NN
5180	624	15	on	on	IN
5180	624	16	automated	automated	JJ
5180	624	17	classification	classification	NN
5180	624	18	systems	system	NNS
5180	624	19	.	.	.
5180	625	1	When	when	WRB
5180	625	2	compiling	compile	VBG
5180	625	3	and	and	CC
5180	625	4	categorizing	categorize	VBG
5180	625	5	URLs	url	NNS
5180	625	6	for	for	IN
5180	625	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	625	8	category	category	NN
5180	625	9	lists	list	NNS
5180	625	10	,	,	,
5180	625	11	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	625	12	software	software	NN
5180	625	13	companies	company	NNS
5180	625	14	go	go	VBP
5180	625	15	through	through	IN
5180	625	16	two	two	CD
5180	625	17	distinct	distinct	JJ
5180	625	18	phases	phase	NNS
5180	625	19	.	.	.
5180	626	1	First	first	RB
5180	626	2	,	,	,
5180	626	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	626	4	must	must	MD
5180	626	5	collect	collect	VB
5180	626	6	or	or	CC
5180	626	7	"	"	``
5180	626	8	harvest	harvest	VB
5180	626	9	"	"	''
5180	626	10	the	the	DT
5180	626	11	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	626	12	URLs	url	NNS
5180	626	13	from	from	IN
5180	626	14	the	the	DT
5180	626	15	vast	vast	JJ
5180	626	16	number	number	NN
5180	626	17	of	of	IN
5180	626	18	sites	site	NNS
5180	626	19	that	that	WDT
5180	626	20	exist	exist	VBP
5180	626	21	on	on	IN
5180	626	22	the	the	DT
5180	626	23	Web	web	NN
5180	626	24	.	.	.
5180	627	1	Second	second	JJ
5180	627	2	,	,	,
5180	627	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	627	4	must	must	MD
5180	627	5	sort	sort	VB
5180	627	6	through	through	IN
5180	627	7	the	the	DT
5180	627	8	URLs	url	NNS
5180	627	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	627	10	have	have	VBP
5180	627	11	collected	collect	VBN
5180	627	12	to	to	TO
5180	627	13	determine	determine	VB
5180	627	14	under	under	IN
5180	627	15	which	which	WDT
5180	627	16	of	of	IN
5180	627	17	the	the	DT
5180	627	18	company	company	NN
5180	627	19	's	's	POS
5180	627	20	self	self	NN
5180	627	21	-	-	HYPH
5180	627	22	defined	define	VBN
5180	627	23	categories	category	NNS
5180	627	24	(	(	-LRB-
5180	627	25	if	if	IN
5180	627	26	any	any	DT
5180	627	27	)	)	-RRB-
5180	627	28	,	,	,
5180	627	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	627	30	should	should	MD
5180	627	31	be	be	VB
5180	627	32	classified	classify	VBN
5180	627	33	.	.	.
5180	628	1	These	these	DT
5180	628	2	tasks	task	NNS
5180	628	3	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	628	4	result	result	VBP
5180	628	5	in	in	IN
5180	628	6	a	a	DT
5180	628	7	tradeoff	tradeoff	NN
5180	628	8	between	between	IN
5180	628	9	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	628	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	628	11	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	628	12	,	,	,
5180	628	13	the	the	DT
5180	628	14	blocking	blocking	NN
5180	628	15	of	of	IN
5180	628	16	content	content	NN
5180	628	17	that	that	WDT
5180	628	18	does	do	VBZ
5180	628	19	not	not	RB
5180	628	20	meet	meet	VB
5180	628	21	the	the	DT
5180	628	22	category	category	NN
5180	628	23	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	628	24	established	establish	VBN
5180	628	25	by	by	IN
5180	628	26	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	628	27	or	or	CC
5180	628	28	by	by	IN
5180	628	29	the	the	DT
5180	628	30	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	628	31	software	software	NN
5180	628	32	companies	company	NNS
5180	628	33	)	)	-RRB-
5180	628	34	,	,	,
5180	628	35	and	and	CC
5180	628	36	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	628	37	(	(	-LRB-
5180	628	38	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	628	39	,	,	,
5180	628	40	leaving	leave	VBG
5180	628	41	off	off	IN
5180	628	42	of	of	IN
5180	628	43	a	a	DT
5180	628	44	control	control	NN
5180	628	45	list	list	NN
5180	628	46	a	a	DT
5180	628	47	URL	url	NN
5180	628	48	that	that	WDT
5180	628	49	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	628	50	content	content	NN
5180	628	51	that	that	WDT
5180	628	52	would	would	MD
5180	628	53	meet	meet	VB
5180	628	54	the	the	DT
5180	628	55	category	category	NN
5180	628	56	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	628	57	defined	define	VBN
5180	628	58	by	by	IN
5180	628	59	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	628	60	or	or	CC
5180	628	61	the	the	DT
5180	628	62	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	628	63	software	software	NN
5180	628	64	companies	company	NNS
5180	628	65	)	)	-RRB-
5180	628	66	.	.	.
5180	629	1	1	1	LS
5180	629	2	.	.	.
5180	630	1	The	the	DT
5180	630	2	"	"	``
5180	630	3	Harvesting	harvesting	NN
5180	630	4	"	"	''
5180	630	5	Phase	phase	NN
5180	630	6	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	630	7	software	software	NN
5180	630	8	companies	company	NNS
5180	630	9	,	,	,
5180	630	10	given	give	VBN
5180	630	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	630	12	limited	limited	JJ
5180	630	13	resources	resource	NNS
5180	630	14	,	,	,
5180	630	15	do	do	VBP
5180	630	16	not	not	RB
5180	630	17	attempt	attempt	VB
5180	630	18	to	to	TO
5180	630	19	index	index	VB
5180	630	20	or	or	CC
5180	630	21	classify	classify	VB
5180	630	22	all	all	DT
5180	630	23	of	of	IN
5180	630	24	the	the	DT
5180	630	25	billions	billion	NNS
5180	630	26	of	of	IN
5180	630	27	pages	page	NNS
5180	630	28	that	that	WDT
5180	630	29	exist	exist	VBP
5180	630	30	on	on	IN
5180	630	31	the	the	DT
5180	630	32	Web	web	NN
5180	630	33	.	.	.
5180	631	1	Instead	instead	RB
5180	631	2	,	,	,
5180	631	3	the	the	DT
5180	631	4	set	set	NN
5180	631	5	of	of	IN
5180	631	6	pages	page	NNS
5180	631	7	that	that	WDT
5180	631	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	631	9	attempt	attempt	VBP
5180	631	10	to	to	TO
5180	631	11	examine	examine	VB
5180	631	12	and	and	CC
5180	631	13	classify	classify	VB
5180	631	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	631	15	restricted	restrict	VBN
5180	631	16	to	to	IN
5180	631	17	a	a	DT
5180	631	18	small	small	JJ
5180	631	19	portion	portion	NN
5180	631	20	of	of	IN
5180	631	21	the	the	DT
5180	631	22	Web	web	NN
5180	631	23	.	.	.
5180	632	1	The	the	DT
5180	632	2	companies	company	NNS
5180	632	3	use	use	VBP
5180	632	4	a	a	DT
5180	632	5	variety	variety	NN
5180	632	6	of	of	IN
5180	632	7	automated	automate	VBN
5180	632	8	and	and	CC
5180	632	9	manual	manual	JJ
5180	632	10	methods	method	NNS
5180	632	11	to	to	TO
5180	632	12	identify	identify	VB
5180	632	13	a	a	DT
5180	632	14	universe	universe	NN
5180	632	15	of	of	IN
5180	632	16	Web	web	NN
5180	632	17	sites	site	NNS
5180	632	18	and	and	CC
5180	632	19	pages	page	NNS
5180	632	20	to	to	TO
5180	632	21	"	"	``
5180	632	22	harvest	harvest	VB
5180	632	23	"	"	''
5180	632	24	for	for	IN
5180	632	25	classification	classification	NN
5180	632	26	.	.	.
5180	633	1	These	these	DT
5180	633	2	methods	method	NNS
5180	633	3	include	include	VBP
5180	633	4	:	:	:
5180	633	5	entering	enter	VBG
5180	633	6	certain	certain	JJ
5180	633	7	key	key	JJ
5180	633	8	words	word	NNS
5180	633	9	into	into	IN
5180	633	10	search	search	NN
5180	633	11	engines	engine	NNS
5180	633	12	;	;	,
5180	633	13	following	follow	VBG
5180	633	14	links	link	NNS
5180	633	15	from	from	IN
5180	633	16	a	a	DT
5180	633	17	variety	variety	NN
5180	633	18	of	of	IN
5180	633	19	online	online	JJ
5180	633	20	directories	directory	NNS
5180	633	21	(	(	-LRB-
5180	633	22	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	633	23	,	,	,
5180	633	24	generalized	generalize	VBN
5180	633	25	directories	directory	NNS
5180	633	26	like	like	IN
5180	633	27	Yahoo	Yahoo	NNP
5180	633	28	or	or	CC
5180	633	29	various	various	JJ
5180	633	30	specialized	specialized	JJ
5180	633	31	directories	directory	NNS
5180	633	32	,	,	,
5180	633	33	such	such	JJ
5180	633	34	as	as	IN
5180	633	35	those	those	DT
5180	633	36	that	that	WDT
5180	633	37	provide	provide	VBP
5180	633	38	links	link	NNS
5180	633	39	to	to	IN
5180	633	40	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	633	41	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	633	42	content	content	NN
5180	633	43	)	)	-RRB-
5180	633	44	;	;	:
5180	633	45	reviewing	reviewing	NN
5180	633	46	lists	list	NNS
5180	633	47	of	of	IN
5180	633	48	newly	newly	RB
5180	633	49	-	-	HYPH
5180	633	50	registered	register	VBN
5180	633	51	domain	domain	NN
5180	633	52	names	name	NNS
5180	633	53	;	;	,
5180	633	54	buying	buy	VBG
5180	633	55	or	or	CC
5180	633	56	licensing	licensing	NN
5180	633	57	lists	list	NNS
5180	633	58	of	of	IN
5180	633	59	URLs	url	NNS
5180	633	60	from	from	IN
5180	633	61	third	third	JJ
5180	633	62	parties	party	NNS
5180	633	63	;	;	:
5180	633	64	"	"	``
5180	633	65	mining	mine	VBG
5180	633	66	"	"	''
5180	633	67	access	access	NN
5180	633	68	logs	log	NNS
5180	633	69	maintained	maintain	VBN
5180	633	70	by	by	IN
5180	633	71	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	633	72	customers	customer	NNS
5180	633	73	;	;	:
5180	633	74	and	and	CC
5180	633	75	reviewing	review	VBG
5180	633	76	other	other	JJ
5180	633	77	submissions	submission	NNS
5180	633	78	from	from	IN
5180	633	79	customers	customer	NNS
5180	633	80	and	and	CC
5180	633	81	the	the	DT
5180	633	82	public	public	NN
5180	633	83	.	.	.
5180	634	1	The	the	DT
5180	634	2	goal	goal	NN
5180	634	3	of	of	IN
5180	634	4	each	each	DT
5180	634	5	of	of	IN
5180	634	6	these	these	DT
5180	634	7	methods	method	NNS
5180	634	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	634	9	to	to	TO
5180	634	10	identify	identify	VB
5180	634	11	as	as	IN
5180	634	12	many	many	JJ
5180	634	13	URLs	url	NNS
5180	634	14	as	as	IN
5180	634	15	possible	possible	JJ
5180	634	16	that	that	WDT
5180	634	17	are	be	VBP
5180	634	18	likely	likely	JJ
5180	634	19	to	to	TO
5180	634	20	contain	contain	VB
5180	634	21	content	content	NN
5180	634	22	that	that	WDT
5180	634	23	falls	fall	VBZ
5180	634	24	within	within	IN
5180	634	25	the	the	DT
5180	634	26	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	634	27	companies	company	NNS
5180	634	28	'	'	POS
5180	634	29	category	category	NN
5180	634	30	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	634	31	.	.	.
5180	635	1	The	the	DT
5180	635	2	first	first	JJ
5180	635	3	method	method	NN
5180	635	4	,	,	,
5180	635	5	entering	enter	VBG
5180	635	6	certain	certain	JJ
5180	635	7	keywords	keyword	NNS
5180	635	8	into	into	IN
5180	635	9	commercial	commercial	JJ
5180	635	10	search	search	NN
5180	635	11	engines	engine	NNS
5180	635	12	,	,	,
5180	635	13	suffers	suffer	NNS
5180	635	14	from	from	IN
5180	635	15	several	several	JJ
5180	635	16	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	635	17	.	.	.
5180	636	1	First	first	RB
5180	636	2	,	,	,
5180	636	3	the	the	DT
5180	636	4	Web	web	NN
5180	636	5	pages	page	NNS
5180	636	6	that	that	WDT
5180	636	7	may	may	MD
5180	636	8	be	be	VB
5180	636	9	"	"	``
5180	636	10	harvested	harvest	VBN
5180	636	11	"	"	''
5180	636	12	through	through	IN
5180	636	13	this	this	DT
5180	636	14	method	method	NN
5180	636	15	are	be	VBP
5180	636	16	limited	limited	JJ
5180	636	17	to	to	IN
5180	636	18	those	those	DT
5180	636	19	pages	page	NNS
5180	636	20	that	that	WDT
5180	636	21	search	search	NN
5180	636	22	engines	engine	NNS
5180	636	23	have	have	VBP
5180	636	24	already	already	RB
5180	636	25	identified	identify	VBN
5180	636	26	.	.	.
5180	637	1	However	however	RB
5180	637	2	,	,	,
5180	637	3	as	as	IN
5180	637	4	noted	note	VBN
5180	637	5	above	above	IN
5180	637	6	,	,	,
5180	637	7	a	a	DT
5180	637	8	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	637	9	portion	portion	NN
5180	637	10	of	of	IN
5180	637	11	the	the	DT
5180	637	12	Web	web	NN
5180	637	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	637	14	not	not	RB
5180	637	15	even	even	RB
5180	637	16	theoretically	theoretically	RB
5180	637	17	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	637	18	(	(	-LRB-
5180	637	19	because	because	IN
5180	637	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	637	21	is	be	VBZ
5180	637	22	not	not	RB
5180	637	23	linked	link	VBN
5180	637	24	to	to	IN
5180	637	25	by	by	IN
5180	637	26	any	any	DT
5180	637	27	previously	previously	RB
5180	637	28	known	know	VBN
5180	637	29	page	page	NN
5180	637	30	)	)	-RRB-
5180	637	31	,	,	,
5180	637	32	and	and	CC
5180	637	33	only	only	RB
5180	637	34	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	637	35	50	50	CD
5180	637	36	%	%	NN
5180	637	37	of	of	IN
5180	637	38	the	the	DT
5180	637	39	pages	page	NNS
5180	637	40	that	that	WDT
5180	637	41	are	be	VBP
5180	637	42	theoretically	theoretically	RB
5180	637	43	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	637	44	have	have	VBP
5180	637	45	actually	actually	RB
5180	637	46	been	be	VBN
5180	637	47	indexed	index	VBN
5180	637	48	by	by	IN
5180	637	49	search	search	NN
5180	637	50	engines	engine	NNS
5180	637	51	.	.	.
5180	638	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	638	2	are	be	VBP
5180	638	3	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
5180	638	4	that	that	IN
5180	638	5	the	the	DT
5180	638	6	remainder	remainder	NN
5180	638	7	of	of	IN
5180	638	8	the	the	DT
5180	638	9	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	638	10	Web	web	NN
5180	638	11	,	,	,
5180	638	12	and	and	CC
5180	638	13	the	the	DT
5180	638	14	vast	vast	JJ
5180	638	15	"	"	``
5180	638	16	Deep	deep	JJ
5180	638	17	Web	web	NN
5180	638	18	,	,	,
5180	638	19	"	"	''
5180	638	20	which	which	WDT
5180	638	21	can	can	MD
5180	638	22	not	not	RB
5180	638	23	currently	currently	RB
5180	638	24	be	be	VB
5180	638	25	indexed	index	VBN
5180	638	26	,	,	,
5180	638	27	includes	include	VBZ
5180	638	28	materials	material	NNS
5180	638	29	that	that	WDT
5180	638	30	meet	meet	VBP
5180	638	31	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	638	32	's	's	POS
5180	638	33	categories	category	NNS
5180	638	34	of	of	IN
5180	638	35	visual	visual	JJ
5180	638	36	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	638	37	that	that	WDT
5180	638	38	are	be	VBP
5180	638	39	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	638	40	,	,	,
5180	638	41	child	child	NN
5180	638	42	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	638	43	,	,	,
5180	638	44	and	and	CC
5180	638	45	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	638	46	to	to	IN
5180	638	47	minors	minor	NNS
5180	638	48	.	.	.
5180	639	1	These	these	DT
5180	639	2	portions	portion	NNS
5180	639	3	of	of	IN
5180	639	4	the	the	DT
5180	639	5	Web	web	NN
5180	639	6	can	can	MD
5180	639	7	not	not	RB
5180	639	8	presently	presently	RB
5180	639	9	be	be	VB
5180	639	10	harvested	harvest	VBN
5180	639	11	through	through	IN
5180	639	12	the	the	DT
5180	639	13	methods	method	NNS
5180	639	14	that	that	IN
5180	639	15	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	639	16	software	software	NN
5180	639	17	companies	company	NNS
5180	639	18	use	use	VBP
5180	639	19	(	(	-LRB-
5180	639	20	except	except	IN
5180	639	21	through	through	IN
5180	639	22	reporting	report	VBG
5180	639	23	by	by	IN
5180	639	24	customers	customer	NNS
5180	639	25	or	or	CC
5180	639	26	by	by	IN
5180	639	27	observing	observe	VBG
5180	639	28	users	user	NNS
5180	639	29	'	'	POS
5180	639	30	log	log	NN
5180	639	31	files	file	NNS
5180	639	32	)	)	-RRB-
5180	639	33	,	,	,
5180	639	34	because	because	IN
5180	639	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	639	36	are	be	VBP
5180	639	37	not	not	RB
5180	639	38	linked	link	VBN
5180	639	39	to	to	IN
5180	639	40	other	other	JJ
5180	639	41	known	know	VBN
5180	639	42	pages	page	NNS
5180	639	43	.	.	.
5180	640	1	A	a	DT
5180	640	2	user	user	NN
5180	640	3	can	can	MD
5180	640	4	,	,	,
5180	640	5	however	however	RB
5180	640	6	,	,	,
5180	640	7	gain	gain	VB
5180	640	8	access	access	NN
5180	640	9	to	to	IN
5180	640	10	a	a	DT
5180	640	11	Web	web	NN
5180	640	12	site	site	NN
5180	640	13	in	in	IN
5180	640	14	the	the	DT
5180	640	15	unindexed	unindexed	NNS
5180	640	16	Web	web	NN
5180	640	17	or	or	CC
5180	640	18	the	the	DT
5180	640	19	Deep	Deep	NNP
5180	640	20	Web	Web	NNP
5180	640	21	if	if	IN
5180	640	22	the	the	DT
5180	640	23	Web	web	NN
5180	640	24	site	site	NN
5180	640	25	's	's	POS
5180	640	26	proprietor	proprietor	NN
5180	640	27	or	or	CC
5180	640	28	some	some	DT
5180	640	29	other	other	JJ
5180	640	30	third	third	JJ
5180	640	31	party	party	NN
5180	640	32	informs	inform	VBZ
5180	640	33	the	the	DT
5180	640	34	user	user	NN
5180	640	35	of	of	IN
5180	640	36	the	the	DT
5180	640	37	site	site	NN
5180	640	38	's	's	POS
5180	640	39	URL	url	NN
5180	640	40	.	.	.
5180	641	1	Some	some	DT
5180	641	2	Web	web	NN
5180	641	3	sites	site	NNS
5180	641	4	,	,	,
5180	641	5	for	for	IN
5180	641	6	example	example	NN
5180	641	7	,	,	,
5180	641	8	send	send	VB
5180	641	9	out	out	RP
5180	641	10	mass	mass	JJ
5180	641	11	email	email	NN
5180	641	12	advertisements	advertisement	NNS
5180	641	13	containing	contain	VBG
5180	641	14	the	the	DT
5180	641	15	site	site	NN
5180	641	16	's	's	POS
5180	641	17	URL	url	NN
5180	641	18	,	,	,
5180	641	19	the	the	DT
5180	641	20	spamming	spamme	VBG
5180	641	21	process	process	NN
5180	641	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	641	23	have	have	VBP
5180	641	24	described	describe	VBN
5180	641	25	above	above	RB
5180	641	26	.	.	.
5180	642	1	Second	second	JJ
5180	642	2	,	,	,
5180	642	3	the	the	DT
5180	642	4	search	search	NN
5180	642	5	engines	engine	NNS
5180	642	6	that	that	WDT
5180	642	7	software	software	NN
5180	642	8	companies	company	NNS
5180	642	9	use	use	VBP
5180	642	10	for	for	IN
5180	642	11	harvesting	harvesting	NN
5180	642	12	are	be	VBP
5180	642	13	able	able	JJ
5180	642	14	to	to	TO
5180	642	15	search	search	VB
5180	642	16	text	text	NN
5180	642	17	only	only	RB
5180	642	18	,	,	,
5180	642	19	not	not	RB
5180	642	20	images	image	NNS
5180	642	21	.	.	.
5180	643	1	This	this	DT
5180	643	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	643	3	of	of	IN
5180	643	4	critical	critical	JJ
5180	643	5	importance	importance	NN
5180	643	6	,	,	,
5180	643	7	because	because	IN
5180	643	8	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	643	9	,	,	,
5180	643	10	by	by	IN
5180	643	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	643	12	own	own	JJ
5180	643	13	terms	term	NNS
5180	643	14	,	,	,
5180	643	15	covers	cover	VBZ
5180	643	16	only	only	RB
5180	643	17	"	"	``
5180	643	18	visual	visual	JJ
5180	643	19	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	643	20	.	.	.
5180	643	21	"	"	''
5180	644	1	20	20	CD
5180	644	2	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	645	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	645	2	.	.	.
5180	646	1	9134(f)(1)(A)(i	9134(f)(1)(a)(i	CD
5180	646	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	646	3	;	;	:
5180	646	4	47	47	CD
5180	646	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	647	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	647	2	.	.	.
5180	648	1	254(h)(5)(B)(i	254(h)(5)(b)(i	LS
5180	648	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	648	3	.	.	.
5180	649	1	Image	image	NN
5180	649	2	recognition	recognition	NN
5180	649	3	technology	technology	NN
5180	649	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	649	5	immature	immature	JJ
5180	649	6	,	,	,
5180	649	7	ineffective	ineffective	JJ
5180	649	8	,	,	,
5180	649	9	and	and	CC
5180	649	10	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
5180	649	11	to	to	TO
5180	649	12	improve	improve	VB
5180	649	13	substantially	substantially	RB
5180	649	14	in	in	IN
5180	649	15	the	the	DT
5180	649	16	near	near	JJ
5180	649	17	future	future	NN
5180	649	18	.	.	.
5180	650	1	None	none	NN
5180	650	2	of	of	IN
5180	650	3	the	the	DT
5180	650	4	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	650	5	software	software	NN
5180	650	6	companies	company	NNS
5180	650	7	deposed	depose	VBN
5180	650	8	in	in	IN
5180	650	9	this	this	DT
5180	650	10	case	case	NN
5180	650	11	employs	employ	VBZ
5180	650	12	image	image	NN
5180	650	13	recognition	recognition	NN
5180	650	14	technology	technology	NN
5180	650	15	when	when	WRB
5180	650	16	harvesting	harvesting	NN
5180	650	17	or	or	CC
5180	650	18	categorizing	categorize	VBG
5180	650	19	URLs	url	NNS
5180	650	20	.	.	.
5180	651	1	Due	due	IN
5180	651	2	to	to	IN
5180	651	3	the	the	DT
5180	651	4	reliance	reliance	NN
5180	651	5	on	on	IN
5180	651	6	automated	automate	VBN
5180	651	7	text	text	NN
5180	651	8	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	651	9	and	and	CC
5180	651	10	the	the	DT
5180	651	11	absence	absence	NN
5180	651	12	of	of	IN
5180	651	13	image	image	NN
5180	651	14	recognition	recognition	NN
5180	651	15	technology	technology	NN
5180	651	16	,	,	,
5180	651	17	a	a	DT
5180	651	18	Web	web	NN
5180	651	19	page	page	NN
5180	651	20	with	with	IN
5180	651	21	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	651	22	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	651	23	images	image	NNS
5180	651	24	and	and	CC
5180	651	25	no	no	DT
5180	651	26	text	text	NN
5180	651	27	can	can	MD
5180	651	28	not	not	RB
5180	651	29	be	be	VB
5180	651	30	harvested	harvest	VBN
5180	651	31	using	use	VBG
5180	651	32	a	a	DT
5180	651	33	search	search	NN
5180	651	34	engine	engine	NN
5180	651	35	.	.	.
5180	652	1	This	this	DT
5180	652	2	problem	problem	NN
5180	652	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	652	4	complicated	complicate	VBN
5180	652	5	by	by	IN
5180	652	6	the	the	DT
5180	652	7	fact	fact	NN
5180	652	8	that	that	IN
5180	652	9	Web	web	NN
5180	652	10	site	site	NN
5180	652	11	publishers	publisher	NNS
5180	652	12	may	may	MD
5180	652	13	use	use	VB
5180	652	14	image	image	NN
5180	652	15	files	file	NNS
5180	652	16	rather	rather	RB
5180	652	17	than	than	IN
5180	652	18	text	text	NN
5180	652	19	to	to	TO
5180	652	20	represent	represent	VB
5180	652	21	words	word	NNS
5180	652	22	,	,	,
5180	652	23	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	652	24	,	,	,
5180	652	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	652	26	may	may	MD
5180	652	27	use	use	VB
5180	652	28	a	a	DT
5180	652	29	file	file	NN
5180	652	30	that	that	IN
5180	652	31	computers	computer	NNS
5180	652	32	understand	understand	VBP
5180	652	33	to	to	TO
5180	652	34	be	be	VB
5180	652	35	a	a	DT
5180	652	36	picture	picture	NN
5180	652	37	,	,	,
5180	652	38	like	like	IN
5180	652	39	a	a	DT
5180	652	40	photograph	photograph	NN
5180	652	41	of	of	IN
5180	652	42	a	a	DT
5180	652	43	printed	print	VBN
5180	652	44	word	word	NN
5180	652	45	,	,	,
5180	652	46	rather	rather	RB
5180	652	47	than	than	IN
5180	652	48	regular	regular	JJ
5180	652	49	text	text	NN
5180	652	50	,	,	,
5180	652	51	making	make	VBG
5180	652	52	automated	automate	VBN
5180	652	53	review	review	NN
5180	652	54	of	of	IN
5180	652	55	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	652	56	textual	textual	JJ
5180	652	57	content	content	NN
5180	652	58	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	652	59	.	.	.
5180	653	1	For	for	IN
5180	653	2	example	example	NN
5180	653	3	,	,	,
5180	653	4	if	if	IN
5180	653	5	the	the	DT
5180	653	6	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	653	7	Web	Web	NNP
5180	653	8	site	site	NN
5180	653	9	displays	display	VBZ
5180	653	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	653	11	name	name	NN
5180	653	12	using	use	VBG
5180	653	13	a	a	DT
5180	653	14	logo	logo	NN
5180	653	15	rather	rather	RB
5180	653	16	than	than	IN
5180	653	17	regular	regular	JJ
5180	653	18	text	text	NN
5180	653	19	,	,	,
5180	653	20	a	a	DT
5180	653	21	search	search	NN
5180	653	22	engine	engine	NN
5180	653	23	would	would	MD
5180	653	24	not	not	RB
5180	653	25	see	see	VB
5180	653	26	or	or	CC
5180	653	27	recognize	recognize	VB
5180	653	28	the	the	DT
5180	653	29	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	653	30	name	name	NN
5180	653	31	in	in	IN
5180	653	32	that	that	DT
5180	653	33	logo	logo	NN
5180	653	34	.	.	.
5180	654	1	In	in	IN
5180	654	2	addition	addition	NN
5180	654	3	to	to	IN
5180	654	4	collecting	collect	VBG
5180	654	5	URLs	url	NNS
5180	654	6	through	through	IN
5180	654	7	search	search	NN
5180	654	8	engines	engine	NNS
5180	654	9	and	and	CC
5180	654	10	Web	web	NN
5180	654	11	directories	directory	NNS
5180	654	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	654	13	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	654	14	those	those	DT
5180	654	15	specializing	specialize	VBG
5180	654	16	in	in	IN
5180	654	17	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	654	18	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	654	19	sites	site	NNS
5180	654	20	or	or	CC
5180	654	21	other	other	JJ
5180	654	22	categories	category	NNS
5180	654	23	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	654	24	to	to	IN
5180	654	25	one	one	CD
5180	654	26	of	of	IN
5180	654	27	the	the	DT
5180	654	28	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	654	29	companies	company	NNS
5180	654	30	'	'	POS
5180	654	31	category	category	NN
5180	654	32	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	654	33	)	)	-RRB-
5180	654	34	,	,	,
5180	654	35	and	and	CC
5180	654	36	by	by	IN
5180	654	37	mining	mining	NN
5180	654	38	user	user	NN
5180	654	39	logs	log	NNS
5180	654	40	and	and	CC
5180	654	41	collecting	collect	VBG
5180	654	42	URLs	url	NNS
5180	654	43	submitted	submit	VBN
5180	654	44	by	by	IN
5180	654	45	users	user	NNS
5180	654	46	,	,	,
5180	654	47	the	the	DT
5180	654	48	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	654	49	companies	company	NNS
5180	654	50	expand	expand	VBP
5180	654	51	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	654	52	list	list	NN
5180	654	53	of	of	IN
5180	654	54	harvested	harvest	VBN
5180	654	55	URLs	URLs	NNP
5180	654	56	by	by	IN
5180	654	57	using	use	VBG
5180	654	58	"	"	``
5180	654	59	spidering	spidere	VBG
5180	654	60	"	"	''
5180	654	61	software	software	NN
5180	654	62	that	that	WDT
5180	654	63	can	can	MD
5180	654	64	"	"	``
5180	654	65	crawl	crawl	VB
5180	654	66	"	"	''
5180	654	67	the	the	DT
5180	654	68	lists	list	NNS
5180	654	69	of	of	IN
5180	654	70	pages	page	NNS
5180	654	71	produced	produce	VBN
5180	654	72	by	by	IN
5180	654	73	the	the	DT
5180	654	74	previous	previous	JJ
5180	654	75	four	four	CD
5180	654	76	methods	method	NNS
5180	654	77	,	,	,
5180	654	78	following	follow	VBG
5180	654	79	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	654	80	links	link	NNS
5180	654	81	downward	downward	RB
5180	654	82	to	to	TO
5180	654	83	bring	bring	VB
5180	654	84	back	back	RB
5180	654	85	the	the	DT
5180	654	86	pages	page	NNS
5180	654	87	to	to	TO
5180	654	88	which	which	WDT
5180	654	89	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	654	90	link	link	VBP
5180	654	91	(	(	-LRB-
5180	654	92	and	and	CC
5180	654	93	the	the	DT
5180	654	94	pages	page	NNS
5180	654	95	to	to	TO
5180	654	96	which	which	WDT
5180	654	97	those	those	DT
5180	654	98	pages	page	NNS
5180	654	99	link	link	VBP
5180	654	100	,	,	,
5180	654	101	and	and	CC
5180	654	102	so	so	RB
5180	654	103	on	on	RB
5180	654	104	,	,	,
5180	654	105	but	but	CC
5180	654	106	usually	usually	RB
5180	654	107	down	down	RB
5180	654	108	only	only	RB
5180	654	109	a	a	DT
5180	654	110	few	few	JJ
5180	654	111	levels	level	NNS
5180	654	112	)	)	-RRB-
5180	654	113	.	.	.
5180	655	1	This	this	DT
5180	655	2	spidering	spidere	VBG
5180	655	3	software	software	NN
5180	655	4	uses	use	VBZ
5180	655	5	the	the	DT
5180	655	6	same	same	JJ
5180	655	7	type	type	NN
5180	655	8	of	of	IN
5180	655	9	technology	technology	NN
5180	655	10	that	that	IN
5180	655	11	commercial	commercial	JJ
5180	655	12	Web	web	NN
5180	655	13	search	search	NN
5180	655	14	engines	engine	NNS
5180	655	15	use	use	VBP
5180	655	16	.	.	.
5180	656	1	While	while	IN
5180	656	2	useful	useful	JJ
5180	656	3	in	in	IN
5180	656	4	expanding	expand	VBG
5180	656	5	the	the	DT
5180	656	6	number	number	NN
5180	656	7	of	of	IN
5180	656	8	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	656	9	URLs	url	NNS
5180	656	10	,	,	,
5180	656	11	the	the	DT
5180	656	12	ability	ability	NN
5180	656	13	to	to	TO
5180	656	14	retrieve	retrieve	VB
5180	656	15	additional	additional	JJ
5180	656	16	pages	page	NNS
5180	656	17	through	through	IN
5180	656	18	this	this	DT
5180	656	19	approach	approach	NN
5180	656	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	656	21	limited	limit	VBN
5180	656	22	by	by	IN
5180	656	23	the	the	DT
5180	656	24	architectural	architectural	JJ
5180	656	25	feature	feature	NN
5180	656	26	of	of	IN
5180	656	27	the	the	DT
5180	656	28	Web	web	NN
5180	656	29	that	that	IN
5180	656	30	page	page	NN
5180	656	31	-	-	HYPH
5180	656	32	to	to	IN
5180	656	33	-	-	HYPH
5180	656	34	page	page	NN
5180	656	35	links	link	NNS
5180	656	36	tend	tend	VBP
5180	656	37	to	to	TO
5180	656	38	converge	converge	VB
5180	656	39	rather	rather	RB
5180	656	40	than	than	IN
5180	656	41	diverge	diverge	NN
5180	656	42	.	.	.
5180	657	1	That	that	DT
5180	657	2	means	mean	VBZ
5180	657	3	that	that	IN
5180	657	4	the	the	DT
5180	657	5	more	more	JJR
5180	657	6	pages	page	NNS
5180	657	7	from	from	IN
5180	657	8	which	which	WDT
5180	657	9	one	one	NN
5180	657	10	spiders	spider	VBZ
5180	657	11	downward	downward	RB
5180	657	12	through	through	IN
5180	657	13	links	link	NNS
5180	657	14	,	,	,
5180	657	15	the	the	DT
5180	657	16	smaller	small	JJR
5180	657	17	the	the	DT
5180	657	18	proportion	proportion	NN
5180	657	19	of	of	IN
5180	657	20	new	new	JJ
5180	657	21	sites	site	NNS
5180	657	22	one	one	PRP
5180	657	23	will	will	MD
5180	657	24	uncover	uncover	VB
5180	657	25	;	;	:
5180	657	26	if	if	IN
5180	657	27	spidering	spidere	VBG
5180	657	28	the	the	DT
5180	657	29	links	link	NNS
5180	657	30	of	of	IN
5180	657	31	1000	1000	CD
5180	657	32	sites	site	NNS
5180	657	33	retrieved	retrieve	VBN
5180	657	34	through	through	IN
5180	657	35	a	a	DT
5180	657	36	search	search	NN
5180	657	37	engine	engine	NN
5180	657	38	or	or	CC
5180	657	39	Web	web	NN
5180	657	40	directory	directory	NN
5180	657	41	turns	turn	VBZ
5180	657	42	up	up	RB
5180	657	43	500	500	CD
5180	657	44	additional	additional	JJ
5180	657	45	distinct	distinct	JJ
5180	657	46	adult	adult	NN
5180	657	47	sites	site	NNS
5180	657	48	,	,	,
5180	657	49	spidering	spidere	VBG
5180	657	50	an	an	DT
5180	657	51	additional	additional	JJ
5180	657	52	1000	1000	CD
5180	657	53	sites	site	NNS
5180	657	54	may	may	MD
5180	657	55	turn	turn	VB
5180	657	56	up	up	RP
5180	657	57	,	,	,
5180	657	58	for	for	IN
5180	657	59	example	example	NN
5180	657	60	,	,	,
5180	657	61	only	only	RB
5180	657	62	250	250	CD
5180	657	63	additional	additional	JJ
5180	657	64	distinct	distinct	JJ
5180	657	65	sites	site	NNS
5180	657	66	,	,	,
5180	657	67	and	and	CC
5180	657	68	the	the	DT
5180	657	69	proportion	proportion	NN
5180	657	70	of	of	IN
5180	657	71	new	new	JJ
5180	657	72	sites	site	NNS
5180	657	73	uncovered	uncover	VBN
5180	657	74	will	will	MD
5180	657	75	continue	continue	VB
5180	657	76	to	to	TO
5180	657	77	diminish	diminish	VB
5180	657	78	as	as	IN
5180	657	79	more	more	JJR
5180	657	80	pages	page	NNS
5180	657	81	are	be	VBP
5180	657	82	spidered	spidere	VBN
5180	657	83	.	.	.
5180	658	1	These	these	DT
5180	658	2	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	658	3	on	on	IN
5180	658	4	the	the	DT
5180	658	5	technology	technology	NN
5180	658	6	used	use	VBN
5180	658	7	to	to	TO
5180	658	8	harvest	harvest	VB
5180	658	9	a	a	DT
5180	658	10	set	set	NN
5180	658	11	of	of	IN
5180	658	12	URLs	url	NNS
5180	658	13	for	for	IN
5180	658	14	review	review	NN
5180	658	15	will	will	MD
5180	658	16	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	658	17	lead	lead	VB
5180	658	18	to	to	IN
5180	658	19	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	658	20	underblocking	underblocking	NN
5180	658	21	of	of	IN
5180	658	22	material	material	NN
5180	658	23	with	with	IN
5180	658	24	respect	respect	NN
5180	658	25	to	to	IN
5180	658	26	both	both	DT
5180	658	27	the	the	DT
5180	658	28	category	category	NN
5180	658	29	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	658	30	employed	employ	VBN
5180	658	31	by	by	IN
5180	658	32	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	658	33	software	software	NN
5180	658	34	companies	company	NNS
5180	658	35	and	and	CC
5180	658	36	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	658	37	's	's	POS
5180	658	38	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	658	39	of	of	IN
5180	658	40	visual	visual	JJ
5180	658	41	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	658	42	that	that	WDT
5180	658	43	are	be	VBP
5180	658	44	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	658	45	,	,	,
5180	658	46	child	child	NN
5180	658	47	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	658	48	,	,	,
5180	658	49	or	or	CC
5180	658	50	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	658	51	to	to	IN
5180	658	52	minors	minor	NNS
5180	658	53	.	.	.
5180	659	1	2	2	LS
5180	659	2	.	.	.
5180	660	1	The	the	DT
5180	660	2	"	"	``
5180	660	3	Winnowing	winnowing	NN
5180	660	4	"	"	''
5180	660	5	or	or	CC
5180	660	6	Categorization	Categorization	NNP
5180	660	7	Phase	Phase	NNP
5180	660	8	Once	once	IN
5180	660	9	the	the	DT
5180	660	10	URLs	url	NNS
5180	660	11	have	have	VBP
5180	660	12	been	be	VBN
5180	660	13	harvested	harvest	VBN
5180	660	14	,	,	,
5180	660	15	some	some	DT
5180	660	16	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	660	17	software	software	NN
5180	660	18	companies	company	NNS
5180	660	19	use	use	VBP
5180	660	20	automated	automate	VBN
5180	660	21	key	key	JJ
5180	660	22	word	word	NN
5180	660	23	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	660	24	tools	tool	NNS
5180	660	25	to	to	TO
5180	660	26	evaluate	evaluate	VB
5180	660	27	the	the	DT
5180	660	28	content	content	NN
5180	660	29	and/or	and/or	CC
5180	660	30	features	feature	NNS
5180	660	31	of	of	IN
5180	660	32	Web	web	NN
5180	660	33	sites	site	NNS
5180	660	34	or	or	CC
5180	660	35	pages	page	NNS
5180	660	36	accessed	access	VBN
5180	660	37	via	via	IN
5180	660	38	a	a	DT
5180	660	39	particular	particular	JJ
5180	660	40	URL	url	NN
5180	660	41	and	and	CC
5180	660	42	to	to	TO
5180	660	43	tentatively	tentatively	RB
5180	660	44	prioritize	prioritize	VB
5180	660	45	or	or	CC
5180	660	46	categorize	categorize	VB
5180	660	47	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	660	48	.	.	.
5180	661	1	This	this	DT
5180	661	2	process	process	NN
5180	661	3	may	may	MD
5180	661	4	be	be	VB
5180	661	5	characterized	characterize	VBN
5180	661	6	as	as	IN
5180	661	7	"	"	``
5180	661	8	winnowing	winnow	VBG
5180	661	9	"	"	''
5180	661	10	the	the	DT
5180	661	11	harvested	harvest	VBN
5180	661	12	URLs	URLs	NNP
5180	661	13	.	.	.
5180	662	1	Automated	automate	VBN
5180	662	2	systems	system	NNS
5180	662	3	currently	currently	RB
5180	662	4	used	use	VBN
5180	662	5	by	by	IN
5180	662	6	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	662	7	software	software	NN
5180	662	8	vendors	vendor	NNS
5180	662	9	to	to	TO
5180	662	10	prioritize	prioritize	VB
5180	662	11	,	,	,
5180	662	12	and	and	CC
5180	662	13	to	to	TO
5180	662	14	categorize	categorize	VB
5180	662	15	or	or	CC
5180	662	16	tentatively	tentatively	RB
5180	662	17	categorize	categorize	VB
5180	662	18	the	the	DT
5180	662	19	content	content	NN
5180	662	20	and/or	and/or	CC
5180	662	21	features	feature	NNS
5180	662	22	of	of	IN
5180	662	23	a	a	DT
5180	662	24	Web	web	NN
5180	662	25	site	site	NN
5180	662	26	or	or	CC
5180	662	27	page	page	NN
5180	662	28	accessed	access	VBN
5180	662	29	via	via	IN
5180	662	30	a	a	DT
5180	662	31	particular	particular	JJ
5180	662	32	URL	url	NN
5180	662	33	operate	operate	NN
5180	662	34	by	by	IN
5180	662	35	means	mean	NNS
5180	662	36	of	of	IN
5180	662	37	(	(	-LRB-
5180	662	38	1	1	LS
5180	662	39	)	)	-RRB-
5180	662	40	simple	simple	JJ
5180	662	41	key	key	JJ
5180	662	42	word	word	NN
5180	662	43	searching	searching	NN
5180	662	44	,	,	,
5180	662	45	and	and	CC
5180	662	46	(	(	-LRB-
5180	662	47	2	2	LS
5180	662	48	)	)	-RRB-
5180	662	49	the	the	DT
5180	662	50	use	use	NN
5180	662	51	of	of	IN
5180	662	52	statistical	statistical	JJ
5180	662	53	algorithms	algorithm	NNS
5180	662	54	that	that	WDT
5180	662	55	rely	rely	VBP
5180	662	56	on	on	IN
5180	662	57	the	the	DT
5180	662	58	frequency	frequency	NN
5180	662	59	and	and	CC
5180	662	60	structure	structure	NN
5180	662	61	of	of	IN
5180	662	62	various	various	JJ
5180	662	63	linguistic	linguistic	JJ
5180	662	64	features	feature	NNS
5180	662	65	in	in	IN
5180	662	66	a	a	DT
5180	662	67	Web	web	NN
5180	662	68	page	page	NN
5180	662	69	's	's	POS
5180	662	70	text	text	NN
5180	662	71	.	.	.
5180	663	1	The	the	DT
5180	663	2	automated	automate	VBN
5180	663	3	systems	system	NNS
5180	663	4	used	use	VBN
5180	663	5	to	to	TO
5180	663	6	categorize	categorize	VB
5180	663	7	pages	page	NNS
5180	663	8	do	do	VBP
5180	663	9	not	not	RB
5180	663	10	include	include	VB
5180	663	11	image	image	NN
5180	663	12	recognition	recognition	NN
5180	663	13	technology	technology	NN
5180	663	14	.	.	.
5180	664	1	All	all	DT
5180	664	2	of	of	IN
5180	664	3	the	the	DT
5180	664	4	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	664	5	companies	company	NNS
5180	664	6	deposed	depose	VBN
5180	664	7	in	in	IN
5180	664	8	the	the	DT
5180	664	9	case	case	NN
5180	664	10	also	also	RB
5180	664	11	employ	employ	VBP
5180	664	12	human	human	JJ
5180	664	13	review	review	NN
5180	664	14	of	of	IN
5180	664	15	some	some	DT
5180	664	16	or	or	CC
5180	664	17	all	all	DT
5180	664	18	collected	collect	VBN
5180	664	19	Web	web	NN
5180	664	20	pages	page	NNS
5180	664	21	at	at	IN
5180	664	22	some	some	DT
5180	664	23	point	point	NN
5180	664	24	during	during	IN
5180	664	25	the	the	DT
5180	664	26	process	process	NN
5180	664	27	of	of	IN
5180	664	28	categorizing	categorize	VBG
5180	664	29	Web	web	NN
5180	664	30	pages	page	NNS
5180	664	31	.	.	.
5180	665	1	As	as	IN
5180	665	2	with	with	IN
5180	665	3	the	the	DT
5180	665	4	harvesting	harvesting	NN
5180	665	5	process	process	NN
5180	665	6	,	,	,
5180	665	7	each	each	DT
5180	665	8	technique	technique	NN
5180	665	9	employed	employ	VBN
5180	665	10	in	in	IN
5180	665	11	the	the	DT
5180	665	12	winnowing	winnowing	NN
5180	665	13	process	process	NN
5180	665	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	665	15	subject	subject	JJ
5180	665	16	to	to	IN
5180	665	17	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	665	18	that	that	WDT
5180	665	19	can	can	MD
5180	665	20	result	result	VB
5180	665	21	in	in	IN
5180	665	22	both	both	CC
5180	665	23	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	665	24	and	and	CC
5180	665	25	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	665	26	.	.	.
5180	666	1	First	first	JJ
5180	666	2	,	,	,
5180	666	3	simple	simple	JJ
5180	666	4	key	key	JJ
5180	666	5	-	-	HYPH
5180	666	6	word	word	NN
5180	666	7	-	-	HYPH
5180	666	8	based	base	VBN
5180	666	9	filters	filter	NNS
5180	666	10	are	be	VBP
5180	666	11	subject	subject	JJ
5180	666	12	to	to	IN
5180	666	13	the	the	DT
5180	666	14	obvious	obvious	JJ
5180	666	15	limitation	limitation	NN
5180	666	16	that	that	IN
5180	666	17	no	no	DT
5180	666	18	string	string	NN
5180	666	19	of	of	IN
5180	666	20	words	word	NNS
5180	666	21	can	can	MD
5180	666	22	identify	identify	VB
5180	666	23	all	all	DT
5180	666	24	sites	site	NNS
5180	666	25	that	that	WDT
5180	666	26	contain	contain	VBP
5180	666	27	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	666	28	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	666	29	content	content	NN
5180	666	30	,	,	,
5180	666	31	and	and	CC
5180	666	32	most	most	JJS
5180	666	33	strings	string	NNS
5180	666	34	of	of	IN
5180	666	35	words	word	NNS
5180	666	36	are	be	VBP
5180	666	37	likely	likely	JJ
5180	666	38	to	to	TO
5180	666	39	appear	appear	VB
5180	666	40	in	in	IN
5180	666	41	Web	web	NN
5180	666	42	sites	site	NNS
5180	666	43	that	that	WDT
5180	666	44	are	be	VBP
5180	666	45	not	not	RB
5180	666	46	properly	properly	RB
5180	666	47	classified	classify	VBN
5180	666	48	as	as	IN
5180	666	49	containing	contain	VBG
5180	666	50	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	666	51	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	666	52	content	content	NN
5180	666	53	.	.	.
5180	667	1	As	as	IN
5180	667	2	noted	note	VBN
5180	667	3	above	above	RB
5180	667	4	,	,	,
5180	667	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	667	6	software	software	NN
5180	667	7	companies	company	NNS
5180	667	8	also	also	RB
5180	667	9	use	use	VBP
5180	667	10	more	more	RBR
5180	667	11	sophisticated	sophisticated	JJ
5180	667	12	automated	automated	JJ
5180	667	13	classification	classification	NN
5180	667	14	systems	system	NNS
5180	667	15	for	for	IN
5180	667	16	the	the	DT
5180	667	17	statistical	statistical	JJ
5180	667	18	classification	classification	NN
5180	667	19	of	of	IN
5180	667	20	texts	text	NNS
5180	667	21	.	.	.
5180	668	1	These	these	DT
5180	668	2	systems	system	NNS
5180	668	3	assign	assign	VBP
5180	668	4	weights	weight	NNS
5180	668	5	to	to	IN
5180	668	6	words	word	NNS
5180	668	7	or	or	CC
5180	668	8	other	other	JJ
5180	668	9	textual	textual	JJ
5180	668	10	features	feature	NNS
5180	668	11	and	and	CC
5180	668	12	use	use	VBP
5180	668	13	algorithms	algorithm	NNS
5180	668	14	to	to	TO
5180	668	15	determine	determine	VB
5180	668	16	whether	whether	IN
5180	668	17	a	a	DT
5180	668	18	text	text	NN
5180	668	19	belongs	belong	VBZ
5180	668	20	to	to	IN
5180	668	21	a	a	DT
5180	668	22	certain	certain	JJ
5180	668	23	category	category	NN
5180	668	24	.	.	.
5180	669	1	These	these	DT
5180	669	2	algorithms	algorithm	NNS
5180	669	3	sometimes	sometimes	RB
5180	669	4	make	make	VBP
5180	669	5	reference	reference	NN
5180	669	6	to	to	IN
5180	669	7	the	the	DT
5180	669	8	position	position	NN
5180	669	9	of	of	IN
5180	669	10	a	a	DT
5180	669	11	word	word	NN
5180	669	12	within	within	IN
5180	669	13	a	a	DT
5180	669	14	text	text	NN
5180	669	15	or	or	CC
5180	669	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	669	17	relative	relative	JJ
5180	669	18	proximity	proximity	NN
5180	669	19	to	to	IN
5180	669	20	other	other	JJ
5180	669	21	words	word	NNS
5180	669	22	.	.	.
5180	670	1	The	the	DT
5180	670	2	weights	weight	NNS
5180	670	3	are	be	VBP
5180	670	4	usually	usually	RB
5180	670	5	determined	determine	VBN
5180	670	6	by	by	IN
5180	670	7	machine	machine	NN
5180	670	8	learning	learning	NN
5180	670	9	methods	method	NNS
5180	670	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	670	11	often	often	RB
5180	670	12	described	describe	VBN
5180	670	13	as	as	IN
5180	670	14	"	"	``
5180	670	15	artificial	artificial	JJ
5180	670	16	intelligence	intelligence	NN
5180	670	17	"	"	''
5180	670	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	670	19	.	.	.
5180	671	1	In	in	IN
5180	671	2	this	this	DT
5180	671	3	procedure	procedure	NN
5180	671	4	,	,	,
5180	671	5	which	which	WDT
5180	671	6	resembles	resemble	VBZ
5180	671	7	an	an	DT
5180	671	8	automated	automate	VBN
5180	671	9	form	form	NN
5180	671	10	of	of	IN
5180	671	11	trial	trial	NN
5180	671	12	and	and	CC
5180	671	13	error	error	NN
5180	671	14	,	,	,
5180	671	15	a	a	DT
5180	671	16	system	system	NN
5180	671	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	671	18	given	give	VBN
5180	671	19	a	a	DT
5180	671	20	"	"	``
5180	671	21	training	training	NN
5180	671	22	set	set	NN
5180	671	23	"	"	''
5180	671	24	consisting	consist	VBG
5180	671	25	of	of	IN
5180	671	26	documents	document	NNS
5180	671	27	preclassified	preclassifie	VBN
5180	671	28	into	into	IN
5180	671	29	two	two	CD
5180	671	30	or	or	CC
5180	671	31	more	more	JJR
5180	671	32	groups	group	NNS
5180	671	33	,	,	,
5180	671	34	along	along	IN
5180	671	35	with	with	IN
5180	671	36	a	a	DT
5180	671	37	set	set	NN
5180	671	38	of	of	IN
5180	671	39	features	feature	NNS
5180	671	40	that	that	WDT
5180	671	41	might	may	MD
5180	671	42	be	be	VB
5180	671	43	potentially	potentially	RB
5180	671	44	useful	useful	JJ
5180	671	45	in	in	IN
5180	671	46	classifying	classify	VBG
5180	671	47	the	the	DT
5180	671	48	sets	set	NNS
5180	671	49	.	.	.
5180	672	1	The	the	DT
5180	672	2	system	system	NN
5180	672	3	then	then	RB
5180	672	4	"	"	``
5180	672	5	learns	learn	VBZ
5180	672	6	"	"	''
5180	672	7	rules	rule	NNS
5180	672	8	that	that	WDT
5180	672	9	assign	assign	VBP
5180	672	10	weights	weight	NNS
5180	672	11	to	to	IN
5180	672	12	those	those	DT
5180	672	13	features	feature	NNS
5180	672	14	according	accord	VBG
5180	672	15	to	to	IN
5180	672	16	how	how	WRB
5180	672	17	well	well	RB
5180	672	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	672	19	work	work	VBP
5180	672	20	in	in	IN
5180	672	21	classification	classification	NN
5180	672	22	,	,	,
5180	672	23	and	and	CC
5180	672	24	assigns	assign	VBZ
5180	672	25	each	each	DT
5180	672	26	new	new	JJ
5180	672	27	document	document	NN
5180	672	28	to	to	IN
5180	672	29	a	a	DT
5180	672	30	category	category	NN
5180	672	31	with	with	IN
5180	672	32	a	a	DT
5180	672	33	certain	certain	JJ
5180	672	34	probability	probability	NN
5180	672	35	.	.	.
5180	673	1	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
5180	673	2	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	673	3	"	"	``
5180	673	4	artificial	artificial	JJ
5180	673	5	intelligence	intelligence	NN
5180	673	6	"	"	''
5180	673	7	description	description	NN
5180	673	8	,	,	,
5180	673	9	automated	automate	VBD
5180	673	10	text	text	NN
5180	673	11	classification	classification	NN
5180	673	12	systems	system	NNS
5180	673	13	are	be	VBP
5180	673	14	unable	unable	JJ
5180	673	15	to	to	TO
5180	673	16	grasp	grasp	VB
5180	673	17	many	many	JJ
5180	673	18	distinctions	distinction	NNS
5180	673	19	between	between	IN
5180	673	20	types	type	NNS
5180	673	21	of	of	IN
5180	673	22	content	content	NN
5180	673	23	that	that	WDT
5180	673	24	would	would	MD
5180	673	25	be	be	VB
5180	673	26	obvious	obvious	JJ
5180	673	27	to	to	IN
5180	673	28	a	a	DT
5180	673	29	human	human	NN
5180	673	30	.	.	.
5180	674	1	And	and	CC
5180	674	2	of	of	IN
5180	674	3	critical	critical	JJ
5180	674	4	importance	importance	NN
5180	674	5	,	,	,
5180	674	6	no	no	RB
5180	674	7	presently	presently	RB
5180	674	8	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
5180	674	9	technology	technology	NN
5180	674	10	can	can	MD
5180	674	11	make	make	VB
5180	674	12	the	the	DT
5180	674	13	judgments	judgment	NNS
5180	674	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	674	15	to	to	TO
5180	674	16	determine	determine	VB
5180	674	17	whether	whether	IN
5180	674	18	a	a	DT
5180	674	19	visual	visual	JJ
5180	674	20	depiction	depiction	NN
5180	674	21	fits	fit	VBZ
5180	674	22	the	the	DT
5180	674	23	legal	legal	JJ
5180	674	24	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	674	25	of	of	IN
5180	674	26	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	674	27	,	,	,
5180	674	28	child	child	NN
5180	674	29	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	674	30	,	,	,
5180	674	31	or	or	CC
5180	674	32	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	674	33	to	to	IN
5180	674	34	minors	minor	NNS
5180	674	35	.	.	.
5180	675	1	Finally	finally	RB
5180	675	2	,	,	,
5180	675	3	all	all	PDT
5180	675	4	the	the	DT
5180	675	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	675	6	software	software	NN
5180	675	7	companies	company	NNS
5180	675	8	deposed	depose	VBN
5180	675	9	in	in	IN
5180	675	10	this	this	DT
5180	675	11	case	case	NN
5180	675	12	use	use	VB
5180	675	13	some	some	DT
5180	675	14	form	form	NN
5180	675	15	of	of	IN
5180	675	16	human	human	JJ
5180	675	17	review	review	NN
5180	675	18	in	in	IN
5180	675	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	675	20	process	process	NN
5180	675	21	of	of	IN
5180	675	22	winnowing	winnow	VBG
5180	675	23	and	and	CC
5180	675	24	categorizing	categorize	VBG
5180	675	25	Web	web	NN
5180	675	26	pages	page	NNS
5180	675	27	,	,	,
5180	675	28	although	although	IN
5180	675	29	one	one	CD
5180	675	30	company	company	NN
5180	675	31	admitted	admit	VBD
5180	675	32	to	to	IN
5180	675	33	categorizing	categorize	VBG
5180	675	34	some	some	DT
5180	675	35	Web	web	NN
5180	675	36	pages	page	NNS
5180	675	37	without	without	IN
5180	675	38	any	any	DT
5180	675	39	human	human	JJ
5180	675	40	review	review	NN
5180	675	41	.	.	.
5180	676	1	SmartFilter	SmartFilter	NNP
5180	676	2	states	state	VBZ
5180	676	3	that	that	IN
5180	676	4	"	"	``
5180	676	5	the	the	DT
5180	676	6	final	final	JJ
5180	676	7	categorization	categorization	NN
5180	676	8	of	of	IN
5180	676	9	every	every	DT
5180	676	10	Web	web	NN
5180	676	11	site	site	NN
5180	676	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	676	13	done	do	VBN
5180	676	14	by	by	IN
5180	676	15	a	a	DT
5180	676	16	human	human	JJ
5180	676	17	reviewer	reviewer	NN
5180	676	18	.	.	.
5180	676	19	"	"	''
5180	677	1	Another	another	DT
5180	677	2	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	677	3	company	company	NN
5180	677	4	asserts	assert	VBZ
5180	677	5	that	that	DT
5180	677	6	of	of	IN
5180	677	7	the	the	DT
5180	677	8	10,000	10,000	CD
5180	677	9	to	to	TO
5180	677	10	30,000	30,000	CD
5180	677	11	Web	web	NN
5180	677	12	pages	page	NNS
5180	677	13	that	that	WDT
5180	677	14	enter	enter	VBP
5180	677	15	the	the	DT
5180	677	16	"	"	``
5180	677	17	work	work	NN
5180	677	18	queue	queue	NN
5180	677	19	"	"	''
5180	677	20	to	to	TO
5180	677	21	be	be	VB
5180	677	22	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	677	23	each	each	DT
5180	677	24	day	day	NN
5180	677	25	,	,	,
5180	677	26	two	two	CD
5180	677	27	to	to	TO
5180	677	28	three	three	CD
5180	677	29	percent	percent	NN
5180	677	30	of	of	IN
5180	677	31	those	those	DT
5180	677	32	are	be	VBP
5180	677	33	automatically	automatically	RB
5180	677	34	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	677	35	by	by	IN
5180	677	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	677	37	PornByRef	PornByRef	NNP
5180	677	38	system	system	NN
5180	677	39	(	(	-LRB-
5180	677	40	which	which	WDT
5180	677	41	only	only	RB
5180	677	42	applies	apply	VBZ
5180	677	43	to	to	IN
5180	677	44	materials	material	NNS
5180	677	45	classified	classify	VBN
5180	677	46	in	in	IN
5180	677	47	the	the	DT
5180	677	48	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	677	49	category	category	NN
5180	677	50	)	)	-RRB-
5180	677	51	,	,	,
5180	677	52	and	and	CC
5180	677	53	the	the	DT
5180	677	54	remainder	remainder	NN
5180	677	55	are	be	VBP
5180	677	56	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	677	57	by	by	IN
5180	677	58	human	human	JJ
5180	677	59	review	review	NN
5180	677	60	.	.	.
5180	678	1	SurfControl	SurfControl	NNP
5180	678	2	also	also	RB
5180	678	3	states	state	VBZ
5180	678	4	that	that	IN
5180	678	5	no	no	DT
5180	678	6	URL	URL	NNP
5180	678	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	678	8	ever	ever	RB
5180	678	9	added	add	VBN
5180	678	10	to	to	IN
5180	678	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	678	12	database	database	NN
5180	678	13	without	without	IN
5180	678	14	human	human	JJ
5180	678	15	review	review	NN
5180	678	16	.	.	.
5180	679	1	Human	human	JJ
5180	679	2	review	review	NN
5180	679	3	of	of	IN
5180	679	4	Web	web	NN
5180	679	5	pages	page	NNS
5180	679	6	has	have	VBZ
5180	679	7	the	the	DT
5180	679	8	advantage	advantage	NN
5180	679	9	of	of	IN
5180	679	10	allowing	allow	VBG
5180	679	11	more	more	RBR
5180	679	12	nuanced	nuance	VBN
5180	679	13	,	,	,
5180	679	14	if	if	IN
5180	679	15	not	not	RB
5180	679	16	more	more	RBR
5180	679	17	accurate	accurate	JJ
5180	679	18	,	,	,
5180	679	19	interpretations	interpretation	NNS
5180	679	20	than	than	IN
5180	679	21	automated	automated	JJ
5180	679	22	classification	classification	NN
5180	679	23	systems	system	NNS
5180	679	24	are	be	VBP
5180	679	25	capable	capable	JJ
5180	679	26	of	of	IN
5180	679	27	making	make	VBG
5180	679	28	,	,	,
5180	679	29	but	but	CC
5180	679	30	suffers	suffer	NNS
5180	679	31	from	from	IN
5180	679	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	679	33	own	own	JJ
5180	679	34	sources	source	NNS
5180	679	35	of	of	IN
5180	679	36	error	error	NN
5180	679	37	.	.	.
5180	680	1	The	the	DT
5180	680	2	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	680	3	software	software	NN
5180	680	4	companies	company	NNS
5180	680	5	involved	involve	VBN
5180	680	6	here	here	RB
5180	680	7	have	have	VBP
5180	680	8	limited	limit	VBN
5180	680	9	staff	staff	NN
5180	680	10	,	,	,
5180	680	11	of	of	IN
5180	680	12	between	between	IN
5180	680	13	eight	eight	CD
5180	680	14	and	and	CC
5180	680	15	a	a	DT
5180	680	16	few	few	JJ
5180	680	17	dozen	dozen	NN
5180	680	18	people	people	NNS
5180	680	19	,	,	,
5180	680	20	available	available	JJ
5180	680	21	for	for	IN
5180	680	22	hand	hand	NN
5180	680	23	reviewing	reviewing	NN
5180	680	24	Web	web	NN
5180	680	25	pages	page	NNS
5180	680	26	.	.	.
5180	681	1	The	the	DT
5180	681	2	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	681	3	that	that	WDT
5180	681	4	are	be	VBP
5180	681	5	employed	employ	VBN
5180	681	6	by	by	IN
5180	681	7	these	these	DT
5180	681	8	companies	company	NNS
5180	681	9	base	base	VBP
5180	681	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	681	11	categorization	categorization	NN
5180	681	12	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	681	13	on	on	IN
5180	681	14	both	both	CC
5180	681	15	the	the	DT
5180	681	16	text	text	NN
5180	681	17	and	and	CC
5180	681	18	the	the	DT
5180	681	19	visual	visual	JJ
5180	681	20	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	681	21	that	that	WDT
5180	681	22	appear	appear	VBP
5180	681	23	on	on	IN
5180	681	24	the	the	DT
5180	681	25	sites	site	NNS
5180	681	26	or	or	CC
5180	681	27	pages	page	NNS
5180	681	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	681	29	are	be	VBP
5180	681	30	assigned	assign	VBN
5180	681	31	to	to	TO
5180	681	32	review	review	VB
5180	681	33	.	.	.
5180	682	1	Human	human	JJ
5180	682	2	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	682	3	generally	generally	RB
5180	682	4	focus	focus	VBP
5180	682	5	on	on	IN
5180	682	6	English	english	JJ
5180	682	7	language	language	NN
5180	682	8	Web	web	NN
5180	682	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	682	10	,	,	,
5180	682	11	and	and	CC
5180	682	12	are	be	VBP
5180	682	13	generally	generally	RB
5180	682	14	not	not	RB
5180	682	15	required	require	VBN
5180	682	16	to	to	TO
5180	682	17	be	be	VB
5180	682	18	multi	multi	JJ
5180	682	19	-	-	JJ
5180	682	20	lingual	lingual	JJ
5180	682	21	.	.	.
5180	683	1	Given	give	VBN
5180	683	2	the	the	DT
5180	683	3	speed	speed	NN
5180	683	4	at	at	IN
5180	683	5	which	which	WDT
5180	683	6	human	human	JJ
5180	683	7	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	683	8	must	must	MD
5180	683	9	work	work	VB
5180	683	10	to	to	TO
5180	683	11	keep	keep	VB
5180	683	12	up	up	RP
5180	683	13	with	with	IN
5180	683	14	even	even	RB
5180	683	15	a	a	DT
5180	683	16	fraction	fraction	NN
5180	683	17	of	of	IN
5180	683	18	the	the	DT
5180	683	19	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	683	20	1.5	1.5	CD
5180	683	21	million	million	CD
5180	683	22	pages	page	NNS
5180	683	23	added	add	VBN
5180	683	24	to	to	IN
5180	683	25	the	the	DT
5180	683	26	publicly	publicly	RB
5180	683	27	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	683	28	Web	web	NN
5180	683	29	each	each	DT
5180	683	30	day	day	NN
5180	683	31	,	,	,
5180	683	32	human	human	JJ
5180	683	33	error	error	NN
5180	683	34	is	be	VBZ
5180	683	35	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
5180	683	36	.	.	.
5180	684	1	Errors	error	NNS
5180	684	2	are	be	VBP
5180	684	3	likely	likely	JJ
5180	684	4	to	to	TO
5180	684	5	result	result	VB
5180	684	6	from	from	IN
5180	684	7	boredom	boredom	NN
5180	684	8	or	or	CC
5180	684	9	lack	lack	NN
5180	684	10	of	of	IN
5180	684	11	attentiveness	attentiveness	NN
5180	684	12	,	,	,
5180	684	13	overzealousness	overzealousness	JJ
5180	684	14	,	,	,
5180	684	15	or	or	CC
5180	684	16	a	a	DT
5180	684	17	desire	desire	NN
5180	684	18	to	to	TO
5180	684	19	"	"	``
5180	684	20	err	err	VB
5180	684	21	on	on	IN
5180	684	22	the	the	DT
5180	684	23	side	side	NN
5180	684	24	of	of	IN
5180	684	25	caution	caution	NN
5180	684	26	"	"	''
5180	684	27	by	by	IN
5180	684	28	screening	screen	VBG
5180	684	29	out	out	RP
5180	684	30	material	material	NN
5180	684	31	that	that	WDT
5180	684	32	might	may	MD
5180	684	33	be	be	VB
5180	684	34	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	684	35	to	to	IN
5180	684	36	some	some	DT
5180	684	37	customers	customer	NNS
5180	684	38	,	,	,
5180	684	39	even	even	RB
5180	684	40	if	if	IN
5180	684	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	684	42	does	do	VBZ
5180	684	43	not	not	RB
5180	684	44	fit	fit	VB
5180	684	45	within	within	IN
5180	684	46	any	any	DT
5180	684	47	of	of	IN
5180	684	48	the	the	DT
5180	684	49	company	company	NN
5180	684	50	's	's	POS
5180	684	51	category	category	NN
5180	684	52	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	684	53	.	.	.
5180	685	1	None	none	NN
5180	685	2	of	of	IN
5180	685	3	the	the	DT
5180	685	4	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	685	5	companies	company	NNS
5180	685	6	trains	train	VBZ
5180	685	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	685	8	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	685	9	in	in	IN
5180	685	10	the	the	DT
5180	685	11	legal	legal	JJ
5180	685	12	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	685	13	concerning	concern	VBG
5180	685	14	what	what	WP
5180	685	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	685	16	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	685	17	,	,	,
5180	685	18	child	child	NN
5180	685	19	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	685	20	,	,	,
5180	685	21	or	or	CC
5180	685	22	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	685	23	to	to	IN
5180	685	24	minors	minor	NNS
5180	685	25	,	,	,
5180	685	26	and	and	CC
5180	685	27	none	none	NN
5180	685	28	instructs	instruct	VBZ
5180	685	29	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	685	30	to	to	TO
5180	685	31	take	take	VB
5180	685	32	community	community	NN
5180	685	33	standards	standard	NNS
5180	685	34	into	into	IN
5180	685	35	account	account	NN
5180	685	36	when	when	WRB
5180	685	37	making	make	VBG
5180	685	38	categorization	categorization	NN
5180	685	39	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	685	40	.	.	.
5180	686	1	Perhaps	perhaps	RB
5180	686	2	because	because	IN
5180	686	3	of	of	IN
5180	686	4	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	686	5	on	on	IN
5180	686	6	the	the	DT
5180	686	7	number	number	NN
5180	686	8	of	of	IN
5180	686	9	human	human	JJ
5180	686	10	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	686	11	and	and	CC
5180	686	12	because	because	IN
5180	686	13	of	of	IN
5180	686	14	the	the	DT
5180	686	15	large	large	JJ
5180	686	16	number	number	NN
5180	686	17	of	of	IN
5180	686	18	new	new	JJ
5180	686	19	pages	page	NNS
5180	686	20	that	that	WDT
5180	686	21	are	be	VBP
5180	686	22	added	add	VBN
5180	686	23	to	to	IN
5180	686	24	the	the	DT
5180	686	25	Web	web	NN
5180	686	26	every	every	DT
5180	686	27	day	day	NN
5180	686	28	,	,	,
5180	686	29	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	686	30	companies	company	NNS
5180	686	31	also	also	RB
5180	686	32	widely	widely	RB
5180	686	33	engage	engage	VBP
5180	686	34	in	in	IN
5180	686	35	the	the	DT
5180	686	36	practice	practice	NN
5180	686	37	of	of	IN
5180	686	38	categorizing	categorize	VBG
5180	686	39	entire	entire	JJ
5180	686	40	Web	web	NN
5180	686	41	sites	site	NNS
5180	686	42	at	at	IN
5180	686	43	the	the	DT
5180	686	44	"	"	``
5180	686	45	root	root	NN
5180	686	46	URL	url	NN
5180	686	47	,	,	,
5180	686	48	"	"	''
5180	686	49	rather	rather	RB
5180	686	50	than	than	IN
5180	686	51	engaging	engage	VBG
5180	686	52	in	in	IN
5180	686	53	a	a	DT
5180	686	54	more	more	RBR
5180	686	55	fine	fine	RB
5180	686	56	-	-	HYPH
5180	686	57	grained	grain	VBN
5180	686	58	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	686	59	of	of	IN
5180	686	60	the	the	DT
5180	686	61	individual	individual	JJ
5180	686	62	pages	page	NNS
5180	686	63	within	within	IN
5180	686	64	a	a	DT
5180	686	65	Web	web	NN
5180	686	66	site	site	NN
5180	686	67	.	.	.
5180	687	1	For	for	IN
5180	687	2	example	example	NN
5180	687	3	,	,	,
5180	687	4	the	the	DT
5180	687	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	687	6	software	software	NN
5180	687	7	companies	company	NNS
5180	687	8	deposed	depose	VBN
5180	687	9	in	in	IN
5180	687	10	this	this	DT
5180	687	11	case	case	NN
5180	687	12	all	all	DT
5180	687	13	categorize	categorize	VBP
5180	687	14	the	the	DT
5180	687	15	entire	entire	JJ
5180	687	16	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	687	17	Web	web	NN
5180	687	18	site	site	NN
5180	687	19	as	as	IN
5180	687	20	Adult	Adult	NNP
5180	687	21	,	,	,
5180	687	22	Sexually	Sexually	NNP
5180	687	23	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	687	24	,	,	,
5180	687	25	or	or	CC
5180	687	26	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	687	27	.	.	.
5180	688	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
5180	688	2	do	do	VBP
5180	688	3	not	not	RB
5180	688	4	differentiate	differentiate	VB
5180	688	5	between	between	IN
5180	688	6	pages	page	NNS
5180	688	7	within	within	IN
5180	688	8	the	the	DT
5180	688	9	site	site	NN
5180	688	10	containing	contain	VBG
5180	688	11	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	688	12	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	688	13	images	image	NNS
5180	688	14	or	or	CC
5180	688	15	text	text	NN
5180	688	16	,	,	,
5180	688	17	and	and	CC
5180	688	18	for	for	IN
5180	688	19	example	example	NN
5180	688	20	,	,	,
5180	688	21	pages	page	NNS
5180	688	22	containing	contain	VBG
5180	688	23	no	no	DT
5180	688	24	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	688	25	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	688	26	content	content	NN
5180	688	27	,	,	,
5180	688	28	such	such	JJ
5180	688	29	as	as	IN
5180	688	30	the	the	DT
5180	688	31	text	text	NN
5180	688	32	of	of	IN
5180	688	33	interviews	interview	NNS
5180	688	34	of	of	IN
5180	688	35	celebrities	celebrity	NNS
5180	688	36	or	or	CC
5180	688	37	politicians	politician	NNS
5180	688	38	.	.	.
5180	689	1	If	if	IN
5180	689	2	the	the	DT
5180	689	3	"	"	``
5180	689	4	root	root	NN
5180	689	5	"	"	''
5180	689	6	or	or	CC
5180	689	7	"	"	``
5180	689	8	top	top	JJ
5180	689	9	-	-	HYPH
5180	689	10	level	level	NN
5180	689	11	"	"	''
5180	689	12	URL	url	NN
5180	689	13	of	of	IN
5180	689	14	a	a	DT
5180	689	15	Web	web	NN
5180	689	16	site	site	NN
5180	689	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	689	18	given	give	VBN
5180	689	19	a	a	DT
5180	689	20	category	category	NN
5180	689	21	tag	tag	NN
5180	689	22	,	,	,
5180	689	23	then	then	RB
5180	689	24	access	access	VB
5180	689	25	to	to	IN
5180	689	26	all	all	DT
5180	689	27	content	content	NN
5180	689	28	on	on	IN
5180	689	29	that	that	DT
5180	689	30	Web	web	NN
5180	689	31	site	site	NN
5180	689	32	will	will	MD
5180	689	33	be	be	VB
5180	689	34	blocked	block	VBN
5180	689	35	if	if	IN
5180	689	36	the	the	DT
5180	689	37	assigned	assign	VBN
5180	689	38	category	category	NN
5180	689	39	is	be	VBZ
5180	689	40	enabled	enable	VBN
5180	689	41	by	by	IN
5180	689	42	a	a	DT
5180	689	43	customer	customer	NN
5180	689	44	.	.	.
5180	690	1	In	in	IN
5180	690	2	some	some	DT
5180	690	3	cases	case	NNS
5180	690	4	,	,	,
5180	690	5	whole	whole	JJ
5180	690	6	Web	web	NN
5180	690	7	sites	site	NNS
5180	690	8	are	be	VBP
5180	690	9	blocked	block	VBN
5180	690	10	because	because	IN
5180	690	11	the	the	DT
5180	690	12	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	690	13	companies	company	NNS
5180	690	14	focus	focus	VBP
5180	690	15	only	only	RB
5180	690	16	on	on	IN
5180	690	17	the	the	DT
5180	690	18	content	content	NN
5180	690	19	of	of	IN
5180	690	20	the	the	DT
5180	690	21	home	home	NN
5180	690	22	page	page	NN
5180	690	23	that	that	WDT
5180	690	24	is	be	VBZ
5180	690	25	accessed	access	VBN
5180	690	26	by	by	IN
5180	690	27	entering	enter	VBG
5180	690	28	the	the	DT
5180	690	29	root	root	NN
5180	690	30	URL	url	NN
5180	690	31	.	.	.
5180	691	1	Entire	entire	JJ
5180	691	2	Web	web	NN
5180	691	3	sites	site	NNS
5180	691	4	containing	contain	VBG
5180	691	5	multiple	multiple	JJ
5180	691	6	Web	web	NN
5180	691	7	pages	page	NNS
5180	691	8	are	be	VBP
5180	691	9	commonly	commonly	RB
5180	691	10	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	691	11	without	without	IN
5180	691	12	human	human	JJ
5180	691	13	review	review	NN
5180	691	14	of	of	IN
5180	691	15	each	each	DT
5180	691	16	individual	individual	JJ
5180	691	17	page	page	NN
5180	691	18	on	on	IN
5180	691	19	that	that	DT
5180	691	20	site	site	NN
5180	691	21	.	.	.
5180	692	1	Web	web	NN
5180	692	2	sites	site	NNS
5180	692	3	that	that	WDT
5180	692	4	may	may	MD
5180	692	5	contain	contain	VB
5180	692	6	multiple	multiple	JJ
5180	692	7	Web	web	NN
5180	692	8	pages	page	NNS
5180	692	9	and	and	CC
5180	692	10	that	that	WDT
5180	692	11	require	require	VBP
5180	692	12	authentication	authentication	NN
5180	692	13	or	or	CC
5180	692	14	payment	payment	NN
5180	692	15	for	for	IN
5180	692	16	access	access	NN
5180	692	17	are	be	VBP
5180	692	18	commonly	commonly	RB
5180	692	19	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	692	20	based	base	VBN
5180	692	21	solely	solely	RB
5180	692	22	on	on	IN
5180	692	23	a	a	DT
5180	692	24	human	human	JJ
5180	692	25	reviewer	reviewer	NN
5180	692	26	's	's	POS
5180	692	27	evaluation	evaluation	NN
5180	692	28	of	of	IN
5180	692	29	the	the	DT
5180	692	30	pages	page	NNS
5180	692	31	that	that	WDT
5180	692	32	may	may	MD
5180	692	33	be	be	VB
5180	692	34	viewed	view	VBN
5180	692	35	prior	prior	RB
5180	692	36	to	to	IN
5180	692	37	reaching	reach	VBG
5180	692	38	the	the	DT
5180	692	39	authentication	authentication	NN
5180	692	40	or	or	CC
5180	692	41	payment	payment	NN
5180	692	42	page	page	NN
5180	692	43	.	.	.
5180	693	1	Because	because	IN
5180	693	2	there	there	EX
5180	693	3	may	may	MD
5180	693	4	be	be	VB
5180	693	5	hundreds	hundred	NNS
5180	693	6	or	or	CC
5180	693	7	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	693	8	of	of	IN
5180	693	9	pages	page	NNS
5180	693	10	under	under	IN
5180	693	11	a	a	DT
5180	693	12	root	root	NN
5180	693	13	URL	url	NN
5180	693	14	,	,	,
5180	693	15	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	693	16	companies	company	NNS
5180	693	17	make	make	VBP
5180	693	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	693	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	693	20	primary	primary	JJ
5180	693	21	mission	mission	NN
5180	693	22	to	to	TO
5180	693	23	categorize	categorize	VB
5180	693	24	the	the	DT
5180	693	25	root	root	NN
5180	693	26	URL	url	NN
5180	693	27	,	,	,
5180	693	28	and	and	CC
5180	693	29	categorize	categorize	VB
5180	693	30	subsidiary	subsidiary	NN
5180	693	31	pages	page	NNS
5180	693	32	if	if	IN
5180	693	33	the	the	DT
5180	693	34	need	need	NN
5180	693	35	arises	arise	VBZ
5180	693	36	or	or	CC
5180	693	37	if	if	IN
5180	693	38	there	there	EX
5180	693	39	is	be	VBZ
5180	693	40	time	time	NN
5180	693	41	.	.	.
5180	694	1	This	this	DT
5180	694	2	form	form	NN
5180	694	3	of	of	IN
5180	694	4	overblocking	overblocking	NN
5180	694	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	694	6	called	call	VBN
5180	694	7	"	"	``
5180	694	8	inheritance	inheritance	NN
5180	694	9	,	,	,
5180	694	10	"	"	''
5180	694	11	because	because	IN
5180	694	12	lower	low	JJR
5180	694	13	-	-	HYPH
5180	694	14	level	level	NN
5180	694	15	pages	page	NNS
5180	694	16	inherit	inherit	VBP
5180	694	17	the	the	DT
5180	694	18	categorization	categorization	NN
5180	694	19	of	of	IN
5180	694	20	the	the	DT
5180	694	21	root	root	NN
5180	694	22	URL	url	NN
5180	694	23	without	without	IN
5180	694	24	regard	regard	NN
5180	694	25	to	to	IN
5180	694	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	694	27	specific	specific	JJ
5180	694	28	content	content	NN
5180	694	29	.	.	.
5180	695	1	In	in	IN
5180	695	2	some	some	DT
5180	695	3	cases	case	NNS
5180	695	4	,	,	,
5180	695	5	"	"	``
5180	695	6	reverse	reverse	JJ
5180	695	7	inheritance	inheritance	NN
5180	695	8	"	"	''
5180	695	9	also	also	RB
5180	695	10	occurs	occur	VBZ
5180	695	11	,	,	,
5180	695	12	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	695	13	,	,	,
5180	695	14	parent	parent	NN
5180	695	15	sites	site	NNS
5180	695	16	inherit	inherit	VBP
5180	695	17	the	the	DT
5180	695	18	classification	classification	NN
5180	695	19	of	of	IN
5180	695	20	pages	page	NNS
5180	695	21	in	in	IN
5180	695	22	a	a	DT
5180	695	23	lower	low	JJR
5180	695	24	level	level	NN
5180	695	25	of	of	IN
5180	695	26	the	the	DT
5180	695	27	site	site	NN
5180	695	28	.	.	.
5180	696	1	This	this	DT
5180	696	2	might	may	MD
5180	696	3	happen	happen	VB
5180	696	4	when	when	WRB
5180	696	5	pages	page	NNS
5180	696	6	with	with	IN
5180	696	7	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	696	8	content	content	NN
5180	696	9	appear	appear	VBP
5180	696	10	in	in	IN
5180	696	11	a	a	DT
5180	696	12	Web	web	NN
5180	696	13	site	site	NN
5180	696	14	that	that	WDT
5180	696	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	696	16	devoted	devote	VBN
5180	696	17	primarily	primarily	RB
5180	696	18	to	to	IN
5180	696	19	non	non	JJ
5180	696	20	-	-	JJ
5180	696	21	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	696	22	content	content	NN
5180	696	23	.	.	.
5180	697	1	For	for	IN
5180	697	2	example	example	NN
5180	697	3	,	,	,
5180	697	4	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	697	5	's	's	POS
5180	697	6	Bess	Bess	NNP
5180	697	7	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	697	8	product	product	NN
5180	697	9	classifies	classifie	NNS
5180	697	10	every	every	DT
5180	697	11	page	page	NN
5180	697	12	in	in	IN
5180	697	13	the	the	DT
5180	697	14	Salon.com	Salon.com	NNP
5180	697	15	Web	web	NN
5180	697	16	site	site	NN
5180	697	17	,	,	,
5180	697	18	which	which	WDT
5180	697	19	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	697	20	a	a	DT
5180	697	21	wide	wide	JJ
5180	697	22	range	range	NN
5180	697	23	of	of	IN
5180	697	24	news	news	NN
5180	697	25	and	and	CC
5180	697	26	cultural	cultural	JJ
5180	697	27	commentary	commentary	NN
5180	697	28	,	,	,
5180	697	29	as	as	IN
5180	697	30	"	"	``
5180	697	31	Sex	Sex	NNP
5180	697	32	,	,	,
5180	697	33	Profanity	Profanity	NNP
5180	697	34	,	,	,
5180	697	35	"	"	''
5180	697	36	based	base	VBN
5180	697	37	on	on	IN
5180	697	38	the	the	DT
5180	697	39	fact	fact	NN
5180	697	40	that	that	IN
5180	697	41	the	the	DT
5180	697	42	site	site	NN
5180	697	43	includes	include	VBZ
5180	697	44	a	a	DT
5180	697	45	regular	regular	JJ
5180	697	46	column	column	NN
5180	697	47	that	that	WDT
5180	697	48	deals	deal	VBZ
5180	697	49	with	with	IN
5180	697	50	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	697	51	issues	issue	NNS
5180	697	52	.	.	.
5180	698	1	Blocking	block	VBG
5180	698	2	by	by	IN
5180	698	3	both	both	DT
5180	698	4	domain	domain	NN
5180	698	5	name	name	NN
5180	698	6	and	and	CC
5180	698	7	IP	IP	NNP
5180	698	8	address	address	NN
5180	698	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	698	10	another	another	DT
5180	698	11	practice	practice	NN
5180	698	12	in	in	IN
5180	698	13	which	which	WDT
5180	698	14	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	698	15	companies	company	NNS
5180	698	16	engage	engage	VBP
5180	698	17	that	that	DT
5180	698	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	698	19	a	a	DT
5180	698	20	function	function	NN
5180	698	21	both	both	DT
5180	698	22	of	of	IN
5180	698	23	the	the	DT
5180	698	24	architecture	architecture	NN
5180	698	25	of	of	IN
5180	698	26	the	the	DT
5180	698	27	Web	web	NN
5180	698	28	and	and	CC
5180	698	29	of	of	IN
5180	698	30	the	the	DT
5180	698	31	exigencies	exigency	NNS
5180	698	32	of	of	IN
5180	698	33	dealing	deal	VBG
5180	698	34	with	with	IN
5180	698	35	the	the	DT
5180	698	36	rapidly	rapidly	RB
5180	698	37	expanding	expand	VBG
5180	698	38	number	number	NN
5180	698	39	of	of	IN
5180	698	40	Web	web	NN
5180	698	41	pages	page	NNS
5180	698	42	.	.	.
5180	699	1	The	the	DT
5180	699	2	category	category	NN
5180	699	3	lists	list	NNS
5180	699	4	maintained	maintain	VBN
5180	699	5	by	by	IN
5180	699	6	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	699	7	software	software	NN
5180	699	8	companies	company	NNS
5180	699	9	can	can	MD
5180	699	10	include	include	VB
5180	699	11	URLs	url	NNS
5180	699	12	in	in	IN
5180	699	13	either	either	CC
5180	699	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	699	15	human	human	JJ
5180	699	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	699	17	readable	readable	JJ
5180	699	18	domain	domain	NN
5180	699	19	name	name	NN
5180	699	20	address	address	NN
5180	699	21	form	form	NN
5180	699	22	,	,	,
5180	699	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	699	24	numeric	numeric	JJ
5180	699	25	IP	IP	NNP
5180	699	26	address	address	NN
5180	699	27	form	form	NN
5180	699	28	,	,	,
5180	699	29	or	or	CC
5180	699	30	both	both	DT
5180	699	31	.	.	.
5180	700	1	Through	through	IN
5180	700	2	"	"	``
5180	700	3	virtual	virtual	JJ
5180	700	4	hosting	hosting	NN
5180	700	5	"	"	''
5180	700	6	services	service	NNS
5180	700	7	,	,	,
5180	700	8	hundreds	hundred	NNS
5180	700	9	of	of	IN
5180	700	10	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	700	11	of	of	IN
5180	700	12	Web	web	NN
5180	700	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	700	14	with	with	IN
5180	700	15	distinct	distinct	JJ
5180	700	16	domain	domain	NN
5180	700	17	names	name	NNS
5180	700	18	may	may	MD
5180	700	19	share	share	VB
5180	700	20	a	a	DT
5180	700	21	single	single	JJ
5180	700	22	numeric	numeric	JJ
5180	700	23	IP	IP	NNP
5180	700	24	address	address	NN
5180	700	25	.	.	.
5180	701	1	To	to	IN
5180	701	2	the	the	DT
5180	701	3	extent	extent	NN
5180	701	4	that	that	IN
5180	701	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	701	6	companies	company	NNS
5180	701	7	block	block	VBP
5180	701	8	the	the	DT
5180	701	9	IP	IP	NNP
5180	701	10	addresses	address	NNS
5180	701	11	of	of	IN
5180	701	12	virtual	virtual	JJ
5180	701	13	hosting	hosting	NN
5180	701	14	services	service	NNS
5180	701	15	,	,	,
5180	701	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	701	17	will	will	MD
5180	701	18	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	701	19	block	block	VB
5180	701	20	a	a	DT
5180	701	21	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	701	22	amount	amount	NN
5180	701	23	of	of	IN
5180	701	24	content	content	NN
5180	701	25	without	without	IN
5180	701	26	reviewing	review	VBG
5180	701	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	701	28	,	,	,
5180	701	29	and	and	CC
5180	701	30	will	will	MD
5180	701	31	likely	likely	RB
5180	701	32	overblock	overblock	VB
5180	701	33	a	a	DT
5180	701	34	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	701	35	amount	amount	NN
5180	701	36	of	of	IN
5180	701	37	content	content	NN
5180	701	38	.	.	.
5180	702	1	Another	another	DT
5180	702	2	technique	technique	NN
5180	702	3	that	that	IN
5180	702	4	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	702	5	companies	company	NNS
5180	702	6	use	use	VBP
5180	702	7	in	in	IN
5180	702	8	order	order	NN
5180	702	9	to	to	TO
5180	702	10	deal	deal	VB
5180	702	11	with	with	IN
5180	702	12	a	a	DT
5180	702	13	structural	structural	JJ
5180	702	14	feature	feature	NN
5180	702	15	of	of	IN
5180	702	16	the	the	DT
5180	702	17	Internet	internet	NN
5180	702	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	702	19	blocking	block	VBG
5180	702	20	the	the	DT
5180	702	21	root	root	NN
5180	702	22	level	level	NN
5180	702	23	URLs	url	NNS
5180	702	24	of	of	IN
5180	702	25	so	so	RB
5180	702	26	-	-	HYPH
5180	702	27	called	call	VBN
5180	702	28	"	"	``
5180	702	29	loophole	loophole	NN
5180	702	30	"	"	''
5180	702	31	Web	web	NN
5180	702	32	sites	site	NNS
5180	702	33	.	.	.
5180	703	1	These	these	DT
5180	703	2	are	be	VBP
5180	703	3	Web	web	NN
5180	703	4	sites	site	NNS
5180	703	5	that	that	WDT
5180	703	6	provide	provide	VBP
5180	703	7	access	access	NN
5180	703	8	to	to	IN
5180	703	9	a	a	DT
5180	703	10	particular	particular	JJ
5180	703	11	Web	web	NN
5180	703	12	page	page	NN
5180	703	13	,	,	,
5180	703	14	but	but	CC
5180	703	15	display	display	VB
5180	703	16	in	in	IN
5180	703	17	the	the	DT
5180	703	18	user	user	NN
5180	703	19	's	's	POS
5180	703	20	browser	browser	NN
5180	703	21	a	a	DT
5180	703	22	URL	url	NN
5180	703	23	that	that	WDT
5180	703	24	is	be	VBZ
5180	703	25	different	different	JJ
5180	703	26	from	from	IN
5180	703	27	the	the	DT
5180	703	28	URL	url	NN
5180	703	29	with	with	IN
5180	703	30	which	which	WDT
5180	703	31	the	the	DT
5180	703	32	particular	particular	JJ
5180	703	33	page	page	NN
5180	703	34	is	be	VBZ
5180	703	35	usually	usually	RB
5180	703	36	associated	associate	VBN
5180	703	37	.	.	.
5180	704	1	Because	because	IN
5180	704	2	of	of	IN
5180	704	3	this	this	DT
5180	704	4	feature	feature	NN
5180	704	5	,	,	,
5180	704	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	704	7	provide	provide	VBP
5180	704	8	a	a	DT
5180	704	9	"	"	``
5180	704	10	loophole	loophole	NN
5180	704	11	"	"	''
5180	704	12	that	that	WDT
5180	704	13	can	can	MD
5180	704	14	be	be	VB
5180	704	15	used	use	VBN
5180	704	16	to	to	TO
5180	704	17	get	get	VB
5180	704	18	around	around	RB
5180	704	19	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	704	20	software	software	NN
5180	704	21	,	,	,
5180	704	22	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	704	23	,	,	,
5180	704	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	704	25	display	display	VBP
5180	704	26	a	a	DT
5180	704	27	URL	url	NN
5180	704	28	that	that	WDT
5180	704	29	is	be	VBZ
5180	704	30	different	different	JJ
5180	704	31	from	from	IN
5180	704	32	the	the	DT
5180	704	33	one	one	NN
5180	704	34	that	that	WDT
5180	704	35	appears	appear	VBZ
5180	704	36	on	on	IN
5180	704	37	the	the	DT
5180	704	38	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	704	39	company	company	NN
5180	704	40	's	's	POS
5180	704	41	control	control	NN
5180	704	42	list	list	NN
5180	704	43	.	.	.
5180	705	1	"	"	``
5180	705	2	Loophole	Loophole	NNP
5180	705	3	"	"	''
5180	705	4	Web	web	NN
5180	705	5	sites	site	NNS
5180	705	6	include	include	VBP
5180	705	7	caches	cache	NNS
5180	705	8	of	of	IN
5180	705	9	Web	web	NN
5180	705	10	pages	page	NNS
5180	705	11	that	that	WDT
5180	705	12	have	have	VBP
5180	705	13	been	be	VBN
5180	705	14	removed	remove	VBN
5180	705	15	from	from	IN
5180	705	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	705	17	original	original	JJ
5180	705	18	location	location	NN
5180	705	19	,	,	,
5180	705	20	"	"	''
5180	705	21	anonymizer	anonymizer	NN
5180	705	22	"	"	''
5180	705	23	sites	site	NNS
5180	705	24	,	,	,
5180	705	25	and	and	CC
5180	705	26	translation	translation	NN
5180	705	27	sites	site	NNS
5180	705	28	.	.	.
5180	706	1	Caches	cache	NNS
5180	706	2	are	be	VBP
5180	706	3	archived	archive	VBN
5180	706	4	copies	copy	NNS
5180	706	5	that	that	IN
5180	706	6	some	some	DT
5180	706	7	search	search	NN
5180	706	8	engines	engine	NNS
5180	706	9	,	,	,
5180	706	10	such	such	JJ
5180	706	11	as	as	IN
5180	706	12	Google	Google	NNP
5180	706	13	,	,	,
5180	706	14	keep	keep	VBP
5180	706	15	of	of	IN
5180	706	16	the	the	DT
5180	706	17	Web	web	NN
5180	706	18	pages	page	NNS
5180	706	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	706	20	index	index	VBP
5180	706	21	.	.	.
5180	707	1	The	the	DT
5180	707	2	cached	cached	JJ
5180	707	3	copy	copy	NN
5180	707	4	stored	store	VBN
5180	707	5	by	by	IN
5180	707	6	Google	Google	NNP
5180	707	7	will	will	MD
5180	707	8	have	have	VB
5180	707	9	a	a	DT
5180	707	10	URL	url	NN
5180	707	11	that	that	WDT
5180	707	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	707	13	different	different	JJ
5180	707	14	from	from	IN
5180	707	15	the	the	DT
5180	707	16	original	original	JJ
5180	707	17	URL	url	NN
5180	707	18	.	.	.
5180	708	1	Because	because	IN
5180	708	2	Web	web	NN
5180	708	3	sites	site	NNS
5180	708	4	often	often	RB
5180	708	5	change	change	VBP
5180	708	6	rapidly	rapidly	RB
5180	708	7	,	,	,
5180	708	8	caches	cache	NNS
5180	708	9	are	be	VBP
5180	708	10	the	the	DT
5180	708	11	only	only	JJ
5180	708	12	way	way	NN
5180	708	13	to	to	TO
5180	708	14	access	access	VB
5180	708	15	pages	page	NNS
5180	708	16	that	that	WDT
5180	708	17	have	have	VBP
5180	708	18	been	be	VBN
5180	708	19	taken	take	VBN
5180	708	20	down	down	RP
5180	708	21	,	,	,
5180	708	22	revised	revise	VBN
5180	708	23	,	,	,
5180	708	24	or	or	CC
5180	708	25	have	have	VBP
5180	708	26	changed	change	VBN
5180	708	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	708	28	URLs	url	NNS
5180	708	29	for	for	IN
5180	708	30	some	some	DT
5180	708	31	reason	reason	NN
5180	708	32	.	.	.
5180	709	1	For	for	IN
5180	709	2	example	example	NN
5180	709	3	,	,	,
5180	709	4	a	a	DT
5180	709	5	magazine	magazine	NN
5180	709	6	might	may	MD
5180	709	7	place	place	VB
5180	709	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	709	9	current	current	JJ
5180	709	10	stories	story	NNS
5180	709	11	under	under	IN
5180	709	12	a	a	DT
5180	709	13	given	give	VBN
5180	709	14	URL	url	NN
5180	709	15	,	,	,
5180	709	16	and	and	CC
5180	709	17	replace	replace	VB
5180	709	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	709	19	monthly	monthly	RB
5180	709	20	with	with	IN
5180	709	21	new	new	JJ
5180	709	22	stories	story	NNS
5180	709	23	.	.	.
5180	710	1	If	if	IN
5180	710	2	a	a	DT
5180	710	3	user	user	NN
5180	710	4	wanted	want	VBD
5180	710	5	to	to	TO
5180	710	6	find	find	VB
5180	710	7	an	an	DT
5180	710	8	article	article	NN
5180	710	9	published	publish	VBN
5180	710	10	six	six	CD
5180	710	11	months	month	NNS
5180	710	12	ago	ago	RB
5180	710	13	,	,	,
5180	710	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	710	15	or	or	CC
5180	710	16	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	710	17	would	would	MD
5180	710	18	be	be	VB
5180	710	19	unable	unable	JJ
5180	710	20	to	to	TO
5180	710	21	access	access	VB
5180	710	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	710	23	if	if	IN
5180	710	24	not	not	RB
5180	710	25	for	for	IN
5180	710	26	Google	Google	NNP
5180	710	27	's	's	POS
5180	710	28	cached	cached	JJ
5180	710	29	version	version	NN
5180	710	30	.	.	.
5180	711	1	Some	some	DT
5180	711	2	sites	site	NNS
5180	711	3	on	on	IN
5180	711	4	the	the	DT
5180	711	5	Web	web	NN
5180	711	6	serve	serve	NN
5180	711	7	as	as	IN
5180	711	8	a	a	DT
5180	711	9	proxy	proxy	NN
5180	711	10	or	or	CC
5180	711	11	intermediary	intermediary	NN
5180	711	12	between	between	IN
5180	711	13	a	a	DT
5180	711	14	user	user	NN
5180	711	15	and	and	CC
5180	711	16	another	another	DT
5180	711	17	Web	web	NN
5180	711	18	page	page	NN
5180	711	19	.	.	.
5180	712	1	When	when	WRB
5180	712	2	using	use	VBG
5180	712	3	a	a	DT
5180	712	4	proxy	proxy	JJ
5180	712	5	server	server	NN
5180	712	6	,	,	,
5180	712	7	a	a	DT
5180	712	8	user	user	NN
5180	712	9	does	do	VBZ
5180	712	10	not	not	RB
5180	712	11	access	access	VB
5180	712	12	the	the	DT
5180	712	13	page	page	NN
5180	712	14	from	from	IN
5180	712	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	712	16	original	original	JJ
5180	712	17	URL	url	NN
5180	712	18	,	,	,
5180	712	19	but	but	CC
5180	712	20	rather	rather	RB
5180	712	21	from	from	IN
5180	712	22	the	the	DT
5180	712	23	URL	url	NN
5180	712	24	of	of	IN
5180	712	25	the	the	DT
5180	712	26	proxy	proxy	JJ
5180	712	27	server	server	NN
5180	712	28	.	.	.
5180	713	1	One	one	CD
5180	713	2	type	type	NN
5180	713	3	of	of	IN
5180	713	4	proxy	proxy	NN
5180	713	5	service	service	NN
5180	713	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	713	7	an	an	DT
5180	713	8	"	"	``
5180	713	9	anonymizer	anonymizer	NN
5180	713	10	.	.	.
5180	713	11	"	"	''
5180	714	1	Users	user	NNS
5180	714	2	may	may	MD
5180	714	3	access	access	VB
5180	714	4	Web	web	NN
5180	714	5	sites	site	NNS
5180	714	6	indirectly	indirectly	RB
5180	714	7	via	via	IN
5180	714	8	an	an	DT
5180	714	9	anonymizer	anonymizer	NN
5180	714	10	when	when	WRB
5180	714	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	714	12	do	do	VBP
5180	714	13	not	not	RB
5180	714	14	want	want	VB
5180	714	15	the	the	DT
5180	714	16	Web	web	NN
5180	714	17	site	site	NN
5180	714	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	714	19	are	be	VBP
5180	714	20	visiting	visit	VBG
5180	714	21	to	to	TO
5180	714	22	be	be	VB
5180	714	23	able	able	JJ
5180	714	24	to	to	TO
5180	714	25	determine	determine	VB
5180	714	26	the	the	DT
5180	714	27	IP	IP	NNP
5180	714	28	address	address	NN
5180	714	29	from	from	IN
5180	714	30	which	which	WDT
5180	714	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	714	32	are	be	VBP
5180	714	33	accessing	access	VBG
5180	714	34	the	the	DT
5180	714	35	site	site	NN
5180	714	36	,	,	,
5180	714	37	or	or	CC
5180	714	38	to	to	TO
5180	714	39	leave	leave	VB
5180	714	40	"	"	``
5180	714	41	cookies	cookie	NNS
5180	714	42	"	"	''
5180	714	43	on	on	IN
5180	714	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	714	45	browser	browser	NN
5180	714	46	.	.	.
5180	715	1	Some	some	DT
5180	715	2	proxy	proxy	NN
5180	715	3	servers	server	NNS
5180	715	4	can	can	MD
5180	715	5	be	be	VB
5180	715	6	used	use	VBN
5180	715	7	to	to	TO
5180	715	8	attempt	attempt	VB
5180	715	9	to	to	TO
5180	715	10	translate	translate	VB
5180	715	11	Web	web	NN
5180	715	12	page	page	NN
5180	715	13	content	content	NN
5180	715	14	from	from	IN
5180	715	15	one	one	CD
5180	715	16	language	language	NN
5180	715	17	to	to	IN
5180	715	18	another	another	DT
5180	715	19	.	.	.
5180	716	1	Rather	rather	RB
5180	716	2	than	than	IN
5180	716	3	directly	directly	RB
5180	716	4	accessing	access	VBG
5180	716	5	the	the	DT
5180	716	6	original	original	JJ
5180	716	7	Web	web	NN
5180	716	8	page	page	NN
5180	716	9	in	in	IN
5180	716	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	716	11	original	original	JJ
5180	716	12	language	language	NN
5180	716	13	,	,	,
5180	716	14	users	user	NNS
5180	716	15	can	can	MD
5180	716	16	instead	instead	RB
5180	716	17	indirectly	indirectly	RB
5180	716	18	access	access	VB
5180	716	19	the	the	DT
5180	716	20	page	page	NN
5180	716	21	via	via	IN
5180	716	22	a	a	DT
5180	716	23	proxy	proxy	JJ
5180	716	24	server	server	NN
5180	716	25	offering	offer	VBG
5180	716	26	translation	translation	NN
5180	716	27	features	feature	NNS
5180	716	28	.	.	.
5180	717	1	As	as	IN
5180	717	2	noted	note	VBN
5180	717	3	above	above	RB
5180	717	4	,	,	,
5180	717	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	717	6	companies	company	NNS
5180	717	7	often	often	RB
5180	717	8	block	block	VBP
5180	717	9	loophole	loophole	NN
5180	717	10	sites	site	NNS
5180	717	11	,	,	,
5180	717	12	such	such	JJ
5180	717	13	as	as	IN
5180	717	14	caches	cache	NNS
5180	717	15	,	,	,
5180	717	16	anonymizers	anonymizer	NNS
5180	717	17	,	,	,
5180	717	18	and	and	CC
5180	717	19	translation	translation	NN
5180	717	20	sites	site	NNS
5180	717	21	.	.	.
5180	718	1	The	the	DT
5180	718	2	practice	practice	NN
5180	718	3	of	of	IN
5180	718	4	blocking	block	VBG
5180	718	5	loophole	loophole	NN
5180	718	6	sites	site	NNS
5180	718	7	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	718	8	results	result	VBZ
5180	718	9	in	in	IN
5180	718	10	a	a	DT
5180	718	11	significant	significant	JJ
5180	718	12	amount	amount	NN
5180	718	13	of	of	IN
5180	718	14	overblocking	overblocking	NN
5180	718	15	,	,	,
5180	718	16	because	because	IN
5180	718	17	the	the	DT
5180	718	18	vast	vast	JJ
5180	718	19	majority	majority	NN
5180	718	20	of	of	IN
5180	718	21	the	the	DT
5180	718	22	pages	page	NNS
5180	718	23	that	that	WDT
5180	718	24	are	be	VBP
5180	718	25	cached	cache	VBN
5180	718	26	,	,	,
5180	718	27	for	for	IN
5180	718	28	example	example	NN
5180	718	29	,	,	,
5180	718	30	do	do	VB
5180	718	31	not	not	RB
5180	718	32	contain	contain	VB
5180	718	33	content	content	NN
5180	718	34	that	that	WDT
5180	718	35	would	would	MD
5180	718	36	match	match	VB
5180	718	37	a	a	DT
5180	718	38	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	718	39	company	company	NN
5180	718	40	's	's	POS
5180	718	41	category	category	NN
5180	718	42	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	718	43	.	.	.
5180	719	1	Filters	filter	NNS
5180	719	2	that	that	WDT
5180	719	3	do	do	VBP
5180	719	4	not	not	RB
5180	719	5	block	block	VB
5180	719	6	these	these	DT
5180	719	7	loophole	loophole	NN
5180	719	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	719	9	,	,	,
5180	719	10	however	however	RB
5180	719	11	,	,	,
5180	719	12	may	may	MD
5180	719	13	enable	enable	VB
5180	719	14	users	user	NNS
5180	719	15	to	to	TO
5180	719	16	access	access	VB
5180	719	17	any	any	DT
5180	719	18	URL	url	NN
5180	719	19	on	on	IN
5180	719	20	the	the	DT
5180	719	21	Web	web	NN
5180	719	22	via	via	IN
5180	719	23	the	the	DT
5180	719	24	loophole	loophole	NN
5180	719	25	site	site	NN
5180	719	26	,	,	,
5180	719	27	thus	thus	RB
5180	719	28	resulting	result	VBG
5180	719	29	in	in	IN
5180	719	30	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	719	31	underblocking	underblocking	NN
5180	719	32	.	.	.
5180	720	1	3	3	LS
5180	720	2	.	.	.
5180	721	1	The	the	DT
5180	721	2	Process	Process	NNP
5180	721	3	for	for	IN
5180	721	4	"	"	``
5180	721	5	Re	Re	NNP
5180	721	6	-	-	NN
5180	721	7	Reviewing	reviewing	NN
5180	721	8	"	"	''
5180	721	9	Web	web	NN
5180	721	10	Pages	page	NNS
5180	721	11	After	after	IN
5180	721	12	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	721	13	Initial	initial	JJ
5180	721	14	Categorization	categorization	NN
5180	721	15	Most	most	RBS
5180	721	16	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	721	17	software	software	NN
5180	721	18	companies	company	NNS
5180	721	19	do	do	VBP
5180	721	20	not	not	RB
5180	721	21	engage	engage	VB
5180	721	22	in	in	IN
5180	721	23	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
5180	721	24	reviews	review	NNS
5180	721	25	of	of	IN
5180	721	26	categorized	categorized	JJ
5180	721	27	sites	site	NNS
5180	721	28	or	or	CC
5180	721	29	pages	page	NNS
5180	721	30	on	on	IN
5180	721	31	a	a	DT
5180	721	32	scheduled	scheduled	JJ
5180	721	33	basis	basis	NN
5180	721	34	.	.	.
5180	722	1	Priority	priority	NN
5180	722	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	722	3	placed	place	VBN
5180	722	4	on	on	IN
5180	722	5	reviewing	review	VBG
5180	722	6	and	and	CC
5180	722	7	categorizing	categorize	VBG
5180	722	8	new	new	JJ
5180	722	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	722	10	and	and	CC
5180	722	11	pages	page	NNS
5180	722	12	,	,	,
5180	722	13	rather	rather	RB
5180	722	14	than	than	IN
5180	722	15	on	on	IN
5180	722	16	re	re	NN
5180	722	17	-	-	NN
5180	722	18	reviewing	review	VBG
5180	722	19	already	already	RB
5180	722	20	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	722	21	sites	site	NNS
5180	722	22	and	and	CC
5180	722	23	pages	page	NNS
5180	722	24	.	.	.
5180	723	1	Typically	typically	RB
5180	723	2	,	,	,
5180	723	3	a	a	DT
5180	723	4	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	723	5	software	software	NN
5180	723	6	vendor	vendor	NN
5180	723	7	's	's	POS
5180	723	8	previous	previous	JJ
5180	723	9	categorization	categorization	NN
5180	723	10	of	of	IN
5180	723	11	a	a	DT
5180	723	12	Web	web	NN
5180	723	13	site	site	NN
5180	723	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	723	15	not	not	RB
5180	723	16	re	re	VBG
5180	723	17	-	-	VBN
5180	723	18	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	723	19	for	for	IN
5180	723	20	accuracy	accuracy	NN
5180	723	21	when	when	WRB
5180	723	22	new	new	JJ
5180	723	23	pages	page	NNS
5180	723	24	are	be	VBP
5180	723	25	added	add	VBN
5180	723	26	to	to	IN
5180	723	27	the	the	DT
5180	723	28	Web	web	NN
5180	723	29	site	site	NN
5180	723	30	.	.	.
5180	724	1	To	to	IN
5180	724	2	the	the	DT
5180	724	3	extent	extent	NN
5180	724	4	the	the	DT
5180	724	5	Web	web	NN
5180	724	6	site	site	NN
5180	724	7	was	be	VBD
5180	724	8	previously	previously	RB
5180	724	9	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	724	10	as	as	IN
5180	724	11	a	a	DT
5180	724	12	whole	whole	NN
5180	724	13	,	,	,
5180	724	14	the	the	DT
5180	724	15	new	new	JJ
5180	724	16	pages	page	NNS
5180	724	17	added	add	VBN
5180	724	18	to	to	IN
5180	724	19	the	the	DT
5180	724	20	site	site	NN
5180	724	21	usually	usually	RB
5180	724	22	share	share	VBP
5180	724	23	the	the	DT
5180	724	24	categorization	categorization	NN
5180	724	25	assigned	assign	VBN
5180	724	26	by	by	IN
5180	724	27	the	the	DT
5180	724	28	blocking	block	VBG
5180	724	29	product	product	NN
5180	724	30	vendor	vendor	NN
5180	724	31	.	.	.
5180	725	1	This	this	DT
5180	725	2	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	725	3	results	result	VBZ
5180	725	4	in	in	IN
5180	725	5	both	both	DT
5180	725	6	over-	over-	NN
5180	725	7	and	and	CC
5180	725	8	underblocking	underblocking	NN
5180	725	9	,	,	,
5180	725	10	because	because	IN
5180	725	11	,	,	,
5180	725	12	as	as	IN
5180	725	13	noted	note	VBN
5180	725	14	above	above	IN
5180	725	15	,	,	,
5180	725	16	the	the	DT
5180	725	17	content	content	NN
5180	725	18	of	of	IN
5180	725	19	Web	web	NN
5180	725	20	pages	page	NNS
5180	725	21	and	and	CC
5180	725	22	Web	web	NN
5180	725	23	sites	site	NNS
5180	725	24	changes	change	NNS
5180	725	25	relatively	relatively	RB
5180	725	26	rapidly	rapidly	RB
5180	725	27	.	.	.
5180	726	1	In	in	IN
5180	726	2	addition	addition	NN
5180	726	3	to	to	IN
5180	726	4	the	the	DT
5180	726	5	content	content	NN
5180	726	6	on	on	IN
5180	726	7	Web	web	NN
5180	726	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	726	9	or	or	CC
5180	726	10	pages	page	NNS
5180	726	11	changing	change	VBG
5180	726	12	rapidly	rapidly	RB
5180	726	13	,	,	,
5180	726	14	Web	web	NN
5180	726	15	sites	site	NNS
5180	726	16	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	726	17	may	may	MD
5180	726	18	disappear	disappear	VB
5180	726	19	and	and	CC
5180	726	20	be	be	VB
5180	726	21	replaced	replace	VBN
5180	726	22	by	by	IN
5180	726	23	sites	site	NNS
5180	726	24	with	with	IN
5180	726	25	entirely	entirely	RB
5180	726	26	different	different	JJ
5180	726	27	content	content	NN
5180	726	28	.	.	.
5180	727	1	If	if	IN
5180	727	2	an	an	DT
5180	727	3	IP	IP	NNP
5180	727	4	address	address	NN
5180	727	5	associated	associate	VBN
5180	727	6	with	with	IN
5180	727	7	a	a	DT
5180	727	8	particular	particular	JJ
5180	727	9	Web	web	NN
5180	727	10	site	site	NN
5180	727	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	727	12	blocked	block	VBN
5180	727	13	under	under	IN
5180	727	14	a	a	DT
5180	727	15	particular	particular	JJ
5180	727	16	category	category	NN
5180	727	17	and	and	CC
5180	727	18	the	the	DT
5180	727	19	Web	web	NN
5180	727	20	site	site	NN
5180	727	21	goes	go	VBZ
5180	727	22	out	out	IN
5180	727	23	of	of	IN
5180	727	24	existence	existence	NN
5180	727	25	,	,	,
5180	727	26	then	then	RB
5180	727	27	the	the	DT
5180	727	28	IP	IP	NNP
5180	727	29	address	address	NN
5180	727	30	likely	likely	RB
5180	727	31	would	would	MD
5180	727	32	be	be	VB
5180	727	33	reassigned	reassign	VBN
5180	727	34	to	to	IN
5180	727	35	a	a	DT
5180	727	36	different	different	JJ
5180	727	37	Web	web	NN
5180	727	38	site	site	NN
5180	727	39	,	,	,
5180	727	40	either	either	CC
5180	727	41	by	by	IN
5180	727	42	an	an	DT
5180	727	43	Internet	internet	NN
5180	727	44	service	service	NN
5180	727	45	provider	provider	NN
5180	727	46	or	or	CC
5180	727	47	by	by	IN
5180	727	48	a	a	DT
5180	727	49	registration	registration	NN
5180	727	50	organization	organization	NN
5180	727	51	,	,	,
5180	727	52	such	such	JJ
5180	727	53	as	as	IN
5180	727	54	the	the	DT
5180	727	55	American	American	NNP
5180	727	56	Registry	Registry	NNP
5180	727	57	for	for	IN
5180	727	58	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	727	59	Numbers	number	NNS
5180	727	60	,	,	,
5180	727	61	see	see	VB
5180	727	62	http://www.arin.net	http://www.arin.net	ADD
5180	727	63	.	.	.
5180	728	1	In	in	IN
5180	728	2	that	that	DT
5180	728	3	case	case	NN
5180	728	4	,	,	,
5180	728	5	the	the	DT
5180	728	6	site	site	NN
5180	728	7	that	that	WDT
5180	728	8	received	receive	VBD
5180	728	9	the	the	DT
5180	728	10	reassigned	reassign	VBN
5180	728	11	IP	IP	NNP
5180	728	12	address	address	NN
5180	728	13	would	would	MD
5180	728	14	likely	likely	RB
5180	728	15	be	be	VB
5180	728	16	miscategorized	miscategorize	VBN
5180	728	17	.	.	.
5180	729	1	Because	because	IN
5180	729	2	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	729	3	companies	company	NNS
5180	729	4	do	do	VBP
5180	729	5	not	not	RB
5180	729	6	engage	engage	VB
5180	729	7	in	in	IN
5180	729	8	systematic	systematic	JJ
5180	729	9	re	re	NN
5180	729	10	-	-	NN
5180	729	11	review	review	NN
5180	729	12	of	of	IN
5180	729	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	729	14	category	category	NN
5180	729	15	lists	list	NNS
5180	729	16	,	,	,
5180	729	17	such	such	PDT
5180	729	18	a	a	DT
5180	729	19	site	site	NN
5180	729	20	would	would	MD
5180	729	21	likely	likely	RB
5180	729	22	remain	remain	VB
5180	729	23	miscategorized	miscategorized	JJ
5180	729	24	unless	unless	IN
5180	729	25	someone	someone	NN
5180	729	26	submitted	submit	VBD
5180	729	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	729	28	to	to	IN
5180	729	29	the	the	DT
5180	729	30	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	729	31	company	company	NN
5180	729	32	for	for	IN
5180	729	33	re	re	NN
5180	729	34	-	-	NN
5180	729	35	review	review	NN
5180	729	36	,	,	,
5180	729	37	increasing	increase	VBG
5180	729	38	the	the	DT
5180	729	39	incidence	incidence	NN
5180	729	40	of	of	IN
5180	729	41	over-	over-	NN
5180	729	42	and	and	CC
5180	729	43	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	729	44	.	.	.
5180	730	1	This	this	DT
5180	730	2	failure	failure	NN
5180	730	3	to	to	IN
5180	730	4	re	re	NN
5180	730	5	-	-	VB
5180	730	6	review	review	VB
5180	730	7	Web	web	NN
5180	730	8	pages	page	NNS
5180	730	9	primarily	primarily	RB
5180	730	10	increases	increase	VBZ
5180	730	11	a	a	DT
5180	730	12	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	730	13	company	company	NN
5180	730	14	's	's	POS
5180	730	15	rate	rate	NN
5180	730	16	of	of	IN
5180	730	17	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	730	18	.	.	.
5180	731	1	However	however	RB
5180	731	2	,	,	,
5180	731	3	if	if	IN
5180	731	4	a	a	DT
5180	731	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	731	6	company	company	NN
5180	731	7	does	do	VBZ
5180	731	8	not	not	RB
5180	731	9	re	re	VB
5180	731	10	-	-	VB
5180	731	11	review	review	VB
5180	731	12	Web	web	NN
5180	731	13	pages	page	NNS
5180	731	14	after	after	IN
5180	731	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	731	16	determines	determine	VBZ
5180	731	17	that	that	IN
5180	731	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	731	19	do	do	VBP
5180	731	20	not	not	RB
5180	731	21	fall	fall	VB
5180	731	22	into	into	IN
5180	731	23	any	any	DT
5180	731	24	of	of	IN
5180	731	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	731	26	blocking	blocking	NN
5180	731	27	categories	category	NNS
5180	731	28	,	,	,
5180	731	29	then	then	RB
5180	731	30	that	that	DT
5180	731	31	would	would	MD
5180	731	32	result	result	VB
5180	731	33	in	in	IN
5180	731	34	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	731	35	(	(	-LRB-
5180	731	36	because	because	IN
5180	731	37	,	,	,
5180	731	38	for	for	IN
5180	731	39	example	example	NN
5180	731	40	,	,	,
5180	731	41	a	a	DT
5180	731	42	page	page	NN
5180	731	43	might	may	MD
5180	731	44	add	add	VB
5180	731	45	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	731	46	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	731	47	content	content	NN
5180	731	48	)	)	-RRB-
5180	731	49	.	.	.
5180	732	1	3	3	LS
5180	732	2	.	.	.
5180	733	1	The	the	DT
5180	733	2	Inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	733	3	Tradeoff	tradeoff	NN
5180	733	4	Between	between	IN
5180	733	5	Overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	733	6	and	and	CC
5180	733	7	Underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	733	8	There	there	EX
5180	733	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	733	10	an	an	DT
5180	733	11	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	733	12	tradeoff	tradeoff	NN
5180	733	13	between	between	IN
5180	733	14	any	any	DT
5180	733	15	filter	filter	NN
5180	733	16	's	's	POS
5180	733	17	rate	rate	NN
5180	733	18	of	of	IN
5180	733	19	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	733	20	(	(	-LRB-
5180	733	21	which	which	WDT
5180	733	22	information	information	NN
5180	733	23	scientists	scientist	NNS
5180	733	24	also	also	RB
5180	733	25	call	call	VBP
5180	733	26	"	"	``
5180	733	27	precision	precision	NN
5180	733	28	"	"	''
5180	733	29	)	)	-RRB-
5180	733	30	and	and	CC
5180	733	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	733	32	rate	rate	NN
5180	733	33	of	of	IN
5180	733	34	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	733	35	(	(	-LRB-
5180	733	36	which	which	WDT
5180	733	37	is	be	VBZ
5180	733	38	also	also	RB
5180	733	39	referred	refer	VBN
5180	733	40	to	to	IN
5180	733	41	as	as	IN
5180	733	42	"	"	``
5180	733	43	recall	recall	NN
5180	733	44	"	"	''
5180	733	45	)	)	-RRB-
5180	733	46	.	.	.
5180	734	1	The	the	DT
5180	734	2	rate	rate	NN
5180	734	3	of	of	IN
5180	734	4	overblocking	overblocking	NN
5180	734	5	or	or	CC
5180	734	6	precision	precision	NN
5180	734	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	734	8	measured	measure	VBN
5180	734	9	by	by	IN
5180	734	10	the	the	DT
5180	734	11	proportion	proportion	NN
5180	734	12	of	of	IN
5180	734	13	the	the	DT
5180	734	14	things	thing	NNS
5180	734	15	a	a	DT
5180	734	16	classification	classification	NN
5180	734	17	system	system	NN
5180	734	18	assigns	assign	VBZ
5180	734	19	to	to	IN
5180	734	20	a	a	DT
5180	734	21	certain	certain	JJ
5180	734	22	category	category	NN
5180	734	23	that	that	WDT
5180	734	24	are	be	VBP
5180	734	25	appropriately	appropriately	RB
5180	734	26	classified	classified	JJ
5180	734	27	.	.	.
5180	735	1	The	the	DT
5180	735	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	735	3	'	'	POS
5180	735	4	expert	expert	NN
5180	735	5	,	,	,
5180	735	6	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
5180	735	7	Nunberg	Nunberg	NNP
5180	735	8	,	,	,
5180	735	9	provided	provide	VBD
5180	735	10	the	the	DT
5180	735	11	hypothetical	hypothetical	JJ
5180	735	12	example	example	NN
5180	735	13	of	of	IN
5180	735	14	a	a	DT
5180	735	15	classification	classification	NN
5180	735	16	system	system	NN
5180	735	17	that	that	WDT
5180	735	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	735	19	asked	ask	VBN
5180	735	20	to	to	TO
5180	735	21	pick	pick	VB
5180	735	22	out	out	RP
5180	735	23	pictures	picture	NNS
5180	735	24	of	of	IN
5180	735	25	dogs	dog	NNS
5180	735	26	from	from	IN
5180	735	27	a	a	DT
5180	735	28	database	database	NN
5180	735	29	consisting	consisting	NN
5180	735	30	of	of	IN
5180	735	31	1000	1000	CD
5180	735	32	pictures	picture	NNS
5180	735	33	of	of	IN
5180	735	34	animals	animal	NNS
5180	735	35	,	,	,
5180	735	36	of	of	IN
5180	735	37	which	which	WDT
5180	735	38	80	80	CD
5180	735	39	were	be	VBD
5180	735	40	actually	actually	RB
5180	735	41	dogs	dog	NNS
5180	735	42	.	.	.
5180	736	1	If	if	IN
5180	736	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	736	3	returned	return	VBD
5180	736	4	100	100	CD
5180	736	5	hits	hit	NNS
5180	736	6	,	,	,
5180	736	7	of	of	IN
5180	736	8	which	which	WDT
5180	736	9	80	80	CD
5180	736	10	were	be	VBD
5180	736	11	in	in	IN
5180	736	12	fact	fact	NN
5180	736	13	pictures	picture	NNS
5180	736	14	of	of	IN
5180	736	15	dogs	dog	NNS
5180	736	16	,	,	,
5180	736	17	and	and	CC
5180	736	18	the	the	DT
5180	736	19	remaining	remaining	JJ
5180	736	20	20	20	CD
5180	736	21	were	be	VBD
5180	736	22	pictures	picture	NNS
5180	736	23	of	of	IN
5180	736	24	cats	cat	NNS
5180	736	25	,	,	,
5180	736	26	horses	horse	NNS
5180	736	27	,	,	,
5180	736	28	and	and	CC
5180	736	29	deer	deer	NN
5180	736	30	,	,	,
5180	736	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	736	32	would	would	MD
5180	736	33	say	say	VB
5180	736	34	that	that	IN
5180	736	35	the	the	DT
5180	736	36	system	system	NN
5180	736	37	identified	identify	VBD
5180	736	38	dog	dog	NN
5180	736	39	pictures	picture	NNS
5180	736	40	with	with	IN
5180	736	41	a	a	DT
5180	736	42	precision	precision	NN
5180	736	43	of	of	IN
5180	736	44	80	80	CD
5180	736	45	%	%	NN
5180	736	46	.	.	.
5180	737	1	This	this	DT
5180	737	2	would	would	MD
5180	737	3	be	be	VB
5180	737	4	analogous	analogous	JJ
5180	737	5	to	to	IN
5180	737	6	a	a	DT
5180	737	7	filter	filter	NN
5180	737	8	that	that	WDT
5180	737	9	overblocked	overblocke	VBD
5180	737	10	at	at	IN
5180	737	11	a	a	DT
5180	737	12	rate	rate	NN
5180	737	13	of	of	IN
5180	737	14	20	20	CD
5180	737	15	%	%	NN
5180	737	16	.	.	.
5180	738	1	The	the	DT
5180	738	2	recall	recall	NN
5180	738	3	measure	measure	NN
5180	738	4	involves	involve	VBZ
5180	738	5	determining	determine	VBG
5180	738	6	what	what	WDT
5180	738	7	proportion	proportion	NN
5180	738	8	of	of	IN
5180	738	9	the	the	DT
5180	738	10	actual	actual	JJ
5180	738	11	members	member	NNS
5180	738	12	of	of	IN
5180	738	13	a	a	DT
5180	738	14	category	category	NN
5180	738	15	the	the	DT
5180	738	16	classification	classification	NN
5180	738	17	system	system	NN
5180	738	18	has	have	VBZ
5180	738	19	been	be	VBN
5180	738	20	able	able	JJ
5180	738	21	to	to	TO
5180	738	22	identify	identify	VB
5180	738	23	.	.	.
5180	739	1	For	for	IN
5180	739	2	example	example	NN
5180	739	3	,	,	,
5180	739	4	if	if	IN
5180	739	5	the	the	DT
5180	739	6	hypothetical	hypothetical	JJ
5180	739	7	animal-	animal-	NN
5180	739	8	picture	picture	NNP
5180	739	9	database	database	NN
5180	739	10	contained	contain	VBD
5180	739	11	a	a	DT
5180	739	12	total	total	NN
5180	739	13	of	of	IN
5180	739	14	200	200	CD
5180	739	15	pictures	picture	NNS
5180	739	16	of	of	IN
5180	739	17	dogs	dog	NNS
5180	739	18	,	,	,
5180	739	19	and	and	CC
5180	739	20	the	the	DT
5180	739	21	system	system	NN
5180	739	22	identified	identify	VBD
5180	739	23	80	80	CD
5180	739	24	of	of	IN
5180	739	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	739	26	and	and	CC
5180	739	27	failed	fail	VBD
5180	739	28	to	to	TO
5180	739	29	identify	identify	VB
5180	739	30	120	120	CD
5180	739	31	,	,	,
5180	739	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	739	33	would	would	MD
5180	739	34	have	have	VB
5180	739	35	performed	perform	VBN
5180	739	36	with	with	IN
5180	739	37	a	a	DT
5180	739	38	recall	recall	NN
5180	739	39	of	of	IN
5180	739	40	40	40	CD
5180	739	41	%	%	NN
5180	739	42	.	.	.
5180	740	1	This	this	DT
5180	740	2	would	would	MD
5180	740	3	be	be	VB
5180	740	4	analogous	analogous	JJ
5180	740	5	to	to	IN
5180	740	6	a	a	DT
5180	740	7	filter	filter	NN
5180	740	8	that	that	WDT
5180	740	9	underblocked	underblocke	VBD
5180	740	10	60	60	CD
5180	740	11	%	%	NN
5180	740	12	of	of	IN
5180	740	13	the	the	DT
5180	740	14	material	material	NN
5180	740	15	in	in	IN
5180	740	16	a	a	DT
5180	740	17	category	category	NN
5180	740	18	.	.	.
5180	741	1	In	in	IN
5180	741	2	automated	automated	JJ
5180	741	3	classification	classification	NN
5180	741	4	systems	system	NNS
5180	741	5	,	,	,
5180	741	6	there	there	EX
5180	741	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	741	8	always	always	RB
5180	741	9	a	a	DT
5180	741	10	tradeoff	tradeoff	NN
5180	741	11	between	between	IN
5180	741	12	precision	precision	NN
5180	741	13	and	and	CC
5180	741	14	recall	recall	NN
5180	741	15	.	.	.
5180	742	1	In	in	IN
5180	742	2	the	the	DT
5180	742	3	animal	animal	NN
5180	742	4	-	-	HYPH
5180	742	5	picture	picture	NN
5180	742	6	example	example	NN
5180	742	7	,	,	,
5180	742	8	the	the	DT
5180	742	9	recall	recall	NN
5180	742	10	could	could	MD
5180	742	11	be	be	VB
5180	742	12	improved	improve	VBN
5180	742	13	by	by	IN
5180	742	14	using	use	VBG
5180	742	15	a	a	DT
5180	742	16	looser	loose	JJR
5180	742	17	set	set	NN
5180	742	18	of	of	IN
5180	742	19	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	742	20	to	to	TO
5180	742	21	identify	identify	VB
5180	742	22	the	the	DT
5180	742	23	dog	dog	NN
5180	742	24	pictures	picture	NNS
5180	742	25	in	in	IN
5180	742	26	the	the	DT
5180	742	27	set	set	NN
5180	742	28	,	,	,
5180	742	29	such	such	JJ
5180	742	30	as	as	IN
5180	742	31	any	any	DT
5180	742	32	animal	animal	NN
5180	742	33	with	with	IN
5180	742	34	four	four	CD
5180	742	35	legs	leg	NNS
5180	742	36	,	,	,
5180	742	37	and	and	CC
5180	742	38	all	all	PDT
5180	742	39	the	the	DT
5180	742	40	dogs	dog	NNS
5180	742	41	would	would	MD
5180	742	42	be	be	VB
5180	742	43	identified	identify	VBN
5180	742	44	,	,	,
5180	742	45	but	but	CC
5180	742	46	cats	cat	NNS
5180	742	47	and	and	CC
5180	742	48	other	other	JJ
5180	742	49	animals	animal	NNS
5180	742	50	would	would	MD
5180	742	51	also	also	RB
5180	742	52	be	be	VB
5180	742	53	included	include	VBN
5180	742	54	,	,	,
5180	742	55	with	with	IN
5180	742	56	a	a	DT
5180	742	57	resulting	result	VBG
5180	742	58	loss	loss	NN
5180	742	59	of	of	IN
5180	742	60	precision	precision	NN
5180	742	61	.	.	.
5180	743	1	The	the	DT
5180	743	2	same	same	JJ
5180	743	3	tradeoff	tradeoff	NN
5180	743	4	exists	exist	VBZ
5180	743	5	between	between	IN
5180	743	6	rates	rate	NNS
5180	743	7	of	of	IN
5180	743	8	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	743	9	and	and	CC
5180	743	10	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	743	11	in	in	IN
5180	743	12	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	743	13	systems	system	NNS
5180	743	14	that	that	WDT
5180	743	15	use	use	VBP
5180	743	16	automated	automate	VBD
5180	743	17	classification	classification	NN
5180	743	18	systems	system	NNS
5180	743	19	.	.	.
5180	744	1	For	for	IN
5180	744	2	example	example	NN
5180	744	3	,	,	,
5180	744	4	an	an	DT
5180	744	5	automated	automated	JJ
5180	744	6	system	system	NN
5180	744	7	that	that	WDT
5180	744	8	classifies	classify	VBZ
5180	744	9	any	any	DT
5180	744	10	Web	web	NN
5180	744	11	page	page	NN
5180	744	12	that	that	WDT
5180	744	13	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	744	14	the	the	DT
5180	744	15	word	word	NN
5180	744	16	"	"	``
5180	744	17	sex	sex	NN
5180	744	18	"	"	''
5180	744	19	as	as	IN
5180	744	20	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	744	21	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	744	22	will	will	MD
5180	744	23	underblock	underblock	VB
5180	744	24	much	much	RB
5180	744	25	less	less	RBR
5180	744	26	,	,	,
5180	744	27	but	but	CC
5180	744	28	overblock	overblock	NN
5180	744	29	much	much	RB
5180	744	30	more	more	RBR
5180	744	31	,	,	,
5180	744	32	than	than	IN
5180	744	33	a	a	DT
5180	744	34	system	system	NN
5180	744	35	that	that	WDT
5180	744	36	classifies	classify	VBZ
5180	744	37	any	any	DT
5180	744	38	Web	web	NN
5180	744	39	page	page	NN
5180	744	40	containing	contain	VBG
5180	744	41	the	the	DT
5180	744	42	phrase	phrase	NN
5180	744	43	"	"	``
5180	744	44	free	free	JJ
5180	744	45	pictures	picture	NNS
5180	744	46	of	of	IN
5180	744	47	people	people	NNS
5180	744	48	having	have	VBG
5180	744	49	sex	sex	NN
5180	744	50	"	"	''
5180	744	51	as	as	IN
5180	744	52	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	744	53	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	744	54	.	.	.
5180	745	1	This	this	DT
5180	745	2	tradeoff	tradeoff	NN
5180	745	3	between	between	IN
5180	745	4	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	745	5	and	and	CC
5180	745	6	underblocking	underblocking	NN
5180	745	7	also	also	RB
5180	745	8	applies	apply	VBZ
5180	745	9	not	not	RB
5180	745	10	just	just	RB
5180	745	11	to	to	IN
5180	745	12	automated	automate	VBN
5180	745	13	classification	classification	NN
5180	745	14	systems	system	NNS
5180	745	15	,	,	,
5180	745	16	but	but	CC
5180	745	17	also	also	RB
5180	745	18	to	to	IN
5180	745	19	filters	filter	NNS
5180	745	20	that	that	WDT
5180	745	21	use	use	VBP
5180	745	22	only	only	JJ
5180	745	23	human	human	JJ
5180	745	24	review	review	NN
5180	745	25	.	.	.
5180	746	1	Given	give	VBN
5180	746	2	the	the	DT
5180	746	3	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	746	4	two	two	CD
5180	746	5	billion	billion	CD
5180	746	6	pages	page	NNS
5180	746	7	that	that	WDT
5180	746	8	exist	exist	VBP
5180	746	9	on	on	IN
5180	746	10	the	the	DT
5180	746	11	Web	web	NN
5180	746	12	,	,	,
5180	746	13	the	the	DT
5180	746	14	1.5	1.5	CD
5180	746	15	million	million	CD
5180	746	16	new	new	JJ
5180	746	17	pages	page	NNS
5180	746	18	that	that	WDT
5180	746	19	are	be	VBP
5180	746	20	added	add	VBN
5180	746	21	daily	daily	RB
5180	746	22	,	,	,
5180	746	23	and	and	CC
5180	746	24	the	the	DT
5180	746	25	rate	rate	NN
5180	746	26	at	at	IN
5180	746	27	which	which	WDT
5180	746	28	content	content	NN
5180	746	29	on	on	IN
5180	746	30	existing	exist	VBG
5180	746	31	pages	page	NNS
5180	746	32	changes	change	NNS
5180	746	33	,	,	,
5180	746	34	if	if	IN
5180	746	35	a	a	DT
5180	746	36	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	746	37	company	company	NN
5180	746	38	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	746	39	only	only	RB
5180	746	40	those	those	DT
5180	746	41	Web	web	NN
5180	746	42	pages	page	NNS
5180	746	43	that	that	WDT
5180	746	44	have	have	VBP
5180	746	45	been	be	VBN
5180	746	46	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	746	47	by	by	IN
5180	746	48	humans	human	NNS
5180	746	49	,	,	,
5180	746	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	746	51	will	will	MD
5180	746	52	be	be	VB
5180	746	53	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	746	54	,	,	,
5180	746	55	as	as	IN
5180	746	56	a	a	DT
5180	746	57	practical	practical	JJ
5180	746	58	matter	matter	NN
5180	746	59	,	,	,
5180	746	60	to	to	TO
5180	746	61	avoid	avoid	VB
5180	746	62	vast	vast	JJ
5180	746	63	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	746	64	of	of	IN
5180	746	65	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	746	66	.	.	.
5180	747	1	Techniques	technique	NNS
5180	747	2	used	use	VBN
5180	747	3	by	by	IN
5180	747	4	human	human	JJ
5180	747	5	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	747	6	such	such	JJ
5180	747	7	as	as	IN
5180	747	8	blocking	block	VBG
5180	747	9	at	at	IN
5180	747	10	the	the	DT
5180	747	11	IP	IP	NNP
5180	747	12	address	address	NN
5180	747	13	level	level	NN
5180	747	14	,	,	,
5180	747	15	domain	domain	NN
5180	747	16	name	name	NN
5180	747	17	level	level	NN
5180	747	18	,	,	,
5180	747	19	or	or	CC
5180	747	20	directory	directory	NN
5180	747	21	level	level	NN
5180	747	22	reduce	reduce	VBP
5180	747	23	the	the	DT
5180	747	24	rates	rate	NNS
5180	747	25	of	of	IN
5180	747	26	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	747	27	,	,	,
5180	747	28	but	but	CC
5180	747	29	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	747	30	increase	increase	VB
5180	747	31	the	the	DT
5180	747	32	rates	rate	NNS
5180	747	33	of	of	IN
5180	747	34	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	747	35	,	,	,
5180	747	36	as	as	IN
5180	747	37	discussed	discuss	VBN
5180	747	38	above	above	RB
5180	747	39	.	.	.
5180	748	1	To	to	TO
5180	748	2	use	use	VB
5180	748	3	a	a	DT
5180	748	4	simple	simple	JJ
5180	748	5	example	example	NN
5180	748	6	,	,	,
5180	748	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	748	8	would	would	MD
5180	748	9	be	be	VB
5180	748	10	easy	easy	JJ
5180	748	11	to	to	TO
5180	748	12	design	design	VB
5180	748	13	a	a	DT
5180	748	14	filter	filter	NN
5180	748	15	intended	intend	VBN
5180	748	16	to	to	TO
5180	748	17	block	block	VB
5180	748	18	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	748	19	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	748	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	748	21	that	that	WDT
5180	748	22	completely	completely	RB
5180	748	23	avoids	avoid	VBZ
5180	748	24	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	748	25	.	.	.
5180	749	1	Such	such	PDT
5180	749	2	a	a	DT
5180	749	3	filter	filter	NN
5180	749	4	would	would	MD
5180	749	5	have	have	VB
5180	749	6	only	only	RB
5180	749	7	a	a	DT
5180	749	8	single	single	JJ
5180	749	9	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	749	10	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	749	11	Web	web	NN
5180	749	12	site	site	NN
5180	749	13	on	on	IN
5180	749	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	749	15	control	control	NN
5180	749	16	list	list	NN
5180	749	17	,	,	,
5180	749	18	which	which	WDT
5180	749	19	could	could	MD
5180	749	20	be	be	VB
5180	749	21	re	re	VBN
5180	749	22	-	-	VBN
5180	749	23	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	749	24	daily	daily	RB
5180	749	25	to	to	TO
5180	749	26	ensure	ensure	VB
5180	749	27	that	that	IN
5180	749	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	749	29	content	content	NN
5180	749	30	does	do	VBZ
5180	749	31	not	not	RB
5180	749	32	change	change	VB
5180	749	33	.	.	.
5180	750	1	While	while	IN
5180	750	2	there	there	EX
5180	750	3	would	would	MD
5180	750	4	be	be	VB
5180	750	5	no	no	DT
5180	750	6	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	750	7	problem	problem	NN
5180	750	8	with	with	IN
5180	750	9	such	such	PDT
5180	750	10	a	a	DT
5180	750	11	filter	filter	NN
5180	750	12	,	,	,
5180	750	13	such	such	PDT
5180	750	14	a	a	DT
5180	750	15	filter	filter	NN
5180	750	16	would	would	MD
5180	750	17	have	have	VB
5180	750	18	a	a	DT
5180	750	19	severe	severe	JJ
5180	750	20	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	750	21	problem	problem	NN
5180	750	22	,	,	,
5180	750	23	as	as	IN
5180	750	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	750	25	would	would	MD
5180	750	26	fail	fail	VB
5180	750	27	to	to	TO
5180	750	28	block	block	VB
5180	750	29	all	all	PDT
5180	750	30	the	the	DT
5180	750	31	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	750	32	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	750	33	speech	speech	NN
5180	750	34	on	on	IN
5180	750	35	the	the	DT
5180	750	36	Web	web	NN
5180	750	37	other	other	JJ
5180	750	38	than	than	IN
5180	750	39	the	the	DT
5180	750	40	one	one	CD
5180	750	41	site	site	NN
5180	750	42	on	on	IN
5180	750	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	750	44	control	control	NN
5180	750	45	list	list	NN
5180	750	46	.	.	.
5180	751	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	751	2	,	,	,
5180	751	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	751	4	would	would	MD
5180	751	5	also	also	RB
5180	751	6	be	be	VB
5180	751	7	easy	easy	JJ
5180	751	8	to	to	TO
5180	751	9	design	design	VB
5180	751	10	a	a	DT
5180	751	11	filter	filter	NN
5180	751	12	intended	intend	VBN
5180	751	13	to	to	TO
5180	751	14	block	block	VB
5180	751	15	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	751	16	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	751	17	speech	speech	NN
5180	751	18	that	that	WDT
5180	751	19	completely	completely	RB
5180	751	20	avoids	avoid	VBZ
5180	751	21	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	751	22	.	.	.
5180	752	1	Such	such	PDT
5180	752	2	a	a	DT
5180	752	3	filter	filter	NN
5180	752	4	would	would	MD
5180	752	5	operate	operate	VB
5180	752	6	by	by	IN
5180	752	7	permitting	permit	VBG
5180	752	8	users	user	NNS
5180	752	9	to	to	TO
5180	752	10	view	view	VB
5180	752	11	only	only	RB
5180	752	12	a	a	DT
5180	752	13	single	single	JJ
5180	752	14	Web	web	NN
5180	752	15	site	site	NN
5180	752	16	,	,	,
5180	752	17	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	752	18	,	,	,
5180	752	19	the	the	DT
5180	752	20	Sesame	Sesame	NNP
5180	752	21	Street	Street	NNP
5180	752	22	Web	web	NN
5180	752	23	site	site	NN
5180	752	24	.	.	.
5180	753	1	While	while	IN
5180	753	2	there	there	EX
5180	753	3	would	would	MD
5180	753	4	be	be	VB
5180	753	5	no	no	DT
5180	753	6	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	753	7	problem	problem	NN
5180	753	8	with	with	IN
5180	753	9	such	such	PDT
5180	753	10	a	a	DT
5180	753	11	filter	filter	NN
5180	753	12	,	,	,
5180	753	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	753	14	would	would	MD
5180	753	15	have	have	VB
5180	753	16	a	a	DT
5180	753	17	severe	severe	JJ
5180	753	18	overblocking	overblocking	NN
5180	753	19	problem	problem	NN
5180	753	20	,	,	,
5180	753	21	as	as	IN
5180	753	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	753	23	would	would	MD
5180	753	24	block	block	VB
5180	753	25	access	access	NN
5180	753	26	to	to	IN
5180	753	27	millions	million	NNS
5180	753	28	of	of	IN
5180	753	29	non	non	JJ
5180	753	30	-	-	JJ
5180	753	31	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	753	32	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	753	33	sites	site	NNS
5180	753	34	on	on	IN
5180	753	35	the	the	DT
5180	753	36	Web	web	NN
5180	753	37	other	other	JJ
5180	753	38	than	than	IN
5180	753	39	the	the	DT
5180	753	40	Sesame	Sesame	NNP
5180	753	41	Street	Street	NNP
5180	753	42	site	site	NN
5180	753	43	.	.	.
5180	754	1	While	while	IN
5180	754	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	754	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	754	4	thus	thus	RB
5180	754	5	quite	quite	RB
5180	754	6	simple	simple	JJ
5180	754	7	to	to	TO
5180	754	8	design	design	VB
5180	754	9	a	a	DT
5180	754	10	filter	filter	NN
5180	754	11	that	that	WDT
5180	754	12	does	do	VBZ
5180	754	13	not	not	RB
5180	754	14	overblock	overblock	VB
5180	754	15	,	,	,
5180	754	16	and	and	CC
5180	754	17	equally	equally	RB
5180	754	18	simple	simple	JJ
5180	754	19	to	to	TO
5180	754	20	design	design	VB
5180	754	21	a	a	DT
5180	754	22	filter	filter	NN
5180	754	23	that	that	WDT
5180	754	24	does	do	VBZ
5180	754	25	not	not	RB
5180	754	26	underblock	underblock	VB
5180	754	27	,	,	,
5180	754	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	754	29	is	be	VBZ
5180	754	30	currently	currently	RB
5180	754	31	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	754	32	,	,	,
5180	754	33	given	give	VBN
5180	754	34	the	the	DT
5180	754	35	Internet	internet	NN
5180	754	36	's	's	POS
5180	754	37	size	size	NN
5180	754	38	,	,	,
5180	754	39	rate	rate	NN
5180	754	40	of	of	IN
5180	754	41	growth	growth	NN
5180	754	42	,	,	,
5180	754	43	rate	rate	NN
5180	754	44	of	of	IN
5180	754	45	change	change	NN
5180	754	46	,	,	,
5180	754	47	and	and	CC
5180	754	48	architecture	architecture	NN
5180	754	49	,	,	,
5180	754	50	and	and	CC
5180	754	51	given	give	VBN
5180	754	52	the	the	DT
5180	754	53	state	state	NN
5180	754	54	of	of	IN
5180	754	55	the	the	DT
5180	754	56	art	art	NN
5180	754	57	of	of	IN
5180	754	58	automated	automate	VBN
5180	754	59	classification	classification	NN
5180	754	60	systems	system	NNS
5180	754	61	,	,	,
5180	754	62	to	to	TO
5180	754	63	develop	develop	VB
5180	754	64	a	a	DT
5180	754	65	filter	filter	NN
5180	754	66	that	that	IN
5180	754	67	neither	neither	CC
5180	754	68	underblocks	underblock	NNS
5180	754	69	nor	nor	CC
5180	754	70	overblocks	overblock	VBZ
5180	754	71	a	a	DT
5180	754	72	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	754	73	amount	amount	NN
5180	754	74	of	of	IN
5180	754	75	speech	speech	NN
5180	754	76	.	.	.
5180	755	1	The	the	DT
5180	755	2	more	more	RBR
5180	755	3	effective	effective	JJ
5180	755	4	a	a	DT
5180	755	5	filter	filter	NN
5180	755	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	755	7	at	at	IN
5180	755	8	blocking	block	VBG
5180	755	9	Web	web	NN
5180	755	10	sites	site	NNS
5180	755	11	in	in	IN
5180	755	12	a	a	DT
5180	755	13	given	give	VBN
5180	755	14	category	category	NN
5180	755	15	,	,	,
5180	755	16	the	the	DT
5180	755	17	more	more	RBR
5180	755	18	the	the	DT
5180	755	19	filter	filter	NN
5180	755	20	will	will	MD
5180	755	21	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	755	22	overblock	overblock	VB
5180	755	23	.	.	.
5180	756	1	Any	any	DT
5180	756	2	filter	filter	NN
5180	756	3	that	that	WDT
5180	756	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	756	5	reasonably	reasonably	RB
5180	756	6	effective	effective	JJ
5180	756	7	in	in	IN
5180	756	8	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	756	9	users	user	NNS
5180	756	10	from	from	IN
5180	756	11	accessing	access	VBG
5180	756	12	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	756	13	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	756	14	content	content	NN
5180	756	15	on	on	IN
5180	756	16	the	the	DT
5180	756	17	Web	web	NN
5180	756	18	will	will	MD
5180	756	19	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	756	20	block	block	VB
5180	756	21	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	756	22	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	756	23	of	of	IN
5180	756	24	non-	non-	NNP
5180	756	25	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	756	26	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	756	27	speech	speech	NN
5180	756	28	.	.	.
5180	757	1	4	4	LS
5180	757	2	.	.	.
5180	758	1	Attempts	attempt	NNS
5180	758	2	to	to	TO
5180	758	3	Quantify	quantify	VB
5180	758	4	Filtering	Filtering	NNP
5180	758	5	Programs	Programs	NNPS
5180	758	6	'	'	POS
5180	758	7	Rates	Rates	NNPS
5180	758	8	of	of	IN
5180	758	9	Over-	Over-	NNP
5180	758	10	and	and	CC
5180	758	11	Underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	758	12	The	the	DT
5180	758	13	government	government	NN
5180	758	14	presented	present	VBD
5180	758	15	three	three	CD
5180	758	16	studies	study	NNS
5180	758	17	,	,	,
5180	758	18	two	two	CD
5180	758	19	from	from	IN
5180	758	20	expert	expert	NN
5180	758	21	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	758	22	,	,	,
5180	758	23	and	and	CC
5180	758	24	one	one	CD
5180	758	25	from	from	IN
5180	758	26	a	a	DT
5180	758	27	librarian	librarian	JJ
5180	758	28	fact	fact	NN
5180	758	29	witness	witness	NN
5180	758	30	who	who	WP
5180	758	31	conducted	conduct	VBD
5180	758	32	a	a	DT
5180	758	33	study	study	NN
5180	758	34	using	use	VBG
5180	758	35	Internet	internet	NN
5180	758	36	use	use	NN
5180	758	37	logs	log	NNS
5180	758	38	from	from	IN
5180	758	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	758	40	own	own	JJ
5180	758	41	library	library	NN
5180	758	42	,	,	,
5180	758	43	that	that	DT
5180	758	44	attempt	attempt	VBP
5180	758	45	to	to	TO
5180	758	46	quantify	quantify	VB
5180	758	47	the	the	DT
5180	758	48	over-	over-	NN
5180	758	49	and	and	CC
5180	758	50	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	758	51	rates	rate	NNS
5180	758	52	of	of	IN
5180	758	53	five	five	CD
5180	758	54	different	different	JJ
5180	758	55	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	758	56	programs	program	NNS
5180	758	57	.	.	.
5180	759	1	The	the	DT
5180	759	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	759	3	presented	present	VBD
5180	759	4	one	one	CD
5180	759	5	expert	expert	NN
5180	759	6	witness	witness	NN
5180	759	7	who	who	WP
5180	759	8	attempted	attempt	VBD
5180	759	9	to	to	TO
5180	759	10	quantify	quantify	VB
5180	759	11	the	the	DT
5180	759	12	rates	rate	NNS
5180	759	13	of	of	IN
5180	759	14	over-	over-	NN
5180	759	15	and	and	CC
5180	759	16	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	759	17	for	for	IN
5180	759	18	various	various	JJ
5180	759	19	programs	program	NNS
5180	759	20	.	.	.
5180	760	1	Each	each	DT
5180	760	2	of	of	IN
5180	760	3	these	these	DT
5180	760	4	attempts	attempt	NNS
5180	760	5	to	to	TO
5180	760	6	quantify	quantify	VB
5180	760	7	rates	rate	NNS
5180	760	8	of	of	IN
5180	760	9	over-	over-	NN
5180	760	10	and	and	CC
5180	760	11	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	760	12	suffers	suffer	NNS
5180	760	13	from	from	IN
5180	760	14	various	various	JJ
5180	760	15	methodological	methodological	JJ
5180	760	16	flaws	flaw	NNS
5180	760	17	.	.	.
5180	761	1	The	the	DT
5180	761	2	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
5180	761	3	problem	problem	NN
5180	761	4	with	with	IN
5180	761	5	calculating	calculate	VBG
5180	761	6	over-	over-	NN
5180	761	7	and	and	CC
5180	761	8	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	761	9	rates	rate	NNS
5180	761	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	761	11	selecting	select	VBG
5180	761	12	a	a	DT
5180	761	13	universe	universe	NN
5180	761	14	of	of	IN
5180	761	15	Web	web	NN
5180	761	16	sites	site	NNS
5180	761	17	or	or	CC
5180	761	18	Web	web	NN
5180	761	19	pages	page	NNS
5180	761	20	to	to	TO
5180	761	21	serve	serve	VB
5180	761	22	as	as	IN
5180	761	23	the	the	DT
5180	761	24	set	set	NN
5180	761	25	to	to	TO
5180	761	26	be	be	VB
5180	761	27	tested	test	VBN
5180	761	28	.	.	.
5180	762	1	The	the	DT
5180	762	2	studies	study	NNS
5180	762	3	that	that	WDT
5180	762	4	the	the	DT
5180	762	5	parties	party	NNS
5180	762	6	submitted	submit	VBN
5180	762	7	in	in	IN
5180	762	8	this	this	DT
5180	762	9	case	case	NN
5180	762	10	took	take	VBD
5180	762	11	two	two	CD
5180	762	12	different	different	JJ
5180	762	13	approaches	approach	NNS
5180	762	14	to	to	IN
5180	762	15	this	this	DT
5180	762	16	problem	problem	NN
5180	762	17	.	.	.
5180	763	1	Two	two	CD
5180	763	2	of	of	IN
5180	763	3	the	the	DT
5180	763	4	studies	study	NNS
5180	763	5	,	,	,
5180	763	6	one	one	CD
5180	763	7	prepared	prepare	VBN
5180	763	8	by	by	IN
5180	763	9	the	the	DT
5180	763	10	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	763	11	'	'	POS
5180	763	12	expert	expert	JJ
5180	763	13	witness	witness	NN
5180	763	14	Chris	Chris	NNP
5180	763	15	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
5180	763	16	,	,	,
5180	763	17	a	a	DT
5180	763	18	graduate	graduate	NN
5180	763	19	student	student	NN
5180	763	20	at	at	IN
5180	763	21	the	the	DT
5180	763	22	University	University	NNP
5180	763	23	of	of	IN
5180	763	24	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
5180	763	25	,	,	,
5180	763	26	and	and	CC
5180	763	27	the	the	DT
5180	763	28	other	other	JJ
5180	763	29	prepared	prepare	VBN
5180	763	30	by	by	IN
5180	763	31	the	the	DT
5180	763	32	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	763	33	'	'	POS
5180	763	34	expert	expert	NN
5180	763	35	,	,	,
5180	763	36	Chris	Chris	NNP
5180	763	37	Lemmons	Lemmons	NNP
5180	763	38	of	of	IN
5180	763	39	eTesting	eTesting	NNP
5180	763	40	Laboratories	Laboratories	NNP
5180	763	41	,	,	,
5180	763	42	in	in	IN
5180	763	43	Research	Research	NNP
5180	763	44	Triangle	Triangle	NNP
5180	763	45	Park	Park	NNP
5180	763	46	,	,	,
5180	763	47	North	North	NNP
5180	763	48	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
5180	763	49	,	,	,
5180	763	50	approached	approach	VBD
5180	763	51	this	this	DT
5180	763	52	problem	problem	NN
5180	763	53	by	by	IN
5180	763	54	compiling	compile	VBG
5180	763	55	two	two	CD
5180	763	56	separate	separate	JJ
5180	763	57	lists	list	NNS
5180	763	58	of	of	IN
5180	763	59	Web	web	NN
5180	763	60	sites	site	NNS
5180	763	61	,	,	,
5180	763	62	one	one	CD
5180	763	63	of	of	IN
5180	763	64	URLs	URLs	NNPS
5180	763	65	that	that	IN
5180	763	66	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	763	67	deemed	deem	VBD
5180	763	68	should	should	MD
5180	763	69	be	be	VB
5180	763	70	blocked	block	VBN
5180	763	71	according	accord	VBG
5180	763	72	to	to	IN
5180	763	73	the	the	DT
5180	763	74	filters	filter	NNS
5180	763	75	'	'	POS
5180	763	76	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	763	77	,	,	,
5180	763	78	and	and	CC
5180	763	79	another	another	DT
5180	763	80	of	of	IN
5180	763	81	URLs	URLs	NNPS
5180	763	82	that	that	WDT
5180	763	83	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	763	84	deemed	deem	VBD
5180	763	85	should	should	MD
5180	763	86	not	not	RB
5180	763	87	be	be	VB
5180	763	88	blocked	block	VBN
5180	763	89	according	accord	VBG
5180	763	90	to	to	IN
5180	763	91	the	the	DT
5180	763	92	filters	filter	NNS
5180	763	93	'	'	POS
5180	763	94	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	763	95	.	.	.
5180	764	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
5180	764	2	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	764	3	these	these	DT
5180	764	4	lists	list	NNS
5180	764	5	by	by	IN
5180	764	6	choosing	choose	VBG
5180	764	7	Web	web	NN
5180	764	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	764	9	from	from	IN
5180	764	10	the	the	DT
5180	764	11	results	result	NNS
5180	764	12	of	of	IN
5180	764	13	certain	certain	JJ
5180	764	14	key	key	JJ
5180	764	15	word	word	NN
5180	764	16	searches	search	NNS
5180	764	17	.	.	.
5180	765	1	The	the	DT
5180	765	2	problem	problem	NN
5180	765	3	with	with	IN
5180	765	4	this	this	DT
5180	765	5	selection	selection	NN
5180	765	6	method	method	NN
5180	765	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	765	8	that	that	IN
5180	765	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	765	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	765	11	neither	neither	RB
5180	765	12	random	random	JJ
5180	765	13	,	,	,
5180	765	14	nor	nor	CC
5180	765	15	does	do	VBZ
5180	765	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	765	17	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	765	18	approximate	approximate	VB
5180	765	19	the	the	DT
5180	765	20	universe	universe	NN
5180	765	21	of	of	IN
5180	765	22	Web	web	NN
5180	765	23	pages	page	NNS
5180	765	24	that	that	WDT
5180	765	25	library	library	NN
5180	765	26	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	765	27	visit	visit	VBP
5180	765	28	.	.	.
5180	766	1	The	the	DT
5180	766	2	two	two	CD
5180	766	3	other	other	JJ
5180	766	4	studies	study	NNS
5180	766	5	,	,	,
5180	766	6	one	one	CD
5180	766	7	by	by	IN
5180	766	8	David	David	NNP
5180	766	9	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	766	10	,	,	,
5180	766	11	head	head	NN
5180	766	12	librarian	librarian	NNP
5180	766	13	at	at	IN
5180	766	14	the	the	DT
5180	766	15	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	766	16	Public	Public	NNP
5180	766	17	Library	Library	NNP
5180	766	18	's	's	POS
5180	766	19	main	main	JJ
5180	766	20	branch	branch	NN
5180	766	21	,	,	,
5180	766	22	and	and	CC
5180	766	23	one	one	CD
5180	766	24	by	by	IN
5180	766	25	Cory	Cory	NNP
5180	766	26	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	766	27	of	of	IN
5180	766	28	Certus	Certus	NNP
5180	766	29	Consulting	Consulting	NNP
5180	766	30	Group	Group	NNP
5180	766	31	,	,	,
5180	766	32	of	of	IN
5180	766	33	Seattle	Seattle	NNP
5180	766	34	,	,	,
5180	766	35	Washington	Washington	NNP
5180	766	36	,	,	,
5180	766	37	chose	choose	VBD
5180	766	38	actual	actual	JJ
5180	766	39	logs	log	NNS
5180	766	40	of	of	IN
5180	766	41	Web	web	NN
5180	766	42	pages	page	NNS
5180	766	43	visited	visit	VBN
5180	766	44	by	by	IN
5180	766	45	library	library	NN
5180	766	46	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	766	47	during	during	IN
5180	766	48	specific	specific	JJ
5180	766	49	time	time	NN
5180	766	50	periods	period	NNS
5180	766	51	as	as	IN
5180	766	52	the	the	DT
5180	766	53	universe	universe	NN
5180	766	54	of	of	IN
5180	766	55	Web	web	NN
5180	766	56	pages	page	NNS
5180	766	57	to	to	TO
5180	766	58	analyze	analyze	VB
5180	766	59	.	.	.
5180	767	1	This	this	DT
5180	767	2	method	method	NN
5180	767	3	,	,	,
5180	767	4	while	while	IN
5180	767	5	surely	surely	RB
5180	767	6	not	not	RB
5180	767	7	as	as	RB
5180	767	8	accurate	accurate	JJ
5180	767	9	as	as	IN
5180	767	10	a	a	DT
5180	767	11	truly	truly	RB
5180	767	12	random	random	JJ
5180	767	13	sample	sample	NN
5180	767	14	of	of	IN
5180	767	15	the	the	DT
5180	767	16	indexed	index	VBN
5180	767	17	Web	web	NN
5180	767	18	would	would	MD
5180	767	19	be	be	VB
5180	767	20	(	(	-LRB-
5180	767	21	assuming	assume	VBG
5180	767	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	767	23	would	would	MD
5180	767	24	be	be	VB
5180	767	25	possible	possible	JJ
5180	767	26	to	to	TO
5180	767	27	take	take	VB
5180	767	28	such	such	PDT
5180	767	29	a	a	DT
5180	767	30	sample	sample	NN
5180	767	31	)	)	-RRB-
5180	767	32	,	,	,
5180	767	33	has	have	VBZ
5180	767	34	the	the	DT
5180	767	35	virtue	virtue	NN
5180	767	36	of	of	IN
5180	767	37	using	use	VBG
5180	767	38	the	the	DT
5180	767	39	actual	actual	JJ
5180	767	40	Web	web	NN
5180	767	41	sites	site	NNS
5180	767	42	that	that	WDT
5180	767	43	library	library	NN
5180	767	44	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	767	45	visited	visit	VBN
5180	767	46	during	during	IN
5180	767	47	a	a	DT
5180	767	48	specific	specific	JJ
5180	767	49	period	period	NN
5180	767	50	.	.	.
5180	768	1	Because	because	IN
5180	768	2	library	library	NN
5180	768	3	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	768	4	selected	select	VBD
5180	768	5	the	the	DT
5180	768	6	universe	universe	NN
5180	768	7	of	of	IN
5180	768	8	Web	web	NN
5180	768	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	768	10	that	that	IN
5180	768	11	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	768	12	and	and	CC
5180	768	13	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	768	14	's	's	POS
5180	768	15	studies	study	NNS
5180	768	16	analyzed	analyze	VBD
5180	768	17	,	,	,
5180	768	18	this	this	DT
5180	768	19	removes	remove	VBZ
5180	768	20	the	the	DT
5180	768	21	possibility	possibility	NN
5180	768	22	of	of	IN
5180	768	23	bias	bias	NN
5180	768	24	resulting	result	VBG
5180	768	25	from	from	IN
5180	768	26	the	the	DT
5180	768	27	study	study	NN
5180	768	28	author	author	NN
5180	768	29	's	's	POS
5180	768	30	selection	selection	NN
5180	768	31	of	of	IN
5180	768	32	the	the	DT
5180	768	33	universe	universe	NN
5180	768	34	of	of	IN
5180	768	35	sites	site	NNS
5180	768	36	to	to	TO
5180	768	37	be	be	VB
5180	768	38	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	768	39	.	.	.
5180	769	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	769	2	find	find	VBP
5180	769	3	that	that	IN
5180	769	4	the	the	DT
5180	769	5	Lemmons	Lemmons	NNPS
5180	769	6	and	and	CC
5180	769	7	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
5180	769	8	studies	study	NNS
5180	769	9	are	be	VBP
5180	769	10	of	of	IN
5180	769	11	little	little	JJ
5180	769	12	probative	probative	JJ
5180	769	13	value	value	NN
5180	769	14	because	because	IN
5180	769	15	of	of	IN
5180	769	16	the	the	DT
5180	769	17	methodology	methodology	NN
5180	769	18	used	use	VBN
5180	769	19	to	to	TO
5180	769	20	select	select	VB
5180	769	21	the	the	DT
5180	769	22	sample	sample	NN
5180	769	23	universe	universe	NN
5180	769	24	of	of	IN
5180	769	25	Web	web	NN
5180	769	26	sites	site	NNS
5180	769	27	to	to	TO
5180	769	28	be	be	VB
5180	769	29	tested	test	VBN
5180	769	30	.	.	.
5180	770	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	770	2	will	will	MD
5180	770	3	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	770	4	focus	focus	VB
5180	770	5	on	on	IN
5180	770	6	the	the	DT
5180	770	7	studies	study	NNS
5180	770	8	conducted	conduct	VBN
5180	770	9	by	by	IN
5180	770	10	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	770	11	and	and	CC
5180	770	12	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	770	13	in	in	IN
5180	770	14	trying	try	VBG
5180	770	15	to	to	TO
5180	770	16	ascertain	ascertain	VB
5180	770	17	estimates	estimate	NNS
5180	770	18	of	of	IN
5180	770	19	the	the	DT
5180	770	20	rates	rate	NNS
5180	770	21	of	of	IN
5180	770	22	over-	over-	NN
5180	770	23	and	and	CC
5180	770	24	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	770	25	that	that	DT
5180	770	26	takes	take	VBZ
5180	770	27	place	place	NN
5180	770	28	when	when	WRB
5180	770	29	filters	filter	NNS
5180	770	30	are	be	VBP
5180	770	31	used	use	VBN
5180	770	32	in	in	IN
5180	770	33	public	public	JJ
5180	770	34	libraries	library	NNS
5180	770	35	.	.	.
5180	771	1	The	the	DT
5180	771	2	government	government	NN
5180	771	3	hired	hire	VBD
5180	771	4	expert	expert	JJ
5180	771	5	witness	witness	NN
5180	771	6	Cory	Cory	NNP
5180	771	7	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	771	8	to	to	TO
5180	771	9	study	study	VB
5180	771	10	the	the	DT
5180	771	11	Internet	internet	NN
5180	771	12	logs	log	NNS
5180	771	13	compiled	compile	VBN
5180	771	14	by	by	IN
5180	771	15	the	the	DT
5180	771	16	public	public	JJ
5180	771	17	libraries	library	NNS
5180	771	18	systems	system	NNS
5180	771	19	in	in	IN
5180	771	20	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	771	21	,	,	,
5180	771	22	Washington	Washington	NNP
5180	771	23	;	;	:
5180	771	24	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	771	25	,	,	,
5180	771	26	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
5180	771	27	;	;	:
5180	771	28	and	and	CC
5180	771	29	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	771	30	,	,	,
5180	771	31	South	South	NNP
5180	771	32	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
5180	771	33	.	.	.
5180	772	1	Each	each	DT
5180	772	2	of	of	IN
5180	772	3	these	these	DT
5180	772	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	772	5	uses	use	VBZ
5180	772	6	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	772	7	software	software	NN
5180	772	8	that	that	WDT
5180	772	9	keeps	keep	VBZ
5180	772	10	a	a	DT
5180	772	11	log	log	NN
5180	772	12	of	of	IN
5180	772	13	information	information	NN
5180	772	14	about	about	IN
5180	772	15	individual	individual	JJ
5180	772	16	Web	web	NN
5180	772	17	site	site	NN
5180	772	18	requests	request	NNS
5180	772	19	made	make	VBN
5180	772	20	by	by	IN
5180	772	21	library	library	NN
5180	772	22	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	772	23	.	.	.
5180	773	1	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	773	2	,	,	,
5180	773	3	whose	whose	WP$
5180	773	4	consulting	consult	VBG
5180	773	5	firm	firm	NN
5180	773	6	specializes	specialize	VBZ
5180	773	7	in	in	IN
5180	773	8	data	datum	NNS
5180	773	9	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	773	10	,	,	,
5180	773	11	has	have	VBZ
5180	773	12	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	773	13	experience	experience	NN
5180	773	14	evaluating	evaluate	VBG
5180	773	15	Internet	internet	NN
5180	773	16	access	access	NN
5180	773	17	logs	log	NNS
5180	773	18	generated	generate	VBN
5180	773	19	on	on	IN
5180	773	20	networked	networked	JJ
5180	773	21	systems	system	NNS
5180	773	22	.	.	.
5180	774	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	774	2	spent	spend	VBD
5180	774	3	more	more	JJR
5180	774	4	than	than	IN
5180	774	5	a	a	DT
5180	774	6	year	year	NN
5180	774	7	developing	develop	VBG
5180	774	8	a	a	DT
5180	774	9	reporting	reporting	NN
5180	774	10	tool	tool	NN
5180	774	11	for	for	IN
5180	774	12	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	774	13	,	,	,
5180	774	14	and	and	CC
5180	774	15	,	,	,
5180	774	16	in	in	IN
5180	774	17	the	the	DT
5180	774	18	course	course	NN
5180	774	19	of	of	IN
5180	774	20	that	that	DT
5180	774	21	work	work	NN
5180	774	22	,	,	,
5180	774	23	acquired	acquire	VBD
5180	774	24	a	a	DT
5180	774	25	familiarity	familiarity	NN
5180	774	26	with	with	IN
5180	774	27	the	the	DT
5180	774	28	design	design	NN
5180	774	29	and	and	CC
5180	774	30	operation	operation	NN
5180	774	31	of	of	IN
5180	774	32	Internet	internet	NN
5180	774	33	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	774	34	products	product	NNS
5180	774	35	.	.	.
5180	775	1	The	the	DT
5180	775	2	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	775	3	library	library	NN
5180	775	4	uses	use	VBZ
5180	775	5	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	775	6	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	775	7	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	775	8	software	software	NN
5180	775	9	,	,	,
5180	775	10	and	and	CC
5180	775	11	logs	log	VBZ
5180	775	12	information	information	NN
5180	775	13	only	only	RB
5180	775	14	on	on	IN
5180	775	15	sites	site	NNS
5180	775	16	that	that	WDT
5180	775	17	were	be	VBD
5180	775	18	blocked	block	VBN
5180	775	19	.	.	.
5180	776	1	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	776	2	worked	work	VBD
5180	776	3	from	from	IN
5180	776	4	a	a	DT
5180	776	5	list	list	NN
5180	776	6	of	of	IN
5180	776	7	all	all	DT
5180	776	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	776	9	that	that	WDT
5180	776	10	were	be	VBD
5180	776	11	blocked	block	VBN
5180	776	12	in	in	IN
5180	776	13	the	the	DT
5180	776	14	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	776	15	public	public	JJ
5180	776	16	library	library	NN
5180	776	17	in	in	IN
5180	776	18	the	the	DT
5180	776	19	month	month	NN
5180	776	20	of	of	IN
5180	776	21	August	August	NNP
5180	776	22	2001	2001	CD
5180	776	23	.	.	.
5180	777	1	The	the	DT
5180	777	2	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	777	3	library	library	NN
5180	777	4	uses	use	VBZ
5180	777	5	the	the	DT
5180	777	6	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	777	7	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	777	8	product	product	NN
5180	777	9	,	,	,
5180	777	10	and	and	CC
5180	777	11	logs	log	VBZ
5180	777	12	information	information	NN
5180	777	13	on	on	IN
5180	777	14	both	both	DT
5180	777	15	blocked	block	VBN
5180	777	16	sites	site	NNS
5180	777	17	and	and	CC
5180	777	18	non	non	JJ
5180	777	19	-	-	JJ
5180	777	20	blocked	blocked	JJ
5180	777	21	sites	site	NNS
5180	777	22	.	.	.
5180	778	1	When	when	WRB
5180	778	2	the	the	DT
5180	778	3	logs	log	NNS
5180	778	4	reach	reach	VBP
5180	778	5	a	a	DT
5180	778	6	certain	certain	JJ
5180	778	7	size	size	NN
5180	778	8	,	,	,
5180	778	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	778	10	are	be	VBP
5180	778	11	overwritten	overwrite	VBN
5180	778	12	by	by	IN
5180	778	13	new	new	JJ
5180	778	14	usage	usage	NN
5180	778	15	logs	log	NNS
5180	778	16	.	.	.
5180	779	1	Because	because	IN
5180	779	2	of	of	IN
5180	779	3	this	this	DT
5180	779	4	overwriting	overwrite	VBG
5180	779	5	feature	feature	NN
5180	779	6	,	,	,
5180	779	7	logs	log	NNS
5180	779	8	were	be	VBD
5180	779	9	available	available	JJ
5180	779	10	to	to	IN
5180	779	11	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	779	12	only	only	RB
5180	779	13	for	for	IN
5180	779	14	the	the	DT
5180	779	15	relatively	relatively	RB
5180	779	16	short	short	JJ
5180	779	17	period	period	NN
5180	779	18	from	from	IN
5180	779	19	October	October	NNP
5180	779	20	1	1	CD
5180	779	21	,	,	,
5180	779	22	2001	2001	CD
5180	779	23	to	to	IN
5180	779	24	October	October	NNP
5180	779	25	3	3	CD
5180	779	26	,	,	,
5180	779	27	2001	2001	CD
5180	779	28	.	.	.
5180	780	1	The	the	DT
5180	780	2	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	780	3	library	library	NN
5180	780	4	uses	use	VBZ
5180	780	5	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	780	6	's	's	POS
5180	780	7	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	780	8	product	product	NN
5180	780	9	and	and	CC
5180	780	10	logs	log	NNS
5180	780	11	both	both	DT
5180	780	12	blocked	block	VBD
5180	780	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	780	14	and	and	CC
5180	780	15	sites	site	NNS
5180	780	16	that	that	IN
5180	780	17	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	780	18	accessed	access	VBD
5180	780	19	.	.	.
5180	781	1	The	the	DT
5180	781	2	logs	log	NNS
5180	781	3	contain	contain	VBP
5180	781	4	more	more	JJR
5180	781	5	than	than	IN
5180	781	6	500,000	500,000	CD
5180	781	7	records	record	NNS
5180	781	8	per	per	IN
5180	781	9	day	day	NN
5180	781	10	.	.	.
5180	782	1	Because	because	IN
5180	782	2	of	of	IN
5180	782	3	the	the	DT
5180	782	4	volume	volume	NN
5180	782	5	of	of	IN
5180	782	6	the	the	DT
5180	782	7	records	record	NNS
5180	782	8	,	,	,
5180	782	9	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	782	10	restricted	restrict	VBD
5180	782	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	782	12	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	782	13	to	to	IN
5180	782	14	the	the	DT
5180	782	15	period	period	NN
5180	782	16	from	from	IN
5180	782	17	August	August	NNP
5180	782	18	2	2	CD
5180	782	19	,	,	,
5180	782	20	2001	2001	CD
5180	782	21	to	to	IN
5180	782	22	August	August	NNP
5180	782	23	15	15	CD
5180	782	24	,	,	,
5180	782	25	2001	2001	CD
5180	782	26	.	.	.
5180	783	1	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	783	2	calculated	calculate	VBD
5180	783	3	an	an	DT
5180	783	4	overblocking	overblocking	NN
5180	783	5	rate	rate	NN
5180	783	6	for	for	IN
5180	783	7	each	each	DT
5180	783	8	of	of	IN
5180	783	9	the	the	DT
5180	783	10	three	three	CD
5180	783	11	libraries	library	NNS
5180	783	12	by	by	IN
5180	783	13	examining	examine	VBG
5180	783	14	the	the	DT
5180	783	15	host	host	NN
5180	783	16	Web	web	NN
5180	783	17	site	site	NN
5180	783	18	containing	contain	VBG
5180	783	19	each	each	DT
5180	783	20	of	of	IN
5180	783	21	the	the	DT
5180	783	22	blocked	block	VBN
5180	783	23	pages	page	NNS
5180	783	24	.	.	.
5180	784	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	784	2	did	do	VBD
5180	784	3	not	not	RB
5180	784	4	employ	employ	VB
5180	784	5	a	a	DT
5180	784	6	sampling	sampling	NN
5180	784	7	technique	technique	NN
5180	784	8	,	,	,
5180	784	9	but	but	CC
5180	784	10	instead	instead	RB
5180	784	11	examined	examine	VBD
5180	784	12	each	each	DT
5180	784	13	blocked	block	VBN
5180	784	14	Web	web	NN
5180	784	15	site	site	NN
5180	784	16	.	.	.
5180	785	1	If	if	IN
5180	785	2	the	the	DT
5180	785	3	contents	content	NNS
5180	785	4	of	of	IN
5180	785	5	a	a	DT
5180	785	6	host	host	NN
5180	785	7	Web	web	NN
5180	785	8	site	site	NN
5180	785	9	or	or	CC
5180	785	10	the	the	DT
5180	785	11	pages	page	NNS
5180	785	12	within	within	IN
5180	785	13	the	the	DT
5180	785	14	Web	web	NN
5180	785	15	site	site	NN
5180	785	16	were	be	VBD
5180	785	17	consistent	consistent	JJ
5180	785	18	with	with	IN
5180	785	19	the	the	DT
5180	785	20	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	785	21	product	product	NN
5180	785	22	's	's	POS
5180	785	23	definition	definition	NN
5180	785	24	of	of	IN
5180	785	25	the	the	DT
5180	785	26	category	category	NN
5180	785	27	under	under	IN
5180	785	28	which	which	WDT
5180	785	29	the	the	DT
5180	785	30	site	site	NN
5180	785	31	was	be	VBD
5180	785	32	blocked	block	VBN
5180	785	33	,	,	,
5180	785	34	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	785	35	considered	consider	VBD
5180	785	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	785	37	to	to	TO
5180	785	38	be	be	VB
5180	785	39	an	an	DT
5180	785	40	accurate	accurate	JJ
5180	785	41	block	block	NN
5180	785	42	.	.	.
5180	786	1	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	786	2	and	and	CC
5180	786	3	three	three	CD
5180	786	4	others	other	NNS
5180	786	5	,	,	,
5180	786	6	two	two	CD
5180	786	7	of	of	IN
5180	786	8	whom	whom	WP
5180	786	9	were	be	VBD
5180	786	10	temporary	temporary	JJ
5180	786	11	employees	employee	NNS
5180	786	12	,	,	,
5180	786	13	examined	examine	VBD
5180	786	14	the	the	DT
5180	786	15	Web	web	NN
5180	786	16	sites	site	NNS
5180	786	17	to	to	TO
5180	786	18	determine	determine	VB
5180	786	19	whether	whether	IN
5180	786	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	786	21	were	be	VBD
5180	786	22	consistent	consistent	JJ
5180	786	23	with	with	IN
5180	786	24	the	the	DT
5180	786	25	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	786	26	companies	company	NNS
5180	786	27	'	'	POS
5180	786	28	category	category	NN
5180	786	29	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	786	30	.	.	.
5180	787	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	787	2	review	review	NN
5180	787	3	was	be	VBD
5180	787	4	,	,	,
5180	787	5	of	of	IN
5180	787	6	course	course	NN
5180	787	7	,	,	,
5180	787	8	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	787	9	limited	limit	VBN
5180	787	10	by	by	IN
5180	787	11	:	:	:
5180	787	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	787	13	1	1	LS
5180	787	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	787	15	the	the	DT
5180	787	16	clarity	clarity	NN
5180	787	17	of	of	IN
5180	787	18	the	the	DT
5180	787	19	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	787	20	companies	company	NNS
5180	787	21	'	'	POS
5180	787	22	category	category	NN
5180	787	23	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	787	24	;	;	,
5180	787	25	(	(	-LRB-
5180	787	26	2	2	LS
5180	787	27	)	)	-RRB-
5180	787	28	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	787	29	's	's	POS
5180	787	30	and	and	CC
5180	787	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	787	32	employees	employee	NNS
5180	787	33	'	'	POS
5180	787	34	interpretations	interpretation	NNS
5180	787	35	of	of	IN
5180	787	36	the	the	DT
5180	787	37	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	787	38	;	;	,
5180	787	39	and	and	CC
5180	787	40	(	(	-LRB-
5180	787	41	3	3	LS
5180	787	42	)	)	-RRB-
5180	787	43	human	human	JJ
5180	787	44	error	error	NN
5180	787	45	.	.	.
5180	788	1	The	the	DT
5180	788	2	study	study	NN
5180	788	3	's	's	POS
5180	788	4	reliability	reliability	NN
5180	788	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	788	6	also	also	RB
5180	788	7	undercut	undercut	JJ
5180	788	8	by	by	IN
5180	788	9	the	the	DT
5180	788	10	fact	fact	NN
5180	788	11	that	that	IN
5180	788	12	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	788	13	failed	fail	VBD
5180	788	14	to	to	TO
5180	788	15	archive	archive	VB
5180	788	16	the	the	DT
5180	788	17	blocked	block	VBN
5180	788	18	Web	web	NN
5180	788	19	pages	page	NNS
5180	788	20	as	as	IN
5180	788	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	788	22	existed	exist	VBD
5180	788	23	either	either	CC
5180	788	24	at	at	IN
5180	788	25	the	the	DT
5180	788	26	point	point	NN
5180	788	27	that	that	IN
5180	788	28	a	a	DT
5180	788	29	patron	patron	NN
5180	788	30	in	in	IN
5180	788	31	one	one	CD
5180	788	32	of	of	IN
5180	788	33	the	the	DT
5180	788	34	three	three	CD
5180	788	35	libraries	library	NNS
5180	788	36	was	be	VBD
5180	788	37	denied	deny	VBN
5180	788	38	access	access	NN
5180	788	39	or	or	CC
5180	788	40	when	when	WRB
5180	788	41	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	788	42	and	and	CC
5180	788	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	788	44	team	team	NN
5180	788	45	reviewed	review	VBD
5180	788	46	the	the	DT
5180	788	47	pages	page	NNS
5180	788	48	.	.	.
5180	789	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	789	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	789	3	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	789	4	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	789	5	for	for	IN
5180	789	6	anyone	anyone	NN
5180	789	7	to	to	TO
5180	789	8	check	check	VB
5180	789	9	the	the	DT
5180	789	10	accuracy	accuracy	NN
5180	789	11	and	and	CC
5180	789	12	consistency	consistency	NN
5180	789	13	of	of	IN
5180	789	14	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	789	15	's	's	POS
5180	789	16	review	review	NN
5180	789	17	team	team	NN
5180	789	18	,	,	,
5180	789	19	or	or	CC
5180	789	20	to	to	TO
5180	789	21	know	know	VB
5180	789	22	whether	whether	IN
5180	789	23	the	the	DT
5180	789	24	pages	page	NNS
5180	789	25	contained	contain	VBD
5180	789	26	the	the	DT
5180	789	27	same	same	JJ
5180	789	28	content	content	NN
5180	789	29	when	when	WRB
5180	789	30	the	the	DT
5180	789	31	block	block	NN
5180	789	32	occurred	occur	VBD
5180	789	33	as	as	IN
5180	789	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	789	35	did	do	VBD
5180	789	36	when	when	WRB
5180	789	37	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	789	38	's	's	POS
5180	789	39	team	team	NN
5180	789	40	reviewed	review	VBD
5180	789	41	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	789	42	.	.	.
5180	790	1	This	this	DT
5180	790	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	790	3	a	a	DT
5180	790	4	key	key	JJ
5180	790	5	flaw	flaw	NN
5180	790	6	,	,	,
5180	790	7	because	because	IN
5180	790	8	the	the	DT
5180	790	9	results	result	NNS
5180	790	10	of	of	IN
5180	790	11	the	the	DT
5180	790	12	study	study	NN
5180	790	13	depend	depend	VBP
5180	790	14	on	on	IN
5180	790	15	individual	individual	JJ
5180	790	16	determinations	determination	NNS
5180	790	17	as	as	IN
5180	790	18	to	to	IN
5180	790	19	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	790	20	and	and	CC
5180	790	21	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	790	22	,	,	,
5180	790	23	in	in	IN
5180	790	24	which	which	WDT
5180	790	25	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	790	26	and	and	CC
5180	790	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	790	28	team	team	NN
5180	790	29	were	be	VBD
5180	790	30	required	require	VBN
5180	790	31	to	to	TO
5180	790	32	compare	compare	VB
5180	790	33	what	what	WP
5180	790	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	790	35	saw	see	VBD
5180	790	36	on	on	IN
5180	790	37	the	the	DT
5180	790	38	Web	web	NN
5180	790	39	pages	page	NNS
5180	790	40	that	that	WDT
5180	790	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	790	42	reviewed	review	VBD
5180	790	43	with	with	IN
5180	790	44	standard	standard	JJ
5180	790	45	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	790	46	provided	provide	VBN
5180	790	47	by	by	IN
5180	790	48	the	the	DT
5180	790	49	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	790	50	company	company	NN
5180	790	51	.	.	.
5180	791	1	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	791	2	library	library	NN
5180	791	3	's	's	POS
5180	791	4	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	791	5	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	791	6	software	software	NN
5180	791	7	blocked	block	VBD
5180	791	8	836	836	CD
5180	791	9	unique	unique	JJ
5180	791	10	Web	web	NN
5180	791	11	sites	site	NNS
5180	791	12	during	during	IN
5180	791	13	the	the	DT
5180	791	14	month	month	NN
5180	791	15	of	of	IN
5180	791	16	August	August	NNP
5180	791	17	.	.	.
5180	792	1	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	792	2	determined	determine	VBD
5180	792	3	that	that	IN
5180	792	4	783	783	CD
5180	792	5	of	of	IN
5180	792	6	those	those	DT
5180	792	7	blocks	block	NNS
5180	792	8	were	be	VBD
5180	792	9	accurate	accurate	JJ
5180	792	10	and	and	CC
5180	792	11	that	that	IN
5180	792	12	53	53	CD
5180	792	13	were	be	VBD
5180	792	14	inaccurate	inaccurate	JJ
5180	792	15	.	.	.
5180	793	1	The	the	DT
5180	793	2	error	error	NN
5180	793	3	rate	rate	NN
5180	793	4	for	for	IN
5180	793	5	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	793	6	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	793	7	was	be	VBD
5180	793	8	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	793	9	estimated	estimate	VBN
5180	793	10	to	to	TO
5180	793	11	be	be	VB
5180	793	12	6.34	6.34	CD
5180	793	13	%	%	NN
5180	793	14	,	,	,
5180	793	15	and	and	CC
5180	793	16	the	the	DT
5180	793	17	true	true	JJ
5180	793	18	error	error	NN
5180	793	19	rate	rate	NN
5180	793	20	was	be	VBD
5180	793	21	estimated	estimate	VBN
5180	793	22	with	with	IN
5180	793	23	95	95	CD
5180	793	24	%	%	NN
5180	793	25	confidence	confidence	NN
5180	793	26	to	to	TO
5180	793	27	lie	lie	VB
5180	793	28	within	within	IN
5180	793	29	the	the	DT
5180	793	30	range	range	NN
5180	793	31	of	of	IN
5180	793	32	4.69	4.69	CD
5180	793	33	%	%	NN
5180	793	34	to	to	IN
5180	793	35	7.99	7.99	CD
5180	793	36	%	%	NN
5180	793	37	.	.	.
5180	794	1	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	794	2	and	and	CC
5180	794	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	794	4	team	team	NN
5180	794	5	reviewed	review	VBD
5180	794	6	185	185	CD
5180	794	7	unique	unique	JJ
5180	794	8	Web	web	NN
5180	794	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	794	10	that	that	WDT
5180	794	11	were	be	VBD
5180	794	12	blocked	block	VBN
5180	794	13	by	by	IN
5180	794	14	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	794	15	Library	Library	NNP
5180	794	16	's	's	POS
5180	794	17	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	794	18	filter	filter	NN
5180	794	19	during	during	IN
5180	794	20	the	the	DT
5180	794	21	logged	log	VBN
5180	794	22	period	period	NN
5180	794	23	and	and	CC
5180	794	24	determined	determine	VBD
5180	794	25	that	that	IN
5180	794	26	158	158	CD
5180	794	27	of	of	IN
5180	794	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	794	29	were	be	VBD
5180	794	30	accurate	accurate	JJ
5180	794	31	and	and	CC
5180	794	32	that	that	IN
5180	794	33	27	27	CD
5180	794	34	of	of	IN
5180	794	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	794	36	were	be	VBD
5180	794	37	inaccurate	inaccurate	JJ
5180	794	38	.	.	.
5180	795	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	795	2	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	795	3	estimated	estimate	VBD
5180	795	4	the	the	DT
5180	795	5	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	795	6	filter	filter	NN
5180	795	7	's	's	POS
5180	795	8	overblocking	overblocking	NN
5180	795	9	rate	rate	NN
5180	795	10	at	at	IN
5180	795	11	14.59	14.59	CD
5180	795	12	%	%	NN
5180	795	13	with	with	IN
5180	795	14	a	a	DT
5180	795	15	95	95	CD
5180	795	16	%	%	NN
5180	795	17	confidence	confidence	NN
5180	795	18	interval	interval	NN
5180	795	19	of	of	IN
5180	795	20	9.51	9.51	CD
5180	795	21	%	%	NN
5180	795	22	to	to	IN
5180	795	23	19.68	19.68	CD
5180	795	24	%	%	NN
5180	795	25	.	.	.
5180	796	1	Additionally	additionally	RB
5180	796	2	,	,	,
5180	796	3	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	796	4	examined	examine	VBD
5180	796	5	1,674	1,674	CD
5180	796	6	unique	unique	JJ
5180	796	7	Web	web	NN
5180	796	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	796	9	that	that	WDT
5180	796	10	were	be	VBD
5180	796	11	blocked	block	VBN
5180	796	12	by	by	IN
5180	796	13	the	the	DT
5180	796	14	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	796	15	Library	Library	NNP
5180	796	16	's	's	POS
5180	796	17	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	796	18	filter	filter	NN
5180	796	19	during	during	IN
5180	796	20	the	the	DT
5180	796	21	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	796	22	period	period	NN
5180	796	23	and	and	CC
5180	796	24	determined	determine	VBD
5180	796	25	that	that	IN
5180	796	26	1,520	1,520	CD
5180	796	27	were	be	VBD
5180	796	28	accurate	accurate	JJ
5180	796	29	and	and	CC
5180	796	30	that	that	IN
5180	796	31	87	87	CD
5180	796	32	were	be	VBD
5180	796	33	inaccurate	inaccurate	JJ
5180	796	34	.	.	.
5180	797	1	This	this	DT
5180	797	2	yields	yield	VBZ
5180	797	3	an	an	DT
5180	797	4	estimated	estimate	VBN
5180	797	5	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	797	6	rate	rate	NN
5180	797	7	of	of	IN
5180	797	8	5.41	5.41	CD
5180	797	9	%	%	NN
5180	797	10	and	and	CC
5180	797	11	a	a	DT
5180	797	12	95	95	CD
5180	797	13	%	%	NN
5180	797	14	confidence	confidence	NN
5180	797	15	interval	interval	NN
5180	797	16	of	of	IN
5180	797	17	4.33	4.33	CD
5180	797	18	%	%	NN
5180	797	19	to	to	IN
5180	797	20	6.55	6.55	CD
5180	797	21	%	%	NN
5180	797	22	.	.	.
5180	798	1	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	798	2	's	's	POS
5180	798	3	methodology	methodology	NN
5180	798	4	was	be	VBD
5180	798	5	materially	materially	RB
5180	798	6	flawed	flawed	JJ
5180	798	7	in	in	IN
5180	798	8	that	that	IN
5180	798	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	798	10	understates	understate	VBZ
5180	798	11	the	the	DT
5180	798	12	rate	rate	NN
5180	798	13	of	of	IN
5180	798	14	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	798	15	for	for	IN
5180	798	16	the	the	DT
5180	798	17	following	follow	VBG
5180	798	18	reasons	reason	NNS
5180	798	19	.	.	.
5180	799	1	First	first	RB
5180	799	2	,	,	,
5180	799	3	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	799	4	from	from	IN
5180	799	5	the	the	DT
5180	799	6	three	three	CD
5180	799	7	libraries	library	NNS
5180	799	8	knew	know	VBD
5180	799	9	that	that	IN
5180	799	10	the	the	DT
5180	799	11	filters	filter	NNS
5180	799	12	were	be	VBD
5180	799	13	operating	operate	VBG
5180	799	14	,	,	,
5180	799	15	and	and	CC
5180	799	16	may	may	MD
5180	799	17	have	have	VB
5180	799	18	been	be	VBN
5180	799	19	deterred	deter	VBN
5180	799	20	from	from	IN
5180	799	21	attempting	attempt	VBG
5180	799	22	to	to	IN
5180	799	23	access	access	VB
5180	799	24	Web	web	NN
5180	799	25	sites	site	NNS
5180	799	26	that	that	IN
5180	799	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	799	28	perceived	perceive	VBD
5180	799	29	to	to	TO
5180	799	30	be	be	VB
5180	799	31	"	"	``
5180	799	32	borderline	borderline	NN
5180	799	33	"	"	''
5180	799	34	sites	site	NNS
5180	799	35	,	,	,
5180	799	36	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	799	37	,	,	,
5180	799	38	those	those	DT
5180	799	39	that	that	WDT
5180	799	40	may	may	MD
5180	799	41	or	or	CC
5180	799	42	may	may	MD
5180	799	43	not	not	RB
5180	799	44	have	have	VB
5180	799	45	been	be	VBN
5180	799	46	appropriately	appropriately	RB
5180	799	47	filtered	filter	VBN
5180	799	48	according	accord	VBG
5180	799	49	to	to	IN
5180	799	50	the	the	DT
5180	799	51	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	799	52	companies	company	NNS
5180	799	53	'	'	POS
5180	799	54	category	category	NN
5180	799	55	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	799	56	.	.	.
5180	800	1	Second	second	JJ
5180	800	2	,	,	,
5180	800	3	in	in	IN
5180	800	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	800	5	cross	cross	NN
5180	800	6	-	-	NN
5180	800	7	examination	examination	NN
5180	800	8	of	of	IN
5180	800	9	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	800	10	,	,	,
5180	800	11	the	the	DT
5180	800	12	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	800	13	offered	offer	VBD
5180	800	14	screen	screen	NN
5180	800	15	shots	shot	NNS
5180	800	16	of	of	IN
5180	800	17	a	a	DT
5180	800	18	number	number	NN
5180	800	19	of	of	IN
5180	800	20	Web	web	NN
5180	800	21	sites	site	NNS
5180	800	22	that	that	WDT
5180	800	23	,	,	,
5180	800	24	according	accord	VBG
5180	800	25	to	to	IN
5180	800	26	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	800	27	,	,	,
5180	800	28	had	have	VBD
5180	800	29	been	be	VBN
5180	800	30	appropriately	appropriately	RB
5180	800	31	blocked	block	VBN
5180	800	32	,	,	,
5180	800	33	but	but	CC
5180	800	34	that	that	IN
5180	800	35	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	800	36	admitted	admit	VBD
5180	800	37	contained	contain	VBD
5180	800	38	only	only	RB
5180	800	39	benign	benign	JJ
5180	800	40	materials	material	NNS
5180	800	41	.	.	.
5180	801	1	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	801	2	's	's	POS
5180	801	3	explanation	explanation	NN
5180	801	4	was	be	VBD
5180	801	5	that	that	IN
5180	801	6	the	the	DT
5180	801	7	Web	web	NN
5180	801	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	801	9	must	must	MD
5180	801	10	have	have	VB
5180	801	11	changed	change	VBN
5180	801	12	between	between	IN
5180	801	13	the	the	DT
5180	801	14	time	time	NN
5180	801	15	when	when	WRB
5180	801	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	801	17	conducted	conduct	VBD
5180	801	18	the	the	DT
5180	801	19	study	study	NN
5180	801	20	and	and	CC
5180	801	21	the	the	DT
5180	801	22	time	time	NN
5180	801	23	of	of	IN
5180	801	24	the	the	DT
5180	801	25	trial	trial	NN
5180	801	26	,	,	,
5180	801	27	but	but	CC
5180	801	28	because	because	IN
5180	801	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	801	30	did	do	VBD
5180	801	31	not	not	RB
5180	801	32	archive	archive	VB
5180	801	33	the	the	DT
5180	801	34	images	image	NNS
5180	801	35	as	as	IN
5180	801	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	801	37	existed	exist	VBD
5180	801	38	when	when	WRB
5180	801	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	801	40	team	team	NN
5180	801	41	reviewed	review	VBD
5180	801	42	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	801	43	for	for	IN
5180	801	44	the	the	DT
5180	801	45	study	study	NN
5180	801	46	,	,	,
5180	801	47	there	there	EX
5180	801	48	is	be	VBZ
5180	801	49	no	no	DT
5180	801	50	way	way	NN
5180	801	51	to	to	TO
5180	801	52	verify	verify	VB
5180	801	53	this	this	DT
5180	801	54	.	.	.
5180	802	1	Third	third	JJ
5180	802	2	,	,	,
5180	802	3	because	because	IN
5180	802	4	of	of	IN
5180	802	5	the	the	DT
5180	802	6	way	way	NN
5180	802	7	in	in	IN
5180	802	8	which	which	WDT
5180	802	9	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	802	10	counted	count	VBN
5180	802	11	blocked	block	VBN
5180	802	12	Web	web	NN
5180	802	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	802	14	–	–	:
5180	802	15	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	802	16	,	,	,
5180	802	17	if	if	IN
5180	802	18	separate	separate	JJ
5180	802	19	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	802	20	attempted	attempt	VBD
5180	802	21	to	to	TO
5180	802	22	reach	reach	VB
5180	802	23	the	the	DT
5180	802	24	same	same	JJ
5180	802	25	Web	web	NN
5180	802	26	site	site	NN
5180	802	27	,	,	,
5180	802	28	or	or	CC
5180	802	29	one	one	CD
5180	802	30	or	or	CC
5180	802	31	more	more	JJR
5180	802	32	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	802	33	attempted	attempt	VBD
5180	802	34	to	to	TO
5180	802	35	access	access	VB
5180	802	36	more	more	JJR
5180	802	37	than	than	IN
5180	802	38	one	one	CD
5180	802	39	page	page	NN
5180	802	40	on	on	IN
5180	802	41	a	a	DT
5180	802	42	single	single	JJ
5180	802	43	Web	web	NN
5180	802	44	site	site	NN
5180	802	45	,	,	,
5180	802	46	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	802	47	counted	count	VBD
5180	802	48	these	these	DT
5180	802	49	attempts	attempt	NNS
5180	802	50	as	as	IN
5180	802	51	a	a	DT
5180	802	52	single	single	JJ
5180	802	53	block	block	NN
5180	802	54	,	,	,
5180	802	55	see	see	VB
5180	802	56	supra	supra	NNP
5180	802	57	note	note	NNP
5180	802	58	10	10	CD
5180	802	59	–	–	:
5180	802	60	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	802	61	results	result	NNS
5180	802	62	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	802	63	understate	understate	VBP
5180	802	64	the	the	DT
5180	802	65	number	number	NN
5180	802	66	of	of	IN
5180	802	67	times	time	NNS
5180	802	68	that	that	IN
5180	802	69	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	802	70	were	be	VBD
5180	802	71	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	802	72	denied	deny	VBN
5180	802	73	access	access	NN
5180	802	74	to	to	IN
5180	802	75	information	information	NN
5180	802	76	.	.	.
