id sid tid token lemma pos 3251 1 1 EDitoRiaL EDitoRiaL NNP 3251 1 2 | | NNP 3251 1 3 tRuitt tRuitt NNP 3251 1 4 3 3 CD 3251 1 5 Marc Marc NNP 3251 1 6 TruittEditorial TruittEditorial NNP 3251 1 7 marc marc NN 3251 1 8 truitt truitt NN 3251 1 9 ( ( -LRB- 3251 1 10 marc.truitt@ualberta.ca marc.truitt@ualberta.ca NNP 3251 1 11 ) ) -RRB- 3251 1 12 is be VBZ 3251 1 13 Associate Associate NNP 3251 1 14 Director Director NNP 3251 1 15 , , , 3251 1 16 Bibliographic Bibliographic NNP 3251 1 17 and and CC 3251 1 18 Information Information NNP 3251 1 19 Technology Technology NNP 3251 1 20 Services Services NNP 3251 1 21 , , , 3251 1 22 University University NNP 3251 1 23 of of IN 3251 1 24 Alberta Alberta NNP 3251 1 25 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3251 1 26 , , , 3251 1 27 Edmonton Edmonton NNP 3251 1 28 , , , 3251 1 29 Alberta Alberta NNP 3251 1 30 , , , 3251 1 31 Canada Canada NNP 3251 1 32 , , , 3251 1 33 and and CC 3251 1 34 Editor Editor NNP 3251 1 35 of of IN 3251 1 36 ITAL ITAL NNP 3251 1 37 . . . 3251 2 1 The the DT 3251 2 2 catalog catalog NN 3251 2 3 . . . 3251 3 1 Love love VB 3251 3 2 it -PRON- PRP 3251 3 3 ? ? . 3251 4 1 Hate hate VB 3251 4 2 it -PRON- PRP 3251 4 3 ? ? . 3251 5 1 Depending depend VBG 3251 5 2 upon upon IN 3251 5 3 who who WP 3251 5 4 is be VBZ 3251 5 5 speaking speak VBG 3251 5 6 , , , 3251 5 7 it -PRON- PRP 3251 5 8 may may MD 3251 5 9 be be VB 3251 5 10 cast cast VBN 3251 5 11 as as IN 3251 5 12 the the DT 3251 5 13 ultimate ultimate JJ 3251 5 14 portal portal NN 3251 5 15 that that WDT 3251 5 16 enables enable VBZ 3251 5 17 user user VBP 3251 5 18 access access NN 3251 5 19 to to IN 3251 5 20 all all DT 3251 5 21 local local JJ 3251 5 22 and and CC 3251 5 23 networked networked JJ 3251 5 24 resources resource NNS 3251 5 25 , , , 3251 5 26 or or CC 3251 5 27 it -PRON- PRP 3251 5 28 may may MD 3251 5 29 be be VB 3251 5 30 a a DT 3251 5 31 tool tool NN 3251 5 32 of of IN 3251 5 33 Byzantine byzantine JJ 3251 5 34 complexity complexity NN 3251 5 35 , , , 3251 5 36 comprehensible comprehensible JJ 3251 5 37 at at IN 3251 5 38 best good JJS 3251 5 39 to to TO 3251 5 40 but but CC 3251 5 41 a a DT 3251 5 42 small small JJ 3251 5 43 fraction fraction NN 3251 5 44 of of IN 3251 5 45 librarians librarian NNS 3251 5 46 able able JJ 3251 5 47 to to TO 3251 5 48 navigate navigate VB 3251 5 49 its -PRON- PRP$ 3251 5 50 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3251 5 51 metadata metadata NN 3251 5 52 encoded encode VBN 3251 5 53 in in IN 3251 5 54 an an DT 3251 5 55 arcane arcane JJ 3251 5 56 1960s 1960s CD 3251 5 57 - - HYPH 3251 5 58 era era NN 3251 5 59 format format NN 3251 5 60 . . . 3251 6 1 It -PRON- PRP 3251 6 2 is be VBZ 3251 6 3 a a DT 3251 6 4 rich rich JJ 3251 6 5 trove trove NN 3251 6 6 of of IN 3251 6 7 structured structure VBN 3251 6 8 and and CC 3251 6 9 controlled control VBN 3251 6 10 information information NN 3251 6 11 assembled assemble VBN 3251 6 12 over over IN 3251 6 13 decades decade NNS 3251 6 14 by by IN 3251 6 15 the the DT 3251 6 16 work work NN 3251 6 17 of of IN 3251 6 18 countless countless JJ 3251 6 19 dedicated dedicated JJ 3251 6 20 catalogers cataloger NNS 3251 6 21 and and CC 3251 6 22 others other NNS 3251 6 23 . . . 