id sid tid token lemma pos www-nature-com-63 1 1 Policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 1 2 assessments assessment NNS www-nature-com-63 1 3 for for IN www-nature-com-63 1 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 1 5 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 1 6 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 1 7 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 1 8 and and CC www-nature-com-63 1 9 sustainability sustainability NN www-nature-com-63 1 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 1 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 1 12 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 1 13 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 1 14 in in IN www-nature-com-63 1 15 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 1 16 ARTICLE ARTICLE NNP www-nature-com-63 1 17 Policy Policy NNP www-nature-com-63 1 18 assessments assessment NNS www-nature-com-63 1 19 for for IN www-nature-com-63 1 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 1 21 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 1 22 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 1 23 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 1 24 and and CC www-nature-com-63 1 25 sustainability sustainability NN www-nature-com-63 1 26 of of IN www-nature-com-63 1 27 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 1 28 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 1 29 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 1 30 in in IN www-nature-com-63 1 31 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 1 32 Shangrong Shangrong NNP www-nature-com-63 1 33 Jiang Jiang NNP www-nature-com-63 1 34 1,7 1,7 CD www-nature-com-63 1 35 , , , www-nature-com-63 1 36 Yuze Yuze NNP www-nature-com-63 1 37 Li Li NNP www-nature-com-63 1 38 1,2,7 1,2,7 CD www-nature-com-63 1 39 , , , www-nature-com-63 1 40 Quanying Quanying NNP www-nature-com-63 1 41 Lu2 lu2 NN www-nature-com-63 1 42 , , , www-nature-com-63 1 43 Yongmiao Yongmiao NNP www-nature-com-63 1 44 Hong2,3 Hong2,3 NNP www-nature-com-63 1 45 , , , www-nature-com-63 1 46 Dabo Dabo NNP www-nature-com-63 1 47 Guan4 guan4 CD www-nature-com-63 1 48 ✉ ✉ NN www-nature-com-63 1 49 , , , www-nature-com-63 1 50 Yu Yu NNP www-nature-com-63 1 51 Xiong5 Xiong5 NNP www-nature-com-63 1 52 & & CC www-nature-com-63 1 53 Shouyang Shouyang NNP www-nature-com-63 1 54 Wang Wang NNP www-nature-com-63 1 55 1,2,6 1,2,6 CD www-nature-com-63 1 56 ✉ ✉ NN www-nature-com-63 1 57 The the DT www-nature-com-63 1 58 growing grow VBG www-nature-com-63 1 59 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 1 60 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 1 61 and and CC www-nature-com-63 1 62 associated associated JJ www-nature-com-63 1 63 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 1 64 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 1 65 of of IN www-nature-com-63 1 66 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 1 67 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 1 68 could could MD www-nature-com-63 1 69 potentially potentially RB www-nature-com-63 1 70 undermine undermine VB www-nature-com-63 1 71 global global JJ www-nature-com-63 1 72 sustainable sustainable JJ www-nature-com-63 1 73 efforts effort NNS www-nature-com-63 1 74 . . . www-nature-com-63 2 1 By by IN www-nature-com-63 2 2 investigating investigate VBG www-nature-com-63 2 3 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 2 4 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 2 5 flows flow NNS www-nature-com-63 2 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 2 7 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 2 8 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 2 9 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 2 10 in in IN www-nature-com-63 2 11 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 2 12 with with IN www-nature-com-63 2 13 a a DT www-nature-com-63 2 14 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 2 15 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 2 16 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 2 17 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 2 18 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 2 19 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 2 20 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 2 21 model model NN www-nature-com-63 2 22 , , , www-nature-com-63 2 23 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 2 24 find find VBP www-nature-com-63 2 25 that that IN www-nature-com-63 2 26 without without IN www-nature-com-63 2 27 any any DT www-nature-com-63 2 28 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 2 29 interventions intervention NNS www-nature-com-63 2 30 , , , www-nature-com-63 2 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 2 32 annual annual JJ www-nature-com-63 2 33 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 2 34 con- con- NN www-nature-com-63 2 35 sumption sumption NN www-nature-com-63 2 36 of of IN www-nature-com-63 2 37 the the DT www-nature-com-63 2 38 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 2 39 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 2 40 in in IN www-nature-com-63 2 41 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 2 42 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 2 43 expected expect VBN www-nature-com-63 2 44 to to TO www-nature-com-63 2 45 peak peak VB www-nature-com-63 2 46 in in IN www-nature-com-63 2 47 2024 2024 CD www-nature-com-63 2 48 at at IN www-nature-com-63 2 49 296.59 296.59 CD www-nature-com-63 2 50 Twh Twh NNP www-nature-com-63 2 51 and and CC www-nature-com-63 2 52 generate generate VB www-nature-com-63 2 53 130.50 130.50 CD www-nature-com-63 2 54 million million CD www-nature-com-63 2 55 metric metric JJ www-nature-com-63 2 56 tons ton NNS www-nature-com-63 2 57 of of IN www-nature-com-63 2 58 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 2 59 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 2 60 correspondingly correspondingly RB www-nature-com-63 2 61 . . . www-nature-com-63 3 1 Internationally internationally RB www-nature-com-63 3 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 3 3 this this DT www-nature-com-63 3 4 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 3 5 output output NN www-nature-com-63 3 6 would would MD www-nature-com-63 3 7 exceed exceed VB www-nature-com-63 3 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 3 9 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 3 10 annualized annualize VBN www-nature-com-63 3 11 greenhouse greenhouse NN www-nature-com-63 3 12 gas gas NN www-nature-com-63 3 13 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 3 14 output output NN www-nature-com-63 3 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 3 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 3 17 Czech Czech NNP www-nature-com-63 3 18 Republic Republic NNP www-nature-com-63 3 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 3 20 Qatar Qatar NNP www-nature-com-63 3 21 . . . www-nature-com-63 4 1 Domestically domestically RB www-nature-com-63 4 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 4 3 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 4 4 ranks rank VBZ www-nature-com-63 4 5 in in IN www-nature-com-63 4 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 4 7 top top JJ www-nature-com-63 4 8 10 10 CD www-nature-com-63 4 9 among among IN www-nature-com-63 4 10 182 182 CD www-nature-com-63 4 11 cities city NNS www-nature-com-63 4 12 and and CC www-nature-com-63 4 13 42 42 CD www-nature-com-63 4 14 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 4 15 sectors sector NNS www-nature-com-63 4 16 in in IN www-nature-com-63 4 17 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 4 18 . . . www-nature-com-63 5 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 5 2 this this DT www-nature-com-63 5 3 work work NN www-nature-com-63 5 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 5 5 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 5 6 show show VBP www-nature-com-63 5 7 that that IN www-nature-com-63 5 8 moving move VBG www-nature-com-63 5 9 away away RB www-nature-com-63 5 10 from from IN www-nature-com-63 5 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 5 12 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 5 13 punitive punitive JJ www-nature-com-63 5 14 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 5 15 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 5 16 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 5 17 to to IN www-nature-com-63 5 18 a a DT www-nature-com-63 5 19 site site NN www-nature-com-63 5 20 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 5 21 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 5 22 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 5 23 induces induce VBZ www-nature-com-63 5 24 changes change NNS www-nature-com-63 5 25 in in IN www-nature-com-63 5 26 the the DT www-nature-com-63 5 27 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 5 28 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 5 29 structure structure NN www-nature-com-63 5 30 of of IN www-nature-com-63 5 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 5 32 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 5 33 activities activity NNS www-nature-com-63 5 34 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 5 35 more more RBR www-nature-com-63 5 36 effective effective JJ www-nature-com-63 5 37 in in IN www-nature-com-63 5 38 limiting limit VBG www-nature-com-63 5 39 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 5 40 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 5 41 of of IN www-nature-com-63 5 42 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 5 43 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 5 44 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 5 45 . . . www-nature-com-63 6 1 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 NNP www-nature-com-63 6 2 OPEN OPEN NNP www-nature-com-63 6 3 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 6 4 School School NNP www-nature-com-63 6 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 6 6 Economics Economics NNP www-nature-com-63 6 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 6 8 Management Management NNP www-nature-com-63 6 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 6 10 University University NNP www-nature-com-63 6 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 6 12 Chinese Chinese NNP www-nature-com-63 6 13 Academy Academy NNP www-nature-com-63 6 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 6 15 Sciences Sciences NNPS www-nature-com-63 6 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 6 17 Beijing Beijing NNP www-nature-com-63 6 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 6 19 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 6 20 . . . www-nature-com-63 7 1 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 7 2 Academy Academy NNP www-nature-com-63 7 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 7 4 Mathematics Mathematics NNP www-nature-com-63 7 5 and and CC www-nature-com-63 7 6 Systems Systems NNPS www-nature-com-63 7 7 Science Science NNP www-nature-com-63 7 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 7 9 Chinese Chinese NNP www-nature-com-63 7 10 Academy Academy NNP www-nature-com-63 7 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 7 12 Sciences Sciences NNPS www-nature-com-63 7 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 7 14 Beijing Beijing NNP www-nature-com-63 7 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 7 16 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 7 17 . . . www-nature-com-63 8 1 3 3 CD www-nature-com-63 8 2 Department Department NNP www-nature-com-63 8 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 8 4 Economics Economics NNP www-nature-com-63 8 5 and and CC www-nature-com-63 8 6 Department Department NNP www-nature-com-63 8 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 8 8 Statistical Statistical NNP www-nature-com-63 8 9 Science Science NNP www-nature-com-63 8 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 8 11 Cornell Cornell NNP www-nature-com-63 8 12 University University NNP www-nature-com-63 8 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 8 14 Ithaca Ithaca NNP www-nature-com-63 8 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 8 16 NY NY NNP www-nature-com-63 8 17 , , , www-nature-com-63 8 18 USA USA NNP www-nature-com-63 8 19 . . . www-nature-com-63 9 1 4 4 CD www-nature-com-63 9 2 Department Department NNP www-nature-com-63 9 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 9 4 Earth Earth NNP www-nature-com-63 9 5 System System NNP www-nature-com-63 9 6 Science Science NNP www-nature-com-63 9 7 , , , www-nature-com-63 9 8 Tsinghua Tsinghua NNP www-nature-com-63 9 9 University University NNP www-nature-com-63 9 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 9 11 Beijing Beijing NNP www-nature-com-63 9 12 , , , www-nature-com-63 9 13 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 9 14 . . . www-nature-com-63 10 1 5 5 CD www-nature-com-63 10 2 Surrey Surrey NNP www-nature-com-63 10 3 Business Business NNP www-nature-com-63 10 4 School School NNP www-nature-com-63 10 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 10 6 University University NNP www-nature-com-63 10 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 10 8 Surrey Surrey NNP www-nature-com-63 10 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 10 10 Guildford Guildford NNP www-nature-com-63 10 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 10 12 UK UK NNP www-nature-com-63 10 13 . . . www-nature-com-63 11 1 6 6 CD www-nature-com-63 11 2 Center Center NNP www-nature-com-63 11 3 for for IN www-nature-com-63 11 4 Forecasting Forecasting NNP www-nature-com-63 11 5 Science Science NNP www-nature-com-63 11 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 11 7 Chinese Chinese NNP www-nature-com-63 11 8 Academy Academy NNP www-nature-com-63 11 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 11 10 Sciences Sciences NNPS www-nature-com-63 11 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 11 12 Beijing Beijing NNP www-nature-com-63 11 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 11 14 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 11 15 . . . www-nature-com-63 12 1 7These 7these JJ www-nature-com-63 12 2 authors author NNS www-nature-com-63 12 3 contributed contribute VBD www-nature-com-63 12 4 equally equally RB www-nature-com-63 12 5 : : : www-nature-com-63 12 6 Shangrong Shangrong NNP www-nature-com-63 12 7 Jiang Jiang NNP www-nature-com-63 12 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 12 9 Yuze Yuze NNP www-nature-com-63 12 10 Li Li NNP www-nature-com-63 12 11 . . . www-nature-com-63 13 1 ✉ ✉ NNP www-nature-com-63 13 2 email email NNP www-nature-com-63 13 3 : : : www-nature-com-63 13 4 guandabo@tsinghua.edu.cn guandabo@tsinghua.edu.cn NNP www-nature-com-63 13 5 ; ; : www-nature-com-63 13 6 sywang@amss.ac.cn sywang@amss.ac.cn CD www-nature-com-63 13 7 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 13 8 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 13 9 | | CD www-nature-com-63 13 10 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 13 11 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 13 12 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 13 13 12:1938 12:1938 CD www-nature-com-63 13 14 | | CD www-nature-com-63 13 15 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 13 16 | | NNP www-nature-com-63 13 17 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 13 18 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 13 19 12 12 CD www-nature-com-63 13 20 3 3 CD www-nature-com-63 13 21 4 4 CD www-nature-com-63 13 22 5 5 CD www-nature-com-63 13 23 6 6 CD www-nature-com-63 13 24 7 7 CD www-nature-com-63 13 25 8 8 CD www-nature-com-63 13 26 9 9 CD www-nature-com-63 13 27 0 0 CD www-nature-com-63 13 28 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 13 29 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 13 30 : : : www-nature-com-63 13 31 , , , www-nature-com-63 13 32 ; ; : www-nature-com-63 13 33 http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3&domain=pdf http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3&domain=pdf ADD www-nature-com-63 13 34 http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3&domain=pdf http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3&domain=pdf NN www-nature-com-63 13 35 http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3&domain=pdf http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3&domain=pdf NNP www-nature-com-63 13 36 http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3&domain=pdf http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3&domain=pdf NNP www-nature-com-63 13 37 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2780-9075 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2780-9075 NNP www-nature-com-63 13 38 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2780-9075 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2780-9075 NNP www-nature-com-63 13 39 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2780-9075 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2780-9075 NNP www-nature-com-63 13 40 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2780-9075 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2780-9075 NNP www-nature-com-63 13 41 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2780-9075 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-2780-9075 NNP www-nature-com-63 13 42 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7649-0750 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7649-0750 JJ www-nature-com-63 13 43 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7649-0750 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7649-0750 JJ www-nature-com-63 13 44 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7649-0750 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7649-0750 JJ www-nature-com-63 13 45 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7649-0750 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7649-0750 JJ www-nature-com-63 13 46 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7649-0750 http://orcid.org/0000-0002-7649-0750 NNP www-nature-com-63 13 47 http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5773-998X http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5773-998x UH www-nature-com-63 13 48 http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5773-998X http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5773-998x UH www-nature-com-63 13 49 http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5773-998X http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5773-998x UH www-nature-com-63 13 50 http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5773-998X http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5773-998x UH www-nature-com-63 13 51 http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5773-998X http://orcid.org/0000-0001-5773-998x UH www-nature-com-63 13 52 mailto:guandabo@tsinghua.edu.cn mailto:guandabo@tsinghua.edu.cn NNP www-nature-com-63 13 53 mailto:sywang@amss.ac.cn mailto:sywang@amss.ac.cn NNP www-nature-com-63 13 54 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 13 55 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication VBZ www-nature-com-63 13 56 A a DT www-nature-com-63 13 57 s s NNP www-nature-com-63 13 58 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 13 59 attracted attract VBD www-nature-com-63 13 60 considerable considerable JJ www-nature-com-63 13 61 amount amount NN www-nature-com-63 13 62 of of IN www-nature-com-63 13 63 attention attention NN www-nature-com-63 13 64 in in IN www-nature-com-63 13 65 recent recent JJ www-nature-com-63 13 66 years year NNS www-nature-com-63 13 67 , , , www-nature-com-63 13 68 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 13 69 underlying underlying JJ www-nature-com-63 13 70 core core NN www-nature-com-63 13 71 mechanism mechanism NN www-nature-com-63 13 72 , , , www-nature-com-63 13 73 namely namely RB www-nature-com-63 13 74 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 13 75 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 13 76 , , , www-nature-com-63 13 77 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 13 78 also also RB www-nature-com-63 13 79 quickly quickly RB www-nature-com-63 13 80 gained gain VBN www-nature-com-63 13 81 popularity popularity NN www-nature-com-63 13 82 . . . www-nature-com-63 14 1 Due due IN www-nature-com-63 14 2 to to IN www-nature-com-63 14 3 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 14 4 key key JJ www-nature-com-63 14 5 characteristics characteristic NNS www-nature-com-63 14 6 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 14 7 as as IN www-nature-com-63 14 8 decentralization decentralization NN www-nature-com-63 14 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 14 10 audit- audit- NNP www-nature-com-63 14 11 ability ability NN www-nature-com-63 14 12 , , , www-nature-com-63 14 13 and and CC www-nature-com-63 14 14 anonymity anonymity NN www-nature-com-63 14 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 14 16 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 14 17 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 14 18 widely widely RB www-nature-com-63 14 19 regarded regard VBN www-nature-com-63 14 20 as as IN www-nature-com-63 14 21 one one CD www-nature-com-63 14 22 of of IN www-nature-com-63 14 23 the the DT www-nature-com-63 14 24 most most RBS www-nature-com-63 14 25 promising promising JJ www-nature-com-63 14 26 and and CC www-nature-com-63 14 27 attractive attractive JJ www-nature-com-63 14 28 technologies technology NNS www-nature-com-63 14 29 for for IN www-nature-com-63 14 30 a a DT www-nature-com-63 14 31 variety variety NN www-nature-com-63 14 32 of of IN www-nature-com-63 14 33 industries industry NNS www-nature-com-63 14 34 , , , www-nature-com-63 14 35 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 14 36 as as IN www-nature-com-63 14 37 supply supply NN www-nature-com-63 14 38 chain chain NN www-nature-com-63 14 39 finance finance NN www-nature-com-63 14 40 , , , www-nature-com-63 14 41 production production NN www-nature-com-63 14 42 operations operation NNS www-nature-com-63 14 43 management management NN www-nature-com-63 14 44 , , , www-nature-com-63 14 45 logistics logistic NNS www-nature-com-63 14 46 management management NN www-nature-com-63 14 47 , , , www-nature-com-63 14 48 and and CC www-nature-com-63 14 49 the the DT www-nature-com-63 14 50 Internet internet NN www-nature-com-63 14 51 of of IN www-nature-com-63 14 52 Things thing NNS www-nature-com-63 14 53 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 14 54 IoT)1–3 IoT)1–3 NNP www-nature-com-63 14 55 . . . www-nature-com-63 15 1 Despite despite IN www-nature-com-63 15 2 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 15 3 promises promise NNS www-nature-com-63 15 4 and and CC www-nature-com-63 15 5 attractiveness attractiveness NN www-nature-com-63 15 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 15 7 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 15 8 first first JJ www-nature-com-63 15 9 appli- appli- NNP www-nature-com-63 15 10 cation cation NN www-nature-com-63 15 11 in in IN www-nature-com-63 15 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 15 13 actual actual JJ www-nature-com-63 15 14 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 15 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 15 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 15 17 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 15 18 network network NN www-nature-com-63 15 19 indicates indicate VBZ www-nature-com-63 15 20 that that IN www-nature-com-63 15 21 there there EX www-nature-com-63 15 22 exists exist VBZ www-nature-com-63 15 23 a a DT www-nature-com-63 15 24 non non JJ www-nature-com-63 15 25 - - JJ www-nature-com-63 15 26 negligible negligible JJ www-nature-com-63 15 27 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 15 28 and and CC www-nature-com-63 15 29 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 15 30 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 15 31 drawback drawback NN www-nature-com-63 15 32 with with IN www-nature-com-63 15 33 the the DT www-nature-com-63 15 34 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 15 35 consensus consensus NN www-nature-com-63 15 36 algorithm algorithm NN www-nature-com-63 15 37 . . . www-nature-com-63 16 1 Therefore therefore RB www-nature-com-63 16 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 16 3 there there EX www-nature-com-63 16 4 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 16 5 an an DT www-nature-com-63 16 6 urgent urgent JJ www-nature-com-63 16 7 need need NN www-nature-com-63 16 8 to to TO www-nature-com-63 16 9 address address VB www-nature-com-63 16 10 this this DT www-nature-com-63 16 11 issue issue NN www-nature-com-63 16 12 . . . www-nature-com-63 17 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 17 2 this this DT www-nature-com-63 17 3 paper paper NN www-nature-com-63 17 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 17 5 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 17 6 quantify quantify VBP www-nature-com-63 17 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 17 8 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 17 9 and and CC www-nature-com-63 17 10 future future JJ www-nature-com-63 17 11 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 17 12 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 17 13 patterns pattern NNS www-nature-com-63 17 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 17 15 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 17 16 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 17 17 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 17 18 in in IN www-nature-com-63 17 19 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 17 20 under under IN www-nature-com-63 17 21 different different JJ www-nature-com-63 17 22 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 17 23 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 17 24 . . . www-nature-com-63 18 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 18 2 recent recent JJ www-nature-com-63 18 3 years year NNS www-nature-com-63 18 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 18 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 18 6 system system NN www-nature-com-63 18 7 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 18 8 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 18 9 SD SD NNP www-nature-com-63 18 10 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 18 11 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 18 12 model model NN www-nature-com-63 18 13 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 18 14 widely widely RB www-nature-com-63 18 15 introduced introduce VBN www-nature-com-63 18 16 for for IN www-nature-com-63 18 17 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 18 18 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 18 19 flow flow NN www-nature-com-63 18 20 estimation estimation NN www-nature-com-63 18 21 of of IN www-nature-com-63 18 22 a a DT www-nature-com-63 18 23 specific specific JJ www-nature-com-63 18 24 area area NN www-nature-com-63 18 25 or or CC www-nature-com-63 18 26 industry4,5 industry4,5 NN www-nature-com-63 18 27 . . . www-nature-com-63 19 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 19 2 comparison comparison NN www-nature-com-63 19 3 to to IN www-nature-com-63 19 4 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 19 5 counterparts counterpart NNS www-nature-com-63 19 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 19 7 SD SD NNP www-nature-com-63 19 8 modeling modeling NN www-nature-com-63 19 9 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 19 10 two two CD www-nature-com-63 19 11 main main JJ www-nature-com-63 19 12 advantages advantage NNS www-nature-com-63 19 13 in in IN www-nature-com-63 19 14 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 19 15 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 19 16 flow flow NN www-nature-com-63 19 17 assessment assessment NN www-nature-com-63 19 18 : : : www-nature-com-63 19 19 first first RB www-nature-com-63 19 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 19 21 by by IN www-nature-com-63 19 22 combining combine VBG www-nature-com-63 19 23 the the DT www-nature-com-63 19 24 feedback feedback NN www-nature-com-63 19 25 loops loop NNS www-nature-com-63 19 26 of of IN www-nature-com-63 19 27 stock stock NN www-nature-com-63 19 28 and and CC www-nature-com-63 19 29 flow flow NN www-nature-com-63 19 30 para- para- NNP www-nature-com-63 19 31 meters meter NNS www-nature-com-63 19 32 , , , www-nature-com-63 19 33 SD SD NNP www-nature-com-63 19 34 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 19 35 able able JJ www-nature-com-63 19 36 to to TO www-nature-com-63 19 37 capture capture VB www-nature-com-63 19 38 and and CC www-nature-com-63 19 39 reproduce reproduce VB www-nature-com-63 19 40 the the DT www-nature-com-63 19 41 endogenous endogenous JJ www-nature-com-63 19 42 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 19 43 of of IN www-nature-com-63 19 44 complex complex JJ www-nature-com-63 19 45 system system NN www-nature-com-63 19 46 elements element NNS www-nature-com-63 19 47 , , , www-nature-com-63 19 48 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 19 49 enables enable VBZ www-nature-com-63 19 50 the the DT www-nature-com-63 19 51 simu- simu- NN www-nature-com-63 19 52 lation lation NN www-nature-com-63 19 53 and and CC www-nature-com-63 19 54 estimation estimation NN www-nature-com-63 19 55 of of IN www-nature-com-63 19 56 specific specific JJ www-nature-com-63 19 57 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 19 58 operations6–8 operations6–8 JJ www-nature-com-63 19 59 . . . www-nature-com-63 20 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 20 2 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 20 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 20 4 since since IN www-nature-com-63 20 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 20 6 SD sd NN www-nature-com-63 20 7 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 20 8 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 20 9 model model NN www-nature-com-63 20 10 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 20 11 focused focus VBN www-nature-com-63 20 12 on on IN www-nature-com-63 20 13 disequilibrium disequilibrium NN www-nature-com-63 20 14 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 20 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 20 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 20 17 complex complex JJ www-nature-com-63 20 18 system9,10 system9,10 NNP www-nature-com-63 20 19 , , , www-nature-com-63 20 20 intended intend VBN www-nature-com-63 20 21 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 20 22 can can MD www-nature-com-63 20 23 be be VB www-nature-com-63 20 24 adjusted adjust VBN www-nature-com-63 20 25 for for IN www-nature-com-63 20 26 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 20 27 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 20 28 effectiveness effectiveness NN www-nature-com-63 20 29 evaluation evaluation NN www-nature-com-63 20 30 . . . www-nature-com-63 21 1 Conse- Conse- NNP www-nature-com-63 21 2 quently quently RB www-nature-com-63 21 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 21 4 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 21 5 on on IN www-nature-com-63 21 6 system system NN www-nature-com-63 21 7 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 21 8 modeling modeling NN www-nature-com-63 21 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 21 10 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 21 11 develop develop VBP www-nature-com-63 21 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 21 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 21 14 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 21 15 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 21 16 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 21 17 model model NN www-nature-com-63 21 18 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 21 19 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 21 20 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 21 21 to to TO www-nature-com-63 21 22 assess assess VB www-nature-com-63 21 23 the the DT www-nature-com-63 21 24 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 21 25 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 21 26 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 21 27 of of IN www-nature-com-63 21 28 the the DT www-nature-com-63 21 29 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 21 30 network network NN www-nature-com-63 21 31 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 21 32 in in IN www-nature-com-63 21 33 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 21 34 under under IN www-nature-com-63 21 35 different different JJ www-nature-com-63 21 36 scenarios scenario NNS www-nature-com-63 21 37 . . . www-nature-com-63 22 1 This this DT www-nature-com-63 22 2 paper paper NN www-nature-com-63 22 3 uses use VBZ www-nature-com-63 22 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 22 5 theory theory NN www-nature-com-63 22 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 22 7 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 22 8 footprint footprint NN www-nature-com-63 22 9 to to TO www-nature-com-63 22 10 create create VB www-nature-com-63 22 11 a a DT www-nature-com-63 22 12 theoretical theoretical JJ www-nature-com-63 22 13 model model NN www-nature-com-63 22 14 for for IN www-nature-com-63 22 15 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 22 16 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 22 17 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 22 18 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 22 19 assessment assessment NN www-nature-com-63 22 20 and and CC www-nature-com-63 22 21 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 22 22 evaluation11,12 evaluation11,12 NNP www-nature-com-63 22 23 . . . www-nature-com-63 23 1 First first RB www-nature-com-63 23 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 23 3 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 23 4 establish establish VBP www-nature-com-63 23 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 23 6 system system NN www-nature-com-63 23 7 boundary boundary JJ www-nature-com-63 23 8 and and CC www-nature-com-63 23 9 feedback feedback VB www-nature-com-63 23 10 loops loop NNS www-nature-com-63 23 11 for for IN www-nature-com-63 23 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 23 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 23 14 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 23 15 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 23 16 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 23 17 system system NN www-nature-com-63 23 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 23 19 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 23 20 serve serve VBP www-nature-com-63 23 21 as as IN www-nature-com-63 23 22 the the DT www-nature-com-63 23 23 theoretical theoretical JJ www-nature-com-63 23 24 framework framework NN www-nature-com-63 23 25 to to TO www-nature-com-63 23 26 investigate investigate VB www-nature-com-63 23 27 the the DT www-nature-com-63 23 28 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 23 29 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 23 30 mechanism mechanism NN www-nature-com-63 23 31 of of IN www-nature-com-63 23 32 the the DT www-nature-com-63 23 33 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 23 34 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 23 35 . . . www-nature-com-63 24 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 24 2 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 24 3 model model NN www-nature-com-63 24 4 consists consist VBZ www-nature-com-63 24 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 24 6 three three CD www-nature-com-63 24 7 interacting interact VBG www-nature-com-63 24 8 sub- sub- JJ www-nature-com-63 24 9 systems system NNS www-nature-com-63 24 10 : : : www-nature-com-63 24 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 24 12 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 24 13 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 24 14 and and CC www-nature-com-63 24 15 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 24 16 subsystem subsystem NNP www-nature-com-63 24 17 , , , www-nature-com-63 24 18 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 24 19 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 24 20 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 24 21 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 24 22 subsystem subsystem NN www-nature-com-63 24 23 , , , www-nature-com-63 24 24 and and CC www-nature-com-63 24 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 24 26 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 24 27 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 24 28 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 24 29 subsystem subsystem NN www-nature-com-63 24 30 . . . www-nature-com-63 25 1 Specifically specifically RB www-nature-com-63 25 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 25 3 transactions transaction NNS www-nature-com-63 25 4 packaged package VBN www-nature-com-63 25 5 in in IN www-nature-com-63 25 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 25 7 block block NN www-nature-com-63 25 8 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 25 9 confirmed confirm VBN www-nature-com-63 25 10 when when WRB www-nature-com-63 25 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 25 12 block block NN www-nature-com-63 25 13 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 25 14 formally formally RB www-nature-com-63 25 15 broadcasted broadcast VBN www-nature-com-63 25 16 to to IN www-nature-com-63 25 17 the the DT www-nature-com-63 25 18 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 25 19 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 25 20 . . . www-nature-com-63 26 1 To to TO www-nature-com-63 26 2 increase increase VB www-nature-com-63 26 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 26 4 probability probability NN www-nature-com-63 26 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 26 6 mining mine VBG www-nature-com-63 26 7 a a DT www-nature-com-63 26 8 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 26 9 block block NN www-nature-com-63 26 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 26 11 getting get VBG www-nature-com-63 26 12 rewarded reward VBN www-nature-com-63 26 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 26 14 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 26 15 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 26 16 will will MD www-nature-com-63 26 17 be be VB www-nature-com-63 26 18 updated update VBN www-nature-com-63 26 19 continuously continuously RB www-nature-com-63 26 20 and and CC www-nature-com-63 26 21 invested invest VBN www-nature-com-63 26 22 by by IN www-nature-com-63 26 23 network network NN www-nature-com-63 26 24 partici- partici- NN www-nature-com-63 26 25 pants pant NNS www-nature-com-63 26 26 for for IN www-nature-com-63 26 27 a a DT www-nature-com-63 26 28 higher high JJR www-nature-com-63 26 29 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 26 30 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 26 31 , , , www-nature-com-63 26 32 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 26 33 would would MD www-nature-com-63 26 34 cause cause VB www-nature-com-63 26 35 the the DT www-nature-com-63 26 36 overall overall JJ www-nature-com-63 26 37 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 26 38 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 26 39 of of IN www-nature-com-63 26 40 the the DT www-nature-com-63 26 41 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 26 42 network network NN www-nature-com-63 26 43 to to TO www-nature-com-63 26 44 rise rise VB www-nature-com-63 26 45 . . . www-nature-com-63 27 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 27 2 network network NN www-nature-com-63 27 3 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 27 4 power power NN www-nature-com-63 27 5 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 27 6 determined determine VBN www-nature-com-63 27 7 by by IN www-nature-com-63 27 8 two two CD www-nature-com-63 27 9 factors factor NNS www-nature-com-63 27 10 : : : www-nature-com-63 27 11 first first RB www-nature-com-63 27 12 , , , www-nature-com-63 27 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 27 14 network network NN www-nature-com-63 27 15 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 27 16 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 27 17 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 27 18 hashes hash NNS www-nature-com-63 27 19 computed compute VBN www-nature-com-63 27 20 per per IN www-nature-com-63 27 21 second second NN www-nature-com-63 27 22 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 27 23 positively positively RB www-nature-com-63 27 24 accounts account VBZ www-nature-com-63 27 25 for for IN www-nature-com-63 27 26 the the DT www-nature-com-63 27 27 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 27 28 power power NN www-nature-com-63 27 29 increase increase NN www-nature-com-63 27 30 in in IN www-nature-com-63 27 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 27 32 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 27 33 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 27 34 when when WRB www-nature-com-63 27 35 high high JJ www-nature-com-63 27 36 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 27 37 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 27 38 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 27 39 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 27 40 mining mine VBG www-nature-com-63 27 41 ; ; : www-nature-com-63 27 42 second second JJ www-nature-com-63 27 43 , , , www-nature-com-63 27 44 power power NN www-nature-com-63 27 45 usage usage NN www-nature-com-63 27 46 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 27 47 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 27 48 PUE PUE NNP www-nature-com-63 27 49 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 27 50 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 27 51 introduced introduce VBN www-nature-com-63 27 52 to to TO www-nature-com-63 27 53 illustrate illustrate VB www-nature-com-63 27 54 the the DT www-nature-com-63 27 55 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 27 56 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 27 57 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 27 58 of of IN www-nature-com-63 27 59 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 27 60 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 27 61 as as IN www-nature-com-63 27 62 suggested suggest VBN www-nature-com-63 27 63 by by IN www-nature-com-63 27 64 Stoll13 Stoll13 NNP www-nature-com-63 27 65 . . . www-nature-com-63 28 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 28 2 network network NN www-nature-com-63 28 3 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 28 4 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 28 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 28 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 28 7 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 28 8 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 28 9 process process NN www-nature-com-63 28 10 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 28 11 determined determine VBN www-nature-com-63 28 12 by by IN www-nature-com-63 28 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 28 14 network network NN www-nature-com-63 28 15 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 28 16 consump- consump- NNP www-nature-com-63 28 17 tion tion NN www-nature-com-63 28 18 and and CC www-nature-com-63 28 19 average average JJ www-nature-com-63 28 20 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 28 21 price price NN www-nature-com-63 28 22 , , , www-nature-com-63 28 23 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 28 24 further further RB www-nature-com-63 28 25 influences influence VBZ www-nature-com-63 28 26 the the DT www-nature-com-63 28 27 dynamic dynamic JJ www-nature-com-63 28 28 behavior behavior NN www-nature-com-63 28 29 of of IN www-nature-com-63 28 30 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 28 31 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 28 32 . . . www-nature-com-63 29 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 29 2 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 29 3 model model NN www-nature-com-63 29 4 collects collect VBZ www-nature-com-63 29 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 29 6 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 29 7 footprint footprint NN www-nature-com-63 29 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 29 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 29 10 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 29 11 in in IN www-nature-com-63 29 12 both both CC www-nature-com-63 29 13 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 29 14 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 29 15 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 29 16 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 29 17 and and CC www-nature-com-63 29 18 hydro hydro NNP www-nature-com-63 29 19 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 29 20 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 29 21 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 29 22 regions region NNS www-nature-com-63 29 23 to to TO www-nature-com-63 29 24 formulate formulate VB www-nature-com-63 29 25 the the DT www-nature-com-63 29 26 overall overall JJ www-nature-com-63 29 27 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 29 28 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 29 29 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 29 30 of of IN www-nature-com-63 29 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 29 32 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 29 33 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 29 34 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 29 35 in in IN www-nature-com-63 29 36 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 29 37 . . . www-nature-com-63 30 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 30 2 level level NN www-nature-com-63 30 3 variable variable JJ www-nature-com-63 30 4 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 30 5 consists consist VBZ www-nature-com-63 30 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 30 7 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 30 8 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 30 9 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 30 10 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 30 11 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 30 12 and and CC www-nature-com-63 30 13 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 30 14 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 30 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 30 16 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 30 17 reflects reflect VBZ www-nature-com-63 30 18 the the DT www-nature-com-63 30 19 accumulated accumulated JJ www-nature-com-63 30 20 productivity productivity NN www-nature-com-63 30 21 of of IN www-nature-com-63 30 22 the the DT www-nature-com-63 30 23 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 30 24 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 30 25 . . . www-nature-com-63 31 1 It -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 31 2 also also RB www-nature-com-63 31 3 serves serve VBZ www-nature-com-63 31 4 as as IN www-nature-com-63 31 5 an an DT www-nature-com-63 31 6 auxiliary auxiliary JJ www-nature-com-63 31 7 factor factor NN www-nature-com-63 31 8 to to TO www-nature-com-63 31 9 generate generate VB www-nature-com-63 31 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 31 11 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 31 12 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 31 13 per per IN www-nature-com-63 31 14 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 31 15 in in IN www-nature-com-63 31 16 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 31 17 model model NN www-nature-com-63 31 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 31 19 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 31 20 provides provide VBZ www-nature-com-63 31 21 guidance guidance NN www-nature-com-63 31 22 for for IN www-nature-com-63 31 23 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 31 24 makers maker NNS www-nature-com-63 31 25 in in IN www-nature-com-63 31 26 implementing implement VBG www-nature-com-63 31 27 the the DT www-nature-com-63 31 28 punitive punitive JJ www-nature-com-63 31 29 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 31 30 taxation taxation NN www-nature-com-63 31 31 on on IN www-nature-com-63 31 32 the the DT www-nature-com-63 31 33 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 31 34 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 31 35 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 31 36 . . . www-nature-com-63 32 1 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 32 2 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 32 3 reward reward NN www-nature-com-63 32 4 halving halving NN www-nature-com-63 32 5 occurs occur VBZ www-nature-com-63 32 6 every every DT www-nature-com-63 32 7 four four CD www-nature-com-63 32 8 years year NNS www-nature-com-63 32 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 32 10 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 32 11 means mean VBZ www-nature-com-63 32 12 that that IN www-nature-com-63 32 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 32 14 reward reward NN www-nature-com-63 32 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 32 16 broadcasting broadcast VBG www-nature-com-63 32 17 a a DT www-nature-com-63 32 18 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 32 19 block block NN www-nature-com-63 32 20 in in IN www-nature-com-63 32 21 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 32 22 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 32 23 will will MD www-nature-com-63 32 24 be be VB www-nature-com-63 32 25 zero zero CD www-nature-com-63 32 26 in in IN www-nature-com-63 32 27 2140 2140 CD www-nature-com-63 32 28 . . . www-nature-com-63 33 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 33 2 a a DT www-nature-com-63 33 3 result result NN www-nature-com-63 33 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 33 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 33 6 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 33 7 market market NN www-nature-com-63 33 8 price price NN www-nature-com-63 33 9 increases increase NNS www-nature-com-63 33 10 periodically periodically RB www-nature-com-63 33 11 due due JJ www-nature-com-63 33 12 to to IN www-nature-com-63 33 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 33 14 halving halve VBG www-nature-com-63 33 15 mechanism mechanism NN www-nature-com-63 33 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 33 17 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 33 18 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 33 19 . . . www-nature-com-63 34 1 Finally finally RB www-nature-com-63 34 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 34 3 by by IN www-nature-com-63 34 4 combining combine VBG www-nature-com-63 34 5 both both DT www-nature-com-63 34 6 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 34 7 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 34 8 and and CC www-nature-com-63 34 9 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 34 10 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 34 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 34 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 34 13 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 34 14 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 34 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 34 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 34 17 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 34 18 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 34 19 process process NN www-nature-com-63 34 20 provides provide VBZ www-nature-com-63 34 21 a a DT www-nature-com-63 34 22 negative negative JJ www-nature-com-63 34 23 feedback feedback NN www-nature-com-63 34 24 for for IN www-nature-com-63 34 25 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 34 26 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 34 27 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 34 28 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 34 29 and and CC www-nature-com-63 34 30 their -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 34 31 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 34 32 strategies strategy NNS www-nature-com-63 34 33 . . . www-nature-com-63 35 1 Miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 35 2 will will MD www-nature-com-63 35 3 gradually gradually RB www-nature-com-63 35 4 stop stop VB www-nature-com-63 35 5 mining mine VBG www-nature-com-63 35 6 in in IN www-nature-com-63 35 7 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 35 8 or or CC www-nature-com-63 35 9 relocate relocate VB www-nature-com-63 35 10 to to IN www-nature-com-63 35 11 elsewhere elsewhere RB www-nature-com-63 35 12 when when WRB www-nature-com-63 35 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 35 14 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 35 15 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 35 16 turns turn VBZ www-nature-com-63 35 17 negative negative JJ www-nature-com-63 35 18 in in IN www-nature-com-63 35 19 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 35 20 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 35 21 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 35 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 36 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 36 2 comprehensive comprehensive JJ www-nature-com-63 36 3 theoretical theoretical JJ www-nature-com-63 36 4 relationship relationship NN www-nature-com-63 36 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 36 6 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 36 7 parameters parameter NNS www-nature-com-63 36 8 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 36 9 demonstrated demonstrate VBN www-nature-com-63 36 10 in in IN www-nature-com-63 36 11 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 36 12 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 36 13 . . . www-nature-com-63 37 1 1 1 LS www-nature-com-63 37 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 38 1 We -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 38 2 find find VBP www-nature-com-63 38 3 that that IN www-nature-com-63 38 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 38 5 annualized annualize VBN www-nature-com-63 38 6 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 38 7 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 38 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 38 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 38 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 38 11 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 38 12 in in IN www-nature-com-63 38 13 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 38 14 will will MD www-nature-com-63 38 15 peak peak VB www-nature-com-63 38 16 in in IN www-nature-com-63 38 17 2024 2024 CD www-nature-com-63 38 18 at at IN www-nature-com-63 38 19 296.59 296.59 CD www-nature-com-63 38 20 Twh Twh NNP www-nature-com-63 38 21 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 38 22 on on IN www-nature-com-63 38 23 the the DT www-nature-com-63 38 24 Benchmark benchmark JJ www-nature-com-63 38 25 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 38 26 of of IN www-nature-com-63 38 27 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 38 28 modeling modeling NN www-nature-com-63 38 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 39 1 This this DT www-nature-com-63 39 2 exceeds exceed VBZ www-nature-com-63 39 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 39 4 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 39 5 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 39 6 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 39 7 level level NN www-nature-com-63 39 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 39 9 Italy Italy NNP www-nature-com-63 39 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 39 11 Saudi Saudi NNP www-nature-com-63 39 12 Arabia Arabia NNP www-nature-com-63 39 13 and and CC www-nature-com-63 39 14 ranks rank VBZ www-nature-com-63 39 15 12th 12th RB www-nature-com-63 39 16 among among IN www-nature-com-63 39 17 all all DT www-nature-com-63 39 18 countries country NNS www-nature-com-63 39 19 in in IN www-nature-com-63 39 20 2016 2016 CD www-nature-com-63 39 21 . . . www-nature-com-63 40 1 Correspondingly correspondingly RB www-nature-com-63 40 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 40 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 40 4 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 40 5 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 40 6 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 40 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 40 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 40 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 40 10 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 40 11 would would MD www-nature-com-63 40 12 peak peak VB www-nature-com-63 40 13 at at IN www-nature-com-63 40 14 130.50 130.50 CD www-nature-com-63 40 15 million million CD www-nature-com-63 40 16 metric metric JJ www-nature-com-63 40 17 