5180	803	1	At	at	IN
5180	803	2	all	all	DT
5180	803	3	events	event	NNS
5180	803	4	,	,	,
5180	803	5	there	there	EX
5180	803	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	803	7	no	no	DT
5180	803	8	doubt	doubt	NN
5180	803	9	that	that	IN
5180	803	10	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	803	11	's	's	POS
5180	803	12	estimated	estimated	JJ
5180	803	13	rates	rate	NNS
5180	803	14	of	of	IN
5180	803	15	overblocking	overblocking	NN
5180	803	16	,	,	,
5180	803	17	which	which	WDT
5180	803	18	are	be	VBP
5180	803	19	based	base	VBN
5180	803	20	on	on	IN
5180	803	21	the	the	DT
5180	803	22	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	803	23	companies	company	NNS
5180	803	24	'	'	POS
5180	803	25	own	own	JJ
5180	803	26	category	category	NN
5180	803	27	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	803	28	,	,	,
5180	803	29	significantly	significantly	RB
5180	803	30	understate	understate	VBP
5180	803	31	the	the	DT
5180	803	32	rate	rate	NN
5180	803	33	of	of	IN
5180	803	34	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	803	35	with	with	IN
5180	803	36	respect	respect	NN
5180	803	37	to	to	IN
5180	803	38	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	803	39	's	's	POS
5180	803	40	category	category	NN
5180	803	41	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	803	42	for	for	IN
5180	803	43	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	803	44	for	for	IN
5180	803	45	adults	adult	NNS
5180	803	46	.	.	.
5180	804	1	The	the	DT
5180	804	2	filters	filter	NNS
5180	804	3	used	use	VBN
5180	804	4	in	in	IN
5180	804	5	the	the	DT
5180	804	6	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	804	7	,	,	,
5180	804	8	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	804	9	,	,	,
5180	804	10	and	and	CC
5180	804	11	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	804	12	libraries	library	NNS
5180	804	13	were	be	VBD
5180	804	14	configured	configure	VBN
5180	804	15	to	to	TO
5180	804	16	block	block	VB
5180	804	17	,	,	,
5180	804	18	among	among	IN
5180	804	19	other	other	JJ
5180	804	20	things	thing	NNS
5180	804	21	,	,	,
5180	804	22	images	image	NNS
5180	804	23	of	of	IN
5180	804	24	full	full	JJ
5180	804	25	nudity	nudity	NN
5180	804	26	and	and	CC
5180	804	27	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	804	28	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	804	29	materials	material	NNS
5180	804	30	.	.	.
5180	805	1	There	there	EX
5180	805	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	805	3	no	no	DT
5180	805	4	dispute	dispute	NN
5180	805	5	,	,	,
5180	805	6	however	however	RB
5180	805	7	,	,	,
5180	805	8	that	that	IN
5180	805	9	these	these	DT
5180	805	10	categories	category	NNS
5180	805	11	are	be	VBP
5180	805	12	far	far	RB
5180	805	13	broader	broad	JJR
5180	805	14	than	than	IN
5180	805	15	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	805	16	's	's	POS
5180	805	17	categories	category	NNS
5180	805	18	of	of	IN
5180	805	19	visual	visual	JJ
5180	805	20	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	805	21	that	that	WDT
5180	805	22	are	be	VBP
5180	805	23	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	805	24	,	,	,
5180	805	25	or	or	CC
5180	805	26	child	child	NN
5180	805	27	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	805	28	,	,	,
5180	805	29	the	the	DT
5180	805	30	two	two	CD
5180	805	31	categories	category	NNS
5180	805	32	of	of	IN
5180	805	33	material	material	NN
5180	805	34	that	that	WDT
5180	805	35	libraries	librarie	VBZ
5180	805	36	subject	subject	JJ
5180	805	37	to	to	IN
5180	805	38	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	805	39	must	must	MD
5180	805	40	certify	certify	VB
5180	805	41	that	that	IN
5180	805	42	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	805	43	filter	filter	VBP
5180	805	44	during	during	IN
5180	805	45	adults	adult	NNS
5180	805	46	'	'	POS
5180	805	47	use	use	NN
5180	805	48	of	of	IN
5180	805	49	the	the	DT
5180	805	50	Internet	internet	NN
5180	805	51	.	.	.
5180	806	1	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	806	2	's	's	POS
5180	806	3	study	study	NN
5180	806	4	also	also	RB
5180	806	5	calculated	calculate	VBD
5180	806	6	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	806	7	rates	rate	NNS
5180	806	8	with	with	IN
5180	806	9	respect	respect	NN
5180	806	10	to	to	IN
5180	806	11	the	the	DT
5180	806	12	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	806	13	and	and	CC
5180	806	14	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	806	15	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	806	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	806	17	both	both	DT
5180	806	18	of	of	IN
5180	806	19	which	which	WDT
5180	806	20	logged	log	VBD
5180	806	21	not	not	RB
5180	806	22	only	only	RB
5180	806	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	806	24	blocked	block	VBN
5180	806	25	sites	site	NNS
5180	806	26	,	,	,
5180	806	27	but	but	CC
5180	806	28	all	all	DT
5180	806	29	sites	site	NNS
5180	806	30	visited	visit	VBN
5180	806	31	by	by	IN
5180	806	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	806	33	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	806	34	)	)	-RRB-
5180	806	35	,	,	,
5180	806	36	by	by	IN
5180	806	37	taking	take	VBG
5180	806	38	random	random	JJ
5180	806	39	samples	sample	NNS
5180	806	40	of	of	IN
5180	806	41	URLs	url	NNS
5180	806	42	from	from	IN
5180	806	43	the	the	DT
5180	806	44	list	list	NN
5180	806	45	of	of	IN
5180	806	46	sites	site	NNS
5180	806	47	that	that	WDT
5180	806	48	were	be	VBD
5180	806	49	not	not	RB
5180	806	50	blocked	block	VBN
5180	806	51	.	.	.
5180	807	1	The	the	DT
5180	807	2	study	study	NN
5180	807	3	used	use	VBD
5180	807	4	a	a	DT
5180	807	5	sample	sample	NN
5180	807	6	of	of	IN
5180	807	7	159	159	CD
5180	807	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	807	9	that	that	WDT
5180	807	10	were	be	VBD
5180	807	11	accessed	access	VBN
5180	807	12	by	by	IN
5180	807	13	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	807	14	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	807	15	and	and	CC
5180	807	16	determined	determine	VBD
5180	807	17	that	that	IN
5180	807	18	only	only	RB
5180	807	19	one	one	CD
5180	807	20	of	of	IN
5180	807	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	807	22	should	should	MD
5180	807	23	have	have	VB
5180	807	24	been	be	VBN
5180	807	25	blocked	block	VBN
5180	807	26	under	under	IN
5180	807	27	the	the	DT
5180	807	28	software	software	NN
5180	807	29	's	's	POS
5180	807	30	category	category	NN
5180	807	31	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	807	32	,	,	,
5180	807	33	yielding	yield	VBG
5180	807	34	an	an	DT
5180	807	35	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	807	36	rate	rate	NN
5180	807	37	of	of	IN
5180	807	38	0.6	0.6	CD
5180	807	39	%	%	NN
5180	807	40	.	.	.
5180	808	1	Given	give	VBN
5180	808	2	the	the	DT
5180	808	3	size	size	NN
5180	808	4	of	of	IN
5180	808	5	the	the	DT
5180	808	6	sample	sample	NN
5180	808	7	,	,	,
5180	808	8	the	the	DT
5180	808	9	95	95	CD
5180	808	10	%	%	NN
5180	808	11	confidence	confidence	NN
5180	808	12	interval	interval	NN
5180	808	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	808	14	0	0	CD
5180	808	15	%	%	NN
5180	808	16	to	to	TO
5180	808	17	1.86	1.86	CD
5180	808	18	%	%	NN
5180	808	19	.	.	.
5180	809	1	The	the	DT
5180	809	2	study	study	NN
5180	809	3	examined	examine	VBD
5180	809	4	a	a	DT
5180	809	5	sample	sample	NN
5180	809	6	of	of	IN
5180	809	7	254	254	CD
5180	809	8	Web	web	NN
5180	809	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	809	10	accessed	access	VBN
5180	809	11	by	by	IN
5180	809	12	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	809	13	in	in	IN
5180	809	14	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	809	15	and	and	CC
5180	809	16	found	find	VBD
5180	809	17	that	that	IN
5180	809	18	three	three	CD
5180	809	19	of	of	IN
5180	809	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	809	21	should	should	MD
5180	809	22	have	have	VB
5180	809	23	been	be	VBN
5180	809	24	blocked	block	VBN
5180	809	25	under	under	IN
5180	809	26	the	the	DT
5180	809	27	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	809	28	software	software	NN
5180	809	29	's	's	POS
5180	809	30	category	category	NN
5180	809	31	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	809	32	.	.	.
5180	810	1	This	this	DT
5180	810	2	results	result	VBZ
5180	810	3	in	in	IN
5180	810	4	an	an	DT
5180	810	5	estimated	estimate	VBN
5180	810	6	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	810	7	rate	rate	NN
5180	810	8	of	of	IN
5180	810	9	1.2	1.2	CD
5180	810	10	%	%	NN
5180	810	11	with	with	IN
5180	810	12	a	a	DT
5180	810	13	95	95	CD
5180	810	14	%	%	NN
5180	810	15	confidence	confidence	NN
5180	810	16	interval	interval	NN
5180	810	17	ranging	range	VBG
5180	810	18	from	from	IN
5180	810	19	0	0	CD
5180	810	20	%	%	NN
5180	810	21	to	to	TO
5180	810	22	2.51	2.51	CD
5180	810	23	%	%	NN
5180	810	24	.	.	.
5180	811	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	811	2	do	do	VBP
5180	811	3	not	not	RB
5180	811	4	credit	credit	VB
5180	811	5	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	811	6	's	's	POS
5180	811	7	estimates	estimate	NNS
5180	811	8	of	of	IN
5180	811	9	the	the	DT
5180	811	10	rates	rate	NNS
5180	811	11	of	of	IN
5180	811	12	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	811	13	in	in	IN
5180	811	14	the	the	DT
5180	811	15	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	811	16	and	and	CC
5180	811	17	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	811	18	public	public	JJ
5180	811	19	libraries	library	NNS
5180	811	20	for	for	IN
5180	811	21	several	several	JJ
5180	811	22	reasons	reason	NNS
5180	811	23	.	.	.
5180	812	1	First	first	RB
5180	812	2	,	,	,
5180	812	3	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	812	4	's	's	POS
5180	812	5	estimates	estimate	NNS
5180	812	6	likely	likely	RB
5180	812	7	understate	understate	VBP
5180	812	8	the	the	DT
5180	812	9	actual	actual	JJ
5180	812	10	rate	rate	NN
5180	812	11	of	of	IN
5180	812	12	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	812	13	because	because	IN
5180	812	14	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	812	15	,	,	,
5180	812	16	who	who	WP
5180	812	17	knew	know	VBD
5180	812	18	that	that	IN
5180	812	19	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	812	20	programs	program	NNS
5180	812	21	were	be	VBD
5180	812	22	operating	operate	VBG
5180	812	23	in	in	IN
5180	812	24	the	the	DT
5180	812	25	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	812	26	and	and	CC
5180	812	27	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	812	28	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	812	29	,	,	,
5180	812	30	may	may	MD
5180	812	31	have	have	VB
5180	812	32	refrained	refrain	VBN
5180	812	33	from	from	IN
5180	812	34	attempting	attempt	VBG
5180	812	35	to	to	TO
5180	812	36	access	access	VB
5180	812	37	sites	site	NNS
5180	812	38	with	with	IN
5180	812	39	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	812	40	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	812	41	materials	material	NNS
5180	812	42	,	,	,
5180	812	43	or	or	CC
5180	812	44	other	other	JJ
5180	812	45	contents	content	NNS
5180	812	46	that	that	IN
5180	812	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	812	48	knew	know	VBD
5180	812	49	would	would	MD
5180	812	50	probably	probably	RB
5180	812	51	meet	meet	VB
5180	812	52	a	a	DT
5180	812	53	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	812	54	program	program	NN
5180	812	55	's	's	POS
5180	812	56	blocked	block	VBN
5180	812	57	categories	category	NNS
5180	812	58	.	.	.
5180	813	1	Second	second	JJ
5180	813	2	,	,	,
5180	813	3	and	and	CC
5180	813	4	most	most	RBS
5180	813	5	importantly	importantly	RB
5180	813	6	,	,	,
5180	813	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	813	8	think	think	VBP
5180	813	9	that	that	IN
5180	813	10	the	the	DT
5180	813	11	formula	formula	NN
5180	813	12	that	that	WDT
5180	813	13	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	813	14	used	use	VBD
5180	813	15	to	to	TO
5180	813	16	calculate	calculate	VB
5180	813	17	the	the	DT
5180	813	18	rate	rate	NN
5180	813	19	of	of	IN
5180	813	20	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	813	21	in	in	IN
5180	813	22	these	these	DT
5180	813	23	two	two	CD
5180	813	24	libraries	library	NNS
5180	813	25	is	be	VBZ
5180	813	26	not	not	RB
5180	813	27	as	as	RB
5180	813	28	meaningful	meaningful	JJ
5180	813	29	as	as	IN
5180	813	30	the	the	DT
5180	813	31	formula	formula	NN
5180	813	32	that	that	WDT
5180	813	33	information	information	NN
5180	813	34	scientists	scientist	NNS
5180	813	35	typically	typically	RB
5180	813	36	use	use	VBP
5180	813	37	to	to	TO
5180	813	38	calculate	calculate	VB
5180	813	39	a	a	DT
5180	813	40	rate	rate	NN
5180	813	41	of	of	IN
5180	813	42	recall	recall	NN
5180	813	43	,	,	,
5180	813	44	which	which	WDT
5180	813	45	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	813	46	describe	describe	VBP
5180	813	47	above	above	RB
5180	813	48	in	in	IN
5180	813	49	Subsection	Subsection	NNP
5180	813	50	II.E.3	II.E.3	NNP
5180	813	51	.	.	.
5180	814	1	As	as	IN
5180	814	2	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
5180	814	3	Nunberg	Nunberg	NNP
5180	814	4	explained	explain	VBD
5180	814	5	,	,	,
5180	814	6	the	the	DT
5180	814	7	standard	standard	JJ
5180	814	8	method	method	NN
5180	814	9	that	that	IN
5180	814	10	information	information	NN
5180	814	11	scientists	scientist	NNS
5180	814	12	use	use	VBP
5180	814	13	to	to	TO
5180	814	14	calculate	calculate	VB
5180	814	15	a	a	DT
5180	814	16	rate	rate	NN
5180	814	17	of	of	IN
5180	814	18	recall	recall	NN
5180	814	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	814	20	to	to	TO
5180	814	21	sort	sort	VB
5180	814	22	a	a	DT
5180	814	23	set	set	NN
5180	814	24	of	of	IN
5180	814	25	items	item	NNS
5180	814	26	into	into	IN
5180	814	27	two	two	CD
5180	814	28	groups	group	NNS
5180	814	29	,	,	,
5180	814	30	those	those	DT
5180	814	31	that	that	WDT
5180	814	32	fall	fall	VBP
5180	814	33	into	into	IN
5180	814	34	a	a	DT
5180	814	35	particular	particular	JJ
5180	814	36	category	category	NN
5180	814	37	(	(	-LRB-
5180	814	38	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	814	39	,	,	,
5180	814	40	those	those	DT
5180	814	41	that	that	WDT
5180	814	42	should	should	MD
5180	814	43	have	have	VB
5180	814	44	been	be	VBN
5180	814	45	blocked	block	VBN
5180	814	46	by	by	IN
5180	814	47	a	a	DT
5180	814	48	filter	filter	NN
5180	814	49	)	)	-RRB-
5180	814	50	and	and	CC
5180	814	51	those	those	DT
5180	814	52	that	that	WDT
5180	814	53	do	do	VBP
5180	814	54	not	not	RB
5180	814	55	.	.	.
5180	815	1	The	the	DT
5180	815	2	rate	rate	NN
5180	815	3	of	of	IN
5180	815	4	recall	recall	NN
5180	815	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	815	6	then	then	RB
5180	815	7	calculated	calculate	VBN
5180	815	8	by	by	IN
5180	815	9	dividing	divide	VBG
5180	815	10	the	the	DT
5180	815	11	number	number	NN
5180	815	12	of	of	IN
5180	815	13	items	item	NNS
5180	815	14	that	that	WDT
5180	815	15	the	the	DT
5180	815	16	system	system	NN
5180	815	17	correctly	correctly	RB
5180	815	18	identified	identify	VBD
5180	815	19	as	as	IN
5180	815	20	belonging	belong	VBG
5180	815	21	to	to	IN
5180	815	22	the	the	DT
5180	815	23	category	category	NN
5180	815	24	by	by	IN
5180	815	25	the	the	DT
5180	815	26	total	total	JJ
5180	815	27	number	number	NN
5180	815	28	of	of	IN
5180	815	29	items	item	NNS
5180	815	30	in	in	IN
5180	815	31	the	the	DT
5180	815	32	category	category	NN
5180	815	33	.	.	.
5180	816	1	In	in	IN
5180	816	2	the	the	DT
5180	816	3	example	example	NN
5180	816	4	above	above	RB
5180	816	5	,	,	,
5180	816	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	816	7	discussed	discuss	VBD
5180	816	8	a	a	DT
5180	816	9	database	database	NN
5180	816	10	that	that	WDT
5180	816	11	contained	contain	VBD
5180	816	12	1000	1000	CD
5180	816	13	photographs	photograph	NNS
5180	816	14	.	.	.
5180	817	1	Assume	assume	VB
5180	817	2	that	that	IN
5180	817	3	200	200	CD
5180	817	4	of	of	IN
5180	817	5	these	these	DT
5180	817	6	photographs	photograph	NNS
5180	817	7	were	be	VBD
5180	817	8	pictures	picture	NNS
5180	817	9	of	of	IN
5180	817	10	dogs	dog	NNS
5180	817	11	.	.	.
5180	818	1	If	if	IN
5180	818	2	,	,	,
5180	818	3	for	for	IN
5180	818	4	example	example	NN
5180	818	5	,	,	,
5180	818	6	a	a	DT
5180	818	7	classification	classification	NN
5180	818	8	system	system	NN
5180	818	9	designed	design	VBN
5180	818	10	to	to	TO
5180	818	11	identify	identify	VB
5180	818	12	pictures	picture	NNS
5180	818	13	of	of	IN
5180	818	14	dogs	dog	NNS
5180	818	15	identified	identify	VBD
5180	818	16	80	80	CD
5180	818	17	of	of	IN
5180	818	18	the	the	DT
5180	818	19	dog	dog	NN
5180	818	20	pictures	picture	NNS
5180	818	21	and	and	CC
5180	818	22	failed	fail	VBD
5180	818	23	to	to	TO
5180	818	24	identify	identify	VB
5180	818	25	120	120	CD
5180	818	26	,	,	,
5180	818	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	818	28	would	would	MD
5180	818	29	have	have	VB
5180	818	30	performed	perform	VBN
5180	818	31	with	with	IN
5180	818	32	a	a	DT
5180	818	33	recall	recall	NN
5180	818	34	rate	rate	NN
5180	818	35	of	of	IN
5180	818	36	40	40	CD
5180	818	37	%	%	NN
5180	818	38	.	.	.
5180	819	1	This	this	DT
5180	819	2	would	would	MD
5180	819	3	be	be	VB
5180	819	4	analogous	analogous	JJ
5180	819	5	to	to	IN
5180	819	6	a	a	DT
5180	819	7	filter	filter	NN
5180	819	8	that	that	WDT
5180	819	9	underblocked	underblocke	VBD
5180	819	10	at	at	IN
5180	819	11	a	a	DT
5180	819	12	rate	rate	NN
5180	819	13	of	of	IN
5180	819	14	60	60	CD
5180	819	15	%	%	NN
5180	819	16	.	.	.
5180	820	1	To	to	TO
5180	820	2	calculate	calculate	VB
5180	820	3	the	the	DT
5180	820	4	recall	recall	NN
5180	820	5	rate	rate	NN
5180	820	6	of	of	IN
5180	820	7	the	the	DT
5180	820	8	filters	filter	NNS
5180	820	9	in	in	IN
5180	820	10	the	the	DT
5180	820	11	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	820	12	and	and	CC
5180	820	13	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	820	14	public	public	JJ
5180	820	15	libraries	library	NNS
5180	820	16	in	in	IN
5180	820	17	accordance	accordance	NN
5180	820	18	with	with	IN
5180	820	19	the	the	DT
5180	820	20	standard	standard	JJ
5180	820	21	method	method	NN
5180	820	22	described	describe	VBN
5180	820	23	above	above	RB
5180	820	24	,	,	,
5180	820	25	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	820	26	should	should	MD
5180	820	27	have	have	VB
5180	820	28	taken	take	VBN
5180	820	29	a	a	DT
5180	820	30	sample	sample	NN
5180	820	31	of	of	IN
5180	820	32	sites	site	NNS
5180	820	33	from	from	IN
5180	820	34	the	the	DT
5180	820	35	libraries	library	NNS
5180	820	36	'	'	POS
5180	820	37	Internet	internet	NN
5180	820	38	use	use	NN
5180	820	39	logs	log	NNS
5180	820	40	(	(	-LRB-
5180	820	41	including	include	VBG
5180	820	42	both	both	DT
5180	820	43	sites	site	NNS
5180	820	44	that	that	WDT
5180	820	45	were	be	VBD
5180	820	46	blocked	block	VBN
5180	820	47	and	and	CC
5180	820	48	sites	site	NNS
5180	820	49	that	that	WDT
5180	820	50	were	be	VBD
5180	820	51	not	not	RB
5180	820	52	)	)	-RRB-
5180	820	53	,	,	,
5180	820	54	and	and	CC
5180	820	55	divided	divide	VBD
5180	820	56	the	the	DT
5180	820	57	number	number	NN
5180	820	58	of	of	IN
5180	820	59	sites	site	NNS
5180	820	60	in	in	IN
5180	820	61	the	the	DT
5180	820	62	sample	sample	NN
5180	820	63	that	that	WDT
5180	820	64	the	the	DT
5180	820	65	filter	filter	NN
5180	820	66	incorrectly	incorrectly	RB
5180	820	67	failed	fail	VBD
5180	820	68	to	to	TO
5180	820	69	block	block	VB
5180	820	70	by	by	IN
5180	820	71	the	the	DT
5180	820	72	total	total	JJ
5180	820	73	number	number	NN
5180	820	74	of	of	IN
5180	820	75	sites	site	NNS
5180	820	76	in	in	IN
5180	820	77	the	the	DT
5180	820	78	sample	sample	NN
5180	820	79	that	that	WDT
5180	820	80	should	should	MD
5180	820	81	have	have	VB
5180	820	82	been	be	VBN
5180	820	83	blocked	block	VBN
5180	820	84	.	.	.
5180	821	1	What	what	WP
5180	821	2	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	821	3	did	do	VBD
5180	821	4	instead	instead	RB
5180	821	5	was	be	VBD
5180	821	6	to	to	TO
5180	821	7	take	take	VB
5180	821	8	a	a	DT
5180	821	9	sample	sample	NN
5180	821	10	of	of	IN
5180	821	11	sites	site	NNS
5180	821	12	that	that	WDT
5180	821	13	were	be	VBD
5180	821	14	not	not	RB
5180	821	15	blocked	block	VBN
5180	821	16	,	,	,
5180	821	17	and	and	CC
5180	821	18	divide	divide	VB
5180	821	19	the	the	DT
5180	821	20	total	total	JJ
5180	821	21	number	number	NN
5180	821	22	of	of	IN
5180	821	23	sites	site	NNS
5180	821	24	in	in	IN
5180	821	25	this	this	DT
5180	821	26	sample	sample	NN
5180	821	27	by	by	IN
5180	821	28	the	the	DT
5180	821	29	number	number	NN
5180	821	30	of	of	IN
5180	821	31	sites	site	NNS
5180	821	32	in	in	IN
5180	821	33	the	the	DT
5180	821	34	sample	sample	NN
5180	821	35	that	that	WDT
5180	821	36	should	should	MD
5180	821	37	have	have	VB
5180	821	38	been	be	VBN
5180	821	39	blocked	block	VBN
5180	821	40	.	.	.
5180	822	1	This	this	DT
5180	822	2	made	make	VBD
5180	822	3	the	the	DT
5180	822	4	denominator	denominator	NN
5180	822	5	that	that	WDT
5180	822	6	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	822	7	used	use	VBD
5180	822	8	much	much	RB
5180	822	9	larger	large	JJR
5180	822	10	than	than	IN
5180	822	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	822	12	would	would	MD
5180	822	13	have	have	VB
5180	822	14	been	be	VBN
5180	822	15	had	have	VBN
5180	822	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	822	17	used	use	VBN
5180	822	18	the	the	DT
5180	822	19	standard	standard	JJ
5180	822	20	method	method	NN
5180	822	21	for	for	IN
5180	822	22	calculating	calculate	VBG
5180	822	23	recall	recall	NN
5180	822	24	,	,	,
5180	822	25	consequently	consequently	RB
5180	822	26	making	make	VBG
5180	822	27	the	the	DT
5180	822	28	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	822	29	rate	rate	NN
5180	822	30	that	that	WDT
5180	822	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	822	32	calculated	calculate	VBD
5180	822	33	much	much	RB
5180	822	34	lower	low	JJR
5180	822	35	than	than	IN
5180	822	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	822	37	would	would	MD
5180	822	38	have	have	VB
5180	822	39	been	be	VBN
5180	822	40	under	under	IN
5180	822	41	the	the	DT
5180	822	42	standard	standard	JJ
5180	822	43	method	method	NN
5180	822	44	.	.	.
5180	823	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	823	2	,	,	,
5180	823	3	despite	despite	IN
5180	823	4	the	the	DT
5180	823	5	relatively	relatively	RB
5180	823	6	low	low	JJ
5180	823	7	rates	rate	NNS
5180	823	8	of	of	IN
5180	823	9	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	823	10	that	that	IN
5180	823	11	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	823	12	's	's	POS
5180	823	13	study	study	NN
5180	823	14	found	find	VBD
5180	823	15	,	,	,
5180	823	16	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	823	17	from	from	IN
5180	823	18	several	several	JJ
5180	823	19	of	of	IN
5180	823	20	the	the	DT
5180	823	21	libraries	library	NNS
5180	823	22	proffered	proffer	VBN
5180	823	23	by	by	IN
5180	823	24	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	823	25	that	that	WDT
5180	823	26	use	use	VBP
5180	823	27	blocking	blocking	NN
5180	823	28	products	product	NNS
5180	823	29	,	,	,
5180	823	30	including	include	VBG
5180	823	31	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	823	32	,	,	,
5180	823	33	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	823	34	,	,	,
5180	823	35	and	and	CC
5180	823	36	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	823	37	,	,	,
5180	823	38	testified	testify	VBD
5180	823	39	that	that	IN
5180	823	40	there	there	EX
5180	823	41	are	be	VBP
5180	823	42	instances	instance	NNS
5180	823	43	of	of	IN
5180	823	44	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	823	45	in	in	IN
5180	823	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	823	47	libraries	library	NNS
5180	823	48	.	.	.
5180	824	1	No	no	DT
5180	824	2	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
5180	824	3	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	824	4	was	be	VBD
5180	824	5	presented	present	VBN
5180	824	6	comparing	compare	VBG
5180	824	7	the	the	DT
5180	824	8	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
5180	824	9	of	of	IN
5180	824	10	filters	filter	NNS
5180	824	11	and	and	CC
5180	824	12	other	other	JJ
5180	824	13	alternative	alternative	JJ
5180	824	14	methods	method	NNS
5180	824	15	used	use	VBN
5180	824	16	by	by	IN
5180	824	17	libraries	library	NNS
5180	824	18	to	to	TO
5180	824	19	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	824	20	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	824	21	from	from	IN
5180	824	22	accessing	access	VBG
5180	824	23	visual	visual	JJ
5180	824	24	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	824	25	that	that	WDT
5180	824	26	are	be	VBP
5180	824	27	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	824	28	,	,	,
5180	824	29	child	child	NN
5180	824	30	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	824	31	,	,	,
5180	824	32	or	or	CC
5180	824	33	in	in	IN
5180	824	34	the	the	DT
5180	824	35	case	case	NN
5180	824	36	of	of	IN
5180	824	37	minors	minor	NNS
5180	824	38	,	,	,
5180	824	39	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	824	40	to	to	IN
5180	824	41	minors	minor	NNS
5180	824	42	.	.	.
5180	825	1	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	825	2	undertook	undertake	VBD
5180	825	3	a	a	DT
5180	825	4	similar	similar	JJ
5180	825	5	study	study	NN
5180	825	6	of	of	IN
5180	825	7	the	the	DT
5180	825	8	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	825	9	rates	rate	NNS
5180	825	10	that	that	WDT
5180	825	11	result	result	VBP
5180	825	12	from	from	IN
5180	825	13	the	the	DT
5180	825	14	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	825	15	Library	Library	NNP
5180	825	16	's	's	POS
5180	825	17	use	use	NN
5180	825	18	of	of	IN
5180	825	19	the	the	DT
5180	825	20	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	825	21	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	825	22	software	software	NN
5180	825	23	.	.	.
5180	826	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	826	2	began	begin	VBD
5180	826	3	with	with	IN
5180	826	4	the	the	DT
5180	826	5	3,733	3,733	CD
5180	826	6	individual	individual	JJ
5180	826	7	blocks	block	NNS
5180	826	8	that	that	WDT
5180	826	9	occurred	occur	VBD
5180	826	10	in	in	IN
5180	826	11	the	the	DT
5180	826	12	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	826	13	Library	Library	NNP
5180	826	14	in	in	IN
5180	826	15	October	October	NNP
5180	826	16	2000	2000	CD
5180	826	17	and	and	CC
5180	826	18	drew	draw	VBD
5180	826	19	from	from	IN
5180	826	20	this	this	DT
5180	826	21	data	data	NN
5180	826	22	set	set	VBD
5180	826	23	a	a	DT
5180	826	24	random	random	JJ
5180	826	25	sample	sample	NN
5180	826	26	of	of	IN
5180	826	27	786	786	CD
5180	826	28	URLs	url	NNS
5180	826	29	.	.	.
5180	827	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	827	2	calculated	calculate	VBD
5180	827	3	two	two	CD
5180	827	4	rates	rate	NNS
5180	827	5	of	of	IN
5180	827	6	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	827	7	,	,	,
5180	827	8	one	one	CD
5180	827	9	with	with	IN
5180	827	10	respect	respect	NN
5180	827	11	to	to	IN
5180	827	12	the	the	DT
5180	827	13	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	827	14	Library	Library	NNP
5180	827	15	's	's	POS
5180	827	16	policy	policy	NN
5180	827	17	on	on	IN
5180	827	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	827	19	use	use	NN
5180	827	20	–	–	:
5180	827	21	that	that	IN
5180	827	22	the	the	DT
5180	827	23	pictorial	pictorial	JJ
5180	827	24	content	content	NN
5180	827	25	of	of	IN
5180	827	26	the	the	DT
5180	827	27	site	site	NN
5180	827	28	may	may	MD
5180	827	29	not	not	RB
5180	827	30	include	include	VB
5180	827	31	"	"	``
5180	827	32	graphic	graphic	JJ
5180	827	33	materials	material	NNS
5180	827	34	depicting	depict	VBG
5180	827	35	full	full	JJ
5180	827	36	nudity	nudity	NN
5180	827	37	and	and	CC
5180	827	38	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	827	39	acts	act	NNS
5180	827	40	which	which	WDT
5180	827	41	are	be	VBP
5180	827	42	portrayed	portray	VBN
5180	827	43	obviously	obviously	RB
5180	827	44	and	and	CC
5180	827	45	exclusively	exclusively	RB
5180	827	46	for	for	IN
5180	827	47	sensational	sensational	JJ
5180	827	48	or	or	CC
5180	827	49	pornographic	pornographic	JJ
5180	827	50	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	827	51	"	"	''
5180	827	52	–	–	:
5180	827	53	and	and	CC
5180	827	54	the	the	DT
5180	827	55	other	other	JJ
5180	827	56	with	with	IN
5180	827	57	respect	respect	NN
5180	827	58	to	to	IN
5180	827	59	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	827	60	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	827	61	's	's	POS
5180	827	62	own	own	JJ
5180	827	63	category	category	NN
5180	827	64	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	827	65	.	.	.
5180	828	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	828	2	estimated	estimate	VBD
5180	828	3	that	that	IN
5180	828	4	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	828	5	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	828	6	overblocked	overblocke	VBD
5180	828	7	4	4	CD
5180	828	8	%	%	NN
5180	828	9	of	of	IN
5180	828	10	all	all	DT
5180	828	11	Web	web	NN
5180	828	12	pages	page	NNS
5180	828	13	in	in	IN
5180	828	14	October	October	NNP
5180	828	15	2000	2000	CD
5180	828	16	with	with	IN
5180	828	17	respect	respect	NN
5180	828	18	to	to	IN
5180	828	19	the	the	DT
5180	828	20	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	828	21	of	of	IN
5180	828	22	the	the	DT
5180	828	23	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	828	24	Library	Library	NNP
5180	828	25	's	's	POS
5180	828	26	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	828	27	Policy	Policy	NNP
5180	828	28	and	and	CC
5180	828	29	2	2	CD
5180	828	30	%	%	NN
5180	828	31	of	of	IN
5180	828	32	all	all	DT
5180	828	33	pages	page	NNS
5180	828	34	with	with	IN
5180	828	35	respect	respect	NN
5180	828	36	to	to	IN
5180	828	37	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	828	38	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	828	39	's	's	POS
5180	828	40	own	own	JJ
5180	828	41	category	category	NN
5180	828	42	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	828	43	.	.	.
5180	829	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	829	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	829	3	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	829	4	to	to	TO
5180	829	5	determine	determine	VB
5180	829	6	how	how	WRB
5180	829	7	reliable	reliable	JJ
5180	829	8	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	829	9	's	's	POS
5180	829	10	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
5180	829	11	are	be	VBP
5180	829	12	,	,	,
5180	829	13	because	because	IN
5180	829	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	829	15	did	do	VBD
5180	829	16	not	not	RB
5180	829	17	keep	keep	VB
5180	829	18	records	record	NNS
5180	829	19	of	of	IN
5180	829	20	the	the	DT
5180	829	21	raw	raw	JJ
5180	829	22	data	datum	NNS
5180	829	23	that	that	WDT
5180	829	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	829	25	used	use	VBD
5180	829	26	in	in	IN
5180	829	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	829	28	study	study	NN
5180	829	29	;	;	:
5180	829	30	nor	nor	CC
5180	829	31	did	do	VBD
5180	829	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	829	33	archive	archive	JJ
5180	829	34	images	image	NNS
5180	829	35	of	of	IN
5180	829	36	the	the	DT
5180	829	37	Web	web	NN
5180	829	38	pages	page	NNS
5180	829	39	as	as	IN
5180	829	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	829	41	looked	look	VBD
5180	829	42	when	when	WRB
5180	829	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	829	44	made	make	VBD
5180	829	45	the	the	DT
5180	829	46	determination	determination	NN
5180	829	47	whether	whether	IN
5180	829	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	829	49	were	be	VBD
5180	829	50	properly	properly	RB
5180	829	51	classified	classify	VBN
5180	829	52	by	by	IN
5180	829	53	the	the	DT
5180	829	54	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	829	55	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	829	56	program	program	NN
5180	829	57	.	.	.
5180	830	1	Without	without	IN
5180	830	2	this	this	DT
5180	830	3	information	information	NN
5180	830	4	,	,	,
5180	830	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	830	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	830	7	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	830	8	to	to	TO
5180	830	9	verify	verify	VB
5180	830	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	830	11	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
5180	830	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	830	13	or	or	CC
5180	830	14	to	to	TO
5180	830	15	undermine	undermine	VB
5180	830	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	830	17	)	)	-RRB-
5180	830	18	.	.	.
5180	831	1	And	and	CC
5180	831	2	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	831	3	's	's	POS
5180	831	4	study	study	NN
5180	831	5	certainly	certainly	RB
5180	831	6	understates	understate	VBZ
5180	831	7	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	831	8	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	831	9	's	's	POS
5180	831	10	overblocking	overblocking	NN
5180	831	11	rate	rate	NN
5180	831	12	for	for	IN
5180	831	13	some	some	DT
5180	831	14	of	of	IN
5180	831	15	the	the	DT
5180	831	16	same	same	JJ
5180	831	17	reasons	reason	NNS
5180	831	18	that	that	WDT
5180	831	19	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	831	20	's	's	POS
5180	831	21	study	study	NN
5180	831	22	likely	likely	RB
5180	831	23	understates	understate	VBZ
5180	831	24	the	the	DT
5180	831	25	true	true	JJ
5180	831	26	rates	rate	NNS
5180	831	27	of	of	IN
5180	831	28	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	831	29	used	use	VBN
5180	831	30	in	in	IN
5180	831	31	the	the	DT
5180	831	32	libraries	library	NNS
5180	831	33	that	that	WDT
5180	831	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	831	35	studied	study	VBD
5180	831	36	.	.	.
5180	832	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	832	2	also	also	RB
5180	832	3	note	note	VBP
5180	832	4	that	that	IN
5180	832	5	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	832	6	's	's	POS
5180	832	7	study	study	NN
5180	832	8	,	,	,
5180	832	9	which	which	WDT
5180	832	10	analyzed	analyze	VBD
5180	832	11	a	a	DT
5180	832	12	set	set	NN
5180	832	13	of	of	IN
5180	832	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	832	15	logs	log	VBZ
5180	832	16	from	from	IN
5180	832	17	the	the	DT
5180	832	18	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	832	19	Library	Library	NNP
5180	832	20	during	during	IN
5180	832	21	which	which	WDT
5180	832	22	the	the	DT
5180	832	23	same	same	JJ
5180	832	24	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	832	25	program	program	NN
5180	832	26	was	be	VBD
5180	832	27	operating	operate	VBG
5180	832	28	with	with	IN
5180	832	29	the	the	DT
5180	832	30	same	same	JJ
5180	832	31	set	set	NN
5180	832	32	of	of	IN
5180	832	33	blocking	block	VBG
5180	832	34	categories	category	NNS
5180	832	35	enabled	enable	VBD
5180	832	36	,	,	,
5180	832	37	found	find	VBD
5180	832	38	a	a	DT
5180	832	39	significantly	significantly	RB
5180	832	40	higher	high	JJR
5180	832	41	rate	rate	NN
5180	832	42	of	of	IN
5180	832	43	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	832	44	than	than	IN
5180	832	45	the	the	DT
5180	832	46	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	832	47	study	study	NN
5180	832	48	did	do	VBD
5180	832	49	.	.	.
5180	833	1	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	833	2	found	find	VBD
5180	833	3	a	a	DT
5180	833	4	rate	rate	NN
5180	833	5	of	of	IN
5180	833	6	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	833	7	of	of	IN
5180	833	8	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	833	9	2	2	CD
5180	833	10	%	%	NN
5180	833	11	while	while	IN
5180	833	12	the	the	DT
5180	833	13	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	833	14	study	study	NN
5180	833	15	estimated	estimate	VBD
5180	833	16	a	a	DT
5180	833	17	6.34	6.34	CD
5180	833	18	%	%	NN
5180	833	19	rate	rate	NN
5180	833	20	of	of	IN
5180	833	21	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	833	22	.	.	.
5180	834	1	At	at	IN
5180	834	2	all	all	DT
5180	834	3	events	event	NNS
5180	834	4	,	,	,
5180	834	5	the	the	DT
5180	834	6	category	category	NN
5180	834	7	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	834	8	employed	employ	VBN
5180	834	9	by	by	IN
5180	834	10	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	834	11	,	,	,
5180	834	12	at	at	IN
5180	834	13	least	least	JJS
5180	834	14	with	with	IN
5180	834	15	respect	respect	NN
5180	834	16	to	to	TO
5180	834	17	adult	adult	VB
5180	834	18	use	use	NN
5180	834	19	–	–	:
5180	834	20	visual	visual	JJ
5180	834	21	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	834	22	that	that	WDT
5180	834	23	are	be	VBP
5180	834	24	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	834	25	or	or	CC
5180	834	26	child	child	NN
5180	834	27	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	834	28	–	–	:
5180	834	29	are	be	VBP
5180	834	30	narrower	narrow	JJR
5180	834	31	than	than	IN
5180	834	32	the	the	DT
5180	834	33	materials	material	NNS
5180	834	34	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
5180	834	35	by	by	IN
5180	834	36	the	the	DT
5180	834	37	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	834	38	Library	Library	NNP
5180	834	39	policy	policy	NN
5180	834	40	,	,	,
5180	834	41	and	and	CC
5180	834	42	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	834	43	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	834	44	's	's	POS
5180	834	45	study	study	NN
5180	834	46	understates	understate	VBZ
5180	834	47	the	the	DT
5180	834	48	rate	rate	NN
5180	834	49	of	of	IN
5180	834	50	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	834	51	with	with	IN
5180	834	52	respect	respect	NN
5180	834	53	to	to	IN
5180	834	54	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	834	55	's	's	POS
5180	834	56	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	834	57	for	for	IN
5180	834	58	adults	adult	NNS
5180	834	59	.	.	.
5180	835	1	In	in	IN
5180	835	2	sum	sum	NN
5180	835	3	,	,	,
5180	835	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	835	5	think	think	VBP
5180	835	6	that	that	IN
5180	835	7	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	835	8	's	's	POS
5180	835	9	study	study	NN
5180	835	10	,	,	,
5180	835	11	while	while	IN
5180	835	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	835	13	do	do	VBP
5180	835	14	not	not	RB
5180	835	15	credit	credit	VB
5180	835	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	835	17	estimates	estimate	NNS
5180	835	18	of	of	IN
5180	835	19	underblocking	underblocking	NN
5180	835	20	,	,	,
5180	835	21	is	be	VBZ
5180	835	22	useful	useful	JJ
5180	835	23	because	because	IN
5180	835	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	835	25	states	state	VBZ
5180	835	26	lower	low	JJR
5180	835	27	bounds	bound	NNS
5180	835	28	with	with	IN
5180	835	29	respect	respect	NN
5180	835	30	to	to	IN
5180	835	31	the	the	DT
5180	835	32	rates	rate	NNS
5180	835	33	of	of	IN
5180	835	34	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	835	35	that	that	WDT
5180	835	36	occurred	occur	VBD
5180	835	37	when	when	WRB
5180	835	38	the	the	DT
5180	835	39	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	835	40	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	835	41	,	,	,
5180	835	42	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	835	43	,	,	,
5180	835	44	and	and	CC
5180	835	45	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	835	46	filters	filter	NNS
5180	835	47	were	be	VBD
5180	835	48	operating	operate	VBG
5180	835	49	in	in	IN
5180	835	50	public	public	JJ
5180	835	51	libraries	library	NNS
5180	835	52	.	.	.
5180	836	1	While	while	IN
5180	836	2	these	these	DT
5180	836	3	rates	rate	NNS
5180	836	4	are	be	VBP
5180	836	5	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	836	6	–	–	:
5180	836	7	between	between	IN
5180	836	8	nearly	nearly	RB
5180	836	9	6	6	CD
5180	836	10	%	%	NN
5180	836	11	and	and	CC
5180	836	12	15	15	CD
5180	836	13	%	%	NN
5180	836	14	–	–	:
5180	836	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	836	16	think	think	VBP
5180	836	17	,	,	,
5180	836	18	for	for	IN
5180	836	19	the	the	DT
5180	836	20	reasons	reason	NNS
5180	836	21	stated	state	VBN
5180	836	22	above	above	RB
5180	836	23	,	,	,
5180	836	24	that	that	IN
5180	836	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	836	26	greatly	greatly	RB
5180	836	27	understate	understate	VBP
5180	836	28	the	the	DT
5180	836	29	actual	actual	JJ
5180	836	30	rates	rate	NNS
5180	836	31	of	of	IN
5180	836	32	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	836	33	that	that	DT
5180	836	34	occurs	occur	VBZ
5180	836	35	,	,	,
5180	836	36	and	and	CC
5180	836	37	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	836	38	can	can	MD
5180	836	39	not	not	RB
5180	836	40	be	be	VB
5180	836	41	considered	consider	VBN
5180	836	42	as	as	IN
5180	836	43	anything	anything	NN
5180	836	44	more	more	JJR
5180	836	45	than	than	IN
5180	836	46	minimum	minimum	JJ
5180	836	47	estimates	estimate	NNS
5180	836	48	of	of	IN
5180	836	49	the	the	DT
5180	836	50	rates	rate	NNS
5180	836	51	of	of	IN
5180	836	52	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	836	53	that	that	WDT
5180	836	54	happens	happen	VBZ
5180	836	55	in	in	IN
5180	836	56	all	all	DT
5180	836	57	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	836	58	programs	program	NNS
5180	836	59	.	.	.
5180	837	1	5	5	CD
5180	837	2	.	.	.
5180	838	1	Methods	method	NNS
5180	838	2	of	of	IN
5180	838	3	Obtaining	obtain	VBG
5180	838	4	Examples	Examples	NNPS
5180	838	5	of	of	IN
5180	838	6	Erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	838	7	Blocked	block	VBN
5180	838	8	Web	web	NN
5180	838	9	Sites	site	NNS
5180	838	10	The	the	DT
5180	838	11	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	838	12	assembled	assemble	VBD
5180	838	13	a	a	DT
5180	838	14	list	list	NN
5180	838	15	of	of	IN
5180	838	16	several	several	JJ
5180	838	17	thousand	thousand	CD
5180	838	18	Web	web	NN
5180	838	19	sites	site	NNS
5180	838	20	that	that	IN
5180	838	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	838	22	contend	contend	VBP
5180	838	23	were	be	VBD
5180	838	24	,	,	,
5180	838	25	at	at	IN
5180	838	26	the	the	DT
5180	838	27	time	time	NN
5180	838	28	of	of	IN
5180	838	29	the	the	DT
5180	838	30	study	study	NN
5180	838	31	,	,	,
5180	838	32	likely	likely	JJ
5180	838	33	to	to	TO
5180	838	34	have	have	VB
5180	838	35	been	be	VBN
5180	838	36	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	838	37	blocked	block	VBN
5180	838	38	by	by	IN
5180	838	39	one	one	CD
5180	838	40	or	or	CC
5180	838	41	more	more	JJR
5180	838	42	of	of	IN
5180	838	43	four	four	CD
5180	838	44	major	major	JJ
5180	838	45	commercial	commercial	JJ
5180	838	46	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	838	47	programs	program	NNS
5180	838	48	:	:	:
5180	838	49	SurfControl	SurfControl	NNP
5180	838	50	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	838	51	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	838	52	6.0.1.47	6.0.1.47	CD
5180	838	53	,	,	,
5180	838	54	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	838	55	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	838	56	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	838	57	2.0	2.0	CD
5180	838	58	,	,	,
5180	838	59	Secure	Secure	NNP
5180	838	60	Computing	Computing	NNP
5180	838	61	SmartFilter	SmartFilter	NNP
5180	838	62	3.0.0.01	3.0.0.01	CD
5180	838	63	,	,	,
5180	838	64	and	and	CC
5180	838	65	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	838	66	Enterprise	Enterprise	NNP
5180	838	67	4.3.0	4.3.0	CD
5180	838	68	.	.	.
5180	839	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
5180	839	2	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	839	3	this	this	DT
5180	839	4	list	list	NN
5180	839	5	using	use	VBG
5180	839	6	a	a	DT
5180	839	7	two	two	CD
5180	839	8	-	-	HYPH
5180	839	9	step	step	NN
5180	839	10	process	process	NN
5180	839	11	.	.	.
5180	840	1	First	first	RB
5180	840	2	,	,	,
5180	840	3	Benjamin	Benjamin	NNP
5180	840	4	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	840	5	,	,	,
5180	840	6	an	an	DT
5180	840	7	expert	expert	JJ
5180	840	8	witness	witness	NN
5180	840	9	who	who	WP
5180	840	10	testified	testify	VBD
5180	840	11	before	before	IN
5180	840	12	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	840	13	,	,	,
5180	840	14	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	840	15	a	a	DT
5180	840	16	list	list	NN
5180	840	17	of	of	IN
5180	840	18	more	more	JJR
5180	840	19	than	than	IN
5180	840	20	500,000	500,000	CD
5180	840	21	URLs	url	NNS
5180	840	22	and	and	CC
5180	840	23	devised	devise	VBD
5180	840	24	a	a	DT
5180	840	25	program	program	NN
5180	840	26	to	to	TO
5180	840	27	feed	feed	VB
5180	840	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	840	29	through	through	IN
5180	840	30	all	all	DT
5180	840	31	four	four	CD
5180	840	32	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	840	33	programs	program	NNS
5180	840	34	in	in	IN
5180	840	35	order	order	NN
5180	840	36	to	to	TO
5180	840	37	compile	compile	VB
5180	840	38	a	a	DT
5180	840	39	list	list	NN
5180	840	40	of	of	IN
5180	840	41	URLs	url	NNS
5180	840	42	that	that	WDT
5180	840	43	might	may	MD
5180	840	44	have	have	VB
5180	840	45	been	be	VBN
5180	840	46	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	840	47	blocked	block	VBN
5180	840	48	by	by	IN
5180	840	49	one	one	CD
5180	840	50	or	or	CC
5180	840	51	more	more	JJR
5180	840	52	of	of	IN
5180	840	53	the	the	DT
5180	840	54	programs	program	NNS
5180	840	55	.	.	.
5180	841	1	Second	second	JJ
5180	841	2	,	,	,
5180	841	3	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	841	4	forwarded	forward	VBD
5180	841	5	subsets	subset	NNS
5180	841	6	of	of	IN
5180	841	7	the	the	DT
5180	841	8	list	list	NN
5180	841	9	that	that	WDT
5180	841	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	841	11	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	841	12	to	to	IN
5180	841	13	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	841	14	and	and	CC
5180	841	15	professors	professor	NNS
5180	841	16	of	of	IN
5180	841	17	library	library	NN
5180	841	18	science	science	NN
5180	841	19	whom	whom	WP
5180	841	20	the	the	DT
5180	841	21	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	841	22	had	have	VBD
5180	841	23	hired	hire	VBN
5180	841	24	to	to	TO
5180	841	25	review	review	VB
5180	841	26	the	the	DT
5180	841	27	blocked	block	VBN
5180	841	28	sites	site	NNS
5180	841	29	for	for	IN
5180	841	30	suitability	suitability	NN
5180	841	31	in	in	IN
5180	841	32	the	the	DT
5180	841	33	public	public	JJ
5180	841	34	library	library	NN
5180	841	35	context	context	NN
5180	841	36	.	.	.
5180	842	1	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	842	2	assembled	assemble	VBD
5180	842	3	the	the	DT
5180	842	4	list	list	NN
5180	842	5	of	of	IN
5180	842	6	URLs	url	NNS
5180	842	7	by	by	IN
5180	842	8	compiling	compile	VBG
5180	842	9	Web	web	NN
5180	842	10	pages	page	NNS
5180	842	11	that	that	WDT
5180	842	12	were	be	VBD
5180	842	13	blocked	block	VBN
5180	842	14	by	by	IN
5180	842	15	the	the	DT
5180	842	16	following	follow	VBG
5180	842	17	categories	category	NNS
5180	842	18	in	in	IN
5180	842	19	the	the	DT
5180	842	20	four	four	CD
5180	842	21	programs	program	NNS
5180	842	22	:	:	:
5180	842	23	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	842	24	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	842	25	:	:	:
5180	842	26	Adult	adult	NN
5180	842	27	/	/	SYM
5180	842	28	Sexually	sexually	RB
5180	842	29	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	842	30	;	;	:
5180	842	31	N2H2	n2h2	NN
5180	842	32	:	:	:
5180	842	33	Adults	Adults	NNP
5180	842	34	Only	only	RB
5180	842	35	,	,	,
5180	842	36	Nudity	Nudity	NNP
5180	842	37	,	,	,
5180	842	38	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	842	39	,	,	,
5180	842	40	and	and	CC
5180	842	41	Sex	sex	NN
5180	842	42	,	,	,
5180	842	43	with	with	IN
5180	842	44	"	"	``
5180	842	45	exceptions	exception	NNS
5180	842	46	"	"	''
5180	842	47	engaged	engage	VBN
5180	842	48	in	in	IN
5180	842	49	the	the	DT
5180	842	50	categories	category	NNS
5180	842	51	of	of	IN
5180	842	52	Education	Education	NNP
5180	842	53	,	,	,
5180	842	54	For	for	IN
5180	842	55	Kids	Kids	NNPS
5180	842	56	,	,	,
5180	842	57	History	history	NN
5180	842	58	,	,	,
5180	842	59	Medical	Medical	NNP
5180	842	60	,	,	,
5180	842	61	Moderated	Moderated	NNP
5180	842	62	,	,	,
5180	842	63	and	and	CC
5180	842	64	Text	Text	NNP
5180	842	65	/	/	SYM
5180	842	66	Spoken	Spoken	NNP
5180	842	67	Only	only	RB
5180	842	68	;	;	:
5180	842	69	SmartFilter	SmartFilter	NNP
5180	842	70	:	:	:
5180	842	71	Sex	sex	NN
5180	842	72	,	,	,
5180	842	73	Nudity	Nudity	NNP
5180	842	74	,	,	,
5180	842	75	Mature	Mature	NNP
5180	842	76	,	,	,
5180	842	77	and	and	CC
5180	842	78	Extreme	Extreme	NNP
5180	842	79	;	;	:
5180	842	80	Websense	websense	NN
5180	842	81	:	:	:
5180	842	82	Adult	Adult	NNP
5180	842	83	Content	Content	NNP
5180	842	84	,	,	,
5180	842	85	Nudity	nudity	NN
5180	842	86	,	,	,
5180	842	87	and	and	CC
5180	842	88	Sex	sex	NN
5180	842	89	.	.	.
5180	843	1	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	843	2	then	then	RB
5180	843	3	assembled	assemble	VBD
5180	843	4	a	a	DT
5180	843	5	database	database	NN
5180	843	6	of	of	IN
5180	843	7	Web	web	NN
5180	843	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	843	9	for	for	IN
5180	843	10	possible	possible	JJ
5180	843	11	testing	testing	NN
5180	843	12	.	.	.
5180	844	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	844	2	derived	derive	VBD
5180	844	3	this	this	DT
5180	844	4	list	list	NN
5180	844	5	by	by	IN
5180	844	6	automatically	automatically	RB
5180	844	7	compiling	compile	VBG
5180	844	8	URLs	url	NNS
5180	844	9	from	from	IN
5180	844	10	the	the	DT
5180	844	11	Yahoo	Yahoo	NNP
5180	844	12	index	index	NN
5180	844	13	of	of	IN
5180	844	14	Web	web	NN
5180	844	15	sites	site	NNS
5180	844	16	,	,	,
5180	844	17	taking	take	VBG
5180	844	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	844	19	from	from	IN
5180	844	20	categories	category	NNS
5180	844	21	from	from	IN
5180	844	22	the	the	DT
5180	844	23	Yahoo	Yahoo	NNP
5180	844	24	index	index	NN
5180	844	25	that	that	WDT
5180	844	26	differed	differ	VBD
5180	844	27	significantly	significantly	RB
5180	844	28	from	from	IN
5180	844	29	the	the	DT
5180	844	30	classifications	classification	NNS
5180	844	31	that	that	WDT
5180	844	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	844	33	had	have	VBD
5180	844	34	enabled	enable	VBN
5180	844	35	in	in	IN
5180	844	36	each	each	DT
5180	844	37	of	of	IN
5180	844	38	the	the	DT
5180	844	39	blocking	blocking	NN
5180	844	40	programs	program	NNS
5180	844	41	(	(	-LRB-
5180	844	42	taking	take	VBG
5180	844	43	,	,	,
5180	844	44	for	for	IN
5180	844	45	example	example	NN
5180	844	46	,	,	,
5180	844	47	Web	web	NN
5180	844	48	sites	site	NNS
5180	844	49	from	from	IN
5180	844	50	Yahoo	Yahoo	NNP
5180	844	51	's	's	POS
5180	844	52	"	"	``
5180	844	53	Government	Government	NNP
5180	844	54	"	"	''
5180	844	55	category	category	NN
5180	844	56	)	)	-RRB-
5180	844	57	.	.	.
5180	845	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	845	2	then	then	RB
5180	845	3	expanded	expand	VBD
5180	845	4	this	this	DT
5180	845	5	list	list	NN
5180	845	6	by	by	IN
5180	845	7	entering	enter	VBG
5180	845	8	URLs	URLs	NNPS
5180	845	9	taken	take	VBN
5180	845	10	from	from	IN
5180	845	11	the	the	DT
5180	845	12	Yahoo	Yahoo	NNP
5180	845	13	index	index	NN
5180	845	14	into	into	IN
5180	845	15	the	the	DT
5180	845	16	Google	Google	NNP
5180	845	17	search	search	NN
5180	845	18	engine	engine	NN
5180	845	19	's	's	POS
5180	845	20	"	"	``
5180	845	21	related	related	JJ
5180	845	22	"	"	''
5180	845	23	search	search	NN
5180	845	24	function	function	NN
5180	845	25	,	,	,
5180	845	26	which	which	WDT
5180	845	27	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	845	28	the	the	DT
5180	845	29	user	user	NN
5180	845	30	with	with	IN
5180	845	31	a	a	DT
5180	845	32	list	list	NN
5180	845	33	of	of	IN
5180	845	34	similar	similar	JJ
5180	845	35	sites	site	NNS
5180	845	36	.	.	.
5180	846	1	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	846	2	also	also	RB
5180	846	3	included	include	VBD
5180	846	4	and	and	CC
5180	846	5	excluded	exclude	VBN
5180	846	6	specific	specific	JJ
5180	846	7	Web	web	NN
5180	846	8	sites	site	NNS
5180	846	9	at	at	IN
5180	846	10	the	the	DT
5180	846	11	request	request	NN
5180	846	12	of	of	IN
5180	846	13	the	the	DT
5180	846	14	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	846	15	'	'	POS
5180	846	16	counsel	counsel	NN
5180	846	17	.	.	.
5180	847	1	Taking	take	VBG
5180	847	2	the	the	DT
5180	847	3	list	list	NN
5180	847	4	of	of	IN
5180	847	5	more	more	JJR
5180	847	6	than	than	IN
5180	847	7	500,000	500,000	CD
5180	847	8	URLs	url	NNS
5180	847	9	that	that	IN
5180	847	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	847	11	had	have	VBD
5180	847	12	compiled	compile	VBN
5180	847	13	,	,	,
5180	847	14	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	847	15	used	use	VBD
5180	847	16	an	an	DT
5180	847	17	automated	automated	JJ
5180	847	18	system	system	NN
5180	847	19	that	that	IN
5180	847	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	847	21	had	have	VBD
5180	847	22	developed	develop	VBN
5180	847	23	to	to	TO
5180	847	24	test	test	VB
5180	847	25	whether	whether	IN
5180	847	26	particular	particular	JJ
5180	847	27	URLs	url	NNS
5180	847	28	were	be	VBD
5180	847	29	blocked	block	VBN
5180	847	30	by	by	IN
5180	847	31	each	each	DT
5180	847	32	of	of	IN
5180	847	33	the	the	DT
5180	847	34	four	four	CD
5180	847	35	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	847	36	programs	program	NNS
5180	847	37	.	.	.
5180	848	1	This	this	DT
5180	848	2	testing	testing	NN
5180	848	3	took	take	VBD
5180	848	4	place	place	NN
5180	848	5	between	between	IN
5180	848	6	February	February	NNP
5180	848	7	and	and	CC
5180	848	8	October	October	NNP
5180	848	9	2001	2001	CD
5180	848	10	.	.	.
5180	849	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	849	2	recorded	record	VBD
5180	849	3	the	the	DT
5180	849	4	specific	specific	JJ
5180	849	5	dates	date	NNS
5180	849	6	on	on	IN
5180	849	7	which	which	WDT
5180	849	8	particular	particular	JJ
5180	849	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	849	10	were	be	VBD
5180	849	11	blocked	block	VBN
5180	849	12	by	by	IN
5180	849	13	particular	particular	JJ
5180	849	14	programs	program	NNS
5180	849	15	,	,	,
5180	849	16	and	and	CC
5180	849	17	,	,	,
5180	849	18	using	use	VBG
5180	849	19	commercial	commercial	JJ
5180	849	20	archiving	archive	VBG
5180	849	21	software	software	NN
5180	849	22	,	,	,
5180	849	23	archived	archive	VBD
5180	849	24	the	the	DT
5180	849	25	contents	content	NNS
5180	849	26	of	of	IN
5180	849	27	the	the	DT
5180	849	28	home	home	NN
5180	849	29	page	page	NN
5180	849	30	of	of	IN
5180	849	31	the	the	DT
5180	849	32	blocked	block	VBN
5180	849	33	Web	web	NN
5180	849	34	sites	site	NNS
5180	849	35	(	(	-LRB-
5180	849	36	and	and	CC
5180	849	37	in	in	IN
5180	849	38	some	some	DT
5180	849	39	instances	instance	NNS
5180	849	40	the	the	DT
5180	849	41	pages	page	NNS
5180	849	42	linked	link	VBN
5180	849	43	to	to	IN
5180	849	44	from	from	IN
5180	849	45	the	the	DT
5180	849	46	home	home	NN
5180	849	47	page	page	NN
5180	849	48	)	)	-RRB-
5180	849	49	as	as	IN
5180	849	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	849	51	existed	exist	VBD
5180	849	52	when	when	WRB
5180	849	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	849	54	was	be	VBD
5180	849	55	blocked	block	VBN
5180	849	56	.	.	.
5180	850	1	Through	through	IN
5180	850	2	this	this	DT
5180	850	3	process	process	NN
5180	850	4	,	,	,
5180	850	5	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	850	6	,	,	,
5180	850	7	whose	whose	WP$
5180	850	8	testimony	testimony	NN
5180	850	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	850	10	credit	credit	NN
5180	850	11	,	,	,
5180	850	12	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	850	13	a	a	DT
5180	850	14	list	list	NN
5180	850	15	of	of	IN
5180	850	16	6,777	6,777	CD
5180	850	17	URLs	url	NNS
5180	850	18	that	that	WDT
5180	850	19	were	be	VBD
5180	850	20	blocked	block	VBN
5180	850	21	by	by	IN
5180	850	22	one	one	CD
5180	850	23	or	or	CC
5180	850	24	more	more	JJR
5180	850	25	of	of	IN
5180	850	26	the	the	DT
5180	850	27	four	four	CD
5180	850	28	programs	program	NNS
5180	850	29	.	.	.
5180	851	1	Because	because	IN
5180	851	2	these	these	DT
5180	851	3	sites	site	NNS
5180	851	4	were	be	VBD
5180	851	5	chosen	choose	VBN
5180	851	6	from	from	IN
5180	851	7	categories	category	NNS
5180	851	8	from	from	IN
5180	851	9	the	the	DT
5180	851	10	Yahoo	Yahoo	NNP
5180	851	11	directory	directory	NN
5180	851	12	that	that	WDT
5180	851	13	were	be	VBD
5180	851	14	unrelated	unrelated	JJ
5180	851	15	to	to	IN
5180	851	16	the	the	DT
5180	851	17	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	851	18	categories	category	NNS
5180	851	19	that	that	WDT
5180	851	20	were	be	VBD
5180	851	21	enabled	enable	VBN
5180	851	22	during	during	IN
5180	851	23	the	the	DT
5180	851	24	test	test	NN
5180	851	25	(	(	-LRB-
5180	851	26	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	851	27	,	,	,
5180	851	28	"	"	``
5180	851	29	Government	government	NN
5180	851	30	"	"	''
5180	851	31	vs.	vs.	IN
5180	851	32	"	"	``
5180	851	33	Nudity	Nudity	NNP
5180	851	34	"	"	''
5180	851	35	)	)	-RRB-
5180	851	36	,	,	,
5180	851	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	851	38	reasoned	reason	VBD
5180	851	39	that	that	IN
5180	851	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	851	41	were	be	VBD
5180	851	42	likely	likely	RB
5180	851	43	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	851	44	blocked	block	VBN
5180	851	45	.	.	.
5180	852	1	As	as	IN
5180	852	2	explained	explain	VBN
5180	852	3	in	in	IN
5180	852	4	the	the	DT
5180	852	5	margin	margin	NN
5180	852	6	,	,	,
5180	852	7	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	852	8	repeated	repeat	VBD
5180	852	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	852	10	testing	testing	NN
5180	852	11	and	and	CC
5180	852	12	discovered	discover	VBD
5180	852	13	that	that	IN
5180	852	14	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	852	15	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	852	16	had	have	VBD
5180	852	17	unblocked	unblock	VBN
5180	852	18	most	most	JJS
5180	852	19	of	of	IN
5180	852	20	the	the	DT
5180	852	21	pages	page	NNS
5180	852	22	on	on	IN
5180	852	23	the	the	DT
5180	852	24	list	list	NN
5180	852	25	of	of	IN
5180	852	26	6,777	6,777	CD
5180	852	27	after	after	IN
5180	852	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	852	29	had	have	VBD
5180	852	30	published	publish	VBN
5180	852	31	the	the	DT
5180	852	32	list	list	NN
5180	852	33	on	on	IN
5180	852	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	852	35	Web	web	NN
5180	852	36	site	site	NN
5180	852	37	.	.	.
5180	853	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	853	2	records	record	NNS
5180	853	3	indicate	indicate	VBP
5180	853	4	that	that	IN
5180	853	5	an	an	DT
5180	853	6	employee	employee	NN
5180	853	7	of	of	IN
5180	853	8	SurfControl	SurfControl	NNP
5180	853	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	853	10	the	the	DT
5180	853	11	company	company	NN
5180	853	12	that	that	WDT
5180	853	13	produces	produce	VBZ
5180	853	14	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	853	15	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	853	16	software	software	NN
5180	853	17	)	)	-RRB-
5180	853	18	accessed	access	VBD
5180	853	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	853	20	site	site	NN
5180	853	21	and	and	CC
5180	853	22	presumably	presumably	RB
5180	853	23	checked	check	VBD
5180	853	24	out	out	RP
5180	853	25	the	the	DT
5180	853	26	URLs	url	NNS
5180	853	27	on	on	IN
5180	853	28	the	the	DT
5180	853	29	list	list	NN
5180	853	30	,	,	,
5180	853	31	thus	thus	RB
5180	853	32	confirming	confirm	VBG
5180	853	33	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	853	34	's	's	POS
5180	853	35	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	853	36	that	that	IN
5180	853	37	the	the	DT
5180	853	38	majority	majority	NN
5180	853	39	of	of	IN
5180	853	40	URLs	URLs	NNPS
5180	853	41	on	on	IN
5180	853	42	the	the	DT
5180	853	43	list	list	NN
5180	853	44	were	be	VBD
5180	853	45	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	853	46	blocked	block	VBN
5180	853	47	.	.	.
5180	854	1	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	854	2	forwarded	forward	VBD
5180	854	3	the	the	DT
5180	854	4	list	list	NN
5180	854	5	of	of	IN
5180	854	6	blocked	block	VBN
5180	854	7	sites	site	NNS
5180	854	8	to	to	IN
5180	854	9	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
5180	854	10	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
5180	854	11	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	854	12	,	,	,
5180	854	13	an	an	DT
5180	854	14	Assistant	Assistant	NNP
5180	854	15	Professor	Professor	NNP
5180	854	16	in	in	IN
5180	854	17	the	the	DT
5180	854	18	Information	Information	NNP
5180	854	19	School	School	NNP
5180	854	20	of	of	IN
5180	854	21	the	the	DT
5180	854	22	University	University	NNP
5180	854	23	of	of	IN
5180	854	24	Washington	Washington	NNP
5180	854	25	who	who	WP
5180	854	26	also	also	RB
5180	854	27	testified	testify	VBD
5180	854	28	at	at	IN
5180	854	29	trial	trial	NN
5180	854	30	as	as	IN
5180	854	31	an	an	DT
5180	854	32	expert	expert	JJ
5180	854	33	witness	witness	NN
5180	854	34	.	.	.
5180	855	1	Janes	jane	NNS
5180	855	2	reviewed	review	VBD
5180	855	3	the	the	DT
5180	855	4	sites	site	NNS
5180	855	5	that	that	WDT
5180	855	6	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	855	7	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	855	8	to	to	TO
5180	855	9	determine	determine	VB
5180	855	10	whether	whether	IN
5180	855	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	855	12	are	be	VBP
5180	855	13	consistent	consistent	JJ
5180	855	14	with	with	IN
5180	855	15	library	library	JJ
5180	855	16	collection	collection	NN
5180	855	17	development	development	NN
5180	855	18	,	,	,
5180	855	19	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	855	20	,	,	,
5180	855	21	whether	whether	IN
5180	855	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	855	23	are	be	VBP
5180	855	24	sites	site	NNS
5180	855	25	to	to	TO
5180	855	26	which	which	WDT
5180	855	27	a	a	DT
5180	855	28	reference	reference	NN
5180	855	29	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	855	30	would	would	MD
5180	855	31	,	,	,
5180	855	32	consistent	consistent	JJ
5180	855	33	with	with	IN
5180	855	34	professional	professional	JJ
5180	855	35	standards	standard	NNS
5180	855	36	,	,	,
5180	855	37	direct	direct	VB
5180	855	38	a	a	DT
5180	855	39	patron	patron	NN
5180	855	40	as	as	IN
5180	855	41	a	a	DT
5180	855	42	source	source	NN
5180	855	43	of	of	IN
5180	855	44	information	information	NN
5180	855	45	.	.	.
5180	856	1	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	856	2	forwarded	forward	VBD
5180	856	3	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	856	4	a	a	DT
5180	856	5	list	list	NN
5180	856	6	of	of	IN
5180	856	7	6,775	6,775	CD
5180	856	8	Web	web	NN
5180	856	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	856	10	,	,	,
5180	856	11	almost	almost	RB
5180	856	12	the	the	DT
5180	856	13	entire	entire	JJ
5180	856	14	list	list	NN
5180	856	15	of	of	IN
5180	856	16	blocked	block	VBN
5180	856	17	sites	site	NNS
5180	856	18	that	that	WDT
5180	856	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	856	20	collected	collect	VBD
5180	856	21	,	,	,
5180	856	22	from	from	IN
5180	856	23	which	which	WDT
5180	856	24	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	856	25	took	take	VBD
5180	856	26	a	a	DT
5180	856	27	random	random	JJ
5180	856	28	sample	sample	NN
5180	856	29	of	of	IN
5180	856	30	859	859	CD
5180	856	31	using	use	VBG
5180	856	32	the	the	DT
5180	856	33	SPSS	SPSS	NNP
5180	856	34	statistical	statistical	JJ
5180	856	35	software	software	NN
5180	856	36	package	package	NN
5180	856	37	.	.	.
5180	857	1	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	857	2	indicated	indicate	VBD
5180	857	3	that	that	IN
5180	857	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	857	5	chose	choose	VBD
5180	857	6	a	a	DT
5180	857	7	sample	sample	NN
5180	857	8	size	size	NN
5180	857	9	of	of	IN
5180	857	10	859	859	CD
5180	857	11	because	because	IN
5180	857	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	857	13	would	would	MD
5180	857	14	yield	yield	VB
5180	857	15	a	a	DT
5180	857	16	95	95	CD
5180	857	17	%	%	NN
5180	857	18	confidence	confidence	NN
5180	857	19	interval	interval	NN
5180	857	20	of	of	IN
5180	857	21	plus	plus	NN
5180	857	22	or	or	CC
5180	857	23	minus	minus	CC
5180	857	24	2.5	2.5	CD
5180	857	25	%	%	NN
5180	857	26	.	.	.
5180	858	1	Janes	jane	NNS
5180	858	2	recruited	recruit	VBD
5180	858	3	a	a	DT
5180	858	4	group	group	NN
5180	858	5	of	of	IN
5180	858	6	16	16	CD
5180	858	7	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	858	8	,	,	,
5180	858	9	most	most	JJS
5180	858	10	of	of	IN
5180	858	11	whom	whom	WP
5180	858	12	were	be	VBD
5180	858	13	current	current	JJ
5180	858	14	or	or	CC
5180	858	15	former	former	JJ
5180	858	16	students	student	NNS
5180	858	17	at	at	IN
5180	858	18	the	the	DT
5180	858	19	University	University	NNP
5180	858	20	of	of	IN
5180	858	21	Washington	Washington	NNP
5180	858	22	's	's	POS
5180	858	23	Information	Information	NNP
5180	858	24	School	School	NNP
5180	858	25	,	,	,
5180	858	26	to	to	TO
5180	858	27	help	help	VB
5180	858	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
5180	858	29	identify	identify	VB
5180	858	30	which	which	WDT
5180	858	31	sites	site	NNS
5180	858	32	were	be	VBD
5180	858	33	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	858	34	for	for	IN
5180	858	35	library	library	JJ
5180	858	36	use	use	NN
5180	858	37	.	.	.
5180	859	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	859	2	describe	describe	VBP
5180	859	3	the	the	DT
5180	859	4	process	process	NN
5180	859	5	that	that	WDT
5180	859	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	859	7	used	use	VBD
5180	859	8	in	in	IN
5180	859	9	the	the	DT
5180	859	10	margin	margin	NN
5180	859	11	.	.	.
5180	860	1	Due	due	IN
5180	860	2	to	to	IN
5180	860	3	the	the	DT
5180	860	4	inability	inability	NN
5180	860	5	of	of	IN
5180	860	6	a	a	DT
5180	860	7	member	member	NN
5180	860	8	of	of	IN
5180	860	9	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	860	10	's	's	POS
5180	860	11	review	review	NN
5180	860	12	team	team	NN
5180	860	13	to	to	TO
5180	860	14	complete	complete	VB
5180	860	15	the	the	DT
5180	860	16	reviewing	reviewing	NN
5180	860	17	process	process	NN
5180	860	18	,	,	,
5180	860	19	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	860	20	had	have	VBD
5180	860	21	to	to	TO
5180	860	22	cut	cut	VB
5180	860	23	157	157	CD
5180	860	24	Web	web	NN
5180	860	25	sites	site	NNS
5180	860	26	out	out	IN
5180	860	27	of	of	IN
5180	860	28	the	the	DT
5180	860	29	sample	sample	NN
5180	860	30	,	,	,
5180	860	31	but	but	CC
5180	860	32	because	because	IN
5180	860	33	the	the	DT
5180	860	34	Web	web	NN
5180	860	35	sites	site	NNS
5180	860	36	were	be	VBD
5180	860	37	randomly	randomly	RB
5180	860	38	assigned	assign	VBN
5180	860	39	to	to	IN
5180	860	40	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	860	41	,	,	,
5180	860	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	860	43	is	be	VBZ
5180	860	44	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
5180	860	45	that	that	IN
5180	860	46	these	these	DT
5180	860	47	sites	site	NNS
5180	860	48	differed	differ	VBD
5180	860	49	significantly	significantly	RB
5180	860	50	from	from	IN
5180	860	51	the	the	DT
5180	860	52	rest	rest	NN
5180	860	53	of	of	IN
5180	860	54	the	the	DT
5180	860	55	sample	sample	NN
5180	860	56	.	.	.
5180	861	1	That	that	DT
5180	861	2	left	leave	VBD
5180	861	3	the	the	DT
5180	861	4	sample	sample	NN
5180	861	5	size	size	NN
5180	861	6	at	at	IN
5180	861	7	699	699	CD
5180	861	8	,	,	,
5180	861	9	which	which	WDT
5180	861	10	widened	widen	VBD
5180	861	11	the	the	DT
5180	861	12	95	95	CD
5180	861	13	%	%	NN
5180	861	14	confidence	confidence	NN
5180	861	15	interval	interval	NN
5180	861	16	to	to	IN
5180	861	17	plus	plus	NN
5180	861	18	or	or	CC
5180	861	19	minus	minus	CC
5180	861	20	2.8	2.8	CD
5180	861	21	%	%	NN
5180	861	22	.	.	.
5180	862	1	Of	of	IN
5180	862	2	the	the	DT
5180	862	3	total	total	JJ
5180	862	4	699	699	CD
5180	862	5	sites	site	NNS
5180	862	6	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	862	7	,	,	,
5180	862	8	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	862	9	's	's	POS
5180	862	10	team	team	NN
5180	862	11	concluded	conclude	VBD
5180	862	12	that	that	IN
5180	862	13	165	165	CD
5180	862	14	of	of	IN
5180	862	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	862	16	,	,	,
5180	862	17	or	or	CC
5180	862	18	23.6	23.6	CD
5180	862	19	%	%	NN
5180	862	20	percent	percent	NN
5180	862	21	of	of	IN
5180	862	22	the	the	DT
5180	862	23	sample	sample	NN
5180	862	24	,	,	,
5180	862	25	were	be	VBD
5180	862	26	not	not	RB
5180	862	27	of	of	IN
5180	862	28	any	any	DT
5180	862	29	value	value	NN
5180	862	30	in	in	IN
5180	862	31	the	the	DT
5180	862	32	library	library	NN
5180	862	33	context	context	NN
5180	862	34	(	(	-LRB-
5180	862	35	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	862	36	,	,	,
5180	862	37	no	no	DT
5180	862	38	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	862	39	would	would	MD
5180	862	40	,	,	,
5180	862	41	consistent	consistent	JJ
5180	862	42	with	with	IN
5180	862	43	professional	professional	JJ
5180	862	44	standards	standard	NNS
5180	862	45	,	,	,
5180	862	46	refer	refer	VBP
5180	862	47	a	a	DT
5180	862	48	patron	patron	NN
5180	862	49	to	to	IN
5180	862	50	these	these	DT
5180	862	51	sites	site	NNS
5180	862	52	as	as	IN
5180	862	53	a	a	DT
5180	862	54	source	source	NN
5180	862	55	of	of	IN
5180	862	56	information	information	NN
5180	862	57	)	)	-RRB-
5180	862	58	.	.	.
5180	863	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
5180	863	2	were	be	VBD
5180	863	3	unable	unable	JJ
5180	863	4	to	to	TO
5180	863	5	find	find	VB
5180	863	6	60	60	CD
5180	863	7	of	of	IN
5180	863	8	the	the	DT
5180	863	9	Web	web	NN
5180	863	10	sites	site	NNS
5180	863	11	,	,	,
5180	863	12	or	or	CC
5180	863	13	8.6	8.6	CD
5180	863	14	%	%	NN
5180	863	15	of	of	IN
5180	863	16	the	the	DT
5180	863	17	sample	sample	NN
5180	863	18	.	.	.
5180	864	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
5180	864	2	,	,	,
5180	864	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	864	4	concluded	conclude	VBD
5180	864	5	that	that	IN
5180	864	6	the	the	DT
5180	864	7	remaining	remain	VBG
5180	864	8	474	474	CD
5180	864	9	Web	web	NN
5180	864	10	sites	site	NNS
5180	864	11	,	,	,
5180	864	12	or	or	CC
5180	864	13	67.8	67.8	CD
5180	864	14	%	%	NN
5180	864	15	of	of	IN
5180	864	16	the	the	DT
5180	864	17	sample	sample	NN
5180	864	18	,	,	,
5180	864	19	were	be	VBD
5180	864	20	examples	example	NNS
5180	864	21	of	of	IN
5180	864	22	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	864	23	with	with	IN
5180	864	24	respect	respect	NN
5180	864	25	to	to	IN
5180	864	26	materials	material	NNS
5180	864	27	that	that	WDT
5180	864	28	are	be	VBP
5180	864	29	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	864	30	sources	source	NNS
5180	864	31	of	of	IN
5180	864	32	information	information	NN
5180	864	33	in	in	IN
5180	864	34	public	public	JJ
5180	864	35	libraries	library	NNS
5180	864	36	.	.	.
5180	865	1	Applying	apply	VBG
5180	865	2	a	a	DT
5180	865	3	95	95	CD
5180	865	4	%	%	NN
5180	865	5	confidence	confidence	NN
5180	865	6	interval	interval	NN
5180	865	7	of	of	IN
5180	865	8	plus	plus	NN
5180	865	9	or	or	CC
5180	865	10	minus	minus	CC
5180	865	11	2.8	2.8	CD
5180	865	12	%	%	NN
5180	865	13	,	,	,
5180	865	14	the	the	DT
5180	865	15	study	study	NN
5180	865	16	concluded	conclude	VBD
5180	865	17	that	that	IN
5180	865	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	865	19	can	can	MD
5180	865	20	be	be	VB
5180	865	21	95	95	CD
5180	865	22	%	%	NN
5180	865	23	confident	confident	JJ
5180	865	24	that	that	IN
5180	865	25	the	the	DT
5180	865	26	actual	actual	JJ
5180	865	27	percentage	percentage	NN
5180	865	28	of	of	IN
5180	865	29	sites	site	NNS
5180	865	30	in	in	IN
5180	865	31	the	the	DT
5180	865	32	list	list	NN
5180	865	33	of	of	IN
5180	865	34	6,775	6,775	CD
5180	865	35	sites	site	NNS
5180	865	36	that	that	WDT
5180	865	37	are	be	VBP
5180	865	38	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	865	39	for	for	IN
5180	865	40	use	use	NN
5180	865	41	in	in	IN
5180	865	42	public	public	JJ
5180	865	43	libraries	library	NNS
5180	865	44	is	be	VBZ
5180	865	45	somewhere	somewhere	RB
5180	865	46	between	between	IN
5180	865	47	65.0	65.0	CD
5180	865	48	%	%	NN
5180	865	49	and	and	CC
5180	865	50	70.6	70.6	CD
5180	865	51	%	%	NN
5180	865	52	.	.	.
5180	866	1	In	in	IN
5180	866	2	other	other	JJ
5180	866	3	words	word	NNS
5180	866	4	,	,	,
5180	866	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	866	6	can	can	MD
5180	866	7	be	be	VB
5180	866	8	95	95	CD
5180	866	9	%	%	NN
5180	866	10	certain	certain	JJ
5180	866	11	that	that	IN
5180	866	12	the	the	DT
5180	866	13	actual	actual	JJ
5180	866	14	number	number	NN
5180	866	15	of	of	IN
5180	866	16	sites	site	NNS
5180	866	17	out	out	IN
5180	866	18	of	of	IN
5180	866	19	the	the	DT
5180	866	20	6,775	6,775	CD
5180	866	21	that	that	WDT
5180	866	22	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	866	23	forwarded	forward	VBD
5180	866	24	to	to	IN
5180	866	25	Janes	Janes	NNPS
5180	866	26	that	that	WDT
5180	866	27	are	be	VBP
5180	866	28	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	866	29	for	for	IN
5180	866	30	use	use	NN
5180	866	31	in	in	IN
5180	866	32	public	public	JJ
5180	866	33	libraries	library	NNS
5180	866	34	(	(	-LRB-
5180	866	35	under	under	IN
5180	866	36	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	866	37	's	's	POS
5180	866	38	standard	standard	NN
5180	866	39	)	)	-RRB-
5180	866	40	is	be	VBZ
5180	866	41	somewhere	somewhere	RB
5180	866	42	between	between	IN
5180	866	43	4,403	4,403	CD
5180	866	44	and	and	CC
5180	866	45	4,783	4,783	CD
5180	866	46	.	.	.
5180	867	1	The	the	DT
5180	867	2	government	government	NN
5180	867	3	raised	raise	VBD
5180	867	4	some	some	DT
5180	867	5	valid	valid	JJ
5180	867	6	criticisms	criticism	NNS
5180	867	7	of	of	IN
5180	867	8	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	867	9	's	's	POS
5180	867	10	methodology	methodology	NN
5180	867	11	,	,	,
5180	867	12	attacking	attack	VBG
5180	867	13	in	in	IN
5180	867	14	particular	particular	JJ
5180	867	15	the	the	DT
5180	867	16	fact	fact	NN
5180	867	17	that	that	IN
5180	867	18	,	,	,
5180	867	19	while	while	IN
5180	867	20	sites	site	NNS
5180	867	21	that	that	WDT
5180	867	22	received	receive	VBD
5180	867	23	two	two	CD
5180	867	24	"	"	``
5180	867	25	yes	yes	UH
5180	867	26	"	"	''
5180	867	27	votes	vote	NNS
5180	867	28	in	in	IN
5180	867	29	the	the	DT
5180	867	30	first	first	JJ
5180	867	31	round	round	NN
5180	867	32	of	of	IN
5180	867	33	voting	voting	NN
5180	867	34	were	be	VBD
5180	867	35	determined	determined	JJ
5180	867	36	to	to	TO
5180	867	37	be	be	VB
5180	867	38	of	of	IN
5180	867	39	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
5180	867	40	interest	interest	NN
5180	867	41	in	in	IN
5180	867	42	a	a	DT
5180	867	43	library	library	NN
5180	867	44	context	context	NN
5180	867	45	to	to	TO
5180	867	46	be	be	VB
5180	867	47	removed	remove	VBN
5180	867	48	from	from	IN
5180	867	49	further	further	JJ
5180	867	50	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	867	51	,	,	,
5180	867	52	sites	site	NNS
5180	867	53	receiving	receive	VBG
5180	867	54	one	one	CD
5180	867	55	or	or	CC
5180	867	56	two	two	CD
5180	867	57	"	"	``
5180	867	58	no	no	UH
5180	867	59	"	"	''
5180	867	60	votes	vote	NNS
5180	867	61	were	be	VBD
5180	867	62	sent	send	VBN
5180	867	63	to	to	IN
5180	867	64	the	the	DT
5180	867	65	next	next	JJ
5180	867	66	round	round	NN
5180	867	67	.	.	.
5180	868	1	The	the	DT
5180	868	2	government	government	NN
5180	868	3	also	also	RB
5180	868	4	correctly	correctly	RB
5180	868	5	points	point	VBZ
5180	868	6	out	out	RP
5180	868	7	that	that	IN
5180	868	8	results	result	NNS
5180	868	9	of	of	IN
5180	868	10	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	868	11	's	's	POS
5180	868	12	study	study	NN
5180	868	13	can	can	MD
5180	868	14	be	be	VB
5180	868	15	generalized	generalize	VBN
5180	868	16	only	only	RB
5180	868	17	to	to	IN
5180	868	18	the	the	DT
5180	868	19	population	population	NN
5180	868	20	of	of	IN
5180	868	21	6,775	6,775	CD
5180	868	22	sites	site	NNS
5180	868	23	that	that	WDT
5180	868	24	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	868	25	forwarded	forward	VBD
5180	868	26	to	to	IN
5180	868	27	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	868	28	.	.	.
5180	869	1	Even	even	RB
5180	869	2	taking	take	VBG
5180	869	3	these	these	DT
5180	869	4	criticisms	criticism	NNS
5180	869	5	into	into	IN
5180	869	6	account	account	NN
5180	869	7	,	,	,
5180	869	8	and	and	CC
5180	869	9	discounting	discount	VBG
5180	869	10	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	869	11	's	's	POS
5180	869	12	numbers	number	NNS
5180	869	13	appropriately	appropriately	RB
5180	869	14	,	,	,
5180	869	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	869	16	credit	credit	VBP
5180	869	17	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	869	18	's	's	POS
5180	869	19	study	study	NN
5180	869	20	as	as	IN
5180	869	21	confirming	confirm	VBG
5180	869	22	that	that	IN
5180	869	23	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	869	24	's	's	POS
5180	869	25	set	set	NN
5180	869	26	of	of	IN
5180	869	27	6,775	6,775	CD
5180	869	28	Web	web	NN
5180	869	29	sites	site	NNS
5180	869	30	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	869	31	at	at	IN
5180	869	32	least	least	JJS
5180	869	33	a	a	DT
5180	869	34	few	few	JJ
5180	869	35	thousand	thousand	CD
5180	869	36	URLs	url	NNS
5180	869	37	that	that	WDT
5180	869	38	were	be	VBD
5180	869	39	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	869	40	blocked	block	VBN
5180	869	41	by	by	IN
5180	869	42	one	one	CD
5180	869	43	or	or	CC
5180	869	44	more	more	JJR
5180	869	45	of	of	IN
5180	869	46	the	the	DT
5180	869	47	four	four	CD
5180	869	48	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	869	49	programs	program	NNS
5180	869	50	that	that	WDT
5180	869	51	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	869	52	used	use	VBD
5180	869	53	,	,	,
5180	869	54	whether	whether	IN
5180	869	55	judged	judge	VBN
5180	869	56	against	against	IN
5180	869	57	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	869	58	's	's	POS
5180	869	59	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	869	60	,	,	,
5180	869	61	the	the	DT
5180	869	62	filters	filter	NNS
5180	869	63	'	'	POS
5180	869	64	own	own	JJ
5180	869	65	category	category	NN
5180	869	66	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	869	67	,	,	,
5180	869	68	or	or	CC
5180	869	69	against	against	IN
5180	869	70	the	the	DT
5180	869	71	standard	standard	NN
5180	869	72	that	that	WDT
5180	869	73	the	the	DT
5180	869	74	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	869	75	study	study	NN
5180	869	76	used	use	VBD
5180	869	77	.	.	.
5180	870	1	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	870	2	tested	test	VBD
5180	870	3	only	only	RB
5180	870	4	500,000	500,000	CD
5180	870	5	unique	unique	JJ
5180	870	6	URLs	url	NNS
5180	870	7	out	out	IN
5180	870	8	of	of	IN
5180	870	9	the	the	DT
5180	870	10	4000	4000	CD
5180	870	11	times	time	NNS
5180	870	12	that	that	IN
5180	870	13	many	many	JJ
5180	870	14	,	,	,
5180	870	15	or	or	CC
5180	870	16	two	two	CD
5180	870	17	billion	billion	CD
5180	870	18	,	,	,
5180	870	19	that	that	WDT
5180	870	20	are	be	VBP
5180	870	21	estimated	estimate	VBN
5180	870	22	to	to	TO
5180	870	23	exist	exist	VB
5180	870	24	in	in	IN
5180	870	25	the	the	DT
5180	870	26	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	870	27	Web	web	NN
5180	870	28	.	.	.
5180	871	1	Even	even	RB
5180	871	2	assuming	assume	VBG
5180	871	3	that	that	IN
5180	871	4	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	871	5	chose	choose	VBD
5180	871	6	the	the	DT
5180	871	7	URLs	url	NNS
5180	871	8	that	that	WDT
5180	871	9	were	be	VBD
5180	871	10	most	most	RBS
5180	871	11	likely	likely	JJ
5180	871	12	to	to	TO
5180	871	13	be	be	VB
5180	871	14	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	871	15	blocked	block	VBN
5180	871	16	by	by	IN
5180	871	17	commercial	commercial	JJ
5180	871	18	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	871	19	programs	program	NNS
5180	871	20	,	,	,
5180	871	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	871	22	conclude	conclude	VBP
5180	871	23	that	that	IN
5180	871	24	many	many	JJ
5180	871	25	times	time	NNS
5180	871	26	the	the	DT
5180	871	27	number	number	NN
5180	871	28	of	of	IN
5180	871	29	pages	page	NNS
5180	871	30	that	that	WDT
5180	871	31	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	871	32	identified	identify	VBN
5180	871	33	are	be	VBP
5180	871	34	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	871	35	blocked	block	VBN
5180	871	36	by	by	IN
5180	871	37	one	one	CD
5180	871	38	or	or	CC
5180	871	39	more	more	JJR
5180	871	40	of	of	IN
5180	871	41	the	the	DT
5180	871	42	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	871	43	programs	program	NNS
5180	871	44	that	that	WDT
5180	871	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	871	46	tested	test	VBD
5180	871	47	.	.	.
5180	872	1	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	872	2	's	's	POS
5180	872	3	and	and	CC
5180	872	4	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	872	5	's	's	POS
5180	872	6	studies	study	NNS
5180	872	7	provide	provide	VBP
5180	872	8	numerous	numerous	JJ
5180	872	9	specific	specific	JJ
5180	872	10	examples	example	NNS
5180	872	11	of	of	IN
5180	872	12	Web	web	NN
5180	872	13	pages	page	NNS
5180	872	14	that	that	WDT
5180	872	15	were	be	VBD
5180	872	16	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	872	17	blocked	block	VBN
5180	872	18	by	by	IN
5180	872	19	one	one	CD
5180	872	20	or	or	CC
5180	872	21	more	more	JJR
5180	872	22	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	872	23	programs	program	NNS
5180	872	24	.	.	.
5180	873	1	The	the	DT
5180	873	2	Web	web	NN
5180	873	3	pages	page	NNS
5180	873	4	that	that	WDT
5180	873	5	were	be	VBD
5180	873	6	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	873	7	blocked	block	VBN
5180	873	8	by	by	IN
5180	873	9	one	one	CD
5180	873	10	or	or	CC
5180	873	11	more	more	JJR
5180	873	12	of	of	IN
5180	873	13	the	the	DT
5180	873	14	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	873	15	programs	program	NNS
5180	873	16	do	do	VBP
5180	873	17	not	not	RB
5180	873	18	fall	fall	VB
5180	873	19	into	into	IN
5180	873	20	any	any	DT
5180	873	21	neat	neat	JJ
5180	873	22	patterns	pattern	NNS
5180	873	23	;	;	:
5180	873	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	873	25	range	range	VBP
5180	873	26	widely	widely	RB
5180	873	27	in	in	IN
5180	873	28	subject	subject	JJ
5180	873	29	matter	matter	NN
5180	873	30	,	,	,
5180	873	31	and	and	CC
5180	873	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	873	33	is	be	VBZ
5180	873	34	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	873	35	to	to	TO
5180	873	36	tell	tell	VB
5180	873	37	why	why	WRB
5180	873	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	873	39	may	may	MD
5180	873	40	have	have	VB
5180	873	41	been	be	VBN
5180	873	42	overblocked	overblocke	VBN
5180	873	43	.	.	.
5180	874	1	The	the	DT
5180	874	2	list	list	NN
5180	874	3	that	that	WDT
5180	874	4	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	874	5	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	874	6	,	,	,
5180	874	7	for	for	IN
5180	874	8	example	example	NN
5180	874	9	,	,	,
5180	874	10	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	874	11	Web	web	NN
5180	874	12	pages	page	NNS
5180	874	13	relating	relate	VBG
5180	874	14	to	to	IN
5180	874	15	religion	religion	NN
5180	874	16	,	,	,
5180	874	17	politics	politics	NN
5180	874	18	and	and	CC
5180	874	19	government	government	NN
5180	874	20	,	,	,
5180	874	21	health	health	NN
5180	874	22	,	,	,
5180	874	23	careers	career	NNS
5180	874	24	,	,	,
5180	874	25	education	education	NN
5180	874	26	,	,	,
5180	874	27	travel	travel	NN
5180	874	28	,	,	,
5180	874	29	sports	sport	NNS
5180	874	30	,	,	,
5180	874	31	and	and	CC
5180	874	32	many	many	JJ
5180	874	33	other	other	JJ
5180	874	34	topics	topic	NNS
5180	874	35	.	.	.
5180	875	1	In	in	IN
5180	875	2	the	the	DT
5180	875	3	next	next	JJ
5180	875	4	section	section	NN
5180	875	5	,	,	,
5180	875	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	875	7	provide	provide	VBP
5180	875	8	examples	example	NNS
5180	875	9	from	from	IN
5180	875	10	each	each	DT
5180	875	11	of	of	IN
5180	875	12	these	these	DT
5180	875	13	categories	category	NNS
5180	875	14	.	.	.
5180	876	1	6	6	CD
5180	876	2	.	.	.
5180	877	1	Examples	example	NNS
5180	877	2	of	of	IN
5180	877	3	Erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	877	4	Blocked	block	VBN
5180	877	5	Web	web	NN
5180	877	6	Sites	Sites	NNPS
5180	877	7	Several	several	JJ
5180	877	8	of	of	IN
5180	877	9	the	the	DT
5180	877	10	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	877	11	blocked	block	VBN
5180	877	12	Web	web	NN
5180	877	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	877	14	had	have	VBD
5180	877	15	content	content	NN
5180	877	16	relating	relate	VBG
5180	877	17	to	to	IN
5180	877	18	churches	church	NNS
5180	877	19	,	,	,
5180	877	20	religious	religious	JJ
5180	877	21	orders	order	NNS
5180	877	22	,	,	,
5180	877	23	religious	religious	JJ
5180	877	24	charities	charity	NNS
5180	877	25	,	,	,
5180	877	26	and	and	CC
5180	877	27	religious	religious	JJ
5180	877	28	fellowship	fellowship	NN
5180	877	29	organizations	organization	NNS
5180	877	30	.	.	.
5180	878	1	These	these	DT
5180	878	2	included	include	VBD
5180	878	3	the	the	DT
5180	878	4	following	follow	VBG
5180	878	5	Web	web	NN
5180	878	6	sites	site	NNS
5180	878	7	:	:	:
5180	878	8	the	the	DT
5180	878	9	Knights	Knights	NNPS
5180	878	10	of	of	IN
5180	878	11	Columbus	Columbus	NNP
5180	878	12	Council	Council	NNP
5180	878	13	4828	4828	CD
5180	878	14	,	,	,
5180	878	15	a	a	DT
5180	878	16	Catholic	catholic	JJ
5180	878	17	men	man	NNS
5180	878	18	's	's	POS
5180	878	19	group	group	NN
5180	878	20	associated	associate	VBN
5180	878	21	with	with	IN
5180	878	22	St.	St.	NNP
5180	878	23	Patrick	Patrick	NNP
5180	878	24	's	's	POS
5180	878	25	Church	Church	NNP
5180	878	26	in	in	IN
5180	878	27	Fallon	Fallon	NNP
5180	878	28	,	,	,
5180	878	29	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
5180	878	30	,	,	,
5180	878	31	http://msnhomepages.talkcity.com/SpiritSt/kofc4828	http://msnhomepages.talkcity.com/SpiritSt/kofc4828	NNP
5180	878	32	,	,	,
5180	878	33	which	which	WDT
5180	878	34	was	be	VBD
5180	878	35	blocked	block	VBN
5180	878	36	by	by	IN
5180	878	37	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	878	38	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	878	39	in	in	IN
5180	878	40	the	the	DT
5180	878	41	"	"	``
5180	878	42	Adult	adult	NN
5180	878	43	/	/	,
5180	878	44	Sexually	sexually	RB
5180	878	45	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	878	46	"	"	''
5180	878	47	category	category	NN
5180	878	48	;	;	:
5180	878	49	the	the	DT
5180	878	50	Agape	Agape	NNP
5180	878	51	Church	Church	NNP
5180	878	52	of	of	IN
5180	878	53	Searcy	Searcy	NNP
5180	878	54	,	,	,
5180	878	55	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
5180	878	56	,	,	,
5180	878	57	http://www.agapechurch.com	http://www.agapechurch.com	ADD
5180	878	58	,	,	,
5180	878	59	which	which	WDT
5180	878	60	was	be	VBD
5180	878	61	blocked	block	VBN
5180	878	62	by	by	IN
5180	878	63	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	878	64	as	as	IN
5180	878	65	"	"	``
5180	878	66	Adult	Adult	NNP
5180	878	67	Content	Content	NNP
5180	878	68	"	"	''
5180	878	69	;	;	:
5180	878	70	the	the	DT
5180	878	71	home	home	NN
5180	878	72	page	page	NN
5180	878	73	of	of	IN
5180	878	74	the	the	DT
5180	878	75	Lesbian	lesbian	JJ
5180	878	76	and	and	CC
5180	878	77	Gay	Gay	NNP
5180	878	78	Havurah	Havurah	NNP
5180	878	79	of	of	IN
5180	878	80	the	the	DT
5180	878	81	Long	Long	NNP
5180	878	82	Beach	Beach	NNP
5180	878	83	,	,	,
5180	878	84	California	California	NNP
5180	878	85	Jewish	Jewish	NNP
5180	878	86	Community	Community	NNP
5180	878	87	Center	Center	NNP
5180	878	88	,	,	,
5180	878	89	http://www.compupix.com/gay/havurah.htm	http://www.compupix.com/gay/havurah.htm	NNP
5180	878	90	,	,	,
5180	878	91	which	which	WDT
5180	878	92	was	be	VBD
5180	878	93	blocked	block	VBN
5180	878	94	by	by	IN
5180	878	95	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	878	96	as	as	IN
5180	878	97	"	"	``
5180	878	98	Adults	Adults	NNP
5180	878	99	Only	only	RB
5180	878	100	,	,	,
5180	878	101	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	878	102	,	,	,
5180	878	103	"	"	''
5180	878	104	by	by	IN
5180	878	105	Smartfilter	Smartfilter	NNP
5180	878	106	as	as	IN
5180	878	107	"	"	``
5180	878	108	Sex	sex	NN
5180	878	109	,	,	,
5180	878	110	"	"	''
5180	878	111	and	and	CC
5180	878	112	by	by	IN
5180	878	113	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	878	114	as	as	IN
5180	878	115	"	"	``
5180	878	116	Sex	sex	NN
5180	878	117	"	"	''
5180	878	118	;	;	:
5180	878	119	Orphanage	Orphanage	NNP
5180	878	120	Emmanuel	Emmanuel	NNP
5180	878	121	,	,	,
5180	878	122	a	a	DT
5180	878	123	Christian	christian	JJ
5180	878	124	orphanage	orphanage	NN
5180	878	125	in	in	IN
5180	878	126	Honduras	Honduras	NNP
5180	878	127	that	that	IN
5180	878	128	houses	house	VBZ
5180	878	129	225	225	CD
5180	878	130	children	child	NNS
5180	878	131	,	,	,
5180	878	132	http://home8.inet.tele.dk/rfb_viva	http://home8.inet.tele.dk/rfb_viva	NNP
5180	878	133	,	,	,
5180	878	134	which	which	WDT
5180	878	135	was	be	VBD
5180	878	136	blocked	block	VBN
5180	878	137	by	by	IN
5180	878	138	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	878	139	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	878	140	in	in	IN
5180	878	141	the	the	DT
5180	878	142	"	"	``
5180	878	143	Adult	adult	NN
5180	878	144	/	/	,
5180	878	145	Sexually	sexually	RB
5180	878	146	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	878	147	"	"	''
5180	878	148	category	category	NN
5180	878	149	;	;	:
5180	878	150	Vision	Vision	NNP
5180	878	151	Art	Art	NNP
5180	878	152	Online	Online	NNP
5180	878	153	,	,	,
5180	878	154	which	which	WDT
5180	878	155	sells	sell	VBZ
5180	878	156	wooden	wooden	JJ
5180	878	157	wall	wall	NN
5180	878	158	hangings	hanging	NNS
5180	878	159	for	for	IN
5180	878	160	the	the	DT
5180	878	161	home	home	NN
5180	878	162	that	that	WDT
5180	878	163	contain	contain	VBP
5180	878	164	prayers	prayer	NNS
5180	878	165	,	,	,
5180	878	166	passages	passage	NNS
5180	878	167	from	from	IN
5180	878	168	the	the	DT
5180	878	169	Bible	Bible	NNP
5180	878	170	,	,	,
5180	878	171	and	and	CC
5180	878	172	images	image	NNS
5180	878	173	of	of	IN
5180	878	174	the	the	DT
5180	878	175	Star	Star	NNP
5180	878	176	of	of	IN
5180	878	177	David	David	NNP
5180	878	178	,	,	,
5180	878	179	http://www.visionartonline.com	http://www.visionartonline.com	ADD
5180	878	180	,	,	,
5180	878	181	which	which	WDT
5180	878	182	was	be	VBD
5180	878	183	blocked	block	VBN
5180	878	184	in	in	IN
5180	878	185	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	878	186	's	's	POS
5180	878	187	"	"	``
5180	878	188	Sex	sex	NN
5180	878	189	"	"	''
5180	878	190	category	category	NN
5180	878	191	;	;	,
5180	878	192	and	and	CC
5180	878	193	the	the	DT
5180	878	194	home	home	NN
5180	878	195	page	page	NN
5180	878	196	of	of	IN
5180	878	197	Tenzin	Tenzin	NNP
5180	878	198	Palmo	Palmo	NNP
5180	878	199	,	,	,
5180	878	200	a	a	DT
5180	878	201	Buddhist	buddhist	JJ
5180	878	202	nun	nun	NN
5180	878	203	,	,	,
5180	878	204	which	which	WDT
5180	878	205	contained	contain	VBD
5180	878	206	a	a	DT
5180	878	207	description	description	NN
5180	878	208	of	of	IN
5180	878	209	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	878	210	project	project	NN
5180	878	211	to	to	TO
5180	878	212	build	build	VB
5180	878	213	a	a	DT
5180	878	214	Buddhist	buddhist	JJ
5180	878	215	nunnery	nunnery	NN
5180	878	216	and	and	CC
5180	878	217	international	international	JJ
5180	878	218	retreat	retreat	NN
5180	878	219	center	center	NN
5180	878	220	for	for	IN
5180	878	221	women	woman	NNS
5180	878	222	,	,	,
5180	878	223	http://www.tenzinpalmo.com	http://www.tenzinpalmo.com	NNS
5180	878	224	,	,	,
5180	878	225	which	which	WDT
5180	878	226	was	be	VBD
5180	878	227	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	878	228	as	as	IN
5180	878	229	"	"	``
5180	878	230	Nudity	nudity	NN
5180	878	231	"	"	''
5180	878	232	by	by	IN
5180	878	233	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	878	234	.	.	.
5180	879	1	Several	several	JJ
5180	879	2	blocked	block	VBN
5180	879	3	sites	site	NNS
5180	879	4	also	also	RB
5180	879	5	contained	contain	VBD
5180	879	6	information	information	NN
5180	879	7	about	about	IN
5180	879	8	governmental	governmental	JJ
5180	879	9	entities	entity	NNS
5180	879	10	or	or	CC
5180	879	11	specific	specific	JJ
5180	879	12	political	political	JJ
5180	879	13	candidates	candidate	NNS
5180	879	14	,	,	,
5180	879	15	or	or	CC
5180	879	16	contained	contain	VBD
5180	879	17	political	political	JJ
5180	879	18	commentary	commentary	NN
5180	879	19	.	.	.
5180	880	1	These	these	DT
5180	880	2	included	include	VBN
5180	880	3	:	:	:
5180	880	4	the	the	DT
5180	880	5	Web	web	NN
5180	880	6	site	site	NN
5180	880	7	for	for	IN
5180	880	8	Kelley	Kelley	NNP
5180	880	9	Ross	Ross	NNP
5180	880	10	,	,	,
5180	880	11	a	a	DT
5180	880	12	Libertarian	libertarian	JJ
5180	880	13	candidate	candidate	NN
5180	880	14	for	for	IN
5180	880	15	the	the	DT
5180	880	16	California	California	NNP
5180	880	17	State	State	NNP
5180	880	18	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
5180	880	19	,	,	,
5180	880	20	http://www.friesian.com/ross/ca40	http://www.friesian.com/ross/ca40	UH
5180	880	21	,	,	,
5180	880	22	which	which	WDT
5180	880	23	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	880	24	blocked	block	VBD
5180	880	25	as	as	IN
5180	880	26	"	"	``
5180	880	27	Nudity	Nudity	NNP
5180	880	28	"	"	''
5180	880	29	;	;	:
5180	880	30	the	the	DT
5180	880	31	Web	web	NN
5180	880	32	site	site	NN
5180	880	33	for	for	IN
5180	880	34	Bob	Bob	NNP
5180	880	35	Coughlin	Coughlin	NNP
5180	880	36	,	,	,
5180	880	37	a	a	DT
5180	880	38	town	town	NN
5180	880	39	selectman	selectman	NN
5180	880	40	in	in	IN
5180	880	41	Dedham	Dedham	NNP
5180	880	42	,	,	,
5180	880	43	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
5180	880	44	,	,	,
5180	880	45	http://www.bobcoughlin.org	http://www.bobcoughlin.org	ADD
5180	880	46	,	,	,
5180	880	47	which	which	WDT
5180	880	48	was	be	VBD
5180	880	49	blocked	block	VBN
5180	880	50	under	under	IN
5180	880	51	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	880	52	's	's	POS
5180	880	53	"	"	``
5180	880	54	Nudity	Nudity	NNP
5180	880	55	"	"	''
5180	880	56	category	category	NN
5180	880	57	;	;	,
5180	880	58	a	a	DT
5180	880	59	list	list	NN
5180	880	60	of	of	IN
5180	880	61	Web	web	NN
5180	880	62	sites	site	NNS
5180	880	63	containing	contain	VBG
5180	880	64	information	information	NN
5180	880	65	about	about	IN
5180	880	66	government	government	NN
5180	880	67	and	and	CC
5180	880	68	politics	politic	NNS
5180	880	69	in	in	IN
5180	880	70	Adams	Adams	NNP
5180	880	71	County	County	NNP
5180	880	72	,	,	,
5180	880	73	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
5180	880	74	,	,	,
5180	880	75	http://www.geocities.com/adamscopa	http://www.geocities.com/adamscopa	ADD
5180	880	76	,	,	,
5180	880	77	which	which	WDT
5180	880	78	was	be	VBD
5180	880	79	blocked	block	VBN
5180	880	80	by	by	IN
5180	880	81	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	880	82	as	as	IN
5180	880	83	"	"	``
5180	880	84	Sex	Sex	NNP
5180	880	85	"	"	''
5180	880	86	;	;	:
5180	880	87	the	the	DT
5180	880	88	Web	web	NN
5180	880	89	site	site	NN
5180	880	90	for	for	IN
5180	880	91	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
5180	880	92	Right	Right	NNP
5180	880	93	to	to	IN
5180	880	94	Life	Life	NNP
5180	880	95	,	,	,
5180	880	96	http://www.wrtl.org	http://www.wrtl.org	ADD
5180	880	97	,	,	,
5180	880	98	which	which	WDT
5180	880	99	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	880	100	blocked	block	VBD
5180	880	101	as	as	IN
5180	880	102	"	"	``
5180	880	103	Nudity	Nudity	NNP
5180	880	104	"	"	''
5180	880	105	;	;	:
5180	880	106	a	a	DT
5180	880	107	Web	web	NN
5180	880	108	site	site	NN
5180	880	109	that	that	WDT
5180	880	110	promotes	promote	VBZ
5180	880	111	federalism	federalism	NN
5180	880	112	in	in	IN
5180	880	113	Uganda	Uganda	NNP
5180	880	114	,	,	,
5180	880	115	http://federo.com	http://federo.com	ADD
5180	880	116	,	,	,
5180	880	117	which	which	WDT
5180	880	118	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	880	119	blocked	block	VBD
5180	880	120	as	as	IN
5180	880	121	"	"	``
5180	880	122	Adults	Adults	NNP
5180	880	123	Only	only	RB
5180	880	124	,	,	,
5180	880	125	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	880	126	"	"	''
5180	880	127	;	;	:
5180	880	128	"	"	``
5180	880	129	Fight	fight	VB
5180	880	130	the	the	DT
5180	880	131	Death	Death	NNP
5180	880	132	Penalty	Penalty	NNP
5180	880	133	in	in	IN
5180	880	134	the	the	DT
5180	880	135	USA	USA	NNP
5180	880	136	,	,	,
5180	880	137	"	"	''
5180	880	138	a	a	DT
5180	880	139	Danish	danish	JJ
5180	880	140	Web	web	NN
5180	880	141	site	site	NN
5180	880	142	dedicated	dedicate	VBN
5180	880	143	to	to	IN
5180	880	144	criticizing	criticize	VBG
5180	880	145	the	the	DT
5180	880	146	American	american	JJ
5180	880	147	system	system	NN
5180	880	148	of	of	IN
5180	880	149	capital	capital	NN
5180	880	150	punishment	punishment	NN
5180	880	151	,	,	,
5180	880	152	http://www.fdp.dk	http://www.fdp.dk	NNP
5180	880	153	,	,	,
5180	880	154	which	which	WDT
5180	880	155	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	880	156	blocked	block	VBD
5180	880	157	as	as	IN
5180	880	158	"	"	``
5180	880	159	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	880	160	"	"	''
5180	880	161	;	;	:
5180	880	162	and	and	CC
5180	880	163	"	"	``
5180	880	164	Dumb	Dumb	NNP
5180	880	165	Laws	Laws	NNPS
5180	880	166	,	,	,
5180	880	167	"	"	''
5180	880	168	a	a	DT
5180	880	169	humor	humor	NN
5180	880	170	Web	web	NN
5180	880	171	site	site	NN
5180	880	172	that	that	WDT
5180	880	173	makes	make	VBZ
5180	880	174	fun	fun	NN
5180	880	175	of	of	IN
5180	880	176	outmoded	outmoded	JJ
5180	880	177	laws	law	NNS
5180	880	178	,	,	,
5180	880	179	http://www.dumblaws.com	http://www.dumblaws.com	ADD
5180	880	180	,	,	,
5180	880	181	which	which	WDT
5180	880	182	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	880	183	blocked	block	VBD
5180	880	184	under	under	IN
5180	880	185	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	880	186	"	"	``
5180	880	187	Sex	sex	NN
5180	880	188	"	"	''
5180	880	189	category	category	NN
5180	880	190	.	.	.
5180	881	1	Erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	881	2	blocked	block	VBN
5180	881	3	Web	web	NN
5180	881	4	sites	site	NNS
5180	881	5	relating	relate	VBG
5180	881	6	to	to	IN
5180	881	7	health	health	NN
5180	881	8	issues	issue	NNS
5180	881	9	included	include	VBD
5180	881	10	the	the	DT
5180	881	11	following	follow	VBG
5180	881	12	:	:	:
5180	881	13	a	a	DT
5180	881	14	guide	guide	NN
5180	881	15	to	to	IN
5180	881	16	allergies	allergy	NNS
5180	881	17	,	,	,
5180	881	18	http://www.x-	http://www.x-	NNP
5180	881	19	sitez.com/allergy	sitez.com/allergy	NNP
5180	881	20	,	,	,
5180	881	21	which	which	WDT
5180	881	22	was	be	VBD
5180	881	23	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	881	24	as	as	IN
5180	881	25	"	"	``
5180	881	26	Adults	Adults	NNP
5180	881	27	Only	only	RB
5180	881	28	,	,	,
5180	881	29	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	881	30	"	"	''
5180	881	31	by	by	IN
5180	881	32	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	881	33	;	;	:
5180	881	34	a	a	DT
5180	881	35	health	health	NN
5180	881	36	question	question	NN
5180	881	37	and	and	CC
5180	881	38	answer	answer	NN
5180	881	39	site	site	NN
5180	881	40	sponsored	sponsor	VBN
5180	881	41	by	by	IN
5180	881	42	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
5180	881	43	University	University	NNP
5180	881	44	,	,	,
5180	881	45	http://www.goaskalice.com.columbia.edu	http://www.goaskalice.com.columbia.edu	NNS
5180	881	46	,	,	,
5180	881	47	which	which	WDT
5180	881	48	was	be	VBD
5180	881	49	blocked	block	VBN
5180	881	50	as	as	IN
5180	881	51	"	"	``
5180	881	52	Sex	sex	NN
5180	881	53	"	"	''
5180	881	54	by	by	IN
5180	881	55	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	881	56	,	,	,
5180	881	57	and	and	CC
5180	881	58	as	as	IN
5180	881	59	"	"	``
5180	881	60	Mature	Mature	NNP
5180	881	61	"	"	''
5180	881	62	by	by	IN
5180	881	63	Smartfilter	Smartfilter	NNP
5180	881	64	;	;	:
5180	881	65	the	the	DT
5180	881	66	Western	Western	NNP
5180	881	67	Amputee	Amputee	NNP
5180	881	68	Support	Support	NNP
5180	881	69	Alliance	Alliance	NNP
5180	881	70	Home	Home	NNP
5180	881	71	Page	Page	NNP
5180	881	72	,	,	,
5180	881	73	http://www.usinter.net/wasa	http://www.usinter.net/wasa	ADD
5180	881	74	,	,	,
5180	881	75	which	which	WDT
5180	881	76	was	be	VBD
5180	881	77	blocked	block	VBN
5180	881	78	by	by	IN
5180	881	79	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	881	80	as	as	IN
5180	881	81	"	"	``
5180	881	82	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	881	83	"	"	''
5180	881	84	;	;	:
5180	881	85	the	the	DT
5180	881	86	Web	web	NN
5180	881	87	site	site	NN
5180	881	88	of	of	IN
5180	881	89	the	the	DT
5180	881	90	Willis	Willis	NNP
5180	881	91	-	-	HYPH
5180	881	92	Knighton	Knighton	NNP
5180	881	93	Cancer	Cancer	NNP
5180	881	94	Center	Center	NNP
5180	881	95	,	,	,
5180	881	96	a	a	DT
5180	881	97	Shreveport	Shreveport	NNP
5180	881	98	,	,	,
5180	881	99	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
5180	881	100	cancer	cancer	NN
5180	881	101	treatment	treatment	NN
5180	881	102	facility	facility	NN
5180	881	103	,	,	,
5180	881	104	http://cancerftr.wkmc.com	http://cancerftr.wkmc.com	NNP
5180	881	105	,	,	,
5180	881	106	which	which	WDT
5180	881	107	was	be	VBD
5180	881	108	blocked	block	VBN
5180	881	109	by	by	IN
5180	881	110	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	881	111	under	under	IN
5180	881	112	the	the	DT
5180	881	113	"	"	``
5180	881	114	Sex	sex	NN
5180	881	115	"	"	''
5180	881	116	category	category	NN
5180	881	117	;	;	,
5180	881	118	and	and	CC
5180	881	119	a	a	DT
5180	881	120	site	site	NN
5180	881	121	dealing	deal	VBG
5180	881	122	with	with	IN
5180	881	123	halitosis	halitosis	NN
5180	881	124	,	,	,
5180	881	125	http://www.dreamcastle.com/tungs	http://www.dreamcastle.com/tungs	ADD
5180	881	126	,	,	,
5180	881	127	which	which	WDT
5180	881	128	was	be	VBD
5180	881	129	blocked	block	VBN
5180	881	130	by	by	IN
5180	881	131	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	881	132	as	as	IN
5180	881	133	"	"	``
5180	881	134	Adults	Adults	NNP
5180	881	135	,	,	,
5180	881	136	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	881	137	,	,	,
5180	881	138	"	"	''
5180	881	139	by	by	IN
5180	881	140	Smartfilter	Smartfilter	NNP
5180	881	141	as	as	IN
5180	881	142	"	"	``
5180	881	143	Sex	sex	NN
5180	881	144	,	,	,
5180	881	145	"	"	''
5180	881	146	by	by	IN
5180	881	147	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	881	148	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	881	149	as	as	IN
5180	881	150	"	"	``
5180	881	151	Adult	adult	NN
5180	881	152	/	/	,
5180	881	153	Sexually	sexually	RB
5180	881	154	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	881	155	,	,	,
5180	881	156	"	"	''
5180	881	157	and	and	CC
5180	881	158	by	by	IN
5180	881	159	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	881	160	as	as	IN
5180	881	161	"	"	``
5180	881	162	Adult	Adult	NNP
5180	881	163	Content	Content	NNP
5180	881	164	.	.	.
5180	881	165	"	"	''
5180	882	1	The	the	DT
5180	882	2	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	882	3	programs	program	NNS
5180	882	4	also	also	RB
5180	882	5	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	882	6	blocked	block	VBD
5180	882	7	several	several	JJ
5180	882	8	Web	web	NN
5180	882	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	882	10	having	have	VBG
5180	882	11	to	to	TO
5180	882	12	do	do	VB
5180	882	13	with	with	IN
5180	882	14	education	education	NN
5180	882	15	and	and	CC
5180	882	16	careers	career	NNS
5180	882	17	.	.	.
5180	883	1	The	the	DT
5180	883	2	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	883	3	programs	program	NNS
5180	883	4	blocked	block	VBD
5180	883	5	two	two	CD
5180	883	6	sites	site	NNS
5180	883	7	that	that	WDT
5180	883	8	provide	provide	VBP
5180	883	9	information	information	NN
5180	883	10	on	on	IN
5180	883	11	home	home	NN
5180	883	12	schooling	schooling	NN
5180	883	13	.	.	.
5180	884	1	"	"	``
5180	884	2	HomEduStation	homedustation	NN
5180	884	3	–	–	:
5180	884	4	the	the	DT
5180	884	5	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	884	6	Source	Source	NNP
5180	884	7	for	for	IN
5180	884	8	Home	Home	NNP
5180	884	9	Education	Education	NNP
5180	884	10	,	,	,
5180	884	11	"	"	''
5180	884	12	http://www.perigee.net/~mcmullen/homedustation/	http://www.perigee.net/~mcmullen/homedustation/	UH
5180	884	13	,	,	,
5180	884	14	was	be	VBD
5180	884	15	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	884	16	by	by	IN
5180	884	17	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	884	18	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	884	19	as	as	IN
5180	884	20	"	"	``
5180	884	21	Adult	adult	NN
5180	884	22	/	/	,
5180	884	23	Sexually	sexually	RB
5180	884	24	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	884	25	.	.	.
5180	884	26	"	"	''
5180	885	1	Smartfilter	Smartfilter	NNP
5180	885	2	blocked	block	VBD
5180	885	3	"	"	``
5180	885	4	Apricot	Apricot	NNP
5180	885	5	:	:	:
5180	885	6	A	a	DT
5180	885	7	Web	web	NN
5180	885	8	site	site	NN
5180	885	9	made	make	VBN
5180	885	10	by	by	IN
5180	885	11	and	and	CC
5180	885	12	for	for	IN
5180	885	13	home	home	NN
5180	885	14	schoolers	schooler	NNS
5180	885	15	,	,	,
5180	885	16	"	"	''
5180	885	17	http://apricotpie.com	http://apricotpie.com	ADD
5180	885	18	,	,	,
5180	885	19	as	as	IN
5180	885	20	"	"	``
5180	885	21	Sex	Sex	NNP
5180	885	22	.	.	.
5180	885	23	"	"	''
5180	886	1	The	the	DT
5180	886	2	programs	program	NNS
5180	886	3	also	also	RB
5180	886	4	miscategorized	miscategorize	VBD
5180	886	5	several	several	JJ
5180	886	6	career	career	NN
5180	886	7	-	-	HYPH
5180	886	8	related	relate	VBN
5180	886	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	886	10	.	.	.
5180	887	1	"	"	``
5180	887	2	Social	Social	NNP
5180	887	3	Work	Work	NNP
5180	887	4	Search	Search	NNP
5180	887	5	,	,	,
5180	887	6	"	"	''
5180	887	7	http://www.socialworksearch.com/	http://www.socialworksearch.com/	NN
5180	887	8	,	,	,
5180	887	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	887	10	a	a	DT
5180	887	11	directory	directory	NN
5180	887	12	for	for	IN
5180	887	13	social	social	JJ
5180	887	14	workers	worker	NNS
5180	887	15	that	that	WDT
5180	887	16	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	887	17	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	887	18	placed	place	VBD
5180	887	19	in	in	IN
5180	887	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	887	21	"	"	``
5180	887	22	Adult	adult	NN
5180	887	23	/	/	,
5180	887	24	Sexually	sexually	RB
5180	887	25	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	887	26	"	"	''
5180	887	27	category	category	NN
5180	887	28	.	.	.
5180	888	1	The	the	DT
5180	888	2	"	"	``
5180	888	3	Gay	Gay	NNP
5180	888	4	and	and	CC
5180	888	5	Lesbian	lesbian	JJ
5180	888	6	Chamber	Chamber	NNP
5180	888	7	of	of	IN
5180	888	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
5180	888	9	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
5180	888	10	,	,	,
5180	888	11	"	"	''
5180	888	12	http://www.lambdalv.com	http://www.lambdalv.com	ADD
5180	888	13	,	,	,
5180	888	14	"	"	''
5180	888	15	a	a	DT
5180	888	16	forum	forum	NN
5180	888	17	for	for	IN
5180	888	18	the	the	DT
5180	888	19	business	business	NN
5180	888	20	community	community	NN
5180	888	21	to	to	TO
5180	888	22	develop	develop	VB
5180	888	23	relationships	relationship	NNS
5180	888	24	within	within	IN
5180	888	25	the	the	DT
5180	888	26	Las	Las	NNP
5180	888	27	Vegas	Vegas	NNP
5180	888	28	lesbian	lesbian	NN
5180	888	29	,	,	,
5180	888	30	gay	gay	JJ
5180	888	31	,	,	,
5180	888	32	transsexual	transsexual	JJ
5180	888	33	,	,	,
5180	888	34	and	and	CC
5180	888	35	bisexual	bisexual	JJ
5180	888	36	community	community	NN
5180	888	37	"	"	''
5180	888	38	was	be	VBD
5180	888	39	blocked	block	VBN
5180	888	40	by	by	IN
5180	888	41	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	888	42	as	as	IN
5180	888	43	"	"	``
5180	888	44	Adults	Adults	NNP
5180	888	45	Only	only	RB
5180	888	46	,	,	,
5180	888	47	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	888	48	.	.	.
5180	888	49	"	"	''
5180	889	1	A	a	DT
5180	889	2	site	site	NN
5180	889	3	for	for	IN
5180	889	4	aspiring	aspire	VBG
5180	889	5	dentists	dentist	NNS
5180	889	6	,	,	,
5180	889	7	http://www.vvm.com/~bond/home.htm	http://www.vvm.com/~bond/home.htm	ADD
5180	889	8	,	,	,
5180	889	9	was	be	VBD
5180	889	10	blocked	block	VBN
5180	889	11	by	by	IN
5180	889	12	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	889	13	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	889	14	in	in	IN
5180	889	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	889	16	"	"	``
5180	889	17	Adult	adult	NN
5180	889	18	/	/	,
5180	889	19	Sexually	sexually	RB
5180	889	20	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	889	21	"	"	''
5180	889	22	category	category	NN
5180	889	23	.	.	.
5180	890	1	The	the	DT
5180	890	2	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	890	3	programs	program	NNS
5180	890	4	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	890	5	blocked	block	VBD
5180	890	6	many	many	JJ
5180	890	7	travel	travel	NN
5180	890	8	Web	web	NN
5180	890	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	890	10	,	,	,
5180	890	11	including	include	VBG
5180	890	12	:	:	:
5180	890	13	the	the	DT
5180	890	14	Web	web	NN
5180	890	15	site	site	NN
5180	890	16	for	for	IN
5180	890	17	the	the	DT
5180	890	18	Allen	Allen	NNP
5180	890	19	Farmhouse	Farmhouse	NNP
5180	890	20	Bed	Bed	NNP
5180	890	21	&	&	CC
5180	890	22	Breakfast	Breakfast	NNP
5180	890	23	of	of	IN
5180	890	24	Alleghany	Alleghany	NNP
5180	890	25	County	County	NNP
5180	890	26	,	,	,
5180	890	27	North	North	NNP
5180	890	28	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
5180	890	29	,	,	,
5180	890	30	http://planet-	http://planet-	NFP
5180	890	31	nc.com/Beth/index.html	nc.com/Beth/index.html	NNP
5180	890	32	,	,	,
5180	890	33	which	which	WDT
5180	890	34	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	890	35	blocked	block	VBD
5180	890	36	as	as	IN
5180	890	37	"	"	``
5180	890	38	Adult	Adult	NNP
5180	890	39	Content	content	NN
5180	890	40	"	"	''
5180	890	41	;	;	:
5180	890	42	Odysseus	Odysseus	NNP
5180	890	43	Gay	Gay	NNP
5180	890	44	Travel	Travel	NNP
5180	890	45	,	,	,
5180	890	46	a	a	DT
5180	890	47	travel	travel	NN
5180	890	48	company	company	NN
5180	890	49	serving	serve	VBG
5180	890	50	gay	gay	JJ
5180	890	51	men	man	NNS
5180	890	52	,	,	,
5180	890	53	http://www.odyusa.com	http://www.odyusa.com	ADD
5180	890	54	,	,	,
5180	890	55	which	which	WDT
5180	890	56	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	890	57	categorized	categorize	VBD
5180	890	58	as	as	IN
5180	890	59	"	"	``
5180	890	60	Adults	Adults	NNP
5180	890	61	Only	only	RB
5180	890	62	,	,	,
5180	890	63	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	890	64	"	"	''
5180	890	65	;	;	:
5180	890	66	Southern	Southern	NNP
5180	890	67	Alberta	Alberta	NNP
5180	890	68	Fly	Fly	NNP
5180	890	69	Fishing	Fishing	NNP
5180	890	70	Outfitters	Outfitters	NNPS
5180	890	71	,	,	,
5180	890	72	http://albertaflyfish.com	http://albertaflyfish.com	ADD
5180	890	73	,	,	,
5180	890	74	which	which	WDT
5180	890	75	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	890	76	blocked	block	VBD
5180	890	77	as	as	IN
5180	890	78	"	"	``
5180	890	79	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	890	80	"	"	''
5180	890	81	;	;	:
5180	890	82	and	and	CC
5180	890	83	"	"	``
5180	890	84	Nature	Nature	NNP
5180	890	85	and	and	CC
5180	890	86	Culture	Culture	NNP
5180	890	87	Conscious	Conscious	NNP
5180	890	88	Travel	Travel	NNP
5180	890	89	,	,	,
5180	890	90	"	"	''
5180	890	91	a	a	DT
5180	890	92	tour	tour	NN
5180	890	93	operator	operator	NN
5180	890	94	in	in	IN
5180	890	95	Namibia	Namibia	NNP
5180	890	96	,	,	,
5180	890	97	http://www.trans-namibia-tours.com	http://www.trans-namibia-tours.com	NNP
5180	890	98	,	,	,
5180	890	99	which	which	WDT
5180	890	100	was	be	VBD
5180	890	101	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	890	102	as	as	IN
5180	890	103	"	"	``
5180	890	104	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	890	105	"	"	''
5180	890	106	by	by	IN
5180	890	107	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	890	108	.	.	.
5180	891	1	The	the	DT
5180	891	2	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	891	3	programs	program	NNS
5180	891	4	also	also	RB
5180	891	5	miscategorized	miscategorize	VBD
5180	891	6	a	a	DT
5180	891	7	large	large	JJ
5180	891	8	number	number	NN
5180	891	9	of	of	IN
5180	891	10	sports	sport	NNS
5180	891	11	Web	web	NN
5180	891	12	sites	site	NNS
5180	891	13	.	.	.
5180	892	1	These	these	DT
5180	892	2	included	include	VBD
5180	892	3	:	:	:
5180	892	4	a	a	DT
5180	892	5	site	site	NN
5180	892	6	devoted	devote	VBN
5180	892	7	to	to	IN
5180	892	8	Willie	Willie	NNP
5180	892	9	O'Ree	O'Ree	NNP
5180	892	10	,	,	,
5180	892	11	the	the	DT
5180	892	12	first	first	JJ
5180	892	13	African	african	JJ
5180	892	14	-	-	HYPH
5180	892	15	American	american	JJ
5180	892	16	player	player	NN
5180	892	17	in	in	IN
5180	892	18	the	the	DT
5180	892	19	National	National	NNP
5180	892	20	Hockey	Hockey	NNP
5180	892	21	League	League	NNP
5180	892	22	,	,	,
5180	892	23	http://www.missioncreep.com/mw/oree.html	http://www.missioncreep.com/mw/oree.html	NNP
5180	892	24	,	,	,
5180	892	25	which	which	WDT
5180	892	26	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	892	27	blocked	block	VBD
5180	892	28	under	under	IN
5180	892	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	892	30	"	"	``
5180	892	31	Nudity	Nudity	NNP
5180	892	32	"	"	''
5180	892	33	category	category	NN
5180	892	34	;	;	:
5180	892	35	the	the	DT
5180	892	36	home	home	NN
5180	892	37	page	page	NN
5180	892	38	of	of	IN
5180	892	39	the	the	DT
5180	892	40	Sydney	Sydney	NNP
5180	892	41	University	University	NNP
5180	892	42	Australian	Australian	NNP
5180	892	43	Football	Football	NNP
5180	892	44	Club	Club	NNP
5180	892	45	,	,	,
5180	892	46	http://www.tek.com.au/suafc	http://www.tek.com.au/suafc	NN
5180	892	47	,	,	,
5180	892	48	which	which	WDT
5180	892	49	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	892	50	blocked	block	VBD
5180	892	51	as	as	IN
5180	892	52	"	"	``
5180	892	53	Adults	Adults	NNP
5180	892	54	Only	only	RB
5180	892	55	,	,	,
5180	892	56	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	892	57	,	,	,
5180	892	58	"	"	''
5180	892	59	Smartfilter	Smartfilter	NNP
5180	892	60	blocked	block	VBD
5180	892	61	as	as	IN
5180	892	62	"	"	``
5180	892	63	Sex	sex	NN
5180	892	64	,	,	,
5180	892	65	"	"	''
5180	892	66	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	892	67	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	892	68	blocked	block	VBD
5180	892	69	as	as	IN
5180	892	70	"	"	``
5180	892	71	Adult	adult	NN
5180	892	72	/	/	,
5180	892	73	Sexually	sexually	RB
5180	892	74	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	892	75	"	"	''
5180	892	76	and	and	CC
5180	892	77	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	892	78	blocked	block	VBD
5180	892	79	as	as	IN
5180	892	80	"	"	``
5180	892	81	Sex	Sex	NNP
5180	892	82	"	"	''
5180	892	83	;	;	:
5180	892	84	and	and	CC
5180	892	85	a	a	DT
5180	892	86	fan	fan	NN
5180	892	87	's	's	POS
5180	892	88	page	page	NN
5180	892	89	devoted	devote	VBN
5180	892	90	to	to	IN
5180	892	91	the	the	DT
5180	892	92	Toronto	Toronto	NNP
5180	892	93	Maple	Maple	NNP
5180	892	94	Leafs	Leafs	NNP
5180	892	95	hockey	hockey	NN
5180	892	96	team	team	NN
5180	892	97	,	,	,
5180	892	98	http://www.torontomapleleafs.atmypage.com	http://www.torontomapleleafs.atmypage.com	ADD
5180	892	99	,	,	,
5180	892	100	which	which	WDT
5180	892	101	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	892	102	blocked	block	VBD
5180	892	103	under	under	IN
5180	892	104	the	the	DT
5180	892	105	"	"	``
5180	892	106	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	892	107	"	"	''
5180	892	108	category	category	NN
5180	892	109	.	.	.
5180	893	1	7	7	LS
5180	893	2	.	.	.
5180	894	1	Conclusion	conclusion	NN
5180	894	2	:	:	:
5180	894	3	The	the	DT
5180	894	4	Effectiveness	Effectiveness	NNP
5180	894	5	of	of	IN
5180	894	6	Filtering	filter	VBG
5180	894	7	Programs	Programs	NNPS
5180	894	8	Public	public	JJ
5180	894	9	libraries	library	NNS
5180	894	10	have	have	VBP
5180	894	11	adopted	adopt	VBN
5180	894	12	a	a	DT
5180	894	13	variety	variety	NN
5180	894	14	of	of	IN
5180	894	15	means	mean	NNS
5180	894	16	of	of	IN
5180	894	17	dealing	deal	VBG
5180	894	18	with	with	IN
5180	894	19	problems	problem	NNS
5180	894	20	created	create	VBN
5180	894	21	by	by	IN
5180	894	22	the	the	DT
5180	894	23	provision	provision	NN
5180	894	24	of	of	IN
5180	894	25	Internet	internet	NN
5180	894	26	access	access	NN
5180	894	27	.	.	.
5180	895	1	The	the	DT
5180	895	2	large	large	JJ
5180	895	3	amount	amount	NN
5180	895	4	of	of	IN
5180	895	5	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	895	6	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	895	7	speech	speech	NN
5180	895	8	that	that	WDT
5180	895	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	895	10	freely	freely	RB
5180	895	11	available	available	JJ
5180	895	12	on	on	IN
5180	895	13	the	the	DT
5180	895	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	895	15	has	have	VBZ
5180	895	16	,	,	,
5180	895	17	to	to	IN
5180	895	18	varying	vary	VBG
5180	895	19	degrees	degree	NNS
5180	895	20	,	,	,
5180	895	21	led	lead	VBN
5180	895	22	to	to	IN
5180	895	23	patron	patron	NN
5180	895	24	complaints	complaint	NNS
5180	895	25	about	about	IN
5180	895	26	such	such	JJ
5180	895	27	matters	matter	NNS
5180	895	28	as	as	IN
5180	895	29	unsought	unsought	NN
5180	895	30	exposure	exposure	NN
5180	895	31	to	to	IN
5180	895	32	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	895	33	material	material	NN
5180	895	34	,	,	,
5180	895	35	incidents	incident	NNS
5180	895	36	of	of	IN
5180	895	37	staff	staff	NN
5180	895	38	and	and	CC
5180	895	39	patron	patron	NN
5180	895	40	harassment	harassment	NN
5180	895	41	by	by	IN
5180	895	42	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	895	43	viewing	view	VBG
5180	895	44	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	895	45	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	895	46	content	content	NN
5180	895	47	on	on	IN
5180	895	48	the	the	DT
5180	895	49	Internet	internet	NN
5180	895	50	,	,	,
5180	895	51	and	and	CC
5180	895	52	the	the	DT
5180	895	53	use	use	NN
5180	895	54	of	of	IN
5180	895	55	library	library	JJ
5180	895	56	computers	computer	NNS
5180	895	57	to	to	TO
5180	895	58	access	access	VB
5180	895	59	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	895	60	material	material	NN
5180	895	61	,	,	,
5180	895	62	such	such	JJ
5180	895	63	as	as	IN
5180	895	64	child	child	NN
5180	895	65	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	895	66	.	.	.
5180	896	1	In	in	IN
5180	896	2	some	some	DT
5180	896	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	896	4	,	,	,
5180	896	5	youthful	youthful	JJ
5180	896	6	library	library	NN
5180	896	7	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	896	8	have	have	VBP
5180	896	9	persistently	persistently	RB
5180	896	10	attempted	attempt	VBN
5180	896	11	to	to	TO
5180	896	12	use	use	VB
5180	896	13	the	the	DT
5180	896	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	896	15	to	to	TO
5180	896	16	access	access	VB
5180	896	17	hardcore	hardcore	JJ
5180	896	18	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	896	19	.	.	.
5180	897	1	Those	those	DT
5180	897	2	public	public	JJ
5180	897	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	897	4	that	that	WDT
5180	897	5	have	have	VBP
5180	897	6	responded	respond	VBN
5180	897	7	to	to	IN
5180	897	8	these	these	DT
5180	897	9	problems	problem	NNS
5180	897	10	by	by	IN
5180	897	11	using	use	VBG
5180	897	12	software	software	NN
5180	897	13	filters	filter	NNS
5180	897	14	have	have	VBP
5180	897	15	found	find	VBN
5180	897	16	such	such	JJ
5180	897	17	filters	filter	NNS
5180	897	18	to	to	TO
5180	897	19	provide	provide	VB
5180	897	20	a	a	DT
5180	897	21	relatively	relatively	RB
5180	897	22	effective	effective	JJ
5180	897	23	means	mean	NNS
5180	897	24	of	of	IN
5180	897	25	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	897	26	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	897	27	from	from	IN
5180	897	28	accessing	access	VBG
5180	897	29	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	897	30	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	897	31	material	material	NN
5180	897	32	on	on	IN
5180	897	33	the	the	DT
5180	897	34	Internet	internet	NN
5180	897	35	.	.	.
5180	898	1	Nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	898	2	,	,	,
5180	898	3	out	out	IN
5180	898	4	of	of	IN
5180	898	5	the	the	DT
5180	898	6	entire	entire	JJ
5180	898	7	universe	universe	NN
5180	898	8	of	of	IN
5180	898	9	speech	speech	NN
5180	898	10	on	on	IN
5180	898	11	the	the	DT
5180	898	12	Internet	internet	NN
5180	898	13	falling	fall	VBG
5180	898	14	within	within	IN
5180	898	15	the	the	DT
5180	898	16	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	898	17	products	product	NNS
5180	898	18	'	'	POS
5180	898	19	category	category	NN
5180	898	20	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	898	21	,	,	,
5180	898	22	the	the	DT
5180	898	23	filters	filter	NNS
5180	898	24	will	will	MD
5180	898	25	incorrectly	incorrectly	RB
5180	898	26	fail	fail	VB
5180	898	27	to	to	TO
5180	898	28	block	block	VB
5180	898	29	a	a	DT
5180	898	30	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	898	31	amount	amount	NN
5180	898	32	of	of	IN
5180	898	33	speech	speech	NN
5180	898	34	.	.	.
5180	899	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	899	2	,	,	,
5180	899	3	software	software	NN
5180	899	4	filters	filter	NNS
5180	899	5	have	have	VBP
5180	899	6	not	not	RB
5180	899	7	completely	completely	RB
5180	899	8	eliminated	eliminate	VBN
5180	899	9	the	the	DT
5180	899	10	problems	problem	NNS
5180	899	11	that	that	WDT
5180	899	12	public	public	JJ
5180	899	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	899	14	have	have	VBP
5180	899	15	sought	seek	VBN
5180	899	16	to	to	TO
5180	899	17	address	address	VB
5180	899	18	by	by	IN
5180	899	19	using	use	VBG
5180	899	20	the	the	DT
5180	899	21	filters	filter	NNS
5180	899	22	,	,	,
5180	899	23	as	as	IN
5180	899	24	evidenced	evidence	VBN
5180	899	25	by	by	IN
5180	899	26	frequent	frequent	JJ
5180	899	27	instances	instance	NNS
5180	899	28	of	of	IN
5180	899	29	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	899	30	.	.	.
5180	900	1	Nor	nor	CC
5180	900	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	900	3	there	there	EX
5180	900	4	any	any	DT
5180	900	5	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
5180	900	6	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	900	7	of	of	IN
5180	900	8	the	the	DT
5180	900	9	relative	relative	JJ
5180	900	10	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
5180	900	11	of	of	IN
5180	900	12	filters	filter	NNS
5180	900	13	and	and	CC
5180	900	14	the	the	DT
5180	900	15	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	900	16	to	to	IN
5180	900	17	filters	filter	NNS
5180	900	18	that	that	WDT
5180	900	19	are	be	VBP
5180	900	20	also	also	RB
5180	900	21	intended	intend	VBN
5180	900	22	to	to	TO
5180	900	23	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	900	24	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	900	25	from	from	IN
5180	900	26	accessing	access	VBG
5180	900	27	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	900	28	content	content	NN
5180	900	29	on	on	IN
5180	900	30	the	the	DT
5180	900	31	Internet	internet	NN
5180	900	32	.	.	.
5180	901	1	Even	even	RB
5180	901	2	more	more	RBR
5180	901	3	importantly	importantly	RB
5180	901	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	901	5	for	for	IN
5180	901	6	this	this	DT
5180	901	7	case	case	NN
5180	901	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	901	9	,	,	,
5180	901	10	although	although	IN
5180	901	11	software	software	NN
5180	901	12	filters	filter	NNS
5180	901	13	provide	provide	VBP
5180	901	14	a	a	DT
5180	901	15	relatively	relatively	RB
5180	901	16	cheap	cheap	JJ
5180	901	17	and	and	CC
5180	901	18	effective	effective	JJ
5180	901	19	,	,	,
5180	901	20	albeit	albeit	IN
5180	901	21	imperfect	imperfect	NN
5180	901	22	,	,	,
5180	901	23	means	mean	VBZ
5180	901	24	for	for	IN
5180	901	25	public	public	JJ
5180	901	26	libraries	library	NNS
5180	901	27	to	to	TO
5180	901	28	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	901	29	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	901	30	from	from	IN
5180	901	31	accessing	access	VBG
5180	901	32	speech	speech	NN
5180	901	33	that	that	WDT
5180	901	34	falls	fall	VBZ
5180	901	35	within	within	IN
5180	901	36	the	the	DT
5180	901	37	filters	filter	NNS
5180	901	38	'	'	POS
5180	901	39	category	category	NN
5180	901	40	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	901	41	,	,	,
5180	901	42	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	901	43	find	find	VBP
5180	901	44	that	that	IN
5180	901	45	commercially	commercially	RB
5180	901	46	available	available	JJ
5180	901	47	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	901	48	programs	program	NNS
5180	901	49	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	901	50	block	block	VBP
5180	901	51	a	a	DT
5180	901	52	huge	huge	JJ
5180	901	53	amount	amount	NN
5180	901	54	of	of	IN
5180	901	55	speech	speech	NN
5180	901	56	that	that	WDT
5180	901	57	is	be	VBZ
5180	901	58	protected	protect	VBN
5180	901	59	by	by	IN
5180	901	60	the	the	DT
5180	901	61	First	First	NNP
5180	901	62	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	901	63	.	.	.
5180	902	1	Any	any	DT
5180	902	2	currently	currently	RB
5180	902	3	available	available	JJ
5180	902	4	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	902	5	product	product	NN
5180	902	6	that	that	WDT
5180	902	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	902	8	reasonably	reasonably	RB
5180	902	9	effective	effective	JJ
5180	902	10	in	in	IN
5180	902	11	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	902	12	users	user	NNS
5180	902	13	from	from	IN
5180	902	14	accessing	access	VBG
5180	902	15	content	content	NN
5180	902	16	within	within	IN
5180	902	17	the	the	DT
5180	902	18	filter	filter	NN
5180	902	19	's	's	POS
5180	902	20	category	category	NN
5180	902	21	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	902	22	will	will	MD
5180	902	23	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	902	24	block	block	VB
5180	902	25	countless	countless	JJ
5180	902	26	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	902	27	of	of	IN
5180	902	28	Web	web	NN
5180	902	29	pages	page	NNS
5180	902	30	,	,	,
5180	902	31	the	the	DT
5180	902	32	content	content	NN
5180	902	33	of	of	IN
5180	902	34	which	which	WDT
5180	902	35	does	do	VBZ
5180	902	36	not	not	RB
5180	902	37	match	match	VB
5180	902	38	the	the	DT
5180	902	39	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	902	40	company	company	NN
5180	902	41	's	's	POS
5180	902	42	category	category	NN
5180	902	43	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	902	44	,	,	,
5180	902	45	much	much	RB
5180	902	46	less	less	JJR
5180	902	47	the	the	DT
5180	902	48	legal	legal	JJ
5180	902	49	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	902	50	of	of	IN
5180	902	51	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	902	52	,	,	,
5180	902	53	child	child	NN
5180	902	54	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	902	55	,	,	,
5180	902	56	or	or	CC
5180	902	57	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	902	58	to	to	IN
5180	902	59	minors	minor	NNS
5180	902	60	.	.	.
5180	903	1	Even	even	RB
5180	903	2	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	903	3	,	,	,
5180	903	4	an	an	DT
5180	903	5	expert	expert	JJ
5180	903	6	witness	witness	NN
5180	903	7	for	for	IN
5180	903	8	the	the	DT
5180	903	9	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	903	10	,	,	,
5180	903	11	found	find	VBD
5180	903	12	that	that	IN
5180	903	13	between	between	IN
5180	903	14	6	6	CD
5180	903	15	%	%	NN
5180	903	16	and	and	CC
5180	903	17	15	15	CD
5180	903	18	%	%	NN
5180	903	19	of	of	IN
5180	903	20	the	the	DT
5180	903	21	blocked	block	VBN
5180	903	22	Web	web	NN
5180	903	23	sites	site	NNS
5180	903	24	in	in	IN
5180	903	25	the	the	DT
5180	903	26	public	public	JJ
5180	903	27	libraries	library	NNS
5180	903	28	that	that	WDT
5180	903	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	903	30	analyzed	analyze	VBD
5180	903	31	did	do	VBD
5180	903	32	not	not	RB
5180	903	33	contain	contain	VB
5180	903	34	content	content	NN
5180	903	35	that	that	WDT
5180	903	36	meets	meet	VBZ
5180	903	37	even	even	RB
5180	903	38	the	the	DT
5180	903	39	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	903	40	products	product	NNS
5180	903	41	'	'	POS
5180	903	42	own	own	JJ
5180	903	43	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	903	44	of	of	IN
5180	903	45	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	903	46	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	903	47	content	content	NN
5180	903	48	,	,	,
5180	903	49	let	let	VB
5180	903	50	alone	alone	RB
5180	903	51	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	903	52	's	's	POS
5180	903	53	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	903	54	.	.	.
5180	904	1	This	this	DT
5180	904	2	phenomenon	phenomenon	NN
5180	904	3	occurs	occur	VBZ
5180	904	4	for	for	IN
5180	904	5	a	a	DT
5180	904	6	number	number	NN
5180	904	7	of	of	IN
5180	904	8	reasons	reason	NNS
5180	904	9	explicated	explicate	VBN
5180	904	10	in	in	IN
5180	904	11	the	the	DT
5180	904	12	more	more	RBR
5180	904	13	detailed	detailed	JJ
5180	904	14	findings	finding	NNS
5180	904	15	of	of	IN
5180	904	16	fact	fact	NN
5180	904	17	supra	supra	NNP
5180	904	18	.	.	.
5180	905	1	These	these	DT
5180	905	2	include	include	VBP
5180	905	3	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	905	4	on	on	IN
5180	905	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	905	6	companies	company	NNS
5180	905	7	'	'	POS
5180	905	8	ability	ability	NN
5180	905	9	to	to	TO
5180	905	10	:	:	:
5180	905	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	905	12	1	1	LS
5180	905	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	905	14	harvest	harvest	NN
5180	905	15	Web	web	NN
5180	905	16	pages	page	NNS
5180	905	17	for	for	IN
5180	905	18	review	review	NN
5180	905	19	;	;	,
5180	905	20	(	(	-LRB-
5180	905	21	2	2	LS
5180	905	22	)	)	-RRB-
5180	905	23	review	review	VB
5180	905	24	and	and	CC
5180	905	25	categorize	categorize	VB
5180	905	26	the	the	DT
5180	905	27	Web	web	NN
5180	905	28	pages	page	NNS
5180	905	29	that	that	IN
5180	905	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	905	31	have	have	VBP
5180	905	32	harvested	harvest	VBN
5180	905	33	;	;	:
5180	905	34	and	and	CC
5180	905	35	(	(	-LRB-
5180	905	36	3	3	LS
5180	905	37	)	)	-RRB-
5180	905	38	engage	engage	VB
5180	905	39	in	in	IN
5180	905	40	regular	regular	JJ
5180	905	41	re	re	NN
5180	905	42	-	-	NN
5180	905	43	review	review	NN
5180	905	44	of	of	IN
5180	905	45	the	the	DT
5180	905	46	Web	web	NN
5180	905	47	pages	page	NNS
5180	905	48	that	that	IN
5180	905	49	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	905	50	have	have	VBP
5180	905	51	previously	previously	RB
5180	905	52	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	905	53	.	.	.
5180	906	1	The	the	DT
5180	906	2	primary	primary	JJ
5180	906	3	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	906	4	on	on	IN
5180	906	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	906	6	companies	company	NNS
5180	906	7	'	'	POS
5180	906	8	ability	ability	NN
5180	906	9	to	to	TO
5180	906	10	harvest	harvest	VB
5180	906	11	Web	web	NN
5180	906	12	pages	page	NNS
5180	906	13	for	for	IN
5180	906	14	review	review	NN
5180	906	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	906	16	that	that	IN
5180	906	17	a	a	DT
5180	906	18	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	906	19	majority	majority	NN
5180	906	20	of	of	IN
5180	906	21	pages	page	NNS
5180	906	22	on	on	IN
5180	906	23	the	the	DT
5180	906	24	Web	web	NN
5180	906	25	are	be	VBP
5180	906	26	not	not	RB
5180	906	27	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	906	28	using	use	VBG
5180	906	29	the	the	DT
5180	906	30	spidering	spidere	VBG
5180	906	31	technology	technology	NN
5180	906	32	that	that	WDT
5180	906	33	Web	web	NN
5180	906	34	search	search	NN
5180	906	35	engines	engine	NNS
5180	906	36	use	use	VBP
5180	906	37	,	,	,
5180	906	38	and	and	CC
5180	906	39	that	that	IN
5180	906	40	together	together	RB
5180	906	41	,	,	,
5180	906	42	search	search	NN
5180	906	43	engines	engine	NNS
5180	906	44	have	have	VBP
5180	906	45	indexed	index	VBN
5180	906	46	only	only	RB
5180	906	47	around	around	IN
5180	906	48	half	half	NN
5180	906	49	of	of	IN
5180	906	50	the	the	DT
5180	906	51	Web	web	NN
5180	906	52	pages	page	NNS
5180	906	53	that	that	WDT
5180	906	54	are	be	VBP
5180	906	55	theoretically	theoretically	RB
5180	906	56	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	906	57	.	.	.
5180	907	1	The	the	DT
5180	907	2	fast	fast	JJ
5180	907	3	rate	rate	NN
5180	907	4	of	of	IN
5180	907	5	growth	growth	NN
5180	907	6	in	in	IN
5180	907	7	the	the	DT
5180	907	8	number	number	NN
5180	907	9	of	of	IN
5180	907	10	Web	web	NN
5180	907	11	pages	page	NNS
5180	907	12	also	also	RB
5180	907	13	limits	limit	VBZ
5180	907	14	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	907	15	companies	company	NNS
5180	907	16	'	'	POS
5180	907	17	ability	ability	NN
5180	907	18	to	to	TO
5180	907	19	harvest	harvest	VB
5180	907	20	pages	page	NNS
5180	907	21	for	for	IN
5180	907	22	review	review	NN
5180	907	23	.	.	.
5180	908	1	These	these	DT
5180	908	2	shortcomings	shortcoming	NNS
5180	908	3	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	908	4	result	result	VBP
5180	908	5	in	in	IN
5180	908	6	significant	significant	JJ
5180	908	7	underblocking	underblocking	NN
5180	908	8	.	.	.
5180	909	1	Several	several	JJ
5180	909	2	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	909	3	on	on	IN
5180	909	4	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	909	5	companies	company	NNS
5180	909	6	'	'	POS
5180	909	7	ability	ability	NN
5180	909	8	to	to	TO
5180	909	9	review	review	VB
5180	909	10	and	and	CC
5180	909	11	categorize	categorize	VB
5180	909	12	the	the	DT
5180	909	13	Web	web	NN
5180	909	14	pages	page	NNS
5180	909	15	that	that	IN
5180	909	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	909	17	have	have	VBP
5180	909	18	harvested	harvest	VBN
5180	909	19	also	also	RB
5180	909	20	contribute	contribute	VB
5180	909	21	to	to	IN
5180	909	22	over-	over-	NN
5180	909	23	and	and	CC
5180	909	24	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	909	25	.	.	.
5180	910	1	First	first	RB
5180	910	2	,	,	,
5180	910	3	automated	automated	JJ
5180	910	4	review	review	NN
5180	910	5	processes	process	NNS
5180	910	6	,	,	,
5180	910	7	even	even	RB
5180	910	8	those	those	DT
5180	910	9	based	base	VBN
5180	910	10	on	on	IN
5180	910	11	"	"	``
5180	910	12	artificial	artificial	JJ
5180	910	13	intelligence	intelligence	NN
5180	910	14	,	,	,
5180	910	15	"	"	''
5180	910	16	are	be	VBP
5180	910	17	unable	unable	JJ
5180	910	18	with	with	IN
5180	910	19	any	any	DT
5180	910	20	consistency	consistency	NN
5180	910	21	to	to	TO
5180	910	22	distinguish	distinguish	VB
5180	910	23	accurately	accurately	RB
5180	910	24	material	material	NN
5180	910	25	that	that	WDT
5180	910	26	falls	fall	VBZ
5180	910	27	within	within	IN
5180	910	28	a	a	DT
5180	910	29	category	category	NN
5180	910	30	definition	definition	NN
5180	910	31	from	from	IN
5180	910	32	material	material	NN
5180	910	33	that	that	WDT
5180	910	34	does	do	VBZ
5180	910	35	not	not	RB
5180	910	36	.	.	.
5180	911	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	911	2	,	,	,
5180	911	3	human	human	JJ
5180	911	4	review	review	NN
5180	911	5	of	of	IN
5180	911	6	URLs	URLs	NNP
5180	911	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	911	8	hampered	hamper	VBN
5180	911	9	by	by	IN
5180	911	10	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	911	11	companies	company	NNS
5180	911	12	'	'	POS
5180	911	13	limited	limited	JJ
5180	911	14	staff	staff	NN
5180	911	15	sizes	size	NNS
5180	911	16	,	,	,
5180	911	17	and	and	CC
5180	911	18	by	by	IN
5180	911	19	human	human	JJ
5180	911	20	error	error	NN
5180	911	21	or	or	CC
5180	911	22	misjudgment	misjudgment	NN
5180	911	23	.	.	.
5180	912	1	In	in	IN
5180	912	2	order	order	NN
5180	912	3	to	to	TO
5180	912	4	deal	deal	VB
5180	912	5	with	with	IN
5180	912	6	the	the	DT
5180	912	7	vast	vast	JJ
5180	912	8	size	size	NN
5180	912	9	of	of	IN
5180	912	10	the	the	DT
5180	912	11	Web	web	NN
5180	912	12	and	and	CC
5180	912	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	912	14	rapid	rapid	JJ
5180	912	15	rates	rate	NNS
5180	912	16	of	of	IN
5180	912	17	growth	growth	NN
5180	912	18	and	and	CC
5180	912	19	change	change	NN
5180	912	20	,	,	,
5180	912	21	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	912	22	companies	company	NNS
5180	912	23	engage	engage	VBP
5180	912	24	in	in	IN
5180	912	25	several	several	JJ
5180	912	26	practices	practice	NNS
5180	912	27	that	that	WDT
5180	912	28	are	be	VBP
5180	912	29	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	912	30	to	to	TO
5180	912	31	reduce	reduce	VB
5180	912	32	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	912	33	,	,	,
5180	912	34	but	but	CC
5180	912	35	inevitably	inevitably	RB
5180	912	36	result	result	VBP
5180	912	37	in	in	IN
5180	912	38	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	912	39	.	.	.
5180	913	1	These	these	DT
5180	913	2	include	include	VBP
5180	913	3	:	:	:
5180	913	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	913	5	1	1	LS
5180	913	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	913	7	blocking	block	VBG
5180	913	8	whole	whole	JJ
5180	913	9	Web	web	NN
5180	913	10	sites	site	NNS
5180	913	11	even	even	RB
5180	913	12	when	when	WRB
5180	913	13	only	only	RB
5180	913	14	a	a	DT
5180	913	15	small	small	JJ
5180	913	16	minority	minority	NN
5180	913	17	of	of	IN
5180	913	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	913	19	pages	page	NNS
5180	913	20	contain	contain	VBP
5180	913	21	material	material	NN
5180	913	22	that	that	WDT
5180	913	23	would	would	MD
5180	913	24	fit	fit	VB
5180	913	25	under	under	IN
5180	913	26	one	one	CD
5180	913	27	of	of	IN
5180	913	28	the	the	DT
5180	913	29	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	913	30	company	company	NN
5180	913	31	's	's	POS
5180	913	32	categories	category	NNS
5180	913	33	(	(	-LRB-
5180	913	34	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	913	35	,	,	,
5180	913	36	blocking	block	VBG
5180	913	37	the	the	DT
5180	913	38	Salon.com	Salon.com	NNP
5180	913	39	site	site	NN
5180	913	40	because	because	IN
5180	913	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	913	42	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	913	43	a	a	DT
5180	913	44	sex	sex	NN
5180	913	45	column	column	NN
5180	913	46	)	)	-RRB-
5180	913	47	;	;	,
5180	913	48	(	(	-LRB-
5180	913	49	2	2	LS
5180	913	50	)	)	-RRB-
5180	913	51	blocking	block	VBG
5180	913	52	by	by	IN
5180	913	53	IP	IP	NNP
5180	913	54	address	address	NN
5180	913	55	(	(	-LRB-
5180	913	56	because	because	IN
5180	913	57	a	a	DT
5180	913	58	single	single	JJ
5180	913	59	IP	IP	NNP
5180	913	60	address	address	NN
5180	913	61	may	may	MD
5180	913	62	contain	contain	VB
5180	913	63	many	many	JJ
5180	913	64	different	different	JJ
5180	913	65	Web	web	NN
5180	913	66	sites	site	NNS
5180	913	67	and	and	CC
5180	913	68	many	many	JJ
5180	913	69	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	913	70	of	of	IN
5180	913	71	pages	page	NNS
5180	913	72	of	of	IN
5180	913	73	heterogenous	heterogenous	JJ
5180	913	74	content	content	NN
5180	913	75	)	)	-RRB-
5180	913	76	;	;	:
5180	913	77	and	and	CC
5180	913	78	(	(	-LRB-
5180	913	79	3	3	LS
5180	913	80	)	)	-RRB-
5180	913	81	blocking	block	VBG
5180	913	82	loophole	loophole	NN
5180	913	83	sites	site	NNS
5180	913	84	such	such	JJ
5180	913	85	as	as	IN
5180	913	86	translator	translator	NN
5180	913	87	sites	site	NNS
5180	913	88	and	and	CC
5180	913	89	cache	cache	JJ
5180	913	90	sites	site	NNS
5180	913	91	,	,	,
5180	913	92	which	which	WDT
5180	913	93	archive	archive	NN
5180	913	94	Web	web	NN
5180	913	95	pages	page	NNS
5180	913	96	that	that	WDT
5180	913	97	have	have	VBP
5180	913	98	been	be	VBN
5180	913	99	removed	remove	VBN
5180	913	100	from	from	IN
5180	913	101	the	the	DT
5180	913	102	Web	web	NN
5180	913	103	by	by	IN
5180	913	104	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	913	105	original	original	JJ
5180	913	106	publisher	publisher	NN
5180	913	107	.	.	.
5180	914	1	Finally	finally	RB
5180	914	2	,	,	,
5180	914	3	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	914	4	companies	company	NNS
5180	914	5	'	'	POS
5180	914	6	failure	failure	NN
5180	914	7	to	to	TO
5180	914	8	engage	engage	VB
5180	914	9	in	in	IN
5180	914	10	regular	regular	JJ
5180	914	11	re	re	NN
5180	914	12	-	-	NN
5180	914	13	review	review	NN
5180	914	14	of	of	IN
5180	914	15	Web	web	NN
5180	914	16	pages	page	NNS
5180	914	17	that	that	IN
5180	914	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	914	19	have	have	VBP
5180	914	20	already	already	RB
5180	914	21	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	914	22	(	(	-LRB-
5180	914	23	or	or	CC
5180	914	24	that	that	IN
5180	914	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	914	26	have	have	VBP
5180	914	27	determined	determine	VBN
5180	914	28	do	do	VBP
5180	914	29	not	not	RB
5180	914	30	fall	fall	VB
5180	914	31	into	into	IN
5180	914	32	any	any	DT
5180	914	33	category	category	NN
5180	914	34	)	)	-RRB-
5180	914	35	results	result	VBZ
5180	914	36	in	in	IN
5180	914	37	a	a	DT
5180	914	38	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	914	39	amount	amount	NN
5180	914	40	of	of	IN
5180	914	41	over-	over-	NN
5180	914	42	and	and	CC
5180	914	43	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	914	44	.	.	.
5180	915	1	For	for	IN
5180	915	2	example	example	NN
5180	915	3	,	,	,
5180	915	4	Web	web	NN
5180	915	5	publishers	publisher	NNS
5180	915	6	change	change	VBP
5180	915	7	the	the	DT
5180	915	8	contents	content	NNS
5180	915	9	of	of	IN
5180	915	10	Web	web	NN
5180	915	11	pages	page	NNS
5180	915	12	frequently	frequently	RB
5180	915	13	.	.	.
5180	916	1	The	the	DT
5180	916	2	problem	problem	NN
5180	916	3	also	also	RB
5180	916	4	arises	arise	VBZ
5180	916	5	when	when	WRB
5180	916	6	a	a	DT
5180	916	7	Web	web	NN
5180	916	8	site	site	NN
5180	916	9	goes	go	VBZ
5180	916	10	out	out	IN
5180	916	11	of	of	IN
5180	916	12	existence	existence	NN
5180	916	13	and	and	CC
5180	916	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	916	15	domain	domain	NN
5180	916	16	name	name	NN
5180	916	17	or	or	CC
5180	916	18	IP	IP	NNP
5180	916	19	address	address	NN
5180	916	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	916	21	reassigned	reassign	VBN
5180	916	22	to	to	IN
5180	916	23	a	a	DT
5180	916	24	new	new	JJ
5180	916	25	Web	web	NN
5180	916	26	site	site	NN
5180	916	27	publisher	publisher	NN
5180	916	28	.	.	.
5180	917	1	In	in	IN
5180	917	2	that	that	DT
5180	917	3	case	case	NN
5180	917	4	,	,	,
5180	917	5	a	a	DT
5180	917	6	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	917	7	company	company	NN
5180	917	8	's	's	POS
5180	917	9	previous	previous	JJ
5180	917	10	categorization	categorization	NN
5180	917	11	of	of	IN
5180	917	12	the	the	DT
5180	917	13	IP	IP	NNP
5180	917	14	address	address	NN
5180	917	15	or	or	CC
5180	917	16	domain	domain	NN
5180	917	17	name	name	NN
5180	917	18	would	would	MD
5180	917	19	likely	likely	RB
5180	917	20	be	be	VB
5180	917	21	incorrect	incorrect	JJ
5180	917	22	,	,	,
5180	917	23	potentially	potentially	RB
5180	917	24	resulting	result	VBG
5180	917	25	in	in	IN
5180	917	26	the	the	DT
5180	917	27	over-	over-	NN
5180	917	28	or	or	CC
5180	917	29	underblocking	underblocking	NN
5180	917	30	of	of	IN
5180	917	31	many	many	JJ
5180	917	32	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	917	33	of	of	IN
5180	917	34	pages	page	NNS
5180	917	35	.	.	.
5180	918	1	The	the	DT
5180	918	2	inaccuracies	inaccuracy	NNS
5180	918	3	that	that	WDT
5180	918	4	result	result	VBP
5180	918	5	from	from	IN
5180	918	6	these	these	DT
5180	918	7	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	918	8	of	of	IN
5180	918	9	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	918	10	technology	technology	NN
5180	918	11	are	be	VBP
5180	918	12	quite	quite	RB
5180	918	13	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	918	14	.	.	.
5180	919	1	At	at	IN
5180	919	2	least	least	JJS
5180	919	3	tens	ten	NNS
5180	919	4	of	of	IN
5180	919	5	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	919	6	of	of	IN
5180	919	7	pages	page	NNS
5180	919	8	of	of	IN
5180	919	9	the	the	DT
5180	919	10	indexable	indexable	JJ
5180	919	11	Web	web	NN
5180	919	12	are	be	VBP
5180	919	13	overblocked	overblocke	VBN
5180	919	14	by	by	IN
5180	919	15	each	each	DT
5180	919	16	of	of	IN
5180	919	17	the	the	DT
5180	919	18	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	919	19	programs	program	NNS
5180	919	20	evaluated	evaluate	VBN
5180	919	21	by	by	IN
5180	919	22	experts	expert	NNS
5180	919	23	in	in	IN
5180	919	24	this	this	DT
5180	919	25	case	case	NN
5180	919	26	,	,	,
5180	919	27	even	even	RB
5180	919	28	when	when	WRB
5180	919	29	considered	consider	VBN
5180	919	30	against	against	IN
5180	919	31	the	the	DT
5180	919	32	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	919	33	companies	company	NNS
5180	919	34	'	'	POS
5180	919	35	own	own	JJ
5180	919	36	category	category	NN
5180	919	37	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	919	38	.	.	.
5180	920	1	Many	many	JJ
5180	920	2	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	920	3	blocked	block	VBD
5180	920	4	pages	page	NNS
5180	920	5	contain	contain	VBP
5180	920	6	content	content	NN
5180	920	7	that	that	WDT
5180	920	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	920	9	completely	completely	RB
5180	920	10	innocuous	innocuous	JJ
5180	920	11	for	for	IN
5180	920	12	both	both	DT
5180	920	13	adults	adult	NNS
5180	920	14	and	and	CC
5180	920	15	minors	minor	NNS
5180	920	16	,	,	,
5180	920	17	and	and	CC
5180	920	18	that	that	IN
5180	920	19	no	no	DT
5180	920	20	rational	rational	JJ
5180	920	21	person	person	NN
5180	920	22	could	could	MD
5180	920	23	conclude	conclude	VB
5180	920	24	matches	match	NNS
5180	920	25	the	the	DT
5180	920	26	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	920	27	companies	company	NNS
5180	920	28	'	'	POS
5180	920	29	category	category	NN
5180	920	30	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	920	31	,	,	,
5180	920	32	such	such	JJ
5180	920	33	as	as	IN
5180	920	34	"	"	``
5180	920	35	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	920	36	"	"	''
5180	920	37	or	or	CC
5180	920	38	"	"	``
5180	920	39	sex	sex	NN
5180	920	40	.	.	.
5180	920	41	"	"	''
5180	921	1	The	the	DT
5180	921	2	number	number	NN
5180	921	3	of	of	IN
5180	921	4	overblocked	overblocked	JJ
5180	921	5	sites	site	NNS
5180	921	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	921	7	of	of	IN
5180	921	8	course	course	NN
5180	921	9	much	much	RB
5180	921	10	higher	high	JJR
5180	921	11	with	with	IN
5180	921	12	respect	respect	NN
5180	921	13	to	to	IN
5180	921	14	the	the	DT
5180	921	15	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	921	16	of	of	IN
5180	921	17	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	921	18	and	and	CC
5180	921	19	child	child	NN
5180	921	20	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	921	21	that	that	WDT
5180	921	22	CIPA	CIPA	VBD
5180	921	23	employs	employ	NNS
5180	921	24	for	for	IN
5180	921	25	adults	adult	NNS
5180	921	26	,	,	,
5180	921	27	since	since	IN
5180	921	28	the	the	DT
5180	921	29	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	921	30	products	product	NNS
5180	921	31	'	'	POS
5180	921	32	category	category	NN
5180	921	33	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	921	34	,	,	,
5180	921	35	such	such	JJ
5180	921	36	as	as	IN
5180	921	37	"	"	``
5180	921	38	sex	sex	NN
5180	921	39	"	"	''
5180	921	40	and	and	CC
5180	921	41	"	"	``
5180	921	42	nudity	nudity	NN
5180	921	43	,	,	,
5180	921	44	"	"	''
5180	921	45	encompass	encompass	VB
5180	921	46	vast	vast	JJ
5180	921	47	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	921	48	of	of	IN
5180	921	49	Web	web	NN
5180	921	50	pages	page	NNS
5180	921	51	that	that	WDT
5180	921	52	are	be	VBP
5180	921	53	neither	neither	DT
5180	921	54	child	child	NN
5180	921	55	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	921	56	nor	nor	CC
5180	921	57	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	921	58	.	.	.
5180	922	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	922	2	,	,	,
5180	922	3	the	the	DT
5180	922	4	number	number	NN
5180	922	5	of	of	IN
5180	922	6	pages	page	NNS
5180	922	7	of	of	IN
5180	922	8	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	922	9	protected	protect	VBN
5180	922	10	speech	speech	NN
5180	922	11	blocked	block	VBN
5180	922	12	by	by	IN
5180	922	13	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	922	14	products	product	NNS
5180	922	15	far	far	RB
5180	922	16	exceeds	exceed	VBZ
5180	922	17	the	the	DT
5180	922	18	many	many	JJ
5180	922	19	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	922	20	of	of	IN
5180	922	21	pages	page	NNS
5180	922	22	that	that	WDT
5180	922	23	are	be	VBP
5180	922	24	overblocked	overblocke	VBN
5180	922	25	by	by	IN
5180	922	26	reference	reference	NN
5180	922	27	to	to	IN
5180	922	28	the	the	DT
5180	922	29	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	922	30	products	product	NNS
5180	922	31	'	'	POS
5180	922	32	category	category	NN
5180	922	33	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	922	34	.	.	.
5180	923	1	No	no	UH
5180	923	2	presently	presently	RB
5180	923	3	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
5180	923	4	technology	technology	NN
5180	923	5	can	can	MD
5180	923	6	make	make	VB
5180	923	7	the	the	DT
5180	923	8	judgments	judgment	NNS
5180	923	9	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	923	10	to	to	TO
5180	923	11	determine	determine	VB
5180	923	12	whether	whether	IN
5180	923	13	a	a	DT
5180	923	14	visual	visual	JJ
5180	923	15	depiction	depiction	NN
5180	923	16	fits	fit	VBZ
5180	923	17	the	the	DT
5180	923	18	legal	legal	JJ
5180	923	19	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	923	20	of	of	IN
5180	923	21	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	923	22	,	,	,
5180	923	23	child	child	NN
5180	923	24	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	923	25	,	,	,
5180	923	26	or	or	CC
5180	923	27	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	923	28	to	to	IN
5180	923	29	minors	minor	NNS
5180	923	30	.	.	.
5180	924	1	Given	give	VBN
5180	924	2	the	the	DT
5180	924	3	state	state	NN
5180	924	4	of	of	IN
5180	924	5	the	the	DT
5180	924	6	art	art	NN
5180	924	7	in	in	IN
5180	924	8	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	924	9	and	and	CC
5180	924	10	image	image	NN
5180	924	11	recognition	recognition	NN
5180	924	12	technology	technology	NN
5180	924	13	,	,	,
5180	924	14	and	and	CC
5180	924	15	the	the	DT
5180	924	16	rapidly	rapidly	RB
5180	924	17	changing	change	VBG
5180	924	18	and	and	CC
5180	924	19	expanding	expand	VBG
5180	924	20	nature	nature	NN
5180	924	21	of	of	IN
5180	924	22	the	the	DT
5180	924	23	Web	web	NN
5180	924	24	,	,	,
5180	924	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	924	26	find	find	VBP
5180	924	27	that	that	IN
5180	924	28	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	924	29	products	product	NNS
5180	924	30	'	'	POS
5180	924	31	shortcomings	shortcoming	NNS
5180	924	32	will	will	MD
5180	924	33	not	not	RB
5180	924	34	be	be	VB
5180	924	35	solved	solve	VBN
5180	924	36	through	through	IN
5180	924	37	a	a	DT
5180	924	38	technical	technical	JJ
5180	924	39	solution	solution	NN
5180	924	40	in	in	IN
5180	924	41	the	the	DT
5180	924	42	foreseeable	foreseeable	JJ
5180	924	43	future	future	NN
5180	924	44	.	.	.
5180	925	1	In	in	IN
5180	925	2	sum	sum	NN
5180	925	3	,	,	,
5180	925	4	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	925	5	products	product	NNS
5180	925	6	are	be	VBP
5180	925	7	currently	currently	RB
5180	925	8	unable	unable	JJ
5180	925	9	to	to	TO
5180	925	10	block	block	VB
5180	925	11	only	only	RB
5180	925	12	visual	visual	JJ
5180	925	13	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	925	14	that	that	WDT
5180	925	15	are	be	VBP
5180	925	16	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	925	17	,	,	,
5180	925	18	child	child	NN
5180	925	19	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	925	20	,	,	,
5180	925	21	or	or	CC
5180	925	22	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	925	23	to	to	IN
5180	925	24	minors	minor	NNS
5180	925	25	(	(	-LRB-
5180	925	26	or	or	CC
5180	925	27	,	,	,
5180	925	28	only	only	RB
5180	925	29	content	content	NN
5180	925	30	matching	match	VBG
5180	925	31	a	a	DT
5180	925	32	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	925	33	product	product	NN
5180	925	34	's	's	POS
5180	925	35	category	category	NN
5180	925	36	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	925	37	)	)	-RRB-
5180	925	38	while	while	IN
5180	925	39	simultaneously	simultaneously	RB
5180	925	40	allowing	allow	VBG
5180	925	41	access	access	NN
5180	925	42	to	to	IN
5180	925	43	all	all	DT
5180	925	44	protected	protect	VBN
5180	925	45	speech	speech	NN
5180	925	46	(	(	-LRB-
5180	925	47	or	or	CC
5180	925	48	,	,	,
5180	925	49	all	all	DT
5180	925	50	content	content	NN
5180	925	51	not	not	RB
5180	925	52	matching	match	VBG
5180	925	53	the	the	DT
5180	925	54	blocking	block	VBG
5180	925	55	product	product	NN
5180	925	56	's	's	POS
5180	925	57	category	category	NN
5180	925	58	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	925	59	)	)	-RRB-
5180	925	60	.	.	.
5180	926	1	Any	any	DT
5180	926	2	software	software	NN
5180	926	3	filter	filter	NN
5180	926	4	that	that	WDT
5180	926	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	926	6	reasonably	reasonably	RB
5180	926	7	effective	effective	JJ
5180	926	8	in	in	IN
5180	926	9	blocking	block	VBG
5180	926	10	access	access	NN
5180	926	11	to	to	IN
5180	926	12	Web	web	NN
5180	926	13	pages	page	NNS
5180	926	14	that	that	WDT
5180	926	15	fall	fall	VBP
5180	926	16	within	within	IN
5180	926	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	926	18	category	category	NN
5180	926	19	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	926	20	will	will	MD
5180	926	21	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	926	22	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	926	23	block	block	VB
5180	926	24	a	a	DT
5180	926	25	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	926	26	number	number	NN
5180	926	27	of	of	IN
5180	926	28	Web	web	NN
5180	926	29	pages	page	NNS
5180	926	30	that	that	WDT
5180	926	31	do	do	VBP
5180	926	32	not	not	RB
5180	926	33	fall	fall	VB
5180	926	34	within	within	IN
5180	926	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	926	36	category	category	NN
5180	926	37	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	926	38	.	.	.
5180	927	1	2	2	LS
5180	927	2	.	.	.
5180	928	1	Analytic	Analytic	NNP
5180	928	2	Framework	Framework	NNP
5180	928	3	for	for	IN
5180	928	4	the	the	DT
5180	928	5	Opinion	opinion	NN
5180	928	6	:	:	:
5180	928	7	The	the	DT
5180	928	8	Centrality	Centrality	NNP
5180	928	9	of	of	IN
5180	928	10	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	928	11	and	and	CC
5180	928	12	the	the	DT
5180	928	13	Role	role	NN
5180	928	14	of	of	IN
5180	928	15	the	the	DT
5180	928	16	Facial	Facial	NNP
5180	928	17	Challenge	Challenge	NNP
5180	928	18	Both	both	CC
5180	928	19	the	the	DT
5180	928	20	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	928	21	and	and	CC
5180	928	22	the	the	DT
5180	928	23	government	government	NN
5180	928	24	agree	agree	VBP
5180	928	25	that	that	IN
5180	928	26	,	,	,
5180	928	27	because	because	IN
5180	928	28	this	this	DT
5180	928	29	case	case	NN
5180	928	30	involves	involve	VBZ
5180	928	31	a	a	DT
5180	928	32	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	928	33	to	to	IN
5180	928	34	the	the	DT
5180	928	35	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
5180	928	36	of	of	IN
5180	928	37	the	the	DT
5180	928	38	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	928	39	that	that	WDT
5180	928	40	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	928	41	has	have	VBZ
5180	928	42	set	set	VBN
5180	928	43	on	on	IN
5180	928	44	state	state	NN
5180	928	45	actors	actor	NNS
5180	928	46	'	'	POS
5180	928	47	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	928	48	of	of	IN
5180	928	49	federal	federal	JJ
5180	928	50	funds	fund	NNS
5180	928	51	,	,	,
5180	928	52	the	the	DT
5180	928	53	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	928	54	Court	Court	NNP
5180	928	55	's	's	POS
5180	928	56	decision	decision	NN
5180	928	57	in	in	IN
5180	928	58	South	South	NNP
5180	928	59	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
5180	928	60	v.	v.	IN
5180	928	61	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	928	62	,	,	,
5180	928	63	483	483	CD
5180	928	64	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	928	65	203	203	CD
5180	928	66	(	(	-LRB-
5180	928	67	1987	1987	CD
5180	928	68	)	)	-RRB-
5180	928	69	,	,	,
5180	928	70	supplies	supply	VBZ
5180	928	71	the	the	DT
5180	928	72	proper	proper	JJ
5180	928	73	threshold	threshold	NN
5180	928	74	analytic	analytic	JJ
5180	928	75	framework	framework	NN
5180	928	76	.	.	.
5180	929	1	The	the	DT
5180	929	2	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	929	3	source	source	NN
5180	929	4	of	of	IN
5180	929	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	929	6	's	's	POS
5180	929	7	spending	spending	NN
5180	929	8	power	power	NN
5180	929	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	929	10	Article	Article	NNP
5180	929	11	I	I	NNP
5180	929	12	,	,	,
5180	929	13	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	929	14	.	.	.
5180	930	1	8	8	CD
5180	930	2	,	,	,
5180	930	3	cl	cl	IN
5180	930	4	.	.	.
5180	931	1	1	1	CD
5180	931	2	,	,	,
5180	931	3	which	which	WDT
5180	931	4	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	931	5	that	that	IN
5180	931	6	"	"	``
5180	931	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	931	8	shall	shall	MD
5180	931	9	have	have	VB
5180	931	10	Power	power	NN
5180	931	11	.	.	.
5180	932	1	.	.	.
5180	933	1	.	.	.
5180	934	1	to	to	TO
5180	934	2	pay	pay	VB
5180	934	3	the	the	DT
5180	934	4	Debts	debt	NNS
5180	934	5	and	and	CC
5180	934	6	provide	provide	VB
5180	934	7	for	for	IN
5180	934	8	the	the	DT
5180	934	9	common	common	JJ
5180	934	10	Defence	Defence	NNP
5180	934	11	and	and	CC
5180	934	12	general	general	JJ
5180	934	13	Welfare	Welfare	NNP
5180	934	14	of	of	IN
5180	934	15	the	the	DT
5180	934	16	United	United	NNP
5180	934	17	States	States	NNP
5180	934	18	.	.	.
5180	934	19	"	"	''
5180	935	1	In	in	IN
5180	935	2	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	935	3	,	,	,
5180	935	4	the	the	DT
5180	935	5	Court	Court	NNP
5180	935	6	upheld	uphold	VBD
5180	935	7	the	the	DT
5180	935	8	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
5180	935	9	of	of	IN
5180	935	10	a	a	DT
5180	935	11	federal	federal	JJ
5180	935	12	statute	statute	NN
5180	935	13	requiring	require	VBG
5180	935	14	the	the	DT
5180	935	15	withholding	withholding	NN
5180	935	16	of	of	IN
5180	935	17	federal	federal	JJ
5180	935	18	highway	highway	NN
5180	935	19	funds	fund	NNS
5180	935	20	from	from	IN
5180	935	21	any	any	DT
5180	935	22	state	state	NN
5180	935	23	with	with	IN
5180	935	24	a	a	DT
5180	935	25	drinking	drinking	NN
5180	935	26	age	age	NN
5180	935	27	below	below	IN
5180	935	28	21	21	CD
5180	935	29	.	.	.
5180	936	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	937	1	at	at	IN
5180	937	2	211	211	CD
5180	937	3	-	-	SYM
5180	937	4	12	12	CD
5180	937	5	.	.	.
5180	938	1	In	in	IN
5180	938	2	sustaining	sustain	VBG
5180	938	3	the	the	DT
5180	938	4	provision	provision	NN
5180	938	5	's	's	POS
5180	938	6	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
5180	938	7	,	,	,
5180	938	8	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	938	9	articulated	articulate	VBD
5180	938	10	four	four	CD
5180	938	11	general	general	JJ
5180	938	12	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	938	13	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	938	14	on	on	IN
5180	938	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	938	16	's	's	POS
5180	938	17	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	938	18	of	of	IN
5180	938	19	the	the	DT
5180	938	20	spending	spending	NN
5180	938	21	power	power	NN
5180	938	22	.	.	.
5180	939	1	First	first	RB
5180	939	2	,	,	,
5180	939	3	"	"	''
5180	939	4	the	the	DT
5180	939	5	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	939	6	of	of	IN
5180	939	7	the	the	DT
5180	939	8	spending	spending	NN
5180	939	9	power	power	NN
5180	939	10	must	must	MD
5180	939	11	be	be	VB
5180	939	12	in	in	IN
5180	939	13	pursuit	pursuit	NN
5180	939	14	of	of	IN
5180	939	15	'	'	''
5180	939	16	the	the	DT
5180	939	17	general	general	JJ
5180	939	18	welfare	welfare	NN
5180	939	19	.	.	.
5180	939	20	'	'	''
5180	939	21	"	"	''
5180	940	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	941	1	at	at	IN
5180	941	2	207	207	CD
5180	941	3	.	.	.
5180	942	1	Second	second	RB
5180	942	2	,	,	,
5180	942	3	any	any	DT
5180	942	4	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	942	5	that	that	WDT
5180	942	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	942	7	sets	set	VBZ
5180	942	8	on	on	IN
5180	942	9	states	state	NNS
5180	942	10	'	'	POS
5180	942	11	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	942	12	of	of	IN
5180	942	13	federal	federal	JJ
5180	942	14	funds	fund	NNS
5180	942	15	must	must	MD
5180	942	16	be	be	VB
5180	942	17	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
5180	942	18	clear	clear	JJ
5180	942	19	to	to	TO
5180	942	20	enable	enable	VB
5180	942	21	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	942	22	"	"	''
5180	942	23	to	to	TO
5180	942	24	exercise	exercise	VB
5180	942	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	942	26	choice	choice	NN
5180	942	27	knowingly	knowingly	RB
5180	942	28	,	,	,
5180	942	29	cognizant	cognizant	JJ
5180	942	30	of	of	IN
5180	942	31	the	the	DT
5180	942	32	consequences	consequence	NNS
5180	942	33	of	of	IN
5180	942	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	942	35	participation	participation	NN
5180	942	36	.	.	.
5180	942	37	"	"	''
5180	943	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	944	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	944	2	internal	internal	JJ
5180	944	3	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	944	4	marks	mark	NNS
5180	944	5	and	and	CC
5180	944	6	citation	citation	NN
5180	944	7	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	944	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	944	9	.	.	.
5180	945	1	Third	third	JJ
5180	945	2	,	,	,
5180	945	3	the	the	DT
5180	945	4	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	945	5	on	on	IN
5180	945	6	the	the	DT
5180	945	7	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	945	8	of	of	IN
5180	945	9	federal	federal	JJ
5180	945	10	funds	fund	NNS
5180	945	11	must	must	MD
5180	945	12	bear	bear	VB
5180	945	13	some	some	DT
5180	945	14	relation	relation	NN
5180	945	15	to	to	IN
5180	945	16	the	the	DT
5180	945	17	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	945	18	of	of	IN
5180	945	19	the	the	DT
5180	945	20	funding	funding	NN
5180	945	21	program	program	NN
5180	945	22	.	.	.
5180	946	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	947	1	And	and	CC
5180	947	2	finally	finally	RB
5180	947	3	,	,	,
5180	947	4	"	"	``
5180	947	5	other	other	JJ
5180	947	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	947	7	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	947	8	may	may	MD
5180	947	9	provide	provide	VB
5180	947	10	an	an	DT
5180	947	11	independent	independent	JJ
5180	947	12	bar	bar	NN
5180	947	13	to	to	IN
5180	947	14	the	the	DT
5180	947	15	conditional	conditional	JJ
5180	947	16	grant	grant	NN
5180	947	17	of	of	IN
5180	947	18	federal	federal	JJ
5180	947	19	funds	fund	NNS
5180	947	20	.	.	.
5180	947	21	"	"	''
5180	948	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	949	1	at	at	IN
5180	949	2	208	208	CD
5180	949	3	.	.	.
5180	950	1	In	in	IN
5180	950	2	particular	particular	JJ
5180	950	3	,	,	,
5180	950	4	the	the	DT
5180	950	5	spending	spending	NN
5180	950	6	power	power	NN
5180	950	7	"	"	''
5180	950	8	may	may	MD
5180	950	9	not	not	RB
5180	950	10	be	be	VB
5180	950	11	used	use	VBN
5180	950	12	to	to	TO
5180	950	13	induce	induce	VB
5180	950	14	the	the	DT
5180	950	15	States	States	NNPS
5180	950	16	to	to	TO
5180	950	17	engage	engage	VB
5180	950	18	in	in	IN
5180	950	19	activities	activity	NNS
5180	950	20	that	that	WDT
5180	950	21	would	would	MD
5180	950	22	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	950	23	be	be	VB
5180	950	24	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	950	25	.	.	.
5180	951	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	951	2	,	,	,
5180	951	3	for	for	IN
5180	951	4	example	example	NN
5180	951	5	,	,	,
5180	951	6	a	a	DT
5180	951	7	grant	grant	NN
5180	951	8	of	of	IN
5180	951	9	federal	federal	JJ
5180	951	10	funds	fund	NNS
5180	951	11	conditioned	condition	VBN
5180	951	12	on	on	IN
5180	951	13	invidiously	invidiously	RB
5180	951	14	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
5180	951	15	state	state	NN
5180	951	16	action	action	NN
5180	951	17	or	or	CC
5180	951	18	the	the	DT
5180	951	19	infliction	infliction	NN
5180	951	20	of	of	IN
5180	951	21	cruel	cruel	JJ
5180	951	22	and	and	CC
5180	951	23	unusual	unusual	JJ
5180	951	24	punishment	punishment	NN
5180	951	25	would	would	MD
5180	951	26	be	be	VB
5180	951	27	an	an	DT
5180	951	28	illegitimate	illegitimate	JJ
5180	951	29	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	951	30	of	of	IN
5180	951	31	the	the	DT
5180	951	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	951	33	'	'	POS
5180	951	34	broad	broad	JJ
5180	951	35	spending	spending	NN
5180	951	36	power	power	NN
5180	951	37	.	.	.
5180	951	38	"	"	''
5180	952	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	953	1	at	at	IN
5180	953	2	210	210	CD
5180	953	3	.	.	.
5180	954	1	Plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	954	2	do	do	VBP
5180	954	3	not	not	RB
5180	954	4	contend	contend	VB
5180	954	5	that	that	IN
5180	954	6	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	954	7	runs	run	VBZ
5180	954	8	afoul	afoul	RB
5180	954	9	of	of	IN
5180	954	10	the	the	DT
5180	954	11	first	first	JJ
5180	954	12	three	three	CD
5180	954	13	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	954	14	.	.	.
5180	955	1	However	however	RB
5180	955	2	,	,	,
5180	955	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	955	4	do	do	VBP
5180	955	5	allege	allege	VB
5180	955	6	that	that	IN
5180	955	7	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	955	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	955	9	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	955	10	under	under	IN
5180	955	11	the	the	DT
5180	955	12	fourth	fourth	JJ
5180	955	13	prong	prong	NN
5180	955	14	of	of	IN
5180	955	15	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	955	16	because	because	IN
5180	955	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	955	18	will	will	MD
5180	955	19	induce	induce	VB
5180	955	20	public	public	JJ
5180	955	21	libraries	library	NNS
5180	955	22	to	to	TO
5180	955	23	violate	violate	VB
5180	955	24	the	the	DT
5180	955	25	First	First	NNP
5180	955	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	955	27	.	.	.
5180	956	1	Plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	956	2	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	956	3	submit	submit	VBP
5180	956	4	that	that	IN
5180	956	5	the	the	DT
5180	956	6	First	First	NNP
5180	956	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	956	8	"	"	''
5180	956	9	provide[s	provide[s	NNP
5180	956	10	]	]	-RRB-
5180	956	11	an	an	DT
5180	956	12	independent	independent	JJ
5180	956	13	bar	bar	NN
5180	956	14	to	to	IN
5180	956	15	the	the	DT
5180	956	16	conditional	conditional	JJ
5180	956	17	grant	grant	NN
5180	956	18	of	of	IN
5180	956	19	federal	federal	JJ
5180	956	20	funds	fund	NNS
5180	956	21	"	"	``
5180	956	22	created	create	VBN
5180	956	23	by	by	IN
5180	956	24	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	956	25	.	.	.
5180	957	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	958	1	at	at	IN
5180	958	2	208	208	CD
5180	958	3	.	.	.
5180	959	1	More	more	RBR
5180	959	2	specifically	specifically	RB
5180	959	3	,	,	,
5180	959	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	959	5	argue	argue	VBP
5180	959	6	that	that	IN
5180	959	7	by	by	IN
5180	959	8	conditioning	condition	VBG
5180	959	9	public	public	JJ
5180	959	10	libraries	library	NNS
5180	959	11	'	'	POS
5180	959	12	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	959	13	of	of	IN
5180	959	14	federal	federal	JJ
5180	959	15	funds	fund	NNS
5180	959	16	on	on	IN
5180	959	17	the	the	DT
5180	959	18	use	use	NN
5180	959	19	of	of	IN
5180	959	20	software	software	NN
5180	959	21	filters	filter	NNS
5180	959	22	,	,	,
5180	959	23	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	959	24	will	will	MD
5180	959	25	induce	induce	VB
5180	959	26	public	public	JJ
5180	959	27	libraries	library	NNS
5180	959	28	to	to	TO
5180	959	29	violate	violate	VB
5180	959	30	the	the	DT
5180	959	31	First	First	NNP
5180	959	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	959	33	rights	right	NNS
5180	959	34	of	of	IN
5180	959	35	Internet	internet	NN
5180	959	36	content	content	NN
5180	959	37	-	-	HYPH
5180	959	38	providers	provider	NNS
5180	959	39	to	to	TO
5180	959	40	disseminate	disseminate	VB
5180	959	41	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	959	42	protected	protect	VBN
5180	959	43	speech	speech	NN
5180	959	44	to	to	IN
5180	959	45	library	library	NN
5180	959	46	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	959	47	via	via	IN
5180	959	48	the	the	DT
5180	959	49	Internet	internet	NN
5180	959	50	,	,	,
5180	959	51	and	and	CC
5180	959	52	the	the	DT
5180	959	53	correlative	correlative	JJ
5180	959	54	First	First	NNP
5180	959	55	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	959	56	rights	right	NNS
5180	959	57	of	of	IN
5180	959	58	public	public	JJ
5180	959	59	library	library	NN
5180	959	60	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	959	61	to	to	TO
5180	959	62	receive	receive	VB
5180	959	63	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	959	64	protected	protect	VBN
5180	959	65	speech	speech	NN
5180	959	66	on	on	IN
5180	959	67	the	the	DT
5180	959	68	Internet	internet	NN
5180	959	69	.	.	.
5180	960	1	The	the	DT
5180	960	2	government	government	NN
5180	960	3	concedes	concede	VBZ
5180	960	4	that	that	IN
5180	960	5	under	under	IN
5180	960	6	the	the	DT
5180	960	7	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	960	8	framework	framework	NN
5180	960	9	,	,	,
5180	960	10	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	960	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	960	12	facially	facially	RB
5180	960	13	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	960	14	if	if	IN
5180	960	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	960	16	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	960	17	will	will	MD
5180	960	18	induce	induce	VB
5180	960	19	public	public	JJ
5180	960	20	libraries	library	NNS
5180	960	21	to	to	TO
5180	960	22	violate	violate	VB
5180	960	23	the	the	DT
5180	960	24	First	First	NNP
5180	960	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	960	26	.	.	.
5180	961	1	The	the	DT
5180	961	2	government	government	NN
5180	961	3	and	and	CC
5180	961	4	the	the	DT
5180	961	5	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	961	6	disagree	disagree	VBP
5180	961	7	,	,	,
5180	961	8	however	however	RB
5180	961	9	,	,	,
5180	961	10	on	on	IN
5180	961	11	the	the	DT
5180	961	12	meaning	meaning	NN
5180	961	13	of	of	IN
5180	961	14	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	961	15	's	's	POS
5180	961	16	"	"	``
5180	961	17	inducement	inducement	JJ
5180	961	18	"	"	''
5180	961	19	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	961	20	in	in	IN
5180	961	21	the	the	DT
5180	961	22	context	context	NN
5180	961	23	of	of	IN
5180	961	24	a	a	DT
5180	961	25	First	First	NNP
5180	961	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	961	27	facial	facial	JJ
5180	961	28	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	961	29	to	to	IN
5180	961	30	the	the	DT
5180	961	31	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	961	32	that	that	WDT
5180	961	33	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	961	34	places	place	VBZ
5180	961	35	on	on	IN
5180	961	36	state	state	NN
5180	961	37	actors	actor	NNS
5180	961	38	'	'	POS
5180	961	39	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	961	40	of	of	IN
5180	961	41	federal	federal	JJ
5180	961	42	funds	fund	NNS
5180	961	43	.	.	.
5180	962	1	The	the	DT
5180	962	2	government	government	NN
5180	962	3	contends	contend	VBZ
5180	962	4	that	that	IN
5180	962	5	because	because	IN
5180	962	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	962	7	are	be	VBP
5180	962	8	bringing	bring	VBG
5180	962	9	a	a	DT
5180	962	10	facial	facial	JJ
5180	962	11	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	962	12	,	,	,
5180	962	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	962	14	must	must	MD
5180	962	15	show	show	VB
5180	962	16	that	that	IN
5180	962	17	under	under	IN
5180	962	18	no	no	DT
5180	962	19	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
5180	962	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	962	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	962	22	possible	possible	JJ
5180	962	23	for	for	IN
5180	962	24	a	a	DT
5180	962	25	public	public	JJ
5180	962	26	library	library	NN
5180	962	27	to	to	TO
5180	962	28	comply	comply	VB
5180	962	29	with	with	IN
5180	962	30	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	962	31	's	's	POS
5180	962	32	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	962	33	without	without	IN
5180	962	34	violating	violate	VBG
5180	962	35	the	the	DT
5180	962	36	First	First	NNP
5180	962	37	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	962	38	.	.	.
