id sid tid token lemma pos 9098 1 1 Reference reference NN 9098 1 2 is be VBZ 9098 1 3 Dead dead JJ 9098 1 4 , , , 9098 1 5 Long Long NNP 9098 1 6 Live live JJ 9098 1 7 Reference reference NN 9098 1 8 : : : 9098 1 9 Electronic Electronic NNP 9098 1 10 Collections collection NNS 9098 1 11 in in IN 9098 1 12 the the DT 9098 1 13 Digital Digital NNP 9098 1 14 Age Age NNP 9098 1 15 Heather Heather NNP 9098 1 16 B. B. NNP 9098 1 17 Terrell Terrell NNP 9098 1 18 INFORMATION INFORMATION VBD 9098 1 19 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 9098 1 20 AND and CC 9098 1 21 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 9098 1 22 | | NNP 9098 1 23 DECEMBER DECEMBER NNP 9098 1 24 2015 2015 CD 9098 1 25 55 55 CD 9098 1 26 ABSTRACT ABSTRACT NNP 9098 1 27 In in IN 9098 1 28 a a DT 9098 1 29 literature literature NN 9098 1 30 survey survey NN 9098 1 31 on on IN 9098 1 32 how how WRB 9098 1 33 reference reference NN 9098 1 34 collections collection NNS 9098 1 35 have have VBP 9098 1 36 changed change VBN 9098 1 37 to to TO 9098 1 38 accommodate accommodate VB 9098 1 39 patrons patron NNS 9098 1 40 ’ ’ POS 9098 1 41 web- web- NN 9098 1 42 based base VBN 9098 1 43 information information NN 9098 1 44 - - HYPH 9098 1 45 seeking seek VBG 9098 1 46 behaviors behavior NNS 9098 1 47 , , , 9098 1 48 one one PRP 9098 1 49 notes note VBZ 9098 1 50 a a DT 9098 1 51 marked marked JJ 9098 1 52 “ " `` 9098 1 53 us -PRON- PRP 9098 1 54 vs. vs. IN 9098 1 55 them -PRON- PRP 9098 1 56 ” " '' 9098 1 57 mentality mentality NN 9098 1 58 — — : 9098 1 59 a a DT 9098 1 60 fear fear NN 9098 1 61 that that IN 9098 1 62 the the DT 9098 1 63 Internet internet NN 9098 1 64 might may MD 9098 1 65 render render VB 9098 1 66 reference reference NN 9098 1 67 irrelevant irrelevant JJ 9098 1 68 . . . 9098 2 1 These these DT 9098 2 2 anxieties anxiety NNS 9098 2 3 are be VBP 9098 2 4 oft oft RB 9098 2 5 - - HYPH 9098 2 6 noted note VBN 9098 2 7 in in IN 9098 2 8 articles article NNS 9098 2 9 urging urge VBG 9098 2 10 libraries library NNS 9098 2 11 to to TO 9098 2 12 embrace embrace VB 9098 2 13 digital digital JJ 9098 2 14 and and CC 9098 2 15 online online JJ 9098 2 16 reference reference NN 9098 2 17 sources source NNS 9098 2 18 . . . 9098 3 1 Why why WRB 9098 3 2 all all PDT 9098 3 3 the the DT 9098 3 4 ambivalence ambivalence NN 9098 3 5 ? ? . 9098 4 1 Citing cite VBG 9098 4 2 existing exist VBG 9098 4 3 research research NN 9098 4 4 and and CC 9098 4 5 literature literature NN 9098 4 6 , , , 9098 4 7 this this DT 9098 4 8 essay essay NN 9098 4 9 explores explore VBZ 9098 4 10 myths myth NNS 9098 4 11 about about IN 9098 4 12 the the DT 9098 4 13 supposed suppose VBN 9098 4 14 superiority superiority NN 9098 4 15 of of IN 9098 4 16 physical physical JJ 9098 4 17 reference reference NN 9098 4 18 collections collection NNS 9098 4 19 and and CC 9098 4 20 how how WRB 9098 4 21 patrons patron NNS 9098 4 22 actually actually RB 9098 4 23 use use VBP 9098 4 24 them -PRON- PRP 9098 4 25 , , , 9098 4 26 potential potential JJ 9098 4 27 challenges challenge NNS 9098 4 28 associated associate VBN 9098 4 29 with with IN 9098 4 30 electronic electronic JJ 9098 4 31 reference reference NN 9098 4 32 collections collection NNS 9098 4 33 , , , 9098 4 34 and and CC 9098 4 35 how how WRB 9098 4 36 providing provide VBG 9098 4 37 vital vital JJ 9098 4 38 e e JJ 9098 4 39 - - NN 9098 4 40 reference reference NN 9098 4 41 collections collection NNS 9098 4 42 benefits benefit VBZ 9098 4 43 the the DT 9098 4 44 library library NN 9098 4 45 as as RB 9098 4 46 well well RB 9098 4 47 as as IN 9098 4 48 its -PRON- PRP$ 9098 4 49 patrons patron NNS 9098 4 50 . . . 9098 5 1 INTRODUCTION introduction NN 9098 5 2 Reference reference NN 9098 5 3 collections collection NNS 9098 5 4 are be VBP 9098 5 5 intended intend VBN 9098 5 6 to to TO 9098 5 7 meet meet VB 9098 5 8 the the DT 9098 5 9 immediate immediate JJ 9098 5 10 information information NN 9098 5 11 needs need NNS 9098 5 12 of of IN 9098 5 13 users user NNS 9098 5 14 . . . 9098 6 1 Reference reference NN 9098 6 2 librarians librarian NNS 9098 6 3 develop develop VBP 9098 6 4 these these DT 9098 6 5 collections collection NNS 9098 6 6 with with IN 9098 6 7 the the DT 9098 6 8 intention intention NN 9098 6 9 of of IN 9098 6 10 using use VBG 9098 6 11 them -PRON- PRP 9098 6 12 to to TO 9098 6 13 answer answer VB 9098 6 14 in- in- JJ 9098 6 15 depth depth NN 9098 6 16 questions question NNS 9098 6 17 and and CC 9098 6 18 to to TO 9098 6 19 conduct conduct VB 9098 6 20 ready ready JJ 9098 6 21 - - HYPH 9098 6 22 reference reference NN 9098 6 23 searches search NNS 9098 6 24 on on IN 9098 6 25 a a DT 9098 6 26 patron patron NN 9098 6 27 ’s ’s POS 9098 6 28 behalf behalf NN 9098 6 29 . . . 9098 7 1 Library library JJ 9098 7 2 users user NNS 9098 7 3 depend depend VBP 9098 7 4 on on IN 9098 7 5 reference reference NN 9098 7 6 collections collection NNS 9098 7 7 to to TO 9098 7 8 include include VB 9098 7 9 easily easily RB 9098 7 10 navigable navigable JJ 9098 7 11 finding finding NN 9098 7 12 tools tool NNS 9098 7 13 that that WDT 9098 7 14 assist assist VBP 9098 7 15 them -PRON- PRP 9098 7 16 in in IN 9098 7 17 locating locate VBG 9098 7 18 sources source NNS 9098 7 19 that that WDT 9098 7 20 contain contain VBP 9098 7 21 reliable reliable JJ 9098 7 22 information information NN 9098 7 23 in in IN 9098 7 24 a a DT 9098 7 25 useful useful JJ 9098 7 26 , , , 9098 7 27 accessible accessible JJ 9098 7 28 format format NN 9098 7 29 and and CC 9098 7 30 can can MD 9098 7 31 be be VB 9098 7 32 accessed access VBN 9098 7 33 when when WRB 9098 7 34 the the DT 9098 7 35 information information NN 9098 7 36 is be VBZ 9098 7 37 needed need VBN 9098 7 38 . . . 9098 8 1 The the DT 9098 8 2 expectation expectation NN 9098 8 3 for for IN 9098 8 4 print print NN 9098 8 5 reference reference NN 9098 8 6 collections collection NNS 9098 8 7 is be VBZ 9098 8 8 that that IN 9098 8 9 they -PRON- PRP 9098 8 10 are be VBP 9098 8 11 comprised comprise VBN 9098 8 12 of of IN 9098 8 13 high high JJ 9098 8 14 - - HYPH 9098 8 15 use use NN 9098 8 16 materials material NNS 9098 8 17 — — : 9098 8 18 the the DT 9098 8 19 very very JJ 9098 8 20 reason reason NN 9098 8 21 for for IN 9098 8 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 9098 8 23 designation designation NN 9098 8 24 as as IN 9098 8 25 noncirculating noncirculate VBG 9098 8 26 items item NNS 9098 8 27 is be VBZ 9098 8 28 ostensibly ostensibly RB 9098 8 29 so so IN 9098 8 30 that that IN 9098 8 31 materials material NNS 9098 8 32 are be VBP 9098 8 33 available available JJ 9098 8 34 for for IN 9098 8 35 on on IN 9098 8 36 - - HYPH 9098 8 37 demand demand NN 9098 8 38 access access NN 9098 8 39 by by IN 9098 8 40 both both DT 9098 8 41 patrons patron NNS 9098 8 42 and and CC 9098 8 43 staff staff NN 9098 8 44 , , , 9098 8 45 who who WP 9098 8 46 use use VBP 9098 8 47 them -PRON- PRP 9098 8 48 frequently frequently RB 9098 8 49 . . . 9098 9 1 However however RB 9098 9 2 , , , 9098 9 3 librarians librarian NNS 9098 9 4 and and CC 9098 9 5 patrons patron NNS 9098 9 6 alike alike RB 9098 9 7 have have VBP 9098 9 8 acquired acquire VBN 9098 9 9 what what WP 9098 9 10 Margaret Margaret NNP 9098 9 11 Landesman Landesman NNP 9098 9 12 calls call VBZ 9098 9 13 “ " `` 9098 9 14 online online JJ 9098 9 15 habits habit NNS 9098 9 16 , , , 9098 9 17 ” " '' 9098 9 18 to to IN 9098 9 19 wit wit NN 9098 9 20 , , , 9098 9 21 the the DT 9098 9 22 most most RBS 9098 9 23 - - HYPH 9098 9 24 utilized utilize VBN 9098 9 25 access access NN 9098 9 26 point point NN 9098 9 27 to to IN 9098 9 28 information information NN 9098 9 29 is be VBZ 9098 9 30 often often RB 9098 9 31 the the DT 9098 9 32 24/7 24/7 CD 9098 9 33 web.1 web.1 NN 9098 9 34 In in IN 9098 9 35 a a DT 9098 9 36 wired wire VBN 9098 9 37 world world NN 9098 9 38 , , , 9098 9 39 where where WRB 9098 9 40 the the DT 9098 9 41 information information NN 9098 9 42 universe universe NN 9098 9 43 of of IN 9098 9 44 the the DT 9098 9 45 Internet internet NN 9098 9 46 is be VBZ 9098 9 47 not not RB 9098 9 48 only only RB 9098 9 49 on on IN 9098 9 50 our -PRON- PRP$ 9098 9 51 desktops desktop NNS 9098 9 52 , , , 9098 9 53 but but CC 9098 9 54 also also RB 9098 9 55 in in IN 9098 9 56 our -PRON- PRP$ 9098 9 57 pockets pocket NNS 9098 9 58 and and CC 9098 9 59 on on IN 9098 9 60 our -PRON- PRP$ 9098 9 61 fashion fashion NN 9098 9 62 accessories accessory NNS 9098 9 63 , , , 9098 9 64 the the DT 9098 9 65 role role NN 9098 9 66 of of IN 9098 9 67 the the DT 9098 9 68 print print NN 9098 9 69 reference reference NN 9098 9 70 collection collection NN 9098 9 71 is be VBZ 9098 9 72 less less RBR 9098 9 73 relevant relevant JJ 9098 9 74 in in IN 9098 9 75 supporting support VBG 9098 9 76 information information NN 9098 9 77 and and CC 9098 9 78 research research NN 9098 9 79 aims aim NNS 9098 9 80 . . . 9098 10 1 In in IN 9098 10 2 no no DT 9098 10 3 other other JJ 9098 10 4 realm realm NN 9098 10 5 have have VBP 9098 10 6 the the DT 9098 10 7 common common JJ 9098 10 8 practices practice NNS 9098 10 9 of of IN 9098 10 10 both both DT 9098 10 11 users user NNS 9098 10 12 and and CC 9098 10 13 librarians librarian NNS 9098 10 14 changed change VBD 9098 10 15 more more RBR 9098 10 16 than than IN 9098 10 17 in in IN 9098 10 18 how how WRB 9098 10 19 we -PRON- PRP 9098 10 20 seek seek VBP 9098 10 21 information information NN 9098 10 22 . . . 9098 11 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 9098 11 2 , , , 9098 11 3 a a DT 9098 11 4 technology technology NN 9098 11 5 - - HYPH 9098 11 6 related relate VBN 9098 11 7 panic panic NN 9098 11 8 seems seem VBZ 9098 11 9 to to TO 9098 11 10 be be VB 9098 11 11 at at IN 9098 11 12 the the DT 9098 11 13 boil boil NN 9098 11 14 , , , 9098 11 15 with with IN 9098 11 16 article article NN 9098 11 17 titles title NNS 9098 11 18 like like IN 9098 11 19 “ " `` 9098 11 20 Are be VBP 9098 11 21 Reference reference NN 9098 11 22 Books book NNS 9098 11 23 Becoming become VBG 9098 11 24 an an DT 9098 11 25 Endangered Endangered NNP 9098 11 26 Species?”2 Species?”2 NNP 9098 11 27 and and CC 9098 11 28 “ " `` 9098 11 29 Off Off NNP 9098 11 30 the the DT 9098 11 31 Shelf Shelf NNP 9098 11 32 : : : 9098 11 33 Is be VBZ 9098 11 34 Print print NN 9098 11 35 Reference reference NN 9098 11 36 Dead?”3 dead?”3 JJ 9098 11 37 Words word NNS 9098 11 38 like like IN 9098 11 39 “ " `` 9098 11 40 invasion invasion NN 9098 11 41 ” " '' 9098 11 42 are be VBP 9098 11 43 used use VBN 9098 11 44 to to TO 9098 11 45 describe describe VB 9098 11 46 the the DT 9098 11 47 influx influx NN 9098 11 48 of of IN 9098 11 49 electronic electronic JJ 9098 11 50 reference reference NN 9098 11 51 sources source NNS 9098 11 52 . . . 9098 12 1 We -PRON- PRP 9098 12 2 read read VBD 9098 12 3 about about IN 9098 12 4 the the DT 9098 12 5 Heather Heather NNP 9098 12 6 B. B. NNP 9098 12 7 Terrell Terrell NNP 9098 12 8 ( ( -LRB- 9098 12 9 hterrell@milibrary.org hterrell@milibrary.org NNP 9098 12 10 ) ) -RRB- 9098 12 11 , , , 9098 12 12 a a DT 9098 12 13 recent recent JJ 9098 12 14 MLIS MLIS NNP 9098 12 15 degree degree NN 9098 12 16 graduate graduate NN 9098 12 17 from from IN 9098 12 18 the the DT 9098 12 19 School School NNP 9098 12 20 of of IN 9098 12 21 Library Library NNP 9098 12 22 and and CC 9098 12 23 Information Information NNP 9098 12 24 Science Science NNP 9098 12 25 , , , 9098 12 26 San San NNP 9098 12 27 Jose Jose NNP 9098 12 28 State State NNP 9098 12 29 University University NNP 9098 12 30 , , , 9098 12 31 is be VBZ 9098 12 32 winner winner NN 9098 12 33 of of IN 9098 12 34 the the DT 9098 12 35 2015 2015 CD 9098 12 36 LITA LITA NNP 9098 12 37 / / SYM 9098 12 38 Ex Ex NNP 9098 12 39 Libris Libris NNP 9098 12 40 Student Student NNP 9098 12 41 Writing Writing NNP 9098 12 42 Award Award NNP 9098 12 43 . . . 9098 13 1 mailto:hterrell@milibrary.org mailto:hterrell@milibrary.org NNP 9098 13 2 REFERENCE REFERENCE NNP 9098 13 3 IS be VBZ 9098 13 4 DEAD DEAD NNP 9098 13 5 , , , 9098 13 6 LONG LONG NNP 9098 13 7 LIVE live JJ 9098 13 8 REFERENCE reference NN 9098 13 9 : : : 9098 13 10 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9098 13 11 COLLECTIONS collections VBP 9098 13 12 IN in IN 9098 13 13 THE the DT 9098 13 14 DIGITAL DIGITAL NNP 9098 13 15 AGE AGE NNP 9098 13 16 | | NNP 9098 13 17 TERRELL TERRELL NNP 9098 13 18 | | JJ 9098 13 19 doi doi NN 9098 13 20 : : : 9098 13 21 10.6017 10.6017 CD 9098 13 22 / / SYM 9098 13 23 ital.v34i4.9098 ital.v34i4.9098 CD 9098 13 24 56 56 CD 9098 13 25 “ " `` 9098 13 26 unsustainable unsustainable JJ 9098 13 27 luxury luxury NN 9098 13 28 ” " '' 9098 13 29 of of IN 9098 13 30 housing housing NN 9098 13 31 hundreds hundred NNS 9098 13 32 — — : 9098 13 33 sometimes sometimes RB 9098 13 34 thousands thousand NNS 9098 13 35 — — : 9098 13 36 of of IN 9098 13 37 unused unused JJ 9098 13 38 books book NNS 9098 13 39 on on IN 9098 13 40 the the DT 9098 13 41 open open JJ 9098 13 42 shelves shelf NNS 9098 13 43 . . . 9098 14 1 All all PDT 9098 14 2 this this DT 9098 14 3 handwringing handwringing NN 9098 14 4 leads lead VBZ 9098 14 5 us -PRON- PRP 9098 14 6 to to TO 9098 14 7 wonder wonder VB 9098 14 8 why why WRB 9098 14 9 librarians librarian NNS 9098 14 10 in in IN 9098 14 11 the the DT 9098 14 12 field field NN 9098 14 13 need need VBP 9098 14 14 this this DT 9098 14 15 much much RB 9098 14 16 coaxing coax VBG 9098 14 17 to to TO 9098 14 18 be be VB 9098 14 19 cajoled cajole VBN 9098 14 20 into into IN 9098 14 21 weeding weed VBG 9098 14 22 their -PRON- PRP$ 9098 14 23 print print NN 9098 14 24 reference reference NN 9098 14 25 collections collection NNS 9098 14 26 in in IN 9098 14 27 favor favor NN 9098 14 28 of of IN 9098 14 29 electronic electronic JJ 9098 14 30 reference reference NN 9098 14 31 resources resource NNS 9098 14 32 . . . 