Ethics of uncertain sentience - Wikipedia Ethics of uncertain sentience From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Jump to navigation Jump to search Applied ethics issue Ethical questions around whether crustaceans, such as lobsters, are sentient and can experience pain, are a topic of much debate The ethics of uncertain sentience refers to questions surrounding the treatment of and moral obligations towards individuals whose sentience—the capacity to subjectively sense and feel—and resulting ability to experience pain is uncertain; the topic has been particularly discussed within the field of animal ethics, with the precautionary principle frequently invoked in response. Contents 1 Views 1.1 Animal ethics 1.2 Environmental ethics 1.3 Ethics of artificial intelligence 1.4 Neuroethics 2 See also 3 References Views[edit] Animal ethics[edit] David Foster Wallace in his 2005 essay "Consider the Lobster" investigated the potential sentience and capacity of crustaceans to experience pain and the resulting ethical implications of eating them.[1][2] In 2014, the philosopher Robert C. Jones explored the ethical question that Wallace raised, arguing that "[e]ven if one remains skeptical of crustacean sentience, when it comes to issues of welfare it would be most prudent to employ the precautionary principle regarding our treatment of these animals, erring on the side of caution".[3] Maximilian Padden Elder takes a similar view regarding the capacity for fishes to feel pain, arguing that the "precautionary principle is the moral ethic one ought to adopt in the face of uncertainty".[4] In the 2015 essay "Reconsider the Lobster", Jeff Sebo quotes Wallace's discussion of the difficulty of establishing whether an animal can experience pain.[5] Sebo calls the question of how to treat individuals of uncertain sentience, the "sentience problem" and argues that this problem which "Wallace raises deserves much more philosophical attention than it currently receives."[5] Sebo asserts that there are two motivating assumptions behind the problem: "sentientism about moral status"—the idea that if an individual is sentient, that they deserve moral consideration—and "uncertainty about other minds", which refers to scientific and philosophical uncertainty about which individuals are sentient.[5] In response to the problem, Sebo lays out three different potential approaches: the incautionary principle, which postulates that in cases of uncertainty about sentience it is morally permissible to treat individuals as if they are not sentient; the precautionary principle, which suggests that in such cases we have a moral obligation to treat them as if they are sentient; and the expected value principle, which asserts that we are "morally required to multiply our credence that they are by the amount of moral value they would have if they were, and to treat the product of this equation as the amount of moral value that they actually have". Sebo advocates for the latter position.[5][6] Jonathan Birch, in answer to the question surrounding animal sentience, advocates for a practical framework based on the precautionary principle, arguing that the framework aligns well with conventional practices in animal welfare science.[7] Simon Knutsson and Christian Munthe argue that from the perspective of virtue ethics, that when it comes to animals of uncertain sentience, such as "fish, invertebrates such as crustaceans, snails and insects", that it is a "requirement of a morally decent (or virtuous) person that she at least pays attention to and is cautious regarding the possibly morally relevant aspects of such animals".[8] Shelley A. Adamo argues that although the precautionary principle in relation to potential invertebrate sentience is the safest option, that it's not cost-free, as thoughtless legislation employed following the precautionary principle could be economically costly and that, as a result, we should be cautious about adopting it.[9] Environmental ethics[edit] Kai Chan advocates for an environmental ethic, which is a form of ethical extensionism applied to all living beings because "there is a non-zero probability of sentience and consciousness" and that "we cannot justify excluding beings from consideration on the basis of uncertainty of their sentience".