5180	963	1	The	the	DT
5180	963	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	963	3	respond	respond	VBP
5180	963	4	that	that	IN
5180	963	5	even	even	RB
5180	963	6	if	if	IN
5180	963	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	963	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	963	9	possible	possible	JJ
5180	963	10	for	for	IN
5180	963	11	some	some	DT
5180	963	12	public	public	JJ
5180	963	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	963	14	to	to	TO
5180	963	15	comply	comply	VB
5180	963	16	with	with	IN
5180	963	17	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	963	18	without	without	IN
5180	963	19	violating	violate	VBG
5180	963	20	the	the	DT
5180	963	21	First	First	NNP
5180	963	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	963	23	,	,	,
5180	963	24	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	963	25	is	be	VBZ
5180	963	26	facially	facially	RB
5180	963	27	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	963	28	if	if	IN
5180	963	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	963	30	"	"	``
5180	963	31	will	will	MD
5180	963	32	result	result	VB
5180	963	33	in	in	IN
5180	963	34	the	the	DT
5180	963	35	impermissible	impermissible	JJ
5180	963	36	suppression	suppression	NN
5180	963	37	of	of	IN
5180	963	38	a	a	DT
5180	963	39	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	963	40	amount	amount	NN
5180	963	41	of	of	IN
5180	963	42	protected	protect	VBN
5180	963	43	speech	speech	NN
5180	963	44	.	.	.
5180	963	45	"	"	''
5180	964	1	Because	because	IN
5180	964	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	964	3	was	be	VBD
5180	964	4	clear	clear	JJ
5180	964	5	in	in	IN
5180	964	6	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	964	7	that	that	IN
5180	964	8	the	the	DT
5180	964	9	states	state	NNS
5180	964	10	could	could	MD
5180	964	11	comply	comply	VB
5180	964	12	with	with	IN
5180	964	13	the	the	DT
5180	964	14	challenged	challenge	VBN
5180	964	15	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	964	16	that	that	WDT
5180	964	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	964	18	attached	attach	VBD
5180	964	19	to	to	IN
5180	964	20	the	the	DT
5180	964	21	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	964	22	of	of	IN
5180	964	23	federal	federal	JJ
5180	964	24	funds	fund	NNS
5180	964	25	without	without	IN
5180	964	26	violating	violate	VBG
5180	964	27	the	the	DT
5180	964	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
5180	964	29	,	,	,
5180	964	30	the	the	DT
5180	964	31	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	964	32	Court	Court	NNP
5180	964	33	did	do	VBD
5180	964	34	not	not	RB
5180	964	35	have	have	VB
5180	964	36	occasion	occasion	NN
5180	964	37	to	to	TO
5180	964	38	explain	explain	VB
5180	964	39	fully	fully	RB
5180	964	40	what	what	WP
5180	964	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	964	42	means	mean	VBZ
5180	964	43	for	for	IN
5180	964	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	964	45	to	to	TO
5180	964	46	use	use	VB
5180	964	47	the	the	DT
5180	964	48	spending	spending	NN
5180	964	49	power	power	NN
5180	964	50	to	to	TO
5180	964	51	"	"	``
5180	964	52	induce	induce	VB
5180	964	53	[	[	-LRB-
5180	964	54	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	964	55	]	]	-RRB-
5180	964	56	to	to	TO
5180	964	57	engage	engage	VB
5180	964	58	in	in	IN
5180	964	59	activities	activity	NNS
5180	964	60	that	that	WDT
5180	964	61	would	would	MD
5180	964	62	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	964	63	be	be	VB
5180	964	64	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	964	65	.	.	.
5180	964	66	"	"	''
5180	965	1	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	965	2	,	,	,
5180	965	3	483	483	CD
5180	965	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	965	5	at	at	IN
5180	965	6	210	210	CD
5180	965	7	;	;	:
5180	965	8	see	see	VB
5180	965	9	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	965	10	d	d	NN
5180	965	11	.	.	.
5180	966	1	at	at	IN
5180	966	2	211	211	CD
5180	966	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	966	4	"	"	``
5180	966	5	Were	be	VBD
5180	966	6	South	South	NNP
5180	966	7	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
5180	966	8	to	to	TO
5180	966	9	succumb	succumb	VB
5180	966	10	to	to	IN
5180	966	11	the	the	DT
5180	966	12	blandishments	blandishment	NNS
5180	966	13	offered	offer	VBN
5180	966	14	by	by	IN
5180	966	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	966	16	and	and	CC
5180	966	17	raise	raise	VB
5180	966	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	966	19	drinking	drinking	NN
5180	966	20	age	age	NN
5180	966	21	to	to	IN
5180	966	22	21	21	CD
5180	966	23	,	,	,
5180	966	24	the	the	DT
5180	966	25	State	state	NN
5180	966	26	's	's	POS
5180	966	27	action	action	NN
5180	966	28	in	in	IN
5180	966	29	so	so	RB
5180	966	30	doing	do	VBG
5180	966	31	would	would	MD
5180	966	32	not	not	RB
5180	966	33	violate	violate	VB
5180	966	34	the	the	DT
5180	966	35	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	966	36	rights	right	NNS
5180	966	37	of	of	IN
5180	966	38	anyone	anyone	NN
5180	966	39	.	.	.
5180	966	40	"	"	''
5180	966	41	)	)	-RRB-
5180	966	42	.	.	.
5180	967	1	Although	although	IN
5180	967	2	the	the	DT
5180	967	3	proposition	proposition	NN
5180	967	4	that	that	WDT
5180	967	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	967	6	may	may	MD
5180	967	7	not	not	RB
5180	967	8	pay	pay	VB
5180	967	9	state	state	NN
5180	967	10	actors	actor	NNS
5180	967	11	to	to	TO
5180	967	12	violate	violate	VB
5180	967	13	citizens	citizen	NNS
5180	967	14	'	'	POS
5180	967	15	First	First	NNP
5180	967	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	967	17	rights	right	NNS
5180	967	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	967	19	unexceptionable	unexceptionable	JJ
5180	967	20	when	when	WRB
5180	967	21	stated	state	VBN
5180	967	22	in	in	IN
5180	967	23	the	the	DT
5180	967	24	abstract	abstract	NN
5180	967	25	,	,	,
5180	967	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	967	27	is	be	VBZ
5180	967	28	unclear	unclear	JJ
5180	967	29	what	what	WP
5180	967	30	exactly	exactly	RB
5180	967	31	a	a	DT
5180	967	32	litigant	litigant	NN
5180	967	33	must	must	MD
5180	967	34	establish	establish	VB
5180	967	35	to	to	IN
5180	967	36	facially	facially	RB
5180	967	37	invalidate	invalidate	VB
5180	967	38	an	an	DT
5180	967	39	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	967	40	of	of	IN
5180	967	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	967	42	's	's	POS
5180	967	43	spending	spending	NN
5180	967	44	power	power	NN
5180	967	45	on	on	IN
5180	967	46	this	this	DT
5180	967	47	ground	ground	NN
5180	967	48	.	.	.
5180	968	1	In	in	IN
5180	968	2	general	general	JJ
5180	968	3	,	,	,
5180	968	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	968	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	968	6	well	well	RB
5180	968	7	-	-	HYPH
5180	968	8	established	establish	VBN
5180	968	9	that	that	IN
5180	968	10	a	a	DT
5180	968	11	court	court	NN
5180	968	12	may	may	MD
5180	968	13	sustain	sustain	VB
5180	968	14	a	a	DT
5180	968	15	facial	facial	JJ
5180	968	16	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	968	17	to	to	IN
5180	968	18	a	a	DT
5180	968	19	statute	statute	NN
5180	968	20	only	only	RB
5180	968	21	if	if	IN
5180	968	22	the	the	DT
5180	968	23	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
5180	968	24	demonstrates	demonstrate	VBZ
5180	968	25	that	that	IN
5180	968	26	the	the	DT
5180	968	27	statute	statute	NN
5180	968	28	admits	admit	VBZ
5180	968	29	of	of	IN
5180	968	30	no	no	DT
5180	968	31	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	968	32	application	application	NN
5180	968	33	.	.	.
5180	969	1	See	see	VB
5180	969	2	United	United	NNP
5180	969	3	States	States	NNP
5180	969	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	969	5	Salerno	Salerno	NNP
5180	969	6	,	,	,
5180	969	7	481	481	CD
5180	969	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	969	9	739	739	CD
5180	969	10	,	,	,
5180	969	11	745	745	CD
5180	969	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	969	13	1987	1987	CD
5180	969	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	969	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	969	16	"	"	``
5180	969	17	A	a	DT
5180	969	18	facial	facial	JJ
5180	969	19	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	969	20	to	to	IN
5180	969	21	a	a	DT
5180	969	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
5180	969	23	Act	Act	NNP
5180	969	24	is	be	VBZ
5180	969	25	,	,	,
5180	969	26	of	of	IN
5180	969	27	course	course	NN
5180	969	28	,	,	,
5180	969	29	the	the	DT
5180	969	30	most	most	RBS
5180	969	31	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	969	32	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	969	33	to	to	TO
5180	969	34	mount	mount	NNP
5180	969	35	successfully	successfully	RB
5180	969	36	,	,	,
5180	969	37	since	since	IN
5180	969	38	the	the	DT
5180	969	39	challenger	challenger	NN
5180	969	40	must	must	MD
5180	969	41	establish	establish	VB
5180	969	42	that	that	IN
5180	969	43	no	no	DT
5180	969	44	set	set	NN
5180	969	45	of	of	IN
5180	969	46	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
5180	969	47	exists	exist	VBZ
5180	969	48	under	under	IN
5180	969	49	which	which	WDT
5180	969	50	the	the	DT
5180	969	51	Act	Act	NNP
5180	969	52	would	would	MD
5180	969	53	be	be	VB
5180	969	54	valid	valid	JJ
5180	969	55	.	.	.
5180	970	1	")	")	``
5180	970	2	;	;	:
5180	970	3	see	see	VB
5180	970	4	also	also	RB
5180	970	5	Bowen	Bowen	NNP
5180	970	6	v.	v.	IN
5180	970	7	Kendrick	Kendrick	NNP
5180	970	8	,	,	,
5180	970	9	487	487	CD
5180	970	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	970	11	589	589	CD
5180	970	12	,	,	,
5180	970	13	612	612	CD
5180	970	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	970	15	1988	1988	CD
5180	970	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	970	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	970	18	"	"	``
5180	970	19	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	970	20	has	have	VBZ
5180	970	21	not	not	RB
5180	970	22	been	be	VBN
5180	970	23	the	the	DT
5180	970	24	Court	Court	NNP
5180	970	25	's	's	POS
5180	970	26	practice	practice	NN
5180	970	27	,	,	,
5180	970	28	in	in	IN
5180	970	29	considering	consider	VBG
5180	970	30	facial	facial	JJ
5180	970	31	challenges	challenge	NNS
5180	970	32	to	to	IN
5180	970	33	statutes	statute	NNS
5180	970	34	of	of	IN
5180	970	35	this	this	DT
5180	970	36	kind	kind	NN
5180	970	37	,	,	,
5180	970	38	to	to	TO
5180	970	39	strike	strike	VB
5180	970	40	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	970	41	down	down	RP
5180	970	42	in	in	IN
5180	970	43	anticipation	anticipation	NN
5180	970	44	that	that	IN
5180	970	45	particular	particular	JJ
5180	970	46	applications	application	NNS
5180	970	47	may	may	MD
5180	970	48	result	result	VB
5180	970	49	in	in	IN
5180	970	50	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	970	51	use	use	NN
5180	970	52	of	of	IN
5180	970	53	funds	fund	NNS
5180	970	54	.	.	.
5180	970	55	"	"	''
5180	970	56	)	)	-RRB-
5180	971	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	971	2	internal	internal	JJ
5180	971	3	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	971	4	marks	mark	NNS
5180	971	5	and	and	CC
5180	971	6	citation	citation	NN
5180	971	7	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	971	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	971	9	.	.	.
5180	972	1	First	First	NNP
5180	972	2	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	972	3	overbreadth	overbreadth	NN
5180	972	4	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	972	5	creates	create	VBZ
5180	972	6	a	a	DT
5180	972	7	limited	limited	JJ
5180	972	8	exception	exception	NN
5180	972	9	to	to	IN
5180	972	10	this	this	DT
5180	972	11	rule	rule	NN
5180	972	12	by	by	IN
5180	972	13	permitting	permit	VBG
5180	972	14	facial	facial	JJ
5180	972	15	invalidation	invalidation	NN
5180	972	16	of	of	IN
5180	972	17	a	a	DT
5180	972	18	statute	statute	NN
5180	972	19	that	that	WDT
5180	972	20	burdens	burden	VBZ
5180	972	21	a	a	DT
5180	972	22	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	972	23	amount	amount	NN
5180	972	24	of	of	IN
5180	972	25	protected	protect	VBN
5180	972	26	speech	speech	NN
5180	972	27	,	,	,
5180	972	28	even	even	RB
5180	972	29	if	if	IN
5180	972	30	the	the	DT
5180	972	31	statute	statute	NN
5180	972	32	may	may	MD
5180	972	33	be	be	VB
5180	972	34	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	972	35	applied	apply	VBN
5180	972	36	in	in	IN
5180	972	37	particular	particular	JJ
5180	972	38	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
5180	972	39	.	.	.
5180	973	1	"	"	``
5180	973	2	The	the	DT
5180	973	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
5180	973	4	gives	give	VBZ
5180	973	5	significant	significant	JJ
5180	973	6	protection	protection	NN
5180	973	7	from	from	IN
5180	973	8	overbroad	overbroad	NN
5180	973	9	laws	law	NNS
5180	973	10	that	that	WDT
5180	973	11	chill	chill	VBP
5180	973	12	speech	speech	NN
5180	973	13	within	within	IN
5180	973	14	the	the	DT
5180	973	15	First	First	NNP
5180	973	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	973	17	's	's	POS
5180	973	18	vast	vast	JJ
5180	973	19	and	and	CC
5180	973	20	privileged	privileged	JJ
5180	973	21	sphere	sphere	NN
5180	973	22	.	.	.
5180	974	1	Under	under	IN
5180	974	2	this	this	DT
5180	974	3	principle	principle	NN
5180	974	4	,	,	,
5180	974	5	[	[	-LRB-
5180	974	6	a	a	DT
5180	974	7	law	law	NN
5180	974	8	]	]	-RRB-
5180	974	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	974	10	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	974	11	on	on	IN
5180	974	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	974	13	face	face	NN
5180	974	14	if	if	IN
5180	974	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	974	16	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
5180	974	17	a	a	DT
5180	974	18	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	974	19	amount	amount	NN
5180	974	20	of	of	IN
5180	974	21	protected	protect	VBN
5180	974	22	expression	expression	NN
5180	974	23	.	.	.
5180	974	24	"	"	''
5180	975	1	Ashcroft	Ashcroft	NNP
5180	975	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	975	3	Free	Free	NNP
5180	975	4	Speech	Speech	NNP
5180	975	5	Coalition	Coalition	NNP
5180	975	6	,	,	,
5180	975	7	122	122	CD
5180	975	8	S.	S.	NNP
5180	975	9	Ct	Ct	NNP
5180	975	10	.	.	NNP
5180	975	11	1389	1389	CD
5180	975	12	,	,	,
5180	975	13	1399	1399	CD
5180	975	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	975	15	2002	2002	CD
5180	975	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	975	17	;	;	:
5180	975	18	see	see	VB
5180	975	19	also	also	RB
5180	975	20	Broadrick	Broadrick	NNP
5180	975	21	v.	v.	IN
5180	975	22	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
5180	975	23	,	,	,
5180	975	24	413	413	CD
5180	975	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	975	26	601	601	CD
5180	975	27	,	,	,
5180	975	28	612	612	CD
5180	975	29	(	(	-LRB-
5180	975	30	1973	1973	CD
5180	975	31	)	)	-RRB-
5180	975	32	.	.	.
5180	976	1	This	this	DT
5180	976	2	more	more	RBR
5180	976	3	liberal	liberal	JJ
5180	976	4	test	test	NN
5180	976	5	of	of	IN
5180	976	6	a	a	DT
5180	976	7	statute	statute	NN
5180	976	8	's	's	POS
5180	976	9	facial	facial	JJ
5180	976	10	validity	validity	NN
5180	976	11	under	under	IN
5180	976	12	the	the	DT
5180	976	13	First	First	NNP
5180	976	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	976	15	stems	stem	VBZ
5180	976	16	from	from	IN
5180	976	17	the	the	DT
5180	976	18	recognition	recognition	NN
5180	976	19	that	that	IN
5180	976	20	where	where	WRB
5180	976	21	a	a	DT
5180	976	22	statute	statute	NN
5180	976	23	's	's	POS
5180	976	24	reach	reach	NN
5180	976	25	contemplates	contemplate	VBZ
5180	976	26	a	a	DT
5180	976	27	number	number	NN
5180	976	28	of	of	IN
5180	976	29	both	both	CC
5180	976	30	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	976	31	and	and	CC
5180	976	32	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	976	33	applications	application	NNS
5180	976	34	,	,	,
5180	976	35	the	the	DT
5180	976	36	law	law	NN
5180	976	37	's	's	POS
5180	976	38	sanctions	sanction	NNS
5180	976	39	may	may	MD
5180	976	40	deter	deter	VB
5180	976	41	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	976	42	from	from	IN
5180	976	43	challenging	challenge	VBG
5180	976	44	the	the	DT
5180	976	45	law	law	NN
5180	976	46	's	's	POS
5180	976	47	validity	validity	NN
5180	976	48	by	by	IN
5180	976	49	engaging	engage	VBG
5180	976	50	in	in	RB
5180	976	51	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	976	52	protected	protect	VBN
5180	976	53	speech	speech	NN
5180	976	54	that	that	WDT
5180	976	55	may	may	MD
5180	976	56	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	976	57	be	be	VB
5180	976	58	proscribed	proscribe	VBN
5180	976	59	by	by	IN
5180	976	60	the	the	DT
5180	976	61	law	law	NN
5180	976	62	.	.	.
5180	977	1	Without	without	IN
5180	977	2	an	an	DT
5180	977	3	overbreadth	overbreadth	JJ
5180	977	4	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	977	5	,	,	,
5180	977	6	"	"	''
5180	977	7	the	the	DT
5180	977	8	contours	contours	NN
5180	977	9	of	of	IN
5180	977	10	regulation	regulation	NN
5180	977	11	would	would	MD
5180	977	12	have	have	VB
5180	977	13	to	to	TO
5180	977	14	be	be	VB
5180	977	15	hammered	hammer	VBN
5180	977	16	out	out	RP
5180	977	17	case	case	NN
5180	977	18	by	by	IN
5180	977	19	case	case	NN
5180	977	20	–	–	:
5180	977	21	and	and	CC
5180	977	22	tested	test	VBN
5180	977	23	only	only	RB
5180	977	24	by	by	IN
5180	977	25	those	those	DT
5180	977	26	hardy	hardy	JJ
5180	977	27	enough	enough	RB
5180	977	28	to	to	TO
5180	977	29	risk	risk	VB
5180	977	30	criminal	criminal	JJ
5180	977	31	prosecution	prosecution	NN
5180	977	32	to	to	TO
5180	977	33	determine	determine	VB
5180	977	34	the	the	DT
5180	977	35	proper	proper	JJ
5180	977	36	scope	scope	NN
5180	977	37	of	of	IN
5180	977	38	regulation	regulation	NN
5180	977	39	.	.	.
5180	977	40	"	"	''
5180	978	1	Dombrowski	Dombrowski	NNP
5180	978	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	978	3	Pfister	Pfister	NNP
5180	978	4	,	,	,
5180	978	5	380	380	CD
5180	978	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	978	7	479	479	CD
5180	978	8	,	,	,
5180	978	9	487	487	CD
5180	978	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	978	11	1965	1965	CD
5180	978	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	978	13	;	;	:
5180	978	14	see	see	VB
5180	978	15	also	also	RB
5180	978	16	Brockett	Brockett	NNP
5180	978	17	v.	v.	IN
5180	978	18	Spokane	Spokane	NNP
5180	978	19	Arcades	Arcades	NNP
5180	978	20	,	,	,
5180	978	21	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	978	22	,	,	,
5180	978	23	472	472	CD
5180	978	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	978	25	491	491	CD
5180	978	26	,	,	,
5180	978	27	503	503	CD
5180	978	28	(	(	-LRB-
5180	978	29	1985	1985	CD
5180	978	30	)	)	-RRB-
5180	978	31	(	(	-LRB-
5180	978	32	"	"	``
5180	978	33	[	[	-LRB-
5180	978	34	A]n	A]n	NNP
5180	978	35	individual	individual	NN
5180	978	36	whose	whose	WP$
5180	978	37	own	own	JJ
5180	978	38	speech	speech	NN
5180	978	39	or	or	CC
5180	978	40	expressive	expressive	JJ
5180	978	41	conduct	conduct	NN
5180	978	42	may	may	MD
5180	978	43	validly	validly	RB
5180	978	44	be	be	VB
5180	978	45	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
5180	978	46	or	or	CC
5180	978	47	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
5180	978	48	is	be	VBZ
5180	978	49	permitted	permit	VBN
5180	978	50	to	to	TO
5180	978	51	challenge	challenge	VB
5180	978	52	a	a	DT
5180	978	53	statute	statute	NN
5180	978	54	on	on	IN
5180	978	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	978	56	face	face	NN
5180	978	57	because	because	IN
5180	978	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	978	59	also	also	RB
5180	978	60	threatens	threaten	VBZ
5180	978	61	others	other	NNS
5180	978	62	not	not	RB
5180	978	63	before	before	IN
5180	978	64	the	the	DT
5180	978	65	court	court	NN
5180	978	66	–	–	:
5180	978	67	those	those	DT
5180	978	68	who	who	WP
5180	978	69	desire	desire	VBP
5180	978	70	to	to	TO
5180	978	71	engage	engage	VB
5180	978	72	in	in	RP
5180	978	73	legally	legally	RB
5180	978	74	protected	protect	VBN
5180	978	75	expression	expression	NN
5180	978	76	but	but	CC
5180	978	77	who	who	WP
5180	978	78	may	may	MD
5180	978	79	refrain	refrain	VB
5180	978	80	from	from	IN
5180	978	81	doing	do	VBG
5180	978	82	so	so	RB
5180	978	83	rather	rather	RB
5180	978	84	than	than	IN
5180	978	85	risk	risk	NN
5180	978	86	prosecution	prosecution	NN
5180	978	87	or	or	CC
5180	978	88	undertake	undertake	VB
5180	978	89	to	to	TO
5180	978	90	have	have	VB
5180	978	91	the	the	DT
5180	978	92	law	law	NN
5180	978	93	declared	declare	VBN
5180	978	94	partially	partially	RB
5180	978	95	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	978	96	.	.	.
5180	978	97	"	"	''
5180	978	98	)	)	-RRB-
5180	978	99	.	.	.
5180	979	1	Plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	979	2	argue	argue	VBP
5180	979	3	that	that	IN
5180	979	4	the	the	DT
5180	979	5	overbreadth	overbreadth	JJ
5180	979	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	979	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	979	8	applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	979	9	here	here	RB
5180	979	10	,	,	,
5180	979	11	since	since	IN
5180	979	12	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	979	13	"	"	``
5180	979	14	threatens	threaten	VBZ
5180	979	15	to	to	TO
5180	979	16	chill	chill	VB
5180	979	17	free	free	JJ
5180	979	18	speech	speech	NN
5180	979	19	–	–	:
5180	979	20	because	because	IN
5180	979	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	979	22	will	will	MD
5180	979	23	censor	censor	VB
5180	979	24	a	a	DT
5180	979	25	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	979	26	amount	amount	NN
5180	979	27	of	of	IN
5180	979	28	protected	protect	VBN
5180	979	29	speech	speech	NN
5180	979	30	,	,	,
5180	979	31	because	because	IN
5180	979	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	979	33	is	be	VBZ
5180	979	34	vague	vague	JJ
5180	979	35	,	,	,
5180	979	36	and	and	CC
5180	979	37	because	because	IN
5180	979	38	the	the	DT
5180	979	39	law	law	NN
5180	979	40	creates	create	VBZ
5180	979	41	a	a	DT
5180	979	42	prior	prior	JJ
5180	979	43	restraint	restraint	NN
5180	979	44	.	.	.
5180	980	1	.	.	.
5180	981	1	.	.	.
5180	982	1	.	.	.
5180	982	2	"	"	''
5180	983	1	Unlike	unlike	IN
5180	983	2	the	the	DT
5180	983	3	statutes	statute	NNS
5180	983	4	typically	typically	RB
5180	983	5	challenged	challenge	VBN
5180	983	6	as	as	IN
5180	983	7	facially	facially	RB
5180	983	8	overbroad	overbroad	NN
5180	983	9	,	,	,
5180	983	10	however	however	RB
5180	983	11	,	,	,
5180	983	12	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	983	13	does	do	VBZ
5180	983	14	not	not	RB
5180	983	15	impose	impose	VB
5180	983	16	criminal	criminal	JJ
5180	983	17	penalties	penalty	NNS
5180	983	18	on	on	IN
5180	983	19	those	those	DT
5180	983	20	who	who	WP
5180	983	21	violate	violate	VBP
5180	983	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	983	23	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	983	24	.	.	.
5180	984	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	984	2	.	.	.
5180	985	1	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
5180	985	2	of	of	IN
5180	985	3	Speech	Speech	NNP
5180	985	4	Coalition	Coalition	NNP
5180	985	5	,	,	,
5180	985	6	122	122	CD
5180	985	7	S.	S.	NNP
5180	985	8	Ct	Ct	NNP
5180	985	9	.	.	.
5180	985	10	at	at	IN
5180	985	11	1398	1398	CD
5180	985	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	985	13	"	"	``
5180	985	14	With	with	IN
5180	985	15	these	these	DT
5180	985	16	severe	severe	JJ
5180	985	17	penalties	penalty	NNS
5180	985	18	in	in	IN
5180	985	19	force	force	NN
5180	985	20	,	,	,
5180	985	21	few	few	JJ
5180	985	22	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	985	23	movie	movie	NN
5180	985	24	producers	producer	NNS
5180	985	25	or	or	CC
5180	985	26	book	book	NN
5180	985	27	publishers	publisher	NNS
5180	985	28	,	,	,
5180	985	29	or	or	CC
5180	985	30	few	few	JJ
5180	985	31	other	other	JJ
5180	985	32	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	985	33	in	in	IN
5180	985	34	any	any	DT
5180	985	35	capacity	capacity	NN
5180	985	36	,	,	,
5180	985	37	would	would	MD
5180	985	38	risk	risk	VB
5180	985	39	distributing	distribute	VBG
5180	985	40	images	image	NNS
5180	985	41	in	in	IN
5180	985	42	or	or	CC
5180	985	43	near	near	IN
5180	985	44	the	the	DT
5180	985	45	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
5180	985	46	reach	reach	NN
5180	985	47	of	of	IN
5180	985	48	this	this	DT
5180	985	49	law	law	NN
5180	985	50	.	.	.
5180	985	51	"	"	''
5180	985	52	)	)	-RRB-
5180	985	53	.	.	.
5180	986	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	986	2	,	,	,
5180	986	3	the	the	DT
5180	986	4	rationale	rationale	NN
5180	986	5	for	for	IN
5180	986	6	permitting	permit	VBG
5180	986	7	facial	facial	JJ
5180	986	8	challenges	challenge	NNS
5180	986	9	to	to	IN
5180	986	10	laws	law	NNS
5180	986	11	that	that	WDT
5180	986	12	may	may	MD
5180	986	13	be	be	VB
5180	986	14	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	986	15	applied	apply	VBN
5180	986	16	in	in	IN
5180	986	17	some	some	DT
5180	986	18	instances	instance	NNS
5180	986	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	986	20	less	less	RBR
5180	986	21	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	986	22	in	in	IN
5180	986	23	cases	case	NNS
5180	986	24	such	such	JJ
5180	986	25	as	as	IN
5180	986	26	this	this	DT
5180	986	27	,	,	,
5180	986	28	which	which	WDT
5180	986	29	involve	involve	VBP
5180	986	30	challenges	challenge	NNS
5180	986	31	to	to	IN
5180	986	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	986	33	's	's	POS
5180	986	34	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	986	35	of	of	IN
5180	986	36	the	the	DT
5180	986	37	spending	spending	NN
5180	986	38	power	power	NN
5180	986	39	,	,	,
5180	986	40	than	than	IN
5180	986	41	in	in	IN
5180	986	42	challenges	challenge	NNS
5180	986	43	to	to	IN
5180	986	44	criminal	criminal	JJ
5180	986	45	statutes	statute	NNS
5180	986	46	.	.	.
5180	987	1	Nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	987	2	,	,	,
5180	987	3	"	"	``
5180	987	4	even	even	RB
5180	987	5	minor	minor	JJ
5180	987	6	punishments	punishment	NNS
5180	987	7	can	can	MD
5180	987	8	chill	chill	VB
5180	987	9	protected	protect	VBN
5180	987	10	speech	speech	NN
5180	987	11	,	,	,
5180	987	12	"	"	''
5180	987	13	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	987	14	d	d	NNP
5180	987	15	.	.	NNP
5180	987	16	,	,	,
5180	987	17	and	and	CC
5180	987	18	absent	absent	VB
5180	987	19	the	the	DT
5180	987	20	ability	ability	NN
5180	987	21	to	to	TO
5180	987	22	challenge	challenge	VB
5180	987	23	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	987	24	on	on	IN
5180	987	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	987	26	face	face	NN
5180	987	27	,	,	,
5180	987	28	public	public	JJ
5180	987	29	libraries	library	NNS
5180	987	30	that	that	WDT
5180	987	31	depend	depend	VBP
5180	987	32	on	on	IN
5180	987	33	federal	federal	JJ
5180	987	34	funds	fund	NNS
5180	987	35	may	may	MD
5180	987	36	decide	decide	VB
5180	987	37	to	to	TO
5180	987	38	comply	comply	VB
5180	987	39	with	with	IN
5180	987	40	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	987	41	's	's	POS
5180	987	42	terms	term	NNS
5180	987	43	,	,	,
5180	987	44	thereby	thereby	RB
5180	987	45	denying	deny	VBG
5180	987	46	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	987	47	access	access	NN
5180	987	48	to	to	IN
5180	987	49	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	987	50	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	987	51	of	of	IN
5180	987	52	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	987	53	protected	protect	VBN
5180	987	54	speech	speech	NN
5180	987	55	,	,	,
5180	987	56	rather	rather	RB
5180	987	57	than	than	IN
5180	987	58	refusing	refuse	VBG
5180	987	59	to	to	TO
5180	987	60	comply	comply	VB
5180	987	61	with	with	IN
5180	987	62	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	987	63	's	's	POS
5180	987	64	terms	term	NNS
5180	987	65	and	and	CC
5180	987	66	consequently	consequently	RB
5180	987	67	losing	lose	VBG
5180	987	68	the	the	DT
5180	987	69	benefits	benefit	NNS
5180	987	70	of	of	IN
5180	987	71	federal	federal	JJ
5180	987	72	funds	fund	NNS
5180	987	73	.	.	.
5180	988	1	See	see	VB
5180	988	2	47	47	CD
5180	988	3	C.F.R.	C.F.R.	NNS
5180	989	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	989	2	.	.	.
5180	990	1	54.520(e)(1	54.520(e)(1	LS
5180	990	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	990	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	990	4	"	"	``
5180	990	5	A	a	DT
5180	990	6	school	school	NN
5180	990	7	or	or	CC
5180	990	8	library	library	NN
5180	990	9	that	that	WDT
5180	990	10	knowingly	knowingly	RB
5180	990	11	fails	fail	VBZ
5180	990	12	to	to	TO
5180	990	13	ensure	ensure	VB
5180	990	14	the	the	DT
5180	990	15	use	use	NN
5180	990	16	of	of	IN
5180	990	17	computers	computer	NNS
5180	990	18	in	in	IN
5180	990	19	accordance	accordance	NN
5180	990	20	with	with	IN
5180	990	21	the	the	DT
5180	990	22	certifications	certification	NNS
5180	990	23	required	require	VBN
5180	990	24	by	by	IN
5180	990	25	this	this	DT
5180	990	26	section	section	NN
5180	990	27	,	,	,
5180	990	28	must	must	MD
5180	990	29	reimburse	reimburse	VB
5180	990	30	any	any	DT
5180	990	31	funds	fund	NNS
5180	990	32	and	and	CC
5180	990	33	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	990	34	received	receive	VBN
5180	990	35	under	under	IN
5180	990	36	the	the	DT
5180	990	37	federal	federal	JJ
5180	990	38	universal	universal	NNP
5180	990	39	support	support	NNP
5180	990	40	service	service	NN
5180	990	41	support	support	NN
5180	990	42	mechanism	mechanism	NN
5180	990	43	for	for	IN
5180	990	44	schools	school	NNS
5180	990	45	and	and	CC
5180	990	46	libraries	library	NNS
5180	990	47	for	for	IN
5180	990	48	the	the	DT
5180	990	49	period	period	NN
5180	990	50	in	in	IN
5180	990	51	which	which	WDT
5180	990	52	there	there	EX
5180	990	53	was	be	VBD
5180	990	54	noncompliance	noncompliance	NN
5180	990	55	.	.	.
5180	990	56	"	"	''
5180	990	57	)	)	-RRB-
5180	990	58	.	.	.
5180	991	1	Even	even	RB
5180	991	2	in	in	IN
5180	991	3	cases	case	NNS
5180	991	4	where	where	WRB
5180	991	5	the	the	DT
5180	991	6	only	only	JJ
5180	991	7	penalty	penalty	NN
5180	991	8	for	for	IN
5180	991	9	failure	failure	NN
5180	991	10	to	to	TO
5180	991	11	comply	comply	VB
5180	991	12	with	with	IN
5180	991	13	a	a	DT
5180	991	14	statute	statute	NN
5180	991	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	991	16	the	the	DT
5180	991	17	withholding	withholding	NN
5180	991	18	of	of	IN
5180	991	19	federal	federal	JJ
5180	991	20	funds	fund	NNS
5180	991	21	,	,	,
5180	991	22	the	the	DT
5180	991	23	Court	Court	NNP
5180	991	24	has	have	VBZ
5180	991	25	sustained	sustain	VBN
5180	991	26	facial	facial	JJ
5180	991	27	challenges	challenge	NNS
5180	991	28	to	to	IN
5180	991	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	991	30	's	's	POS
5180	991	31	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	991	32	of	of	IN
5180	991	33	the	the	DT
5180	991	34	spending	spending	NN
5180	991	35	power	power	NN
5180	991	36	.	.	.
5180	992	1	See	see	VB
5180	992	2	,	,	,
5180	992	3	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	992	4	,	,	,
5180	992	5	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	992	6	Servs	Servs	NNP
5180	992	7	.	.	.
5180	993	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
5180	993	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	993	3	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	993	4	,	,	,
5180	993	5	531	531	CD
5180	993	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	993	7	533	533	CD
5180	993	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	993	9	2001	2001	CD
5180	993	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	993	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	993	12	declaring	declare	VBG
5180	993	13	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	993	14	on	on	IN
5180	993	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	993	16	face	face	NN
5180	993	17	a	a	DT
5180	993	18	federal	federal	JJ
5180	993	19	statute	statute	NN
5180	993	20	restricting	restrict	VBG
5180	993	21	the	the	DT
5180	993	22	ability	ability	NN
5180	993	23	of	of	IN
5180	993	24	legal	legal	JJ
5180	993	25	services	service	NNS
5180	993	26	providers	provider	NNS
5180	993	27	who	who	WP
5180	993	28	receive	receive	VBP
5180	993	29	federal	federal	JJ
5180	993	30	funds	fund	NNS
5180	993	31	to	to	TO
5180	993	32	engage	engage	VB
5180	993	33	in	in	IN
5180	993	34	activity	activity	NN
5180	993	35	protected	protect	VBN
5180	993	36	by	by	IN
5180	993	37	the	the	DT
5180	993	38	First	First	NNP
5180	993	39	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	993	40	)	)	-RRB-
5180	993	41	.	.	.
5180	994	1	The	the	DT
5180	994	2	Court	Court	NNP
5180	994	3	's	's	POS
5180	994	4	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	994	5	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	994	6	cases	case	NNS
5180	994	7	,	,	,
5180	994	8	such	such	JJ
5180	994	9	as	as	IN
5180	994	10	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	994	11	,	,	,
5180	994	12	are	be	VBP
5180	994	13	not	not	RB
5180	994	14	strictly	strictly	RB
5180	994	15	controlling	control	VBG
5180	994	16	,	,	,
5180	994	17	since	since	IN
5180	994	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	994	19	do	do	VBP
5180	994	20	not	not	RB
5180	994	21	require	require	VB
5180	994	22	a	a	DT
5180	994	23	showing	showing	NN
5180	994	24	that	that	IN
5180	994	25	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	994	26	who	who	WP
5180	994	27	comply	comply	VBP
5180	994	28	with	with	IN
5180	994	29	the	the	DT
5180	994	30	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	994	31	attached	attach	VBN
5180	994	32	to	to	IN
5180	994	33	federal	federal	JJ
5180	994	34	funding	funding	NN
5180	994	35	will	will	MD
5180	994	36	,	,	,
5180	994	37	as	as	IN
5180	994	38	state	state	NN
5180	994	39	actors	actor	NNS
5180	994	40	,	,	,
5180	994	41	violate	violate	VBP
5180	994	42	others	other	NNS
5180	994	43	'	'	POS
5180	994	44	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	994	45	rights	right	NNS
5180	994	46	,	,	,
5180	994	47	as	as	IN
5180	994	48	is	be	VBZ
5180	994	49	the	the	DT
5180	994	50	case	case	NN
5180	994	51	under	under	IN
5180	994	52	the	the	DT
5180	994	53	fourth	fourth	JJ
5180	994	54	prong	prong	NN
5180	994	55	of	of	IN
5180	994	56	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	994	57	.	.	.
5180	995	1	However	however	RB
5180	995	2	,	,	,
5180	995	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	995	4	are	be	VBP
5180	995	5	highly	highly	RB
5180	995	6	instructive	instructive	JJ
5180	995	7	.	.	.
5180	996	1	The	the	DT
5180	996	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	996	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	996	4	's	's	POS
5180	996	5	pronouncements	pronouncement	NNS
5180	996	6	in	in	IN
5180	996	7	the	the	DT
5180	996	8	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	996	9	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	996	10	cases	case	NNS
5180	996	11	on	on	IN
5180	996	12	what	what	WP
5180	996	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	996	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	996	15	for	for	IN
5180	996	16	a	a	DT
5180	996	17	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
5180	996	18	to	to	TO
5180	996	19	mount	mount	VB
5180	996	20	a	a	DT
5180	996	21	successful	successful	JJ
5180	996	22	First	First	NNP
5180	996	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	996	24	facial	facial	JJ
5180	996	25	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	996	26	to	to	IN
5180	996	27	an	an	DT
5180	996	28	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	996	29	of	of	IN
5180	996	30	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	996	31	's	's	POS
5180	996	32	spending	spending	NN
5180	996	33	power	power	NN
5180	996	34	have	have	VBP
5180	996	35	not	not	RB
5180	996	36	produced	produce	VBN
5180	996	37	a	a	DT
5180	996	38	seamless	seamless	NN
5180	996	39	web	web	NN
5180	996	40	.	.	.
5180	997	1	For	for	IN
5180	997	2	example	example	NN
5180	997	3	,	,	,
5180	997	4	in	in	IN
5180	997	5	Rust	Rust	NNP
5180	997	6	v.	v.	IN
5180	997	7	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
5180	997	8	,	,	,
5180	997	9	500	500	CD
5180	997	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	997	11	173	173	CD
5180	997	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	997	13	1991	1991	CD
5180	997	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	997	15	,	,	,
5180	997	16	the	the	DT
5180	997	17	Court	Court	NNP
5180	997	18	rejected	reject	VBD
5180	997	19	a	a	DT
5180	997	20	First	First	NNP
5180	997	21	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	997	22	facial	facial	JJ
5180	997	23	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	997	24	to	to	IN
5180	997	25	federal	federal	JJ
5180	997	26	regulations	regulation	NNS
5180	997	27	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
5180	997	28	federally	federally	RB
5180	997	29	funded	funded	JJ
5180	997	30	healthcare	healthcare	NN
5180	997	31	clinics	clinic	NNS
5180	997	32	from	from	IN
5180	997	33	providing	provide	VBG
5180	997	34	counseling	counseling	NN
5180	997	35	concerning	concern	VBG
5180	997	36	the	the	DT
5180	997	37	use	use	NN
5180	997	38	of	of	IN
5180	997	39	abortion	abortion	NN
5180	997	40	as	as	IN
5180	997	41	a	a	DT
5180	997	42	method	method	NN
5180	997	43	of	of	IN
5180	997	44	family	family	NN
5180	997	45	planning	planning	NN
5180	997	46	,	,	,
5180	997	47	explaining	explain	VBG
5180	997	48	that	that	IN
5180	997	49	:	:	:
5180	997	50	Petitioners	petitioner	NNS
5180	997	51	are	be	VBP
5180	997	52	challenging	challenge	VBG
5180	997	53	the	the	DT
5180	997	54	facial	facial	JJ
5180	997	55	validity	validity	NN
5180	997	56	of	of	IN
5180	997	57	the	the	DT
5180	997	58	regulations	regulation	NNS
5180	997	59	.	.	.
5180	998	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	998	2	,	,	,
5180	998	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	998	4	are	be	VBP
5180	998	5	concerned	concern	VBN
5180	998	6	only	only	RB
5180	998	7	with	with	IN
5180	998	8	the	the	DT
5180	998	9	question	question	NN
5180	998	10	whether	whether	IN
5180	998	11	,	,	,
5180	998	12	on	on	IN
5180	998	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	998	14	face	face	NN
5180	998	15	,	,	,
5180	998	16	the	the	DT
5180	998	17	regulations	regulation	NNS
5180	998	18	are	be	VBP
5180	998	19	both	both	DT
5180	998	20	authorized	authorize	VBN
5180	998	21	by	by	IN
5180	998	22	the	the	DT
5180	998	23	Act	Act	NNP
5180	998	24	and	and	CC
5180	998	25	can	can	MD
5180	998	26	be	be	VB
5180	998	27	construed	construe	VBN
5180	998	28	in	in	IN
5180	998	29	such	such	PDT
5180	998	30	a	a	DT
5180	998	31	manner	manner	NN
5180	998	32	that	that	IN
5180	998	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	998	34	can	can	MD
5180	998	35	be	be	VB
5180	998	36	applied	apply	VBN
5180	998	37	to	to	IN
5180	998	38	a	a	DT
5180	998	39	set	set	NN
5180	998	40	of	of	IN
5180	998	41	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	998	42	without	without	IN
5180	998	43	infringing	infringe	VBG
5180	998	44	upon	upon	IN
5180	998	45	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	998	46	protected	protect	VBN
5180	998	47	rights	right	NNS
5180	998	48	.	.	.
5180	999	1	Petitioners	petitioner	NNS
5180	999	2	face	face	VBP
5180	999	3	a	a	DT
5180	999	4	heavy	heavy	JJ
5180	999	5	burden	burden	NN
5180	999	6	in	in	IN
5180	999	7	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	999	8	to	to	TO
5180	999	9	have	have	VB
5180	999	10	the	the	DT
5180	999	11	regulations	regulation	NNS
5180	999	12	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
5180	999	13	as	as	IN
5180	999	14	facially	facially	RB
5180	999	15	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	999	16	.	.	.
5180	1000	1	.	.	.
5180	1001	1	.	.	.
5180	1002	1	.	.	.
5180	1003	1	The	the	DT
5180	1003	2	fact	fact	NN
5180	1003	3	that	that	IN
5180	1003	4	the	the	DT
5180	1003	5	regulations	regulation	NNS
5180	1003	6	might	may	MD
5180	1003	7	operate	operate	VB
5180	1003	8	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
5180	1003	9	under	under	IN
5180	1003	10	some	some	DT
5180	1003	11	conceivable	conceivable	JJ
5180	1003	12	set	set	NN
5180	1003	13	of	of	IN
5180	1003	14	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
5180	1003	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	1003	16	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
5180	1003	17	to	to	TO
5180	1003	18	render	render	VB
5180	1003	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1003	20	wholly	wholly	RB
5180	1003	21	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1003	22	.	.	.
5180	1004	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1005	1	at	at	IN
5180	1005	2	183	183	CD
5180	1005	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1005	4	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1005	5	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1005	6	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1005	7	,	,	,
5180	1005	8	alterations	alteration	NNS
5180	1005	9	,	,	,
5180	1005	10	and	and	CC
5180	1005	11	citation	citation	NN
5180	1005	12	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1005	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1005	14	.	.	.
5180	1006	1	In	in	IN
5180	1006	2	contrast	contrast	NN
5180	1006	3	,	,	,
5180	1006	4	NEA	NEA	NNP
5180	1006	5	v.	v.	IN
5180	1006	6	Finley	Finley	NNP
5180	1006	7	,	,	,
5180	1006	8	524	524	CD
5180	1006	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1006	10	569	569	CD
5180	1006	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1006	12	1998	1998	CD
5180	1006	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1006	14	,	,	,
5180	1006	15	which	which	WDT
5180	1006	16	also	also	RB
5180	1006	17	involved	involve	VBD
5180	1006	18	a	a	DT
5180	1006	19	facial	facial	JJ
5180	1006	20	First	First	NNP
5180	1006	21	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1006	22	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	1006	23	to	to	IN
5180	1006	24	an	an	DT
5180	1006	25	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	1006	26	of	of	IN
5180	1006	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1006	28	's	's	POS
5180	1006	29	spending	spending	NN
5180	1006	30	power	power	NN
5180	1006	31	,	,	,
5180	1006	32	articulated	articulate	VBD
5180	1006	33	a	a	DT
5180	1006	34	somewhat	somewhat	RB
5180	1006	35	more	more	RBR
5180	1006	36	liberal	liberal	JJ
5180	1006	37	test	test	NN
5180	1006	38	of	of	IN
5180	1006	39	facial	facial	JJ
5180	1006	40	validity	validity	NN
5180	1006	41	than	than	IN
5180	1006	42	Rust	Rust	NNP
5180	1006	43	,	,	,
5180	1006	44	explaining	explain	VBG
5180	1006	45	that	that	IN
5180	1006	46	"	"	``
5180	1006	47	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1006	48	t]o	t]o	NN
5180	1006	49	prevail	prevail	NN
5180	1006	50	,	,	,
5180	1006	51	respondents	respondent	NNS
5180	1006	52	must	must	MD
5180	1006	53	demonstrate	demonstrate	VB
5180	1006	54	a	a	DT
5180	1006	55	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1006	56	risk	risk	NN
5180	1006	57	that	that	IN
5180	1006	58	application	application	NN
5180	1006	59	of	of	IN
5180	1006	60	the	the	DT
5180	1006	61	provision	provision	NN
5180	1006	62	will	will	MD
5180	1006	63	lead	lead	VB
5180	1006	64	to	to	IN
5180	1006	65	the	the	DT
5180	1006	66	suppression	suppression	NN
5180	1006	67	of	of	IN
5180	1006	68	speech	speech	NN
5180	1006	69	.	.	.
5180	1006	70	"	"	''
5180	1007	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1008	1	at	at	IN
5180	1008	2	580	580	CD
5180	1008	3	.	.	.
5180	1009	1	Against	against	IN
5180	1009	2	this	this	DT
5180	1009	3	background	background	NN
5180	1009	4	,	,	,
5180	1009	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1009	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	1009	7	unclear	unclear	JJ
5180	1009	8	to	to	IN
5180	1009	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1009	10	whether	whether	IN
5180	1009	11	,	,	,
5180	1009	12	to	to	TO
5180	1009	13	succeed	succeed	VB
5180	1009	14	in	in	IN
5180	1009	15	facially	facially	RB
5180	1009	16	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
5180	1009	17	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	1009	18	on	on	IN
5180	1009	19	the	the	DT
5180	1009	20	grounds	ground	NNS
5180	1009	21	that	that	IN
5180	1009	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1009	23	will	will	MD
5180	1009	24	"	"	``
5180	1009	25	induce	induce	VB
5180	1009	26	the	the	DT
5180	1009	27	States	States	NNPS
5180	1009	28	to	to	TO
5180	1009	29	engage	engage	VB
5180	1009	30	in	in	IN
5180	1009	31	activities	activity	NNS
5180	1009	32	that	that	WDT
5180	1009	33	would	would	MD
5180	1009	34	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1009	35	be	be	VB
5180	1009	36	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	1009	37	,	,	,
5180	1009	38	"	"	''
5180	1009	39	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	1009	40	,	,	,
5180	1009	41	483	483	CD
5180	1009	42	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1009	43	at	at	IN
5180	1009	44	210	210	CD
5180	1009	45	,	,	,
5180	1009	46	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1009	47	must	must	MD
5180	1009	48	show	show	VB
5180	1009	49	that	that	IN
5180	1009	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1009	51	is	be	VBZ
5180	1009	52	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	1009	53	for	for	IN
5180	1009	54	public	public	JJ
5180	1009	55	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1009	56	to	to	TO
5180	1009	57	comply	comply	VB
5180	1009	58	with	with	IN
5180	1009	59	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1009	60	's	's	POS
5180	1009	61	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	1009	62	without	without	IN
5180	1009	63	violating	violate	VBG
5180	1009	64	the	the	DT
5180	1009	65	First	First	NNP
5180	1009	66	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1009	67	,	,	,
5180	1009	68	or	or	CC
5180	1009	69	rather	rather	RB
5180	1009	70	simply	simply	RB
5180	1009	71	that	that	IN
5180	1009	72	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1009	73	will	will	MD
5180	1009	74	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	1009	75	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	1009	76	library	library	NN
5180	1009	77	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1009	78	'	'	POS
5180	1009	79	access	access	NN
5180	1009	80	to	to	IN
5180	1009	81	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1009	82	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	1009	83	of	of	IN
5180	1009	84	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1009	85	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1009	86	speech	speech	NN
5180	1009	87	,	,	,
5180	1009	88	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1009	89	causing	cause	VBG
5180	1009	90	many	many	JJ
5180	1009	91	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1009	92	to	to	TO
5180	1009	93	violate	violate	VB
5180	1009	94	the	the	DT
5180	1009	95	First	First	NNP
5180	1009	96	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1009	97	.	.	.
5180	1010	1	However	however	RB
5180	1010	2	,	,	,
5180	1010	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1010	4	need	need	VBP
5180	1010	5	not	not	RB
5180	1010	6	resolve	resolve	VB
5180	1010	7	this	this	DT
5180	1010	8	issue	issue	NN
5180	1010	9	.	.	.
5180	1011	1	Rather	rather	RB
5180	1011	2	,	,	,
5180	1011	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1011	4	may	may	MD
5180	1011	5	assume	assume	VB
5180	1011	6	without	without	IN
5180	1011	7	deciding	decide	VBG
5180	1011	8	,	,	,
5180	1011	9	for	for	IN
5180	1011	10	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1011	11	of	of	IN
5180	1011	12	this	this	DT
5180	1011	13	case	case	NN
5180	1011	14	,	,	,
5180	1011	15	that	that	IN
5180	1011	16	a	a	DT
5180	1011	17	facial	facial	JJ
5180	1011	18	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	1011	19	to	to	IN
5180	1011	20	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1011	21	requires	require	VBZ
5180	1011	22	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1011	23	to	to	TO
5180	1011	24	show	show	VB
5180	1011	25	that	that	IN
5180	1011	26	any	any	DT
5180	1011	27	public	public	JJ
5180	1011	28	library	library	NN
5180	1011	29	that	that	WDT
5180	1011	30	complies	comply	VBZ
5180	1011	31	with	with	IN
5180	1011	32	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1011	33	's	's	POS
5180	1011	34	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	1011	35	will	will	MD
5180	1011	36	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	1011	37	violate	violate	VB
5180	1011	38	the	the	DT
5180	1011	39	First	First	NNP
5180	1011	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1011	41	and	and	CC
5180	1011	42	,	,	,
5180	1011	43	as	as	IN
5180	1011	44	explained	explain	VBN
5180	1011	45	in	in	IN
5180	1011	46	detail	detail	NN
5180	1011	47	below	below	RB
5180	1011	48	,	,	,
5180	1011	49	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1011	50	believe	believe	VBP
5180	1011	51	that	that	IN
5180	1011	52	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1011	53	's	's	POS
5180	1011	54	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
5180	1011	55	fails	fail	VBZ
5180	1011	56	even	even	RB
5180	1011	57	under	under	IN
5180	1011	58	this	this	DT
5180	1011	59	more	more	RBR
5180	1011	60	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1011	61	test	test	NN
5180	1011	62	of	of	IN
5180	1011	63	facial	facial	JJ
5180	1011	64	validity	validity	NN
5180	1011	65	urged	urge	VBD
5180	1011	66	on	on	IN
5180	1011	67	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1011	68	by	by	IN
5180	1011	69	the	the	DT
5180	1011	70	government	government	NN
5180	1011	71	.	.	.
5180	1012	1	Because	because	IN
5180	1012	2	of	of	IN
5180	1012	3	the	the	DT
5180	1012	4	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	1012	5	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	1012	6	in	in	IN
5180	1012	7	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1012	8	technology	technology	NN
5180	1012	9	,	,	,
5180	1012	10	public	public	JJ
5180	1012	11	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1012	12	can	can	MD
5180	1012	13	never	never	RB
5180	1012	14	comply	comply	VB
5180	1012	15	with	with	IN
5180	1012	16	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1012	17	without	without	IN
5180	1012	18	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1012	19	access	access	NN
5180	1012	20	to	to	IN
5180	1012	21	a	a	DT
5180	1012	22	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1012	23	amount	amount	NN
5180	1012	24	of	of	IN
5180	1012	25	speech	speech	NN
5180	1012	26	that	that	WDT
5180	1012	27	is	be	VBZ
5180	1012	28	both	both	DT
5180	1012	29	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1012	30	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1012	31	and	and	CC
5180	1012	32	fails	fail	VBZ
5180	1012	33	to	to	TO
5180	1012	34	meet	meet	VB
5180	1012	35	even	even	RB
5180	1012	36	the	the	DT
5180	1012	37	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1012	38	companies	company	NNS
5180	1012	39	'	'	POS
5180	1012	40	own	own	JJ
5180	1012	41	blocking	blocking	NN
5180	1012	42	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	1012	43	.	.	.
5180	1013	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1013	2	turn	turn	VBP
5180	1013	3	first	first	RB
5180	1013	4	to	to	IN
5180	1013	5	the	the	DT
5180	1013	6	governing	govern	VBG
5180	1013	7	legal	legal	JJ
5180	1013	8	principles	principle	NNS
5180	1013	9	to	to	TO
5180	1013	10	be	be	VB
5180	1013	11	applied	apply	VBN
5180	1013	12	to	to	IN
5180	1013	13	the	the	DT
5180	1013	14	facts	fact	NNS
5180	1013	15	in	in	IN
5180	1013	16	order	order	NN
5180	1013	17	to	to	TO
5180	1013	18	determine	determine	VB
5180	1013	19	whether	whether	IN
5180	1013	20	the	the	DT
5180	1013	21	First	First	NNP
5180	1013	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1013	23	permits	permit	VBZ
5180	1013	24	a	a	DT
5180	1013	25	library	library	NN
5180	1013	26	to	to	TO
5180	1013	27	use	use	VB
5180	1013	28	the	the	DT
5180	1013	29	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1013	30	technology	technology	NN
5180	1013	31	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	1013	32	by	by	IN
5180	1013	33	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1013	34	.	.	.
5180	1014	1	3	3	LS
5180	1014	2	.	.	.
5180	1015	1	Level	level	NN
5180	1015	2	of	of	IN
5180	1015	3	Scrutiny	Scrutiny	NNP
5180	1015	4	Applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	1015	5	to	to	IN
5180	1015	6	Content	content	NN
5180	1015	7	-	-	HYPH
5180	1015	8	based	base	VBN
5180	1015	9	Restrictions	Restrictions	NNPS
5180	1015	10	on	on	IN
5180	1015	11	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	1015	12	Access	Access	NNP
5180	1015	13	in	in	IN
5180	1015	14	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1015	15	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	1015	16	In	in	IN
5180	1015	17	analyzing	analyze	VBG
5180	1015	18	the	the	DT
5180	1015	19	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
5180	1015	20	of	of	IN
5180	1015	21	a	a	DT
5180	1015	22	public	public	JJ
5180	1015	23	library	library	NN
5180	1015	24	's	's	POS
5180	1015	25	use	use	NN
5180	1015	26	of	of	IN
5180	1015	27	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1015	28	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1015	29	software	software	NN
5180	1015	30	,	,	,
5180	1015	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1015	32	must	must	MD
5180	1015	33	first	first	RB
5180	1015	34	identify	identify	VB
5180	1015	35	the	the	DT
5180	1015	36	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1015	37	level	level	NN
5180	1015	38	of	of	IN
5180	1015	39	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1015	40	to	to	TO
5180	1015	41	apply	apply	VB
5180	1015	42	to	to	IN
5180	1015	43	this	this	DT
5180	1015	44	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1015	45	on	on	IN
5180	1015	46	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1015	47	'	'	POS
5180	1015	48	access	access	NN
5180	1015	49	to	to	IN
5180	1015	50	speech	speech	NN
5180	1015	51	.	.	.
5180	1016	1	While	while	IN
5180	1016	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1016	3	argue	argue	VBP
5180	1016	4	that	that	IN
5180	1016	5	a	a	DT
5180	1016	6	public	public	JJ
5180	1016	7	library	library	NN
5180	1016	8	's	's	POS
5180	1016	9	use	use	NN
5180	1016	10	of	of	IN
5180	1016	11	such	such	JJ
5180	1016	12	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1016	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	1016	14	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1016	15	to	to	IN
5180	1016	16	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1016	17	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1016	18	,	,	,
5180	1016	19	the	the	DT
5180	1016	20	government	government	NN
5180	1016	21	maintains	maintain	VBZ
5180	1016	22	that	that	IN
5180	1016	23	the	the	DT
5180	1016	24	applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	1016	25	standard	standard	NN
5180	1016	26	is	be	VBZ
5180	1016	27	rational	rational	JJ
5180	1016	28	basis	basis	NN
5180	1016	29	review	review	NN
5180	1016	30	.	.	.
5180	1017	1	If	if	IN
5180	1017	2	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1017	3	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1017	4	applies	apply	VBZ
5180	1017	5	,	,	,
5180	1017	6	the	the	DT
5180	1017	7	government	government	NN
5180	1017	8	must	must	MD
5180	1017	9	show	show	VB
5180	1017	10	that	that	IN
5180	1017	11	the	the	DT
5180	1017	12	challenged	challenge	VBN
5180	1017	13	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1017	14	on	on	IN
5180	1017	15	speech	speech	NN
5180	1017	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	1017	17	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1017	18	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1017	19	to	to	TO
5180	1017	20	promote	promote	VB
5180	1017	21	a	a	DT
5180	1017	22	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1017	23	government	government	NN
5180	1017	24	interest	interest	NN
5180	1017	25	and	and	CC
5180	1017	26	that	that	IN
5180	1017	27	no	no	DT
5180	1017	28	less	less	RBR
5180	1017	29	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1017	30	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1017	31	would	would	MD
5180	1017	32	further	further	RB
5180	1017	33	that	that	DT
5180	1017	34	interest	interest	NN
5180	1017	35	.	.	.
5180	1018	1	United	United	NNP
5180	1018	2	States	States	NNP
5180	1018	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1018	4	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1018	5	Entm't	Entm't	NNP
5180	1018	6	Group	Group	NNP
5180	1018	7	,	,	,
5180	1018	8	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1018	9	,	,	,
5180	1018	10	529	529	CD
5180	1018	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1018	12	803	803	CD
5180	1018	13	,	,	,
5180	1018	14	813	813	CD
5180	1018	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1018	16	2000	2000	CD
5180	1018	17	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1018	18	.	.	.
5180	1019	1	In	in	IN
5180	1019	2	contrast	contrast	NN
5180	1019	3	,	,	,
5180	1019	4	under	under	IN
5180	1019	5	rational	rational	JJ
5180	1019	6	basis	basis	NN
5180	1019	7	review	review	NN
5180	1019	8	,	,	,
5180	1019	9	the	the	DT
5180	1019	10	challenged	challenge	VBN
5180	1019	11	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1019	12	need	nee	MD
5180	1019	13	only	only	RB
5180	1019	14	be	be	VB
5180	1019	15	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
5180	1019	16	;	;	:
5180	1019	17	the	the	DT
5180	1019	18	government	government	NN
5180	1019	19	interest	interest	NN
5180	1019	20	that	that	IN
5180	1019	21	the	the	DT
5180	1019	22	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1019	23	serves	serve	VBZ
5180	1019	24	need	nee	MD
5180	1019	25	not	not	RB
5180	1019	26	be	be	VB
5180	1019	27	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1019	28	;	;	:
5180	1019	29	the	the	DT
5180	1019	30	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1019	31	need	nee	MD
5180	1019	32	not	not	RB
5180	1019	33	be	be	VB
5180	1019	34	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1019	35	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1019	36	to	to	TO
5180	1019	37	serve	serve	VB
5180	1019	38	that	that	DT
5180	1019	39	interest	interest	NN
5180	1019	40	;	;	:
5180	1019	41	and	and	CC
5180	1019	42	the	the	DT
5180	1019	43	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1019	44	"	"	``
5180	1019	45	need	nee	MD
5180	1019	46	not	not	RB
5180	1019	47	be	be	VB
5180	1019	48	the	the	DT
5180	1019	49	most	most	RBS
5180	1019	50	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
5180	1019	51	or	or	CC
5180	1019	52	the	the	DT
5180	1019	53	only	only	JJ
5180	1019	54	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
5180	1019	55	limitation	limitation	NN
5180	1019	56	.	.	.
5180	1019	57	"	"	''
5180	1020	1	Cornelius	Cornelius	NNP
5180	1020	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	1020	3	NAACP	NAACP	NNP
5180	1020	4	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	1020	5	Def	Def	NNP
5180	1020	6	.	.	.
5180	1021	1	&	&	CC
5180	1021	2	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	1021	3	.	.	.
5180	1022	1	Fund	Fund	NNP
5180	1022	2	,	,	,
5180	1022	3	473	473	CD
5180	1022	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1022	5	788	788	CD
5180	1022	6	,	,	,
5180	1022	7	808	808	CD
5180	1022	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1022	9	1985	1985	CD
5180	1022	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1022	11	.	.	.
5180	1023	1	Software	software	NN
5180	1023	2	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1023	3	,	,	,
5180	1023	4	by	by	IN
5180	1023	5	definition	definition	NN
5180	1023	6	,	,	,
5180	1023	7	block	block	NN
5180	1023	8	access	access	NN
5180	1023	9	to	to	IN
5180	1023	10	speech	speech	NN
5180	1023	11	on	on	IN
5180	1023	12	the	the	DT
5180	1023	13	basis	basis	NN
5180	1023	14	of	of	IN
5180	1023	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1023	16	content	content	NN
5180	1023	17	,	,	,
5180	1023	18	and	and	CC
5180	1023	19	content	content	NN
5180	1023	20	-	-	HYPH
5180	1023	21	based	base	VBN
5180	1023	22	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1023	23	on	on	IN
5180	1023	24	speech	speech	NN
5180	1023	25	are	be	VBP
5180	1023	26	generally	generally	RB
5180	1023	27	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1023	28	to	to	IN
5180	1023	29	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1023	30	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1023	31	.	.	.
5180	1024	1	See	see	VB
5180	1024	2	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1024	3	,	,	,
5180	1024	4	529	529	CD
5180	1024	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1024	6	at	at	IN
5180	1024	7	813	813	CD
5180	1024	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1024	9	"	"	``
5180	1024	10	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1024	11	A	a	NN
5180	1024	12	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1024	13	content	content	NN
5180	1024	14	-	-	HYPH
5180	1024	15	based	base	VBN
5180	1024	16	speech	speech	NN
5180	1024	17	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1024	18	.	.	.
5180	1025	1	.	.	.
5180	1026	1	.	.	.
5180	1027	1	can	can	MD
5180	1027	2	stand	stand	VB
5180	1027	3	only	only	RB
5180	1027	4	if	if	IN
5180	1027	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1027	6	satisfies	satisfy	VBZ
5180	1027	7	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1027	8	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1027	9	.	.	.
5180	1027	10	"	"	''
5180	1027	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1027	12	.	.	.
5180	1028	1	Strict	strict	JJ
5180	1028	2	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1028	3	does	do	VBZ
5180	1028	4	not	not	RB
5180	1028	5	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	1028	6	apply	apply	VB
5180	1028	7	to	to	IN
5180	1028	8	content	content	NN
5180	1028	9	-	-	HYPH
5180	1028	10	based	base	VBN
5180	1028	11	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1028	12	on	on	IN
5180	1028	13	speech	speech	NN
5180	1028	14	,	,	,
5180	1028	15	however	however	RB
5180	1028	16	,	,	,
5180	1028	17	where	where	WRB
5180	1028	18	the	the	DT
5180	1028	19	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1028	20	apply	apply	VBP
5180	1028	21	only	only	RB
5180	1028	22	to	to	IN
5180	1028	23	speech	speech	NN
5180	1028	24	on	on	IN
5180	1028	25	government	government	NN
5180	1028	26	property	property	NN
5180	1028	27	,	,	,
5180	1028	28	such	such	JJ
5180	1028	29	as	as	IN
5180	1028	30	public	public	JJ
5180	1028	31	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1028	32	.	.	.
5180	1029	1	"	"	``
5180	1029	2	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1029	3	I]t	I]t	NNP
5180	1029	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	1029	5	.	.	.
5180	1030	1	.	.	.
5180	1031	1	.	.	.
5180	1032	1	well	well	UH
5180	1032	2	settled	settle	VBD
5180	1032	3	that	that	IN
5180	1032	4	the	the	DT
5180	1032	5	government	government	NN
5180	1032	6	need	nee	MD
5180	1032	7	not	not	RB
5180	1032	8	permit	permit	VB
5180	1032	9	all	all	DT
5180	1032	10	forms	form	NNS
5180	1032	11	of	of	IN
5180	1032	12	speech	speech	NN
5180	1032	13	on	on	IN
5180	1032	14	property	property	NN
5180	1032	15	that	that	WDT
5180	1032	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1032	17	owns	own	VBZ
5180	1032	18	and	and	CC
5180	1032	19	controls	control	VBZ
5180	1032	20	.	.	.
5180	1032	21	"	"	''
5180	1033	1	Int'l	Int'l	NNPS
5180	1033	2	Soc'y	Soc'y	NNP
5180	1033	3	for	for	IN
5180	1033	4	Krishna	Krishna	NNP
5180	1033	5	Consciousness	Consciousness	NNP
5180	1033	6	,	,	,
5180	1033	7	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1033	8	v.	v.	IN
5180	1033	9	Lee	Lee	NNP
5180	1033	10	,	,	,
5180	1033	11	505	505	CD
5180	1033	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1033	13	672	672	CD
5180	1033	14	,	,	,
5180	1033	15	678	678	CD
5180	1033	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1033	17	1992	1992	CD
5180	1033	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1033	19	.	.	.
5180	1034	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1034	2	perforce	perforce	VBP
5180	1034	3	turn	turn	VBP
5180	1034	4	to	to	IN
5180	1034	5	a	a	DT
5180	1034	6	discussion	discussion	NN
5180	1034	7	of	of	IN
5180	1034	8	public	public	NNP
5180	1034	9	forum	forum	NNP
5180	1034	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	1034	11	.	.	.
5180	1035	1	1	1	LS
5180	1035	2	.	.	.
5180	1036	1	Overview	Overview	NNP
5180	1036	2	of	of	IN
5180	1036	3	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1036	4	Forum	Forum	NNP
5180	1036	5	Doctrine	Doctrine	NNP
5180	1036	6	The	the	DT
5180	1036	7	government	government	NN
5180	1036	8	's	's	POS
5180	1036	9	power	power	NN
5180	1036	10	to	to	TO
5180	1036	11	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	1036	12	speech	speech	NN
5180	1036	13	on	on	IN
5180	1036	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1036	15	own	own	JJ
5180	1036	16	property	property	NN
5180	1036	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	1036	18	not	not	RB
5180	1036	19	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	1036	20	.	.	.
5180	1037	1	Rather	rather	RB
5180	1037	2	,	,	,
5180	1037	3	under	under	IN
5180	1037	4	public	public	JJ
5180	1037	5	forum	forum	NN
5180	1037	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	1037	7	,	,	,
5180	1037	8	the	the	DT
5180	1037	9	extent	extent	NN
5180	1037	10	to	to	TO
5180	1037	11	which	which	WDT
5180	1037	12	the	the	DT
5180	1037	13	First	First	NNP
5180	1037	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1037	15	permits	permit	VBZ
5180	1037	16	the	the	DT
5180	1037	17	government	government	NN
5180	1037	18	to	to	TO
5180	1037	19	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	1037	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	1037	21	on	on	IN
5180	1037	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1037	23	own	own	JJ
5180	1037	24	property	property	NN
5180	1037	25	depends	depend	VBZ
5180	1037	26	on	on	IN
5180	1037	27	the	the	DT
5180	1037	28	character	character	NN
5180	1037	29	of	of	IN
5180	1037	30	the	the	DT
5180	1037	31	forum	forum	NN
5180	1037	32	that	that	WDT
5180	1037	33	the	the	DT
5180	1037	34	government	government	NN
5180	1037	35	has	have	VBZ
5180	1037	36	created	create	VBN
5180	1037	37	.	.	.
5180	1038	1	See	see	VB
5180	1038	2	Cornelius	Cornelius	NNP
5180	1038	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1038	4	NAACP	NAACP	NNP
5180	1038	5	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	1038	6	Def	Def	NNP
5180	1038	7	.	.	.
5180	1039	1	&	&	CC
5180	1039	2	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	1039	3	.	.	.
5180	1040	1	Fund	Fund	NNP
5180	1040	2	,	,	,
5180	1040	3	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1040	4	,	,	,
5180	1040	5	473	473	CD
5180	1040	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1040	7	788	788	CD
5180	1040	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1040	9	1985	1985	CD
5180	1040	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1040	11	.	.	.
5180	1041	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1041	2	,	,	,
5180	1041	3	the	the	DT
5180	1041	4	First	First	NNP
5180	1041	5	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1041	6	affords	afford	VBZ
5180	1041	7	greater	great	JJR
5180	1041	8	deference	deference	NN
5180	1041	9	to	to	IN
5180	1041	10	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1041	11	on	on	IN
5180	1041	12	speech	speech	NN
5180	1041	13	in	in	IN
5180	1041	14	those	those	DT
5180	1041	15	areas	area	NNS
5180	1041	16	considered	consider	VBD
5180	1041	17	less	less	RBR
5180	1041	18	amenable	amenable	JJ
5180	1041	19	to	to	IN
5180	1041	20	free	free	JJ
5180	1041	21	expression	expression	NN
5180	1041	22	,	,	,
5180	1041	23	such	such	JJ
5180	1041	24	as	as	IN
5180	1041	25	military	military	JJ
5180	1041	26	bases	basis	NNS
5180	1041	27	,	,	,
5180	1041	28	see	see	VB
5180	1041	29	Greer	Greer	NNP
5180	1041	30	v.	v.	IN
5180	1041	31	Spock	Spock	NNP
5180	1041	32	,	,	,
5180	1041	33	424	424	CD
5180	1041	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1041	35	828	828	CD
5180	1041	36	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1041	37	1976	1976	CD
5180	1041	38	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1041	39	,	,	,
5180	1041	40	jail	jail	NN
5180	1041	41	grounds	ground	NNS
5180	1041	42	,	,	,
5180	1041	43	see	see	VB
5180	1041	44	Adderley	Adderley	NNP
5180	1041	45	v.	v.	IN
5180	1041	46	Florida	Florida	NNP
5180	1041	47	,	,	,
5180	1041	48	385	385	CD
5180	1041	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1041	50	39	39	CD
5180	1041	51	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1041	52	1966	1966	CD
5180	1041	53	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1041	54	,	,	,
5180	1041	55	or	or	CC
5180	1041	56	public	public	JJ
5180	1041	57	airport	airport	NN
5180	1041	58	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1041	59	,	,	,
5180	1041	60	see	see	VB
5180	1041	61	Int'l	Int'l	NNPS
5180	1041	62	Soc'y	Soc'y	NNP
5180	1041	63	for	for	IN
5180	1041	64	Krishna	Krishna	NNP
5180	1041	65	Consciousness	Consciousness	NNP
5180	1041	66	,	,	,
5180	1041	67	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1041	68	v.	v.	IN
5180	1041	69	Lee	Lee	NNP
5180	1041	70	,	,	,
5180	1041	71	505	505	CD
5180	1041	72	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1041	73	672	672	CD
5180	1041	74	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1041	75	1992	1992	CD
5180	1041	76	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1041	77	,	,	,
5180	1041	78	than	than	IN
5180	1041	79	to	to	IN
5180	1041	80	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1041	81	on	on	IN
5180	1041	82	speech	speech	NN
5180	1041	83	in	in	IN
5180	1041	84	state	state	NN
5180	1041	85	universities	university	NNS
5180	1041	86	,	,	,
5180	1041	87	see	see	VB
5180	1041	88	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
5180	1041	89	v.	v.	IN
5180	1041	90	Rector	Rector	NNP
5180	1041	91	&	&	CC
5180	1041	92	Visitors	Visitors	NNPS
5180	1041	93	of	of	IN
5180	1041	94	Univ	Univ	NNP
5180	1041	95	.	.	.
5180	1042	1	of	of	IN
5180	1042	2	Va.	Virginia	NNP
5180	1042	3	,	,	,
5180	1042	4	515	515	CD
5180	1042	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1042	6	819	819	CD
5180	1042	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1042	8	1995	1995	CD
5180	1042	9	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1042	10	,	,	,
5180	1042	11	or	or	CC
5180	1042	12	streets	street	NNS
5180	1042	13	,	,	,
5180	1042	14	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1042	15	and	and	CC
5180	1042	16	public	public	JJ
5180	1042	17	parks	park	NNS
5180	1042	18	,	,	,
5180	1042	19	see	see	VB
5180	1042	20	Frisby	Frisby	NNP
5180	1042	21	v.	v.	IN
5180	1042	22	Schultz	Schultz	NNP
5180	1042	23	,	,	,
5180	1042	24	487	487	CD
5180	1042	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1042	26	474	474	CD
5180	1042	27	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1042	28	1988	1988	CD
5180	1042	29	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1042	30	;	;	:
5180	1042	31	Hague	Hague	NNP
5180	1042	32	v.	v.	CC
5180	1042	33	CIO	CIO	NNP
5180	1042	34	,	,	,
5180	1042	35	307	307	CD
5180	1042	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1042	37	496	496	CD
5180	1042	38	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1042	39	1939	1939	CD
5180	1042	40	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1042	41	.	.	.
5180	1043	1	The	the	DT
5180	1043	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1043	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1043	4	has	have	VBZ
5180	1043	5	identified	identify	VBN
5180	1043	6	three	three	CD
5180	1043	7	types	type	NNS
5180	1043	8	of	of	IN
5180	1043	9	fora	fora	NN
5180	1043	10	for	for	IN
5180	1043	11	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1043	12	of	of	IN
5180	1043	13	identifying	identify	VBG
5180	1043	14	the	the	DT
5180	1043	15	level	level	NN
5180	1043	16	of	of	IN
5180	1043	17	First	First	NNP
5180	1043	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1043	19	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1043	20	applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	1043	21	to	to	IN
5180	1043	22	content	content	NN
5180	1043	23	-	-	HYPH
5180	1043	24	based	base	VBN
5180	1043	25	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1043	26	on	on	IN
5180	1043	27	speech	speech	NN
5180	1043	28	on	on	IN
5180	1043	29	government	government	NN
5180	1043	30	property	property	NN
5180	1043	31	:	:	:
5180	1043	32	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1043	33	public	public	JJ
5180	1043	34	fora	fora	NN
5180	1043	35	,	,	,
5180	1043	36	designated	designate	VBD
5180	1043	37	public	public	JJ
5180	1043	38	fora	fora	NN
5180	1043	39	,	,	,
5180	1043	40	and	and	CC
5180	1043	41	nonpublic	nonpublic	NNP
5180	1043	42	fora	fora	NNP
5180	1043	43	.	.	.
5180	1044	1	Traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1044	2	public	public	JJ
5180	1044	3	fora	fora	NN
5180	1044	4	include	include	VBP
5180	1044	5	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1044	6	,	,	,
5180	1044	7	squares	square	NNS
5180	1044	8	,	,	,
5180	1044	9	and	and	CC
5180	1044	10	public	public	JJ
5180	1044	11	parks	park	NNS
5180	1044	12	:	:	:
5180	1044	13	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1044	14	S]treets	S]treets	NNP
5180	1044	15	and	and	CC
5180	1044	16	parks	park	NNS
5180	1044	17	.	.	.
5180	1045	1	.	.	.
5180	1046	1	.	.	.
5180	1047	1	have	have	VBP
5180	1047	2	immemorially	immemorially	RB
5180	1047	3	been	be	VBN
5180	1047	4	held	hold	VBN
5180	1047	5	in	in	IN
5180	1047	6	trust	trust	NN
5180	1047	7	for	for	IN
5180	1047	8	the	the	DT
5180	1047	9	use	use	NN
5180	1047	10	of	of	IN
5180	1047	11	the	the	DT
5180	1047	12	public	public	NN
5180	1047	13	and	and	CC
5180	1047	14	,	,	,
5180	1047	15	time	time	NN
5180	1047	16	out	out	IN
5180	1047	17	of	of	IN
5180	1047	18	mind	mind	NN
5180	1047	19	,	,	,
5180	1047	20	have	have	VBP
5180	1047	21	been	be	VBN
5180	1047	22	used	use	VBN
5180	1047	23	for	for	IN
5180	1047	24	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1047	25	of	of	IN
5180	1047	26	assembly	assembly	NN
5180	1047	27	,	,	,
5180	1047	28	communicating	communicate	VBG
5180	1047	29	thoughts	thought	NNS
5180	1047	30	between	between	IN
5180	1047	31	citizens	citizen	NNS
5180	1047	32	,	,	,
5180	1047	33	and	and	CC
5180	1047	34	discussing	discuss	VBG
5180	1047	35	public	public	JJ
5180	1047	36	questions	question	NNS
5180	1047	37	.	.	.
5180	1048	1	Such	such	JJ
5180	1048	2	use	use	NN
5180	1048	3	of	of	IN
5180	1048	4	the	the	DT
5180	1048	5	streets	street	NNS
5180	1048	6	and	and	CC
5180	1048	7	public	public	JJ
5180	1048	8	places	place	NNS
5180	1048	9	has	have	VBZ
5180	1048	10	,	,	,
5180	1048	11	from	from	IN
5180	1048	12	ancient	ancient	JJ
5180	1048	13	times	time	NNS
5180	1048	14	,	,	,
5180	1048	15	been	be	VBN
5180	1048	16	a	a	DT
5180	1048	17	part	part	NN
5180	1048	18	of	of	IN
5180	1048	19	the	the	DT
5180	1048	20	privileges	privilege	NNS
5180	1048	21	,	,	,
5180	1048	22	immunities	immunity	NNS
5180	1048	23	,	,	,
5180	1048	24	rights	right	NNS
5180	1048	25	,	,	,
5180	1048	26	and	and	CC
5180	1048	27	liberties	liberty	NNS
5180	1048	28	of	of	IN
5180	1048	29	citizens	citizen	NNS
5180	1048	30	.	.	.
5180	1049	1	Hague	Hague	NNP
5180	1049	2	,	,	,
5180	1049	3	307	307	CD
5180	1049	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1049	5	at	at	IN
5180	1049	6	515	515	CD
5180	1049	7	.	.	.
5180	1050	1	"	"	``
5180	1050	2	In	in	IN
5180	1050	3	these	these	DT
5180	1050	4	quintessential	quintessential	JJ
5180	1050	5	public	public	JJ
5180	1050	6	forums	forum	NNS
5180	1050	7	,	,	,
5180	1050	8	.	.	.
5180	1051	1	.	.	.
5180	1052	1	.	.	.
5180	1053	1	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1053	2	f]or	f]or	:
5180	1053	3	the	the	DT
5180	1053	4	State	State	NNP
5180	1053	5	to	to	TO
5180	1053	6	enforce	enforce	VB
5180	1053	7	a	a	DT
5180	1053	8	content	content	NN
5180	1053	9	-	-	HYPH
5180	1053	10	based	base	VBN
5180	1053	11	exclusion	exclusion	NN
5180	1053	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1053	13	must	must	MD
5180	1053	14	show	show	VB
5180	1053	15	that	that	IN
5180	1053	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1053	17	regulation	regulation	NN
5180	1053	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	1053	19	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	1053	20	to	to	TO
5180	1053	21	serve	serve	VB
5180	1053	22	a	a	DT
5180	1053	23	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1053	24	state	state	NN
5180	1053	25	interest	interest	NN
5180	1053	26	and	and	CC
5180	1053	27	that	that	IN
5180	1053	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1053	29	is	be	VBZ
5180	1053	30	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1053	31	drawn	draw	VBN
5180	1053	32	to	to	TO
5180	1053	33	achieve	achieve	VB
5180	1053	34	that	that	DT
5180	1053	35	end	end	NN
5180	1053	36	.	.	.
5180	1053	37	"	"	''
5180	1054	1	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	1054	2	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	1054	3	.	.	.
5180	1055	1	Ass'n	Ass'n	NFP
5180	1055	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	1055	3	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	1055	4	Local	Local	NNP
5180	1055	5	Educs	Educs	NNP
5180	1055	6	.	.	.
5180	1056	1	Ass'n	Ass'n	NFP
5180	1056	2	,	,	,
5180	1056	3	460	460	CD
5180	1056	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1056	5	37	37	CD
5180	1056	6	,	,	,
5180	1056	7	45	45	CD
5180	1056	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1056	9	1983	1983	CD
5180	1056	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1056	11	;	;	:
5180	1056	12	see	see	VB
5180	1056	13	also	also	RB
5180	1056	14	Int'l	Int'l	NNPS
5180	1056	15	Soc'y	Soc'y	:
5180	1056	16	for	for	IN
5180	1056	17	Krishna	Krishna	NNP
5180	1056	18	Consciousness	Consciousness	NNP
5180	1056	19	,	,	,
5180	1056	20	505	505	CD
5180	1056	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNS
5180	1056	22	at	at	IN
5180	1056	23	678	678	CD
5180	1056	24	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1056	25	"	"	''
5180	1056	26	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1056	27	R]egulation	R]egulation	NNP
5180	1056	28	of	of	IN
5180	1056	29	speech	speech	NN
5180	1056	30	on	on	IN
5180	1056	31	government	government	NN
5180	1056	32	property	property	NN
5180	1056	33	that	that	WDT
5180	1056	34	has	have	VBZ
5180	1056	35	traditionally	traditionally	RB
5180	1056	36	been	be	VBN
5180	1056	37	available	available	JJ
5180	1056	38	for	for	IN
5180	1056	39	public	public	JJ
5180	1056	40	expression	expression	NN
5180	1056	41	is	be	VBZ
5180	1056	42	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1056	43	to	to	IN
5180	1056	44	the	the	DT
5180	1056	45	highest	high	JJS
5180	1056	46	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1056	47	.	.	.
5180	1057	1	")	")	``
5180	1057	2	;	;	:
5180	1057	3	Frisby	Frisby	NNP
5180	1057	4	,	,	,
5180	1057	5	487	487	CD
5180	1057	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1057	7	at	at	IN
5180	1057	8	480	480	CD
5180	1057	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1057	10	"	"	``
5180	1057	11	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1057	12	W]e	W]e	NNP
5180	1057	13	have	have	VBP
5180	1057	14	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
5180	1057	15	referred	refer	VBN
5180	1057	16	to	to	IN
5180	1057	17	public	public	JJ
5180	1057	18	streets	street	NNS
5180	1057	19	as	as	IN
5180	1057	20	the	the	DT
5180	1057	21	archetype	archetype	NN
5180	1057	22	of	of	IN
5180	1057	23	a	a	DT
5180	1057	24	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1057	25	public	public	JJ
5180	1057	26	forum	forum	NN
5180	1057	27	.	.	.
5180	1057	28	"	"	''
5180	1057	29	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1057	30	.	.	.
5180	1058	1	A	a	DT
5180	1058	2	second	second	JJ
5180	1058	3	category	category	NN
5180	1058	4	of	of	IN
5180	1058	5	fora	fora	NNP
5180	1058	6	,	,	,
5180	1058	7	known	know	VBN
5180	1058	8	as	as	IN
5180	1058	9	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1058	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1058	11	or	or	CC
5180	1058	12	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1058	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1058	14	public	public	JJ
5180	1058	15	fora	fora	NN
5180	1058	16	,	,	,
5180	1058	17	"	"	''
5180	1058	18	consists	consist	VBZ
5180	1058	19	of	of	IN
5180	1058	20	public	public	JJ
5180	1058	21	property	property	NN
5180	1058	22	which	which	WDT
5180	1058	23	the	the	DT
5180	1058	24	State	State	NNP
5180	1058	25	has	have	VBZ
5180	1058	26	opened	open	VBN
5180	1058	27	for	for	IN
5180	1058	28	use	use	NN
5180	1058	29	by	by	IN
5180	1058	30	the	the	DT
5180	1058	31	public	public	NN
5180	1058	32	as	as	IN
5180	1058	33	a	a	DT
5180	1058	34	place	place	NN
5180	1058	35	for	for	IN
5180	1058	36	expressive	expressive	JJ
5180	1058	37	activity	activity	NN
5180	1058	38	.	.	.
5180	1058	39	"	"	''
5180	1059	1	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	1059	2	,	,	,
5180	1059	3	460	460	CD
5180	1059	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1059	5	at	at	IN
5180	1059	6	46	46	CD
5180	1059	7	.	.	.
5180	1060	1	Whereas	whereas	IN
5180	1060	2	any	any	DT
5180	1060	3	content	content	NN
5180	1060	4	-	-	HYPH
5180	1060	5	based	base	VBN
5180	1060	6	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1060	7	on	on	IN
5180	1060	8	the	the	DT
5180	1060	9	use	use	NN
5180	1060	10	of	of	IN
5180	1060	11	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1060	12	public	public	JJ
5180	1060	13	fora	fora	NN
5180	1060	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	1060	15	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1060	16	to	to	IN
5180	1060	17	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1060	18	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1060	19	,	,	,
5180	1060	20	the	the	DT
5180	1060	21	state	state	NN
5180	1060	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	1060	23	generally	generally	RB
5180	1060	24	permitted	permit	VBN
5180	1060	25	,	,	,
5180	1060	26	as	as	RB
5180	1060	27	long	long	RB
5180	1060	28	as	as	IN
5180	1060	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1060	30	does	do	VBZ
5180	1060	31	not	not	RB
5180	1060	32	discriminate	discriminate	VB
5180	1060	33	on	on	IN
5180	1060	34	the	the	DT
5180	1060	35	basis	basis	NN
5180	1060	36	of	of	IN
5180	1060	37	viewpoint	viewpoint	NN
5180	1060	38	,	,	,
5180	1060	39	to	to	TO
5180	1060	40	limit	limit	VB
5180	1060	41	a	a	DT
5180	1060	42	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1060	43	public	public	JJ
5180	1060	44	forum	forum	NN
5180	1060	45	to	to	IN
5180	1060	46	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1060	47	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1060	48	or	or	CC
5180	1060	49	the	the	DT
5180	1060	50	discussion	discussion	NN
5180	1060	51	of	of	IN
5180	1060	52	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1060	53	subjects	subject	NNS
5180	1060	54	.	.	.
5180	1061	1	See	see	UH
5180	1061	2	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	1061	3	,	,	,
5180	1061	4	460	460	CD
5180	1061	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1061	6	at	at	IN
5180	1061	7	45	45	CD
5180	1061	8	n.7	n.7	NNS
5180	1061	9	.	.	.
5180	1062	1	Once	once	IN
5180	1062	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1062	3	has	have	VBZ
5180	1062	4	defined	define	VBN
5180	1062	5	the	the	DT
5180	1062	6	limits	limit	NNS
5180	1062	7	of	of	IN
5180	1062	8	a	a	DT
5180	1062	9	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1062	10	public	public	JJ
5180	1062	11	forum	forum	NN
5180	1062	12	,	,	,
5180	1062	13	however	however	RB
5180	1062	14	,	,	,
5180	1062	15	"	"	''
5180	1062	16	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1062	17	r]egulation	r]egulation	NN
5180	1062	18	of	of	IN
5180	1062	19	such	such	JJ
5180	1062	20	property	property	NN
5180	1062	21	is	be	VBZ
5180	1062	22	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1062	23	to	to	IN
5180	1062	24	the	the	DT
5180	1062	25	same	same	JJ
5180	1062	26	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	1062	27	as	as	IN
5180	1062	28	that	that	DT
5180	1062	29	governing	govern	VBG
5180	1062	30	a	a	DT
5180	1062	31	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1062	32	public	public	JJ
5180	1062	33	forum	forum	NN
5180	1062	34	.	.	.
5180	1062	35	"	"	''
5180	1063	1	Int'l	Int'l	NNPS
5180	1063	2	Soc'y	Soc'y	NNP
5180	1063	3	for	for	IN
5180	1063	4	Krishna	Krishna	NNP
5180	1063	5	Consciousness	Consciousness	NNP
5180	1063	6	,	,	,
5180	1063	7	505	505	CD
5180	1063	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNS
5180	1063	9	at	at	IN
5180	1063	10	678	678	CD
5180	1063	11	.	.	.
5180	1064	1	Examples	example	NNS
5180	1064	2	of	of	IN
5180	1064	3	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1064	4	fora	fora	NNP
5180	1064	5	include	include	VBP
5180	1064	6	university	university	NN
5180	1064	7	meeting	meeting	NN
5180	1064	8	facilities	facility	NNS
5180	1064	9	,	,	,
5180	1064	10	see	see	VB
5180	1064	11	Widmar	Widmar	NNP
5180	1064	12	v.	v.	IN
5180	1064	13	Vincent	Vincent	NNP
5180	1064	14	,	,	,
5180	1064	15	454	454	CD
5180	1064	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1064	17	263	263	CD
5180	1064	18	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1064	19	1981	1981	CD
5180	1064	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1064	21	,	,	,
5180	1064	22	school	school	NN
5180	1064	23	board	board	NN
5180	1064	24	meetings	meeting	NNS
5180	1064	25	,	,	,
5180	1064	26	see	see	VB
5180	1064	27	City	City	NNP
5180	1064	28	of	of	IN
5180	1064	29	Madison	Madison	NNP
5180	1064	30	Joint	Joint	NNP
5180	1064	31	School	School	NNP
5180	1064	32	Dist	Dist	NNP
5180	1064	33	.	.	.
5180	1065	1	v.	v.	CC
5180	1065	2	Wisc	Wisc	NNP
5180	1065	3	.	.	.
5180	1066	1	Employment	Employment	NNP
5180	1066	2	Relations	Relations	NNPS
5180	1066	3	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
5180	1066	4	,	,	,
5180	1066	5	429	429	CD
5180	1066	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1066	7	167	167	CD
5180	1066	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1066	9	1976	1976	CD
5180	1066	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1066	11	,	,	,
5180	1066	12	and	and	CC
5180	1066	13	municipal	municipal	JJ
5180	1066	14	theaters	theater	NNS
5180	1066	15	,	,	,
5180	1066	16	see	see	VB
5180	1066	17	Southeastern	Southeastern	NNP
5180	1066	18	Promotions	Promotions	NNP
5180	1066	19	,	,	,
5180	1066	20	Ltd.	Ltd.	NNP
5180	1066	21	v.	v.	IN
5180	1066	22	Conrad	Conrad	NNP
5180	1066	23	,	,	,
5180	1066	24	420	420	CD
5180	1066	25	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1066	26	546	546	CD
5180	1066	27	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1066	28	1975	1975	CD
5180	1066	29	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1066	30	.	.	.
5180	1067	1	The	the	DT
5180	1067	2	third	third	JJ
5180	1067	3	category	category	NN
5180	1067	4	,	,	,
5180	1067	5	nonpublic	nonpublic	NNP
5180	1067	6	fora	fora	NNP
5180	1067	7	,	,	,
5180	1067	8	consists	consist	VBZ
5180	1067	9	of	of	IN
5180	1067	10	all	all	DT
5180	1067	11	remaining	remain	VBG
5180	1067	12	public	public	JJ
5180	1067	13	property	property	NN
5180	1067	14	.	.	.
5180	1068	1	"	"	``
5180	1068	2	Limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	1068	3	on	on	IN
5180	1068	4	expressive	expressive	JJ
5180	1068	5	activity	activity	NN
5180	1068	6	conducted	conduct	VBN
5180	1068	7	on	on	IN
5180	1068	8	this	this	DT
5180	1068	9	last	last	JJ
5180	1068	10	category	category	NN
5180	1068	11	of	of	IN
5180	1068	12	property	property	NN
5180	1068	13	must	must	MD
5180	1068	14	survive	survive	VB
5180	1068	15	only	only	RB
5180	1068	16	a	a	DT
5180	1068	17	much	much	RB
5180	1068	18	more	more	RBR
5180	1068	19	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1068	20	review	review	NN
5180	1068	21	.	.	.
5180	1069	1	The	the	DT
5180	1069	2	challenged	challenge	VBN
5180	1069	3	regulation	regulation	NN
5180	1069	4	need	nee	MD
5180	1069	5	only	only	RB
5180	1069	6	be	be	VB
5180	1069	7	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
5180	1069	8	,	,	,
5180	1069	9	as	as	RB
5180	1069	10	long	long	RB
5180	1069	11	as	as	IN
5180	1069	12	the	the	DT
5180	1069	13	regulation	regulation	NN
5180	1069	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	1069	15	not	not	RB
5180	1069	16	an	an	DT
5180	1069	17	effort	effort	NN
5180	1069	18	to	to	TO
5180	1069	19	suppress	suppress	VB
5180	1069	20	the	the	DT
5180	1069	21	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	1069	22	's	's	POS
5180	1069	23	activity	activity	NN
5180	1069	24	due	due	JJ
5180	1069	25	to	to	IN
5180	1069	26	disagreement	disagreement	NN
5180	1069	27	with	with	IN
5180	1069	28	the	the	DT
5180	1069	29	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	1069	30	's	's	POS
5180	1069	31	view	view	NN
5180	1069	32	.	.	.
5180	1069	33	"	"	''
5180	1070	1	Int'l	Int'l	NNPS
5180	1070	2	Soc'y	Soc'y	NNP
5180	1070	3	for	for	IN
5180	1070	4	Krishna	Krishna	NNP
5180	1070	5	Consciousness	Consciousness	NNP
5180	1070	6	,	,	,
5180	1070	7	505	505	CD
5180	1070	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNS
5180	1070	9	at	at	IN
5180	1070	10	679	679	CD
5180	1070	11	.	.	.
5180	1071	1	2	2	LS
5180	1071	2	.	.	.
5180	1072	1	Contours	contour	NNS
5180	1072	2	of	of	IN
5180	1072	3	the	the	DT
5180	1072	4	Relevant	Relevant	NNP
5180	1072	5	Forum	Forum	NNP
5180	1072	6	:	:	:
5180	1072	7	the	the	DT
5180	1072	8	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1072	9	's	's	POS
5180	1072	10	Collection	Collection	NNP
5180	1072	11	as	as	IN
5180	1072	12	a	a	DT
5180	1072	13	Whole	Whole	NNP
5180	1072	14	or	or	CC
5180	1072	15	the	the	DT
5180	1072	16	Provision	Provision	NNP
5180	1072	17	of	of	IN
5180	1072	18	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	1072	19	Access	Access	NNP
5180	1072	20	?	?	.
5180	1073	1	To	to	TO
5180	1073	2	apply	apply	VB
5180	1073	3	public	public	JJ
5180	1073	4	forum	forum	NN
5180	1073	5	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	1073	6	to	to	IN
5180	1073	7	this	this	DT
5180	1073	8	case	case	NN
5180	1073	9	,	,	,
5180	1073	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1073	11	must	must	MD
5180	1073	12	first	first	RB
5180	1073	13	determine	determine	VB
5180	1073	14	whether	whether	IN
5180	1073	15	the	the	DT
5180	1073	16	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1073	17	forum	forum	NN
5180	1073	18	for	for	IN
5180	1073	19	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	1073	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	1073	21	the	the	DT
5180	1073	22	library	library	NN
5180	1073	23	's	's	POS
5180	1073	24	collection	collection	NN
5180	1073	25	as	as	IN
5180	1073	26	a	a	DT
5180	1073	27	whole	whole	NN
5180	1073	28	,	,	,
5180	1073	29	which	which	WDT
5180	1073	30	includes	include	VBZ
5180	1073	31	both	both	DT
5180	1073	32	print	print	NN
5180	1073	33	and	and	CC
5180	1073	34	electronic	electronic	JJ
5180	1073	35	resources	resource	NNS
5180	1073	36	,	,	,
5180	1073	37	or	or	CC
5180	1073	38	the	the	DT
5180	1073	39	library	library	NN
5180	1073	40	's	's	POS
5180	1073	41	provision	provision	NN
5180	1073	42	of	of	IN
5180	1073	43	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1073	44	access	access	NN
5180	1073	45	.	.	.
5180	1074	1	Where	where	WRB
5180	1074	2	a	a	DT
5180	1074	3	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
5180	1074	4	seeks	seek	VBZ
5180	1074	5	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1074	6	access	access	NN
5180	1074	7	,	,	,
5180	1074	8	for	for	IN
5180	1074	9	expressive	expressive	JJ
5180	1074	10	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1074	11	,	,	,
5180	1074	12	to	to	IN
5180	1074	13	governmentally	governmentally	RB
5180	1074	14	controlled	control	VBN
5180	1074	15	property	property	NN
5180	1074	16	,	,	,
5180	1074	17	the	the	DT
5180	1074	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1074	19	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1074	20	has	have	VBZ
5180	1074	21	held	hold	VBN
5180	1074	22	that	that	IN
5180	1074	23	the	the	DT
5180	1074	24	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	1074	25	forum	forum	NN
5180	1074	26	is	be	VBZ
5180	1074	27	defined	define	VBN
5180	1074	28	not	not	RB
5180	1074	29	by	by	IN
5180	1074	30	the	the	DT
5180	1074	31	physical	physical	JJ
5180	1074	32	limits	limit	NNS
5180	1074	33	of	of	IN
5180	1074	34	the	the	DT
5180	1074	35	government	government	NN
5180	1074	36	property	property	NN
5180	1074	37	at	at	IN
5180	1074	38	issue	issue	NN
5180	1074	39	,	,	,
5180	1074	40	but	but	CC
5180	1074	41	rather	rather	RB
5180	1074	42	by	by	IN
5180	1074	43	the	the	DT
5180	1074	44	specific	specific	JJ
5180	1074	45	access	access	NN
5180	1074	46	that	that	WDT
5180	1074	47	the	the	DT
5180	1074	48	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
5180	1074	49	seeks	seek	VBZ
5180	1074	50	:	:	:
5180	1074	51	Although	although	IN
5180	1074	52	.	.	.
5180	1075	1	.	.	.
5180	1076	1	.	.	.
5180	1077	1	as	as	IN
5180	1077	2	an	an	DT
5180	1077	3	initial	initial	JJ
5180	1077	4	matter	matter	NN
5180	1077	5	a	a	DT
5180	1077	6	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	1077	7	must	must	MD
5180	1077	8	seek	seek	VB
5180	1077	9	access	access	NN
5180	1077	10	to	to	IN
5180	1077	11	public	public	JJ
5180	1077	12	property	property	NN
5180	1077	13	or	or	CC
5180	1077	14	to	to	IN
5180	1077	15	private	private	JJ
5180	1077	16	property	property	NN
5180	1077	17	dedicated	dedicate	VBN
5180	1077	18	to	to	IN
5180	1077	19	public	public	JJ
5180	1077	20	use	use	NN
5180	1077	21	to	to	TO
5180	1077	22	evoke	evoke	VB
5180	1077	23	First	First	NNP
5180	1077	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1077	25	concerns	concern	NNS
5180	1077	26	,	,	,
5180	1077	27	forum	forum	NN
5180	1077	28	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	1077	29	is	be	VBZ
5180	1077	30	not	not	RB
5180	1077	31	completed	complete	VBN
5180	1077	32	merely	merely	RB
5180	1077	33	by	by	IN
5180	1077	34	identifying	identify	VBG
5180	1077	35	the	the	DT
5180	1077	36	government	government	NN
5180	1077	37	property	property	NN
5180	1077	38	at	at	IN
5180	1077	39	issue	issue	NN
5180	1077	40	.	.	.
5180	1078	1	Rather	rather	RB
5180	1078	2	,	,	,
5180	1078	3	in	in	IN
5180	1078	4	defining	define	VBG
5180	1078	5	the	the	DT
5180	1078	6	forum	forum	NN
5180	1078	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1078	8	have	have	VBP
5180	1078	9	focused	focus	VBN
5180	1078	10	on	on	IN
5180	1078	11	the	the	DT
5180	1078	12	access	access	NN
5180	1078	13	sought	seek	VBN
5180	1078	14	by	by	IN
5180	1078	15	the	the	DT
5180	1078	16	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	1078	17	.	.	.
5180	1079	1	When	when	WRB
5180	1079	2	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1079	3	seek	seek	VBP
5180	1079	4	general	general	JJ
5180	1079	5	access	access	NN
5180	1079	6	to	to	IN
5180	1079	7	public	public	JJ
5180	1079	8	property	property	NN
5180	1079	9	,	,	,
5180	1079	10	the	the	DT
5180	1079	11	forum	forum	NN
5180	1079	12	encompasses	encompass	VBZ
5180	1079	13	that	that	DT
5180	1079	14	property	property	NN
5180	1079	15	.	.	.
5180	1080	1	In	in	IN
5180	1080	2	cases	case	NNS
5180	1080	3	in	in	IN
5180	1080	4	which	which	WDT
5180	1080	5	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1080	6	access	access	NN
5180	1080	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	1080	8	sought	seek	VBN
5180	1080	9	,	,	,
5180	1080	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1080	11	cases	case	NNS
5180	1080	12	have	have	VBP
5180	1080	13	taken	take	VBN
5180	1080	14	a	a	DT
5180	1080	15	more	more	RBR
5180	1080	16	tailored	tailored	JJ
5180	1080	17	approach	approach	NN
5180	1080	18	to	to	IN
5180	1080	19	ascertaining	ascertain	VBG
5180	1080	20	the	the	DT
5180	1080	21	perimeters	perimeter	NNS
5180	1080	22	of	of	IN
5180	1080	23	a	a	DT
5180	1080	24	forum	forum	NN
5180	1080	25	within	within	IN
5180	1080	26	the	the	DT
5180	1080	27	confines	confine	NNS
5180	1080	28	of	of	IN
5180	1080	29	the	the	DT
5180	1080	30	government	government	NN
5180	1080	31	property	property	NN
5180	1080	32	.	.	.
5180	1081	1	Cornelius	Cornelius	NNP
5180	1081	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	1081	3	NAACP	NAACP	NNP
5180	1081	4	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	1081	5	Def	Def	NNP
5180	1081	6	.	.	.
5180	1082	1	&	&	CC
5180	1082	2	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	1082	3	.	.	.
5180	1083	1	Fund	Fund	NNP
5180	1083	2	,	,	,
5180	1083	3	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1083	4	,	,	,
5180	1083	5	473	473	CD
5180	1083	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1083	7	788	788	CD
5180	1083	8	,	,	,
5180	1083	9	801	801	CD
5180	1083	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1083	11	1985	1985	CD
5180	1083	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1083	13	.	.	.
5180	1084	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1084	2	,	,	,
5180	1084	3	in	in	IN
5180	1084	4	Cornelius	Cornelius	NNP
5180	1084	5	,	,	,
5180	1084	6	where	where	WRB
5180	1084	7	the	the	DT
5180	1084	8	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1084	9	were	be	VBD
5180	1084	10	legal	legal	JJ
5180	1084	11	defense	defense	NN
5180	1084	12	and	and	CC
5180	1084	13	political	political	JJ
5180	1084	14	advocacy	advocacy	NN
5180	1084	15	groups	group	NNS
5180	1084	16	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	1084	17	to	to	TO
5180	1084	18	participate	participate	VB
5180	1084	19	in	in	IN
5180	1084	20	the	the	DT
5180	1084	21	Combined	Combined	NNP
5180	1084	22	Federal	Federal	NNP
5180	1084	23	Campaign	Campaign	NNP
5180	1084	24	charity	charity	NN
5180	1084	25	drive	drive	NN
5180	1084	26	,	,	,
5180	1084	27	the	the	DT
5180	1084	28	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1084	29	held	hold	VBD
5180	1084	30	that	that	IN
5180	1084	31	the	the	DT
5180	1084	32	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	1084	33	forum	forum	NN
5180	1084	34	,	,	,
5180	1084	35	for	for	IN
5180	1084	36	First	First	NNP
5180	1084	37	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1084	38	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1084	39	,	,	,
5180	1084	40	was	be	VBD
5180	1084	41	not	not	RB
5180	1084	42	the	the	DT
5180	1084	43	entire	entire	JJ
5180	1084	44	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1084	45	workplace	workplace	NN
5180	1084	46	,	,	,
5180	1084	47	but	but	CC
5180	1084	48	rather	rather	RB
5180	1084	49	the	the	DT
5180	1084	50	charity	charity	NN
5180	1084	51	drive	drive	VBP
5180	1084	52	itself	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1084	53	.	.	.
5180	1085	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1086	1	at	at	IN
5180	1086	2	801	801	CD
5180	1086	3	.	.	.
5180	1087	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1087	2	,	,	,
5180	1087	3	in	in	IN
5180	1087	4	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	1087	5	Education	Education	NNP
5180	1087	6	Association	Association	NNP
5180	1087	7	v.	v.	IN
5180	1087	8	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	1087	9	Local	Local	NNP
5180	1087	10	Educators	Educators	NNPS
5180	1087	11	'	'	POS
5180	1087	12	Association	Association	NNP
5180	1087	13	,	,	,
5180	1087	14	460	460	CD
5180	1087	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1087	16	37	37	CD
5180	1087	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1087	18	1983	1983	CD
5180	1087	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1087	20	,	,	,
5180	1087	21	which	which	WDT
5180	1087	22	addressed	address	VBD
5180	1087	23	a	a	DT
5180	1087	24	union	union	NN
5180	1087	25	's	's	POS
5180	1087	26	right	right	NN
5180	1087	27	to	to	TO
5180	1087	28	access	access	VB
5180	1087	29	a	a	DT
5180	1087	30	public	public	JJ
5180	1087	31	school	school	NN
5180	1087	32	's	's	POS
5180	1087	33	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1087	34	mail	mail	NN
5180	1087	35	system	system	NN
5180	1087	36	and	and	CC
5180	1087	37	teachers	teacher	NNS
5180	1087	38	'	'	POS
5180	1087	39	mailboxes	mailbox	NNS
5180	1087	40	,	,	,
5180	1087	41	the	the	DT
5180	1087	42	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1087	43	identified	identify	VBD
5180	1087	44	the	the	DT
5180	1087	45	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	1087	46	forum	forum	NN
5180	1087	47	as	as	IN
5180	1087	48	the	the	DT
5180	1087	49	school	school	NN
5180	1087	50	's	's	POS
5180	1087	51	mail	mail	NN
5180	1087	52	system	system	NN
5180	1087	53	,	,	,
5180	1087	54	not	not	RB
5180	1087	55	the	the	DT
5180	1087	56	public	public	JJ
5180	1087	57	school	school	NN
5180	1087	58	as	as	IN
5180	1087	59	a	a	DT
5180	1087	60	whole	whole	NN
5180	1087	61	.	.	.
5180	1088	1	In	in	IN
5180	1088	2	Widmar	Widmar	NNP
5180	1088	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1088	4	Vincent	Vincent	NNP
5180	1088	5	,	,	,
5180	1088	6	454	454	CD
5180	1088	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1088	8	263	263	CD
5180	1088	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1088	10	1981	1981	CD
5180	1088	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1088	12	,	,	,
5180	1088	13	in	in	IN
5180	1088	14	which	which	WDT
5180	1088	15	a	a	DT
5180	1088	16	student	student	NN
5180	1088	17	group	group	NN
5180	1088	18	challenged	challenge	VBD
5180	1088	19	a	a	DT
5180	1088	20	state	state	NN
5180	1088	21	university	university	NN
5180	1088	22	's	's	POS
5180	1088	23	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1088	24	on	on	IN
5180	1088	25	use	use	NN
5180	1088	26	of	of	IN
5180	1088	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1088	28	meeting	meeting	NN
5180	1088	29	facilities	facility	NNS
5180	1088	30	,	,	,
5180	1088	31	the	the	DT
5180	1088	32	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1088	33	identified	identify	VBD
5180	1088	34	the	the	DT
5180	1088	35	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	1088	36	forum	forum	NN
5180	1088	37	as	as	IN
5180	1088	38	the	the	DT
5180	1088	39	meeting	meeting	NN
5180	1088	40	facilities	facilitie	VBZ
5180	1088	41	to	to	TO
5180	1088	42	which	which	WDT
5180	1088	43	the	the	DT
5180	1088	44	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1088	45	sought	seek	VBD
5180	1088	46	access	access	NN
5180	1088	47	,	,	,
5180	1088	48	not	not	RB
5180	1088	49	the	the	DT
5180	1088	50	state	state	NNP
5180	1088	51	university	university	NNP
5180	1088	52	generally	generally	RB
5180	1088	53	.	.	.
5180	1089	1	And	and	CC
5180	1089	2	in	in	IN
5180	1089	3	Christ	Christ	NNP
5180	1089	4	's	's	POS
5180	1089	5	Bride	Bride	NNP
5180	1089	6	Ministries	Ministries	NNPS
5180	1089	7	,	,	,
5180	1089	8	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1089	9	v.	v.	CC
5180	1089	10	SEPTA	SEPTA	NNP
5180	1089	11	,	,	,
5180	1089	12	148	148	CD
5180	1089	13	F.3d	f.3d	NN
5180	1089	14	242	242	CD
5180	1089	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1089	16	3d	3d	NNP
5180	1089	17	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	1089	18	.	.	.
5180	1090	1	1998	1998	CD
5180	1090	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1090	3	,	,	,
5180	1090	4	involving	involve	VBG
5180	1090	5	a	a	DT
5180	1090	6	First	First	NNP
5180	1090	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1090	8	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	1090	9	to	to	IN
5180	1090	10	the	the	DT
5180	1090	11	removal	removal	NN
5180	1090	12	of	of	IN
5180	1090	13	advertisements	advertisement	NNS
5180	1090	14	from	from	IN
5180	1090	15	subway	subway	NN
5180	1090	16	and	and	CC
5180	1090	17	commuter	commuter	NN
5180	1090	18	rail	rail	NN
5180	1090	19	stations	station	NNS
5180	1090	20	,	,	,
5180	1090	21	the	the	DT
5180	1090	22	Third	Third	NNP
5180	1090	23	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
5180	1090	24	noted	note	VBD
5180	1090	25	that	that	IN
5180	1090	26	the	the	DT
5180	1090	27	forum	forum	NN
5180	1090	28	at	at	IN
5180	1090	29	issue	issue	NN
5180	1090	30	was	be	VBD
5180	1090	31	not	not	RB
5180	1090	32	the	the	DT
5180	1090	33	rail	rail	NN
5180	1090	34	and	and	CC
5180	1090	35	subway	subway	NN
5180	1090	36	stations	station	NNS
5180	1090	37	as	as	IN
5180	1090	38	a	a	DT
5180	1090	39	whole	whole	NN
5180	1090	40	,	,	,
5180	1090	41	but	but	CC
5180	1090	42	rather	rather	RB
5180	1090	43	the	the	DT
5180	1090	44	advertising	advertising	NN
5180	1090	45	space	space	NN
5180	1090	46	within	within	IN
5180	1090	47	the	the	DT
5180	1090	48	stations	station	NNS
5180	1090	49	.	.	.
5180	1091	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1092	1	at	at	IN
5180	1092	2	248	248	CD
5180	1092	3	.	.	.
5180	1093	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1093	2	these	these	DT
5180	1093	3	cases	case	NNS
5180	1093	4	dealt	deal	VBD
5180	1093	5	with	with	IN
5180	1093	6	the	the	DT
5180	1093	7	problem	problem	NN
5180	1093	8	of	of	IN
5180	1093	9	identifying	identify	VBG
5180	1093	10	the	the	DT
5180	1093	11	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	1093	12	forum	forum	NN
5180	1093	13	where	where	WRB
5180	1093	14	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1093	15	are	be	VBP
5180	1093	16	claiming	claim	VBG
5180	1093	17	a	a	DT
5180	1093	18	right	right	NN
5180	1093	19	of	of	IN
5180	1093	20	access	access	NN
5180	1093	21	,	,	,
5180	1093	22	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1093	23	believe	believe	VBP
5180	1093	24	that	that	IN
5180	1093	25	the	the	DT
5180	1093	26	same	same	JJ
5180	1093	27	approach	approach	NN
5180	1093	28	applies	apply	VBZ
5180	1093	29	to	to	IN
5180	1093	30	identifying	identify	VBG
5180	1093	31	the	the	DT
5180	1093	32	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	1093	33	forum	forum	NN
5180	1093	34	where	where	WRB
5180	1093	35	the	the	DT
5180	1093	36	parties	party	NNS
5180	1093	37	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	1093	38	access	access	NN
5180	1093	39	are	be	VBP
5180	1093	40	listeners	listener	NNS
5180	1093	41	or	or	CC
5180	1093	42	readers	reader	NNS
5180	1093	43	.	.	.
5180	1094	1	In	in	IN
5180	1094	2	this	this	DT
5180	1094	3	case	case	NN
5180	1094	4	,	,	,
5180	1094	5	the	the	DT
5180	1094	6	patron	patron	NN
5180	1094	7	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1094	8	are	be	VBP
5180	1094	9	not	not	RB
5180	1094	10	asserting	assert	VBG
5180	1094	11	a	a	DT
5180	1094	12	First	First	NNP
5180	1094	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1094	14	right	right	NN
5180	1094	15	to	to	TO
5180	1094	16	compel	compel	VB
5180	1094	17	public	public	JJ
5180	1094	18	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1094	19	to	to	TO
5180	1094	20	acquire	acquire	VB
5180	1094	21	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1094	22	books	book	NNS
5180	1094	23	or	or	CC
5180	1094	24	magazines	magazine	NNS
5180	1094	25	for	for	IN
5180	1094	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1094	27	print	print	NN
5180	1094	28	collections	collection	NNS
5180	1094	29	.	.	.
5180	1095	1	Nor	nor	CC
5180	1095	2	are	be	VBP
5180	1095	3	the	the	DT
5180	1095	4	Web	web	NN
5180	1095	5	site	site	NN
5180	1095	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1095	7	claiming	claim	VBG
5180	1095	8	a	a	DT
5180	1095	9	First	First	NNP
5180	1095	10	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1095	11	right	right	NN
5180	1095	12	to	to	TO
5180	1095	13	compel	compel	VB
5180	1095	14	public	public	JJ
5180	1095	15	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1095	16	to	to	TO
5180	1095	17	carry	carry	VB
5180	1095	18	print	print	NN
5180	1095	19	materials	material	NNS
5180	1095	20	that	that	IN
5180	1095	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1095	22	publish	publish	VBP
5180	1095	23	.	.	.
5180	1096	1	Rather	rather	RB
5180	1096	2	,	,	,
5180	1096	3	the	the	DT
5180	1096	4	right	right	NN
5180	1096	5	at	at	IN
5180	1096	6	issue	issue	NN
5180	1096	7	in	in	IN
5180	1096	8	this	this	DT
5180	1096	9	case	case	NN
5180	1096	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	1096	11	the	the	DT
5180	1096	12	specific	specific	JJ
5180	1096	13	right	right	NN
5180	1096	14	of	of	IN
5180	1096	15	library	library	NN
5180	1096	16	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1096	17	to	to	TO
5180	1096	18	access	access	VB
5180	1096	19	information	information	NN
5180	1096	20	on	on	IN
5180	1096	21	the	the	DT
5180	1096	22	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1096	23	,	,	,
5180	1096	24	and	and	CC
5180	1096	25	the	the	DT
5180	1096	26	specific	specific	JJ
5180	1096	27	right	right	NN
5180	1096	28	of	of	IN
5180	1096	29	Web	web	NN
5180	1096	30	publishers	publisher	NNS
5180	1096	31	to	to	TO
5180	1096	32	provide	provide	VB
5180	1096	33	library	library	NN
5180	1096	34	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1096	35	with	with	IN
5180	1096	36	information	information	NN
5180	1096	37	via	via	IN
5180	1096	38	the	the	DT
5180	1096	39	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1096	40	.	.	.
5180	1097	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1097	2	,	,	,
5180	1097	3	the	the	DT
5180	1097	4	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	1097	5	forum	forum	NN
5180	1097	6	for	for	IN
5180	1097	7	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	1097	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	1097	9	not	not	RB
5180	1097	10	the	the	DT
5180	1097	11	library	library	NN
5180	1097	12	's	's	POS
5180	1097	13	entire	entire	JJ
5180	1097	14	collection	collection	NN
5180	1097	15	,	,	,
5180	1097	16	which	which	WDT
5180	1097	17	includes	include	VBZ
5180	1097	18	both	both	DT
5180	1097	19	print	print	NN
5180	1097	20	and	and	CC
5180	1097	21	electronic	electronic	JJ
5180	1097	22	media	medium	NNS
5180	1097	23	,	,	,
5180	1097	24	such	such	JJ
5180	1097	25	as	as	IN
5180	1097	26	the	the	DT
5180	1097	27	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1097	28	,	,	,
5180	1097	29	but	but	CC
5180	1097	30	rather	rather	RB
5180	1097	31	the	the	DT
5180	1097	32	specific	specific	JJ
5180	1097	33	forum	forum	NN
5180	1097	34	created	create	VBD
5180	1097	35	when	when	WRB
5180	1097	36	the	the	DT
5180	1097	37	library	library	NN
5180	1097	38	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	1097	39	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1097	40	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1097	41	with	with	IN
5180	1097	42	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1097	43	access	access	NN
5180	1097	44	.	.	.
5180	1098	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1098	2	a	a	DT
5180	1098	3	public	public	JJ
5180	1098	4	library	library	NN
5180	1098	5	's	's	POS
5180	1098	6	provision	provision	NN
5180	1098	7	of	of	IN
5180	1098	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1098	9	access	access	NN
5180	1098	10	does	do	VBZ
5180	1098	11	not	not	RB
5180	1098	12	resemble	resemble	VB
5180	1098	13	the	the	DT
5180	1098	14	conventional	conventional	JJ
5180	1098	15	notion	notion	NN
5180	1098	16	of	of	IN
5180	1098	17	a	a	DT
5180	1098	18	forum	forum	NN
5180	1098	19	as	as	IN
5180	1098	20	a	a	DT
5180	1098	21	well-	well-	NN
5180	1098	22	defined	define	VBN
5180	1098	23	physical	physical	JJ
5180	1098	24	space	space	NN
5180	1098	25	,	,	,
5180	1098	26	the	the	DT
5180	1098	27	same	same	JJ
5180	1098	28	First	First	NNP
5180	1098	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1098	30	standards	standard	NNS
5180	1098	31	apply	apply	VBP
5180	1098	32	.	.	.
5180	1099	1	See	see	VB
5180	1099	2	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
5180	1099	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1099	4	Rector	Rector	NNP
5180	1099	5	&	&	CC
5180	1099	6	Visitors	Visitors	NNPS
5180	1099	7	of	of	IN
5180	1099	8	Univ	Univ	NNP
5180	1099	9	.	.	.
5180	1100	1	of	of	IN
5180	1100	2	Va.	Virginia	NNP
5180	1100	3	,	,	,
5180	1100	4	515	515	CD
5180	1100	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1100	6	819	819	CD
5180	1100	7	,	,	,
5180	1100	8	830	830	CD
5180	1100	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1100	10	1995	1995	CD
5180	1100	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1100	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1100	13	holding	hold	VBG
5180	1100	14	that	that	IN
5180	1100	15	a	a	DT
5180	1100	16	state	state	NN
5180	1100	17	university	university	NN
5180	1100	18	's	's	POS
5180	1100	19	student	student	NN
5180	1100	20	activities	activity	NNS
5180	1100	21	fund	fund	NN
5180	1100	22	"	"	''
5180	1100	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	1100	24	a	a	DT
5180	1100	25	forum	forum	NN
5180	1100	26	more	more	RBR
5180	1100	27	in	in	IN
5180	1100	28	a	a	DT
5180	1100	29	metaphysical	metaphysical	JJ
5180	1100	30	than	than	IN
5180	1100	31	a	a	DT
5180	1100	32	spatial	spatial	JJ
5180	1100	33	or	or	CC
5180	1100	34	geographic	geographic	JJ
5180	1100	35	sense	sense	NN
5180	1100	36	,	,	,
5180	1100	37	but	but	CC
5180	1100	38	the	the	DT
5180	1100	39	same	same	JJ
5180	1100	40	principles	principle	NNS
5180	1100	41	are	be	VBP
5180	1100	42	applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	1100	43	"	"	''
5180	1100	44	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1100	45	;	;	:
5180	1100	46	see	see	VB
5180	1100	47	also	also	RB
5180	1100	48	Cornelius	Cornelius	NNP
5180	1100	49	,	,	,
5180	1100	50	473	473	CD
5180	1100	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1100	52	at	at	IN
5180	1100	53	801	801	CD
5180	1100	54	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1100	55	identifying	identify	VBG
5180	1100	56	the	the	DT
5180	1100	57	Combined	Combined	NNP
5180	1100	58	Federal	Federal	NNP
5180	1100	59	Campaign	Campaign	NNP
5180	1100	60	charity	charity	NN
5180	1100	61	drive	drive	NN
5180	1100	62	as	as	IN
5180	1100	63	the	the	DT
5180	1100	64	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	1100	65	unit	unit	NN
5180	1100	66	of	of	IN
5180	1100	67	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	1100	68	for	for	IN
5180	1100	69	application	application	NN
5180	1100	70	of	of	IN
5180	1100	71	public	public	JJ
5180	1100	72	forum	forum	NN
5180	1100	73	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	1100	74	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1100	75	.	.	.
5180	1101	1	3	3	LS
5180	1101	2	.	.	.
5180	1102	1	Content	content	NN
5180	1102	2	-	-	HYPH
5180	1102	3	based	base	VBN
5180	1102	4	Restrictions	Restrictions	NNPS
5180	1102	5	in	in	IN
5180	1102	6	Designated	Designated	NNP
5180	1102	7	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1102	8	Fora	Fora	NNP
5180	1102	9	Unlike	unlike	IN
5180	1102	10	nonpublic	nonpublic	JJ
5180	1102	11	fora	fora	NN
5180	1102	12	such	such	JJ
5180	1102	13	as	as	IN
5180	1102	14	airport	airport	NN
5180	1102	15	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1102	16	,	,	,
5180	1102	17	see	see	VB
5180	1102	18	Int'l	Int'l	NNPS
5180	1102	19	Soc'y	Soc'y	NNP
5180	1102	20	for	for	IN
5180	1102	21	Krishna	Krishna	NNP
5180	1102	22	Consciousness	Consciousness	NNP
5180	1102	23	,	,	,
5180	1102	24	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1102	25	v.	v.	IN
5180	1102	26	Lee	Lee	NNP
5180	1102	27	,	,	,
5180	1102	28	505	505	CD
5180	1102	29	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1102	30	672	672	CD
5180	1102	31	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1102	32	1992	1992	CD
5180	1102	33	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1102	34	,	,	,
5180	1102	35	military	military	JJ
5180	1102	36	bases	basis	NNS
5180	1102	37	,	,	,
5180	1102	38	see	see	VB
5180	1102	39	Greer	Greer	NNP
5180	1102	40	v.	v.	IN
5180	1102	41	Spock	Spock	NNP
5180	1102	42	,	,	,
5180	1102	43	424	424	CD
5180	1102	44	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1102	45	828	828	CD
5180	1102	46	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1102	47	1976	1976	CD
5180	1102	48	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1102	49	,	,	,
5180	1102	50	jail	jail	NN
5180	1102	51	grounds	ground	NNS
5180	1102	52	,	,	,
5180	1102	53	see	see	VB
5180	1102	54	Adderley	Adderley	NNP
5180	1102	55	v.	v.	IN
5180	1102	56	Florida	Florida	NNP
5180	1102	57	,	,	,
5180	1102	58	385	385	CD
5180	1102	59	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1102	60	39	39	CD
5180	1102	61	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1102	62	1966	1966	CD
5180	1102	63	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1102	64	,	,	,
5180	1102	65	the	the	DT
5180	1102	66	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1102	67	workplace	workplace	NN
5180	1102	68	,	,	,
5180	1102	69	see	see	VB
5180	1102	70	Cornelius	Cornelius	NNP
5180	1102	71	v.	v.	IN
5180	1102	72	NAACP	NAACP	NNP
5180	1102	73	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	1102	74	Def	Def	NNP
5180	1102	75	.	.	.
5180	1103	1	&	&	CC
5180	1103	2	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	1103	3	.	.	.
5180	1104	1	Fund	Fund	NNP
5180	1104	2	,	,	,
5180	1104	3	473	473	CD
5180	1104	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1104	5	788	788	CD
5180	1104	6	,	,	,
5180	1104	7	805	805	CD
5180	1104	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1104	9	1985	1985	CD
5180	1104	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1104	11	,	,	,
5180	1104	12	and	and	CC
5180	1104	13	public	public	JJ
5180	1104	14	transit	transit	NN
5180	1104	15	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
5180	1104	16	,	,	,
5180	1104	17	see	see	VB
5180	1104	18	Lehman	Lehman	NNP
5180	1104	19	v.	v.	IN
5180	1104	20	City	City	NNP
5180	1104	21	of	of	IN
5180	1104	22	Shaker	Shaker	NNP
5180	1104	23	Heights	Heights	NNPS
5180	1104	24	,	,	,
5180	1104	25	418	418	CD
5180	1104	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1104	27	298	298	CD
5180	1104	28	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1104	29	1974	1974	CD
5180	1104	30	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1104	31	,	,	,
5180	1104	32	the	the	DT
5180	1104	33	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1104	34	of	of	IN
5180	1104	35	a	a	DT
5180	1104	36	public	public	JJ
5180	1104	37	library	library	NN
5180	1104	38	in	in	IN
5180	1104	39	general	general	JJ
5180	1104	40	,	,	,
5180	1104	41	and	and	CC
5180	1104	42	the	the	DT
5180	1104	43	provision	provision	NN
5180	1104	44	of	of	IN
5180	1104	45	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1104	46	access	access	NN
5180	1104	47	within	within	IN
5180	1104	48	a	a	DT
5180	1104	49	public	public	JJ
5180	1104	50	library	library	NN
5180	1104	51	in	in	IN
5180	1104	52	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1104	53	,	,	,
5180	1104	54	is	be	VBZ
5180	1104	55	"	"	``
5180	1104	56	for	for	IN
5180	1104	57	use	use	NN
5180	1104	58	by	by	IN
5180	1104	59	the	the	DT
5180	1104	60	public	public	NN
5180	1104	61	.	.	.
5180	1105	1	.	.	.
5180	1106	1	.	.	.
5180	1107	1	for	for	IN
5180	1107	2	expressive	expressive	JJ
5180	1107	3	activity	activity	NN
5180	1107	4	,	,	,
5180	1107	5	"	"	''
5180	1107	6	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	1107	7	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	1107	8	.	.	.
5180	1108	1	Ass'n	Ass'n	NFP
5180	1108	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	1108	3	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	1108	4	Local	Local	NNP
5180	1108	5	Educs	Educs	NNP
5180	1108	6	.	.	.
5180	1109	1	Ass'n	Ass'n	NFP
5180	1109	2	,	,	,
5180	1109	3	460	460	CD
5180	1109	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1109	5	37	37	CD
5180	1109	6	,	,	,
5180	1109	7	45	45	CD
5180	1109	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1109	9	1983	1983	CD
5180	1109	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1109	11	,	,	,
5180	1109	12	namely	namely	RB
5180	1109	13	,	,	,
5180	1109	14	the	the	DT
5180	1109	15	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1109	16	and	and	CC
5180	1109	17	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	1109	18	by	by	IN
5180	1109	19	the	the	DT
5180	1109	20	public	public	NN
5180	1109	21	of	of	IN
5180	1109	22	a	a	DT
5180	1109	23	wide	wide	JJ
5180	1109	24	range	range	NN
5180	1109	25	of	of	IN
5180	1109	26	information	information	NN
5180	1109	27	.	.	.
5180	1110	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1110	2	are	be	VBP
5180	1110	3	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
5180	1110	4	that	that	IN
5180	1110	5	when	when	WRB
5180	1110	6	the	the	DT
5180	1110	7	government	government	NN
5180	1110	8	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	1110	9	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1110	10	access	access	NN
5180	1110	11	in	in	IN
5180	1110	12	a	a	DT
5180	1110	13	public	public	JJ
5180	1110	14	library	library	NN
5180	1110	15	,	,	,
5180	1110	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1110	17	has	have	VBZ
5180	1110	18	created	create	VBN
5180	1110	19	a	a	DT
5180	1110	20	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1110	21	public	public	JJ
5180	1110	22	forum	forum	NN
5180	1110	23	.	.	.
5180	1111	1	See	see	VB
5180	1111	2	Mainstream	Mainstream	NNP
5180	1111	3	Loudoun	Loudoun	NNP
5180	1111	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	1111	5	Bd	Bd	NNP
5180	1111	6	.	.	.
5180	1112	1	of	of	IN
5180	1112	2	Trustees	Trustees	NNPS
5180	1112	3	of	of	IN
5180	1112	4	the	the	DT
5180	1112	5	Loudoun	Loudoun	NNP
5180	1112	6	County	County	NNP
5180	1112	7	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1112	8	,	,	,
5180	1112	9	24	24	CD
5180	1112	10	F.	F.	NNP
5180	1112	11	Supp	Supp	NNP
5180	1112	12	.	.	.
5180	1113	1	2d	2d	IN
5180	1113	2	552	552	CD
5180	1113	3	,	,	,
5180	1113	4	563	563	CD
5180	1113	5	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1113	6	E.D.	E.D.	NNP
5180	1114	1	Va.	Virginia	NNP
5180	1114	2	1998	1998	CD
5180	1114	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1114	4	;	;	:
5180	1114	5	cf	cf	NN
5180	1114	6	.	.	.
5180	1115	1	Kreimer	Kreimer	NNP
5180	1115	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1115	3	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
5180	1115	4	of	of	IN
5180	1115	5	Police	Police	NNP
5180	1115	6	,	,	,
5180	1115	7	958	958	CD
5180	1115	8	F.2d	F.2d	NNP
5180	1115	9	1242	1242	CD
5180	1115	10	,	,	,
5180	1115	11	1259	1259	CD
5180	1115	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1115	13	3d	3d	NNP
5180	1115	14	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	1115	15	.	.	.
5180	1116	1	1992	1992	CD
5180	1116	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1116	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1116	4	holding	hold	VBG
5180	1116	5	that	that	IN
5180	1116	6	a	a	DT
5180	1116	7	public	public	JJ
5180	1116	8	library	library	NN
5180	1116	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	1116	10	a	a	DT
5180	1116	11	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1116	12	public	public	JJ
5180	1116	13	forum	forum	NN
5180	1116	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1116	15	.	.	.
5180	1117	1	Relying	rely	VBG
5180	1117	2	on	on	IN
5180	1117	3	those	those	DT
5180	1117	4	cases	case	NNS
5180	1117	5	that	that	WDT
5180	1117	6	have	have	VBP
5180	1117	7	recognized	recognize	VBN
5180	1117	8	that	that	IN
5180	1117	9	government	government	NN
5180	1117	10	has	have	VBZ
5180	1117	11	leeway	leeway	NN
5180	1117	12	,	,	,
5180	1117	13	under	under	IN
5180	1117	14	the	the	DT
5180	1117	15	First	First	NNP
5180	1117	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1117	17	,	,	,
5180	1117	18	to	to	TO
5180	1117	19	limit	limit	VB
5180	1117	20	use	use	NN
5180	1117	21	of	of	IN
5180	1117	22	a	a	DT
5180	1117	23	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1117	24	public	public	JJ
5180	1117	25	forum	forum	NN
5180	1117	26	to	to	IN
5180	1117	27	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1117	28	specified	specified	JJ
5180	1117	29	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1117	30	,	,	,
5180	1117	31	and	and	CC
5180	1117	32	that	that	IN
5180	1117	33	content	content	NN
5180	1117	34	-	-	HYPH
5180	1117	35	based	base	VBN
5180	1117	36	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1117	37	on	on	IN
5180	1117	38	speech	speech	NN
5180	1117	39	that	that	WDT
5180	1117	40	are	be	VBP
5180	1117	41	consistent	consistent	JJ
5180	1117	42	with	with	IN
5180	1117	43	those	those	DT
5180	1117	44	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1117	45	are	be	VBP
5180	1117	46	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1117	47	only	only	RB
5180	1117	48	to	to	IN
5180	1117	49	rational	rational	JJ
5180	1117	50	basis	basis	NN
5180	1117	51	review	review	NN
5180	1117	52	,	,	,
5180	1117	53	the	the	DT
5180	1117	54	government	government	NN
5180	1117	55	argues	argue	VBZ
5180	1117	56	for	for	IN
5180	1117	57	application	application	NN
5180	1117	58	of	of	IN
5180	1117	59	rational	rational	JJ
5180	1117	60	basis	basis	NN
5180	1117	61	review	review	NN
5180	1117	62	to	to	IN
5180	1117	63	public	public	JJ
5180	1117	64	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1117	65	'	'	POS
5180	1117	66	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1117	67	about	about	IN
5180	1117	68	which	which	WDT
5180	1117	69	content	content	NN
5180	1117	70	to	to	TO
5180	1117	71	make	make	VB
5180	1117	72	available	available	JJ
5180	1117	73	to	to	IN
5180	1117	74	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1117	75	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1117	76	via	via	IN
5180	1117	77	the	the	DT
5180	1117	78	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1117	79	.	.	.
5180	1118	1	See	see	VB
5180	1118	2	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
5180	1118	3	,	,	,
5180	1118	4	515	515	CD
5180	1118	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1118	6	819	819	CD
5180	1118	7	,	,	,
5180	1118	8	829	829	CD
5180	1118	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1118	10	1995	1995	CD
5180	1118	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1118	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1118	13	"	"	``
5180	1118	14	The	the	DT
5180	1118	15	necessities	necessity	NNS
5180	1118	16	of	of	IN
5180	1118	17	confining	confine	VBG
5180	1118	18	a	a	DT
5180	1118	19	forum	forum	NN
5180	1118	20	to	to	IN
5180	1118	21	the	the	DT
5180	1118	22	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1118	23	and	and	CC
5180	1118	24	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1118	25	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1118	26	for	for	IN
5180	1118	27	which	which	WDT
5180	1118	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1118	29	was	be	VBD
5180	1118	30	created	create	VBN
5180	1118	31	may	may	MD
5180	1118	32	justify	justify	VB
5180	1118	33	the	the	DT
5180	1118	34	State	State	NNP
5180	1118	35	in	in	IN
5180	1118	36	reserving	reserve	VBG
5180	1118	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1118	38	for	for	IN
5180	1118	39	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1118	40	groups	group	NNS
5180	1118	41	or	or	CC
5180	1118	42	for	for	IN
5180	1118	43	the	the	DT
5180	1118	44	discussion	discussion	NN
5180	1118	45	of	of	IN
5180	1118	46	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1118	47	topics	topic	NNS
5180	1118	48	.	.	.
5180	1119	1	")	")	``
5180	1119	2	;	;	:
5180	1119	3	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	1119	4	,	,	,
5180	1119	5	460	460	CD
5180	1119	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1119	7	at	at	IN
5180	1119	8	46	46	CD
5180	1119	9	n.7	n.7	NNS
5180	1119	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1119	11	1983	1983	CD
5180	1119	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1119	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1119	14	"	"	``
5180	1119	15	A	a	DT
5180	1119	16	public	public	JJ
5180	1119	17	forum	forum	NN
5180	1119	18	may	may	MD
5180	1119	19	be	be	VB
5180	1119	20	created	create	VBN
5180	1119	21	for	for	IN
5180	1119	22	a	a	DT
5180	1119	23	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1119	24	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1119	25	such	such	JJ
5180	1119	26	as	as	IN
5180	1119	27	use	use	NN
5180	1119	28	by	by	IN
5180	1119	29	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1119	30	groups	group	NNS
5180	1119	31	.	.	.
5180	1120	1	.	.	.
5180	1121	1	.	.	.
5180	1122	1	or	or	CC
5180	1122	2	for	for	IN
5180	1122	3	the	the	DT
5180	1122	4	discussion	discussion	NN
5180	1122	5	of	of	IN
5180	1122	6	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1122	7	subjects	subject	NNS
5180	1122	8	.	.	.
5180	1122	9	"	"	''
5180	1122	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1122	11	.	.	.
5180	1123	1	In	in	IN
5180	1123	2	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1123	3	,	,	,
5180	1123	4	the	the	DT
5180	1123	5	government	government	NN
5180	1123	6	forcefully	forcefully	RB
5180	1123	7	argues	argue	VBZ
5180	1123	8	that	that	IN
5180	1123	9	a	a	DT
5180	1123	10	public	public	JJ
5180	1123	11	library	library	NN
5180	1123	12	's	's	POS
5180	1123	13	decision	decision	NN
5180	1123	14	to	to	TO
5180	1123	15	limit	limit	VB
5180	1123	16	the	the	DT
5180	1123	17	content	content	NN
5180	1123	18	of	of	IN
5180	1123	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1123	20	digital	digital	JJ
5180	1123	21	offerings	offering	NNS
5180	1123	22	on	on	IN
5180	1123	23	the	the	DT
5180	1123	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1123	25	should	should	MD
5180	1123	26	be	be	VB
5180	1123	27	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1123	28	to	to	IN
5180	1123	29	no	no	DT
5180	1123	30	stricter	strict	JJR
5180	1123	31	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1123	32	than	than	IN
5180	1123	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1123	34	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1123	35	about	about	IN
5180	1123	36	what	what	WDT
5180	1123	37	content	content	NN
5180	1123	38	to	to	TO
5180	1123	39	make	make	VB
5180	1123	40	available	available	JJ
5180	1123	41	to	to	IN
5180	1123	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1123	43	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1123	44	through	through	IN
5180	1123	45	the	the	DT
5180	1123	46	library	library	NN
5180	1123	47	's	's	POS
5180	1123	48	print	print	NN
5180	1123	49	collection	collection	NN
5180	1123	50	.	.	.
5180	1124	1	According	accord	VBG
5180	1124	2	to	to	IN
5180	1124	3	the	the	DT
5180	1124	4	government	government	NN
5180	1124	5	,	,	,
5180	1124	6	just	just	RB
5180	1124	7	as	as	IN
5180	1124	8	a	a	DT
5180	1124	9	public	public	JJ
5180	1124	10	library	library	NN
5180	1124	11	may	may	MD
5180	1124	12	choose	choose	VB
5180	1124	13	to	to	TO
5180	1124	14	acquire	acquire	VB
5180	1124	15	books	book	NNS
5180	1124	16	about	about	IN
5180	1124	17	gardening	garden	VBG
5180	1124	18	but	but	CC
5180	1124	19	not	not	RB
5180	1124	20	golf	golf	NN
5180	1124	21	,	,	,
5180	1124	22	without	without	IN
5180	1124	23	having	have	VBG
5180	1124	24	to	to	TO
5180	1124	25	show	show	VB
5180	1124	26	that	that	IN
5180	1124	27	this	this	DT
5180	1124	28	content	content	NN
5180	1124	29	-	-	HYPH
5180	1124	30	based	base	VBN
5180	1124	31	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1124	32	on	on	IN
5180	1124	33	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1124	34	'	'	POS
5180	1124	35	access	access	NN
5180	1124	36	to	to	IN
5180	1124	37	speech	speech	NN
5180	1124	38	is	be	VBZ
5180	1124	39	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1124	40	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1124	41	to	to	TO
5180	1124	42	further	further	RB
5180	1124	43	a	a	DT
5180	1124	44	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1124	45	state	state	NN
5180	1124	46	interest	interest	NN
5180	1124	47	,	,	,
5180	1124	48	so	so	RB
5180	1124	49	may	may	MD
5180	1124	50	a	a	DT
5180	1124	51	public	public	JJ
5180	1124	52	library	library	NN
5180	1124	53	make	make	VBP
5180	1124	54	content	content	NN
5180	1124	55	-	-	HYPH
5180	1124	56	based	base	VBN
5180	1124	57	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1124	58	about	about	IN
5180	1124	59	which	which	WDT
5180	1124	60	speech	speech	NN
5180	1124	61	to	to	TO
5180	1124	62	make	make	VB
5180	1124	63	available	available	JJ
5180	1124	64	on	on	IN
5180	1124	65	the	the	DT
5180	1124	66	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1124	67	,	,	,
5180	1124	68	without	without	IN
5180	1124	69	having	have	VBG
5180	1124	70	to	to	TO
5180	1124	71	show	show	VB
5180	1124	72	that	that	IN
5180	1124	73	such	such	PDT
5180	1124	74	a	a	DT
5180	1124	75	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1124	76	satisfies	satisfie	NNS
5180	1124	77	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1124	78	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1124	79	.	.	.
5180	1125	1	Plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1125	2	respond	respond	VBP
5180	1125	3	that	that	IN
5180	1125	4	the	the	DT
5180	1125	5	government	government	NN
5180	1125	6	's	's	POS
5180	1125	7	ability	ability	NN
5180	1125	8	to	to	TO
5180	1125	9	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	1125	10	the	the	DT
5180	1125	11	content	content	NN
5180	1125	12	of	of	IN
5180	1125	13	speech	speech	NN
5180	1125	14	in	in	IN
5180	1125	15	a	a	DT
5180	1125	16	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1125	17	public	public	JJ
5180	1125	18	forum	forum	NN
5180	1125	19	by	by	IN
5180	1125	20	restricting	restrict	VBG
5180	1125	21	the	the	DT
5180	1125	22	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1125	23	of	of	IN
5180	1125	24	the	the	DT
5180	1125	25	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1125	26	public	public	JJ
5180	1125	27	forum	forum	NN
5180	1125	28	that	that	IN
5180	1125	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1125	30	creates	create	VBZ
5180	1125	31	is	be	VBZ
5180	1125	32	not	not	RB
5180	1125	33	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	1125	34	.	.	.
5180	1126	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1126	2	.	.	.
5180	1127	1	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	1127	2	Servs	Servs	NNP
5180	1127	3	.	.	.
5180	1128	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
5180	1128	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1128	3	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	1128	4	,	,	,
5180	1128	5	531	531	CD
5180	1128	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1128	7	533	533	CD
5180	1128	8	,	,	,
5180	1128	9	547	547	CD
5180	1128	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1128	11	2001	2001	CD
5180	1128	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1128	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1128	14	"	"	``
5180	1128	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1128	16	can	can	MD
5180	1128	17	not	not	RB
5180	1128	18	recast	recast	VB
5180	1128	19	a	a	DT
5180	1128	20	condition	condition	NN
5180	1128	21	on	on	IN
5180	1128	22	funding	funding	NN
5180	1128	23	as	as	IN
5180	1128	24	a	a	DT
5180	1128	25	mere	mere	JJ
5180	1128	26	definition	definition	NN
5180	1128	27	of	of	IN
5180	1128	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1128	29	program	program	NN
5180	1128	30	in	in	IN
5180	1128	31	every	every	DT
5180	1128	32	case	case	NN
5180	1128	33	,	,	,
5180	1128	34	lest	lest	IN
5180	1128	35	the	the	DT
5180	1128	36	First	First	NNP
5180	1128	37	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1128	38	be	be	VB
5180	1128	39	reduced	reduce	VBN
5180	1128	40	to	to	IN
5180	1128	41	a	a	DT
5180	1128	42	simple	simple	JJ
5180	1128	43	semantic	semantic	JJ
5180	1128	44	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	1128	45	.	.	.
5180	1128	46	"	"	''
5180	1128	47	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1128	48	.	.	.
5180	1129	1	As	as	IN
5180	1129	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
5180	1129	3	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
5180	1129	4	has	have	VBZ
5180	1129	5	explained	explain	VBN
5180	1129	6	:	:	:
5180	1129	7	If	if	IN
5180	1129	8	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1129	9	has	have	VBZ
5180	1129	10	a	a	DT
5180	1129	11	freer	free	JJR
5180	1129	12	hand	hand	NN
5180	1129	13	to	to	TO
5180	1129	14	draw	draw	VB
5180	1129	15	content	content	NN
5180	1129	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	1129	17	based	base	VBN
5180	1129	18	distinctions	distinction	NNS
5180	1129	19	in	in	IN
5180	1129	20	limiting	limit	VBG
5180	1129	21	a	a	DT
5180	1129	22	forum	forum	NN
5180	1129	23	than	than	IN
5180	1129	24	in	in	IN
5180	1129	25	excluding	exclude	VBG
5180	1129	26	someone	someone	NN
5180	1129	27	from	from	IN
5180	1129	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1129	29	,	,	,
5180	1129	30	the	the	DT
5180	1129	31	First	First	NNP
5180	1129	32	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1129	33	would	would	MD
5180	1129	34	be	be	VB
5180	1129	35	a	a	DT
5180	1129	36	dead	dead	JJ
5180	1129	37	letter	letter	NN
5180	1129	38	in	in	IN
5180	1129	39	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1129	40	public	public	JJ
5180	1129	41	forums	forum	NNS
5180	1129	42	;	;	:
5180	1129	43	every	every	DT
5180	1129	44	exclusion	exclusion	NN
5180	1129	45	could	could	MD
5180	1129	46	be	be	VB
5180	1129	47	recast	recast	VBN
5180	1129	48	as	as	IN
5180	1129	49	a	a	DT
5180	1129	50	limitation	limitation	NN
5180	1129	51	.	.	.
5180	1130	1	.	.	.
5180	1131	1	.	.	.
5180	1132	1	.	.	.
5180	1133	1	The	the	DT
5180	1133	2	power	power	NN
5180	1133	3	to	to	TO
5180	1133	4	limit	limit	VB
5180	1133	5	or	or	CC
5180	1133	6	redefine	redefine	VB
5180	1133	7	forums	forum	NNS
5180	1133	8	for	for	IN
5180	1133	9	a	a	DT
5180	1133	10	specific	specific	JJ
5180	1133	11	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1133	12	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1133	13	does	do	VBZ
5180	1133	14	not	not	RB
5180	1133	15	allow	allow	VB
5180	1133	16	the	the	DT
5180	1133	17	government	government	NN
5180	1133	18	to	to	TO
5180	1133	19	exclude	exclude	VB
5180	1133	20	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1133	21	speech	speech	NN
5180	1133	22	or	or	CC
5180	1133	23	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1133	24	from	from	IN
5180	1133	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1133	26	for	for	IN
5180	1133	27	any	any	DT
5180	1133	28	reason	reason	NN
5180	1133	29	at	at	RB
5180	1133	30	all	all	RB
5180	1133	31	.	.	.
5180	1134	1	Denver	Denver	NNP
5180	1134	2	Area	Area	NNP
5180	1134	3	Telecomm	Telecomm	NNP
5180	1134	4	.	.	.
5180	1135	1	Consortium	Consortium	NNP
5180	1135	2	,	,	,
5180	1135	3	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1135	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	1135	5	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	1135	6	,	,	,
5180	1135	7	518	518	CD
5180	1135	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1135	9	727	727	CD
5180	1135	10	,	,	,
5180	1135	11	801	801	CD
5180	1135	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1135	13	1996	1996	CD
5180	1135	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1135	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1135	16	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
5180	1135	17	,	,	,
5180	1135	18	J.	J.	NNP
5180	1135	19	,	,	,
5180	1135	20	concurring	concur	VBG
5180	1135	21	in	in	IN
5180	1135	22	the	the	DT
5180	1135	23	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1135	24	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1135	25	.	.	.
5180	1136	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1136	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1136	3	agree	agree	VBP
5180	1136	4	with	with	IN
5180	1136	5	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1136	6	that	that	WDT
5180	1136	7	the	the	DT
5180	1136	8	First	First	NNP
5180	1136	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1136	10	imposes	impose	VBZ
5180	1136	11	some	some	DT
5180	1136	12	limits	limit	NNS
5180	1136	13	on	on	IN
5180	1136	14	the	the	DT
5180	1136	15	state	state	NN
5180	1136	16	's	's	POS
5180	1136	17	ability	ability	NN
5180	1136	18	to	to	TO
5180	1136	19	adopt	adopt	VB
5180	1136	20	content	content	NN
5180	1136	21	-	-	HYPH
5180	1136	22	based	base	VBN
5180	1136	23	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1136	24	in	in	IN
5180	1136	25	defining	define	VBG
5180	1136	26	the	the	DT
5180	1136	27	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1136	28	of	of	IN
5180	1136	29	a	a	DT
5180	1136	30	public	public	JJ
5180	1136	31	forum	forum	NN
5180	1136	32	,	,	,
5180	1136	33	precisely	precisely	RB
5180	1136	34	what	what	WP
5180	1136	35	those	those	DT
5180	1136	36	limits	limit	NNS
5180	1136	37	are	be	VBP
5180	1136	38	is	be	VBZ
5180	1136	39	unclear	unclear	JJ
5180	1136	40	,	,	,
5180	1136	41	and	and	CC
5180	1136	42	presents	present	VBZ
5180	1136	43	a	a	DT
5180	1136	44	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	1136	45	problem	problem	NN
5180	1136	46	in	in	IN
5180	1136	47	First	First	NNP
5180	1136	48	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1136	49	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
5180	1136	50	.	.	.
5180	1137	1	The	the	DT
5180	1137	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1137	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1137	4	's	's	POS
5180	1137	5	"	"	``
5180	1137	6	cases	case	NNS
5180	1137	7	have	have	VBP
5180	1137	8	not	not	RB
5180	1137	9	yet	yet	RB
5180	1137	10	determined	determine	VBN
5180	1137	11	.	.	.
5180	1138	1	.	.	.
5180	1139	1	.	.	.
5180	1140	1	that	that	DT
5180	1140	2	government	government	NN
5180	1140	3	's	's	POS
5180	1140	4	decision	decision	NN
5180	1140	5	to	to	TO
5180	1140	6	dedicate	dedicate	VB
5180	1140	7	a	a	DT
5180	1140	8	public	public	JJ
5180	1140	9	forum	forum	NN
5180	1140	10	to	to	IN
5180	1140	11	one	one	CD
5180	1140	12	type	type	NN
5180	1140	13	of	of	IN
5180	1140	14	content	content	NN
5180	1140	15	or	or	CC
5180	1140	16	another	another	DT
5180	1140	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	1140	18	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	1140	19	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1140	20	to	to	IN
5180	1140	21	the	the	DT
5180	1140	22	highest	high	JJS
5180	1140	23	level	level	NN
5180	1140	24	of	of	IN
5180	1140	25	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1140	26	.	.	.
5180	1141	1	Must	Must	MD
5180	1141	2	a	a	DT
5180	1141	3	local	local	JJ
5180	1141	4	government	government	NN
5180	1141	5	,	,	,
5180	1141	6	for	for	IN
5180	1141	7	example	example	NN
5180	1141	8	,	,	,
5180	1141	9	show	show	VBP
5180	1141	10	a	a	DT
5180	1141	11	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1141	12	state	state	NN
5180	1141	13	interest	interest	NN
5180	1141	14	if	if	IN
5180	1141	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1141	16	builds	build	VBZ
5180	1141	17	a	a	DT
5180	1141	18	band	band	NN
5180	1141	19	shell	shell	NN
5180	1141	20	in	in	IN
5180	1141	21	the	the	DT
5180	1141	22	park	park	NN
5180	1141	23	and	and	CC
5180	1141	24	dedicates	dedicate	VBZ
5180	1141	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1141	26	solely	solely	RB
5180	1141	27	to	to	IN
5180	1141	28	classical	classical	JJ
5180	1141	29	music	music	NN
5180	1141	30	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1141	31	but	but	CC
5180	1141	32	not	not	RB
5180	1141	33	to	to	TO
5180	1141	34	jazz	jazz	NN
5180	1141	35	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1141	36	?	?	.
5180	1142	1	The	the	DT
5180	1142	2	answer	answer	NN
5180	1142	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1142	4	not	not	RB
5180	1142	5	obvious	obvious	JJ
5180	1142	6	.	.	.
5180	1142	7	"	"	''
5180	1143	1	Denver	Denver	NNP
5180	1143	2	,	,	,
5180	1143	3	518	518	CD
5180	1143	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1143	5	at	at	IN
5180	1143	6	750	750	CD
5180	1143	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1143	8	plurality	plurality	NN
5180	1143	9	opinion	opinion	NN
5180	1143	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1143	11	;	;	:
5180	1143	12	see	see	VB
5180	1143	13	also	also	RB
5180	1143	14	Southeastern	Southeastern	NNP
5180	1143	15	Promotions	Promotions	NNP
5180	1143	16	,	,	,
5180	1143	17	Ltd.	Ltd.	NNP
5180	1143	18	v.	v.	IN
5180	1143	19	Conrad	Conrad	NNP
5180	1143	20	,	,	,
5180	1143	21	420	420	CD
5180	1143	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1143	23	546	546	CD
5180	1143	24	,	,	,
5180	1143	25	572	572	CD
5180	1143	26	-	-	SYM
5180	1143	27	73	73	CD
5180	1143	28	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1143	29	1975	1975	CD
5180	1143	30	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1143	31	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1143	32	Rehnquist	Rehnquist	NNP
5180	1143	33	,	,	,
5180	1143	34	J.	J.	NNP
5180	1143	35	,	,	,
5180	1143	36	dissenting	dissent	VBG
5180	1143	37	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1143	38	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1143	39	"	"	``
5180	1143	40	May	May	MD
5180	1143	41	an	an	DT
5180	1143	42	opera	opera	NN
5180	1143	43	house	house	NN
5180	1143	44	limit	limit	VB
5180	1143	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1143	46	productions	production	NNS
5180	1143	47	to	to	IN
5180	1143	48	operas	opera	NNS
5180	1143	49	,	,	,
5180	1143	50	or	or	CC
5180	1143	51	must	must	MD
5180	1143	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1143	53	also	also	RB
5180	1143	54	show	show	VB
5180	1143	55	rock	rock	NN
5180	1143	56	musicals	musical	NNS
5180	1143	57	?	?	.
5180	1144	1	May	May	MD
5180	1144	2	a	a	DT
5180	1144	3	municipal	municipal	JJ
5180	1144	4	theater	theater	NN
5180	1144	5	devote	devote	NN
5180	1144	6	an	an	DT
5180	1144	7	entire	entire	JJ
5180	1144	8	season	season	NN
5180	1144	9	to	to	IN
5180	1144	10	Shakespeare	Shakespeare	NNP
5180	1144	11	,	,	,
5180	1144	12	or	or	CC
5180	1144	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	1144	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1144	15	required	require	VBN
5180	1144	16	to	to	TO
5180	1144	17	book	book	VB
5180	1144	18	any	any	DT
5180	1144	19	potential	potential	JJ
5180	1144	20	producer	producer	NN
5180	1144	21	on	on	IN
5180	1144	22	a	a	DT
5180	1144	23	first	first	JJ
5180	1144	24	come	come	NN
5180	1144	25	,	,	,
5180	1144	26	first	first	RB
5180	1144	27	served	serve	VBN
5180	1144	28	basis	basis	NN
5180	1144	29	?	?	.
5180	1144	30	"	"	''
5180	1144	31	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1144	32	.	.	.
5180	1145	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1145	2	believe	believe	VBP
5180	1145	3	,	,	,
5180	1145	4	however	however	RB
5180	1145	5	,	,	,
5180	1145	6	that	that	IN
5180	1145	7	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1145	8	principles	principle	NNS
5180	1145	9	emerge	emerge	VBP
5180	1145	10	from	from	IN
5180	1145	11	the	the	DT
5180	1145	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1145	13	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1145	14	's	's	POS
5180	1145	15	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
5180	1145	16	on	on	IN
5180	1145	17	this	this	DT
5180	1145	18	question	question	NN
5180	1145	19	.	.	.
5180	1146	1	In	in	IN
5180	1146	2	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1146	3	,	,	,
5180	1146	4	and	and	CC
5180	1146	5	perhaps	perhaps	RB
5180	1146	6	somewhat	somewhat	RB
5180	1146	7	counterintuitively	counterintuitively	RB
5180	1146	8	,	,	,
5180	1146	9	the	the	DT
5180	1146	10	more	more	RBR
5180	1146	11	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1146	12	the	the	DT
5180	1146	13	range	range	NN
5180	1146	14	of	of	IN
5180	1146	15	speech	speech	NN
5180	1146	16	that	that	WDT
5180	1146	17	the	the	DT
5180	1146	18	government	government	NN
5180	1146	19	chooses	choose	VBZ
5180	1146	20	to	to	TO
5180	1146	21	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	1146	22	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1146	23	whether	whether	IN
5180	1146	24	directly	directly	RB
5180	1146	25	,	,	,
5180	1146	26	through	through	IN
5180	1146	27	government	government	NN
5180	1146	28	grants	grant	NNS
5180	1146	29	or	or	CC
5180	1146	30	other	other	JJ
5180	1146	31	funding	funding	NN
5180	1146	32	,	,	,
5180	1146	33	or	or	CC
5180	1146	34	indirectly	indirectly	RB
5180	1146	35	,	,	,
5180	1146	36	through	through	IN
5180	1146	37	the	the	DT
5180	1146	38	creation	creation	NN
5180	1146	39	of	of	IN
5180	1146	40	a	a	DT
5180	1146	41	public	public	JJ
5180	1146	42	forum	forum	NN
5180	1146	43	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1146	44	the	the	DT
5180	1146	45	more	more	JJR
5180	1146	46	deference	deference	NN
5180	1146	47	the	the	DT
5180	1146	48	First	First	NNP
5180	1146	49	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1146	50	accords	accord	VBZ
5180	1146	51	the	the	DT
5180	1146	52	government	government	NN
5180	1146	53	in	in	IN
5180	1146	54	drawing	draw	VBG
5180	1146	55	content	content	NN
5180	1146	56	-	-	HYPH
5180	1146	57	based	base	VBN
5180	1146	58	distinctions	distinction	NNS
5180	1146	59	.	.	.
5180	1147	1	At	at	IN
5180	1147	2	one	one	CD
5180	1147	3	extreme	extreme	NN
5180	1147	4	lies	lie	VBZ
5180	1147	5	the	the	DT
5180	1147	6	government	government	NN
5180	1147	7	's	's	POS
5180	1147	8	decision	decision	NN
5180	1147	9	to	to	TO
5180	1147	10	fund	fund	VB
5180	1147	11	a	a	DT
5180	1147	12	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1147	13	message	message	NN
5180	1147	14	that	that	IN
5180	1147	15	the	the	DT
5180	1147	16	government	government	NN
5180	1147	17	seeks	seek	VBZ
5180	1147	18	to	to	TO
5180	1147	19	disseminate	disseminate	VB
5180	1147	20	.	.	.
5180	1148	1	In	in	IN
5180	1148	2	this	this	DT
5180	1148	3	context	context	NN
5180	1148	4	,	,	,
5180	1148	5	content	content	NN
5180	1148	6	-	-	HYPH
5180	1148	7	based	base	VBN
5180	1148	8	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1148	9	on	on	IN
5180	1148	10	the	the	DT
5180	1148	11	speech	speech	NN
5180	1148	12	that	that	WDT
5180	1148	13	government	government	NN
5180	1148	14	chooses	choose	VBZ
5180	1148	15	to	to	TO
5180	1148	16	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	1148	17	are	be	VBP
5180	1148	18	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	1148	19	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1148	20	to	to	IN
5180	1148	21	at	at	IN
5180	1148	22	most	most	JJS
5180	1148	23	rational	rational	JJ
5180	1148	24	basis	basis	NN
5180	1148	25	review	review	NN
5180	1148	26	,	,	,
5180	1148	27	and	and	CC
5180	1148	28	even	even	RB
5180	1148	29	viewpoint	viewpoint	VB
5180	1148	30	discrimination	discrimination	NN
5180	1148	31	is	be	VBZ
5180	1148	32	permissible	permissible	JJ
5180	1148	33	.	.	.
5180	1149	1	For	for	IN
5180	1149	2	example	example	NN
5180	1149	3	,	,	,
5180	1149	4	"	"	''
5180	1149	5	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1149	6	w]hen	w]hen	WRB
5180	1149	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1149	8	established	establish	VBD
5180	1149	9	a	a	DT
5180	1149	10	National	National	NNP
5180	1149	11	Endowment	Endowment	NNP
5180	1149	12	for	for	IN
5180	1149	13	Democracy	Democracy	NNP
5180	1149	14	to	to	TO
5180	1149	15	encourage	encourage	VB
5180	1149	16	other	other	JJ
5180	1149	17	countries	country	NNS
5180	1149	18	to	to	TO
5180	1149	19	adopt	adopt	VB
5180	1149	20	democratic	democratic	JJ
5180	1149	21	principles	principle	NNS
5180	1149	22	,	,	,
5180	1149	23	22	22	CD
5180	1149	24	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1150	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1150	2	.	.	.
5180	1151	1	4411(b	4411(b	LS
5180	1151	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1151	3	,	,	,
5180	1151	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1151	5	was	be	VBD
5180	1151	6	not	not	RB
5180	1151	7	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1151	8	required	require	VBN
5180	1151	9	to	to	TO
5180	1151	10	fund	fund	VB
5180	1151	11	a	a	DT
5180	1151	12	program	program	NN
5180	1151	13	to	to	TO
5180	1151	14	encourage	encourage	VB
5180	1151	15	competing	compete	VBG
5180	1151	16	lines	line	NNS
5180	1151	17	of	of	IN
5180	1151	18	political	political	JJ
5180	1151	19	philosophy	philosophy	NN
5180	1151	20	such	such	JJ
5180	1151	21	as	as	IN
5180	1151	22	communism	communism	NN
5180	1151	23	and	and	CC
5180	1151	24	fascism	fascism	NN
5180	1151	25	.	.	.
5180	1151	26	"	"	''
5180	1152	1	Rust	rust	VB
5180	1152	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1152	3	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
5180	1152	4	,	,	,
5180	1152	5	500	500	CD
5180	1152	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1152	7	173	173	CD
5180	1152	8	,	,	,
5180	1152	9	194	194	CD
5180	1152	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1152	11	1991	1991	CD
5180	1152	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1152	13	;	;	:
5180	1152	14	see	see	VB
5180	1152	15	also	also	RB
5180	1152	16	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	1152	17	,	,	,
5180	1152	18	531	531	CD
5180	1152	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1152	20	at	at	IN
5180	1152	21	541	541	CD
5180	1152	22	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1152	23	"	"	``
5180	1152	24	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1152	25	V]iewpoint	V]iewpoint	NNP
5180	1152	26	-	-	HYPH
5180	1152	27	based	base	VBN
5180	1152	28	funding	funding	NN
5180	1152	29	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1152	30	can	can	MD
5180	1152	31	be	be	VB
5180	1152	32	sustained	sustain	VBN
5180	1152	33	in	in	IN
5180	1152	34	instances	instance	NNS
5180	1152	35	in	in	IN
5180	1152	36	which	which	WDT
5180	1152	37	the	the	DT
5180	1152	38	government	government	NN
5180	1152	39	is	be	VBZ
5180	1152	40	itself	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1152	41	the	the	DT
5180	1152	42	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	1152	43	,	,	,
5180	1152	44	or	or	CC
5180	1152	45	in	in	IN
5180	1152	46	instances	instance	NNS
5180	1152	47	,	,	,
5180	1152	48	like	like	IN
5180	1152	49	Rust	Rust	NNP
5180	1152	50	,	,	,
5180	1152	51	in	in	IN
5180	1152	52	which	which	WDT
5180	1152	53	the	the	DT
5180	1152	54	government	government	NN
5180	1152	55	used	use	VBD
5180	1152	56	private	private	JJ
5180	1152	57	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1152	58	to	to	TO
5180	1152	59	transmit	transmit	VB
5180	1152	60	information	information	NN
5180	1152	61	pertaining	pertain	VBG
5180	1152	62	to	to	IN
5180	1152	63	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1152	64	own	own	JJ
5180	1152	65	program	program	NN
5180	1152	66	.	.	.
5180	1152	67	"	"	''
5180	1152	68	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1153	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1153	2	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1153	3	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1153	4	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1153	5	and	and	CC
5180	1153	6	citation	citation	NN
5180	1153	7	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1153	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1153	9	.	.	.
5180	1154	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1154	2	not	not	RB
5180	1154	3	strictly	strictly	RB
5180	1154	4	controlling	control	VBG
5180	1154	5	,	,	,
5180	1154	6	the	the	DT
5180	1154	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1154	8	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1154	9	's	's	POS
5180	1154	10	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	1154	11	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	1154	12	cases	case	NNS
5180	1154	13	,	,	,
5180	1154	14	such	such	JJ
5180	1154	15	as	as	IN
5180	1154	16	Rust	Rust	NNP
5180	1154	17	and	and	CC
5180	1154	18	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	1154	19	,	,	,
5180	1154	20	are	be	VBP
5180	1154	21	instructive	instructive	JJ
5180	1154	22	for	for	IN
5180	1154	23	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1154	24	of	of	IN
5180	1154	25	analyzing	analyze	VBG
5180	1154	26	content	content	NN
5180	1154	27	-	-	HYPH
5180	1154	28	based	base	VBN
5180	1154	29	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1154	30	on	on	IN
5180	1154	31	the	the	DT
5180	1154	32	use	use	NN
5180	1154	33	of	of	IN
5180	1154	34	public	public	JJ
5180	1154	35	fora	fora	NN
5180	1154	36	.	.	.
5180	1155	1	This	this	DT
5180	1155	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	1155	3	because	because	IN
5180	1155	4	the	the	DT
5180	1155	5	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	1155	6	that	that	WDT
5180	1155	7	government	government	NN
5180	1155	8	places	place	NNS
5180	1155	9	on	on	IN
5180	1155	10	the	the	DT
5180	1155	11	use	use	NN
5180	1155	12	of	of	IN
5180	1155	13	a	a	DT
5180	1155	14	public	public	JJ
5180	1155	15	forum	forum	NN
5180	1155	16	can	can	MD
5180	1155	17	be	be	VB
5180	1155	18	conceptualized	conceptualize	VBN
5180	1155	19	as	as	IN
5180	1155	20	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	1155	21	that	that	IN
5180	1155	22	the	the	DT
5180	1155	23	government	government	NN
5180	1155	24	attaches	attach	VBZ
5180	1155	25	to	to	IN
5180	1155	26	the	the	DT
5180	1155	27	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	1155	28	of	of	IN
5180	1155	29	a	a	DT
5180	1155	30	benefit	benefit	NN
5180	1155	31	that	that	WDT
5180	1155	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1155	33	offers	offer	VBZ
5180	1155	34	,	,	,
5180	1155	35	namely	namely	RB
5180	1155	36	,	,	,
5180	1155	37	the	the	DT
5180	1155	38	use	use	NN
5180	1155	39	of	of	IN
5180	1155	40	government	government	NN
5180	1155	41	property	property	NN
5180	1155	42	.	.	.
5180	1156	1	Public	public	JJ
5180	1156	2	forum	forum	NN
5180	1156	3	cases	case	NNS
5180	1156	4	thus	thus	RB
5180	1156	5	resemble	resemble	VBP
5180	1156	6	those	those	DT
5180	1156	7	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	1156	8	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	1156	9	cases	case	NNS
5180	1156	10	involving	involve	VBG
5180	1156	11	First	First	NNP
5180	1156	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1156	13	challenges	challenge	VBZ
5180	1156	14	to	to	IN
5180	1156	15	the	the	DT
5180	1156	16	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	1156	17	that	that	WDT
5180	1156	18	the	the	DT
5180	1156	19	state	state	NN
5180	1156	20	places	place	NNS
5180	1156	21	on	on	IN
5180	1156	22	the	the	DT
5180	1156	23	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	1156	24	of	of	IN
5180	1156	25	a	a	DT
5180	1156	26	government	government	NN
5180	1156	27	benefit	benefit	NN
5180	1156	28	.	.	.
5180	1157	1	See	see	VB
5180	1157	2	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	1157	3	,	,	,
5180	1157	4	531	531	CD
5180	1157	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1157	6	at	at	IN
5180	1157	7	544	544	CD
5180	1157	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1157	9	"	"	``
5180	1157	10	As	as	IN
5180	1157	11	this	this	DT
5180	1157	12	suit	suit	NN
5180	1157	13	involves	involve	VBZ
5180	1157	14	a	a	DT
5180	1157	15	subsidy	subsidy	NN
5180	1157	16	,	,	,
5180	1157	17	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1157	18	forum	forum	NN
5180	1157	19	cases	case	NNS
5180	1157	20	.	.	.
5180	1158	1	.	.	.
5180	1159	1	.	.	.
5180	1160	1	may	may	MD
5180	1160	2	not	not	RB
5180	1160	3	be	be	VB
5180	1160	4	controlling	control	VBG
5180	1160	5	in	in	IN
5180	1160	6	the	the	DT
5180	1160	7	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1160	8	sense	sense	NN
5180	1160	9	,	,	,
5180	1160	10	yet	yet	CC
5180	1160	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1160	12	do	do	VBP
5180	1160	13	provide	provide	VB
5180	1160	14	some	some	DT
5180	1160	15	instruction	instruction	NN
5180	1160	16	.	.	.
5180	1160	17	"	"	''
5180	1160	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1160	19	.	.	.
5180	1161	1	Even	even	RB
5180	1161	2	when	when	WRB
5180	1161	3	the	the	DT
5180	1161	4	government	government	NN
5180	1161	5	does	do	VBZ
5180	1161	6	not	not	RB
5180	1161	7	fund	fund	VB
5180	1161	8	the	the	DT
5180	1161	9	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1161	10	of	of	IN
5180	1161	11	a	a	DT
5180	1161	12	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1161	13	government	government	NN
5180	1161	14	message	message	NN
5180	1161	15	,	,	,
5180	1161	16	the	the	DT
5180	1161	17	First	First	NNP
5180	1161	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1161	19	generally	generally	RB
5180	1161	20	permits	permit	VBZ
5180	1161	21	government	government	NN
5180	1161	22	,	,	,
5180	1161	23	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1161	24	to	to	IN
5180	1161	25	the	the	DT
5180	1161	26	constraints	constraint	NNS
5180	1161	27	of	of	IN
5180	1161	28	viewpoint	viewpoint	NN
5180	1161	29	neutrality	neutrality	NN
5180	1161	30	,	,	,
5180	1161	31	to	to	TO
5180	1161	32	create	create	VB
5180	1161	33	public	public	JJ
5180	1161	34	institutions	institution	NNS
5180	1161	35	such	such	JJ
5180	1161	36	as	as	IN
5180	1161	37	art	art	NN
5180	1161	38	museums	museum	NNS
5180	1161	39	and	and	CC
5180	1161	40	state	state	NN
5180	1161	41	universities	university	NNS
5180	1161	42	,	,	,
5180	1161	43	dedicated	dedicated	JJ
5180	1161	44	to	to	IN
5180	1161	45	facilitating	facilitate	VBG
5180	1161	46	the	the	DT
5180	1161	47	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1161	48	of	of	IN
5180	1161	49	private	private	JJ
5180	1161	50	speech	speech	NN
5180	1161	51	that	that	WDT
5180	1161	52	the	the	DT
5180	1161	53	government	government	NN
5180	1161	54	believes	believe	VBZ
5180	1161	55	to	to	TO
5180	1161	56	have	have	VB
5180	1161	57	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1161	58	merit	merit	NN
5180	1161	59	.	.	.
5180	1162	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1162	2	,	,	,
5180	1162	3	in	in	IN
5180	1162	4	NEA	NEA	NNP
5180	1162	5	v.	v.	IN
5180	1162	6	Finley	Finley	NNP
5180	1162	7	,	,	,
5180	1162	8	524	524	CD
5180	1162	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1162	10	569	569	CD
5180	1162	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1162	12	1998	1998	CD
5180	1162	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1162	14	,	,	,
5180	1162	15	the	the	DT
5180	1162	16	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1162	17	upheld	uphold	VBD
5180	1162	18	the	the	DT
5180	1162	19	use	use	NN
5180	1162	20	of	of	IN
5180	1162	21	content	content	NN
5180	1162	22	-	-	HYPH
5180	1162	23	based	base	VBN
5180	1162	24	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1162	25	in	in	IN
5180	1162	26	a	a	DT
5180	1162	27	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1162	28	program	program	NN
5180	1162	29	awarding	award	VBG
5180	1162	30	grants	grant	NNS
5180	1162	31	to	to	IN
5180	1162	32	artists	artist	NNS
5180	1162	33	on	on	IN
5180	1162	34	the	the	DT
5180	1162	35	basis	basis	NN
5180	1162	36	of	of	IN
5180	1162	37	,	,	,
5180	1162	38	inter	inter	NNP
5180	1162	39	alia	alia	NNP
5180	1162	40	,	,	,
5180	1162	41	artistic	artistic	JJ
5180	1162	42	excellence	excellence	NN
5180	1162	43	.	.	.
5180	1163	1	"	"	``
5180	1163	2	The	the	DT
5180	1163	3	very	very	JJ
5180	1163	4	assumption	assumption	NN
5180	1163	5	of	of	IN
5180	1163	6	the	the	DT
5180	1163	7	NEA	NEA	NNP
5180	1163	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	1163	9	that	that	IN
5180	1163	10	grants	grant	NNS
5180	1163	11	will	will	MD
5180	1163	12	be	be	VB
5180	1163	13	awarded	award	VBN
5180	1163	14	according	accord	VBG
5180	1163	15	to	to	IN
5180	1163	16	the	the	DT
5180	1163	17	artistic	artistic	JJ
5180	1163	18	worth	worth	NN
5180	1163	19	of	of	IN
5180	1163	20	competing	compete	VBG
5180	1163	21	applications	application	NNS
5180	1163	22	,	,	,
5180	1163	23	and	and	CC
5180	1163	24	absolute	absolute	JJ
5180	1163	25	neutrality	neutrality	NN
5180	1163	26	is	be	VBZ
5180	1163	27	simply	simply	RB
5180	1163	28	inconceivable	inconceivable	JJ
5180	1163	29	.	.	.
5180	1163	30	"	"	''
5180	1164	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1165	1	at	at	IN
5180	1165	2	585	585	CD
5180	1165	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1165	4	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1165	5	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1165	6	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1165	7	and	and	CC
5180	1165	8	citation	citation	NN
5180	1165	9	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1165	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1165	11	.	.	.
5180	1166	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1166	2	,	,	,
5180	1166	3	as	as	IN
5180	1166	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
5180	1166	5	Stevens	Stevens	NNP
5180	1166	6	explained	explain	VBD
5180	1166	7	in	in	IN
5180	1166	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1166	9	concurring	concur	VBG
5180	1166	10	opinion	opinion	NN
5180	1166	11	in	in	IN
5180	1166	12	Widmar	Widmar	NNP
5180	1166	13	v.	v.	IN
5180	1166	14	Vincent	Vincent	NNP
5180	1166	15	,	,	,
5180	1166	16	454	454	CD
5180	1166	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1166	18	263	263	CD
5180	1166	19	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1166	20	1981	1981	CD
5180	1166	21	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1166	22	,	,	,
5180	1166	23	the	the	DT
5180	1166	24	First	First	NNP
5180	1166	25	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1166	26	does	do	VBZ
5180	1166	27	not	not	RB
5180	1166	28	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	1166	29	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1166	30	to	to	IN
5180	1166	31	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1166	32	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1166	33	a	a	DT
5180	1166	34	state	state	NN
5180	1166	35	university	university	NN
5180	1166	36	's	's	POS
5180	1166	37	use	use	NN
5180	1166	38	of	of	IN
5180	1166	39	content	content	NN
5180	1166	40	-	-	HYPH
5180	1166	41	based	base	VBN
5180	1166	42	means	mean	NNS
5180	1166	43	of	of	IN
5180	1166	44	allocating	allocate	VBG
5180	1166	45	scarce	scarce	JJ
5180	1166	46	resources	resource	NNS
5180	1166	47	,	,	,
5180	1166	48	including	include	VBG
5180	1166	49	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1166	50	public	public	JJ
5180	1166	51	fora	fora	NN
5180	1166	52	such	such	JJ
5180	1166	53	as	as	IN
5180	1166	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1166	55	meeting	meeting	NN
5180	1166	56	facilities	facility	NNS
5180	1166	57	:	:	:
5180	1166	58	Because	because	IN
5180	1166	59	every	every	DT
5180	1166	60	university	university	NN
5180	1166	61	's	's	POS
5180	1166	62	resources	resource	NNS
5180	1166	63	are	be	VBP
5180	1166	64	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1166	65	,	,	,
5180	1166	66	an	an	DT
5180	1166	67	educational	educational	JJ
5180	1166	68	institution	institution	NN
5180	1166	69	must	must	MD
5180	1166	70	routinely	routinely	RB
5180	1166	71	make	make	VB
5180	1166	72	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1166	73	concerning	concern	VBG
5180	1166	74	the	the	DT
5180	1166	75	use	use	NN
5180	1166	76	of	of	IN
5180	1166	77	the	the	DT
5180	1166	78	time	time	NN
5180	1166	79	and	and	CC
5180	1166	80	space	space	NN
5180	1166	81	that	that	WDT
5180	1166	82	is	be	VBZ
5180	1166	83	available	available	JJ
5180	1166	84	for	for	IN
5180	1166	85	extracurricular	extracurricular	JJ
5180	1166	86	activities	activity	NNS
5180	1166	87	.	.	.
5180	1167	1	In	in	IN
5180	1167	2	my	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1167	3	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1167	4	,	,	,
5180	1167	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1167	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	1167	7	both	both	CC
5180	1167	8	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	1167	9	and	and	CC
5180	1167	10	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1167	11	for	for	IN
5180	1167	12	those	those	DT
5180	1167	13	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1167	14	to	to	TO
5180	1167	15	evaluate	evaluate	VB
5180	1167	16	the	the	DT
5180	1167	17	content	content	NN
5180	1167	18	of	of	IN
5180	1167	19	a	a	DT
5180	1167	20	proposed	propose	VBN
5180	1167	21	student	student	NN
5180	1167	22	activity	activity	NN
5180	1167	23	.	.	.
5180	1168	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1168	2	should	should	MD
5180	1168	3	think	think	VB
5180	1168	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1168	5	obvious	obvious	JJ
5180	1168	6	,	,	,
5180	1168	7	for	for	IN
5180	1168	8	example	example	NN
5180	1168	9	,	,	,
5180	1168	10	that	that	IN
5180	1168	11	if	if	IN
5180	1168	12	two	two	CD
5180	1168	13	groups	group	NNS
5180	1168	14	of	of	IN
5180	1168	15	25	25	CD
5180	1168	16	students	student	NNS
5180	1168	17	requested	request	VBD
5180	1168	18	the	the	DT
5180	1168	19	use	use	NN
5180	1168	20	of	of	IN
5180	1168	21	a	a	DT
5180	1168	22	room	room	NN
5180	1168	23	at	at	IN
5180	1168	24	a	a	DT
5180	1168	25	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1168	26	time	time	NN
5180	1168	27	–	–	:
5180	1168	28	one	one	NN
5180	1168	29	to	to	TO
5180	1168	30	view	view	VB
5180	1168	31	Mickey	Mickey	NNP
5180	1168	32	Mouse	Mouse	NNP
5180	1168	33	cartoons	cartoon	NNS
5180	1168	34	and	and	CC
5180	1168	35	the	the	DT
5180	1168	36	other	other	JJ
5180	1168	37	to	to	TO
5180	1168	38	rehearse	rehearse	VB
5180	1168	39	an	an	DT
5180	1168	40	amateur	amateur	JJ
5180	1168	41	performance	performance	NN
5180	1168	42	of	of	IN
5180	1168	43	Hamlet	Hamlet	NNP
5180	1168	44	–	–	:
5180	1168	45	the	the	DT
5180	1168	46	First	First	NNP
5180	1168	47	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1168	48	would	would	MD
5180	1168	49	not	not	RB
5180	1168	50	require	require	VB
5180	1168	51	that	that	IN
5180	1168	52	the	the	DT
5180	1168	53	room	room	NN
5180	1168	54	be	be	VB
5180	1168	55	reserved	reserve	VBN
5180	1168	56	for	for	IN
5180	1168	57	the	the	DT
5180	1168	58	group	group	NN
5180	1168	59	that	that	WDT
5180	1168	60	submitted	submit	VBD
5180	1168	61	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1168	62	application	application	NN
5180	1168	63	first	first	RB
5180	1168	64	.	.	.
5180	1169	1	Nor	nor	CC
5180	1169	2	do	do	VBP
5180	1169	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1169	4	see	see	VB
5180	1169	5	why	why	WRB
5180	1169	6	a	a	DT
5180	1169	7	university	university	NN
5180	1169	8	should	should	MD
5180	1169	9	have	have	VB
5180	1169	10	to	to	TO
5180	1169	11	establish	establish	VB
5180	1169	12	a	a	DT
5180	1169	13	"	"	``
5180	1169	14	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1169	15	state	state	NN
5180	1169	16	interest	interest	NN
5180	1169	17	"	"	''
5180	1169	18	to	to	TO
5180	1169	19	defend	defend	VB
5180	1169	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1169	21	decision	decision	NN
5180	1169	22	to	to	TO
5180	1169	23	permit	permit	VB
5180	1169	24	one	one	CD
5180	1169	25	group	group	NN
5180	1169	26	to	to	TO
5180	1169	27	use	use	VB
5180	1169	28	the	the	DT
5180	1169	29	facility	facility	NN
5180	1169	30	and	and	CC
5180	1169	31	not	not	RB
5180	1169	32	the	the	DT
5180	1169	33	other	other	JJ
5180	1169	34	.	.	.
5180	1170	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1171	1	at	at	IN
5180	1171	2	278	278	CD
5180	1171	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1171	4	Stevens	Stevens	NNP
5180	1171	5	,	,	,
5180	1171	6	J.	J.	NNP
5180	1171	7	,	,	,
5180	1171	8	concurring	concur	VBG
5180	1171	9	in	in	IN
5180	1171	10	the	the	DT
5180	1171	11	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1171	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1171	13	.	.	.
5180	1172	1	The	the	DT
5180	1172	2	more	more	RBR
5180	1172	3	broadly	broadly	RB
5180	1172	4	the	the	DT
5180	1172	5	government	government	NN
5180	1172	6	facilitates	facilitate	VBZ
5180	1172	7	private	private	JJ
5180	1172	8	speech	speech	NN
5180	1172	9	,	,	,
5180	1172	10	however	however	RB
5180	1172	11	,	,	,
5180	1172	12	the	the	DT
5180	1172	13	less	less	JJR
5180	1172	14	deference	deference	NN
5180	1172	15	the	the	DT
5180	1172	16	First	First	NNP
5180	1172	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1172	18	accords	accord	NNS
5180	1172	19	to	to	IN
5180	1172	20	the	the	DT
5180	1172	21	government	government	NN
5180	1172	22	's	's	POS
5180	1172	23	content	content	NN
5180	1172	24	-	-	HYPH
5180	1172	25	based	base	VBN
5180	1172	26	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1172	27	on	on	IN
5180	1172	28	the	the	DT
5180	1172	29	speech	speech	NN
5180	1172	30	that	that	WDT
5180	1172	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1172	32	facilitates	facilitate	VBZ
5180	1172	33	.	.	.
5180	1173	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1173	2	,	,	,
5180	1173	3	where	where	WRB
5180	1173	4	the	the	DT
5180	1173	5	government	government	NN
5180	1173	6	creates	create	VBZ
5180	1173	7	a	a	DT
5180	1173	8	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1173	9	public	public	JJ
5180	1173	10	forum	forum	NN
5180	1173	11	to	to	TO
5180	1173	12	facilitate	facilitate	VB
5180	1173	13	private	private	JJ
5180	1173	14	speech	speech	NN
5180	1173	15	representing	represent	VBG
5180	1173	16	a	a	DT
5180	1173	17	diverse	diverse	JJ
5180	1173	18	range	range	NN
5180	1173	19	of	of	IN
5180	1173	20	viewpoints	viewpoint	NNS
5180	1173	21	,	,	,
5180	1173	22	the	the	DT
5180	1173	23	government	government	NN
5180	1173	24	's	's	POS
5180	1173	25	decision	decision	NN
5180	1173	26	selectively	selectively	RB
5180	1173	27	to	to	IN
5180	1173	28	single	single	VB
5180	1173	29	out	out	RP
5180	1173	30	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1173	31	viewpoints	viewpoint	NNS
5180	1173	32	for	for	IN
5180	1173	33	exclusion	exclusion	NN
5180	1173	34	is	be	VBZ
5180	1173	35	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1173	36	to	to	IN
5180	1173	37	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1173	38	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1173	39	.	.	.
5180	1174	1	Compare	compare	VB
5180	1174	2	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
5180	1174	3	,	,	,
5180	1174	4	515	515	CD
5180	1174	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1174	6	at	at	IN
5180	1174	7	834	834	CD
5180	1174	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1174	9	applying	apply	VBG
5180	1174	10	heightened	heighten	VBN
5180	1174	11	First	First	NNP
5180	1174	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1174	13	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1174	14	to	to	TO
5180	1174	15	viewpoint	viewpoint	NN
5180	1174	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	1174	17	based	base	VBN
5180	1174	18	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1174	19	on	on	IN
5180	1174	20	the	the	DT
5180	1174	21	use	use	NN
5180	1174	22	of	of	IN
5180	1174	23	a	a	DT
5180	1174	24	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1174	25	public	public	JJ
5180	1174	26	forum	forum	NN
5180	1174	27	where	where	WRB
5180	1174	28	the	the	DT
5180	1174	29	government	government	NN
5180	1174	30	"	"	``
5180	1174	31	does	do	VBZ
5180	1174	32	not	not	RB
5180	1174	33	itself	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1174	34	speak	speak	VB
5180	1174	35	or	or	CC
5180	1174	36	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	1174	37	transmittal	transmittal	NN
5180	1174	38	of	of	IN
5180	1174	39	a	a	DT
5180	1174	40	message	message	NN
5180	1174	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1174	42	favors	favor	VBZ
5180	1174	43	but	but	CC
5180	1174	44	instead	instead	RB
5180	1174	45	expends	expend	VBZ
5180	1174	46	funds	fund	NNS
5180	1174	47	to	to	TO
5180	1174	48	encourage	encourage	VB
5180	1174	49	a	a	DT
5180	1174	50	diversity	diversity	NN
5180	1174	51	of	of	IN
5180	1174	52	views	view	NNS
5180	1174	53	from	from	IN
5180	1174	54	private	private	JJ
5180	1174	55	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1174	56	"	"	''
5180	1174	57	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1174	58	,	,	,
5180	1174	59	with	with	IN
5180	1174	60	Finley	Finley	NNP
5180	1174	61	,	,	,
5180	1174	62	524	524	CD
5180	1174	63	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1174	64	at	at	IN
5180	1174	65	586	586	CD
5180	1174	66	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1174	67	"	"	``
5180	1174	68	In	in	IN
5180	1174	69	the	the	DT
5180	1174	70	context	context	NN
5180	1174	71	of	of	IN
5180	1174	72	arts	art	NNS
5180	1174	73	funding	funding	NN
5180	1174	74	,	,	,
5180	1174	75	in	in	IN
5180	1174	76	contrast	contrast	NN
5180	1174	77	to	to	IN
5180	1174	78	many	many	JJ
5180	1174	79	other	other	JJ
5180	1174	80	subsidies	subsidy	NNS
5180	1174	81	,	,	,
5180	1174	82	the	the	DT
5180	1174	83	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1174	84	does	do	VBZ
5180	1174	85	not	not	RB
5180	1174	86	indiscriminately	indiscriminately	RB
5180	1174	87	encourage	encourage	VB
5180	1174	88	a	a	DT
5180	1174	89	diversity	diversity	NN
5180	1174	90	of	of	IN
5180	1174	91	views	view	NNS
5180	1174	92	from	from	IN
5180	1174	93	private	private	JJ
5180	1174	94	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1174	95	.	.	.
5180	1174	96	"	"	''
5180	1174	97	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1175	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1175	2	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1175	3	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1175	4	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1175	5	and	and	CC
5180	1175	6	citation	citation	NN
5180	1175	7	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1175	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1175	9	.	.	.
5180	1176	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1176	2	,	,	,
5180	1176	3	although	although	IN
5180	1176	4	the	the	DT
5180	1176	5	government	government	NN
5180	1176	6	may	may	MD
5180	1176	7	create	create	VB
5180	1176	8	a	a	DT
5180	1176	9	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1176	10	public	public	JJ
5180	1176	11	forum	forum	NN
5180	1176	12	limited	limit	VBN
5180	1176	13	to	to	IN
5180	1176	14	speech	speech	NN
5180	1176	15	on	on	IN
5180	1176	16	a	a	DT
5180	1176	17	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1176	18	topic	topic	NN
5180	1176	19	,	,	,
5180	1176	20	if	if	IN
5180	1176	21	the	the	DT
5180	1176	22	government	government	NN
5180	1176	23	opens	open	VBZ
5180	1176	24	the	the	DT
5180	1176	25	forum	forum	NN
5180	1176	26	to	to	IN
5180	1176	27	members	member	NNS
5180	1176	28	of	of	IN
5180	1176	29	the	the	DT
5180	1176	30	general	general	JJ
5180	1176	31	public	public	NN
5180	1176	32	to	to	TO
5180	1176	33	speak	speak	VB
5180	1176	34	on	on	IN
5180	1176	35	that	that	DT
5180	1176	36	topic	topic	NN
5180	1176	37	while	while	IN
5180	1176	38	selectively	selectively	RB
5180	1176	39	singling	single	VBG
5180	1176	40	out	out	RP
5180	1176	41	for	for	IN
5180	1176	42	exclusion	exclusion	NN
5180	1176	43	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1176	44	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1176	45	on	on	IN
5180	1176	46	the	the	DT
5180	1176	47	basis	basis	NN
5180	1176	48	of	of	IN
5180	1176	49	the	the	DT
5180	1176	50	content	content	NN
5180	1176	51	of	of	IN
5180	1176	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1176	53	speech	speech	NN
5180	1176	54	,	,	,
5180	1176	55	that	that	DT
5180	1176	56	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1176	57	is	be	VBZ
5180	1176	58	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1176	59	to	to	IN
5180	1176	60	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1176	61	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1176	62	.	.	.
5180	1177	1	For	for	IN
5180	1177	2	instance	instance	NN
5180	1177	3	,	,	,
5180	1177	4	in	in	IN
5180	1177	5	City	City	NNP
5180	1177	6	of	of	IN
5180	1177	7	Madison	Madison	NNP
5180	1177	8	Joint	Joint	NNP
5180	1177	9	School	School	NNP
5180	1177	10	District	District	NNP
5180	1177	11	No	No	NNP
5180	1177	12	.	.	.
5180	1178	1	8	8	CD
5180	1178	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1178	3	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
5180	1178	4	Employment	Employment	NNP
5180	1178	5	Relations	Relations	NNPS
5180	1178	6	Commission	Commission	NNP
5180	1178	7	,	,	,
5180	1178	8	429	429	CD
5180	1178	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1178	10	167	167	CD
5180	1178	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1178	12	1976	1976	CD
5180	1178	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1178	14	,	,	,
5180	1178	15	the	the	DT
5180	1178	16	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1178	17	held	hold	VBD
5180	1178	18	that	that	IN
5180	1178	19	where	where	WRB
5180	1178	20	a	a	DT
5180	1178	21	school	school	NN
5180	1178	22	board	board	NN
5180	1178	23	opens	open	VBZ
5180	1178	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1178	25	meetings	meeting	NNS
5180	1178	26	for	for	IN
5180	1178	27	public	public	JJ
5180	1178	28	participation	participation	NN
5180	1178	29	,	,	,
5180	1178	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1178	31	may	may	MD
5180	1178	32	not	not	RB
5180	1178	33	,	,	,
5180	1178	34	consistent	consistent	JJ
5180	1178	35	with	with	IN
5180	1178	36	the	the	DT
5180	1178	37	First	First	NNP
5180	1178	38	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1178	39	,	,	,
5180	1178	40	prohibit	prohibit	NN
5180	1178	41	teachers	teacher	NNS
5180	1178	42	other	other	JJ
5180	1178	43	than	than	IN
5180	1178	44	union	union	NN
5180	1178	45	representatives	representative	NNS
5180	1178	46	from	from	IN
5180	1178	47	speaking	speak	VBG
5180	1178	48	on	on	IN
5180	1178	49	the	the	DT
5180	1178	50	subject	subject	NN
5180	1178	51	of	of	IN
5180	1178	52	pending	pende	VBG
5180	1178	53	collective	collective	JJ
5180	1178	54	-	-	HYPH
5180	1178	55	bargaining	bargaining	NN
5180	1178	56	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
5180	1178	57	.	.	.
5180	1179	1	See	see	VB
5180	1179	2	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1179	3	d	d	VBN
5180	1179	4	.	.	.
5180	1180	1	at	at	IN
5180	1180	2	175	175	CD
5180	1180	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1180	4	noting	note	VBG
5180	1180	5	that	that	IN
5180	1180	6	the	the	DT
5180	1180	7	state	state	NN
5180	1180	8	"	"	``
5180	1180	9	has	have	VBZ
5180	1180	10	opened	open	VBN
5180	1180	11	a	a	DT
5180	1180	12	forum	forum	NN
5180	1180	13	for	for	IN
5180	1180	14	direct	direct	JJ
5180	1180	15	citizen	citizen	NN
5180	1180	16	involvement	involvement	NN
5180	1180	17	"	"	''
5180	1180	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1180	19	;	;	:
5180	1180	20	see	see	VB
5180	1180	21	also	also	RB
5180	1180	22	Ark.	Arkansas	NNP
5180	1181	1	Educ	Educ	NNS
5180	1181	2	.	.	.
5180	1182	1	Television	television	NN
5180	1182	2	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
5180	1182	3	v.	v.	CC
5180	1182	4	Forbes	Forbes	NNP
5180	1182	5	,	,	,
5180	1182	6	523	523	CD
5180	1182	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1182	8	666	666	CD
5180	1182	9	,	,	,
5180	1182	10	680	680	CD
5180	1182	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1182	12	1998	1998	CD
5180	1182	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1182	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1182	15	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
5180	1182	16	,	,	,
5180	1182	17	for	for	IN
5180	1182	18	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1182	19	of	of	IN
5180	1182	20	determining	determine	VBG
5180	1182	21	the	the	DT
5180	1182	22	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1182	23	level	level	NN
5180	1182	24	of	of	IN
5180	1182	25	First	First	NNP
5180	1182	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1182	27	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1182	28	,	,	,
5180	1182	29	a	a	DT
5180	1182	30	televised	televise	VBN
5180	1182	31	debate	debate	NN
5180	1182	32	in	in	IN
5180	1182	33	which	which	WDT
5180	1182	34	a	a	DT
5180	1182	35	public	public	JJ
5180	1182	36	broadcasting	broadcasting	NN
5180	1182	37	station	station	NN
5180	1182	38	exercises	exercise	VBZ
5180	1182	39	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	1182	40	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1182	41	in	in	IN
5180	1182	42	selecting	select	VBG
5180	1182	43	participating	participate	VBG
5180	1182	44	candidates	candidate	NNS
5180	1182	45	from	from	IN
5180	1182	46	a	a	DT
5180	1182	47	debate	debate	NN
5180	1182	48	that	that	WDT
5180	1182	49	has	have	VBZ
5180	1182	50	"	"	``
5180	1182	51	an	an	DT
5180	1182	52	open	open	JJ
5180	1182	53	-	-	HYPH
5180	1182	54	microphone	microphone	NN
5180	1182	55	format	format	NN
5180	1182	56	"	"	''
5180	1182	57	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1182	58	.	.	.
5180	1183	1	Finally	finally	RB
5180	1183	2	,	,	,
5180	1183	3	content	content	NN
5180	1183	4	-	-	HYPH
5180	1183	5	based	base	VBN
5180	1183	6	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1183	7	on	on	IN
5180	1183	8	speech	speech	NN
5180	1183	9	in	in	IN
5180	1183	10	a	a	DT
5180	1183	11	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1183	12	public	public	JJ
5180	1183	13	forum	forum	NN
5180	1183	14	are	be	VBP
5180	1183	15	most	most	RBS
5180	1183	16	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	1183	17	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1183	18	to	to	IN
5180	1183	19	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1183	20	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1183	21	when	when	WRB
5180	1183	22	the	the	DT
5180	1183	23	government	government	NN
5180	1183	24	opens	open	VBZ
5180	1183	25	a	a	DT
5180	1183	26	forum	forum	NN
5180	1183	27	for	for	IN
5180	1183	28	virtually	virtually	RB
5180	1183	29	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
5180	1183	30	use	use	NN
5180	1183	31	by	by	IN
5180	1183	32	the	the	DT
5180	1183	33	general	general	JJ
5180	1183	34	public	public	NN
5180	1183	35	for	for	IN
5180	1183	36	speech	speech	NN
5180	1183	37	on	on	IN
5180	1183	38	a	a	DT
5180	1183	39	virtually	virtually	RB
5180	1183	40	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
5180	1183	41	range	range	NN
5180	1183	42	of	of	IN
5180	1183	43	topics	topic	NNS
5180	1183	44	,	,	,
5180	1183	45	while	while	IN
5180	1183	46	selectively	selectively	RB
5180	1183	47	excluding	exclude	VBG
5180	1183	48	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1183	49	speech	speech	NN
5180	1183	50	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1183	51	content	content	NN
5180	1183	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1183	53	disfavors	disfavor	VBZ
5180	1183	54	.	.	.
