id sid tid token lemma pos 3168 1 1 6 6 CD 3168 1 2 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3168 1 3 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3168 1 4 AND and CC 3168 1 5 LIBRARIES library NNS 3168 1 6 | | JJ 3168 1 7 MARCH MARCH NNP 3168 1 8 2009 2009 CD 3168 1 9 Paul Paul NNP 3168 1 10 T. T. NNP 3168 1 11 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 1 12 and and CC 3168 1 13 Zheng Zheng NNP 3168 1 14 Yan Yan NNP 3168 1 15 One one CD 3168 1 16 Law Law NNP 3168 1 17 with with IN 3168 1 18 Two two CD 3168 1 19 Outcomes Outcomes NNPS 3168 1 20 : : : 3168 1 21 Comparing compare VBG 3168 1 22 the the DT 3168 1 23 Implementation implementation NN 3168 1 24 of of IN 3168 1 25 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 1 26 in in IN 3168 1 27 Public Public NNP 3168 1 28 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 1 29 and and CC 3168 1 30 Schools Schools NNPS 3168 1 31 Though though IN 3168 1 32 the the DT 3168 1 33 Children Children NNPS 3168 1 34 ’s ’s POS 3168 1 35 Internet Internet NNP 3168 1 36 Protection Protection NNP 3168 1 37 Act Act NNP 3168 1 38 ( ( -LRB- 3168 1 39 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 1 40 ) ) -RRB- 3168 1 41 established establish VBD 3168 1 42 requirements requirement NNS 3168 1 43 for for IN 3168 1 44 both both CC 3168 1 45 public public JJ 3168 1 46 libraries library NNS 3168 1 47 and and CC 3168 1 48 public public JJ 3168 1 49 schools school NNS 3168 1 50 to to TO 3168 1 51 adopt adopt VB 3168 1 52 filters filter NNS 3168 1 53 on on IN 3168 1 54 all all DT 3168 1 55 of of IN 3168 1 56 their -PRON- PRP$ 3168 1 57 computers computer NNS 3168 1 58 when when WRB 3168 1 59 they -PRON- PRP 3168 1 60 receive receive VBP 3168 1 61 certain certain JJ 3168 1 62 federal federal JJ 3168 1 63 funding funding NN 3168 1 64 , , , 3168 1 65 it -PRON- PRP 3168 1 66 has have VBZ 3168 1 67 not not RB 3168 1 68 attracted attract VBN 3168 1 69 a a DT 3168 1 70 great great JJ 3168 1 71 amount amount NN 3168 1 72 of of IN 3168 1 73 research research NN 3168 1 74 into into IN 3168 1 75 the the DT 3168 1 76 effects effect NNS 3168 1 77 on on IN 3168 1 78 libraries library NNS 3168 1 79 and and CC 3168 1 80 schools school NNS 3168 1 81 and and CC 3168 1 82 the the DT 3168 1 83 users user NNS 3168 1 84 of of IN 3168 1 85 these these DT 3168 1 86 social social JJ 3168 1 87 insti- insti- NN 3168 1 88 tutions tution NNS 3168 1 89 . . . 3168 2 1 This this DT 3168 2 2 paper paper NN 3168 2 3 explores explore VBZ 3168 2 4 the the DT 3168 2 5 implications implication NNS 3168 2 6 of of IN 3168 2 7 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 2 8 in in IN 3168 2 9 terms term NNS 3168 2 10 of of IN 3168 2 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 3168 2 12 effects effect NNS 3168 2 13 on on IN 3168 2 14 public public JJ 3168 2 15 libraries library NNS 3168 2 16 and and CC 3168 2 17 public public JJ 3168 2 18 schools school NNS 3168 2 19 , , , 3168 2 20 individually individually RB 3168 2 21 and and CC 3168 2 22 in in IN 3168 2 23 tandem tandem NN 3168 2 24 . . . 3168 3 1 Drawing draw VBG 3168 3 2 from from IN 3168 3 3 both both DT 3168 3 4 library library NN 3168 3 5 and and CC 3168 3 6 education education NN 3168 3 7 research research NN 3168 3 8 , , , 3168 3 9 the the DT 3168 3 10 paper paper NN 3168 3 11 examines examine VBZ 3168 3 12 the the DT 3168 3 13 legal legal JJ 3168 3 14 background background NN 3168 3 15 and and CC 3168 3 16 basis basis NN 3168 3 17 of of IN 3168 3 18 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 3 19 , , , 3168 3 20 the the DT 3168 3 21 current current JJ 3168 3 22 state state NN 3168 3 23 of of IN 3168 3 24 Internet internet NN 3168 3 25 access access NN 3168 3 26 and and CC 3168 3 27 levels level NNS 3168 3 28 of of IN 3168 3 29 filtering filtering NN 3168 3 30 in in IN 3168 3 31 public public JJ 3168 3 32 librar- librar- NNP 3168 3 33 ies ie NNS 3168 3 34 and and CC 3168 3 35 public public JJ 3168 3 36 schools school NNS 3168 3 37 , , , 3168 3 38 the the DT 3168 3 39 perceived perceive VBN 3168 3 40 value value NN 3168 3 41 of of IN 3168 3 42 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 3 43 , , , 3168 3 44 the the DT 3168 3 45 perceived perceive VBN 3168 3 46 consequences consequence NNS 3168 3 47 of of IN 3168 3 48 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 3 49 , , , 3168 3 50 the the DT 3168 3 51 differences difference NNS 3168 3 52 in in IN 3168 3 53 levels level NNS 3168 3 54 of of IN 3168 3 55 implementation implementation NN 3168 3 56 of of IN 3168 3 57 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 3 58 in in IN 3168 3 59 public public JJ 3168 3 60 libraries library NNS 3168 3 61 and and CC 3168 3 62 public public JJ 3168 3 63 schools school NNS 3168 3 64 , , , 3168 3 65 and and CC 3168 3 66 the the DT 3168 3 67 reasons reason NNS 3168 3 68 for for IN 3168 3 69 those those DT 3168 3 70 dramatic dramatic JJ 3168 3 71 differences difference NNS 3168 3 72 . . . 3168 4 1 After after IN 3168 4 2 an an DT 3168 4 3 analysis analysis NN 3168 4 4 of of IN 3168 4 5 these these DT 3168 4 6 issues issue NNS 3168 4 7 within within IN 3168 4 8 the the DT 3168 4 9 greater great JJR 3168 4 10 policy policy NN 3168 4 11 context context NN 3168 4 12 , , , 3168 4 13 the the DT 3168 4 14 paper paper NN 3168 4 15 suggests suggest VBZ 3168 4 16 research research NN 3168 4 17 questions question NNS 3168 4 18 to to TO 3168 4 19 help help VB 3168 4 20 provide provide VB 3168 4 21 more more JJR 3168 4 22 data datum NNS 3168 4 23 about about IN 3168 4 24 the the DT 3168 4 25 challenges challenge NNS 3168 4 26 and and CC 3168 4 27 questions question NNS 3168 4 28 revealed reveal VBN 3168 4 29 in in IN 3168 4 30 this this DT 3168 4 31 analysis analysis NN 3168 4 32 . . . 3168 5 1 T T NNP 3168 5 2 he he NNP 3168 5 3 Children Children NNP 3168 5 4 ’s ’s POS 3168 5 5 Internet Internet NNP 3168 5 6 Protection Protection NNP 3168 5 7 Act Act NNP 3168 5 8 ( ( -LRB- 3168 5 9 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 5 10 ) ) -RRB- 3168 5 11 estab- estab- NNP 3168 5 12 lished lished JJ 3168 5 13 requirements requirement NNS 3168 5 14 for for IN 3168 5 15 both both CC 3168 5 16 public public JJ 3168 5 17 libraries library NNS 3168 5 18 and and CC 3168 5 19 public public JJ 3168 5 20 schools school NNS 3168 5 21 to to TO 3168 5 22 — — : 3168 5 23 as as IN 3168 5 24 a a DT 3168 5 25 condition condition NN 3168 5 26 for for IN 3168 5 27 receiving receive VBG 3168 5 28 cer- cer- VBG 3168 5 29 tain tain NN 3168 5 30 federal federal JJ 3168 5 31 funds fund NNS 3168 5 32 — — : 3168 5 33 adopt adopt VB 3168 5 34 filters filter NNS 3168 5 35 on on IN 3168 5 36 all all DT 3168 5 37 of of IN 3168 5 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 3168 5 39 computers computer NNS 3168 5 40 to to TO 3168 5 41 protect protect VB 3168 5 42 children child NNS 3168 5 43 from from IN 3168 5 44 online online JJ 3168 5 45 content content NN 3168 5 46 that that WDT 3168 5 47 was be VBD 3168 5 48 deemed deem VBN 3168 5 49 potentially potentially RB 3168 5 50 harmful.1 harmful.1 CD 3168 5 51 Passed pass VBN 3168 5 52 in in IN 3168 5 53 2000 2000 CD 3168 5 54 , , , 3168 5 55 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 5 56 was be VBD 3168 5 57 initially initially RB 3168 5 58 implemented implement VBN 3168 5 59 by by IN 3168 5 60 public public JJ 3168 5 61 schools school NNS 3168 5 62 after after IN 3168 5 63 its -PRON- PRP$ 3168 5 64 passage passage NN 3168 5 65 , , , 3168 5 66 but but CC 3168 5 67 it -PRON- PRP 3168 5 68 was be VBD 3168 5 69 not not RB 3168 5 70 widely widely RB 3168 5 71 implemented implement VBN 3168 5 72 in in IN 3168 5 73 public public JJ 3168 5 74 libraries library NNS 3168 5 75 until until IN 3168 5 76 the the DT 3168 5 77 2003 2003 CD 3168 5 78 Supreme Supreme NNP 3168 5 79 Court Court NNP 3168 5 80 decision decision NN 3168 5 81 ( ( -LRB- 3168 5 82 United United NNP 3168 5 83 States States NNP 3168 5 84 v. v. CC 3168 5 85 American American NNP 3168 5 86 Library Library NNP 3168 5 87 Association Association NNP 3168 5 88 ) ) -RRB- 3168 5 89 upholding uphold VBG 3168 5 90 the the DT 3168 5 91 law law NN 3168 5 92 ’s ’ VBZ 3168 5 93 constitutional- constitutional- NN 3168 5 94 ity.2 ity.2 NNP 3168 5 95 Now now RB 3168 5 96 that that IN 3168 5 97 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 5 98 has have VBZ 3168 5 99 been be VBN 3168 5 100 extensively extensively RB 3168 5 101 implemented implement VBN 3168 5 102 for for IN 3168 5 103 five five CD 3168 5 104 years year NNS 3168 5 105 in in IN 3168 5 106 libraries library NNS 3168 5 107 and and CC 3168 5 108 eight eight CD 3168 5 109 years year NNS 3168 5 110 in in IN 3168 5 111 schools school NNS 3168 5 112 , , , 3168 5 113 it -PRON- PRP 3168 5 114 has have VBZ 3168 5 115 had have VBN 3168 5 116 time time NN 3168 5 117 to to TO 3168 5 118 have have VB 3168 5 119 significant significant JJ 3168 5 120 effects effect NNS 3168 5 121 on on IN 3168 5 122 access access NN 3168 5 123 to to IN 3168 5 124 online online JJ 3168 5 125 information information NN 3168 5 126 and and CC 3168 5 127 services service NNS 3168 5 128 . . . 3168 6 1 While while IN 3168 6 2 the the DT 3168 6 3 goal goal NN 3168 6 4 of of IN 3168 6 5 filter- filter- NNP 3168 6 6 ing ing NN 3168 6 7 requirements requirement NNS 3168 6 8 is be VBZ 3168 6 9 to to TO 3168 6 10 protect protect VB 3168 6 11 children child NNS 3168 6 12 from from IN 3168 6 13 potentially potentially RB 3168 6 14 inappropriate inappropriate JJ 3168 6 15 content content NN 3168 6 16 , , , 3168 6 17 filtering filtering NN 3168 6 18 also also RB 3168 6 19 creates create VBZ 3168 6 20 major major JJ 3168 6 21 edu- edu- NN 3168 6 22 cational cational JJ 3168 6 23 and and CC 3168 6 24 social social JJ 3168 6 25 implications implication NNS 3168 6 26 because because IN 3168 6 27 filters filter NNS 3168 6 28 also also RB 3168 6 29 limit limit VBP 3168 6 30 access access NN 3168 6 31 to to IN 3168 6 32 other other JJ 3168 6 33 kinds kind NNS 3168 6 34 of of IN 3168 6 35 information information NN 3168 6 36 and and CC 3168 6 37 create create VB 3168 6 38 different different JJ 3168 6 39 perceptions perception NNS 3168 6 40 about about IN 3168 6 41 schools school NNS 3168 6 42 and and CC 3168 6 43 libraries library NNS 3168 6 44 as as IN 3168 6 45 social social JJ 3168 6 46 institu- institu- NN 3168 6 47 tions tion NNS 3168 6 48 . . . 3168 7 1 Curiously curiously RB 3168 7 2 , , , 3168 7 3 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 7 4 and and CC 3168 7 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 3168 7 6 requirements requirement NNS 3168 7 7 have have VBP 3168 7 8 not not RB 3168 7 9 attracted attract VBN 3168 7 10 a a DT 3168 7 11 great great JJ 3168 7 12 amount amount NN 3168 7 13 of of IN 3168 7 14 research research NN 3168 7 15 into into IN 3168 7 16 the the DT 3168 7 17 effects effect NNS 3168 7 18 on on IN 3168 7 19 schools school NNS 3168 7 20 , , , 3168 7 21 libraries library NNS 3168 7 22 , , , 3168 7 23 and and CC 3168 7 24 the the DT 3168 7 25 users user NNS 3168 7 26 of of IN 3168 7 27 these these DT 3168 7 28 social social JJ 3168 7 29 institu- institu- NN 3168 7 30 tions tion NNS 3168 7 31 . . . 3168 8 1 Much much JJ 3168 8 2 of of IN 3168 8 3 the the DT 3168 8 4 literature literature NN 3168 8 5 about about IN 3168 8 6 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 8 7 has have VBZ 3168 8 8 focused focus VBN 3168 8 9 on on IN 3168 8 10 practical practical JJ 3168 8 11 issues issue NNS 3168 8 12 — — : 3168 8 13 either either CC 3168 8 14 recommendations recommendation NNS 3168 8 15 on on IN 3168 8 16 implement- implement- JJ 3168 8 17 ing ing NN 3168 8 18 filters filter NNS 3168 8 19 or or CC 3168 8 20 stories story NNS 3168 8 21 of of IN 3168 8 22 practical practical JJ 3168 8 23 experiences experience NNS 3168 8 24 with with IN 3168 8 25 filtering filter VBG 3168 8 26 . . . 3168 9 1 While while IN 3168 9 2 those those DT 3168 9 3 types type NNS 3168 9 4 of of IN 3168 9 5 writing writing NN 3168 9 6 are be VBP 3168 9 7 valuable valuable JJ 3168 9 8 to to IN 3168 9 9 practitioners practitioner NNS 3168 9 10 who who WP 3168 9 11 must must MD 3168 9 12 deal deal VB 3168 9 13 with with IN 3168 9 14 the the DT 3168 9 15 consequences consequence NNS 3168 9 16 of of IN 3168 9 17 filtering filtering NN 3168 9 18 , , , 3168 9 19 there there EX 3168 9 20 are be VBP 3168 9 21 major major JJ 3168 9 22 educational educational JJ 3168 9 23 and and CC 3168 9 24 societal societal JJ 3168 9 25 issues issue NNS 3168 9 26 raised raise VBN 3168 9 27 by by IN 3168 9 28 filter- filter- NNP 3168 9 29 ing ing NNP 3168 9 30 that that DT 3168 9 31 merit merit NN 3168 9 32 much much RB 3168 9 33 greater great JJR 3168 9 34 exploration exploration NN 3168 9 35 . . . 3168 10 1 While while IN 3168 10 2 relatively relatively RB 3168 10 3 small small JJ 3168 10 4 bodies body NNS 3168 10 5 of of IN 3168 10 6 research research NN 3168 10 7 have have VBP 3168 10 8 been be VBN 3168 10 9 generated generate VBN 3168 10 10 about about IN 3168 10 11 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 10 12 ’s ’s POS 3168 10 13 effects effect NNS 3168 10 14 in in IN 3168 10 15 public public JJ 3168 10 16 libraries library NNS 3168 10 17 and and CC 3168 10 18 public public JJ 3168 10 19 schools,3 schools,3 NNP 3168 10 20 thus thus RB 3168 10 21 far far RB 3168 10 22 these these DT 3168 10 23 two two CD 3168 10 24 strands strand NNS 3168 10 25 of of IN 3168 10 26 research research NN 3168 10 27 have have VBP 3168 10 28 remained remain VBN 3168 10 29 separate separate JJ 3168 10 30 . . . 3168 11 1 But but CC 3168 11 2 it -PRON- PRP 3168 11 3 is be VBZ 3168 11 4 the the DT 3168 11 5 contention contention NN 3168 11 6 of of IN 3168 11 7 this this DT 3168 11 8 paper paper NN 3168 11 9 that that WDT 3168 11 10 these these DT 3168 11 11 two two CD 3168 11 12 strands strand NNS 3168 11 13 of of IN 3168 11 14 research research NN 3168 11 15 , , , 3168 11 16 when when WRB 3168 11 17 viewed view VBN 3168 11 18 together together RB 3168 11 19 , , , 3168 11 20 have have VBP 3168 11 21 much much RB 3168 11 22 more more JJR 3168 11 23 value value NN 3168 11 24 for for IN 3168 11 25 creating create VBG 3168 11 26 a a DT 3168 11 27 broader broad JJR 3168 11 28 understanding understanding NN 3168 11 29 of of IN 3168 11 30 the the DT 3168 11 31 educational educational JJ 3168 11 32 and and CC 3168 11 33 societal societal JJ 3168 11 34 implications implication NNS 3168 11 35 . . . 3168 12 1 It -PRON- PRP 3168 12 2 would would MD 3168 12 3 be be VB 3168 12 4 impossible impossible JJ 3168 12 5 to to TO 3168 12 6 see see VB 3168 12 7 the the DT 3168 12 8 real real JJ 3168 12 9 consequences consequence NNS 3168 12 10 of of IN 3168 12 11 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 12 12 without without IN 3168 12 13 the the DT 3168 12 14 development development NN 3168 12 15 of of IN 3168 12 16 an an DT 3168 12 17 integrative integrative JJ 3168 12 18 picture picture NN 3168 12 19 of of IN 3168 12 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 3168 12 21 effects effect NNS 3168 12 22 on on IN 3168 12 23 both both CC 3168 12 24 public public JJ 3168 12 25 schools school NNS 3168 12 26 and and CC 3168 12 27 public public JJ 3168 12 28 libraries library NNS 3168 12 29 . . . 3168 13 1 In in IN 3168 13 2 this this DT 3168 13 3 paper paper NN 3168 13 4 , , , 3168 13 5 the the DT 3168 13 6 implications implication NNS 3168 13 7 of of IN 3168 13 8 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 13 9 will will MD 3168 13 10 be be VB 3168 13 11 explored explore VBN 3168 13 12 in in IN 3168 13 13 terms term NNS 3168 13 14 of of IN 3168 13 15 effects effect NNS 3168 13 16 on on IN 3168 13 17 public public JJ 3168 13 18 libraries library NNS 3168 13 19 and and CC 3168 13 20 public public JJ 3168 13 21 schools school NNS 3168 13 22 , , , 3168 13 23 individually individually RB 3168 13 24 and and CC 3168 13 25 in in IN 3168 13 26 tandem tandem NN 3168 13 27 . . . 3168 14 1 Public public JJ 3168 14 2 libraries library NNS 3168 14 3 and and CC 3168 14 4 public public JJ 3168 14 5 schools school NNS 3168 14 6 are be VBP 3168 14 7 generally generally RB 3168 14 8 considered consider VBN 3168 14 9 separate separate JJ 3168 14 10 but but CC 3168 14 11 related related JJ 3168 14 12 public public JJ 3168 14 13 sphere sphere NN 3168 14 14 entities entity NNS 3168 14 15 because because IN 3168 14 16 both both DT 3168 14 17 serve serve VBP 3168 14 18 core core NN 3168 14 19 educa- educa- NNP 3168 14 20 tional tional JJ 3168 14 21 and and CC 3168 14 22 information information NN 3168 14 23 - - HYPH 3168 14 24 provision provision NN 3168 14 25 functions function NNS 3168 14 26 in in IN 3168 14 27 society society NN 3168 14 28 . . . 3168 15 1 Furthermore furthermore RB 3168 15 2 , , , 3168 15 3 the the DT 3168 15 4 fact fact NN 3168 15 5 that that IN 3168 15 6 public public JJ 3168 15 7 schools school NNS 3168 15 8 also also RB 3168 15 9 contain contain VBP 3168 15 10 school school NN 3168 15 11 library library NN 3168 15 12 media medium NNS 3168 15 13 centers center NNS 3168 15 14 highlights highlight VBZ 3168 15 15 some some DT 3168 15 16 very very RB 3168 15 17 inter- inter- JJ 3168 15 18 esting esting NN 3168 15 19 points point NNS 3168 15 20 of of IN 3168 15 21 intersection intersection NN 3168 15 22 between between IN 3168 15 23 public public JJ 3168 15 24 libraries library NNS 3168 15 25 and and CC 3168 15 26 school school NN 3168 15 27 libraries library NNS 3168 15 28 in in IN 3168 15 29 terms term NNS 3168 15 30 of of IN 3168 15 31 the the DT 3168 15 32 consequences consequence NNS 3168 15 33 of of IN 3168 15 34 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 15 35 : : : 3168 15 36 While while IN 3168 15 37 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 15 38 requires require VBZ 3168 15 39 filtering filter VBG 3168 15 40 of of IN 3168 15 41 computers computer NNS 3168 15 42 throughout throughout IN 3168 15 43 public public JJ 3168 15 44 libraries library NNS 3168 15 45 and and CC 3168 15 46 public public JJ 3168 15 47 schools school NNS 3168 15 48 , , , 3168 15 49 the the DT 3168 15 50 presence presence NN 3168 15 51 of of IN 3168 15 52 school school NN 3168 15 53 library library NN 3168 15 54 media medium NNS 3168 15 55 centers center NNS 3168 15 56 makes make VBZ 3168 15 57 the the DT 3168 15 58 connection connection NN 3168 15 59 between between IN 3168 15 60 libraries library NNS 3168 15 61 and and CC 3168 15 62 schools school NNS 3168 15 63 stronger strong JJR 3168 15 64 , , , 3168 15 65 as as IN 3168 15 66 do do VBP 3168 15 67 the the DT 3168 15 68 teaching teaching NN 3168 15 69 roles role NNS 3168 15 70 of of IN 3168 15 71 public public JJ 3168 15 72 libraries library NNS 3168 15 73 ( ( -LRB- 3168 15 74 e.g. e.g. RB 3168 15 75 , , , 3168 15 76 training training NN 3168 15 77 classes class NNS 3168 15 78 , , , 3168 15 79 workshops workshop NNS 3168 15 80 , , , 3168 15 81 and and CC 3168 15 82 evening evening NN 3168 15 83 classes class NNS 3168 15 84 ) ) -RRB- 3168 15 85 . . . 3168 16 1 n n LS 3168 16 2 The the DT 3168 16 3 legal legal JJ 3168 16 4 road road NN 3168 16 5 to to IN 3168 16 6 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 16 7 History history NN 3168 16 8 Under under IN 3168 16 9 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 16 10 , , , 3168 16 11 public public JJ 3168 16 12 libraries library NNS 3168 16 13 and and CC 3168 16 14 public public JJ 3168 16 15 schools school NNS 3168 16 16 receiving receive VBG 3168 16 17 certain certain JJ 3168 16 18 kinds kind NNS 3168 16 19 of of IN 3168 16 20 federal federal JJ 3168 16 21 funds fund NNS 3168 16 22 are be VBP 3168 16 23 required require VBN 3168 16 24 to to TO 3168 16 25 use use VB 3168 16 26 filtering filter VBG 3168 16 27 programs program NNS 3168 16 28 to to TO 3168 16 29 protect protect VB 3168 16 30 children child NNS 3168 16 31 under under IN 3168 16 32 the the DT 3168 16 33 age age NN 3168 16 34 of of IN 3168 16 35 seventeen seventeen CD 3168 16 36 from from IN 3168 16 37 harmful harmful JJ 3168 16 38 visual visual JJ 3168 16 39 depictions depiction NNS 3168 16 40 on on IN 3168 16 41 the the DT 3168 16 42 Internet internet NN 3168 16 43 and and CC 3168 16 44 to to TO 3168 16 45 provide provide VB 3168 16 46 public public JJ 3168 16 47 notices notice NNS 3168 16 48 and and CC 3168 16 49 hearings hearing NNS 3168 16 50 to to TO 3168 16 51 increase increase VB 3168 16 52 public public JJ 3168 16 53 awareness awareness NN 3168 16 54 of of IN 3168 16 55 Internet internet NN 3168 16 56 safety safety NN 3168 16 57 . . . 3168 17 1 Senator Senator NNP 3168 17 2 John John NNP 3168 17 3 McCain McCain NNP 3168 17 4 ( ( -LRB- 3168 17 5 R R NNP 3168 17 6 - - HYPH 3168 17 7 AZ AZ NNP 3168 17 8 ) ) -RRB- 3168 17 9 sponsored sponsor VBD 3168 17 10 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 17 11 , , , 3168 17 12 and and CC 3168 17 13 it -PRON- PRP 3168 17 14 was be VBD 3168 17 15 signed sign VBN 3168 17 16 into into IN 3168 17 17 law law NN 3168 17 18 by by IN 3168 17 19 President President NNP 3168 17 20 Bill Bill NNP 3168 17 21 Clinton Clinton NNP 3168 17 22 on on IN 3168 17 23 December December NNP 3168 17 24 21 21 CD 3168 17 25 , , , 3168 17 26 2000 2000 CD 3168 17 27 . . . 3168 18 1 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 18 2 requires require VBZ 3168 18 3 that that IN 3168 18 4 filters filter NNS 3168 18 5 at at IN 3168 18 6 public public JJ 3168 18 7 libraries library NNS 3168 18 8 and and CC 3168 18 9 public public JJ 3168 18 10 schools school NNS 3168 18 11 block block VB 3168 18 12 three three CD 3168 18 13 specific specific JJ 3168 18 14 types type NNS 3168 18 15 of of IN 3168 18 16 content content NN 3168 18 17 : : : 3168 18 18 ( ( -LRB- 3168 18 19 1 1 LS 3168 18 20 ) ) -RRB- 3168 18 21 obscene obscene JJ 3168 18 22 material material NN 3168 18 23 ( ( -LRB- 3168 18 24 that that IN 3168 18 25 Paul Paul NNP 3168 18 26 T. T. NNP 3168 18 27 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 18 28 ( ( -LRB- 3168 18 29 pjaeger@umd.edu pjaeger@umd.edu NN 3168 18 30 ) ) -RRB- 3168 18 31 is be VBZ 3168 18 32 Assistant Assistant NNP 3168 18 33 Professor Professor NNP 3168 18 34 at at IN 3168 18 35 the the DT 3168 18 36 College College NNP 3168 18 37 of of IN 3168 18 38 Information Information NNP 3168 18 39 Studies Studies NNPS 3168 18 40 and and CC 3168 18 41 Director Director NNP 3168 18 42 of of IN 3168 18 43 the the DT 3168 18 44 Center Center NNP 3168 18 45 for for IN 3168 18 46 Information Information NNP 3168 18 47 Policy Policy NNP 3168 18 48 and and CC 3168 18 49 Electronic electronic JJ 3168 18 50 government government NN 3168 18 51 of of IN 3168 18 52 the the DT 3168 18 53 University University NNP 3168 18 54 of of IN 3168 18 55 Maryland Maryland NNP 3168 18 56 in in IN 3168 18 57 College College NNP 3168 18 58 Park Park NNP 3168 18 59 . . . 3168 19 1 Zheng Zheng NNP 3168 19 2 Yan Yan NNP 3168 19 3 ( ( -LRB- 3168 19 4 zyan@uamail.albany zyan@uamail.albany NNP 3168 19 5 .edu .edu . 3168 19 6 ) ) -RRB- 3168 19 7 is be VBZ 3168 19 8 Associate Associate NNP 3168 19 9 Professor Professor NNP 3168 19 10 at at IN 3168 19 11 the the DT 3168 19 12 Department Department NNP 3168 19 13 of of IN 3168 19 14 Educational Educational NNP 3168 19 15 and and CC 3168 19 16 Counseling Counseling NNP 3168 19 17 Psychology Psychology NNP 3168 19 18 in in IN 3168 19 19 the the DT 3168 19 20 School School NNP 3168 19 21 of of IN 3168 19 22 Education Education NNP 3168 19 23 of of IN 3168 19 24 the the DT 3168 19 25 State State NNP 3168 19 26 University University NNP 3168 19 27 of of IN 3168 19 28 New New NNP 3168 19 29 York York NNP 3168 19 30 at at IN 3168 19 31 Albany Albany NNP 3168 19 32 . . . 3168 20 1 ONE one CD 3168 20 2 LAw LAw NNP 3168 20 3 wITH with IN 3168 20 4 TwO TwO NNP 3168 20 5 OuTCOMES OuTCOMES NNP 3168 20 6 | | NNP 3168 20 7 JAEGER JAEGER NNP 3168 20 8 AND and CC 3168 20 9 YAN YAN NNP 3168 20 10 7 7 CD 3168 20 11 which which WDT 3168 20 12 appeals appeal VBZ 3168 20 13 to to IN 3168 20 14 prurient prurient JJ 3168 20 15 interests interest NNS 3168 20 16 only only RB 3168 20 17 and and CC 3168 20 18 is be VBZ 3168 20 19 “ " `` 3168 20 20 offen- offen- RB 3168 20 21 sive sive JJ 3168 20 22 to to IN 3168 20 23 community community NN 3168 20 24 standards standard NNS 3168 20 25 ” " '' 3168 20 26 ) ) -RRB- 3168 20 27 ; ; , 3168 20 28 ( ( -LRB- 3168 20 29 2 2 LS 3168 20 30 ) ) -RRB- 3168 20 31 child child NN 3168 20 32 pornography pornography NN 3168 20 33 ( ( -LRB- 3168 20 34 depictions depiction NNS 3168 20 35 of of IN 3168 20 36 sexual sexual JJ 3168 20 37 conduct conduct NN 3168 20 38 and and CC 3168 20 39 or or CC 3168 20 40 lewd lewd VBZ 3168 20 41 exhibitionism exhibitionism NN 3168 20 42 involving involve VBG 3168 20 43 minors minor NNS 3168 20 44 ) ) -RRB- 3168 20 45 ; ; : 3168 20 46 and and CC 3168 20 47 ( ( -LRB- 3168 20 48 3 3 LS 3168 20 49 ) ) -RRB- 3168 20 50 material material NN 3168 20 51 that that WDT 3168 20 52 is be VBZ 3168 20 53 harmful harmful JJ 3168 20 54 to to IN 3168 20 55 minors minor NNS 3168 20 56 ( ( -LRB- 3168 20 57 depictions depiction NNS 3168 20 58 of of IN 3168 20 59 nudity nudity NN 3168 20 60 and and CC 3168 20 61 sexual sexual JJ 3168 20 62 activity activity NN 3168 20 63 that that WDT 3168 20 64 lack lack VBP 3168 20 65 artistic artistic JJ 3168 20 66 , , , 3168 20 67 literary literary JJ 3168 20 68 , , , 3168 20 69 or or CC 3168 20 70 scientific scientific JJ 3168 20 71 value value NN 3168 20 72 ) ) -RRB- 3168 20 73 . . . 3168 21 1 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 21 2 focused focus VBD 3168 21 3 on on IN 3168 21 4 “ " `` 3168 21 5 the the DT 3168 21 6 recipients recipient NNS 3168 21 7 of of IN 3168 21 8 Internet internet NN 3168 21 9 transmission transmission NN 3168 21 10 , , , 3168 21 11 ” " '' 3168 21 12 rather rather RB 3168 21 13 than than IN 3168 21 14 the the DT 3168 21 15 send- send- NN 3168 21 16 ers ers NNP 3168 21 17 , , , 3168 21 18 in in IN 3168 21 19 an an DT 3168 21 20 attempt attempt NN 3168 21 21 to to TO 3168 21 22 avoid avoid VB 3168 21 23 the the DT 3168 21 24 constitutional constitutional JJ 3168 21 25 issues issue NNS 3168 21 26 that that WDT 3168 21 27 undermined undermine VBD 3168 21 28 the the DT 3168 21 29 previous previous JJ 3168 21 30 attempts attempt NNS 3168 21 31 to to TO 3168 21 32 regulate regulate VB 3168 21 33 Internet internet NN 3168 21 34 content.4 content.4 NN 3168 21 35 Using use VBG 3168 21 36 congressional congressional JJ 3168 21 37 authority authority NN 3168 21 38 under under IN 3168 21 39 the the DT 3168 21 40 spending spending NN 3168 21 41 clause clause NN 3168 21 42 of of IN 3168 21 43 Article Article NNP 3168 21 44 I I NNP 3168 21 45 , , , 3168 21 46 section section NN 3168 21 47 8 8 CD 3168 21 48 of of IN 3168 21 49 the the DT 3168 21 50 U.S. U.S. NNP 3168 21 51 Constitution Constitution NNP 3168 21 52 , , , 3168 21 53 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 21 54 ties tie VBZ 3168 21 55 the the DT 3168 21 56 direct direct JJ 3168 21 57 or or CC 3168 21 58 indirect indirect JJ 3168 21 59 receipt receipt NN 3168 21 60 of of IN 3168 21 61 certain certain JJ 3168 21 62 types type NNS 3168 21 63 of of IN 3168 21 64 federal federal JJ 3168 21 65 funds fund NNS 3168 21 66 to to IN 3168 21 67 the the DT 3168 21 68 installation installation NN 3168 21 69 of of IN 3168 21 70 filters filter NNS 3168 21 71 on on IN 3168 21 72 library library NN 3168 21 73 and and CC 3168 21 74 school school NN 3168 21 75 computers computer NNS 3168 21 76 . . . 3168 22 1 Therefore therefore RB 3168 22 2 each each DT 3168 22 3 public public JJ 3168 22 4 library library NN 3168 22 5 and and CC 3168 22 6 school school NN 3168 22 7 that that WDT 3168 22 8 receives receive VBZ 3168 22 9 the the DT 3168 22 10 applicable applicable JJ 3168 22 11 types type NNS 3168 22 12 of of IN 3168 22 13 federal federal JJ 3168 22 14 funding funding NN 3168 22 15 must must MD 3168 22 16 implement implement VB 3168 22 17 filters filter NNS 3168 22 18 on on IN 3168 22 19 all all DT 3168 22 20 computers computer NNS 3168 22 21 in in IN 3168 22 22 the the DT 3168 22 23 library library NN 3168 22 24 and and CC 3168 22 25 school school NN 3168 22 26 buildings building NNS 3168 22 27 , , , 3168 22 28 including include VBG 3168 22 29 computers computer NNS 3168 22 30 that that WDT 3168 22 31 are be VBP 3168 22 32 exclusively exclusively RB 3168 22 33 for for IN 3168 22 34 staff staff NN 3168 22 35 use use NN 3168 22 36 . . . 3168 23 1 Libraries library NNS 3168 23 2 and and CC 3168 23 3 schools school NNS 3168 23 4 had have VBD 3168 23 5 to to TO 3168 23 6 address address VB 3168 23 7 these these DT 3168 23 8 issues issue NNS 3168 23 9 very very RB 3168 23 10 quickly quickly RB 3168 23 11 because because IN 3168 23 12 the the DT 3168 23 13 Federal Federal NNP 3168 23 14 Communications Communications NNPS 3168 23 15 Commission Commission NNP 3168 23 16 ( ( -LRB- 3168 23 17 FCC FCC NNP 3168 23 18 ) ) -RRB- 3168 23 19 mandated mandate VBD 3168 23 20 certifi- certifi- XX 3168 23 21 cation cation NNP 3168 23 22 of of IN 3168 23 23 compliance compliance NN 3168 23 24 with with IN 3168 23 25 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 23 26 by by IN 3168 23 27 funding funding NN 3168 23 28 year year NN 3168 23 29 2004 2004 CD 3168 23 30 , , , 3168 23 31 which which WDT 3168 23 32 began begin VBD 3168 23 33 in in IN 3168 23 34 Summer Summer NNP 3168 23 35 2004.5 2004.5 CD 3168 23 36 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 23 37 requires require VBZ 3168 23 38 that that IN 3168 23 39 filters filter NNS 3168 23 40 on on IN 3168 23 41 computers computer NNS 3168 23 42 block block VBP 3168 23 43 three three CD 3168 23 44 specific specific JJ 3168 23 45 types type NNS 3168 23 46 of of IN 3168 23 47 content content NN 3168 23 48 , , , 3168 23 49 and and CC 3168 23 50 each each DT 3168 23 51 of of IN 3168 23 52 the the DT 3168 23 53 three three CD 3168 23 54 cat- cat- NN 3168 23 55 egories egorie NNS 3168 23 56 of of IN 3168 23 57 materials material NNS 3168 23 58 has have VBZ 3168 23 59 a a DT 3168 23 60 specific specific JJ 3168 23 61 legal legal JJ 3168 23 62 meaning meaning NN 3168 23 63 . . . 