[10] Ethics of artificial intelligence[edit] Nick Bostrom and Eliezer Yudkowsky argue that if an artificial intelligence is sentient, that it is wrong to inflict unnecessary pain on them, in the same way that it is wrong to inflict pain on an animal, unless there are "sufficiently strong morally overriding reasons to do so".[11] They also advocate for the "Principle of Substrate Non-Discrimination", which asserts that "[i]f two beings have the same functionality and the same conscious experience, and differ only in the substrate of their implementation, then they have the same moral status."[11] Neuroethics[edit] Adam J. Shriver argues for "precise, precautionary, and probabilistic approaches to sentience" and asserts that the evidence provided by neuroscience has differing relevance to each; he concludes that basic protections for animals should be guided by the precautionary principle and that although neuroscientific evidence in certain instances is not necessary to indicate that individuals of certain species require protections, "ongoing search for the neural correlates of sentience must be pursued in order to avoid harms that occur from mistaken accounts."[12] See also[edit] Animal consciousness Ethics of eating meat Pain in animals Pain in amphibians Pain in cephalopods Pain in invertebrates Pain in fish Sentiocentrism References[edit] ^ Elder, Maximilian Padden (2014). "The Fish Pain Debate: Broadening Humanity's Moral Horizon". Journal of Animal Ethics. 4 (2): 16–29. doi:10.5406/janimalethics.4.2.0016. ISSN 2156-5414. JSTOR 10.5406/janimalethics.4.2.0016. ^ Wallace, David Foster (August 2004). "Consider the Lobster" (PDF). Gourmet. pp. 50–64. Retrieved 2020-07-30. ^ Jones, Robert C. (2014). "The Lobster Considered". In Korb, Scott; Bolger, Robert K. (eds.). Gesturing Toward Reality: David Foster Wallace and Philosophy (PDF). New York: Bloomsbury. pp. 87–106. ISBN 978-1-4411-2835-5. OCLC 857981573. ^ Elder, Maximilian Padden (2014). "The Fish Pain Debate: Broadening Humanity's Moral Horizon". Journal of Animal Ethics. 4 (2): 16–29. doi:10.5406/janimalethics.4.2.0016. ISSN 2156-5414. JSTOR 10.5406/janimalethics.4.2.0016. ^ a b c d Sebo, Jeff (2015-09-09). "Reconsider the Lobster". What's Wrong?. Retrieved 2020-07-30. ^ Sebo, Jeff (2018-05-23). "The Moral Problem of Other Minds" (PDF). The Harvard Review of Philosophy. 25: 51–70. doi:10.5840/harvardreview20185913. S2CID 212633342. Retrieved 2020-07-30. ^ Birch, Jonathan (2017-01-01). "Animal sentience and the precautionary principle". Animal Sentience. 2 (16). ISSN 2377-7478. ^ Knutsson, Simon; Munthe, Christian (2017-04-01). "A Virtue of Precaution Regarding the Moral Status of Animals with Uncertain Sentience". Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics. 30 (2): 213–224. doi:10.1007/s10806-017-9662-y. ISSN 1573-322X. S2CID 149006196. ^ Adamo, Shelley Anne (2016-08-01). "Do insects feel pain? A question at the intersection of animal behaviour, philosophy and robotics". Animal Behaviour. 118: 75–79. doi:10.1016/j.anbehav.2016.05.005. ISSN 0003-3472. S2CID 53167462. ^ Chan, Kai M.A. (2011-08-01). "Ethical Extensionism under Uncertainty of Sentience: Duties to Non-Human Organisms without Drawing a Line". Environmental Values. 20 (3): 323–346. doi:10.3197/096327111X13077055165983. hdl:2429/45342. ^ a b Bostrom, Nick; Yudkowsky, Eliezer (2014), Frankish, Keith; Ramsey, William M. (eds.), "The ethics of artificial intelligence" (PDF), The Cambridge Handbook of Artificial Intelligence, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 316–334, doi:10.1017/cbo9781139046855.020, ISBN 978-1-139-04685-5, retrieved 2020-07-30 ^ Shriver, Adam J. (2020), Johnson, L. Syd M.; Fenton, Andrew; Shriver, Adam (eds.), "The Role of Neuroscience in Precise, Precautionary, and Probabilistic Accounts of Sentience", Neuroethics and Nonhuman Animals, Wellcome Trust–Funded Monographs and Book Chapters, Cham (CH): Springer, pp. 221–233, doi:10.1007/978-3-030-31011-0_13, ISBN 978-3-030-31010-3, PMID 