3251 7 1 Or or CC 3251 7 2 , , , 3251 7 3 it -PRON- PRP 3251 7 4 is be VBZ 3251 7 5 the the DT 3251 7 6 now now RB 3251 7 7 - - HYPH 3251 7 8 obsolete obsolete JJ 3251 7 9 product product NN 3251 7 10 of of IN 3251 7 11 a a DT 3251 7 12 labor labor NN 3251 7 13 - - HYPH 3251 7 14 intensive intensive JJ 3251 7 15 process process NN 3251 7 16 of of IN 3251 7 17 description description NN 3251 7 18 and and CC 3251 7 19 subject subject JJ 3251 7 20 analysis analysis NN 3251 7 21 that that WDT 3251 7 22 has have VBZ 3251 7 23 no no DT 3251 7 24 relevance relevance NN 3251 7 25 in in IN 3251 7 26 a a DT 3251 7 27 Web web NN 3251 7 28 - - HYPH 3251 7 29 centric centric NN 3251 7 30 world world NN 3251 7 31 where where WRB 3251 7 32 “ " `` 3251 7 33 everything everything NN 3251 7 34 ” " '' 3251 7 35 is be VBZ 3251 7 36 findable findable JJ 3251 7 37 via via IN 3251 7 38 the the DT 3251 7 39 Google Google NNP 3251 7 40 search search NN 3251 7 41 - - HYPH 3251 7 42 box box NN 3251 7 43 . . . 3251 8 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 3251 8 2 attempt attempt NN 3251 8 3 to to TO 3251 8 4 organize organize VB 3251 8 5 knowledge knowledge NN 3251 8 6 provides provide VBZ 3251 8 7 catalogers cataloger NNS 3251 8 8 with with IN 3251 8 9 a a DT 3251 8 10 raison raison NNP 3251 8 11 d’etre d’etre NNP 3251 8 12 , , , 3251 8 13 but but CC 3251 8 14 sends send VBZ 3251 8 15 their -PRON- PRP$ 3251 8 16 colleagues colleague NNS 3251 8 17 and and CC 3251 8 18 many many JJ 3251 8 19 users user NNS 3251 8 20 fleeing flee VBG 3251 8 21 for for IN 3251 8 22 simpler simple JJR 3251 8 23 and and CC 3251 8 24 more more RBR 3251 8 25 all all RB 3251 8 26 - - HYPH 3251 8 27 encompassing encompass VBG 3251 8 28 tools tool NNS 3251 8 29 . . . 3251 9 1 It -PRON- PRP 3251 9 2 is be VBZ 3251 9 3 our -PRON- PRP$ 3251 9 4 alpha alpha NN 3251 9 5 and and CC 3251 9 6 omega omega NN 3251 9 7 , , , 3251 9 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 3251 9 9 yin yin NN 3251 9 10 and and CC 3251 9 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 3251 9 12 yang yang NNP 3251 9 13 . . . 3251 10 1 Few few JJ 3251 10 2 topics topic NNS 3251 10 3 in in IN 3251 10 4 librarianship librarianship NN 3251 10 5 — — : 3251 10 6 perhaps perhaps RB 3251 10 7 with with IN 3251 10 8 the the DT 3251 10 9 con- con- NN 3251 10 10 spicuous spicuous JJ 3251 10 11 exception exception NN 3251 10 12 of of IN 3251 10 13 that that DT 3251 10 14 perennial perennial JJ 3251 10 15 library library NN 3251 10 16 school school NN 3251 10 17 favor- favor- NNP 3251 10 18 ite ite NNP 3251 10 19 , , , 3251 10 20 our -PRON- PRP$ 3251 10 21 profession profession NN 3251 10 22 ’s ’s POS 3251 10 23 status status NN 3251 10 24 as as IN 3251 10 25 a a DT 3251 10 26 profession profession NN 3251 10 27 — — : 3251 10 28 seem seem VBP 3251 10 29 to to TO 3251 10 30 provoke provoke VB 3251 10 31 the the DT 3251 10 32 range range NN 3251 10 33 and and CC 3251 10 34 depth depth NN 3251 10 35 of of IN 3251 10 36 sentiment sentiment NN 3251 10 37 engendered engender VBN 3251 10 38 by by IN 3251 10 39 discussions discussion NNS 3251 10 40 of of IN 3251 10 41 the the DT 3251 10 42 place place NN 3251 10 43 of of IN 3251 10 44 the the DT 3251 10 45 catalog catalog NN 3251 10 46 . . . 