3168 24 1 The the DT 3168 24 2 first first JJ 3168 24 3 type type NN 3168 24 4 — — : 3168 24 5 obscene obscene JJ 3168 24 6 materials material NNS 3168 24 7 — — : 3168 24 8 is be VBZ 3168 24 9 statutorily statutorily RB 3168 24 10 defined define VBN 3168 24 11 as as IN 3168 24 12 depicting depict VBG 3168 24 13 sexual sexual JJ 3168 24 14 conduct conduct NN 3168 24 15 that that IN 3168 24 16 appeals appeal NNS 3168 24 17 only only RB 3168 24 18 to to IN 3168 24 19 prurient prurient JJ 3168 24 20 interests interest NNS 3168 24 21 , , , 3168 24 22 is be VBZ 3168 24 23 offensive offensive JJ 3168 24 24 to to IN 3168 24 25 community community NN 3168 24 26 standards standard NNS 3168 24 27 , , , 3168 24 28 and and CC 3168 24 29 lacks lack VBZ 3168 24 30 serious serious JJ 3168 24 31 literary literary JJ 3168 24 32 , , , 3168 24 33 artistic artistic JJ 3168 24 34 , , , 3168 24 35 political political JJ 3168 24 36 , , , 3168 24 37 or or CC 3168 24 38 scientific scientific JJ 3168 24 39 value.6 value.6 NN 3168 24 40 Historically historically RB 3168 24 41 , , , 3168 24 42 obscene obscene JJ 3168 24 43 speech speech NN 3168 24 44 has have VBZ 3168 24 45 been be VBN 3168 24 46 viewed view VBN 3168 24 47 as as IN 3168 24 48 being be VBG 3168 24 49 bereft bereft JJ 3168 24 50 of of IN 3168 24 51 any any DT 3168 24 52 meaningful meaningful JJ 3168 24 53 ideas idea NNS 3168 24 54 or or CC 3168 24 55 educational educational JJ 3168 24 56 , , , 3168 24 57 social social JJ 3168 24 58 , , , 3168 24 59 or or CC 3168 24 60 professional professional JJ 3168 24 61 value value NN 3168 24 62 to to IN 3168 24 63 society.7 society.7 CD 3168 24 64 Statutes Statutes NNPS 3168 24 65 regulating regulating NN 3168 24 66 speech speech NN 3168 24 67 as as IN 3168 24 68 obscene obscene JJ 3168 24 69 have have VBP 3168 24 70 to to TO 3168 24 71 do do VB 3168 24 72 so so RB 3168 24 73 very very RB 3168 24 74 carefully carefully RB 3168 24 75 and and CC 3168 24 76 specifically specifically RB 3168 24 77 , , , 3168 24 78 and and CC 3168 24 79 speech speech NN 3168 24 80 can can MD 3168 24 81 only only RB 3168 24 82 be be VB 3168 24 83 labeled label VBN 3168 24 84 obscene obscene JJ 3168 24 85 if if IN 3168 24 86 the the DT 3168 24 87 entire entire JJ 3168 24 88 work work NN 3168 24 89 is be VBZ 3168 24 90 without without IN 3168 24 91 merit.8 merit.8 CD 3168 24 92 If if IN 3168 24 93 speech speech NN 3168 24 94 has have VBZ 3168 24 95 any any DT 3168 24 96 educational educational JJ 3168 24 97 , , , 3168 24 98 social social JJ 3168 24 99 , , , 3168 24 100 or or CC 3168 24 101 professional professional JJ 3168 24 102 importance importance NN 3168 24 103 , , , 3168 24 104 even even RB 3168 24 105 for for IN 3168 24 106 embody- embody- NNP 3168 24 107 ing e VBG 3168 24 108 controversial controversial JJ 3168 24 109 or or CC 3168 24 110 unorthodox unorthodox JJ 3168 24 111 ideas idea NNS 3168 24 112 , , , 3168 24 113 it -PRON- PRP 3168 24 114 is be VBZ 3168 24 115 supposed suppose VBN 3168 24 116 to to TO 3168 24 117 receive receive VB 3168 24 118 First First NNP 3168 24 119 Amendment Amendment NNP 3168 24 120 protection.9 protection.9 NNP 3168 24 121 The the DT 3168 24 122 second second JJ 3168 24 123 type type NN 3168 24 124 of of IN 3168 24 125 content content NN 3168 24 126 — — : 3168 24 127 child child NN 3168 24 128 pornography pornography NN 3168 24 129 — — : 3168 24 130 is be VBZ 3168 24 131 statutorily statutorily RB 3168 24 132 defined define VBN 3168 24 133 as as IN 3168 24 134 depicting depict VBG 3168 24 135 any any DT 3168 24 136 form form NN 3168 24 137 of of IN 3168 24 138 sexual sexual JJ 3168 24 139 conduct conduct NN 3168 24 140 or or CC 3168 24 141 lewd lewd VBZ 3168 24 142 exhi- exhi- NN 3168 24 143 bitionism bitionism NN 3168 24 144 involving involve VBG 3168 24 145 minors.10 minors.10 NNP 3168 24 146 Both both DT 3168 24 147 of of IN 3168 24 148 these these DT 3168 24 149 types type NNS 3168 24 150 of of IN 3168 24 151 speech speech NN 3168 24 152 have have VBP 3168 24 153 a a DT 3168 24 154 long long JJ 3168 24 155 history history NN 3168 24 156 of of IN 3168 24 157 being be VBG 3168 24 158 regulated regulate VBN 3168 24 159 and and CC 3168 24 160 being be VBG 3168 24 161 considered consider VBN 3168 24 162 as as IN 3168 24 163 having have VBG 3168 24 164 no no DT 3168 24 165 constitutional constitutional JJ 3168 24 166 protections protection NNS 3168 24 167 in in IN 3168 24 168 the the DT 3168 24 169 United United NNP 3168 24 170 States States NNP 3168 24 171 . . . 3168 25 1 The the DT 3168 25 2 third third JJ 3168 25 3 type type NN 3168 25 4 of of IN 3168 25 5 content content NN 3168 25 6 that that WDT 3168 25 7 must must MD 3168 25 8 be be VB 3168 25 9 filtered filter VBN 3168 25 10 — — : 3168 25 11 material material NN 3168 25 12 that that WDT 3168 25 13 is be VBZ 3168 25 14 harmful harmful JJ 3168 25 15 to to IN 3168 25 16 minors minor NNS 3168 25 17 — — : 3168 25 18 encompasses encompass VBZ 3168 25 19 a a DT 3168 25 20 range range NN 3168 25 21 of of IN 3168 25 22 otherwise otherwise RB 3168 25 23 protected protect VBN 3168 25 24 forms form NNS 3168 25 25 of of IN 3168 25 26 speech speech NN 3168 25 27 . . . 3168 26 1 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 26 2 defines define NNS 3168 26 3 “ " `` 3168 26 4 harmful harmful JJ 3168 26 5 to to IN 3168 26 6 minors minor NNS 3168 26 7 ” " '' 3168 26 8 as as IN 3168 26 9 including include VBG 3168 26 10 any any DT 3168 26 11 depiction depiction NN 3168 26 12 of of IN 3168 26 13 nudity nudity NN 3168 26 14 , , , 3168 26 15 sexual sexual JJ 3168 26 16 activity activity NN 3168 26 17 , , , 3168 26 18 or or CC 3168 26 19 simulated simulate VBN 3168 26 20 sexual sexual JJ 3168 26 21 activity activity NN 3168 26 22 that that WDT 3168 26 23 has have VBZ 3168 26 24 no no DT 3168 26 25 serious serious JJ 3168 26 26 literary literary JJ 3168 26 27 , , , 3168 26 28 artistic artistic JJ 3168 26 29 , , , 3168 26 30 political political JJ 3168 26 31 , , , 3168 26 32 or or CC 3168 26 33 scientific scientific JJ 3168 26 34 value value NN 3168 26 35 to to IN 3168 26 36 minors.11 minors.11 NNP 3168 26 37 The the DT 3168 26 38 material material NN 3168 26 39 that that WDT 3168 26 40 falls fall VBZ 3168 26 41 into into IN 3168 26 42 this this DT 3168 26 43 third third JJ 3168 26 44 category category NN 3168 26 45 is be VBZ 3168 26 46 constitutionally constitutionally RB 3168 26 47 protected protect VBN 3168 26 48 speech speech NN 3168 26 49 that that WDT 3168 26 50 encompasses encompass VBZ 3168 26 51 any any DT 3168 26 52 depiction depiction NN 3168 26 53 of of IN 3168 26 54 nudity nudity NN 3168 26 55 , , , 3168 26 56 sexual sexual JJ 3168 26 57 activity activity NN 3168 26 58 , , , 3168 26 59 or or CC 3168 26 60 simulated simulate VBN 3168 26 61 sexual sexual JJ 3168 26 62 activity activity NN 3168 26 63 that that WDT 3168 26 64 has have VBZ 3168 26 65 serious serious JJ 3168 26 66 literary literary JJ 3168 26 67 , , , 3168 26 68 artistic artistic JJ 3168 26 69 , , , 3168 26 70 political political JJ 3168 26 71 , , , 3168 26 72 or or CC 3168 26 73 scientific scientific JJ 3168 26 74 value value NN 3168 26 75 to to IN 3168 26 76 adults adult NNS 3168 26 77 . . . 3168 27 1 Along along IN 3168 27 2 with with IN 3168 27 3 possibly possibly RB 3168 27 4 includ- includ- NNP 3168 27 5 ing e VBG 3168 27 6 a a DT 3168 27 7 range range NN 3168 27 8 of of IN 3168 27 9 materials material NNS 3168 27 10 related relate VBN 3168 27 11 to to IN 3168 27 12 literature literature NN 3168 27 13 , , , 3168 27 14 art art NN 3168 27 15 , , , 3168 27 16 science science NN 3168 27 17 , , , 3168 27 18 and and CC 3168 27 19 policy policy NN 3168 27 20 , , , 3168 27 21 this this DT 3168 27 22 third third JJ 3168 27 23 category category NN 3168 27 24 may may MD 3168 27 25 involve involve VB 3168 27 26 materials material NNS 3168 27 27 on on IN 3168 27 28 issues issue NNS 3168 27 29 vital vital JJ 3168 27 30 to to IN 3168 27 31 personal personal JJ 3168 27 32 well well RB 3168 27 33 - - HYPH 3168 27 34 being be VBG 3168 27 35 such such JJ 3168 27 36 as as IN 3168 27 37 safe safe JJ 3168 27 38 sexual sexual JJ 3168 27 39 practices practice NNS 3168 27 40 , , , 3168 27 41 sexual sexual JJ 3168 27 42 identity identity NN 3168 27 43 issues issue NNS 3168 27 44 , , , 3168 27 45 and and CC 3168 27 46 even even RB 3168 27 47 general general JJ 3168 27 48 health health NN 3168 27 49 care care NN 3168 27 50 issues issue NNS 3168 27 51 such such JJ 3168 27 52 as as IN 3168 27 53 breast breast NN 3168 27 54 cancer cancer NN 3168 27 55 . . . 3168 28 1 In in IN 3168 28 2 addition addition NN 3168 28 3 to to IN 3168 28 4 the the DT 3168 28 5 filtering filtering NN 3168 28 6 requirements requirement NNS 3168 28 7 , , , 3168 28 8 section section NN 3168 28 9 1731 1731 CD 3168 28 10 also also RB 3168 28 11 prescribes prescribe VBZ 3168 28 12 an an DT 3168 28 13 Internet internet NN 3168 28 14 awareness awareness NN 3168 28 15 strategy strategy NN 3168 28 16 that that IN 3168 28 17 public public JJ 3168 28 18 libraries library NNS 3168 28 19 and and CC 3168 28 20 schools school NNS 3168 28 21 must must MD 3168 28 22 adopt adopt VB 3168 28 23 to to TO 3168 28 24 address address VB 3168 28 25 five five CD 3168 28 26 major major JJ 3168 28 27 Internet internet NN 3168 28 28 safety safety NN 3168 28 29 issues issue NNS 3168 28 30 related relate VBN 3168 28 31 to to IN 3168 28 32 minors minor NNS 3168 28 33 . . . 3168 29 1 It -PRON- PRP 3168 29 2 requires require VBZ 3168 29 3 librar- librar- NNP 3168 29 4 ies ie NNS 3168 29 5 and and CC 3168 29 6 schools school NNS 3168 29 7 to to TO 3168 29 8 provide provide VB 3168 29 9 reasonable reasonable JJ 3168 29 10 public public JJ 3168 29 11 notice notice NN 3168 29 12 and and CC 3168 29 13 to to TO 3168 29 14 hold hold VB 3168 29 15 at at RB 3168 29 16 least least RBS 3168 29 17 one one CD 3168 29 18 public public JJ 3168 29 19 hearing hearing NN 3168 29 20 or or CC 3168 29 21 meeting meeting NN 3168 29 22 to to TO 3168 29 23 address address VB 3168 29 24 these these DT 3168 29 25 Internet internet NN 3168 29 26 safety safety NN 3168 29 27 issues issue NNS 3168 29 28 . . . 3168 30 1 Requirements requirement NNS 3168 30 2 for for IN 3168 30 3 schools school NNS 3168 30 4 and and CC 3168 30 5 libraries library NNS 3168 30 6 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 30 7 includes include VBZ 3168 30 8 sections section NNS 3168 30 9 specifying specify VBG 3168 30 10 two two CD 3168 30 11 major major JJ 3168 30 12 strategies strategy NNS 3168 30 13 for for IN 3168 30 14 protecting protect VBG 3168 30 15 children child NNS 3168 30 16 online online RB 3168 30 17 ( ( -LRB- 3168 30 18 mainly mainly RB 3168 30 19 in in IN 3168 30 20 sections section NNS 3168 30 21 1711 1711 CD 3168 30 22 , , , 3168 30 23 1712 1712 CD 3168 30 24 , , , 3168 30 25 1721 1721 CD 3168 30 26 , , , 3168 30 27 and and CC 3168 30 28 1732 1732 CD 3168 30 29 ) ) -RRB- 3168 30 30 as as RB 3168 30 31 well well RB 3168 30 32 as as IN 3168 30 33 sections section NNS 3168 30 34 describing describe VBG 3168 30 35 vari- vari- JJ 3168 30 36 ous ous JJ 3168 30 37 definitions definition NNS 3168 30 38 and and CC 3168 30 39 procedural procedural JJ 3168 30 40 issues issue NNS 3168 30 41 for for IN 3168 30 42 implementing implement VBG 3168 30 43 the the DT 3168 30 44 strategies strategy NNS 3168 30 45 ( ( -LRB- 3168 30 46 mainly mainly RB 3168 30 47 in in IN 3168 30 48 sections section NNS 3168 30 49 1701 1701 CD 3168 30 50 , , , 3168 30 51 1703 1703 CD 3168 30 52 , , , 3168 30 53 1731 1731 CD 3168 30 54 , , , 3168 30 55 1732 1732 CD 3168 30 56 , , , 3168 30 57 1733 1733 CD 3168 30 58 , , , 3168 30 59 and and CC 3168 30 60 1741 1741 CD 3168 30 61 ) ) -RRB- 3168 30 62 . . . 3168 31 1 Section section NN 3168 31 2 1711 1711 CD 3168 31 3 specifies specify VBZ 3168 31 4 the the DT 3168 31 5 primary primary JJ 3168 31 6 Internet internet NN 3168 31 7 protec- protec- NN 3168 31 8 tion tion NN 3168 31 9 strategy strategy NN 3168 31 10 — — : 3168 31 11 filtering filtering NN 3168 31 12 — — : 3168 31 13 in in IN 3168 31 14 public public JJ 3168 31 15 schools school NNS 3168 31 16 . . . 3168 32 1 Specifically specifically RB 3168 32 2 , , , 3168 32 3 it -PRON- PRP 3168 32 4 amends amend VBZ 3168 32 5 the the DT 3168 32 6 Elementary Elementary NNP 3168 32 7 and and CC 3168 32 8 Secondary Secondary NNP 3168 32 9 Education Education NNP 3168 32 10 Act Act NNP 3168 32 11 of of IN 3168 32 12 1965 1965 CD 3168 32 13 by by IN 3168 32 14 limiting limit VBG 3168 32 15 funding funding NN 3168 32 16 availability availability NN 3168 32 17 for for IN 3168 32 18 schools school NNS 3168 32 19 under under IN 3168 32 20 section section NN 3168 32 21 254 254 CD 3168 32 22 of of IN 3168 32 23 the the DT 3168 32 24 Communication Communication NNP 3168 32 25 Act Act NNP 3168 32 26 of of IN 3168 32 27 1934 1934 CD 3168 32 28 . . . 3168 33 1 Through through IN 3168 33 2 a a DT 3168 33 3 compliance compliance NN 3168 33 4 certification certification NN 3168 33 5 process process NN 3168 33 6 within within IN 3168 33 7 a a DT 3168 33 8 school school NN 3168 33 9 under under IN 3168 33 10 supervision supervision NN 3168 33 11 by by IN 3168 33 12 the the DT 3168 33 13 local local JJ 3168 33 14 educational educational JJ 3168 33 15 agency agency NN 3168 33 16 , , , 3168 33 17 it -PRON- PRP 3168 33 18 requires require VBZ 3168 33 19 schools school NNS 3168 33 20 to to TO 3168 33 21 include include VB 3168 33 22 the the DT 3168 33 23 operation operation NN 3168 33 24 of of IN 3168 33 25 a a DT 3168 33 26 technology technology NN 3168 33 27 protec- protec- NN 3168 33 28 tion tion NN 3168 33 29 measure measure NN 3168 33 30 that that WDT 3168 33 31 protects protect VBZ 3168 33 32 students student NNS 3168 33 33 against against IN 3168 33 34 access access NN 3168 33 35 to to IN 3168 33 36 visual visual JJ 3168 33 37 depictions depiction NNS 3168 33 38 that that WDT 3168 33 39 are be VBP 3168 33 40 obscene obscene JJ 3168 33 41 , , , 3168 33 42 are be VBP 3168 33 43 child child NN 3168 33 44 pornography pornography NN 3168 33 45 , , , 3168 33 46 or or CC 3168 33 47 are be VBP 3168 33 48 harmful harmful JJ 3168 33 49 to to IN 3168 33 50 minors minor NNS 3168 33 51 under under IN 3168 33 52 the the DT 3168 33 53 age age NN 3168 33 54 of of IN 3168 33 55 seventeen seventeen CD 3168 33 56 . . . 3168 34 1 Likewise likewise RB 3168 34 2 , , , 3168 34 3 section section NN 3168 34 4 1712 1712 CD 3168 34 5 specifies specify VBZ 3168 34 6 the the DT 3168 34 7 same same JJ 3168 34 8 filtering filtering NN 3168 34 9 strategy strategy NN 3168 34 10 in in IN 3168 34 11 public public JJ 3168 34 12 libraries library NNS 3168 34 13 . . . 3168 35 1 Specifically specifically RB 3168 35 2 , , , 3168 35 3 it -PRON- PRP 3168 35 4 amends amend VBZ 3168 35 5 section section NN 3168 35 6 224 224 CD 3168 35 7 of of IN 3168 35 8 the the DT 3168 35 9 Museum Museum NNP 3168 35 10 and and CC 3168 35 11 Library Library NNP 3168 35 12 Service Service NNP 3168 35 13 Act Act NNP 3168 35 14 of of IN 3168 35 15 1996/2003 1996/2003 CD 3168 35 16 by by IN 3168 35 17 limiting limit VBG 3168 35 18 funding funding NN 3168 35 19 availability availability NN 3168 35 20 for for IN 3168 35 21 libraries library NNS 3168 35 22 under under IN 3168 35 23 sec- sec- JJ 3168 35 24 tion tion NN 3168 35 25 254 254 CD 3168 35 26 of of IN 3168 35 27 the the DT 3168 35 28 Communication Communication NNP 3168 35 29 Act Act NNP 3168 35 30 of of IN 3168 35 31 1934 1934 CD 3168 35 32 . . . 3168 36 1 Through through IN 3168 36 2 a a DT 3168 36 3 compliance compliance NN 3168 36 4 certification certification NN 3168 36 5 process process NN 3168 36 6 within within IN 3168 36 7 a a DT 3168 36 8 library library NN 3168 36 9 under under IN 3168 36 10 supervision supervision NN 3168 36 11 by by IN 3168 36 12 the the DT 3168 36 13 Institute Institute NNP 3168 36 14 of of IN 3168 36 15 Museum Museum NNP 3168 36 16 and and CC 3168 36 17 Library Library NNP 3168 36 18 Services Services NNPS 3168 36 19 ( ( -LRB- 3168 36 20 IMLS IMLS NNP 3168 36 21 ) ) -RRB- 3168 36 22 , , , 3168 36 23 it -PRON- PRP 3168 36 24 requires require VBZ 3168 36 25 libraries library NNS 3168 36 26 to to TO 3168 36 27 include include VB 3168 36 28 the the DT 3168 36 29 opera- opera- JJ 3168 36 30 tion tion NN 3168 36 31 of of IN 3168 36 32 a a DT 3168 36 33 technology technology NN 3168 36 34 protection protection NN 3168 36 35 measure measure NN 3168 36 36 that that WDT 3168 36 37 protects protect VBZ 3168 36 38 stu- stu- NN 3168 36 39 dents dent NNS 3168 36 40 against against IN 3168 36 41 access access NN 3168 36 42 to to IN 3168 36 43 visual visual JJ 3168 36 44 depictions depiction NNS 3168 36 45 that that WDT 3168 36 46 are be VBP 3168 36 47 obscene obscene JJ 3168 36 48 , , , 3168 36 49 child child NN 3168 36 50 pornography pornography NN 3168 36 51 , , , 3168 36 52 or or CC 3168 36 53 harmful harmful JJ 3168 36 54 to to IN 3168 36 55 minors minor NNS 3168 36 56 under under IN 3168 36 57 the the DT 3168 36 58 age age NN 3168 36 59 of of IN 3168 36 60 seventeen seventeen CD 3168 36 61 . . . 3168 37 1 Section section NN 3168 37 2 1721 1721 CD 3168 37 3 is be VBZ 3168 37 4 a a DT 3168 37 5 requirement requirement NN 3168 37 6 for for IN 3168 37 7 both both DT 3168 37 8 libraries library NNS 3168 37 9 and and CC 3168 37 10 schools school NNS 3168 37 11 to to TO 3168 37 12 enforce enforce VB 3168 37 13 the the DT 3168 37 14 Internet internet NN 3168 37 15 safety safety NN 3168 37 16 policy policy NN 3168 37 17 with with IN 3168 37 18 the the DT 3168 37 19 Internet internet NN 3168 37 20 safety safety NN 3168 37 21 policy policy NN 3168 37 22 strategy strategy NN 3168 37 23 and and CC 3168 37 24 the the DT 3168 37 25 filtering filter VBG 3168 37 26 technol- technol- XX 3168 37 27 ogy ogy NN 3168 37 28 strategy strategy NN 3168 37 29 as as IN 3168 37 30 a a DT 3168 37 31 condition condition NN 3168 37 32 of of IN 3168 37 33 universal universal JJ 3168 37 34 service service NN 3168 37 35 discounts discount NNS 3168 37 36 . . . 3168 38 1 Specifically specifically RB 3168 38 2 , , , 3168 38 3 it -PRON- PRP 3168 38 4 amends amend VBZ 3168 38 5 section section NN 3168 38 6 254 254 CD 3168 38 7 of of IN 3168 38 8 the the DT 3168 38 9 Communication Communication NNP 3168 38 10 Act Act NNP 3168 38 11 of of IN 3168 38 12 1934 1934 CD 3168 38 13 and and CC 3168 38 14 requests request NNS 3168 38 15 both both CC 3168 38 16 schools school NNS 3168 38 17 and and CC 3168 38 18 libraries library NNS 3168 38 19 to to TO 3168 38 20 monitor monitor VB 3168 38 21 the the DT 3168 38 22 online online JJ 3168 38 23 activities activity NNS 3168 38 24 of of IN 3168 38 25 minors minor NNS 3168 38 26 , , , 3168 38 27 operate operate VBP 3168 38 28 a a DT 3168 38 29 tech- tech- JJ 3168 38 30 nical nical JJ 3168 38 31 protection protection NN 3168 38 32 measure measure NN 3168 38 33 , , , 3168 38 34 provide provide VB 3168 38 35 reasonable reasonable JJ 3168 38 36 public public JJ 3168 38 37 notice notice NN 3168 38 38 , , , 3168 38 39 and and CC 3168 38 40 hold hold VB 3168 38 41 at at RB 3168 38 42 least least RBS 3168 38 43 one one CD 3168 38 44 public public JJ 3168 38 45 hearing hearing NN 3168 38 46 or or CC 3168 38 47 meeting meeting NN 3168 38 48 to to TO 3168 38 49 address address VB 3168 38 50 the the DT 3168 38 51 Internet internet NN 3168 38 52 safety safety NN 3168 38 53 policy policy NN 3168 38 54 . . . 3168 39 1 This this DT 3168 39 2 is be VBZ 3168 39 3 through through IN 3168 39 4 the the DT 3168 39 5 8 8 CD 3168 39 6 INFORMATION information NN 3168 39 7 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3168 39 8 AND and CC 3168 39 9 LIBRARIES library NNS 3168 39 10 | | NNP 3168 39 11 MARCH MARCH NNP 3168 39 12 2009 2009 CD 3168 39 13 certification certification NN 3168 39 14 process process NN 3168 39 15 regulated regulate VBN 3168 39 16 by by IN 3168 39 17 the the DT 3168 39 18 FCC FCC NNP 3168 39 19 . . . 3168 40 1 Section section NN 3168 40 2 1732 1732 CD 3168 40 3 , , , 3168 40 4 titled title VBD 3168 40 5 the the DT 3168 40 6 Neighborhood Neighborhood NNP 3168 40 7 Children Children NNPS 3168 40 8 ’s ’s POS 3168 40 9 Internet Internet NNP 3168 40 10 Protection Protection NNP 3168 40 11 Act Act NNP 3168 40 12 ( ( -LRB- 3168 40 13 NCIPA NCIPA NNP 3168 40 14 ) ) -RRB- 3168 40 15 , , , 3168 40 16 amends amend NNS 3168 40 17 section section NN 3168 40 18 254 254 CD 3168 40 19 of of IN 3168 40 20 the the DT 3168 40 21 Communication Communication NNP 3168 40 22 Act Act NNP 3168 40 23 of of IN 3168 40 24 1934 1934 CD 3168 40 25 and and CC 3168 40 26 requires require VBZ 3168 40 27 schools school NNS 3168 40 28 and and CC 3168 40 29 libraries library NNS 3168 40 30 to to TO 3168 40 31 adopt adopt VB 3168 40 32 and and CC 3168 40 33 implement implement VB 3168 40 34 an an DT 3168 40 35 Internet internet NN 3168 40 36 safety safety NN 3168 40 37 policy policy NN 3168 40 38 . . . 3168 41 1 It -PRON- PRP 3168 41 2 specifies specify VBZ 3168 41 3 five five CD 3168 41 4 types type NNS 3168 41 5 of of IN 3168 41 6 Internet internet NN 3168 41 7 safety safety NN 3168 41 8 issues issue NNS 3168 41 9 : : : 3168 41 10 ( ( -LRB- 3168 41 11 1 1 LS 3168 41 12 ) ) -RRB- 3168 41 13 access access NN 3168 41 14 by by IN 3168 41 15 minors minor NNS 3168 41 16 to to TO 3168 41 17 inappropriate inappropriate VB 3168 41 18 matter matter NN 3168 41 19 on on IN 3168 41 20 the the DT 3168 41 21 Internet internet NN 3168 41 22 ; ; : 3168 41 23 ( ( -LRB- 3168 41 24 2 2 LS 3168 41 25 ) ) -RRB- 3168 41 26 safety safety NN 3168 41 27 and and CC 3168 41 28 security security NN 3168 41 29 of of IN 3168 41 30 minors minor NNS 3168 41 31 when when WRB 3168 41 32 using use VBG 3168 41 33 e e NN 3168 41 34 - - NN 3168 41 35 mail mail NN 3168 41 36 , , , 3168 41 37 chat chat NN 3168 41 38 rooms room NNS 3168 41 39 , , , 3168 41 40 and and CC 3168 41 41 other other JJ 3168 41 42 online online JJ 3168 41 43 communications communication NNS 3168 41 44 ; ; , 3168 41 45 ( ( -LRB- 3168 41 46 3 3 LS 3168 41 47 ) ) -RRB- 3168 41 48 unauthor- unauthor- JJ 3168 41 49 ized ized JJ 3168 41 50 access access NN 3168 41 51 ; ; : 3168 41 52 ( ( -LRB- 3168 41 53 4 4 LS 3168 41 54 ) ) -RRB- 3168 41 55 unauthorized unauthorized JJ 3168 41 56 disclosure disclosure NN 3168 41 57 , , , 3168 41 58 use use NN 3168 41 59 , , , 3168 41 60 and and CC 3168 41 61 dis- dis- IN 3168 41 62 semination semination NN 3168 41 63 of of IN 3168 41 64 personal personal JJ 3168 41 65 information information NN 3168 41 66 ; ; , 3168 41 67 and and CC 3168 41 68 ( ( -LRB- 3168 41 69 5 5 LS 3168 41 70 ) ) -RRB- 3168 41 71 measures measure NNS 3168 41 72 to to TO 3168 41 73 restrict restrict VB 3168 41 74 access access NN 3168 41 75 to to IN 3168 41 76 harmful harmful JJ 3168 41 77 online online JJ 3168 41 78 materials material NNS 3168 41 79 . . . 3168 42 1 From from IN 3168 42 2 the the DT 3168 42 3 above above JJ 3168 42 4 summary summary NN 3168 42 5 , , , 3168 42 6 it -PRON- PRP 3168 42 7 is be VBZ 3168 42 8 clear clear JJ 3168 42 9 that that IN 3168 42 10 ( ( -LRB- 3168 42 11 1 1 LS 3168 42 12 ) ) -RRB- 3168 42 13 the the DT 3168 42 14 two two CD 3168 42 15 protection protection NN 3168 42 16 strategies strategy NNS 3168 42 17 of of IN 3168 42 18 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 42 19 ( ( -LRB- 3168 42 20 the the DT 3168 42 21 Internet internet NN 3168 42 22 filtering filter VBG 3168 42 23 strat- strat- NN 3168 42 24 egy egy NN 3168 42 25 and and CC 3168 42 26 safety safety NN 3168 42 27 policy policy NN 3168 42 28 strategy strategy NN 3168 42 29 ) ) -RRB- 3168 42 30 were be VBD 3168 42 31 equally equally RB 3168 42 32 enforced enforce VBN 3168 42 33 in in IN 3168 42 34 both both CC 3168 42 35 public public JJ 3168 42 36 schools school NNS 3168 42 37 and and CC 3168 42 38 public public JJ 3168 42 39 libraries library NNS 3168 42 40 because because IN 3168 42 41 they -PRON- PRP 3168 42 42 are be VBP 3168 42 43 two two CD 3168 42 44 of of IN 3168 42 45 the the DT 3168 42 46 most most RBS 3168 42 47 important important JJ 3168 42 48 social social JJ 3168 42 49 institutions institution NNS 3168 42 50 for for IN 3168 42 51 children child NNS 3168 42 52 ’s ’s POS 3168 42 53 Internet internet NN 3168 42 54 safety safety NN 3168 42 55 ; ; : 3168 42 56 ( ( -LRB- 3168 42 57 2 2 LS 3168 42 58 ) ) -RRB- 3168 42 59 the the DT 3168 42 60 nature nature NN 3168 42 61 of of IN 3168 42 62 the the DT 3168 42 63 implementation implementation NN 3168 42 64 mechanism mechanism NN 3168 42 65 is be VBZ 3168 42 66 exactly exactly RB 3168 42 67 the the DT 3168 42 68 same same JJ 3168 42 69 , , , 3168 42 70 using use VBG 3168 42 71 the the DT 3168 42 72 same same JJ 3168 42 73 federal federal JJ 3168 42 74 funding funding NN 3168 42 75 mechanisms mechanism NNS 3168 42 76 as as IN 3168 42 77 the the DT 3168 42 78 sole sole NNP 3168 42 79 financial financial NNP 3168 42 80 incentive incentive NN 3168 42 81 ( ( -LRB- 3168 42 82 lim- lim- RB 3168 42 83 iting ite VBG 3168 42 84 funding funding NN 3168 42 85 availability availability NN 3168 42 86 for for IN 3168 42 87 schools school NNS 3168 42 88 and and CC 3168 42 89 libraries library NNS 3168 42 90 under under IN 3168 42 91 section section NN 3168 42 92 254 254 CD 3168 42 93 of of IN 3168 42 94 the the DT 3168 42 95 Communication Communication NNP 3168 42 96 Act Act NNP 3168 42 97 of of IN 3168 42 98 1934 1934 CD 3168 42 99 ) ) -RRB- 3168 42 100 through through IN 3168 42 101 a a DT 3168 42 102 compliance compliance NN 3168 42 103 certification certification NN 3168 42 104 process process NN 3168 42 105 to to TO 3168 42 106 enforce enforce VB 3168 42 107 the the DT 3168 42 108 imple- imple- NN 3168 42 109 mentation mentation NN 3168 42 110 of of IN 3168 42 111 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 42 112 ; ; : 3168 42 113 and and CC 3168 42 114 ( ( -LRB- 3168 42 115 3 3 LS 3168 42 116 ) ) -RRB- 3168 42 117 the the DT 3168 42 118 actual actual JJ 3168 42 119 implementation implementation NN 3168 42 120 procedure procedure NN 3168 42 121 differs differ NNS 3168 42 122 in in IN 3168 42 123 libraries library NNS 3168 42 124 and and CC 3168 42 125 schools school NNS 3168 42 126 , , , 3168 42 127 with with IN 3168 42 128 schools school NNS 3168 42 129 to to TO 3168 42 130 be be VB 3168 42 131 certified certify VBN 3168 42 132 under under IN 3168 42 133 the the DT 3168 42 134 supervision supervision NN 3168 42 135 of of IN 3168 42 136 local local JJ 3168 42 137 educational educational JJ 3168 42 138 agencies agency NNS 3168 42 139 ( ( -LRB- 3168 42 140 such such JJ 3168 42 141 as as IN 3168 42 142 school school NN 3168 42 143 districts district NNS 3168 42 144 and and CC 3168 42 145 state state NN 3168 42 146 departments department NNS 3168 42 147 of of IN 3168 42 148 education education NN 3168 42 149 ) ) -RRB- 3168 42 150 and and CC 3168 42 151 with with IN 3168 42 152 libraries library NNS 3168 42 153 to to TO 3168 42 154 be be VB 3168 42 155 certified certify VBN 3168 42 156 within within IN 3168 42 157 a a DT 3168 42 158 library library NN 3168 42 159 under under IN 3168 42 160 the the DT 3168 42 161 supervision supervision NN 3168 42 162 of of IN 3168 42 163 the the DT 3168 42 164 IMLS IMLS NNP 3168 42 165 . . . 3168 43 1 Economics Economics NNP 3168 43 2 of of IN 3168 43 3 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 43 4 The the DT 3168 43 5 Universal Universal NNP 3168 43 6 Service Service NNP 3168 43 7 program program NN 3168 43 8 ( ( -LRB- 3168 43 9 commonly commonly RB 3168 43 10 known know VBN 3168 43 11 as as IN 3168 43 12 E e NN 3168 43 13 – – : 3168 43 14 Rate rate NN 3168 43 15 ) ) -RRB- 3168 43 16 was be VBD 3168 43 17 established establish VBN 3168 43 18 by by IN 3168 43 19 the the DT 3168 43 20 Telecommunications Telecommunications NNPS 3168 43 21 Act Act NNP 3168 43 22 of of IN 3168 43 23 1996 1996 CD 3168 43 24 to to TO 3168 43 25 provide provide VB 3168 43 26 discounts discount NNS 3168 43 27 , , , 3168 43 28 ranging range VBG 3168 43 29 from from IN 3168 43 30 20 20 CD 3168 43 31 to to TO 3168 43 32 90 90 CD 3168 43 33 percent percent NN 3168 43 34 , , , 3168 43 35 to to IN 3168 43 36 libraries library NNS 3168 43 37 and and CC 3168 43 38 schools school NNS 3168 43 39 for for IN 3168 43 40 telecommunications telecommunications NN 3168 43 41 services service NNS 3168 43 42 , , , 3168 43 43 Internet internet NN 3168 43 44 services service NNS 3168 43 45 , , , 3168 43 46 internal internal JJ 3168 43 47 systems system NNS 3168 43 48 , , , 3168 43 49 and and CC 3168 43 50 equip- equip- VBZ 3168 43 51 ment.12 ment.12 NNP 3168 43 52 The the DT 3168 43 53 program program NN 3168 43 54 has have VBZ 3168 43 55 been be VBN 3168 43 56 very very RB 3168 43 57 successful successful JJ 3168 43 58 , , , 3168 43 59 provid- provid- NN 3168 43 60 ing e VBG 3168 43 61 approximately approximately RB 3168 43 62 $ $ $ 3168 43 63 2.25 2.25 CD 3168 43 64 billion billion CD 3168 43 65 dollars dollar NNS 3168 43 66 a a DT 3168 43 67 year year NN 3168 43 68 to to IN 3168 43 69 public public JJ 3168 43 70 schools school NNS 3168 43 71 , , , 3168 43 72 public public JJ 3168 43 73 libraries library NNS 3168 43 74 , , , 3168 43 75 and and CC 3168 43 76 public public JJ 3168 43 77 hospitals hospital NNS 3168 43 78 . . . 