9098 15 1 Does do VBZ 9098 15 2 this this DT 9098 15 3 format format NN 9098 15 4 transition transition NN 9098 15 5 really really RB 9098 15 6 constitute constitute VBP 9098 15 7 such such PDT 9098 15 8 a a DT 9098 15 9 dire dire JJ 9098 15 10 situation situation NN 9098 15 11 ? ? . 9098 16 1 What what WP 9098 16 2 if if IN 9098 16 3 the the DT 9098 16 4 decline decline NN 9098 16 5 of of IN 9098 16 6 print print NN 9098 16 7 reference reference NN 9098 16 8 usage usage NN 9098 16 9 is be VBZ 9098 16 10 n’t not RB 9098 16 11 a a DT 9098 16 12 problem problem NN 9098 16 13 ? ? . 9098 17 1 And and CC 9098 17 2 what what WP 9098 17 3 ’s ’ VBZ 9098 17 4 so so RB 9098 17 5 luxurious luxurious JJ 9098 17 6 about about IN 9098 17 7 dusty dusty JJ 9098 17 8 , , , 9098 17 9 overcrowded overcrowded JJ 9098 17 10 shelves shelf NNS 9098 17 11 full full JJ 9098 17 12 of of IN 9098 17 13 books book NNS 9098 17 14 no no DT 9098 17 15 one one NN 9098 17 16 cares care VBZ 9098 17 17 to to TO 9098 17 18 use use VB 9098 17 19 ? ? . 9098 18 1 In in IN 9098 18 2 “ " `` 9098 18 3 The the DT 9098 18 4 Myth Myth NNP 9098 18 5 of of IN 9098 18 6 Browsing Browsing NNP 9098 18 7 , , , 9098 18 8 ” " '' 9098 18 9 Barclay Barclay NNP 9098 18 10 concludes conclude VBZ 9098 18 11 that that IN 9098 18 12 “ " `` 9098 18 13 the the DT 9098 18 14 continued continue VBN 9098 18 15 over over IN 9098 18 16 - - HYPH 9098 18 17 my -PRON- PRP$ 9098 18 18 - - HYPH 9098 18 19 dead dead JJ 9098 18 20 - - HYPH 9098 18 21 body body NN 9098 18 22 insistence insistence NN 9098 18 23 that that IN 9098 18 24 no no DT 9098 18 25 books book NNS 9098 18 26 be be VB 9098 18 27 removed remove VBN 9098 18 28 [ [ -LRB- 9098 18 29 from from IN 9098 18 30 libraries library NNS 9098 18 31 ] ] -RRB- 9098 18 32 is be VBZ 9098 18 33 an an DT 9098 18 34 unsustainable unsustainable JJ 9098 18 35 position position NN 9098 18 36 . . . 9098 18 37 ”4 ”4 NNP 9098 18 38 A a DT 9098 18 39 survey survey NN 9098 18 40 of of IN 9098 18 41 the the DT 9098 18 42 relevant relevant JJ 9098 18 43 literature literature NN 9098 18 44 reveals reveal VBZ 9098 18 45 that that DT 9098 18 46 staff staff NN 9098 18 47 resistant resistant JJ 9098 18 48 to to IN 9098 18 49 the the DT 9098 18 50 transition transition NN 9098 18 51 from from IN 9098 18 52 print print NN 9098 18 53 to to IN 9098 18 54 electronic electronic JJ 9098 18 55 reference reference NN 9098 18 56 collections collection NNS 9098 18 57 often often RB 9098 18 58 share share VBP 9098 18 59 three three CD 9098 18 60 core core NN 9098 18 61 presumptions presumption NNS 9098 18 62 about about IN 9098 18 63 reference reference NN 9098 18 64 : : : 9098 18 65 • • VB 9098 18 66 Users user NNS 9098 18 67 prefer prefer VBP 9098 18 68 using use VBG 9098 18 69 print print NN 9098 18 70 sources source NNS 9098 18 71 , , , 9098 18 72 and and CC 9098 18 73 the the DT 9098 18 74 importance importance NN 9098 18 75 of of IN 9098 18 76 patrons patron NNS 9098 18 77 ’ ’ POS 9098 18 78 ability ability NN 9098 18 79 to to TO 9098 18 80 browse browse VB 9098 18 81 the the DT 9098 18 82 physical physical JJ 9098 18 83 collection collection NN 9098 18 84 is be VBZ 9098 18 85 paramount paramount JJ 9098 18 86 . . . 9098 19 1 • • VB 9098 19 2 The the DT 9098 19 3 reliability reliability NN 9098 19 4 of of IN 9098 19 5 web web NN 9098 19 6 - - HYPH 9098 19 7 based base VBN 9098 19 8 reference reference NN 9098 19 9 sources source NNS 9098 19 10 may may MD 9098 19 11 be be VB 9098 19 12 questionable questionable JJ 9098 19 13 , , , 9098 19 14 especially especially RB 9098 19 15 when when WRB 9098 19 16 compared compare VBN 9098 19 17 with with IN 9098 19 18 the the DT 9098 19 19 authority authority NN 9098 19 20 of of IN 9098 19 21 print print NN 9098 19 22 reference reference NN 9098 19 23 materials material NNS 9098 19 24 . . . 9098 20 1 • • VB 9098 20 2 Access access NN 9098 20 3 to to TO 9098 20 4 print print VB 9098 20 5 materials material NNS 9098 20 6 is be VBZ 9098 20 7 the the DT 9098 20 8 only only JJ 9098 20 9 option option NN 9098 20 10 that that IN 9098 20 11 certain certain JJ 9098 20 12 users user NNS 9098 20 13 ( ( -LRB- 9098 20 14 namely namely RB 9098 20 15 , , , 9098 20 16 those those DT 9098 20 17 without without IN 9098 20 18 library library JJ 9098 20 19 cards card NNS 9098 20 20 ) ) -RRB- 9098 20 21 have have VBP 9098 20 22 for for IN 9098 20 23 being be VBG 9098 20 24 connected connect VBN 9098 20 25 to to IN 9098 20 26 information information NN 9098 20 27 . . . 9098 21 1 There there EX 9098 21 2 also also RB 9098 21 3 seems seem VBZ 9098 21 4 to to TO 9098 21 5 be be VB 9098 21 6 a a DT 9098 21 7 more more RBR 9098 21 8 subtle subtle JJ 9098 21 9 assumption assumption NN 9098 21 10 at at IN 9098 21 11 play play NN 9098 21 12 in in IN 9098 21 13 the the DT 9098 21 14 print print NN 9098 21 15 vs. vs. IN 9098 21 16 electronic electronic JJ 9098 21 17 reference reference NN 9098 21 18 debate debate NN 9098 21 19 — — : 9098 21 20 that that IN 9098 21 21 print print NN 9098 21 22 books book NNS 9098 21 23 are be VBP 9098 21 24 more more RBR 9098 21 25 “ " `` 9098 21 26 dignified dignified JJ 9098 21 27 , , , 9098 21 28 ” " '' 9098 21 29 cultivating cultivate VBG 9098 21 30 a a DT 9098 21 31 scholarly scholarly JJ 9098 21 32 atmosphere atmosphere NN 9098 21 33 in in IN 9098 21 34 the the DT 9098 21 35 library library NN 9098 21 36 . . . 9098 22 1 Certain certain JJ 9098 22 2 objections objection NNS 9098 22 3 to to IN 9098 22 4 removing remove VBG 9098 22 5 print print NN 9098 22 6 reference reference NN 9098 22 7 collections collection NNS 9098 22 8 to to IN 9098 22 9 closed closed JJ 9098 22 10 stacks stack NNS 9098 22 11 and and CC 9098 22 12 using use VBG 9098 22 13 the the DT 9098 22 14 newly newly RB 9098 22 15 freed free VBN 9098 22 16 public public JJ 9098 22 17 space space NN 9098 22 18 to to TO 9098 22 19 build build VB 9098 22 20 a a DT 9098 22 21 cooperative cooperative JJ 9098 22 22 learning learn VBG 9098 22 23 commons common NNS 9098 22 24 , , , 9098 22 25 for for IN 9098 22 26 instance instance NN 9098 22 27 , , , 9098 22 28 tend tend VBP 9098 22 29 to to TO 9098 22 30 devolve devolve VB 9098 22 31 into into IN 9098 22 32 hysterics hysteric NNS 9098 22 33 about about IN 9098 22 34 the the DT 9098 22 35 potentiality potentiality NN 9098 22 36 of of IN 9098 22 37 libraries library NNS 9098 22 38 becoming become VBG 9098 22 39 “ " `` 9098 22 40 no no RB 9098 22 41 better well JJR 9098 22 42 than than IN 9098 22 43 a a DT 9098 22 44 Starbucks Starbucks NNP 9098 22 45 . . . 9098 22 46 ” " '' 9098 22 47 The the DT 9098 22 48 “ " `` 9098 22 49 no no RB 9098 22 50 better well JJR 9098 22 51 ” " '' 9098 22 52 variable variable JJ 9098 22 53 in in IN 9098 22 54 this this DT 9098 22 55 equation equation NN 9098 22 56 is be VBZ 9098 22 57 a a DT 9098 22 58 cosmetic cosmetic JJ 9098 22 59 one one CD 9098 22 60 — — : 9098 22 61 librarians librarian NNS 9098 22 62 are be VBP 9098 22 63 n’t not RB 9098 22 64 worrying worry VBG 9098 22 65 about about IN 9098 22 66 libraries library NNS 9098 22 67 serving serve VBG 9098 22 68 up up RP 9098 22 69 a a DT 9098 22 70 flavored flavored JJ 9098 22 71 “ " `` 9098 22 72 information information NN 9098 22 73 latte latte NN 9098 22 74 ” " '' 9098 22 75 for for IN 9098 22 76 vast vast JJ 9098 22 77 profit profit NN 9098 22 78 margins margin NNS 9098 22 79 — — : 9098 22 80 they -PRON- PRP 9098 22 81 are be VBP 9098 22 82 worrying worry VBG 9098 22 83 that that IN 9098 22 84 libraries library NNS 9098 22 85 will will MD 9098 22 86 be be VB 9098 22 87 perceived perceive VBN 9098 22 88 as as IN 9098 22 89 a a DT 9098 22 90 place place NN 9098 22 91 to to TO 9098 22 92 loiter loiter VB 9098 22 93 , , , 9098 22 94 use use VB 9098 22 95 the the DT 9098 22 96 Internet internet NN 9098 22 97 , , , 9098 22 98 and and CC 9098 22 99 “ " `` 9098 22 100 hang hang VB 9098 22 101 out out RP 9098 22 102 , , , 9098 22 103 ” " '' 9098 22 104 rather rather RB 9098 22 105 than than IN 9098 22 106 a a DT 9098 22 107 place place NN 9098 22 108 for for IN 9098 22 109 serious serious JJ 9098 22 110 study study NN 9098 22 111 . . . 9098 23 1 One one CD 9098 23 2 thing thing NN 9098 23 3 for for IN 9098 23 4 librarians librarian NNS 9098 23 5 who who WP 9098 23 6 worry worry VBP 9098 23 7 about about IN 9098 23 8 this this DT 9098 23 9 potential potential JJ 9098 23 10 outcome outcome NN 9098 23 11 to to TO 9098 23 12 consider consider VB 9098 23 13 is be VBZ 9098 23 14 that that DT 9098 23 15 loyal loyal JJ 9098 23 16 coffee coffee NN 9098 23 17 shop shop NN 9098 23 18 denizens denizen NNS 9098 23 19 would would MD 9098 23 20 be be VB 9098 23 21 up up RB 9098 23 22 in in IN 9098 23 23 arms arm NNS 9098 23 24 to to TO 9098 23 25 learn learn VB 9098 23 26 that that IN 9098 23 27 their -PRON- PRP$ 9098 23 28 favorite favorite JJ 9098 23 29 shop shop NN 9098 23 30 was be VBD 9098 23 31 being be VBG 9098 23 32 closed close VBN 9098 23 33 or or CC 9098 23 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 9098 23 35 services service NNS 9098 23 36 being be VBG 9098 23 37 reduced reduce VBN 9098 23 38 or or CC 9098 23 39 eliminated eliminate VBN 9098 23 40 . . . 9098 24 1 The the DT 9098 24 2 implications implication NNS 9098 24 3 are be VBP 9098 24 4 clear clear JJ 9098 24 5 . . . 9098 25 1 Perhaps perhaps RB 9098 25 2 libraries library NNS 9098 25 3 should should MD 9098 25 4 consider consider VB 9098 25 5 the the DT 9098 25 6 café café NN 9098 25 7 model model NN 9098 25 8 : : : 9098 25 9 a a DT 9098 25 10 collaborative collaborative JJ 9098 25 11 “ " `` 9098 25 12 no no RB 9098 25 13 - - HYPH 9098 25 14 shushing shush VBG 9098 25 15 ” " '' 9098 25 16 zone zone NN 9098 25 17 — — : 9098 25 18 the the DT 9098 25 19 difference difference NN 9098 25 20 between between IN 9098 25 21 a a DT 9098 25 22 library library NN 9098 25 23 and and CC 9098 25 24 a a DT 9098 25 25 coffee coffee NN 9098 25 26 house house NN 9098 25 27 being be VBG 9098 25 28 that that IN 9098 25 29 at at IN 9098 25 30 a a DT 9098 25 31 library library NN 9098 25 32 , , , 9098 25 33 people people NNS 9098 25 34 are be VBP 9098 25 35 able able JJ 9098 25 36 to to TO 9098 25 37 explore explore VB 9098 25 38 , , , 9098 25 39 learn learn VB 9098 25 40 , , , 9098 25 41 and and CC 9098 25 42 be be VB 9098 25 43 entertained entertain VBN 9098 25 44 using use VBG 9098 25 45 the the DT 9098 25 46 resources resource NNS 9098 25 47 provided provide VBN 9098 25 48 by by IN 9098 25 49 the the DT 9098 25 50 institution institution NN 9098 25 51 . . . 9098 26 1 At at IN 9098 26 2 Homer Homer NNP 9098 26 3 Babbidge Babbidge NNP 9098 26 4 Library Library NNP 9098 26 5 at at IN 9098 26 6 the the DT 9098 26 7 University University NNP 9098 26 8 of of IN 9098 26 9 Connecticut Connecticut NNP 9098 26 10 , , , 9098 26 11 staff staff NN 9098 26 12 considered consider VBD 9098 26 13 it -PRON- PRP 9098 26 14 important important JJ 9098 26 15 to to TO 9098 26 16 “ " `` 9098 26 17 maintain maintain VB 9098 26 18 a a DT 9098 26 19 vestige vestige NN 9098 26 20 of of IN 9098 26 21 the the DT 9098 26 22 reference reference NN 9098 26 23 collection collection NN 9098 26 24 , , , 9098 26 25 so so IN 9098 26 26 that that IN 9098 26 27 students student NNS 9098 26 28 were be VBD 9098 26 29 reminded remind VBN 9098 26 30 they -PRON- PRP 9098 26 31 had have VBD 9098 26 32 entered enter VBN 9098 26 33 a a DT 9098 26 34 special special JJ 9098 26 35 place place NN 9098 26 36 where where WRB 9098 26 37 scholarship scholarship NN 9098 26 38 was be VBD 9098 26 39 tangible tangible JJ 9098 26 40 . . . 9098 26 41 ”5 ”5 NNP 9098 26 42 However however RB 9098 26 43 , , , 9098 26 44 users user NNS 9098 26 45 considered consider VBD 9098 26 46 the the DT 9098 26 47 underutilized underutilize VBN 9098 26 48 stacks stack NNS 9098 26 49 of of IN 9098 26 50 books book NNS 9098 26 51 a a DT 9098 26 52 waste waste NN 9098 26 53 of of IN 9098 26 54 space space NN 9098 26 55 that that WDT 9098 26 56 could could MD 9098 26 57 be be VB 9098 26 58 better well RBR 9098 26 59 used use VBN 9098 26 60 for for IN 9098 26 61 cooperative cooperative JJ 9098 26 62 work work NN 9098 26 63 areas area NNS 9098 26 64 or or CC 9098 26 65 INFORMATION information NN 9098 26 66 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 9098 26 67 AND and CC 9098 26 68 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 9098 26 69 | | NNP 9098 26 70 DECEMBER DECEMBER NNP 9098 26 71 2015 2015 CD 9098 26 72 57 57 CD 9098 26 73 computer computer NN 9098 26 74 access access NN 9098 26 75 stations station NNS 9098 26 76 . . . 9098 27 1 The the DT 9098 27 2 students student NNS 9098 27 3 ’ ’ POS 9098 27 4 needs need NNS 9098 27 5 and and CC 9098 27 6 interests interest NNS 9098 27 7 were be VBD 9098 27 8 heeded heed VBN 9098 27 9 , , , 9098 27 10 and and CC 9098 27 11 Homer Homer NNP 9098 27 12 Babbidge Babbidge NNP 9098 27 13 Library Library NNP 9098 27 14 ’s ’s POS 9098 27 15 Learning Learning NNP 9098 27 16 Commons Commons NNP 9098 27 17 has have VBZ 9098 27 18 been be VBN 9098 27 19 a a DT 9098 27 20 successful successful JJ 9098 27 21 endeavour endeavour NN 9098 27 22 . . . 9098 28 1 Reference reference NN 9098 28 2 Collections collection NNS 9098 28 3 : : : 9098 28 4 History history NN 9098 28 5 and and CC 9098 28 6 Purpose Purpose NNP 9098 28 7 Brief brief JJ 9098 28 8 points point VBZ 9098 28 9 about about IN 9098 28 10 the the DT 9098 28 11 history history NN 9098 28 12 of of IN 9098 28 13 reference reference NN 9098 28 14 services service NNS 9098 28 15 lend lend VBP 9098 28 16 context context NN 9098 28 17 to to IN 9098 28 18 the the DT 9098 28 19 arguments argument NNS 9098 28 20 presented present VBN 9098 28 21 in in IN 9098 28 22 favor favor NN 9098 28 23 of of IN 9098 28 24 building build VBG 9098 28 25 electronic electronic JJ 9098 28 26 reference reference NN 9098 28 27 collections collection NNS 9098 28 28 . . . 