3251 11 1 Especially especially RB 3251 11 2 in in IN 3251 11 3 recent recent JJ 3251 11 4 years year NNS 3251 11 5 , , , 3251 11 6 criticism criticism NN 3251 11 7 of of IN 3251 11 8 the the DT 3251 11 9 catalog catalog NN 3251 11 10 has have VBZ 3251 11 11 grown grow VBN 3251 11 12 ever ever RB 3251 11 13 more more RBR 3251 11 14 strident strident JJ 3251 11 15 , , , 3251 11 16 to to IN 3251 11 17 the the DT 3251 11 18 point point NN 3251 11 19 where where WRB 3251 11 20 it -PRON- PRP 3251 11 21 has have VBZ 3251 11 22 become become VBN 3251 11 23 commonplace commonplace JJ 3251 11 24 in in IN 3251 11 25 our -PRON- PRP$ 3251 11 26 profession profession NN 3251 11 27 ’s ’s POS 3251 11 28 literature literature NN 3251 11 29 to to TO 3251 11 30 say say VB 3251 11 31 that that IN 3251 11 32 this this DT 3251 11 33 most most RBS 3251 11 34 basic basic JJ 3251 11 35 of of IN 3251 11 36 library library JJ 3251 11 37 services service NNS 3251 11 38 “ " `` 3251 11 39 sucks suck NNS 3251 11 40 . . . 3251 11 41 ” " '' 3251 11 42 As as IN 3251 11 43 a a DT 3251 11 44 consequence consequence NN 3251 11 45 , , , 3251 11 46 librarians librarian NNS 3251 11 47 have have VBP 3251 11 48 increasingly increasingly RB 3251 11 49 fallen fall VBN 3251 11 50 into into IN 3251 11 51 one one CD 3251 11 52 of of IN 3251 11 53 two two CD 3251 11 54 camps camp NNS 3251 11 55 , , , 3251 11 56 with with IN 3251 11 57 those those DT 3251 11 58 critical critical JJ 3251 11 59 of of IN 3251 11 60 the the DT 3251 11 61 catalog catalog NN 3251 11 62 often often RB 3251 11 63 simplistically simplistically RB 3251 11 64 characterized characterize VBN 3251 11 65 as as IN 3251 11 66 favoring favoring NN 3251 11 67 , , , 3251 11 68 and and CC 3251 11 69 those those DT 3251 11 70 defending defend VBG 3251 11 71 it -PRON- PRP 3251 11 72 as as IN 3251 11 73 opposing oppose VBG 3251 11 74 “ " `` 3251 11 75 change change NN 3251 11 76 . . . 3251 11 77 ” " '' 3251 11 78 A a DT 3251 11 79 number number NN 3251 11 80 of of IN 3251 11 81 initiatives initiative NNS 3251 11 82 have have VBP 3251 11 83 emerged emerge VBN 3251 11 84 in in IN 3251 11 85 response response NN 3251 11 86 to to IN 3251 11 87 this this DT 3251 11 88 ferment ferment NN 3251 11 89 . . . 3251 12 1 Some some DT 3251 12 2 of of IN 3251 12 3 these these DT 3251 12 4 have have VBP 3251 12 5 focused focus VBN 3251 12 6 on on IN 3251 12 7 our -PRON- PRP$ 3251 12 8 bib- bib- JJ 3251 12 9 liographic liographic JJ 3251 12 10 metadata metadata NN 3251 12 11 , , , 3251 12 12 and and CC 3251 12 13 particularly particularly RB 3251 12 14 on on IN 3251 12 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 3251 12 16 ability ability NN 3251 12 17 to to TO 3251 12 18 express express VB 3251 12 19 the the DT 3251 12 20 relationships relationship NNS 3251 12 21 and and CC 3251 12 22 interconnectedness interconnectedness NN 3251 12 23 of of IN 3251 12 24 the the DT 3251 12 25 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3251 12 26 universe universe NN 3251 12 27 . . . 