id sid tid token lemma pos en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 1 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 2 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 3 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 5 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 6 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 7 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 8 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 9 From from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 10 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 13 free free JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 14 encyclopedia encyclopedia NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 15       _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 16 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 17 Redirected redirect VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 18 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 19 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 20 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 21 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 22 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 23 Jump jump VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 24 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 25 navigation navigation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 26 Jump Jump NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 27 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 28 search search VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 29 For for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 30 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 31 uses use NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 32 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 33 see see VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 34 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 35 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 36 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 37 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 38 disambiguation disambiguation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 39 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 1 40 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 2 1 Not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 2 2 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 2 3 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 2 4 confused confuse VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 2 5 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 2 6 Three three CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 2 7 Prisoners Prisoners NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 2 8 problem problem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 2 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 1 Canonical canonical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 2 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 4 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 5 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 6 analyzed analyze VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 7 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 8 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 9 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 10 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 11 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 12 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 13 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 14 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 15 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 16 A A NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 17 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 18 stays stay VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 19 silent silent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 20 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 21 betrays betray NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 22 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 23 stays stay VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 24 silent silent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 25 -1 -1 . en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 26 -1 -1 ADD en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 27 0 0 NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 28 -3 -3 . en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 29 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 30 betrays betray NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 31 -3 -3 . en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 32 0 0 NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 33 -2 -2 : en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 34 -2 -2 . en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 35 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 36 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 37 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 38 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 39 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 40 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 41 standard standard JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 42 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 43 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 44 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 45 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 46 analyzed analyze VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 47 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 48 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 49 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 50 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 51 shows show VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 52 why why WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 53 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 54 completely completely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 55 rational rational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 56 individuals individual NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 57 might may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 58 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 59 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 60 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 61 even even RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 62 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 63 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 64 appears appear VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 65 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 66 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 67 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 68 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 69 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 70 best good JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 71 interests interest NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 72 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 73 do do VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 74 so so RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 3 75 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 2 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 3 originally originally RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 4 framed frame VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 5 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 6 Merrill Merrill NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 7 Flood Flood NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 8 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 9 Melvin Melvin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 10 Dresher Dresher NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 11 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 12 working work VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 13 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 14 RAND RAND NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 15 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 16 1950 1950 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 4 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 1 Albert Albert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 2 W. W. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 3 Tucker Tucker NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 4 formalized formalize VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 6 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 7 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 8 prison prison NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 9 sentence sentence NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 10 rewards reward NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 11 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 12 named name VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 13 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 14 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 15 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 16 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 17 dilemma",[1 dilemma",[1 NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 18 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 19 presenting present VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 20 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 21 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 22 follows follow VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 23 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 24 Two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 25 members member NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 26 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 27 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 28 criminal criminal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 29 gang gang NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 30 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 31 arrested arrest VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 32 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 33 imprisoned imprison VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 5 34 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 1 Each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 2 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 3 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 4 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 5 solitary solitary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 6 confinement confinement NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 7 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 8 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 9 means means NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 11 communicating communicate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 12 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 14 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 6 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 2 prosecutors prosecutor NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 3 lack lack VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 4 sufficient sufficient JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 5 evidence evidence NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 6 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 7 convict convict VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 9 pair pair NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 10 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 12 principal principal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 13 charge charge NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 15 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 16 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 17 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 18 enough enough JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 19 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 20 convict convict VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 21 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 22 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 23 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 24 lesser less JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 25 charge charge NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 7 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 8 1 Simultaneously simultaneously RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 8 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 8 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 8 4 prosecutors prosecutor NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 8 5 offer offer VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 8 6 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 8 7 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 8 8 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 8 9 bargain bargain NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 8 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 1 Each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 2 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 3 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 4 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 6 opportunity opportunity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 7 either either CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 8 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 9 betray betray VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 11 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 12 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 13 testifying testify VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 14 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 15 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 16 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 17 committed commit VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 18 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 19 crime crime NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 20 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 21 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 22 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 23 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 24 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 25 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 26 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 27 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 28 remaining remain VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 29 silent silent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 9 30 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 2 possible possible JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 3 outcomes outcome NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 4 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 6 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 7 A a NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 8 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 9 B b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 10 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 11 betray betray NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 13 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 15 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 16 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 17 them -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 18 serves serve VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 19 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 20 years year NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 21 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 22 prison prison NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 23 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 24 A a NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 25 betrays betray NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 26 B b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 27 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 28 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 29 remains remain VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 30 silent silent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 32 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 33 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 34 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 35 set set VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 36 free free JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 37 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 38 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 39 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 40 serve serve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 41 three three CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 42 years year NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 43 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 44 prison prison NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 45 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 46 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 47 remains remain VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 48 silent silent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 49 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 50 B b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 51 betrays betrays NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 52 A a NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 53 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 54 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 55 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 56 serve serve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 57 three three CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 58 years year NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 59 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 60 prison prison NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 61 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 62 B b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 63 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 64 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 65 set set VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 66 free free JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 67 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 68 A a NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 69 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 70 B b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 71 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 72 remain remain VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 73 silent silent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 74 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 75 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 76 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 77 them -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 78 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 79 serve serve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 80 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 81 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 82 year year NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 83 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 84 prison prison NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 85 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 86 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 87 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 88 lesser less JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 89 charge charge NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 90 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 10 91 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 2 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 3 implied imply VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 4 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 6 prisoners prisoner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 7 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 8 have have VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 9 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 10 opportunity opportunity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 11 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 12 reward reward VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 13 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 14 punish punish VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 15 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 16 partner partner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 17 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 18 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 20 prison prison NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 21 sentences sentence NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 22 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 23 get get VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 24 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 25 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 26 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 27 decision decision NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 28 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 29 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 30 affect affect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 31 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 32 reputation reputation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 33 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 34 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 35 future future NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 11 36 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 1 Because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 2 betraying betray VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 3 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 4 partner partner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 5 offers offer VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 6 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 7 greater great JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 8 reward reward NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 9 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 10 cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 11 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 12 them -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 13 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 14 all all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 15 purely purely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 16 rational rational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 17 self self NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 18 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 19 interested interested JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 20 prisoners prisoner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 21 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 22 betray betray VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 24 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 25 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 26 meaning mean VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 27 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 28 only only JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 29 possible possible JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 30 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 31 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 32 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 33 purely purely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 34 rational rational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 35 prisoners prisoner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 36 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 37 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 38 them -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 39 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 40 betray betray VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 41 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 42 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 12 43 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 2 2 2 LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 4 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 5 reality reality NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 7 humans human NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 8 display display VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 9 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 10 systemic systemic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 11 bias bias NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 12 towards towards IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 13 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 14 behavior behavior NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 15 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 16 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 17 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 18 similar similar JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 19 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 20 despite despite IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 21 what what WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 22 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 23 predicted predict VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 24 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 25 simple simple JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 26 models model NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 27 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 28 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 29 rational rational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 30 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 31 self self NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 32 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 33 interested interested JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 34 action action NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 13 35 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 2 3][4][5][6 3][4][5][6 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 4 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 5 bias bias NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 6 towards towards IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 7 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 8 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 9 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 10 known know VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 11 since since IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 13 test test NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 14 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 15 first first RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 16 conducted conduct VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 17 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 18 RAND RAND NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 19 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 21 secretaries secretary NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 22 involved involve VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 23 trusted trust VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 24 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 25 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 26 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 27 worked work VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 28 together together RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 29 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 30 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 31 best good JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 32 common common JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 33 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 14 34 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 2 7 7 LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 4 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 5 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 6 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 7 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 8 became become VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 10 focus focus NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 11 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 12 extensive extensive JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 13 experimental experimental JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 14 research research NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 15 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 2 8][9 8][9 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 4 An an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 5 extended extended JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 6 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 7 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 8 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 9 version version NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 12 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 13 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 14 exists exist VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 16 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 2 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 3 version version NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 6 classic classic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 7 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 8 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 9 played play VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 10 repeatedly repeatedly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 11 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 13 same same JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 14 prisoners prisoner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 16 who who WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 17 continuously continuously RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 18 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 20 opportunity opportunity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 21 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 22 penalize penalize VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 24 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 25 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 26 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 27 decisions decision NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 17 28 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 3 number number NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 5 times time NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 7 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 8 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 9 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 10 played play VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 11 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 12 known know VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 13 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 15 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 17 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 18 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 19 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 20 backward backward JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 21 induction induction NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 22 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 23 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 24 classically classically RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 25 rational rational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 26 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 27 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 28 betray betray VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 29 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 30 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 31 repeatedly repeatedly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 32 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 33 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 34 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 35 same same JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 36 reasons reason NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 37 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 38 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 39 single single JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 40 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 41 shot shot NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 42 variant variant NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 18 43 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 2 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 3 infinite infinite JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 4 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 5 unknown unknown JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 6 length length NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 7 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 8 there there EX en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 9 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 10 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 11 fixed fixed JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 12 optimum optimum JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 13 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 15 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 16 prisoner prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 17 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 18 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 19 tournaments tournament NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 20 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 21 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 22 held hold VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 23 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 24 compete compete VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 25 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 26 test test VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 27 algorithms algorithm NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 28 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 29 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 30 cases case NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 19 31 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 2 10 10 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 4 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 5 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 6 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 7 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 8 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 9 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 10 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 11 used use VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 12 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 13 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 14 model model NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 15 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 16 many many JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 17 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 18 world world NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 19 situations situation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 20 involving involve VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 21 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 22 behavior behavior NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 20 23 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 2 casual casual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 3 usage usage NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 6 label label NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 7 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 8 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 9 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 10 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 11 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 12 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 13 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 14 applied apply VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 15 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 16 situations situation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 17 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 18 strictly strictly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 19 matching match VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 21 formal formal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 22 criteria criterion NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 23 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 24 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 25 classic classic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 26 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 27 iterative iterative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 28 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 29 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 30 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 31 instance instance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 32 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 33 those those DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 34 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 35 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 36 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 37 entities entity NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 38 could could MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 39 gain gain VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 40 important important JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 41 benefits benefit NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 42 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 43 cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 44 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 45 suffer suffer VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 46 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 47 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 48 failure failure NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 49 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 50 do do VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 51 so so RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 52 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 53 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 54 find find VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 55 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 56 difficult difficult JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 57 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 58 expensive expensive JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 59 — — : en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 60 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 61 necessarily necessarily RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 62 impossible impossible JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 63 — — : en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 64 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 65 coordinate coordinate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 66 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 67 activities activity NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 21 68 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 1 Contents content NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 2 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 3 Strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 4 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 6 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 7 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 8 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 9 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 10 Generalized generalize VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 11 form form NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 12 2.1 2.1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 13 Special special JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 14 case case NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 15 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 16 donation donation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 17 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 18 3 3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 19 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 20 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 21 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 22 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 23 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 24 3.1 3.1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 25 Strategy Strategy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 26 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 27 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 28 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 29 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 30 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 31 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 32 3.2 3.2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 33 Stochastic stochastic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 34 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 35 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 36 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 37 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 38 3.2.1 3.2.1 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 39 Zero Zero NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 40 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 41 determinant determinant NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 42 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 43 3.3 3.3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 44 Continuous continuous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 45 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 46 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 47 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 48 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 49 3.4 3.4 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 50 Emergence emergence NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 51 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 52 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 53 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 54 4 4 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 55 Real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 56 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 57 life life NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 58 examples example NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 59 4.1 4.1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 60 Environmental environmental JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 61 studies study NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 62 4.2 4.2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 63 Animals animal NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 64 4.3 4.3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 65 Psychology psychology NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 66 4.4 4.4 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 67 Economics Economics NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 68 4.5 4.5 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 69 Sport Sport NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 70 4.6 4.6 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 71 International international JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 72 politics politic NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 73 4.7 4.7 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 74 Multiplayer Multiplayer NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 75 dilemmas dilemma NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 76 5 5 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 77 Related related JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 78 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 79 5.1 5.1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 80 Closed closed JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 81 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 82 bag bag NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 83 exchange exchange NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 84 5.2 5.2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 85 Friend Friend NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 86 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 87 Foe Foe NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 22 88 ? ? . en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 1 5.3 5.3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 2 Iterated Iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 3 snowdrift snowdrift NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 4 5.4 5.4 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 5 Coordination coordination NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 6 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 7 5.5 5.5 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 8 Asymmetric Asymmetric NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 9 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 10 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 11 dilemmas dilemmas NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 12 6 6 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 13 Software Software NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 14 7 7 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 15 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 16 fiction fiction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 17 8 8 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 18 See see VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 19 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 20 9 9 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 21 References reference NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 22 10 10 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 23 Further further JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 24 reading read VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 25 11 11 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 26 External external JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 27 links link NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 28 Strategy Strategy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 29 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 30 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 31 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 32 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 33 dilemma[edit dilemma[edit CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 34 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 35 Two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 36 prisoners prisoner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 37 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 38 separated separate VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 39 into into IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 40 individual individual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 41 rooms room NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 42 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 43 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 44 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 45 communicate communicate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 46 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 47 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 48 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 23 49 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 2 normal normal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 3 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 5 shown show VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 6 below below IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 7 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 8 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 9 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 10 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 11 A A NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 12 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 13 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 14 stays stay VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 15 silent silent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 16 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 17 cooperates cooperate NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 18 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 19 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 20 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 21 betrays betray NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 22 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 23 defects defect NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 24 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 25 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 26 A A NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 27 stays stay VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 28 silent silent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 29 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 30 cooperates cooperate NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 31 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 32 Each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 33 serves serve VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 34 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 35 year year NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 36 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 37 A A NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 38 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 39 3 3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 40 years year NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 41 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 42 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 43 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 44 goes go VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 45 free free JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 46 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 47 A A NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 48 betrays betray NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 49 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 50 defects defect NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 51 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 52 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 53 A a NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 54 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 55 goes go VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 56 free free JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 57 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 58 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 59 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 60 3 3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 61 years year NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 62 Each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 63 serves serve VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 64 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 65 years year NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 66 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 67 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 68 assumed assume VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 69 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 70 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 71 prisoners prisoner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 72 understand understand VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 73 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 74 nature nature NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 75 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 76 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 77 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 78 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 79 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 80 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 81 loyalty loyalty NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 82 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 83 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 84 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 85 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 86 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 87 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 88 have have VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 89 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 90 opportunity opportunity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 91 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 92 retribution retribution NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 93 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 94 reward reward NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 95 outside outside IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 96 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 97 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 24 98 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 1 Regardless regardless RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 3 what what WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 5 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 6 decides decide VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 8 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 9 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 10 gets get VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 11 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 12 higher high JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 13 reward reward NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 14 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 15 betraying betray VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 16 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 17 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 18 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 19 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 20 defecting defect VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 21 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 22 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 25 23 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 2 reasoning reasoning NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 3 involves involve VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 4 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 5 argument argument NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 6 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 7 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 8 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 9 B b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 10 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 11 either either CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 12 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 13 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 14 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 26 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 2 B b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 3 cooperates cooperate NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 5 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 6 should should MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 7 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 9 because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 10 going go VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 11 free free JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 12 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 13 better well JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 14 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 15 serving serve VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 16 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 17 year year NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 27 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 2 B b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 3 defects defect NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 5 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 6 should should MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 7 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 8 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 10 because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 11 serving serve VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 12 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 13 years year NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 14 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 15 better well JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 16 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 17 serving serve VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 18 3 3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 28 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 29 1 So so RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 29 2 either either DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 29 3 way way NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 29 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 29 5 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 29 6 should should MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 29 7 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 29 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 30 1 Parallel parallel JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 30 2 reasoning reasoning NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 30 3 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 30 4 show show VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 30 5 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 30 6 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 30 7 should should MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 30 8 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 30 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 1 Because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 2 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 3 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 4 results result VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 5 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 6 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 7 better well JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 8 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 9 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 10 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 11 regardless regardless RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 14 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 15 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 16 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 17 choice choice NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 19 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 20 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 21 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 22 dominant dominant JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 23 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 31 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 1 Mutual mutual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 2 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 3 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 5 only only JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 6 strong strong JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 7 Nash Nash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 8 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 9 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 11 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 12 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 32 13 i.e. i.e. FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 1 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 2 only only JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 3 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 4 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 5 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 6 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 7 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 8 could could MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 9 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 10 do do VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 11 worse bad JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 12 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 13 unilaterally unilaterally RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 14 changing change VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 15 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 16 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 33 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 2 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 4 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 6 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 7 that that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 8 mutual mutual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 9 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 10 yields yield VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 11 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 12 better well JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 13 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 14 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 15 mutual mutual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 16 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 17 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 18 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 19 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 21 rational rational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 22 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 23 because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 24 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 25 choice choice NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 26 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 27 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 28 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 29 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 30 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 31 self self NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 32 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 33 interested interested JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 34 perspective perspective NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 35 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 36 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 37 irrational irrational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 34 38 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 1 Generalized generalize VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 2 form[edit form[edit LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 4 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 5 structure structure NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 8 traditional traditional JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 9 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 10 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 11 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 12 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 13 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 14 generalized generalize VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 15 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 16 its -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 17 original original JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 18 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 19 setting setting NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 35 20 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 1 Suppose suppose VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 2 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 4 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 5 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 6 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 7 represented represent VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 8 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 10 colors color NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 11 red red JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 12 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 13 blue blue JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 15 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 16 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 17 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 18 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 19 chooses choose VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 20 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 21 either either CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 22 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 23 cooperate cooperate NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 24 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 25 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 26 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 27 defect defect JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 28 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 36 29 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 2 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 3 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 4 cooperate cooperate VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 6 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 7 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 8 receive receive VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 10 reward reward NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 11 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 12 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 13 cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 37 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 2 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 3 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 4 defect defect VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 6 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 7 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 8 receive receive VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 10 punishment punishment NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 11 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 12 P. P. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 13 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 14 Blue Blue NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 15 defects defect NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 16 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 17 Red red JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 18 cooperates cooperate NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 20 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 21 Blue Blue NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 22 receives receive VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 24 temptation temptation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 25 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 26 T t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 27 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 28 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 29 Red Red NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 30 receives receive VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 31 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 32 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 33 sucker sucker NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 34 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 35 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 36 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 37 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 38 S. S. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 39 Similarly Similarly NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 40 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 41 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 42 Blue blue JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 43 cooperates cooperate NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 44 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 45 Red red JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 46 defects defect NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 47 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 48 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 49 Blue Blue NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 50 receives receive VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 51 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 52 sucker sucker NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 53 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 54 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 55 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 56 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 57 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 58 Red Red NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 59 receives receive VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 60 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 61 temptation temptation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 62 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 63 T. T. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 64 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 65 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 66 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 67 expressed express VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 68 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 69 normal normal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 70 form form NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 71 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 72 Canonical Canonical NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 73 PD PD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 74 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 75 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 76 Red Red NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 77 Blue Blue NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 78 Cooperate Cooperate NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 79 Defect Defect NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 80 Cooperate cooperate NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 81 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 82 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 83 T t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 84 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 85 Defect defect NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 86 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 87 T t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 88 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 89 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 90 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 91 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 92 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 93 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 94 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 95 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 96 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 97 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 98 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 99 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 100 strong strong JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 101 sense sense NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 102 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 103 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 104 following follow VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 105 condition condition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 106 must must MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 107 hold hold VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 108 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 109 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 110 payoffs payoff NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 111 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 112 T t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 113 > > . en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 114 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 115 > > XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 116 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 117 > > FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 118 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 119 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 120 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 121 T t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 122 > > NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 123 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 124 > > XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 125 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 126 > > FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 127 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 128 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 129 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 130 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 131 relationship relationship NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 132 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 133 > > XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 134 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 135 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 136 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 137 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 138 > > NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 139 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 140 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 141 implies imply VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 142 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 143 mutual mutual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 144 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 145 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 146 superior superior JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 147 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 148 mutual mutual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 149 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 150 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 151 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 152 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 153 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 154 relationships relationship VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 155 T T NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 156 > > NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 157 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 158 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 159 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 160 T t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 161 > > NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 162 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 163 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 164 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 165 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 166 > > XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 167 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 168 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 169 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 170 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 171 > > NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 172 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 173 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 174 imply imply VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 175 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 176 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 177 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 178 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 179 dominant dominant JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 180 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 181 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 182 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 183 agents agent NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 38 184 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 1 Special special JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 2 case case NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 3 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 4 donation donation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 5 game[edit game[edit , en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 6 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 7 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 8 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 9 donation donation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 10 game"[11 game"[11 NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 11 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 12 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 13 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 14 form form NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 15 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 16 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 17 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 18 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 19 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 20 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 21 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 22 corresponds correspond VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 23 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 24 offering offer VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 25 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 26 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 27 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 28 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 29 benefit benefit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 30 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 31 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 32 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 33 personal personal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 34 cost cost NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 35 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 36 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 37 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 38 > > XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 39 c. c. NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 40 Defection Defection NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 41 means mean VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 42 offering offer VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 43 nothing nothing NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 39 44 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 2 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 3 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 5 thus thus RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 6 Red Red NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 7 Blue Blue NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 8 Cooperate Cooperate NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 9 Defect Defect NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 10 Cooperate Cooperate NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 11 b−c b−c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 12 b−c b−c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 13 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 14 −c −c NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 15 Defect Defect NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 16 −c −c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 17 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 18 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 19 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 20 Note note NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 21 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 22 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 23 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 24 > > XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 25 T t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 26 + + CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 27 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 28 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 29 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 30 2R 2r CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 31 > > NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 32 T+S T+S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 33 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 34 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 40 35 i.e. i.e. FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 1 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 3 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 4 − − NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 5 c c NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 6 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 7 > > XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 8 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 9 − − NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 10 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 11 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 12 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 13 2(b 2(b CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 14 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 15 c)>b c)>b NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 16 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 17 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 18 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 19 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 20 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 21 qualifies qualify VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 22 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 23 donation donation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 24 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 25 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 26 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 27 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 28 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 29 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 30 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 31 see see VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 32 next next JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 33 section section NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 34 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 41 35 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 42 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 42 2 donation donation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 42 3 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 42 4 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 42 5 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 42 6 applied apply VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 42 7 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 42 8 markets market NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 42 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 43 1 Suppose suppose VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 43 2 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 43 3 grows grow VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 43 4 oranges orange NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 43 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 43 6 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 43 7 grows grow VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 43 8 apples apple NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 43 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 2 marginal marginal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 3 utility utility NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 5 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 6 apple apple NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 7 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 9 orange orange JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 10 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 11 grower grower NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 12 X x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 13 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 14 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 16 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 17 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 18 higher high JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 19 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 21 marginal marginal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 22 utility utility NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 23 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 24 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 25 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 26 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 27 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 28 orange orange NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 29 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 30 since since IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 31 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 32 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 33 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 34 surplus surplus NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 35 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 36 oranges orange NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 37 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 38 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 39 apples apple NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 44 40 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 1 Similarly similarly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 3 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 4 apple apple NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 5 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 6 grower grower NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 7 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 10 marginal marginal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 11 utility utility NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 13 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 14 orange orange NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 15 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 16 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 17 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 18 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 19 marginal marginal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 20 utility utility NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 21 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 22 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 23 apple apple NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 24 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 25 c. c. NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 26 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 27 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 28 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 29 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 30 contract contract NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 31 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 32 exchange exchange VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 33 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 34 apple apple NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 35 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 36 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 37 orange orange NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 38 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 39 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 40 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 41 fulfills fulfill VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 42 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 43 end end NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 44 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 45 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 46 deal deal NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 47 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 48 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 49 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 50 receive receive VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 51 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 52 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 53 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 54 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 55 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 56 c c NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 45 57 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 2 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 3 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 4 defects defect NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 5 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 6 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 7 does do VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 8 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 9 deliver deliver VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 10 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 11 promised promise VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 14 defector defector NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 15 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 16 receive receive VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 17 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 18 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 19 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 20 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 21 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 22 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 24 cooperator cooperator NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 25 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 26 lose lose VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 27 c. c. NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 28 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 29 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 30 defect defect VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 32 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 33 neither neither CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 34 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 35 gains gain VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 36 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 37 loses lose VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 38 anything anything NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 46 39 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 2 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 3 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 4 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 5 dilemma[edit dilemma[edit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 6 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 7 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 8 section section NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 9 needs need VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 10 additional additional JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 11 citations citation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 12 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 13 verification verification NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 47 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 1 Please please UH en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 2 help help VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 3 improve improve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 4 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 5 article article NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 6 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 7 adding add VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 8 citations citation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 9 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 10 reliable reliable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 11 sources source NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 48 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 49 1 Unsourced unsourced JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 49 2 material material NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 49 3 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 49 4 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 49 5 challenged challenge VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 49 6 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 49 7 removed remove VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 49 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 1 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 2 November November NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 3 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 6 Learn learn VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 7 how how WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 8 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 9 when when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 10 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 11 remove remove VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 12 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 13 template template NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 14 message message NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 15 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 16 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 17 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 18 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 19 play play VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 20 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 21 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 22 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 23 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 24 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 25 once once RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 26 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 27 succession succession NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 28 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 29 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 30 remember remember VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 31 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 32 actions action NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 33 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 34 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 35 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 36 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 37 change change VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 38 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 39 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 40 accordingly accordingly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 41 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 42 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 43 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 44 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 45 called call VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 46 iterated iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 47 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 48 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 49 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 50 50 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 2 addition addition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 3 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 5 general general JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 6 form form NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 7 above above RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 10 iterative iterative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 11 version version NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 12 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 13 requires require VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 14 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 15 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 16 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 17 > > XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 18 T t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 19 + + CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 20 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 21 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 22 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 23 2R 2r CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 24 > > NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 25 T+S T+S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 26 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 27 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 28 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 29 prevent prevent VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 30 alternating alternate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 31 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 32 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 33 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 34 giving give VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 35 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 36 greater great JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 37 reward reward NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 38 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 39 mutual mutual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 40 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 51 41 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 2 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 3 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 4 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 5 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 6 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 7 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 8 fundamental fundamental JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 9 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 10 some some DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 11 theories theory NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 13 human human JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 14 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 15 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 16 trust trust NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 52 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 1 On on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 3 assumption assumption NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 4 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 6 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 7 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 8 model model VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 9 transactions transaction NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 10 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 11 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 12 people people NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 13 requiring require VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 14 trust trust NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 16 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 17 behaviour behaviour NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 18 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 19 populations population NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 20 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 21 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 22 modeled model VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 23 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 24 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 25 multi multi NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 26 - - NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 27 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 28 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 29 iterated iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 30 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 31 version version NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 32 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 33 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 34 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 53 35 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 2 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 4 consequently consequently RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 6 fascinated fascinate VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 7 many many JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 8 scholars scholar NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 9 over over IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 11 years year NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 54 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 2 1975 1975 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 4 Grofman Grofman NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 5 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 6 Pool Pool NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 7 estimated estimate VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 9 count count NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 11 scholarly scholarly JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 12 articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 13 devoted devoted JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 14 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 15 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 16 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 17 over over IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 18 2,000 2,000 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 55 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 2 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 3 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 4 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 5 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 6 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 7 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 8 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 9 referred refer VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 10 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 11 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 13 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 14 peace peace NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 15 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 16 war war NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 17 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 18 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 56 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 2 12 12 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 4 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 6 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 7 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 8 played play VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 9 exactly exactly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 10 N n CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 11 times time NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 12 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 13 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 14 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 15 know know VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 16 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 18 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 19 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 20 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 21 optimal optimal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 22 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 23 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 24 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 25 all all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 26 rounds round NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 57 27 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 58 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 58 2 only only JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 58 3 possible possible JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 58 4 Nash Nash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 58 5 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 58 6 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 58 7 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 58 8 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 58 9 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 58 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 2 proof proof NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 3 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 4 inductive inductive JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 6 one one PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 7 might may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 8 as as RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 9 well well RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 10 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 11 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 13 last last JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 14 turn turn NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 16 since since IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 17 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 18 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 19 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 20 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 21 have have VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 22 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 23 chance chance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 24 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 25 later later RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 26 retaliate retaliate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 59 27 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 60 1 Therefore therefore RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 60 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 60 3 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 60 4 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 60 5 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 60 6 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 60 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 60 8 last last JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 60 9 turn turn NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 60 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 1 Thus thus RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 4 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 5 might may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 6 as as RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 7 well well RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 8 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 9 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 11 second second NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 12 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 13 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 14 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 15 last last JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 16 turn turn NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 18 since since IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 20 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 21 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 22 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 23 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 24 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 25 last last JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 26 no no RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 27 matter matter RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 28 what what WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 29 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 30 done do VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 32 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 33 so so RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 34 on on RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 61 35 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 2 same same JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 3 applies apply VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 4 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 6 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 7 length length NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 8 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 9 unknown unknown JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 10 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 11 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 12 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 13 known know VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 14 upper upper JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 15 limit limit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 62 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 1 Unlike unlike IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 3 standard standard JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 4 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 5 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 6 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 10 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 11 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 12 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 13 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 15 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 16 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 17 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 18 counter counter JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 19 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 20 intuitive intuitive JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 21 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 22 fails fail VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 23 badly badly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 24 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 25 predict predict VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 26 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 27 behavior behavior NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 28 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 29 human human JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 30 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 63 31 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 1 Within within IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 2 standard standard JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 3 economic economic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 4 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 6 though though RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 8 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 9 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 11 only only JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 12 correct correct JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 13 answer answer NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 64 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 2 superrational superrational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 3 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 4 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 6 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 7 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 8 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 9 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 10 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 11 fixed fix VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 12 N n CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 13 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 14 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 15 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 16 against against IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 17 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 18 superrational superrational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 19 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 20 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 21 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 22 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 24 limit limit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 25 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 26 large large JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 27 N n NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 28 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 29 experimental experimental JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 30 results result NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 31 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 32 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 33 agree agree VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 34 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 35 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 36 superrational superrational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 37 version version NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 38 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 39 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 40 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 41 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 42 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 43 theoretic theoretic NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 44 rational rational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 45 one one NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 65 46 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 1 For for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 2 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 3 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 4 emerge emerge VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 5 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 6 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 7 theoretic theoretic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 8 rational rational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 9 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 12 total total JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 13 number number NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 15 rounds round NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 16 N n CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 17 must must MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 18 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 19 unknown unknown JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 20 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 22 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 66 23 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 2 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 3 case case NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 4 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 5 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 6 defect defect VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 7 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 8 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 9 no no RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 10 longer longer RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 11 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 12 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 13 strictly strictly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 14 dominant dominant JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 15 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 17 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 18 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 19 Nash Nash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 20 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 67 21 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 1 Amongst amongst IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 2 results result NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 3 shown show VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 4 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 5 Robert Robert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 6 Aumann Aumann NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 7 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 8 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 9 1959 1959 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 10 paper paper NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 12 rational rational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 13 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 14 repeatedly repeatedly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 15 interacting interact VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 16 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 17 indefinitely indefinitely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 18 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 19 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 20 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 21 sustain sustain VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 22 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 23 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 24 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 68 25 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 1 According accord VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 2 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 3 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 4 2019 2019 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 5 experimental experimental JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 6 study study NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 7 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 9 American American NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 10 Economic Economic NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 11 Review Review NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 12 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 13 tested test VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 14 what what WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 15 strategies strategie VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 16 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 17 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 18 life life NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 19 subjects subject NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 20 used use VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 21 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 22 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 23 prisoners prisoner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 24 ' ' POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 25 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 26 situations situation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 27 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 28 perfect perfect JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 29 monitoring monitoring NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 30 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 31 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 32 majority majority NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 33 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 34 chosen choose VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 35 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 36 were be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 37 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 38 defect defect JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 39 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 40 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 41 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 42 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 43 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 44 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 45 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 46 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 47 grim grim JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 48 trigger trigger NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 69 49 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 1 Which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 2 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 4 subjects subject NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 5 chose choose VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 6 depended depend VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 7 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 9 parameters parameter NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 12 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 70 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 2 13 13 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 4 Strategy Strategy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 5 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 7 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 8 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 9 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 10 dilemma[edit dilemma[edit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 11 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 12 Interest interest NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 13 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 15 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 16 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 17 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 18 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 19 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 20 IPD IPD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 21 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 22 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 23 kindled kindle VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 24 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 25 Robert Robert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 26 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 27 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 28 his -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 29 book book NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 30 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 31 Evolution Evolution NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 32 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 33 Cooperation Cooperation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 34 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 35 1984 1984 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 36 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 71 37 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 2 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 3 he -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 4 reports report VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 5 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 6 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 7 tournament tournament NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 8 he -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 9 organized organize VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 12 N N NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 13 step step NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 14 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 15 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 16 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 17 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 18 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 19 N N NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 20 fixed fix VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 21 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 22 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 23 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 24 participants participant NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 25 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 26 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 27 choose choose VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 28 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 29 mutual mutual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 30 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 31 again again RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 32 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 33 again again RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 34 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 35 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 36 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 37 memory memory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 38 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 39 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 40 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 41 encounters encounter NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 72 42 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 1 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 2 invited invite VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 3 academic academic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 4 colleagues colleague NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 5 all all RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 6 over over IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 8 world world NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 9 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 10 devise devise VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 11 computer computer NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 12 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 13 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 14 compete compete VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 15 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 16 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 17 IPD IPD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 18 tournament tournament NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 73 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 2 programs program NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 3 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 4 were be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 5 entered enter VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 6 varied varied JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 7 widely widely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 9 algorithmic algorithmic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 10 complexity complexity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 12 initial initial JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 13 hostility hostility NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 15 capacity capacity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 16 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 17 forgiveness forgiveness NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 19 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 20 so so RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 21 forth forth RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 74 22 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 1 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 2 discovered discover VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 3 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 4 when when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 5 these these DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 6 encounters encounter NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 7 were be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 8 repeated repeat VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 9 over over IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 10 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 11 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 12 period period NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 13 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 14 time time NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 15 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 16 many many JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 17 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 19 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 20 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 21 different different JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 22 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 23 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 24 greedy greedy JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 25 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 26 tended tend VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 27 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 28 do do VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 29 very very RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 30 poorly poorly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 31 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 32 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 33 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 34 run run NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 35 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 36 more more JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 37 altruistic altruistic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 38 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 39 did do VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 40 better well RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 41 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 42 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 43 judged judge VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 44 purely purely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 45 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 46 self self NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 47 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 48 interest interest NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 75 49 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 1 He -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 2 used use VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 3 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 4 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 5 show show VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 6 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 7 possible possible JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 8 mechanism mechanism NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 9 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 11 evolution evolution NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 13 altruistic altruistic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 14 behaviour behaviour NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 15 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 16 mechanisms mechanism NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 17 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 18 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 19 initially initially RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 20 purely purely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 21 selfish selfish JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 22 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 23 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 24 natural natural JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 25 selection selection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 76 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 2 winning win VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 3 deterministic deterministic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 4 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 5 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 6 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 7 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 8 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 10 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 11 Anatol Anatol NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 12 Rapoport Rapoport NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 13 developed develop VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 14 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 15 entered enter VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 16 into into IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 17 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 18 tournament tournament NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 77 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 2 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 4 simplest simple JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 5 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 6 any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 7 program program NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 8 entered enter VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 10 containing contain VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 11 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 12 four four CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 13 lines line NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 15 BASIC basic NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 17 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 18 won win VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 20 contest contest NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 78 21 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 2 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 3 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 4 simply simply RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 5 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 6 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 7 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 9 first first JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 10 iteration iteration NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 11 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 13 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 14 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 15 after after IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 16 that that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 18 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 19 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 20 does do VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 21 what what WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 22 his -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 23 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 24 her -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 25 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 26 did do VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 27 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 28 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 29 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 30 move move NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 79 31 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 1 Depending depend VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 2 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 4 situation situation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 6 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 7 slightly slightly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 8 better well JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 9 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 10 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 11 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 12 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 13 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 14 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 15 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 16 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 17 forgiveness forgiveness NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 18 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 80 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 1 When when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 3 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 4 defects defect VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 6 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 8 next next JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 9 move move NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 12 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 13 sometimes sometimes RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 14 cooperates cooperate VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 15 anyway anyway RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 17 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 18 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 19 small small JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 20 probability probability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 21 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 22 around around RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 23 1–5 1–5 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 24 % % NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 25 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 81 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 2 allows allow VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 3 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 4 occasional occasional JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 5 recovery recovery NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 6 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 7 getting get VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 8 trapped trap VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 9 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 10 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 11 cycle cycle NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 13 defections defection NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 82 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 2 exact exact JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 3 probability probability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 4 depends depend VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 5 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 7 line line NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 8 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 9 up up NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 11 opponents opponent NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 83 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 1 By by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 2 analysing analyse VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 4 top top RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 5 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 6 scoring score VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 7 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 9 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 10 stated state VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 11 several several JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 12 conditions condition NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 13 necessary necessary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 14 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 15 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 16 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 17 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 18 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 19 successful successful JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 84 20 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 1 Nice Nice NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 2 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 3 most most RBS en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 4 important important JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 5 condition condition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 6 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 7 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 9 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 10 must must MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 11 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 12 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 13 nice nice JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 14 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 16 that that RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 17 is is RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 19 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 20 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 21 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 22 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 23 before before IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 24 its -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 25 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 26 does do VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 27 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 28 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 29 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 30 sometimes sometimes RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 31 referred refer VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 32 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 33 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 34 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 35 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 36 optimistic optimistic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 37 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 38 algorithm algorithm NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 39 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 85 40 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 1 Almost almost RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 2 all all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 5 top top RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 7 scoring score VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 8 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 9 were be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 10 nice nice JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 11 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 12 therefore therefore RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 13 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 14 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 15 purely purely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 16 selfish selfish JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 17 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 18 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 19 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 20 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 21 cheat cheat VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 22 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 23 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 24 its -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 25 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 26 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 27 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 28 purely purely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 29 self self NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 30 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 31 interested interested JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 32 reasons reason NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 33 first first RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 86 34 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 1 Retaliating retaliate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 2 However however RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 4 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 5 contended contend VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 8 successful successful JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 9 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 10 must must MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 11 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 12 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 13 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 14 blind blind JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 15 optimist optimist NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 87 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 88 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 88 2 must must MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 88 3 sometimes sometimes RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 88 4 retaliate retaliate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 88 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 1 An an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 2 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 4 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 5 non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 6 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 7 retaliating retaliating JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 8 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 9 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 10 Always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 11 Cooperate Cooperate NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 89 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 2 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 3 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 4 very very RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 5 bad bad JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 6 choice choice NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 8 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 9 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 10 nasty nasty JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 11 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 12 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 13 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 14 ruthlessly ruthlessly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 15 exploit exploit VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 16 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 17 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 90 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 91 1 Forgiving forgive VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 91 2 Successful successful JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 91 3 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 91 4 must must MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 91 5 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 91 6 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 91 7 forgiving forgive VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 91 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 1 Though though IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 2 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 3 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 4 retaliate retaliate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 6 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 7 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 8 once once RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 9 again again RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 10 fall fall VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 11 back back RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 12 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 13 cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 14 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 15 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 16 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 17 does do VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 18 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 19 continue continue VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 20 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 21 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 92 22 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 2 stops stop VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 3 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 4 runs run NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 5 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 6 revenge revenge NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 7 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 8 counter counter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 9 - - NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 10 revenge revenge NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 12 maximizing maximize VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 13 points point NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 93 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 1 Non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 2 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 3 envious envious JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 4 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 5 last last JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 6 quality quality NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 7 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 8 being be VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 9 non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 10 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 11 envious envious JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 13 that that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 14 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 15 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 16 striving strive VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 17 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 18 score score VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 19 more more JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 20 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 22 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 94 23 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 2 optimal optimal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 3 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 4 points point NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 5 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 6 maximizing maximize VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 8 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 9 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 11 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 12 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 13 time time NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 14 PD PD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 15 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 16 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 17 simply simply RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 18 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 19 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 20 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 21 explained explain VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 22 above above RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 23 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 24 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 25 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 26 true true JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 27 whatever whatever WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 28 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 29 composition composition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 30 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 31 opponents opponent NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 32 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 33 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 95 34 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 1 However however RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 3 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 5 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 7 PD PD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 8 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 10 optimal optimal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 11 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 12 depends depend VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 13 upon upon IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 15 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 16 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 17 likely likely JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 18 opponents opponent NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 20 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 21 how how WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 22 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 23 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 24 react react VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 25 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 26 defections defection NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 27 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 28 cooperations cooperation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 96 29 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 1 For for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 2 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 4 consider consider VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 5 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 6 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 7 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 8 everyone everyone NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 9 defects defect VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 10 every every DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 11 time time NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 13 except except IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 14 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 15 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 16 single single JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 17 individual individual NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 18 following follow VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 20 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 21 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 22 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 23 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 97 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 1 That that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 2 individual individual NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 3 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 4 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 5 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 6 slight slight JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 7 disadvantage disadvantage NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 8 because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 9 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 11 loss loss NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 12 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 14 first first JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 15 turn turn NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 98 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 2 such such PDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 3 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 4 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 7 optimal optimal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 8 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 9 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 10 that that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 11 individual individual NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 12 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 13 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 14 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 15 every every DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 16 time time NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 99 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 3 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 4 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 5 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 6 certain certain JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 7 percentage percentage NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 8 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 9 always alway NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 10 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 11 defectors defector NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 12 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 14 rest rest NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 15 being be VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 16 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 17 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 18 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 19 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 20 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 22 optimal optimal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 23 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 24 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 25 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 26 individual individual NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 27 depends depend VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 28 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 29 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 30 percentage percentage NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 32 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 33 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 34 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 35 length length NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 36 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 37 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 38 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 100 39 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 3 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 4 called call VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 5 Pavlov Pavlov NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 7 win win NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 8 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 9 stay stay VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 11 lose lose JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 12 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 13 switch switch NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 15 faced face VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 16 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 17 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 18 failure failure NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 19 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 20 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 21 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 22 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 23 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 24 switches switch VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 25 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 26 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 27 next next JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 28 turn turn NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 101 29 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 2 14 14 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 4 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 5 certain certain JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 6 circumstances,[specify circumstances,[specify . en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 7 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 8 Pavlov Pavlov NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 9 beats beat VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 10 all all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 11 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 12 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 13 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 14 giving give VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 15 preferential preferential JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 16 treatment treatment NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 17 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 18 co co NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 19 - - NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 20 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 21 using use VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 22 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 23 similar similar JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 24 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 102 25 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 1 Deriving derive VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 3 optimal optimal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 4 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 5 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 6 generally generally RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 7 done do VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 9 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 10 ways way NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 11 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 12 Bayesian Bayesian NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 13 Nash Nash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 14 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 15 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 16 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 17 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 18 statistical statistical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 19 distribution distribution NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 20 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 21 opposing oppose VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 22 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 23 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 24 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 25 determined determine VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 26 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 103 27 e.g. e.g. RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 1 50 50 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 2 % % NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 3 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 4 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 5 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 7 50 50 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 8 % % NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 9 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 10 cooperate cooperate VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 11 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 12 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 13 optimal optimal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 14 counter counter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 15 - - NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 16 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 17 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 18 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 19 derived derive VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 20 analytically analytically RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 104 21 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 4 Monte Monte NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 5 Carlo Carlo NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 6 simulations simulation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 8 populations population NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 9 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 10 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 11 made make VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 13 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 14 individuals individual NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 15 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 16 low low JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 17 scores score NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 18 die die VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 19 off off RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 20 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 21 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 22 those those DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 23 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 24 high high JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 25 scores score NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 26 reproduce reproduce VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 27 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 28 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 29 genetic genetic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 30 algorithm algorithm NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 31 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 32 finding find VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 33 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 34 optimal optimal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 35 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 36 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 105 37 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 2 mix mix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 4 algorithms algorithm NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 5 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 7 final final JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 8 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 9 generally generally RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 10 depends depend VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 11 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 13 mix mix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 14 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 15 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 16 initial initial JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 17 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 106 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 2 introduction introduction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 4 mutation mutation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 6 random random JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 7 variation variation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 8 during during IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 9 reproduction reproduction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 10 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 11 lessens lessen VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 13 dependency dependency NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 14 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 15 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 16 initial initial JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 17 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 18 ; ; , en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 19 empirical empirical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 20 experiments experiment NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 21 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 22 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 23 systems system NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 24 tend tend VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 25 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 26 produce produce VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 27 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 28 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 29 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 30 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 31 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 32 see see VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 33 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 34 instance instance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 35 Chess Chess NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 36 1988),[clarification 1988),[clarification CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 37 needed need VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 38 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 39 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 40 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 41 analytic analytic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 42 proof proof NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 43 exists exist VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 44 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 45 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 46 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 47 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 48 occur occur VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 107 49 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 2 16 16 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 4 Although although IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 5 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 6 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 7 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 8 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 9 considered consider VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 10 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 11 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 13 most most RBS en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 14 robust robust JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 15 basic basic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 16 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 18 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 19 team team NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 20 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 21 Southampton Southampton NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 22 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 23 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 24 England England NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 25 introduced introduce VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 26 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 27 new new JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 28 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 29 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 30 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 31 20th 20th JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 32 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 33 anniversary anniversary NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 34 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 35 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 36 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 37 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 38 competition competition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 39 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 40 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 41 proved prove VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 42 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 43 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 44 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 45 successful successful JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 46 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 47 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 48 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 49 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 108 50 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 2 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 3 relied rely VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 4 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 5 collusion collusion NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 6 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 7 programs program NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 8 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 9 achieve achieve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 11 highest high JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 12 number number NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 13 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 14 points point NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 15 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 16 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 17 single single JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 18 program program NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 109 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 2 university university NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 3 submitted submit VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 4 60 60 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 5 programs program NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 6 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 8 competition competition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 10 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 11 were be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 12 designed design VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 13 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 14 recognize recognize VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 15 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 16 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 17 through through IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 18 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 19 series series NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 20 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 21 five five CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 22 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 23 ten ten CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 24 moves move NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 25 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 26 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 27 start start NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 110 28 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 2 17 17 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 4 Once once IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 5 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 6 recognition recognition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 7 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 8 made make VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 10 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 11 program program NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 12 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 13 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 14 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 15 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 16 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 17 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 18 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 19 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 20 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 21 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 22 assuring assure VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 24 maximum maximum JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 25 number number NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 26 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 27 points point NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 28 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 29 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 30 defector defector NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 111 31 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 3 program program NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 4 realized realize VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 5 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 6 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 7 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 8 playing play VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 9 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 10 non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 11 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 12 Southampton southampton JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 13 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 15 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 16 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 17 continuously continuously RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 18 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 19 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 20 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 21 attempt attempt NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 22 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 23 minimize minimize VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 24 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 25 score score NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 26 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 27 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 28 competing compete VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 29 program program NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 112 30 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 1 As as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 3 result result NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 6 2004 2004 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 7 Prisoners Prisoners NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 8 ' ' POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 9 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 10 Tournament Tournament NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 11 results result NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 12 show show VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 13 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 15 Southampton Southampton NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 16 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 17 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 18 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 20 first first JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 21 three three CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 22 places place NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 23 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 24 despite despite IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 25 having have VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 26 fewer few JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 27 wins win NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 28 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 29 many many JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 30 more more JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 31 losses loss NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 32 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 33 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 34 GRIM GRIM NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 35 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 113 36 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 1 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 2 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 3 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 4 PD pd NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 5 tournament tournament NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 8 aim aim NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 9 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 11 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 12 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 13 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 14 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 15 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 16 win win VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 17 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 18 matches match NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 19   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 20 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 21 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 22 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 23 easily easily RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 24 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 25 achieved achieve VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 26 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 27 frequent frequent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 28 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 29 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 114 30 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 1 Also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 3 even even RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 4 without without IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 5 implicit implicit JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 6 collusion collusion NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 7 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 8 software software NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 9 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 10 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 11 exploited exploit VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 12 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 14 Southampton Southampton NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 15 team team NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 16 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 17 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 18 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 19 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 20 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 21 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 22 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 24 absolute absolute JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 25 winner winner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 26 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 27 any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 28 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 29 tournament tournament NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 30 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 31 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 32 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 33 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 34 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 35 precise precise JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 36 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 37 say say VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 38 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 39 its -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 40 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 41 run run NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 42 results result NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 43 over over IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 44 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 45 series series NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 46 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 47 tournaments tournament NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 48 outperform outperform VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 49 its -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 50 rivals rival NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 115 51 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 1 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 2 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 3 any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 4 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 5 event event NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 6 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 7 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 8 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 9 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 10 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 11 slightly slightly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 12 better well RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 13 adjusted adjust VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 14 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 15 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 16 competition competition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 17 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 18 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 19 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 20 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 21 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 22 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 23 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 24 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 25 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 26 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 27 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 28 robust robust JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 29 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 116 30 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 2 same same JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 3 applies apply VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 4 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 6 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 7 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 8 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 9 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 10 forgiveness forgiveness NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 11 variant variant JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 13 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 14 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 15 optimal optimal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 16 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 17 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 18 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 19 any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 20 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 21 day day NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 22 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 23 might may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 24 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 25 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 26 win win VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 27 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 28 against against IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 29 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 30 specific specific JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 31 mix mix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 32 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 33 counter counter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 34 - - NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 35 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 117 36 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 1 An an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 2 alternative alternative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 3 way way NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 5 putting put VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 6 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 7 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 8 using use VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 10 Darwinian darwinian JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 11 ESS ESS NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 12 simulation simulation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 118 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 2 such such PDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 3 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 4 simulation simulation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 6 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 7 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 8 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 9 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 10 almost almost RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 11 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 12 come come VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 13 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 14 dominate dominate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 16 though though IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 17 nasty nasty JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 18 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 19 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 20 drift drift VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 21 in in RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 22 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 23 out out IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 24 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 25 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 26 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 27 because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 28 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 29 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 30 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 31 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 32 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 33 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 34 penetrable penetrable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 35 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 36 non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 37 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 38 retaliating retaliating JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 39 nice nice JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 40 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 41 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 42 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 43 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 44 turn turn NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 45 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 46 easy easy JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 47 prey prey NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 48 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 49 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 50 nasty nasty JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 51 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 119 52 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 1 Richard Richard NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 2 Dawkins Dawkins NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 3 showed show VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 4 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 5 here here RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 7 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 8 static static JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 9 mix mix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 11 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 12 form form VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 13 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 14 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 15 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 16 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 17 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 18 system system NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 19 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 20 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 21 oscillate oscillate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 22 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 23 bounds bound NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 25 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 120 26 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 1 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 2 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 3 ended end VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 4 up up RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 5 taking take VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 7 top top JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 8 three three CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 9 positions position NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 10 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 12 competition competition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 13 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 14 as as RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 15 well well RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 16 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 17 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 18 number number NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 19 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 20 positions position NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 21 towards towards IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 22 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 23 bottom bottom NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 121 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 2 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 3 takes take VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 4 advantage advantage NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 5 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 7 fact fact NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 8 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 9 multiple multiple JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 10 entries entry NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 11 were be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 12 allowed allow VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 13 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 14 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 15 particular particular JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 16 competition competition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 17 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 18 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 20 performance performance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 21 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 22 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 23 team team NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 24 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 25 measured measure VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 26 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 27 that that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 28 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 29 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 30 highest highest RBS en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 31 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 32 scoring score VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 33 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 34 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 35 meaning mean VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 36 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 37 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 38 use use NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 39 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 40 self self NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 41 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 42 sacrificing sacrifice VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 43 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 44 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 45 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 46 form form NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 47 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 48 minmaxing minmaxing NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 49 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 122 50 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 3 competition competition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 4 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 5 one one PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 6 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 7 control control NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 8 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 9 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 10 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 11 single single JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 12 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 13 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 14 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 15 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 16 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 17 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 18 certainly certainly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 19 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 20 better well JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 21 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 123 22 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 1 Because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 3 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 4 new new JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 5 rule rule NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 7 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 8 competition competition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 9 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 10 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 11 little little JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 12 theoretical theoretical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 13 significance significance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 14 when when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 15 analyzing analyze VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 16 single single JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 17 agent agent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 18 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 19 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 20 compared compare VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 21 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 22 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 23 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 24 seminal seminal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 25 tournament tournament NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 124 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 1 However however RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 3 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 4 provided provide VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 5 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 6 basis basis NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 7 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 8 analysing analyse VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 9 how how WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 10 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 11 achieve achieve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 12 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 13 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 14 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 15 multi multi JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 16 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 17 agent agent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 18 frameworks framework NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 20 especially especially RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 21 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 22 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 23 presence presence NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 24 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 25 noise noise NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 125 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 2 fact fact NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 4 long long RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 5 before before IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 6 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 7 new new JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 8 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 9 rules rule NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 10 tournament tournament NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 11 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 12 played play VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 13 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 14 Dawkins Dawkins NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 16 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 17 his -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 18 book book NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 19 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 20 Selfish Selfish NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 21 Gene Gene NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 22 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 23 pointed point VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 24 out out RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 25 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 26 possibility possibility NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 27 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 28 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 29 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 30 winning win VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 31 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 32 multiple multiple JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 33 entries entry NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 34 were be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 35 allowed allow VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 36 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 37 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 38 he -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 39 remarked remark VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 40 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 41 most most RBS en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 42 probably probably RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 43 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 44 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 45 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 46 have have VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 47 allowed allow VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 48 them -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 49 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 50 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 51 had have VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 52 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 53 submitted submit VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 126 54 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 2 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 3 relies rely VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 4 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 5 circumventing circumvent VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 6 rules rule NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 7 about about IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 9 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 10 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 11 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 12 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 13 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 14 there there EX en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 15 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 16 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 17 communication communication NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 18 allowed allow VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 19 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 21 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 22 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 23 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 24 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 25 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 26 Southampton Southampton NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 27 programs program NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 28 arguably arguably RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 29 did do VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 30 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 31 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 32 opening open VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 33 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 34 ten ten CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 35 move move NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 36 dance dance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 37 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 38 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 39 recognize recognize VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 40 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 41 another another DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 42 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 43 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 44 only only JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 45 reinforces reinforce VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 46 just just RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 47 how how WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 48 valuable valuable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 49 communication communication NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 50 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 51 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 52 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 53 shifting shift VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 54 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 55 balance balance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 56 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 57 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 58 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 127 59 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 1 Stochastic stochastic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 2 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 3 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 4 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 5 dilemma[edit dilemma[edit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 6 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 7 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 8 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 9 stochastic stochastic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 10 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 11 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 12 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 13 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 14 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 16 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 17 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 18 specified specify VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 19 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 20 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 21 terms term NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 22 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 23 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 24 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 25 probabilities probability NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 26 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 128 27 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 2 18 18 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 4 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 5 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 6 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 7 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 8 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 9 X x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 10 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 11 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 12 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 13 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 14 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 15 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 16 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 17 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 18 specified specify VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 19 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 20 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 21 set set NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 22 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 23 probabilities probability NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 24 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 25 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 26 cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 27 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 28 Y. Y. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 29 P P NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 30 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 31 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 32 function function NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 33 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 34 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 35 outcomes outcome NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 36 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 37 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 38 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 39 encounters encounter NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 40 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 41 some some DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 42 subset subset NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 43 thereof thereof RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 129 44 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 2 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 3 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 4 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 5 function function NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 7 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 8 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 9 most most RBS en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 10 recent recent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 11 n n JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 12 encounters encounter NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 13 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 14 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 15 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 16 called call VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 17 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 18 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 19 memory memory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 20 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 21 n n NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 22 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 23 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 130 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 1 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 2 memory-1 memory-1 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 3 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 5 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 6 specified specify VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 7 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 8 four four CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 9 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 10 probabilities probability NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 11 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 12 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 13 = = NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 14 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 15 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 16 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 17 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 19 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 20 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 21 d d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 22 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 23 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 24 d d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 25 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 26 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 27 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 28 d d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 29 d d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 30 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 31 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 32 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 33 P=\{P_{cc},P_{cd},P_{dc},P_{dd}\ p=\{p_{cc},p_{cd},p_{dc},p_{dd}\ NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 34 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 35 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 36 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 37 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 38 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 39 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 40 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 41 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 42 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 43 P_{ab P_{ab NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 44 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 45 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 46 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 47 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 48 probability probability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 49 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 50 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 51 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 52 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 53 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 54 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 55 present present JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 56 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 57 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 58 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 59 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 60 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 61 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 62 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 63 characterized characterize VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 64 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 65 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 66 ab ab NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 67 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 131 68 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 1 For for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 2 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 4 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 6 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 7 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 8 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 9 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 10 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 11 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 12 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 13 cooperated cooperate VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 14 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 15 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 16 defected defect VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 18 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 19 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 20 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 21 d d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 22 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 23 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 24 P_{cd p_{cd NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 25 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 26 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 27 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 28 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 29 probability probability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 30 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 31 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 32 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 33 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 34 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 35 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 36 present present JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 37 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 132 38 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 2 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 5 probabilities probability NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 6 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 7 either either CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 8 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 9 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 10 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 13 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 14 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 15 called call VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 16 deterministic deterministic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 133 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 1 An an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 2 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 4 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 5 deterministic deterministic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 6 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 7 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 9 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 10 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 11 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 12 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 13 written write VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 14 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 15 P={1,0,1,0 p={1,0,1,0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 16 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 18 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 19 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 20 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 21 responds respond VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 22 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 23 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 24 did do VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 25 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 26 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 27 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 28 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 134 29 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 1 Another another DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 2 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 4 win win NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 5 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 6 stay stay VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 8 lose lose VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 9 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 10 switch switch NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 11 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 12 written write VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 13 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 14 P={1,0,0,1 p={1,0,0,1 RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 15 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 17 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 18 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 19 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 20 responds respond VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 21 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 22 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 24 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 25 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 26 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 27 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 28 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 29 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 30 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 31 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 32 win win NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 33 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 34 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 135 35 i.e. i.e. FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 1 cc cc NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 2 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 3 dc dc NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 5 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 6 changes change VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 7 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 8 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 9 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 10 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 11 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 12 loss loss NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 13 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 136 14 i.e. i.e. FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 137 1 cd cd NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 137 2 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 137 3 dd dd NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 137 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 137 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 2 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 3 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 4 shown show VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 5 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 6 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 7 any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 8 memory memory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 9 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 10 n n CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 11 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 12 there there EX en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 13 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 14 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 15 corresponding corresponding JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 16 memory-1 memory-1 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 17 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 18 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 19 gives give VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 21 same same JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 22 statistical statistical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 23 results result NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 24 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 25 so so IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 26 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 27 only only JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 28 memory-1 memory-1 JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 29 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 30 need need VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 31 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 32 considered consider VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 138 33 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 2 18 18 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 4 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 5 we -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 6 define define VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 7 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 8 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 10 above above JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 11 4-element 4-element CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 12 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 13 vector vector NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 15 X x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 16 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 17 Q q NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 18 = = NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 19 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 20 Q q NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 21 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 22 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 23 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 24 Q q NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 25 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 26 d d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 27 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 28 Q Q NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 29 d d NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 30 c c NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 32 Q Q NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 33 d d NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 34 d d NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 35 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 36 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 37 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 38 Q=\{Q_{cc},Q_{cd},Q_{dc},Q_{dd}\ q=\{q_{cc},q_{cd},q_{dc},q_{dd}\ NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 39 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 40 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 41 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 42 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 43 4-element 4-element CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 44 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 45 vector vector NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 46 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 47 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 48 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 49 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 50 transition transition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 51 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 52 M M NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 53 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 54 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 55 defined define VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 56 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 57 X X NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 58 whose whose WP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 59 ij ij NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 60 th th XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 61 entry entry NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 62 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 63 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 64 probability probability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 65 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 66 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 67 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 68 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 69 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 70 particular particular JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 71 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 72 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 73 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 74 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 75 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 76 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 77 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 78 j j NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 79 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 80 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 81 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 82 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 83 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 84 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 85 i i PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 86 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 87 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 88 i i PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 89 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 90 j j NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 91 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 92 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 93 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 94 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 95 four four CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 96 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 97 indices index NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 98 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 99 cc cc NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 100 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 101 cd cd NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 102 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 103 dc dc NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 104 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 105 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 106 dd dd NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 139 107 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 1 For for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 2 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 4 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 5 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 6 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 7 point point NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 8 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 9 view view NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 12 probability probability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 13 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 15 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 16 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 17 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 18 present present JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 19 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 20 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 21 cd cd NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 22 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 23 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 24 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 25 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 26 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 27 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 28 cd cd NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 29 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 30 equal equal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 31 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 32 M M NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 33 c c NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 34 d d NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 35 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 36 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 37 d d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 38 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 39 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 40 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 41 d d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 42 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 43 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 44 − − NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 45 Q Q NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 46 d d NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 47 c c NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 48 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 49 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 50 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 51 M_{cd m_{cd NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 52 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 53 cd}=P_{cd}(1-Q_{dc cd}=P_{cd}(1-Q_{dc NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 54 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 55 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 56 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 140 57 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 1 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 2 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 3 indices index NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 4 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 5 Q Q NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 6 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 7 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 8 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 9 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 10 point point NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 11 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 12 view view NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 13 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 14 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 15 cd cd NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 16 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 17 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 18 X x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 19 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 20 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 21 dc dc NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 22 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 23 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 24 Y. Y. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 141 25 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 1 Under under IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 2 these these DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 3 definitions definition NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 6 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 7 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 8 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 9 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 10 qualifies qualify VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 11 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 12 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 13 stochastic stochastic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 14 process process NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 15 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 16 M m NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 17 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 18 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 19 stochastic stochastic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 20 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 21 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 22 allowing allow VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 23 all all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 24 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 25 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 26 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 27 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 28 stochastic stochastic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 29 processes process NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 30 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 31 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 32 applied apply VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 142 33 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 2 18 18 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 4 One one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 5 result result NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 7 stochastic stochastic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 8 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 9 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 10 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 11 there there EX en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 12 exists exist VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 13 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 14 stationary stationary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 15 vector vector NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 16 v v NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 17 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 18 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 19 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 20 M m NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 21 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 22 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 23 v v LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 24 ⋅ ⋅ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 25 M M NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 26 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 27 v v NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 28 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 29 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 30 v\cdot v\cdot NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 31 M m NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 32 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 33 v v NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 34 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 143 35 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 1 Without without IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 2 loss loss NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 4 generality generality NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 6 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 7 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 8 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 9 specified specify VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 10 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 11 v v NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 12 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 13 normalized normalized JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 14 so so IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 15 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 16 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 17 sum sum NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 18 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 19 its -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 20 four four CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 21 components component NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 22 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 23 unity unity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 144 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 2 ij ij NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 3 th th XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 4 entry entry NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 5 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 6 M M NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 7 n n CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 8 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 9 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 10 M^{n M^{n NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 11 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 12 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 13 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 14 give give VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 15 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 16 probability probability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 17 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 18 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 19 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 20 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 21 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 22 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 23 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 24 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 25 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 26 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 27 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 28 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 29 j j NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 30 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 31 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 32 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 33 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 34 n n JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 35 steps step NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 36 previous previous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 37 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 145 38 i. i. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 3 limit limit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 4 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 5 n n DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 6 approaches approach VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 7 infinity infinity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 9 M M NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 10 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 11 converge converge VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 12 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 13 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 14 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 15 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 16 fixed fix VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 17 values value NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 19 giving give VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 21 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 22 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 23 term term NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 24 probabilities probability NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 25 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 26 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 27 encounter encounter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 28 producing produce VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 29 j j NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 30 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 31 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 32 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 33 independent independent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 34 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 146 35 i. i. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 2 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 3 words word NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 6 rows row NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 8 M M NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 9 ∞ ∞ NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 10 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 11 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 12 M^{\infty M^{\infty NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 13 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 14 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 15 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 16 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 17 identical identical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 19 giving give VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 21 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 22 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 23 term term NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 24 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 25 result result NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 26 probabilities probability NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 27 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 28 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 29 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 30 prisoners prisoner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 31 dilemma dilemma VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 32 without without IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 33 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 34 need need NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 35 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 36 explicitly explicitly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 37 evaluate evaluate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 38 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 39 large large JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 40 number number NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 41 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 42 interactions interaction NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 147 43 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 2 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 3 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 4 seen see VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 5 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 6 v v NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 7 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 8 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 9 stationary stationary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 10 vector vector NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 11 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 12 M M NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 13 n n CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 14 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 15 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 16 M^{n M^{n NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 17 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 18 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 19 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 20 particularly particularly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 21 M m NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 22 ∞ ∞ NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 23 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 24 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 25 M^{\infty M^{\infty NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 26 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 27 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 28 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 29 so so IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 30 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 31 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 32 row row NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 33 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 34 M M NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 35 ∞ ∞ NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 36 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 37 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 38 M^{\infty M^{\infty NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 39 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 40 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 41 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 42 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 43 equal equal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 44 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 45 v. v. VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 46 Thus thus RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 47 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 48 stationary stationary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 49 vector vector NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 50 specifies specify VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 51 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 52 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 53 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 54 probabilities probability NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 55 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 148 56 X. X. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 1 Defining define VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 2 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 3 x x NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 4 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 5 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 6 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 8 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 10 T t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 12 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 13 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 14 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 15 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 16 S_{x}=\{R s_{x}=\{r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 18 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 20 T T NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 21 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 22 P\ p\ UH en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 23 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 24 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 25 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 26 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 27 y y FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 28 = = NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 29 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 30 R r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 32 T t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 33 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 34 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 35 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 36 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 37 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 38 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 39 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 40 S_{y}=\{R s_{y}=\{r NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 41 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 42 T T NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 43 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 44 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 45 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 46 P\ p\ UH en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 47 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 48 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 49 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 50 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 51 short short JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 52 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 53 term term NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 54 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 55 vectors vector NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 56 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 57 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 58 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 59 cc cc NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 60 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 61 cd cd NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 62 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 63 dc dc NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 64 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 65 dd dd NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 66 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 67 outcomes outcome NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 68 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 69 From from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 70 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 71 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 72 point point NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 73 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 74 view view NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 75 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 76 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 77 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 78 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 79 payoffs payoff NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 80 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 81 X x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 82 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 83 Y y NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 84 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 85 now now RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 86 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 87 specified specify VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 88 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 89 s s NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 90 x x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 91 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 92 v v NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 93 ⋅ ⋅ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 94 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 95 x x NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 96 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 97 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 98 s_{x}=v\cdot s_{x}=v\cdot NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 99 S_{x S_{x NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 100 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 101 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 102 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 103 s s NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 104 y y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 105 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 106 v v NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 107 ⋅ ⋅ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 108 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 109 y y NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 110 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 111 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 112 s_{y}=v\cdot s_{y}=v\cdot NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 113 S_{y S_{y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 114 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 115 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 116 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 117 allowing allow VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 118 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 119 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 120 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 121 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 122 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 123 Q q NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 124 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 125 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 126 compared compare VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 127 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 128 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 129 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 130 term term NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 131 payoffs payoff NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 149 132 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 1 Zero zero CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 2 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 3 determinant determinant NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 4 strategies[edit strategies[edit , en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 5 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 6 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 7 relationship relationship NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 8 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 9 zero zero CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 10 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 11 determinant determinant NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 12 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 13 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 14 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 16 cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 17 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 18 defecting defect VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 19 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 20 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 22 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 23 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 24 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 25 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 26 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 27 IPD IPD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 28 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 29 illustrated illustrate VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 30 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 31 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 32 Venn Venn NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 33 diagram diagram NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 150 34 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 1 Cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 2 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 3 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 4 cooperate cooperate VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 5 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 6 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 7 cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 8 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 10 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 11 defecting defect VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 12 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 13 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 14 defect defect VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 15 against against IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 16 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 17 defecting defect VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 18 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 151 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 1 Both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 2 contain contain VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 3 subsets subset NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 5 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 6 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 7 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 8 robust robust JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 9 under under IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 10 strong strong JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 11 selection selection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 13 meaning mean VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 14 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 15 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 16 memory-1 memory-1 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 17 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 18 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 19 selected select VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 20 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 21 invade invade VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 22 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 23 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 24 when when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 25 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 26 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 27 resident resident JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 28 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 29 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 30 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 152 31 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 1 Only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 2 cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 3 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 4 contain contain VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 5 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 6 subset subset NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 7 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 8 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 9 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 10 robust robust JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 12 meaning mean VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 13 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 14 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 15 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 16 memory-1 memory-1 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 17 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 18 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 19 selected select VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 20 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 21 invade invade VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 22 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 23 replace replace VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 24 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 25 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 26 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 27 under under IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 28 both both CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 29 strong strong JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 30 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 31 weak weak JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 32 selection selection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 153 33 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 2 intersection intersection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 3 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 4 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 5 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 6 good good JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 7 cooperating cooperating NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 8 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 9 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 11 set set NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 13 generous generous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 14 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 15 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 154 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 1 Extortion extortion NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 2 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 3 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 5 intersection intersection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 6 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 7 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 8 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 9 non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 10 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 11 robust robust JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 12 defecting defect VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 13 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 155 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 1 Tit Tit VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 2 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 3 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 5 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 6 lies lie NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 7 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 9 intersection intersection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 11 cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 13 defecting defecting NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 14 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 15 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 16 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 156 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 2 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 4 William William NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 5 H. H. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 6 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 7 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 8 Freeman Freeman NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 9 Dyson Dyson NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 10 published publish VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 11 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 12 new new JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 13 class class NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 15 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 16 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 17 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 18 stochastic stochastic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 19 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 20 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 21 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 22 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 23 called call VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 24 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 25 zero zero CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 26 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 27 determinant determinant NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 28 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 29 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 30 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 31 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 32 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 157 33 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 2 18 18 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 4 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 5 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 6 term term NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 7 payoffs payoff NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 8 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 9 encounters encounter NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 10 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 11 X x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 12 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 13 Y y NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 14 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 15 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 16 expressed express VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 17 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 18 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 19 determinant determinant NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 20 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 21 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 22 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 23 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 24 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 25 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 26 function function NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 27 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 28 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 29 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 30 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 31 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 32 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 33 short short JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 34 term term NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 35 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 36 vectors vector NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 37 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 38 s s NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 39 x x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 40 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 41 D d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 42 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 43 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 44 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 45 Q Q NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 46 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 47 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 48 x x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 49 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 50 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 51 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 52 s_{x}=D(P s_{x}=d(p UH en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 53 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 54 Q Q NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 55 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 56 S_{x S_{x NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 57 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 58 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 59 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 60 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 61 s s NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 62 y y NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 63 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 64 D d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 65 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 66 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 67 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 68 Q Q NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 69 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 70 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 71 y y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 72 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 73 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 74 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 75 s_{y}=D(P s_{y}=d(p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 76 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 77 Q Q NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 78 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 79 S_{y S_{y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 80 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 81 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 82 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 83 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 84 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 85 do do VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 86 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 87 involve involve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 88 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 89 stationary stationary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 90 vector vector NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 91 v. v. CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 92 Since since IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 93 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 94 determinant determinant JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 95 function function NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 96 s s POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 97 y y NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 98 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 99 D d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 100 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 101 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 102 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 103 Q Q NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 104 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 105 f f LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 106 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 107 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 108 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 109 s_{y}=D(P s_{y}=d(p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 110 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 111 Q Q NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 112 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 113 f f NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 114 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 115 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 116 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 117 linear linear JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 118 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 119 f f NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 120 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 121 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 122 follows follow VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 123 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 124 α α NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 125 s s NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 126 x x NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 127 + + NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 128 β β NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 129 s s NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 130 y y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 131 + + CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 132 γ γ NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 133 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 134 D d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 135 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 136 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 137 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 138 Q q NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 139 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 140 α α NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 141 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 142 x x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 143 + + SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 144 β β NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 145 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 146 y y NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 147 + + CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 148 γ γ NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 149 U u NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 150 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 151 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 152 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 153 \alpha \alpha CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 154 s_{x}+\beta s_{x}+\beta NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 155 s_{y}+\gamma s_{y}+\gamma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 156 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 157 D(P D(P NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 158 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 159 Q,\alpha Q,\alpha NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 160 S_{x}+\beta S_{x}+\beta NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 161 S_{y}+\gamma S_{y}+\gamma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 162 U u NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 163 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 164 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 165 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 166 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 167 U={1,1,1,1 U={1,1,1,1 NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 168 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 169 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 158 170 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 1 Any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 2 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 3 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 4 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 5 D d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 6 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 7 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 9 Q q NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 11 α α NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 12 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 13 x x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 14 + + SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 15 β β NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 16 S s NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 17 y y NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 18 + + CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 19 γ γ NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 20 U u NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 21 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 22 = = NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 23 0 0 NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 24 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 25 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 26 D(P D(P NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 27 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 28 Q,\alpha Q,\alpha NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 29 S_{x}+\beta S_{x}+\beta NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 30 S_{y}+\gamma S_{y}+\gamma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 31 U)=0 u)=0 NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 32 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 33 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 34 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 35 definition definition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 36 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 37 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 38 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 39 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 40 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 41 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 42 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 43 term term NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 44 payoffs payoff NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 45 obey obey VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 46 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 47 relation relation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 48 α α NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 49 s s NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 50 x x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 51 + + NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 52 β β NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 53 s s NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 54 y y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 55 + + CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 56 γ γ NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 57 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 58 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 59 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 60 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 61 \alpha \alpha CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 62 s_{x}+\beta s_{x}+\beta NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 63 s_{y}+\gamma s_{y}+\gamma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 64 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 65 0 0 NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 66 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 159 67 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 1 Tit Tit VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 2 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 3 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 5 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 6 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 7 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 8 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 9 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 10 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 11 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 12 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 13 fair fair JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 14 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 15 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 16 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 17 sense sense NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 18 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 19 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 20 gaining gain VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 21 advantage advantage NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 22 over over IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 24 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 25 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 160 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 1 However however RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 4 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 5 space space NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 6 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 7 contains contain VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 8 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 9 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 11 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 13 case case NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 15 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 16 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 18 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 19 allow allow VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 20 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 21 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 22 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 23 unilaterally unilaterally RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 24 set set VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 25 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 26 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 27 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 28 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 29 score score NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 30 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 31 alternatively alternatively RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 32 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 33 force force VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 34 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 35 evolutionary evolutionary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 36 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 37 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 38 achieve achieve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 39 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 40 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 41 some some DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 42 percentage percentage NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 43 lower low JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 44 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 45 his -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 46 own own JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 161 47 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 2 extorted extorted JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 3 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 4 could could MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 5 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 6 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 7 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 8 thereby thereby RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 9 hurt hurt VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 10 himself -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 11 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 12 getting get VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 13 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 14 lower low JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 15 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 162 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 1 Thus thus RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 3 extortion extortion NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 4 solutions solution NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 5 turn turn VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 7 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 8 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 9 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 10 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 11 into into IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 12 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 13 sort sort NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 15 ultimatum ultimatum NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 16 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 163 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 1 Specifically specifically RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 3 X X NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 5 able able JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 6 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 7 choose choose VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 8 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 9 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 10 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 11 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 12 D d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 13 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 14 P p NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 16 Q q NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 18 β β NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 19 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 20 y y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 21 + + CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 22 γ γ NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 23 U u NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 24 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 25 = = NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 26 0 0 NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 27 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 28 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 29 D(P D(P NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 30 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 31 Q,\beta q,\beta XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 32 S_{y}+\gamma s_{y}+\gamma JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 33 U)=0 u)=0 JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 34 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 35 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 36 unilaterally unilaterally RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 37 setting set VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 38 s s POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 39 y y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 40 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 41 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 42 s_{y s_{y NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 43 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 44 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 45 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 46 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 47 specific specific JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 48 value value NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 49 within within IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 50 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 51 particular particular JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 52 range range NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 53 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 54 values value NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 55 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 56 independent independent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 57 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 58 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 59 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 60 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 61 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 62 offering offer VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 63 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 64 opportunity opportunity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 65 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 66 X x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 67 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 68 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 69 extort extort VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 70 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 71 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 72 Y Y NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 73 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 74 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 75 vice vice RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 76 versa versa RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 77 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 164 78 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 1 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 2 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 3 turns turn VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 4 out out RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 5 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 6 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 7 X x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 8 tries try VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 9 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 10 set set VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 11 s s NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 12 x x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 13 { { -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 14 \displaystyle \displaystyle CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 15 s_{x s_{x NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 16 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 17 } } -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 18 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 19 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 20 particular particular JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 21 value value NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 22 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 24 range range NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 25 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 26 possibilities possibility NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 27 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 28 much much RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 29 smaller small JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 30 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 31 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 32 consisting consist VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 33 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 34 complete complete JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 35 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 36 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 37 complete complete JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 38 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 165 39 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 2 18 18 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 5 An an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 6 extension extension NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 9 IPD IPD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 10 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 11 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 12 evolutionary evolutionary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 13 stochastic stochastic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 14 IPD IPD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 16 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 17 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 18 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 19 relative relative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 20 abundance abundance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 21 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 22 particular particular JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 23 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 24 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 25 allowed allow VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 26 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 27 change change VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 28 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 29 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 30 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 31 successful successful JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 32 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 33 relatively relatively RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 34 increasing increase VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 166 35 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 2 process process NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 3 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 4 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 5 accomplished accomplish VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 6 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 7 having have VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 8 less less JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 9 successful successful JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 10 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 11 imitate imitate VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 13 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 14 successful successful JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 15 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 17 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 18 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 19 eliminating eliminate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 20 less less RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 21 successful successful JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 22 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 23 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 24 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 25 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 26 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 27 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 28 multiplying multiply VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 29 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 30 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 31 successful successful JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 32 ones one NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 167 33 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 2 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 3 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 4 shown show VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 5 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 6 unfair unfair JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 7 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 8 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 9 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 10 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 11 evolutionarily evolutionarily RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 12 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 168 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 2 key key JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 3 intuition intuition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 5 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 6 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 7 evolutionarily evolutionarily RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 8 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 9 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 10 must must MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 11 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 12 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 13 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 14 able able JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 15 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 16 invade invade VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 17 another another DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 18 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 19 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 20 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 21 extortionary extortionary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 22 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 23 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 24 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 25 do do VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 26 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 27 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 28 must must MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 29 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 30 perform perform VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 31 well well RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 32 against against IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 33 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 34 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 35 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 36 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 37 same same JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 38 type type NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 39 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 40 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 41 extortionary extortionary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 42 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 43 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 44 do do VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 45 poorly poorly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 46 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 47 because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 48 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 49 reduce reduce VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 50 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 51 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 52 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 53 surplus surplus NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 54 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 169 55 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 2 19 19 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 4 Theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 5 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 6 simulations simulation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 7 confirm confirm VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 8 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 9 beyond beyond IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 10 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 11 critical critical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 12 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 13 size size NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 15 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 16 extortion extortion NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 17 loses lose VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 18 out out RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 19 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 20 evolutionary evolutionary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 21 competition competition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 22 against against IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 23 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 24 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 25 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 26 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 27 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 28 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 29 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 30 result result NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 32 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 33 average average JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 34 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 35 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 36 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 37 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 38 increases increase NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 39 when when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 40 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 41 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 42 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 43 larger large JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 170 44 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 2 addition addition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 4 there there EX en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 5 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 6 some some DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 7 cases case NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 9 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 10 extortioners extortioner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 11 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 12 even even RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 13 catalyze catalyze VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 14 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 15 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 16 helping help VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 17 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 18 break break VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 19 out out IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 20 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 21 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 22 face face NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 23 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 24 off off NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 25 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 26 uniform uniform JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 27 defectors defector NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 28 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 29 win win VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 30 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 31 stay stay VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 32 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 33 lose lose VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 34 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 35 switch switch NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 36 agents agent NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 171 37 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 2 11 11 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 4 While while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 5 extortionary extortionary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 6 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 7 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 8 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 9 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 10 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 11 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 12 large large JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 13 populations population NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 15 another another DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 16 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 17 class class NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 18 called call VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 19 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 20 generous generous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 21 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 22 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 23 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 24 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 25 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 26 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 27 robust robust JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 172 28 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 2 fact fact NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 4 when when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 6 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 7 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 8 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 9 too too RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 10 small small JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 12 these these DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 13 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 14 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 15 supplant supplant VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 16 any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 17 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 18 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 19 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 20 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 21 even even RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 22 perform perform VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 23 well well RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 24 against against IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 25 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 26 broad broad JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 27 array array NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 28 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 29 generic generic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 30 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 31 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 32 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 33 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 34 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 35 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 36 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 37 including include VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 38 win win NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 39 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 40 stay stay VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 41 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 42 lose lose VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 43 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 44 switch switch VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 173 45 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 2 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 3 proven prove VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 4 specifically specifically RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 5 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 7 donation donation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 8 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 9 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 10 Alexander Alexander NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 11 Stewart Stewart NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 12 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 13 Joshua Joshua NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 14 Plotkin Plotkin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 15 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 16 2013 2013 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 174 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 2 20 20 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 4 Generous generous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 5 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 6 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 7 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 8 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 9 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 10 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 11 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 13 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 14 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 15 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 16 face face NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 17 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 18 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 21 generous generous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 22 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 23 loses lose VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 24 more more JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 25 utility utility NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 26 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 27 its -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 28 rival rival NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 175 29 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 1 Generous generous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 2 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 3 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 5 intersection intersection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 7 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 8 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 9 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 10 so so RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 11 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 12 called call VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 13 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 14 good good JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 15 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 16 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 18 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 19 were be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 20 defined define VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 21 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 22 Akin Akin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 23 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 24 2013)[21 2013)[21 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 25 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 26 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 27 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 28 those those DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 29 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 30 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 31 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 32 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 33 responds respond VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 34 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 35 past past VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 36 mutual mutual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 37 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 38 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 39 future future JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 40 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 41 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 42 splits split NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 43 expected expect VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 44 payoffs payoff NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 45 equally equally RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 46 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 47 he -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 48 receives receive VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 49 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 50 least least JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 51 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 52 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 53 expected expect VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 54 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 176 55 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 1 Among among IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 2 good good JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 3 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 6 generous generous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 7 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 8 ZD ZD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 9 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 10 subset subset NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 11 performs perform NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 12 well well RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 13 when when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 15 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 16 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 17 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 18 too too RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 19 small small JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 177 20 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 3 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 5 very very RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 6 small small JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 8 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 9 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 10 tend tend VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 11 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 12 dominate dominate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 178 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 2 20 20 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 4 Continuous continuous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 5 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 6 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 7 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 8 dilemma[edit dilemma[edit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 9 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 10 Most Most JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 11 work work NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 12 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 14 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 15 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 16 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 17 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 18 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 19 focused focus VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 20 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 22 discrete discrete JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 23 case case NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 24 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 25 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 26 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 27 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 28 either either CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 29 cooperate cooperate VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 30 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 31 defect defect JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 32 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 33 because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 34 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 35 model model NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 36 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 37 relatively relatively RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 38 simple simple JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 39 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 40 analyze analyze VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 179 41 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 1 However however RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 3 some some DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 4 researchers researcher NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 5 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 6 looked look VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 7 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 8 models model NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 9 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 11 continuous continuous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 12 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 13 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 14 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 15 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 17 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 18 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 19 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 20 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 21 able able JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 22 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 23 make make VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 24 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 25 variable variable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 26 contribution contribution NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 27 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 28 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 29 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 30 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 180 31 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 1 Le Le NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 2 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 3 Boyd[22 Boyd[22 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 4 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 5 found find VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 6 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 7 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 8 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 9 situations situation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 11 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 12 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 13 much much RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 14 harder hard JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 15 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 16 evolve evolve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 17 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 18 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 20 discrete discrete JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 21 iterated iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 22 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 23 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 24 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 181 25 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 2 basic basic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 3 intuition intuition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 4 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 5 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 6 result result NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 7 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 8 straightforward straightforward JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 9 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 10 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 11 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 12 continuous continuous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 13 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 14 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 15 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 17 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 18 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 19 population population NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 20 starts start VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 21 off off RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 22 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 23 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 24 non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 25 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 26 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 27 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 28 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 29 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 30 who who WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 31 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 32 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 33 marginally marginally RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 34 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 35 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 36 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 37 non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 38 - - NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 39 cooperators cooperator NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 40 get get VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 41 little little JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 42 benefit benefit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 43 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 44 assorting assort VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 45 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 46 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 47 another another DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 182 48 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 1 By by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 2 contrast contrast NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 4 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 5 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 6 discrete discrete JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 7 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 8 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 9 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 11 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 12 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 13 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 14 cooperators cooperator NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 15 get get VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 16 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 17 big big JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 18 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 19 boost boost NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 20 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 21 assorting assort VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 22 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 23 one one NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 24 another another DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 25 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 26 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 27 non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 28 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 29 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 30 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 32 relative relative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 33 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 34 non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 35 - - NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 36 cooperators cooperator NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 183 37 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 1 Since since IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 2 nature nature NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 3 arguably arguably RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 4 offers offer VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 5 more more JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 6 opportunities opportunity NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 7 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 8 variable variable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 9 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 10 rather rather RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 11 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 12 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 13 strict strict JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 14 dichotomy dichotomy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 15 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 16 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 17 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 18 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 21 continuous continuous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 22 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 23 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 24 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 25 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 26 help help VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 27 explain explain VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 28 why why WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 29 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 30 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 31 life life NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 32 examples example NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 33 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 34 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 35 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 36 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 37 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 38 like like JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 39 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 40 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 41 extremely extremely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 42 rare rare JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 43 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 44 nature nature NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 45 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 46 ex ex UH en-wikipedia-org-1554 184 47 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 1 Hammerstein[23 hammerstein[23 LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 2 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 3 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 4 even even RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 5 though though IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 6 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 7 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 8 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 9 seems seem VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 10 robust robust JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 11 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 12 theoretical theoretical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 13 models model NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 185 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 1 Emergence emergence NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 3 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 4 strategies[edit strategies[edit , en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 5 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 6 Players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 7 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 8 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 9 seem seem VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 10 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 11 coordinate coordinate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 12 mutual mutual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 13 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 15 thus thus RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 16 often often RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 17 get get VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 18 locked lock VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 19 into into IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 21 inferior inferior JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 22 yet yet CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 23 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 24 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 25 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 26 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 186 27 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 2 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 3 way way NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 5 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 6 rounds round NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 7 facilitate facilitate VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 9 evolution evolution NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 11 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 12 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 187 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 2 24 24 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 4 Iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 5 rounds round NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 6 often often RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 7 produce produce VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 8 novel novel NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 9 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 11 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 12 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 13 implications implication NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 14 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 15 complex complex JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 16 social social JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 17 interaction interaction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 188 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 189 1 One one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 189 2 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 189 3 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 189 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 189 5 win win NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 189 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 189 7 stay stay VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 189 8 lose lose JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 189 9 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 189 10 shift shift NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 189 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 2 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 3 outperforms outperform VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 4 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 5 simple simple JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 6 Tit tit JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 7 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 8 For for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 9 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 10 Tat Tat NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 11 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 12   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 13 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 14 that that RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 15 is is RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 17 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 18 you -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 19 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 20 get get VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 21 away away RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 22 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 23 cheating cheating NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 24 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 25 repeat repeat VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 26 that that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 27 behavior behavior NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 28 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 29 however however RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 30 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 31 you -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 32 get get VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 33 caught catch VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 34 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 35 switch switch NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 190 36 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 2 25 25 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 4 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 5 only only JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 6 problem problem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 8 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 9 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 10 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 11 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 12 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 13 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 14 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 15 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 16 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 17 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 18 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 19 vulnerable vulnerable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 20 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 21 signal signal NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 22 error error NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 191 23 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 2 problem problem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 3 arises arise VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 4 when when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 5 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 6 individual individual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 7 cheats cheat VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 9 retaliation retaliation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 10 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 12 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 13 interprets interpret VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 14 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 15 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 16 cheating cheat VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 192 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 1 As as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 3 result result NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 5 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 8 second second JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 9 individual individual NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 10 now now RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 11 cheats cheat VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 12 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 13 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 14 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 15 starts start VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 16 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 17 see see VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 18 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 19 saw saw NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 20 pattern pattern NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 21 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 22 cheating cheat VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 23 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 24 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 25 chain chain NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 26 reaction reaction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 193 27 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 1 Real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 2 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 3 life life NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 4 examples[edit examples[edit , en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 5 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 6 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 7 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 8 setting setting NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 9 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 10 seem seem VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 11 contrived contrive VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 13 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 14 there there EX en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 15 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 16 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 17 fact fact NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 18 many many JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 19 examples example NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 20 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 21 human human JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 22 interaction interaction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 23 as as RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 24 well well RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 25 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 26 interactions interaction NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 27 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 28 nature nature NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 29 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 30 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 31 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 32 same same JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 33 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 34 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 194 35 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 2 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 3 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 4 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 5 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 6 therefore therefore RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 8 interest interest NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 9 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 11 social social JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 12 sciences science NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 13 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 14 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 15 economics economics NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 17 politics politic NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 19 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 20 sociology sociology NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 21 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 22 as as RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 23 well well RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 24 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 25 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 26 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 27 biological biological JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 28 sciences science NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 29 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 30 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 31 ethology ethology NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 32 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 33 evolutionary evolutionary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 34 biology biology NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 195 35 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 1 Many many JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 2 natural natural JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 3 processes process NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 4 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 5 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 6 abstracted abstract VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 7 into into IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 8 models model NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 9 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 10 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 11 living live VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 12 beings being NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 13 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 14 engaged engage VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 15 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 16 endless endless JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 17 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 18 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 19 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 20 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 21 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 196 22 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 2 wide wide JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 3 applicability applicability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 6 PD PD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 7 gives give VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 9 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 10 its -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 11 substantial substantial JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 12 importance importance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 197 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 1 Environmental environmental JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 2 studies[edit studies[edit LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 4 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 5 environmental environmental JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 6 studies study NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 9 PD PD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 10 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 11 evident evident JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 12 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 13 crises crisis NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 14 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 15 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 16 global global JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 17 climate climate NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 18 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 19 change change NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 198 20 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 2 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 3 argued argue VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 4 all all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 5 countries country NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 6 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 7 benefit benefit VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 8 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 9 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 10 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 11 climate climate NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 13 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 14 any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 15 single single JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 16 country country NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 17 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 18 often often RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 19 hesitant hesitant JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 20 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 21 curb curb VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 22 CO CO NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 23 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 24 emissions emission NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 199 25 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 2 immediate immediate JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 3 benefit benefit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 4 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 5 any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 6 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 7 country country NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 8 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 9 maintaining maintain VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 10 current current JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 11 behavior behavior NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 12 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 13 wrongly wrongly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 14 perceived perceive VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 15 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 16 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 17 greater great JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 18 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 20 purported purport VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 21 eventual eventual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 22 benefit benefit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 23 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 24 that that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 25 country country NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 26 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 27 all all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 28 countries country NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 29 ' ' POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 30 behavior behavior NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 31 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 32 changed change VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 33 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 34 therefore therefore RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 35 explaining explain VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 36 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 37 impasse impasse NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 38 concerning concern VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 39 climate climate NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 40 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 41 change change NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 42 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 43 2007 2007 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 200 44 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 2 26 26 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 4 An an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 5 important important JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 6 difference difference NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 7 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 8 climate climate NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 9 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 10 change change NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 11 politics politic NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 12 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 14 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 15 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 16 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 17 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 18 uncertainty uncertainty NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 19 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 21 extent extent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 22 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 23 pace pace NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 24 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 25 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 26 pollution pollution NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 27 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 28 change change VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 29 climate climate NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 30 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 31 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 32 known know VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 201 33 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 2 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 3 faced face VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 4 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 5 government government NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 6 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 7 therefore therefore RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 8 different different JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 9 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 11 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 12 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 13 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 14 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 15 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 16 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 17 payoffs payoff NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 18 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 19 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 20 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 21 unknown unknown JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 202 22 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 2 difference difference NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 3 suggests suggest VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 4 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 5 states state NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 6 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 7 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 8 much much RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 9 less less JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 10 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 11 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 12 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 13 real real RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 14 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 15 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 16 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 17 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 19 so so IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 20 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 22 probability probability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 23 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 24 avoiding avoid VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 25 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 26 possible possible JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 27 climate climate NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 28 catastrophe catastrophe NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 29 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 30 much much RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 31 smaller small JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 32 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 33 that that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 34 suggested suggest VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 35 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 36 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 37 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 38 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 39 theoretical theoretical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 40 analysis analysis NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 41 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 42 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 43 situation situation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 44 using use VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 45 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 46 real real RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 47 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 48 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 49 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 50 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 203 51 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 2 27 27 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 4 Osang Osang NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 5 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 6 Nandy Nandy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 7 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 8 2003 2003 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 9 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 10 provide provide VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 11 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 12 theoretical theoretical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 13 explanation explanation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 14 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 15 proofs proofs NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 16 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 17 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 18 regulation regulation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 19 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 20 driven drive VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 21 win win NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 22 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 23 win win NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 24 situation situation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 25 along along IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 26 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 27 lines line NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 28 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 29 Michael Michael NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 30 Porter Porter NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 31 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 32 hypothesis hypothesis NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 33 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 34 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 35 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 36 government government NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 37 regulation regulation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 38 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 39 competing compete VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 40 firms firm NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 41 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 42 substantial substantial JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 204 43 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 2 28 28 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 4 Animals[edit animals[edit CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 5 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 6 Cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 7 behavior behavior NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 8 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 9 many many JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 10 animals animal NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 11 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 12 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 13 understood understand VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 14 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 15 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 16 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 17 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 18 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 19 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 20 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 21 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 205 22 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 1 Often often RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 2 animals animal NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 3 engage engage VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 4 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 5 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 6 term term NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 7 partnerships partnership NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 9 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 10 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 11 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 12 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 13 specifically specifically RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 14 modeled model VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 15 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 16 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 17 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 18 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 19 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 206 20 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 1 For for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 2 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 4 guppies guppy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 5 inspect inspect VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 6 predators predator NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 7 cooperatively cooperatively RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 9 groups group NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 11 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 12 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 13 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 14 thought think VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 15 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 16 punish punish VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 17 non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 18 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 19 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 20 inspectors inspector NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 207 21 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 1 Vampire Vampire NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 2 bats bat NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 3 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 4 social social JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 5 animals animal NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 6 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 7 engage engage VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 9 reciprocal reciprocal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 10 food food NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 11 exchange exchange NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 208 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 1 Applying apply VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 3 payoffs payoff NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 4 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 6 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 7 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 8 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 9 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 10 help help VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 11 explain explain VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 12 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 13 behavior:[29 behavior:[29 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 14 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 15 C C NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 16 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 17 C C NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 18 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 19 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 20 Reward reward NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 21 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 22 I -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 23 get get VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 24 blood blood NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 25 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 26 my -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 27 unlucky unlucky JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 28 nights night NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 29 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 30 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 31 saves save VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 32 me -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 33 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 34 starving starve VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 209 35 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 1 I -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 2 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 3 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 4 give give VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 5 blood blood NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 6 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 7 my -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 8 lucky lucky JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 9 nights night NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 11 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 12 does do VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 13 n't not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 14 cost cost VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 15 me -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 16 too too RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 17 much much RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 210 19 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 1 D D NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 3 C c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 4 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 5 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 6 Temptation temptation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 7 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 8 You -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 9 save save VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 10 my -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 11 life life NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 12 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 13 my -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 14 poor poor JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 15 night night NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 211 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 1 But but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 2 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 3 I -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 4 get get VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 6 added add VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 7 benefit benefit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 8 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 9 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 10 having have VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 11 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 12 pay pay VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 14 slight slight JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 15 cost cost NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 16 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 17 feeding feed VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 18 you -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 19 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 20 my -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 21 good good JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 22 night night NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 23 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 212 24 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 1 C C NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 3 D D NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 4 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 5 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 6 Sucker Sucker NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 7 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 8 Payoff Payoff NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 9 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 10 I -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 11 pay pay VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 13 cost cost NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 15 saving save VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 16 your -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 17 life life NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 18 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 19 my -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 20 good good JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 21 night night NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 213 22 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 1 But but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 2 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 3 my -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 4 bad bad JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 5 night night NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 6 you -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 7 do do VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 8 n't not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 9 feed feed VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 10 me -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 11 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 12 I -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 13 run run VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 14 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 15 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 16 risk risk NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 17 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 18 starving starve VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 19 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 20 death death NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 21 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 214 22 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 1 D D NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 3 D d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 4 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 5 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 6 Punishment punishment NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 7 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 8 I -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 9 do do VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 10 n't not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 11 have have VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 12 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 13 pay pay VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 15 slight slight JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 16 costs cost NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 17 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 18 feeding feed VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 19 you -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 20 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 21 my -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 22 good good JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 23 nights night NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 215 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 1 But but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 2 I -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 3 run run VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 4 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 5 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 6 risk risk NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 8 starving starve VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 9 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 10 my -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 11 poor poor JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 12 nights night NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 216 14 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 1 Psychology[edit psychology[edit LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 2 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 3 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 4 addiction addiction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 5 research research NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 6 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 7 behavioral behavioral JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 8 economics economic NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 10 George George NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 11 Ainslie Ainslie NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 12 points point NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 13 out[30 out[30 JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 14 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 15 that that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 16 addiction addiction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 17 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 18 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 19 cast cast VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 20 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 21 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 22 intertemporal intertemporal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 23 PD pd NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 24 problem problem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 25 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 26 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 27 present present JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 28 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 29 future future JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 30 selves self NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 31 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 32 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 33 addict addict NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 217 34 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 2 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 3 case case NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 5 defecting defecting NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 6 means mean NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 7 relapsing relapse VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 9 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 10 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 11 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 12 easy easy JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 13 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 14 see see VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 15 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 16 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 17 defecting defect VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 18 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 19 today today NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 20 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 21 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 22 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 23 future future NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 24 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 25 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 26 far far RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 27 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 28 best good JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 29 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 218 30 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 2 case case NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 3 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 4 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 5 abstains abstain VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 6 today today NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 7 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 8 relapses relapse VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 9 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 11 future future NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 12 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 14 worst bad JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 15 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 16   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 17 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 18 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 19 some some DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 20 sense sense NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 22 discipline discipline NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 23 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 24 self self NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 25 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 26 sacrifice sacrifice NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 27 involved involve VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 28 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 29 abstaining abstain VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 30 today today NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 31 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 32 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 33 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 34 wasted waste VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 35 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 36 because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 37 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 38 future future JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 39 relapse relapse NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 40 means mean VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 41 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 42 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 43 addict addict NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 44 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 45 right right RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 46 back back RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 47 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 48 he -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 49 started start VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 50 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 51 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 52 have have VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 53 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 54 start start VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 55 over over RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 56 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 57 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 58 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 59 quite quite RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 60 demoralizing demoralizing JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 61 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 62 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 63 makes make VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 64 starting start VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 65 over over IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 66 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 67 difficult difficult JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 68 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 219 69 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 1 Relapsing relapse VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 2 today today NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 3 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 4 tomorrow tomorrow NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 5 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 6 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 7 slightly slightly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 8 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 9 better well JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 10 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 11 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 13 because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 14 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 15 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 16 addict addict NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 17 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 18 still still RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 19 addicted addict VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 20 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 21 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 22 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 23 n't not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 24 put put VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 25 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 26 effort effort NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 27 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 28 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 29 trying try VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 30 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 31 stop stop VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 220 32 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 2 final final JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 3 case case NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 5 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 6 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 7 engages engage VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 10 addictive addictive JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 11 behavior behavior NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 12 today today NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 13 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 14 abstaining abstain VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 15 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 16 tomorrow tomorrow NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 17 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 18 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 19 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 20 familiar familiar JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 21 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 22 anyone anyone NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 23 who who WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 24 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 25 struggled struggle VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 26 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 27 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 28 addiction addiction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 221 29 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 2 problem problem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 3 here here RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 5 that that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 6 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 7 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 9 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 10 PDs pd NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 11 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 12 there there EX en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 13 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 14 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 15 obvious obvious JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 16 benefit benefit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 17 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 18 defecting defect VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 19 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 20 today today NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 21 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 22 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 23 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 24 tomorrow tomorrow NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 25 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 26 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 27 face face VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 28 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 29 same same JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 30 PD PD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 32 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 33 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 34 same same JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 35 obvious obvious JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 36 benefit benefit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 37 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 38 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 39 present present JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 40 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 41 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 42 ultimately ultimately RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 43 leading lead VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 44 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 45 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 46 endless endless JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 47 string string NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 48 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 49 defections defection NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 222 50 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 1 John John NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 2 Gottman Gottman NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 3 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 4 his -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 5 research research NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 6 described describe VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 7 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 8 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 10 science science NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 11 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 12 trust trust NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 13 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 14 defines define VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 15 good good JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 16 relationships relationship NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 17 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 18 those those DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 19 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 20 partners partner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 21 know know VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 22 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 23 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 24 enter enter VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 25 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 26 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 27 D d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 28 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 29 D d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 30 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 31 cell cell NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 32 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 33 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 34 least least JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 35 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 36 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 37 get get VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 38 dynamically dynamically RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 39 stuck stick VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 40 there there RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 41 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 42 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 43 loop loop NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 223 44 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 1 Economics[edit economics[edit LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 2 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 3 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 4 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 5 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 6 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 7 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 8 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 9 called call VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 11 E. E. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 12 coli coli NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 13 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 14 social social JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 15 psychology psychology NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 17 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 18 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 19 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 20 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 21 used use VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 22 widely widely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 23 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 24 research research VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 25 various various JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 26 topics topic NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 27 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 28 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 29 oligopolistic oligopolistic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 30 competition competition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 31 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 32 collective collective JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 33 action action NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 34 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 35 produce produce VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 36 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 37 collective collective JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 38 good good NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 224 39 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 2 31 31 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 4 Advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 5 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 6 sometimes sometimes RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 7 cited cite VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 8 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 9 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 10 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 11 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 12 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 13 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 15 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 16 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 17 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 225 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 1 When when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 2 cigarette cigarette NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 3 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 4 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 5 legal legal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 6 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 8 United United NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 9 States States NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 11 competing compete VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 12 cigarette cigarette NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 13 manufacturers manufacturer NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 14 had have VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 15 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 16 decide decide VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 17 how how WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 18 much much JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 19 money money NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 20 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 21 spend spend VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 22 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 23 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 226 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 2 effectiveness effectiveness NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 4 Firm firm JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 5 A A NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 6 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 7 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 8 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 9 partially partially RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 10 determined determine VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 11 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 13 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 14 conducted conduct VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 15 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 16 Firm Firm NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 227 17 B. B. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 1 Likewise likewise RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 4 profit profit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 5 derived derive VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 6 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 7 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 8 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 9 Firm Firm NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 10 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 11 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 12 affected affect VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 13 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 15 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 16 conducted conduct VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 17 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 18 Firm firm NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 228 19 A. a. NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 2 both both CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 3 Firm firm VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 4 A a NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 5 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 6 Firm Firm NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 7 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 8 chose choose VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 9 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 10 advertise advertise VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 11 during during IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 12 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 13 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 14 period period NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 16 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 17 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 18 advertisement advertisement NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 19 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 20 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 21 firm firm NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 22 negates negate VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 24 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 25 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 26 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 27 receipts receipt NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 28 remain remain VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 29 constant constant JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 30 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 31 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 32 expenses expense NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 33 increase increase VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 34 due due IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 35 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 36 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 37 cost cost NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 38 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 39 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 229 40 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 230 1 Both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 230 2 firms firm NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 230 3 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 230 4 benefit benefit VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 230 5 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 230 6 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 230 7 reduction reduction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 230 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 230 9 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 230 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 1 However however RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 3 should should MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 4 Firm firm VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 5 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 6 choose choose VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 7 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 8 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 9 advertise advertise VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 11 Firm firm VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 12 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 13 could could MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 14 benefit benefit VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 15 greatly greatly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 16 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 17 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 231 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 4 optimal optimal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 5 amount amount NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 7 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 8 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 9 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 10 firm firm NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 11 depends depend VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 12 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 13 how how WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 14 much much JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 15 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 16 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 17 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 18 undertakes undertake NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 232 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 1 As as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 3 best good JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 4 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 5 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 6 dependent dependent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 7 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 8 what what WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 10 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 11 firm firm NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 12 chooses choose NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 13 there there EX en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 14 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 15 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 16 dominant dominant JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 17 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 19 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 20 makes make VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 21 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 22 slightly slightly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 23 different different JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 24 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 25 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 26 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 27 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 28 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 233 29 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 2 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 3 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 4 similar similar JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 6 though though RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 9 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 10 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 11 firms firm NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 12 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 13 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 14 better well JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 15 off off RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 16 were be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 17 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 18 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 19 advertise advertise VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 20 less less JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 21 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 22 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 24 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 234 25 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 235 1 Sometimes sometimes RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 235 2 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 235 3 behaviors behavior NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 235 4 do do VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 235 5 emerge emerge VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 235 6 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 235 7 business business NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 235 8 situations situation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 235 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 1 For for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 2 instance instance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 4 cigarette cigarette NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 5 manufacturers manufacturer NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 6 endorsed endorse VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 8 making making NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 9 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 10 laws law NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 11 banning ban VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 12 cigarette cigarette NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 13 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 15 understanding understand VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 16 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 17 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 18 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 19 reduce reduce VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 20 costs cost NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 21 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 22 increase increase VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 23 profits profit NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 24 across across IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 25 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 26 industry industry NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 236 27 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 2 citation citation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 3 needed][b needed][b NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 4 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 5 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 6 analysis analysis NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 7 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 8 likely likely JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 9 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 10 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 11 pertinent pertinent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 12 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 13 many many JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 14 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 15 business business NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 16 situations situation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 17 involving involve VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 18 advertising advertising NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 237 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 2 citation citation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 3 needed need VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 4 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 5 Without without IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 6 enforceable enforceable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 7 agreements agreement NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 9 members member NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 11 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 12 cartel cartel NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 13 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 14 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 15 involved involve VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 16 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 17 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 18 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 19 multi multi JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 20 - - NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 21 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 22 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 23 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 24 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 25 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 238 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 2 32 32 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 4 ' ' `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 5 Cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 6 ' ' '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 7 typically typically RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 8 means mean VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 9 keeping keep VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 10 prices price NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 11 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 12 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 13 pre pre JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 14 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 15 agreed agree VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 16 minimum minimum JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 17 level level NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 239 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 1 ' ' `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 2 Defecting defect VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 3 ' ' '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 4 means mean NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 5 selling sell VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 6 under under IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 7 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 8 minimum minimum JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 9 level level NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 11 instantly instantly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 12 taking take VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 13 business business NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 14 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 15 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 16 profits profit NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 17 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 18 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 19 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 20 cartel cartel NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 21 members member NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 240 22 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 1 Anti anti JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 2 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 3 trust trust NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 4 authorities authority NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 5 want want VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 6 potential potential JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 7 cartel cartel NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 8 members member NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 9 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 10 mutually mutually RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 11 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 13 ensuring ensure VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 15 lowest low JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 16 possible possible JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 17 prices price NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 18 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 19 consumers consumer NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 241 20 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 1 Sport[edit sport[edit LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 2 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 3 Doping dope VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 4 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 5 sport sport NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 6 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 7 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 8 cited cite VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 9 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 10 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 11 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 13 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 14 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 15 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 16 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 242 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 2 33 33 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 4 Two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 5 competing compete VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 6 athletes athlete NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 7 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 9 option option NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 10 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 11 use use VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 12 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 13 illegal illegal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 14 and/or and/or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 15 dangerous dangerous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 16 drug drug NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 17 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 18 boost boost VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 19 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 20 performance performance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 243 21 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 2 neither neither DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 3 athlete athlete NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 4 takes take VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 6 drug drug NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 8 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 9 neither neither CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 10 gains gain VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 11 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 12 advantage advantage NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 244 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 2 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 3 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 4 does do VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 6 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 7 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 8 athlete athlete NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 9 gains gain VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 10 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 11 significant significant JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 12 advantage advantage NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 13 over over IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 14 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 15 competitor competitor NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 17 reduced reduce VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 18 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 20 legal legal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 21 and/or and/or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 22 medical medical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 23 dangers danger NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 24 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 25 having have VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 26 taken take VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 27 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 28 drug drug NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 245 29 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 2 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 3 athletes athlete NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 4 take take VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 6 drug drug NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 8 however however RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 11 benefits benefit NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 12 cancel cancel VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 13 out out RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 14 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 15 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 16 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 17 dangers danger NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 18 remain remain VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 20 putting put VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 21 them -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 22 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 23 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 24 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 25 worse bad JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 26 position position NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 27 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 28 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 29 neither neither DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 30 had have VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 31 used use VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 32 doping dope VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 246 33 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 2 33 33 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 4 International international JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 5 politics[edit politics[edit , en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 6 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 7 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 8 international international JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 9 political political JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 10 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 13 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 14 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 15 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 16 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 17 often often RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 18 used use VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 19 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 20 demonstrate demonstrate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 22 coherence coherence NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 23 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 24 strategic strategic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 25 realism realism NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 26 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 27 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 28 holds hold VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 29 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 30 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 31 international international JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 32 relations relation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 33 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 34 all all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 35 states state NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 36 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 37 regardless regardless RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 38 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 39 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 40 internal internal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 41 policies policy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 42 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 43 professed profess VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 44 ideology ideology NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 45 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 46 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 47 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 48 act act VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 49 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 50 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 51 rational rational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 52 self self NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 53 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 54 interest interest NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 55 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 56 international international JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 57 anarchy anarchy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 247 58 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 1 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 2 classic classic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 3 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 5 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 6 arms arm NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 7 race race NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 8 like like IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 10 Cold Cold NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 11 War War NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 12 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 13 similar similar JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 14 conflicts conflict NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 248 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 2 34 34 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 4 During during IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 6 Cold Cold NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 7 War War NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 9 opposing oppose VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 10 alliances alliance NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 11 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 12 NATO NATO NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 13 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 15 Warsaw Warsaw NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 16 Pact Pact NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 17 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 18 had have VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 20 choice choice NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 21 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 22 arm arm VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 23 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 24 disarm disarm VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 249 25 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 1 From from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 2 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 3 side side NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 4 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 5 point point NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 7 view view NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 9 disarming disarm VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 10 whilst whilst IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 11 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 12 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 13 continued continue VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 14 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 15 arm arm VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 16 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 17 have have VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 18 led lead VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 19 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 20 military military JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 21 inferiority inferiority NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 22 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 23 possible possible JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 24 annihilation annihilation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 250 25 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 1 Conversely conversely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 3 arming arm VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 4 whilst whilst IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 5 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 6 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 7 disarmed disarm VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 8 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 9 have have VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 10 led lead VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 11 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 12 superiority superiority NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 251 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 2 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 3 sides side NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 4 chose choose VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 5 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 6 arm arm VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 8 neither neither CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 9 could could MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 10 afford afford VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 11 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 12 attack attack VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 14 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 16 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 17 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 18 incurred incur VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 20 high high JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 21 cost cost NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 22 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 23 developing develop VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 24 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 25 maintaining maintain VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 26 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 27 nuclear nuclear JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 28 arsenal arsenal NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 252 29 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 2 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 3 sides side NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 4 chose choose VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 5 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 6 disarm disarm VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 8 war war NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 9 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 10 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 11 avoided avoid VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 12 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 13 there there EX en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 14 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 15 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 16 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 17 costs cost NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 253 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 1 Although although IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 3 ' ' `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 4 best good JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 5 ' ' '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 6 overall overall JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 7 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 8 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 9 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 10 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 11 sides side NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 12 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 13 disarm disarm VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 15 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 16 rational rational JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 17 course course NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 18 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 19 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 20 sides side NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 21 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 22 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 23 arm arm VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 24 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 25 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 26 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 27 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 28 indeed indeed RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 29 what what WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 30 happened happen VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 254 31 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 1 Both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 2 sides side NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 3 poured pour VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 4 enormous enormous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 5 resources resource NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 6 into into IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 7 military military JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 8 research research NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 9 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 10 armament armament NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 11 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 12 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 13 war war NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 15 attrition attrition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 16 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 17 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 18 next next JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 19 thirty thirty CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 20 years year NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 21 until until IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 22 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 23 Soviet Soviet NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 24 Union Union NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 25 could could MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 26 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 27 withstand withstand VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 28 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 29 economic economic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 30 cost cost NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 255 31 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 2 35 35 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 4 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 5 same same JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 6 logic logic NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 7 could could MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 8 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 9 applied apply VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 10 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 11 any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 12 similar similar JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 13 scenario scenario NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 15 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 16 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 17 economic economic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 18 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 19 technological technological JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 20 competition competition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 21 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 22 sovereign sovereign JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 23 states state NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 256 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 1 Multiplayer Multiplayer NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 2 dilemmas[edit dilemmas[edit NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 4 Many many JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 5 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 7 life life NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 8 dilemmas dilemma NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 9 involve involve VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 10 multiple multiple JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 11 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 257 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 2 36 36 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 4 Although although IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 5 metaphorical metaphorical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 7 Hardin Hardin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 8 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 9 tragedy tragedy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 12 commons common NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 13 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 14 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 15 viewed view VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 16 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 17 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 18 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 19 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 20 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 21 multi multi JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 22 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 23 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 24 generalization generalization NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 25 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 26 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 27 PD PD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 28 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 29 Each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 30 villager villager NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 31 makes make VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 32 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 33 choice choice NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 34 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 35 personal personal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 36 gain gain NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 37 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 38 restraint restraint NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 258 39 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 2 collective collective JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 3 reward reward NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 4 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 5 unanimous unanimous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 6 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 7 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 8 even even RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 9 frequent frequent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 10 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 11 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 12 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 13 very very RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 14 low low JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 15 payoffs payoff NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 16 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 17 representing represent VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 18 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 19 destruction destruction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 20 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 22 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 23 commons common NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 24 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 25 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 259 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 1 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 2 commons common NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 3 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 4 most most JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 5 people people NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 6 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 7 relate relate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 8 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 9 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 10 washing wash VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 12 dishes dish NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 13 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 14 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 15 shared shared JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 16 house house NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 260 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 1 By by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 2 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 3 washing wash VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 4 dishes dish NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 5 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 6 individual individual NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 7 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 8 gain gain VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 9 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 10 saving save VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 11 his -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 12 time time NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 13 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 14 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 15 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 16 that that DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 17 behavior behavior NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 18 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 19 adopted adopt VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 20 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 21 every every DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 22 resident resident NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 24 collective collective JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 25 cost cost NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 26 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 27 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 28 clean clean JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 29 plates plate NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 30 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 31 anyone anyone NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 261 32 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 2 commons common NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 3 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 4 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 5 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 6 exploited exploit VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 7 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 8 William William NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 9 Poundstone Poundstone NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 11 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 12 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 13 book book NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 14 about about IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 15 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 16 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 17 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 18 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 20 describes describe VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 21 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 22 situation situation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 23 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 24 New New NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 25 Zealand Zealand NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 26 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 27 newspaper newspaper NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 28 boxes box NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 29 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 30 left leave VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 31 unlocked unlocked JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 262 32 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 2 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 3 possible possible JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 4 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 5 people people NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 6 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 7 take take VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 8 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 9 paper paper NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 10 without without IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 11 paying pay VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 12 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 13 defecting defecting NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 14 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 15 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 16 very very RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 17 few few JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 18 do do VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 20 feeling feel VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 21 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 22 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 23 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 24 do do VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 25 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 26 pay pay VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 27 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 28 neither neither CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 29 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 30 others other NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 32 destroying destroy VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 33 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 34 system system NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 263 35 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 2 37 37 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 4 Subsequent subsequent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 5 research research NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 6 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 7 Elinor Elinor NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 8 Ostrom Ostrom NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 10 winner winner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 11 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 13 2009 2009 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 14 Nobel Nobel NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 15 Memorial Memorial NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 16 Prize Prize NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 17 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 18 Economic Economic NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 19 Sciences Sciences NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 20 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 21 hypothesized hypothesize VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 22 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 24 tragedy tragedy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 25 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 26 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 27 commons common NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 28 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 29 oversimplified oversimplify VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 30 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 31 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 32 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 33 negative negative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 34 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 35 influenced influence VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 36 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 37 outside outside JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 38 influences influence NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 264 39 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 1 Without without IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 2 complicating complicate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 3 pressures pressure NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 5 groups group NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 6 communicate communicate VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 7 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 8 manage manage VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 10 commons common NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 11 among among IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 12 themselves -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 13 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 14 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 15 mutual mutual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 16 benefit benefit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 18 enforcing enforce VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 19 social social JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 20 norms norm NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 21 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 22 preserve preserve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 24 resource resource NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 25 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 26 achieve achieve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 27 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 28 maximum maximum NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 29 good good NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 30 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 31 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 32 group group NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 33 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 34 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 35 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 36 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 37 effecting effect VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 38 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 39 best good JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 40 case case NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 41 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 42 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 43 PD PD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 265 44 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 2 38][39 38][39 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 4 Related Related NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 5 games[edit games[edit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 6 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 7 Closed closed JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 8 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 9 bag bag NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 10 exchange[edit exchange[edit NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 11 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 12 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 13 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 14 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 15 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 16 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 17 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 18 briefcase briefcase NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 19 exchange exchange NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 20 Douglas Douglas NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 21 Hofstadter[40 Hofstadter[40 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 22 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 23 once once RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 24 suggested suggest VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 25 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 26 people people NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 27 often often RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 28 find find VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 29 problems problem NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 30 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 31 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 32 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 33 PD PD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 34 problem problem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 35 easier easy JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 36 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 37 understand understand VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 38 when when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 39 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 40 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 41 illustrated illustrate VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 42 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 43 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 44 form form NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 45 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 46 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 47 simple simple JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 48 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 49 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 50 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 51 trade trade NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 52 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 53 off off NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 266 54 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 1 One one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 3 several several JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 4 examples example NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 5 he -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 6 used use VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 7 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 8 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 9 closed closed JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 10 bag bag NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 11 exchange exchange NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 12 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 13 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 14 Two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 15 people people NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 16 meet meet VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 17 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 18 exchange exchange NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 19 closed closed JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 20 bags bag NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 21 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 22 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 24 understanding understanding NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 25 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 26 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 27 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 28 them -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 29 contains contain VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 30 money money NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 32 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 33 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 34 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 35 contains contain VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 36 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 37 purchase purchase NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 267 38 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 1 Either either DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 2 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 3 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 4 choose choose VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 5 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 6 honor honor VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 8 deal deal NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 9 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 10 putting put VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 11 into into IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 12 his -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 13 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 14 her -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 15 bag bag NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 16 what what WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 17 he -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 18 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 19 she -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 20 agreed agree VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 21 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 22 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 23 he -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 24 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 25 she -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 26 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 27 defect defect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 28 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 29 handing hand VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 30 over over RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 31 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 32 empty empty JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 33 bag bag NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 268 34 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 269 1 Defection Defection NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 269 2 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 269 3 gives give VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 269 4 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 269 5 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 269 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 269 7 theoretically theoretically RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 269 8 preferable preferable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 269 9 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 269 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 270 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 270 2 41 41 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 270 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 270 4 Friend friend NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 270 5 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 270 6 Foe Foe NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 270 7 ? ? . en-wikipedia-org-1554 271 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 271 2 edit edit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 271 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 271 4 Friend friend NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 271 5 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 271 6 Foe Foe NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 271 7 ? ? . en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 1 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 3 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 4 show show NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 5 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 6 aired air VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 7 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 8 2002 2002 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 9 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 10 2003 2003 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 11 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 13 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 14 Show Show NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 15 Network Network NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 16 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 17 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 18 US US NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 272 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 2 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 3 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 4 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 5 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 7 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 8 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 9 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 10 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 11 tested test VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 12 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 13 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 14 people people NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 16 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 17 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 18 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 19 artificial artificial JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 20 setting setting NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 273 21 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 274 1 On on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 274 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 274 3 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 274 4 show show NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 274 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 274 6 three three CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 274 7 pairs pair NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 274 8 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 274 9 people people NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 274 10 compete compete VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 274 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 1 When when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 3 pair pair NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 5 eliminated eliminate VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 7 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 8 play play VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 9 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 10 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 11 similar similar JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 12 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 14 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 15 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 16 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 17 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 18 determine determine VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 19 how how WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 21 winnings winning NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 22 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 23 split split VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 275 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 2 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 3 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 4 cooperate cooperate VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 6 Friend friend NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 9 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 10 share share VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 12 winnings winning NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 13 50–50 50–50 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 276 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 2 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 3 cooperates cooperate VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 4 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 6 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 7 defects defect NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 8 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 9 Foe Foe NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 10 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 13 defector defector NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 14 gets get VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 15 all all PDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 16 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 17 winnings winning NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 18 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 20 cooperator cooperator NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 21 gets get VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 22 nothing nothing NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 277 23 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 278 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 278 2 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 278 3 defect defect VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 278 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 278 5 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 278 6 leave leave VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 278 7 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 278 8 nothing nothing NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 278 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 1 Notice notice VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 2 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 4 reward reward NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 5 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 6 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 7 slightly slightly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 8 different different JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 9 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 11 standard standard JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 12 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 13 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 14 above above RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 16 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 17 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 18 rewards reward NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 19 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 21 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 22 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 23 defect defect VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 24 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 25 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 26 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 27 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 28 cooperate cooperate NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 29 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 30 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 31 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 32 defects defect VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 33 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 34 cases case NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 35 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 36 identical identical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 279 37 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 2 makes make VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 4 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 5 both both CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 6 defect defect VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 7 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 8 case case NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 9 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 10 weak weak JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 11 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 13 compared compare VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 14 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 15 being be VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 16 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 17 strict strict JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 18 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 19 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 21 standard standard JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 22 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 23 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 24 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 280 25 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 3 contestant contestant NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 4 knows know VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 5 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 6 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 7 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 8 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 9 going go VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 10 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 11 vote vote VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 12 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 13 Foe Foe NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 14 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 16 then then RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 17 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 18 own own JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 19 choice choice NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 20 does do VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 21 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 22 affect affect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 23 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 24 own own JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 25 winnings winning NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 281 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 3 specific specific JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 4 sense sense NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 6 Friend friend NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 7 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 8 Foe Foe NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 9 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 10 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 11 rewards reward NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 12 model model NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 13 between between IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 14 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 15 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 16 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 17 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 18 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 19 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 20 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 21 Chicken Chicken NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 282 22 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 2 rewards reward NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 3 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 5 Pair Pair NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 6 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 7 Pair pair NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 8 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 9 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 10 Friend friend NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 11 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 12 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 13 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 14 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 15 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 16 Foe Foe NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 17 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 18 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 19 defect defect NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 20 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 21 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 22 Friend friend NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 23 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 24 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 25 cooperate cooperate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 26 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 27 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 28 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 29 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 30 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 31 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 32 Foe Foe NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 33 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 34 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 35 defect defect JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 36 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 37 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 38 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 39 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 40 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 41 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 42 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 43 matrix matrix NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 44 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 45 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 46 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 47 used use VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 48 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 49 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 50 British british JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 51 television television NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 52 programmes programme NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 53 Trust trust VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 54 Me -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 55 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 56 Shafted Shafted NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 57 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 58 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 59 Bank Bank NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 60 Job Job NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 61 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 62 Golden Golden NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 63 Balls Balls NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 64 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 65 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 66 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 67 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 68 American american JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 69 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 70 shows show VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 71 Take take VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 72 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 73 All all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 74 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 75 as as RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 76 well well RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 77 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 78 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 79 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 80 winning win VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 81 couple couple NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 82 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 83 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 84 Reality Reality NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 85 Show Show NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 86 shows show VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 87 Bachelor Bachelor NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 88 Pad Pad NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 283 89 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 1 Game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 2 data datum NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 3 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 5 Golden Golden NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 6 Balls Balls NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 7 series series NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 8 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 9 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 10 analyzed analyze VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 11 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 12 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 13 team team NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 15 economists economist NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 17 who who WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 18 found find VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 19 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 20 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 21 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 22 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 23 surprisingly surprisingly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 24 high high JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 25 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 26 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 27 amounts amount NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 28 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 29 money money NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 30 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 31 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 32 seem seem VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 33 consequential consequential JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 34 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 35 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 36 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 37 world world NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 38 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 39 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 40 were be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 41 comparatively comparatively RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 42 low low JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 43 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 44 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 45 context context NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 46 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 47 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 48 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 284 49 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 2 42 42 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 4 Iterated Iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 5 snowdrift[edit snowdrift[edit NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 6 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 7 Main main JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 8 article article NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 9 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 10 snowdrift snowdrift NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 11 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 12 Researchers Researchers NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 13 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 15 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 16 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 17 Lausanne Lausanne NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 18 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 20 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 21 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 22 Edinburgh Edinburgh NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 23 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 24 suggested suggest VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 25 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 26 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 27 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 28 Iterated Iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 29 Snowdrift Snowdrift NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 30 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 31 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 32 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 33 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 34 closely closely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 35 reflect reflect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 36 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 37 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 38 world world NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 39 social social JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 40 situations situation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 285 41 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 1 Although although IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 2 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 3 model model NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 4 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 5 actually actually RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 6 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 7 chicken chicken NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 8 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 10 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 11 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 12 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 13 described describe VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 14 here here RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 286 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 2 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 3 model model NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 6 risk risk NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 8 being be VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 9 exploited exploit VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 10 through through IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 11 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 12 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 13 lower low JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 15 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 16 individuals individual NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 17 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 18 gain gain VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 19 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 20 taking take VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 22 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 23 choice choice NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 287 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 2 snowdrift snowdrift NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 3 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 4 imagines imagine VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 5 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 6 drivers driver NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 7 who who WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 8 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 9 stuck stick VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 10 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 11 opposite opposite JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 12 sides side NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 13 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 14 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 15 snowdrift snowdrift NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 17 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 18 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 19 whom whom WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 20 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 21 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 22 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 23 option option NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 24 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 25 shoveling shovel VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 26 snow snow NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 27 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 28 clear clear VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 29 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 30 path path NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 31 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 32 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 33 remaining remain VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 34 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 35 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 36 car car NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 288 37 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 1 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 2 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 3 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 4 highest high JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 5 payoff payoff NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 6 comes come VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 7 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 8 leaving leave VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 10 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 11 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 12 clear clear VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 13 all all PDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 14 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 15 snow snow NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 16 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 17 themselves -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 19 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 21 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 22 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 23 still still RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 24 nominally nominally RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 25 rewarded reward VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 26 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 27 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 28 work work NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 289 29 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 1 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 2 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 3 better well RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 4 reflect reflect VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 5 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 6 world world NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 7 scenarios scenario NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 10 researchers researcher NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 11 giving give VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 12 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 13 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 15 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 16 scientists scientist NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 17 collaborating collaborate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 18 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 19 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 20 report report NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 21 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 22 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 23 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 24 whom whom WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 25 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 26 benefit benefit VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 27 if if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 28 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 29 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 30 worked work VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 31 harder hard RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 290 32 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 2 But but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 3 when when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 4 your -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 5 collaborator collaborator NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 6 does do VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 7 n’t not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 8 do do VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 9 any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 10 work work NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 12 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 13 ’s ’ VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 14 probably probably RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 15 better well RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 16 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 17 you -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 18 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 19 do do VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 20 all all PDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 22 work work NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 23 yourself -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 291 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 292 1 You -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 292 2 ’ll will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 292 3 still still RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 292 4 end end VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 292 5 up up RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 292 6 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 292 7 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 292 8 completed complete VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 292 9 project project NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 292 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 2 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 3 43 43 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 4 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 5 Example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 6 snowdrift snowdrift NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 7 payouts payout NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 8 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 9 A a NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 10 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 11 B b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 12 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 13 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 14         _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 15 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 16 Cooperates Cooperates NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 17 Defects Defects NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 18 Cooperates Cooperates NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 19 200 200 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 20 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 21 200 200 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 22 100 100 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 23 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 24 300 300 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 25 Defects Defects NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 26 300 300 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 27 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 28 100 100 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 29 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 30 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 31 0 0 NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 32 Example Example NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 33 PD PD NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 34 payouts payout NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 35 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 36 A a NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 37 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 38 B b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 39 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 40 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 41         _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 42 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 43 Cooperates Cooperates NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 44 Defects Defects NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 45 Cooperates Cooperates NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 46 200 200 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 47 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 48 200 200 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 49 -100 -100 NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 50 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 51 300 300 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 52 Defects Defects NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 53 300 300 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 54 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 55 -100 -100 VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 56 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 57 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 58 0 0 NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 59 Coordination coordination NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 60 games[edit games[edit LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 61 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 62 Main main JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 63 article article NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 64 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 65 coordination coordination NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 66 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 67 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 68 coordination coordination NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 69 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 70 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 71 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 72 must must MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 73 coordinate coordinate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 74 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 75 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 76 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 77 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 78 good good JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 79 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 293 80 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 1 An an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 2 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 3 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 4 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 5 cars car NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 6 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 7 abruptly abruptly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 8 meet meet VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 9 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 10 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 11 blizzard blizzard NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 12 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 13 each each DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 14 must must MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 15 choose choose VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 16 whether whether IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 17 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 18 swerve swerve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 19 left left RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 20 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 21 right right RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 294 22 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 2 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 3 swerve swerve VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 4 left leave VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 6 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 7 both both CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 8 right right JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 11 cars car NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 12 do do VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 13 not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 14 collide collide VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 295 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 2 local local JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 3 left- left- NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 4 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 5 right right JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 7 hand hand NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 8 traffic traffic NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 9 convention convention NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 10 helps help VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 11 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 12 co co VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 13 - - VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 14 ordinate ordinate VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 15 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 16 actions action NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 296 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 1 Symmetrical symmetrical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 2 co co NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 3 - - NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 4 ordination ordination JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 5 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 6 include include VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 7 Stag Stag NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 8 hunt hunt NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 9 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 10 Bach Bach NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 11 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 12 Stravinsky Stravinsky NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 297 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 1 Asymmetric asymmetric JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 2 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 3 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 4 dilemmas[edit dilemmas[edit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 5 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 6 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 7 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 8 general general JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 9 set set NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 11 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 12 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 13 asymmetric asymmetric JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 298 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 1 As as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 2 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 4 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 5 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 6 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 9 best good JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 10 outcome outcome NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 11 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 12 co co NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 13 - - NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 14 operation operation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 16 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 17 there there EX en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 18 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 19 motives motive NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 20 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 21 defection defection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 299 22 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 1 Unlike unlike IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 3 symmetric symmetric JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 4 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 5 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 6 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 8 though though RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 10 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 11 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 12 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 13 more more JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 14 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 15 lose lose VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 16 and/or and/or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 17 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 18 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 19 gain gain VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 20 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 22 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 300 23 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 1 Some some DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 2 such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 3 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 4 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 5 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 6 described describe VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 7 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 8 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 9 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 10 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 11 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 12 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 13 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 14 one one CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 15 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 16 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 17 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 18 alibi alibi NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 20 whence whence NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 21 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 22 term term NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 23 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 24 alibi alibi NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 25 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 26 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 301 27 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 2 44 44 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 4 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 5 experiments experiment NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 7 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 8 getting get VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 9 unequal unequal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 10 payoffs payoff NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 11 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 12 repeated repeat VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 13 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 14 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 15 seek seek VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 16 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 17 maximize maximize VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 18 profits profit NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 20 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 21 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 22 under under IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 23 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 24 condition condition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 25 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 26 both both DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 27 players player NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 28 receive receive VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 29 equal equal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 30 payoffs payoff NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 31 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 32 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 33 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 34 lead lead VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 35 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 36 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 37 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 38 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 39 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 40 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 41 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 42 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 43 disadvantaged disadvantaged JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 44 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 45 defects defect VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 46 every every DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 47 X x NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 48 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 49 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 50 while while IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 51 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 52 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 53 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 54 co co NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 55 - - NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 56 operates operate NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 302 57 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 1 Such such JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 2 behaviour behaviour NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 3 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 4 depend depend VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 5 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 7 experiment experiment NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 8 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 9 social social JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 10 norms norm NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 11 around around IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 12 fairness fairness NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 303 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 2 45 45 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 4 Software[edit software[edit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 5 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 6 Several several JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 7 software software NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 8 packages package NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 9 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 10 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 11 created create VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 12 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 13 run run VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 14 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 15 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 16 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 17 simulations simulation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 18 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 19 tournaments tournament NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 20 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 21 some some DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 22 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 23 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 24 have have VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 25 available available JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 26 source source NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 27 code code NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 304 28 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 2 source source NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 3 code code NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 4 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 6 second second JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 7 tournament tournament NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 8 run run VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 9 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 10 Robert Robert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 11 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 12 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 13 written write VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 14 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 15 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 16 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 17 many many JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 18 contributors contributor NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 19 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 20 Fortran Fortran NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 21 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 22 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 23 available available JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 24 online online JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 25 Prison Prison NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 26 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 27 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 28 library library NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 29 written write VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 30 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 31 Java Java NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 32 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 33 last last RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 34 updated update VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 35 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 36 1998 1998 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 37 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 38 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 39 Python Python NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 40 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 41 written write VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 42 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 43 Python Python NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 44 play play VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 45 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 46 Iterative Iterative NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 47 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 48 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 49 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 50 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 51 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 52 browser browser NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 53 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 54 play play VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 55 against against IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 56 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 57 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 58 let let VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 59 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 60 play play VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 61 against against IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 62 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 63 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 64 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 65 fiction[edit fiction[edit LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 66 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 67 Hannu Hannu NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 68 Rajaniemi Rajaniemi NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 69 set set VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 70 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 71 opening opening JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 72 scene scene NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 73 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 74 his -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 75 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 76 Quantum Quantum NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 77 Thief thief NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 78 trilogy trilogy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 79 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 80 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 81 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 82 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 83 prison prison NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 84 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 305 85 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 2 main main JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 3 theme theme NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 6 series series NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 7 has have VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 8 been be VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 9 described describe VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 10 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 12 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 13 inadequacy inadequacy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 14 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 15 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 16 binary binary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 17 universe universe NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 18 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 19 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 21 ultimate ultimate JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 22 antagonist antagonist NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 23 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 24 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 25 character character NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 26 called call VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 27 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 28 All All NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 29 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 30 Defector Defector NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 306 31 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 1 Rajaniemi rajaniemi NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 2 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 3 particularly particularly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 4 interesting interesting JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 5 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 6 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 7 artist artist NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 8 treating treat VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 9 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 10 subject subject NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 11 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 12 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 13 he -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 14 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 15 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 16 Cambridge Cambridge NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 17 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 18 trained train VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 19 mathematician mathematician NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 20 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 21 holds hold VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 22 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 23 PhD phd NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 24 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 25 mathematical mathematical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 26 physics physics NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 27   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 28 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 29 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 30 interchangeability interchangeability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 31 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 32 matter matter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 33 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 34 information information NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 35 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 36 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 37 major major JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 38 feature feature NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 39 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 40 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 41 books book NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 42 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 43 which which WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 44 take take VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 45 place place NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 46 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 47 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 48 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 49 post post JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 50 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 51 singularity singularity JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 52 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 53 future future NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 307 54 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 2 first first JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 3 book book NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 4 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 6 series series NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 7 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 8 published publish VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 9 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 10 2010 2010 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 12 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 14 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 15 sequels sequel NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 16 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 17 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 18 Fractal Fractal NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 19 Prince Prince NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 20 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 21 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 22 Causal Causal NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 23 Angel Angel NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 24 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 25 published publish VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 26 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 27 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 28 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 29 2014 2014 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 30 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 31 respectively respectively RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 308 32 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 1 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 2 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 3 modeled model VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 4 after after IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 6 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 7 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 8 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 9 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 10 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 11 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 12 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 13 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 14 central central JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 15 focus focus NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 16 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 17 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 18 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 19 video video NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 20 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 21 Zero Zero NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 22 Escape Escape NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 23 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 24 Virtue Virtue NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 25 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 26 Last last JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 27 Reward Reward NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 28 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 29 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 30 minor minor JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 31 part part NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 32 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 33 its -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 34 2016 2016 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 35 sequel sequel NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 36 Zero Zero NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 37 Escape Escape NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 38 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 39 Zero Zero NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 40 Time Time NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 41 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 309 42 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 2 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 3 Mysterious Mysterious NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 4 Benedict Benedict NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 5 Society Society NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 6 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 7 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 8 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 9 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 10 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 11 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 12 Trenton Trenton NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 13 Lee Lee NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 14 Stewart Stewart NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 16 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 17 main main JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 18 characters character NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 19 start start VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 20 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 21 playing play VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 22 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 23 version version NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 24 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 25 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 26 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 27 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 28 escaping escape VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 29 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 30 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 31 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 32 prison prison NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 33 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 34 altogether altogether RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 310 35 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 311 1 Later later RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 311 2 they -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 311 3 become become VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 311 4 actual actual JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 311 5 prisoners prisoner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 311 6 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 311 7 escape escape VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 311 8 once once RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 311 9 again again RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 311 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 2 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 3 Adventure Adventure NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 4 Zone Zone NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 6 Balance balance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 7 during during IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 8 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 9 Suffering Suffering NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 10 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 11 subarc subarc NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 14 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 15 characters character NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 16 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 17 twice twice RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 18 presented present VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 19 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 21 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 22 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 23 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 24 during during IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 25 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 26 time time NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 27 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 28 two two CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 29 liches liche NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 30 ' ' POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 31 domain domain NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 32 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 33 once once RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 34 cooperating cooperate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 35 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 36 once once IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 37 defecting defect VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 312 38 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 3 8th 8th JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 4 novel novel NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 5 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 7 author author NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 8 James James NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 9 S. S. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 10 A. a. NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 11 Corey Corey NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 12 Tiamat Tiamat NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 13 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 14 Wrath Wrath NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 16 Winston Winston NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 17 Duarte Duarte NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 18 explains explain VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 20 prisoners prisoner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 21 dilemma dilemma VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 22 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 23 his -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 24 14-year 14-year CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 25 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 26 old old JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 27 daughter daughter NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 28 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 29 Teresa Teresa NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 30 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 31 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 32 train train VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 33 her -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 34 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 35 strategic strategic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 36 thinking thinking NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 313 37 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 1 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 2 citation citation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 3 needed need VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 4 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 5 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 6 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 7 examined examine VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 8 literally literally RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 9 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 11 2019 2019 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 12 film film NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 13 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 14 Platform Platform NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 16 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 17 inmates inmate NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 18 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 19 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 20 vertical vertical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 21 prison prison NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 22 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 23 only only RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 24 eat eat VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 25 whatever whatever WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 26 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 27 left leave VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 28 over over RP en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 29 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 30 those those DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 31 above above IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 32 them -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 314 33 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 1 If if IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 2 everyone everyone NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 3 were be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 4 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 5 eat eat VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 6 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 7 fair fair JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 8 share share NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 10 there there EX en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 11 would would MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 12 be be VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 13 enough enough JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 14 food food NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 16 but but CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 17 those those DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 18 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 19 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 20 lower low JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 21 levels level NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 22 are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 23 shown show VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 24 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 25 starve starve VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 26 because because IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 27 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 28 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 29 higher high JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 30 inmates inmate NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 31 ' ' POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 32 overconsumption overconsumption NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 315 33 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 1 See see VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 2 also[edit also[edit LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 4 Abilene abilene NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 5 paradox paradox NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 6 Centipede Centipede NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 7 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 8 Christmas Christmas NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 9 truce truce NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 10 Externality Externality NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 11 Folk Folk NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 12 theorem theorem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 13 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 14 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 15 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 16 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 17 Free free JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 18 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 19 rider rider NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 20 problem problem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 21 Hobbesian hobbesian JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 22 trap trap NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 23 Innocent innocent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 24 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 25 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 26 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 27 Liar Liar NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 28 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 29 Optional Optional NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 30 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 31 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 32 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 33 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 34 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 35 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 36 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 37 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 38 Public public JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 39 goods good NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 40 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 41 Gift Gift NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 42 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 43 exchange exchange NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 44 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 45 Reciprocal reciprocal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 46 altruism altruism NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 47 Rent rent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 48 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 49 seeking seek VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 50 Social Social NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 51 preferences preference NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 52 Swift swift JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 53 trust trust NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 54 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 55 Unscrupulous unscrupulous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 56 diner diner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 57 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 58 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 59 References[edit references[edit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 60 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 61 ^ ^ . en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 62 For for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 63 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 64 see see VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 65 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 66 2003 2003 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 67 study[15 study[15 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 68 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 69 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 70 discussion discussion NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 71 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 72 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 73 concept concept NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 74 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 75 whether whether IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 76 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 77 can can MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 78 apply apply VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 79 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 80 real real JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 81 economic economic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 82 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 83 strategic strategic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 84 situations situation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 316 85 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 1 ^ ^ NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 2 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 3 argument argument NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 4 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 6 development development NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 8 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 9 through through IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 10 trust trust NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 11 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 12 given give VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 13 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 14 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 15 Wisdom Wisdom NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 16 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 17 Crowds Crowds NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 19 where where WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 20 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 21 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 22 argued argue VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 23 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 24 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 25 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 26 distance distance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 27 capitalism capitalism NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 28 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 29 able able JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 30 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 31 form form VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 32 around around IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 33 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 34 nucleus nucleus NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 35 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 36 Quakers Quakers NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 37 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 38 who who WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 39 always always RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 40 dealt deal VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 41 honourably honourably RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 42 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 43 their -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 44 business business NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 45 partners partner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 317 46 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 1 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 2 Rather rather RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 3 than than IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 4 defecting defect VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 5 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 6 reneging renege VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 7 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 8 promises promise NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 9   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 10 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 11 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 12 phenomenon phenomenon NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 13 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 14 had have VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 15 discouraged discourage VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 16 earlier early JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 17 long long JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 18 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 19 term term NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 20 unenforceable unenforceable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 21 overseas overseas JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 22 contracts contract NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 23 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 318 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 1 It -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 2 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 3 argued argue VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 4 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 5 dealings dealing NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 6 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 7 reliable reliable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 8 merchants merchant NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 9 allowed allow VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 11 meme meme NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 12 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 13 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 14 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 15 spread spread VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 16 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 17 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 18 traders trader NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 20 who who WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 21 spread spread VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 22 it -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 23 further further RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 24 until until IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 25 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 26 high high JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 27 degree degree NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 28 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 29 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 30 became become VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 31 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 32 profitable profitable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 33 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 34 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 35 general general JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 36 commerce commerce NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 37 ^ ^ . en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 38 Poundstone Poundstone NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 39 1993 1993 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 40 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 41 pp pp NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 319 42 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 320 1 8 8 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 320 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 320 3 117 117 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 320 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 321 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 321 2 Milovsky Milovsky NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 321 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 321 4 Nicholas Nicholas NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 321 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 322 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 322 2 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 322 3 Basics Basics NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 322 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 322 5 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 322 6 Theory Theory NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 322 7 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 322 8 Associated Associated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 322 9 Games Games NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 322 10 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 322 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 323 1 Retrieved retrieve VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 323 2 11 11 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 323 3 February February NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 323 4 2014 2014 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 323 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 2 Fehr Fehr NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 4 Ernst Ernst NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 5 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 6 Fischbacher Fischbacher NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 8 Urs Urs NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 9 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 10 Oct Oct NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 11 23 23 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 13 2003 2003 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 14 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 324 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 325 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 325 2 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 325 3 Nature Nature NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 325 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 325 5 human human JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 325 6 altruism altruism NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 325 7 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 325 8 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 325 9 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 325 10 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 325 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 326 1 Nature nature NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 326 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 327 1 425 425 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 327 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 327 3 6960 6960 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 327 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 327 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 327 6 785–91 785–91 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 327 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 328 1 Bibcode:2003Natur.425 bibcode:2003natur.425 LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 328 2 .. .. NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 328 3 785F. 785f. CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 329 1 doi:10.1038 doi:10.1038 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 329 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 329 3 nature02043 nature02043 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 329 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 330 1 PMID PMID NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 330 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 330 3 14574401 14574401 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 330 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 331 1 S2CID S2CID NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 331 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 331 3 4305295 4305295 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 331 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 332 1 Retrieved Retrieved NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 332 2 February February NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 332 3 27 27 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 332 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 332 5 2013 2013 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 332 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 2 Tversky Tversky NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 4 Amos Amos NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 5 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 6 Shafir Shafir NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 8 Eldar Eldar NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 9 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 10 2004 2004 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 11 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 333 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 1 Preference preference NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 3 belief belief NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 5 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 6 similarity similarity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 7 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 8 selected select VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 9 writings writing NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 10 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 11 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 12 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 334 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 335 1 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 335 2 Institute Institute NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 335 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 335 4 Technology Technology NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 335 5 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 335 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 336 1 ISBN ISBN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 336 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 336 3 9780262700931 9780262700931 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 336 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 337 1 Retrieved Retrieved NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 337 2 February February NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 337 3 27 27 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 337 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 337 5 2013 2013 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 337 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 2 Toh Toh NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 3 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 4 Kyeong Kyeong NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 6 Ahn Ahn NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 7 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 8 Ostrom Ostrom NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 10 Elinor Elinor NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 11 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 12 Walker Walker NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 13 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 14 James James NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 15 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 16 Sep Sep NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 17 5 5 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 19 2002 2002 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 20 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 338 21 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 2 Incorporating Incorporating NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 3 Motivational Motivational NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 4 Heterogeneity heterogeneity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 5 into into IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 6 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 7 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 8 Theoretic Theoretic NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 9 Models Models NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 11 Collective Collective NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 12 Action Action NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 13 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 14 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 15 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 16 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 339 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 340 1 Public Public NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 340 2 Choice Choice NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 340 3 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 341 1 117 117 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 341 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 341 3 3–4 3–4 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 341 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 341 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 341 6 295–314 295–314 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 341 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 342 1 doi:10.1023 doi:10.1023 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 342 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 342 3 b b NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 342 4 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 342 5 puch.0000003739.54365.fd puch.0000003739.54365.fd NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 342 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 343 1 hdl:10535/4697 hdl:10535/4697 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 343 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 344 1 S2CID S2CID NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 344 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 344 3 153414274 153414274 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 344 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 345 1 Retrieved Retrieved NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 345 2 June June NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 345 3 27 27 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 345 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 345 5 2015 2015 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 345 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 2 Oosterbeek Oosterbeek NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 4 Hessel Hessel NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 5 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 6 Sloof Sloof NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 8 Randolph Randolph NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 9 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 10 Van Van NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 11 de de FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 12 Kuilen Kuilen NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 13 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 14 Gus Gus NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 15 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 16 Dec Dec NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 17 3 3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 19 2003 2003 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 20 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 346 21 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 2 Cultural cultural JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 3 Differences difference NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 4 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 5 Ultimatum Ultimatum NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 6 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 7 Experiments Experiments NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 8 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 9 Evidence evidence NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 10 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 11 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 12 Meta Meta NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 13 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 14 Analysis Analysis NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 15 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 16 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 17 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 18 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 347 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 348 1 Experimental Experimental NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 348 2 Economics Economics NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 348 3 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 349 1 7 7 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 349 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 349 3 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 349 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 349 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 349 6 171–88 171–88 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 349 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 350 1 doi:10.1023 doi:10.1023 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 350 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 350 3 B B NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 350 4 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 350 5 EXEC.0000026978.14316.74 exec.0000026978.14316.74 ADD en-wikipedia-org-1554 350 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 351 1 S2CID S2CID NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 351 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 351 3 17659329 17659329 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 351 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 1 Archived archived JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 2 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 4 original original JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 6 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 8 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 9 May May NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 10 12 12 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 12 2013 2013 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 352 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 353 1 Retrieved Retrieved NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 353 2 February February NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 353 3 27 27 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 353 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 353 5 2013 2013 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 353 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 2 Ormerod Ormerod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 4 Paul Paul NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 6 2010 2010 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 7 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 8 12 12 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 9 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 10 22 22 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 11 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 354 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 355 1 Why why WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 355 2 Most Most JJS en-wikipedia-org-1554 355 3 Things thing NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 355 4 Fail fail VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 355 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 356 1 ISBN ISBN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 356 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 356 3 9780571266142 9780571266142 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 356 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 357 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 357 2 Deutsch Deutsch NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 357 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 357 4 M. M. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 357 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 357 6 1958 1958 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 357 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 357 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 358 1 Trust trust NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 358 2 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 358 3 suspicion suspicion NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 358 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 359 1 Journal Journal NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 359 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 359 3 Conflict Conflict NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 359 4 Resolution Resolution NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 359 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 359 6 2(4 2(4 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 359 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 359 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 359 9 265–279 265–279 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 359 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 1 https://doi.org/10.1177/002200275800200401 https://doi.org/10.1177/002200275800200401 UH en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 2 ^ ^ FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 3 Rapoport rapoport NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 5 A. a. NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 7 & & CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 8 Chammah Chammah NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 10 A. a. NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 11 M. M. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 12 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 13 1965 1965 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 14 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 360 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 361 1 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 361 2 ’s ’s NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 361 3 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 361 4 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 361 5 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 361 6 study study NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 361 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 361 8 conflict conflict NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 361 9 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 361 10 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 361 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 362 1 Ann Ann NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 362 2 Arbor Arbor NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 362 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 362 4 MI MI NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 362 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 362 6 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 362 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 362 8 Michigan Michigan NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 362 9 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 362 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 363 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 363 2 Kaznatcheev Kaznatcheev NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 363 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 363 4 Artem Artem NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 363 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 363 6 March March NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 363 7 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 363 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 363 9 2015 2015 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 363 10 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 363 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 364 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 364 2 Short short JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 364 3 history history NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 364 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 364 5 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 364 6 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 364 7 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 364 8 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 364 9 tournaments tournament NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 364 10 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 364 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 365 1 Theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 365 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 365 3 Evolution evolution NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 365 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 365 5 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 365 6 Games Games NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 365 7 Group Group NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 365 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 366 1 Retrieved Retrieved NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 366 2 February February NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 366 3 8 8 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 366 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 366 5 2016 2016 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 366 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 3 b b NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 4 Hilbe Hilbe NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 6 Christian Christian NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 7 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 8 Martin Martin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 9 A. A. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 10 Nowak Nowak NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 11 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 12 Karl Karl NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 13 Sigmund Sigmund NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 14 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 15 April April NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 16 2013 2013 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 17 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 367 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 2 Evolution evolution NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 4 extortion extortion NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 5 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 6 Iterated Iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 7 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 8 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 9 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 10 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 11 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 368 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 369 1 PNAS pna NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 369 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 370 1 110 110 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 370 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 370 3 17 17 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 370 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 370 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 370 6 6913–18 6913–18 ADD en-wikipedia-org-1554 370 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 371 1 arXiv:1212.1067 arxiv:1212.1067 UH en-wikipedia-org-1554 371 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 372 1 Bibcode:2013PNAS bibcode:2013pnas UH en-wikipedia-org-1554 372 2 .. .. NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 372 3 110.6913H. 110.6913h. CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 373 1 doi:10.1073 doi:10.1073 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 373 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 373 3 pnas.1214834110 pnas.1214834110 NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 373 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 374 1 PMC PMC NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 374 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 374 3 3637695 3637695 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 374 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 375 1 PMID PMID NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 375 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 375 3 23572576 23572576 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 375 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 376 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 376 2 Shy Shy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 376 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 376 4 Oz Oz NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 376 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 376 6 1995 1995 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 376 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 376 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 377 1 Industrial Industrial NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 377 2 Organization Organization NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 377 3 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 377 4 Theory Theory NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 377 5 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 377 6 Applications application NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 377 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 378 1 Massachusetts Massachusetts NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 378 2 Institute Institute NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 378 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 378 4 Technology Technology NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 378 5 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 378 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 379 1 ISBN ISBN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 379 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 379 3 978 978 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 379 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 379 5 0262193665 0262193665 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 379 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 380 1 Retrieved Retrieved NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 380 2 February February NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 380 3 27 27 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 380 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 380 5 2013 2013 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 380 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 2 Dal Dal NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 3 Bó Bó NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 5 Pedro Pedro NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 6 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 7 Fréchette Fréchette NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 9 Guillaume Guillaume NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 10 R. R. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 11 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 12 2019 2019 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 13 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 381 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 2 Strategy Strategy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 3 Choice Choice NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 4 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 6 Infinitely infinitely RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 7 Repeated repeat VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 8 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 9 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 10 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 11 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 382 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 383 1 American American NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 383 2 Economic Economic NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 383 3 Review Review NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 383 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 384 1 109 109 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 384 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 384 3 11 11 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 384 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 384 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 384 6 3929–3952 3929–3952 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 384 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 385 1 doi:10.1257 doi:10.1257 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 385 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 385 3 aer.20181480 aer.20181480 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 385 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 386 1 ISSN issn NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 386 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 386 3 0002 0002 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 386 4 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 386 5 8282 8282 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 386 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 2 Wedekind Wedekind NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 4 C. C. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 5 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 6 Milinski Milinski NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 8 M. M. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 9 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 10 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 11 April April NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 12 1996 1996 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 13 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 387 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 2 Human human JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 3 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 4 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 6 simultaneous simultaneous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 7 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 9 alternating alternate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 10 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 11 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 12 Dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 13 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 14 Pavlov Pavlov NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 15 versus versus IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 16 Generous Generous NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 17 Tit Tit NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 18 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 19 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 20 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 21 Tat Tat NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 22 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 388 23 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 389 1 Proceedings proceeding NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 389 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 389 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 389 4 National National NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 389 5 Academy Academy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 389 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 389 7 Sciences Sciences NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 389 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 390 1 93 93 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 390 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 390 3 7 7 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 390 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 390 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 390 6 2686–2689 2686–2689 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 390 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 391 1 doi:10.1073 doi:10.1073 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 391 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 391 3 pnas.93.7.2686 pnas.93.7.2686 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 391 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 392 1 PMC PMC NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 392 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 392 3 39691 39691 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 392 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 393 1 PMID PMID NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 393 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 393 3 11607644 11607644 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 393 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 1 ^ ^ FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 2 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 3 Bayesian Bayesian NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 4 Nash Nash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 5 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 6 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 7 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 8 statistical statistical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 9 test test NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 10 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 11 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 12 hypothesis hypothesis NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 13 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 14 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 15 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 16 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 394 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 395 1 Tel Tel NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 395 2 Aviv Aviv NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 395 3 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 395 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 1 Archived archived JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 2 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 4 original original JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 6 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 8 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 9 2005 2005 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 10 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 11 10 10 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 12 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 13 02 02 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 396 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 2 Wu Wu NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 4 Jiadong Jiadong NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 5 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 6 Zhao Zhao NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 8 Chengye Chengye NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 9 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 10 2019 2019 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 11 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 13 Sun Sun NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 15 Xiaoming Xiaoming NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 16 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 17 He -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 18 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 19 Kun Kun NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 20 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 21 Chen Chen NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 22 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 23 Xiaoyun Xiaoyun NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 24 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 25 eds eds XX en-wikipedia-org-1554 397 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 1 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 3 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 4 Cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 5 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 7 Monte Monte NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 8 Carlo Carlo NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 9 Rule Rule NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 10 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 11 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 12 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 13 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 14 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 15 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 16 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 17 Grid Grid NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 18 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 20 Theoretical Theoretical NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 21 Computer Computer NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 22 Science Science NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 23 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 24 Springer Springer NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 25 Singapore Singapore NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 26 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 27 1069 1069 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 28 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 29 pp pp NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 398 30 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 1 3–15 3–15 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 3 doi:10.1007/978 doi:10.1007/978 NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 5 981 981 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 7 15 15 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 8 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 9 0105 0105 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 10 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 11 0_1 0_1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 13 ISBN ISBN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 14   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 15 978 978 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 16 - - CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 17 981 981 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 18 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 19 15 15 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 20 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 21 0104 0104 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 22 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 23 3 3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 24 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 25 S2CID S2CID NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 26   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 27 118687103 118687103 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 28 ^ ^ SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 29 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 30 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 31 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 32 Southampton Southampton NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 33 team team NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 34 wins win VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 35 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 36 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 37 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 38 competition competition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 39 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 40 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 41 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 42 release release NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 43 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 399 44 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 400 1 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 400 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 400 3 Southampton Southampton NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 400 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 401 1 7 7 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 401 2 October October NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 401 3 2004 2004 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 401 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 402 1 Archived archived JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 402 2 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 402 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 402 4 original original NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 402 5 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 402 6 2014 2014 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 402 7 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 402 8 04 04 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 402 9 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 402 10 21 21 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 402 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 3 b b NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 4 c c NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 5 d d NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 6 e e NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 7 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 9 WH WH NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 10 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 11 Dyson Dyson NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 12 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 13 FJ FJ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 14 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 15 26 26 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 16 June June NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 17 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 18 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 403 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 2 Iterated Iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 3 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 4 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 5 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 6 contains contain VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 7 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 8 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 9 dominate dominate VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 10 any any DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 11 evolutionary evolutionary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 12 opponent opponent NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 13 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 404 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 1 Proceedings proceeding NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 4 National National NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 5 Academy Academy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 7 Sciences Sciences NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 8 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 10 United United NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 11 States States NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 13 America America NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 405 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 406 1 109 109 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 406 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 406 3 26 26 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 406 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 406 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 406 6 10409–13 10409–13 LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 406 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 407 1 Bibcode:2012PNAS bibcode:2012pnas UH en-wikipedia-org-1554 407 2 .. .. . en-wikipedia-org-1554 407 3 10910409P. 10910409p. CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 408 1 doi:10.1073 doi:10.1073 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 408 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 408 3 pnas.1206569109 pnas.1206569109 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 408 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 409 1 PMC PMC NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 409 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 409 3 3387070 3387070 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 409 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 410 1 PMID PMID NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 410 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 410 3 22615375 22615375 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 410 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 411 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 411 2 Adami Adami NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 411 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 411 4 Christoph Christoph NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 411 5 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 411 6 Arend Arend NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 411 7 Hintze Hintze NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 411 8 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 411 9 2013 2013 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 411 10 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 411 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 2 Evolutionary evolutionary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 3 instability instability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 5 Zero Zero NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 6 Determinant Determinant NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 7 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 8 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 9 that that IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 10 winning win VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 11 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 12 n't not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 13 everything everything NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 14 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 412 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 413 1 Nature Nature NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 413 2 Communications Communications NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 413 3 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 414 1 4 4 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 414 2 : : SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 414 3 3 3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 414 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 414 5 arXiv:1208.2666 arxiv:1208.2666 ADD en-wikipedia-org-1554 414 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 415 1 Bibcode:2013NatCo bibcode:2013natco NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 415 2 ... ... NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 415 3 4.2193A. 4.2193a. CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 416 1 doi:10.1038 doi:10.1038 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 416 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 416 3 ncomms3193 ncomms3193 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 416 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 417 1 PMC PMC NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 417 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 417 3 3741637 3741637 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 417 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 418 1 PMID PMID NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 418 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 418 3 23903782 23903782 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 418 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 3 b b NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 4 Stewart Stewart NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 6 Alexander Alexander NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 7 J. J. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 8 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 9 Joshua Joshua NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 10 B. B. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 11 Plotkin Plotkin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 12 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 13 2013 2013 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 14 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 419 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 2 From from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 3 extortion extortion NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 4 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 5 generosity generosity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 7 evolution evolution NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 8 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 10 Iterated Iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 11 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 12 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 13 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 14 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 420 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 1 Proceedings proceeding NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 4 National National NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 5 Academy Academy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 7 Sciences Sciences NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 8 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 10 United United NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 11 States States NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 13 America America NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 421 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 422 1 110 110 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 422 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 422 3 38 38 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 422 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 422 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 422 6 15348–53 15348–53 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 422 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 423 1 Bibcode:2013PNAS bibcode:2013pnas UH en-wikipedia-org-1554 423 2 .. .. . en-wikipedia-org-1554 423 3 11015348S. 11015348s. JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 424 1 doi:10.1073 doi:10.1073 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 424 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 424 3 pnas.1306246110 pnas.1306246110 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 424 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 425 1 PMC PMC NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 425 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 425 3 3780848 3780848 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 425 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 426 1 PMID PMID NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 426 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 426 3 24003115 24003115 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 426 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 427 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 427 2 Akin Akin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 427 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 427 4 Ethan Ethan NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 427 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 427 6 2013 2013 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 427 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 427 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 2 Stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 3 Cooperative Cooperative NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 4 Solutions Solutions NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 5 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 7 Iterated Iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 8 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 9 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 10 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 11 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 428 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 429 1 p. p. NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 429 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 429 3 9 9 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 429 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 429 5 arXiv:1211.0969 arXiv:1211.0969 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 429 6 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 429 7 math math NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 429 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 429 9 DS DS NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 429 10 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 429 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 430 1 Bibcode:2012arXiv1211.0969A bibcode:2012arxiv1211.0969a NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 430 2 ^ ^ . en-wikipedia-org-1554 430 3 Le Le NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 430 4 S S NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 430 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 430 6 Boyd Boyd NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 430 7 R R NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 430 8 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 430 9 2007 2007 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 430 10 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 430 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 2 Evolutionary Evolutionary NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 3 Dynamics Dynamics NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 6 Continuous Continuous NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 7 Iterated Iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 8 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 9 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 10 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 11 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 431 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 432 1 Journal Journal NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 432 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 432 3 Theoretical Theoretical NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 432 4 Biology Biology NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 432 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 433 1 245 245 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 433 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 433 3 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 433 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 433 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 433 6 258–67 258–67 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 433 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 434 1 doi:10.1016 doi:10.1016 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 434 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 434 3 j.jtbi.2006.09.016 j.jtbi.2006.09.016 JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 434 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 435 1 PMID PMID NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 435 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 435 3 17125798 17125798 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 435 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 436 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 436 2 Hammerstein Hammerstein NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 436 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 436 4 P. P. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 436 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 436 6 2003 2003 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 436 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 436 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 437 1 Why why WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 437 2 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 437 3 reciprocity reciprocity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 437 4 so so RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 437 5 rare rare JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 437 6 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 437 7 social social JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 437 8 animals animal NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 437 9 ? ? . en-wikipedia-org-1554 438 1 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 438 2 protestant protestant JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 438 3 appeal appeal NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 438 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 2 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 3 P. P. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 4 Hammerstein Hammerstein NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 6 Editor Editor NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 8 Genetic Genetic NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 9 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 10 Cultural Cultural NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 11 Evolution Evolution NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 13 Cooperation Cooperation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 15 MIT MIT NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 16 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 439 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 440 1 pp pp NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 440 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 441 1 83–94 83–94 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 441 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 442 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 442 2 Spaniel Spaniel NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 442 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 442 4 William William NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 442 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 442 6 2011 2011 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 442 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 442 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 443 1 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 443 2 Theory Theory NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 443 3 101 101 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 443 4 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 443 5 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 443 6 Complete Complete NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 443 7 Textbook Textbook NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 443 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 444 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 444 2 Nowak Nowak NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 444 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 444 4 Martin Martin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 444 5 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 444 6 Karl Karl NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 444 7 Sigmund Sigmund NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 444 8 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 444 9 1993 1993 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 444 10 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 444 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 2 A a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 3 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 5 win win NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 7 stay stay VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 9 lose lose JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 10 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 11 shift shift NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 12 that that WDT en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 13 outperforms outperform VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 14 tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 15 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 16 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 17 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 18 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 19 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 20 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 21 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 22 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 23 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 24 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 25 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 445 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 446 1 Nature nature NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 446 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 447 1 364 364 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 447 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 447 3 6432 6432 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 447 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 447 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 447 6 56–58 56–58 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 447 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 448 1 Bibcode:1993Natur.364 bibcode:1993natur.364 LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 448 2 ... ... : en-wikipedia-org-1554 448 3 56N. 56n. LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 449 1 doi:10.1038/364056a0 doi:10.1038/364056a0 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 449 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 450 1 PMID PMID NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 450 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 450 3 8316296 8316296 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 450 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 451 1 S2CID S2CID NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 451 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 451 3 4238908 4238908 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 451 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 452 1 ^ ^ FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 452 2 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 452 3 Markets Markets NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 452 4 & & CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 452 5 Data Data NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 452 6 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 452 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 453 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 453 2 Economist Economist NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 453 3 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 454 1 2007 2007 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 454 2 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 454 3 09 09 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 454 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 454 5 27 27 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 454 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 2 Rehmeyer Rehmeyer NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 4 Julie Julie NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 6 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 7 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 8 10 10 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 9 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 10 29 29 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 11 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 455 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 2 Game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 3 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 4 suggests suggest VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 5 current current JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 6 climate climate NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 7 negotiations negotiation NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 8 wo will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 9 n't not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 10 avert avert VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 11 catastrophe catastrophe NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 12 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 456 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 457 1 Science Science NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 457 2 News News NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 457 3 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 458 1 Society Society NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 458 2 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 458 3 Science Science NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 458 4 & & CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 458 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 458 6 Public public NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 458 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 2 Osang Osang NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 4 Thomas Thomas NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 5 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 6 Nandyyz Nandyyz NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 8 Arundhati Arundhati NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 9 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 10 August August NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 11 2003 2003 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 12 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 459 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 1 Environmental environmental JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 2 Regulation Regulation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 4 Polluting Polluting NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 5 Firms Firms NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 6 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 7 Porter Porter NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 8 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 9 Hypothesis Hypothesis NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 10 Revisited Revisited NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 11 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 12 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 13 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 14 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 15 paper paper NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 16 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 460 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 461 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 461 2 Dawkins Dawkins NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 461 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 461 4 Richard Richard NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 461 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 461 6 1976 1976 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 461 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 461 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 462 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 462 2 Selfish Selfish NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 462 3 Gene Gene NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 462 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 463 1 Oxford Oxford NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 463 2 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 463 3 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 463 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 464 1 ^ ^ FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 464 2 Ainslie Ainslie NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 464 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 464 4 George George NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 464 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 464 6 2001 2001 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 464 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 464 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 465 1 Breakdown Breakdown NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 465 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 465 3 Will Will NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 465 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 1 ISBN ISBN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 3 978 978 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 5 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 7 521 521 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 8 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 9 59694 59694 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 10 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 11 7 7 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 466 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 467 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 467 2 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 467 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 467 4 Robert Robert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 467 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 467 6 1980 1980 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 467 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 467 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 468 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 468 2 Effective effective JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 468 3 Choice Choice NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 468 4 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 468 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 468 6 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 468 7 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 468 8 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 468 9 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 468 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 469 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 469 2 Journal Journal NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 469 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 469 4 Conflict Conflict NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 469 5 Resolution Resolution NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 469 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 470 1 24 24 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 470 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 470 3 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 470 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 470 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 470 6 3–25 3–25 NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 470 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 471 1 doi:10.1177/002200278002400101 doi:10.1177/002200278002400101 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 471 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 472 1 ISSN issn NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 472 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 472 3 0022 0022 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 472 4 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 472 5 0027 0027 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 472 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 473 1 JSTOR JSTOR NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 473 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 473 3 173932 173932 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 473 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 474 1 S2CID S2CID NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 474 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 474 3 143112198 143112198 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 474 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 475 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 475 2 Nicholson Nicholson NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 475 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 475 4 Walter Walter NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 475 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 475 6 2000 2000 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 475 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 475 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 476 1 Intermediate intermediate JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 476 2 microeconomics microeconomic NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 476 3 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 476 4 its -PRON- PRP$ en-wikipedia-org-1554 476 5 application application NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 476 6 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 476 7 8th 8th JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 476 8 ed ed NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 476 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 476 10 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 476 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 1 Fort Fort NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 2 Worth Worth NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 4 TX TX NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 6 Dryden Dryden NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 7 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 8   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 9 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 10 Harcourt Harcourt NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 11 College College NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 12 Publishers Publishers NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 477 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 1 ISBN ISBN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 3 978 978 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 5 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 7 030 030 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 8 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 9 25916 25916 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 10 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 11 6 6 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 478 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 2 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 3 b b NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 4 Schneier Schneier NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 6 Bruce Bruce NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 7 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 8 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 9 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 10 10 10 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 11 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 12 26 26 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 13 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 479 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 2 Lance Lance NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 3 Armstrong Armstrong NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 4 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 6 Prisoners Prisoners NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 7 ' ' POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 8 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 9 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 10 Doping Doping NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 11 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 12 Professional Professional NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 13 Sports Sports NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 14 | | NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 15 Wired Wired NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 16 Opinion Opinion NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 17 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 480 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 481 1 Wired wire VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 481 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 482 1 Wired.com Wired.com NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 482 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 483 1 Retrieved Retrieved NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 483 2 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 483 3 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 483 4 10 10 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 483 5 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 483 6 29 29 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 483 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 484 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 484 2 Stephen Stephen NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 484 3 J. J. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 484 4 Majeski Majeski NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 484 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 484 6 1984 1984 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 484 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 484 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 485 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 485 2 Arms arm NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 485 3 races race NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 485 4 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 485 5 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 485 6 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 485 7 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 485 8 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 485 9 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 485 10 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 485 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 486 1 Mathematical mathematical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 486 2 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 486 3 Social Social NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 486 4 Sciences Sciences NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 486 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 487 1 7 7 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 487 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 487 3 3 3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 487 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 487 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 487 6 253–66 253–66 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 487 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 488 1 doi:10.1016/0165 doi:10.1016/0165 JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 488 2 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 488 3 4896(84)90022 4896(84)90022 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 488 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 488 5 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 488 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 2 Kuhn Kuhn NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 4 Steven Steven NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 6 2019 2019 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 9 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 10 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 11 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 12 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 13 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 15 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 16 Zalta Zalta NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 18 Edward Edward NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 489 19 N. N. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 490 1 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 490 2 ed ed NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 490 3 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 1 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 3 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 4 Stanford Stanford NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 5 Encyclopedia Encyclopedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 7 Philosophy Philosophy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 8 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 9 Winter Winter NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 10 2019 2019 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 11 ed ed NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 491 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 1 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 3 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 4 Research Research NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 5 Lab Lab NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 7 Stanford Stanford NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 8 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 10 retrieved retrieve VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 11 2020 2020 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 12 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 13 04 04 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 14 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 15 12 12 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 16 ^ ^ NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 17 Gokhale Gokhale NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 18 CS CS NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 19 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 20 Traulsen Traulsen NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 492 21 A. A. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 493 1 Evolutionary evolutionary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 493 2 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 493 3 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 493 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 493 5 multiverse multiverse NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 493 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 494 1 Proceedings proceeding NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 494 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 494 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 494 4 National National NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 494 5 Academy Academy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 494 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 494 7 Sciences Sciences NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 494 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 495 1 2010 2010 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 495 2 Mar Mar NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 495 3 23 23 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 495 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 496 1 107(12):5500–04 107(12):5500–04 NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 496 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 497 1 ^ ^ NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 497 2 Poundstone poundstone NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 497 3 1993 1993 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 497 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 497 5 pp pp NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 497 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 498 1 126–127 126–127 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 498 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 1 ^ ^ FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 2 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 3 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 4 Volokh Volokh NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 5 Conspiracy Conspiracy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 6 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 7 Elinor Elinor NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 8 Ostrom Ostrom NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 9 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 11 Tragedy Tragedy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 13 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 14 Commons Commons NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 15 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 499 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 500 1 Volokh.com Volokh.com NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 500 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 501 1 2009 2009 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 501 2 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 501 3 10 10 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 501 4 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 501 5 12 12 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 501 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 502 1 Retrieved retrieve VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 502 2 2011 2011 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 502 3 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 502 4 12 12 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 502 5 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 502 6 17 17 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 502 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 503 1 ^ ^ FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 503 2 Ostrom Ostrom NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 503 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 503 4 Elinor Elinor NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 503 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 503 6 2015 2015 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 503 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 503 8 [ [ -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 503 9 1990 1990 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 503 10 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 503 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 1 Governing govern VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 2 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 3 Commons Commons NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 4 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 5 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 6 Evolution Evolution NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 8 Institutions Institutions NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 9 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 10 Collective Collective NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 11 Action Action NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 504 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 505 1 Cambridge Cambridge NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 505 2 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 505 3 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 505 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 506 1 doi:10.1017 doi:10.1017 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 506 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 506 3 CBO9781316423936 CBO9781316423936 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 506 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 1 ISBN ISBN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 3 978 978 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 5 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 7 107 107 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 8 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 9 56978 56978 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 10 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 11 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 507 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 508 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 508 2 Hofstadter Hofstadter NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 508 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 508 4 Douglas Douglas NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 508 5 R. R. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 508 6 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 508 7 1985 1985 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 508 8 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 508 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 2 Ch.29 Ch.29 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 3 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 4 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 5 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 6 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 7 Computer Computer NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 8 Tournaments Tournaments NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 9 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 10 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 11 Evolution Evolution NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 12 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 13 Cooperation Cooperation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 15 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 509 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 1 Metamagical metamagical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 2 Themas Themas NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 3 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 4 questing quest VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 5 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 7 essence essence NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 8 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 9 mind mind NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 10 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 11 pattern pattern NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 510 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 511 1 Bantam Bantam NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 511 2 Dell Dell NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 511 3 Pub Pub NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 511 4 Group Group NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 511 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 1 ISBN ISBN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 3 978 978 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 5 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 7 465 465 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 8 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 9 04566 04566 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 10 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 11 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 512 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 1 ^ ^ FW en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 2 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 3 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 4 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 5 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 7 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 10 free free JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 11 encyclopedia encyclopedia NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 12 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 513 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 514 1 users.auth.gr users.auth.gr ADD en-wikipedia-org-1554 514 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 515 1 Retrieved retrieve VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 515 2 2020 2020 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 515 3 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 515 4 04 04 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 515 5 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 515 6 12 12 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 515 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 516 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 516 2 Van Van NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 516 3 den den NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 516 4 Assem Assem NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 516 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 516 6 Martijn Martijn NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 516 7 J. J. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 517 1 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 517 2 January January NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 517 3 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 517 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 517 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 518 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 518 2 Split split NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 518 3 or or CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 518 4 Steal steal VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 518 5 ? ? . en-wikipedia-org-1554 519 1 Cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 519 2 Behavior Behavior NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 519 3 When when WRB en-wikipedia-org-1554 519 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 519 5 Stakes stake NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 519 6 Are be VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 519 7 Large large JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 519 8 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 519 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 520 1 Management Management NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 520 2 Science Science NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 520 3 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 521 1 58 58 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 521 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 521 3 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 521 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 521 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 521 6 2–20 2–20 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 521 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 522 1 doi:10.1287 doi:10.1287 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 522 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 522 3 mnsc.1110.1413 mnsc.1110.1413 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 522 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 523 1 S2CID S2CID NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 523 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 523 3 1371739 1371739 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 523 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 524 1 SSRN SSRN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 524 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 524 3 1592456 1592456 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 524 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 525 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 525 2 Kümmerli Kümmerli NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 525 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 525 4 Rolf Rolf NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 525 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 2 ' ' `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 3 Snowdrift Snowdrift NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 4 ' ' '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 5 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 6 tops top NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 7 ' ' `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 8 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 9 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 10 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 11 ' ' '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 12 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 13 explaining explain VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 14 cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 15 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 526 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 527 1 Retrieved retrieve VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 527 2 11 11 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 527 3 April April NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 527 4 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 527 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 528 1 ^ ^ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 528 2 Robinson Robinson NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 528 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 528 4 D.R. D.R. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 529 1 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 529 2 Goforth Goforth NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 529 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 529 4 D.J. D.J. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 530 1 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 530 2 May May NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 530 3 5 5 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 530 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 530 5 2004 2004 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 530 6 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 530 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 1 Alibi Alibi NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 2 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 3 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 4 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 5 Asymmetric Asymmetric NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 6 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 7 ' ' POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 8 s s VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 9 Dilemmas Dilemmas NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 10 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 11 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 12 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 531 13 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 1 Meetings meeting NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 4 Canadian Canadian NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 5 Economics Economics NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 6 Association Association NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 7 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 8 Toronto Toronto NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 10 June June NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 11 4 4 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 12 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 13 6 6 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 15 2004 2004 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 532 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 1 ^ ^ NFP en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 2 Beckenkamp Beckenkamp NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 4 Martin Martin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 5 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 6 Hennig Hennig NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 7 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 8 Schmidt Schmidt NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 9 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 10 Heike Heike NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 11 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 12 Maier Maier NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 13 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 14 Rigaud Rigaud NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 15 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 16 Frank Frank NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 17 P. P. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 18 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 19 March March NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 20 4 4 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 21 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 22 2007 2007 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 23 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 533 24 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 2 Cooperation cooperation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 3 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 4 Symmetric Symmetric NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 5 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 6 Asymmetric Asymmetric NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 7 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 8 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 9 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 10 Games Games NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 11 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 12 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 13 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 14 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 534 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 535 1 Max Max NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 535 2 Planck Planck NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 535 3 Institute Institute NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 535 4 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 535 5 Research Research NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 535 6 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 535 7 Collective Collective NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 535 8 Goods Goods NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 535 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 536 1 Further further JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 536 2 reading[edit reading[edit LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 536 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 536 4 Amadae Amadae NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 536 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 536 6 S. S. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 536 7 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 536 8 2016 2016 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 536 9 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 536 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 537 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 537 2 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 537 3 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 537 4 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 537 5 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 537 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 537 7 Prisoners Prisoners NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 537 8 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 537 9 Reason Reason NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 537 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 538 1 Cambridge Cambridge NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 538 2 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 538 3 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 538 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 538 5 NY NY NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 538 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 538 7 pp pp NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 538 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 539 1 24–61 24–61 LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 539 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 540 1 Aumann Aumann NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 540 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 540 3 Robert Robert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 540 4 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 540 5 1959 1959 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 540 6 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 540 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 2 Acceptable acceptable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 3 points point NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 4 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 5 general general JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 6 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 7 n n JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 8 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 9 person person NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 10 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 11 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 541 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 542 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 542 2 Luce Luce NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 542 3 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 542 4 R. R. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 542 5 D. D. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 542 6 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 542 7 Tucker Tucker NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 542 8 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 542 9 A. a. NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 542 10 W. w. NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 543 1 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 543 2 eds eds NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 543 3 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 543 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 543 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 544 1 Contributions contribution NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 544 2 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 544 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 544 4 Theory Theory NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 544 5 23 23 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 544 6 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 544 7 Games Games NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 544 8 IV IV NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 544 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 545 1 Annals Annals NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 545 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 545 3 Mathematics Mathematics NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 545 4 Study Study NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 545 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 546 1 40 40 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 546 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 547 1 Princeton Princeton NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 547 2 NJ NJ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 547 3 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 547 4 Princeton Princeton NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 547 5 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 547 6 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 547 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 548 1 pp pp NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 548 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 549 1 287–324 287–324 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 549 2 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 550 1 MR MR NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 550 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 550 3 0104521 0104521 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 550 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 551 1 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 551 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 551 3 R. R. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 551 4 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 551 5 1984 1984 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 551 6 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 551 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 552 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 552 2 Evolution Evolution NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 552 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 552 4 Cooperation Cooperation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 552 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 1 ISBN ISBN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 3 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 5 465 465 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 7 02121 02121 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 8 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 9 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 10 Bicchieri Bicchieri NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 12 Cristina Cristina NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 13 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 14 1993 1993 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 15 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 553 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 554 1 Rationality Rationality NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 554 2 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 554 3 Coordination Coordination NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 554 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 555 1 Cambridge Cambridge NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 555 2 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 555 3 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 555 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 556 1 Chess Chess NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 556 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 556 3 David David NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 556 4 M. M. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 556 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 556 6 December December NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 556 7 1988 1988 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 556 8 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 556 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 2 Simulating simulate VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 4 evolution evolution NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 5 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 6 behavior behavior NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 7 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 9 iterated iterated JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 10 prisoners prisoner NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 11 ' ' POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 12 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 13 problem problem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 14 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 15 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 16 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 17 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 557 18 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 558 1 Complex Complex NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 558 2 Systems Systems NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 558 3 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 559 1 2 2 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 559 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 559 3 6 6 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 559 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 559 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 559 6 663–70 663–70 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 559 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 560 1 Dresher dresher NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 560 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 560 3 M. M. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 560 4 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 560 5 1961 1961 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 560 6 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 560 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 2 Mathematics Mathematics NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 4 Games Games NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 5 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 6 Strategy Strategy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 7 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 8 Theory Theory NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 9 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 10 Applications Applications NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 11 Prentice Prentice NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 12 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 13 Hall Hall NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 14 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 15 Englewood Englewood NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 16 Cliffs Cliffs NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 18 NJ NJ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 561 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 562 1 Greif Greif NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 562 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 562 3 A. a. NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 563 1 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 563 2 2006 2006 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 563 3 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 563 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 1 Institutions institution NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 2 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 3 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 4 Path path NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 5 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 6 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 7 Modern modern JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 8 Economy economy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 9 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 10 Lessons lesson NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 11 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 12 Medieval Medieval NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 13 Trade Trade NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 564 14 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 565 1 Cambridge Cambridge NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 565 2 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 565 3 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 565 4 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 565 5 Cambridge Cambridge NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 565 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 565 7 UK UK NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 565 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 566 1 Kopelman Kopelman NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 566 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 566 3 Shirli Shirli NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 566 4 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 566 5 February February NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 566 6 2020 2020 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 566 7 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 566 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 2 Tit tit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 3 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 4 tat tat NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 5 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 6 beyond beyond IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 7 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 9 legendary legendary JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 10 work work NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 11 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 12 Anatol Anatol NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 13 Rapoport Rapoport NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 14 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 567 15 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 568 1 Negotiation negotiation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 568 2 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 568 3 Conflict Conflict NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 568 4 Management Management NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 568 5 Research Research NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 568 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 569 1 13 13 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 569 2 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 569 3 1 1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 569 4 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 569 5 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 569 6 60–84 60–84 LS en-wikipedia-org-1554 569 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 570 1 doi:10.1111 doi:10.1111 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 570 2 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 570 3 ncmr.12172 ncmr.12172 NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 570 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 571 1 Poundstone Poundstone NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 571 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 571 3 William William NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 571 4 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 571 5 1993 1993 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 571 6 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 571 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 572 1 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 572 2 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 572 3 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 572 4 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 572 5 1st 1st NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 572 6 Anchor Anchor NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 572 7 Books Books NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 572 8 ed ed NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 572 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 572 10 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 572 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 573 1 New New NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 573 2 York York NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 573 3 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 573 4 Anchor Anchor NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 573 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 1 ISBN ISBN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 3 0 0 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 5 385 385 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 6 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 7 41580-X.CS1 41580-x.cs1 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 8 maint maint NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 9 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 10 ref ref NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 11 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 12 harv harv NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 13 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 14 link link NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 15 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 16 Rapoport Rapoport NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 17 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 18 Anatol Anatol NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 19 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 20 Albert Albert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 21 M. M. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 22 Chammah Chammah NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 23 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 24 1965 1965 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 25 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 574 26 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 575 1 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 575 2 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 575 3 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 575 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 576 1 University University NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 576 2 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 576 3 Michigan Michigan NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 576 4 Press Press NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 576 5 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 1 External External NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 2 links[edit links[edit , en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 3 ] ] -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 4 Media medium NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 5 related relate VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 6 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 7 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 8 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 9 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 10 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 11 Wikimedia Wikimedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 12 Commons Commons NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 13 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 14 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 15 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 16 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 17 Stanford Stanford NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 18 Encyclopedia Encyclopedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 19 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 20 Philosophy Philosophy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 21 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 22 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 23 Bowerbird Bowerbird NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 24 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 25 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 26 The The NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 27 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 28 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 29 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 30 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 31 ornithology ornithology NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 32   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 33 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 34 mathematical mathematical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 35 cartoon cartoon NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 36 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 37 Larry Larry NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 38 Gonick Gonick NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 577 39 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 1 The the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 2 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 3 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 4 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 5 The The NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 6 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 7 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 8 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 9 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 10 Lego Lego NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 11 minifigures minifigure NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 578 12 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 579 1 Dixit Dixit NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 579 2 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 579 3 Avinash Avinash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 579 4 ; ; : en-wikipedia-org-1554 579 5 Nalebuff Nalebuff NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 579 6 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 579 7 Barry Barry NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 579 8 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 579 9 2008 2008 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 579 10 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 579 11 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 580 1 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 580 2 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 580 3 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 580 4 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 580 5 " " '' en-wikipedia-org-1554 580 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 581 1 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 581 2 David David NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 581 3 R. R. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 581 4 Henderson Henderson NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 581 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 581 6 ed ed NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 581 7 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 581 8 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 581 9 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 582 1 Concise Concise NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 582 2 Encyclopedia Encyclopedia NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 582 3 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 582 4 Economics Economics NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 582 5 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 582 6 2nd 2nd NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 582 7 ed ed NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 582 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 582 9 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 582 10 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 583 1 Indianapolis Indianapolis NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 583 2 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 583 3 Library Library NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 583 4 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 583 5 Economics Economics NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 583 6 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 583 7 Liberty Liberty NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 583 8 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 584 1 ISBN ISBN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 584 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 584 3 978 978 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 584 4 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 584 5 0865976658 0865976658 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 584 6 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 585 1 OCLC oclc NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 585 2   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 585 3 237794267 237794267 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 585 4 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 2 Theory Theory NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 3 101 101 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 4 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 5 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 6 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 7 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 8 Dawkins dawkin VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 9 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 10 Nice Nice NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 11 Guys guy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 12 Finish finish VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 13 First First NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 14 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 15 Iterated Iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 16 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 17 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 18 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 19 Python Python NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 20 library library NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 21 Play play VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 22 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 23 Iterated Iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 24 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 25 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 26 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 27 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 28 gametheorygames.nl gametheorygames.nl ADD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 29 Play Play NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 30 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 31 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 32 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 33 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 34 oTree oTree NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 35 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 36 N N NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 37 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 38 A A NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 39 11 11 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 40 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 41 5 5 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 42 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 43 17 17 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 44 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 45 Nicky Nicky NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 46 Case Case NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 47 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 48 Evolution Evolution NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 49 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 50 Trust Trust NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 51 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 52 an an DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 53 example example NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 54 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 55 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 56 donation donation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 57 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 58 Iterated Iterated NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 59 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 60 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 61 Dilemma Dilemma NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 62 online online JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 63 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 64 by by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 65 Wayne Wayne NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 66 Davis Davis NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 67 v v IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 68 t t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 69 e e NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 70 Paradoxes Paradoxes NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 71 Philosophical Philosophical NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 72 Analysis Analysis NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 73 Buridan Buridan NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 74 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 75 bridge bridge NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 76 Dream Dream NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 77 argument argument NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 78 Epicurean Epicurean NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 79 Fiction Fiction NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 80 Fitch Fitch NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 81 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 82 knowability knowability NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 83 Free Free NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 84 will will MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 85 Goodman Goodman NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 86 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 87 Hedonism Hedonism NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 88 Liberal Liberal NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 89 Meno Meno NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 90 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 91 Mere Mere NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 92 addition addition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 93 Moore Moore NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 94 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 95 Newcomb Newcomb NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 96 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 97 Nihilism Nihilism NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 98 Omnipotence Omnipotence NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 99 Preface Preface NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 100 Rule Rule NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 101 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 102 following follow VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 103 White white JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 104 horse horse NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 105 Zeno Zeno NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 106 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 107 Logical Logical NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 108 Self self NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 109 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 110 reference reference NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 111 Barber Barber NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 112 Berry Berry NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 113 Bhartrhari Bhartrhari NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 114 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 115 Burali Burali NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 116 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 117 Forti Forti NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 118 Court Court NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 119 Crocodile Crocodile NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 120 Curry Curry NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 121 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 122 Epimenides Epimenides NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 123 Grelling Grelling NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 124 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 125 Nelson Nelson NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 126 Kleene Kleene NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 127 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 128 Rosser Rosser NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 129 Liar Liar NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 130 Card Card NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 131 No no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 132 - - : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 133 no no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 134 Pinocchio Pinocchio NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 135 Quine Quine NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 136 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 137 Yablo Yablo NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 138 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 139 Opposite Opposite NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 140 Day Day NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 141 Richard Richard NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 142 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 143 Russell Russell NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 144 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 145 Socratic Socratic NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 146 Hilbert Hilbert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 147 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 148 Hotel Hotel NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 149 Vagueness Vagueness NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 150 Theseus Theseus NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 151 ' ' POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 152 ship ship NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 153 List list NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 154 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 155 examples example NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 156 Sorites sorite VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 157 Others other NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 158 Barbershop Barbershop NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 159 Catch-22 Catch-22 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 160 Drinker Drinker NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 161 Entailment Entailment NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 162 Lottery Lottery NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 163 Plato Plato NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 164 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 165 beard beard NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 166 Raven Raven NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 167 Ross Ross NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 168 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 169 Unexpected unexpected JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 170 hanging hanging NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 171 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 172 What what WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 173 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 174 Tortoise Tortoise NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 175 Said say VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 176 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 177 Achilles Achilles NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 178 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 179 Heat Heat NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 180 death death NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 181 paradox paradox NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 182 Olbers olber NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 183 ' ' POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 184 paradox paradox NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 185 Economic Economic NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 186 Allais Allais NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 187 Antitrust Antitrust NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 188 Arrow Arrow NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 189 information information NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 190 Bertrand Bertrand NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 191 Braess Braess NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 192 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 193 Competition Competition NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 194 Income Income NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 195 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 196 fertility fertility NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 197 Downs down NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 198 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 199 Thomson Thomson NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 200 Easterlin Easterlin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 201 Edgeworth Edgeworth NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 202 Ellsberg Ellsberg NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 203 European European NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 204 Gibson Gibson NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 205 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 206 Giffen Giffen NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 207 good good JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 208 Icarus Icarus NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 209 Jevons Jevons NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 210 Leontief Leontief NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 211 Lucas Lucas NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 212 Mandeville Mandeville NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 213 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 214 Mayfield Mayfield NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 215 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 216 Metzler Metzler NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 217 Plenty Plenty NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 218 Productivity Productivity NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 219 Prosperity Prosperity NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 220 Scitovsky Scitovsky NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 221 Service Service NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 222 recovery recovery NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 223 St. St. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 224 Petersburg Petersburg NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 225 Thrift Thrift NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 226 Toil Toil NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 227 Tullock Tullock NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 228 Value Value NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 229 Decision Decision NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 230 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 231 Abilene Abilene NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 232 Apportionment Apportionment NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 233 Alabama Alabama NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 234 New New NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 235 states state VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 236 Population Population NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 237 Arrow Arrow NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 238 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 239 Buridan Buridan NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 240 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 241 ass ass NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 242 Chainstore Chainstore NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 243 Condorcet Condorcet NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 244 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 245 Decision decision NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 246 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 247 making make VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 248 Downs Downs NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 249 Ellsberg Ellsberg NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 250 Fenno Fenno NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 251 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 252 Fredkin Fredkin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 253 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 254 Green Green NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 255 Hedgehog Hedgehog NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 256 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 257 Inventor Inventor NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 258 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 259 Kavka Kavka NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 260 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 261 toxin toxin NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 262 puzzle puzzle NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 263 Morton Morton NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 264 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 265 fork fork NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 266 Navigation Navigation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 267 Newcomb Newcomb NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 268 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 269 Parrondo Parrondo NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 270 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 271 Prevention Prevention NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 272 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 273 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 274 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 275 Tolerance Tolerance NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 276 Willpower Willpower NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 277 List List NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 278 Category Category NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 279 Book Book NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 280 v v NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 281 t t NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 282 e e NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 283 Topics Topics NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 284 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 285 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 286 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 287 Definitions definition NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 288 Cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 289 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 290 Determinacy Determinacy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 291 Escalation Escalation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 292 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 293 commitment commitment JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 294 Extensive extensive JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 295 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 296 form form NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 297 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 298 First first JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 299 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 300 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 301 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 302 second second JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 303 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 304 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 305 win win NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 306 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 307 complexity complexity NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 308 Graphical graphical JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 309 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 310 Hierarchy Hierarchy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 311 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 312 beliefs belief NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 313 Information information NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 314 set set VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 315 Normal normal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 316 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 317 form form NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 318 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 319 Preference Preference NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 320 Sequential Sequential NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 321 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 322 Simultaneous simultaneous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 323 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 324 Simultaneous simultaneous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 325 action action NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 326 selection selection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 327 Solved solved JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 328 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 329 Succinct succinct JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 330 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 331 Equilibrium Equilibrium NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 332 concepts concept VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 333 Nash Nash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 334 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 335 Subgame subgame NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 336 perfection perfection NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 337 Mertens Mertens NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 338 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 339 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 340 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 341 Bayesian Bayesian NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 342 Nash Nash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 343 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 344 Perfect perfect JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 345 Bayesian bayesian JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 346 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 347 Trembling tremble VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 348 hand hand NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 349 Proper proper JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 350 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 351 Epsilon epsilon NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 352 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 353 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 354 Correlated correlate VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 355 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 356 Sequential sequential JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 357 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 358 Quasi Quasi NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 359 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 360 perfect perfect JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 361 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 362 Evolutionarily evolutionarily RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 363 stable stable JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 364 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 365 Risk risk NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 366 dominance dominance NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 367 Core Core NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 368 Shapley Shapley NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 369 value value NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 370 Pareto Pareto NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 371 efficiency efficiency NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 372 Gibbs Gibbs NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 373 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 374 Quantal quantal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 375 response response NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 376 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 377 Self self NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 378 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 379 confirming confirm VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 380 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 381 Strong Strong NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 382 Nash Nash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 383 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 384 Markov Markov NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 385 perfect perfect JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 386 equilibrium equilibrium NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 387 Strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 388 Dominant dominant JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 389 strategies strategy NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 390 Pure pure JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 391 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 392 Mixed mixed JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 393 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 394 Strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 395 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 396 stealing steal VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 397 argument argument NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 398 Tit Tit NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 399 for for IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 400 tat tat NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 401 Grim Grim NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 402 trigger trigger NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 403 Collusion Collusion NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 404 Backward Backward NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 405 induction induction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 406 Forward Forward NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 407 induction induction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 408 Markov Markov NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 409 strategy strategy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 410 Bid Bid NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 411 shading shade VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 412 Classes class NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 413 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 414 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 415 Symmetric symmetric JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 416 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 417 Perfect perfect JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 418 information information NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 419 Repeated repeat VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 420 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 421 Signaling signal VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 422 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 423 Screening screening NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 424 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 425 Cheap cheap JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 426 talk talk NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 427 Zero zero CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 428 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 429 sum sum NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 430 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 431 Mechanism Mechanism NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 432 design design NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 433 Bargaining bargaining NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 434 problem problem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 435 Stochastic stochastic JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 436 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 437 Mean mean JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 438 field field NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 439 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 440 n n NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 441 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 442 player player NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 443 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 444 Large large JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 445 Poisson Poisson NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 446 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 447 Nontransitive Nontransitive NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 448 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 449 Global global JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 450 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 451 Strictly strictly RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 452 determined determine VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 453 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 454 Potential potential JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 455 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 456 Games Games NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 457 Go Go NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 458 Chess Chess NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 459 Infinite Infinite NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 460 chess chess NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 461 Checkers Checkers NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 462 Tic Tic NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 463 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 464 tac tac NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 465 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 466 toe toe NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 467 Prisoner Prisoner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 468 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 469 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 470 Gift Gift NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 471 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 472 exchange exchange NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 473 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 474 Optional optional JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 475 prisoner prisoner NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 476 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 477 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 478 Traveler Traveler NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 479 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 480 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 481 Coordination Coordination NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 482 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 483 Chicken Chicken NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 484 Centipede Centipede NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 485 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 486 Volunteer Volunteer NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 487 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 488 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 489 Dollar Dollar NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 490 auction auction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 491 Battle Battle NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 492 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 493 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 494 sexes sex NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 495 Stag stag JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 496 hunt hunt NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 497 Matching Matching NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 498 pennies penny NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 499 Ultimatum Ultimatum NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 500 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 501 Rock Rock NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 502 paper paper NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 503 scissors scissor NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 504 Pirate Pirate NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 505 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 506 Dictator Dictator NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 507 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 508 Public public JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 509 goods good NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 510 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 511 Blotto Blotto NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 512 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 513 War War NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 514 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 515 attrition attrition NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 516 El El NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 517 Farol Farol NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 518 Bar Bar NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 519 problem problem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 520 Fair Fair NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 521 division division NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 522 Fair fair JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 523 cake cake NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 524 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 525 cutting cut VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 526 Cournot Cournot NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 527 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 528 Deadlock Deadlock NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 529 Diner Diner NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 530 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 531 dilemma dilemma NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 532 Guess Guess NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 533 2/3 2/3 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 534 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 535 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 536 average average JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 537 Kuhn Kuhn NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 538 poker poker NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 539 Nash Nash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 540 bargaining bargaining NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 541 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 542 Induction Induction NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 543 puzzles puzzle NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 544 Trust Trust NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 545 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 546 Princess Princess NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 547 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 548 Monster Monster NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 549 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 550 Rendezvous rendezvous JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 551 problem problem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 552 Theorems Theorems NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 553 Arrow Arrow NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 554 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 555 impossibility impossibility NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 556 theorem theorem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 557 Aumann Aumann NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 558 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 559 agreement agreement NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 560 theorem theorem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 561 Folk Folk NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 562 theorem theorem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 563 Minimax Minimax NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 564 theorem theorem NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 565 Nash Nash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 566 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 567 theorem theorem JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 568 Purification Purification NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 569 theorem theorem JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 570 Revelation Revelation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 571 principle principle NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 572 Zermelo Zermelo NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 573 's 's POS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 574 theorem theorem JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 575 Key key JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 576 figures figure NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 577 Albert Albert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 578 W. W. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 579 Tucker Tucker NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 580 Amos Amos NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 581 Tversky Tversky NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 582 Antoine Antoine NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 583 Augustin Augustin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 584 Cournot Cournot NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 585 Ariel Ariel NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 586 Rubinstein Rubinstein NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 587 Claude Claude NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 588 Shannon Shannon NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 589 Daniel Daniel NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 590 Kahneman Kahneman NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 591 David David NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 592 K. K. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 593 Levine Levine NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 594 David David NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 595 M. M. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 596 Kreps Kreps NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 597 Donald Donald NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 598 B. B. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 599 Gillies Gillies NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 600 Drew Drew NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 601 Fudenberg Fudenberg NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 602 Eric Eric NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 603 Maskin Maskin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 604 Harold Harold NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 605 W. W. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 606 Kuhn Kuhn NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 607 Herbert Herbert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 608 Simon Simon NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 609 Hervé Hervé NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 610 Moulin Moulin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 611 Jean Jean NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 612 Tirole Tirole NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 613 Jean Jean NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 614 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 615 François François NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 616 Mertens Mertens NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 617 Jennifer Jennifer NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 618 Tour Tour NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 619 Chayes Chayes NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 620 John John NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 621 Harsanyi Harsanyi NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 622 John John NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 623 Maynard Maynard NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 624 Smith Smith NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 625 John John NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 626 Nash Nash NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 627 John John NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 628 von von NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 629 Neumann Neumann NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 630 Kenneth Kenneth NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 631 Arrow Arrow NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 632 Kenneth Kenneth NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 633 Binmore Binmore NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 634 Leonid Leonid NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 635 Hurwicz Hurwicz NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 636 Lloyd Lloyd NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 637 Shapley Shapley NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 638 Melvin Melvin NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 639 Dresher Dresher NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 640 Merrill Merrill NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 641 M. M. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 642 Flood Flood NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 643 Olga Olga NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 644 Bondareva Bondareva NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 645 Oskar Oskar NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 646 Morgenstern Morgenstern NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 647 Paul Paul NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 648 Milgrom Milgrom NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 649 Peyton Peyton NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 650 Young Young NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 651 Reinhard Reinhard NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 652 Selten Selten NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 653 Robert Robert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 654 Axelrod Axelrod NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 655 Robert Robert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 656 Aumann Aumann NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 657 Robert Robert NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 658 B. B. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 659 Wilson Wilson NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 660 Roger Roger NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 661 Myerson Myerson NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 662 Samuel Samuel NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 663 Bowles Bowles NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 664 Suzanne Suzanne NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 665 Scotchmer Scotchmer NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 666 Thomas Thomas NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 667 Schelling Schelling NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 668 William William NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 669 Vickrey Vickrey NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 670 See see VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 671 also also RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 672 All all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 673 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 674 pay pay VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 675 auction auction NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 676 Alpha alpha NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 677 – – : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 678 beta beta NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 679 pruning prune VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 680 Bertrand Bertrand NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 681 paradox paradox NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 682 Bounded bound VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 683 rationality rationality NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 684 Combinatorial combinatorial JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 685 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 686 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 687 Confrontation Confrontation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 688 analysis analysis NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 689 Coopetition Coopetition NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 690 Evolutionary Evolutionary NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 691 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 692 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 693 First first JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 694 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 695 move move NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 696 advantage advantage NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 697 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 698 chess chess NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 699 Game Game NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 700 mechanics mechanic NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 701 Glossary Glossary NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 702 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 703 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 704 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 705 List List NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 706 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 707 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 708 theorists theorist NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 709 List List NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 710 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 711 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 712 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 713 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 714 theory theory NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 715 No no DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 716 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 717 win win NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 718 situation situation NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 719 Solving solve VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 720 chess chess NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 721 Topological topological JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 722 game game NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 723 Tragedy Tragedy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 724 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 725 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 726 commons common NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 727 Tyranny tyranny NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 728 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 729 small small JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 730 decisions decision NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 731 Authority Authority NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 732 control control NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 733 BNE BNE NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 734 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 735 XX550497 XX550497 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 736 BNF BNF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 737 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 738 cb12526229f cb12526229f NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 739 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 740 data datum NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 741 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 742 GND GND NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 743 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 744 4139587 4139587 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 745 - - SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 746 6 6 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 747 LCCN LCCN NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 748 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 749 sh85106969 sh85106969 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 750 SUDOC SUDOC NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 751 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 752 034513272 034513272 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 753 Retrieved retrieve VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 754 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 755 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 756 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Prisoner%27s_dilemma&oldid=993781792 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Prisoner%27s_dilemma&oldid=993781792 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 757 " " `` en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 758 Categories category NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 759 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 760 Non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 761 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 762 cooperative cooperative JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 763 games game NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 764 Thought think VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 765 experiments experiment NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 766 Dilemmas Dilemmas NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 767 Environmental environmental JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 768 studies study VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 769 Social social JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 770 psychology psychology NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 771 Moral moral JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 772 psychology psychology NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 773 Hidden hide VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 774 categories category NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 775 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 776 Articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 777 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 778 short short JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 779 description description NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 780 Short short JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 781 description description NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 782 matches match VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 783 Wikidata Wikidata NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 784 Articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 785 needing need VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 786 additional additional JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 787 references reference NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 788 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 789 November November NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 790 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 791 All all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 792 articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 793 needing need VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 794 additional additional JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 795 references reference NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 796 Articles Articles NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 797 needing need VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 798 more more RBR en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 799 detailed detailed JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 800 references reference NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 801 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 802 articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 803 needing need VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 804 clarification clarification NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 805 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 806 August August NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 807 2016 2016 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 808 All all DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 809 articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 810 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 811 unsourced unsourced JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 812 statements statement NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 813 Articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 814 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 815 unsourced unsourced JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 816 statements statement NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 817 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 818 December December NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 819 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 820 Articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 821 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 822 unsourced unsourced JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 823 statements statement NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 824 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 825 November November NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 826 2012 2012 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 827 Articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 828 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 829 unsourced unsourced JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 830 statements statement NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 831 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 832 April April NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 833 2020 2020 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 834 CS1 CS1 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 835 maint maint NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 836 : : : en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 837 ref ref NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 838 = = SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 839 harv harv NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 840 Commons Commons NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 841 category category NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 842 link link NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 843 from from IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 844 Wikidata Wikidata NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 845 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 846 articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 847 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 848 BNE BNE NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 849 identifiers identifier NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 850 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 851 articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 852 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 853 BNF BNF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 854 identifiers identifier NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 855 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 856 articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 857 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 858 GND GND NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 859 identifiers identifier NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 860 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 861 articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 862 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 863 LCCN LCCN NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 864 identifiers identifier NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 865 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 866 articles article NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 867 with with IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 868 SUDOC SUDOC NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 869 identifiers identifier NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 870 Navigation Navigation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 871 menu menu NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 872 Personal personal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 873 tools tool NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 874 Not not RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 875 logged log VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 876 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 877 Talk Talk NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 878 Contributions Contributions NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 879 Create Create NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 880 account account NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 881 Log Log NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 882 in in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 883 Namespaces Namespaces NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 884 Article Article NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 885 Talk talk NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 886 Variants variant VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 887 Views view NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 888 Read read VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 889 Edit edit NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 890 View View NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 891 history history NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 892 More More JJR en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 893 Search Search NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 894 Navigation Navigation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 895 Main Main NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 896 page page NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 897 Contents content VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 898 Current current JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 899 events event NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 900 Random random JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 901 article article NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 902 About about IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 903 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 904 Contact Contact NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 905 us -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 906 Donate Donate NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 907 Contribute contribute NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 908 Help help NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 909 Learn learn VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 910 to to TO en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 911 edit edit VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 912 Community community NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 913 portal portal JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 914 Recent recent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 915 changes change NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 916 Upload upload JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 917 file file NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 918 Tools tool NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 919 What what WP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 920 links link NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 921 here here RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 922 Related relate VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 923 changes change VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 924 Upload upload JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 925 file file VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 926 Special special JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 927 pages page NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 928 Permanent permanent JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 929 link link NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 930 Page Page NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 931 information information NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 932 Cite cite VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 933 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 934 page page NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 935 Wikidata wikidata NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 936 item item NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 937 Print print NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 938 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 939 export export NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 940 Download Download NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 941 as as IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 942 PDF PDF NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 943 Printable Printable NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 944 version version NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 945 In in IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 946 other other JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 947 projects project NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 948 Wikimedia Wikimedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 949 Commons Commons NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 950 Wikiquote Wikiquote NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 951 Languages Languages NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 952 العربية العربية NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 953 Български Български NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 954 Català Català NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 955 Čeština Čeština NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 956 Cymraeg Cymraeg NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 957 Dansk Dansk NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 958 Deutsch Deutsch NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 959 Eesti Eesti NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 960 Ελληνικά Ελληνικά NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 961 Español Español NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 962 Esperanto Esperanto NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 963 Euskara Euskara NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 964 فارسی فارسی JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 965 Français Français NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 966 Galego Galego NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 967 한국어 한국어 NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 968 हिन्दी हिन्दी NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 969 Hrvatski Hrvatski NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 970 Ido Ido NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 971 Bahasa Bahasa NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 972 Indonesia Indonesia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 973 Íslenska Íslenska NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 974 Italiano Italiano NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 975 עברית עברית NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 976 ქართული ქართული NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 977 Latina Latina NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 978 Latviešu Latviešu NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 979 Lietuvių Lietuvių NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 980 Magyar Magyar NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 981 Nederlands Nederlands NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 982 日本語 日本語 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 983 Norsk Norsk NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 984 bokmål bokmål NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 985 Occitan Occitan NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 986 ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਪੰਜਾਬੀ NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 987 Polski Polski NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 988 Português Português NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 989 Română Română NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 990 Русский Русский NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 991 Simple Simple NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 992 English English NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 993 Slovenčina Slovenčina NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 994 Slovenščina Slovenščina NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 995 Српски Српски NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 996 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 997 srpski srpski JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 998 Srpskohrvatski Srpskohrvatski NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 999 / / SYM en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1000 српскохрватски српскохрватски NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1001 Suomi Suomi NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1002 Svenska Svenska NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1003 Tagalog Tagalog NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1004 தமிழ் தமிழ் , en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1005 ไทย ไทย NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1006 Türkçe Türkçe NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1007 Українська Українська NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1008 اردو اردو NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1009 Tiếng Tiếng NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1010 Việt Việt NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1011 粵語 粵語 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1012 中文 中文 NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1013 Edit Edit NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1014 links link NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1015 This this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1016 page page NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1017 was be VBD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1018 last last RB en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1019 edited edit VBN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1020 on on IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1021 12 12 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1022 December December NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1023 2020 2020 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1024 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1025 at at IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1026 13:40 13:40 CD en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1027   _SP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1028 ( ( -LRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1029 UTC UTC NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1030 ) ) -RRB- en-wikipedia-org-1554 586 1031 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 1 Text text NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 2 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 3 available available JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 4 under under IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 5 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 6 Creative Creative NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 7 Commons Commons NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 8 Attribution Attribution NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 9 - - HYPH en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 10 ShareAlike ShareAlike NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 11 License License NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 12 ; ; , en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 13 additional additional JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 14 terms term NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 15 may may MD en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 16 apply apply VB en-wikipedia-org-1554 587 17 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 1 By by IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 2 using use VBG en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 3 this this DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 4 site site NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 5 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 6 you -PRON- PRP en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 7 agree agree VBP en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 8 to to IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 9 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 10 Terms term NNS en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 11 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 12 Use Use NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 13 and and CC en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 14 Privacy Privacy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 15 Policy Policy NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 588 16 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 1 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 2 ® ® NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 3 is be VBZ en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 4 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 5 registered registered JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 6 trademark trademark NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 7 of of IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 8 the the DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 9 Wikimedia Wikimedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 10 Foundation Foundation NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 11 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 12 Inc. Inc. NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 13 , , , en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 14 a a DT en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 15 non non JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 16 - - JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 17 profit profit JJ en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 18 organization organization NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 589 19 . . . en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 1 Privacy privacy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 2 policy policy NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 3 About about IN en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 4 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 5 Disclaimers Disclaimers NNPS en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 6 Contact Contact NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 7 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 8 Mobile Mobile NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 9 view view NN en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 10 Developers Developers NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 11 Statistics Statistics NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 12 Cookie Cookie NNP en-wikipedia-org-1554 590 13 statement statement NN