9098 29 1 Grimmelman Grimmelman NNP 9098 29 2 points point VBZ 9098 29 3 out out RP 9098 29 4 that that IN 9098 29 5 “ " `` 9098 29 6 it -PRON- PRP 9098 29 7 ’s ’ VBZ 9098 29 8 almost almost RB 9098 29 9 a a DT 9098 29 10 cliché cliché NN 9098 29 11 to to TO 9098 29 12 assert assert VB 9098 29 13 that that IN 9098 29 14 the the DT 9098 29 15 Internet internet NN 9098 29 16 is be VBZ 9098 29 17 like like IN 9098 29 18 a a DT 9098 29 19 vast vast JJ 9098 29 20 library library NN 9098 29 21 , , , 9098 29 22 that that IN 9098 29 23 it -PRON- PRP 9098 29 24 causes cause VBZ 9098 29 25 problems problem NNS 9098 29 26 of of IN 9098 29 27 information information NN 9098 29 28 overload overload NN 9098 29 29 , , , 9098 29 30 or or CC 9098 29 31 that that IN 9098 29 32 it -PRON- PRP 9098 29 33 contains contain VBZ 9098 29 34 both both DT 9098 29 35 treasures treasure NNS 9098 29 36 and and CC 9098 29 37 junk junk NN 9098 29 38 in in IN 9098 29 39 vast vast JJ 9098 29 40 quantities quantity NNS 9098 29 41 . . . 9098 29 42 ”6 ”6 NN 9098 29 43 From from IN 9098 29 44 the the DT 9098 29 45 earliest early JJS 9098 29 46 dedicated dedicated JJ 9098 29 47 reference reference NN 9098 29 48 departments department NNS 9098 29 49 to to IN 9098 29 50 the the DT 9098 29 51 24/7 24/7 CD 9098 29 52 reference reference NN 9098 29 53 model model NN 9098 29 54 developed develop VBN 9098 29 55 in in IN 9098 29 56 response response NN 9098 29 57 to to IN 9098 29 58 progressing progressing NN 9098 29 59 technology technology NN 9098 29 60 , , , 9098 29 61 Tyckoson Tyckoson NNP 9098 29 62 affirms affirm VBZ 9098 29 63 that that IN 9098 29 64 “ " `` 9098 29 65 one one CD 9098 29 66 thing thing NN 9098 29 67 remains remain VBZ 9098 29 68 constant constant JJ 9098 29 69 — — : 9098 29 70 users user NNS 9098 29 71 still still RB 9098 29 72 need need VBP 9098 29 73 help help NN 9098 29 74 . . . 9098 30 1 The the DT 9098 30 2 question question NN 9098 30 3 . . . 9098 31 1 . . . 9098 32 1 . . . 9098 33 1 is be VBZ 9098 33 2 how how WRB 9098 33 3 to to TO 9098 33 4 provide provide VB 9098 33 5 the the DT 9098 33 6 library library NN 9098 33 7 ’s ’s POS 9098 33 8 users user NNS 9098 33 9 with with IN 9098 33 10 the the DT 9098 33 11 best good JJS 9098 33 12 help help NN 9098 33 13 . . . 9098 33 14 ”7 ”7 '' 9098 33 15 Browsing browsing NN 9098 33 16 collections collection NNS 9098 33 17 in in IN 9098 33 18 libraries library NNS 9098 33 19 are be VBP 9098 33 20 newer new JJR 9098 33 21 than than IN 9098 33 22 one one PRP 9098 33 23 might may MD 9098 33 24 assume assume VB 9098 33 25 . . . 9098 34 1 Prior prior RB 9098 34 2 to to IN 9098 34 3 World World NNP 9098 34 4 War War NNP 9098 34 5 II II NNP 9098 34 6 , , , 9098 34 7 academic academic JJ 9098 34 8 library library NN 9098 34 9 faculty faculty NN 9098 34 10 could could MD 9098 34 11 browse browse VB 9098 34 12 to to TO 9098 34 13 find find VB 9098 34 14 reference reference NN 9098 34 15 materials material NNS 9098 34 16 that that WDT 9098 34 17 met meet VBD 9098 34 18 the the DT 9098 34 19 information information NN 9098 34 20 needs need NNS 9098 34 21 of of IN 9098 34 22 students student NNS 9098 34 23 , , , 9098 34 24 but but CC 9098 34 25 undergrads undergrad NNS 9098 34 26 were be VBD 9098 34 27 n’t not RB 9098 34 28 even even RB 9098 34 29 allowed allow VBN 9098 34 30 in in IN 9098 34 31 the the DT 9098 34 32 stacks.8 stacks.8 NNP 9098 34 33 In in IN 9098 34 34 public public JJ 9098 34 35 libraries library NNS 9098 34 36 , , , 9098 34 37 reference reference NN 9098 34 38 collections collection NNS 9098 34 39 were be VBD 9098 34 40 open open JJ 9098 34 41 to to IN 9098 34 42 users user NNS 9098 34 43 , , , 9098 34 44 but but CC 9098 34 45 reference reference NN 9098 34 46 rooms room NNS 9098 34 47 were be VBD 9098 34 48 considered consider VBN 9098 34 49 to to TO 9098 34 50 be be VB 9098 34 51 , , , 9098 34 52 first first RB 9098 34 53 and and CC 9098 34 54 foremost foremost RB 9098 34 55 , , , 9098 34 56 the the DT 9098 34 57 domain domain NN 9098 34 58 and and CC 9098 34 59 workplace workplace NN 9098 34 60 of of IN 9098 34 61 the the DT 9098 34 62 reference.9 reference.9 NN 9098 34 63 This this DT 9098 34 64 raises raise VBZ 9098 34 65 the the DT 9098 34 66 question question NN 9098 34 67 , , , 9098 34 68 what what WP 9098 34 69 is be VBZ 9098 34 70 the the DT 9098 34 71 domain domain NN 9098 34 72 and and CC 9098 34 73 workplace workplace NN 9098 34 74 of of IN 9098 34 75 the the DT 9098 34 76 contemporary contemporary JJ 9098 34 77 reference reference NN 9098 34 78 librarian librarian NN 9098 34 79 ? ? . 9098 35 1 Arguably arguably RB 9098 35 2 , , , 9098 35 3 the the DT 9098 35 4 answer answer NN 9098 35 5 to to IN 9098 35 6 this this DT 9098 35 7 query query NN 9098 35 8 is be VBZ 9098 35 9 wherever wherever WRB 9098 35 10 the the DT 9098 35 11 information information NN 9098 35 12 is be VBZ 9098 35 13 , , , 9098 35 14 for for IN 9098 35 15 example example NN 9098 35 16 , , , 9098 35 17 online online RB 9098 35 18 . . . 9098 36 1 Ready ready JJ 9098 36 2 reference reference NN 9098 36 3 collections collection NNS 9098 36 4 arose arise VBD 9098 36 5 from from IN 9098 36 6 the the DT 9098 36 7 need need NN 9098 36 8 to to TO 9098 36 9 make make VB 9098 36 10 the the DT 9098 36 11 most most RBS 9098 36 12 commonly commonly RB 9098 36 13 used use VBN 9098 36 14 resources resource NNS 9098 36 15 in in IN 9098 36 16 the the DT 9098 36 17 library library NN 9098 36 18 convenient convenient JJ 9098 36 19 and and CC 9098 36 20 readily readily RB 9098 36 21 available available JJ 9098 36 22 for for IN 9098 36 23 patron patron NN 9098 36 24 use.10 use.10 NNP 9098 36 25 The the DT 9098 36 26 most most RBS 9098 36 27 commonly commonly RB 9098 36 28 used use VBN 9098 36 29 resources resource NNS 9098 36 30 in in IN 9098 36 31 contemporary contemporary JJ 9098 36 32 libraries library NNS 9098 36 33 are be VBP 9098 36 34 those those DT 9098 36 35 found find VBN 9098 36 36 online online RB 9098 36 37 — — : 9098 36 38 again again RB 9098 36 39 , , , 9098 36 40 where where WRB 9098 36 41 the the DT 9098 36 42 information information NN 9098 36 43 is be VBZ 9098 36 44 . . . 9098 37 1 Both both DT 9098 37 2 users user NNS 9098 37 3 and and CC 9098 37 4 librarians librarian NNS 9098 37 5 now now RB 9098 37 6 turn turn VBP 9098 37 7 to to IN 9098 37 8 the the DT 9098 37 9 web web NN 9098 37 10 as as IN 9098 37 11 the the DT 9098 37 12 first first JJ 9098 37 13 resort resort NN 9098 37 14 for for IN 9098 37 15 answering answer VBG 9098 37 16 quick quick JJ 9098 37 17 reference reference NN 9098 37 18 queries query NNS 9098 37 19 , , , 9098 37 20 and and CC 9098 37 21 they -PRON- PRP 9098 37 22 turn turn VBP 9098 37 23 to to IN 9098 37 24 online online JJ 9098 37 25 databases database NNS 9098 37 26 and and CC 9098 37 27 journals journal NNS 9098 37 28 for for IN 9098 37 29 exploring explore VBG 9098 37 30 complex complex JJ 9098 37 31 research research NN 9098 37 32 questions question NNS 9098 37 33 . . . 9098 38 1 Meanwhile meanwhile RB 9098 38 2 print print NN 9098 38 3 works work VBZ 9098 38 4 that that WDT 9098 38 5 were be VBD 9098 38 6 once once RB 9098 38 7 used use VBN 9098 38 8 daily daily RB 9098 38 9 sit sit NN 9098 38 10 moldering moldering NN 9098 38 11 , , , 9098 38 12 gathering gather VBG 9098 38 13 dust dust NN 9098 38 14 on on IN 9098 38 15 the the DT 9098 38 16 shelves shelf NNS 9098 38 17 either either CC 9098 38 18 because because IN 9098 38 19 they -PRON- PRP 9098 38 20 are be VBP 9098 38 21 outdated outdate VBN 9098 38 22 or or CC 9098 38 23 because because IN 9098 38 24 no no DT 9098 38 25 one one NN 9098 38 26 thinks think VBZ 9098 38 27 to to TO 9098 38 28 find find VB 9098 38 29 them -PRON- PRP 9098 38 30 when when WRB 9098 38 31 the the DT 9098 38 32 answer answer NN 9098 38 33 is be VBZ 9098 38 34 available available JJ 9098 38 35 at at IN 9098 38 36 the the DT 9098 38 37 swipe swipe NN 9098 38 38 of of IN 9098 38 39 a a DT 9098 38 40 finger finger NN 9098 38 41 or or CC 9098 38 42 the the DT 9098 38 43 click click NN 9098 38 44 of of IN 9098 38 45 a a DT 9098 38 46 mouse mouse NN 9098 38 47 from from IN 9098 38 48 where where WRB 9098 38 49 they -PRON- PRP 9098 38 50 sit sit VBP 9098 38 51 , , , 9098 38 52 whether whether IN 9098 38 53 that that DT 9098 38 54 ’s ’ VBZ 9098 38 55 in in IN 9098 38 56 the the DT 9098 38 57 library library NN 9098 38 58 or or CC 9098 38 59 in in IN 9098 38 60 , , , 9098 38 61 ahem ahem NN 9098 38 62 , , , 9098 38 63 a a DT 9098 38 64 coffee coffee NN 9098 38 65 shop shop NN 9098 38 66 . . . 9098 39 1 “ " `` 9098 39 2 The the DT 9098 39 3 convenience convenience NN 9098 39 4 , , , 9098 39 5 speed speed NN 9098 39 6 , , , 9098 39 7 and and CC 9098 39 8 ubiquity ubiquity NN 9098 39 9 of of IN 9098 39 10 the the DT 9098 39 11 Internet internet NN 9098 39 12 is be VBZ 9098 39 13 making make VBG 9098 39 14 most most JJS 9098 39 15 print print NN 9098 39 16 reference reference NN 9098 39 17 sources source NNS 9098 39 18 irrelevant irrelevant VBP 9098 39 19 , , , 9098 39 20 ” " '' 9098 39 21 Tyckoson Tyckoson NNP 9098 39 22 says.11 says.11 NNP 9098 39 23 Print Print NNP 9098 39 24 Preference Preference NNP 9098 39 25 , , , 9098 39 26 Browsing Browsing NNP 9098 39 27 Collections Collections NNPS 9098 39 28 Library Library NNP 9098 39 29 use use NN 9098 39 30 is be VBZ 9098 39 31 increasing increase VBG 9098 39 32 — — : 9098 39 33 but but CC 9098 39 34 , , , 9098 39 35 as as IN 9098 39 36 Landesman Landesman NNP 9098 39 37 and and CC 9098 39 38 others other NNS 9098 39 39 point point VBP 9098 39 40 out out RP 9098 39 41 , , , 9098 39 42 it -PRON- PRP 9098 39 43 is be VBZ 9098 39 44 increasing increase VBG 9098 39 45 because because IN 9098 39 46 users user NNS 9098 39 47 want want VBP 9098 39 48 access access NN 9098 39 49 to to IN 9098 39 50 computers computer NNS 9098 39 51 , , , 9098 39 52 instruction instruction NN 9098 39 53 in in IN 9098 39 54 technology technology NN 9098 39 55 , , , 9098 39 56 study study NN 9098 39 57 spaces space NNS 9098 39 58 , , , 9098 39 59 or or CC 9098 39 60 just just RB 9098 39 61 a a DT 9098 39 62 place place NN 9098 39 63 to to TO 9098 39 64 be be VB 9098 39 65 that that DT 9098 39 66 ’s ’ VBZ 9098 39 67 not not RB 9098 39 68 home home NN 9098 39 69 , , , 9098 39 70 not not RB 9098 39 71 school school NN 9098 39 72 , , , 9098 39 73 and and CC 9098 39 74 not not RB 9098 39 75 work work VB 9098 39 76 . . . 9098 40 1 Users user NNS 9098 40 2 do do VBP 9098 40 3 not not RB 9098 40 4 come come VB 9098 40 5 to to IN 9098 40 6 the the DT 9098 40 7 library library NN 9098 40 8 for for IN 9098 40 9 reference reference NN 9098 40 10 sources source NNS 9098 40 11 — — : 9098 40 12 researchers researcher NNS 9098 40 13 and and CC 9098 40 14 scholars scholar NNS 9098 40 15 prefer prefer VBP 9098 40 16 to to TO 9098 40 17 access access VB 9098 40 18 full full JJ 9098 40 19 - - HYPH 9098 40 20 text text NN 9098 40 21 works work NNS 9098 40 22 via via IN 9098 40 23 their -PRON- PRP$ 9098 40 24 computing computing NN 9098 40 25 devices.12 devices.12 NNP 9098 40 26 The the DT 9098 40 27 argument argument NN 9098 40 28 that that IN 9098 40 29 users user NNS 9098 40 30 prefer prefer VBP 9098 40 31 print print NN 9098 40 32 sources source NNS 9098 40 33 is be VBZ 9098 40 34 antiquated antiquate VBN 9098 40 35 , , , 9098 40 36 and and CC 9098 40 37 the the DT 9098 40 38 emphasis emphasis NN 9098 40 39 on on IN 9098 40 40 building build VBG 9098 40 41 browsing browsing NN 9098 40 42 collections collection NNS 9098 40 43 of of IN 9098 40 44 physical physical JJ 9098 40 45 reference reference NN 9098 40 46 materials material NNS 9098 40 47 reflects reflect VBZ 9098 40 48 a a DT 9098 40 49 misguided misguided JJ 9098 40 50 notion notion NN 9098 40 51 that that IN 9098 40 52 users user NNS 9098 40 53 crave crave VBP 9098 40 54 tactile tactile NN 9098 40 55 information information NN 9098 40 56 . . . 9098 41 1 Landesman landesman NN 9098 41 2 is be VBZ 9098 41 3 blunt blunt JJ 9098 41 4 : : : 9098 41 5 “ " `` 9098 41 6 When when WRB 9098 41 7 it -PRON- PRP 9098 41 8 is be VBZ 9098 41 9 a a DT 9098 41 10 core core NN 9098 41 11 title title NN 9098 41 12 , , , 9098 41 13 users user NNS 9098 41 14 want want VBP 9098 41 15 it -PRON- PRP 9098 41 16 online online RB 9098 41 17 . . . 9098 41 18 ”13 ”13 NN 9098 41 19 REFERENCE reference NN 9098 41 20 IS be VBZ 9098 41 21 DEAD DEAD NNP 9098 41 22 , , , 9098 41 23 LONG LONG NNP 9098 41 24 LIVE live JJ 9098 41 25 REFERENCE reference NN 9098 41 26 : : : 9098 41 27 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9098 41 28 COLLECTIONS collections VBP 9098 41 29 IN in IN 9098 41 30 THE the DT 9098 41 31 DIGITAL DIGITAL NNP 9098 41 32 AGE AGE NNP 9098 41 33 | | NNP 9098 41 34 TERRELL TERRELL NNP 9098 41 35 | | JJ 9098 41 36 doi doi NN 9098 41 37 : : : 9098 41 38 10.6017 10.6017 CD 9098 41 39 / / SYM 9098 41 40 ital.v34i4.9098 ital.v34i4.9098 CD 9098 41 41 58 58 CD 9098 41 42 Statistics statistic NNS 9098 41 43 bear bear VBP 9098 41 44 her -PRON- PRP$ 9098 41 45 assertions assertion NNS 9098 41 46 out out RP 9098 41 47 . . . 9098 42 1 Studies study NNS 9098 42 2 show show VBP 9098 42 3 that that IN 9098 42 4 usage usage NN 9098 42 5 of of IN 9098 42 6 print print NN 9098 42 7 reference reference NN 9098 42 8 collections collection NNS 9098 42 9 is be VBZ 9098 42 10 minimal minimal JJ 9098 42 11 and and CC 9098 42 12 that that IN 9098 42 13 users user NNS 9098 42 14 strongly strongly RB 9098 42 15 prefer prefer VBP 9098 42 16 online online JJ 9098 42 17 access access NN 9098 42 18 to to IN 9098 42 19 reference reference NN 9098 42 20 materials material NNS 9098 42 21 . . . 