3251 13 1 As as IN 3251 13 2 we -PRON- PRP 3251 13 3 have have VBP 3251 13 4 traditionally traditionally RB 3251 13 5 cataloged catalog VBN 3251 13 6 whatever whatever WDT 3251 13 7 we -PRON- PRP 3251 13 8 had have VBD 3251 13 9 “ " `` 3251 13 10 in in IN 3251 13 11 - - HYPH 3251 13 12 hand hand NN 3251 13 13 , , , 3251 13 14 ” " '' 3251 13 15 our -PRON- PRP$ 3251 13 16 cataloging cataloging NN 3251 13 17 codes code NNS 3251 13 18 and and CC 3251 13 19 encoding encoding NN 3251 13 20 standards standard NNS 3251 13 21 have have VBP 3251 13 22 done do VBN 3251 13 23 a a DT 3251 13 24 very very RB 3251 13 25 good good JJ 3251 13 26 job job NN 3251 13 27 of of IN 3251 13 28 manag- manag- NNP 3251 13 29 ing e VBG 3251 13 30 the the DT 3251 13 31 description description NN 3251 13 32 of of IN 3251 13 33 bibliographic bibliographic JJ 3251 13 34 items item NNS 3251 13 35 ; ; : 3251 13 36 what what WP 3251 13 37 they -PRON- PRP 3251 13 38 have have VBP 3251 13 39 not not RB 3251 13 40 generally generally RB 3251 13 41 expressed express VBN 3251 13 42 well well RB 3251 13 43 are be VBP 3251 13 44 the the DT 3251 13 45 relationships relationship NNS 3251 13 46 among among IN 3251 13 47 items item NNS 3251 13 48 . . . 3251 14 1 FRBR FRBR NNP 3251 14 2 and and CC 3251 14 3 FRAD FRAD NNP 3251 14 4 — — : 3251 14 5 the the DT 3251 14 6 Functional Functional NNP 3251 14 7 Requirements Requirements NNPS 3251 14 8 for for IN 3251 14 9 Bibliographic Bibliographic NNP 3251 14 10 Records Records NNPS 3251 14 11 and and CC 3251 14 12 the the DT 3251 14 13 Functional Functional NNP 3251 14 14 Requirements Requirements NNPS 3251 14 15 for for IN 3251 14 16 Authority Authority NNP 3251 14 17 Data Data NNP 3251 14 18 — — : 3251 14 19 seem seem VBP 3251 14 20 promising promise VBG 3251 14 21 beginnings beginning NNS 3251 14 22 for for IN 3251 14 23 addressing address VBG 3251 14 24 the the DT 3251 14 25 relationship relationship NN 3251 14 26 issues issue NNS 3251 14 27 , , , 3251 14 28 although although IN 3251 14 29 there there EX 3251 14 30 are be VBP 3251 14 31 as as RB 3251 14 32 - - : 3251 14 33 yet yet RB 3251 14 34 very very RB 3251 14 35 few few JJ 3251 14 36 practical practical JJ 3251 14 37 implementations implementation NNS 3251 14 38 . . . 3251 15 1 Resource resource NN 3251 15 2 Description description NN 3251 15 3 and and CC 3251 15 4 Access Access NNP 3251 15 5 ( ( -LRB- 3251 15 6 RDA RDA NNP 3251 15 7 ) ) -RRB- 3251 15 8 , , , 3251 15 9 the the DT 3251 15 10 forthcoming forthcoming JJ 3251 15 11 successor successor NN 3251 15 12 to to IN 3251 15 13 AACR2 AACR2 NNP 3251 15 14 , , , 3251 15 15 is be VBZ 3251 15 16 designed design VBN 3251 15 17 around around IN 3251 15 18 FRBR FRBR NNP 3251 15 19 concepts concept NNS 3251 15 20 ; ; : 3251 15 21 it -PRON- PRP 3251 15 22 will will MD 3251 15 23 be be VB 3251 15 24 interesting interesting JJ 3251 15 25 to to TO 3251 15 26 see see VB 3251 15 27 how how WRB 3251 15 28 this this DT 3251 15 29 plays play VBZ 3251 15 30 out out RP 3251 15 31 in in IN 3251 15 32 the the DT 3251 15 33 “ " `` 3251 15 34 real real JJ 3251 15 35 world world NN 3251 15 36 ; ; : 3251 15 37 ” " '' 3251 15 38 equally equally RB 3251 15 39 interesting interesting JJ 3251 15 40 will will MD 3251 15 41 be be VB 3251 15 42 to to IN 3251 15 43 what what WP 3251 15 44 degree degree NN 3251 15 45 the the DT 3251 15 46 present present NN 3251 15 47 ( ( -LRB- 3251 15 48 or or CC 3251 15 49 a a DT 3251 15 50 modified modify VBN 3251 15 51 ) ) -RRB- 3251 15 52 MARC21 MARC21 NNP 3251 15 53 is be VBZ 3251 15 54 able able JJ 3251 15 55 to to TO 3251 15 56 express express VB 3251 15 57 RDA RDA NNP 3251 15 58 ’s ’s NNP 3251 15 59 FRBR FRBR NNP 3251 15 60 - - HYPH 3251 15 61 based base VBN 3251 15 62 relationship relationship NN 3251 15 63 model model NN 3251 15 64 . . . 