tons ton NNS www-nature-com-63 40 18 per per IN www-nature-com-63 40 19 year year NN www-nature-com-63 40 20 in in IN www-nature-com-63 40 21 2024 2024 CD www-nature-com-63 40 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 41 1 Internationally internationally RB www-nature-com-63 41 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 41 3 this this DT www-nature-com-63 41 4 emis- emis- JJ www-nature-com-63 41 5 sion sion NN www-nature-com-63 41 6 output output NN www-nature-com-63 41 7 surpasses surpass VBZ www-nature-com-63 41 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 41 9 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 41 10 greenhouse greenhouse NN www-nature-com-63 41 11 gas gas NN www-nature-com-63 41 12 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 41 13 output output NN www-nature-com-63 41 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 41 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 41 16 Czech Czech NNP www-nature-com-63 41 17 Republic Republic NNP www-nature-com-63 41 18 and and CC www-nature-com-63 41 19 Qatar Qatar NNP www-nature-com-63 41 20 in in IN www-nature-com-63 41 21 2016 2016 CD www-nature-com-63 41 22 reported report VBN www-nature-com-63 41 23 by by IN www-nature-com-63 41 24 cia.gov cia.gov NNS www-nature-com-63 41 25 under under IN www-nature-com-63 41 26 the the DT www-nature-com-63 41 27 Benchmark benchmark JJ www-nature-com-63 41 28 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 41 29 without without IN www-nature-com-63 41 30 any any DT www-nature-com-63 41 31 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 41 32 intervention intervention NN www-nature-com-63 41 33 . . . www-nature-com-63 42 1 Domestically domestically RB www-nature-com-63 42 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 42 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 42 4 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 42 5 output output NN www-nature-com-63 42 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 42 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 42 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 42 9 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 42 10 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 42 11 would would MD www-nature-com-63 42 12 rank rank VB www-nature-com-63 42 13 in in IN www-nature-com-63 42 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 42 15 top top JJ www-nature-com-63 42 16 10 10 CD www-nature-com-63 42 17 among among IN www-nature-com-63 42 18 182 182 CD www-nature-com-63 42 19 prefecture prefecture NN www-nature-com-63 42 20 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 42 21 level level NN www-nature-com-63 42 22 cities city NNS www-nature-com-63 42 23 and and CC www-nature-com-63 42 24 42 42 CD www-nature-com-63 42 25 major major JJ www-nature-com-63 42 26 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 42 27 sectors sector NNS www-nature-com-63 42 28 in in IN www-nature-com-63 42 29 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 42 30 , , , www-nature-com-63 42 31 accounting account VBG www-nature-com-63 42 32 for for IN www-nature-com-63 42 33 approximately approximately RB www-nature-com-63 42 34 5.41 5.41 CD www-nature-com-63 42 35 % % NN www-nature-com-63 42 36 of of IN www-nature-com-63 42 37 the the DT www-nature-com-63 42 38 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 42 39 of of IN www-nature-com-63 42 40 the the DT www-nature-com-63 42 41 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 42 42 generation generation NN www-nature-com-63 42 43 in in IN www-nature-com-63 42 44 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 42 45 according accord VBG www-nature-com-63 42 46 to to IN www-nature-com-63 42 47 the the DT www-nature-com-63 42 48 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 42 49 Emission Emission NNP www-nature-com-63 42 50 Accounts Accounts NNPS www-nature-com-63 42 51 & & CC www-nature-com-63 42 52 Datasets Datasets NNPS www-nature-com-63 42 53 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 42 54 www www NNP www-nature-com-63 42 55 . . . www-nature-com-63 43 1 ceads.net ceads.net LS www-nature-com-63 43 2 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 43 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 44 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 44 2 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 44 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 44 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 44 5 maximized maximize VBN www-nature-com-63 44 6 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 44 7 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 44 8 per per IN www-nature-com-63 44 9 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 44 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 44 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 44 12 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 44 13 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 44 14 would would MD www-nature-com-63 44 15 reach reach VB www-nature-com-63 44 16 10.77 10.77 CD www-nature-com-63 44 17 kg kg NNS www-nature-com-63 44 18 / / SYM www-nature-com-63 44 19 USD usd NN www-nature-com-63 44 20 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 44 21 on on IN www-nature-com-63 44 22 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 44 23 modeling modeling NN www-nature-com-63 44 24 . . . www-nature-com-63 45 1 Through through IN www-nature-com-63 45 2 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 45 3 analysis analysis NN www-nature-com-63 45 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 45 5 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 45 6 find find VBP www-nature-com-63 45 7 that that IN www-nature-com-63 45 8 some some DT www-nature-com-63 45 9 com- com- NN www-nature-com-63 45 10 monly monly RB www-nature-com-63 45 11 implemented implement VBD www-nature-com-63 45 12 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 45 13 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 45 14 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 45 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 45 16 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 45 17 as as IN www-nature-com-63 45 18 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 45 19 taxation taxation NN www-nature-com-63 45 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 45 21 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 45 22 relatively relatively RB www-nature-com-63 45 23 ineffective ineffective JJ www-nature-com-63 45 24 for for IN www-nature-com-63 45 25 the the DT www-nature-com-63 45 26 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 45 27 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 45 28 . . . www-nature-com-63 46 1 On on IN www-nature-com-63 46 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 46 3 contrary contrary JJ www-nature-com-63 46 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 46 5 site site NN www-nature-com-63 46 6 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 46 7 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 46 8 for for IN www-nature-com-63 46 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 46 10 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 46 11 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 46 12 induce induce VBP www-nature-com-63 46 13 changes change NNS www-nature-com-63 46 14 in in IN www-nature-com-63 46 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 46 16 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 46 17 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 46 18 structure structure NN www-nature-com-63 46 19 of of IN www-nature-com-63 46 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 46 21 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 46 22 activities activity NNS www-nature-com-63 46 23 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 46 24 able able JJ www-nature-com-63 46 25 to to TO www-nature-com-63 46 26 provide provide VB www-nature-com-63 46 27 effective effective JJ www-nature-com-63 46 28 negative negative JJ www-nature-com-63 46 29 feedbacks feedback NNS www-nature-com-63 46 30 for for IN www-nature-com-63 46 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 46 32 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 46 33 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 46 34 of of IN www-nature-com-63 46 35 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 46 36 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 46 37 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 46 38 . . . www-nature-com-63 47 1 Results result NNS www-nature-com-63 47 2 The the DT www-nature-com-63 47 3 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 47 4 and and CC www-nature-com-63 47 5 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 47 6 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 47 7 problem problem NN www-nature-com-63 47 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 47 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 47 10 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 47 11 in in IN www-nature-com-63 47 12 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 47 13 . . . www-nature-com-63 48 1 Although although IN www-nature-com-63 48 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 48 3 Proof Proof NNP www-nature-com-63 48 4 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 48 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 48 6 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 48 7 Work work NN www-nature-com-63 48 8 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 48 9 PoW PoW NNP www-nature-com-63 48 10 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 48 11 consensus consensus NN www-nature-com-63 48 12 algorithm algorithm NNP www-nature-com-63 48 13 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 48 14 enabled enable VBN www-nature-com-63 48 15 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 48 16 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 48 17 to to TO www-nature-com-63 48 18 operate operate VB www-nature-com-63 48 19 in in IN www-nature-com-63 48 20 a a DT www-nature-com-63 48 21 relatively relatively RB www-nature-com-63 48 22 stable stable JJ www-nature-com-63 48 23 manner manner NN www-nature-com-63 48 24 , , , www-nature-com-63 48 25 several several JJ www-nature-com-63 48 26 unexpected unexpected JJ www-nature-com-63 48 27 behaviors behavior NNS www-nature-com-63 48 28 of of IN www-nature-com-63 48 29 the the DT www-nature-com-63 48 30 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 48 31 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 48 32 have have VBP www-nature-com-63 48 33 been be VBN www-nature-com-63 48 34 detected detect VBN www-nature-com-63 48 35 : : : www-nature-com-63 48 36 first first RB www-nature-com-63 48 37 , , , www-nature-com-63 48 38 the the DT www-nature-com-63 48 39 attractive attractive JJ www-nature-com-63 48 40 financial financial JJ www-nature-com-63 48 41 incentive incentive NN www-nature-com-63 48 42 of of IN www-nature-com-63 48 43 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 48 44 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 48 45 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 48 46 caused cause VBN www-nature-com-63 48 47 an an DT www-nature-com-63 48 48 arms arm NNS www-nature-com-63 48 49 race race NN www-nature-com-63 48 50 in in IN www-nature-com-63 48 51 dedicated dedicated JJ www-nature-com-63 48 52 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 48 53 hardware14 hardware14 NNS www-nature-com-63 48 54 . . . www-nature-com-63 49 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 49 2 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 49 3 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 49 4 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 49 5 evolved evolve VBN www-nature-com-63 49 6 through through IN www-nature-com-63 49 7 several several JJ www-nature-com-63 49 8 generations generation NNS www-nature-com-63 49 9 . . . www-nature-com-63 50 1 Initially initially RB www-nature-com-63 50 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 50 3 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 50 4 used use VBD www-nature-com-63 50 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 50 6 basic basic JJ www-nature-com-63 50 7 Central Central NNP www-nature-com-63 50 8 Processing Processing NNP www-nature-com-63 50 9 Unit Unit NNP www-nature-com-63 50 10 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 50 11 CPU CPU NNP www-nature-com-63 50 12 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 50 13 on on IN www-nature-com-63 50 14 general general JJ www-nature-com-63 50 15 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 50 16 purpose purpose NN www-nature-com-63 50 17 computers computer NNS www-nature-com-63 50 18 . . . www-nature-com-63 51 1 Then then RB www-nature-com-63 51 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 51 3 a a DT www-nature-com-63 51 4 shift shift NN www-nature-com-63 51 5 was be VBD www-nature-com-63 51 6 made make VBN www-nature-com-63 51 7 to to IN www-nature-com-63 51 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 51 9 Graphic Graphic NNP www-nature-com-63 51 10 Processing Processing NNP www-nature-com-63 51 11 Unit Unit NNP www-nature-com-63 51 12 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 51 13 GPU GPU NNP www-nature-com-63 51 14 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 51 15 that that WDT www-nature-com-63 51 16 offered offer VBD www-nature-com-63 51 17 more more JJR www-nature-com-63 51 18 power power NN www-nature-com-63 51 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 51 20 higher high JJR www-nature-com-63 51 21 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 51 22 rates rate NNS www-nature-com-63 51 23 than than IN www-nature-com-63 51 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 51 25 CPU CPU NNP www-nature-com-63 51 26 . . . www-nature-com-63 52 1 Finally finally RB www-nature-com-63 52 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 52 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 52 4 Application Application NNP www-nature-com-63 52 5 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 52 6 Specific Specific NNP www-nature-com-63 52 7 Integrated Integrated NNP www-nature-com-63 52 8 Circuits circuit NNS www-nature-com-63 52 9 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 52 10 ASICs ASICs NNP www-nature-com-63 52 11 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 52 12 that that WDT www-nature-com-63 52 13 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 52 14 optimized optimize VBN www-nature-com-63 52 15 to to TO www-nature-com-63 52 16 perform perform VB www-nature-com-63 52 17 hashing hash VBG www-nature-com-63 52 18 calcula- calcula- JJ www-nature-com-63 52 19 tions tion NNS www-nature-com-63 52 20 were be VBD www-nature-com-63 52 21 introduced introduce VBN www-nature-com-63 52 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 53 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB www-nature-com-63 53 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 53 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 53 4 rapid rapid JJ www-nature-com-63 53 5 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 53 6 develop- develop- NNP www-nature-com-63 53 7 ment ment JJ www-nature-com-63 53 8 and and CC www-nature-com-63 53 9 fierce fierce JJ www-nature-com-63 53 10 competition competition NN www-nature-com-63 53 11 have have VBP www-nature-com-63 53 12 significantly significantly RB www-nature-com-63 53 13 increased increase VBN www-nature-com-63 53 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 53 15 capital capital NN www-nature-com-63 53 16 expenditure expenditure NN www-nature-com-63 53 17 for for IN www-nature-com-63 53 18 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 53 19 mining15 mining15 NNP www-nature-com-63 53 20 ; ; : www-nature-com-63 53 21 second second LS www-nature-com-63 53 22 , , , www-nature-com-63 53 23 the the DT www-nature-com-63 53 24 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 53 25 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 53 26 activity activity NN www-nature-com-63 53 27 and and CC www-nature-com-63 53 28 the the DT www-nature-com-63 53 29 constant constant RB www-nature-com-63 53 30 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 53 31 running run VBG www-nature-com-63 53 32 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 53 33 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 53 34 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 53 35 led lead VBN www-nature-com-63 53 36 to to IN www-nature-com-63 53 37 large large JJ www-nature-com-63 53 38 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 53 39 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 53 40 volume volume NN www-nature-com-63 53 41 . . . www-nature-com-63 54 1 Previous previous JJ www-nature-com-63 54 2 literature literature NN www-nature-com-63 54 3 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 54 4 estimated estimate VBN www-nature-com-63 54 5 that that IN www-nature-com-63 54 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 54 7 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 54 8 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 54 9 could could MD www-nature-com-63 54 10 consume consume VB www-nature-com-63 54 11 as as RB www-nature-com-63 54 12 much much JJ www-nature-com-63 54 13 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 54 14 per per IN www-nature-com-63 54 15 year year NN www-nature-com-63 54 16 as as IN www-nature-com-63 54 17 a a DT www-nature-com-63 54 18 small small JJ www-nature-com-63 54 19 to to TO www-nature-com-63 54 20 medium medium JJ www-nature-com-63 54 21 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 54 22 sized sized JJ www-nature-com-63 54 23 country country NN www-nature-com-63 54 24 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 54 25 as as IN www-nature-com-63 54 26 Denmark Denmark NNP www-nature-com-63 54 27 , , , www-nature-com-63 54 28 Ireland Ireland NNP www-nature-com-63 54 29 , , , www-nature-com-63 54 30 or or CC www-nature-com-63 54 31 Bangladesh16 Bangladesh16 NNP www-nature-com-63 54 32 ; ; : www-nature-com-63 54 33 finally finally RB www-nature-com-63 54 34 , , , www-nature-com-63 54 35 the the DT www-nature-com-63 54 36 large large JJ www-nature-com-63 54 37 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 54 38 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 54 39 of of IN www-nature-com-63 54 40 the the DT www-nature-com-63 54 41 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 54 42 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 54 43 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 54 44 created create VBN www-nature-com-63 54 45 considerable considerable JJ www-nature-com-63 54 46 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 54 47 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 54 48 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 54 49 see see VB www-nature-com-63 54 50 Sup- Sup- NNP www-nature-com-63 54 51 plementary plementary NN www-nature-com-63 54 52 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 54 53 . . . www-nature-com-63 55 1 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 55 2 for for IN www-nature-com-63 55 3 details detail NNS www-nature-com-63 55 4 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 55 5 . . . www-nature-com-63 56 1 It -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 56 2 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 56 3 estimated estimate VBN www-nature-com-63 56 4 that that IN www-nature-com-63 56 5 between between IN www-nature-com-63 56 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 56 7 period period NN www-nature-com-63 56 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 56 9 January January NNP www-nature-com-63 56 10 1st 1st NN www-nature-com-63 56 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 56 12 2016 2016 CD www-nature-com-63 56 13 and and CC www-nature-com-63 56 14 June June NNP www-nature-com-63 56 15 30th 30th NN www-nature-com-63 56 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 56 17 2018 2018 CD www-nature-com-63 56 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 56 19 up up IN www-nature-com-63 56 20 to to TO www-nature-com-63 56 21 13 13 CD www-nature-com-63 56 22 million million CD www-nature-com-63 56 23 metric metric JJ www-nature-com-63 56 24 tons ton NNS www-nature-com-63 56 25 of of IN www-nature-com-63 56 26 CO2 CO2 NNP www-nature-com-63 56 27 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 56 28 can can MD www-nature-com-63 56 29 be be VB www-nature-com-63 56 30 attributed attribute VBN www-nature-com-63 56 31 to to IN www-nature-com-63 56 32 the the DT www-nature-com-63 56 33 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 56 34 blockchain17 blockchain17 NNP www-nature-com-63 56 35 . . . www-nature-com-63 57 1 Although although IN www-nature-com-63 57 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 57 3 estimate estimate NN www-nature-com-63 57 4 ranges range VBZ www-nature-com-63 57 5 vary vary VBP www-nature-com-63 57 6 considerably considerably RB www-nature-com-63 57 7 , , , www-nature-com-63 57 8 they -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 57 9 have have VBP www-nature-com-63 57 10 indicated indicate VBN www-nature-com-63 57 11 that that IN www-nature-com-63 57 12 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 57 13 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 57 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 57 15 network network NN www-nature-com-63 57 16 and and CC www-nature-com-63 57 17 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 57 18 corresponding correspond VBG www-nature-com-63 57 19 environmental environmental JJ www-nature-com-63 57 20 impacts impact NNS www-nature-com-63 57 21 have have VBP www-nature-com-63 57 22 become become VBN www-nature-com-63 57 23 a a DT www-nature-com-63 57 24 non non JJ www-nature-com-63 57 25 - - JJ www-nature-com-63 57 26 negligible negligible JJ www-nature-com-63 57 27 issue issue NN www-nature-com-63 57 28 . . . www-nature-com-63 58 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 58 2 growing grow VBG www-nature-com-63 58 3 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 58 4 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 58 5 and and CC www-nature-com-63 58 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 58 7 environmental environmental JJ www-nature-com-63 58 8 impacts impact NNS www-nature-com-63 58 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 58 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 58 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 58 12 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 58 13 have have VBP www-nature-com-63 58 14 posed pose VBN www-nature-com-63 58 15 problems problem NNS www-nature-com-63 58 16 for for IN www-nature-com-63 58 17 many many JJ www-nature-com-63 58 18 ARTICLE ARTICLE NNP www-nature-com-63 58 19 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 58 20 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 58 21 | | CD www-nature-com-63 58 22 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 58 23 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 58 24 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 58 25 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 58 26 | | CD www-nature-com-63 58 27 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 58 28 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 58 29 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 58 30 12:1938 12:1938 CD www-nature-com-63 58 31 | | CD www-nature-com-63 58 32 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 58 33 | | NNS www-nature-com-63 58 34 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 58 35 http://www.ceads.net http://www.ceads.net ADD www-nature-com-63 58 36 http://www.ceads.net http://www.ceads.net NNP www-nature-com-63 58 37 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 58 38 countries country NNS www-nature-com-63 58 39 , , , www-nature-com-63 58 40 especially especially RB www-nature-com-63 58 41 for for IN www-nature-com-63 58 42 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 58 43 . . . www-nature-com-63 59 1 Due due IN www-nature-com-63 59 2 to to IN www-nature-com-63 59 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 59 4 proximity proximity NN www-nature-com-63 59 5 to to IN www-nature-com-63 59 6 manufacturers manufacturer NNS www-nature-com-63 59 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 59 8 specialized specialized JJ www-nature-com-63 59 9 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 59 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 59 11 access access NN www-nature-com-63 59 12 to to IN www-nature-com-63 59 13 cheap cheap JJ www-nature-com-63 59 14 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 59 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 59 16 majority majority NN www-nature-com-63 59 17 of of IN www-nature-com-63 59 18 the the DT www-nature-com-63 59 19 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 59 20 process process NN www-nature-com-63 59 21 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 59 22 been be VBN www-nature-com-63 59 23 conducted conduct VBN www-nature-com-63 59 24 in in IN www-nature-com-63 59 25 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 59 26 as as IN www-nature-com-63 59 27 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 59 28 in in IN www-nature-com-63 59 29 the the DT www-nature-com-63 59 30 country country NN www-nature-com-63 59 31 account account VBP www-nature-com-63 59 32 for for IN www-nature-com-63 59 33 more more JJR www-nature-com-63 59 34 than than IN www-nature-com-63 59 35 75 75 CD www-nature-com-63 59 36 % % NN www-nature-com-63 59 37 of of IN www-nature-com-63 59 38 the the DT www-nature-com-63 59 39 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 59 40 network network NN www-nature-com-63 59 41 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 59 42 hashing hash VBG www-nature-com-63 59 43 power power NN www-nature-com-63 59 44 , , , www-nature-com-63 59 45 as as IN www-nature-com-63 59 46 shown show VBN www-nature-com-63 59 47 in in IN www-nature-com-63 59 48 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 59 49 . . . www-nature-com-63 60 1 1 1 LS www-nature-com-63 60 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 61 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 61 2 one one CD www-nature-com-63 61 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 61 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 61 5 largest large JJS www-nature-com-63 61 6 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 61 7 consuming consume VBG www-nature-com-63 61 8 countries country NNS www-nature-com-63 61 9 on on IN www-nature-com-63 61 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 61 11 planet planet NN www-nature-com-63 61 12 , , , www-nature-com-63 61 13 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 61 14 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 61 15 a a DT www-nature-com-63 61 16 key key JJ www-nature-com-63 61 17 signatory signatory NN www-nature-com-63 61 18 of of IN www-nature-com-63 61 19 the the DT www-nature-com-63 61 20 Paris Paris NNP www-nature-com-63 61 21 Agreement18–20 Agreement18–20 NNP www-nature-com-63 61 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 62 1 However however RB www-nature-com-63 62 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 62 3 without without IN www-nature-com-63 62 4 appropriate appropriate JJ www-nature-com-63 62 5 interventions intervention NNS www-nature-com-63 62 6 and and CC www-nature-com-63 62 7 feasible feasible JJ www-nature-com-63 62 8 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 62 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 62 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 62 11 intensive intensive JJ www-nature-com-63 62 12 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 62 13 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 62 14 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 62 15 in in IN www-nature-com-63 62 16 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 62 17 can can MD www-nature-com-63 62 18 quickly quickly RB www-nature-com-63 62 19 grow grow VB www-nature-com-63 62 20 as as IN www-nature-com-63 62 21 a a DT www-nature-com-63 62 22 threat threat NN www-nature-com-63 62 23 that that WDT www-nature-com-63 62 24 could could MD www-nature-com-63 62 25 potentially potentially RB www-nature-com-63 62 26 undermine undermine VB www-nature-com-63 62 27 the the DT www-nature-com-63 62 28 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 62 29 reduction reduction NN www-nature-com-63 62 30 effort effort NN www-nature-com-63 62 31 taken take VBN www-nature-com-63 62 32 place place NN www-nature-com-63 62 33 in in IN www-nature-com-63 62 34 the the DT www-nature-com-63 62 35 country10 country10 NNP www-nature-com-63 62 36 . . . www-nature-com-63 63 1 Suggested suggest VBN www-nature-com-63 63 2 by by IN www-nature-com-63 63 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 63 4 previous previous JJ www-nature-com-63 63 5 work21 work21 NNP www-nature-com-63 63 6 and and CC www-nature-com-63 63 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 63 8 subsystems subsystem NNS www-nature-com-63 63 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 63 10 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 63 11 proposed propose VBN www-nature-com-63 63 12 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 63 13 model model NN www-nature-com-63 63 14 , , , www-nature-com-63 63 15 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 63 16 consider consider VBP www-nature-com-63 63 17 three three CD www-nature-com-63 63 18 main main JJ www-nature-com-63 63 19 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 63 20 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 63 21 conducted conduct VBN www-nature-com-63 63 22 at at IN www-nature-com-63 63 23 different different JJ www-nature-com-63 63 24 stages stage NNS www-nature-com-63 63 25 of of IN www-nature-com-63 63 26 the the DT www-nature-com-63 63 27 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 63 28 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 63 29 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 63 30 , , , www-nature-com-63 63 31 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 63 32 then then RB www-nature-com-63 63 33 formulates formulate VBZ www-nature-com-63 63 34 the the DT www-nature-com-63 63 35 four four CD www-nature-com-63 63 36 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 63 37 assessments assessment NNS www-nature-com-63 63 38 for for IN www-nature-com-63 63 39 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 63 40 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 63 41 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 63 42 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 63 43 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 63 44 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 63 45 in in IN www-nature-com-63 63 46 Table table NN www-nature-com-63 63 47 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 63 48 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 63 49 . . . www-nature-com-63 64 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 64 2 detail detail NN www-nature-com-63 64 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 64 4 Benchmark Benchmark NNP www-nature-com-63 64 5 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 64 6 BM BM NNP www-nature-com-63 64 7 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 64 8 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 64 9 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 64 10 a a DT www-nature-com-63 64 11 baseline baseline NN www-nature-com-63 64 12 and and CC www-nature-com-63 64 13 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 64 14 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 64 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 64 16 each each DT www-nature-com-63 64 17 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 64 18 factor factor NN www-nature-com-63 64 19 , , , www-nature-com-63 64 20 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 64 21 suggests suggest VBZ www-nature-com-63 64 22 that that IN www-nature-com-63 64 23 the the DT www-nature-com-63 64 24 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 64 25 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 64 26 continues continue VBZ www-nature-com-63 64 27 to to TO www-nature-com-63 64 28 operate operate VB www-nature-com-63 64 29 under under IN www-nature-com-63 64 30 minimal minimal JJ www-nature-com-63 64 31 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 64 32 intervention intervention NN www-nature-com-63 64 33 . . . www-nature-com-63 65 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 65 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 65 3 Benchmark benchmark JJ www-nature-com-63 65 4 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 65 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 65 6 market market NN www-nature-com-63 65 7 access access NN www-nature-com-63 65 8 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 65 9 assumed assume VBN www-nature-com-63 65 10 to to TO www-nature-com-63 65 11 be be VB www-nature-com-63 65 12 100 100 CD www-nature-com-63 65 13 % % NN www-nature-com-63 65 14 , , , www-nature-com-63 65 15 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 65 16 indicates indicate VBZ www-nature-com-63 65 17 that that IN www-nature-com-63 65 18 profitable profitable JJ www-nature-com-63 65 19 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 65 20 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 65 21 of of IN www-nature-com-63 65 22 all all DT www-nature-com-63 65 23 efficiencies efficiency NNS www-nature-com-63 65 24 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 65 25 allowed allow VBN www-nature-com-63 65 26 to to TO www-nature-com-63 65 27 operate operate VB www-nature-com-63 65 28 in in IN www-nature-com-63 65 29 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 65 30 . . . www-nature-com-63 66 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 66 2 suggested suggest VBN www-nature-com-63 66 3 by by IN www-nature-com-63 66 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 66 5 actual actual JJ www-nature-com-63 66 6 regional regional JJ www-nature-com-63 66 7 statistics statistic NNS www-nature-com-63 66 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 66 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 66 10 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 66 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 66 12 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 66 13 assume assume VBP www-nature-com-63 66 14 40 40 CD www-nature-com-63 66 15 % % NN www-nature-com-63 66 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 66 17 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 66 18 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 66 19 located locate VBN www-nature-com-63 66 20 in in IN www-nature-com-63 66 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 66 22 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 66 23 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 66 24 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 66 25 area area NN www-nature-com-63 66 26 in in IN www-nature-com-63 66 27 the the DT www-nature-com-63 66 28 Benchmark benchmark JJ www-nature-com-63 66 29 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 66 30 . . . www-nature-com-63 67 1 Moreover moreover RB www-nature-com-63 67 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 67 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 67 4 punitive punitive JJ www-nature-com-63 67 5 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 67 6 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 67 7 will will MD www-nature-com-63 67 8 be be VB www-nature-com-63 67 9 imposed impose VBN www-nature-com-63 67 10 if if IN www-nature-com-63 67 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 67 12 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 67 13 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 67 14 per per IN www-nature-com-63 67 15 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 67 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 67 17 the the DT www-nature-com-63 67 18 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 67 19 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 67 20 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 67 21 greater great JJR www-nature-com-63 67 22 than than IN www-nature-com-63 67 23 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 67 24 . . . www-nature-com-63 68 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 68 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 68 3 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 68 4 three three CD www-nature-com-63 68 5 scenarios scenario NNS www-nature-com-63 68 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 68 7 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 68 8 on on IN www-nature-com-63 68 9 different different JJ www-nature-com-63 68 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 68 11 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 68 12 procedures procedure NNS www-nature-com-63 68 13 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 68 14 adjusted adjust VBN www-nature-com-63 68 15 due due IN www-nature-com-63 68 16 to to IN www-nature-com-63 68 17 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 68 18 saving saving NN www-nature-com-63 68 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 68 20 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 68 21 reduction reduction NN www-nature-com-63 68 22 concerns concern NNS www-nature-com-63 68 23 . . . www-nature-com-63 69 1 Specifically specifically RB www-nature-com-63 69 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 69 3 in in IN www-nature-com-63 69 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 69 5 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 69 6 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 69 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 69 8 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 69 9 subsystem subsystem NN www-nature-com-63 69 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 69 11 market market NN www-nature-com-63 69 12 access access NN www-nature-com-63 69 13 standard standard NN www-nature-com-63 69 14 for for IN www-nature-com-63 69 15 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 69 16 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 69 17 doubled double VBN www-nature-com-63 69 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 69 19 i.e. i.e. FW www-nature-com-63 69 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 69 21 profitable profitable JJ www-nature-com-63 69 22 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 69 23 with with IN www-nature-com-63 69 24 low low JJ www-nature-com-63 69 25 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 69 26 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 69 27 forbidden forbid VBN www-nature-com-63 69 28 to to TO www-nature-com-63 69 29 enter enter VB www-nature-com-63 69 30 the the DT www-nature-com-63 69 31 Chinese chinese JJ www-nature-com-63 69 32 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 69 33 market market NN www-nature-com-63 69 34 in in IN www-nature-com-63 69 35 the the DT www-nature-com-63 69 36 market market NN www-nature-com-63 69 37 access access NN www-nature-com-63 69 38 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 69 39 MA MA NNP www-nature-com-63 69 40 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 69 41 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 69 42 , , , www-nature-com-63 69 43 and and CC www-nature-com-63 69 44 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 69 45 makers maker NNS www-nature-com-63 69 46 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 69 47 forced force VBN www-nature-com-63 69 48 to to TO www-nature-com-63 69 49 maintain maintain VB www-nature-com-63 69 50 the the DT www-nature-com-63 69 51 network network NN www-nature-com-63 69 52 stability stability NN www-nature-com-63 69 53 of of IN www-nature-com-63 69 54 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 69 55 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 69 56 in in IN www-nature-com-63 69 57 an an DT www-nature-com-63 69 58 efficient efficient JJ www-nature-com-63 69 59 manner manner NN www-nature-com-63 69 60 . . . www-nature-com-63 70 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 70 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 70 3 site site NN www-nature-com-63 70 4 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 70 5 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 70 6 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 70 7 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 70 8 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 70 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 70 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 70 11 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 70 12 in in IN www-nature-com-63 70 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 70 14 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 70 15 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 70 16 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 70 17 area area NN www-nature-com-63 70 18 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 70 19 persuaded persuade VBN www-nature-com-63 70 20 and and CC www-nature-com-63 70 21 suggested suggest VBN www-nature-com-63 70 22 to to TO www-nature-com-63 70 23 relocate relocate VB www-nature-com-63 70 24 to to IN www-nature-com-63 70 25 the the DT www-nature-com-63 70 26 hydro hydro NNP www-nature-com-63 70 27 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 70 28 rich rich JJ www-nature-com-63 70 29 area area NN www-nature-com-63 70 30 to to TO www-nature-com-63 70 31 take take VB www-nature-com-63 70 32 advantage advantage NN www-nature-com-63 70 33 of of IN www-nature-com-63 70 34 the the DT www-nature-com-63 70 35 relatively relatively RB www-nature-com-63 70 36 lower low JJR www-nature-com-63 70 37 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 70 38 of of IN www-nature-com-63 70 39 surplus surplus JJ www-nature-com-63 70 40 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 70 41 availability availability NN www-nature-com-63 70 42 in in IN www-nature-com-63 70 43 the the DT www-nature-com-63 70 44 area area NN www-nature-com-63 70 45 due due JJ www-nature-com-63 70 46 to to IN www-nature-com-63 70 47 factors factor NNS www-nature-com-63 70 48 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 70 49 as as IN www-nature-com-63 70 50 rain rain NN www-nature-com-63 70 51 season season NN www-nature-com-63 70 52 , , , www-nature-com-63 70 53 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 70 54 results result VBZ www-nature-com-63 70 55 in in IN www-nature-com-63 70 56 only only RB www-nature-com-63 70 57 20 20 CD www-nature-com-63 70 58 % % NN www-nature-com-63 70 59 of of IN www-nature-com-63 70 60 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 70 61 . . . www-nature-com-63 71 1 1 1 LS www-nature-com-63 71 2 Mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 71 3 pool pool NN www-nature-com-63 71 4 distributions distribution NNS www-nature-com-63 71 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 71 6 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 71 7 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 71 8 . . . www-nature-com-63 72 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 72 2 of of IN www-nature-com-63 72 3 April April NNP www-nature-com-63 72 4 2020 2020 CD www-nature-com-63 72 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 72 6 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 72 7 accounts account VBZ www-nature-com-63 72 8 for for IN www-nature-com-63 72 9 more more JJR www-nature-com-63 72 10 than than IN www-nature-com-63 72 11 75 75 CD www-nature-com-63 72 12 % % NN www-nature-com-63 72 13 of of IN www-nature-com-63 72 14 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 72 15 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 72 16 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 72 17 around around IN www-nature-com-63 72 18 the the DT www-nature-com-63 72 19 world world NN www-nature-com-63 72 20 . . . www-nature-com-63 73 1 Some some DT www-nature-com-63 73 2 rural rural JJ www-nature-com-63 73 3 areas area NNS www-nature-com-63 73 4 in in IN www-nature-com-63 73 5 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 73 6 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 73 7 considered consider VBN www-nature-com-63 73 8 as as IN www-nature-com-63 73 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 73 10 ideal ideal JJ www-nature-com-63 73 11 destination destination NN www-nature-com-63 73 12 for for IN www-nature-com-63 73 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 73 14 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 73 15 mainly mainly RB www-nature-com-63 73 16 due due IN www-nature-com-63 73 17 to to IN www-nature-com-63 73 18 the the DT www-nature-com-63 73 19 cheaper cheap JJR www-nature-com-63 73 20 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 73 21 price price NN www-nature-com-63 73 22 and and CC www-nature-com-63 73 23 large large JJ www-nature-com-63 73 24 undeveloped undeveloped JJ www-nature-com-63 73 25 land land NN www-nature-com-63 73 26 for for IN www-nature-com-63 73 27 pool pool NN www-nature-com-63 73 28 construction construction NN www-nature-com-63 73 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 74 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 74 2 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 74 3 pool pool NN www-nature-com-63 74 4 statistics statistic NNS www-nature-com-63 74 5 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 74 6 obtained obtain VBN www-nature-com-63 74 7 from from IN www-nature-com-63 74 8 https://btc.com/stats https://btc.com/stats NNP www-nature-com-63 74 9 . . . www-nature-com-63 75 1 Table table NN www-nature-com-63 75 2 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 75 3 Scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 75 4 parameter parameter NN www-nature-com-63 75 5 settings setting NNS www-nature-com-63 75 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 76 1 Scenarios scenario NNS www-nature-com-63 76 2 Measures measure VBZ www-nature-com-63 76 3 Market market NN www-nature-com-63 76 4 access access NN www-nature-com-63 76 5 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 76 6 % % NN www-nature-com-63 76 7 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 76 8 Miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 76 9 site site NN www-nature-com-63 76 10 selection selection NN www-nature-com-63 76 11 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 76 12 % % NN www-nature-com-63 76 13 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 76 14 Carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 76 15 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 76 16 Benchmark benchmark NN www-nature-com-63 76 17 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 76 18 BM BM NNP www-nature-com-63 76 19 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 76 20 Baseline Baseline NNP www-nature-com-63 76 21 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 76 22 intervention intervention NN www-nature-com-63 76 23 100 100 CD www-nature-com-63 76 24 40 40 CD www-nature-com-63 76 25 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 76 26 Market market NN www-nature-com-63 76 27 access access NN www-nature-com-63 76 28 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 76 29 MA MA NNP www-nature-com-63 76 30 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 76 31 Raise raise VB www-nature-com-63 76 32 the the DT www-nature-com-63 76 33 market market NN www-nature-com-63 76 34 access access NN www-nature-com-63 76 35 standards standard NNS www-nature-com-63 76 36 for for IN www-nature-com-63 76 37 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 76 38 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 76 39 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 76 40 50 50 CD www-nature-com-63 76 41 40 40 CD www-nature-com-63 76 42 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 76 43 Site site NN www-nature-com-63 76 44 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 76 45 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 76 46 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 76 47 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 76 48 Strict strict JJ www-nature-com-63 76 49 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 76 50 on on IN www-nature-com-63 76 51 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 76 52 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 76 53 in in IN www-nature-com-63 76 54 the the DT www-nature-com-63 76 55 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 76 56 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 76 57 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 76 58 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 76 59 region region NN www-nature-com-63 76 60 100 100 CD www-nature-com-63 76 61 20 20 CD www-nature-com-63 76 62 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 76 63 Carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 76 64 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 76 65 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 76 66 CT CT NNP www-nature-com-63 76 67 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 76 68 Extra extra JJ www-nature-com-63 76 69 punitive punitive JJ www-nature-com-63 76 70 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 76 71 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 76 72 on on IN www-nature-com-63 76 73 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 76 74 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 76 75 100 100 CD www-nature-com-63 76 76 40 40 CD www-nature-com-63 76 77 4 4 CD www-nature-com-63 76 78 Note note NN www-nature-com-63 76 79 : : : www-nature-com-63 76 80 Exogenous exogenous JJ www-nature-com-63 76 81 auxiliary auxiliary JJ www-nature-com-63 76 82 parameters parameter NNS www-nature-com-63 76 83 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 76 84 introduced introduce VBN www-nature-com-63 76 85 to to TO www-nature-com-63 76 86 assess assess VB www-nature-com-63 76 87 the the DT www-nature-com-63 76 88 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 76 89 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 76 90 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 76 91 under under IN www-nature-com-63 76 92 different different JJ www-nature-com-63 76 93 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 76 94 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 76 95 measures measure NNS www-nature-com-63 76 96 . . . www-nature-com-63 77 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 77 2 terms term NNS www-nature-com-63 77 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 77 4 variable variable JJ www-nature-com-63 77 5 settings setting NNS www-nature-com-63 77 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 77 7 three three CD www-nature-com-63 77 8 main main JJ www-nature-com-63 77 9 parameters parameter NNS www-nature-com-63 77 10 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 77 11 chosen choose VBN www-nature-com-63 77 12 as as IN www-nature-com-63 77 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 77 14 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 77 15 factors factor NNS www-nature-com-63 77 16 in in IN www-nature-com-63 77 17 the the DT www-nature-com-63 77 18 proposed propose VBN www-nature-com-63 77 19 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 77 20 model model NN www-nature-com-63 77 21 , , , www-nature-com-63 77 22 including include VBG www-nature-com-63 77 23 market market NN www-nature-com-63 77 24 access access NN www-nature-com-63 77 25 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 77 26 MA MA NNP www-nature-com-63 77 27 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 77 28 , , , www-nature-com-63 77 29 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 77 30 site site NN www-nature-com-63 77 31 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 77 32 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 77 33 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 77 34 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 77 35 , , , www-nature-com-63 77 36 and and CC www-nature-com-63 77 37 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 77 38 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 77 39 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 77 40 CT CT NNP www-nature-com-63 77 41 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 77 42 . . . www-nature-com-63 78 1 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 78 2 COMMUNICATIONS COMMUNICATIONS NNPS www-nature-com-63 78 3 | | CD www-nature-com-63 78 4 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 78 5 ARTICLE article NN www-nature-com-63 78 6 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 78 7 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 78 8 | | CD www-nature-com-63 78 9 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 78 10 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 78 11 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 78 12 12:1938 12:1938 CD www-nature-com-63 78 13 | | CD www-nature-com-63 78 14 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 78 15 | | CD www-nature-com-63 78 16 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 78 17 3 3 CD www-nature-com-63 78 18 https://btc.com/stats https://btc.com/stat NNS www-nature-com-63 78 19 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 78 20 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 78 21 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 78 22 remaining remain VBG www-nature-com-63 78 23 in in IN www-nature-com-63 78 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 78 25 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 78 26 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 78 27 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 78 28 area area NN www-nature-com-63 78 29 in in IN www-nature-com-63 78 30 the the DT www-nature-com-63 78 31 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 78 32 . . . www-nature-com-63 79 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 79 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 79 3 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 79 4 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 79 5 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 79 6 CT CT NNP www-nature-com-63 79 7 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 79 8 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 79 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 79 10 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 79 11 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 79 12 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 79 13 increased increase VBN www-nature-com-63 79 14 to to IN www-nature-com-63 79 15 two two CD www-nature-com-63 79 16 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 79 17 times time NNS www-nature-com-63 79 18 the the DT www-nature-com-63 79 19 initial initial JJ www-nature-com-63 79 20 value value NN www-nature-com-63 79 21 to to TO www-nature-com-63 79 22 enforce enforce VB www-nature-com-63 79 23 more more RBR www-nature-com-63 79 24 strict strict JJ www-nature-com-63 79 25 punishment punishment NN www-nature-com-63 79 26 for for IN www-nature-com-63 79 27 high high JJ www-nature-com-63 79 28 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 79 29 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 79 30 behaviors behavior NNS www-nature-com-63 79 31 of of IN www-nature-com-63 79 32 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 79 33 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 79 34 . . . www-nature-com-63 80 1 Utilizing utilize VBG www-nature-com-63 80 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 80 3 above above JJ www-nature-com-63 80 4 scenarios scenario NNS www-nature-com-63 80 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 80 6 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 80 7 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 80 8 flows flow NNS www-nature-com-63 80 9 and and CC www-nature-com-63 80 10 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 80 11 consumptions consumption NNS www-nature-com-63 80 12 of of IN www-nature-com-63 80 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 80 14 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 80 15 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 80 16 assessed assess VBN www-nature-com-63 80 17 , , , www-nature-com-63 80 18 the the DT www-nature-com-63 80 19 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 80 20 and and CC www-nature-com-63 80 21 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 80 22 reduction reduction NN www-nature-com-63 80 23 effectiveness effectiveness NN www-nature-com-63 80 24 of of IN www-nature-com-63 80 25 different different JJ www-nature-com-63 80 26 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 80 27 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 80 28 evaluated evaluate VBN www-nature-com-63 80 29 in in IN www-nature-com-63 80 30 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 80 31 simulations simulation NNS www-nature-com-63 80 32 from from IN www-nature-com-63 80 33 the the DT www-nature-com-63 80 34 period period NN www-nature-com-63 80 35 of of IN www-nature-com-63 80 