5180	1184	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1184	2	,	,	,
5180	1184	3	in	in	IN
5180	1184	4	Conrad	Conrad	NNP
5180	1184	5	,	,	,
5180	1184	6	the	the	DT
5180	1184	7	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1184	8	held	hold	VBD
5180	1184	9	that	that	IN
5180	1184	10	a	a	DT
5180	1184	11	local	local	JJ
5180	1184	12	government	government	NN
5180	1184	13	violated	violate	VBD
5180	1184	14	the	the	DT
5180	1184	15	First	First	NNP
5180	1184	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1184	17	when	when	WRB
5180	1184	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1184	19	denied	deny	VBD
5180	1184	20	a	a	DT
5180	1184	21	group	group	NN
5180	1184	22	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	1184	23	to	to	TO
5180	1184	24	perform	perform	VB
5180	1184	25	the	the	DT
5180	1184	26	rock	rock	NN
5180	1184	27	musical	musical	JJ
5180	1184	28	"	"	``
5180	1184	29	Hair	Hair	NNP
5180	1184	30	"	"	''
5180	1184	31	access	access	NN
5180	1184	32	to	to	IN
5180	1184	33	a	a	DT
5180	1184	34	general	general	JJ
5180	1184	35	-	-	HYPH
5180	1184	36	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1184	37	municipal	municipal	JJ
5180	1184	38	theater	theater	NN
5180	1184	39	open	open	NN
5180	1184	40	for	for	IN
5180	1184	41	the	the	DT
5180	1184	42	public	public	NN
5180	1184	43	at	at	IN
5180	1184	44	large	large	JJ
5180	1184	45	to	to	TO
5180	1184	46	use	use	VB
5180	1184	47	for	for	IN
5180	1184	48	performances	performance	NNS
5180	1184	49	.	.	.
5180	1185	1	See	see	VB
5180	1185	2	also	also	RB
5180	1185	3	Denver	Denver	NNP
5180	1185	4	,	,	,
5180	1185	5	518	518	CD
5180	1185	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1185	7	at	at	IN
5180	1185	8	802	802	CD
5180	1185	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1185	10	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
5180	1185	11	,	,	,
5180	1185	12	J.	J.	NNP
5180	1185	13	,	,	,
5180	1185	14	concurring	concur	VBG
5180	1185	15	in	in	IN
5180	1185	16	the	the	DT
5180	1185	17	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1185	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1185	19	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1185	20	suggesting	suggest	VBG
5180	1185	21	that	that	DT
5180	1185	22	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1185	23	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1185	24	would	would	MD
5180	1185	25	not	not	RB
5180	1185	26	apply	apply	VB
5180	1185	27	to	to	IN
5180	1185	28	a	a	DT
5180	1185	29	local	local	JJ
5180	1185	30	government	government	NN
5180	1185	31	's	's	POS
5180	1185	32	decision	decision	NN
5180	1185	33	to	to	TO
5180	1185	34	"	"	``
5180	1185	35	build	build	VB
5180	1185	36	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1185	37	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1185	38	a	a	DT
5180	1185	39	band	band	NN
5180	1185	40	shell	shell	NN
5180	1185	41	in	in	IN
5180	1185	42	the	the	DT
5180	1185	43	park	park	NN
5180	1185	44	and	and	CC
5180	1185	45	dedicate	dedicate	VB
5180	1185	46	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1185	47	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1185	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1185	49	solely	solely	RB
5180	1185	50	to	to	IN
5180	1185	51	classical	classical	JJ
5180	1185	52	music	music	NN
5180	1185	53	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1185	54	but	but	CC
5180	1185	55	not	not	RB
5180	1185	56	jazz	jazz	NN
5180	1185	57	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1185	58	,	,	,
5180	1185	59	"	"	''
5180	1185	60	but	but	CC
5180	1185	61	would	would	MD
5180	1185	62	apply	apply	VB
5180	1185	63	to	to	IN
5180	1185	64	"	"	``
5180	1185	65	the	the	DT
5180	1185	66	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1185	67	's	's	POS
5180	1185	68	creation	creation	NN
5180	1185	69	of	of	IN
5180	1185	70	a	a	DT
5180	1185	71	band	band	NN
5180	1185	72	shell	shell	NN
5180	1185	73	in	in	IN
5180	1185	74	which	which	WDT
5180	1185	75	all	all	DT
5180	1185	76	types	type	NNS
5180	1185	77	of	of	IN
5180	1185	78	music	music	NN
5180	1185	79	might	may	MD
5180	1185	80	be	be	VB
5180	1185	81	performed	perform	VBN
5180	1185	82	except	except	IN
5180	1185	83	for	for	IN
5180	1185	84	rap	rap	NN
5180	1185	85	music	music	NN
5180	1185	86	"	"	''
5180	1185	87	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1185	88	.	.	.
5180	1186	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1186	2	,	,	,
5180	1186	3	in	in	IN
5180	1186	4	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	1186	5	v.	v.	IN
5180	1186	6	League	League	NNP
5180	1186	7	of	of	IN
5180	1186	8	Women	Women	NNP
5180	1186	9	Voters	Voters	NNPS
5180	1186	10	of	of	IN
5180	1186	11	Cal	Cal	NNP
5180	1186	12	.	.	NNP
5180	1186	13	,	,	,
5180	1186	14	468	468	CD
5180	1186	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1186	16	364	364	CD
5180	1186	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1186	18	1984	1984	CD
5180	1186	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1186	20	,	,	,
5180	1186	21	the	the	DT
5180	1186	22	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1186	23	subjected	subject	VBD
5180	1186	24	to	to	IN
5180	1186	25	heightened	heighten	VBN
5180	1186	26	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1186	27	a	a	DT
5180	1186	28	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1186	29	program	program	NN
5180	1186	30	that	that	WDT
5180	1186	31	funded	fund	VBD
5180	1186	32	a	a	DT
5180	1186	33	wide	wide	JJ
5180	1186	34	range	range	NN
5180	1186	35	of	of	IN
5180	1186	36	public	public	JJ
5180	1186	37	broadcasting	broadcasting	NN
5180	1186	38	stations	station	NNS
5180	1186	39	that	that	WDT
5180	1186	40	disseminated	disseminate	VBN
5180	1186	41	speech	speech	NN
5180	1186	42	on	on	IN
5180	1186	43	a	a	DT
5180	1186	44	wide	wide	JJ
5180	1186	45	range	range	NN
5180	1186	46	of	of	IN
5180	1186	47	subjects	subject	NNS
5180	1186	48	,	,	,
5180	1186	49	where	where	WRB
5180	1186	50	the	the	DT
5180	1186	51	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1186	52	program	program	NN
5180	1186	53	singled	single	VBN
5180	1186	54	out	out	RP
5180	1186	55	for	for	IN
5180	1186	56	exclusion	exclusion	NN
5180	1186	57	speech	speech	NN
5180	1186	58	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1186	59	content	content	NN
5180	1186	60	amounted	amount	VBD
5180	1186	61	to	to	IN
5180	1186	62	editorializing	editorialize	VBG
5180	1186	63	.	.	.
5180	1187	1	As	as	IN
5180	1187	2	the	the	DT
5180	1187	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1187	4	later	later	RB
5180	1187	5	explained	explain	VBD
5180	1187	6	:	:	:
5180	1187	7	In	in	IN
5180	1187	8	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	1187	9	v.	v.	IN
5180	1187	10	League	League	NNP
5180	1187	11	of	of	IN
5180	1187	12	Women	Women	NNP
5180	1187	13	Voters	Voters	NNPS
5180	1187	14	of	of	IN
5180	1187	15	Cal	Cal	NNP
5180	1187	16	.	.	NNP
5180	1187	17	,	,	,
5180	1187	18	468	468	CD
5180	1187	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1187	20	364	364	CD
5180	1187	21	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1187	22	1984	1984	CD
5180	1187	23	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1187	24	the	the	DT
5180	1187	25	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1187	26	was	be	VBD
5180	1187	27	instructed	instruct	VBN
5180	1187	28	by	by	IN
5180	1187	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1187	30	understanding	understanding	NN
5180	1187	31	of	of	IN
5180	1187	32	the	the	DT
5180	1187	33	dynamics	dynamic	NNS
5180	1187	34	of	of	IN
5180	1187	35	the	the	DT
5180	1187	36	broadcast	broadcast	NN
5180	1187	37	industry	industry	NN
5180	1187	38	in	in	IN
5180	1187	39	holding	hold	VBG
5180	1187	40	that	that	IN
5180	1187	41	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
5180	1187	42	against	against	IN
5180	1187	43	editorializing	editorialize	VBG
5180	1187	44	by	by	IN
5180	1187	45	public	public	JJ
5180	1187	46	radio	radio	NN
5180	1187	47	networks	network	NNS
5180	1187	48	were	be	VBD
5180	1187	49	an	an	DT
5180	1187	50	impermissible	impermissible	JJ
5180	1187	51	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1187	52	,	,	,
5180	1187	53	even	even	RB
5180	1187	54	though	though	IN
5180	1187	55	the	the	DT
5180	1187	56	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1187	57	enacted	enact	VBD
5180	1187	58	the	the	DT
5180	1187	59	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1187	60	to	to	TO
5180	1187	61	control	control	VB
5180	1187	62	the	the	DT
5180	1187	63	use	use	NN
5180	1187	64	of	of	IN
5180	1187	65	public	public	JJ
5180	1187	66	funds	fund	NNS
5180	1187	67	.	.	.
5180	1188	1	The	the	DT
5180	1188	2	First	First	NNP
5180	1188	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1188	4	forbade	forbid	VBD
5180	1188	5	the	the	DT
5180	1188	6	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1188	7	from	from	IN
5180	1188	8	using	use	VBG
5180	1188	9	the	the	DT
5180	1188	10	forum	forum	NN
5180	1188	11	in	in	IN
5180	1188	12	an	an	DT
5180	1188	13	unconventional	unconventional	JJ
5180	1188	14	way	way	NN
5180	1188	15	to	to	TO
5180	1188	16	suppress	suppress	VB
5180	1188	17	speech	speech	NN
5180	1188	18	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	1188	19	in	in	IN
5180	1188	20	the	the	DT
5180	1188	21	nature	nature	NN
5180	1188	22	of	of	IN
5180	1188	23	the	the	DT
5180	1188	24	medium	medium	NN
5180	1188	25	.	.	.
5180	1189	1	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	1189	2	,	,	,
5180	1189	3	531	531	CD
5180	1189	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1189	5	at	at	IN
5180	1189	6	543	543	CD
5180	1189	7	.	.	.
5180	1190	1	In	in	IN
5180	1190	2	sum	sum	NN
5180	1190	3	,	,	,
5180	1190	4	the	the	DT
5180	1190	5	more	more	RBR
5180	1190	6	widely	widely	RB
5180	1190	7	the	the	DT
5180	1190	8	state	state	NN
5180	1190	9	opens	open	VBZ
5180	1190	10	a	a	DT
5180	1190	11	forum	forum	NN
5180	1190	12	for	for	IN
5180	1190	13	members	member	NNS
5180	1190	14	of	of	IN
5180	1190	15	the	the	DT
5180	1190	16	public	public	NN
5180	1190	17	to	to	TO
5180	1190	18	speak	speak	VB
5180	1190	19	on	on	IN
5180	1190	20	a	a	DT
5180	1190	21	variety	variety	NN
5180	1190	22	of	of	IN
5180	1190	23	subjects	subject	NNS
5180	1190	24	and	and	CC
5180	1190	25	viewpoints	viewpoint	NNS
5180	1190	26	,	,	,
5180	1190	27	the	the	DT
5180	1190	28	more	more	RBR
5180	1190	29	vulnerable	vulnerable	JJ
5180	1190	30	is	be	VBZ
5180	1190	31	the	the	DT
5180	1190	32	state	state	NN
5180	1190	33	's	's	POS
5180	1190	34	decision	decision	NN
5180	1190	35	selectively	selectively	RB
5180	1190	36	to	to	TO
5180	1190	37	exclude	exclude	VB
5180	1190	38	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1190	39	speech	speech	NN
5180	1190	40	on	on	IN
5180	1190	41	the	the	DT
5180	1190	42	basis	basis	NN
5180	1190	43	of	of	IN
5180	1190	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1190	45	disfavored	disfavor	VBN
5180	1190	46	content	content	NN
5180	1190	47	,	,	,
5180	1190	48	as	as	IN
5180	1190	49	such	such	JJ
5180	1190	50	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
5180	1190	51	distort	distort	VBP
5180	1190	52	the	the	DT
5180	1190	53	marketplace	marketplace	NN
5180	1190	54	of	of	IN
5180	1190	55	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	1190	56	that	that	WDT
5180	1190	57	the	the	DT
5180	1190	58	state	state	NN
5180	1190	59	has	have	VBZ
5180	1190	60	created	create	VBN
5180	1190	61	in	in	IN
5180	1190	62	establishing	establish	VBG
5180	1190	63	the	the	DT
5180	1190	64	forum	forum	NN
5180	1190	65	.	.	.
5180	1191	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1191	2	.	.	.
5180	1192	1	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	1192	2	,	,	,
5180	1192	3	531	531	CD
5180	1192	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1192	5	at	at	IN
5180	1192	6	544	544	CD
5180	1192	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1192	8	"	"	``
5180	1192	9	Restricting	restrict	VBG
5180	1192	10	LSC	LSC	NNP
5180	1192	11	attorneys	attorney	NNS
5180	1192	12	in	in	IN
5180	1192	13	advising	advise	VBG
5180	1192	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1192	15	clients	client	NNS
5180	1192	16	and	and	CC
5180	1192	17	in	in	IN
5180	1192	18	presenting	present	VBG
5180	1192	19	arguments	argument	NNS
5180	1192	20	and	and	CC
5180	1192	21	analyses	analysis	NNS
5180	1192	22	to	to	IN
5180	1192	23	the	the	DT
5180	1192	24	courts	court	NNS
5180	1192	25	distorts	distort	VBZ
5180	1192	26	the	the	DT
5180	1192	27	legal	legal	JJ
5180	1192	28	system	system	NN
5180	1192	29	by	by	IN
5180	1192	30	altering	alter	VBG
5180	1192	31	the	the	DT
5180	1192	32	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1192	33	role	role	NN
5180	1192	34	of	of	IN
5180	1192	35	the	the	DT
5180	1192	36	attorneys	attorney	NNS
5180	1192	37	in	in	IN
5180	1192	38	much	much	RB
5180	1192	39	the	the	DT
5180	1192	40	same	same	JJ
5180	1192	41	way	way	NN
5180	1192	42	broadcast	broadcast	NN
5180	1192	43	systems	system	NNS
5180	1192	44	or	or	CC
5180	1192	45	student	student	NN
5180	1192	46	publication	publication	NN
5180	1192	47	networks	network	NNS
5180	1192	48	were	be	VBD
5180	1192	49	changed	change	VBN
5180	1192	50	in	in	IN
5180	1192	51	the	the	DT
5180	1192	52	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1192	53	forum	forum	NN
5180	1192	54	cases	case	NNS
5180	1192	55	.	.	.
5180	1193	1	.	.	.
5180	1194	1	.	.	.
5180	1195	1	.	.	.
5180	1195	2	"	"	''
5180	1195	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1195	4	.	.	.
5180	1196	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1196	2	,	,	,
5180	1196	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1196	4	believe	believe	VBP
5180	1196	5	that	that	IN
5180	1196	6	where	where	WRB
5180	1196	7	the	the	DT
5180	1196	8	state	state	NN
5180	1196	9	designates	designate	VBZ
5180	1196	10	a	a	DT
5180	1196	11	forum	forum	NN
5180	1196	12	for	for	IN
5180	1196	13	expressive	expressive	JJ
5180	1196	14	activity	activity	NN
5180	1196	15	and	and	CC
5180	1196	16	opens	open	VBZ
5180	1196	17	the	the	DT
5180	1196	18	forum	forum	NN
5180	1196	19	for	for	IN
5180	1196	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	1196	21	by	by	IN
5180	1196	22	the	the	DT
5180	1196	23	public	public	NN
5180	1196	24	at	at	IN
5180	1196	25	large	large	JJ
5180	1196	26	on	on	IN
5180	1196	27	a	a	DT
5180	1196	28	wide	wide	JJ
5180	1196	29	range	range	NN
5180	1196	30	of	of	IN
5180	1196	31	topics	topic	NNS
5180	1196	32	,	,	,
5180	1196	33	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1196	34	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1196	35	applies	apply	VBZ
5180	1196	36	to	to	IN
5180	1196	37	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1196	38	that	that	WDT
5180	1196	39	single	single	VBP
5180	1196	40	out	out	RP
5180	1196	41	for	for	IN
5180	1196	42	exclusion	exclusion	NN
5180	1196	43	from	from	IN
5180	1196	44	the	the	DT
5180	1196	45	forum	forum	NN
5180	1196	46	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1196	47	speech	speech	NN
5180	1196	48	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1196	49	content	content	NN
5180	1196	50	is	be	VBZ
5180	1196	51	disfavored	disfavor	VBN
5180	1196	52	.	.	.
5180	1197	1	"	"	``
5180	1197	2	Laws	law	NNS
5180	1197	3	designed	design	VBN
5180	1197	4	or	or	CC
5180	1197	5	intended	intend	VBD
5180	1197	6	to	to	TO
5180	1197	7	suppress	suppress	VB
5180	1197	8	or	or	CC
5180	1197	9	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	1197	10	the	the	DT
5180	1197	11	expression	expression	NN
5180	1197	12	of	of	IN
5180	1197	13	specific	specific	JJ
5180	1197	14	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1197	15	contradict	contradict	VBP
5180	1197	16	basic	basic	JJ
5180	1197	17	First	First	NNP
5180	1197	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1197	19	principles	principle	NNS
5180	1197	20	.	.	.
5180	1197	21	"	"	''
5180	1198	1	United	United	NNP
5180	1198	2	States	States	NNP
5180	1198	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1198	4	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1198	5	Entm't	Entm't	NNP
5180	1198	6	Group	Group	NNP
5180	1198	7	,	,	,
5180	1198	8	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1198	9	,	,	,
5180	1198	10	529	529	CD
5180	1198	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1198	12	803	803	CD
5180	1198	13	,	,	,
5180	1198	14	812	812	CD
5180	1198	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1198	16	2000	2000	CD
5180	1198	17	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1198	18	;	;	:
5180	1198	19	see	see	VB
5180	1198	20	also	also	RB
5180	1198	21	Denver	Denver	NNP
5180	1198	22	,	,	,
5180	1198	23	518	518	CD
5180	1198	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1198	25	at	at	IN
5180	1198	26	782	782	CD
5180	1198	27	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1198	28	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
5180	1198	29	,	,	,
5180	1198	30	J.	J.	NNP
5180	1198	31	,	,	,
5180	1198	32	concurring	concur	VBG
5180	1198	33	in	in	IN
5180	1198	34	the	the	DT
5180	1198	35	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1198	36	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1198	37	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1198	38	noting	note	VBG
5180	1198	39	the	the	DT
5180	1198	40	flaw	flaw	NN
5180	1198	41	in	in	IN
5180	1198	42	a	a	DT
5180	1198	43	law	law	NN
5180	1198	44	that	that	IN
5180	1198	45	"	"	``
5180	1198	46	singles	single	VBZ
5180	1198	47	out	out	RP
5180	1198	48	one	one	CD
5180	1198	49	sort	sort	NN
5180	1198	50	of	of	IN
5180	1198	51	speech	speech	NN
5180	1198	52	for	for	IN
5180	1198	53	vulnerability	vulnerability	NN
5180	1198	54	to	to	IN
5180	1198	55	private	private	JJ
5180	1198	56	censorship	censorship	NN
5180	1198	57	in	in	IN
5180	1198	58	a	a	DT
5180	1198	59	context	context	NN
5180	1198	60	where	where	WRB
5180	1198	61	content	content	NN
5180	1198	62	-	-	HYPH
5180	1198	63	based	base	VBN
5180	1198	64	discrimination	discrimination	NN
5180	1198	65	is	be	VBZ
5180	1198	66	not	not	RB
5180	1198	67	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1198	68	permitted	permit	VBN
5180	1198	69	"	"	''
5180	1198	70	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1198	71	.	.	.
5180	1199	1	Compare	Compare	NNP
5180	1199	2	Forbes	Forbes	NNP
5180	1199	3	,	,	,
5180	1199	4	523	523	CD
5180	1199	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1199	6	at	at	IN
5180	1199	7	679	679	CD
5180	1199	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1199	9	holding	hold	VBG
5180	1199	10	that	that	IN
5180	1199	11	the	the	DT
5180	1199	12	state	state	NN
5180	1199	13	does	do	VBZ
5180	1199	14	not	not	RB
5180	1199	15	create	create	VB
5180	1199	16	a	a	DT
5180	1199	17	public	public	JJ
5180	1199	18	forum	forum	NN
5180	1199	19	when	when	WRB
5180	1199	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1199	21	"	"	``
5180	1199	22	allows	allow	VBZ
5180	1199	23	selective	selective	JJ
5180	1199	24	access	access	NN
5180	1199	25	for	for	IN
5180	1199	26	individual	individual	JJ
5180	1199	27	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1199	28	rather	rather	RB
5180	1199	29	than	than	IN
5180	1199	30	general	general	JJ
5180	1199	31	access	access	NN
5180	1199	32	for	for	IN
5180	1199	33	a	a	DT
5180	1199	34	class	class	NN
5180	1199	35	of	of	IN
5180	1199	36	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1199	37	"	"	''
5180	1199	38	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1199	39	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1199	40	emphasis	emphasis	NN
5180	1199	41	added	add	VBN
5180	1199	42	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1199	43	,	,	,
5180	1199	44	with	with	IN
5180	1199	45	Police	Police	NNS
5180	1199	46	Dep't	Dep't	NNS
5180	1199	47	of	of	IN
5180	1199	48	the	the	DT
5180	1199	49	City	City	NNP
5180	1199	50	of	of	IN
5180	1199	51	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
5180	1199	52	v.	v.	CC
5180	1199	53	Mosley	Mosley	NNP
5180	1199	54	,	,	,
5180	1199	55	408	408	CD
5180	1199	56	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1199	57	92	92	CD
5180	1199	58	,	,	,
5180	1199	59	96	96	CD
5180	1199	60	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1199	61	1972	1972	CD
5180	1199	62	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1199	63	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1199	64	"	"	``
5180	1199	65	Selective	selective	JJ
5180	1199	66	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
5180	1199	67	from	from	IN
5180	1199	68	a	a	DT
5180	1199	69	public	public	JJ
5180	1199	70	forum	forum	NN
5180	1199	71	may	may	MD
5180	1199	72	not	not	RB
5180	1199	73	be	be	VB
5180	1199	74	based	base	VBN
5180	1199	75	on	on	IN
5180	1199	76	content	content	NN
5180	1199	77	alone	alone	RB
5180	1199	78	,	,	,
5180	1199	79	and	and	CC
5180	1199	80	may	may	MD
5180	1199	81	not	not	RB
5180	1199	82	be	be	VB
5180	1199	83	justified	justify	VBN
5180	1199	84	by	by	IN
5180	1199	85	reference	reference	NN
5180	1199	86	to	to	TO
5180	1199	87	content	content	VB
5180	1199	88	alone	alone	RB
5180	1199	89	.	.	.
5180	1199	90	"	"	''
5180	1199	91	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1200	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1200	2	emphasis	emphasis	NN
5180	1200	3	added	add	VBN
5180	1200	4	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1200	5	.	.	.
5180	1201	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1201	2	note	note	VBP
5180	1201	3	further	further	RB
5180	1201	4	that	that	IN
5180	1201	5	to	to	IN
5180	1201	6	the	the	DT
5180	1201	7	extent	extent	NN
5180	1201	8	that	that	IN
5180	1201	9	the	the	DT
5180	1201	10	government	government	NN
5180	1201	11	creates	create	VBZ
5180	1201	12	a	a	DT
5180	1201	13	public	public	JJ
5180	1201	14	forum	forum	NN
5180	1201	15	expressly	expressly	RB
5180	1201	16	designed	design	VBN
5180	1201	17	to	to	TO
5180	1201	18	facilitate	facilitate	VB
5180	1201	19	the	the	DT
5180	1201	20	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1201	21	of	of	IN
5180	1201	22	private	private	JJ
5180	1201	23	speech	speech	NN
5180	1201	24	,	,	,
5180	1201	25	opens	open	VBZ
5180	1201	26	the	the	DT
5180	1201	27	forum	forum	NN
5180	1201	28	to	to	IN
5180	1201	29	any	any	DT
5180	1201	30	member	member	NN
5180	1201	31	of	of	IN
5180	1201	32	the	the	DT
5180	1201	33	public	public	NN
5180	1201	34	to	to	TO
5180	1201	35	speak	speak	VB
5180	1201	36	on	on	IN
5180	1201	37	any	any	DT
5180	1201	38	virtually	virtually	RB
5180	1201	39	any	any	DT
5180	1201	40	topic	topic	NN
5180	1201	41	,	,	,
5180	1201	42	and	and	CC
5180	1201	43	then	then	RB
5180	1201	44	selectively	selectively	RB
5180	1201	45	targets	target	VBZ
5180	1201	46	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1201	47	speech	speech	NN
5180	1201	48	for	for	IN
5180	1201	49	exclusion	exclusion	NN
5180	1201	50	based	base	VBN
5180	1201	51	on	on	IN
5180	1201	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1201	53	content	content	NN
5180	1201	54	,	,	,
5180	1201	55	the	the	DT
5180	1201	56	government	government	NN
5180	1201	57	is	be	VBZ
5180	1201	58	singling	single	VBG
5180	1201	59	out	out	RP
5180	1201	60	speech	speech	NN
5180	1201	61	in	in	IN
5180	1201	62	a	a	DT
5180	1201	63	manner	manner	NN
5180	1201	64	that	that	WDT
5180	1201	65	resembles	resemble	VBZ
5180	1201	66	the	the	DT
5180	1201	67	discriminatory	discriminatory	JJ
5180	1201	68	taxes	taxis	NNS
5180	1201	69	on	on	IN
5180	1201	70	the	the	DT
5180	1201	71	press	press	NN
5180	1201	72	that	that	IN
5180	1201	73	the	the	DT
5180	1201	74	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1201	75	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1201	76	subjected	subject	VBD
5180	1201	77	to	to	IN
5180	1201	78	heightened	heighten	VBN
5180	1201	79	First	First	NNP
5180	1201	80	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1201	81	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1201	82	in	in	IN
5180	1201	83	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
5180	1201	84	Writers	Writers	NNPS
5180	1201	85	'	'	POS
5180	1201	86	Project	Project	NNP
5180	1201	87	,	,	,
5180	1201	88	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1201	89	v.	v.	IN
5180	1201	90	Ragland	Ragland	NNP
5180	1201	91	,	,	,
5180	1201	92	481	481	CD
5180	1201	93	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1201	94	221	221	CD
5180	1201	95	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1201	96	1987	1987	CD
5180	1201	97	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1201	98	,	,	,
5180	1201	99	and	and	CC
5180	1201	100	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
5180	1201	101	Star	Star	NNP
5180	1201	102	&	&	CC
5180	1201	103	Tribune	Tribune	NNP
5180	1201	104	Co.	Co.	NNP
5180	1201	105	v.	v.	IN
5180	1201	106	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
5180	1201	107	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
5180	1201	108	of	of	IN
5180	1201	109	Revenue	Revenue	NNP
5180	1201	110	,	,	,
5180	1201	111	460	460	CD
5180	1201	112	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1201	113	575	575	CD
5180	1201	114	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1201	115	1983	1983	CD
5180	1201	116	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1201	117	,	,	,
5180	1201	118	which	which	WDT
5180	1201	119	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1201	120	explain	explain	VBP
5180	1201	121	in	in	IN
5180	1201	122	the	the	DT
5180	1201	123	margin	margin	NN
5180	1201	124	.	.	.
5180	1202	1	4	4	LS
5180	1202	2	.	.	.
5180	1203	1	Reasons	reason	NNS
5180	1203	2	for	for	IN
5180	1203	3	Applying	apply	VBG
5180	1203	4	Strict	Strict	NNP
5180	1203	5	Scrutiny	Scrutiny	NNP
5180	1203	6	1	1	CD
5180	1203	7	.	.	.
5180	1204	1	Selective	Selective	NNP
5180	1204	2	Exclusion	exclusion	NN
5180	1204	3	From	from	IN
5180	1204	4	a	a	DT
5180	1204	5	"	"	``
5180	1204	6	Vast	Vast	NNP
5180	1204	7	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
5180	1204	8	Forum	Forum	NNP
5180	1204	9	"	"	``
5180	1204	10	Applying	apply	VBG
5180	1204	11	these	these	DT
5180	1204	12	principles	principle	NNS
5180	1204	13	to	to	IN
5180	1204	14	public	public	JJ
5180	1204	15	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1204	16	,	,	,
5180	1204	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1204	18	agree	agree	VBP
5180	1204	19	with	with	IN
5180	1204	20	the	the	DT
5180	1204	21	government	government	NN
5180	1204	22	that	that	WDT
5180	1204	23	generally	generally	RB
5180	1204	24	the	the	DT
5180	1204	25	First	First	NNP
5180	1204	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1204	27	subjects	subject	VBZ
5180	1204	28	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1204	29	'	'	POS
5180	1204	30	content	content	NN
5180	1204	31	-	-	HYPH
5180	1204	32	based	base	VBN
5180	1204	33	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1204	34	about	about	IN
5180	1204	35	which	which	WDT
5180	1204	36	print	print	NN
5180	1204	37	materials	material	NNS
5180	1204	38	to	to	TO
5180	1204	39	acquire	acquire	VB
5180	1204	40	for	for	IN
5180	1204	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1204	42	collections	collection	NNS
5180	1204	43	to	to	IN
5180	1204	44	only	only	JJ
5180	1204	45	rational	rational	JJ
5180	1204	46	review	review	NN
5180	1204	47	.	.	.
5180	1205	1	In	in	IN
5180	1205	2	making	make	VBG
5180	1205	3	these	these	DT
5180	1205	4	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1205	5	,	,	,
5180	1205	6	public	public	JJ
5180	1205	7	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1205	8	are	be	VBP
5180	1205	9	generally	generally	RB
5180	1205	10	free	free	JJ
5180	1205	11	to	to	TO
5180	1205	12	adopt	adopt	VB
5180	1205	13	collection	collection	NN
5180	1205	14	development	development	NN
5180	1205	15	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	1205	16	that	that	WDT
5180	1205	17	reflect	reflect	VBP
5180	1205	18	not	not	RB
5180	1205	19	simply	simply	RB
5180	1205	20	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1205	21	'	'	POS
5180	1205	22	demand	demand	NN
5180	1205	23	for	for	IN
5180	1205	24	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1205	25	material	material	NN
5180	1205	26	,	,	,
5180	1205	27	but	but	CC
5180	1205	28	also	also	RB
5180	1205	29	the	the	DT
5180	1205	30	library	library	NN
5180	1205	31	's	's	POS
5180	1205	32	evaluation	evaluation	NN
5180	1205	33	of	of	IN
5180	1205	34	the	the	DT
5180	1205	35	material	material	NN
5180	1205	36	's	's	POS
5180	1205	37	quality	quality	NN
5180	1205	38	.	.	.
5180	1206	1	See	see	VB
5180	1206	2	Bernard	Bernard	NNP
5180	1206	3	W.	W.	NNP
5180	1206	4	Bell	Bell	NNP
5180	1206	5	,	,	,
5180	1206	6	Filth	Filth	NNP
5180	1206	7	,	,	,
5180	1206	8	Filtering	Filtering	NNP
5180	1206	9	,	,	,
5180	1206	10	and	and	CC
5180	1206	11	the	the	DT
5180	1206	12	First	First	NNP
5180	1206	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1206	14	:	:	:
5180	1206	15	Ruminations	rumination	NNS
5180	1206	16	on	on	IN
5180	1206	17	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1206	18	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	1206	19	'	'	POS
5180	1206	20	Use	Use	NNP
5180	1206	21	of	of	IN
5180	1206	22	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	1206	23	Filtering	Filtering	NNP
5180	1206	24	Software	Software	NNP
5180	1206	25	,	,	,
5180	1206	26	53	53	CD
5180	1206	27	Fed	Fed	NNP
5180	1206	28	.	.	.
5180	1207	1	Comm	Comm	NNP
5180	1207	2	.	.	.
5180	1208	1	L.J.	L.J.	NNP
5180	1209	1	191	191	CD
5180	1209	2	,	,	,
5180	1209	3	225	225	CD
5180	1209	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1209	5	2001	2001	CD
5180	1209	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1209	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1209	8	"	"	``
5180	1209	9	Librarians	Librarians	NNPS
5180	1209	10	should	should	MD
5180	1209	11	have	have	VB
5180	1209	12	the	the	DT
5180	1209	13	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1209	14	to	to	TO
5180	1209	15	decide	decide	VB
5180	1209	16	that	that	IN
5180	1209	17	the	the	DT
5180	1209	18	library	library	NN
5180	1209	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	1209	20	committed	commit	VBN
5180	1209	21	to	to	IN
5180	1209	22	intellectual	intellectual	JJ
5180	1209	23	inquiry	inquiry	NN
5180	1209	24	,	,	,
5180	1209	25	not	not	RB
5180	1209	26	to	to	IN
5180	1209	27	the	the	DT
5180	1209	28	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
5180	1209	29	of	of	IN
5180	1209	30	the	the	DT
5180	1209	31	full	full	JJ
5180	1209	32	range	range	NN
5180	1209	33	of	of	IN
5180	1209	34	human	human	JJ
5180	1209	35	desires	desire	NNS
5180	1209	36	.	.	.
5180	1209	37	"	"	''
5180	1209	38	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1209	39	.	.	.
5180	1210	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1210	2	,	,	,
5180	1210	3	a	a	DT
5180	1210	4	public	public	JJ
5180	1210	5	library	library	NN
5180	1210	6	's	's	POS
5180	1210	7	decision	decision	NN
5180	1210	8	to	to	TO
5180	1210	9	use	use	VB
5180	1210	10	the	the	DT
5180	1210	11	last	last	JJ
5180	1210	12	$	$	$
5180	1210	13	100	100	CD
5180	1210	14	of	of	IN
5180	1210	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1210	16	budget	budget	NN
5180	1210	17	to	to	TO
5180	1210	18	purchase	purchase	VB
5180	1210	19	the	the	DT
5180	1210	20	complete	complete	JJ
5180	1210	21	works	work	NNS
5180	1210	22	of	of	IN
5180	1210	23	Shakespeare	Shakespeare	NNP
5180	1210	24	even	even	RB
5180	1210	25	though	though	IN
5180	1210	26	more	more	JJR
5180	1210	27	of	of	IN
5180	1210	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1210	29	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1210	30	would	would	MD
5180	1210	31	prefer	prefer	VB
5180	1210	32	the	the	DT
5180	1210	33	library	library	NN
5180	1210	34	to	to	TO
5180	1210	35	use	use	VB
5180	1210	36	the	the	DT
5180	1210	37	same	same	JJ
5180	1210	38	amount	amount	NN
5180	1210	39	to	to	TO
5180	1210	40	purchase	purchase	VB
5180	1210	41	the	the	DT
5180	1210	42	complete	complete	JJ
5180	1210	43	works	work	NNS
5180	1210	44	of	of	IN
5180	1210	45	John	John	NNP
5180	1210	46	Grisham	Grisham	NNP
5180	1210	47	,	,	,
5180	1210	48	is	be	VBZ
5180	1210	49	not	not	RB
5180	1210	50	,	,	,
5180	1210	51	in	in	IN
5180	1210	52	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1210	53	view	view	NN
5180	1210	54	,	,	,
5180	1210	55	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1210	56	to	to	IN
5180	1210	57	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1210	58	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1210	59	.	.	.
5180	1211	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1211	2	.	.	.
5180	1212	1	NEA	NEA	NNP
5180	1212	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	1212	3	Finley	Finley	NNP
5180	1212	4	,	,	,
5180	1212	5	524	524	CD
5180	1212	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1212	7	569	569	CD
5180	1212	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1212	9	1998	1998	CD
5180	1212	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1212	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1212	12	subjecting	subject	VBG
5180	1212	13	only	only	RB
5180	1212	14	to	to	IN
5180	1212	15	rational	rational	JJ
5180	1212	16	basis	basis	NN
5180	1212	17	review	review	NN
5180	1212	18	the	the	DT
5180	1212	19	government	government	NN
5180	1212	20	's	's	POS
5180	1212	21	decision	decision	NN
5180	1212	22	to	to	TO
5180	1212	23	award	award	VB
5180	1212	24	NEA	NEA	NNP
5180	1212	25	grants	grant	NNS
5180	1212	26	on	on	IN
5180	1212	27	the	the	DT
5180	1212	28	basis	basis	NN
5180	1212	29	of	of	IN
5180	1212	30	,	,	,
5180	1212	31	inter	inter	NNP
5180	1212	32	alia	alia	NNP
5180	1212	33	,	,	,
5180	1212	34	artistic	artistic	JJ
5180	1212	35	excellence	excellence	NN
5180	1212	36	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1212	37	.	.	.
5180	1213	1	Nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	1213	2	,	,	,
5180	1213	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1213	4	disagree	disagree	VBP
5180	1213	5	with	with	IN
5180	1213	6	the	the	DT
5180	1213	7	government	government	NN
5180	1213	8	's	's	POS
5180	1213	9	argument	argument	NN
5180	1213	10	that	that	IN
5180	1213	11	public	public	JJ
5180	1213	12	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1213	13	'	'	POS
5180	1213	14	use	use	NN
5180	1213	15	of	of	IN
5180	1213	16	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1213	17	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1213	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	1213	19	no	no	RB
5180	1213	20	different	different	JJ
5180	1213	21	,	,	,
5180	1213	22	for	for	IN
5180	1213	23	First	First	NNP
5180	1213	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1213	25	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1213	26	,	,	,
5180	1213	27	from	from	IN
5180	1213	28	the	the	DT
5180	1213	29	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	1213	30	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1213	31	that	that	WDT
5180	1213	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1213	33	exercise	exercise	VBP
5180	1213	34	when	when	WRB
5180	1213	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1213	36	choose	choose	VBP
5180	1213	37	to	to	TO
5180	1213	38	acquire	acquire	VB
5180	1213	39	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1213	40	books	book	NNS
5180	1213	41	on	on	IN
5180	1213	42	the	the	DT
5180	1213	43	basis	basis	NN
5180	1213	44	of	of	IN
5180	1213	45	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	1213	46	'	'	POS
5180	1213	47	evaluation	evaluation	NN
5180	1213	48	of	of	IN
5180	1213	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1213	50	quality	quality	NN
5180	1213	51	.	.	.
5180	1214	1	The	the	DT
5180	1214	2	central	central	JJ
5180	1214	3	difference	difference	NN
5180	1214	4	,	,	,
5180	1214	5	in	in	IN
5180	1214	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1214	7	view	view	NN
5180	1214	8	,	,	,
5180	1214	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	1214	10	that	that	IN
5180	1214	11	by	by	IN
5180	1214	12	providing	provide	VBG
5180	1214	13	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1214	14	with	with	IN
5180	1214	15	even	even	RB
5180	1214	16	filtered	filter	VBN
5180	1214	17	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1214	18	access	access	NN
5180	1214	19	,	,	,
5180	1214	20	the	the	DT
5180	1214	21	library	library	NN
5180	1214	22	permits	permit	VBZ
5180	1214	23	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1214	24	to	to	TO
5180	1214	25	receive	receive	VB
5180	1214	26	speech	speech	NN
5180	1214	27	on	on	IN
5180	1214	28	a	a	DT
5180	1214	29	virtually	virtually	RB
5180	1214	30	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	1214	31	number	number	NN
5180	1214	32	of	of	IN
5180	1214	33	topics	topic	NNS
5180	1214	34	,	,	,
5180	1214	35	from	from	IN
5180	1214	36	a	a	DT
5180	1214	37	virtually	virtually	RB
5180	1214	38	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	1214	39	number	number	NN
5180	1214	40	of	of	IN
5180	1214	41	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1214	42	,	,	,
5180	1214	43	without	without	IN
5180	1214	44	attempting	attempt	VBG
5180	1214	45	to	to	TO
5180	1214	46	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	1214	47	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1214	48	'	'	POS
5180	1214	49	access	access	NN
5180	1214	50	to	to	IN
5180	1214	51	speech	speech	NN
5180	1214	52	that	that	IN
5180	1214	53	the	the	DT
5180	1214	54	library	library	NN
5180	1214	55	,	,	,
5180	1214	56	in	in	IN
5180	1214	57	the	the	DT
5180	1214	58	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	1214	59	of	of	IN
5180	1214	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1214	61	professional	professional	JJ
5180	1214	62	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1214	63	,	,	,
5180	1214	64	determines	determine	VBZ
5180	1214	65	to	to	TO
5180	1214	66	be	be	VB
5180	1214	67	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	1214	68	valuable	valuable	JJ
5180	1214	69	.	.	.
5180	1215	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1215	2	.	.	.
5180	1216	1	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
5180	1216	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	1216	3	Rector	Rector	NNP
5180	1216	4	&	&	CC
5180	1216	5	Visitors	Visitors	NNPS
5180	1216	6	of	of	IN
5180	1216	7	Univ	Univ	NNP
5180	1216	8	.	.	.
5180	1217	1	of	of	IN
5180	1217	2	Va.	Virginia	NNP
5180	1217	3	,	,	,
5180	1217	4	515	515	CD
5180	1217	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1217	6	819	819	CD
5180	1217	7	,	,	,
5180	1217	8	834	834	CD
5180	1217	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1217	10	1995	1995	CD
5180	1217	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1217	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1217	13	applying	apply	VBG
5180	1217	14	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1217	15	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1217	16	to	to	TO
5180	1217	17	viewpoint	viewpoint	NN
5180	1217	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	1217	19	based	base	VBN
5180	1217	20	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1217	21	where	where	WRB
5180	1217	22	the	the	DT
5180	1217	23	state	state	NN
5180	1217	24	"	"	``
5180	1217	25	does	do	VBZ
5180	1217	26	not	not	RB
5180	1217	27	itself	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1217	28	speak	speak	VB
5180	1217	29	or	or	CC
5180	1217	30	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	1217	31	transmittal	transmittal	NN
5180	1217	32	of	of	IN
5180	1217	33	a	a	DT
5180	1217	34	message	message	NN
5180	1217	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1217	36	favors	favor	VBZ
5180	1217	37	but	but	CC
5180	1217	38	instead	instead	RB
5180	1217	39	expends	expend	VBZ
5180	1217	40	funds	fund	NNS
5180	1217	41	to	to	TO
5180	1217	42	encourage	encourage	VB
5180	1217	43	a	a	DT
5180	1217	44	diversity	diversity	NN
5180	1217	45	of	of	IN
5180	1217	46	views	view	NNS
5180	1217	47	from	from	IN
5180	1217	48	private	private	JJ
5180	1217	49	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1217	50	"	"	''
5180	1217	51	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1217	52	.	.	.
5180	1218	1	See	see	VB
5180	1218	2	generally	generally	RB
5180	1218	3	supra	supra	NNP
5180	1218	4	Section	section	NN
5180	1218	5	IV.C.	iv.c.	NN
5180	1219	1	In	in	IN
5180	1219	2	those	those	DT
5180	1219	3	cases	case	NNS
5180	1219	4	upholding	uphold	VBG
5180	1219	5	the	the	DT
5180	1219	6	government	government	NN
5180	1219	7	's	's	POS
5180	1219	8	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	1219	9	of	of	IN
5180	1219	10	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	1219	11	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1219	12	in	in	IN
5180	1219	13	selecting	select	VBG
5180	1219	14	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1219	15	speech	speech	NN
5180	1219	16	for	for	IN
5180	1219	17	subsidization	subsidization	NN
5180	1219	18	or	or	CC
5180	1219	19	inclusion	inclusion	NN
5180	1219	20	in	in	IN
5180	1219	21	a	a	DT
5180	1219	22	state	state	NN
5180	1219	23	-	-	HYPH
5180	1219	24	created	create	VBN
5180	1219	25	forum	forum	NN
5180	1219	26	,	,	,
5180	1219	27	the	the	DT
5180	1219	28	state	state	NN
5180	1219	29	actor	actor	NN
5180	1219	30	exercising	exercise	VBG
5180	1219	31	the	the	DT
5180	1219	32	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	1219	33	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1219	34	has	have	VBZ
5180	1219	35	at	at	IN
5180	1219	36	least	least	JJS
5180	1219	37	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	1219	38	the	the	DT
5180	1219	39	content	content	NN
5180	1219	40	of	of	IN
5180	1219	41	the	the	DT
5180	1219	42	speech	speech	NN
5180	1219	43	that	that	WDT
5180	1219	44	the	the	DT
5180	1219	45	forum	forum	NN
5180	1219	46	facilitates	facilitate	VBZ
5180	1219	47	.	.	.
5180	1220	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1220	2	,	,	,
5180	1220	3	in	in	IN
5180	1220	4	Finley	Finley	NNP
5180	1220	5	the	the	DT
5180	1220	6	NEA	NEA	NNP
5180	1220	7	examined	examine	VBD
5180	1220	8	the	the	DT
5180	1220	9	content	content	NN
5180	1220	10	of	of	IN
5180	1220	11	those	those	DT
5180	1220	12	works	work	NNS
5180	1220	13	of	of	IN
5180	1220	14	art	art	NN
5180	1220	15	that	that	WDT
5180	1220	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1220	17	chose	choose	VBD
5180	1220	18	to	to	TO
5180	1220	19	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	1220	20	,	,	,
5180	1220	21	and	and	CC
5180	1220	22	in	in	IN
5180	1220	23	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
5180	1220	24	Educational	Educational	NNP
5180	1220	25	Television	Television	NNP
5180	1220	26	Commission	Commission	NNP
5180	1220	27	v.	v.	CC
5180	1220	28	Forbes	Forbes	NNP
5180	1220	29	,	,	,
5180	1220	30	523	523	CD
5180	1220	31	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1220	32	666	666	CD
5180	1220	33	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1220	34	1998	1998	CD
5180	1220	35	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1220	36	,	,	,
5180	1220	37	the	the	DT
5180	1220	38	public	public	JJ
5180	1220	39	broadcaster	broadcaster	NN
5180	1220	40	specifically	specifically	RB
5180	1220	41	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	1220	42	and	and	CC
5180	1220	43	approved	approve	VBN
5180	1220	44	each	each	DT
5180	1220	45	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	1220	46	permitted	permit	VBN
5180	1220	47	to	to	TO
5180	1220	48	participate	participate	VB
5180	1220	49	in	in	IN
5180	1220	50	the	the	DT
5180	1220	51	debate	debate	NN
5180	1220	52	.	.	.
5180	1221	1	See	see	VB
5180	1221	2	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1221	3	d	d	VBN
5180	1221	4	.	.	.
5180	1222	1	at	at	IN
5180	1222	2	673	673	CD
5180	1222	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1222	4	"	"	``
5180	1222	5	In	in	IN
5180	1222	6	the	the	DT
5180	1222	7	case	case	NN
5180	1222	8	of	of	IN
5180	1222	9	television	television	NN
5180	1222	10	broadcasting	broadcasting	NN
5180	1222	11	,	,	,
5180	1222	12	.	.	.
5180	1223	1	.	.	.
5180	1224	1	.	.	.
5180	1225	1	broad	broad	JJ
5180	1225	2	rights	right	NNS
5180	1225	3	of	of	IN
5180	1225	4	access	access	NN
5180	1225	5	for	for	IN
5180	1225	6	outside	outside	JJ
5180	1225	7	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1225	8	would	would	MD
5180	1225	9	be	be	VB
5180	1225	10	antithetical	antithetical	JJ
5180	1225	11	,	,	,
5180	1225	12	as	as	IN
5180	1225	13	a	a	DT
5180	1225	14	general	general	JJ
5180	1225	15	rule	rule	NN
5180	1225	16	,	,	,
5180	1225	17	to	to	IN
5180	1225	18	the	the	DT
5180	1225	19	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1225	20	that	that	WDT
5180	1225	21	stations	station	VBZ
5180	1225	22	and	and	CC
5180	1225	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1225	24	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	1225	25	staff	staff	NN
5180	1225	26	must	must	MD
5180	1225	27	exercise	exercise	VB
5180	1225	28	to	to	TO
5180	1225	29	fulfill	fulfill	VB
5180	1225	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1225	31	journalistic	journalistic	JJ
5180	1225	32	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1225	33	and	and	CC
5180	1225	34	statutory	statutory	JJ
5180	1225	35	obligations	obligation	NNS
5180	1225	36	.	.	.
5180	1226	1	")	")	``
5180	1226	2	;	;	:
5180	1226	3	Finley	Finley	NNP
5180	1226	4	,	,	,
5180	1226	5	524	524	CD
5180	1226	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1226	7	at	at	IN
5180	1226	8	586	586	CD
5180	1226	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1226	10	"	"	``
5180	1226	11	The	the	DT
5180	1226	12	NEA	NEA	NNP
5180	1226	13	's	's	POS
5180	1226	14	mandate	mandate	NN
5180	1226	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	1226	16	to	to	TO
5180	1226	17	make	make	VB
5180	1226	18	esthetic	esthetic	JJ
5180	1226	19	judgments	judgment	NNS
5180	1226	20	,	,	,
5180	1226	21	and	and	CC
5180	1226	22	the	the	DT
5180	1226	23	inherently	inherently	RB
5180	1226	24	content	content	NN
5180	1226	25	-	-	HYPH
5180	1226	26	based	base	VBN
5180	1226	27	'	'	``
5180	1226	28	excellence	excellence	NN
5180	1226	29	'	'	''
5180	1226	30	threshold	threshold	NN
5180	1226	31	for	for	IN
5180	1226	32	NEA	NEA	NNP
5180	1226	33	support	support	NN
5180	1226	34	sets	set	VBZ
5180	1226	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1226	36	apart	apart	RB
5180	1226	37	from	from	IN
5180	1226	38	the	the	DT
5180	1226	39	subsidy	subsidy	NN
5180	1226	40	at	at	IN
5180	1226	41	issue	issue	NN
5180	1226	42	in	in	IN
5180	1226	43	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
5180	1226	44	–	–	:
5180	1226	45	which	which	WDT
5180	1226	46	was	be	VBD
5180	1226	47	available	available	JJ
5180	1226	48	to	to	IN
5180	1226	49	all	all	DT
5180	1226	50	student	student	NN
5180	1226	51	organizations	organization	NNS
5180	1226	52	that	that	WDT
5180	1226	53	were	be	VBD
5180	1226	54	'	'	``
5180	1226	55	related	relate	VBN
5180	1226	56	to	to	IN
5180	1226	57	the	the	DT
5180	1226	58	educational	educational	JJ
5180	1226	59	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1226	60	of	of	IN
5180	1226	61	the	the	DT
5180	1226	62	University	University	NNP
5180	1226	63	.	.	.
5180	1227	1	.	.	.
5180	1228	1	.	.	.
5180	1229	1	.	.	.
5180	1229	2	'	'	''
5180	1229	3	"	"	''
5180	1229	4	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1230	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1230	2	quoting	quote	VBG
5180	1230	3	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
5180	1230	4	,	,	,
5180	1230	5	515	515	CD
5180	1230	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1230	7	at	at	IN
5180	1230	8	824	824	CD
5180	1230	9	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1230	10	;	;	:
5180	1230	11	see	see	VB
5180	1230	12	also	also	RB
5180	1230	13	Cornelius	Cornelius	NNP
5180	1230	14	v.	v.	IN
5180	1230	15	NAACP	NAACP	NNP
5180	1230	16	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	1230	17	Def	Def	NNP
5180	1230	18	.	.	.
5180	1231	1	&	&	CC
5180	1231	2	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	1231	3	.	.	.
5180	1232	1	Fund	Fund	NNP
5180	1232	2	,	,	,
5180	1232	3	473	473	CD
5180	1232	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1232	5	788	788	CD
5180	1232	6	,	,	,
5180	1232	7	804	804	CD
5180	1232	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1232	9	1985	1985	CD
5180	1232	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1232	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1232	12	"	"	``
5180	1232	13	The	the	DT
5180	1232	14	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1232	15	's	's	POS
5180	1232	16	consistent	consistent	JJ
5180	1232	17	policy	policy	NN
5180	1232	18	has	have	VBZ
5180	1232	19	been	be	VBN
5180	1232	20	to	to	TO
5180	1232	21	limit	limit	VB
5180	1232	22	participation	participation	NN
5180	1232	23	in	in	IN
5180	1232	24	the	the	DT
5180	1232	25	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1232	26	Combined	Combined	NNP
5180	1232	27	Federal	Federal	NNP
5180	1232	28	Campaign	Campaign	NNP
5180	1232	29	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1232	30	to	to	TO
5180	1232	31	'	'	``
5180	1232	32	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1232	33	'	'	''
5180	1232	34	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
5180	1232	35	agencies	agency	NNS
5180	1232	36	and	and	CC
5180	1232	37	to	to	TO
5180	1232	38	require	require	VB
5180	1232	39	agencies	agency	NNS
5180	1232	40	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	1232	41	admission	admission	NN
5180	1232	42	to	to	TO
5180	1232	43	obtain	obtain	VB
5180	1232	44	permission	permission	NN
5180	1232	45	from	from	IN
5180	1232	46	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1232	47	and	and	CC
5180	1232	48	local	local	JJ
5180	1232	49	Campaign	campaign	NN
5180	1232	50	officials	official	NNS
5180	1232	51	.	.	.
5180	1233	1	.	.	.
5180	1234	1	.	.	.
5180	1235	1	.	.	.
5180	1236	1	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1236	2	T]here	T]here	NNP
5180	1236	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1236	4	no	no	DT
5180	1236	5	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	1236	6	suggesting	suggest	VBG
5180	1236	7	that	that	IN
5180	1236	8	the	the	DT
5180	1236	9	granting	granting	NN
5180	1236	10	of	of	IN
5180	1236	11	the	the	DT
5180	1236	12	requisite	requisite	JJ
5180	1236	13	permission	permission	NN
5180	1236	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	1236	15	merely	merely	RB
5180	1236	16	ministerial	ministerial	JJ
5180	1236	17	.	.	.
5180	1236	18	"	"	''
5180	1236	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1236	20	.	.	.
5180	1237	1	The	the	DT
5180	1237	2	essence	essence	NN
5180	1237	3	of	of	IN
5180	1237	4	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	1237	5	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1237	6	requires	require	VBZ
5180	1237	7	the	the	DT
5180	1237	8	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	1237	9	of	of	IN
5180	1237	10	professional	professional	JJ
5180	1237	11	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1237	12	in	in	IN
5180	1237	13	examining	examine	VBG
5180	1237	14	the	the	DT
5180	1237	15	content	content	NN
5180	1237	16	that	that	WDT
5180	1237	17	the	the	DT
5180	1237	18	government	government	NN
5180	1237	19	singles	single	VBZ
5180	1237	20	out	out	RP
5180	1237	21	as	as	IN
5180	1237	22	speech	speech	NN
5180	1237	23	of	of	IN
5180	1237	24	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1237	25	value	value	NN
5180	1237	26	.	.	.
5180	1238	1	This	this	DT
5180	1238	2	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	1238	3	of	of	IN
5180	1238	4	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	1238	5	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1238	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	1238	7	evident	evident	JJ
5180	1238	8	in	in	IN
5180	1238	9	a	a	DT
5180	1238	10	library	library	NN
5180	1238	11	's	's	POS
5180	1238	12	decision	decision	NN
5180	1238	13	to	to	TO
5180	1238	14	acquire	acquire	VB
5180	1238	15	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1238	16	books	book	NNS
5180	1238	17	for	for	IN
5180	1238	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1238	19	collection	collection	NN
5180	1238	20	.	.	.
5180	1239	1	As	as	IN
5180	1239	2	the	the	DT
5180	1239	3	government	government	NN
5180	1239	4	's	's	POS
5180	1239	5	experts	expert	NNS
5180	1239	6	in	in	IN
5180	1239	7	library	library	NN
5180	1239	8	science	science	NN
5180	1239	9	testified	testify	VBD
5180	1239	10	,	,	,
5180	1239	11	in	in	IN
5180	1239	12	selecting	select	VBG
5180	1239	13	a	a	DT
5180	1239	14	book	book	NN
5180	1239	15	for	for	IN
5180	1239	16	a	a	DT
5180	1239	17	library	library	NN
5180	1239	18	's	's	POS
5180	1239	19	collection	collection	NN
5180	1239	20	,	,	,
5180	1239	21	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	1239	22	evaluate	evaluate	VBP
5180	1239	23	the	the	DT
5180	1239	24	book	book	NN
5180	1239	25	's	's	POS
5180	1239	26	quality	quality	NN
5180	1239	27	by	by	IN
5180	1239	28	reference	reference	NN
5180	1239	29	to	to	IN
5180	1239	30	a	a	DT
5180	1239	31	variety	variety	NN
5180	1239	32	of	of	IN
5180	1239	33	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	1239	34	such	such	JJ
5180	1239	35	as	as	IN
5180	1239	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1239	37	accuracy	accuracy	NN
5180	1239	38	,	,	,
5180	1239	39	the	the	DT
5180	1239	40	title	title	NN
5180	1239	41	's	's	POS
5180	1239	42	niche	niche	NN
5180	1239	43	in	in	IN
5180	1239	44	relation	relation	NN
5180	1239	45	to	to	IN
5180	1239	46	the	the	DT
5180	1239	47	rest	rest	NN
5180	1239	48	of	of	IN
5180	1239	49	the	the	DT
5180	1239	50	collection	collection	NN
5180	1239	51	,	,	,
5180	1239	52	the	the	DT
5180	1239	53	authority	authority	NN
5180	1239	54	of	of	IN
5180	1239	55	the	the	DT
5180	1239	56	author	author	NN
5180	1239	57	,	,	,
5180	1239	58	the	the	DT
5180	1239	59	publisher	publisher	NN
5180	1239	60	,	,	,
5180	1239	61	the	the	DT
5180	1239	62	work	work	NN
5180	1239	63	's	's	POS
5180	1239	64	presentation	presentation	NN
5180	1239	65	,	,	,
5180	1239	66	and	and	CC
5180	1239	67	how	how	WRB
5180	1239	68	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1239	69	compares	compare	VBZ
5180	1239	70	with	with	IN
5180	1239	71	other	other	JJ
5180	1239	72	material	material	NN
5180	1239	73	available	available	JJ
5180	1239	74	in	in	IN
5180	1239	75	the	the	DT
5180	1239	76	same	same	JJ
5180	1239	77	genre	genre	NN
5180	1239	78	or	or	CC
5180	1239	79	on	on	IN
5180	1239	80	the	the	DT
5180	1239	81	same	same	JJ
5180	1239	82	subject	subject	NN
5180	1239	83	.	.	.
5180	1240	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1240	2	,	,	,
5180	1240	3	the	the	DT
5180	1240	4	content	content	NN
5180	1240	5	of	of	IN
5180	1240	6	every	every	DT
5180	1240	7	book	book	NN
5180	1240	8	that	that	WDT
5180	1240	9	a	a	DT
5180	1240	10	library	library	NN
5180	1240	11	acquires	acquire	NNS
5180	1240	12	has	have	VBZ
5180	1240	13	been	be	VBN
5180	1240	14	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	1240	15	by	by	IN
5180	1240	16	the	the	DT
5180	1240	17	library	library	NN
5180	1240	18	's	's	POS
5180	1240	19	collection	collection	NN
5180	1240	20	development	development	NN
5180	1240	21	staff	staff	NN
5180	1240	22	or	or	CC
5180	1240	23	someone	someone	NN
5180	1240	24	to	to	TO
5180	1240	25	whom	whom	WP
5180	1240	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1240	27	have	have	VBP
5180	1240	28	delegated	delegate	VBN
5180	1240	29	the	the	DT
5180	1240	30	task	task	NN
5180	1240	31	,	,	,
5180	1240	32	and	and	CC
5180	1240	33	has	have	VBZ
5180	1240	34	been	be	VBN
5180	1240	35	judged	judge	VBN
5180	1240	36	to	to	TO
5180	1240	37	meet	meet	VB
5180	1240	38	the	the	DT
5180	1240	39	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	1240	40	that	that	WDT
5180	1240	41	form	form	VBP
5180	1240	42	the	the	DT
5180	1240	43	basis	basis	NN
5180	1240	44	for	for	IN
5180	1240	45	the	the	DT
5180	1240	46	library	library	NN
5180	1240	47	's	's	POS
5180	1240	48	collection	collection	NN
5180	1240	49	development	development	NN
5180	1240	50	policy	policy	NN
5180	1240	51	.	.	.
5180	1241	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1241	2	some	some	DT
5180	1241	3	public	public	JJ
5180	1241	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1241	5	use	use	VBP
5180	1241	6	"	"	``
5180	1241	7	approval	approval	NN
5180	1241	8	plans	plan	NNS
5180	1241	9	"	"	''
5180	1241	10	to	to	TO
5180	1241	11	delegate	delegate	VB
5180	1241	12	the	the	DT
5180	1241	13	collection	collection	NN
5180	1241	14	development	development	NN
5180	1241	15	to	to	IN
5180	1241	16	third	third	JJ
5180	1241	17	-	-	HYPH
5180	1241	18	party	party	NN
5180	1241	19	vendors	vendor	NNS
5180	1241	20	which	which	WDT
5180	1241	21	provide	provide	VBP
5180	1241	22	the	the	DT
5180	1241	23	library	library	NN
5180	1241	24	with	with	IN
5180	1241	25	recommended	recommend	VBN
5180	1241	26	materials	material	NNS
5180	1241	27	that	that	IN
5180	1241	28	the	the	DT
5180	1241	29	library	library	NN
5180	1241	30	is	be	VBZ
5180	1241	31	then	then	RB
5180	1241	32	free	free	JJ
5180	1241	33	to	to	TO
5180	1241	34	retain	retain	VB
5180	1241	35	or	or	CC
5180	1241	36	return	return	VB
5180	1241	37	to	to	IN
5180	1241	38	the	the	DT
5180	1241	39	vendor	vendor	NN
5180	1241	40	,	,	,
5180	1241	41	the	the	DT
5180	1241	42	same	same	JJ
5180	1241	43	principle	principle	NN
5180	1241	44	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	1241	45	attains	attain	VBZ
5180	1241	46	.	.	.
5180	1242	1	In	in	IN
5180	1242	2	contrast	contrast	NN
5180	1242	3	,	,	,
5180	1242	4	in	in	IN
5180	1242	5	providing	provide	VBG
5180	1242	6	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1242	7	with	with	IN
5180	1242	8	even	even	RB
5180	1242	9	filtered	filter	VBN
5180	1242	10	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1242	11	access	access	NN
5180	1242	12	,	,	,
5180	1242	13	a	a	DT
5180	1242	14	public	public	JJ
5180	1242	15	library	library	NN
5180	1242	16	invites	invite	VBZ
5180	1242	17	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1242	18	to	to	TO
5180	1242	19	access	access	NN
5180	1242	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	1242	21	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1242	22	content	content	NN
5180	1242	23	has	have	VBZ
5180	1242	24	never	never	RB
5180	1242	25	been	be	VBN
5180	1242	26	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	1242	27	and	and	CC
5180	1242	28	recommended	recommend	VBN
5180	1242	29	as	as	RB
5180	1242	30	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	1242	31	valuable	valuable	JJ
5180	1242	32	by	by	IN
5180	1242	33	either	either	CC
5180	1242	34	a	a	DT
5180	1242	35	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	1242	36	or	or	CC
5180	1242	37	a	a	DT
5180	1242	38	third	third	JJ
5180	1242	39	party	party	NN
5180	1242	40	to	to	TO
5180	1242	41	whom	whom	WP
5180	1242	42	the	the	DT
5180	1242	43	library	library	NN
5180	1242	44	has	have	VBZ
5180	1242	45	delegated	delegate	VBN
5180	1242	46	collection	collection	NN
5180	1242	47	development	development	NN
5180	1242	48	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1242	49	.	.	.
5180	1243	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1243	2	several	several	JJ
5180	1243	3	of	of	IN
5180	1243	4	the	the	DT
5180	1243	5	government	government	NN
5180	1243	6	's	's	POS
5180	1243	7	librarian	librarian	JJ
5180	1243	8	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	1243	9	who	who	WP
5180	1243	10	testified	testify	VBD
5180	1243	11	at	at	IN
5180	1243	12	trial	trial	NN
5180	1243	13	purport	purport	NN
5180	1243	14	to	to	TO
5180	1243	15	apply	apply	VB
5180	1243	16	the	the	DT
5180	1243	17	same	same	JJ
5180	1243	18	standards	standard	NNS
5180	1243	19	that	that	WDT
5180	1243	20	govern	govern	VBP
5180	1243	21	the	the	DT
5180	1243	22	library	library	NN
5180	1243	23	's	's	POS
5180	1243	24	acquisition	acquisition	NN
5180	1243	25	of	of	IN
5180	1243	26	print	print	NN
5180	1243	27	materials	material	NNS
5180	1243	28	to	to	IN
5180	1243	29	the	the	DT
5180	1243	30	library	library	NN
5180	1243	31	's	's	POS
5180	1243	32	provision	provision	NN
5180	1243	33	of	of	IN
5180	1243	34	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1243	35	access	access	NN
5180	1243	36	to	to	IN
5180	1243	37	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1243	38	,	,	,
5180	1243	39	when	when	WRB
5180	1243	40	public	public	JJ
5180	1243	41	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1243	42	provide	provide	VBP
5180	1243	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1243	44	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1243	45	with	with	IN
5180	1243	46	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1243	47	access	access	NN
5180	1243	48	,	,	,
5180	1243	49	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1243	50	intentionally	intentionally	RB
5180	1243	51	open	open	VBP
5180	1243	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1243	53	doors	door	NNS
5180	1243	54	to	to	IN
5180	1243	55	vast	vast	JJ
5180	1243	56	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	1243	57	of	of	IN
5180	1243	58	speech	speech	NN
5180	1243	59	that	that	WDT
5180	1243	60	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	1243	61	lacks	lack	VBZ
5180	1243	62	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
5180	1243	63	quality	quality	NN
5180	1243	64	to	to	TO
5180	1243	65	ever	ever	RB
5180	1243	66	be	be	VB
5180	1243	67	considered	consider	VBN
5180	1243	68	for	for	IN
5180	1243	69	the	the	DT
5180	1243	70	library	library	NN
5180	1243	71	's	's	POS
5180	1243	72	print	print	NN
5180	1243	73	collection	collection	NN
5180	1243	74	.	.	.
5180	1244	1	Unless	unless	IN
5180	1244	2	a	a	DT
5180	1244	3	library	library	NN
5180	1244	4	allows	allow	VBZ
5180	1244	5	access	access	NN
5180	1244	6	to	to	IN
5180	1244	7	only	only	RB
5180	1244	8	those	those	DT
5180	1244	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	1244	10	that	that	WDT
5180	1244	11	have	have	VBP
5180	1244	12	been	be	VBN
5180	1244	13	preselected	preselecte	VBN
5180	1244	14	as	as	IN
5180	1244	15	having	have	VBG
5180	1244	16	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1244	17	value	value	NN
5180	1244	18	,	,	,
5180	1244	19	a	a	DT
5180	1244	20	method	method	NN
5180	1244	21	that	that	WDT
5180	1244	22	,	,	,
5180	1244	23	as	as	IN
5180	1244	24	noted	note	VBN
5180	1244	25	above	above	RB
5180	1244	26	,	,	,
5180	1244	27	was	be	VBD
5180	1244	28	tried	try	VBN
5180	1244	29	and	and	CC
5180	1244	30	rejected	reject	VBN
5180	1244	31	by	by	IN
5180	1244	32	the	the	DT
5180	1244	33	Westerville	Westerville	NNP
5180	1244	34	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
5180	1244	35	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1244	36	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1244	37	,	,	,
5180	1244	38	see	see	VB
5180	1244	39	supra	supra	NNP
5180	1244	40	at	at	IN
5180	1244	41	46	46	CD
5180	1244	42	-	-	SYM
5180	1244	43	47	47	CD
5180	1244	44	,	,	,
5180	1244	45	even	even	RB
5180	1244	46	a	a	DT
5180	1244	47	library	library	NN
5180	1244	48	that	that	WDT
5180	1244	49	uses	use	VBZ
5180	1244	50	software	software	NN
5180	1244	51	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1244	52	has	have	VBZ
5180	1244	53	opened	open	VBN
5180	1244	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1244	55	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1244	56	collection	collection	NN
5180	1244	57	"	"	''
5180	1244	58	for	for	IN
5180	1244	59	indiscriminate	indiscriminate	JJ
5180	1244	60	use	use	NN
5180	1244	61	by	by	IN
5180	1244	62	the	the	DT
5180	1244	63	general	general	JJ
5180	1244	64	public	public	NN
5180	1244	65	.	.	.
5180	1244	66	"	"	''
5180	1245	1	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	1245	2	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	1245	3	.	.	.
5180	1246	1	Ass'n	Ass'n	NFP
5180	1246	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	1246	3	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	1246	4	Local	Local	NNP
5180	1246	5	Educs	Educs	NNP
5180	1246	6	.	.	.
5180	1247	1	Ass'n	Ass'n	NFP
5180	1247	2	,	,	,
5180	1247	3	460	460	CD
5180	1247	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1247	5	37	37	CD
5180	1247	6	,	,	,
5180	1247	7	47	47	CD
5180	1247	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1247	9	1983	1983	CD
5180	1247	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1247	11	.	.	.
5180	1248	1	"	"	``
5180	1248	2	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1248	3	M]ost	m]ost	NN
5180	1248	4	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1248	5	forums	forum	NNS
5180	1248	6	–	–	:
5180	1248	7	including	include	VBG
5180	1248	8	chat	chat	NN
5180	1248	9	rooms	room	NNS
5180	1248	10	,	,	,
5180	1248	11	newsgroups	newsgroup	NNS
5180	1248	12	,	,	,
5180	1248	13	mail	mail	NN
5180	1248	14	exploders	exploder	NNS
5180	1248	15	,	,	,
5180	1248	16	and	and	CC
5180	1248	17	the	the	DT
5180	1248	18	Web	web	NN
5180	1248	19	–	–	:
5180	1248	20	are	be	VBP
5180	1248	21	open	open	JJ
5180	1248	22	to	to	IN
5180	1248	23	all	all	DT
5180	1248	24	comers	comer	NNS
5180	1248	25	.	.	.
5180	1248	26	"	"	''
5180	1249	1	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1249	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	1249	3	ACLU	ACLU	NNP
5180	1249	4	,	,	,
5180	1249	5	521	521	CD
5180	1249	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1249	7	844	844	CD
5180	1249	8	,	,	,
5180	1249	9	880	880	CD
5180	1249	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1249	11	1997	1997	CD
5180	1249	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1249	13	.	.	.
5180	1250	1	The	the	DT
5180	1250	2	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
5180	1250	3	difference	difference	NN
5180	1250	4	between	between	IN
5180	1250	5	a	a	DT
5180	1250	6	library	library	NN
5180	1250	7	's	's	POS
5180	1250	8	print	print	NN
5180	1250	9	collection	collection	NN
5180	1250	10	and	and	CC
5180	1250	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1250	12	provision	provision	NN
5180	1250	13	of	of	IN
5180	1250	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1250	15	access	access	NN
5180	1250	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	1250	17	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
5180	1250	18	by	by	IN
5180	1250	19	comparing	compare	VBG
5180	1250	20	the	the	DT
5180	1250	21	extent	extent	NN
5180	1250	22	to	to	TO
5180	1250	23	which	which	WDT
5180	1250	24	the	the	DT
5180	1250	25	library	library	NN
5180	1250	26	opens	open	VBZ
5180	1250	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1250	28	print	print	NN
5180	1250	29	collection	collection	NN
5180	1250	30	to	to	IN
5180	1250	31	members	member	NNS
5180	1250	32	of	of	IN
5180	1250	33	the	the	DT
5180	1250	34	public	public	NN
5180	1250	35	to	to	TO
5180	1250	36	speak	speak	VB
5180	1250	37	on	on	IN
5180	1250	38	a	a	DT
5180	1250	39	given	give	VBN
5180	1250	40	topic	topic	NN
5180	1250	41	and	and	CC
5180	1250	42	the	the	DT
5180	1250	43	extent	extent	NN
5180	1250	44	to	to	TO
5180	1250	45	which	which	WDT
5180	1250	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1250	47	opens	open	VBZ
5180	1250	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1250	49	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1250	50	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1250	51	to	to	IN
5180	1250	52	members	member	NNS
5180	1250	53	of	of	IN
5180	1250	54	the	the	DT
5180	1250	55	public	public	NN
5180	1250	56	to	to	TO
5180	1250	57	speak	speak	VB
5180	1250	58	on	on	IN
5180	1250	59	a	a	DT
5180	1250	60	given	give	VBN
5180	1250	61	topic	topic	NN
5180	1250	62	.	.	.
5180	1251	1	When	when	WRB
5180	1251	2	a	a	DT
5180	1251	3	public	public	JJ
5180	1251	4	library	library	NN
5180	1251	5	chooses	choose	NNS
5180	1251	6	to	to	TO
5180	1251	7	carry	carry	VB
5180	1251	8	books	book	NNS
5180	1251	9	on	on	IN
5180	1251	10	a	a	DT
5180	1251	11	selected	select	VBN
5180	1251	12	topic	topic	NN
5180	1251	13	,	,	,
5180	1251	14	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	1252	1	chemistry	chemistry	NN
5180	1252	2	,	,	,
5180	1252	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1252	4	does	do	VBZ
5180	1252	5	not	not	RB
5180	1252	6	open	open	VB
5180	1252	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1252	8	print	print	NN
5180	1252	9	collection	collection	NN
5180	1252	10	to	to	IN
5180	1252	11	any	any	DT
5180	1252	12	member	member	NN
5180	1252	13	of	of	IN
5180	1252	14	the	the	DT
5180	1252	15	public	public	NN
5180	1252	16	who	who	WP
5180	1252	17	wishes	wish	VBZ
5180	1252	18	to	to	TO
5180	1252	19	write	write	VB
5180	1252	20	about	about	IN
5180	1252	21	chemistry	chemistry	NN
5180	1252	22	.	.	.
5180	1253	1	Rather	rather	RB
5180	1253	2	,	,	,
5180	1253	3	out	out	IN
5180	1253	4	of	of	IN
5180	1253	5	the	the	DT
5180	1253	6	myriad	myriad	NN
5180	1253	7	of	of	IN
5180	1253	8	books	book	NNS
5180	1253	9	that	that	WDT
5180	1253	10	have	have	VBP
5180	1253	11	ever	ever	RB
5180	1253	12	been	be	VBN
5180	1253	13	written	write	VBN
5180	1253	14	on	on	IN
5180	1253	15	chemistry	chemistry	NN
5180	1253	16	,	,	,
5180	1253	17	each	each	DT
5180	1253	18	book	book	NN
5180	1253	19	on	on	IN
5180	1253	20	chemistry	chemistry	NN
5180	1253	21	that	that	IN
5180	1253	22	the	the	DT
5180	1253	23	library	library	NN
5180	1253	24	carries	carry	VBZ
5180	1253	25	has	have	VBZ
5180	1253	26	been	be	VBN
5180	1253	27	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	1253	28	and	and	CC
5180	1253	29	selected	select	VBN
5180	1253	30	because	because	IN
5180	1253	31	the	the	DT
5180	1253	32	person	person	NN
5180	1253	33	reviewing	review	VBG
5180	1253	34	the	the	DT
5180	1253	35	book	book	NN
5180	1253	36	,	,	,
5180	1253	37	in	in	IN
5180	1253	38	the	the	DT
5180	1253	39	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	1253	40	of	of	IN
5180	1253	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1253	42	or	or	CC
5180	1253	43	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1253	44	professional	professional	JJ
5180	1253	45	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1253	46	,	,	,
5180	1253	47	has	have	VBZ
5180	1253	48	deemed	deem	VBN
5180	1253	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1253	50	content	content	NN
5180	1253	51	to	to	TO
5180	1253	52	be	be	VB
5180	1253	53	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	1253	54	valuable	valuable	JJ
5180	1253	55	.	.	.
5180	1254	1	In	in	IN
5180	1254	2	contrast	contrast	NN
5180	1254	3	,	,	,
5180	1254	4	when	when	WRB
5180	1254	5	a	a	DT
5180	1254	6	public	public	JJ
5180	1254	7	library	library	NN
5180	1254	8	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	1254	9	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1254	10	access	access	NN
5180	1254	11	,	,	,
5180	1254	12	even	even	RB
5180	1254	13	filtered	filter	VBN
5180	1254	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1254	15	access	access	NN
5180	1254	16	,	,	,
5180	1254	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1254	18	has	have	VBZ
5180	1254	19	created	create	VBN
5180	1254	20	a	a	DT
5180	1254	21	forum	forum	NN
5180	1254	22	open	open	JJ
5180	1254	23	to	to	IN
5180	1254	24	any	any	DT
5180	1254	25	member	member	NN
5180	1254	26	of	of	IN
5180	1254	27	the	the	DT
5180	1254	28	public	public	NN
5180	1254	29	who	who	WP
5180	1254	30	writes	write	VBZ
5180	1254	31	about	about	IN
5180	1254	32	chemistry	chemistry	NN
5180	1254	33	on	on	IN
5180	1254	34	the	the	DT
5180	1254	35	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1254	36	,	,	,
5180	1254	37	regardless	regardless	RB
5180	1254	38	of	of	IN
5180	1254	39	how	how	WRB
5180	1254	40	unscientific	unscientific	JJ
5180	1254	41	the	the	DT
5180	1254	42	author	author	NN
5180	1254	43	's	's	POS
5180	1254	44	methods	method	NNS
5180	1254	45	or	or	CC
5180	1254	46	of	of	IN
5180	1254	47	how	how	WRB
5180	1254	48	patently	patently	RB
5180	1254	49	false	false	JJ
5180	1254	50	the	the	DT
5180	1254	51	author	author	NN
5180	1254	52	's	's	POS
5180	1254	53	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
5180	1254	54	are	be	VBP
5180	1254	55	,	,	,
5180	1254	56	regardless	regardless	RB
5180	1254	57	of	of	IN
5180	1254	58	the	the	DT
5180	1254	59	author	author	NN
5180	1254	60	's	's	POS
5180	1254	61	reputation	reputation	NN
5180	1254	62	or	or	CC
5180	1254	63	grammar	grammar	NN
5180	1254	64	,	,	,
5180	1254	65	and	and	CC
5180	1254	66	regardless	regardless	RB
5180	1254	67	of	of	IN
5180	1254	68	the	the	DT
5180	1254	69	reviews	review	NNS
5180	1254	70	of	of	IN
5180	1254	71	the	the	DT
5180	1254	72	scientific	scientific	JJ
5180	1254	73	community	community	NN
5180	1254	74	.	.	.
5180	1255	1	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
5180	1255	2	protestations	protestation	NNS
5180	1255	3	in	in	IN
5180	1255	4	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1255	5	's	's	POS
5180	1255	6	legislative	legislative	JJ
5180	1255	7	history	history	NN
5180	1255	8	to	to	IN
5180	1255	9	the	the	DT
5180	1255	10	contrary	contrary	NN
5180	1255	11	,	,	,
5180	1255	12	members	member	NNS
5180	1255	13	of	of	IN
5180	1255	14	the	the	DT
5180	1255	15	general	general	JJ
5180	1255	16	public	public	NN
5180	1255	17	do	do	VBP
5180	1255	18	define	define	VB
5180	1255	19	the	the	DT
5180	1255	20	content	content	NN
5180	1255	21	that	that	IN
5180	1255	22	public	public	JJ
5180	1255	23	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1255	24	make	make	VBP
5180	1255	25	available	available	JJ
5180	1255	26	to	to	IN
5180	1255	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1255	28	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1255	29	through	through	IN
5180	1255	30	the	the	DT
5180	1255	31	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1255	32	.	.	.
5180	1256	1	Any	any	DT
5180	1256	2	member	member	NN
5180	1256	3	of	of	IN
5180	1256	4	the	the	DT
5180	1256	5	public	public	NN
5180	1256	6	with	with	IN
5180	1256	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1256	8	access	access	NN
5180	1256	9	could	could	MD
5180	1256	10	,	,	,
5180	1256	11	through	through	IN
5180	1256	12	the	the	DT
5180	1256	13	free	free	JJ
5180	1256	14	Web	web	NN
5180	1256	15	hosting	host	VBG
5180	1256	16	services	service	NNS
5180	1256	17	available	available	JJ
5180	1256	18	on	on	IN
5180	1256	19	the	the	DT
5180	1256	20	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1256	21	,	,	,
5180	1256	22	tonight	tonight	NN
5180	1256	23	jot	jot	NNP
5180	1256	24	down	down	RP
5180	1256	25	a	a	DT
5180	1256	26	few	few	JJ
5180	1256	27	musings	musing	NNS
5180	1256	28	on	on	IN
5180	1256	29	any	any	DT
5180	1256	30	subject	subject	NN
5180	1256	31	under	under	IN
5180	1256	32	the	the	DT
5180	1256	33	sun	sun	NN
5180	1256	34	,	,	,
5180	1256	35	and	and	CC
5180	1256	36	tomorrow	tomorrow	NN
5180	1256	37	those	those	DT
5180	1256	38	musings	musing	NNS
5180	1256	39	would	would	MD
5180	1256	40	become	become	VB
5180	1256	41	part	part	NN
5180	1256	42	of	of	IN
5180	1256	43	public	public	JJ
5180	1256	44	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1256	45	'	'	POS
5180	1256	46	online	online	JJ
5180	1256	47	offerings	offering	NNS
5180	1256	48	and	and	CC
5180	1256	49	be	be	VB
5180	1256	50	available	available	JJ
5180	1256	51	to	to	IN
5180	1256	52	any	any	DT
5180	1256	53	library	library	NN
5180	1256	54	patron	patron	NN
5180	1256	55	who	who	WP
5180	1256	56	seeks	seek	VBZ
5180	1256	57	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1256	58	out	out	RP
5180	1256	59	.	.	.
5180	1257	1	In	in	IN
5180	1257	2	providing	provide	VBG
5180	1257	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1257	4	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1257	5	with	with	IN
5180	1257	6	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1257	7	access	access	NN
5180	1257	8	,	,	,
5180	1257	9	a	a	DT
5180	1257	10	public	public	JJ
5180	1257	11	library	library	NN
5180	1257	12	creates	create	VBZ
5180	1257	13	a	a	DT
5180	1257	14	forum	forum	NN
5180	1257	15	for	for	IN
5180	1257	16	the	the	DT
5180	1257	17	facilitation	facilitation	NN
5180	1257	18	of	of	IN
5180	1257	19	speech	speech	NN
5180	1257	20	,	,	,
5180	1257	21	almost	almost	RB
5180	1257	22	none	none	NN
5180	1257	23	of	of	IN
5180	1257	24	which	which	WDT
5180	1257	25	either	either	CC
5180	1257	26	the	the	DT
5180	1257	27	library	library	NN
5180	1257	28	's	's	POS
5180	1257	29	collection	collection	NN
5180	1257	30	development	development	NN
5180	1257	31	staff	staff	NN
5180	1257	32	or	or	CC
5180	1257	33	even	even	RB
5180	1257	34	the	the	DT
5180	1257	35	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1257	36	companies	company	NNS
5180	1257	37	have	have	VBP
5180	1257	38	ever	ever	RB
5180	1257	39	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	1257	40	.	.	.
5180	1258	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1258	2	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1258	3	companies	company	NNS
5180	1258	4	review	review	VBP
5180	1258	5	a	a	DT
5180	1258	6	portion	portion	NN
5180	1258	7	of	of	IN
5180	1258	8	the	the	DT
5180	1258	9	Web	web	NN
5180	1258	10	in	in	IN
5180	1258	11	classifying	classify	VBG
5180	1258	12	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1258	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	1258	14	,	,	,
5180	1258	15	the	the	DT
5180	1258	16	portion	portion	NN
5180	1258	17	of	of	IN
5180	1258	18	the	the	DT
5180	1258	19	Web	web	NN
5180	1258	20	that	that	IN
5180	1258	21	the	the	DT
5180	1258	22	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1258	23	companies	company	NNS
5180	1258	24	actually	actually	RB
5180	1258	25	review	review	VBP
5180	1258	26	is	be	VBZ
5180	1258	27	quite	quite	RB
5180	1258	28	small	small	JJ
5180	1258	29	in	in	IN
5180	1258	30	relation	relation	NN
5180	1258	31	to	to	IN
5180	1258	32	the	the	DT
5180	1258	33	Web	web	NN
5180	1258	34	as	as	IN
5180	1258	35	a	a	DT
5180	1258	36	whole	whole	NN
5180	1258	37	.	.	.
5180	1259	1	The	the	DT
5180	1259	2	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1259	3	companies	company	NNS
5180	1259	4	'	'	POS
5180	1259	5	harvesting	harvesting	NN
5180	1259	6	process	process	NN
5180	1259	7	,	,	,
5180	1259	8	described	describe	VBN
5180	1259	9	in	in	IN
5180	1259	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1259	11	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1259	12	of	of	IN
5180	1259	13	fact	fact	NN
5180	1259	14	,	,	,
5180	1259	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	1259	16	intended	intend	VBN
5180	1259	17	to	to	TO
5180	1259	18	identify	identify	VB
5180	1259	19	only	only	RB
5180	1259	20	a	a	DT
5180	1259	21	small	small	JJ
5180	1259	22	fraction	fraction	NN
5180	1259	23	of	of	IN
5180	1259	24	Web	web	NN
5180	1259	25	sites	site	NNS
5180	1259	26	for	for	IN
5180	1259	27	the	the	DT
5180	1259	28	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1259	29	companies	company	NNS
5180	1259	30	to	to	TO
5180	1259	31	review	review	VB
5180	1259	32	.	.	.
5180	1260	1	Put	put	VB
5180	1260	2	simply	simply	RB
5180	1260	3	,	,	,
5180	1260	4	the	the	DT
5180	1260	5	state	state	NN
5180	1260	6	can	can	MD
5180	1260	7	not	not	RB
5180	1260	8	be	be	VB
5180	1260	9	said	say	VBN
5180	1260	10	to	to	TO
5180	1260	11	be	be	VB
5180	1260	12	exercising	exercise	VBG
5180	1260	13	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	1260	14	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1260	15	permitted	permit	VBN
5180	1260	16	under	under	IN
5180	1260	17	the	the	DT
5180	1260	18	First	First	NNP
5180	1260	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1260	20	when	when	WRB
5180	1260	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1260	22	indiscriminately	indiscriminately	RB
5180	1260	23	facilitates	facilitate	VBZ
5180	1260	24	private	private	JJ
5180	1260	25	speech	speech	NN
5180	1260	26	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1260	27	content	content	NN
5180	1260	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1260	29	makes	make	VBZ
5180	1260	30	no	no	DT
5180	1260	31	effort	effort	NN
5180	1260	32	to	to	TO
5180	1260	33	examine	examine	VB
5180	1260	34	.	.	.
5180	1261	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1261	2	.	.	.
5180	1262	1	Bell	Bell	NNP
5180	1262	2	,	,	,
5180	1262	3	supra	supra	NNP
5180	1262	4	,	,	,
5180	1262	5	at	at	IN
5180	1262	6	226	226	CD
5180	1262	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1262	8	"	"	``
5180	1262	9	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1262	10	C]ourts	C]ourts	NNP
5180	1262	11	should	should	MD
5180	1262	12	take	take	VB
5180	1262	13	a	a	DT
5180	1262	14	much	much	RB
5180	1262	15	more	more	RBR
5180	1262	16	jaundiced	jaundiced	JJ
5180	1262	17	view	view	NN
5180	1262	18	of	of	IN
5180	1262	19	library	library	JJ
5180	1262	20	policies	policy	NNS
5180	1262	21	that	that	WDT
5180	1262	22	block	block	VBP
5180	1262	23	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1262	24	access	access	NN
5180	1262	25	to	to	IN
5180	1262	26	a	a	DT
5180	1262	27	very	very	RB
5180	1262	28	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1262	29	array	array	NN
5180	1262	30	of	of	IN
5180	1262	31	subjects	subject	NNS
5180	1262	32	than	than	IN
5180	1262	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1262	34	take	take	VBP
5180	1262	35	of	of	IN
5180	1262	36	library	library	JJ
5180	1262	37	policies	policy	NNS
5180	1262	38	that	that	WDT
5180	1262	39	reserve	reserve	VBP
5180	1262	40	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1262	41	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1262	42	for	for	IN
5180	1262	43	very	very	RB
5180	1262	44	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1262	45	use	use	NN
5180	1262	46	.	.	.
5180	1262	47	"	"	''
5180	1262	48	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1262	49	.	.	.
5180	1263	1	While	while	IN
5180	1263	2	the	the	DT
5180	1263	3	First	First	NNP
5180	1263	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1263	5	permits	permit	VBZ
5180	1263	6	the	the	DT
5180	1263	7	government	government	NN
5180	1263	8	to	to	TO
5180	1263	9	exercise	exercise	VB
5180	1263	10	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	1263	11	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1263	12	in	in	IN
5180	1263	13	singling	single	VBG
5180	1263	14	out	out	RP
5180	1263	15	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	1263	16	favored	favor	VBN
5180	1263	17	speech	speech	NN
5180	1263	18	for	for	IN
5180	1263	19	subsidization	subsidization	NN
5180	1263	20	or	or	CC
5180	1263	21	inclusion	inclusion	NN
5180	1263	22	in	in	IN
5180	1263	23	a	a	DT
5180	1263	24	state	state	NN
5180	1263	25	-	-	HYPH
5180	1263	26	created	create	VBN
5180	1263	27	forum	forum	NN
5180	1263	28	,	,	,
5180	1263	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1263	30	believe	believe	VBP
5180	1263	31	that	that	IN
5180	1263	32	where	where	WRB
5180	1263	33	the	the	DT
5180	1263	34	state	state	NN
5180	1263	35	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	1263	36	access	access	NN
5180	1263	37	to	to	IN
5180	1263	38	a	a	DT
5180	1263	39	"	"	``
5180	1263	40	vast	vast	JJ
5180	1263	41	democratic	democratic	JJ
5180	1263	42	forum	forum	NN
5180	1263	43	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1263	44	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1263	45	,	,	,
5180	1263	46	"	"	``
5180	1263	47	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1263	48	,	,	,
5180	1263	49	521	521	CD
5180	1263	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1263	51	at	at	IN
5180	1263	52	868	868	CD
5180	1263	53	,	,	,
5180	1263	54	open	open	JJ
5180	1263	55	to	to	IN
5180	1263	56	any	any	DT
5180	1263	57	member	member	NN
5180	1263	58	of	of	IN
5180	1263	59	the	the	DT
5180	1263	60	public	public	NN
5180	1263	61	to	to	TO
5180	1263	62	speak	speak	VB
5180	1263	63	on	on	IN
5180	1263	64	subjects	subject	NNS
5180	1263	65	"	"	''
5180	1263	66	as	as	RB
5180	1263	67	diverse	diverse	JJ
5180	1263	68	as	as	IN
5180	1263	69	human	human	JJ
5180	1263	70	thought	thought	NN
5180	1263	71	,	,	,
5180	1263	72	"	"	''
5180	1263	73	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1263	74	d	d	VBN
5180	1263	75	.	.	.
5180	1264	1	at	at	IN
5180	1264	2	870	870	CD
5180	1264	3	,	,	,
5180	1264	4	and	and	CC
5180	1264	5	then	then	RB
5180	1264	6	selectively	selectively	RB
5180	1264	7	excludes	exclude	VBZ
5180	1264	8	from	from	IN
5180	1264	9	the	the	DT
5180	1264	10	forum	forum	NN
5180	1264	11	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1264	12	speech	speech	NN
5180	1264	13	on	on	IN
5180	1264	14	the	the	DT
5180	1264	15	basis	basis	NN
5180	1264	16	of	of	IN
5180	1264	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1264	18	content	content	NN
5180	1264	19	,	,	,
5180	1264	20	such	such	JJ
5180	1264	21	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
5180	1264	22	are	be	VBP
5180	1264	23	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1264	24	to	to	IN
5180	1264	25	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1264	26	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1264	27	.	.	.
5180	1265	1	These	these	DT
5180	1265	2	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
5180	1265	3	risk	risk	NN
5180	1265	4	fundamentally	fundamentally	RB
5180	1265	5	distorting	distort	VBG
5180	1265	6	the	the	DT
5180	1265	7	unique	unique	JJ
5180	1265	8	marketplace	marketplace	NN
5180	1265	9	of	of	IN
5180	1265	10	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	1265	11	that	that	WDT
5180	1265	12	public	public	JJ
5180	1265	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1265	14	create	create	VBP
5180	1265	15	when	when	WRB
5180	1265	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1265	17	open	open	VBP
5180	1265	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1265	19	collections	collection	NNS
5180	1265	20	,	,	,
5180	1265	21	via	via	IN
5180	1265	22	the	the	DT
5180	1265	23	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1265	24	,	,	,
5180	1265	25	to	to	IN
5180	1265	26	the	the	DT
5180	1265	27	speech	speech	NN
5180	1265	28	of	of	IN
5180	1265	29	millions	million	NNS
5180	1265	30	of	of	IN
5180	1265	31	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	1265	32	around	around	IN
5180	1265	33	the	the	DT
5180	1265	34	world	world	NN
5180	1265	35	on	on	IN
5180	1265	36	a	a	DT
5180	1265	37	virtually	virtually	RB
5180	1265	38	limitless	limitless	JJ
5180	1265	39	number	number	NN
5180	1265	40	of	of	IN
5180	1265	41	subjects	subject	NNS
5180	1265	42	.	.	.
5180	1266	1	A	a	DT
5180	1266	2	public	public	JJ
5180	1266	3	library	library	NN
5180	1266	4	's	's	POS
5180	1266	5	content	content	NN
5180	1266	6	-	-	HYPH
5180	1266	7	based	base	VBN
5180	1266	8	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1266	9	on	on	IN
5180	1266	10	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1266	11	'	'	POS
5180	1266	12	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1266	13	access	access	NN
5180	1266	14	thus	thus	RB
5180	1266	15	resemble	resemble	VBP
5180	1266	16	the	the	DT
5180	1266	17	content	content	NN
5180	1266	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	1266	19	based	base	VBN
5180	1266	20	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1266	21	on	on	IN
5180	1266	22	speech	speech	NN
5180	1266	23	subsidized	subsidize	VBN
5180	1266	24	by	by	IN
5180	1266	25	the	the	DT
5180	1266	26	government	government	NN
5180	1266	27	,	,	,
5180	1266	28	whether	whether	IN
5180	1266	29	through	through	IN
5180	1266	30	direct	direct	JJ
5180	1266	31	funding	funding	NN
5180	1266	32	or	or	CC
5180	1266	33	through	through	IN
5180	1266	34	the	the	DT
5180	1266	35	creation	creation	NN
5180	1266	36	of	of	IN
5180	1266	37	a	a	DT
5180	1266	38	designated	designate	VBN
5180	1266	39	public	public	JJ
5180	1266	40	forum	forum	NN
5180	1266	41	,	,	,
5180	1266	42	that	that	IN
5180	1266	43	the	the	DT
5180	1266	44	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1266	45	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1266	46	has	have	VBZ
5180	1266	47	subjected	subject	VBN
5180	1266	48	to	to	IN
5180	1266	49	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1266	50	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1266	51	,	,	,
5180	1266	52	as	as	IN
5180	1266	53	discussed	discuss	VBN
5180	1266	54	above	above	RB
5180	1266	55	in	in	IN
5180	1266	56	Section	section	NN
5180	1266	57	IV.C.	iv.c.	NN
5180	1267	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1267	2	the	the	DT
5180	1267	3	government	government	NN
5180	1267	4	may	may	MD
5180	1267	5	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	1267	6	a	a	DT
5180	1267	7	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1267	8	message	message	NN
5180	1267	9	representing	represent	VBG
5180	1267	10	the	the	DT
5180	1267	11	government	government	NN
5180	1267	12	's	's	POS
5180	1267	13	viewpoint	viewpoint	NN
5180	1267	14	without	without	IN
5180	1267	15	having	have	VBG
5180	1267	16	to	to	TO
5180	1267	17	satisfy	satisfy	VB
5180	1267	18	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1267	19	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1267	20	,	,	,
5180	1267	21	see	see	VB
5180	1267	22	Rust	Rust	NNP
5180	1267	23	v.	v.	IN
5180	1267	24	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
5180	1267	25	,	,	,
5180	1267	26	500	500	CD
5180	1267	27	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1267	28	173	173	CD
5180	1267	29	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1267	30	1991	1991	CD
5180	1267	31	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1267	32	,	,	,
5180	1267	33	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1267	34	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1267	35	applies	apply	VBZ
5180	1267	36	to	to	IN
5180	1267	37	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1267	38	that	that	WDT
5180	1267	39	selectively	selectively	RB
5180	1267	40	exclude	exclude	VBP
5180	1267	41	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1267	42	viewpoints	viewpoint	NNS
5180	1267	43	from	from	IN
5180	1267	44	a	a	DT
5180	1267	45	public	public	JJ
5180	1267	46	forum	forum	NN
5180	1267	47	designed	design	VBN
5180	1267	48	to	to	TO
5180	1267	49	facilitate	facilitate	VB
5180	1267	50	a	a	DT
5180	1267	51	wide	wide	JJ
5180	1267	52	range	range	NN
5180	1267	53	of	of	IN
5180	1267	54	viewpoints	viewpoint	NNS
5180	1267	55	,	,	,
5180	1267	56	see	see	VB
5180	1267	57	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
5180	1267	58	v.	v.	IN
5180	1267	59	Rector	Rector	NNP
5180	1267	60	&	&	CC
5180	1267	61	Visitors	Visitors	NNPS
5180	1267	62	of	of	IN
5180	1267	63	Univ	Univ	NNP
5180	1267	64	.	.	.
5180	1268	1	of	of	IN
5180	1268	2	Va.	Virginia	NNP
5180	1268	3	,	,	,
5180	1268	4	515	515	CD
5180	1268	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1268	6	819	819	CD
5180	1268	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1268	8	1995	1995	CD
5180	1268	9	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1268	10	.	.	.
5180	1269	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1269	2	,	,	,
5180	1269	3	although	although	IN
5180	1269	4	the	the	DT
5180	1269	5	state	state	NN
5180	1269	6	's	's	POS
5180	1269	7	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	1269	8	of	of	IN
5180	1269	9	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	1269	10	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1269	11	in	in	IN
5180	1269	12	selecting	select	VBG
5180	1269	13	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1269	14	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1269	15	for	for	IN
5180	1269	16	participation	participation	NN
5180	1269	17	in	in	IN
5180	1269	18	a	a	DT
5180	1269	19	state	state	NN
5180	1269	20	-	-	HYPH
5180	1269	21	sponsored	sponsor	VBN
5180	1269	22	forum	forum	NN
5180	1269	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	1269	24	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1269	25	to	to	IN
5180	1269	26	rational	rational	JJ
5180	1269	27	basis	basis	NN
5180	1269	28	review	review	NN
5180	1269	29	,	,	,
5180	1269	30	see	see	VB
5180	1269	31	Ark.	Arkansas	NNP
5180	1270	1	Educ	Educ	NNS
5180	1270	2	.	.	.
5180	1271	1	Television	television	NN
5180	1271	2	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
5180	1271	3	v.	v.	CC
5180	1271	4	Forbes	Forbes	NNP
5180	1271	5	,	,	,
5180	1271	6	523	523	CD
5180	1271	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1271	8	666	666	CD
5180	1271	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1271	10	1998	1998	CD
5180	1271	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1271	12	,	,	,
5180	1271	13	selective	selective	JJ
5180	1271	14	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
5180	1271	15	of	of	IN
5180	1271	16	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1271	17	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1271	18	from	from	IN
5180	1271	19	a	a	DT
5180	1271	20	forum	forum	NN
5180	1271	21	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1271	22	open	open	JJ
5180	1271	23	to	to	IN
5180	1271	24	any	any	DT
5180	1271	25	member	member	NN
5180	1271	26	of	of	IN
5180	1271	27	the	the	DT
5180	1271	28	public	public	NN
5180	1271	29	to	to	TO
5180	1271	30	speak	speak	VB
5180	1271	31	are	be	VBP
5180	1271	32	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1271	33	to	to	IN
5180	1271	34	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1271	35	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1271	36	,	,	,
5180	1271	37	see	see	VB
5180	1271	38	City	City	NNP
5180	1271	39	of	of	IN
5180	1271	40	Madison	Madison	NNP
5180	1271	41	Joint	Joint	NNP
5180	1271	42	School	School	NNP
5180	1271	43	Dist	Dist	NNP
5180	1271	44	.	.	.
5180	1272	1	No	no	UH
5180	1272	2	.	.	.
5180	1273	1	8	8	CD
5180	1273	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	1273	3	Wis.	Wisconsin	NNP
5180	1273	4	Employment	Employment	NNP
5180	1273	5	Relations	Relations	NNPS
5180	1273	6	Comm'n	Comm'n	NNP
5180	1273	7	,	,	,
5180	1273	8	429	429	CD
5180	1273	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1273	10	167	167	CD
5180	1273	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1273	12	1976	1976	CD
5180	1273	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1273	14	.	.	.
5180	1274	1	And	and	CC
5180	1274	2	while	while	IN
5180	1274	3	the	the	DT
5180	1274	4	government	government	NN
5180	1274	5	may	may	MD
5180	1274	6	,	,	,
5180	1274	7	subject	subject	VB
5180	1274	8	only	only	RB
5180	1274	9	to	to	IN
5180	1274	10	rational	rational	JJ
5180	1274	11	basis	basis	NN
5180	1274	12	review	review	NN
5180	1274	13	,	,	,
5180	1274	14	make	make	VBP
5180	1274	15	content	content	NN
5180	1274	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	1274	17	based	base	VBN
5180	1274	18	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1274	19	in	in	IN
5180	1274	20	selecting	select	VBG
5180	1274	21	works	work	NNS
5180	1274	22	of	of	IN
5180	1274	23	artistic	artistic	JJ
5180	1274	24	excellence	excellence	NN
5180	1274	25	to	to	TO
5180	1274	26	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	1274	27	,	,	,
5180	1274	28	see	see	VB
5180	1274	29	NEA	NEA	NNP
5180	1274	30	v.	v.	IN
5180	1274	31	Finley	Finley	NNP
5180	1274	32	,	,	,
5180	1274	33	524	524	CD
5180	1274	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1274	35	569	569	CD
5180	1274	36	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1274	37	1998	1998	CD
5180	1274	38	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1274	39	,	,	,
5180	1274	40	the	the	DT
5180	1274	41	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1274	42	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1274	43	has	have	VBZ
5180	1274	44	applied	apply	VBN
5180	1274	45	heightened	heightened	JJ
5180	1274	46	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1274	47	where	where	WRB
5180	1274	48	the	the	DT
5180	1274	49	government	government	NN
5180	1274	50	opens	open	VBZ
5180	1274	51	a	a	DT
5180	1274	52	general	general	JJ
5180	1274	53	-	-	HYPH
5180	1274	54	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1274	55	municipal	municipal	JJ
5180	1274	56	theater	theater	NN
5180	1274	57	for	for	IN
5180	1274	58	use	use	NN
5180	1274	59	by	by	IN
5180	1274	60	the	the	DT
5180	1274	61	public	public	NN
5180	1274	62	,	,	,
5180	1274	63	but	but	CC
5180	1274	64	selectively	selectively	RB
5180	1274	65	excludes	exclude	VBZ
5180	1274	66	disfavored	disfavor	VBN
5180	1274	67	content	content	NN
5180	1274	68	,	,	,
5180	1274	69	see	see	VB
5180	1274	70	Southeastern	Southeastern	NNP
5180	1274	71	Promotions	Promotions	NNP
5180	1274	72	,	,	,
5180	1274	73	Ltd.	Ltd.	NNP
5180	1274	74	v.	v.	IN
5180	1274	75	Conrad	Conrad	NNP
5180	1274	76	,	,	,
5180	1274	77	420	420	CD
5180	1274	78	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1274	79	546	546	CD
5180	1274	80	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1274	81	1975	1975	CD
5180	1274	82	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1274	83	,	,	,
5180	1274	84	where	where	WRB
5180	1274	85	the	the	DT
5180	1274	86	government	government	NN
5180	1274	87	facilitates	facilitate	VBZ
5180	1274	88	the	the	DT
5180	1274	89	speech	speech	NN
5180	1274	90	of	of	IN
5180	1274	91	public	public	JJ
5180	1274	92	broadcasters	broadcaster	NNS
5180	1274	93	on	on	IN
5180	1274	94	a	a	DT
5180	1274	95	virtually	virtually	RB
5180	1274	96	limitless	limitless	JJ
5180	1274	97	number	number	NN
5180	1274	98	of	of	IN
5180	1274	99	topics	topic	NNS
5180	1274	100	,	,	,
5180	1274	101	but	but	CC
5180	1274	102	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
5180	1274	103	editorializing	editorialize	VBG
5180	1274	104	,	,	,
5180	1274	105	see	see	VB
5180	1274	106	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	1274	107	v.	v.	IN
5180	1274	108	League	League	NNP
5180	1274	109	of	of	IN
5180	1274	110	Women	Women	NNP
5180	1274	111	Voters	Voters	NNPS
5180	1274	112	of	of	IN
5180	1274	113	Cal	Cal	NNP
5180	1274	114	.	.	NNP
5180	1274	115	,	,	,
5180	1274	116	468	468	CD
5180	1274	117	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1274	118	364	364	CD
5180	1274	119	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1274	120	1984	1984	CD
5180	1274	121	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1274	122	,	,	,
5180	1274	123	and	and	CC
5180	1274	124	where	where	WRB
5180	1274	125	the	the	DT
5180	1274	126	government	government	NN
5180	1274	127	funds	fund	VBZ
5180	1274	128	a	a	DT
5180	1274	129	wide	wide	JJ
5180	1274	130	range	range	NN
5180	1274	131	of	of	IN
5180	1274	132	legal	legal	JJ
5180	1274	133	services	service	NNS
5180	1274	134	but	but	CC
5180	1274	135	restricts	restrict	NNS
5180	1274	136	funding	funding	NN
5180	1274	137	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	1274	138	from	from	IN
5180	1274	139	challenging	challenge	VBG
5180	1274	140	welfare	welfare	NN
5180	1274	141	laws	law	NNS
5180	1274	142	,	,	,
5180	1274	143	see	see	VB
5180	1274	144	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	1274	145	Servs	Servs	NNP
5180	1274	146	.	.	.
5180	1275	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
5180	1275	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1275	3	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	1275	4	,	,	,
5180	1275	5	531	531	CD
5180	1275	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1275	7	533	533	CD
5180	1275	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1275	9	2001	2001	CD
5180	1275	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1275	11	.	.	.
5180	1276	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1276	2	,	,	,
5180	1276	3	where	where	WRB
5180	1276	4	a	a	DT
5180	1276	5	public	public	JJ
5180	1276	6	library	library	NN
5180	1276	7	opens	open	VBZ
5180	1276	8	a	a	DT
5180	1276	9	forum	forum	NN
5180	1276	10	to	to	IN
5180	1276	11	an	an	DT
5180	1276	12	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	1276	13	number	number	NN
5180	1276	14	of	of	IN
5180	1276	15	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1276	16	around	around	IN
5180	1276	17	the	the	DT
5180	1276	18	world	world	NN
5180	1276	19	to	to	TO
5180	1276	20	speak	speak	VB
5180	1276	21	on	on	IN
5180	1276	22	an	an	DT
5180	1276	23	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	1276	24	number	number	NN
5180	1276	25	of	of	IN
5180	1276	26	topics	topic	NNS
5180	1276	27	,	,	,
5180	1276	28	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1276	29	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1276	30	applies	apply	VBZ
5180	1276	31	to	to	IN
5180	1276	32	the	the	DT
5180	1276	33	library	library	NN
5180	1276	34	's	's	POS
5180	1276	35	selective	selective	JJ
5180	1276	36	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
5180	1276	37	of	of	IN
5180	1276	38	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1276	39	speech	speech	NN
5180	1276	40	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1276	41	content	content	NN
5180	1276	42	the	the	DT
5180	1276	43	library	library	NN
5180	1276	44	disfavors	disfavor	NNS
5180	1276	45	.	.	.
5180	1277	1	2	2	LS
5180	1277	2	.	.	.
5180	1278	1	Analogy	analogy	NN
5180	1278	2	to	to	IN
5180	1278	3	Traditional	Traditional	NNP
5180	1278	4	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1278	5	Fora	Fora	NNP
5180	1278	6	Application	Application	NNP
5180	1278	7	of	of	IN
5180	1278	8	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1278	9	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1278	10	to	to	IN
5180	1278	11	public	public	JJ
5180	1278	12	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1278	13	'	'	POS
5180	1278	14	use	use	NN
5180	1278	15	of	of	IN
5180	1278	16	software	software	NN
5180	1278	17	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1278	18	,	,	,
5180	1278	19	in	in	IN
5180	1278	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1278	21	view	view	NN
5180	1278	22	,	,	,
5180	1278	23	finds	find	VBZ
5180	1278	24	further	further	JJ
5180	1278	25	support	support	NN
5180	1278	26	in	in	IN
5180	1278	27	the	the	DT
5180	1278	28	extent	extent	NN
5180	1278	29	to	to	TO
5180	1278	30	which	which	WDT
5180	1278	31	public	public	JJ
5180	1278	32	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1278	33	'	'	POS
5180	1278	34	provision	provision	NN
5180	1278	35	of	of	IN
5180	1278	36	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1278	37	access	access	NN
5180	1278	38	promotes	promote	VBZ
5180	1278	39	First	First	NNP
5180	1278	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1278	41	values	value	NNS
5180	1278	42	in	in	IN
5180	1278	43	an	an	DT
5180	1278	44	analogous	analogous	JJ
5180	1278	45	manner	manner	NN
5180	1278	46	to	to	IN
5180	1278	47	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1278	48	public	public	JJ
5180	1278	49	fora	fora	NN
5180	1278	50	,	,	,
5180	1278	51	such	such	JJ
5180	1278	52	as	as	IN
5180	1278	53	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1278	54	and	and	CC
5180	1278	55	parks	park	NNS
5180	1278	56	,	,	,
5180	1278	57	in	in	IN
5180	1278	58	which	which	WDT
5180	1278	59	content	content	NN
5180	1278	60	-	-	HYPH
5180	1278	61	based	base	VBN
5180	1278	62	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1278	63	on	on	IN
5180	1278	64	speech	speech	NN
5180	1278	65	are	be	VBP
5180	1278	66	always	always	RB
5180	1278	67	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1278	68	to	to	IN
5180	1278	69	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1278	70	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1278	71	.	.	.
5180	1279	1	The	the	DT
5180	1279	2	public	public	JJ
5180	1279	3	library	library	NN
5180	1279	4	,	,	,
5180	1279	5	by	by	IN
5180	1279	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1279	7	very	very	JJ
5180	1279	8	nature	nature	NN
5180	1279	9	,	,	,
5180	1279	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	1279	11	"	"	``
5180	1279	12	designed	design	VBN
5180	1279	13	for	for	IN
5180	1279	14	freewheeling	freewheel	VBG
5180	1279	15	inquiry	inquiry	NN
5180	1279	16	.	.	.
5180	1279	17	"	"	''
5180	1280	1	Bd	Bd	NNP
5180	1280	2	.	.	.
5180	1281	1	of	of	IN
5180	1281	2	Education	Education	NNP
5180	1281	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1281	4	Pico	Pico	NNP
5180	1281	5	,	,	,
5180	1281	6	457	457	CD
5180	1281	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1281	8	853	853	CD
5180	1281	9	,	,	,
5180	1281	10	915	915	CD
5180	1281	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1281	12	1982	1982	CD
5180	1281	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1281	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1281	15	Rehnquist	Rehnquist	NNP
5180	1281	16	,	,	,
5180	1281	17	J.	J.	NNP
5180	1281	18	,	,	,
5180	1281	19	dissenting	dissent	VBG
5180	1281	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1281	21	.	.	.
5180	1282	1	As	as	IN
5180	1282	2	such	such	JJ
5180	1282	3	,	,	,
5180	1282	4	the	the	DT
5180	1282	5	library	library	NN
5180	1282	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	1282	7	a	a	DT
5180	1282	8	"	"	``
5180	1282	9	mighty	mighty	JJ
5180	1282	10	resource	resource	NN
5180	1282	11	in	in	IN
5180	1282	12	the	the	DT
5180	1282	13	free	free	JJ
5180	1282	14	marketplace	marketplace	NN
5180	1282	15	of	of	IN
5180	1282	16	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	1282	17	,	,	,
5180	1282	18	"	"	''
5180	1282	19	Minarcini	Minarcini	NNP
5180	1282	20	v.	v.	IN
5180	1282	21	Strongsville	Strongsville	NNP
5180	1282	22	City	City	NNP
5180	1282	23	Sch	Sch	NNP
5180	1282	24	.	.	.
5180	1283	1	Dist	Dist	NNP
5180	1283	2	.	.	.
5180	1283	3	,	,	,
5180	1283	4	541	541	CD
5180	1283	5	F.2d	F.2d	NNP
5180	1283	6	577	577	CD
5180	1283	7	,	,	,
5180	1283	8	582	582	CD
5180	1283	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1283	10	6th	6th	JJ
5180	1283	11	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	1283	12	.	.	.
5180	1284	1	1976	1976	CD
5180	1284	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1284	3	,	,	,
5180	1284	4	and	and	CC
5180	1284	5	represents	represent	VBZ
5180	1284	6	a	a	DT
5180	1284	7	"	"	``
5180	1284	8	quintessential	quintessential	JJ
5180	1284	9	locus	locus	NN
5180	1284	10	of	of	IN
5180	1284	11	the	the	DT
5180	1284	12	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	1284	13	of	of	IN
5180	1284	14	information	information	NN
5180	1284	15	.	.	.
5180	1284	16	"	"	''
5180	1285	1	Kreimer	Kreimer	NNP
5180	1285	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1285	3	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
5180	1285	4	of	of	IN
5180	1285	5	Police	Police	NNP
5180	1285	6	for	for	IN
5180	1285	7	Morristown	Morristown	NNP
5180	1285	8	,	,	,
5180	1285	9	958	958	CD
5180	1285	10	F.2d	F.2d	NNP
5180	1285	11	1242	1242	CD
5180	1285	12	,	,	,
5180	1285	13	1255	1255	CD
5180	1285	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1285	15	3d	3d	NNP
5180	1285	16	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	1285	17	.	.	.
5180	1286	1	1992	1992	CD
5180	1286	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1286	3	;	;	:
5180	1286	4	see	see	VB
5180	1286	5	also	also	RB
5180	1286	6	Sund	Sund	NNP
5180	1286	7	v.	v.	IN
5180	1286	8	City	City	NNP
5180	1286	9	of	of	IN
5180	1286	10	Wichita	Wichita	NNP
5180	1286	11	Falls	Falls	NNP
5180	1286	12	,	,	,
5180	1286	13	121	121	CD
5180	1286	14	F.	F.	NNP
5180	1286	15	Supp	Supp	NNP
5180	1286	16	.	.	.
5180	1287	1	2d	2d	CD
5180	1287	2	530	530	CD
5180	1287	3	,	,	,
5180	1287	4	547	547	CD
5180	1287	5	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1287	6	N.D.	North Dakota	NNP
5180	1287	7	Tex	Tex	NNP
5180	1287	8	.	.	.
5180	1288	1	2000	2000	CD
5180	1288	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1288	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1288	4	"	"	``
5180	1288	5	The	the	DT
5180	1288	6	right	right	NN
5180	1288	7	to	to	TO
5180	1288	8	receive	receive	VB
5180	1288	9	information	information	NN
5180	1288	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	1288	11	vigorously	vigorously	RB
5180	1288	12	enforced	enforce	VBN
5180	1288	13	in	in	IN
5180	1288	14	the	the	DT
5180	1288	15	context	context	NN
5180	1288	16	of	of	IN
5180	1288	17	a	a	DT
5180	1288	18	public	public	JJ
5180	1288	19	library	library	NN
5180	1288	20	.	.	.
5180	1289	1	.	.	.
5180	1290	1	.	.	.
5180	1291	1	.	.	.
5180	1292	1	")	")	``
5180	1292	2	;	;	:
5180	1292	3	cf	cf	NN
5180	1292	4	.	.	.
5180	1293	1	Int'l	Int'l	NNPS
5180	1293	2	Soc'y	Soc'y	NNP
5180	1293	3	for	for	IN
5180	1293	4	Krishna	Krishna	NNP
5180	1293	5	Consciousness	Consciousness	NNP
5180	1293	6	,	,	,
5180	1293	7	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1293	8	v.	v.	IN
5180	1293	9	Lee	Lee	NNP
5180	1293	10	,	,	,
5180	1293	11	505	505	CD
5180	1293	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1293	13	672	672	CD
5180	1293	14	,	,	,
5180	1293	15	681	681	CD
5180	1293	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1293	17	1992	1992	CD
5180	1293	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1293	19	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1293	20	"	"	``
5180	1293	21	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1293	22	A	a	NN
5180	1293	23	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1293	24	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1293	25	public	public	JJ
5180	1293	26	forum	forum	NN
5180	1293	27	is	be	VBZ
5180	1293	28	property	property	NN
5180	1293	29	that	that	WDT
5180	1293	30	has	have	VBZ
5180	1293	31	as	as	IN
5180	1293	32	'	'	''
5180	1293	33	a	a	DT
5180	1293	34	principal	principal	JJ
5180	1293	35	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1293	36	.	.	.
5180	1294	1	.	.	.
5180	1295	1	.	.	.
5180	1296	1	the	the	DT
5180	1296	2	free	free	JJ
5180	1296	3	exchange	exchange	NNP
5180	1296	4	of	of	IN
5180	1296	5	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	1296	6	.	.	.
5180	1296	7	'	'	''
5180	1296	8	"	"	''
5180	1296	9	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1297	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1297	2	quoting	quote	VBG
5180	1297	3	Cornelius	Cornelius	NNP
5180	1297	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	1297	5	NAACP	NAACP	NNP
5180	1297	6	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	1297	7	Def	Def	NNP
5180	1297	8	.	.	.
5180	1298	1	&	&	CC
5180	1298	2	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	1298	3	.	.	.
5180	1299	1	Fund	Fund	NNP
5180	1299	2	,	,	,
5180	1299	3	473	473	CD
5180	1299	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1299	5	788	788	CD
5180	1299	6	,	,	,
5180	1299	7	800	800	CD
5180	1299	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1299	9	1985	1985	CD
5180	1299	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1299	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1299	12	.	.	.
5180	1300	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1300	2	acknowledge	acknowledge	VBP
5180	1300	3	that	that	IN
5180	1300	4	the	the	DT
5180	1300	5	provision	provision	NN
5180	1300	6	of	of	IN
5180	1300	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1300	8	access	access	NN
5180	1300	9	in	in	IN
5180	1300	10	a	a	DT
5180	1300	11	public	public	JJ
5180	1300	12	library	library	NN
5180	1300	13	does	do	VBZ
5180	1300	14	not	not	RB
5180	1300	15	enjoy	enjoy	VB
5180	1300	16	the	the	DT
5180	1300	17	historical	historical	JJ
5180	1300	18	pedigree	pedigree	NN
5180	1300	19	of	of	IN
5180	1300	20	streets	street	NNS
5180	1300	21	,	,	,
5180	1300	22	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1300	23	,	,	,
5180	1300	24	and	and	CC
5180	1300	25	parks	park	NNS
5180	1300	26	as	as	IN
5180	1300	27	a	a	DT
5180	1300	28	vehicle	vehicle	NN
5180	1300	29	of	of	IN
5180	1300	30	free	free	JJ
5180	1300	31	expression	expression	NN
5180	1300	32	.	.	.
5180	1301	1	Nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	1301	2	,	,	,
5180	1301	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1301	4	believe	believe	VBP
5180	1301	5	that	that	IN
5180	1301	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1301	7	shares	share	VBZ
5180	1301	8	many	many	JJ
5180	1301	9	of	of	IN
5180	1301	10	the	the	DT
5180	1301	11	characteristics	characteristic	NNS
5180	1301	12	of	of	IN
5180	1301	13	these	these	DT
5180	1301	14	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1301	15	public	public	JJ
5180	1301	16	fora	fora	NN
5180	1301	17	that	that	WDT
5180	1301	18	uniquely	uniquely	RB
5180	1301	19	promote	promote	VB
5180	1301	20	First	First	NNP
5180	1301	21	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1301	22	values	value	NNS
5180	1301	23	and	and	CC
5180	1301	24	accordingly	accordingly	RB
5180	1301	25	warrant	warrant	VBP
5180	1301	26	application	application	NN
5180	1301	27	of	of	IN
5180	1301	28	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1301	29	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1301	30	to	to	IN
5180	1301	31	any	any	DT
5180	1301	32	content	content	NN
5180	1301	33	-	-	HYPH
5180	1301	34	based	base	VBN
5180	1301	35	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1301	36	on	on	IN
5180	1301	37	speech	speech	NN
5180	1301	38	in	in	IN
5180	1301	39	these	these	DT
5180	1301	40	fora	fora	NNP
5180	1301	41	.	.	.
5180	1302	1	Regulation	regulation	NN
5180	1302	2	of	of	IN
5180	1302	3	speech	speech	NN
5180	1302	4	in	in	IN
5180	1302	5	streets	street	NNS
5180	1302	6	,	,	,
5180	1302	7	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1302	8	,	,	,
5180	1302	9	and	and	CC
5180	1302	10	parks	park	NNS
5180	1302	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	1302	12	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1302	13	to	to	IN
5180	1302	14	the	the	DT
5180	1302	15	highest	high	JJS
5180	1302	16	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1302	17	not	not	RB
5180	1302	18	simply	simply	RB
5180	1302	19	by	by	IN
5180	1302	20	virtue	virtue	NN
5180	1302	21	of	of	IN
5180	1302	22	history	history	NN
5180	1302	23	and	and	CC
5180	1302	24	tradition	tradition	NN
5180	1302	25	,	,	,
5180	1302	26	but	but	CC
5180	1302	27	also	also	RB
5180	1302	28	because	because	IN
5180	1302	29	the	the	DT
5180	1302	30	speech	speech	NN
5180	1302	31	-	-	HYPH
5180	1302	32	facilitating	facilitate	VBG
5180	1302	33	character	character	NN
5180	1302	34	of	of	IN
5180	1302	35	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1302	36	and	and	CC
5180	1302	37	parks	park	NNS
5180	1302	38	makes	make	VBZ
5180	1302	39	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1302	40	distinctly	distinctly	RB
5180	1302	41	deserving	deserve	VBG
5180	1302	42	of	of	IN
5180	1302	43	First	First	NNP
5180	1302	44	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1302	45	protection	protection	NN
5180	1302	46	.	.	.
5180	1303	1	Many	many	JJ
5180	1303	2	of	of	IN
5180	1303	3	these	these	DT
5180	1303	4	same	same	JJ
5180	1303	5	speech	speech	NN
5180	1303	6	-	-	HYPH
5180	1303	7	promoting	promote	VBG
5180	1303	8	features	feature	NNS
5180	1303	9	of	of	IN
5180	1303	10	the	the	DT
5180	1303	11	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1303	12	public	public	NNP
5180	1303	13	forum	forum	NN
5180	1303	14	appear	appear	VBP
5180	1303	15	in	in	IN
5180	1303	16	public	public	JJ
5180	1303	17	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1303	18	'	'	POS
5180	1303	19	provision	provision	NN
5180	1303	20	of	of	IN
5180	1303	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1303	22	access	access	NN
5180	1303	23	.	.	.
5180	1304	1	First	first	JJ
5180	1304	2	,	,	,
5180	1304	3	public	public	JJ
5180	1304	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1304	5	,	,	,
5180	1304	6	like	like	IN
5180	1304	7	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1304	8	and	and	CC
5180	1304	9	parks	park	NNS
5180	1304	10	,	,	,
5180	1304	11	are	be	VBP
5180	1304	12	generally	generally	RB
5180	1304	13	open	open	JJ
5180	1304	14	to	to	IN
5180	1304	15	any	any	DT
5180	1304	16	member	member	NN
5180	1304	17	of	of	IN
5180	1304	18	the	the	DT
5180	1304	19	public	public	NN
5180	1304	20	who	who	WP
5180	1304	21	wishes	wish	VBZ
5180	1304	22	to	to	TO
5180	1304	23	receive	receive	VB
5180	1304	24	the	the	DT
5180	1304	25	speech	speech	NN
5180	1304	26	that	that	WDT
5180	1304	27	these	these	DT
5180	1304	28	fora	fora	NNP
5180	1304	29	facilitate	facilitate	NN
5180	1304	30	,	,	,
5180	1304	31	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1304	32	only	only	RB
5180	1304	33	to	to	IN
5180	1304	34	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1304	35	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	1304	36	.	.	.
5180	1305	1	See	see	VB
5180	1305	2	Kreimer	Kreimer	NNP
5180	1305	3	,	,	,
5180	1305	4	958	958	CD
5180	1305	5	F.2d	F.2d	NNS
5180	1305	6	at	at	IN
5180	1305	7	1260	1260	CD
5180	1305	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1305	9	noting	note	VBG
5180	1305	10	that	that	IN
5180	1305	11	a	a	DT
5180	1305	12	public	public	JJ
5180	1305	13	library	library	NN
5180	1305	14	does	do	VBZ
5180	1305	15	not	not	RB
5180	1305	16	retain	retain	VB
5180	1305	17	unfettered	unfettered	JJ
5180	1305	18	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1305	19	"	"	''
5180	1305	20	to	to	TO
5180	1305	21	choose	choose	VB
5180	1305	22	whom	whom	WP
5180	1305	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1305	24	will	will	MD
5180	1305	25	permit	permit	VB
5180	1305	26	to	to	TO
5180	1305	27	enter	enter	VB
5180	1305	28	the	the	DT
5180	1305	29	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1305	30	,	,	,
5180	1305	31	"	"	''
5180	1305	32	but	but	CC
5180	1305	33	upholding	uphold	VBG
5180	1305	34	the	the	DT
5180	1305	35	library	library	NN
5180	1305	36	's	's	POS
5180	1305	37	right	right	NN
5180	1305	38	to	to	TO
5180	1305	39	exclude	exclude	VB
5180	1305	40	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1305	41	who	who	WP
5180	1305	42	harass	harass	VBP
5180	1305	43	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1305	44	or	or	CC
5180	1305	45	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1305	46	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1305	47	personal	personal	JJ
5180	1305	48	hygiene	hygiene	NN
5180	1305	49	precludes	preclude	VBZ
5180	1305	50	the	the	DT
5180	1305	51	library	library	NN
5180	1305	52	's	's	POS
5180	1305	53	use	use	NN
5180	1305	54	by	by	IN
5180	1305	55	other	other	JJ
5180	1305	56	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1305	57	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1305	58	.	.	.
5180	1306	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	1306	2	,	,	,
5180	1306	3	like	like	IN
5180	1306	4	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1306	5	public	public	JJ
5180	1306	6	fora	fora	NN
5180	1306	7	,	,	,
5180	1306	8	public	public	JJ
5180	1306	9	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1306	10	are	be	VBP
5180	1306	11	funded	fund	VBN
5180	1306	12	by	by	IN
5180	1306	13	taxpayers	taxpayer	NNS
5180	1306	14	and	and	CC
5180	1306	15	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1306	16	do	do	VBP
5180	1306	17	not	not	RB
5180	1306	18	charge	charge	VB
5180	1306	19	members	member	NNS
5180	1306	20	of	of	IN
5180	1306	21	the	the	DT
5180	1306	22	public	public	JJ
5180	1306	23	each	each	DT
5180	1306	24	time	time	NN
5180	1306	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1306	26	use	use	VBP
5180	1306	27	the	the	DT
5180	1306	28	forum	forum	NN
5180	1306	29	.	.	.
5180	1307	1	The	the	DT
5180	1307	2	only	only	JJ
5180	1307	3	direct	direct	JJ
5180	1307	4	cost	cost	NN
5180	1307	5	to	to	IN
5180	1307	6	library	library	NN
5180	1307	7	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1307	8	who	who	WP
5180	1307	9	wish	wish	VBP
5180	1307	10	to	to	TO
5180	1307	11	receive	receive	VB
5180	1307	12	information	information	NN
5180	1307	13	,	,	,
5180	1307	14	whether	whether	IN
5180	1307	15	via	via	IN
5180	1307	16	the	the	DT
5180	1307	17	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1307	18	or	or	CC
5180	1307	19	the	the	DT
5180	1307	20	library	library	NN
5180	1307	21	's	's	POS
5180	1307	22	print	print	NN
5180	1307	23	collection	collection	NN
5180	1307	24	,	,	,
5180	1307	25	is	be	VBZ
5180	1307	26	the	the	DT
5180	1307	27	time	time	NN
5180	1307	28	spent	spend	VBD
5180	1307	29	reading	read	VBG
5180	1307	30	.	.	.
5180	1308	1	By	by	IN
5180	1308	2	providing	provide	VBG
5180	1308	3	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1308	4	access	access	NN
5180	1308	5	to	to	IN
5180	1308	6	millions	million	NNS
5180	1308	7	of	of	IN
5180	1308	8	Americans	Americans	NNPS
5180	1308	9	to	to	TO
5180	1308	10	whom	whom	WP
5180	1308	11	such	such	JJ
5180	1308	12	access	access	NN
5180	1308	13	would	would	MD
5180	1308	14	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1308	15	be	be	VB
5180	1308	16	unavailable	unavailable	JJ
5180	1308	17	,	,	,
5180	1308	18	public	public	JJ
5180	1308	19	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1308	20	play	play	VBP
5180	1308	21	a	a	DT
5180	1308	22	critical	critical	JJ
5180	1308	23	role	role	NN
5180	1308	24	in	in	IN
5180	1308	25	bridging	bridge	VBG
5180	1308	26	the	the	DT
5180	1308	27	digital	digital	JJ
5180	1308	28	divide	divide	NN
5180	1308	29	separating	separate	VBG
5180	1308	30	those	those	DT
5180	1308	31	with	with	IN
5180	1308	32	access	access	NN
5180	1308	33	to	to	IN
5180	1308	34	new	new	JJ
5180	1308	35	information	information	NN
5180	1308	36	technologies	technology	NNS
5180	1308	37	from	from	IN
5180	1308	38	those	those	DT
5180	1308	39	that	that	WDT
5180	1308	40	lack	lack	VBP
5180	1308	41	access	access	NN
5180	1308	42	.	.	.
5180	1309	1	See	see	VB
5180	1309	2	generally	generally	RB
5180	1309	3	National	National	NNP
5180	1309	4	Telecommunications	Telecommunications	NNPS
5180	1309	5	and	and	CC
5180	1309	6	Information	Information	NNP
5180	1309	7	Administration	Administration	NNP
5180	1309	8	,	,	,
5180	1309	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1309	10	Department	Department	NNP
5180	1309	11	of	of	IN
5180	1309	12	Commerce	Commerce	NNP
5180	1309	13	,	,	,
5180	1309	14	Falling	fall	VBG
5180	1309	15	Through	through	IN
5180	1309	16	the	the	DT
5180	1309	17	Net	net	NN
5180	1309	18	:	:	:
5180	1309	19	Defining	define	VBG
5180	1309	20	the	the	DT
5180	1309	21	Digital	Digital	NNP
5180	1309	22	Divide	Divide	NNP
5180	1309	23	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1309	24	1999	1999	CD
5180	1309	25	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1309	26	,	,	,
5180	1309	27	available	available	JJ
5180	1309	28	at	at	IN
5180	1309	29	http://www.ntia.doc.gov/ntiahome/fttn99/contents.html	http://www.ntia.doc.gov/ntiahome/fttn99/contents.html	ADD
5180	1309	30	.	.	.
5180	1310	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1310	2	.	.	.
5180	1311	1	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	1311	2	,	,	,
5180	1311	3	531	531	CD
5180	1311	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1311	5	at	at	IN
5180	1311	6	546	546	CD
5180	1311	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1311	8	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
5180	1311	9	a	a	DT
5180	1311	10	content	content	NN
5180	1311	11	-	-	HYPH
5180	1311	12	based	base	VBN
5180	1311	13	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1311	14	on	on	IN
5180	1311	15	the	the	DT
5180	1311	16	speech	speech	NN
5180	1311	17	of	of	IN
5180	1311	18	federally	federally	RB
5180	1311	19	funded	funded	JJ
5180	1311	20	legal	legal	JJ
5180	1311	21	services	service	NNS
5180	1311	22	corporations	corporation	NNS
5180	1311	23	and	and	CC
5180	1311	24	noting	note	VBG
5180	1311	25	that	that	IN
5180	1311	26	given	give	VBN
5180	1311	27	the	the	DT
5180	1311	28	financial	financial	JJ
5180	1311	29	hardship	hardship	NN
5180	1311	30	of	of	IN
5180	1311	31	legal	legal	JJ
5180	1311	32	services	service	NNS
5180	1311	33	corporations	corporation	NNS
5180	1311	34	'	'	POS
5180	1311	35	clients	client	NNS
5180	1311	36	,	,	,
5180	1311	37	"	"	''
5180	1311	38	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1311	39	t]he	t]he	NNP
5180	1311	40	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1311	41	on	on	IN
5180	1311	42	speech	speech	NN
5180	1311	43	is	be	VBZ
5180	1311	44	even	even	RB
5180	1311	45	more	more	RBR
5180	1311	46	problematic	problematic	JJ
5180	1311	47	because	because	IN
5180	1311	48	in	in	IN
5180	1311	49	cases	case	NNS
5180	1311	50	where	where	WRB
5180	1311	51	the	the	DT
5180	1311	52	attorney	attorney	NN
5180	1311	53	withdraws	withdraw	VBZ
5180	1311	54	from	from	IN
5180	1311	55	a	a	DT
5180	1311	56	representation	representation	NN
5180	1311	57	,	,	,
5180	1311	58	the	the	DT
5180	1311	59	client	client	NN
5180	1311	60	is	be	VBZ
5180	1311	61	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
5180	1311	62	to	to	TO
5180	1311	63	find	find	VB
5180	1311	64	other	other	JJ
5180	1311	65	counsel	counsel	NN
5180	1311	66	"	"	''
5180	1311	67	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1311	68	.	.	.
5180	1312	1	Public	public	JJ
5180	1312	2	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1312	3	that	that	WDT
5180	1312	4	provide	provide	VBP
5180	1312	5	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1312	6	access	access	NN
5180	1312	7	greatly	greatly	RB
5180	1312	8	expand	expand	VBP
5180	1312	9	the	the	DT
5180	1312	10	educational	educational	JJ
5180	1312	11	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
5180	1312	12	for	for	IN
5180	1312	13	millions	million	NNS
5180	1312	14	of	of	IN
5180	1312	15	Americans	Americans	NNPS
5180	1312	16	who	who	WP
5180	1312	17	,	,	,
5180	1312	18	as	as	IN
5180	1312	19	explained	explain	VBN
5180	1312	20	in	in	IN
5180	1312	21	the	the	DT
5180	1312	22	margin	margin	NN
5180	1312	23	,	,	,
5180	1312	24	would	would	MD
5180	1312	25	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1312	26	be	be	VB
5180	1312	27	deprived	deprive	VBN
5180	1312	28	of	of	IN
5180	1312	29	the	the	DT
5180	1312	30	benefits	benefit	NNS
5180	1312	31	of	of	IN
5180	1312	32	this	this	DT
5180	1312	33	new	new	JJ
5180	1312	34	medium	medium	NN
5180	1312	35	.	.	.
5180	1313	1	Just	just	RB
5180	1313	2	as	as	RB
5180	1313	3	important	important	JJ
5180	1313	4	as	as	IN
5180	1313	5	the	the	DT
5180	1313	6	openness	openness	NN
5180	1313	7	of	of	IN
5180	1313	8	a	a	DT
5180	1313	9	forum	forum	NN
5180	1313	10	to	to	IN
5180	1313	11	listeners	listener	NNS
5180	1313	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	1313	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1313	14	openness	openness	NN
5180	1313	15	to	to	IN
5180	1313	16	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1313	17	.	.	.
5180	1314	1	Parks	park	NNS
5180	1314	2	and	and	CC
5180	1314	3	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1314	4	are	be	VBP
5180	1314	5	paradigmatic	paradigmatic	JJ
5180	1314	6	loci	loci	NN
5180	1314	7	of	of	IN
5180	1314	8	First	First	NNP
5180	1314	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1314	10	values	value	NNS
5180	1314	11	in	in	IN
5180	1314	12	large	large	JJ
5180	1314	13	part	part	NN
5180	1314	14	because	because	IN
5180	1314	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1314	16	permit	permit	VBP
5180	1314	17	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1314	18	to	to	TO
5180	1314	19	communicate	communicate	VB
5180	1314	20	with	with	IN
5180	1314	21	a	a	DT
5180	1314	22	wide	wide	JJ
5180	1314	23	audience	audience	NN
5180	1314	24	at	at	IN
5180	1314	25	low	low	JJ
5180	1314	26	cost	cost	NN
5180	1314	27	.	.	.
5180	1315	1	One	one	PRP
5180	1315	2	can	can	MD
5180	1315	3	address	address	VB
5180	1315	4	members	member	NNS
5180	1315	5	of	of	IN
5180	1315	6	the	the	DT
5180	1315	7	public	public	NN
5180	1315	8	in	in	IN
5180	1315	9	a	a	DT
5180	1315	10	park	park	NN
5180	1315	11	for	for	IN
5180	1315	12	little	little	JJ
5180	1315	13	more	more	JJR
5180	1315	14	than	than	IN
5180	1315	15	the	the	DT
5180	1315	16	cost	cost	NN
5180	1315	17	of	of	IN
5180	1315	18	a	a	DT
5180	1315	19	soapbox	soapbox	NN
5180	1315	20	,	,	,
5180	1315	21	and	and	CC
5180	1315	22	one	one	PRP
5180	1315	23	can	can	MD
5180	1315	24	distribute	distribute	VB
5180	1315	25	handbills	handbill	NNS
5180	1315	26	on	on	IN
5180	1315	27	the	the	DT
5180	1315	28	sidewalk	sidewalk	NN
5180	1315	29	for	for	IN
5180	1315	30	little	little	JJ
5180	1315	31	more	more	JJR
5180	1315	32	than	than	IN
5180	1315	33	the	the	DT
5180	1315	34	cost	cost	NN
5180	1315	35	of	of	IN
5180	1315	36	a	a	DT
5180	1315	37	pen	pen	NN
5180	1315	38	,	,	,
5180	1315	39	paper	paper	NN
5180	1315	40	,	,	,
5180	1315	41	and	and	CC
5180	1315	42	some	some	DT
5180	1315	43	photocopies	photocopy	NNS
5180	1315	44	.	.	.
5180	1316	1	See	see	VB
5180	1316	2	Martin	Martin	NNP
5180	1316	3	v.	v.	CC
5180	1316	4	City	City	NNP
5180	1316	5	of	of	IN
5180	1316	6	Struthers	Struthers	NNPS
5180	1316	7	,	,	,
5180	1316	8	319	319	CD
5180	1316	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1316	10	141	141	CD
5180	1316	11	,	,	,
5180	1316	12	146	146	CD
5180	1316	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1316	14	1943	1943	CD
5180	1316	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1316	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1316	17	"	"	``
5180	1316	18	Door	door	NN
5180	1316	19	to	to	TO
5180	1316	20	door	door	VB
5180	1316	21	distribution	distribution	NN
5180	1316	22	of	of	IN
5180	1316	23	circulars	circular	NNS
5180	1316	24	is	be	VBZ
5180	1316	25	essential	essential	JJ
5180	1316	26	to	to	IN
5180	1316	27	the	the	DT
5180	1316	28	poorly	poorly	RB
5180	1316	29	financed	finance	VBN
5180	1316	30	causes	cause	NNS
5180	1316	31	of	of	IN
5180	1316	32	little	little	JJ
5180	1316	33	people	people	NNS
5180	1316	34	.	.	.
5180	1317	1	")	")	``
5180	1317	2	;	;	:
5180	1317	3	Laurence	Laurence	NNP
5180	1317	4	H.	H.	NNP
5180	1317	5	Tribe	Tribe	NNP
5180	1317	6	,	,	,
5180	1317	7	American	American	NNP
5180	1317	8	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
5180	1317	9	Law	Law	NNP
5180	1317	10	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1317	11	.	.	.
5180	1318	1	12	12	CD
5180	1318	2	-	-	SYM
5180	1318	3	24	24	CD
5180	1318	4	at	at	IN
5180	1318	5	987	987	CD
5180	1318	6	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1318	7	2d	2d	CD
5180	1318	8	ed	ed	NNP
5180	1318	9	.	.	.
5180	1319	1	1988	1988	CD
5180	1319	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1319	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1319	4	"	"	``
5180	1319	5	The	the	DT
5180	1319	6	'	'	``
5180	1319	7	public	public	JJ
5180	1319	8	forum	forum	NN
5180	1319	9	'	'	''
5180	1319	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	1319	11	holds	hold	VBZ
5180	1319	12	that	that	IN
5180	1319	13	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1319	14	on	on	IN
5180	1319	15	speech	speech	NN
5180	1319	16	should	should	MD
5180	1319	17	be	be	VB
5180	1319	18	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1319	19	to	to	IN
5180	1319	20	higher	high	JJR
5180	1319	21	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1319	22	when	when	WRB
5180	1319	23	,	,	,
5180	1319	24	all	all	DT
5180	1319	25	other	other	JJ
5180	1319	26	things	thing	NNS
5180	1319	27	being	be	VBG
5180	1319	28	equal	equal	JJ
5180	1319	29	,	,	,
5180	1319	30	that	that	IN
5180	1319	31	speech	speech	NN
5180	1319	32	occurs	occur	VBZ
5180	1319	33	in	in	IN
5180	1319	34	areas	area	NNS
5180	1319	35	playing	play	VBG
5180	1319	36	a	a	DT
5180	1319	37	vital	vital	JJ
5180	1319	38	role	role	NN
5180	1319	39	in	in	IN
5180	1319	40	communication	communication	NN
5180	1319	41	–	–	:
5180	1319	42	such	such	JJ
5180	1319	43	as	as	IN
5180	1319	44	in	in	IN
5180	1319	45	those	those	DT
5180	1319	46	places	place	NNS
5180	1319	47	historically	historically	RB
5180	1319	48	associated	associate	VBN
5180	1319	49	with	with	IN
5180	1319	50	first	first	JJ
5180	1319	51	amendment	amendment	NN
5180	1319	52	activities	activity	NNS
5180	1319	53	,	,	,
5180	1319	54	such	such	JJ
5180	1319	55	as	as	IN
5180	1319	56	streets	street	NNS
5180	1319	57	,	,	,
5180	1319	58	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1319	59	,	,	,
5180	1319	60	and	and	CC
5180	1319	61	parks	park	NNS
5180	1319	62	–	–	:
5180	1319	63	especially	especially	RB
5180	1319	64	because	because	IN
5180	1319	65	of	of	IN
5180	1319	66	how	how	WRB
5180	1319	67	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
5180	1319	68	communication	communication	NN
5180	1319	69	in	in	IN
5180	1319	70	these	these	DT
5180	1319	71	places	place	NNS
5180	1319	72	is	be	VBZ
5180	1319	73	to	to	IN
5180	1319	74	people	people	NNS
5180	1319	75	who	who	WP
5180	1319	76	lack	lack	VBP
5180	1319	77	access	access	NN
5180	1319	78	to	to	IN
5180	1319	79	more	more	RBR
5180	1319	80	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
5180	1319	81	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1319	82	and	and	CC
5180	1319	83	more	more	RBR
5180	1319	84	costly	costly	JJ
5180	1319	85	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1319	86	channels	channel	NNS
5180	1319	87	.	.	.
5180	1320	1	")	")	``
5180	1320	2	;	;	:
5180	1320	3	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
5180	1320	4	A.	A.	NNP
5180	1320	5	Farber	Farber	NNP
5180	1320	6	,	,	,
5180	1320	7	Free	Free	NNP
5180	1320	8	Speech	Speech	NNP
5180	1320	9	without	without	IN
5180	1320	10	Romance	Romance	NNP
5180	1320	11	:	:	:
5180	1320	12	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1320	13	Choice	Choice	NNP
5180	1320	14	and	and	CC
5180	1320	15	the	the	DT
5180	1320	16	First	First	NNP
5180	1320	17	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1320	18	,	,	,
5180	1320	19	105	105	CD
5180	1320	20	Harv	Harv	NNP
5180	1320	21	.	.	.
5180	1321	1	L.	L.	NNP
5180	1321	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
5180	1322	1	554	554	CD
5180	1322	2	,	,	,
5180	1322	3	574	574	CD
5180	1322	4	n.86	n.86	NNP
5180	1322	5	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1322	6	1991	1991	CD
5180	1322	7	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1322	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1322	9	noting	note	VBG
5180	1322	10	that	that	IN
5180	1322	11	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1322	12	public	public	JJ
5180	1322	13	fora	fora	NN
5180	1322	14	"	"	''
5180	1322	15	are	be	VBP
5180	1322	16	often	often	RB
5180	1322	17	the	the	DT
5180	1322	18	only	only	JJ
5180	1322	19	place	place	NN
5180	1322	20	where	where	WRB
5180	1322	21	less	less	RBR
5180	1322	22	affluent	affluent	JJ
5180	1322	23	groups	group	NNS
5180	1322	24	and	and	CC
5180	1322	25	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	1322	26	can	can	MD
5180	1322	27	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	1322	28	express	express	VB
5180	1322	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1322	30	message	message	NN
5180	1322	31	"	"	''
5180	1322	32	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1322	33	;	;	:
5180	1322	34	Harry	Harry	NNP
5180	1322	35	Kalven	Kalven	NNP
5180	1322	36	,	,	,
5180	1322	37	Jr.	Jr.	NNP
5180	1322	38	,	,	,
5180	1322	39	The	the	DT
5180	1322	40	Concept	Concept	NNP
5180	1322	41	of	of	IN
5180	1322	42	the	the	DT
5180	1322	43	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1322	44	Forum	Forum	NNP
5180	1322	45	:	:	:
5180	1322	46	Cox	Cox	NNP
5180	1322	47	v.	v.	IN
5180	1322	48	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
5180	1322	49	,	,	,
5180	1322	50	1965	1965	CD
5180	1322	51	Sup	Sup	NNP
5180	1322	52	.	.	.
5180	1323	1	Ct	Ct	NNP
5180	1323	2	.	.	.
5180	1323	3	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
5180	1324	1	1	1	CD
5180	1324	2	,	,	,
5180	1324	3	30	30	CD
5180	1324	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1324	5	"	"	``
5180	1324	6	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1324	7	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	1324	8	parade	parade	NN
5180	1324	9	,	,	,
5180	1324	10	the	the	DT
5180	1324	11	picket	picket	NN
5180	1324	12	,	,	,
5180	1324	13	the	the	DT
5180	1324	14	leaflet	leaflet	NN
5180	1324	15	,	,	,
5180	1324	16	the	the	DT
5180	1324	17	sound	sound	JJ
5180	1324	18	truck	truck	NN
5180	1324	19	,	,	,
5180	1324	20	have	have	VBP
5180	1324	21	been	be	VBN
5180	1324	22	the	the	DT
5180	1324	23	media	medium	NNS
5180	1324	24	of	of	IN
5180	1324	25	communication	communication	NN
5180	1324	26	exploited	exploit	VBN
5180	1324	27	by	by	IN
5180	1324	28	those	those	DT
5180	1324	29	with	with	IN
5180	1324	30	little	little	JJ
5180	1324	31	access	access	NN
5180	1324	32	to	to	IN
5180	1324	33	the	the	DT
5180	1324	34	more	more	RBR
5180	1324	35	genteel	genteel	JJ
5180	1324	36	means	mean	NNS
5180	1324	37	of	of	IN
5180	1324	38	communication	communication	NN
5180	1324	39	.	.	.
5180	1324	40	"	"	''
5180	1324	41	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1324	42	.	.	.
5180	1325	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1325	2	,	,	,
5180	1325	3	given	give	VBN
5180	1325	4	the	the	DT
5180	1325	5	existence	existence	NN
5180	1325	6	of	of	IN
5180	1325	7	message	message	NN
5180	1325	8	boards	board	NNS
5180	1325	9	and	and	CC
5180	1325	10	free	free	JJ
5180	1325	11	Web	web	NN
5180	1325	12	hosting	host	VBG
5180	1325	13	services	service	NNS
5180	1325	14	,	,	,
5180	1325	15	a	a	DT
5180	1325	16	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	1325	17	can	can	MD
5180	1325	18	,	,	,
5180	1325	19	via	via	IN
5180	1325	20	the	the	DT
5180	1325	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1325	22	,	,	,
5180	1325	23	address	address	VB
5180	1325	24	the	the	DT
5180	1325	25	public	public	NN
5180	1325	26	,	,	,
5180	1325	27	including	include	VBG
5180	1325	28	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1325	29	of	of	IN
5180	1325	30	public	public	JJ
5180	1325	31	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1325	32	,	,	,
5180	1325	33	for	for	IN
5180	1325	34	little	little	JJ
5180	1325	35	more	more	JJR
5180	1325	36	than	than	IN
5180	1325	37	the	the	DT
5180	1325	38	cost	cost	NN
5180	1325	39	of	of	IN
5180	1325	40	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1325	41	access	access	NN
5180	1325	42	.	.	.
5180	1326	1	As	as	IN
5180	1326	2	the	the	DT
5180	1326	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1326	4	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1326	5	explained	explain	VBD
5180	1326	6	in	in	IN
5180	1326	7	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1326	8	v.	v.	CC
5180	1326	9	ACLU	ACLU	NNP
5180	1326	10	,	,	,
5180	1326	11	521	521	CD
5180	1326	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1326	13	844	844	CD
5180	1326	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1326	15	1997	1997	CD
5180	1326	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1326	17	,	,	,
5180	1326	18	"	"	''
5180	1326	19	the	the	DT
5180	1326	20	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1326	21	can	can	MD
5180	1326	22	hardly	hardly	RB
5180	1326	23	be	be	VB
5180	1326	24	considered	consider	VBN
5180	1326	25	a	a	DT
5180	1326	26	'	'	``
5180	1326	27	scarce	scarce	JJ
5180	1326	28	'	'	''
5180	1326	29	expressive	expressive	JJ
5180	1326	30	commodity	commodity	NN
5180	1326	31	.	.	.
5180	1327	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1327	2	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	1327	3	relatively	relatively	RB
5180	1327	4	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	1327	5	,	,	,
5180	1327	6	low	low	JJ
5180	1327	7	-	-	HYPH
5180	1327	8	cost	cost	NN
5180	1327	9	capacity	capacity	NN
5180	1327	10	for	for	IN
5180	1327	11	communication	communication	NN
5180	1327	12	of	of	IN
5180	1327	13	all	all	DT
5180	1327	14	kinds	kind	NNS
5180	1327	15	.	.	.
5180	1327	16	"	"	''
5180	1328	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1329	1	at	at	IN
5180	1329	2	870	870	CD
5180	1329	3	.	.	.
5180	1330	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1330	2	the	the	DT
5180	1330	3	cost	cost	NN
5180	1330	4	of	of	IN
5180	1330	5	a	a	DT
5180	1330	6	home	home	NN
5180	1330	7	computer	computer	NN
5180	1330	8	and	and	CC
5180	1330	9	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1330	10	access	access	NN
5180	1330	11	considerably	considerably	RB
5180	1330	12	exceeds	exceed	VBZ
5180	1330	13	the	the	DT
5180	1330	14	cost	cost	NN
5180	1330	15	of	of	IN
5180	1330	16	a	a	DT
5180	1330	17	soapbox	soapbox	NN
5180	1330	18	or	or	CC
5180	1330	19	a	a	DT
5180	1330	20	few	few	JJ
5180	1330	21	hundred	hundred	CD
5180	1330	22	photocopies	photocopy	NNS
5180	1330	23	,	,	,
5180	1330	24	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1330	25	wishing	wish	VBG
5180	1330	26	to	to	TO
5180	1330	27	avail	avail	VB
5180	1330	28	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1330	29	of	of	IN
5180	1330	30	the	the	DT
5180	1330	31	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1330	32	may	may	MD
5180	1330	33	gain	gain	VB
5180	1330	34	free	free	JJ
5180	1330	35	access	access	NN
5180	1330	36	in	in	IN
5180	1330	37	schools	school	NNS
5180	1330	38	,	,	,
5180	1330	39	workplaces	workplace	NNS
5180	1330	40	,	,	,
5180	1330	41	or	or	CC
5180	1330	42	the	the	DT
5180	1330	43	public	public	JJ
5180	1330	44	library	library	NN
5180	1330	45	.	.	.
5180	1331	1	As	as	IN
5180	1331	2	Professor	Professor	NNP
5180	1331	3	Lessig	Lessig	NNP
5180	1331	4	has	have	VBZ
5180	1331	5	explained	explain	VBN
5180	1331	6	:	:	:
5180	1331	7	The	the	DT
5180	1331	8	"	"	``
5180	1331	9	press	press	NN
5180	1331	10	"	"	''
5180	1331	11	in	in	IN
5180	1331	12	1791	1791	CD
5180	1331	13	was	be	VBD
5180	1331	14	not	not	RB
5180	1331	15	the	the	DT
5180	1331	16	New	New	NNP
5180	1331	17	York	York	NNP
5180	1331	18	Times	Times	NNP
5180	1331	19	or	or	CC
5180	1331	20	the	the	DT
5180	1331	21	Wall	Wall	NNP
5180	1331	22	Street	Street	NNP
5180	1331	23	Journal	Journal	NNP
5180	1331	24	.	.	.
5180	1332	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1332	2	did	do	VBD
5180	1332	3	not	not	RB
5180	1332	4	comprise	comprise	VB
5180	1332	5	large	large	JJ
5180	1332	6	organizations	organization	NNS
5180	1332	7	of	of	IN
5180	1332	8	private	private	JJ
5180	1332	9	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1332	10	,	,	,
5180	1332	11	with	with	IN
5180	1332	12	millions	million	NNS
5180	1332	13	of	of	IN
5180	1332	14	readers	reader	NNS
5180	1332	15	associated	associate	VBN
5180	1332	16	with	with	IN
5180	1332	17	each	each	DT
5180	1332	18	organization	organization	NN
5180	1332	19	.	.	.
5180	1333	1	Rather	rather	RB
5180	1333	2	,	,	,
5180	1333	3	the	the	DT
5180	1333	4	press	press	NN
5180	1333	5	then	then	RB
5180	1333	6	was	be	VBD
5180	1333	7	much	much	JJ
5180	1333	8	like	like	IN
5180	1333	9	the	the	DT
5180	1333	10	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1333	11	today	today	NN
5180	1333	12	.	.	.
5180	1334	1	The	the	DT
5180	1334	2	cost	cost	NN
5180	1334	3	of	of	IN
5180	1334	4	a	a	DT
5180	1334	5	printing	print	VBG
5180	1334	6	press	press	NN
5180	1334	7	was	be	VBD
5180	1334	8	low	low	JJ
5180	1334	9	,	,	,
5180	1334	10	the	the	DT
5180	1334	11	readership	readership	NN
5180	1334	12	was	be	VBD
5180	1334	13	slight	slight	JJ
5180	1334	14	,	,	,
5180	1334	15	and	and	CC
5180	1334	16	anyone	anyone	NN
5180	1334	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1334	18	within	within	IN
5180	1334	19	reason	reason	NN
5180	1334	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1334	21	could	could	MD
5180	1334	22	become	become	VB
5180	1334	23	a	a	DT
5180	1334	24	publisher	publisher	NN
5180	1334	25	–	–	:
5180	1334	26	and	and	CC
5180	1334	27	in	in	IN
5180	1334	28	fact	fact	NN
5180	1334	29	an	an	DT
5180	1334	30	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
5180	1334	31	number	number	NN
5180	1334	32	did	do	VBD
5180	1334	33	.	.	.
5180	1335	1	When	when	WRB
5180	1335	2	the	the	DT
5180	1335	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
5180	1335	4	speaks	speak	VBZ
5180	1335	5	of	of	IN
5180	1335	6	the	the	DT
5180	1335	7	rights	right	NNS
5180	1335	8	of	of	IN
5180	1335	9	the	the	DT
5180	1335	10	"	"	``
5180	1335	11	press	press	NN
5180	1335	12	,	,	,
5180	1335	13	"	"	''
5180	1335	14	the	the	DT
5180	1335	15	architecture	architecture	NN
5180	1335	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1335	17	has	have	VBZ
5180	1335	18	in	in	IN
5180	1335	19	mind	mind	NN
5180	1335	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	1335	21	the	the	DT
5180	1335	22	architecture	architecture	NN
5180	1335	23	of	of	IN
5180	1335	24	the	the	DT
5180	1335	25	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1335	26	.	.	.
5180	1336	1	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
5180	1336	2	Lessig	Lessig	NNP
5180	1336	3	,	,	,
5180	1336	4	Code	Code	NNP
5180	1336	5	183	183	CD
5180	1336	6	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1336	7	1999	1999	CD
5180	1336	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1336	9	.	.	.
5180	1337	1	While	while	IN
5180	1337	2	public	public	JJ
5180	1337	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1337	4	'	'	POS
5180	1337	5	provision	provision	NN
5180	1337	6	of	of	IN
5180	1337	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1337	8	access	access	NN
5180	1337	9	shares	share	NNS
5180	1337	10	many	many	JJ
5180	1337	11	of	of	IN
5180	1337	12	the	the	DT
5180	1337	13	speech	speech	NN
5180	1337	14	-	-	HYPH
5180	1337	15	promoting	promote	VBG
5180	1337	16	qualities	quality	NNS
5180	1337	17	of	of	IN
5180	1337	18	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1337	19	public	public	JJ
5180	1337	20	fora	fora	NN
5180	1337	21	,	,	,
5180	1337	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1337	23	also	also	RB
5180	1337	24	facilitates	facilitate	VBZ
5180	1337	25	speech	speech	NN
5180	1337	26	in	in	IN
5180	1337	27	ways	way	NNS
5180	1337	28	that	that	IN
5180	1337	29	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1337	30	public	public	JJ
5180	1337	31	fora	fora	NN
5180	1337	32	can	can	MD
5180	1337	33	not	not	RB
5180	1337	34	.	.	.
5180	1338	1	In	in	IN
5180	1338	2	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1338	3	,	,	,
5180	1338	4	whereas	whereas	IN
5180	1338	5	the	the	DT
5180	1338	6	architecture	architecture	NN
5180	1338	7	of	of	IN
5180	1338	8	real	real	JJ
5180	1338	9	space	space	NN
5180	1338	10	limits	limit	VBZ
5180	1338	11	the	the	DT
5180	1338	12	audience	audience	NN
5180	1338	13	of	of	IN
5180	1338	14	a	a	DT
5180	1338	15	pamphleteer	pamphleteer	NN
5180	1338	16	or	or	CC
5180	1338	17	soapbox	soapbox	NN
5180	1338	18	orator	orator	NN
5180	1338	19	to	to	IN
5180	1338	20	people	people	NNS
5180	1338	21	within	within	IN
5180	1338	22	the	the	DT
5180	1338	23	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	1338	24	's	's	POS
5180	1338	25	immediate	immediate	JJ
5180	1338	26	vicinity	vicinity	NN
5180	1338	27	,	,	,
5180	1338	28	the	the	DT
5180	1338	29	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1338	30	renders	render	VBZ
5180	1338	31	the	the	DT
5180	1338	32	geography	geography	NN
5180	1338	33	of	of	IN
5180	1338	34	speaker	speaker	NNP
5180	1338	35	and	and	CC
5180	1338	36	listener	listener	NN
5180	1338	37	irrelevant	irrelevant	JJ
5180	1338	38	:	:	:
5180	1338	39	Through	through	IN
5180	1338	40	the	the	DT
5180	1338	41	use	use	NN
5180	1338	42	of	of	IN
5180	1338	43	chat	chat	NN
5180	1338	44	rooms	room	NNS
5180	1338	45	,	,	,
5180	1338	46	any	any	DT
5180	1338	47	person	person	NN
5180	1338	48	with	with	IN
5180	1338	49	a	a	DT
5180	1338	50	phone	phone	NN
5180	1338	51	line	line	NN
5180	1338	52	can	can	MD
5180	1338	53	become	become	VB
5180	1338	54	a	a	DT
5180	1338	55	town	town	NN
5180	1338	56	crier	crier	NN
5180	1338	57	with	with	IN
5180	1338	58	a	a	DT
5180	1338	59	voice	voice	NN
5180	1338	60	that	that	WDT
5180	1338	61	resonates	resonate	VBZ
5180	1338	62	farther	farth	JJR
5180	1338	63	than	than	IN
5180	1338	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1338	65	could	could	MD
5180	1338	66	from	from	IN
5180	1338	67	any	any	DT
5180	1338	68	soapbox	soapbox	NN
5180	1338	69	.	.	.
5180	1339	1	Through	through	IN
5180	1339	2	the	the	DT
5180	1339	3	use	use	NN
5180	1339	4	of	of	IN
5180	1339	5	Web	web	NN
5180	1339	6	pages	page	NNS
5180	1339	7	,	,	,
5180	1339	8	mail	mail	NN
5180	1339	9	exploders	exploder	NNS
5180	1339	10	,	,	,
5180	1339	11	and	and	CC
5180	1339	12	newsgroups	newsgroup	NNS
5180	1339	13	,	,	,
5180	1339	14	the	the	DT
5180	1339	15	same	same	JJ
5180	1339	16	individual	individual	NN
5180	1339	17	can	can	MD
5180	1339	18	become	become	VB
5180	1339	19	a	a	DT
5180	1339	20	pamphleteer	pamphleteer	NN
5180	1339	21	.	.	.
5180	1340	1	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1340	2	,	,	,
5180	1340	3	521	521	CD
5180	1340	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1340	5	at	at	IN
5180	1340	6	870	870	CD
5180	1340	7	.	.	.
5180	1341	1	By	by	IN
5180	1341	2	providing	provide	VBG
5180	1341	3	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1341	4	with	with	IN
5180	1341	5	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1341	6	access	access	NN
5180	1341	7	,	,	,
5180	1341	8	public	public	JJ
5180	1341	9	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1341	10	in	in	IN
5180	1341	11	effect	effect	NN
5180	1341	12	open	open	VBP
5180	1341	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1341	14	doors	door	NNS
5180	1341	15	to	to	IN
5180	1341	16	an	an	DT
5180	1341	17	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	1341	18	number	number	NN
5180	1341	19	of	of	IN
5180	1341	20	potential	potential	JJ
5180	1341	21	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1341	22	around	around	IN
5180	1341	23	the	the	DT
5180	1341	24	world	world	NN
5180	1341	25	,	,	,
5180	1341	26	inviting	invite	VBG
5180	1341	27	the	the	DT
5180	1341	28	speech	speech	NN
5180	1341	29	of	of	IN
5180	1341	30	any	any	DT
5180	1341	31	member	member	NN
5180	1341	32	of	of	IN
5180	1341	33	the	the	DT
5180	1341	34	public	public	NN
5180	1341	35	who	who	WP
5180	1341	36	wishes	wish	VBZ
5180	1341	37	to	to	TO
5180	1341	38	communicate	communicate	VB
5180	1341	39	with	with	IN
5180	1341	40	library	library	JJ
5180	1341	41	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1341	42	via	via	IN
5180	1341	43	the	the	DT
5180	1341	44	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1341	45	.	.	.
5180	1342	1	Due	due	IN
5180	1342	2	to	to	IN
5180	1342	3	the	the	DT
5180	1342	4	low	low	JJ
5180	1342	5	costs	cost	NNS
5180	1342	6	for	for	IN
5180	1342	7	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1342	8	and	and	CC
5180	1342	9	the	the	DT
5180	1342	10	irrelevance	irrelevance	NN
5180	1342	11	of	of	IN
5180	1342	12	geography	geography	NN
5180	1342	13	,	,	,
5180	1342	14	the	the	DT
5180	1342	15	volume	volume	NN
5180	1342	16	of	of	IN
5180	1342	17	speech	speech	NN
5180	1342	18	available	available	JJ
5180	1342	19	to	to	IN
5180	1342	20	library	library	JJ
5180	1342	21	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1342	22	on	on	IN
5180	1342	23	the	the	DT
5180	1342	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1342	25	is	be	VBZ
5180	1342	26	enormous	enormous	JJ
5180	1342	27	and	and	CC
5180	1342	28	far	far	RB
5180	1342	29	exceeds	exceed	VBZ
5180	1342	30	the	the	DT
5180	1342	31	volume	volume	NN
5180	1342	32	of	of	IN
5180	1342	33	speech	speech	NN
5180	1342	34	available	available	JJ
5180	1342	35	to	to	IN
5180	1342	36	audiences	audience	NNS
5180	1342	37	in	in	IN
5180	1342	38	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1342	39	public	public	JJ
5180	1342	40	fora	fora	NN
5180	1342	41	.	.	.
5180	1343	1	See	see	VB
5180	1343	2	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1343	3	d	d	VBN
5180	1343	4	.	.	.
5180	1344	1	at	at	IN
5180	1344	2	868	868	CD
5180	1344	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1344	4	referring	refer	VBG
5180	1344	5	to	to	IN
5180	1344	6	"	"	``
5180	1344	7	the	the	DT
5180	1344	8	vast	vast	JJ
5180	1344	9	democratic	democratic	JJ
5180	1344	10	forums	forum	NNS
5180	1344	11	of	of	IN
5180	1344	12	the	the	DT
5180	1344	13	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1344	14	"	"	''
5180	1344	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1344	16	.	.	.
5180	1345	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	1345	2	,	,	,
5180	1345	3	as	as	IN
5180	1345	4	noted	note	VBN
5180	1345	5	in	in	IN
5180	1345	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1345	7	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1345	8	of	of	IN
5180	1345	9	fact	fact	NN
5180	1345	10	,	,	,
5180	1345	11	the	the	DT
5180	1345	12	Web	web	NN
5180	1345	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	1345	14	estimated	estimate	VBN
5180	1345	15	to	to	TO
5180	1345	16	contain	contain	VB
5180	1345	17	over	over	RP
5180	1345	18	one	one	CD
5180	1345	19	billion	billion	CD
5180	1345	20	pages	page	NNS
5180	1345	21	,	,	,
5180	1345	22	and	and	CC
5180	1345	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	1345	24	said	say	VBN
5180	1345	25	to	to	TO
5180	1345	26	be	be	VB
5180	1345	27	growing	grow	VBG
5180	1345	28	at	at	IN
5180	1345	29	a	a	DT
5180	1345	30	rate	rate	NN
5180	1345	31	of	of	IN
5180	1345	32	over	over	IN
5180	1345	33	1.5	1.5	CD
5180	1345	34	million	million	CD
5180	1345	35	pages	page	NNS
5180	1345	36	per	per	IN
5180	1345	37	day	day	NN
5180	1345	38	.	.	.
5180	1346	1	See	see	VB
5180	1346	2	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1346	3	d	d	VBN
5180	1346	4	.	.	.
5180	1347	1	at	at	IN
5180	1347	2	885	885	CD
5180	1347	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1347	4	noting	note	VBG
5180	1347	5	"	"	``
5180	1347	6	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1347	7	t]he	t]he	HYPH
5180	1347	8	dramatic	dramatic	JJ
5180	1347	9	expansion	expansion	NN
5180	1347	10	of	of	IN
5180	1347	11	this	this	DT
5180	1347	12	new	new	JJ
5180	1347	13	marketplace	marketplace	NN
5180	1347	14	of	of	IN
5180	1347	15	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	1347	16	"	"	''
5180	1347	17	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1347	18	.	.	.
5180	1348	1	This	this	DT
5180	1348	2	staggering	staggering	JJ
5180	1348	3	volume	volume	NN
5180	1348	4	of	of	IN
5180	1348	5	content	content	NN
5180	1348	6	on	on	IN
5180	1348	7	the	the	DT
5180	1348	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1348	9	"	"	''
5180	1348	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	1348	11	as	as	RB
5180	1348	12	diverse	diverse	JJ
5180	1348	13	as	as	IN
5180	1348	14	human	human	JJ
5180	1348	15	thought	thought	NN
5180	1348	16	,	,	,
5180	1348	17	"	"	''
5180	1348	18	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1348	19	d	d	VBN
5180	1348	20	.	.	.
5180	1349	1	at	at	IN
5180	1349	2	870	870	CD
5180	1349	3	,	,	,
5180	1349	4	and	and	CC
5180	1349	5	"	"	``
5180	1349	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	1349	7	thus	thus	RB
5180	1349	8	comparable	comparable	JJ
5180	1349	9	,	,	,
5180	1349	10	from	from	IN
5180	1349	11	the	the	DT
5180	1349	12	reader	reader	NN
5180	1349	13	's	's	POS
5180	1349	14	viewpoint	viewpoint	NN
5180	1349	15	,	,	,
5180	1349	16	to	to	IN
5180	1349	17	.	.	.
5180	1350	1	.	.	.
5180	1351	1	.	.	.
5180	1352	1	a	a	DT
5180	1352	2	vast	vast	JJ
5180	1352	3	library	library	NN
5180	1352	4	including	include	VBG
5180	1352	5	millions	million	NNS
5180	1352	6	of	of	IN
5180	1352	7	readily	readily	RB
5180	1352	8	available	available	JJ
5180	1352	9	and	and	CC
5180	1352	10	indexed	indexed	JJ
5180	1352	11	publications	publication	NNS
5180	1352	12	,	,	,
5180	1352	13	"	"	''
5180	1352	14	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1352	15	d	d	VBN
5180	1352	16	.	.	.
5180	1353	1	at	at	IN
5180	1353	2	853	853	CD
5180	1353	3	.	.	.
5180	1354	1	As	as	IN
5180	1354	2	a	a	DT
5180	1354	3	result	result	NN
5180	1354	4	of	of	IN
5180	1354	5	the	the	DT
5180	1354	6	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1354	7	's	's	POS
5180	1354	8	unique	unique	JJ
5180	1354	9	speech	speech	NN
5180	1354	10	-	-	HYPH
5180	1354	11	facilitating	facilitate	VBG
5180	1354	12	qualities	quality	NNS
5180	1354	13	,	,	,
5180	1354	14	"	"	''
5180	1354	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1354	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	1354	17	hard	hard	JJ
5180	1354	18	to	to	TO
5180	1354	19	find	find	VB
5180	1354	20	an	an	DT
5180	1354	21	aspiring	aspire	VBG
5180	1354	22	social	social	JJ
5180	1354	23	movement	movement	NN
5180	1354	24	,	,	,
5180	1354	25	new	new	JJ
5180	1354	26	or	or	CC
5180	1354	27	old	old	JJ
5180	1354	28	,	,	,
5180	1354	29	of	of	IN
5180	1354	30	left	left	JJ
5180	1354	31	,	,	,
5180	1354	32	right	right	UH
5180	1354	33	,	,	,
5180	1354	34	or	or	CC
5180	1354	35	center	center	NN
5180	1354	36	,	,	,
5180	1354	37	without	without	IN
5180	1354	38	a	a	DT
5180	1354	39	website	website	NN
5180	1354	40	,	,	,
5180	1354	41	a	a	DT
5180	1354	42	bulletin	bulletin	NN
5180	1354	43	board	board	NN
5180	1354	44	,	,	,
5180	1354	45	and	and	CC
5180	1354	46	an	an	DT
5180	1354	47	email	email	NN
5180	1354	48	list	list	NN
5180	1354	49	.	.	.
5180	1354	50	"	"	''
5180	1355	1	Kreimer	Kreimer	NNP
5180	1355	2	,	,	,
5180	1355	3	supra	supra	NNP
5180	1355	4	n.27	n.27	NNP
5180	1355	5	,	,	,
5180	1355	6	at	at	IN
5180	1355	7	125	125	CD
5180	1355	8	.	.	.
5180	1356	1	"	"	``
5180	1356	2	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1356	3	T]he	t]he	CD
5180	1356	4	growth	growth	NN
5180	1356	5	of	of	IN
5180	1356	6	the	the	DT
5180	1356	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1356	8	has	have	VBZ
5180	1356	9	been	be	VBN
5180	1356	10	and	and	CC
5180	1356	11	continues	continue	VBZ
5180	1356	12	to	to	TO
5180	1356	13	be	be	VB
5180	1356	14	phenomenal	phenomenal	JJ
5180	1356	15	.	.	.
5180	1356	16	"	"	''
5180	1357	1	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1357	2	,	,	,
5180	1357	3	521	521	CD
5180	1357	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1357	5	at	at	IN
5180	1357	6	885	885	CD
5180	1357	7	.	.	.
5180	1358	1	This	this	DT
5180	1358	2	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
5180	1358	3	growth	growth	NN
5180	1358	4	of	of	IN
5180	1358	5	the	the	DT
5180	1358	6	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1358	7	illustrates	illustrate	VBZ
5180	1358	8	the	the	DT
5180	1358	9	extent	extent	NN
5180	1358	10	to	to	TO
5180	1358	11	which	which	WDT
5180	1358	12	the	the	DT
5180	1358	13	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1358	14	promotes	promote	VBZ
5180	1358	15	First	First	NNP
5180	1358	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1358	17	values	value	NNS
5180	1358	18	in	in	IN
5180	1358	19	the	the	DT
5180	1358	20	same	same	JJ
5180	1358	21	way	way	NN
5180	1358	22	that	that	WDT
5180	1358	23	the	the	DT
5180	1358	24	historical	historical	JJ
5180	1358	25	use	use	NN
5180	1358	26	of	of	IN
5180	1358	27	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1358	28	public	public	JJ
5180	1358	29	fora	fora	NN
5180	1358	30	for	for	IN
5180	1358	31	speaking	speaking	NN
5180	1358	32	,	,	,
5180	1358	33	handbilling	handbilling	NN
5180	1358	34	,	,	,
5180	1358	35	and	and	CC
5180	1358	36	protesting	protest	VBG
5180	1358	37	testifies	testifie	NNS
5180	1358	38	to	to	IN
5180	1358	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1358	40	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
5180	1358	41	as	as	IN
5180	1358	42	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
5180	1358	43	for	for	IN
5180	1358	44	free	free	JJ
5180	1358	45	speech	speech	NN
5180	1358	46	.	.	.
5180	1359	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1359	2	.	.	.
5180	1360	1	Martin	Martin	NNP
5180	1360	2	,	,	,
5180	1360	3	319	319	CD
5180	1360	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1360	5	at	at	IN
5180	1360	6	145	145	CD
5180	1360	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1360	8	"	"	``
5180	1360	9	The	the	DT
5180	1360	10	widespread	widespread	JJ
5180	1360	11	use	use	NN
5180	1360	12	of	of	IN
5180	1360	13	this	this	DT
5180	1360	14	method	method	NN
5180	1360	15	of	of	IN
5180	1360	16	communication	communication	NN
5180	1360	17	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1360	18	door	door	NN
5180	1360	19	-	-	HYPH
5180	1360	20	to	to	IN
5180	1360	21	-	-	HYPH
5180	1360	22	door	door	NN
5180	1360	23	distribution	distribution	NN
5180	1360	24	of	of	IN
5180	1360	25	leaflets	leaflet	NNS
5180	1360	26	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1360	27	by	by	IN
5180	1360	28	many	many	JJ
5180	1360	29	groups	group	NNS
5180	1360	30	espousing	espouse	VBG
5180	1360	31	various	various	JJ
5180	1360	32	causes	cause	NNS
5180	1360	33	attests	attest	VBZ
5180	1360	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1360	35	major	major	JJ
5180	1360	36	importance	importance	NN
5180	1360	37	.	.	.
5180	1361	1	")	")	LS
5180	1361	2	;	;	:
5180	1361	3	Schneider	Schneider	NNP
5180	1361	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	1361	5	State	State	NNP
5180	1361	6	,	,	,
5180	1361	7	308	308	CD
5180	1361	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1361	9	147	147	CD
5180	1361	10	,	,	,
5180	1361	11	164	164	CD
5180	1361	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1361	13	1939	1939	CD
5180	1361	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1361	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1361	16	"	"	``
5180	1361	17	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1361	18	P]amphlets	P]amphlets	NNP
5180	1361	19	have	have	VBP
5180	1361	20	proved	prove	VBN
5180	1361	21	most	most	RBS
5180	1361	22	effective	effective	JJ
5180	1361	23	instruments	instrument	NNS
5180	1361	24	in	in	IN
5180	1361	25	the	the	DT
5180	1361	26	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1361	27	of	of	IN
5180	1361	28	opinion	opinion	NN
5180	1361	29	.	.	.
5180	1361	30	"	"	''
5180	1361	31	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1361	32	.	.	.
5180	1362	1	The	the	DT
5180	1362	2	provision	provision	NN
5180	1362	3	of	of	IN
5180	1362	4	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1362	5	access	access	NN
5180	1362	6	in	in	IN
5180	1362	7	public	public	JJ
5180	1362	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1362	9	,	,	,
5180	1362	10	in	in	IN
5180	1362	11	addition	addition	NN
5180	1362	12	to	to	IN
5180	1362	13	sharing	share	VBG
5180	1362	14	the	the	DT
5180	1362	15	speech	speech	NN
5180	1362	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	1362	17	enhancing	enhance	VBG
5180	1362	18	qualities	quality	NNS
5180	1362	19	of	of	IN
5180	1362	20	fora	fora	NNP
5180	1362	21	such	such	JJ
5180	1362	22	as	as	IN
5180	1362	23	streets	street	NNS
5180	1362	24	,	,	,
5180	1362	25	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1362	26	,	,	,
5180	1362	27	and	and	CC
5180	1362	28	parks	park	NNS
5180	1362	29	,	,	,
5180	1362	30	also	also	RB
5180	1362	31	supplies	supply	VBZ
5180	1362	32	many	many	JJ
5180	1362	33	of	of	IN
5180	1362	34	the	the	DT
5180	1362	35	speech	speech	NN
5180	1362	36	-	-	HYPH
5180	1362	37	enhancing	enhance	VBG
5180	1362	38	properties	property	NNS
5180	1362	39	of	of	IN
5180	1362	40	the	the	DT
5180	1362	41	postal	postal	JJ
5180	1362	42	service	service	NN
5180	1362	43	,	,	,
5180	1362	44	which	which	WDT
5180	1362	45	is	be	VBZ
5180	1362	46	open	open	JJ
5180	1362	47	to	to	IN
5180	1362	48	the	the	DT
5180	1362	49	public	public	NN
5180	1362	50	at	at	RB
5180	1362	51	large	large	JJ
5180	1362	52	as	as	IN
5180	1362	53	both	both	DT
5180	1362	54	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1362	55	and	and	CC
5180	1362	56	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	1362	57	of	of	IN
5180	1362	58	information	information	NN
5180	1362	59	,	,	,
5180	1362	60	and	and	CC
5180	1362	61	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	1362	62	a	a	DT
5180	1362	63	relatively	relatively	RB
5180	1362	64	low	low	JJ
5180	1362	65	-	-	HYPH
5180	1362	66	cost	cost	NN
5180	1362	67	means	mean	NNS
5180	1362	68	of	of	IN
5180	1362	69	disseminating	disseminate	VBG
5180	1362	70	information	information	NN
5180	1362	71	to	to	IN
5180	1362	72	a	a	DT
5180	1362	73	geographically	geographically	RB
5180	1362	74	dispersed	disperse	VBN
5180	1362	75	audience	audience	NN
5180	1362	76	.	.	.
5180	1363	1	See	see	VB
5180	1363	2	Lamont	Lamont	NNP
5180	1363	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1363	4	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
5180	1363	5	Gen.	Gen.	NNP
5180	1363	6	,	,	,
5180	1363	7	381	381	CD
5180	1363	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1363	9	301	301	CD
5180	1363	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1363	11	1965	1965	CD
5180	1363	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1363	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1363	14	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
5180	1363	15	a	a	DT
5180	1363	16	content	content	NN
5180	1363	17	-	-	HYPH
5180	1363	18	based	base	VBN
5180	1363	19	prior	prior	JJ
5180	1363	20	restraint	restraint	NN
5180	1363	21	on	on	IN
5180	1363	22	the	the	DT
5180	1363	23	use	use	NN
5180	1363	24	of	of	IN
5180	1363	25	the	the	DT
5180	1363	26	mails	mail	NNS
5180	1363	27	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1363	28	;	;	:
5180	1363	29	see	see	VB
5180	1363	30	also	also	RB
5180	1363	31	Blount	Blount	NNP
5180	1363	32	v.	v.	IN
5180	1363	33	Rizzi	Rizzi	NNP
5180	1363	34	,	,	,
5180	1363	35	400	400	CD
5180	1363	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1363	37	410	410	CD
5180	1363	38	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1363	39	1971	1971	CD
5180	1363	40	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1363	41	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1363	42	same	same	JJ
5180	1363	43	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1363	44	.	.	.
5180	1364	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	1364	2	,	,	,
5180	1364	3	the	the	DT
5180	1364	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1364	5	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1364	6	's	's	POS
5180	1364	7	description	description	NN
5180	1364	8	of	of	IN
5180	1364	9	the	the	DT
5180	1364	10	postal	postal	JJ
5180	1364	11	system	system	NN
5180	1364	12	in	in	IN
5180	1364	13	Lamont	Lamont	NNP
5180	1364	14	seems	seem	VBZ
5180	1364	15	equally	equally	RB
5180	1364	16	apt	apt	JJ
5180	1364	17	as	as	IN
5180	1364	18	a	a	DT
5180	1364	19	description	description	NN
5180	1364	20	of	of	IN
5180	1364	21	the	the	DT
5180	1364	22	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1364	23	today	today	NN
5180	1364	24	:	:	:
5180	1364	25	"	"	``
5180	1364	26	the	the	DT
5180	1364	27	postal	postal	JJ
5180	1364	28	system	system	NN
5180	1364	29	.	.	.
5180	1365	1	.	.	.
5180	1366	1	.	.	.
5180	1367	1	is	be	VBZ
5180	1367	2	now	now	RB
5180	1367	3	the	the	DT
5180	1367	4	main	main	JJ
5180	1367	5	artery	artery	NN
5180	1367	6	through	through	IN
5180	1367	7	which	which	WDT
5180	1367	8	the	the	DT
5180	1367	9	business	business	NN
5180	1367	10	,	,	,
5180	1367	11	social	social	JJ
5180	1367	12	,	,	,
5180	1367	13	and	and	CC
5180	1367	14	personal	personal	JJ
5180	1367	15	affairs	affair	NNS
5180	1367	16	of	of	IN
5180	1367	17	the	the	DT
5180	1367	18	people	people	NNS
5180	1367	19	are	be	VBP
5180	1367	20	conducted	conduct	VBN
5180	1367	21	.	.	.
5180	1368	1	.	.	.
5180	1369	1	.	.	.
5180	1370	1	.	.	.
5180	1370	2	"	"	''
5180	1371	1	381	381	CD
5180	1371	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1371	3	at	at	IN
5180	1371	4	305	305	CD
5180	1371	5	n.3	n.3	NNP
5180	1371	6	.	.	.
5180	1372	1	In	in	IN
5180	1372	2	short	short	JJ
5180	1372	3	,	,	,
5180	1372	4	public	public	JJ
5180	1372	5	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1372	6	,	,	,
5180	1372	7	by	by	IN
5180	1372	8	providing	provide	VBG
5180	1372	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1372	10	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1372	11	with	with	IN
5180	1372	12	access	access	NN
5180	1372	13	to	to	IN
5180	1372	14	the	the	DT
5180	1372	15	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1372	16	,	,	,
5180	1372	17	have	have	VBP
5180	1372	18	created	create	VBN
5180	1372	19	a	a	DT
5180	1372	20	public	public	JJ
5180	1372	21	forum	forum	NN
5180	1372	22	that	that	WDT
5180	1372	23	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	1372	24	any	any	DT
5180	1372	25	member	member	NN
5180	1372	26	of	of	IN
5180	1372	27	the	the	DT
5180	1372	28	public	public	JJ
5180	1372	29	free	free	JJ
5180	1372	30	access	access	NN
5180	1372	31	to	to	IN
5180	1372	32	information	information	NN
5180	1372	33	from	from	IN
5180	1372	34	millions	million	NNS
5180	1372	35	of	of	IN
5180	1372	36	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1372	37	around	around	IN
5180	1372	38	the	the	DT
5180	1372	39	world	world	NN
5180	1372	40	.	.	.
5180	1373	1	The	the	DT
5180	1373	2	unique	unique	JJ
5180	1373	3	speech	speech	NN
5180	1373	4	-	-	HYPH
5180	1373	5	enhancing	enhance	VBG
5180	1373	6	character	character	NN
5180	1373	7	of	of	IN
5180	1373	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1373	9	use	use	NN
5180	1373	10	in	in	IN
5180	1373	11	public	public	JJ
5180	1373	12	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1373	13	derives	derive	VBZ
5180	1373	14	from	from	IN
5180	1373	15	the	the	DT
5180	1373	16	openness	openness	NN
5180	1373	17	of	of	IN
5180	1373	18	the	the	DT
5180	1373	19	public	public	JJ
5180	1373	20	library	library	NN
5180	1373	21	to	to	IN
5180	1373	22	any	any	DT
5180	1373	23	member	member	NN
5180	1373	24	of	of	IN
5180	1373	25	the	the	DT
5180	1373	26	public	public	NN
5180	1373	27	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	1373	28	to	to	TO
5180	1373	29	receive	receive	VB
5180	1373	30	information	information	NN
5180	1373	31	,	,	,
5180	1373	32	and	and	CC
5180	1373	33	the	the	DT
5180	1373	34	openness	openness	NN
5180	1373	35	of	of	IN
5180	1373	36	the	the	DT
5180	1373	37	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1373	38	to	to	IN
5180	1373	39	any	any	DT
5180	1373	40	member	member	NN
5180	1373	41	of	of	IN
5180	1373	42	the	the	DT
5180	1373	43	public	public	NN
5180	1373	44	who	who	WP
5180	1373	45	wishes	wish	VBZ
5180	1373	46	to	to	TO
5180	1373	47	speak	speak	VB
5180	1373	48	.	.	.
5180	1374	1	In	in	IN
5180	1374	2	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1374	3	,	,	,
5180	1374	4	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1374	5	on	on	IN
5180	1374	6	the	the	DT
5180	1374	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1374	8	enjoy	enjoy	VBP
5180	1374	9	low	low	JJ
5180	1374	10	barriers	barrier	NNS
5180	1374	11	to	to	IN
5180	1374	12	entry	entry	NN
5180	1374	13	and	and	CC
5180	1374	14	the	the	DT
5180	1374	15	ability	ability	NN
5180	1374	16	to	to	TO
5180	1374	17	reach	reach	VB
5180	1374	18	a	a	DT
5180	1374	19	mass	mass	NN
5180	1374	20	audience	audience	NN
5180	1374	21	,	,	,
5180	1374	22	unhindered	unhindered	JJ
5180	1374	23	by	by	IN
5180	1374	24	the	the	DT
5180	1374	25	constraints	constraint	NNS
5180	1374	26	of	of	IN
5180	1374	27	geography	geography	NN
5180	1374	28	.	.	.
5180	1375	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	1375	2	,	,	,
5180	1375	3	just	just	RB
5180	1375	4	as	as	IN
5180	1375	5	the	the	DT
5180	1375	6	development	development	NN
5180	1375	7	of	of	IN
5180	1375	8	new	new	JJ
5180	1375	9	media	medium	NNS
5180	1375	10	"	"	''
5180	1375	11	presents	present	VBZ
5180	1375	12	unique	unique	JJ
5180	1375	13	problems	problem	NNS
5180	1375	14	,	,	,
5180	1375	15	which	which	WDT
5180	1375	16	inform	inform	VBP
5180	1375	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1375	18	assessment	assessment	NN
5180	1375	19	of	of	IN
5180	1375	20	the	the	DT
5180	1375	21	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1375	22	at	at	IN
5180	1375	23	stake	stake	NN
5180	1375	24	,	,	,
5180	1375	25	and	and	CC
5180	1375	26	which	which	WDT
5180	1375	27	may	may	MD
5180	1375	28	justify	justify	VB
5180	1375	29	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1375	30	that	that	WDT
5180	1375	31	would	would	MD
5180	1375	32	be	be	VB
5180	1375	33	unacceptable	unacceptable	JJ
5180	1375	34	in	in	IN
5180	1375	35	other	other	JJ
5180	1375	36	contexts	contexts	NN
5180	1375	37	,	,	,
5180	1375	38	"	"	''
5180	1375	39	United	United	NNP
5180	1375	40	States	States	NNP
5180	1375	41	v.	v.	IN
5180	1375	42	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1375	43	Entm't	Entm't	NNP
5180	1375	44	Group	Group	NNP
5180	1375	45	,	,	,
5180	1375	46	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1375	47	,	,	,
5180	1375	48	529	529	CD
5180	1375	49	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1375	50	803	803	CD
5180	1375	51	,	,	,
5180	1375	52	813	813	CD
5180	1375	53	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1375	54	2000	2000	CD
5180	1375	55	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1375	56	,	,	,
5180	1375	57	the	the	DT
5180	1375	58	development	development	NN
5180	1375	59	of	of	IN
5180	1375	60	new	new	JJ
5180	1375	61	media	medium	NNS
5180	1375	62	,	,	,
5180	1375	63	such	such	JJ
5180	1375	64	as	as	IN
5180	1375	65	the	the	DT
5180	1375	66	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1375	67	,	,	,
5180	1375	68	also	also	RB
5180	1375	69	presents	present	VBZ
5180	1375	70	unique	unique	JJ
5180	1375	71	possibilities	possibility	NNS
5180	1375	72	for	for	IN
5180	1375	73	promoting	promote	VBG
5180	1375	74	First	First	NNP
5180	1375	75	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1375	76	values	value	NNS
5180	1375	77	,	,	,
5180	1375	78	which	which	WDT
5180	1375	79	also	also	RB
5180	1375	80	inform	inform	VBP
5180	1375	81	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1375	82	assessment	assessment	NN
5180	1375	83	of	of	IN
5180	1375	84	the	the	DT
5180	1375	85	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1375	86	at	at	IN
5180	1375	87	stake	stake	NN
5180	1375	88	,	,	,
5180	1375	89	and	and	CC
5180	1375	90	which	which	WDT
5180	1375	91	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1375	92	believe	believe	VBP
5180	1375	93	,	,	,
5180	1375	94	in	in	IN
5180	1375	95	the	the	DT
5180	1375	96	context	context	NN
5180	1375	97	of	of	IN
5180	1375	98	the	the	DT
5180	1375	99	provision	provision	NN
5180	1375	100	of	of	IN
5180	1375	101	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1375	102	access	access	NN
5180	1375	103	in	in	IN
5180	1375	104	public	public	JJ
5180	1375	105	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1375	106	,	,	,
5180	1375	107	justify	justify	VB
5180	1375	108	the	the	DT
5180	1375	109	application	application	NN
5180	1375	110	of	of	IN
5180	1375	111	heightened	heighten	VBN
5180	1375	112	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1375	113	to	to	IN
5180	1375	114	content	content	NN
5180	1375	115	-	-	HYPH
5180	1375	116	based	base	VBN
5180	1375	117	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1375	118	that	that	WDT
5180	1375	119	might	may	MD
5180	1375	120	be	be	VB
5180	1375	121	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1375	122	to	to	IN
5180	1375	123	only	only	JJ
5180	1375	124	rational	rational	JJ
5180	1375	125	review	review	NN
5180	1375	126	in	in	IN
5180	1375	127	other	other	JJ
5180	1375	128	contexts	contexts	NN
5180	1375	129	,	,	,
5180	1375	130	such	such	JJ
5180	1375	131	as	as	IN
5180	1375	132	the	the	DT
5180	1375	133	development	development	NN
5180	1375	134	of	of	IN
5180	1375	135	the	the	DT
5180	1375	136	library	library	NN
5180	1375	137	's	's	POS
5180	1375	138	print	print	NN
5180	1375	139	collection	collection	NN
5180	1375	140	.	.	.
5180	1376	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1376	2	.	.	.
5180	1377	1	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1377	2	d	d	VBD
5180	1377	3	.	.	.
5180	1378	1	at	at	IN
5180	1378	2	818	818	CD
5180	1378	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1378	4	"	"	``
5180	1378	5	Technology	technology	NN
5180	1378	6	expands	expand	VBZ
5180	1378	7	the	the	DT
5180	1378	8	capacity	capacity	NN
5180	1378	9	to	to	TO
5180	1378	10	choose	choose	VB
5180	1378	11	;	;	:
5180	1378	12	and	and	CC
5180	1378	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1378	14	denies	deny	VBZ
5180	1378	15	the	the	DT
5180	1378	16	potential	potential	NN
5180	1378	17	of	of	IN
5180	1378	18	this	this	DT
5180	1378	19	revolution	revolution	NN
5180	1378	20	if	if	IN
5180	1378	21	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1378	22	assume	assume	VBP
5180	1378	23	the	the	DT
5180	1378	24	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1378	25	is	be	VBZ
5180	1378	26	best	well	RBS
5180	1378	27	positioned	position	VBN
5180	1378	28	to	to	TO
5180	1378	29	make	make	VB
5180	1378	30	these	these	DT
5180	1378	31	choices	choice	NNS
5180	1378	32	for	for	IN
5180	1378	33	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1378	34	.	.	.
5180	1378	35	"	"	''
5180	1378	36	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1378	37	.	.	.
5180	1379	1	A	a	DT
5180	1379	2	faithful	faithful	JJ
5180	1379	3	translation	translation	NN
5180	1379	4	of	of	IN
5180	1379	5	First	First	NNP
5180	1379	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1379	7	values	value	NNS
5180	1379	8	from	from	IN
5180	1379	9	the	the	DT
5180	1379	10	context	context	NN
5180	1379	11	of	of	IN
5180	1379	12	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1379	13	public	public	JJ
5180	1379	14	fora	fora	NN
5180	1379	15	such	such	JJ
5180	1379	16	as	as	IN
5180	1379	17	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1379	18	and	and	CC
5180	1379	19	parks	park	NNS
5180	1379	20	to	to	IN
5180	1379	21	the	the	DT
5180	1379	22	distinctly	distinctly	RB
5180	1379	23	non	non	JJ
5180	1379	24	-	-	JJ
5180	1379	25	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1379	26	public	public	JJ
5180	1379	27	forum	forum	NN
5180	1379	28	of	of	IN
5180	1379	29	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1379	30	access	access	NN
5180	1379	31	in	in	IN
5180	1379	32	public	public	JJ
5180	1379	33	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1379	34	requires	require	VBZ
5180	1379	35	,	,	,
5180	1379	36	in	in	IN
5180	1379	37	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1379	38	view	view	NN
5180	1379	39	,	,	,
5180	1379	40	that	that	IN
5180	1379	41	content	content	NN
5180	1379	42	-	-	HYPH
5180	1379	43	based	base	VBN
5180	1379	44	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1379	45	on	on	IN
5180	1379	46	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1379	47	access	access	NN
5180	1379	48	in	in	IN
5180	1379	49	public	public	JJ
5180	1379	50	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1379	51	be	be	VB
5180	1379	52	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1379	53	to	to	IN
5180	1379	54	the	the	DT
5180	1379	55	same	same	JJ
5180	1379	56	exacting	exacting	NN
5180	1379	57	standards	standard	NNS
5180	1379	58	of	of	IN
5180	1379	59	First	First	NNP
5180	1379	60	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1379	61	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1379	62	as	as	IN
5180	1379	63	content	content	NN
5180	1379	64	-	-	HYPH
5180	1379	65	based	base	VBN
5180	1379	66	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1379	67	on	on	IN
5180	1379	68	speech	speech	NN
5180	1379	69	in	in	IN
5180	1379	70	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1379	71	public	public	JJ
5180	1379	72	fora	fora	NN
5180	1379	73	such	such	JJ
5180	1379	74	as	as	IN
5180	1379	75	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1379	76	,	,	,
5180	1379	77	town	town	NN
5180	1379	78	squares	square	NNS
5180	1379	79	,	,	,
5180	1379	80	and	and	CC
5180	1379	81	parks	park	NNS
5180	1379	82	:	:	:
5180	1379	83	The	the	DT
5180	1379	84	architecture	architecture	NN
5180	1379	85	of	of	IN
5180	1379	86	the	the	DT
5180	1379	87	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1379	88	,	,	,
5180	1379	89	as	as	IN
5180	1379	90	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1379	91	is	be	VBZ
5180	1379	92	right	right	RB
5180	1379	93	now	now	RB
5180	1379	94	,	,	,
5180	1379	95	is	be	VBZ
5180	1379	96	perhaps	perhaps	RB
5180	1379	97	the	the	DT
5180	1379	98	most	most	RBS
5180	1379	99	important	important	JJ
5180	1379	100	model	model	NN
5180	1379	101	of	of	IN
5180	1379	102	free	free	JJ
5180	1379	103	speech	speech	NN
5180	1379	104	since	since	IN
5180	1379	105	the	the	DT
5180	1379	106	founding	founding	NN
5180	1379	107	.	.	.