3251 16 1 Other other JJ 3251 16 2 approaches approach NNS 3251 16 3 have have VBP 3251 16 4 focused focus VBN 3251 16 5 on on IN 3251 16 6 developing develop VBG 3251 16 7 systems system NNS 3251 16 8 that that WDT 3251 16 9 are be VBP 3251 16 10 able able JJ 3251 16 11 to to TO 3251 16 12 exploit exploit VB 3251 16 13 our -PRON- PRP$ 3251 16 14 existing exist VBG 3251 16 15 investment investment NN 3251 16 16 in in IN 3251 16 17 biblio- biblio- JJ 3251 16 18 graphic graphic JJ 3251 16 19 metadata metadata NN 3251 16 20 in in IN 3251 16 21 new new JJ 3251 16 22 and and CC 3251 16 23 useful useful JJ 3251 16 24 ways way NNS 3251 16 25 . . . 3251 17 1 The the DT 3251 17 2 pioneering pioneering JJ 3251 17 3 and and CC 3251 17 4 best best RB 3251 17 5 - - HYPH 3251 17 6 known know VBN 3251 17 7 example example NN 3251 17 8 of of IN 3251 17 9 this this DT 3251 17 10 , , , 3251 17 11 of of IN 3251 17 12 course course NN 3251 17 13 , , , 3251 17 14 is be VBZ 3251 17 15 the the DT 3251 17 16 discov- discov- JJ 3251 17 17 ery ery NN 3251 17 18 tool tool NN 3251 17 19 developed develop VBN 3251 17 20 by by IN 3251 17 21 a a DT 3251 17 22 partnership partnership NN 3251 17 23 of of IN 3251 17 24 North North NNP 3251 17 25 Carolina Carolina NNP 3251 17 26 State State NNP 3251 17 27 University University NNP 3251 17 28 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3251 17 29 and and CC 3251 17 30 Endeca Endeca NNP 3251 17 31 , , , 3251 17 32 which which WDT 3251 17 33 premiered premiere VBD 3251 17 34 in in RP 3251 17 35 early early JJ 3251 17 36 2006 2006 CD 3251 17 37 . . . 3251 18 1 This this DT 3251 18 2 initiative initiative NN 3251 18 3 included include VBD 3251 18 4 several several JJ 3251 18 5 innova- innova- NN 3251 18 6 tive tive JJ 3251 18 7 features feature NNS 3251 18 8 not not RB 3251 18 9 previously previously RB 3251 18 10 found find VBN 3251 18 11 in in IN 3251 18 12 library library NN 3251 18 13 catalogs catalog NNS 3251 18 14 , , , 3251 18 15 such such JJ 3251 18 16 as as IN 3251 18 17 search search NN 3251 18 18 result result NN 3251 18 19 relevance relevance NN 3251 18 20 ranking rank VBG 3251 18 21 and and CC 3251 18 22 the the DT 3251 18 23 ability ability NN 3251 18 24 to to TO 3251 18 25 perform perform VB 3251 18 26 faceted faceted JJ 3251 18 27 searching search VBG 3251 18 28 against against IN 3251 18 29 a a DT 3251 18 30 variety variety NN 3251 18 31 of of IN 3251 18 32 controlled- controlled- FW 3251 18 33 vocabulary vocabulary NN 3251 18 34 indices index NNS 3251 18 35 ( ( -LRB- 3251 18 36 subject subject JJ 3251 18 37 / / SYM 3251 18 38 topical topical JJ 3251 18 39 , , , 3251 18 40 form form NN 3251 18 41 / / SYM 3251 18 42 genre genre NN 3251 18 43 , , , 3251 18 44 date date NN 3251 18 45 , , , 3251 18 46 etc etc FW 3251 18 47 . . . 