id sid tid token lemma pos 3093 1 1 Searchable searchable JJ 3093 1 2 Signatures signature NNS 3093 1 3 : : : 3093 1 4 Context context NN 3093 1 5 and and CC 3093 1 6 the the DT 3093 1 7 Struggle Struggle NNP 3093 1 8 for for IN 3093 1 9 Recognition Recognition NNP 3093 1 10 Gina Gina NNP 3093 1 11 Schlesselman- Schlesselman- NNP 3093 1 12 Tarango Tarango NNP 3093 1 13 INFORMATION INFORMATION VBD 3093 1 14 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3093 1 15 AND and CC 3093 1 16 LIBRARIES library NNS 3093 1 17 | | NNP 3093 1 18 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3093 1 19 2013 2013 CD 3093 1 20 5 5 CD 3093 1 21 ABSTRACT abstract JJ 3093 1 22 Social social JJ 3093 1 23 networking networking NN 3093 1 24 sites site NNS 3093 1 25 made make VBD 3093 1 26 possible possible JJ 3093 1 27 through through IN 3093 1 28 Web web NN 3093 1 29 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 1 30 allow allow VB 3093 1 31 for for IN 3093 1 32 unique unique JJ 3093 1 33 user user NN 3093 1 34 - - HYPH 3093 1 35 generated generate VBN 3093 1 36 tags tag NNS 3093 1 37 called call VBN 3093 1 38 “ " `` 3093 1 39 searchable searchable JJ 3093 1 40 signatures signature NNS 3093 1 41 . . . 3093 1 42 ” " '' 3093 1 43 These these DT 3093 1 44 tags tag NNS 3093 1 45 move move VBP 3093 1 46 beyond beyond IN 3093 1 47 the the DT 3093 1 48 descriptive descriptive JJ 3093 1 49 and and CC 3093 1 50 act act VBP 3093 1 51 as as IN 3093 1 52 means mean NNS 3093 1 53 for for IN 3093 1 54 users user NNS 3093 1 55 to to TO 3093 1 56 assert assert VB 3093 1 57 online online JJ 3093 1 58 individual individual NN 3093 1 59 and and CC 3093 1 60 group group NN 3093 1 61 identities identity NNS 3093 1 62 . . . 3093 2 1 This this DT 3093 2 2 paper paper NN 3093 2 3 presents present VBZ 3093 2 4 a a DT 3093 2 5 study study NN 3093 2 6 of of IN 3093 2 7 searchable searchable JJ 3093 2 8 signatures signature NNS 3093 2 9 on on IN 3093 2 10 the the DT 3093 2 11 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 2 12 application application NN 3093 2 13 , , , 3093 2 14 demonstrating demonstrate VBG 3093 2 15 that that IN 3093 2 16 these these DT 3093 2 17 types type NNS 3093 2 18 of of IN 3093 2 19 tags tag NNS 3093 2 20 are be VBP 3093 2 21 valuable valuable JJ 3093 2 22 not not RB 3093 2 23 only only RB 3093 2 24 because because IN 3093 2 25 they -PRON- PRP 3093 2 26 allow allow VBP 3093 2 27 for for IN 3093 2 28 both both DT 3093 2 29 individuals individual NNS 3093 2 30 and and CC 3093 2 31 groups group NNS 3093 2 32 to to TO 3093 2 33 engage engage VB 3093 2 34 in in IN 3093 2 35 what what WP 3093 2 36 social social JJ 3093 2 37 theorist theorist NN 3093 2 38 Axel Axel NNP 3093 2 39 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 2 40 calls call VBZ 3093 2 41 the the DT 3093 2 42 “ " `` 3093 2 43 struggle struggle NN 3093 2 44 for for IN 3093 2 45 recognition recognition NN 3093 2 46 , , , 3093 2 47 ” " '' 3093 2 48 but but CC 3093 2 49 also also RB 3093 2 50 because because IN 3093 2 51 they -PRON- PRP 3093 2 52 provide provide VBP 3093 2 53 contextual contextual JJ 3093 2 54 use use NN 3093 2 55 data datum NNS 3093 2 56 and and CC 3093 2 57 sociohistorical sociohistorical JJ 3093 2 58 information information NN 3093 2 59 so so RB 3093 2 60 important important JJ 3093 2 61 to to IN 3093 2 62 the the DT 3093 2 63 understanding understanding NN 3093 2 64 of of IN 3093 2 65 digital digital JJ 3093 2 66 objects object NNS 3093 2 67 . . . 3093 3 1 Methods method NNS 3093 3 2 for for IN 3093 3 3 the the DT 3093 3 4 gathering gathering NN 3093 3 5 and and CC 3093 3 6 display display NN 3093 3 7 of of IN 3093 3 8 searchable searchable JJ 3093 3 9 signatures signature NNS 3093 3 10 in in IN 3093 3 11 digital digital JJ 3093 3 12 library library NN 3093 3 13 environments environment NNS 3093 3 14 are be VBP 3093 3 15 also also RB 3093 3 16 explored explore VBN 3093 3 17 . . . 3093 4 1 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 3093 4 2 A a DT 3093 4 3 comparison comparison NN 3093 4 4 of of IN 3093 4 5 user user NN 3093 4 6 - - HYPH 3093 4 7 generated generate VBN 3093 4 8 tags tag NNS 3093 4 9 with with IN 3093 4 10 metadata metadata NN 3093 4 11 traditionally traditionally RB 3093 4 12 assigned assign VBN 3093 4 13 to to IN 3093 4 14 digital digital JJ 3093 4 15 objects object NNS 3093 4 16 suggests suggest VBZ 3093 4 17 that that IN 3093 4 18 social social JJ 3093 4 19 network network NN 3093 4 20 platforms platform NNS 3093 4 21 provide provide VBP 3093 4 22 an an DT 3093 4 23 intersubjective intersubjective JJ 3093 4 24 space space NN 3093 4 25 for for IN 3093 4 26 what what WP 3093 4 27 social social JJ 3093 4 28 theorist theorist NN 3093 4 29 Axel Axel NNP 3093 4 30 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 4 31 has have VBZ 3093 4 32 termed term VBN 3093 4 33 the the DT 3093 4 34 “ " `` 3093 4 35 struggle struggle NN 3093 4 36 for for IN 3093 4 37 recognition recognition NN 3093 4 38 . . . 3093 4 39 ” " '' 3093 4 40 1 1 CD 3093 4 41 Social social JJ 3093 4 42 network network NN 3093 4 43 users user NNS 3093 4 44 , , , 3093 4 45 through through IN 3093 4 46 the the DT 3093 4 47 creation creation NN 3093 4 48 of of IN 3093 4 49 identity identity NN 3093 4 50 - - HYPH 3093 4 51 based base VBN 3093 4 52 tags tag NNS 3093 4 53 — — : 3093 4 54 or or CC 3093 4 55 what what WP 3093 4 56 can can MD 3093 4 57 be be VB 3093 4 58 understood understand VBN 3093 4 59 as as IN 3093 4 60 “ " `` 3093 4 61 searchable searchable JJ 3093 4 62 signatures”—are signatures”—are NN 3093 4 63 able able JJ 3093 4 64 to to TO 3093 4 65 assert assert VB 3093 4 66 and and CC 3093 4 67 perform perform VB 3093 4 68 online online JJ 3093 4 69 selves self NNS 3093 4 70 and and CC 3093 4 71 are be VBP 3093 4 72 thus thus RB 3093 4 73 able able JJ 3093 4 74 to to TO 3093 4 75 demand demand VB 3093 4 76 , , , 3093 4 77 or or CC 3093 4 78 struggle struggle VB 3093 4 79 for for IN 3093 4 80 , , , 3093 4 81 recognition recognition NN 3093 4 82 within within IN 3093 4 83 a a DT 3093 4 84 larger large JJR 3093 4 85 social social JJ 3093 4 86 framework framework NN 3093 4 87 . . . 3093 5 1 Baroncelli Baroncelli NNP 3093 5 2 and and CC 3093 5 3 Freitas Freitas NNP 3093 5 4 cogently cogently RB 3093 5 5 argue argue VBP 3093 5 6 that that IN 3093 5 7 Web web NN 3093 5 8 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 5 9 , , , 3093 5 10 or or CC 3093 5 11 the the DT 3093 5 12 interactive interactive JJ 3093 5 13 online online JJ 3093 5 14 social social JJ 3093 5 15 arena arena NN 3093 5 16 , , , 3093 5 17 in in IN 3093 5 18 fact fact NN 3093 5 19 functions function NNS 3093 5 20 as as IN 3093 5 21 a a DT 3093 5 22 “ " `` 3093 5 23 recognition recognition NN 3093 5 24 market market NN 3093 5 25 in in IN 3093 5 26 which which WDT 3093 5 27 contemporary contemporary JJ 3093 5 28 individuals individual NNS 3093 5 29 . . . 3093 6 1 . . . 3093 7 1 . . . 3093 8 1 trade trade NNP 3093 8 2 personal personal JJ 3093 8 3 worth worth NN 3093 8 4 through through IN 3093 8 5 displays display NNS 3093 8 6 and and CC 3093 8 7 exchanges exchange NNS 3093 8 8 of of IN 3093 8 9 . . . 3093 9 1 . . . 3093 10 1 . . . 3093 11 1 self self NN 3093 11 2 - - HYPH 3093 11 3 presentations presentation NNS 3093 11 4 . . . 3093 11 5 ” " '' 3093 11 6 2 2 CD 3093 11 7 A a DT 3093 11 8 comparison comparison NN 3093 11 9 of of IN 3093 11 10 a a DT 3093 11 11 metadata metadata NN 3093 11 12 schema schema NN 3093 11 13 used use VBN 3093 11 14 in in IN 3093 11 15 Yale Yale NNP 3093 11 16 University University NNP 3093 11 17 ’s ’s POS 3093 11 18 Digital Digital NNP 3093 11 19 Images Images NNP 3093 11 20 Database Database NNP 3093 11 21 with with IN 3093 11 22 user- user- NN 3093 11 23 generated generate VBN 3093 11 24 tags tag NNS 3093 11 25 accompanying accompany VBG 3093 11 26 shared shared JJ 3093 11 27 photographs photograph NNS 3093 11 28 on on IN 3093 11 29 the the DT 3093 11 30 social social JJ 3093 11 31 networking networking NN 3093 11 32 platform platform NN 3093 11 33 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 11 34 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 3093 11 35 that that IN 3093 11 36 searchable searchable JJ 3093 11 37 signatures signature NNS 3093 11 38 are be VBP 3093 11 39 unique unique JJ 3093 11 40 to to IN 3093 11 41 social social JJ 3093 11 42 networking networking NN 3093 11 43 sites site NNS 3093 11 44 . . . 3093 12 1 As as IN 3093 12 2 phenomena phenomenon NNS 3093 12 3 that that WDT 3093 12 4 allow allow VBP 3093 12 5 for for IN 3093 12 6 public public JJ 3093 12 7 presentations presentation NNS 3093 12 8 of of IN 3093 12 9 disembodied disembodied JJ 3093 12 10 selves self NNS 3093 12 11 , , , 3093 12 12 searchable searchable JJ 3093 12 13 signatures signature NNS 3093 12 14 thus thus RB 3093 12 15 provide provide VBP 3093 12 16 specific specific JJ 3093 12 17 information information NN 3093 12 18 about about IN 3093 12 19 the the DT 3093 12 20 context context NN 3093 12 21 of of IN 3093 12 22 the the DT 3093 12 23 digital digital JJ 3093 12 24 images image NNS 3093 12 25 with with IN 3093 12 26 which which WDT 3093 12 27 they -PRON- PRP 3093 12 28 are be VBP 3093 12 29 associated associate VBN 3093 12 30 . . . 3093 13 1 Capturing capture VBG 3093 13 2 context context NN 3093 13 3 remains remain VBZ 3093 13 4 a a DT 3093 13 5 challenge challenge NN 3093 13 6 for for IN 3093 13 7 those those DT 3093 13 8 working work VBG 3093 13 9 with with IN 3093 13 10 digital digital JJ 3093 13 11 collections collection NNS 3093 13 12 , , , 3093 13 13 but but CC 3093 13 14 searchable searchable JJ 3093 13 15 signatures signature NNS 3093 13 16 allow allow VBP 3093 13 17 viewers viewer NNS 3093 13 18 to to TO 3093 13 19 derive derive VB 3093 13 20 valuable valuable JJ 3093 13 21 use use NN 3093 13 22 data datum NNS 3093 13 23 and and CC 3093 13 24 sociohistorical sociohistorical JJ 3093 13 25 information information NN 3093 13 26 to to TO 3093 13 27 better better RB 3093 13 28 understand understand VB 3093 13 29 the the DT 3093 13 30 world world NN 3093 13 31 in in IN 3093 13 32 which which WDT 3093 13 33 digital digital JJ 3093 13 34 images image NNS 3093 13 35 originated originated VBP 3093 13 36 and and CC 3093 13 37 exist exist VBP 3093 13 38 . . . 3093 14 1 LITERATURE LITERATURE NNP 3093 14 2 REVIEW REVIEW NNP 3093 14 3 Web Web NNP 3093 14 4 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 14 5 Identities Identities NNPS 3093 14 6 and and CC 3093 14 7 Recognition Recognition NNP 3093 14 8 Theory Theory NNP 3093 14 9 While while IN 3093 14 10 Web web NN 3093 14 11 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 14 12 can can MD 3093 14 13 be be VB 3093 14 14 imagined imagine VBN 3093 14 15 as as IN 3093 14 16 a a DT 3093 14 17 highly highly RB 3093 14 18 collaborative collaborative JJ 3093 14 19 space space NN 3093 14 20 where where WRB 3093 14 21 social social JJ 3093 14 22 actors actor NNS 3093 14 23 are be VBP 3093 14 24 able able JJ 3093 14 25 to to IN 3093 14 26 Gina Gina NNP 3093 14 27 Schlesselman Schlesselman NNP 3093 14 28 - - HYPH 3093 14 29 Tarango Tarango NNP 3093 14 30 ( ( -LRB- 3093 14 31 gina.schlesselman@du.edu gina.schlesselman@du.edu NNP 3093 14 32 ) ) -RRB- 3093 14 33 holds hold VBZ 3093 14 34 a a DT 3093 14 35 Master Master NNP 3093 14 36 of of IN 3093 14 37 Social Social NNP 3093 14 38 Sciences Sciences NNPS 3093 14 39 from from IN 3093 14 40 the the DT 3093 14 41 University University NNP 3093 14 42 of of IN 3093 14 43 Colorado Colorado NNP 3093 14 44 Denver Denver NNP 3093 14 45 and and CC 3093 14 46 is be VBZ 3093 14 47 currently currently RB 3093 14 48 an an DT 3093 14 49 MLIS MLIS NNP 3093 14 50 candidate candidate NN 3093 14 51 at at IN 3093 14 52 University University NNP 3093 14 53 of of IN 3093 14 54 Colorado Colorado NNP 3093 14 55 . . . 3093 15 1 mailto:gina.schlesselman@du.edu mailto:gina.schlesselman@du.edu NNS 3093 15 2 SEARCHABLE SEARCHABLE NNP 3093 15 3 SIGNATURES signatures VBP 3093 15 4 : : : 3093 15 5 CONTEXT context NN 3093 15 6 AND and CC 3093 15 7 THE the DT 3093 15 8 STRUGGLE struggle NN 3093 15 9 FOR for IN 3093 15 10 RECOGNITION RECOGNITION NNP 3093 15 11 | | CD 3093 15 12 SCHLESSELMAN SCHLESSELMAN NNP 3093 15 13 - - HYPH 3093 15 14 TARANGO TARANGO NNP 3093 15 15 6 6 CD 3093 15 16 communicate communicate NN 3093 15 17 to to IN 3093 15 18 the the DT 3093 15 19 world world NN 3093 15 20 new new JJ 3093 15 21 identities identity NNS 3093 15 22 , , , 3093 15 23 some some DT 3093 15 24 warn warn VBP 3093 15 25 that that IN 3093 15 26 this this DT 3093 15 27 communication communication NN 3093 15 28 is be VBZ 3093 15 29 somehow somehow RB 3093 15 30 engineered engineer VBN 3093 15 31 and and CC 3093 15 32 performed perform VBN 3093 15 33 . . . 3093 16 1 Van Van NNP 3093 16 2 Dijck Dijck NNP 3093 16 3 , , , 3093 16 4 in in IN 3093 16 5 an an DT 3093 16 6 analysis analysis NN 3093 16 7 of of IN 3093 16 8 social social JJ 3093 16 9 media medium NNS 3093 16 10 , , , 3093 16 11 argues argue VBZ 3093 16 12 that that IN 3093 16 13 it -PRON- PRP 3093 16 14 is be VBZ 3093 16 15 indeed indeed RB 3093 16 16 “ " `` 3093 16 17 publicity publicity NN 3093 16 18 strategies strategy NNS 3093 16 19 [ [ -LRB- 3093 16 20 that that IN 3093 16 21 ] ] -RRB- 3093 16 22 mediate mediate VBP 3093 16 23 the the DT 3093 16 24 norms norm NNS 3093 16 25 for for IN 3093 16 26 sociality sociality NN 3093 16 27 and and CC 3093 16 28 connectivity connectivity NN 3093 16 29 , , , 3093 16 30 ” " '' 3093 16 31 and and CC 3093 16 32 Baroncelli Baroncelli NNP 3093 16 33 and and CC 3093 16 34 Freitas Freitas NNP 3093 16 35 note note VBP 3093 16 36 that that IN 3093 16 37 Web web NN 3093 16 38 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 16 39 allows allow VBZ 3093 16 40 people people NNS 3093 16 41 to to TO 3093 16 42 make make VB 3093 16 43 themselves -PRON- PRP 3093 16 44 visible visible JJ 3093 16 45 through through IN 3093 16 46 modes mode NNS 3093 16 47 of of IN 3093 16 48 spectacularization.3 spectacularization.3 CD 3093 16 49 Though though IN 3093 16 50 his -PRON- PRP$ 3093 16 51 focus focus NN 3093 16 52 is be VBZ 3093 16 53 on on IN 3093 16 54 the the DT 3093 16 55 spectacle spectacle NN 3093 16 56 in in IN 3093 16 57 fin fin NNP 3093 16 58 de de NNP 3093 16 59 siècle siècle NNP 3093 16 60 France France NNP 3093 16 61 , , , 3093 16 62 Clark Clark NNP 3093 16 63 provides provide VBZ 3093 16 64 some some DT 3093 16 65 insight insight NN 3093 16 66 into into IN 3093 16 67 the the DT 3093 16 68 effects effect NNS 3093 16 69 of of IN 3093 16 70 spectacularization spectacularization NN 3093 16 71 on on IN 3093 16 72 the the DT 3093 16 73 individual individual NN 3093 16 74 . . . 3093 17 1 4 4 LS 3093 17 2 Working work VBG 3093 17 3 within within IN 3093 17 4 a a DT 3093 17 5 historical historical JJ 3093 17 6 materialist materialist JJ 3093 17 7 framework framework NN 3093 17 8 , , , 3093 17 9 Clark Clark NNP 3093 17 10 points point VBZ 3093 17 11 that that IN 3093 17 12 with with IN 3093 17 13 the the DT 3093 17 14 growth growth NN 3093 17 15 of of IN 3093 17 16 capitalism capitalism NN 3093 17 17 , , , 3093 17 18 the the DT 3093 17 19 individual individual NN 3093 17 20 has have VBZ 3093 17 21 become become VBN 3093 17 22 colonized colonize VBN 3093 17 23 . . . 3093 18 1 5 5 CD 3093 18 2 Clark Clark NNP 3093 18 3 further further RB 3093 18 4 describes describe VBZ 3093 18 5 this this DT 3093 18 6 colonization colonization NN 3093 18 7 as as IN 3093 18 8 “ " `` 3093 18 9 massive massive JJ 3093 18 10 internal internal JJ 3093 18 11 extension extension NN 3093 18 12 of of IN 3093 18 13 the the DT 3093 18 14 capitalist capitalist JJ 3093 18 15 market market NN 3093 18 16 — — : 3093 18 17 the the DT 3093 18 18 invasion invasion NN 3093 18 19 and and CC 3093 18 20 restructuring restructuring NN 3093 18 21 of of IN 3093 18 22 whole whole JJ 3093 18 23 areas area NNS 3093 18 24 of of IN 3093 18 25 free free JJ 3093 18 26 time time NN 3093 18 27 , , , 3093 18 28 private private JJ 3093 18 29 life life NN 3093 18 30 , , , 3093 18 31 leisure leisure NN 3093 18 32 , , , 3093 18 33 and and CC 3093 18 34 personal personal JJ 3093 18 35 expression expression NN 3093 18 36 . . . 3093 19 1 . . . 3093 20 1 . . . 3093 21 1 the the DT 3093 21 2 making make VBG 3093 21 3 - - HYPH 3093 21 4 into into IN 3093 21 5 - - HYPH 3093 21 6 commodities commodity NNS 3093 21 7 of of IN 3093 21 8 whole whole JJ 3093 21 9 areas area NNS 3093 21 10 of of IN 3093 21 11 social social JJ 3093 21 12 practice practice NN 3093 21 13 which which WDT 3093 21 14 had have VBD 3093 21 15 once once RB 3093 21 16 been be VBN 3093 21 17 referred refer VBN 3093 21 18 to to TO 3093 21 19 casually casually RB 3093 21 20 as as IN 3093 21 21 everyday everyday JJ 3093 21 22 life life NN 3093 21 23 . . . 3093 21 24 ” " '' 3093 21 25 6 6 CD 3093 21 26 Here here RB 3093 21 27 , , , 3093 21 28 Web web NN 3093 21 29 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 21 30 is be VBZ 3093 21 31 not not RB 3093 21 32 a a DT 3093 21 33 liberatory liberatory JJ 3093 21 34 tool tool NN 3093 21 35 but but CC 3093 21 36 instead instead RB 3093 21 37 a a DT 3093 21 38 space space NN 3093 21 39 where where WRB 3093 21 40 users user NNS 3093 21 41 are be VBP 3093 21 42 colonized colonize VBN 3093 21 43 to to IN 3093 21 44 the the DT 3093 21 45 extent extent NN 3093 21 46 that that IN 3093 21 47 they -PRON- PRP 3093 21 48 create create VBP 3093 21 49 selves self NNS 3093 21 50 exchanged exchange VBD 3093 21 51 through through IN 3093 21 52 social social JJ 3093 21 53 networking networking NN 3093 21 54 sites site NNS 3093 21 55 owned own VBN 3093 21 56 by by IN 3093 21 57 capitalist capitalist JJ 3093 21 58 enterprises enterprise NNS 3093 21 59 . . . 3093 22 1 Web web NN 3093 22 2 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 22 3 , , , 3093 22 4 then then RB 3093 22 5 , , , 3093 22 6 has have VBZ 3093 22 7 created create VBN 3093 22 8 a a DT 3093 22 9 situation situation NN 3093 22 10 in in IN 3093 22 11 which which WDT 3093 22 12 personal personal JJ 3093 22 13 time time NN 3093 22 14 and and CC 3093 22 15 identification identification NN 3093 22 16 can can MD 3093 22 17 be be VB 3093 22 18 successfully successfully RB 3093 22 19 commodified commodifie VBN 3093 22 20 . . . 3093 23 1 Baroncelli Baroncelli NNP 3093 23 2 and and CC 3093 23 3 Freitas Freitas NNP 3093 23 4 conclude conclude VBP 3093 23 5 , , , 3093 23 6 “ " `` 3093 23 7 From from IN 3093 23 8 that that DT 3093 23 9 formula formula NN 3093 23 10 , , , 3093 23 11 personal personal JJ 3093 23 12 life life NN 3093 23 13 becomes become VBZ 3093 23 14 a a DT 3093 23 15 capital capital NN 3093 23 16 to to TO 3093 23 17 be be VB 3093 23 18 shared share VBN 3093 23 19 with with IN 3093 23 20 other other JJ 3093 23 21 people people NNS 3093 23 22 — — : 3093 23 23 preferably preferably RB 3093 23 24 , , , 3093 23 25 with with IN 3093 23 26 a a DT 3093 23 27 large large JJ 3093 23 28 audience audience NN 3093 23 29 . . . 3093 23 30 ” " '' 3093 23 31 7 7 CD 3093 23 32 The the DT 3093 23 33 problem problem NN 3093 23 34 , , , 3093 23 35 then then RB 3093 23 36 , , , 3093 23 37 is be VBZ 3093 23 38 that that DT 3093 23 39 one one NN 3093 23 40 ’s ’s POS 3093 23 41 existence existence NN 3093 23 42 is be VBZ 3093 23 43 defined define VBN 3093 23 44 simply simply RB 3093 23 45 “ " `` 3093 23 46 by by IN 3093 23 47 being be VBG 3093 23 48 seen see VBN 3093 23 49 by by IN 3093 23 50 others other NNS 3093 23 51 ” " '' 3093 23 52 and and CC 3093 23 53 can can MD 3093 23 54 no no RB 3093 23 55 longer longer RB 3093 23 56 be be VB 3093 23 57 understood understand VBN 3093 23 58 as as IN 3093 23 59 authentic.8 authentic.8 NNP 3093 23 60 Despite despite IN 3093 23 61 the the DT 3093 23 62 sophistication sophistication NN 3093 23 63 of of IN 3093 23 64 the the DT 3093 23 65 argument argument NN 3093 23 66 detailed detail VBN 3093 23 67 above above RB 3093 23 68 , , , 3093 23 69 there there EX 3093 23 70 are be VBP 3093 23 71 some some DT 3093 23 72 who who WP 3093 23 73 view view VBP 3093 23 74 the the DT 3093 23 75 online online JJ 3093 23 76 self self NN 3093 23 77 , , , 3093 23 78 created create VBN 3093 23 79 through through IN 3093 23 80 Web web NN 3093 23 81 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 23 82 , , , 3093 23 83 as as IN 3093 23 84 a a DT 3093 23 85 legitimate legitimate JJ 3093 23 86 and and CC 3093 23 87 authentic authentic JJ 3093 23 88 identity identity NN 3093 23 89 . . . 3093 24 1 In in IN 3093 24 2 an an DT 3093 24 3 account account NN 3093 24 4 of of IN 3093 24 5 the the DT 3093 24 6 online online JJ 3093 24 7 self self NN 3093 24 8 , , , 3093 24 9 Hongladarom Hongladarom NNP 3093 24 10 summarizes summarize VBZ 3093 24 11 this this DT 3093 24 12 position position NN 3093 24 13 , , , 3093 24 14 noting note VBG 3093 24 15 that that IN 3093 24 16 both both DT 3093 24 17 offline offline JJ 3093 24 18 and and CC 3093 24 19 virtual virtual JJ 3093 24 20 identities identity NNS 3093 24 21 are be VBP 3093 24 22 constructed construct VBN 3093 24 23 in in IN 3093 24 24 social social JJ 3093 24 25 environments environment NNS 3093 24 26 . . . 3093 25 1 9 9 CD 3093 25 2 For for IN 3093 25 3 Hongladarom Hongladarom NNP 3093 25 4 , , , 3093 25 5 these these DT 3093 25 6 identities identity NNS 3093 25 7 are be VBP 3093 25 8 not not RB 3093 25 9 different different JJ 3093 25 10 in in IN 3093 25 11 essence essence NN 3093 25 12 because because IN 3093 25 13 “ " `` 3093 25 14 what what WP 3093 25 15 it -PRON- PRP 3093 25 16 is be VBZ 3093 25 17 to to TO 3093 25 18 be be VB 3093 25 19 a a DT 3093 25 20 person person NN 3093 25 21 . . . 3093 26 1 . . . 3093 27 1 . . . 3093 28 1 is be VBZ 3093 28 2 constituted constitute VBN 3093 28 3 by by IN 3093 28 4 external external JJ 3093 28 5 factors factor NNS 3093 28 6 . . . 3093 28 7 ” " '' 3093 28 8 10 10 CD 3093 28 9 The the DT 3093 28 10 online online JJ 3093 28 11 world world NN 3093 28 12 as as IN 3093 28 13 an an DT 3093 28 14 external external JJ 3093 28 15 factor factor NN 3093 28 16 has have VBZ 3093 28 17 the the DT 3093 28 18 ability ability NN 3093 28 19 to to TO 3093 28 20 affirm affirm VB 3093 28 21 one one PRP 3093 28 22 ’s ’s '' 3093 28 23 existence existence NN 3093 28 24 , , , 3093 28 25 regardless regardless RB 3093 28 26 of of IN 3093 28 27 whether whether IN 3093 28 28 that that DT 3093 28 29 existence existence NN 3093 28 30 is be VBZ 3093 28 31 physical physical JJ 3093 28 32 or or CC 3093 28 33 virtual virtual JJ 3093 28 34 . . . 