5180	1380	1	.	.	.
5180	1381	1	.	.	.
5180	1382	1	.	.	.
5180	1383	1	Two	two	CD
5180	1383	2	hundred	hundred	CD
5180	1383	3	years	year	NNS
5180	1383	4	after	after	IN
5180	1383	5	the	the	DT
5180	1383	6	framers	framer	NNS
5180	1383	7	ratified	ratify	VBD
5180	1383	8	the	the	DT
5180	1383	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
5180	1383	10	,	,	,
5180	1383	11	the	the	DT
5180	1383	12	Net	net	NN
5180	1383	13	has	have	VBZ
5180	1383	14	taught	teach	VBN
5180	1383	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1383	16	what	what	WP
5180	1383	17	the	the	DT
5180	1383	18	First	First	NNP
5180	1383	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1383	20	means	mean	VBZ
5180	1383	21	.	.	.
5180	1384	1	.	.	.
5180	1385	1	.	.	.
5180	1386	1	.	.	.
5180	1387	1	The	the	DT
5180	1387	2	model	model	NN
5180	1387	3	for	for	IN
5180	1387	4	speech	speech	NN
5180	1387	5	that	that	WDT
5180	1387	6	the	the	DT
5180	1387	7	framers	framer	NNS
5180	1387	8	embraced	embrace	VBD
5180	1387	9	was	be	VBD
5180	1387	10	the	the	DT
5180	1387	11	model	model	NN
5180	1387	12	of	of	IN
5180	1387	13	the	the	DT
5180	1387	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1387	15	–	–	:
5180	1387	16	distributed	distribute	VBN
5180	1387	17	,	,	,
5180	1387	18	noncentralized	noncentralize	VBN
5180	1387	19	,	,	,
5180	1387	20	fully	fully	RB
5180	1387	21	free	free	JJ
5180	1387	22	and	and	CC
5180	1387	23	diverse	diverse	JJ
5180	1387	24	.	.	.
5180	1388	1	Lessig	Lessig	NNP
5180	1388	2	,	,	,
5180	1388	3	Code	Code	NNP
5180	1388	4	,	,	,
5180	1388	5	at	at	IN
5180	1388	6	167	167	CD
5180	1388	7	,	,	,
5180	1388	8	185	185	CD
5180	1388	9	.	.	.
5180	1389	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	1389	2	,	,	,
5180	1389	3	"	"	''
5180	1389	4	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1389	5	m]inds	m]ind	NNS
5180	1389	6	are	be	VBP
5180	1389	7	not	not	RB
5180	1389	8	changed	change	VBN
5180	1389	9	in	in	IN
5180	1389	10	streets	street	NNS
5180	1389	11	and	and	CC
5180	1389	12	parks	park	NNS
5180	1389	13	as	as	IN
5180	1389	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1389	15	once	once	RB
5180	1389	16	were	be	VBD
5180	1389	17	.	.	.
5180	1390	1	To	to	IN
5180	1390	2	an	an	DT
5180	1390	3	increasing	increase	VBG
5180	1390	4	degree	degree	NN
5180	1390	5	,	,	,
5180	1390	6	the	the	DT
5180	1390	7	more	more	RBR
5180	1390	8	significant	significant	JJ
5180	1390	9	interchanges	interchange	NNS
5180	1390	10	of	of	IN
5180	1390	11	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	1390	12	and	and	CC
5180	1390	13	shaping	shaping	NN
5180	1390	14	of	of	IN
5180	1390	15	public	public	JJ
5180	1390	16	consciousness	consciousness	NN
5180	1390	17	occur	occur	VBP
5180	1390	18	in	in	IN
5180	1390	19	mass	mass	JJ
5180	1390	20	and	and	CC
5180	1390	21	electronic	electronic	JJ
5180	1390	22	media	medium	NNS
5180	1390	23	.	.	.
5180	1390	24	"	"	''
5180	1391	1	Denver	Denver	NNP
5180	1391	2	Area	Area	NNP
5180	1391	3	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	1391	4	.	.	.
5180	1392	1	Telecomms	Telecomms	NNP
5180	1392	2	.	.	.
5180	1393	1	Consortium	Consortium	NNP
5180	1393	2	,	,	,
5180	1393	3	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1393	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	1393	5	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	1393	6	,	,	,
5180	1393	7	518	518	CD
5180	1393	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1393	9	727	727	CD
5180	1393	10	,	,	,
5180	1393	11	802	802	CD
5180	1393	12	-	-	HYPH
5180	1393	13	03	03	CD
5180	1393	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1393	15	1996	1996	CD
5180	1393	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1393	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1393	18	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
5180	1393	19	,	,	,
5180	1393	20	J.	J.	NNP
5180	1393	21	,	,	,
5180	1393	22	concurring	concur	VBG
5180	1393	23	in	in	IN
5180	1393	24	the	the	DT
5180	1393	25	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1393	26	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1393	27	.	.	.
5180	1394	1	In	in	IN
5180	1394	2	providing	provide	VBG
5180	1394	3	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1394	4	with	with	IN
5180	1394	5	even	even	RB
5180	1394	6	filtered	filter	VBN
5180	1394	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1394	8	access	access	NN
5180	1394	9	,	,	,
5180	1394	10	a	a	DT
5180	1394	11	public	public	JJ
5180	1394	12	library	library	NN
5180	1394	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	1394	14	not	not	RB
5180	1394	15	exercising	exercise	VBG
5180	1394	16	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	1394	17	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1394	18	in	in	IN
5180	1394	19	selecting	select	VBG
5180	1394	20	only	only	JJ
5180	1394	21	speech	speech	NN
5180	1394	22	of	of	IN
5180	1394	23	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1394	24	quality	quality	NN
5180	1394	25	for	for	IN
5180	1394	26	inclusion	inclusion	NN
5180	1394	27	in	in	IN
5180	1394	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1394	29	collection	collection	NN
5180	1394	30	,	,	,
5180	1394	31	as	as	IN
5180	1394	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1394	33	may	may	MD
5180	1394	34	do	do	VB
5180	1394	35	when	when	WRB
5180	1394	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1394	37	decides	decide	VBZ
5180	1394	38	to	to	TO
5180	1394	39	acquire	acquire	VB
5180	1394	40	print	print	NN
5180	1394	41	materials	material	NNS
5180	1394	42	.	.	.
5180	1395	1	By	by	IN
5180	1395	2	providing	provide	VBG
5180	1395	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1395	4	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1395	5	with	with	IN
5180	1395	6	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1395	7	access	access	NN
5180	1395	8	,	,	,
5180	1395	9	public	public	JJ
5180	1395	10	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1395	11	create	create	VBP
5180	1395	12	a	a	DT
5180	1395	13	forum	forum	NN
5180	1395	14	in	in	IN
5180	1395	15	which	which	WDT
5180	1395	16	any	any	DT
5180	1395	17	member	member	NN
5180	1395	18	of	of	IN
5180	1395	19	the	the	DT
5180	1395	20	public	public	NN
5180	1395	21	may	may	MD
5180	1395	22	receive	receive	VB
5180	1395	23	speech	speech	NN
5180	1395	24	from	from	IN
5180	1395	25	anyone	anyone	NN
5180	1395	26	around	around	IN
5180	1395	27	the	the	DT
5180	1395	28	world	world	NN
5180	1395	29	who	who	WP
5180	1395	30	wishes	wish	VBZ
5180	1395	31	to	to	TO
5180	1395	32	disseminate	disseminate	VB
5180	1395	33	information	information	NN
5180	1395	34	over	over	IN
5180	1395	35	the	the	DT
5180	1395	36	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1395	37	.	.	.
5180	1396	1	Within	within	IN
5180	1396	2	this	this	DT
5180	1396	3	"	"	``
5180	1396	4	vast	vast	JJ
5180	1396	5	democratic	democratic	JJ
5180	1396	6	forum	forum	NN
5180	1396	7	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1396	8	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1396	9	,	,	,
5180	1396	10	"	"	``
5180	1396	11	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1396	12	,	,	,
5180	1396	13	521	521	CD
5180	1396	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1396	15	at	at	IN
5180	1396	16	868	868	CD
5180	1396	17	,	,	,
5180	1396	18	which	which	WDT
5180	1396	19	facilitates	facilitate	VBZ
5180	1396	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	1396	21	that	that	WDT
5180	1396	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	1396	23	"	"	``
5180	1396	24	as	as	RB
5180	1396	25	diverse	diverse	JJ
5180	1396	26	as	as	IN
5180	1396	27	human	human	JJ
5180	1396	28	thought	thought	NN
5180	1396	29	,	,	,
5180	1396	30	"	"	''
5180	1396	31	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1396	32	d	d	VBN
5180	1396	33	.	.	.
5180	1397	1	at	at	IN
5180	1397	2	870	870	CD
5180	1397	3	,	,	,
5180	1397	4	software	software	NN
5180	1397	5	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1397	6	single	single	JJ
5180	1397	7	out	out	RP
5180	1397	8	for	for	IN
5180	1397	9	exclusion	exclusion	NN
5180	1397	10	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1397	11	speech	speech	NN
5180	1397	12	on	on	IN
5180	1397	13	the	the	DT
5180	1397	14	basis	basis	NN
5180	1397	15	of	of	IN
5180	1397	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1397	17	disfavored	disfavor	VBN
5180	1397	18	content	content	NN
5180	1397	19	.	.	.
5180	1398	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1398	2	hold	hold	VBP
5180	1398	3	that	that	IN
5180	1398	4	these	these	DT
5180	1398	5	content-	content-	XX
5180	1398	6	based	base	VBN
5180	1398	7	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1398	8	on	on	IN
5180	1398	9	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1398	10	'	'	POS
5180	1398	11	access	access	NN
5180	1398	12	to	to	IN
5180	1398	13	speech	speech	NN
5180	1398	14	are	be	VBP
5180	1398	15	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1398	16	to	to	IN
5180	1398	17	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1398	18	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1398	19	.	.	.
5180	1399	1	4	4	LS
5180	1399	2	.	.	.
5180	1400	1	Application	application	NN
5180	1400	2	of	of	IN
5180	1400	3	Strict	Strict	NNP
5180	1400	4	Scrutiny	Scrutiny	NNP
5180	1400	5	Having	have	VBG
5180	1400	6	concluded	conclude	VBD
5180	1400	7	that	that	IN
5180	1400	8	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1400	9	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1400	10	applies	apply	VBZ
5180	1400	11	to	to	IN
5180	1400	12	public	public	JJ
5180	1400	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1400	14	'	'	POS
5180	1400	15	content	content	NN
5180	1400	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	1400	17	based	base	VBN
5180	1400	18	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1400	19	on	on	IN
5180	1400	20	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1400	21	'	'	POS
5180	1400	22	access	access	NN
5180	1400	23	to	to	IN
5180	1400	24	speech	speech	NN
5180	1400	25	on	on	IN
5180	1400	26	the	the	DT
5180	1400	27	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1400	28	,	,	,
5180	1400	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1400	30	must	must	MD
5180	1400	31	next	next	RB
5180	1400	32	determine	determine	VB
5180	1400	33	whether	whether	IN
5180	1400	34	a	a	DT
5180	1400	35	public	public	JJ
5180	1400	36	library	library	NN
5180	1400	37	's	's	POS
5180	1400	38	use	use	NN
5180	1400	39	of	of	IN
5180	1400	40	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1400	41	software	software	NN
5180	1400	42	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1400	43	can	can	MD
5180	1400	44	survive	survive	VB
5180	1400	45	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1400	46	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1400	47	.	.	.
5180	1401	1	To	to	TO
5180	1401	2	survive	survive	VB
5180	1401	3	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1401	4	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1401	5	,	,	,
5180	1401	6	a	a	DT
5180	1401	7	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1401	8	on	on	IN
5180	1401	9	speech	speech	NN
5180	1401	10	"	"	''
5180	1401	11	must	must	MD
5180	1401	12	be	be	VB
5180	1401	13	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1401	14	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1401	15	to	to	TO
5180	1401	16	promote	promote	VB
5180	1401	17	a	a	DT
5180	1401	18	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1401	19	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1401	20	interest	interest	NN
5180	1401	21	.	.	.
5180	1402	1	If	if	IN
5180	1402	2	a	a	DT
5180	1402	3	less	less	RBR
5180	1402	4	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1402	5	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1402	6	would	would	MD
5180	1402	7	serve	serve	VB
5180	1402	8	the	the	DT
5180	1402	9	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1402	10	's	's	POS
5180	1402	11	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1402	12	,	,	,
5180	1402	13	the	the	DT
5180	1402	14	legislature	legislature	NN
5180	1402	15	must	must	MD
5180	1402	16	use	use	VB
5180	1402	17	that	that	DT
5180	1402	18	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1402	19	.	.	.
5180	1402	20	"	"	''
5180	1403	1	United	United	NNP
5180	1403	2	States	States	NNP
5180	1403	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1403	4	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1403	5	Entm't	Entm't	NNP
5180	1403	6	Group	Group	NNP
5180	1403	7	,	,	,
5180	1403	8	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1403	9	,	,	,
5180	1403	10	529	529	CD
5180	1403	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1403	12	803	803	CD
5180	1403	13	,	,	,
5180	1403	14	813	813	CD
5180	1403	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1403	16	2000	2000	CD
5180	1403	17	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1403	18	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1403	19	citation	citation	NN
5180	1403	20	omitted	omit	VBN
5180	1403	21	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1403	22	;	;	:
5180	1403	23	see	see	VB
5180	1403	24	also	also	RB
5180	1403	25	Fabulous	Fabulous	NNP
5180	1403	26	Assocs	Assocs	NNP
5180	1403	27	.	.	.
5180	1403	28	,	,	,
5180	1403	29	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1403	30	v.	v.	CC
5180	1403	31	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
5180	1403	32	Pub	Pub	NNP
5180	1403	33	.	.	.
5180	1404	1	Util	util	IN
5180	1404	2	.	.	.
5180	1405	1	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
5180	1405	2	,	,	,
5180	1405	3	896	896	CD
5180	1405	4	F.2d	F.2d	NNP
5180	1405	5	780	780	CD
5180	1405	6	,	,	,
5180	1405	7	787	787	CD
5180	1405	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1405	9	3d	3d	NNP
5180	1405	10	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	1405	11	.	.	.
5180	1406	1	1990	1990	CD
5180	1406	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1406	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1406	4	holding	hold	VBG
5180	1406	5	that	that	IN
5180	1406	6	a	a	DT
5180	1406	7	content	content	NN
5180	1406	8	-	-	HYPH
5180	1406	9	based	base	VBN
5180	1406	10	burden	burden	NN
5180	1406	11	on	on	IN
5180	1406	12	speech	speech	NN
5180	1406	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	1406	14	permissible	permissible	JJ
5180	1406	15	"	"	``
5180	1406	16	only	only	RB
5180	1406	17	if	if	IN
5180	1406	18	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1406	19	the	the	DT
5180	1406	20	government	government	NN
5180	1406	21	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1406	22	shows	show	VBZ
5180	1406	23	that	that	IN
5180	1406	24	the	the	DT
5180	1406	25	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1406	26	serves	serve	VBZ
5180	1406	27	a	a	DT
5180	1406	28	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1406	29	interest	interest	NN
5180	1406	30	and	and	CC
5180	1406	31	that	that	IN
5180	1406	32	there	there	EX
5180	1406	33	are	be	VBP
5180	1406	34	no	no	DT
5180	1406	35	less	less	RBR
5180	1406	36	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1406	37	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1406	38	"	"	''
5180	1406	39	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1406	40	.	.	.
5180	1407	1	The	the	DT
5180	1407	2	application	application	NN
5180	1407	3	of	of	IN
5180	1407	4	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1407	5	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1407	6	to	to	IN
5180	1407	7	a	a	DT
5180	1407	8	public	public	JJ
5180	1407	9	library	library	NN
5180	1407	10	's	's	POS
5180	1407	11	use	use	NN
5180	1407	12	of	of	IN
5180	1407	13	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	1407	14	products	product	NNS
5180	1407	15	thus	thus	RB
5180	1407	16	requires	require	VBZ
5180	1407	17	three	three	CD
5180	1407	18	distinct	distinct	JJ
5180	1407	19	inquiries	inquiry	NNS
5180	1407	20	.	.	.
5180	1408	1	First	first	RB
5180	1408	2	,	,	,
5180	1408	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1408	4	must	must	MD
5180	1408	5	identify	identify	VB
5180	1408	6	those	those	DT
5180	1408	7	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1408	8	government	government	NN
5180	1408	9	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1408	10	that	that	IN
5180	1408	11	the	the	DT
5180	1408	12	use	use	NN
5180	1408	13	of	of	IN
5180	1408	14	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1408	15	software	software	NN
5180	1408	16	promotes	promote	NNS
5180	1408	17	.	.	.
5180	1409	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1409	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	1409	3	then	then	RB
5180	1409	4	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	1409	5	to	to	TO
5180	1409	6	analyze	analyze	VB
5180	1409	7	whether	whether	IN
5180	1409	8	the	the	DT
5180	1409	9	use	use	NN
5180	1409	10	of	of	IN
5180	1409	11	software	software	NN
5180	1409	12	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1409	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	1409	14	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1409	15	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1409	16	to	to	TO
5180	1409	17	further	further	RB
5180	1409	18	those	those	DT
5180	1409	19	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1409	20	.	.	.
5180	1410	1	Finally	finally	RB
5180	1410	2	,	,	,
5180	1410	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1410	4	must	must	MD
5180	1410	5	determine	determine	VB
5180	1410	6	whether	whether	IN
5180	1410	7	less	less	JJR
5180	1410	8	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1410	9	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1410	10	exist	exist	VBP
5180	1410	11	that	that	WDT
5180	1410	12	would	would	MD
5180	1410	13	promote	promote	VB
5180	1410	14	the	the	DT
5180	1410	15	state	state	NN
5180	1410	16	interest	interest	NN
5180	1410	17	.	.	.
5180	1411	1	1	1	LS
5180	1411	2	.	.	.
5180	1412	1	State	state	NN
5180	1412	2	Interests	interest	NNS
5180	1412	3	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1412	4	begin	begin	VBP
5180	1412	5	by	by	IN
5180	1412	6	identifying	identify	VBG
5180	1412	7	those	those	DT
5180	1412	8	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1412	9	state	state	NN
5180	1412	10	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1412	11	that	that	WDT
5180	1412	12	a	a	DT
5180	1412	13	public	public	JJ
5180	1412	14	library	library	NN
5180	1412	15	's	's	POS
5180	1412	16	use	use	NN
5180	1412	17	of	of	IN
5180	1412	18	software	software	NN
5180	1412	19	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1412	20	promotes	promote	VBZ
5180	1412	21	.	.	.
5180	1413	1	1	1	LS
5180	1413	2	.	.	.
5180	1414	1	Preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1414	2	the	the	DT
5180	1414	3	Dissemination	Dissemination	NNP
5180	1414	4	of	of	IN
5180	1414	5	Obscenity	Obscenity	NNP
5180	1414	6	,	,	,
5180	1414	7	Child	Child	NNP
5180	1414	8	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	1414	9	,	,	,
5180	1414	10	and	and	CC
5180	1414	11	Material	Material	NNP
5180	1414	12	Harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1414	13	to	to	IN
5180	1414	14	Minors	minor	NNS
5180	1414	15	On	on	IN
5180	1414	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1414	17	face	face	NN
5180	1414	18	,	,	,
5180	1414	19	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1414	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	1414	21	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	1414	22	intended	intend	VBN
5180	1414	23	to	to	TO
5180	1414	24	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	1414	25	public	public	JJ
5180	1414	26	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1414	27	'	'	POS
5180	1414	28	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1414	29	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1414	30	from	from	IN
5180	1414	31	being	be	VBG
5180	1414	32	used	use	VBN
5180	1414	33	to	to	TO
5180	1414	34	disseminate	disseminate	VB
5180	1414	35	to	to	IN
5180	1414	36	library	library	NN
5180	1414	37	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1414	38	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1414	39	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	1414	40	that	that	WDT
5180	1414	41	are	be	VBP
5180	1414	42	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1414	43	,	,	,
5180	1414	44	child	child	NN
5180	1414	45	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1414	46	,	,	,
5180	1414	47	or	or	CC
5180	1414	48	in	in	IN
5180	1414	49	the	the	DT
5180	1414	50	case	case	NN
5180	1414	51	of	of	IN
5180	1414	52	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1414	53	,	,	,
5180	1414	54	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1414	55	to	to	IN
5180	1414	56	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1414	57	.	.	.
5180	1415	1	See	see	VB
5180	1415	2	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1415	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1415	4	.	.	.
5180	1416	1	1712	1712	CD
5180	1416	2	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1416	3	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1416	4	at	at	IN
5180	1416	5	20	20	CD
5180	1416	6	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1417	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1417	2	.	.	.
5180	1418	1	9134(f)(1)(A	9134(f)(1)(A	NNP
5180	1418	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1418	3	&	&	CC
5180	1418	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1418	5	B	B	NNP
5180	1418	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1418	7	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1418	8	,	,	,
5180	1418	9	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1418	10	.	.	.
5180	1419	1	1721(b	1721(b	LS
5180	1419	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1419	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1419	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1419	5	at	at	IN
5180	1419	6	47	47	CD
5180	1419	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	1420	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1420	2	.	.	.
5180	1421	1	254(h)(6)(B	254(h)(6)(b	LS
5180	1421	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1421	3	&	&	CC
5180	1421	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1421	5	C	C	NNP
5180	1421	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1421	7	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1421	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1421	9	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1421	10	any	any	DT
5180	1421	11	library	library	NN
5180	1421	12	that	that	WDT
5180	1421	13	receives	receive	VBZ
5180	1421	14	E	e	NN
5180	1421	15	-	-	NN
5180	1421	16	rate	rate	NN
5180	1421	17	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	1421	18	to	to	TO
5180	1421	19	certify	certify	VB
5180	1421	20	that	that	IN
5180	1421	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1421	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	1421	23	enforcing	enforce	VBG
5180	1421	24	"	"	``
5180	1421	25	a	a	DT
5180	1421	26	policy	policy	NN
5180	1421	27	of	of	IN
5180	1421	28	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1421	29	safety	safety	NN
5180	1421	30	that	that	WDT
5180	1421	31	includes	include	VBZ
5180	1421	32	the	the	DT
5180	1421	33	operation	operation	NN
5180	1421	34	of	of	IN
5180	1421	35	a	a	DT
5180	1421	36	technology	technology	NN
5180	1421	37	protection	protection	NN
5180	1421	38	measure	measure	NN
5180	1421	39	with	with	IN
5180	1421	40	respect	respect	NN
5180	1421	41	to	to	IN
5180	1421	42	any	any	DT
5180	1421	43	of	of	IN
5180	1421	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1421	45	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1421	46	with	with	IN
5180	1421	47	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1421	48	access	access	NN
5180	1421	49	that	that	WDT
5180	1421	50	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	1421	51	against	against	IN
5180	1421	52	access	access	NN
5180	1421	53	through	through	IN
5180	1421	54	such	such	JJ
5180	1421	55	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1421	56	to	to	IN
5180	1421	57	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1421	58	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	1421	59	"	"	''
5180	1421	60	that	that	WDT
5180	1421	61	are	be	VBP
5180	1421	62	"	"	``
5180	1421	63	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1421	64	"	"	''
5180	1421	65	or	or	CC
5180	1421	66	"	"	``
5180	1421	67	child	child	NN
5180	1421	68	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1421	69	,	,	,
5180	1421	70	"	"	''
5180	1421	71	and	and	CC
5180	1421	72	,	,	,
5180	1421	73	when	when	WRB
5180	1421	74	the	the	DT
5180	1421	75	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1421	76	are	be	VBP
5180	1421	77	in	in	IN
5180	1421	78	use	use	NN
5180	1421	79	by	by	IN
5180	1421	80	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1421	81	,	,	,
5180	1421	82	also	also	RB
5180	1421	83	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	1421	84	against	against	IN
5180	1421	85	access	access	NN
5180	1421	86	to	to	IN
5180	1421	87	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1421	88	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	1421	89	that	that	WDT
5180	1421	90	are	be	VBP
5180	1421	91	"	"	``
5180	1421	92	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1421	93	to	to	IN
5180	1421	94	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1421	95	"	"	''
5180	1421	96	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1421	97	.	.	.
5180	1422	1	The	the	DT
5180	1422	2	government	government	NN
5180	1422	3	's	's	POS
5180	1422	4	interest	interest	NN
5180	1422	5	in	in	IN
5180	1422	6	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1422	7	the	the	DT
5180	1422	8	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1422	9	of	of	IN
5180	1422	10	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1422	11	,	,	,
5180	1422	12	child	child	NN
5180	1422	13	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1422	14	,	,	,
5180	1422	15	or	or	CC
5180	1422	16	,	,	,
5180	1422	17	in	in	IN
5180	1422	18	the	the	DT
5180	1422	19	case	case	NN
5180	1422	20	of	of	IN
5180	1422	21	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1422	22	,	,	,
5180	1422	23	material	material	NN
5180	1422	24	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1422	25	to	to	IN
5180	1422	26	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1422	27	,	,	,
5180	1422	28	is	be	VBZ
5180	1422	29	well	well	RB
5180	1422	30	-	-	HYPH
5180	1422	31	established	establish	VBN
5180	1422	32	.	.	.
5180	1423	1	Speech	speech	NN
5180	1423	2	that	that	WDT
5180	1423	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1423	4	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1423	5	,	,	,
5180	1423	6	under	under	IN
5180	1423	7	the	the	DT
5180	1423	8	legal	legal	JJ
5180	1423	9	definition	definition	NN
5180	1423	10	of	of	IN
5180	1423	11	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1423	12	set	set	VBN
5180	1423	13	forth	forth	RP
5180	1423	14	in	in	IN
5180	1423	15	the	the	DT
5180	1423	16	margin	margin	NN
5180	1423	17	,	,	,
5180	1423	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	1423	19	unprotected	unprotected	JJ
5180	1423	20	under	under	IN
5180	1423	21	the	the	DT
5180	1423	22	First	First	NNP
5180	1423	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1423	24	,	,	,
5180	1423	25	and	and	CC
5180	1423	26	accordingly	accordingly	RB
5180	1423	27	the	the	DT
5180	1423	28	state	state	NN
5180	1423	29	has	have	VBZ
5180	1423	30	a	a	DT
5180	1423	31	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1423	32	interest	interest	NN
5180	1423	33	in	in	IN
5180	1423	34	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1423	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1423	36	distribution	distribution	NN
5180	1423	37	.	.	.
5180	1424	1	See	see	VB
5180	1424	2	Miller	Miller	NNP
5180	1424	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1424	4	California	California	NNP
5180	1424	5	,	,	,
5180	1424	6	413	413	CD
5180	1424	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1424	8	15	15	CD
5180	1424	9	,	,	,
5180	1424	10	18	18	CD
5180	1424	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1424	12	1973	1973	CD
5180	1424	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1424	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1424	15	"	"	``
5180	1424	16	This	this	DT
5180	1424	17	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1424	18	has	have	VBZ
5180	1424	19	recognized	recognize	VBN
5180	1424	20	that	that	IN
5180	1424	21	the	the	DT
5180	1424	22	States	state	NNS
5180	1424	23	have	have	VBP
5180	1424	24	a	a	DT
5180	1424	25	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1424	26	interest	interest	NN
5180	1424	27	in	in	IN
5180	1424	28	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
5180	1424	29	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1424	30	or	or	CC
5180	1424	31	exhibition	exhibition	NN
5180	1424	32	of	of	IN
5180	1424	33	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1424	34	material	material	NN
5180	1424	35	.	.	.
5180	1425	1	")	")	``
5180	1425	2	;	;	:
5180	1425	3	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
5180	1425	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	1425	5	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
5180	1425	6	,	,	,
5180	1425	7	394	394	CD
5180	1425	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1425	9	557	557	CD
5180	1425	10	,	,	,
5180	1425	11	563	563	CD
5180	1425	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1425	13	1969	1969	CD
5180	1425	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1425	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1425	16	"	"	``
5180	1425	17	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1425	18	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	1425	19	First	First	NNP
5180	1425	20	and	and	CC
5180	1425	21	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
5180	1425	22	Amendments	Amendments	NNPS
5180	1425	23	recognize	recognize	VBP
5180	1425	24	a	a	DT
5180	1425	25	valid	valid	JJ
5180	1425	26	governmental	governmental	JJ
5180	1425	27	interest	interest	NN
5180	1425	28	in	in	IN
5180	1425	29	dealing	deal	VBG
5180	1425	30	with	with	IN
5180	1425	31	the	the	DT
5180	1425	32	problem	problem	NN
5180	1425	33	of	of	IN
5180	1425	34	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1425	35	.	.	.
5180	1426	1	")	")	``
5180	1426	2	;	;	:
5180	1426	3	Roth	Roth	NNP
5180	1426	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	1426	5	United	United	NNP
5180	1426	6	States	States	NNP
5180	1426	7	,	,	,
5180	1426	8	354	354	CD
5180	1426	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1426	10	476	476	CD
5180	1426	11	,	,	,
5180	1426	12	485	485	CD
5180	1426	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1426	14	1957	1957	CD
5180	1426	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1426	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1426	17	"	"	``
5180	1426	18	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1426	19	hold	hold	VBP
5180	1426	20	that	that	IN
5180	1426	21	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1426	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	1426	23	not	not	RB
5180	1426	24	within	within	IN
5180	1426	25	the	the	DT
5180	1426	26	area	area	NN
5180	1426	27	of	of	IN
5180	1426	28	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1426	29	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1426	30	speech	speech	NN
5180	1426	31	of	of	IN
5180	1426	32	press	press	NN
5180	1426	33	.	.	.
5180	1426	34	"	"	''
5180	1426	35	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1426	36	.	.	.
5180	1427	1	The	the	DT
5180	1427	2	First	First	NNP
5180	1427	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1427	4	also	also	RB
5180	1427	5	permits	permit	VBZ
5180	1427	6	the	the	DT
5180	1427	7	state	state	NN
5180	1427	8	to	to	TO
5180	1427	9	prohibit	prohibit	VB
5180	1427	10	the	the	DT
5180	1427	11	distribution	distribution	NN
5180	1427	12	to	to	IN
5180	1427	13	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1427	14	of	of	IN
5180	1427	15	material	material	NN
5180	1427	16	that	that	WDT
5180	1427	17	,	,	,
5180	1427	18	while	while	IN
5180	1427	19	not	not	RB
5180	1427	20	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1427	21	with	with	IN
5180	1427	22	respect	respect	NN
5180	1427	23	to	to	IN
5180	1427	24	adults	adult	NNS
5180	1427	25	,	,	,
5180	1427	26	is	be	VBZ
5180	1427	27	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1427	28	with	with	IN
5180	1427	29	respect	respect	NN
5180	1427	30	to	to	IN
5180	1427	31	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1427	32	.	.	.
5180	1428	1	See	see	VB
5180	1428	2	Ginsberg	Ginsberg	NNP
5180	1428	3	v.	v.	CC
5180	1428	4	New	New	NNP
5180	1428	5	York	York	NNP
5180	1428	6	,	,	,
5180	1428	7	390	390	CD
5180	1428	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1428	9	629	629	CD
5180	1428	10	,	,	,
5180	1428	11	637	637	CD
5180	1428	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1428	13	1968	1968	CD
5180	1428	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1428	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1428	16	holding	hold	VBG
5180	1428	17	that	that	IN
5180	1428	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1428	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	1428	20	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1428	21	permissible	permissible	JJ
5180	1428	22	"	"	''
5180	1428	23	to	to	TO
5180	1428	24	accord	accord	VB
5180	1428	25	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1428	26	under	under	IN
5180	1428	27	17	17	CD
5180	1428	28	a	a	DT
5180	1428	29	more	more	RBR
5180	1428	30	restricted	restricted	JJ
5180	1428	31	right	right	RB
5180	1428	32	than	than	IN
5180	1428	33	that	that	DT
5180	1428	34	assured	assure	VBN
5180	1428	35	to	to	IN
5180	1428	36	adults	adult	NNS
5180	1428	37	to	to	TO
5180	1428	38	judge	judge	VB
5180	1428	39	and	and	CC
5180	1428	40	determine	determine	VB
5180	1428	41	for	for	IN
5180	1428	42	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1428	43	what	what	WP
5180	1428	44	sex	sex	NN
5180	1428	45	material	material	NN
5180	1428	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1428	47	may	may	MD
5180	1428	48	read	read	VB
5180	1428	49	or	or	CC
5180	1428	50	see	see	VB
5180	1428	51	"	"	''
5180	1428	52	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1428	53	.	.	.
5180	1429	1	Proscribing	proscribe	VBG
5180	1429	2	the	the	DT
5180	1429	3	distribution	distribution	NN
5180	1429	4	of	of	IN
5180	1429	5	such	such	JJ
5180	1429	6	material	material	NN
5180	1429	7	to	to	IN
5180	1429	8	minors	minors	NNP
5180	1429	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	1429	10	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1429	11	justified	justify	VBN
5180	1429	12	by	by	IN
5180	1429	13	the	the	DT
5180	1429	14	government	government	NN
5180	1429	15	's	's	POS
5180	1429	16	well	well	RB
5180	1429	17	-	-	HYPH
5180	1429	18	recognized	recognize	VBN
5180	1429	19	interest	interest	NN
5180	1429	20	in	in	IN
5180	1429	21	safeguarding	safeguard	VBG
5180	1429	22	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1429	23	'	'	POS
5180	1429	24	well	well	RB
5180	1429	25	-	-	HYPH
5180	1429	26	being	being	NN
5180	1429	27	.	.	.
5180	1430	1	See	see	VB
5180	1430	2	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1430	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1430	4	ACLU	ACLU	NNP
5180	1430	5	,	,	,
5180	1430	6	521	521	CD
5180	1430	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1430	8	844	844	CD
5180	1430	9	,	,	,
5180	1430	10	869	869	CD
5180	1430	11	-	-	SYM
5180	1430	12	70	70	CD
5180	1430	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1430	14	1997	1997	CD
5180	1430	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1430	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1430	17	"	"	``
5180	1430	18	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1430	19	T]here	T]here	NNP
5180	1430	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	1430	21	a	a	DT
5180	1430	22	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1430	23	interest	interest	NN
5180	1430	24	in	in	IN
5180	1430	25	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1430	26	the	the	DT
5180	1430	27	physical	physical	JJ
5180	1430	28	and	and	CC
5180	1430	29	psychological	psychological	JJ
5180	1430	30	well	well	NN
5180	1430	31	-	-	HYPH
5180	1430	32	being	being	NN
5180	1430	33	of	of	IN
5180	1430	34	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1430	35	which	which	WDT
5180	1430	36	extend[s	extend[s	RB
5180	1430	37	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1430	38	to	to	TO
5180	1430	39	shielding	shield	VBG
5180	1430	40	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1430	41	from	from	IN
5180	1430	42	indecent	indecent	JJ
5180	1430	43	messages	message	NNS
5180	1430	44	that	that	WDT
5180	1430	45	are	be	VBP
5180	1430	46	not	not	RB
5180	1430	47	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1430	48	by	by	IN
5180	1430	49	adult	adult	NN
5180	1430	50	standards	standard	NNS
5180	1430	51	.	.	.
5180	1431	1	.	.	.
5180	1432	1	.	.	.
5180	1433	1	.	.	.
5180	1433	2	"	"	''
5180	1433	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1434	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1434	2	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1434	3	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1434	4	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1434	5	and	and	CC
5180	1434	6	citation	citation	NN
5180	1434	7	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1434	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1434	9	;	;	:
5180	1434	10	New	New	NNP
5180	1434	11	York	York	NNP
5180	1434	12	v.	v.	IN
5180	1434	13	Ferber	Ferber	NNP
5180	1434	14	,	,	,
5180	1434	15	458	458	CD
5180	1434	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1434	17	747	747	CD
5180	1434	18	,	,	,
5180	1434	19	756	756	CD
5180	1434	20	-	-	SYM
5180	1434	21	57	57	CD
5180	1434	22	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1434	23	1982	1982	CD
5180	1434	24	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1434	25	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1434	26	"	"	``
5180	1434	27	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1434	28	is	be	VBZ
5180	1434	29	evident	evident	JJ
5180	1434	30	beyond	beyond	IN
5180	1434	31	the	the	DT
5180	1434	32	need	need	NN
5180	1434	33	for	for	IN
5180	1434	34	elaboration	elaboration	NN
5180	1434	35	that	that	IN
5180	1434	36	a	a	DT
5180	1434	37	State	state	NN
5180	1434	38	's	's	POS
5180	1434	39	interest	interest	NN
5180	1434	40	in	in	IN
5180	1434	41	safeguarding	safeguard	VBG
5180	1434	42	the	the	DT
5180	1434	43	physical	physical	JJ
5180	1434	44	and	and	CC
5180	1434	45	psychological	psychological	JJ
5180	1434	46	well	well	NN
5180	1434	47	-	-	HYPH
5180	1434	48	being	being	NN
5180	1434	49	of	of	IN
5180	1434	50	a	a	DT
5180	1434	51	minor	minor	JJ
5180	1434	52	is	be	VBZ
5180	1434	53	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1434	54	.	.	.
5180	1434	55	"	"	''
5180	1434	56	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1435	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1435	2	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1435	3	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1435	4	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1435	5	and	and	CC
5180	1435	6	citation	citation	NN
5180	1435	7	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1435	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1435	9	;	;	:
5180	1435	10	Ginsberg	Ginsberg	NNP
5180	1435	11	,	,	,
5180	1435	12	390	390	CD
5180	1435	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1435	14	at	at	IN
5180	1435	15	640	640	CD
5180	1435	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1435	17	"	"	``
5180	1435	18	The	the	DT
5180	1435	19	State	state	NN
5180	1435	20	.	.	.
5180	1436	1	.	.	.
5180	1437	1	.	.	.
5180	1438	1	has	have	VBZ
5180	1438	2	an	an	DT
5180	1438	3	independent	independent	JJ
5180	1438	4	interest	interest	NN
5180	1438	5	in	in	IN
5180	1438	6	the	the	DT
5180	1438	7	well	well	NN
5180	1438	8	-	-	HYPH
5180	1438	9	being	being	NN
5180	1438	10	of	of	IN
5180	1438	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1438	12	youth	youth	NN
5180	1438	13	.	.	.
5180	1438	14	"	"	''
5180	1438	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1438	16	.	.	.
5180	1439	1	The	the	DT
5180	1439	2	government	government	NN
5180	1439	3	's	's	POS
5180	1439	4	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1439	5	interest	interest	NN
5180	1439	6	in	in	IN
5180	1439	7	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1439	8	the	the	DT
5180	1439	9	well-	well-	XX
5180	1439	10	being	being	NN
5180	1439	11	of	of	IN
5180	1439	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1439	13	youth	youth	NN
5180	1439	14	justifies	justifie	NNS
5180	1439	15	laws	law	NNS
5180	1439	16	that	that	WDT
5180	1439	17	criminalize	criminalize	VBP
5180	1439	18	not	not	RB
5180	1439	19	only	only	RB
5180	1439	20	the	the	DT
5180	1439	21	distribution	distribution	NN
5180	1439	22	to	to	IN
5180	1439	23	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1439	24	of	of	IN
5180	1439	25	material	material	NN
5180	1439	26	that	that	WDT
5180	1439	27	is	be	VBZ
5180	1439	28	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1439	29	to	to	IN
5180	1439	30	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1439	31	,	,	,
5180	1439	32	but	but	CC
5180	1439	33	also	also	RB
5180	1439	34	the	the	DT
5180	1439	35	possession	possession	NN
5180	1439	36	and	and	CC
5180	1439	37	distribution	distribution	NN
5180	1439	38	of	of	IN
5180	1439	39	child	child	NN
5180	1439	40	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1439	41	.	.	.
5180	1440	1	See	see	VB
5180	1440	2	Osborne	Osborne	NNP
5180	1440	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1440	4	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
5180	1440	5	,	,	,
5180	1440	6	495	495	CD
5180	1440	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1440	8	103	103	CD
5180	1440	9	,	,	,
5180	1440	10	111	111	CD
5180	1440	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1440	12	1990	1990	CD
5180	1440	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1440	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1440	15	holding	hold	VBG
5180	1440	16	that	that	IN
5180	1440	17	a	a	DT
5180	1440	18	state	state	NN
5180	1440	19	"	"	``
5180	1440	20	may	may	MD
5180	1440	21	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1440	22	proscribe	proscribe	VB
5180	1440	23	the	the	DT
5180	1440	24	possession	possession	NN
5180	1440	25	and	and	CC
5180	1440	26	viewing	viewing	NN
5180	1440	27	of	of	IN
5180	1440	28	child	child	NN
5180	1440	29	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1440	30	"	"	''
5180	1440	31	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1440	32	;	;	:
5180	1440	33	Ferber	Ferber	NNP
5180	1440	34	,	,	,
5180	1440	35	458	458	CD
5180	1440	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1440	37	at	at	IN
5180	1440	38	757	757	CD
5180	1440	39	,	,	,
5180	1440	40	763	763	CD
5180	1440	41	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1440	42	noting	note	VBG
5180	1440	43	that	that	IN
5180	1440	44	"	"	``
5180	1440	45	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1440	46	t]he	t]he	NN
5180	1440	47	prevention	prevention	NN
5180	1440	48	of	of	IN
5180	1440	49	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	1440	50	exploitation	exploitation	NN
5180	1440	51	and	and	CC
5180	1440	52	abuse	abuse	NN
5180	1440	53	of	of	IN
5180	1440	54	children	child	NNS
5180	1440	55	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
5180	1440	56	a	a	DT
5180	1440	57	government	government	NN
5180	1440	58	objective	objective	NN
5180	1440	59	of	of	IN
5180	1440	60	surpassing	surpass	VBG
5180	1440	61	importance	importance	NN
5180	1440	62	,	,	,
5180	1440	63	"	"	''
5180	1440	64	and	and	CC
5180	1440	65	holding	hold	VBG
5180	1440	66	that	that	DT
5180	1440	67	"	"	``
5180	1440	68	child	child	NN
5180	1440	69	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1440	70	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1440	71	is	be	VBZ
5180	1440	72	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1440	73	a	a	DT
5180	1440	74	category	category	NN
5180	1440	75	of	of	IN
5180	1440	76	material	material	NN
5180	1440	77	outside	outside	IN
5180	1440	78	the	the	DT
5180	1440	79	protection	protection	NN
5180	1440	80	of	of	IN
5180	1440	81	the	the	DT
5180	1440	82	First	First	NNP
5180	1440	83	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1440	84	"	"	''
5180	1440	85	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1440	86	.	.	.
5180	1441	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1441	2	,	,	,
5180	1441	3	a	a	DT
5180	1441	4	public	public	JJ
5180	1441	5	library	library	NN
5180	1441	6	's	's	POS
5180	1441	7	use	use	NN
5180	1441	8	of	of	IN
5180	1441	9	software	software	NN
5180	1441	10	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1441	11	survives	survive	VBZ
5180	1441	12	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1441	13	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1441	14	if	if	IN
5180	1441	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1441	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	1441	17	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1441	18	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1441	19	to	to	TO
5180	1441	20	further	further	RB
5180	1441	21	the	the	DT
5180	1441	22	state	state	NN
5180	1441	23	's	's	POS
5180	1441	24	well	well	RB
5180	1441	25	-	-	HYPH
5180	1441	26	recognized	recognize	VBN
5180	1441	27	interest	interest	NN
5180	1441	28	in	in	IN
5180	1441	29	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1441	30	the	the	DT
5180	1441	31	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1441	32	of	of	IN
5180	1441	33	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1441	34	and	and	CC
5180	1441	35	child	child	NN
5180	1441	36	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1441	37	,	,	,
5180	1441	38	and	and	CC
5180	1441	39	in	in	IN
5180	1441	40	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1441	41	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1441	42	from	from	IN
5180	1441	43	being	be	VBG
5180	1441	44	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1441	45	to	to	IN
5180	1441	46	material	material	NN
5180	1441	47	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1441	48	to	to	IN
5180	1441	49	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1441	50	well	well	NN
5180	1441	51	-	-	HYPH
5180	1441	52	being	being	NN
5180	1441	53	.	.	.
5180	1442	1	2	2	LS
5180	1442	2	.	.	.
5180	1443	1	Protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1443	2	the	the	DT
5180	1443	3	Unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1443	4	Viewer	Viewer	NNP
5180	1443	5	Several	Several	NNP
5180	1443	6	of	of	IN
5180	1443	7	the	the	DT
5180	1443	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1443	9	that	that	WDT
5180	1443	10	use	use	VBP
5180	1443	11	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1443	12	assert	assert	VBP
5180	1443	13	that	that	IN
5180	1443	14	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1443	15	serve	serve	VBP
5180	1443	16	the	the	DT
5180	1443	17	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1443	18	'	'	POS
5180	1443	19	interest	interest	NN
5180	1443	20	in	in	IN
5180	1443	21	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1443	22	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1443	23	from	from	IN
5180	1443	24	being	be	VBG
5180	1443	25	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	1443	26	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1443	27	to	to	IN
5180	1443	28	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1443	29	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1443	30	speech	speech	NN
5180	1443	31	that	that	WDT
5180	1443	32	the	the	DT
5180	1443	33	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1443	34	find	find	VBP
5180	1443	35	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1443	36	.	.	.
5180	1444	1	Nearly	nearly	RB
5180	1444	2	every	every	DT
5180	1444	3	library	library	NN
5180	1444	4	proffered	proffer	VBN
5180	1444	5	by	by	IN
5180	1444	6	either	either	CC
5180	1444	7	the	the	DT
5180	1444	8	government	government	NN
5180	1444	9	or	or	CC
5180	1444	10	the	the	DT
5180	1444	11	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1444	12	received	receive	VBD
5180	1444	13	complaints	complaint	NNS
5180	1444	14	,	,	,
5180	1444	15	in	in	IN
5180	1444	16	varying	vary	VBG
5180	1444	17	degrees	degree	NNS
5180	1444	18	of	of	IN
5180	1444	19	frequency	frequency	NN
5180	1444	20	,	,	,
5180	1444	21	from	from	IN
5180	1444	22	library	library	JJ
5180	1444	23	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1444	24	who	who	WP
5180	1444	25	saw	see	VBD
5180	1444	26	other	other	JJ
5180	1444	27	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1444	28	accessing	access	VBG
5180	1444	29	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1444	30	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1444	31	material	material	NN
5180	1444	32	on	on	IN
5180	1444	33	the	the	DT
5180	1444	34	library	library	NN
5180	1444	35	's	's	POS
5180	1444	36	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1444	37	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1444	38	.	.	.
5180	1445	1	In	in	IN
5180	1445	2	general	general	JJ
5180	1445	3	,	,	,
5180	1445	4	First	First	NNP
5180	1445	5	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1445	6	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
5180	1445	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	1445	8	reluctant	reluctant	JJ
5180	1445	9	to	to	TO
5180	1445	10	recognize	recognize	VB
5180	1445	11	a	a	DT
5180	1445	12	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1445	13	state	state	NN
5180	1445	14	interest	interest	NN
5180	1445	15	in	in	IN
5180	1445	16	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1445	17	the	the	DT
5180	1445	18	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1445	19	viewer	viewer	NN
5180	1445	20	from	from	IN
5180	1445	21	speech	speech	NN
5180	1445	22	that	that	WDT
5180	1445	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	1445	24	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1445	25	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1445	26	.	.	.
5180	1446	1	"	"	``
5180	1446	2	Where	where	WRB
5180	1446	3	the	the	DT
5180	1446	4	designed	design	VBN
5180	1446	5	benefit	benefit	NN
5180	1446	6	of	of	IN
5180	1446	7	a	a	DT
5180	1446	8	content	content	NN
5180	1446	9	-	-	HYPH
5180	1446	10	based	base	VBN
5180	1446	11	speech	speech	NN
5180	1446	12	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1446	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	1446	14	to	to	TO
5180	1446	15	shield	shield	VB
5180	1446	16	the	the	DT
5180	1446	17	sensibilities	sensibility	NNS
5180	1446	18	of	of	IN
5180	1446	19	listeners	listener	NNS
5180	1446	20	,	,	,
5180	1446	21	the	the	DT
5180	1446	22	general	general	JJ
5180	1446	23	rule	rule	NN
5180	1446	24	is	be	VBZ
5180	1446	25	that	that	IN
5180	1446	26	the	the	DT
5180	1446	27	right	right	NN
5180	1446	28	of	of	IN
5180	1446	29	expression	expression	NN
5180	1446	30	prevails	prevail	VBZ
5180	1446	31	,	,	,
5180	1446	32	even	even	RB
5180	1446	33	where	where	WRB
5180	1446	34	no	no	DT
5180	1446	35	less	less	RBR
5180	1446	36	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1446	37	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1446	38	exists	exist	VBZ
5180	1446	39	.	.	.
5180	1447	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1447	2	are	be	VBP
5180	1447	3	expected	expect	VBN
5180	1447	4	to	to	TO
5180	1447	5	protect	protect	VB
5180	1447	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1447	7	own	own	JJ
5180	1447	8	sensibilities	sensibility	NNS
5180	1447	9	simply	simply	RB
5180	1447	10	by	by	IN
5180	1447	11	averting	avert	VBG
5180	1447	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1447	13	eyes	eye	NNS
5180	1447	14	.	.	.
5180	1447	15	"	"	''
5180	1448	1	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1448	2	,	,	,
5180	1448	3	529	529	CD
5180	1448	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1448	5	at	at	IN
5180	1448	6	813	813	CD
5180	1448	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1448	8	2000	2000	CD
5180	1448	9	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1448	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1448	11	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1448	12	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1448	13	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1448	14	and	and	CC
5180	1448	15	citation	citation	NN
5180	1448	16	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1448	17	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1448	18	;	;	:
5180	1448	19	see	see	VB
5180	1448	20	also	also	RB
5180	1448	21	Erznoznik	Erznoznik	NNP
5180	1448	22	v.	v.	IN
5180	1448	23	City	City	NNP
5180	1448	24	of	of	IN
5180	1448	25	Jacksonville	Jacksonville	NNP
5180	1448	26	,	,	,
5180	1448	27	422	422	CD
5180	1448	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1448	29	205	205	CD
5180	1448	30	,	,	,
5180	1448	31	209	209	CD
5180	1448	32	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1448	33	1975	1975	CD
5180	1448	34	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1448	35	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1448	36	"	"	``
5180	1448	37	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1448	38	W]hen	w]hen	RB
5180	1448	39	the	the	DT
5180	1448	40	government	government	NN
5180	1448	41	,	,	,
5180	1448	42	acting	act	VBG
5180	1448	43	as	as	IN
5180	1448	44	censor	censor	NN
5180	1448	45	,	,	,
5180	1448	46	undertakes	undertake	VBZ
5180	1448	47	selectively	selectively	RB
5180	1448	48	to	to	TO
5180	1448	49	shield	shield	VB
5180	1448	50	the	the	DT
5180	1448	51	public	public	NN
5180	1448	52	from	from	IN
5180	1448	53	some	some	DT
5180	1448	54	kinds	kind	NNS
5180	1448	55	of	of	IN
5180	1448	56	speech	speech	NN
5180	1448	57	on	on	IN
5180	1448	58	the	the	DT
5180	1448	59	ground	ground	NN
5180	1448	60	that	that	IN
5180	1448	61	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1448	62	are	be	VBP
5180	1448	63	more	more	RBR
5180	1448	64	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1448	65	than	than	IN
5180	1448	66	others	other	NNS
5180	1448	67	,	,	,
5180	1448	68	the	the	DT
5180	1448	69	First	First	NNP
5180	1448	70	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1448	71	strictly	strictly	RB
5180	1448	72	limits	limit	VBZ
5180	1448	73	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1448	74	power	power	NN
5180	1448	75	.	.	.
5180	1448	76	"	"	''
5180	1448	77	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1448	78	.	.	.
5180	1449	1	For	for	IN
5180	1449	2	example	example	NN
5180	1449	3	,	,	,
5180	1449	4	in	in	IN
5180	1449	5	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
5180	1449	6	v.	v.	IN
5180	1449	7	California	California	NNP
5180	1449	8	,	,	,
5180	1449	9	403	403	CD
5180	1449	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1449	11	15	15	CD
5180	1449	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1449	13	1971	1971	CD
5180	1449	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1449	15	,	,	,
5180	1449	16	the	the	DT
5180	1449	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1449	18	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1449	19	reversed	reverse	VBD
5180	1449	20	defendant	defendant	NN
5180	1449	21	's	's	POS
5180	1449	22	conviction	conviction	NN
5180	1449	23	for	for	IN
5180	1449	24	wearing	wear	VBG
5180	1449	25	,	,	,
5180	1449	26	in	in	IN
5180	1449	27	a	a	DT
5180	1449	28	municipal	municipal	JJ
5180	1449	29	courthouse	courthouse	NN
5180	1449	30	,	,	,
5180	1449	31	a	a	DT
5180	1449	32	jacket	jacket	NN
5180	1449	33	bearing	bear	VBG
5180	1449	34	the	the	DT
5180	1449	35	inscription	inscription	NN
5180	1449	36	"	"	``
5180	1449	37	Fuck	Fuck	NNP
5180	1449	38	the	the	DT
5180	1449	39	Draft	Draft	NNP
5180	1449	40	.	.	.
5180	1449	41	"	"	''
5180	1450	1	The	the	DT
5180	1450	2	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1450	3	noted	note	VBD
5180	1450	4	that	that	IN
5180	1450	5	"	"	``
5180	1450	6	much	much	JJ
5180	1450	7	has	have	VBZ
5180	1450	8	been	be	VBN
5180	1450	9	made	make	VBN
5180	1450	10	of	of	IN
5180	1450	11	the	the	DT
5180	1450	12	claim	claim	NN
5180	1450	13	that	that	IN
5180	1450	14	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
5180	1450	15	's	's	POS
5180	1450	16	distasteful	distasteful	JJ
5180	1450	17	mode	mode	NN
5180	1450	18	of	of	IN
5180	1450	19	expression	expression	NN
5180	1450	20	was	be	VBD
5180	1450	21	thrust	thrust	VBN
5180	1450	22	upon	upon	IN
5180	1450	23	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1450	24	or	or	CC
5180	1450	25	unsuspecting	unsuspecting	JJ
5180	1450	26	viewers	viewer	NNS
5180	1450	27	,	,	,
5180	1450	28	and	and	CC
5180	1450	29	that	that	IN
5180	1450	30	the	the	DT
5180	1450	31	State	State	NNP
5180	1450	32	might	may	MD
5180	1450	33	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1450	34	legitimately	legitimately	RB
5180	1450	35	act	act	VB
5180	1450	36	as	as	IN
5180	1450	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1450	38	did	do	VBD
5180	1450	39	in	in	IN
5180	1450	40	order	order	NN
5180	1450	41	to	to	TO
5180	1450	42	protect	protect	VB
5180	1450	43	the	the	DT
5180	1450	44	sensitive	sensitive	JJ
5180	1450	45	from	from	IN
5180	1450	46	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1450	47	unavoidable	unavoidable	JJ
5180	1450	48	exposure	exposure	NN
5180	1450	49	to	to	IN
5180	1450	50	appellant	appellant	VB
5180	1450	51	's	's	POS
5180	1450	52	crude	crude	JJ
5180	1450	53	form	form	NN
5180	1450	54	of	of	IN
5180	1450	55	protest	protest	NN
5180	1450	56	.	.	.
5180	1450	57	"	"	''
5180	1451	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1452	1	at	at	IN
5180	1452	2	21	21	CD
5180	1452	3	.	.	.
5180	1453	1	This	this	DT
5180	1453	2	justification	justification	NN
5180	1453	3	for	for	IN
5180	1453	4	suppressing	suppress	VBG
5180	1453	5	speech	speech	NN
5180	1453	6	failed	fail	VBD
5180	1453	7	,	,	,
5180	1453	8	however	however	RB
5180	1453	9	,	,	,
5180	1453	10	because	because	IN
5180	1453	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1453	12	"	"	``
5180	1453	13	would	would	MD
5180	1453	14	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	1453	15	empower	empower	VB
5180	1453	16	a	a	DT
5180	1453	17	majority	majority	NN
5180	1453	18	to	to	TO
5180	1453	19	silence	silence	VB
5180	1453	20	dissidents	dissident	NNS
5180	1453	21	simply	simply	RB
5180	1453	22	as	as	IN
5180	1453	23	a	a	DT
5180	1453	24	matter	matter	NN
5180	1453	25	of	of	IN
5180	1453	26	personal	personal	JJ
5180	1453	27	predilections	predilection	NNS
5180	1453	28	.	.	.
5180	1453	29	"	"	''
5180	1454	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1455	1	The	the	DT
5180	1455	2	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1455	3	concluded	conclude	VBD
5180	1455	4	that	that	IN
5180	1455	5	"	"	``
5180	1455	6	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1455	7	t]hose	t]hose	NN
5180	1455	8	in	in	IN
5180	1455	9	the	the	DT
5180	1455	10	Los	Los	NNP
5180	1455	11	Angeles	Angeles	NNP
5180	1455	12	courthouse	courthouse	NN
5180	1455	13	could	could	MD
5180	1455	14	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	1455	15	avoid	avoid	VB
5180	1455	16	further	further	JJ
5180	1455	17	bombardment	bombardment	NN
5180	1455	18	of	of	IN
5180	1455	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1455	20	sensibilities	sensibility	NNS
5180	1455	21	simply	simply	RB
5180	1455	22	by	by	IN
5180	1455	23	averting	avert	VBG
5180	1455	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1455	25	eyes	eye	NNS
5180	1455	26	.	.	.
5180	1455	27	"	"	''
5180	1456	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1457	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1457	2	,	,	,
5180	1457	3	in	in	IN
5180	1457	4	Erznoznik	Erznoznik	NNP
5180	1457	5	,	,	,
5180	1457	6	the	the	DT
5180	1457	7	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1457	8	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
5180	1457	9	on	on	IN
5180	1457	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1457	11	face	face	NN
5180	1457	12	a	a	DT
5180	1457	13	municipal	municipal	JJ
5180	1457	14	ordinance	ordinance	NN
5180	1457	15	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
5180	1457	16	drive	drive	VB
5180	1457	17	-	-	HYPH
5180	1457	18	in	in	RP
5180	1457	19	movie	movie	NN
5180	1457	20	theaters	theater	NNS
5180	1457	21	from	from	IN
5180	1457	22	showing	show	VBG
5180	1457	23	films	film	NNS
5180	1457	24	containing	contain	VBG
5180	1457	25	nudity	nudity	NN
5180	1457	26	if	if	IN
5180	1457	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1457	28	were	be	VBD
5180	1457	29	visible	visible	JJ
5180	1457	30	from	from	IN
5180	1457	31	a	a	DT
5180	1457	32	public	public	JJ
5180	1457	33	street	street	NN
5180	1457	34	or	or	CC
5180	1457	35	place	place	NN
5180	1457	36	.	.	.
5180	1458	1	The	the	DT
5180	1458	2	city	city	NN
5180	1458	3	's	's	POS
5180	1458	4	"	"	``
5180	1458	5	primary	primary	JJ
5180	1458	6	argument	argument	NN
5180	1458	7	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1458	8	was	be	VBD
5180	1458	9	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1458	10	that	that	IN
5180	1458	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1458	12	may	may	MD
5180	1458	13	protect	protect	VB
5180	1458	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1458	15	citizens	citizen	NNS
5180	1458	16	against	against	IN
5180	1458	17	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1458	18	exposure	exposure	NN
5180	1458	19	to	to	IN
5180	1458	20	materials	material	NNS
5180	1458	21	that	that	WDT
5180	1458	22	may	may	MD
5180	1458	23	be	be	VB
5180	1458	24	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1458	25	.	.	.
5180	1458	26	"	"	''
5180	1459	1	422	422	CD
5180	1459	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1459	3	at	at	IN
5180	1459	4	208	208	CD
5180	1459	5	.	.	.
5180	1460	1	The	the	DT
5180	1460	2	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1460	3	soundly	soundly	RB
5180	1460	4	rejected	reject	VBD
5180	1460	5	this	this	DT
5180	1460	6	interest	interest	NN
5180	1460	7	in	in	IN
5180	1460	8	shielding	shield	VBG
5180	1460	9	the	the	DT
5180	1460	10	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1460	11	viewer	viewer	NN
5180	1460	12	:	:	:
5180	1460	13	The	the	DT
5180	1460	14	plain	plain	JJ
5180	1460	15	,	,	,
5180	1460	16	if	if	IN
5180	1460	17	at	at	IN
5180	1460	18	times	time	NNS
5180	1460	19	disquieting	disquiet	VBG
5180	1460	20	,	,	,
5180	1460	21	truth	truth	NN
5180	1460	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	1460	23	that	that	IN
5180	1460	24	in	in	IN
5180	1460	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1460	26	pluralistic	pluralistic	JJ
5180	1460	27	society	society	NN
5180	1460	28	,	,	,
5180	1460	29	constantly	constantly	RB
5180	1460	30	proliferating	proliferate	VBG
5180	1460	31	new	new	JJ
5180	1460	32	and	and	CC
5180	1460	33	ingenious	ingenious	JJ
5180	1460	34	forms	form	NNS
5180	1460	35	of	of	IN
5180	1460	36	expression	expression	NN
5180	1460	37	,	,	,
5180	1460	38	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1460	39	are	be	VBP
5180	1460	40	inescapably	inescapably	RB
5180	1460	41	captive	captive	JJ
5180	1460	42	audiences	audience	NNS
5180	1460	43	for	for	IN
5180	1460	44	many	many	JJ
5180	1460	45	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1460	46	.	.	.
5180	1461	1	Much	much	JJ
5180	1461	2	that	that	IN
5180	1461	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1461	4	encounter	encounter	VBP
5180	1461	5	offends	offend	VBZ
5180	1461	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1461	7	esthetic	esthetic	JJ
5180	1461	8	,	,	,
5180	1461	9	if	if	IN
5180	1461	10	not	not	RB
5180	1461	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1461	12	political	political	JJ
5180	1461	13	and	and	CC
5180	1461	14	moral	moral	JJ
5180	1461	15	,	,	,
5180	1461	16	sensibilities	sensibility	NNS
5180	1461	17	.	.	.
5180	1462	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
5180	1462	2	,	,	,
5180	1462	3	the	the	DT
5180	1462	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
5180	1462	5	does	do	VBZ
5180	1462	6	not	not	RB
5180	1462	7	permit	permit	VB
5180	1462	8	government	government	NN
5180	1462	9	to	to	TO
5180	1462	10	decide	decide	VB
5180	1462	11	which	which	WDT
5180	1462	12	types	type	NNS
5180	1462	13	of	of	IN
5180	1462	14	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1462	15	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1462	16	speech	speech	NN
5180	1462	17	are	be	VBP
5180	1462	18	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
5180	1462	19	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1462	20	to	to	TO
5180	1462	21	require	require	VB
5180	1462	22	protection	protection	NN
5180	1462	23	for	for	IN
5180	1462	24	the	the	DT
5180	1462	25	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1462	26	listener	listener	NN
5180	1462	27	or	or	CC
5180	1462	28	viewer	viewer	NN
5180	1462	29	.	.	.
5180	1463	1	Rather	rather	RB
5180	1463	2	,	,	,
5180	1463	3	absent	absent	JJ
5180	1463	4	.	.	.
5180	1464	1	.	.	.
5180	1465	1	.	.	.
5180	1466	1	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1466	2	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
5180	1466	3	.	.	.
5180	1467	1	.	.	.
5180	1468	1	.	.	.
5180	1469	1	the	the	DT
5180	1469	2	burden	burden	NN
5180	1469	3	normally	normally	RB
5180	1469	4	falls	fall	VBZ
5180	1469	5	upon	upon	IN
5180	1469	6	the	the	DT
5180	1469	7	viewer	viewer	NN
5180	1469	8	to	to	TO
5180	1469	9	avoid	avoid	VB
5180	1469	10	further	further	JJ
5180	1469	11	bombardment	bombardment	NN
5180	1469	12	of	of	IN
5180	1469	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1469	14	sensibilities	sensibility	NNS
5180	1469	15	simply	simply	RB
5180	1469	16	by	by	IN
5180	1469	17	averting	avert	VBG
5180	1469	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1469	19	eyes	eye	NNS
5180	1469	20	.	.	.
5180	1470	1	422	422	CD
5180	1470	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1470	3	at	at	IN
5180	1470	4	210	210	CD
5180	1470	5	-	-	SYM
5180	1470	6	11	11	CD
5180	1470	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1470	8	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1470	9	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1470	10	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1470	11	and	and	CC
5180	1470	12	citation	citation	NN
5180	1470	13	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1470	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1470	15	.	.	.
5180	1471	1	The	the	DT
5180	1471	2	state	state	NN
5180	1471	3	's	's	POS
5180	1471	4	interest	interest	NN
5180	1471	5	in	in	IN
5180	1471	6	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1471	7	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1471	8	viewers	viewer	NNS
5180	1471	9	from	from	IN
5180	1471	10	exposure	exposure	NN
5180	1471	11	to	to	IN
5180	1471	12	patently	patently	RB
5180	1471	13	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1471	14	material	material	NN
5180	1471	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	1471	16	accounted	account	VBN
5180	1471	17	for	for	IN
5180	1471	18	,	,	,
5180	1471	19	to	to	IN
5180	1471	20	some	some	DT
5180	1471	21	degree	degree	NN
5180	1471	22	,	,	,
5180	1471	23	by	by	IN
5180	1471	24	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1471	25	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	1471	26	,	,	,
5180	1471	27	which	which	WDT
5180	1471	28	originated	originate	VBD
5180	1471	29	in	in	IN
5180	1471	30	part	part	NN
5180	1471	31	to	to	TO
5180	1471	32	permit	permit	VB
5180	1471	33	the	the	DT
5180	1471	34	state	state	NN
5180	1471	35	to	to	TO
5180	1471	36	shield	shield	VB
5180	1471	37	the	the	DT
5180	1471	38	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1471	39	viewer	viewer	NN
5180	1471	40	.	.	.
5180	1472	1	"	"	``
5180	1472	2	The	the	DT
5180	1472	3	Miller	Miller	NNP
5180	1472	4	standard	standard	NN
5180	1472	5	,	,	,
5180	1472	6	like	like	IN
5180	1472	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1472	8	predecessors	predecessor	NNS
5180	1472	9	,	,	,
5180	1472	10	was	be	VBD
5180	1472	11	an	an	DT
5180	1472	12	accommodation	accommodation	NN
5180	1472	13	between	between	IN
5180	1472	14	the	the	DT
5180	1472	15	State	state	NN
5180	1472	16	's	's	POS
5180	1472	17	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1472	18	in	in	IN
5180	1472	19	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1472	20	the	the	DT
5180	1472	21	sensibilities	sensibility	NNS
5180	1472	22	of	of	IN
5180	1472	23	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1472	24	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	1472	25	from	from	IN
5180	1472	26	exposure	exposure	NN
5180	1472	27	to	to	IN
5180	1472	28	pornographic	pornographic	JJ
5180	1472	29	material	material	NN
5180	1472	30	and	and	CC
5180	1472	31	the	the	DT
5180	1472	32	dangers	danger	NNS
5180	1472	33	of	of	IN
5180	1472	34	censorship	censorship	NN
5180	1472	35	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	1472	36	in	in	IN
5180	1472	37	unabashedly	unabashedly	RB
5180	1472	38	content	content	NN
5180	1472	39	-	-	HYPH
5180	1472	40	based	base	VBN
5180	1472	41	laws	law	NNS
5180	1472	42	.	.	.
5180	1472	43	"	"	''
5180	1473	1	Ferber	Ferber	NNP
5180	1473	2	,	,	,
5180	1473	3	458	458	CD
5180	1473	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1473	5	at	at	IN
5180	1473	6	756	756	CD
5180	1473	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1473	8	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1473	9	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1473	10	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1473	11	and	and	CC
5180	1473	12	citation	citation	NN
5180	1473	13	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1473	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1473	15	;	;	:
5180	1473	16	see	see	VB
5180	1473	17	also	also	RB
5180	1473	18	Miller	Miller	NNP
5180	1473	19	,	,	,
5180	1473	20	413	413	CD
5180	1473	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1473	22	at	at	IN
5180	1473	23	18	18	CD
5180	1473	24	-	-	SYM
5180	1473	25	19	19	CD
5180	1473	26	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1473	27	"	"	``
5180	1473	28	This	this	DT
5180	1473	29	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1473	30	has	have	VBZ
5180	1473	31	recognized	recognize	VBN
5180	1473	32	that	that	IN
5180	1473	33	the	the	DT
5180	1473	34	States	state	NNS
5180	1473	35	have	have	VBP
5180	1473	36	a	a	DT
5180	1473	37	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1473	38	interest	interest	NN
5180	1473	39	in	in	IN
5180	1473	40	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
5180	1473	41	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1473	42	or	or	CC
5180	1473	43	exhibition	exhibition	NN
5180	1473	44	of	of	IN
5180	1473	45	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1473	46	material	material	NN
5180	1473	47	when	when	WRB
5180	1473	48	the	the	DT
5180	1473	49	mode	mode	NN
5180	1473	50	of	of	IN
5180	1473	51	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1473	52	carries	carry	VBZ
5180	1473	53	with	with	IN
5180	1473	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1473	55	a	a	DT
5180	1473	56	significant	significant	JJ
5180	1473	57	danger	danger	NN
5180	1473	58	of	of	IN
5180	1473	59	offending	offend	VBG
5180	1473	60	the	the	DT
5180	1473	61	sensibilities	sensibility	NNS
5180	1473	62	of	of	IN
5180	1473	63	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1473	64	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	1473	65	or	or	CC
5180	1473	66	of	of	IN
5180	1473	67	exposure	exposure	NN
5180	1473	68	to	to	IN
5180	1473	69	juveniles	juvenile	NNS
5180	1473	70	.	.	.
5180	1473	71	"	"	''
5180	1473	72	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1474	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1474	2	citation	citation	NNP
5180	1474	3	omitted	omit	VBN
5180	1474	4	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1474	5	.	.	.
5180	1475	1	To	to	IN
5180	1475	2	the	the	DT
5180	1475	3	extent	extent	NN
5180	1475	4	that	that	DT
5180	1475	5	speech	speech	NN
5180	1475	6	has	have	VBZ
5180	1475	7	serious	serious	JJ
5180	1475	8	literary	literary	JJ
5180	1475	9	,	,	,
5180	1475	10	artistic	artistic	JJ
5180	1475	11	,	,	,
5180	1475	12	political	political	JJ
5180	1475	13	,	,	,
5180	1475	14	or	or	CC
5180	1475	15	scientific	scientific	JJ
5180	1475	16	value	value	NN
5180	1475	17	,	,	,
5180	1475	18	and	and	CC
5180	1475	19	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1475	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	1475	21	not	not	RB
5180	1475	22	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1475	23	under	under	IN
5180	1475	24	the	the	DT
5180	1475	25	Miller	Miller	NNP
5180	1475	26	test	test	NN
5180	1475	27	of	of	IN
5180	1475	28	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1475	29	,	,	,
5180	1475	30	the	the	DT
5180	1475	31	state	state	NN
5180	1475	32	's	's	POS
5180	1475	33	interest	interest	NN
5180	1475	34	in	in	IN
5180	1475	35	shielding	shield	VBG
5180	1475	36	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1475	37	viewers	viewer	NNS
5180	1475	38	from	from	IN
5180	1475	39	such	such	JJ
5180	1475	40	speech	speech	NN
5180	1475	41	is	be	VBZ
5180	1475	42	tenuous	tenuous	JJ
5180	1475	43	.	.	.
5180	1476	1	Nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	1476	2	,	,	,
5180	1476	3	the	the	DT
5180	1476	4	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1476	5	has	have	VBZ
5180	1476	6	recognized	recognize	VBN
5180	1476	7	that	that	IN
5180	1476	8	in	in	IN
5180	1476	9	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1476	10	limited	limited	JJ
5180	1476	11	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
5180	1476	12	,	,	,
5180	1476	13	the	the	DT
5180	1476	14	state	state	NN
5180	1476	15	has	have	VBZ
5180	1476	16	a	a	DT
5180	1476	17	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1476	18	interest	interest	NN
5180	1476	19	in	in	IN
5180	1476	20	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1476	21	the	the	DT
5180	1476	22	public	public	NN
5180	1476	23	from	from	IN
5180	1476	24	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1476	25	exposure	exposure	NN
5180	1476	26	to	to	IN
5180	1476	27	speech	speech	NN
5180	1476	28	that	that	WDT
5180	1476	29	is	be	VBZ
5180	1476	30	not	not	RB
5180	1476	31	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1476	32	.	.	.
5180	1477	1	This	this	DT
5180	1477	2	interest	interest	NN
5180	1477	3	has	have	VBZ
5180	1477	4	justified	justify	VBN
5180	1477	5	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1477	6	on	on	IN
5180	1477	7	speech	speech	NN
5180	1477	8	"	"	''
5180	1477	9	when	when	WRB
5180	1477	10	the	the	DT
5180	1477	11	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	1477	12	intrudes	intrude	VBZ
5180	1477	13	on	on	IN
5180	1477	14	the	the	DT
5180	1477	15	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1477	16	of	of	IN
5180	1477	17	the	the	DT
5180	1477	18	home	home	NN
5180	1477	19	,	,	,
5180	1477	20	or	or	CC
5180	1477	21	the	the	DT
5180	1477	22	degree	degree	NN
5180	1477	23	of	of	IN
5180	1477	24	captivity	captivity	NN
5180	1477	25	makes	make	VBZ
5180	1477	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1477	27	impractical	impractical	JJ
5180	1477	28	for	for	IN
5180	1477	29	the	the	DT
5180	1477	30	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1477	31	viewer	viewer	NN
5180	1477	32	or	or	CC
5180	1477	33	auditor	auditor	NN
5180	1477	34	to	to	TO
5180	1477	35	avoid	avoid	VB
5180	1477	36	exposure	exposure	NN
5180	1477	37	.	.	.
5180	1477	38	"	"	''
5180	1478	1	Erznoznik	Erznoznik	NNP
5180	1478	2	,	,	,
5180	1478	3	422	422	CD
5180	1478	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1478	5	at	at	IN
5180	1478	6	209	209	CD
5180	1478	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1478	8	citations	citation	NNS
5180	1478	9	omitted	omit	VBN
5180	1478	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1478	11	.	.	.
5180	1479	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1479	2	,	,	,
5180	1479	3	in	in	IN
5180	1479	4	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	1479	5	v.	v.	IN
5180	1479	6	Pacifica	Pacifica	NNP
5180	1479	7	Foundation	Foundation	NNP
5180	1479	8	,	,	,
5180	1479	9	438	438	CD
5180	1479	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1479	11	726	726	CD
5180	1479	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1479	13	1978	1978	CD
5180	1479	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1479	15	,	,	,
5180	1479	16	the	the	DT
5180	1479	17	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1479	18	relied	rely	VBD
5180	1479	19	on	on	IN
5180	1479	20	the	the	DT
5180	1479	21	state	state	NN
5180	1479	22	's	's	POS
5180	1479	23	interest	interest	NN
5180	1479	24	in	in	IN
5180	1479	25	shielding	shield	VBG
5180	1479	26	viewers	viewer	NNS
5180	1479	27	'	'	POS
5180	1479	28	sensibilities	sensibility	NNS
5180	1479	29	to	to	TO
5180	1479	30	uphold	uphold	VB
5180	1479	31	a	a	DT
5180	1479	32	prohibition	prohibition	NN
5180	1479	33	against	against	IN
5180	1479	34	profanity	profanity	NN
5180	1479	35	in	in	IN
5180	1479	36	radio	radio	NN
5180	1479	37	broadcasts	broadcast	NNS
5180	1479	38	:	:	:
5180	1479	39	Patently	patently	RB
5180	1479	40	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1479	41	,	,	,
5180	1479	42	indecent	indecent	JJ
5180	1479	43	material	material	NN
5180	1479	44	presented	present	VBN
5180	1479	45	over	over	IN
5180	1479	46	the	the	DT
5180	1479	47	airwaves	airwave	NNS
5180	1479	48	confronts	confront	VBZ
5180	1479	49	the	the	DT
5180	1479	50	citizen	citizen	NN
5180	1479	51	,	,	,
5180	1479	52	not	not	RB
5180	1479	53	only	only	RB
5180	1479	54	in	in	IN
5180	1479	55	public	public	NN
5180	1479	56	,	,	,
5180	1479	57	but	but	CC
5180	1479	58	also	also	RB
5180	1479	59	in	in	IN
5180	1479	60	the	the	DT
5180	1479	61	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1479	62	of	of	IN
5180	1479	63	the	the	DT
5180	1479	64	home	home	NN
5180	1479	65	,	,	,
5180	1479	66	where	where	WRB
5180	1479	67	the	the	DT
5180	1479	68	individual	individual	NN
5180	1479	69	's	's	POS
5180	1479	70	right	right	NN
5180	1479	71	to	to	TO
5180	1479	72	be	be	VB
5180	1479	73	left	leave	VBN
5180	1479	74	alone	alone	JJ
5180	1479	75	plainly	plainly	RB
5180	1479	76	outweighs	outweigh	VBZ
5180	1479	77	the	the	DT
5180	1479	78	First	First	NNP
5180	1479	79	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1479	80	rights	right	NNS
5180	1479	81	of	of	IN
5180	1479	82	an	an	DT
5180	1479	83	intruder	intruder	NN
5180	1479	84	.	.	.
5180	1480	1	Because	because	IN
5180	1480	2	the	the	DT
5180	1480	3	broadcast	broadcast	NN
5180	1480	4	audience	audience	NN
5180	1480	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	1480	6	constantly	constantly	RB
5180	1480	7	tuning	tune	VBG
5180	1480	8	in	in	IN
5180	1480	9	and	and	CC
5180	1480	10	out	out	RB
5180	1480	11	,	,	,
5180	1480	12	prior	prior	JJ
5180	1480	13	warnings	warning	NNS
5180	1480	14	can	can	MD
5180	1480	15	not	not	RB
5180	1480	16	completely	completely	RB
5180	1480	17	protect	protect	VB
5180	1480	18	the	the	DT
5180	1480	19	listener	listener	NN
5180	1480	20	or	or	CC
5180	1480	21	viewer	viewer	NN
5180	1480	22	from	from	IN
5180	1480	23	unexpected	unexpected	JJ
5180	1480	24	program	program	NN
5180	1480	25	content	content	NN
5180	1480	26	.	.	.
5180	1481	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1482	1	at	at	IN
5180	1482	2	748	748	CD
5180	1482	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1482	4	citation	citation	NN
5180	1482	5	omitted	omit	VBN
5180	1482	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1482	7	;	;	:
5180	1482	8	accord	accord	NN
5180	1482	9	Frisby	Frisby	NNP
5180	1482	10	v.	v.	IN
5180	1482	11	Schultz	Schultz	NNP
5180	1482	12	,	,	,
5180	1482	13	487	487	CD
5180	1482	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1482	15	474	474	CD
5180	1482	16	,	,	,
5180	1482	17	485	485	CD
5180	1482	18	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1482	19	1988	1988	CD
5180	1482	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1482	21	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1482	22	"	"	``
5180	1482	23	Although	although	IN
5180	1482	24	in	in	IN
5180	1482	25	many	many	JJ
5180	1482	26	locations	location	NNS
5180	1482	27	,	,	,
5180	1482	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1482	29	expect	expect	VBP
5180	1482	30	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	1482	31	simply	simply	RB
5180	1482	32	to	to	TO
5180	1482	33	avoid	avoid	VB
5180	1482	34	speech	speech	NN
5180	1482	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1482	36	do	do	VBP
5180	1482	37	not	not	RB
5180	1482	38	want	want	VB
5180	1482	39	to	to	TO
5180	1482	40	hear	hear	VB
5180	1482	41	,	,	,
5180	1482	42	the	the	DT
5180	1482	43	home	home	NN
5180	1482	44	is	be	VBZ
5180	1482	45	different	different	JJ
5180	1482	46	.	.	.
5180	1483	1	")	")	``
5180	1483	2	;	;	:
5180	1483	3	see	see	VB
5180	1483	4	also	also	RB
5180	1483	5	Lehman	Lehman	NNP
5180	1483	6	v.	v.	IN
5180	1483	7	City	City	NNP
5180	1483	8	of	of	IN
5180	1483	9	Shaker	Shaker	NNP
5180	1483	10	Heights	Heights	NNPS
5180	1483	11	,	,	,
5180	1483	12	418	418	CD
5180	1483	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1483	14	298	298	CD
5180	1483	15	,	,	,
5180	1483	16	302	302	CD
5180	1483	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1483	18	1974	1974	CD
5180	1483	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1483	20	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1483	21	plurality	plurality	NN
5180	1483	22	opinion	opinion	NN
5180	1483	23	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1483	24	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1483	25	upholding	uphold	VBG
5180	1483	26	a	a	DT
5180	1483	27	content	content	NN
5180	1483	28	-	-	HYPH
5180	1483	29	based	base	VBN
5180	1483	30	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1483	31	on	on	IN
5180	1483	32	the	the	DT
5180	1483	33	sale	sale	NN
5180	1483	34	of	of	IN
5180	1483	35	advertising	advertising	NN
5180	1483	36	space	space	NN
5180	1483	37	in	in	IN
5180	1483	38	public	public	JJ
5180	1483	39	transit	transit	NN
5180	1483	40	vehicles	vehicle	NNS
5180	1483	41	and	and	CC
5180	1483	42	noting	note	VBG
5180	1483	43	that	that	IN
5180	1483	44	"	"	``
5180	1483	45	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1483	46	t]he	t]he	NN
5180	1483	47	streetcar	streetcar	NN
5180	1483	48	audience	audience	NN
5180	1483	49	is	be	VBZ
5180	1483	50	a	a	DT
5180	1483	51	captive	captive	JJ
5180	1483	52	audience	audience	NN
5180	1483	53	"	"	''
5180	1483	54	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1483	55	.	.	.
5180	1484	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1484	2	neither	neither	CC
5180	1484	3	the	the	DT
5180	1484	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1484	5	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1484	6	nor	nor	CC
5180	1484	7	the	the	DT
5180	1484	8	Third	Third	NNP
5180	1484	9	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
5180	1484	10	has	have	VBZ
5180	1484	11	recognized	recognize	VBN
5180	1484	12	a	a	DT
5180	1484	13	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1484	14	state	state	NN
5180	1484	15	interest	interest	NN
5180	1484	16	in	in	IN
5180	1484	17	shielding	shield	VBG
5180	1484	18	the	the	DT
5180	1484	19	sensibilities	sensibility	NNS
5180	1484	20	of	of	IN
5180	1484	21	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1484	22	viewers	viewer	NNS
5180	1484	23	,	,	,
5180	1484	24	beyond	beyond	IN
5180	1484	25	laws	law	NNS
5180	1484	26	intended	intend	VBN
5180	1484	27	to	to	TO
5180	1484	28	preserve	preserve	VB
5180	1484	29	the	the	DT
5180	1484	30	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1484	31	of	of	IN
5180	1484	32	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	1484	33	'	'	POS
5180	1484	34	homes	home	NNS
5180	1484	35	or	or	CC
5180	1484	36	to	to	TO
5180	1484	37	protect	protect	VB
5180	1484	38	captive	captive	JJ
5180	1484	39	audiences	audience	NNS
5180	1484	40	,	,	,
5180	1484	41	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1484	42	do	do	VBP
5180	1484	43	not	not	RB
5180	1484	44	read	read	VB
5180	1484	45	the	the	DT
5180	1484	46	case	case	NN
5180	1484	47	law	law	NN
5180	1484	48	as	as	IN
5180	1484	49	categorically	categorically	RB
5180	1484	50	foreclosing	foreclose	VBG
5180	1484	51	recognition	recognition	NN
5180	1484	52	,	,	,
5180	1484	53	in	in	IN
5180	1484	54	the	the	DT
5180	1484	55	public	public	JJ
5180	1484	56	library	library	NN
5180	1484	57	setting	setting	NN
5180	1484	58	,	,	,
5180	1484	59	of	of	IN
5180	1484	60	the	the	DT
5180	1484	61	state	state	NN
5180	1484	62	's	's	POS
5180	1484	63	interest	interest	NN
5180	1484	64	in	in	IN
5180	1484	65	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1484	66	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1484	67	viewers	viewer	NNS
5180	1484	68	.	.	.
5180	1485	1	See	see	VB
5180	1485	2	Pacifica	Pacifica	NNP
5180	1485	3	,	,	,
5180	1485	4	438	438	CD
5180	1485	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1485	6	at	at	IN
5180	1485	7	749	749	CD
5180	1485	8	n.27	n.27	NNP
5180	1485	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1485	10	"	"	``
5180	1485	11	Outside	outside	IN
5180	1485	12	the	the	DT
5180	1485	13	home	home	NN
5180	1485	14	,	,	,
5180	1485	15	the	the	DT
5180	1485	16	balance	balance	NN
5180	1485	17	between	between	IN
5180	1485	18	the	the	DT
5180	1485	19	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1485	20	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	1485	21	and	and	CC
5180	1485	22	the	the	DT
5180	1485	23	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1485	24	audience	audience	NN
5180	1485	25	may	may	MD
5180	1485	26	sometimes	sometimes	RB
5180	1485	27	tip	tip	VB
5180	1485	28	in	in	IN
5180	1485	29	favor	favor	NN
5180	1485	30	of	of	IN
5180	1485	31	the	the	DT
5180	1485	32	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	1485	33	,	,	,
5180	1485	34	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1485	35	the	the	DT
5180	1485	36	offended	offend	VBN
5180	1485	37	listener	listener	NN
5180	1485	38	to	to	TO
5180	1485	39	turn	turn	VB
5180	1485	40	away	away	RB
5180	1485	41	.	.	.
5180	1485	42	"	"	''
5180	1485	43	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1486	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1486	2	emphasis	emphasis	NN
5180	1486	3	added	add	VBN
5180	1486	4	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1486	5	.	.	.
5180	1487	1	Under	under	IN
5180	1487	2	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1487	3	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
5180	1487	4	,	,	,
5180	1487	5	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1487	6	a	a	DT
5180	1487	7	public	public	JJ
5180	1487	8	library	library	NN
5180	1487	9	might	may	MD
5180	1487	10	have	have	VB
5180	1487	11	a	a	DT
5180	1487	12	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1487	13	interest	interest	NN
5180	1487	14	in	in	IN
5180	1487	15	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1487	16	library	library	NN
5180	1487	17	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1487	18	and	and	CC
5180	1487	19	staff	staff	NN
5180	1487	20	from	from	IN
5180	1487	21	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1487	22	exposure	exposure	NN
5180	1487	23	to	to	IN
5180	1487	24	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1487	25	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1487	26	speech	speech	NN
5180	1487	27	that	that	WDT
5180	1487	28	,	,	,
5180	1487	29	although	although	IN
5180	1487	30	not	not	RB
5180	1487	31	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1487	32	,	,	,
5180	1487	33	is	be	VBZ
5180	1487	34	patently	patently	RB
5180	1487	35	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1487	36	.	.	.
5180	1488	1	3	3	LS
5180	1488	2	.	.	.
5180	1489	1	Preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1489	2	Unlawful	unlawful	JJ
5180	1489	3	or	or	CC
5180	1489	4	Inappropriate	inappropriate	JJ
5180	1489	5	Conduct	conduct	NN
5180	1489	6	Several	several	JJ
5180	1489	7	of	of	IN
5180	1489	8	the	the	DT
5180	1489	9	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	1489	10	proffered	proffer	VBN
5180	1489	11	by	by	IN
5180	1489	12	the	the	DT
5180	1489	13	government	government	NN
5180	1489	14	testified	testify	VBD
5180	1489	15	that	that	IN
5180	1489	16	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	1489	17	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1489	18	access	access	NN
5180	1489	19	had	have	VBD
5180	1489	20	led	lead	VBN
5180	1489	21	to	to	IN
5180	1489	22	occurrences	occurrence	NNS
5180	1489	23	of	of	IN
5180	1489	24	criminal	criminal	JJ
5180	1489	25	or	or	CC
5180	1489	26	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1489	27	inappropriate	inappropriate	JJ
5180	1489	28	conduct	conduct	NN
5180	1489	29	by	by	IN
5180	1489	30	library	library	NN
5180	1489	31	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1489	32	,	,	,
5180	1489	33	such	such	JJ
5180	1489	34	as	as	IN
5180	1489	35	public	public	JJ
5180	1489	36	masturbation	masturbation	NN
5180	1489	37	,	,	,
5180	1489	38	and	and	CC
5180	1489	39	harassment	harassment	NN
5180	1489	40	of	of	IN
5180	1489	41	library	library	NN
5180	1489	42	staff	staff	NN
5180	1489	43	and	and	CC
5180	1489	44	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1489	45	,	,	,
5180	1489	46	sometimes	sometimes	RB
5180	1489	47	rising	rise	VBG
5180	1489	48	to	to	IN
5180	1489	49	the	the	DT
5180	1489	50	level	level	NN
5180	1489	51	of	of	IN
5180	1489	52	physical	physical	JJ
5180	1489	53	assault	assault	NN
5180	1489	54	.	.	.
5180	1490	1	As	as	IN
5180	1490	2	in	in	IN
5180	1490	3	the	the	DT
5180	1490	4	case	case	NN
5180	1490	5	with	with	IN
5180	1490	6	patron	patron	NN
5180	1490	7	complaints	complaint	NNS
5180	1490	8	,	,	,
5180	1490	9	however	however	RB
5180	1490	10	,	,	,
5180	1490	11	the	the	DT
5180	1490	12	government	government	NN
5180	1490	13	adduced	adduce	VBD
5180	1490	14	no	no	DT
5180	1490	15	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
5180	1490	16	data	datum	NNS
5180	1490	17	comparing	compare	VBG
5180	1490	18	the	the	DT
5180	1490	19	frequency	frequency	NN
5180	1490	20	of	of	IN
5180	1490	21	criminal	criminal	JJ
5180	1490	22	or	or	CC
5180	1490	23	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1490	24	inappropriate	inappropriate	JJ
5180	1490	25	patron	patron	NN
5180	1490	26	conduct	conduct	NN
5180	1490	27	before	before	IN
5180	1490	28	the	the	DT
5180	1490	29	library	library	NN
5180	1490	30	's	's	POS
5180	1490	31	use	use	NN
5180	1490	32	of	of	IN
5180	1490	33	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1490	34	and	and	CC
5180	1490	35	after	after	IN
5180	1490	36	the	the	DT
5180	1490	37	library	library	NN
5180	1490	38	's	's	POS
5180	1490	39	use	use	NN
5180	1490	40	of	of	IN
5180	1490	41	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1490	42	.	.	.
5180	1491	1	The	the	DT
5180	1491	2	sporadic	sporadic	JJ
5180	1491	3	anecdotal	anecdotal	JJ
5180	1491	4	accounts	account	NNS
5180	1491	5	of	of	IN
5180	1491	6	the	the	DT
5180	1491	7	government	government	NN
5180	1491	8	's	's	POS
5180	1491	9	library	library	NN
5180	1491	10	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	1491	11	were	be	VBD
5180	1491	12	countered	counter	VBN
5180	1491	13	by	by	IN
5180	1491	14	anecdotal	anecdotal	JJ
5180	1491	15	accounts	account	NNS
5180	1491	16	by	by	IN
5180	1491	17	the	the	DT
5180	1491	18	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1491	19	'	'	POS
5180	1491	20	library	library	NN
5180	1491	21	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	1491	22	,	,	,
5180	1491	23	that	that	IN
5180	1491	24	incidents	incident	NNS
5180	1491	25	of	of	IN
5180	1491	26	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1491	27	patron	patron	NN
5180	1491	28	behavior	behavior	NN
5180	1491	29	in	in	IN
5180	1491	30	public	public	JJ
5180	1491	31	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1491	32	have	have	VBP
5180	1491	33	long	long	RB
5180	1491	34	predated	predate	VBN
5180	1491	35	the	the	DT
5180	1491	36	advent	advent	NN
5180	1491	37	of	of	IN
5180	1491	38	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1491	39	access	access	NN
5180	1491	40	.	.	.
5180	1492	1	Aside	aside	RB
5180	1492	2	from	from	IN
5180	1492	3	a	a	DT
5180	1492	4	public	public	JJ
5180	1492	5	library	library	NN
5180	1492	6	's	's	POS
5180	1492	7	interest	interest	NN
5180	1492	8	in	in	IN
5180	1492	9	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1492	10	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1492	11	from	from	IN
5180	1492	12	using	use	VBG
5180	1492	13	the	the	DT
5180	1492	14	library	library	NN
5180	1492	15	's	's	POS
5180	1492	16	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1492	17	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1492	18	to	to	TO
5180	1492	19	receive	receive	VB
5180	1492	20	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1492	21	or	or	CC
5180	1492	22	child	child	NN
5180	1492	23	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1492	24	,	,	,
5180	1492	25	which	which	WDT
5180	1492	26	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
5180	1492	27	criminal	criminal	JJ
5180	1492	28	conduct	conduct	NN
5180	1492	29	,	,	,
5180	1492	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1492	31	are	be	VBP
5180	1492	32	constrained	constrain	VBN
5180	1492	33	to	to	TO
5180	1492	34	reject	reject	VB
5180	1492	35	any	any	DT
5180	1492	36	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1492	37	state	state	NN
5180	1492	38	interest	interest	NN
5180	1492	39	in	in	IN
5180	1492	40	regulating	regulate	VBG
5180	1492	41	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1492	42	'	'	POS
5180	1492	43	conduct	conduct	NN
5180	1492	44	as	as	IN
5180	1492	45	a	a	DT
5180	1492	46	justification	justification	NN
5180	1492	47	for	for	IN
5180	1492	48	content	content	NN
5180	1492	49	-	-	HYPH
5180	1492	50	based	base	VBN
5180	1492	51	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1492	52	on	on	IN
5180	1492	53	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1492	54	'	'	POS
5180	1492	55	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1492	56	access	access	NN
5180	1492	57	.	.	.
5180	1493	1	"	"	``
5180	1493	2	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1493	3	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	1493	4	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1493	5	's	's	POS
5180	1493	6	First	First	NNP
5180	1493	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1493	8	cases	case	NNS
5180	1493	9	draw	draw	VBP
5180	1493	10	vital	vital	JJ
5180	1493	11	distinctions	distinction	NNS
5180	1493	12	between	between	IN
5180	1493	13	words	word	NNS
5180	1493	14	and	and	CC
5180	1493	15	deeds	deed	NNS
5180	1493	16	,	,	,
5180	1493	17	between	between	IN
5180	1493	18	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	1493	19	and	and	CC
5180	1493	20	conduct	conduct	NN
5180	1493	21	.	.	.
5180	1493	22	"	"	''
5180	1494	1	Ashcroft	Ashcroft	NNP
5180	1494	2	,	,	,
5180	1494	3	122	122	CD
5180	1494	4	S.	S.	NNP
5180	1494	5	Ct	Ct	NNP
5180	1494	6	.	.	.
5180	1494	7	at	at	IN
5180	1494	8	1403	1403	CD
5180	1494	9	.	.	.
5180	1495	1	First	First	NNP
5180	1495	2	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1495	3	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
5180	1495	4	makes	make	VBZ
5180	1495	5	clear	clear	JJ
5180	1495	6	that	that	IN
5180	1495	7	speech	speech	NN
5180	1495	8	may	may	MD
5180	1495	9	not	not	RB
5180	1495	10	be	be	VB
5180	1495	11	restricted	restrict	VBN
5180	1495	12	on	on	IN
5180	1495	13	the	the	DT
5180	1495	14	ground	ground	NN
5180	1495	15	that	that	IN
5180	1495	16	restricting	restrict	VBG
5180	1495	17	speech	speech	NN
5180	1495	18	will	will	MD
5180	1495	19	reduce	reduce	VB
5180	1495	20	crime	crime	NN
5180	1495	21	or	or	CC
5180	1495	22	other	other	JJ
5180	1495	23	undesirable	undesirable	JJ
5180	1495	24	behavior	behavior	NN
5180	1495	25	that	that	WDT
5180	1495	26	the	the	DT
5180	1495	27	speech	speech	NN
5180	1495	28	is	be	VBZ
5180	1495	29	thought	think	VBN
5180	1495	30	to	to	TO
5180	1495	31	cause	cause	VB
5180	1495	32	,	,	,
5180	1495	33	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1495	34	to	to	IN
5180	1495	35	only	only	RB
5180	1495	36	a	a	DT
5180	1495	37	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1495	38	exception	exception	NN
5180	1495	39	for	for	IN
5180	1495	40	speech	speech	NN
5180	1495	41	that	that	IN
5180	1495	42	"	"	``
5180	1495	43	is	be	VBZ
5180	1495	44	directed	direct	VBN
5180	1495	45	to	to	IN
5180	1495	46	inciting	incite	VBG
5180	1495	47	or	or	CC
5180	1495	48	producing	produce	VBG
5180	1495	49	imminent	imminent	JJ
5180	1495	50	lawless	lawless	JJ
5180	1495	51	action	action	NN
5180	1495	52	and	and	CC
5180	1495	53	is	be	VBZ
5180	1495	54	likely	likely	JJ
5180	1495	55	to	to	TO
5180	1495	56	incite	incite	VB
5180	1495	57	or	or	CC
5180	1495	58	produce	produce	VB
5180	1495	59	such	such	JJ
5180	1495	60	action	action	NN
5180	1495	61	.	.	.
5180	1495	62	"	"	''
5180	1496	1	Brandenburg	Brandenburg	NNP
5180	1496	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1496	3	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
5180	1496	4	,	,	,
5180	1496	5	395	395	CD
5180	1496	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1496	7	444	444	CD
5180	1496	8	,	,	,
5180	1496	9	447	447	CD
5180	1496	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1496	11	1969	1969	CD
5180	1496	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1496	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1496	14	per	per	IN
5180	1496	15	curiam	curiam	NN
5180	1496	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1496	17	.	.	.
5180	1497	1	"	"	``
5180	1497	2	The	the	DT
5180	1497	3	mere	mere	JJ
5180	1497	4	tendency	tendency	NN
5180	1497	5	of	of	IN
5180	1497	6	speech	speech	NN
5180	1497	7	to	to	TO
5180	1497	8	encourage	encourage	VB
5180	1497	9	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
5180	1497	10	acts	act	NNS
5180	1497	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	1497	12	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
5180	1497	13	reason	reason	NN
5180	1497	14	for	for	IN
5180	1497	15	banning	ban	VBG
5180	1497	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1497	17	.	.	.
5180	1497	18	"	"	''
5180	1498	1	Ashcroft	Ashcroft	NNP
5180	1498	2	,	,	,
5180	1498	3	122	122	CD
5180	1498	4	S.	S.	NNP
5180	1498	5	Ct	Ct	NNP
5180	1498	6	.	.	.
5180	1498	7	at	at	IN
5180	1498	8	1403	1403	CD
5180	1498	9	.	.	.
5180	1499	1	Outside	outside	IN
5180	1499	2	of	of	IN
5180	1499	3	the	the	DT
5180	1499	4	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1499	5	"	"	``
5180	1499	6	incitement	incitement	JJ
5180	1499	7	"	"	''
5180	1499	8	exception	exception	NN
5180	1499	9	,	,	,
5180	1499	10	the	the	DT
5180	1499	11	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1499	12	method	method	NN
5180	1499	13	of	of	IN
5180	1499	14	deterring	deter	VBG
5180	1499	15	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
5180	1499	16	or	or	CC
5180	1499	17	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1499	18	undesirable	undesirable	JJ
5180	1499	19	behavior	behavior	NN
5180	1499	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	1499	21	not	not	RB
5180	1499	22	to	to	TO
5180	1499	23	suppress	suppress	VB
5180	1499	24	the	the	DT
5180	1499	25	speech	speech	NN
5180	1499	26	that	that	WDT
5180	1499	27	induces	induce	VBZ
5180	1499	28	such	such	JJ
5180	1499	29	behavior	behavior	NN
5180	1499	30	,	,	,
5180	1499	31	but	but	CC
5180	1499	32	to	to	TO
5180	1499	33	attach	attach	VB
5180	1499	34	sanctions	sanction	NNS
5180	1499	35	to	to	IN
5180	1499	36	the	the	DT
5180	1499	37	behavior	behavior	NN
5180	1499	38	itself	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1499	39	.	.	.
5180	1500	1	"	"	``
5180	1500	2	Among	among	IN
5180	1500	3	free	free	JJ
5180	1500	4	men	man	NNS
5180	1500	5	,	,	,
5180	1500	6	the	the	DT
5180	1500	7	deterrents	deterrent	NNS
5180	1500	8	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
5180	1500	9	to	to	TO
5180	1500	10	be	be	VB
5180	1500	11	applied	apply	VBN
5180	1500	12	to	to	TO
5180	1500	13	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	1500	14	crime	crime	NN
5180	1500	15	are	be	VBP
5180	1500	16	education	education	NN
5180	1500	17	and	and	CC
5180	1500	18	punishment	punishment	NN
5180	1500	19	for	for	IN
5180	1500	20	violations	violation	NNS
5180	1500	21	of	of	IN
5180	1500	22	the	the	DT
5180	1500	23	law	law	NN
5180	1500	24	,	,	,
5180	1500	25	not	not	RB
5180	1500	26	abridgement	abridgement	JJ
5180	1500	27	of	of	IN
5180	1500	28	the	the	DT
5180	1500	29	rights	right	NNS
5180	1500	30	of	of	IN
5180	1500	31	free	free	JJ
5180	1500	32	speech	speech	NN
5180	1500	33	.	.	.
5180	1500	34	"	"	''
5180	1501	1	Kingsley	Kingsley	NNP
5180	1501	2	Int'l	Int'l	NNP
5180	1501	3	Pictures	Pictures	NNP
5180	1501	4	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
5180	1501	5	v.	v.	IN
5180	1501	6	Regents	Regents	NNPS
5180	1501	7	of	of	IN
5180	1501	8	the	the	DT
5180	1501	9	Univ	Univ	NNP
5180	1501	10	.	.	.
5180	1502	1	of	of	IN
5180	1502	2	the	the	DT
5180	1502	3	State	State	NNP
5180	1502	4	of	of	IN
5180	1502	5	New	New	NNP
5180	1502	6	York	York	NNP
5180	1502	7	,	,	,
5180	1502	8	360	360	CD
5180	1502	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1502	10	684	684	CD
5180	1502	11	,	,	,
5180	1502	12	689	689	CD
5180	1502	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1502	14	1959	1959	CD
5180	1502	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1502	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1502	17	quoting	quote	VBG
5180	1502	18	Whitney	Whitney	NNP
5180	1502	19	v.	v.	IN
5180	1503	1	Cal	Cal	NNP
5180	1503	2	.	.	NNP
5180	1503	3	,	,	,
5180	1503	4	274	274	CD
5180	1503	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1503	6	357	357	CD
5180	1503	7	,	,	,
5180	1503	8	378	378	CD
5180	1503	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1503	10	1927	1927	CD
5180	1503	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1503	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1503	13	Brandeis	Brandeis	NNP
5180	1503	14	,	,	,
5180	1503	15	J.	J.	NNP
5180	1503	16	,	,	,
5180	1503	17	concurring	concur	VBG
5180	1503	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1503	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1503	20	;	;	:
5180	1503	21	see	see	VB
5180	1503	22	also	also	RB
5180	1503	23	Bartnicki	Bartnicki	NNP
5180	1503	24	v.	v.	IN
5180	1503	25	Vopper	Vopper	NNP
5180	1503	26	,	,	,
5180	1503	27	532	532	CD
5180	1503	28	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1503	29	514	514	CD
5180	1503	30	,	,	,
5180	1503	31	529	529	CD
5180	1503	32	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1503	33	2001	2001	CD
5180	1503	34	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1503	35	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1503	36	"	"	``
5180	1503	37	The	the	DT
5180	1503	38	normal	normal	JJ
5180	1503	39	method	method	NN
5180	1503	40	of	of	IN
5180	1503	41	deterring	deter	VBG
5180	1503	42	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
5180	1503	43	conduct	conduct	NN
5180	1503	44	is	be	VBZ
5180	1503	45	to	to	TO
5180	1503	46	impose	impose	VB
5180	1503	47	an	an	DT
5180	1503	48	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1503	49	punishment	punishment	NN
5180	1503	50	on	on	IN
5180	1503	51	the	the	DT
5180	1503	52	person	person	NN
5180	1503	53	who	who	WP
5180	1503	54	engages	engage	VBZ
5180	1503	55	in	in	IN
5180	1503	56	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1503	57	.	.	.
5180	1503	58	"	"	''
5180	1503	59	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1503	60	.	.	.
5180	1504	1	4	4	LS
5180	1504	2	.	.	.
5180	1505	1	Summary	Summary	NNP
5180	1505	2	In	in	IN
5180	1505	3	sum	sum	NN
5180	1505	4	,	,	,
5180	1505	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1505	6	reject	reject	VBP
5180	1505	7	a	a	DT
5180	1505	8	public	public	JJ
5180	1505	9	library	library	NN
5180	1505	10	's	's	POS
5180	1505	11	interest	interest	NN
5180	1505	12	in	in	IN
5180	1505	13	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1505	14	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
5180	1505	15	or	or	CC
5180	1505	16	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1505	17	inappropriate	inappropriate	JJ
5180	1505	18	patron	patron	NN
5180	1505	19	conduct	conduct	NN
5180	1505	20	as	as	IN
5180	1505	21	a	a	DT
5180	1505	22	basis	basis	NN
5180	1505	23	for	for	IN
5180	1505	24	restricting	restrict	VBG
5180	1505	25	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1505	26	'	'	POS
5180	1505	27	access	access	NN
5180	1505	28	to	to	IN
5180	1505	29	speech	speech	NN
5180	1505	30	on	on	IN
5180	1505	31	the	the	DT
5180	1505	32	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1505	33	.	.	.
5180	1506	1	The	the	DT
5180	1506	2	proper	proper	JJ
5180	1506	3	method	method	NN
5180	1506	4	for	for	IN
5180	1506	5	a	a	DT
5180	1506	6	library	library	NN
5180	1506	7	to	to	TO
5180	1506	8	deter	deter	VB
5180	1506	9	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
5180	1506	10	or	or	CC
5180	1506	11	inappropriate	inappropriate	JJ
5180	1506	12	patron	patron	NN
5180	1506	13	conduct	conduct	NN
5180	1506	14	,	,	,
5180	1506	15	such	such	JJ
5180	1506	16	as	as	IN
5180	1506	17	harassment	harassment	NN
5180	1506	18	or	or	CC
5180	1506	19	assault	assault	NN
5180	1506	20	of	of	IN
5180	1506	21	other	other	JJ
5180	1506	22	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1506	23	,	,	,
5180	1506	24	is	be	VBZ
5180	1506	25	to	to	TO
5180	1506	26	impose	impose	VB
5180	1506	27	sanctions	sanction	NNS
5180	1506	28	on	on	IN
5180	1506	29	such	such	JJ
5180	1506	30	conduct	conduct	NN
5180	1506	31	,	,	,
5180	1506	32	such	such	JJ
5180	1506	33	as	as	IN
5180	1506	34	either	either	CC
5180	1506	35	removing	remove	VBG
5180	1506	36	the	the	DT
5180	1506	37	patron	patron	NN
5180	1506	38	from	from	IN
5180	1506	39	the	the	DT
5180	1506	40	library	library	NN
5180	1506	41	,	,	,
5180	1506	42	revoking	revoke	VBG
5180	1506	43	the	the	DT
5180	1506	44	patron	patron	NN
5180	1506	45	's	's	POS
5180	1506	46	library	library	NN
5180	1506	47	privileges	privilege	NNS
5180	1506	48	,	,	,
5180	1506	49	or	or	CC
5180	1506	50	,	,	,
5180	1506	51	in	in	IN
5180	1506	52	the	the	DT
5180	1506	53	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1506	54	case	case	NN
5180	1506	55	,	,	,
5180	1506	56	calling	call	VBG
5180	1506	57	the	the	DT
5180	1506	58	police	police	NN
5180	1506	59	.	.	.
5180	1507	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1507	2	believe	believe	VBP
5180	1507	3	,	,	,
5180	1507	4	however	however	RB
5180	1507	5	,	,	,
5180	1507	6	that	that	IN
5180	1507	7	the	the	DT
5180	1507	8	state	state	NN
5180	1507	9	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1507	10	in	in	IN
5180	1507	11	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1507	12	the	the	DT
5180	1507	13	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1507	14	of	of	IN
5180	1507	15	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1507	16	,	,	,
5180	1507	17	child	child	NN
5180	1507	18	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1507	19	,	,	,
5180	1507	20	or	or	CC
5180	1507	21	in	in	IN
5180	1507	22	the	the	DT
5180	1507	23	case	case	NN
5180	1507	24	of	of	IN
5180	1507	25	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1507	26	,	,	,
5180	1507	27	material	material	NN
5180	1507	28	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1507	29	to	to	IN
5180	1507	30	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1507	31	,	,	,
5180	1507	32	and	and	CC
5180	1507	33	in	in	IN
5180	1507	34	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1507	35	library	library	NN
5180	1507	36	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1507	37	from	from	IN
5180	1507	38	being	be	VBG
5180	1507	39	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	1507	40	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1507	41	to	to	IN
5180	1507	42	offensive	offensive	NN
5180	1507	43	,	,	,
5180	1507	44	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1507	45	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1507	46	material	material	NN
5180	1507	47	,	,	,
5180	1507	48	could	could	MD
5180	1507	49	all	all	DT
5180	1507	50	justify	justify	VB
5180	1507	51	,	,	,
5180	1507	52	for	for	IN
5180	1507	53	First	First	NNP
5180	1507	54	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1507	55	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1507	56	,	,	,
5180	1507	57	a	a	DT
5180	1507	58	public	public	JJ
5180	1507	59	library	library	NN
5180	1507	60	's	's	POS
5180	1507	61	use	use	NN
5180	1507	62	of	of	IN
5180	1507	63	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1507	64	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1507	65	,	,	,
5180	1507	66	provided	provide	VBD
5180	1507	67	that	that	IN
5180	1507	68	use	use	NN
5180	1507	69	of	of	IN
5180	1507	70	such	such	JJ
5180	1507	71	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1507	72	is	be	VBZ
5180	1507	73	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1507	74	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1507	75	to	to	TO
5180	1507	76	further	further	RB
5180	1507	77	those	those	DT
5180	1507	78	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1507	79	,	,	,
5180	1507	80	and	and	CC
5180	1507	81	that	that	IN
5180	1507	82	no	no	DT
5180	1507	83	less	less	RBR
5180	1507	84	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1507	85	means	mean	NNS
5180	1507	86	of	of	IN
5180	1507	87	promoting	promote	VBG
5180	1507	88	those	those	DT
5180	1507	89	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1507	90	exist	exist	VBP
5180	1507	91	.	.	.
5180	1508	1	Accordingly	accordingly	RB
5180	1508	2	,	,	,
5180	1508	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1508	4	turn	turn	VBP
5180	1508	5	to	to	IN
5180	1508	6	the	the	DT
5180	1508	7	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1508	8	tailoring	tailoring	NN
5180	1508	9	question	question	NN
5180	1508	10	.	.	.
5180	1509	1	2	2	LS
5180	1509	2	.	.	.
5180	1510	1	Narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1510	2	Tailoring	tailoring	NN
5180	1510	3	Having	have	VBG
5180	1510	4	identified	identify	VBN
5180	1510	5	the	the	DT
5180	1510	6	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	1510	7	state	state	NN
5180	1510	8	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1510	9	that	that	WDT
5180	1510	10	could	could	MD
5180	1510	11	justify	justify	VB
5180	1510	12	content	content	NN
5180	1510	13	-	-	HYPH
5180	1510	14	based	base	VBN
5180	1510	15	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1510	16	on	on	IN
5180	1510	17	public	public	JJ
5180	1510	18	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1510	19	'	'	POS
5180	1510	20	provision	provision	NN
5180	1510	21	of	of	IN
5180	1510	22	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1510	23	access	access	NN
5180	1510	24	,	,	,
5180	1510	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1510	26	must	must	MD
5180	1510	27	determine	determine	VB
5180	1510	28	whether	whether	IN
5180	1510	29	a	a	DT
5180	1510	30	public	public	JJ
5180	1510	31	library	library	NN
5180	1510	32	's	's	POS
5180	1510	33	use	use	NN
5180	1510	34	of	of	IN
5180	1510	35	software	software	NN
5180	1510	36	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1510	37	is	be	VBZ
5180	1510	38	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1510	39	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1510	40	to	to	TO
5180	1510	41	further	further	RB
5180	1510	42	those	those	DT
5180	1510	43	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1510	44	.	.	.
5180	1511	1	"	"	``
5180	1511	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1511	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1511	4	not	not	RB
5180	1511	5	enough	enough	JJ
5180	1511	6	to	to	TO
5180	1511	7	show	show	VB
5180	1511	8	that	that	IN
5180	1511	9	the	the	DT
5180	1511	10	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1511	11	's	's	POS
5180	1511	12	ends	end	NNS
5180	1511	13	are	be	VBP
5180	1511	14	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1511	15	;	;	:
5180	1511	16	the	the	DT
5180	1511	17	means	mean	NNS
5180	1511	18	must	must	MD
5180	1511	19	be	be	VB
5180	1511	20	carefully	carefully	RB
5180	1511	21	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1511	22	to	to	TO
5180	1511	23	achieve	achieve	VB
5180	1511	24	those	those	DT
5180	1511	25	ends	end	NNS
5180	1511	26	.	.	.
5180	1511	27	"	"	''
5180	1512	1	Sable	sable	JJ
5180	1512	2	Communications	Communications	NNPS
5180	1512	3	of	of	IN
5180	1512	4	Cal	Cal	NNP
5180	1512	5	.	.	NNP
5180	1512	6	,	,	,
5180	1512	7	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1512	8	v.	v.	IN
5180	1512	9	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	1512	10	,	,	,
5180	1512	11	492	492	CD
5180	1512	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1512	13	115	115	CD
5180	1512	14	,	,	,
5180	1512	15	126	126	CD
5180	1512	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1512	17	1989	1989	CD
5180	1512	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1512	19	.	.	.
5180	1513	1	"	"	``
5180	1513	2	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1513	3	M]anifest	M]anifest	NNP
5180	1513	4	imprecision	imprecision	NN
5180	1513	5	of	of	IN
5180	1513	6	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1513	7	a	a	DT
5180	1513	8	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1513	9	ban	ban	NN
5180	1513	10	.	.	.
5180	1514	1	.	.	.
5180	1515	1	.	.	.
5180	1516	1	reveals	reveal	VBZ
5180	1516	2	that	that	IN
5180	1516	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1516	4	proscription	proscription	NN
5180	1516	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	1516	6	not	not	RB
5180	1516	7	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
5180	1516	8	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1516	9	to	to	IN
5180	1516	10	the	the	DT
5180	1516	11	harms	harm	NNS
5180	1516	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1516	13	seeks	seek	VBZ
5180	1516	14	to	to	TO
5180	1516	15	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	1516	16	to	to	IN
5180	1516	17	justify	justify	VB
5180	1516	18	.	.	.
5180	1517	1	.	.	.
5180	1518	1	.	.	.
5180	1519	1	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1519	2	interference	interference	NN
5180	1519	3	with	with	IN
5180	1519	4	.	.	.
5180	1520	1	.	.	.
5180	1521	1	.	.	.
5180	1522	1	speech	speech	NN
5180	1522	2	.	.	.
5180	1522	3	"	"	''
5180	1523	1	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	1523	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1523	3	League	League	NNP
5180	1523	4	of	of	IN
5180	1523	5	Women	Women	NNP
5180	1523	6	Voters	Voters	NNPS
5180	1523	7	of	of	IN
5180	1523	8	Cal	Cal	NNP
5180	1523	9	.	.	NNP
5180	1523	10	,	,	,
5180	1523	11	468	468	CD
5180	1523	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1523	13	364	364	CD
5180	1523	14	,	,	,
5180	1523	15	392	392	CD
5180	1523	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1523	17	1984	1984	CD
5180	1523	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1523	19	.	.	.
5180	1524	1	The	the	DT
5180	1524	2	commercially	commercially	RB
5180	1524	3	available	available	JJ
5180	1524	4	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1524	5	on	on	IN
5180	1524	6	which	which	WDT
5180	1524	7	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	1524	8	was	be	VBD
5180	1524	9	presented	present	VBN
5180	1524	10	at	at	IN
5180	1524	11	trial	trial	NN
5180	1524	12	all	all	DT
5180	1524	13	block	block	NN
5180	1524	14	many	many	JJ
5180	1524	15	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	1524	16	of	of	IN
5180	1524	17	Web	web	NN
5180	1524	18	pages	page	NNS
5180	1524	19	that	that	WDT
5180	1524	20	are	be	VBP
5180	1524	21	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	1524	22	not	not	RB
5180	1524	23	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1524	24	to	to	IN
5180	1524	25	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1524	26	,	,	,
5180	1524	27	and	and	CC
5180	1524	28	many	many	JJ
5180	1524	29	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	1524	30	more	more	JJR
5180	1524	31	pages	page	NNS
5180	1524	32	that	that	WDT
5180	1524	33	,	,	,
5180	1524	34	while	while	IN
5180	1524	35	possibly	possibly	RB
5180	1524	36	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1524	37	to	to	IN
5180	1524	38	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1524	39	,	,	,
5180	1524	40	are	be	VBP
5180	1524	41	neither	neither	CC
5180	1524	42	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1524	43	nor	nor	CC
5180	1524	44	child	child	NN
5180	1524	45	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1524	46	.	.	.
5180	1525	1	See	see	VB
5180	1525	2	supra	supra	NNP
5180	1525	3	,	,	,
5180	1525	4	Subsection	Subsection	NNP
5180	1525	5	II.E.7	II.E.7	NNP
5180	1525	6	.	.	.
5180	1526	1	Even	even	RB
5180	1526	2	the	the	DT
5180	1526	3	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	1526	4	'	'	POS
5180	1526	5	own	own	JJ
5180	1526	6	expert	expert	NN
5180	1526	7	,	,	,
5180	1526	8	after	after	IN
5180	1526	9	analyzing	analyze	VBG
5180	1526	10	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	1526	11	products	product	NNS
5180	1526	12	'	'	POS
5180	1526	13	performance	performance	NN
5180	1526	14	in	in	IN
5180	1526	15	public	public	JJ
5180	1526	16	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1526	17	,	,	,
5180	1526	18	concluded	conclude	VBD
5180	1526	19	that	that	IN
5180	1526	20	of	of	IN
5180	1526	21	the	the	DT
5180	1526	22	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1526	23	Web	web	NN
5180	1526	24	pages	page	NNS
5180	1526	25	to	to	TO
5180	1526	26	which	which	WDT
5180	1526	27	library	library	NN
5180	1526	28	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1526	29	sought	seek	VBD
5180	1526	30	access	access	NN
5180	1526	31	,	,	,
5180	1526	32	between	between	IN
5180	1526	33	6	6	CD
5180	1526	34	%	%	NN
5180	1526	35	and	and	CC
5180	1526	36	15	15	CD
5180	1526	37	%	%	NN
5180	1526	38	contained	contain	VBD
5180	1526	39	no	no	DT
5180	1526	40	content	content	NN
5180	1526	41	that	that	WDT
5180	1526	42	meets	meet	VBZ
5180	1526	43	even	even	RB
5180	1526	44	the	the	DT
5180	1526	45	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	1526	46	products	product	NNS
5180	1526	47	'	'	POS
5180	1526	48	own	own	JJ
5180	1526	49	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	1526	50	of	of	IN
5180	1526	51	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1526	52	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1526	53	content	content	NN
5180	1526	54	,	,	,
5180	1526	55	let	let	VB
5180	1526	56	alone	alone	RB
5180	1526	57	the	the	DT
5180	1526	58	legal	legal	JJ
5180	1526	59	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	1526	60	of	of	IN
5180	1526	61	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1526	62	or	or	CC
5180	1526	63	child	child	NN
5180	1526	64	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1526	65	,	,	,
5180	1526	66	which	which	WDT
5180	1526	67	none	none	NN
5180	1526	68	of	of	IN
5180	1526	69	the	the	DT
5180	1526	70	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1526	71	companies	company	NNS
5180	1526	72	that	that	WDT
5180	1526	73	were	be	VBD
5180	1526	74	studied	study	VBN
5180	1526	75	use	use	NN
5180	1526	76	as	as	IN
5180	1526	77	the	the	DT
5180	1526	78	basis	basis	NN
5180	1526	79	for	for	IN
5180	1526	80	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1526	81	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1526	82	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1526	83	.	.	.
5180	1527	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	1527	2	,	,	,
5180	1527	3	in	in	IN
5180	1527	4	light	light	NN
5180	1527	5	of	of	IN
5180	1527	6	the	the	DT
5180	1527	7	flaws	flaw	NNS
5180	1527	8	in	in	IN
5180	1527	9	these	these	DT
5180	1527	10	studies	study	NNS
5180	1527	11	,	,	,
5180	1527	12	discussed	discuss	VBN
5180	1527	13	in	in	IN
5180	1527	14	detail	detail	NN
5180	1527	15	in	in	IN
5180	1527	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1527	17	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1527	18	of	of	IN
5180	1527	19	fact	fact	NN
5180	1527	20	above	above	IN
5180	1527	21	,	,	,
5180	1527	22	these	these	DT
5180	1527	23	percentages	percentage	NNS
5180	1527	24	significantly	significantly	RB
5180	1527	25	underestimate	underestimate	VBP
5180	1527	26	the	the	DT
5180	1527	27	amount	amount	NN
5180	1527	28	of	of	IN
5180	1527	29	speech	speech	NN
5180	1527	30	that	that	WDT
5180	1527	31	filters	filter	VBZ
5180	1527	32	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1527	33	block	block	VBP
5180	1527	34	,	,	,
5180	1527	35	and	and	CC
5180	1527	36	at	at	IN
5180	1527	37	best	good	JJS
5180	1527	38	provide	provide	VBP
5180	1527	39	a	a	DT
5180	1527	40	rough	rough	JJ
5180	1527	41	lower	low	JJR
5180	1527	42	bound	bind	VBN
5180	1527	43	on	on	IN
5180	1527	44	the	the	DT
5180	1527	45	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1527	46	'	'	POS
5180	1527	47	rates	rate	NNS
5180	1527	48	of	of	IN
5180	1527	49	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1527	50	.	.	.
5180	1528	1	Given	give	VBN
5180	1528	2	the	the	DT
5180	1528	3	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1528	4	amount	amount	NN
5180	1528	5	of	of	IN
5180	1528	6	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1528	7	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1528	8	speech	speech	NN
5180	1528	9	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1528	10	by	by	IN
5180	1528	11	the	the	DT
5180	1528	12	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1528	13	studied	study	VBD
5180	1528	14	,	,	,
5180	1528	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1528	16	conclude	conclude	VBP
5180	1528	17	that	that	IN
5180	1528	18	use	use	NN
5180	1528	19	of	of	IN
5180	1528	20	such	such	JJ
5180	1528	21	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1528	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	1528	23	not	not	RB
5180	1528	24	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1528	25	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1528	26	with	with	IN
5180	1528	27	respect	respect	NN
5180	1528	28	to	to	IN
5180	1528	29	the	the	DT
5180	1528	30	government	government	NN
5180	1528	31	's	's	POS
5180	1528	32	interest	interest	NN
5180	1528	33	in	in	IN
5180	1528	34	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1528	35	the	the	DT
5180	1528	36	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1528	37	of	of	IN
5180	1528	38	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1528	39	,	,	,
5180	1528	40	child	child	NN
5180	1528	41	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1528	42	,	,	,
5180	1528	43	and	and	CC
5180	1528	44	material	material	NN
5180	1528	45	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1528	46	to	to	IN
5180	1528	47	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1528	48	.	.	.
5180	1529	1	To	to	TO
5180	1529	2	be	be	VB
5180	1529	3	sure	sure	JJ
5180	1529	4	,	,	,
5180	1529	5	the	the	DT
5180	1529	6	quantitative	quantitative	JJ
5180	1529	7	estimates	estimate	NNS
5180	1529	8	of	of	IN
5180	1529	9	the	the	DT
5180	1529	10	rates	rate	NNS
5180	1529	11	of	of	IN
5180	1529	12	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1529	13	apply	apply	VBP
5180	1529	14	only	only	RB
5180	1529	15	to	to	IN
5180	1529	16	those	those	DT
5180	1529	17	four	four	CD
5180	1529	18	commercially	commercially	RB
5180	1529	19	available	available	JJ
5180	1529	20	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1529	21	analyzed	analyze	VBN
5180	1529	22	by	by	IN
5180	1529	23	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1529	24	'	'	POS
5180	1529	25	and	and	CC
5180	1529	26	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	1529	27	'	'	POS
5180	1529	28	expert	expert	NN
5180	1529	29	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	1529	30	.	.	.
5180	1530	1	Nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	1530	2	,	,	,
5180	1530	3	given	give	VBN
5180	1530	4	the	the	DT
5180	1530	5	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	1530	6	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	1530	7	in	in	IN
5180	1530	8	the	the	DT
5180	1530	9	current	current	JJ
5180	1530	10	state	state	NN
5180	1530	11	of	of	IN
5180	1530	12	the	the	DT
5180	1530	13	art	art	NN
5180	1530	14	of	of	IN
5180	1530	15	automated	automate	VBN
5180	1530	16	classification	classification	NN
5180	1530	17	systems	system	NNS
5180	1530	18	,	,	,
5180	1530	19	and	and	CC
5180	1530	20	the	the	DT
5180	1530	21	limits	limit	NNS
5180	1530	22	of	of	IN
5180	1530	23	human	human	JJ
5180	1530	24	review	review	NN
5180	1530	25	in	in	IN
5180	1530	26	relation	relation	NN
5180	1530	27	to	to	IN
5180	1530	28	the	the	DT
5180	1530	29	size	size	NN
5180	1530	30	,	,	,
5180	1530	31	rate	rate	NN
5180	1530	32	of	of	IN
5180	1530	33	growth	growth	NN
5180	1530	34	,	,	,
5180	1530	35	and	and	CC
5180	1530	36	rate	rate	NN
5180	1530	37	of	of	IN
5180	1530	38	change	change	NN
5180	1530	39	of	of	IN
5180	1530	40	the	the	DT
5180	1530	41	Web	web	NN
5180	1530	42	,	,	,
5180	1530	43	there	there	EX
5180	1530	44	is	be	VBZ
5180	1530	45	a	a	DT
5180	1530	46	tradeoff	tradeoff	NN
5180	1530	47	between	between	IN
5180	1530	48	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	1530	49	and	and	CC
5180	1530	50	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1530	51	that	that	WDT
5180	1530	52	is	be	VBZ
5180	1530	53	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	1530	54	in	in	IN
5180	1530	55	any	any	DT
5180	1530	56	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1530	57	technology	technology	NN
5180	1530	58	,	,	,
5180	1530	59	as	as	IN
5180	1530	60	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1530	61	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1530	62	of	of	IN
5180	1530	63	fact	fact	NN
5180	1530	64	have	have	VBP
5180	1530	65	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBN
5180	1530	66	.	.	.
5180	1531	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1531	2	credit	credit	VBP
5180	1531	3	the	the	DT
5180	1531	4	testimony	testimony	NN
5180	1531	5	of	of	IN
5180	1531	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1531	7	'	'	POS
5180	1531	8	expert	expert	JJ
5180	1531	9	witness	witness	NN
5180	1531	10	,	,	,
5180	1531	11	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
5180	1531	12	Geoffrey	Geoffrey	NNP
5180	1531	13	Nunberg	Nunberg	NNP
5180	1531	14	,	,	,
5180	1531	15	that	that	IN
5180	1531	16	no	no	DT
5180	1531	17	software	software	NN
5180	1531	18	exists	exist	VBZ
5180	1531	19	that	that	WDT
5180	1531	20	can	can	MD
5180	1531	21	automatically	automatically	RB
5180	1531	22	distinguish	distinguish	VB
5180	1531	23	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1531	24	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	1531	25	that	that	WDT
5180	1531	26	are	be	VBP
5180	1531	27	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1531	28	,	,	,
5180	1531	29	child	child	NN
5180	1531	30	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1531	31	,	,	,
5180	1531	32	or	or	CC
5180	1531	33	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1531	34	to	to	IN
5180	1531	35	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1531	36	,	,	,
5180	1531	37	from	from	IN
5180	1531	38	those	those	DT
5180	1531	39	that	that	WDT
5180	1531	40	are	be	VBP
5180	1531	41	not	not	RB
5180	1531	42	.	.	.
5180	1532	1	Nor	nor	CC
5180	1532	2	can	can	MD
5180	1532	3	software	software	VB
5180	1532	4	,	,	,
5180	1532	5	through	through	IN
5180	1532	6	keyword	keyword	NNP
5180	1532	7	analysis	analysis	NNP
5180	1532	8	or	or	CC
5180	1532	9	more	more	RBR
5180	1532	10	sophisticated	sophisticated	JJ
5180	1532	11	techniques	technique	NNS
5180	1532	12	,	,	,
5180	1532	13	consistently	consistently	RB
5180	1532	14	distinguish	distinguish	JJ
5180	1532	15	web	web	NN
5180	1532	16	pages	page	NNS
5180	1532	17	that	that	WDT
5180	1532	18	contain	contain	VBP
5180	1532	19	such	such	JJ
5180	1532	20	content	content	NN
5180	1532	21	from	from	IN
5180	1532	22	web	web	NN
5180	1532	23	pages	page	NNS
5180	1532	24	that	that	WDT
5180	1532	25	do	do	VBP
5180	1532	26	not	not	RB
5180	1532	27	.	.	.
5180	1533	1	In	in	IN
5180	1533	2	light	light	NN
5180	1533	3	of	of	IN
5180	1533	4	the	the	DT
5180	1533	5	absence	absence	NN
5180	1533	6	of	of	IN
5180	1533	7	any	any	DT
5180	1533	8	automated	automate	VBN
5180	1533	9	method	method	NN
5180	1533	10	of	of	IN
5180	1533	11	classifying	classify	VBG
5180	1533	12	Web	web	NN
5180	1533	13	pages	page	NNS
5180	1533	14	,	,	,
5180	1533	15	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1533	16	companies	company	NNS
5180	1533	17	are	be	VBP
5180	1533	18	left	leave	VBN
5180	1533	19	with	with	IN
5180	1533	20	the	the	DT
5180	1533	21	Sisyphean	sisyphean	JJ
5180	1533	22	task	task	NN
5180	1533	23	of	of	IN
5180	1533	24	using	use	VBG
5180	1533	25	human	human	JJ
5180	1533	26	review	review	NN
5180	1533	27	to	to	TO
5180	1533	28	identify	identify	VB
5180	1533	29	,	,	,
5180	1533	30	from	from	IN
5180	1533	31	among	among	IN
5180	1533	32	the	the	DT
5180	1533	33	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	1533	34	two	two	CD
5180	1533	35	billion	billion	CD
5180	1533	36	web	web	NN
5180	1533	37	pages	page	NNS
5180	1533	38	that	that	WDT
5180	1533	39	exist	exist	VBP
5180	1533	40	,	,	,
5180	1533	41	the	the	DT
5180	1533	42	1.5	1.5	CD
5180	1533	43	million	million	CD
5180	1533	44	new	new	JJ
5180	1533	45	pages	page	NNS
5180	1533	46	that	that	WDT
5180	1533	47	are	be	VBP
5180	1533	48	created	create	VBN
5180	1533	49	daily	daily	RB
5180	1533	50	,	,	,
5180	1533	51	and	and	CC
5180	1533	52	the	the	DT
5180	1533	53	many	many	JJ
5180	1533	54	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	1533	55	of	of	IN
5180	1533	56	pages	page	NNS
5180	1533	57	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1533	58	content	content	NN
5180	1533	59	changes	change	NNS
5180	1533	60	from	from	IN
5180	1533	61	day	day	NN
5180	1533	62	to	to	IN
5180	1533	63	day	day	NN
5180	1533	64	,	,	,
5180	1533	65	those	those	DT
5180	1533	66	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1533	67	web	web	NN
5180	1533	68	pages	page	NNS
5180	1533	69	to	to	TO
5180	1533	70	be	be	VB
5180	1533	71	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1533	72	.	.	.
5180	1534	1	To	to	TO
5180	1534	2	cope	cope	VB
5180	1534	3	with	with	IN
5180	1534	4	the	the	DT
5180	1534	5	Web	web	NN
5180	1534	6	's	's	POS
5180	1534	7	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
5180	1534	8	size	size	NN
5180	1534	9	,	,	,
5180	1534	10	rate	rate	NN
5180	1534	11	of	of	IN
5180	1534	12	growth	growth	NN
5180	1534	13	,	,	,
5180	1534	14	and	and	CC
5180	1534	15	rate	rate	NN
5180	1534	16	of	of	IN
5180	1534	17	change	change	NN
5180	1534	18	,	,	,
5180	1534	19	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1534	20	companies	company	NNS
5180	1534	21	that	that	WDT
5180	1534	22	rely	rely	VBP
5180	1534	23	solely	solely	RB
5180	1534	24	on	on	IN
5180	1534	25	human	human	JJ
5180	1534	26	review	review	NN
5180	1534	27	to	to	TO
5180	1534	28	block	block	VB
5180	1534	29	access	access	NN
5180	1534	30	to	to	IN
5180	1534	31	material	material	NN
5180	1534	32	falling	fall	VBG
5180	1534	33	within	within	IN
5180	1534	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1534	35	category	category	NN
5180	1534	36	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	1534	37	must	must	MD
5180	1534	38	use	use	VB
5180	1534	39	a	a	DT
5180	1534	40	variety	variety	NN
5180	1534	41	of	of	IN
5180	1534	42	techniques	technique	NNS
5180	1534	43	that	that	WDT
5180	1534	44	will	will	MD
5180	1534	45	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	1534	46	introduce	introduce	VB
5180	1534	47	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1534	48	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	1534	49	of	of	IN
5180	1534	50	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1534	51	.	.	.
5180	1535	1	These	these	DT
5180	1535	2	techniques	technique	NNS
5180	1535	3	include	include	VBP
5180	1535	4	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1535	5	every	every	DT
5180	1535	6	page	page	NN
5180	1535	7	of	of	IN
5180	1535	8	a	a	DT
5180	1535	9	Web	web	NN
5180	1535	10	site	site	NN
5180	1535	11	that	that	WDT
5180	1535	12	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	1535	13	only	only	RB
5180	1535	14	some	some	DT
5180	1535	15	content	content	NN
5180	1535	16	falling	fall	VBG
5180	1535	17	within	within	IN
5180	1535	18	the	the	DT
5180	1535	19	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1535	20	companies	company	NNS
5180	1535	21	'	'	POS
5180	1535	22	category	category	NN
5180	1535	23	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	1535	24	,	,	,
5180	1535	25	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1535	26	every	every	DT
5180	1535	27	Web	web	NN
5180	1535	28	site	site	NN
5180	1535	29	that	that	WDT
5180	1535	30	shares	share	VBZ
5180	1535	31	an	an	DT
5180	1535	32	IP	IP	NNP
5180	1535	33	-	-	HYPH
5180	1535	34	address	address	NN
5180	1535	35	with	with	IN
5180	1535	36	a	a	DT
5180	1535	37	Web	web	NN
5180	1535	38	site	site	NN
5180	1535	39	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1535	40	content	content	NN
5180	1535	41	falls	fall	VBZ
5180	1535	42	within	within	IN
5180	1535	43	the	the	DT
5180	1535	44	category	category	NN
5180	1535	45	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	1535	46	,	,	,
5180	1535	47	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1535	48	"	"	``
5180	1535	49	loophole	loophole	NN
5180	1535	50	sites	site	NNS
5180	1535	51	,	,	,
5180	1535	52	"	"	''
5180	1535	53	such	such	JJ
5180	1535	54	as	as	IN
5180	1535	55	anonymizers	anonymizer	NNS
5180	1535	56	,	,	,
5180	1535	57	cache	cache	NNP
5180	1535	58	sites	site	NNS
5180	1535	59	,	,	,
5180	1535	60	and	and	CC
5180	1535	61	translation	translation	NN
5180	1535	62	sites	site	NNS
5180	1535	63	,	,	,
5180	1535	64	and	and	CC
5180	1535	65	allocating	allocate	VBG
5180	1535	66	staff	staff	NN
5180	1535	67	resources	resource	NNS
5180	1535	68	to	to	IN
5180	1535	69	reviewing	review	VBG
5180	1535	70	content	content	NN
5180	1535	71	of	of	IN
5180	1535	72	uncategorized	uncategorized	JJ
5180	1535	73	pages	page	NNS
5180	1535	74	rather	rather	RB
5180	1535	75	than	than	IN
5180	1535	76	re	re	VB
5180	1535	77	-	-	JJ
5180	1535	78	reviewing	reviewing	JJ
5180	1535	79	pages	page	NNS
5180	1535	80	,	,	,
5180	1535	81	domain	domain	NN
5180	1535	82	names	name	NNS
5180	1535	83	,	,	,
5180	1535	84	or	or	CC
5180	1535	85	IP	IP	NNP
5180	1535	86	-	-	HYPH
5180	1535	87	addresses	address	NNS
5180	1535	88	that	that	WDT
5180	1535	89	have	have	VBP
5180	1535	90	been	be	VBN
5180	1535	91	already	already	RB
5180	1535	92	categorized	categorize	VBN
5180	1535	93	to	to	TO
5180	1535	94	determine	determine	VB
5180	1535	95	whether	whether	IN
5180	1535	96	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1535	97	content	content	NN
5180	1535	98	has	have	VBZ
5180	1535	99	changed	change	VBN
5180	1535	100	.	.	.
5180	1536	1	While	while	IN
5180	1536	2	a	a	DT
5180	1536	3	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1536	4	company	company	NN
5180	1536	5	could	could	MD
5180	1536	6	choose	choose	VB
5180	1536	7	not	not	RB
5180	1536	8	to	to	TO
5180	1536	9	use	use	VB
5180	1536	10	these	these	DT
5180	1536	11	techniques	technique	NNS
5180	1536	12	,	,	,
5180	1536	13	due	due	IN
5180	1536	14	to	to	IN
5180	1536	15	the	the	DT
5180	1536	16	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1536	17	errors	error	NNS
5180	1536	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1536	19	introduce	introduce	VBP
5180	1536	20	,	,	,
5180	1536	21	if	if	IN
5180	1536	22	a	a	DT
5180	1536	23	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1536	24	company	company	NN
5180	1536	25	does	do	VBZ
5180	1536	26	not	not	RB
5180	1536	27	use	use	VB
5180	1536	28	such	such	JJ
5180	1536	29	techniques	technique	NNS
5180	1536	30	,	,	,
5180	1536	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1536	32	filter	filter	NN
5180	1536	33	will	will	MD
5180	1536	34	be	be	VB
5180	1536	35	ineffective	ineffective	JJ
5180	1536	36	at	at	IN
5180	1536	37	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1536	38	access	access	NN
5180	1536	39	to	to	IN
5180	1536	40	speech	speech	NN
5180	1536	41	that	that	WDT
5180	1536	42	falls	fall	VBZ
5180	1536	43	within	within	IN
5180	1536	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1536	45	category	category	NN
5180	1536	46	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	1536	47	.	.	.
5180	1537	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1537	2	,	,	,
5180	1537	3	while	while	IN
5180	1537	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1537	5	would	would	MD
5180	1537	6	be	be	VB
5180	1537	7	easy	easy	JJ
5180	1537	8	to	to	TO
5180	1537	9	design	design	VB
5180	1537	10	,	,	,
5180	1537	11	for	for	IN
5180	1537	12	example	example	NN
5180	1537	13	,	,	,
5180	1537	14	a	a	DT
5180	1537	15	filter	filter	NN
5180	1537	16	that	that	WDT
5180	1537	17	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	1537	18	only	only	RB
5180	1537	19	ten	ten	CD
5180	1537	20	Web	web	NN
5180	1537	21	sites	site	NNS
5180	1537	22	,	,	,
5180	1537	23	all	all	DT
5180	1537	24	of	of	IN
5180	1537	25	which	which	WDT
5180	1537	26	are	be	VBP
5180	1537	27	either	either	CC
5180	1537	28	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1537	29	,	,	,
5180	1537	30	child	child	NN
5180	1537	31	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1537	32	,	,	,
5180	1537	33	or	or	CC
5180	1537	34	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1537	35	to	to	IN
5180	1537	36	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1537	37	,	,	,
5180	1537	38	and	and	CC
5180	1537	39	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1537	40	completely	completely	RB
5180	1537	41	avoids	avoid	VBZ
5180	1537	42	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1537	43	,	,	,
5180	1537	44	such	such	PDT
5180	1537	45	a	a	DT
5180	1537	46	filter	filter	NN
5180	1537	47	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	1537	48	would	would	MD
5180	1537	49	not	not	RB
5180	1537	50	comply	comply	VB
5180	1537	51	with	with	IN
5180	1537	52	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1537	53	,	,	,
5180	1537	54	since	since	IN
5180	1537	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1537	56	would	would	MD
5180	1537	57	fail	fail	VB
5180	1537	58	to	to	TO
5180	1537	59	offer	offer	VB
5180	1537	60	any	any	DT
5180	1537	61	meaningful	meaningful	JJ
5180	1537	62	protection	protection	NN
5180	1537	63	against	against	IN
5180	1537	64	the	the	DT
5180	1537	65	hundreds	hundred	NNS
5180	1537	66	of	of	IN
5180	1537	67	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	1537	68	of	of	IN
5180	1537	69	Web	web	NN
5180	1537	70	sites	site	NNS
5180	1537	71	containing	contain	VBG
5180	1537	72	speech	speech	NN
5180	1537	73	in	in	IN
5180	1537	74	these	these	DT
5180	1537	75	categories	category	NNS
5180	1537	76	.	.	.
5180	1538	1	As	as	IN
5180	1538	2	detailed	detail	VBN
5180	1538	3	in	in	IN
5180	1538	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1538	5	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1538	6	of	of	IN
5180	1538	7	fact	fact	NN
5180	1538	8	,	,	,
5180	1538	9	any	any	DT
5180	1538	10	filter	filter	NN
5180	1538	11	that	that	WDT
5180	1538	12	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	1538	13	enough	enough	JJ
5180	1538	14	speech	speech	NN
5180	1538	15	to	to	TO
5180	1538	16	protect	protect	VB
5180	1538	17	against	against	IN
5180	1538	18	access	access	NN
5180	1538	19	to	to	IN
5180	1538	20	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1538	21	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	1538	22	that	that	WDT
5180	1538	23	are	be	VBP
5180	1538	24	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1538	25	,	,	,
5180	1538	26	child	child	NN
5180	1538	27	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1538	28	,	,	,
5180	1538	29	and	and	CC
5180	1538	30	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1538	31	to	to	IN
5180	1538	32	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1538	33	,	,	,
5180	1538	34	will	will	MD
5180	1538	35	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	1538	36	overblock	overblock	VB
5180	1538	37	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1538	38	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	1538	39	of	of	IN
5180	1538	40	speech	speech	NN
5180	1538	41	that	that	WDT
5180	1538	42	does	do	VBZ
5180	1538	43	not	not	RB
5180	1538	44	fall	fall	VB
5180	1538	45	within	within	IN
5180	1538	46	these	these	DT
5180	1538	47	categories	category	NNS
5180	1538	48	.	.	.
5180	1539	1	This	this	DT
5180	1539	2	finding	finding	NN
5180	1539	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1539	4	supported	support	VBN
5180	1539	5	by	by	IN
5180	1539	6	the	the	DT
5180	1539	7	government	government	NN
5180	1539	8	's	's	POS
5180	1539	9	failure	failure	NN
5180	1539	10	to	to	TO
5180	1539	11	produce	produce	VB
5180	1539	12	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	1539	13	of	of	IN
5180	1539	14	any	any	DT
5180	1539	15	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1539	16	technology	technology	NN
5180	1539	17	that	that	WDT
5180	1539	18	avoids	avoid	VBZ
5180	1539	19	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1539	20	a	a	DT
5180	1539	21	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1539	22	amount	amount	NN
5180	1539	23	of	of	IN
5180	1539	24	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1539	25	speech	speech	NN
5180	1539	26	.	.	.
5180	1540	1	Where	where	WRB
5180	1540	2	,	,	,
5180	1540	3	as	as	IN
5180	1540	4	here	here	RB
5180	1540	5	,	,	,
5180	1540	6	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1540	7	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1540	8	applies	apply	VBZ
5180	1540	9	to	to	IN
5180	1540	10	a	a	DT
5180	1540	11	content	content	NN
5180	1540	12	-	-	HYPH
5180	1540	13	based	base	VBN
5180	1540	14	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1540	15	on	on	IN
5180	1540	16	speech	speech	NN
5180	1540	17	,	,	,
5180	1540	18	the	the	DT
5180	1540	19	burden	burden	NN
5180	1540	20	rests	rest	VBZ
5180	1540	21	with	with	IN
5180	1540	22	the	the	DT
5180	1540	23	government	government	NN
5180	1540	24	to	to	TO
5180	1540	25	show	show	VB
5180	1540	26	that	that	IN
5180	1540	27	the	the	DT
5180	1540	28	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1540	29	is	be	VBZ
5180	1540	30	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1540	31	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1540	32	to	to	TO
5180	1540	33	serve	serve	VB
5180	1540	34	a	a	DT
5180	1540	35	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1540	36	government	government	NN
5180	1540	37	interest	interest	NN
5180	1540	38	.	.	.
5180	1541	1	See	see	VB
5180	1541	2	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1541	3	,	,	,
5180	1541	4	529	529	CD
5180	1541	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1541	6	at	at	IN
5180	1541	7	816	816	CD
5180	1541	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1541	9	"	"	``
5180	1541	10	When	when	WRB
5180	1541	11	the	the	DT
5180	1541	12	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1541	13	restricts	restrict	VBZ
5180	1541	14	speech	speech	NN
5180	1541	15	,	,	,
5180	1541	16	the	the	DT
5180	1541	17	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1541	18	bears	bear	VBZ
5180	1541	19	the	the	DT
5180	1541	20	burden	burden	NN
5180	1541	21	of	of	IN
5180	1541	22	proving	prove	VBG
5180	1541	23	the	the	DT
5180	1541	24	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
5180	1541	25	of	of	IN
5180	1541	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1541	27	actions	action	NNS
5180	1541	28	.	.	.
5180	1542	1	")	")	``
5180	1542	2	;	;	:
5180	1542	3	see	see	VB
5180	1542	4	also	also	RB
5180	1542	5	R.A.V.	R.A.V.	NNP
5180	1543	1	v.	v.	IN
5180	1543	2	City	City	NNP
5180	1543	3	of	of	IN
5180	1543	4	St.	St.	NNP
5180	1543	5	Paul	Paul	NNP
5180	1543	6	,	,	,
5180	1543	7	505	505	CD
5180	1543	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1543	9	377	377	CD
5180	1543	10	,	,	,
5180	1543	11	382	382	CD
5180	1543	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1543	13	1992	1992	CD
5180	1543	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1543	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1543	16	"	"	``
5180	1543	17	Content	content	NN
5180	1543	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	1543	19	based	base	VBN
5180	1543	20	regulations	regulation	NNS
5180	1543	21	are	be	VBP
5180	1543	22	presumptively	presumptively	RB
5180	1543	23	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1543	24	.	.	.
5180	1543	25	"	"	''
5180	1543	26	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1543	27	.	.	.
5180	1544	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1544	2	,	,	,
5180	1544	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1544	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	1544	5	the	the	DT
5180	1544	6	government	government	NN
5180	1544	7	's	's	POS
5180	1544	8	burden	burden	NN
5180	1544	9	,	,	,
5180	1544	10	in	in	IN
5180	1544	11	this	this	DT
5180	1544	12	case	case	NN
5180	1544	13	,	,	,
5180	1544	14	to	to	TO
5180	1544	15	show	show	VB
5180	1544	16	the	the	DT
5180	1544	17	existence	existence	NN
5180	1544	18	of	of	IN
5180	1544	19	a	a	DT
5180	1544	20	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1544	21	technology	technology	NN
5180	1544	22	that	that	IN
5180	1544	23	both	both	DT
5180	1544	24	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	1544	25	enough	enough	JJ
5180	1544	26	speech	speech	NN
5180	1544	27	to	to	TO
5180	1544	28	qualify	qualify	VB
5180	1544	29	as	as	IN
5180	1544	30	a	a	DT
5180	1544	31	technology	technology	NN
5180	1544	32	protection	protection	NN
5180	1544	33	measure	measure	NN
5180	1544	34	,	,	,
5180	1544	35	for	for	IN
5180	1544	36	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1544	37	of	of	IN
5180	1544	38	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1544	39	,	,	,
5180	1544	40	and	and	CC
5180	1544	41	avoids	avoid	NNS
5180	1544	42	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1544	43	a	a	DT
5180	1544	44	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1544	45	amount	amount	NN
5180	1544	46	of	of	IN
5180	1544	47	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1544	48	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1544	49	speech	speech	NN
5180	1544	50	.	.	.
5180	1545	1	Here	here	RB
5180	1545	2	,	,	,
5180	1545	3	the	the	DT
5180	1545	4	government	government	NN
5180	1545	5	has	have	VBZ
5180	1545	6	failed	fail	VBN
5180	1545	7	to	to	TO
5180	1545	8	meet	meet	VB
5180	1545	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1545	10	burden	burden	NN
5180	1545	11	.	.	.
5180	1546	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	1546	2	,	,	,
5180	1546	3	as	as	IN
5180	1546	4	discussed	discuss	VBN
5180	1546	5	in	in	IN
5180	1546	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1546	7	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1546	8	of	of	IN
5180	1546	9	fact	fact	NN
5180	1546	10	,	,	,
5180	1546	11	every	every	DT
5180	1546	12	technology	technology	NN
5180	1546	13	protection	protection	NN
5180	1546	14	measure	measure	NN
5180	1546	15	used	use	VBN
5180	1546	16	by	by	IN
5180	1546	17	the	the	DT
5180	1546	18	government	government	NN
5180	1546	19	's	's	POS
5180	1546	20	library	library	NN
5180	1546	21	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	1546	22	or	or	CC
5180	1546	23	analyzed	analyze	VBN
5180	1546	24	by	by	IN
5180	1546	25	the	the	DT
5180	1546	26	government	government	NN
5180	1546	27	's	's	POS
5180	1546	28	expert	expert	NN
5180	1546	29	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	1546	30	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	1546	31	access	access	NN
5180	1546	32	to	to	IN
5180	1546	33	a	a	DT
5180	1546	34	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1546	35	amount	amount	NN
5180	1546	36	of	of	IN
5180	1546	37	speech	speech	NN
5180	1546	38	that	that	WDT
5180	1546	39	is	be	VBZ
5180	1546	40	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1546	41	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1546	42	with	with	IN
5180	1546	43	respect	respect	NN
5180	1546	44	to	to	IN
5180	1546	45	both	both	DT
5180	1546	46	adults	adult	NNS
5180	1546	47	and	and	CC
5180	1546	48	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1546	49	.	.	.
5180	1547	1	In	in	IN
5180	1547	2	light	light	NN
5180	1547	3	of	of	IN
5180	1547	4	the	the	DT
5180	1547	5	credited	credited	JJ
5180	1547	6	testimony	testimony	NN
5180	1547	7	of	of	IN
5180	1547	8	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
5180	1547	9	Nunberg	Nunberg	NNP
5180	1547	10	,	,	,
5180	1547	11	and	and	CC
5180	1547	12	the	the	DT
5180	1547	13	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	1547	14	tradeoff	tradeoff	NN
5180	1547	15	between	between	IN
5180	1547	16	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1547	17	and	and	CC
5180	1547	18	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	1547	19	,	,	,
5180	1547	20	together	together	RB
5180	1547	21	with	with	IN
5180	1547	22	the	the	DT
5180	1547	23	government	government	NN
5180	1547	24	's	's	POS
5180	1547	25	failure	failure	NN
5180	1547	26	to	to	TO
5180	1547	27	offer	offer	VB
5180	1547	28	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	1547	29	of	of	IN
5180	1547	30	any	any	DT
5180	1547	31	technology	technology	NN
5180	1547	32	protection	protection	NN
5180	1547	33	measure	measure	NN
5180	1547	34	that	that	WDT
5180	1547	35	avoids	avoid	VBZ
5180	1547	36	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1547	37	,	,	,
5180	1547	38	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1547	39	conclude	conclude	VBP
5180	1547	40	that	that	IN
5180	1547	41	any	any	DT
5180	1547	42	technology	technology	NN
5180	1547	43	protection	protection	NN
5180	1547	44	measure	measure	NN
5180	1547	45	that	that	WDT
5180	1547	46	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	1547	47	a	a	DT
5180	1547	48	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
5180	1547	49	amount	amount	NN
5180	1547	50	of	of	IN
5180	1547	51	speech	speech	NN
5180	1547	52	to	to	TO
5180	1547	53	comply	comply	VB
5180	1547	54	with	with	IN
5180	1547	55	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1547	56	's	's	POS
5180	1547	57	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	1547	58	that	that	IN
5180	1547	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1547	60	"	"	``
5180	1547	61	protect	protect	VBP
5180	1547	62	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1547	63	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1547	64	against	against	IN
5180	1547	65	access	access	NN
5180	1547	66	through	through	IN
5180	1547	67	such	such	JJ
5180	1547	68	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1547	69	to	to	IN
5180	1547	70	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1547	71	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	1547	72	that	that	WDT
5180	1547	73	are	be	VBP
5180	1547	74	–	–	:
5180	1547	75	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1547	76	I	i	NN
5180	1547	77	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1547	78	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1547	79	;	;	:
5180	1547	80	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1547	81	II	II	NNP
5180	1547	82	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1547	83	child	child	NN
5180	1547	84	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1547	85	;	;	:
5180	1547	86	or	or	CC
5180	1547	87	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1547	88	III	III	NNP
5180	1547	89	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1547	90	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1547	91	to	to	IN
5180	1547	92	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1547	93	"	"	``
5180	1547	94	will	will	MD
5180	1547	95	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	1547	96	block	block	VB
5180	1547	97	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1547	98	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	1547	99	of	of	IN
5180	1547	100	speech	speech	NN
5180	1547	101	that	that	WDT
5180	1547	102	does	do	VBZ
5180	1547	103	not	not	RB
5180	1547	104	fall	fall	VB
5180	1547	105	within	within	IN
5180	1547	106	these	these	DT
5180	1547	107	categories	category	NNS
5180	1547	108	.	.	.
5180	1548	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1548	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1548	3	.	.	.
5180	1549	1	1712	1712	CD
5180	1549	2	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1549	3	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1549	4	at	at	IN
5180	1549	5	20	20	CD
5180	1549	6	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1550	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1550	2	.	.	.
5180	1551	1	9134(f)(1)(A	9134(f)(1)(A	NNP
5180	1551	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1551	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1551	4	.	.	.
5180	1552	1	Hence	hence	RB
5180	1552	2	,	,	,
5180	1552	3	any	any	DT
5180	1552	4	public	public	JJ
5180	1552	5	library	library	NN
5180	1552	6	's	's	POS
5180	1552	7	use	use	NN
5180	1552	8	of	of	IN
5180	1552	9	a	a	DT
5180	1552	10	software	software	NN
5180	1552	11	filter	filter	NN
5180	1552	12	required	require	VBN
5180	1552	13	by	by	IN
5180	1552	14	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1552	15	will	will	MD
5180	1552	16	fail	fail	VB
5180	1552	17	to	to	TO
5180	1552	18	be	be	VB
5180	1552	19	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1552	20	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1552	21	to	to	IN
5180	1552	22	the	the	DT
5180	1552	23	government	government	NN
5180	1552	24	's	's	POS
5180	1552	25	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1552	26	interest	interest	NN
5180	1552	27	in	in	IN
5180	1552	28	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1552	29	the	the	DT
5180	1552	30	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1552	31	,	,	,
5180	1552	32	through	through	IN
5180	1552	33	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1552	34	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1552	35	in	in	IN
5180	1552	36	public	public	JJ
5180	1552	37	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1552	38	,	,	,
5180	1552	39	of	of	IN
5180	1552	40	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1552	41	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	1552	42	that	that	WDT
5180	1552	43	are	be	VBP
5180	1552	44	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1552	45	,	,	,
5180	1552	46	child	child	NN
5180	1552	47	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1552	48	,	,	,
5180	1552	49	or	or	CC
5180	1552	50	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1552	51	to	to	IN
5180	1552	52	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1552	53	.	.	.
5180	1553	1	Where	where	WRB
5180	1553	2	,	,	,
5180	1553	3	as	as	IN
5180	1553	4	here	here	RB
5180	1553	5	,	,	,
5180	1553	6	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1553	7	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1553	8	applies	apply	VBZ
5180	1553	9	,	,	,
5180	1553	10	the	the	DT
5180	1553	11	government	government	NN
5180	1553	12	may	may	MD
5180	1553	13	not	not	RB
5180	1553	14	justify	justify	VB
5180	1553	15	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1553	16	on	on	IN
5180	1553	17	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1553	18	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1553	19	speech	speech	NN
5180	1553	20	on	on	IN
5180	1553	21	the	the	DT
5180	1553	22	ground	ground	NN
5180	1553	23	that	that	IN
5180	1553	24	such	such	JJ
5180	1553	25	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1553	26	are	be	VBP
5180	1553	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	1553	28	in	in	IN
5180	1553	29	order	order	NN
5180	1553	30	for	for	IN
5180	1553	31	the	the	DT
5180	1553	32	government	government	NN
5180	1553	33	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	1553	34	to	to	TO
5180	1553	35	suppress	suppress	VB
5180	1553	36	the	the	DT
5180	1553	37	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1553	38	of	of	IN
5180	1553	39	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1553	40	unprotected	unprotected	JJ
5180	1553	41	speech	speech	NN
5180	1553	42	,	,	,
5180	1553	43	such	such	JJ
5180	1553	44	as	as	IN
5180	1553	45	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1553	46	and	and	CC
5180	1553	47	child	child	NN
5180	1553	48	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1553	49	.	.	.
5180	1554	1	"	"	``
5180	1554	2	The	the	DT
5180	1554	3	argument	argument	NN
5180	1554	4	.	.	.
5180	1555	1	.	.	.
5180	1556	1	.	.	.
5180	1557	1	that	that	DT
5180	1557	2	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1557	3	speech	speech	NN
5180	1557	4	may	may	MD
5180	1557	5	be	be	VB
5180	1557	6	banned	ban	VBN
5180	1557	7	as	as	IN
5180	1557	8	a	a	DT
5180	1557	9	means	means	NN
5180	1557	10	to	to	TO
5180	1557	11	ban	ban	VB
5180	1557	12	unprotected	unprotected	JJ
5180	1557	13	speech	speech	NN
5180	1557	14	.	.	.
5180	1558	1	.	.	.
5180	1559	1	.	.	.
5180	1560	1	.	.	.
5180	1561	1	turns	turn	VBZ
5180	1561	2	the	the	DT
5180	1561	3	First	First	NNP
5180	1561	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1561	5	upside	upside	RB
5180	1561	6	down	down	RB
5180	1561	7	.	.	.
5180	1562	1	The	the	DT
5180	1562	2	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1562	3	may	may	MD
5180	1562	4	not	not	RB
5180	1562	5	suppress	suppress	VB
5180	1562	6	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	1562	7	speech	speech	NN
5180	1562	8	as	as	IN
5180	1562	9	the	the	DT
5180	1562	10	means	mean	NNS
5180	1562	11	to	to	TO
5180	1562	12	suppress	suppress	VB
5180	1562	13	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
5180	1562	14	speech	speech	NN
5180	1562	15	.	.	.
5180	1562	16	"	"	''
5180	1563	1	Ashcroft	Ashcroft	NNP
5180	1563	2	,	,	,
5180	1563	3	122	122	CD
5180	1563	4	S.	S.	NNP
5180	1563	5	Ct	Ct	NNP
5180	1563	6	.	.	.
5180	1563	7	at	at	IN
5180	1563	8	1404	1404	CD
5180	1563	9	.	.	.
5180	1564	1	This	this	DT
5180	1564	2	rule	rule	NN
5180	1564	3	reflects	reflect	VBZ
5180	1564	4	the	the	DT
5180	1564	5	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1564	6	that	that	IN
5180	1564	7	"	"	``
5180	1564	8	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1564	9	t]he	t]he	VBG
5180	1564	10	possible	possible	JJ
5180	1564	11	harm	harm	NN
5180	1564	12	to	to	IN
5180	1564	13	society	society	NN
5180	1564	14	in	in	IN
5180	1564	15	permitting	permit	VBG
5180	1564	16	some	some	DT
5180	1564	17	unprotected	unprotected	JJ
5180	1564	18	speech	speech	NN
5180	1564	19	to	to	TO
5180	1564	20	go	go	VB
5180	1564	21	unpunished	unpunished	JJ
5180	1564	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	1564	23	outweighed	outweigh	VBN
5180	1564	24	by	by	IN
5180	1564	25	the	the	DT
5180	1564	26	possibility	possibility	NN
5180	1564	27	that	that	WDT
5180	1564	28	protected	protect	VBD
5180	1564	29	speech	speech	NN
5180	1564	30	of	of	IN
5180	1564	31	others	other	NNS
5180	1564	32	may	may	MD
5180	1564	33	be	be	VB
5180	1564	34	muted	mute	VBN
5180	1564	35	.	.	.
5180	1565	1	.	.	.
5180	1566	1	.	.	.
5180	1567	1	.	.	.
5180	1567	2	"	"	''
5180	1568	1	Broadrick	Broadrick	NNP
5180	1568	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1568	3	Oklahoma	Oklahoma	NNP
5180	1568	4	,	,	,
5180	1568	5	413	413	CD
5180	1568	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1568	7	at	at	IN
5180	1568	8	612	612	CD
5180	1568	9	.	.	.
5180	1569	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	1569	2	,	,	,
5180	1569	3	in	in	IN
5180	1569	4	Ashcroft	Ashcroft	NNP
5180	1569	5	,	,	,
5180	1569	6	the	the	DT
5180	1569	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1569	8	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1569	9	rejected	reject	VBD
5180	1569	10	the	the	DT
5180	1569	11	government	government	NN
5180	1569	12	's	's	POS
5180	1569	13	argument	argument	NN
5180	1569	14	that	that	IN
5180	1569	15	a	a	DT
5180	1569	16	statute	statute	NN
5180	1569	17	criminalizing	criminalize	VBG
5180	1569	18	the	the	DT
5180	1569	19	distribution	distribution	NN
5180	1569	20	of	of	IN
5180	1569	21	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1569	22	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1569	23	"	"	``
5180	1569	24	virtual	virtual	JJ
5180	1569	25	"	"	''
5180	1569	26	child	child	NN
5180	1569	27	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1569	28	,	,	,
5180	1569	29	produced	produce	VBN
5180	1569	30	through	through	IN
5180	1569	31	computer	computer	NN
5180	1569	32	imaging	image	VBG
5180	1569	33	technology	technology	NN
5180	1569	34	without	without	IN
5180	1569	35	the	the	DT
5180	1569	36	use	use	NN
5180	1569	37	of	of	IN
5180	1569	38	real	real	JJ
5180	1569	39	children	child	NNS
5180	1569	40	,	,	,
5180	1569	41	was	be	VBD
5180	1569	42	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	1569	43	to	to	TO
5180	1569	44	further	further	RB
5180	1569	45	the	the	DT
5180	1569	46	state	state	NN
5180	1569	47	's	's	POS
5180	1569	48	interest	interest	NN
5180	1569	49	in	in	IN
5180	1569	50	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
5180	1569	51	the	the	DT
5180	1569	52	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1569	53	of	of	IN
5180	1569	54	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1569	55	unprotected	unprotected	JJ
5180	1569	56	child	child	NN
5180	1569	57	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1569	58	produced	produce	VBD
5180	1569	59	using	use	VBG
5180	1569	60	real	real	JJ
5180	1569	61	children	child	NNS
5180	1569	62	,	,	,
5180	1569	63	since	since	IN
5180	1569	64	"	"	``
5180	1569	65	the	the	DT
5180	1569	66	possibility	possibility	NN
5180	1569	67	of	of	IN
5180	1569	68	producing	produce	VBG
5180	1569	69	images	image	NNS
5180	1569	70	by	by	IN
5180	1569	71	using	use	VBG
5180	1569	72	computer	computer	NN
5180	1569	73	imaging	imaging	NN
5180	1569	74	makes	make	VBZ
5180	1569	75	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1569	76	very	very	RB
5180	1569	77	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	1569	78	for	for	IN
5180	1569	79	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1569	80	the	the	DT
5180	1569	81	government	government	NN
5180	1569	82	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1569	83	to	to	TO
5180	1569	84	prosecute	prosecute	VB
5180	1569	85	those	those	DT
5180	1569	86	who	who	WP
5180	1569	87	produce	produce	VBP
5180	1569	88	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1569	89	using	use	VBG
5180	1569	90	real	real	JJ
5180	1569	91	children	child	NNS
5180	1569	92	.	.	.
5180	1569	93	"	"	''
5180	1570	1	Ashcroft	Ashcroft	NNP
5180	1570	2	,	,	,
5180	1570	3	122	122	CD
5180	1570	4	S.	S.	NNP
5180	1570	5	Ct	Ct	NNP
5180	1570	6	.	.	.
5180	1570	7	at	at	IN
5180	1570	8	1404	1404	CD
5180	1570	9	;	;	:
5180	1570	10	see	see	VB
5180	1570	11	also	also	RB
5180	1570	12	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
5180	1570	13	,	,	,
5180	1570	14	394	394	CD
5180	1570	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1570	16	at	at	IN
5180	1570	17	567	567	CD
5180	1570	18	-	-	SYM
5180	1570	19	58	58	CD
5180	1570	20	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1570	21	holding	hold	VBG
5180	1570	22	that	that	IN
5180	1570	23	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	1570	24	have	have	VBP
5180	1570	25	a	a	DT
5180	1570	26	First	First	NNP
5180	1570	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1570	28	right	right	NN
5180	1570	29	to	to	TO
5180	1570	30	possess	possess	VB
5180	1570	31	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1570	32	material	material	NN
5180	1570	33	,	,	,
5180	1570	34	even	even	RB
5180	1570	35	though	though	IN
5180	1570	36	the	the	DT
5180	1570	37	existence	existence	NN
5180	1570	38	of	of	IN
5180	1570	39	this	this	DT
5180	1570	40	right	right	NN
5180	1570	41	makes	make	VBZ
5180	1570	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1570	43	more	more	RBR
5180	1570	44	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	1570	45	for	for	IN
5180	1570	46	the	the	DT
5180	1570	47	states	state	NNS
5180	1570	48	to	to	TO
5180	1570	49	further	further	VB
5180	1570	50	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1570	51	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1570	52	interest	interest	NN
5180	1570	53	in	in	IN
5180	1570	54	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
5180	1570	55	the	the	DT
5180	1570	56	distribution	distribution	NN
5180	1570	57	of	of	IN
5180	1570	58	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1570	59	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1570	60	.	.	.
5180	1571	1	By	by	IN
5180	1571	2	the	the	DT
5180	1571	3	same	same	JJ
5180	1571	4	token	token	NN
5180	1571	5	,	,	,
5180	1571	6	even	even	RB
5180	1571	7	if	if	IN
5180	1571	8	the	the	DT
5180	1571	9	use	use	NN
5180	1571	10	of	of	IN
5180	1571	11	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1571	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	1571	13	effective	effective	JJ
5180	1571	14	in	in	IN
5180	1571	15	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1571	16	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1571	17	from	from	IN
5180	1571	18	receiving	receive	VBG
5180	1571	19	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1571	20	unprotected	unprotected	JJ
5180	1571	21	speech	speech	NN
5180	1571	22	,	,	,
5180	1571	23	the	the	DT
5180	1571	24	government	government	NN
5180	1571	25	's	's	POS
5180	1571	26	interest	interest	NN
5180	1571	27	in	in	IN
5180	1571	28	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1571	29	the	the	DT
5180	1571	30	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1571	31	of	of	IN
5180	1571	32	such	such	JJ
5180	1571	33	speech	speech	NN
5180	1571	34	can	can	MD
5180	1571	35	not	not	RB
5180	1571	36	justify	justify	VB
5180	1571	37	the	the	DT
5180	1571	38	use	use	NN
5180	1571	39	of	of	IN
5180	1571	40	the	the	DT
5180	1571	41	technology	technology	NN
5180	1571	42	protection	protection	NN
5180	1571	43	measures	measure	NNS
5180	1571	44	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	1571	45	by	by	IN
5180	1571	46	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1571	47	,	,	,
5180	1571	48	which	which	WDT
5180	1571	49	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	1571	50	block	block	VBP
5180	1571	51	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1571	52	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	1571	53	of	of	IN
5180	1571	54	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1571	55	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1571	56	speech	speech	NN
5180	1571	57	.	.	.
5180	1572	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1572	2	thus	thus	RB
5180	1572	3	resembles	resemble	VBZ
5180	1572	4	the	the	DT
5180	1572	5	Communications	Communications	NNP
5180	1572	6	Decency	Decency	NNP
5180	1572	7	Act	Act	NNP
5180	1572	8	,	,	,
5180	1572	9	which	which	WDT
5180	1572	10	the	the	DT
5180	1572	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1572	12	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1572	13	facially	facially	RB
5180	1572	14	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
5180	1572	15	in	in	IN
5180	1572	16	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1572	17	v.	v.	CC
5180	1572	18	ACLU	ACLU	NNP
5180	1572	19	,	,	,
5180	1572	20	521	521	CD
5180	1572	21	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1572	22	844	844	CD
5180	1572	23	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1572	24	1997	1997	CD
5180	1572	25	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1572	26	.	.	.
5180	1573	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1573	2	on	on	IN
5180	1573	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1573	4	face	face	NN
5180	1573	5	,	,	,
5180	1573	6	the	the	DT
5180	1573	7	CDA	CDA	NNP
5180	1573	8	simply	simply	RB
5180	1573	9	restricted	restrict	VBD
5180	1573	10	the	the	DT
5180	1573	11	distribution	distribution	NN
5180	1573	12	to	to	IN
5180	1573	13	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1573	14	of	of	IN
5180	1573	15	speech	speech	NN
5180	1573	16	that	that	WDT
5180	1573	17	was	be	VBD
5180	1573	18	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1573	19	unprotected	unprotected	JJ
5180	1573	20	with	with	IN
5180	1573	21	respect	respect	NN
5180	1573	22	to	to	IN
5180	1573	23	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1573	24	,	,	,
5180	1573	25	as	as	IN
5180	1573	26	a	a	DT
5180	1573	27	practical	practical	JJ
5180	1573	28	matter	matter	NN
5180	1573	29	,	,	,
5180	1573	30	given	give	VBN
5180	1573	31	Web	web	NN
5180	1573	32	sites	site	NNS
5180	1573	33	'	'	POS
5180	1573	34	difficulties	difficulty	NNS
5180	1573	35	in	in	IN
5180	1573	36	identifying	identify	VBG
5180	1573	37	the	the	DT
5180	1573	38	ages	age	NNS
5180	1573	39	of	of	IN
5180	1573	40	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1573	41	users	user	NNS
5180	1573	42	,	,	,
5180	1573	43	the	the	DT
5180	1573	44	CDA	CDA	NNP
5180	1573	45	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	1573	46	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
5180	1573	47	the	the	DT
5180	1573	48	distribution	distribution	NN
5180	1573	49	to	to	IN
5180	1573	50	adults	adult	NNS
5180	1573	51	of	of	IN
5180	1573	52	material	material	NN
5180	1573	53	that	that	WDT
5180	1573	54	was	be	VBD
5180	1573	55	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1573	56	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1573	57	with	with	IN
5180	1573	58	respect	respect	NN
5180	1573	59	to	to	IN
5180	1573	60	adults	adult	NNS
5180	1573	61	.	.	.
5180	1574	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1574	2	,	,	,
5180	1574	3	although	although	IN
5180	1574	4	on	on	IN
5180	1574	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1574	6	face	face	NN
5180	1574	7	,	,	,
5180	1574	8	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1574	9	,	,	,
5180	1574	10	like	like	IN
5180	1574	11	the	the	DT
5180	1574	12	CDA	CDA	NNP
5180	1574	13	,	,	,
5180	1574	14	requires	require	VBZ
5180	1574	15	the	the	DT
5180	1574	16	suppression	suppression	NN
5180	1574	17	of	of	IN
5180	1574	18	only	only	RB
5180	1574	19	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1574	20	unprotected	unprotected	JJ
5180	1574	21	speech	speech	NN
5180	1574	22	,	,	,
5180	1574	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1574	24	is	be	VBZ
5180	1574	25	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	1574	26	as	as	IN
5180	1574	27	a	a	DT
5180	1574	28	practical	practical	JJ
5180	1574	29	matter	matter	NN
5180	1574	30	,	,	,
5180	1574	31	given	give	VBN
5180	1574	32	the	the	DT
5180	1574	33	state	state	NN
5180	1574	34	of	of	IN
5180	1574	35	the	the	DT
5180	1574	36	art	art	NN
5180	1574	37	of	of	IN
5180	1574	38	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1574	39	technology	technology	NN
5180	1574	40	,	,	,
5180	1574	41	for	for	IN
5180	1574	42	a	a	DT
5180	1574	43	public	public	JJ
5180	1574	44	library	library	NN
5180	1574	45	to	to	TO
5180	1574	46	comply	comply	VB
5180	1574	47	with	with	IN
5180	1574	48	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1574	49	without	without	IN
5180	1574	50	also	also	RB
5180	1574	51	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1574	52	significant	significant	JJ
5180	1574	53	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	1574	54	of	of	IN
5180	1574	55	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1574	56	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1574	57	speech	speech	NN
5180	1574	58	.	.	.
5180	1575	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1575	2	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1575	3	hold	hold	VBP
5180	1575	4	that	that	IN
5180	1575	5	a	a	DT
5180	1575	6	library	library	NN
5180	1575	7	's	's	POS
5180	1575	8	use	use	NN
5180	1575	9	of	of	IN
5180	1575	10	a	a	DT
5180	1575	11	technology	technology	NN
5180	1575	12	protection	protection	NN
5180	1575	13	measure	measure	NN
5180	1575	14	required	require	VBN
5180	1575	15	by	by	IN
5180	1575	16	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1575	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	1575	18	not	not	RB
5180	1575	19	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1575	20	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1575	21	to	to	IN
5180	1575	22	the	the	DT
5180	1575	23	government	government	NN
5180	1575	24	's	's	POS
5180	1575	25	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1575	26	interest	interest	NN
5180	1575	27	in	in	IN
5180	1575	28	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1575	29	the	the	DT
5180	1575	30	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1575	31	of	of	IN
5180	1575	32	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1575	33	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	1575	34	that	that	WDT
5180	1575	35	are	be	VBP
5180	1575	36	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1575	37	,	,	,
5180	1575	38	child	child	NN
5180	1575	39	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1575	40	,	,	,
5180	1575	41	or	or	CC
5180	1575	42	in	in	IN
5180	1575	43	the	the	DT
5180	1575	44	case	case	NN
5180	1575	45	of	of	IN
5180	1575	46	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1575	47	,	,	,
5180	1575	48	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1575	49	to	to	IN
5180	1575	50	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1575	51	.	.	.
5180	1576	1	For	for	IN
5180	1576	2	the	the	DT
5180	1576	3	same	same	JJ
5180	1576	4	reason	reason	NN
5180	1576	5	that	that	IN
5180	1576	6	a	a	DT
5180	1576	7	public	public	JJ
5180	1576	8	library	library	NN
5180	1576	9	's	's	POS
5180	1576	10	use	use	NN
5180	1576	11	of	of	IN
5180	1576	12	software	software	NN
5180	1576	13	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1576	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	1576	15	not	not	RB
5180	1576	16	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1576	17	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1576	18	to	to	TO
5180	1576	19	further	further	RB
5180	1576	20	the	the	DT
5180	1576	21	library	library	NN
5180	1576	22	's	's	POS
5180	1576	23	interest	interest	NN
5180	1576	24	in	in	IN
5180	1576	25	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1576	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1576	27	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1576	28	from	from	IN
5180	1576	29	being	be	VBG
5180	1576	30	used	use	VBN
5180	1576	31	to	to	TO
5180	1576	32	disseminate	disseminate	VB
5180	1576	33	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1576	34	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	1576	35	that	that	WDT
5180	1576	36	are	be	VBP
5180	1576	37	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1576	38	,	,	,
5180	1576	39	child	child	NN
5180	1576	40	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1576	41	,	,	,
5180	1576	42	and	and	CC
5180	1576	43	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1576	44	to	to	IN
5180	1576	45	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1576	46	,	,	,
5180	1576	47	a	a	DT
5180	1576	48	public	public	JJ
5180	1576	49	library	library	NN
5180	1576	50	's	's	POS
5180	1576	51	use	use	NN
5180	1576	52	of	of	IN
5180	1576	53	software	software	NN
5180	1576	54	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1576	55	is	be	VBZ
5180	1576	56	not	not	RB
5180	1576	57	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1576	58	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1576	59	to	to	TO
5180	1576	60	further	further	RB
5180	1576	61	the	the	DT
5180	1576	62	library	library	NN
5180	1576	63	's	's	POS
5180	1576	64	interest	interest	NN
5180	1576	65	in	in	IN
5180	1576	66	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1576	67	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1576	68	from	from	IN
5180	1576	69	being	be	VBG
5180	1576	70	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	1576	71	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1576	72	to	to	IN
5180	1576	73	offensive	offensive	NN
5180	1576	74	,	,	,
5180	1576	75	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1576	76	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1576	77	material	material	NN
5180	1576	78	.	.	.
5180	1577	1	As	as	IN
5180	1577	2	discussed	discuss	VBN
5180	1577	3	in	in	IN
5180	1577	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1577	5	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1577	6	of	of	IN
5180	1577	7	fact	fact	NN
5180	1577	8	,	,	,
5180	1577	9	the	the	DT
5180	1577	10	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1577	11	required	require	VBN
5180	1577	12	by	by	IN
5180	1577	13	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1577	14	block	block	NN
5180	1577	15	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1577	16	numbers	number	NNS
5180	1577	17	of	of	IN
5180	1577	18	Web	web	NN
5180	1577	19	sites	site	NNS
5180	1577	20	that	that	IN
5180	1577	21	even	even	RB
5180	1577	22	the	the	DT
5180	1577	23	most	most	RBS
5180	1577	24	puritanical	puritanical	JJ
5180	1577	25	public	public	JJ
5180	1577	26	library	library	NN
5180	1577	27	patron	patron	NN
5180	1577	28	would	would	MD
5180	1577	29	not	not	RB
5180	1577	30	find	find	VB
5180	1577	31	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1577	32	,	,	,
5180	1577	33	such	such	JJ
5180	1577	34	as	as	IN
5180	1577	35	http://federo.com	http://federo.com	ADD
5180	1577	36	,	,	,
5180	1577	37	a	a	DT
5180	1577	38	Web	web	NN
5180	1577	39	site	site	NN
5180	1577	40	that	that	WDT
5180	1577	41	promotes	promote	VBZ
5180	1577	42	federalism	federalism	NN
5180	1577	43	in	in	IN
5180	1577	44	Uganda	Uganda	NNP
5180	1577	45	,	,	,
5180	1577	46	which	which	WDT
5180	1577	47	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	1577	48	blocked	block	VBD
5180	1577	49	as	as	IN
5180	1577	50	"	"	``
5180	1577	51	Adults	Adults	NNP
5180	1577	52	Only	only	RB
5180	1577	53	,	,	,
5180	1577	54	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	1577	55	,	,	,
5180	1577	56	"	"	''
5180	1577	57	and	and	CC
5180	1577	58	http://www.vvm.com/~bond/home.htm	http://www.vvm.com/~bond/home.htm	CD
5180	1577	59	,	,	,
5180	1577	60	a	a	DT
5180	1577	61	site	site	NN
5180	1577	62	for	for	IN
5180	1577	63	aspiring	aspire	VBG
5180	1577	64	dentists	dentist	NNS
5180	1577	65	,	,	,
5180	1577	66	which	which	WDT
5180	1577	67	was	be	VBD
5180	1577	68	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1577	69	by	by	IN
5180	1577	70	Cyberpatrol	Cyberpatrol	NNP
5180	1577	71	as	as	IN
5180	1577	72	"	"	``
5180	1577	73	Adult	adult	NN
5180	1577	74	/	/	,
5180	1577	75	Sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1577	76	Explicit	Explicit	NNP
5180	1577	77	.	.	.
5180	1577	78	"	"	''
5180	1578	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1578	2	list	list	VBP
5180	1578	3	many	many	RB
5180	1578	4	more	more	JJR
5180	1578	5	such	such	JJ
5180	1578	6	examples	example	NNS
5180	1578	7	in	in	IN
5180	1578	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1578	9	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1578	10	of	of	IN
5180	1578	11	fact	fact	NN
5180	1578	12	,	,	,
5180	1578	13	see	see	VB
5180	1578	14	supra	supra	NNP
5180	1578	15	,	,	,
5180	1578	16	and	and	CC
5180	1578	17	find	find	VB
5180	1578	18	that	that	IN
5180	1578	19	such	such	JJ
5180	1578	20	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1578	21	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1578	22	sites	site	NNS
5180	1578	23	number	number	NN
5180	1578	24	in	in	IN
5180	1578	25	at	at	RB
5180	1578	26	least	least	JJS
5180	1578	27	the	the	DT
5180	1578	28	thousands	thousand	NNS
5180	1578	29	.	.	.
5180	1579	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1579	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1579	3	have	have	VBP
5180	1579	4	found	find	VBN
5180	1579	5	large	large	JJ
5180	1579	6	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	1579	7	of	of	IN
5180	1579	8	overblocking	overblocking	NN
5180	1579	9	,	,	,
5180	1579	10	even	even	RB
5180	1579	11	if	if	IN
5180	1579	12	only	only	RB
5180	1579	13	a	a	DT
5180	1579	14	small	small	JJ
5180	1579	15	percentage	percentage	NN
5180	1579	16	of	of	IN
5180	1579	17	sites	site	NNS
5180	1579	18	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1579	19	are	be	VBP
5180	1579	20	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1579	21	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1579	22	,	,	,
5180	1579	23	either	either	CC
5180	1579	24	with	with	IN
5180	1579	25	respect	respect	NN
5180	1579	26	to	to	IN
5180	1579	27	the	the	DT
5180	1579	28	state	state	NN
5180	1579	29	's	's	POS
5180	1579	30	interest	interest	NN
5180	1579	31	in	in	IN
5180	1579	32	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1579	33	adults	adult	NNS
5180	1579	34	from	from	IN
5180	1579	35	viewing	view	VBG
5180	1579	36	material	material	NN
5180	1579	37	that	that	WDT
5180	1579	38	is	be	VBZ
5180	1579	39	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1579	40	or	or	CC
5180	1579	41	child	child	NN
5180	1579	42	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1579	43	and	and	CC
5180	1579	44	in	in	IN
5180	1579	45	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1579	46	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1579	47	from	from	IN
5180	1579	48	viewing	view	VBG
5180	1579	49	material	material	NN
5180	1579	50	that	that	WDT
5180	1579	51	is	be	VBZ
5180	1579	52	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1579	53	to	to	IN
5180	1579	54	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1579	55	,	,	,
5180	1579	56	or	or	CC
5180	1579	57	with	with	IN
5180	1579	58	respect	respect	NN
5180	1579	59	to	to	IN
5180	1579	60	the	the	DT
5180	1579	61	state	state	NN
5180	1579	62	's	's	POS
5180	1579	63	interest	interest	NN
5180	1579	64	in	in	IN
5180	1579	65	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1579	66	library	library	NN
5180	1579	67	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1579	68	generally	generally	RB
5180	1579	69	from	from	IN
5180	1579	70	being	be	VBG
5180	1579	71	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	1579	72	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1579	73	to	to	IN
5180	1579	74	offensive	offensive	NN
5180	1579	75	,	,	,
5180	1579	76	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1579	77	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1579	78	material	material	NN
5180	1579	79	,	,	,
5180	1579	80	this	this	DT
5180	1579	81	imprecision	imprecision	NN
5180	1579	82	is	be	VBZ
5180	1579	83	fatal	fatal	JJ
5180	1579	84	under	under	IN
5180	1579	85	the	the	DT
5180	1579	86	First	First	NNP
5180	1579	87	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1579	88	.	.	.
5180	1580	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1580	2	.	.	.
5180	1581	1	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1581	2	,	,	,
5180	1581	3	521	521	CD
5180	1581	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1581	5	at	at	IN
5180	1581	6	874	874	CD
5180	1581	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1581	8	"	"	``
5180	1581	9	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1581	10	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	1581	11	CDA	CDA	NNP
5180	1581	12	lacks	lack	VBZ
5180	1581	13	the	the	DT
5180	1581	14	precision	precision	NN
5180	1581	15	that	that	IN
5180	1581	16	the	the	DT
5180	1581	17	First	First	NNP
5180	1581	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1581	19	requires	require	VBZ
5180	1581	20	when	when	WRB
5180	1581	21	a	a	DT
5180	1581	22	statute	statute	NN
5180	1581	23	regulates	regulate	VBZ
5180	1581	24	the	the	DT
5180	1581	25	content	content	NN
5180	1581	26	of	of	IN
5180	1581	27	speech	speech	NN
5180	1581	28	.	.	.
5180	1582	1	")	")	LS
5180	1582	2	;	;	:
5180	1582	3	League	League	NNP
5180	1582	4	of	of	IN
5180	1582	5	Women	Women	NNP
5180	1582	6	Voters	Voters	NNPS
5180	1582	7	,	,	,
5180	1582	8	468	468	CD
5180	1582	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1582	10	at	at	IN
5180	1582	11	398	398	CD
5180	1582	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1582	13	"	"	``
5180	1582	14	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1582	15	E]ven	e]ven	JJ
5180	1582	16	if	if	IN
5180	1582	17	some	some	DT
5180	1582	18	of	of	IN
5180	1582	19	the	the	DT
5180	1582	20	hazards	hazard	NNS
5180	1582	21	at	at	IN
5180	1582	22	which	which	WDT
5180	1582	23	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1582	24	the	the	DT
5180	1582	25	challenged	challenge	VBN
5180	1582	26	provision	provision	NN
5180	1582	27	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1582	28	was	be	VBD
5180	1582	29	aimed	aim	VBN
5180	1582	30	are	be	VBP
5180	1582	31	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
5180	1582	32	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1582	33	,	,	,
5180	1582	34	the	the	DT
5180	1582	35	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1582	36	is	be	VBZ
5180	1582	37	not	not	RB
5180	1582	38	crafted	craft	VBN
5180	1582	39	with	with	IN
5180	1582	40	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
5180	1582	41	precision	precision	NN
5180	1582	42	to	to	TO
5180	1582	43	remedy	remedy	VB
5180	1582	44	those	those	DT
5180	1582	45	dangers	danger	NNS
5180	1582	46	that	that	WDT
5180	1582	47	may	may	MD
5180	1582	48	exist	exist	VB
5180	1582	49	to	to	TO
5180	1582	50	justify	justify	VB
5180	1582	51	the	the	DT
5180	1582	52	significant	significant	JJ
5180	1582	53	abridgement	abridgement	NN
5180	1582	54	of	of	IN
5180	1582	55	speech	speech	NN
5180	1582	56	worked	work	VBN
5180	1582	57	by	by	IN
5180	1582	58	the	the	DT
5180	1582	59	provision	provision	NN
5180	1582	60	's	's	POS
5180	1582	61	broad	broad	JJ
5180	1582	62	ban	ban	NN
5180	1582	63	.	.	.
5180	1583	1	.	.	.
5180	1584	1	.	.	.
5180	1585	1	.	.	.
5180	1585	2	"	"	''
5180	1585	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1585	4	.	.	.
5180	1586	1	While	while	IN
5180	1586	2	the	the	DT
5180	1586	3	First	First	NNP
5180	1586	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1586	5	does	do	VBZ
5180	1586	6	not	not	RB
5180	1586	7	demand	demand	VB
5180	1586	8	perfection	perfection	NN
5180	1586	9	when	when	WRB
5180	1586	10	the	the	DT
5180	1586	11	government	government	NN
5180	1586	12	restricts	restrict	VBZ
5180	1586	13	speech	speech	NN
5180	1586	14	in	in	IN
5180	1586	15	order	order	NN
5180	1586	16	to	to	TO
5180	1586	17	advance	advance	VB
5180	1586	18	a	a	DT
5180	1586	19	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1586	20	interest	interest	NN
5180	1586	21	,	,	,
5180	1586	22	the	the	DT
5180	1586	23	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1586	24	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	1586	25	of	of	IN
5180	1586	26	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
5180	1586	27	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1586	28	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	1586	29	in	in	IN
5180	1586	30	the	the	DT
5180	1586	31	technology	technology	NN
5180	1586	32	protection	protection	NN
5180	1586	33	measures	measure	NNS
5180	1586	34	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	1586	35	by	by	IN
5180	1586	36	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1586	37	are	be	VBP
5180	1586	38	more	more	JJR
5180	1586	39	than	than	IN
5180	1586	40	simply	simply	RB
5180	1586	41	de	de	IN
5180	1586	42	minimis	minimis	NNP
5180	1586	43	instances	instance	NNS
5180	1586	44	of	of	IN
5180	1586	45	human	human	JJ
5180	1586	46	error	error	NN
5180	1586	47	.	.	.
5180	1587	1	"	"	``
5180	1587	2	The	the	DT
5180	1587	3	line	line	NN
5180	1587	4	between	between	IN
5180	1587	5	speech	speech	NN
5180	1587	6	unconditionally	unconditionally	RB
5180	1587	7	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
5180	1587	8	and	and	CC
5180	1587	9	speech	speech	NN
5180	1587	10	which	which	WDT
5180	1587	11	may	may	MD
5180	1587	12	legitimately	legitimately	RB
5180	1587	13	be	be	VB
5180	1587	14	regulated	regulate	VBN
5180	1587	15	,	,	,
5180	1587	16	suppressed	suppress	VBN
5180	1587	17	,	,	,
5180	1587	18	or	or	CC
5180	1587	19	punished	punish	VBN
5180	1587	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	1587	21	finely	finely	RB
5180	1587	22	drawn	draw	VBN
5180	1587	23	.	.	.
5180	1588	1	Error	error	NN
5180	1588	2	in	in	IN
5180	1588	3	marking	mark	VBG
5180	1588	4	that	that	DT
5180	1588	5	line	line	NN
5180	1588	6	exacts	exact	VBZ
5180	1588	7	an	an	DT
5180	1588	8	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
5180	1588	9	cost	cost	NN
5180	1588	10	.	.	.
5180	1588	11	"	"	''
5180	1589	1	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1589	2	,	,	,
5180	1589	3	529	529	CD
5180	1589	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1589	5	at	at	IN
5180	1589	6	817	817	CD
5180	1589	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1589	8	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1589	9	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1589	10	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1589	11	and	and	CC
5180	1589	12	citation	citation	NN
5180	1589	13	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1589	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1589	15	.	.	.
5180	1590	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	1590	2	,	,	,
5180	1590	3	"	"	``
5180	1590	4	precision	precision	NN
5180	1590	5	of	of	IN
5180	1590	6	regulation	regulation	NN
5180	1590	7	must	must	MD
5180	1590	8	be	be	VB
5180	1590	9	the	the	DT
5180	1590	10	touchstone	touchstone	NN
5180	1590	11	in	in	IN
5180	1590	12	an	an	DT
5180	1590	13	area	area	NN
5180	1590	14	so	so	RB
5180	1590	15	closely	closely	RB
5180	1590	16	touching	touch	VBG
5180	1590	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1590	18	most	most	RBS
5180	1590	19	precious	precious	JJ
5180	1590	20	freedoms	freedom	NNS
5180	1590	21	.	.	.
5180	1590	22	"	"	''
5180	1591	1	Keyishian	Keyishian	NNP
5180	1591	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1591	3	Bd	Bd	NNP
5180	1591	4	.	.	.
5180	1592	1	of	of	IN
5180	1592	2	Regents	Regents	NNPS
5180	1592	3	of	of	IN
5180	1592	4	the	the	DT
5180	1592	5	Univ	Univ	NNP
5180	1592	6	.	.	.
5180	1593	1	of	of	IN
5180	1593	2	the	the	DT
5180	1593	3	State	State	NNP
5180	1593	4	of	of	IN
5180	1593	5	N.Y.	New York	NNP
5180	1593	6	,	,	,
5180	1593	7	385	385	CD
5180	1593	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1593	9	589	589	CD
5180	1593	10	,	,	,
5180	1593	11	603	603	CD
5180	1593	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1593	13	1967	1967	CD
5180	1593	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1593	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1593	16	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1593	17	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1593	18	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1593	19	and	and	CC
5180	1593	20	citation	citation	NN
5180	1593	21	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1593	22	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1593	23	;	;	:
5180	1593	24	see	see	VB
5180	1593	25	also	also	RB
5180	1593	26	Bantam	Bantam	NNP
5180	1593	27	Books	Books	NNP
5180	1593	28	,	,	,
5180	1593	29	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1593	30	v.	v.	IN
5180	1593	31	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
5180	1593	32	,	,	,
5180	1593	33	372	372	CD
5180	1593	34	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1593	35	58	58	CD
5180	1593	36	,	,	,
5180	1593	37	66	66	CD
5180	1593	38	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1593	39	1963	1963	CD
5180	1593	40	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1593	41	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1593	42	"	"	``
5180	1593	43	The	the	DT
5180	1593	44	separation	separation	NN
5180	1593	45	of	of	IN
5180	1593	46	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1593	47	from	from	IN
5180	1593	48	illegitimate	illegitimate	JJ
5180	1593	49	speech	speech	NN
5180	1593	50	calls	call	NNS
5180	1593	51	for	for	IN
5180	1593	52	sensitive	sensitive	JJ
5180	1593	53	tools	tool	NNS
5180	1593	54	.	.	.
5180	1593	55	"	"	''
5180	1593	56	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1594	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1594	2	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1594	3	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1594	4	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1594	5	and	and	CC
5180	1594	6	citation	citation	NN
5180	1594	7	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1594	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1594	9	.	.	.
5180	1595	1	Where	where	WRB
5180	1595	2	the	the	DT
5180	1595	3	government	government	NN
5180	1595	4	draws	draw	VBZ
5180	1595	5	content	content	NN
5180	1595	6	-	-	HYPH
5180	1595	7	based	base	VBN
5180	1595	8	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1595	9	on	on	IN
5180	1595	10	speech	speech	NN
5180	1595	11	in	in	IN
5180	1595	12	order	order	NN
5180	1595	13	to	to	TO
5180	1595	14	advance	advance	VB
5180	1595	15	a	a	DT
5180	1595	16	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1595	17	government	government	NN
5180	1595	18	interest	interest	NN
5180	1595	19	,	,	,
5180	1595	20	the	the	DT
5180	1595	21	First	First	NNP
5180	1595	22	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1595	23	demands	demand	VBZ
5180	1595	24	the	the	DT
5180	1595	25	precision	precision	NN
5180	1595	26	of	of	IN
5180	1595	27	a	a	DT
5180	1595	28	scalpel	scalpel	NN
5180	1595	29	,	,	,
5180	1595	30	not	not	RB
5180	1595	31	a	a	DT
5180	1595	32	sledgehammer	sledgehammer	NN
5180	1595	33	.	.	.
5180	1596	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1596	2	believe	believe	VBP
5180	1596	3	that	that	IN
5180	1596	4	a	a	DT
5180	1596	5	public	public	JJ
5180	1596	6	library	library	NN
5180	1596	7	's	's	POS
5180	1596	8	use	use	NN
5180	1596	9	of	of	IN
5180	1596	10	the	the	DT
5180	1596	11	technology	technology	NN
5180	1596	12	protection	protection	NN
5180	1596	13	measures	measure	NNS
5180	1596	14	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	1596	15	by	by	IN
5180	1596	16	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1596	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	1596	18	not	not	RB
5180	1596	19	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1596	20	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1596	21	to	to	TO
5180	1596	22	further	further	RB
5180	1596	23	the	the	DT
5180	1596	24	governmental	governmental	JJ
5180	1596	25	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1596	26	at	at	IN
5180	1596	27	stake	stake	NN
5180	1596	28	.	.	.
5180	1597	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1597	2	the	the	DT
5180	1597	3	strength	strength	NN
5180	1597	4	of	of	IN
5180	1597	5	different	different	JJ
5180	1597	6	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1597	7	'	'	POS
5180	1597	8	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1597	9	in	in	IN
5180	1597	10	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1597	11	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1597	12	forms	form	NNS
5180	1597	13	of	of	IN
5180	1597	14	speech	speech	NN
5180	1597	15	may	may	MD
5180	1597	16	vary	vary	VB
5180	1597	17	from	from	IN
5180	1597	18	library	library	NN
5180	1597	19	to	to	IN
5180	1597	20	library	library	NN
5180	1597	21	,	,	,
5180	1597	22	depending	depend	VBG
5180	1597	23	on	on	IN
5180	1597	24	the	the	DT
5180	1597	25	frequency	frequency	NN
5180	1597	26	and	and	CC
5180	1597	27	severity	severity	NN
5180	1597	28	of	of	IN
5180	1597	29	problems	problem	NNS
5180	1597	30	experienced	experience	VBN
5180	1597	31	by	by	IN
5180	1597	32	each	each	DT
5180	1597	33	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1597	34	library	library	NN
5180	1597	35	,	,	,
5180	1597	36	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1597	37	conclude	conclude	VBP
5180	1597	38	,	,	,
5180	1597	39	based	base	VBN
5180	1597	40	on	on	IN
5180	1597	41	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1597	42	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1597	43	of	of	IN
5180	1597	44	fact	fact	NN
5180	1597	45	,	,	,
5180	1597	46	that	that	IN
5180	1597	47	any	any	DT
5180	1597	48	public	public	JJ
5180	1597	49	library	library	NN
5180	1597	50	's	's	POS
5180	1597	51	use	use	NN
5180	1597	52	of	of	IN
5180	1597	53	a	a	DT
5180	1597	54	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1597	55	product	product	NN
5180	1597	56	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	1597	57	by	by	IN
5180	1597	58	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1597	59	will	will	MD
5180	1597	60	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	1597	61	fail	fail	VB
5180	1597	62	to	to	TO
5180	1597	63	be	be	VB
5180	1597	64	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1597	65	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1597	66	to	to	TO
5180	1597	67	address	address	VB
5180	1597	68	the	the	DT
5180	1597	69	library	library	NN
5180	1597	70	's	's	POS
5180	1597	71	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1597	72	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1597	73	.	.	.