3251 18 48 ) ) -RRB- 3251 19 1 NCSU NCSU NNP 3251 19 2 ’s ’s NNP 3251 19 3 Endeca Endeca NNP 3251 19 4 discovery discovery NN 3251 19 5 tool tool NN 3251 19 6 spawned spawn VBD 3251 19 7 an an DT 3251 19 8 entirely entirely RB 3251 19 9 new new JJ 3251 19 10 product product NN 3251 19 11 segment segment NN 3251 19 12 for for IN 3251 19 13 the the DT 3251 19 14 catalog catalog NN 3251 19 15 : : : 3251 19 16 major major JJ 3251 19 17 ILS ILS NNP 3251 19 18 vendors vendor NNS 3251 19 19 have have VBP 3251 19 20 scrambled scramble VBN 3251 19 21 to to TO 3251 19 22 develop develop VB 3251 19 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 3251 19 24 own own JJ 3251 19 25 next next JJ 3251 19 26 - - HYPH 3251 19 27 gen gen NN 3251 19 28 products product NNS 3251 19 29 , , , 3251 19 30 combining combine VBG 3251 19 31 relevancy relevancy NN 3251 19 32 and and CC 3251 19 33 facets facet NNS 3251 19 34 with with IN 3251 19 35 additional additional JJ 3251 19 36 function- function- NN 3251 19 37 ality ality NN 3251 19 38 such such JJ 3251 19 39 as as IN 3251 19 40 Web web NN 3251 19 41 2.0 2.0 CD 3251 19 42 social social JJ 3251 19 43 and and CC 3251 19 44 collaborative collaborative JJ 3251 19 45 tools tool NNS 3251 19 46 and and CC 3251 19 47 enhanced enhance VBD 3251 19 48 federated federated NNP 3251 19 49 searching search VBG 3251 19 50 capabilities capability NNS 3251 19 51 . . . 3251 20 1 The the DT 3251 20 2 result result NN 3251 20 3 of of IN 3251 20 4 all all PDT 3251 20 5 this this DT 3251 20 6 activity activity NN 3251 20 7 has have VBZ 3251 20 8 been be VBN 3251 20 9 the the DT 3251 20 10 first first JJ 3251 20 11 cross cross JJ 3251 20 12 - - JJ 3251 20 13 platform platform JJ 3251 20 14 growth growth NN 3251 20 15 opportunity opportunity NN 3251 20 16 for for IN 3251 20 17 ILS ILS NNP 3251 20 18 vendors vendor NNS 3251 20 19 since since IN 3251 20 20 the the DT 3251 20 21 development development NN 3251 20 22 of of IN 3251 20 23 resource resource NN 3251 20 24 - - HYPH 3251 20 25 linking link VBG 3251 20 26 tools tool NNS 3251 20 27 and and CC 3251 20 28 the the DT 3251 20 29 ERM ERM NNP 3251 20 30 . . . 3251 21 1 We -PRON- PRP 3251 21 2 at at IN 3251 21 3 ITAL ITAL NNP 3251 21 4 have have VBP 3251 21 5 watched watch VBN 3251 21 6 these these DT 3251 21 7 trends trend NNS 3251 21 8 with with IN 3251 21 9 keen keen JJ 3251 21 10 interest interest NN 3251 21 11 and and CC 3251 21 12 have have VBP 3251 21 13 published publish VBN 3251 21 14 works work NNS 3251 21 15 describing describe VBG 3251 21 16 many many JJ 3251 21 17 of of IN 3251 21 18 the the DT 3251 21 19 major major JJ 3251 21 20 developments development NNS 3251 21 21 vis vis FW 3251 21 22 - - HYPH 3251 21 23 a a FW 3251 21 24 - - HYPH 3251 21 25 vis vis FW 3251 21 26 the the DT 3251 21 27 catalog catalog NN 3251 21 28 in in IN 3251 21 29 recent recent JJ 3251 21 30 years year NNS 3251 21 31 . . . 