3093 29 1 In in IN 3093 29 2 sum sum NN 3093 29 3 , , , 3093 29 4 it -PRON- PRP 3093 29 5 is be VBZ 3093 29 6 the the DT 3093 29 7 social social JJ 3093 29 8 other other JJ 3093 29 9 and and CC 3093 29 10 not not RB 3093 29 11 a a DT 3093 29 12 material material JJ 3093 29 13 existence existence NN 3093 29 14 that that WDT 3093 29 15 is be VBZ 3093 29 16 the the DT 3093 29 17 authenticating authenticate VBG 3093 29 18 factor factor NN 3093 29 19 in in IN 3093 29 20 identity identity NN 3093 29 21 formation formation NN 3093 29 22 . . . 3093 30 1 There there EX 3093 30 2 are be VBP 3093 30 3 others other NNS 3093 30 4 who who WP 3093 30 5 validate validate VBP 3093 30 6 the the DT 3093 30 7 role role NN 3093 30 8 that that WDT 3093 30 9 spectacle spectacle NN 3093 30 10 — — : 3093 30 11 or or CC 3093 30 12 what what WP 3093 30 13 also also RB 3093 30 14 can can MD 3093 30 15 be be VB 3093 30 16 understood understand VBN 3093 30 17 as as IN 3093 30 18 performance performance NN 3093 30 19 — — : 3093 30 20 plays play NNS 3093 30 21 in in IN 3093 30 22 identity identity NN 3093 30 23 formation formation NN 3093 30 24 . . . 3093 31 1 Pearson Pearson NNP 3093 31 2 calls call VBZ 3093 31 3 on on IN 3093 31 4 the the DT 3093 31 5 work work NN 3093 31 6 of of IN 3093 31 7 Goffman Goffman NNP 3093 31 8 to to TO 3093 31 9 argue argue VB 3093 31 10 , , , 3093 31 11 “ " `` 3093 31 12 identity identity NN 3093 31 13 - - HYPH 3093 31 14 as as IN 3093 31 15 - - HYPH 3093 31 16 performance performance NN 3093 31 17 is be VBZ 3093 31 18 seen see VBN 3093 31 19 as as IN 3093 31 20 part part NN 3093 31 21 of of IN 3093 31 22 the the DT 3093 31 23 flow flow NN 3093 31 24 of of IN 3093 31 25 social social JJ 3093 31 26 interaction interaction NN 3093 31 27 as as IN 3093 31 28 individuals individual NNS 3093 31 29 construct construct VBP 3093 31 30 identity identity NN 3093 31 31 performances performance NNS 3093 31 32 fitting fit VBG 3093 31 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 31 34 milieu milieu NN 3093 31 35 . . . 3093 31 36 ” " '' 3093 31 37 11 11 CD 3093 31 38 For for IN 3093 31 39 Pearson Pearson NNP 3093 31 40 , , , 3093 31 41 the the DT 3093 31 42 identity identity NN 3093 31 43 is be VBZ 3093 31 44 always always RB 3093 31 45 performed perform VBN 3093 31 46 , , , 3093 31 47 be be VB 3093 31 48 it -PRON- PRP 3093 31 49 through through IN 3093 31 50 Web web NN 3093 31 51 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 31 52 or or CC 3093 31 53 otherwise otherwise RB 3093 31 54 . . . 3093 32 1 There there EX 3093 32 2 is be VBZ 3093 32 3 nothing nothing NN 3093 32 4 particularly particularly RB 3093 32 5 worrisome worrisome JJ 3093 32 6 , , , 3093 32 7 then then RB 3093 32 8 , , , 3093 32 9 about about IN 3093 32 10 the the DT 3093 32 11 effects effect NNS 3093 32 12 of of IN 3093 32 13 Web web NN 3093 32 14 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 32 15 on on IN 3093 32 16 the the DT 3093 32 17 self self NN 3093 32 18 , , , 3093 32 19 nor nor CC 3093 32 20 does do VBZ 3093 32 21 Web web NN 3093 32 22 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 32 23 threaten threaten VB 3093 32 24 the the DT 3093 32 25 authenticity authenticity NN 3093 32 26 of of IN 3093 32 27 the the DT 3093 32 28 self self NN 3093 32 29 . . . 3093 33 1 Identity identity NN 3093 33 2 is be VBZ 3093 33 3 always always RB 3093 33 4 performed perform VBN 3093 33 5 and and CC 3093 33 6 is be VBZ 3093 33 7 in in IN 3093 33 8 a a DT 3093 33 9 sense sense NN 3093 33 10 a a DT 3093 33 11 spectacle spectacle NN 3093 33 12 — — : 3093 33 13 this this DT 3093 33 14 does do VBZ 3093 33 15 not not RB 3093 33 16 mean mean VB 3093 33 17 , , , 3093 33 18 however however RB 3093 33 19 , , , 3093 33 20 that that IN 3093 33 21 identity identity NN 3093 33 22 in in IN 3093 33 23 itself -PRON- PRP 3093 33 24 is be VBZ 3093 33 25 spurious spurious JJ 3093 33 26 . . . 3093 34 1 It -PRON- PRP 3093 34 2 is be VBZ 3093 34 3 with with IN 3093 34 4 this this DT 3093 34 5 perspective perspective NN 3093 34 6 of of IN 3093 34 7 the the DT 3093 34 8 online online JJ 3093 34 9 self self NN 3093 34 10 as as IN 3093 34 11 a a DT 3093 34 12 performed perform VBN 3093 34 13 albeit albeit IN 3093 34 14 authentic authentic JJ 3093 34 15 identity identity NN 3093 34 16 that that WDT 3093 34 17 this this DT 3093 34 18 paper paper NN 3093 34 19 further further RB 3093 34 20 develops develop VBZ 3093 34 21 . . . 3093 35 1 Before before IN 3093 35 2 a a DT 3093 35 3 thorough thorough JJ 3093 35 4 analysis analysis NN 3093 35 5 of of IN 3093 35 6 the the DT 3093 35 7 searchable searchable JJ 3093 35 8 signature signature NN 3093 35 9 as as IN 3093 35 10 an an DT 3093 35 11 online online JJ 3093 35 12 self self NN 3093 35 13 can can MD 3093 35 14 be be VB 3093 35 15 conducted conduct VBN 3093 35 16 , , , 3093 35 17 a a DT 3093 35 18 deeper deep JJR 3093 35 19 understanding understanding NN 3093 35 20 of of IN 3093 35 21 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 35 22 ’s ’s POS 3093 35 23 theory theory NN 3093 35 24 of of IN 3093 35 25 recognition recognition NN 3093 35 26 is be VBZ 3093 35 27 in in IN 3093 35 28 order order NN 3093 35 29 . . . 3093 36 1 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3093 36 2 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3093 36 3 AND and CC 3093 36 4 LIBRARIES library NNS 3093 36 5 | | NNP 3093 36 6 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3093 36 7 2013 2013 CD 3093 36 8 7 7 CD 3093 36 9 In in IN 3093 36 10 his -PRON- PRP$ 3093 36 11 1995 1995 CD 3093 36 12 work work NN 3093 36 13 The the DT 3093 36 14 Struggle Struggle NNP 3093 36 15 for for IN 3093 36 16 Recognition Recognition NNP 3093 36 17 : : : 3093 36 18 The the DT 3093 36 19 Moral Moral NNP 3093 36 20 Grammar Grammar NNP 3093 36 21 of of IN 3093 36 22 Social Social NNP 3093 36 23 Conflicts Conflicts NNPS 3093 36 24 , , , 3093 36 25 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 36 26 sets set VBZ 3093 36 27 out out RP 3093 36 28 to to TO 3093 36 29 develop develop VB 3093 36 30 a a DT 3093 36 31 social social JJ 3093 36 32 theory theory NN 3093 36 33 based base VBN 3093 36 34 on on IN 3093 36 35 what what WP 3093 36 36 he -PRON- PRP 3093 36 37 calls call VBZ 3093 36 38 “ " `` 3093 36 39 morally morally RB 3093 36 40 motivated motivated JJ 3093 36 41 struggle struggle NN 3093 36 42 . . . 3093 36 43 ” " '' 3093 36 44 12 12 CD 3093 36 45 Based base VBN 3093 36 46 on on IN 3093 36 47 the the DT 3093 36 48 Habermasian habermasian JJ 3093 36 49 concept concept NN 3093 36 50 of of IN 3093 36 51 communicative communicative JJ 3093 36 52 action action NN 3093 36 53 , , , 3093 36 54 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 36 55 contends contend VBZ 3093 36 56 that that IN 3093 36 57 it -PRON- PRP 3093 36 58 is be VBZ 3093 36 59 through through IN 3093 36 60 mutual mutual JJ 3093 36 61 recognition recognition NN 3093 36 62 that that IN 3093 36 63 “ " `` 3093 36 64 one one PRP 3093 36 65 can can MD 3093 36 66 develop develop VB 3093 36 67 a a DT 3093 36 68 practical practical JJ 3093 36 69 relation relation NN 3093 36 70 - - HYPH 3093 36 71 to to IN 3093 36 72 - - HYPH 3093 36 73 self self NN 3093 36 74 [ [ -LRB- 3093 36 75 and and CC 3093 36 76 can can MD 3093 36 77 ] ] -RRB- 3093 36 78 view view VB 3093 36 79 oneself oneself PRP 3093 36 80 from from IN 3093 36 81 the the DT 3093 36 82 normative normative JJ 3093 36 83 perspective perspective NN 3093 36 84 of of IN 3093 36 85 one one NN 3093 36 86 ’s ’s POS 3093 36 87 partners partner NNS 3093 36 88 in in IN 3093 36 89 interaction interaction NN 3093 36 90 , , , 3093 36 91 as as IN 3093 36 92 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 36 93 social social JJ 3093 36 94 addressee addressee NN 3093 36 95 . . . 3093 36 96 ” " '' 3093 36 97 13 13 CD 3093 36 98 Relation relation NN 3093 36 99 - - HYPH 3093 36 100 to- to- NN 3093 36 101 self self NN 3093 36 102 is be VBZ 3093 36 103 key key JJ 3093 36 104 for for IN 3093 36 105 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 36 106 , , , 3093 36 107 and and CC 3093 36 108 he -PRON- PRP 3093 36 109 argues argue VBZ 3093 36 110 that that IN 3093 36 111 a a DT 3093 36 112 healthy healthy JJ 3093 36 113 relation relation NN 3093 36 114 - - HYPH 3093 36 115 to to IN 3093 36 116 - - HYPH 3093 36 117 self self NN 3093 36 118 , , , 3093 36 119 or or CC 3093 36 120 what what WP 3093 36 121 can can MD 3093 36 122 be be VB 3093 36 123 thought think VBN 3093 36 124 of of IN 3093 36 125 as as IN 3093 36 126 self self NN 3093 36 127 - - HYPH 3093 36 128 esteem esteem NN 3093 36 129 , , , 3093 36 130 is be VBZ 3093 36 131 developed develop VBN 3093 36 132 when when WRB 3093 36 133 one one PRP 3093 36 134 is be VBZ 3093 36 135 seen see VBN 3093 36 136 as as IN 3093 36 137 valuable valuable JJ 3093 36 138 by by IN 3093 36 139 others other NNS 3093 36 140 . . . 3093 37 1 Beyond beyond IN 3093 37 2 self self NN 3093 37 3 - - HYPH 3093 37 4 esteem esteem NN 3093 37 5 , , , 3093 37 6 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 37 7 points point VBZ 3093 37 8 that that IN 3093 37 9 the the DT 3093 37 10 success success NN 3093 37 11 of of IN 3093 37 12 social social JJ 3093 37 13 life life NN 3093 37 14 itself -PRON- PRP 3093 37 15 depends depend VBZ 3093 37 16 on on IN 3093 37 17 “ " `` 3093 37 18 symmetrical symmetrical JJ 3093 37 19 esteem esteem NN 3093 37 20 between between IN 3093 37 21 individualized individualized JJ 3093 37 22 ( ( -LRB- 3093 37 23 and and CC 3093 37 24 autonomous autonomous JJ 3093 37 25 ) ) -RRB- 3093 37 26 subjects subject NNS 3093 37 27 . . . 3093 37 28 ” " '' 3093 37 29 14 14 CD 3093 37 30 For for IN 3093 37 31 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 37 32 , , , 3093 37 33 this this DT 3093 37 34 “ " `` 3093 37 35 symmetrical symmetrical JJ 3093 37 36 esteem esteem NN 3093 37 37 ” " '' 3093 37 38 can can MD 3093 37 39 lead lead VB 3093 37 40 to to IN 3093 37 41 solidarity solidarity NN 3093 37 42 between between IN 3093 37 43 individuals individual NNS 3093 37 44 . . . 3093 38 1 “ " `` 3093 38 2 Relationships relationship NNS 3093 38 3 of of IN 3093 38 4 this this DT 3093 38 5 sort sort NN 3093 38 6 , , , 3093 38 7 ” " '' 3093 38 8 he -PRON- PRP 3093 38 9 explains explain VBZ 3093 38 10 , , , 3093 38 11 “ " `` 3093 38 12 can can MD 3093 38 13 be be VB 3093 38 14 said say VBN 3093 38 15 to to TO 3093 38 16 be be VB 3093 38 17 cases case NNS 3093 38 18 of of IN 3093 38 19 ‘ ' `` 3093 38 20 solidarity solidarity NN 3093 38 21 ’ ' '' 3093 38 22 because because IN 3093 38 23 they -PRON- PRP 3093 38 24 inspire inspire VBP 3093 38 25 not not RB 3093 38 26 just just RB 3093 38 27 passive passive JJ 3093 38 28 tolerance tolerance NN 3093 38 29 but but CC 3093 38 30 felt feel VBD 3093 38 31 concern concern NN 3093 38 32 for for IN 3093 38 33 what what WP 3093 38 34 is be VBZ 3093 38 35 individual individual JJ 3093 38 36 and and CC 3093 38 37 particular particular JJ 3093 38 38 about about IN 3093 38 39 the the DT 3093 38 40 other other JJ 3093 38 41 person person NN 3093 38 42 . . . 3093 38 43 ” " '' 3093 38 44 15 15 CD 3093 38 45 That that DT 3093 38 46 is be VBZ 3093 38 47 to to TO 3093 38 48 say say VB 3093 38 49 that that DT 3093 38 50 felt feel VBD 3093 38 51 concern concern NN 3093 38 52 for for IN 3093 38 53 another another DT 3093 38 54 allows allow VBZ 3093 38 55 one one PRP 3093 38 56 to to TO 3093 38 57 see see VB 3093 38 58 the the DT 3093 38 59 specific specific JJ 3093 38 60 traits trait NNS 3093 38 61 of of IN 3093 38 62 the the DT 3093 38 63 other other JJ 3093 38 64 as as IN 3093 38 65 valuable valuable JJ 3093 38 66 in in IN 3093 38 67 working work VBG 3093 38 68 towards towards IN 3093 38 69 common common JJ 3093 38 70 goals goal NNS 3093 38 71 , , , 3093 38 72 and and CC 3093 38 73 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 38 74 imagines imagine VBZ 3093 38 75 that that IN 3093 38 76 in in IN 3093 38 77 situations situation NNS 3093 38 78 of of IN 3093 38 79 “ " `` 3093 38 80 symmetrical symmetrical JJ 3093 38 81 esteem esteem NN 3093 38 82 . . . 3093 39 1 . . . 3093 40 1 . . . 3093 41 1 every every DT 3093 41 2 subject subject NN 3093 41 3 is be VBZ 3093 41 4 free free JJ 3093 41 5 from from IN 3093 41 6 being be VBG 3093 41 7 collectively collectively RB 3093 41 8 denigrated denigrate VBN 3093 41 9 , , , 3093 41 10 so so IN 3093 41 11 that that IN 3093 41 12 one one NN 3093 41 13 is be VBZ 3093 41 14 given give VBN 3093 41 15 the the DT 3093 41 16 chance chance NN 3093 41 17 to to TO 3093 41 18 experience experience VB 3093 41 19 oneself oneself PRP 3093 41 20 to to TO 3093 41 21 be be VB 3093 41 22 recognized recognize VBN 3093 41 23 , , , 3093 41 24 in in IN 3093 41 25 light light NN 3093 41 26 of of IN 3093 41 27 one one PRP 3093 41 28 ’s ’s POS 3093 41 29 own own JJ 3093 41 30 accomplishments accomplishment NNS 3093 41 31 and and CC 3093 41 32 abilities ability NNS 3093 41 33 , , , 3093 41 34 as as IN 3093 41 35 valuable valuable JJ 3093 41 36 for for IN 3093 41 37 society society NN 3093 41 38 . . . 3093 41 39 ” " '' 3093 41 40 16 16 CD 3093 41 41 Until until IN 3093 41 42 this this DT 3093 41 43 ideal ideal NN 3093 41 44 is be VBZ 3093 41 45 realized realize VBN 3093 41 46 , , , 3093 41 47 however however RB 3093 41 48 , , , 3093 41 49 individuals individual NNS 3093 41 50 must must MD 3093 41 51 find find VB 3093 41 52 sites site NNS 3093 41 53 in in IN 3093 41 54 which which WDT 3093 41 55 to to TO 3093 41 56 struggle struggle VB 3093 41 57 to to TO 3093 41 58 be be VB 3093 41 59 recognized recognize VBN 3093 41 60 as as IN 3093 41 61 valuable valuable JJ 3093 41 62 social social JJ 3093 41 63 assets asset NNS 3093 41 64 . . . 3093 42 1 According accord VBG 3093 42 2 to to IN 3093 42 3 Baroncelli Baroncelli NNP 3093 42 4 and and CC 3093 42 5 Freitas Freitas NNP 3093 42 6 , , , 3093 42 7 it -PRON- PRP 3093 42 8 is be VBZ 3093 42 9 in in IN 3093 42 10 fact fact NN 3093 42 11 Web web NN 3093 42 12 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 42 13 that that WDT 3093 42 14 provides provide VBZ 3093 42 15 the the DT 3093 42 16 arena arena NN 3093 42 17 where where WRB 3093 42 18 “ " `` 3093 42 19 the the DT 3093 42 20 contemporary contemporary JJ 3093 42 21 demand demand NN 3093 42 22 for for IN 3093 42 23 the the DT 3093 42 24 visibility visibility NN 3093 42 25 of of IN 3093 42 26 the the DT 3093 42 27 self self NN 3093 42 28 ” " '' 3093 42 29 is be VBZ 3093 42 30 able able JJ 3093 42 31 to to TO 3093 42 32 flourish flourish VB 3093 42 33 . . . 3093 43 1 17 17 CD 3093 43 2 They -PRON- PRP 3093 43 3 position position VBP 3093 43 4 this this DT 3093 43 5 argument argument NN 3093 43 6 within within IN 3093 43 7 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 43 8 ’s ’s POS 3093 43 9 framework framework NN 3093 43 10 , , , 3093 43 11 asserting assert VBG 3093 43 12 that that IN 3093 43 13 the the DT 3093 43 14 visibility visibility NN 3093 43 15 of of IN 3093 43 16 self self NN 3093 43 17 is be VBZ 3093 43 18 “ " `` 3093 43 19 directed direct VBN 3093 43 20 towards towards IN 3093 43 21 a a DT 3093 43 22 quest quest NN 3093 43 23 for for IN 3093 43 24 recognition recognition NN 3093 43 25 , , , 3093 43 26 ” " '' 3093 43 27 and and CC 3093 43 28 they -PRON- PRP 3093 43 29 thus thus RB 3093 43 30 conclude conclude VBP 3093 43 31 that that IN 3093 43 32 Web web NN 3093 43 33 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 43 34 can can MD 3093 43 35 be be VB 3093 43 36 understood understand VBN 3093 43 37 as as IN 3093 43 38 a a DT 3093 43 39 “ " `` 3093 43 40 recognition recognition NN 3093 43 41 market market NN 3093 43 42 . . . 3093 43 43 ” " '' 3093 43 44 18 18 CD 3093 43 45 Context Context NNP 3093 43 46 and and CC 3093 43 47 Its -PRON- PRP$ 3093 43 48 Importance Importance NNP 3093 43 49 Capturing capturing NN 3093 43 50 and and CC 3093 43 51 integrating integrate VBG 3093 43 52 markers marker NNS 3093 43 53 of of IN 3093 43 54 context context NN 3093 43 55 into into IN 3093 43 56 records record NNS 3093 43 57 , , , 3093 43 58 according accord VBG 3093 43 59 to to IN 3093 43 60 Chowdhury Chowdhury NNP 3093 43 61 , , , 3093 43 62 still still RB 3093 43 63 present present VB 3093 43 64 a a DT 3093 43 65 challenge challenge NN 3093 43 66 for for IN 3093 43 67 many.19 many.19 NNP 3093 43 68 “ " `` 3093 43 69 There there EX 3093 43 70 is be VBZ 3093 43 71 now now RB 3093 43 72 a a DT 3093 43 73 general general JJ 3093 43 74 consensus consensus NN 3093 43 75 that that WDT 3093 43 76 the the DT 3093 43 77 major major JJ 3093 43 78 challenge challenge NN 3093 43 79 facing face VBG 3093 43 80 a a DT 3093 43 81 digital digital JJ 3093 43 82 library library NN 3093 43 83 as as RB 3093 43 84 well well RB 3093 43 85 as as IN 3093 43 86 a a DT 3093 43 87 digital digital JJ 3093 43 88 preservation preservation NN 3093 43 89 program program NN 3093 43 90 is be VBZ 3093 43 91 that that IN 3093 43 92 it -PRON- PRP 3093 43 93 must must MD 3093 43 94 describe describe VB 3093 43 95 its -PRON- PRP$ 3093 43 96 content content NN 3093 43 97 as as RB 3093 43 98 well well RB 3093 43 99 as as IN 3093 43 100 the the DT 3093 43 101 context context NN 3093 43 102 sufficiently sufficiently RB 3093 43 103 well well RB 3093 43 104 to to TO 3093 43 105 allow allow VB 3093 43 106 its -PRON- PRP$ 3093 43 107 correct correct JJ 3093 43 108 interpretation interpretation NN 3093 43 109 by by IN 3093 43 110 the the DT 3093 43 111 current current JJ 3093 43 112 and and CC 3093 43 113 future future JJ 3093 43 114 generations generation NNS 3093 43 115 of of IN 3093 43 116 users user NNS 3093 43 117 , , , 3093 43 118 ” " '' 3093 43 119 he -PRON- PRP 3093 43 120 contends.20 contends.20 NNP 3093 43 121 Context Context NNP 3093 43 122 in in IN 3093 43 123 itself -PRON- PRP 3093 43 124 is be VBZ 3093 43 125 difficult difficult JJ 3093 43 126 to to TO 3093 43 127 define define VB 3093 43 128 , , , 3093 43 129 let let VB 3093 43 130 alone alone RB 3093 43 131 its -PRON- PRP$ 3093 43 132 myriad myriad JJ 3093 43 133 facets facet NNS 3093 43 134 that that WDT 3093 43 135 might may MD 3093 43 136 or or CC 3093 43 137 might may MD 3093 43 138 not not RB 3093 43 139 facilitate facilitate VB 3093 43 140 better well JJR 3093 43 141 understanding understanding NN 3093 43 142 of of IN 3093 43 143 digital digital JJ 3093 43 144 objects object NNS 3093 43 145 . . . 3093 44 1 Dervin Dervin NNP 3093 44 2 , , , 3093 44 3 in in IN 3093 44 4 her -PRON- PRP$ 3093 44 5 exploration exploration NN 3093 44 6 of of IN 3093 44 7 the the DT 3093 44 8 meaning meaning NN 3093 44 9 of of IN 3093 44 10 context context NN 3093 44 11 , , , 3093 44 12 points point VBZ 3093 44 13 that that IN 3093 44 14 it -PRON- PRP 3093 44 15 is be VBZ 3093 44 16 often often RB 3093 44 17 conceptualized conceptualize VBN 3093 44 18 as as IN 3093 44 19 the the DT 3093 44 20 “ " `` 3093 44 21 container container NN 3093 44 22 in in IN 3093 44 23 which which WDT 3093 44 24 the the DT 3093 44 25 phenomenon phenomenon NN 3093 44 26 resides reside VBZ 3093 44 27 . . . 3093 44 28 ” " '' 3093 44 29 21 21 CD 3093 44 30 She -PRON- PRP 3093 44 31 points point VBZ 3093 44 32 that that IN 3093 44 33 the the DT 3093 44 34 list list NN 3093 44 35 of of IN 3093 44 36 factors factor NNS 3093 44 37 that that WDT 3093 44 38 constitute constitute VBP 3093 44 39 the the DT 3093 44 40 container container NN 3093 44 41 and and CC 3093 44 42 might may MD 3093 44 43 be be VB 3093 44 44 considered consider VBN 3093 44 45 contextual contextual JJ 3093 44 46 is be VBZ 3093 44 47 in in IN 3093 44 48 fact fact NN 3093 44 49 “ " `` 3093 44 50 inexhaustible”—items inexhaustible”—item NNS 3093 44 51 on on IN 3093 44 52 this this DT 3093 44 53 list list NN 3093 44 54 , , , 3093 44 55 for for IN 3093 44 56 example example NN 3093 44 57 , , , 3093 44 58 might may MD 3093 44 59 include include VB 3093 44 60 the the DT 3093 44 61 gender gender NN 3093 44 62 , , , 3093 44 63 race race NN 3093 44 64 , , , 3093 44 65 and and CC 3093 44 66 ethnicity ethnicity NN 3093 44 67 of of IN 3093 44 68 those those DT 3093 44 69 involved involve VBN 3093 44 70 in in IN 3093 44 71 a a DT 3093 44 72 phenomenon phenomenon NN 3093 44 73 . . . 3093 45 1 22 22 CD 3093 45 2 In in IN 3093 45 3 an an DT 3093 45 4 indexing indexing NN 3093 45 5 or or CC 3093 45 6 digital digital JJ 3093 45 7 collection collection NN 3093 45 8 environment environment NN 3093 45 9 , , , 3093 45 10 the the DT 3093 45 11 goal goal NN 3093 45 12 is be VBZ 3093 45 13 to to TO 3093 45 14 determine determine VB 3093 45 15 which which WDT 3093 45 16 of of IN 3093 45 17 these these DT 3093 45 18 many many JJ 3093 45 19 factors factor NNS 3093 45 20 ought ought MD 3093 45 21 be be VB 3093 45 22 included include VBN 3093 45 23 in in IN 3093 45 24 a a DT 3093 45 25 record record NN 3093 45 26 to to TO 3093 45 27 best best RB 3093 45 28 allow allow VB 3093 45 29 for for IN 3093 45 30 discovery discovery NN 3093 45 31 and and CC 3093 45 32 use use NN 3093 45 33 . . . 3093 46 1 SEARCHABLE SEARCHABLE NNP 3093 46 2 SIGNATURES SIGNATURES NNP 3093 46 3 : : : 3093 46 4 CONTEXT context NN 3093 46 5 AND and CC 3093 46 6 THE the DT 3093 46 7 STRUGGLE struggle NN 3093 46 8 FOR for IN 3093 46 9 RECOGNITION RECOGNITION NNP 3093 46 10 | | CD 3093 46 11 SCHLESSELMAN schlesselman NN 3093 46 12 - - HYPH 3093 46 13 TARANGO TARANGO NNP 3093 46 14 8 8 CD 3093 46 15 Others other NNS 3093 46 16 imagine imagine VBP 3093 46 17 context context NN 3093 46 18 as as IN 3093 46 19 a a DT 3093 46 20 fluid fluid NN 3093 46 21 , , , 3093 46 22 ever ever RB 3093 46 23 - - HYPH 3093 46 24 changing change VBG 3093 46 25 process process NN 3093 46 26 rather rather RB 3093 46 27 than than IN 3093 46 28 as as IN 3093 46 29 a a DT 3093 46 30 static static JJ 3093 46 31 container container NN 3093 46 32 of of IN 3093 46 33 data datum NNS 3093 46 34 . . . 3093 47 1 “ " `` 3093 47 2 In in IN 3093 47 3 this this DT 3093 47 4 framework framework NN 3093 47 5 , , , 3093 47 6 ” " '' 3093 47 7 Dervin Dervin NNP 3093 47 8 writes write VBZ 3093 47 9 , , , 3093 47 10 “ " `` 3093 47 11 reality reality NN 3093 47 12 is be VBZ 3093 47 13 in in IN 3093 47 14 a a DT 3093 47 15 continuous continuous JJ 3093 47 16 and and CC 3093 47 17 always always RB 3093 47 18 incomplete incomplete JJ 3093 47 19 process process NN 3093 47 20 of of IN 3093 47 21 becoming become VBG 3093 47 22 . . . 