3168 44 1 The the DT 3168 44 2 vast vast JJ 3168 44 3 majority majority NN 3168 44 4 of of IN 3168 44 5 E e JJ 3168 44 6 - - NN 3168 44 7 Rate rate NN 3168 44 8 funding funding NN 3168 44 9 — — : 3168 44 10 about about IN 3168 44 11 90 90 CD 3168 44 12 percent percent NN 3168 44 13 — — : 3168 44 14 goes go VBZ 3168 44 15 to to IN 3168 44 16 public public JJ 3168 44 17 schools school NNS 3168 44 18 each each DT 3168 44 19 year year NN 3168 44 20 , , , 3168 44 21 with with IN 3168 44 22 roughly roughly RB 3168 44 23 4 4 CD 3168 44 24 percent percent NN 3168 44 25 being be VBG 3168 44 26 awarded award VBN 3168 44 27 to to IN 3168 44 28 public public JJ 3168 44 29 libraries library NNS 3168 44 30 and and CC 3168 44 31 the the DT 3168 44 32 remainder remainder NN 3168 44 33 going go VBG 3168 44 34 to to IN 3168 44 35 hospitals.13 hospitals.13 NNP 3168 44 36 The the DT 3168 44 37 emphasis emphasis NN 3168 44 38 on on IN 3168 44 39 funding funding NN 3168 44 40 schools school NNS 3168 44 41 results result NNS 3168 44 42 from from IN 3168 44 43 the the DT 3168 44 44 large large JJ 3168 44 45 number number NN 3168 44 46 of of IN 3168 44 47 public public JJ 3168 44 48 schools school NNS 3168 44 49 and and CC 3168 44 50 the the DT 3168 44 51 size- size- XX 3168 44 52 able able JJ 3168 44 53 computing computing NN 3168 44 54 needs need NNS 3168 44 55 of of IN 3168 44 56 all all DT 3168 44 57 of of IN 3168 44 58 these these DT 3168 44 59 schools school NNS 3168 44 60 . . . 3168 45 1 But but CC 3168 45 2 even even RB 3168 45 3 4 4 CD 3168 45 4 percent percent NN 3168 45 5 of of IN 3168 45 6 the the DT 3168 45 7 E e JJ 3168 45 8 - - NN 3168 45 9 Rate rate NN 3168 45 10 funding funding NN 3168 45 11 is be VBZ 3168 45 12 quite quite RB 3168 45 13 substantial substantial JJ 3168 45 14 , , , 3168 45 15 with with IN 3168 45 16 public public JJ 3168 45 17 libraries library NNS 3168 45 18 receiving receive VBG 3168 45 19 more more JJR 3168 45 20 than than IN 3168 45 21 $ $ $ 3168 45 22 250 250 CD 3168 45 23 million million CD 3168 45 24 between between IN 3168 45 25 2000 2000 CD 3168 45 26 and and CC 3168 45 27 2003.14 2003.14 CD 3168 45 28 Schools Schools NNPS 3168 45 29 received receive VBD 3168 45 30 about about RB 3168 45 31 $ $ $ 3168 45 32 12 12 CD 3168 45 33 billion billion CD 3168 45 34 in in IN 3168 45 35 the the DT 3168 45 36 same same JJ 3168 45 37 time time NN 3168 45 38 period.15 period.15 NNP 3168 45 39 Along along IN 3168 45 40 with with IN 3168 45 41 E e NN 3168 45 42 - - NN 3168 45 43 Rate rate NN 3168 45 44 funds fund NNS 3168 45 45 , , , 3168 45 46 the the DT 3168 45 47 Library Library NNP 3168 45 48 Services Services NNPS 3168 45 49 and and CC 3168 45 50 Technology Technology NNP 3168 45 51 Act Act NNP 3168 45 52 ( ( -LRB- 3168 45 53 LSTA LSTA NNP 3168 45 54 ) ) -RRB- 3168 45 55 program program NN 3168 45 56 adminis- adminis- NN 3168 45 57 tered tere VBN 3168 45 58 by by IN 3168 45 59 the the DT 3168 45 60 IMLS IMLS NNP 3168 45 61 provides provide VBZ 3168 45 62 money money NN 3168 45 63 to to IN 3168 45 64 each each DT 3168 45 65 state state NN 3168 45 66 library library JJ 3168 45 67 agency agency NN 3168 45 68 to to TO 3168 45 69 use use VB 3168 45 70 on on IN 3168 45 71 library library NN 3168 45 72 programs program NNS 3168 45 73 and and CC 3168 45 74 services service NNS 3168 45 75 in in IN 3168 45 76 that that DT 3168 45 77 state state NN 3168 45 78 , , , 3168 45 79 though though IN 3168 45 80 the the DT 3168 45 81 amount amount NN 3168 45 82 of of IN 3168 45 83 these these DT 3168 45 84 funds fund NNS 3168 45 85 is be VBZ 3168 45 86 considerably considerably RB 3168 45 87 lower low JJR 3168 45 88 than than IN 3168 45 89 E e JJ 3168 45 90 - - NN 3168 45 91 Rate rate NN 3168 45 92 funds fund NNS 3168 45 93 . . . 3168 46 1 The the DT 3168 46 2 American American NNP 3168 46 3 Library Library NNP 3168 46 4 Association Association NNP 3168 46 5 ( ( -LRB- 3168 46 6 ALA ALA NNP 3168 46 7 ) ) -RRB- 3168 46 8 has have VBZ 3168 46 9 noted note VBN 3168 46 10 that that IN 3168 46 11 the the DT 3168 46 12 E e JJ 3168 46 13 - - NN 3168 46 14 Rate rate NN 3168 46 15 program program NN 3168 46 16 has have VBZ 3168 46 17 been be VBN 3168 46 18 particularly particularly RB 3168 46 19 significant significant JJ 3168 46 20 in in IN 3168 46 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 3168 46 22 role role NN 3168 46 23 of of IN 3168 46 24 expanding expand VBG 3168 46 25 online online JJ 3168 46 26 access access NN 3168 46 27 to to IN 3168 46 28 students student NNS 3168 46 29 and and CC 3168 46 30 to to IN 3168 46 31 library library JJ 3168 46 32 patrons patron NNS 3168 46 33 in in IN 3168 46 34 both both CC 3168 46 35 rural rural JJ 3168 46 36 and and CC 3168 46 37 underserved underserved JJ 3168 46 38 com- com- NN 3168 46 39 munities.16 munities.16 NNP 3168 46 40 In in IN 3168 46 41 addition addition NN 3168 46 42 to to IN 3168 46 43 the the DT 3168 46 44 effect effect NN 3168 46 45 on on IN 3168 46 46 libraries library NNS 3168 46 47 , , , 3168 46 48 E e NN 3168 46 49 - - NN 3168 46 50 Rate rate NN 3168 46 51 and and CC 3168 46 52 LSTA lsta NN 3168 46 53 funds fund NNS 3168 46 54 have have VBP 3168 46 55 significantly significantly RB 3168 46 56 affected affect VBN 3168 46 57 the the DT 3168 46 58 lives life NNS 3168 46 59 of of IN 3168 46 60 individuals individual NNS 3168 46 61 and and CC 3168 46 62 communities community NNS 3168 46 63 . . . 3168 47 1 These these DT 3168 47 2 programs program NNS 3168 47 3 have have VBP 3168 47 4 contributed contribute VBN 3168 47 5 to to IN 3168 47 6 the the DT 3168 47 7 increase increase NN 3168 47 8 in in IN 3168 47 9 the the DT 3168 47 10 availability availability NN 3168 47 11 of of IN 3168 47 12 free free JJ 3168 47 13 public public JJ 3168 47 14 Internet internet NN 3168 47 15 access access NN 3168 47 16 in in IN 3168 47 17 schools school NNS 3168 47 18 and and CC 3168 47 19 libraries library NNS 3168 47 20 . . . 3168 48 1 By by IN 3168 48 2 2001 2001 CD 3168 48 3 , , , 3168 48 4 more more JJR 3168 48 5 than than IN 3168 48 6 99 99 CD 3168 48 7 percent percent NN 3168 48 8 of of IN 3168 48 9 public public JJ 3168 48 10 school school NN 3168 48 11 libraries library NNS 3168 48 12 provided provide VBD 3168 48 13 students student NNS 3168 48 14 with with IN 3168 48 15 Internet internet NN 3168 48 16 access.17 access.17 NNP 3168 48 17 By by IN 3168 48 18 2007 2007 CD 3168 48 19 , , , 3168 48 20 99.7 99.7 CD 3168 48 21 percent percent NN 3168 48 22 of of IN 3168 48 23 public public JJ 3168 48 24 library library NN 3168 48 25 branches branch NNS 3168 48 26 were be VBD 3168 48 27 connected connect VBN 3168 48 28 to to IN 3168 48 29 the the DT 3168 48 30 Internet internet NN 3168 48 31 , , , 3168 48 32 and and CC 3168 48 33 99.1 99.1 CD 3168 48 34 percent percent NN 3168 48 35 of of IN 3168 48 36 public public JJ 3168 48 37 library library NN 3168 48 38 branches branch NNS 3168 48 39 offered offer VBD 3168 48 40 pub- pub- JJ 3168 48 41 lic lic JJ 3168 48 42 Internet internet NN 3168 48 43 access.18 access.18 NNP 3168 48 44 However however RB 3168 48 45 , , , 3168 48 46 only only RB 3168 48 47 a a DT 3168 48 48 small small JJ 3168 48 49 portion portion NN 3168 48 50 of of IN 3168 48 51 libraries library NNS 3168 48 52 and and CC 3168 48 53 schools school NNS 3168 48 54 used use VBN 3168 48 55 filters filter NNS 3168 48 56 prior prior RB 3168 48 57 to to IN 3168 48 58 CIPA.19 CIPA.19 NNP 3168 48 59 Since since IN 3168 48 60 the the DT 3168 48 61 advent advent NN 3168 48 62 of of IN 3168 48 63 computers computer NNS 3168 48 64 in in IN 3168 48 65 libraries library NNS 3168 48 66 , , , 3168 48 67 librarians librarian NNS 3168 48 68 typically typically RB 3168 48 69 had have VBD 3168 48 70 used use VBN 3168 48 71 informal informal JJ 3168 48 72 monitoring monitoring NN 3168 48 73 practices practice NNS 3168 48 74 for for IN 3168 48 75 computer computer NN 3168 48 76 users user NNS 3168 48 77 to to TO 3168 48 78 ensure ensure VB 3168 48 79 that that IN 3168 48 80 nothing nothing NN 3168 48 81 age age NN 3168 48 82 inappropriate inappropriate JJ 3168 48 83 or or CC 3168 48 84 morally morally RB 3168 48 85 offensive offensive JJ 3168 48 86 was be VBD 3168 48 87 publicly publicly RB 3168 48 88 visible.20 visible.20 NNP 3168 48 89 Some some DT 3168 48 90 individual individual JJ 3168 48 91 school school NN 3168 48 92 and and CC 3168 48 93 library library NN 3168 48 94 systems system NNS 3168 48 95 , , , 3168 48 96 such such JJ 3168 48 97 as as IN 3168 48 98 in in IN 3168 48 99 Kansas Kansas NNP 3168 48 100 and and CC 3168 48 101 Indiana Indiana NNP 3168 48 102 , , , 3168 48 103 even even RB 3168 48 104 developed develop VBD 3168 48 105 formal formal JJ 3168 48 106 or or CC 3168 48 107 informal informal JJ 3168 48 108 statewide statewide JJ 3168 48 109 Internet internet NN 3168 48 110 safety safety NN 3168 48 111 strategies strategy NNS 3168 48 112 and and CC 3168 48 113 approaches.21 approaches.21 NNP 3168 48 114 why why WRB 3168 48 115 were be VBD 3168 48 116 only only RB 3168 48 117 libraries library NNS 3168 48 118 and and CC 3168 48 119 schools school NNS 3168 48 120 chosen choose VBN 3168 48 121 to to TO 3168 48 122 protect protect VB 3168 48 123 children child NNS 3168 48 124 ’s ’s POS 3168 48 125 online online JJ 3168 48 126 safety safety NN 3168 48 127 ? ? . 3168 49 1 While while IN 3168 49 2 there there EX 3168 49 3 are be VBP 3168 49 4 many many JJ 3168 49 5 social social JJ 3168 49 6 institutions institution NNS 3168 49 7 that that WDT 3168 49 8 could could MD 3168 49 9 have have VB 3168 49 10 been be VBN 3168 49 11 the the DT 3168 49 12 focus focus NN 3168 49 13 of of IN 3168 49 14 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 49 15 , , , 3168 49 16 the the DT 3168 49 17 law law NN 3168 49 18 places place VBZ 3168 49 19 the the DT 3168 49 20 requirements requirement NNS 3168 49 21 specifically specifically RB 3168 49 22 on on IN 3168 49 23 public public JJ 3168 49 24 libraries library NNS 3168 49 25 and and CC 3168 49 26 public public JJ 3168 49 27 schools school NNS 3168 49 28 . . . 3168 50 1 If if IN 3168 50 2 Congress Congress NNP 3168 50 3 was be VBD 3168 50 4 so so RB 3168 50 5 interested interested JJ 3168 50 6 in in IN 3168 50 7 protecting protect VBG 3168 50 8 children child NNS 3168 50 9 from from IN 3168 50 10 access access NN 3168 50 11 to to IN 3168 50 12 harmful harmful JJ 3168 50 13 Internet internet NN 3168 50 14 content content NN 3168 50 15 , , , 3168 50 16 it -PRON- PRP 3168 50 17 seems seem VBZ 3168 50 18 that that IN 3168 50 19 the the DT 3168 50 20 law law NN 3168 50 21 would would MD 3168 50 22 be be VB 3168 50 23 more more RBR 3168 50 24 expansive expansive JJ 3168 50 25 and and CC 3168 50 26 focused focus VBD 3168 50 27 on on IN 3168 50 28 the the DT 3168 50 29 content content NN 3168 50 30 itself -PRON- PRP 3168 50 31 rather rather RB 3168 50 32 than than IN 3168 50 33 filtering filter VBG 3168 50 34 access access NN 3168 50 35 to to IN 3168 50 36 the the DT 3168 50 37 content content NN 3168 50 38 . . . 3168 51 1 However however RB 3168 51 2 , , , 3168 51 3 earlier early JJR 3168 51 4 laws law NNS 3168 51 5 that that WDT 3168 51 6 attempted attempt VBD 3168 51 7 to to TO 3168 51 8 regulate regulate VB 3168 51 9 access access NN 3168 51 10 to to IN 3168 51 11 Internet internet NN 3168 51 12 content content NN 3168 51 13 failed fail VBD 3168 51 14 legal legal JJ 3168 51 15 challenges challenge NNS 3168 51 16 specifically specifically RB 3168 51 17 because because IN 3168 51 18 they -PRON- PRP 3168 51 19 tried try VBD 3168 51 20 to to TO 3168 51 21 regulate regulate VB 3168 51 22 content content NN 3168 51 23 . . . 3168 52 1 Prior prior RB 3168 52 2 to to IN 3168 52 3 the the DT 3168 52 4 enactment enactment NN 3168 52 5 of of IN 3168 52 6 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 52 7 , , , 3168 52 8 there there EX 3168 52 9 were be VBD 3168 52 10 a a DT 3168 52 11 num- num- JJ 3168 52 12 ber ber NN 3168 52 13 of of IN 3168 52 14 other other JJ 3168 52 15 proposed propose VBN 3168 52 16 laws law NNS 3168 52 17 aimed aim VBN 3168 52 18 at at IN 3168 52 19 preventing prevent VBG 3168 52 20 minors minor NNS 3168 52 21 from from IN 3168 52 22 accessing access VBG 3168 52 23 inappropriate inappropriate JJ 3168 52 24 Internet internet NN 3168 52 25 content content NN 3168 52 26 . . . 3168 53 1 The the DT 3168 53 2 Communications Communications NNPS 3168 53 3 Decency Decency NNP 3168 53 4 Act Act NNP 3168 53 5 ( ( -LRB- 3168 53 6 CDA CDA NNP 3168 53 7 ) ) -RRB- 3168 53 8 of of IN 3168 53 9 1996 1996 CD 3168 53 10 prohib- prohib- NN 3168 53 11 ited ite VBD 3168 53 12 the the DT 3168 53 13 sending send VBG 3168 53 14 or or CC 3168 53 15 posting posting NN 3168 53 16 of of IN 3168 53 17 obscene obscene JJ 3168 53 18 material material NN 3168 53 19 through through IN 3168 53 20 the the DT 3168 53 21 Internet internet NN 3168 53 22 to to IN 3168 53 23 individuals individual NNS 3168 53 24 under under IN 3168 53 25 the the DT 3168 53 26 age age NN 3168 53 27 of of IN 3168 53 28 eighteen.22 eighteen.22 NNP 3168 53 29 However however RB 3168 53 30 , , , 3168 53 31 the the DT 3168 53 32 Supreme Supreme NNP 3168 53 33 Court Court NNP 3168 53 34 found find VBD 3168 53 35 the the DT 3168 53 36 CDA CDA NNP 3168 53 37 to to TO 3168 53 38 be be VB 3168 53 39 unconstitutional unconstitutional JJ 3168 53 40 , , , 3168 53 41 stating state VBG 3168 53 42 that that IN 3168 53 43 the the DT 3168 53 44 law law NN 3168 53 45 violated violate VBD 3168 53 46 free free JJ 3168 53 47 speech speech NN 3168 53 48 under under IN 3168 53 49 the the DT 3168 53 50 First First NNP 3168 53 51 Amendment Amendment NNP 3168 53 52 . . . 3168 54 1 In in IN 3168 54 2 1998 1998 CD 3168 54 3 , , , 3168 54 4 Congress Congress NNP 3168 54 5 passed pass VBD 3168 54 6 the the DT 3168 54 7 Child Child NNP 3168 54 8 Online Online NNP 3168 54 9 Protection Protection NNP 3168 54 10 Act Act NNP 3168 54 11 ( ( -LRB- 3168 54 12 COPA COPA NNP 3168 54 13 ) ) -RRB- 3168 54 14 , , , 3168 54 15 which which WDT 3168 54 16 prohibited prohibit VBD 3168 54 17 commercial commercial JJ 3168 54 18 websites website NNS 3168 54 19 from from IN 3168 54 20 displaying display VBG 3168 54 21 material material NN 3168 54 22 deemed deem VBD 3168 54 23 harmful harmful JJ 3168 54 24 to to IN 3168 54 25 minors minor NNS 3168 54 26 and and CC 3168 54 27 imposed impose VBD 3168 54 28 criminal criminal JJ 3168 54 29 penalties penalty NNS 3168 54 30 on on IN 3168 54 31 Internet internet NN 3168 54 32 violators.23 violators.23 NNP 3168 54 33 A a DT 3168 54 34 three three CD 3168 54 35 - - HYPH 3168 54 36 panel panel NN 3168 54 37 judge judge NN 3168 54 38 for for IN 3168 54 39 the the DT 3168 54 40 District District NNP 3168 54 41 Court Court NNP 3168 54 42 for for IN 3168 54 43 the the DT 3168 54 44 Eastern Eastern NNP 3168 54 45 District District NNP 3168 54 46 of of IN 3168 54 47 Pennsylvania Pennsylvania NNP 3168 54 48 ruled rule VBD 3168 54 49 that that IN 3168 54 50 COPA COPA NNP 3168 54 51 ’s ’s POS 3168 54 52 focus focus NN 3168 54 53 on on IN 3168 54 54 “ " `` 3168 54 55 contemporary contemporary JJ 3168 54 56 community community NN 3168 54 57 standards standard NNS 3168 54 58 ” " '' 3168 54 59 violated violate VBD 3168 54 60 the the DT 3168 54 61 First First NNP 3168 54 62 Amendment Amendment NNP 3168 54 63 , , , 3168 54 64 and and CC 3168 54 65 the the DT 3168 54 66 panel panel NN 3168 54 67 subsequently subsequently RB 3168 54 68 imposed impose VBD 3168 54 69 an an DT 3168 54 70 ONE one CD 3168 54 71 LAw LAw NNS 3168 54 72 wITH with IN 3168 54 73 TwO TwO NNP 3168 54 74 OuTCOMES OuTCOMES NNP 3168 54 75 | | NNP 3168 54 76 JAEGER JAEGER NNP 3168 54 77 AND and CC 3168 54 78 YAN YAN NNP 3168 54 79 9 9 CD 3168 54 80 injunction injunction NN 3168 54 81 on on IN 3168 54 82 COPA COPA NNP 3168 54 83 ’s ’s POS 3168 54 84 enforcement enforcement NN 3168 54 85 . . . 3168 55 1 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 55 2 ’s ’s POS 3168 55 3 force force NN 3168 55 4 comes come VBZ 3168 55 5 from from IN 3168 55 6 Congress Congress NNP 3168 55 7 ’s ’s POS 3168 55 8 power power NN 3168 55 9 under under IN 3168 55 10 the the DT 3168 55 11 spending spending NN 3168 55 12 clause clause NN 3168 55 13 ; ; : 3168 55 14 that that RB 3168 55 15 is is RB 3168 55 16 , , , 3168 55 17 Congress Congress NNP 3168 55 18 can can MD 3168 55 19 legally legally RB 3168 55 20 attach attach VB 3168 55 21 requirements requirement NNS 3168 55 22 to to IN 3168 55 23 funds fund NNS 3168 55 24 that that IN 3168 55 25 it -PRON- PRP 3168 55 26 gives give VBZ 3168 55 27 out out RP 3168 55 28 . . . 3168 56 1 Since since IN 3168 56 2 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 56 3 is be VBZ 3168 56 4 based base VBN 3168 56 5 on on IN 3168 56 6 economic economic JJ 3168 56 7 persuasion persuasion NN 3168 56 8 — — : 3168 56 9 the the DT 3168 56 10 potential potential JJ 3168 56 11 loss loss NN 3168 56 12 of of IN 3168 56 13 funds fund NNS 3168 56 14 for for IN 3168 56 15 technology technology NN 3168 56 16 — — : 3168 56 17 the the DT 3168 56 18 law law NN 3168 56 19 can can MD 3168 56 20 only only RB 3168 56 21 have have VB 3168 56 22 an an DT 3168 56 23 effect effect NN 3168 56 24 on on IN 3168 56 25 recipients recipient NNS 3168 56 26 of of IN 3168 56 27 those those DT 3168 56 28 funds fund NNS 3168 56 29 . . . 3168 57 1 While while IN 3168 57 2 regulating regulate VBG 3168 57 3 Internet internet NN 3168 57 4 access access NN 3168 57 5 in in IN 3168 57 6 other other JJ 3168 57 7 venues venue NNS 3168 57 8 like like IN 3168 57 9 coffee coffee NN 3168 57 10 shops shop NNS 3168 57 11 , , , 3168 57 12 Internet internet NN 3168 57 13 cafés café NNS 3168 57 14 , , , 3168 57 15 bookstores bookstore NNS 3168 57 16 , , , 3168 57 17 and and CC 3168 57 18 even even RB 3168 57 19 individual individual JJ 3168 57 20 homes home NNS 3168 57 21 would would MD 3168 57 22 provide provide VB 3168 57 23 a a DT 3168 57 24 more more RBR 3168 57 25 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 3168 57 26 shield shield NN 3168 57 27 to to TO 3168 57 28 limit limit VB 3168 57 29 children child NNS 3168 57 30 ’s ’s POS 3168 57 31 access access NN 3168 57 32 to to IN 3168 57 33 certain certain JJ 3168 57 34 online online JJ 3168 57 35 content content NN 3168 57 36 , , , 3168 57 37 these these DT 3168 57 38 institutions institution NNS 3168 57 39 could could MD 3168 57 40 not not RB 3168 57 41 be be VB 3168 57 42 reached reach VBN 3168 57 43 under under IN 3168 57 44 the the DT 3168 57 45 spending spending NN 3168 57 46 clause clause NN 3168 57 47 . . . 3168 58 1 As as IN 3168 58 2 a a DT 3168 58 3 result result NN 3168 58 4 , , , 3168 58 5 the the DT 3168 58 6 burdens burden NNS 3168 58 7 of of IN 3168 58 8 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 58 9 fall fall VB 3168 58 10 squarely squarely RB 3168 58 11 on on IN 3168 58 12 public public JJ 3168 58 13 libraries library NNS 3168 58 14 and and CC 3168 58 15 public public JJ 3168 58 16 schools school NNS 3168 58 17 . . . 3168 59 1 n n LS 3168 59 2 The the DT 3168 59 3 current current JJ 3168 59 4 state state NN 3168 59 5 of of IN 3168 59 6 filtering filtering NN 3168 59 7 when when WRB 3168 59 8 did do VBD 3168 59 9 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 59 10 actually actually RB 3168 59 11 come come VB 3168 59 12 into into IN 3168 59 13 effect effect NN 3168 59 14 in in IN 3168 59 15 libraries library NNS 3168 59 16 and and CC 3168 59 17 schools school NNS 3168 59 18 ? ? . 3168 60 1 After after IN 3168 60 2 overcoming overcome VBG 3168 60 3 a a DT 3168 60 4 series series NN 3168 60 5 of of IN 3168 60 6 legal legal JJ 3168 60 7 challenges challenge NNS 3168 60 8 that that WDT 3168 60 9 were be VBD 3168 60 10 ultimately ultimately RB 3168 60 11 decided decide VBN 3168 60 12 by by IN 3168 60 13 the the DT 3168 60 14 Supreme Supreme NNP 3168 60 15 Court Court NNP 3168 60 16 , , , 3168 60 17 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 60 18 came come VBD 3168 60 19 into into IN 3168 60 20 effect effect NN 3168 60 21 in in IN 3168 60 22 full full JJ 3168 60 23 force force NN 3168 60 24 in in IN 3168 60 25 2003 2003 CD 3168 60 26 , , , 3168 60 27 though though IN 3168 60 28 96 96 CD 3168 60 29 percent percent NN 3168 60 30 of of IN 3168 60 31 public public JJ 3168 60 32 schools school NNS 3168 60 33 were be VBD 3168 60 34 already already RB 3168 60 35 in in IN 3168 60 36 compliance compliance NN 3168 60 37 with with IN 3168 60 38 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 60 39 in in IN 3168 60 40 2001 2001 CD 3168 60 41 . . . 3168 61 1 When when WRB 3168 61 2 the the DT 3168 61 3 Court Court NNP 3168 61 4 upheld uphold VBD 3168 61 5 the the DT 3168 61 6 constitutionality constitutionality NN 3168 61 7 of of IN 3168 61 8 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 61 9 , , , 3168 61 10 the the DT 3168 61 11 legal legal JJ 3168 61 12 challenge challenge NN 3168 61 13 by by IN 3168 61 14 public public JJ 3168 61 15 libraries library NNS 3168 61 16 centered center VBN 3168 61 17 on on IN 3168 61 18 the the DT 3168 61 19 way way NN 3168 61 20 the the DT 3168 61 21 statute statute NN 3168 61 22 was be VBD 3168 61 23 written.24 written.24 NNP 3168 61 24 The the DT 3168 61 25 Court Court NNP 3168 61 26 ’s ’s POS 3168 61 27 deci- deci- NN 3168 61 28 sion sion NN 3168 61 29 states state VBZ 3168 61 30 that that IN 3168 61 31 the the DT 3168 61 32 wording wording NN 3168 61 33 of of IN 3168 61 34 the the DT 3168 61 35 law law NN 3168 61 36 does do VBZ 3168 61 37 not not RB 3168 61 38 place place VB 3168 61 39 unconstitutional unconstitutional JJ 3168 61 40 limitations limitation NNS 3168 61 41 on on IN 3168 61 42 free free JJ 3168 61 43 speech speech NN 3168 61 44 in in IN 3168 61 45 public public JJ 3168 61 46 libraries library NNS 3168 61 47 . . . 3168 62 1 To to TO 3168 62 2 continue continue VB 3168 62 3 receiving receive VBG 3168 62 4 federal federal JJ 3168 62 5 dollars dollar NNS 3168 62 6 directly directly RB 3168 62 7 or or CC 3168 62 8 indirectly indirectly RB 3168 62 9 through through IN 3168 62 10 certain certain JJ 3168 62 11 federal federal JJ 3168 62 12 programs program NNS 3168 62 13 , , , 3168 62 14 public public JJ 3168 62 15 libraries library NNS 3168 62 16 and and CC 3168 62 17 schools school NNS 3168 62 18 were be VBD 3168 62 19 required require VBN 3168 62 20 to to TO 3168 62 21 install install VB 3168 62 22 filtering filtering NN 3168 62 23 technologies technology NNS 3168 62 24 on on IN 3168 62 25 all all DT 3168 62 26 computers computer NNS 3168 62 27 . . . 3168 63 1 While while IN 3168 63 2 the the DT 3168 63 3 case case NN 3168 63 4 decided decide VBN 3168 63 5 by by IN 3168 63 6 the the DT 3168 63 7 Supreme Supreme NNP 3168 63 8 Court Court NNP 3168 63 9 focused focus VBD 3168 63 10 on on IN 3168 63 11 public public JJ 3168 63 12 libraries library NNS 3168 63 13 , , , 3168 63 14 the the DT 3168 63 15 decision decision NN 3168 63 16 virtually virtually RB 3168 63 17 precludes preclude VBZ 3168 63 18 public public JJ 3168 63 19 schools school NNS 3168 63 20 from from IN 3168 63 21 making make VBG 3168 63 22 the the DT 3168 63 23 same same JJ 3168 63 24 or or CC 3168 63 25 related relate VBN 3168 63 26 challenges.25 challenges.25 NNP 3168 63 27 Before before IN 3168 63 28 that that DT 3168 63 29 case case NN 3168 63 30 was be VBD 3168 63 31 decided decide VBN 3168 63 32 , , , 3168 63 33 however however RB 3168 63 34 , , , 3168 63 35 most most JJS 3168 63 36 schools school NNS 3168 63 37 had have VBD 3168 63 38 already already RB 3168 63 39 adopted adopt VBN 3168 63 40 filters filter NNS 3168 63 41 to to TO 3168 63 42 comply comply VB 3168 63 43 with with IN 3168 63 44 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 63 45 . . . 3168 64 1 As as IN 3168 64 2 a a DT 3168 64 3 result result NN 3168 64 4 of of IN 3168 64 5 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 64 6 , , , 3168 64 7 a a DT 3168 64 8 public public JJ 3168 64 9 library library NN 3168 64 10 or or CC 3168 64 11 public public JJ 3168 64 12 school school NN 3168 64 13 must must MD 3168 64 14 install install VB 3168 64 15 technology technology NN 3168 64 16 protection protection NN 3168 64 17 measures measure NNS 3168 64 18 , , , 3168 64 19 better well RBR 3168 64 20 known know VBN 3168 64 21 as as IN 3168 64 22 filters filter NNS 3168 64 23 , , , 3168 64 24 on on IN 3168 64 25 all all DT 3168 64 26 of of IN 3168 64 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 3168 64 28 computers computer NNS 3168 64 29 if if IN 3168 64 30 it -PRON- PRP 3168 64 31 receives receive VBZ 3168 64 32 n n DT 3168 64 33 E e JJ 3168 64 34 - - NN 3168 64 35 Rate rate NN 3168 64 36 discounts discount NNS 3168 64 37 for for IN 3168 64 38 Internet internet NN 3168 64 39 access access NN 3168 64 40 costs cost NNS 3168 64 41 , , , 3168 64 42 n n CC 3168 64 43 E e NN 3168 64 44 – – : 3168 64 45 Rate rate NN 3168 64 46 discounts discount NNS 3168 64 47 for for IN 3168 64 48 internal internal JJ 3168 64 49 connections connection NNS 3168 64 50 costs cost NNS 3168 64 51 , , , 3168 64 52 n n DT 3168 64 53 LSTA LSTA NNP 3168 64 54 funding funding NN 3168 64 55 for for IN 3168 64 56 direct direct JJ 3168 64 57 Internet internet NN 3168 64 58 costs,26 costs,26 NN 3168 64 59 or or CC 3168 64 60 n n CC 3168 64 61 LSTA LSTA NNP 3168 64 62 funding funding NN 3168 64 63 for for IN 3168 64 64 purchasing purchase VBG 3168 64 65 technology technology NN 3168 64 66 to to TO 3168 64 67 access access VB 3168 64 68 the the DT 3168 64 69 Internet internet NN 3168 64 70 . . . 3168 65 1 The the DT 3168 65 2 requirements requirement NNS 3168 65 3 of of IN 3168 65 4 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 65 5 extend extend VBP 3168 65 6 to to IN 3168 65 7 public public JJ 3168 65 8 libraries library NNS 3168 65 9 , , , 3168 65 10 public public JJ 3168 65 11 schools school NNS 3168 65 12 , , , 3168 65 13 and and CC 3168 65 14 any any DT 3168 65 15 library library NN 3168 65 16 institution institution NN 3168 65 17 that that WDT 3168 65 18 receives receive VBZ 3168 65 19 LSTA LSTA NNP 3168 65 20 and and CC 3168 65 21 E e NN 3168 65 22 – – : 3168 65 23 Rate rate NN 3168 65 24 funds fund NNS 3168 65 25 as as IN 3168 65 26 part part NN 3168 65 27 of of IN 3168 65 28 a a DT 3168 65 29 system system NN 3168 65 30 , , , 3168 65 31 including include VBG 3168 65 32 state state NN 3168 65 33 library library NN 3168 65 34 agencies agency NNS 3168 65 35 and and CC 3168 65 36 library library JJ 3168 65 37 consortia consortium NNS 3168 65 38 . . . 3168 66 1 As as IN 3168 66 2 a a DT 3168 66 3 result result NN 3168 66 4 of of IN 3168 66 5 the the DT 3168 66 6 financial financial JJ 3168 66 7 incentives incentive NNS 3168 66 8 to to TO 3168 66 9 comply comply VB 3168 66 10 , , , 3168 66 11 almost almost RB 3168 66 12 100 100 CD 3168 66 13 percent percent NN 3168 66 14 of of IN 3168 66 15 public public JJ 3168 66 16 schools school NNS 3168 66 17 in in IN 3168 66 18 the the DT 3168 66 19 United United NNP 3168 66 20 States States NNP 3168 66 21 have have VBP 3168 66 22 implemented implement VBN 3168 66 23 the the DT 3168 66 24 requirements requirement NNS 3168 66 25 of of IN 3168 66 26 CIPA,27 CIPA,27 NNP 3168 66 27 and and CC 3168 66 28 approximately approximately RB 3168 66 29 half half NN 3168 66 30 of of IN 3168 66 31 public public JJ 3168 66 32 libraries library NNS 3168 66 33 have have VBP 3168 66 34 done do VBN 3168 66 35 so.28 so.28 NNP 3168 66 36 How how WRB 3168 66 37 many many JJ 3168 66 38 public public JJ 3168 66 39 schools school NNS 3168 66 40 have have VBP 3168 66 41 implemented implement VBN 3168 66 42 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 66 43 ? ? . 3168 67 1 According accord VBG 3168 67 2 to to IN 3168 67 3 the the DT 3168 67 4 latest late JJS 3168 67 5 report report NN 3168 67 6 by by IN 3168 67 7 the the DT 3168 67 8 Department Department NNP 3168 67 9 of of IN 3168 67 10 Education Education NNP 3168 67 11 ( ( -LRB- 3168 67 12 see see VB 3168 67 13 table table NN 3168 67 14 1 1 CD 3168 67 15 ) ) -RRB- 3168 67 16 , , , 3168 67 17 by by IN 3168 67 18 2005 2005 CD 3168 67 19 , , , 3168 67 20 100 100 CD 3168 67 21 percent percent NN 3168 67 22 of of IN 3168 67 23 public public JJ 3168 67 24 schools school NNS 3168 67 25 had have VBD 3168 67 26 implemented implement VBN 3168 67 27 both both DT 3168 67 28 the the DT 3168 67 29 Internet internet NN 3168 67 30 filtering filtering NN 3168 67 31 strategy strategy NN 3168 67 32 and and CC 3168 67 33 safety safety NN 3168 67 34 policy policy NN 3168 67 35 strategy strategy NN 3168 67 36 . . . 3168 68 1 In in IN 3168 68 2 fact fact NN 3168 68 3 , , , 3168 68 4 in in IN 3168 68 5 2001 2001 CD 3168 68 6 ( ( -LRB- 3168 68 7 the the DT 3168 68 8 first first JJ 3168 68 9 year year NN 3168 68 10 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 68 11 was be VBD 3168 68 12 in in IN 3168 68 13 effect effect NN 3168 68 14 ) ) -RRB- 3168 68 15 , , , 3168 68 16 96 96 CD 3168 68 17 percent percent NN 3168 68 18 of of IN 3168 68 19 schools school NNS 3168 68 20 had have VBD 3168 68 21 implemented implement VBN 3168 68 22 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 68 23 , , , 3168 68 24 with with IN 3168 68 25 99 99 CD 3168 68 26 percent percent NN 3168 68 27 filtering filter VBG 3168 68 28 by by IN 3168 68 29 2002 2002 CD 3168 68 30 . . . 3168 69 1 When when WRB 3168 69 2 compared compare VBN 3168 69 3 to to IN 3168 69 4 the the DT 3168 69 5 percentage percentage NN 3168 69 6 of of IN 3168 69 7 all all DT 3168 69 8 public public JJ 3168 69 9 schools school NNS 3168 69 10 with with IN 3168 69 11 Internet internet NN 3168 69 12 access access NN 3168 69 13 from from IN 3168 69 14 1994 1994 CD 3168 69 15 to to IN 3168 69 16 2005 2005 CD 3168 69 17 , , , 3168 69 18 Internet internet NN 3168 69 19 access access NN 3168 69 20 became become VBD 3168 69 21 nearly nearly RB 3168 69 22 universal universal JJ 3168 69 23 in in IN 3168 69 24 schools school NNS 3168 69 25 between between IN 3168 69 26 1999 1999 CD 3168 69 27 and and CC 3168 69 28 2000 2000 CD 3168 69 29 ( ( -LRB- 3168 69 30 95 95 CD 3168 69 31 to to TO 3168 69 32 98 98 CD 3168 69 33 percent percent NN 3168 69 34 ) ) -RRB- 3168 69 35 , , , 3168 69 36 and and CC 3168 69 37 one one PRP 3168 69 38 can can MD 3168 69 39 see see VB 3168 69 40 that that IN 3168 69 41 the the DT 3168 69 42 Internet internet NN 3168 69 43 access access NN 3168 69 44 percentage percentage NN 3168 69 45 in in IN 3168 69 46 2001 2001 CD 3168 69 47 was be VBD 3168 69 48 almost almost RB 3168 69 49 the the DT 3168 69 50 same same JJ 3168 69 51 as as IN 3168 69 52 the the DT 3168 69 53 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 69 54 implementation implementation NN 3168 69 55 percentage percentage NN 3168 69 56 . . . 