3251 22 1 Indeed indeed RB 3251 22 2 , , , 3251 22 3 since since IN 3251 22 4 late late JJ 3251 22 5 2004 2004 CD 3251 22 6 , , , 3251 22 7 ITAL ITAL NNP 3251 22 8 has have VBZ 3251 22 9 published publish VBN 3251 22 10 at at IN 3251 22 11 least least JJS 3251 22 12 eleven eleven CD 3251 22 13 major major JJ 3251 22 14 papers paper NNS 3251 22 15 on on IN 3251 22 16 various various JJ 3251 22 17 topics topic NNS 3251 22 18 related relate VBN 3251 22 19 to to IN 3251 22 20 improv- improv- NNP 3251 22 21 ing e VBG 3251 22 22 the the DT 3251 22 23 catalog catalog NN 3251 22 24 . . . 3251 23 1 With with IN 3251 23 2 our -PRON- PRP$ 3251 23 3 publication publication NN 3251 23 4 of of IN 3251 23 5 Jennifer Jennifer NNP 3251 23 6 Bowen Bowen NNP 3251 23 7 ’s ’s POS 3251 23 8 report report NN 3251 23 9 on on IN 3251 23 10 the the DT 3251 23 11 first first JJ 3251 23 12 phase phase NN 3251 23 13 outcomes outcome NNS 3251 23 14 of of IN 3251 23 15 the the DT 3251 23 16 University University NNP 3251 23 17 of of IN 3251 23 18 Rochester Rochester NNP 3251 23 19 ’s ’s POS 3251 23 20 eXtensible extensible JJ 3251 23 21 catalog catalog NN 3251 23 22 ( ( -LRB- 3251 23 23 XC XC NNP 3251 23 24 ) ) -RRB- 3251 23 25 project project NN 3251 23 26 in in IN 3251 23 27 this this DT 3251 23 28 issue issue NN 3251 23 29 of of IN 3251 23 30 ITAL ITAL NNP 3251 23 31 , , , 3251 23 32 we -PRON- PRP 3251 23 33 continue continue VBP 3251 23 34 our -PRON- PRP$ 3251 23 35 commitment commitment NN 3251 23 36 to to TO 3251 23 37 publish publish VB 3251 23 38 important important JJ 3251 23 39 research research NN 3251 23 40 in in IN 3251 23 41 this this DT 3251 23 42 area area NN 3251 23 43 . . . 3251 24 1 The the DT 3251 24 2 Rochester Rochester NNP 3251 24 3 project project NN 3251 24 4 is be VBZ 3251 24 5 noteworthy noteworthy JJ 3251 24 6 , , , 3251 24 7 both both DT 3251 24 8 for for IN 3251 24 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 3251 24 10 modular modular JJ 3251 24 11 and and CC 3251 24 12 metadata metadata NN 3251 24 13 - - HYPH 3251 24 14 focused focus VBN 3251 24 15 approach approach NN 3251 24 16 and and CC 3251 24 17 for for IN 3251 24 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 3251 24 19 high high JJ 3251 24 20 visibility visibility NN 3251 24 21 as as IN 3251 24 22 an an DT 3251 24 23 open open JJ 3251 24 24 source source NN 3251 24 25 effort effort NN 3251 24 26 that that WDT 3251 24 27 has have VBZ 3251 24 28 received receive VBN 3251 24 29 significant significant JJ 3251 24 30 support support NN 3251 24 31 from from IN 3251 24 32 the the DT 3251 24 33 Andrew Andrew NNP 3251 24 34 W. W. NNP 3251 24 35 Mellon Mellon NNP 3251 24 36 Foundation Foundation NNP 3251 24 37 . . . 3251 25 1 I -PRON- PRP 3251 25 2 predict predict VBP 3251 25 3 that that IN 3251 25 4 this this DT 3251 25 5 paper paper NN 3251 25 6 will will MD 3251 25 7 quickly quickly RB 3251 25 8 take take VB 3251 25 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 3251 25 10 place place NN 3251 25 11 among among IN 3251 25 12 the the DT 3251 25 13 other other JJ 3251 25 14 ground ground NN 3251 25 15 - - HYPH 3251 25 16 breaking break VBG 3251 25 17 works work NNS 3251 25 18 on on IN 3251 25 19 the the DT 3251 25 20 catalog catalog NN 3251 25 21 that that IN 3251 25 22 ITAL ITAL NNP 3251 25 23 has have VBZ 3251 25 24 published publish VBN 3251 25 25 , , , 3251 25 26 and and CC 3251 25 27 I -PRON- PRP 3251 25 28 ’ll will MD 3251 25 29 eagerly eagerly RB 3251 25 30 be be VB 3251 25 31 await- await- JJ 3251 25 32 ing e VBG 3251 25 33 the the DT 3251 25 34 next next JJ 3251 25 35 progress progress NN 3251 25 36 report report NN 3251 25 37 on on IN 3251 25 38 the the DT 3251 25 39 XC XC NNP 3251 25 40 . . . 3251 26 1 n n LS 3251 26 2 “ " `` 3251 26 3 Must Must MD 3251 26 4 - - HYPH 3251 26 5 reads read VBZ 3251 26 6 ” " '' 3251 26 7 Dept Dept NNP 3251 26 8 . . . 3251 27 1 Okay okay UH 3251 27 2 , , , 3251 27 3 so so RB 3251 27 4 I -PRON- PRP 3251 27 5 may may MD 3251 27 6 not not RB 3251 27 7 be be VB 3251 27 8 the the DT 3251 27 9 first first JJ 3251 27 10 out out IN 3251 27 11 of of IN 3251 27 12 the the DT 3251 27 13 gate gate NN 3251 27 14 with with IN 3251 27 15 this this DT 3251 27 16 one one NN 3251 27 17 , , , 3251 27 18 but but CC 3251 27 19 for for IN 3251 27 20 those those DT 3251 27 21 of of IN 3251 27 22 you -PRON- PRP 3251 27 23 who who WP 3251 27 24 have have VBP 3251 27 25 n’t not RB 3251 27 26 looked look VBN 3251 27 27 at at IN 3251 27 28 it -PRON- PRP 3251 27 29 yet yet RB 3251 27 30 , , , 3251 27 31 trust trust VB 3251 27 32 me -PRON- PRP 3251 27 33 , , , 3251 27 34 you -PRON- PRP 3251 27 35 ’ll will MD 3251 27 36 want want VB 3251 27 37 to to TO 3251 27 38 . . . 3251 28 1 Jonathan Jonathan NNP 3251 28 2 Zittrain Zittrain NNP 3251 28 3 ’s ’s , 3251 28 4 The the DT 3251 28 5 Future future NN 3251 28 6 of of IN 3251 28 7 the the DT 3251 28 8 Internet internet NN 3251 28 9 and and CC 3251 28 10 How how WRB 3251 28 11 to to TO 3251 28 12 Stop stop VB 3251 28 13 It -PRON- PRP 3251 28 14 ( ( -LRB- 3251 28 15 Yale Yale NNP 3251 28 16 University University NNP 3251 28 17 Press Press NNP 3251 28 18 , , , 3251 28 19 2008 2008 CD 3251 28 20 ) ) -RRB- 3251 28 21 , , , 3251 28 22 which which WDT 3251 28 23 divides divide VBZ 3251 28 24 the the DT 3251 28 25 Internet internet NN 3251 28 26 into into IN 3251 28 27 “ " `` 3251 28 28 generative generative JJ 3251 28 29 ” " '' 3251 28 30 tech- tech- JJ 3251 28 31 nologies nologie NNS 3251 28 32 such such JJ 3251 28 33 as as IN 3251 28 34 the the DT 3251 28 35 PC pc NN 3251 28 36 , , , 3251 28 37 and and CC 3251 28 38 proprietary proprietary JJ 3251 28 39 appliances appliance NNS 3251 28 40 such such JJ 3251 28 41 as as IN 3251 28 42 the the DT 3251 28 43 iPhone iPhone NNP 3251 28 44 , , , 3251 28 45 may may MD 3251 28 46 or or CC 3251 28 47 may may MD 3251 28 48 not not RB 3251 28 49 resonate resonate VB 3251 28 50 with with IN 3251 28 51 you -PRON- PRP 3251 28 52 , , , 3251 28 53 but but CC 3251 28 54 I -PRON- PRP 3251 28 55 think think VBP 3251 28 56 it -PRON- PRP 3251 28 57 could could MD 3251 28 58 well well RB 3251 28 59 become become VB 3251 28 60 the the DT 3251 28 61 next next JJ 3251 28 62 big big JJ 3251 28 63 debate debate NN 3251 28 64 about about IN 3251 28 65 where where WRB 3251 28 66 the the DT 3251 28 67 Net net NN 3251 28 68 is be VBZ 3251 28 69 and and CC 3251 28 70 where where WRB 3251 28 71 it -PRON- PRP 3251 28 72 should should MD 3251 28 73 be be VB 3251 28 74 going go VBG 3251 28 75 . . . 3251 29 1 Grab grab VB 3251 29 2 a a DT 3251 29 3 copy copy NN 3251 29 4 and and CC 3251 29 5 read read VBD 3251 29 6 it -PRON- PRP 3251 29 7 today today NN 3251 29 8 . . .