3093 47 23 ” " '' 3093 47 24 23 23 CD 3093 47 25 This this DT 3093 47 26 understanding understanding NN 3093 47 27 of of IN 3093 47 28 context context NN 3093 47 29 as as IN 3093 47 30 changing change VBG 3093 47 31 is be VBZ 3093 47 32 helpful helpful JJ 3093 47 33 for for IN 3093 47 34 those those DT 3093 47 35 working work VBG 3093 47 36 with with IN 3093 47 37 objects object NNS 3093 47 38 that that WDT 3093 47 39 live live VBP 3093 47 40 in in IN 3093 47 41 digital digital JJ 3093 47 42 environments environment NNS 3093 47 43 , , , 3093 47 44 especially especially RB 3093 47 45 Web Web VBD 3093 47 46 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 47 47 . . . 3093 48 1 Certainly certainly RB 3093 48 2 the the DT 3093 48 3 interactive interactive JJ 3093 48 4 nature nature NN 3093 48 5 of of IN 3093 48 6 the the DT 3093 48 7 web web NN 3093 48 8 has have VBZ 3093 48 9 created create VBN 3093 48 10 room room NN 3093 48 11 for for IN 3093 48 12 a a DT 3093 48 13 variety variety NN 3093 48 14 of of IN 3093 48 15 users user NNS 3093 48 16 to to TO 3093 48 17 create create VB 3093 48 18 , , , 3093 48 19 share share VB 3093 48 20 , , , 3093 48 21 appropriate appropriate JJ 3093 48 22 , , , 3093 48 23 comment comment VB 3093 48 24 on on IN 3093 48 25 , , , 3093 48 26 tag tag NN 3093 48 27 , , , 3093 48 28 reject reject VBP 3093 48 29 , , , 3093 48 30 celebrate celebrate VBP 3093 48 31 , , , 3093 48 32 and and CC 3093 48 33 ultimately ultimately RB 3093 48 34 understand understand VBP 3093 48 35 images image NNS 3093 48 36 in in IN 3093 48 37 a a DT 3093 48 38 multitude multitude NN 3093 48 39 of of IN 3093 48 40 contexts contexts NN 3093 48 41 that that WDT 3093 48 42 might may MD 3093 48 43 be be VB 3093 48 44 different different JJ 3093 48 45 from from IN 3093 48 46 one one CD 3093 48 47 moment moment NN 3093 48 48 to to IN 3093 48 49 the the DT 3093 48 50 next next JJ 3093 48 51 . . . 3093 49 1 There there EX 3093 49 2 are be VBP 3093 49 3 many many JJ 3093 49 4 reasons reason NNS 3093 49 5 to to TO 3093 49 6 include include VB 3093 49 7 contextual contextual JJ 3093 49 8 information information NN 3093 49 9 in in IN 3093 49 10 records record NNS 3093 49 11 of of IN 3093 49 12 digital digital JJ 3093 49 13 objects object NNS 3093 49 14 . . . 3093 50 1 Lee Lee NNP 3093 50 2 argues argue VBZ 3093 50 3 that that IN 3093 50 4 by by IN 3093 50 5 providing provide VBG 3093 50 6 context context NN 3093 50 7 , , , 3093 50 8 or or CC 3093 50 9 what what WP 3093 50 10 he -PRON- PRP 3093 50 11 describes describe VBZ 3093 50 12 as as IN 3093 50 13 the the DT 3093 50 14 “ " `` 3093 50 15 social social JJ 3093 50 16 and and CC 3093 50 17 documentary documentary JJ 3093 50 18 ” " '' 3093 50 19 world world NN 3093 50 20 “ " '' 3093 50 21 in in IN 3093 50 22 which which WDT 3093 50 23 [ [ -LRB- 3093 50 24 a a DT 3093 50 25 digital digital JJ 3093 50 26 object object NN 3093 50 27 ] ] -RRB- 3093 50 28 is be VBZ 3093 50 29 embedded embed VBN 3093 50 30 , , , 3093 50 31 ” " '' 3093 50 32 future future JJ 3093 50 33 users user NNS 3093 50 34 will will MD 3093 50 35 be be VB 3093 50 36 able able JJ 3093 50 37 to to TO 3093 50 38 better well RBR 3093 50 39 understand understand VB 3093 50 40 the the DT 3093 50 41 “ " `` 3093 50 42 details detail NNS 3093 50 43 of of IN 3093 50 44 our -PRON- PRP$ 3093 50 45 current current JJ 3093 50 46 lives life NNS 3093 50 47 . . . 3093 50 48 ” " '' 3093 50 49 24 24 CD 3093 50 50 Further further RB 3093 50 51 , , , 3093 50 52 Lee Lee NNP 3093 50 53 contends contend VBZ 3093 50 54 that that IN 3093 50 55 context context NN 3093 50 56 is be VBZ 3093 50 57 helpful helpful JJ 3093 50 58 in in IN 3093 50 59 that that DT 3093 50 60 is is RB 3093 50 61 illustrates illustrate VBZ 3093 50 62 the the DT 3093 50 63 ways way NNS 3093 50 64 in in IN 3093 50 65 which which WDT 3093 50 66 a a DT 3093 50 67 digital digital JJ 3093 50 68 object object NN 3093 50 69 is be VBZ 3093 50 70 related relate VBN 3093 50 71 to to IN 3093 50 72 other other JJ 3093 50 73 materials material NNS 3093 50 74 : : : 3093 50 75 Relationships relationship NNS 3093 50 76 to to IN 3093 50 77 other other JJ 3093 50 78 digital digital JJ 3093 50 79 objects object NNS 3093 50 80 can can MD 3093 50 81 dramatically dramatically RB 3093 50 82 affect affect VB 3093 50 83 the the DT 3093 50 84 ways way NNS 3093 50 85 in in IN 3093 50 86 which which WDT 3093 50 87 digital digital JJ 3093 50 88 objects object NNS 3093 50 89 have have VBP 3093 50 90 been be VBN 3093 50 91 perceived perceive VBN 3093 50 92 and and CC 3093 50 93 experienced experience VBN 3093 50 94 . . . 3093 51 1 In in IN 3093 51 2 order order NN 3093 51 3 for for IN 3093 51 4 a a DT 3093 51 5 future future JJ 3093 51 6 user user NN 3093 51 7 to to TO 3093 51 8 make make VB 3093 51 9 sense sense NN 3093 51 10 of of IN 3093 51 11 a a DT 3093 51 12 digital digital JJ 3093 51 13 object object NN 3093 51 14 , , , 3093 51 15 it -PRON- PRP 3093 51 16 could could MD 3093 51 17 be be VB 3093 51 18 useful useful JJ 3093 51 19 for for IN 3093 51 20 that that DT 3093 51 21 user user NN 3093 51 22 to to TO 3093 51 23 know know VB 3093 51 24 precisely precisely RB 3093 51 25 what what WP 3093 51 26 set set NN 3093 51 27 of of IN 3093 51 28 . . . 3093 52 1 . . . 3093 53 1 . . . 3093 54 1 representations representation NNS 3093 54 2 — — : 3093 54 3 e.g e.g NNP 3093 54 4 . . . 3093 55 1 titles title NNS 3093 55 2 , , , 3093 55 3 tags tag NNS 3093 55 4 , , , 3093 55 5 captions caption NNS 3093 55 6 , , , 3093 55 7 annotations annotation NNS 3093 55 8 , , , 3093 55 9 image image NN 3093 55 10 thumbnails thumbnail NNS 3093 55 11 , , , 3093 55 12 video video NN 3093 55 13 keyframes keyframes NNPS 3093 55 14 — — : 3093 55 15 were be VBD 3093 55 16 associated associate VBN 3093 55 17 with with IN 3093 55 18 a a DT 3093 55 19 digital digital JJ 3093 55 20 object object NN 3093 55 21 at at IN 3093 55 22 a a DT 3093 55 23 given give VBN 3093 55 24 point point NN 3093 55 25 in in IN 3093 55 26 time time NN 3093 55 27 . . . 3093 56 1 25 25 CD 3093 56 2 The the DT 3093 56 3 user user NN 3093 56 4 - - HYPH 3093 56 5 generated generate VBN 3093 56 6 tag tag NN 3093 56 7 , , , 3093 56 8 then then RB 3093 56 9 , , , 3093 56 10 is be VBZ 3093 56 11 a a DT 3093 56 12 valuable valuable JJ 3093 56 13 representation representation NN 3093 56 14 that that WDT 3093 56 15 provides provide VBZ 3093 56 16 contextual contextual JJ 3093 56 17 information information NN 3093 56 18 surrounding surround VBG 3093 56 19 the the DT 3093 56 20 perception perception NN 3093 56 21 and and CC 3093 56 22 experience experience NN 3093 56 23 of of IN 3093 56 24 the the DT 3093 56 25 image image NN 3093 56 26 with with IN 3093 56 27 which which WDT 3093 56 28 it -PRON- PRP 3093 56 29 is be VBZ 3093 56 30 directly directly RB 3093 56 31 related relate VBN 3093 56 32 . . . 3093 57 1 DISCUSSION DISCUSSION NNP 3093 57 2 User User NNP 3093 57 3 - - HYPH 3093 57 4 Generated Generated NNP 3093 57 5 Tags Tags NNP 3093 57 6 and and CC 3093 57 7 Traditional Traditional NNP 3093 57 8 Metadata Metadata NNP 3093 57 9 User User NNP 3093 57 10 - - HYPH 3093 57 11 generated generate VBN 3093 57 12 tags tag NNS 3093 57 13 have have VBP 3093 57 14 been be VBN 3093 57 15 hailed hail VBN 3093 57 16 as as IN 3093 57 17 an an DT 3093 57 18 important important JJ 3093 57 19 stage stage NN 3093 57 20 in in IN 3093 57 21 the the DT 3093 57 22 evolution evolution NN 3093 57 23 of of IN 3093 57 24 image image NN 3093 57 25 description description NN 3093 57 26 and and CC 3093 57 27 are be VBP 3093 57 28 said say VBN 3093 57 29 to to TO 3093 57 30 have have VB 3093 57 31 the the DT 3093 57 32 potential potential NN 3093 57 33 to to TO 3093 57 34 shape shape VB 3093 57 35 controlled control VBN 3093 57 36 vocabularies vocabulary NNS 3093 57 37 used use VBN 3093 57 38 in in IN 3093 57 39 traditional traditional JJ 3093 57 40 metadata metadata NN 3093 57 41 schemas schema NNS 3093 57 42 . . . 3093 58 1 For for IN 3093 58 2 example example NN 3093 58 3 , , , 3093 58 4 in in IN 3093 58 5 a a DT 3093 58 6 comparison comparison NN 3093 58 7 of of IN 3093 58 8 Flickr Flickr NNP 3093 58 9 tags tag NNS 3093 58 10 and and CC 3093 58 11 index index NN 3093 58 12 terms term NNS 3093 58 13 from from IN 3093 58 14 the the DT 3093 58 15 University University NNP 3093 58 16 of of IN 3093 58 17 St. St. NNP 3093 58 18 Andrews Andrews NNP 3093 58 19 Library Library NNP 3093 58 20 Photographic Photographic NNP 3093 58 21 Archive Archive NNP 3093 58 22 , , , 3093 58 23 Rorissa Rorissa NNP 3093 58 24 stresses stress VBZ 3093 58 25 the the DT 3093 58 26 importance importance NN 3093 58 27 of of IN 3093 58 28 exploring explore VBG 3093 58 29 similarities similarity NNS 3093 58 30 and and CC 3093 58 31 differences difference NNS 3093 58 32 between between IN 3093 58 33 indexers indexer NNS 3093 58 34 ’ ' '' 3093 58 35 and and CC 3093 58 36 users user NNS 3093 58 37 ’ ’ POS 3093 58 38 language language NN 3093 58 39 , , , 3093 58 40 noting note VBG 3093 58 41 that that IN 3093 58 42 “ " `` 3093 58 43 social social JJ 3093 58 44 tagging tagging NN 3093 58 45 could could MD 3093 58 46 serve serve VB 3093 58 47 as as IN 3093 58 48 a a DT 3093 58 49 platform platform NN 3093 58 50 on on IN 3093 58 51 which which WDT 3093 58 52 to to TO 3093 58 53 build build VB 3093 58 54 future future JJ 3093 58 55 indexing indexing NN 3093 58 56 systems system NNS 3093 58 57 . . . 3093 58 58 ” " '' 3093 58 59 26 26 CD 3093 58 60 Like like IN 3093 58 61 others other NNS 3093 58 62 , , , 3093 58 63 Rorissa Rorissa NNP 3093 58 64 hopes hope VBZ 3093 58 65 that that IN 3093 58 66 continued continue VBD 3093 58 67 research research NN 3093 58 68 into into IN 3093 58 69 user user NN 3093 58 70 - - HYPH 3093 58 71 generated generate VBN 3093 58 72 social social JJ 3093 58 73 tags tag NNS 3093 58 74 will will MD 3093 58 75 be be VB 3093 58 76 able able JJ 3093 58 77 to to TO 3093 58 78 “ " `` 3093 58 79 bridge bridge VB 3093 58 80 the the DT 3093 58 81 semantic semantic JJ 3093 58 82 gap gap NN 3093 58 83 between between IN 3093 58 84 indexer- indexer- JJ 3093 58 85 assigned assigned JJ 3093 58 86 terms term NNS 3093 58 87 and and CC 3093 58 88 users user NNS 3093 58 89 ’ ’ POS 3093 58 90 search search NN 3093 58 91 language language NN 3093 58 92 . . . 3093 58 93 ” " '' 3093 58 94 27 27 CD 3093 58 95 In in IN 3093 58 96 fact fact NN 3093 58 97 , , , 3093 58 98 some some DT 3093 58 99 are be VBP 3093 58 100 currently currently RB 3093 58 101 utilizing utilize VBG 3093 58 102 social social JJ 3093 58 103 tags tag NNS 3093 58 104 in in IN 3093 58 105 an an DT 3093 58 106 effort effort NN 3093 58 107 to to TO 3093 58 108 describe describe VB 3093 58 109 and and CC 3093 58 110 facilitate facilitate VB 3093 58 111 access access NN 3093 58 112 to to IN 3093 58 113 collections collection NNS 3093 58 114 . . . 3093 59 1 One one CD 3093 59 2 such such JJ 3093 59 3 organization organization NN 3093 59 4 is be VBZ 3093 59 5 Steve Steve NNP 3093 59 6 : : : 3093 59 7 The the DT 3093 59 8 Museum Museum NNP 3093 59 9 Social Social NNP 3093 59 10 Tagging Tagging NNP 3093 59 11 Project Project NNP 3093 59 12 , , , 3093 59 13 “ " `` 3093 59 14 a a DT 3093 59 15 place place NN 3093 59 16 where where WRB 3093 59 17 you -PRON- PRP 3093 59 18 can can MD 3093 59 19 help help VB 3093 59 20 museums museum NNS 3093 59 21 describe describe VB 3093 59 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 59 23 collections collection NNS 3093 59 24 by by IN 3093 59 25 applying apply VBG 3093 59 26 keywords keyword NNS 3093 59 27 , , , 3093 59 28 or or CC 3093 59 29 tags tag NNS 3093 59 30 , , , 3093 59 31 to to IN 3093 59 32 objects object NNS 3093 59 33 . . . 3093 59 34 ” " '' 3093 59 35 28 28 CD 3093 59 36 The the DT 3093 59 37 organization organization NN 3093 59 38 allows allow VBZ 3093 59 39 users user NNS 3093 59 40 to to TO 3093 59 41 not not RB 3093 59 42 only only RB 3093 59 43 view view VB 3093 59 44 traditional traditional JJ 3093 59 45 metadata metadata NN 3093 59 46 associated associate VBN 3093 59 47 with with IN 3093 59 48 cultural cultural JJ 3093 59 49 objects object NNS 3093 59 50 , , , 3093 59 51 but but CC 3093 59 52 also also RB 3093 59 53 tags tag VBZ 3093 59 54 generated generate VBN 3093 59 55 by by IN 3093 59 56 others other NNS 3093 59 57 . . . 3093 60 1 In in IN 3093 60 2 an an DT 3093 60 3 effort effort NN 3093 60 4 to to TO 3093 60 5 better better RB 3093 60 6 understand understand VB 3093 60 7 the the DT 3093 60 8 similarities similarity NNS 3093 60 9 and and CC 3093 60 10 differences difference NNS 3093 60 11 between between IN 3093 60 12 user user NN 3093 60 13 - - HYPH 3093 60 14 generated generate VBN 3093 60 15 tags tag NNS 3093 60 16 and and CC 3093 60 17 the the DT 3093 60 18 language language NN 3093 60 19 used use VBN 3093 60 20 in in IN 3093 60 21 traditional traditional JJ 3093 60 22 metadata metadata NN 3093 60 23 schemas schema NNS 3093 60 24 , , , 3093 60 25 one one PRP 3093 60 26 must must MD 3093 60 27 compare compare VB 3093 60 28 the the DT 3093 60 29 two two CD 3093 60 30 systems system NNS 3093 60 31 . . . 3093 61 1 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3093 61 2 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3093 61 3 AND and CC 3093 61 4 LIBRARIES library NNS 3093 61 5 | | NNP 3093 61 6 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3093 61 7 2013 2013 CD 3093 61 8 9 9 CD 3093 61 9 Yale Yale NNP 3093 61 10 University University NNP 3093 61 11 ’s ’s POS 3093 61 12 Digital Digital NNP 3093 61 13 Images Images NNP 3093 61 14 Database Database NNP 3093 61 15 provides provide VBZ 3093 61 16 a a DT 3093 61 17 glimpse glimpse NN 3093 61 18 at at IN 3093 61 19 the the DT 3093 61 20 ways way NNS 3093 61 21 in in IN 3093 61 22 which which WDT 3093 61 23 traditional traditional JJ 3093 61 24 metadata metadata NN 3093 61 25 schemas schema NNS 3093 61 26 are be VBP 3093 61 27 typically typically RB 3093 61 28 used use VBN 3093 61 29 to to TO 3093 61 30 describe describe VB 3093 61 31 images image NNS 3093 61 32 in in IN 3093 61 33 digital digital JJ 3093 61 34 library library NN 3093 61 35 settings setting NNS 3093 61 36 . . . 3093 62 1 Most Most JJS 3093 62 2 of of IN 3093 62 3 the the DT 3093 62 4 images image NNS 3093 62 5 included include VBN 3093 62 6 in in IN 3093 62 7 the the DT 3093 62 8 database database NN 3093 62 9 are be VBP 3093 62 10 accompanied accompany VBN 3093 62 11 by by IN 3093 62 12 descriptive descriptive JJ 3093 62 13 , , , 3093 62 14 structural structural JJ 3093 62 15 , , , 3093 62 16 and and CC 3093 62 17 administrative administrative JJ 3093 62 18 metadata metadata NN 3093 62 19 . . . 3093 63 1 For for IN 3093 63 2 example example NN 3093 63 3 , , , 3093 63 4 an an DT 3093 63 5 item item NN 3093 63 6 entitled entitle VBN 3093 63 7 “ " `` 3093 63 8 Boy boy VB 3093 63 9 sitting sit VBG 3093 63 10 on on IN 3093 63 11 a a DT 3093 63 12 stoop stoop NN 3093 63 13 holding hold VBG 3093 63 14 a a DT 3093 63 15 pole pole NN 3093 63 16 ” " '' 3093 63 17 ( ( -LRB- 3093 63 18 see see VB 3093 63 19 figure figure NN 3093 63 20 1 1 CD 3093 63 21 ) ) -RRB- 3093 63 22 from from IN 3093 63 23 the the DT 3093 63 24 university university NN 3093 63 25 ’s ’s POS 3093 63 26 collection collection NN 3093 63 27 of of IN 3093 63 28 1957–90 1957–90 CD 3093 63 29 Andrews Andrews NNP 3093 63 30 St. St. NNP 3093 63 31 George George NNP 3093 63 32 papers paper NNS 3093 63 33 provides provide VBZ 3093 63 34 a a DT 3093 63 35 digital digital JJ 3093 63 36 copy copy NN 3093 63 37 of of IN 3093 63 38 the the DT 3093 63 39 image image NN 3093 63 40 , , , 3093 63 41 the the DT 3093 63 42 image image NN 3093 63 43 number number NN 3093 63 44 , , , 3093 63 45 name name NN 3093 63 46 of of IN 3093 63 47 the the DT 3093 63 48 creator creator NN 3093 63 49 , , , 3093 63 50 date date NN 3093 63 51 of of IN 3093 63 52 creation creation NN 3093 63 53 , , , 3093 63 54 type type NN 3093 63 55 of of IN 3093 63 56 original original JJ 3093 63 57 material material NN 3093 63 58 , , , 3093 63 59 dimensions dimension NNS 3093 63 60 , , , 3093 63 61 copyright copyright NN 3093 63 62 information information NN 3093 63 63 , , , 3093 63 64 manuscript manuscript NNP 3093 63 65 group group NN 3093 63 66 name name NN 3093 63 67 and and CC 3093 63 68 number number NN 3093 63 69 , , , 3093 63 70 box box NN 3093 63 71 and and CC 3093 63 72 folder folder NN 3093 63 73 numbers number NNS 3093 63 74 , , , 3093 63 75 and and CC 3093 63 76 a a DT 3093 63 77 credit credit NN 3093 63 78 line.29 line.29 NNP 3093 63 79 The the DT 3093 63 80 image image NN 3093 63 81 is be VBZ 3093 63 82 further further RB 3093 63 83 described describe VBN 3093 63 84 by by IN 3093 63 85 the the DT 3093 63 86 following follow VBG 3093 63 87 : : : 3093 63 88 “ " `` 3093 63 89 Man man NN 3093 63 90 in in IN 3093 63 91 the the DT 3093 63 92 shed shed NN 3093 63 93 is be VBZ 3093 63 94 making make VBG 3093 63 95 homemade homemade JJ 3093 63 96 bombs bomb NNS 3093 63 97 . . . 3093 64 1 The the DT 3093 64 2 boy boy NN 3093 64 3 and and CC 3093 64 4 man man NN 3093 64 5 are be VBP 3093 64 6 also also RB 3093 64 7 in in IN 3093 64 8 image image NN 3093 64 9 45350 45350 CD 3093 64 10 . . . 3093 64 11 ” " '' 3093 64 12 30 30 CD 3093 64 13 Figure figure NN 3093 64 14 1 1 CD 3093 64 15 . . . 3093 65 1 “ " `` 3093 65 2 Boy boy VB 3093 65 3 sitting sit VBG 3093 65 4 on on IN 3093 65 5 a a DT 3093 65 6 stoop stoop NN 3093 65 7 holding hold VBG 3093 65 8 a a DT 3093 65 9 pole pole NN 3093 65 10 ” " '' 3093 65 11 from from IN 3093 65 12 Yale Yale NNP 3093 65 13 University University NNP 3093 65 14 ’s ’s POS 3093 65 15 Digital Digital NNP 3093 65 16 Images Images NNP 3093 65 17 Database Database NNP 3093 65 18 collection collection NN 3093 65 19 of of IN 3093 65 20 1957–90 1957–90 CD 3093 65 21 Andrews Andrews NNP 3093 65 22 St. St. NNP 3093 65 23 George George NNP 3093 65 24 papers paper NNS 3093 65 25 , , , 3093 65 26 November November NNP 3093 65 27 2012 2012 CD 3093 65 28 . . . 3093 66 1 Certainly certainly RB 3093 66 2 , , , 3093 66 3 such such JJ 3093 66 4 information information NN 3093 66 5 is be VBZ 3093 66 6 useful useful JJ 3093 66 7 in in IN 3093 66 8 library library JJ 3093 66 9 environments environment NNS 3093 66 10 and and CC 3093 66 11 provides provide VBZ 3093 66 12 users user NNS 3093 66 13 with with IN 3093 66 14 helpful helpful JJ 3093 66 15 and and CC 3093 66 16 formatted formatted JJ 3093 66 17 data datum NNS 3093 66 18 to to TO 3093 66 19 best best RB 3093 66 20 guide guide VB 3093 66 21 the the DT 3093 66 22 information information NN 3093 66 23 discovery discovery NN 3093 66 24 process process NN 3093 66 25 . . . 3093 67 1 The the DT 3093 67 2 finding finding NN 3093 67 3 aid aid NN 3093 67 4 for for IN 3093 67 5 the the DT 3093 67 6 Andrews Andrews NNP 3093 67 7 St. St. NNP 3093 67 8 George George NNP 3093 67 9 collection collection NN 3093 67 10 is be VBZ 3093 67 11 additionally additionally RB 3093 67 12 helpful helpful JJ 3093 67 13 in in IN 3093 67 14 that that IN 3093 67 15 it -PRON- PRP 3093 67 16 includes include VBZ 3093 67 17 information information NN 3093 67 18 about about IN 3093 67 19 provenance provenance NN 3093 67 20 , , , 3093 67 21 access access NN 3093 67 22 , , , 3093 67 23 processing processing NN 3093 67 24 , , , 3093 67 25 associated associated JJ 3093 67 26 materials material NNS 3093 67 27 , , , 3093 67 28 and and CC 3093 67 29 the the DT 3093 67 30 creator creator NN 3093 67 31 ; ; : 3093 67 32 it -PRON- PRP 3093 67 33 also also RB 3093 67 34 contains contain VBZ 3093 67 35 descriptive descriptive JJ 3093 67 36 information information NN 3093 67 37 about about IN 3093 67 38 the the DT 3093 67 39 collection collection NN 3093 67 40 by by IN 3093 67 41 box box NN 3093 67 42 and and CC 3093 67 43 folder folder NN 3093 67 44 number number NN 3093 67 45 . . . 3093 68 1 31 31 CD 3093 68 2 However however RB 3093 68 3 , , , 3093 68 4 if if IN 3093 68 5 additional additional JJ 3093 68 6 use use NN 3093 68 7 data datum NNS 3093 68 8 and and CC 3093 68 9 sociohistorical sociohistorical JJ 3093 68 10 SEARCHABLE SEARCHABLE NNP 3093 68 11 SIGNATURES signature VBN 3093 68 12 : : : 3093 68 13 CONTEXT context NN 3093 68 14 AND and CC 3093 68 15 THE the DT 3093 68 16 STRUGGLE struggle NN 3093 68 17 FOR for IN 3093 68 18 RECOGNITION RECOGNITION NNP 3093 68 19 | | CD 3093 68 20 SCHLESSELMAN SCHLESSELMAN NNP 3093 68 21 - - HYPH 3093 68 22 TARANGO TARANGO NNP 3093 68 23 10 10 CD 3093 68 24 information information NN 3093 68 25 specific specific JJ 3093 68 26 to to IN 3093 68 27 this this DT 3093 68 28 individual individual JJ 3093 68 29 item item NN 3093 68 30 were be VBD 3093 68 31 available available JJ 3093 68 32 , , , 3093 68 33 it -PRON- PRP 3093 68 34 would would MD 3093 68 35 be be VB 3093 68 36 most most RBS 3093 68 37 helpful helpful JJ 3093 68 38 in in IN 3093 68 39 assisting assist VBG 3093 68 40 users user NNS 3093 68 41 in in IN 3093 68 42 determining determine VBG 3093 68 43 the the DT 3093 68 44 image image NN 3093 68 45 ’s ’s POS 3093 68 46 greater great JJR 3093 68 47 context context NN 3093 68 48 . . . 3093 69 1 A a DT 3093 69 2 study study NN 3093 69 3 of of IN 3093 69 4 modes mode NNS 3093 69 5 of of IN 3093 69 6 participation participation NN 3093 69 7 on on IN 3093 69 8 social social JJ 3093 69 9 networking networking NN 3093 69 10 sites site NNS 3093 69 11 suggests suggest VBZ 3093 69 12 that that IN 3093 69 13 it -PRON- PRP 3093 69 14 is be VBZ 3093 69 15 now now RB 3093 69 16 possible possible JJ 3093 69 17 to to TO 3093 69 18 supply supply VB 3093 69 19 such such JJ 3093 69 20 contextual contextual JJ 3093 69 21 information information NN 3093 69 22 for for IN 3093 69 23 digital digital JJ 3093 69 24 objects object NNS 3093 69 25 that that WDT 3093 69 26 live live VBP 3093 69 27 in in IN 3093 69 28 interactive interactive JJ 3093 69 29 online online JJ 3093 69 30 environments environment NNS 3093 69 31 . . . 