5180	1598	1	Because	because	IN
5180	1598	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1598	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1598	4	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	1598	5	for	for	IN
5180	1598	6	a	a	DT
5180	1598	7	public	public	JJ
5180	1598	8	library	library	NN
5180	1598	9	to	to	TO
5180	1598	10	comply	comply	VB
5180	1598	11	with	with	IN
5180	1598	12	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1598	13	without	without	IN
5180	1598	14	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1598	15	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1598	16	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	1598	17	of	of	IN
5180	1598	18	speech	speech	NN
5180	1598	19	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1598	20	suppression	suppression	NN
5180	1598	21	serves	serve	VBZ
5180	1598	22	no	no	DT
5180	1598	23	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1598	24	state	state	NN
5180	1598	25	interest	interest	NN
5180	1598	26	,	,	,
5180	1598	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1598	28	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1598	29	hold	hold	VBP
5180	1598	30	that	that	IN
5180	1598	31	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1598	32	is	be	VBZ
5180	1598	33	facially	facially	RB
5180	1598	34	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1598	35	,	,	,
5180	1598	36	even	even	RB
5180	1598	37	under	under	IN
5180	1598	38	the	the	DT
5180	1598	39	more	more	RBR
5180	1598	40	stringent	stringent	JJ
5180	1598	41	standard	standard	NN
5180	1598	42	of	of	IN
5180	1598	43	facial	facial	JJ
5180	1598	44	invalidity	invalidity	NN
5180	1598	45	urged	urge	VBD
5180	1598	46	on	on	IN
5180	1598	47	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1598	48	by	by	IN
5180	1598	49	the	the	DT
5180	1598	50	government	government	NN
5180	1598	51	,	,	,
5180	1598	52	which	which	WDT
5180	1598	53	would	would	MD
5180	1598	54	require	require	VB
5180	1598	55	upholding	uphold	VBG
5180	1598	56	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	1598	57	if	if	IN
5180	1598	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1598	59	is	be	VBZ
5180	1598	60	possible	possible	JJ
5180	1598	61	for	for	IN
5180	1598	62	just	just	RB
5180	1598	63	a	a	DT
5180	1598	64	single	single	JJ
5180	1598	65	library	library	NN
5180	1598	66	to	to	TO
5180	1598	67	comply	comply	VB
5180	1598	68	with	with	IN
5180	1598	69	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1598	70	's	's	POS
5180	1598	71	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	1598	72	without	without	IN
5180	1598	73	violating	violate	VBG
5180	1598	74	the	the	DT
5180	1598	75	First	First	NNP
5180	1598	76	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1598	77	.	.	.
5180	1599	1	See	see	VB
5180	1599	2	supra	supra	NNP
5180	1599	3	Part	Part	NNP
5180	1599	4	III	III	NNP
5180	1599	5	.	.	.
5180	1600	1	3	3	LS
5180	1600	2	.	.	.
5180	1601	1	Less	Less	JJR
5180	1601	2	Restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1601	3	Alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1601	4	The	the	DT
5180	1601	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	1601	6	infirmity	infirmity	NN
5180	1601	7	of	of	IN
5180	1601	8	a	a	DT
5180	1601	9	public	public	JJ
5180	1601	10	library	library	NN
5180	1601	11	's	's	POS
5180	1601	12	use	use	NN
5180	1601	13	of	of	IN
5180	1601	14	software	software	NN
5180	1601	15	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1601	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	1601	17	evidenced	evidence	VBN
5180	1601	18	not	not	RB
5180	1601	19	only	only	RB
5180	1601	20	by	by	IN
5180	1601	21	the	the	DT
5180	1601	22	absence	absence	NN
5180	1601	23	of	of	IN
5180	1601	24	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1601	25	tailoring	tailoring	NN
5180	1601	26	,	,	,
5180	1601	27	but	but	CC
5180	1601	28	also	also	RB
5180	1601	29	by	by	IN
5180	1601	30	the	the	DT
5180	1601	31	existence	existence	NN
5180	1601	32	of	of	IN
5180	1601	33	less	less	RBR
5180	1601	34	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1601	35	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1601	36	that	that	WDT
5180	1601	37	further	further	RB
5180	1601	38	the	the	DT
5180	1601	39	government	government	NN
5180	1601	40	's	's	POS
5180	1601	41	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1601	42	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1601	43	.	.	.
5180	1602	1	See	see	VB
5180	1602	2	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1602	3	,	,	,
5180	1602	4	529	529	CD
5180	1602	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1602	6	at	at	IN
5180	1602	7	813	813	CD
5180	1602	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1602	9	"	"	``
5180	1602	10	If	if	IN
5180	1602	11	a	a	DT
5180	1602	12	less	less	RBR
5180	1602	13	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1602	14	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1602	15	would	would	MD
5180	1602	16	serve	serve	VB
5180	1602	17	the	the	DT
5180	1602	18	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1602	19	's	's	POS
5180	1602	20	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1602	21	,	,	,
5180	1602	22	the	the	DT
5180	1602	23	legislature	legislature	NN
5180	1602	24	must	must	MD
5180	1602	25	use	use	VB
5180	1602	26	that	that	DT
5180	1602	27	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1602	28	.	.	.
5180	1603	1	")	")	``
5180	1603	2	;	;	:
5180	1603	3	Sable	sable	JJ
5180	1603	4	,	,	,
5180	1603	5	492	492	CD
5180	1603	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1603	7	at	at	IN
5180	1603	8	126	126	CD
5180	1603	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1603	10	"	"	``
5180	1603	11	The	the	DT
5180	1603	12	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1603	13	may	may	MD
5180	1603	14	.	.	.
5180	1604	1	.	.	.
5180	1605	1	.	.	.
5180	1606	1	regulate	regulate	VB
5180	1606	2	the	the	DT
5180	1606	3	content	content	NN
5180	1606	4	of	of	IN
5180	1606	5	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1606	6	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1606	7	speech	speech	NN
5180	1606	8	in	in	IN
5180	1606	9	order	order	NN
5180	1606	10	to	to	TO
5180	1606	11	promote	promote	VB
5180	1606	12	a	a	DT
5180	1606	13	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1606	14	interest	interest	NN
5180	1606	15	if	if	IN
5180	1606	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1606	17	chooses	choose	VBZ
5180	1606	18	the	the	DT
5180	1606	19	least	least	JJS
5180	1606	20	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1606	21	means	mean	NNS
5180	1606	22	to	to	TO
5180	1606	23	further	further	RB
5180	1606	24	the	the	DT
5180	1606	25	articulated	articulate	VBN
5180	1606	26	interest	interest	NN
5180	1606	27	.	.	.
5180	1606	28	"	"	''
5180	1606	29	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1606	30	.	.	.
5180	1607	1	As	as	IN
5180	1607	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	1607	3	the	the	DT
5180	1607	4	case	case	NN
5180	1607	5	with	with	IN
5180	1607	6	the	the	DT
5180	1607	7	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1607	8	tailoring	tailoring	NN
5180	1607	9	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	1607	10	,	,	,
5180	1607	11	the	the	DT
5180	1607	12	government	government	NN
5180	1607	13	bears	bear	VBZ
5180	1607	14	the	the	DT
5180	1607	15	burden	burden	NN
5180	1607	16	of	of	IN
5180	1607	17	proof	proof	NN
5180	1607	18	in	in	IN
5180	1607	19	showing	show	VBG
5180	1607	20	the	the	DT
5180	1607	21	ineffectiveness	ineffectiveness	NN
5180	1607	22	of	of	IN
5180	1607	23	less	less	RBR
5180	1607	24	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1607	25	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1607	26	.	.	.
5180	1608	1	"	"	``
5180	1608	2	When	when	WRB
5180	1608	3	a	a	DT
5180	1608	4	plausible	plausible	JJ
5180	1608	5	,	,	,
5180	1608	6	less	less	RBR
5180	1608	7	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1608	8	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1608	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	1608	10	offered	offer	VBN
5180	1608	11	to	to	IN
5180	1608	12	a	a	DT
5180	1608	13	content-	content-	NN
5180	1608	14	based	base	VBN
5180	1608	15	speech	speech	NN
5180	1608	16	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1608	17	,	,	,
5180	1608	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1608	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	1608	20	the	the	DT
5180	1608	21	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1608	22	's	's	POS
5180	1608	23	obligation	obligation	NN
5180	1608	24	to	to	TO
5180	1608	25	prove	prove	VB
5180	1608	26	that	that	IN
5180	1608	27	the	the	DT
5180	1608	28	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1608	29	will	will	MD
5180	1608	30	be	be	VB
5180	1608	31	ineffective	ineffective	JJ
5180	1608	32	to	to	TO
5180	1608	33	achieve	achieve	VB
5180	1608	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1608	35	goals	goal	NNS
5180	1608	36	.	.	.
5180	1608	37	"	"	''
5180	1609	1	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1609	2	,	,	,
5180	1609	3	529	529	CD
5180	1609	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1609	5	at	at	IN
5180	1609	6	816	816	CD
5180	1609	7	;	;	:
5180	1609	8	see	see	VB
5180	1609	9	also	also	RB
5180	1609	10	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1609	11	,	,	,
5180	1609	12	521	521	CD
5180	1609	13	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1609	14	at	at	IN
5180	1609	15	879	879	CD
5180	1609	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1609	17	"	"	``
5180	1609	18	The	the	DT
5180	1609	19	breadth	breadth	NN
5180	1609	20	of	of	IN
5180	1609	21	this	this	DT
5180	1609	22	content	content	NN
5180	1609	23	-	-	HYPH
5180	1609	24	based	base	VBN
5180	1609	25	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1609	26	of	of	IN
5180	1609	27	speech	speech	NN
5180	1609	28	imposes	impose	VBZ
5180	1609	29	an	an	DT
5180	1609	30	especially	especially	RB
5180	1609	31	heavy	heavy	JJ
5180	1609	32	burden	burden	NN
5180	1609	33	on	on	IN
5180	1609	34	the	the	DT
5180	1609	35	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1609	36	to	to	TO
5180	1609	37	explain	explain	VB
5180	1609	38	why	why	WRB
5180	1609	39	a	a	DT
5180	1609	40	less	less	RBR
5180	1609	41	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1609	42	provision	provision	NN
5180	1609	43	would	would	MD
5180	1609	44	not	not	RB
5180	1609	45	be	be	VB
5180	1609	46	as	as	RB
5180	1609	47	effective	effective	JJ
5180	1609	48	.	.	.
5180	1610	1	.	.	.
5180	1611	1	.	.	.
5180	1612	1	.	.	.
5180	1613	1	")	")	``
5180	1613	2	;	;	:
5180	1613	3	Fabulous	Fabulous	NNP
5180	1613	4	Assocs	Assocs	NNP
5180	1613	5	.	.	.
5180	1613	6	,	,	,
5180	1613	7	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1613	8	v.	v.	CC
5180	1613	9	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
5180	1613	10	Pub	Pub	NNP
5180	1613	11	.	.	.
5180	1614	1	Util	util	IN
5180	1614	2	.	.	.
5180	1615	1	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
5180	1615	2	,	,	,
5180	1615	3	896	896	CD
5180	1615	4	F.2d	F.2d	NNP
5180	1615	5	780	780	CD
5180	1615	6	,	,	,
5180	1615	7	787	787	CD
5180	1615	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1615	9	3d	3d	NNP
5180	1615	10	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	1615	11	.	.	.
5180	1616	1	1990	1990	CD
5180	1616	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1616	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1616	4	"	"	``
5180	1616	5	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1616	6	focus	focus	VBP
5180	1616	7	.	.	.
5180	1617	1	.	.	.
5180	1618	1	.	.	.
5180	1619	1	on	on	IN
5180	1619	2	the	the	DT
5180	1619	3	more	more	RBR
5180	1619	4	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	1619	5	question	question	NN
5180	1619	6	whether	whether	IN
5180	1619	7	the	the	DT
5180	1619	8	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
5180	1619	9	has	have	VBZ
5180	1619	10	borne	bear	VBN
5180	1619	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1619	12	heavy	heavy	JJ
5180	1619	13	burden	burden	NN
5180	1619	14	of	of	IN
5180	1619	15	demonstrating	demonstrate	VBG
5180	1619	16	that	that	IN
5180	1619	17	the	the	DT
5180	1619	18	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1619	19	state	state	NN
5180	1619	20	interest	interest	NN
5180	1619	21	could	could	MD
5180	1619	22	not	not	RB
5180	1619	23	be	be	VB
5180	1619	24	served	serve	VBN
5180	1619	25	by	by	IN
5180	1619	26	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1619	27	that	that	WDT
5180	1619	28	are	be	VBP
5180	1619	29	less	less	RBR
5180	1619	30	intrusive	intrusive	JJ
5180	1619	31	on	on	IN
5180	1619	32	protected	protected	JJ
5180	1619	33	forms	form	NNS
5180	1619	34	of	of	IN
5180	1619	35	expression	expression	NN
5180	1619	36	.	.	.
5180	1619	37	"	"	''
5180	1619	38	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1620	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1620	2	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1620	3	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1620	4	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1620	5	and	and	CC
5180	1620	6	citation	citation	NN
5180	1620	7	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1620	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1620	9	.	.	.
5180	1621	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1621	2	find	find	VBP
5180	1621	3	that	that	IN
5180	1621	4	there	there	EX
5180	1621	5	are	be	VBP
5180	1621	6	plausible	plausible	JJ
5180	1621	7	,	,	,
5180	1621	8	less	less	RBR
5180	1621	9	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1621	10	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1621	11	to	to	IN
5180	1621	12	the	the	DT
5180	1621	13	use	use	NN
5180	1621	14	of	of	IN
5180	1621	15	software	software	NN
5180	1621	16	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1621	17	that	that	WDT
5180	1621	18	would	would	MD
5180	1621	19	serve	serve	VB
5180	1621	20	the	the	DT
5180	1621	21	government	government	NN
5180	1621	22	's	's	POS
5180	1621	23	interest	interest	NN
5180	1621	24	in	in	IN
5180	1621	25	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1621	26	the	the	DT
5180	1621	27	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1621	28	of	of	IN
5180	1621	29	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1621	30	and	and	CC
5180	1621	31	child	child	NN
5180	1621	32	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1621	33	to	to	IN
5180	1621	34	library	library	NN
5180	1621	35	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1621	36	.	.	.
5180	1622	1	In	in	IN
5180	1622	2	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1622	3	,	,	,
5180	1622	4	public	public	JJ
5180	1622	5	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1622	6	can	can	MD
5180	1622	7	adopt	adopt	VB
5180	1622	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1622	9	use	use	VB
5180	1622	10	policies	policy	NNS
5180	1622	11	that	that	WDT
5180	1622	12	make	make	VBP
5180	1622	13	clear	clear	JJ
5180	1622	14	to	to	IN
5180	1622	15	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1622	16	that	that	IN
5180	1622	17	the	the	DT
5180	1622	18	library	library	NN
5180	1622	19	's	's	POS
5180	1622	20	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1622	21	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1622	22	may	may	MD
5180	1622	23	not	not	RB
5180	1622	24	be	be	VB
5180	1622	25	used	use	VBN
5180	1622	26	to	to	TO
5180	1622	27	access	access	VB
5180	1622	28	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	1622	29	content	content	NN
5180	1622	30	.	.	.
5180	1623	1	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	1623	2	can	can	MD
5180	1623	3	ensure	ensure	VB
5180	1623	4	that	that	IN
5180	1623	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1623	6	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1623	7	are	be	VBP
5180	1623	8	aware	aware	JJ
5180	1623	9	of	of	IN
5180	1623	10	such	such	JJ
5180	1623	11	policies	policy	NNS
5180	1623	12	by	by	IN
5180	1623	13	posting	post	VBG
5180	1623	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1623	15	in	in	IN
5180	1623	16	prominent	prominent	JJ
5180	1623	17	places	place	NNS
5180	1623	18	in	in	IN
5180	1623	19	the	the	DT
5180	1623	20	library	library	NN
5180	1623	21	,	,	,
5180	1623	22	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1623	23	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1623	24	to	to	TO
5180	1623	25	sign	sign	VB
5180	1623	26	forms	form	NNS
5180	1623	27	agreeing	agree	VBG
5180	1623	28	to	to	TO
5180	1623	29	comply	comply	VB
5180	1623	30	with	with	IN
5180	1623	31	the	the	DT
5180	1623	32	policy	policy	NN
5180	1623	33	before	before	IN
5180	1623	34	the	the	DT
5180	1623	35	library	library	NN
5180	1623	36	issues	issue	NNS
5180	1623	37	library	library	NN
5180	1623	38	cards	card	NNS
5180	1623	39	to	to	IN
5180	1623	40	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1623	41	,	,	,
5180	1623	42	and	and	CC
5180	1623	43	by	by	IN
5180	1623	44	presenting	present	VBG
5180	1623	45	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1623	46	,	,	,
5180	1623	47	when	when	WRB
5180	1623	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1623	49	log	log	VBP
5180	1623	50	on	on	RP
5180	1623	51	to	to	IN
5180	1623	52	one	one	CD
5180	1623	53	of	of	IN
5180	1623	54	the	the	DT
5180	1623	55	library	library	NN
5180	1623	56	's	's	POS
5180	1623	57	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1623	58	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1623	59	,	,	,
5180	1623	60	with	with	IN
5180	1623	61	a	a	DT
5180	1623	62	screen	screen	NN
5180	1623	63	that	that	WDT
5180	1623	64	requires	require	VBZ
5180	1623	65	the	the	DT
5180	1623	66	user	user	NN
5180	1623	67	to	to	TO
5180	1623	68	agree	agree	VB
5180	1623	69	to	to	TO
5180	1623	70	comply	comply	VB
5180	1623	71	with	with	IN
5180	1623	72	the	the	DT
5180	1623	73	library	library	NN
5180	1623	74	's	's	POS
5180	1623	75	policy	policy	NN
5180	1623	76	before	before	IN
5180	1623	77	allowing	allow	VBG
5180	1623	78	the	the	DT
5180	1623	79	user	user	NN
5180	1623	80	access	access	NN
5180	1623	81	to	to	IN
5180	1623	82	the	the	DT
5180	1623	83	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1623	84	.	.	.
5180	1624	1	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	1624	2	can	can	MD
5180	1624	3	detect	detect	VB
5180	1624	4	violations	violation	NNS
5180	1624	5	of	of	IN
5180	1624	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1624	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1624	8	use	use	VBP
5180	1624	9	policies	policy	NNS
5180	1624	10	either	either	CC
5180	1624	11	through	through	IN
5180	1624	12	direct	direct	JJ
5180	1624	13	observation	observation	NN
5180	1624	14	or	or	CC
5180	1624	15	through	through	IN
5180	1624	16	review	review	NN
5180	1624	17	of	of	IN
5180	1624	18	the	the	DT
5180	1624	19	library	library	NN
5180	1624	20	's	's	POS
5180	1624	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1624	22	use	use	NN
5180	1624	23	logs	log	NNS
5180	1624	24	.	.	.
5180	1625	1	In	in	IN
5180	1625	2	some	some	DT
5180	1625	3	cases	case	NNS
5180	1625	4	,	,	,
5180	1625	5	library	library	JJ
5180	1625	6	staff	staff	NN
5180	1625	7	or	or	CC
5180	1625	8	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1625	9	may	may	MD
5180	1625	10	directly	directly	RB
5180	1625	11	observe	observe	VB
5180	1625	12	a	a	DT
5180	1625	13	patron	patron	NN
5180	1625	14	accessing	access	VBG
5180	1625	15	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1625	16	and	and	CC
5180	1625	17	child	child	NN
5180	1625	18	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1625	19	.	.	.
5180	1626	1	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	1626	2	'	'	POS
5180	1626	3	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1626	4	use	use	NN
5180	1626	5	logs	log	NNS
5180	1626	6	,	,	,
5180	1626	7	however	however	RB
5180	1626	8	,	,	,
5180	1626	9	also	also	RB
5180	1626	10	provide	provide	VBP
5180	1626	11	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1626	12	with	with	IN
5180	1626	13	a	a	DT
5180	1626	14	means	means	NN
5180	1626	15	of	of	IN
5180	1626	16	detecting	detect	VBG
5180	1626	17	violations	violation	NNS
5180	1626	18	of	of	IN
5180	1626	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1626	20	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1626	21	use	use	NN
5180	1626	22	policies	policy	NNS
5180	1626	23	.	.	.
5180	1627	1	These	these	DT
5180	1627	2	logs	log	NNS
5180	1627	3	,	,	,
5180	1627	4	which	which	WDT
5180	1627	5	can	can	MD
5180	1627	6	be	be	VB
5180	1627	7	kept	keep	VBN
5180	1627	8	regardless	regardless	RB
5180	1627	9	whether	whether	IN
5180	1627	10	a	a	DT
5180	1627	11	library	library	NN
5180	1627	12	uses	use	VBZ
5180	1627	13	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1627	14	software	software	NN
5180	1627	15	,	,	,
5180	1627	16	record	record	VB
5180	1627	17	the	the	DT
5180	1627	18	URL	url	NN
5180	1627	19	of	of	IN
5180	1627	20	every	every	DT
5180	1627	21	Web	web	NN
5180	1627	22	page	page	NN
5180	1627	23	accessed	access	VBN
5180	1627	24	by	by	IN
5180	1627	25	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1627	26	.	.	.
5180	1628	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1628	2	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
5180	1628	3	the	the	DT
5180	1628	4	logs	log	NNS
5180	1628	5	do	do	VBP
5180	1628	6	not	not	RB
5180	1628	7	link	link	VB
5180	1628	8	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1628	9	URLs	url	NNS
5180	1628	10	with	with	IN
5180	1628	11	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1628	12	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1628	13	,	,	,
5180	1628	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1628	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	1628	16	possible	possible	JJ
5180	1628	17	,	,	,
5180	1628	18	using	use	VBG
5180	1628	19	access	access	NN
5180	1628	20	logs	log	NNS
5180	1628	21	,	,	,
5180	1628	22	to	to	TO
5180	1628	23	identify	identify	VB
5180	1628	24	the	the	DT
5180	1628	25	patron	patron	NN
5180	1628	26	who	who	WP
5180	1628	27	viewed	view	VBD
5180	1628	28	the	the	DT
5180	1628	29	Web	web	NN
5180	1628	30	page	page	NN
5180	1628	31	corresponding	correspond	VBG
5180	1628	32	to	to	IN
5180	1628	33	a	a	DT
5180	1628	34	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1628	35	URL	url	NN
5180	1628	36	,	,	,
5180	1628	37	if	if	IN
5180	1628	38	library	library	NN
5180	1628	39	staff	staff	NN
5180	1628	40	discover	discover	VBP
5180	1628	41	in	in	IN
5180	1628	42	the	the	DT
5180	1628	43	access	access	NN
5180	1628	44	logs	log	VBZ
5180	1628	45	the	the	DT
5180	1628	46	URL	url	NN
5180	1628	47	of	of	IN
5180	1628	48	a	a	DT
5180	1628	49	Web	web	NN
5180	1628	50	page	page	NN
5180	1628	51	containing	contain	VBG
5180	1628	52	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1628	53	or	or	CC
5180	1628	54	child	child	NN
5180	1628	55	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1628	56	.	.	.
5180	1629	1	For	for	IN
5180	1629	2	example	example	NN
5180	1629	3	,	,	,
5180	1629	4	David	David	NNP
5180	1629	5	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	1629	6	,	,	,
5180	1629	7	Director	Director	NNP
5180	1629	8	of	of	IN
5180	1629	9	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	1629	10	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1629	11	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1629	12	's	's	POS
5180	1629	13	main	main	JJ
5180	1629	14	branch	branch	NN
5180	1629	15	,	,	,
5180	1629	16	testified	testify	VBD
5180	1629	17	that	that	IN
5180	1629	18	in	in	IN
5180	1629	19	the	the	DT
5180	1629	20	course	course	NN
5180	1629	21	of	of	IN
5180	1629	22	scanning	scan	VBG
5180	1629	23	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1629	24	use	use	NN
5180	1629	25	logs	log	NNS
5180	1629	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1629	27	has	have	VBZ
5180	1629	28	found	find	VBN
5180	1629	29	what	what	WP
5180	1629	30	looked	look	VBD
5180	1629	31	like	like	IN
5180	1629	32	attempts	attempt	NNS
5180	1629	33	to	to	TO
5180	1629	34	access	access	VB
5180	1629	35	child	child	NN
5180	1629	36	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1629	37	,	,	,
5180	1629	38	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
5180	1629	39	the	the	DT
5180	1629	40	fact	fact	NN
5180	1629	41	that	that	IN
5180	1629	42	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	1629	43	uses	use	VBZ
5180	1629	44	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	1629	45	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	1629	46	software	software	NN
5180	1629	47	.	.	.
5180	1630	1	In	in	IN
5180	1630	2	two	two	CD
5180	1630	3	cases	case	NNS
5180	1630	4	,	,	,
5180	1630	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1630	6	communicated	communicate	VBD
5180	1630	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1630	8	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1630	9	to	to	IN
5180	1630	10	law	law	NN
5180	1630	11	enforcement	enforcement	NN
5180	1630	12	and	and	CC
5180	1630	13	turned	turn	VBD
5180	1630	14	over	over	RP
5180	1630	15	the	the	DT
5180	1630	16	logs	log	NNS
5180	1630	17	to	to	IN
5180	1630	18	law	law	NN
5180	1630	19	enforcement	enforcement	NN
5180	1630	20	in	in	IN
5180	1630	21	response	response	NN
5180	1630	22	to	to	IN
5180	1630	23	a	a	DT
5180	1630	24	subpoena	subpoena	NN
5180	1630	25	.	.	.
5180	1631	1	Once	once	RB
5180	1631	2	a	a	DT
5180	1631	3	violation	violation	NN
5180	1631	4	of	of	IN
5180	1631	5	a	a	DT
5180	1631	6	library	library	NN
5180	1631	7	's	's	POS
5180	1631	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1631	9	use	use	NN
5180	1631	10	policy	policy	NN
5180	1631	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	1631	12	detected	detect	VBN
5180	1631	13	through	through	IN
5180	1631	14	the	the	DT
5180	1631	15	methods	method	NNS
5180	1631	16	described	describe	VBN
5180	1631	17	above	above	RB
5180	1631	18	,	,	,
5180	1631	19	a	a	DT
5180	1631	20	library	library	NN
5180	1631	21	may	may	MD
5180	1631	22	either	either	CC
5180	1631	23	issue	issue	VB
5180	1631	24	the	the	DT
5180	1631	25	patron	patron	NN
5180	1631	26	a	a	DT
5180	1631	27	warning	warning	NN
5180	1631	28	,	,	,
5180	1631	29	revoke	revoke	VB
5180	1631	30	the	the	DT
5180	1631	31	patron	patron	NN
5180	1631	32	's	's	POS
5180	1631	33	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1631	34	privileges	privilege	NNS
5180	1631	35	,	,	,
5180	1631	36	or	or	CC
5180	1631	37	notify	notify	VB
5180	1631	38	law	law	NN
5180	1631	39	enforcement	enforcement	NN
5180	1631	40	,	,	,
5180	1631	41	if	if	IN
5180	1631	42	the	the	DT
5180	1631	43	library	library	NN
5180	1631	44	believes	believe	VBZ
5180	1631	45	that	that	IN
5180	1631	46	the	the	DT
5180	1631	47	patron	patron	NN
5180	1631	48	violated	violate	VBD
5180	1631	49	either	either	CC
5180	1631	50	state	state	NN
5180	1631	51	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1631	52	laws	law	NNS
5180	1631	53	or	or	CC
5180	1631	54	child	child	NN
5180	1631	55	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1631	56	laws	law	NNS
5180	1631	57	.	.	.
5180	1632	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1632	2	these	these	DT
5180	1632	3	methods	method	NNS
5180	1632	4	of	of	IN
5180	1632	5	detecting	detect	VBG
5180	1632	6	use	use	NN
5180	1632	7	of	of	IN
5180	1632	8	library	library	JJ
5180	1632	9	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1632	10	to	to	TO
5180	1632	11	access	access	VB
5180	1632	12	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	1632	13	content	content	NN
5180	1632	14	are	be	VBP
5180	1632	15	not	not	RB
5180	1632	16	perfect	perfect	JJ
5180	1632	17	,	,	,
5180	1632	18	and	and	CC
5180	1632	19	a	a	DT
5180	1632	20	library	library	NN
5180	1632	21	,	,	,
5180	1632	22	out	out	IN
5180	1632	23	of	of	IN
5180	1632	24	respect	respect	NN
5180	1632	25	for	for	IN
5180	1632	26	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1632	27	'	'	POS
5180	1632	28	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1632	29	,	,	,
5180	1632	30	may	may	MD
5180	1632	31	choose	choose	VB
5180	1632	32	not	not	RB
5180	1632	33	to	to	TO
5180	1632	34	adopt	adopt	VB
5180	1632	35	such	such	JJ
5180	1632	36	policies	policy	NNS
5180	1632	37	,	,	,
5180	1632	38	the	the	DT
5180	1632	39	government	government	NN
5180	1632	40	has	have	VBZ
5180	1632	41	failed	fail	VBN
5180	1632	42	to	to	TO
5180	1632	43	show	show	VB
5180	1632	44	that	that	IN
5180	1632	45	such	such	JJ
5180	1632	46	methods	method	NNS
5180	1632	47	are	be	VBP
5180	1632	48	substantially	substantially	RB
5180	1632	49	less	less	RBR
5180	1632	50	effective	effective	JJ
5180	1632	51	at	at	IN
5180	1632	52	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1632	53	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1632	54	from	from	IN
5180	1632	55	accessing	access	VBG
5180	1632	56	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1632	57	and	and	CC
5180	1632	58	child	child	NN
5180	1632	59	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1632	60	than	than	IN
5180	1632	61	software	software	NN
5180	1632	62	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1632	63	.	.	.
5180	1633	1	As	as	IN
5180	1633	2	detailed	detail	VBN
5180	1633	3	in	in	IN
5180	1633	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1633	5	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1633	6	of	of	IN
5180	1633	7	fact	fact	NN
5180	1633	8	,	,	,
5180	1633	9	the	the	DT
5180	1633	10	underblocking	underblocking	NN
5180	1633	11	that	that	WDT
5180	1633	12	results	result	VBZ
5180	1633	13	from	from	IN
5180	1633	14	the	the	DT
5180	1633	15	size	size	NN
5180	1633	16	,	,	,
5180	1633	17	rate	rate	NN
5180	1633	18	of	of	IN
5180	1633	19	change	change	NN
5180	1633	20	,	,	,
5180	1633	21	and	and	CC
5180	1633	22	rate	rate	NN
5180	1633	23	of	of	IN
5180	1633	24	growth	growth	NN
5180	1633	25	of	of	IN
5180	1633	26	the	the	DT
5180	1633	27	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1633	28	significantly	significantly	RB
5180	1633	29	impairs	impairs	VBP
5180	1633	30	the	the	DT
5180	1633	31	software	software	NN
5180	1633	32	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1633	33	from	from	IN
5180	1633	34	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1633	35	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1633	36	from	from	IN
5180	1633	37	accessing	access	VBG
5180	1633	38	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1633	39	and	and	CC
5180	1633	40	child	child	NN
5180	1633	41	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1633	42	.	.	.
5180	1634	1	Unless	unless	IN
5180	1634	2	software	software	NN
5180	1634	3	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1634	4	are	be	VBP
5180	1634	5	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1634	6	perfectly	perfectly	RB
5180	1634	7	effective	effective	JJ
5180	1634	8	at	at	IN
5180	1634	9	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1634	10	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1634	11	from	from	IN
5180	1634	12	accessing	access	VBG
5180	1634	13	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1634	14	and	and	CC
5180	1634	15	child	child	NN
5180	1634	16	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1634	17	,	,	,
5180	1634	18	"	"	''
5180	1634	19	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1634	20	i]t	i]t	NN
5180	1634	21	is	be	VBZ
5180	1634	22	no	no	DT
5180	1634	23	response	response	NN
5180	1634	24	that	that	WDT
5180	1634	25	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1634	26	a	a	DT
5180	1634	27	less	less	RBR
5180	1634	28	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1634	29	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1634	30	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1634	31	.	.	.
5180	1635	1	.	.	.
5180	1636	1	.	.	.
5180	1637	1	may	may	MD
5180	1637	2	not	not	RB
5180	1637	3	go	go	VB
5180	1637	4	perfectly	perfectly	RB
5180	1637	5	every	every	DT
5180	1637	6	time	time	NN
5180	1637	7	.	.	.
5180	1637	8	"	"	''
5180	1638	1	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1638	2	,	,	,
5180	1638	3	529	529	CD
5180	1638	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1638	5	at	at	IN
5180	1638	6	824	824	CD
5180	1638	7	;	;	:
5180	1638	8	cf	cf	NN
5180	1638	9	.	.	.
5180	1639	1	Denver	Denver	NNP
5180	1639	2	Area	Area	NNP
5180	1639	3	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	1639	4	.	.	.
5180	1640	1	Telecomm	Telecomm	NNP
5180	1640	2	.	.	.
5180	1641	1	Consortium	Consortium	NNP
5180	1641	2	,	,	,
5180	1641	3	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1641	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	1641	5	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	1641	6	,	,	,
5180	1641	7	518	518	CD
5180	1641	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1641	9	727	727	CD
5180	1641	10	,	,	,
5180	1641	11	759	759	CD
5180	1641	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1641	13	1996	1996	CD
5180	1641	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1641	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1641	16	"	"	``
5180	1641	17	No	no	DT
5180	1641	18	provision	provision	NN
5180	1641	19	.	.	.
5180	1642	1	.	.	.
5180	1643	1	.	.	.
5180	1644	1	short	short	JJ
5180	1644	2	of	of	IN
5180	1644	3	an	an	DT
5180	1644	4	absolute	absolute	JJ
5180	1644	5	ban	ban	NN
5180	1644	6	,	,	,
5180	1644	7	can	can	MD
5180	1644	8	offer	offer	VB
5180	1644	9	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1644	10	protection	protection	NN
5180	1644	11	against	against	IN
5180	1644	12	assault	assault	NN
5180	1644	13	by	by	IN
5180	1644	14	a	a	DT
5180	1644	15	determined	determine	VBN
5180	1644	16	child	child	NN
5180	1644	17	.	.	.
5180	1644	18	"	"	''
5180	1644	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1644	20	.	.	.
5180	1645	1	The	the	DT
5180	1645	2	government	government	NN
5180	1645	3	has	have	VBZ
5180	1645	4	not	not	RB
5180	1645	5	offered	offer	VBN
5180	1645	6	any	any	DT
5180	1645	7	data	datum	NNS
5180	1645	8	comparing	compare	VBG
5180	1645	9	the	the	DT
5180	1645	10	frequency	frequency	NN
5180	1645	11	with	with	IN
5180	1645	12	which	which	WDT
5180	1645	13	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1645	14	and	and	CC
5180	1645	15	child	child	NN
5180	1645	16	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1645	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	1645	18	accessed	access	VBN
5180	1645	19	at	at	IN
5180	1645	20	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1645	21	that	that	WDT
5180	1645	22	enforce	enforce	VBP
5180	1645	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1645	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1645	25	use	use	NN
5180	1645	26	policies	policy	NNS
5180	1645	27	through	through	IN
5180	1645	28	software	software	NN
5180	1645	29	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1645	30	with	with	IN
5180	1645	31	the	the	DT
5180	1645	32	frequency	frequency	NN
5180	1645	33	with	with	IN
5180	1645	34	which	which	WDT
5180	1645	35	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1645	36	and	and	CC
5180	1645	37	child	child	NN
5180	1645	38	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1645	39	is	be	VBZ
5180	1645	40	accessed	access	VBN
5180	1645	41	at	at	IN
5180	1645	42	public	public	JJ
5180	1645	43	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1645	44	that	that	WDT
5180	1645	45	enforce	enforce	VBP
5180	1645	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1645	47	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1645	48	use	use	NN
5180	1645	49	policies	policy	NNS
5180	1645	50	through	through	IN
5180	1645	51	methods	method	NNS
5180	1645	52	other	other	JJ
5180	1645	53	than	than	IN
5180	1645	54	software	software	NN
5180	1645	55	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1645	56	.	.	.
5180	1646	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1646	2	the	the	DT
5180	1646	3	government	government	NN
5180	1646	4	's	's	POS
5180	1646	5	library	library	NN
5180	1646	6	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	1646	7	offered	offer	VBD
5180	1646	8	anecdotal	anecdotal	JJ
5180	1646	9	accounts	account	NNS
5180	1646	10	of	of	IN
5180	1646	11	a	a	DT
5180	1646	12	reduction	reduction	NN
5180	1646	13	in	in	IN
5180	1646	14	the	the	DT
5180	1646	15	use	use	NN
5180	1646	16	of	of	IN
5180	1646	17	library	library	JJ
5180	1646	18	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1646	19	to	to	TO
5180	1646	20	access	access	VB
5180	1646	21	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1646	22	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1646	23	speech	speech	NN
5180	1646	24	when	when	WRB
5180	1646	25	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1646	26	software	software	NN
5180	1646	27	was	be	VBD
5180	1646	28	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	1646	29	,	,	,
5180	1646	30	these	these	DT
5180	1646	31	anecdotal	anecdotal	JJ
5180	1646	32	accounts	account	NNS
5180	1646	33	are	be	VBP
5180	1646	34	not	not	RB
5180	1646	35	a	a	DT
5180	1646	36	substitute	substitute	NN
5180	1646	37	for	for	IN
5180	1646	38	more	more	RBR
5180	1646	39	robust	robust	JJ
5180	1646	40	analyses	analysis	NNS
5180	1646	41	comparing	compare	VBG
5180	1646	42	the	the	DT
5180	1646	43	use	use	NN
5180	1646	44	of	of	IN
5180	1646	45	library	library	JJ
5180	1646	46	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1646	47	to	to	TO
5180	1646	48	access	access	VB
5180	1646	49	child	child	NN
5180	1646	50	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1646	51	and	and	CC
5180	1646	52	material	material	NN
5180	1646	53	that	that	WDT
5180	1646	54	meets	meet	VBZ
5180	1646	55	the	the	DT
5180	1646	56	legal	legal	JJ
5180	1646	57	definition	definition	NN
5180	1646	58	of	of	IN
5180	1646	59	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1646	60	in	in	IN
5180	1646	61	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1646	62	that	that	WDT
5180	1646	63	use	use	VBP
5180	1646	64	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1646	65	software	software	NN
5180	1646	66	and	and	CC
5180	1646	67	in	in	IN
5180	1646	68	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1646	69	that	that	WDT
5180	1646	70	use	use	VBP
5180	1646	71	alternative	alternative	JJ
5180	1646	72	methods	method	NNS
5180	1646	73	.	.	.
5180	1647	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1647	2	.	.	.
5180	1648	1	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1648	2	,	,	,
5180	1648	3	529	529	CD
5180	1648	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1648	5	at	at	IN
5180	1648	6	822	822	CD
5180	1648	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1648	8	"	"	``
5180	1648	9	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1648	10	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	1648	11	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1648	12	must	must	MD
5180	1648	13	present	present	VB
5180	1648	14	more	more	RBR
5180	1648	15	than	than	IN
5180	1648	16	anecdote	anecdote	NN
5180	1648	17	and	and	CC
5180	1648	18	supposition	supposition	NN
5180	1648	19	.	.	.
5180	1648	20	"	"	''
5180	1648	21	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1648	22	.	.	.
5180	1649	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1649	2	acknowledge	acknowledge	VBP
5180	1649	3	that	that	IN
5180	1649	4	some	some	DT
5180	1649	5	library	library	NN
5180	1649	6	staff	staff	NN
5180	1649	7	will	will	MD
5180	1649	8	be	be	VB
5180	1649	9	uncomfortable	uncomfortable	JJ
5180	1649	10	using	use	VBG
5180	1649	11	the	the	DT
5180	1649	12	"	"	``
5180	1649	13	tap	tap	NN
5180	1649	14	-	-	HYPH
5180	1649	15	on	on	IN
5180	1649	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	1649	17	the	the	DT
5180	1649	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	1649	19	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	1649	20	"	"	''
5180	1649	21	method	method	NN
5180	1649	22	of	of	IN
5180	1649	23	enforcing	enforce	VBG
5180	1649	24	the	the	DT
5180	1649	25	library	library	NN
5180	1649	26	's	's	POS
5180	1649	27	policy	policy	NN
5180	1649	28	against	against	IN
5180	1649	29	using	use	VBG
5180	1649	30	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1649	31	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1649	32	to	to	TO
5180	1649	33	access	access	VB
5180	1649	34	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1649	35	and	and	CC
5180	1649	36	child	child	NN
5180	1649	37	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1649	38	.	.	.
5180	1650	1	The	the	DT
5180	1650	2	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
5180	1650	3	County	County	NNP
5180	1650	4	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1650	5	,	,	,
5180	1650	6	for	for	IN
5180	1650	7	example	example	NN
5180	1650	8	,	,	,
5180	1650	9	experienced	experience	VBD
5180	1650	10	high	high	JJ
5180	1650	11	turnover	turnover	NN
5180	1650	12	among	among	IN
5180	1650	13	library	library	NN
5180	1650	14	staff	staff	NN
5180	1650	15	when	when	WRB
5180	1650	16	staff	staff	NN
5180	1650	17	were	be	VBD
5180	1650	18	required	require	VBN
5180	1650	19	to	to	TO
5180	1650	20	enforce	enforce	VB
5180	1650	21	the	the	DT
5180	1650	22	library	library	NN
5180	1650	23	's	's	POS
5180	1650	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1650	25	use	use	NN
5180	1650	26	policy	policy	NN
5180	1650	27	through	through	IN
5180	1650	28	the	the	DT
5180	1650	29	tap	tap	NN
5180	1650	30	-	-	HYPH
5180	1650	31	on	on	IN
5180	1650	32	-	-	HYPH
5180	1650	33	the	the	DT
5180	1650	34	-	-	HYPH
5180	1650	35	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	1650	36	technique	technique	NN
5180	1650	37	.	.	.
5180	1651	1	Given	give	VBN
5180	1651	2	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1651	3	'	'	POS
5180	1651	4	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
5180	1651	5	underblocking	underblocking	NN
5180	1651	6	,	,	,
5180	1651	7	however	however	RB
5180	1651	8	,	,	,
5180	1651	9	even	even	RB
5180	1651	10	a	a	DT
5180	1651	11	library	library	NN
5180	1651	12	that	that	WDT
5180	1651	13	uses	use	VBZ
5180	1651	14	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	1651	15	will	will	MD
5180	1651	16	have	have	VB
5180	1651	17	to	to	TO
5180	1651	18	resort	resort	VB
5180	1651	19	to	to	IN
5180	1651	20	a	a	DT
5180	1651	21	tap	tap	NN
5180	1651	22	-	-	HYPH
5180	1651	23	on	on	IN
5180	1651	24	-	-	HYPH
5180	1651	25	the	the	DT
5180	1651	26	-	-	HYPH
5180	1651	27	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	1651	28	method	method	NN
5180	1651	29	of	of	IN
5180	1651	30	enforcement	enforcement	NN
5180	1651	31	,	,	,
5180	1651	32	where	where	WRB
5180	1651	33	library	library	JJ
5180	1651	34	staff	staff	NN
5180	1651	35	observes	observe	VBZ
5180	1651	36	a	a	DT
5180	1651	37	patron	patron	NN
5180	1651	38	openly	openly	RB
5180	1651	39	violating	violate	VBG
5180	1651	40	the	the	DT
5180	1651	41	library	library	NN
5180	1651	42	's	's	POS
5180	1651	43	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1651	44	use	use	NN
5180	1651	45	policy	policy	NN
5180	1651	46	,	,	,
5180	1651	47	by	by	RB
5180	1651	48	,	,	,
5180	1651	49	for	for	IN
5180	1651	50	example	example	NN
5180	1651	51	,	,	,
5180	1651	52	accessing	access	VBG
5180	1651	53	material	material	NN
5180	1651	54	that	that	WDT
5180	1651	55	is	be	VBZ
5180	1651	56	obviously	obviously	RB
5180	1651	57	child	child	NN
5180	1651	58	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1651	59	but	but	CC
5180	1651	60	that	that	IN
5180	1651	61	the	the	DT
5180	1651	62	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1651	63	software	software	NN
5180	1651	64	failed	fail	VBD
5180	1651	65	to	to	TO
5180	1651	66	block	block	VB
5180	1651	67	.	.	.
5180	1652	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	1652	2	,	,	,
5180	1652	3	a	a	DT
5180	1652	4	library	library	NN
5180	1652	5	employee	employee	NN
5180	1652	6	's	's	POS
5180	1652	7	degree	degree	NN
5180	1652	8	of	of	IN
5180	1652	9	comfort	comfort	NN
5180	1652	10	in	in	IN
5180	1652	11	using	use	VBG
5180	1652	12	the	the	DT
5180	1652	13	tap	tap	NN
5180	1652	14	-	-	HYPH
5180	1652	15	on	on	IN
5180	1652	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	1652	17	the	the	DT
5180	1652	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	1652	19	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	1652	20	method	method	NN
5180	1652	21	will	will	MD
5180	1652	22	vary	vary	VB
5180	1652	23	from	from	IN
5180	1652	24	employee	employee	NN
5180	1652	25	to	to	IN
5180	1652	26	employee	employee	NN
5180	1652	27	,	,	,
5180	1652	28	and	and	CC
5180	1652	29	there	there	EX
5180	1652	30	is	be	VBZ
5180	1652	31	no	no	DT
5180	1652	32	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	1652	33	that	that	IN
5180	1652	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1652	35	is	be	VBZ
5180	1652	36	impossible	impossible	JJ
5180	1652	37	or	or	CC
5180	1652	38	prohibitively	prohibitively	RB
5180	1652	39	costly	costly	JJ
5180	1652	40	for	for	IN
5180	1652	41	public	public	JJ
5180	1652	42	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1652	43	to	to	TO
5180	1652	44	hire	hire	VB
5180	1652	45	at	at	IN
5180	1652	46	least	least	JJS
5180	1652	47	some	some	DT
5180	1652	48	employees	employee	NNS
5180	1652	49	who	who	WP
5180	1652	50	are	be	VBP
5180	1652	51	comfortable	comfortable	JJ
5180	1652	52	enforcing	enforce	VBG
5180	1652	53	the	the	DT
5180	1652	54	library	library	NN
5180	1652	55	's	's	POS
5180	1652	56	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1652	57	use	use	NN
5180	1652	58	policy	policy	NN
5180	1652	59	.	.	.
5180	1653	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1653	2	also	also	RB
5180	1653	3	acknowledge	acknowledge	VBP
5180	1653	4	that	that	IN
5180	1653	5	use	use	NN
5180	1653	6	of	of	IN
5180	1653	7	a	a	DT
5180	1653	8	tap	tap	NN
5180	1653	9	on	on	IN
5180	1653	10	the	the	DT
5180	1653	11	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	1653	12	delegates	delegate	NNS
5180	1653	13	to	to	IN
5180	1653	14	librarians	librarian	VBZ
5180	1653	15	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1653	16	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1653	17	to	to	TO
5180	1653	18	determine	determine	VB
5180	1653	19	which	which	WDT
5180	1653	20	Web	web	NN
5180	1653	21	sites	site	NNS
5180	1653	22	a	a	DT
5180	1653	23	patron	patron	NN
5180	1653	24	may	may	MD
5180	1653	25	view	view	VB
5180	1653	26	.	.	.
5180	1654	1	Nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	1654	2	,	,	,
5180	1654	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1654	4	do	do	VBP
5180	1654	5	not	not	RB
5180	1654	6	believe	believe	VB
5180	1654	7	that	that	IN
5180	1654	8	this	this	DT
5180	1654	9	putative	putative	JJ
5180	1654	10	"	"	``
5180	1654	11	prior	prior	JJ
5180	1654	12	restraint	restraint	NN
5180	1654	13	"	"	''
5180	1654	14	problem	problem	NN
5180	1654	15	can	can	MD
5180	1654	16	be	be	VB
5180	1654	17	avoided	avoid	VBN
5180	1654	18	through	through	IN
5180	1654	19	the	the	DT
5180	1654	20	use	use	NN
5180	1654	21	of	of	IN
5180	1654	22	software	software	NN
5180	1654	23	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1654	24	,	,	,
5180	1654	25	for	for	IN
5180	1654	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1654	27	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	1654	28	delegate	delegate	VBP
5180	1654	29	to	to	IN
5180	1654	30	the	the	DT
5180	1654	31	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	1654	32	company	company	NN
5180	1654	33	the	the	DT
5180	1654	34	same	same	JJ
5180	1654	35	unfettered	unfettered	JJ
5180	1654	36	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1654	37	to	to	TO
5180	1654	38	determine	determine	VB
5180	1654	39	which	which	WDT
5180	1654	40	Web	web	NN
5180	1654	41	sites	site	NNS
5180	1654	42	a	a	DT
5180	1654	43	patron	patron	NN
5180	1654	44	may	may	MD
5180	1654	45	view	view	VB
5180	1654	46	.	.	.
5180	1655	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	1655	2	,	,	,
5180	1655	3	as	as	IN
5180	1655	4	noted	note	VBN
5180	1655	5	above	above	IN
5180	1655	6	,	,	,
5180	1655	7	violations	violation	NNS
5180	1655	8	of	of	IN
5180	1655	9	a	a	DT
5180	1655	10	public	public	JJ
5180	1655	11	library	library	NN
5180	1655	12	's	's	POS
5180	1655	13	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1655	14	use	use	NN
5180	1655	15	policy	policy	NN
5180	1655	16	may	may	MD
5180	1655	17	be	be	VB
5180	1655	18	detected	detect	VBN
5180	1655	19	not	not	RB
5180	1655	20	only	only	RB
5180	1655	21	by	by	IN
5180	1655	22	direct	direct	JJ
5180	1655	23	observation	observation	NN
5180	1655	24	,	,	,
5180	1655	25	but	but	CC
5180	1655	26	also	also	RB
5180	1655	27	by	by	IN
5180	1655	28	reviewing	review	VBG
5180	1655	29	the	the	DT
5180	1655	30	library	library	NN
5180	1655	31	's	's	POS
5180	1655	32	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1655	33	use	use	NN
5180	1655	34	logs	log	NNS
5180	1655	35	after	after	IN
5180	1655	36	the	the	DT
5180	1655	37	fact	fact	NN
5180	1655	38	,	,	,
5180	1655	39	which	which	WDT
5180	1655	40	alleviates	alleviate	VBZ
5180	1655	41	the	the	DT
5180	1655	42	need	need	NN
5180	1655	43	for	for	IN
5180	1655	44	library	library	JJ
5180	1655	45	staff	staff	NN
5180	1655	46	to	to	TO
5180	1655	47	directly	directly	RB
5180	1655	48	confront	confront	VB
5180	1655	49	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1655	50	while	while	IN
5180	1655	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1655	52	are	be	VBP
5180	1655	53	viewing	view	VBG
5180	1655	54	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1655	55	or	or	CC
5180	1655	56	child	child	NN
5180	1655	57	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1655	58	.	.	.
5180	1656	1	Similar	similar	JJ
5180	1656	2	less	less	RBR
5180	1656	3	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1656	4	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1656	5	exist	exist	VBP
5180	1656	6	for	for	IN
5180	1656	7	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1656	8	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1656	9	from	from	IN
5180	1656	10	accessing	access	VBG
5180	1656	11	material	material	NN
5180	1656	12	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1656	13	to	to	IN
5180	1656	14	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1656	15	.	.	.
5180	1657	1	First	first	RB
5180	1657	2	,	,	,
5180	1657	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1657	4	may	may	MD
5180	1657	5	use	use	VB
5180	1657	6	the	the	DT
5180	1657	7	tap	tap	NN
5180	1657	8	-	-	HYPH
5180	1657	9	on	on	IN
5180	1657	10	-	-	HYPH
5180	1657	11	the	the	DT
5180	1657	12	-	-	HYPH
5180	1657	13	shoulder	shoulder	NN
5180	1657	14	method	method	NN
5180	1657	15	when	when	WRB
5180	1657	16	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1657	17	are	be	VBP
5180	1657	18	observed	observe	VBN
5180	1657	19	using	use	VBG
5180	1657	20	the	the	DT
5180	1657	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1657	22	to	to	TO
5180	1657	23	access	access	NN
5180	1657	24	material	material	NN
5180	1657	25	that	that	WDT
5180	1657	26	is	be	VBZ
5180	1657	27	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1657	28	to	to	IN
5180	1657	29	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1657	30	.	.	.
5180	1658	1	Requiring	require	VBG
5180	1658	2	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1658	3	to	to	TO
5180	1658	4	use	use	VB
5180	1658	5	specific	specific	JJ
5180	1658	6	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1658	7	,	,	,
5180	1658	8	for	for	IN
5180	1658	9	example	example	NN
5180	1658	10	in	in	IN
5180	1658	11	a	a	DT
5180	1658	12	children	child	NNS
5180	1658	13	's	's	POS
5180	1658	14	room	room	NN
5180	1658	15	,	,	,
5180	1658	16	that	that	WDT
5180	1658	17	are	be	VBP
5180	1658	18	in	in	IN
5180	1658	19	direct	direct	JJ
5180	1658	20	view	view	NN
5180	1658	21	of	of	IN
5180	1658	22	library	library	NN
5180	1658	23	staff	staff	NN
5180	1658	24	will	will	MD
5180	1658	25	increase	increase	VB
5180	1658	26	the	the	DT
5180	1658	27	likelihood	likelihood	NN
5180	1658	28	that	that	IN
5180	1658	29	library	library	NN
5180	1658	30	staff	staff	NN
5180	1658	31	will	will	MD
5180	1658	32	detect	detect	VB
5180	1658	33	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1658	34	'	'	POS
5180	1658	35	use	use	NN
5180	1658	36	of	of	IN
5180	1658	37	the	the	DT
5180	1658	38	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1658	39	to	to	TO
5180	1658	40	access	access	VB
5180	1658	41	material	material	NN
5180	1658	42	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1658	43	to	to	IN
5180	1658	44	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1658	45	.	.	.
5180	1659	1	Alternatively	alternatively	RB
5180	1659	2	,	,	,
5180	1659	3	public	public	JJ
5180	1659	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1659	5	could	could	MD
5180	1659	6	require	require	VB
5180	1659	7	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1659	8	to	to	TO
5180	1659	9	use	use	VB
5180	1659	10	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1659	11	software	software	NN
5180	1659	12	only	only	RB
5180	1659	13	if	if	IN
5180	1659	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1659	15	are	be	VBP
5180	1659	16	unaccompanied	unaccompanied	JJ
5180	1659	17	by	by	IN
5180	1659	18	a	a	DT
5180	1659	19	parent	parent	NN
5180	1659	20	,	,	,
5180	1659	21	or	or	CC
5180	1659	22	only	only	RB
5180	1659	23	if	if	IN
5180	1659	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1659	25	parent	parent	NN
5180	1659	26	consents	consent	NNS
5180	1659	27	in	in	IN
5180	1659	28	advance	advance	NN
5180	1659	29	to	to	IN
5180	1659	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1659	31	child	child	NN
5180	1659	32	's	's	POS
5180	1659	33	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	1659	34	use	use	NN
5180	1659	35	of	of	IN
5180	1659	36	the	the	DT
5180	1659	37	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1659	38	.	.	.
5180	1660	1	"	"	``
5180	1660	2	A	a	DT
5180	1660	3	court	court	NN
5180	1660	4	should	should	MD
5180	1660	5	not	not	RB
5180	1660	6	assume	assume	VB
5180	1660	7	that	that	IN
5180	1660	8	a	a	DT
5180	1660	9	plausible	plausible	JJ
5180	1660	10	,	,	,
5180	1660	11	less	less	RBR
5180	1660	12	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1660	13	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1660	14	would	would	MD
5180	1660	15	be	be	VB
5180	1660	16	ineffective	ineffective	JJ
5180	1660	17	;	;	:
5180	1660	18	and	and	CC
5180	1660	19	a	a	DT
5180	1660	20	court	court	NN
5180	1660	21	should	should	MD
5180	1660	22	not	not	RB
5180	1660	23	presume	presume	VB
5180	1660	24	parents	parent	NNS
5180	1660	25	,	,	,
5180	1660	26	given	give	VBN
5180	1660	27	full	full	JJ
5180	1660	28	information	information	NN
5180	1660	29	,	,	,
5180	1660	30	will	will	MD
5180	1660	31	fail	fail	VB
5180	1660	32	to	to	TO
5180	1660	33	act	act	VB
5180	1660	34	.	.	.
5180	1660	35	"	"	''
5180	1661	1	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1661	2	,	,	,
5180	1661	3	529	529	CD
5180	1661	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1661	5	at	at	IN
5180	1661	6	824	824	CD
5180	1661	7	.	.	.
5180	1662	1	In	in	IN
5180	1662	2	contrast	contrast	NN
5180	1662	3	to	to	IN
5180	1662	4	the	the	DT
5180	1662	5	"	"	``
5180	1662	6	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1662	7	to	to	IN
5180	1662	8	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1662	9	"	"	''
5180	1662	10	statute	statute	NN
5180	1662	11	upheld	uphold	VBD
5180	1662	12	in	in	IN
5180	1662	13	Ginsberg	Ginsberg	NNP
5180	1662	14	v.	v.	CC
5180	1662	15	New	New	NNP
5180	1662	16	York	York	NNP
5180	1662	17	,	,	,
5180	1662	18	390	390	CD
5180	1662	19	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1662	20	629	629	CD
5180	1662	21	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1662	22	1968	1968	CD
5180	1662	23	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1662	24	,	,	,
5180	1662	25	which	which	WDT
5180	1662	26	permitted	permit	VBD
5180	1662	27	parents	parent	NNS
5180	1662	28	to	to	TO
5180	1662	29	determine	determine	VB
5180	1662	30	whether	whether	IN
5180	1662	31	to	to	TO
5180	1662	32	provide	provide	VB
5180	1662	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1662	34	children	child	NNS
5180	1662	35	with	with	IN
5180	1662	36	access	access	NN
5180	1662	37	to	to	IN
5180	1662	38	material	material	NN
5180	1662	39	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1662	40	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
5180	1662	41	by	by	IN
5180	1662	42	the	the	DT
5180	1662	43	statute	statute	NN
5180	1662	44	,	,	,
5180	1662	45	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1662	46	,	,	,
5180	1662	47	like	like	IN
5180	1662	48	the	the	DT
5180	1662	49	Communications	Communications	NNP
5180	1662	50	Decency	Decency	NNP
5180	1662	51	Act	Act	NNP
5180	1662	52	,	,	,
5180	1662	53	which	which	WDT
5180	1662	54	the	the	DT
5180	1662	55	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1662	56	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
5180	1662	57	in	in	IN
5180	1662	58	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1662	59	,	,	,
5180	1662	60	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	1662	61	no	no	DT
5180	1662	62	exception	exception	NN
5180	1662	63	for	for	IN
5180	1662	64	parental	parental	JJ
5180	1662	65	consent	consent	NN
5180	1662	66	:	:	:
5180	1662	67	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1662	68	W]e	W]e	NNP
5180	1662	69	noted	note	VBN
5180	1662	70	in	in	IN
5180	1662	71	Ginsberg	Ginsberg	NNP
5180	1662	72	that	that	IN
5180	1662	73	"	"	``
5180	1662	74	the	the	DT
5180	1662	75	prohibition	prohibition	NN
5180	1662	76	against	against	IN
5180	1662	77	sales	sale	NNS
5180	1662	78	to	to	IN
5180	1662	79	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1662	80	does	do	VBZ
5180	1662	81	not	not	RB
5180	1662	82	bar	bar	VB
5180	1662	83	parents	parent	NNS
5180	1662	84	who	who	WP
5180	1662	85	so	so	RB
5180	1662	86	desire	desire	VBP
5180	1662	87	from	from	IN
5180	1662	88	purchasing	purchase	VBG
5180	1662	89	the	the	DT
5180	1662	90	magazines	magazine	NNS
5180	1662	91	for	for	IN
5180	1662	92	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1662	93	children	child	NNS
5180	1662	94	.	.	.
5180	1662	95	"	"	''
5180	1663	1	Under	under	IN
5180	1663	2	the	the	DT
5180	1663	3	CDA	cda	NN
5180	1663	4	,	,	,
5180	1663	5	by	by	IN
5180	1663	6	contrast	contrast	NN
5180	1663	7	,	,	,
5180	1663	8	neither	neither	CC
5180	1663	9	the	the	DT
5180	1663	10	parents	parent	NNS
5180	1663	11	'	'	POS
5180	1663	12	consent	consent	NN
5180	1663	13	–	–	:
5180	1663	14	nor	nor	CC
5180	1663	15	even	even	RB
5180	1663	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1663	17	participation	participation	NN
5180	1663	18	–	–	:
5180	1663	19	in	in	IN
5180	1663	20	the	the	DT
5180	1663	21	communication	communication	NN
5180	1663	22	would	would	MD
5180	1663	23	avoid	avoid	VB
5180	1663	24	the	the	DT
5180	1663	25	application	application	NN
5180	1663	26	of	of	IN
5180	1663	27	the	the	DT
5180	1663	28	statute	statute	NN
5180	1663	29	.	.	.
5180	1664	1	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	1664	2	,	,	,
5180	1664	3	521	521	CD
5180	1664	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1664	5	at	at	IN
5180	1664	6	865	865	CD
5180	1664	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1664	8	citation	citation	NN
5180	1664	9	omitted	omit	VBN
5180	1664	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1664	11	;	;	:
5180	1664	12	see	see	VB
5180	1664	13	also	also	RB
5180	1664	14	Ginsberg	Ginsberg	NNP
5180	1664	15	,	,	,
5180	1664	16	390	390	CD
5180	1664	17	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1664	18	at	at	IN
5180	1664	19	639	639	CD
5180	1664	20	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1664	21	"	"	``
5180	1664	22	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1664	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	1664	24	cardinal	cardinal	JJ
5180	1664	25	with	with	IN
5180	1664	26	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1664	27	that	that	IN
5180	1664	28	the	the	DT
5180	1664	29	custody	custody	NN
5180	1664	30	,	,	,
5180	1664	31	care	care	NN
5180	1664	32	,	,	,
5180	1664	33	and	and	CC
5180	1664	34	nurture	nurture	NN
5180	1664	35	of	of	IN
5180	1664	36	the	the	DT
5180	1664	37	child	child	NN
5180	1664	38	reside	reside	VBP
5180	1664	39	first	first	RB
5180	1664	40	in	in	IN
5180	1664	41	the	the	DT
5180	1664	42	parents	parent	NNS
5180	1664	43	,	,	,
5180	1664	44	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1664	45	primary	primary	JJ
5180	1664	46	function	function	NN
5180	1664	47	and	and	CC
5180	1664	48	freedom	freedom	NN
5180	1664	49	include	include	VBP
5180	1664	50	preparation	preparation	NN
5180	1664	51	for	for	IN
5180	1664	52	obligations	obligation	NNS
5180	1664	53	the	the	DT
5180	1664	54	state	state	NN
5180	1664	55	can	can	MD
5180	1664	56	neither	neither	CC
5180	1664	57	supply	supply	VB
5180	1664	58	nor	nor	CC
5180	1664	59	hinder	hinder	NN
5180	1664	60	.	.	.
5180	1664	61	"	"	''
5180	1665	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1665	2	quoting	quote	VBG
5180	1665	3	Prince	Prince	NNP
5180	1665	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	1665	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
5180	1665	6	,	,	,
5180	1665	7	321	321	CD
5180	1665	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1665	9	158	158	CD
5180	1665	10	,	,	,
5180	1665	11	166	166	CD
5180	1665	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1665	13	1944	1944	CD
5180	1665	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1665	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1665	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1665	17	.	.	.
5180	1666	1	The	the	DT
5180	1666	2	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1666	3	in	in	IN
5180	1666	4	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1666	5	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBD
5180	1666	6	that	that	IN
5180	1666	7	although	although	IN
5180	1666	8	a	a	DT
5180	1666	9	regime	regime	NN
5180	1666	10	of	of	IN
5180	1666	11	permitting	permit	VBG
5180	1666	12	parents	parent	NNS
5180	1666	13	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
5180	1666	14	to	to	TO
5180	1666	15	block	block	VB
5180	1666	16	cable	cable	NN
5180	1666	17	channels	channel	NNS
5180	1666	18	containing	contain	VBG
5180	1666	19	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1666	20	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1666	21	programming	programming	NN
5180	1666	22	might	may	MD
5180	1666	23	not	not	RB
5180	1666	24	be	be	VB
5180	1666	25	a	a	DT
5180	1666	26	completely	completely	RB
5180	1666	27	effective	effective	JJ
5180	1666	28	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1666	29	to	to	IN
5180	1666	30	the	the	DT
5180	1666	31	challenged	challenge	VBN
5180	1666	32	law	law	NN
5180	1666	33	,	,	,
5180	1666	34	which	which	WDT
5180	1666	35	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	1666	36	required	require	VBD
5180	1666	37	cable	cable	NN
5180	1666	38	operators	operator	NNS
5180	1666	39	to	to	TO
5180	1666	40	transmit	transmit	VB
5180	1666	41	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1666	42	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1666	43	programming	programming	NN
5180	1666	44	only	only	RB
5180	1666	45	during	during	IN
5180	1666	46	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1666	47	hours	hour	NNS
5180	1666	48	,	,	,
5180	1666	49	the	the	DT
5180	1666	50	challenged	challenge	VBN
5180	1666	51	law	law	NN
5180	1666	52	itself	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1666	53	was	be	VBD
5180	1666	54	not	not	RB
5180	1666	55	completely	completely	RB
5180	1666	56	effective	effective	JJ
5180	1666	57	in	in	IN
5180	1666	58	serving	serve	VBG
5180	1666	59	the	the	DT
5180	1666	60	government	government	NN
5180	1666	61	's	's	POS
5180	1666	62	interest	interest	NN
5180	1666	63	:	:	:
5180	1666	64	There	there	EX
5180	1666	65	can	can	MD
5180	1666	66	be	be	VB
5180	1666	67	little	little	JJ
5180	1666	68	doubt	doubt	NN
5180	1666	69	,	,	,
5180	1666	70	of	of	IN
5180	1666	71	course	course	NN
5180	1666	72	,	,	,
5180	1666	73	that	that	IN
5180	1666	74	under	under	IN
5180	1666	75	a	a	DT
5180	1666	76	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
5180	1666	77	blocking	blocking	NN
5180	1666	78	regime	regime	NN
5180	1666	79	,	,	,
5180	1666	80	even	even	RB
5180	1666	81	with	with	IN
5180	1666	82	adequate	adequate	JJ
5180	1666	83	notice	notice	NN
5180	1666	84	,	,	,
5180	1666	85	some	some	DT
5180	1666	86	children	child	NNS
5180	1666	87	will	will	MD
5180	1666	88	be	be	VB
5180	1666	89	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1666	90	to	to	IN
5180	1666	91	signal	signal	JJ
5180	1666	92	bleed	bleed	NN
5180	1666	93	;	;	:
5180	1666	94	and	and	CC
5180	1666	95	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1666	96	need	need	VBP
5180	1666	97	not	not	RB
5180	1666	98	discount	discount	VB
5180	1666	99	the	the	DT
5180	1666	100	possibility	possibility	NN
5180	1666	101	that	that	IN
5180	1666	102	a	a	DT
5180	1666	103	graphic	graphic	JJ
5180	1666	104	image	image	NN
5180	1666	105	could	could	MD
5180	1666	106	have	have	VB
5180	1666	107	a	a	DT
5180	1666	108	negative	negative	JJ
5180	1666	109	impact	impact	NN
5180	1666	110	on	on	IN
5180	1666	111	a	a	DT
5180	1666	112	young	young	JJ
5180	1666	113	child	child	NN
5180	1666	114	.	.	.
5180	1667	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1667	2	must	must	MD
5180	1667	3	be	be	VB
5180	1667	4	remembered	remember	VBN
5180	1667	5	,	,	,
5180	1667	6	however	however	RB
5180	1667	7	,	,	,
5180	1667	8	that	that	IN
5180	1667	9	children	child	NNS
5180	1667	10	will	will	MD
5180	1667	11	be	be	VB
5180	1667	12	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1667	13	to	to	IN
5180	1667	14	signal	signal	JJ
5180	1667	15	bleed	bleed	NN
5180	1667	16	under	under	IN
5180	1667	17	time	time	NN
5180	1667	18	channeling	channel	VBG
5180	1667	19	as	as	RB
5180	1667	20	well	well	RB
5180	1667	21	.	.	.
5180	1668	1	.	.	.
5180	1669	1	.	.	.
5180	1670	1	.	.	.
5180	1671	1	The	the	DT
5180	1671	2	record	record	NN
5180	1671	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1671	4	silent	silent	JJ
5180	1671	5	as	as	IN
5180	1671	6	to	to	IN
5180	1671	7	the	the	DT
5180	1671	8	comparative	comparative	JJ
5180	1671	9	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
5180	1671	10	of	of	IN
5180	1671	11	the	the	DT
5180	1671	12	two	two	CD
5180	1671	13	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1671	14	.	.	.
5180	1672	1	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1672	2	,	,	,
5180	1672	3	529	529	CD
5180	1672	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1672	5	at	at	IN
5180	1672	6	826	826	CD
5180	1672	7	.	.	.
5180	1673	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1673	2	,	,	,
5180	1673	3	in	in	IN
5180	1673	4	this	this	DT
5180	1673	5	case	case	NN
5180	1673	6	,	,	,
5180	1673	7	the	the	DT
5180	1673	8	government	government	NN
5180	1673	9	has	have	VBZ
5180	1673	10	offered	offer	VBN
5180	1673	11	no	no	DT
5180	1673	12	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	1673	13	comparing	compare	VBG
5180	1673	14	the	the	DT
5180	1673	15	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
5180	1673	16	of	of	IN
5180	1673	17	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1673	18	software	software	NN
5180	1673	19	and	and	CC
5180	1673	20	alternative	alternative	JJ
5180	1673	21	methods	method	NNS
5180	1673	22	used	use	VBN
5180	1673	23	by	by	IN
5180	1673	24	public	public	JJ
5180	1673	25	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1673	26	to	to	TO
5180	1673	27	protect	protect	VB
5180	1673	28	children	child	NNS
5180	1673	29	from	from	IN
5180	1673	30	material	material	NN
5180	1673	31	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1673	32	to	to	IN
5180	1673	33	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1673	34	.	.	.
5180	1674	1	Finally	finally	RB
5180	1674	2	,	,	,
5180	1674	3	there	there	EX
5180	1674	4	are	be	VBP
5180	1674	5	other	other	JJ
5180	1674	6	less	less	RBR
5180	1674	7	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1674	8	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1674	9	to	to	IN
5180	1674	10	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1674	11	software	software	NN
5180	1674	12	that	that	WDT
5180	1674	13	further	further	JJ
5180	1674	14	public	public	JJ
5180	1674	15	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1674	16	'	'	POS
5180	1674	17	interest	interest	NN
5180	1674	18	in	in	IN
5180	1674	19	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1674	20	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1674	21	from	from	IN
5180	1674	22	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	1674	23	being	be	VBG
5180	1674	24	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1674	25	to	to	IN
5180	1674	26	patently	patently	RB
5180	1674	27	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1674	28	,	,	,
5180	1674	29	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1674	30	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1674	31	content	content	NN
5180	1674	32	on	on	IN
5180	1674	33	the	the	DT
5180	1674	34	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1674	35	.	.	.
5180	1675	1	To	to	IN
5180	1675	2	the	the	DT
5180	1675	3	extent	extent	NN
5180	1675	4	that	that	IN
5180	1675	5	public	public	JJ
5180	1675	6	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1675	7	are	be	VBP
5180	1675	8	concerned	concern	VBN
5180	1675	9	with	with	IN
5180	1675	10	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1675	11	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1675	12	from	from	IN
5180	1675	13	accidentally	accidentally	RB
5180	1675	14	encountering	encounter	VBG
5180	1675	15	such	such	JJ
5180	1675	16	material	material	NN
5180	1675	17	while	while	IN
5180	1675	18	using	use	VBG
5180	1675	19	the	the	DT
5180	1675	20	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1675	21	,	,	,
5180	1675	22	public	public	JJ
5180	1675	23	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1675	24	can	can	MD
5180	1675	25	provide	provide	VB
5180	1675	26	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1675	27	with	with	IN
5180	1675	28	guidance	guidance	NN
5180	1675	29	in	in	IN
5180	1675	30	finding	find	VBG
5180	1675	31	the	the	DT
5180	1675	32	material	material	NN
5180	1675	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1675	34	want	want	VBP
5180	1675	35	and	and	CC
5180	1675	36	avoiding	avoid	VBG
5180	1675	37	unwanted	unwanted	JJ
5180	1675	38	material	material	NN
5180	1675	39	.	.	.
5180	1676	1	Some	some	DT
5180	1676	2	public	public	JJ
5180	1676	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1676	4	also	also	RB
5180	1676	5	offer	offer	VBP
5180	1676	6	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1676	7	the	the	DT
5180	1676	8	option	option	NN
5180	1676	9	of	of	IN
5180	1676	10	using	use	VBG
5180	1676	11	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1676	12	software	software	NN
5180	1676	13	,	,	,
5180	1676	14	if	if	IN
5180	1676	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1676	16	so	so	RB
5180	1676	17	desire	desire	VBP
5180	1676	18	.	.	.
5180	1677	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1677	2	.	.	.
5180	1678	1	Rowan	Rowan	NNP
5180	1678	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1678	3	Post	Post	NNP
5180	1678	4	Office	Office	NNP
5180	1678	5	Dept	Dept	NNP
5180	1678	6	.	.	NNP
5180	1678	7	,	,	,
5180	1678	8	397	397	CD
5180	1678	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1678	10	728	728	CD
5180	1678	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1678	12	1970	1970	CD
5180	1678	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1678	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1678	15	upholding	uphold	VBG
5180	1678	16	a	a	DT
5180	1678	17	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1678	18	statute	statute	NN
5180	1678	19	permitting	permit	VBG
5180	1678	20	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	1678	21	to	to	TO
5180	1678	22	instruct	instruct	VB
5180	1678	23	the	the	DT
5180	1678	24	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
5180	1678	25	General	General	NNP
5180	1678	26	not	not	RB
5180	1678	27	to	to	TO
5180	1678	28	deliver	deliver	VB
5180	1678	29	advertisements	advertisement	NNS
5180	1678	30	that	that	WDT
5180	1678	31	are	be	VBP
5180	1678	32	"	"	``
5180	1678	33	erotically	erotically	RB
5180	1678	34	arousing	arousing	JJ
5180	1678	35	or	or	CC
5180	1678	36	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1678	37	provocative	provocative	JJ
5180	1678	38	"	"	''
5180	1678	39	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1678	40	.	.	.
5180	1679	1	With	with	IN
5180	1679	2	respect	respect	NN
5180	1679	3	to	to	IN
5180	1679	4	protecting	protect	VBG
5180	1679	5	library	library	NN
5180	1679	6	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1679	7	from	from	IN
5180	1679	8	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1679	9	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1679	10	content	content	NN
5180	1679	11	viewed	view	VBN
5180	1679	12	by	by	IN
5180	1679	13	other	other	JJ
5180	1679	14	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1679	15	,	,	,
5180	1679	16	public	public	JJ
5180	1679	17	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1679	18	have	have	VBP
5180	1679	19	used	use	VBN
5180	1679	20	a	a	DT
5180	1679	21	variety	variety	NN
5180	1679	22	of	of	IN
5180	1679	23	less	less	JJR
5180	1679	24	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1679	25	methods	method	NNS
5180	1679	26	.	.	.
5180	1680	1	One	one	CD
5180	1680	2	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1680	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1680	4	simply	simply	RB
5180	1680	5	to	to	TO
5180	1680	6	segregate	segregate	VB
5180	1680	7	filtered	filter	VBN
5180	1680	8	from	from	IN
5180	1680	9	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	1680	10	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1680	11	,	,	,
5180	1680	12	and	and	CC
5180	1680	13	to	to	TO
5180	1680	14	place	place	VB
5180	1680	15	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	1680	16	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1680	17	outside	outside	RB
5180	1680	18	of	of	IN
5180	1680	19	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1680	20	'	'	POS
5180	1680	21	sight	sight	NN
5180	1680	22	-	-	HYPH
5180	1680	23	lines	line	NNS
5180	1680	24	and	and	CC
5180	1680	25	areas	area	NNS
5180	1680	26	of	of	IN
5180	1680	27	heavy	heavy	JJ
5180	1680	28	traffic	traffic	NN
5180	1680	29	.	.	.
5180	1681	1	Even	even	RB
5180	1681	2	the	the	DT
5180	1681	3	less	less	RBR
5180	1681	4	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1681	5	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1681	6	of	of	IN
5180	1681	7	allowing	allow	VBG
5180	1681	8	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	1681	9	access	access	NN
5180	1681	10	on	on	IN
5180	1681	11	only	only	RB
5180	1681	12	a	a	DT
5180	1681	13	single	single	JJ
5180	1681	14	terminal	terminal	NN
5180	1681	15	,	,	,
5180	1681	16	well	well	UH
5180	1681	17	out	out	IN
5180	1681	18	of	of	IN
5180	1681	19	the	the	DT
5180	1681	20	line	line	NN
5180	1681	21	of	of	IN
5180	1681	22	sight	sight	NN
5180	1681	23	of	of	IN
5180	1681	24	other	other	JJ
5180	1681	25	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1681	26	,	,	,
5180	1681	27	however	however	RB
5180	1681	28	,	,	,
5180	1681	29	is	be	VBZ
5180	1681	30	not	not	RB
5180	1681	31	permitted	permit	VBN
5180	1681	32	under	under	IN
5180	1681	33	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1681	34	,	,	,
5180	1681	35	which	which	WDT
5180	1681	36	requires	require	VBZ
5180	1681	37	the	the	DT
5180	1681	38	use	use	NN
5180	1681	39	of	of	IN
5180	1681	40	a	a	DT
5180	1681	41	technology	technology	NN
5180	1681	42	protection	protection	NN
5180	1681	43	measure	measure	NN
5180	1681	44	on	on	IN
5180	1681	45	every	every	DT
5180	1681	46	computer	computer	NN
5180	1681	47	in	in	IN
5180	1681	48	the	the	DT
5180	1681	49	library	library	NN
5180	1681	50	.	.	.
5180	1682	1	See	see	VB
5180	1682	2	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1682	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1682	4	.	.	.
5180	1683	1	1721(b)(6)(C	1721(b)(6)(C	NNP
5180	1683	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1683	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1683	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1683	5	at	at	IN
5180	1683	6	47	47	CD
5180	1683	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	1684	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1684	2	.	.	.
5180	1685	1	254(h)(6)(C	254(h)(6)(c	LS
5180	1685	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1685	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1685	4	,	,	,
5180	1685	5	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1685	6	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1685	7	.	.	.
5180	1686	1	1712	1712	CD
5180	1686	2	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1686	3	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1686	4	at	at	IN
5180	1686	5	20	20	CD
5180	1686	6	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1687	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1687	2	.	.	.
5180	1688	1	9134(f)(1)(A	9134(f)(1)(A	NNP
5180	1688	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1688	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1688	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1688	5	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1688	6	a	a	DT
5180	1688	7	public	public	JJ
5180	1688	8	library	library	NN
5180	1688	9	receiving	receive	VBG
5180	1688	10	E	e	NN
5180	1688	11	-	-	NN
5180	1688	12	rate	rate	NN
5180	1688	13	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	1688	14	or	or	CC
5180	1688	15	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	1688	16	grants	grant	NNS
5180	1688	17	to	to	TO
5180	1688	18	certify	certify	VB
5180	1688	19	that	that	IN
5180	1688	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1688	21	"	"	``
5180	1688	22	has	have	VBZ
5180	1688	23	in	in	IN
5180	1688	24	place	place	NN
5180	1688	25	a	a	DT
5180	1688	26	policy	policy	NN
5180	1688	27	of	of	IN
5180	1688	28	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1688	29	safety	safety	NN
5180	1688	30	that	that	WDT
5180	1688	31	includes	include	VBZ
5180	1688	32	the	the	DT
5180	1688	33	operation	operation	NN
5180	1688	34	of	of	IN
5180	1688	35	a	a	DT
5180	1688	36	technology	technology	NN
5180	1688	37	protection	protection	NN
5180	1688	38	measure	measure	NN
5180	1688	39	with	with	IN
5180	1688	40	respect	respect	NN
5180	1688	41	to	to	IN
5180	1688	42	any	any	DT
5180	1688	43	of	of	IN
5180	1688	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1688	45	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1688	46	with	with	IN
5180	1688	47	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1688	48	access	access	NN
5180	1688	49	.	.	.
5180	1689	1	.	.	.
5180	1690	1	.	.	.
5180	1691	1	.	.	.
5180	1691	2	"	"	''
5180	1692	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1692	2	emphasis	emphasis	NN
5180	1692	3	added	add	VBN
5180	1692	4	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1692	5	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1692	6	;	;	:
5180	1692	7	In	in	IN
5180	1692	8	re	re	IN
5180	1692	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
5180	1692	10	-	-	HYPH
5180	1692	11	State	State	NNP
5180	1692	12	Joint	Joint	NNP
5180	1692	13	Board	Board	NNP
5180	1692	14	on	on	IN
5180	1692	15	Universal	Universal	NNP
5180	1692	16	Service	Service	NNP
5180	1692	17	:	:	:
5180	1692	18	Children	Children	NNP
5180	1692	19	's	's	POS
5180	1692	20	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	1692	21	Protection	Protection	NNP
5180	1692	22	Act	Act	NNP
5180	1692	23	,	,	,
5180	1692	24	CC	CC	NNP
5180	1692	25	Docket	Docket	NNP
5180	1692	26	No	no	UH
5180	1692	27	.	.	.
5180	1693	1	96	96	CD
5180	1693	2	-	-	SYM
5180	1693	3	45	45	CD
5180	1693	4	,	,	,
5180	1693	5	Report	Report	NNP
5180	1693	6	and	and	CC
5180	1693	7	Order	Order	NNP
5180	1693	8	,	,	,
5180	1693	9	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	1693	10	01	01	CD
5180	1693	11	-	-	SYM
5180	1693	12	120	120	CD
5180	1693	13	,	,	,
5180	1693	14	30	30	CD
5180	1693	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1693	16	Apr.	April	NNP
5180	1694	1	5	5	CD
5180	1694	2	,	,	,
5180	1694	3	2001	2001	CD
5180	1694	4	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1694	5	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1694	6	"	"	``
5180	1694	7	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1694	8	makes	make	VBZ
5180	1694	9	no	no	DT
5180	1694	10	distinction	distinction	NN
5180	1694	11	between	between	IN
5180	1694	12	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1694	13	used	use	VBN
5180	1694	14	only	only	RB
5180	1694	15	by	by	IN
5180	1694	16	staff	staff	NN
5180	1694	17	and	and	CC
5180	1694	18	those	those	DT
5180	1694	19	accessible	accessible	JJ
5180	1694	20	to	to	IN
5180	1694	21	the	the	DT
5180	1694	22	public	public	NN
5180	1694	23	.	.	.
5180	1694	24	"	"	''
5180	1694	25	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1694	26	.	.	.
5180	1695	1	Alternatively	alternatively	RB
5180	1695	2	,	,	,
5180	1695	3	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1695	4	can	can	MD
5180	1695	5	use	use	VB
5180	1695	6	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1695	7	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1695	8	or	or	CC
5180	1695	9	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	1695	10	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	1695	11	to	to	TO
5180	1695	12	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	1695	13	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1695	14	from	from	IN
5180	1695	15	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	1695	16	being	be	VBG
5180	1695	17	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1695	18	to	to	IN
5180	1695	19	material	material	NN
5180	1695	20	viewed	view	VBN
5180	1695	21	by	by	IN
5180	1695	22	other	other	JJ
5180	1695	23	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1695	24	.	.	.
5180	1696	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1696	2	acknowledge	acknowledge	VBP
5180	1696	3	that	that	IN
5180	1696	4	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1696	5	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1696	6	and	and	CC
5180	1696	7	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	1696	8	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	1696	9	suffer	suffer	VBP
5180	1696	10	from	from	IN
5180	1696	11	imperfections	imperfection	NNS
5180	1696	12	as	as	IN
5180	1696	13	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1696	14	to	to	IN
5180	1696	15	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1696	16	.	.	.
5180	1697	1	Both	both	DT
5180	1697	2	impose	impose	VB
5180	1697	3	costs	cost	NNS
5180	1697	4	on	on	IN
5180	1697	5	the	the	DT
5180	1697	6	library	library	NN
5180	1697	7	,	,	,
5180	1697	8	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	1697	9	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	1697	10	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	1697	11	,	,	,
5180	1697	12	which	which	WDT
5180	1697	13	,	,	,
5180	1697	14	according	accord	VBG
5180	1697	15	to	to	IN
5180	1697	16	the	the	DT
5180	1697	17	government	government	NN
5180	1697	18	's	's	POS
5180	1697	19	library	library	NN
5180	1697	20	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	1697	21	,	,	,
5180	1697	22	are	be	VBP
5180	1697	23	expensive	expensive	JJ
5180	1697	24	.	.	.
5180	1698	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	1698	2	,	,	,
5180	1698	3	some	some	DT
5180	1698	4	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1698	5	have	have	VBP
5180	1698	6	experienced	experience	VBN
5180	1698	7	problems	problem	NNS
5180	1698	8	with	with	IN
5180	1698	9	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1698	10	attempting	attempt	VBG
5180	1698	11	to	to	TO
5180	1698	12	remove	remove	VB
5180	1698	13	the	the	DT
5180	1698	14	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1698	15	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1698	16	.	.	.
5180	1699	1	Privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1699	2	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1699	3	and	and	CC
5180	1699	4	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	1699	5	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	1699	6	also	also	RB
5180	1699	7	make	make	VBP
5180	1699	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1699	9	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	1699	10	for	for	IN
5180	1699	11	more	more	JJR
5180	1699	12	than	than	IN
5180	1699	13	one	one	CD
5180	1699	14	person	person	NN
5180	1699	15	to	to	TO
5180	1699	16	work	work	VB
5180	1699	17	at	at	IN
5180	1699	18	the	the	DT
5180	1699	19	same	same	JJ
5180	1699	20	terminal	terminal	NN
5180	1699	21	.	.	.
5180	1700	1	These	these	DT
5180	1700	2	problems	problem	NNS
5180	1700	3	,	,	,
5180	1700	4	however	however	RB
5180	1700	5	,	,	,
5180	1700	6	are	be	VBP
5180	1700	7	not	not	RB
5180	1700	8	insurmountable	insurmountable	JJ
5180	1700	9	.	.	.
5180	1701	1	While	while	IN
5180	1701	2	there	there	EX
5180	1701	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1701	4	no	no	DT
5180	1701	5	doubt	doubt	NN
5180	1701	6	that	that	IN
5180	1701	7	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1701	8	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1701	9	and	and	CC
5180	1701	10	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	1701	11	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1701	12	impose	impose	VBP
5180	1701	13	additional	additional	JJ
5180	1701	14	costs	cost	NNS
5180	1701	15	on	on	IN
5180	1701	16	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1701	17	,	,	,
5180	1701	18	the	the	DT
5180	1701	19	government	government	NN
5180	1701	20	has	have	VBZ
5180	1701	21	failed	fail	VBN
5180	1701	22	to	to	TO
5180	1701	23	show	show	VB
5180	1701	24	that	that	IN
5180	1701	25	the	the	DT
5180	1701	26	cost	cost	NN
5180	1701	27	of	of	IN
5180	1701	28	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1701	29	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1701	30	or	or	CC
5180	1701	31	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	1701	32	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1701	33	is	be	VBZ
5180	1701	34	substantially	substantially	RB
5180	1701	35	greater	great	JJR
5180	1701	36	than	than	IN
5180	1701	37	the	the	DT
5180	1701	38	cost	cost	NN
5180	1701	39	of	of	IN
5180	1701	40	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1701	41	software	software	NN
5180	1701	42	and	and	CC
5180	1701	43	the	the	DT
5180	1701	44	resources	resource	NNS
5180	1701	45	needed	need	VBN
5180	1701	46	to	to	TO
5180	1701	47	maintain	maintain	VB
5180	1701	48	such	such	JJ
5180	1701	49	software	software	NN
5180	1701	50	.	.	.
5180	1702	1	Nor	nor	CC
5180	1702	2	has	have	VBZ
5180	1702	3	the	the	DT
5180	1702	4	government	government	NN
5180	1702	5	shown	show	VBN
5180	1702	6	that	that	IN
5180	1702	7	the	the	DT
5180	1702	8	cost	cost	NN
5180	1702	9	of	of	IN
5180	1702	10	these	these	DT
5180	1702	11	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1702	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	1702	13	so	so	RB
5180	1702	14	high	high	JJ
5180	1702	15	as	as	IN
5180	1702	16	to	to	TO
5180	1702	17	make	make	VB
5180	1702	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1702	19	use	use	NN
5180	1702	20	prohibitive	prohibitive	JJ
5180	1702	21	.	.	.
5180	1703	1	With	with	IN
5180	1703	2	respect	respect	NN
5180	1703	3	to	to	IN
5180	1703	4	the	the	DT
5180	1703	5	problem	problem	NN
5180	1703	6	of	of	IN
5180	1703	7	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1703	8	removing	remove	VBG
5180	1703	9	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1703	10	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1703	11	,	,	,
5180	1703	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1703	13	find	find	VBP
5180	1703	14	,	,	,
5180	1703	15	based	base	VBN
5180	1703	16	on	on	IN
5180	1703	17	the	the	DT
5180	1703	18	successful	successful	JJ
5180	1703	19	use	use	NN
5180	1703	20	of	of	IN
5180	1703	21	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1703	22	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1703	23	by	by	IN
5180	1703	24	the	the	DT
5180	1703	25	Fort	Fort	NNP
5180	1703	26	Vancouver	Vancouver	NNP
5180	1703	27	Regional	Regional	NNP
5180	1703	28	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1703	29	and	and	CC
5180	1703	30	the	the	DT
5180	1703	31	Multnomah	Multnomah	NNP
5180	1703	32	County	County	NNP
5180	1703	33	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1703	34	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1703	35	,	,	,
5180	1703	36	that	that	IN
5180	1703	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1703	38	is	be	VBZ
5180	1703	39	possible	possible	JJ
5180	1703	40	for	for	IN
5180	1703	41	public	public	JJ
5180	1703	42	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1703	43	to	to	TO
5180	1703	44	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	1703	45	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1703	46	from	from	IN
5180	1703	47	removing	remove	VBG
5180	1703	48	the	the	DT
5180	1703	49	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1703	50	.	.	.
5180	1704	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1704	2	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1704	3	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1704	4	may	may	MD
5180	1704	5	make	make	VB
5180	1704	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1704	7	difficult	difficult	JJ
5180	1704	8	for	for	IN
5180	1704	9	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1704	10	to	to	TO
5180	1704	11	work	work	VB
5180	1704	12	at	at	IN
5180	1704	13	the	the	DT
5180	1704	14	same	same	JJ
5180	1704	15	terminal	terminal	JJ
5180	1704	16	side	side	NN
5180	1704	17	by	by	IN
5180	1704	18	side	side	NN
5180	1704	19	with	with	IN
5180	1704	20	other	other	JJ
5180	1704	21	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1704	22	or	or	CC
5180	1704	23	with	with	IN
5180	1704	24	library	library	NN
5180	1704	25	staff	staff	NN
5180	1704	26	,	,	,
5180	1704	27	a	a	DT
5180	1704	28	library	library	NN
5180	1704	29	could	could	MD
5180	1704	30	provide	provide	VB
5180	1704	31	filtered	filtered	JJ
5180	1704	32	access	access	NN
5180	1704	33	at	at	IN
5180	1704	34	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1704	35	that	that	WDT
5180	1704	36	lack	lack	VBP
5180	1704	37	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1704	38	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1704	39	,	,	,
5180	1704	40	when	when	WRB
5180	1704	41	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1704	42	wish	wish	VBP
5180	1704	43	to	to	TO
5180	1704	44	use	use	VB
5180	1704	45	a	a	DT
5180	1704	46	terminal	terminal	NN
5180	1704	47	with	with	IN
5180	1704	48	others	other	NNS
5180	1704	49	.	.	.
5180	1705	1	Alternatively	alternatively	RB
5180	1705	2	,	,	,
5180	1705	3	a	a	DT
5180	1705	4	library	library	NN
5180	1705	5	can	can	MD
5180	1705	6	reserve	reserve	VB
5180	1705	7	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1705	8	outside	outside	RB
5180	1705	9	of	of	IN
5180	1705	10	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1705	11	'	'	POS
5180	1705	12	sight	sight	NN
5180	1705	13	lines	line	NNS
5180	1705	14	for	for	IN
5180	1705	15	groups	group	NNS
5180	1705	16	of	of	IN
5180	1705	17	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1705	18	who	who	WP
5180	1705	19	wish	wish	VBP
5180	1705	20	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	1705	21	access	access	NN
5180	1705	22	.	.	.
5180	1706	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1706	2	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1706	3	conclude	conclude	VBP
5180	1706	4	that	that	IN
5180	1706	5	the	the	DT
5180	1706	6	government	government	NN
5180	1706	7	has	have	VBZ
5180	1706	8	failed	fail	VBN
5180	1706	9	to	to	TO
5180	1706	10	show	show	VB
5180	1706	11	that	that	IN
5180	1706	12	the	the	DT
5180	1706	13	less	less	RBR
5180	1706	14	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1706	15	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1706	16	discussed	discuss	VBN
5180	1706	17	above	above	RB
5180	1706	18	are	be	VBP
5180	1706	19	ineffective	ineffective	JJ
5180	1706	20	at	at	IN
5180	1706	21	furthering	further	VBG
5180	1706	22	the	the	DT
5180	1706	23	government	government	NN
5180	1706	24	's	's	POS
5180	1706	25	interest	interest	NN
5180	1706	26	either	either	CC
5180	1706	27	in	in	IN
5180	1706	28	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1706	29	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1706	30	from	from	IN
5180	1706	31	using	use	VBG
5180	1706	32	library	library	NN
5180	1706	33	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1706	34	to	to	TO
5180	1706	35	access	access	VB
5180	1706	36	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1706	37	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	1706	38	that	that	WDT
5180	1706	39	are	be	VBP
5180	1706	40	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1706	41	,	,	,
5180	1706	42	child	child	NN
5180	1706	43	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1706	44	,	,	,
5180	1706	45	or	or	CC
5180	1706	46	in	in	IN
5180	1706	47	the	the	DT
5180	1706	48	case	case	NN
5180	1706	49	of	of	IN
5180	1706	50	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1706	51	,	,	,
5180	1706	52	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1706	53	to	to	IN
5180	1706	54	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1706	55	,	,	,
5180	1706	56	or	or	CC
5180	1706	57	in	in	IN
5180	1706	58	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1706	59	library	library	NN
5180	1706	60	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1706	61	from	from	IN
5180	1706	62	being	be	VBG
5180	1706	63	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	1706	64	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1706	65	to	to	IN
5180	1706	66	patently	patently	RB
5180	1706	67	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1706	68	,	,	,
5180	1706	69	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1706	70	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1706	71	speech	speech	NN
5180	1706	72	.	.	.
5180	1707	1	4	4	LS
5180	1707	2	.	.	.
5180	1708	1	Do	do	VBP
5180	1708	2	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1708	3	's	's	POS
5180	1708	4	Disabling	Disabling	NNP
5180	1708	5	Provisions	Provisions	NNPS
5180	1708	6	Cure	Cure	NNP
5180	1708	7	the	the	DT
5180	1708	8	Defect	defect	NN
5180	1708	9	?	?	.
5180	1709	1	The	the	DT
5180	1709	2	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1709	3	argues	argue	VBZ
5180	1709	4	that	that	IN
5180	1709	5	even	even	RB
5180	1709	6	if	if	IN
5180	1709	7	the	the	DT
5180	1709	8	use	use	NN
5180	1709	9	of	of	IN
5180	1709	10	software	software	NN
5180	1709	11	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1709	12	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	1709	13	by	by	IN
5180	1709	14	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1709	15	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	1709	16	a	a	DT
5180	1709	17	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1709	18	amount	amount	NN
5180	1709	19	of	of	IN
5180	1709	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	1709	21	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1709	22	suppression	suppression	NN
5180	1709	23	serves	serve	VBZ
5180	1709	24	no	no	DT
5180	1709	25	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1709	26	state	state	NN
5180	1709	27	interest	interest	NN
5180	1709	28	,	,	,
5180	1709	29	and	and	CC
5180	1709	30	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1709	31	fails	fail	VBZ
5180	1709	32	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1709	33	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1709	34	's	's	POS
5180	1709	35	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1709	36	tailoring	tailoring	NN
5180	1709	37	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	1709	38	,	,	,
5180	1709	39	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1709	40	's	's	POS
5180	1709	41	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1709	42	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1709	43	cure	cure	VBP
5180	1709	44	any	any	DT
5180	1709	45	lack	lack	NN
5180	1709	46	of	of	IN
5180	1709	47	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1709	48	tailoring	tailor	VBG
5180	1709	49	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	1709	50	in	in	IN
5180	1709	51	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1709	52	technology	technology	NN
5180	1709	53	.	.	.
5180	1710	1	The	the	DT
5180	1710	2	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1710	3	provision	provision	NN
5180	1710	4	applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	1710	5	to	to	IN
5180	1710	6	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1710	7	receiving	receive	VBG
5180	1710	8	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	1710	9	grants	grant	NNS
5180	1710	10	states	state	VBZ
5180	1710	11	that	that	IN
5180	1710	12	"	"	``
5180	1710	13	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1710	14	a]n	a]n	NNP
5180	1710	15	administrator	administrator	NN
5180	1710	16	,	,	,
5180	1710	17	supervisor	supervisor	NN
5180	1710	18	,	,	,
5180	1710	19	or	or	CC
5180	1710	20	other	other	JJ
5180	1710	21	authority	authority	NN
5180	1710	22	may	may	MD
5180	1710	23	disable	disable	VB
5180	1710	24	a	a	DT
5180	1710	25	technology	technology	NN
5180	1710	26	protection	protection	NN
5180	1710	27	measure	measure	NN
5180	1710	28	.	.	.
5180	1711	1	.	.	.
5180	1712	1	.	.	.
5180	1713	1	to	to	TO
5180	1713	2	enable	enable	VB
5180	1713	3	access	access	NN
5180	1713	4	for	for	IN
5180	1713	5	bona	bona	FW
5180	1713	6	fide	fide	JJ
5180	1713	7	research	research	NN
5180	1713	8	or	or	CC
5180	1713	9	other	other	JJ
5180	1713	10	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	1713	11	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1713	12	.	.	.
5180	1713	13	"	"	''
5180	1714	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1714	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1714	3	.	.	.
5180	1715	1	1712(a)(2	1712(a)(2	CD
5180	1715	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1715	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1715	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1715	5	at	at	IN
5180	1715	6	20	20	CD
5180	1715	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1716	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1716	2	.	.	.
5180	1717	1	9134(f)(3	9134(f)(3	LS
5180	1717	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1717	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1717	4	.	.	.
5180	1718	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1718	2	's	's	POS
5180	1718	3	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1718	4	provision	provision	NN
5180	1718	5	with	with	IN
5180	1718	6	respect	respect	NN
5180	1718	7	to	to	IN
5180	1718	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1718	9	receiving	receive	VBG
5180	1718	10	E	e	NN
5180	1718	11	-	-	NN
5180	1718	12	rate	rate	NN
5180	1718	13	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	1718	14	similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1718	15	states	state	VBZ
5180	1718	16	that	that	IN
5180	1718	17	"	"	``
5180	1718	18	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1718	19	a]n	a]n	NNP
5180	1718	20	administrator	administrator	NN
5180	1718	21	,	,	,
5180	1718	22	supervisor	supervisor	NN
5180	1718	23	,	,	,
5180	1718	24	or	or	CC
5180	1718	25	other	other	JJ
5180	1718	26	person	person	NN
5180	1718	27	authorized	authorize	VBN
5180	1718	28	by	by	IN
5180	1718	29	the	the	DT
5180	1718	30	certifying	certify	VBG
5180	1718	31	authority	authority	NN
5180	1718	32	.	.	.
5180	1719	1	.	.	.
5180	1720	1	.	.	.
5180	1721	1	may	may	MD
5180	1721	2	disable	disable	VB
5180	1721	3	the	the	DT
5180	1721	4	technology	technology	NN
5180	1721	5	protection	protection	NN
5180	1721	6	measure	measure	NN
5180	1721	7	concerned	concern	VBN
5180	1721	8	,	,	,
5180	1721	9	during	during	IN
5180	1721	10	use	use	NN
5180	1721	11	by	by	IN
5180	1721	12	an	an	DT
5180	1721	13	adult	adult	NN
5180	1721	14	,	,	,
5180	1721	15	to	to	TO
5180	1721	16	enable	enable	VB
5180	1721	17	access	access	NN
5180	1721	18	for	for	IN
5180	1721	19	bona	bona	FW
5180	1721	20	fide	fide	JJ
5180	1721	21	research	research	NN
5180	1721	22	or	or	CC
5180	1721	23	other	other	JJ
5180	1721	24	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	1721	25	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1721	26	.	.	.
5180	1721	27	"	"	''
5180	1722	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1722	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1722	3	.	.	.
5180	1723	1	1721(b	1721(b	LS
5180	1723	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1723	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1723	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1723	5	at	at	IN
5180	1723	6	47	47	CD
5180	1723	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	1724	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1724	2	.	.	.
5180	1725	1	254(h)(6)(D	254(h)(6)(d	LS
5180	1725	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1725	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1725	4	.	.	.
5180	1726	1	To	to	TO
5180	1726	2	determine	determine	VB
5180	1726	3	whether	whether	IN
5180	1726	4	the	the	DT
5180	1726	5	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1726	6	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1726	7	cure	cure	NN
5180	1726	8	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1726	9	's	's	POS
5180	1726	10	lack	lack	NN
5180	1726	11	of	of	IN
5180	1726	12	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1726	13	tailoring	tailoring	NN
5180	1726	14	,	,	,
5180	1726	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1726	16	must	must	MD
5180	1726	17	first	first	RB
5180	1726	18	determine	determine	VB
5180	1726	19	,	,	,
5180	1726	20	as	as	IN
5180	1726	21	a	a	DT
5180	1726	22	matter	matter	NN
5180	1726	23	of	of	IN
5180	1726	24	statutory	statutory	JJ
5180	1726	25	construction	construction	NN
5180	1726	26	,	,	,
5180	1726	27	under	under	IN
5180	1726	28	what	what	WP
5180	1726	29	circumstances	circumstance	VBZ
5180	1726	30	the	the	DT
5180	1726	31	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1726	32	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1726	33	permit	permit	VBP
5180	1726	34	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1726	35	to	to	TO
5180	1726	36	disable	disable	VB
5180	1726	37	the	the	DT
5180	1726	38	software	software	NN
5180	1726	39	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1726	40	.	.	.
5180	1727	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1727	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	1727	3	unclear	unclear	JJ
5180	1727	4	to	to	IN
5180	1727	5	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1727	6	whether	whether	IN
5180	1727	7	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1727	8	's	's	POS
5180	1727	9	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1727	10	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1727	11	permit	permit	VBP
5180	1727	12	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1727	13	to	to	TO
5180	1727	14	disable	disable	VB
5180	1727	15	the	the	DT
5180	1727	16	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1727	17	any	any	DT
5180	1727	18	time	time	NN
5180	1727	19	a	a	DT
5180	1727	20	patron	patron	NN
5180	1727	21	wishes	wish	VBZ
5180	1727	22	to	to	TO
5180	1727	23	access	access	VB
5180	1727	24	speech	speech	NN
5180	1727	25	that	that	WDT
5180	1727	26	is	be	VBZ
5180	1727	27	neither	neither	DT
5180	1727	28	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1727	29	,	,	,
5180	1727	30	child	child	NN
5180	1727	31	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1727	32	,	,	,
5180	1727	33	or	or	CC
5180	1727	34	in	in	IN
5180	1727	35	the	the	DT
5180	1727	36	case	case	NN
5180	1727	37	of	of	IN
5180	1727	38	a	a	DT
5180	1727	39	minor	minor	JJ
5180	1727	40	patron	patron	NN
5180	1727	41	,	,	,
5180	1727	42	material	material	NN
5180	1727	43	that	that	WDT
5180	1727	44	is	be	VBZ
5180	1727	45	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1727	46	to	to	IN
5180	1727	47	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1727	48	.	.	.
5180	1728	1	Whether	whether	IN
5180	1728	2	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1728	3	permits	permit	NNS
5180	1728	4	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1728	5	in	in	IN
5180	1728	6	such	such	JJ
5180	1728	7	instances	instance	NNS
5180	1728	8	depends	depend	VBZ
5180	1728	9	on	on	IN
5180	1728	10	the	the	DT
5180	1728	11	meaning	meaning	NN
5180	1728	12	of	of	IN
5180	1728	13	the	the	DT
5180	1728	14	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1728	15	'	'	POS
5180	1728	16	reference	reference	NN
5180	1728	17	to	to	TO
5180	1728	18	"	"	``
5180	1728	19	bona	bona	VB
5180	1728	20	fide	fide	JJ
5180	1728	21	research	research	NN
5180	1728	22	or	or	CC
5180	1728	23	other	other	JJ
5180	1728	24	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	1728	25	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1728	26	.	.	.
5180	1728	27	"	"	''
5180	1729	1	On	on	IN
5180	1729	2	the	the	DT
5180	1729	3	one	one	CD
5180	1729	4	hand	hand	NN
5180	1729	5	,	,	,
5180	1729	6	the	the	DT
5180	1729	7	language	language	NN
5180	1729	8	"	"	``
5180	1729	9	to	to	TO
5180	1729	10	enable	enable	VB
5180	1729	11	access	access	NN
5180	1729	12	for	for	IN
5180	1729	13	bona	bona	FW
5180	1729	14	fide	fide	JJ
5180	1729	15	research	research	NN
5180	1729	16	or	or	CC
5180	1729	17	other	other	JJ
5180	1729	18	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	1729	19	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1729	20	"	"	``
5180	1729	21	could	could	MD
5180	1729	22	be	be	VB
5180	1729	23	interpreted	interpret	VBN
5180	1729	24	to	to	TO
5180	1729	25	mean	mean	VB
5180	1729	26	"	"	``
5180	1729	27	to	to	TO
5180	1729	28	enable	enable	VB
5180	1729	29	access	access	NN
5180	1729	30	to	to	IN
5180	1729	31	all	all	DT
5180	1729	32	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1729	33	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1729	34	material	material	NN
5180	1729	35	.	.	.
5180	1729	36	"	"	''
5180	1730	1	As	as	IN
5180	1730	2	a	a	DT
5180	1730	3	textual	textual	JJ
5180	1730	4	matter	matter	NN
5180	1730	5	,	,	,
5180	1730	6	this	this	DT
5180	1730	7	reading	reading	NN
5180	1730	8	of	of	IN
5180	1730	9	the	the	DT
5180	1730	10	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1730	11	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1730	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	1730	13	plausible	plausible	JJ
5180	1730	14	.	.	.
5180	1731	1	If	if	IN
5180	1731	2	a	a	DT
5180	1731	3	patron	patron	NN
5180	1731	4	seeks	seek	VBZ
5180	1731	5	access	access	NN
5180	1731	6	to	to	IN
5180	1731	7	speech	speech	NN
5180	1731	8	that	that	WDT
5180	1731	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	1731	10	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1731	11	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1731	12	,	,	,
5180	1731	13	then	then	RB
5180	1731	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1731	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	1731	16	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
5180	1731	17	to	to	TO
5180	1731	18	conclude	conclude	VB
5180	1731	19	that	that	IN
5180	1731	20	the	the	DT
5180	1731	21	patron	patron	NN
5180	1731	22	has	have	VBZ
5180	1731	23	a	a	DT
5180	1731	24	"	"	``
5180	1731	25	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	1731	26	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1731	27	,	,	,
5180	1731	28	"	"	''
5180	1731	29	since	since	IN
5180	1731	30	the	the	DT
5180	1731	31	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	1731	32	and	and	CC
5180	1731	33	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	1731	34	of	of	IN
5180	1731	35	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1731	36	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1731	37	speech	speech	NN
5180	1731	38	can	can	MD
5180	1731	39	not	not	RB
5180	1731	40	be	be	VB
5180	1731	41	made	make	VBN
5180	1731	42	unlawful	unlawful	JJ
5180	1731	43	.	.	.
5180	1732	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	1732	2	,	,	,
5180	1732	3	since	since	IN
5180	1732	4	a	a	DT
5180	1732	5	narrower	narrow	JJR
5180	1732	6	construction	construction	NN
5180	1732	7	of	of	IN
5180	1732	8	the	the	DT
5180	1732	9	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1732	10	provision	provision	NN
5180	1732	11	creates	create	VBZ
5180	1732	12	more	more	RBR
5180	1732	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	1732	14	problems	problem	NNS
5180	1732	15	than	than	IN
5180	1732	16	a	a	DT
5180	1732	17	construction	construction	NN
5180	1732	18	of	of	IN
5180	1732	19	the	the	DT
5180	1732	20	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1732	21	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1732	22	that	that	WDT
5180	1732	23	permits	permit	VBZ
5180	1732	24	access	access	NN
5180	1732	25	to	to	IN
5180	1732	26	all	all	DT
5180	1732	27	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1732	28	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1732	29	speech	speech	NN
5180	1732	30	,	,	,
5180	1732	31	the	the	DT
5180	1732	32	broader	broad	JJR
5180	1732	33	interpretation	interpretation	NN
5180	1732	34	is	be	VBZ
5180	1732	35	preferable	preferable	JJ
5180	1732	36	.	.	.
5180	1733	1	"	"	``
5180	1733	2	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1733	3	I]f	I]f	NNP
5180	1733	4	an	an	DT
5180	1733	5	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	1733	6	acceptable	acceptable	JJ
5180	1733	7	construction	construction	NN
5180	1733	8	of	of	IN
5180	1733	9	a	a	DT
5180	1733	10	statute	statute	NN
5180	1733	11	would	would	MD
5180	1733	12	raise	raise	VB
5180	1733	13	serious	serious	JJ
5180	1733	14	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	1733	15	problems	problem	NNS
5180	1733	16	,	,	,
5180	1733	17	and	and	CC
5180	1733	18	where	where	WRB
5180	1733	19	an	an	DT
5180	1733	20	alternative	alternative	JJ
5180	1733	21	interpretation	interpretation	NN
5180	1733	22	of	of	IN
5180	1733	23	the	the	DT
5180	1733	24	statute	statute	NN
5180	1733	25	is	be	VBZ
5180	1733	26	fairly	fairly	RB
5180	1733	27	possible	possible	JJ
5180	1733	28	,	,	,
5180	1733	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1733	30	are	be	VBP
5180	1733	31	obligated	obligated	JJ
5180	1733	32	to	to	TO
5180	1733	33	construe	construe	VB
5180	1733	34	the	the	DT
5180	1733	35	statute	statute	NN
5180	1733	36	to	to	TO
5180	1733	37	avoid	avoid	VB
5180	1733	38	such	such	JJ
5180	1733	39	problems	problem	NNS
5180	1733	40	.	.	.
5180	1733	41	"	"	''
5180	1734	1	INS	INS	NNP
5180	1734	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	1734	3	St.	St.	NNP
5180	1734	4	Cyr	Cyr	NNP
5180	1734	5	,	,	,
5180	1734	6	121	121	CD
5180	1734	7	S.	S.	NNP
5180	1734	8	Ct	Ct	NNP
5180	1734	9	.	.	NNP
5180	1734	10	2271	2271	CD
5180	1734	11	,	,	,
5180	1734	12	2279	2279	CD
5180	1734	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1734	14	2001	2001	CD
5180	1734	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1734	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1734	17	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1734	18	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1734	19	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1734	20	and	and	CC
5180	1734	21	citations	citation	NNS
5180	1734	22	omitted	omit	VBN
5180	1734	23	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1734	24	.	.	.
5180	1735	1	On	on	IN
5180	1735	2	the	the	DT
5180	1735	3	other	other	JJ
5180	1735	4	hand	hand	NN
5180	1735	5	,	,	,
5180	1735	6	interpreting	interpret	VBG
5180	1735	7	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1735	8	's	's	POS
5180	1735	9	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1735	10	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1735	11	to	to	TO
5180	1735	12	permit	permit	VB
5180	1735	13	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1735	14	for	for	IN
5180	1735	15	access	access	NN
5180	1735	16	to	to	IN
5180	1735	17	all	all	DT
5180	1735	18	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1735	19	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1735	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	1735	21	presents	present	NNS
5180	1735	22	several	several	JJ
5180	1735	23	problems	problem	NNS
5180	1735	24	.	.	.
5180	1736	1	First	first	RB
5180	1736	2	,	,	,
5180	1736	3	if	if	IN
5180	1736	4	"	"	``
5180	1736	5	other	other	JJ
5180	1736	6	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	1736	7	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1736	8	"	"	``
5180	1736	9	means	mean	VBZ
5180	1736	10	"	"	''
5180	1736	11	for	for	IN
5180	1736	12	the	the	DT
5180	1736	13	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1736	14	of	of	IN
5180	1736	15	accessing	access	VBG
5180	1736	16	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1736	17	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1736	18	speech	speech	NN
5180	1736	19	,	,	,
5180	1736	20	"	"	``
5180	1736	21	then	then	RB
5180	1736	22	this	this	DT
5180	1736	23	reading	reading	NN
5180	1736	24	renders	render	VBZ
5180	1736	25	superfluous	superfluous	JJ
5180	1736	26	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1736	27	's	's	POS
5180	1736	28	reference	reference	NN
5180	1736	29	to	to	TO
5180	1736	30	"	"	``
5180	1736	31	bona	bona	VB
5180	1736	32	fide	fide	JJ
5180	1736	33	research	research	NN
5180	1736	34	,	,	,
5180	1736	35	"	"	''
5180	1736	36	which	which	WDT
5180	1736	37	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	1736	38	contemplates	contemplate	VBZ
5180	1736	39	some	some	DT
5180	1736	40	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1736	41	beyond	beyond	IN
5180	1736	42	simply	simply	RB
5180	1736	43	accessing	access	VBG
5180	1736	44	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1736	45	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1736	46	speech	speech	NN
5180	1736	47	.	.	.
5180	1737	1	In	in	IN
5180	1737	2	general	general	JJ
5180	1737	3	,	,	,
5180	1737	4	"	"	''
5180	1737	5	courts	court	NNS
5180	1737	6	should	should	MD
5180	1737	7	disfavor	disfavor	VB
5180	1737	8	interpretations	interpretation	NNS
5180	1737	9	of	of	IN
5180	1737	10	statutes	statute	NNS
5180	1737	11	that	that	WDT
5180	1737	12	render	render	VBP
5180	1737	13	language	language	NN
5180	1737	14	superfluous	superfluous	JJ
5180	1737	15	.	.	.
5180	1737	16	"	"	''
5180	1738	1	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
5180	1738	2	Nat'l	Nat'l	NNP
5180	1738	3	Bank	Bank	NNP
5180	1738	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	1738	5	Germain	Germain	NNP
5180	1738	6	,	,	,
5180	1738	7	503	503	CD
5180	1738	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1738	9	249	249	CD
5180	1738	10	,	,	,
5180	1738	11	253	253	CD
5180	1738	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1738	13	1992	1992	CD
5180	1738	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1738	15	.	.	.
5180	1739	1	Furthermore	furthermore	RB
5180	1739	2	,	,	,
5180	1739	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1739	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	1739	5	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	1739	6	capable	capable	JJ
5180	1739	7	of	of	IN
5180	1739	8	explicitly	explicitly	RB
5180	1739	9	specifying	specify	VBG
5180	1739	10	categories	category	NNS
5180	1739	11	of	of	IN
5180	1739	12	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1739	13	unprotected	unprotected	JJ
5180	1739	14	speech	speech	NN
5180	1739	15	,	,	,
5180	1739	16	as	as	IN
5180	1739	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1739	18	did	do	VBD
5180	1739	19	when	when	WRB
5180	1739	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1739	21	drafted	draft	VBD
5180	1739	22	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1739	23	to	to	TO
5180	1739	24	require	require	VB
5180	1739	25	funding	funding	NN
5180	1739	26	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	1739	27	to	to	TO
5180	1739	28	use	use	VB
5180	1739	29	technology	technology	NN
5180	1739	30	protection	protection	NN
5180	1739	31	measures	measure	NNS
5180	1739	32	that	that	WDT
5180	1739	33	protect	protect	VBP
5180	1739	34	against	against	IN
5180	1739	35	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1739	36	depictions	depiction	NNS
5180	1739	37	that	that	WDT
5180	1739	38	are	be	VBP
5180	1739	39	"	"	``
5180	1739	40	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1739	41	,	,	,
5180	1739	42	"	"	''
5180	1739	43	"	"	``
5180	1739	44	child	child	NN
5180	1739	45	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1739	46	,	,	,
5180	1739	47	"	"	''
5180	1739	48	or	or	CC
5180	1739	49	,	,	,
5180	1739	50	in	in	IN
5180	1739	51	the	the	DT
5180	1739	52	case	case	NN
5180	1739	53	of	of	IN
5180	1739	54	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1739	55	,	,	,
5180	1739	56	"	"	''
5180	1739	57	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1739	58	to	to	IN
5180	1739	59	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1739	60	.	.	.
5180	1739	61	"	"	''
5180	1740	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1740	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1740	3	.	.	.
5180	1741	1	1712(a	1712(a	LS
5180	1741	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1741	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1741	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1741	5	at	at	IN
5180	1741	6	20	20	CD
5180	1741	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1742	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1742	2	.	.	.
5180	1743	1	9134(f)(1)(A)(i)(I)-(III	9134(f)(1)(a)(i)(i)-(iii	LS
5180	1743	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1743	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1743	4	;	;	:
5180	1743	5	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1743	6	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1743	7	.	.	.
5180	1744	1	1721(b	1721(b	LS
5180	1744	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1744	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1744	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1744	5	at	at	IN
5180	1744	6	47	47	CD
5180	1744	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	1745	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1745	2	.	.	.
5180	1746	1	254(h)(6)(B)(i)(I)-(III	254(h)(6)(b)(i)(i)-(iii	LS
5180	1746	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1746	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1746	4	.	.	.
5180	1747	1	If	if	IN
5180	1747	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1747	3	intended	intend	VBD
5180	1747	4	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1747	5	's	's	POS
5180	1747	6	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1747	7	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1747	8	simply	simply	RB
5180	1747	9	to	to	TO
5180	1747	10	permit	permit	VB
5180	1747	11	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1747	12	to	to	TO
5180	1747	13	disable	disable	VB
5180	1747	14	the	the	DT
5180	1747	15	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1747	16	to	to	TO
5180	1747	17	allow	allow	VB
5180	1747	18	access	access	NN
5180	1747	19	to	to	IN
5180	1747	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	1747	21	falling	fall	VBG
5180	1747	22	outside	outside	RB
5180	1747	23	of	of	IN
5180	1747	24	these	these	DT
5180	1747	25	categories	category	NNS
5180	1747	26	,	,	,
5180	1747	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1747	28	could	could	MD
5180	1747	29	have	have	VB
5180	1747	30	drafted	draft	VBN
5180	1747	31	the	the	DT
5180	1747	32	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1747	33	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1747	34	with	with	IN
5180	1747	35	greater	great	JJR
5180	1747	36	precision	precision	NN
5180	1747	37	,	,	,
5180	1747	38	expressly	expressly	RB
5180	1747	39	permitting	permit	VBG
5180	1747	40	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1747	41	to	to	TO
5180	1747	42	disable	disable	VB
5180	1747	43	the	the	DT
5180	1747	44	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1747	45	"	"	``
5180	1747	46	to	to	TO
5180	1747	47	enable	enable	VB
5180	1747	48	access	access	NN
5180	1747	49	for	for	IN
5180	1747	50	any	any	DT
5180	1747	51	material	material	NN
5180	1747	52	that	that	WDT
5180	1747	53	is	be	VBZ
5180	1747	54	not	not	RB
5180	1747	55	obscene	obscene	JJ
5180	1747	56	,	,	,
5180	1747	57	child	child	NN
5180	1747	58	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1747	59	,	,	,
5180	1747	60	or	or	CC
5180	1747	61	in	in	IN
5180	1747	62	the	the	DT
5180	1747	63	case	case	NN
5180	1747	64	of	of	IN
5180	1747	65	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1747	66	,	,	,
5180	1747	67	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1747	68	to	to	IN
5180	1747	69	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1747	70	,	,	,
5180	1747	71	"	"	''
5180	1747	72	rather	rather	RB
5180	1747	73	than	than	IN
5180	1747	74	"	"	``
5180	1747	75	to	to	TO
5180	1747	76	enable	enable	VB
5180	1747	77	access	access	NN
5180	1747	78	for	for	IN
5180	1747	79	bona	bona	FW
5180	1747	80	fide	fide	JJ
5180	1747	81	research	research	NN
5180	1747	82	or	or	CC
5180	1747	83	other	other	JJ
5180	1747	84	lawful	lawful	JJ
5180	1747	85	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	1747	86	,	,	,
5180	1747	87	"	"	''
5180	1747	88	which	which	WDT
5180	1747	89	is	be	VBZ
5180	1747	90	the	the	DT
5180	1747	91	language	language	NN
5180	1747	92	that	that	WDT
5180	1747	93	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1747	94	actually	actually	RB
5180	1747	95	chose	choose	VBD
5180	1747	96	.	.	.
5180	1748	1	At	at	IN
5180	1748	2	bottom	bottom	NN
5180	1748	3	,	,	,
5180	1748	4	however	however	RB
5180	1748	5	,	,	,
5180	1748	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1748	7	need	need	VBP
5180	1748	8	not	not	RB
5180	1748	9	definitively	definitively	RB
5180	1748	10	construe	construe	VB
5180	1748	11	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1748	12	's	's	POS
5180	1748	13	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1748	14	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1748	15	,	,	,
5180	1748	16	since	since	IN
5180	1748	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1748	18	suffices	suffice	VBZ
5180	1748	19	in	in	IN
5180	1748	20	this	this	DT
5180	1748	21	case	case	NN
5180	1748	22	to	to	TO
5180	1748	23	assume	assume	VB
5180	1748	24	without	without	IN
5180	1748	25	deciding	decide	VBG
5180	1748	26	that	that	IN
5180	1748	27	the	the	DT
5180	1748	28	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1748	29	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1748	30	permit	permit	VBP
5180	1748	31	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1748	32	to	to	TO
5180	1748	33	allow	allow	VB
5180	1748	34	a	a	DT
5180	1748	35	patron	patron	NN
5180	1748	36	access	access	NN
5180	1748	37	to	to	IN
5180	1748	38	any	any	DT
5180	1748	39	speech	speech	NN
5180	1748	40	that	that	WDT
5180	1748	41	is	be	VBZ
5180	1748	42	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1748	43	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1748	44	with	with	IN
5180	1748	45	respect	respect	NN
5180	1748	46	to	to	IN
5180	1748	47	that	that	DT
5180	1748	48	patron	patron	NN
5180	1748	49	.	.	.
5180	1749	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1749	2	this	this	DT
5180	1749	3	interpretation	interpretation	NN
5180	1749	4	raises	raise	VBZ
5180	1749	5	fewer	few	JJR
5180	1749	6	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	1749	7	problems	problem	NNS
5180	1749	8	than	than	IN
5180	1749	9	a	a	DT
5180	1749	10	narrower	narrow	JJR
5180	1749	11	interpretation	interpretation	NN
5180	1749	12	,	,	,
5180	1749	13	this	this	DT
5180	1749	14	interpretation	interpretation	NN
5180	1749	15	of	of	IN
5180	1749	16	the	the	DT
5180	1749	17	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1749	18	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1749	19	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	1749	20	fails	fail	VBZ
5180	1749	21	to	to	TO
5180	1749	22	cure	cure	VB
5180	1749	23	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1749	24	's	's	POS
5180	1749	25	lack	lack	NN
5180	1749	26	of	of	IN
5180	1749	27	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1749	28	tailoring	tailoring	NN
5180	1749	29	.	.	.
5180	1750	1	Even	even	RB
5180	1750	2	if	if	IN
5180	1750	3	the	the	DT
5180	1750	4	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1750	5	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1750	6	permit	permit	VBP
5180	1750	7	public	public	JJ
5180	1750	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1750	9	to	to	TO
5180	1750	10	allow	allow	VB
5180	1750	11	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1750	12	to	to	IN
5180	1750	13	access	access	NN
5180	1750	14	speech	speech	NN
5180	1750	15	that	that	WDT
5180	1750	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	1750	17	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1750	18	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1750	19	yet	yet	RB
5180	1750	20	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1750	21	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1750	22	by	by	IN
5180	1750	23	the	the	DT
5180	1750	24	software	software	NN
5180	1750	25	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1750	26	,	,	,
5180	1750	27	the	the	DT
5180	1750	28	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	1750	29	that	that	IN
5180	1750	30	library	library	NN
5180	1750	31	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1750	32	ask	ask	VBP
5180	1750	33	a	a	DT
5180	1750	34	state	state	NN
5180	1750	35	actor	actor	NN
5180	1750	36	's	's	POS
5180	1750	37	permission	permission	NN
5180	1750	38	to	to	TO
5180	1750	39	access	access	VB
5180	1750	40	disfavored	disfavor	VBD
5180	1750	41	content	content	NN
5180	1750	42	violates	violate	VBZ
5180	1750	43	the	the	DT
5180	1750	44	First	First	NNP
5180	1750	45	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1750	46	.	.	.
5180	1751	1	The	the	DT
5180	1751	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1751	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1751	4	has	have	VBZ
5180	1751	5	made	make	VBN
5180	1751	6	clear	clear	JJ
5180	1751	7	that	that	IN
5180	1751	8	content	content	NN
5180	1751	9	-	-	HYPH
5180	1751	10	based	base	VBN
5180	1751	11	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1751	12	that	that	WDT
5180	1751	13	require	require	VBP
5180	1751	14	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	1751	15	to	to	TO
5180	1751	16	identify	identify	VB
5180	1751	17	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1751	18	before	before	IN
5180	1751	19	being	be	VBG
5180	1751	20	granted	grant	VBN
5180	1751	21	access	access	NN
5180	1751	22	to	to	IN
5180	1751	23	disfavored	disfavor	VBN
5180	1751	24	speech	speech	NN
5180	1751	25	are	be	VBP
5180	1751	26	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1751	27	to	to	IN
5180	1751	28	no	no	DT
5180	1751	29	less	less	JJR
5180	1751	30	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1751	31	than	than	IN
5180	1751	32	outright	outright	JJ
5180	1751	33	bans	ban	NNS
5180	1751	34	on	on	IN
5180	1751	35	access	access	NN
5180	1751	36	to	to	IN
5180	1751	37	such	such	JJ
5180	1751	38	speech	speech	NN
5180	1751	39	.	.	.
5180	1752	1	In	in	IN
5180	1752	2	Lamont	Lamont	NNP
5180	1752	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1752	4	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
5180	1752	5	General	General	NNP
5180	1752	6	,	,	,
5180	1752	7	381	381	CD
5180	1752	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1752	9	301	301	CD
5180	1752	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1752	11	1965	1965	CD
5180	1752	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1752	13	,	,	,
5180	1752	14	for	for	IN
5180	1752	15	example	example	NN
5180	1752	16	,	,	,
5180	1752	17	the	the	DT
5180	1752	18	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1752	19	held	hold	VBD
5180	1752	20	that	that	IN
5180	1752	21	a	a	DT
5180	1752	22	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1752	23	statute	statute	NN
5180	1752	24	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1752	25	the	the	DT
5180	1752	26	Postmaster	Postmaster	NNP
5180	1752	27	General	General	NNP
5180	1752	28	to	to	TO
5180	1752	29	halt	halt	VB
5180	1752	30	delivery	delivery	NN
5180	1752	31	of	of	IN
5180	1752	32	communist	communist	JJ
5180	1752	33	propaganda	propaganda	NN
5180	1752	34	unless	unless	IN
5180	1752	35	the	the	DT
5180	1752	36	addressee	addressee	NN
5180	1752	37	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
5180	1752	38	requested	request	VBD
5180	1752	39	the	the	DT
5180	1752	40	material	material	NN
5180	1752	41	violated	violate	VBD
5180	1752	42	the	the	DT
5180	1752	43	First	First	NNP
5180	1752	44	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1752	45	:	:	:
5180	1752	46	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1752	47	rest	rest	VBP
5180	1752	48	on	on	IN
5180	1752	49	the	the	DT
5180	1752	50	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1752	51	ground	ground	NN
5180	1752	52	that	that	IN
5180	1752	53	the	the	DT
5180	1752	54	addressee	addressee	NN
5180	1752	55	in	in	IN
5180	1752	56	order	order	NN
5180	1752	57	to	to	TO
5180	1752	58	receive	receive	VB
5180	1752	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1752	60	mail	mail	NN
5180	1752	61	must	must	MD
5180	1752	62	request	request	VB
5180	1752	63	in	in	IN
5180	1752	64	writing	writing	NN
5180	1752	65	that	that	IN
5180	1752	66	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1752	67	be	be	VB
5180	1752	68	delivered	deliver	VBN
5180	1752	69	.	.	.
5180	1753	1	This	this	DT
5180	1753	2	amounts	amount	VBZ
5180	1753	3	in	in	IN
5180	1753	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1753	5	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1753	6	to	to	IN
5180	1753	7	an	an	DT
5180	1753	8	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	1753	9	abridgment	abridgment	NN
5180	1753	10	of	of	IN
5180	1753	11	the	the	DT
5180	1753	12	addressee	addressee	NN
5180	1753	13	's	's	POS
5180	1753	14	First	First	NNP
5180	1753	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1753	16	rights	right	NNS
5180	1753	17	.	.	.
5180	1754	1	The	the	DT
5180	1754	2	addressee	addressee	NN
5180	1754	3	carries	carry	VBZ
5180	1754	4	an	an	DT
5180	1754	5	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
5180	1754	6	obligation	obligation	NN
5180	1754	7	which	which	WDT
5180	1754	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1754	9	do	do	VBP
5180	1754	10	not	not	RB
5180	1754	11	think	think	VB
5180	1754	12	the	the	DT
5180	1754	13	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1754	14	may	may	MD
5180	1754	15	impose	impose	VB
5180	1754	16	on	on	IN
5180	1754	17	him	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1754	18	.	.	.
5180	1755	1	This	this	DT
5180	1755	2	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	1755	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1755	4	almost	almost	RB
5180	1755	5	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1755	6	to	to	TO
5180	1755	7	have	have	VB
5180	1755	8	a	a	DT
5180	1755	9	deterrent	deterrent	JJ
5180	1755	10	effect	effect	NN
5180	1755	11	,	,	,
5180	1755	12	especially	especially	RB
5180	1755	13	as	as	IN
5180	1755	14	respects	respect	VBZ
5180	1755	15	those	those	DT
5180	1755	16	who	who	WP
5180	1755	17	have	have	VBP
5180	1755	18	sensitive	sensitive	JJ
5180	1755	19	positions	position	NNS
5180	1755	20	.	.	.
5180	1756	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1757	1	at	at	IN
5180	1757	2	307	307	CD
5180	1757	3	.	.	.
5180	1758	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1758	2	,	,	,
5180	1758	3	in	in	IN
5180	1758	4	Denver	Denver	NNP
5180	1758	5	Area	Area	NNP
5180	1758	6	Educational	Educational	NNP
5180	1758	7	Telecommunications	Telecommunications	NNPS
5180	1758	8	Consortium	Consortium	NNP
5180	1758	9	,	,	,
5180	1758	10	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1758	11	v.	v.	IN
5180	1758	12	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	1758	13	,	,	,
5180	1758	14	518	518	CD
5180	1758	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1758	16	727	727	CD
5180	1758	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1758	18	1996	1996	CD
5180	1758	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1758	20	,	,	,
5180	1758	21	the	the	DT
5180	1758	22	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1758	23	held	hold	VBD
5180	1758	24	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	1758	25	a	a	DT
5180	1758	26	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1758	27	law	law	NN
5180	1758	28	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1758	29	cable	cable	NN
5180	1758	30	operators	operator	NNS
5180	1758	31	to	to	TO
5180	1758	32	allow	allow	VB
5180	1758	33	access	access	NN
5180	1758	34	to	to	IN
5180	1758	35	patently	patently	RB
5180	1758	36	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1758	37	,	,	,
5180	1758	38	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1758	39	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1758	40	programming	programming	NN
5180	1758	41	only	only	RB
5180	1758	42	to	to	IN
5180	1758	43	those	those	DT
5180	1758	44	subscribers	subscriber	NNS
5180	1758	45	who	who	WP
5180	1758	46	requested	request	VBD
5180	1758	47	access	access	NN
5180	1758	48	to	to	IN
5180	1758	49	the	the	DT
5180	1758	50	programming	programming	NN
5180	1758	51	in	in	IN
5180	1758	52	advance	advance	NN
5180	1758	53	and	and	CC
5180	1758	54	in	in	IN
5180	1758	55	writing	writing	NN
5180	1758	56	.	.	.
5180	1759	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1760	1	at	at	IN
5180	1760	2	732	732	CD
5180	1760	3	-	-	SYM
5180	1760	4	33	33	CD
5180	1760	5	.	.	.
5180	1761	1	As	as	IN
5180	1761	2	in	in	IN
5180	1761	3	Lamont	Lamont	NNP
5180	1761	4	,	,	,
5180	1761	5	the	the	DT
5180	1761	6	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1761	7	in	in	IN
5180	1761	8	Denver	Denver	NNP
5180	1761	9	reasoned	reason	VBD
5180	1761	10	that	that	IN
5180	1761	11	this	this	DT
5180	1761	12	content	content	NN
5180	1761	13	-	-	HYPH
5180	1761	14	based	base	VBN
5180	1761	15	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1761	16	on	on	IN
5180	1761	17	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	1761	18	'	'	POS
5180	1761	19	access	access	NN
5180	1761	20	to	to	IN
5180	1761	21	speech	speech	NN
5180	1761	22	would	would	MD
5180	1761	23	have	have	VB
5180	1761	24	an	an	DT
5180	1761	25	impermissible	impermissible	JJ
5180	1761	26	chilling	chilling	JJ
5180	1761	27	effect	effect	NN
5180	1761	28	:	:	:
5180	1761	29	"	"	``
5180	1761	30	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1761	31	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	1761	32	written	write	VBN
5180	1761	33	notice	notice	NN
5180	1761	34	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	1761	35	will	will	MD
5180	1761	36	.	.	.
5180	1762	1	.	.	.
5180	1763	1	.	.	.
5180	1764	1	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	1764	2	viewing	view	VBG
5180	1764	3	by	by	IN
5180	1764	4	subscribers	subscriber	NNS
5180	1764	5	who	who	WP
5180	1764	6	fear	fear	VBP
5180	1764	7	for	for	IN
5180	1764	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1764	9	reputations	reputation	NNS
5180	1764	10	should	should	MD
5180	1764	11	the	the	DT
5180	1764	12	operator	operator	NN
5180	1764	13	,	,	,
5180	1764	14	advertently	advertently	RB
5180	1764	15	or	or	CC
5180	1764	16	inadvertently	inadvertently	RB
5180	1764	17	,	,	,
5180	1764	18	disclose	disclose	VB
5180	1764	19	the	the	DT
5180	1764	20	list	list	NN
5180	1764	21	of	of	IN
5180	1764	22	those	those	DT
5180	1764	23	who	who	WP
5180	1764	24	wish	wish	VBP
5180	1764	25	to	to	TO
5180	1764	26	watch	watch	VB
5180	1764	27	the	the	DT
5180	1764	28	'	'	``
5180	1764	29	patently	patently	RB
5180	1764	30	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1764	31	'	'	POS
5180	1764	32	channel	channel	NN
5180	1764	33	.	.	.
5180	1764	34	"	"	''
5180	1765	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	1766	1	at	at	IN
5180	1766	2	754	754	CD
5180	1766	3	;	;	:
5180	1766	4	see	see	VB
5180	1766	5	also	also	RB
5180	1766	6	Fabulous	Fabulous	NNP
5180	1766	7	Assocs	Assocs	NNP
5180	1766	8	.	.	.
5180	1766	9	,	,	,
5180	1766	10	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1766	11	v.	v.	CC
5180	1766	12	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
5180	1766	13	Pub	Pub	NNP
5180	1766	14	.	.	.
5180	1767	1	Util	util	IN
5180	1767	2	.	.	.
5180	1768	1	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
5180	1768	2	,	,	,
5180	1768	3	896	896	CD
5180	1768	4	F.2d	F.2d	NNP
5180	1768	5	780	780	CD
5180	1768	6	,	,	,
5180	1768	7	785	785	CD
5180	1768	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1768	9	3d	3d	NNP
5180	1768	10	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	1768	11	.	.	.
5180	1769	1	1990	1990	CD
5180	1769	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1769	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1769	4	considering	consider	VBG
5180	1769	5	the	the	DT
5180	1769	6	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
5180	1769	7	of	of	IN
5180	1769	8	a	a	DT
5180	1769	9	state	state	NN
5180	1769	10	law	law	NN
5180	1769	11	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1769	12	telephone	telephone	NN
5180	1769	13	users	user	NNS
5180	1769	14	who	who	WP
5180	1769	15	wish	wish	VBP
5180	1769	16	to	to	TO
5180	1769	17	listen	listen	VB
5180	1769	18	to	to	IN
5180	1769	19	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1769	20	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1769	21	telephone	telephone	NN
5180	1769	22	messages	message	NNS
5180	1769	23	to	to	TO
5180	1769	24	apply	apply	VB
5180	1769	25	for	for	IN
5180	1769	26	an	an	DT
5180	1769	27	access	access	NN
5180	1769	28	code	code	NN
5180	1769	29	to	to	TO
5180	1769	30	receive	receive	VB
5180	1769	31	such	such	JJ
5180	1769	32	messages	message	NNS
5180	1769	33	,	,	,
5180	1769	34	and	and	CC
5180	1769	35	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
5180	1769	36	the	the	DT
5180	1769	37	law	law	NN
5180	1769	38	on	on	IN
5180	1769	39	the	the	DT
5180	1769	40	ground	ground	NN
5180	1769	41	that	that	IN
5180	1769	42	"	"	``
5180	1769	43	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1769	44	a]n	a]n	NNP
5180	1769	45	identification	identification	NN
5180	1769	46	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	1769	47	exerts	exert	VBZ
5180	1769	48	an	an	DT
5180	1769	49	inhibitory	inhibitory	JJ
5180	1769	50	effect	effect	NN
5180	1769	51	"	"	''
5180	1769	52	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1769	53	.	.	.
5180	1770	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1770	2	believe	believe	VBP
5180	1770	3	that	that	IN
5180	1770	4	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1770	5	's	's	POS
5180	1770	6	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1770	7	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1770	8	suffer	suffer	VBP
5180	1770	9	from	from	IN
5180	1770	10	the	the	DT
5180	1770	11	same	same	JJ
5180	1770	12	flaws	flaw	NNS
5180	1770	13	as	as	IN
5180	1770	14	the	the	DT
5180	1770	15	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1770	16	on	on	IN
5180	1770	17	speech	speech	NN
5180	1770	18	in	in	IN
5180	1770	19	Lamont	Lamont	NNP
5180	1770	20	,	,	,
5180	1770	21	Denver	Denver	NNP
5180	1770	22	,	,	,
5180	1770	23	and	and	CC
5180	1770	24	Fabulous	Fabulous	NNP
5180	1770	25	Associates	Associates	NNPS
5180	1770	26	.	.	.
5180	1771	1	By	by	IN
5180	1771	2	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1771	3	library	library	NN
5180	1771	4	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1771	5	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
5180	1771	6	to	to	TO
5180	1771	7	request	request	VB
5180	1771	8	permission	permission	NN
5180	1771	9	to	to	TO
5180	1771	10	access	access	VB
5180	1771	11	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1771	12	speech	speech	NN
5180	1771	13	singled	single	VBN
5180	1771	14	out	out	RP
5180	1771	15	on	on	IN
5180	1771	16	the	the	DT
5180	1771	17	basis	basis	NN
5180	1771	18	of	of	IN
5180	1771	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1771	20	content	content	NN
5180	1771	21	,	,	,
5180	1771	22	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1771	23	will	will	MD
5180	1771	24	deter	deter	VB
5180	1771	25	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1771	26	from	from	IN
5180	1771	27	requesting	request	VBG
5180	1771	28	that	that	IN
5180	1771	29	a	a	DT
5180	1771	30	library	library	NN
5180	1771	31	disable	disable	JJ
5180	1771	32	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1771	33	to	to	TO
5180	1771	34	allow	allow	VB
5180	1771	35	the	the	DT
5180	1771	36	patron	patron	NN
5180	1771	37	to	to	TO
5180	1771	38	access	access	VB
5180	1771	39	speech	speech	NN
5180	1771	40	that	that	WDT
5180	1771	41	is	be	VBZ
5180	1771	42	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1771	43	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1771	44	,	,	,
5180	1771	45	yet	yet	CC
5180	1771	46	sensitive	sensitive	JJ
5180	1771	47	in	in	IN
5180	1771	48	nature	nature	NN
5180	1771	49	.	.	.
5180	1772	1	As	as	IN
5180	1772	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1772	3	explain	explain	VBP
5180	1772	4	above	above	RB
5180	1772	5	,	,	,
5180	1772	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1772	7	find	find	VBP
5180	1772	8	that	that	IN
5180	1772	9	library	library	NN
5180	1772	10	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1772	11	will	will	MD
5180	1772	12	be	be	VB
5180	1772	13	reluctant	reluctant	JJ
5180	1772	14	and	and	CC
5180	1772	15	hence	hence	RB
5180	1772	16	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
5180	1772	17	to	to	TO
5180	1772	18	ask	ask	VB
5180	1772	19	permission	permission	NN
5180	1772	20	to	to	IN
5180	1772	21	access	access	NN
5180	1772	22	,	,	,
5180	1772	23	for	for	IN
5180	1772	24	example	example	NN
5180	1772	25	,	,	,
5180	1772	26	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1772	27	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1772	28	Web	web	NN
5180	1772	29	sites	site	NNS
5180	1772	30	containing	contain	VBG
5180	1772	31	information	information	NN
5180	1772	32	about	about	IN
5180	1772	33	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1772	34	transmitted	transmit	VBN
5180	1772	35	diseases	disease	NNS
5180	1772	36	,	,	,
5180	1772	37	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	1772	38	identity	identity	NN
5180	1772	39	,	,	,
5180	1772	40	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1772	41	medical	medical	JJ
5180	1772	42	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	1772	43	,	,	,
5180	1772	44	and	and	CC
5180	1772	45	a	a	DT
5180	1772	46	variety	variety	NN
5180	1772	47	of	of	IN
5180	1772	48	other	other	JJ
5180	1772	49	topics	topic	NNS
5180	1772	50	.	.	.
5180	1773	1	As	as	IN
5180	1773	2	discussed	discuss	VBN
5180	1773	3	in	in	IN
5180	1773	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1773	5	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1773	6	of	of	IN
5180	1773	7	fact	fact	NN
5180	1773	8	,	,	,
5180	1773	9	software	software	NN
5180	1773	10	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1773	11	block	block	VBP
5180	1773	12	access	access	NN
5180	1773	13	to	to	IN
5180	1773	14	a	a	DT
5180	1773	15	wide	wide	JJ
5180	1773	16	range	range	NN
5180	1773	17	of	of	IN
5180	1773	18	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1773	19	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1773	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	1773	21	,	,	,
5180	1773	22	including	include	VBG
5180	1773	23	Web	web	NN
5180	1773	24	sites	site	NNS
5180	1773	25	containing	contain	VBG
5180	1773	26	information	information	NN
5180	1773	27	that	that	WDT
5180	1773	28	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	1773	29	are	be	VBP
5180	1773	30	likely	likely	JJ
5180	1773	31	to	to	TO
5180	1773	32	wish	wish	VB
5180	1773	33	to	to	TO
5180	1773	34	access	access	VB
5180	1773	35	anonymously	anonymously	RB
5180	1773	36	.	.	.
5180	1774	1	That	that	DT
5180	1774	2	library	library	NN
5180	1774	3	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1774	4	will	will	MD
5180	1774	5	be	be	VB
5180	1774	6	deterred	deter	VBN
5180	1774	7	from	from	IN
5180	1774	8	asking	ask	VBG
5180	1774	9	permission	permission	NN
5180	1774	10	to	to	IN
5180	1774	11	access	access	NN
5180	1774	12	Web	web	NN
5180	1774	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	1774	14	containing	contain	VBG
5180	1774	15	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1774	16	kinds	kind	NNS
5180	1774	17	of	of	IN
5180	1774	18	content	content	NN
5180	1774	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	1774	20	evident	evident	JJ
5180	1774	21	as	as	IN
5180	1774	22	a	a	DT
5180	1774	23	matter	matter	NN
5180	1774	24	of	of	IN
5180	1774	25	common	common	JJ
5180	1774	26	sense	sense	NN
5180	1774	27	as	as	RB
5180	1774	28	well	well	RB
5180	1774	29	as	as	IN
5180	1774	30	amply	amply	RB
5180	1774	31	borne	bear	VBN
5180	1774	32	out	out	RP
5180	1774	33	by	by	IN
5180	1774	34	the	the	DT
5180	1774	35	trial	trial	NN
5180	1774	36	record	record	NN
5180	1774	37	.	.	.
5180	1775	1	Plaintiff	Plaintiff	NNP
5180	1775	2	Emmalyn	Emmalyn	NNP
5180	1775	3	Rood	Rood	NNP
5180	1775	4	,	,	,
5180	1775	5	who	who	WP
5180	1775	6	used	use	VBD
5180	1775	7	the	the	DT
5180	1775	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1775	9	at	at	IN
5180	1775	10	a	a	DT
5180	1775	11	public	public	JJ
5180	1775	12	library	library	NN
5180	1775	13	to	to	TO
5180	1775	14	research	research	VB
5180	1775	15	information	information	NN
5180	1775	16	relating	relate	VBG
5180	1775	17	to	to	IN
5180	1775	18	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1775	19	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	1775	20	identity	identity	NN
5180	1775	21	,	,	,
5180	1775	22	testified	testify	VBD
5180	1775	23	that	that	IN
5180	1775	24	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1775	25	would	would	MD
5180	1775	26	have	have	VB
5180	1775	27	been	be	VBN
5180	1775	28	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
5180	1775	29	as	as	IN
5180	1775	30	a	a	DT
5180	1775	31	young	young	JJ
5180	1775	32	teen	teen	NN
5180	1775	33	to	to	TO
5180	1775	34	ask	ask	VB
5180	1775	35	a	a	DT
5180	1775	36	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	1775	37	to	to	TO
5180	1775	38	disable	disable	VB
5180	1775	39	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1775	40	software	software	NN
5180	1775	41	so	so	IN
5180	1775	42	that	that	IN
5180	1775	43	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1775	44	could	could	MD
5180	1775	45	view	view	VB
5180	1775	46	materials	material	NNS
5180	1775	47	concerning	concern	VBG
5180	1775	48	gay	gay	NN
5180	1775	49	and	and	CC
5180	1775	50	lesbian	lesbian	JJ
5180	1775	51	issues	issue	NNS
5180	1775	52	.	.	.
5180	1776	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1776	2	,	,	,
5180	1776	3	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
5180	1776	4	Mark	Mark	NNP
5180	1776	5	Brown	Brown	NNP
5180	1776	6	stated	state	VBD
5180	1776	7	that	that	IN
5180	1776	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1776	9	would	would	MD
5180	1776	10	have	have	VB
5180	1776	11	been	be	VBN
5180	1776	12	too	too	RB
5180	1776	13	embarrassed	embarrassed	JJ
5180	1776	14	to	to	TO
5180	1776	15	ask	ask	VB
5180	1776	16	a	a	DT
5180	1776	17	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	1776	18	to	to	TO
5180	1776	19	disable	disable	VB
5180	1776	20	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1776	21	software	software	NN
5180	1776	22	if	if	IN
5180	1776	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1776	24	had	have	VBD
5180	1776	25	impeded	impede	VBN
5180	1776	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1776	27	ability	ability	NN
5180	1776	28	to	to	TO
5180	1776	29	research	research	VB
5180	1776	30	surgery	surgery	NN
5180	1776	31	options	option	NNS
5180	1776	32	for	for	IN
5180	1776	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1776	34	mother	mother	NN
5180	1776	35	when	when	WRB
5180	1776	36	she	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1776	37	was	be	VBD
5180	1776	38	treated	treat	VBN
5180	1776	39	for	for	IN
5180	1776	40	breast	breast	NN
5180	1776	41	cancer	cancer	NN
5180	1776	42	.	.	.
5180	1777	1	As	as	IN
5180	1777	2	explained	explain	VBN
5180	1777	3	in	in	IN
5180	1777	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1777	5	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1777	6	of	of	IN
5180	1777	7	fact	fact	NN
5180	1777	8	,	,	,
5180	1777	9	see	see	VB
5180	1777	10	supra	supra	NNP
5180	1777	11	at	at	IN
5180	1777	12	Subsection	Subsection	NNP
5180	1777	13	II.D.2.b	II.D.2.b	NNP
5180	1777	14	,	,	,
5180	1777	15	the	the	DT
5180	1777	16	reluctance	reluctance	NN
5180	1777	17	of	of	IN
5180	1777	18	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1777	19	to	to	TO
5180	1777	20	request	request	VB
5180	1777	21	permission	permission	NN
5180	1777	22	to	to	IN
5180	1777	23	access	access	NN
5180	1777	24	Web	web	NN
5180	1777	25	sites	site	NNS
5180	1777	26	that	that	WDT
5180	1777	27	were	be	VBD
5180	1777	28	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1777	29	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1777	30	is	be	VBZ
5180	1777	31	further	further	RB
5180	1777	32	established	establish	VBN
5180	1777	33	by	by	IN
5180	1777	34	the	the	DT
5180	1777	35	low	low	JJ
5180	1777	36	number	number	NN
5180	1777	37	of	of	IN
5180	1777	38	patron	patron	NN
5180	1777	39	unblocking	unblocking	NN
5180	1777	40	requests	request	NNS
5180	1777	41	,	,	,
5180	1777	42	relative	relative	JJ
5180	1777	43	to	to	IN
5180	1777	44	the	the	DT
5180	1777	45	number	number	NN
5180	1777	46	of	of	IN
5180	1777	47	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1777	48	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1777	49	Web	web	NN
5180	1777	50	sites	site	NNS
5180	1777	51	,	,	,
5180	1777	52	in	in	IN
5180	1777	53	those	those	DT
5180	1777	54	public	public	JJ
5180	1777	55	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1777	56	that	that	WDT
5180	1777	57	use	use	VBP
5180	1777	58	software	software	NN
5180	1777	59	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1777	60	and	and	CC
5180	1777	61	permit	permit	NN
5180	1777	62	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1777	63	to	to	TO
5180	1777	64	request	request	VB
5180	1777	65	access	access	NN
5180	1777	66	to	to	IN
5180	1777	67	incorrectly	incorrectly	RB
5180	1777	68	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1777	69	Web	web	NN
5180	1777	70	sites	site	NNS
5180	1777	71	.	.	.
5180	1778	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	1778	2	.	.	.
5180	1779	1	Fabulous	Fabulous	NNP
5180	1779	2	Assocs	Assocs	NNP
5180	1779	3	.	.	.
5180	1779	4	,	,	,
5180	1779	5	896	896	CD
5180	1779	6	F.2d	F.2d	NNS
5180	1779	7	at	at	IN
5180	1779	8	786	786	CD
5180	1779	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1779	10	"	"	``
5180	1779	11	On	on	IN
5180	1779	12	the	the	DT
5180	1779	13	record	record	NN
5180	1779	14	before	before	IN
5180	1779	15	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1779	16	,	,	,
5180	1779	17	there	there	EX
5180	1779	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	1779	19	more	more	JJR
5180	1779	20	than	than	IN
5180	1779	21	enough	enough	JJ
5180	1779	22	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	1779	23	to	to	TO
5180	1779	24	support	support	VB
5180	1779	25	the	the	DT
5180	1779	26	district	district	NN
5180	1779	27	court	court	NN
5180	1779	28	's	's	POS
5180	1779	29	finding	finding	NN
5180	1779	30	that	that	IN
5180	1779	31	access	access	NN
5180	1779	32	codes	code	NNS
5180	1779	33	will	will	MD
5180	1779	34	chill	chill	VB
5180	1779	35	the	the	DT
5180	1779	36	exercise	exercise	NN
5180	1779	37	of	of	IN
5180	1779	38	some	some	DT
5180	1779	39	users	user	NNS
5180	1779	40	'	'	POS
5180	1779	41	right	right	NN
5180	1779	42	to	to	TO
5180	1779	43	hear	hear	VB
5180	1779	44	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1779	45	communications	communication	NNS
5180	1779	46	.	.	.
5180	1779	47	"	"	''
5180	1779	48	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1779	49	.	.	.
5180	1780	1	To	to	TO
5180	1780	2	be	be	VB
5180	1780	3	sure	sure	JJ
5180	1780	4	,	,	,
5180	1780	5	the	the	DT
5180	1780	6	government	government	NN
5180	1780	7	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBD
5180	1780	8	that	that	IN
5180	1780	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1780	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	1780	11	possible	possible	JJ
5180	1780	12	for	for	IN
5180	1780	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1780	14	to	to	TO
5180	1780	15	permit	permit	VB
5180	1780	16	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1780	17	to	to	TO
5180	1780	18	request	request	VB
5180	1780	19	anonymously	anonymously	RB
5180	1780	20	that	that	IN
5180	1780	21	a	a	DT
5180	1780	22	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1780	23	Web	web	NN
5180	1780	24	site	site	NN
5180	1780	25	be	be	VB
5180	1780	26	unblocked	unblocked	JJ
5180	1780	27	.	.	.
5180	1781	1	In	in	IN
5180	1781	2	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1781	3	,	,	,
5180	1781	4	the	the	DT
5180	1781	5	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	1781	6	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1781	7	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1781	8	has	have	VBZ
5180	1781	9	configured	configure	VBN
5180	1781	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1781	11	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1781	12	to	to	TO
5180	1781	13	present	present	VB
5180	1781	14	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1781	15	with	with	IN
5180	1781	16	the	the	DT
5180	1781	17	option	option	NN
5180	1781	18	,	,	,
5180	1781	19	each	each	DT
5180	1781	20	time	time	NN
5180	1781	21	the	the	DT
5180	1781	22	software	software	NN
5180	1781	23	filter	filter	NN
5180	1781	24	blocks	block	VBZ
5180	1781	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1781	26	access	access	NN
5180	1781	27	to	to	IN
5180	1781	28	a	a	DT
5180	1781	29	Web	web	NN
5180	1781	30	page	page	NN
5180	1781	31	,	,	,
5180	1781	32	of	of	IN
5180	1781	33	sending	send	VBG
5180	1781	34	an	an	DT
5180	1781	35	anonymous	anonymous	JJ
5180	1781	36	email	email	NN
5180	1781	37	to	to	IN
5180	1781	38	library	library	NN
5180	1781	39	staff	staff	NN
5180	1781	40	requesting	request	VBG
5180	1781	41	that	that	IN
5180	1781	42	the	the	DT
5180	1781	43	page	page	NN
5180	1781	44	be	be	VB
5180	1781	45	unblocked	unblocked	JJ
5180	1781	46	.	.	.
5180	1782	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	1782	2	,	,	,
5180	1782	3	a	a	DT
5180	1782	4	library	library	NN
5180	1782	5	staff	staff	NN
5180	1782	6	member	member	NN
5180	1782	7	periodically	periodically	RB
5180	1782	8	scans	scan	VBZ
5180	1782	9	logs	log	NNS
5180	1782	10	of	of	IN
5180	1782	11	URLs	url	NNS
5180	1782	12	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1782	13	by	by	IN
5180	1782	14	the	the	DT
5180	1782	15	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1782	16	,	,	,
5180	1782	17	in	in	IN
5180	1782	18	an	an	DT
5180	1782	19	effort	effort	NN
5180	1782	20	to	to	TO
5180	1782	21	identify	identify	VB
5180	1782	22	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1782	23	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1782	24	sites	site	NNS
5180	1782	25	,	,	,
5180	1782	26	which	which	WDT
5180	1782	27	the	the	DT
5180	1782	28	library	library	NN
5180	1782	29	will	will	MD
5180	1782	30	subsequently	subsequently	RB
5180	1782	31	unblock	unblock	VB
5180	1782	32	.	.	.
5180	1783	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1783	2	a	a	DT
5180	1783	3	public	public	JJ
5180	1783	4	library	library	NN
5180	1783	5	's	's	POS
5180	1783	6	ability	ability	NN
5180	1783	7	to	to	TO
5180	1783	8	permit	permit	VB
5180	1783	9	anonymous	anonymous	JJ
5180	1783	10	unblocking	unblocking	NN
5180	1783	11	requests	request	NNS
5180	1783	12	addresses	address	VBZ
5180	1783	13	the	the	DT
5180	1783	14	deterrent	deterrent	JJ
5180	1783	15	effect	effect	NN
5180	1783	16	of	of	IN
5180	1783	17	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1783	18	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1783	19	to	to	TO
5180	1783	20	identify	identify	VB
5180	1783	21	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1783	22	before	before	IN
5180	1783	23	gaining	gain	VBG
5180	1783	24	access	access	NN
5180	1783	25	to	to	IN
5180	1783	26	a	a	DT
5180	1783	27	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1783	28	Web	web	NN
5180	1783	29	site	site	NN
5180	1783	30	,	,	,
5180	1783	31	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1783	32	believe	believe	VBP
5180	1783	33	that	that	IN
5180	1783	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1783	35	fails	fail	VBZ
5180	1783	36	adequately	adequately	RB
5180	1783	37	to	to	TO
5180	1783	38	address	address	VB
5180	1783	39	the	the	DT
5180	1783	40	overblocking	overblocking	NN
5180	1783	41	problem	problem	NN
5180	1783	42	.	.	.
5180	1784	1	In	in	IN
5180	1784	2	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1784	3	,	,	,
5180	1784	4	even	even	RB
5180	1784	5	allowing	allow	VBG
5180	1784	6	anonymous	anonymous	JJ
5180	1784	7	requests	request	NNS
5180	1784	8	for	for	IN
5180	1784	9	unblocking	unblock	VBG
5180	1784	10	burdens	burden	NNS
5180	1784	11	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1784	12	'	'	POS
5180	1784	13	access	access	NN
5180	1784	14	to	to	IN
5180	1784	15	speech	speech	NN
5180	1784	16	,	,	,
5180	1784	17	since	since	IN
5180	1784	18	such	such	JJ
5180	1784	19	requests	request	NNS
5180	1784	20	can	can	MD
5180	1784	21	not	not	RB
5180	1784	22	immediately	immediately	RB
5180	1784	23	be	be	VB
5180	1784	24	acted	act	VBN
5180	1784	25	on	on	IN
5180	1784	26	.	.	.
5180	1785	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1785	2	the	the	DT
5180	1785	3	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	1785	4	Public	Public	NNP
5180	1785	5	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1785	6	,	,	,
5180	1785	7	for	for	IN
5180	1785	8	example	example	NN
5180	1785	9	,	,	,
5180	1785	10	attempts	attempt	VBZ
5180	1785	11	to	to	TO
5180	1785	12	review	review	VB
5180	1785	13	requests	request	NNS
5180	1785	14	for	for	IN
5180	1785	15	unblocking	unblock	VBG
5180	1785	16	within	within	IN
5180	1785	17	24	24	CD
5180	1785	18	hours	hour	NNS
5180	1785	19	,	,	,
5180	1785	20	requests	request	NNS
5180	1785	21	sometimes	sometimes	RB
5180	1785	22	are	be	VBP
5180	1785	23	not	not	RB
5180	1785	24	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	1785	25	for	for	IN
5180	1785	26	several	several	JJ
5180	1785	27	days	day	NNS
5180	1785	28	.	.	.
5180	1786	1	And	and	CC
5180	1786	2	delays	delay	NNS
5180	1786	3	are	be	VBP
5180	1786	4	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
5180	1786	5	in	in	IN
5180	1786	6	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1786	7	with	with	IN
5180	1786	8	branches	branch	NNS
5180	1786	9	that	that	WDT
5180	1786	10	lack	lack	VBP
5180	1786	11	the	the	DT
5180	1786	12	staff	staff	NN
5180	1786	13	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	1786	14	immediately	immediately	RB
5180	1786	15	to	to	TO
5180	1786	16	review	review	VB
5180	1786	17	patron	patron	NN
5180	1786	18	unblocking	unblocking	NN
5180	1786	19	requests	request	NNS
5180	1786	20	.	.	.
5180	1787	1	Because	because	IN
5180	1787	2	many	many	JJ
5180	1787	3	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1787	4	users	user	NNS
5180	1787	5	"	"	``
5180	1787	6	surf	surf	NN
5180	1787	7	"	"	''
5180	1787	8	the	the	DT
5180	1787	9	Web	web	NN
5180	1787	10	,	,	,
5180	1787	11	visiting	visit	VBG
5180	1787	12	hundreds	hundred	NNS
5180	1787	13	of	of	IN
5180	1787	14	Web	web	NN
5180	1787	15	sites	site	NNS
5180	1787	16	in	in	IN
5180	1787	17	a	a	DT
5180	1787	18	single	single	JJ
5180	1787	19	session	session	NN
5180	1787	20	and	and	CC
5180	1787	21	spending	spend	VBG
5180	1787	22	only	only	RB
5180	1787	23	a	a	DT
5180	1787	24	short	short	JJ
5180	1787	25	period	period	NN
5180	1787	26	of	of	IN
5180	1787	27	time	time	NN
5180	1787	28	viewing	view	VBG
5180	1787	29	many	many	JJ
5180	1787	30	of	of	IN
5180	1787	31	the	the	DT
5180	1787	32	sites	site	NNS
5180	1787	33	,	,	,
5180	1787	34	the	the	DT
5180	1787	35	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	1787	36	that	that	IN
5180	1787	37	a	a	DT
5180	1787	38	patron	patron	NN
5180	1787	39	take	take	VB
5180	1787	40	the	the	DT
5180	1787	41	time	time	NN
5180	1787	42	to	to	TO
5180	1787	43	affirmatively	affirmatively	RB
5180	1787	44	request	request	VB
5180	1787	45	access	access	NN
5180	1787	46	to	to	IN
5180	1787	47	a	a	DT
5180	1787	48	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1787	49	Web	web	NN
5180	1787	50	site	site	NN
5180	1787	51	and	and	CC
5180	1787	52	then	then	RB
5180	1787	53	wait	wait	VB
5180	1787	54	several	several	JJ
5180	1787	55	days	day	NNS
5180	1787	56	until	until	IN
5180	1787	57	the	the	DT
5180	1787	58	site	site	NN
5180	1787	59	is	be	VBZ
5180	1787	60	unblocked	unblocked	JJ
5180	1787	61	will	will	NN
5180	1787	62	,	,	,
5180	1787	63	as	as	IN
5180	1787	64	a	a	DT
5180	1787	65	practical	practical	JJ
5180	1787	66	matter	matter	NN
5180	1787	67	,	,	,
5180	1787	68	impose	impose	VB
5180	1787	69	a	a	DT
5180	1787	70	significant	significant	JJ
5180	1787	71	burden	burden	NN
5180	1787	72	on	on	IN
5180	1787	73	library	library	NN
5180	1787	74	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1787	75	'	'	POS
5180	1787	76	use	use	NN
5180	1787	77	of	of	IN
5180	1787	78	the	the	DT
5180	1787	79	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1787	80	.	.	.
5180	1788	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	1788	2	,	,	,
5180	1788	3	a	a	DT
5180	1788	4	patron	patron	NN
5180	1788	5	's	's	POS
5180	1788	6	time	time	NN
5180	1788	7	spent	spend	VBD
5180	1788	8	requesting	request	VBG
5180	1788	9	access	access	NN
5180	1788	10	to	to	IN
5180	1788	11	an	an	DT
5180	1788	12	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1788	13	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1788	14	Web	web	NN
5180	1788	15	site	site	NN
5180	1788	16	and	and	CC
5180	1788	17	checking	check	VBG
5180	1788	18	to	to	TO
5180	1788	19	determine	determine	VB
5180	1788	20	whether	whether	IN
5180	1788	21	access	access	NN
5180	1788	22	was	be	VBD
5180	1788	23	eventually	eventually	RB
5180	1788	24	granted	grant	VBN
5180	1788	25	is	be	VBZ
5180	1788	26	likely	likely	JJ
5180	1788	27	to	to	TO
5180	1788	28	exceed	exceed	VB
5180	1788	29	the	the	DT
5180	1788	30	amount	amount	NN
5180	1788	31	of	of	IN
5180	1788	32	time	time	NN
5180	1788	33	the	the	DT
5180	1788	34	patron	patron	NN
5180	1788	35	would	would	MD
5180	1788	36	have	have	VB
5180	1788	37	actually	actually	RB
5180	1788	38	spent	spend	VBN
5180	1788	39	viewing	view	VBG
5180	1788	40	the	the	DT
5180	1788	41	site	site	NN
5180	1788	42	,	,	,
5180	1788	43	had	have	VBD
5180	1788	44	the	the	DT
5180	1788	45	site	site	NN
5180	1788	46	not	not	RB
5180	1788	47	been	be	VBN
5180	1788	48	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1788	49	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1788	50	.	.	.
5180	1789	1	This	this	DT
5180	1789	2	delay	delay	NN
5180	1789	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1789	4	especially	especially	RB
5180	1789	5	burdensome	burdensome	JJ
5180	1789	6	in	in	IN
5180	1789	7	view	view	NN
5180	1789	8	of	of	IN
5180	1789	9	many	many	JJ
5180	1789	10	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1789	11	'	'	POS
5180	1789	12	practice	practice	NN
5180	1789	13	of	of	IN
5180	1789	14	limiting	limit	VBG
5180	1789	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1789	16	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1789	17	to	to	IN
5180	1789	18	a	a	DT
5180	1789	19	half	half	JJ
5180	1789	20	hour	hour	NN
5180	1789	21	or	or	CC
5180	1789	22	an	an	DT
5180	1789	23	hour	hour	NN
5180	1789	24	of	of	IN
5180	1789	25	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1789	26	use	use	NN
5180	1789	27	per	per	IN
5180	1789	28	day	day	NN
5180	1789	29	,	,	,
5180	1789	30	given	give	VBN
5180	1789	31	the	the	DT
5180	1789	32	scarcity	scarcity	NN
5180	1789	33	of	of	IN
5180	1789	34	terminal	terminal	JJ
5180	1789	35	time	time	NN
5180	1789	36	in	in	IN
5180	1789	37	relation	relation	NN
5180	1789	38	to	to	IN
5180	1789	39	patron	patron	NN
5180	1789	40	demand	demand	NN
5180	1789	41	.	.	.
5180	1790	1	The	the	DT
5180	1790	2	burden	burden	NN
5180	1790	3	of	of	IN
5180	1790	4	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1790	5	library	library	NN
5180	1790	6	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1790	7	to	to	TO
5180	1790	8	ask	ask	VB
5180	1790	9	permission	permission	NN
5180	1790	10	to	to	TO
5180	1790	11	view	view	VB
5180	1790	12	Web	web	NN
5180	1790	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	1790	14	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1790	15	content	content	NN
5180	1790	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	1790	17	disfavored	disfavor	VBN
5180	1790	18	resembles	resemble	NNS
5180	1790	19	the	the	DT
5180	1790	20	burden	burden	NN
5180	1790	21	that	that	WDT
5180	1790	22	the	the	DT
5180	1790	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1790	24	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1790	25	found	find	VBD
5180	1790	26	unacceptable	unacceptable	JJ
5180	1790	27	in	in	IN
5180	1790	28	Denver	Denver	NNP
5180	1790	29	,	,	,
5180	1790	30	which	which	WDT
5180	1790	31	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
5180	1790	32	a	a	DT
5180	1790	33	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1790	34	law	law	NN
5180	1790	35	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1790	36	cable	cable	NN
5180	1790	37	systems	system	NNS
5180	1790	38	operators	operator	NNS
5180	1790	39	to	to	TO
5180	1790	40	block	block	VB
5180	1790	41	subscribers	subscriber	NNS
5180	1790	42	'	'	POS
5180	1790	43	access	access	NN
5180	1790	44	to	to	IN
5180	1790	45	channels	channel	NNS
5180	1790	46	containing	contain	VBG
5180	1790	47	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1790	48	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1790	49	programming	programming	NN
5180	1790	50	,	,	,
5180	1790	51	unless	unless	IN
5180	1790	52	subscribers	subscriber	NNS
5180	1790	53	requested	request	VBD
5180	1790	54	unblocking	unblock	VBG
5180	1790	55	in	in	IN
5180	1790	56	advance	advance	NN
5180	1790	57	.	.	.
5180	1791	1	The	the	DT
5180	1791	2	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1791	3	reasoned	reason	VBD
5180	1791	4	that	that	IN
5180	1791	5	"	"	``
5180	1791	6	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1791	7	t]hese	t]hese	JJ
5180	1791	8	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1791	9	will	will	MD
5180	1791	10	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	1791	11	programmers	programmer	NNS
5180	1791	12	from	from	IN
5180	1791	13	broadcasting	broadcasting	NN
5180	1791	14	to	to	IN
5180	1791	15	viewers	viewer	NNS
5180	1791	16	who	who	WP
5180	1791	17	select	select	VBP
5180	1791	18	programs	program	NNS
5180	1791	19	day	day	NN
5180	1791	20	by	by	IN
5180	1791	21	day	day	NN
5180	1791	22	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1791	23	or	or	CC
5180	1791	24	,	,	,
5180	1791	25	through	through	IN
5180	1791	26	'	'	``
5180	1791	27	surfing	surfing	NN
5180	1791	28	,	,	,
5180	1791	29	'	'	''
5180	1791	30	minute	minute	NN
5180	1791	31	by	by	IN
5180	1791	32	minute	minute	NN
5180	1791	33	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1791	34	.	.	.
5180	1792	1	.	.	.
5180	1793	1	.	.	.
5180	1794	1	.	.	.
5180	1794	2	"	"	''
5180	1795	1	Denver	Denver	NNP
5180	1795	2	,	,	,
5180	1795	3	518	518	CD
5180	1795	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1795	5	at	at	IN
5180	1795	6	754	754	CD
5180	1795	7	.	.	.
5180	1796	1	Similarly	similarly	RB
5180	1796	2	,	,	,
5180	1796	3	in	in	IN
5180	1796	4	Fabulous	Fabulous	NNP
5180	1796	5	Associates	Associates	NNPS
5180	1796	6	,	,	,
5180	1796	7	the	the	DT
5180	1796	8	Third	Third	NNP
5180	1796	9	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
5180	1796	10	explained	explain	VBD
5180	1796	11	that	that	IN
5180	1796	12	a	a	DT
5180	1796	13	law	law	NN
5180	1796	14	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1796	15	adults	adult	NNS
5180	1796	16	from	from	IN
5180	1796	17	listening	listen	VBG
5180	1796	18	to	to	IN
5180	1796	19	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1796	20	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1796	21	phone	phone	NN
5180	1796	22	messages	message	NNS
5180	1796	23	unless	unless	IN
5180	1796	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1796	25	applied	apply	VBD
5180	1796	26	in	in	IN
5180	1796	27	advance	advance	NN
5180	1796	28	for	for	IN
5180	1796	29	access	access	NN
5180	1796	30	to	to	IN
5180	1796	31	such	such	JJ
5180	1796	32	messages	message	NNS
5180	1796	33	would	would	MD
5180	1796	34	burden	burden	VB
5180	1796	35	adults	adult	NNS
5180	1796	36	'	'	POS
5180	1796	37	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	1796	38	of	of	IN
5180	1796	39	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1796	40	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1796	41	speech	speech	NN
5180	1796	42	,	,	,
5180	1796	43	given	give	VBN
5180	1796	44	consumers	consumer	NNS
5180	1796	45	'	'	POS
5180	1796	46	tendency	tendency	NN
5180	1796	47	to	to	TO
5180	1796	48	purchase	purchase	VB
5180	1796	49	such	such	JJ
5180	1796	50	speech	speech	NN
5180	1796	51	on	on	IN
5180	1796	52	impulse	impulse	NN
5180	1796	53	.	.	.
5180	1797	1	See	see	VB
5180	1797	2	Fabulous	Fabulous	NNP
5180	1797	3	Assocs	Assocs	NNP
5180	1797	4	.	.	.
5180	1797	5	,	,	,
5180	1797	6	896	896	CD
5180	1797	7	F.2d	F.2d	NNS
5180	1797	8	at	at	IN
5180	1797	9	785	785	CD
5180	1797	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1797	11	noting	note	VBG
5180	1797	12	that	that	IN
5180	1797	13	officers	officer	NNS
5180	1797	14	of	of	IN
5180	1797	15	two	two	CD
5180	1797	16	companies	company	NNS
5180	1797	17	that	that	WDT
5180	1797	18	sell	sell	VBP
5180	1797	19	access	access	NN
5180	1797	20	to	to	IN
5180	1797	21	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1797	22	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1797	23	recorded	record	VBN
5180	1797	24	phone	phone	NN
5180	1797	25	messages	message	NNS
5180	1797	26	"	"	''
5180	1797	27	testified	testify	VBD
5180	1797	28	that	that	IN
5180	1797	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1797	30	is	be	VBZ
5180	1797	31	usually	usually	RB
5180	1797	32	'	'	``
5180	1797	33	impulse	impulse	JJ
5180	1797	34	callers	caller	NNS
5180	1797	35	'	'	''
5180	1797	36	who	who	WP
5180	1797	37	utilize	utilize	VBP
5180	1797	38	these	these	DT
5180	1797	39	types	type	NNS
5180	1797	40	of	of	IN
5180	1797	41	services	service	NNS
5180	1797	42	,	,	,
5180	1797	43	and	and	CC
5180	1797	44	that	that	IN
5180	1797	45	people	people	NNS
5180	1797	46	will	will	MD
5180	1797	47	not	not	RB
5180	1797	48	call	call	VB
5180	1797	49	if	if	IN
5180	1797	50	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1797	51	must	must	MD
5180	1797	52	apply	apply	VB
5180	1797	53	for	for	IN
5180	1797	54	an	an	DT
5180	1797	55	access	access	NN
5180	1797	56	code	code	NN
5180	1797	57	"	"	''
5180	1797	58	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1797	59	.	.	.
5180	1798	1	In	in	IN
5180	1798	2	sum	sum	NN
5180	1798	3	,	,	,
5180	1798	4	in	in	IN
5180	1798	5	many	many	JJ
5180	1798	6	cases	case	NNS
5180	1798	7	,	,	,
5180	1798	8	as	as	IN
5180	1798	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1798	10	have	have	VBP
5180	1798	11	noted	note	VBN
5180	1798	12	above	above	IN
5180	1798	13	,	,	,
5180	1798	14	library	library	JJ
5180	1798	15	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1798	16	who	who	WP
5180	1798	17	have	have	VBP
5180	1798	18	been	be	VBN
5180	1798	19	wrongly	wrongly	RB
5180	1798	20	denied	deny	VBN
5180	1798	21	access	access	NN
5180	1798	22	to	to	IN
5180	1798	23	a	a	DT
5180	1798	24	Web	web	NN
5180	1798	25	site	site	NN
5180	1798	26	will	will	MD
5180	1798	27	decline	decline	VB
5180	1798	28	to	to	TO
5180	1798	29	ask	ask	VB
5180	1798	30	the	the	DT
5180	1798	31	library	library	NN
5180	1798	32	to	to	TO
5180	1798	33	disable	disable	VB
5180	1798	34	the	the	DT
5180	1798	35	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1798	36	so	so	IN
5180	1798	37	that	that	IN
5180	1798	38	the	the	DT
5180	1798	39	patron	patron	NN
5180	1798	40	can	can	MD
5180	1798	41	access	access	VB
5180	1798	42	the	the	DT
5180	1798	43	Web	web	NN
5180	1798	44	site	site	NN
5180	1798	45	.	.	.
5180	1799	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	1799	2	,	,	,
5180	1799	3	even	even	RB
5180	1799	4	if	if	IN
5180	1799	5	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1799	6	requested	request	VBD
5180	1799	7	unblocking	unblock	VBG
5180	1799	8	every	every	DT
5180	1799	9	time	time	NN
5180	1799	10	a	a	DT
5180	1799	11	site	site	NN
5180	1799	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	1799	13	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1799	14	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1799	15	,	,	,
5180	1799	16	and	and	CC
5180	1799	17	even	even	RB
5180	1799	18	if	if	IN
5180	1799	19	library	library	NN
5180	1799	20	staff	staff	NN
5180	1799	21	granted	grant	VBD
5180	1799	22	every	every	DT
5180	1799	23	such	such	JJ
5180	1799	24	request	request	NN
5180	1799	25	,	,	,
5180	1799	26	a	a	DT
5180	1799	27	public	public	JJ
5180	1799	28	library	library	NN
5180	1799	29	's	's	POS
5180	1799	30	use	use	NN
5180	1799	31	of	of	IN
5180	1799	32	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1799	33	software	software	NN
5180	1799	34	would	would	MD
5180	1799	35	still	still	RB
5180	1799	36	impermissibly	impermissibly	RB
5180	1799	37	burden	burden	VB
5180	1799	38	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1799	39	'	'	POS
5180	1799	40	access	access	NN
5180	1799	41	to	to	IN
5180	1799	42	speech	speech	NN
5180	1799	43	based	base	VBN
5180	1799	44	on	on	IN
5180	1799	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1799	46	content	content	NN
5180	1799	47	.	.	.
5180	1800	1	The	the	DT
5180	1800	2	First	First	NNP
5180	1800	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1800	4	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
5180	1800	5	of	of	IN
5180	1800	6	the	the	DT
5180	1800	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	1800	8	Court	Court	NNP
5180	1800	9	and	and	CC
5180	1800	10	the	the	DT
5180	1800	11	Third	Third	NNP
5180	1800	12	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
5180	1800	13	makes	make	VBZ
5180	1800	14	clear	clear	JJ
5180	1800	15	that	that	IN
5180	1800	16	laws	law	NNS
5180	1800	17	imposing	impose	VBG
5180	1800	18	content	content	NN
5180	1800	19	-	-	HYPH
5180	1800	20	based	base	VBN
5180	1800	21	burdens	burden	NNS
5180	1800	22	on	on	IN
5180	1800	23	access	access	NN
5180	1800	24	to	to	IN
5180	1800	25	speech	speech	NN
5180	1800	26	are	be	VBP
5180	1800	27	no	no	DT
5180	1800	28	less	less	RBR
5180	1800	29	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1800	30	to	to	IN
5180	1800	31	the	the	DT
5180	1800	32	First	First	NNP
5180	1800	33	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1800	34	than	than	IN
5180	1800	35	laws	law	NNS
5180	1800	36	imposing	impose	VBG
5180	1800	37	content	content	NN
5180	1800	38	-	-	HYPH
5180	1800	39	based	base	VBN
5180	1800	40	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
5180	1800	41	on	on	IN
5180	1800	42	speech	speech	NN
5180	1800	43	:	:	:
5180	1800	44	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1800	45	is	be	VBZ
5180	1800	46	of	of	IN
5180	1800	47	no	no	DT
5180	1800	48	moment	moment	NN
5180	1800	49	that	that	IN
5180	1800	50	the	the	DT
5180	1800	51	statute	statute	NN
5180	1800	52	does	do	VBZ
5180	1800	53	not	not	RB
5180	1800	54	impose	impose	VB
5180	1800	55	a	a	DT
5180	1800	56	complete	complete	JJ
5180	1800	57	prohibition	prohibition	NN
5180	1800	58	.	.	.
5180	1801	1	The	the	DT
5180	1801	2	distinction	distinction	NN
5180	1801	3	between	between	IN
5180	1801	4	laws	law	NNS
5180	1801	5	burdening	burden	VBG
5180	1801	6	and	and	CC
5180	1801	7	laws	law	NNS
5180	1801	8	banning	ban	VBG
5180	1801	9	speech	speech	NN
5180	1801	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	1801	11	but	but	CC
5180	1801	12	a	a	DT
5180	1801	13	matter	matter	NN
5180	1801	14	of	of	IN
5180	1801	15	degree	degree	NN
5180	1801	16	.	.	.
5180	1802	1	The	the	DT
5180	1802	2	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1802	3	's	's	POS
5180	1802	4	content	content	NN
5180	1802	5	-	-	HYPH
5180	1802	6	based	base	VBN
5180	1802	7	burdens	burden	NNS
5180	1802	8	must	must	MD
5180	1802	9	satisfy	satisfy	VB
5180	1802	10	the	the	DT
5180	1802	11	same	same	JJ
5180	1802	12	rigorous	rigorous	JJ
5180	1802	13	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1802	14	as	as	IN
5180	1802	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1802	16	content	content	NN
5180	1802	17	-	-	HYPH
5180	1802	18	based	base	VBN
5180	1802	19	bans	ban	NNS
5180	1802	20	.	.	.
5180	1803	1	.	.	.
5180	1804	1	.	.	.
5180	1805	1	.	.	.
5180	1806	1	When	when	WRB
5180	1806	2	the	the	DT
5180	1806	3	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1806	4	and	and	CC
5180	1806	5	design	design	NN
5180	1806	6	of	of	IN
5180	1806	7	a	a	DT
5180	1806	8	statute	statute	NN
5180	1806	9	is	be	VBZ
5180	1806	10	to	to	TO
5180	1806	11	regulate	regulate	VB
5180	1806	12	speech	speech	NN
5180	1806	13	by	by	IN
5180	1806	14	reason	reason	NN
5180	1806	15	of	of	IN
5180	1806	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1806	17	content	content	NN
5180	1806	18	,	,	,
5180	1806	19	special	special	JJ
5180	1806	20	consideration	consideration	NN
5180	1806	21	or	or	CC
5180	1806	22	latitude	latitude	NN
5180	1806	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	1806	24	not	not	RB
5180	1806	25	afforded	afford	VBN
5180	1806	26	to	to	IN
5180	1806	27	the	the	DT
5180	1806	28	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1806	29	merely	merely	RB
5180	1806	30	because	because	IN
5180	1806	31	the	the	DT
5180	1806	32	law	law	NN
5180	1806	33	can	can	MD
5180	1806	34	somehow	somehow	RB
5180	1806	35	be	be	VB
5180	1806	36	described	describe	VBN
5180	1806	37	as	as	IN
5180	1806	38	a	a	DT
5180	1806	39	burden	burden	NN
5180	1806	40	rather	rather	RB
5180	1806	41	than	than	IN
5180	1806	42	outright	outright	JJ
5180	1806	43	suppression	suppression	NN
5180	1806	44	.	.	.
5180	1807	1	United	United	NNP
5180	1807	2	States	States	NNP
5180	1807	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1807	4	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1807	5	Entm't	Entm't	NNP
5180	1807	6	Group	Group	NNP
5180	1807	7	,	,	,
5180	1807	8	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1807	9	,	,	,
5180	1807	10	529	529	CD
5180	1807	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1807	12	803	803	CD
5180	1807	13	,	,	,
5180	1807	14	812	812	CD
5180	1807	15	,	,	,
5180	1807	16	826	826	CD
5180	1807	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1807	18	2000	2000	CD
5180	1807	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1807	20	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1807	21	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
5180	1807	22	a	a	DT
5180	1807	23	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1807	24	law	law	NN
5180	1807	25	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1807	26	cable	cable	NN
5180	1807	27	television	television	NN
5180	1807	28	operators	operator	NNS
5180	1807	29	to	to	TO
5180	1807	30	limit	limit	VB
5180	1807	31	the	the	DT
5180	1807	32	transmission	transmission	NN
5180	1807	33	of	of	IN
5180	1807	34	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1807	35	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1807	36	programming	programming	NN
5180	1807	37	to	to	IN
5180	1807	38	the	the	DT
5180	1807	39	hours	hour	NNS
5180	1807	40	between	between	IN
5180	1807	41	10:00	10:00	CD
5180	1807	42	p.m.	p.m.	NN
5180	1807	43	and	and	CC
5180	1807	44	6:00	6:00	CD
5180	1807	45	a.m.	a.m.	NN
5180	1807	46	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1807	47	;	;	:
5180	1807	48	see	see	VB
5180	1807	49	also	also	RB
5180	1807	50	Fabulous	Fabulous	NNP
5180	1807	51	Assocs	Assocs	NNP
5180	1807	52	.	.	.
5180	1807	53	,	,	,
5180	1807	54	896	896	CD
5180	1807	55	F.2d	F.2d	NNS
5180	1807	56	at	at	IN
5180	1807	57	785	785	CD
5180	1807	58	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1807	59	"	"	``
5180	1807	60	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1807	61	H]ere	H]ere	NNP
5180	1807	62	.	.	.
5180	1808	1	.	.	.
5180	1809	1	.	.	.
5180	1810	1	there	there	EX
5180	1810	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	1810	3	no	no	DT
5180	1810	4	outright	outright	JJ
5180	1810	5	prohibition	prohibition	NN
5180	1810	6	of	of	IN
5180	1810	7	indecent	indecent	JJ
5180	1810	8	communication	communication	NN
5180	1810	9	.	.	.
5180	1811	1	However	however	RB
5180	1811	2	,	,	,
5180	1811	3	the	the	DT
5180	1811	4	First	First	NNP
5180	1811	5	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1811	6	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	1811	7	against	against	IN
5180	1811	8	government	government	NN
5180	1811	9	inhibition	inhibition	NN
5180	1811	10	as	as	RB
5180	1811	11	well	well	RB
5180	1811	12	as	as	IN
5180	1811	13	prohibition	prohibition	NN
5180	1811	14	.	.	.
5180	1811	15	"	"	''
5180	1811	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1812	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1812	2	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1812	3	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1812	4	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1812	5	and	and	CC
5180	1812	6	citation	citation	NN
5180	1812	7	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1812	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1812	9	.	.	.
5180	1813	1	Even	even	RB
5180	1813	2	if	if	IN
5180	1813	3	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1813	4	's	's	POS
5180	1813	5	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1813	6	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1813	7	could	could	MD
5180	1813	8	be	be	VB
5180	1813	9	perfectly	perfectly	RB
5180	1813	10	implemented	implement	VBN
5180	1813	11	by	by	IN
5180	1813	12	library	library	NN
5180	1813	13	staff	staff	NN
5180	1813	14	every	every	DT
5180	1813	15	time	time	NN
5180	1813	16	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1813	17	request	request	VBP
5180	1813	18	access	access	NN
5180	1813	19	to	to	IN
5180	1813	20	an	an	DT
5180	1813	21	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1813	22	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1813	23	Web	web	NN
5180	1813	24	site	site	NN
5180	1813	25	,	,	,
5180	1813	26	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1813	27	hold	hold	VBP
5180	1813	28	that	that	IN
5180	1813	29	the	the	DT
5180	1813	30	content	content	NN
5180	1813	31	-	-	HYPH
5180	1813	32	based	base	VBN
5180	1813	33	burden	burden	NN
5180	1813	34	that	that	IN
5180	1813	35	the	the	DT
5180	1813	36	library	library	NN
5180	1813	37	's	's	POS
5180	1813	38	use	use	NN
5180	1813	39	of	of	IN
5180	1813	40	software	software	NN
5180	1813	41	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1813	42	places	place	NNS
5180	1813	43	on	on	IN
5180	1813	44	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1813	45	'	'	POS
5180	1813	46	access	access	NN
5180	1813	47	to	to	IN
5180	1813	48	speech	speech	NN
5180	1813	49	suffers	suffer	NNS
5180	1813	50	from	from	IN
5180	1813	51	the	the	DT
5180	1813	52	same	same	JJ
5180	1813	53	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	1813	54	deficiencies	deficiency	NNS
5180	1813	55	as	as	IN
5180	1813	56	a	a	DT
5180	1813	57	complete	complete	JJ
5180	1813	58	ban	ban	NN
5180	1813	59	on	on	IN
5180	1813	60	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1813	61	'	'	POS
5180	1813	62	access	access	NN
5180	1813	63	to	to	IN
5180	1813	64	speech	speech	NN
5180	1813	65	that	that	WDT
5180	1813	66	was	be	VBD
5180	1813	67	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1813	68	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1813	69	by	by	IN
5180	1813	70	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1813	71	,	,	,
5180	1813	72	since	since	IN
5180	1813	73	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1813	74	will	will	MD
5180	1813	75	often	often	RB
5180	1813	76	be	be	VB
5180	1813	77	deterred	deter	VBN
5180	1813	78	from	from	IN
5180	1813	79	asking	ask	VBG
5180	1813	80	the	the	DT
5180	1813	81	library	library	NN
5180	1813	82	to	to	TO
5180	1813	83	unblock	unblock	VB
5180	1813	84	a	a	DT
5180	1813	85	site	site	NN
5180	1813	86	and	and	CC
5180	1813	87	patron	patron	NN
5180	1813	88	requests	request	NNS
5180	1813	89	can	can	MD
5180	1813	90	not	not	RB
5180	1813	91	be	be	VB
5180	1813	92	immediately	immediately	RB
5180	1813	93	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	1813	94	.	.	.
5180	1814	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1814	2	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1814	3	hold	hold	VBP
5180	1814	4	that	that	IN
5180	1814	5	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1814	6	's	's	POS
5180	1814	7	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1814	8	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1814	9	fail	fail	VBP
5180	1814	10	to	to	TO
5180	1814	11	cure	cure	VB
5180	1814	12	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1814	13	's	's	POS
5180	1814	14	lack	lack	NN
5180	1814	15	of	of	IN
5180	1814	16	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1814	17	tailoring	tailoring	NN
5180	1814	18	.	.	.
5180	1815	1	5	5	CD
5180	1815	2	.	.	.
5180	1816	1	Conclusion	conclusion	NN
5180	1816	2	;	;	:
5180	1816	3	Severability	severability	NN
5180	1816	4	Based	base	VBN
5180	1816	5	upon	upon	IN
5180	1816	6	the	the	DT
5180	1816	7	foregoing	foregoing	JJ
5180	1816	8	discussion	discussion	NN
5180	1816	9	,	,	,
5180	1816	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1816	11	hold	hold	VBP
5180	1816	12	that	that	IN
5180	1816	13	a	a	DT
5180	1816	14	public	public	JJ
5180	1816	15	library	library	NN
5180	1816	16	's	's	POS
5180	1816	17	content	content	NN
5180	1816	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	1816	19	based	base	VBN
5180	1816	20	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1816	21	on	on	IN
5180	1816	22	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1816	23	'	'	POS
5180	1816	24	access	access	NN
5180	1816	25	to	to	IN
5180	1816	26	speech	speech	NN
5180	1816	27	on	on	IN
5180	1816	28	the	the	DT
5180	1816	29	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1816	30	is	be	VBZ
5180	1816	31	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1816	32	to	to	IN
5180	1816	33	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1816	34	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1816	35	.	.	.
5180	1817	1	Every	every	DT
5180	1817	2	item	item	NN
5180	1817	3	in	in	IN
5180	1817	4	a	a	DT
5180	1817	5	library	library	NN
5180	1817	6	's	's	POS
5180	1817	7	print	print	NN
5180	1817	8	collection	collection	NN
5180	1817	9	has	have	VBZ
5180	1817	10	been	be	VBN
5180	1817	11	selected	select	VBN
5180	1817	12	because	because	IN
5180	1817	13	library	library	NN
5180	1817	14	staff	staff	NN
5180	1817	15	,	,	,
5180	1817	16	or	or	CC
5180	1817	17	a	a	DT
5180	1817	18	party	party	NN
5180	1817	19	to	to	TO
5180	1817	20	whom	whom	WP
5180	1817	21	staff	staff	NN
5180	1817	22	delegates	delegate	VBZ
5180	1817	23	the	the	DT
5180	1817	24	decision	decision	NN
5180	1817	25	,	,	,
5180	1817	26	deems	deem	VBZ
5180	1817	27	the	the	DT
5180	1817	28	content	content	NN
5180	1817	29	to	to	TO
5180	1817	30	be	be	VB
5180	1817	31	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	1817	32	valuable	valuable	JJ
5180	1817	33	.	.	.
5180	1818	1	In	in	IN
5180	1818	2	contrast	contrast	NN
5180	1818	3	,	,	,
5180	1818	4	the	the	DT
5180	1818	5	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1818	6	,	,	,
5180	1818	7	as	as	IN
5180	1818	8	a	a	DT
5180	1818	9	forum	forum	NN
5180	1818	10	,	,	,
5180	1818	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	1818	12	open	open	JJ
5180	1818	13	to	to	IN
5180	1818	14	any	any	DT
5180	1818	15	member	member	NN
5180	1818	16	of	of	IN
5180	1818	17	the	the	DT
5180	1818	18	public	public	NN
5180	1818	19	to	to	TO
5180	1818	20	speak	speak	VB
5180	1818	21	,	,	,
5180	1818	22	and	and	CC
5180	1818	23	hence	hence	RB
5180	1818	24	,	,	,
5180	1818	25	even	even	RB
5180	1818	26	when	when	WRB
5180	1818	27	a	a	DT
5180	1818	28	library	library	NN
5180	1818	29	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	1818	30	filtered	filter	VBN
5180	1818	31	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1818	32	access	access	NN
5180	1818	33	,	,	,
5180	1818	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1818	35	creates	create	VBZ
5180	1818	36	a	a	DT
5180	1818	37	public	public	JJ
5180	1818	38	forum	forum	NN
5180	1818	39	in	in	IN
5180	1818	40	which	which	WDT
5180	1818	41	the	the	DT
5180	1818	42	vast	vast	JJ
5180	1818	43	majority	majority	NN
5180	1818	44	of	of	IN
5180	1818	45	the	the	DT
5180	1818	46	speech	speech	NN
5180	1818	47	has	have	VBZ
5180	1818	48	been	be	VBN
5180	1818	49	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	1818	50	by	by	IN
5180	1818	51	neither	neither	DT
5180	1818	52	librarians	librarian	NNS
5180	1818	53	nor	nor	CC
5180	1818	54	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1818	55	companies	company	NNS
5180	1818	56	.	.	.
5180	1819	1	Under	under	IN
5180	1819	2	public	public	JJ
5180	1819	3	forum	forum	NN
5180	1819	4	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	1819	5	,	,	,
5180	1819	6	where	where	WRB
5180	1819	7	the	the	DT
5180	1819	8	state	state	NN
5180	1819	9	creates	create	VBZ
5180	1819	10	such	such	PDT
5180	1819	11	a	a	DT
5180	1819	12	forum	forum	NN
5180	1819	13	open	open	JJ
5180	1819	14	to	to	IN
5180	1819	15	any	any	DT
5180	1819	16	member	member	NN
5180	1819	17	of	of	IN
5180	1819	18	the	the	DT
5180	1819	19	public	public	NN
5180	1819	20	to	to	TO
5180	1819	21	speak	speak	VB
5180	1819	22	on	on	IN
5180	1819	23	an	an	DT
5180	1819	24	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	1819	25	number	number	NN
5180	1819	26	of	of	IN
5180	1819	27	subjects	subject	NNS
5180	1819	28	,	,	,
5180	1819	29	the	the	DT
5180	1819	30	state	state	NN
5180	1819	31	's	's	POS
5180	1819	32	decision	decision	NN
5180	1819	33	selectively	selectively	RB
5180	1819	34	to	to	TO
5180	1819	35	exclude	exclude	VB
5180	1819	36	certain	certain	JJ
5180	1819	37	speech	speech	NN
5180	1819	38	on	on	IN
5180	1819	39	the	the	DT
5180	1819	40	basis	basis	NN
5180	1819	41	of	of	IN
5180	1819	42	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1819	43	content	content	NN
5180	1819	44	,	,	,
5180	1819	45	is	be	VBZ
5180	1819	46	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1819	47	to	to	IN
5180	1819	48	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1819	49	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1819	50	,	,	,
5180	1819	51	since	since	IN
5180	1819	52	such	such	JJ
5180	1819	53	exclusions	exclusion	NNS
5180	1819	54	risk	risk	NN
5180	1819	55	distorting	distort	VBG
5180	1819	56	the	the	DT
5180	1819	57	marketplace	marketplace	NN
5180	1819	58	of	of	IN
5180	1819	59	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	1819	60	that	that	WDT
5180	1819	61	the	the	DT
5180	1819	62	state	state	NN
5180	1819	63	has	have	VBZ
5180	1819	64	created	create	VBN
5180	1819	65	.	.	.