36 2014–2030 2014–2030 CD www-nature-com-63 80 37 . . . www-nature-com-63 81 1 Carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 81 2 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 81 3 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 81 4 of of IN www-nature-com-63 81 5 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 81 6 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 81 7 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 81 8 . . . www-nature-com-63 82 1 Without without IN www-nature-com-63 82 2 any any DT www-nature-com-63 82 3 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 82 4 interventions intervention NNS www-nature-com-63 82 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 82 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 82 7 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 82 8 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 82 9 pattern pattern NN www-nature-com-63 82 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 82 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 82 12 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 82 13 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 82 14 will will MD www-nature-com-63 82 15 become become VB www-nature-com-63 82 16 a a DT www-nature-com-63 82 17 non non JJ www-nature-com-63 82 18 - - JJ www-nature-com-63 82 19 negligible negligible JJ www-nature-com-63 82 20 barrier barrier NN www-nature-com-63 82 21 against against IN www-nature-com-63 82 22 the the DT www-nature-com-63 82 23 sustainability sustainability NN www-nature-com-63 82 24 efforts effort NNS www-nature-com-63 82 25 of of IN www-nature-com-63 82 26 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 82 27 . . . www-nature-com-63 83 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 83 2 peak peak NN www-nature-com-63 83 3 annual annual JJ www-nature-com-63 83 4 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 83 5 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 83 6 and and CC www-nature-com-63 83 7 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 83 8 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 83 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 83 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 83 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 83 12 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 83 13 in in IN www-nature-com-63 83 14 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 83 15 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 83 16 expected expect VBN www-nature-com-63 83 17 to to TO www-nature-com-63 83 18 exceed exceed VB www-nature-com-63 83 19 those those DT www-nature-com-63 83 20 of of IN www-nature-com-63 83 21 some some DT www-nature-com-63 83 22 developed develop VBN www-nature-com-63 83 23 countries country NNS www-nature-com-63 83 24 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 83 25 as as IN www-nature-com-63 83 26 Italy Italy NNP www-nature-com-63 83 27 , , , www-nature-com-63 83 28 the the DT www-nature-com-63 83 29 Netherlands Netherlands NNP www-nature-com-63 83 30 , , , www-nature-com-63 83 31 Spain Spain NNP www-nature-com-63 83 32 , , , www-nature-com-63 83 33 and and CC www-nature-com-63 83 34 Czech Czech NNP www-nature-com-63 83 35 Republic Republic NNP www-nature-com-63 83 36 . . . www-nature-com-63 84 1 Fig- Fig- NNP www-nature-com-63 84 2 ure ure NNP www-nature-com-63 84 3 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 84 4 reports report VBZ www-nature-com-63 84 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 84 6 estimated estimate VBN www-nature-com-63 84 7 annualized annualized JJ www-nature-com-63 84 8 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 84 9 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 84 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 84 11 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 84 12 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 84 13 flows flow NNS www-nature-com-63 84 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 84 15 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 84 16 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 84 17 in in IN www-nature-com-63 84 18 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 84 19 . . . www-nature-com-63 85 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 85 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 85 3 baseline baseline NN www-nature-com-63 85 4 assessment assessment NN www-nature-com-63 85 5 under under IN www-nature-com-63 85 6 minimal minimal JJ www-nature-com-63 85 7 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 85 8 intervention intervention NN www-nature-com-63 85 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 85 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 85 11 Benchmark benchmark JJ www-nature-com-63 85 12 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 85 13 simulates simulate VBZ www-nature-com-63 85 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 85 15 natural natural JJ www-nature-com-63 85 16 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 85 17 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 85 18 of of IN www-nature-com-63 85 19 the the DT www-nature-com-63 85 20 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 85 21 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 85 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 86 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 86 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 86 3 BM BM NNP www-nature-com-63 86 4 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 86 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 86 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 86 7 annual annual JJ www-nature-com-63 86 8 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 86 9 con- con- NN www-nature-com-63 86 10 sumption sumption NN www-nature-com-63 86 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 86 12 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 86 13 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 86 14 in in IN www-nature-com-63 86 15 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 86 16 will will MD www-nature-com-63 86 17 gradually gradually RB www-nature-com-63 86 18 grow grow VB www-nature-com-63 86 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 86 20 eventually eventually RB www-nature-com-63 86 21 peak peak VB www-nature-com-63 86 22 in in IN www-nature-com-63 86 23 2024 2024 CD www-nature-com-63 86 24 , , , www-nature-com-63 86 25 at at IN www-nature-com-63 86 26 296.59 296.59 CD www-nature-com-63 86 27 Twh Twh NNP www-nature-com-63 86 28 per per IN www-nature-com-63 86 29 year year NN www-nature-com-63 86 30 . . . www-nature-com-63 87 1 This this DT www-nature-com-63 87 2 suggests suggest VBZ www-nature-com-63 87 3 that that IN www-nature-com-63 87 4 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 87 5 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 87 6 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 87 7 would would MD www-nature-com-63 87 8 follow follow VB www-nature-com-63 87 9 an an DT www-nature-com-63 87 10 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 87 11 intensive intensive JJ www-nature-com-63 87 12 pattern pattern NN www-nature-com-63 87 13 . . . www-nature-com-63 88 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 88 2 fact fact NN www-nature-com-63 88 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 88 4 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 88 5 consumed consume VBN www-nature-com-63 88 6 by by IN www-nature-com-63 88 7 Chinese Chinese NNP www-nature-com-63 88 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 88 9 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 88 10 in in IN www-nature-com-63 88 11 2024 2024 CD www-nature-com-63 88 12 will will MD www-nature-com-63 88 13 exceed exceed VB www-nature-com-63 88 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 88 15 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 88 16 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 88 17 level level NN www-nature-com-63 88 18 of of IN www-nature-com-63 88 19 Italy Italy NNP www-nature-com-63 88 20 and and CC www-nature-com-63 88 21 Saudi Saudi NNP www-nature-com-63 88 22 Arabia Arabia NNP www-nature-com-63 88 23 in in IN www-nature-com-63 88 24 2016 2016 CD www-nature-com-63 88 25 , , , www-nature-com-63 88 26 ranking rank VBG www-nature-com-63 88 27 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 88 28 12th 12th JJ www-nature-com-63 88 29 among among IN www-nature-com-63 88 30 all all PDT www-nature-com-63 88 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 88 32 countries country NNS www-nature-com-63 88 33 . . . www-nature-com-63 89 1 Regarding regard VBG www-nature-com-63 89 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 89 3 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 89 4 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 89 5 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 89 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 89 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 89 8 highest high JJS www-nature-com-63 89 9 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 89 10 demand demand NN www-nature-com-63 89 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 89 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 89 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 89 14 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 89 15 slightly slightly RB www-nature-com-63 89 16 decreases decrease VBZ www-nature-com-63 89 17 due due JJ www-nature-com-63 89 18 to to IN www-nature-com-63 89 19 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 89 20 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 89 21 Fig fig NN www-nature-com-63 89 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 90 1 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 90 2 Estimated Estimated NNP www-nature-com-63 90 3 annualized annualized JJ www-nature-com-63 90 4 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 90 5 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 90 6 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 90 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 91 1 Estimated estimate VBN www-nature-com-63 91 2 annualized annualized JJ www-nature-com-63 91 3 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 91 4 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 91 5 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 91 6 a a NN www-nature-com-63 91 7 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 91 8 and and CC www-nature-com-63 91 9 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 91 10 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 91 11 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 91 12 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 91 13 b b NN www-nature-com-63 91 14 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 91 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 91 16 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 91 17 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 91 18 in in IN www-nature-com-63 91 19 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 91 20 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 91 21 generated generate VBN www-nature-com-63 91 22 through through IN www-nature-com-63 91 23 monthly monthly JJ www-nature-com-63 91 24 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 91 25 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 91 26 of of IN www-nature-com-63 91 27 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 91 28 modeling model VBG www-nature-com-63 91 29 from from IN www-nature-com-63 91 30 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 91 31 to to IN www-nature-com-63 91 32 2029 2029 CD www-nature-com-63 91 33 . . . www-nature-com-63 92 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 92 2 blue blue JJ www-nature-com-63 92 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 92 4 red red JJ www-nature-com-63 92 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 92 6 yellow yellow JJ www-nature-com-63 92 7 , , , www-nature-com-63 92 8 and and CC www-nature-com-63 92 9 green green JJ www-nature-com-63 92 10 bars bar NNS www-nature-com-63 92 11 in in IN www-nature-com-63 92 12 a a NN www-nature-com-63 92 13 and and CC www-nature-com-63 92 14 b b LS www-nature-com-63 92 15 indicate indicate VBP www-nature-com-63 92 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 92 17 annual annual JJ www-nature-com-63 92 18 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 92 19 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 92 20 and and CC www-nature-com-63 92 21 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 92 22 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 92 23 flows flow NNS www-nature-com-63 92 24 of of IN www-nature-com-63 92 25 Chinese Chinese NNP www-nature-com-63 92 26 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 92 27 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 92 28 in in IN www-nature-com-63 92 29 benchmark benchmark NN www-nature-com-63 92 30 , , , www-nature-com-63 92 31 site site NN www-nature-com-63 92 32 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 92 33 , , , www-nature-com-63 92 34 market market NN www-nature-com-63 92 35 access access NN www-nature-com-63 92 36 , , , www-nature-com-63 92 37 and and CC www-nature-com-63 92 38 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 92 39 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 92 40 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 92 41 , , , www-nature-com-63 92 42 respectively respectively RB www-nature-com-63 92 43 . . . www-nature-com-63 93 1 Each each DT www-nature-com-63 93 2 data data NN www-nature-com-63 93 3 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 93 4 presented present VBN www-nature-com-63 93 5 as as IN www-nature-com-63 93 6 mean mean JJ www-nature-com-63 93 7 values value NNS www-nature-com-63 93 8 ± ± CD www-nature-com-63 93 9 SEM sem RB www-nature-com-63 93 10 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 93 11 on on IN www-nature-com-63 93 12 95 95 CD www-nature-com-63 93 13 % % NN www-nature-com-63 93 14 confidence confidence NN www-nature-com-63 93 15 intervals interval NNS www-nature-com-63 93 16 calculated calculate VBN www-nature-com-63 93 17 by by IN www-nature-com-63 93 18 two two CD www-nature-com-63 93 19 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 93 20 tailed tailed JJ www-nature-com-63 93 21 t t NN www-nature-com-63 93 22 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 93 23 tests test NNS www-nature-com-63 93 24 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 93 25 p p NN www-nature-com-63 93 26 < < XX www-nature-com-63 93 27 0:05 0:05 CD www-nature-com-63 93 28 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 93 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 94 1 n n NNP www-nature-com-63 94 2 = = SYM www-nature-com-63 94 3 204 204 CD www-nature-com-63 94 4 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 94 5 observations observation NNS www-nature-com-63 94 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 95 1 ARTICLE article NN www-nature-com-63 95 2 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 95 3 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 95 4 | | CD www-nature-com-63 95 5 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 95 6 4 4 CD www-nature-com-63 95 7 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 95 8 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 95 9 | | CD www-nature-com-63 95 10 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 95 11 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 95 12 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 95 13 12:1938 12:1938 CD www-nature-com-63 95 14 | | CD www-nature-com-63 95 15 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 95 16 | | JJ www-nature-com-63 95 17 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 95 18 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 95 19 penalties penalty NNS www-nature-com-63 95 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 95 21 at at IN www-nature-com-63 95 22 217.37 217.37 CD www-nature-com-63 95 23 Twh Twh NNP www-nature-com-63 95 24 . . . www-nature-com-63 96 1 However however RB www-nature-com-63 96 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 96 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 96 4 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 96 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 96 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 96 7 market market NN www-nature-com-63 96 8 access access NN www-nature-com-63 96 9 and and CC www-nature-com-63 96 10 site site NN www-nature-com-63 96 11 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 96 12 scenarios scenario NNS www-nature-com-63 96 13 indicate indicate VBP www-nature-com-63 96 14 that that IN www-nature-com-63 96 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 96 16 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 96 17 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 96 18 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 96 19 of of IN www-nature-com-63 96 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 96 21 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 96 22 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 96 23 will will MD www-nature-com-63 96 24 reach reach VB www-nature-com-63 96 25 350.11 350.11 CD www-nature-com-63 96 26 Twh Twh NNP www-nature-com-63 96 27 and and CC www-nature-com-63 96 28 319.80 319.80 CD www-nature-com-63 96 29 Twh Twh NNP www-nature-com-63 96 30 , , , www-nature-com-63 96 31 respectively respectively RB www-nature-com-63 96 32 , , , www-nature-com-63 96 33 in in IN www-nature-com-63 96 34 2024 2024 CD www-nature-com-63 96 35 and and CC www-nature-com-63 96 36 2025 2025 CD www-nature-com-63 96 37 . . . www-nature-com-63 97 1 It -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 97 2 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 97 3 clear clear JJ www-nature-com-63 97 4 that that IN www-nature-com-63 97 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 97 6 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 97 7 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 97 8 behavior behavior NN www-nature-com-63 97 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 97 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 97 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 97 12 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 97 13 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 97 14 consistent consistent JJ www-nature-com-63 97 15 with with IN www-nature-com-63 97 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 97 17 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 97 18 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 97 19 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 97 20 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 97 21 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 97 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 98 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 98 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 98 3 BM BM NNP www-nature-com-63 98 4 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 98 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 98 6 annual annual JJ www-nature-com-63 98 7 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 98 8 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 98 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 98 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 98 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 98 12 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 98 13 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 98 14 expected expect VBN www-nature-com-63 98 15 to to TO www-nature-com-63 98 16 reach reach VB www-nature-com-63 98 17 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 98 18 maximum maximum NN www-nature-com-63 98 19 in in IN www-nature-com-63 98 20 2024 2024 CD www-nature-com-63 98 21 , , , www-nature-com-63 98 22 at at IN www-nature-com-63 98 23 130.50 130.50 CD www-nature-com-63 98 24 million million CD www-nature-com-63 98 25 metric metric JJ www-nature-com-63 98 26 tons ton NNS www-nature-com-63 98 27 . . . www-nature-com-63 99 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 99 2 essence essence NN www-nature-com-63 99 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 99 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 99 5 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 99 6 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 99 7 pattern pattern NN www-nature-com-63 99 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 99 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 99 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 99 11 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 99 12 would would MD www-nature-com-63 99 13 become become VB www-nature-com-63 99 14 an an DT www-nature-com-63 99 15 increasing increase VBG www-nature-com-63 99 16 threat threat NN www-nature-com-63 99 17 to to IN www-nature-com-63 99 18 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 99 19 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 99 20 greenhouse greenhouse NN www-nature-com-63 99 21 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 99 22 reduction reduction NN www-nature-com-63 99 23 target target NN www-nature-com-63 99 24 . . . www-nature-com-63 100 1 At at IN www-nature-com-63 100 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 100 3 international international JJ www-nature-com-63 100 4 level level NN www-nature-com-63 100 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 100 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 100 7 estimated estimate VBN www-nature-com-63 100 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 100 9 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 100 10 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 100 11 in in IN www-nature-com-63 100 12 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 100 13 exceeds exceed VBZ www-nature-com-63 100 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 100 15 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 100 16 greenhouse greenhouse NN www-nature-com-63 100 17 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 100 18 of of IN www-nature-com-63 100 19 the the DT www-nature-com-63 100 20 Czech Czech NNP www-nature-com-63 100 21 Republic Republic NNP www-nature-com-63 100 22 and and CC www-nature-com-63 100 23 Qatar Qatar NNP www-nature-com-63 100 24 in in IN www-nature-com-63 100 25 2016 2016 CD www-nature-com-63 100 26 , , , www-nature-com-63 100 27 ranking rank VBG www-nature-com-63 100 28 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 100 29 36th 36th NN www-nature-com-63 100 30 worldwide worldwide RB www-nature-com-63 100 31 . . . www-nature-com-63 101 1 At at IN www-nature-com-63 101 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 101 3 domestic domestic JJ www-nature-com-63 101 4 level level NN www-nature-com-63 101 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 101 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 101 7 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 101 8 output output NN www-nature-com-63 101 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 101 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 101 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 101 12 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 101 13 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 101 14 would would MD www-nature-com-63 101 15 rank rank VB www-nature-com-63 101 16 in in IN www-nature-com-63 101 17 the the DT www-nature-com-63 101 18 top top JJ www-nature-com-63 101 19 10 10 CD www-nature-com-63 101 20 among among IN www-nature-com-63 101 21 182 182 CD www-nature-com-63 101 22 Chinese chinese JJ www-nature-com-63 101 23 prefecture- prefecture- JJ www-nature-com-63 101 24 level level NN www-nature-com-63 101 25 cities city NNS www-nature-com-63 101 26 and and CC www-nature-com-63 101 27 42 42 CD www-nature-com-63 101 28 major major JJ www-nature-com-63 101 29 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 101 30 sectors sector NNS www-nature-com-63 101 31 . . . www-nature-com-63 102 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 102 2 comparison comparison NN www-nature-com-63 102 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 102 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 102 5 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 102 6 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 102 7 generated generate VBN www-nature-com-63 102 8 by by IN www-nature-com-63 102 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 102 10 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 102 11 experienced experience VBD www-nature-com-63 102 12 a a DT www-nature-com-63 102 13 significant significant JJ www-nature-com-63 102 14 reduction reduction NN www-nature-com-63 102 15 in in IN www-nature-com-63 102 16 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 102 17 and and CC www-nature-com-63 102 18 CT CT NNP www-nature-com-63 102 19 scenarios scenario NNS www-nature-com-63 102 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 102 21 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 102 22 illustrate illustrate VBP www-nature-com-63 102 23 the the DT www-nature-com-63 102 24 positive positive JJ www-nature-com-63 102 25 impact impact NN www-nature-com-63 102 26 of of IN www-nature-com-63 102 27 these these DT www-nature-com-63 102 28 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 102 29 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 102 30 related relate VBN www-nature-com-63 102 31 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 102 32 . . . www-nature-com-63 103 1 On on IN www-nature-com-63 103 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 103 3 contrary contrary NN www-nature-com-63 103 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 103 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 103 6 MA MA NNP www-nature-com-63 103 7 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 103 8 witnesses witness NNS www-nature-com-63 103 9 a a DT www-nature-com-63 103 10 considerable considerable JJ www-nature-com-63 103 11 increase increase NN www-nature-com-63 103 12 of of IN www-nature-com-63 103 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 103 14 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 103 15 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 103 16 to to IN www-nature-com-63 103 17 140.71 140.71 CD www-nature-com-63 103 18 million million CD www-nature-com-63 103 19 metric metric JJ www-nature-com-63 103 20 tons ton NNS www-nature-com-63 103 21 in in IN www-nature-com-63 103 22 2025 2025 CD www-nature-com-63 103 23 . . . www-nature-com-63 104 1 Based base VBN www-nature-com-63 104 2 on on IN www-nature-com-63 104 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 104 4 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 104 5 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 104 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 104 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 104 8 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 104 9 model model NN www-nature-com-63 104 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 104 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 104 12 Benchmark benchmark JJ www-nature-com-63 104 13 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 104 14 indicates indicate VBZ www-nature-com-63 104 15 that that IN www-nature-com-63 104 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 104 17 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 104 18 consumed consume VBN www-nature-com-63 104 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 104 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 104 21 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 104 22 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 104 23 generated generate VBN www-nature-com-63 104 24 by by IN www-nature-com-63 104 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 104 26 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 104 27 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 104 28 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 104 29 simulated simulate VBN www-nature-com-63 104 30 to to TO www-nature-com-63 104 31 grow grow VB www-nature-com-63 104 32 continuously continuously RB www-nature-com-63 104 33 as as RB www-nature-com-63 104 34 long long RB www-nature-com-63 104 35 as as IN www-nature-com-63 104 36 mining mine VBG www-nature-com-63 104 37 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 104 38 maintains maintain VBZ www-nature-com-63 104 39 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 104 40 profitability profitability NN www-nature-com-63 104 41 in in IN www-nature-com-63 104 42 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 104 43 . . . www-nature-com-63 105 1 This this DT www-nature-com-63 105 2 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 105 3 mainly mainly RB www-nature-com-63 105 4 due due JJ www-nature-com-63 105 5 to to IN www-nature-com-63 105 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 105 7 positive positive JJ www-nature-com-63 105 8 feedback feedback NN www-nature-com-63 105 9 loop loop NN www-nature-com-63 105 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 105 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 105 12 PoW pow NN www-nature-com-63 105 13 competitive competitive JJ www-nature-com-63 105 14 mechanism mechanism NN www-nature-com-63 105 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 105 16 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 105 17 requires require VBZ www-nature-com-63 105 18 advanced advanced JJ www-nature-com-63 105 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 105 20 high high JJ www-nature-com-63 105 21 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 105 22 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 105 23 consuming consume VBG www-nature-com-63 105 24 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 105 25 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 105 26 for for IN www-nature-com-63 105 27 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 105 28 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 105 29 in in IN www-nature-com-63 105 30 order order NN www-nature-com-63 105 31 to to TO www-nature-com-63 105 32 increase increase VB www-nature-com-63 105 33 the the DT www-nature-com-63 105 34 probability probability NN www-nature-com-63 105 35 of of IN www-nature-com-63 105 36 earning earn VBG www-nature-com-63 105 37 block block NN www-nature-com-63 105 38 rewards reward NNS www-nature-com-63 105 39 . . . www-nature-com-63 106 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 106 2 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 106 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 106 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 106 5 flows flow NNS www-nature-com-63 106 6 and and CC www-nature-com-63 106 7 long long JJ www-nature-com-63 106 8 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 106 9 term term NN www-nature-com-63 106 10 trend trend NN www-nature-com-63 106 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 106 12 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 106 13 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 106 14 simulated simulate VBN www-nature-com-63 106 15 by by IN www-nature-com-63 106 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 106 17 proposed propose VBN www-nature-com-63 106 18 system system NN www-nature-com-63 106 19 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 106 20 model model NN www-nature-com-63 106 21 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 106 22 consistent consistent JJ www-nature-com-63 106 23 with with IN www-nature-com-63 106 24 several several JJ www-nature-com-63 106 25 previous previous JJ www-nature-com-63 106 26 estimations10,13 estimations10,13 NNP www-nature-com-63 106 27 , , , www-nature-com-63 106 28 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 106 29 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 106 30 devoted devoted JJ www-nature-com-63 106 31 to to TO www-nature-com-63 106 32 precisely precisely RB www-nature-com-63 106 33 estimate estimate VB www-nature-com-63 106 34 the the DT www-nature-com-63 106 35 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 106 36 footprint footprint NN www-nature-com-63 106 37 of of IN www-nature-com-63 106 38 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 106 39 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 106 40 . . . www-nature-com-63 107 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 107 2 Paris Paris NNP www-nature-com-63 107 3 Agreement Agreement NNP www-nature-com-63 107 4 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 107 5 a a DT www-nature-com-63 107 6 worldwide worldwide JJ www-nature-com-63 107 7 agreement agreement NN www-nature-com-63 107 8 committed commit VBN www-nature-com-63 107 9 to to TO www-nature-com-63 107 10 limit limit VB www-nature-com-63 107 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 107 12 increase increase NN www-nature-com-63 107 13 of of IN www-nature-com-63 107 14 global global JJ www-nature-com-63 107 15 average average JJ www-nature-com-63 107 16 temperature22,23 temperature22,23 NN www-nature-com-63 107 17 . . . www-nature-com-63 108 1 Under under IN www-nature-com-63 108 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 108 3 Paris Paris NNP www-nature-com-63 108 4 Agreement Agreement NNP www-nature-com-63 108 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 108 6 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 108 7 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 108 8 devoted devote VBN www-nature-com-63 108 9 to to TO www-nature-com-63 108 10 cut cut VB www-nature-com-63 108 11 down down RP www-nature-com-63 108 12 60 60 CD www-nature-com-63 108 13 % % NN www-nature-com-63 108 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 108 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 108 16 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 108 17 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 108 18 per per IN www-nature-com-63 108 19 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 108 20 by by IN www-nature-com-63 108 21 2030 2030 CD www-nature-com-63 108 22 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 108 23 on on IN www-nature-com-63 108 24 that that DT www-nature-com-63 108 25 of of IN www-nature-com-63 108 26 2005 2005 CD www-nature-com-63 108 27 . . . www-nature-com-63 109 1 However however RB www-nature-com-63 109 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 109 3 according accord VBG www-nature-com-63 109 4 to to IN www-nature-com-63 109 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 109 6 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 109 7 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 109 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 109 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 109 10 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 109 11 model model NN www-nature-com-63 109 12 , , , www-nature-com-63 109 13 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 109 14 find find VBP www-nature-com-63 109 15 that that IN www-nature-com-63 109 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 109 17 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 109 18 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 109 19 pattern pattern NN www-nature-com-63 109 20 of of IN www-nature-com-63 109 21 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 109 22 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 109 23 will will MD www-nature-com-63 109 24 become become VB www-nature-com-63 109 25 a a DT www-nature-com-63 109 26 potential potential JJ www-nature-com-63 109 27 barrier barrier NN www-nature-com-63 109 28 against against IN www-nature-com-63 109 29 the the DT www-nature-com-63 109 30 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 109 31 reduction reduction NN www-nature-com-63 109 32 target target NN www-nature-com-63 109 33 of of IN www-nature-com-63 109 34 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 109 35 . . . www-nature-com-63 110 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 110 2 shown show VBN www-nature-com-63 110 3 in in IN www-nature-com-63 110 4 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 110 5 . . . www-nature-com-63 111 1 3 3 LS www-nature-com-63 111 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 111 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 111 4 peak peak NN www-nature-com-63 111 5 annualized annualize VBN www-nature-com-63 111 6 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 111 7 output output NN www-nature-com-63 111 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 111 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 111 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 111 11 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 111 12 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 111 13 would would MD www-nature-com-63 111 14 make make VB www-nature-com-63 111 15 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 111 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 111 17 10th 10th RB www-nature-com-63 111 18 largest large JJS www-nature-com-63 111 19 emitting emitting JJ www-nature-com-63 111 20 sector sector NN www-nature-com-63 111 21 out out IN www-nature-com-63 111 22 of of IN www-nature-com-63 111 23 a a DT www-nature-com-63 111 24 total total NN www-nature-com-63 111 25 of of IN www-nature-com-63 111 26 42 42 CD www-nature-com-63 111 27 major major JJ www-nature-com-63 111 28 Chinese chinese JJ www-nature-com-63 111 29 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 111 30 sectors sector NNS www-nature-com-63 111 31 . . . www-nature-com-63 112 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 112 2 particular particular JJ www-nature-com-63 112 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 112 4 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 112 5 would would MD www-nature-com-63 112 6 account account VB www-nature-com-63 112 7 for for IN www-nature-com-63 112 8 approximately approximately RB www-nature-com-63 112 9 5.41 5.41 CD www-nature-com-63 112 10 % % NN www-nature-com-63 112 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 112 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 112 13 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 112 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 112 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 112 16 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 112 17 generation generation NN www-nature-com-63 112 18 in in IN www-nature-com-63 112 19 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 112 20 according accord VBG www-nature-com-63 112 21 to to IN www-nature-com-63 112 22 the the DT www-nature-com-63 112 23 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 112 24 Emission Emission NNP www-nature-com-63 112 25 Accounts Accounts NNPS www-nature-com-63 112 26 & & CC www-nature-com-63 112 27 Datasets Datasets NNPS www-nature-com-63 112 28 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 112 29 www.ceads.net www.ceads.net NN www-nature-com-63 112 30 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 112 31 . . . www-nature-com-63 113 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 113 2 peak peak NN www-nature-com-63 113 3 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 113 4 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 113 5 per per IN www-nature-com-63 113 6 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 113 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 113 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 113 9 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 113 10 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 113 11 expected expect VBN www-nature-com-63 113 12 to to TO www-nature-com-63 113 13 sit sit VB www-nature-com-63 113 14 at at IN www-nature-com-63 113 15 10.77 10.77 CD www-nature-com-63 113 16 kg kg NNS www-nature-com-63 113 17 per per IN www-nature-com-63 113 18 USD usd NN www-nature-com-63 113 19 . . . www-nature-com-63 114 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 114 2 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 114 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 114 4 in in IN www-nature-com-63 114 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 114 6 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 114 7 national national JJ www-nature-com-63 114 8 economy economy NN www-nature-com-63 114 9 and and CC www-nature-com-63 114 10 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 114 11 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 114 12 accounting accounting NN www-nature-com-63 114 13 of of IN www-nature-com-63 114 14 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 114 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 114 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 114 17 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 114 18 of of IN www-nature-com-63 114 19 the the DT www-nature-com-63 114 20 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 114 21 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 114 22 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 114 23 not not RB www-nature-com-63 114 24 listed list VBN www-nature-com-63 114 25 as as IN www-nature-com-63 114 26 an an DT www-nature-com-63 114 27 independent independent JJ www-nature-com-63 114 28 department department NN www-nature-com-63 114 29 for for IN www-nature-com-63 114 30 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 114 31 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 114 32 and and CC www-nature-com-63 114 33 productivity productivity NN www-nature-com-63 114 34 calculation calculation NN www-nature-com-63 114 35 . . . www-nature-com-63 115 1 This this DT www-nature-com-63 115 2 adds add VBZ www-nature-com-63 115 3 difficulty difficulty NN www-nature-com-63 115 4 for for IN www-nature-com-63 115 5 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 115 6 makers maker NNS www-nature-com-63 115 7 to to TO www-nature-com-63 115 8 monitor monitor VB www-nature-com-63 115 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 115 10 actual actual JJ www-nature-com-63 115 11 behaviors behavior NNS www-nature-com-63 115 12 of of IN www-nature-com-63 115 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 115 14 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 115 15 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 115 16 and and CC www-nature-com-63 115 17 design design NN www-nature-com-63 115 18 well well RB www-nature-com-63 115 19 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 115 20 directed direct VBN www-nature-com-63 115 21 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 115 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 116 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 116 2 fact fact NN www-nature-com-63 116 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 116 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 116 5 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 116 6 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 116 7 per per IN www-nature-com-63 116 8 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 116 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 116 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 116 11 network network NN www-nature-com-63 116 12 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 116 13 larger large JJR www-nature-com-63 116 14 than than IN www-nature-com-63 116 15 numerous numerous JJ www-nature-com-63 116 16 mainstream mainstream JJ www-nature-com-63 116 17 financial financial JJ www-nature-com-63 116 18 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 116 19 channels17 channels17 NNP www-nature-com-63 116 20 . . . www-nature-com-63 117 1 To to TO www-nature-com-63 117 2 address address VB www-nature-com-63 117 3 this this DT www-nature-com-63 117 4 issue issue NN www-nature-com-63 117 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 117 6 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 117 7 suggest suggest VBP www-nature-com-63 117 8 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 117 9 makers maker NNS www-nature-com-63 117 10 to to TO www-nature-com-63 117 11 set set VB www-nature-com-63 117 12 up up RP www-nature-com-63 117 13 separated separated JJ www-nature-com-63 117 14 accounts account NNS www-nature-com-63 117 15 for for IN www-nature-com-63 117 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 117 17 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 117 18 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 117 19 in in IN www-nature-com-63 117 20 order order NN www-nature-com-63 117 21 to to TO www-nature-com-63 117 22 better well RBR www-nature-com-63 117 23 manage manage VB www-nature-com-63 117 24 and and CC www-nature-com-63 117 25 control control VB www-nature-com-63 117 26 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 117 27 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 117 28 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 117 29 behaviors behavior NNS www-nature-com-63 117 30 in in IN www-nature-com-63 117 31 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 117 32 . . . www-nature-com-63 118 1 Carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 118 2 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 118 3 effectiveness effectiveness NN www-nature-com-63 118 4 evaluation evaluation NN www-nature-com-63 118 5 . . . www-nature-com-63 119 1 Policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 119 2 that that WDT www-nature-com-63 119 3 induce induce VBP www-nature-com-63 119 4 changes change NNS www-nature-com-63 119 5 in in IN www-nature-com-63 119 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 119 7 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 119 8 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 119 9 structure structure NN www-nature-com-63 119 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 119 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 119 12 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 119 13 activities activity NNS www-nature-com-63 119 14 may may MD www-nature-com-63 119 15 be be VB www-nature-com-63 119 16 more more RBR www-nature-com-63 119 17 effective effective JJ www-nature-com-63 119 18 than than IN www-nature-com-63 119 19 intuitive intuitive JJ www-nature-com-63 119 20 punitive punitive JJ www-nature-com-63 119 21 measures measure NNS www-nature-com-63 119 22 in in IN www-nature-com-63 119 23 limiting limit VBG www-nature-com-63 119 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 119 25 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 119 26 amount amount NN www-nature-com-63 119 27 of of IN www-nature-com-63 119 28 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 119 29 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 119 30 and and CC www-nature-com-63 119 31 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 119 32 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 119 33 in in IN www-nature-com-63 119 34 the the DT www-nature-com-63 119 35 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 119 36 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 119 37 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 119 38 . . . www-nature-com-63 120 1 Figure figure NN www-nature-com-63 120 2 4 4 CD www-nature-com-63 120 3 presents present VBZ www-nature-com-63 120 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 120 5 values value NNS www-nature-com-63 120 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 120 7 key key JJ www-nature-com-63 120 8 parameters parameter NNS www-nature-com-63 120 9 simulated simulate VBN www-nature-com-63 120 10 by by IN www-nature-com-63 120 11 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 120 12 model model NN www-nature-com-63 120 13 . . . www-nature-com-63 121 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 121 2 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 121 3 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 121 4 per per IN www-nature-com-63 121 5 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 121 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 121 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 121 8 BM BM NNP www-nature-com-63 121 9 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 121 10 in in IN www-nature-com-63 121 11 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 121 12 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 121 13 larger large JJR www-nature-com-63 121 14 than than IN www-nature-com-63 121 15 that that DT www-nature-com-63 121 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 121 17 all all DT www-nature-com-63 121 18 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 121 19 scenarios scenario NNS www-nature-com-63 121 20 throughout throughout IN www-nature-com-63 121 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 121 22 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 121 23 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 121 24 period period NN www-nature-com-63 121 25 , , , www-nature-com-63 121 26 reaching reach VBG www-nature-com-63 121 27 a a DT www-nature-com-63 121 28 maximum maximum NN www-nature-com-63 121 29 of of IN www-nature-com-63 121 30 10.77 10.77 CD www-nature-com-63 121 31 kg kg NNS www-nature-com-63 121 32 per per IN www-nature-com-63 121 33 USD usd NN www-nature-com-63 121 34 in in IN www-nature-com-63 121 35 June June NNP www-nature-com-63 121 36 2026 2026 CD www-nature-com-63 121 37 . . . www-nature-com-63 122 1 However however RB www-nature-com-63 122 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 122 3 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 122 4 find find VBP www-nature-com-63 122 5 that that IN www-nature-com-63 122 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 122 7 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 122 8 effectiveness effectiveness NN www-nature-com-63 122 9 under under IN www-nature-com-63 122 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 122 11 MA MA NNP www-nature-com-63 122 12 and and CC www-nature-com-63 122 13 CT CT NNP www-nature-com-63 122 14 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 122 15 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 122 16 rather rather RB www-nature-com-63 122 17 limited limited JJ www-nature-com-63 122 18 on on IN www-nature-com-63 122 19 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 122 20 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 122 21 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 122 22 reduction reduction NN www-nature-com-63 122 23 , , , www-nature-com-63 122 24 i.e. i.e. FW www-nature-com-63 122 25 , , , www-nature-com-63 122 26 the the DT www-nature-com-63 122 27 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 122 28 effectiveness effectiveness NN www-nature-com-63 122 29 of of IN www-nature-com-63 122 30 Market market NN www-nature-com-63 122 31 access access NN www-nature-com-63 122 32 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 122 33 expected expect VBN www-nature-com-63 122 34 to to TO www-nature-com-63 122 35 reduce reduce VB www-nature-com-63 122 36 in in IN www-nature-com-63 122 37 August August NNP www-nature-com-63 122 38 2027 2027 CD www-nature-com-63 122 39 and and CC www-nature-com-63 122 40 that that DT www-nature-com-63 122 41 of of IN www-nature-com-63 122 42 Carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 122 43 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 122 44 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 122 45 expected expect VBN www-nature-com-63 122 46 to to TO www-nature-com-63 122 47 be be VB www-nature-com-63 122 48 effective effective JJ www-nature-com-63 122 49 until until IN www-nature-com-63 122 50 July July NNP www-nature-com-63 122 51 2024 2024 CD www-nature-com-63 122 52 . . . www-nature-com-63 123 1 Among among IN www-nature-com-63 123 2 all all PDT www-nature-com-63 123 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 123 4 intended intend VBN www-nature-com-63 123 5 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 123 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 123 7 Site Site NNP www-nature-com-63 123 8 Regulation Regulation NNP www-nature-com-63 123 9 shows show VBZ www-nature-com-63 123 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 123 11 best good JJS www-nature-com-63 123 12 effectiveness effectiveness NN www-nature-com-63 123 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 123 14 reducing reduce VBG www-nature-com-63 123 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 123 16 peak peak NN www-nature-com-63 123 17 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 123 18 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 123 19 per per IN www-nature-com-63 123 20 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 123 21 of of IN www-nature-com-63 123 22 the the DT www-nature-com-63 123 23 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 123 24 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 123 25 to to IN www-nature-com-63 123 26 6 6 CD www-nature-com-63 123 27 kg kg NNS www-nature-com-63 123 28 per per IN www-nature-com-63 123 29 USD usd NN www-nature-com-63 123 30 . . . www-nature-com-63 124 1 Overall overall RB www-nature-com-63 124 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 124 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 124 4 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 124 5 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 124 6 per per IN www-nature-com-63 124 7 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 124 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 124 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 124 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 124 11 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 124 12 far far RB www-nature-com-63 124 13 exceeds exceed VBZ www-nature-com-63 124 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 124 15 average average JJ www-nature-com-63 124 16 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 124 17 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 124 18 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 124 19 of of IN www-nature-com-63 124 20 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 124 21 , , , www-nature-com-63 124 22 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 124 23 indicates indicate VBZ www-nature-com-63 124 24 that that IN www-nature-com-63 124 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 124 26 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 124 27 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 124 28 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 124 29 a a DT www-nature-com-63 124 30 highly highly RB www-nature-com-63 124 31 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 124 32 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 124 33 intense intense JJ www-nature-com-63 124 34 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 124 35 . . . www-nature-com-63 125 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 125 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 125 3 BM BM NNP www-nature-com-63 125 4 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 125 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 125 6 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 125 7 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 125 8 ’ ’ POS www-nature-com-63 125 9 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 125 10 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 125 11 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 125 12 expected expect VBN www-nature-com-63 125 13 to to TO www-nature-com-63 125 14 drop drop VB www-nature-com-63 125 15 to to IN www-nature-com-63 125 16 zero zero CD www-nature-com-63 125 17 in in IN www-nature-com-63 125 18 April April NNP www-nature-com-63 125 19 2024 2024 CD www-nature-com-63 125 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 125 21 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 125 22 suggests suggest VBZ www-nature-com-63 125 23 that that IN www-nature-com-63 125 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 125 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 125 26 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 125 27 will will MD www-nature-com-63 125 28 gradually gradually RB www-nature-com-63 125 29 stop stop VB www-nature-com-63 125 30 mining mine VBG www-nature-com-63 125 31 in in IN www-nature-com-63 125 32 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 125 33 and and CC www-nature-com-63 125 34 relocate relocate VB www-nature-com-63 125 35 their -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 125 36 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 125 37 elsewhere elsewhere RB www-nature-com-63 125 38 . . . www-nature-com-63 126 1 However however RB www-nature-com-63 126 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 126 3 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 126 4 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 126 5 important important JJ www-nature-com-63 126 6 to to TO www-nature-com-63 126 7 note note VB www-nature-com-63 126 8 that that IN www-nature-com-63 126 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 126 10 entire entire JJ www-nature-com-63 126 11 relocation relocation NN www-nature-com-63 126 12 process process NN www-nature-com-63 126 13 does do VBZ www-nature-com-63 126 14 not not RB www-nature-com-63 126 15 occur occur VB www-nature-com-63 126 16 immediately immediately RB www-nature-com-63 126 17 . . . www-nature-com-63 127 1 Miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 127 2 with with IN www-nature-com-63 127 3 higher high JJR www-nature-com-63 127 4 sunk sunk NN www-nature-com-63 127 5 costs cost NNS www-nature-com-63 127 6 tend tend VBP www-nature-com-63 127 7 to to TO www-nature-com-63 127 8 stay stay VB www-nature-com-63 127 9 in in IN www-nature-com-63 127 10 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 127 11 longer long RBR www-nature-com-63 127 12 than than IN www-nature-com-63 127 13 those those DT www-nature-com-63 127 14 with with IN www-nature-com-63 127 15 lower low JJR www-nature-com-63 127 16 sunk sink VBN www-nature-com-63 127 17 costs cost NNS www-nature-com-63 127 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 127 19 hoping hope VBG www-nature-com-63 127 20 to to TO www-nature-com-63 127 21 eventually eventually RB www-nature-com-63 127 22 make make VB www-nature-com-63 127 23 a a DT www-nature-com-63 127 24 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 127 25 again again RB www-nature-com-63 127 26 . . . www-nature-com-63 128 1 Consequently consequently RB www-nature-com-63 128 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 128 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 128 4 overall overall JJ www-nature-com-63 128 5 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 128 6 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 128 7 associated associate VBN www-nature-com-63 128 8 with with IN www-nature-com-63 128 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 128 10 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 128 11 remains remain VBZ www-nature-com-63 128 12 positive positive JJ www-nature-com-63 128 13 until until IN www-nature-com-63 128 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 128 15 end end NN www-nature-com-63 128 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 128 17 2030 2030 CD www-nature-com-63 128 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 128 19 at at IN www-nature-com-63 128 20 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 128 21 time time NN www-nature-com-63 128 22 almost almost RB www-nature-com-63 128 23 all all DT www-nature-com-63 128 24 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 128 25 would would MD www-nature-com-63 128 26 have have VB www-nature-com-63 128 27 relocated relocate VBN www-nature-com-63 128 28 elsewhere elsewhere RB www-nature-com-63 128 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 129 1 Correspondingly correspondingly RB www-nature-com-63 129 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 129 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 129 4 network network NN www-nature-com-63 129 5 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 129 6 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 129 7 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 129 8 computed compute VBN www-nature-com-63 129 9 to to TO www-nature-com-63 129 10 reach reach VB www-nature-com-63 129 11 1775 1775 CD www-nature-com-63 129 12 EH EH NNP www-nature-com-63 129 13 per per IN www-nature-com-63 129 14 second second NN www-nature-com-63 129 15 in in IN www-nature-com-63 129 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 129 17 BM BM NNP www-nature-com-63 129 18 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 129 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 129 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 129 21 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 129 22 total total NN www-nature-com-63 129 23 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 129 24 to to TO www-nature-com-63 129 25 reach reach VB www-nature-com-63 129 26 a a DT www-nature-com-63 129 27 maximum maximum NN www-nature-com-63 129 28 of of IN www-nature-com-63 129 29 1268 1268 CD www-nature-com-63 129 30 million million CD www-nature-com-63 129 31 dollars dollar NNS www-nature-com-63 129 32 . . . www-nature-com-63 130 1 Comparing compare VBG www-nature-com-63 130 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 130 3 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 130 4 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 130 5 for for IN www-nature-com-63 130 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 130 7 three three CD www-nature-com-63 130 8 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 130 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 130 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 130 11 profitability profitability NN www-nature-com-63 130 12 of of IN www-nature-com-63 130 13 mining mine VBG www-nature-com-63 130 14 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 130 15 in in IN www-nature-com-63 130 16 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 130 17 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 130 18 expected expect VBN www-nature-com-63 130 19 to to TO www-nature-com-63 130 20 deteriorate deteriorate VB www-nature-com-63 130 21 more more RBR www-nature-com-63 130 22 quickly quickly RB www-nature-com-63 130 23 in in IN www-nature-com-63 130 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 130 25 CT CT NNP www-nature-com-63 130 26 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 130 27 . . . www-nature-com-63 131 1 On on IN www-nature-com-63 131 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 131 3 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 131 4 hand hand NN www-nature-com-63 131 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 131 6 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 131 7 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 131 8 can can MD www-nature-com-63 131 9 maintain maintain VB www-nature-com-63 131 10 profitability profitability NN www-nature-com-63 131 11 for for IN www-nature-com-63 131 12 a a DT www-nature-com-63 131 13 longer long JJR www-nature-com-63 131 14 period period NN www-nature-com-63 131 15 in in IN www-nature-com-63 131 16 MA MA NNP www-nature-com-63 131 17 and and CC www-nature-com-63 131 18 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 131 19 scenarios scenario NNS www-nature-com-63 131 20 . . . www-nature-com-63 132 1 Some some DT www-nature-com-63 132 2 attractive attractive JJ www-nature-com-63 132 3 conclusions conclusion NNS www-nature-com-63 132 4 can can MD www-nature-com-63 132 5 be be VB www-nature-com-63 132 6 drawn draw VBN www-nature-com-63 132 7 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 132 8 on on IN www-nature-com-63 132 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 132 10 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 132 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 132 12 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 132 13 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 132 14 : : : www-nature-com-63 132 15 although although IN www-nature-com-63 132 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 132 17 MA MA NNP www-nature-com-63 132 18 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 132 19 enhances enhance VBZ www-nature-com-63 132 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 132 21 market market NN www-nature-com-63 132 22 access access NN www-nature-com-63 132 23 standard standard JJ www-nature-com-63 132 24 to to TO www-nature-com-63 132 25 increase increase VB www-nature-com-63 132 26 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 132 27 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 132 28 ’ ’ POS www-nature-com-63 132 29 efficiencies efficiency NNS www-nature-com-63 132 30 , , , www-nature-com-63 132 31 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 132 32 actually actually RB www-nature-com-63 132 33 raises raise VBZ www-nature-com-63 132 34 , , , www-nature-com-63 132 35 rather rather RB www-nature-com-63 132 36 than than IN www-nature-com-63 132 37 reduces reduce NNS www-nature-com-63 132 38 , , , www-nature-com-63 132 39 the the DT www-nature-com-63 132 40 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 132 41 output output NN www-nature-com-63 132 42 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 132 43 on on IN www-nature-com-63 132 44 the the DT www-nature-com-63 132 45 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 132 46 outcome outcome NN www-nature-com-63 132 47 . . . www-nature-com-63 133 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 133 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 133 3 MA MA NNP www-nature-com-63 133 4 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 133 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 133 6 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 133 7 observe observe VBP www-nature-com-63 133 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 133 9 phenomenon phenomenon NN www-nature-com-63 133 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 133 11 incentive incentive JJ www-nature-com-63 133 12 effects effect NNS www-nature-com-63 133 13 proposed propose VBN www-nature-com-63 133 14 by by IN www-nature-com-63 133 15 previous previous JJ www-nature-com-63 133 16 works work NNS www-nature-com-63 133 17 , , , www-nature-com-63 133 18 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 133 19 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 133 20 identified identify VBN www-nature-com-63 133 21 in in IN www-nature-com-63 133 22 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 133 23 fields field NNS www-nature-com-63 133 24 of of IN www-nature-com-63 133 25 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 133 26 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 133 27 , , , www-nature-com-63 133 28 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 133 29 as as IN www-nature-com-63 133 30 monetary monetary JJ www-nature-com-63 133 31 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 133 32 , , , www-nature-com-63 133 33 transportation transportation NN www-nature-com-63 133 34 regulations regulation NNS www-nature-com-63 133 35 , , , www-nature-com-63 133 36 and and CC www-nature-com-63 133 37 firm firm JJ www-nature-com-63 133 38 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 133 39 strategies24–26 strategies24–26 NN www-nature-com-63 133 40 . . . www-nature-com-63 134 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 134 2 essence essence NN www-nature-com-63 134 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 134 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 134 5 purpose purpose NN www-nature-com-63 134 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 134 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 134 8 market market NN www-nature-com-63 134 9 access access NN www-nature-com-63 134 10 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 134 11 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 134 12 to to TO www-nature-com-63 134 13 limit limit VB www-nature-com-63 134 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 134 15 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 134 16 operations operation NNS www-nature-com-63 134 17 of of IN www-nature-com-63 134 18 low low JJ www-nature-com-63 134 19 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 134 20 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 134 21 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 134 22 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 134 23 in in IN www-nature-com-63 134 24 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 134 25 . . . www-nature-com-63 135 1 However however RB www-nature-com-63 135 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 135 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 135 4 surviving survive VBG www-nature-com-63 135 5 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 135 6 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 135 7 all all RB www-nature-com-63 135 8 devoted devoted JJ www-nature-com-63 135 9 to to IN www-nature-com-63 135 10 squeezing squeeze VBG www-nature-com-63 135 11 more more JJR www-nature-com-63 135 12 proportion proportion NN www-nature-com-63 135 13 of of IN www-nature-com-63 135 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 135 15 network network NN www-nature-com-63 135 16 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 135 17 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 135 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 135 19 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 135 20 enables enable VBZ www-nature-com-63 135 21 them -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 135 22 to to TO www-nature-com-63 135 23 stay stay VB www-nature-com-63 135 24 profitable profitable JJ www-nature-com-63 135 25 for for IN www-nature-com-63 135 26 a a DT www-nature-com-63 135 27 longer long JJR www-nature-com-63 135 28 period period NN www-nature-com-63 135 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 136 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 136 2 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 136 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 136 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 136 5 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 136 6 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 136 7 in in IN www-nature-com-63 136 8 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 136 9 generates generate VBZ www-nature-com-63 136 10 more more JJR www-nature-com-63 136 11 CO2 CO2 NNP www-nature-com-63 136 12 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 136 13 under under IN www-nature-com-63 136 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 136 15 MA MA NNP www-nature-com-63 136 16 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 136 17 , , , www-nature-com-63 136 18 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 136 19 can can MD www-nature-com-63 136 20 be be VB www-nature-com-63 136 21 mainly mainly RB www-nature-com-63 136 22 attributed attribute VBN www-nature-com-63 136 23 to to IN www-nature-com-63 136 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 136 25 Proof Proof NNP www-nature-com-63 136 26 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 136 27 of of IN www-nature-com-63 136 28 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 136 29 Work work NN www-nature-com-63 136 30 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 136 31 PoW PoW NNP www-nature-com-63 136 32 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 136 33 algorithm algorithm NN www-nature-com-63 136 34 and and CC www-nature-com-63 136 35 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 136 36 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 136 37 pursuit pursuit NN www-nature-com-63 136 38 behaviors behavior NNS www-nature-com-63 136 39 of of IN www-nature-com-63 136 40 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 136 41 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 136 42 . . . www-nature-com-63 137 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 137 2 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 137 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 137 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 137 5 MA MA NNP www-nature-com-63 137 6 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 137 7 indicate indicate VBP www-nature-com-63 137 8 that that IN www-nature-com-63 137 9 market market NN www-nature-com-63 137 10 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 137 11 related relate VBN www-nature-com-63 137 12 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 137 13 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 137 14 likely likely JJ www-nature-com-63 137 15 to to TO www-nature-com-63 137 16 be be VB www-nature-com-63 137 17 less less RBR www-nature-com-63 137 18 effective effective JJ www-nature-com-63 137 19 in in IN www-nature-com-63 137 20 dealing deal VBG www-nature-com-63 137 21 with with IN www-nature-com-63 137 22 high high JJ www-nature-com-63 137 23 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 137 24 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 137 25 behaviors behavior NNS www-nature-com-63 137 26 of of IN www-nature-com-63 137 27 the the DT www-nature-com-63 137 28 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 137 29 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 137 30 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 137 31 . . . www-nature-com-63 138 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 138 2 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 138 3 taxation taxation NN www-nature-com-63 138 4 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 138 5 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 138 6 widely widely RB www-nature-com-63 138 7 acknowledged acknowledge VBN www-nature-com-63 138 8 as as IN www-nature-com-63 138 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 138 10 most most RBS www-nature-com-63 138 11 effective effective JJ www-nature-com-63 138 12 and and CC www-nature-com-63 138 13 most most RBS www-nature-com-63 138 14 commonly commonly RB www-nature-com-63 138 15 implemented implement VBN www-nature-com-63 138 16 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 138 17 on on IN www-nature-com-63 138 18 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 138 19 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 138 20 reduction27 reduction27 NN www-nature-com-63 138 21 . . . www-nature-com-63 139 1 However however RB www-nature-com-63 139 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 139 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 139 4 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 139 5 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 139 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 139 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 139 8 CT CT NNP www-nature-com-63 139 9 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 139 10 indicate indicate VBP www-nature-com-63 139 11 that that IN www-nature-com-63 139 12 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 139 13 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 139 14 only only RB www-nature-com-63 139 15 provides provide VBZ www-nature-com-63 139 16 limited limited JJ www-nature-com-63 139 17 effective- effective- JJ www-nature-com-63 139 18 ness ness NN www-nature-com-63 139 19 for for IN www-nature-com-63 139 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 139 21 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 139 22 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 139 23 . . . www-nature-com-63 140 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 140 2 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 140 3 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 140 4 patterns pattern NNS www-nature-com-63 140 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 140 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 140 7 CT CT NNP www-nature-com-63 140 8 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 140 9 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 140 10 consistent consistent JJ www-nature-com-63 140 11 with with IN www-nature-com-63 140 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 140 13 BM BM NNP www-nature-com-63 140 14 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 140 15 until until IN www-nature-com-63 140 16 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 140 17 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 140 18 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 140 19 aware aware JJ www-nature-com-63 140 20 that that IN www-nature-com-63 140 21 their -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 140 22 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 140 23 profits profit NNS www-nature-com-63 140 24 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 140 25 affected affect VBN www-nature-com-63 140 26 by by IN www-nature-com-63 140 27 the the DT www-nature-com-63 140 28 punitive punitive JJ www-nature-com-63 140 29 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 140 30 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 140 31 on on IN www-nature-com-63 140 32 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 140 33 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 140 34 . . . www-nature-com-63 141 1 On on IN www-nature-com-63 141 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 141 3 contrary contrary NN www-nature-com-63 141 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 141 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 141 6 evidence evidence NN www-nature-com-63 141 7 from from IN www-nature-com-63 141 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 141 9 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 141 10 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 141 11 shows show VBZ www-nature-com-63 141 12 that that IN www-nature-com-63 141 13 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 141 14 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 141 15 able able JJ www-nature-com-63 141 16 to to TO www-nature-com-63 141 17 provide provide VB www-nature-com-63 141 18 a a DT www-nature-com-63 141 19 negative negative JJ www-nature-com-63 141 20 feedback feedback NN www-nature-com-63 141 21 for for IN www-nature-com-63 141 22 the the DT www-nature-com-63 141 23 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 141 24 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 141 25 of of IN www-nature-com-63 141 26 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 141 27 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 141 28 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 141 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 142 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 142 2 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 142 3 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 142 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 142 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 142 6 maximized maximize VBN www-nature-com-63 142 7 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 142 8 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 142 9 per per IN www-nature-com-63 142 10 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 142 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 142 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 142 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 142 14 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 142 15 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 142 16 halved halve VBN www-nature-com-63 142 17 in in IN www-nature-com-63 142 18 the the DT www-nature-com-63 142 19 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 142 20 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 142 21 in in IN www-nature-com-63 142 22 comparison comparison NN www-nature-com-63 142 23 to to IN www-nature-com-63 142 24 that that DT www-nature-com-63 142 25 in in IN www-nature-com-63 142 26 the the DT www-nature-com-63 142 27 BM BM NNP www-nature-com-63 142 28 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 142 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 143 1 It -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 143 2 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 143 3 interesting interesting JJ www-nature-com-63 143 4 to to TO www-nature-com-63 143 5 note note VB www-nature-com-63 143 6 that that IN www-nature-com-63 143 7 although although IN www-nature-com-63 143 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 143 9 peak peak NN www-nature-com-63 143 10 annualized annualize VBD www-nature-com-63 143 11 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 143 12 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 143 13 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 143 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 143 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 143 16 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 143 17 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 143 18 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 143 19 in in IN www-nature-com-63 143 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 143 21 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 143 22 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 143 23 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 143 24 higher high JJR www-nature-com-63 143 25 than than IN www-nature-com-63 143 26 that that DT www-nature-com-63 143 27 in in IN www-nature-com-63 143 28 the the DT www-nature-com-63 143 29 BM BM NNP www-nature-com-63 143 30 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 143 31 , , , www-nature-com-63 143 32 a a DT www-nature-com-63 143 33 significantly significantly RB www-nature-com-63 143 34 higher high JJR www-nature-com-63 143 35 proportion proportion NN www-nature-com-63 143 36 of of IN www-nature-com-63 143 37 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 143 38 have have VBP www-nature-com-63 143 39 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 143 40 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 143 41 | | CD www-nature-com-63 143 42 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 143 43 ARTICLE article NN www-nature-com-63 143 44 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 143 45 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 143 46 | | CD www-nature-com-63 143 47 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 143 48 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 143 49 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 143 50 12:1938 12:1938 CD www-nature-com-63 143 51 | | CD www-nature-com-63 143 52 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 143 53 | | CD www-nature-com-63 143 54 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 143 55 5 5 CD www-nature-com-63 143 56 http://www.ceads.net http://www.ceads.net NN www-nature-com-63 143 57 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 143 58 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 143 59 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 143 60 . . . www-nature-com-63 144 1 4 4 CD www-nature-com-63 144 2 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 144 3 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 144 4 assessment assessment NN www-nature-com-63 144 5 comparisons comparison NNS www-nature-com-63 144 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 145 1 a a LS www-nature-com-63 145 2 – – : www-nature-com-63 145 3 i i PRP www-nature-com-63 145 4 Monthly monthly JJ www-nature-com-63 145 5 network network NN www-nature-com-63 145 6 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 145 7 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 145 8 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 145 9 a a LS www-nature-com-63 145 10 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 145 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 145 12 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 145 13 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 145 14 per per IN www-nature-com-63 145 15 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 145 16 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 145 17 b b NNP www-nature-com-63 145 18 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 145 19 , , , www-nature-com-63 145 20 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 145 21 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 145 22 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 145 23 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 145 24 c c NN www-nature-com-63 145 25 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 145 26 , , , www-nature-com-63 145 27 network network NN www-nature-com-63 145 28 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 145 29 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 145 30 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 145 31 d d NNP www-nature-com-63 145 32 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 145 33 , , , www-nature-com-63 145 34 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 145 35 cumulative cumulative JJ www-nature-com-63 145 36 profits profit NNS www-nature-com-63 145 37 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 145 38 e e NNP www-nature-com-63 145 39 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 145 40 , , , www-nature-com-63 145 41 block block NN www-nature-com-63 145 42 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 145 43 difficulty difficulty NN www-nature-com-63 145 44 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 145 45 f f NNP www-nature-com-63 145 46 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 145 47 , , , www-nature-com-63 145 48 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 145 49 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 145 50 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 145 51 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 145 52 g g NNP www-nature-com-63 145 53 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 145 54 , , , www-nature-com-63 145 55 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 145 56 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 145 57 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 145 58 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 145 59 h h NN www-nature-com-63 145 60 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 145 61 , , , www-nature-com-63 145 62 and and CC www-nature-com-63 145 63 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 145 64 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 145 65 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 145 66 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 145 67 i i NN www-nature-com-63 145 68 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 145 69 under under IN www-nature-com-63 145 70 each each DT www-nature-com-63 145 71 intended intend VBN www-nature-com-63 145 72 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 145 73 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 145 74 simulated simulate VBN www-nature-com-63 145 75 and and CC www-nature-com-63 145 76 calculated calculate VBN www-nature-com-63 145 77 by by IN www-nature-com-63 145 78 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 145 79 framework framework NN www-nature-com-63 145 80 . . . www-nature-com-63 146 1 Based base VBN www-nature-com-63 146 2 on on IN www-nature-com-63 146 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 146 4 regressed regress VBN www-nature-com-63 146 5 parameters parameter NNS www-nature-com-63 146 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 146 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 146 8 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 146 9 model model NN www-nature-com-63 146 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 146 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 146 12 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 146 13 sample sample NN www-nature-com-63 146 14 timesteps timestep NNS www-nature-com-63 146 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 146 16 network network NN www-nature-com-63 146 17 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 146 18 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 146 19 assessment assessment NN www-nature-com-63 146 20 cover cover VBP www-nature-com-63 146 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 146 22 period period NN www-nature-com-63 146 23 from from IN www-nature-com-63 146 24 January January NNP www-nature-com-63 146 25 2014 2014 CD www-nature-com-63 146 26 to to IN www-nature-com-63 146 27 January January NNP www-nature-com-63 146 28 2030 2030 CD www-nature-com-63 146 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 147 1 Fig fig NN www-nature-com-63 147 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 148 1 3 3 CD www-nature-com-63 148 2 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 148 3 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 148 4 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 148 5 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 148 6 and and CC www-nature-com-63 148 7 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 148 8 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 148 9 comparisons comparison NNS www-nature-com-63 148 10 . . . www-nature-com-63 149 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 149 2 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 149 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 150 1 3 3 LS www-nature-com-63 150 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 150 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 150 4 peak peak NN www-nature-com-63 150 5 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 150 6 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 150 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 150 8 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 150 9 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 150 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 150 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 150 12 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 150 13 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 150 14 compared compare VBN www-nature-com-63 150 15 to to IN www-nature-com-63 150 16 national national JJ www-nature-com-63 150 17 level level NN www-nature-com-63 150 18 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 150 19 of of IN www-nature-com-63 150 20 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 150 21 countries country NNS www-nature-com-63 150 22 as as RB www-nature-com-63 150 23 well well RB www-nature-com-63 150 24 as as IN www-nature-com-63 150 25 to to IN www-nature-com-63 150 26 the the DT www-nature-com-63 150 27 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 150 28 of of IN www-nature-com-63 150 29 domestic domestic JJ www-nature-com-63 150 30 cities city NNS www-nature-com-63 150 31 and and CC www-nature-com-63 150 32 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 150 33 sectors sector NNS www-nature-com-63 150 34 in in IN www-nature-com-63 150 35 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 150 36 . . . www-nature-com-63 151 1 Annual annual JJ www-nature-com-63 151 2 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 151 3 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 151 4 and and CC www-nature-com-63 151 5 ranking rank VBG www-nature-com-63 151 6 by by IN www-nature-com-63 151 7 countries country NNS www-nature-com-63 151 8 a a DT www-nature-com-63 151 9 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 151 10 obtained obtain VBN www-nature-com-63 151 11 from from IN www-nature-com-63 151 12 cia.gov cia.gov NNP www-nature-com-63 151 13 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 151 14 www.cia.gov www.cia.gov NNP www-nature-com-63 151 15 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 151 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 151 17 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 151 18 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 151 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 151 20 ranking rank VBG www-nature-com-63 151 21 by by IN www-nature-com-63 151 22 countries country NNS www-nature-com-63 151 23 b b LS www-nature-com-63 151 24 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 151 25 collected collect VBN www-nature-com-63 151 26 from from IN www-nature-com-63 151 27 global global JJ www-nature-com-63 151 28 carbonatlas carbonatla NNS www-nature-com-63 151 29 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 151 30 www.globalcarbonatlas.org www.globalcarbonatlas.org NNP www-nature-com-63 151 31 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 151 32 . . . www-nature-com-63 152 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 152 2 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 152 3 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 152 4 by by IN www-nature-com-63 152 5 Chinese chinese JJ www-nature-com-63 152 6 cities city NNS www-nature-com-63 152 7 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 152 8 c c NN www-nature-com-63 152 9 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 152 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 152 11 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 152 12 sectors sector NNS www-nature-com-63 152 13 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 152 14 d d NNP www-nature-com-63 152 15 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 152 16 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 152 17 obtained obtain VBN www-nature-com-63 152 18 from from IN www-nature-com-63 152 19 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 152 20 Emission Emission NNP www-nature-com-63 152 21 Accounts Accounts NNPS www-nature-com-63 152 22 and and CC www-nature-com-63 152 23 Datasets Datasets NNPS www-nature-com-63 152 24 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 152 25 www.ceads.net www.ceads.net NN www-nature-com-63 152 26 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 152 27 . . . www-nature-com-63 153 1 Due due IN www-nature-com-63 153 2 to to IN www-nature-com-63 153 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 153 4 unreleased unreleased JJ www-nature-com-63 153 5 or or CC www-nature-com-63 153 6 missing miss VBG www-nature-com-63 153 7 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 153 8 in in IN www-nature-com-63 153 9 some some DT www-nature-com-63 153 10 database database NN www-nature-com-63 153 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 153 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 153 13 above above JJ www-nature-com-63 153 14 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 153 15 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 153 16 and and CC www-nature-com-63 153 17 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 153 18 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 153 19 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 153 20 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 153 21 obtained obtain VBN www-nature-com-63 153 22 for for IN www-nature-com-63 153 23 2016 2016 CD www-nature-com-63 153 24 level level NN www-nature-com-63 153 25 . . . www-nature-com-63 154 1 ARTICLE article NN www-nature-com-63 154 2 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 154 3 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 154 4 | | CD www-nature-com-63 154 5 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 154 6 6 6 CD www-nature-com-63 154 7 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 154 8 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 154 9 | | CD www-nature-com-63 154 10 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 154 11 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 154 12 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 154 13 12:1938 12:1938 CD www-nature-com-63 154 14 | | CD www-nature-com-63 154 15 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 154 16 | | CD www-nature-com-63 154 17 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 154 18 http://www.cia.gov http://www.cia.gov CD www-nature-com-63 154 19 http://www.globalcarbonatlas.org http://www.globalcarbonatlas.org NN www-nature-com-63 154 20 http://www.ceads.net http://www.ceads.net NNP www-nature-com-63 154 21 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 154 22 relocated relocate VBN www-nature-com-63 154 23 to to TO www-nature-com-63 154 24 conduct conduct VB www-nature-com-63 154 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 154 26 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 154 27 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 154 28 in in IN www-nature-com-63 154 29 the the DT www-nature-com-63 154 30 hydro hydro NNP www-nature-com-63 154 31 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 154 32 rich rich JJ www-nature-com-63 154 33 area area NN www-nature-com-63 154 34 in in IN www-nature-com-63 154 35 the the DT www-nature-com-63 154 36 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 154 37 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 154 38 . . . www-nature-com-63 155 1 Consequently consequently RB www-nature-com-63 155 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 155 3 this this DT www-nature-com-63 155 4 naturally naturally RB www-nature-com-63 155 5 lowers lower VBZ www-nature-com-63 155 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 155 7 associated associated NNP www-nature-com-63 155 8 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 155 9 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 155 10 cost cost VBN www-nature-com-63 155 11 in in IN www-nature-com-63 155 12 comparison comparison NN www-nature-com-63 155 13 to to IN www-nature-com-63 155 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 155 15 BM BM NNP www-nature-com-63 155 16 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 155 17 . . . www-nature-com-63 156 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 156 2 general general JJ www-nature-com-63 156 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 156 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 156 5 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 156 6 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 156 7 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 156 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 156 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 156 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 156 11 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 156 12 still still RB www-nature-com-63 156 13 far far RB www-nature-com-63 156 14 exceeds exceed VBZ www-nature-com-63 156 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 156 16 average average JJ www-nature-com-63 156 17 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 156 18 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 156 19 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 156 20 of of IN www-nature-com-63 156 21 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 156 22 under under IN www-nature-com-63 156 23 different different JJ www-nature-com-63 156 24 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 156 25 interventions intervention NNS www-nature-com-63 156 26 , , , www-nature-com-63 156 27 including include VBG www-nature-com-63 156 28 limiting limit VBG www-nature-com-63 156 29 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 156 30 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 156 31 access access NN www-nature-com-63 156 32 , , , www-nature-com-63 156 33 altering alter VBG www-nature-com-63 156 34 the the DT www-nature-com-63 156 35 miner miner NNP www-nature-com-63 156 36 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 156 37 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 156 38 structure structure NN www-nature-com-63 156 39 and and CC www-nature-com-63 156 40 implementing implement VBG www-nature-com-63 156 41 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 156 42 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 156 43 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 156 44 . . . www-nature-com-63 157 1 This this DT www-nature-com-63 157 2 result result NN www-nature-com-63 157 3 indicates indicate VBZ www-nature-com-63 157 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 157 5 stable stable JJ www-nature-com-63 157 6 high high JJ www-nature-com-63 157 7 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 157 8 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 157 9 property property NN www-nature-com-63 157 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 157 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 157 12 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 157 13 operations operation NNS www-nature-com-63 157 14 . . . www-nature-com-63 158 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB www-nature-com-63 158 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 158 3 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 158 4 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 158 5 rather rather RB www-nature-com-63 158 6 surprising surprising JJ www-nature-com-63 158 7 to to TO www-nature-com-63 158 8 arrive arrive VB www-nature-com-63 158 9 at at IN www-nature-com-63 158 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 158 11 conclusion conclusion NN www-nature-com-63 158 12 that that IN www-nature-com-63 158 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 158 14 newly newly RB www-nature-com-63 158 15 introduced introduce VBN www-nature-com-63 158 16 cryptocurrency cryptocurrency NN www-nature-com-63 158 17 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 158 18 on on IN www-nature-com-63 158 19 disruptive disruptive JJ www-nature-com-63 158 20 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 158 21 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 158 22 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 158 23 expected expect VBN www-nature-com-63 158 24 to to TO www-nature-com-63 158 25 become become VB www-nature-com-63 158 26 an an DT www-nature-com-63 158 27 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 158 28 and and CC www-nature-com-63 158 29 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 158 30 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 158 31 intensive intensive JJ www-nature-com-63 158 32 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 158 33 in in IN www-nature-com-63 158 34 the the DT www-nature-com-63 158 35 near near JJ www-nature-com-63 158 36 future future NN www-nature-com-63 158 37 . . . www-nature-com-63 159 1 Discussion discussion NN www-nature-com-63 159 2 The the DT www-nature-com-63 159 3 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 159 4 Proof proof NN www-nature-com-63 159 5 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 159 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 159 7 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 159 8 Work work NN www-nature-com-63 159 9 consensus consensus NN www-nature-com-63 159 10 algorithm algorithm NN www-nature-com-63 159 11 used use VBN www-nature-com-63 159 12 in in IN www-nature-com-63 159 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 159 14 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 159 15 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 159 16 can can MD www-nature-com-63 159 17 potentially potentially RB www-nature-com-63 159 18 undermine undermine VB www-nature-com-63 159 19 the the DT www-nature-com-63 159 20 wide wide JJ www-nature-com-63 159 21 imple- imple- NN www-nature-com-63 159 22 mentation mentation NN www-nature-com-63 159 23 and and CC www-nature-com-63 159 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 159 25 operational operational JJ www-nature-com-63 159 26 sustainability sustainability NN www-nature-com-63 159 27 of of IN www-nature-com-63 159 28 the the DT www-nature-com-63 159 29 disruptive disruptive JJ www-nature-com-63 159 30 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 159 31 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 159 32 . . . www-nature-com-63 160 1 Overall overall JJ www-nature-com-63 160 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 160 3 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 160 4 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 160 5 a a DT www-nature-com-63 160 6 typical typical JJ www-nature-com-63 160 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 160 8 pioneer- pioneer- JJ www-nature-com-63 160 9 ing ing NN www-nature-com-63 160 10 implementation implementation NN www-nature-com-63 160 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 160 12 blockchain blockchain JJ www-nature-com-63 160 13 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 160 14 . . . www-nature-com-63 161 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 161 2 decentralized decentralized JJ www-nature-com-63 161 3 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 161 4 characteristics characteristic NNS www-nature-com-63 161 5 and and CC www-nature-com-63 161 6 consensus consensus NN www-nature-com-63 161 7 algorithm algorithm NNP www-nature-com-63 161 8 provide provide VBP www-nature-com-63 161 9 a a DT www-nature-com-63 161 10 novel novel JJ www-nature-com-63 161 11 solution solution NN www-nature-com-63 161 12 for for IN www-nature-com-63 161 13 trust trust NN www-nature-com-63 161 14 mechanism mechanism NN www-nature-com-63 161 15 construction construction NN www-nature-com-63 161 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 161 17 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 161 18 can can MD www-nature-com-63 161 19 be be VB www-nature-com-63 161 20 beneficial beneficial JJ www-nature-com-63 161 21 and and CC www-nature-com-63 161 22 innovative innovative JJ www-nature-com-63 161 23 for for IN www-nature-com-63 161 24 a a DT www-nature-com-63 161 25 variety variety NN www-nature-com-63 161 26 of of IN www-nature-com-63 161 27 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 161 28 development development NN www-nature-com-63 161 29 and and CC www-nature-com-63 161 30 remote remote JJ www-nature-com-63 161 31 transactions transaction NNS www-nature-com-63 161 32 . . . www-nature-com-63 162 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 162 2 recent recent JJ www-nature-com-63 162 3 years year NNS www-nature-com-63 162 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 162 5 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 162 6 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 162 7 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 162 8 been be VBN www-nature-com-63 162 9 introduced introduce VBN www-nature-com-63 162 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 162 11 adopted adopt VBN www-nature-com-63 162 12 by by IN www-nature-com-63 162 13 abundant abundant JJ www-nature-com-63 162 14 traditional traditional JJ www-nature-com-63 162 15 industries industry NNS www-nature-com-63 162 16 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 162 17 seek seek VBP www-nature-com-63 162 18 to to TO www-nature-com-63 162 19 optimize optimize VB www-nature-com-63 162 20 their -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 162 21 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 162 22 process process NN www-nature-com-63 162 23 in in IN www-nature-com-63 162 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 162 25 real real JJ www-nature-com-63 162 26 world28 world28 CD www-nature-com-63 162 27 , , , www-nature-com-63 162 28 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 162 29 as as IN www-nature-com-63 162 30 supply supply NN www-nature-com-63 162 31 chain chain NN www-nature-com-63 162 32 finance29 finance29 NNP www-nature-com-63 162 33 , , , www-nature-com-63 162 34 smart smart JJ www-nature-com-63 162 35 contract30 contract30 NNP www-nature-com-63 162 36 , , , www-nature-com-63 162 37 international international JJ www-nature-com-63 162 38 business business NN www-nature-com-63 162 39 and and CC www-nature-com-63 162 40 trade31 trade31 NNP www-nature-com-63 162 41 , , , www-nature-com-63 162 42 as as RB www-nature-com-63 162 43 well well RB www-nature-com-63 162 44 as as IN www-nature-com-63 162 45 manufacturing manufacturing NN www-nature-com-63 162 46 operations32 operations32 NNP www-nature-com-63 162 47 . . . www-nature-com-63 163 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 163 2 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 163 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 163 4 a a DT www-nature-com-63 163 5 national national JJ www-nature-com-63 163 6 digital digital JJ www-nature-com-63 163 7 currency currency NN www-nature-com-63 163 8 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 163 9 on on IN www-nature-com-63 163 10 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 163 11 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 163 12 , , , www-nature-com-63 163 13 namely namely RB www-nature-com-63 163 14 Digital Digital NNP www-nature-com-63 163 15 Currency Currency NNP www-nature-com-63 163 16 Electronic Electronic NNP www-nature-com-63 163 17 Pay- Pay- NNP www-nature-com-63 163 18 ment ment NN www-nature-com-63 163 19 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 163 20 DCEP DCEP NNP www-nature-com-63 163 21 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 163 22 , , , www-nature-com-63 163 23 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 163 24 scheduled schedule VBN www-nature-com-63 163 25 and and CC www-nature-com-63 163 26 designed design VBN www-nature-com-63 163 27 by by IN www-nature-com-63 163 28 The the DT www-nature-com-63 163 29 People People NNPS www-nature-com-63 163 30 ’s ’s NNP www-nature-com-63 163 31 Bank Bank NNP www-nature-com-63 163 32 of of IN www-nature-com-63 163 33 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 163 34 , , , www-nature-com-63 163 35 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 163 36 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 163 37 expected expect VBN www-nature-com-63 163 38 to to TO www-nature-com-63 163 39 replace replace VB www-nature-com-63 163 40 the the DT www-nature-com-63 163 41 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 163 42 paper paper NN www-nature-com-63 163 43 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 163 44 currency- currency- NN www-nature-com-63 163 45 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 163 46 M0 M0 NNP www-nature-com-63 163 47 supply supply NN www-nature-com-63 163 48 in in IN www-nature-com-63 163 49 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 163 50 . . . www-nature-com-63 164 1 However however RB www-nature-com-63 164 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 164 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 164 4 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 164 5 consensus consensus NN www-nature-com-63 164 6 algorithm algorithm NN www-nature-com-63 164 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 164 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 164 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 164 10 namely namely RB www-nature-com-63 164 11 Proof Proof NNP www-nature-com-63 164 12 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 164 13 of of IN www-nature-com-63 164 14 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 164 15 Work work NN www-nature-com-63 164 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 164 17 gives give VBZ www-nature-com-63 164 18 rise rise NN www-nature-com-63 164 19 to to IN www-nature-com-63 164 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 164 21 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 164 22 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 164 23 competitions competition NNS www-nature-com-63 164 24 among among IN www-nature-com-63 164 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 164 26 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 164 27 for for IN www-nature-com-63 164 28 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 164 29 potential potential JJ www-nature-com-63 164 30 block block NN www-nature-com-63 164 31 reward reward NN www-nature-com-63 164 32 , , , www-nature-com-63 164 33 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 164 34 attracts attract VBZ www-nature-com-63 164 35 an an DT www-nature-com-63 164 36 increasing increase VBG www-nature-com-63 164 37 number number NN www-nature-com-63 164 38 of of IN www-nature-com-63 164 39 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 164 40 to to TO www-nature-com-63 164 41 engage engage VB www-nature-com-63 164 42 in in IN www-nature-com-63 164 43 an an DT www-nature-com-63 164 44 arms arm NNS www-nature-com-63 164 45 race race NN www-nature-com-63 164 46 and and CC www-nature-com-63 164 47 raise raise VB www-nature-com-63 164 48 the the DT www-nature-com-63 164 49 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 164 50 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 164 51 volumes volume NNS www-nature-com-63 164 52 of of IN www-nature-com-63 164 53 the the DT www-nature-com-63 164 54 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 164 55 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 164 56 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 164 57 . . . www-nature-com-63 165 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 165 2 a a DT www-nature-com-63 165 3 result result NN www-nature-com-63 165 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 165 5 although although IN www-nature-com-63 165 6 PoW pow NN www-nature-com-63 165 7 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 165 8 designed design VBN www-nature-com-63 165 9 to to TO www-nature-com-63 165 10 decentralize decentralize VB www-nature-com-63 165 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 165 12 transactions transaction NNS www-nature-com-63 165 13 and and CC www-nature-com-63 165 14 prevent prevent VB www-nature-com-63 165 15 inflation inflation NN www-nature-com-63 165 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 165 17 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 165 18 find find VBP www-nature-com-63 165 19 that that IN www-nature-com-63 165 20 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 165 21 would would MD www-nature-com-63 165 22 become become VB www-nature-com-63 165 23 an an DT www-nature-com-63 165 24 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 165 25 and and CC www-nature-com-63 165 26 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 165 27 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 165 28 intensive intensive JJ www-nature-com-63 165 29 protocol protocol NN www-nature-com-63 165 30 , , , www-nature-com-63 165 31 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 165 32 eventually eventually RB www-nature-com-63 165 33 leads lead VBZ www-nature-com-63 165 34 to to IN www-nature-com-63 165 35 the the DT www-nature-com-63 165 36 high high JJ www-nature-com-63 165 37 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 165 38 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 165 39 patterns pattern NNS www-nature-com-63 165 40 of of IN www-nature-com-63 165 41 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 165 42 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 165 43 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 165 44 in in IN www-nature-com-63 165 45 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 165 46 . . . www-nature-com-63 166 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 166 2 evidence evidence NN www-nature-com-63 166 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 166 4 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 166 5 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 166 6 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 166 7 suggests suggest VBZ www-nature-com-63 166 8 that that IN www-nature-com-63 166 9 with with IN www-nature-com-63 166 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 166 11 broaden broaden NN www-nature-com-63 166 12 usages usage NNS www-nature-com-63 166 13 and and CC www-nature-com-63 166 14 applications application NNS www-nature-com-63 166 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 166 16 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 166 17 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 166 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 166 19 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 166 20 protocols protocol NNS www-nature-com-63 166 21 should should MD www-nature-com-63 166 22 be be VB www-nature-com-63 166 23 designed design VBN www-nature-com-63 166 24 and and CC www-nature-com-63 166 25 scheduled schedule VBN www-nature-com-63 166 26 in in IN www-nature-com-63 166 27 an an DT www-nature-com-63 166 28 environmentally environmentally RB www-nature-com-63 166 29 friendly friendly JJ www-nature-com-63 166 30 manner manner NN www-nature-com-63 166 31 . . . www-nature-com-63 167 1 This this DT www-nature-com-63 167 2 change change NN www-nature-com-63 167 3 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 167 4 necessary necessary JJ www-nature-com-63 167 5 to to TO www-nature-com-63 167 6 ensure ensure VB www-nature-com-63 167 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 167 8 sustainability sustainability NN www-nature-com-63 167 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 167 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 167 11 network network NN www-nature-com-63 167 12 — — : www-nature-com-63 167 13 after after RB www-nature-com-63 167 14 all all RB www-nature-com-63 167 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 167 16 no no DT www-nature-com-63 167 17 one one NN www-nature-com-63 167 18 wants want VBZ www-nature-com-63 167 19 to to TO www-nature-com-63 167 20 witness witness VB www-nature-com-63 167 21 a a DT www-nature-com-63 167 22 disruptive disruptive JJ www-nature-com-63 167 23 and and CC www-nature-com-63 167 24 promising promising JJ www-nature-com-63 167 25 technique technique NN www-nature-com-63 167 26 to to TO www-nature-com-63 167 27 become become VB www-nature-com-63 167 28 a a DT www-nature-com-63 167 29 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 167 30 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 167 31 intensive intensive JJ www-nature-com-63 167 32 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 167 33 that that WDT www-nature-com-63 167 34 hinders hinder VBZ www-nature-com-63 167 35 the the DT www-nature-com-63 167 36 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 167 37 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 167 38 reduction reduction NN www-nature-com-63 167 39 efforts effort NNS www-nature-com-63 167 40 around around IN www-nature-com-63 167 41 the the DT www-nature-com-63 167 42 world world NN www-nature-com-63 167 43 . . . www-nature-com-63 168 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 168 2 auditable auditable JJ www-nature-com-63 168 3 and and CC www-nature-com-63 168 4 decentralized decentralize VBD www-nature-com-63 168 5 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 168 6 properties property NNS www-nature-com-63 168 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 168 8 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 168 9 provide provide VBP www-nature-com-63 168 10 a a DT www-nature-com-63 168 11 novel novel JJ www-nature-com-63 168 12 solution solution NN www-nature-com-63 168 13 for for IN www-nature-com-63 168 14 trust trust NN www-nature-com-63 168 15 mechanism mechanism NN www-nature-com-63 168 16 construction construction NN www-nature-com-63 168 17 , , , www-nature-com-63 168 18 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 168 19 can can MD www-nature-com-63 168 20 be be VB www-nature-com-63 168 21 bene- bene- VBN www-nature-com-63 168 22 ficial ficial JJ www-nature-com-63 168 23 and and CC www-nature-com-63 168 24 innovative innovative JJ www-nature-com-63 168 25 for for IN www-nature-com-63 168 26 a a DT www-nature-com-63 168 27 variety variety NN www-nature-com-63 168 28 of of IN www-nature-com-63 168 29 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 168 30 development development NN www-nature-com-63 168 31 and and CC www-nature-com-63 168 32 remote remote JJ www-nature-com-63 168 33 transactions transaction NNS www-nature-com-63 168 34 . . . www-nature-com-63 169 1 However however RB www-nature-com-63 169 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 169 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 169 4 high high JJ www-nature-com-63 169 5 GHG GHG NNP www-nature-com-63 169 6 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 169 7 behavior behavior NN www-nature-com-63 169 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 169 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 169 10 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 169 11 may may MD www-nature-com-63 169 12 pose pose VB www-nature-com-63 169 13 a a DT www-nature-com-63 169 14 barrier barrier NN www-nature-com-63 169 15 to to IN www-nature-com-63 169 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 169 17 worldwide worldwide JJ www-nature-com-63 169 18 effort effort NN www-nature-com-63 169 19 on on IN www-nature-com-63 169 20 GHG GHG NNP www-nature-com-63 169 21 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 169 22 management management NN www-nature-com-63 169 23 in in IN www-nature-com-63 169 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 169 25 near near JJ www-nature-com-63 169 26 future future NN www-nature-com-63 169 27 . . . www-nature-com-63 170 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 170 2 a a DT www-nature-com-63 170 3 result result NN www-nature-com-63 170 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 170 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 170 6 above above JJ www-nature-com-63 170 7 tradeoff tradeoff NN www-nature-com-63 170 8 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 170 9 worthy worthy JJ www-nature-com-63 170 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 170 11 future future JJ www-nature-com-63 170 12 exploration exploration NN www-nature-com-63 170 13 and and CC www-nature-com-63 170 14 investigation investigation NN www-nature-com-63 170 15 . . . www-nature-com-63 171 1 Different different JJ www-nature-com-63 171 2 from from IN www-nature-com-63 171 3 traditional traditional JJ www-nature-com-63 171 4 industries industry NNS www-nature-com-63 171 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 171 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 171 7 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 171 8 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 171 9 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 171 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 171 11 emerging emerge VBG www-nature-com-63 171 12 industries industry NNS www-nature-com-63 171 13 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 171 14 as as IN www-nature-com-63 171 15 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 171 16 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 171 17 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 171 18 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 171 19 unaccounted unaccounted JJ www-nature-com-63 171 20 for for IN www-nature-com-63 171 21 in in IN www-nature-com-63 171 22 the the DT www-nature-com-63 171 23 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 171 24 GDP gdp NN www-nature-com-63 171 25 and and CC www-nature-com-63 171 26 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 171 27 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 171 28 cal- cal- NN www-nature-com-63 171 29 culations culation NNS www-nature-com-63 171 30 . . . www-nature-com-63 172 1 Without without IN www-nature-com-63 172 2 proper proper JJ www-nature-com-63 172 3 accounting accounting NN www-nature-com-63 172 4 and and CC www-nature-com-63 172 5 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 172 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 172 7 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 172 8 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 172 9 rather rather RB www-nature-com-63 172 10 challenging challenge VBG www-nature-com-63 172 11 to to TO www-nature-com-63 172 12 assess assess VB www-nature-com-63 172 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 172 14 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 172 15 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 172 16 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 172 17 of of IN www-nature-com-63 172 18 these these DT www-nature-com-63 172 19 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 172 20 industries industry NNS www-nature-com-63 172 21 using use VBG www-nature-com-63 172 22 traditional traditional JJ www-nature-com-63 172 23 tools tool NNS www-nature-com-63 172 24 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 172 25 as as IN www-nature-com-63 172 26 input input NN www-nature-com-63 172 27 – – : www-nature-com-63 172 28 output output NN www-nature-com-63 172 29 analysis analysis NN www-nature-com-63 172 30 . . . www-nature-com-63 173 1 Through through IN www-nature-com-63 173 2 system system NN www-nature-com-63 173 3 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 173 4 modeling modeling NN www-nature-com-63 173 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 173 6 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 173 7 analysis analysis NN www-nature-com-63 173 8 constructs construct VBZ www-nature-com-63 173 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 173 10 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 173 11 feedback feedback NN www-nature-com-63 173 12 loops loop NNS www-nature-com-63 173 13 as as RB www-nature-com-63 173 14 well well RB www-nature-com-63 173 15 as as IN www-nature-com-63 173 16 captures capture VBZ www-nature-com-63 173 17 the the DT www-nature-com-63 173 18 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 173 19 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 173 20 patterns pattern NNS www-nature-com-63 173 21 . . . www-nature-com-63 174 1 Furthermore furthermore RB www-nature-com-63 174 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 174 3 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 174 4 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 174 5 able able JJ www-nature-com-63 174 6 to to TO www-nature-com-63 174 7 conduct conduct VB www-nature-com-63 174 8 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 174 9 assess- assess- IN www-nature-com-63 174 10 ment ment JJ www-nature-com-63 174 11 and and CC www-nature-com-63 174 12 evaluate evaluate VB www-nature-com-63 174 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 174 14 effectiveness effectiveness NN www-nature-com-63 174 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 174 16 various various JJ www-nature-com-63 174 17 potential potential JJ www-nature-com-63 174 18 imple- imple- NNS www-nature-com-63 174 19 mentable mentable JJ www-nature-com-63 174 20 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 174 21 . . . www-nature-com-63 175 1 Through through IN www-nature-com-63 175 2 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 175 3 analysis analysis NN www-nature-com-63 175 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 175 5 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 175 6 show show VBP www-nature-com-63 175 7 that that IN www-nature-com-63 175 8 moving move VBG www-nature-com-63 175 9 away away RB www-nature-com-63 175 10 from from IN www-nature-com-63 175 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 175 12 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 175 13 punitive punitive JJ www-nature-com-63 175 14 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 175 15 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 175 16 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 175 17 con- con- NN www-nature-com-63 175 18 sensus sensu VBD www-nature-com-63 175 19 to to IN www-nature-com-63 175 20 a a DT www-nature-com-63 175 21 site site NN www-nature-com-63 175 22 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 175 23 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 175 24 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 175 25 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 175 26 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 175 27 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 175 28 induces induce VBZ www-nature-com-63 175 29 changes change NNS www-nature-com-63 175 30 in in IN www-nature-com-63 175 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 175 32 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 175 33 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 175 34 structure structure NN www-nature-com-63 175 35 of of IN www-nature-com-63 175 36 the the DT www-nature-com-63 175 37 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 175 38 activities activity NNS www-nature-com-63 175 39 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 175 40 more more RBR www-nature-com-63 175 41 effective effective JJ www-nature-com-63 175 42 in in IN www-nature-com-63 175 43 limiting limit VBG www-nature-com-63 175 44 the the DT www-nature-com-63 175 45 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 175 46 amount amount NN www-nature-com-63 175 47 of of IN www-nature-com-63 175 48 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 175 49 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 175 50 of of IN www-nature-com-63 175 51 Bit- Bit- NNP www-nature-com-63 175 52 coin coin NNP www-nature-com-63 175 53 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 175 54 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 175 55 . . . www-nature-com-63 176 1 Overall overall RB www-nature-com-63 176 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 176 3 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 176 4 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 176 5 have have VBP www-nature-com-63 176 6 demonstrated demonstrate VBN www-nature-com-63 176 7 that that IN www-nature-com-63 176 8 system system NN www-nature-com-63 176 9 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 176 10 modeling modeling NN www-nature-com-63 176 11 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 176 12 a a DT www-nature-com-63 176 13 promising promising JJ www-nature-com-63 176 14 approach approach NN www-nature-com-63 176 15 to to TO www-nature-com-63 176 16 investigate investigate VB www-nature-com-63 176 17 the the DT www-nature-com-63 176 18 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 176 19 flow flow NN www-nature-com-63 176 20 mechanisms mechanism NNS www-nature-com-63 176 21 in in IN www-nature-com-63 176 22 emerging emerge VBG www-nature-com-63 176 23 industries industry NNS www-nature-com-63 176 24 . . . www-nature-com-63 177 1 At at IN www-nature-com-63 177 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 177 3 same same JJ www-nature-com-63 177 4 time time NN www-nature-com-63 177 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 177 6 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 177 7 acknowledge acknowledge VBP www-nature-com-63 177 8 there there EX www-nature-com-63 177 9 exists exist VBZ www-nature-com-63 177 10 some some DT www-nature-com-63 177 11 limitations limitation NNS www-nature-com-63 177 12 to to IN www-nature-com-63 177 13 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 177 14 study study NN www-nature-com-63 177 15 and and CC www-nature-com-63 177 16 outline outline VB www-nature-com-63 177 17 future future JJ www-nature-com-63 177 18 directions direction NNS www-nature-com-63 177 19 for for IN www-nature-com-63 177 20 research research NN www-nature-com-63 177 21 . . . www-nature-com-63 178 1 First first RB www-nature-com-63 178 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 178 3 to to TO www-nature-com-63 178 4 reflect reflect VB www-nature-com-63 178 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 178 6 true true JJ www-nature-com-63 178 7 designed design VBN www-nature-com-63 178 8 fundamental fundamental JJ www-nature-com-63 178 9 value value NN www-nature-com-63 178 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 178 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 178 12 as as IN www-nature-com-63 178 13 intended intend VBN www-nature-com-63 178 14 by by IN www-nature-com-63 178 15 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-nature-com-63 178 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 178 17 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 178 18 model model NN www-nature-com-63 178 19 assumes assume VBZ www-nature-com-63 178 20 that that IN www-nature-com-63 178 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 178 22 long long JJ www-nature-com-63 178 23 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 178 24 term term NN www-nature-com-63 178 25 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 178 26 price price NN www-nature-com-63 178 27 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 178 28 primarily primarily RB www-nature-com-63 178 29 influenced influence VBN www-nature-com-63 178 30 by by IN www-nature-com-63 178 31 halving halve VBG www-nature-com-63 178 32 mechanism mechanism NN www-nature-com-63 178 33 of of IN www-nature-com-63 178 34 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 178 35 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 178 36 rewards reward NNS www-nature-com-63 178 37 and and CC www-nature-com-63 178 38 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 178 39 subjected subject VBN www-nature-com-63 178 40 to to IN www-nature-com-63 178 41 a a DT www-nature-com-63 178 42 linear linear JJ www-nature-com-63 178 43 increase increase NN www-nature-com-63 178 44 every every DT www-nature-com-63 178 45 time time NN www-nature-com-63 178 46 a a DT www-nature-com-63 178 47 reward reward NN www-nature-com-63 178 48 halving halving NN www-nature-com-63 178 49 occurs occur VBZ www-nature-com-63 178 50 . . . www-nature-com-63 179 1 While while IN www-nature-com-63 179 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 179 3 historical historical JJ www-nature-com-63 179 4 average average JJ www-nature-com-63 179 5 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 179 6 price price NN www-nature-com-63 179 7 between between IN www-nature-com-63 179 8 each each DT www-nature-com-63 179 9 reward reward NN www-nature-com-63 179 10 halving halving NN www-nature-com-63 179 11 occurrence occurrence NN www-nature-com-63 179 12 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 179 13 generally generally RB www-nature-com-63 179 14 followed follow VBN www-nature-com-63 179 15 this this DT www-nature-com-63 179 16 pattern pattern NN www-nature-com-63 179 17 since since IN www-nature-com-63 179 18 2014 2014 CD www-nature-com-63 179 19 , , , www-nature-com-63 179 20 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 179 21 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 179 22 extremely extremely RB www-nature-com-63 179 23 volatile volatile JJ www-nature-com-63 179 24 in in IN www-nature-com-63 179 25 real real JJ www-nature-com-63 179 26 market market NN www-nature-com-63 179 27 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 179 28 and and CC www-nature-com-63 179 29 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 179 30 subjected subject VBN www-nature-com-63 179 31 to to IN www-nature-com-63 179 32 the the DT www-nature-com-63 179 33 influence influence NN www-nature-com-63 179 34 of of IN www-nature-com-63 179 35 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 179 36 factors factor NNS www-nature-com-63 179 37 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 179 38 as as IN www-nature-com-63 179 39 investor investor NN www-nature-com-63 179 40 expectations expectation NNS www-nature-com-63 179 41 . . . www-nature-com-63 180 1 Therefore therefore RB www-nature-com-63 180 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 180 3 a a DT www-nature-com-63 180 4 degree degree NN www-nature-com-63 180 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 180 6 uncertainty uncertainty NN www-nature-com-63 180 7 remains remain VBZ www-nature-com-63 180 8 as as IN www-nature-com-63 180 9 to to IN www-nature-com-63 180 10 whether whether IN www-nature-com-63 180 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 180 12 linearity linearity NN www-nature-com-63 180 13 price price NN www-nature-com-63 180 14 assumption assumption NN www-nature-com-63 180 15 would would MD www-nature-com-63 180 16 hold hold VB www-nature-com-63 180 17 , , , www-nature-com-63 180 18 parti- parti- VBN www-nature-com-63 180 19 cularly cularly RB www-nature-com-63 180 20 as as IN www-nature-com-63 180 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 180 22 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 180 23 market market NN www-nature-com-63 180 24 continues continue VBZ www-nature-com-63 180 25 to to TO www-nature-com-63 180 26 grow grow VB www-nature-com-63 180 27 into into IN www-nature-com-63 180 28 the the DT www-nature-com-63 180 29 future future NN www-nature-com-63 180 30 . . . www-nature-com-63 181 1 Furthermore furthermore RB www-nature-com-63 181 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 181 3 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 181 4 site site NN www-nature-com-63 181 5 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 181 6 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 181 7 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 181 8 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 181 9 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 181 10 assumes assume VBZ www-nature-com-63 181 11 no no DT www-nature-com-63 181 12 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 181 13 on on IN www-nature-com-63 181 14 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 181 15 from from IN www-nature-com-63 181 16 relocating relocate VBG www-nature-com-63 181 17 to to IN www-nature-com-63 181 18 clean clean JJ www-nature-com-63 181 19 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 181 20 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 181 21 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 181 22 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 181 23 regions region NNS www-nature-com-63 181 24 . . . www-nature-com-63 182 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 182 2 reality reality NN www-nature-com-63 182 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 182 4 there there EX www-nature-com-63 182 5 may may MD www-nature-com-63 182 6 be be VB www-nature-com-63 182 7 certain certain JJ www-nature-com-63 182 8 costs cost NNS www-nature-com-63 182 9 associated associate VBN www-nature-com-63 182 10 with with IN www-nature-com-63 182 11 this this DT www-nature-com-63 182 12 action action NN www-nature-com-63 182 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 182 14 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 182 15 as as IN www-nature-com-63 182 16 transportation transportation NN www-nature-com-63 182 17 . . . www-nature-com-63 183 1 Therefore therefore RB www-nature-com-63 183 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 183 3 although although IN www-nature-com-63 183 4 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 183 5 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 183 6 suggest suggest VBP www-nature-com-63 183 7 that that IN www-nature-com-63 183 8 a a DT www-nature-com-63 183 9 site site NN www-nature-com-63 183 10 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 183 11 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 183 12 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 183 13 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 183 14 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 183 15 may may MD www-nature-com-63 183 16 be be VB www-nature-com-63 183 17 more more RBR www-nature-com-63 183 18 effective effective JJ www-nature-com-63 183 19 that that IN www-nature-com-63 183 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 183 21 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 183 22 punitive punitive JJ www-nature-com-63 183 23 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 183 24 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 183 25 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 183 26 consensus consensus NN www-nature-com-63 183 27 in in IN www-nature-com-63 183 28 limiting limit VBG www-nature-com-63 183 29 the the DT www-nature-com-63 183 30 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 183 31 amount amount NN www-nature-com-63 183 32 of of IN www-nature-com-63 183 33 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 183 34 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 183 35 of of IN www-nature-com-63 183 36 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 183 37 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 183 38 operations operation NNS www-nature-com-63 183 39 , , , www-nature-com-63 183 40 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 183 41 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 183 42 important important JJ www-nature-com-63 183 43 to to TO www-nature-com-63 183 44 note note VB www-nature-com-63 183 45 that that IN www-nature-com-63 183 46 these these DT www-nature-com-63 183 47 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 183 48 simulations simulation NNS www-nature-com-63 183 49 arising arise VBG www-nature-com-63 183 50 from from IN www-nature-com-63 183 51 system system NN www-nature-com-63 183 52 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 183 53 modeling modeling NN www-nature-com-63 183 54 and and CC www-nature-com-63 183 55 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 183 56 limited limit VBN www-nature-com-63 183 57 by by IN www-nature-com-63 183 58 the the DT www-nature-com-63 183 59 assumptions assumption NNS www-nature-com-63 183 60 above above RB www-nature-com-63 183 61 . . . www-nature-com-63 184 1 Second second JJ www-nature-com-63 184 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 184 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 184 4 projected project VBN www-nature-com-63 184 5 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 184 6 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 184 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 184 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 184 9 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 184 10 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 184 11 related relate VBN www-nature-com-63 184 12 to to IN www-nature-com-63 184 13 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 184 14 production production NN www-nature-com-63 184 15 depends depend VBZ www-nature-com-63 184 16 on on IN www-nature-com-63 184 17 the the DT www-nature-com-63 184 18 source source NN www-nature-com-63 184 19 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 184 20 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 184 21 used use VBN www-nature-com-63 184 22 for for IN www-nature-com-63 184 23 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 184 24 generation generation NN www-nature-com-63 184 25 . . . www-nature-com-63 185 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 185 2 all all DT www-nature-com-63 185 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 185 4 except except IN www-nature-com-63 185 5 for for IN www-nature-com-63 185 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 185 7 Site Site NNP www-nature-com-63 185 8 Reg- Reg- NNP www-nature-com-63 185 9 ulation ulation NN www-nature-com-63 185 10 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 185 11 SR SR NNP www-nature-com-63 185 12 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 185 13 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 185 14 , , , www-nature-com-63 185 15 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 185 16 do do VBP www-nature-com-63 185 17 not not RB www-nature-com-63 185 18 consider consider VB www-nature-com-63 185 19 the the DT www-nature-com-63 185 20 potential potential JJ www-nature-com-63 185 21 changes change NNS www-nature-com-63 185 22 of of IN www-nature-com-63 185 23 the the DT www-nature-com-63 185 24 Chinese chinese JJ www-nature-com-63 185 25 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 185 26 sector sector NN www-nature-com-63 185 27 in in IN www-nature-com-63 185 28 the the DT www-nature-com-63 185 29 future future NN www-nature-com-63 185 30 , , , www-nature-com-63 185 31 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 185 32 implies imply VBZ www-nature-com-63 185 33 that that IN www-nature-com-63 185 34 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 185 35 would would MD www-nature-com-63 185 36 predominantly predominantly RB www-nature-com-63 185 37 operate operate VB www-nature-com-63 185 38 in in IN www-nature-com-63 185 39 the the DT www-nature-com-63 185 40 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 185 41 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 185 42 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 185 43 area area NN www-nature-com-63 185 44 . . . www-nature-com-63 186 1 While while IN www-nature-com-63 186 2 this this DT www-nature-com-63 186 3 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 186 4 certainly certainly RB www-nature-com-63 186 5 true true JJ www-nature-com-63 186 6 as as IN www-nature-com-63 186 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 186 8 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 186 9 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 186 10 mix mix NN www-nature-com-63 186 11 in in IN www-nature-com-63 186 12 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 186 13 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 186 14 heavily heavily RB www-nature-com-63 186 15 dominated dominate VBN www-nature-com-63 186 16 by by IN www-nature-com-63 186 17 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 186 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 186 19 a a DT www-nature-com-63 186 20 series series NN www-nature-com-63 186 21 of of IN www-nature-com-63 186 22 efforts effort NNS www-nature-com-63 186 23 to to TO www-nature-com-63 186 24 incentivise incentivise VB www-nature-com-63 186 25 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 186 26 production production NN www-nature-com-63 186 27 on on IN www-nature-com-63 186 28 the the DT www-nature-com-63 186 29 basis basis NN www-nature-com-63 186 30 of of IN www-nature-com-63 186 31 renewable renewable JJ www-nature-com-63 186 32 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 186 33 sources source NNS www-nature-com-63 186 34 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 186 35 www.iea.org www.iea.org NNP www-nature-com-63 186 36 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 186 37 and and CC www-nature-com-63 186 38 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 186 39 to to TO www-nature-com-63 186 40 increase increase VB www-nature-com-63 186 41 the the DT www-nature-com-63 186 42 price price NN www-nature-com-63 186 43 for for IN www-nature-com-63 186 44 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 186 45 generated generate VBN www-nature-com-63 186 46 on on IN www-nature-com-63 186 47 the the DT www-nature-com-63 186 48 basis basis NN www-nature-com-63 186 49 of of IN www-nature-com-63 186 50 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 186 51 have have VBP www-nature-com-63 186 52 been be VBN www-nature-com-63 186 53 implemented implement VBN www-nature-com-63 186 54 . . . www-nature-com-63 187 1 Consequently consequently RB www-nature-com-63 187 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 187 3 these these DT www-nature-com-63 187 4 renew- renew- NN www-nature-com-63 187 5 able able JJ www-nature-com-63 187 6 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 187 7 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 187 8 related relate VBN www-nature-com-63 187 9 efforts effort NNS www-nature-com-63 187 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 187 11 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 187 12 can can MD www-nature-com-63 187 13 potentially potentially RB www-nature-com-63 187 14 affect affect VB www-nature-com-63 187 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 187 16 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 187 17 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 187 18 and and CC www-nature-com-63 187 19 subsequently subsequently RB www-nature-com-63 187 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 187 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 187 22 amount amount NN www-nature-com-63 187 23 of of IN www-nature-com-63 187 24 related related JJ www-nature-com-63 187 25 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 187 26 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 187 27 generated generate VBN www-nature-com-63 187 28 from from IN www-nature-com-63 187 29 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 187 30 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 187 31 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 187 32 . . . www-nature-com-63 188 1 Third third JJ www-nature-com-63 188 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 188 3 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 188 4 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 188 5 important important JJ www-nature-com-63 188 6 to to TO www-nature-com-63 188 7 note note VB www-nature-com-63 188 8 that that IN www-nature-com-63 188 9 although although IN www-nature-com-63 188 10 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 188 11 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 188 12 suggest suggest VBP www-nature-com-63 188 13 that that IN www-nature-com-63 188 14 with with IN www-nature-com-63 188 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 188 16 broaden broaden NN www-nature-com-63 188 17 usage usage NN www-nature-com-63 188 18 and and CC www-nature-com-63 188 19 application application NN www-nature-com-63 188 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 188 21 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 188 22 tech- tech- NN www-nature-com-63 188 23 nology nology NN www-nature-com-63 188 24 could could MD www-nature-com-63 188 25 become become VB www-nature-com-63 188 26 a a DT www-nature-com-63 188 27 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 188 28 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 188 29 intensive intensive JJ www-nature-com-63 188 30 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 188 31 that that WDT www-nature-com-63 188 32 hinders hinder VBZ www-nature-com-63 188 33 the the DT www-nature-com-63 188 34 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 188 35 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 188 36 reduction reduction NN www-nature-com-63 188 37 efforts effort NNS www-nature-com-63 188 38 around around IN www-nature-com-63 188 39 the the DT www-nature-com-63 188 40 world world NN www-nature-com-63 188 41 , , , www-nature-com-63 188 42 as as IN www-nature-com-63 188 43 with with IN www-nature-com-63 188 44 any any DT www-nature-com-63 188 45 prediction prediction NN www-nature-com-63 188 46 model model NN www-nature-com-63 188 47 , , , www-nature-com-63 188 48 many many JJ www-nature-com-63 188 49 unforeseeable unforeseeable JJ www-nature-com-63 188 50 uncertainties uncertainty NNS www-nature-com-63 188 51 could could MD www-nature-com-63 188 52 happen happen VB www-nature-com-63 188 53 in in IN www-nature-com-63 188 54 the the DT www-nature-com-63 188 55 future future NN www-nature-com-63 188 56 that that WDT www-nature-com-63 188 57 could could MD www-nature-com-63 188 58 cause cause VB www-nature-com-63 188 59 the the DT www-nature-com-63 188 60 reality reality NN www-nature-com-63 188 61 to to TO www-nature-com-63 188 62 deviate deviate VB www-nature-com-63 188 63 from from IN www-nature-com-63 188 64 the the DT www-nature-com-63 188 65 prediction prediction NN www-nature-com-63 188 66 . . . www-nature-com-63 189 1 While while IN www-nature-com-63 189 2 it -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 189 3 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 189 4 true true JJ www-nature-com-63 189 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 189 6 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 189 7 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 189 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 189 9 and and CC www-nature-com-63 189 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 189 11 as as IN www-nature-com-63 189 12 one one CD www-nature-com-63 189 13 of of IN www-nature-com-63 189 14 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 189 15 applications application NNS www-nature-com-63 189 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 189 17 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 189 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 189 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 189 20 increasingly increasingly RB www-nature-com-63 189 21 will will MD www-nature-com-63 189 22 play play VB www-nature-com-63 189 23 a a DT www-nature-com-63 189 24 significant significant JJ www-nature-com-63 189 25 role role NN www-nature-com-63 189 26 in in IN www-nature-com-63 189 27 the the DT www-nature-com-63 189 28 economy economy NN www-nature-com-63 189 29 , , , www-nature-com-63 189 30 ultimately ultimately RB www-nature-com-63 189 31 , , , www-nature-com-63 189 32 the the DT www-nature-com-63 189 33 choice choice NN www-nature-com-63 189 34 of of IN www-nature-com-63 189 35 adopting adopt VBG www-nature-com-63 189 36 and and CC www-nature-com-63 189 37 using use VBG www-nature-com-63 189 38 this this DT www-nature-com-63 189 39 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 189 40 lies lie VBZ www-nature-com-63 189 41 in in IN www-nature-com-63 189 42 the the DT www-nature-com-63 189 43 hands hand NNS www-nature-com-63 189 44 of of IN www-nature-com-63 189 45 humans human NNS www-nature-com-63 189 46 . . . www-nature-com-63 190 1 Conse- Conse- NNP www-nature-com-63 190 2 quently quently RB www-nature-com-63 190 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 190 4 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 190 5 should should MD www-nature-com-63 190 6 carefully carefully RB www-nature-com-63 190 7 evaluate evaluate VB www-nature-com-63 190 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 190 9 trade trade NN www-nature-com-63 190 10 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 190 11 offs off NNS www-nature-com-63 190 12 before before IN www-nature-com-63 190 13 applying apply VBG www-nature-com-63 190 14 this this DT www-nature-com-63 190 15 promising promise VBG www-nature-com-63 190 16 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 190 17 to to IN www-nature-com-63 190 18 a a DT www-nature-com-63 190 19 variety variety NN www-nature-com-63 190 20 of of IN www-nature-com-63 190 21 industries industry NNS www-nature-com-63 190 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 191 1 Methods method NNS www-nature-com-63 191 2 This this DT www-nature-com-63 191 3 paper paper NN www-nature-com-63 191 4 constructs construct VBZ www-nature-com-63 191 5 a a DT www-nature-com-63 191 6 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 191 7 model model NN www-nature-com-63 191 8 to to TO www-nature-com-63 191 9 investigate investigate VB www-nature-com-63 191 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 191 11 feedback feedback NN www-nature-com-63 191 12 loops loop NNS www-nature-com-63 191 13 of of IN www-nature-com-63 191 14 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 191 15 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 191 16 and and CC www-nature-com-63 191 17 simulates simulate VBZ www-nature-com-63 191 18 the the DT www-nature-com-63 191 19 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 191 20 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 191 21 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 191 22 of of IN www-nature-com-63 191 23 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 191 24 operations operation NNS www-nature-com-63 191 25 in in IN www-nature-com-63 191 26 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 191 27 . . . www-nature-com-63 192 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 192 2 view view NN www-nature-com-63 192 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 192 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 192 5 complexity complexity NN www-nature-com-63 192 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 192 7 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 192 8 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 192 9 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 192 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 192 11 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 192 12 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 192 13 process process NN www-nature-com-63 192 14 , , , www-nature-com-63 192 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 192 16 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 192 17 modeling model VBG www-nature-com-63 192 18 for for IN www-nature-com-63 192 19 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 192 20 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 192 21 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 192 22 assessment assessment NN www-nature-com-63 192 23 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 192 24 mainly mainly RB www-nature-com-63 192 25 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 192 26 on on IN www-nature-com-63 192 27 the the DT www-nature-com-63 192 28 following follow VBG www-nature-com-63 192 29 assumptions assumption NNS www-nature-com-63 192 30 : : : www-nature-com-63 192 31 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 192 32 1 1 LS www-nature-com-63 192 33 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 192 34 The the DT www-nature-com-63 192 35 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 192 36 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 192 37 of of IN www-nature-com-63 192 38 the the DT www-nature-com-63 192 39 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 192 40 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 192 41 process process NN www-nature-com-63 192 42 mainly mainly RB www-nature-com-63 192 43 consists consist VBZ www-nature-com-63 192 44 of of IN www-nature-com-63 192 45 two two CD www-nature-com-63 192 46 types type NNS www-nature-com-63 192 47 of of IN www-nature-com-63 192 48 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 192 49 : : : www-nature-com-63 192 50 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 192 51 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 192 52 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 192 53 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 192 54 and and CC www-nature-com-63 192 55 hydro hydro NNP www-nature-com-63 192 56 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 192 57 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 192 58 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 192 59 . . . www-nature-com-63 193 1 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 193 2 2 2 LS www-nature-com-63 193 3 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 193 4 Bitcoin bitcoin NN www-nature-com-63 193 5 price price NN www-nature-com-63 193 6 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 193 7 extremely extremely RB www-nature-com-63 193 8 volatile volatile JJ www-nature-com-63 193 9 in in IN www-nature-com-63 193 10 real real JJ www-nature-com-63 193 11 market market NN www-nature-com-63 193 12 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 193 13 COMMUNICATIONS COMMUNICATIONS NNPS www-nature-com-63 193 14 | | CD www-nature-com-63 193 15 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 193 16 ARTICLE article NN www-nature-com-63 193 17 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 193 18 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 193 19 | | CD www-nature-com-63 193 20 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 193 21 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 193 22 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 193 23 12:1938 12:1938 CD www-nature-com-63 193 24 | | CD www-nature-com-63 193 25 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 193 26 | | CD www-nature-com-63 193 27 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 193 28 7 7 CD www-nature-com-63 193 29 http://www.iea.org http://www.iea.org NNP www-nature-com-63 193 30 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 193 31 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 193 32 operations operation NNS www-nature-com-63 193 33 , , , www-nature-com-63 193 34 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 193 35 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 193 36 inappropriate inappropriate JJ www-nature-com-63 193 37 for for IN www-nature-com-63 193 38 long long JJ www-nature-com-63 193 39 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 193 40 term term NN www-nature-com-63 193 41 assessment assessment NN www-nature-com-63 193 42 in in IN www-nature-com-63 193 43 the the DT www-nature-com-63 193 44 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 193 45 model model NN www-nature-com-63 193 46 . . . www-nature-com-63 194 1 Referring refer VBG www-nature-com-63 194 2 to to IN www-nature-com-63 194 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 194 4 historical historical JJ www-nature-com-63 194 5 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 194 6 price price NN www-nature-com-63 194 7 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 194 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 194 9 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 194 10 assume assume VBP www-nature-com-63 194 11 that that IN www-nature-com-63 194 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 194 13 long long JJ www-nature-com-63 194 14 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 194 15 term term NN www-nature-com-63 194 16 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 194 17 price price NN www-nature-com-63 194 18 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 194 19 mainly mainly RB www-nature-com-63 194 20 affected affect VBN www-nature-com-63 194 21 by by IN www-nature-com-63 194 22 the the DT www-nature-com-63 194 23 halving halve VBG www-nature-com-63 194 24 mechanism mechanism NN www-nature-com-63 194 25 of of IN www-nature-com-63 194 26 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 194 27 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 194 28 rewards reward NNS www-nature-com-63 194 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 195 1 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 195 2 3 3 LS www-nature-com-63 195 3 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 195 4 Miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 195 5 gradually gradually RB www-nature-com-63 195 6 stop stop VBP www-nature-com-63 195 7 or or CC www-nature-com-63 195 8 choose choose VB www-nature-com-63 195 9 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 195 10 destinations destination NNS www-nature-com-63 195 11 for for IN www-nature-com-63 195 12 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 195 13 if if IN www-nature-com-63 195 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 195 15 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 195 16 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 195 17 process process NN www-nature-com-63 195 18 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 195 19 no no DT www-nature-com-63 195 20 longer long RBR www-nature-com-63 195 21 profitable profitable JJ www-nature-com-63 195 22 in in IN www-nature-com-63 195 23 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 195 24 . . . www-nature-com-63 196 1 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 196 2 4 4 LS www-nature-com-63 196 3 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 196 4 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 196 5 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 196 6 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 196 7 consistent consistent JJ www-nature-com-63 196 8 with with IN www-nature-com-63 196 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 196 10 overall overall JJ www-nature-com-63 196 11 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 196 12 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 196 13 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 196 14 in in IN www-nature-com-63 196 15 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 196 16 . . . www-nature-com-63 197 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 197 2 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 197 3 words word NNS www-nature-com-63 197 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 197 5 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 197 6 such such JJ www-nature-com-63 197 7 as as IN www-nature-com-63 197 8 market market NN www-nature-com-63 197 9 access access NN www-nature-com-63 197 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 197 11 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 197 12 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 197 13 and and CC www-nature-com-63 197 14 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 197 15 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 197 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 197 17 the the DT www-nature-com-63 197 18 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 197 19 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 197 20 operations operation NNS www-nature-com-63 197 21 can can MD www-nature-com-63 197 22 be be VB www-nature-com-63 197 23 rejiggered rejiggere VBN www-nature-com-63 197 24 for for IN www-nature-com-63 197 25 different different JJ www-nature-com-63 197 26 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 197 27 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 197 28 levels level NNS www-nature-com-63 197 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 198 1 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 198 2 5 5 LS www-nature-com-63 198 3 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 198 4 Miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 198 5 maintain maintain VB www-nature-com-63 198 6 full full JJ www-nature-com-63 198 7 invest- invest- JJ www-nature-com-63 198 8 ment ment JJ www-nature-com-63 198 9 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 198 10 while while IN www-nature-com-63 198 11 in in IN www-nature-com-63 198 12 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 198 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 198 14 as as IN www-nature-com-63 198 15 any any DT www-nature-com-63 198 16 reduction reduction NN www-nature-com-63 198 17 in in IN www-nature-com-63 198 18 individual individual JJ www-nature-com-63 198 19 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 198 20 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 198 21 would would MD www-nature-com-63 198 22 put put VB www-nature-com-63 198 23 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 198 24 in in IN www-nature-com-63 198 25 disadvantage disadvantage NN www-nature-com-63 198 26 and and CC www-nature-com-63 198 27 jeopardize jeopardize VB www-nature-com-63 198 28 their -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 198 29 chances chance NNS www-nature-com-63 198 30 of of IN www-nature-com-63 198 31 mining mine VBG www-nature-com-63 198 32 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 198 33 blocks block NNS www-nature-com-63 198 34 and and CC www-nature-com-63 198 35 receiving receive VBG www-nature-com-63 198 36 the the DT www-nature-com-63 198 37 reward reward NN www-nature-com-63 198 38 . . . www-nature-com-63 199 1 By by IN www-nature-com-63 199 2 investigating investigate VBG www-nature-com-63 199 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 199 4 inner inner JJ www-nature-com-63 199 5 feedback feedback NN www-nature-com-63 199 6 loops loop NNS www-nature-com-63 199 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 199 8 causalities causality NNS www-nature-com-63 199 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 199 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 199 11 systems system NNS www-nature-com-63 199 12 , , , www-nature-com-63 199 13 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 199 14 modeling modeling NN www-nature-com-63 199 15 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 199 16 able able JJ www-nature-com-63 199 17 to to TO www-nature-com-63 199 18 capture capture VB www-nature-com-63 199 19 the the DT www-nature-com-63 199 20 corresponding correspond VBG www-nature-com-63 199 21 dynamic dynamic JJ www-nature-com-63 199 22 behaviors behavior NNS www-nature-com-63 199 23 of of IN www-nature-com-63 199 24 system system NN www-nature-com-63 199 25 vari- vari- NNP www-nature-com-63 199 26 ables able NNS www-nature-com-63 199 27 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 199 28 on on IN www-nature-com-63 199 29 proposed propose VBN www-nature-com-63 199 30 scenarios33,34 scenarios33,34 NNP www-nature-com-63 199 31 . . . www-nature-com-63 200 1 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 200 2 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 200 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 201 1 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 201 2 shows show VBZ www-nature-com-63 201 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 201 4 complete complete JJ www-nature-com-63 201 5 structure structure NN www-nature-com-63 201 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 201 7 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 201 8 modeling modeling NN www-nature-com-63 201 9 . . . www-nature-com-63 202 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 202 2 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 202 3 quantitative quantitative JJ www-nature-com-63 202 4 relationships relationship NNS www-nature-com-63 202 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 202 6 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 202 7 para- para- NNP www-nature-com-63 202 8 meters meter NNS www-nature-com-63 202 9 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 202 10 demonstrated demonstrate VBN www-nature-com-63 202 11 in in IN www-nature-com-63 202 12 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 202 13 Methods Methods NNPS www-nature-com-63 202 14 . . . www-nature-com-63 203 1 Utilizing utilize VBG www-nature-com-63 203 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 203 3 flow flow NN www-nature-com-63 203 4 diagram diagram NN www-nature-com-63 203 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 203 6 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 203 7 systems system NNS www-nature-com-63 203 8 illustrated illustrate VBN www-nature-com-63 203 9 in in IN www-nature-com-63 203 10 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 203 11 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 203 12 . . . www-nature-com-63 204 1 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 204 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 204 3 detailed detailed JJ www-nature-com-63 204 4 feedback feedback NN www-nature-com-63 204 5 loops loop NNS www-nature-com-63 204 6 and and CC www-nature-com-63 204 7 flows flow NNS www-nature-com-63 204 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 204 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 204 10 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 204 11 subsystems subsystem NNS www-nature-com-63 204 12 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 204 13 discussed discuss VBN www-nature-com-63 204 14 and and CC www-nature-com-63 204 15 clarified clarify VBN www-nature-com-63 204 16 . . . www-nature-com-63 205 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 205 2 types type NNS www-nature-com-63 205 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 205 4 definitions definition NNS www-nature-com-63 205 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 205 6 units unit NNS www-nature-com-63 205 7 , , , www-nature-com-63 205 8 and and CC www-nature-com-63 205 9 related related JJ www-nature-com-63 205 10 references reference NNS www-nature-com-63 205 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 205 12 each each DT www-nature-com-63 205 13 variable variable NN www-nature-com-63 205 14 in in IN www-nature-com-63 205 15 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 205 16 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 205 17 . . . www-nature-com-63 206 1 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 206 2 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 206 3 reported report VBN www-nature-com-63 206 4 in in IN www-nature-com-63 206 5 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 206 6 Table Table NNP www-nature-com-63 206 7 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 206 8 . . . www-nature-com-63 207 1 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 207 2 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 207 3 and and CC www-nature-com-63 207 4 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 207 5 subsystem subsystem NNP www-nature-com-63 207 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 208 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 208 2 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 208 3 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 208 4 utilizes utilize VBZ www-nature-com-63 208 5 Proof Proof NNP www-nature-com-63 208 6 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 208 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 208 8 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 208 9 Work work NN www-nature-com-63 208 10 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 208 11 PoW PoW NNP www-nature-com-63 208 12 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 208 13 consensus consensus NN www-nature-com-63 208 14 algorithm algorithm NN www-nature-com-63 208 15 for for IN www-nature-com-63 208 16 generating generate VBG www-nature-com-63 208 17 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 208 18 blocks block NNS www-nature-com-63 208 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 208 20 vali- vali- NN www-nature-com-63 208 21 dating date VBG www-nature-com-63 208 22 transactions transaction NNS www-nature-com-63 208 23 . . . www-nature-com-63 209 1 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 209 2 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 209 3 earn earn VBP www-nature-com-63 209 4 a a DT www-nature-com-63 209 5 reward reward NN www-nature-com-63 209 6 if if IN www-nature-com-63 209 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 209 8 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 209 9 value value NN www-nature-com-63 209 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 209 11 target target NN www-nature-com-63 209 12 blocks block NNS www-nature-com-63 209 13 computed compute VBN www-nature-com-63 209 14 by by IN www-nature-com-63 209 15 their -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 209 16 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 209 17 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 209 18 validated validate VBN www-nature-com-63 209 19 by by IN www-nature-com-63 209 20 all all DT www-nature-com-63 209 21 network network NN www-nature-com-63 209 22 participants participant NNS www-nature-com-63 209 23 . . . www-nature-com-63 210 1 On on IN www-nature-com-63 210 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 210 3 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 210 4 hand hand NN www-nature-com-63 210 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 210 6 transactions transaction NNS www-nature-com-63 210 7 packaged package VBN www-nature-com-63 210 8 in in IN www-nature-com-63 210 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 210 10 block block NN www-nature-com-63 210 11 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 210 12 confirmed confirm VBN www-nature-com-63 210 13 when when WRB www-nature-com-63 210 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 210 15 block block NN www-nature-com-63 210 16 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 210 17 formally formally RB www-nature-com-63 210 18 broadcasted broadcast VBN www-nature-com-63 210 19 to to IN www-nature-com-63 210 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 210 21 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 210 22 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 210 23 . . . www-nature-com-63 211 1 To to TO www-nature-com-63 211 2 increase increase VB www-nature-com-63 211 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 211 4 probability probability NN www-nature-com-63 211 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 211 6 mining mine VBG www-nature-com-63 211 7 a a DT www-nature-com-63 211 8 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 211 9 block block NN www-nature-com-63 211 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 211 11 getting get VBG www-nature-com-63 211 12 rewarded reward VBN www-nature-com-63 211 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 211 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 211 15 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 211 16 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 211 17 will will MD www-nature-com-63 211 18 be be VB www-nature-com-63 211 19 updated update VBN www-nature-com-63 211 20 continuously continuously RB www-nature-com-63 211 21 and and CC www-nature-com-63 211 22 invested invest VBN www-nature-com-63 211 23 by by IN www-nature-com-63 211 24 network network NN www-nature-com-63 211 25 participants participant NNS www-nature-com-63 211 26 for for IN www-nature-com-63 211 27 higher high JJR www-nature-com-63 211 28 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 211 29 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 211 30 , , , www-nature-com-63 211 31 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 211 32 would would MD www-nature-com-63 211 33 cause cause VB www-nature-com-63 211 34 the the DT www-nature-com-63 211 35 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 211 36 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 211 37 of of IN www-nature-com-63 211 38 the the DT www-nature-com-63 211 39 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 211 40 network network NN www-nature-com-63 211 41 to to TO www-nature-com-63 211 42 rise rise VB www-nature-com-63 211 43 . . . www-nature-com-63 212 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 212 2 order order NN www-nature-com-63 212 3 to to TO www-nature-com-63 212 4 maintain maintain VB www-nature-com-63 212 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 212 6 constant constant JJ www-nature-com-63 212 7 10-minute 10-minute CD www-nature-com-63 212 8 per per IN www-nature-com-63 212 9 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 212 10 block block NN www-nature-com-63 212 11 generation generation NN www-nature-com-63 212 12 process process NN www-nature-com-63 212 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 212 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 212 15 difficulty difficulty NN www-nature-com-63 212 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 212 17 generating generate VBG www-nature-com-63 212 18 a a DT www-nature-com-63 212 19 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 212 20 block block NN www-nature-com-63 212 21 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 212 22 adjusted adjust VBN www-nature-com-63 212 23 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 212 24 on on IN www-nature-com-63 212 25 the the DT www-nature-com-63 212 26 current current JJ www-nature-com-63 212 27 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 212 28 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 212 29 of of IN www-nature-com-63 212 30 the the DT www-nature-com-63 212 31 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 212 32 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 212 33 network network NN www-nature-com-63 212 34 . . . www-nature-com-63 213 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 213 2 halving halve VBG www-nature-com-63 213 3 mechanism mechanism NN www-nature-com-63 213 4 of of IN www-nature-com-63 213 5 block block NN www-nature-com-63 213 6 reward reward NN www-nature-com-63 213 7 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 213 8 designed design VBN www-nature-com-63 213 9 to to TO www-nature-com-63 213 10 control control VB www-nature-com-63 213 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 213 12 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 213 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 213 14 circulation circulation NN www-nature-com-63 213 15 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 213 16 maximum maximum NN www-nature-com-63 213 17 of of IN www-nature-com-63 213 18 21 21 CD www-nature-com-63 213 19 million million CD www-nature-com-63 213 20 Bitcoins Bitcoins NNPS www-nature-com-63 213 21 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 213 22 and and CC www-nature-com-63 213 23 prevent prevent VB www-nature-com-63 213 24 inflation inflation NN www-nature-com-63 213 25 . . . www-nature-com-63 214 1 Reward reward VB www-nature-com-63 214 2 halving halving NN www-nature-com-63 214 3 occurs occur VBZ www-nature-com-63 214 4 every every DT www-nature-com-63 214 5 four four CD www-nature-com-63 214 6 years year NNS www-nature-com-63 214 7 , , , www-nature-com-63 214 8 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 214 9 means mean VBZ www-nature-com-63 214 10 that that IN www-nature-com-63 214 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 214 12 reward reward NN www-nature-com-63 214 13 of of IN www-nature-com-63 214 14 broadcasting broadcast VBG www-nature-com-63 214 15 a a DT www-nature-com-63 214 16 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 214 17 block block NN www-nature-com-63 214 18 in in IN www-nature-com-63 214 19 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 214 20 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 214 21 will will MD www-nature-com-63 214 22 be be VB www-nature-com-63 214 23 zero zero CD www-nature-com-63 214 24 in in IN www-nature-com-63 214 25 2140 2140 CD www-nature-com-63 214 26 . . . www-nature-com-63 215 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 215 2 a a DT www-nature-com-63 215 3 result result NN www-nature-com-63 215 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 215 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 215 6 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 215 7 market market NN www-nature-com-63 215 8 price price NN www-nature-com-63 215 9 increases increase NNS www-nature-com-63 215 10 periodically periodically RB www-nature-com-63 215 11 due due JJ www-nature-com-63 215 12 to to IN www-nature-com-63 215 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 215 14 halving halve VBG www-nature-com-63 215 15 mechanism mechanism NN www-nature-com-63 215 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 215 17 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 215 18 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 215 19 . . . www-nature-com-63 216 1 With with IN www-nature-com-63 216 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 216 3 growing grow VBG www-nature-com-63 216 4 popularity popularity NN www-nature-com-63 216 5 and and CC www-nature-com-63 216 6 broadened broaden VBD www-nature-com-63 216 7 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 216 8 scope scope NN www-nature-com-63 216 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 216 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 216 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 216 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 216 13 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 216 14 transactions transaction NNS www-nature-com-63 216 15 and and CC www-nature-com-63 216 16 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 216 17 fee fee NN www-nature-com-63 216 18 per per IN www-nature-com-63 216 19 block block NN www-nature-com-63 216 20 may may MD www-nature-com-63 216 21 steadily steadily RB www-nature-com-63 216 22 grow grow VB www-nature-com-63 216 23 , , , www-nature-com-63 216 24 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 216 25 drive drive VBP www-nature-com-63 216 26 the the DT www-nature-com-63 216 27 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 216 28 source source NN www-nature-com-63 216 29 of of IN www-nature-com-63 216 30 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 216 31 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 216 32 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 216 33 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 216 34 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 216 35 . . . www-nature-com-63 217 1 Overall overall RB www-nature-com-63 217 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 217 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 217 4 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 217 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 217 6 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 217 7 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 217 8 can can MD www-nature-com-63 217 9 be be VB www-nature-com-63 217 10 calculated calculate VBN www-nature-com-63 217 11 by by IN www-nature-com-63 217 12 subtracting subtract VBG www-nature-com-63 217 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 217 14 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 217 15 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 217 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 217 17 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 217 18 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 217 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 217 20 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 217 21 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 217 22 from from IN www-nature-com-63 217 23 block block NN www-nature-com-63 217 24 reward reward NN www-nature-com-63 217 25 and and CC www-nature-com-63 217 26 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 217 27 fees fee NNS www-nature-com-63 217 28 . . . www-nature-com-63 218 1 Miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 218 2 will will MD www-nature-com-63 218 3 stop stop VB www-nature-com-63 218 4 investing invest VBG www-nature-com-63 218 5 and and CC www-nature-com-63 218 6 updating update VBG www-nature-com-63 218 7 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 218 8 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 218 9 in in IN www-nature-com-63 218 10 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 218 11 when when WRB www-nature-com-63 218 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 218 13 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 218 14 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 218 15 exceeds exceed VBZ www-nature-com-63 218 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 218 17 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 218 18 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 218 19 . . . www-nature-com-63 219 1 Consequently consequently RB www-nature-com-63 219 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 219 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 219 4 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 219 5 network network NN www-nature-com-63 219 6 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 219 7 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 219 8 receives receive VBZ www-nature-com-63 219 9 a a DT www-nature-com-63 219 10 negative negative JJ www-nature-com-63 219 11 feedback feedback NN www-nature-com-63 219 12 due due IN www-nature-com-63 219 13 to to IN www-nature-com-63 219 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 219 15 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 219 16 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 219 17 reductions reduction NNS www-nature-com-63 219 18 . . . www-nature-com-63 220 1 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 220 2 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 220 3 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 220 4 subsystem subsystem NN www-nature-com-63 220 5 . . . www-nature-com-63 221 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 221 2 network network NN www-nature-com-63 221 3 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 221 4 power power NN www-nature-com-63 221 5 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 221 6 deter- deter- XX www-nature-com-63 221 7 mined mine VBN www-nature-com-63 221 8 by by IN www-nature-com-63 221 9 two two CD www-nature-com-63 221 10 factors factor NNS www-nature-com-63 221 11 : : : www-nature-com-63 221 12 first first RB www-nature-com-63 221 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 221 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 221 15 network network NN www-nature-com-63 221 16 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 221 17 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 221 18 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 221 19 hashes hash NNS www-nature-com-63 221 20 computed compute VBN www-nature-com-63 221 21 per per IN www-nature-com-63 221 22 second second NN www-nature-com-63 221 23 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 221 24 positively positively RB www-nature-com-63 221 25 accounts account VBZ www-nature-com-63 221 26 for for IN www-nature-com-63 221 27 the the DT www-nature-com-63 221 28 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 221 29 power power NN www-nature-com-63 221 30 increase increase NN www-nature-com-63 221 31 in in IN www-nature-com-63 221 32 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 221 33 network network NN www-nature-com-63 221 34 when when WRB www-nature-com-63 221 35 high high JJ www-nature-com-63 221 36 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 221 37 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 221 38 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 221 39 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 221 40 invested invest VBN www-nature-com-63 221 41 . . . www-nature-com-63 222 1 However however RB www-nature-com-63 222 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 222 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 222 4 updated update VBN www-nature-com-63 222 5 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 222 6 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 222 7 also also RB www-nature-com-63 222 8 attempt attempt VBP www-nature-com-63 222 9 to to TO www-nature-com-63 222 10 reduce reduce VB www-nature-com-63 222 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 222 12 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 222 13 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 222 14 per per IN www-nature-com-63 222 15 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 222 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 222 17 i.e. i.e. FW www-nature-com-63 222 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 222 19 improve improve VB www-nature-com-63 222 20 the the DT www-nature-com-63 222 21 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 222 22 of of IN www-nature-com-63 222 23 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 222 24 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 222 25 process process NN www-nature-com-63 222 26 , , , www-nature-com-63 222 27 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 222 28 helps help VBZ www-nature-com-63 222 29 to to TO www-nature-com-63 222 30 reduce reduce VB www-nature-com-63 222 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 222 32 network network NN www-nature-com-63 222 33 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 222 34 power power NN www-nature-com-63 222 35 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 222 36 . . . www-nature-com-63 223 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 223 2 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 223 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 223 4 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 223 5 makers maker NNS www-nature-com-63 223 6 may may MD www-nature-com-63 223 7 raise raise VB www-nature-com-63 223 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 223 9 market market NN www-nature-com-63 223 10 access access NN www-nature-com-63 223 11 standard standard NN www-nature-com-63 223 12 and and CC www-nature-com-63 223 13 create create VB www-nature-com-63 223 14 barriers barrier NNS www-nature-com-63 223 15 for for IN www-nature-com-63 223 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 223 17 low- low- NN www-nature-com-63 223 18 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 223 19 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 223 20 to to TO www-nature-com-63 223 21 participate participate VB www-nature-com-63 223 22 in in IN www-nature-com-63 223 23 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 223 24 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 223 25 activities activity NNS www-nature-com-63 223 26 in in IN www-nature-com-63 223 27 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 223 28 . . . www-nature-com-63 224 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 224 2 terms term NNS www-nature-com-63 224 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 224 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 224 5 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 224 6 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 224 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 224 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 224 9 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 224 10 network network NN www-nature-com-63 224 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 224 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 224 13 power power NN www-nature-com-63 224 14 usage usage NN www-nature-com-63 224 15 effectiveness effectiveness NN www-nature-com-63 224 16 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 224 17 intro- intro- NN www-nature-com-63 224 18 duced duced JJ www-nature-com-63 224 19 to to TO www-nature-com-63 224 20 illustrate illustrate VB www-nature-com-63 224 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 224 22 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 224 23 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 224 24 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 224 25 of of IN www-nature-com-63 224 26 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 224 27 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 224 28 as as IN www-nature-com-63 224 29 sug- sug- NN www-nature-com-63 224 30 gested geste VBN www-nature-com-63 224 31 by by IN www-nature-com-63 224 32 Stoll13 Stoll13 NNP www-nature-com-63 224 33 . . . www-nature-com-63 225 1 Finally finally RB www-nature-com-63 225 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 225 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 225 4 network network NN www-nature-com-63 225 5 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 225 6 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 225 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 225 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 225 9 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 225 10 process process NN www-nature-com-63 225 11 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 225 12 determined determine VBN www-nature-com-63 225 13 by by IN www-nature-com-63 225 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 225 15 network network NN www-nature-com-63 225 16 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 225 17 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 225 18 and and CC www-nature-com-63 225 19 average average JJ www-nature-com-63 225 20 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 225 21 price price NN www-nature-com-63 225 22 , , , www-nature-com-63 225 23 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 225 24 further further RB www-nature-com-63 225 25 influences influence VBZ www-nature-com-63 225 26 the the DT www-nature-com-63 225 27 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 225 28 behaviors behavior NNS www-nature-com-63 225 29 of of IN www-nature-com-63 225 30 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 225 31 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 225 32 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 225 33 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 225 34 . . . www-nature-com-63 226 1 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 226 2 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 226 3 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 226 4 subsystem subsystem NN www-nature-com-63 226 5 . . . www-nature-com-63 227 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 227 2 site site NN www-nature-com-63 227 3 selection selection NN www-nature-com-63 227 4 strategies strategy NNS www-nature-com-63 227 5 directly directly RB www-nature-com-63 227 6 deter- deter- VBP www-nature-com-63 227 7 mine -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 227 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 227 9 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 227 10 types type NNS www-nature-com-63 227 11 consumed consume VBN www-nature-com-63 227 12 by by IN www-nature-com-63 227 13 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 227 14 . . . www-nature-com-63 228 1 Although although IN www-nature-com-63 228 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 228 3 electricity electricity NN www-nature-com-63 228 4 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 228 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 228 6 dis- dis- NN www-nature-com-63 228 7 tinctive tinctive JJ www-nature-com-63 228 8 energies energy NNS www-nature-com-63 228 9 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 228 10 more more RBR www-nature-com-63 228 11 or or CC www-nature-com-63 228 12 less less RBR www-nature-com-63 228 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 228 14 same same JJ www-nature-com-63 228 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 228 16 their -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 228 17 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 228 18 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 228 19 patterns pattern NNS www-nature-com-63 228 20 may may MD www-nature-com-63 228 21 vary vary VB www-nature-com-63 228 22 significantly significantly RB www-nature-com-63 228 23 according accord VBG www-nature-com-63 228 24 to to IN www-nature-com-63 228 25 their -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 228 26 respective respective JJ www-nature-com-63 228 27 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 228 28 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 228 29 index index NN www-nature-com-63 228 30 . . . www-nature-com-63 229 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 229 2 comparison comparison NN www-nature-com-63 229 3 to to IN www-nature-com-63 229 4 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 229 5 located locate VBN www-nature-com-63 229 6 in in IN www-nature-com-63 229 7 hydro hydro NNP www-nature-com-63 229 8 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 229 9 rich rich JJ www-nature-com-63 229 10 regions region NNS www-nature-com-63 229 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 229 12 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 229 13 located locate VBN www-nature-com-63 229 14 in in IN www-nature-com-63 229 15 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 229 16 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 229 17 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 229 18 regions region NNS www-nature-com-63 229 19 generate generate VBP www-nature-com-63 229 20 more more JJR www-nature-com-63 229 21 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 229 22 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 229 23 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 229 24 under under IN www-nature-com-63 229 25 the the DT www-nature-com-63 229 26 similar similar JJ www-nature-com-63 229 27 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 229 28 techniques technique NNS www-nature-com-63 229 29 and and CC www-nature-com-63 229 30 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 229 31 usage usage NN www-nature-com-63 229 32 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 229 33 due due IN www-nature-com-63 229 34 to to IN www-nature-com-63 229 35 the the DT www-nature-com-63 229 36 higher high JJR www-nature-com-63 229 37 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 229 38 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 229 39 of of IN www-nature-com-63 229 40 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 229 41 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 229 42 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 229 43 energy17 energy17 NNP www-nature-com-63 229 44 . . . www-nature-com-63 230 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 230 2 proposed propose VBN www-nature-com-63 230 3 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 230 4 model model NN www-nature-com-63 230 5 collects collect VBZ www-nature-com-63 230 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 230 7 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 230 8 footprint footprint NN www-nature-com-63 230 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 230 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 230 11 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 230 12 in in IN www-nature-com-63 230 13 both both CC www-nature-com-63 230 14 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 230 15 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 230 16 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 230 17 and and CC www-nature-com-63 230 18 hydro hydro NNP www-nature-com-63 230 19 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 230 20 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 230 21 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 230 22 regions region NNS www-nature-com-63 230 23 to to TO www-nature-com-63 230 24 formulate formulate VB www-nature-com-63 230 25 the the DT www-nature-com-63 230 26 overall overall JJ www-nature-com-63 230 27 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 230 28 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 230 29 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 230 30 of of IN www-nature-com-63 230 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 230 32 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 230 33 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 230 34 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 230 35 in in IN www-nature-com-63 230 36 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 230 37 . . . www-nature-com-63 231 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 231 2 level level NN www-nature-com-63 231 3 variable variable JJ www-nature-com-63 231 4 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 231 5 consists consist VBZ www-nature-com-63 231 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 231 7 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 231 8 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 231 9 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 231 10 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 231 11 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 231 12 and and CC www-nature-com-63 231 13 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 231 14 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 231 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 231 16 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 231 17 suggests suggest VBZ www-nature-com-63 231 18 the the DT www-nature-com-63 231 19 productivity productivity NN www-nature-com-63 231 20 of of IN www-nature-com-63 231 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 231 22 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 231 23 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 231 24 . . . www-nature-com-63 232 1 It -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 232 2 also also RB www-nature-com-63 232 3 serves serve VBZ www-nature-com-63 232 4 as as IN www-nature-com-63 232 5 an an DT www-nature-com-63 232 6 auxiliary auxiliary JJ www-nature-com-63 232 7 factor factor NN www-nature-com-63 232 8 to to TO www-nature-com-63 232 9 generate generate VB www-nature-com-63 232 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 232 11 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 232 12 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 232 13 per per IN www-nature-com-63 232 14 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 232 15 in in IN www-nature-com-63 232 16 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 232 17 model model NN www-nature-com-63 232 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 232 19 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 232 20 provides provide VBZ www-nature-com-63 232 21 guidance guidance NN www-nature-com-63 232 22 for for IN www-nature-com-63 232 23 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 232 24 makers maker NNS www-nature-com-63 232 25 to to TO www-nature-com-63 232 26 implement implement VB www-nature-com-63 232 27 punitive punitive JJ www-nature-com-63 232 28 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 232 29 taxation taxation NN www-nature-com-63 232 30 on on IN www-nature-com-63 232 31 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 232 32 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 232 33 . . . www-nature-com-63 233 1 Finally finally RB www-nature-com-63 233 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 233 3 by by IN www-nature-com-63 233 4 combining combine VBG www-nature-com-63 233 5 both both DT www-nature-com-63 233 6 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 233 7 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 233 8 and and CC www-nature-com-63 233 9 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 233 10 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 233 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 233 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 233 13 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 233 14 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 233 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 233 16 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 233 17 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 233 18 process process NN www-nature-com-63 233 19 provides provide VBZ www-nature-com-63 233 20 a a DT www-nature-com-63 233 21 negative negative JJ www-nature-com-63 233 22 feedback feedback NN www-nature-com-63 233 23 for for IN www-nature-com-63 233 24 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 233 25 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 233 26 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 233 27 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 233 28 and and CC www-nature-com-63 233 29 their -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 233 30 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 233 31 strategies strategy NNS www-nature-com-63 233 32 . . . www-nature-com-63 234 1 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 234 2 model model NN www-nature-com-63 234 3 parameterizations parameterization NNS www-nature-com-63 234 4 and and CC www-nature-com-63 234 5 quantitative quantitative JJ www-nature-com-63 234 6 settings setting NNS www-nature-com-63 234 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 235 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 235 2 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 235 3 model model NN www-nature-com-63 235 4 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 235 5 been be VBN www-nature-com-63 235 6 constructed construct VBN www-nature-com-63 235 7 in in IN www-nature-com-63 235 8 Vensim Vensim NNP www-nature-com-63 235 9 software software NN www-nature-com-63 235 10 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 235 11 PLE PLE NNP www-nature-com-63 235 12 version version NN www-nature-com-63 235 13 8.2.1 8.2.1 NNP www-nature-com-63 235 14 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 235 15 . . . www-nature-com-63 236 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 236 2 time time NN www-nature-com-63 236 3 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 236 4 related relate VBN www-nature-com-63 236 5 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 236 6 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 236 7 time time NN www-nature-com-63 236 8 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 236 9 series series NN www-nature-com-63 236 10 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 236 11 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 236 12 obtained obtain VBN www-nature-com-63 236 13 from from IN www-nature-com-63 236 14 www.btc.com www.btc.com NNP www-nature-com-63 236 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 236 16 including include VBG www-nature-com-63 236 17 network network NN www-nature-com-63 236 18 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 236 19 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 236 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 236 21 block block NN www-nature-com-63 236 22 size size NN www-nature-com-63 236 23 , , , www-nature-com-63 236 24 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 236 25 fee fee NN www-nature-com-63 236 26 , , , www-nature-com-63 236 27 and and CC www-nature-com-63 236 28 difficulty difficulty NN www-nature-com-63 236 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 237 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 237 2 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 237 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 237 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 237 5 auxiliary auxiliary JJ www-nature-com-63 237 6 parameters parameter NNS www-nature-com-63 237 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 237 8 macroenvironment macroenvironment JJ www-nature-com-63 237 9 variables variable NNS www-nature-com-63 237 10 for for IN www-nature-com-63 237 11 network network NN www-nature-com-63 237 12 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 237 13 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 237 14 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 237 15 assessment assessment NN www-nature-com-63 237 16 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 237 17 set set VBN www-nature-com-63 237 18 and and CC www-nature-com-63 237 19 considered consider VBN www-nature-com-63 237 20 through through IN www-nature-com-63 237 21 various various JJ www-nature-com-63 237 22 guidelines guideline NNS www-nature-com-63 237 23 . . . www-nature-com-63 238 1 For for IN www-nature-com-63 238 2 example example NN www-nature-com-63 238 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 238 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 238 5 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 238 6 intensities intensity NNS www-nature-com-63 238 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 238 8 different different JJ www-nature-com-63 238 9 energies energy NNS www-nature-com-63 238 10 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 238 11 suggested suggest VBN www-nature-com-63 238 12 by by IN www-nature-com-63 238 13 Cheng Cheng NNP www-nature-com-63 238 14 et et NNP www-nature-com-63 238 15 al.35 al.35 NNP www-nature-com-63 238 16 . . . www-nature-com-63 239 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 239 2 average average JJ www-nature-com-63 239 3 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 239 4 cost cost NN www-nature-com-63 239 5 in in IN www-nature-com-63 239 6 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 239 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 239 8 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 239 9 taxation taxation NN www-nature-com-63 239 10 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 239 11 collected collect VBN www-nature-com-63 239 12 from from IN www-nature-com-63 239 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 239 14 World World NNP www-nature-com-63 239 15 Bank Bank NNP www-nature-com-63 239 16 . . . www-nature-com-63 240 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 240 2 site site NN www-nature-com-63 240 3 proportion proportion NN www-nature-com-63 240 4 of of IN www-nature-com-63 240 5 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 240 6 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 240 7 in in IN www-nature-com-63 240 8 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 240 9 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 240 10 set set VBN www-nature-com-63 240 11 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 240 12 on on IN www-nature-com-63 240 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 240 14 regional regional JJ www-nature-com-63 240 15 statistics statistic NNS www-nature-com-63 240 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 240 17 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 240 18 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 240 19 pools pool NNS www-nature-com-63 240 20 in in IN www-nature-com-63 240 21 www.btc.com www.btc.com NNP www-nature-com-63 240 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 241 1 Moreover moreover RB www-nature-com-63 241 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 241 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 241 4 monthly monthly JJ www-nature-com-63 241 5 historical historical JJ www-nature-com-63 241 6 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 241 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 241 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 241 9 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 241 10 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 241 11 utilized utilize VBN www-nature-com-63 241 12 for for IN www-nature-com-63 241 13 time time NN www-nature-com-63 241 14 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 241 15 related relate VBN www-nature-com-63 241 16 parameter parameter NN www-nature-com-63 241 17 regression regression NN www-nature-com-63 241 18 and and CC www-nature-com-63 241 19 simulation simulation NN www-nature-com-63 241 20 from from IN www-nature-com-63 241 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 241 22 period period NN www-nature-com-63 241 23 of of IN www-nature-com-63 241 24 January January NNP www-nature-com-63 241 25 2014 2014 CD www-nature-com-63 241 26 to to IN www-nature-com-63 241 27 January January NNP www-nature-com-63 241 28 2020 2020 CD www-nature-com-63 241 29 through through IN www-nature-com-63 241 30 Stata Stata NNP www-nature-com-63 241 31 software software NN www-nature-com-63 241 32 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 241 33 version version NN www-nature-com-63 241 34 14.1 14.1 CD www-nature-com-63 241 35 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 241 36 . . . www-nature-com-63 242 1 Based base VBN www-nature-com-63 242 2 on on IN www-nature-com-63 242 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 242 4 regressed regress VBN www-nature-com-63 242 5 parameters parameter NNS www-nature-com-63 242 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 242 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 242 8 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 242 9 sample sample NN www-nature-com-63 242 10 timesteps timestep NNS www-nature-com-63 242 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 242 12 network network NN www-nature-com-63 242 13 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 242 14 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 242 15 assessment assessment NN www-nature-com-63 242 16 cover cover VBP www-nature-com-63 242 17 the the DT www-nature-com-63 242 18 period period NN www-nature-com-63 242 19 from from IN www-nature-com-63 242 20 January January NNP www-nature-com-63 242 21 2014 2014 CD www-nature-com-63 242 22 to to IN www-nature-com-63 242 23 January January NNP www-nature-com-63 242 24 2030 2030 CD www-nature-com-63 242 25 in in IN www-nature-com-63 242 26 this this DT www-nature-com-63 242 27 study study NN www-nature-com-63 242 28 , , , www-nature-com-63 242 29 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 242 30 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 242 31 available available JJ www-nature-com-63 242 32 for for IN www-nature-com-63 242 33 scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 242 34 investigations investigation NNS www-nature-com-63 242 35 under under IN www-nature-com-63 242 36 different different JJ www-nature-com-63 242 37 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 242 38 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 242 39 . . . www-nature-com-63 243 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 243 2 initial initial JJ www-nature-com-63 243 3 value value NN www-nature-com-63 243 4 of of IN www-nature-com-63 243 5 static static JJ www-nature-com-63 243 6 parameters parameter NNS www-nature-com-63 243 7 in in IN www-nature-com-63 243 8 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 243 9 model model NN www-nature-com-63 243 10 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 243 11 shown show VBN www-nature-com-63 243 12 in in IN www-nature-com-63 243 13 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 243 14 Table Table NNP www-nature-com-63 243 15 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 243 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 243 17 the the DT www-nature-com-63 243 18 actual actual JJ www-nature-com-63 243 19 values value NNS www-nature-com-63 243 20 of of IN www-nature-com-63 243 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 243 22 parameterizations parameterization NNS www-nature-com-63 243 23 adopted adopt VBN www-nature-com-63 243 24 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 243 25 reported report VBN www-nature-com-63 243 26 in in IN www-nature-com-63 243 27 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 243 28 Methods Methods NNPS www-nature-com-63 243 29 , , , www-nature-com-63 243 30 and and CC www-nature-com-63 243 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 243 32 key key JJ www-nature-com-63 243 33 quantitative quantitative JJ www-nature-com-63 243 34 settings setting NNS www-nature-com-63 243 35 of of IN www-nature-com-63 243 36 each each DT www-nature-com-63 243 37 subsystem subsystem NN www-nature-com-63 243 38 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 243 39 , , , www-nature-com-63 243 40 respectively respectively RB www-nature-com-63 243 41 , , , www-nature-com-63 243 42 run run VB www-nature-com-63 243 43 as as IN www-nature-com-63 243 44 follows follow VBZ www-nature-com-63 243 45 : : : www-nature-com-63 243 46 According accord VBG www-nature-com-63 243 47 to to IN www-nature-com-63 243 48 the the DT www-nature-com-63 243 49 guidance guidance NN www-nature-com-63 243 50 of of IN www-nature-com-63 243 51 the the DT www-nature-com-63 243 52 Cambridge Cambridge NNP www-nature-com-63 243 53 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 243 54 Electricity Electricity NNP www-nature-com-63 243 55 Consumption Consumption NNP www-nature-com-63 243 56 Index Index NNP www-nature-com-63 243 57 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 243 58 https://www.cbeci.org https://www.cbeci.org ADD www-nature-com-63 243 59 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 243 60 and and CC www-nature-com-63 243 61 Küfeoğlu Küfeoğlu NNP www-nature-com-63 243 62 and and CC www-nature-com-63 243 63 Özkuran16 Özkuran16 NNP www-nature-com-63 243 64 , , , www-nature-com-63 243 65 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 243 66 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 243 67 equipment equipment NN www-nature-com-63 243 68 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 243 69 required require VBN www-nature-com-63 243 70 to to TO www-nature-com-63 243 71 update update VB www-nature-com-63 243 72 and and CC www-nature-com-63 243 73 invest invest VB www-nature-com-63 243 74 for for IN www-nature-com-63 243 75 remaining remain VBG www-nature-com-63 243 76 profitability profitability NN www-nature-com-63 243 77 . . . www-nature-com-63 244 1 It -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 244 2 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 244 3 clear clear JJ www-nature-com-63 244 4 that that IN www-nature-com-63 244 5 mining mine VBG www-nature-com-63 244 6 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 244 7 in in IN www-nature-com-63 244 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 244 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 244 10 network network NN www-nature-com-63 244 11 consists consist VBZ www-nature-com-63 244 12 of of IN www-nature-com-63 244 13 various various JJ www-nature-com-63 244 14 equipments equipment NNS www-nature-com-63 244 15 and and CC www-nature-com-63 244 16 their -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 244 17 specifications specification NNS www-nature-com-63 244 18 . . . www-nature-com-63 245 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 245 2 a a DT www-nature-com-63 245 3 result result NN www-nature-com-63 245 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 245 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 245 6 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 245 7 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 245 8 in in IN www-nature-com-63 245 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 245 10 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 245 11 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 245 12 computed compute VBN www-nature-com-63 245 13 by by IN www-nature-com-63 245 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 245 15 average average JJ www-nature-com-63 245 16 price price NN www-nature-com-63 245 17 of of IN www-nature-com-63 245 18 a a DT www-nature-com-63 245 19 profitable profitable JJ www-nature-com-63 245 20 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 245 21 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 245 22 portfolio portfolio NN www-nature-com-63 245 23 . . . www-nature-com-63 246 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 246 2 quantitative quantitative JJ www-nature-com-63 246 3 relationship relationship NN www-nature-com-63 246 4 between between IN www-nature-com-63 246 5 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 246 6 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 246 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 246 8 time time NN www-nature-com-63 246 9 can can MD www-nature-com-63 246 10 be be VB www-nature-com-63 246 11 expressed express VBN www-nature-com-63 246 12 as as IN www-nature-com-63 246 13 the the DT www-nature-com-63 246 14 following follow VBG www-nature-com-63 246 15 form form NN www-nature-com-63 246 16 : : : www-nature-com-63 246 17 Investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 246 18 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 246 19 ¼ ¼ NN www-nature-com-63 246 20 α1 α1 FW www-nature-com-63 246 21 ´ ´ CD www-nature-com-63 246 22 Time Time NNP www-nature-com-63 246 23 ´ ´ CD www-nature-com-63 246 24 Proportion proportion NN www-nature-com-63 246 25 of of IN www-nature-com-63 246 26 Chinese chinese JJ www-nature-com-63 246 27 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 246 28 ð1Þ ð1Þ NNS www-nature-com-63 246 29 In in IN www-nature-com-63 246 30 Eq Eq NNP www-nature-com-63 246 31 . . . www-nature-com-63 247 1 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 247 2 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 247 3 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 247 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 247 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 247 6 parameter parameter NN www-nature-com-63 247 7 α1 α1 NNP www-nature-com-63 247 8 serves serve VBZ www-nature-com-63 247 9 as as IN www-nature-com-63 247 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 247 11 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 247 12 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 247 13 function function NN www-nature-com-63 247 14 coefficient coefficient JJ www-nature-com-63 247 15 on on IN www-nature-com-63 247 16 time time NN www-nature-com-63 247 17 and and CC www-nature-com-63 247 18 the the DT www-nature-com-63 247 19 proportion proportion NN www-nature-com-63 247 20 of of IN www-nature-com-63 247 21 Chinese chinese JJ www-nature-com-63 247 22 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 247 23 , , , www-nature-com-63 247 24 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 247 25 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 247 26 estimated estimate VBN www-nature-com-63 247 27 and and CC www-nature-com-63 247 28 formulated formulate VBN www-nature-com-63 247 29 by by IN www-nature-com-63 247 30 the the DT www-nature-com-63 247 31 historical historical JJ www-nature-com-63 247 32 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 247 33 of of IN www-nature-com-63 247 34 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 247 35 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 247 36 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 247 37 from from IN www-nature-com-63 247 38 the the DT www-nature-com-63 247 39 period period NN www-nature-com-63 247 40 of of IN www-nature-com-63 247 41 January January NNP www-nature-com-63 247 42 2014–January 2014–january CD www-nature-com-63 247 43 2020 2020 CD www-nature-com-63 247 44 . . . www-nature-com-63 248 1 Then then RB www-nature-com-63 248 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 248 3 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 248 4 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 248 5 profits profit NNS www-nature-com-63 248 6 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 248 7 accumulated accumulate VBN www-nature-com-63 248 8 by by IN www-nature-com-63 248 9 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 248 10 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 248 11 and and CC www-nature-com-63 248 12 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 248 13 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 248 14 flows flow NNS www-nature-com-63 248 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 248 16 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 248 17 can can MD www-nature-com-63 248 18 be be VB www-nature-com-63 248 19 obtained obtain VBN www-nature-com-63 248 20 as as IN www-nature-com-63 248 21 follows follow VBZ www-nature-com-63 248 22 : : : www-nature-com-63 248 23 Miner Miner NNP www-nature-com-63 248 24 cumulative cumulative JJ www-nature-com-63 248 25 profitst profitst NN www-nature-com-63 248 26 ¼ ¼ JJ www-nature-com-63 248 27 Z z NN www-nature-com-63 248 28 t t NN www-nature-com-63 248 29 0 0 CD www-nature-com-63 248 30 Miner Miner NNP www-nature-com-63 248 31 profit profit NN www-nature-com-63 248 32 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 248 33 � � NNP www-nature-com-63 248 34 Investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 248 35 intensityð intensityð NN www-nature-com-63 248 36 Þdt Þdt NNP www-nature-com-63 248 37 ð2Þ ð2Þ NNP www-nature-com-63 248 38 As as IN www-nature-com-63 248 39 discussed discuss VBN www-nature-com-63 248 40 above above RB www-nature-com-63 248 41 , , , www-nature-com-63 248 42 the the DT www-nature-com-63 248 43 aim aim NN www-nature-com-63 248 44 of of IN www-nature-com-63 248 45 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 248 46 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 248 47 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 248 48 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 248 49 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 248 50 to to TO www-nature-com-63 248 51 improve improve VB www-nature-com-63 248 52 the the DT www-nature-com-63 248 53 miner miner NN www-nature-com-63 248 54 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 248 55 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 248 56 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 248 57 and and CC www-nature-com-63 248 58 the the DT www-nature-com-63 248 59 probability probability NN www-nature-com-63 248 60 of of IN www-nature-com-63 248 61 broadcasting broadcast VBG www-nature-com-63 248 62 a a DT www-nature-com-63 248 63 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 248 64 block block NN www-nature-com-63 248 65 . . . www-nature-com-63 249 1 Utilizing utilize VBG www-nature-com-63 249 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 249 3 statistics statistic NNS www-nature-com-63 249 4 of of IN www-nature-com-63 249 5 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 249 6 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 249 7 , , , www-nature-com-63 249 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 249 9 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 249 10 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 249 11 of of IN www-nature-com-63 249 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 249 13 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 249 14 network network NN www-nature-com-63 249 15 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 249 16 regressed regress VBN www-nature-com-63 249 17 , , , www-nature-com-63 249 18 and and CC www-nature-com-63 249 19 the the DT www-nature-com-63 249 20 equation equation NN www-nature-com-63 249 21 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 249 22 : : : www-nature-com-63 249 23 Mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 249 24 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 249 25 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 249 26 ¼ ¼ JJ www-nature-com-63 249 27 eβ1þα2Investment eβ1þα2investment JJ www-nature-com-63 249 28 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 249 29 ð3Þ ð3Þ NNP www-nature-com-63 249 30 Where where WRB www-nature-com-63 249 31 β1 β1 NNP www-nature-com-63 249 32 and and CC www-nature-com-63 249 33 α2 α2 NNP www-nature-com-63 249 34 represent represent VBP www-nature-com-63 249 35 the the DT www-nature-com-63 249 36 network network NN www-nature-com-63 249 37 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 249 38 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 249 39 constant constant JJ www-nature-com-63 249 40 function function NN www-nature-com-63 249 41 coefficient coefficient NN www-nature-com-63 249 42 and and CC www-nature-com-63 249 43 coefficient coefficient NN www-nature-com-63 249 44 on on IN www-nature-com-63 249 45 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 249 46 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 249 47 , , , www-nature-com-63 249 48 respectively respectively RB www-nature-com-63 249 49 . . . www-nature-com-63 250 1 Similarly similarly RB www-nature-com-63 250 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 250 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 250 4 average average JJ www-nature-com-63 250 5 block block NN www-nature-com-63 250 6 size size NN www-nature-com-63 250 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 250 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 250 9 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 250 10 consistent consistent JJ www-nature-com-63 250 11 with with IN www-nature-com-63 250 12 time time NN www-nature-com-63 250 13 due due IN www-nature-com-63 250 14 to to IN www-nature-com-63 250 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 250 16 growing grow VBG www-nature-com-63 250 17 popularity popularity NN www-nature-com-63 250 18 of of IN www-nature-com-63 250 19 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 250 20 transactions transaction NNS www-nature-com-63 250 21 and and CC www-nature-com-63 250 22 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 250 23 . . . www-nature-com-63 251 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 251 2 block block NN www-nature-com-63 251 3 size size NN www-nature-com-63 251 4 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 251 5 estimated estimate VBN www-nature-com-63 251 6 by by IN www-nature-com-63 251 7 time time NN www-nature-com-63 251 8 and and CC www-nature-com-63 251 9 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 251 10 illustrated illustrate VBN www-nature-com-63 251 11 as as IN www-nature-com-63 251 12 below below IN www-nature-com-63 251 13 : : : www-nature-com-63 251 14 Block Block NNP www-nature-com-63 251 15 size size NN www-nature-com-63 251 16 ¼ ¼ NNP www-nature-com-63 251 17 eβ2þα3Time eβ2þα3time ADD www-nature-com-63 251 18 ð4Þ ð4Þ NNP www-nature-com-63 251 19 Where where WRB www-nature-com-63 251 20 β2 β2 NNP www-nature-com-63 251 21 and and CC www-nature-com-63 251 22 α3 α3 NNP www-nature-com-63 251 23 indicate indicate VBP www-nature-com-63 251 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 251 25 block block NN www-nature-com-63 251 26 size size NN www-nature-com-63 251 27 function function NN www-nature-com-63 251 28 constant constant JJ www-nature-com-63 251 29 coefficient coefficient NN www-nature-com-63 251 30 and and CC www-nature-com-63 251 31 coefficient coefficient NN www-nature-com-63 251 32 on on IN www-nature-com-63 251 33 time time NN www-nature-com-63 251 34 , , , www-nature-com-63 251 35 respectively respectively RB www-nature-com-63 251 36 . . . www-nature-com-63 252 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 252 2 proportion proportion NN www-nature-com-63 252 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 252 4 Chinese chinese JJ www-nature-com-63 252 5 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 252 6 in in IN www-nature-com-63 252 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 252 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 252 9 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 252 10 process process NN www-nature-com-63 252 11 will will MD www-nature-com-63 252 12 gradually gradually RB www-nature-com-63 252 13 decrease decrease VB www-nature-com-63 252 14 if if IN www-nature-com-63 252 15 mining mine VBG www-nature-com-63 252 16 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 252 17 in in IN www-nature-com-63 252 18 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 252 19 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 252 20 not not RB www-nature-com-63 252 21 profitable profitable JJ www-nature-com-63 252 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 253 1 So so RB www-nature-com-63 253 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 253 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 253 4 proportion proportion NN www-nature-com-63 253 5 parameter parameter NN www-nature-com-63 253 6 in in IN www-nature-com-63 253 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 253 8 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 253 9 model model NN www-nature-com-63 253 10 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 253 11 set set VBN www-nature-com-63 253 12 as as IN www-nature-com-63 253 13 follows follow VBZ www-nature-com-63 253 14 : : : www-nature-com-63 253 15 Proportion proportion NN www-nature-com-63 253 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 253 17 Chinese chinese JJ www-nature-com-63 253 18 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 253 19 ¼IF ¼IF NNP www-nature-com-63 253 20 THEN then RB www-nature-com-63 253 21 ELSEðMiner ELSEðMiner NNP www-nature-com-63 253 22 cumulative cumulative JJ www-nature-com-63 253 23 Profits profit NNS www-nature-com-63 253 24 < < XX www-nature-com-63 253 25 0 0 NFP www-nature-com-63 253 26 ; ; : www-nature-com-63 253 27 0:7 0:7 NFP www-nature-com-63 253 28 � � NNP www-nature-com-63 253 29 0:01 0:01 CD www-nature-com-63 253 30 ´ ´ CD www-nature-com-63 253 31 Time Time NNP www-nature-com-63 253 32 ; ; : www-nature-com-63 253 33 0:7Þ 0:7Þ NFP www-nature-com-63 253 34 ð5Þ ð5þ NN www-nature-com-63 253 35 Suggested suggest VBN www-nature-com-63 253 36 by by IN www-nature-com-63 253 37 the the DT www-nature-com-63 253 38 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 253 39 pool pool NN www-nature-com-63 253 40 statistics statistic NNS www-nature-com-63 253 41 obtained obtain VBN www-nature-com-63 253 42 from from IN www-nature-com-63 253 43 BTC.com BTC.com NNP www-nature-com-63 253 44 , , , www-nature-com-63 253 45 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 253 46 accounts account VBZ www-nature-com-63 253 47 for for IN www-nature-com-63 253 48 approximately approximately RB www-nature-com-63 253 49 70 70 CD www-nature-com-63 253 50 % % NN www-nature-com-63 253 51 of of IN www-nature-com-63 253 52 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 253 53 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 253 54 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 253 55 around around IN www-nature-com-63 253 56 the the DT www-nature-com-63 253 57 world world NN www-nature-com-63 253 58 . . . www-nature-com-63 254 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 254 2 a a DT www-nature-com-63 254 3 result result NN www-nature-com-63 254 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 254 5 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 254 6 set set VBD www-nature-com-63 254 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 254 8 initial initial JJ www-nature-com-63 254 9 proportion proportion NN www-nature-com-63 254 10 of of IN www-nature-com-63 254 11 Chinese chinese JJ www-nature-com-63 254 12 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 254 13 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 254 14 as as IN www-nature-com-63 254 15 70 70 CD www-nature-com-63 254 16 % % NN www-nature-com-63 254 17 . . . www-nature-com-63 255 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 255 2 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 255 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 255 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 255 5 proportion proportion NN www-nature-com-63 255 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 255 7 Chinese chinese JJ www-nature-com-63 255 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 255 9 miners miner NNS www-nature-com-63 255 10 will will MD www-nature-com-63 255 11 gradually gradually RB www-nature-com-63 255 12 decrease decrease VB www-nature-com-63 255 13 if if IN www-nature-com-63 255 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 255 15 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 255 16 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 255 17 process process NN www-nature-com-63 255 18 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 255 19 no no DT www-nature-com-63 255 20 longer long RBR www-nature-com-63 255 21 profitable profitable JJ www-nature-com-63 255 22 in in IN www-nature-com-63 255 23 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 255 24 . . . www-nature-com-63 256 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 256 2 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 256 3 consumed consume VBN www-nature-com-63 256 4 per per IN www-nature-com-63 256 5 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 256 6 will will MD www-nature-com-63 256 7 reduce reduce VB www-nature-com-63 256 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 256 9 i.e. i.e. FW www-nature-com-63 256 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 256 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 256 12 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 256 13 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 256 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 256 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 256 16 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 256 17 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 256 18 will will MD www-nature-com-63 256 19 improve improve VB www-nature-com-63 256 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 256 21 when when WRB www-nature-com-63 256 22 updated update VBN www-nature-com-63 256 23 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 256 24 hardware hardware NN www-nature-com-63 256 25 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 256 26 invested invest VBN www-nature-com-63 256 27 and and CC www-nature-com-63 256 28 introduced introduce VBN www-nature-com-63 256 29 . . . www-nature-com-63 257 1 Moreover moreover RB www-nature-com-63 257 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 257 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 257 4 market market NN www-nature-com-63 257 5 access access NN www-nature-com-63 257 6 standard standard NN www-nature-com-63 257 7 for for IN www-nature-com-63 257 8 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 257 9 proposed propose VBN www-nature-com-63 257 10 by by IN www-nature-com-63 257 11 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 257 12 makers maker NNS www-nature-com-63 257 13 also also RB www-nature-com-63 257 14 affects affect VBZ www-nature-com-63 257 15 network network NN www-nature-com-63 257 16 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 257 17 . . . www-nature-com-63 258 1 Consequently consequently RB www-nature-com-63 258 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 258 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 258 4 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 258 5 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 258 6 can can MD www-nature-com-63 258 7 be be VB www-nature-com-63 258 8 calculated calculate VBN www-nature-com-63 258 9 as as IN www-nature-com-63 258 10 follows follow VBZ www-nature-com-63 258 11 : : : www-nature-com-63 258 12 Mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 258 13 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 258 14 ¼ ¼ JJ www-nature-com-63 258 15 eβ3þα4 eβ3þα4 NNP www-nature-com-63 258 16 ´ ´ NNP www-nature-com-63 258 17 Investment Investment NNP www-nature-com-63 258 18 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 258 19 ´ ´ CD www-nature-com-63 258 20 Market market NN www-nature-com-63 258 21 assess assess VBP www-nature-com-63 258 22 standard standard NN www-nature-com-63 258 23 for for IN www-nature-com-63 258 24 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 258 25 ð6Þ ð6þ NN www-nature-com-63 258 26 Where where WRB www-nature-com-63 258 27 β3 β3 NNP www-nature-com-63 258 28 and and CC www-nature-com-63 258 29 α4 α4 NNP www-nature-com-63 258 30 act act NNP www-nature-com-63 258 31 as as IN www-nature-com-63 258 32 the the DT www-nature-com-63 258 33 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 258 34 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 258 35 function function VBP www-nature-com-63 258 36 constant constant JJ www-nature-com-63 258 37 coefficient coefficient NN www-nature-com-63 258 38 and and CC www-nature-com-63 258 39 coefficient coefficient NN www-nature-com-63 258 40 on on IN www-nature-com-63 258 41 investment investment NN www-nature-com-63 258 42 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 258 43 and and CC www-nature-com-63 258 44 market market NN www-nature-com-63 258 45 access access NN www-nature-com-63 258 46 standard standard NN www-nature-com-63 258 47 for for IN www-nature-com-63 258 48 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 258 49 , , , www-nature-com-63 258 50 respectively respectively RB www-nature-com-63 258 51 . . . www-nature-com-63 259 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 259 2 above above JJ www-nature-com-63 259 3 function function NN www-nature-com-63 259 4 coefficients coefficient NNS www-nature-com-63 259 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 259 6 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 259 7 parameters parameter NNS www-nature-com-63 259 8 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 259 9 regressed regress VBN www-nature-com-63 259 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 259 11 formulated formulate VBN www-nature-com-63 259 12 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 259 13 on on IN www-nature-com-63 259 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 259 15 actual actual JJ www-nature-com-63 259 16 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 259 17 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 259 18 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 259 19 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 259 20 from from IN www-nature-com-63 259 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 259 22 period period NN www-nature-com-63 259 23 of of IN www-nature-com-63 259 24 January January NNP www-nature-com-63 259 25 2014 2014 CD www-nature-com-63 259 26 to to IN www-nature-com-63 259 27 January January NNP www-nature-com-63 259 28 2020 2020 CD www-nature-com-63 259 29 , , , www-nature-com-63 259 30 and and CC www-nature-com-63 259 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 259 32 specific specific JJ www-nature-com-63 259 33 value value NN www-nature-com-63 259 34 of of IN www-nature-com-63 259 35 each each DT www-nature-com-63 259 36 parameter parameter NN www-nature-com-63 259 37 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 259 38 reported report VBN www-nature-com-63 259 39 in in IN www-nature-com-63 259 40 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 259 41 Methods Methods NNPS www-nature-com-63 259 42 . . . www-nature-com-63 260 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 260 2 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 260 3 power power NN www-nature-com-63 260 4 of of IN www-nature-com-63 260 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 260 6 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 260 7 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 260 8 can can MD www-nature-com-63 260 9 be be VB www-nature-com-63 260 10 obtained obtain VBN www-nature-com-63 260 11 by by IN www-nature-com-63 260 12 network network NN www-nature-com-63 260 13 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 260 14 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 260 15 and and CC www-nature-com-63 260 16 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 260 17 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 260 18 . . . www-nature-com-63 261 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 261 2 equation equation NN www-nature-com-63 261 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 261 4 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 261 5 power power NN www-nature-com-63 261 6 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 261 7 shown show VBN www-nature-com-63 261 8 as as IN www-nature-com-63 261 9 follows follow VBZ www-nature-com-63 261 10 : : : www-nature-com-63 261 11 Mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 261 12 power power NN www-nature-com-63 261 13 ¼ ¼ NN www-nature-com-63 261 14 Mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 261 15 hash hash NN www-nature-com-63 261 16 rate rate NN www-nature-com-63 261 17 ´ ´ CD www-nature-com-63 261 18 Mining Mining NNP www-nature-com-63 261 19 efficiency efficiency NN www-nature-com-63 261 20 ð7Þ ð7Þ NNP www-nature-com-63 261 21 ARTICLE ARTICLE NNP www-nature-com-63 261 22 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 261 23 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 261 24 | | CD www-nature-com-63 261 25 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 261 26 8 8 CD www-nature-com-63 261 27 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 261 28 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 261 29 | | CD www-nature-com-63 261 30 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 261 31 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 261 32 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 261 33 12:1938 12:1938 CD www-nature-com-63 261 34 | | CD www-nature-com-63 261 35 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 261 36 | | CD www-nature-com-63 261 37 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 261 38 http://www.btc.com http://www.btc.com NNP www-nature-com-63 261 39 http://www.btc.com http://www.btc.com NN www-nature-com-63 261 40 https://www.cbeci.org https://www.cbeci.org VBZ www-nature-com-63 261 41 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 261 42 Finally finally RB www-nature-com-63 261 43 , , , www-nature-com-63 261 44 the the DT www-nature-com-63 261 45 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 261 46 consumed consume VBN www-nature-com-63 261 47 by by IN www-nature-com-63 261 48 the the DT www-nature-com-63 261 49 whole whole JJ www-nature-com-63 261 50 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 261 51 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 261 52 can can MD www-nature-com-63 261 53 be be VB www-nature-com-63 261 54 expressed express VBN www-nature-com-63 261 55 by by IN www-nature-com-63 261 56 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 261 57 power power NN www-nature-com-63 261 58 and and CC www-nature-com-63 261 59 power power NN www-nature-com-63 261 60 usage usage NN www-nature-com-63 261 61 effectiveness effectiveness NN www-nature-com-63 261 62 : : : www-nature-com-63 261 63 Network network NN www-nature-com-63 261 64 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 261 65 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 261 66 ¼ ¼ NN www-nature-com-63 261 67 Mining Mining NNP www-nature-com-63 261 68 power power NN www-nature-com-63 261 69 ´ ´ NNP www-nature-com-63 261 70 Power Power NNP www-nature-com-63 261 71 usage usage NN www-nature-com-63 261 72 effectiveness effectiveness NN www-nature-com-63 261 73 ð8Þ ð8þ NN www-nature-com-63 261 74 Employing employ VBG www-nature-com-63 261 75 the the DT www-nature-com-63 261 76 regional regional JJ www-nature-com-63 261 77 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 261 78 of of IN www-nature-com-63 261 79 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 261 80 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 261 81 pools pool NNS www-nature-com-63 261 82 , , , www-nature-com-63 261 83 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 261 84 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 261 85 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 261 86 and and CC www-nature-com-63 261 87 hydro hydro NNP www-nature-com-63 261 88 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 261 89 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 261 90 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 261 91 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 261 92 proportionally proportionally RB www-nature-com-63 261 93 consumed consume VBN www-nature-com-63 261 94 by by IN www-nature-com-63 261 95 distinctive distinctive JJ www-nature-com-63 261 96 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 261 97 pools pool NNS www-nature-com-63 261 98 . . . www-nature-com-63 262 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 262 2 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 262 3 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 262 4 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 262 5 in in IN www-nature-com-63 262 6 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 262 7 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 262 8 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 262 9 measured measure VBN www-nature-com-63 262 10 by by IN www-nature-com-63 262 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 262 12 sum sum NN www-nature-com-63 262 13 of of IN www-nature-com-63 262 14 both both CC www-nature-com-63 262 15 monthly monthly JJ www-nature-com-63 262 16 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 262 17 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 262 18 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 262 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 262 20 hydro hydro NNP www-nature-com-63 262 21 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 262 22 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 262 23 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 262 24 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 262 25 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 262 26 growth growth NN www-nature-com-63 262 27 . . . www-nature-com-63 263 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 263 2 integration integration NN www-nature-com-63 263 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 263 4 total total JJ www-nature-com-63 263 5 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 263 6 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 263 7 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 263 8 : : : www-nature-com-63 263 9 Total total JJ www-nature-com-63 263 10 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 263 11 emissiont emissiont NN www-nature-com-63 263 12 ¼ ¼ NNP www-nature-com-63 263 13 Z Z NNP www-nature-com-63 263 14 t t NNP www-nature-com-63 263 15 0 0 NFP www-nature-com-63 263 16 Carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 263 17 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 263 18 flow flow NN www-nature-com-63 263 19 dt dt NNP www-nature-com-63 263 20 ð9Þ ð9þ NN www-nature-com-63 263 21 In in IN www-nature-com-63 263 22 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 263 23 , , , www-nature-com-63 263 24 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 263 25 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 263 26 per per IN www-nature-com-63 263 27 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 263 28 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 263 29 introduced introduce VBN www-nature-com-63 263 30 to to TO www-nature-com-63 263 31 investigate investigate VB www-nature-com-63 263 32 the the DT www-nature-com-63 263 33 overall overall JJ www-nature-com-63 263 34 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 263 35 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 263 36 of of IN www-nature-com-63 263 37 the the DT www-nature-com-63 263 38 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 263 39 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 263 40 process process NN www-nature-com-63 263 41 in in IN www-nature-com-63 263 42 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 263 43 , , , www-nature-com-63 263 44 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 263 45 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 263 46 formulated formulate VBN www-nature-com-63 263 47 by by IN www-nature-com-63 263 48 the the DT www-nature-com-63 263 49 following following JJ www-nature-com-63 263 50 equation equation NN www-nature-com-63 263 51 : : : www-nature-com-63 263 52 Carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 263 53 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 263 54 per per IN www-nature-com-63 263 55 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 263 56 ¼ ¼ FW www-nature-com-63 263 57 Carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 263 58 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 263 59 = = -RRB- www-nature-com-63 263 60 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 263 61 ð10Þ ð10þ CD www-nature-com-63 263 62 Suggested suggest VBN www-nature-com-63 263 63 by by IN www-nature-com-63 263 64 the the DT www-nature-com-63 263 65 World World NNP www-nature-com-63 263 66 Bank Bank NNP www-nature-com-63 263 67 database database NN www-nature-com-63 263 68 , , , www-nature-com-63 263 69 we -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 263 70 introduce introduce VBP www-nature-com-63 263 71 the the DT www-nature-com-63 263 72 average average JJ www-nature-com-63 263 73 taxation taxation NN www-nature-com-63 263 74 percentage percentage NN www-nature-com-63 263 75 for for IN www-nature-com-63 263 76 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 263 77 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 263 78 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 263 79 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 263 80 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 263 81 % % NN www-nature-com-63 263 82 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 263 83 as as IN www-nature-com-63 263 84 the the DT www-nature-com-63 263 85 initial initial JJ www-nature-com-63 263 86 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 263 87 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 263 88 parameter parameter NN www-nature-com-63 263 89 in in IN www-nature-com-63 263 90 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 263 91 modeling modeling NN www-nature-com-63 263 92 . . . www-nature-com-63 264 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 264 2 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 264 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 264 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 264 5 punitive punitive JJ www-nature-com-63 264 6 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 264 7 taxation taxation NN www-nature-com-63 264 8 on on IN www-nature-com-63 264 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 264 10 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 264 11 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 264 12 will will MD www-nature-com-63 264 13 be be VB www-nature-com-63 264 14 conducted conduct VBN www-nature-com-63 264 15 by by IN www-nature-com-63 264 16 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 264 17 makers maker NNS www-nature-com-63 264 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 264 19 i.e i.e NNP www-nature-com-63 264 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 264 21 the the DT www-nature-com-63 264 22 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 264 23 taxation taxation NN www-nature-com-63 264 24 on on IN www-nature-com-63 264 25 the the DT www-nature-com-63 264 26 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 264 27 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 264 28 will will MD www-nature-com-63 264 29 be be VB www-nature-com-63 264 30 doubled double VBN www-nature-com-63 264 31 , , , www-nature-com-63 264 32 if if IN www-nature-com-63 264 33 the the DT www-nature-com-63 264 34 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 264 35 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 264 36 per per IN www-nature-com-63 264 37 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 264 38 of of IN www-nature-com-63 264 39 the the DT www-nature-com-63 264 40 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 264 41 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 264 42 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 264 43 larger large JJR www-nature-com-63 264 44 than than IN www-nature-com-63 264 45 average average JJ www-nature-com-63 264 46 industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 264 47 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 264 48 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 264 49 per per IN www-nature-com-63 264 50 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 264 51 in in IN www-nature-com-63 264 52 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 264 53 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 264 54 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 264 55 kg kg NNP www-nature-com-63 264 56 / / SYM www-nature-com-63 264 57 GDP GDP NNP www-nature-com-63 264 58 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 264 59 . . . www-nature-com-63 265 1 As as IN www-nature-com-63 265 2 a a DT www-nature-com-63 265 3 result result NN www-nature-com-63 265 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 265 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 265 6 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 265 7 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 265 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 265 9 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 265 10 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 265 11 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 265 12 set set VBN www-nature-com-63 265 13 as as IN www-nature-com-63 265 14 : : : www-nature-com-63 265 15 Carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 265 16 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 265 17 ¼ ¼ NN www-nature-com-63 265 18 0:01 0:01 CD www-nature-com-63 265 19 ´ ´ CD www-nature-com-63 265 20 IF if IN www-nature-com-63 265 21 THEN then RB www-nature-com-63 265 22 ELSEðcarbon elseðcarbon NN www-nature-com-63 265 23 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 265 24 per per IN www-nature-com-63 265 25 GDP>2 gdp>2 JJ www-nature-com-63 265 26 ; ; : www-nature-com-63 265 27 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 265 28 ; ; : www-nature-com-63 265 29 1Þ 1Þ NNP www-nature-com-63 265 30 ð11Þ ð11Þ NNP www-nature-com-63 265 31 Validation validation NN www-nature-com-63 265 32 and and CC www-nature-com-63 265 33 robustness robustness NN www-nature-com-63 265 34 tests test NNS www-nature-com-63 265 35 . . . www-nature-com-63 266 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 266 2 order order NN www-nature-com-63 266 3 to to TO www-nature-com-63 266 4 test test VB www-nature-com-63 266 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 266 6 suitability suitability NN www-nature-com-63 266 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 266 8 robustness robustness NN www-nature-com-63 266 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 266 10 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 266 11 modeling modeling NN www-nature-com-63 266 12 system system NN www-nature-com-63 266 13 structures structure NNS www-nature-com-63 266 14 and and CC www-nature-com-63 266 15 behaviors behavior NNS www-nature-com-63 266 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 266 17 three three CD www-nature-com-63 266 18 model model NN www-nature-com-63 266 19 validation validation NN www-nature-com-63 266 20 experi- experi- NN www-nature-com-63 266 21 ments ment NNS www-nature-com-63 266 22 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 266 23 introduced introduce VBN www-nature-com-63 266 24 and and CC www-nature-com-63 266 25 conducted conduct VBN www-nature-com-63 266 26 in in IN www-nature-com-63 266 27 our -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 266 28 study study NN www-nature-com-63 266 29 , , , www-nature-com-63 266 30 i.e. i.e. FW www-nature-com-63 266 31 , , , www-nature-com-63 266 32 the the DT www-nature-com-63 266 33 structural structural JJ www-nature-com-63 266 34 suitability suitability NN www-nature-com-63 266 35 tests test NNS www-nature-com-63 266 36 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 266 37 see see VB www-nature-com-63 266 38 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 266 39 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 266 40 . . . www-nature-com-63 267 1 3 3 LS www-nature-com-63 267 2 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 267 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 267 4 reality reality NN www-nature-com-63 267 5 and and CC www-nature-com-63 267 6 statistical statistical JJ www-nature-com-63 267 7 tests test NNS www-nature-com-63 267 8 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 267 9 see see VB www-nature-com-63 267 10 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 267 11 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 267 12 . . . www-nature-com-63 268 1 4 4 LS www-nature-com-63 268 2 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 268 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 268 4 and and CC www-nature-com-63 268 5 sensitivity sensitivity NN www-nature-com-63 268 6 analysis analysis NN www-nature-com-63 268 7 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 268 8 see see VB www-nature-com-63 268 9 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 268 10 Fig Fig NNP www-nature-com-63 268 11 . . . www-nature-com-63 269 1 5 5 LS www-nature-com-63 269 2 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 269 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 270 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 270 2 validation validation NN www-nature-com-63 270 3 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 270 4 of of IN www-nature-com-63 270 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 270 6 three three CD www-nature-com-63 270 7 tests test NNS www-nature-com-63 270 8 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 270 9 reported report VBN www-nature-com-63 270 10 in in IN www-nature-com-63 270 11 Supplementary Supplementary NNP www-nature-com-63 270 12 Discussion Discussion NNP www-nature-com-63 270 13 . . . www-nature-com-63 271 1 Overall overall RB www-nature-com-63 271 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 271 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 271 4 model model NN www-nature-com-63 271 5 validation validation NN www-nature-com-63 271 6 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 271 7 indicate indicate VBP www-nature-com-63 271 8 that that IN www-nature-com-63 271 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 271 10 proposed propose VBN www-nature-com-63 271 11 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 271 12 model model NN www-nature-com-63 271 13 can can MD www-nature-com-63 271 14 effectively effectively RB www-nature-com-63 271 15 simulate simulate VB www-nature-com-63 271 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 271 17 causal causal JJ www-nature-com-63 271 18 relationship relationship NN www-nature-com-63 271 19 and and CC www-nature-com-63 271 20 feedback feedback NN www-nature-com-63 271 21 loops loop NNS www-nature-com-63 271 22 of of IN www-nature-com-63 271 23 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 271 24 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 271 25 system system NN www-nature-com-63 271 26 in in IN www-nature-com-63 271 27 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 271 28 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 271 29 , , , www-nature-com-63 271 30 and and CC www-nature-com-63 271 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 271 32 parameters parameter NNS www-nature-com-63 271 33 in in IN www-nature-com-63 271 34 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 271 35 model model NN www-nature-com-63 271 36 have have VBP www-nature-com-63 271 37 significant significant JJ www-nature-com-63 271 38 consistencies consistency NNS www-nature-com-63 271 39 with with IN www-nature-com-63 271 40 actual actual JJ www-nature-com-63 271 41 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 271 42 operating operating NN www-nature-com-63 271 43 time time NN www-nature-com-63 271 44 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 271 45 series series NN www-nature-com-63 271 46 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 271 47 . . . www-nature-com-63 272 1 In in IN www-nature-com-63 272 2 addition addition NN www-nature-com-63 272 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 272 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 272 5 sensitivity sensitivity NN www-nature-com-63 272 6 analysis analysis NN www-nature-com-63 272 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 272 8 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 272 9 model model NN www-nature-com-63 272 10 also also RB www-nature-com-63 272 11 shows show VBZ www-nature-com-63 272 12 that that IN www-nature-com-63 272 13 a a DT www-nature-com-63 272 14 slight slight JJ www-nature-com-63 272 15 variation variation NN www-nature-com-63 272 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 272 17 the the DT www-nature-com-63 272 18 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 272 19 parameters parameter NNS www-nature-com-63 272 20 does do VBZ www-nature-com-63 272 21 not not RB www-nature-com-63 272 22 lead lead VB www-nature-com-63 272 23 to to IN www-nature-com-63 272 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 272 25 remarkable remarkable JJ www-nature-com-63 272 26 changes change NNS www-nature-com-63 272 27 in in IN www-nature-com-63 272 28 the the DT www-nature-com-63 272 29 model model NN www-nature-com-63 272 30 behaviors behavior NNS www-nature-com-63 272 31 or or CC www-nature-com-63 272 32 the the DT www-nature-com-63 272 33 ranking ranking NN www-nature-com-63 272 34 of of IN www-nature-com-63 272 35 the the DT www-nature-com-63 272 36 intended intended JJ www-nature-com-63 272 37 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 272 38 reduction reduction NN www-nature-com-63 272 39 policies policy NNS www-nature-com-63 272 40 , , , www-nature-com-63 272 41 thus thus RB www-nature-com-63 272 42 indicating indicate VBG www-nature-com-63 272 43 that that IN www-nature-com-63 272 44 the the DT www-nature-com-63 272 45 proposed propose VBN www-nature-com-63 272 46 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 272 47 model model NN www-nature-com-63 272 48 has have VBZ www-nature-com-63 272 49 excellent excellent JJ www-nature-com-63 272 50 behavioral behavioral JJ www-nature-com-63 272 51 robustness robustness NN www-nature-com-63 272 52 and and CC www-nature-com-63 272 53 stability stability NN www-nature-com-63 272 54 . . . www-nature-com-63 273 1 Reporting report VBG www-nature-com-63 273 2 summary summary NN www-nature-com-63 273 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 274 1 Further further JJ www-nature-com-63 274 2 information information NN www-nature-com-63 274 3 on on IN www-nature-com-63 274 4 experimental experimental JJ www-nature-com-63 274 5 design design NN www-nature-com-63 274 6 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 274 7 available available JJ www-nature-com-63 274 8 in in IN www-nature-com-63 274 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 274 10 Nature Nature NNP www-nature-com-63 274 11 Research Research NNP www-nature-com-63 274 12 Reporting Reporting NNP www-nature-com-63 274 13 Summary Summary NNP www-nature-com-63 274 14 linked link VBD www-nature-com-63 274 15 to to IN www-nature-com-63 274 16 this this DT www-nature-com-63 274 17 paper paper NN www-nature-com-63 274 18 . . . www-nature-com-63 275 1 Data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 275 2 availability availability NN www-nature-com-63 275 3 All all DT www-nature-com-63 275 4 original original JJ www-nature-com-63 275 5 datasets dataset NNS www-nature-com-63 275 6 used use VBN www-nature-com-63 275 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 275 8 the the DT www-nature-com-63 275 9 generated generate VBN www-nature-com-63 275 10 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 275 11 from from IN www-nature-com-63 275 12 the the DT www-nature-com-63 275 13 results result NNS www-nature-com-63 275 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 275 15 the the DT www-nature-com-63 275 16 study study NN www-nature-com-63 275 17 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 275 18 available available JJ www-nature-com-63 275 19 at at IN www-nature-com-63 275 20 CEADS CEADS NNP www-nature-com-63 275 21 database database NN www-nature-com-63 275 22 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 275 23 https://www.ceads.net/user/download-anonymous.php https://www.ceads.net/user/download-anonymous.php NN www-nature-com-63 275 24 ? ? . www-nature-com-63 276 1 id=1083 id=1083 LS www-nature-com-63 276 2 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 276 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 277 1 All all DT www-nature-com-63 277 2 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 277 3 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 277 4 also also RB www-nature-com-63 277 5 available available JJ www-nature-com-63 277 6 from from IN www-nature-com-63 277 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 277 8 corresponding correspond VBG www-nature-com-63 277 9 authors author NNS www-nature-com-63 277 10 upon upon IN www-nature-com-63 277 11 reasonable reasonable JJ www-nature-com-63 277 12 request request NN www-nature-com-63 277 13 . . . www-nature-com-63 278 1 Received receive VBN www-nature-com-63 278 2 : : : www-nature-com-63 278 3 25 25 CD www-nature-com-63 278 4 August August NNP www-nature-com-63 278 5 2020 2020 CD www-nature-com-63 278 6 ; ; : www-nature-com-63 278 7 Accepted accept VBN www-nature-com-63 278 8 : : : www-nature-com-63 278 9 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 278 10 March March NNP www-nature-com-63 278 11 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 278 12 ; ; : www-nature-com-63 278 13 References reference NNS www-nature-com-63 278 14 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 278 15 . . . www-nature-com-63 279 1 Nakamoto Nakamoto NNP www-nature-com-63 279 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 279 3 S. S. NNP www-nature-com-63 279 4 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 279 5 : : : www-nature-com-63 279 6 A A NNP www-nature-com-63 279 7 Peer Peer NNP www-nature-com-63 279 8 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 279 9 to to IN www-nature-com-63 279 10 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 279 11 Peer Peer NNP www-nature-com-63 279 12 Electronic electronic JJ www-nature-com-63 279 13 Cash cash NN www-nature-com-63 279 14 System system NN www-nature-com-63 279 15 . . . www-nature-com-63 280 1 Bitcoin.org Bitcoin.org NNP www-nature-com-63 280 2 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 280 3 2008 2008 CD www-nature-com-63 280 4 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 280 5 . . . www-nature-com-63 281 1 2 2 LS www-nature-com-63 281 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 282 1 Zheng Zheng NNP www-nature-com-63 282 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 282 3 Z. Z. NNP www-nature-com-63 282 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 282 5 Xie Xie NNP www-nature-com-63 282 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 282 7 S. S. NNP www-nature-com-63 282 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 282 9 Dai Dai NNP www-nature-com-63 282 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 282 11 H. H. NNP www-nature-com-63 282 12 N. N. NNP www-nature-com-63 282 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 282 14 Chen Chen NNP www-nature-com-63 282 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 282 16 X. X. NNP www-nature-com-63 283 1 & & CC www-nature-com-63 283 2 Wang Wang NNP www-nature-com-63 283 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 283 4 H. H. NNP www-nature-com-63 283 5 Blockchain Blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 283 6 challenges challenge NNS www-nature-com-63 283 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 283 8 opportunities opportunity NNS www-nature-com-63 283 9 : : : www-nature-com-63 283 10 a a DT www-nature-com-63 283 11 survey survey NN www-nature-com-63 283 12 . . . www-nature-com-63 284 1 Int Int NNP www-nature-com-63 284 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 285 1 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 286 1 Web web NN www-nature-com-63 286 2 Grid Grid NNP www-nature-com-63 286 3 Serv Serv NNP www-nature-com-63 286 4 . . . www-nature-com-63 287 1 14 14 CD www-nature-com-63 287 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 287 3 352–375 352–375 CD www-nature-com-63 287 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 287 5 2018 2018 CD www-nature-com-63 287 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 287 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 288 1 3 3 LS www-nature-com-63 288 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 289 1 Li Li NNP www-nature-com-63 289 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 289 3 L. L. NNP www-nature-com-63 289 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 289 5 Liu Liu NNP www-nature-com-63 289 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 289 7 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 289 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 289 9 Chang Chang NNP www-nature-com-63 289 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 289 11 X. X. NNP www-nature-com-63 289 12 , , , www-nature-com-63 289 13 Liu Liu NNP www-nature-com-63 289 14 , , , www-nature-com-63 289 15 T. T. NNP www-nature-com-63 289 16 & & CC www-nature-com-63 289 17 Liu Liu NNP www-nature-com-63 289 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 289 19 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 290 1 Toward toward IN www-nature-com-63 290 2 conditionally conditionally RB www-nature-com-63 290 3 anonymous anonymous JJ www-nature-com-63 290 4 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 290 5 transactions transaction NNS www-nature-com-63 290 6 : : : www-nature-com-63 290 7 a a DT www-nature-com-63 290 8 lightweight lightweight JJ www-nature-com-63 290 9 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 290 10 script script NN www-nature-com-63 290 11 approach approach NN www-nature-com-63 290 12 . . . www-nature-com-63 291 1 Inf inf NN www-nature-com-63 291 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 292 1 Sci Sci NNP www-nature-com-63 292 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 293 1 509 509 CD www-nature-com-63 293 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 293 3 290–303 290–303 CD www-nature-com-63 293 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 293 5 2020 2020 CD www-nature-com-63 293 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 293 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 294 1 4 4 LS www-nature-com-63 294 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 295 1 Gallagher Gallagher NNP www-nature-com-63 295 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 295 3 K. K. NNP www-nature-com-63 295 4 S. S. NNP www-nature-com-63 295 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 295 6 Zhang Zhang NNP www-nature-com-63 295 7 , , , www-nature-com-63 295 8 F. F. NNP www-nature-com-63 295 9 , , , www-nature-com-63 295 10 Orvis Orvis NNP www-nature-com-63 295 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 295 12 R. R. NNP www-nature-com-63 295 13 , , , www-nature-com-63 295 14 Rissman Rissman NNP www-nature-com-63 295 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 295 16 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 296 1 & & CC www-nature-com-63 296 2 Liu Liu NNP www-nature-com-63 296 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 296 4 Q. Q. NNP www-nature-com-63 296 5 Assessing assess VBG www-nature-com-63 296 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 296 7 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 296 8 gaps gap NNS www-nature-com-63 296 9 for for IN www-nature-com-63 296 10 achieving achieve VBG www-nature-com-63 296 11 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 296 12 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 296 13 climate climate NN www-nature-com-63 296 14 targets target NNS www-nature-com-63 296 15 in in IN www-nature-com-63 296 16 the the DT www-nature-com-63 296 17 Paris Paris NNP www-nature-com-63 296 18 Agreement Agreement NNP www-nature-com-63 296 19 . . . www-nature-com-63 297 1 Nat Nat NNP www-nature-com-63 297 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 298 1 Commun Commun VBN www-nature-com-63 298 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 299 1 10 10 CD www-nature-com-63 299 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 299 3 1–10 1–10 CD www-nature-com-63 299 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 299 5 2019 2019 CD www-nature-com-63 299 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 299 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 300 1 5 5 CD www-nature-com-63 300 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 301 1 Jokar Jokar NNP www-nature-com-63 301 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 301 3 Z. Z. NNP www-nature-com-63 302 1 & & CC www-nature-com-63 302 2 Mokhtar Mokhtar NNP www-nature-com-63 302 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 302 4 A. a. NN www-nature-com-63 303 1 Policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 303 2 making making NN www-nature-com-63 303 3 in in IN www-nature-com-63 303 4 the the DT www-nature-com-63 303 5 cement cement NN www-nature-com-63 303 6 industry industry NN www-nature-com-63 303 7 for for IN www-nature-com-63 303 8 CO2 CO2 NNP www-nature-com-63 303 9 mitigation mitigation NN www-nature-com-63 303 10 on on IN www-nature-com-63 303 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 303 12 pathway pathway NN www-nature-com-63 303 13 of of IN www-nature-com-63 303 14 sustainable sustainable JJ www-nature-com-63 303 15 development development NN www-nature-com-63 303 16 - - : www-nature-com-63 303 17 A a NN www-nature-com-63 303 18 system system NN www-nature-com-63 303 19 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 303 20 approach approach NN www-nature-com-63 303 21 . . . www-nature-com-63 304 1 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 305 1 Clean clean JJ www-nature-com-63 305 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 306 1 Prod Prod NNP www-nature-com-63 306 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 307 1 201 201 CD www-nature-com-63 307 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 307 3 142–155 142–155 CD www-nature-com-63 307 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 307 5 2018 2018 CD www-nature-com-63 307 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 307 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 308 1 6 6 CD www-nature-com-63 308 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 309 1 Beckage beckage NN www-nature-com-63 309 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 309 3 B. B. NNP www-nature-com-63 309 4 et et NNP www-nature-com-63 309 5 al al NNP www-nature-com-63 309 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 310 1 Linking link VBG www-nature-com-63 310 2 models model NNS www-nature-com-63 310 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 310 4 human human JJ www-nature-com-63 310 5 behaviour behaviour NN www-nature-com-63 310 6 and and CC www-nature-com-63 310 7 climate climate NN www-nature-com-63 310 8 alters alter NNS www-nature-com-63 310 9 projected project VBD www-nature-com-63 310 10 climate climate NN www-nature-com-63 310 11 change change NN www-nature-com-63 310 12 . . . www-nature-com-63 311 1 Nat Nat NNP www-nature-com-63 311 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 312 1 Clim Clim NNP www-nature-com-63 312 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 313 1 Chang Chang NNP www-nature-com-63 313 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 314 1 8 8 CD www-nature-com-63 314 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 314 3 79–84 79–84 CD www-nature-com-63 314 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 314 5 2018 2018 CD www-nature-com-63 314 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 314 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 315 1 7 7 LS www-nature-com-63 315 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 316 1 Wang Wang NNP www-nature-com-63 316 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 316 3 D. D. NNP www-nature-com-63 316 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 316 5 Nie Nie NNP www-nature-com-63 316 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 316 7 R. R. NNP www-nature-com-63 316 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 316 9 Long Long NNP www-nature-com-63 316 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 316 11 R. R. NNP www-nature-com-63 316 12 , , , www-nature-com-63 316 13 Shi Shi NNP www-nature-com-63 316 14 , , , www-nature-com-63 316 15 R. R. NNP www-nature-com-63 316 16 & & CC www-nature-com-63 316 17 Zhao Zhao NNP www-nature-com-63 316 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 316 19 Y. Y. NNP www-nature-com-63 317 1 Scenario scenario NN www-nature-com-63 317 2 prediction prediction NN www-nature-com-63 317 3 of of IN www-nature-com-63 317 4 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 317 5 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 317 6 coal coal NN www-nature-com-63 317 7 production production NN www-nature-com-63 317 8 capacity capacity NN www-nature-com-63 317 9 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 317 10 on on IN www-nature-com-63 317 11 system system NN www-nature-com-63 317 12 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 317 13 model model NN www-nature-com-63 317 14 . . . www-nature-com-63 318 1 Resour Resour NNP www-nature-com-63 318 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 319 1 Conserv Conserv NNP www-nature-com-63 319 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 320 1 Recycl Recycl NNS www-nature-com-63 320 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 321 1 129 129 CD www-nature-com-63 321 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 321 3 432–442 432–442 CD www-nature-com-63 321 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 321 5 2018 2018 CD www-nature-com-63 321 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 321 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 322 1 8 8 LS www-nature-com-63 322 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 323 1 Hepburn Hepburn NNP www-nature-com-63 323 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 323 3 C. C. NNP www-nature-com-63 323 4 et et NNP www-nature-com-63 323 5 al al NNP www-nature-com-63 323 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 324 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 324 2 technological technological JJ www-nature-com-63 324 3 and and CC www-nature-com-63 324 4 economic economic JJ www-nature-com-63 324 5 prospects prospect NNS www-nature-com-63 324 6 for for IN www-nature-com-63 324 7 CO2 CO2 NNP www-nature-com-63 324 8 utilization utilization NN www-nature-com-63 324 9 and and CC www-nature-com-63 324 10 removal removal NN www-nature-com-63 324 11 . . . www-nature-com-63 325 1 Nature nature NN www-nature-com-63 325 2 575 575 CD www-nature-com-63 325 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 325 4 87–97 87–97 CD www-nature-com-63 325 5 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 325 6 2019 2019 CD www-nature-com-63 325 7 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 325 8 . . . www-nature-com-63 326 1 9 9 CD www-nature-com-63 326 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 327 1 Stave stave NN www-nature-com-63 327 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 327 3 K. K. NNP www-nature-com-63 327 4 A. a. NN www-nature-com-63 328 1 A a DT www-nature-com-63 328 2 system system NN www-nature-com-63 328 3 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 328 4 model model NN www-nature-com-63 328 5 to to TO www-nature-com-63 328 6 facilitate facilitate VB www-nature-com-63 328 7 public public JJ www-nature-com-63 328 8 understanding understanding NN www-nature-com-63 328 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 328 10 water water NN www-nature-com-63 328 11 management management NN www-nature-com-63 328 12 options option NNS www-nature-com-63 328 13 in in IN www-nature-com-63 328 14 Las Las NNP www-nature-com-63 328 15 Vegas Vegas NNP www-nature-com-63 328 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 328 17 Nevada Nevada NNP www-nature-com-63 328 18 . . . www-nature-com-63 329 1 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 329 2 Environ Environ NNP www-nature-com-63 329 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 330 1 Manag Manag NNP www-nature-com-63 330 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 331 1 67 67 CD www-nature-com-63 331 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 331 3 303–313 303–313 CD www-nature-com-63 331 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 331 5 2003 2003 CD www-nature-com-63 331 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 331 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 332 1 10 10 CD www-nature-com-63 332 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 333 1 Wu Wu NNP www-nature-com-63 333 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 333 3 S. S. NNP www-nature-com-63 333 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 333 5 Liu Liu NNP www-nature-com-63 333 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 333 7 L. L. NNP www-nature-com-63 333 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 333 9 Gao Gao NNP www-nature-com-63 333 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 333 11 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 334 1 & & CC www-nature-com-63 334 2 Wang Wang NNP www-nature-com-63 334 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 334 4 W. W. NNP www-nature-com-63 334 5 Integrate Integrate NNP www-nature-com-63 334 6 risk risk NN www-nature-com-63 334 7 from from IN www-nature-com-63 334 8 climate climate NN www-nature-com-63 334 9 change change NN www-nature-com-63 334 10 in in IN www-nature-com-63 334 11 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 