3168 70 1 According accord VBG 3168 70 2 to to IN 3168 70 3 the the DT 3168 70 4 Department Department NNP 3168 70 5 of of IN 3168 70 6 Education Education NNP 3168 70 7 , , , 3168 70 8 the the DT 3168 70 9 above above JJ 3168 70 10 estimations estimation NNS 3168 70 11 are be VBP 3168 70 12 based base VBN 3168 70 13 on on IN 3168 70 14 a a DT 3168 70 15 survey survey NN 3168 70 16 of of IN 3168 70 17 1,205 1,205 CD 3168 70 18 elementary elementary JJ 3168 70 19 and and CC 3168 70 20 secondary secondary JJ 3168 70 21 schools school NNS 3168 70 22 selected select VBN 3168 70 23 from from IN 3168 70 24 63,000 63,000 CD 3168 70 25 elementary elementary JJ 3168 70 26 schools school NNS 3168 70 27 and and CC 3168 70 28 21,000 21,000 CD 3168 70 29 secondary secondary JJ 3168 70 30 and and CC 3168 70 31 combined combine VBN 3168 70 32 schools.29 schools.29 NNP 3168 70 33 After after IN 3168 70 34 reviewing review VBG 3168 70 35 the the DT 3168 70 36 design design NN 3168 70 37 and and CC 3168 70 38 administration administration NN 3168 70 39 of of IN 3168 70 40 the the DT 3168 70 41 sur- sur- NNP 3168 70 42 vey vey NN 3168 70 43 , , , 3168 70 44 it -PRON- PRP 3168 70 45 can can MD 3168 70 46 be be VB 3168 70 47 concluded conclude VBN 3168 70 48 that that IN 3168 70 49 these these DT 3168 70 50 estimations estimation NNS 3168 70 51 should should MD 3168 70 52 be be VB 3168 70 53 considered consider VBN 3168 70 54 valid valid JJ 3168 70 55 and and CC 3168 70 56 reliable reliable JJ 3168 70 57 and and CC 3168 70 58 that that IN 3168 70 59 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 70 60 was be VBD 3168 70 61 immedi- immedi- VBN 3168 70 62 ately ately RB 3168 70 63 and and CC 3168 70 64 consistently consistently RB 3168 70 65 implemented implement VBN 3168 70 66 in in IN 3168 70 67 the the DT 3168 70 68 majority majority NN 3168 70 69 of of IN 3168 70 70 the the DT 3168 70 71 public public JJ 3168 70 72 schools school NNS 3168 70 73 since since IN 3168 70 74 2001.30 2001.30 CD 3168 70 75 How how WRB 3168 70 76 many many JJ 3168 70 77 public public JJ 3168 70 78 libraries library NNS 3168 70 79 have have VBP 3168 70 80 implemented implement VBN 3168 70 81 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 70 82 ? ? . 3168 71 1 In in IN 3168 71 2 2002 2002 CD 3168 71 3 , , , 3168 71 4 43.4 43.4 CD 3168 71 5 percent percent NN 3168 71 6 of of IN 3168 71 7 public public JJ 3168 71 8 libraries library NNS 3168 71 9 were be VBD 3168 71 10 receiving receive VBG 3168 71 11 E e NN 3168 71 12 - - NN 3168 71 13 Rate rate NN 3168 71 14 discounts discount NNS 3168 71 15 , , , 3168 71 16 and and CC 3168 71 17 18.9 18.9 CD 3168 71 18 percent percent NN 3168 71 19 said say VBD 3168 71 20 they -PRON- PRP 3168 71 21 would would MD 3168 71 22 not not RB 3168 71 23 apply apply VB 3168 71 24 for for IN 3168 71 25 E e NN 3168 71 26 - - NN 3168 71 27 Rate rate NN 3168 71 28 discounts discount NNS 3168 71 29 if if IN 3168 71 30 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 71 31 was be VBD 3168 71 32 upheld.31 upheld.31 NNP 3168 71 33 Since since IN 3168 71 34 the the DT 3168 71 35 Supreme Supreme NNP 3168 71 36 Court Court NNP 3168 71 37 decision decision NN 3168 71 38 upholding upholding NN 3168 71 39 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 71 40 , , , 3168 71 41 the the DT 3168 71 42 num- num- NNP 3168 71 43 ber ber NN 3168 71 44 of of IN 3168 71 45 libraries library NNS 3168 71 46 complying comply VBG 3168 71 47 with with IN 3168 71 48 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 71 49 has have VBZ 3168 71 50 increased increase VBN 3168 71 51 , , , 3168 71 52 as as IN 3168 71 53 Table table NN 3168 71 54 1 1 CD 3168 71 55 . . . 3168 72 1 Implementation implementation NN 3168 72 2 of of IN 3168 72 3 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 72 4 in in IN 3168 72 5 public public JJ 3168 72 6 schools school NNS 3168 72 7 Year Year NNP 3168 72 8 1994 1994 CD 3168 72 9 1995 1995 CD 3168 72 10 1996 1996 CD 3168 72 11 1997 1997 CD 3168 72 12 1998 1998 CD 3168 72 13 1999 1999 CD 3168 72 14 2000 2000 CD 3168 72 15 2001 2001 CD 3168 72 16 2002 2002 CD 3168 72 17 2003 2003 CD 3168 72 18 2005 2005 CD 3168 72 19 Access Access NNP 3168 72 20 ( ( -LRB- 3168 72 21 % % NN 3168 72 22 ) ) -RRB- 3168 72 23 35 35 CD 3168 72 24 50 50 CD 3168 72 25 65 65 CD 3168 72 26 78 78 CD 3168 72 27 89 89 CD 3168 72 28 95 95 CD 3168 72 29 98 98 CD 3168 72 30 99 99 CD 3168 72 31 99 99 CD 3168 72 32 100 100 CD 3168 72 33 100 100 CD 3168 72 34 Filtering filtering NN 3168 72 35 ( ( -LRB- 3168 72 36 % % NN 3168 72 37 ) ) -RRB- 3168 72 38 96 96 CD 3168 72 39 99 99 CD 3168 72 40 97 97 CD 3168 72 41 100 100 CD 3168 72 42 10 10 CD 3168 72 43 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNS 3168 72 44 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3168 72 45 AND and CC 3168 72 46 LIBRARIES library NNS 3168 72 47 | | NNP 3168 72 48 MARCH MARCH NNP 3168 72 49 2009 2009 CD 3168 72 50 have have VB 3168 72 51 the the DT 3168 72 52 number number NN 3168 72 53 of of IN 3168 72 54 libraries library NNS 3168 72 55 not not RB 3168 72 56 applying apply VBG 3168 72 57 for for IN 3168 72 58 E e NN 3168 72 59 - - NN 3168 72 60 Rate rate NN 3168 72 61 funds fund NNS 3168 72 62 to to TO 3168 72 63 avoid avoid VB 3168 72 64 complying comply VBG 3168 72 65 with with IN 3168 72 66 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 72 67 . . . 3168 73 1 However however RB 3168 73 2 , , , 3168 73 3 unlike unlike IN 3168 73 4 schools school NNS 3168 73 5 , , , 3168 73 6 there there EX 3168 73 7 is be VBZ 3168 73 8 no no DT 3168 73 9 exact exact JJ 3168 73 10 count count NN 3168 73 11 of of IN 3168 73 12 how how WRB 3168 73 13 many many JJ 3168 73 14 libraries library NNS 3168 73 15 have have VBP 3168 73 16 filtered filter VBN 3168 73 17 Internet internet NN 3168 73 18 access access NN 3168 73 19 . . . 3168 74 1 In in IN 3168 74 2 many many JJ 3168 74 3 cases case NNS 3168 74 4 , , , 3168 74 5 the the DT 3168 74 6 libraries library NNS 3168 74 7 themselves -PRON- PRP 3168 74 8 do do VBP 3168 74 9 not not RB 3168 74 10 filter filter VB 3168 74 11 , , , 3168 74 12 but but CC 3168 74 13 a a DT 3168 74 14 state state NN 3168 74 15 library library NN 3168 74 16 , , , 3168 74 17 library library JJ 3168 74 18 con- con- NN 3168 74 19 sortium sortium NN 3168 74 20 , , , 3168 74 21 or or CC 3168 74 22 local local JJ 3168 74 23 or or CC 3168 74 24 state state NN 3168 74 25 government government NN 3168 74 26 system system NN 3168 74 27 of of IN 3168 74 28 which which WDT 3168 74 29 they -PRON- PRP 3168 74 30 are be VBP 3168 74 31 a a DT 3168 74 32 part part NN 3168 74 33 filters filter NNS 3168 74 34 access access NN 3168 74 35 from from IN 3168 74 36 beyond beyond IN 3168 74 37 the the DT 3168 74 38 walls wall NNS 3168 74 39 of of IN 3168 74 40 the the DT 3168 74 41 library library NN 3168 74 42 . . . 3168 75 1 In in IN 3168 75 2 some some DT 3168 75 3 of of IN 3168 75 4 these these DT 3168 75 5 cases case NNS 3168 75 6 , , , 3168 75 7 the the DT 3168 75 8 library library NN 3168 75 9 staff staff NN 3168 75 10 may may MD 3168 75 11 not not RB 3168 75 12 even even RB 3168 75 13 be be VB 3168 75 14 aware aware JJ 3168 75 15 that that IN 3168 75 16 such such JJ 3168 75 17 filtering filtering NN 3168 75 18 is be VBZ 3168 75 19 occurring occur VBG 3168 75 20 . . . 3168 76 1 A a DT 3168 76 2 number number NN 3168 76 3 of of IN 3168 76 4 state state NN 3168 76 5 and and CC 3168 76 6 local local JJ 3168 76 7 governments government NNS 3168 76 8 have have VBP 3168 76 9 also also RB 3168 76 10 passed pass VBN 3168 76 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 3168 76 12 own own JJ 3168 76 13 laws law NNS 3168 76 14 to to TO 3168 76 15 encourage encourage VB 3168 76 16 or or CC 3168 76 17 require require VB 3168 76 18 all all DT 3168 76 19 libraries library NNS 3168 76 20 in in IN 3168 76 21 the the DT 3168 76 22 state state NN 3168 76 23 to to TO 3168 76 24 filter filter VB 3168 76 25 Internet internet NN 3168 76 26 access access NN 3168 76 27 regardless regardless RB 3168 76 28 of of IN 3168 76 29 E e JJ 3168 76 30 - - NN 3168 76 31 Rate rate NN 3168 76 32 or or CC 3168 76 33 LSTA LSTA NNP 3168 76 34 funds.32 funds.32 NNP 3168 76 35 In in IN 3168 76 36 2008 2008 CD 3168 76 37 , , , 3168 76 38 38.2 38.2 CD 3168 76 39 percent percent NN 3168 76 40 of of IN 3168 76 41 public public JJ 3168 76 42 libraries library NNS 3168 76 43 were be VBD 3168 76 44 filtering filter VBG 3168 76 45 access access NN 3168 76 46 within within IN 3168 76 47 the the DT 3168 76 48 library library NN 3168 76 49 as as IN 3168 76 50 a a DT 3168 76 51 result result NN 3168 76 52 of of IN 3168 76 53 directly directly RB 3168 76 54 receiving receive VBG 3168 76 55 E e NN 3168 76 56 - - HYPH 3168 76 57 Rate Rate NNP 3168 76 58 funding.33 funding.33 NNP 3168 76 59 Furthermore Furthermore NNP 3168 76 60 , , , 3168 76 61 13.1 13.1 CD 3168 76 62 percent percent NN 3168 76 63 of of IN 3168 76 64 libraries library NNS 3168 76 65 were be VBD 3168 76 66 receiving receive VBG 3168 76 67 E e NN 3168 76 68 - - NN 3168 76 69 Rate rate NN 3168 76 70 funding funding NN 3168 76 71 as as IN 3168 76 72 a a DT 3168 76 73 part part NN 3168 76 74 of of IN 3168 76 75 another another DT 3168 76 76 orga- orga- JJ 3168 76 77 nization nization NN 3168 76 78 , , , 3168 76 79 meaning mean VBG 3168 76 80 that that IN 3168 76 81 these these DT 3168 76 82 libraries library NNS 3168 76 83 also also RB 3168 76 84 would would MD 3168 76 85 need need VB 3168 76 86 to to TO 3168 76 87 comply comply VB 3168 76 88 with with IN 3168 76 89 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 76 90 ’s ’s NNP 3168 76 91 requirements.34 requirements.34 NNP 3168 76 92 As as IN 3168 76 93 such such JJ 3168 76 94 , , , 3168 76 95 the the DT 3168 76 96 number number NN 3168 76 97 of of IN 3168 76 98 public public JJ 3168 76 99 libraries library NNS 3168 76 100 filtering filter VBG 3168 76 101 access access NN 3168 76 102 is be VBZ 3168 76 103 now now RB 3168 76 104 at at IN 3168 76 105 least least JJS 3168 76 106 51.3 51.3 CD 3168 76 107 percent percent NN 3168 76 108 , , , 3168 76 109 but but CC 3168 76 110 the the DT 3168 76 111 number number NN 3168 76 112 will will MD 3168 76 113 likely likely RB 3168 76 114 be be VB 3168 76 115 higher high JJR 3168 76 116 as as IN 3168 76 117 a a DT 3168 76 118 result result NN 3168 76 119 of of IN 3168 76 120 state state NN 3168 76 121 and and CC 3168 76 122 local local JJ 3168 76 123 laws law NNS 3168 76 124 requiring require VBG 3168 76 125 libraries library NNS 3168 76 126 to to TO 3168 76 127 filter filter VB 3168 76 128 as as RB 3168 76 129 well well RB 3168 76 130 as as IN 3168 76 131 other other JJ 3168 76 132 reasons reason NNS 3168 76 133 libraries library NNS 3168 76 134 have have VBP 3168 76 135 implemented implement VBN 3168 76 136 filters filter NNS 3168 76 137 . . . 3168 77 1 In in IN 3168 77 2 contrast contrast NN 3168 77 3 , , , 3168 77 4 among among IN 3168 77 5 libraries library NNS 3168 77 6 not not RB 3168 77 7 receiving receive VBG 3168 77 8 E e NN 3168 77 9 - - HYPH 3168 77 10 Rate rate NN 3168 77 11 funds fund NNS 3168 77 12 , , , 3168 77 13 the the DT 3168 77 14 number number NN 3168 77 15 of of IN 3168 77 16 libraries library NNS 3168 77 17 now now RB 3168 77 18 not not RB 3168 77 19 applying apply VBG 3168 77 20 for for IN 3168 77 21 E e NN 3168 77 22 - - NN 3168 77 23 Rate rate NN 3168 77 24 inten- inten- NN 3168 77 25 tionally tionally RB 3168 77 26 to to TO 3168 77 27 avoid avoid VB 3168 77 28 the the DT 3168 77 29 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 77 30 requirements requirement NNS 3168 77 31 is be VBZ 3168 77 32 31.6 31.6 CD 3168 77 33 percent.35 percent.35 NNP 3168 77 34 While while IN 3168 77 35 it -PRON- PRP 3168 77 36 is be VBZ 3168 77 37 not not RB 3168 77 38 possible possible JJ 3168 77 39 to to TO 3168 77 40 identify identify VB 3168 77 41 an an DT 3168 77 42 exact exact JJ 3168 77 43 number number NN 3168 77 44 of of IN 3168 77 45 public public JJ 3168 77 46 libraries library NNS 3168 77 47 that that WDT 3168 77 48 filter filter VBP 3168 77 49 access access NN 3168 77 50 , , , 3168 77 51 it -PRON- PRP 3168 77 52 is be VBZ 3168 77 53 clear clear JJ 3168 77 54 that that IN 3168 77 55 libraries library NNS 3168 77 56 overall overall RB 3168 77 57 have have VBP 3168 77 58 far far RB 3168 77 59 lower low JJR 3168 77 60 levels level NNS 3168 77 61 of of IN 3168 77 62 filtering filtering NN 3168 77 63 than than IN 3168 77 64 the the DT 3168 77 65 100 100 CD 3168 77 66 per- per- NN 3168 77 67 cent cent NN 3168 77 68 of of IN 3168 77 69 public public JJ 3168 77 70 schools school NNS 3168 77 71 that that WDT 3168 77 72 filter filter VBP 3168 77 73 access access NN 3168 77 74 . . . 3168 78 1 E e JJ 3168 78 2 - - NN 3168 78 3 Rate rate NN 3168 78 4 and and CC 3168 78 5 other other JJ 3168 78 6 program program NN 3168 78 7 issues issue NNS 3168 78 8 The the DT 3168 78 9 administration administration NN 3168 78 10 of of IN 3168 78 11 the the DT 3168 78 12 E E NNP 3168 78 13 - - HYPH 3168 78 14 Rate rate NN 3168 78 15 program program NN 3168 78 16 has have VBZ 3168 78 17 not not RB 3168 78 18 occurred occur VBN 3168 78 19 without without IN 3168 78 20 controversy controversy NN 3168 78 21 . . . 3168 79 1 Throughout throughout IN 3168 79 2 the the DT 3168 79 3 course course NN 3168 79 4 of of IN 3168 79 5 the the DT 3168 79 6 program program NN 3168 79 7 , , , 3168 79 8 many many JJ 3168 79 9 applicants applicant NNS 3168 79 10 for for IN 3168 79 11 and and CC 3168 79 12 recipients recipient NNS 3168 79 13 of of IN 3168 79 14 the the DT 3168 79 15 funding funding NN 3168 79 16 have have VBP 3168 79 17 found find VBN 3168 79 18 the the DT 3168 79 19 program program NN 3168 79 20 structure structure NN 3168 79 21 to to TO 3168 79 22 be be VB 3168 79 23 obtuse obtuse JJ 3168 79 24 , , , 3168 79 25 the the DT 3168 79 26 application application NN 3168 79 27 process process NN 3168 79 28 to to TO 3168 79 29 be be VB 3168 79 30 complicated complicate VBN 3168 79 31 and and CC 3168 79 32 time time NN 3168 79 33 con- con- NN 3168 79 34 suming suming NN 3168 79 35 , , , 3168 79 36 and and CC 3168 79 37 the the DT 3168 79 38 administration administration NN 3168 79 39 of of IN 3168 79 40 the the DT 3168 79 41 decision decision NN 3168 79 42 - - HYPH 3168 79 43 making make VBG 3168 79 44 process process NN 3168 79 45 to to TO 3168 79 46 be be VB 3168 79 47 slow.36 slow.36 NNP 3168 79 48 As as IN 3168 79 49 a a DT 3168 79 50 result result NN 3168 79 51 , , , 3168 79 52 many many JJ 3168 79 53 schools school NNS 3168 79 54 and and CC 3168 79 55 librar- librar- NNP 3168 79 56 ies ie NNS 3168 79 57 find find VBP 3168 79 58 it -PRON- PRP 3168 79 59 difficult difficult JJ 3168 79 60 to to TO 3168 79 61 plan plan VB 3168 79 62 ahead ahead RB 3168 79 63 for for IN 3168 79 64 budgeting budgeting NN 3168 79 65 purposes purpose NNS 3168 79 66 , , , 3168 79 67 not not RB 3168 79 68 knowing know VBG 3168 79 69 how how WRB 3168 79 70 much much JJ 3168 79 71 funding funding NN 3168 79 72 they -PRON- PRP 3168 79 73 will will MD 3168 79 74 receive receive VB 3168 79 75 or or CC 3168 79 76 when when WRB 3168 79 77 they -PRON- PRP 3168 79 78 will will MD 3168 79 79 receive receive VB 3168 79 80 it.37 it.37 NNP 3168 79 81 There there EX 3168 79 82 also also RB 3168 79 83 have have VBP 3168 79 84 been be VBN 3168 79 85 larger large JJR 3168 79 86 difficulties difficulty NNS 3168 79 87 for for IN 3168 79 88 the the DT 3168 79 89 program program NN 3168 79 90 . . . 3168 80 1 Following follow VBG 3168 80 2 revelations revelation NNS 3168 80 3 about about IN 3168 80 4 the the DT 3168 80 5 uses use NNS 3168 80 6 of of IN 3168 80 7 some some DT 3168 80 8 E e JJ 3168 80 9 - - NN 3168 80 10 Rate rate NN 3168 80 11 awards award NNS 3168 80 12 , , , 3168 80 13 the the DT 3168 80 14 FCC FCC NNP 3168 80 15 suspended suspend VBD 3168 80 16 the the DT 3168 80 17 program program NN 3168 80 18 from from IN 3168 80 19 August August NNP 3168 80 20 to to IN 3168 80 21 December December NNP 3168 80 22 2004 2004 CD 3168 80 23 to to TO 3168 80 24 impose impose VB 3168 80 25 new new JJ 3168 80 26 accounting accounting NN 3168 80 27 and and CC 3168 80 28 spending spending NN 3168 80 29 rules rule NNS 3168 80 30 for for IN 3168 80 31 the the DT 3168 80 32 funds fund NNS 3168 80 33 , , , 3168 80 34 delaying delay VBG 3168 80 35 the the DT 3168 80 36 distribution distribution NN 3168 80 37 of of IN 3168 80 38 over over IN 3168 80 39 $ $ $ 3168 80 40 1 1 CD 3168 80 41 billion billion CD 3168 80 42 in in IN 3168 80 43 funding funding NN 3168 80 44 to to IN 3168 80 45 libraries library NNS 3168 80 46 and and CC 3168 80 47 schools.38 schools.38 NNP 3168 80 48 News News NNP 3168 80 49 inves- inves- NN 3168 80 50 tigations tigation NNS 3168 80 51 had have VBD 3168 80 52 discovered discover VBN 3168 80 53 that that IN 3168 80 54 certain certain JJ 3168 80 55 school school NN 3168 80 56 systems system NNS 3168 80 57 were be VBD 3168 80 58 using use VBG 3168 80 59 E e NN 3168 80 60 - - HYPH 3168 80 61 Rate rate NN 3168 80 62 funds fund NNS 3168 80 63 to to TO 3168 80 64 purchase purchase VB 3168 80 65 more more JJR 3168 80 66 technology technology NN 3168 80 67 than than IN 3168 80 68 they -PRON- PRP 3168 80 69 needed need VBD 3168 80 70 or or CC 3168 80 71 could could MD 3168 80 72 afford afford VB 3168 80 73 to to TO 3168 80 74 maintain maintain VB 3168 80 75 , , , 3168 80 76 and and CC 3168 80 77 some some DT 3168 80 78 school school NN 3168 80 79 systems system NNS 3168 80 80 failed fail VBD 3168 80 81 to to TO 3168 80 82 ever ever RB 3168 80 83 use use VB 3168 80 84 technology technology NN 3168 80 85 they -PRON- PRP 3168 80 86 had have VBD 3168 80 87 acquired.39 acquired.39 NNP 3168 80 88 While while IN 3168 80 89 the the DT 3168 80 90 administration administration NN 3168 80 91 of of IN 3168 80 92 the the DT 3168 80 93 E E NNP 3168 80 94 - - HYPH 3168 80 95 Rate rate NN 3168 80 96 program program NN 3168 80 97 has have VBZ 3168 80 98 been be VBN 3168 80 99 comparatively comparatively RB 3168 80 100 smooth smooth JJ 3168 80 101 since since IN 3168 80 102 , , , 3168 80 103 the the DT 3168 80 104 temporary temporary JJ 3168 80 105 suspension suspension NN 3168 80 106 of of IN 3168 80 107 the the DT 3168 80 108 program program NN 3168 80 109 caused cause VBD 3168 80 110 serious serious JJ 3168 80 111 short short JJ 3168 80 112 - - HYPH 3168 80 113 term term NN 3168 80 114 problems problem NNS 3168 80 115 for for IN 3168 80 116 , , , 3168 80 117 and and CC 3168 80 118 left leave VBD 3168 80 119 a a DT 3168 80 120 sense sense NN 3168 80 121 of of IN 3168 80 122 distrust distrust NN 3168 80 123 of of IN 3168 80 124 , , , 3168 80 125 the the DT 3168 80 126 program program NN 3168 80 127 among among IN 3168 80 128 many many JJ 3168 80 129 recipients.40 recipients.40 NNP 3168 80 130 Filtering filter VBG 3168 80 131 issues issue NNS 3168 80 132 During during IN 3168 80 133 the the DT 3168 80 134 1990s 1990s CD 3168 80 135 , , , 3168 80 136 many many JJ 3168 80 137 types type NNS 3168 80 138 of of IN 3168 80 139 software software NN 3168 80 140 filtering filter VBG 3168 80 141 prod- prod- JJ 3168 80 142 ucts uct NNS 3168 80 143 became become VBD 3168 80 144 available available JJ 3168 80 145 to to IN 3168 80 146 consumers consumer NNS 3168 80 147 , , , 3168 80 148 including include VBG 3168 80 149 server- server- NN 3168 80 150 side side NN 3168 80 151 filtering filtering NN 3168 80 152 products product NNS 3168 80 153 ( ( -LRB- 3168 80 154 using use VBG 3168 80 155 a a DT 3168 80 156 list list NN 3168 80 157 of of IN 3168 80 158 server server NN 3168 80 159 - - HYPH 3168 80 160 selected select VBN 3168 80 161 blocked block VBN 3168 80 162 URLs url NNS 3168 80 163 that that WDT 3168 80 164 may may MD 3168 80 165 or or CC 3168 80 166 may may MD 3168 80 167 not not RB 3168 80 168 be be VB 3168 80 169 disclosed disclose VBN 3168 80 170 to to IN 3168 80 171 the the DT 3168 80 172 user user NN 3168 80 173 ) ) -RRB- 3168 80 174 , , , 3168 80 175 client client NN 3168 80 176 - - HYPH 3168 80 177 side side NN 3168 80 178 filtering filtering NN 3168 80 179 ( ( -LRB- 3168 80 180 controlling control VBG 3168 80 181 the the DT 3168 80 182 blocking blocking NN 3168 80 183 of of IN 3168 80 184 specific specific JJ 3168 80 185 content content NN 3168 80 186 with with IN 3168 80 187 a a DT 3168 80 188 user user NN 3168 80 189 password password NN 3168 80 190 ) ) -RRB- 3168 80 191 , , , 3168 80 192 text text NN 3168 80 193 - - HYPH 3168 80 194 based base VBN 3168 80 195 content content NN 3168 80 196 - - HYPH 3168 80 197 analysis analysis NN 3168 80 198 filtering filtering NN 3168 80 199 ( ( -LRB- 3168 80 200 removing remove VBG 3168 80 201 illicit illicit JJ 3168 80 202 content content NN 3168 80 203 of of IN 3168 80 204 a a DT 3168 80 205 website website NN 3168 80 206 using use VBG 3168 80 207 real real JJ 3168 80 208 - - HYPH 3168 80 209 time time NN 3168 80 210 analysis analysis NN 3168 80 211 ) ) -RRB- 3168 80 212 , , , 3168 80 213 monitoring monitoring NN 3168 80 214 and and CC 3168 80 215 time- time- NN 3168 80 216 limiting limiting NN 3168 80 217 technologies technology NNS 3168 80 218 ( ( -LRB- 3168 80 219 tracking track VBG 3168 80 220 a a DT 3168 80 221 child child NN 3168 80 222 ’s ’s POS 3168 80 223 online online JJ 3168 80 224 activi- activi- XX 3168 80 225 ties tie NNS 3168 80 226 and and CC 3168 80 227 limiting limit VBG 3168 80 228 the the DT 3168 80 229 amount amount NN 3168 80 230 of of IN 3168 80 231 time time NN 3168 80 232 he -PRON- PRP 3168 80 233 or or CC 3168 80 234 she -PRON- PRP 3168 80 235 spends spend VBZ 3168 80 236 online online RB 3168 80 237 ) ) -RRB- 3168 80 238 , , , 3168 80 239 and and CC 3168 80 240 age age NN 3168 80 241 - - HYPH 3168 80 242 verification verification NN 3168 80 243 systems system NNS 3168 80 244 ( ( -LRB- 3168 80 245 allowing allow VBG 3168 80 246 access access NN 3168 80 247 to to IN 3168 80 248 webpages webpage NNS 3168 80 249 by by IN 3168 80 250 passwords password NNS 3168 80 251 issued issue VBN 3168 80 252 by by IN 3168 80 253 a a DT 3168 80 254 third third JJ 3168 80 255 party party NN 3168 80 256 to to IN 3168 80 257 an an DT 3168 80 258 adult).41 adult).41 NN 3168 80 259 But but CC 3168 80 260 because because IN 3168 80 261 filtering filter VBG 3168 80 262 software software NN 3168 80 263 companies company NNS 3168 80 264 make make VBP 3168 80 265 the the DT 3168 80 266 decisions decision NNS 3168 80 267 about about IN 3168 80 268 how how WRB 3168 80 269 the the DT 3168 80 270 products product NNS 3168 80 271 work work VBP 3168 80 272 , , , 3168 80 273 content content NN 3168 80 274 and and CC 3168 80 275 collection collection NN 3168 80 276 decisions decision NNS 3168 80 277 for for IN 3168 80 278 electronic electronic JJ 3168 80 279 resources resource NNS 3168 80 280 in in IN 3168 80 281 schools school NNS 3168 80 282 and and CC 3168 80 283 public public JJ 3168 80 284 libraries library NNS 3168 80 285 have have VBP 3168 80 286 been be VBN 3168 80 287 taken take VBN 3168 80 288 out out IN 3168 80 289 of of IN 3168 80 290 the the DT 3168 80 291 hands hand NNS 3168 80 292 of of IN 3168 80 293 librarians librarian NNS 3168 80 294 , , , 3168 80 295 teachers teacher NNS 3168 80 296 , , , 3168 80 297 and and CC 3168 80 298 local local JJ 3168 80 299 communities community NNS 3168 80 300 and and CC 3168 80 301 placed place VBN 3168 80 302 in in IN 3168 80 303 the the DT 3168 80 304 trust trust NN 3168 80 305 of of IN 3168 80 306 proprietary proprietary JJ 3168 80 307 software software NN 3168 80 308 products.42 products.42 NNP 3168 80 309 Some some DT 3168 80 310 filtering filtering NN 3168 80 311 programs program NNS 3168 80 312 also also RB 3168 80 313 have have VBP 3168 80 314 specific specific JJ 3168 80 315 political political JJ 3168 80 316 agendas agenda NNS 3168 80 317 , , , 3168 80 318 which which WDT 3168 80 319 many many JJ 3168 80 320 organizations organization NNS 3168 80 321 that that WDT 3168 80 322 purchase purchase VBP 3168 80 323 them -PRON- PRP 3168 80 324 are be VBP 3168 80 325 not not RB 3168 80 326 aware aware JJ 3168 80 327 of.43 of.43 NNP 3168 80 328 In in IN 3168 80 329 a a DT 3168 80 330 study study NN 3168 80 331 of of IN 3168 80 332 over over IN 3168 80 333 one one CD 3168 80 334 million million CD 3168 80 335 pages page NNS 3168 80 336 , , , 3168 80 337 for for IN 3168 80 338 every every DT 3168 80 339 webpage webpage NN 3168 80 340 blocked block VBN 3168 80 341 by by IN 3168 80 342 a a DT 3168 80 343 filter filter NN 3168 80 344 as as IN 3168 80 345 advertised advertise VBN 3168 80 346 by by IN 3168 80 347 the the DT 3168 80 348 software software NN 3168 80 349 vendor vendor NN 3168 80 350 , , , 3168 80 351 one one CD 3168 80 352 or or CC 3168 80 353 more more JJR 3168 80 354 pages page NNS 3168 80 355 were be VBD 3168 80 356 blocked block VBN 3168 80 357 inappropriately inappropriately RB 3168 80 358 , , , 3168 80 359 while while IN 3168 80 360 many many JJ 3168 80 361 of of IN 3168 80 362 the the DT 3168 80 363 criteria criterion NNS 3168 80 364 used use VBN 3168 80 365 by by IN 3168 80 366 the the DT 3168 80 367 filtering filtering NN 3168 80 368 products product NNS 3168 80 369 go go VBP 3168 80 370 beyond beyond IN 3168 80 371 the the DT 3168 80 372 criteria criterion NNS 3168 80 373 enumerated enumerate VBD 3168 80 374 in in IN 3168 80 375 CIPA.44 CIPA.44 NNP 3168 80 376 Filters filter NNS 3168 80 377 have have VBP 3168 80 378 significant significant JJ 3168 80 379 rates rate NNS 3168 80 380 of of IN 3168 80 381 inappropriately inappropriately RB 3168 80 382 block- block- JJ 3168 80 383 ing ing NN 3168 80 384 materials material NNS 3168 80 385 , , , 3168 80 386 meaning mean VBG 3168 80 387 that that IN 3168 80 388 filters filter VBZ 3168 80 389 misidentify misidentify VBP 3168 80 390 harmless harmless JJ 3168 80 391 materials material NNS 3168 80 392 as as IN 3168 80 393 suspect suspect JJ 3168 80 394 and and CC 3168 80 395 prevent prevent VB 3168 80 396 access access NN 3168 80 397 to to IN 3168 80 398 harmless harmless JJ 3168 80 399 items item NNS 3168 80 400 ( ( -LRB- 3168 80 401 e.g. e.g. RB 3168 80 402 , , , 3168 80 403 one one CD 3168 80 404 filter filter NN 3168 80 405 blocked block VBD 3168 80 406 access access NN 3168 80 407 to to IN 3168 80 408 the the DT 3168 80 409 Declaration Declaration NNP 3168 80 410 of of IN 3168 80 411 Independence Independence NNP 3168 80 412 and and CC 3168 80 413 the the DT 3168 80 414 Constitution).45 Constitution).45 : 3168 80 415 Furthermore furthermore RB 3168 80 416 , , , 3168 80 417 when when WRB 3168 80 418 libraries library NNS 3168 80 419 install install VBP 3168 80 420 filters filter NNS 3168 80 421 to to TO 3168 80 422 comply comply VB 3168 80 423 with with IN 3168 80 424 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 80 425 , , , 3168 80 426 in in IN 3168 80 427 many many JJ 3168 80 428 instances instance NNS 3168 80 429 the the DT 3168 80 430 filters filter NNS 3168 80 431 will will MD 3168 80 432 frequently frequently RB 3168 80 433 be be VB 3168 80 434 blocking block VBG 3168 80 435 text text NN 3168 80 436 as as RB 3168 80 437 well well RB 3168 80 438 as as IN 3168 80 439 images image NNS 3168 80 440 , , , 3168 80 441 and and CC 3168 80 442 ( ( -LRB- 3168 80 443 depending depend VBG 3168 80 444 on on IN 3168 80 445 the the DT 3168 80 446 type type NN 3168 80 447 of of IN 3168 80 448 filter- filter- NN 3168 80 449 ing ing NN 3168 80 450 product product NN 3168 80 451 employed employ VBN 3168 80 452 ) ) -RRB- 3168 80 453 filters filter NNS 3168 80 454 may may MD 3168 80 455 be be VB 3168 80 456 blocking block VBG 3168 80 457 access access NN 3168 80 458 to to IN 3168 80 459 entire entire JJ 3168 80 460 websites website NNS 3168 80 461 or or CC 3168 80 462 even even RB 3168 80 463 all all PDT 3168 80 464 the the DT 3168 80 465 sites site NNS 3168 80 466 from from IN 3168 80 467 certain certain JJ 3168 80 468 Internet internet NN 3168 80 469 service service NN 3168 80 470 providers provider NNS 3168 80 471 . . . 3168 81 1 As as IN 3168 81 2 such such JJ 3168 81 3 , , , 3168 81 4 the the DT 3168 81 5 current current JJ 3168 81 6 state state NN 3168 81 7 of of IN 3168 81 8 filtering filter VBG 3168 81 9 technology technology NN 3168 81 10 will will MD 3168 81 11 create create VB 3168 81 12 the the DT 3168 81 13 practical practical JJ 3168 81 14 effect effect NN 3168 81 15 of of IN 3168 81 16 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 81 17 restrict- restrict- NN 3168 81 18 ing e VBG 3168 81 19 access access NN 3168 81 20 to to IN 3168 81 21 far far RB 3168 81 22 more more RBR 3168 81 23 than than IN 3168 81 24 just just RB 3168 81 25 certain certain JJ 3168 81 26 types type NNS 3168 81 27 of of IN 3168 81 28 images image NNS 3168 81 29 in in IN 3168 81 30 many many JJ 3168 81 31 schools school NNS 3168 81 32 and and CC 3168 81 33 libraries.46 libraries.46 NNP 3168 81 34 n n CC 3168 81 35 Differences difference NNS 3168 81 36 in in IN 3168 81 37 the the DT 3168 81 38 perceived perceive VBN 3168 81 39 value value NN 3168 81 40 of of IN 3168 81 41 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 81 42 and and CC 3168 81 43 filtering filter VBG 3168 81 44 Based base VBN 3168 81 45 on on IN 3168 81 46 the the DT 3168 81 47 available available JJ 3168 81 48 data datum NNS 3168 81 49 , , , 3168 81 50 there there EX 3168 81 51 clearly clearly RB 3168 81 52 is be VBZ 3168 81 53 a a DT 3168 81 54 sizeable sizeable JJ 3168 81 55 contrast contrast NN 3168 81 56 in in IN 3168 81 57 the the DT 3168 81 58 levels level NNS 3168 81 59 of of IN 3168 81 60 implementation implementation NN 3168 81 61 of of IN 3168 81 62 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 81 63 between between IN 3168 81 64 ONE one CD 3168 81 65 LAw LAw NNS 3168 81 66 wITH with IN 3168 81 67 TwO TwO NNP 3168 81 68 OuTCOMES OuTCOMES NNP 3168 81 69 | | NNP 3168 81 70 JAEGER JAEGER NNP 3168 81 71 AND and CC 3168 81 72 YAN YAN NNP 3168 81 73 11 11 CD 3168 81 74 schools school NNS 3168 81 75 and and CC 3168 81 76 libraries library NNS 3168 81 77 . . . 