5180	1820	1	Application	application	NN
5180	1820	2	of	of	IN
5180	1820	3	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1820	4	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1820	5	to	to	IN
5180	1820	6	public	public	JJ
5180	1820	7	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1820	8	'	'	POS
5180	1820	9	content-	content-	NN
5180	1820	10	based	base	VBN
5180	1820	11	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1820	12	on	on	IN
5180	1820	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1820	14	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1820	15	'	'	POS
5180	1820	16	access	access	NN
5180	1820	17	to	to	IN
5180	1820	18	the	the	DT
5180	1820	19	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1820	20	finds	find	VBZ
5180	1820	21	further	further	JJ
5180	1820	22	support	support	NN
5180	1820	23	in	in	IN
5180	1820	24	the	the	DT
5180	1820	25	analogy	analogy	NN
5180	1820	26	to	to	IN
5180	1820	27	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1820	28	public	public	JJ
5180	1820	29	fora	fora	NN
5180	1820	30	,	,	,
5180	1820	31	such	such	JJ
5180	1820	32	as	as	IN
5180	1820	33	sidewalks	sidewalk	NNS
5180	1820	34	,	,	,
5180	1820	35	parks	park	NNS
5180	1820	36	,	,	,
5180	1820	37	and	and	CC
5180	1820	38	squares	square	NNS
5180	1820	39	,	,	,
5180	1820	40	in	in	IN
5180	1820	41	which	which	WDT
5180	1820	42	content	content	NN
5180	1820	43	-	-	HYPH
5180	1820	44	based	base	VBN
5180	1820	45	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1820	46	on	on	IN
5180	1820	47	speech	speech	NN
5180	1820	48	are	be	VBP
5180	1820	49	always	always	RB
5180	1820	50	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1820	51	to	to	IN
5180	1820	52	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1820	53	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1820	54	.	.	.
5180	1821	1	Like	like	IN
5180	1821	2	these	these	DT
5180	1821	3	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	1821	4	public	public	JJ
5180	1821	5	fora	fora	NN
5180	1821	6	,	,	,
5180	1821	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1821	8	access	access	NN
5180	1821	9	in	in	IN
5180	1821	10	public	public	JJ
5180	1821	11	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1821	12	uniquely	uniquely	RB
5180	1821	13	promotes	promote	VBZ
5180	1821	14	First	First	NNP
5180	1821	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1821	16	values	value	NNS
5180	1821	17	,	,	,
5180	1821	18	by	by	IN
5180	1821	19	offering	offer	VBG
5180	1821	20	low	low	JJ
5180	1821	21	barriers	barrier	NNS
5180	1821	22	to	to	IN
5180	1821	23	entry	entry	NN
5180	1821	24	to	to	IN
5180	1821	25	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	1821	26	and	and	CC
5180	1821	27	listeners	listener	NNS
5180	1821	28	.	.	.
5180	1822	1	The	the	DT
5180	1822	2	content	content	NN
5180	1822	3	of	of	IN
5180	1822	4	speech	speech	NN
5180	1822	5	on	on	IN
5180	1822	6	the	the	DT
5180	1822	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1822	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	1822	9	as	as	RB
5180	1822	10	diverse	diverse	JJ
5180	1822	11	as	as	IN
5180	1822	12	human	human	JJ
5180	1822	13	thought	thought	NN
5180	1822	14	,	,	,
5180	1822	15	and	and	CC
5180	1822	16	the	the	DT
5180	1822	17	extent	extent	NN
5180	1822	18	to	to	TO
5180	1822	19	which	which	WDT
5180	1822	20	the	the	DT
5180	1822	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1822	22	promotes	promote	VBZ
5180	1822	23	First	First	NNP
5180	1822	24	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1822	25	values	value	NNS
5180	1822	26	is	be	VBZ
5180	1822	27	evident	evident	JJ
5180	1822	28	from	from	IN
5180	1822	29	the	the	DT
5180	1822	30	sheer	sheer	JJ
5180	1822	31	breadth	breadth	NN
5180	1822	32	of	of	IN
5180	1822	33	speech	speech	NN
5180	1822	34	that	that	IN
5180	1822	35	this	this	DT
5180	1822	36	new	new	JJ
5180	1822	37	medium	medium	JJ
5180	1822	38	enables	enable	NNS
5180	1822	39	.	.	.
5180	1823	1	To	to	TO
5180	1823	2	survive	survive	VB
5180	1823	3	strict	strict	JJ
5180	1823	4	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	1823	5	,	,	,
5180	1823	6	a	a	DT
5180	1823	7	public	public	JJ
5180	1823	8	library	library	NN
5180	1823	9	's	's	POS
5180	1823	10	use	use	NN
5180	1823	11	of	of	IN
5180	1823	12	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1823	13	software	software	NN
5180	1823	14	must	must	MD
5180	1823	15	be	be	VB
5180	1823	16	narrowly	narrowly	RB
5180	1823	17	tailored	tailor	VBN
5180	1823	18	to	to	TO
5180	1823	19	further	further	RB
5180	1823	20	a	a	DT
5180	1823	21	compelling	compelling	JJ
5180	1823	22	state	state	NN
5180	1823	23	interest	interest	NN
5180	1823	24	,	,	,
5180	1823	25	and	and	CC
5180	1823	26	there	there	EX
5180	1823	27	must	must	MD
5180	1823	28	be	be	VB
5180	1823	29	no	no	DT
5180	1823	30	less	less	RBR
5180	1823	31	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1823	32	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	1823	33	that	that	WDT
5180	1823	34	could	could	MD
5180	1823	35	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	1823	36	further	far	RBR
5180	1823	37	that	that	DT
5180	1823	38	interest	interest	NN
5180	1823	39	.	.	.
5180	1824	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1824	2	find	find	VBP
5180	1824	3	that	that	IN
5180	1824	4	,	,	,
5180	1824	5	given	give	VBN
5180	1824	6	the	the	DT
5180	1824	7	crudeness	crudeness	NN
5180	1824	8	of	of	IN
5180	1824	9	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1824	10	technology	technology	NN
5180	1824	11	,	,	,
5180	1824	12	any	any	DT
5180	1824	13	technology	technology	NN
5180	1824	14	protection	protection	NN
5180	1824	15	measure	measure	NN
5180	1824	16	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	1824	17	by	by	IN
5180	1824	18	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1824	19	will	will	MD
5180	1824	20	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	1824	21	block	block	VB
5180	1824	22	access	access	NN
5180	1824	23	to	to	IN
5180	1824	24	a	a	DT
5180	1824	25	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1824	26	amount	amount	NN
5180	1824	27	of	of	IN
5180	1824	28	speech	speech	NN
5180	1824	29	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1824	30	suppression	suppression	NN
5180	1824	31	serves	serve	VBZ
5180	1824	32	no	no	DT
5180	1824	33	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1824	34	government	government	NN
5180	1824	35	interest	interest	NN
5180	1824	36	.	.	.
5180	1825	1	This	this	DT
5180	1825	2	lack	lack	NN
5180	1825	3	of	of	IN
5180	1825	4	narrow	narrow	JJ
5180	1825	5	tailoring	tailoring	NN
5180	1825	6	can	can	MD
5180	1825	7	not	not	RB
5180	1825	8	be	be	VB
5180	1825	9	cured	cure	VBN
5180	1825	10	by	by	IN
5180	1825	11	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1825	12	's	's	POS
5180	1825	13	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	1825	14	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1825	15	,	,	,
5180	1825	16	because	because	IN
5180	1825	17	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1825	18	will	will	MD
5180	1825	19	often	often	RB
5180	1825	20	be	be	VB
5180	1825	21	deterred	deter	VBN
5180	1825	22	from	from	IN
5180	1825	23	asking	ask	VBG
5180	1825	24	the	the	DT
5180	1825	25	library	library	NN
5180	1825	26	's	's	POS
5180	1825	27	permission	permission	NN
5180	1825	28	to	to	TO
5180	1825	29	access	access	VB
5180	1825	30	an	an	DT
5180	1825	31	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1825	32	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1825	33	Web	web	NN
5180	1825	34	page	page	NN
5180	1825	35	,	,	,
5180	1825	36	and	and	CC
5180	1825	37	anonymous	anonymous	JJ
5180	1825	38	requests	request	NNS
5180	1825	39	for	for	IN
5180	1825	40	unblocking	unblocking	NN
5180	1825	41	can	can	MD
5180	1825	42	not	not	RB
5180	1825	43	be	be	VB
5180	1825	44	acted	act	VBN
5180	1825	45	on	on	IN
5180	1825	46	without	without	IN
5180	1825	47	delaying	delay	VBG
5180	1825	48	the	the	DT
5180	1825	49	patron	patron	NN
5180	1825	50	's	's	POS
5180	1825	51	access	access	NN
5180	1825	52	to	to	IN
5180	1825	53	the	the	DT
5180	1825	54	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1825	55	Web	web	NN
5180	1825	56	page	page	NN
5180	1825	57	,	,	,
5180	1825	58	thereby	thereby	RB
5180	1825	59	impermissibly	impermissibly	RB
5180	1825	60	burdening	burden	VBG
5180	1825	61	access	access	NN
5180	1825	62	to	to	IN
5180	1825	63	speech	speech	NN
5180	1825	64	on	on	IN
5180	1825	65	the	the	DT
5180	1825	66	basis	basis	NN
5180	1825	67	of	of	IN
5180	1825	68	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1825	69	content	content	NN
5180	1825	70	.	.	.
5180	1826	1	Moreover	moreover	RB
5180	1826	2	,	,	,
5180	1826	3	less	less	RBR
5180	1826	4	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1826	5	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1826	6	exist	exist	VBP
5180	1826	7	to	to	TO
5180	1826	8	further	further	VB
5180	1826	9	a	a	DT
5180	1826	10	public	public	JJ
5180	1826	11	library	library	NN
5180	1826	12	's	's	POS
5180	1826	13	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	1826	14	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1826	15	in	in	IN
5180	1826	16	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1826	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1826	18	computers	computer	NNS
5180	1826	19	from	from	IN
5180	1826	20	being	be	VBG
5180	1826	21	used	use	VBN
5180	1826	22	to	to	TO
5180	1826	23	access	access	VB
5180	1826	24	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	1826	25	,	,	,
5180	1826	26	child	child	NN
5180	1826	27	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1826	28	,	,	,
5180	1826	29	or	or	CC
5180	1826	30	in	in	IN
5180	1826	31	the	the	DT
5180	1826	32	case	case	NN
5180	1826	33	of	of	IN
5180	1826	34	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1826	35	,	,	,
5180	1826	36	material	material	NN
5180	1826	37	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1826	38	to	to	IN
5180	1826	39	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1826	40	,	,	,
5180	1826	41	and	and	CC
5180	1826	42	in	in	IN
5180	1826	43	preventing	prevent	VBG
5180	1826	44	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1826	45	from	from	IN
5180	1826	46	being	be	VBG
5180	1826	47	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	1826	48	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1826	49	to	to	IN
5180	1826	50	patently	patently	RB
5180	1826	51	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1826	52	,	,	,
5180	1826	53	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1826	54	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1826	55	speech	speech	NN
5180	1826	56	.	.	.
5180	1827	1	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	1827	2	may	may	MD
5180	1827	3	use	use	VB
5180	1827	4	a	a	DT
5180	1827	5	variety	variety	NN
5180	1827	6	of	of	IN
5180	1827	7	means	mean	NNS
5180	1827	8	to	to	TO
5180	1827	9	monitor	monitor	VB
5180	1827	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1827	11	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1827	12	'	'	POS
5180	1827	13	use	use	NN
5180	1827	14	of	of	IN
5180	1827	15	the	the	DT
5180	1827	16	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1827	17	and	and	CC
5180	1827	18	impose	impose	VB
5180	1827	19	sanctions	sanction	NNS
5180	1827	20	on	on	IN
5180	1827	21	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1827	22	who	who	WP
5180	1827	23	violate	violate	VBP
5180	1827	24	the	the	DT
5180	1827	25	library	library	NN
5180	1827	26	's	's	POS
5180	1827	27	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1827	28	use	use	NN
5180	1827	29	policy	policy	NN
5180	1827	30	.	.	.
5180	1828	1	To	to	TO
5180	1828	2	protect	protect	VB
5180	1828	3	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1828	4	from	from	IN
5180	1828	5	material	material	NN
5180	1828	6	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1828	7	to	to	IN
5180	1828	8	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1828	9	,	,	,
5180	1828	10	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1828	11	could	could	MD
5180	1828	12	grant	grant	VB
5180	1828	13	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1828	14	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	1828	15	access	access	NN
5180	1828	16	only	only	RB
5180	1828	17	if	if	IN
5180	1828	18	accompanied	accompany	VBN
5180	1828	19	by	by	IN
5180	1828	20	a	a	DT
5180	1828	21	parent	parent	NN
5180	1828	22	,	,	,
5180	1828	23	or	or	CC
5180	1828	24	upon	upon	IN
5180	1828	25	parental	parental	JJ
5180	1828	26	consent	consent	NN
5180	1828	27	,	,	,
5180	1828	28	or	or	CC
5180	1828	29	could	could	MD
5180	1828	30	require	require	VB
5180	1828	31	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1828	32	to	to	TO
5180	1828	33	use	use	VB
5180	1828	34	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	1828	35	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1828	36	in	in	IN
5180	1828	37	view	view	NN
5180	1828	38	of	of	IN
5180	1828	39	library	library	NN
5180	1828	40	staff	staff	NN
5180	1828	41	.	.	.
5180	1829	1	To	to	TO
5180	1829	2	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	1829	3	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1829	4	from	from	IN
5180	1829	5	being	be	VBG
5180	1829	6	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
5180	1829	7	exposed	expose	VBN
5180	1829	8	to	to	IN
5180	1829	9	offensive	offensive	NN
5180	1829	10	,	,	,
5180	1829	11	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1829	12	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1829	13	content	content	NN
5180	1829	14	,	,	,
5180	1829	15	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1829	16	can	can	MD
5180	1829	17	offer	offer	VB
5180	1829	18	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1829	19	the	the	DT
5180	1829	20	option	option	NN
5180	1829	21	of	of	IN
5180	1829	22	using	use	VBG
5180	1829	23	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1829	24	software	software	NN
5180	1829	25	,	,	,
5180	1829	26	can	can	MD
5180	1829	27	place	place	VB
5180	1829	28	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	1829	29	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1829	30	outside	outside	RB
5180	1829	31	of	of	IN
5180	1829	32	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1829	33	'	'	POS
5180	1829	34	sight	sight	NN
5180	1829	35	lines	line	NNS
5180	1829	36	,	,	,
5180	1829	37	and	and	CC
5180	1829	38	can	can	MD
5180	1829	39	use	use	VB
5180	1829	40	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1829	41	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1829	42	and	and	CC
5180	1829	43	recessed	recess	VBN
5180	1829	44	monitors	monitor	NNS
5180	1829	45	.	.	.
5180	1830	1	While	while	IN
5180	1830	2	none	none	NN
5180	1830	3	of	of	IN
5180	1830	4	these	these	DT
5180	1830	5	less	less	RBR
5180	1830	6	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1830	7	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1830	8	are	be	VBP
5180	1830	9	perfect	perfect	JJ
5180	1830	10	,	,	,
5180	1830	11	the	the	DT
5180	1830	12	government	government	NN
5180	1830	13	has	have	VBZ
5180	1830	14	failed	fail	VBN
5180	1830	15	to	to	TO
5180	1830	16	show	show	VB
5180	1830	17	that	that	IN
5180	1830	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1830	19	are	be	VBP
5180	1830	20	significantly	significantly	RB
5180	1830	21	less	less	RBR
5180	1830	22	effective	effective	JJ
5180	1830	23	than	than	IN
5180	1830	24	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1830	25	software	software	NN
5180	1830	26	,	,	,
5180	1830	27	which	which	WDT
5180	1830	28	itself	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1830	29	fails	fail	VBZ
5180	1830	30	to	to	TO
5180	1830	31	block	block	VB
5180	1830	32	access	access	NN
5180	1830	33	to	to	IN
5180	1830	34	large	large	JJ
5180	1830	35	amounts	amount	NNS
5180	1830	36	of	of	IN
5180	1830	37	speech	speech	NN
5180	1830	38	that	that	WDT
5180	1830	39	fall	fall	VBP
5180	1830	40	within	within	IN
5180	1830	41	the	the	DT
5180	1830	42	categories	category	NNS
5180	1830	43	sought	seek	VBD
5180	1830	44	to	to	TO
5180	1830	45	be	be	VB
5180	1830	46	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1830	47	.	.	.
5180	1831	1	In	in	IN
5180	1831	2	view	view	NN
5180	1831	3	of	of	IN
5180	1831	4	the	the	DT
5180	1831	5	severe	severe	JJ
5180	1831	6	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	1831	7	of	of	IN
5180	1831	8	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1831	9	technology	technology	NN
5180	1831	10	and	and	CC
5180	1831	11	the	the	DT
5180	1831	12	existence	existence	NN
5180	1831	13	of	of	IN
5180	1831	14	these	these	DT
5180	1831	15	less	less	RBR
5180	1831	16	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	1831	17	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	1831	18	,	,	,
5180	1831	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1831	20	conclude	conclude	VBP
5180	1831	21	that	that	IN
5180	1831	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1831	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	1831	24	not	not	RB
5180	1831	25	possible	possible	JJ
5180	1831	26	for	for	IN
5180	1831	27	a	a	DT
5180	1831	28	public	public	JJ
5180	1831	29	library	library	NN
5180	1831	30	to	to	TO
5180	1831	31	comply	comply	VB
5180	1831	32	with	with	IN
5180	1831	33	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1831	34	without	without	IN
5180	1831	35	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1831	36	a	a	DT
5180	1831	37	very	very	RB
5180	1831	38	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	1831	39	amount	amount	NN
5180	1831	40	of	of	IN
5180	1831	41	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1831	42	protected	protect	VBN
5180	1831	43	speech	speech	NN
5180	1831	44	,	,	,
5180	1831	45	in	in	IN
5180	1831	46	violation	violation	NN
5180	1831	47	of	of	IN
5180	1831	48	the	the	DT
5180	1831	49	First	First	NNP
5180	1831	50	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1831	51	.	.	.
5180	1832	1	Because	because	IN
5180	1832	2	this	this	DT
5180	1832	3	conclusion	conclusion	NN
5180	1832	4	derives	derive	VBZ
5180	1832	5	from	from	IN
5180	1832	6	the	the	DT
5180	1832	7	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	1832	8	limits	limit	NNS
5180	1832	9	of	of	IN
5180	1832	10	the	the	DT
5180	1832	11	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1832	12	technology	technology	NN
5180	1832	13	mandated	mandate	VBN
5180	1832	14	by	by	IN
5180	1832	15	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1832	16	,	,	,
5180	1832	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1832	18	holds	hold	VBZ
5180	1832	19	for	for	IN
5180	1832	20	any	any	DT
5180	1832	21	library	library	NN
5180	1832	22	that	that	WDT
5180	1832	23	complies	comply	VBZ
5180	1832	24	with	with	IN
5180	1832	25	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1832	26	's	's	POS
5180	1832	27	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	1832	28	.	.	.
5180	1833	1	Hence	hence	RB
5180	1833	2	,	,	,
5180	1833	3	even	even	RB
5180	1833	4	under	under	IN
5180	1833	5	the	the	DT
5180	1833	6	stricter	strict	JJR
5180	1833	7	standard	standard	NN
5180	1833	8	of	of	IN
5180	1833	9	facial	facial	JJ
5180	1833	10	invalidity	invalidity	NN
5180	1833	11	proposed	propose	VBN
5180	1833	12	by	by	IN
5180	1833	13	the	the	DT
5180	1833	14	government	government	NN
5180	1833	15	,	,	,
5180	1833	16	which	which	WDT
5180	1833	17	would	would	MD
5180	1833	18	require	require	VB
5180	1833	19	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1833	20	to	to	TO
5180	1833	21	uphold	uphold	VB
5180	1833	22	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1833	23	if	if	IN
5180	1833	24	only	only	RB
5180	1833	25	a	a	DT
5180	1833	26	single	single	JJ
5180	1833	27	library	library	NN
5180	1833	28	can	can	MD
5180	1833	29	comply	comply	VB
5180	1833	30	with	with	IN
5180	1833	31	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1833	32	's	's	POS
5180	1833	33	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	1833	34	without	without	IN
5180	1833	35	violating	violate	VBG
5180	1833	36	the	the	DT
5180	1833	37	First	First	NNP
5180	1833	38	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1833	39	,	,	,
5180	1833	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1833	41	conclude	conclude	VBP
5180	1833	42	that	that	IN
5180	1833	43	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1833	44	is	be	VBZ
5180	1833	45	facially	facially	RB
5180	1833	46	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1833	47	,	,	,
5180	1833	48	since	since	IN
5180	1833	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1833	50	will	will	MD
5180	1833	51	induce	induce	VB
5180	1833	52	public	public	JJ
5180	1833	53	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1833	54	,	,	,
5180	1833	55	as	as	IN
5180	1833	56	state	state	NN
5180	1833	57	actors	actor	NNS
5180	1833	58	,	,	,
5180	1833	59	to	to	TO
5180	1833	60	violate	violate	VB
5180	1833	61	the	the	DT
5180	1833	62	First	First	NNP
5180	1833	63	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1833	64	.	.	.
5180	1834	1	Because	because	IN
5180	1834	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1834	3	hold	hold	VBP
5180	1834	4	that	that	IN
5180	1834	5	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1834	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	1834	7	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1834	8	on	on	IN
5180	1834	9	these	these	DT
5180	1834	10	grounds	ground	NNS
5180	1834	11	,	,	,
5180	1834	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1834	13	need	need	VBP
5180	1834	14	not	not	RB
5180	1834	15	reach	reach	VB
5180	1834	16	the	the	DT
5180	1834	17	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1834	18	'	'	POS
5180	1834	19	alternative	alternative	JJ
5180	1834	20	theories	theory	NNS
5180	1834	21	that	that	WDT
5180	1834	22	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1834	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	1834	24	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1834	25	as	as	IN
5180	1834	26	a	a	DT
5180	1834	27	prior	prior	JJ
5180	1834	28	restraint	restraint	NN
5180	1834	29	on	on	IN
5180	1834	30	speech	speech	NN
5180	1834	31	and	and	CC
5180	1834	32	is	be	VBZ
5180	1834	33	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
5180	1834	34	vague	vague	JJ
5180	1834	35	.	.	.
5180	1835	1	Nor	nor	CC
5180	1835	2	need	need	VBP
5180	1835	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1835	4	decide	decide	VBP
5180	1835	5	whether	whether	IN
5180	1835	6	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1835	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	1835	8	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1835	9	because	because	IN
5180	1835	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1835	11	requires	require	VBZ
5180	1835	12	public	public	JJ
5180	1835	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1835	14	,	,	,
5180	1835	15	as	as	IN
5180	1835	16	a	a	DT
5180	1835	17	condition	condition	NN
5180	1835	18	on	on	IN
5180	1835	19	the	the	DT
5180	1835	20	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	1835	21	of	of	IN
5180	1835	22	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1835	23	funds	fund	NNS
5180	1835	24	,	,	,
5180	1835	25	to	to	TO
5180	1835	26	relinquish	relinquish	VB
5180	1835	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1835	28	own	own	JJ
5180	1835	29	First	First	NNP
5180	1835	30	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1835	31	rights	right	NNS
5180	1835	32	to	to	TO
5180	1835	33	provide	provide	VB
5180	1835	34	the	the	DT
5180	1835	35	public	public	NN
5180	1835	36	with	with	IN
5180	1835	37	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	1835	38	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1835	39	access	access	NN
5180	1835	40	,	,	,
5180	1835	41	a	a	DT
5180	1835	42	theory	theory	NN
5180	1835	43	that	that	IN
5180	1835	44	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1835	45	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	1835	46	feel	feel	VBP
5180	1835	47	constrained	constrain	VBN
5180	1835	48	to	to	TO
5180	1835	49	discuss	discuss	VB
5180	1835	50	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1835	51	at	at	IN
5180	1835	52	length	length	NN
5180	1835	53	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1835	54	in	in	IN
5180	1835	55	the	the	DT
5180	1835	56	margin	margin	NN
5180	1835	57	.	.	.
5180	1836	1	Having	have	VBG
5180	1836	2	determined	determine	VBN
5180	1836	3	that	that	IN
5180	1836	4	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1836	5	violates	violate	VBZ
5180	1836	6	the	the	DT
5180	1836	7	First	First	NNP
5180	1836	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1836	9	,	,	,
5180	1836	10	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1836	11	would	would	MD
5180	1836	12	usually	usually	RB
5180	1836	13	be	be	VB
5180	1836	14	required	require	VBN
5180	1836	15	to	to	TO
5180	1836	16	determine	determine	VB
5180	1836	17	whether	whether	IN
5180	1836	18	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1836	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	1836	20	severable	severable	JJ
5180	1836	21	from	from	IN
5180	1836	22	the	the	DT
5180	1836	23	remainder	remainder	NN
5180	1836	24	of	of	IN
5180	1836	25	the	the	DT
5180	1836	26	statutes	statute	NNS
5180	1836	27	governing	govern	VBG
5180	1836	28	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	1836	29	and	and	CC
5180	1836	30	E	e	NN
5180	1836	31	-	-	NN
5180	1836	32	rate	rate	NN
5180	1836	33	funding	funding	NN
5180	1836	34	.	.	.
5180	1837	1	Neither	neither	DT
5180	1837	2	party	party	NN
5180	1837	3	,	,	,
5180	1837	4	however	however	RB
5180	1837	5	,	,	,
5180	1837	6	has	have	VBZ
5180	1837	7	advanced	advance	VBN
5180	1837	8	the	the	DT
5180	1837	9	argument	argument	NN
5180	1837	10	that	that	IN
5180	1837	11	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1837	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	1837	13	not	not	RB
5180	1837	14	severable	severable	JJ
5180	1837	15	from	from	IN
5180	1837	16	the	the	DT
5180	1837	17	remainder	remainder	NN
5180	1837	18	the	the	DT
5180	1837	19	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1837	20	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	1837	21	and	and	CC
5180	1837	22	Technology	Technology	NNP
5180	1837	23	Act	Act	NNP
5180	1837	24	and	and	CC
5180	1837	25	Communications	Communications	NNP
5180	1837	26	Act	Act	NNP
5180	1837	27	of	of	IN
5180	1837	28	1934	1934	CD
5180	1837	29	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1837	30	the	the	DT
5180	1837	31	two	two	CD
5180	1837	32	statutes	statute	NNS
5180	1837	33	governing	govern	VBG
5180	1837	34	LSTA	lsta	NN
5180	1837	35	and	and	CC
5180	1837	36	E	e	NN
5180	1837	37	-	-	NN
5180	1837	38	rate	rate	NN
5180	1837	39	funding	funding	NN
5180	1837	40	,	,	,
5180	1837	41	respectively	respectively	RB
5180	1837	42	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1837	43	,	,	,
5180	1837	44	and	and	CC
5180	1837	45	at	at	IN
5180	1837	46	all	all	DT
5180	1837	47	events	event	NNS
5180	1837	48	,	,	,
5180	1837	49	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1837	50	think	think	VBP
5180	1837	51	that	that	IN
5180	1837	52	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1837	53	is	be	VBZ
5180	1837	54	severable	severable	JJ
5180	1837	55	.	.	.
5180	1838	1	"	"	``
5180	1838	2	The	the	DT
5180	1838	3	inquiry	inquiry	NN
5180	1838	4	into	into	IN
5180	1838	5	whether	whether	IN
5180	1838	6	a	a	DT
5180	1838	7	statute	statute	NN
5180	1838	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	1838	9	severable	severable	JJ
5180	1838	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	1838	11	essentially	essentially	RB
5180	1838	12	an	an	DT
5180	1838	13	inquiry	inquiry	NN
5180	1838	14	into	into	IN
5180	1838	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
5180	1838	16	intent	intent	NN
5180	1838	17	.	.	.
5180	1838	18	"	"	''
5180	1839	1	Minn.	Minnesota	NNP
5180	1839	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1839	3	Mille	Mille	NNP
5180	1839	4	Lacs	Lacs	NNP
5180	1839	5	Band	Band	NNP
5180	1839	6	of	of	IN
5180	1839	7	Chippewa	Chippewa	NNP
5180	1839	8	Indians	Indians	NNPS
5180	1839	9	,	,	,
5180	1839	10	526	526	CD
5180	1839	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1839	12	172	172	CD
5180	1839	13	,	,	,
5180	1839	14	191	191	CD
5180	1839	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1839	16	1999	1999	CD
5180	1839	17	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1839	18	.	.	.
5180	1840	1	"	"	``
5180	1840	2	Unless	unless	IN
5180	1840	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1840	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	1840	5	evident	evident	JJ
5180	1840	6	that	that	IN
5180	1840	7	the	the	DT
5180	1840	8	legislature	legislature	NN
5180	1840	9	would	would	MD
5180	1840	10	not	not	RB
5180	1840	11	have	have	VB
5180	1840	12	enacted	enact	VBN
5180	1840	13	those	those	DT
5180	1840	14	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1840	15	which	which	WDT
5180	1840	16	are	be	VBP
5180	1840	17	within	within	IN
5180	1840	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1840	19	power	power	NN
5180	1840	20	,	,	,
5180	1840	21	independently	independently	RB
5180	1840	22	of	of	IN
5180	1840	23	that	that	DT
5180	1840	24	which	which	WDT
5180	1840	25	is	be	VBZ
5180	1840	26	not	not	RB
5180	1840	27	,	,	,
5180	1840	28	the	the	DT
5180	1840	29	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1840	30	part	part	NN
5180	1840	31	may	may	MD
5180	1840	32	be	be	VB
5180	1840	33	dropped	drop	VBN
5180	1840	34	if	if	IN
5180	1840	35	what	what	WP
5180	1840	36	is	be	VBZ
5180	1840	37	left	leave	VBN
5180	1840	38	is	be	VBZ
5180	1840	39	fully	fully	RB
5180	1840	40	operative	operative	JJ
5180	1840	41	as	as	IN
5180	1840	42	a	a	DT
5180	1840	43	law	law	NN
5180	1840	44	.	.	.
5180	1840	45	"	"	''
5180	1841	1	Buckley	Buckley	NNP
5180	1841	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1841	3	Valeo	Valeo	NNP
5180	1841	4	,	,	,
5180	1841	5	424	424	CD
5180	1841	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1841	7	1	1	CD
5180	1841	8	,	,	,
5180	1841	9	108	108	CD
5180	1841	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1841	11	1976	1976	CD
5180	1841	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1841	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1841	14	internal	internal	JJ
5180	1841	15	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	1841	16	marks	mark	NNS
5180	1841	17	and	and	CC
5180	1841	18	citation	citation	NN
5180	1841	19	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	1841	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1841	21	.	.	.
5180	1842	1	There	there	EX
5180	1842	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	1842	3	no	no	DT
5180	1842	4	doubt	doubt	NN
5180	1842	5	that	that	IN
5180	1842	6	if	if	IN
5180	1842	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1842	8	were	be	VBD
5180	1842	9	to	to	TO
5180	1842	10	strike	strike	VB
5180	1842	11	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	1842	12	from	from	IN
5180	1842	13	the	the	DT
5180	1842	14	sections	section	NNS
5180	1842	15	of	of	IN
5180	1842	16	the	the	DT
5180	1842	17	United	United	NNP
5180	1842	18	States	States	NNP
5180	1842	19	Code	Code	NNP
5180	1842	20	where	where	WRB
5180	1842	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1842	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	1842	23	currently	currently	RB
5180	1842	24	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1842	25	,	,	,
5180	1842	26	the	the	DT
5180	1842	27	remaining	remain	VBG
5180	1842	28	statutory	statutory	JJ
5180	1842	29	sections	section	NNS
5180	1842	30	,	,	,
5180	1842	31	providing	provide	VBG
5180	1842	32	eligible	eligible	JJ
5180	1842	33	public	public	JJ
5180	1842	34	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1842	35	with	with	IN
5180	1842	36	E-	e-	NN
5180	1842	37	rate	rate	NN
5180	1842	38	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	1842	39	and	and	CC
5180	1842	40	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	1842	41	grants	grant	NNS
5180	1842	42	,	,	,
5180	1842	43	would	would	MD
5180	1842	44	be	be	VB
5180	1842	45	fully	fully	RB
5180	1842	46	operative	operative	JJ
5180	1842	47	as	as	IN
5180	1842	48	law	law	NN
5180	1842	49	.	.	.
5180	1843	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	1843	2	,	,	,
5180	1843	3	the	the	DT
5180	1843	4	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	1843	5	and	and	CC
5180	1843	6	E	e	NN
5180	1843	7	-	-	NN
5180	1843	8	rate	rate	NN
5180	1843	9	programs	program	NNS
5180	1843	10	existed	exist	VBN
5180	1843	11	prior	prior	RB
5180	1843	12	to	to	IN
5180	1843	13	the	the	DT
5180	1843	14	enactment	enactment	NN
5180	1843	15	of	of	IN
5180	1843	16	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1843	17	in	in	IN
5180	1843	18	substantially	substantially	RB
5180	1843	19	the	the	DT
5180	1843	20	same	same	JJ
5180	1843	21	form	form	NN
5180	1843	22	as	as	IN
5180	1843	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1843	24	would	would	MD
5180	1843	25	exist	exist	VB
5180	1843	26	were	be	VBD
5180	1843	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1843	28	to	to	TO
5180	1843	29	strike	strike	VB
5180	1843	30	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1843	31	and	and	CC
5180	1843	32	leave	leave	VB
5180	1843	33	the	the	DT
5180	1843	34	rest	rest	NN
5180	1843	35	of	of	IN
5180	1843	36	the	the	DT
5180	1843	37	programs	program	NNS
5180	1843	38	intact	intact	JJ
5180	1843	39	.	.	.
5180	1844	1	The	the	DT
5180	1844	2	second	second	JJ
5180	1844	3	question	question	NN
5180	1844	4	,	,	,
5180	1844	5	whether	whether	IN
5180	1844	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1844	7	would	would	MD
5180	1844	8	in	in	IN
5180	1844	9	this	this	DT
5180	1844	10	case	case	NN
5180	1844	11	have	have	VBP
5180	1844	12	chosen	choose	VBN
5180	1844	13	to	to	TO
5180	1844	14	repeal	repeal	VB
5180	1844	15	the	the	DT
5180	1844	16	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	1844	17	and	and	CC
5180	1844	18	E	e	NN
5180	1844	19	-	-	NN
5180	1844	20	rate	rate	NN
5180	1844	21	subsidy	subsidy	NN
5180	1844	22	programs	program	NNS
5180	1844	23	instead	instead	RB
5180	1844	24	of	of	IN
5180	1844	25	continuing	continue	VBG
5180	1844	26	to	to	TO
5180	1844	27	fund	fund	VB
5180	1844	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1844	29	if	if	IN
5180	1844	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1844	31	had	have	VBD
5180	1844	32	known	know	VBN
5180	1844	33	that	that	IN
5180	1844	34	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1844	35	's	's	POS
5180	1844	36	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	1844	37	on	on	IN
5180	1844	38	these	these	DT
5180	1844	39	programs	program	NNS
5180	1844	40	were	be	VBD
5180	1844	41	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	1844	42	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1844	43	,	,	,
5180	1844	44	is	be	VBZ
5180	1844	45	less	less	RBR
5180	1844	46	clear	clear	JJ
5180	1844	47	.	.	.
5180	1845	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1845	2	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	1845	3	"	"	``
5180	1845	4	separability	separability	NN
5180	1845	5	"	"	''
5180	1845	6	clauses	clause	NNS
5180	1845	7	that	that	DT
5180	1845	8	state	state	NN
5180	1845	9	that	that	IN
5180	1845	10	if	if	IN
5180	1845	11	any	any	DT
5180	1845	12	of	of	IN
5180	1845	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1845	14	additions	addition	NNS
5180	1845	15	to	to	IN
5180	1845	16	the	the	DT
5180	1845	17	statutes	statute	NNS
5180	1845	18	governing	govern	VBG
5180	1845	19	the	the	DT
5180	1845	20	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	1845	21	and	and	CC
5180	1845	22	E-	e-	NN
5180	1845	23	rate	rate	NN
5180	1845	24	programs	program	NNS
5180	1845	25	are	be	VBP
5180	1845	26	found	find	VBN
5180	1845	27	to	to	TO
5180	1845	28	be	be	VB
5180	1845	29	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	1845	30	,	,	,
5180	1845	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1845	32	intended	intend	VBD
5180	1845	33	to	to	TO
5180	1845	34	effectuate	effectuate	VB
5180	1845	35	as	as	RB
5180	1845	36	much	much	JJ
5180	1845	37	of	of	IN
5180	1845	38	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1845	39	's	's	POS
5180	1845	40	amendments	amendment	NNS
5180	1845	41	as	as	IN
5180	1845	42	possible	possible	JJ
5180	1845	43	.	.	.
5180	1846	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1846	2	interpret	interpret	VBP
5180	1846	3	these	these	DT
5180	1846	4	clauses	clause	NNS
5180	1846	5	to	to	TO
5180	1846	6	mean	mean	VB
5180	1846	7	,	,	,
5180	1846	8	for	for	IN
5180	1846	9	example	example	NN
5180	1846	10	,	,	,
5180	1846	11	that	that	IN
5180	1846	12	if	if	IN
5180	1846	13	a	a	DT
5180	1846	14	court	court	NN
5180	1846	15	were	be	VBD
5180	1846	16	to	to	TO
5180	1846	17	find	find	VB
5180	1846	18	that	that	IN
5180	1846	19	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1846	20	's	's	POS
5180	1846	21	requirements	requirement	NNS
5180	1846	22	are	be	VBP
5180	1846	23	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	1846	24	with	with	IN
5180	1846	25	respect	respect	NN
5180	1846	26	to	to	TO
5180	1846	27	adult	adult	NN
5180	1846	28	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1846	29	,	,	,
5180	1846	30	but	but	CC
5180	1846	31	permissible	permissible	JJ
5180	1846	32	with	with	IN
5180	1846	33	respect	respect	NN
5180	1846	34	to	to	IN
5180	1846	35	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1846	36	,	,	,
5180	1846	37	that	that	IN
5180	1846	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1846	39	intended	intend	VBD
5180	1846	40	to	to	TO
5180	1846	41	have	have	VB
5180	1846	42	the	the	DT
5180	1846	43	court	court	NN
5180	1846	44	effectuate	effectuate	VB
5180	1846	45	only	only	RB
5180	1846	46	the	the	DT
5180	1846	47	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1846	48	with	with	IN
5180	1846	49	respect	respect	NN
5180	1846	50	to	to	IN
5180	1846	51	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1846	52	.	.	.
5180	1847	1	These	these	DT
5180	1847	2	separability	separability	NN
5180	1847	3	clauses	clause	NNS
5180	1847	4	do	do	VBP
5180	1847	5	not	not	RB
5180	1847	6	speak	speak	VB
5180	1847	7	to	to	IN
5180	1847	8	the	the	DT
5180	1847	9	situation	situation	NN
5180	1847	10	before	before	IN
5180	1847	11	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1847	12	,	,	,
5180	1847	13	however	however	RB
5180	1847	14	,	,	,
5180	1847	15	where	where	WRB
5180	1847	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1847	17	have	have	VBP
5180	1847	18	found	find	VBN
5180	1847	19	that	that	IN
5180	1847	20	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1847	21	is	be	VBZ
5180	1847	22	facially	facially	RB
5180	1847	23	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	1847	24	in	in	IN
5180	1847	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1847	26	entirety	entirety	NN
5180	1847	27	.	.	.
5180	1848	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
5180	1848	2	,	,	,
5180	1848	3	the	the	DT
5180	1848	4	government	government	NN
5180	1848	5	has	have	VBZ
5180	1848	6	not	not	RB
5180	1848	7	pointed	point	VBN
5180	1848	8	to	to	IN
5180	1848	9	anything	anything	NN
5180	1848	10	in	in	IN
5180	1848	11	the	the	DT
5180	1848	12	legislative	legislative	JJ
5180	1848	13	history	history	NN
5180	1848	14	or	or	CC
5180	1848	15	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
5180	1848	16	to	to	TO
5180	1848	17	suggest	suggest	VB
5180	1848	18	that	that	IN
5180	1848	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1848	20	intended	intend	VBD
5180	1848	21	to	to	TO
5180	1848	22	discontinue	discontinue	VB
5180	1848	23	funding	funding	NN
5180	1848	24	under	under	IN
5180	1848	25	the	the	DT
5180	1848	26	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	1848	27	and	and	CC
5180	1848	28	E	e	NN
5180	1848	29	-	-	NN
5180	1848	30	rate	rate	NN
5180	1848	31	programs	program	NNS
5180	1848	32	unless	unless	IN
5180	1848	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1848	34	could	could	MD
5180	1848	35	effectuate	effectuate	VB
5180	1848	36	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1848	37	's	's	POS
5180	1848	38	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1848	39	on	on	IN
5180	1848	40	the	the	DT
5180	1848	41	funding	funding	NN
5180	1848	42	.	.	.
5180	1849	1	And	and	CC
5180	1849	2	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1849	3	's	's	POS
5180	1849	4	decision	decision	NN
5180	1849	5	,	,	,
5180	1849	6	prior	prior	RB
5180	1849	7	to	to	IN
5180	1849	8	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1849	9	's	's	POS
5180	1849	10	enactment	enactment	NN
5180	1849	11	,	,	,
5180	1849	12	to	to	TO
5180	1849	13	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	1849	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1849	15	access	access	NN
5180	1849	16	through	through	IN
5180	1849	17	the	the	DT
5180	1849	18	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	1849	19	and	and	CC
5180	1849	20	E	e	NN
5180	1849	21	-	-	HYPH
5180	1849	22	rate	rate	NN
5180	1849	23	programs	program	NNS
5180	1849	24	without	without	IN
5180	1849	25	such	such	JJ
5180	1849	26	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	1849	27	,	,	,
5180	1849	28	counsels	counsel	VBZ
5180	1849	29	that	that	IN
5180	1849	30	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1849	31	reach	reach	VBP
5180	1849	32	the	the	DT
5180	1849	33	opposite	opposite	JJ
5180	1849	34	conclusion	conclusion	NN
5180	1849	35	.	.	.
5180	1850	1	At	at	IN
5180	1850	2	bottom	bottom	NN
5180	1850	3	,	,	,
5180	1850	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1850	5	think	think	VBP
5180	1850	6	that	that	IN
5180	1850	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1850	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	1850	9	unclear	unclear	JJ
5180	1850	10	what	what	WP
5180	1850	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1850	12	's	's	POS
5180	1850	13	intent	intent	NN
5180	1850	14	was	be	VBD
5180	1850	15	on	on	IN
5180	1850	16	this	this	DT
5180	1850	17	point	point	NN
5180	1850	18	,	,	,
5180	1850	19	and	and	CC
5180	1850	20	in	in	IN
5180	1850	21	the	the	DT
5180	1850	22	absence	absence	NN
5180	1850	23	of	of	IN
5180	1850	24	such	such	JJ
5180	1850	25	information	information	NN
5180	1850	26	,	,	,
5180	1850	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1850	28	exercise	exercise	VBP
5180	1850	29	a	a	DT
5180	1850	30	presumption	presumption	NN
5180	1850	31	in	in	IN
5180	1850	32	favor	favor	NN
5180	1850	33	of	of	IN
5180	1850	34	severability	severability	NN
5180	1850	35	.	.	.
5180	1851	1	Regan	Regan	NNP
5180	1851	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1851	3	Time	Time	NNP
5180	1851	4	,	,	,
5180	1851	5	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	1851	6	,	,	,
5180	1851	7	468	468	CD
5180	1851	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1851	9	641	641	CD
5180	1851	10	,	,	,
5180	1851	11	653	653	CD
5180	1851	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1851	13	1984	1984	CD
5180	1851	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1851	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1851	16	"	"	``
5180	1851	17	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1851	18	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	1851	19	presumption	presumption	NN
5180	1851	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	1851	21	in	in	IN
5180	1851	22	favor	favor	NN
5180	1851	23	of	of	IN
5180	1851	24	severability	severability	NN
5180	1851	25	.	.	.
5180	1852	1	")	")	``
5180	1852	2	;	;	:
5180	1852	3	cf	cf	NN
5180	1852	4	.	.	.
5180	1853	1	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	1853	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	1853	3	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	1853	4	Servs	Servs	NNP
5180	1853	5	.	.	.
5180	1854	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
5180	1854	2	,	,	,
5180	1854	3	164	164	CD
5180	1854	4	F.3d	F.3d	NNP
5180	1854	5	757	757	CD
5180	1854	6	,	,	,
5180	1854	7	773	773	CD
5180	1854	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1854	9	2d	2d	NNP
5180	1854	10	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	1854	11	.	.	.
5180	1855	1	1999	1999	CD
5180	1855	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1855	3	,	,	,
5180	1855	4	aff'd	aff'd	NNS
5180	1855	5	531	531	CD
5180	1855	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1855	7	533	533	CD
5180	1855	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1855	9	2001	2001	CD
5180	1855	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1855	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1855	12	applying	apply	VBG
5180	1855	13	a	a	DT
5180	1855	14	presumption	presumption	NN
5180	1855	15	in	in	IN
5180	1855	16	favor	favor	NN
5180	1855	17	of	of	IN
5180	1855	18	severability	severability	NN
5180	1855	19	in	in	IN
5180	1855	20	the	the	DT
5180	1855	21	face	face	NN
5180	1855	22	of	of	IN
5180	1855	23	uncertainty	uncertainty	NN
5180	1855	24	whether	whether	IN
5180	1855	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	1855	26	intended	intend	VBD
5180	1855	27	to	to	TO
5180	1855	28	fund	fund	VB
5180	1855	29	the	the	DT
5180	1855	30	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	1855	31	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	1855	32	Corporation	Corporation	NNP
5180	1855	33	even	even	RB
5180	1855	34	if	if	IN
5180	1855	35	a	a	DT
5180	1855	36	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	1855	37	on	on	IN
5180	1855	38	the	the	DT
5180	1855	39	funding	funding	NN
5180	1855	40	was	be	VBD
5180	1855	41	to	to	TO
5180	1855	42	be	be	VB
5180	1855	43	declared	declare	VBN
5180	1855	44	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1855	45	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1855	46	.	.	.
5180	1856	1	For	for	IN
5180	1856	2	the	the	DT
5180	1856	3	foregoing	foregoing	JJ
5180	1856	4	reasons	reason	NNS
5180	1856	5	,	,	,
5180	1856	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1856	7	will	will	MD
5180	1856	8	enter	enter	VB
5180	1856	9	a	a	DT
5180	1856	10	final	final	JJ
5180	1856	11	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1856	12	declaring	declare	VBG
5180	1856	13	Sections	section	NNS
5180	1856	14	1712(a)(2	1712(a)(2	CD
5180	1856	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1856	16	and	and	CC
5180	1856	17	1721(b	1721(b	CD
5180	1856	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1856	19	of	of	IN
5180	1856	20	the	the	DT
5180	1856	21	Children	Children	NNPS
5180	1856	22	's	's	POS
5180	1856	23	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	1856	24	Protection	Protection	NNP
5180	1856	25	Act	Act	NNP
5180	1856	26	,	,	,
5180	1856	27	codified	codify	VBD
5180	1856	28	at	at	IN
5180	1856	29	20	20	CD
5180	1856	30	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1857	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1857	2	.	.	.
5180	1858	1	9134(f	9134(f	LS
5180	1858	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1858	3	and	and	CC
5180	1858	4	47	47	CD
5180	1858	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1859	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1859	2	.	.	.
5180	1860	1	254(h)(6	254(h)(6	LS
5180	1860	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1860	3	,	,	,
5180	1860	4	respectively	respectively	RB
5180	1860	5	,	,	,
5180	1860	6	to	to	TO
5180	1860	7	be	be	VB
5180	1860	8	facially	facially	RB
5180	1860	9	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1860	10	under	under	IN
5180	1860	11	the	the	DT
5180	1860	12	First	First	NNP
5180	1860	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1860	14	and	and	CC
5180	1860	15	permanently	permanently	RB
5180	1860	16	enjoining	enjoin	VBG
5180	1860	17	the	the	DT
5180	1860	18	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	1860	19	from	from	IN
5180	1860	20	enforcing	enforce	VBG
5180	1860	21	those	those	DT
5180	1860	22	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	1860	23	.	.	.
5180	1861	1	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	2	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	3	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	4	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	5	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	6	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	7	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	8	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	9	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	10	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	11	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	12	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	13	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	14	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	15	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	16	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	17	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	18	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	19	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	20	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	21	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	22	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	23	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	24	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	25	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	26	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	27	_	_	NNP
5180	1861	28	Edward	Edward	NNP
5180	1861	29	R.	R.	NNP
5180	1861	30	Becker	Becker	NNP
5180	1861	31	,	,	,
5180	1861	32	Chief	Chief	NNP
5180	1861	33	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
5180	1861	34	Judge	Judge	NNP
5180	1861	35	IN	in	IN
5180	1861	36	THE	the	DT
5180	1861	37	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
5180	1861	38	STATES	STATES	NNP
5180	1861	39	DISTRICT	district	NN
5180	1861	40	COURT	court	NN
5180	1861	41	FOR	for	IN
5180	1861	42	THE	the	DT
5180	1861	43	EASTERN	EASTERN	NNP
5180	1861	44	DISTRICT	DISTRICT	NNP
5180	1861	45	OF	of	IN
5180	1861	46	PENNSYLVANIA	PENNSYLVANIA	NNP
5180	1861	47	AMERICAN	AMERICAN	NNP
5180	1861	48	LIBRARY	LIBRARY	NNP
5180	1861	49	ASSOCIATION	ASSOCIATION	NNP
5180	1861	50	,	,	,
5180	1861	51	:	:	:
5180	1861	52	CIVIL	CIVIL	NNP
5180	1861	53	ACTION	ACTION	NNP
5180	1861	54	INC	INC	NNP
5180	1861	55	.	.	NNP
5180	1861	56	,	,	,
5180	1861	57	et	et	NNP
5180	1861	58	al	al	NNP
5180	1861	59	.	.	.
5180	1862	1	:	:	:
5180	1862	2	:	:	:
5180	1862	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1862	4	:	:	:
5180	1862	5	:	:	:
5180	1862	6	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
5180	1862	7	STATES	STATES	NNP
5180	1862	8	,	,	,
5180	1862	9	et	et	NNP
5180	1862	10	al	al	NNP
5180	1862	11	.	.	.
5180	1863	1	:	:	:
5180	1863	2	NO	no	UH
5180	1863	3	.	.	.
5180	1864	1	01	01	CD
5180	1864	2	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	3	1303	1303	CD
5180	1864	4	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	5	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	6	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	7	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	8	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	9	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	10	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	11	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	12	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	13	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	14	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	15	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	17	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	19	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	20	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	21	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	22	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	23	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	24	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	25	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	26	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	27	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	28	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	29	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	30	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	31	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	32	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	33	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	34	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	35	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	36	-	-	HYPH
5180	1864	37	MULTNOMAH	multnomah	JJ
5180	1864	38	COUNTY	COUNTY	NNP
5180	1864	39	PUBLIC	PUBLIC	NNS
5180	1864	40	:	:	:
5180	1864	41	CIVIL	civil	NN
5180	1864	42	ACTION	action	NN
5180	1864	43	LIBRARY	LIBRARY	NNP
5180	1864	44	,	,	,
5180	1864	45	et	et	NNP
5180	1864	46	al	al	NNP
5180	1864	47	.	.	.
5180	1865	1	:	:	:
5180	1865	2	:	:	:
5180	1865	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	1865	4	:	:	:
5180	1865	5	:	:	:
5180	1865	6	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
5180	1865	7	STATES	state	NNS
5180	1865	8	OF	of	IN
5180	1865	9	AMERICA	AMERICA	NNP
5180	1865	10	,	,	,
5180	1865	11	et	et	NNP
5180	1865	12	al	al	NNP
5180	1865	13	.	.	.
5180	1866	1	:	:	:
5180	1866	2	NO	no	UH
5180	1866	3	.	.	.
5180	1867	1	01	01	CD
5180	1867	2	-	-	SYM
5180	1867	3	1322	1322	CD
5180	1867	4	ORDER	ORDER	NNP
5180	1867	5	AND	and	CC
5180	1867	6	NOW	now	RB
5180	1867	7	,	,	,
5180	1867	8	this	this	DT
5180	1867	9	day	day	NN
5180	1867	10	of	of	IN
5180	1867	11	May	May	NNP
5180	1867	12	,	,	,
5180	1867	13	2002	2002	CD
5180	1867	14	,	,	,
5180	1867	15	based	base	VBN
5180	1867	16	on	on	IN
5180	1867	17	the	the	DT
5180	1867	18	foregoing	forego	VBG
5180	1867	19	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1867	20	of	of	IN
5180	1867	21	fact	fact	NN
5180	1867	22	and	and	CC
5180	1867	23	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
5180	1867	24	of	of	IN
5180	1867	25	law	law	NN
5180	1867	26	,	,	,
5180	1867	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1867	28	is	be	VBZ
5180	1867	29	hereby	hereby	NNP
5180	1867	30	ORDERED	ORDERED	NNP
5180	1867	31	that	that	DT
5180	1867	32	:	:	:
5180	1867	33	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1867	34	1	1	LS
5180	1867	35	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1867	36	judgment	judgment	NN
5180	1867	37	is	be	VBZ
5180	1867	38	entered	enter	VBN
5180	1867	39	in	in	IN
5180	1867	40	favor	favor	NN
5180	1867	41	of	of	IN
5180	1867	42	the	the	DT
5180	1867	43	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1867	44	and	and	CC
5180	1867	45	against	against	IN
5180	1867	46	the	the	DT
5180	1867	47	defendants	defendant	NNS
5180	1867	48	,	,	,
5180	1867	49	declaring	declare	VBG
5180	1867	50	that	that	IN
5180	1867	51	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1867	52	.	.	.
5180	1867	53	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1867	54	.	.	.
5180	1868	1	1712(a)(2	1712(a)(2	LS
5180	1868	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1868	3	and	and	CC
5180	1868	4	1721(b	1721(b	CD
5180	1868	5	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1868	6	of	of	IN
5180	1868	7	the	the	DT
5180	1868	8	Children	Children	NNPS
5180	1868	9	's	's	POS
5180	1868	10	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	1868	11	Protection	Protection	NNP
5180	1868	12	Act	Act	NNP
5180	1868	13	,	,	,
5180	1868	14	20	20	CD
5180	1868	15	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1869	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1869	2	.	.	.
5180	1870	1	9134(f	9134(f	LS
5180	1870	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1870	3	and	and	CC
5180	1870	4	47	47	CD
5180	1870	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1871	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1871	2	.	.	.
5180	1872	1	254(h)(6	254(h)(6	LS
5180	1872	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1872	3	,	,	,
5180	1872	4	are	be	VBP
5180	1872	5	facially	facially	RB
5180	1872	6	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1872	7	under	under	IN
5180	1872	8	the	the	DT
5180	1872	9	First	First	NNP
5180	1872	10	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1872	11	to	to	IN
5180	1872	12	the	the	DT
5180	1872	13	United	United	NNP
5180	1872	14	States	States	NNP
5180	1872	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
5180	1872	16	;	;	:
5180	1872	17	and	and	CC
5180	1872	18	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1872	19	2	2	LS
5180	1872	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1872	21	the	the	DT
5180	1872	22	United	United	NNP
5180	1872	23	States	States	NNP
5180	1872	24	,	,	,
5180	1872	25	Michael	Michael	NNP
5180	1872	26	Powell	Powell	NNP
5180	1872	27	,	,	,
5180	1872	28	in	in	IN
5180	1872	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1872	30	official	official	JJ
5180	1872	31	capacity	capacity	NN
5180	1872	32	as	as	IN
5180	1872	33	Chairman	Chairman	NNP
5180	1872	34	of	of	IN
5180	1872	35	the	the	DT
5180	1872	36	Federal	Federal	NNP
5180	1872	37	Communications	Communications	NNPS
5180	1872	38	Commission	Commission	NNP
5180	1872	39	,	,	,
5180	1872	40	the	the	DT
5180	1872	41	Federal	Federal	NNP
5180	1872	42	Communications	Communications	NNPS
5180	1872	43	Commission	Commission	NNP
5180	1872	44	,	,	,
5180	1872	45	Beverly	Beverly	NNP
5180	1872	46	Sheppard	Sheppard	NNP
5180	1872	47	,	,	,
5180	1872	48	in	in	IN
5180	1872	49	her	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1872	50	official	official	JJ
5180	1872	51	capacity	capacity	NN
5180	1872	52	as	as	IN
5180	1872	53	Acting	Acting	NNP
5180	1872	54	Director	Director	NNP
5180	1872	55	of	of	IN
5180	1872	56	the	the	DT
5180	1872	57	Institute	Institute	NNP
5180	1872	58	of	of	IN
5180	1872	59	Museum	Museum	NNP
5180	1872	60	and	and	CC
5180	1872	61	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1872	62	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	1872	63	,	,	,
5180	1872	64	and	and	CC
5180	1872	65	the	the	DT
5180	1872	66	Institute	Institute	NNP
5180	1872	67	of	of	IN
5180	1872	68	Museum	Museum	NNP
5180	1872	69	and	and	CC
5180	1872	70	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1872	71	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	1872	72	are	be	VBP
5180	1872	73	permanently	permanently	RB
5180	1872	74	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
5180	1872	75	from	from	IN
5180	1872	76	withholding	withhold	VBG
5180	1872	77	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1872	78	funds	fund	NNS
5180	1872	79	from	from	IN
5180	1872	80	any	any	DT
5180	1872	81	public	public	JJ
5180	1872	82	library	library	NN
5180	1872	83	for	for	IN
5180	1872	84	failure	failure	NN
5180	1872	85	to	to	TO
5180	1872	86	comply	comply	VB
5180	1872	87	with	with	IN
5180	1872	88	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1872	89	.	.	.
5180	1872	90	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1872	91	.	.	.
5180	1873	1	1712(a)(2	1712(a)(2	LS
5180	1873	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1873	3	and	and	CC
5180	1873	4	1721(b	1721(b	CD
5180	1873	5	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1873	6	of	of	IN
5180	1873	7	the	the	DT
5180	1873	8	Children	Children	NNPS
5180	1873	9	's	's	POS
5180	1873	10	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	1873	11	Protection	Protection	NNP
5180	1873	12	Act	Act	NNP
5180	1873	13	,	,	,
5180	1873	14	20	20	CD
5180	1873	15	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1874	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1874	2	.	.	.
5180	1875	1	9134(f	9134(f	LS
5180	1875	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1875	3	and	and	CC
5180	1875	4	47	47	CD
5180	1875	5	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1876	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1876	2	.	.	.
5180	1877	1	254(h)(6	254(h)(6	CD
5180	1877	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1877	3	.	.	.
5180	1878	1	BY	by	IN
5180	1878	2	THE	the	DT
5180	1878	3	COURT	COURT	NNP
5180	1878	4	:	:	:
5180	1878	5	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	6	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	7	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	8	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	9	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	10	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	11	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	12	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	13	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	14	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	15	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	16	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	17	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	18	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	19	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	20	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	21	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	22	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	23	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	24	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	25	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	26	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	27	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	28	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	29	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	30	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	31	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	32	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	33	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	34	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	35	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	36	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	37	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	38	_	_	NNP
5180	1878	39	Ch	Ch	NNP
5180	1878	40	.	.	.
5180	1879	1	Cir	Cir	NNS
5180	1879	2	.	.	.
5180	1880	1	J.	J.	NNP
5180	1881	1	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	2	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	3	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	4	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	5	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	6	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	7	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	8	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	9	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	10	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	11	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	12	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	13	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	14	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	15	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	16	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	17	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	18	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	19	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	20	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	21	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	22	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	23	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	24	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	25	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	26	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	27	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	28	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	29	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	30	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	31	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	32	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	33	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	34	_	_	NNP
5180	1881	35	J.	J.	NNP
5180	1882	1	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	2	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	3	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	4	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	5	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	6	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	7	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	8	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	9	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	10	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	11	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	12	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	13	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	14	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	15	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	16	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	17	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	18	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	19	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	20	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	21	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	22	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	23	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	24	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	25	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	26	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	27	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	28	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	29	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	30	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	31	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	32	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	33	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	34	_	_	NNP
5180	1882	35	J.	J.	NNP
5180	1882	36	FOOTNOTES	FOOTNOTES	NNP
5180	1882	37	Plaintiffs	Plaintiffs	NNPS
5180	1882	38	advance	advance	VBP
5180	1882	39	three	three	CD
5180	1882	40	other	other	JJ
5180	1882	41	alternative	alternative	JJ
5180	1882	42	,	,	,
5180	1882	43	independent	independent	JJ
5180	1882	44	grounds	ground	NNS
5180	1882	45	for	for	IN
5180	1882	46	holding	hold	VBG
5180	1882	47	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	1882	48	facially	facially	RB
5180	1882	49	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1882	50	.	.	.
5180	1883	1	First	first	RB
5180	1883	2	,	,	,
5180	1883	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1883	4	submit	submit	VBP
5180	1883	5	that	that	IN
5180	1883	6	even	even	RB
5180	1883	7	if	if	IN
5180	1883	8	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1883	9	will	will	MD
5180	1883	10	not	not	RB
5180	1883	11	induce	induce	VB
5180	1883	12	public	public	JJ
5180	1883	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1883	14	to	to	TO
5180	1883	15	violate	violate	VB
5180	1883	16	the	the	DT
5180	1883	17	First	First	NNP
5180	1883	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1883	19	,	,	,
5180	1883	20	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1883	21	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	1883	22	imposes	impose	VBZ
5180	1883	23	an	an	DT
5180	1883	24	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	1883	25	condition	condition	NN
5180	1883	26	on	on	IN
5180	1883	27	public	public	JJ
5180	1883	28	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1883	29	by	by	IN
5180	1883	30	requiring	require	VBG
5180	1883	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1883	32	to	to	TO
5180	1883	33	relinquish	relinquish	VB
5180	1883	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1883	35	own	own	JJ
5180	1883	36	First	First	NNP
5180	1883	37	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1883	38	rights	right	NNS
5180	1883	39	to	to	TO
5180	1883	40	provide	provide	VB
5180	1883	41	unfiltered	unfiltered	JJ
5180	1883	42	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1883	43	access	access	NN
5180	1883	44	as	as	IN
5180	1883	45	a	a	DT
5180	1883	46	condition	condition	NN
5180	1883	47	on	on	IN
5180	1883	48	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1883	49	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	1883	50	of	of	IN
5180	1883	51	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1883	52	funds	fund	NNS
5180	1883	53	.	.	.
5180	1884	1	See	see	VB
5180	1884	2	infra	infra	FW
5180	1884	3	n.36	n.36	NN
5180	1884	4	.	.	.
5180	1885	1	Second	second	JJ
5180	1885	2	,	,	,
5180	1885	3	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1885	4	contend	contend	VBP
5180	1885	5	that	that	IN
5180	1885	6	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1885	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	1885	8	facially	facially	RB
5180	1885	9	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	1885	10	because	because	IN
5180	1885	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1885	12	effects	effect	VBZ
5180	1885	13	an	an	DT
5180	1885	14	impermissible	impermissible	JJ
5180	1885	15	prior	prior	JJ
5180	1885	16	restraint	restraint	NN
5180	1885	17	on	on	IN
5180	1885	18	speech	speech	NN
5180	1885	19	by	by	IN
5180	1885	20	granting	grant	VBG
5180	1885	21	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1885	22	companies	company	NNS
5180	1885	23	and	and	CC
5180	1885	24	library	library	JJ
5180	1885	25	staff	staff	NN
5180	1885	26	unfettered	unfettered	JJ
5180	1885	27	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	1885	28	to	to	IN
5180	1885	29	suppress	suppress	VB
5180	1885	30	speech	speech	NN
5180	1885	31	before	before	IN
5180	1885	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1885	33	has	have	VBZ
5180	1885	34	been	be	VBN
5180	1885	35	received	receive	VBN
5180	1885	36	by	by	IN
5180	1885	37	library	library	NN
5180	1885	38	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1885	39	and	and	CC
5180	1885	40	before	before	IN
5180	1885	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1885	42	has	have	VBZ
5180	1885	43	been	be	VBN
5180	1885	44	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1885	45	to	to	IN
5180	1885	46	a	a	DT
5180	1885	47	judicial	judicial	JJ
5180	1885	48	determination	determination	NN
5180	1885	49	that	that	IN
5180	1885	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1885	51	is	be	VBZ
5180	1885	52	unprotected	unprotected	JJ
5180	1885	53	under	under	IN
5180	1885	54	the	the	DT
5180	1885	55	First	First	NNP
5180	1885	56	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	1885	57	.	.	.
5180	1886	1	See	see	VB
5180	1886	2	Southeastern	Southeastern	NNP
5180	1886	3	Promotions	Promotions	NNP
5180	1886	4	,	,	,
5180	1886	5	Ltd.	Ltd.	NNP
5180	1886	6	v.	v.	IN
5180	1886	7	Conrad	Conrad	NNP
5180	1886	8	,	,	,
5180	1886	9	420	420	CD
5180	1886	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1886	11	546	546	CD
5180	1886	12	,	,	,
5180	1886	13	558	558	CD
5180	1886	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1886	15	1975	1975	CD
5180	1886	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1886	17	.	.	.
5180	1887	1	Finally	finally	RB
5180	1887	2	,	,	,
5180	1887	3	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1887	4	submit	submit	VBP
5180	1887	5	that	that	IN
5180	1887	6	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1887	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	1887	8	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	RB
5180	1887	9	vague	vague	JJ
5180	1887	10	.	.	.
5180	1888	1	See	see	VB
5180	1888	2	City	City	NNP
5180	1888	3	of	of	IN
5180	1888	4	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
5180	1888	5	v.	v.	IN
5180	1888	6	Morales	Morales	NNP
5180	1888	7	,	,	,
5180	1888	8	527	527	CD
5180	1888	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	1888	10	41	41	CD
5180	1888	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1888	12	1999	1999	CD
5180	1888	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1888	14	.	.	.
5180	1889	1	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	1889	2	defines	define	NNS
5180	1889	3	"	"	''
5180	1889	4	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1889	5	m]inor	m]inor	NNP
5180	1889	6	"	"	''
5180	1889	7	as	as	IN
5180	1889	8	"	"	``
5180	1889	9	any	any	DT
5180	1889	10	individual	individual	NN
5180	1889	11	who	who	WP
5180	1889	12	has	have	VBZ
5180	1889	13	not	not	RB
5180	1889	14	attained	attain	VBN
5180	1889	15	the	the	DT
5180	1889	16	age	age	NN
5180	1889	17	of	of	IN
5180	1889	18	17	17	CD
5180	1889	19	years	year	NNS
5180	1889	20	.	.	.
5180	1889	21	"	"	''
5180	1890	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1890	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1890	3	.	.	.
5180	1891	1	1721(c	1721(c	LS
5180	1891	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1891	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1891	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1891	5	at	at	IN
5180	1891	6	47	47	CD
5180	1891	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	1892	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1892	2	.	.	.
5180	1893	1	254(h)(7)(D	254(h)(7)(d	LS
5180	1893	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1893	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1893	4	.	.	.
5180	1894	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1894	2	further	further	RB
5180	1894	3	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	1894	4	that	that	IN
5180	1894	5	"	"	``
5180	1894	6	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1894	7	o]bscene	o]bscene	NNP
5180	1894	8	"	"	''
5180	1894	9	has	have	VBZ
5180	1894	10	the	the	DT
5180	1894	11	meaning	meaning	NN
5180	1894	12	given	give	VBN
5180	1894	13	in	in	IN
5180	1894	14	18	18	CD
5180	1894	15	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1895	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1895	2	.	.	.
5180	1896	1	1460	1460	CD
5180	1896	2	,	,	,
5180	1896	3	and	and	CC
5180	1896	4	"	"	``
5180	1896	5	child	child	NN
5180	1896	6	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1896	7	"	"	''
5180	1896	8	has	have	VBZ
5180	1896	9	the	the	DT
5180	1896	10	meaning	meaning	NN
5180	1896	11	given	give	VBN
5180	1896	12	in	in	IN
5180	1896	13	18	18	CD
5180	1896	14	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	1897	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1897	2	.	.	.
5180	1898	1	2256	2256	CD
5180	1898	2	.	.	.
5180	1899	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1899	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1899	3	.	.	.
5180	1900	1	1721(c	1721(c	LS
5180	1900	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1900	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1900	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1900	5	at	at	IN
5180	1900	6	47	47	CD
5180	1900	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	1901	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1901	2	.	.	.
5180	1902	1	254(h)(7)(E	254(h)(7)(e	CD
5180	1902	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1902	3	&	&	CC
5180	1902	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1902	5	F	F	NNP
5180	1902	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1902	7	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1902	8	.	.	.
5180	1903	1	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	1903	2	defines	define	NNS
5180	1903	3	material	material	NN
5180	1903	4	that	that	WDT
5180	1903	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	1903	6	"	"	``
5180	1903	7	harmful	harmful	JJ
5180	1903	8	to	to	IN
5180	1903	9	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1903	10	"	"	''
5180	1903	11	as	as	IN
5180	1903	12	:	:	:
5180	1903	13	any	any	DT
5180	1903	14	picture	picture	NN
5180	1903	15	,	,	,
5180	1903	16	image	image	NN
5180	1903	17	,	,	,
5180	1903	18	graphic	graphic	JJ
5180	1903	19	image	image	NN
5180	1903	20	file	file	NN
5180	1903	21	,	,	,
5180	1903	22	or	or	CC
5180	1903	23	other	other	JJ
5180	1903	24	visual	visual	JJ
5180	1903	25	depiction	depiction	NN
5180	1903	26	that	that	WDT
5180	1903	27	–	–	:
5180	1903	28	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1903	29	i	i	NN
5180	1903	30	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1903	31	taken	take	VBN
5180	1903	32	as	as	IN
5180	1903	33	a	a	DT
5180	1903	34	whole	whole	NN
5180	1903	35	and	and	CC
5180	1903	36	with	with	IN
5180	1903	37	respect	respect	NN
5180	1903	38	to	to	IN
5180	1903	39	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1903	40	,	,	,
5180	1903	41	appeals	appeal	NNS
5180	1903	42	to	to	IN
5180	1903	43	a	a	DT
5180	1903	44	prurient	prurient	JJ
5180	1903	45	interest	interest	NN
5180	1903	46	in	in	IN
5180	1903	47	nudity	nudity	NN
5180	1903	48	,	,	,
5180	1903	49	sex	sex	NN
5180	1903	50	,	,	,
5180	1903	51	or	or	CC
5180	1903	52	excretion	excretion	NN
5180	1903	53	;	;	:
5180	1903	54	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1903	55	ii	ii	NN
5180	1903	56	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1903	57	depicts	depict	VBZ
5180	1903	58	,	,	,
5180	1903	59	describes	describe	NNS
5180	1903	60	,	,	,
5180	1903	61	or	or	CC
5180	1903	62	represents	represent	VBZ
5180	1903	63	,	,	,
5180	1903	64	in	in	IN
5180	1903	65	a	a	DT
5180	1903	66	patently	patently	RB
5180	1903	67	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	1903	68	way	way	NN
5180	1903	69	with	with	IN
5180	1903	70	respect	respect	NN
5180	1903	71	to	to	IN
5180	1903	72	what	what	WP
5180	1903	73	is	be	VBZ
5180	1903	74	suitable	suitable	JJ
5180	1903	75	for	for	IN
5180	1903	76	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1903	77	,	,	,
5180	1903	78	an	an	DT
5180	1903	79	actual	actual	JJ
5180	1903	80	or	or	CC
5180	1903	81	simulated	simulate	VBN
5180	1903	82	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	1903	83	act	act	NN
5180	1903	84	or	or	CC
5180	1903	85	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	1903	86	contact	contact	NN
5180	1903	87	,	,	,
5180	1903	88	actual	actual	JJ
5180	1903	89	or	or	CC
5180	1903	90	simulated	simulate	VBN
5180	1903	91	normal	normal	JJ
5180	1903	92	or	or	CC
5180	1903	93	perverted	pervert	VBD
5180	1903	94	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	1903	95	acts	act	NNS
5180	1903	96	,	,	,
5180	1903	97	or	or	CC
5180	1903	98	a	a	DT
5180	1903	99	lewd	lewd	JJ
5180	1903	100	exhibition	exhibition	NN
5180	1903	101	of	of	IN
5180	1903	102	the	the	DT
5180	1903	103	genitals	genital	NNS
5180	1903	104	;	;	:
5180	1903	105	and	and	CC
5180	1903	106	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1903	107	iii	iii	NN
5180	1903	108	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1903	109	taken	take	VBN
5180	1903	110	as	as	IN
5180	1903	111	a	a	DT
5180	1903	112	whole	whole	NN
5180	1903	113	,	,	,
5180	1903	114	lacks	lack	VBZ
5180	1903	115	serious	serious	JJ
5180	1903	116	literary	literary	JJ
5180	1903	117	,	,	,
5180	1903	118	artistic	artistic	JJ
5180	1903	119	,	,	,
5180	1903	120	political	political	JJ
5180	1903	121	,	,	,
5180	1903	122	or	or	CC
5180	1903	123	scientific	scientific	JJ
5180	1903	124	value	value	NN
5180	1903	125	as	as	IN
5180	1903	126	to	to	IN
5180	1903	127	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1903	128	.	.	.
5180	1904	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1904	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1904	3	.	.	.
5180	1905	1	1721(c	1721(c	LS
5180	1905	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1905	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1905	4	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1905	5	at	at	IN
5180	1905	6	47	47	CD
5180	1905	7	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	1906	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1906	2	.	.	.
5180	1907	1	254(h)(7)(G	254(h)(7)(g	CD
5180	1907	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1907	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1907	4	.	.	.
5180	1908	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1908	2	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
5180	1908	3	federal	federal	JJ
5180	1908	4	interference	interference	NN
5180	1908	5	in	in	IN
5180	1908	6	local	local	JJ
5180	1908	7	determinations	determination	NNS
5180	1908	8	regarding	regard	VBG
5180	1908	9	what	what	WP
5180	1908	10	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1908	11	content	content	NN
5180	1908	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	1908	13	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1908	14	for	for	IN
5180	1908	15	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1908	16	:	:	:
5180	1908	17	A	a	DT
5180	1908	18	determination	determination	NN
5180	1908	19	regarding	regard	VBG
5180	1908	20	what	what	WP
5180	1908	21	matter	matter	NN
5180	1908	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	1908	23	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1908	24	for	for	IN
5180	1908	25	minors	minor	NNS
5180	1908	26	shall	shall	MD
5180	1908	27	be	be	VB
5180	1908	28	made	make	VBN
5180	1908	29	by	by	IN
5180	1908	30	the	the	DT
5180	1908	31	school	school	NN
5180	1908	32	board	board	NN
5180	1908	33	,	,	,
5180	1908	34	local	local	JJ
5180	1908	35	educational	educational	JJ
5180	1908	36	agency	agency	NN
5180	1908	37	,	,	,
5180	1908	38	library	library	NN
5180	1908	39	or	or	CC
5180	1908	40	other	other	JJ
5180	1908	41	authority	authority	NN
5180	1908	42	responsible	responsible	JJ
5180	1908	43	for	for	IN
5180	1908	44	making	make	VBG
5180	1908	45	the	the	DT
5180	1908	46	determination	determination	NN
5180	1908	47	.	.	.
5180	1909	1	No	no	DT
5180	1909	2	agency	agency	NN
5180	1909	3	or	or	CC
5180	1909	4	instrumentality	instrumentality	NN
5180	1909	5	of	of	IN
5180	1909	6	the	the	DT
5180	1909	7	United	United	NNP
5180	1909	8	States	States	NNP
5180	1909	9	Government	Government	NNP
5180	1909	10	may	may	MD
5180	1909	11	–	–	:
5180	1909	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1909	13	A	a	NN
5180	1909	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1909	15	establish	establish	VB
5180	1909	16	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	1909	17	for	for	IN
5180	1909	18	making	make	VBG
5180	1909	19	such	such	JJ
5180	1909	20	determination	determination	NN
5180	1909	21	;	;	,
5180	1909	22	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1909	23	B	b	NN
5180	1909	24	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1909	25	review	review	VB
5180	1909	26	the	the	DT
5180	1909	27	determination	determination	NN
5180	1909	28	made	make	VBN
5180	1909	29	by	by	IN
5180	1909	30	the	the	DT
5180	1909	31	certifying	certifying	NN
5180	1909	32	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1909	33	entity	entity	NN
5180	1909	34	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1909	35	.	.	.
5180	1910	1	.	.	.
5180	1911	1	.	.	.
5180	1912	1	;	;	:
5180	1912	2	or	or	CC
5180	1912	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1912	4	C	C	NNP
5180	1912	5	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1912	6	consider	consider	VB
5180	1912	7	the	the	DT
5180	1912	8	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	1912	9	employed	employ	VBN
5180	1912	10	by	by	IN
5180	1912	11	the	the	DT
5180	1912	12	certifying	certifying	NN
5180	1912	13	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1912	14	entity	entity	NN
5180	1912	15	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1912	16	.	.	.
5180	1913	1	.	.	.
5180	1914	1	.	.	.
5180	1915	1	in	in	IN
5180	1915	2	the	the	DT
5180	1915	3	administration	administration	NN
5180	1915	4	of	of	IN
5180	1915	5	subsection	subsection	NN
5180	1915	6	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1915	7	h)(1)(B	h)(1)(b	UH
5180	1915	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1915	9	.	.	.
5180	1916	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1916	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1916	3	.	.	.
5180	1917	1	1732	1732	CD
5180	1917	2	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1917	3	codified	codify	VBN
5180	1917	4	at	at	IN
5180	1917	5	47	47	CD
5180	1917	6	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNP
5180	1918	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1918	2	.	.	.
5180	1919	1	254(l)(2	254(l)(2	NNP
5180	1919	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1919	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1919	4	.	.	.
5180	1920	1	The	the	DT
5180	1920	2	government	government	NN
5180	1920	3	challenges	challenge	VBZ
5180	1920	4	the	the	DT
5180	1920	5	standing	standing	NN
5180	1920	6	of	of	IN
5180	1920	7	several	several	JJ
5180	1920	8	of	of	IN
5180	1920	9	the	the	DT
5180	1920	10	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1920	11	and	and	CC
5180	1920	12	the	the	DT
5180	1920	13	ripeness	ripeness	NN
5180	1920	14	of	of	IN
5180	1920	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1920	16	claims	claim	NNS
5180	1920	17	.	.	.
5180	1921	1	These	these	DT
5180	1921	2	include	include	VBP
5180	1921	3	all	all	DT
5180	1921	4	of	of	IN
5180	1921	5	the	the	DT
5180	1921	6	Web	web	NN
5180	1921	7	site	site	NN
5180	1921	8	publishers	publisher	NNS
5180	1921	9	and	and	CC
5180	1921	10	all	all	DT
5180	1921	11	of	of	IN
5180	1921	12	the	the	DT
5180	1921	13	individual	individual	JJ
5180	1921	14	library	library	NN
5180	1921	15	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1921	16	.	.	.
5180	1922	1	Notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
5180	1922	2	these	these	DT
5180	1922	3	objections	objection	NNS
5180	1922	4	,	,	,
5180	1922	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1922	6	are	be	VBP
5180	1922	7	confident	confident	JJ
5180	1922	8	that	that	IN
5180	1922	9	the	the	DT
5180	1922	10	"	"	``
5180	1922	11	case	case	NN
5180	1922	12	or	or	CC
5180	1922	13	controversy	controversy	NN
5180	1922	14	"	"	''
5180	1922	15	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	1922	16	of	of	IN
5180	1922	17	Article	Article	NNP
5180	1922	18	III	III	NNP
5180	1922	19	,	,	,
5180	1922	20	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1922	21	.	.	.
5180	1923	1	2	2	CD
5180	1923	2	of	of	IN
5180	1923	3	the	the	DT
5180	1923	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
5180	1923	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	1923	6	met	meet	VBN
5180	1923	7	by	by	IN
5180	1923	8	the	the	DT
5180	1923	9	existence	existence	NN
5180	1923	10	of	of	IN
5180	1923	11	the	the	DT
5180	1923	12	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
5180	1923	13	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1923	14	that	that	WDT
5180	1923	15	qualify	qualify	VBP
5180	1923	16	for	for	IN
5180	1923	17	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	1923	18	and	and	CC
5180	1923	19	E	e	NN
5180	1923	20	-	-	NN
5180	1923	21	rate	rate	NN
5180	1923	22	funding	funding	NN
5180	1923	23	and	and	CC
5180	1923	24	the	the	DT
5180	1923	25	library	library	NN
5180	1923	26	associations	association	NNS
5180	1923	27	whose	whose	WP$
5180	1923	28	members	member	NNS
5180	1923	29	qualify	qualify	VBP
5180	1923	30	for	for	IN
5180	1923	31	such	such	JJ
5180	1923	32	funding	funding	NN
5180	1923	33	.	.	.
5180	1924	1	These	these	DT
5180	1924	2	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1924	3	are	be	VBP
5180	1924	4	faced	face	VBN
5180	1924	5	with	with	IN
5180	1924	6	the	the	DT
5180	1924	7	impending	impending	JJ
5180	1924	8	choice	choice	NN
5180	1924	9	of	of	IN
5180	1924	10	either	either	DT
5180	1924	11	certifying	certify	VBG
5180	1924	12	compliance	compliance	NN
5180	1924	13	with	with	IN
5180	1924	14	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	1924	15	by	by	IN
5180	1924	16	July	July	NNP
5180	1924	17	1	1	CD
5180	1924	18	,	,	,
5180	1924	19	2002	2002	CD
5180	1924	20	,	,	,
5180	1924	21	or	or	CC
5180	1924	22	foregoing	forego	VBG
5180	1924	23	subsidies	subsidy	NNS
5180	1924	24	under	under	IN
5180	1924	25	the	the	DT
5180	1924	26	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	1924	27	and	and	CC
5180	1924	28	E	e	NN
5180	1924	29	-	-	HYPH
5180	1924	30	rate	rate	NN
5180	1924	31	programs	program	NNS
5180	1924	32	,	,	,
5180	1924	33	and	and	CC
5180	1924	34	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	1924	35	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	1924	36	have	have	VBP
5180	1924	37	standing	stand	VBG
5180	1924	38	to	to	TO
5180	1924	39	challenge	challenge	VB
5180	1924	40	the	the	DT
5180	1924	41	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
5180	1924	42	of	of	IN
5180	1924	43	the	the	DT
5180	1924	44	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	1924	45	to	to	TO
5180	1924	46	which	which	WDT
5180	1924	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1924	48	will	will	MD
5180	1924	49	be	be	VB
5180	1924	50	subject	subject	JJ
5180	1924	51	should	should	MD
5180	1924	52	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1924	53	accept	accept	VB
5180	1924	54	the	the	DT
5180	1924	55	subsidies	subsidy	NNS
5180	1924	56	.	.	.
5180	1925	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1925	2	also	also	RB
5180	1925	3	note	note	VBP
5180	1925	4	that	that	IN
5180	1925	5	the	the	DT
5180	1925	6	presence	presence	NN
5180	1925	7	of	of	IN
5180	1925	8	the	the	DT
5180	1925	9	Web	web	NN
5180	1925	10	site	site	NN
5180	1925	11	publishers	publisher	NNS
5180	1925	12	and	and	CC
5180	1925	13	individual	individual	JJ
5180	1925	14	library	library	NN
5180	1925	15	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1925	16	does	do	VBZ
5180	1925	17	not	not	RB
5180	1925	18	affect	affect	VB
5180	1925	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1925	20	legal	legal	JJ
5180	1925	21	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	1925	22	or	or	CC
5180	1925	23	disposition	disposition	NN
5180	1925	24	of	of	IN
5180	1925	25	the	the	DT
5180	1925	26	case	case	NN
5180	1925	27	.	.	.
5180	1926	1	The	the	DT
5180	1926	2	OCLC	oclc	NN
5180	1926	3	database	database	NN
5180	1926	4	,	,	,
5180	1926	5	a	a	DT
5180	1926	6	cooperative	cooperative	JJ
5180	1926	7	cataloging	catalog	VBG
5180	1926	8	service	service	NN
5180	1926	9	established	establish	VBN
5180	1926	10	to	to	TO
5180	1926	11	facilitate	facilitate	VB
5180	1926	12	interlibrary	interlibrary	JJ
5180	1926	13	loan	loan	NN
5180	1926	14	requests	request	NNS
5180	1926	15	,	,	,
5180	1926	16	includes	include	VBZ
5180	1926	17	40	40	CD
5180	1926	18	million	million	CD
5180	1926	19	catalog	catalog	NN
5180	1926	20	records	record	NNS
5180	1926	21	from	from	IN
5180	1926	22	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	1926	23	48,000	48,000	CD
5180	1926	24	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1926	25	of	of	IN
5180	1926	26	all	all	DT
5180	1926	27	types	type	NNS
5180	1926	28	worldwide	worldwide	RB
5180	1926	29	.	.	.
5180	1927	1	Slightly	slightly	RB
5180	1927	2	more	more	JJR
5180	1927	3	than	than	IN
5180	1927	4	400	400	CD
5180	1927	5	of	of	IN
5180	1927	6	the	the	DT
5180	1927	7	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1927	8	in	in	IN
5180	1927	9	the	the	DT
5180	1927	10	OCLC	oclc	NN
5180	1927	11	database	database	NN
5180	1927	12	are	be	VBP
5180	1927	13	listed	list	VBN
5180	1927	14	as	as	IN
5180	1927	15	carrying	carry	VBG
5180	1927	16	Playboy	Playboy	NNP
5180	1927	17	in	in	IN
5180	1927	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1927	19	collections	collection	NNS
5180	1927	20	,	,	,
5180	1927	21	while	while	IN
5180	1927	22	only	only	RB
5180	1927	23	eight	eight	CD
5180	1927	24	subscribe	subscribe	NN
5180	1927	25	to	to	IN
5180	1927	26	Hustler	Hustler	NNP
5180	1927	27	.	.	.
5180	1928	1	Fort	Fort	NNP
5180	1928	2	Vancouver	Vancouver	NNP
5180	1928	3	Regional	Regional	NNP
5180	1928	4	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1928	5	,	,	,
5180	1928	6	for	for	IN
5180	1928	7	example	example	NN
5180	1928	8	,	,	,
5180	1928	9	combines	combine	VBZ
5180	1928	10	the	the	DT
5180	1928	11	methods	method	NNS
5180	1928	12	of	of	IN
5180	1928	13	strategically	strategically	RB
5180	1928	14	placing	place	VBG
5180	1928	15	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1928	16	in	in	IN
5180	1928	17	low	low	JJ
5180	1928	18	traffic	traffic	NN
5180	1928	19	areas	area	NNS
5180	1928	20	and	and	CC
5180	1928	21	using	use	VBG
5180	1928	22	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1928	23	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1928	24	.	.	.
5180	1929	1	A	a	DT
5180	1929	2	section	section	NN
5180	1929	3	headed	head	VBN
5180	1929	4	"	"	``
5180	1929	5	Confidentiality	Confidentiality	NNP
5180	1929	6	and	and	CC
5180	1929	7	Privacy	Privacy	NNP
5180	1929	8	"	"	''
5180	1929	9	on	on	IN
5180	1929	10	the	the	DT
5180	1929	11	library	library	NN
5180	1929	12	's	's	POS
5180	1929	13	home	home	NN
5180	1929	14	page	page	NN
5180	1929	15	states	state	NNS
5180	1929	16	:	:	:
5180	1929	17	"	"	``
5180	1929	18	in	in	IN
5180	1929	19	order	order	NN
5180	1929	20	to	to	TO
5180	1929	21	protect	protect	VB
5180	1929	22	the	the	DT
5180	1929	23	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1929	24	of	of	IN
5180	1929	25	the	the	DT
5180	1929	26	user	user	NN
5180	1929	27	and	and	CC
5180	1929	28	the	the	DT
5180	1929	29	interests	interest	NNS
5180	1929	30	of	of	IN
5180	1929	31	other	other	JJ
5180	1929	32	library	library	NN
5180	1929	33	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1929	34	,	,	,
5180	1929	35	the	the	DT
5180	1929	36	library	library	NN
5180	1929	37	will	will	MD
5180	1929	38	attempt	attempt	VB
5180	1929	39	to	to	TO
5180	1929	40	minimize	minimize	VB
5180	1929	41	unintentional	unintentional	JJ
5180	1929	42	viewing	viewing	NN
5180	1929	43	of	of	IN
5180	1929	44	the	the	DT
5180	1929	45	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1929	46	.	.	.
5180	1930	1	This	this	DT
5180	1930	2	will	will	MD
5180	1930	3	be	be	VB
5180	1930	4	done	do	VBN
5180	1930	5	by	by	IN
5180	1930	6	use	use	NN
5180	1930	7	of	of	IN
5180	1930	8	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	1930	9	screens	screen	NNS
5180	1930	10	,	,	,
5180	1930	11	and	and	CC
5180	1930	12	by	by	IN
5180	1930	13	judicious	judicious	JJ
5180	1930	14	placement	placement	NN
5180	1930	15	of	of	IN
5180	1930	16	the	the	DT
5180	1930	17	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	1930	18	and	and	CC
5180	1930	19	other	other	JJ
5180	1930	20	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1930	21	means	mean	NNS
5180	1930	22	.	.	.
5180	1930	23	"	"	''
5180	1931	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	1931	2	,	,	,
5180	1931	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1931	4	granted	grant	VBD
5180	1931	5	leave	leave	NN
5180	1931	6	for	for	IN
5180	1931	7	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	1931	8	's	's	POS
5180	1931	9	counsel	counsel	NN
5180	1931	10	to	to	TO
5180	1931	11	intervene	intervene	VB
5180	1931	12	in	in	IN
5180	1931	13	order	order	NN
5180	1931	14	to	to	TO
5180	1931	15	object	object	VB
5180	1931	16	to	to	IN
5180	1931	17	testimony	testimony	NN
5180	1931	18	that	that	WDT
5180	1931	19	would	would	MD
5180	1931	20	potentially	potentially	RB
5180	1931	21	reveal	reveal	VB
5180	1931	22	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	1931	23	's	's	POS
5180	1931	24	trade	trade	NN
5180	1931	25	secrets	secret	NNS
5180	1931	26	,	,	,
5180	1931	27	which	which	WDT
5180	1931	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1931	29	did	do	VBD
5180	1931	30	on	on	IN
5180	1931	31	several	several	JJ
5180	1931	32	occasions	occasion	NNS
5180	1931	33	.	.	.
5180	1932	1	Geoffrey	Geoffrey	NNP
5180	1932	2	Nunberg	Nunberg	NNP
5180	1932	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1932	4	Ph.D.	Ph.D.	NNP
5180	1932	5	,	,	,
5180	1932	6	Linguistics	Linguistics	NNP
5180	1932	7	,	,	,
5180	1932	8	C.U.N.Y.	C.U.N.Y.	NNP
5180	1933	1	1977	1977	CD
5180	1933	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1933	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	1933	4	a	a	DT
5180	1933	5	researcher	researcher	NN
5180	1933	6	at	at	IN
5180	1933	7	the	the	DT
5180	1933	8	Center	Center	NNP
5180	1933	9	for	for	IN
5180	1933	10	the	the	DT
5180	1933	11	Study	Study	NNP
5180	1933	12	of	of	IN
5180	1933	13	Language	Language	NNP
5180	1933	14	and	and	CC
5180	1933	15	Information	Information	NNP
5180	1933	16	at	at	IN
5180	1933	17	Stanford	Stanford	NNP
5180	1933	18	University	University	NNP
5180	1933	19	and	and	CC
5180	1933	20	a	a	DT
5180	1933	21	Consulting	Consulting	NNP
5180	1933	22	Full	full	JJ
5180	1933	23	Professor	professor	NN
5180	1933	24	of	of	IN
5180	1933	25	Linguistics	Linguistics	NNP
5180	1933	26	at	at	IN
5180	1933	27	Stanford	Stanford	NNP
5180	1933	28	University	University	NNP
5180	1933	29	.	.	.
5180	1934	1	Until	until	IN
5180	1934	2	2001	2001	CD
5180	1934	3	,	,	,
5180	1934	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1934	5	was	be	VBD
5180	1934	6	also	also	RB
5180	1934	7	a	a	DT
5180	1934	8	principal	principal	JJ
5180	1934	9	scientist	scientist	NN
5180	1934	10	at	at	IN
5180	1934	11	the	the	DT
5180	1934	12	Xerox	Xerox	NNP
5180	1934	13	Palo	Palo	NNP
5180	1934	14	Alto	Alto	NNP
5180	1934	15	Research	Research	NNP
5180	1934	16	Center	Center	NNP
5180	1934	17	.	.	.
5180	1935	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1935	2	research	research	NN
5180	1935	3	centers	center	VBZ
5180	1935	4	on	on	IN
5180	1935	5	automated	automated	JJ
5180	1935	6	classification	classification	NN
5180	1935	7	systems	system	NNS
5180	1935	8	,	,	,
5180	1935	9	with	with	IN
5180	1935	10	a	a	DT
5180	1935	11	focus	focus	NN
5180	1935	12	on	on	IN
5180	1935	13	classifying	classify	VBG
5180	1935	14	documents	document	NNS
5180	1935	15	on	on	IN
5180	1935	16	the	the	DT
5180	1935	17	Web	web	NN
5180	1935	18	with	with	IN
5180	1935	19	respect	respect	NN
5180	1935	20	to	to	IN
5180	1935	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1935	22	linguistic	linguistic	JJ
5180	1935	23	properties	property	NNS
5180	1935	24	.	.	.
5180	1936	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1936	2	has	have	VBZ
5180	1936	3	published	publish	VBN
5180	1936	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1936	5	research	research	NN
5180	1936	6	in	in	IN
5180	1936	7	numerous	numerous	JJ
5180	1936	8	professional	professional	JJ
5180	1936	9	journals	journal	NNS
5180	1936	10	,	,	,
5180	1936	11	including	include	VBG
5180	1936	12	peer-	peer-	NN
5180	1936	13	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	1936	14	journals	journal	NNS
5180	1936	15	.	.	.
5180	1937	1	A	a	DT
5180	1937	2	"	"	``
5180	1937	3	cookie	cookie	NN
5180	1937	4	"	"	''
5180	1937	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	1937	6	"	"	``
5180	1937	7	a	a	DT
5180	1937	8	small	small	JJ
5180	1937	9	file	file	NN
5180	1937	10	or	or	CC
5180	1937	11	part	part	NN
5180	1937	12	of	of	IN
5180	1937	13	a	a	DT
5180	1937	14	file	file	NN
5180	1937	15	stored	store	VBN
5180	1937	16	on	on	IN
5180	1937	17	a	a	DT
5180	1937	18	World	World	NNP
5180	1937	19	Wide	Wide	NNP
5180	1937	20	Web	web	NN
5180	1937	21	user	user	NN
5180	1937	22	's	's	POS
5180	1937	23	computer	computer	NN
5180	1937	24	,	,	,
5180	1937	25	created	create	VBN
5180	1937	26	and	and	CC
5180	1937	27	subsequently	subsequently	RB
5180	1937	28	read	read	VBN
5180	1937	29	by	by	IN
5180	1937	30	a	a	DT
5180	1937	31	Web	web	NN
5180	1937	32	site	site	NN
5180	1937	33	server	server	NN
5180	1937	34	,	,	,
5180	1937	35	and	and	CC
5180	1937	36	containing	contain	VBG
5180	1937	37	personal	personal	JJ
5180	1937	38	information	information	NN
5180	1937	39	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1937	40	as	as	IN
5180	1937	41	a	a	DT
5180	1937	42	user	user	NN
5180	1937	43	identification	identification	NN
5180	1937	44	code	code	NN
5180	1937	45	,	,	,
5180	1937	46	customized	customized	JJ
5180	1937	47	preferences	preference	NNS
5180	1937	48	,	,	,
5180	1937	49	or	or	CC
5180	1937	50	a	a	DT
5180	1937	51	record	record	NN
5180	1937	52	of	of	IN
5180	1937	53	pages	page	NNS
5180	1937	54	visited	visit	VBN
5180	1937	55	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1937	56	.	.	.
5180	1937	57	"	"	''
5180	1938	1	Merriam	Merriam	NNP
5180	1938	2	-	-	HYPH
5180	1938	3	Webster	Webster	NNP
5180	1938	4	's	's	POS
5180	1938	5	Collegiate	Collegiate	NNP
5180	1938	6	Dictionary	Dictionary	NNP
5180	1938	7	,	,	,
5180	1938	8	available	available	JJ
5180	1938	9	at	at	IN
5180	1938	10	http://www.m-w.com/dictionary.htm	http://www.m-w.com/dictionary.htm	ADD
5180	1938	11	.	.	.
5180	1939	1	Hunter	Hunter	NNP
5180	1939	2	drew	draw	VBD
5180	1939	3	three	three	CD
5180	1939	4	different	different	JJ
5180	1939	5	"	"	``
5180	1939	6	samples	sample	NNS
5180	1939	7	"	"	''
5180	1939	8	for	for	IN
5180	1939	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1939	10	test	test	NN
5180	1939	11	.	.	.
5180	1940	1	The	the	DT
5180	1940	2	first	first	JJ
5180	1940	3	consisted	consist	VBN
5180	1940	4	of	of	IN
5180	1940	5	"	"	``
5180	1940	6	50	50	CD
5180	1940	7	randomly	randomly	RB
5180	1940	8	generated	generate	VBN
5180	1940	9	Web	web	NN
5180	1940	10	pages	page	NNS
5180	1940	11	from	from	IN
5180	1940	12	the	the	DT
5180	1940	13	Webcrawler	Webcrawler	NNP
5180	1940	14	search	search	NN
5180	1940	15	engine	engine	NN
5180	1940	16	.	.	.
5180	1940	17	"	"	''
5180	1941	1	The	the	DT
5180	1941	2	"	"	``
5180	1941	3	second	second	JJ
5180	1941	4	sample	sample	NN
5180	1941	5	of	of	IN
5180	1941	6	50	50	CD
5180	1941	7	Web	web	NN
5180	1941	8	pages	page	NNS
5180	1941	9	was	be	VBD
5180	1941	10	drawn	draw	VBN
5180	1941	11	from	from	IN
5180	1941	12	searches	search	NNS
5180	1941	13	for	for	IN
5180	1941	14	the	the	DT
5180	1941	15	terms	term	NNS
5180	1941	16	'	'	POS
5180	1941	17	yahoo	yahoo	NNP
5180	1941	18	,	,	,
5180	1941	19	warez	warez	NNP
5180	1941	20	,	,	,
5180	1941	21	hotmail	hotmail	NN
5180	1941	22	,	,	,
5180	1941	23	sex	sex	NN
5180	1941	24	,	,	,
5180	1941	25	and	and	CC
5180	1941	26	MP3	mp3	NN
5180	1941	27	,	,	,
5180	1941	28	'	'	''
5180	1941	29	using	use	VBG
5180	1941	30	the	the	DT
5180	1941	31	AltaVista.com	altavista.com	ADD
5180	1941	32	search	search	NN
5180	1941	33	engine	engine	NN
5180	1941	34	.	.	.
5180	1941	35	"	"	''
5180	1942	1	And	and	CC
5180	1942	2	the	the	DT
5180	1942	3	"	"	``
5180	1942	4	final	final	JJ
5180	1942	5	sample	sample	NN
5180	1942	6	of	of	IN
5180	1942	7	100	100	CD
5180	1942	8	Web	web	NN
5180	1942	9	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	10	was	be	VBD
5180	1942	11	drawn	draw	VBN
5180	1942	12	from	from	IN
5180	1942	13	the	the	DT
5180	1942	14	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	15	of	of	IN
5180	1942	16	organizations	organization	NNS
5180	1942	17	who	who	WP
5180	1942	18	filed	file	VBD
5180	1942	19	amicus	amicus	JJ
5180	1942	20	briefs	brief	NNS
5180	1942	21	in	in	IN
5180	1942	22	support	support	NN
5180	1942	23	of	of	IN
5180	1942	24	the	the	DT
5180	1942	25	ACLU	ACLU	NNP
5180	1942	26	's	's	POS
5180	1942	27	challenges	challenge	NNS
5180	1942	28	to	to	IN
5180	1942	29	the	the	DT
5180	1942	30	Community	Community	NNP
5180	1942	31	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1942	32	sic	sic	NN
5180	1942	33	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1942	34	Decency	Decency	NNP
5180	1942	35	Act	Act	NNP
5180	1942	36	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1942	37	CDA	CDA	NNP
5180	1942	38	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1942	39	and	and	CC
5180	1942	40	COPA	COPA	NNP
5180	1942	41	[	[	-LRB-
5180	1942	42	the	the	DT
5180	1942	43	Children	Children	NNPS
5180	1942	44	's	's	POS
5180	1942	45	Online	Online	NNP
5180	1942	46	Protection	Protection	NNP
5180	1942	47	Act	Act	NNP
5180	1942	48	]	]	-RRB-
5180	1942	49	,	,	,
5180	1942	50	and	and	CC
5180	1942	51	from	from	IN
5180	1942	52	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1942	53	portals	portal	NNS
5180	1942	54	,	,	,
5180	1942	55	political	political	JJ
5180	1942	56	Web	web	NN
5180	1942	57	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	58	,	,	,
5180	1942	59	feminist	feminist	JJ
5180	1942	60	Web	web	NN
5180	1942	61	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	62	,	,	,
5180	1942	63	hate	hate	NN
5180	1942	64	speech	speech	NN
5180	1942	65	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	66	,	,	,
5180	1942	67	gambling	gambling	NN
5180	1942	68	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	69	,	,	,
5180	1942	70	religious	religious	JJ
5180	1942	71	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	72	,	,	,
5180	1942	73	gay	gay	JJ
5180	1942	74	pride	pride	NN
5180	1942	75	/	/	SYM
5180	1942	76	homosexual	homosexual	JJ
5180	1942	77	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	78	,	,	,
5180	1942	79	alcohol	alcohol	NN
5180	1942	80	,	,	,
5180	1942	81	tobacco	tobacco	NN
5180	1942	82	,	,	,
5180	1942	83	and	and	CC
5180	1942	84	drug	drug	NN
5180	1942	85	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	86	,	,	,
5180	1942	87	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1942	88	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	89	,	,	,
5180	1942	90	new	new	JJ
5180	1942	91	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	92	,	,	,
5180	1942	93	violent	violent	JJ
5180	1942	94	game	game	NN
5180	1942	95	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	96	,	,	,
5180	1942	97	safe	safe	JJ
5180	1942	98	sex	sex	NN
5180	1942	99	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	100	,	,	,
5180	1942	101	and	and	CC
5180	1942	102	pro	pro	JJ
5180	1942	103	and	and	CC
5180	1942	104	anti	anti	JJ
5180	1942	105	-	-	JJ
5180	1942	106	abortion	abortion	JJ
5180	1942	107	sites	site	NNS
5180	1942	108	listed	list	VBN
5180	1942	109	on	on	IN
5180	1942	110	the	the	DT
5180	1942	111	popular	popular	JJ
5180	1942	112	Web	web	NN
5180	1942	113	directory	directory	NN
5180	1942	114	,	,	,
5180	1942	115	Yahoo.com	Yahoo.com	NNP
5180	1942	116	.	.	.
5180	1942	117	"	"	''
5180	1943	1	Lemmons	lemmon	NNS
5180	1943	2	testified	testify	VBD
5180	1943	3	that	that	IN
5180	1943	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1943	5	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	1943	6	the	the	DT
5180	1943	7	list	list	NN
5180	1943	8	of	of	IN
5180	1943	9	sexually	sexually	RB
5180	1943	10	explicit	explicit	JJ
5180	1943	11	sites	site	NNS
5180	1943	12	that	that	WDT
5180	1943	13	should	should	MD
5180	1943	14	have	have	VB
5180	1943	15	been	be	VBN
5180	1943	16	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1943	17	by	by	IN
5180	1943	18	entering	enter	VBG
5180	1943	19	the	the	DT
5180	1943	20	terms	term	NNS
5180	1943	21	"	"	``
5180	1943	22	free	free	JJ
5180	1943	23	adult	adult	NN
5180	1943	24	sex	sex	NN
5180	1943	25	,	,	,
5180	1943	26	anal	anal	JJ
5180	1943	27	sex	sex	NN
5180	1943	28	,	,	,
5180	1943	29	oral	oral	JJ
5180	1943	30	sex	sex	NN
5180	1943	31	,	,	,
5180	1943	32	fisting	fiste	VBG
5180	1943	33	lesbians	lesbian	NNS
5180	1943	34	,	,	,
5180	1943	35	gay	gay	JJ
5180	1943	36	sex	sex	NN
5180	1943	37	,	,	,
5180	1943	38	interracial	interracial	JJ
5180	1943	39	sex	sex	NN
5180	1943	40	,	,	,
5180	1943	41	big	big	JJ
5180	1943	42	tits	tit	NNS
5180	1943	43	,	,	,
5180	1943	44	blow	blow	VB
5180	1943	45	job	job	NN
5180	1943	46	,	,	,
5180	1943	47	shaved	shave	VBD
5180	1943	48	pussy	pussy	JJ
5180	1943	49	,	,	,
5180	1943	50	and	and	CC
5180	1943	51	bondage	bondage	VB
5180	1943	52	"	"	''
5180	1943	53	into	into	IN
5180	1943	54	the	the	DT
5180	1943	55	Google	Google	NNP
5180	1943	56	search	search	NN
5180	1943	57	engine	engine	NN
5180	1943	58	and	and	CC
5180	1943	59	then	then	RB
5180	1943	60	"	"	``
5180	1943	61	surfing	surf	VBG
5180	1943	62	"	"	''
5180	1943	63	through	through	IN
5180	1943	64	links	link	NNS
5180	1943	65	from	from	IN
5180	1943	66	pages	page	NNS
5180	1943	67	generated	generate	VBN
5180	1943	68	by	by	IN
5180	1943	69	the	the	DT
5180	1943	70	list	list	NN
5180	1943	71	of	of	IN
5180	1943	72	sites	site	NNS
5180	1943	73	that	that	IN
5180	1943	74	the	the	DT
5180	1943	75	search	search	NN
5180	1943	76	engine	engine	NN
5180	1943	77	returned	return	VBD
5180	1943	78	.	.	.
5180	1944	1	Using	use	VBG
5180	1944	2	this	this	DT
5180	1944	3	method	method	NN
5180	1944	4	,	,	,
5180	1944	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1944	6	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	1944	7	a	a	DT
5180	1944	8	list	list	NN
5180	1944	9	of	of	IN
5180	1944	10	197	197	CD
5180	1944	11	sites	site	NNS
5180	1944	12	that	that	WDT
5180	1944	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1944	14	determined	determine	VBD
5180	1944	15	should	should	MD
5180	1944	16	be	be	VB
5180	1944	17	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1944	18	according	accord	VBG
5180	1944	19	to	to	IN
5180	1944	20	the	the	DT
5180	1944	21	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	1944	22	programs	program	NNS
5180	1944	23	'	'	POS
5180	1944	24	category	category	NN
5180	1944	25	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	1944	26	.	.	.
5180	1945	1	Lemmons	lemmon	NNS
5180	1945	2	also	also	RB
5180	1945	3	attempted	attempt	VBD
5180	1945	4	to	to	TO
5180	1945	5	compile	compile	VB
5180	1945	6	a	a	DT
5180	1945	7	list	list	NN
5180	1945	8	of	of	IN
5180	1945	9	"	"	``
5180	1945	10	sensitive	sensitive	JJ
5180	1945	11	"	"	''
5180	1945	12	Web	web	NN
5180	1945	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	1945	14	that	that	WDT
5180	1945	15	,	,	,
5180	1945	16	although	although	IN
5180	1945	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1945	18	should	should	MD
5180	1945	19	not	not	RB
5180	1945	20	have	have	VB
5180	1945	21	been	be	VBN
5180	1945	22	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1945	23	according	accord	VBG
5180	1945	24	to	to	IN
5180	1945	25	the	the	DT
5180	1945	26	filtering	filtering	NN
5180	1945	27	programs	program	NNS
5180	1945	28	'	'	POS
5180	1945	29	category	category	NN
5180	1945	30	definitions	definition	NNS
5180	1945	31	,	,	,
5180	1945	32	might	may	MD
5180	1945	33	have	have	VB
5180	1945	34	been	be	VBN
5180	1945	35	mistakenly	mistakenly	RB
5180	1945	36	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1945	37	.	.	.
5180	1946	1	In	in	IN
5180	1946	2	order	order	NN
5180	1946	3	to	to	TO
5180	1946	4	do	do	VB
5180	1946	5	this	this	DT
5180	1946	6	,	,	,
5180	1946	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1946	8	used	use	VBD
5180	1946	9	the	the	DT
5180	1946	10	same	same	JJ
5180	1946	11	method	method	NN
5180	1946	12	of	of	IN
5180	1946	13	entering	enter	VBG
5180	1946	14	terms	term	NNS
5180	1946	15	into	into	IN
5180	1946	16	the	the	DT
5180	1946	17	Google	Google	NNP
5180	1946	18	search	search	NN
5180	1946	19	engine	engine	NN
5180	1946	20	and	and	CC
5180	1946	21	surfing	surf	VBG
5180	1946	22	through	through	IN
5180	1946	23	the	the	DT
5180	1946	24	results	result	NNS
5180	1946	25	.	.	.
5180	1947	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1947	2	used	use	VBD
5180	1947	3	the	the	DT
5180	1947	4	following	follow	VBG
5180	1947	5	terms	term	NNS
5180	1947	6	to	to	TO
5180	1947	7	compile	compile	VB
5180	1947	8	this	this	DT
5180	1947	9	list	list	NN
5180	1947	10	:	:	:
5180	1947	11	"	"	``
5180	1947	12	breast	breast	NN
5180	1947	13	feeding	feeding	NN
5180	1947	14	,	,	,
5180	1947	15	bondages	bondage	NNS
5180	1947	16	,	,	,
5180	1947	17	fetishes	fetish	NNS
5180	1947	18	,	,	,
5180	1947	19	ebony	ebony	NN
5180	1947	20	,	,	,
5180	1947	21	gay	gay	JJ
5180	1947	22	issues	issue	NNS
5180	1947	23	,	,	,
5180	1947	24	women	woman	NNS
5180	1947	25	's	's	POS
5180	1947	26	health	health	NN
5180	1947	27	,	,	,
5180	1947	28	lesbian	lesbian	JJ
5180	1947	29	,	,	,
5180	1947	30	homosexual	homosexual	JJ
5180	1947	31	,	,	,
5180	1947	32	vagina	vagina	NNP
5180	1947	33	,	,	,
5180	1947	34	vaginal	vaginal	JJ
5180	1947	35	dryness	dryness	NN
5180	1947	36	,	,	,
5180	1947	37	pain	pain	NN
5180	1947	38	,	,	,
5180	1947	39	anal	anal	JJ
5180	1947	40	cancer	cancer	NN
5180	1947	41	,	,	,
5180	1947	42	teen	teen	NN
5180	1947	43	issues	issue	NNS
5180	1947	44	,	,	,
5180	1947	45	safe	safe	JJ
5180	1947	46	sex	sex	NN
5180	1947	47	,	,	,
5180	1947	48	penis	penis	NN
5180	1947	49	,	,	,
5180	1947	50	pregnant	pregnant	JJ
5180	1947	51	,	,	,
5180	1947	52	interracial	interracial	JJ
5180	1947	53	,	,	,
5180	1947	54	sex	sex	NN
5180	1947	55	education	education	NN
5180	1947	56	,	,	,
5180	1947	57	penis	penis	NN
5180	1947	58	enlargement	enlargement	NN
5180	1947	59	,	,	,
5180	1947	60	breast	breast	NN
5180	1947	61	enlargement	enlargement	NN
5180	1947	62	,	,	,
5180	1947	63	.	.	.
5180	1948	1	.	.	.
5180	1949	1	.	.	.
5180	1950	1	and	and	CC
5180	1950	2	shave	shave	VB
5180	1950	3	.	.	.
5180	1950	4	"	"	''
5180	1951	1	If	if	IN
5180	1951	2	separate	separate	JJ
5180	1951	3	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1951	4	attempted	attempt	VBD
5180	1951	5	to	to	TO
5180	1951	6	reach	reach	VB
5180	1951	7	the	the	DT
5180	1951	8	same	same	JJ
5180	1951	9	Web	web	NN
5180	1951	10	site	site	NN
5180	1951	11	,	,	,
5180	1951	12	or	or	CC
5180	1951	13	one	one	CD
5180	1951	14	or	or	CC
5180	1951	15	more	more	JJR
5180	1951	16	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1951	17	attempted	attempt	VBD
5180	1951	18	to	to	TO
5180	1951	19	access	access	VB
5180	1951	20	more	more	JJR
5180	1951	21	than	than	IN
5180	1951	22	one	one	CD
5180	1951	23	page	page	NN
5180	1951	24	on	on	IN
5180	1951	25	a	a	DT
5180	1951	26	single	single	JJ
5180	1951	27	Web	web	NN
5180	1951	28	site	site	NN
5180	1951	29	,	,	,
5180	1951	30	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	1951	31	counted	count	VBD
5180	1951	32	these	these	DT
5180	1951	33	attempts	attempt	NNS
5180	1951	34	as	as	IN
5180	1951	35	a	a	DT
5180	1951	36	single	single	JJ
5180	1951	37	block	block	NN
5180	1951	38	.	.	.
5180	1952	1	For	for	IN
5180	1952	2	example	example	NN
5180	1952	3	,	,	,
5180	1952	4	the	the	DT
5180	1952	5	total	total	JJ
5180	1952	6	number	number	NN
5180	1952	7	of	of	IN
5180	1952	8	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1952	9	requests	request	NNS
5180	1952	10	for	for	IN
5180	1952	11	Web	web	NN
5180	1952	12	pages	page	NNS
5180	1952	13	at	at	IN
5180	1952	14	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	1952	15	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1952	16	during	during	IN
5180	1952	17	the	the	DT
5180	1952	18	logged	log	VBN
5180	1952	19	period	period	NN
5180	1952	20	was	be	VBD
5180	1952	21	2,812	2,812	CD
5180	1952	22	,	,	,
5180	1952	23	but	but	CC
5180	1952	24	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	1952	25	counted	count	VBD
5180	1952	26	this	this	DT
5180	1952	27	as	as	IN
5180	1952	28	only	only	RB
5180	1952	29	895	895	CD
5180	1952	30	blocks	block	NNS
5180	1952	31	of	of	IN
5180	1952	32	unique	unique	JJ
5180	1952	33	Web	web	NN
5180	1952	34	sites	site	NNS
5180	1952	35	.	.	.
5180	1953	1	Of	of	IN
5180	1953	2	the	the	DT
5180	1953	3	895	895	CD
5180	1953	4	unique	unique	JJ
5180	1953	5	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1953	6	sites	site	NNS
5180	1953	7	,	,	,
5180	1953	8	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	1953	9	was	be	VBD
5180	1953	10	unable	unable	JJ
5180	1953	11	to	to	TO
5180	1953	12	access	access	VB
5180	1953	13	59	59	CD
5180	1953	14	,	,	,
5180	1953	15	yielding	yield	VBG
5180	1953	16	836	836	CD
5180	1953	17	unique	unique	JJ
5180	1953	18	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1953	19	sites	site	NNS
5180	1953	20	for	for	IN
5180	1953	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1953	22	team	team	NN
5180	1953	23	to	to	TO
5180	1953	24	review	review	VB
5180	1953	25	.	.	.
5180	1954	1	The	the	DT
5180	1954	2	confidence	confidence	NN
5180	1954	3	intervals	interval	NNS
5180	1954	4	that	that	WDT
5180	1954	5	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	1954	6	calculated	calculate	VBD
5180	1954	7	represent	represent	VBP
5180	1954	8	the	the	DT
5180	1954	9	range	range	NN
5180	1954	10	of	of	IN
5180	1954	11	percentages	percentage	NNS
5180	1954	12	within	within	IN
5180	1954	13	which	which	WDT
5180	1954	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1954	15	can	can	MD
5180	1954	16	be	be	VB
5180	1954	17	95	95	CD
5180	1954	18	%	%	NN
5180	1954	19	confident	confident	JJ
5180	1954	20	that	that	IN
5180	1954	21	the	the	DT
5180	1954	22	actual	actual	JJ
5180	1954	23	rate	rate	NN
5180	1954	24	of	of	IN
5180	1954	25	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1954	26	in	in	IN
5180	1954	27	that	that	DT
5180	1954	28	particular	particular	JJ
5180	1954	29	library	library	NN
5180	1954	30	falls	fall	NNS
5180	1954	31	.	.	.
5180	1955	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1955	2	note	note	VBP
5180	1955	3	that	that	IN
5180	1955	4	these	these	DT
5180	1955	5	confidence	confidence	NN
5180	1955	6	intervals	interval	NNS
5180	1955	7	assume	assume	VBP
5180	1955	8	that	that	IN
5180	1955	9	the	the	DT
5180	1955	10	time	time	NN
5180	1955	11	period	period	NN
5180	1955	12	for	for	IN
5180	1955	13	which	which	WDT
5180	1955	14	the	the	DT
5180	1955	15	study	study	NN
5180	1955	16	assessed	assess	VBD
5180	1955	17	the	the	DT
5180	1955	18	library	library	NN
5180	1955	19	's	's	POS
5180	1955	20	internet	internet	NN
5180	1955	21	logs	logs	NN
5180	1955	22	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
5180	1955	23	a	a	DT
5180	1955	24	random	random	JJ
5180	1955	25	and	and	CC
5180	1955	26	representative	representative	JJ
5180	1955	27	sample	sample	NN
5180	1955	28	.	.	.
5180	1956	1	To	to	TO
5180	1956	2	illustrate	illustrate	VB
5180	1956	3	the	the	DT
5180	1956	4	two	two	CD
5180	1956	5	different	different	JJ
5180	1956	6	methods	method	NNS
5180	1956	7	,	,	,
5180	1956	8	consider	consider	VB
5180	1956	9	a	a	DT
5180	1956	10	random	random	JJ
5180	1956	11	sample	sample	NN
5180	1956	12	of	of	IN
5180	1956	13	1010	1010	CD
5180	1956	14	web	web	NN
5180	1956	15	sites	site	NNS
5180	1956	16	taken	take	VBN
5180	1956	17	from	from	IN
5180	1956	18	a	a	DT
5180	1956	19	library	library	NN
5180	1956	20	's	's	POS
5180	1956	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1956	22	use	use	NN
5180	1956	23	log	log	NN
5180	1956	24	,	,	,
5180	1956	25	10	10	CD
5180	1956	26	of	of	IN
5180	1956	27	which	which	WDT
5180	1956	28	fall	fall	VBP
5180	1956	29	within	within	IN
5180	1956	30	the	the	DT
5180	1956	31	category	category	NN
5180	1956	32	that	that	WDT
5180	1956	33	a	a	DT
5180	1956	34	filter	filter	NN
5180	1956	35	is	be	VBZ
5180	1956	36	intended	intend	VBN
5180	1956	37	to	to	TO
5180	1956	38	block	block	VB
5180	1956	39	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1956	40	e.g.	e.g.	RB
5180	1956	41	,	,	,
5180	1956	42	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	1956	43	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1956	44	,	,	,
5180	1956	45	and	and	CC
5180	1956	46	suppose	suppose	VB
5180	1956	47	that	that	IN
5180	1956	48	the	the	DT
5180	1956	49	filter	filter	NN
5180	1956	50	incorrectly	incorrectly	RB
5180	1956	51	failed	fail	VBD
5180	1956	52	to	to	TO
5180	1956	53	block	block	VB
5180	1956	54	2	2	CD
5180	1956	55	of	of	IN
5180	1956	56	the	the	DT
5180	1956	57	10	10	CD
5180	1956	58	sites	site	NNS
5180	1956	59	that	that	IN
5180	1956	60	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1956	61	should	should	MD
5180	1956	62	have	have	VB
5180	1956	63	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1956	64	and	and	CC
5180	1956	65	did	do	VBD
5180	1956	66	not	not	RB
5180	1956	67	block	block	VB
5180	1956	68	any	any	DT
5180	1956	69	sites	site	NNS
5180	1956	70	that	that	WDT
5180	1956	71	should	should	MD
5180	1956	72	not	not	RB
5180	1956	73	have	have	VB
5180	1956	74	been	be	VBN
5180	1956	75	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1956	76	.	.	.
5180	1957	1	The	the	DT
5180	1957	2	standard	standard	JJ
5180	1957	3	method	method	NN
5180	1957	4	of	of	IN
5180	1957	5	quantifying	quantify	VBG
5180	1957	6	the	the	DT
5180	1957	7	rate	rate	NN
5180	1957	8	of	of	IN
5180	1957	9	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	1957	10	would	would	MD
5180	1957	11	divide	divide	VB
5180	1957	12	the	the	DT
5180	1957	13	number	number	NN
5180	1957	14	of	of	IN
5180	1957	15	sites	site	NNS
5180	1957	16	in	in	IN
5180	1957	17	the	the	DT
5180	1957	18	sample	sample	NN
5180	1957	19	that	that	WDT
5180	1957	20	the	the	DT
5180	1957	21	filter	filter	NN
5180	1957	22	incorrectly	incorrectly	RB
5180	1957	23	failed	fail	VBD
5180	1957	24	to	to	TO
5180	1957	25	block	block	VB
5180	1957	26	by	by	IN
5180	1957	27	the	the	DT
5180	1957	28	number	number	NN
5180	1957	29	of	of	IN
5180	1957	30	sites	site	NNS
5180	1957	31	in	in	IN
5180	1957	32	the	the	DT
5180	1957	33	sample	sample	NN
5180	1957	34	that	that	WDT
5180	1957	35	the	the	DT
5180	1957	36	filter	filter	NN
5180	1957	37	should	should	MD
5180	1957	38	have	have	VB
5180	1957	39	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1957	40	,	,	,
5180	1957	41	yielding	yield	VBG
5180	1957	42	an	an	DT
5180	1957	43	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	1957	44	rate	rate	NN
5180	1957	45	in	in	IN
5180	1957	46	this	this	DT
5180	1957	47	example	example	NN
5180	1957	48	of	of	IN
5180	1957	49	20	20	CD
5180	1957	50	%	%	NN
5180	1957	51	.	.	.
5180	1958	1	Finnell	Finnell	NNP
5180	1958	2	's	's	POS
5180	1958	3	study	study	NN
5180	1958	4	,	,	,
5180	1958	5	however	however	RB
5180	1958	6	,	,	,
5180	1958	7	calculated	calculate	VBD
5180	1958	8	the	the	DT
5180	1958	9	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	1958	10	rate	rate	NN
5180	1958	11	by	by	IN
5180	1958	12	dividing	divide	VBG
5180	1958	13	the	the	DT
5180	1958	14	number	number	NN
5180	1958	15	of	of	IN
5180	1958	16	sites	site	NNS
5180	1958	17	that	that	IN
5180	1958	18	the	the	DT
5180	1958	19	filter	filter	NN
5180	1958	20	incorrectly	incorrectly	RB
5180	1958	21	failed	fail	VBD
5180	1958	22	to	to	TO
5180	1958	23	block	block	VB
5180	1958	24	by	by	IN
5180	1958	25	the	the	DT
5180	1958	26	total	total	JJ
5180	1958	27	number	number	NN
5180	1958	28	of	of	IN
5180	1958	29	sites	site	NNS
5180	1958	30	in	in	IN
5180	1958	31	the	the	DT
5180	1958	32	sample	sample	NN
5180	1958	33	that	that	WDT
5180	1958	34	were	be	VBD
5180	1958	35	not	not	RB
5180	1958	36	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1958	37	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1958	38	whether	whether	CC
5180	1958	39	correctly	correctly	RB
5180	1958	40	or	or	CC
5180	1958	41	incorrectly	incorrectly	RB
5180	1958	42	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1958	43	yielding	yield	VBG
5180	1958	44	an	an	DT
5180	1958	45	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	1958	46	rate	rate	NN
5180	1958	47	in	in	IN
5180	1958	48	this	this	DT
5180	1958	49	example	example	NN
5180	1958	50	of	of	IN
5180	1958	51	only	only	RB
5180	1958	52	.2	.2	.
5180	1958	53	%	%	NN
5180	1958	54	.	.	.
5180	1959	1	According	accord	VBG
5180	1959	2	to	to	IN
5180	1959	3	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	1959	4	,	,	,
5180	1959	5	the	the	DT
5180	1959	6	sample	sample	NN
5180	1959	7	size	size	NN
5180	1959	8	that	that	WDT
5180	1959	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1959	10	used	use	VBD
5180	1959	11	yielded	yield	VBD
5180	1959	12	a	a	DT
5180	1959	13	95	95	CD
5180	1959	14	%	%	NN
5180	1959	15	confidence	confidence	NN
5180	1959	16	interval	interval	NN
5180	1959	17	of	of	IN
5180	1959	18	plus	plus	NN
5180	1959	19	or	or	CC
5180	1959	20	minus	minus	CC
5180	1959	21	3.11	3.11	CD
5180	1959	22	%	%	NN
5180	1959	23	.	.	.
5180	1960	1	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1960	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	1960	3	a	a	DT
5180	1960	4	Harvard	Harvard	NNP
5180	1960	5	University	University	NNP
5180	1960	6	student	student	NN
5180	1960	7	and	and	CC
5180	1960	8	a	a	DT
5180	1960	9	systems	system	NNS
5180	1960	10	administrator	administrator	NN
5180	1960	11	and	and	CC
5180	1960	12	multimedia	multimedia	NN
5180	1960	13	specialist	specialist	NN
5180	1960	14	at	at	IN
5180	1960	15	the	the	DT
5180	1960	16	Berkman	Berkman	NNP
5180	1960	17	Center	Center	NNP
5180	1960	18	for	for	IN
5180	1960	19	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	1960	20	and	and	CC
5180	1960	21	Society	Society	NNP
5180	1960	22	at	at	IN
5180	1960	23	Harvard	Harvard	NNP
5180	1960	24	Law	Law	NNP
5180	1960	25	School	School	NNP
5180	1960	26	.	.	.
5180	1961	1	Despite	despite	IN
5180	1961	2	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1961	3	's	's	POS
5180	1961	4	young	young	JJ
5180	1961	5	age	age	NN
5180	1961	6	,	,	,
5180	1961	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1961	8	has	have	VBZ
5180	1961	9	been	be	VBN
5180	1961	10	doing	do	VBG
5180	1961	11	consulting	consult	VBG
5180	1961	12	work	work	NN
5180	1961	13	on	on	IN
5180	1961	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1961	15	-	-	HYPH
5180	1961	16	related	relate	VBN
5180	1961	17	issues	issue	NNS
5180	1961	18	for	for	IN
5180	1961	19	nine	nine	CD
5180	1961	20	years	year	NNS
5180	1961	21	,	,	,
5180	1961	22	since	since	IN
5180	1961	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1961	24	was	be	VBD
5180	1961	25	in	in	IN
5180	1961	26	junior	junior	JJ
5180	1961	27	high	high	JJ
5180	1961	28	school	school	NN
5180	1961	29	.	.	.
5180	1962	1	The	the	DT
5180	1962	2	archiving	archive	VBG
5180	1962	3	process	process	NN
5180	1962	4	in	in	IN
5180	1962	5	some	some	DT
5180	1962	6	cases	case	NNS
5180	1962	7	took	take	VBD
5180	1962	8	up	up	RB
5180	1962	9	to	to	TO
5180	1962	10	48	48	CD
5180	1962	11	hours	hour	NNS
5180	1962	12	from	from	IN
5180	1962	13	when	when	WRB
5180	1962	14	the	the	DT
5180	1962	15	page	page	NN
5180	1962	16	was	be	VBD
5180	1962	17	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1962	18	.	.	.
5180	1963	1	In	in	IN
5180	1963	2	October	October	NNP
5180	1963	3	2001	2001	CD
5180	1963	4	,	,	,
5180	1963	5	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1963	6	published	publish	VBD
5180	1963	7	the	the	DT
5180	1963	8	results	result	NNS
5180	1963	9	of	of	IN
5180	1963	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1963	11	initial	initial	JJ
5180	1963	12	testing	testing	NN
5180	1963	13	on	on	IN
5180	1963	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1963	15	Web	web	NN
5180	1963	16	site	site	NN
5180	1963	17	.	.	.
5180	1964	1	In	in	IN
5180	1964	2	February	February	NNP
5180	1964	3	and	and	CC
5180	1964	4	March	March	NNP
5180	1964	5	2002	2002	CD
5180	1964	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1964	7	repeated	repeat	VBD
5180	1964	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1964	9	testing	testing	NN
5180	1964	10	of	of	IN
5180	1964	11	the	the	DT
5180	1964	12	6,777	6,777	CD
5180	1964	13	URLs	url	NNS
5180	1964	14	originally	originally	RB
5180	1964	15	found	find	VBN
5180	1964	16	to	to	TO
5180	1964	17	be	be	VB
5180	1964	18	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1964	19	by	by	IN
5180	1964	20	at	at	RB
5180	1964	21	least	least	RBS
5180	1964	22	one	one	CD
5180	1964	23	of	of	IN
5180	1964	24	the	the	DT
5180	1964	25	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1964	26	products	product	NNS
5180	1964	27	,	,	,
5180	1964	28	in	in	IN
5180	1964	29	order	order	NN
5180	1964	30	to	to	TO
5180	1964	31	determine	determine	VB
5180	1964	32	whether	whether	IN
5180	1964	33	and	and	CC
5180	1964	34	to	to	TO
5180	1964	35	what	what	WDT
5180	1964	36	extent	extent	NN
5180	1964	37	the	the	DT
5180	1964	38	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1964	39	product	product	NN
5180	1964	40	vendors	vendor	NNS
5180	1964	41	had	have	VBD
5180	1964	42	corrected	correct	VBN
5180	1964	43	the	the	DT
5180	1964	44	mistakes	mistake	NNS
5180	1964	45	that	that	WDT
5180	1964	46	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1964	47	publicized	publicize	VBD
5180	1964	48	.	.	.
5180	1965	1	Of	of	IN
5180	1965	2	those	those	DT
5180	1965	3	URLs	url	NNS
5180	1965	4	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1965	5	by	by	IN
5180	1965	6	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	1965	7	in	in	IN
5180	1965	8	the	the	DT
5180	1965	9	October	October	NNP
5180	1965	10	2001	2001	CD
5180	1965	11	testing	testing	NN
5180	1965	12	,	,	,
5180	1965	13	55.10	55.10	CD
5180	1965	14	%	%	NN
5180	1965	15	remained	remain	VBD
5180	1965	16	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1965	17	when	when	WRB
5180	1965	18	tested	test	VBN
5180	1965	19	by	by	IN
5180	1965	20	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1965	21	in	in	IN
5180	1965	22	March	March	NNP
5180	1965	23	2002	2002	CD
5180	1965	24	.	.	.
5180	1966	1	Of	of	IN
5180	1966	2	those	those	DT
5180	1966	3	URLs	url	NNS
5180	1966	4	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1966	5	by	by	IN
5180	1966	6	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	1966	7	in	in	IN
5180	1966	8	the	the	DT
5180	1966	9	October	October	NNP
5180	1966	10	2001	2001	CD
5180	1966	11	testing	testing	NN
5180	1966	12	,	,	,
5180	1966	13	76.28	76.28	CD
5180	1966	14	%	%	NN
5180	1966	15	remained	remain	VBD
5180	1966	16	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1966	17	when	when	WRB
5180	1966	18	tested	test	VBN
5180	1966	19	by	by	IN
5180	1966	20	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1966	21	in	in	IN
5180	1966	22	February	February	NNP
5180	1966	23	2002	2002	CD
5180	1966	24	.	.	.
5180	1967	1	Of	of	IN
5180	1967	2	those	those	DT
5180	1967	3	URLs	url	NNS
5180	1967	4	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1967	5	by	by	IN
5180	1967	6	SurfControl	SurfControl	NNP
5180	1967	7	's	's	POS
5180	1967	8	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	1967	9	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	1967	10	product	product	NN
5180	1967	11	,	,	,
5180	1967	12	only	only	RB
5180	1967	13	7.16	7.16	CD
5180	1967	14	%	%	NN
5180	1967	15	remained	remain	VBD
5180	1967	16	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1967	17	,	,	,
5180	1967	18	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	1967	19	,	,	,
5180	1967	20	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	1967	21	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	1967	22	had	have	VBD
5180	1967	23	unblocked	unblock	VBN
5180	1967	24	almost	almost	RB
5180	1967	25	93	93	CD
5180	1967	26	%	%	NN
5180	1967	27	of	of	IN
5180	1967	28	the	the	DT
5180	1967	29	Web	web	NN
5180	1967	30	pages	page	NNS
5180	1967	31	originally	originally	RB
5180	1967	32	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1967	33	.	.	.
5180	1968	1	Because	because	IN
5180	1968	2	the	the	DT
5180	1968	3	results	result	NNS
5180	1968	4	posted	post	VBN
5180	1968	5	to	to	IN
5180	1968	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1968	7	Web	web	NN
5180	1968	8	site	site	NN
5180	1968	9	were	be	VBD
5180	1968	10	accessed	access	VBN
5180	1968	11	by	by	IN
5180	1968	12	an	an	DT
5180	1968	13	employee	employee	NN
5180	1968	14	of	of	IN
5180	1968	15	SurfControl	SurfControl	NNP
5180	1968	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1968	17	as	as	IN
5180	1968	18	evidenced	evidence	VBN
5180	1968	19	by	by	IN
5180	1968	20	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1968	21	's	's	POS
5180	1968	22	records	record	NNS
5180	1968	23	of	of	IN
5180	1968	24	who	who	WP
5180	1968	25	was	be	VBD
5180	1968	26	accessing	access	VBG
5180	1968	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1968	28	Web	web	NN
5180	1968	29	site	site	NN
5180	1968	30	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1968	31	,	,	,
5180	1968	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1968	33	infer	infer	VBP
5180	1968	34	that	that	IN
5180	1968	35	Cyber	Cyber	NNP
5180	1968	36	Patrol	Patrol	NNP
5180	1968	37	had	have	VBD
5180	1968	38	determined	determine	VBN
5180	1968	39	that	that	IN
5180	1968	40	93	93	CD
5180	1968	41	%	%	NN
5180	1968	42	of	of	IN
5180	1968	43	all	all	DT
5180	1968	44	6,777	6,777	CD
5180	1968	45	pages	page	NNS
5180	1968	46	,	,	,
5180	1968	47	or	or	CC
5180	1968	48	6,302	6,302	CD
5180	1968	49	Web	web	NN
5180	1968	50	pages	page	NNS
5180	1968	51	,	,	,
5180	1968	52	were	be	VBD
5180	1968	53	originally	originally	RB
5180	1968	54	wrongly	wrongly	RB
5180	1968	55	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1968	56	by	by	IN
5180	1968	57	the	the	DT
5180	1968	58	product	product	NN
5180	1968	59	.	.	.
5180	1969	1	Two	two	CD
5180	1969	2	other	other	JJ
5180	1969	3	expert	expert	NN
5180	1969	4	witnesses	witness	NNS
5180	1969	5	reviewed	review	VBD
5180	1969	6	subsets	subset	NNS
5180	1969	7	of	of	IN
5180	1969	8	the	the	DT
5180	1969	9	list	list	NN
5180	1969	10	of	of	IN
5180	1969	11	Web	web	NN
5180	1969	12	pages	page	NNS
5180	1969	13	that	that	WDT
5180	1969	14	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1969	15	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	1969	16	.	.	.
5180	1970	1	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
5180	1970	2	Michael	Michael	NNP
5180	1970	3	T.	T.	NNP
5180	1970	4	Ryan	Ryan	NNP
5180	1970	5	,	,	,
5180	1970	6	Director	Director	NNP
5180	1970	7	of	of	IN
5180	1970	8	the	the	DT
5180	1970	9	Rare	Rare	NNP
5180	1970	10	Book	Book	NNP
5180	1970	11	and	and	CC
5180	1970	12	Manuscript	Manuscript	NNP
5180	1970	13	Library	Library	NNP
5180	1970	14	and	and	CC
5180	1970	15	of	of	IN
5180	1970	16	the	the	DT
5180	1970	17	Center	Center	NNP
5180	1970	18	for	for	IN
5180	1970	19	Electronic	Electronic	NNP
5180	1970	20	Text	Text	NNP
5180	1970	21	and	and	CC
5180	1970	22	Image	Image	NNP
5180	1970	23	at	at	IN
5180	1970	24	the	the	DT
5180	1970	25	University	University	NNP
5180	1970	26	of	of	IN
5180	1970	27	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
5180	1970	28	,	,	,
5180	1970	29	reviewed	review	VBD
5180	1970	30	a	a	DT
5180	1970	31	list	list	NN
5180	1970	32	of	of	IN
5180	1970	33	204	204	CD
5180	1970	34	sites	site	NNS
5180	1970	35	that	that	WDT
5180	1970	36	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1970	37	forwarded	forward	VBD
5180	1970	38	to	to	IN
5180	1970	39	him	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1970	40	in	in	IN
5180	1970	41	order	order	NN
5180	1970	42	to	to	TO
5180	1970	43	determine	determine	VB
5180	1970	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1970	45	appropriateness	appropriateness	NN
5180	1970	46	and	and	CC
5180	1970	47	usefulness	usefulness	NN
5180	1970	48	in	in	IN
5180	1970	49	the	the	DT
5180	1970	50	library	library	NN
5180	1970	51	setting	setting	NN
5180	1970	52	.	.	.
5180	1971	1	Because	because	IN
5180	1971	2	the	the	DT
5180	1971	3	sites	site	NNS
5180	1971	4	that	that	WDT
5180	1971	5	Ryan	Ryan	NNP
5180	1971	6	reviewed	review	VBN
5180	1971	7	were	be	VBD
5180	1971	8	not	not	RB
5180	1971	9	selected	select	VBN
5180	1971	10	randomly	randomly	RB
5180	1971	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1971	12	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	1971	13	,	,	,
5180	1971	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1971	15	were	be	VBD
5180	1971	16	chosen	choose	VBN
5180	1971	17	by	by	IN
5180	1971	18	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	1971	19	'	'	POS
5180	1971	20	counsel	counsel	NN
5180	1971	21	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1971	22	,	,	,
5180	1971	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1971	24	study	study	NN
5180	1971	25	says	say	VBZ
5180	1971	26	little	little	JJ
5180	1971	27	about	about	IN
5180	1971	28	the	the	DT
5180	1971	29	character	character	NN
5180	1971	30	of	of	IN
5180	1971	31	the	the	DT
5180	1971	32	set	set	NN
5180	1971	33	of	of	IN
5180	1971	34	6,777	6,777	CD
5180	1971	35	sites	site	NNS
5180	1971	36	that	that	WDT
5180	1971	37	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1971	38	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	1971	39	,	,	,
5180	1971	40	or	or	CC
5180	1971	41	the	the	DT
5180	1971	42	total	total	JJ
5180	1971	43	amount	amount	NN
5180	1971	44	of	of	IN
5180	1971	45	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1971	46	by	by	IN
5180	1971	47	the	the	DT
5180	1971	48	four	four	CD
5180	1971	49	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1971	50	programs	program	NNS
5180	1971	51	that	that	WDT
5180	1971	52	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1971	53	used	use	VBD
5180	1971	54	.	.	.
5180	1972	1	Anne	Anne	NNP
5180	1972	2	Lipow	Lipow	NNP
5180	1972	3	,	,	,
5180	1972	4	a	a	DT
5180	1972	5	practicing	practice	VBG
5180	1972	6	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	1972	7	for	for	IN
5180	1972	8	more	more	JJR
5180	1972	9	than	than	IN
5180	1972	10	30	30	CD
5180	1972	11	years	year	NNS
5180	1972	12	and	and	CC
5180	1972	13	the	the	DT
5180	1972	14	director	director	NN
5180	1972	15	of	of	IN
5180	1972	16	a	a	DT
5180	1972	17	library	library	NN
5180	1972	18	consulting	consulting	NN
5180	1972	19	firm	firm	NN
5180	1972	20	,	,	,
5180	1972	21	also	also	RB
5180	1972	22	reviewed	review	VBD
5180	1972	23	the	the	DT
5180	1972	24	same	same	JJ
5180	1972	25	list	list	NN
5180	1972	26	of	of	IN
5180	1972	27	204	204	CD
5180	1972	28	URLs	url	NNS
5180	1972	29	from	from	IN
5180	1972	30	the	the	DT
5180	1972	31	set	set	NN
5180	1972	32	that	that	IN
5180	1972	33	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1972	34	had	have	VBD
5180	1972	35	collected	collect	VBN
5180	1972	36	for	for	IN
5180	1972	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1972	38	appropriateness	appropriateness	NN
5180	1972	39	for	for	IN
5180	1972	40	a	a	DT
5180	1972	41	library	library	NN
5180	1972	42	's	's	POS
5180	1972	43	collection	collection	NN
5180	1972	44	.	.	.
5180	1973	1	She	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1973	2	categorized	categorize	VBD
5180	1973	3	sites	site	NNS
5180	1973	4	in	in	IN
5180	1973	5	four	four	CD
5180	1973	6	different	different	JJ
5180	1973	7	levels	level	NNS
5180	1973	8	according	accord	VBG
5180	1973	9	to	to	IN
5180	1973	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1973	11	appropriateness	appropriateness	NN
5180	1973	12	for	for	IN
5180	1973	13	a	a	DT
5180	1973	14	public	public	JJ
5180	1973	15	library	library	NN
5180	1973	16	's	's	POS
5180	1973	17	collection	collection	NN
5180	1973	18	.	.	.
5180	1974	1	Again	again	RB
5180	1974	2	,	,	,
5180	1974	3	because	because	IN
5180	1974	4	these	these	DT
5180	1974	5	URLs	url	NNS
5180	1974	6	were	be	VBD
5180	1974	7	not	not	RB
5180	1974	8	selected	select	VBN
5180	1974	9	randomly	randomly	RB
5180	1974	10	,	,	,
5180	1974	11	Lipow	Lipow	NNP
5180	1974	12	's	's	POS
5180	1974	13	study	study	NN
5180	1974	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	1974	15	not	not	RB
5180	1974	16	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	1974	17	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	1974	18	to	to	IN
5180	1974	19	the	the	DT
5180	1974	20	total	total	JJ
5180	1974	21	set	set	NN
5180	1974	22	that	that	IN
5180	1974	23	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1974	24	compiled	compile	VBD
5180	1974	25	,	,	,
5180	1974	26	or	or	CC
5180	1974	27	to	to	IN
5180	1974	28	the	the	DT
5180	1974	29	total	total	JJ
5180	1974	30	amount	amount	NN
5180	1974	31	of	of	IN
5180	1974	32	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1974	33	by	by	IN
5180	1974	34	the	the	DT
5180	1974	35	four	four	CD
5180	1974	36	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	1974	37	programs	program	NNS
5180	1974	38	that	that	WDT
5180	1974	39	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1974	40	used	use	VBD
5180	1974	41	.	.	.
5180	1975	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1975	2	the	the	DT
5180	1975	3	methodology	methodology	NN
5180	1975	4	used	use	VBD
5180	1975	5	to	to	TO
5180	1975	6	select	select	VB
5180	1975	7	the	the	DT
5180	1975	8	list	list	NN
5180	1975	9	of	of	IN
5180	1975	10	Web	web	NN
5180	1975	11	pages	page	NNS
5180	1975	12	that	that	WDT
5180	1975	13	was	be	VBD
5180	1975	14	forwarded	forward	VBN
5180	1975	15	to	to	IN
5180	1975	16	Ryan	Ryan	NNP
5180	1975	17	and	and	CC
5180	1975	18	Lipow	Lipow	NNP
5180	1975	19	is	be	VBZ
5180	1975	20	problematic	problematic	JJ
5180	1975	21	,	,	,
5180	1975	22	Ryan	Ryan	NNP
5180	1975	23	's	's	POS
5180	1975	24	and	and	CC
5180	1975	25	Lipow	Lipow	NNP
5180	1975	26	's	's	POS
5180	1975	27	testimony	testimony	NN
5180	1975	28	established	establish	VBD
5180	1975	29	that	that	IN
5180	1975	30	many	many	JJ
5180	1975	31	of	of	IN
5180	1975	32	the	the	DT
5180	1975	33	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	1975	34	blocked	block	VBN
5180	1975	35	sites	site	NNS
5180	1975	36	that	that	IN
5180	1975	37	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	1975	38	identified	identify	VBD
5180	1975	39	would	would	MD
5180	1975	40	be	be	VB
5180	1975	41	useful	useful	JJ
5180	1975	42	and	and	CC
5180	1975	43	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
5180	1975	44	sources	source	NNS
5180	1975	45	of	of	IN
5180	1975	46	information	information	NN
5180	1975	47	for	for	IN
5180	1975	48	library	library	NN
5180	1975	49	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	1975	50	.	.	.
5180	1976	1	All	all	DT
5180	1976	2	of	of	IN
5180	1976	3	the	the	DT
5180	1976	4	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	1976	5	that	that	WDT
5180	1976	6	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	1976	7	recruited	recruit	VBD
5180	1976	8	had	have	VBD
5180	1976	9	some	some	DT
5180	1976	10	relevant	relevant	JJ
5180	1976	11	experience	experience	NN
5180	1976	12	in	in	IN
5180	1976	13	library	library	JJ
5180	1976	14	reference	reference	NN
5180	1976	15	services	service	NNS
5180	1976	16	or	or	CC
5180	1976	17	library	library	JJ
5180	1976	18	collection	collection	NN
5180	1976	19	development	development	NN
5180	1976	20	.	.	.
5180	1977	1	Janes	jane	NNS
5180	1977	2	divided	divide	VBD
5180	1977	3	the	the	DT
5180	1977	4	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	1977	5	into	into	IN
5180	1977	6	two	two	CD
5180	1977	7	groups	group	NNS
5180	1977	8	,	,	,
5180	1977	9	a	a	DT
5180	1977	10	group	group	NN
5180	1977	11	of	of	IN
5180	1977	12	11	11	CD
5180	1977	13	less	less	CC
5180	1977	14	experienced	experienced	JJ
5180	1977	15	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	1977	16	,	,	,
5180	1977	17	and	and	CC
5180	1977	18	a	a	DT
5180	1977	19	group	group	NN
5180	1977	20	of	of	IN
5180	1977	21	five	five	CD
5180	1977	22	more	more	RBR
5180	1977	23	experienced	experienced	JJ
5180	1977	24	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	1977	25	.	.	.
5180	1978	1	Janes	Janes	NNP
5180	1978	2	assigned	assign	VBD
5180	1978	3	the	the	DT
5180	1978	4	less	less	RBR
5180	1978	5	experienced	experienced	JJ
5180	1978	6	group	group	NN
5180	1978	7	to	to	TO
5180	1978	8	do	do	VB
5180	1978	9	a	a	DT
5180	1978	10	first	first	JJ
5180	1978	11	-	-	HYPH
5180	1978	12	round	round	JJ
5180	1978	13	review	review	NN
5180	1978	14	with	with	IN
5180	1978	15	the	the	DT
5180	1978	16	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1978	17	of	of	IN
5180	1978	18	identifying	identify	VBG
5180	1978	19	the	the	DT
5180	1978	20	most	most	RBS
5180	1978	21	obviously	obviously	RB
5180	1978	22	overblocked	overblocke	VBN
5180	1978	23	sites	site	NNS
5180	1978	24	.	.	.
5180	1979	1	The	the	DT
5180	1979	2	more	more	RBR
5180	1979	3	experienced	experienced	JJ
5180	1979	4	group	group	NN
5180	1979	5	was	be	VBD
5180	1979	6	to	to	TO
5180	1979	7	review	review	VB
5180	1979	8	the	the	DT
5180	1979	9	remaining	remain	VBG
5180	1979	10	sites	site	NNS
5180	1979	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1979	12	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	1979	13	,	,	,
5180	1979	14	those	those	DT
5180	1979	15	that	that	WDT
5180	1979	16	were	be	VBD
5180	1979	17	not	not	RB
5180	1979	18	obviously	obviously	RB
5180	1979	19	overblocked	overblocked	JJ
5180	1979	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1979	21	and	and	CC
5180	1979	22	to	to	TO
5180	1979	23	make	make	VB
5180	1979	24	final	final	JJ
5180	1979	25	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	1979	26	regarding	regard	VBG
5180	1979	27	these	these	DT
5180	1979	28	sites	site	NNS
5180	1979	29	.	.	.
5180	1980	1	In	in	IN
5180	1980	2	the	the	DT
5180	1980	3	first	first	JJ
5180	1980	4	round	round	NN
5180	1980	5	,	,	,
5180	1980	6	each	each	DT
5180	1980	7	person	person	NN
5180	1980	8	evaluated	evaluate	VBD
5180	1980	9	two	two	CD
5180	1980	10	sets	set	NNS
5180	1980	11	of	of	IN
5180	1980	12	around	around	RB
5180	1980	13	80	80	CD
5180	1980	14	sites	site	NNS
5180	1980	15	,	,	,
5180	1980	16	and	and	CC
5180	1980	17	each	each	DT
5180	1980	18	group	group	NN
5180	1980	19	was	be	VBD
5180	1980	20	evaluated	evaluate	VBN
5180	1980	21	by	by	IN
5180	1980	22	two	two	CD
5180	1980	23	different	different	JJ
5180	1980	24	people	people	NNS
5180	1980	25	.	.	.
5180	1981	1	Each	each	DT
5180	1981	2	set	set	NN
5180	1981	3	of	of	IN
5180	1981	4	sites	site	NNS
5180	1981	5	included	include	VBD
5180	1981	6	the	the	DT
5180	1981	7	following	follow	VBG
5180	1981	8	instructions	instruction	NNS
5180	1981	9	:	:	:
5180	1981	10	Look	look	VB
5180	1981	11	carefully	carefully	RB
5180	1981	12	at	at	IN
5180	1981	13	each	each	DT
5180	1981	14	of	of	IN
5180	1981	15	the	the	DT
5180	1981	16	Web	web	NN
5180	1981	17	sites	site	NNS
5180	1981	18	on	on	IN
5180	1981	19	the	the	DT
5180	1981	20	list	list	NN
5180	1981	21	.	.	.
5180	1982	1	Please	please	UH
5180	1982	2	make	make	VB
5180	1982	3	a	a	DT
5180	1982	4	notation	notation	NN
5180	1982	5	of	of	IN
5180	1982	6	any	any	DT
5180	1982	7	site	site	NN
5180	1982	8	that	that	WDT
5180	1982	9	appears	appear	VBZ
5180	1982	10	to	to	TO
5180	1982	11	meet	meet	VB
5180	1982	12	any	any	DT
5180	1982	13	of	of	IN
5180	1982	14	the	the	DT
5180	1982	15	following	follow	VBG
5180	1982	16	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	1982	17	:	:	:
5180	1982	18	a.	a.	NN
5180	1983	1	Contains	contain	VBZ
5180	1983	2	information	information	NN
5180	1983	3	similar	similar	JJ
5180	1983	4	to	to	IN
5180	1983	5	that	that	DT
5180	1983	6	already	already	RB
5180	1983	7	found	find	VBN
5180	1983	8	in	in	IN
5180	1983	9	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1983	10	,	,	,
5180	1983	11	or	or	CC
5180	1983	12	b.	b.	NN
5180	1984	1	Contains	contain	VBZ
5180	1984	2	information	information	NN
5180	1984	3	a	a	DT
5180	1984	4	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	1984	5	would	would	MD
5180	1984	6	want	want	VB
5180	1984	7	in	in	IN
5180	1984	8	the	the	DT
5180	1984	9	library	library	NN
5180	1984	10	if	if	IN
5180	1984	11	s	s	PRP
5180	1984	12	/	/	SYM
5180	1984	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1984	14	had	have	VBD
5180	1984	15	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	1984	16	funds	fund	NNS
5180	1984	17	to	to	TO
5180	1984	18	purchase	purchase	VB
5180	1984	19	information	information	NN
5180	1984	20	and	and	CC
5180	1984	21	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	1984	22	shelf	shelf	NN
5180	1984	23	space	space	NN
5180	1984	24	,	,	,
5180	1984	25	or	or	CC
5180	1984	26	c.	c.	NN
5180	1984	27	You	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1984	28	would	would	MD
5180	1984	29	be	be	VB
5180	1984	30	willing	willing	JJ
5180	1984	31	to	to	TO
5180	1984	32	refer	refer	VB
5180	1984	33	a	a	DT
5180	1984	34	patron	patron	NN
5180	1984	35	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1984	36	of	of	IN
5180	1984	37	any	any	DT
5180	1984	38	age	age	NN
5180	1984	39	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1984	40	to	to	IN
5180	1984	41	the	the	DT
5180	1984	42	site	site	NN
5180	1984	43	if	if	IN
5180	1984	44	the	the	DT
5180	1984	45	patron	patron	NN
5180	1984	46	appeared	appear	VBD
5180	1984	47	at	at	IN
5180	1984	48	a	a	DT
5180	1984	49	reference	reference	NN
5180	1984	50	desk	desk	NN
5180	1984	51	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	1984	52	information	information	NN
5180	1984	53	about	about	IN
5180	1984	54	the	the	DT
5180	1984	55	subject	subject	NN
5180	1984	56	of	of	IN
5180	1984	57	the	the	DT
5180	1984	58	site	site	NN
5180	1984	59	.	.	.
5180	1985	1	For	for	IN
5180	1985	2	this	this	DT
5180	1985	3	last	last	JJ
5180	1985	4	criterion	criterion	NN
5180	1985	5	,	,	,
5180	1985	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1985	7	recognize	recognize	VBP
5180	1985	8	that	that	IN
5180	1985	9	you	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1985	10	might	may	MD
5180	1985	11	not	not	RB
5180	1985	12	refer	refer	VB
5180	1985	13	a	a	DT
5180	1985	14	young	young	JJ
5180	1985	15	child	child	NN
5180	1985	16	to	to	IN
5180	1985	17	a	a	DT
5180	1985	18	Calculus	calculus	NN
5180	1985	19	site	site	NN
5180	1985	20	just	just	RB
5180	1985	21	because	because	IN
5180	1985	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1985	23	would	would	MD
5180	1985	24	not	not	RB
5180	1985	25	be	be	VB
5180	1985	26	useful	useful	JJ
5180	1985	27	to	to	IN
5180	1985	28	that	that	DT
5180	1985	29	child	child	NN
5180	1985	30	,	,	,
5180	1985	31	but	but	CC
5180	1985	32	you	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1985	33	should	should	MD
5180	1985	34	ignore	ignore	VB
5180	1985	35	that	that	DT
5180	1985	36	factor	factor	NN
5180	1985	37	.	.	.
5180	1986	1	Informational	informational	JJ
5180	1986	2	sites	site	NNS
5180	1986	3	,	,	,
5180	1986	4	such	such	JJ
5180	1986	5	as	as	IN
5180	1986	6	a	a	DT
5180	1986	7	Calculus	calculus	NN
5180	1986	8	site	site	NN
5180	1986	9	,	,	,
5180	1986	10	should	should	MD
5180	1986	11	be	be	VB
5180	1986	12	noted	note	VBN
5180	1986	13	.	.	.
5180	1987	1	A	a	DT
5180	1987	2	site	site	NN
5180	1987	3	that	that	WDT
5180	1987	4	is	be	VBZ
5180	1987	5	purely	purely	RB
5180	1987	6	erotica	erotica	NNP
5180	1987	7	should	should	MD
5180	1987	8	not	not	RB
5180	1987	9	be	be	VB
5180	1987	10	noted	note	VBN
5180	1987	11	.	.	.
5180	1988	1	Sites	site	NNS
5180	1988	2	that	that	WDT
5180	1988	3	received	receive	VBD
5180	1988	4	"	"	``
5180	1988	5	Yes	yes	UH
5180	1988	6	"	"	''
5180	1988	7	votes	vote	NNS
5180	1988	8	from	from	IN
5180	1988	9	both	both	DT
5180	1988	10	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	1988	11	were	be	VBD
5180	1988	12	determined	determine	VBN
5180	1988	13	to	to	TO
5180	1988	14	be	be	VB
5180	1988	15	of	of	IN
5180	1988	16	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
5180	1988	17	interest	interest	NN
5180	1988	18	in	in	IN
5180	1988	19	a	a	DT
5180	1988	20	library	library	NN
5180	1988	21	context	context	NN
5180	1988	22	and	and	CC
5180	1988	23	removed	remove	VBN
5180	1988	24	from	from	IN
5180	1988	25	further	further	JJ
5180	1988	26	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	1988	27	.	.	.
5180	1989	1	Sites	site	NNS
5180	1989	2	receiving	receive	VBG
5180	1989	3	one	one	CD
5180	1989	4	or	or	CC
5180	1989	5	two	two	CD
5180	1989	6	"	"	``
5180	1989	7	No	no	UH
5180	1989	8	"	"	''
5180	1989	9	votes	vote	NNS
5180	1989	10	would	would	MD
5180	1989	11	go	go	VB
5180	1989	12	to	to	IN
5180	1989	13	the	the	DT
5180	1989	14	next	next	JJ
5180	1989	15	round	round	NN
5180	1989	16	.	.	.
5180	1990	1	In	in	IN
5180	1990	2	the	the	DT
5180	1990	3	first	first	JJ
5180	1990	4	round	round	NN
5180	1990	5	,	,	,
5180	1990	6	243	243	CD
5180	1990	7	sites	site	NNS
5180	1990	8	received	receive	VBD
5180	1990	9	"	"	``
5180	1990	10	Yes	yes	UH
5180	1990	11	"	"	''
5180	1990	12	votes	vote	NNS
5180	1990	13	from	from	IN
5180	1990	14	both	both	DT
5180	1990	15	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	1990	16	,	,	,
5180	1990	17	while	while	IN
5180	1990	18	456	456	CD
5180	1990	19	sites	site	NNS
5180	1990	20	received	receive	VBD
5180	1990	21	one	one	CD
5180	1990	22	or	or	CC
5180	1990	23	more	more	JJR
5180	1990	24	"	"	``
5180	1990	25	No	no	UH
5180	1990	26	"	"	''
5180	1990	27	votes	vote	NNS
5180	1990	28	or	or	CC
5180	1990	29	could	could	MD
5180	1990	30	not	not	RB
5180	1990	31	be	be	VB
5180	1990	32	found	find	VBN
5180	1990	33	.	.	.
5180	1991	1	These	these	DT
5180	1991	2	456	456	CD
5180	1991	3	sites	site	NNS
5180	1991	4	were	be	VBD
5180	1991	5	sent	send	VBN
5180	1991	6	forward	forward	RB
5180	1991	7	to	to	IN
5180	1991	8	the	the	DT
5180	1991	9	second	second	JJ
5180	1991	10	round	round	NN
5180	1991	11	of	of	IN
5180	1991	12	judging	judging	NN
5180	1991	13	.	.	.
5180	1992	1	The	the	DT
5180	1992	2	instructions	instruction	NNS
5180	1992	3	for	for	IN
5180	1992	4	the	the	DT
5180	1992	5	second	second	JJ
5180	1992	6	-	-	HYPH
5180	1992	7	round	round	NN
5180	1992	8	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	1992	9	were	be	VBD
5180	1992	10	the	the	DT
5180	1992	11	same	same	JJ
5180	1992	12	as	as	IN
5180	1992	13	those	those	DT
5180	1992	14	given	give	VBN
5180	1992	15	to	to	IN
5180	1992	16	the	the	DT
5180	1992	17	first	first	JJ
5180	1992	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	1992	19	round	round	NN
5180	1992	20	reviewers	reviewer	NNS
5180	1992	21	,	,	,
5180	1992	22	except	except	IN
5180	1992	23	that	that	DT
5180	1992	24	in	in	IN
5180	1992	25	section	section	NN
5180	1992	26	c	c	NN
5180	1992	27	,	,	,
5180	1992	28	the	the	DT
5180	1992	29	following	follow	VBG
5180	1992	30	sentence	sentence	NN
5180	1992	31	was	be	VBD
5180	1992	32	added	add	VBN
5180	1992	33	:	:	:
5180	1992	34	"	"	``
5180	1992	35	Sites	site	NNS
5180	1992	36	that	that	WDT
5180	1992	37	have	have	VBP
5180	1992	38	a	a	DT
5180	1992	39	commercial	commercial	JJ
5180	1992	40	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	1992	41	should	should	MD
5180	1992	42	be	be	VB
5180	1992	43	included	include	VBN
5180	1992	44	here	here	RB
5180	1992	45	if	if	IN
5180	1992	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1992	47	might	may	MD
5180	1992	48	be	be	VB
5180	1992	49	of	of	IN
5180	1992	50	use	use	NN
5180	1992	51	or	or	CC
5180	1992	52	interest	interest	NN
5180	1992	53	to	to	IN
5180	1992	54	someone	someone	NN
5180	1992	55	wishing	wish	VBG
5180	1992	56	to	to	TO
5180	1992	57	buy	buy	VB
5180	1992	58	the	the	DT
5180	1992	59	product	product	NN
5180	1992	60	or	or	CC
5180	1992	61	service	service	NN
5180	1992	62	or	or	CC
5180	1992	63	doing	do	VBG
5180	1992	64	research	research	NN
5180	1992	65	on	on	IN
5180	1992	66	commercial	commercial	JJ
5180	1992	67	behavior	behavior	NN
5180	1992	68	on	on	IN
5180	1992	69	the	the	DT
5180	1992	70	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1992	71	,	,	,
5180	1992	72	much	much	RB
5180	1992	73	as	as	IN
5180	1992	74	most	most	JJS
5180	1992	75	libraries	library	NNS
5180	1992	76	include	include	VBP
5180	1992	77	the	the	DT
5180	1992	78	Yellow	Yellow	NNP
5180	1992	79	Pages	Pages	NNPS
5180	1992	80	in	in	IN
5180	1992	81	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1992	82	collections	collection	NNS
5180	1992	83	.	.	.
5180	1992	84	"	"	''
5180	1993	1	The	the	DT
5180	1993	2	second	second	JJ
5180	1993	3	round	round	NN
5180	1993	4	of	of	IN
5180	1993	5	review	review	NN
5180	1993	6	produced	produce	VBD
5180	1993	7	the	the	DT
5180	1993	8	following	following	JJ
5180	1993	9	results	result	NNS
5180	1993	10	:	:	:
5180	1993	11	60	60	CD
5180	1993	12	sites	site	NNS
5180	1993	13	could	could	MD
5180	1993	14	not	not	RB
5180	1993	15	be	be	VB
5180	1993	16	found	find	VBN
5180	1993	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1993	18	due	due	IN
5180	1993	19	to	to	IN
5180	1993	20	broken	broken	JJ
5180	1993	21	links	link	NNS
5180	1993	22	,	,	,
5180	1993	23	404	404	CD
5180	1993	24	"	"	``
5180	1993	25	not	not	RB
5180	1993	26	found	find	VBN
5180	1993	27	"	"	``
5180	1993	28	errors	error	NNS
5180	1993	29	,	,	,
5180	1993	30	domain	domain	NN
5180	1993	31	for	for	IN
5180	1993	32	sale	sale	NN
5180	1993	33	messages	message	NNS
5180	1993	34	,	,	,
5180	1993	35	etc	etc	FW
5180	1993	36	.	.	.
5180	1994	1	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1994	2	,	,	,
5180	1994	3	231	231	CD
5180	1994	4	sites	site	NNS
5180	1994	5	were	be	VBD
5180	1994	6	judged	judge	VBN
5180	1994	7	"	"	``
5180	1994	8	Yes	yes	UH
5180	1994	9	,	,	,
5180	1994	10	"	"	''
5180	1994	11	and	and	CC
5180	1994	12	165	165	CD
5180	1994	13	judged	judge	VBN
5180	1994	14	"	"	``
5180	1994	15	No	no	UH
5180	1994	16	.	.	.
5180	1994	17	"	"	''
5180	1995	1	Although	although	IN
5180	1995	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1995	3	was	be	VBD
5180	1995	4	not	not	RB
5180	1995	5	proffered	proffer	VBN
5180	1995	6	as	as	IN
5180	1995	7	evidence	evidence	NN
5180	1995	8	in	in	IN
5180	1995	9	this	this	DT
5180	1995	10	trial	trial	NN
5180	1995	11	,	,	,
5180	1995	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1995	13	and	and	CC
5180	1995	14	hence	hence	RB
5180	1995	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1995	16	do	do	VBP
5180	1995	17	not	not	RB
5180	1995	18	rely	rely	VB
5180	1995	19	on	on	IN
5180	1995	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1995	21	to	to	TO
5180	1995	22	inform	inform	VB
5180	1995	23	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	1995	24	findings	finding	NNS
5180	1995	25	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1995	26	,	,	,
5180	1995	27	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1995	28	note	note	VBP
5180	1995	29	that	that	IN
5180	1995	30	Youth	Youth	NNP
5180	1995	31	,	,	,
5180	1995	32	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	1995	33	,	,	,
5180	1995	34	and	and	CC
5180	1995	35	the	the	DT
5180	1995	36	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1995	37	,	,	,
5180	1995	38	a	a	DT
5180	1995	39	congressionally	congressionally	RB
5180	1995	40	commissioned	commission	VBN
5180	1995	41	study	study	NN
5180	1995	42	by	by	IN
5180	1995	43	the	the	DT
5180	1995	44	National	National	NNP
5180	1995	45	Research	Research	NNP
5180	1995	46	Council	Council	NNP
5180	1995	47	,	,	,
5180	1995	48	a	a	DT
5180	1995	49	division	division	NN
5180	1995	50	of	of	IN
5180	1995	51	the	the	DT
5180	1995	52	National	National	NNP
5180	1995	53	Academies	Academies	NNPS
5180	1995	54	of	of	IN
5180	1995	55	Science	Science	NNP
5180	1995	56	,	,	,
5180	1995	57	see	see	VB
5180	1995	58	Pub	Pub	NNP
5180	1995	59	.	.	.
5180	1996	1	L.	L.	NNP
5180	1996	2	105	105	CD
5180	1996	3	-	-	SYM
5180	1996	4	314	314	CD
5180	1996	5	,	,	,
5180	1996	6	Title	Title	NNP
5180	1996	7	X	X	NNP
5180	1996	8	,	,	,
5180	1996	9	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	1996	10	.	.	.
5180	1997	1	901	901	CD
5180	1997	2	,	,	,
5180	1997	3	comes	come	VBZ
5180	1997	4	to	to	IN
5180	1997	5	a	a	DT
5180	1997	6	conclusion	conclusion	NN
5180	1997	7	similar	similar	JJ
5180	1997	8	to	to	IN
5180	1997	9	the	the	DT
5180	1997	10	one	one	NN
5180	1997	11	that	that	WDT
5180	1997	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	1997	13	reach	reach	VBP
5180	1997	14	regarding	regard	VBG
5180	1997	15	the	the	DT
5180	1997	16	effectiveness	effectiveness	NN
5180	1997	17	of	of	IN
5180	1997	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	1997	19	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1997	20	.	.	.
5180	1998	1	The	the	DT
5180	1998	2	commission	commission	NN
5180	1998	3	concludes	conclude	VBZ
5180	1998	4	that	that	DT
5180	1998	5	:	:	:
5180	1998	6	All	all	DT
5180	1998	7	filters	filter	NNS
5180	1998	8	–	–	:
5180	1998	9	those	those	DT
5180	1998	10	of	of	IN
5180	1998	11	today	today	NN
5180	1998	12	and	and	CC
5180	1998	13	for	for	IN
5180	1998	14	the	the	DT
5180	1998	15	foreseeable	foreseeable	JJ
5180	1998	16	future	future	NN
5180	1998	17	–	–	:
5180	1998	18	suffer	suffer	VB
5180	1998	19	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1998	20	and	and	CC
5180	1998	21	will	will	MD
5180	1998	22	suffer	suffer	VB
5180	1998	23	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1998	24	from	from	IN
5180	1998	25	some	some	DT
5180	1998	26	degree	degree	NN
5180	1998	27	of	of	IN
5180	1998	28	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1998	29	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1998	30	blocking	block	VBG
5180	1998	31	content	content	NN
5180	1998	32	that	that	WDT
5180	1998	33	should	should	MD
5180	1998	34	be	be	VB
5180	1998	35	allowed	allow	VBN
5180	1998	36	through	through	IN
5180	1998	37	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1998	38	and	and	CC
5180	1998	39	some	some	DT
5180	1998	40	degree	degree	NN
5180	1998	41	of	of	IN
5180	1998	42	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	1998	43	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1998	44	passing	pass	VBG
5180	1998	45	content	content	NN
5180	1998	46	that	that	WDT
5180	1998	47	should	should	MD
5180	1998	48	not	not	RB
5180	1998	49	be	be	VB
5180	1998	50	allowed	allow	VBN
5180	1998	51	through	through	IN
5180	1998	52	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1998	53	.	.	.
5180	1999	1	While	while	IN
5180	1999	2	the	the	DT
5180	1999	3	extent	extent	NN
5180	1999	4	of	of	IN
5180	1999	5	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1999	6	and	and	CC
5180	1999	7	underblocking	underblocking	NN
5180	1999	8	will	will	MD
5180	1999	9	vary	vary	VB
5180	1999	10	with	with	IN
5180	1999	11	the	the	DT
5180	1999	12	product	product	NN
5180	1999	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	1999	14	and	and	CC
5180	1999	15	may	may	MD
5180	1999	16	improve	improve	VB
5180	1999	17	over	over	IN
5180	1999	18	time	time	NN
5180	1999	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	1999	20	,	,	,
5180	1999	21	underblocking	underblocke	VBG
5180	1999	22	and	and	CC
5180	1999	23	overblocking	overblocke	VBG
5180	1999	24	result	result	NN
5180	1999	25	from	from	IN
5180	1999	26	numerous	numerous	JJ
5180	1999	27	sources	source	NNS
5180	1999	28	,	,	,
5180	1999	29	including	include	VBG
5180	1999	30	the	the	DT
5180	1999	31	variability	variability	NN
5180	1999	32	in	in	IN
5180	1999	33	the	the	DT
5180	1999	34	perspectives	perspective	NNS
5180	1999	35	that	that	WDT
5180	1999	36	humans	human	NNS
5180	1999	37	bring	bring	VBP
5180	1999	38	to	to	IN
5180	1999	39	the	the	DT
5180	1999	40	task	task	NN
5180	1999	41	of	of	IN
5180	1999	42	judging	judge	VBG
5180	1999	43	content	content	NN
5180	1999	44	.	.	.
5180	2000	1	Youth	Youth	NNP
5180	2000	2	,	,	,
5180	2000	3	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	2000	4	,	,	,
5180	2000	5	and	and	CC
5180	2000	6	the	the	DT
5180	2000	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2000	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2000	9	Dick	Dick	NNP
5180	2000	10	Thornburgh	Thornburgh	NNP
5180	2000	11	&	&	CC
5180	2000	12	Herbert	Herbert	NNP
5180	2000	13	S.	S.	NNP
5180	2000	14	Lin	Lin	NNP
5180	2000	15	,	,	,
5180	2000	16	eds	eds	NNP
5180	2000	17	.	.	NNP
5180	2000	18	,	,	,
5180	2000	19	2002	2002	CD
5180	2000	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2000	21	,	,	,
5180	2000	22	available	available	JJ
5180	2000	23	at	at	IN
5180	2000	24	http://bob.nap.edu/html/youth_internet/.	http://bob.nap.edu/html/youth_internet/.	ADD
5180	2001	1	Because	because	IN
5180	2001	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2001	3	find	find	VBP
5180	2001	4	that	that	IN
5180	2001	5	the	the	DT
5180	2001	6	plaintiff	plaintiff	JJ
5180	2001	7	public	public	JJ
5180	2001	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2001	9	are	be	VBP
5180	2001	10	funded	fund	VBN
5180	2001	11	and	and	CC
5180	2001	12	controlled	control	VBN
5180	2001	13	by	by	IN
5180	2001	14	state	state	NN
5180	2001	15	and	and	CC
5180	2001	16	local	local	JJ
5180	2001	17	governments	government	NNS
5180	2001	18	,	,	,
5180	2001	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2001	20	are	be	VBP
5180	2001	21	state	state	NN
5180	2001	22	actors	actor	NNS
5180	2001	23	,	,	,
5180	2001	24	subject	subject	JJ
5180	2001	25	to	to	IN
5180	2001	26	the	the	DT
5180	2001	27	constraints	constraint	NNS
5180	2001	28	of	of	IN
5180	2001	29	the	the	DT
5180	2001	30	First	First	NNP
5180	2001	31	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2001	32	,	,	,
5180	2001	33	as	as	IN
5180	2001	34	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
5180	2001	35	by	by	IN
5180	2001	36	the	the	DT
5180	2001	37	Due	Due	NNP
5180	2001	38	Process	Process	NNP
5180	2001	39	Clause	Clause	NNP
5180	2001	40	of	of	IN
5180	2001	41	the	the	DT
5180	2001	42	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
5180	2001	43	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2001	44	.	.	.
5180	2002	1	The	the	DT
5180	2002	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	2002	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2002	4	has	have	VBZ
5180	2002	5	recognized	recognize	VBN
5180	2002	6	that	that	IN
5180	2002	7	the	the	DT
5180	2002	8	First	First	NNP
5180	2002	9	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2002	10	encompasses	encompass	VBZ
5180	2002	11	not	not	RB
5180	2002	12	only	only	RB
5180	2002	13	the	the	DT
5180	2002	14	right	right	NN
5180	2002	15	to	to	TO
5180	2002	16	speak	speak	VB
5180	2002	17	,	,	,
5180	2002	18	but	but	CC
5180	2002	19	also	also	RB
5180	2002	20	the	the	DT
5180	2002	21	right	right	NN
5180	2002	22	to	to	TO
5180	2002	23	receive	receive	VB
5180	2002	24	information	information	NN
5180	2002	25	.	.	.
5180	2003	1	See	see	VB
5180	2003	2	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	2003	3	v.	v.	IN
5180	2003	4	ACLU	ACLU	NNP
5180	2003	5	,	,	,
5180	2003	6	521	521	CD
5180	2003	7	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2003	8	844	844	CD
5180	2003	9	,	,	,
5180	2003	10	874	874	CD
5180	2003	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2003	12	1997	1997	CD
5180	2003	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2003	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2003	15	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
5180	2003	16	a	a	DT
5180	2003	17	statute	statute	NN
5180	2003	18	because	because	IN
5180	2003	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2003	20	"	"	``
5180	2003	21	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	2003	22	suppresses	suppress	VBZ
5180	2003	23	a	a	DT
5180	2003	24	large	large	JJ
5180	2003	25	amount	amount	NN
5180	2003	26	of	of	IN
5180	2003	27	speech	speech	NN
5180	2003	28	that	that	WDT
5180	2003	29	adults	adult	NNS
5180	2003	30	have	have	VBP
5180	2003	31	a	a	DT
5180	2003	32	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	2003	33	right	right	NN
5180	2003	34	to	to	TO
5180	2003	35	receive	receive	VB
5180	2003	36	and	and	CC
5180	2003	37	to	to	TO
5180	2003	38	address	address	VB
5180	2003	39	to	to	IN
5180	2003	40	one	one	CD
5180	2003	41	another	another	DT
5180	2003	42	"	"	''
5180	2003	43	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2003	44	;	;	:
5180	2003	45	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
5180	2003	46	v.	v.	IN
5180	2003	47	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
5180	2003	48	,	,	,
5180	2003	49	394	394	CD
5180	2003	50	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2003	51	557	557	CD
5180	2003	52	,	,	,
5180	2003	53	564	564	CD
5180	2003	54	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2003	55	1969	1969	CD
5180	2003	56	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2003	57	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2003	58	"	"	``
5180	2003	59	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2003	60	The	the	DT
5180	2003	61	]	]	-RRB-
5180	2003	62	right	right	NN
5180	2003	63	to	to	TO
5180	2003	64	receive	receive	VB
5180	2003	65	information	information	NN
5180	2003	66	and	and	CC
5180	2003	67	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	2003	68	,	,	,
5180	2003	69	regardless	regardless	RB
5180	2003	70	of	of	IN
5180	2003	71	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2003	72	social	social	JJ
5180	2003	73	worth	worth	NN
5180	2003	74	.	.	.
5180	2004	1	.	.	.
5180	2005	1	.	.	.
5180	2006	1	is	be	VBZ
5180	2006	2	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
5180	2006	3	to	to	IN
5180	2006	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2006	5	free	free	JJ
5180	2006	6	society	society	NN
5180	2006	7	.	.	.
5180	2007	1	")	")	``
5180	2007	2	;	;	:
5180	2007	3	see	see	VB
5180	2007	4	also	also	RB
5180	2007	5	Bd	Bd	NNP
5180	2007	6	.	.	.
5180	2008	1	of	of	IN
5180	2008	2	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	2008	3	.	.	.
5180	2009	1	v.	v.	IN
5180	2009	2	Pico	Pico	NNP
5180	2009	3	,	,	,
5180	2009	4	457	457	CD
5180	2009	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2009	6	853	853	CD
5180	2009	7	,	,	,
5180	2009	8	867	867	CD
5180	2009	9	-	-	SYM
5180	2009	10	68	68	CD
5180	2009	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2009	12	1982	1982	CD
5180	2009	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2009	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2009	15	plurality	plurality	NN
5180	2009	16	opinion	opinion	NN
5180	2009	17	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2009	18	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2009	19	"	"	``
5180	2009	20	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2009	21	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	2009	22	right	right	RB
5180	2009	23	to	to	TO
5180	2009	24	receive	receive	VB
5180	2009	25	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	2009	26	follows	follow	VBZ
5180	2009	27	ineluctably	ineluctably	RB
5180	2009	28	from	from	IN
5180	2009	29	the	the	DT
5180	2009	30	sender	sender	NN
5180	2009	31	's	's	POS
5180	2009	32	First	First	NNP
5180	2009	33	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2009	34	right	right	RB
5180	2009	35	to	to	TO
5180	2009	36	send	send	VB
5180	2009	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2009	38	.	.	.
5180	2009	39	"	"	''
5180	2009	40	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2009	41	.	.	.
5180	2010	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	2010	2	,	,	,
5180	2010	3	if	if	IN
5180	2010	4	the	the	DT
5180	2010	5	First	First	NNP
5180	2010	6	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2010	7	subjected	subject	VBN
5180	2010	8	to	to	IN
5180	2010	9	strict	strict	JJ
5180	2010	10	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
5180	2010	11	the	the	DT
5180	2010	12	government	government	NN
5180	2010	13	's	's	POS
5180	2010	14	decision	decision	NN
5180	2010	15	to	to	TO
5180	2010	16	dedicate	dedicate	VB
5180	2010	17	a	a	DT
5180	2010	18	forum	forum	NN
5180	2010	19	to	to	IN
5180	2010	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	2010	21	whose	whose	WP$
5180	2010	22	content	content	NN
5180	2010	23	the	the	DT
5180	2010	24	government	government	NN
5180	2010	25	judges	judge	NNS
5180	2010	26	to	to	TO
5180	2010	27	be	be	VB
5180	2010	28	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	2010	29	valuable	valuable	JJ
5180	2010	30	,	,	,
5180	2010	31	many	many	JJ
5180	2010	32	of	of	IN
5180	2010	33	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2010	34	public	public	JJ
5180	2010	35	institutions	institution	NNS
5180	2010	36	of	of	IN
5180	2010	37	culture	culture	NN
5180	2010	38	would	would	MD
5180	2010	39	cease	cease	VB
5180	2010	40	to	to	TO
5180	2010	41	exist	exist	VB
5180	2010	42	in	in	IN
5180	2010	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2010	44	current	current	JJ
5180	2010	45	form	form	NN
5180	2010	46	:	:	:
5180	2010	47	From	from	IN
5180	2010	48	here	here	RB
5180	2010	49	on	on	RB
5180	2010	50	out	out	RB
5180	2010	51	,	,	,
5180	2010	52	the	the	DT
5180	2010	53	National	National	NNP
5180	2010	54	Gallery	Gallery	NNP
5180	2010	55	in	in	IN
5180	2010	56	Washington	Washington	NNP
5180	2010	57	,	,	,
5180	2010	58	D.C.	D.C.	NNP
5180	2010	59	,	,	,
5180	2010	60	for	for	IN
5180	2010	61	example	example	NN
5180	2010	62	,	,	,
5180	2010	63	would	would	MD
5180	2010	64	be	be	VB
5180	2010	65	required	require	VBN
5180	2010	66	to	to	TO
5180	2010	67	display	display	VB
5180	2010	68	the	the	DT
5180	2010	69	art	art	NN
5180	2010	70	of	of	IN
5180	2010	71	all	all	DT
5180	2010	72	would	would	MD
5180	2010	73	-	-	HYPH
5180	2010	74	be	be	VB
5180	2010	75	artists	artist	NNS
5180	2010	76	on	on	IN
5180	2010	77	a	a	DT
5180	2010	78	first	first	JJ
5180	2010	79	-	-	HYPH
5180	2010	80	come	come	VBN
5180	2010	81	-	-	HYPH
5180	2010	82	first	first	RB
5180	2010	83	-	-	HYPH
5180	2010	84	served	serve	VBN
5180	2010	85	basis	basis	NN
5180	2010	86	and	and	CC
5180	2010	87	would	would	MD
5180	2010	88	not	not	RB
5180	2010	89	be	be	VB
5180	2010	90	able	able	JJ
5180	2010	91	to	to	TO
5180	2010	92	exercise	exercise	VB
5180	2010	93	any	any	DT
5180	2010	94	content	content	NN
5180	2010	95	control	control	NN
5180	2010	96	over	over	IN
5180	2010	97	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2010	98	collection	collection	NN
5180	2010	99	through	through	IN
5180	2010	100	evaluations	evaluation	NNS
5180	2010	101	of	of	IN
5180	2010	102	quality	quality	NN
5180	2010	103	.	.	.
5180	2011	1	Such	such	PDT
5180	2011	2	a	a	DT
5180	2011	3	conclusion	conclusion	NN
5180	2011	4	,	,	,
5180	2011	5	of	of	IN
5180	2011	6	course	course	NN
5180	2011	7	,	,	,
5180	2011	8	strikes	strike	VBZ
5180	2011	9	us	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2011	10	as	as	IN
5180	2011	11	absurd	absurd	JJ
5180	2011	12	,	,	,
5180	2011	13	but	but	CC
5180	2011	14	that	that	DT
5180	2011	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	2011	16	only	only	RB
5180	2011	17	because	because	IN
5180	2011	18	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2011	19	feel	feel	VBP
5180	2011	20	that	that	IN
5180	2011	21	the	the	DT
5180	2011	22	government	government	NN
5180	2011	23	should	should	MD
5180	2011	24	be	be	VB
5180	2011	25	free	free	JJ
5180	2011	26	to	to	TO
5180	2011	27	establish	establish	VB
5180	2011	28	public	public	JJ
5180	2011	29	cultural	cultural	JJ
5180	2011	30	institutions	institution	NNS
5180	2011	31	guided	guide	VBN
5180	2011	32	by	by	IN
5180	2011	33	standards	standard	NNS
5180	2011	34	such	such	JJ
5180	2011	35	as	as	IN
5180	2011	36	"	"	``
5180	2011	37	quality	quality	NN
5180	2011	38	.	.	.
5180	2011	39	"	"	''
5180	2012	1	.	.	.
5180	2013	1	.	.	.
5180	2014	1	.	.	.
5180	2015	1	While	while	IN
5180	2015	2	the	the	DT
5180	2015	3	First	First	NNP
5180	2015	4	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2015	5	articulates	articulate	VBZ
5180	2015	6	a	a	DT
5180	2015	7	deep	deep	JJ
5180	2015	8	fear	fear	NN
5180	2015	9	of	of	IN
5180	2015	10	government	government	NN
5180	2015	11	intervention	intervention	NN
5180	2015	12	in	in	IN
5180	2015	13	the	the	DT
5180	2015	14	marketplace	marketplace	NN
5180	2015	15	of	of	IN
5180	2015	16	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	2015	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2015	18	because	because	IN
5180	2015	19	of	of	IN
5180	2015	20	the	the	DT
5180	2015	21	risk	risk	NN
5180	2015	22	of	of	IN
5180	2015	23	distortion	distortion	NN
5180	2015	24	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2015	25	,	,	,
5180	2015	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2015	27	also	also	RB
5180	2015	28	seems	seem	VBZ
5180	2015	29	prepared	prepared	JJ
5180	2015	30	to	to	TO
5180	2015	31	permit	permit	VB
5180	2015	32	state	state	NN
5180	2015	33	-	-	HYPH
5180	2015	34	sponsored	sponsor	VBN
5180	2015	35	and	and	CC
5180	2015	36	-supported	-supporte	VBN
5180	2015	37	cultural	cultural	JJ
5180	2015	38	institutions	institution	NNS
5180	2015	39	that	that	WDT
5180	2015	40	exercise	exercise	VBP
5180	2015	41	considerable	considerable	JJ
5180	2015	42	control	control	NN
5180	2015	43	over	over	IN
5180	2015	44	which	which	WDT
5180	2015	45	art	art	NN
5180	2015	46	to	to	TO
5180	2015	47	fund	fund	VB
5180	2015	48	,	,	,
5180	2015	49	which	which	WDT
5180	2015	50	pictures	picture	VBZ
5180	2015	51	to	to	TO
5180	2015	52	hang	hang	VB
5180	2015	53	,	,	,
5180	2015	54	and	and	CC
5180	2015	55	which	which	WDT
5180	2015	56	courses	course	NNS
5180	2015	57	to	to	TO
5180	2015	58	teach	teach	VB
5180	2015	59	.	.	.
5180	2016	1	That	that	IN
5180	2016	2	these	these	DT
5180	2016	3	choices	choice	NNS
5180	2016	4	necessarily	necessarily	RB
5180	2016	5	involve	involve	VBP
5180	2016	6	judgments	judgment	NNS
5180	2016	7	about	about	IN
5180	2016	8	favored	favor	VBN
5180	2016	9	and	and	CC
5180	2016	10	disfavored	disfavor	VBN
5180	2016	11	content	content	NN
5180	2016	12	–	–	:
5180	2016	13	judgments	judgment	NNS
5180	2016	14	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	2016	15	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
5180	2016	16	in	in	IN
5180	2016	17	the	the	DT
5180	2016	18	realm	realm	NN
5180	2016	19	of	of	IN
5180	2016	20	censorship	censorship	NN
5180	2016	21	–	–	:
5180	2016	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	2016	23	indisputable	indisputable	JJ
5180	2016	24	.	.	.
5180	2017	1	Lee	Lee	NNP
5180	2017	2	C.	C.	NNP
5180	2017	3	Bollinger	Bollinger	NNP
5180	2017	4	,	,	,
5180	2017	5	Public	Public	NNP
5180	2017	6	Institutions	Institutions	NNPS
5180	2017	7	of	of	IN
5180	2017	8	Culture	Culture	NNP
5180	2017	9	and	and	CC
5180	2017	10	the	the	DT
5180	2017	11	First	First	NNP
5180	2017	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2017	13	:	:	:
5180	2017	14	The	the	DT
5180	2017	15	New	New	NNP
5180	2017	16	Frontier	Frontier	NNP
5180	2017	17	,	,	,
5180	2017	18	63	63	CD
5180	2017	19	U.	U.	NNP
5180	2017	20	Cin	Cin	NNP
5180	2017	21	.	.	.
5180	2018	1	L.	L.	NNP
5180	2018	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
5180	2019	1	1103	1103	CD
5180	2019	2	,	,	,
5180	2019	3	1110	1110	CD
5180	2019	4	-	-	SYM
5180	2019	5	15	15	CD
5180	2019	6	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2019	7	1995	1995	CD
5180	2019	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2019	9	.	.	.
5180	2020	1	In	in	IN
5180	2020	2	both	both	DT
5180	2020	3	of	of	IN
5180	2020	4	these	these	DT
5180	2020	5	cases	case	NNS
5180	2020	6	,	,	,
5180	2020	7	the	the	DT
5180	2020	8	taxation	taxation	NN
5180	2020	9	scheme	scheme	NN
5180	2020	10	at	at	IN
5180	2020	11	issue	issue	NN
5180	2020	12	effectively	effectively	RB
5180	2020	13	subsidized	subsidize	VBD
5180	2020	14	a	a	DT
5180	2020	15	vast	vast	JJ
5180	2020	16	range	range	NN
5180	2020	17	of	of	IN
5180	2020	18	publications	publication	NNS
5180	2020	19	,	,	,
5180	2020	20	and	and	CC
5180	2020	21	singled	single	VBD
5180	2020	22	out	out	RP
5180	2020	23	for	for	IN
5180	2020	24	penalty	penalty	NN
5180	2020	25	only	only	RB
5180	2020	26	a	a	DT
5180	2020	27	handful	handful	NN
5180	2020	28	of	of	IN
5180	2020	29	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	2020	30	.	.	.
5180	2021	1	See	see	VB
5180	2021	2	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
5180	2021	3	Writers	Writers	NNPS
5180	2021	4	'	'	POS
5180	2021	5	Project	Project	NNP
5180	2021	6	,	,	,
5180	2021	7	460	460	CD
5180	2021	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2021	9	at	at	IN
5180	2021	10	228	228	CD
5180	2021	11	-	-	SYM
5180	2021	12	29	29	CD
5180	2021	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2021	14	noting	note	VBG
5180	2021	15	that	that	IN
5180	2021	16	"	"	``
5180	2021	17	selective	selective	JJ
5180	2021	18	taxation	taxation	NN
5180	2021	19	of	of	IN
5180	2021	20	the	the	DT
5180	2021	21	press	press	NN
5180	2021	22	–	–	:
5180	2021	23	.	.	.
5180	2022	1	.	.	.
5180	2023	1	.	.	.
5180	2024	1	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2024	2	by	by	IN
5180	2024	3	]	]	-RRB-
5180	2024	4	targeting	target	VBG
5180	2024	5	individual	individual	JJ
5180	2024	6	members	member	NNS
5180	2024	7	of	of	IN
5180	2024	8	the	the	DT
5180	2024	9	press	press	NN
5180	2024	10	–	–	:
5180	2024	11	poses	pose	VBZ
5180	2024	12	a	a	DT
5180	2024	13	particular	particular	JJ
5180	2024	14	danger	danger	NN
5180	2024	15	of	of	IN
5180	2024	16	abuse	abuse	NN
5180	2024	17	by	by	IN
5180	2024	18	the	the	DT
5180	2024	19	State	State	NNP
5180	2024	20	"	"	''
5180	2024	21	and	and	CC
5180	2024	22	explaining	explain	VBG
5180	2024	23	that	that	IN
5180	2024	24	"	"	``
5180	2024	25	this	this	DT
5180	2024	26	case	case	NN
5180	2024	27	involves	involve	VBZ
5180	2024	28	a	a	DT
5180	2024	29	more	more	RBR
5180	2024	30	disturbing	disturbing	JJ
5180	2024	31	use	use	NN
5180	2024	32	of	of	IN
5180	2024	33	selective	selective	JJ
5180	2024	34	taxation	taxation	NN
5180	2024	35	than	than	IN
5180	2024	36	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
5180	2024	37	Star	Star	NNP
5180	2024	38	,	,	,
5180	2024	39	because	because	IN
5180	2024	40	the	the	DT
5180	2024	41	basis	basis	NN
5180	2024	42	on	on	IN
5180	2024	43	which	which	WDT
5180	2024	44	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
5180	2024	45	differentiates	differentiate	VBZ
5180	2024	46	between	between	IN
5180	2024	47	magazines	magazine	NNS
5180	2024	48	is	be	VBZ
5180	2024	49	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	2024	50	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
5180	2024	51	to	to	IN
5180	2024	52	First	First	NNP
5180	2024	53	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2024	54	principles	principle	NNS
5180	2024	55	:	:	:
5180	2024	56	a	a	DT
5180	2024	57	magazine	magazine	NN
5180	2024	58	's	's	POS
5180	2024	59	tax	tax	NN
5180	2024	60	status	status	NN
5180	2024	61	depends	depend	VBZ
5180	2024	62	entirely	entirely	RB
5180	2024	63	on	on	IN
5180	2024	64	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2024	65	content	content	NN
5180	2024	66	"	"	''
5180	2024	67	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2024	68	;	;	:
5180	2024	69	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
5180	2024	70	Star	Star	NNP
5180	2024	71	,	,	,
5180	2024	72	460	460	CD
5180	2024	73	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2024	74	at	at	IN
5180	2024	75	591	591	CD
5180	2024	76	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2024	77	"	"	``
5180	2024	78	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
5180	2024	79	's	's	POS
5180	2024	80	ink	ink	NN
5180	2024	81	and	and	CC
5180	2024	82	paper	paper	NN
5180	2024	83	tax	tax	NN
5180	2024	84	violates	violate	VBZ
5180	2024	85	the	the	DT
5180	2024	86	First	First	NNP
5180	2024	87	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2024	88	not	not	RB
5180	2024	89	only	only	RB
5180	2024	90	because	because	IN
5180	2024	91	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2024	92	singles	single	VBZ
5180	2024	93	out	out	RP
5180	2024	94	the	the	DT
5180	2024	95	press	press	NN
5180	2024	96	,	,	,
5180	2024	97	but	but	CC
5180	2024	98	also	also	RB
5180	2024	99	because	because	IN
5180	2024	100	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2024	101	targets	target	VBZ
5180	2024	102	a	a	DT
5180	2024	103	small	small	JJ
5180	2024	104	group	group	NN
5180	2024	105	of	of	IN
5180	2024	106	newspapers	newspaper	NNS
5180	2024	107	.	.	.
5180	2025	1	")	")	``
5180	2025	2	;	;	:
5180	2025	3	see	see	VB
5180	2025	4	also	also	RB
5180	2025	5	Turner	Turner	NNP
5180	2025	6	Broad	Broad	NNP
5180	2025	7	.	.	.
5180	2026	1	Sys	Sys	NNP
5180	2026	2	.	.	NNP
5180	2026	3	,	,	,
5180	2026	4	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	2026	5	v.	v.	IN
5180	2026	6	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	2026	7	,	,	,
5180	2026	8	512	512	CD
5180	2026	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2026	10	622	622	CD
5180	2026	11	,	,	,
5180	2026	12	660	660	CD
5180	2026	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2026	14	1994	1994	CD
5180	2026	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2026	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2026	17	"	"	``
5180	2026	18	The	the	DT
5180	2026	19	taxes	taxis	NNS
5180	2026	20	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
5180	2026	21	in	in	IN
5180	2026	22	Minneapolis	Minneapolis	NNP
5180	2026	23	Star	Star	NNP
5180	2026	24	and	and	CC
5180	2026	25	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
5180	2026	26	Writers	Writers	NNPS
5180	2026	27	'	'	POS
5180	2026	28	Project	Project	NNP
5180	2026	29	.	.	.
5180	2027	1	.	.	.
5180	2028	1	.	.	.
5180	2029	1	targeted	target	VBD
5180	2029	2	a	a	DT
5180	2029	3	small	small	JJ
5180	2029	4	number	number	NN
5180	2029	5	of	of	IN
5180	2029	6	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	2029	7	,	,	,
5180	2029	8	and	and	CC
5180	2029	9	thus	thus	RB
5180	2029	10	threatened	threaten	VBD
5180	2029	11	to	to	TO
5180	2029	12	distort	distort	VB
5180	2029	13	the	the	DT
5180	2029	14	market	market	NN
5180	2029	15	for	for	IN
5180	2029	16	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	2029	17	.	.	.
5180	2029	18	"	"	''
5180	2029	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2030	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2030	2	internal	internal	JJ
5180	2030	3	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	2030	4	marks	mark	NNS
5180	2030	5	and	and	CC
5180	2030	6	citation	citation	NN
5180	2030	7	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	2030	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2030	9	.	.	.
5180	2031	1	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2031	2	P]atrons	P]atrons	NNP
5180	2031	3	at	at	IN
5180	2031	4	a	a	DT
5180	2031	5	library	library	NN
5180	2031	6	do	do	VBP
5180	2031	7	not	not	RB
5180	2031	8	have	have	VB
5180	2031	9	the	the	DT
5180	2031	10	right	right	NN
5180	2031	11	to	to	TO
5180	2031	12	make	make	VB
5180	2031	13	editorial	editorial	JJ
5180	2031	14	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	2031	15	regarding	regard	VBG
5180	2031	16	the	the	DT
5180	2031	17	availability	availability	NN
5180	2031	18	of	of	IN
5180	2031	19	certain	certain	JJ
5180	2031	20	material	material	NN
5180	2031	21	.	.	.
5180	2032	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2032	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	2032	3	the	the	DT
5180	2032	4	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
5180	2032	5	authority	authority	NN
5180	2032	6	of	of	IN
5180	2032	7	the	the	DT
5180	2032	8	library	library	NN
5180	2032	9	to	to	TO
5180	2032	10	make	make	VB
5180	2032	11	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
5180	2032	12	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	2032	13	regarding	regard	VBG
5180	2032	14	what	what	WP
5180	2032	15	books	book	NNS
5180	2032	16	,	,	,
5180	2032	17	magazines	magazine	NNS
5180	2032	18	,	,	,
5180	2032	19	or	or	CC
5180	2032	20	other	other	JJ
5180	2032	21	material	material	NN
5180	2032	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	2032	23	placed	place	VBN
5180	2032	24	on	on	IN
5180	2032	25	library	library	JJ
5180	2032	26	shelves	shelf	NNS
5180	2032	27	,	,	,
5180	2032	28	or	or	CC
5180	2032	29	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	2032	30	made	make	VBN
5180	2032	31	available	available	JJ
5180	2032	32	to	to	IN
5180	2032	33	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2032	34	.	.	.