9098 43 1 • • NNP 9098 43 2 At at IN 9098 43 3 Stetson Stetson NNP 9098 43 4 University University NNP 9098 43 5 , , , 9098 43 6 usage usage NN 9098 43 7 statistics statistic NNS 9098 43 8 gathered gather VBN 9098 43 9 during during IN 9098 43 10 the the DT 9098 43 11 2003–4 2003–4 NNP 9098 43 12 academic academic JJ 9098 43 13 year year NN 9098 43 14 showed show VBD 9098 43 15 that that IN 9098 43 16 only only RB 9098 43 17 8.5 8.5 CD 9098 43 18 percent percent NN 9098 43 19 of of IN 9098 43 20 the the DT 9098 43 21 library library NN 9098 43 22 ’s ’s POS 9098 43 23 25,626 25,626 CD 9098 43 24 reference reference NN 9098 43 25 volumes volume NNS 9098 43 26 were be VBD 9098 43 27 used use VBN 9098 43 28 during during IN 9098 43 29 that that DT 9098 43 30 period.14 period.14 NNP 9098 43 31 • • NNP 9098 43 32 A a DT 9098 43 33 year year NN 9098 43 34 - - HYPH 9098 43 35 long long JJ 9098 43 36 study study NN 9098 43 37 by by IN 9098 43 38 Public Public NNP 9098 43 39 Libraries Libraries NNPS 9098 43 40 revealed reveal VBD 9098 43 41 that that IN 9098 43 42 only only RB 9098 43 43 13 13 CD 9098 43 44 percent percent NN 9098 43 45 of of IN 9098 43 46 Winter Winter NNP 9098 43 47 Park Park NNP 9098 43 48 ( ( -LRB- 9098 43 49 FL FL NNP 9098 43 50 ) ) -RRB- 9098 43 51 Public Public NNP 9098 43 52 Library Library NNP 9098 43 53 ’s ’s POS 9098 43 54 collection collection NN 9098 43 55 of of IN 9098 43 56 8,211 8,211 CD 9098 43 57 reference reference NN 9098 43 58 items item NNS 9098 43 59 was be VBD 9098 43 60 used.15 used.15 NNP 9098 43 61 • • XX 9098 43 62 When when WRB 9098 43 63 Texas Texas NNP 9098 43 64 A&M A&M NNP 9098 43 65 University University NNP 9098 43 66 converted convert VBD 9098 43 67 its -PRON- PRP$ 9098 43 68 reference reference NN 9098 43 69 collection collection NN 9098 43 70 ’s ’s POS 9098 43 71 primary primary JJ 9098 43 72 format format NN 9098 43 73 from from IN 9098 43 74 print print NN 9098 43 75 to to IN 9098 43 76 e e NN 9098 43 77 - - HYPH 9098 43 78 books book NNS 9098 43 79 , , , 9098 43 80 a a DT 9098 43 81 dramatic dramatic JJ 9098 43 82 increase increase NN 9098 43 83 of of IN 9098 43 84 the the DT 9098 43 85 e e NNS 9098 43 86 - - NNS 9098 43 87 versions version NNS 9098 43 88 of of IN 9098 43 89 reference reference NN 9098 43 90 titles title NNS 9098 43 91 was be VBD 9098 43 92 recorded.16 recorded.16 NNP 9098 43 93 • • NNP 9098 43 94 In in IN 9098 43 95 a a DT 9098 43 96 survey survey NN 9098 43 97 of of IN 9098 43 98 William William NNP 9098 43 99 & & CC 9098 43 100 Mary Mary NNP 9098 43 101 Law Law NNP 9098 43 102 Library Library NNP 9098 43 103 users user NNS 9098 43 104 , , , 9098 43 105 a a DT 9098 43 106 majority majority NN 9098 43 107 of of IN 9098 43 108 respondents respondent NNS 9098 43 109 indicated indicate VBD 9098 43 110 that that IN 9098 43 111 they -PRON- PRP 9098 43 112 consciously consciously RB 9098 43 113 select select VBP 9098 43 114 online online JJ 9098 43 115 reference reference NN 9098 43 116 sources source NNS 9098 43 117 over over IN 9098 43 118 print print NN 9098 43 119 , , , 9098 43 120 citing cite VBG 9098 43 121 convenience convenience NN 9098 43 122 and and CC 9098 43 123 currency currency NN 9098 43 124 as as IN 9098 43 125 top top JJ 9098 43 126 reasons reason NNS 9098 43 127 for for IN 9098 43 128 doing do VBG 9098 43 129 so.17 so.17 NNP 9098 43 130 Scanning Scanning NNP 9098 43 131 the the DT 9098 43 132 shelves shelf NNS 9098 43 133 may may MD 9098 43 134 seem seem VB 9098 43 135 to to IN 9098 43 136 some some DT 9098 43 137 to to TO 9098 43 138 be be VB 9098 43 139 the the DT 9098 43 140 most most RBS 9098 43 141 intuitive intuitive JJ 9098 43 142 way way NN 9098 43 143 to to TO 9098 43 144 search search VB 9098 43 145 for for IN 9098 43 146 information information NN 9098 43 147 , , , 9098 43 148 but but CC 9098 43 149 in in IN 9098 43 150 actual actual JJ 9098 43 151 practice practice NN 9098 43 152 , , , 9098 43 153 browsing browsing NN 9098 43 154 is be VBZ 9098 43 155 ineffective ineffective JJ 9098 43 156 — — : 9098 43 157 books book NNS 9098 43 158 at at IN 9098 43 159 eye eye NN 9098 43 160 level level NN 9098 43 161 are be VBP 9098 43 162 used use VBN 9098 43 163 more more RBR 9098 43 164 often often RB 9098 43 165 , , , 9098 43 166 patrons patron NNS 9098 43 167 are be VBP 9098 43 168 limited limit VBN 9098 43 169 to to IN 9098 43 170 sources source NNS 9098 43 171 not not RB 9098 43 172 being be VBG 9098 43 173 used use VBN 9098 43 174 by by IN 9098 43 175 another another DT 9098 43 176 patron patron NN 9098 43 177 at at IN 9098 43 178 any any DT 9098 43 179 given given JJ 9098 43 180 moment moment NN 9098 43 181 , , , 9098 43 182 and and CC 9098 43 183 overcrowding overcrowding NN 9098 43 184 of of IN 9098 43 185 the the DT 9098 43 186 shelves shelf NNS 9098 43 187 results result VBZ 9098 43 188 in in IN 9098 43 189 patrons patron NNS 9098 43 190 overlooking overlook VBG 9098 43 191 useful useful JJ 9098 43 192 materials.18 materials.18 NNP 9098 43 193 Browsing Browsing NNP 9098 43 194 is be VBZ 9098 43 195 the the DT 9098 43 196 least least JJS 9098 43 197 effective effective JJ 9098 43 198 way way NN 9098 43 199 for for IN 9098 43 200 patrons patron NNS 9098 43 201 to to IN 9098 43 202 “ " `` 9098 43 203 shop shop VB 9098 43 204 ” " '' 9098 43 205 a a DT 9098 43 206 collection collection NN 9098 43 207 . . . 9098 44 1 Searching search VBG 9098 44 2 by by IN 9098 44 3 electronic electronic JJ 9098 44 4 means mean NNS 9098 44 5 overcomes overcome VBZ 9098 44 6 the the DT 9098 44 7 obstacles obstacle NNS 9098 44 8 inherent inherent JJ 9098 44 9 in in IN 9098 44 10 browsing browse VBG 9098 44 11 the the DT 9098 44 12 physical physical JJ 9098 44 13 shelves shelf NNS 9098 44 14 when when WRB 9098 44 15 using use VBG 9098 44 16 well well RB 9098 44 17 - - HYPH 9098 44 18 designed design VBN 9098 44 19 search search NN 9098 44 20 algorithms algorithm NNS 9098 44 21 that that WDT 9098 44 22 employ employ VBP 9098 44 23 keywords keyword NNS 9098 44 24 on on IN 9098 44 25 the the DT 9098 44 26 basis basis NN 9098 44 27 of of IN 9098 44 28 accurate accurate JJ 9098 44 29 metadata metadata NN 9098 44 30 . . . 9098 45 1 Landesman Landesman NNP 9098 45 2 indicates indicate VBZ 9098 45 3 that that IN 9098 45 4 if if IN 9098 45 5 librarians librarian NNS 9098 45 6 commit commit VBP 9098 45 7 to to IN 9098 45 8 educating educate VBG 9098 45 9 patrons patron NNS 9098 45 10 on on IN 9098 45 11 the the DT 9098 45 12 use use NN 9098 45 13 of of IN 9098 45 14 the the DT 9098 45 15 reference reference NN 9098 45 16 databases database NNS 9098 45 17 , , , 9098 45 18 ebooks ebook NNS 9098 45 19 , , , 9098 45 20 and and CC 9098 45 21 websites website NNS 9098 45 22 they -PRON- PRP 9098 45 23 offer offer VBP 9098 45 24 , , , 9098 45 25 online online JJ 9098 45 26 reference reference NN 9098 45 27 will will MD 9098 45 28 be be VB 9098 45 29 “ " `` 9098 45 30 a a DT 9098 45 31 huge huge JJ 9098 45 32 win win NN 9098 45 33 for for IN 9098 45 34 users user NNS 9098 45 35 . . . 9098 45 36 ”19 ”19 UH 9098 45 37 It -PRON- PRP 9098 45 38 should should MD 9098 45 39 be be VB 9098 45 40 noted note VBN 9098 45 41 : : : 9098 45 42 no no DT 9098 45 43 one one NN 9098 45 44 suggests suggest VBZ 9098 45 45 that that IN 9098 45 46 print print NN 9098 45 47 reference reference NN 9098 45 48 should should MD 9098 45 49 be be VB 9098 45 50 eliminated eliminate VBN 9098 45 51 entirely entirely RB 9098 45 52 , , , 9098 45 53 at at IN 9098 45 54 least least JJS 9098 45 55 not not RB 9098 45 56 yet yet RB 9098 45 57 . . . 9098 46 1 Smaller small JJR 9098 46 2 print print NN 9098 46 3 reference reference NN 9098 46 4 collections collection NNS 9098 46 5 result result VBP 9098 46 6 in in IN 9098 46 7 better well RBR 9098 46 8 - - HYPH 9098 46 9 utilized utilize VBN 9098 46 10 spaces space NNS 9098 46 11 ; ; : 9098 46 12 they -PRON- PRP 9098 46 13 ensure ensure VBP 9098 46 14 that that IN 9098 46 15 remaining remain VBG 9098 46 16 resources resource NNS 9098 46 17 in in IN 9098 46 18 the the DT 9098 46 19 physical physical JJ 9098 46 20 collections collection NNS 9098 46 21 are be VBP 9098 46 22 used use VBN 9098 46 23 more more RBR 9098 46 24 effectively effectively RB 9098 46 25 — — : 9098 46 26 only only RB 9098 46 27 the the DT 9098 46 28 items item NNS 9098 46 29 that that WDT 9098 46 30 are be VBP 9098 46 31 actually actually RB 9098 46 32 high high JJ 9098 46 33 - - HYPH 9098 46 34 use use NN 9098 46 35 are be VBP 9098 46 36 included include VBN 9098 46 37 , , , 9098 46 38 which which WDT 9098 46 39 makes make VBZ 9098 46 40 these these DT 9098 46 41 sources source NNS 9098 46 42 easier easy JJR 9098 46 43 to to TO 9098 46 44 locate locate VB 9098 46 45 ; ; : 9098 46 46 books book NNS 9098 46 47 formerly formerly RB 9098 46 48 classified classify VBD 9098 46 49 as as IN 9098 46 50 reference reference NN 9098 46 51 materials material NNS 9098 46 52 are be VBP 9098 46 53 able able JJ 9098 46 54 to to TO 9098 46 55 circulate circulate VB 9098 46 56 to to IN 9098 46 57 those those DT 9098 46 58 interested interested JJ 9098 46 59 in in IN 9098 46 60 their -PRON- PRP$ 9098 46 61 specialized specialize VBN 9098 46 62 content content NN 9098 46 63 . . . 9098 47 1 Smaller small JJR 9098 47 2 print print NN 9098 47 3 reference reference NN 9098 47 4 collections collection NNS 9098 47 5 serve serve VBP 9098 47 6 patrons patron NNS 9098 47 7 in in IN 9098 47 8 myriad myriad JJ 9098 47 9 ways way NNS 9098 47 10 , , , 9098 47 11 including include VBG 9098 47 12 freeing free VBG 9098 47 13 up up RP 9098 47 14 funds fund NNS 9098 47 15 that that WDT 9098 47 16 can can MD 9098 47 17 be be VB 9098 47 18 used use VBN 9098 47 19 to to TO 9098 47 20 enhance enhance VB 9098 47 21 electronic electronic JJ 9098 47 22 reference reference NN 9098 47 23 collections collection NNS 9098 47 24 . . . 9098 48 1 Digital digital JJ 9098 48 2 reference reference NN 9098 48 3 services service NNS 9098 48 4 are be VBP 9098 48 5 just just RB 9098 48 6 another another DT 9098 48 7 way way NN 9098 48 8 of of IN 9098 48 9 organizing organize VBG 9098 48 10 information information NN 9098 48 11 — — : 9098 48 12 there there EX 9098 48 13 is be VBZ 9098 48 14 no no DT 9098 48 15 revolution revolution NN 9098 48 16 here here RB 9098 48 17 , , , 9098 48 18 unless unless IN 9098 48 19 it -PRON- PRP 9098 48 20 is be VBZ 9098 48 21 in in IN 9098 48 22 providing provide VBG 9098 48 23 information information NN 9098 48 24 with with IN 9098 48 25 more more JJR 9098 48 26 efficiency efficiency NN 9098 48 27 — — : 9098 48 28 with with IN 9098 48 29 breadth breadth NN 9098 48 30 , , , 9098 48 31 depth depth NN 9098 48 32 , , , 9098 48 33 and and CC 9098 48 34 access access NN 9098 48 35 that that WDT 9098 48 36 surpasses surpass VBZ 9098 48 37 what what WP 9098 48 38 is be VBZ 9098 48 39 possible possible JJ 9098 48 40 via via IN 9098 48 41 a a DT 9098 48 42 print print NN 9098 48 43 - - HYPH 9098 48 44 only only RB 9098 48 45 reference reference NN 9098 48 46 collection collection NN 9098 48 47 . . . 9098 49 1 The the DT 9098 49 2 inevitable inevitable JJ 9098 49 3 digital digital JJ 9098 49 4 shift shift NN 9098 49 5 is be VBZ 9098 49 6 a a DT 9098 49 7 very very RB 9098 49 8 natural natural JJ 9098 49 9 evolution evolution NN 9098 49 10 of of IN 9098 49 11 patron patron NN 9098 49 12 - - HYPH 9098 49 13 driven drive VBN 9098 49 14 library library NN 9098 49 15 services service NNS 9098 49 16 rather rather RB 9098 49 17 than than IN 9098 49 18 cause cause VB 9098 49 19 for for IN 9098 49 20 consternation consternation NN 9098 49 21 on on IN 9098 49 22 the the DT 9098 49 23 part part NN 9098 49 24 of of IN 9098 49 25 library library JJ 9098 49 26 service service NN 9098 49 27 providers provider NNS 9098 49 28 . . . 9098 50 1 Web web NN 9098 50 2 Reliability Reliability NNP 9098 50 3 : : : 9098 50 4 Google Google NNP 9098 50 5 and and CC 9098 50 6 Wikipedia wikipedia VB 9098 50 7 Those those DT 9098 50 8 who who WP 9098 50 9 argue argue VBP 9098 50 10 that that IN 9098 50 11 the the DT 9098 50 12 reliability reliability NN 9098 50 13 of of IN 9098 50 14 online online JJ 9098 50 15 sources source NNS 9098 50 16 is be VBZ 9098 50 17 questionable questionable JJ 9098 50 18 are be VBP 9098 50 19 typically typically RB 9098 50 20 referring refer VBG 9098 50 21 to to IN 9098 50 22 Google Google NNP 9098 50 23 results result NNS 9098 50 24 and and CC 9098 50 25 Wikipedia wikipedia JJ 9098 50 26 entries entry NNS 9098 50 27 , , , 9098 50 28 which which WDT 9098 50 29 have have VBP 9098 50 30 little little JJ 9098 50 31 bearing bearing NN 9098 50 32 on on IN 9098 50 33 a a DT 9098 50 34 library library NN 9098 50 35 ’s ’s POS 9098 50 36 electronic electronic JJ 9098 50 37 collections collection NNS 9098 50 38 INFORMATION INFORMATION VBD 9098 50 39 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 9098 50 40 AND and CC 9098 50 41 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 9098 50 42 | | NNP 9098 50 43 DECEMBER DECEMBER NNP 9098 50 44 2015 2015 CD 9098 50 45 59 59 CD 9098 50 46 of of IN 9098 50 47 databases database NNS 9098 50 48 and and CC 9098 50 49 e e NNS 9098 50 50 - - HYPH 9098 50 51 books book NNS 9098 50 52 , , , 9098 50 53 but but CC 9098 50 54 has have VBZ 9098 50 55 plenty plenty NN 9098 50 56 to to TO 9098 50 57 do do VB 9098 50 58 with with IN 9098 50 59 a a DT 9098 50 60 library library NN 9098 50 61 ’s ’s POS 9098 50 62 reference reference NN 9098 50 63 services service NNS 9098 50 64 : : : 9098 50 65 these these DT 9098 50 66 two two CD 9098 50 67 sources source NNS 9098 50 68 are be VBP 9098 50 69 very very RB 9098 50 70 often often RB 9098 50 71 used use VBN 9098 50 72 in in IN 9098 50 73 lieu lieu NN 9098 50 74 of of IN 9098 50 75 printed print VBN 9098 50 76 fact fact NN 9098 50 77 - - HYPH 9098 50 78 finding find VBG 9098 50 79 sources source NNS 9098 50 80 such such JJ 9098 50 81 as as IN 9098 50 82 atlases atlas NNS 9098 50 83 , , , 9098 50 84 subject subject JJ 9098 50 85 or or CC 9098 50 86 biographical biographical JJ 9098 50 87 dictionaries dictionary NNS 9098 50 88 , , , 9098 50 89 and and CC 9098 50 90 specialized specialized JJ 9098 50 91 sources source NNS 9098 50 92 like like IN 9098 50 93 Bartlett Bartlett NNP 9098 50 94 ’s ’s POS 9098 50 95 Familiar Familiar NNP 9098 50 96 Quotations Quotations NNP 9098 50 97 — — : 9098 50 98 which which WDT 9098 50 99 was be VBD 9098 50 100 last last RB 9098 50 101 printed print VBN 9098 50 102 in in IN 9098 50 103 2012 2012 CD 9098 50 104 and and CC 9098 50 105 has have VBZ 9098 50 106 recently recently RB 9098 50 107 gone go VBN 9098 50 108 digital digital JJ 9098 50 109 . . . 