3168 82 1 This this DT 3168 82 2 difference difference NN 3168 82 3 raises raise VBZ 3168 82 4 a a DT 3168 82 5 number number NN 3168 82 6 of of IN 3168 82 7 questions question NNS 3168 82 8 : : : 3168 82 9 For for IN 3168 82 10 what what WDT 3168 82 11 reasons reason NNS 3168 82 12 has have VBZ 3168 82 13 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 82 14 been be VBN 3168 82 15 much much RB 3168 82 16 more more RBR 3168 82 17 widely widely RB 3168 82 18 implemented implement VBN 3168 82 19 in in IN 3168 82 20 schools school NNS 3168 82 21 ? ? . 3168 83 1 Is be VBZ 3168 83 2 this this DT 3168 83 3 issue issue NN 3168 83 4 mainly mainly RB 3168 83 5 value value NN 3168 83 6 driven drive VBN 3168 83 7 , , , 3168 83 8 dollar dollar NN 3168 83 9 driven drive VBN 3168 83 10 , , , 3168 83 11 both both DT 3168 83 12 , , , 3168 83 13 or or CC 3168 83 14 neither neither CC 3168 83 15 in in IN 3168 83 16 these these DT 3168 83 17 two two CD 3168 83 18 public public JJ 3168 83 19 institutions institution NNS 3168 83 20 ? ? . 3168 84 1 Why why WRB 3168 84 2 are be VBP 3168 84 3 these these DT 3168 84 4 two two CD 3168 84 5 institutions institution NNS 3168 84 6 so so RB 3168 84 7 dif- dif- RB 3168 84 8 ferent ferent JJ 3168 84 9 regarding regard VBG 3168 84 10 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 84 11 implementation implementation NN 3168 84 12 while while IN 3168 84 13 they -PRON- PRP 3168 84 14 share share VBP 3168 84 15 many many JJ 3168 84 16 social social JJ 3168 84 17 and and CC 3168 84 18 educational educational JJ 3168 84 19 similarities similarity NNS 3168 84 20 ? ? . 3168 85 1 Reasons reason NNS 3168 85 2 for for IN 3168 85 3 nationwide nationwide JJ 3168 85 4 full full JJ 3168 85 5 implementation implementation NN 3168 85 6 in in IN 3168 85 7 schools school NNS 3168 85 8 There there EX 3168 85 9 are be VBP 3168 85 10 various various JJ 3168 85 11 reasons reason NNS 3168 85 12 — — : 3168 85 13 from from IN 3168 85 14 financial financial JJ 3168 85 15 , , , 3168 85 16 population population NN 3168 85 17 , , , 3168 85 18 social social JJ 3168 85 19 , , , 3168 85 20 and and CC 3168 85 21 management management NN 3168 85 22 issues issue NNS 3168 85 23 to to TO 3168 85 24 computer computer NN 3168 85 25 and and CC 3168 85 26 Internet internet NN 3168 85 27 availability availability NN 3168 85 28 — — : 3168 85 29 that that WDT 3168 85 30 have have VBP 3168 85 31 driven drive VBN 3168 85 32 the the DT 3168 85 33 rapid rapid JJ 3168 85 34 and and CC 3168 85 35 compre- compre- NN 3168 85 36 hensive hensive JJ 3168 85 37 implementation implementation NN 3168 85 38 of of IN 3168 85 39 filters filter NNS 3168 85 40 in in IN 3168 85 41 public public JJ 3168 85 42 schools school NNS 3168 85 43 . . . 3168 86 1 First first JJ 3168 86 2 , , , 3168 86 3 public public JJ 3168 86 4 schools school NNS 3168 86 5 have have VBP 3168 86 6 to to TO 3168 86 7 implement implement VB 3168 86 8 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 86 9 because because IN 3168 86 10 of of IN 3168 86 11 societal societal JJ 3168 86 12 pressures pressure NNS 3168 86 13 and and CC 3168 86 14 the the DT 3168 86 15 lobbying lobbying NN 3168 86 16 of of IN 3168 86 17 parents parent NNS 3168 86 18 to to TO 3168 86 19 ensure ensure VB 3168 86 20 students student NNS 3168 86 21 ’ ’ POS 3168 86 22 Internet internet NN 3168 86 23 safety safety NN 3168 86 24 . . . 3168 87 1 Almost almost RB 3168 87 2 all all DT 3168 87 3 users user NNS 3168 87 4 of of IN 3168 87 5 computers computer NNS 3168 87 6 in in IN 3168 87 7 schools school NNS 3168 87 8 are be VBP 3168 87 9 minors minor NNS 3168 87 10 , , , 3168 87 11 the the DT 3168 87 12 most most RBS 3168 87 13 vulnerable vulnerable JJ 3168 87 14 groups group NNS 3168 87 15 for for IN 3168 87 16 Internet internet NN 3168 87 17 crimes crime NNS 3168 87 18 and and CC 3168 87 19 child child NN 3168 87 20 pornography pornography NN 3168 87 21 . . . 3168 88 1 Public public JJ 3168 88 2 schools school NNS 3168 88 3 in in IN 3168 88 4 America America NNP 3168 88 5 have have VBP 3168 88 6 been be VBN 3168 88 7 the the DT 3168 88 8 focus focus NN 3168 88 9 of of IN 3168 88 10 public public JJ 3168 88 11 attention attention NN 3168 88 12 and and CC 3168 88 13 scru- scru- NN 3168 88 14 tiny tiny JJ 3168 88 15 for for IN 3168 88 16 years year NNS 3168 88 17 , , , 3168 88 18 and and CC 3168 88 19 the the DT 3168 88 20 political political JJ 3168 88 21 and and CC 3168 88 22 social social JJ 3168 88 23 responsibility responsibility NN 3168 88 24 of of IN 3168 88 25 public public JJ 3168 88 26 schools school NNS 3168 88 27 for for IN 3168 88 28 children child NNS 3168 88 29 ’s ’s POS 3168 88 30 Internet internet NN 3168 88 31 safety safety NN 3168 88 32 is be VBZ 3168 88 33 huge huge JJ 3168 88 34 . . . 3168 89 1 As as IN 3168 89 2 a a DT 3168 89 3 result result NN 3168 89 4 , , , 3168 89 5 society society NN 3168 89 6 has have VBZ 3168 89 7 decided decide VBN 3168 89 8 these these DT 3168 89 9 students student NNS 3168 89 10 should should MD 3168 89 11 be be VB 3168 89 12 most most RBS 3168 89 13 strongly strongly RB 3168 89 14 protected protect VBN 3168 89 15 , , , 3168 89 16 and and CC 3168 89 17 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 89 18 was be VBD 3168 89 19 implemented implement VBN 3168 89 20 immediately immediately RB 3168 89 21 and and CC 3168 89 22 most most RBS 3168 89 23 widely widely RB 3168 89 24 at at IN 3168 89 25 schools school NNS 3168 89 26 . . . 3168 90 1 Second second JJ 3168 90 2 , , , 3168 90 3 in in IN 3168 90 4 contrast contrast NN 3168 90 5 to to IN 3168 90 6 public public JJ 3168 90 7 libraries library NNS 3168 90 8 ( ( -LRB- 3168 90 9 which which WDT 3168 90 10 average average VBP 3168 90 11 slightly slightly RB 3168 90 12 less less JJR 3168 90 13 than than IN 3168 90 14 eleven eleven CD 3168 90 15 computers computer NNS 3168 90 16 per per IN 3168 90 17 library library NN 3168 90 18 outlet outlet NN 3168 90 19 ) ) -RRB- 3168 90 20 , , , 3168 90 21 the the DT 3168 90 22 typical typical JJ 3168 90 23 number number NN 3168 90 24 of of IN 3168 90 25 computers computer NNS 3168 90 26 in in IN 3168 90 27 public public JJ 3168 90 28 schools school NNS 3168 90 29 ranges range VBZ 3168 90 30 from from IN 3168 90 31 one one CD 3168 90 32 hundred hundred CD 3168 90 33 to to IN 3168 90 34 five five CD 3168 90 35 hundred hundred CD 3168 90 36 , , , 3168 90 37 which which WDT 3168 90 38 are be VBP 3168 90 39 needed need VBN 3168 90 40 to to TO 3168 90 41 meet meet VB 3168 90 42 the the DT 3168 90 43 needs need NNS 3168 90 44 of of IN 3168 90 45 students student NNS 3168 90 46 and and CC 3168 90 47 teachers teacher NNS 3168 90 48 for for IN 3168 90 49 daily daily JJ 3168 90 50 learning learning NN 3168 90 51 and and CC 3168 90 52 teaching teaching NN 3168 90 53 . . . 3168 91 1 Since since IN 3168 91 2 the the DT 3168 91 3 number number NN 3168 91 4 of of IN 3168 91 5 computers computer NNS 3168 91 6 is be VBZ 3168 91 7 quite quite RB 3168 91 8 large large JJ 3168 91 9 , , , 3168 91 10 the the DT 3168 91 11 financial financial JJ 3168 91 12 incentives incentive NNS 3168 91 13 of of IN 3168 91 14 E e JJ 3168 91 15 - - NN 3168 91 16 Rate rate NN 3168 91 17 funding funding NN 3168 91 18 are be VBP 3168 91 19 substantial substantial JJ 3168 91 20 and and CC 3168 91 21 critical critical JJ 3168 91 22 to to IN 3168 91 23 the the DT 3168 91 24 operation operation NN 3168 91 25 of of IN 3168 91 26 the the DT 3168 91 27 schools school NNS 3168 91 28 . . . 3168 92 1 This this DT 3168 92 2 situation situation NN 3168 92 3 provides provide VBZ 3168 92 4 administrators administrator NNS 3168 92 5 in in IN 3168 92 6 schools school NNS 3168 92 7 and and CC 3168 92 8 school school NN 3168 92 9 districts district NNS 3168 92 10 with with IN 3168 92 11 the the DT 3168 92 12 incentive incentive NN 3168 92 13 to to TO 3168 92 14 make make VB 3168 92 15 decisions decision NNS 3168 92 16 to to TO 3168 92 17 implement implement VB 3168 92 18 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 92 19 as as RB 3168 92 20 quickly quickly RB 3168 92 21 and and CC 3168 92 22 extensively extensively RB 3168 92 23 as as IN 3168 92 24 possible possible JJ 3168 92 25 . . . 3168 93 1 Furthermore furthermore RB 3168 93 2 , , , 3168 93 3 the the DT 3168 93 4 amount amount NN 3168 93 5 of of IN 3168 93 6 money money NN 3168 93 7 that that WDT 3168 93 8 E e NN 3168 93 9 - - NN 3168 93 10 Rate rate NN 3168 93 11 provides provide VBZ 3168 93 12 for for IN 3168 93 13 schools school NNS 3168 93 14 in in IN 3168 93 15 terms term NNS 3168 93 16 of of IN 3168 93 17 technology technology NN 3168 93 18 is be VBZ 3168 93 19 astounding astounding JJ 3168 93 20 . . . 3168 94 1 As as IN 3168 94 2 was be VBD 3168 94 3 noted note VBN 3168 94 4 earlier early RBR 3168 94 5 , , , 3168 94 6 schools school NNS 3168 94 7 received receive VBD 3168 94 8 over over IN 3168 94 9 $ $ $ 3168 94 10 12 12 CD 3168 94 11 billion billion CD 3168 94 12 from from IN 3168 94 13 2000 2000 CD 3168 94 14 to to IN 3168 94 15 2003 2003 CD 3168 94 16 alone alone RB 3168 94 17 . . . 3168 95 1 Schools school NNS 3168 95 2 likely likely RB 3168 95 3 would would MD 3168 95 4 not not RB 3168 95 5 be be VB 3168 95 6 able able JJ 3168 95 7 to to TO 3168 95 8 provide provide VB 3168 95 9 the the DT 3168 95 10 necessary necessary JJ 3168 95 11 computers computer NNS 3168 95 12 for for IN 3168 95 13 students student NNS 3168 95 14 and and CC 3168 95 15 teachers teacher NNS 3168 95 16 with- with- VBP 3168 95 17 out out IN 3168 95 18 the the DT 3168 95 19 E e JJ 3168 95 20 - - NN 3168 95 21 Rate rate NN 3168 95 22 funds fund NNS 3168 95 23 . . . 3168 96 1 Third third JJ 3168 96 2 , , , 3168 96 3 the the DT 3168 96 4 actual actual JJ 3168 96 5 implementation implementation NN 3168 96 6 procedure procedure NN 3168 96 7 differs differ NNS 3168 96 8 in in IN 3168 96 9 schools school NNS 3168 96 10 and and CC 3168 96 11 libraries library NNS 3168 96 12 : : : 3168 96 13 Schools school NNS 3168 96 14 are be VBP 3168 96 15 certified certify VBN 3168 96 16 under under IN 3168 96 17 the the DT 3168 96 18 supervision supervision NN 3168 96 19 of of IN 3168 96 20 the the DT 3168 96 21 local local JJ 3168 96 22 educational educational JJ 3168 96 23 agencies agency NNS 3168 96 24 such such JJ 3168 96 25 as as IN 3168 96 26 school school NN 3168 96 27 districts district NNS 3168 96 28 and and CC 3168 96 29 state state NN 3168 96 30 departments department NNS 3168 96 31 of of IN 3168 96 32 education education NN 3168 96 33 ; ; : 3168 96 34 libraries library NNS 3168 96 35 are be VBP 3168 96 36 certified certify VBN 3168 96 37 within within IN 3168 96 38 a a DT 3168 96 39 library library NN 3168 96 40 organization organization NN 3168 96 41 under under IN 3168 96 42 the the DT 3168 96 43 supervision supervision NN 3168 96 44 of of IN 3168 96 45 the the DT 3168 96 46 IMLS IMLS NNP 3168 96 47 . . . 3168 97 1 In in IN 3168 97 2 other other JJ 3168 97 3 words word NNS 3168 97 4 , , , 3168 97 5 the the DT 3168 97 6 cer- cer- JJ 3168 97 7 tification tification NN 3168 97 8 process process NN 3168 97 9 at at IN 3168 97 10 schools school NNS 3168 97 11 is be VBZ 3168 97 12 directly directly RB 3168 97 13 and and CC 3168 97 14 effectively effectively RB 3168 97 15 controlled control VBN 3168 97 16 by by IN 3168 97 17 school school NN 3168 97 18 districts district NNS 3168 97 19 and and CC 3168 97 20 state state NN 3168 97 21 departments department NNS 3168 97 22 of of IN 3168 97 23 education education NN 3168 97 24 , , , 3168 97 25 following follow VBG 3168 97 26 the the DT 3168 97 27 same same JJ 3168 97 28 fundamental fundamental JJ 3168 97 29 values value NNS 3168 97 30 of of IN 3168 97 31 protecting protect VBG 3168 97 32 children child NNS 3168 97 33 . . . 3168 98 1 The the DT 3168 98 2 resistance resistance NN 3168 98 3 to to IN 3168 98 4 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 98 5 in in IN 3168 98 6 schools school NNS 3168 98 7 has have VBZ 3168 98 8 been be VBN 3168 98 9 very very RB 3168 98 10 small small JJ 3168 98 11 in in IN 3168 98 12 comparison comparison NN 3168 98 13 to to IN 3168 98 14 libraries library NNS 3168 98 15 . . . 3168 99 1 The the DT 3168 99 2 primary primary JJ 3168 99 3 concern concern NN 3168 99 4 raised raise VBN 3168 99 5 has have VBZ 3168 99 6 been be VBN 3168 99 7 the the DT 3168 99 8 issue issue NN 3168 99 9 of of IN 3168 99 10 educational educational JJ 3168 99 11 equality equality NN 3168 99 12 . . . 3168 100 1 Concerns concern NNS 3168 100 2 have have VBP 3168 100 3 been be VBN 3168 100 4 raised raise VBN 3168 100 5 that that IN 3168 100 6 filters filter NNS 3168 100 7 in in IN 3168 100 8 schools school NNS 3168 100 9 may may MD 3168 100 10 create create VB 3168 100 11 two two CD 3168 100 12 classes class NNS 3168 100 13 of of IN 3168 100 14 students student NNS 3168 100 15 — — : 3168 100 16 ones one NNS 3168 100 17 with with IN 3168 100 18 only only RB 3168 100 19 filtered filter VBN 3168 100 20 access access NN 3168 100 21 at at IN 3168 100 22 school school NN 3168 100 23 and and CC 3168 100 24 ones one NNS 3168 100 25 who who WP 3168 100 26 also also RB 3168 100 27 can can MD 3168 100 28 get get VB 3168 100 29 unfiltered unfiltered JJ 3168 100 30 access access NN 3168 100 31 at at IN 3168 100 32 home.47 home.47 NNP 3168 100 33 Reasons Reasons NNP 3168 100 34 for for IN 3168 100 35 more more RBR 3168 100 36 limited limited JJ 3168 100 37 implementation implementation NN 3168 100 38 in in IN 3168 100 39 libraries library NNS 3168 100 40 In in IN 3168 100 41 public public JJ 3168 100 42 libraries library NNS 3168 100 43 , , , 3168 100 44 the the DT 3168 100 45 reasons reason NNS 3168 100 46 for for IN 3168 100 47 implementing implement VBG 3168 100 48 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 100 49 are be VBP 3168 100 50 similar similar JJ 3168 100 51 to to IN 3168 100 52 those those DT 3168 100 53 of of IN 3168 100 54 public public JJ 3168 100 55 schools school NNS 3168 100 56 in in IN 3168 100 57 many many JJ 3168 100 58 ways way NNS 3168 100 59 . . . 3168 101 1 Public public JJ 3168 101 2 libraries library NNS 3168 101 3 provide provide VBP 3168 101 4 an an DT 3168 101 5 average average NN 3168 101 6 of of IN 3168 101 7 10.7 10.7 CD 3168 101 8 computers computer NNS 3168 101 9 in in IN 3168 101 10 each each DT 3168 101 11 of of IN 3168 101 12 the the DT 3168 101 13 approximately approximately RB 3168 101 14 seven seven CD 3168 101 15 thousand thousand CD 3168 101 16 public public JJ 3168 101 17 libraries library NNS 3168 101 18 in in IN 3168 101 19 the the DT 3168 101 20 United United NNP 3168 101 21 States States NNP 3168 101 22 , , , 3168 101 23 which which WDT 3168 101 24 is be VBZ 3168 101 25 a a DT 3168 101 26 lot lot NN 3168 101 27 of of IN 3168 101 28 technology technology NN 3168 101 29 that that WDT 3168 101 30 needs need VBZ 3168 101 31 to to TO 3168 101 32 be be VB 3168 101 33 supported support VBN 3168 101 34 . . . 3168 102 1 The the DT 3168 102 2 E E NNP 3168 102 3 - - NN 3168 102 4 Rate rate NN 3168 102 5 and and CC 3168 102 6 LSTA lsta NN 3168 102 7 funds fund NNS 3168 102 8 are be VBP 3168 102 9 vital vital JJ 3168 102 10 to to IN 3168 102 11 many many JJ 3168 102 12 libraries library NNS 3168 102 13 in in IN 3168 102 14 the the DT 3168 102 15 provision provision NN 3168 102 16 of of IN 3168 102 17 computers computer NNS 3168 102 18 and and CC 3168 102 19 the the DT 3168 102 20 Internet internet NN 3168 102 21 . . . 3168 103 1 Furthermore furthermore RB 3168 103 2 , , , 3168 103 3 with with IN 3168 103 4 limited limited JJ 3168 103 5 alternative alternative JJ 3168 103 6 sources source NNS 3168 103 7 of of IN 3168 103 8 funding funding NN 3168 103 9 , , , 3168 103 10 the the DT 3168 103 11 E E NNP 3168 103 12 - - NN 3168 103 13 Rate rate NN 3168 103 14 and and CC 3168 103 15 LSTA lsta NN 3168 103 16 funds fund NNS 3168 103 17 are be VBP 3168 103 18 hard hard JJ 3168 103 19 to to TO 3168 103 20 replace replace VB 3168 103 21 if if IN 3168 103 22 they -PRON- PRP 3168 103 23 are be VBP 3168 103 24 not not RB 3168 103 25 available available JJ 3168 103 26 . . . 3168 104 1 Given give VBN 3168 104 2 that that IN 3168 104 3 the the DT 3168 104 4 public public JJ 3168 104 5 libraries library NNS 3168 104 6 have have VBP 3168 104 7 become become VBN 3168 104 8 the the DT 3168 104 9 guarantor guarantor NNP 3168 104 10 of of IN 3168 104 11 public public JJ 3168 104 12 access access NN 3168 104 13 to to IN 3168 104 14 comput- comput- NNP 3168 104 15 ing ing NNP 3168 104 16 and and CC 3168 104 17 the the DT 3168 104 18 Internet internet NN 3168 104 19 , , , 3168 104 20 libraries library NNS 3168 104 21 have have VBP 3168 104 22 to to TO 3168 104 23 find find VB 3168 104 24 ways way NNS 3168 104 25 to to TO 3168 104 26 ensure ensure VB 3168 104 27 that that IN 3168 104 28 patrons patron NNS 3168 104 29 can can MD 3168 104 30 access access VB 3168 104 31 the the DT 3168 104 32 Internet.48 Internet.48 NNP 3168 104 33 Libraries library NNS 3168 104 34 also also RB 3168 104 35 have have VBP 3168 104 36 to to TO 3168 104 37 be be VB 3168 104 38 concerned concern VBN 3168 104 39 about about IN 3168 104 40 protect- protect- JJ 3168 104 41 ing ing NN 3168 104 42 and and CC 3168 104 43 providing provide VBG 3168 104 44 a a DT 3168 104 45 safe safe JJ 3168 104 46 environment environment NN 3168 104 47 for for IN 3168 104 48 younger young JJR 3168 104 49 patrons patron NNS 3168 104 50 . . . 3168 105 1 While while IN 3168 105 2 libraries library NNS 3168 105 3 serve serve VBP 3168 105 4 patrons patron NNS 3168 105 5 of of IN 3168 105 6 all all DT 3168 105 7 ages age NNS 3168 105 8 , , , 3168 105 9 one one CD 3168 105 10 of of IN 3168 105 11 the the DT 3168 105 12 key key JJ 3168 105 13 social social JJ 3168 105 14 expectations expectation NNS 3168 105 15 of of IN 3168 105 16 libraries library NNS 3168 105 17 is be VBZ 3168 105 18 the the DT 3168 105 19 provision provision NN 3168 105 20 of of IN 3168 105 21 educational educational JJ 3168 105 22 materials material NNS 3168 105 23 for for IN 3168 105 24 children child NNS 3168 105 25 and and CC 3168 105 26 young young JJ 3168 105 27 adults adult NNS 3168 105 28 . . . 3168 106 1 Children child NNS 3168 106 2 ’s ’s POS 3168 106 3 sections section NNS 3168 106 4 of of IN 3168 106 5 libraries library NNS 3168 106 6 almost almost RB 3168 106 7 always always RB 3168 106 8 have have VBP 3168 106 9 com- com- NN 3168 106 10 puters puter NNS 3168 106 11 in in IN 3168 106 12 them -PRON- PRP 3168 106 13 . . . 3168 107 1 Much much JJ 3168 107 2 of of IN 3168 107 3 the the DT 3168 107 4 content content NN 3168 107 5 blocked block VBN 3168 107 6 by by IN 3168 107 7 filters filter NNS 3168 107 8 is be VBZ 3168 107 9 of of IN 3168 107 10 little little JJ 3168 107 11 or or CC 3168 107 12 no no DT 3168 107 13 education education NN 3168 107 14 value value NN 3168 107 15 . . . 3168 108 1 As as IN 3168 108 2 such such JJ 3168 108 3 , , , 3168 108 4 “ " `` 3168 108 5 defending defend VBG 3168 108 6 unfil- unfil- JJ 3168 108 7 tered tere VBN 3168 108 8 Internet internet NN 3168 108 9 access access NN 3168 108 10 was be VBD 3168 108 11 quite quite RB 3168 108 12 different different JJ 3168 108 13 from from IN 3168 108 14 defending defend VBG 3168 108 15 Catcher Catcher NNP 3168 108 16 in in IN 3168 108 17 the the DT 3168 108 18 Rye Rye NNP 3168 108 19 . . . 3168 108 20 ”49 ”49 NNP 3168 108 21 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 3168 108 22 , , , 3168 108 23 many many JJ 3168 108 24 libraries library NNS 3168 108 25 have have VBP 3168 108 26 fought fight VBN 3168 108 27 against against IN 3168 108 28 the the DT 3168 108 29 filtering filtering NN 3168 108 30 requirements requirement NNS 3168 108 31 of of IN 3168 108 32 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 108 33 because because IN 3168 108 34 they -PRON- PRP 3168 108 35 believe believe VBP 3168 108 36 that that IN 3168 108 37 it -PRON- PRP 3168 108 38 violates violate VBZ 3168 108 39 the the DT 3168 108 40 principles principle NNS 3168 108 41 of of IN 3168 108 42 librarianship librarianship NN 3168 108 43 or or CC 3168 108 44 for for IN 3168 108 45 a a DT 3168 108 46 number number NN 3168 108 47 of of IN 3168 108 48 other other JJ 3168 108 49 reasons reason NNS 3168 108 50 . . . 3168 109 1 In in IN 3168 109 2 2008 2008 CD 3168 109 3 , , , 3168 109 4 31.6 31.6 CD 3168 109 5 percent percent NN 3168 109 6 of of IN 3168 109 7 public public JJ 3168 109 8 libraries library NNS 3168 109 9 refused refuse VBD 3168 109 10 to to TO 3168 109 11 apply apply VB 3168 109 12 for for IN 3168 109 13 E e NN 3168 109 14 - - NN 3168 109 15 Rate rate NN 3168 109 16 or or CC 3168 109 17 LSTA lsta NN 3168 109 18 funds fund NNS 3168 109 19 specifically specifically RB 3168 109 20 to to TO 3168 109 21 avoid avoid VB 3168 109 22 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 109 23 requirements requirement NNS 3168 109 24 , , , 3168 109 25 a a DT 3168 109 26 substantial substantial JJ 3168 109 27 increase increase NN 3168 109 28 from from IN 3168 109 29 the the DT 3168 109 30 15.3 15.3 CD 3168 109 31 percent percent NN 3168 109 32 of of IN 3168 109 33 libraries library NNS 3168 109 34 that that WDT 3168 109 35 did do VBD 3168 109 36 not not RB 3168 109 37 apply apply VB 3168 109 38 for for IN 3168 109 39 E e NN 3168 109 40 - - NN 3168 109 41 Rate rate NN 3168 109 42 because because IN 3168 109 43 of of IN 3168 109 44 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 109 45 in in IN 3168 109 46 2006.50 2006.50 CD 3168 109 47 As as IN 3168 109 48 a a DT 3168 109 49 result result NN 3168 109 50 of of IN 3168 109 51 defending defend VBG 3168 109 52 patron patron NN 3168 109 53 ’s ’s POS 3168 109 54 rights right NNS 3168 109 55 to to IN 3168 109 56 free free JJ 3168 109 57 access access NN 3168 109 58 , , , 3168 109 59 the the DT 3168 109 60 libraries library NNS 3168 109 61 that that WDT 3168 109 62 are be VBP 3168 109 63 not not RB 3168 109 64 applying apply VBG 3168 109 65 for for IN 3168 109 66 E e NN 3168 109 67 - - NN 3168 109 68 Rate rate NN 3168 109 69 funds fund NNS 3168 109 70 because because IN 3168 109 71 of of IN 3168 109 72 the the DT 3168 109 73 requirements requirement NNS 3168 109 74 of of IN 3168 109 75 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 109 76 are be VBP 3168 109 77 being be VBG 3168 109 78 forced force VBN 3168 109 79 to to TO 3168 109 80 turn turn VB 3168 109 81 down down RP 3168 109 82 the the DT 3168 109 83 chance chance NN 3168 109 84 for for IN 3168 109 85 fund- fund- NNP 3168 109 86 ing ing NNP 3168 109 87 to to TO 3168 109 88 help help VB 3168 109 89 pay pay VB 3168 109 90 for for IN 3168 109 91 Internet internet NN 3168 109 92 access access NN 3168 109 93 in in IN 3168 109 94 order order NN 3168 109 95 to to TO 3168 109 96 preserve preserve VB 3168 109 97 community community NN 3168 109 98 access access NN 3168 109 99 to to IN 3168 109 100 the the DT 3168 109 101 Internet internet NN 3168 109 102 . . . 3168 110 1 Because because IN 3168 110 2 many many JJ 3168 110 3 librar- librar- NN 3168 110 4 ies ie NNS 3168 110 5 feel feel VBP 3168 110 6 that that IN 3168 110 7 they -PRON- PRP 3168 110 8 can can MD 3168 110 9 not not RB 3168 110 10 apply apply VB 3168 110 11 for for IN 3168 110 12 E e NN 3168 110 13 - - NN 3168 110 14 Rate rate NN 3168 110 15 funds fund NNS 3168 110 16 , , , 3168 110 17 local local JJ 3168 110 18 and and CC 3168 110 19 regional regional JJ 3168 110 20 discrepancies discrepancy NNS 3168 110 21 are be VBP 3168 110 22 occurring occur VBG 3168 110 23 in in IN 3168 110 24 the the DT 3168 110 25 levels level NNS 3168 110 26 of of IN 3168 110 27 Internet internet NN 3168 110 28 access access NN 3168 110 29 that that WDT 3168 110 30 are be VBP 3168 110 31 available available JJ 3168 110 32 to to IN 3168 110 33 patrons patron NNS 3168 110 34 of of IN 3168 110 35 public public JJ 3168 110 36 libraries library NNS 3168 110 37 in in IN 3168 110 38 different different JJ 3168 110 39 parts part NNS 3168 110 40 of of IN 3168 110 41 the the DT 3168 110 42 country.51 country.51 NNP 3168 110 43 For for IN 3168 110 44 adult adult NN 3168 110 45 patrons patron NNS 3168 110 46 who who WP 3168 110 47 wish wish VBP 3168 110 48 to to TO 3168 110 49 access access VB 3168 110 50 material material NN 3168 110 51 on on IN 3168 110 52 computers computer NNS 3168 110 53 with with IN 3168 110 54 filters filter NNS 3168 110 55 , , , 3168 110 56 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 110 57 states state VBZ 3168 110 58 that that IN 3168 110 59 the the DT 3168 110 60 library library NN 3168 110 61 has have VBZ 3168 110 62 the the DT 3168 110 63 option option NN 3168 110 64 of of IN 3168 110 65 disabling disable VBG 3168 110 66 the the DT 3168 110 67 filters filter NNS 3168 110 68 for for IN 3168 110 69 “ " `` 3168 110 70 bona bona FW 3168 110 71 fide fide JJ 3168 110 72 research research NN 3168 110 73 or or CC 3168 110 74 other other JJ 3168 110 75 lawful lawful JJ 3168 110 76 purposes purpose NNS 3168 110 77 ” " '' 3168 110 78 when when WRB 3168 110 79 adult adult NN 3168 110 80 patrons patron NNS 3168 110 81 request request VBP 3168 110 82 such such JJ 3168 110 83 disabling disabling NN 3168 110 84 . . . 3168 111 1 The the DT 3168 111 2 law law NN 3168 111 3 does do VBZ 3168 111 4 not not RB 3168 111 5 require require VB 3168 111 6 libraries library NNS 3168 111 7 to to IN 3168 111 8 12 12 CD 3168 111 9 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNS 3168 111 10 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3168 111 11 AND and CC 3168 111 12 LIBRARIES library NNS 3168 111 13 | | NNP 3168 111 14 MARCH MARCH NNP 3168 111 15 2009 2009 CD 3168 111 16 disable disable VB 3168 111 17 the the DT 3168 111 18 filters filter NNS 3168 111 19 for for IN 3168 111 20 adult adult NN 3168 111 21 patrons patron NNS 3168 111 22 , , , 3168 111 23 and and CC 3168 111 24 the the DT 3168 111 25 criteria criterion NNS 3168 111 26 for for IN 3168 111 27 disabling disabling NN 3168 111 28 of of IN 3168 111 29 filters filter NNS 3168 111 30 do do VBP 3168 111 31 not not RB 3168 111 32 have have VB 3168 111 33 a a DT 3168 111 34 set set VBN 3168 111 35 definition definition NN 3168 111 36 in in IN 3168 111 37 the the DT 3168 111 38 law law NN 3168 111 39 . . . 3168 112 1 The the DT 3168 112 2 potential potential JJ 3168 112 3 problems problem NNS 3168 112 4 in in IN 3168 112 5 the the DT 3168 112 6 process process NN 3168 112 7 of of IN 3168 112 8 having have VBG 3168 112 9 the the DT 3168 112 10 filters filter NNS 3168 112 11 disabled disable VBN 3168 112 12 are be VBP 3168 112 13 many many JJ 3168 112 14 and and CC 3168 112 15 significant significant JJ 3168 112 16 , , , 3168 112 17 including include VBG 3168 112 18 librarians librarian NNS 3168 112 19 not not RB 3168 112 20 allowing allow VBG 3168 112 21 the the DT 3168 112 22 filters filter NNS 3168 112 23 to to TO 3168 112 24 be be VB 3168 112 25 turned turn VBN 3168 112 26 off off RP 3168 112 27 , , , 3168 112 28 librarians librarian NNS 3168 112 29 not not RB 3168 112 30 knowing know VBG 3168 112 31 how how WRB 3168 112 32 to to TO 3168 112 33 turn turn VB 3168 112 34 the the DT 3168 112 35 filters filter NNS 3168 112 36 off off RP 3168 112 37 , , , 3168 112 38 the the DT 3168 112 39 filtering filter VBG 3168 112 40 software software NN 3168 112 41 being be VBG 3168 112 42 too too RB 3168 112 43 complicated complicated JJ 3168 112 44 to to TO 3168 112 45 turn turn VB 3168 112 46 off off RP 3168 112 47 without without IN 3168 112 48 injuring injure VBG 3168 112 49 the the DT 3168 112 50 performance performance NN 3168 112 51 of of IN 3168 112 52 the the DT 3168 112 53 workstation workstation NN 3168 112 54 in in IN 3168 112 55 other other JJ 3168 112 56 applications application NNS 3168 112 57 , , , 3168 112 58 or or CC 3168 112 59 the the DT 3168 112 60 filtering filter VBG 3168 112 61 software software NN 3168 112 62 being be VBG 3168 112 63 unable unable JJ 3168 112 64 to to TO 3168 112 65 be be VB 3168 112 66 turned turn VBN 3168 112 67 off off RP 3168 112 68 in in IN 3168 112 69 a a DT 3168 112 70 reasonable reasonable JJ 3168 112 71 amount amount NN 3168 112 72 of of IN 3168 112 73 time.52 time.52 NNP 3168 112 74 It -PRON- PRP 3168 112 75 has have VBZ 3168 112 76 been be VBN 3168 112 77 estimated estimate VBN 3168 112 78 that that IN 3168 112 79 approximately approximately RB 3168 112 80 11 11 CD 3168 112 81 million million CD 3168 112 82 low low JJ 3168 112 83 - - HYPH 3168 112 84 income income NN 3168 112 85 individuals individual NNS 3168 112 86 rely rely VBP 3168 112 87 on on IN 3168 112 88 public public JJ 3168 112 89 libraries library NNS 3168 112 90 to to TO 3168 112 91 access access VB 3168 112 92 online online JJ 3168 112 93 information information NN 3168 112 94 because because IN 3168 112 95 they -PRON- PRP 3168 112 96 lack lack VBP 3168 112 97 Internet internet NN 3168 112 98 access access NN 3168 112 99 at at IN 3168 112 100 home home NN 3168 112 101 or or CC 3168 112 102 work.53 work.53 NNP 3168 112 103 The the DT 3168 112 104 E E NNP 3168 112 105 - - NN 3168 112 106 Rate rate NN 3168 112 107 and and CC 3168 112 108 LSTA lsta NN 3168 112 109 programs program NNS 3168 112 110 have have VBP 3168 112 111 helped help VBN 3168 112 112 to to TO 3168 112 113 make make VB 3168 112 114 public public JJ 3168 112 115 libraries library NNS 3168 112 116 a a DT 3168 112 117 trusted trust VBN 3168 112 118 community community NN 3168 112 119 source source NN 3168 112 120 of of IN 3168 112 121 Internet internet NN 3168 112 122 access access NN 3168 112 123 , , , 3168 112 124 with with IN 3168 112 125 the the DT 3168 112 126 public public JJ 3168 112 127 library library NN 3168 112 128 being be VBG 3168 112 129 the the DT 3168 112 130 only only JJ 3168 112 131 source source NN 3168 112 132 of of IN 3168 112 133 free free JJ 3168 112 134 public public JJ 3168 112 135 Internet internet NN 3168 112 136 access access NN 3168 112 137 available available JJ 3168 112 138 to to IN 3168 112 139 all all DT 3168 112 140 community community NN 3168 112 141 residents resident NNS 3168 112 142 in in IN 3168 112 143 nearly nearly RB 3168 112 144 75 75 CD 3168 112 145 percent percent NN 3168 112 146 of of IN 3168 112 147 communities community NNS 3168 112 148 in in IN 3168 112 149 the the DT 3168 112 150 United United NNP 3168 112 151 States.54 States.54 . 