32223121, retrieved 2020-07-30 v t e Animal rights Topics (overviews, concepts, issues, cases) Overviews Animal rights movement Animal rights by country or territory Anarchism and animal rights Animal rights and punk subculture Animal rights and the Holocaust Animal rights in Jainism, Hinduism, and Buddhism Christianity and animal rights Moral status of animals in the ancient world Timeline of animal welfare and rights Universal Declaration on Animal Welfare Concepts Abolitionism Ahimsa Animal cognition Animal consciousness Animal ethics Animal law Animal protectionism Animal welfare Animal-free agriculture Anthrozoology Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness Carnism Equal consideration of interests Ethics of eating meat Ethics of uncertain sentience Ethology Meat paradox Nonviolence Open rescue Opposition to hunting Personism Sentientism Sentiocentrism Speciesism Veganism Vegaphobia Vegetarianism Issues Animal agriculture Animal product Battery cage Bile bear Chick culling Concentrated animal feeding operation Fish farming Fur farming Fur trade Insect farming Intensive animal farming Intensive pig farming Livestock Poultry farming Slaughterhouse Wildlife farming Animal testing Animal testing on non-human primates Animal testing regulations Covance Great ape research ban Green Scare Huntingdon Life Sciences Model organism Nafovanny Operation Backfire Animal welfare Animal euthanasia Cruelty to animals Pain in animals Pain in amphibians Pain in cephalopods Pain in crustaceans Pain in fish Pain in invertebrates Pain and suffering in laboratory animals Welfare of farmed insects Fishing Commercial fishing Fishing bait Recreational fishing Wild animals Culling wildlife Hunting International primate trade Ivory trade Predation problem Wild animal suffering Wildlife management Other Abandoned pets Animal sacrifice Animals in sport Live food Cases Brown Dog affair Cambridge University primates McLibel case Pit of despair Silver Spring monkeys University of California, Riverside 1985 laboratory raid Unnecessary Fuss Advocates (academics, writers, activists) Academics and writers Contemporary Carol J. Adams Kristin Andrews Tom Beauchamp Marc Bekoff Steven Best Paola Cavalieri Stephen R. L. Clark Alasdair Cochrane J. M. Coetzee Alice Crary David DeGrazia Sue Donaldson Josephine Donovan Lawrence Finsen Gary L. Francione Robert Garner Valéry Giroux John Hadley Oscar Horta Melanie Joy Hilda Kean Will Kymlicka Thomas Lepeltier Andrew Linzey Clair Linzey Dan Lyons Martha Nussbaum David Pearce Siobhan O'Sullivan Clare Palmer Bernard Rollin Mark Rowlands Richard D. Ryder Peter Singer Steve F. Sapontzis Jeff Sebo Gary Steiner Cass Sunstein David J. Wolfson Corey Lee Wrenn Historical David Renaud Boullier Peter Buchan Mona Caird Priscilla Cohn Henry Crowe Herman Daggett Richard Dean Wilhelm Dietler William Hamilton Drummond Edward Payson Evans Thomas G. Gentry Arthur Helps John Hildrop John Lawrence Charles R. Magel Mary Midgley J. Howard Moore José Ferrater Mora Edward Nicholson Humphrey Primatt Tom Regan Henry Stephens Salt Arthur Schopenhauer Laurids Smith John Styles Johann Friedrich Ludwig Volckmann Adam Gottlieb Weigen Jon Wynne-Tyson Activists Contemporary James Aspey Greg Avery Matt Ball Martin Balluch Carole Baskin Barbi Twins Brigitte Bardot Brigitte Gothière Bob Barker Gene Baur Yves Bonnardel Rod Coronado Karen Davis Chris DeRose John Feldmann Bruce Friedrich Juliet Gellatley Tal Gilboa Antoine Goetschel Jordan Halliday Ronnie Lee Evanna Lynch Bill Maher Keith Mann Jim Mason Dan Mathews Jo-Anne McArthur Luísa Mell Ingrid Newkirk Heather Nicholson Jack Norris David Olivier Alex Pacheco Craig Rosebraugh Nathan Runkle Jasmin Singer Kim Stallwood Marianne Thieme Darren Thurston Louise Wallis Gary Yourofsky Historical Cleveland Amory Henry B. Amos Ernest Bell Frances Power Cobbe Alice Drakoules Robert Enke Lewis Gompertz James Granger Barry Horne Marie Huot Lizzy Lind af Hageby Jill Phipps Catherine Smithies Henry Spira Andrew Tyler Movement (groups, parties) Groups Contemporary Animal Aid Animal Ethics Animal Justice Project Animal Legal Defense Fund Animal Liberation Front Anonymous for the