9098 51 1 For for IN 9098 51 2 questions question NNS 9098 51 3 of of IN 9098 51 4 fact fact NN 9098 51 5 , , , 9098 51 6 Google Google NNP 9098 51 7 is be VBZ 9098 51 8 often often RB 9098 51 9 a a DT 9098 51 10 convenient convenient JJ 9098 51 11 and and CC 9098 51 12 “ " `` 9098 51 13 reliable reliable JJ 9098 51 14 enough enough JJ 9098 51 15 ” " '' 9098 51 16 source source NN 9098 51 17 for for IN 9098 51 18 most most JJS 9098 51 19 queries query NNS 9098 51 20 ; ; : 9098 51 21 authority authority NN 9098 51 22 of of IN 9098 51 23 the the DT 9098 51 24 results result NNS 9098 51 25 yielded yield VBN 9098 51 26 by by IN 9098 51 27 a a DT 9098 51 28 Google Google NNP 9098 51 29 search search NN 9098 51 30 is be VBZ 9098 51 31 not not RB 9098 51 32 always always RB 9098 51 33 detectable detectable JJ 9098 51 34 , , , 9098 51 35 and and CC 9098 51 36 is be VBZ 9098 51 37 sometimes sometimes RB 9098 51 38 intentionally intentionally RB 9098 51 39 obscured obscure VBN 9098 51 40 , , , 9098 51 41 so so RB 9098 51 42 the the DT 9098 51 43 librarian librarian NN 9098 51 44 must must MD 9098 51 45 vet vet VB 9098 51 46 results result NNS 9098 51 47 carefully carefully RB 9098 51 48 and and CC 9098 51 49 select select VB 9098 51 50 the the DT 9098 51 51 most most RBS 9098 51 52 reliable reliable JJ 9098 51 53 sources source NNS 9098 51 54 when when WRB 9098 51 55 providing provide VBG 9098 51 56 ready ready JJ 9098 51 57 reference reference NN 9098 51 58 to to IN 9098 51 59 patrons patron NNS 9098 51 60 . . . 9098 52 1 However however RB 9098 52 2 , , , 9098 52 3 Google Google NNP 9098 52 4 is be VBZ 9098 52 5 far far RB 9098 52 6 more more JJR 9098 52 7 than than IN 9098 52 8 just just RB 9098 52 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 9098 52 10 main main JJ 9098 52 11 search search NN 9098 52 12 page page NN 9098 52 13 . . . 9098 53 1 For for IN 9098 53 2 instance instance NN 9098 53 3 , , , 9098 53 4 Google Google NNP 9098 53 5 Scholar Scholar NNP 9098 53 6 allows allow VBZ 9098 53 7 searchers searcher NNS 9098 53 8 to to TO 9098 53 9 locate locate VB 9098 53 10 full full JJ 9098 53 11 - - HYPH 9098 53 12 text text NN 9098 53 13 articles article NNS 9098 53 14 as as RB 9098 53 15 well well RB 9098 53 16 as as IN 9098 53 17 citations citation NNS 9098 53 18 for for IN 9098 53 19 scholarly scholarly JJ 9098 53 20 papers paper NNS 9098 53 21 and and CC 9098 53 22 peer peer NN 9098 53 23 - - HYPH 9098 53 24 reviewed review VBN 9098 53 25 journal journal NN 9098 53 26 articles article NNS 9098 53 27 . . . 9098 54 1 In in IN 9098 54 2 general general JJ 9098 54 3 , , , 9098 54 4 there there EX 9098 54 5 are be VBP 9098 54 6 many many JJ 9098 54 7 tools tool NNS 9098 54 8 on on IN 9098 54 9 the the DT 9098 54 10 web web NN 9098 54 11 , , , 9098 54 12 and and CC 9098 54 13 librarians librarian NNS 9098 54 14 must must MD 9098 54 15 expend expend VB 9098 54 16 effort effort NN 9098 54 17 determining determine VBG 9098 54 18 how how WRB 9098 54 19 to to TO 9098 54 20 make make VB 9098 54 21 the the DT 9098 54 22 best good JJS 9098 54 23 use use NN 9098 54 24 of of IN 9098 54 25 each each DT 9098 54 26 . . . 9098 55 1 In in IN 9098 55 2 particular particular JJ 9098 55 3 , , , 9098 55 4 Google Google NNP 9098 55 5 is be VBZ 9098 55 6 better well RBR 9098 55 7 suited suited JJ 9098 55 8 to to IN 9098 55 9 some some DT 9098 55 10 information information NN 9098 55 11 tasks task NNS 9098 55 12 than than IN 9098 55 13 others other NNS 9098 55 14 — — : 9098 55 15 it -PRON- PRP 9098 55 16 ’s ’ VBZ 9098 55 17 up up IN 9098 55 18 to to IN 9098 55 19 the the DT 9098 55 20 librarian librarian NN 9098 55 21 to to TO 9098 55 22 know know VB 9098 55 23 when when WRB 9098 55 24 to to TO 9098 55 25 use use VB 9098 55 26 this this DT 9098 55 27 tool tool NN 9098 55 28 and and CC 9098 55 29 when when WRB 9098 55 30 to to TO 9098 55 31 eschew eschew VB 9098 55 32 it -PRON- PRP 9098 55 33 . . . 9098 56 1 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP 9098 56 2 has have VBZ 9098 56 3 been be VBN 9098 56 4 the the DT 9098 56 5 subject subject NN 9098 56 6 of of IN 9098 56 7 much much JJ 9098 56 8 heated heated JJ 9098 56 9 debate debate NN 9098 56 10 since since IN 9098 56 11 its -PRON- PRP$ 9098 56 12 inception inception NN 9098 56 13 in in IN 9098 56 14 2001 2001 CD 9098 56 15 , , , 9098 56 16 but but CC 9098 56 17 in in IN 9098 56 18 a a DT 9098 56 19 study study NN 9098 56 20 conducted conduct VBN 9098 56 21 by by IN 9098 56 22 Nature Nature NNP 9098 56 23 magazine magazine NN 9098 56 24 , , , 9098 56 25 the the DT 9098 56 26 encyclopedias encyclopedias JJ 9098 56 27 Britannica Britannica NNP 9098 56 28 and and CC 9098 56 29 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP 9098 56 30 were be VBD 9098 56 31 evaluated evaluate VBN 9098 56 32 on on IN 9098 56 33 the the DT 9098 56 34 basis basis NN 9098 56 35 of of IN 9098 56 36 a a DT 9098 56 37 review review NN 9098 56 38 of of IN 9098 56 39 fifty fifty CD 9098 56 40 pairs pair NNS 9098 56 41 of of IN 9098 56 42 articles article NNS 9098 56 43 by by IN 9098 56 44 subject subject JJ 9098 56 45 experts expert NNS 9098 56 46 and and CC 9098 56 47 found find VBN 9098 56 48 to to TO 9098 56 49 be be VB 9098 56 50 comparable comparable JJ 9098 56 51 in in IN 9098 56 52 terms term NNS 9098 56 53 of of IN 9098 56 54 the the DT 9098 56 55 number number NN 9098 56 56 of of IN 9098 56 57 content content NN 9098 56 58 errors—2.9 errors—2.9 NNP 9098 56 59 and and CC 9098 56 60 3.9 3.9 CD 9098 56 61 , , , 9098 56 62 respectively.20 respectively.20 NNP 9098 56 63 Deliberate deliberate JJ 9098 56 64 misstatements misstatement NNS 9098 56 65 of of IN 9098 56 66 fact fact NN 9098 56 67 , , , 9098 56 68 usually usually RB 9098 56 69 in in IN 9098 56 70 biographical biographical JJ 9098 56 71 entries entry NNS 9098 56 72 , , , 9098 56 73 are be VBP 9098 56 74 cited cite VBN 9098 56 75 as as IN 9098 56 76 evidence evidence NN 9098 56 77 that that IN 9098 56 78 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP 9098 56 79 is be VBZ 9098 56 80 utterly utterly RB 9098 56 81 unreliable unreliable JJ 9098 56 82 as as IN 9098 56 83 a a DT 9098 56 84 reference reference NN 9098 56 85 source source NN 9098 56 86 . . . 9098 57 1 In in IN 9098 57 2 fact fact NN 9098 57 3 , , , 9098 57 4 print print NN 9098 57 5 sources source NNS 9098 57 6 have have VBP 9098 57 7 been be VBN 9098 57 8 plagued plague VBN 9098 57 9 with with IN 9098 57 10 the the DT 9098 57 11 same same JJ 9098 57 12 issues issue NNS 9098 57 13 . . . 9098 58 1 For for IN 9098 58 2 many many JJ 9098 58 3 years year NNS 9098 58 4 , , , 9098 58 5 the the DT 9098 58 6 Dictionary Dictionary NNP 9098 58 7 of of IN 9098 58 8 American American NNP 9098 58 9 Biography Biography NNP 9098 58 10 contained contain VBD 9098 58 11 an an DT 9098 58 12 entry entry NN 9098 58 13 based base VBN 9098 58 14 on on IN 9098 58 15 a a DT 9098 58 16 hoax hoax NN 9098 58 17 claiming claim VBG 9098 58 18 a a DT 9098 58 19 ( ( -LRB- 9098 58 20 nonexistent nonexistent JJ 9098 58 21 ) ) -RRB- 9098 58 22 diary diary NN 9098 58 23 of of IN 9098 58 24 Horatio Horatio NNP 9098 58 25 Alger Alger NNP 9098 58 26 — — : 9098 58 27 and and CC 9098 58 28 while while IN 9098 58 29 the the DT 9098 58 30 entry entry NN 9098 58 31 was be VBD 9098 58 32 removed remove VBN 9098 58 33 in in IN 9098 58 34 later later JJ 9098 58 35 editions edition NNS 9098 58 36 , , , 9098 58 37 the the DT 9098 58 38 article article NN 9098 58 39 was be VBD 9098 58 40 still still RB 9098 58 41 referred refer VBN 9098 58 42 to to IN 9098 58 43 in in IN 9098 58 44 the the DT 9098 58 45 index index NN 9098 58 46 for for IN 9098 58 47 several several JJ 9098 58 48 years year NNS 9098 58 49 after after IN 9098 58 50 its -PRON- PRP$ 9098 58 51 removal.21 removal.21 NNP 9098 58 52 If if IN 9098 58 53 anything anything NN 9098 58 54 , , , 9098 58 55 it -PRON- PRP 9098 58 56 seems seem VBZ 9098 58 57 that that IN 9098 58 58 format format NN 9098 58 59 might may MD 9098 58 60 provide provide VB 9098 58 61 a a DT 9098 58 62 false false JJ 9098 58 63 sense sense NN 9098 58 64 of of IN 9098 58 65 assurance assurance NN 9098 58 66 that that IN 9098 58 67 a a DT 9098 58 68 source source NN 9098 58 69 ’s ’s POS 9098 58 70 authority authority NN 9098 58 71 is be VBZ 9098 58 72 infallible infallible JJ 9098 58 73 . . . 9098 59 1 All all DT 9098 59 2 reference reference NN 9098 59 3 sources source NNS 9098 59 4 include include VBP 9098 59 5 bias bias NN 9098 59 6 , , , 9098 59 7 and and CC 9098 59 8 all all DT 9098 59 9 will will MD 9098 59 10 include include VB 9098 59 11 faulty faulty JJ 9098 59 12 information information NN 9098 59 13 . . . 9098 60 1 The the DT 9098 60 2 major major JJ 9098 60 3 difference difference NN 9098 60 4 between between IN 9098 60 5 print print NN 9098 60 6 and and CC 9098 60 7 electronic electronic JJ 9098 60 8 sources source NNS 9098 60 9 is be VBZ 9098 60 10 that that IN 9098 60 11 in in IN 9098 60 12 the the DT 9098 60 13 digital digital JJ 9098 60 14 era era NN 9098 60 15 , , , 9098 60 16 using use VBG 9098 60 17 the the DT 9098 60 18 tools tool NNS 9098 60 19 of of IN 9098 60 20 technology technology NN 9098 60 21 , , , 9098 60 22 these these DT 9098 60 23 errors error NNS 9098 60 24 can can MD 9098 60 25 be be VB 9098 60 26 corrected correct VBN 9098 60 27 quickly quickly RB 9098 60 28 . . . 9098 61 1 What what WP 9098 61 2 some some DT 9098 61 3 see see VBP 9098 61 4 as as IN 9098 61 5 declining decline VBG 9098 61 6 quality quality NN 9098 61 7 of of IN 9098 61 8 a a DT 9098 61 9 source source NN 9098 61 10 based base VBN 9098 61 11 on on IN 9098 61 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 9098 61 13 format format NN 9098 61 14 is be VBZ 9098 61 15 simply simply RB 9098 61 16 a a DT 9098 61 17 longstanding longstanding JJ 9098 61 18 feature feature NN 9098 61 19 of of IN 9098 61 20 human human NN 9098 61 21 - - HYPH 9098 61 22 produced produce VBN 9098 61 23 reference reference NN 9098 61 24 works work NNS 9098 61 25 , , , 9098 61 26 dissociated dissociate VBD 9098 61 27 from from IN 9098 61 28 any any DT 9098 61 29 print print NN 9098 61 30 vs. vs. IN 9098 61 31 web web NN 9098 61 32 debate debate NN 9098 61 33 . . . 9098 62 1 Access access NN 9098 62 2 : : : 9098 62 3 Collection collection NN 9098 62 4 vs. vs. IN 9098 62 5 Policy Policy NNP 9098 62 6 Some some DT 9098 62 7 academic academic JJ 9098 62 8 and and CC 9098 62 9 public public JJ 9098 62 10 libraries library NNS 9098 62 11 intend intend VBP 9098 62 12 to to TO 9098 62 13 decrease decrease VB 9098 62 14 or or CC 9098 62 15 discontinue discontinue VB 9098 62 16 purchasing purchasing NN 9098 62 17 print print NN 9098 62 18 - - HYPH 9098 62 19 based base VBN 9098 62 20 reference reference NN 9098 62 21 sources source NNS 9098 62 22 so so IN 9098 62 23 funds fund NNS 9098 62 24 can can MD 9098 62 25 be be VB 9098 62 26 diverted divert VBN 9098 62 27 to to TO 9098 62 28 build build VB 9098 62 29 electronic electronic JJ 9098 62 30 reference reference NN 9098 62 31 collections collection NNS 9098 62 32 ; ; : 9098 62 33 they -PRON- PRP 9098 62 34 weed weed VBP 9098 62 35 print print NN 9098 62 36 reference reference NN 9098 62 37 to to TO 9098 62 38 make make VB 9098 62 39 room room NN 9098 62 40 for for IN 9098 62 41 information information NN 9098 62 42 commons common NNS 9098 62 43 containing contain VBG 9098 62 44 technology technology NN 9098 62 45 used use VBN 9098 62 46 for for IN 9098 62 47 accessing access VBG 9098 62 48 these these DT 9098 62 49 electronic electronic JJ 9098 62 50 collections collection NNS 9098 62 51 . . . 9098 63 1 The the DT 9098 63 2 basic basic JJ 9098 63 3 assumption assumption NN 9098 63 4 in in IN 9098 63 5 the the DT 9098 63 6 objection objection NN 9098 63 7 to to IN 9098 63 8 this this DT 9098 63 9 practice practice NN 9098 63 10 is be VBZ 9098 63 11 that that IN 9098 63 12 the the DT 9098 63 13 traditional traditional JJ 9098 63 14 model model NN 9098 63 15 of of IN 9098 63 16 in in IN 9098 63 17 - - HYPH 9098 63 18 person person NN 9098 63 19 reference reference NN 9098 63 20 is be VBZ 9098 63 21 integral integral JJ 9098 63 22 to to IN 9098 63 23 a a DT 9098 63 24 functioning function VBG 9098 63 25 reference reference NN 9098 63 26 collection collection NN 9098 63 27 , , , 9098 63 28 that that DT 9098 63 29 access access NN 9098 63 30 to to IN 9098 63 31 information information NN 9098 63 32 depends depend VBZ 9098 63 33 on on IN 9098 63 34 that that DT 9098 63 35 information information NN 9098 63 36 being be VBG 9098 63 37 printed print VBN 9098 63 38 on on IN 9098 63 39 a a DT 9098 63 40 physical physical JJ 9098 63 41 page page NN 9098 63 42 . . . 