3168 112 152 Therefore therefore RB 3168 112 153 usage usage NN 3168 112 154 of of IN 3168 112 155 computers computer NNS 3168 112 156 and and CC 3168 112 157 the the DT 3168 112 158 Internet internet NN 3168 112 159 in in IN 3168 112 160 public public JJ 3168 112 161 libraries library NNS 3168 112 162 has have VBZ 3168 112 163 continued continue VBN 3168 112 164 to to TO 3168 112 165 grow grow VB 3168 112 166 at at IN 3168 112 167 a a DT 3168 112 168 very very RB 3168 112 169 fast fast JJ 3168 112 170 pace pace NN 3168 112 171 over over IN 3168 112 172 the the DT 3168 112 173 past past JJ 3168 112 174 ten ten CD 3168 112 175 years.55 years.55 NNP 3168 112 176 Thus Thus NNP 3168 112 177 public public JJ 3168 112 178 librar- librar- XX 3168 112 179 ies ie NNS 3168 112 180 are be VBP 3168 112 181 torn tear VBN 3168 112 182 between between IN 3168 112 183 the the DT 3168 112 184 values value NNS 3168 112 185 of of IN 3168 112 186 providing provide VBG 3168 112 187 safe safe JJ 3168 112 188 access access NN 3168 112 189 for for IN 3168 112 190 younger young JJR 3168 112 191 patrons patron NNS 3168 112 192 and and CC 3168 112 193 broad broad JJ 3168 112 194 access access NN 3168 112 195 for for IN 3168 112 196 adult adult NN 3168 112 197 patrons patron NNS 3168 112 198 who who WP 3168 112 199 may may MD 3168 112 200 have have VB 3168 112 201 no no DT 3168 112 202 other other JJ 3168 112 203 means mean NNS 3168 112 204 of of IN 3168 112 205 accessing access VBG 3168 112 206 the the DT 3168 112 207 Internet internet NN 3168 112 208 . . . 3168 113 1 n n NNP 3168 113 2 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 113 3 , , , 3168 113 4 public public JJ 3168 113 5 policy policy NN 3168 113 6 , , , 3168 113 7 and and CC 3168 113 8 further further JJ 3168 113 9 research research NN 3168 113 10 While while IN 3168 113 11 the the DT 3168 113 12 diverse diverse JJ 3168 113 13 implementations implementation NNS 3168 113 14 , , , 3168 113 15 effects effect NNS 3168 113 16 , , , 3168 113 17 and and CC 3168 113 18 levels level NNS 3168 113 19 of of IN 3168 113 20 acceptance acceptance NN 3168 113 21 of of IN 3168 113 22 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 113 23 across across IN 3168 113 24 schools school NNS 3168 113 25 and and CC 3168 113 26 libraries library NNS 3168 113 27 dem- dem- RB 3168 113 28 onstrate onstrate VBP 3168 113 29 the the DT 3168 113 30 wide wide JJ 3168 113 31 range range NN 3168 113 32 of of IN 3168 113 33 potential potential JJ 3168 113 34 ramifications ramification NNS 3168 113 35 of of IN 3168 113 36 the the DT 3168 113 37 law law NN 3168 113 38 , , , 3168 113 39 surprisingly surprisingly RB 3168 113 40 little little JJ 3168 113 41 consideration consideration NN 3168 113 42 is be VBZ 3168 113 43 given give VBN 3168 113 44 to to IN 3168 113 45 major major JJ 3168 113 46 assumptions assumption NNS 3168 113 47 in in IN 3168 113 48 the the DT 3168 113 49 law law NN 3168 113 50 , , , 3168 113 51 including include VBG 3168 113 52 the the DT 3168 113 53 appropriateness appropriateness NN 3168 113 54 of of IN 3168 113 55 the the DT 3168 113 56 requirements requirement NNS 3168 113 57 to to IN 3168 113 58 different different JJ 3168 113 59 age age NN 3168 113 60 groups group NNS 3168 113 61 and and CC 3168 113 62 the the DT 3168 113 63 nature nature NN 3168 113 64 of of IN 3168 113 65 information information NN 3168 113 66 on on IN 3168 113 67 the the DT 3168 113 68 Internet internet NN 3168 113 69 . . . 3168 114 1 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 114 2 treats treat VBZ 3168 114 3 all all DT 3168 114 4 users user NNS 3168 114 5 as as IN 3168 114 6 if if IN 3168 114 7 they -PRON- PRP 3168 114 8 are be VBP 3168 114 9 the the DT 3168 114 10 same same JJ 3168 114 11 level level NN 3168 114 12 of of IN 3168 114 13 maturity maturity NN 3168 114 14 and and CC 3168 114 15 need need VB 3168 114 16 the the DT 3168 114 17 same same JJ 3168 114 18 level level NN 3168 114 19 of of IN 3168 114 20 protection protection NN 3168 114 21 as as IN 3168 114 22 a a DT 3168 114 23 small small JJ 3168 114 24 child child NN 3168 114 25 , , , 3168 114 26 as as IN 3168 114 27 evidenced evidence VBN 3168 114 28 by by IN 3168 114 29 the the DT 3168 114 30 require- require- JJ 3168 114 31 ment ment NN 3168 114 32 that that IN 3168 114 33 all all DT 3168 114 34 computers computer NNS 3168 114 35 in in IN 3168 114 36 a a DT 3168 114 37 library library NN 3168 114 38 or or CC 3168 114 39 school school NN 3168 114 40 have have VBP 3168 114 41 filters filter NNS 3168 114 42 regardless regardless RB 3168 114 43 of of IN 3168 114 44 whether whether IN 3168 114 45 children child NNS 3168 114 46 use use VBP 3168 114 47 a a DT 3168 114 48 particular particular JJ 3168 114 49 computer computer NN 3168 114 50 . . . 3168 115 1 In in IN 3168 115 2 reality reality NN 3168 115 3 , , , 3168 115 4 children child NNS 3168 115 5 and and CC 3168 115 6 adults adult NNS 3168 115 7 interact interact VBP 3168 115 8 in in IN 3168 115 9 different different JJ 3168 115 10 social social JJ 3168 115 11 , , , 3168 115 12 physical physical JJ 3168 115 13 , , , 3168 115 14 and and CC 3168 115 15 cognitive cognitive JJ 3168 115 16 ways way NNS 3168 115 17 with with IN 3168 115 18 computers computer NNS 3168 115 19 because because IN 3168 115 20 of of IN 3168 115 21 different different JJ 3168 115 22 developmental developmental JJ 3168 115 23 processes.56 processes.56 NNP 3168 115 24 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 115 25 fails fail VBZ 3168 115 26 to to TO 3168 115 27 recognize recognize VB 3168 115 28 that that IN 3168 115 29 children child NNS 3168 115 30 as as IN 3168 115 31 individual individual JJ 3168 115 32 users user NNS 3168 115 33 are be VBP 3168 115 34 active active JJ 3168 115 35 processors processor NNS 3168 115 36 of of IN 3168 115 37 information information NN 3168 115 38 and and CC 3168 115 39 that that IN 3168 115 40 children child NNS 3168 115 41 of of IN 3168 115 42 different different JJ 3168 115 43 ages age NNS 3168 115 44 are be VBP 3168 115 45 going go VBG 3168 115 46 to to TO 3168 115 47 be be VB 3168 115 48 affected affect VBN 3168 115 49 in in IN 3168 115 50 divergent divergent JJ 3168 115 51 ways way NNS 3168 115 52 by by IN 3168 115 53 filtering filter VBG 3168 115 54 programs.57 programs.57 NNP 3168 115 55 Younger Younger NNP 3168 115 56 children child NNS 3168 115 57 benefit benefit VBP 3168 115 58 from from IN 3168 115 59 more more JJR 3168 115 60 restrictive restrictive JJ 3168 115 61 filters filter NNS 3168 115 62 while while IN 3168 115 63 older old JJR 3168 115 64 children child NNS 3168 115 65 benefit benefit VBP 3168 115 66 from from IN 3168 115 67 less less JJR 3168 115 68 restrictive restrictive JJ 3168 115 69 filters filter NNS 3168 115 70 . . . 3168 116 1 Moreover moreover RB 3168 116 2 , , , 3168 116 3 filtering filtering NN 3168 116 4 can can MD 3168 116 5 be be VB 3168 116 6 compli- compli- NN 3168 116 7 mented mente VBN 3168 116 8 by by IN 3168 116 9 encouragement encouragement NN 3168 116 10 of of IN 3168 116 11 frequent frequent JJ 3168 116 12 positive positive JJ 3168 116 13 Internet internet NN 3168 116 14 usage usage NN 3168 116 15 and and CC 3168 116 16 informal informal JJ 3168 116 17 instruction instruction NN 3168 116 18 to to TO 3168 116 19 encourage encourage VB 3168 116 20 positive positive JJ 3168 116 21 use use NN 3168 116 22 . . . 3168 117 1 Finally finally RB 3168 117 2 , , , 3168 117 3 children child NNS 3168 117 4 of of IN 3168 117 5 all all DT 3168 117 6 ages age NNS 3168 117 7 need need VBP 3168 117 8 a a DT 3168 117 9 better well JJR 3168 117 10 understanding understanding NN 3168 117 11 of of IN 3168 117 12 the the DT 3168 117 13 structure structure NN 3168 117 14 of of IN 3168 117 15 the the DT 3168 117 16 Internet internet NN 3168 117 17 to to TO 3168 117 18 encourage encourage VB 3168 117 19 appropriate appropriate JJ 3168 117 20 caution caution NN 3168 117 21 in in IN 3168 117 22 terms term NNS 3168 117 23 of of IN 3168 117 24 online online JJ 3168 117 25 safety safety NN 3168 117 26 . . . 3168 118 1 The the DT 3168 118 2 Internet internet NN 3168 118 3 represents represent VBZ 3168 118 4 a a DT 3168 118 5 new new JJ 3168 118 6 social social JJ 3168 118 7 and and CC 3168 118 8 cultural cultural JJ 3168 118 9 environment environment NN 3168 118 10 in in IN 3168 118 11 which which WDT 3168 118 12 users user NNS 3168 118 13 simultaneously simultaneously RB 3168 118 14 are be VBP 3168 118 15 affected affect VBN 3168 118 16 by by IN 3168 118 17 the the DT 3168 118 18 social social JJ 3168 118 19 environment environment NN 3168 118 20 and and CC 3168 118 21 also also RB 3168 118 22 construct construct VB 3168 118 23 that that DT 3168 118 24 environment environment NN 3168 118 25 with with IN 3168 118 26 other other JJ 3168 118 27 users.58 users.58 NNP 3168 118 28 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 118 29 also also RB 3168 118 30 is be VBZ 3168 118 31 based base VBN 3168 118 32 on on IN 3168 118 33 fundamental fundamental JJ 3168 118 34 misconceptions misconception NNS 3168 118 35 about about IN 3168 118 36 information information NN 3168 118 37 on on IN 3168 118 38 the the DT 3168 118 39 Internet internet NN 3168 118 40 . . . 3168 119 1 The the DT 3168 119 2 Supreme Supreme NNP 3168 119 3 Court Court NNP 3168 119 4 ’s ’s POS 3168 119 5 decision decision NN 3168 119 6 upholding upholding NN 3168 119 7 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 119 8 represents represent VBZ 3168 119 9 several several JJ 3168 119 10 of of IN 3168 119 11 these these DT 3168 119 12 mis- mis- NNS 3168 119 13 conceptions conception NNS 3168 119 14 , , , 3168 119 15 adopting adopt VBG 3168 119 16 an an DT 3168 119 17 attitude attitude NN 3168 119 18 that that IN 3168 119 19 ‘ ' `` 3168 119 20 we -PRON- PRP 3168 119 21 know know VBP 3168 119 22 what what WP 3168 119 23 is be VBZ 3168 119 24 best good JJS 3168 119 25 for for IN 3168 119 26 you -PRON- PRP 3168 119 27 ’ ' '' 3168 119 28 in in IN 3168 119 29 terms term NNS 3168 119 30 of of IN 3168 119 31 the the DT 3168 119 32 information information NN 3168 119 33 that that WDT 3168 119 34 citizens citizen NNS 3168 119 35 should should MD 3168 119 36 be be VB 3168 119 37 allowed allow VBN 3168 119 38 to to IN 3168 119 39 access.59 access.59 NNP 3168 119 40 It -PRON- PRP 3168 119 41 assumes assume VBZ 3168 119 42 that that IN 3168 119 43 schools school NNS 3168 119 44 and and CC 3168 119 45 libraries library NNS 3168 119 46 select select VBP 3168 119 47 printed print VBN 3168 119 48 materials material NNS 3168 119 49 out out IN 3168 119 50 of of IN 3168 119 51 a a DT 3168 119 52 desire desire NN 3168 119 53 to to TO 3168 119 54 protect protect VB 3168 119 55 and and CC 3168 119 56 censor censor VB 3168 119 57 rather rather RB 3168 119 58 than than IN 3168 119 59 recognizing recognize VBG 3168 119 60 the the DT 3168 119 61 basic basic JJ 3168 119 62 reality reality NN 3168 119 63 that that IN 3168 119 64 only only RB 3168 119 65 a a DT 3168 119 66 small small JJ 3168 119 67 number number NN 3168 119 68 of of IN 3168 119 69 print print NN 3168 119 70 materials material NNS 3168 119 71 can can MD 3168 119 72 be be VB 3168 119 73 afforded afford VBN 3168 119 74 by by IN 3168 119 75 any any DT 3168 119 76 school school NN 3168 119 77 or or CC 3168 119 78 library library NN 3168 119 79 . . . 3168 120 1 The the DT 3168 120 2 Internet internet NN 3168 120 3 frees free VBZ 3168 120 4 schools school NNS 3168 120 5 and and CC 3168 120 6 libraries library NNS 3168 120 7 from from IN 3168 120 8 many many JJ 3168 120 9 of of IN 3168 120 10 these these DT 3168 120 11 costs cost NNS 3168 120 12 . . . 3168 121 1 Furthermore furthermore RB 3168 121 2 , , , 3168 121 3 the the DT 3168 121 4 Court Court NNP 3168 121 5 assumes assume VBZ 3168 121 6 that that IN 3168 121 7 libraries library NNS 3168 121 8 should should MD 3168 121 9 censor censor VB 3168 121 10 the the DT 3168 121 11 Internet internet NN 3168 121 12 as as RB 3168 121 13 well well RB 3168 121 14 , , , 3168 121 15 ultimately ultimately RB 3168 121 16 upholding uphold VBG 3168 121 17 the the DT 3168 121 18 same same JJ 3168 121 19 level level NN 3168 121 20 of of IN 3168 121 21 access access NN 3168 121 22 to to IN 3168 121 23 information information NN 3168 121 24 for for IN 3168 121 25 adult adult NN 3168 121 26 patrons patron NNS 3168 121 27 and and CC 3168 121 28 librarians librarian NNS 3168 121 29 in in IN 3168 121 30 public public JJ 3168 121 31 libraries library NNS 3168 121 32 as as IN 3168 121 33 students student NNS 3168 121 34 in in IN 3168 121 35 public public JJ 3168 121 36 schools school NNS 3168 121 37 . . . 3168 122 1 These these DT 3168 122 2 two two CD 3168 122 3 major major JJ 3168 122 4 unexamined unexamined JJ 3168 122 5 assumptions assumption NNS 3168 122 6 in in IN 3168 122 7 the the DT 3168 122 8 law law NN 3168 122 9 certainly certainly RB 3168 122 10 have have VBP 3168 122 11 played play VBN 3168 122 12 a a DT 3168 122 13 part part NN 3168 122 14 in in IN 3168 122 15 the the DT 3168 122 16 difficulty difficulty NN 3168 122 17 of of IN 3168 122 18 implementing implement VBG 3168 122 19 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 122 20 and and CC 3168 122 21 in in IN 3168 122 22 the the DT 3168 122 23 resistance resistance NN 3168 122 24 to to IN 3168 122 25 the the DT 3168 122 26 law law NN 3168 122 27 . . . 3168 123 1 And and CC 3168 123 2 this this DT 3168 123 3 does do VBZ 3168 123 4 not not RB 3168 123 5 even even RB 3168 123 6 address address VB 3168 123 7 the the DT 3168 123 8 problems problem NNS 3168 123 9 of of IN 3168 123 10 assuming assume VBG 3168 123 11 that that IN 3168 123 12 public public JJ 3168 123 13 libraries library NNS 3168 123 14 and and CC 3168 123 15 public public JJ 3168 123 16 schools school NNS 3168 123 17 can can MD 3168 123 18 be be VB 3168 123 19 treated treat VBN 3168 123 20 interchangeably interchangeably RB 3168 123 21 in in IN 3168 123 22 crafting craft VBG 3168 123 23 legislation legislation NN 3168 123 24 . . . 3168 124 1 These these DT 3168 124 2 problem- problem- XX 3168 124 3 atic atic JJ 3168 124 4 assumptions assumption NNS 3168 124 5 point point NN 3168 124 6 to to IN 3168 124 7 a a DT 3168 124 8 significantly significantly RB 3168 124 9 larger large JJR 3168 124 10 issue issue NN 3168 124 11 : : : 3168 124 12 In in IN 3168 124 13 trying try VBG 3168 124 14 to to TO 3168 124 15 deal deal VB 3168 124 16 with with IN 3168 124 17 the the DT 3168 124 18 new new JJ 3168 124 19 situations situation NNS 3168 124 20 created create VBN 3168 124 21 by by IN 3168 124 22 the the DT 3168 124 23 Internet internet NN 3168 124 24 and and CC 3168 124 25 related related JJ 3168 124 26 technology technology NN 3168 124 27 , , , 3168 124 28 the the DT 3168 124 29 federal federal JJ 3168 124 30 government government NN 3168 124 31 has have VBZ 3168 124 32 significantly significantly RB 3168 124 33 increased increase VBN 3168 124 34 the the DT 3168 124 35 attention attention NN 3168 124 36 paid pay VBN 3168 124 37 to to IN 3168 124 38 informa- informa- JJ 3168 124 39 tion tion NN 3168 124 40 policy.60 policy.60 NNP 3168 124 41 Over over IN 3168 124 42 the the DT 3168 124 43 past past JJ 3168 124 44 few few JJ 3168 124 45 years year NNS 3168 124 46 , , , 3168 124 47 government government NN 3168 124 48 laws law NNS 3168 124 49 and and CC 3168 124 50 standards standard NNS 3168 124 51 related relate VBN 3168 124 52 to to IN 3168 124 53 information information NN 3168 124 54 have have VBP 3168 124 55 begun begin VBN 3168 124 56 to to TO 3168 124 57 more more RBR 3168 124 58 clearly clearly RB 3168 124 59 relate relate JJ 3168 124 60 to to IN 3168 124 61 social social JJ 3168 124 62 aspects aspect NNS 3168 124 63 of of IN 3168 124 64 information information NN 3168 124 65 technolo- technolo- NN 3168 124 66 gies gy NNS 3168 124 67 such such JJ 3168 124 68 as as IN 3168 124 69 the the DT 3168 124 70 filtering filtering NN 3168 124 71 requirements requirement NNS 3168 124 72 of of IN 3168 124 73 CIPA.61 CIPA.61 NNP 3168 124 74 But but CC 3168 124 75 the the DT 3168 124 76 social social JJ 3168 124 77 , , , 3168 124 78 economic economic JJ 3168 124 79 , , , 3168 124 80 and and CC 3168 124 81 political political JJ 3168 124 82 ramifications ramification NNS 3168 124 83 for for IN 3168 124 84 decisions decision NNS 3168 124 85 about about IN 3168 124 86 information information NN 3168 124 87 policy policy NN 3168 124 88 are be VBP 3168 124 89 often often RB 3168 124 90 woefully woefully RB 3168 124 91 underexam- underexam- RB 3168 124 92 ined ine VBN 3168 124 93 in in IN 3168 124 94 the the DT 3168 124 95 development development NN 3168 124 96 of of IN 3168 124 97 legislation.62 legislation.62 NNP 3168 124 98 This this DT 3168 124 99 paper paper NN 3168 124 100 has have VBZ 3168 124 101 documented document VBN 3168 124 102 that that IN 3168 124 103 many many JJ 3168 124 104 of of IN 3168 124 105 the the DT 3168 124 106 reasons reason NNS 3168 124 107 for for IN 3168 124 108 and and CC 3168 124 109 statistics statistic NNS 3168 124 110 about about IN 3168 124 111 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 124 112 implementation implementation NN 3168 124 113 are be VBP 3168 124 114 avail- avail- JJ 3168 124 115 able able JJ 3168 124 116 by by IN 3168 124 117 bringing bring VBG 3168 124 118 together together RB 3168 124 119 information information NN 3168 124 120 from from IN 3168 124 121 different different JJ 3168 124 122 social social JJ 3168 124 123 institutions institution NNS 3168 124 124 . . . 3168 125 1 The the DT 3168 125 2 biggest big JJS 3168 125 3 questions question NNS 3168 125 4 about about IN 3168 125 5 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 125 6 are be VBP 3168 125 7 about about IN 3168 125 8 the the DT 3168 125 9 societal societal JJ 3168 125 10 effects effect NNS 3168 125 11 of of IN 3168 125 12 the the DT 3168 125 13 policy policy NN 3168 125 14 decisions decision NNS 3168 125 15 : : : 3168 125 16 n n NNP 3168 125 17 Has Has NNP 3168 125 18 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 125 19 changed change VBD 3168 125 20 the the DT 3168 125 21 education education NN 3168 125 22 and and CC 3168 125 23 information- information- NN 3168 125 24 provision provision NN 3168 125 25 roles role NNS 3168 125 26 of of IN 3168 125 27 libraries library NNS 3168 125 28 and and CC 3168 125 29 schools school NNS 3168 125 30 ? ? . 3168 126 1 n n NNP 3168 126 2 Has Has NNP 3168 126 3 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 126 4 changed change VBD 3168 126 5 the the DT 3168 126 6 social social JJ 3168 126 7 expectations expectation NNS 3168 126 8 for for IN 3168 126 9 libraries library NNS 3168 126 10 and and CC 3168 126 11 schools school NNS 3168 126 12 ? ? . 3168 127 1 n n LS 3168 127 2 Have have VBP 3168 127 3 adult adult NN 3168 127 4 patron patron NN 3168 127 5 information information NN 3168 127 6 behaviors behavior NNS 3168 127 7 changed change VBD 3168 127 8 in in IN 3168 127 9 libraries library NNS 3168 127 10 ? ? . 3168 128 1 n n LS 3168 128 2 Have have VBP 3168 128 3 minor minor JJ 3168 128 4 patron patron NN 3168 128 5 information information NN 3168 128 6 behaviors behavior NNS 3168 128 7 changed change VBD 3168 128 8 in in IN 3168 128 9 libraries library NNS 3168 128 10 ? ? . 3168 129 1 n n LS 3168 129 2 Have have VBP 3168 129 3 student student NN 3168 129 4 information information NN 3168 129 5 behaviors behavior NNS 3168 129 6 changed change VBN 3168 129 7 in in IN 3168 129 8 school school NN 3168 129 9 ? ? . 3168 130 1 n n LS 3168 130 2 How how WRB 3168 130 3 has have VBZ 3168 130 4 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 130 5 changed change VBD 3168 130 6 the the DT 3168 130 7 management management NN 3168 130 8 of of IN 3168 130 9 librar- librar- NNP 3168 130 10 ies ie NNS 3168 130 11 and and CC 3168 130 12 schools school NNS 3168 130 13 ? ? . 3168 131 1 n n LS 3168 131 2 Will Will NNP 3168 131 3 Congress Congress NNP 3168 131 4 view view VB 3168 131 5 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 131 6 as as IN 3168 131 7 successful successful JJ 3168 131 8 enough enough RB 3168 131 9 to to TO 3168 131 10 merit merit NN 3168 131 11 using use VBG 3168 131 12 libraries library NNS 3168 131 13 and and CC 3168 131 14 schools school NNS 3168 131 15 as as IN 3168 131 16 the the DT 3168 131 17 means mean NNS 3168 131 18 of of IN 3168 131 19 enforcing enforce VBG 3168 131 20 other other JJ 3168 131 21 legislation legislation NN 3168 131 22 ? ? . 3168 132 1 ONE one CD 3168 132 2 LAw LAw NNP 3168 132 3 wITH with IN 3168 132 4 TwO TwO NNP 3168 132 5 OuTCOMES OuTCOMES NNP 3168 132 6 | | NNP 3168 132 7 JAEGER JAEGER NNP 3168 132 8 AND and CC 3168 132 9 YAN YAN NNP 3168 132 10 13 13 CD 3168 132 11 But but CC 3168 132 12 these these DT 3168 132 13 social social JJ 3168 132 14 and and CC 3168 132 15 administrative administrative JJ 3168 132 16 concerns concern NNS 3168 132 17 are be VBP 3168 132 18 not not RB 3168 132 19 the the DT 3168 132 20 only only JJ 3168 132 21 major major JJ 3168 132 22 research research NN 3168 132 23 questions question NNS 3168 132 24 raised raise VBN 3168 132 25 by by IN 3168 132 26 the the DT 3168 132 27 imple- imple- NN 3168 132 28 mentation mentation NN 3168 132 29 of of IN 3168 132 30 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 132 31 . . . 3168 133 1 Future future JJ 3168 133 2 research research NN 3168 133 3 about about IN 3168 133 4 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 133 5 not not RB 3168 133 6 only only RB 3168 133 7 needs need VBZ 3168 133 8 to to TO 3168 133 9 focus focus VB 3168 133 10 on on IN 3168 133 11 the the DT 3168 133 12 individual individual JJ 3168 133 13 , , , 3168 133 14 institutional institutional JJ 3168 133 15 , , , 3168 133 16 and and CC 3168 133 17 social social JJ 3168 133 18 effects effect NNS 3168 133 19 of of IN 3168 133 20 the the DT 3168 133 21 law law NN 3168 133 22 . . . 3168 134 1 It -PRON- PRP 3168 134 2 must must MD 3168 134 3 explore explore VB 3168 134 4 the the DT 3168 134 5 lessons lesson NNS 3168 134 6 that that WDT 3168 134 7 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 134 8 can can MD 3168 134 9 provide provide VB 3168 134 10 to to IN 3168 134 11 the the DT 3168 134 12 process process NN 3168 134 13 of of IN 3168 134 14 creating create VBG 3168 134 15 and and CC 3168 134 16 implementing implement VBG 3168 134 17 information information NN 3168 134 18 policies policy NNS 3168 134 19 with with IN 3168 134 20 significant significant JJ 3168 134 21 societal societal JJ 3168 134 22 implications implication NNS 3168 134 23 . . . 3168 135 1 The the DT 3168 135 2 most most RBS 3168 135 3 significant significant JJ 3168 135 4 research research NN 3168 135 5 issues issue NNS 3168 135 6 related relate VBN 3168 135 7 to to IN 3168 135 8 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 135 9 may may MD 3168 135 10 be be VB 3168 135 11 the the DT 3168 135 12 ones one NNS 3168 135 13 that that WDT 3168 135 14 help help VBP 3168 135 15 illuminate illuminate VB 3168 135 16 how how WRB 3168 135 17 to to TO 3168 135 18 improve improve VB 3168 135 19 the the DT 3168 135 20 legislative legislative JJ 3168 135 21 process process NN 3168 135 22 to to IN 3168 135 23 better well JJR 3168 135 24 account account VB 3168 135 25 for for IN 3168 135 26 the the DT 3168 135 27 potential potential JJ 3168 135 28 consequences consequence NNS 3168 135 29 of of IN 3168 135 30 regulating regulate VBG 3168 135 31 information information NN 3168 135 32 while while IN 3168 135 33 the the DT 3168 135 34 legislation legislation NN 3168 135 35 is be VBZ 3168 135 36 still still RB 3168 135 37 being be VBG 3168 135 38 developed develop VBN 3168 135 39 . . . 3168 136 1 Such such JJ 3168 136 2 cross cross JJ 3168 136 3 - - JJ 3168 136 4 disciplinary disciplinary JJ 3168 136 5 analyses analysis NNS 3168 136 6 would would MD 3168 136 7 be be VB 3168 136 8 of of IN 3168 136 9 great great JJ 3168 136 10 value value NN 3168 136 11 as as IN 3168 136 12 information information NN 3168 136 13 becomes become VBZ 3168 136 14 the the DT 3168 136 15 center center NN 3168 136 16 of of IN 3168 136 17 an an DT 3168 136 18 increasing increase VBG 3168 136 19 amount amount NN 3168 136 20 of of IN 3168 136 21 legislation legislation NN 3168 136 22 , , , 3168 136 23 and and CC 3168 136 24 the the DT 3168 136 25 effects effect NNS 3168 136 26 of of IN 3168 136 27 this this DT 3168 136 28 legislation legislation NN 3168 136 29 have have VBP 3168 136 30 continually continually RB 3168 136 31 wider wide JJR 3168 136 32 consequences consequence NNS 3168 136 33 for for IN 3168 136 34 the the DT 3168 136 35 flow flow NN 3168 136 36 of of IN 3168 136 37 information information NN 3168 136 38 through through IN 3168 136 39 society society NN 3168 136 40 . . . 3168 137 1 It -PRON- PRP 3168 137 2 could could MD 3168 137 3 also also RB 3168 137 4 be be VB 3168 137 5 of of IN 3168 137 6 great great JJ 3168 137 7 benefit benefit NN 3168 137 8 to to IN 3168 137 9 public public JJ 3168 137 10 schools school NNS 3168 137 11 and and CC 3168 137 12 libraries library NNS 3168 137 13 , , , 3168 137 14 which which WDT 3168 137 15 , , , 3168 137 16 if if IN 3168 137 17 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 137 18 is be VBZ 3168 137 19 any any DT 3168 137 20 indication indication NN 3168 137 21 , , , 3168 137 22 may may MD 3168 137 23 play play VB 3168 137 24 a a DT 3168 137 25 large large JJ 3168 137 26 role role NN 3168 137 27 in in IN 3168 137 28 future future JJ 3168 137 29 legislation legislation NN 3168 137 30 about about IN 3168 137 31 public public JJ 3168 137 32 Internet internet NN 3168 137 33 access access NN 3168 137 34 . . . 3168 138 1 References reference NNS 3168 138 2 1 1 CD 3168 138 3 . . . 3168 139 1 Children child NNS 3168 139 2 ’s ’s POS 3168 139 3 Internet Internet NNP 3168 139 4 Protection Protection NNP 3168 139 5 Act Act NNP 3168 139 6 ( ( -LRB- 3168 139 7 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 139 8 ) ) -RRB- 3168 139 9 , , , 3168 139 10 Public Public NNP 3168 139 11 Law Law NNP 3168 139 12 106- 106- CD 3168 139 13 554 554 CD 3168 139 14 . . . 3168 140 1 2 2 LS 3168 140 2 . . . 3168 141 1 United United NNP 3168 141 2 States States NNP 3168 141 3 v. v. CC 3168 141 4 American American NNP 3168 141 5 Library Library NNP 3168 141 6 Association Association NNP 3168 141 7 , , , 3168 141 8 539 539 CD 3168 141 9 U.S. U.S. NNP 3168 141 10 154 154 CD 3168 141 11 ( ( -LRB- 3168 141 12 2003 2003 CD 3168 141 13 ) ) -RRB- 3168 141 14 . . . 3168 142 1 3 3 LS 3168 142 2 . . . 3168 143 1 American American NNP 3168 143 2 Library Library NNP 3168 143 3 Association Association NNP 3168 143 4 , , , 3168 143 5 Libraries Libraries NNP 3168 143 6 Connect Connect NNP 3168 143 7 Communi- Communi- NNP 3168 143 8 ties tie NNS 3168 143 9 : : : 3168 143 10 Public Public NNP 3168 143 11 Library Library NNP 3168 143 12 Funding Funding NNP 3168 143 13 & & CC 3168 143 14 Technology Technology NNP 3168 143 15 Access Access NNP 3168 143 16 Study Study NNP 3168 143 17 2007–2008 2007–2008 CD 3168 143 18 ( ( -LRB- 3168 143 19 Chicago Chicago NNP 3168 143 20 : : : 3168 143 21 ALA ALA NNP 3168 143 22 , , , 3168 143 23 2008 2008 CD 3168 143 24 ) ) -RRB- 3168 143 25 ; ; : 3168 143 26 Paul Paul NNP 3168 143 27 T. T. NNP 3168 143 28 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 143 29 , , , 3168 143 30 John John NNP 3168 143 31 Carlo Carlo NNP 3168 143 32 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 143 33 , , , 3168 143 34 and and CC 3168 143 35 Charles Charles NNP 3168 143 36 R. R. NNP 3168 143 37 McClure McClure NNP 3168 143 38 , , , 3168 143 39 “ " `` 3168 143 40 The the DT 3168 143 41 Effects effect NNS 3168 143 42 of of IN 3168 143 43 the the DT 3168 143 44 Children Children NNPS 3168 143 45 ’s ’s POS 3168 143 46 Internet Internet NNP 3168 143 47 Protection Protection NNP 3168 143 48 Act Act NNP 3168 143 49 ( ( -LRB- 3168 143 50 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 143 51 ) ) -RRB- 3168 143 52 in in IN 3168 143 53 Public Public NNP 3168 143 54 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 143 55 and and CC 3168 143 56 its -PRON- PRP$ 3168 143 57 Implications implication NNS 3168 143 58 for for IN 3168 143 59 Research research NN 3168 143 60 : : : 3168 143 61 A a DT 3168 143 62 Statistical Statistical NNP 3168 143 63 , , , 3168 143 64 Policy policy NN 3168 143 65 , , , 3168 143 66 and and CC 3168 143 67 Legal Legal NNP 3168 143 68 Analysis Analysis NNP 3168 143 69 , , , 3168 143 70 ” " '' 3168 143 71 Journal Journal NNP 3168 143 72 of of IN 3168 143 73 the the DT 3168 143 74 American American NNP 3168 143 75 Society Society NNP 3168 143 76 for for IN 3168 143 77 Information Information NNP 3168 143 78 Science Science NNP 3168 143 79 and and CC 3168 143 80 Technology Technology NNP 3168 143 81 55 55 CD 3168 143 82 , , , 3168 143 83 no no UH 3168 143 84 . . . 3168 144 1 13 13 CD 3168 144 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 144 3 2004 2004 CD 3168 144 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 144 5 : : : 3168 144 6 1131–39 1131–39 LS 3168 144 7 ; ; : 3168 144 8 Paul Paul NNP 3168 144 9 T. T. NNP 3168 144 10 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 144 11 et et NNP 3168 144 12 al al NNP 3168 144 13 . . NNP 3168 144 14 , , , 3168 144 15 “ " `` 3168 144 16 Public Public NNP 3168 144 17 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 144 18 and and CC 3168 144 19 Internet Internet NNP 3168 144 20 Access access NN 3168 144 21 Across across IN 3168 144 22 the the DT 3168 144 23 United United NNP 3168 144 24 States States NNP 3168 144 25 : : : 3168 144 26 A a DT 3168 144 27 Comparison Comparison NNP 3168 144 28 by by IN 3168 144 29 State State NNP 3168 144 30 from from IN 3168 144 31 2004 2004 CD 3168 144 32 to to IN 3168 144 33 2006 2006 CD 3168 144 34 , , , 3168 144 35 ” " '' 3168 144 36 Information Information NNP 3168 144 37 Technology Technology NNP 3168 144 38 and and CC 3168 144 39 Librar- Librar- NNP 3168 144 40 ies ie VBZ 3168 144 41 26 26 CD 3168 144 42 , , , 3168 144 43 no no UH 3168 144 44 . . . 3168 145 1 2 2 CD 3168 145 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 145 3 2007 2007 CD 3168 145 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 145 5 : : : 3168 145 6 4–14 4–14 LS 3168 145 7 ; ; : 3168 145 8 Paul Paul NNP 3168 145 9 T. T. NNP 3168 145 10 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 145 11 et et NNP 3168 145 12 al al NNP 3168 145 13 . . NNP 3168 145 14 , , , 3168 145 15 “ " `` 3168 145 16 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 145 17 : : : 3168 145 18 Decisions decision NNS 3168 145 19 , , , 3168 145 20 Implementation implementation NN 3168 145 21 , , , 3168 145 22 and and CC 3168 145 23 Impacts impact NNS 3168 145 24 , , , 3168 145 25 ” " '' 3168 145 26 Public Public NNP 3168 145 27 Libraries Libraries NNP 3168 145 28 44 44 CD 3168 145 29 , , , 3168 145 30 no no UH 3168 145 31 . . . 3168 146 1 2 2 CD 3168 146 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 146 3 2005 2005 CD 3168 146 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 146 5 : : : 3168 146 6 105–9 105–9 CD 3168 146 7 ; ; : 3168 146 8 Zheng Zheng NNP 3168 146 9 Yan Yan NNP 3168 146 10 , , , 3168 146 11 “ " `` 3168 146 12 Limited limited JJ 3168 146 13 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 3168 146 14 and and CC 3168 146 15 Limited Limited NNP 3168 146 16 Resources Resources NNPS 3168 146 17 : : : 3168 146 18 Children child NNS 3168 146 19 ’s ’s POS 3168 146 20 and and CC 3168 146 21 Adolescents Adolescents NNP 3168 146 22 ’ ’ POS 3168 146 23 Understanding understanding NN 3168 146 24 of of IN 3168 146 25 the the DT 3168 146 26 Internet internet NN 3168 146 27 , , , 3168 146 28 ” " '' 3168 146 29 Journal Journal NNP 3168 146 30 of of IN 3168 146 31 Applied Applied NNP 3168 146 32 Developmental Developmental NNP 3168 146 33 Psychology Psychology NNP 3168 146 34 ( ( -LRB- 3168 146 35 forthcoming forthcoming JJ 3168 146 36 ) ) -RRB- 3168 146 37 ; ; : 3168 146 38 Zheng Zheng NNP 3168 146 39 Yan Yan NNP 3168 146 40 , , , 3168 146 41 “ " `` 3168 146 42 Differences difference NNS 3168 146 43 in in IN 3168 146 44 Basic Basic NNP 3168 146 45 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 3168 146 46 and and CC 3168 146 47 Perceived Perceived NNP 3168 146 48 Education Education NNP 3168 146 49 of of IN 3168 146 50 Internet Internet NNP 3168 146 51 Safety Safety NNP 3168 146 52 between between IN 3168 146 53 High High NNP 3168 146 54 School School NNP 3168 146 55 and and CC 3168 146 56 Undergraduate Undergraduate NNP 3168 146 57 Students Students NNPS 3168 146 58 : : : 3168 146 59 Do do VBP 3168 146 60 High High NNP 3168 146 61 School School NNP 3168 146 62 Students student NNS 3168 146 63 Really really RB 3168 146 64 Benefit benefit VBP 3168 146 65 from from IN 3168 146 66 the the DT 3168 146 67 Children Children NNPS 3168 146 68 ’s ’s POS 3168 146 69 Internet Internet NNP 3168 146 70 Protection Protection NNP 3168 146 71 Act Act NNP 3168 146 72 ? ? . 3168 146 73 ” " '' 3168 146 74 Journal Journal NNP 3168 146 75 of of IN 3168 146 76 Applied Applied NNP 3168 146 77 Develop- Develop- NNP 3168 146 78 mental mental JJ 3168 146 79 Psychology Psychology NNP 3168 146 80 ( ( -LRB- 3168 146 81 forthcoming forthcoming JJ 3168 146 82 ) ) -RRB- 3168 146 83 ; ; : 3168 146 84 Zheng Zheng NNP 3168 146 85 Yan Yan NNP 3168 146 86 , , , 3168 146 87 “ " `` 3168 146 88 What what WP 3168 146 89 Influences Influences NNP 3168 146 90 Children Children NNP 3168 146 91 ’s ’s , 3168 146 92 and and CC 3168 146 93 Adolescents Adolescents NNP 3168 146 94 ’ ’ POS 3168 146 95 Understanding understanding NN 3168 146 96 of of IN 3168 146 97 the the DT 3168 146 98 Complexity complexity NN 3168 146 99 of of IN 3168 146 100 the the DT 3168 146 101 Internet internet NN 3168 146 102 ? ? . 3168 146 103 , , , 3168 146 104 ” " '' 3168 146 105 Developmental Developmental NNP 3168 146 106 Psychology Psychology NNP 3168 146 107 42 42 CD 3168 146 108 ( ( -LRB- 3168 146 109 2006 2006 CD 3168 146 110 ) ) -RRB- 3168 146 111 : : : 3168 146 112 418–28 418–28 CD 3168 146 113 . . . 3168 147 1 4 4 LS 3168 147 2 . . . 3168 148 1 Martha Martha NNP 3168 148 2 M. M. NNP 3168 148 3 McCarthy McCarthy NNP 3168 148 4 , , , 3168 148 5 “ " `` 3168 148 6 Filtering filter VBG 3168 148 7 the the DT 3168 148 8 Internet internet NN 3168 148 9 : : : 3168 148 10 The the DT 3168 148 11 Chil- Chil- NNP 3168 148 12 dren dren NN 3168 148 13 ’s ’s POS 3168 148 14 Internet Internet NNP 3168 148 15 Protection Protection NNP 3168 148 16 Act Act NNP 3168 148 17 , , , 3168 148 18 ” " '' 3168 148 19 Educational Educational NNP 3168 148 20 Horizons Horizons NNPS 3168 148 21 82 82 CD 3168 148 22 , , , 3168 148 23 no no UH 3168 148 24 , , , 3168 148 25 2 2 CD 3168 148 26 ( ( -LRB- 3168 148 27 Winter winter NN 3168 148 28 2004 2004 CD 3168 148 29 ) ) -RRB- 3168 148 30 : : : 3168 148 31 108 108 CD 3168 148 32 . . . 3168 149 1 5 5 CD 3168 149 2 . . . 3168 150 1 Federal Federal NNP 3168 150 2 Communications Communications NNPS 3168 150 3 Commission Commission NNP 3168 150 4 , , , 3168 150 5 In in IN 3168 150 6 the the DT 3168 150 7 Matter Matter NNP 3168 150 8 of of IN 3168 150 9 Federal Federal NNP 3168 150 10 – – : 3168 150 11 State State NNP 3168 150 12 Joint Joint NNP 3168 150 13 Board Board NNP 3168 150 14 on on IN 3168 150 15 Universal Universal NNP 3168 150 16 Service Service NNP 3168 150 17 : : : 3168 150 18 Children Children NNP 3168 150 19 ’s ’s POS 3168 150 20 Internet Internet NNP 3168 150 21 Protection Protection NNP 3168 150 22 Act Act NNP 3168 150 23 , , , 3168 150 24 FCC FCC NNP 3168 150 25 order order NN 3168 150 26 03 03 CD 3168 150 27 - - SYM 3168 150 28 188 188 NNP 3168 150 29 ( ( -LRB- 3168 150 30 Washington Washington NNP 3168 150 31 , , , 3168 150 32 D.C. D.C. NNP 3168 150 33 : : : 3168 150 34 2003 2003 CD 3168 150 35 ) ) -RRB- 3168 150 36 . . . 3168 151 1 6 6 CD 3168 151 2 . . . 3168 152 1 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 152 2 . . . 3168 153 1 7 7 LS 3168 153 2 . . . 3168 154 1 Roth Roth NNP 3168 154 2 v. v. IN 3168 154 3 United United NNP 3168 154 4 States States NNP 3168 154 5 , , , 3168 154 6 354 354 CD 3168 154 7 U.S. U.S. NNP 3168 154 8 476 476 CD 3168 154 9 ( ( -LRB- 3168 154 10 1957 1957 CD 3168 154 11 ) ) -RRB- 3168 154 12 . . . 3168 155 1 8 8 LS 3168 155 2 . . . 3168 156 1 Miller Miller NNP 3168 156 2 v. v. IN 3168 156 3 California California NNP 3168 156 4 , , , 3168 156 5 413 413 CD 3168 156 6 U.S. U.S. NNP 3168 156 7 15 15 CD 3168 156 8 ( ( -LRB- 3168 156 9 1973 1973 CD 3168 156 10 ) ) -RRB- 3168 156 11 . . . 3168 157 1 9 9 CD 3168 157 2 . . . 3168 158 1 Roth Roth NNP 3168 158 2 v. v. IN 3168 158 3 United United NNP 3168 158 4 States States NNP 3168 158 5 . . . 3168 159 1 10 10 CD 3168 159 2 . . . 3168 160 1 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 160 2 . . . 3168 161 1 11 11 CD 3168 161 2 . . . 3168 162 1 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 162 2 . . . 3168 163 1 12 12 CD 3168 163 2 . . . 3168 164 1 Telecommunications Telecommunications NNPS 3168 164 2 Act Act NNP 3168 164 3 of of IN 3168 164 4 1996 1996 CD 3168 164 5 , , , 3168 164 6 Public Public NNP 3168 164 7 Law Law NNP 3168 164 8 104 104 NNP 3168 164 9 - - HYPH 3168 164 10 104 104 NNP 3168 164 11 ( ( -LRB- 3168 164 12 Feb. February NNP 3168 164 13 8 8 CD 3168 164 14 , , , 3168 164 15 1996 1996 CD 3168 164 16 ) ) -RRB- 3168 164 17 . . . 3168 165 1 13 13 CD 3168 165 2 . . . 3168 166 1 Paul Paul NNP 3168 166 2 T. T. NNP 3168 166 3 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 166 4 , , , 3168 166 5 Charles Charles NNP 3168 166 6 R. R. NNP 3168 166 7 McClure McClure NNP 3168 166 8 , , , 3168 166 9 and and CC 3168 166 10 John John NNP 3168 166 11 Carlo Carlo NNP 3168 166 12 Ber- Ber- NNP 3168 166 13 tot tot NN 3168 166 14 , , , 3168 166 15 “ " `` 3168 166 16 The the DT 3168 166 17 E E NNP 3168 166 18 - - HYPH 3168 166 19 Rate Rate NNP 3168 166 20 Program Program NNP 3168 166 21 and and CC 3168 166 22 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 166 23 and and CC 3168 166 24 Library Library NNP 3168 166 25 Consortia Consortia NNP 3168 166 26 , , , 3168 166 27 2000–2004 2000–2004 CD 3168 166 28 : : : 3168 166 29 Trends Trends NNPS 3168 166 30 and and CC 3168 166 31 Issues Issues NNPS 3168 166 32 , , , 3168 166 33 ” " '' 3168 166 34 Information Information NNP 3168 166 35 Technology Technology NNP 3168 166 36 & & CC 3168 166 37 Libraries Libraries NNP 3168 166 38 24 24 CD 3168 166 39 , , , 3168 166 40 no no UH 3168 166 41 . . . 3168 167 1 2 2 CD 3168 167 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 167 3 2005 2005 CD 3168 167 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 167 5 : : : 3168 167 6 57–67 57–67 CD 3168 167 7 . . . 3168 168 1 14 14 CD 3168 168 2 . . . 3168 169 1 Ibid ibid RB 3168 169 2 . . . 3168 170 1 15 15 CD 3168 170 2 . . . 3168 171 1 Ibid ibid RB 3168 171 2 . . . 3168 172 1 16 16 CD 3168 172 2 . . . 3168 173 1 American American NNP 3168 173 2 Library Library NNP 3168 173 3 Association Association NNP 3168 173 4 , , , 3168 173 5 “ " `` 3168 173 6 U.S. U.S. NNP 3168 174 1 Supreme Supreme NNP 3168 174 2 Court Court NNP 3168 174 3 Arguments Arguments NNPS 3168 174 4 on on IN 3168 174 5 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 174 6 Expected expect VBN 3168 174 7 in in IN 3168 174 8 Late Late NNP 3168 174 9 Winter Winter NNP 3168 174 10 or or CC 3168 174 11 Early early JJ 3168 174 12 Spring spring NN 3168 174 13 , , , 3168 174 14 ” " '' 3168 174 15 press press NN 3168 174 16 release release NN 3168 174 17 , , , 3168 174 18 Nov. November NNP 3168 174 19 13 13 CD 3168 174 20 , , , 3168 174 21 2002 2002 CD 3168 174 22 , , , 3168 174 23 www.ala.org/ala/aboutala/hqops/ www.ala.org/ala/aboutala/hqops/ NNP 3168 174 24 pio pio NNP 3168 174 25 / / SYM 3168 174 26 pressreleasesbucket pressreleasesbucket NNP 3168 174 27 / / SYM 3168 174 28 ussupremecourt.cfm ussupremecourt.cfm NNP 3168 174 29 ( ( -LRB- 3168 174 30 accessed access VBN 3168 174 31 May May NNP 3168 174 32 19 19 CD 3168 174 33 , , , 3168 174 34 2008 2008 CD 3168 174 35 ) ) -RRB- 3168 174 36 . . . 3168 175 1 17 17 CD 3168 175 2 . . . 3168 176 1 Kelly Kelly NNP 3168 176 2 Rodden Rodden NNP 3168 176 3 , , , 3168 176 4 “ " `` 3168 176 5 The the DT 3168 176 6 Children Children NNPS 3168 176 7 ’s ’s POS 3168 176 8 Internet Internet NNP 3168 176 9 Protection Protection NNP 3168 176 10 Act Act NNP 3168 176 11 in in IN 3168 176 12 Public Public NNP 3168 176 13 Schools Schools NNP 3168 176 14 : : : 3168 176 15 The the DT 3168 176 16 Government Government NNP 3168 176 17 Stepping step VBG 3168 176 18 on on IN 3168 176 19 Parents parent NNS 3168 176 20 ’ ’ POS 3168 176 21 Toes toe NNS 3168 176 22 ? ? . 3168 176 23 ” " '' 3168 176 24 Fordham Fordham NNP 3168 176 25 Law Law NNP 3168 176 26 Review Review NNP 3168 176 27 71 71 CD 3168 176 28 ( ( -LRB- 3168 176 29 2003 2003 CD 3168 176 30 ) ) -RRB- 3168 176 31 : : : 3168 176 32 2141–75 2141–75 LS 3168 176 33 . . . 3168 177 1 18 18 CD 3168 177 2 . . . 3168 178 1 John John NNP 3168 178 2 Carlo Carlo NNP 3168 178 3 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 178 4 , , , 3168 178 5 Paul Paul NNP 3168 178 6 T. T. NNP 3168 178 7 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 178 8 , , , 3168 178 9 and and CC 3168 178 10 Charles Charles NNP 3168 178 11 R. R. NNP 3168 178 12 McClure McClure NNP 3168 178 13 , , , 3168 178 14 “ " `` 3168 178 15 Public Public NNP 3168 178 16 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 178 17 and and CC 3168 178 18 the the DT 3168 178 19 Internet internet NN 3168 178 20 2007 2007 CD 3168 178 21 : : : 3168 178 22 Issues issue NNS 3168 178 23 , , , 3168 178 24 Implications Implications NNPS 3168 178 25 , , , 3168 178 26 and and CC 3168 178 27 Expectations expectation NNS 3168 178 28 , , , 3168 178 29 ” " '' 3168 178 30 Library Library NNP 3168 178 31 & & CC 3168 178 32 Information Information NNP 3168 178 33 Science Science NNP 3168 178 34 Research Research NNP 3168 178 35 30 30 CD 3168 178 36 ( ( -LRB- 3168 178 37 2008 2008 CD 3168 178 38 ) ) -RRB- 3168 178 39 : : : 3168 178 40 175–184 175–184 CD 3168 178 41 ; ; : 3168 178 42 Charles Charles NNP 3168 178 43 R. R. NNP 3168 178 44 McClure McClure NNP 3168 178 45 , , , 3168 178 46 Paul Paul NNP 3168 178 47 T. T. NNP 3168 178 48 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 178 49 , , , 3168 178 50 and and CC 3168 178 51 John John NNP 3168 178 52 Carlo Carlo NNP 3168 178 53 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 178 54 , , , 3168 178 55 “ " `` 3168 178 56 The the DT 3168 178 57 Looming loom VBG 3168 178 58 Infrastructure infrastructure NN 3168 178 59 Plateau Plateau NNP 3168 178 60 ? ? . 3168 179 1 : : : 3168 179 2 Space space NN 3168 179 3 , , , 3168 179 4 Funding Funding NNP 3168 179 5 , , , 3168 179 6 Connection Connection NNP 3168 179 7 Speed Speed NNP 3168 179 8 , , , 3168 179 9 and and CC 3168 179 10 the the DT 3168 179 11 Ability Ability NNP 3168 179 12 of of IN 3168 179 13 Public Public NNP 3168 179 14 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 179 15 to to TO 3168 179 16 Meet meet VB 3168 179 17 the the DT 3168 179 18 Demand demand NN 3168 179 19 for for IN 3168 179 20 Free Free NNP 3168 179 21 Internet Internet NNP 3168 179 22 Access Access NNP 3168 179 23 , , , 3168 179 24 ” " '' 3168 179 25 First First NNP 3168 179 26 Monday Monday NNP 3168 179 27 12 12 CD 3168 179 28 , , , 3168 179 29 no no UH 3168 179 30 . . . 3168 180 1 12 12 CD 3168 180 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 180 3 2007 2007 CD 3168 180 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 180 5 , , , 3168 180 6 www.uic.edu/htbin/cgiwrap/bin/ojs/index.php/fm/ www.uic.edu/htbin/cgiwrap/bin/ojs/index.php/fm/ NNP 3168 180 7 article article NNP 3168 180 8 / / SYM 3168 180 9 view/2017/1907 view/2017/1907 NNP 3168 180 10 ( ( -LRB- 3168 180 11 accessed access VBN 3168 180 12 May May NNP 3168 180 13 19 19 CD 3168 180 14 , , , 3168 180 15 2008 2008 CD 3168 180 16 ) ) -RRB- 3168 180 17 . . . 3168 181 1 19 19 CD 3168 181 2 . . . 3168 182 1 McCarthy McCarthy NNP 3168 182 2 , , , 3168 182 3 “ " `` 3168 182 4 Filtering filter VBG 3168 182 5 the the DT 3168 182 6 Internet internet NN 3168 182 7 . . . 3168 182 8 ” " '' 3168 182 9 20 20 CD 3168 182 10 . . . 3168 183 1 Leigh Leigh NNP 3168 183 2 S. S. NNP 3168 183 3 Estabrook Estabrook NNP 3168 183 4 and and CC 3168 183 5 Edward Edward NNP 3168 183 6 Lakner Lakner NNP 3168 183 7 , , , 3168 183 8 “ " `` 3168 183 9 Managing manage VBG 3168 183 10 Inter- Inter- NNP 3168 183 11 net net JJ 3168 183 12 Access access NN 3168 183 13 : : : 3168 183 14 Results result NNS 3168 183 15 of of IN 3168 183 16 a a DT 3168 183 17 National National NNP 3168 183 18 Survey Survey NNP 3168 183 19 , , , 3168 183 20 ” " '' 3168 183 21 American American NNP 3168 183 22 Libraries Libraries NNP 3168 183 23 31 31 CD 3168 183 24 , , , 3168 183 25 no no UH 3168 183 26 . . . 3168 184 1 8 8 CD 3168 184 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 184 3 2000 2000 CD 3168 184 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 184 5 : : : 3168 184 6 60–62 60–62 CD 3168 184 7 . . . 3168 185 1 21 21 CD 3168 185 2 . . . 3168 186 1 Alberta Alberta NNP 3168 186 2 Davis Davis NNP 3168 186 3 Comer Comer NNP 3168 186 4 , , , 3168 186 5 “ " `` 3168 186 6 Studying study VBG 3168 186 7 Indiana Indiana NNP 3168 186 8 Public Public NNP 3168 186 9 Librar- Librar- NNP 3168 186 10 ies ie NNS 3168 186 11 ’ ' '' 3168 186 12 Usage Usage NNP 3168 186 13 of of IN 3168 186 14 Internet internet NN 3168 186 15 Filters filter NNS 3168 186 16 , , , 3168 186 17 ” " '' 3168 186 18 Computers computer NNS 3168 186 19 in in IN 3168 186 20 Libraries Libraries NNP 3168 186 21 ( ( -LRB- 3168 186 22 June June NNP 3168 186 23 2005 2005 CD 3168 186 24 ) ) -RRB- 3168 186 25 : : : 3168 186 26 10–15 10–15 LS 3168 186 27 ; ; : 3168 186 28 Thomas Thomas NNP 3168 186 29 M. M. NNP 3168 186 30 Reddick Reddick NNP 3168 186 31 , , , 3168 186 32 “ " `` 3168 186 33 Building build VBG 3168 186 34 and and CC 3168 186 35 Running run VBG 3168 186 36 a a DT 3168 186 37 Collabora- Collabora- NNP 3168 186 38 tive tive JJ 3168 186 39 Internet Internet NNP 3168 186 40 Filter Filter NNP 3168 186 41 is be VBZ 3168 186 42 Akin Akin NNP 3168 186 43 to to IN 3168 186 44 a a DT 3168 186 45 Kansas Kansas NNP 3168 186 46 Barn Barn NNP 3168 186 47 Raising Raising NNP 3168 186 48 , , , 3168 186 49 ” " '' 3168 186 50 Computers computer NNS 3168 186 51 in in IN 3168 186 52 Libraries Libraries NNP 3168 186 53 20 20 CD 3168 186 54 , , , 3168 186 55 no no UH 3168 186 56 . . . 3168 187 1 4 4 CD 3168 187 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 187 3 2004 2004 CD 3168 187 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 187 5 : : : 3168 187 6 10–14 10–14 CD 3168 187 7 . . . 3168 188 1 22 22 CD 3168 188 2 . . . 3168 189 1 Communications Communications NNPS 3168 189 2 Decency Decency NNP 3168 189 3 Act Act NNP 3168 189 4 of of IN 3168 189 5 1996 1996 CD 3168 189 6 , , , 3168 189 7 Public Public NNP 3168 189 8 Law Law NNP 3168 189 9 104 104 NNP 3168 189 10 - - HYPH 3168 189 11 104 104 NNP 3168 189 12 ( ( -LRB- 3168 189 13 Feb. February NNP 3168 189 14 8 8 CD 3168 189 15 , , , 3168 189 16 1996 1996 CD 3168 189 17 ) ) -RRB- 3168 189 18 . . . 3168 190 1 23 23 CD 3168 190 2 . . . 3168 191 1 Child Child NNP 3168 191 2 Online Online NNP 3168 191 3 Protection Protection NNP 3168 191 4 Act Act NNP 3168 191 5 ( ( -LRB- 3168 191 6 COPA COPA NNP 3168 191 7 ) ) -RRB- 3168 191 8 , , , 3168 191 9 Public Public NNP 3168 191 10 Law Law NNP 3168 191 11 105 105 CD 3168 191 12 - - SYM 3168 191 13 277 277 CD 3168 191 14 ( ( -LRB- 3168 191 15 Oct. October NNP 3168 191 16 21 21 CD 3168 191 17 , , , 3168 191 18 1998 1998 CD 3168 191 19 ) ) -RRB- 3168 191 20 . . . 3168 192 1 24 24 CD 3168 192 2 . . . 3168 193 1 United United NNP 3168 193 2 States States NNP 3168 193 3 v. v. CC 3168 193 4 American American NNP 3168 193 5 Library Library NNP 3168 193 6 Association Association NNP 3168 193 7 . . . 3168 194 1 25 25 CD 3168 194 2 . . . 3168 195 1 R. R. NNP 3168 195 2 Trevor Trevor NNP 3168 195 3 Hall Hall NNP 3168 195 4 and and CC 3168 195 5 Ed Ed NNP 3168 195 6 Carter Carter NNP 3168 195 7 , , , 3168 195 8 “ " `` 3168 195 9 Examining examine VBG 3168 195 10 the the DT 3168 195 11 Constitu- Constitu- NNP 3168 195 12 tionality tionality NN 3168 195 13 of of IN 3168 195 14 Internet internet NN 3168 195 15 Filtering filter VBG 3168 195 16 in in IN 3168 195 17 Public Public NNP 3168 195 18 Schools Schools NNPS 3168 195 19 : : : 3168 195 20 A a DT 3168 195 21 U.S. U.S. NNP 3168 195 22 Perspec- Perspec- NNP 3168 195 23 tive tive JJ 3168 195 24 , , , 3168 195 25 ” " '' 3168 195 26 Education Education NNP 3168 195 27 & & CC 3168 195 28 the the DT 3168 195 29 Law Law NNP 3168 195 30 18 18 CD 3168 195 31 , , , 3168 195 32 no no UH 3168 195 33 . . . 3168 196 1 4 4 CD 3168 196 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 196 3 2006 2006 CD 3168 196 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 196 5 : : : 3168 196 6 227–45 227–45 CD 3168 196 7 ; ; : 3168 196 8 McCarthy McCarthy NNP 3168 196 9 “ " `` 3168 196 10 Filtering filter VBG 3168 196 11 the the DT 3168 196 12 Internet internet NN 3168 196 13 . . . 3168 196 14 ” " '' 3168 196 15 26 26 CD 3168 196 16 . . . 3168 197 1 Library Library NNP 3168 197 2 Services Services NNPS 3168 197 3 and and CC 3168 197 4 Technology Technology NNP 3168 197 5 Act Act NNP 3168 197 6 , , , 3168 197 7 Public Public NNP 3168 197 8 Law Law NNP 3168 197 9 104 104 NNP 3168 197 10 - - HYPH 3168 197 11 208 208 CD 3168 197 12 ( ( -LRB- 3168 197 13 Sept. September NNP 3168 197 14 30 30 CD 3168 197 15 , , , 3168 197 16 1996 1996 CD 3168 197 17 ) ) -RRB- 3168 197 18 . . . 3168 198 1 27 27 CD 3168 198 2 . . . 3168 199 1 John John NNP 3168 199 2 Wells Wells NNP 3168 199 3 and and CC 3168 199 4 Laurie Laurie NNP 3168 199 5 Lewis Lewis NNP 3168 199 6 , , , 3168 199 7 Internet Internet NNP 3168 199 8 Access Access NNP 3168 199 9 in in IN 3168 199 10 U.S. U.S. NNP 3168 199 11 Public Public NNP 3168 199 12 Schools Schools NNPS 3168 199 13 and and CC 3168 199 14 Classrooms Classrooms NNPS 3168 199 15 : : : 3168 199 16 1994–2005 1994–2005 CD 3168 199 17 , , , 3168 199 18 special special JJ 3168 199 19 report report NN 3168 199 20 prepared prepare VBN 3168 199 21 at at IN 3168 199 22 the the DT 3168 199 23 request request NN 3168 199 24 of of IN 3168 199 25 the the DT 3168 199 26 National National NNP 3168 199 27 Center Center NNP 3168 199 28 for for IN 3168 199 29 Education Education NNP 3168 199 30 Statistics Statistics NNPS 3168 199 31 , , , 3168 199 32 Nov. November NNP 3168 199 33 2006 2006 CD 3168 199 34 . . . 3168 200 1 28 28 CD 3168 200 2 . . . 3168 201 1 American American NNP 3168 201 2 Library Library NNP 3168 201 3 Association Association NNP 3168 201 4 , , , 3168 201 5 Libraries Libraries NNP 3168 201 6 Connect Connect NNP 3168 201 7 Commu- Commu- NNP 3168 201 8 nities nitie NNS 3168 201 9 ; ; : 3168 201 10 John John NNP 3168 201 11 Carlo Carlo NNP 3168 201 12 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 201 13 , , , 3168 201 14 Charles Charles NNP 3168 201 15 R. R. NNP 3168 201 16 McClure McClure NNP 3168 201 17 , , , 3168 201 18 and and CC 3168 201 19 Paul Paul NNP 3168 201 20 T. T. NNP 3168 201 21 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 201 22 , , , 3168 201 23 “ " `` 3168 201 24 The the DT 3168 201 25 Impacts impact NNS 3168 201 26 of of IN 3168 201 27 Free Free NNP 3168 201 28 Public Public NNP 3168 201 29 Internet Internet NNP 3168 201 30 Access Access NNP 3168 201 31 on on IN 3168 201 32 Public Public NNP 3168 201 33 Library Library NNP 3168 201 34 Patrons Patrons NNPS 3168 201 35 and and CC 3168 201 36 Communities Communities NNPS 3168 201 37 , , , 3168 201 38 ” " '' 3168 201 39 Library Library NNP 3168 201 40 Quarterly Quarterly NNP 3168 201 41 78 78 CD 3168 201 42 , , , 3168 201 43 no no UH 3168 201 44 . . . 3168 202 1 3 3 CD 3168 202 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 202 3 2008 2008 CD 3168 202 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 202 5 : : : 3168 202 6 285–301 285–301 CD 3168 202 7 ; ; : 3168 202 8 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 202 9 et et NNP 3168 202 10 al al NNP 3168 202 11 . . NNP 3168 202 12 , , , 3168 202 13 “ " `` 3168 202 14 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 202 15 . . . 3168 202 16 ” " '' 3168 202 17 29 29 CD 3168 202 18 . . . 3168 203 1 Wells Wells NNP 3168 203 2 and and CC 3168 203 3 Lewis Lewis NNP 3168 203 4 , , , 3168 203 5 Internet Internet NNP 3168 203 6 Access Access NNP 3168 203 7 in in IN 3168 203 8 U.S. U.S. NNP 3168 203 9 Public Public NNP 3168 203 10 Schools Schools NNPS 3168 203 11 and and CC 3168 203 12 Classrooms Classrooms NNP 3168 203 13 . . . 3168 204 1 14 14 CD 3168 204 2 INFORMATION information NN 3168 204 3 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3168 204 4 AND and CC 3168 204 5 LIBRARIES library NNS 3168 204 6 | | NNP 3168 204 7 MARCH MARCH NNP 3168 204 8 2009 2009 CD 3168 204 9 30 30 CD 3168 204 10 . . . 3168 205 1 Ibid ibid RB 3168 205 2 . . . 3168 206 1 31 31 CD 3168 206 2 . . . 3168 207 1 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 207 2 , , , 3168 207 3 McClure McClure NNP 3168 207 4 , , , 3168 207 5 and and CC 3168 207 6 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 207 7 , , , 3168 207 8 “ " `` 3168 207 9 The the DT 3168 207 10 E E NNP 3168 207 11 - - HYPH 3168 207 12 Rate Rate NNP 3168 207 13 Program Program NNP 3168 207 14 and and CC 3168 207 15 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 207 16 and and CC 3168 207 17 Library Library NNP 3168 207 18 Consortia Consortia NNP 3168 207 19 . . . 3168 207 20 ” " '' 3168 207 21 32 32 CD 3168 207 22 . . . 3168 208 1 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 208 2 et et NNP 3168 208 3 al al NNP 3168 208 4 . . NNP 3168 208 5 , , , 3168 208 6 “ " `` 3168 208 7 CIPA CIPA VBN 3168 208 8 . . . 3168 208 9 ” " '' 3168 208 10 33 33 CD 3168 208 11 . . . 3168 209 1 American American NNP 3168 209 2 Library Library NNP 3168 209 3 Association Association NNP 3168 209 4 , , , 3168 209 5 Libraries Libraries NNP 3168 209 6 Connect Connect NNP 3168 209 7 Commu- Commu- NNP 3168 209 8 nities nitie NNS 3168 209 9 . . . 3168 210 1 34 34 CD 3168 210 2 . . . 3168 211 1 Ibid ibid RB 3168 211 2 . . . 3168 212 1 35 35 CD 3168 212 2 . . . 3168 213 1 Ibid ibid RB 3168 213 2 . . . 3168 214 1 36 36 CD 3168 214 2 . . . 3168 215 1 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 215 2 , , , 3168 215 3 McClure McClure NNP 3168 215 4 , , , 3168 215 5 and and CC 3168 215 6 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 215 7 , , , 3168 215 8 “ " `` 3168 215 9 The the DT 3168 215 10 E E NNP 3168 215 11 - - HYPH 3168 215 12 Rate Rate NNP 3168 215 13 Program Program NNP 3168 215 14 and and CC 3168 215 15 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 215 16 and and CC 3168 215 17 Library Library NNP 3168 215 18 Consortia Consortia NNP 3168 215 19 . . . 3168 215 20 ” " '' 3168 215 21 37 37 CD 3168 215 22 . . . 3168 216 1 Ibid ibid RB 3168 216 2 . . . 3168 217 1 38 38 CD 3168 217 2 . . . 3168 218 1 Norman Norman NNP 3168 218 2 Oder Oder NNP 3168 218 3 , , , 3168 218 4 “ " `` 3168 218 5 $ $ $ 3168 218 6 40 40 CD 3168 218 7 Million million CD 3168 218 8 in in IN 3168 218 9 E e NN 3168 218 10 - - NN 3168 218 11 Rate Rate NNP 3168 218 12 Funds fund NNS 3168 218 13 Suspended suspend VBN 3168 218 14 : : : 3168 218 15 Delays Delays NNPS 3168 218 16 Caused cause VBN 3168 218 17 as as IN 3168 218 18 FCC FCC NNP 3168 218 19 Requires require VBZ 3168 218 20 New New NNP 3168 218 21 Accounting Accounting NNP 3168 218 22 Standards Standards NNPS 3168 218 23 , , , 3168 218 24 ” " '' 3168 218 25 Library Library NNP 3168 218 26 Journal Journal NNP 3168 218 27 129 129 CD 3168 218 28 , , , 3168 218 29 no no UH 3168 218 30 . . . 3168 219 1 18 18 CD 3168 219 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 219 3 2004 2004 CD 3168 219 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 219 5 : : : 3168 219 6 16 16 CD 3168 219 7 ; ; : 3168 219 8 Debra Debra NNP 3168 219 9 Lau Lau NNP 3168 219 10 Whelan Whelan NNP 3168 219 11 , , , 3168 219 12 “ " `` 3168 219 13 E e JJ 3168 219 14 - - NN 3168 219 15 Rate rate NN 3168 219 16 Funding funding NN 3168 219 17 Still still RB 3168 219 18 Up up RB 3168 219 19 in in IN 3168 219 20 the the DT 3168 219 21 Air air NN 3168 219 22 : : : 3168 219 23 Schools school NNS 3168 219 24 , , , 3168 219 25 Libraries library NNS 3168 219 26 Left leave VBN 3168 219 27 in in IN 3168 219 28 the the DT 3168 219 29 Dark Dark NNP 3168 219 30 about about IN 3168 219 31 Discounted Discounted NNP 3168 219 32 Funds Funds NNPS 3168 219 33 for for IN 3168 219 34 Internet Internet NNP 3168 219 35 Services service NNS 3168 219 36 , , , 3168 219 37 ” " '' 3168 219 38 School School NNP 3168 219 39 Library Library NNP 3168 219 40 Journal Journal NNP 3168 219 41 50 50 CD 3168 219 42 , , , 3168 219 43 no no UH 3168 219 44 . . . 3168 220 1 11 11 CD 3168 220 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 220 3 2004 2004 CD 3168 220 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 220 5 : : : 3168 220 6 16 16 CD 3168 220 7 . . . 3168 221 1 39 39 CD 3168 221 2 . . . 3168 222 1 Ken Ken NNP 3168 222 2 Foskett Foskett NNP 3168 222 3 and and CC 3168 222 4 Paul Paul NNP 3168 222 5 Donsky Donsky NNP 3168 222 6 , , , 3168 222 7 “ " `` 3168 222 8 Hard hard JJ 3168 222 9 Eye Eye NNP 3168 222 10 on on IN 3168 222 11 City City NNP 3168 222 12 Schools Schools NNP 3168 222 13 ’ ' '' 3168 222 14 Hardware Hardware NNP 3168 222 15 , , , 3168 222 16 ” " '' 3168 222 17 Atlanta Atlanta NNP 3168 222 18 Journal Journal NNP 3168 222 19 - - HYPH 3168 222 20 Constitution Constitution NNP 3168 222 21 , , , 3168 222 22 May May NNP 3168 222 23 25 25 CD 3168 222 24 , , , 3168 222 25 2004 2004 CD 3168 222 26 ; ; : 3168 222 27 Ken Ken NNP 3168 222 28 Fos- Fos- NNP 3168 222 29 kett kett NNP 3168 222 30 and and CC 3168 222 31 Jeff Jeff NNP 3168 222 32 Nesmith Nesmith NNP 3168 222 33 , , , 3168 222 34 “ " `` 3168 222 35 Wired wire VBN 3168 222 36 for for IN 3168 222 37 Waste Waste NNP 3168 222 38 : : : 3168 222 39 Abuses Abuses NNPS 3168 222 40 Tarnish Tarnish NNP 3168 222 41 E e NN 3168 222 42 - - NN 3168 222 43 rate rate NN 3168 222 44 Program program NN 3168 222 45 , , , 3168 222 46 ” " '' 3168 222 47 Atlanta Atlanta NNP 3168 222 48 Journal Journal NNP 3168 222 49 - - HYPH 3168 222 50 Constitution Constitution NNP 3168 222 51 , , , 3168 222 52 May May NNP 3168 222 53 24 24 CD 3168 222 54 , , , 3168 222 55 2004 2004 CD 3168 222 56 . . . 3168 223 1 40 40 CD 3168 223 2 . . . 3168 224 1 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 224 2 , , , 3168 224 3 McClure McClure NNP 3168 224 4 , , , 3168 224 5 and and CC 3168 224 6 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 224 7 , , , 3168 224 8 “ " `` 3168 224 9 The the DT 3168 224 10 E E NNP 3168 224 11 - - HYPH 3168 224 12 Rate Rate NNP 3168 224 13 Program Program NNP 3168 224 14 and and CC 3168 224 15 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 224 16 and and CC 3168 224 17 Library Library NNP 3168 224 18 Consortia Consortia NNP 3168 224 19 . . . 