5180	2033	1	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	2033	2	impose	impose	VBP
5180	2033	3	many	many	JJ
5180	2033	4	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	2033	5	on	on	IN
5180	2033	6	the	the	DT
5180	2033	7	use	use	NN
5180	2033	8	of	of	IN
5180	2033	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2033	10	systems	system	NNS
5180	2033	11	which	which	WDT
5180	2033	12	demonstrate	demonstrate	VBP
5180	2033	13	that	that	IN
5180	2033	14	the	the	DT
5180	2033	15	content	content	NN
5180	2033	16	of	of	IN
5180	2033	17	the	the	DT
5180	2033	18	library	library	NN
5180	2033	19	's	's	POS
5180	2033	20	offerings	offering	NNS
5180	2033	21	are	be	VBP
5180	2033	22	not	not	RB
5180	2033	23	determined	determine	VBN
5180	2033	24	by	by	IN
5180	2033	25	the	the	DT
5180	2033	26	general	general	JJ
5180	2033	27	public	public	NN
5180	2033	28	.	.	.
5180	2034	1	S.	S.	NNP
5180	2034	2	Rep.	Rep.	NNP
5180	2034	3	No	No	NNP
5180	2034	4	.	.	.
5180	2035	1	106	106	CD
5180	2035	2	-	-	SYM
5180	2035	3	141	141	CD
5180	2035	4	,	,	,
5180	2035	5	at	at	IN
5180	2035	6	8	8	CD
5180	2035	7	-	-	SYM
5180	2035	8	9	9	CD
5180	2035	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2035	10	1999	1999	CD
5180	2035	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2035	12	.	.	.
5180	2036	1	In	in	IN
5180	2036	2	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
5180	2036	3	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	2036	4	on	on	IN
5180	2036	5	public	public	JJ
5180	2036	6	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2036	7	'	'	POS
5180	2036	8	print	print	NN
5180	2036	9	collections	collection	NNS
5180	2036	10	from	from	IN
5180	2036	11	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	2036	12	on	on	IN
5180	2036	13	the	the	DT
5180	2036	14	provision	provision	NN
5180	2036	15	of	of	IN
5180	2036	16	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2036	17	access	access	NN
5180	2036	18	,	,	,
5180	2036	19	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2036	20	do	do	VBP
5180	2036	21	not	not	RB
5180	2036	22	rely	rely	VB
5180	2036	23	on	on	IN
5180	2036	24	the	the	DT
5180	2036	25	rationale	rationale	NN
5180	2036	26	adopted	adopt	VBN
5180	2036	27	in	in	IN
5180	2036	28	Mainstream	Mainstream	NNP
5180	2036	29	Loudoun	Loudoun	NNP
5180	2036	30	v.	v.	CC
5180	2036	31	Board	Board	NNP
5180	2036	32	of	of	IN
5180	2036	33	Trustees	Trustees	NNPS
5180	2036	34	of	of	IN
5180	2036	35	the	the	DT
5180	2036	36	Loudoun	Loudoun	NNP
5180	2036	37	County	County	NNP
5180	2036	38	Library	Library	NNP
5180	2036	39	,	,	,
5180	2036	40	2	2	CD
5180	2036	41	F.	F.	NNP
5180	2036	42	Supp	Supp	NNP
5180	2036	43	.	.	.
5180	2037	1	2d	2d	LS
5180	2037	2	783	783	CD
5180	2037	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2037	4	E.D.	E.D.	NNP
5180	2038	1	Va.	Virginia	NNP
5180	2038	2	1998	1998	CD
5180	2038	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2038	4	.	.	.
5180	2039	1	The	the	DT
5180	2039	2	Loudoun	Loudoun	NNP
5180	2039	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2039	4	reasoned	reason	VBD
5180	2039	5	that	that	IN
5180	2039	6	a	a	DT
5180	2039	7	library	library	NN
5180	2039	8	's	's	POS
5180	2039	9	decision	decision	NN
5180	2039	10	to	to	TO
5180	2039	11	block	block	VB
5180	2039	12	certain	certain	JJ
5180	2039	13	Web	web	NN
5180	2039	14	sites	site	NNS
5180	2039	15	fundamentally	fundamentally	RB
5180	2039	16	differs	differ	VBZ
5180	2039	17	from	from	IN
5180	2039	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2039	19	decision	decision	NN
5180	2039	20	to	to	TO
5180	2039	21	carry	carry	VB
5180	2039	22	certain	certain	JJ
5180	2039	23	books	book	NNS
5180	2039	24	but	but	CC
5180	2039	25	not	not	RB
5180	2039	26	others	other	NNS
5180	2039	27	,	,	,
5180	2039	28	in	in	IN
5180	2039	29	that	that	DT
5180	2039	30	unlike	unlike	IN
5180	2039	31	the	the	DT
5180	2039	32	money	money	NN
5180	2039	33	and	and	CC
5180	2039	34	shelf	shelf	NN
5180	2039	35	space	space	NN
5180	2039	36	consumed	consume	VBN
5180	2039	37	by	by	IN
5180	2039	38	the	the	DT
5180	2039	39	library	library	NN
5180	2039	40	's	's	POS
5180	2039	41	provision	provision	NN
5180	2039	42	of	of	IN
5180	2039	43	print	print	NN
5180	2039	44	materials	material	NNS
5180	2039	45	,	,	,
5180	2039	46	"	"	''
5180	2039	47	no	no	DT
5180	2039	48	appreciable	appreciable	JJ
5180	2039	49	expenditure	expenditure	NN
5180	2039	50	of	of	IN
5180	2039	51	library	library	JJ
5180	2039	52	time	time	NN
5180	2039	53	or	or	CC
5180	2039	54	resources	resource	NNS
5180	2039	55	is	be	VBZ
5180	2039	56	required	require	VBN
5180	2039	57	to	to	TO
5180	2039	58	make	make	VB
5180	2039	59	a	a	DT
5180	2039	60	particular	particular	JJ
5180	2039	61	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2039	62	publication	publication	NN
5180	2039	63	available	available	JJ
5180	2039	64	"	"	``
5180	2039	65	once	once	IN
5180	2039	66	the	the	DT
5180	2039	67	library	library	NN
5180	2039	68	has	have	VBZ
5180	2039	69	acquired	acquire	VBN
5180	2039	70	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2039	71	access	access	NN
5180	2039	72	.	.	.
5180	2040	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	2041	1	at	at	IN
5180	2041	2	793	793	CD
5180	2041	3	-	-	SYM
5180	2041	4	94	94	CD
5180	2041	5	.	.	.
5180	2042	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2042	2	disagree	disagree	VBP
5180	2042	3	.	.	.
5180	2043	1	Nearly	nearly	RB
5180	2043	2	every	every	DT
5180	2043	3	librarian	librarian	NN
5180	2043	4	who	who	WP
5180	2043	5	testified	testify	VBD
5180	2043	6	at	at	IN
5180	2043	7	trial	trial	NN
5180	2043	8	stated	state	VBD
5180	2043	9	that	that	IN
5180	2043	10	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2043	11	'	'	POS
5180	2043	12	demand	demand	NN
5180	2043	13	for	for	IN
5180	2043	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2043	15	access	access	NN
5180	2043	16	exceeds	exceed	VBZ
5180	2043	17	the	the	DT
5180	2043	18	library	library	NN
5180	2043	19	's	's	POS
5180	2043	20	supply	supply	NN
5180	2043	21	of	of	IN
5180	2043	22	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2043	23	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	2043	24	.	.	.
5180	2044	1	Under	under	IN
5180	2044	2	such	such	JJ
5180	2044	3	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
5180	2044	4	,	,	,
5180	2044	5	every	every	DT
5180	2044	6	time	time	NN
5180	2044	7	library	library	NN
5180	2044	8	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2044	9	visit	visit	VBP
5180	2044	10	a	a	DT
5180	2044	11	Web	web	NN
5180	2044	12	site	site	NN
5180	2044	13	,	,	,
5180	2044	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2044	15	deny	deny	VBP
5180	2044	16	other	other	JJ
5180	2044	17	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2044	18	waiting	wait	VBG
5180	2044	19	to	to	TO
5180	2044	20	use	use	VB
5180	2044	21	the	the	DT
5180	2044	22	terminal	terminal	JJ
5180	2044	23	access	access	NN
5180	2044	24	to	to	IN
5180	2044	25	other	other	JJ
5180	2044	26	Web	web	NN
5180	2044	27	sites	site	NNS
5180	2044	28	.	.	.
5180	2045	1	Just	just	RB
5180	2045	2	as	as	IN
5180	2045	3	the	the	DT
5180	2045	4	scarcity	scarcity	NN
5180	2045	5	of	of	IN
5180	2045	6	a	a	DT
5180	2045	7	library	library	NN
5180	2045	8	's	's	POS
5180	2045	9	budget	budget	NN
5180	2045	10	and	and	CC
5180	2045	11	shelf	shelf	NN
5180	2045	12	space	space	NN
5180	2045	13	constrains	constrain	VBZ
5180	2045	14	a	a	DT
5180	2045	15	library	library	NN
5180	2045	16	's	's	POS
5180	2045	17	ability	ability	NN
5180	2045	18	to	to	TO
5180	2045	19	provide	provide	VB
5180	2045	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2045	21	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2045	22	with	with	IN
5180	2045	23	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
5180	2045	24	access	access	NN
5180	2045	25	to	to	IN
5180	2045	26	print	print	NN
5180	2045	27	materials	material	NNS
5180	2045	28	,	,	,
5180	2045	29	the	the	DT
5180	2045	30	scarcity	scarcity	NN
5180	2045	31	of	of	IN
5180	2045	32	time	time	NN
5180	2045	33	at	at	IN
5180	2045	34	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2045	35	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	2045	36	constrains	constrain	VBZ
5180	2045	37	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2045	38	'	'	POS
5180	2045	39	ability	ability	NN
5180	2045	40	to	to	TO
5180	2045	41	provide	provide	VB
5180	2045	42	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2045	43	with	with	IN
5180	2045	44	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
5180	2045	45	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2045	46	access	access	NN
5180	2045	47	:	:	:
5180	2045	48	The	the	DT
5180	2045	49	same	same	JJ
5180	2045	50	budget	budget	NN
5180	2045	51	concerns	concern	NNS
5180	2045	52	constraining	constrain	VBG
5180	2045	53	the	the	DT
5180	2045	54	number	number	NN
5180	2045	55	of	of	IN
5180	2045	56	books	book	NNS
5180	2045	57	that	that	WDT
5180	2045	58	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2045	59	can	can	MD
5180	2045	60	offer	offer	VB
5180	2045	61	also	also	RB
5180	2045	62	limits	limit	VBZ
5180	2045	63	the	the	DT
5180	2045	64	number	number	NN
5180	2045	65	of	of	IN
5180	2045	66	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	2045	67	,	,	,
5180	2045	68	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2045	69	accounts	account	NNS
5180	2045	70	,	,	,
5180	2045	71	and	and	CC
5180	2045	72	speed	speed	NN
5180	2045	73	of	of	IN
5180	2045	74	access	access	NN
5180	2045	75	links	link	NNS
5180	2045	76	that	that	WDT
5180	2045	77	can	can	MD
5180	2045	78	be	be	VB
5180	2045	79	purchased	purchase	VBN
5180	2045	80	,	,	,
5180	2045	81	and	and	CC
5180	2045	82	thus	thus	RB
5180	2045	83	the	the	DT
5180	2045	84	number	number	NN
5180	2045	85	of	of	IN
5180	2045	86	Web	web	NN
5180	2045	87	pages	page	NNS
5180	2045	88	that	that	IN
5180	2045	89	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2045	90	can	can	MD
5180	2045	91	view	view	VB
5180	2045	92	.	.	.
5180	2046	1	This	this	DT
5180	2046	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	2046	3	clear	clear	JJ
5180	2046	4	to	to	IN
5180	2046	5	anyone	anyone	NN
5180	2046	6	who	who	WP
5180	2046	7	has	have	VBZ
5180	2046	8	been	be	VBN
5180	2046	9	denied	deny	VBN
5180	2046	10	access	access	NN
5180	2046	11	to	to	IN
5180	2046	12	a	a	DT
5180	2046	13	Website	website	NN
5180	2046	14	because	because	IN
5180	2046	15	no	no	DT
5180	2046	16	terminal	terminal	NN
5180	2046	17	was	be	VBD
5180	2046	18	unoccupied	unoccupied	JJ
5180	2046	19	.	.	.
5180	2047	1	Mark	Mark	NNP
5180	2047	2	S.	S.	NNP
5180	2047	3	Nadel	Nadel	NNP
5180	2047	4	,	,	,
5180	2047	5	The	the	DT
5180	2047	6	First	First	NNP
5180	2047	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2047	8	's	's	POS
5180	2047	9	Limitations	Limitations	NNPS
5180	2047	10	on	on	IN
5180	2047	11	the	the	DT
5180	2047	12	Use	Use	NNP
5180	2047	13	of	of	IN
5180	2047	14	Internet	Internet	NNP
5180	2047	15	Filtering	Filtering	NNP
5180	2047	16	in	in	IN
5180	2047	17	Public	Public	NNP
5180	2047	18	and	and	CC
5180	2047	19	School	School	NNP
5180	2047	20	Libraries	Libraries	NNPS
5180	2047	21	:	:	:
5180	2047	22	What	what	WP
5180	2047	23	Content	content	NN
5180	2047	24	Can	Can	MD
5180	2047	25	Libraries	library	NNS
5180	2047	26	Exclude	exclude	VB
5180	2047	27	?	?	.
5180	2047	28	,	,	,
5180	2047	29	78	78	CD
5180	2047	30	Tex	tex	NN
5180	2047	31	.	.	.
5180	2048	1	L.	L.	NNP
5180	2048	2	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
5180	2049	1	1117	1117	CD
5180	2049	2	,	,	,
5180	2049	3	1128	1128	CD
5180	2049	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2049	5	2000	2000	CD
5180	2049	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2049	7	.	.	.
5180	2050	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2050	2	have	have	VBP
5180	2050	3	found	find	VBN
5180	2050	4	that	that	IN
5180	2050	5	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	2050	6	14.3	14.3	CD
5180	2050	7	million	million	CD
5180	2050	8	Americans	Americans	NNPS
5180	2050	9	access	access	VBP
5180	2050	10	the	the	DT
5180	2050	11	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2050	12	at	at	IN
5180	2050	13	a	a	DT
5180	2050	14	public	public	JJ
5180	2050	15	library	library	NN
5180	2050	16	,	,	,
5180	2050	17	and	and	CC
5180	2050	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2050	19	access	access	NN
5180	2050	20	at	at	IN
5180	2050	21	public	public	JJ
5180	2050	22	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2050	23	is	be	VBZ
5180	2050	24	more	more	RBR
5180	2050	25	often	often	RB
5180	2050	26	used	use	VBN
5180	2050	27	by	by	IN
5180	2050	28	those	those	DT
5180	2050	29	with	with	IN
5180	2050	30	lower	low	JJR
5180	2050	31	incomes	income	NNS
5180	2050	32	than	than	IN
5180	2050	33	those	those	DT
5180	2050	34	with	with	IN
5180	2050	35	higher	high	JJR
5180	2050	36	incomes	income	NNS
5180	2050	37	.	.	.
5180	2051	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2051	2	found	find	VBD
5180	2051	3	that	that	IN
5180	2051	4	about	about	RB
5180	2051	5	20.3	20.3	CD
5180	2051	6	%	%	NN
5180	2051	7	of	of	IN
5180	2051	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2051	9	users	user	NNS
5180	2051	10	with	with	IN
5180	2051	11	household	household	NN
5180	2051	12	family	family	NN
5180	2051	13	income	income	NN
5180	2051	14	of	of	IN
5180	2051	15	less	less	JJR
5180	2051	16	than	than	IN
5180	2051	17	$	$	$
5180	2051	18	15,000	15,000	CD
5180	2051	19	per	per	IN
5180	2051	20	year	year	NN
5180	2051	21	use	use	VBP
5180	2051	22	public	public	JJ
5180	2051	23	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2051	24	for	for	IN
5180	2051	25	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2051	26	access	access	NN
5180	2051	27	,	,	,
5180	2051	28	and	and	CC
5180	2051	29	approximately	approximately	RB
5180	2051	30	70	70	CD
5180	2051	31	%	%	NN
5180	2051	32	of	of	IN
5180	2051	33	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2051	34	serving	serve	VBG
5180	2051	35	communities	community	NNS
5180	2051	36	with	with	IN
5180	2051	37	poverty	poverty	NN
5180	2051	38	levels	level	NNS
5180	2051	39	in	in	IN
5180	2051	40	excess	excess	NN
5180	2051	41	of	of	IN
5180	2051	42	40	40	CD
5180	2051	43	%	%	NN
5180	2051	44	receive	receive	JJ
5180	2051	45	E	e	NN
5180	2051	46	-	-	NN
5180	2051	47	rate	rate	NN
5180	2051	48	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	2051	49	.	.	.
5180	2052	1	The	the	DT
5180	2052	2	widespread	widespread	JJ
5180	2052	3	availability	availability	NN
5180	2052	4	of	of	IN
5180	2052	5	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2052	6	access	access	NN
5180	2052	7	in	in	IN
5180	2052	8	public	public	JJ
5180	2052	9	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2052	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	2052	11	due	due	JJ
5180	2052	12	,	,	,
5180	2052	13	in	in	IN
5180	2052	14	part	part	NN
5180	2052	15	,	,	,
5180	2052	16	to	to	IN
5180	2052	17	the	the	DT
5180	2052	18	availability	availability	NN
5180	2052	19	of	of	IN
5180	2052	20	public	public	JJ
5180	2052	21	funding	funding	NN
5180	2052	22	,	,	,
5180	2052	23	including	include	VBG
5180	2052	24	state	state	NN
5180	2052	25	and	and	CC
5180	2052	26	local	local	JJ
5180	2052	27	funding	funding	NN
5180	2052	28	and	and	CC
5180	2052	29	the	the	DT
5180	2052	30	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2052	31	funding	funding	NN
5180	2052	32	programs	program	NNS
5180	2052	33	regulated	regulate	VBN
5180	2052	34	by	by	IN
5180	2052	35	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	2052	36	.	.	.
5180	2053	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2053	2	acknowledge	acknowledge	VBP
5180	2053	3	that	that	IN
5180	2053	4	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	2053	5	public	public	JJ
5180	2053	6	fora	fora	NNP
5180	2053	7	have	have	VBP
5180	2053	8	characteristics	characteristic	NNS
5180	2053	9	that	that	WDT
5180	2053	10	promote	promote	VBP
5180	2053	11	First	First	NNP
5180	2053	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2053	13	values	value	NNS
5180	2053	14	in	in	IN
5180	2053	15	ways	way	NNS
5180	2053	16	that	that	IN
5180	2053	17	the	the	DT
5180	2053	18	provision	provision	NN
5180	2053	19	of	of	IN
5180	2053	20	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2053	21	access	access	NN
5180	2053	22	in	in	IN
5180	2053	23	public	public	JJ
5180	2053	24	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2053	25	does	do	VBZ
5180	2053	26	not	not	RB
5180	2053	27	.	.	.
5180	2054	1	For	for	IN
5180	2054	2	example	example	NN
5180	2054	3	,	,	,
5180	2054	4	a	a	DT
5180	2054	5	significant	significant	JJ
5180	2054	6	virtue	virtue	NN
5180	2054	7	of	of	IN
5180	2054	8	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	2054	9	public	public	JJ
5180	2054	10	fora	fora	NN
5180	2054	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	2054	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2054	13	facilitation	facilitation	NN
5180	2054	14	of	of	IN
5180	2054	15	face	face	NN
5180	2054	16	-	-	HYPH
5180	2054	17	to	to	IN
5180	2054	18	-	-	HYPH
5180	2054	19	face	face	NN
5180	2054	20	communication	communication	NN
5180	2054	21	.	.	.
5180	2055	1	"	"	``
5180	2055	2	In	in	IN
5180	2055	3	a	a	DT
5180	2055	4	face	face	NN
5180	2055	5	-	-	HYPH
5180	2055	6	to-	to-	NN
5180	2055	7	face	face	NN
5180	2055	8	encounter	encounter	NN
5180	2055	9	there	there	EX
5180	2055	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	2055	11	a	a	DT
5180	2055	12	greater	great	JJR
5180	2055	13	opportunity	opportunity	NN
5180	2055	14	for	for	IN
5180	2055	15	the	the	DT
5180	2055	16	exchange	exchange	NN
5180	2055	17	of	of	IN
5180	2055	18	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	2055	19	and	and	CC
5180	2055	20	the	the	DT
5180	2055	21	propagation	propagation	NN
5180	2055	22	of	of	IN
5180	2055	23	views	view	NNS
5180	2055	24	.	.	.
5180	2056	1	.	.	.
5180	2057	1	.	.	.
5180	2058	1	.	.	.
5180	2058	2	"	"	''
5180	2059	1	Cornelius	Cornelius	NNP
5180	2059	2	,	,	,
5180	2059	3	473	473	CD
5180	2059	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2059	5	at	at	IN
5180	2059	6	798	798	CD
5180	2059	7	.	.	.
5180	2060	1	Face	face	NN
5180	2060	2	-	-	HYPH
5180	2060	3	to	to	IN
5180	2060	4	-	-	HYPH
5180	2060	5	face	face	NN
5180	2060	6	exchanges	exchange	NNS
5180	2060	7	also	also	RB
5180	2060	8	permit	permit	VBP
5180	2060	9	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	2060	10	to	to	TO
5180	2060	11	confront	confront	VB
5180	2060	12	listeners	listener	NNS
5180	2060	13	who	who	WP
5180	2060	14	would	would	MD
5180	2060	15	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	2060	16	not	not	RB
5180	2060	17	actively	actively	RB
5180	2060	18	seek	seek	VB
5180	2060	19	out	out	RP
5180	2060	20	the	the	DT
5180	2060	21	information	information	NN
5180	2060	22	that	that	WDT
5180	2060	23	the	the	DT
5180	2060	24	speaker	speaker	NN
5180	2060	25	has	have	VBZ
5180	2060	26	to	to	TO
5180	2060	27	offer	offer	VB
5180	2060	28	.	.	.
5180	2061	1	In	in	IN
5180	2061	2	contrast	contrast	NN
5180	2061	3	,	,	,
5180	2061	4	the	the	DT
5180	2061	5	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2061	6	operates	operate	VBZ
5180	2061	7	largely	largely	RB
5180	2061	8	by	by	IN
5180	2061	9	providing	provide	VBG
5180	2061	10	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	2061	11	with	with	IN
5180	2061	12	only	only	RB
5180	2061	13	that	that	DT
5180	2061	14	information	information	NN
5180	2061	15	that	that	IN
5180	2061	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2061	17	actively	actively	RB
5180	2061	18	seek	seek	VBP
5180	2061	19	out	out	RP
5180	2061	20	.	.	.
5180	2062	1	Although	although	IN
5180	2062	2	the	the	DT
5180	2062	3	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2062	4	does	do	VBZ
5180	2062	5	not	not	RB
5180	2062	6	permit	permit	VB
5180	2062	7	face	face	NN
5180	2062	8	-	-	HYPH
5180	2062	9	to	to	IN
5180	2062	10	-	-	HYPH
5180	2062	11	face	face	NN
5180	2062	12	communication	communication	NN
5180	2062	13	in	in	IN
5180	2062	14	the	the	DT
5180	2062	15	same	same	JJ
5180	2062	16	way	way	NN
5180	2062	17	that	that	IN
5180	2062	18	traditional	traditional	JJ
5180	2062	19	public	public	JJ
5180	2062	20	fora	fora	NN
5180	2062	21	do	do	VB
5180	2062	22	,	,	,
5180	2062	23	the	the	DT
5180	2062	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2062	25	,	,	,
5180	2062	26	as	as	IN
5180	2062	27	a	a	DT
5180	2062	28	medium	medium	NN
5180	2062	29	of	of	IN
5180	2062	30	expression	expression	NN
5180	2062	31	,	,	,
5180	2062	32	is	be	VBZ
5180	2062	33	significantly	significantly	RB
5180	2062	34	more	more	RBR
5180	2062	35	interactive	interactive	JJ
5180	2062	36	than	than	IN
5180	2062	37	the	the	DT
5180	2062	38	broadcast	broadcast	NN
5180	2062	39	media	medium	NNS
5180	2062	40	and	and	CC
5180	2062	41	the	the	DT
5180	2062	42	press	press	NN
5180	2062	43	.	.	.
5180	2063	1	"	"	``
5180	2063	2	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2063	3	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	2063	4	Web	web	NN
5180	2063	5	makes	make	VBZ
5180	2063	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2063	7	possible	possible	JJ
5180	2063	8	to	to	TO
5180	2063	9	establish	establish	VB
5180	2063	10	two	two	CD
5180	2063	11	-	-	HYPH
5180	2063	12	way	way	NN
5180	2063	13	linkages	linkage	NNS
5180	2063	14	with	with	IN
5180	2063	15	potential	potential	JJ
5180	2063	16	sympathizers	sympathizer	NNS
5180	2063	17	.	.	.
5180	2064	1	Unlike	unlike	IN
5180	2064	2	the	the	DT
5180	2064	3	unidirectional	unidirectional	JJ
5180	2064	4	nature	nature	NN
5180	2064	5	of	of	IN
5180	2064	6	most	most	JJS
5180	2064	7	mass	mass	NN
5180	2064	8	media	medium	NNS
5180	2064	9	,	,	,
5180	2064	10	websites	website	NNS
5180	2064	11	,	,	,
5180	2064	12	bulletin	bulletin	NN
5180	2064	13	boards	board	NNS
5180	2064	14	,	,	,
5180	2064	15	chatrooms	chatroom	NNS
5180	2064	16	,	,	,
5180	2064	17	and	and	CC
5180	2064	18	email	email	NN
5180	2064	19	are	be	VBP
5180	2064	20	potentially	potentially	RB
5180	2064	21	interactive	interactive	JJ
5180	2064	22	.	.	.
5180	2064	23	"	"	''
5180	2065	1	Seth	Seth	NNP
5180	2065	2	F.	F.	NNP
5180	2065	3	Kreimer	Kreimer	NNP
5180	2065	4	,	,	,
5180	2065	5	Technologies	Technologies	NNPS
5180	2065	6	of	of	IN
5180	2065	7	Protest	Protest	NNP
5180	2065	8	:	:	:
5180	2065	9	Insurgent	Insurgent	NNP
5180	2065	10	Social	Social	NNP
5180	2065	11	Movements	Movements	NNPS
5180	2065	12	and	and	CC
5180	2065	13	the	the	DT
5180	2065	14	First	First	NNP
5180	2065	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2065	16	in	in	IN
5180	2065	17	the	the	DT
5180	2065	18	Era	era	NN
5180	2065	19	of	of	IN
5180	2065	20	the	the	DT
5180	2065	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2065	22	,	,	,
5180	2065	23	150	150	CD
5180	2065	24	U.	U.	NNP
5180	2065	25	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
5180	2065	26	L.	L.	NNP
5180	2065	27	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
5180	2066	1	119	119	CD
5180	2066	2	,	,	,
5180	2066	3	130	130	CD
5180	2066	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2066	5	2001	2001	CD
5180	2066	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2066	7	.	.	.
5180	2067	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2067	2	acknowledge	acknowledge	VBP
5180	2067	3	that	that	IN
5180	2067	4	the	the	DT
5180	2067	5	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2067	6	's	's	POS
5180	2067	7	architecture	architecture	NN
5180	2067	8	is	be	VBZ
5180	2067	9	a	a	DT
5180	2067	10	human	human	JJ
5180	2067	11	creation	creation	NN
5180	2067	12	,	,	,
5180	2067	13	and	and	CC
5180	2067	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	2067	15	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	2067	16	subject	subject	JJ
5180	2067	17	to	to	IN
5180	2067	18	change	change	NN
5180	2067	19	.	.	.
5180	2068	1	The	the	DT
5180	2068	2	foregoing	foregoing	JJ
5180	2068	3	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	2068	4	of	of	IN
5180	2068	5	the	the	DT
5180	2068	6	unique	unique	JJ
5180	2068	7	speech	speech	NN
5180	2068	8	-	-	HYPH
5180	2068	9	enhancing	enhance	VBG
5180	2068	10	qualities	quality	NNS
5180	2068	11	of	of	IN
5180	2068	12	the	the	DT
5180	2068	13	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2068	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	2068	15	limited	limit	VBN
5180	2068	16	to	to	IN
5180	2068	17	the	the	DT
5180	2068	18	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2068	19	as	as	RB
5180	2068	20	currently	currently	RB
5180	2068	21	constructed	construct	VBN
5180	2068	22	.	.	.
5180	2069	1	Indeed	indeed	RB
5180	2069	2	,	,	,
5180	2069	3	the	the	DT
5180	2069	4	characteristics	characteristic	NNS
5180	2069	5	of	of	IN
5180	2069	6	the	the	DT
5180	2069	7	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2069	8	that	that	WDT
5180	2069	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2069	10	believe	believe	VBP
5180	2069	11	render	render	VBP
5180	2069	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2069	13	uniquely	uniquely	RB
5180	2069	14	suited	suit	VBD
5180	2069	15	to	to	TO
5180	2069	16	promote	promote	VB
5180	2069	17	First	First	NNP
5180	2069	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2069	19	values	value	NNS
5180	2069	20	may	may	MD
5180	2069	21	change	change	VB
5180	2069	22	as	as	IN
5180	2069	23	the	the	DT
5180	2069	24	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2069	25	's	's	POS
5180	2069	26	architecture	architecture	NN
5180	2069	27	evolves	evolve	NNS
5180	2069	28	.	.	.
5180	2070	1	See	see	VB
5180	2070	2	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
5180	2070	3	Lessig	Lessig	NNP
5180	2070	4	,	,	,
5180	2070	5	Reading	read	VBG
5180	2070	6	the	the	DT
5180	2070	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
5180	2070	8	in	in	IN
5180	2070	9	Cyberspace	Cyberspace	NNP
5180	2070	10	,	,	,
5180	2070	11	45	45	CD
5180	2070	12	Emory	emory	NN
5180	2070	13	L.J.	L.J.	NNP
5180	2071	1	869	869	CD
5180	2071	2	,	,	,
5180	2071	3	888	888	CD
5180	2071	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2071	5	1996	1996	CD
5180	2071	6	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2071	7	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2071	8	"	"	``
5180	2071	9	Cyberspace	cyberspace	NN
5180	2071	10	has	have	VBZ
5180	2071	11	no	no	DT
5180	2071	12	permanent	permanent	JJ
5180	2071	13	nature	nature	NN
5180	2071	14	,	,	,
5180	2071	15	save	save	VB
5180	2071	16	the	the	DT
5180	2071	17	nature	nature	NN
5180	2071	18	of	of	IN
5180	2071	19	a	a	DT
5180	2071	20	place	place	NN
5180	2071	21	of	of	IN
5180	2071	22	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
5180	2071	23	plasticity	plasticity	NN
5180	2071	24	.	.	.
5180	2072	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2072	2	do	do	VBP
5180	2072	3	n't	not	RB
5180	2072	4	find	find	VB
5180	2072	5	cyberspace	cyberspace	NN
5180	2072	6	,	,	,
5180	2072	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2072	8	build	build	VBP
5180	2072	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2072	10	.	.	.
5180	2073	1	")	")	``
5180	2073	2	;	;	:
5180	2073	3	see	see	VB
5180	2073	4	also	also	RB
5180	2073	5	Lawrence	Lawrence	NNP
5180	2073	6	Lessig	Lessig	NNP
5180	2073	7	,	,	,
5180	2073	8	The	the	DT
5180	2073	9	Death	Death	NNP
5180	2073	10	of	of	IN
5180	2073	11	Cyberspace	Cyberspace	NNP
5180	2073	12	,	,	,
5180	2073	13	57	57	CD
5180	2073	14	Wash.	Washington	NNP
5180	2073	15	&	&	CC
5180	2073	16	Lee	Lee	NNP
5180	2073	17	L.	L.	NNP
5180	2073	18	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
5180	2074	1	337	337	CD
5180	2074	2	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2074	3	2000	2000	CD
5180	2074	4	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2074	5	.	.	.
5180	2075	1	For	for	IN
5180	2075	2	First	First	NNP
5180	2075	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2075	4	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	2075	5	,	,	,
5180	2075	6	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	2075	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	2075	8	"	"	``
5180	2075	9	limited	limited	JJ
5180	2075	10	to	to	IN
5180	2075	11	works	work	NNS
5180	2075	12	which	which	WDT
5180	2075	13	,	,	,
5180	2075	14	taken	take	VBN
5180	2075	15	as	as	IN
5180	2075	16	a	a	DT
5180	2075	17	whole	whole	NN
5180	2075	18	,	,	,
5180	2075	19	appeal	appeal	VBP
5180	2075	20	to	to	IN
5180	2075	21	the	the	DT
5180	2075	22	prurient	prurient	JJ
5180	2075	23	interest	interest	NN
5180	2075	24	in	in	IN
5180	2075	25	sex	sex	NN
5180	2075	26	,	,	,
5180	2075	27	which	which	WDT
5180	2075	28	portray	portray	VBP
5180	2075	29	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	2075	30	conduct	conduct	NN
5180	2075	31	in	in	IN
5180	2075	32	a	a	DT
5180	2075	33	patently	patently	RB
5180	2075	34	offensive	offensive	JJ
5180	2075	35	way	way	NN
5180	2075	36	,	,	,
5180	2075	37	and	and	CC
5180	2075	38	which	which	WDT
5180	2075	39	,	,	,
5180	2075	40	taken	take	VBN
5180	2075	41	as	as	IN
5180	2075	42	a	a	DT
5180	2075	43	whole	whole	NN
5180	2075	44	,	,	,
5180	2075	45	do	do	VB
5180	2075	46	not	not	RB
5180	2075	47	have	have	VB
5180	2075	48	serious	serious	JJ
5180	2075	49	literary	literary	JJ
5180	2075	50	,	,	,
5180	2075	51	artistic	artistic	JJ
5180	2075	52	,	,	,
5180	2075	53	political	political	JJ
5180	2075	54	,	,	,
5180	2075	55	or	or	CC
5180	2075	56	scientific	scientific	JJ
5180	2075	57	value	value	NN
5180	2075	58	.	.	.
5180	2075	59	"	"	''
5180	2076	1	Miller	Miller	NNP
5180	2076	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	2076	3	California	California	NNP
5180	2076	4	,	,	,
5180	2076	5	413	413	CD
5180	2076	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2076	7	15	15	CD
5180	2076	8	,	,	,
5180	2076	9	24	24	CD
5180	2076	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2076	11	1973	1973	CD
5180	2076	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2076	13	.	.	.
5180	2077	1	The	the	DT
5180	2077	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	2077	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2077	4	in	in	IN
5180	2077	5	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	2077	6	explained	explain	VBD
5180	2077	7	:	:	:
5180	2077	8	The	the	DT
5180	2077	9	District	District	NNP
5180	2077	10	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2077	11	found	find	VBD
5180	2077	12	that	that	IN
5180	2077	13	at	at	IN
5180	2077	14	the	the	DT
5180	2077	15	time	time	NN
5180	2077	16	of	of	IN
5180	2077	17	trial	trial	NN
5180	2077	18	existing	exist	VBG
5180	2077	19	technology	technology	NN
5180	2077	20	did	do	VBD
5180	2077	21	not	not	RB
5180	2077	22	include	include	VB
5180	2077	23	any	any	DT
5180	2077	24	effective	effective	JJ
5180	2077	25	method	method	NN
5180	2077	26	for	for	IN
5180	2077	27	a	a	DT
5180	2077	28	sender	sender	NN
5180	2077	29	to	to	TO
5180	2077	30	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	2077	31	minors	minor	NNS
5180	2077	32	from	from	IN
5180	2077	33	obtaining	obtain	VBG
5180	2077	34	access	access	NN
5180	2077	35	to	to	IN
5180	2077	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2077	37	communications	communication	NNS
5180	2077	38	on	on	IN
5180	2077	39	the	the	DT
5180	2077	40	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2077	41	without	without	IN
5180	2077	42	also	also	RB
5180	2077	43	denying	deny	VBG
5180	2077	44	access	access	NN
5180	2077	45	to	to	IN
5180	2077	46	adults	adult	NNS
5180	2077	47	.	.	.
5180	2078	1	The	the	DT
5180	2078	2	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2078	3	found	find	VBD
5180	2078	4	no	no	DT
5180	2078	5	effective	effective	JJ
5180	2078	6	way	way	NN
5180	2078	7	to	to	TO
5180	2078	8	determine	determine	VB
5180	2078	9	the	the	DT
5180	2078	10	age	age	NN
5180	2078	11	of	of	IN
5180	2078	12	a	a	DT
5180	2078	13	user	user	NN
5180	2078	14	who	who	WP
5180	2078	15	is	be	VBZ
5180	2078	16	accessing	access	VBG
5180	2078	17	material	material	NN
5180	2078	18	through	through	IN
5180	2078	19	e	e	NN
5180	2078	20	-	-	NN
5180	2078	21	mail	mail	NN
5180	2078	22	,	,	,
5180	2078	23	mail	mail	NN
5180	2078	24	exploders	exploder	NNS
5180	2078	25	,	,	,
5180	2078	26	newsgroups	newsgroup	NNS
5180	2078	27	,	,	,
5180	2078	28	or	or	CC
5180	2078	29	chat	chat	NN
5180	2078	30	rooms	room	NNS
5180	2078	31	.	.	.
5180	2079	1	As	as	IN
5180	2079	2	a	a	DT
5180	2079	3	practical	practical	JJ
5180	2079	4	matter	matter	NN
5180	2079	5	,	,	,
5180	2079	6	the	the	DT
5180	2079	7	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2079	8	also	also	RB
5180	2079	9	found	find	VBD
5180	2079	10	that	that	IN
5180	2079	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2079	12	would	would	MD
5180	2079	13	be	be	VB
5180	2079	14	prohibitively	prohibitively	RB
5180	2079	15	expensive	expensive	JJ
5180	2079	16	for	for	IN
5180	2079	17	noncommercial	noncommercial	JJ
5180	2079	18	–	–	:
5180	2079	19	as	as	RB
5180	2079	20	well	well	RB
5180	2079	21	as	as	IN
5180	2079	22	some	some	DT
5180	2079	23	commercial	commercial	NN
5180	2079	24	–	–	:
5180	2079	25	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	2079	26	who	who	WP
5180	2079	27	have	have	VBP
5180	2079	28	Web	web	NN
5180	2079	29	sites	site	NNS
5180	2079	30	to	to	TO
5180	2079	31	verify	verify	VB
5180	2079	32	that	that	IN
5180	2079	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2079	34	users	user	NNS
5180	2079	35	are	be	VBP
5180	2079	36	adults	adult	NNS
5180	2079	37	.	.	.
5180	2080	1	These	these	DT
5180	2080	2	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	2080	3	must	must	MD
5180	2080	4	inevitably	inevitably	RB
5180	2080	5	curtail	curtail	VB
5180	2080	6	a	a	DT
5180	2080	7	significant	significant	JJ
5180	2080	8	amount	amount	NN
5180	2080	9	of	of	IN
5180	2080	10	adult	adult	NN
5180	2080	11	communication	communication	NN
5180	2080	12	on	on	IN
5180	2080	13	the	the	DT
5180	2080	14	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2080	15	.	.	.
5180	2081	1	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	2081	2	,	,	,
5180	2081	3	521	521	CD
5180	2081	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2081	5	at	at	IN
5180	2081	6	876	876	CD
5180	2081	7	-	-	SYM
5180	2081	8	77	77	CD
5180	2081	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2081	10	citation	citation	NNP
5180	2081	11	omitted	omit	VBN
5180	2081	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2081	13	.	.	.
5180	2082	1	To	to	IN
5180	2082	2	the	the	DT
5180	2082	3	extent	extent	NN
5180	2082	4	that	that	IN
5180	2082	5	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	2082	6	software	software	NN
5180	2082	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	2082	8	effective	effective	JJ
5180	2082	9	in	in	IN
5180	2082	10	identifying	identify	VBG
5180	2082	11	URLs	url	NNS
5180	2082	12	of	of	IN
5180	2082	13	Web	web	NN
5180	2082	14	pages	page	NNS
5180	2082	15	containing	contain	VBG
5180	2082	16	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	2082	17	or	or	CC
5180	2082	18	child	child	NN
5180	2082	19	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	2082	20	,	,	,
5180	2082	21	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2082	22	may	may	MD
5180	2082	23	use	use	VB
5180	2082	24	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	2082	25	software	software	NN
5180	2082	26	as	as	IN
5180	2082	27	a	a	DT
5180	2082	28	tool	tool	NN
5180	2082	29	for	for	IN
5180	2082	30	identifying	identify	VBG
5180	2082	31	URLs	url	NNS
5180	2082	32	in	in	IN
5180	2082	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2082	34	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2082	35	use	use	NN
5180	2082	36	logs	log	NNS
5180	2082	37	that	that	WDT
5180	2082	38	fall	fall	VBP
5180	2082	39	within	within	IN
5180	2082	40	these	these	DT
5180	2082	41	categories	category	NNS
5180	2082	42	,	,	,
5180	2082	43	without	without	IN
5180	2082	44	requiring	require	VBG
5180	2082	45	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2082	46	to	to	TO
5180	2082	47	use	use	VB
5180	2082	48	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	2082	49	software	software	NN
5180	2082	50	.	.	.
5180	2083	1	As	as	IN
5180	2083	2	the	the	DT
5180	2083	3	study	study	NN
5180	2083	4	of	of	IN
5180	2083	5	Benjamin	Benjamin	NNP
5180	2083	6	Edelman	Edelman	NNP
5180	2083	7	,	,	,
5180	2083	8	an	an	DT
5180	2083	9	expert	expert	JJ
5180	2083	10	witness	witness	NN
5180	2083	11	for	for	IN
5180	2083	12	the	the	DT
5180	2083	13	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	2083	14	,	,	,
5180	2083	15	demonstrates	demonstrate	VBZ
5180	2083	16	,	,	,
5180	2083	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2083	18	is	be	VBZ
5180	2083	19	possible	possible	JJ
5180	2083	20	to	to	TO
5180	2083	21	develop	develop	VB
5180	2083	22	software	software	NN
5180	2083	23	that	that	WDT
5180	2083	24	automatically	automatically	RB
5180	2083	25	tests	test	VBZ
5180	2083	26	a	a	DT
5180	2083	27	list	list	NN
5180	2083	28	of	of	IN
5180	2083	29	URLs	url	NNS
5180	2083	30	,	,	,
5180	2083	31	such	such	JJ
5180	2083	32	as	as	IN
5180	2083	33	the	the	DT
5180	2083	34	list	list	NN
5180	2083	35	of	of	IN
5180	2083	36	URLs	url	NNS
5180	2083	37	in	in	IN
5180	2083	38	a	a	DT
5180	2083	39	public	public	JJ
5180	2083	40	library	library	NN
5180	2083	41	's	's	POS
5180	2083	42	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2083	43	use	use	NN
5180	2083	44	logs	log	NNS
5180	2083	45	,	,	,
5180	2083	46	to	to	TO
5180	2083	47	determine	determine	VB
5180	2083	48	whether	whether	IN
5180	2083	49	any	any	DT
5180	2083	50	of	of	IN
5180	2083	51	those	those	DT
5180	2083	52	URLs	url	NNS
5180	2083	53	would	would	MD
5180	2083	54	be	be	VB
5180	2083	55	blocked	block	VBN
5180	2083	56	by	by	IN
5180	2083	57	a	a	DT
5180	2083	58	particular	particular	JJ
5180	2083	59	software	software	NN
5180	2083	60	filter	filter	NN
5180	2083	61	as	as	IN
5180	2083	62	falling	fall	VBG
5180	2083	63	within	within	IN
5180	2083	64	a	a	DT
5180	2083	65	particular	particular	JJ
5180	2083	66	category	category	NN
5180	2083	67	.	.	.
5180	2084	1	Alternatively	alternatively	RB
5180	2084	2	,	,	,
5180	2084	3	library	library	NN
5180	2084	4	staff	staff	NN
5180	2084	5	can	can	MD
5180	2084	6	review	review	VB
5180	2084	7	the	the	DT
5180	2084	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2084	9	use	use	NN
5180	2084	10	logs	log	VBZ
5180	2084	11	by	by	IN
5180	2084	12	hand	hand	NN
5180	2084	13	,	,	,
5180	2084	14	skimming	skim	VBG
5180	2084	15	the	the	DT
5180	2084	16	list	list	NN
5180	2084	17	of	of	IN
5180	2084	18	URLs	url	NNS
5180	2084	19	for	for	IN
5180	2084	20	those	those	DT
5180	2084	21	that	that	WDT
5180	2084	22	are	be	VBP
5180	2084	23	likely	likely	JJ
5180	2084	24	to	to	TO
5180	2084	25	correspond	correspond	VB
5180	2084	26	to	to	IN
5180	2084	27	Web	web	NN
5180	2084	28	pages	page	NNS
5180	2084	29	containing	contain	VBG
5180	2084	30	obscenity	obscenity	NN
5180	2084	31	or	or	CC
5180	2084	32	child	child	NN
5180	2084	33	pornography	pornography	NN
5180	2084	34	,	,	,
5180	2084	35	as	as	IN
5180	2084	36	is	be	VBZ
5180	2084	37	the	the	DT
5180	2084	38	practice	practice	NN
5180	2084	39	of	of	IN
5180	2084	40	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
5180	2084	41	's	's	POS
5180	2084	42	David	David	NNP
5180	2084	43	Biek	Biek	NNP
5180	2084	44	,	,	,
5180	2084	45	who	who	WP
5180	2084	46	testified	testify	VBD
5180	2084	47	as	as	IN
5180	2084	48	a	a	DT
5180	2084	49	government	government	NN
5180	2084	50	witness	witness	NN
5180	2084	51	.	.	.
5180	2085	1	Under	under	IN
5180	2085	2	either	either	DT
5180	2085	3	method	method	NN
5180	2085	4	,	,	,
5180	2085	5	public	public	JJ
5180	2085	6	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2085	7	can	can	MD
5180	2085	8	assure	assure	VB
5180	2085	9	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2085	10	of	of	IN
5180	2085	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2085	12	privacy	privacy	NN
5180	2085	13	by	by	IN
5180	2085	14	tracing	trace	VBG
5180	2085	15	a	a	DT
5180	2085	16	given	give	VBN
5180	2085	17	URL	url	NN
5180	2085	18	to	to	IN
5180	2085	19	a	a	DT
5180	2085	20	particular	particular	JJ
5180	2085	21	patron	patron	NN
5180	2085	22	only	only	RB
5180	2085	23	after	after	IN
5180	2085	24	determining	determine	VBG
5180	2085	25	that	that	IN
5180	2085	26	the	the	DT
5180	2085	27	URL	URL	NNP
5180	2085	28	corresponds	correspond	VBZ
5180	2085	29	to	to	IN
5180	2085	30	a	a	DT
5180	2085	31	Web	web	NN
5180	2085	32	site	site	NN
5180	2085	33	whose	whose	WP$
5180	2085	34	content	content	NN
5180	2085	35	is	be	VBZ
5180	2085	36	illegal	illegal	JJ
5180	2085	37	.	.	.
5180	2086	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2086	2	need	need	VBP
5180	2086	3	not	not	RB
5180	2086	4	decide	decide	VB
5180	2086	5	whether	whether	IN
5180	2086	6	these	these	DT
5180	2086	7	less	less	RBR
5180	2086	8	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	2086	9	alternatives	alternative	NNS
5180	2086	10	would	would	MD
5180	2086	11	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2086	12	be	be	VB
5180	2086	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	2086	14	.	.	.
5180	2087	1	See	see	VB
5180	2087	2	Fabulous	Fabulous	NNP
5180	2087	3	Assocs	Assocs	NNP
5180	2087	4	.	.	.
5180	2087	5	,	,	,
5180	2087	6	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	2087	7	v.	v.	CC
5180	2087	8	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
5180	2087	9	Pub	Pub	NNP
5180	2087	10	.	.	.
5180	2088	1	Util	util	IN
5180	2088	2	.	.	.
5180	2089	1	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
5180	2089	2	,	,	,
5180	2089	3	896	896	CD
5180	2089	4	F.2d	F.2d	NNP
5180	2089	5	780	780	CD
5180	2089	6	,	,	,
5180	2089	7	787	787	CD
5180	2089	8	n.6	n.6	CD
5180	2089	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2089	10	3d	3d	NNP
5180	2089	11	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	2089	12	.	.	.
5180	2090	1	1990	1990	CD
5180	2090	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2090	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2090	4	"	"	``
5180	2090	5	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2090	6	intimate	intimate	JJ
5180	2090	7	no	no	DT
5180	2090	8	opinion	opinion	NN
5180	2090	9	on	on	IN
5180	2090	10	the	the	DT
5180	2090	11	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
5180	2090	12	of	of	IN
5180	2090	13	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2090	14	a	a	DT
5180	2090	15	less	less	RBR
5180	2090	16	restrictive	restrictive	JJ
5180	2090	17	alternative	alternative	NN
5180	2090	18	to	to	IN
5180	2090	19	the	the	DT
5180	2090	20	challenged	challenge	VBN
5180	2090	21	law	law	NN
5180	2090	22	]	]	-RRB-
5180	2090	23	.	.	.
5180	2091	1	.	.	.
5180	2092	1	.	.	.
5180	2092	2	,	,	,
5180	2092	3	inasmuch	inasmuch	JJ
5180	2092	4	as	as	IN
5180	2092	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2092	6	consider	consider	VBP
5180	2092	7	merely	merely	RB
5180	2092	8	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2092	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2092	10	]	]	-RRB-
5180	2092	11	comparative	comparative	JJ
5180	2092	12	restrictiveness	restrictiveness	NN
5180	2092	13	.	.	.
5180	2093	1	.	.	.
5180	2094	1	.	.	.
5180	2095	1	.	.	.
5180	2095	2	"	"	''
5180	2095	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2095	4	.	.	.
5180	2096	1	Whereas	whereas	IN
5180	2096	2	the	the	DT
5180	2096	3	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	2096	4	provision	provision	NN
5180	2096	5	applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	2096	6	to	to	IN
5180	2096	7	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2096	8	that	that	WDT
5180	2096	9	receive	receive	VBP
5180	2096	10	LSTA	LSTA	NNP
5180	2096	11	grants	grant	NNS
5180	2096	12	permits	permit	VBZ
5180	2096	13	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	2096	14	for	for	IN
5180	2096	15	both	both	DT
5180	2096	16	adults	adult	NNS
5180	2096	17	and	and	CC
5180	2096	18	minors	minor	NNS
5180	2096	19	,	,	,
5180	2096	20	the	the	DT
5180	2096	21	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	2096	22	provision	provision	NN
5180	2096	23	applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	2096	24	to	to	IN
5180	2096	25	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2096	26	that	that	WDT
5180	2096	27	receive	receive	VBP
5180	2096	28	E	e	NN
5180	2096	29	-	-	NN
5180	2096	30	rate	rate	NN
5180	2096	31	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	2096	32	permits	permit	VBZ
5180	2096	33	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	2096	34	only	only	RB
5180	2096	35	during	during	IN
5180	2096	36	adult	adult	NN
5180	2096	37	use	use	NN
5180	2096	38	.	.	.
5180	2097	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	2097	2	,	,	,
5180	2097	3	the	the	DT
5180	2097	4	disabling	disable	VBG
5180	2097	5	provision	provision	NN
5180	2097	6	applicable	applicable	JJ
5180	2097	7	to	to	IN
5180	2097	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2097	9	receiving	receive	VBG
5180	2097	10	E	e	NN
5180	2097	11	-	-	NN
5180	2097	12	rate	rate	NN
5180	2097	13	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	2097	14	can	can	MD
5180	2097	15	not	not	RB
5180	2097	16	cure	cure	VB
5180	2097	17	the	the	DT
5180	2097	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
5180	2097	19	infirmity	infirmity	NN
5180	2097	20	of	of	IN
5180	2097	21	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	2097	22	's	's	POS
5180	2097	23	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	2097	24	that	that	IN
5180	2097	25	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2097	26	receiving	receive	VBG
5180	2097	27	E	e	NN
5180	2097	28	-	-	NN
5180	2097	29	rate	rate	NN
5180	2097	30	discounts	discount	NNS
5180	2097	31	use	use	VBP
5180	2097	32	software	software	NN
5180	2097	33	filters	filter	NNS
5180	2097	34	when	when	WRB
5180	2097	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2097	36	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2097	37	terminals	terminal	NNS
5180	2097	38	are	be	VBP
5180	2097	39	in	in	IN
5180	2097	40	use	use	NN
5180	2097	41	by	by	IN
5180	2097	42	minors	minor	NNS
5180	2097	43	.	.	.
5180	2098	1	Software	software	NN
5180	2098	2	filters	filter	NNS
5180	2098	3	sometimes	sometimes	RB
5180	2098	4	incorrectly	incorrectly	RB
5180	2098	5	block	block	VBP
5180	2098	6	access	access	NN
5180	2098	7	to	to	IN
5180	2098	8	,	,	,
5180	2098	9	inter	inter	NNP
5180	2098	10	alia	alia	NNS
5180	2098	11	,	,	,
5180	2098	12	Web	web	NN
5180	2098	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	2098	14	dealing	deal	VBG
5180	2098	15	with	with	IN
5180	2098	16	issues	issue	NNS
5180	2098	17	relating	relate	VBG
5180	2098	18	to	to	IN
5180	2098	19	sexual	sexual	JJ
5180	2098	20	identity	identity	NN
5180	2098	21	.	.	.
5180	2099	1	For	for	IN
5180	2099	2	example	example	NN
5180	2099	3	,	,	,
5180	2099	4	the	the	DT
5180	2099	5	"	"	``
5180	2099	6	Gay	Gay	NNP
5180	2099	7	and	and	CC
5180	2099	8	Lesbian	lesbian	JJ
5180	2099	9	Chamber	Chamber	NNP
5180	2099	10	of	of	IN
5180	2099	11	Southern	Southern	NNP
5180	2099	12	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
5180	2099	13	,	,	,
5180	2099	14	"	"	''
5180	2099	15	http://www.lambdalv.com	http://www.lambdalv.com	ADD
5180	2099	16	,	,	,
5180	2099	17	"	"	''
5180	2099	18	a	a	DT
5180	2099	19	forum	forum	NN
5180	2099	20	for	for	IN
5180	2099	21	the	the	DT
5180	2099	22	business	business	NN
5180	2099	23	community	community	NN
5180	2099	24	to	to	TO
5180	2099	25	develop	develop	VB
5180	2099	26	relationships	relationship	NNS
5180	2099	27	within	within	IN
5180	2099	28	the	the	DT
5180	2099	29	Las	Las	NNP
5180	2099	30	Vegas	Vegas	NNP
5180	2099	31	lesbian	lesbian	JJ
5180	2099	32	,	,	,
5180	2099	33	gay	gay	JJ
5180	2099	34	transsexual	transsexual	NN
5180	2099	35	,	,	,
5180	2099	36	and	and	CC
5180	2099	37	bisexual	bisexual	JJ
5180	2099	38	community	community	NN
5180	2099	39	"	"	''
5180	2099	40	was	be	VBD
5180	2099	41	blocked	block	VBN
5180	2099	42	by	by	IN
5180	2099	43	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	2099	44	as	as	IN
5180	2099	45	"	"	``
5180	2099	46	Adults	Adults	NNP
5180	2099	47	Only	only	RB
5180	2099	48	,	,	,
5180	2099	49	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	2099	50	.	.	.
5180	2099	51	"	"	''
5180	2100	1	The	the	DT
5180	2100	2	home	home	NN
5180	2100	3	page	page	NN
5180	2100	4	of	of	IN
5180	2100	5	the	the	DT
5180	2100	6	Lesbian	lesbian	JJ
5180	2100	7	and	and	CC
5180	2100	8	Gay	Gay	NNP
5180	2100	9	Havurah	Havurah	NNP
5180	2100	10	of	of	IN
5180	2100	11	the	the	DT
5180	2100	12	Long	Long	NNP
5180	2100	13	Beach	Beach	NNP
5180	2100	14	,	,	,
5180	2100	15	California	California	NNP
5180	2100	16	Jewish	Jewish	NNP
5180	2100	17	Community	Community	NNP
5180	2100	18	Center	Center	NNP
5180	2100	19	,	,	,
5180	2100	20	http://www.compupix.com/gay/havurah.htm	http://www.compupix.com/gay/havurah.htm	NNP
5180	2100	21	,	,	,
5180	2100	22	was	be	VBD
5180	2100	23	blocked	block	VBN
5180	2100	24	by	by	IN
5180	2100	25	N2H2	N2H2	NNP
5180	2100	26	as	as	IN
5180	2100	27	"	"	``
5180	2100	28	Adults	Adults	NNP
5180	2100	29	Only	only	RB
5180	2100	30	,	,	,
5180	2100	31	Pornography	Pornography	NNP
5180	2100	32	,	,	,
5180	2100	33	"	"	''
5180	2100	34	by	by	IN
5180	2100	35	Smartfilter	Smartfilter	NNP
5180	2100	36	as	as	IN
5180	2100	37	"	"	``
5180	2100	38	Sex	sex	NN
5180	2100	39	,	,	,
5180	2100	40	"	"	''
5180	2100	41	and	and	CC
5180	2100	42	by	by	IN
5180	2100	43	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	2100	44	as	as	IN
5180	2100	45	"	"	``
5180	2100	46	Sex	sex	NN
5180	2100	47	.	.	.
5180	2100	48	"	"	''
5180	2101	1	Among	among	IN
5180	2101	2	the	the	DT
5180	2101	3	types	type	NNS
5180	2101	4	of	of	IN
5180	2101	5	Web	web	NN
5180	2101	6	sites	site	NNS
5180	2101	7	that	that	WDT
5180	2101	8	filters	filter	NNS
5180	2101	9	erroneously	erroneously	RB
5180	2101	10	block	block	NN
5180	2101	11	are	be	VBP
5180	2101	12	Web	web	NN
5180	2101	13	sites	site	NNS
5180	2101	14	dealing	deal	VBG
5180	2101	15	with	with	IN
5180	2101	16	health	health	NN
5180	2101	17	issues	issue	NNS
5180	2101	18	,	,	,
5180	2101	19	such	such	JJ
5180	2101	20	as	as	IN
5180	2101	21	the	the	DT
5180	2101	22	Web	web	NN
5180	2101	23	site	site	NN
5180	2101	24	of	of	IN
5180	2101	25	the	the	DT
5180	2101	26	Willis	Willis	NNP
5180	2101	27	-	-	HYPH
5180	2101	28	Knighton	Knighton	NNP
5180	2101	29	Cancer	Cancer	NNP
5180	2101	30	Center	Center	NNP
5180	2101	31	,	,	,
5180	2101	32	a	a	DT
5180	2101	33	Shreveport	Shreveport	NNP
5180	2101	34	,	,	,
5180	2101	35	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
5180	2101	36	cancer	cancer	NN
5180	2101	37	treatment	treatment	NN
5180	2101	38	facility	facility	NN
5180	2101	39	,	,	,
5180	2101	40	http://cancerftr.wkmc.com	http://cancerftr.wkmc.com	NNP
5180	2101	41	,	,	,
5180	2101	42	which	which	WDT
5180	2101	43	was	be	VBD
5180	2101	44	blocked	block	VBN
5180	2101	45	by	by	IN
5180	2101	46	Websense	Websense	NNP
5180	2101	47	under	under	IN
5180	2101	48	the	the	DT
5180	2101	49	"	"	``
5180	2101	50	Sex	sex	NN
5180	2101	51	"	"	''
5180	2101	52	category	category	NN
5180	2101	53	.	.	.
5180	2102	1	Although	although	IN
5180	2102	2	in	in	IN
5180	2102	3	light	light	NN
5180	2102	4	of	of	IN
5180	2102	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2102	6	disposition	disposition	NN
5180	2102	7	of	of	IN
5180	2102	8	the	the	DT
5180	2102	9	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	2102	10	'	'	POS
5180	2102	11	Dole	Dole	NNP
5180	2102	12	claim	claim	NN
5180	2102	13	,	,	,
5180	2102	14	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2102	15	do	do	VBP
5180	2102	16	not	not	RB
5180	2102	17	rule	rule	VB
5180	2102	18	upon	upon	IN
5180	2102	19	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	2102	20	'	'	POS
5180	2102	21	contention	contention	NN
5180	2102	22	that	that	IN
5180	2102	23	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	2102	24	's	's	POS
5180	2102	25	conditioning	conditioning	NN
5180	2102	26	of	of	IN
5180	2102	27	funds	fund	NNS
5180	2102	28	on	on	IN
5180	2102	29	the	the	DT
5180	2102	30	installation	installation	NN
5180	2102	31	of	of	IN
5180	2102	32	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	2102	33	software	software	NN
5180	2102	34	violates	violate	VBZ
5180	2102	35	the	the	DT
5180	2102	36	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	2102	37	of	of	IN
5180	2102	38	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2102	39	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	2102	40	,	,	,
5180	2102	41	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2102	42	are	be	VBP
5180	2102	43	mindful	mindful	JJ
5180	2102	44	of	of	IN
5180	2102	45	the	the	DT
5180	2102	46	need	need	NN
5180	2102	47	to	to	TO
5180	2102	48	frame	frame	VB
5180	2102	49	the	the	DT
5180	2102	50	disputed	dispute	VBN
5180	2102	51	legal	legal	JJ
5180	2102	52	issues	issue	NNS
5180	2102	53	and	and	CC
5180	2102	54	to	to	TO
5180	2102	55	develop	develop	VB
5180	2102	56	a	a	DT
5180	2102	57	full	full	JJ
5180	2102	58	factual	factual	JJ
5180	2102	59	record	record	NN
5180	2102	60	for	for	IN
5180	2102	61	the	the	DT
5180	2102	62	certain	certain	JJ
5180	2102	63	appeal	appeal	NN
5180	2102	64	to	to	IN
5180	2102	65	the	the	DT
5180	2102	66	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	2102	67	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2102	68	.	.	.
5180	2103	1	Cf	cf	NN
5180	2103	2	.	.	.
5180	2104	1	Ashcroft	Ashcroft	NNP
5180	2104	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	2104	3	ACLU	ACLU	NNP
5180	2104	4	,	,	,
5180	2104	5	2002	2002	CD
5180	2104	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2104	7	LEXIS	lexis	NN
5180	2104	8	3421	3421	CD
5180	2104	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2104	10	May	May	NNP
5180	2104	11	13	13	CD
5180	2104	12	,	,	,
5180	2104	13	2002	2002	CD
5180	2104	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2104	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2104	16	remanding	remand	VBG
5180	2104	17	the	the	DT
5180	2104	18	case	case	NN
5180	2104	19	to	to	IN
5180	2104	20	the	the	DT
5180	2104	21	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2104	22	of	of	IN
5180	2104	23	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
5180	2104	24	to	to	TO
5180	2104	25	review	review	VB
5180	2104	26	the	the	DT
5180	2104	27	legal	legal	JJ
5180	2104	28	and	and	CC
5180	2104	29	factual	factual	JJ
5180	2104	30	bases	basis	NNS
5180	2104	31	on	on	IN
5180	2104	32	which	which	WDT
5180	2104	33	the	the	DT
5180	2104	34	District	District	NNP
5180	2104	35	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2104	36	granted	grant	VBD
5180	2104	37	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	2104	38	'	'	POS
5180	2104	39	motion	motion	NN
5180	2104	40	for	for	IN
5180	2104	41	a	a	DT
5180	2104	42	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
5180	2104	43	injunction	injunction	NN
5180	2104	44	after	after	IN
5180	2104	45	vacating	vacate	VBG
5180	2104	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2104	47	opinion	opinion	NN
5180	2104	48	that	that	WDT
5180	2104	49	relied	rely	VBD
5180	2104	50	on	on	IN
5180	2104	51	a	a	DT
5180	2104	52	different	different	JJ
5180	2104	53	ground	ground	NN
5180	2104	54	from	from	IN
5180	2104	55	the	the	DT
5180	2104	56	ones	one	NNS
5180	2104	57	used	use	VBN
5180	2104	58	by	by	IN
5180	2104	59	the	the	DT
5180	2104	60	District	District	NNP
5180	2104	61	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2104	62	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2104	63	.	.	.
5180	2105	1	Although	although	IN
5180	2105	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2105	3	do	do	VBP
5180	2105	4	not	not	RB
5180	2105	5	decide	decide	VB
5180	2105	6	the	the	DT
5180	2105	7	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	2105	8	'	'	POS
5180	2105	9	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2105	10	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	2105	11	claim	claim	VBP
5180	2105	12	,	,	,
5180	2105	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2105	14	think	think	VBP
5180	2105	15	that	that	IN
5180	2105	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2105	17	findings	finding	NNS
5180	2105	18	of	of	IN
5180	2105	19	fact	fact	NN
5180	2105	20	on	on	IN
5180	2105	21	public	public	JJ
5180	2105	22	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2105	23	,	,	,
5180	2105	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2105	25	use	use	NN
5180	2105	26	of	of	IN
5180	2105	27	the	the	DT
5180	2105	28	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2105	29	,	,	,
5180	2105	30	and	and	CC
5180	2105	31	the	the	DT
5180	2105	32	technological	technological	JJ
5180	2105	33	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	2105	34	of	of	IN
5180	2105	35	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2105	36	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	2105	37	software	software	NN
5180	2105	38	,	,	,
5180	2105	39	see	see	VB
5180	2105	40	supra	supra	NNP
5180	2105	41	Subsections	Subsections	NNPS
5180	2105	42	II.D	ii.d	NN
5180	2105	43	-	-	HYPH
5180	2105	44	E	e	NN
5180	2105	45	,	,	,
5180	2105	46	and	and	CC
5180	2105	47	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2105	48	framing	framing	NN
5180	2105	49	of	of	IN
5180	2105	50	the	the	DT
5180	2105	51	legal	legal	JJ
5180	2105	52	issue	issue	NN
5180	2105	53	here	here	RB
5180	2105	54	,	,	,
5180	2105	55	would	would	MD
5180	2105	56	allow	allow	VB
5180	2105	57	the	the	DT
5180	2105	58	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	2105	59	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2105	60	to	to	TO
5180	2105	61	decide	decide	VB
5180	2105	62	the	the	DT
5180	2105	63	issue	issue	NN
5180	2105	64	if	if	IN
5180	2105	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2105	66	deems	deem	VBZ
5180	2105	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2105	68	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	2105	69	to	to	TO
5180	2105	70	resolve	resolve	VB
5180	2105	71	this	this	DT
5180	2105	72	case	case	NN
5180	2105	73	.	.	.
5180	2106	1	The	the	DT
5180	2106	2	doctrine	doctrine	NN
5180	2106	3	of	of	IN
5180	2106	4	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2106	5	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	2106	6	"	"	''
5180	2106	7	holds	hold	VBZ
5180	2106	8	that	that	IN
5180	2106	9	the	the	DT
5180	2106	10	government	government	NN
5180	2106	11	'	'	``
5180	2106	12	may	may	MD
5180	2106	13	not	not	RB
5180	2106	14	deny	deny	VB
5180	2106	15	a	a	DT
5180	2106	16	benefit	benefit	NN
5180	2106	17	to	to	IN
5180	2106	18	a	a	DT
5180	2106	19	person	person	NN
5180	2106	20	on	on	IN
5180	2106	21	a	a	DT
5180	2106	22	basis	basis	NN
5180	2106	23	that	that	WDT
5180	2106	24	infringes	infringe	VBZ
5180	2106	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2106	26	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	2106	27	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2106	28	.	.	.
5180	2107	1	.	.	.
5180	2108	1	.	.	.
5180	2109	1	freedom	freedom	NN
5180	2109	2	of	of	IN
5180	2109	3	speech	speech	NN
5180	2109	4	'	'	''
5180	2109	5	even	even	RB
5180	2109	6	if	if	IN
5180	2109	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2109	8	has	have	VBZ
5180	2109	9	no	no	DT
5180	2109	10	entitlement	entitlement	NN
5180	2109	11	to	to	IN
5180	2109	12	that	that	DT
5180	2109	13	benefit	benefit	NN
5180	2109	14	.	.	.
5180	2109	15	"	"	''
5180	2110	1	Bd	Bd	NNP
5180	2110	2	.	.	.
5180	2111	1	of	of	IN
5180	2111	2	County	County	NNP
5180	2111	3	Comm'rs	Comm'rs	NNP
5180	2111	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	2111	5	Umbehr	Umbehr	NNP
5180	2111	6	,	,	,
5180	2111	7	518	518	CD
5180	2111	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2111	9	668	668	CD
5180	2111	10	,	,	,
5180	2111	11	674	674	CD
5180	2111	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2111	13	1996	1996	CD
5180	2111	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2111	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2111	16	quoting	quote	VBG
5180	2111	17	Perry	Perry	NNP
5180	2111	18	v.	v.	IN
5180	2111	19	Sindermann	Sindermann	NNP
5180	2111	20	,	,	,
5180	2111	21	408	408	CD
5180	2111	22	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2111	23	593	593	CD
5180	2111	24	,	,	,
5180	2111	25	597	597	CD
5180	2111	26	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2111	27	1972	1972	CD
5180	2111	28	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2111	29	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2111	30	.	.	.
5180	2112	1	In	in	IN
5180	2112	2	this	this	DT
5180	2112	3	case	case	NN
5180	2112	4	,	,	,
5180	2112	5	the	the	DT
5180	2112	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	2112	7	argue	argue	VBP
5180	2112	8	that	that	IN
5180	2112	9	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	2112	10	imposes	impose	VBZ
5180	2112	11	an	an	DT
5180	2112	12	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2112	13	condition	condition	NN
5180	2112	14	on	on	IN
5180	2112	15	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2112	16	who	who	WP
5180	2112	17	receive	receive	VBP
5180	2112	18	E	e	NN
5180	2112	19	-	-	NN
5180	2112	20	rate	rate	NN
5180	2112	21	and	and	CC
5180	2112	22	LSTA	lsta	JJ
5180	2112	23	subsidies	subsidy	NNS
5180	2112	24	by	by	IN
5180	2112	25	requiring	require	VBG
5180	2112	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2112	27	,	,	,
5180	2112	28	as	as	IN
5180	2112	29	a	a	DT
5180	2112	30	condition	condition	NN
5180	2112	31	on	on	IN
5180	2112	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2112	33	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	2112	34	of	of	IN
5180	2112	35	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2112	36	funds	fund	NNS
5180	2112	37	,	,	,
5180	2112	38	to	to	TO
5180	2112	39	surrender	surrender	VB
5180	2112	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2112	41	First	First	NNP
5180	2112	42	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2112	43	right	right	NN
5180	2112	44	to	to	TO
5180	2112	45	provide	provide	VB
5180	2112	46	the	the	DT
5180	2112	47	public	public	NN
5180	2112	48	with	with	IN
5180	2112	49	access	access	NN
5180	2112	50	to	to	IN
5180	2112	51	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	2112	52	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2112	53	speech	speech	NN
5180	2112	54	.	.	.
5180	2113	1	Under	under	IN
5180	2113	2	this	this	DT
5180	2113	3	theory	theory	NN
5180	2113	4	,	,	,
5180	2113	5	even	even	RB
5180	2113	6	if	if	IN
5180	2113	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2113	8	does	do	VBZ
5180	2113	9	not	not	RB
5180	2113	10	violate	violate	VB
5180	2113	11	the	the	DT
5180	2113	12	First	First	NNP
5180	2113	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2113	14	for	for	IN
5180	2113	15	a	a	DT
5180	2113	16	public	public	JJ
5180	2113	17	library	library	NN
5180	2113	18	to	to	TO
5180	2113	19	use	use	VB
5180	2113	20	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	2113	21	software	software	NN
5180	2113	22	,	,	,
5180	2113	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2113	24	nonetheless	nonetheless	RB
5180	2113	25	violates	violate	VBZ
5180	2113	26	the	the	DT
5180	2113	27	First	First	NNP
5180	2113	28	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2113	29	for	for	IN
5180	2113	30	the	the	DT
5180	2113	31	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2113	32	government	government	NN
5180	2113	33	to	to	TO
5180	2113	34	require	require	VB
5180	2113	35	public	public	JJ
5180	2113	36	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2113	37	to	to	TO
5180	2113	38	use	use	VB
5180	2113	39	filters	filter	NNS
5180	2113	40	as	as	IN
5180	2113	41	a	a	DT
5180	2113	42	condition	condition	NN
5180	2113	43	of	of	IN
5180	2113	44	the	the	DT
5180	2113	45	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	2113	46	of	of	IN
5180	2113	47	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2113	48	funds	fund	NNS
5180	2113	49	.	.	.
5180	2114	1	The	the	DT
5180	2114	2	government	government	NN
5180	2114	3	contends	contend	VBZ
5180	2114	4	that	that	IN
5180	2114	5	this	this	DT
5180	2114	6	case	case	NN
5180	2114	7	does	do	VBZ
5180	2114	8	not	not	RB
5180	2114	9	fall	fall	VB
5180	2114	10	under	under	IN
5180	2114	11	the	the	DT
5180	2114	12	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2114	13	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	2114	14	framework	framework	VBP
5180	2114	15	because	because	IN
5180	2114	16	:	:	:
5180	2114	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2114	18	1	1	LS
5180	2114	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2114	20	as	as	IN
5180	2114	21	state	state	NN
5180	2114	22	actors	actor	NNS
5180	2114	23	,	,	,
5180	2114	24	the	the	DT
5180	2114	25	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	2114	26	of	of	IN
5180	2114	27	the	the	DT
5180	2114	28	funds	fund	NNS
5180	2114	29	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2114	30	the	the	DT
5180	2114	31	public	public	JJ
5180	2114	32	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2114	33	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2114	34	are	be	VBP
5180	2114	35	not	not	RB
5180	2114	36	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2114	37	by	by	IN
5180	2114	38	the	the	DT
5180	2114	39	First	First	NNP
5180	2114	40	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2114	41	,	,	,
5180	2114	42	and	and	CC
5180	2114	43	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	2114	44	are	be	VBP
5180	2114	45	not	not	RB
5180	2114	46	being	be	VBG
5180	2114	47	asked	ask	VBN
5180	2114	48	to	to	TO
5180	2114	49	relinquish	relinquish	VB
5180	2114	50	any	any	DT
5180	2114	51	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	2114	52	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2114	53	rights	right	NNS
5180	2114	54	;	;	,
5180	2114	55	and	and	CC
5180	2114	56	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2114	57	2	2	LS
5180	2114	58	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2114	59	although	although	IN
5180	2114	60	library	library	NN
5180	2114	61	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2114	62	are	be	VBP
5180	2114	63	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
5180	2114	64	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2114	65	by	by	IN
5180	2114	66	the	the	DT
5180	2114	67	First	First	NNP
5180	2114	68	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2114	69	,	,	,
5180	2114	70	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2114	71	are	be	VBP
5180	2114	72	not	not	RB
5180	2114	73	the	the	DT
5180	2114	74	funding	funding	NN
5180	2114	75	recipients	recipient	NNS
5180	2114	76	in	in	IN
5180	2114	77	this	this	DT
5180	2114	78	case	case	NN
5180	2114	79	,	,	,
5180	2114	80	and	and	CC
5180	2114	81	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2114	82	may	may	MD
5180	2114	83	not	not	RB
5180	2114	84	rely	rely	VB
5180	2114	85	on	on	IN
5180	2114	86	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2114	87	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2114	88	'	'	POS
5180	2114	89	rights	right	NNS
5180	2114	90	in	in	IN
5180	2114	91	order	order	NN
5180	2114	92	to	to	TO
5180	2114	93	state	state	VB
5180	2114	94	an	an	DT
5180	2114	95	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2114	96	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	2114	97	claim	claim	NN
5180	2114	98	.	.	.
5180	2115	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2115	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	2115	3	an	an	DT
5180	2115	4	open	open	JJ
5180	2115	5	question	question	NN
5180	2115	6	in	in	IN
5180	2115	7	this	this	DT
5180	2115	8	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
5180	2115	9	whether	whether	IN
5180	2115	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	2115	11	may	may	MD
5180	2115	12	violate	violate	VB
5180	2115	13	the	the	DT
5180	2115	14	First	First	NNP
5180	2115	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2115	16	by	by	IN
5180	2115	17	restricting	restrict	VBG
5180	2115	18	the	the	DT
5180	2115	19	speech	speech	NN
5180	2115	20	of	of	IN
5180	2115	21	public	public	JJ
5180	2115	22	entities	entity	NNS
5180	2115	23	,	,	,
5180	2115	24	such	such	JJ
5180	2115	25	as	as	IN
5180	2115	26	municipalities	municipality	NNS
5180	2115	27	or	or	CC
5180	2115	28	public	public	JJ
5180	2115	29	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2115	30	.	.	.
5180	2116	1	The	the	DT
5180	2116	2	only	only	JJ
5180	2116	3	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2116	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	2116	5	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2116	6	opinion	opinion	NN
5180	2116	7	to	to	TO
5180	2116	8	weigh	weigh	VB
5180	2116	9	in	in	RP
5180	2116	10	on	on	IN
5180	2116	11	the	the	DT
5180	2116	12	issue	issue	NN
5180	2116	13	is	be	VBZ
5180	2116	14	a	a	DT
5180	2116	15	concurrence	concurrence	NN
5180	2116	16	by	by	IN
5180	2116	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
5180	2116	18	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
5180	2116	19	,	,	,
5180	2116	20	joined	join	VBN
5180	2116	21	by	by	IN
5180	2116	22	Chief	Chief	NNP
5180	2116	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
5180	2116	24	Burger	Burger	NNP
5180	2116	25	and	and	CC
5180	2116	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
5180	2116	27	Rehnquist	Rehnquist	NNP
5180	2116	28	,	,	,
5180	2116	29	in	in	IN
5180	2116	30	which	which	WDT
5180	2116	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2116	32	opined	opine	VBD
5180	2116	33	that	that	IN
5180	2116	34	municipalities	municipality	NNS
5180	2116	35	and	and	CC
5180	2116	36	other	other	JJ
5180	2116	37	arms	arm	NNS
5180	2116	38	of	of	IN
5180	2116	39	the	the	DT
5180	2116	40	state	state	NN
5180	2116	41	are	be	VBP
5180	2116	42	not	not	RB
5180	2116	43	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2116	44	by	by	IN
5180	2116	45	the	the	DT
5180	2116	46	First	First	NNP
5180	2116	47	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2116	48	from	from	IN
5180	2116	49	governmental	governmental	JJ
5180	2116	50	interference	interference	NN
5180	2116	51	with	with	IN
5180	2116	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2116	53	expression	expression	NN
5180	2116	54	.	.	.
5180	2117	1	See	see	VB
5180	2117	2	Colum	Colum	NNP
5180	2117	3	.	.	.
5180	2118	1	Broad	broad	JJ
5180	2118	2	.	.	.
5180	2119	1	Sys	Sys	NNP
5180	2119	2	.	.	NNP
5180	2119	3	,	,	,
5180	2119	4	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	2119	5	v.	v.	IN
5180	2119	6	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
5180	2119	7	Nat'l	Nat'l	NNP
5180	2119	8	Comm	Comm	NNP
5180	2119	9	.	.	NNP
5180	2119	10	,	,	,
5180	2119	11	412	412	CD
5180	2119	12	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2119	13	94	94	CD
5180	2119	14	,	,	,
5180	2119	15	139	139	CD
5180	2119	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2119	17	1973	1973	CD
5180	2119	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2119	19	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2119	20	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
5180	2119	21	,	,	,
5180	2119	22	J.	J.	NNP
5180	2119	23	,	,	,
5180	2119	24	concurring	concur	VBG
5180	2119	25	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2119	26	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2119	27	"	"	``
5180	2119	28	The	the	DT
5180	2119	29	First	First	NNP
5180	2119	30	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2119	31	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	2119	32	the	the	DT
5180	2119	33	press	press	NN
5180	2119	34	from	from	IN
5180	2119	35	governmental	governmental	JJ
5180	2119	36	interference	interference	NN
5180	2119	37	;	;	:
5180	2119	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2119	39	confers	confer	VBZ
5180	2119	40	no	no	DT
5180	2119	41	analogous	analogous	JJ
5180	2119	42	protection	protection	NN
5180	2119	43	on	on	IN
5180	2119	44	the	the	DT
5180	2119	45	Government	Government	NNP
5180	2119	46	.	.	.
5180	2120	1	")	")	``
5180	2120	2	;	;	:
5180	2120	3	see	see	VB
5180	2120	4	also	also	RB
5180	2120	5	i	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2120	6	d	d	VBN
5180	2120	7	.	.	.
5180	2121	1	at	at	IN
5180	2121	2	139	139	CD
5180	2121	3	n.7	n.7	NNP
5180	2121	4	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2121	5	"	"	``
5180	2121	6	The	the	DT
5180	2121	7	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	2121	8	of	of	IN
5180	2121	9	the	the	DT
5180	2121	10	First	First	NNP
5180	2121	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2121	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	2121	13	to	to	TO
5180	2121	14	protect	protect	VB
5180	2121	15	private	private	JJ
5180	2121	16	expression	expression	NN
5180	2121	17	and	and	CC
5180	2121	18	nothing	nothing	NN
5180	2121	19	in	in	IN
5180	2121	20	the	the	DT
5180	2121	21	guarantee	guarantee	NN
5180	2121	22	precludes	preclude	VBZ
5180	2121	23	the	the	DT
5180	2121	24	government	government	NN
5180	2121	25	from	from	IN
5180	2121	26	controlling	control	VBG
5180	2121	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2121	28	own	own	JJ
5180	2121	29	expression	expression	NN
5180	2121	30	or	or	CC
5180	2121	31	that	that	DT
5180	2121	32	of	of	IN
5180	2121	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2121	34	agents	agent	NNS
5180	2121	35	.	.	.
5180	2121	36	"	"	''
5180	2121	37	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2122	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2122	2	quoting	quote	VBG
5180	2122	3	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
5180	2122	4	Emerson	Emerson	NNP
5180	2122	5	,	,	,
5180	2122	6	The	the	DT
5180	2122	7	System	System	NNP
5180	2122	8	of	of	IN
5180	2122	9	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
5180	2122	10	of	of	IN
5180	2122	11	Expression	Expression	NNP
5180	2122	12	700	700	CD
5180	2122	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2122	14	1970	1970	CD
5180	2122	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2122	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2122	17	internal	internal	JJ
5180	2122	18	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	2122	19	marks	mark	NNS
5180	2122	20	omitted	omit	VBN
5180	2122	21	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2122	22	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2122	23	.	.	.
5180	2123	1	The	the	DT
5180	2123	2	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2123	3	has	have	VBZ
5180	2123	4	subsequently	subsequently	RB
5180	2123	5	made	make	VBN
5180	2123	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2123	7	clear	clear	JJ
5180	2123	8	,	,	,
5180	2123	9	however	however	RB
5180	2123	10	,	,	,
5180	2123	11	that	that	IN
5180	2123	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2123	13	considers	consider	VBZ
5180	2123	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2123	15	to	to	TO
5180	2123	16	be	be	VB
5180	2123	17	an	an	DT
5180	2123	18	open	open	JJ
5180	2123	19	question	question	NN
5180	2123	20	whether	whether	IN
5180	2123	21	municipalities	municipality	NNS
5180	2123	22	acting	act	VBG
5180	2123	23	in	in	IN
5180	2123	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2123	25	capacity	capacity	NN
5180	2123	26	as	as	IN
5180	2123	27	employers	employer	NNS
5180	2123	28	have	have	VBP
5180	2123	29	First	First	NNP
5180	2123	30	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2123	31	rights	right	NNS
5180	2123	32	,	,	,
5180	2123	33	suggesting	suggest	VBG
5180	2123	34	that	that	IN
5180	2123	35	the	the	DT
5180	2123	36	question	question	NN
5180	2123	37	whether	whether	IN
5180	2123	38	public	public	JJ
5180	2123	39	entities	entity	NNS
5180	2123	40	are	be	VBP
5180	2123	41	ever	ever	RB
5180	2123	42	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2123	43	by	by	IN
5180	2123	44	the	the	DT
5180	2123	45	First	First	NNP
5180	2123	46	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2123	47	also	also	RB
5180	2123	48	remains	remain	VBZ
5180	2123	49	open	open	JJ
5180	2123	50	.	.	.
5180	2124	1	See	see	VB
5180	2124	2	City	City	NNP
5180	2124	3	of	of	IN
5180	2124	4	Madison	Madison	NNP
5180	2124	5	Joint	Joint	NNP
5180	2124	6	Sch	Sch	NNP
5180	2124	7	.	.	.
5180	2125	1	Dist	dist	VB
5180	2125	2	.	.	.
5180	2126	1	No	no	UH
5180	2126	2	.	.	.
5180	2127	1	8	8	CD
5180	2127	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	2127	3	Wisc	Wisc	NNP
5180	2127	4	.	.	.
5180	2128	1	Employment	Employment	NNP
5180	2128	2	Relations	Relations	NNPS
5180	2128	3	Comm'n	comm'n	XX
5180	2128	4	,	,	,
5180	2128	5	429	429	CD
5180	2128	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2128	7	167	167	CD
5180	2128	8	,	,	,
5180	2128	9	175	175	CD
5180	2128	10	n.7	n.7	NNS
5180	2128	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2128	12	1976	1976	CD
5180	2128	13	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2128	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2128	15	"	"	``
5180	2128	16	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2128	17	need	need	VBP
5180	2128	18	not	not	RB
5180	2128	19	decide	decide	VB
5180	2128	20	whether	whether	IN
5180	2128	21	a	a	DT
5180	2128	22	municipal	municipal	JJ
5180	2128	23	corporation	corporation	NN
5180	2128	24	as	as	IN
5180	2128	25	an	an	DT
5180	2128	26	employer	employer	NN
5180	2128	27	has	have	VBZ
5180	2128	28	First	First	NNP
5180	2128	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2128	30	rights	right	NNS
5180	2128	31	to	to	TO
5180	2128	32	hear	hear	VB
5180	2128	33	the	the	DT
5180	2128	34	views	view	NNS
5180	2128	35	of	of	IN
5180	2128	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2128	37	citizens	citizen	NNS
5180	2128	38	and	and	CC
5180	2128	39	employees	employee	NNS
5180	2128	40	.	.	.
5180	2128	41	"	"	''
5180	2128	42	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2128	43	.	.	.
5180	2129	1	Several	several	JJ
5180	2129	2	courts	court	NNS
5180	2129	3	of	of	IN
5180	2129	4	appeals	appeal	NNS
5180	2129	5	have	have	VBP
5180	2129	6	cited	cite	VBN
5180	2129	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
5180	2129	8	Stewart	Stewart	NNP
5180	2129	9	's	's	POS
5180	2129	10	concurrence	concurrence	NN
5180	2129	11	in	in	IN
5180	2129	12	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
5180	2129	13	Broadcasting	Broadcasting	NNP
5180	2129	14	Systems	Systems	NNPS
5180	2129	15	and	and	CC
5180	2129	16	have	have	VBP
5180	2129	17	,	,	,
5180	2129	18	with	with	IN
5180	2129	19	little	little	JJ
5180	2129	20	discussion	discussion	NN
5180	2129	21	or	or	CC
5180	2129	22	analysis	analysis	NN
5180	2129	23	,	,	,
5180	2129	24	concluded	conclude	VBD
5180	2129	25	that	that	IN
5180	2129	26	a	a	DT
5180	2129	27	"	"	``
5180	2129	28	government	government	NN
5180	2129	29	.	.	.
5180	2130	1	.	.	.
5180	2131	1	.	.	.
5180	2132	1	speaker	speaker	NNP
5180	2132	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	2132	3	not	not	RB
5180	2132	4	itself	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2132	5	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2132	6	by	by	IN
5180	2132	7	the	the	DT
5180	2132	8	first	first	JJ
5180	2132	9	amendment	amendment	NN
5180	2132	10	.	.	.
5180	2132	11	"	"	''
5180	2133	1	Warner	Warner	NNP
5180	2133	2	Cable	Cable	NNP
5180	2133	3	Communications	Communications	NNP
5180	2133	4	,	,	,
5180	2133	5	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	2133	6	v.	v.	CC
5180	2133	7	City	City	NNP
5180	2133	8	of	of	IN
5180	2133	9	Niceville	Niceville	NNP
5180	2133	10	,	,	,
5180	2133	11	911	911	CD
5180	2133	12	F.2d	F.2d	NNS
5180	2133	13	634	634	CD
5180	2133	14	,	,	,
5180	2133	15	638	638	CD
5180	2133	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2133	17	11th	11th	JJ
5180	2133	18	Cir	cir	NN
5180	2133	19	.	.	.
5180	2134	1	1990	1990	CD
5180	2134	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2134	3	;	;	:
5180	2134	4	see	see	VB
5180	2134	5	also	also	RB
5180	2134	6	NAACP	NAACP	NNP
5180	2134	7	v.	v.	CC
5180	2134	8	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
5180	2134	9	,	,	,
5180	2134	10	891	891	CD
5180	2134	11	F.2d	F.2d	NNS
5180	2134	12	1555	1555	CD
5180	2134	13	,	,	,
5180	2134	14	1565	1565	CD
5180	2134	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2134	16	11th	11th	JJ
5180	2134	17	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	2134	18	.	.	.
5180	2135	1	1990	1990	CD
5180	2135	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2135	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2135	4	"	"	``
5180	2135	5	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2135	6	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	2135	7	First	First	NNP
5180	2135	8	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2135	9	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	2135	10	citizens	citizen	NNS
5180	2135	11	'	'	POS
5180	2135	12	speech	speech	NN
5180	2135	13	only	only	RB
5180	2135	14	from	from	IN
5180	2135	15	government	government	NN
5180	2135	16	regulation	regulation	NN
5180	2135	17	;	;	:
5180	2135	18	government	government	NN
5180	2135	19	speech	speech	NN
5180	2135	20	itself	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2135	21	is	be	VBZ
5180	2135	22	not	not	RB
5180	2135	23	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2135	24	by	by	IN
5180	2135	25	the	the	DT
5180	2135	26	First	First	NNP
5180	2135	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2135	28	.	.	.
5180	2136	1	")	")	LS
5180	2136	2	;	;	:
5180	2136	3	Student	student	NN
5180	2136	4	Gov't	Gov't	NNS
5180	2136	5	Ass'n	Ass'n	.
5180	2136	6	v.	v.	CC
5180	2136	7	Bd	Bd	NNP
5180	2136	8	.	.	.
5180	2137	1	of	of	IN
5180	2137	2	Trustees	Trustees	NNPS
5180	2137	3	of	of	IN
5180	2137	4	the	the	DT
5180	2137	5	Univ	Univ	NNP
5180	2137	6	.	.	.
5180	2138	1	of	of	IN
5180	2138	2	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
5180	2138	3	,	,	,
5180	2138	4	868	868	CD
5180	2138	5	F.2d	F.2d	NNS
5180	2138	6	473	473	CD
5180	2138	7	,	,	,
5180	2138	8	481	481	CD
5180	2138	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2138	10	1st	1st	NN
5180	2138	11	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	2138	12	.	.	.
5180	2139	1	1989	1989	CD
5180	2139	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2139	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2139	4	concluding	conclude	VBG
5180	2139	5	that	that	IN
5180	2139	6	the	the	DT
5180	2139	7	legal	legal	JJ
5180	2139	8	services	service	NNS
5180	2139	9	organization	organization	NN
5180	2139	10	run	run	VBN
5180	2139	11	by	by	IN
5180	2139	12	a	a	DT
5180	2139	13	state	state	NN
5180	2139	14	university	university	NN
5180	2139	15	,	,	,
5180	2139	16	"	"	''
5180	2139	17	as	as	IN
5180	2139	18	a	a	DT
5180	2139	19	state	state	NN
5180	2139	20	entity	entity	NN
5180	2139	21	,	,	,
5180	2139	22	itself	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2139	23	has	have	VBZ
5180	2139	24	no	no	DT
5180	2139	25	First	First	NNP
5180	2139	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2139	27	rights	right	NNS
5180	2139	28	"	"	''
5180	2139	29	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2139	30	;	;	:
5180	2139	31	Estiverne	Estiverne	NNP
5180	2139	32	v.	v.	IN
5180	2139	33	La.	Louisiana	NNP
5180	2140	1	State	State	NNP
5180	2140	2	Bar	Bar	NNP
5180	2140	3	Ass'n	Ass'n	NNPS
5180	2140	4	,	,	,
5180	2140	5	863	863	CD
5180	2140	6	F.2d	F.2d	NNS
5180	2140	7	371	371	CD
5180	2140	8	,	,	,
5180	2140	9	379	379	CD
5180	2140	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2140	11	5th	5th	JJ
5180	2140	12	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	2140	13	.	.	.
5180	2141	1	1989	1989	CD
5180	2141	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2141	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2141	4	noting	note	VBG
5180	2141	5	that	that	IN
5180	2141	6	"	"	``
5180	2141	7	the	the	DT
5180	2141	8	first	first	JJ
5180	2141	9	amendment	amendment	NN
5180	2141	10	does	do	VBZ
5180	2141	11	not	not	RB
5180	2141	12	protect	protect	VB
5180	2141	13	government	government	NN
5180	2141	14	speech	speech	NN
5180	2141	15	"	"	''
5180	2141	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2141	17	.	.	.
5180	2142	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2142	2	do	do	VBP
5180	2142	3	not	not	RB
5180	2142	4	think	think	VB
5180	2142	5	that	that	IN
5180	2142	6	the	the	DT
5180	2142	7	question	question	NN
5180	2142	8	whether	whether	IN
5180	2142	9	public	public	JJ
5180	2142	10	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2142	11	are	be	VBP
5180	2142	12	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2142	13	by	by	IN
5180	2142	14	the	the	DT
5180	2142	15	First	First	NNP
5180	2142	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2142	17	can	can	MD
5180	2142	18	be	be	VB
5180	2142	19	resolved	resolve	VBN
5180	2142	20	as	as	RB
5180	2142	21	simply	simply	RB
5180	2142	22	as	as	IN
5180	2142	23	these	these	DT
5180	2142	24	cases	case	NNS
5180	2142	25	suggest	suggest	VBP
5180	2142	26	.	.	.
5180	2143	1	This	this	DT
5180	2143	2	difficulty	difficulty	NN
5180	2143	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	2143	4	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBN
5180	2143	5	by	by	IN
5180	2143	6	the	the	DT
5180	2143	7	reasoning	reasoning	NN
5180	2143	8	of	of	IN
5180	2143	9	the	the	DT
5180	2143	10	Seventh	Seventh	NNP
5180	2143	11	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
5180	2143	12	in	in	IN
5180	2143	13	a	a	DT
5180	2143	14	case	case	NN
5180	2143	15	in	in	IN
5180	2143	16	which	which	WDT
5180	2143	17	that	that	DT
5180	2143	18	court	court	NN
5180	2143	19	considered	consider	VBD
5180	2143	20	whether	whether	IN
5180	2143	21	municipalities	municipality	NNS
5180	2143	22	are	be	VBP
5180	2143	23	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2143	24	by	by	IN
5180	2143	25	the	the	DT
5180	2143	26	First	First	NNP
5180	2143	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2143	28	and	and	CC
5180	2143	29	noted	note	VBD
5180	2143	30	that	that	IN
5180	2143	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2143	32	is	be	VBZ
5180	2143	33	an	an	DT
5180	2143	34	open	open	JJ
5180	2143	35	question	question	NN
5180	2143	36	that	that	WDT
5180	2143	37	could	could	MD
5180	2143	38	plausibly	plausibly	RB
5180	2143	39	be	be	VB
5180	2143	40	answered	answer	VBN
5180	2143	41	in	in	IN
5180	2143	42	the	the	DT
5180	2143	43	affirmative	affirmative	NN
5180	2143	44	,	,	,
5180	2143	45	yet	yet	CC
5180	2143	46	declined	decline	VBD
5180	2143	47	to	to	TO
5180	2143	48	decide	decide	VB
5180	2143	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2143	50	:	:	:
5180	2143	51	Only	only	RB
5180	2143	52	a	a	DT
5180	2143	53	few	few	JJ
5180	2143	54	cases	case	NNS
5180	2143	55	address	address	VBP
5180	2143	56	the	the	DT
5180	2143	57	question	question	NN
5180	2143	58	whether	whether	IN
5180	2143	59	municipalities	municipality	NNS
5180	2143	60	or	or	CC
5180	2143	61	other	other	JJ
5180	2143	62	state	state	NN
5180	2143	63	subdivisions	subdivision	NNS
5180	2143	64	or	or	CC
5180	2143	65	agencies	agency	NNS
5180	2143	66	have	have	VBP
5180	2143	67	any	any	DT
5180	2143	68	First	First	NNP
5180	2143	69	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2143	70	rights	right	NNS
5180	2143	71	.	.	.
5180	2144	1	.	.	.
5180	2145	1	.	.	.
5180	2146	1	.	.	.
5180	2147	1	The	the	DT
5180	2147	2	question	question	NN
5180	2147	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	2147	4	an	an	DT
5180	2147	5	open	open	JJ
5180	2147	6	one	one	NN
5180	2147	7	in	in	IN
5180	2147	8	this	this	DT
5180	2147	9	circuit	circuit	NN
5180	2147	10	,	,	,
5180	2147	11	and	and	CC
5180	2147	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2147	13	do	do	VBP
5180	2147	14	not	not	RB
5180	2147	15	consider	consider	VB
5180	2147	16	the	the	DT
5180	2147	17	answer	answer	NN
5180	2147	18	completely	completely	RB
5180	2147	19	free	free	JJ
5180	2147	20	from	from	IN
5180	2147	21	doubt	doubt	NN
5180	2147	22	.	.	.
5180	2148	1	For	for	IN
5180	2148	2	many	many	JJ
5180	2148	3	purposes	purpose	NNS
5180	2148	4	,	,	,
5180	2148	5	for	for	IN
5180	2148	6	example	example	NN
5180	2148	7	diversity	diversity	NN
5180	2148	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
5180	2148	9	and	and	CC
5180	2148	10	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
5180	2148	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2148	12	liability	liability	NN
5180	2148	13	,	,	,
5180	2148	14	municipalities	municipality	NNS
5180	2148	15	are	be	VBP
5180	2148	16	treated	treat	VBN
5180	2148	17	by	by	IN
5180	2148	18	the	the	DT
5180	2148	19	law	law	NN
5180	2148	20	as	as	IN
5180	2148	21	if	if	IN
5180	2148	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2148	23	were	be	VBD
5180	2148	24	persons	person	NNS
5180	2148	25	.	.	.
5180	2149	1	Monell	Monell	NNP
5180	2149	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	2149	3	Department	Department	NNP
5180	2149	4	of	of	IN
5180	2149	5	Social	Social	NNP
5180	2149	6	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	2149	7	,	,	,
5180	2149	8	436	436	CD
5180	2149	9	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2149	10	658	658	CD
5180	2149	11	,	,	,
5180	2149	12	690	690	CD
5180	2149	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2149	14	1978	1978	CD
5180	2149	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2149	16	;	;	:
5180	2149	17	Moor	Moor	NNP
5180	2149	18	v.	v.	IN
5180	2149	19	County	County	NNP
5180	2149	20	of	of	IN
5180	2149	21	Alameda	Alameda	NNP
5180	2149	22	,	,	,
5180	2149	23	411	411	CD
5180	2149	24	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2149	25	693	693	CD
5180	2149	26	,	,	,
5180	2149	27	717	717	CD
5180	2149	28	-	-	SYM
5180	2149	29	18	18	CD
5180	2149	30	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2149	31	1973	1973	CD
5180	2149	32	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2149	33	.	.	.
5180	2150	1	There	there	EX
5180	2150	2	is	be	VBZ
5180	2150	3	at	at	IN
5180	2150	4	least	least	JJS
5180	2150	5	an	an	DT
5180	2150	6	argument	argument	NN
5180	2150	7	that	that	IN
5180	2150	8	the	the	DT
5180	2150	9	marketplace	marketplace	NN
5180	2150	10	of	of	IN
5180	2150	11	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	2150	12	would	would	MD
5180	2150	13	be	be	VB
5180	2150	14	unduly	unduly	RB
5180	2150	15	curtailed	curtail	VBN
5180	2150	16	if	if	IN
5180	2150	17	municipalities	municipality	NNS
5180	2150	18	could	could	MD
5180	2150	19	not	not	RB
5180	2150	20	freely	freely	RB
5180	2150	21	express	express	VB
5180	2150	22	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2150	23	on	on	IN
5180	2150	24	matters	matter	NNS
5180	2150	25	of	of	IN
5180	2150	26	public	public	JJ
5180	2150	27	concern	concern	NN
5180	2150	28	,	,	,
5180	2150	29	including	include	VBG
5180	2150	30	the	the	DT
5180	2150	31	subsidization	subsidization	NN
5180	2150	32	of	of	IN
5180	2150	33	housing	housing	NN
5180	2150	34	and	and	CC
5180	2150	35	the	the	DT
5180	2150	36	demographic	demographic	JJ
5180	2150	37	makeup	makeup	NN
5180	2150	38	of	of	IN
5180	2150	39	the	the	DT
5180	2150	40	community	community	NN
5180	2150	41	.	.	.
5180	2151	1	To	to	IN
5180	2151	2	the	the	DT
5180	2151	3	extent	extent	NN
5180	2151	4	,	,	,
5180	2151	5	moreover	moreover	RB
5180	2151	6	,	,	,
5180	2151	7	that	that	IN
5180	2151	8	a	a	DT
5180	2151	9	municipality	municipality	NN
5180	2151	10	is	be	VBZ
5180	2151	11	the	the	DT
5180	2151	12	voice	voice	NN
5180	2151	13	of	of	IN
5180	2151	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2151	15	residents	resident	NNS
5180	2151	16	—	—	:
5180	2151	17	is	be	VBZ
5180	2151	18	,	,	,
5180	2151	19	indeed	indeed	RB
5180	2151	20	,	,	,
5180	2151	21	a	a	DT
5180	2151	22	megaphone	megaphone	NN
5180	2151	23	amplifying	amplify	VBG
5180	2151	24	voices	voice	NNS
5180	2151	25	that	that	WDT
5180	2151	26	might	may	MD
5180	2151	27	not	not	RB
5180	2151	28	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	2151	29	be	be	VB
5180	2151	30	audible	audible	JJ
5180	2151	31	—	—	:
5180	2151	32	a	a	DT
5180	2151	33	curtailment	curtailment	NN
5180	2151	34	of	of	IN
5180	2151	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2151	36	right	right	NN
5180	2151	37	to	to	TO
5180	2151	38	speak	speak	VB
5180	2151	39	might	may	MD
5180	2151	40	be	be	VB
5180	2151	41	thought	think	VBN
5180	2151	42	a	a	DT
5180	2151	43	curtailment	curtailment	NN
5180	2151	44	of	of	IN
5180	2151	45	the	the	DT
5180	2151	46	unquestioned	unquestioned	JJ
5180	2151	47	First	First	NNP
5180	2151	48	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2151	49	rights	right	NNS
5180	2151	50	of	of	IN
5180	2151	51	those	those	DT
5180	2151	52	residents	resident	NNS
5180	2151	53	.	.	.
5180	2152	1	See	see	VB
5180	2152	2	Meir	Meir	NNP
5180	2152	3	Dan	Dan	NNP
5180	2152	4	-	-	HYPH
5180	2152	5	Cohen	Cohen	NNP
5180	2152	6	,	,	,
5180	2152	7	"	"	``
5180	2152	8	Freedoms	freedom	NNS
5180	2152	9	of	of	IN
5180	2152	10	Collective	Collective	NNP
5180	2152	11	Speech	Speech	NNP
5180	2152	12	:	:	:
5180	2152	13	A	a	DT
5180	2152	14	Theory	Theory	NNP
5180	2152	15	of	of	IN
5180	2152	16	Protected	Protected	NNP
5180	2152	17	Communications	Communications	NNPS
5180	2152	18	by	by	IN
5180	2152	19	Organizations	Organizations	NNPS
5180	2152	20	,	,	,
5180	2152	21	Communities	Communities	NNPS
5180	2152	22	,	,	,
5180	2152	23	and	and	CC
5180	2152	24	the	the	DT
5180	2152	25	State	State	NNP
5180	2152	26	,	,	,
5180	2152	27	"	"	''
5180	2152	28	79	79	CD
5180	2152	29	Calif.	California	NNP
5180	2152	30	L.	L.	NNP
5180	2152	31	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
5180	2153	1	1229	1229	CD
5180	2153	2	,	,	,
5180	2153	3	1261	1261	CD
5180	2153	4	-	-	SYM
5180	2153	5	63	63	CD
5180	2153	6	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2153	7	1991	1991	CD
5180	2153	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2153	9	;	;	:
5180	2153	10	cf	cf	NN
5180	2153	11	.	.	.
5180	2154	1	Student	Student	NNP
5180	2154	2	Government	Government	NNP
5180	2154	3	Ass'n	Ass'n	''
5180	2154	4	v.	v.	CC
5180	2154	5	Board	Board	NNP
5180	2154	6	of	of	IN
5180	2154	7	Trustees	Trustees	NNP
5180	2154	8	,	,	,
5180	2154	9	supra	supra	NNP
5180	2154	10	,	,	,
5180	2154	11	868	868	CD
5180	2154	12	F.2d	F.2d	NNS
5180	2154	13	at	at	IN
5180	2154	14	482	482	CD
5180	2154	15	.	.	.
5180	2155	1	Thus	thus	RB
5180	2155	2	if	if	IN
5180	2155	3	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2155	4	law	law	NN
5180	2155	5	imposed	impose	VBD
5180	2155	6	a	a	DT
5180	2155	7	fine	fine	NN
5180	2155	8	on	on	IN
5180	2155	9	municipalities	municipality	NNS
5180	2155	10	that	that	WDT
5180	2155	11	passed	pass	VBD
5180	2155	12	resolutions	resolution	NNS
5180	2155	13	condemning	condemn	VBG
5180	2155	14	abortion	abortion	NN
5180	2155	15	,	,	,
5180	2155	16	one	one	PRP
5180	2155	17	might	may	MD
5180	2155	18	suppose	suppose	VB
5180	2155	19	that	that	IN
5180	2155	20	a	a	DT
5180	2155	21	genuine	genuine	JJ
5180	2155	22	First	First	NNP
5180	2155	23	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2155	24	issue	issue	NN
5180	2155	25	would	would	MD
5180	2155	26	be	be	VB
5180	2155	27	presented	present	VBN
5180	2155	28	.	.	.
5180	2156	1	Against	against	IN
5180	2156	2	this	this	DT
5180	2156	3	suggestion	suggestion	NN
5180	2156	4	can	can	MD
5180	2156	5	be	be	VB
5180	2156	6	cited	cite	VBN
5180	2156	7	the	the	DT
5180	2156	8	many	many	JJ
5180	2156	9	cases	case	NNS
5180	2156	10	which	which	WDT
5180	2156	11	hold	hold	VBP
5180	2156	12	that	that	IN
5180	2156	13	municipalities	municipality	NNS
5180	2156	14	lack	lack	VBP
5180	2156	15	standing	stand	VBG
5180	2156	16	to	to	TO
5180	2156	17	invoke	invoke	VB
5180	2156	18	the	the	DT
5180	2156	19	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
5180	2156	20	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2156	21	against	against	IN
5180	2156	22	actions	action	NNS
5180	2156	23	by	by	IN
5180	2156	24	the	the	DT
5180	2156	25	state	state	NN
5180	2156	26	.	.	.
5180	2157	1	E.g.	E.g.	NNP
5180	2157	2	,	,	,
5180	2157	3	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
5180	2157	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	2157	5	Miller	Miller	NNP
5180	2157	6	,	,	,
5180	2157	7	307	307	CD
5180	2157	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2157	9	433	433	CD
5180	2157	10	,	,	,
5180	2157	11	441	441	CD
5180	2157	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2157	13	1939	1939	CD
5180	2157	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2157	15	;	;	:
5180	2157	16	Williams	Williams	NNP
5180	2157	17	v.	v.	IN
5180	2157	18	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
5180	2157	19	&	&	CC
5180	2157	20	City	City	NNP
5180	2157	21	Council	Council	NNP
5180	2157	22	of	of	IN
5180	2157	23	Baltimore	Baltimore	NNP
5180	2157	24	,	,	,
5180	2157	25	289	289	CD
5180	2157	26	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2157	27	36	36	CD
5180	2157	28	,	,	,
5180	2157	29	40	40	CD
5180	2157	30	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2157	31	1933	1933	CD
5180	2157	32	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2157	33	;	;	:
5180	2157	34	City	City	NNP
5180	2157	35	of	of	IN
5180	2157	36	East	East	NNP
5180	2157	37	St.	St.	NNP
5180	2157	38	Louis	Louis	NNP
5180	2157	39	v.	v.	IN
5180	2157	40	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
5180	2157	41	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2157	42	for	for	IN
5180	2157	43	the	the	DT
5180	2157	44	Twentieth	Twentieth	NNP
5180	2157	45	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
5180	2157	46	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
5180	2157	47	,	,	,
5180	2157	48	986	986	CD
5180	2157	49	F.2d	F.2d	NNS
5180	2157	50	1142	1142	CD
5180	2157	51	,	,	,
5180	2157	52	1144	1144	CD
5180	2157	53	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2157	54	7th	7th	JJ
5180	2157	55	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	2157	56	.	.	.
5180	2158	1	1993	1993	CD
5180	2158	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2158	3	.	.	.
5180	2159	1	But	but	CC
5180	2159	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2159	3	is	be	VBZ
5180	2159	4	one	one	CD
5180	2159	5	thing	thing	NN
5180	2159	6	to	to	TO
5180	2159	7	hold	hold	VB
5180	2159	8	that	that	IN
5180	2159	9	a	a	DT
5180	2159	10	municipality	municipality	NN
5180	2159	11	can	can	MD
5180	2159	12	not	not	RB
5180	2159	13	interpose	interpose	VB
5180	2159	14	the	the	DT
5180	2159	15	Fourteenth	Fourteenth	NNP
5180	2159	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2159	17	between	between	IN
5180	2159	18	itself	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2159	19	and	and	CC
5180	2159	20	the	the	DT
5180	2159	21	state	state	NN
5180	2159	22	of	of	IN
5180	2159	23	which	which	WDT
5180	2159	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2159	25	is	be	VBZ
5180	2159	26	the	the	DT
5180	2159	27	creature	creature	NN
5180	2159	28	,	,	,
5180	2159	29	Anderson	Anderson	NNP
5180	2159	30	v.	v.	IN
5180	2159	31	City	City	NNP
5180	2159	32	of	of	IN
5180	2159	33	Boston	Boston	NNP
5180	2159	34	,	,	,
5180	2159	35	380	380	CD
5180	2159	36	N.E.2d	n.e.2d	NN
5180	2159	37	628	628	CD
5180	2159	38	,	,	,
5180	2159	39	637	637	CD
5180	2159	40	-	-	SYM
5180	2159	41	38	38	CD
5180	2159	42	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2159	43	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
5180	2160	1	1978	1978	CD
5180	2160	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2160	3	,	,	,
5180	2160	4	appeal	appeal	NN
5180	2160	5	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
5180	2160	6	for	for	IN
5180	2160	7	want	want	NN
5180	2160	8	of	of	IN
5180	2160	9	a	a	DT
5180	2160	10	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	2160	11	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2160	12	question	question	NN
5180	2160	13	,	,	,
5180	2160	14	439	439	CD
5180	2160	15	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2160	16	1060	1060	CD
5180	2160	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2160	18	1979	1979	CD
5180	2160	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2160	20	,	,	,
5180	2160	21	and	and	CC
5180	2160	22	another	another	DT
5180	2160	23	to	to	TO
5180	2160	24	hold	hold	VB
5180	2160	25	that	that	IN
5180	2160	26	a	a	DT
5180	2160	27	municipality	municipality	NN
5180	2160	28	has	have	VBZ
5180	2160	29	no	no	DT
5180	2160	30	rights	right	NNS
5180	2160	31	against	against	IN
5180	2160	32	the	the	DT
5180	2160	33	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2160	34	government	government	NN
5180	2160	35	or	or	CC
5180	2160	36	another	another	DT
5180	2160	37	state	state	NN
5180	2160	38	.	.	.
5180	2161	1	Township	township	NN
5180	2161	2	of	of	IN
5180	2161	3	River	River	NNP
5180	2161	4	Vale	Vale	NNP
5180	2161	5	v.	v.	IN
5180	2161	6	Town	Town	NNP
5180	2161	7	of	of	IN
5180	2161	8	Orangetown	Orangetown	NNP
5180	2161	9	,	,	,
5180	2161	10	403	403	CD
5180	2161	11	F.2d	F.2d	NNS
5180	2161	12	684	684	CD
5180	2161	13	,	,	,
5180	2161	14	686	686	CD
5180	2161	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2161	16	2d	2d	NNP
5180	2161	17	Cir	Cir	NNP
5180	2161	18	.	.	.
5180	2162	1	1968	1968	CD
5180	2162	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2162	3	,	,	,
5180	2162	4	distinguishes	distinguishe	NNS
5180	2162	5	between	between	IN
5180	2162	6	these	these	DT
5180	2162	7	two	two	CD
5180	2162	8	types	type	NNS
5180	2162	9	of	of	IN
5180	2162	10	cases	case	NNS
5180	2162	11	.	.	.
5180	2163	1	Creek	Creek	NNP
5180	2163	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	2163	3	Village	Village	NNP
5180	2163	4	of	of	IN
5180	2163	5	Westhaven	Westhaven	NNP
5180	2163	6	,	,	,
5180	2163	7	80	80	CD
5180	2163	8	F.3d	f.3d	NN
5180	2163	9	186	186	CD
5180	2163	10	,	,	,
5180	2163	11	192	192	CD
5180	2163	12	-	-	SYM
5180	2163	13	93	93	CD
5180	2163	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2163	15	7th	7th	JJ
5180	2163	16	Cir	Cir	NNS
5180	2163	17	.	.	.
5180	2164	1	1996	1996	CD
5180	2164	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2164	3	.	.	.
5180	2165	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2165	2	also	also	RB
5180	2165	3	note	note	VBP
5180	2165	4	that	that	IN
5180	2165	5	there	there	EX
5180	2165	6	is	be	VBZ
5180	2165	7	no	no	DT
5180	2165	8	textual	textual	JJ
5180	2165	9	support	support	NN
5180	2165	10	in	in	IN
5180	2165	11	the	the	DT
5180	2165	12	First	First	NNP
5180	2165	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2165	14	for	for	IN
5180	2165	15	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
5180	2165	16	between	between	IN
5180	2165	17	,	,	,
5180	2165	18	for	for	IN
5180	2165	19	example	example	NN
5180	2165	20	,	,	,
5180	2165	21	municipal	municipal	JJ
5180	2165	22	corporations	corporation	NNS
5180	2165	23	,	,	,
5180	2165	24	and	and	CC
5180	2165	25	private	private	JJ
5180	2165	26	corporations	corporation	NNS
5180	2165	27	,	,	,
5180	2165	28	which	which	WDT
5180	2165	29	the	the	DT
5180	2165	30	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2165	31	has	have	VBZ
5180	2165	32	recognized	recognize	VBN
5180	2165	33	have	have	VBP
5180	2165	34	cognizable	cognizable	JJ
5180	2165	35	First	First	NNP
5180	2165	36	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2165	37	rights	right	NNS
5180	2165	38	.	.	.
5180	2166	1	First	First	NNP
5180	2166	2	Nat'l	Nat'l	NNPS
5180	2166	3	Bank	Bank	NNP
5180	2166	4	of	of	IN
5180	2166	5	Boston	Boston	NNP
5180	2166	6	v.	v.	CC
5180	2166	7	Bellotti	Bellotti	NNP
5180	2166	8	,	,	,
5180	2166	9	435	435	CD
5180	2166	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2166	11	765	765	CD
5180	2166	12	,	,	,
5180	2166	13	775	775	CD
5180	2166	14	-	-	SYM
5180	2166	15	76	76	CD
5180	2166	16	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2166	17	1978	1978	CD
5180	2166	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2166	19	.	.	.
5180	2167	1	Unlike	unlike	IN
5180	2167	2	other	other	JJ
5180	2167	3	provisions	provision	NNS
5180	2167	4	in	in	IN
5180	2167	5	the	the	DT
5180	2167	6	Bill	Bill	NNP
5180	2167	7	of	of	IN
5180	2167	8	Rights	Rights	NNPS
5180	2167	9	,	,	,
5180	2167	10	which	which	WDT
5180	2167	11	the	the	DT
5180	2167	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	2167	13	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2167	14	has	have	VBZ
5180	2167	15	held	hold	VBN
5180	2167	16	to	to	TO
5180	2167	17	be	be	VB
5180	2167	18	"	"	``
5180	2167	19	purely	purely	RB
5180	2167	20	personal	personal	JJ
5180	2167	21	"	"	''
5180	2167	22	and	and	CC
5180	2167	23	thus	thus	RB
5180	2167	24	capable	capable	JJ
5180	2167	25	of	of	IN
5180	2167	26	being	be	VBG
5180	2167	27	invoked	invoke	VBN
5180	2167	28	only	only	RB
5180	2167	29	by	by	IN
5180	2167	30	individuals	individual	NNS
5180	2167	31	,	,	,
5180	2167	32	the	the	DT
5180	2167	33	First	First	NNP
5180	2167	34	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2167	35	is	be	VBZ
5180	2167	36	not	not	RB
5180	2167	37	phrased	phrase	VBN
5180	2167	38	in	in	IN
5180	2167	39	terms	term	NNS
5180	2167	40	of	of	IN
5180	2167	41	who	who	WP
5180	2167	42	holds	hold	VBZ
5180	2167	43	the	the	DT
5180	2167	44	right	right	NN
5180	2167	45	,	,	,
5180	2167	46	but	but	CC
5180	2167	47	rather	rather	RB
5180	2167	48	what	what	WP
5180	2167	49	is	be	VBZ
5180	2167	50	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2167	51	.	.	.
5180	2168	1	Compare	compare	VB
5180	2168	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2168	3	Const	Const	NNP
5180	2168	4	.	.	.
5180	2169	1	amend	amend	VB
5180	2169	2	V	V	NNP
5180	2169	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2169	4	"	"	``
5180	2169	5	No	no	DT
5180	2169	6	person	person	NN
5180	2169	7	shall	shall	MD
5180	2169	8	be	be	VB
5180	2169	9	held	hold	VBN
5180	2169	10	to	to	TO
5180	2169	11	answer	answer	VB
5180	2169	12	.	.	.
5180	2170	1	.	.	.
5180	2171	1	.	.	.
5180	2171	2	"	"	''
5180	2171	3	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2172	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2172	2	emphasis	emphasis	NN
5180	2172	3	added	add	VBN
5180	2172	4	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2172	5	with	with	IN
5180	2172	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2172	7	Const	Const	NNP
5180	2172	8	.	.	.
5180	2173	1	amend	amend	VB
5180	2173	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2173	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2173	4	"	"	``
5180	2173	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	2173	6	shall	shall	MD
5180	2173	7	make	make	VB
5180	2173	8	no	no	DT
5180	2173	9	law	law	NN
5180	2173	10	.	.	.
5180	2174	1	.	.	.
5180	2175	1	.	.	.
5180	2176	1	abridging	abridge	VBG
5180	2176	2	the	the	DT
5180	2176	3	freedom	freedom	NN
5180	2176	4	of	of	IN
5180	2176	5	speech	speech	NN
5180	2176	6	,	,	,
5180	2176	7	or	or	CC
5180	2176	8	of	of	IN
5180	2176	9	the	the	DT
5180	2176	10	press	press	NN
5180	2176	11	.	.	.
5180	2177	1	.	.	.
5180	2178	1	.	.	.
5180	2179	1	.	.	.
5180	2180	1	")	")	``
5180	2180	2	;	;	:
5180	2180	3	see	see	VB
5180	2180	4	also	also	RB
5180	2180	5	United	United	NNP
5180	2180	6	States	States	NNP
5180	2180	7	v.	v.	CC
5180	2180	8	White	White	NNP
5180	2180	9	,	,	,
5180	2180	10	322	322	CD
5180	2180	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2180	12	694	694	CD
5180	2180	13	,	,	,
5180	2180	14	698	698	CD
5180	2180	15	-	-	SYM
5180	2180	16	701	701	CD
5180	2180	17	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2180	18	1944	1944	CD
5180	2180	19	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2180	20	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2180	21	holding	hold	VBG
5180	2180	22	that	that	IN
5180	2180	23	the	the	DT
5180	2180	24	privilege	privilege	NN
5180	2180	25	against	against	IN
5180	2180	26	self-	self-	NNP
5180	2180	27	incrimination	incrimination	NNP
5180	2180	28	applies	apply	VBZ
5180	2180	29	only	only	RB
5180	2180	30	to	to	IN
5180	2180	31	natural	natural	JJ
5180	2180	32	persons	person	NNS
5180	2180	33	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2180	34	.	.	.
5180	2181	1	The	the	DT
5180	2181	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	2181	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2181	4	relied	rely	VBD
5180	2181	5	on	on	IN
5180	2181	6	this	this	DT
5180	2181	7	distinction	distinction	NN
5180	2181	8	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2181	9	i.e.	i.e.	FW
5180	2181	10	,	,	,
5180	2181	11	that	that	IN
5180	2181	12	the	the	DT
5180	2181	13	First	First	NNP
5180	2181	14	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2181	15	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	2181	16	a	a	DT
5180	2181	17	class	class	NN
5180	2181	18	of	of	IN
5180	2181	19	speech	speech	NN
5180	2181	20	rather	rather	RB
5180	2181	21	than	than	IN
5180	2181	22	a	a	DT
5180	2181	23	class	class	NN
5180	2181	24	of	of	IN
5180	2181	25	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	2181	26	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2181	27	in	in	IN
5180	2181	28	a	a	DT
5180	2181	29	similar	similar	JJ
5180	2181	30	context	context	NN
5180	2181	31	in	in	IN
5180	2181	32	Bellotti	Bellotti	NNP
5180	2181	33	.	.	.
5180	2182	1	There	there	RB
5180	2182	2	,	,	,
5180	2182	3	the	the	DT
5180	2182	4	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2182	5	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
5180	2182	6	a	a	DT
5180	2182	7	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
5180	2182	8	statute	statute	NN
5180	2182	9	that	that	WDT
5180	2182	10	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
5180	2182	11	corporations	corporation	NNS
5180	2182	12	from	from	IN
5180	2182	13	spending	spend	VBG
5180	2182	14	money	money	NN
5180	2182	15	to	to	TO
5180	2182	16	influence	influence	VB
5180	2182	17	ballot	ballot	NN
5180	2182	18	initiatives	initiative	NNS
5180	2182	19	that	that	WDT
5180	2182	20	did	do	VBD
5180	2182	21	not	not	RB
5180	2182	22	bear	bear	VB
5180	2182	23	directly	directly	RB
5180	2182	24	on	on	IN
5180	2182	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2182	26	"	"	``
5180	2182	27	property	property	NN
5180	2182	28	,	,	,
5180	2182	29	business	business	NN
5180	2182	30	or	or	CC
5180	2182	31	assets	asset	NNS
5180	2182	32	.	.	.
5180	2182	33	"	"	''
5180	2183	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	2184	1	at	at	IN
5180	2184	2	768	768	CD
5180	2184	3	.	.	.
5180	2185	1	In	in	IN
5180	2185	2	so	so	RB
5180	2185	3	holding	hold	VBG
5180	2185	4	,	,	,
5180	2185	5	the	the	DT
5180	2185	6	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2185	7	rejected	reject	VBD
5180	2185	8	the	the	DT
5180	2185	9	argument	argument	NN
5180	2185	10	that	that	IN
5180	2185	11	the	the	DT
5180	2185	12	First	First	NNP
5180	2185	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2185	14	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	2185	15	only	only	RB
5180	2185	16	an	an	DT
5180	2185	17	individual	individual	NN
5180	2185	18	's	's	POS
5180	2185	19	expression	expression	NN
5180	2185	20	.	.	.
5180	2186	1	The	the	DT
5180	2186	2	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2186	3	wrote	write	VBD
5180	2186	4	:	:	:
5180	2186	5	The	the	DT
5180	2186	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
5180	2186	7	often	often	RB
5180	2186	8	protects	protect	VBZ
5180	2186	9	interests	interest	NNS
5180	2186	10	broader	broad	JJR
5180	2186	11	than	than	IN
5180	2186	12	those	those	DT
5180	2186	13	of	of	IN
5180	2186	14	the	the	DT
5180	2186	15	party	party	NN
5180	2186	16	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	2186	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2186	18	vindication	vindication	NN
5180	2186	19	.	.	.
5180	2187	1	.	.	.
5180	2188	1	.	.	.
5180	2189	1	.	.	.
5180	2190	1	The	the	DT
5180	2190	2	proper	proper	JJ
5180	2190	3	question	question	NN
5180	2190	4	therefore	therefore	RB
5180	2190	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	2190	6	not	not	RB
5180	2190	7	whether	whether	IN
5180	2190	8	corporations	corporation	NNS
5180	2190	9	"	"	``
5180	2190	10	have	have	VBP
5180	2190	11	"	"	``
5180	2190	12	First	First	NNP
5180	2190	13	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2190	14	rights	right	NNS
5180	2190	15	and	and	CC
5180	2190	16	,	,	,
5180	2190	17	if	if	IN
5180	2190	18	so	so	RB
5180	2190	19	,	,	,
5180	2190	20	whether	whether	IN
5180	2190	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2190	22	are	be	VBP
5180	2190	23	coextensive	coextensive	JJ
5180	2190	24	with	with	IN
5180	2190	25	those	those	DT
5180	2190	26	of	of	IN
5180	2190	27	natural	natural	JJ
5180	2190	28	persons	person	NNS
5180	2190	29	.	.	.
5180	2191	1	Instead	instead	RB
5180	2191	2	,	,	,
5180	2191	3	the	the	DT
5180	2191	4	question	question	NN
5180	2191	5	must	must	MD
5180	2191	6	be	be	VB
5180	2191	7	whether	whether	IN
5180	2191	8	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2191	9	the	the	DT
5180	2191	10	government	government	NN
5180	2191	11	is	be	VBZ
5180	2191	12	]	]	-RRB-
5180	2191	13	abridg[ing	abridg[e	VBG
5180	2191	14	]	]	-RRB-
5180	2191	15	expression	expression	NN
5180	2191	16	that	that	IN
5180	2191	17	the	the	DT
5180	2191	18	First	First	NNP
5180	2191	19	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2191	20	was	be	VBD
5180	2191	21	meant	mean	VBN
5180	2191	22	to	to	TO
5180	2191	23	protect	protect	VB
5180	2191	24	.	.	.
5180	2192	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	2193	1	at	at	IN
5180	2193	2	776	776	CD
5180	2193	3	.	.	.
5180	2194	1	The	the	DT
5180	2194	2	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2194	3	thus	thus	RB
5180	2194	4	concluded	conclude	VBD
5180	2194	5	that	that	IN
5180	2194	6	corporations	corporation	NNS
5180	2194	7	are	be	VBP
5180	2194	8	entitled	entitle	VBN
5180	2194	9	to	to	TO
5180	2194	10	assert	assert	VB
5180	2194	11	First	First	NNP
5180	2194	12	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2194	13	claims	claim	VBZ
5180	2194	14	as	as	IN
5180	2194	15	speakers	speaker	NNS
5180	2194	16	,	,	,
5180	2194	17	noting	note	VBG
5180	2194	18	that	that	IN
5180	2194	19	"	"	``
5180	2194	20	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2194	21	t]he	t]he	CD
5180	2194	22	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	2194	23	worth	worth	NN
5180	2194	24	of	of	IN
5180	2194	25	the	the	DT
5180	2194	26	speech	speech	NN
5180	2194	27	in	in	IN
5180	2194	28	terms	term	NNS
5180	2194	29	of	of	IN
5180	2194	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2194	31	capacity	capacity	NN
5180	2194	32	for	for	IN
5180	2194	33	informing	inform	VBG
5180	2194	34	the	the	DT
5180	2194	35	public	public	NN
5180	2194	36	does	do	VBZ
5180	2194	37	not	not	RB
5180	2194	38	depend	depend	VB
5180	2194	39	upon	upon	IN
5180	2194	40	the	the	DT
5180	2194	41	identity	identity	NN
5180	2194	42	of	of	IN
5180	2194	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2194	44	source	source	NN
5180	2194	45	,	,	,
5180	2194	46	whether	whether	IN
5180	2194	47	corporation	corporation	NN
5180	2194	48	,	,	,
5180	2194	49	association	association	NNP
5180	2194	50	,	,	,
5180	2194	51	union	union	NNP
5180	2194	52	,	,	,
5180	2194	53	or	or	CC
5180	2194	54	individual	individual	NN
5180	2194	55	.	.	.
5180	2194	56	"	"	''
5180	2195	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	2196	1	at	at	IN
5180	2196	2	777	777	CD
5180	2196	3	.	.	.
5180	2197	1	In	in	IN
5180	2197	2	view	view	NN
5180	2197	3	of	of	IN
5180	2197	4	the	the	DT
5180	2197	5	foregoing	foregoing	NN
5180	2197	6	,	,	,
5180	2197	7	the	the	DT
5180	2197	8	notion	notion	NN
5180	2197	9	that	that	IN
5180	2197	10	public	public	JJ
5180	2197	11	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2197	12	may	may	MD
5180	2197	13	assert	assert	VB
5180	2197	14	First	First	NNP
5180	2197	15	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2197	16	rights	right	NNS
5180	2197	17	for	for	IN
5180	2197	18	the	the	DT
5180	2197	19	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	2197	20	of	of	IN
5180	2197	21	making	make	VBG
5180	2197	22	an	an	DT
5180	2197	23	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2197	24	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	2197	25	claim	claim	NN
5180	2197	26	is	be	VBZ
5180	2197	27	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	2197	28	plausible	plausible	JJ
5180	2197	29	,	,	,
5180	2197	30	and	and	CC
5180	2197	31	may	may	MD
5180	2197	32	well	well	RB
5180	2197	33	be	be	VB
5180	2197	34	correct	correct	JJ
5180	2197	35	.	.	.
5180	2198	1	But	but	CC
5180	2198	2	even	even	RB
5180	2198	3	if	if	IN
5180	2198	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2198	5	is	be	VBZ
5180	2198	6	not	not	RB
5180	2198	7	,	,	,
5180	2198	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2198	9	think	think	VBP
5180	2198	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2198	11	plausible	plausible	JJ
5180	2198	12	that	that	IN
5180	2198	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2198	14	could	could	MD
5180	2198	15	rely	rely	VB
5180	2198	16	on	on	IN
5180	2198	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2198	18	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2198	19	'	'	POS
5180	2198	20	rights	right	NNS
5180	2198	21	,	,	,
5180	2198	22	even	even	RB
5180	2198	23	though	though	IN
5180	2198	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2198	25	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2198	26	are	be	VBP
5180	2198	27	not	not	RB
5180	2198	28	the	the	DT
5180	2198	29	ones	one	NNS
5180	2198	30	who	who	WP
5180	2198	31	are	be	VBP
5180	2198	32	directly	directly	RB
5180	2198	33	receiving	receive	VBG
5180	2198	34	the	the	DT
5180	2198	35	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2198	36	funding	funding	NN
5180	2198	37	.	.	.
5180	2199	1	In	in	IN
5180	2199	2	similar	similar	JJ
5180	2199	3	cases	case	NNS
5180	2199	4	,	,	,
5180	2199	5	the	the	DT
5180	2199	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	2199	7	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2199	8	has	have	VBZ
5180	2199	9	entertained	entertain	VBN
5180	2199	10	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2199	11	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	2199	12	claims	claim	VBZ
5180	2199	13	both	both	DT
5180	2199	14	by	by	IN
5180	2199	15	the	the	DT
5180	2199	16	organizations	organization	NNS
5180	2199	17	that	that	WDT
5180	2199	18	receive	receive	VBP
5180	2199	19	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2199	20	funding	funding	NN
5180	2199	21	and	and	CC
5180	2199	22	by	by	IN
5180	2199	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2199	24	constituents	constituent	NNS
5180	2199	25	.	.	.
5180	2200	1	See	see	VB
5180	2200	2	Legal	Legal	NNP
5180	2200	3	Servs	Servs	NNP
5180	2200	4	.	.	.
5180	2201	1	Corp.	Corp.	NNP
5180	2201	2	v.	v.	IN
5180	2201	3	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	2201	4	,	,	,
5180	2201	5	531	531	CD
5180	2201	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2201	7	533	533	CD
5180	2201	8	,	,	,
5180	2201	9	537	537	CD
5180	2201	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2201	11	2001	2001	CD
5180	2201	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2201	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2201	14	"	"	``
5180	2201	15	Lawyers	lawyer	NNS
5180	2201	16	employed	employ	VBN
5180	2201	17	by	by	IN
5180	2201	18	New	New	NNP
5180	2201	19	York	York	NNP
5180	2201	20	City	City	NNP
5180	2201	21	LSC	LSC	NNP
5180	2201	22	grantees	grantee	NNS
5180	2201	23	,	,	,
5180	2201	24	together	together	RB
5180	2201	25	with	with	IN
5180	2201	26	private	private	JJ
5180	2201	27	LSC	LSC	NNP
5180	2201	28	contributors	contributor	NNS
5180	2201	29	,	,	,
5180	2201	30	LSC	LSC	NNP
5180	2201	31	indigent	indigent	JJ
5180	2201	32	clients	client	NNS
5180	2201	33	,	,	,
5180	2201	34	and	and	CC
5180	2201	35	various	various	JJ
5180	2201	36	state	state	NN
5180	2201	37	and	and	CC
5180	2201	38	local	local	JJ
5180	2201	39	public	public	JJ
5180	2201	40	officials	official	NNS
5180	2201	41	whose	whose	WP$
5180	2201	42	governments	government	NNS
5180	2201	43	contribute	contribute	VBP
5180	2201	44	to	to	IN
5180	2201	45	LSC	LSC	NNP
5180	2201	46	grantees	grantee	NNS
5180	2201	47	,	,	,
5180	2201	48	brought	bring	VBD
5180	2201	49	suit	suit	NN
5180	2201	50	.	.	.
5180	2202	1	.	.	.
5180	2203	1	.	.	.
5180	2204	1	to	to	TO
5180	2204	2	declare	declare	VB
5180	2204	3	the	the	DT
5180	2204	4	restriction	restriction	NN
5180	2204	5	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2204	6	on	on	IN
5180	2204	7	LSC	LSC	NNP
5180	2204	8	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
5180	2204	9	'	'	POS
5180	2204	10	ability	ability	NN
5180	2204	11	advocate	advocate	VBP
5180	2204	12	the	the	DT
5180	2204	13	amendment	amendment	NN
5180	2204	14	of	of	IN
5180	2204	15	or	or	CC
5180	2204	16	to	to	TO
5180	2204	17	challenge	challenge	VB
5180	2204	18	the	the	DT
5180	2204	19	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
5180	2204	20	of	of	IN
5180	2204	21	existing	exist	VBG
5180	2204	22	welfare	welfare	NN
5180	2204	23	law	law	NN
5180	2204	24	]	]	-RRB-
5180	2204	25	.	.	.
5180	2205	1	.	.	.
5180	2206	1	.	.	.
5180	2207	1	invalid	invalid	NNP
5180	2207	2	.	.	.
5180	2208	1	")	")	LS
5180	2208	2	;	;	:
5180	2208	3	Rust	rust	VB
5180	2208	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	2208	5	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
5180	2208	6	,	,	,
5180	2208	7	500	500	CD
5180	2208	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2208	9	173	173	CD
5180	2208	10	,	,	,
5180	2208	11	181	181	CD
5180	2208	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2208	13	1991	1991	CD
5180	2208	14	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2208	15	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2208	16	"	"	``
5180	2208	17	Petitioners	petitioner	NNS
5180	2208	18	are	be	VBP
5180	2208	19	Title	title	NN
5180	2208	20	X	x	NN
5180	2208	21	grantees	grantee	NNS
5180	2208	22	and	and	CC
5180	2208	23	doctors	doctor	NNS
5180	2208	24	who	who	WP
5180	2208	25	supervise	supervise	VBP
5180	2208	26	Title	title	NN
5180	2208	27	X	X	NNP
5180	2208	28	funds	fund	NNS
5180	2208	29	suing	sue	VBG
5180	2208	30	on	on	IN
5180	2208	31	behalf	behalf	NN
5180	2208	32	of	of	IN
5180	2208	33	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2208	34	and	and	CC
5180	2208	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2208	36	patients	patient	NNS
5180	2208	37	.	.	.
5180	2209	1	.	.	.
5180	2210	1	.	.	.
5180	2211	1	.	.	.
5180	2212	1	Petitioners	petitioner	NNS
5180	2212	2	challenged	challenge	VBD
5180	2212	3	the	the	DT
5180	2212	4	regulations	regulation	NNS
5180	2212	5	on	on	IN
5180	2212	6	the	the	DT
5180	2212	7	grounds	ground	NNS
5180	2212	8	that	that	DT
5180	2212	9	.	.	.
5180	2213	1	.	.	.
5180	2214	1	.	.	.
5180	2215	1	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2215	2	violate	violate	VBP
5180	2215	3	the	the	DT
5180	2215	4	First	First	NNP
5180	2215	5	and	and	CC
5180	2215	6	Fifth	Fifth	NNP
5180	2215	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2215	8	rights	right	NNS
5180	2215	9	of	of	IN
5180	2215	10	Title	title	NN
5180	2215	11	X	X	NNP
5180	2215	12	clients	client	NNS
5180	2215	13	and	and	CC
5180	2215	14	the	the	DT
5180	2215	15	First	First	NNP
5180	2215	16	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2215	17	rights	right	NNS
5180	2215	18	of	of	IN
5180	2215	19	Title	Title	NNP
5180	2215	20	X	X	NNP
5180	2215	21	health	health	NN
5180	2215	22	providers	provider	NNS
5180	2215	23	.	.	.
5180	2216	1	")	")	``
5180	2216	2	;	;	:
5180	2216	3	FCC	FCC	NNP
5180	2216	4	v.	v.	IN
5180	2216	5	League	League	NNP
5180	2216	6	of	of	IN
5180	2216	7	Women	Women	NNP
5180	2216	8	Voters	Voters	NNPS
5180	2216	9	of	of	IN
5180	2216	10	Cal	Cal	NNP
5180	2216	11	.	.	NNP
5180	2216	12	,	,	,
5180	2216	13	468	468	CD
5180	2216	14	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2216	15	364	364	CD
5180	2216	16	,	,	,
5180	2216	17	370	370	CD
5180	2216	18	n.6	n.6	CD
5180	2216	19	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2216	20	1984	1984	CD
5180	2216	21	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2216	22	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2216	23	reviewing	review	VBG
5180	2216	24	a	a	DT
5180	2216	25	First	First	NNP
5180	2216	26	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2216	27	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	2216	28	to	to	IN
5180	2216	29	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	2216	30	on	on	IN
5180	2216	31	public	public	JJ
5180	2216	32	broadcasters	broadcaster	NNS
5180	2216	33	'	'	POS
5180	2216	34	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	2216	35	of	of	IN
5180	2216	36	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2216	37	funds	fund	NNS
5180	2216	38	,	,	,
5180	2216	39	in	in	IN
5180	2216	40	which	which	WDT
5180	2216	41	the	the	DT
5180	2216	42	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	2216	43	included	include	VBD
5180	2216	44	not	not	RB
5180	2216	45	only	only	RB
5180	2216	46	the	the	DT
5180	2216	47	owner	owner	NN
5180	2216	48	of	of	IN
5180	2216	49	a	a	DT
5180	2216	50	public	public	JJ
5180	2216	51	television	television	NN
5180	2216	52	station	station	NN
5180	2216	53	,	,	,
5180	2216	54	but	but	CC
5180	2216	55	also	also	RB
5180	2216	56	viewers	viewer	NNS
5180	2216	57	of	of	IN
5180	2216	58	the	the	DT
5180	2216	59	station	station	NN
5180	2216	60	's	's	POS
5180	2216	61	programs	program	NNS
5180	2216	62	,	,	,
5180	2216	63	including	include	VBG
5180	2216	64	the	the	DT
5180	2216	65	League	League	NNP
5180	2216	66	of	of	IN
5180	2216	67	Women	Women	NNP
5180	2216	68	Voters	Voters	NNPS
5180	2216	69	,	,	,
5180	2216	70	and	and	CC
5180	2216	71	"	"	``
5180	2216	72	Congressman	Congressman	NNP
5180	2216	73	Henry	Henry	NNP
5180	2216	74	Waxman	Waxman	NNP
5180	2216	75	,	,	,
5180	2216	76	.	.	.
5180	2217	1	.	.	.
5180	2218	1	.	.	.
5180	2219	1	a	a	DT
5180	2219	2	regular	regular	JJ
5180	2219	3	listener	listener	NN
5180	2219	4	and	and	CC
5180	2219	5	viewer	viewer	NN
5180	2219	6	of	of	IN
5180	2219	7	public	public	JJ
5180	2219	8	broadcasting	broadcasting	NN
5180	2219	9	"	"	''
5180	2219	10	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2219	11	.	.	.
5180	2220	1	The	the	DT
5180	2220	2	question	question	NN
5180	2220	3	whether	whether	IN
5180	2220	4	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	2220	5	's	's	POS
5180	2220	6	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	2220	7	that	that	IN
5180	2220	8	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2220	9	use	use	VBP
5180	2220	10	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	2220	11	software	software	NN
5180	2220	12	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
5180	2220	13	an	an	DT
5180	2220	14	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2220	15	condition	condition	NN
5180	2220	16	is	be	VBZ
5180	2220	17	not	not	RB
5180	2220	18	an	an	DT
5180	2220	19	easy	easy	JJ
5180	2220	20	one	one	NN
5180	2220	21	.	.	.
5180	2221	1	The	the	DT
5180	2221	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	2221	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2221	4	has	have	VBZ
5180	2221	5	held	hold	VBN
5180	2221	6	that	that	IN
5180	2221	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2221	8	violates	violate	VBZ
5180	2221	9	the	the	DT
5180	2221	10	First	First	NNP
5180	2221	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2221	12	for	for	IN
5180	2221	13	the	the	DT
5180	2221	14	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2221	15	government	government	NN
5180	2221	16	to	to	TO
5180	2221	17	require	require	VB
5180	2221	18	public	public	JJ
5180	2221	19	broadcasting	broadcasting	NN
5180	2221	20	stations	station	NNS
5180	2221	21	that	that	WDT
5180	2221	22	receive	receive	VBP
5180	2221	23	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2221	24	funds	fund	NNS
5180	2221	25	not	not	RB
5180	2221	26	to	to	TO
5180	2221	27	editorialize	editorialize	VB
5180	2221	28	,	,	,
5180	2221	29	see	see	VB
5180	2221	30	League	League	NNP
5180	2221	31	of	of	IN
5180	2221	32	Women	Women	NNP
5180	2221	33	Voters	Voters	NNPS
5180	2221	34	,	,	,
5180	2221	35	468	468	CD
5180	2221	36	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2221	37	at	at	IN
5180	2221	38	366	366	CD
5180	2221	39	,	,	,
5180	2221	40	402	402	CD
5180	2221	41	;	;	:
5180	2221	42	for	for	IN
5180	2221	43	states	state	NNS
5180	2221	44	to	to	TO
5180	2221	45	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	2221	46	"	"	``
5180	2221	47	newspaper	newspaper	NN
5180	2221	48	and	and	CC
5180	2221	49	religious	religious	JJ
5180	2221	50	,	,	,
5180	2221	51	professional	professional	JJ
5180	2221	52	,	,	,
5180	2221	53	trade	trade	NN
5180	2221	54	,	,	,
5180	2221	55	and	and	CC
5180	2221	56	sports	sport	NNS
5180	2221	57	journals	journal	NNS
5180	2221	58	,	,	,
5180	2221	59	"	"	''
5180	2221	60	but	but	CC
5180	2221	61	not	not	RB
5180	2221	62	"	"	``
5180	2221	63	general	general	JJ
5180	2221	64	interest	interest	NN
5180	2221	65	magazines	magazine	NNS
5180	2221	66	,	,	,
5180	2221	67	"	"	''
5180	2221	68	Ark.	Arkansas	NNP
5180	2222	1	Writers	Writers	NNP
5180	2222	2	'	'	POS
5180	2222	3	Project	Project	NNP
5180	2222	4	,	,	,
5180	2222	5	Inc.	Inc.	NNP
5180	2222	6	v.	v.	IN
5180	2222	7	Ragland	Ragland	NNP
5180	2222	8	,	,	,
5180	2222	9	481	481	CD
5180	2222	10	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2222	11	221	221	CD
5180	2222	12	,	,	,
5180	2222	13	223	223	CD
5180	2222	14	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2222	15	1987	1987	CD
5180	2222	16	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2222	17	;	;	:
5180	2222	18	for	for	IN
5180	2222	19	a	a	DT
5180	2222	20	state	state	NN
5180	2222	21	university	university	NN
5180	2222	22	to	to	TO
5180	2222	23	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	2222	24	student	student	NN
5180	2222	25	publications	publication	NNS
5180	2222	26	only	only	RB
5180	2222	27	on	on	IN
5180	2222	28	the	the	DT
5180	2222	29	condition	condition	NN
5180	2222	30	that	that	IN
5180	2222	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2222	32	do	do	VBP
5180	2222	33	not	not	RB
5180	2222	34	"	"	``
5180	2222	35	primarily	primarily	RB
5180	2222	36	promote	promote	VB
5180	2222	37	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2222	38	]	]	-RRB-
5180	2222	39	or	or	CC
5180	2222	40	manifest	manifest	VB
5180	2222	41	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2222	42	]	]	-RRB-
5180	2222	43	a	a	DT
5180	2222	44	particular	particular	JJ
5180	2222	45	belief	belief	NN
5180	2222	46	in	in	IN
5180	2222	47	or	or	CC
5180	2222	48	about	about	IN
5180	2222	49	a	a	DT
5180	2222	50	deity	deity	NN
5180	2222	51	or	or	CC
5180	2222	52	an	an	DT
5180	2222	53	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
5180	2222	54	reality	reality	NN
5180	2222	55	,	,	,
5180	2222	56	"	"	''
5180	2222	57	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
5180	2222	58	v.	v.	IN
5180	2222	59	Rector	Rector	NNP
5180	2222	60	&	&	CC
5180	2222	61	Visitors	Visitors	NNPS
5180	2222	62	of	of	IN
5180	2222	63	Univ	Univ	NNP
5180	2222	64	.	.	.
5180	2223	1	of	of	IN
5180	2223	2	Va.	Virginia	NNP
5180	2223	3	,	,	,
5180	2223	4	515	515	CD
5180	2223	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2223	6	819	819	CD
5180	2223	7	,	,	,
5180	2223	8	823	823	CD
5180	2223	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2223	10	1995	1995	CD
5180	2223	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2223	12	;	;	:
5180	2223	13	and	and	CC
5180	2223	14	for	for	IN
5180	2223	15	the	the	DT
5180	2223	16	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2223	17	government	government	NN
5180	2223	18	to	to	TO
5180	2223	19	prevent	prevent	VB
5180	2223	20	legal	legal	JJ
5180	2223	21	services	service	NNS
5180	2223	22	providers	provider	NNS
5180	2223	23	who	who	WP
5180	2223	24	receive	receive	VBP
5180	2223	25	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2223	26	funds	fund	NNS
5180	2223	27	from	from	IN
5180	2223	28	seeking	seek	VBG
5180	2223	29	to	to	TO
5180	2223	30	"	"	``
5180	2223	31	amend	amend	VB
5180	2223	32	or	or	CC
5180	2223	33	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	2223	34	challenge	challenge	NN
5180	2223	35	existing	exist	VBG
5180	2223	36	welfare	welfare	NN
5180	2223	37	law	law	NN
5180	2223	38	.	.	.
5180	2223	39	"	"	''
5180	2224	1	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	2224	2	,	,	,
5180	2224	3	531	531	CD
5180	2224	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2224	5	at	at	IN
5180	2224	6	537	537	CD
5180	2224	7	.	.	.
5180	2225	1	On	on	IN
5180	2225	2	the	the	DT
5180	2225	3	other	other	JJ
5180	2225	4	hand	hand	NN
5180	2225	5	,	,	,
5180	2225	6	the	the	DT
5180	2225	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	2225	8	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2225	9	has	have	VBZ
5180	2225	10	held	hold	VBN
5180	2225	11	that	that	IN
5180	2225	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2225	13	does	do	VBZ
5180	2225	14	not	not	RB
5180	2225	15	violate	violate	VB
5180	2225	16	the	the	DT
5180	2225	17	First	First	NNP
5180	2225	18	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2225	19	for	for	IN
5180	2225	20	the	the	DT
5180	2225	21	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2225	22	government	government	NN
5180	2225	23	to	to	TO
5180	2225	24	require	require	VB
5180	2225	25	healthcare	healthcare	NN
5180	2225	26	providers	provider	NNS
5180	2225	27	who	who	WP
5180	2225	28	receive	receive	VBP
5180	2225	29	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2225	30	funds	fund	NNS
5180	2225	31	not	not	RB
5180	2225	32	to	to	TO
5180	2225	33	"	"	``
5180	2225	34	encourage	encourage	VB
5180	2225	35	,	,	,
5180	2225	36	promote	promote	VB
5180	2225	37	or	or	CC
5180	2225	38	advocate	advocate	VB
5180	2225	39	abortion	abortion	NN
5180	2225	40	as	as	IN
5180	2225	41	a	a	DT
5180	2225	42	method	method	NN
5180	2225	43	of	of	IN
5180	2225	44	family	family	NN
5180	2225	45	planning	planning	NN
5180	2225	46	,	,	,
5180	2225	47	"	"	``
5180	2225	48	Rust	Rust	NNP
5180	2225	49	,	,	,
5180	2225	50	500	500	CD
5180	2225	51	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2225	52	at	at	IN
5180	2225	53	180	180	CD
5180	2225	54	;	;	:
5180	2225	55	for	for	IN
5180	2225	56	the	the	DT
5180	2225	57	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2225	58	government	government	NN
5180	2225	59	to	to	TO
5180	2225	60	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	2225	61	charitable	charitable	JJ
5180	2225	62	organizations	organization	NNS
5180	2225	63	only	only	RB
5180	2225	64	if	if	IN
5180	2225	65	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2225	66	do	do	VBP
5180	2225	67	not	not	RB
5180	2225	68	engage	engage	VB
5180	2225	69	in	in	IN
5180	2225	70	lobbying	lobby	VBG
5180	2225	71	activity	activity	NN
5180	2225	72	,	,	,
5180	2225	73	see	see	VB
5180	2225	74	Regan	Regan	NNP
5180	2225	75	v.	v.	IN
5180	2225	76	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
5180	2225	77	with	with	IN
5180	2225	78	Representation	Representation	NNP
5180	2225	79	,	,	,
5180	2225	80	461	461	CD
5180	2225	81	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2225	82	540	540	CD
5180	2225	83	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2225	84	1983	1983	CD
5180	2225	85	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2225	86	;	;	:
5180	2225	87	and	and	CC
5180	2225	88	for	for	IN
5180	2225	89	the	the	DT
5180	2225	90	National	National	NNP
5180	2225	91	Endowment	Endowment	NNP
5180	2225	92	for	for	IN
5180	2225	93	the	the	DT
5180	2225	94	Arts	Arts	NNPS
5180	2225	95	,	,	,
5180	2225	96	in	in	IN
5180	2225	97	awarding	award	VBG
5180	2225	98	grants	grant	NNS
5180	2225	99	on	on	IN
5180	2225	100	the	the	DT
5180	2225	101	basis	basis	NN
5180	2225	102	of	of	IN
5180	2225	103	artistic	artistic	JJ
5180	2225	104	excellence	excellence	NN
5180	2225	105	,	,	,
5180	2225	106	to	to	TO
5180	2225	107	"	"	``
5180	2225	108	take	take	VB
5180	2225	109	into	into	IN
5180	2225	110	consideration	consideration	NN
5180	2225	111	general	general	JJ
5180	2225	112	standards	standard	NNS
5180	2225	113	of	of	IN
5180	2225	114	decency	decency	NN
5180	2225	115	and	and	CC
5180	2225	116	respect	respect	NN
5180	2225	117	for	for	IN
5180	2225	118	the	the	DT
5180	2225	119	diverse	diverse	JJ
5180	2225	120	beliefs	belief	NNS
5180	2225	121	and	and	CC
5180	2225	122	values	value	NNS
5180	2225	123	of	of	IN
5180	2225	124	the	the	DT
5180	2225	125	American	American	NNP
5180	2225	126	Public	Public	NNP
5180	2225	127	.	.	.
5180	2225	128	"	"	''
5180	2226	1	NEA	NEA	NNP
5180	2226	2	v.	v.	CC
5180	2226	3	Finley	Finley	NNP
5180	2226	4	,	,	,
5180	2226	5	524	524	CD
5180	2226	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2226	7	569	569	CD
5180	2226	8	,	,	,
5180	2226	9	572	572	CD
5180	2226	10	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2226	11	1998	1998	CD
5180	2226	12	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2226	13	.	.	.
5180	2227	1	In	in	IN
5180	2227	2	light	light	NN
5180	2227	3	of	of	IN
5180	2227	4	the	the	DT
5180	2227	5	facts	fact	NNS
5180	2227	6	that	that	WDT
5180	2227	7	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2227	8	discuss	discuss	VBP
5180	2227	9	above	above	RB
5180	2227	10	regarding	regard	VBG
5180	2227	11	the	the	DT
5180	2227	12	operation	operation	NN
5180	2227	13	of	of	IN
5180	2227	14	public	public	JJ
5180	2227	15	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2227	16	,	,	,
5180	2227	17	and	and	CC
5180	2227	18	the	the	DT
5180	2227	19	limits	limit	NNS
5180	2227	20	of	of	IN
5180	2227	21	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2227	22	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	2227	23	software	software	NN
5180	2227	24	,	,	,
5180	2227	25	see	see	VB
5180	2227	26	supra	supra	NNP
5180	2227	27	Sections	Sections	NNPS
5180	2227	28	II.D	ii.d	NN
5180	2227	29	-	-	HYPH
5180	2227	30	E	e	NN
5180	2227	31	,	,	,
5180	2227	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2227	33	believe	believe	VBP
5180	2227	34	that	that	IN
5180	2227	35	the	the	DT
5180	2227	36	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	2227	37	have	have	VBP
5180	2227	38	a	a	DT
5180	2227	39	good	good	JJ
5180	2227	40	argument	argument	NN
5180	2227	41	that	that	IN
5180	2227	42	this	this	DT
5180	2227	43	case	case	NN
5180	2227	44	is	be	VBZ
5180	2227	45	more	more	RBR
5180	2227	46	analogous	analogous	JJ
5180	2227	47	to	to	IN
5180	2227	48	League	League	NNP
5180	2227	49	of	of	IN
5180	2227	50	Women	Women	NNP
5180	2227	51	Voters	Voters	NNPS
5180	2227	52	,	,	,
5180	2227	53	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
5180	2227	54	Writers	Writers	NNPS
5180	2227	55	'	'	POS
5180	2227	56	Project	Project	NNP
5180	2227	57	,	,	,
5180	2227	58	and	and	CC
5180	2227	59	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	2227	60	than	than	IN
5180	2227	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2227	62	is	be	VBZ
5180	2227	63	to	to	TO
5180	2227	64	Rust	rust	VB
5180	2227	65	,	,	,
5180	2227	66	Finley	Finley	NNP
5180	2227	67	and	and	CC
5180	2227	68	Taxation	Taxation	NNP
5180	2227	69	with	with	IN
5180	2227	70	Representation	Representation	NNP
5180	2227	71	.	.	.
5180	2228	1	Like	like	IN
5180	2228	2	the	the	DT
5180	2228	3	law	law	NN
5180	2228	4	invalidated	invalidate	VBN
5180	2228	5	in	in	IN
5180	2228	6	League	League	NNP
5180	2228	7	of	of	IN
5180	2228	8	Women	Women	NNP
5180	2228	9	Voters	Voters	NNPS
5180	2228	10	,	,	,
5180	2228	11	which	which	WDT
5180	2228	12	targeted	target	VBD
5180	2228	13	editorializing	editorializing	JJ
5180	2228	14	,	,	,
5180	2228	15	and	and	CC
5180	2228	16	the	the	DT
5180	2228	17	law	law	NN
5180	2228	18	invalidated	invalidate	VBD
5180	2228	19	in	in	IN
5180	2228	20	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
5180	2228	21	Writers	Writers	NNPS
5180	2228	22	'	'	POS
5180	2228	23	Project	Project	NNP
5180	2228	24	,	,	,
5180	2228	25	which	which	WDT
5180	2228	26	targeted	target	VBD
5180	2228	27	general	general	JJ
5180	2228	28	interest	interest	NN
5180	2228	29	magazines	magazine	NNS
5180	2228	30	but	but	CC
5180	2228	31	not	not	RB
5180	2228	32	"	"	``
5180	2228	33	religious	religious	JJ
5180	2228	34	,	,	,
5180	2228	35	professional	professional	JJ
5180	2228	36	,	,	,
5180	2228	37	trade	trade	NN
5180	2228	38	,	,	,
5180	2228	39	and	and	CC
5180	2228	40	sports	sport	NNS
5180	2228	41	journals	journal	NNS
5180	2228	42	,	,	,
5180	2228	43	"	"	''
5180	2228	44	the	the	DT
5180	2228	45	law	law	NN
5180	2228	46	in	in	IN
5180	2228	47	this	this	DT
5180	2228	48	case	case	NN
5180	2228	49	places	place	VBZ
5180	2228	50	content	content	NN
5180	2228	51	-	-	HYPH
5180	2228	52	based	base	VBN
5180	2228	53	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	2228	54	on	on	IN
5180	2228	55	public	public	JJ
5180	2228	56	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2228	57	'	'	POS
5180	2228	58	possible	possible	JJ
5180	2228	59	First	First	NNP
5180	2228	60	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2228	61	right	right	NN
5180	2228	62	to	to	TO
5180	2228	63	provide	provide	VB
5180	2228	64	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2228	65	with	with	IN
5180	2228	66	access	access	NN
5180	2228	67	to	to	IN
5180	2228	68	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	2228	69	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2228	70	material	material	NN
5180	2228	71	.	.	.
5180	2229	1	See	see	VB
5180	2229	2	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
5180	2229	3	Writers	Writers	NNPS
5180	2229	4	'	'	POS
5180	2229	5	Project	Project	NNP
5180	2229	6	,	,	,
5180	2229	7	481	481	CD
5180	2229	8	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2229	9	at	at	IN
5180	2229	10	229	229	CD
5180	2229	11	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2229	12	"	"	``
5180	2229	13	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2229	14	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	2229	15	basis	basis	NN
5180	2229	16	on	on	IN
5180	2229	17	which	which	WDT
5180	2229	18	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
5180	2229	19	differentiates	differentiate	VBZ
5180	2229	20	between	between	IN
5180	2229	21	magazines	magazine	NNS
5180	2229	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	2229	23	particularly	particularly	RB
5180	2229	24	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
5180	2229	25	to	to	IN
5180	2229	26	First	First	NNP
5180	2229	27	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2229	28	principles	principle	NNS
5180	2229	29	:	:	:
5180	2229	30	a	a	DT
5180	2229	31	magazine	magazine	NN
5180	2229	32	's	's	POS
5180	2229	33	tax	tax	NN
5180	2229	34	status	status	NN
5180	2229	35	depends	depend	VBZ
5180	2229	36	entirely	entirely	RB
5180	2229	37	on	on	IN
5180	2229	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2229	39	content	content	NN
5180	2229	40	.	.	.
5180	2230	1	Above	above	IN
5180	2230	2	all	all	DT
5180	2230	3	else	else	RB
5180	2230	4	,	,	,
5180	2230	5	the	the	DT
5180	2230	6	First	First	NNP
5180	2230	7	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2230	8	means	mean	VBZ
5180	2230	9	that	that	IN
5180	2230	10	government	government	NN
5180	2230	11	has	have	VBZ
5180	2230	12	no	no	DT
5180	2230	13	power	power	NN
5180	2230	14	to	to	TO
5180	2230	15	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	2230	16	expression	expression	NN
5180	2230	17	because	because	IN
5180	2230	18	of	of	IN
5180	2230	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2230	20	message	message	NN
5180	2230	21	,	,	,
5180	2230	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2230	23	ideas	idea	NNS
5180	2230	24	,	,	,
5180	2230	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2230	26	subject	subject	JJ
5180	2230	27	matter	matter	NN
5180	2230	28	,	,	,
5180	2230	29	or	or	CC
5180	2230	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2230	31	content	content	NN
5180	2230	32	.	.	.
5180	2230	33	"	"	''
5180	2230	34	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2231	1	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2231	2	internal	internal	JJ
5180	2231	3	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	2231	4	marks	mark	NNS
5180	2231	5	and	and	CC
5180	2231	6	citations	citation	NNS
5180	2231	7	omitted	omit	VBD
5180	2231	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2231	9	;	;	:
5180	2231	10	League	League	NNP
5180	2231	11	of	of	IN
5180	2231	12	Women	Women	NNP
5180	2231	13	Voters	Voters	NNPS
5180	2231	14	,	,	,
5180	2231	15	468	468	CD
5180	2231	16	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2231	17	at	at	IN
5180	2231	18	383	383	CD
5180	2231	19	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2231	20	"	"	``
5180	2231	21	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2231	22	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	2231	23	scope	scope	NN
5180	2231	24	of	of	IN
5180	2231	25	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2231	26	the	the	DT
5180	2231	27	challenged	challenge	VBN
5180	2231	28	statute	statute	NN
5180	2231	29	's	's	POS
5180	2231	30	]	]	-RRB-
5180	2231	31	ban	ban	NN
5180	2231	32	is	be	VBZ
5180	2231	33	defined	define	VBN
5180	2231	34	solely	solely	RB
5180	2231	35	on	on	IN
5180	2231	36	the	the	DT
5180	2231	37	basis	basis	NN
5180	2231	38	of	of	IN
5180	2231	39	the	the	DT
5180	2231	40	content	content	NN
5180	2231	41	of	of	IN
5180	2231	42	the	the	DT
5180	2231	43	suppressed	suppress	VBN
5180	2231	44	speech	speech	NN
5180	2231	45	.	.	.
5180	2231	46	"	"	''
5180	2231	47	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2231	48	.	.	.
5180	2232	1	See	see	VB
5180	2232	2	generally	generally	RB
5180	2232	3	Rosenberger	Rosenberger	NNP
5180	2232	4	,	,	,
5180	2232	5	515	515	CD
5180	2232	6	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2232	7	at	at	IN
5180	2232	8	828	828	CD
5180	2232	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2232	10	"	"	``
5180	2232	11	It	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2232	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	2232	13	axiomatic	axiomatic	JJ
5180	2232	14	that	that	IN
5180	2232	15	the	the	DT
5180	2232	16	government	government	NN
5180	2232	17	may	may	MD
5180	2232	18	not	not	RB
5180	2232	19	regulate	regulate	VB
5180	2232	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	2232	21	based	base	VBN
5180	2232	22	on	on	IN
5180	2232	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2232	24	substantive	substantive	JJ
5180	2232	25	content	content	NN
5180	2232	26	or	or	CC
5180	2232	27	the	the	DT
5180	2232	28	message	message	NN
5180	2232	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2232	30	conveys	convey	VBZ
5180	2232	31	.	.	.
5180	2232	32	"	"	''
5180	2232	33	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2232	34	.	.	.
5180	2233	1	Because	because	IN
5180	2233	2	of	of	IN
5180	2233	3	the	the	DT
5180	2233	4	technological	technological	JJ
5180	2233	5	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	2233	6	of	of	IN
5180	2233	7	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	2233	8	software	software	NN
5180	2233	9	described	describe	VBN
5180	2233	10	in	in	IN
5180	2233	11	such	such	JJ
5180	2233	12	detail	detail	NN
5180	2233	13	above	above	RB
5180	2233	14	,	,	,
5180	2233	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	2233	16	's	's	POS
5180	2233	17	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	2233	18	that	that	IN
5180	2233	19	public	public	JJ
5180	2233	20	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2233	21	use	use	VBP
5180	2233	22	such	such	JJ
5180	2233	23	software	software	NN
5180	2233	24	is	be	VBZ
5180	2233	25	in	in	IN
5180	2233	26	effect	effect	NN
5180	2233	27	a	a	DT
5180	2233	28	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	2233	29	that	that	IN
5180	2233	30	public	public	JJ
5180	2233	31	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2233	32	block	block	VBP
5180	2233	33	a	a	DT
5180	2233	34	substantial	substantial	JJ
5180	2233	35	amount	amount	NN
5180	2233	36	of	of	IN
5180	2233	37	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	2233	38	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2233	39	speech	speech	NN
5180	2233	40	on	on	IN
5180	2233	41	the	the	DT
5180	2233	42	basis	basis	NN
5180	2233	43	of	of	IN
5180	2233	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2233	45	content	content	NN
5180	2233	46	.	.	.
5180	2234	1	Plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	2234	2	'	'	POS
5180	2234	3	argument	argument	NN
5180	2234	4	that	that	IN
5180	2234	5	the	the	DT
5180	2234	6	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2234	7	government	government	NN
5180	2234	8	may	may	MD
5180	2234	9	not	not	RB
5180	2234	10	require	require	VB
5180	2234	11	public	public	JJ
5180	2234	12	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2234	13	who	who	WP
5180	2234	14	receive	receive	VBP
5180	2234	15	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2234	16	funds	fund	NNS
5180	2234	17	to	to	TO
5180	2234	18	restrict	restrict	VB
5180	2234	19	the	the	DT
5180	2234	20	availability	availability	NN
5180	2234	21	of	of	IN
5180	2234	22	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	2234	23	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2234	24	Web	web	NN
5180	2234	25	sites	site	NNS
5180	2234	26	solely	solely	RB
5180	2234	27	on	on	IN
5180	2234	28	the	the	DT
5180	2234	29	basis	basis	NN
5180	2234	30	of	of	IN
5180	2234	31	the	the	DT
5180	2234	32	sites	site	NNS
5180	2234	33	'	'	POS
5180	2234	34	content	content	NN
5180	2234	35	finds	find	VBZ
5180	2234	36	further	further	JJ
5180	2234	37	support	support	NN
5180	2234	38	in	in	IN
5180	2234	39	the	the	DT
5180	2234	40	role	role	NN
5180	2234	41	that	that	WDT
5180	2234	42	public	public	JJ
5180	2234	43	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2234	44	have	have	VBP
5180	2234	45	traditionally	traditionally	RB
5180	2234	46	served	serve	VBN
5180	2234	47	in	in	IN
5180	2234	48	maintaining	maintain	VBG
5180	2234	49	First	First	NNP
5180	2234	50	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2234	51	values	value	NNS
5180	2234	52	.	.	.
5180	2235	1	As	as	IN
5180	2235	2	evidenced	evidence	VBN
5180	2235	3	by	by	IN
5180	2235	4	the	the	DT
5180	2235	5	many	many	JJ
5180	2235	6	public	public	JJ
5180	2235	7	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2235	8	that	that	WDT
5180	2235	9	have	have	VBP
5180	2235	10	endorsed	endorse	VBN
5180	2235	11	the	the	DT
5180	2235	12	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
5180	2235	13	to	to	TO
5180	2235	14	Read	read	VB
5180	2235	15	Statement	Statement	NNP
5180	2235	16	and	and	CC
5180	2235	17	the	the	DT
5180	2235	18	Library	Library	NNP
5180	2235	19	Bill	Bill	NNP
5180	2235	20	of	of	IN
5180	2235	21	Rights	Rights	NNPS
5180	2235	22	,	,	,
5180	2235	23	see	see	VB
5180	2235	24	supra	supra	NNP
5180	2235	25	Subsection	Subsection	NNP
5180	2235	26	II.D.1	II.D.1	NNP
5180	2235	27	,	,	,
5180	2235	28	public	public	JJ
5180	2235	29	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2235	30	seemingly	seemingly	RB
5180	2235	31	have	have	VBP
5180	2235	32	a	a	DT
5180	2235	33	duty	duty	NN
5180	2235	34	to	to	TO
5180	2235	35	challenge	challenge	VB
5180	2235	36	prevailing	prevailing	NN
5180	2235	37	orthodoxy	orthodoxy	NN
5180	2235	38	and	and	CC
5180	2235	39	make	make	VB
5180	2235	40	available	available	JJ
5180	2235	41	to	to	IN
5180	2235	42	the	the	DT
5180	2235	43	public	public	JJ
5180	2235	44	controversial	controversial	NN
5180	2235	45	,	,	,
5180	2235	46	yet	yet	CC
5180	2235	47	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	2235	48	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2235	49	material	material	NN
5180	2235	50	,	,	,
5180	2235	51	even	even	RB
5180	2235	52	if	if	IN
5180	2235	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2235	54	means	mean	VBZ
5180	2235	55	drawing	draw	VBG
5180	2235	56	the	the	DT
5180	2235	57	ire	ire	NN
5180	2235	58	of	of	IN
5180	2235	59	the	the	DT
5180	2235	60	community	community	NN
5180	2235	61	.	.	.
5180	2236	1	See	see	VB
5180	2236	2	Bd	Bd	NNP
5180	2236	3	.	.	.
5180	2237	1	of	of	IN
5180	2237	2	Educ	Educ	NNP
5180	2237	3	.	.	.
5180	2238	1	v.	v.	IN
5180	2238	2	Pico	Pico	NNP
5180	2238	3	,	,	,
5180	2238	4	457	457	CD
5180	2238	5	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2238	6	853	853	CD
5180	2238	7	,	,	,
5180	2238	8	915	915	CD
5180	2238	9	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2238	10	1982	1982	CD
5180	2238	11	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2238	12	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2238	13	Rehnquist	Rehnquist	NNP
5180	2238	14	,	,	,
5180	2238	15	J.	J.	NNP
5180	2238	16	,	,	,
5180	2238	17	dissenting	dissent	VBG
5180	2238	18	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2238	19	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2238	20	noting	note	VBG
5180	2238	21	that	that	IN
5180	2238	22	"	"	``
5180	2238	23	public	public	JJ
5180	2238	24	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2238	25	"	"	''
5180	2238	26	are	be	VBP
5180	2238	27	"	"	``
5180	2238	28	designed	design	VBN
5180	2238	29	for	for	IN
5180	2238	30	freewheeling	freewheel	VBG
5180	2238	31	inquiry	inquiry	NN
5180	2238	32	"	"	''
5180	2238	33	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2238	34	.	.	.
5180	2239	1	By	by	IN
5180	2239	2	interfering	interfere	VBG
5180	2239	3	with	with	IN
5180	2239	4	public	public	JJ
5180	2239	5	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2239	6	'	'	POS
5180	2239	7	discretion	discretion	NN
5180	2239	8	to	to	TO
5180	2239	9	make	make	VB
5180	2239	10	available	available	JJ
5180	2239	11	to	to	IN
5180	2239	12	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2239	13	as	as	IN
5180	2239	14	wide	wide	JJ
5180	2239	15	a	a	DT
5180	2239	16	range	range	NN
5180	2239	17	of	of	IN
5180	2239	18	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	2239	19	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2239	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	2239	21	as	as	IN
5180	2239	22	possible	possible	JJ
5180	2239	23	,	,	,
5180	2239	24	the	the	DT
5180	2239	25	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2239	26	government	government	NN
5180	2239	27	is	be	VBZ
5180	2239	28	arguably	arguably	RB
5180	2239	29	distorting	distort	VBG
5180	2239	30	the	the	DT
5180	2239	31	usual	usual	JJ
5180	2239	32	functioning	functioning	NN
5180	2239	33	of	of	IN
5180	2239	34	public	public	JJ
5180	2239	35	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2239	36	as	as	IN
5180	2239	37	places	place	NNS
5180	2239	38	of	of	IN
5180	2239	39	freewheeling	freewheeling	NN
5180	2239	40	inquiry	inquiry	NN
5180	2239	41	.	.	.
5180	2240	1	The	the	DT
5180	2240	2	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	2240	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2240	4	,	,	,
5180	2240	5	in	in	IN
5180	2240	6	invalidating	invalidate	VBG
5180	2240	7	the	the	DT
5180	2240	8	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2240	9	government	government	NN
5180	2240	10	's	's	POS
5180	2240	11	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	2240	12	on	on	IN
5180	2240	13	the	the	DT
5180	2240	14	ability	ability	NN
5180	2240	15	of	of	IN
5180	2240	16	federally	federally	RB
5180	2240	17	funded	funded	JJ
5180	2240	18	legal	legal	JJ
5180	2240	19	services	service	NNS
5180	2240	20	providers	provider	NNS
5180	2240	21	to	to	TO
5180	2240	22	challenge	challenge	VB
5180	2240	23	the	the	DT
5180	2240	24	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
5180	2240	25	of	of	IN
5180	2240	26	welfare	welfare	NN
5180	2240	27	laws	law	NNS
5180	2240	28	,	,	,
5180	2240	29	relied	rely	VBD
5180	2240	30	on	on	IN
5180	2240	31	the	the	DT
5180	2240	32	manner	manner	NN
5180	2240	33	in	in	IN
5180	2240	34	which	which	WDT
5180	2240	35	the	the	DT
5180	2240	36	restrictions	restriction	NNS
5180	2240	37	that	that	WDT
5180	2240	38	the	the	DT
5180	2240	39	federal	federal	JJ
5180	2240	40	government	government	NN
5180	2240	41	placed	place	VBN
5180	2240	42	on	on	IN
5180	2240	43	legal	legal	JJ
5180	2240	44	services	service	NNS
5180	2240	45	'	'	POS
5180	2240	46	attorneys	attorney	NNS
5180	2240	47	'	'	POS
5180	2240	48	speech	speech	NN
5180	2240	49	distorted	distort	VBD
5180	2240	50	the	the	DT
5180	2240	51	usual	usual	JJ
5180	2240	52	functioning	functioning	NN
5180	2240	53	of	of	IN
5180	2240	54	the	the	DT
5180	2240	55	judicial	judicial	JJ
5180	2240	56	system	system	NN
5180	2240	57	:	:	:
5180	2240	58	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2240	59	T]he	T]he	NNP
5180	2240	60	Government	Government	NNP
5180	2240	61	seeks	seek	VBZ
5180	2240	62	to	to	TO
5180	2240	63	use	use	VB
5180	2240	64	an	an	DT
5180	2240	65	existing	exist	VBG
5180	2240	66	medium	medium	NN
5180	2240	67	of	of	IN
5180	2240	68	expression	expression	NN
5180	2240	69	and	and	CC
5180	2240	70	to	to	TO
5180	2240	71	control	control	VB
5180	2240	72	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2240	73	,	,	,
5180	2240	74	in	in	IN
5180	2240	75	a	a	DT
5180	2240	76	class	class	NN
5180	2240	77	of	of	IN
5180	2240	78	cases	case	NNS
5180	2240	79	,	,	,
5180	2240	80	in	in	IN
5180	2240	81	ways	way	NNS
5180	2240	82	which	which	WDT
5180	2240	83	distort	distort	VBP
5180	2240	84	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2240	85	usual	usual	JJ
5180	2240	86	functioning	functioning	NN
5180	2240	87	.	.	.
5180	2241	1	.	.	.
5180	2242	1	.	.	.
5180	2243	1	.	.	.
5180	2244	1	The	the	DT
5180	2244	2	First	First	NNP
5180	2244	3	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2244	4	forb[ids	forb[ids	ADD
5180	2244	5	]	]	-RRB-
5180	2244	6	the	the	DT
5180	2244	7	Government	Government	NNP
5180	2244	8	from	from	IN
5180	2244	9	using	use	VBG
5180	2244	10	the	the	DT
5180	2244	11	forum	forum	NN
5180	2244	12	in	in	IN
5180	2244	13	an	an	DT
5180	2244	14	unconventional	unconventional	JJ
5180	2244	15	way	way	NN
5180	2244	16	to	to	TO
5180	2244	17	suppress	suppress	VB
5180	2244	18	speech	speech	NN
5180	2244	19	inherent	inherent	JJ
5180	2244	20	in	in	IN
5180	2244	21	the	the	DT
5180	2244	22	nature	nature	NN
5180	2244	23	of	of	IN
5180	2244	24	the	the	DT
5180	2244	25	medium	medium	NN
5180	2244	26	.	.	.
5180	2245	1	531	531	CD
5180	2245	2	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2245	3	at	at	IN
5180	2245	4	543	543	CD
5180	2245	5	.	.	.
5180	2246	1	By	by	IN
5180	2246	2	the	the	DT
5180	2246	3	same	same	JJ
5180	2246	4	token	token	NN
5180	2246	5	,	,	,
5180	2246	6	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	2246	7	arguably	arguably	RB
5180	2246	8	distorts	distort	VBZ
5180	2246	9	the	the	DT
5180	2246	10	usual	usual	JJ
5180	2246	11	functioning	functioning	NN
5180	2246	12	of	of	IN
5180	2246	13	public	public	JJ
5180	2246	14	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2246	15	both	both	CC
5180	2246	16	by	by	IN
5180	2246	17	requiring	require	VBG
5180	2246	18	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2246	19	to	to	IN
5180	2246	20	:	:	:
5180	2246	21	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2246	22	1	1	LS
5180	2246	23	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2246	24	deny	deny	VB
5180	2246	25	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2246	26	access	access	NN
5180	2246	27	to	to	IN
5180	2246	28	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	2246	29	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2246	30	speech	speech	NN
5180	2246	31	that	that	IN
5180	2246	32	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2246	33	would	would	MD
5180	2246	34	otherwise	otherwise	RB
5180	2246	35	provide	provide	VB
5180	2246	36	to	to	IN
5180	2246	37	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2246	38	;	;	,
5180	2246	39	and	and	CC
5180	2246	40	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2246	41	2	2	LS
5180	2246	42	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2246	43	delegate	delegate	NN
5180	2246	44	decision	decision	NN
5180	2246	45	making	make	VBG
5180	2246	46	to	to	TO
5180	2246	47	private	private	JJ
5180	2246	48	software	software	NN
5180	2246	49	developers	developer	NNS
5180	2246	50	who	who	WP
5180	2246	51	closely	closely	RB
5180	2246	52	guard	guard	VBP
5180	2246	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2246	54	selection	selection	NN
5180	2246	55	criteria	criterion	NNS
5180	2246	56	as	as	IN
5180	2246	57	trade	trade	NN
5180	2246	58	secrets	secret	NNS
5180	2246	59	and	and	CC
5180	2246	60	who	who	WP
5180	2246	61	do	do	VBP
5180	2246	62	not	not	RB
5180	2246	63	purport	purport	VB
5180	2246	64	to	to	TO
5180	2246	65	make	make	VB
5180	2246	66	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2246	67	decisions	decision	NNS
5180	2246	68	on	on	IN
5180	2246	69	the	the	DT
5180	2246	70	basis	basis	NN
5180	2246	71	of	of	IN
5180	2246	72	whether	whether	IN
5180	2246	73	the	the	DT
5180	2246	74	blocked	block	VBN
5180	2246	75	Web	web	NN
5180	2246	76	sites	site	NNS
5180	2246	77	are	be	VBP
5180	2246	78	constitutionally	constitutionally	RB
5180	2246	79	protected	protect	VBN
5180	2246	80	or	or	CC
5180	2246	81	would	would	MD
5180	2246	82	add	add	VB
5180	2246	83	value	value	NN
5180	2246	84	to	to	IN
5180	2246	85	a	a	DT
5180	2246	86	public	public	JJ
5180	2246	87	library	library	NN
5180	2246	88	's	's	POS
5180	2246	89	collection	collection	NN
5180	2246	90	.	.	.
5180	2247	1	At	at	IN
5180	2247	2	all	all	DT
5180	2247	3	events	event	NNS
5180	2247	4	,	,	,
5180	2247	5	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	2247	6	clearly	clearly	RB
5180	2247	7	does	do	VBZ
5180	2247	8	not	not	RB
5180	2247	9	seem	seem	VB
5180	2247	10	to	to	TO
5180	2247	11	serve	serve	VB
5180	2247	12	the	the	DT
5180	2247	13	purpose	purpose	NN
5180	2247	14	of	of	IN
5180	2247	15	limiting	limit	VBG
5180	2247	16	the	the	DT
5180	2247	17	extent	extent	NN
5180	2247	18	of	of	IN
5180	2247	19	government	government	NN
5180	2247	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	2247	21	given	give	VBN
5180	2247	22	the	the	DT
5180	2247	23	extreme	extreme	JJ
5180	2247	24	diversity	diversity	NN
5180	2247	25	of	of	IN
5180	2247	26	speech	speech	NN
5180	2247	27	on	on	IN
5180	2247	28	the	the	DT
5180	2247	29	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2247	30	.	.	.
5180	2248	1	Nor	nor	CC
5180	2248	2	can	can	MD
5180	2248	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
5180	2248	4	's	's	POS
5180	2248	5	decision	decision	NN
5180	2248	6	to	to	TO
5180	2248	7	subsidize	subsidize	VB
5180	2248	8	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2248	9	access	access	NN
5180	2248	10	be	be	VB
5180	2248	11	said	say	VBN
5180	2248	12	to	to	TO
5180	2248	13	promote	promote	VB
5180	2248	14	a	a	DT
5180	2248	15	governmental	governmental	JJ
5180	2248	16	message	message	NN
5180	2248	17	or	or	CC
5180	2248	18	constitute	constitute	VB
5180	2248	19	governmental	governmental	JJ
5180	2248	20	speech	speech	NN
5180	2248	21	,	,	,
5180	2248	22	even	even	RB
5180	2248	23	under	under	IN
5180	2248	24	a	a	DT
5180	2248	25	generous	generous	JJ
5180	2248	26	understanding	understanding	NN
5180	2248	27	of	of	IN
5180	2248	28	the	the	DT
5180	2248	29	concept	concept	NN
5180	2248	30	.	.	.
5180	2249	1	As	as	IN
5180	2249	2	the	the	DT
5180	2249	3	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2249	4	noted	note	VBD
5180	2249	5	in	in	IN
5180	2249	6	Reno	Reno	NNP
5180	2249	7	v.	v.	CC
5180	2249	8	ACLU	ACLU	NNP
5180	2249	9	,	,	,
5180	2249	10	521	521	CD
5180	2249	11	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2249	12	844	844	CD
5180	2249	13	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2249	14	1997	1997	CD
5180	2249	15	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2249	16	,	,	,
5180	2249	17	"	"	''
5180	2249	18	[	[	-LRB-
5180	2249	19	i]t	i]t	NN
5180	2249	20	is	be	VBZ
5180	2249	21	no	no	DT
5180	2249	22	exaggeration	exaggeration	NN
5180	2249	23	to	to	TO
5180	2249	24	conclude	conclude	VB
5180	2249	25	that	that	IN
5180	2249	26	the	the	DT
5180	2249	27	content	content	NN
5180	2249	28	on	on	IN
5180	2249	29	the	the	DT
5180	2249	30	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2249	31	is	be	VBZ
5180	2249	32	as	as	RB
5180	2249	33	diverse	diverse	JJ
5180	2249	34	as	as	IN
5180	2249	35	human	human	JJ
5180	2249	36	thought	thought	NN
5180	2249	37	.	.	.
5180	2249	38	"	"	''
5180	2250	1	Id.	Idaho	NNP
5180	2251	1	at	at	IN
5180	2251	2	852	852	CD
5180	2251	3	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2251	4	internal	internal	JJ
5180	2251	5	quotation	quotation	NN
5180	2251	6	marks	mark	NNS
5180	2251	7	omitted	omit	VBN
5180	2251	8	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2251	9	.	.	.
5180	2252	1	Even	even	RB
5180	2252	2	with	with	IN
5180	2252	3	software	software	NN
5180	2252	4	filters	filter	NNS
5180	2252	5	in	in	IN
5180	2252	6	place	place	NN
5180	2252	7	,	,	,
5180	2252	8	the	the	DT
5180	2252	9	sheer	sheer	JJ
5180	2252	10	breadth	breadth	NN
5180	2252	11	of	of	IN
5180	2252	12	speech	speech	NN
5180	2252	13	available	available	JJ
5180	2252	14	on	on	IN
5180	2252	15	the	the	DT
5180	2252	16	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2252	17	defeats	defeat	VBZ
5180	2252	18	any	any	DT
5180	2252	19	claim	claim	NN
5180	2252	20	that	that	IN
5180	2252	21	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	2252	22	is	be	VBZ
5180	2252	23	intended	intend	VBN
5180	2252	24	to	to	TO
5180	2252	25	facilitate	facilitate	VB
5180	2252	26	the	the	DT
5180	2252	27	dissemination	dissemination	NN
5180	2252	28	of	of	IN
5180	2252	29	governmental	governmental	JJ
5180	2252	30	speech	speech	NN
5180	2252	31	.	.	.
5180	2253	1	Like	like	IN
5180	2253	2	in	in	IN
5180	2253	3	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	2253	4	,	,	,
5180	2253	5	"	"	''
5180	2253	6	there	there	EX
5180	2253	7	is	be	VBZ
5180	2253	8	no	no	DT
5180	2253	9	programmatic	programmatic	JJ
5180	2253	10	message	message	NN
5180	2253	11	of	of	IN
5180	2253	12	the	the	DT
5180	2253	13	kind	kind	NN
5180	2253	14	recognized	recognize	VBN
5180	2253	15	in	in	IN
5180	2253	16	Rust	Rust	NNP
5180	2253	17	and	and	CC
5180	2253	18	which	which	WDT
5180	2253	19	sufficed	suffice	VBD
5180	2253	20	there	there	RB
5180	2253	21	to	to	TO
5180	2253	22	allow	allow	VB
5180	2253	23	the	the	DT
5180	2253	24	Government	Government	NNP
5180	2253	25	to	to	TO
5180	2253	26	specify	specify	VB
5180	2253	27	the	the	DT
5180	2253	28	advice	advice	NN
5180	2253	29	deemed	deem	VBN
5180	2253	30	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	2253	31	for	for	IN
5180	2253	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2253	33	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
5180	2253	34	objectives	objective	NNS
5180	2253	35	.	.	.
5180	2253	36	"	"	''
5180	2254	1	Velazquez	Velazquez	NNP
5180	2254	2	,	,	,
5180	2254	3	531	531	CD
5180	2254	4	U.S.	U.S.	NNP
5180	2254	5	at	at	IN
5180	2254	6	548	548	CD
5180	2254	7	.	.	.
5180	2255	1	In	in	IN
5180	2255	2	sum	sum	NN
5180	2255	3	,	,	,
5180	2255	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2255	5	think	think	VBP
5180	2255	6	that	that	IN
5180	2255	7	the	the	DT
5180	2255	8	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	2255	9	have	have	VBP
5180	2255	10	good	good	JJ
5180	2255	11	arguments	argument	NNS
5180	2255	12	that	that	IN
5180	2255	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2255	14	may	may	MD
5180	2255	15	assert	assert	VB
5180	2255	16	an	an	DT
5180	2255	17	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2255	18	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	2255	19	claim	claim	VBP
5180	2255	20	by	by	IN
5180	2255	21	relying	rely	VBG
5180	2255	22	either	either	CC
5180	2255	23	on	on	IN
5180	2255	24	the	the	DT
5180	2255	25	public	public	JJ
5180	2255	26	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2255	27	'	'	POS
5180	2255	28	First	First	NNP
5180	2255	29	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
5180	2255	30	rights	right	NNS
5180	2255	31	or	or	CC
5180	2255	32	on	on	IN
5180	2255	33	the	the	DT
5180	2255	34	rights	right	NNS
5180	2255	35	of	of	IN
5180	2255	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2255	37	patrons	patron	NNS
5180	2255	38	.	.	.
5180	2256	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2256	2	also	also	RB
5180	2256	3	think	think	VBP
5180	2256	4	that	that	IN
5180	2256	5	the	the	DT
5180	2256	6	plaintiffs	plaintiff	NNS
5180	2256	7	have	have	VBP
5180	2256	8	a	a	DT
5180	2256	9	good	good	JJ
5180	2256	10	argument	argument	NN
5180	2256	11	that	that	IN
5180	2256	12	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	2256	13	's	's	POS
5180	2256	14	requirement	requirement	NN
5180	2256	15	that	that	IN
5180	2256	16	public	public	JJ
5180	2256	17	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2256	18	use	use	VBP
5180	2256	19	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	2256	20	software	software	NN
5180	2256	21	distorts	distort	VBZ
5180	2256	22	the	the	DT
5180	2256	23	usual	usual	JJ
5180	2256	24	functioning	functioning	NN
5180	2256	25	of	of	IN
5180	2256	26	public	public	JJ
5180	2256	27	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2256	28	in	in	IN
5180	2256	29	such	such	PDT
5180	2256	30	a	a	DT
5180	2256	31	way	way	NN
5180	2256	32	that	that	WDT
5180	2256	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2256	34	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
5180	2256	35	an	an	DT
5180	2256	36	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2256	37	condition	condition	NN
5180	2256	38	on	on	IN
5180	2256	39	the	the	DT
5180	2256	40	receipt	receipt	NN
5180	2256	41	of	of	IN
5180	2256	42	funds	fund	NNS
5180	2256	43	.	.	.
5180	2257	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2257	2	do	do	VBP
5180	2257	3	not	not	RB
5180	2257	4	decide	decide	VB
5180	2257	5	these	these	DT
5180	2257	6	issues	issue	NNS
5180	2257	7	,	,	,
5180	2257	8	confident	confident	JJ
5180	2257	9	that	that	IN
5180	2257	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2257	11	findings	finding	NNS
5180	2257	12	of	of	IN
5180	2257	13	fact	fact	NN
5180	2257	14	on	on	IN
5180	2257	15	the	the	DT
5180	2257	16	functioning	functioning	NN
5180	2257	17	of	of	IN
5180	2257	18	public	public	JJ
5180	2257	19	libraries	library	NNS
5180	2257	20	,	,	,
5180	2257	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
5180	2257	22	use	use	NN
5180	2257	23	of	of	IN
5180	2257	24	the	the	DT
5180	2257	25	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2257	26	,	,	,
5180	2257	27	and	and	CC
5180	2257	28	the	the	DT
5180	2257	29	technological	technological	JJ
5180	2257	30	limitations	limitation	NNS
5180	2257	31	of	of	IN
5180	2257	32	Internet	internet	NN
5180	2257	33	filtering	filter	VBG
5180	2257	34	software	software	NN
5180	2257	35	,	,	,
5180	2257	36	see	see	VB
5180	2257	37	supra	supra	NNP
5180	2257	38	Sections	Sections	NNPS
5180	2257	39	II.D	ii.d	NN
5180	2257	40	-	-	HYPH
5180	2257	41	E	e	NN
5180	2257	42	,	,	,
5180	2257	43	would	would	MD
5180	2257	44	allow	allow	VB
5180	2257	45	the	the	DT
5180	2257	46	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
5180	2257	47	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2257	48	to	to	TO
5180	2257	49	decide	decide	VB
5180	2257	50	the	the	DT
5180	2257	51	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
5180	2257	52	conditions	condition	NNS
5180	2257	53	claim	claim	VBP
5180	2257	54	if	if	IN
5180	2257	55	the	the	DT
5180	2257	56	Court	Court	NNP
5180	2257	57	deems	deem	VBZ
5180	2257	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2257	59	necessary	necessary	JJ
5180	2257	60	.	.	.
5180	2258	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	2258	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	2258	3	.	.	.
5180	2259	1	1712(a)(2	1712(a)(2	LS
5180	2259	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2259	3	contains	contain	VBZ
5180	2259	4	a	a	DT
5180	2259	5	provision	provision	NN
5180	2259	6	titled	title	VBN
5180	2259	7	"	"	``
5180	2259	8	Separability	Separability	NNP
5180	2259	9	,	,	,
5180	2259	10	"	"	''
5180	2259	11	which	which	WDT
5180	2259	12	is	be	VBZ
5180	2259	13	codified	codify	VBN
5180	2259	14	in	in	IN
5180	2259	15	the	the	DT
5180	2259	16	Library	Library	NNP
5180	2259	17	Services	Services	NNPS
5180	2259	18	and	and	CC
5180	2259	19	Technology	Technology	NNP
5180	2259	20	Act	Act	NNP
5180	2259	21	,	,	,
5180	2259	22	20	20	CD
5180	2259	23	U.S.C.	U.S.C.	NNS
5180	2260	1	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	2260	2	.	.	.
5180	2261	1	9134(f)(6	9134(f)(6	LS
5180	2261	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2261	3	,	,	,
5180	2261	4	and	and	CC
5180	2261	5	provides	provide	VBZ
5180	2261	6	:	:	:
5180	2261	7	"	"	``
5180	2261	8	If	if	IN
5180	2261	9	any	any	DT
5180	2261	10	provision	provision	NN
5180	2261	11	of	of	IN
5180	2261	12	this	this	DT
5180	2261	13	subsection	subsection	NN
5180	2261	14	is	be	VBZ
5180	2261	15	held	hold	VBN
5180	2261	16	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	2261	17	,	,	,
5180	2261	18	the	the	DT
5180	2261	19	remainder	remainder	NN
5180	2261	20	of	of	IN
5180	2261	21	this	this	DT
5180	2261	22	subsection	subsection	NN
5180	2261	23	shall	shall	MD
5180	2261	24	not	not	RB
5180	2261	25	be	be	VB
5180	2261	26	affected	affect	VBN
5180	2261	27	thereby	thereby	RB
5180	2261	28	.	.	.
5180	2261	29	"	"	''
5180	2262	1	CIPA	CIPA	VBN
5180	2262	2	section	section	NN
5180	2262	3	1721(e	1721(e	CD
5180	2262	4	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2262	5	also	also	RB
5180	2262	6	contained	contain	VBD
5180	2262	7	a	a	DT
5180	2262	8	similar	similar	JJ
5180	2262	9	provision	provision	NN
5180	2262	10	that	that	WDT
5180	2262	11	applied	apply	VBD
5180	2262	12	to	to	IN
5180	2262	13	E	e	NN
5180	2262	14	-	-	NN
5180	2262	15	rate	rate	NN
5180	2262	16	funding	funding	NN
5180	2262	17	,	,	,
5180	2262	18	although	although	IN
5180	2262	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
5180	2262	20	was	be	VBD
5180	2262	21	not	not	RB
5180	2262	22	codified	codify	VBN
5180	2262	23	in	in	IN
5180	2262	24	the	the	DT
5180	2262	25	Communications	Communications	NNPS
5180	2262	26	Act	Act	NNP
5180	2262	27	.	.	.
5180	2263	1	That	that	DT
5180	2263	2	section	section	NN
5180	2263	3	,	,	,
5180	2263	4	also	also	RB
5180	2263	5	titled	title	VBN
5180	2263	6	"	"	``
5180	2263	7	Separability	Separability	NNP
5180	2263	8	,	,	,
5180	2263	9	"	"	''
5180	2263	10	provided	provide	VBN
5180	2263	11	:	:	:
5180	2263	12	"	"	``
5180	2263	13	If	if	IN
5180	2263	14	any	any	DT
5180	2263	15	provision	provision	NN
5180	2263	16	of	of	IN
5180	2263	17	paragraph	paragraph	NN
5180	2263	18	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2263	19	5	5	CD
5180	2263	20	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2263	21	or	or	CC
5180	2263	22	(	(	-LRB-
5180	2263	23	6	6	CD
5180	2263	24	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2263	25	of	of	IN
5180	2263	26	section	section	NN
5180	2263	27	254(h	254(h	CD
5180	2263	28	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2263	29	of	of	IN
5180	2263	30	the	the	DT
5180	2263	31	Communications	Communications	NNP
5180	2263	32	Act	Act	NNP
5180	2263	33	of	of	IN
5180	2263	34	1934	1934	CD
5180	2263	35	,	,	,
5180	2263	36	as	as	IN
5180	2263	37	amended	amend	VBN
5180	2263	38	by	by	IN
5180	2263	39	this	this	DT
5180	2263	40	section	section	NN
5180	2263	41	,	,	,
5180	2263	42	or	or	CC
5180	2263	43	the	the	DT
5180	2263	44	application	application	NN
5180	2263	45	thereof	thereof	RB
5180	2263	46	to	to	IN
5180	2263	47	any	any	DT
5180	2263	48	person	person	NN
5180	2263	49	or	or	CC
5180	2263	50	circumstance	circumstance	NN
5180	2263	51	is	be	VBZ
5180	2263	52	held	hold	VBN
5180	2263	53	invalid	invalid	JJ
5180	2263	54	,	,	,
5180	2263	55	the	the	DT
5180	2263	56	remainder	remainder	NN
5180	2263	57	of	of	IN
5180	2263	58	such	such	JJ
5180	2263	59	paragraph	paragraph	NN
5180	2263	60	and	and	CC
5180	2263	61	the	the	DT
5180	2263	62	application	application	NN
5180	2263	63	of	of	IN
5180	2263	64	such	such	JJ
5180	2263	65	paragraph	paragraph	NN
5180	2263	66	to	to	IN
5180	2263	67	other	other	JJ
5180	2263	68	persons	person	NNS
5180	2263	69	or	or	CC
5180	2263	70	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
5180	2263	71	shall	shall	MD
5180	2263	72	not	not	RB
5180	2263	73	be	be	VB
5180	2263	74	affected	affect	VBN
5180	2263	75	thereby	thereby	RB
5180	2263	76	.	.	.
5180	2263	77	"	"	''
5180	2264	1	CIPA	CIPA	NNP
5180	2264	2	Sec	Sec	NNP
5180	2264	3	.	.	.
5180	2265	1	1721(e	1721(e	LS
5180	2265	2	)	)	-RRB-
5180	2265	3	.	.	.