9098 64 1 Reference reference NN 9098 64 2 services service NNS 9098 64 3 are be VBP 9098 64 4 provided provide VBN 9098 64 5 virtually virtually RB 9098 64 6 via via IN 9098 64 7 chat chat NN 9098 64 8 , , , 9098 64 9 IM IM NNP 9098 64 10 , , , 9098 64 11 and and CC 9098 64 12 email email NN 9098 64 13 . . . 9098 65 1 Reference reference NN 9098 65 2 services service NNS 9098 65 3 are be VBP 9098 65 4 provided provide VBN 9098 65 5 via via IN 9098 65 6 the the DT 9098 65 7 library library NN 9098 65 8 ’s ’s POS 9098 65 9 website website NN 9098 65 10 . . . 9098 66 1 Reference reference NN 9098 66 2 services service NNS 9098 66 3 are be VBP 9098 66 4 provided provide VBN 9098 66 5 by by IN 9098 66 6 roving rove VBG 9098 66 7 librarians librarian NNS 9098 66 8 , , , 9098 66 9 REFERENCE reference NN 9098 66 10 IS be VBZ 9098 66 11 DEAD DEAD NNP 9098 66 12 , , , 9098 66 13 LONG LONG NNP 9098 66 14 LIVE live JJ 9098 66 15 REFERENCE reference NN 9098 66 16 : : : 9098 66 17 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9098 66 18 COLLECTIONS collections VBP 9098 66 19 IN in IN 9098 66 20 THE the DT 9098 66 21 DIGITAL DIGITAL NNP 9098 66 22 AGE AGE NNP 9098 66 23 | | NNP 9098 66 24 TERRELL TERRELL NNP 9098 66 25 | | JJ 9098 66 26 doi doi NN 9098 66 27 : : : 9098 66 28 10.6017 10.6017 CD 9098 66 29 / / SYM 9098 66 30 ital.v34i4.9098 ital.v34i4.9098 CD 9098 66 31 60 60 CD 9098 66 32 librarians librarian NNS 9098 66 33 engaging engage VBG 9098 66 34 in in IN 9098 66 35 one one CD 9098 66 36 - - HYPH 9098 66 37 on on IN 9098 66 38 - - HYPH 9098 66 39 one one CD 9098 66 40 literacy literacy NN 9098 66 41 sessions session NNS 9098 66 42 , , , 9098 66 43 and and CC 9098 66 44 in in IN 9098 66 45 large large JJ 9098 66 46 - - HYPH 9098 66 47 group group NN 9098 66 48 training training NN 9098 66 49 sessions session NNS 9098 66 50 . . . 9098 67 1 Long long RB 9098 67 2 gone go VBN 9098 67 3 are be VBP 9098 67 4 the the DT 9098 67 5 days day NNS 9098 67 6 of of IN 9098 67 7 the the DT 9098 67 8 reference reference NN 9098 67 9 librarian librarian NN 9098 67 10 who who WP 9098 67 11 waits wait VBZ 9098 67 12 patiently patiently RB 9098 67 13 at at IN 9098 67 14 her -PRON- PRP$ 9098 67 15 station station NN 9098 67 16 for for IN 9098 67 17 a a DT 9098 67 18 patron patron NN 9098 67 19 to to TO 9098 67 20 approach approach VB 9098 67 21 with with IN 9098 67 22 a a DT 9098 67 23 question question NN 9098 67 24 . . . 9098 68 1 Since since IN 9098 68 2 the the DT 9098 68 3 reference reference NN 9098 68 4 services service NNS 9098 68 5 model model NN 9098 68 6 no no RB 9098 68 7 longer long RBR 9098 68 8 mandatorily mandatorily RB 9098 68 9 includes include VBZ 9098 68 10 a a DT 9098 68 11 stationary stationary JJ 9098 68 12 point point NN 9098 68 13 on on IN 9098 68 14 the the DT 9098 68 15 library library NN 9098 68 16 map map NN 9098 68 17 , , , 9098 68 18 nor nor CC 9098 68 19 does do VBZ 9098 68 20 providing provide VBG 9098 68 21 quality quality NN 9098 68 22 reference reference NN 9098 68 23 depend depend VBP 9098 68 24 solely solely RB 9098 68 25 on on IN 9098 68 26 the the DT 9098 68 27 depth depth NN 9098 68 28 and and CC 9098 68 29 breadth breadth NN 9098 68 30 of of IN 9098 68 31 the the DT 9098 68 32 print print NN 9098 68 33 reference reference NN 9098 68 34 collection collection NN 9098 68 35 , , , 9098 68 36 how how WRB 9098 68 37 are be VBP 9098 68 38 print print NN 9098 68 39 reference reference NN 9098 68 40 collections collection NNS 9098 68 41 used use VBN 9098 68 42 ? ? . 9098 69 1 As as IN 9098 69 2 indicated indicate VBN 9098 69 3 previously previously RB 9098 69 4 , , , 9098 69 5 about about RB 9098 69 6 10 10 CD 9098 69 7 percent percent NN 9098 69 8 of of IN 9098 69 9 print print NN 9098 69 10 reference reference NN 9098 69 11 collections collection NNS 9098 69 12 are be VBP 9098 69 13 used use VBN 9098 69 14 by by IN 9098 69 15 patrons patron NNS 9098 69 16 on on IN 9098 69 17 a a DT 9098 69 18 regular regular JJ 9098 69 19 basis basis NN 9098 69 20 . . . 9098 70 1 Concern concern NN 9098 70 2 for for IN 9098 70 3 the the DT 9098 70 4 information information NN 9098 70 5 needs need NNS 9098 70 6 of of IN 9098 70 7 library library NN 9098 70 8 users user NNS 9098 70 9 who who WP 9098 70 10 do do VBP 9098 70 11 not not RB 9098 70 12 have have VB 9098 70 13 library library JJ 9098 70 14 cards card NNS 9098 70 15 is be VBZ 9098 70 16 well well RB 9098 70 17 - - HYPH 9098 70 18 intentioned intentione VBN 9098 70 19 , , , 9098 70 20 but but CC 9098 70 21 the the DT 9098 70 22 question question NN 9098 70 23 remains remain VBZ 9098 70 24 : : : 9098 70 25 if if IN 9098 70 26 90 90 CD 9098 70 27 percent percent NN 9098 70 28 of of IN 9098 70 29 a a DT 9098 70 30 collection collection NN 9098 70 31 goes go VBZ 9098 70 32 unused unused JJ 9098 70 33 , , , 9098 70 34 even even RB 9098 70 35 when when WRB 9098 70 36 those those DT 9098 70 37 users user NNS 9098 70 38 without without IN 9098 70 39 library library NN 9098 70 40 cards card NNS 9098 70 41 have have VBP 9098 70 42 access access NN 9098 70 43 to to IN 9098 70 44 these these DT 9098 70 45 materials material NNS 9098 70 46 , , , 9098 70 47 is be VBZ 9098 70 48 the the DT 9098 70 49 collection collection NN 9098 70 50 useful useful JJ 9098 70 51 ? ? . 9098 71 1 As as IN 9098 71 2 Stewart Stewart NNP 9098 71 3 Bodner Bodner NNP 9098 71 4 of of IN 9098 71 5 NYPL NYPL NNP 9098 71 6 says say VBZ 9098 71 7 , , , 9098 71 8 “ " `` 9098 71 9 It -PRON- PRP 9098 71 10 is be VBZ 9098 71 11 a a DT 9098 71 12 disservice disservice NN 9098 71 13 to to TO 9098 71 14 refer refer VB 9098 71 15 a a DT 9098 71 16 user user NN 9098 71 17 to to IN 9098 71 18 a a DT 9098 71 19 difficult difficult JJ 9098 71 20 print print NN 9098 71 21 resource resource NN 9098 71 22 when when WRB 9098 71 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 9098 71 24 electronic electronic JJ 9098 71 25 counterpart counterpart NN 9098 71 26 is be VBZ 9098 71 27 a a DT 9098 71 28 far far RB 9098 71 29 superior superior JJ 9098 71 30 product product NN 9098 71 31 . . . 9098 71 32 ”22 ”22 VB 9098 71 33 How how WRB 9098 71 34 users user NNS 9098 71 35 want want VBP 9098 71 36 to to TO 9098 71 37 receive receive VB 9098 71 38 their -PRON- PRP$ 9098 71 39 information information NN 9098 71 40 matters matter NNS 9098 71 41 — — : 9098 71 42 access access NN 9098 71 43 should should MD 9098 71 44 not not RB 9098 71 45 depend depend VB 9098 71 46 on on IN 9098 71 47 whether whether IN 9098 71 48 a a DT 9098 71 49 user user NN 9098 71 50 can can MD 9098 71 51 obtain obtain VB 9098 71 52 a a DT 9098 71 53 library library NN 9098 71 54 card card NN 9098 71 55 . . . 9098 72 1 For for IN 9098 72 2 those those DT 9098 72 3 libraries library NNS 9098 72 4 with with IN 9098 72 5 high high JJ 9098 72 6 concentrations concentration NNS 9098 72 7 of of IN 9098 72 8 patrons patron NNS 9098 72 9 who who WP 9098 72 10 do do VBP 9098 72 11 not not RB 9098 72 12 qualify qualify VB 9098 72 13 for for IN 9098 72 14 library library JJ 9098 72 15 cards card NNS 9098 72 16 ( ( -LRB- 9098 72 17 e.g. e.g. RB 9098 72 18 , , , 9098 72 19 individuals individual NNS 9098 72 20 who who WP 9098 72 21 do do VBP 9098 72 22 not not RB 9098 72 23 have have VB 9098 72 24 a a DT 9098 72 25 fixed fix VBN 9098 72 26 home home NN 9098 72 27 address address NN 9098 72 28 , , , 9098 72 29 or or CC 9098 72 30 who who WP 9098 72 31 can can MD 9098 72 32 not not RB 9098 72 33 obtain obtain VB 9098 72 34 a a DT 9098 72 35 state state NN 9098 72 36 - - HYPH 9098 72 37 issued issue VBN 9098 72 38 ID ID NNP 9098 72 39 card card NN 9098 72 40 ) ) -RRB- 9098 72 41 , , , 9098 72 42 libraries library NNS 9098 72 43 might may MD 9098 72 44 reconsider reconsider VB 9098 72 45 their -PRON- PRP$ 9098 72 46 policies policy NNS 9098 72 47 rather rather RB 9098 72 48 than than IN 9098 72 49 their -PRON- PRP$ 9098 72 50 collections collection NNS 9098 72 51 . . . 9098 73 1 Computer computer NN 9098 73 2 - - HYPH 9098 73 3 only only RB 9098 73 4 access access NN 9098 73 5 cards card NNS 9098 73 6 can can MD 9098 73 7 be be VB 9098 73 8 provided provide VBN 9098 73 9 on on IN 9098 73 10 a a DT 9098 73 11 temporary temporary JJ 9098 73 12 basis basis NN 9098 73 13 for for IN 9098 73 14 visitors visitor NNS 9098 73 15 and and CC 9098 73 16 others other NNS 9098 73 17 who who WP 9098 73 18 are be VBP 9098 73 19 unable unable JJ 9098 73 20 to to TO 9098 73 21 obtain obtain VB 9098 73 22 permanent permanent JJ 9098 73 23 cards card NNS 9098 73 24 . . . 9098 74 1 San San NNP 9098 74 2 Francisco Francisco NNP 9098 74 3 Public Public NNP 9098 74 4 Library Library NNP 9098 74 5 recently recently RB 9098 74 6 instituted institute VBD 9098 74 7 a a DT 9098 74 8 Welcome Welcome NNP 9098 74 9 Card card NN 9098 74 10 for for IN 9098 74 11 those those DT 9098 74 12 members member NNS 9098 74 13 of of IN 9098 74 14 the the DT 9098 74 15 community community NN 9098 74 16 who who WP 9098 74 17 can can MD 9098 74 18 not not RB 9098 74 19 meet meet VB 9098 74 20 identification identification NN 9098 74 21 requirements requirement NNS 9098 74 22 for for IN 9098 74 23 full full JJ 9098 74 24 library library NN 9098 74 25 privileges privilege NNS 9098 74 26 . . . 9098 75 1 The the DT 9098 75 2 Welcome Welcome NNP 9098 75 3 Card Card NNP 9098 75 4 allows allow VBZ 9098 75 5 the the DT 9098 75 6 user user NN 9098 75 7 full full JJ 9098 75 8 access access NN 9098 75 9 to to IN 9098 75 10 computers computer NNS 9098 75 11 and and CC 9098 75 12 online online JJ 9098 75 13 resources resource NNS 9098 75 14 and and CC 9098 75 15 permits permit VBZ 9098 75 16 the the DT 9098 75 17 patron patron NN 9098 75 18 to to TO 9098 75 19 check check VB 9098 75 20 out out RP 9098 75 21 one one CD 9098 75 22 physical physical JJ 9098 75 23 item item NN 9098 75 24 at at IN 9098 75 25 a a DT 9098 75 26 time.23 time.23 NNP 9098 75 27 When when WRB 9098 75 28 compared compare VBN 9098 75 29 with with IN 9098 75 30 purchasing purchasing NN 9098 75 31 , , , 9098 75 32 housing housing NN 9098 75 33 , , , 9098 75 34 and and CC 9098 75 35 maintaining maintain VBG 9098 75 36 vast vast JJ 9098 75 37 print print NN 9098 75 38 reference reference NN 9098 75 39 collections collection NNS 9098 75 40 , , , 9098 75 41 this this DT 9098 75 42 is be VBZ 9098 75 43 a a DT 9098 75 44 significantly significantly RB 9098 75 45 less less RBR 9098 75 46 costly costly JJ 9098 75 47 and and CC 9098 75 48 far far RB 9098 75 49 more more JJR 9098 75 50 patron patron NN 9098 75 51 - - HYPH 9098 75 52 centered center VBN 9098 75 53 solution solution NN 9098 75 54 to to IN 9098 75 55 the the DT 9098 75 56 problem problem NN 9098 75 57 of of IN 9098 75 58 access access NN 9098 75 59 to to IN 9098 75 60 electronic electronic JJ 9098 75 61 information information NN 9098 75 62 sources source NNS 9098 75 63 — — : 9098 75 64 librarians librarian NNS 9098 75 65 should should MD 9098 75 66 be be VB 9098 75 67 advocates advocate NNS 9098 75 68 for for IN 9098 75 69 users user NNS 9098 75 70 , , , 9098 75 71 with with IN 9098 75 72 the the DT 9098 75 73 goal goal NN 9098 75 74 being be VBG 9098 75 75 access access NN 9098 75 76 to to IN 9098 75 77 knowledge knowledge NN 9098 75 78 , , , 9098 75 79 no no RB 9098 75 80 matter matter RB 9098 75 81 its -PRON- PRP$ 9098 75 82 format format NN 9098 75 83 . . . 9098 76 1 Conclusion conclusion NN 9098 76 2 : : : 9098 76 3 Building build VBG 9098 76 4 Better Better NNP 9098 76 5 Hybrid Hybrid NNP 9098 76 6 Collections collection NNS 9098 76 7 Most Most JJS 9098 76 8 library library NN 9098 76 9 professionals professional NNS 9098 76 10 agree agree VBP 9098 76 11 that that IN 9098 76 12 libraries library NNS 9098 76 13 should should MD 9098 76 14 collect collect VB 9098 76 15 both both DT 9098 76 16 print print NN 9098 76 17 and and CC 9098 76 18 electronic electronic JJ 9098 76 19 sources source NNS 9098 76 20 for for IN 9098 76 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 9098 76 22 reference reference NN 9098 76 23 collections collection NNS 9098 76 24 , , , 9098 76 25 but but CC 9098 76 26 the the DT 9098 76 27 ratio ratio NN 9098 76 28 of of IN 9098 76 29 print print NN 9098 76 30 to to IN 9098 76 31 digital digital NNP 9098 76 32 is be VBZ 9098 76 33 up up RB 9098 76 34 for for IN 9098 76 35 debate debate NN 9098 76 36 . . . 9098 77 1 As as IN 9098 77 2 more more JJR 9098 77 3 formats format NNS 9098 77 4 with with IN 9098 77 5 improved improved JJ 9098 77 6 capabilities capability NNS 9098 77 7 appear appear VBP 9098 77 8 , , , 9098 77 9 researchers researcher NNS 9098 77 10 find find VBP 9098 77 11 that that IN 9098 77 12 patrons patron NNS 9098 77 13 prefer prefer VBP 9098 77 14 those those DT 9098 77 15 sources source NNS 9098 77 16 that that WDT 9098 77 17 provide provide VBP 9098 77 18 them -PRON- PRP 9098 77 19 with with IN 9098 77 20 the the DT 9098 77 21 best good JJS 9098 77 22 functionality functionality NN 9098 77 23 . . . 9098 78 1 It -PRON- PRP 9098 78 2 is be VBZ 9098 78 3 essential essential JJ 9098 78 4 to to TO 9098 78 5 look look VB 9098 78 6 to to IN 9098 78 7 the the DT 9098 78 8 principles principle NNS 9098 78 9 on on IN 9098 78 10 which which WDT 9098 78 11 reference reference NN 9098 78 12 services service NNS 9098 78 13 are be VBP 9098 78 14 founded found VBN 9098 78 15 . . . 9098 79 1 One one CD 9098 79 2 of of IN 9098 79 3 those those DT 9098 79 4 principles principle NNS 9098 79 5 is be VBZ 9098 79 6 to to TO 9098 79 7 build build VB 9098 79 8 collections collection NNS 9098 79 9 on on IN 9098 79 10 the the DT 9098 79 11 basis basis NN 9098 79 12 of of IN 9098 79 13 user user NN 9098 79 14 preferences preference NNS 9098 79 15 . . . 