3093 70 1 A a DT 3093 70 2 useful useful JJ 3093 70 3 site site NN 3093 70 4 for for IN 3093 70 5 exploring explore VBG 3093 70 6 user user NN 3093 70 7 - - HYPH 3093 70 8 generated generate VBN 3093 70 9 tags tag NNS 3093 70 10 associated associate VBN 3093 70 11 with with IN 3093 70 12 images image NNS 3093 70 13 is be VBZ 3093 70 14 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 70 15 , , , 3093 70 16 a a DT 3093 70 17 social social JJ 3093 70 18 application application NN 3093 70 19 designed design VBN 3093 70 20 for for IN 3093 70 21 iPhone iPhone NNP 3093 70 22 and and CC 3093 70 23 Android.32 Android.32 : 3093 70 24 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 70 25 users user NNS 3093 70 26 are be VBP 3093 70 27 able able JJ 3093 70 28 to to TO 3093 70 29 upload upload VB 3093 70 30 and and CC 3093 70 31 edit edit VB 3093 70 32 photos photo NNS 3093 70 33 , , , 3093 70 34 and and CC 3093 70 35 other other JJ 3093 70 36 users user NNS 3093 70 37 can can MD 3093 70 38 then then RB 3093 70 39 view view VB 3093 70 40 , , , 3093 70 41 like like UH 3093 70 42 , , , 3093 70 43 and and CC 3093 70 44 comment comment VB 3093 70 45 on on IN 3093 70 46 the the DT 3093 70 47 shared shared JJ 3093 70 48 photos photo NNS 3093 70 49 . . . 3093 71 1 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 71 2 users user NNS 3093 71 3 are be VBP 3093 71 4 able able JJ 3093 71 5 to to TO 3093 71 6 follow follow VB 3093 71 7 other other JJ 3093 71 8 users user NNS 3093 71 9 and and CC 3093 71 10 search search VB 3093 71 11 for for IN 3093 71 12 photos photo NNS 3093 71 13 by by IN 3093 71 14 the the DT 3093 71 15 creator creator NN 3093 71 16 ’s ’s POS 3093 71 17 username username NN 3093 71 18 or or CC 3093 71 19 by by IN 3093 71 20 accompanying accompany VBG 3093 71 21 tags tag NNS 3093 71 22 . . . 3093 72 1 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 72 2 , , , 3093 72 3 owned own VBN 3093 72 4 by by IN 3093 72 5 Facebook Facebook NNP 3093 72 6 , , , 3093 72 7 is be VBZ 3093 72 8 interoperable interoperable JJ 3093 72 9 with with IN 3093 72 10 other other JJ 3093 72 11 social social JJ 3093 72 12 networking networking NN 3093 72 13 sites site NNS 3093 72 14 , , , 3093 72 15 and and CC 3093 72 16 users user NNS 3093 72 17 have have VBP 3093 72 18 the the DT 3093 72 19 ability ability NN 3093 72 20 to to TO 3093 72 21 share share VB 3093 72 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 72 23 photos photo NNS 3093 72 24 on on IN 3093 72 25 Facebook Facebook NNP 3093 72 26 , , , 3093 72 27 Flickr Flickr NNP 3093 72 28 , , , 3093 72 29 Tumblr Tumblr NNP 3093 72 30 , , , 3093 72 31 and and CC 3093 72 32 Twitter Twitter NNP 3093 72 33 . . . 3093 73 1 As as IN 3093 73 2 of of IN 3093 73 3 July July NNP 3093 73 4 2012 2012 CD 3093 73 5 , , , 3093 73 6 it -PRON- PRP 3093 73 7 was be VBD 3093 73 8 reported report VBN 3093 73 9 that that IN 3093 73 10 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 73 11 had have VBD 3093 73 12 80 80 CD 3093 73 13 million million CD 3093 73 14 users user NNS 3093 73 15 , , , 3093 73 16 and and CC 3093 73 17 in in IN 3093 73 18 September September NNP 3093 73 19 2012 2012 CD 3093 73 20 , , , 3093 73 21 the the DT 3093 73 22 New New NNP 3093 73 23 York York NNP 3093 73 24 Times Times NNP 3093 73 25 reported report VBD 3093 73 26 that that IN 3093 73 27 5 5 CD 3093 73 28 billion billion CD 3093 73 29 photos photo NNS 3093 73 30 were be VBD 3093 73 31 shared share VBN 3093 73 32 through through IN 3093 73 33 the the DT 3093 73 34 application.33 application.33 NNP 3093 73 35 Users user NNS 3093 73 36 are be VBP 3093 73 37 limited limit VBN 3093 73 38 to to IN 3093 73 39 30 30 CD 3093 73 40 tags tag NNS 3093 73 41 per per IN 3093 73 42 photo photo NN 3093 73 43 , , , 3093 73 44 and and CC 3093 73 45 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 73 46 suggests suggest VBZ 3093 73 47 that that IN 3093 73 48 users user NNS 3093 73 49 be be VB 3093 73 50 as as RB 3093 73 51 specific specific JJ 3093 73 52 as as IN 3093 73 53 possible possible JJ 3093 73 54 when when WRB 3093 73 55 describing describe VBG 3093 73 56 an an DT 3093 73 57 image image NN 3093 73 58 with with IN 3093 73 59 a a DT 3093 73 60 tag tag NN 3093 73 61 so so IN 3093 73 62 that that IN 3093 73 63 communities community NNS 3093 73 64 of of IN 3093 73 65 users user NNS 3093 73 66 with with IN 3093 73 67 similar similar JJ 3093 73 68 interests interest NNS 3093 73 69 can can MD 3093 73 70 form.34 form.34 XX 3093 73 71 Many many JJ 3093 73 72 tags tag NNS 3093 73 73 , , , 3093 73 74 like like IN 3093 73 75 the the DT 3093 73 76 information information NN 3093 73 77 included include VBN 3093 73 78 in in IN 3093 73 79 traditional traditional JJ 3093 73 80 metadata metadata NN 3093 73 81 schemas schema NNS 3093 73 82 , , , 3093 73 83 aim aim VB 3093 73 84 to to TO 3093 73 85 best best RB 3093 73 86 describe describe VB 3093 73 87 an an DT 3093 73 88 image image NN 3093 73 89 by by IN 3093 73 90 explaining explain VBG 3093 73 91 its -PRON- PRP$ 3093 73 92 content content NN 3093 73 93 ; ; : 3093 73 94 for for IN 3093 73 95 example example NN 3093 73 96 , , , 3093 73 97 one one CD 3093 73 98 user user NN 3093 73 99 assigned assign VBD 3093 73 100 the the DT 3093 73 101 tags tag NNS 3093 73 102 # # $ 3093 73 103 kids kid NNS 3093 73 104 , , , 3093 73 105 # # NN 3093 73 106 nieces niece NNS 3093 73 107 , , , 3093 73 108 # # NN 3093 73 109 nephews nephew NNS 3093 73 110 , , , 3093 73 111 and and CC 3093 73 112 # # $ 3093 73 113 family family NN 3093 73 114 to to IN 3093 73 115 a a DT 3093 73 116 photograph photograph NN 3093 73 117 of of IN 3093 73 118 a a DT 3093 73 119 group group NN 3093 73 120 of of IN 3093 73 121 smiling smile VBG 3093 73 122 children child NNS 3093 73 123 ( ( -LRB- 3093 73 124 see see VB 3093 73 125 figure figure NN 3093 73 126 2 2 CD 3093 73 127 ) ) -RRB- 3093 73 128 . . . 3093 74 1 Like like IN 3093 74 2 the the DT 3093 74 3 information information NN 3093 74 4 accompanying accompany VBG 3093 74 5 the the DT 3093 74 6 photograph photograph NN 3093 74 7 in in IN 3093 74 8 the the DT 3093 74 9 Yale Yale NNP 3093 74 10 University University NNP 3093 74 11 Digital Digital NNP 3093 74 12 Images Images NNP 3093 74 13 Database Database NNP 3093 74 14 , , , 3093 74 15 such such JJ 3093 74 16 tags tag NNS 3093 74 17 provide provide VBP 3093 74 18 users user NNS 3093 74 19 and and CC 3093 74 20 viewers viewer NNS 3093 74 21 with with IN 3093 74 22 tools tool NNS 3093 74 23 to to TO 3093 74 24 better better RB 3093 74 25 determine determine VB 3093 74 26 the the DT 3093 74 27 “ " `` 3093 74 28 aboutness aboutness NN 3093 74 29 ” " '' 3093 74 30 of of IN 3093 74 31 the the DT 3093 74 32 image image NN 3093 74 33 at at IN 3093 74 34 hand hand NN 3093 74 35 . . . 3093 75 1 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3093 75 2 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3093 75 3 AND and CC 3093 75 4 LIBRARIES library NNS 3093 75 5 | | NNP 3093 75 6 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3093 75 7 2013 2013 CD 3093 75 8 11 11 CD 3093 75 9 Figure figure NN 3093 75 10 2 2 CD 3093 75 11 . . . 3093 76 1 Photo photo NN 3093 76 2 shared share VBN 3093 76 3 on on IN 3093 76 4 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 76 5 assigning assign VBG 3093 76 6 both both CC 3093 76 7 descriptive descriptive JJ 3093 76 8 tags tag NNS 3093 76 9 and and CC 3093 76 10 the the DT 3093 76 11 searchable searchable JJ 3093 76 12 signature signature NN 3093 76 13 # # JJR 3093 76 14 proudaunt proudaunt NN 3093 76 15 , , , 3093 76 16 November November NNP 3093 76 17 2012 2012 CD 3093 76 18 . . . 3093 77 1 However however RB 3093 77 2 , , , 3093 77 3 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 77 4 users user NNS 3093 77 5 are be VBP 3093 77 6 repurposing repurpose VBG 3093 77 7 the the DT 3093 77 8 tagging tag VBG 3093 77 9 function function NN 3093 77 10 in in IN 3093 77 11 a a DT 3093 77 12 way way NN 3093 77 13 that that WDT 3093 77 14 is be VBZ 3093 77 15 unique unique JJ 3093 77 16 to to IN 3093 77 17 social social JJ 3093 77 18 networking networking NN 3093 77 19 sites site NNS 3093 77 20 . . . 3093 78 1 In in IN 3093 78 2 addition addition NN 3093 78 3 to to IN 3093 78 4 the the DT 3093 78 5 descriptive descriptive JJ 3093 78 6 tags tag NNS 3093 78 7 assigned assign VBN 3093 78 8 to to IN 3093 78 9 the the DT 3093 78 10 image image NN 3093 78 11 of of IN 3093 78 12 the the DT 3093 78 13 children child NNS 3093 78 14 described describe VBN 3093 78 15 above above RB 3093 78 16 , , , 3093 78 17 the the DT 3093 78 18 user user NN 3093 78 19 also also RB 3093 78 20 tagged tag VBD 3093 78 21 the the DT 3093 78 22 photo photo NN 3093 78 23 with with IN 3093 78 24 the the DT 3093 78 25 term term NN 3093 78 26 # # $ 3093 78 27 proudaunt proudaunt NN 3093 78 28 ( ( -LRB- 3093 78 29 see see VB 3093 78 30 figure figure NN 3093 78 31 2 2 CD 3093 78 32 ) ) -RRB- 3093 78 33 . . . 3093 79 1 There there EX 3093 79 2 is be VBZ 3093 79 3 , , , 3093 79 4 however however RB 3093 79 5 , , , 3093 79 6 no no DT 3093 79 7 aunt aunt NN 3093 79 8 ( ( -LRB- 3093 79 9 what what WP 3093 79 10 can can MD 3093 79 11 be be VB 3093 79 12 assumed assume VBN 3093 79 13 to to TO 3093 79 14 be be VB 3093 79 15 an an DT 3093 79 16 adult adult NN 3093 79 17 female female NN 3093 79 18 ) ) -RRB- 3093 79 19 in in IN 3093 79 20 the the DT 3093 79 21 photograph photograph NN 3093 79 22 . . . 3093 80 1 This this DT 3093 80 2 tag tag NN 3093 80 3 , , , 3093 80 4 then then RB 3093 80 5 , , , 3093 80 6 functions function NNS 3093 80 7 to to TO 3093 80 8 further further RB 3093 80 9 identify identify VB 3093 80 10 the the DT 3093 80 11 user user NN 3093 80 12 who who WP 3093 80 13 created create VBD 3093 80 14 or or CC 3093 80 15 shared share VBD 3093 80 16 the the DT 3093 80 17 photograph photograph NN 3093 80 18 and and CC 3093 80 19 does do VBZ 3093 80 20 not not RB 3093 80 21 describe describe VB 3093 80 22 the the DT 3093 80 23 content content NN 3093 80 24 of of IN 3093 80 25 the the DT 3093 80 26 image image NN 3093 80 27 at at IN 3093 80 28 hand hand NN 3093 80 29 . . . 3093 81 1 A a DT 3093 81 2 search search NN 3093 81 3 of of IN 3093 81 4 the the DT 3093 81 5 same same JJ 3093 81 6 tag tag NN 3093 81 7 , , , 3093 81 8 # # NN 3093 81 9 proudaunt proudaunt NN 3093 81 10 , , , 3093 81 11 demonstrates demonstrate VBZ 3093 81 12 that that IN 3093 81 13 this this DT 3093 81 14 user user NN 3093 81 15 is be VBZ 3093 81 16 not not RB 3093 81 17 alone alone RB 3093 81 18 in in IN 3093 81 19 identifying identify VBG 3093 81 20 as as IN 3093 81 21 such such JJ 3093 81 22 : : : 3093 81 23 in in IN 3093 81 24 November November NNP 3093 81 25 2012 2012 CD 3093 81 26 , , , 3093 81 27 this this DT 3093 81 28 search search NN 3093 81 29 returned return VBD 3093 81 30 40,202 40,202 CD 3093 81 31 images image NNS 3093 81 32 with with IN 3093 81 33 the the DT 3093 81 34 same same JJ 3093 81 35 tag tag NN 3093 81 36 and and CC 3093 81 37 more more JJR 3093 81 38 than than IN 3093 81 39 58,000 58,000 CD 3093 81 40 images image NNS 3093 81 41 with with IN 3093 81 42 tags tag NNS 3093 81 43 derived derive VBN 3093 81 44 from from IN 3093 81 45 the the DT 3093 81 46 same same JJ 3093 81 47 phrase phrase NN 3093 81 48 ( ( -LRB- 3093 81 49 # # $ 3093 81 50 proudaunty proudaunty NN 3093 81 51 , , , 3093 81 52 # # , 3093 81 53 proudauntie proudauntie NN 3093 81 54 , , , 3093 81 55 # # NN 3093 81 56 proudaunties proudauntie NNS 3093 81 57 , , , 3093 81 58 # # NN 3093 81 59 proudauntiemoment proudauntiemoment NN 3093 81 60 , , , 3093 81 61 and and CC 3093 81 62 # # $ 3093 81 63 proudaunti proudaunti NN 3093 81 64 ) ) -RRB- 3093 81 65 ( ( -LRB- 3093 81 66 see see VB 3093 81 67 figure figure NN 3093 81 68 3 3 CD 3093 81 69 ) ) -RRB- 3093 81 70 . . . 3093 82 1 Figure figure NN 3093 82 2 3 3 CD 3093 82 3 . . . 3093 83 1 List list NN 3093 83 2 of of IN 3093 83 3 results result NNS 3093 83 4 from from IN 3093 83 5 # # JJR 3093 83 6 proudaunt proudaunt JJ 3093 83 7 hashtag hashtag NN 3093 83 8 search search NN 3093 83 9 on on IN 3093 83 10 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 83 11 , , , 3093 83 12 November November NNP 3093 83 13 2012 2012 CD 3093 83 14 . . . 3093 84 1 This this DT 3093 84 2 type type NN 3093 84 3 of of IN 3093 84 4 user user NN 3093 84 5 - - HYPH 3093 84 6 generated generate VBN 3093 84 7 tag tag NN 3093 84 8 — — : 3093 84 9 one one CD 3093 84 10 that that WDT 3093 84 11 identifies identify VBZ 3093 84 12 the the DT 3093 84 13 creator creator NN 3093 84 14 or or CC 3093 84 15 sharer sharer NN 3093 84 16 of of IN 3093 84 17 the the DT 3093 84 18 photograph photograph NN 3093 84 19 yet yet RB 3093 84 20 is be VBZ 3093 84 21 not not RB 3093 84 22 necessarily necessarily RB 3093 84 23 meant mean VBN 3093 84 24 to to TO 3093 84 25 describe describe VB 3093 84 26 the the DT 3093 84 27 content content NN 3093 84 28 of of IN 3093 84 29 the the DT 3093 84 30 image image NN 3093 84 31 — — : 3093 84 32 can can MD 3093 84 33 be be VB 3093 84 34 understood understand VBN 3093 84 35 as as IN 3093 84 36 a a DT 3093 84 37 searchable searchable JJ 3093 84 38 signature signature NN 3093 84 39 . . . 3093 85 1 Such such JJ 3093 85 2 identity identity NN 3093 85 3 - - HYPH 3093 85 4 based base VBN 3093 85 5 tags tag NNS 3093 85 6 are be VBP 3093 85 7 not not RB 3093 85 8 found find VBN 3093 85 9 within within IN 3093 85 10 Yale Yale NNP 3093 85 11 University University NNP 3093 85 12 ’s ’s POS 3093 85 13 Digital Digital NNP 3093 85 14 Images Images NNP 3093 85 15 Database Database NNP 3093 85 16 ; ; : 3093 85 17 the the DT 3093 85 18 closest close JJS 3093 85 19 relative relative NN 3093 85 20 of of IN 3093 85 21 the the DT 3093 85 22 searchable searchable JJ 3093 85 23 signature signature NN 3093 85 24 is be VBZ 3093 85 25 the the DT 3093 85 26 creator creator NN 3093 85 27 ’s ’s POS 3093 85 28 name name NN 3093 85 29 . . . 3093 86 1 While while IN 3093 86 2 searchable searchable JJ 3093 86 3 , , , 3093 86 4 this this DT 3093 86 5 name name NN 3093 86 6 is be VBZ 3093 86 7 not not RB 3093 86 8 alternative alternative JJ 3093 86 9 , , , 3093 86 10 or or CC 3093 86 11 secondary secondary JJ 3093 86 12 , , , 3093 86 13 and and CC 3093 86 14 it -PRON- PRP 3093 86 15 was be VBD 3093 86 16 not not RB 3093 86 17 created create VBN 3093 86 18 and and CC 3093 86 19 does do VBZ 3093 86 20 not not RB 3093 86 21 exist exist VB 3093 86 22 in in IN 3093 86 23 a a DT 3093 86 24 social social JJ 3093 86 25 environment environment NN 3093 86 26 . . . 3093 87 1 SEARCHABLE SEARCHABLE NNP 3093 87 2 SIGNATURES SIGNATURES NNP 3093 87 3 : : : 3093 87 4 CONTEXT context NN 3093 87 5 AND and CC 3093 87 6 THE the DT 3093 87 7 STRUGGLE struggle NN 3093 87 8 FOR for IN 3093 87 9 RECOGNITION RECOGNITION NNP 3093 87 10 | | CD 3093 87 11 SCHLESSELMAN SCHLESSELMAN NNP 3093 87 12 - - HYPH 3093 87 13 TARANGO TARANGO NNP 3093 87 14 12 12 CD 3093 87 15 Currently currently RB 3093 87 16 , , , 3093 87 17 born bear VBN 3093 87 18 - - HYPH 3093 87 19 digital digital JJ 3093 87 20 objects object NNS 3093 87 21 are be VBP 3093 87 22 often often RB 3093 87 23 created create VBN 3093 87 24 and and CC 3093 87 25 shared share VBN 3093 87 26 in in IN 3093 87 27 a a DT 3093 87 28 technological technological JJ 3093 87 29 milieu milieu NN 3093 87 30 that that WDT 3093 87 31 allows allow VBZ 3093 87 32 for for IN 3093 87 33 the the DT 3093 87 34 assignment assignment NN 3093 87 35 of of IN 3093 87 36 user user NN 3093 87 37 - - HYPH 3093 87 38 generated generate VBN 3093 87 39 tags tag NNS 3093 87 40 . . . 3093 88 1 Consequently consequently RB 3093 88 2 , , , 3093 88 3 the the DT 3093 88 4 integration integration NN 3093 88 5 of of IN 3093 88 6 the the DT 3093 88 7 searchable searchable JJ 3093 88 8 signature signature NN 3093 88 9 into into IN 3093 88 10 the the DT 3093 88 11 presentation presentation NN 3093 88 12 of of IN 3093 88 13 digital digital JJ 3093 88 14 objects object NNS 3093 88 15 has have VBZ 3093 88 16 become become VBN 3093 88 17 part part NN 3093 88 18 of of IN 3093 88 19 accepted accept VBN 3093 88 20 social social JJ 3093 88 21 practice practice NN 3093 88 22 and and CC 3093 88 23 offers offer VBZ 3093 88 24 unique unique JJ 3093 88 25 opportunities opportunity NNS 3093 88 26 for for IN 3093 88 27 digital digital JJ 3093 88 28 library library NN 3093 88 29 curators curator NNS 3093 88 30 and and CC 3093 88 31 users user NNS 3093 88 32 alike alike RB 3093 88 33 . . . 3093 89 1 Until until IN 3093 89 2 quite quite RB 3093 89 3 recently recently RB 3093 89 4 , , , 3093 89 5 most most JJS 3093 89 6 materials material NNS 3093 89 7 — — : 3093 89 8 be be VB 3093 89 9 they -PRON- PRP 3093 89 10 photographs photograph NNS 3093 89 11 , , , 3093 89 12 manuscripts manuscript NNS 3093 89 13 , , , 3093 89 14 or or CC 3093 89 15 government government NN 3093 89 16 documents document NNS 3093 89 17 — — : 3093 89 18 were be VBD 3093 89 19 not not RB 3093 89 20 born bear VBN 3093 89 21 in in IN 3093 89 22 digital digital JJ 3093 89 23 environments environment NNS 3093 89 24 . . . 3093 90 1 However however RB 3093 90 2 , , , 3093 90 3 digitization digitization NN 3093 90 4 projects project NNS 3093 90 5 have have VBP 3093 90 6 been be VBN 3093 90 7 undertaken undertake VBN 3093 90 8 to to TO 3093 90 9 ensure ensure VB 3093 90 10 that that IN 3093 90 11 such such JJ 3093 90 12 historical historical JJ 3093 90 13 materials material NNS 3093 90 14 are be VBP 3093 90 15 more more RBR 3093 90 16 widely widely RB 3093 90 17 and and CC 3093 90 18 eternally eternally RB 3093 90 19 available available JJ 3093 90 20 . . . 3093 91 1 These these DT 3093 91 2 reborn reborn VBN 3093 91 3 digital digital JJ 3093 91 4 objects object NNS 3093 91 5 , , , 3093 91 6 then then RB 3093 91 7 , , , 3093 91 8 have have VBP 3093 91 9 been be VBN 3093 91 10 and and CC 3093 91 11 can can MD 3093 91 12 be be VB 3093 91 13 integrated integrate VBN 3093 91 14 into into IN 3093 91 15 dynamic dynamic JJ 3093 91 16 social social JJ 3093 91 17 environments environment NNS 3093 91 18 . . . 3093 92 1 Steve Steve NNP 3093 92 2 : : : 3093 92 3 The the DT 3093 92 4 Museum Museum NNP 3093 92 5 Social Social NNP 3093 92 6 Tagging Tagging NNP 3093 92 7 Project Project NNP 3093 92 8 , , , 3093 92 9 mentioned mention VBN 3093 92 10 earlier early RBR 3093 92 11 in in IN 3093 92 12 this this DT 3093 92 13 paper paper NN 3093 92 14 , , , 3093 92 15 is be VBZ 3093 92 16 one one CD 3093 92 17 example example NN 3093 92 18 of of IN 3093 92 19 an an DT 3093 92 20 organization organization NN 3093 92 21 that that WDT 3093 92 22 has have VBZ 3093 92 23 capitalized capitalize VBN 3093 92 24 on on IN 3093 92 25 the the DT 3093 92 26 social social JJ 3093 92 27 practice practice NN 3093 92 28 of of IN 3093 92 29 user user NN 3093 92 30 - - HYPH 3093 92 31 generated generate VBN 3093 92 32 tagging tagging NN 3093 92 33 and and CC 3093 92 34 is be VBZ 3093 92 35 using use VBG 3093 92 36 descriptive descriptive JJ 3093 92 37 tags tag NNS 3093 92 38 along along IN 3093 92 39 with with IN 3093 92 40 traditional traditional JJ 3093 92 41 metadata metadata NN 3093 92 42 to to TO 3093 92 43 better better RB 3093 92 44 describe describe VB 3093 92 45 reborn reborn VBN 3093 92 46 digital digital JJ 3093 92 47 objects object NNS 3093 92 48 . . . 3093 93 1 It -PRON- PRP 3093 93 2 is be VBZ 3093 93 3 important important JJ 3093 93 4 , , , 3093 93 5 then then RB 3093 93 6 , , , 3093 93 7 to to TO 3093 93 8 explore explore VB 3093 93 9 what what WP 3093 93 10 ( ( -LRB- 3093 93 11 if if IN 3093 93 12 any any DT 3093 93 13 ) ) -RRB- 3093 93 14 implications implication NNS 3093 93 15 the the DT 3093 93 16 application application NN 3093 93 17 of of IN 3093 93 18 the the DT 3093 93 19 searchable searchable JJ 3093 93 20 signature signature NN 3093 93 21 , , , 3093 93 22 a a DT 3093 93 23 unique unique JJ 3093 93 24 type type NN 3093 93 25 of of IN 3093 93 26 user user NN 3093 93 27 - - HYPH 3093 93 28 generated generate VBN 3093 93 29 tag tag NN 3093 93 30 , , , 3093 93 31 has have VBZ 3093 93 32 for for IN 3093 93 33 historical historical JJ 3093 93 34 objects object NNS 3093 93 35 that that WDT 3093 93 36 are be VBP 3093 93 37 later later RB 3093 93 38 integrated integrate VBN 3093 93 39 into into IN 3093 93 40 digital digital JJ 3093 93 41 environments environment NNS 3093 93 42 . . . 3093 94 1 Searchable searchable JJ 3093 94 2 signatures signature NNS 3093 94 3 associated associate VBN 3093 94 4 with with IN 3093 94 5 born bear VBN 3093 94 6 digital digital JJ 3093 94 7 images image NNS 3093 94 8 on on IN 3093 94 9 social social JJ 3093 94 10 networking networking NN 3093 94 11 sites site NNS 3093 94 12 contain contain VBP 3093 94 13 valuable valuable JJ 3093 94 14 information information NN 3093 94 15 about about IN 3093 94 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 94 17 creators creator NNS 3093 94 18 , , , 3093 94 19 users user NNS 3093 94 20 , , , 3093 94 21 and and CC 3093 94 22 the the DT 3093 94 23 images image NNS 3093 94 24 ’ ’ POS 3093 94 25 context context NN 3093 94 26 . . . 3093 95 1 One one PRP 3093 95 2 can can MD 3093 95 3 not not RB 3093 95 4 ignore ignore VB 3093 95 5 that that IN 3093 95 6 users user NNS 3093 95 7 will will MD 3093 95 8 , , , 3093 95 9 if if IN 3093 95 10 given give VBN 3093 95 11 the the DT 3093 95 12 chance chance NN 3093 95 13 , , , 3093 95 14 also also RB 3093 95 15 likely likely RB 3093 95 16 apply apply VB 3093 95 17 signatures signature NNS 3093 95 18 to to IN 3093 95 19 reborn reborn VB 3093 95 20 digital digital JJ 3093 95 21 objects object NNS 3093 95 22 in in IN 3093 95 23 similar similar JJ 3093 95 24 ways way NNS 3093 95 25 that that WDT 3093 95 26 they -PRON- PRP 3093 95 27 do do VBP 3093 95 28 to to IN 3093 95 29 objects object NNS 3093 95 30 that that WDT 3093 95 31 have have VBP 3093 95 32 always always RB 3093 95 33 existed exist VBN 3093 95 34 in in IN 3093 95 35 social social JJ 3093 95 36 environments environment NNS 3093 95 37 . . . 3093 96 1 Since since IN 3093 96 2 the the DT 3093 96 3 searchable searchable JJ 3093 96 4 signature signature NN 3093 96 5 is be VBZ 3093 96 6 used use VBN 3093 96 7 to to TO 3093 96 8 identify identify VB 3093 96 9 not not RB 3093 96 10 only only RB 3093 96 11 digital digital JJ 3093 96 12 image image NN 3093 96 13 creators creator NNS 3093 96 14 , , , 3093 96 15 but but CC 3093 96 16 also also RB 3093 96 17 sharers sharer NNS 3093 96 18 , , , 3093 96 19 and and CC 3093 96 20 if if IN 3093 96 21 these these DT 3093 96 22 signatures signature NNS 3093 96 23 do do VBP 3093 96 24 in in IN 3093 96 25 fact fact NN 3093 96 26 provide provide VB 3093 96 27 important important JJ 3093 96 28 insight insight NN 3093 96 29 into into IN 3093 96 30 the the DT 3093 96 31 sharers sharer NNS 3093 96 32 and and CC 3093 96 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 96 34 motivations motivation NNS 3093 96 35 , , , 3093 96 36 then then RB 3093 96 37 these these DT 3093 96 38 signatures signature NNS 3093 96 39 are be VBP 3093 96 40 not not RB 3093 96 41 to to TO 3093 96 42 be be VB 3093 96 43 ignored ignore VBN 3093 96 44 . . . 