Voiceless Centre for Animals and Social Justice Chinese Animal Protection Network Cruelty Free International Direct Action Everywhere Equanimal Farm Animal Rights Movement Great Ape Project Hunt Saboteurs Association In Defense of Animals Korea Animal Rights Advocates L214 Last Chance for Animals Mercy for Animals New England Anti-Vivisection Society Oxford Centre for Animal Ethics People for Animals People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals Sentience Politics Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals United Poultry Concerns UPF-Centre for Animal Ethics Historical Bands of Mercy Humanitarian League (1891–1919) Oxford Group Parties Animal Justice Party (Australia) Animal Politics EU (Europe) Animal Protection Party of Canada (Canada) Animal Welfare Party (UK) Animal Justice Party of Finland (Finland) Animalist Party Against Mistreatment of Animals (Spain) DierAnimal (Belgium) Human Environment Animal Protection (Germany) Italian Animalist Party (Italy) Party for Animal Welfare (Ireland) Party for the Animals (Netherlands) People Animals Nature (Portugal) V-Partei³ (Germany) Media (books, films, periodicals, albums) Books Moral Inquiries on the Situation of Man and of Brutes (1824) Animals' Rights (1892) The Universal Kinship (1906) Animals, Men and Morals (1971) Animal Liberation (1975) The Case for Animal Rights (1983) The Lives of Animals (1999) Striking at the Roots (2008) An American Trilogy (2009) An Introduction to Animals and Political Theory (2010) Animal Rights Without Liberation (2012) Political Animals and Animal Politics (2014) Animal (De)liberation (2016) Sentientist Politics (2019) Films The Animals Film (1981) A Cow at My Table (1998) Shores of Silence (2000) The Witness (2000) Meet Your Meat (2002) The Meatrix (2003) Peaceable Kingdom (2004) Earthlings (2005) Behind the Mask (2006) Your Mommy Kills Animals (2007) The Cove (2009) Peaceable Kingdom: The Journey Home (2009) Forks Over Knives (2011) Vegucated (2011) An Apology to Elephants (2013) Speciesism: The Movie (2013) The Ghosts in Our Machine (2013) Unlocking the Cage (2016) Dominion (2018) Periodicals Journals Animal Sentience Between the Species Cahiers antispécistes Journal of Animal Ethics Relations. Beyond Anthropocentrism Magazines Arkangel Bite Back Muutoksen kevät No Compromise Satya Albums Animal Liberation (1987) Tame Yourself (1991) Manifesto (2008) Salvation of Innocents (2014) Onward to Freedom (2014) Category ( 85 ) v t e Animal welfare Issues Abandoned pets Blood sports Chick culling Livestock dehorning Eating live animals Eating live seafood Intensive animal farming Intensive pig farming Overview of discretionary invasive procedures on animals Dairy farming Poultry farming Puppy mill Welfare of farmed insects Wild animal suffering Wildlife farming Concepts Abnormal behaviours in animals Animal psychopathology Animal shelter Animal welfare science Anthrozoology Behavioral enrichment Compassionate conservation Ethics of uncertain sentience Ethical omnivorism Intrinsic value (animal ethics) Rescue group Welfare biology Pain in nonhuman animals Pain in animals Pain in amphibians Pain in cephalopods Pain in crustaceans Pain in fish Pain in invertebrates Grimace scale (animals) Organisations Animal welfare organizations Animal welfare organizations by country Animal welfare (journal) Compassion in World Farming HSUS International Society for Applied Ethology List of animal welfare organizations RSPCA Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals UFAW Animal welfare scholars Contemporary Jonathan Balcombe Michael Balls Marc Bekoff Donald Broom Marian Dawkins Jane Goodall Jane Hurst Alistair Lawrence Jeff McMahan Clare Palmer Temple Grandin Historical George T. Angell Patrick Bateson Ernest Bell Edward Berdoe Arthur Broome Stephen Coleridge Christian Adam Dann J. Morewood Dowsett Ralph Fletcher Ruth Harrison C. W. Hume E. Douglas Hume James Macaulay George Nicholson Charles Reinhardt Francis H. Rowley W. M. S. Russell Chris Sherwin Colin Spedding William O. Stillman D. G. M. Wood-Gush William Youatt Categories Animal advocacy parties Animal killing Animal rights Animal welfare