9098 80 1 Librarians librarian NNS 9098 80 2 must must MD 9098 80 3 consider consider VB 9098 80 4 what what WP 9098 80 5 the the DT 9098 80 6 reference reference NN 9098 80 7 collection collection NN 9098 80 8 is be VBZ 9098 80 9 for for IN 9098 80 10 and and CC 9098 80 11 whether whether IN 9098 80 12 assumptions assumption NNS 9098 80 13 about about IN 9098 80 14 patron patron NN 9098 80 15 preferences preference NNS 9098 80 16 are be VBP 9098 80 17 backed back VBN 9098 80 18 by by IN 9098 80 19 evidence evidence NN 9098 80 20 . . . 9098 81 1 In in IN 9098 81 2 essence essence NN 9098 81 3 , , , 9098 81 4 considering consider VBG 9098 81 5 what what WP 9098 81 6 “ " `` 9098 81 7 reference reference NN 9098 81 8 ” " '' 9098 81 9 means mean VBZ 9098 81 10 to to IN 9098 81 11 users user NNS 9098 81 12 rather rather RB 9098 81 13 than than IN 9098 81 14 defaulting default VBG 9098 81 15 to to IN 9098 81 16 the the DT 9098 81 17 status status NN 9098 81 18 quo quo NN 9098 81 19 . . . 9098 82 1 A a DT 9098 82 2 reference reference NN 9098 82 3 collection collection NN 9098 82 4 development development NN 9098 82 5 policy policy NN 9098 82 6 must must MD 9098 82 7 be be VB 9098 82 8 based base VBN 9098 82 9 on on IN 9098 82 10 what what WP 9098 82 11 is be VBZ 9098 82 12 actually actually RB 9098 82 13 used use VBN 9098 82 14 often often RB 9098 82 15 , , , 9098 82 16 not not RB 9098 82 17 on on IN 9098 82 18 what what WP 9098 82 19 has have VBZ 9098 82 20 the the DT 9098 82 21 potential potential NN 9098 82 22 to to TO 9098 82 23 maybe maybe RB 9098 82 24 be be VB 9098 82 25 used use VBN 9098 82 26 sometime sometime RB 9098 82 27 in in IN 9098 82 28 the the DT 9098 82 29 future future NN 9098 82 30 . . . 9098 83 1 The the DT 9098 83 2 library library NN 9098 83 3 is be VBZ 9098 83 4 not not RB 9098 83 5 an an DT 9098 83 6 archive archive NN 9098 83 7 , , , 9098 83 8 preserving preserve VBG 9098 83 9 great great JJ 9098 83 10 tomes tome NNS 9098 83 11 for for IN 9098 83 12 posterity posterity NN 9098 83 13 — — : 9098 83 14 the the DT 9098 83 15 collections collection NNS 9098 83 16 in in IN 9098 83 17 a a DT 9098 83 18 library library NN 9098 83 19 are be VBP 9098 83 20 for for IN 9098 83 21 use use NN 9098 83 22 . . . 9098 84 1 With with IN 9098 84 2 less less JJR 9098 84 3 emphasis emphasis NN 9098 84 4 on on IN 9098 84 5 print print NN 9098 84 6 materials material NNS 9098 84 7 , , , 9098 84 8 librarians librarian NNS 9098 84 9 might may MD 9098 84 10 focus focus VB 9098 84 11 on on IN 9098 84 12 the the DT 9098 84 13 wealth wealth NN 9098 84 14 of of IN 9098 84 15 sources source NNS 9098 84 16 available available JJ 9098 84 17 electronically electronically RB 9098 84 18 via via IN 9098 84 19 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 9098 84 20 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 9098 84 21 AND and CC 9098 84 22 LIBRARIES LIBRARIES NNP 9098 84 23 | | NNP 9098 84 24 DECEMBER DECEMBER NNP 9098 84 25 2015 2015 CD 9098 84 26 61 61 CD 9098 84 27 databases database NNS 9098 84 28 and and CC 9098 84 29 ebooks ebook NNS 9098 84 30 , , , 9098 84 31 as as RB 9098 84 32 well well RB 9098 84 33 as as IN 9098 84 34 open open JJ 9098 84 35 - - HYPH 9098 84 36 source source NN 9098 84 37 , , , 9098 84 38 free free JJ 9098 84 39 online online JJ 9098 84 40 resources resource NNS 9098 84 41 . . . 9098 85 1 Librarians librarian NNS 9098 85 2 must must MD 9098 85 3 cultivate cultivate VB 9098 85 4 an an DT 9098 85 5 understanding understanding NN 9098 85 6 of of IN 9098 85 7 the the DT 9098 85 8 resources resource NNS 9098 85 9 patrons patron NNS 9098 85 10 use use VBP 9098 85 11 and and CC 9098 85 12 the the DT 9098 85 13 formats format NNS 9098 85 14 in in IN 9098 85 15 which which WDT 9098 85 16 they -PRON- PRP 9098 85 17 prefer prefer VBP 9098 85 18 to to TO 9098 85 19 access access VB 9098 85 20 information information NN 9098 85 21 . . . 9098 86 1 As as IN 9098 86 2 Heintzelman Heintzelman NNP 9098 86 3 and and CC 9098 86 4 coauthors coauthor NNS 9098 86 5 state state NN 9098 86 6 , , , 9098 86 7 “ " `` 9098 86 8 A a DT 9098 86 9 reference reference NN 9098 86 10 collection collection NN 9098 86 11 should should MD 9098 86 12 evolve evolve VB 9098 86 13 into into IN 9098 86 14 a a DT 9098 86 15 smaller small JJR 9098 86 16 and and CC 9098 86 17 more more RBR 9098 86 18 efficient efficient JJ 9098 86 19 tool tool NN 9098 86 20 that that WDT 9098 86 21 continually continually RB 9098 86 22 adapts adapt VBZ 9098 86 23 to to IN 9098 86 24 the the DT 9098 86 25 new new JJ 9098 86 26 era era NN 9098 86 27 , , , 9098 86 28 merging merge VBG 9098 86 29 into into IN 9098 86 30 a a DT 9098 86 31 symbiotic symbiotic JJ 9098 86 32 relationship relationship NN 9098 86 33 with with IN 9098 86 34 electronic electronic JJ 9098 86 35 resources resource NNS 9098 86 36 . . . 9098 86 37 ”24 ”24 JJ 9098 86 38 Rules rule NNS 9098 86 39 of of IN 9098 86 40 reference reference NN 9098 86 41 that that WDT 9098 86 42 were be VBD 9098 86 43 devised devise VBN 9098 86 44 when when WRB 9098 86 45 print print NN 9098 86 46 works work NNS 9098 86 47 were be VBD 9098 86 48 the the DT 9098 86 49 premier premier JJ 9098 86 50 sources source NNS 9098 86 51 of of IN 9098 86 52 reference reference NN 9098 86 53 information information NN 9098 86 54 no no RB 9098 86 55 longer longer RB 9098 86 56 apply apply VBP 9098 86 57 . . . 9098 87 1 Reference reference NN 9098 87 2 librarians librarian NNS 9098 87 3 must must MD 9098 87 4 lead lead VB 9098 87 5 the the DT 9098 87 6 way way NN 9098 87 7 in in IN 9098 87 8 responding respond VBG 9098 87 9 to to IN 9098 87 10 the the DT 9098 87 11 digital digital JJ 9098 87 12 shift shift NN 9098 87 13 — — : 9098 87 14 creating create VBG 9098 87 15 electronic electronic JJ 9098 87 16 collections collection NNS 9098 87 17 centered center VBN 9098 87 18 on on IN 9098 87 19 web web NN 9098 87 20 - - HYPH 9098 87 21 based base VBN 9098 87 22 recommendations recommendation NNS 9098 87 23 , , , 9098 87 24 licensed license VBN 9098 87 25 databases database NNS 9098 87 26 of of IN 9098 87 27 journals journal NNS 9098 87 28 , , , 9098 87 29 and and CC 9098 87 30 ebooks ebook VBZ 9098 87 31 — — : 9098 87 32 with with IN 9098 87 33 a a DT 9098 87 34 focus focus NN 9098 87 35 on on IN 9098 87 36 rich rich JJ 9098 87 37 , , , 9098 87 38 interactive interactive JJ 9098 87 39 , , , 9098 87 40 and and CC 9098 87 41 unbiased unbiase VBD 9098 87 42 content content NN 9098 87 43 . . . 9098 88 1 Weeding weeding JJ 9098 88 2 reference reference NN 9098 88 3 collections collection NNS 9098 88 4 of of IN 9098 88 5 outdated outdated JJ 9098 88 6 and and CC 9098 88 7 unused unused JJ 9098 88 8 tomes tome NNS 9098 88 9 , , , 9098 88 10 moving move VBG 9098 88 11 some some DT 9098 88 12 materials material NNS 9098 88 13 to to IN 9098 88 14 the the DT 9098 88 15 closed close VBN 9098 88 16 stacks stack NNS 9098 88 17 while while IN 9098 88 18 allowing allow VBG 9098 88 19 others other NNS 9098 88 20 to to TO 9098 88 21 circulate circulate VB 9098 88 22 , , , 9098 88 23 and and CC 9098 88 24 building build VBG 9098 88 25 e e JJ 9098 88 26 - - HYPH 9098 88 27 book book NN 9098 88 28 reference reference NN 9098 88 29 collections collection NNS 9098 88 30 allows allow VBZ 9098 88 31 libraries library NNS 9098 88 32 to to TO 9098 88 33 provide provide VB 9098 88 34 effective effective JJ 9098 88 35 reference reference NN 9098 88 36 services service NNS 9098 88 37 by by IN 9098 88 38 cultivating cultivate VBG 9098 88 39 collections collection NNS 9098 88 40 that that WDT 9098 88 41 patrons patron NNS 9098 88 42 want want VBP 9098 88 43 to to TO 9098 88 44 use use VB 9098 88 45 . . . 9098 89 1 Much much JJ 9098 89 2 of of IN 9098 89 3 the the DT 9098 89 4 transition transition NN 9098 89 5 from from IN 9098 89 6 print print NN 9098 89 7 to to IN 9098 89 8 electronic electronic JJ 9098 89 9 reference reference NN 9098 89 10 collections collection NNS 9098 89 11 can can MD 9098 89 12 be be VB 9098 89 13 accomplished accomplish VBN 9098 89 14 by by IN 9098 89 15 ensuring ensure VBG 9098 89 16 that that IN 9098 89 17 resources resource NNS 9098 89 18 are be VBP 9098 89 19 promoted promote VBN 9098 89 20 to to IN 9098 89 21 patrons patron NNS 9098 89 22 and and CC 9098 89 23 staff staff NN 9098 89 24 , , , 9098 89 25 that that DT 9098 89 26 training training NN 9098 89 27 in in IN 9098 89 28 using use VBG 9098 89 29 these these DT 9098 89 30 tools tool NNS 9098 89 31 is be VBZ 9098 89 32 provided provide VBN 9098 89 33 to to IN 9098 89 34 patrons patron NNS 9098 89 35 and and CC 9098 89 36 staff staff NN 9098 89 37 , , , 9098 89 38 that that IN 9098 89 39 librarians librarian NNS 9098 89 40 become become VBP 9098 89 41 involved involved JJ 9098 89 42 in in IN 9098 89 43 the the DT 9098 89 44 selection selection NN 9098 89 45 of of IN 9098 89 46 digital digital JJ 9098 89 47 collections collection NNS 9098 89 48 , , , 9098 89 49 and and CC 9098 89 50 that that IN 9098 89 51 the the DT 9098 89 52 spaces space NNS 9098 89 53 where where WRB 9098 89 54 print print NN 9098 89 55 collections collection NNS 9098 89 56 were be VBD 9098 89 57 formerly formerly RB 9098 89 58 housed house VBN 9098 89 59 are be VBP 9098 89 60 used use VBN 9098 89 61 in in IN 9098 89 62 ways way NNS 9098 89 63 the the DT 9098 89 64 community community NN 9098 89 65 finds find VBZ 9098 89 66 valuable valuable JJ 9098 89 67 . . . 9098 90 1 One one CD 9098 90 2 need nee MD 9098 90 3 not not RB 9098 90 4 worry worry VB 9098 90 5 about about IN 9098 90 6 the the DT 9098 90 7 “ " `` 9098 90 8 invasion invasion NN 9098 90 9 ” " '' 9098 90 10 of of IN 9098 90 11 e e NN 9098 90 12 - - NN 9098 90 13 reference reference NN 9098 90 14 or or CC 9098 90 15 the the DT 9098 90 16 “ " `` 9098 90 17 death death NN 9098 90 18 ” " '' 9098 90 19 of of IN 9098 90 20 print print NN 9098 90 21 reference reference NN 9098 90 22 . . . 9098 91 1 The the DT 9098 91 2 two two CD 9098 91 3 can can MD 9098 91 4 coexist coexist VB 9098 91 5 peacefully peacefully RB 9098 91 6 and and CC 9098 91 7 vitally vitally RB 9098 91 8 , , , 9098 91 9 as as RB 9098 91 10 long long RB 9098 91 11 as as IN 9098 91 12 librarians librarian NNS 9098 91 13 maintain maintain VBP 9098 91 14 focus focus NN 9098 91 15 on on IN 9098 91 16 selecting select VBG 9098 91 17 the the DT 9098 91 18 best good JJS 9098 91 19 material material NN 9098 91 20 for for IN 9098 91 21 their -PRON- PRP$ 9098 91 22 reference reference NN 9098 91 23 collections collection NNS 9098 91 24 , , , 9098 91 25 no no RB 9098 91 26 matter matter RB 9098 91 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 9098 91 28 format format NN 9098 91 29 . . . 9098 92 1 REFERENCES reference NNS 9098 92 2 1 1 CD 9098 92 3 . . . 9098 93 1 Margaret Margaret NNP 9098 93 2 Landesman Landesman NNP 9098 93 3 , , , 9098 93 4 “ " `` 9098 93 5 Getting get VBG 9098 93 6 It -PRON- PRP 9098 93 7 Right right UH 9098 93 8 — — : 9098 93 9 The the DT 9098 93 10 Evolution Evolution NNP 9098 93 11 of of IN 9098 93 12 Reference Reference NNP 9098 93 13 Collections Collections NNPS 9098 93 14 , , , 9098 93 15 ” " '' 9098 93 16 Reference Reference NNP 9098 93 17 Librarian Librarian NNP 9098 93 18 44 44 CD 9098 93 19 , , , 9098 93 20 no no UH 9098 93 21 . . . 9098 94 1 91–92 91–92 CD 9098 94 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 94 3 2005 2005 CD 9098 94 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 94 5 : : : 9098 94 6 8 8 CD 9098 94 7 . . . 9098 95 1 2 2 LS 9098 95 2 . . . 9098 96 1 Nicole Nicole NNP 9098 96 2 Heintzelman Heintzelman NNP 9098 96 3 , , , 9098 96 4 Courtney Courtney NNP 9098 96 5 Moore Moore NNP 9098 96 6 , , , 9098 96 7 and and CC 9098 96 8 Joyce Joyce NNP 9098 96 9 Ward Ward NNP 9098 96 10 , , , 9098 96 11 “ " `` 9098 96 12 Are be VBP 9098 96 13 Reference reference NN 9098 96 14 Books book NNS 9098 96 15 Becoming become VBG 9098 96 16 an an DT 9098 96 17 Endangered Endangered NNP 9098 96 18 Species Species NNPS 9098 96 19 ? ? . 9098 97 1 Results result NNS 9098 97 2 of of IN 9098 97 3 a a DT 9098 97 4 Yearlong Yearlong NNP 9098 97 5 Study Study NNP 9098 97 6 of of IN 9098 97 7 Reference Reference NNP 9098 97 8 Book Book NNP 9098 97 9 Usage Usage NNP 9098 97 10 at at IN 9098 97 11 the the DT 9098 97 12 Winter Winter NNP 9098 97 13 Park Park NNP 9098 97 14 Public Public NNP 9098 97 15 Library Library NNP 9098 97 16 , , , 9098 97 17 ” " '' 9098 97 18 Public Public NNP 9098 97 19 Libraries Libraries NNP 9098 97 20 47 47 CD 9098 97 21 , , , 9098 97 22 no no UH 9098 97 23 . . . 9098 98 1 5 5 CD 9098 98 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 98 3 2008 2008 CD 9098 98 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 98 5 : : : 9098 98 6 60–64 60–64 CD 9098 98 7 . . . 9098 99 1 3 3 LS 9098 99 2 . . . 9098 100 1 Sue Sue NNP 9098 100 2 Polanka Polanka NNP 9098 100 3 , , , 9098 100 4 “ " `` 9098 100 5 Off off IN 9098 100 6 the the DT 9098 100 7 Shelf Shelf NNP 9098 100 8 : : : 9098 100 9 Is be VBZ 9098 100 10 Print print NN 9098 100 11 Reference reference NN 9098 100 12 Dead dead JJ 9098 100 13 ? ? . 9098 100 14 ” " '' 9098 100 15 Booklist Booklist NNP 9098 100 16 104 104 CD 9098 100 17 , , , 9098 100 18 no no UH 9098 100 19 . . . 9098 101 1 9/10 9/10 CD 9098 101 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 101 3 January January NNP 9098 101 4 1 1 CD 9098 101 5 & & CC 9098 101 6 15 15 CD 9098 101 7 , , , 9098 101 8 2008 2008 CD 9098 101 9 ) ) -RRB- 9098 101 10 : : : 9098 101 11 127 127 CD 9098 101 12 . . . 9098 102 1 4 4 LS 9098 102 2 . . . 