334 12 under under IN www-nature-com-63 334 13 global global JJ www-nature-com-63 334 14 warming warming NN www-nature-com-63 334 15 of of IN www-nature-com-63 334 16 1.5 1.5 CD www-nature-com-63 334 17 and and CC www-nature-com-63 334 18 2.0 2.0 CD www-nature-com-63 334 19 ° ° NNS www-nature-com-63 334 20 C c NN www-nature-com-63 334 21 . . . www-nature-com-63 335 1 Earth Earth NNP www-nature-com-63 335 2 ’s ’s , www-nature-com-63 335 3 Futur Futur NNP www-nature-com-63 335 4 . . . www-nature-com-63 336 1 7 7 CD www-nature-com-63 336 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 336 3 1307–1322 1307–1322 CD www-nature-com-63 336 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 336 5 2019 2019 CD www-nature-com-63 336 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 336 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 337 1 11 11 CD www-nature-com-63 337 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 338 1 Magnani Magnani NNP www-nature-com-63 338 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 338 3 F. F. NNP www-nature-com-63 338 4 et et NNP www-nature-com-63 338 5 al al NNP www-nature-com-63 338 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 339 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 339 2 human human JJ www-nature-com-63 339 3 footprint footprint NN www-nature-com-63 339 4 in in IN www-nature-com-63 339 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 339 6 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 339 7 cycle cycle NN www-nature-com-63 339 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 339 9 temperate temperate NN www-nature-com-63 339 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 339 11 boreal boreal NN www-nature-com-63 339 12 forests forest NNS www-nature-com-63 339 13 . . . www-nature-com-63 340 1 Nature nature NN www-nature-com-63 340 2 447 447 CD www-nature-com-63 340 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 340 4 849–851 849–851 CD www-nature-com-63 340 5 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 340 6 2007 2007 CD www-nature-com-63 340 7 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 340 8 . . . www-nature-com-63 341 1 12 12 CD www-nature-com-63 341 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 342 1 Lenzen Lenzen NNP www-nature-com-63 342 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 342 3 M. M. NNP www-nature-com-63 342 4 et et NNP www-nature-com-63 342 5 al al NNP www-nature-com-63 342 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 343 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 343 2 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 343 3 footprint footprint NN www-nature-com-63 343 4 of of IN www-nature-com-63 343 5 global global JJ www-nature-com-63 343 6 tourism tourism NN www-nature-com-63 343 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 344 1 Nat Nat NNP www-nature-com-63 344 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 345 1 Clim Clim NNP www-nature-com-63 345 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 346 1 Chang Chang NNP www-nature-com-63 346 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 347 1 8 8 CD www-nature-com-63 347 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 347 3 522–528 522–528 CD www-nature-com-63 347 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 347 5 2018 2018 CD www-nature-com-63 347 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 347 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 348 1 13 13 CD www-nature-com-63 348 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 349 1 Stoll Stoll NNP www-nature-com-63 349 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 349 3 C. C. NNP www-nature-com-63 349 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 349 5 Klaaßen Klaaßen NNP www-nature-com-63 349 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 349 7 L. L. NNP www-nature-com-63 349 8 & & CC www-nature-com-63 349 9 Gallersdörfer Gallersdörfer NNP www-nature-com-63 349 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 349 11 U. U. NNP www-nature-com-63 350 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 350 2 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 350 3 footprint footprint NN www-nature-com-63 350 4 of of IN www-nature-com-63 350 5 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-nature-com-63 350 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 351 1 Joule Joule NNP www-nature-com-63 351 2 3 3 CD www-nature-com-63 351 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 351 4 1647–1661 1647–1661 CD www-nature-com-63 351 5 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 351 6 2019 2019 CD www-nature-com-63 351 7 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 351 8 . . . www-nature-com-63 352 1 14 14 CD www-nature-com-63 352 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 353 1 Cheng Cheng NNP www-nature-com-63 353 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 353 3 Y. Y. NNP www-nature-com-63 353 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 353 5 Du Du NNP www-nature-com-63 353 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 353 7 D. D. NNP www-nature-com-63 353 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 353 9 & & CC www-nature-com-63 353 10 Han Han NNP www-nature-com-63 353 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 353 12 Q. Q. NNP www-nature-com-63 354 1 A a DT www-nature-com-63 354 2 hashing hash VBG www-nature-com-63 354 3 power power NN www-nature-com-63 354 4 allocation allocation NN www-nature-com-63 354 5 game game NN www-nature-com-63 354 6 in in IN www-nature-com-63 354 7 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-nature-com-63 354 8 . . . www-nature-com-63 355 1 Lect Lect NNP www-nature-com-63 355 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 356 1 Notes Notes NNPS www-nature-com-63 356 2 Comput Comput NNP www-nature-com-63 356 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 357 1 Sci Sci NNP www-nature-com-63 357 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 358 1 11059 11059 CD www-nature-com-63 358 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 358 3 226–238 226–238 CD www-nature-com-63 358 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 358 5 2018 2018 CD www-nature-com-63 358 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 358 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 359 1 15 15 CD www-nature-com-63 359 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 360 1 Vranken Vranken NNP www-nature-com-63 360 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 360 3 H. H. NNP www-nature-com-63 360 4 Sustainability Sustainability NNP www-nature-com-63 360 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 360 6 bitcoin bitcoin NN www-nature-com-63 360 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 360 8 blockchains blockchain NNS www-nature-com-63 360 9 . . . www-nature-com-63 361 1 Curr curr UH www-nature-com-63 361 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 362 1 Opin opin JJ www-nature-com-63 362 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 363 1 Environ Environ NNP www-nature-com-63 363 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 364 1 Sustain sustain NN www-nature-com-63 364 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 365 1 28 28 CD www-nature-com-63 365 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 365 3 1–9 1–9 CD www-nature-com-63 365 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 365 5 2017 2017 CD www-nature-com-63 365 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 365 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 366 1 16 16 CD www-nature-com-63 366 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 367 1 Küfeoğlu Küfeoğlu NNP www-nature-com-63 367 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 367 3 S. S. NNP www-nature-com-63 367 4 & & CC www-nature-com-63 367 5 Özkuran Özkuran NNP www-nature-com-63 367 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 367 7 M. M. NNP www-nature-com-63 367 8 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 367 9 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 367 10 : : : www-nature-com-63 367 11 a a DT www-nature-com-63 367 12 global global JJ www-nature-com-63 367 13 review review NN www-nature-com-63 367 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 367 15 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 367 16 and and CC www-nature-com-63 367 17 power power NN www-nature-com-63 367 18 demand demand NN www-nature-com-63 367 19 . . . www-nature-com-63 367 20 Energy Energy NNP www-nature-com-63 367 21 Res Res NNP www-nature-com-63 367 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 368 1 Soc Soc NNP www-nature-com-63 368 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 369 1 Sci Sci NNP www-nature-com-63 369 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 370 1 58 58 CD www-nature-com-63 370 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 370 3 101273 101273 CD www-nature-com-63 370 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 370 5 2019 2019 CD www-nature-com-63 370 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 370 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 371 1 17 17 CD www-nature-com-63 371 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 372 1 Krause Krause NNP www-nature-com-63 372 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 372 3 M. M. NNP www-nature-com-63 372 4 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 373 1 & & CC www-nature-com-63 373 2 Tolaymat Tolaymat NNP www-nature-com-63 373 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 373 4 T. T. NNP www-nature-com-63 373 5 Quantification quantification NN www-nature-com-63 373 6 of of IN www-nature-com-63 373 7 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 373 8 and and CC www-nature-com-63 373 9 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 373 10 costs cost NNS www-nature-com-63 373 11 for for IN www-nature-com-63 373 12 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 373 13 cryptocurrencies cryptocurrencie NNS www-nature-com-63 373 14 . . . www-nature-com-63 374 1 Nat Nat NNP www-nature-com-63 374 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 375 1 Sustain sustain NN www-nature-com-63 375 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 376 1 1 1 CD www-nature-com-63 376 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 376 3 711–718 711–718 CD www-nature-com-63 376 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 376 5 2018 2018 CD www-nature-com-63 376 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 376 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 377 1 18 18 CD www-nature-com-63 377 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 378 1 Liu Liu NNP www-nature-com-63 378 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 378 3 Z. Z. NNP www-nature-com-63 378 4 et et FW www-nature-com-63 378 5 al al NNP www-nature-com-63 378 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 379 1 Reduced reduced JJ www-nature-com-63 379 2 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 379 3 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 379 4 estimates estimate VBZ www-nature-com-63 379 5 from from IN www-nature-com-63 379 6 fossil fossil JJ www-nature-com-63 379 7 fuel fuel NN www-nature-com-63 379 8 combustion combustion NN www-nature-com-63 379 9 and and CC www-nature-com-63 379 10 cement cement NN www-nature-com-63 379 11 production production NN www-nature-com-63 379 12 in in IN www-nature-com-63 379 13 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 379 14 . . . www-nature-com-63 380 1 Nature nature NN www-nature-com-63 380 2 524 524 CD www-nature-com-63 380 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 380 4 335–338 335–338 CD www-nature-com-63 380 5 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 380 6 2015 2015 CD www-nature-com-63 380 7 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 380 8 . . . www-nature-com-63 381 1 19 19 CD www-nature-com-63 381 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 382 1 Aldy aldy UH www-nature-com-63 382 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 382 3 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 382 4 et et NNP www-nature-com-63 382 5 al al NNP www-nature-com-63 382 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 383 1 Economic economic JJ www-nature-com-63 383 2 tools tool NNS www-nature-com-63 383 3 to to TO www-nature-com-63 383 4 promote promote VB www-nature-com-63 383 5 transparency transparency NN www-nature-com-63 383 6 and and CC www-nature-com-63 383 7 comparability comparability NN www-nature-com-63 383 8 in in IN www-nature-com-63 383 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 383 10 Paris Paris NNP www-nature-com-63 383 11 Agreement Agreement NNP www-nature-com-63 383 12 . . . www-nature-com-63 384 1 Nat Nat NNP www-nature-com-63 384 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 385 1 Clim Clim NNP www-nature-com-63 385 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 386 1 Chang Chang NNP www-nature-com-63 386 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 387 1 6 6 CD www-nature-com-63 387 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 387 3 1000–1004 1000–1004 CD www-nature-com-63 387 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 387 5 2016 2016 CD www-nature-com-63 387 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 387 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 388 1 20 20 CD www-nature-com-63 388 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 388 3 du du NNP www-nature-com-63 388 4 Pont Pont NNP www-nature-com-63 388 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 388 6 Y. Y. NNP www-nature-com-63 388 7 R. R. NNP www-nature-com-63 388 8 et et NNP www-nature-com-63 388 9 al al NNP www-nature-com-63 388 10 . . . www-nature-com-63 389 1 Equitable equitable VB www-nature-com-63 389 2 mitigation mitigation NN www-nature-com-63 389 3 to to TO www-nature-com-63 389 4 achieve achieve VB www-nature-com-63 389 5 the the DT www-nature-com-63 389 6 Paris Paris NNP www-nature-com-63 389 7 Agreement Agreement NNP www-nature-com-63 389 8 goals goal NNS www-nature-com-63 389 9 . . . www-nature-com-63 390 1 Nat Nat NNP www-nature-com-63 390 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 391 1 Clim Clim NNP www-nature-com-63 391 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 392 1 Chang Chang NNP www-nature-com-63 392 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 393 1 7 7 CD www-nature-com-63 393 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 393 3 38–43 38–43 CD www-nature-com-63 393 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 393 5 2017 2017 CD www-nature-com-63 393 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 393 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 394 1 21 21 CD www-nature-com-63 394 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 395 1 Tang Tang NNP www-nature-com-63 395 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 395 3 L. L. NNP www-nature-com-63 395 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 395 5 Wu Wu NNP www-nature-com-63 395 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 395 7 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 395 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 395 9 Yu Yu NNP www-nature-com-63 395 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 395 11 L. L. NNP www-nature-com-63 395 12 & & CC www-nature-com-63 395 13 Bao Bao NNP www-nature-com-63 395 14 , , , www-nature-com-63 395 15 Q. Q. NNP www-nature-com-63 396 1 Carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 396 2 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 396 3 trading trading NN www-nature-com-63 396 4 scheme scheme NN www-nature-com-63 396 5 exploration exploration NN www-nature-com-63 396 6 in in IN www-nature-com-63 396 7 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 396 8 : : : www-nature-com-63 396 9 a a DT www-nature-com-63 396 10 multi multi JJ www-nature-com-63 396 11 - - JJ www-nature-com-63 396 12 agent agent NN www-nature-com-63 396 13 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 396 14 based base VBN www-nature-com-63 396 15 model model NN www-nature-com-63 396 16 . . . www-nature-com-63 397 1 Energy Energy NNP www-nature-com-63 397 2 Policy Policy NNP www-nature-com-63 397 3 81 81 CD www-nature-com-63 397 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 397 5 152–169 152–169 CD www-nature-com-63 397 6 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 397 7 2015 2015 CD www-nature-com-63 397 8 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 397 9 . . . www-nature-com-63 398 1 22 22 CD www-nature-com-63 398 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 399 1 Schleussner Schleussner NNP www-nature-com-63 399 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 399 3 C. C. NNP www-nature-com-63 399 4 F. F. NNP www-nature-com-63 399 5 et et NNP www-nature-com-63 399 6 al al NNP www-nature-com-63 399 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 400 1 Science science NN www-nature-com-63 400 2 and and CC www-nature-com-63 400 3 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 400 4 characteristics characteristic NNS www-nature-com-63 400 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 400 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 400 7 Paris Paris NNP www-nature-com-63 400 8 Agreement Agreement NNP www-nature-com-63 400 9 temperature temperature NN www-nature-com-63 400 10 goal goal NN www-nature-com-63 400 11 . . . www-nature-com-63 401 1 Nat Nat NNP www-nature-com-63 401 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 402 1 Clim Clim NNP www-nature-com-63 402 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 403 1 Chang Chang NNP www-nature-com-63 403 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 404 1 6 6 CD www-nature-com-63 404 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 404 3 827–835 827–835 CD www-nature-com-63 404 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 404 5 2016 2016 CD www-nature-com-63 404 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 404 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 405 1 23 23 CD www-nature-com-63 405 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 406 1 Rogelj Rogelj NNP www-nature-com-63 406 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 406 3 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 406 4 et et NNP www-nature-com-63 406 5 al al NNP www-nature-com-63 406 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 407 1 Paris Paris NNP www-nature-com-63 407 2 Agreement Agreement NNP www-nature-com-63 407 3 climate climate NN www-nature-com-63 407 4 proposals proposal NNS www-nature-com-63 407 5 need need VBP www-nature-com-63 407 6 a a DT www-nature-com-63 407 7 boost boost NN www-nature-com-63 407 8 to to TO www-nature-com-63 407 9 keep keep VB www-nature-com-63 407 10 warming warm VBG www-nature-com-63 407 11 well well RB www-nature-com-63 407 12 below below IN www-nature-com-63 407 13 2 2 CD www-nature-com-63 407 14 C. C. NNP www-nature-com-63 407 15 Nature Nature NNP www-nature-com-63 407 16 534 534 CD www-nature-com-63 407 17 , , , www-nature-com-63 407 18 631–639 631–639 CD www-nature-com-63 407 19 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 407 20 2016 2016 CD www-nature-com-63 407 21 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 407 22 . . . www-nature-com-63 408 1 24 24 CD www-nature-com-63 408 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 409 1 Holt Holt NNP www-nature-com-63 409 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 409 3 C. C. NNP www-nature-com-63 409 4 A. A. NNP www-nature-com-63 410 1 & & CC www-nature-com-63 410 2 Laury Laury NNP www-nature-com-63 410 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 410 4 S. S. NNP www-nature-com-63 410 5 K. K. NNP www-nature-com-63 410 6 Risk Risk NNP www-nature-com-63 410 7 aversion aversion NN www-nature-com-63 410 8 and and CC www-nature-com-63 410 9 incentive incentive NN www-nature-com-63 410 10 effects effect NNS www-nature-com-63 410 11 : : : www-nature-com-63 410 12 new new JJ www-nature-com-63 410 13 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 410 14 without without IN www-nature-com-63 410 15 order order NN www-nature-com-63 410 16 effects effect NNS www-nature-com-63 410 17 . . . www-nature-com-63 411 1 Am Am NNP www-nature-com-63 411 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 412 1 Econ Econ NNP www-nature-com-63 412 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 413 1 Rev. Rev. NNP www-nature-com-63 414 1 95 95 CD www-nature-com-63 414 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 414 3 902–912 902–912 CD www-nature-com-63 414 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 414 5 2005 2005 CD www-nature-com-63 414 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 414 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 415 1 25 25 CD www-nature-com-63 415 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 416 1 Newell Newell NNP www-nature-com-63 416 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 416 3 R. R. NNP www-nature-com-63 416 4 G. G. NNP www-nature-com-63 416 5 , , , www-nature-com-63 416 6 Jaffe Jaffe NNP www-nature-com-63 416 7 , , , www-nature-com-63 416 8 A. A. NNP www-nature-com-63 417 1 B. B. NNP www-nature-com-63 418 1 & & CC www-nature-com-63 418 2 Stavins Stavins NNP www-nature-com-63 418 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 418 4 R. R. NNP www-nature-com-63 418 5 N. N. NNP www-nature-com-63 418 6 The the DT www-nature-com-63 418 7 effects effect NNS www-nature-com-63 418 8 of of IN www-nature-com-63 418 9 economic economic JJ www-nature-com-63 418 10 and and CC www-nature-com-63 418 11 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 418 12 incentives incentive NNS www-nature-com-63 418 13 on on IN www-nature-com-63 418 14 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 418 15 mitigation mitigation NN www-nature-com-63 418 16 technologies technology NNS www-nature-com-63 418 17 . . . www-nature-com-63 419 1 Energy Energy NNP www-nature-com-63 419 2 Econ Econ NNP www-nature-com-63 419 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 420 1 28 28 CD www-nature-com-63 420 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 420 3 563–578 563–578 CD www-nature-com-63 420 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 420 5 2006 2006 CD www-nature-com-63 420 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 420 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 421 1 26 26 CD www-nature-com-63 421 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 422 1 Ioannou Ioannou NNP www-nature-com-63 422 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 422 3 I. I. NNP www-nature-com-63 422 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 422 5 Li Li NNP www-nature-com-63 422 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 422 7 S. S. NNP www-nature-com-63 422 8 X. X. NNP www-nature-com-63 423 1 & & CC www-nature-com-63 423 2 Serafeim Serafeim NNP www-nature-com-63 423 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 423 4 G. G. NNP www-nature-com-63 423 5 The the DT www-nature-com-63 423 6 effect effect NN www-nature-com-63 423 7 of of IN www-nature-com-63 423 8 target target NN www-nature-com-63 423 9 difficulty difficulty NN www-nature-com-63 423 10 on on IN www-nature-com-63 423 11 target target NN www-nature-com-63 423 12 completion completion NN www-nature-com-63 423 13 : : : www-nature-com-63 423 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 423 15 case case NN www-nature-com-63 423 16 of of IN www-nature-com-63 423 17 reducing reduce VBG www-nature-com-63 423 18 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 423 19 emissions emission NNS www-nature-com-63 423 20 . . . www-nature-com-63 424 1 Account Account NNP www-nature-com-63 424 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 425 1 Rev. Rev. NNP www-nature-com-63 426 1 91 91 CD www-nature-com-63 426 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 426 3 1467–1492 1467–1492 CD www-nature-com-63 426 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 426 5 2016 2016 CD www-nature-com-63 426 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 426 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 427 1 27 27 CD www-nature-com-63 427 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 428 1 Hagmann Hagmann NNP www-nature-com-63 428 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 428 3 D. D. NNP www-nature-com-63 428 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 428 5 Ho Ho NNP www-nature-com-63 428 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 428 7 E. E. NNP www-nature-com-63 428 8 H. H. NNP www-nature-com-63 428 9 & & CC www-nature-com-63 428 10 Loewenstein Loewenstein NNP www-nature-com-63 428 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 428 12 G. G. NNP www-nature-com-63 428 13 Nudging Nudging NNP www-nature-com-63 428 14 out out RP www-nature-com-63 428 15 support support NN www-nature-com-63 428 16 for for IN www-nature-com-63 428 17 a a DT www-nature-com-63 428 18 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 428 19 tax tax NN www-nature-com-63 428 20 . . . www-nature-com-63 429 1 Nat Nat NNP www-nature-com-63 429 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 430 1 Clim Clim NNP www-nature-com-63 430 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 431 1 Chang Chang NNP www-nature-com-63 431 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 432 1 9 9 CD www-nature-com-63 432 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 432 3 484–489 484–489 CD www-nature-com-63 432 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 432 5 2019 2019 CD www-nature-com-63 432 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 432 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 433 1 28 28 CD www-nature-com-63 433 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 433 3 van van NNP www-nature-com-63 433 4 der der NNP www-nature-com-63 433 5 Waal Waal NNP www-nature-com-63 433 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 433 7 M. M. NNP www-nature-com-63 433 8 B. B. NNP www-nature-com-63 433 9 et et NNP www-nature-com-63 433 10 al al NNP www-nature-com-63 433 11 . . . www-nature-com-63 434 1 Blockchain Blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 434 2 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 434 3 facilitated facilitate VBN www-nature-com-63 434 4 sharing sharing NN www-nature-com-63 434 5 to to TO www-nature-com-63 434 6 advance advance VB www-nature-com-63 434 7 outbreak outbreak NN www-nature-com-63 434 8 R&D. r&d. CD www-nature-com-63 435 1 Science Science NNP www-nature-com-63 435 2 368 368 CD www-nature-com-63 435 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 435 4 719–721 719–721 CD www-nature-com-63 435 5 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 435 6 2020 2020 CD www-nature-com-63 435 7 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 435 8 . . . www-nature-com-63 436 1 29 29 CD www-nature-com-63 436 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 437 1 Saberi Saberi NNP www-nature-com-63 437 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 437 3 S. S. NNP www-nature-com-63 437 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 437 5 Kouhizadeh Kouhizadeh NNP www-nature-com-63 437 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 437 7 M. M. NNP www-nature-com-63 437 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 437 9 Sarkis Sarkis NNP www-nature-com-63 437 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 437 11 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 438 1 & & CC www-nature-com-63 438 2 Shen Shen NNP www-nature-com-63 438 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 438 4 L. L. NNP www-nature-com-63 438 5 Blockchain Blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 438 6 technology technology NN www-nature-com-63 438 7 and and CC www-nature-com-63 438 8 its -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 438 9 relationships relationship NNS www-nature-com-63 438 10 to to IN www-nature-com-63 438 11 sustainable sustainable JJ www-nature-com-63 438 12 supply supply NN www-nature-com-63 438 13 chain chain NN www-nature-com-63 438 14 management management NN www-nature-com-63 438 15 . . . www-nature-com-63 439 1 Int Int NNP www-nature-com-63 439 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 440 1 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 441 1 Prod Prod NNP www-nature-com-63 441 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 442 1 Res Res NNP www-nature-com-63 442 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 443 1 57 57 CD www-nature-com-63 443 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 443 3 2117–2135 2117–2135 CD www-nature-com-63 443 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 443 5 2019 2019 CD www-nature-com-63 443 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 443 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 444 1 30 30 CD www-nature-com-63 444 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 445 1 Karamitsos Karamitsos NNP www-nature-com-63 445 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 445 3 I. I. NNP www-nature-com-63 445 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 445 5 Papadaki Papadaki NNP www-nature-com-63 445 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 445 7 M. M. NNP www-nature-com-63 445 8 & & CC www-nature-com-63 445 9 Al Al NNP www-nature-com-63 445 10 Barghuthi Barghuthi NNP www-nature-com-63 445 11 , , , www-nature-com-63 445 12 N. N. NNP www-nature-com-63 445 13 B. B. NNP www-nature-com-63 446 1 Design design NN www-nature-com-63 446 2 of of IN www-nature-com-63 446 3 the the DT www-nature-com-63 446 4 blockchain blockchain NNP www-nature-com-63 446 5 smart smart JJ www-nature-com-63 446 6 contract contract NN www-nature-com-63 446 7 : : : www-nature-com-63 446 8 a a DT www-nature-com-63 446 9 use use NN www-nature-com-63 446 10 case case NN www-nature-com-63 446 11 for for IN www-nature-com-63 446 12 real real JJ www-nature-com-63 446 13 estate estate NN www-nature-com-63 446 14 . . . www-nature-com-63 447 1 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 447 2 Inf Inf NNP www-nature-com-63 447 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 448 1 Secur secur NN www-nature-com-63 448 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 449 1 9 9 CD www-nature-com-63 449 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 449 3 177–190 177–190 CD www-nature-com-63 449 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 449 5 2018 2018 CD www-nature-com-63 449 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 449 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 450 1 31 31 CD www-nature-com-63 450 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 451 1 Jessel Jessel NNP www-nature-com-63 451 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 451 3 B. B. NNP www-nature-com-63 452 1 & & CC www-nature-com-63 452 2 DiCaprio DiCaprio NNP www-nature-com-63 452 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 452 4 A. a. NN www-nature-com-63 453 1 Can Can MD www-nature-com-63 453 2 blockchain blockchain VB www-nature-com-63 453 3 make make VB www-nature-com-63 453 4 trade trade NN www-nature-com-63 453 5 finance finance NN www-nature-com-63 453 6 more more RBR www-nature-com-63 453 7 inclusive inclusive JJ www-nature-com-63 453 8 ? ? . www-nature-com-63 454 1 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 454 2 Financ Financ NNP www-nature-com-63 454 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 455 1 Transform transform NN www-nature-com-63 455 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 456 1 47 47 CD www-nature-com-63 456 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 456 3 35–50 35–50 CD www-nature-com-63 456 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 456 5 2018 2018 CD www-nature-com-63 456 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 456 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 457 1 32 32 CD www-nature-com-63 457 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 458 1 Leng Leng NNP www-nature-com-63 458 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 458 3 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 458 4 et et NNP www-nature-com-63 458 5 al al NNP www-nature-com-63 458 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 459 1 Makerchain makerchain NN www-nature-com-63 459 2 : : : www-nature-com-63 459 3 a a DT www-nature-com-63 459 4 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 459 5 with with IN www-nature-com-63 459 6 chemical chemical JJ www-nature-com-63 459 7 signature signature NN www-nature-com-63 459 8 for for IN www-nature-com-63 459 9 self- self- NN www-nature-com-63 459 10 organizing organizing NN www-nature-com-63 459 11 process process NN www-nature-com-63 459 12 in in IN www-nature-com-63 459 13 social social JJ www-nature-com-63 459 14 manufacturing manufacturing NN www-nature-com-63 459 15 . . . www-nature-com-63 460 1 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 461 1 Clean clean JJ www-nature-com-63 461 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 462 1 Prod Prod NNP www-nature-com-63 462 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 463 1 234 234 CD www-nature-com-63 463 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 463 3 767–778 767–778 CD www-nature-com-63 463 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 463 5 2019 2019 CD www-nature-com-63 463 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 463 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 464 1 33 33 CD www-nature-com-63 464 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 465 1 Lane Lane NNP www-nature-com-63 465 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 465 3 D. D. NNP www-nature-com-63 465 4 C. C. NNP www-nature-com-63 465 5 Diagramming Diagramming NNP www-nature-com-63 465 6 conventions convention NNS www-nature-com-63 465 7 in in IN www-nature-com-63 465 8 system system NN www-nature-com-63 465 9 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 465 10 . . . www-nature-com-63 466 1 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 466 2 Oper Oper NNP www-nature-com-63 466 3 . . . www-nature-com-63 467 1 Res Res NNP www-nature-com-63 467 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 468 1 Soc Soc NNP www-nature-com-63 468 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 469 1 51 51 CD www-nature-com-63 469 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 469 3 241–245 241–245 CD www-nature-com-63 469 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 469 5 2000 2000 CD www-nature-com-63 469 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 469 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 470 1 34 34 CD www-nature-com-63 470 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 471 1 Richardson Richardson NNP www-nature-com-63 471 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 471 3 G. G. NNP www-nature-com-63 471 4 P. P. NNP www-nature-com-63 471 5 Reflections Reflections NNP www-nature-com-63 471 6 on on IN www-nature-com-63 471 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 471 8 foundations foundation NNS www-nature-com-63 471 9 of of IN www-nature-com-63 471 10 system system NN www-nature-com-63 471 11 dynamics dynamic NNS www-nature-com-63 471 12 . . . www-nature-com-63 472 1 Syst Syst NNP www-nature-com-63 472 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 473 1 Dyn Dyn NNP www-nature-com-63 473 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 474 1 Rev. Rev. NNP www-nature-com-63 475 1 27 27 CD www-nature-com-63 475 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 475 3 219–243 219–243 CD www-nature-com-63 475 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 475 5 2011 2011 CD www-nature-com-63 475 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 475 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 476 1 35 35 CD www-nature-com-63 476 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 477 1 Cheng Cheng NNP www-nature-com-63 477 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 477 3 Z. Z. NNP www-nature-com-63 477 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 477 5 Li Li NNP www-nature-com-63 477 6 , , , www-nature-com-63 477 7 L. L. NNP www-nature-com-63 477 8 & & CC www-nature-com-63 477 9 Liu Liu NNP www-nature-com-63 477 10 , , , www-nature-com-63 477 11 J. J. NNP www-nature-com-63 478 1 Industrial industrial JJ www-nature-com-63 478 2 structure structure NN www-nature-com-63 478 3 , , , www-nature-com-63 478 4 technical technical JJ www-nature-com-63 478 5 progress progress NN www-nature-com-63 478 6 and and CC www-nature-com-63 478 7 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 478 8 intensity intensity NN www-nature-com-63 478 9 in in IN www-nature-com-63 478 10 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 478 11 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 478 12 provinces province NNS www-nature-com-63 478 13 . . . www-nature-com-63 479 1 Renew renew VB www-nature-com-63 479 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 480 1 Sust Sust NNP www-nature-com-63 480 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 481 1 Energ Energ NNP www-nature-com-63 481 2 . . . www-nature-com-63 482 1 Rev. Rev. NNP www-nature-com-63 483 1 81 81 CD www-nature-com-63 483 2 , , , www-nature-com-63 483 3 2935–2946 2935–2946 CD www-nature-com-63 483 4 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 483 5 2018 2018 CD www-nature-com-63 483 6 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 483 7 . . . www-nature-com-63 484 1 Acknowledgements acknowledgement NNS www-nature-com-63 484 2 This this DT www-nature-com-63 484 3 work work NN www-nature-com-63 484 4 was be VBD www-nature-com-63 484 5 supported support VBN www-nature-com-63 484 6 by by IN www-nature-com-63 484 7 grants grant NNS www-nature-com-63 484 8 from from IN www-nature-com-63 484 9 the the DT www-nature-com-63 484 10 National National NNP www-nature-com-63 484 11 Natural Natural NNP www-nature-com-63 484 12 Science Science NNP www-nature-com-63 484 13 Foundation Foundation NNP www-nature-com-63 484 14 of of IN www-nature-com-63 484 15 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 484 16 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 484 17 71988101 71988101 CD www-nature-com-63 484 18 and and CC www-nature-com-63 484 19 72022019 72022019 CD www-nature-com-63 484 20 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 484 21 . . . www-nature-com-63 485 1 Author author NN www-nature-com-63 485 2 contributions contribution NNS www-nature-com-63 485 3 S.J. S.J. NNP www-nature-com-63 486 1 and and CC www-nature-com-63 486 2 Y.L. Y.L. NNP www-nature-com-63 487 1 contributed contribute VBD www-nature-com-63 487 2 to to IN www-nature-com-63 487 3 conceptualizing conceptualize VBG www-nature-com-63 487 4 and and CC www-nature-com-63 487 5 designing design VBG www-nature-com-63 487 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 487 7 work work NN www-nature-com-63 487 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 487 9 acquiring acquire VBG www-nature-com-63 487 10 the the DT www-nature-com-63 487 11 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 487 12 , , , www-nature-com-63 487 13 conducting conduct VBG www-nature-com-63 487 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 487 15 analysis analysis NN www-nature-com-63 487 16 , , , www-nature-com-63 487 17 interpreting interpret VBG www-nature-com-63 487 18 the the DT www-nature-com-63 487 19 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 487 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 487 21 writing writing NN www-nature-com-63 487 22 , , , www-nature-com-63 487 23 and and CC www-nature-com-63 487 24 revising revising NN www-nature-com-63 487 25 of of IN www-nature-com-63 487 26 the the DT www-nature-com-63 487 27 paper paper NN www-nature-com-63 487 28 . . . www-nature-com-63 488 1 Q.L. Q.L. NNP www-nature-com-63 489 1 interpreted interpret VBD www-nature-com-63 489 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 489 3 data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 489 4 . . . www-nature-com-63 490 1 Y.H. Y.H. NNP www-nature-com-63 491 1 revised revise VBD www-nature-com-63 491 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 491 3 paper paper NN www-nature-com-63 491 4 . . . www-nature-com-63 492 1 D.G. D.G. NNP www-nature-com-63 493 1 revised revise VBD www-nature-com-63 493 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 493 3 paper paper NN www-nature-com-63 493 4 and and CC www-nature-com-63 493 5 supervised supervise VBD www-nature-com-63 493 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 493 7 work work NN www-nature-com-63 493 8 . . . www-nature-com-63 494 1 Y.X. Y.X. NNP www-nature-com-63 495 1 revised revise VBD www-nature-com-63 495 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 495 3 paper paper NN www-nature-com-63 495 4 . . . www-nature-com-63 496 1 S.W. S.W. NNP www-nature-com-63 497 1 conceptualized conceptualize VBD www-nature-com-63 497 2 the the DT www-nature-com-63 497 3 work work NN www-nature-com-63 497 4 , , , www-nature-com-63 497 5 revised revise VBD www-nature-com-63 497 6 the the DT www-nature-com-63 497 7 paper paper NN www-nature-com-63 497 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 497 9 and and CC www-nature-com-63 497 10 supervised supervise VBD www-nature-com-63 497 11 the the DT www-nature-com-63 497 12 work work NN www-nature-com-63 497 13 . . . www-nature-com-63 498 1 Competing compete VBG www-nature-com-63 498 2 interests interest NNS www-nature-com-63 498 3 The the DT www-nature-com-63 498 4 authors author NNS www-nature-com-63 498 5 declare declare VBP www-nature-com-63 498 6 no no DT www-nature-com-63 498 7 competing compete VBG www-nature-com-63 498 8 interests interest NNS www-nature-com-63 498 9 . . . www-nature-com-63 499 1 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 499 2 COMMUNICATIONS COMMUNICATIONS NNPS www-nature-com-63 499 3 | | CD www-nature-com-63 499 4 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 499 5 ARTICLE article NN www-nature-com-63 499 6 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 499 7 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 499 8 | | CD www-nature-com-63 499 9 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 499 10 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 499 11 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 499 12 12:1938 12:1938 CD www-nature-com-63 499 13 | | CD www-nature-com-63 499 14 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 499 15 | | NNP www-nature-com-63 499 16 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 499 17 9 9 CD www-nature-com-63 499 18 https://www.ceads.net/user/download-anonymous.php?id=1083 https://www.ceads.net/user/download-anonymous.php?id=1083 NNP www-nature-com-63 499 19 https://www.ceads.net/user/download-anonymous.php?id=1083 https://www.ceads.net/user/download-anonymous.php?id=1083 NNP www-nature-com-63 499 20 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 499 21 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication VBZ www-nature-com-63 499 22 Additional additional JJ www-nature-com-63 499 23 information information NN www-nature-com-63 499 24 Supplementary supplementary JJ www-nature-com-63 499 25 information information NN www-nature-com-63 499 26 The the DT www-nature-com-63 499 27 online online JJ www-nature-com-63 499 28 version version NN www-nature-com-63 499 29 contains contain VBZ www-nature-com-63 499 30 supplementary supplementary JJ www-nature-com-63 499 31 material material NN www-nature-com-63 499 32 available available JJ www-nature-com-63 499 33 at at IN www-nature-com-63 499 34 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 499 35 . . . www-nature-com-63 500 1 Correspondence correspondence NN www-nature-com-63 500 2 and and CC www-nature-com-63 500 3 requests request NNS www-nature-com-63 500 4 for for IN www-nature-com-63 500 5 materials material NNS www-nature-com-63 500 6 should should MD www-nature-com-63 500 7 be be VB www-nature-com-63 500 8 addressed address VBN www-nature-com-63 500 9 to to IN www-nature-com-63 500 10 D.G. D.G. NNP www-nature-com-63 501 1 or or CC www-nature-com-63 501 2 S.W. S.W. NNP www-nature-com-63 502 1 Peer peer NN www-nature-com-63 502 2 review review NN www-nature-com-63 502 3 information information NN www-nature-com-63 502 4 Nature Nature NNP www-nature-com-63 502 5 Communications Communications NNPS www-nature-com-63 502 6 thanks thank NNS www-nature-com-63 502 7 Hector Hector NNP www-nature-com-63 502 8 F. F. NNP www-nature-com-63 502 9 Calvo Calvo NNP www-nature-com-63 502 10 - - HYPH www-nature-com-63 502 11 Pardo Pardo NNP www-nature-com-63 502 12 , , , www-nature-com-63 502 13 Lea Lea NNP www-nature-com-63 502 14 Diestelmeier Diestelmeier NNP www-nature-com-63 502 15 and and CC www-nature-com-63 502 16 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 502 17 anonymous anonymous NN www-nature-com-63 502 18 , , , www-nature-com-63 502 19 reviewers reviewer NNS www-nature-com-63 502 20 for for IN www-nature-com-63 502 21 their -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 502 22 contributions contribution NNS www-nature-com-63 502 23 to to IN www-nature-com-63 502 24 the the DT www-nature-com-63 502 25 peer peer NN www-nature-com-63 502 26 review review NN www-nature-com-63 502 27 of of IN www-nature-com-63 502 28 this this DT www-nature-com-63 502 29 work work NN www-nature-com-63 502 30 . . . www-nature-com-63 503 1 Peer peer NN www-nature-com-63 503 2 review review NN www-nature-com-63 503 3 reports report NNS www-nature-com-63 503 4 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 503 5 available available JJ www-nature-com-63 503 6 . . . www-nature-com-63 504 1 Reprints reprint NNS www-nature-com-63 504 2 and and CC www-nature-com-63 504 3 permission permission NN www-nature-com-63 504 4 information information NN www-nature-com-63 504 5 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 504 6 available available JJ www-nature-com-63 504 7 at at IN www-nature-com-63 504 8 http://www.nature.com/reprints http://www.nature.com/reprints CD www-nature-com-63 504 9 Publisher Publisher NNP www-nature-com-63 504 10 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 504 11 note note NN www-nature-com-63 504 12 Springer Springer NNP www-nature-com-63 504 13 Nature Nature NNP www-nature-com-63 504 14 remains remain VBZ www-nature-com-63 504 15 neutral neutral JJ www-nature-com-63 504 16 with with IN www-nature-com-63 504 17 regard regard NN www-nature-com-63 504 18 to to IN www-nature-com-63 504 19 jurisdictional jurisdictional JJ www-nature-com-63 504 20 claims claim NNS www-nature-com-63 504 21 in in IN www-nature-com-63 504 22 published publish VBN www-nature-com-63 504 23 maps map NNS www-nature-com-63 504 24 and and CC www-nature-com-63 504 25 institutional institutional JJ www-nature-com-63 504 26 affiliations affiliation NNS www-nature-com-63 504 27 . . . www-nature-com-63 505 1 Open open JJ www-nature-com-63 505 2 Access access NN www-nature-com-63 505 3 This this DT www-nature-com-63 505 4 article article NN www-nature-com-63 505 5 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 505 6 licensed license VBN www-nature-com-63 505 7 under under IN www-nature-com-63 505 8 a a DT www-nature-com-63 505 9 Creative Creative NNP www-nature-com-63 505 10 Commons Commons NNP www-nature-com-63 505 11 Attribution Attribution NNP www-nature-com-63 505 12 4.0 4.0 CD www-nature-com-63 505 13 International International NNP www-nature-com-63 505 14 License License NNP www-nature-com-63 505 15 , , , www-nature-com-63 505 16 which which WDT www-nature-com-63 505 17 permits permit VBZ www-nature-com-63 505 18 use use NN www-nature-com-63 505 19 , , , www-nature-com-63 505 20 sharing sharing NN www-nature-com-63 505 21 , , , www-nature-com-63 505 22 adaptation adaptation NN www-nature-com-63 505 23 , , , www-nature-com-63 505 24 distribution distribution NN www-nature-com-63 505 25 and and CC www-nature-com-63 505 26 reproduction reproduction NN www-nature-com-63 505 27 in in IN www-nature-com-63 505 28 any any DT www-nature-com-63 505 29 medium medium NN www-nature-com-63 505 30 or or CC www-nature-com-63 505 31 format format NN www-nature-com-63 505 32 , , , www-nature-com-63 505 33 as as RB www-nature-com-63 505 34 long long RB www-nature-com-63 505 35 as as IN www-nature-com-63 505 36 you -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 505 37 give give VBP www-nature-com-63 505 38 appropriate appropriate JJ www-nature-com-63 505 39 credit credit NN www-nature-com-63 505 40 to to IN www-nature-com-63 505 41 the the DT www-nature-com-63 505 42 original original JJ www-nature-com-63 505 43 author(s author(s NN www-nature-com-63 505 44 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 505 45 and and CC www-nature-com-63 505 46 the the DT www-nature-com-63 505 47 source source NN www-nature-com-63 505 48 , , , www-nature-com-63 505 49 provide provide VB www-nature-com-63 505 50 a a DT www-nature-com-63 505 51 link link NN www-nature-com-63 505 52 to to IN www-nature-com-63 505 53 the the DT www-nature-com-63 505 54 Creative Creative NNP www-nature-com-63 505 55 Commons Commons NNP www-nature-com-63 505 56 license license NN www-nature-com-63 505 57 , , , www-nature-com-63 505 58 and and CC www-nature-com-63 505 59 indicate indicate VBP www-nature-com-63 505 60 if if IN www-nature-com-63 505 61 changes change NNS www-nature-com-63 505 62 were be VBD www-nature-com-63 505 63 made make VBN www-nature-com-63 505 64 . . . www-nature-com-63 506 1 The the DT www-nature-com-63 506 2 images image NNS www-nature-com-63 506 3 or or CC www-nature-com-63 506 4 other other JJ www-nature-com-63 506 5 third third JJ www-nature-com-63 506 6 party party NN www-nature-com-63 506 7 material material NN www-nature-com-63 506 8 in in IN www-nature-com-63 506 9 this this DT www-nature-com-63 506 10 article article NN www-nature-com-63 506 11 are be VBP www-nature-com-63 506 12 included include VBN www-nature-com-63 506 13 in in IN www-nature-com-63 506 14 the the DT www-nature-com-63 506 15 article article NN www-nature-com-63 506 16 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 506 17 Creative Creative NNP www-nature-com-63 506 18 Commons Commons NNP www-nature-com-63 506 19 license license NN www-nature-com-63 506 20 , , , www-nature-com-63 506 21 unless unless IN www-nature-com-63 506 22 indicated indicate VBN www-nature-com-63 506 23 otherwise otherwise RB www-nature-com-63 506 24 in in IN www-nature-com-63 506 25 a a DT www-nature-com-63 506 26 credit credit NN www-nature-com-63 506 27 line line NN www-nature-com-63 506 28 to to IN www-nature-com-63 506 29 the the DT www-nature-com-63 506 30 material material NN www-nature-com-63 506 31 . . . www-nature-com-63 507 1 If if IN www-nature-com-63 507 2 material material NN www-nature-com-63 507 3 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 507 4 not not RB www-nature-com-63 507 5 included include VBN www-nature-com-63 507 6 in in IN www-nature-com-63 507 7 the the DT www-nature-com-63 507 8 article article NN www-nature-com-63 507 9 ’s ’s POS www-nature-com-63 507 10 Creative Creative NNP www-nature-com-63 507 11 Commons Commons NNP www-nature-com-63 507 12 license license NN www-nature-com-63 507 13 and and CC www-nature-com-63 507 14 your -PRON- PRP$ www-nature-com-63 507 15 intended intended JJ www-nature-com-63 507 16 use use NN www-nature-com-63 507 17 is be VBZ www-nature-com-63 507 18 not not RB www-nature-com-63 507 19 permitted permit VBN www-nature-com-63 507 20 by by IN www-nature-com-63 507 21 statutory statutory JJ www-nature-com-63 507 22 regulation regulation NN www-nature-com-63 507 23 or or CC www-nature-com-63 507 24 exceeds exceed VBZ www-nature-com-63 507 25 the the DT www-nature-com-63 507 26 permitted permit VBN www-nature-com-63 507 27 use use NN www-nature-com-63 507 28 , , , www-nature-com-63 507 29 you -PRON- PRP www-nature-com-63 507 30 will will MD www-nature-com-63 507 31 need need VB www-nature-com-63 507 32 to to TO www-nature-com-63 507 33 obtain obtain VB www-nature-com-63 507 34 permission permission NN www-nature-com-63 507 35 directly directly RB www-nature-com-63 507 36 from from IN www-nature-com-63 507 37 the the DT www-nature-com-63 507 38 copyright copyright NN www-nature-com-63 507 39 holder holder NN www-nature-com-63 507 40 . . . www-nature-com-63 508 1 To to TO www-nature-com-63 508 2 view view VB www-nature-com-63 508 3 a a DT www-nature-com-63 508 4 copy copy NN www-nature-com-63 508 5 of of IN www-nature-com-63 508 6 this this DT www-nature-com-63 508 7 license license NN www-nature-com-63 508 8 , , , www-nature-com-63 508 9 visit visit VBP www-nature-com-63 508 10 http://creativecommons.org/ http://creativecommons.org/ NN www-nature-com-63 508 11 licenses license NNS www-nature-com-63 508 12 / / SYM www-nature-com-63 508 13 by/4.0/. by/4.0/. . www-nature-com-63 509 1 © © LS www-nature-com-63 509 2 The the DT www-nature-com-63 509 3 Author(s author(s NN www-nature-com-63 509 4 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 509 5 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 509 6 ARTICLE ARTICLE NNP www-nature-com-63 509 7 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 509 8 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 509 9 | | CD www-nature-com-63 509 10 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 509 11 10 10 CD www-nature-com-63 509 12 NATURE NATURE NNP www-nature-com-63 509 13 COMMUNICATIONS communication NNS www-nature-com-63 509 14 | | CD www-nature-com-63 509 15 ( ( -LRB- www-nature-com-63 509 16 2021 2021 CD www-nature-com-63 509 17 ) ) -RRB- www-nature-com-63 509 18 12:1938 12:1938 CD www-nature-com-63 509 19 | | CD www-nature-com-63 509 20 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 509 21 | | JJ www-nature-com-63 509 22 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 509 23 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22256-3 CD www-nature-com-63 509 24 http://www.nature.com/reprints http://www.nature.com/reprint NNS www-nature-com-63 509 25 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ -LRB- www-nature-com-63 509 26 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ FW www-nature-com-63 509 27 www.nature.com/naturecommunications www.nature.com/naturecommunication NNS www-nature-com-63 509 28 Policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 509 29 assessments assessment NNS www-nature-com-63 509 30 for for IN www-nature-com-63 509 31 the the DT www-nature-com-63 509 32 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 509 33 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 509 34 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 509 35 and and CC www-nature-com-63 509 36 sustainability sustainability NN www-nature-com-63 509 37 of of IN www-nature-com-63 509 38 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 509 39 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 509 40 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 509 41 in in IN www-nature-com-63 509 42 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 509 43 Results Results NNP www-nature-com-63 509 44 The the DT www-nature-com-63 509 45 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 509 46 and and CC www-nature-com-63 509 47 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 509 48 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 509 49 problem problem NN www-nature-com-63 509 50 of of IN www-nature-com-63 509 51 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 509 52 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 509 53 in in IN www-nature-com-63 509 54 China China NNP www-nature-com-63 509 55 Carbon Carbon NNP www-nature-com-63 509 56 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 509 57 flows flow VBZ www-nature-com-63 509 58 of of IN www-nature-com-63 509 59 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 509 60 blockchain blockchain NN www-nature-com-63 509 61 operation operation NN www-nature-com-63 509 62 Carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 509 63 policy policy NN www-nature-com-63 509 64 effectiveness effectiveness NN www-nature-com-63 509 65 evaluation evaluation NN www-nature-com-63 509 66 Discussion Discussion NNP www-nature-com-63 509 67 Methods Methods NNP www-nature-com-63 509 68 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 509 69 mining mining NN www-nature-com-63 509 70 and and CC www-nature-com-63 509 71 transaction transaction NN www-nature-com-63 509 72 subsystem subsystem NNP www-nature-com-63 509 73 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 509 74 energy energy NN www-nature-com-63 509 75 consumption consumption NN www-nature-com-63 509 76 subsystem subsystem NN www-nature-com-63 509 77 Bitcoin Bitcoin NNP www-nature-com-63 509 78 carbon carbon NN www-nature-com-63 509 79 emission emission NN www-nature-com-63 509 80 subsystem subsystem NNP www-nature-com-63 509 81 BBCE BBCE NNP www-nature-com-63 509 82 model model NN www-nature-com-63 509 83 parameterizations parameterization NNS www-nature-com-63 509 84 and and CC www-nature-com-63 509 85 quantitative quantitative JJ www-nature-com-63 509 86 settings setting NNS www-nature-com-63 509 87 Validation validation NN www-nature-com-63 509 88 and and CC www-nature-com-63 509 89 robustness robustness NN www-nature-com-63 509 90 tests test NNS www-nature-com-63 509 91 Reporting report VBG www-nature-com-63 509 92 summary summary NN www-nature-com-63 509 93 Data datum NNS www-nature-com-63 509 94 availability availability NN www-nature-com-63 509 95 References reference NNS www-nature-com-63 509 96 Acknowledgements Acknowledgements NNP www-nature-com-63 509 97 Author author NN www-nature-com-63 509 98 contributions contribution NNS www-nature-com-63 509 99 Competing compete VBG www-nature-com-63 509 100 interests interest NNS www-nature-com-63 509 101 Additional additional JJ www-nature-com-63 509 102 information information NN