and rights legislation Animal sacrifice Animal sanctuaries Animal testing Animal welfare and rights by country Cruelty to animals Dishes involving the consumption of live animals Fur trade People associated with animal welfare Whaling Religious considerations Dhabihah Jhatka Kutha Shechita Tza'ar ba'alei chayim Rituals and festivals Bous al carrer Cock throwing Combat de Reines Eid al-Adha Gadhimai festival Goat throwing Goose pulling Kapparot Lychee and Dog Meat Festival Monkey Buffet Festival October Horse Pushkar Camel Fair Rapa das Bestas of Sabucedo Running of the Bulls Surin Elephant Round-up Toro embolado World Animal Day Legislation Animal testing regulations Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 (UK) Animal Welfare Act 1999 (NZ) Animal Welfare Act of 1966 (US) EU Directive 2010/63/EU (EU) EU Directive 1999/74/EC (EU) Horse Protection Act of 1970 (US) Hunting Act 2004 (US) Philippine Animal Welfare Act 1998 (Philippines) Category v t e Ethics Normative ethics Consequentialism Utilitarianism Deontology Kantian ethics Ethics of care Existentialist ethics Particularism Pragmatic ethics Role ethics Virtue ethics Eudaimonism Applied ethics Animal ethics Bioethics Business ethics Discourse ethics Engineering ethics Environmental ethics Legal ethics Machine ethics Media ethics Medical ethics Nursing ethics Professional ethics Sexual ethics Ethics of artificial intelligence Ethics of eating meat Ethics of technology Ethics of terraforming Ethics of uncertain sentience Meta-ethics Cognitivism Moral realism Ethical naturalism Ethical non-naturalism Ethical subjectivism Ideal observer theory Divine command theory Error theory Non-cognitivism Emotivism Expressivism Quasi-realism Universal prescriptivism Moral universalism Value monism – Value pluralism Moral relativism Moral nihilism Moral rationalism Ethical intuitionism Moral skepticism Concepts Autonomy Axiology Conscience Consent Equality Free will Good and evil Good Evil Happiness Ideal Immorality Justice Liberty Morality Norm Freedom Suffering or Pain Stewardship Sympathy Trust Value Virtue Wrong full index... Philosophers Laozi Socrates Plato Aristotle Diogenes Valluvar Cicero Confucius Augustine of Hippo Mencius Mozi Xunzi Thomas Aquinas Baruch Spinoza David Hume Immanuel Kant Georg W. F. Hegel Arthur Schopenhauer Jeremy Bentham John Stuart Mill Søren Kierkegaard Henry Sidgwick Friedrich Nietzsche G. E. Moore Karl Barth Paul Tillich Dietrich Bonhoeffer Philippa Foot John Rawls John Dewey Bernard Williams J. L. Mackie G. E. M. Anscombe William Frankena Alasdair MacIntyre R. M. Hare Peter Singer Derek Parfit Thomas Nagel Robert Merrihew Adams Charles Taylor Joxe Azurmendi Christine Korsgaard Martha Nussbaum more... Related articles Casuistry Christian ethics Descriptive ethics Ethics in religion Evolutionary ethics Feminist ethics History of ethics Ideology Islamic ethics Jewish ethics Moral psychology Philosophy of law Political philosophy Population ethics Social philosophy Category Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ethics_of_uncertain_sentience&oldid=990789504" Categories: Animal ethics Bioethics Consciousness studies Environmental ethics Ethics of science and technology Philosophy of artificial intelligence Philosophy of mind Hidden categories: Articles with short description Short description matches Wikidata Navigation menu Personal tools Not logged in Talk Contributions Create account Log in Namespaces Article Talk Variants Views Read Edit View history More Search Navigation Main page Contents Current events Random article About Wikipedia Contact us Donate Contribute Help Learn to edit Community portal Recent changes Upload file Tools What links here Related changes Upload file Special pages Permanent link Page information Cite this page Wikidata item Print/export Download as PDF Printable version Languages Add links This page was last edited on 26 November 2020, at 14:45 (UTC). Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia® is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization. Privacy policy About Wikipedia Disclaimers Contact Wikipedia Mobile view Developers Statistics Cookie statement