9098 103 1 Donald Donald NNP 9098 103 2 A. A. NNP 9098 103 3 Barclay Barclay NNP 9098 103 4 , , , 9098 103 5 “ " `` 9098 103 6 The the DT 9098 103 7 Myth Myth NNP 9098 103 8 of of IN 9098 103 9 Browsing browsing NN 9098 103 10 : : : 9098 103 11 Academic Academic NNP 9098 103 12 Library Library NNP 9098 103 13 Space Space NNP 9098 103 14 in in IN 9098 103 15 the the DT 9098 103 16 Age Age NNP 9098 103 17 of of IN 9098 103 18 Facebook Facebook NNP 9098 103 19 , , , 9098 103 20 ” " '' 9098 103 21 American American NNP 9098 103 22 Libraries Libraries NNP 9098 103 23 41 41 CD 9098 103 24 , , , 9098 103 25 no no UH 9098 103 26 . . . 9098 104 1 6–7 6–7 CD 9098 104 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 104 3 2010 2010 CD 9098 104 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 104 5 : : : 9098 104 6 52–54 52–54 CD 9098 104 7 . . . 9098 105 1 5 5 CD 9098 105 2 . . . 9098 106 1 Scott Scott NNP 9098 106 2 Kennedy Kennedy NNP 9098 106 3 , , , 9098 106 4 “ " `` 9098 106 5 Farewell farewell VB 9098 106 6 to to IN 9098 106 7 the the DT 9098 106 8 Reference Reference NNP 9098 106 9 Librarian Librarian NNP 9098 106 10 , , , 9098 106 11 ” " '' 9098 106 12 Journal Journal NNP 9098 106 13 of of IN 9098 106 14 Library Library NNP 9098 106 15 Administration Administration NNP 9098 106 16 51 51 CD 9098 106 17 , , , 9098 106 18 no no UH 9098 106 19 . . . 9098 107 1 4 4 CD 9098 107 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 107 3 2011 2011 CD 9098 107 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 107 5 : : : 9098 107 6 319–25 319–25 CD 9098 107 7 . . . 9098 108 1 6 6 CD 9098 108 2 . . . 9098 109 1 James James NNP 9098 109 2 Grimmelmann Grimmelmann NNP 9098 109 3 , , , 9098 109 4 “ " `` 9098 109 5 Information Information NNP 9098 109 6 Policy Policy NNP 9098 109 7 for for IN 9098 109 8 the the DT 9098 109 9 Library Library NNP 9098 109 10 of of IN 9098 109 11 Babel Babel NNP 9098 109 12 , , , 9098 109 13 ” " '' 9098 109 14 Journal Journal NNP 9098 109 15 of of IN 9098 109 16 Business Business NNP 9098 109 17 & & CC 9098 109 18 Technology Technology NNP 9098 109 19 Law Law NNP 9098 109 20 3 3 CD 9098 109 21 ( ( -LRB- 9098 109 22 2008 2008 CD 9098 109 23 ) ) -RRB- 9098 109 24 : : : 9098 109 25 29 29 CD 9098 109 26 . . . 9098 110 1 REFERENCE REFERENCE NNP 9098 110 2 IS be VBZ 9098 110 3 DEAD DEAD NNP 9098 110 4 , , , 9098 110 5 LONG LONG NNP 9098 110 6 LIVE live JJ 9098 110 7 REFERENCE reference NN 9098 110 8 : : : 9098 110 9 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9098 110 10 COLLECTIONS collections VBP 9098 110 11 IN in IN 9098 110 12 THE the DT 9098 110 13 DIGITAL DIGITAL NNP 9098 110 14 AGE AGE NNP 9098 110 15 | | NNP 9098 110 16 TERRELL TERRELL NNP 9098 110 17 | | JJ 9098 110 18 doi doi NN 9098 110 19 : : : 9098 110 20 10.6017 10.6017 CD 9098 110 21 / / SYM 9098 110 22 ital.v34i4.9098 ital.v34i4.9098 CD 9098 110 23 62 62 CD 9098 110 24 7 7 CD 9098 110 25 . . . 9098 111 1 David David NNP 9098 111 2 A. A. NNP 9098 111 3 Tyckoson Tyckoson NNP 9098 111 4 , , , 9098 111 5 “ " `` 9098 111 6 Issues Issues NNPS 9098 111 7 and and CC 9098 111 8 Trends Trends NNPS 9098 111 9 in in IN 9098 111 10 the the DT 9098 111 11 Management Management NNP 9098 111 12 of of IN 9098 111 13 Reference Reference NNP 9098 111 14 Services Services NNPS 9098 111 15 : : : 9098 111 16 A a DT 9098 111 17 Historical Historical NNP 9098 111 18 Perspective Perspective NNP 9098 111 19 , , , 9098 111 20 ” " '' 9098 111 21 Journal Journal NNP 9098 111 22 of of IN 9098 111 23 Library Library NNP 9098 111 24 Administration Administration NNP 9098 111 25 51 51 CD 9098 111 26 , , , 9098 111 27 no no UH 9098 111 28 . . . 9098 112 1 3 3 CD 9098 112 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 112 3 2011 2011 CD 9098 112 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 112 5 : : : 9098 112 6 259–78 259–78 CD 9098 112 7 . . . 9098 113 1 8 8 LS 9098 113 2 . . . 9098 114 1 Donald Donald NNP 9098 114 2 A. A. NNP 9098 114 3 Barclay Barclay NNP 9098 114 4 , , , 9098 114 5 “ " `` 9098 114 6 The the DT 9098 114 7 Myth Myth NNP 9098 114 8 of of IN 9098 114 9 Browsing browsing NN 9098 114 10 : : : 9098 114 11 Academic Academic NNP 9098 114 12 Library Library NNP 9098 114 13 Space Space NNP 9098 114 14 in in IN 9098 114 15 the the DT 9098 114 16 Age Age NNP 9098 114 17 of of IN 9098 114 18 Facebook Facebook NNP 9098 114 19 , , , 9098 114 20 ” " '' 9098 114 21 American American NNP 9098 114 22 Libraries Libraries NNP 9098 114 23 41 41 CD 9098 114 24 , , , 9098 114 25 no no UH 9098 114 26 . . . 9098 115 1 6–7 6–7 CD 9098 115 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 115 3 2010 2010 CD 9098 115 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 115 5 : : : 9098 115 6 52–54 52–54 CD 9098 115 7 . . . 9098 116 1 9 9 CD 9098 116 2 . . . 9098 117 1 Tyckoson Tyckoson NNP 9098 117 2 , , , 9098 117 3 “ " `` 9098 117 4 Issues Issues NNPS 9098 117 5 and and CC 9098 117 6 Trends Trends NNPS 9098 117 7 in in IN 9098 117 8 the the DT 9098 117 9 Management Management NNP 9098 117 10 of of IN 9098 117 11 Reference Reference NNP 9098 117 12 Services Services NNPS 9098 117 13 . . . 9098 117 14 ” " '' 9098 117 15 10 10 CD 9098 117 16 . . . 9098 118 1 Carol Carol NNP 9098 118 2 A. A. NNP 9098 119 1 Singer singer NN 9098 119 2 , , , 9098 119 3 “ " `` 9098 119 4 Ready Ready NNP 9098 119 5 Reference Reference NNP 9098 119 6 Collections Collections NNPS 9098 119 7 , , , 9098 119 8 ” " '' 9098 119 9 Reference Reference NNP 9098 119 10 & & CC 9098 119 11 User User NNP 9098 119 12 Services Services NNP 9098 119 13 Quarterly Quarterly NNP 9098 119 14 49 49 CD 9098 119 15 , , , 9098 119 16 no no UH 9098 119 17 . . . 9098 120 1 3 3 CD 9098 120 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 120 3 2010 2010 CD 9098 120 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 120 5 : : : 9098 120 6 253–64 253–64 CD 9098 120 7 . . . 9098 121 1 11 11 CD 9098 121 2 . . . 9098 122 1 Tyckoson Tyckoson NNP 9098 122 2 , , , 9098 122 3 Issues Issues NNPS 9098 122 4 and and CC 9098 122 5 Trends Trends NNPS 9098 122 6 in in IN 9098 122 7 the the DT 9098 122 8 Management Management NNP 9098 122 9 of of IN 9098 122 10 Reference Reference NNP 9098 122 11 Services Services NNPS 9098 122 12 , , , 9098 122 13 ” " '' 9098 122 14 293 293 CD 9098 122 15 . . . 9098 123 1 12 12 CD 9098 123 2 . . . 9098 124 1 Landesman Landesman NNP 9098 124 2 , , , 9098 124 3 “ " `` 9098 124 4 Getting get VBG 9098 124 5 It -PRON- PRP 9098 124 6 Right right UH 9098 124 7 , , , 9098 124 8 ” " '' 9098 124 9 8 8 CD 9098 124 10 . . . 9098 125 1 13 13 CD 9098 125 2 . . . 9098 126 1 Ibid Ibid NNP 9098 126 2 . . . 9098 126 3 , , , 9098 126 4 10 10 CD 9098 126 5 . . . 9098 127 1 14 14 CD 9098 127 2 . . . 9098 128 1 Jane Jane NNP 9098 128 2 T. T. NNP 9098 128 3 Bradford Bradford NNP 9098 128 4 , , , 9098 128 5 “ " `` 9098 128 6 What what WP 9098 128 7 ’s ’ VBZ 9098 128 8 Coming come VBG 9098 128 9 Off off IN 9098 128 10 the the DT 9098 128 11 Shelves Shelves NNPS 9098 128 12 ? ? . 9098 129 1 A a DT 9098 129 2 Reference Reference NNP 9098 129 3 Use Use NNP 9098 129 4 Study Study NNP 9098 129 5 Analyzing Analyzing NNP 9098 129 6 Print Print NNP 9098 129 7 Reference Reference NNP 9098 129 8 Sources Sources NNPS 9098 129 9 Used use VBN 9098 129 10 in in IN 9098 129 11 a a DT 9098 129 12 University University NNP 9098 129 13 Library Library NNP 9098 129 14 , , , 9098 129 15 ” " '' 9098 129 16 Journal Journal NNP 9098 129 17 of of IN 9098 129 18 Academic Academic NNP 9098 129 19 Librarianship Librarianship NNP 9098 129 20 31 31 CD 9098 129 21 , , , 9098 129 22 no no UH 9098 129 23 . . . 9098 130 1 6 6 CD 9098 130 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 130 3 2005 2005 CD 9098 130 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 130 5 : : : 9098 130 6 546–58 546–58 CD 9098 130 7 . . . 9098 131 1 15 15 CD 9098 131 2 . . . 9098 132 1 Heintzelman Heintzelman NNP 9098 132 2 , , , 9098 132 3 Moore Moore NNP 9098 132 4 , , , 9098 132 5 and and CC 9098 132 6 Ward Ward NNP 9098 132 7 , , , 9098 132 8 “ " `` 9098 132 9 Are be VBP 9098 132 10 Reference reference NN 9098 132 11 Books book NNS 9098 132 12 Becoming become VBG 9098 132 13 an an DT 9098 132 14 Endangered Endangered NNP 9098 132 15 Species Species NNPS 9098 132 16 ? ? . 9098 132 17 ” " '' 9098 132 18 16 16 CD 9098 132 19 . . . 9098 133 1 Dennis Dennis NNP 9098 133 2 Dillon Dillon NNP 9098 133 3 , , , 9098 133 4 “ " `` 9098 133 5 E e NN 9098 133 6 - - NN 9098 133 7 books book NNS 9098 133 8 : : : 9098 133 9 The the DT 9098 133 10 University University NNP 9098 133 11 of of IN 9098 133 12 Texas Texas NNP 9098 133 13 Experience Experience NNP 9098 133 14 , , , 9098 133 15 Part Part NNP 9098 133 16 1 1 CD 9098 133 17 , , , 9098 133 18 ” " '' 9098 133 19 Library library JJ 9098 133 20 Hi Hi NNP 9098 133 21 Tech Tech NNP 9098 133 22 19 19 CD 9098 133 23 , , , 9098 133 24 no no UH 9098 133 25 . . . 9098 134 1 2 2 CD 9098 134 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 134 3 2001 2001 CD 9098 134 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 134 5 : : : 9098 134 6 113–25 113–25 CD 9098 134 7 . . . 9098 135 1 17 17 CD 9098 135 2 . . . 9098 136 1 Paul Paul NNP 9098 136 2 Hellyer Hellyer NNP 9098 136 3 , , , 9098 136 4 “ " `` 9098 136 5 Reference reference NN 9098 136 6 2.0 2.0 CD 9098 136 7 : : : 9098 136 8 The the DT 9098 136 9 Future future NN 9098 136 10 of of IN 9098 136 11 Shrinking Shrinking NNP 9098 136 12 Print Print NNP 9098 136 13 Reference reference NN 9098 136 14 Collections collection NNS 9098 136 15 Seems seem VBZ 9098 136 16 Destined destine VBN 9098 136 17 for for IN 9098 136 18 the the DT 9098 136 19 Web web NN 9098 136 20 , , , 9098 136 21 ” " '' 9098 136 22 13 13 CD 9098 136 23 AALL AALL NNP 9098 136 24 Spectrum Spectrum NNP 9098 136 25 24–27 24–27 CD 9098 136 26 ( ( -LRB- 9098 136 27 March March NNP 9098 136 28 2009 2009 CD 9098 136 29 ) ) -RRB- 9098 136 30 . . . 9098 137 1 18 18 CD 9098 137 2 . . . 9098 138 1 Barclay Barclay NNP 9098 138 2 , , , 9098 138 3 “ " `` 9098 138 4 The the DT 9098 138 5 Myth Myth NNP 9098 138 6 of of IN 9098 138 7 Browsing Browsing NNP 9098 138 8 . . . 9098 138 9 ” " '' 9098 138 10 19 19 CD 9098 138 11 . . . 9098 139 1 Landesman Landesman NNP 9098 139 2 , , , 9098 139 3 “ " `` 9098 139 4 Getting get VBG 9098 139 5 It -PRON- PRP 9098 139 6 Right right UH 9098 139 7 . . . 9098 139 8 ” " '' 9098 139 9 20 20 CD 9098 139 10 . . . 9098 140 1 Jim Jim NNP 9098 140 2 Giles Giles NNP 9098 140 3 , , , 9098 140 4 “ " `` 9098 140 5 Internet internet NN 9098 140 6 Encyclopaedias encyclopaedia NNS 9098 140 7 Go go VBP 9098 140 8 Head Head NNP 9098 140 9 to to IN 9098 140 10 Head Head NNP 9098 140 11 , , , 9098 140 12 ” " '' 9098 140 13 Nature nature NN 9098 140 14 438 438 CD 9098 140 15 , , , 9098 140 16 no no UH 9098 140 17 . . . 9098 141 1 7070 7070 CD 9098 141 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 141 3 2005 2005 CD 9098 141 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 141 5 : : : 9098 141 6 900–901 900–901 CD 9098 141 7 . . . 9098 142 1 21 21 CD 9098 142 2 . . . 9098 143 1 Denise Denise NNP 9098 143 2 Beaubien Beaubien NNP 9098 143 3 Bennett Bennett NNP 9098 143 4 , , , 9098 143 5 “ " `` 9098 143 6 The the DT 9098 143 7 Ebb Ebb NNP 9098 143 8 and and CC 9098 143 9 Flow Flow NNP 9098 143 10 of of IN 9098 143 11 Reference Reference NNP 9098 143 12 Products Products NNPS 9098 143 13 , , , 9098 143 14 ” " '' 9098 143 15 Online Online NNP 9098 143 16 Searcher Searcher NNP 9098 143 17 38 38 CD 9098 143 18 , , , 9098 143 19 no no UH 9098 143 20 . . . 9098 144 1 4 4 CD 9098 144 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 144 3 2014 2014 CD 9098 144 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 144 5 : : : 9098 144 6 44–52 44–52 CD 9098 144 7 . . . 9098 145 1 22 22 CD 9098 145 2 . . . 9098 146 1 Mirela Mirela NNP 9098 146 2 Roncevic Roncevic NNP 9098 146 3 , , , 9098 146 4 “ " `` 9098 146 5 THE the DT 9098 146 6 E E NNP 9098 146 7 - - HYPH 9098 146 8 REF REF NNP 9098 146 9 INVASION invasion NN 9098 146 10 - - HYPH 9098 146 11 Now now RB 9098 146 12 that that IN 9098 146 13 E e NN 9098 146 14 - - NN 9098 146 15 reference reference NN 9098 146 16 is be VBZ 9098 146 17 Ubiquitous ubiquitous JJ 9098 146 18 , , , 9098 146 19 Has have VBZ 9098 146 20 the the DT 9098 146 21 Confusion Confusion NNP 9098 146 22 in in IN 9098 146 23 the the DT 9098 146 24 Reference Reference NNP 9098 146 25 Community Community NNP 9098 146 26 Subsided subside VBN 9098 146 27 ? ? . 9098 146 28 ” " '' 9098 146 29 Library Library NNP 9098 146 30 Journal Journal NNP 9098 146 31 130 130 CD 9098 146 32 , , , 9098 146 33 no no UH 9098 146 34 . . . 9098 147 1 19 19 CD 9098 147 2 ( ( -LRB- 9098 147 3 2005 2005 CD 9098 147 4 ) ) -RRB- 9098 147 5 : : : 9098 147 6 8–16 8–16 CD 9098 147 7 . . . 9098 148 1 23 23 CD 9098 148 2 . . . 9098 149 1 San San NNP 9098 149 2 Francisco Francisco NNP 9098 149 3 Public Public NNP 9098 149 4 Library Library NNP 9098 149 5 , , , 9098 149 6 “ " `` 9098 149 7 Welcome welcome VBP 9098 149 8 Card card NN 9098 149 9 , , , 9098 149 10 ” " '' 9098 149 11 sfpl.org/pdf/services/sfpl314.pdf sfpl.org/pdf/services/sfpl314.pdf . 9098 149 12 ( ( -LRB- 9098 149 13 2014 2014 CD 9098 149 14 ) ) -RRB- 9098 149 15 : : : 9098 149 16 1–2 1–2 CD 9098 149 17 . . . 9098 150 1 24 24 CD 9098 150 2 . . . 9098 151 1 Heintzelman Heintzelman NNP 9098 151 2 , , , 9098 151 3 Moore Moore NNP 9098 151 4 , , , 9098 151 5 and and CC 9098 151 6 Ward Ward NNP 9098 151 7 , , , 9098 151 8 “ " `` 9098 151 9 Are be VBP 9098 151 10 Reference reference NN 9098 151 11 Books book NNS 9098 151 12 Becoming become VBG 9098 151 13 an an DT 9098 151 14 Endangered Endangered NNP 9098 151 15 Species Species NNPS 9098 151 16 ? ? . 9098 151 17 ” " '' 9098 151 18 http://sfpl.org/pdf/services/sfpl314.pdf http://sfpl.org/pdf/services/sfpl314.pdf CD 9098 151 19 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP