Bitcoin rival Chia 'destroyed' hard disc supply chains, says its boss | New Scientist × NEWSLETTERS Sign up to read our regular email newsletters image/svg+xml Subscribe and save Menu news podcasts video technology space physics health more mind environment crosswords shop courses events tours jobs SIGN UP TO THE DAILY NEWSLETTER Sign In Search Bitcoin rival Chia 'destroyed' hard disc supply chains, says its boss Technology 26 May 2021 By Matthew Sparkes Chia miners are buying up hard discs Shutterstock / nikkytok Chia, a cryptocurrency intended to be a “green” alternative to bitcoin has instead caused a global shortage of hard discs. Gene Hoffman, the president of Chia Network, the company behind the currency, admits that “we’ve kind of destroyed the short-term supply chain”, but he denies it will become an environmental drain. Bitcoin requires so-called miners to do vast amounts of useless calculations to maintain the network, a system that is known as proof of work. The most recent studies show that bitcoin may currently consume 0.53 per cent of the world’s electricity supply. Chia instead uses a proof-of-space approach that ditches these calculations and relies on empty hard disc space. The more space a miner devotes to the task, the higher their probability of receiving new coins. In theory, this would consume less energy, but there has been a surge in demand for hard discs since the currency launched earlier this year. Around 12 million terabytes of hard disc space is currently being used to mine Chia, having risen on an exponential curve since its launch in March. When New Scientist first reported on Chia just two weeks ago, that figure was only at 3 million terabytes. Advertisement These discs still require energy to produce and run, and there are reports that the constant reading and writing involved in mining can wear them out in weeks, rendering them useless. Hoffman says this problem only affects the cheapest discs. The resulting increase in demand has caused significant price rises for hard discs, especially higher-end models. The share price of hard disc maker Western Digital has increased from $52 at the start of the year to $73, while competitor Seagate is up from $60 to $94 over the same period. Hoffman says he is surprised at the speed at which the hard disc capacity devoted to Chia has grown and admits that this is likely to cause disruptions to the supply chain for some time. In the long term, he thinks the increased demand being driven by Chia will lower the cost of hard discs as manufacturers ramp up production. He is also adamant that even with continued growth, the network won’t approach bitcoin’s energy consumption. Read more: ‘Green’ bitcoin alternative Chia is leading to hard disc shortages Hoffman says that if all hard discs sold in a year – which could hold data totalling roughly 1 zettabyte, or 1 billion terabytes – were used exclusively for mining Chia, it would still use less than 1 per cent of the energy currently used by bitcoin. However, the exact energy consumption of the Chia network is currently unknown, as the cryptocurrency is too new for researchers to have produced reliable estimates. “I’m pretty sure that if we had all 7 zettabytes of storage [the estimated figure for global hard disc capacity], every piece of storage out there – you shut down Google, you shut down Amazon, you shut down Facebook – it’d still be less annual energy consumption,” says Hoffman. But he does concede that the growth of Chia will require significant resources. “Frankly, a Tesla isn’t green compared to running a bicycle, but we all know how those trade-offs work,” he says. Hoffman argues that bitcoin is unsustainable in its current form, but was “so close to being exactly right”. He suggests that issues with bitcoin began when specialised hardware was developed that could mine coins faster than standard computers. This kick-started an arms race that has led to its vast energy use, he says, but he insists that Chia is impervious to such a development. Aggelos Kiayias at the University of Edinburgh, UK, says it is vital to analyse new cryptocurrency technologies to see if the resources they require, such as vast numbers of hard discs, justify the benefit. “Given the current numbers, being merely less resource hungry compared to bitcoin is a rather low bar as far as ‘green’ technology is concerned,” he says. More on these topics: bitcoin & cryptocurrency Advertisement Trending Latest Video Free Real milk, no cows needed: Lab-made dairy products are now a reality Handheld railgun as powerful as an air rifle to go on sale in the US Do you phub? Ignoring friends for your phone is linked to personality US wildfire pollution linked to more covid-19 cases and deaths Journey to Infinity review: M. C. Escher's art of the impossible Ancient comb jelly had more complex nerves than its modern relatives Journey to Infinity review: M. C. Escher's art of the impossible Bacterial probiotics could help protect corals from ocean warming US wildfire pollution linked to more covid-19 cases and deaths Covid-19: Why the UK needs to forget about herd immunity Inside the fight to stop destructive fishing in marine protected areas Single-celled organism uses natural mechanical computer to walk Cockatoos are figuring out how to open bins by copying each other Can kelp forests recover after trawler fishing ban? Wally Funk and the future of female astronauts What is the smallest whole number with no interesting properties? Journey to Infinity review: M. C. Escher's art of the impossible US wildfire pollution linked to more covid-19 cases and deaths NASA’s Perseverance rover took its first Mars sample – but it’s empty Don't Miss: Delightful Disney+ docuseries, Growing Up Animal Subscribe View in the app Buy In Print Advertisement MORE FROM NEW SCIENTIST Coal-powered bitcoin mining soars in Kazakhstan following Chinese ban Technology Streamlined JPEG XL images could cut global data use by 30 per cent Technology Ethereum cryptocurrency creator voices concern over carbon footprint Technology How large is a cubic metre of water? Sign up to our newsletters Enter your email address to get started Contact us Help About us Privacy policy Cookie policy Terms & conditions Advertise Write for us Events Science jobs Syndication RSS feeds Gift subscriptions Student subscriptions Educational subscriptions Corporate subscriptions Cookie Settings Get the app FOLLOW US © Copyright New Scientist Ltd. Back to top