3093 97 1 Rather rather RB 3093 97 2 than than IN 3093 97 3 focusing focus VBG 3093 97 4 on on IN 3093 97 5 the the DT 3093 97 6 creating creating NN 3093 97 7 , , , 3093 97 8 the the DT 3093 97 9 lens lens NN 3093 97 10 through through IN 3093 97 11 which which WDT 3093 97 12 to to TO 3093 97 13 understand understand VB 3093 97 14 the the DT 3093 97 15 searchable searchable JJ 3093 97 16 signature signature NN 3093 97 17 for for IN 3093 97 18 reborn reborn VBN 3093 97 19 digital digital JJ 3093 97 20 objects object NNS 3093 97 21 can can MD 3093 97 22 be be VB 3093 97 23 shifted shift VBN 3093 97 24 to to IN 3093 97 25 the the DT 3093 97 26 social social JJ 3093 97 27 act act NN 3093 97 28 of of IN 3093 97 29 sharing sharing NN 3093 97 30 : : : 3093 97 31 by by IN 3093 97 32 whom whom WP 3093 97 33 , , , 3093 97 34 when when WRB 3093 97 35 , , , 3093 97 36 in in IN 3093 97 37 which which WDT 3093 97 38 social social JJ 3093 97 39 environments environment NNS 3093 97 40 , , , 3093 97 41 and and CC 3093 97 42 for for IN 3093 97 43 what what WDT 3093 97 44 purposes purpose NNS 3093 97 45 . . . 3093 98 1 A a DT 3093 98 2 deeper deep JJR 3093 98 3 analysis analysis NN 3093 98 4 of of IN 3093 98 5 the the DT 3093 98 6 presentation presentation NN 3093 98 7 of of IN 3093 98 8 self self NN 3093 98 9 through through IN 3093 98 10 the the DT 3093 98 11 searchable searchable JJ 3093 98 12 signature signature NN 3093 98 13 and and CC 3093 98 14 the the DT 3093 98 15 role role NN 3093 98 16 that that WDT 3093 98 17 the the DT 3093 98 18 signature signature NN 3093 98 19 plays play VBZ 3093 98 20 in in IN 3093 98 21 providing provide VBG 3093 98 22 valuable valuable JJ 3093 98 23 contextual contextual JJ 3093 98 24 information information NN 3093 98 25 for for IN 3093 98 26 both both CC 3093 98 27 born- born- JJ 3093 98 28 and and CC 3093 98 29 reborn reborn NN 3093 98 30 - - HYPH 3093 98 31 digital digital JJ 3093 98 32 objects object NNS 3093 98 33 is be VBZ 3093 98 34 developed develop VBN 3093 98 35 below below RB 3093 98 36 . . . 3093 99 1 Searchable searchable JJ 3093 99 2 Signatures signature NNS 3093 99 3 and and CC 3093 99 4 the the DT 3093 99 5 Struggle struggle NN 3093 99 6 for for IN 3093 99 7 Recognition Recognition NNP 3093 99 8 If if IN 3093 99 9 Web web NN 3093 99 10 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 99 11 indeed indeed RB 3093 99 12 functions function NNS 3093 99 13 as as IN 3093 99 14 a a DT 3093 99 15 recognition recognition NN 3093 99 16 market market NN 3093 99 17 , , , 3093 99 18 then then RB 3093 99 19 social social JJ 3093 99 20 media medium NNS 3093 99 21 and and CC 3093 99 22 social social JJ 3093 99 23 networking networking NN 3093 99 24 sites site NNS 3093 99 25 might may MD 3093 99 26 appear appear VB 3093 99 27 to to TO 3093 99 28 be be VB 3093 99 29 tables table NNS 3093 99 30 at at IN 3093 99 31 such such PDT 3093 99 32 a a DT 3093 99 33 market market NN 3093 99 34 . . . 3093 100 1 Placing place VBG 3093 100 2 oneself oneself PRP 3093 100 3 behind behind IN 3093 100 4 a a DT 3093 100 5 table table NN 3093 100 6 — — : 3093 100 7 be be VB 3093 100 8 it -PRON- PRP 3093 100 9 Facebook Facebook NNP 3093 100 10 , , , 3093 100 11 Twitter Twitter NNP 3093 100 12 , , , 3093 100 13 or or CC 3093 100 14 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 100 15 — — : 3093 100 16 the the DT 3093 100 17 user user NN 3093 100 18 is be VBZ 3093 100 19 able able JJ 3093 100 20 to to TO 3093 100 21 perform perform VB 3093 100 22 his -PRON- PRP$ 3093 100 23 or or CC 3093 100 24 her -PRON- PRP$ 3093 100 25 online online JJ 3093 100 26 identity identity NN 3093 100 27 to to IN 3093 100 28 passersby passersby NNP 3093 100 29 and and CC 3093 100 30 effectively effectively RB 3093 100 31 struggle struggle VB 3093 100 32 to to TO 3093 100 33 be be VB 3093 100 34 recognized recognize VBN 3093 100 35 as as IN 3093 100 36 a a DT 3093 100 37 unique unique JJ 3093 100 38 individual individual NN 3093 100 39 or or CC 3093 100 40 as as IN 3093 100 41 a a DT 3093 100 42 member member NN 3093 100 43 of of IN 3093 100 44 a a DT 3093 100 45 social social JJ 3093 100 46 group group NN 3093 100 47 . . . 3093 101 1 These these DT 3093 101 2 performances performance NNS 3093 101 3 , , , 3093 101 4 which which WDT 3093 101 5 could could MD 3093 101 6 be be VB 3093 101 7 deemed deem VBN 3093 101 8 narcissistic narcissistic JJ 3093 101 9 in in IN 3093 101 10 nature nature NN 3093 101 11 , , , 3093 101 12 can can MD 3093 101 13 alternatively alternatively RB 3093 101 14 be be VB 3093 101 15 read read VBN 3093 101 16 as as IN 3093 101 17 healthy healthy JJ 3093 101 18 attempts attempt NNS 3093 101 19 to to TO 3093 101 20 self self NN 3093 101 21 - - HYPH 3093 101 22 actualize actualize VB 3093 101 23 and and CC 3093 101 24 connect connect VB 3093 101 25 to to IN 3093 101 26 larger large JJR 3093 101 27 society.35 society.35 NNP 3093 101 28 One one CD 3093 101 29 such such JJ 3093 101 30 “ " `` 3093 101 31 table table NN 3093 101 32 ” " '' 3093 101 33 in in IN 3093 101 34 the the DT 3093 101 35 recognition recognition NN 3093 101 36 market market NN 3093 101 37 is be VBZ 3093 101 38 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 101 39 . . . 3093 102 1 Beyond beyond IN 3093 102 2 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 102 3 ’s ’s POS 3093 102 4 social social JJ 3093 102 5 nature nature NN 3093 102 6 that that WDT 3093 102 7 allows allow VBZ 3093 102 8 participants participant NNS 3093 102 9 to to TO 3093 102 10 interact interact VB 3093 102 11 with with IN 3093 102 12 and and CC 3093 102 13 follow follow VB 3093 102 14 one one CD 3093 102 15 another another DT 3093 102 16 , , , 3093 102 17 the the DT 3093 102 18 specific specific JJ 3093 102 19 role role NN 3093 102 20 of of IN 3093 102 21 the the DT 3093 102 22 searchable searchable JJ 3093 102 23 signature signature NN 3093 102 24 is be VBZ 3093 102 25 of of IN 3093 102 26 interest interest NN 3093 102 27 to to IN 3093 102 28 those those DT 3093 102 29 who who WP 3093 102 30 are be VBP 3093 102 31 concerned concern VBN 3093 102 32 with with IN 3093 102 33 struggles struggle NNS 3093 102 34 for for IN 3093 102 35 recognition recognition NN 3093 102 36 . . . 3093 103 1 Rather rather RB 3093 103 2 than than IN 3093 103 3 describing describe VBG 3093 103 4 shared share VBN 3093 103 5 images image NNS 3093 103 6 , , , 3093 103 7 searchable searchable JJ 3093 103 8 signatures signature NNS 3093 103 9 reflect reflect VBP 3093 103 10 performative performative JJ 3093 103 11 yet yet CC 3093 103 12 authentic authentic JJ 3093 103 13 user user NN 3093 103 14 identities identity NNS 3093 103 15 . . . 3093 104 1 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3093 104 2 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3093 104 3 AND and CC 3093 104 4 LIBRARIES library NNS 3093 104 5 | | NNP 3093 104 6 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3093 104 7 2013 2013 CD 3093 104 8 13 13 CD 3093 104 9 McCune McCune NNP 3093 104 10 , , , 3093 104 11 in in IN 3093 104 12 a a DT 3093 104 13 case case NN 3093 104 14 study study NN 3093 104 15 of of IN 3093 104 16 consumer consumer NN 3093 104 17 production production NN 3093 104 18 on on IN 3093 104 19 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 104 20 , , , 3093 104 21 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ 3093 104 22 the the DT 3093 104 23 potential potential NN 3093 104 24 of of IN 3093 104 25 the the DT 3093 104 26 tag tag NN 3093 104 27 to to IN 3093 104 28 not not RB 3093 104 29 only only RB 3093 104 30 facilitate facilitate VB 3093 104 31 image image NN 3093 104 32 exchange exchange NN 3093 104 33 but but CC 3093 104 34 to to TO 3093 104 35 communicate communicate VB 3093 104 36 users user NNS 3093 104 37 ’ ’ POS 3093 104 38 positions position NNS 3093 104 39 as as IN 3093 104 40 members member NNS 3093 104 41 of of IN 3093 104 42 social social JJ 3093 104 43 groups.36 groups.36 NNP 3093 104 44 Through through IN 3093 104 45 a a DT 3093 104 46 simple simple JJ 3093 104 47 search search NN 3093 104 48 of of IN 3093 104 49 tags tag NNS 3093 104 50 , , , 3093 104 51 users user NNS 3093 104 52 who who WP 3093 104 53 identify identify VBP 3093 104 54 as as IN 3093 104 55 , , , 3093 104 56 for for IN 3093 104 57 example example NN 3093 104 58 , , , 3093 104 59 “ " `` 3093 104 60 cat cat NN 3093 104 61 ladies lady NNS 3093 104 62 , , , 3093 104 63 ” " '' 3093 104 64 are be VBP 3093 104 65 able able JJ 3093 104 66 to to TO 3093 104 67 validate validate VB 3093 104 68 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 104 69 identities identity NNS 3093 104 70 when when WRB 3093 104 71 they -PRON- PRP 3093 104 72 see see VBP 3093 104 73 that that IN 3093 104 74 there there EX 3093 104 75 are be VBP 3093 104 76 many many JJ 3093 104 77 others other NNS 3093 104 78 who who WP 3093 104 79 use use VBP 3093 104 80 the the DT 3093 104 81 same same JJ 3093 104 82 or or CC 3093 104 83 similar similar JJ 3093 104 84 language language NN 3093 104 85 in in IN 3093 104 86 demonstrations demonstration NNS 3093 104 87 of of IN 3093 104 88 the the DT 3093 104 89 self self NN 3093 104 90 ( ( -LRB- 3093 104 91 see see VB 3093 104 92 figure figure NN 3093 104 93 4 4 CD 3093 104 94 ) ) -RRB- 3093 104 95 . . . 3093 105 1 Other other JJ 3093 105 2 signatures signature NNS 3093 105 3 such such JJ 3093 105 4 as as IN 3093 105 5 # # $ 3093 105 6 proudaunt proudaunt NN 3093 105 7 , , , 3093 105 8 while while IN 3093 105 9 not not RB 3093 105 10 necessarily necessarily RB 3093 105 11 playful playful JJ 3093 105 12 , , , 3093 105 13 still still RB 3093 105 14 function function VBP 3093 105 15 to to TO 3093 105 16 provide provide VB 3093 105 17 viewers viewer NNS 3093 105 18 with with IN 3093 105 19 additional additional JJ 3093 105 20 information information NN 3093 105 21 about about IN 3093 105 22 the the DT 3093 105 23 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 105 24 user user NN 3093 105 25 that that WDT 3093 105 26 can can MD 3093 105 27 not not RB 3093 105 28 be be VB 3093 105 29 determined determine VBN 3093 105 30 through through IN 3093 105 31 the the DT 3093 105 32 photo photo NN 3093 105 33 itself -PRON- PRP 3093 105 34 . . . 3093 106 1 The the DT 3093 106 2 ability ability NN 3093 106 3 to to TO 3093 106 4 find find VB 3093 106 5 images image NNS 3093 106 6 based base VBN 3093 106 7 on on IN 3093 106 8 these these DT 3093 106 9 searchable searchable JJ 3093 106 10 signatures signature NNS 3093 106 11 allows allow VBZ 3093 106 12 users user NNS 3093 106 13 to to TO 3093 106 14 find find VB 3093 106 15 others other NNS 3093 106 16 who who WP 3093 106 17 identify identify VBP 3093 106 18 in in IN 3093 106 19 a a DT 3093 106 20 like like JJ 3093 106 21 manner manner NN 3093 106 22 and and CC 3093 106 23 to to TO 3093 106 24 imagine imagine VB 3093 106 25 themselves -PRON- PRP 3093 106 26 as as IN 3093 106 27 part part NN 3093 106 28 of of IN 3093 106 29 a a DT 3093 106 30 larger large JJR 3093 106 31 social social JJ 3093 106 32 group group NN 3093 106 33 . . . 3093 107 1 In in IN 3093 107 2 effect effect NN 3093 107 3 , , , 3093 107 4 searchable searchable JJ 3093 107 5 signatures signature NNS 3093 107 6 allow allow VBP 3093 107 7 users user NNS 3093 107 8 to to TO 3093 107 9 be be VB 3093 107 10 recognized recognize VBN 3093 107 11 as as IN 3093 107 12 social social JJ 3093 107 13 addressees addressee NNS 3093 107 14 of of IN 3093 107 15 like like JJ 3093 107 16 - - HYPH 3093 107 17 minded minded JJ 3093 107 18 others other NNS 3093 107 19 . . . 3093 108 1 Positioning position VBG 3093 108 2 oneself oneself PRP 3093 108 3 within within IN 3093 108 4 a a DT 3093 108 5 group group NN 3093 108 6 must must MD 3093 108 7 be be VB 3093 108 8 understood understand VBN 3093 108 9 as as IN 3093 108 10 a a DT 3093 108 11 struggle struggle NN 3093 108 12 for for IN 3093 108 13 recognition recognition NN 3093 108 14 , , , 3093 108 15 for for IN 3093 108 16 to to TO 3093 108 17 imagine imagine VB 3093 108 18 oneself oneself PRP 3093 108 19 as as IN 3093 108 20 part part NN 3093 108 21 of of IN 3093 108 22 the the DT 3093 108 23 social social JJ 3093 108 24 fabric fabric NN 3093 108 25 is be VBZ 3093 108 26 also also RB 3093 108 27 to to TO 3093 108 28 see see VB 3093 108 29 oneself oneself PRP 3093 108 30 as as RB 3093 108 31 valuable valuable JJ 3093 108 32 . . . 3093 109 1 Figure figure NN 3093 109 2 4 4 CD 3093 109 3 . . . 3093 110 1 List list NN 3093 110 2 of of IN 3093 110 3 results result NNS 3093 110 4 from from IN 3093 110 5 # # $ 3093 110 6 catlady catlady JJ 3093 110 7 hashtag hashtag NN 3093 110 8 search search NN 3093 110 9 on on IN 3093 110 10 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 110 11 , , , 3093 110 12 November November NNP 3093 110 13 2012 2012 CD 3093 110 14 . . . 3093 111 1 Enabled enable VBN 3093 111 2 by by IN 3093 111 3 Web web NN 3093 111 4 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 111 5 , , , 3093 111 6 searchable searchable JJ 3093 111 7 signatures signature NNS 3093 111 8 contain contain VBP 3093 111 9 potential potential NN 3093 111 10 for for IN 3093 111 11 marginalized marginalized JJ 3093 111 12 peoples people NNS 3093 111 13 or or CC 3093 111 14 groups group NNS 3093 111 15 to to TO 3093 111 16 assert assert VB 3093 111 17 online online JJ 3093 111 18 selves self NNS 3093 111 19 to to TO 3093 111 20 be be VB 3093 111 21 seen see VBN 3093 111 22 and and CC 3093 111 23 ultimately ultimately RB 3093 111 24 heard hear VBD 3093 111 25 in in IN 3093 111 26 a a DT 3093 111 27 truly truly RB 3093 111 28 intersubjective intersubjective JJ 3093 111 29 landscape landscape NN 3093 111 30 . . . 3093 112 1 It -PRON- PRP 3093 112 2 is be VBZ 3093 112 3 not not RB 3093 112 4 too too RB 3093 112 5 much much JJ 3093 112 6 of of IN 3093 112 7 a a DT 3093 112 8 leap leap NN 3093 112 9 to to TO 3093 112 10 imagine imagine VB 3093 112 11 that that IN 3093 112 12 searchable searchable JJ 3093 112 13 signatures signature NNS 3093 112 14 might may MD 3093 112 15 make make VB 3093 112 16 possible possible JJ 3093 112 17 the the DT 3093 112 18 organization organization NN 3093 112 19 of of IN 3093 112 20 individuals individual NNS 3093 112 21 and and CC 3093 112 22 groups group NNS 3093 112 23 for for IN 3093 112 24 political political JJ 3093 112 25 purposes purpose NNS 3093 112 26 . . . 3093 113 1 In in IN 3093 113 2 fact fact NN 3093 113 3 , , , 3093 113 4 in in IN 3093 113 5 a a DT 3093 113 6 discussion discussion NN 3093 113 7 of of IN 3093 113 8 social social JJ 3093 113 9 groups group NNS 3093 113 10 , , , 3093 113 11 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 113 12 notes note VBZ 3093 113 13 that that IN 3093 113 14 “ " `` 3093 113 15 the the DT 3093 113 16 more more RBR 3093 113 17 successful successful JJ 3093 113 18 social social JJ 3093 113 19 movements movement NNS 3093 113 20 are be VBP 3093 113 21 at at IN 3093 113 22 drawing draw VBG 3093 113 23 the the DT 3093 113 24 public public JJ 3093 113 25 sphere sphere NN 3093 113 26 ’s ’s POS 3093 113 27 attention attention NN 3093 113 28 to to IN 3093 113 29 SEARCHABLE SEARCHABLE NNP 3093 113 30 SIGNATURES signatures VB 3093 113 31 : : : 3093 113 32 CONTEXT context NN 3093 113 33 AND and CC 3093 113 34 THE the DT 3093 113 35 STRUGGLE struggle NN 3093 113 36 FOR for IN 3093 113 37 RECOGNITION RECOGNITION NNP 3093 113 38 | | CD 3093 113 39 SCHLESSELMAN SCHLESSELMAN NNP 3093 113 40 - - HYPH 3093 113 41 TARANGO TARANGO NNP 3093 113 42 14 14 CD 3093 113 43 the the DT 3093 113 44 neglected neglected JJ 3093 113 45 significance significance NN 3093 113 46 of of IN 3093 113 47 the the DT 3093 113 48 traits trait NNS 3093 113 49 and and CC 3093 113 50 abilities ability NNS 3093 113 51 they -PRON- PRP 3093 113 52 collectively collectively RB 3093 113 53 represent represent VBP 3093 113 54 , , , 3093 113 55 the the DT 3093 113 56 better well JJR 3093 113 57 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 113 58 chances chance NNS 3093 113 59 of of IN 3093 113 60 raising raise VBG 3093 113 61 the the DT 3093 113 62 social social JJ 3093 113 63 worth worth NN 3093 113 64 , , , 3093 113 65 or or CC 3093 113 66 indeed indeed RB 3093 113 67 , , , 3093 113 68 the the DT 3093 113 69 standing standing NN 3093 113 70 of of IN 3093 113 71 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 113 72 members member NNS 3093 113 73 . . . 3093 113 74 ” " '' 3093 113 75 37 37 CD 3093 113 76 Here here RB 3093 113 77 , , , 3093 113 78 searchable searchable JJ 3093 113 79 signatures signature NNS 3093 113 80 might may MD 3093 113 81 provide provide VB 3093 113 82 such such JJ 3093 113 83 movements movement NNS 3093 113 84 with with IN 3093 113 85 a a DT 3093 113 86 venue venue NN 3093 113 87 to to TO 3093 113 88 capture capture VB 3093 113 89 the the DT 3093 113 90 public public NN 3093 113 91 ’s ’s POS 3093 113 92 attention attention NN 3093 113 93 and and CC 3093 113 94 to to TO 3093 113 95 effectively effectively RB 3093 113 96 struggle struggle VB 3093 113 97 for for IN 3093 113 98 and and CC 3093 113 99 gain gain VB 3093 113 100 recognition recognition NN 3093 113 101 . . . 3093 114 1 Searchable searchable JJ 3093 114 2 Signatures Signatures NNPS 3093 114 3 and and CC 3093 114 4 Context Context NNP 3093 114 5 As as IN 3093 114 6 markers marker NNS 3093 114 7 of of IN 3093 114 8 individual individual NN 3093 114 9 and and CC 3093 114 10 group group NN 3093 114 11 identities identity NNS 3093 114 12 , , , 3093 114 13 searchable searchable JJ 3093 114 14 signatures signature NNS 3093 114 15 are be VBP 3093 114 16 unique unique JJ 3093 114 17 in in IN 3093 114 18 that that IN 3093 114 19 they -PRON- PRP 3093 114 20 provide provide VBP 3093 114 21 a a DT 3093 114 22 snapshot snapshot NN 3093 114 23 of of IN 3093 114 24 the the DT 3093 114 25 multitude multitude NN 3093 114 26 of of IN 3093 114 27 social social NNP 3093 114 28 , , , 3093 114 29 historical historical JJ 3093 114 30 , , , 3093 114 31 political political JJ 3093 114 32 , , , 3093 114 33 individual individual JJ 3093 114 34 , , , 3093 114 35 and and CC 3093 114 36 interpersonal interpersonal JJ 3093 114 37 relationships relationship NNS 3093 114 38 that that WDT 3093 114 39 ontologize ontologize VBP 3093 114 40 the the DT 3093 114 41 images image NNS 3093 114 42 with with IN 3093 114 43 which which WDT 3093 114 44 they -PRON- PRP 3093 114 45 are be VBP 3093 114 46 paired pair VBN 3093 114 47 . . . 3093 115 1 It -PRON- PRP 3093 115 2 is be VBZ 3093 115 3 this this DT 3093 115 4 very very RB 3093 115 5 contextual contextual JJ 3093 115 6 information information NN 3093 115 7 that that WDT 3093 115 8 is be VBZ 3093 115 9 at at IN 3093 115 10 times time NNS 3093 115 11 lacking lack VBG 3093 115 12 in in IN 3093 115 13 traditional traditional JJ 3093 115 14 indexing indexing NN 3093 115 15 environments environment NNS 3093 115 16 . . . 3093 116 1 By by IN 3093 116 2 examining examine VBG 3093 116 3 searchable searchable JJ 3093 116 4 signatures signature NNS 3093 116 5 , , , 3093 116 6 experts expert NNS 3093 116 7 and and CC 3093 116 8 users user NNS 3093 116 9 are be VBP 3093 116 10 able able JJ 3093 116 11 to to TO 3093 116 12 understand understand VB 3093 116 13 which which WDT 3093 116 14 individuals individual NNS 3093 116 15 and and CC 3093 116 16 groups group NNS 3093 116 17 create create VBP 3093 116 18 , , , 3093 116 19 use use VBP 3093 116 20 , , , 3093 116 21 and and CC 3093 116 22 identify identify VB 3093 116 23 with with IN 3093 116 24 certain certain JJ 3093 116 25 images image NNS 3093 116 26 . . . 3093 117 1 Thus thus RB 3093 117 2 , , , 3093 117 3 as as IN 3093 117 4 markers marker NNS 3093 117 5 of of IN 3093 117 6 self self NN 3093 117 7 , , , 3093 117 8 searchable searchable JJ 3093 117 9 signatures signature NNS 3093 117 10 provide provide VBP 3093 117 11 use use NN 3093 117 12 data datum NNS 3093 117 13 for for IN 3093 117 14 scholars scholar NNS 3093 117 15 to to TO 3093 117 16 better well RBR 3093 117 17 investigate investigate VB 3093 117 18 which which WDT 3093 117 19 images image NNS 3093 117 20 are be VBP 3093 117 21 important important JJ 3093 117 22 to to IN 3093 117 23 online online JJ 3093 117 24 individual individual NN 3093 117 25 or or CC 3093 117 26 group group NN 3093 117 27 identities identity NNS 3093 117 28 . . . 3093 118 1 If if IN 3093 118 2 the the DT 3093 118 3 searchable searchable JJ 3093 118 4 signature signature NN 3093 118 5 is be VBZ 3093 118 6 used use VBN 3093 118 7 in in IN 3093 118 8 a a DT 3093 118 9 political political JJ 3093 118 10 fashion fashion NN 3093 118 11 , , , 3093 118 12 historians historian NNS 3093 118 13 and and CC 3093 118 14 sociologists sociologist NNS 3093 118 15 might may MD 3093 118 16 be be VB 3093 118 17 able able JJ 3093 118 18 to to TO 3093 118 19 study study VB 3093 118 20 which which WDT 3093 118 21 types type NNS 3093 118 22 of of IN 3093 118 23 images image NNS 3093 118 24 , , , 3093 118 25 for for IN 3093 118 26 example example NN 3093 118 27 , , , 3093 118 28 marginalized marginalized JJ 3093 118 29 groups group NNS 3093 118 30 rally rally VBP 3093 118 31 around around RB 3093 118 32 , , , 3093 118 33 identify identify VB 3093 118 34 with with IN 3093 118 35 , , , 3093 118 36 and and CC 3093 118 37 use use VB 3093 118 38 in in IN 3093 118 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 118 40 struggles struggle NNS 3093 118 41 for for IN 3093 118 42 recognition recognition NN 3093 118 43 . . . 3093 119 1 Such such JJ 3093 119 2 use use NN 3093 119 3 data datum NNS 3093 119 4 also also RB 3093 119 5 illuminates illuminate VBZ 3093 119 6 how how WRB 3093 119 7 and and CC 3093 119 8 by by IN 3093 119 9 whom whom WP 3093 119 10 certain certain JJ 3093 119 11 digital digital JJ 3093 119 12 images image NNS 3093 119 13 have have VBP 3093 119 14 been be VBN 3093 119 15 appropriated appropriate VBN 3093 119 16 over over IN 3093 119 17 time time NN 3093 119 18 . . . 3093 120 1 For for IN 3093 120 2 example example NN 3093 120 3 , , , 3093 120 4 if if IN 3093 120 5 a a DT 3093 120 6 picture picture NN 3093 120 7 of of IN 3093 120 8 a a DT 3093 120 9 cat cat NN 3093 120 10 is be VBZ 3093 120 11 first first RB 3093 120 12 created create VBN 3093 120 13 or or CC 3093 120 14 shared share VBN 3093 120 15 via via IN 3093 120 16 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 120 17 by by IN 3093 120 18 an an DT 3093 120 19 animal animal NN 3093 120 20 rights right NNS 3093 120 21 activist activist NN 3093 120 22 , , , 3093 120 23 the the DT 3093 120 24 image image NN 3093 120 25 might may MD 3093 120 26 be be VB 3093 120 27 accompanied accompany VBN 3093 120 28 by by IN 3093 120 29 the the DT 3093 120 30 searchable searchable JJ 3093 120 31 signature signature NN 3093 120 32 # # : 3093 120 33 humanforcats humanforcat NNS 3093 120 34 . . . 3093 121 1 This this DT 3093 121 2 same same JJ 3093 121 3 image image NN 3093 121 4 , , , 3093 121 5 shared share VBN 3093 121 6 by by IN 3093 121 7 another another DT 3093 121 8 user user NN 3093 121 9 months month NNS 3093 121 10 later later RB 3093 121 11 , , , 3093 121 12 might may MD 3093 121 13 be be VB 3093 121 14 accompanied accompany VBN 3093 121 15 by by IN 3093 121 16 the the DT 3093 121 17 # # $ 3093 121 18 catlady catlady JJ 3093 121 19 signature signature NN 3093 121 20 . . . 3093 122 1 Those those DT 3093 122 2 interested interested JJ 3093 122 3 will will MD 3093 122 4 be be VB 3093 122 5 able able JJ 3093 122 6 to to TO 3093 122 7 examine examine VB 3093 122 8 how how WRB 3093 122 9 the the DT 3093 122 10 same same JJ 3093 122 11 image image NN 3093 122 12 has have VBZ 3093 122 13 been be VBN 3093 122 14 historically historically RB 3093 122 15 used use VBN 3093 122 16 for for IN 3093 122 17 different different JJ 3093 122 18 purposes purpose NNS 3093 122 19 and and CC 3093 122 20 will will MD 3093 122 21 be be VB 3093 122 22 better well RBR 3093 122 23 able able JJ 3093 122 24 to to TO 3093 122 25 grasp grasp VB 3093 122 26 the the DT 3093 122 27 evolving evolve VBG 3093 122 28 nature nature NN 3093 122 29 of of IN 3093 122 30 its -PRON- PRP$ 3093 122 31 digital digital JJ 3093 122 32 context context NN 3093 122 33 . . . 3093 123 1 In in IN 3093 123 2 addition addition NN 3093 123 3 to to TO 3093 123 4 use use VB 3093 123 5 data datum NNS 3093 123 6 , , , 3093 123 7 the the DT 3093 123 8 searchable searchable JJ 3093 123 9 signature signature NN 3093 123 10 provides provide VBZ 3093 123 11 insight insight NN 3093 123 12 into into IN 3093 123 13 the the DT 3093 123 14 sociohistorical sociohistorical JJ 3093 123 15 context context NN 3093 123 16 surrounding surround VBG 3093 123 17 digital digital JJ 3093 123 18 images image NNS 3093 123 19 . . . 3093 124 1 For for IN 3093 124 2 those those DT 3093 124 3 who who WP 3093 124 4 perceive perceive VBP 3093 124 5 “ " `` 3093 124 6 reality reality NN 3093 124 7 . . . 3093 125 1 . . . 3093 126 1 . . . 3093 127 1 as as IN 3093 127 2 accessible accessible JJ 3093 127 3 only only RB 3093 127 4 ( ( -LRB- 3093 127 5 and and CC 3093 127 6 always always RB 3093 127 7 incompletely incompletely RB 3093 127 8 ) ) -RRB- 3093 127 9 in in IN 3093 127 10 context context NN 3093 127 11 , , , 3093 127 12 in in IN 3093 127 13 specific specific JJ 3093 127 14 historicized historicized JJ 3093 127 15 moments moment NNS 3093 127 16 in in IN 3093 127 17 time time NN 3093 127 18 space space NN 3093 127 19 ” " '' 3093 127 20 the the DT 3093 127 21 searchable searchable JJ 3093 127 22 signature signature NN 3093 127 23 clarifies clarifie NNS 3093 127 24 and and CC 3093 127 25 makes make VBZ 3093 127 26 more more RBR 3093 127 27 accessible accessible JJ 3093 127 28 that that IN 3093 127 29 reality reality NN 3093 127 30 surrounding surround VBG 3093 127 31 the the DT 3093 127 32 digital digital JJ 3093 127 33 image image NN 3093 127 34 . . . 3093 128 1 38 38 CD 3093 128 2 In in IN 3093 128 3 a a DT 3093 128 4 traditional traditional JJ 3093 128 5 library library NN 3093 128 6 setting setting NN 3093 128 7 , , , 3093 128 8 a a DT 3093 128 9 photo photo NN 3093 128 10 of of IN 3093 128 11 a a DT 3093 128 12 cat cat NN 3093 128 13 might may MD 3093 128 14 be be VB 3093 128 15 indexed index VBN 3093 128 16 with with IN 3093 128 17 descriptive descriptive JJ 3093 128 18 subject subject JJ 3093 128 19 headings heading NNS 3093 128 20 such such JJ 3093 128 21 as as IN 3093 128 22 “ " `` 3093 128 23 Cat Cat NNP 3093 128 24 , , , 3093 128 25 ” " '' 3093 128 26 “ " `` 3093 128 27 Persian persian JJ 3093 128 28 cat cat NN 3093 128 29 , , , 3093 128 30 ” " '' 3093 128 31 or or CC 3093 128 32 “ " `` 3093 128 33 Kitten Kitten NNP 3093 128 34 — — : 3093 128 35 Behavior Behavior NNP 3093 128 36 . . . 3093 128 37 ” " '' 3093 128 38 However however RB 3093 128 39 , , , 3093 128 40 the the DT 3093 128 41 searchable searchable JJ 3093 128 42 signature signature NN 3093 128 43 # # JJR 3093 128 44 catladyforlife catladyforlife NN 3093 128 45 provides provide VBZ 3093 128 46 additional additional JJ 3093 128 47 information information NN 3093 128 48 on on IN 3093 128 49 how how WRB 3093 128 50 the the DT 3093 128 51 cat cat NN 3093 128 52 has have VBZ 3093 128 53 become become VBN 3093 128 54 , , , 3093 128 55 for for IN 3093 128 56 a a DT 3093 128 57 certain certain JJ 3093 128 58 social social JJ 3093 128 59 group group NN 3093 128 60 in in IN 3093 128 61 a a DT 3093 128 62 specific specific JJ 3093 128 63 moment moment NN 3093 128 64 in in IN 3093 128 65 time time NN 3093 128 66 , , , 3093 128 67 a a DT 3093 128 68 trope trope NN 3093 128 69 of of IN 3093 128 70 sorts sort NNS 3093 128 71 for for IN 3093 128 72 those those DT 3093 128 73 who who WP 3093 128 74 are be VBP 3093 128 75 proud proud JJ 3093 128 76 of of IN 3093 128 77 not not RB 3093 128 78 only only RB 3093 128 79 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 128 80 relationships relationship NNS 3093 128 81 with with IN 3093 128 82 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 128 83 domestic domestic JJ 3093 128 84 pets pet NNS 3093 128 85 , , , 3093 128 86 but but CC 3093 128 87 of of IN 3093 128 88 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 128 89 shared share VBN 3093 128 90 values value NNS 3093 128 91 and and CC 3093 128 92 lifestyles lifestyle NNS 3093 128 93 as as RB 3093 128 94 well well RB 3093 128 95 . . . 3093 129 1 If if IN 3093 129 2 a a DT 3093 129 3 historian historian NN 3093 129 4 were be VBD 3093 129 5 to to TO 3093 129 6 dig dig VB 3093 129 7 deeper deeply RBR 3093 129 8 , , , 3093 129 9 he -PRON- PRP 3093 129 10 or or CC 3093 129 11 she -PRON- PRP 3093 129 12 also also RB 3093 129 13 might may MD 3093 129 14 see see VB 3093 129 15 that that IN 3093 129 16 “ " `` 3093 129 17 cat cat NNP 3093 129 18 lady lady NNP 3093 129 19 ” " '' 3093 129 20 has have VBZ 3093 129 21 historically historically RB 3093 129 22 been be VBN 3093 129 23 used use VBN 3093 129 24 in in IN 3093 129 25 a a DT 3093 129 26 derogatory derogatory JJ 3093 129 27 manner manner NN 3093 129 28 to to TO 3093 129 29 mark mark VB 3093 129 30 single single JJ 3093 129 31 , , , 3093 129 32 unattractive unattractive JJ 3093 129 33 women woman NNS 3093 129 34 thought think VBN 3093 129 35 to to TO 3093 129 36 be be VB 3093 129 37 crazy crazy JJ 3093 129 38 and and CC 3093 129 39 unable unable JJ 3093 129 40 to to TO 3093 129 41 care care VB 3093 129 42 for for IN 3093 129 43 the the DT 3093 129 44 great great JJ 3093 129 45 number number NN 3093 129 46 of of IN 3093 129 47 cats cat NNS 3093 129 48 they -PRON- PRP 3093 129 49 own own VBP 3093 129 50 and and CC 3093 129 51 that that IN 3093 129 52 , , , 3093 129 53 by by IN 3093 129 54 ( ( -LRB- 3093 129 55 re)claiming re)claiming NN 3093 129 56 this this DT 3093 129 57 title title NN 3093 129 58 , , , 3093 129 59 women woman NNS 3093 129 60 might may MD 3093 129 61 be be VB 3093 129 62 engaging engage VBG 3093 129 63 in in IN 3093 129 64 a a DT 3093 129 65 struggle struggle NN 3093 129 66 for for IN 3093 129 67 recognition recognition NN 3093 129 68 that that WDT 3093 129 69 extends extend VBZ 3093 129 70 beyond beyond IN 3093 129 71 mere mere JJ 3093 129 72 admiration admiration NN 3093 129 73 for for IN 3093 129 74 felines.39 felines.39 NNP 3093 129 75 Chowdhury Chowdhury NNP 3093 129 76 , , , 3093 129 77 in in IN 3093 129 78 a a DT 3093 129 79 continued continue VBN 3093 129 80 discussion discussion NN 3093 129 81 of of IN 3093 129 82 challenges challenge NNS 3093 129 83 facing face VBG 3093 129 84 the the DT 3093 129 85 digital digital JJ 3093 129 86 world world NN 3093 129 87 , , , 3093 129 88 asks ask VBZ 3093 129 89 whether whether IN 3093 129 90 it -PRON- PRP 3093 129 91 is be VBZ 3093 129 92 “ " `` 3093 129 93 possible possible JJ 3093 129 94 to to TO 3093 129 95 capture capture VB 3093 129 96 the the DT 3093 129 97 changing change VBG 3093 129 98 context context NN 3093 129 99 along along IN 3093 129 100 with with IN 3093 129 101 the the DT 3093 129 102 content content NN 3093 129 103 of of IN 3093 129 104 each each DT 3093 129 105 information information NN 3093 129 106 resource resource NN 3093 129 107 , , , 3093 129 108 because because IN 3093 129 109 as as IN 3093 129 110 we -PRON- PRP 3093 129 111 know know VBP 3093 129 112 the the DT 3093 129 113 use use NN 3093 129 114 and and CC 3093 129 115 importance importance NN 3093 129 116 . . . 3093 130 1 . . . 3093 131 1 . . . 3093 132 1 changes change NNS 3093 132 2 significantly significantly RB 3093 132 3 with with IN 3093 132 4 time time NN 3093 132 5 . . . 3093 132 6 ” " '' 3093 132 7 40 40 CD 3093 132 8 Additionally additionally RB 3093 132 9 , , , 3093 132 10 he -PRON- PRP 3093 132 11 INFORMATION INFORMATION VBD 3093 132 12 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3093 132 13 AND and CC 3093 132 14 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3093 132 15 | | NNP 3093 132 16 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3093 132 17 2013 2013 CD 3093 132 18 15 15 CD 3093 132 19 asks ask VBZ 3093 132 20 , , , 3093 132 21 “ " `` 3093 132 22 Will Will MD 3093 132 23 it -PRON- PRP 3093 132 24 be be VB 3093 132 25 possible possible JJ 3093 132 26 to to TO 3093 132 27 re re VB 3093 132 28 - - VB 3093 132 29 interpret interpret VB 3093 132 30 the the DT 3093 132 31 stored stored JJ 3093 132 32 digital digital JJ 3093 132 33 content content NN 3093 132 34 in in IN 3093 132 35 the the DT 3093 132 36 light light NN 3093 132 37 of of IN 3093 132 38 the the DT 3093 132 39 changing change VBG 3093 132 40 context context NN 3093 132 41 and and CC 3093 132 42 user user NN 3093 132 43 community community NN 3093 132 44 , , , 3093 132 45 and and CC 3093 132 46 thereby thereby RB 3093 132 47 re re VBG 3093 132 48 - - VBG 3093 132 49 inventing invent VBG 3093 132 50 the the DT 3093 132 51 importance importance NN 3093 132 52 and and CC 3093 132 53 use use NN 3093 132 54 of of IN 3093 132 55 the the DT 3093 132 56 stored stored JJ 3093 132 57 objects object NNS 3093 132 58 ? ? . 3093 132 59 ” " '' 3093 132 60 41 41 CD 3093 132 61 It -PRON- PRP 3093 132 62 is be VBZ 3093 132 63 here here RB 3093 132 64 that that IN 3093 132 65 the the DT 3093 132 66 searchable searchable JJ 3093 132 67 signature signature NN 3093 132 68 offers offer VBZ 3093 132 69 use use VBP 3093 132 70 data datum NNS 3093 132 71 and and CC 3093 132 72 sociohistorical sociohistorical JJ 3093 132 73 information information NN 3093 132 74 to to TO 3093 132 75 illuminate illuminate VB 3093 132 76 the the DT 3093 132 77 ( ( -LRB- 3093 132 78 changing change VBG 3093 132 79 ) ) -RRB- 3093 132 80 value value NN 3093 132 81 digital digital JJ 3093 132 82 images image NNS 3093 132 83 have have VBP 3093 132 84 for for IN 3093 132 85 individuals individual NNS 3093 132 86 , , , 3093 132 87 communities community NNS 3093 132 88 , , , 3093 132 89 and and CC 3093 132 90 society society NN 3093 132 91 . . . 3093 133 1 CONCLUSION CONCLUSION NNP 3093 133 2 Clark Clark NNP 3093 133 3 argues argue VBZ 3093 133 4 that that IN 3093 133 5 representation representation NN 3093 133 6 must must MD 3093 133 7 be be VB 3093 133 8 understood understand VBN 3093 133 9 within within IN 3093 133 10 the the DT 3093 133 11 confines confine NNS 3093 133 12 of of IN 3093 133 13 what what WP 3093 133 14 he -PRON- PRP 3093 133 15 calls call VBZ 3093 133 16 “ " `` 3093 133 17 social social JJ 3093 133 18 practice practice NN 3093 133 19 . . . 3093 133 20 ” " '' 3093 133 21 42 42 CD 3093 133 22 Social social JJ 3093 133 23 practice practice NN 3093 133 24 , , , 3093 133 25 among among IN 3093 133 26 other other JJ 3093 133 27 things thing NNS 3093 133 28 , , , 3093 133 29 can can MD 3093 133 30 be be VB 3093 133 31 understood understand VBN 3093 133 32 as as IN 3093 133 33 “ " `` 3093 133 34 the the DT 3093 133 35 overlap overlap NN 3093 133 36 and and CC 3093 133 37 interference interference NN 3093 133 38 of of IN 3093 133 39 representations representation NNS 3093 133 40 ; ; : 3093 133 41 it -PRON- PRP 3093 133 42 is be VBZ 3093 133 43 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 133 44 rearrangement rearrangement NN 3093 133 45 in in IN 3093 133 46 use use NN 3093 133 47 . . . 3093 133 48 ” " '' 3093 133 49 43 43 CD 3093 133 50 Representation Representation NNP 3093 133 51 of of IN 3093 133 52 self self NN 3093 133 53 also also RB 3093 133 54 must must MD 3093 133 55 be be VB 3093 133 56 understood understand VBN 3093 133 57 within within IN 3093 133 58 current current JJ 3093 133 59 social social JJ 3093 133 60 practice practice NN 3093 133 61 , , , 3093 133 62 and and CC 3093 133 63 an an DT 3093 133 64 important important JJ 3093 133 65 facet facet NN 3093 133 66 of of IN 3093 133 67 today today NN 3093 133 68 ’s ’s POS 3093 133 69 practice practice NN 3093 133 70 is be VBZ 3093 133 71 Web web NN 3093 133 72 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 133 73 . . . 3093 134 1 As as IN 3093 134 2 a a DT 3093 134 3 social social JJ 3093 134 4 space space NN 3093 134 5 , , , 3093 134 6 Web web NN 3093 134 7 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 134 8 allows allow NNS 3093 134 9 for for IN 3093 134 10 the the DT 3093 134 11 creation creation NN 3093 134 12 of of IN 3093 134 13 disembodied disembodied JJ 3093 134 14 self self NN 3093 134 15 - - HYPH 3093 134 16 representations representation NNS 3093 134 17 . . . 3093 135 1 One one CD 3093 135 2 type type NN 3093 135 3 of of IN 3093 135 4 such such JJ 3093 135 5 representation representation NN 3093 135 6 , , , 3093 135 7 the the DT 3093 135 8 searchable searchable JJ 3093 135 9 signature signature NN 3093 135 10 , , , 3093 135 11 is be VBZ 3093 135 12 a a DT 3093 135 13 phenomenon phenomenon NN 3093 135 14 unique unique JJ 3093 135 15 to to IN 3093 135 16 social social JJ 3093 135 17 networking networking NN 3093 135 18 sites site NNS 3093 135 19 . . . 3093 136 1 While while IN 3093 136 2 many many JJ 3093 136 3 acknowledge acknowledge VBP 3093 136 4 the the DT 3093 136 5 potential potential NN 3093 136 6 of of IN 3093 136 7 descriptive descriptive JJ 3093 136 8 , , , 3093 136 9 user user NN 3093 136 10 - - HYPH 3093 136 11 generated generate VBN 3093 136 12 tags tag NNS 3093 136 13 to to TO 3093 136 14 inform inform VB 3093 136 15 or or CC 3093 136 16 even even RB 3093 136 17 to to TO 3093 136 18 be be VB 3093 136 19 used use VBN 3093 136 20 in in IN 3093 136 21 conjunction conjunction NN 3093 136 22 with with IN 3093 136 23 metadata metadata NN 3093 136 24 schemas schema NNS 3093 136 25 or or CC 3093 136 26 controlled control VBN 3093 136 27 vocabularies vocabulary NNS 3093 136 28 , , , 3093 136 29 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 136 30 users user NNS 3093 136 31 have have VBP 3093 136 32 created create VBN 3093 136 33 an an DT 3093 136 34 additional additional JJ 3093 136 35 , , , 3093 136 36 alternative alternative JJ 3093 136 37 use use NN 3093 136 38 for for IN 3093 136 39 the the DT 3093 136 40 tag tag NN 3093 136 41 . . . 3093 137 1 Rather rather RB 3093 137 2 than than IN 3093 137 3 simply simply RB 3093 137 4 using use VBG 3093 137 5 tags tag NNS 3093 137 6 to to TO 3093 137 7 describe describe VB 3093 137 8 shared share VBN 3093 137 9 images image NNS 3093 137 10 , , , 3093 137 11 they -PRON- PRP 3093 137 12 have have VBP 3093 137 13 successfully successfully RB 3093 137 14 created create VBN 3093 137 15 a a DT 3093 137 16 route route NN 3093 137 17 to to IN 3093 137 18 online online JJ 3093 137 19 identity identity NN 3093 137 20 formation formation NN 3093 137 21 and and CC 3093 137 22 recognition recognition NN 3093 137 23 . . . 3093 138 1 Searchable searchable JJ 3093 138 2 signatures signature NNS 3093 138 3 demonstrate demonstrate VBP 3093 138 4 the the DT 3093 138 5 power power NN 3093 138 6 of of IN 3093 138 7 the the DT 3093 138 8 online online JJ 3093 138 9 self self NN 3093 138 10 , , , 3093 138 11 as as IN 3093 138 12 they -PRON- PRP 3093 138 13 allow allow VBP 3093 138 14 users user NNS 3093 138 15 to to TO 3093 138 16 struggle struggle VB 3093 138 17 to to TO 3093 138 18 be be VB 3093 138 19 recognized recognize VBN 3093 138 20 as as IN 3093 138 21 unique unique JJ 3093 138 22 individuals individual NNS 3093 138 23 or or CC 3093 138 24 as as IN 3093 138 25 parts part NNS 3093 138 26 of of IN 3093 138 27 larger large JJR 3093 138 28 social social JJ 3093 138 29 groups group NNS 3093 138 30 . . . 3093 139 1 These these DT 3093 139 2 signatures signature NNS 3093 139 3 , , , 3093 139 4 too too RB 3093 139 5 , , , 3093 139 6 might may MD 3093 139 7 act act VB 3093 139 8 as as IN 3093 139 9 platforms platform NNS 3093 139 10 on on IN 3093 139 11 which which WDT 3093 139 12 social social JJ 3093 139 13 groups group NNS 3093 139 14 can can MD 3093 139 15 assert assert VB 3093 139 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 139 17 value value NN 3093 139 18 and and CC 3093 139 19 thus thus RB 3093 139 20 demand demand NN 3093 139 21 recognition recognition NN 3093 139 22 . . . 3093 140 1 Additionally additionally RB 3093 140 2 , , , 3093 140 3 searchable searchable JJ 3093 140 4 signatures signature NNS 3093 140 5 provide provide VBP 3093 140 6 contextual contextual JJ 3093 140 7 information information NN 3093 140 8 that that WDT 3093 140 9 reflects reflect VBZ 3093 140 10 the the DT 3093 140 11 social social JJ 3093 140 12 practice practice NN 3093 140 13 in in IN 3093 140 14 which which WDT 3093 140 15 digital digital JJ 3093 140 16 images image NNS 3093 140 17 live live VBP 3093 140 18 . . . 3093 141 1 While while IN 3093 141 2 the the DT 3093 141 3 capture capture NN 3093 141 4 and and CC 3093 141 5 integration integration NN 3093 141 6 of of IN 3093 141 7 such such JJ 3093 141 8 information information NN 3093 141 9 remains remain VBZ 3093 141 10 a a DT 3093 141 11 challenge challenge NN 3093 141 12 for for IN 3093 141 13 those those DT 3093 141 14 engaged engage VBN 3093 141 15 in in IN 3093 141 16 traditional traditional JJ 3093 141 17 indexing indexing NN 3093 141 18 , , , 3093 141 19 Web web NN 3093 141 20 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 141 21 allows allow NNS 3093 141 22 for for IN 3093 141 23 this this DT 3093 141 24 unique unique JJ 3093 141 25 type type NN 3093 141 26 of of IN 3093 141 27 user- user- NN 3093 141 28 generated generate VBN 3093 141 29 tag tag NN 3093 141 30 and and CC 3093 141 31 thus thus RB 3093 141 32 provides provide VBZ 3093 141 33 better well JJR 3093 141 34 understanding understanding NN 3093 141 35 of of IN 3093 141 36 the the DT 3093 141 37 context context NN 3093 141 38 surrounding surround VBG 3093 141 39 digital digital JJ 3093 141 40 images image NNS 3093 141 41 . . . 3093 142 1 As as IN 3093 142 2 to to IN 3093 142 3 the the DT 3093 142 4 question question NN 3093 142 5 of of IN 3093 142 6 whether whether IN 3093 142 7 searchable searchable JJ 3093 142 8 signatures signature NNS 3093 142 9 can can MD 3093 142 10 be be VB 3093 142 11 integrated integrate VBN 3093 142 12 into into IN 3093 142 13 existing existing JJ 3093 142 14 metadata metadata NN 3093 142 15 schemas schema NNS 3093 142 16 or or CC 3093 142 17 be be VB 3093 142 18 used use VBN 3093 142 19 to to TO 3093 142 20 inform inform VB 3093 142 21 controlled control VBN 3093 142 22 vocabularies vocabulary NNS 3093 142 23 in in IN 3093 142 24 library library JJ 3093 142 25 environments environment NNS 3093 142 26 , , , 3093 142 27 it -PRON- PRP 3093 142 28 is be VBZ 3093 142 29 not not RB 3093 142 30 unreasonable unreasonable JJ 3093 142 31 to to TO 3093 142 32 suggest suggest VB 3093 142 33 that that IN 3093 142 34 digital digital JJ 3093 142 35 objects object NNS 3093 142 36 be be VB 3093 142 37 accompanied accompany VBN 3093 142 38 by by IN 3093 142 39 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 142 40 supplemental supplemental JJ 3093 142 41 yet yet CC 3093 142 42 valuable valuable JJ 3093 142 43 representations representation NNS 3093 142 44 ( ( -LRB- 3093 142 45 e.g. e.g. RB 3093 142 46 , , , 3093 142 47 searchable searchable JJ 3093 142 48 signatures signature NNS 3093 142 49 and and CC 3093 142 50 the the DT 3093 142 51 like like JJ 3093 142 52 ) ) -RRB- 3093 142 53 . . . 3093 143 1 Many many JJ 3093 143 2 methods method NNS 3093 143 3 exist exist VBP 3093 143 4 through through IN 3093 143 5 which which WDT 3093 143 6 these these DT 3093 143 7 signatures signature NNS 3093 143 8 might may MD 3093 143 9 be be VB 3093 143 10 both both DT 3093 143 11 gathered gather VBN 3093 143 12 and and CC 3093 143 13 displayed display VBN 3093 143 14 . . . 3093 144 1 Certainly certainly RB 3093 144 2 , , , 3093 144 3 a a DT 3093 144 4 full full JJ 3093 144 5 exploration exploration NN 3093 144 6 of of IN 3093 144 7 such such JJ 3093 144 8 practices practice NNS 3093 144 9 is be VBZ 3093 144 10 the the DT 3093 144 11 stuff stuff NN 3093 144 12 of of IN 3093 144 13 future future JJ 3093 144 14 research research NN 3093 144 15 ; ; : 3093 144 16 however however RB 3093 144 17 , , , 3093 144 18 some some DT 3093 144 19 initial initial JJ 3093 144 20 ideas idea NNS 3093 144 21 are be VBP 3093 144 22 detailed detail VBN 3093 144 23 below below RB 3093 144 24 . . . 3093 145 1 One one CD 3093 145 2 method method NN 3093 145 3 of of IN 3093 145 4 gathering gather VBG 3093 145 5 identity identity NN 3093 145 6 - - HYPH 3093 145 7 based base VBN 3093 145 8 tags tag NNS 3093 145 9 would would MD 3093 145 10 involve involve VB 3093 145 11 the the DT 3093 145 12 active active JJ 3093 145 13 hunting hunting NN 3093 145 14 down down RP 3093 145 15 of of IN 3093 145 16 searchable searchable JJ 3093 145 17 signatures signature NNS 3093 145 18 . . . 3093 146 1 Locating locate VBG 3093 146 2 objects object NNS 3093 146 3 on on IN 3093 146 4 social social JJ 3093 146 5 networking networking NN 3093 146 6 sites site NNS 3093 146 7 that that WDT 3093 146 8 are be VBP 3093 146 9 also also RB 3093 146 10 in in IN 3093 146 11 one one NN 3093 146 12 ’s ’s NN 3093 146 13 digital digital JJ 3093 146 14 collection collection NN 3093 146 15 , , , 3093 146 16 the the DT 3093 146 17 indexer indexer NN 3093 146 18 would would MD 3093 146 19 identify identify VB 3093 146 20 and and CC 3093 146 21 track track VB 3093 146 22 associated associate VBN 3093 146 23 user user NN 3093 146 24 - - HYPH 3093 146 25 generated generate VBN 3093 146 26 searchable searchable JJ 3093 146 27 signatures signature NNS 3093 146 28 . . . 3093 147 1 This this DT 3093 147 2 method method NN 3093 147 3 would would MD 3093 147 4 require require VB 3093 147 5 extreme extreme JJ 3093 147 6 diligence diligence NN 3093 147 7 , , , 3093 147 8 high high JJ 3093 147 9 levels level NNS 3093 147 10 of of IN 3093 147 11 comfort comfort NN 3093 147 12 navigating navigating NN 3093 147 13 and and CC 3093 147 14 using use VBG 3093 147 15 Web web NN 3093 147 16 2.0 2.0 CD 3093 147 17 , , , 3093 147 18 a a DT 3093 147 19 clear clear JJ 3093 147 20 idea idea NN 3093 147 21 of of IN 3093 147 22 which which WDT 3093 147 23 social social JJ 3093 147 24 networking networking NN 3093 147 25 sites site NNS 3093 147 26 yield yield VBP 3093 147 27 the the DT 3093 147 28 most most RBS 3093 147 29 valuable valuable JJ 3093 147 30 searchable searchable JJ 3093 147 31 signatures signature NNS 3093 147 32 , , , 3093 147 33 and and CC 3093 147 34 likely likely RB 3093 147 35 one one CD 3093 147 36 or or CC 3093 147 37 more more JJR 3093 147 38 full full JJ 3093 147 39 - - HYPH 3093 147 40 time time NN 3093 147 41 staff staff NN 3093 147 42 members member NNS 3093 147 43 devoted devote VBN 3093 147 44 to to IN 3093 147 45 such such JJ 3093 147 46 activities activity NNS 3093 147 47 . . . 3093 148 1 Even even RB 3093 148 2 if if IN 3093 148 3 feed feed NN 3093 148 4 systems system NNS 3093 148 5 were be VBD 3093 148 6 employed employ VBN 3093 148 7 for for IN 3093 148 8 individual individual JJ 3093 148 9 digital digital JJ 3093 148 10 objects object NNS 3093 148 11 , , , 3093 148 12 this this DT 3093 148 13 method method NN 3093 148 14 demands demand VBZ 3093 148 15 much much JJ 3093 148 16 of of IN 3093 148 17 indexers indexer NNS 3093 148 18 and and CC 3093 148 19 would would MD 3093 148 20 likely likely RB 3093 148 21 not not RB 3093 148 22 be be VB 3093 148 23 sustainable sustainable JJ 3093 148 24 over over IN 3093 148 25 time time NN 3093 148 26 . . . 3093 149 1 SEARCHABLE SEARCHABLE NNP 3093 149 2 SIGNATURES SIGNATURES NNP 3093 149 3 : : : 3093 149 4 CONTEXT context NN 3093 149 5 AND and CC 3093 149 6 THE the DT 3093 149 7 STRUGGLE struggle NN 3093 149 8 FOR for IN 3093 149 9 RECOGNITION RECOGNITION NNP 3093 149 10 | | CD 3093 149 11 SCHLESSELMAN SCHLESSELMAN NNP 3093 149 12 - - HYPH 3093 149 13 TARANGO TARANGO NNP 3093 149 14 16 16 CD 3093 149 15 A a DT 3093 149 16 more more RBR 3093 149 17 passive passive JJ 3093 149 18 yet yet CC 3093 149 19 efficient efficient JJ 3093 149 20 way way NN 3093 149 21 of of IN 3093 149 22 gathering gather VBG 3093 149 23 searchable searchable JJ 3093 149 24 signatures signature NNS 3093 149 25 would would MD 3093 149 26 simply simply RB 3093 149 27 be be VB 3093 149 28 to to TO 3093 149 29 build build VB 3093 149 30 on on IN 3093 149 31 methods method NNS 3093 149 32 that that WDT 3093 149 33 have have VBP 3093 149 34 shown show VBN 3093 149 35 to to TO 3093 149 36 be be VB 3093 149 37 successful successful JJ 3093 149 38 . . . 3093 150 1 By by IN 3093 150 2 creating create VBG 3093 150 3 interactive interactive JJ 3093 150 4 digital digital JJ 3093 150 5 environments environment NNS 3093 150 6 that that WDT 3093 150 7 encourage encourage VBP 3093 150 8 users user NNS 3093 150 9 to to TO 3093 150 10 assign assign VB 3093 150 11 not not RB 3093 150 12 only only RB 3093 150 13 descriptive descriptive JJ 3093 150 14 but but CC 3093 150 15 also also RB 3093 150 16 identity identity NN 3093 150 17 - - HYPH 3093 150 18 based base VBN 3093 150 19 tags tag NNS 3093 150 20 , , , 3093 150 21 indexers indexer NNS 3093 150 22 are be VBP 3093 150 23 freed free VBN 3093 150 24 of of IN 3093 150 25 the the DT 3093 150 26 time time NN 3093 150 27 - - HYPH 3093 150 28 consuming consume VBG 3093 150 29 task task NN 3093 150 30 of of IN 3093 150 31 hunting hunting NN 3093 150 32 for for IN 3093 150 33 searchable searchable JJ 3093 150 34 signatures signature NNS 3093 150 35 on on IN 3093 150 36 the the DT 3093 150 37 web web NN 3093 150 38 . . . 3093 151 1 Since since IN 3093 151 2 searchable searchable JJ 3093 151 3 signatures signature NNS 3093 151 4 have have VBP 3093 151 5 come come VBN 3093 151 6 to to TO 3093 151 7 be be VB 3093 151 8 part part NN 3093 151 9 of of IN 3093 151 10 online online JJ 3093 151 11 social social JJ 3093 151 12 practice practice NN 3093 151 13 , , , 3093 151 14 the the DT 3093 151 15 assigning assigning NN 3093 151 16 of of IN 3093 151 17 them -PRON- PRP 3093 151 18 would would MD 3093 151 19 likely likely RB 3093 151 20 be be VB 3093 151 21 familiar familiar JJ 3093 151 22 to to IN 3093 151 23 users user NNS 3093 151 24 — — : 3093 151 25 initially initially RB 3093 151 26 , , , 3093 151 27 libraries library NNS 3093 151 28 might may MD 3093 151 29 need need VB 3093 151 30 to to TO 3093 151 31 prompt prompt VB 3093 151 32 users user NNS 3093 151 33 to to TO 3093 151 34 share share VB 3093 151 35 signatures signature NNS 3093 151 36 or or CC 3093 151 37 provide provide VB 3093 151 38 them -PRON- PRP 3093 151 39 with with IN 3093 151 40 examples example NNS 3093 151 41 . . . 3093 152 1 This this DT 3093 152 2 gathering gathering NN 3093 152 3 tactic tactic NN 3093 152 4 could could MD 3093 152 5 be be VB 3093 152 6 used use VBN 3093 152 7 to to TO 3093 152 8 harvest harvest VB 3093 152 9 signatures signature NNS 3093 152 10 for for IN 3093 152 11 items item NNS 3093 152 12 that that WDT 3093 152 13 are be VBP 3093 152 14 already already RB 3093 152 15 part part NN 3093 152 16 of of IN 3093 152 17 the the DT 3093 152 18 library library NN 3093 152 19 ’s ’s POS 3093 152 20 digital digital JJ 3093 152 21 collection collection NN 3093 152 22 ( ( -LRB- 3093 152 23 telling tell VBG 3093 152 24 us -PRON- PRP 3093 152 25 about about IN 3093 152 26 signatures signature NNS 3093 152 27 used use VBN 3093 152 28 by by IN 3093 152 29 potential potential JJ 3093 152 30 sharers sharer NNS 3093 152 31 ) ) -RRB- 3093 152 32 or or CC 3093 152 33 as as IN 3093 152 34 a a DT 3093 152 35 means means NN 3093 152 36 to to TO 3093 152 37 incorporate incorporate VB 3093 152 38 new new JJ 3093 152 39 digital digital JJ 3093 152 40 objects object NNS 3093 152 41 into into IN 3093 152 42 the the DT 3093 152 43 collection collection NN 3093 152 44 ( ( -LRB- 3093 152 45 telling tell VBG 3093 152 46 us -PRON- PRP 3093 152 47 about about IN 3093 152 48 signatures signature NNS 3093 152 49 used use VBN 3093 152 50 by by IN 3093 152 51 both both DT 3093 152 52 creators creator NNS 3093 152 53 and and CC 3093 152 54 sharers sharer NNS 3093 152 55 ) ) -RRB- 3093 152 56 . . . 3093 153 1 In in IN 3093 153 2 both both DT 3093 153 3 gathering gathering NN 3093 153 4 scenarios scenario NNS 3093 153 5 , , , 3093 153 6 indexers indexer NNS 3093 153 7 might may MD 3093 153 8 choose choose VB 3093 153 9 to to TO 3093 153 10 display display VB 3093 153 11 only only RB 3093 153 12 the the DT 3093 153 13 most most RBS 3093 153 14 occurring occurring JJ 3093 153 15 or or CC 3093 153 16 what what WP 3093 153 17 they -PRON- PRP 3093 153 18 deem deem VBP 3093 153 19 to to TO 3093 153 20 be be VB 3093 153 21 the the DT 3093 153 22 most most RBS 3093 153 23 relevant relevant JJ 3093 153 24 searchable searchable JJ 3093 153 25 signatures signature NNS 3093 153 26 , , , 3093 153 27 or or CC 3093 153 28 they -PRON- PRP 3093 153 29 might may MD 3093 153 30 choose choose VB 3093 153 31 to to TO 3093 153 32 display display VB 3093 153 33 all all DT 3093 153 34 such such JJ 3093 153 35 tags tag NNS 3093 153 36 ; ; : 3093 153 37 decisions decision NNS 3093 153 38 such such JJ 3093 153 39 as as IN 3093 153 40 these these DT 3093 153 41 will will MD 3093 153 42 ultimately ultimately RB 3093 153 43 depend depend VB 3093 153 44 on on IN 3093 153 45 each each DT 3093 153 46 institution institution NN 3093 153 47 ’s ’s POS 3093 153 48 mission mission NN 3093 153 49 and and CC 3093 153 50 resources resource NNS 3093 153 51 . . . 3093 154 1 Of of RB 3093 154 2 course course RB 3093 154 3 , , , 3093 154 4 if if IN 3093 154 5 a a DT 3093 154 6 library library NN 3093 154 7 integrates integrate VBZ 3093 154 8 a a DT 3093 154 9 born bear VBN 3093 154 10 - - HYPH 3093 154 11 digital digital JJ 3093 154 12 image image NN 3093 154 13 into into IN 3093 154 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 3093 154 15 collection collection NN 3093 154 16 and and CC 3093 154 17 can can MD 3093 154 18 identify identify VB 3093 154 19 the the DT 3093 154 20 searchable searchable JJ 3093 154 21 signatures signature NNS 3093 154 22 originally originally RB 3093 154 23 assigned assign VBN 3093 154 24 to to IN 3093 154 25 it -PRON- PRP 3093 154 26 via via IN 3093 154 27 social social JJ 3093 154 28 networking networking NN 3093 154 29 sites site NNS 3093 154 30 or or CC 3093 154 31 otherwise otherwise RB 3093 154 32 , , , 3093 154 33 this this DT 3093 154 34 information information NN 3093 154 35 should should MD 3093 154 36 also also RB 3093 154 37 be be VB 3093 154 38 recorded record VBN 3093 154 39 . . . 3093 155 1 Here here RB 3093 155 2 , , , 3093 155 3 users user NNS 3093 155 4 will will MD 3093 155 5 be be VB 3093 155 6 able able JJ 3093 155 7 to to TO 3093 155 8 get get VB 3093 155 9 a a DT 3093 155 10 glimpse glimpse NN 3093 155 11 of of IN 3093 155 12 the the DT 3093 155 13 image image NN 3093 155 14 in in IN 3093 155 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 3093 155 16 pre pre JJ 3093 155 17 - - JJ 3093 155 18 library library JJ 3093 155 19 life life NN 3093 155 20 . . . 3093 156 1 Providing provide VBG 3093 156 2 associated associate VBN 3093 156 3 usernames username NNS 3093 156 4 , , , 3093 156 5 dates date VBZ 3093 156 6 posted post VBN 3093 156 7 , , , 3093 156 8 and and CC 3093 156 9 the the DT 3093 156 10 name name NN 3093 156 11 of of IN 3093 156 12 the the DT 3093 156 13 social social JJ 3093 156 14 networking networking NN 3093 156 15 sites site NNS 3093 156 16 too too RB 3093 156 17 will will MD 3093 156 18 assist assist VB 3093 156 19 in in IN 3093 156 20 providing provide VBG 3093 156 21 a a DT 3093 156 22 more more RBR 3093 156 23 complete complete JJ 3093 156 24 picture picture NN 3093 156 25 of of IN 3093 156 26 the the DT 3093 156 27 individuals individual NNS 3093 156 28 or or CC 3093 156 29 groups group NNS 3093 156 30 linked link VBN 3093 156 31 to to IN 3093 156 32 the the DT 3093 156 33 image image NN 3093 156 34 . . . 3093 157 1 This this DT 3093 157 2 information information NN 3093 157 3 can can MD 3093 157 4 provide provide VB 3093 157 5 valuable valuable JJ 3093 157 6 data datum NNS 3093 157 7 about about IN 3093 157 8 the the DT 3093 157 9 information information NN 3093 157 10 creators creator NNS 3093 157 11 and and CC 3093 157 12 sharers sharer NNS 3093 157 13 who who WP 3093 157 14 use use VBP 3093 157 15 specific specific JJ 3093 157 16 social social JJ 3093 157 17 platforms platform NNS 3093 157 18 . . . 3093 158 1 The the DT 3093 158 2 aim aim NN 3093 158 3 of of IN 3093 158 4 this this DT 3093 158 5 paper paper NN 3093 158 6 is be VBZ 3093 158 7 to to TO 3093 158 8 lay lay VB 3093 158 9 the the DT 3093 158 10 theoretical theoretical JJ 3093 158 11 groundwork groundwork NN 3093 158 12 to to TO 3093 158 13 better well RBR 3093 158 14 understand understand VB 3093 158 15 the the DT 3093 158 16 role role NN 3093 158 17 of of IN 3093 158 18 searchable searchable JJ 3093 158 19 signatures signature NNS 3093 158 20 in in IN 3093 158 21 today today NN 3093 158 22 ’s ’s POS 3093 158 23 digital digital JJ 3093 158 24 environment environment NN 3093 158 25 as as RB 3093 158 26 well well RB 3093 158 27 as as IN 3093 158 28 the the DT 3093 158 29 signature signature NN 3093 158 30 ’s ’s POS 3093 158 31 unique unique JJ 3093 158 32 ability ability NN 3093 158 33 to to TO 3093 158 34 provide provide VB 3093 158 35 context context NN 3093 158 36 for for IN 3093 158 37 digital digital JJ 3093 158 38 images image NNS 3093 158 39 . . . 3093 159 1 Surely surely RB 3093 159 2 , , , 3093 159 3 further further JJ 3093 159 4 research research NN 3093 159 5 into into IN 3093 159 6 the the DT 3093 159 7 phenomenon phenomenon NN 3093 159 8 of of IN 3093 159 9 the the DT 3093 159 10 searchable searchable JJ 3093 159 11 signature signature NN 3093 159 12 would would MD 3093 159 13 demonstrate demonstrate VB 3093 159 14 how how WRB 3093 159 15 it -PRON- PRP 3093 159 16 is be VBZ 3093 159 17 currently currently RB 3093 159 18 used use VBN 3093 159 19 outside outside RB 3093 159 20 of of IN 3093 159 21 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 159 22 or or CC 3093 159 23 as as IN 3093 159 24 a a DT 3093 159 25 political political JJ 3093 159 26 tool tool NN 3093 159 27 . . . 3093 160 1 Others other NNS 3093 160 2 might may MD 3093 160 3 consider consider VB 3093 160 4 examining examine VBG 3093 160 5 the the DT 3093 160 6 username username NN 3093 160 7 as as IN 3093 160 8 another another DT 3093 160 9 arena arena NN 3093 160 10 in in IN 3093 160 11 which which WDT 3093 160 12 individuals individual NNS 3093 160 13 or or CC 3093 160 14 groups group NNS 3093 160 15 construct construct VBP 3093 160 16 and and CC 3093 160 17 perform perform VBP 3093 160 18 online online JJ 3093 160 19 identities identity NNS 3093 160 20 and and CC 3093 160 21 thus thus RB 3093 160 22 engage engage VB 3093 160 23 in in IN 3093 160 24 struggles struggle NNS 3093 160 25 for for IN 3093 160 26 recognition recognition NN 3093 160 27 . . . 3093 161 1 Usernames username NNS 3093 161 2 also also RB 3093 161 3 might may MD 3093 161 4 provide provide VB 3093 161 5 contextual contextual JJ 3093 161 6 use use NN 3093 161 7 data datum NNS 3093 161 8 and and CC 3093 161 9 sociohistorical sociohistorical JJ 3093 161 10 information information NN 3093 161 11 that that WDT 3093 161 12 inevitably inevitably RB 3093 161 13 support support VBP 3093 161 14 greater great JJR 3093 161 15 understanding understanding NN 3093 161 16 of of IN 3093 161 17 digital digital JJ 3093 161 18 objects object NNS 3093 161 19 . . . 3093 162 1 Finally finally RB 3093 162 2 , , , 3093 162 3 further further JJ 3093 162 4 research research NN 3093 162 5 is be VBZ 3093 162 6 needed need VBN 3093 162 7 to to TO 3093 162 8 identify identify VB 3093 162 9 how how WRB 3093 162 10 libraries library NNS 3093 162 11 could could MD 3093 162 12 utilize utilize VB 3093 162 13 the the DT 3093 162 14 searchable searchable JJ 3093 162 15 signature signature NN 3093 162 16 in in IN 3093 162 17 promotional promotional JJ 3093 162 18 activities activity NNS 3093 162 19 and and CC 3093 162 20 to to TO 3093 162 21 build build VB 3093 162 22 and and CC 3093 162 23 cater cater VB 3093 162 24 to to TO 3093 162 25 user user VB 3093 162 26 communities community NNS 3093 162 27 . . . 3093 163 1 REFERENCES reference NNS 3093 163 2 1 1 CD 3093 163 3 . . . 3093 164 1 Axel Axel NNP 3093 164 2 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 164 3 , , , 3093 164 4 The the DT 3093 164 5 Struggle Struggle NNP 3093 164 6 for for IN 3093 164 7 Recognition Recognition NNP 3093 164 8 : : : 3093 164 9 The the DT 3093 164 10 Moral Moral NNP 3093 164 11 Grammar Grammar NNP 3093 164 12 of of IN 3093 164 13 Social Social NNP 3093 164 14 Conflicts Conflicts NNPS 3093 164 15 ( ( -LRB- 3093 164 16 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 3093 164 17 : : : 3093 164 18 MIT MIT NNP 3093 164 19 Press Press NNP 3093 164 20 , , , 3093 164 21 1995 1995 CD 3093 164 22 ) ) -RRB- 3093 164 23 . . . 3093 165 1 2 2 LS 3093 165 2 . . . 3093 166 1 Lauane Lauane NNP 3093 166 2 Baroncelli Baroncelli NNP 3093 166 3 and and CC 3093 166 4 Andre Andre NNP 3093 166 5 Freitas Freitas NNP 3093 166 6 , , , 3093 166 7 “ " `` 3093 166 8 The the DT 3093 166 9 Visibility visibility NN 3093 166 10 of of IN 3093 166 11 the the DT 3093 166 12 Self Self NNP 3093 166 13 on on IN 3093 166 14 the the DT 3093 166 15 Web web NN 3093 166 16 : : : 3093 166 17 A a DT 3093 166 18 Struggle Struggle NNP 3093 166 19 for for IN 3093 166 20 Recognition Recognition NNP 3093 166 21 , , , 3093 166 22 ” " '' 3093 166 23 In in IN 3093 166 24 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 3093 166 25 of of IN 3093 166 26 3rd 3rd NNP 3093 166 27 ACM ACM NNP 3093 166 28 International International NNP 3093 166 29 Conference Conference NNP 3093 166 30 on on IN 3093 166 31 Web Web NNP 3093 166 32 Science Science NNP 3093 166 33 , , , 3093 166 34 2011 2011 CD 3093 166 35 , , , 3093 166 36 accessed access VBD 3093 166 37 August August NNP 3093 166 38 12 12 CD 3093 166 39 , , , 3093 166 40 2013 2013 CD 3093 166 41 , , , 3093 166 42 www.websci11.org/fileadmin/websci/Posters/191_paper.pdf www.websci11.org/fileadmin/websci/posters/191_paper.pdf CD 3093 166 43 . . . 3093 167 1 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 3093 167 2 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 3093 167 3 AND and CC 3093 167 4 LIBRARIES library NNS 3093 167 5 | | NNP 3093 167 6 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3093 167 7 2013 2013 CD 3093 167 8 17 17 CD 3093 167 9 3 3 CD 3093 167 10 . . . 3093 168 1 Jose Jose NNP 3093 168 2 van van NNP 3093 168 3 Dijck Dijck NNP 3093 168 4 , , , 3093 168 5 “ " `` 3093 168 6 Facebook Facebook NNP 3093 168 7 as as IN 3093 168 8 a a DT 3093 168 9 Tool Tool NNP 3093 168 10 for for IN 3093 168 11 Producing Producing NNP 3093 168 12 Sociality Sociality NNP 3093 168 13 and and CC 3093 168 14 Connectivity Connectivity NNP 3093 168 15 , , , 3093 168 16 ” " '' 3093 168 17 Television Television NNP 3093 168 18 & & CC 3093 168 19 New New NNP 3093 168 20 Media Media NNP 3093 168 21 13 13 CD 3093 168 22 , , , 3093 168 23 no no UH 3093 168 24 . . . 3093 169 1 2 2 CD 3093 169 2 ( ( -LRB- 3093 169 3 2012 2012 CD 3093 169 4 ) ) -RRB- 3093 169 5 : : : 3093 169 6 160–76 160–76 CD 3093 169 7 ; ; : 3093 169 8 Baroncelli Baroncelli NNP 3093 169 9 and and CC 3093 169 10 Freitas Freitas NNP 3093 169 11 , , , 3093 169 12 “ " `` 3093 169 13 The the DT 3093 169 14 Visibility visibility NN 3093 169 15 of of IN 3093 169 16 the the DT 3093 169 17 Self Self NNP 3093 169 18 . . . 3093 169 19 ” " '' 3093 169 20 4 4 CD 3093 169 21 . . . 3093 170 1 T. T. NNP 3093 170 2 J. J. NNP 3093 170 3 Clark Clark NNP 3093 170 4 , , , 3093 170 5 introduction introduction NN 3093 170 6 to to IN 3093 170 7 The the DT 3093 170 8 Painting Painting NNP 3093 170 9 of of IN 3093 170 10 Modern modern JJ 3093 170 11 Life Life NNP 3093 170 12 : : : 3093 170 13 Paris Paris NNP 3093 170 14 in in IN 3093 170 15 the the DT 3093 170 16 Art Art NNP 3093 170 17 of of IN 3093 170 18 Manet Manet NNP 3093 170 19 and and CC 3093 170 20 His -PRON- PRP$ 3093 170 21 Followers follower NNS 3093 170 22 ( ( -LRB- 3093 170 23 Princeton Princeton NNP 3093 170 24 , , , 3093 170 25 NJ NJ NNP 3093 170 26 : : : 3093 170 27 Princeton Princeton NNP 3093 170 28 University University NNP 3093 170 29 Press Press NNP 3093 170 30 , , , 3093 170 31 1984 1984 CD 3093 170 32 ) ) -RRB- 3093 170 33 , , , 3093 170 34 1–22 1–22 CD 3093 170 35 . . . 3093 171 1 5 5 CD 3093 171 2 . . . 3093 172 1 Ibid ibid RB 3093 172 2 . . . 3093 173 1 6 6 CD 3093 173 2 . . . 3093 174 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3093 174 2 . . . 3093 174 3 , , , 3093 174 4 9 9 CD 3093 174 5 . . . 3093 175 1 7 7 LS 3093 175 2 . . . 3093 176 1 Baroncelli Baroncelli NNP 3093 176 2 and and CC 3093 176 3 Freitas Freitas NNP 3093 176 4 , , , 3093 176 5 “ " `` 3093 176 6 The the DT 3093 176 7 Visibility visibility NN 3093 176 8 of of IN 3093 176 9 the the DT 3093 176 10 Self Self NNP 3093 176 11 . . . 3093 176 12 ” " '' 3093 176 13 8 8 CD 3093 176 14 . . . 3093 177 1 Ibid ibid RB 3093 177 2 . . . 3093 178 1 9 9 CD 3093 178 2 . . . 3093 179 1 Soraj Soraj NNP 3093 179 2 Hongladarom Hongladarom NNP 3093 179 3 , , , 3093 179 4 “ " `` 3093 179 5 Personal Personal NNP 3093 179 6 Identity Identity NNP 3093 179 7 and and CC 3093 179 8 the the DT 3093 179 9 Self self NN 3093 179 10 in in IN 3093 179 11 the the DT 3093 179 12 Online Online NNP 3093 179 13 and and CC 3093 179 14 Offline Offline NNP 3093 179 15 World World NNP 3093 179 16 , , , 3093 179 17 ” " '' 3093 179 18 Minds Minds NNPS 3093 179 19 & & CC 3093 179 20 Machines Machines NNPS 3093 179 21 21 21 CD 3093 179 22 ( ( -LRB- 3093 179 23 2011 2011 CD 3093 179 24 ) ) -RRB- 3093 179 25 : : : 3093 179 26 533–48 533–48 CD 3093 179 27 . . . 3093 180 1 10 10 CD 3093 180 2 . . . 3093 181 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3093 181 2 . . . 3093 181 3 , , , 3093 181 4 541 541 CD 3093 181 5 . . . 3093 182 1 11 11 CD 3093 182 2 . . . 3093 183 1 Erika Erika NNP 3093 183 2 Pearson Pearson NNP 3093 183 3 , , , 3093 183 4 “ " `` 3093 183 5 All all PDT 3093 183 6 the the DT 3093 183 7 World World NNP 3093 183 8 Wide Wide NNP 3093 183 9 Web Web NNP 3093 183 10 ’s ’s NN 3093 183 11 a a DT 3093 183 12 Stage stage NN 3093 183 13 : : : 3093 183 14 The the DT 3093 183 15 Performance Performance NNP 3093 183 16 of of IN 3093 183 17 Identity Identity NNP 3093 183 18 in in IN 3093 183 19 Online Online NNP 3093 183 20 Social Social NNP 3093 183 21 Networks Networks NNPS 3093 183 22 , , , 3093 183 23 ” " '' 3093 183 24 First First NNP 3093 183 25 Monday Monday NNP 3093 183 26 14 14 CD 3093 183 27 ( ( -LRB- 3093 183 28 2009 2009 CD 3093 183 29 ) ) -RRB- 3093 183 30 , , , 3093 183 31 accessed access VBD 3093 183 32 November November NNP 3093 183 33 9 9 CD 3093 183 34 , , , 3093 183 35 2012 2012 CD 3093 183 36 , , , 3093 183 37 www.uic.edu/htbin/cgiwrap/bin/ojs/index.php/fm www.uic.edu/htbin/cgiwrap/bin/ojs/index.php/fm NNP 3093 183 38 ; ; : 3093 183 39 Erving Erving NNP 3093 183 40 Goffman Goffman NNP 3093 183 41 , , , 3093 183 42 The the DT 3093 183 43 Presentation Presentation NNP 3093 183 44 of of IN 3093 183 45 Self Self NNP 3093 183 46 in in IN 3093 183 47 Everyday Everyday NNP 3093 183 48 Life Life NNP 3093 183 49 ( ( -LRB- 3093 183 50 Garden Garden NNP 3093 183 51 City City NNP 3093 183 52 , , , 3093 183 53 NY NY NNP 3093 183 54 : : : 3093 183 55 Doubleday Doubleday NNP 3093 183 56 , , , 3093 183 57 1959 1959 CD 3093 183 58 ) ) -RRB- 3093 183 59 . . . 3093 184 1 12 12 CD 3093 184 2 . . . 3093 185 1 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 185 2 , , , 3093 185 3 The the DT 3093 185 4 Struggle Struggle NNP 3093 185 5 for for IN 3093 185 6 Recognition Recognition NNP 3093 185 7 , , , 3093 185 8 1 1 CD 3093 185 9 . . . 3093 186 1 13 13 CD 3093 186 2 . . . 3093 187 1 Jurgen Jurgen NNP 3093 187 2 Habermas Habermas NNP 3093 187 3 , , , 3093 187 4 The the DT 3093 187 5 Theory Theory NNP 3093 187 6 of of IN 3093 187 7 Communicative Communicative NNP 3093 187 8 Action Action NNP 3093 187 9 ( ( -LRB- 3093 187 10 Boston Boston NNP 3093 187 11 : : : 3093 187 12 Beacon Beacon NNP 3093 187 13 , , , 3093 187 14 1984 1984 CD 3093 187 15 ) ) -RRB- 3093 187 16 ; ; : 3093 187 17 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 187 18 , , , 3093 187 19 The the DT 3093 187 20 Struggle Struggle NNP 3093 187 21 for for IN 3093 187 22 Recognition Recognition NNP 3093 187 23 , , , 3093 187 24 92 92 CD 3093 187 25 . . . 3093 188 1 14 14 CD 3093 188 2 . . . 3093 189 1 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 189 2 , , , 3093 189 3 The the DT 3093 189 4 Struggle Struggle NNP 3093 189 5 for for IN 3093 189 6 Recognition Recognition NNP 3093 189 7 , , , 3093 189 8 129 129 CD 3093 189 9 . . . 3093 190 1 15 15 CD 3093 190 2 . . . 3093 191 1 Ibid ibid RB 3093 191 2 . . . 3093 192 1 16 16 CD 3093 192 2 . . . 3093 193 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3093 193 2 . . . 3093 193 3 , , , 3093 193 4 130 130 CD 3093 193 5 . . . 3093 194 1 17 17 CD 3093 194 2 . . . 3093 195 1 Baroncelli Baroncelli NNP 3093 195 2 and and CC 3093 195 3 Freitas Freitas NNP 3093 195 4 , , , 3093 195 5 “ " `` 3093 195 6 The the DT 3093 195 7 Visibility visibility NN 3093 195 8 of of IN 3093 195 9 the the DT 3093 195 10 Self Self NNP 3093 195 11 . . . 3093 195 12 ” " '' 3093 195 13 18 18 CD 3093 195 14 . . . 3093 196 1 Ibid ibid RB 3093 196 2 . . . 3093 197 1 19 19 CD 3093 197 2 . . . 3093 198 1 Gobinda Gobinda NNP 3093 198 2 Chowdhury Chowdhury NNP 3093 198 3 , , , 3093 198 4 “ " `` 3093 198 5 From from IN 3093 198 6 Digital Digital NNP 3093 198 7 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3093 198 8 to to IN 3093 198 9 Digital Digital NNP 3093 198 10 Preservation Preservation NNP 3093 198 11 Research Research NNP 3093 198 12 : : : 3093 198 13 The the DT 3093 198 14 Importance Importance NNP 3093 198 15 of of IN 3093 198 16 Users Users NNPS 3093 198 17 and and CC 3093 198 18 Context Context NNP 3093 198 19 , , , 3093 198 20 ” " '' 3093 198 21 Journal Journal NNP 3093 198 22 of of IN 3093 198 23 Documentation Documentation NNP 3093 198 24 66 66 CD 3093 198 25 , , , 3093 198 26 no no UH 3093 198 27 . . . 3093 199 1 2 2 CD 3093 199 2 ( ( -LRB- 3093 199 3 2010 2010 CD 3093 199 4 ) ) -RRB- 3093 199 5 : : : 3093 199 6 207–23 207–23 CD 3093 199 7 , , , 3093 199 8 doi doi XX 3093 199 9 : : : 3093 199 10 10.1108/00220411011023625 10.1108/00220411011023625 NNS 3093 199 11 . . . 3093 200 1 20 20 CD 3093 200 2 . . . 3093 201 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3093 201 2 . . . 3093 201 3 , , , 3093 201 4 217 217 CD 3093 201 5 . . . 3093 202 1 21 21 CD 3093 202 2 . . . 3093 203 1 Brenda Brenda NNP 3093 203 2 Dervin Dervin NNP 3093 203 3 , , , 3093 203 4 “ " `` 3093 203 5 Given give VBN 3093 203 6 a a DT 3093 203 7 Context Context NNP 3093 203 8 by by IN 3093 203 9 Any any DT 3093 203 10 Other other JJ 3093 203 11 Name name NN 3093 203 12 : : : 3093 203 13 Methodological Methodological NNP 3093 203 14 Tools tool NNS 3093 203 15 For for IN 3093 203 16 Taming tame VBG 3093 203 17 the the DT 3093 203 18 Unruly Unruly NNP 3093 203 19 Beast Beast NNP 3093 203 20 , , , 3093 203 21 ” " '' 3093 203 22 in in IN 3093 203 23 Information information NN 3093 203 24 Seeking seek VBG 3093 203 25 in in IN 3093 203 26 Context Context NNP 3093 203 27 , , , 3093 203 28 ed ed NN 3093 203 29 . . . 3093 204 1 Pertti Pertti NNP 3093 204 2 Vakkari Vakkari NNP 3093 204 3 et et NNP 3093 204 4 al al NNP 3093 204 5 . . . 3093 205 1 ( ( -LRB- 3093 205 2 London London NNP 3093 205 3 : : : 3093 205 4 Taylor Taylor NNP 3093 205 5 Graham Graham NNP 3093 205 6 , , , 3093 205 7 1997 1997 CD 3093 205 8 ) ) -RRB- 3093 205 9 , , , 3093 205 10 13–38 13–38 CD 3093 205 11 . . . 3093 206 1 SEARCHABLE SEARCHABLE NNP 3093 206 2 SIGNATURES SIGNATURES NNP 3093 206 3 : : : 3093 206 4 CONTEXT context NN 3093 206 5 AND and CC 3093 206 6 THE the DT 3093 206 7 STRUGGLE struggle NN 3093 206 8 FOR for IN 3093 206 9 RECOGNITION RECOGNITION NNP 3093 206 10 | | CD 3093 206 11 SCHLESSELMAN SCHLESSELMAN NNP 3093 206 12 - - HYPH 3093 206 13 TARANGO TARANGO NNP 3093 206 14 18 18 CD 3093 206 15 22 22 CD 3093 206 16 . . . 3093 207 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3093 207 2 . . . 3093 207 3 , , , 3093 207 4 15 15 CD 3093 207 5 . . . 3093 208 1 23 23 CD 3093 208 2 . . . 3093 209 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3093 209 2 . . . 3093 209 3 , , , 3093 209 4 18 18 CD 3093 209 5 . . . 3093 210 1 24 24 CD 3093 210 2 . . . 3093 211 1 Christopher Christopher NNP 3093 211 2 A. A. NNP 3093 212 1 ( ( -LRB- 3093 212 2 Cal Cal NNP 3093 212 3 ) ) -RRB- 3093 212 4 Lee Lee NNP 3093 212 5 , , , 3093 212 6 “ " `` 3093 212 7 A a DT 3093 212 8 Framework Framework NNP 3093 212 9 for for IN 3093 212 10 Contextual Contextual NNP 3093 212 11 Information Information NNP 3093 212 12 in in IN 3093 212 13 Digital Digital NNP 3093 212 14 Collections Collections NNP 3093 212 15 , , , 3093 212 16 ” " '' 3093 212 17 Journal Journal NNP 3093 212 18 of of IN 3093 212 19 Documentation Documentation NNP 3093 212 20 67 67 CD 3093 212 21 ( ( -LRB- 3093 212 22 2011 2011 CD 3093 212 23 ) ) -RRB- 3093 212 24 : : : 3093 212 25 95–143 95–143 CD 3093 212 26 . . . 3093 213 1 25 25 CD 3093 213 2 . . . 3093 214 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3093 214 2 . . . 3093 214 3 , , , 3093 214 4 100 100 CD 3093 214 5 . . . 3093 215 1 26 26 CD 3093 215 2 . . . 3093 216 1 Abebe Abebe NNP 3093 216 2 Rorissa Rorissa NNP 3093 216 3 , , , 3093 216 4 “ " `` 3093 216 5 A a DT 3093 216 6 Comparative Comparative NNP 3093 216 7 Study Study NNP 3093 216 8 of of IN 3093 216 9 Flickr Flickr NNP 3093 216 10 Tags Tags NNPS 3093 216 11 and and CC 3093 216 12 Index Index NNP 3093 216 13 Terms Terms NNPS 3093 216 14 in in IN 3093 216 15 a a DT 3093 216 16 General General NNP 3093 216 17 Image Image NNP 3093 216 18 Collection Collection NNP 3093 216 19 , , , 3093 216 20 ” " '' 3093 216 21 Journal Journal NNP 3093 216 22 of of IN 3093 216 23 the the DT 3093 216 24 American American NNP 3093 216 25 Society Society NNP 3093 216 26 for for IN 3093 216 27 Information Information NNP 3093 216 28 Science Science NNP 3093 216 29 and and CC 3093 216 30 Technology Technology NNP 3093 216 31 61 61 CD 3093 216 32 , , , 3093 216 33 no no UH 3093 216 34 . . . 3093 217 1 11 11 CD 3093 217 2 ( ( -LRB- 3093 217 3 2010 2010 CD 3093 217 4 ) ) -RRB- 3093 217 5 : : : 3093 217 6 2230–42 2230–42 LS 3093 217 7 . . . 3093 218 1 27 27 CD 3093 218 2 . . . 3093 219 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 3093 219 2 . . . 3093 219 3 , , , 3093 219 4 2239 2239 CD 3093 219 5 . . . 3093 220 1 28 28 CD 3093 220 2 . . . 3093 221 1 “ " `` 3093 221 2 Steve Steve NNP 3093 221 3 Central Central NNP 3093 221 4 : : : 3093 221 5 Social Social NNP 3093 221 6 Tagging Tagging NNP 3093 221 7 for for IN 3093 221 8 Cultural Cultural NNP 3093 221 9 Collections Collections NNPS 3093 221 10 , , , 3093 221 11 ” " '' 3093 221 12 Steve Steve NNP 3093 221 13 : : : 3093 221 14 The the DT 3093 221 15 Museum Museum NNP 3093 221 16 Social Social NNP 3093 221 17 Tagging Tagging NNP 3093 221 18 Project Project NNP 3093 221 19 , , , 3093 221 20 accessed access VBD 3093 221 21 December December NNP 3093 221 22 16 16 CD 3093 221 23 , , , 3093 221 24 2012 2012 CD 3093 221 25 , , , 3093 221 26 http://tagger.steve.museum http://tagger.steve.museum NNP 3093 221 27 . . . 3093 222 1 29 29 CD 3093 222 2 . . . 3093 223 1 “ " `` 3093 223 2 Yale Yale NNP 3093 223 3 University University NNP 3093 223 4 Library Library NNP 3093 223 5 Manuscripts Manuscripts NNP 3093 223 6 & & CC 3093 223 7 Archives Archives NNP 3093 223 8 Department Department NNP 3093 223 9 , , , 3093 223 10 ” " '' 3093 223 11 Yale Yale NNP 3093 223 12 University University NNP 3093 223 13 Manuscripts Manuscripts NNPS 3093 223 14 & & CC 3093 223 15 Archives Archives NNP 3093 223 16 Digital Digital NNP 3093 223 17 Images Images NNP 3093 223 18 Database Database NNP 3093 223 19 , , , 3093 223 20 last last JJ 3093 223 21 modified modify VBN 3093 223 22 April April NNP 3093 223 23 19 19 CD 3093 223 24 , , , 3093 223 25 2012 2012 CD 3093 223 26 , , , 3093 223 27 accessed access VBD 3093 223 28 December December NNP 3093 223 29 3 3 CD 3093 223 30 , , , 3093 223 31 2012 2012 CD 3093 223 32 , , , 3093 223 33 http://images.library.yale.edu/madid http://images.library.yale.edu/madid NNP 3093 223 34 . . . 3093 224 1 30 30 CD 3093 224 2 . . . 3093 225 1 Ibid ibid RB 3093 225 2 . . . 3093 226 1 31 31 CD 3093 226 2 . . . 3093 227 1 “ " `` 3093 227 2 Andrew Andrew NNP 3093 227 3 St. St. NNP 3093 227 4 George George NNP 3093 227 5 Papers Papers NNP 3093 227 6 ( ( -LRB- 3093 227 7 MS MS NNP 3093 227 8 1912 1912 CD 3093 227 9 ) ) -RRB- 3093 227 10 , , , 3093 227 11 ” " '' 3093 227 12 Manuscripts Manuscripts NNPS 3093 227 13 and and CC 3093 227 14 Archives Archives NNPS 3093 227 15 , , , 3093 227 16 Yale Yale NNP 3093 227 17 University University NNP 3093 227 18 Library Library NNP 3093 227 19 , , , 3093 227 20 accessed access VBD 3093 227 21 April April NNP 3093 227 22 30 30 CD 3093 227 23 , , , 3093 227 24 2013 2013 CD 3093 227 25 , , , 3093 227 26 http://drs.library.yale.edu:8083/fedoragsearch/rest http://drs.library.yale.edu:8083/fedoragsearch/rest CD 3093 227 27 . . . 3093 228 1 32 32 CD 3093 228 2 . . . 3093 229 1 “ " `` 3093 229 2 FAQ FAQ NNP 3093 229 3 , , , 3093 229 4 ” " '' 3093 229 5 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 229 6 , , , 3093 229 7 accessed access VBD 3093 229 8 November November NNP 3093 229 9 10 10 CD 3093 229 10 , , , 3093 229 11 2012 2012 CD 3093 229 12 , , , 3093 229 13 http://instagram.com/about/faq http://instagram.com/about/faq CD 3093 229 14 . . . 3093 230 1 33 33 CD 3093 230 2 . . . 3093 231 1 Emil Emil NNP 3093 231 2 Protalinksi Protalinksi NNP 3093 231 3 , , , 3093 231 4 “ " `` 3093 231 5 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 231 6 Passes Passes NNP 3093 231 7 80 80 CD 3093 231 8 Million million CD 3093 231 9 Users Users NNPS 3093 231 10 , , , 3093 231 11 ” " '' 3093 231 12 CNET CNET NNP 3093 231 13 , , , 3093 231 14 July July NNP 3093 231 15 6 6 CD 3093 231 16 , , , 3093 231 17 2012 2012 CD 3093 231 18 , , , 3093 231 19 accessed access VBD 3093 231 20 November November NNP 3093 231 21 13 13 CD 3093 231 22 , , , 3093 231 23 2012 2012 CD 3093 231 24 , , , 3093 231 25 http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57480931-93/instagram-passes-80-million- http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57480931-93/instagram-passes-80-million- NN 3093 231 26 users user NNS 3093 231 27 ; ; : 3093 231 28 Jenna Jenna NNP 3093 231 29 Wortham Wortham NNP 3093 231 30 , , , 3093 231 31 “ " `` 3093 231 32 It -PRON- PRP 3093 231 33 ’s ’ VBZ 3093 231 34 Official official NN 3093 231 35 : : : 3093 231 36 Facebook Facebook NNP 3093 231 37 Closes close VBZ 3093 231 38 Its -PRON- PRP$ 3093 231 39 Acquisition Acquisition NNP 3093 231 40 of of IN 3093 231 41 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 231 42 , , , 3093 231 43 ” " '' 3093 231 44 New New NNP 3093 231 45 York York NNP 3093 231 46 Times Times NNP 3093 231 47 , , , 3093 231 48 September September NNP 3093 231 49 6 6 CD 3093 231 50 , , , 3093 231 51 2012 2012 CD 3093 231 52 , , , 3093 231 53 accessed access VBD 3093 231 54 November November NNP 3093 231 55 13 13 CD 3093 231 56 , , , 3093 231 57 2012 2012 CD 3093 231 58 , , , 3093 231 59 http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/09/06/its-official-facebook-closes-its-acquisition-of- http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/09/06/its-official-facebook-closes-its-acquisition-of- NNP 3093 231 60 instagram instagram NNP 3093 231 61 . . . 3093 232 1 34 34 CD 3093 232 2 . . . 3093 233 1 “ " `` 3093 233 2 Tagging tag VBG 3093 233 3 Your -PRON- PRP$ 3093 233 4 Photos photo NNS 3093 233 5 Using use VBG 3093 233 6 # # $ 3093 233 7 hashtags hashtag NNS 3093 233 8 , , , 3093 233 9 ” " '' 3093 233 10 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 233 11 , , , 3093 233 12 accessed access VBD 3093 233 13 November November NNP 3093 233 14 10 10 CD 3093 233 15 , , , 3093 233 16 2012 2012 CD 3093 233 17 , , , 3093 233 18 http://help.instagram.com/customer/portal/articles/95731-tagging-your-photos-using- http://help.instagram.com/customer/portal/articles/95731-tagging-your-photos-using- NNP 3093 233 19 hashtags hashtag VBZ 3093 233 20 ; ; : 3093 233 21 “ " `` 3093 233 22 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 233 23 Tips Tips NNP 3093 233 24 : : : 3093 233 25 Using use VBG 3093 233 26 Hashtags hashtag NNS 3093 233 27 , , , 3093 233 28 ” " '' 3093 233 29 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 233 30 , , , 3093 233 31 accessed access VBD 3093 233 32 November November NNP 3093 233 33 10 10 CD 3093 233 34 , , , 3093 233 35 2012 2012 CD 3093 233 36 , , , 3093 233 37 http://blog.instagram.com/post/17674993957/instagram-tips-using-hashtags http://blog.instagram.com/post/17674993957/instagram-tips-using-hashtags NNP 3093 233 38 . . . 3093 234 1 35 35 CD 3093 234 2 . . . 3093 235 1 Andrew Andrew NNP 3093 235 2 L. L. NNP 3093 235 3 Mendelson Mendelson NNP 3093 235 4 and and CC 3093 235 5 Zizi Zizi NNP 3093 235 6 Papacharissi Papacharissi NNP 3093 235 7 , , , 3093 235 8 “ " `` 3093 235 9 Look look VB 3093 235 10 at at IN 3093 235 11 Us -PRON- PRP 3093 235 12 : : : 3093 235 13 Collective collective JJ 3093 235 14 Narcissism narcissism NN 3093 235 15 in in IN 3093 235 16 College College NNP 3093 235 17 Student Student NNP 3093 235 18 Facebook Facebook NNP 3093 235 19 Photo Photo NNP 3093 235 20 Galleries Galleries NNPS 3093 235 21 , , , 3093 235 22 ” " '' 3093 235 23 in in IN 3093 235 24 A a DT 3093 235 25 Networked networked JJ 3093 235 26 Self self NN 3093 235 27 : : : 3093 235 28 Identity identity NN 3093 235 29 , , , 3093 235 30 Community Community NNP 3093 235 31 and and CC 3093 235 32 Culture Culture NNP 3093 235 33 on on IN 3093 235 34 Social Social NNP 3093 235 35 Network Network NNP 3093 235 36 Sites Sites NNPS 3093 235 37 , , , 3093 235 38 ed ed NN 3093 235 39 . . . 3093 236 1 Zizi Zizi NNP 3093 236 2 Papacharissi Papacharissi NNP 3093 236 3 ( ( -LRB- 3093 236 4 New New NNP 3093 236 5 York York NNP 3093 236 6 : : : 3093 236 7 Routledge Routledge NNP 3093 236 8 , , , 3093 236 9 2010 2010 CD 3093 236 10 ) ) -RRB- 3093 236 11 , , , 3093 236 12 251–73 251–73 CD 3093 236 13 . . . 3093 237 1 36 36 CD 3093 237 2 . . . 3093 238 1 Zachary Zachary NNP 3093 238 2 McCune McCune NNP 3093 238 3 , , , 3093 238 4 “ " `` 3093 238 5 Consumer Consumer NNP 3093 238 6 Production Production NNP 3093 238 7 in in IN 3093 238 8 Social Social NNP 3093 238 9 Media Media NNPS 3093 238 10 Networks Networks NNPS 3093 238 11 : : : 3093 238 12 A a DT 3093 238 13 Case Case NNP 3093 238 14 Study Study NNP 3093 238 15 of of IN 3093 238 16 the the DT 3093 238 17 http://tagger.steve.museum/ http://tagger.steve.museum/ NNP 3093 238 18 http://images.library.yale.edu/madid/ http://images.library.yale.edu/madid/ NN 3093 238 19 http://drs.library.yale.edu:8083/fedoragsearch/rest/ http://drs.library.yale.edu:8083/fedoragsearch/rest/ NNP 3093 238 20 http://instagram.com/about/faq/ http://instagram.com/about/faq/ NNP 3093 238 21 http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57480931-93/instagram-passes-80-million-users/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57480931-93/instagram-passes-80-million-users/ CD 3093 238 22 http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57480931-93/instagram-passes-80-million-users/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57480931-93/instagram-passes-80-million-users/ CC 3093 238 23 http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/09/06/its-official-facebook-closes-its-acquisition-of-instagram/ http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/09/06/its-official-facebook-closes-its-acquisition-of-instagram/ UH 3093 238 24 http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/09/06/its-official-facebook-closes-its-acquisition-of-instagram/ http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/09/06/its-official-facebook-closes-its-acquisition-of-instagram/ UH 3093 238 25 http://help.instagram.com/customer/portal/articles/95731-tagging-your-photos-using-hashtags http://help.instagram.com/customer/portal/articles/95731-tagging-your-photos-using-hashtags JJ 3093 238 26 http://help.instagram.com/customer/portal/articles/95731-tagging-your-photos-using-hashtags http://help.instagram.com/customer/portal/articles/95731-tagging-your-photos-using-hashtag NNS 3093 238 27 http://blog.instagram.com/post/17674993957/instagram-tips-using-hashtags http://blog.instagram.com/post/17674993957/instagram-tips-using-hashtag NNS 3093 238 28 INFORMATION information NN 3093 238 29 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 3093 238 30 AND and CC 3093 238 31 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 3093 238 32 | | NNP 3093 238 33 SEPTEMBER SEPTEMBER NNP 3093 238 34 2013 2013 CD 3093 238 35 19 19 CD 3093 238 36 ‘ ' `` 3093 238 37 Instagram Instagram NNP 3093 238 38 ’ ' '' 3093 238 39 iPhone iPhone NNP 3093 238 40 App App NNP 3093 238 41 ” " '' 3093 238 42 ( ( -LRB- 3093 238 43 master master NN 3093 238 44 ’s ’s POS 3093 238 45 dissertation dissertation NN 3093 238 46 , , , 3093 238 47 University University NNP 3093 238 48 of of IN 3093 238 49 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 3093 238 50 , , , 3093 238 51 2011 2011 CD 3093 238 52 ) ) -RRB- 3093 238 53 , , , 3093 238 54 accessed access VBD 3093 238 55 December December NNP 3093 238 56 20 20 CD 3093 238 57 , , , 3093 238 58 2012 2012 CD 3093 238 59 , , , 3093 238 60 http://thames2thayer.com/portfolio/a-study-of-instagram http://thames2thayer.com/portfolio/a-study-of-instagram NNP 3093 238 61 . . . 3093 239 1 37 37 CD 3093 239 2 . . . 3093 240 1 Honneth Honneth NNP 3093 240 2 , , , 3093 240 3 The the DT 3093 240 4 Struggle Struggle NNP 3093 240 5 for for IN 3093 240 6 Recognition Recognition NNP 3093 240 7 , , , 3093 240 8 127 127 CD 3093 240 9 . . . 3093 241 1 38 38 CD 3093 241 2 . . . 3093 242 1 Dervin Dervin NNP 3093 242 2 , , , 3093 242 3 “ " `` 3093 242 4 Given give VBN 3093 242 5 a a DT 3093 242 6 Context Context NNP 3093 242 7 by by IN 3093 242 8 Any any DT 3093 242 9 Other other JJ 3093 242 10 Name name NN 3093 242 11 , , , 3093 242 12 ” " '' 3093 242 13 17 17 CD 3093 242 14 . . . 3093 243 1 39 39 CD 3093 243 2 . . . 3093 244 1 Kiri Kiri NNP 3093 244 2 Blakeley Blakeley NNP 3093 244 3 , , , 3093 244 4 “ " `` 3093 244 5 Crazy Crazy NNP 3093 244 6 Cat Cat NNP 3093 244 7 Ladies Ladies NNPS 3093 244 8 , , , 3093 244 9 ” " '' 3093 244 10 Forbes Forbes NNP 3093 244 11 , , , 3093 244 12 October October NNP 3093 244 13 15 15 CD 3093 244 14 , , , 3093 244 15 2009 2009 CD 3093 244 16 , , , 3093 244 17 accessed access VBD 3093 244 18 December December NNP 3093 244 19 4 4 CD 3093 244 20 , , , 3093 244 21 2012 2012 CD 3093 244 22 , , , 3093 244 23 www.forbes.com/2009/10/14/crazy-cat-lady-pets-stereotype-forbes-woman-time- www.forbes.com/2009/10/14/crazy-cat-lady-pets-stereotype-forbes-woman-time- NNP 3093 244 24 felines.html felines.html NNS 3093 244 25 ; ; : 3093 244 26 Crazy Crazy NNP 3093 244 27 Cat Cat NNP 3093 244 28 Ladies Ladies NNPS 3093 244 29 Society Society NNP 3093 244 30 & & CC 3093 244 31 Gentlemen Gentlemen NNP 3093 244 32 's 's POS 3093 244 33 Auxiliary Auxiliary NNP 3093 244 34 homepage homepage NN 3093 244 35 , , , 3093 244 36 accessed access VBD 3093 244 37 December December NNP 3093 244 38 4 4 CD 3093 244 39 , , , 3093 244 40 2012 2012 CD 3093 244 41 , , , 3093 244 42 www.crazycatladies.org www.crazycatladies.org NNP 3093 244 43 . . . 3093 245 1 40 40 CD 3093 245 2 . . . 3093 246 1 Chowdhury Chowdhury NNP 3093 246 2 , , , 3093 246 3 “ " `` 3093 246 4 From from IN 3093 246 5 Digital Digital NNP 3093 246 6 Libraries Libraries NNPS 3093 246 7 to to IN 3093 246 8 Digital Digital NNP 3093 246 9 Preservation Preservation NNP 3093 246 10 , , , 3093 246 11 ” " '' 3093 246 12 219 219 CD 3093 246 13 . . . 3093 247 1 41 41 CD 3093 247 2 . . . 3093 248 1 Ibid ibid RB 3093 248 2 . . . 3093 249 1 42 42 CD 3093 249 2 . . . 3093 250 1 Clark Clark NNP 3093 250 2 , , , 3093 250 3 introduction introduction NN 3093 250 4 to to IN 3093 250 5 The the DT 3093 250 6 Painting Painting NNP 3093 250 7 of of IN 3093 250 8 Modern Modern NNP 3093 250 9 Life Life NNP 3093 250 10 , , , 3093 250 11 6 6 CD 3093 250 12 . . . 3093 251 1 43 43 CD 3093 251 2 . . . 3093 252 1 Ibid ibid RB 3093 252 2 . . . 3093 253 1 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS acknowledgment NNS 3093 253 2 Many many JJ 3093 253 3 thanks thank NNS 3093 253 4 to to IN 3093 253 5 Erin Erin NNP 3093 253 6 Meyer Meyer NNP 3093 253 7 and and CC 3093 253 8 Dr. Dr. NNP 3093 253 9 Krystyna Krystyna NNP 3093 253 10 Matusiak Matusiak NNP 3093 253 11 at at IN 3093 253 12 the the DT 3093 253 13 University University NNP 3093 253 14 of of IN 3093 253 15 Denver Denver NNP 3093 253 16 for for IN 3093 253 17 their -PRON- PRP$ 3093 253 18 feedback feedback NN 3093 253 19 and and CC 3093 253 20 guidance guidance NN 3093 253 21 . . . 3093 254 1 http://thames2thayer.com/portfolio/a-study-of-instagram/ http://thames2thayer.com/portfolio/a-study-of-instagram/ NNP