3168 224 20 ” " '' 3168 224 21 41 41 CD 3168 224 22 . . . 3168 225 1 Department Department NNP 3168 225 2 of of IN 3168 225 3 Commerce Commerce NNP 3168 225 4 , , , 3168 225 5 National National NNP 3168 225 6 Telecommunication Telecommunication NNP 3168 225 7 and and CC 3168 225 8 Information Information NNP 3168 225 9 Administration Administration NNP 3168 225 10 , , , 3168 225 11 Children Children NNP 3168 225 12 ’s ’s POS 3168 225 13 Internet Internet NNP 3168 225 14 Protection Protection NNP 3168 225 15 Act Act NNP 3168 225 16 : : : 3168 225 17 Study Study NNP 3168 225 18 of of IN 3168 225 19 Technology Technology NNP 3168 225 20 Protection Protection NNP 3168 225 21 Measures Measures NNPS 3168 225 22 in in IN 3168 225 23 Section Section NNP 3168 225 24 1703 1703 CD 3168 225 25 , , , 3168 225 26 report report NN 3168 225 27 to to IN 3168 225 28 Congress Congress NNP 3168 225 29 ( ( -LRB- 3168 225 30 Washington Washington NNP 3168 225 31 , , , 3168 225 32 D.C. D.C. NNP 3168 225 33 : : : 3168 225 34 2003 2003 CD 3168 225 35 ) ) -RRB- 3168 225 36 . . . 3168 226 1 42 42 CD 3168 226 2 . . . 3168 227 1 McCarthy McCarthy NNP 3168 227 2 , , , 3168 227 3 “ " `` 3168 227 4 Filtering filter VBG 3168 227 5 the the DT 3168 227 6 Internet internet NN 3168 227 7 . . . 3168 227 8 ” " '' 3168 227 9 43 43 CD 3168 227 10 . . . 3168 228 1 Paul Paul NNP 3168 228 2 T. T. NNP 3168 228 3 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 228 4 and and CC 3168 228 5 Charles Charles NNP 3168 228 6 R. R. NNP 3168 228 7 McClure McClure NNP 3168 228 8 , , , 3168 228 9 “ " `` 3168 228 10 Potential Potential NNP 3168 228 11 Legal Legal NNP 3168 228 12 Challenges Challenges NNPS 3168 228 13 to to IN 3168 228 14 the the DT 3168 228 15 Application Application NNP 3168 228 16 of of IN 3168 228 17 the the DT 3168 228 18 Children Children NNPS 3168 228 19 ’s ’s POS 3168 228 20 Internet Internet NNP 3168 228 21 Protec- Protec- NNP 3168 228 22 tion tion NN 3168 228 23 Act Act NNP 3168 228 24 ( ( -LRB- 3168 228 25 CIPA CIPA NNP 3168 228 26 ) ) -RRB- 3168 228 27 in in IN 3168 228 28 Public Public NNP 3168 228 29 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 228 30 : : : 3168 228 31 Strategies Strategies NNPS 3168 228 32 and and CC 3168 228 33 Issues issue NNS 3168 228 34 , , , 3168 228 35 ” " '' 3168 228 36 First First NNP 3168 228 37 Monday Monday NNP 3168 228 38 9 9 CD 3168 228 39 , , , 3168 228 40 no no UH 3168 228 41 . . . 3168 229 1 2 2 CD 3168 229 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 229 3 2004 2004 CD 3168 229 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 229 5 , , , 3168 229 6 www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue9_2/ www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue9_2/ : 3168 229 7 jaeger jaeger NNP 3168 229 8 / / SYM 3168 229 9 index.html index.html NNP 3168 229 10 ( ( -LRB- 3168 229 11 accessed access VBN 3168 229 12 May May NNP 3168 229 13 19 19 CD 3168 229 14 , , , 3168 229 15 2008 2008 CD 3168 229 16 ) ) -RRB- 3168 229 17 . . . 3168 230 1 44 44 CD 3168 230 2 . . . 3168 231 1 Electronic Electronic NNP 3168 231 2 Frontier Frontier NNP 3168 231 3 Foundation Foundation NNP 3168 231 4 , , , 3168 231 5 Internet Internet NNP 3168 231 6 Blocking Blocking NNP 3168 231 7 in in IN 3168 231 8 Public Public NNP 3168 231 9 Schools Schools NNP 3168 231 10 ( ( -LRB- 3168 231 11 Washington Washington NNP 3168 231 12 , , , 3168 231 13 D.C. D.C. NNP 3168 231 14 : : : 3168 231 15 2004 2004 CD 3168 231 16 ) ) -RRB- 3168 231 17 , , , 3168 231 18 http://w2.eff.org/Censor http://w2.eff.org/Censor NNP 3168 231 19 ship ship NN 3168 231 20 / / SYM 3168 231 21 Censorware Censorware NNP 3168 231 22 / / SYM 3168 231 23 net_block_report net_block_report FW 3168 231 24 ( ( -LRB- 3168 231 25 accessed access VBN 3168 231 26 May May NNP 3168 231 27 19 19 CD 3168 231 28 , , , 3168 231 29 2008 2008 CD 3168 231 30 ) ) -RRB- 3168 231 31 . . . 3168 232 1 45 45 CD 3168 232 2 . . . 3168 233 1 Adam Adam NNP 3168 233 2 Horowitz Horowitz NNP 3168 233 3 , , , 3168 233 4 “ " `` 3168 233 5 The the DT 3168 233 6 Constitutionality constitutionality NN 3168 233 7 of of IN 3168 233 8 the the DT 3168 233 9 Children Children NNPS 3168 233 10 ’s ’s POS 3168 233 11 Internet Internet NNP 3168 233 12 Protection Protection NNP 3168 233 13 Act Act NNP 3168 233 14 , , , 3168 233 15 ” " '' 3168 233 16 St. St. NNP 3168 233 17 Thomas Thomas NNP 3168 233 18 Law Law NNP 3168 233 19 Review Review NNP 3168 233 20 13 13 CD 3168 233 21 , , , 3168 233 22 no no UH 3168 233 23 . . . 3168 234 1 1 1 CD 3168 234 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 234 3 2000 2000 CD 3168 234 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 234 5 : : : 3168 234 6 425–44 425–44 CD 3168 234 7 . . . 3168 235 1 46 46 CD 3168 235 2 . . . 3168 236 1 Tanessa Tanessa NNP 3168 236 2 Cabe Cabe NNP 3168 236 3 , , , 3168 236 4 “ " `` 3168 236 5 Regulation Regulation NNP 3168 236 6 of of IN 3168 236 7 Speech Speech NNP 3168 236 8 on on IN 3168 236 9 the the DT 3168 236 10 Internet internet NN 3168 236 11 : : : 3168 236 12 Fourth fourth JJ 3168 236 13 Time Time NNP 3168 236 14 ’s ’s , 3168 236 15 the the DT 3168 236 16 Charm charm NN 3168 236 17 ? ? . 3168 236 18 ” " '' 3168 236 19 Media Media NNP 3168 236 20 Law Law NNP 3168 236 21 and and CC 3168 236 22 Policy Policy NNP 3168 236 23 11 11 CD 3168 236 24 ( ( -LRB- 3168 236 25 2002 2002 CD 3168 236 26 ) ) -RRB- 3168 236 27 : : : 3168 236 28 50–61 50–61 LS 3168 236 29 ; ; : 3168 236 30 Adam Adam NNP 3168 236 31 Goldstein Goldstein NNP 3168 236 32 , , , 3168 236 33 “ " `` 3168 236 34 Like like IN 3168 236 35 a a DT 3168 236 36 Sieve Sieve NNP 3168 236 37 : : : 3168 236 38 The the DT 3168 236 39 Child Child NNP 3168 236 40 Internet Internet NNP 3168 236 41 Pro- Pro- NNP 3168 236 42 tection tection NN 3168 236 43 Act Act NNP 3168 236 44 and and CC 3168 236 45 Ineffective Ineffective NNP 3168 236 46 Filters Filters NNPS 3168 236 47 in in IN 3168 236 48 Libraries Libraries NNP 3168 236 49 , , , 3168 236 50 ” " '' 3168 236 51 Fordham Fordham NNP 3168 236 52 Intel- Intel- NNP 3168 236 53 lectual lectual JJ 3168 236 54 Property Property NNP 3168 236 55 , , , 3168 236 56 Media Media NNP 3168 236 57 , , , 3168 236 58 and and CC 3168 236 59 Entertainment Entertainment NNP 3168 236 60 Law Law NNP 3168 236 61 Journal Journal NNP 3168 236 62 12 12 CD 3168 236 63 ( ( -LRB- 3168 236 64 2002 2002 CD 3168 236 65 ) ) -RRB- 3168 236 66 : : : 3168 236 67 1187–1202 1187–1202 LS 3168 236 68 ; ; : 3168 236 69 Horowitz Horowitz NNP 3168 236 70 , , , 3168 236 71 “ " `` 3168 236 72 The the DT 3168 236 73 Constitutionality constitutionality NN 3168 236 74 of of IN 3168 236 75 the the DT 3168 236 76 Children Children NNPS 3168 236 77 ’s ’s POS 3168 236 78 Internet Internet NNP 3168 236 79 Protection Protection NNP 3168 236 80 Act Act NNP 3168 236 81 ” " '' 3168 236 82 ; ; : 3168 236 83 Marilyn Marilyn NNP 3168 236 84 J. J. NNP 3168 236 85 Maloney Maloney NNP 3168 236 86 and and CC 3168 236 87 Julia Julia NNP 3168 236 88 Morgan Morgan NNP 3168 236 89 , , , 3168 236 90 “ " `` 3168 236 91 Rock Rock NNP 3168 236 92 and and CC 3168 236 93 A a DT 3168 236 94 Hard Hard NNP 3168 236 95 Place place NN 3168 236 96 : : : 3168 236 97 The The NNP 3168 236 98 Public Public NNP 3168 236 99 Library Library NNP 3168 236 100 ’s ’s NNP 3168 236 101 Dilemma Dilemma NNP 3168 236 102 in in IN 3168 236 103 Pro- Pro- NNP 3168 236 104 viding vide VBG 3168 236 105 Access access NN 3168 236 106 to to IN 3168 236 107 Legal Legal NNP 3168 236 108 Materials Materials NNP 3168 236 109 on on IN 3168 236 110 the the DT 3168 236 111 Internet internet NN 3168 236 112 While while IN 3168 236 113 Restrict- Restrict- NNP 3168 236 114 ing e VBG 3168 236 115 Access access NN 3168 236 116 to to IN 3168 236 117 Illegal Illegal NNP 3168 236 118 Materials material NNS 3168 236 119 , , , 3168 236 120 ” " '' 3168 236 121 Hamline Hamline NNP 3168 236 122 Law Law NNP 3168 236 123 Review Review NNP 3168 236 124 24 24 CD 3168 236 125 , , , 3168 236 126 no no UH 3168 236 127 . . . 3168 237 1 2 2 CD 3168 237 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 237 3 2001 2001 CD 3168 237 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 237 5 : : : 3168 237 6 199–222 199–222 CD 3168 237 7 ; ; : 3168 237 8 Mary Mary NNP 3168 237 9 Minow Minow NNP 3168 237 10 , , , 3168 237 11 “ " `` 3168 237 12 Filters filter NNS 3168 237 13 and and CC 3168 237 14 the the DT 3168 237 15 Public Public NNP 3168 237 16 Library Library NNP 3168 237 17 : : : 3168 237 18 A a DT 3168 237 19 Legal Legal NNP 3168 237 20 and and CC 3168 237 21 Policy Policy NNP 3168 237 22 Analysis Analysis NNP 3168 237 23 , , , 3168 237 24 ” " '' 3168 237 25 First First NNP 3168 237 26 Monday Monday NNP 3168 237 27 2 2 CD 3168 237 28 , , , 3168 237 29 no no UH 3168 237 30 . . . 3168 238 1 12 12 CD 3168 238 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 238 3 1997 1997 CD 3168 238 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 238 5 , , , 3168 238 6 www www NNP 3168 238 7 .firstmonday.org .firstmonday.org NN 3168 238 8 / / SYM 3168 238 9 issues issue NNS 3168 238 10 / / SYM 3168 238 11 issue2_12 issue2_12 JJ 3168 238 12 / / SYM 3168 238 13 minnow minnow NN 3168 238 14 ( ( -LRB- 3168 238 15 accessed access VBN 3168 238 16 May May NNP 3168 238 17 19 19 CD 3168 238 18 , , , 3168 238 19 2008 2008 CD 3168 238 20 ) ) -RRB- 3168 238 21 ; ; : 3168 238 22 Richard Richard NNP 3168 238 23 J. J. NNP 3168 238 24 Peltz Peltz NNP 3168 238 25 , , , 3168 238 26 “ " `` 3168 238 27 Use Use NNP 3168 238 28 ‘ ' `` 3168 238 29 the the DT 3168 238 30 Filter Filter NNP 3168 238 31 You -PRON- PRP 3168 238 32 Were be VBD 3168 238 33 Born bear VBN 3168 238 34 with with IN 3168 238 35 ’ ' '' 3168 238 36 : : : 3168 238 37 The the DT 3168 238 38 Unconstitutionality Unconstitutionality NNP 3168 238 39 of of IN 3168 238 40 Mandatory mandatory JJ 3168 238 41 Internet internet NN 3168 238 42 Filtering filter VBG 3168 238 43 for for IN 3168 238 44 Adult Adult NNP 3168 238 45 Patrons Patrons NNPS 3168 238 46 of of IN 3168 238 47 Public Public NNP 3168 238 48 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 238 49 , , , 3168 238 50 ” " '' 3168 238 51 Washington Washington NNP 3168 238 52 Law Law NNP 3168 238 53 Review Review NNP 3168 238 54 77 77 CD 3168 238 55 , , , 3168 238 56 no no UH 3168 238 57 . . . 3168 239 1 2 2 CD 3168 239 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 239 3 2002 2002 CD 3168 239 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 239 5 : : : 3168 239 6 397–479 397–479 CD 3168 239 7 . . . 3168 240 1 47 47 CD 3168 240 2 . . . 3168 241 1 McCarthy McCarthy NNP 3168 241 2 , , , 3168 241 3 “ " `` 3168 241 4 Filtering filter VBG 3168 241 5 the the DT 3168 241 6 Internet internet NN 3168 241 7 . . . 3168 241 8 ” " '' 3168 241 9 48 48 CD 3168 241 10 . . . 3168 242 1 John John NNP 3168 242 2 Carlo Carlo NNP 3168 242 3 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 242 4 et et NNP 3168 242 5 al al NNP 3168 242 6 . . NNP 3168 242 7 , , , 3168 242 8 “ " `` 3168 242 9 Public public JJ 3168 242 10 Access Access NNP 3168 242 11 Computing Computing NNP 3168 242 12 and and CC 3168 242 13 Internet Internet NNP 3168 242 14 Access Access NNP 3168 242 15 in in IN 3168 242 16 Public Public NNP 3168 242 17 Libraries library NNS 3168 242 18 : : : 3168 242 19 The the DT 3168 242 20 Role Role NNP 3168 242 21 of of IN 3168 242 22 Public Public NNP 3168 242 23 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 242 24 in in IN 3168 242 25 E E NNP 3168 242 26 - - NN 3168 242 27 Government Government NNP 3168 242 28 and and CC 3168 242 29 Emergency Emergency NNP 3168 242 30 Situations Situations NNPS 3168 242 31 , , , 3168 242 32 ” " '' 3168 242 33 First First NNP 3168 242 34 Monday Monday NNP 3168 242 35 11 11 CD 3168 242 36 , , , 3168 242 37 no no UH 3168 242 38 . . . 3168 243 1 9 9 CD 3168 243 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 243 3 2006 2006 CD 3168 243 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 243 5 , , , 3168 243 6 www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue11_9/bertot www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue11_9/bertot NNP 3168 243 7 ( ( -LRB- 3168 243 8 accessed access VBN 3168 243 9 May May NNP 3168 243 10 19 19 CD 3168 243 11 , , , 3168 243 12 2008 2008 CD 3168 243 13 ) ) -RRB- 3168 243 14 ; ; : 3168 243 15 John John NNP 3168 243 16 Carlo Carlo NNP 3168 243 17 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 243 18 et et NNP 3168 243 19 al al NNP 3168 243 20 . . NNP 3168 243 21 , , , 3168 243 22 “ " `` 3168 243 23 Drafted draft VBN 3168 243 24 : : : 3168 243 25 I -PRON- PRP 3168 243 26 want want VBP 3168 243 27 You -PRON- PRP 3168 243 28 to to TO 3168 243 29 Deliver deliver VB 3168 243 30 E e NN 3168 243 31 - - HYPH 3168 243 32 Government government NN 3168 243 33 , , , 3168 243 34 ” " '' 3168 243 35 Library Library NNP 3168 243 36 Journal Journal NNP 3168 243 37 131 131 CD 3168 243 38 , , , 3168 243 39 no no UH 3168 243 40 . . . 3168 244 1 13 13 CD 3168 244 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 244 3 2006 2006 CD 3168 244 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 244 5 : : : 3168 244 6 34–39 34–39 LS 3168 244 7 ; ; : 3168 244 8 Paul Paul NNP 3168 244 9 T. T. NNP 3168 244 10 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 244 11 and and CC 3168 244 12 Kenneth Kenneth NNP 3168 244 13 R. R. NNP 3168 244 14 Fleischmann Fleischmann NNP 3168 244 15 , , , 3168 244 16 “ " `` 3168 244 17 Public Public NNP 3168 244 18 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 244 19 , , , 3168 244 20 Values Values NNPS 3168 244 21 , , , 3168 244 22 Trust Trust NNP 3168 244 23 , , , 3168 244 24 and and CC 3168 244 25 E E NNP 3168 244 26 - - NNP 3168 244 27 Government Government NNP 3168 244 28 , , , 3168 244 29 ” " '' 3168 244 30 Informa- Informa- NNP 3168 244 31 tion tion NN 3168 244 32 Technology Technology NNP 3168 244 33 and and CC 3168 244 34 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 244 35 26 26 CD 3168 244 36 , , , 3168 244 37 no no UH 3168 244 38 . . . 3168 245 1 4 4 CD 3168 245 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 245 3 2007 2007 CD 3168 245 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 245 5 : : : 3168 245 6 35–43 35–43 NN 3168 245 7 . . . 3168 246 1 49 49 CD 3168 246 2 . . . 3168 247 1 Doug Doug NNP 3168 247 2 Johnson Johnson NNP 3168 247 3 , , , 3168 247 4 “ " `` 3168 247 5 Maintaining Maintaining NNP 3168 247 6 Intellectual Intellectual NNP 3168 247 7 Freedom Freedom NNP 3168 247 8 in in IN 3168 247 9 a a DT 3168 247 10 Filtered Filtered NNP 3168 247 11 World World NNP 3168 247 12 , , , 3168 247 13 ” " '' 3168 247 14 Learning learn VBG 3168 247 15 & & CC 3168 247 16 Leading lead VBG 3168 247 17 with with IN 3168 247 18 Technology Technology NNP 3168 247 19 32 32 CD 3168 247 20 , , , 3168 247 21 no no UH 3168 247 22 . . . 3168 248 1 8 8 LS 3168 248 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 248 3 May May NNP 3168 248 4 2005 2005 CD 3168 248 5 ) ) -RRB- 3168 248 6 : : : 3168 248 7 39 39 CD 3168 248 8 . . . 3168 249 1 50 50 CD 3168 249 2 . . . 3168 250 1 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 250 2 , , , 3168 250 3 McClure McClure NNP 3168 250 4 , , , 3168 250 5 and and CC 3168 250 6 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 250 7 , , , 3168 250 8 “ " `` 3168 250 9 The the DT 3168 250 10 Impacts impact NNS 3168 250 11 of of IN 3168 250 12 Free Free NNP 3168 250 13 Public Public NNP 3168 250 14 Internet Internet NNP 3168 250 15 Access Access NNP 3168 250 16 on on IN 3168 250 17 Public Public NNP 3168 250 18 Library Library NNP 3168 250 19 Patrons Patrons NNPS 3168 250 20 and and CC 3168 250 21 Communities Communities NNPS 3168 250 22 . . . 3168 250 23 ” " '' 3168 250 24 51 51 CD 3168 250 25 . . . 3168 251 1 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 251 2 et et NNP 3168 251 3 al al NNP 3168 251 4 . . NNP 3168 251 5 , , , 3168 251 6 “ " `` 3168 251 7 Public Public NNP 3168 251 8 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 251 9 and and CC 3168 251 10 Internet Internet NNP 3168 251 11 Access access NN 3168 251 12 Across across IN 3168 251 13 the the DT 3168 251 14 United United NNP 3168 251 15 States States NNP 3168 251 16 . . . 3168 251 17 ” " '' 3168 251 18 52 52 CD 3168 251 19 . . . 3168 252 1 Paul Paul NNP 3168 252 2 T. T. NNP 3168 252 3 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 252 4 et et NNP 3168 252 5 al al NNP 3168 252 6 . . NNP 3168 252 7 , , , 3168 252 8 “ " `` 3168 252 9 The the DT 3168 252 10 Policy Policy NNP 3168 252 11 Implications implication NNS 3168 252 12 of of IN 3168 252 13 Internet internet NN 3168 252 14 Connectivity connectivity NN 3168 252 15 in in IN 3168 252 16 Public Public NNP 3168 252 17 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 252 18 , , , 3168 252 19 ” " '' 3168 252 20 Government Government NNP 3168 252 21 Information Information NNP 3168 252 22 Quar- Quar- NNP 3168 252 23 terly terly RB 3168 252 24 23 23 CD 3168 252 25 , , , 3168 252 26 no no UH 3168 252 27 . . . 3168 253 1 1 1 CD 3168 253 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 253 3 2006 2006 CD 3168 253 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 253 5 : : : 3168 253 6 123–41 123–41 CD 3168 253 7 . . . 3168 254 1 53 53 CD 3168 254 2 . . . 3168 255 1 Goldstein Goldstein NNP 3168 255 2 , , , 3168 255 3 “ " `` 3168 255 4 Like like IN 3168 255 5 a a DT 3168 255 6 Sieve Sieve NNP 3168 255 7 . . . 3168 255 8 ” " '' 3168 255 9 54 54 CD 3168 255 10 . . . 3168 256 1 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 256 2 , , , 3168 256 3 McClure McClure NNP 3168 256 4 , , , 3168 256 5 and and CC 3168 256 6 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 256 7 , , , 3168 256 8 “ " `` 3168 256 9 The the DT 3168 256 10 Impacts impact NNS 3168 256 11 of of IN 3168 256 12 Free Free NNP 3168 256 13 Public Public NNP 3168 256 14 Internet Internet NNP 3168 256 15 Access Access NNP 3168 256 16 on on IN 3168 256 17 Public Public NNP 3168 256 18 Library Library NNP 3168 256 19 Patrons Patrons NNPS 3168 256 20 and and CC 3168 256 21 Communities Communities NNPS 3168 256 22 ” " '' 3168 256 23 ; ; : 3168 256 24 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 256 25 and and CC 3168 256 26 Fleischmann Fleischmann NNP 3168 256 27 , , , 3168 256 28 “ " `` 3168 256 29 Public Public NNP 3168 256 30 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 256 31 , , , 3168 256 32 Values Values NNPS 3168 256 33 , , , 3168 256 34 Trust Trust NNP 3168 256 35 , , , 3168 256 36 and and CC 3168 256 37 E E NNP 3168 256 38 - - NNP 3168 256 39 Government Government NNP 3168 256 40 . . . 3168 256 41 “ " `` 3168 256 42 55 55 CD 3168 256 43 . . . 3168 257 1 Bertot Bertot NNP 3168 257 2 , , , 3168 257 3 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 257 4 , , , 3168 257 5 and and CC 3168 257 6 McClure McClure NNP 3168 257 7 , , , 3168 257 8 “ " `` 3168 257 9 Public Public NNP 3168 257 10 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 257 11 and and CC 3168 257 12 the the DT 3168 257 13 Internet internet NN 3168 257 14 2007 2007 CD 3168 257 15 ” " '' 3168 257 16 ; ; : 3168 257 17 Charles Charles NNP 3168 257 18 R. R. NNP 3168 257 19 McClure McClure NNP 3168 257 20 et et NNP 3168 257 21 al al NNP 3168 257 22 . . NNP 3168 257 23 , , , 3168 257 24 “ " `` 3168 257 25 Funding Funding NNP 3168 257 26 and and CC 3168 257 27 Expen- Expen- NNP 3168 257 28 ditures diture VBZ 3168 257 29 Related relate VBN 3168 257 30 to to IN 3168 257 31 Internet internet NN 3168 257 32 Access Access NNP 3168 257 33 in in IN 3168 257 34 Public Public NNP 3168 257 35 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 257 36 , , , 3168 257 37 ” " '' 3168 257 38 Informa- Informa- NNP 3168 257 39 tion tion NN 3168 257 40 Technology Technology NNP 3168 257 41 & & CC 3168 257 42 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3168 257 43 ( ( -LRB- 3168 257 44 forthcoming forthcoming JJ 3168 257 45 ) ) -RRB- 3168 257 46 . . . 3168 258 1 56 56 CD 3168 258 2 . . . 3168 259 1 Zheng Zheng NNP 3168 259 2 Yan Yan NNP 3168 259 3 and and CC 3168 259 4 Kurt Kurt NNP 3168 259 5 W. W. NNP 3168 259 6 Fischer Fischer NNP 3168 259 7 , , , 3168 259 8 “ " `` 3168 259 9 How how WRB 3168 259 10 Children Children NNPS 3168 259 11 and and CC 3168 259 12 Adults adult NNS 3168 259 13 Learn learn VBP 3168 259 14 to to TO 3168 259 15 Use use VB 3168 259 16 Computers computer NNS 3168 259 17 : : : 3168 259 18 A a DT 3168 259 19 Developmental Developmental NNP 3168 259 20 Approach Approach NNP 3168 259 21 , , , 3168 259 22 ” " '' 3168 259 23 New New NNP 3168 259 24 Directions Directions NNPS 3168 259 25 for for IN 3168 259 26 Child Child NNP 3168 259 27 and and CC 3168 259 28 Adolescent Adolescent NNP 3168 259 29 Development Development NNP 3168 259 30 105 105 CD 3168 259 31 ( ( -LRB- 3168 259 32 2004 2004 CD 3168 259 33 ) ) -RRB- 3168 259 34 : : : 3168 259 35 41–61 41–61 CD 3168 259 36 . . . 3168 260 1 57 57 CD 3168 260 2 . . . 3168 261 1 Zheng Zheng NNP 3168 261 2 Yan Yan NNP 3168 261 3 , , , 3168 261 4 “ " `` 3168 261 5 Age age NN 3168 261 6 Differences difference NNS 3168 261 7 in in IN 3168 261 8 Children Children NNP 3168 261 9 ’s ’s POS 3168 261 10 Understand- Understand- NNP 3168 261 11 ing ing NN 3168 261 12 of of IN 3168 261 13 the the DT 3168 261 14 Complexity complexity NN 3168 261 15 of of IN 3168 261 16 the the DT 3168 261 17 Internet internet NN 3168 261 18 , , , 3168 261 19 ” " '' 3168 261 20 Journal Journal NNP 3168 261 21 of of IN 3168 261 22 Applied Applied NNP 3168 261 23 Devel- Devel- NNP 3168 261 24 opmental opmental JJ 3168 261 25 Psychology Psychology NNP 3168 261 26 26 26 CD 3168 261 27 ( ( -LRB- 3168 261 28 2005 2005 CD 3168 261 29 ) ) -RRB- 3168 261 30 : : : 3168 261 31 385–96 385–96 CD 3168 261 32 ; ; : 3168 261 33 Yan Yan NNP 3168 261 34 , , , 3168 261 35 “ " `` 3168 261 36 Limited limited JJ 3168 261 37 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 3168 261 38 and and CC 3168 261 39 Limited Limited NNP 3168 261 40 Resources Resources NNP 3168 261 41 ” " '' 3168 261 42 ; ; : 3168 261 43 Yan Yan NNP 3168 261 44 , , , 3168 261 45 “ " `` 3168 261 46 Differences difference NNS 3168 261 47 in in IN 3168 261 48 Basic Basic NNP 3168 261 49 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 3168 261 50 and and CC 3168 261 51 Perceived Perceived NNP 3168 261 52 Education Education NNP 3168 261 53 of of IN 3168 261 54 Internet Internet NNP 3168 261 55 Safety Safety NNP 3168 261 56 ” " '' 3168 261 57 ; ; : 3168 261 58 Yan Yan NNP 3168 261 59 , , , 3168 261 60 “ " `` 3168 261 61 What what WP 3168 261 62 Influ- Influ- NNP 3168 261 63 ences ence VBZ 3168 261 64 Children child NNS 3168 261 65 ’s ’s POS 3168 261 66 and and CC 3168 261 67 Adolescents Adolescents NNP 3168 261 68 ’ ’ POS 3168 261 69 Understanding understanding NN 3168 261 70 of of IN 3168 261 71 the the DT 3168 261 72 Com- Com- NNP 3168 261 73 plexity plexity NN 3168 261 74 of of IN 3168 261 75 the the DT 3168 261 76 Internet internet NN 3168 261 77 ? ? . 3168 261 78 ” " '' 3168 261 79 58 58 CD 3168 261 80 . . . 3168 262 1 Patricia Patricia NNP 3168 262 2 Greenfield Greenfield NNP 3168 262 3 and and CC 3168 262 4 Zheng Zheng NNP 3168 262 5 Yan Yan NNP 3168 262 6 , , , 3168 262 7 “ " `` 3168 262 8 Children child NNS 3168 262 9 , , , 3168 262 10 Adoles- Adoles- NNP 3168 262 11 cents cent NNS 3168 262 12 , , , 3168 262 13 and and CC 3168 262 14 the the DT 3168 262 15 Internet internet NN 3168 262 16 : : : 3168 262 17 A a DT 3168 262 18 New New NNP 3168 262 19 Field Field NNP 3168 262 20 of of IN 3168 262 21 Inquiry Inquiry NNP 3168 262 22 in in IN 3168 262 23 Developmen- Developmen- NNP 3168 262 24 tal tal NN 3168 262 25 Psychology psychology NN 3168 262 26 , , , 3168 262 27 ” " '' 3168 262 28 Developmental Developmental NNP 3168 262 29 Psychology Psychology NNP 3168 262 30 42 42 CD 3168 262 31 ( ( -LRB- 3168 262 32 2006 2006 CD 3168 262 33 ) ) -RRB- 3168 262 34 : : : 3168 262 35 391–93 391–93 CD 3168 262 36 . . . 3168 263 1 59 59 CD 3168 263 2 . . . 3168 264 1 John John NNP 3168 264 2 N. N. NNP 3168 264 3 Gathegi Gathegi NNP 3168 264 4 , , , 3168 264 5 “ " `` 3168 264 6 The the DT 3168 264 7 Public Public NNP 3168 264 8 Library Library NNP 3168 264 9 as as IN 3168 264 10 a a DT 3168 264 11 Public Public NNP 3168 264 12 Forum Forum NNP 3168 264 13 : : : 3168 264 14 The the DT 3168 264 15 ( ( -LRB- 3168 264 16 De)Evolution de)evolution NN 3168 264 17 of of IN 3168 264 18 a a DT 3168 264 19 Legal Legal NNP 3168 264 20 Doctrine Doctrine NNP 3168 264 21 , , , 3168 264 22 ” " '' 3168 264 23 Library Library NNP 3168 264 24 Quarterly Quarterly NNP 3168 264 25 75 75 CD 3168 264 26 ( ( -LRB- 3168 264 27 2005 2005 CD 3168 264 28 ) ) -RRB- 3168 264 29 : : : 3168 264 30 12 12 CD 3168 264 31 . . . 3168 265 1 60 60 CD 3168 265 2 . . . 3168 266 1 Sandra Sandra NNP 3168 266 2 Braman Braman NNP 3168 266 3 , , , 3168 266 4 “ " `` 3168 266 5 Where where WRB 3168 266 6 Has have VBZ 3168 266 7 Media Media NNP 3168 266 8 Policy Policy NNP 3168 266 9 Gone go VBN 3168 266 10 ? ? . 3168 267 1 Defin- Defin- NNP 3168 267 2 ing e VBG 3168 267 3 the the DT 3168 267 4 Field field NN 3168 267 5 in in IN 3168 267 6 the the DT 3168 267 7 21st 21st JJ 3168 267 8 Century Century NNP 3168 267 9 , , , 3168 267 10 ” " '' 3168 267 11 Communication Communication NNP 3168 267 12 Law Law NNP 3168 267 13 and and CC 3168 267 14 Policy Policy NNP 3168 267 15 9 9 CD 3168 267 16 , , , 3168 267 17 no no UH 3168 267 18 . . . 3168 268 1 2 2 CD 3168 268 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 268 3 2004 2004 CD 3168 268 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 268 5 : : : 3168 268 6 153–82 153–82 CD 3168 268 7 ; ; : 3168 268 8 Sandra Sandra NNP 3168 268 9 Braman Braman NNP 3168 268 10 , , , 3168 268 11 Change Change NNP 3168 268 12 of of IN 3168 268 13 State state NN 3168 268 14 : : : 3168 268 15 Informa- Informa- NNP 3168 268 16 tion tion NN 3168 268 17 , , , 3168 268 18 Policy Policy NNP 3168 268 19 , , , 3168 268 20 & & CC 3168 268 21 Power Power NNP 3168 268 22 ( ( -LRB- 3168 268 23 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 3168 268 24 , , , 3168 268 25 Mass. Massachusetts NNP 3168 269 1 : : : 3168 269 2 MIT MIT NNP 3168 269 3 Pr Pr NNP 3168 269 4 . . NNP 3168 269 5 , , , 3168 269 6 2007 2007 CD 3168 269 7 ) ) -RRB- 3168 269 8 ; ; : 3168 269 9 Charles Charles NNP 3168 269 10 R. R. NNP 3168 269 11 McClure McClure NNP 3168 269 12 and and CC 3168 269 13 Paul Paul NNP 3168 269 14 T. T. NNP 3168 269 15 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 269 16 , , , 3168 269 17 “ " `` 3168 269 18 Government Government NNP 3168 269 19 Information Information NNP 3168 269 20 Policy Policy NNP 3168 269 21 Research Research NNP 3168 269 22 : : : 3168 269 23 Importance Importance NNP 3168 269 24 , , , 3168 269 25 Approaches Approaches NNP 3168 269 26 , , , 3168 269 27 and and CC 3168 269 28 Realities Realities NNPS 3168 269 29 , , , 3168 269 30 ” " '' 3168 269 31 Library Library NNP 3168 269 32 & & CC 3168 269 33 Information Information NNP 3168 269 34 Science Science NNP 3168 269 35 Research Research NNP 3168 269 36 30 30 CD 3168 269 37 ( ( -LRB- 3168 269 38 2008 2008 CD 3168 269 39 ) ) -RRB- 3168 269 40 : : : 3168 269 41 257–64 257–64 CD 3168 269 42 ; ; : 3168 269 43 Milton Milton NNP 3168 269 44 Mueller Mueller NNP 3168 269 45 , , , 3168 269 46 Christiane Christiane NNP 3168 269 47 Page Page NNP 3168 269 48 , , , 3168 269 49 and and CC 3168 269 50 Brendan Brendan NNP 3168 269 51 Kuerbis Kuerbis NNP 3168 269 52 , , , 3168 269 53 “ " `` 3168 269 54 Civil civil JJ 3168 269 55 Society Society NNP 3168 269 56 and and CC 3168 269 57 the the DT 3168 269 58 Shaping shaping NN 3168 269 59 of of IN 3168 269 60 Communication Communication NNP 3168 269 61 - - HYPH 3168 269 62 Information information NN 3168 269 63 Policy policy NN 3168 269 64 : : : 3168 269 65 Four four CD 3168 269 66 Decades decade NNS 3168 269 67 of of IN 3168 269 68 Advocacy advocacy NN 3168 269 69 , , , 3168 269 70 ” " '' 3168 269 71 Information Information NNP 3168 269 72 Society Society NNP 3168 269 73 20 20 CD 3168 269 74 , , , 3168 269 75 no no UH 3168 269 76 . . . 3168 270 1 3 3 CD 3168 270 2 ( ( -LRB- 3168 270 3 2004 2004 CD 3168 270 4 ) ) -RRB- 3168 270 5 : : : 3168 270 6 169–85 169–85 CD 3168 270 7 . . . 3168 271 1 61 61 CD 3168 271 2 . . . 3168 272 1 Paul Paul NNP 3168 272 2 T. T. NNP 3168 272 3 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 272 4 , , , 3168 272 5 “ " `` 3168 272 6 Information Information NNP 3168 272 7 Policy Policy NNP 3168 272 8 , , , 3168 272 9 Information Information NNP 3168 272 10 Access Access NNP 3168 272 11 , , , 3168 272 12 and and CC 3168 272 13 Democratic democratic JJ 3168 272 14 Participation participation NN 3168 272 15 : : : 3168 272 16 The the DT 3168 272 17 National National NNP 3168 272 18 and and CC 3168 272 19 International International NNP 3168 272 20 Implications Implications NNPS 3168 272 21 of of IN 3168 272 22 the the DT 3168 272 23 Bush Bush NNP 3168 272 24 Administration Administration NNP 3168 272 25 ’s ’s POS 3168 272 26 Information Information NNP 3168 272 27 Politics Politics NNP 3168 272 28 , , , 3168 272 29 ” " '' 3168 272 30 Government Government NNP 3168 272 31 Information Information NNP 3168 272 32 Quarterly Quarterly NNP 3168 272 33 24 24 CD 3168 272 34 ( ( -LRB- 3168 272 35 2007 2007 CD 3168 272 36 ) ) -RRB- 3168 272 37 : : : 3168 272 38 840–59 840–59 CD 3168 272 39 . . . 3168 273 1 62 62 CD 3168 273 2 . . . 3168 274 1 McClure McClure NNP 3168 274 2 and and CC 3168 274 3 Jaeger Jaeger NNP 3168 274 4 , , , 3168 274 5 “ " `` 3168 274 6 Government Government NNP 3168 274 7 Information Information NNP 3168 274 8 Policy Policy NNP 3168 274 9 Research Research NNP 3168 274 10 . . . 3168 274 11 ” " ''