id sid tid token lemma pos 9598 1 1 Microsoft Microsoft NNP 9598 1 2 Word Word NNP 9598 1 3 - - HYPH 9598 1 4 March_ITAL_Massicotte_proof_revised.docx March_ITAL_Massicotte_proof_revised.docx NNP 9598 1 5 Reference Reference NNP 9598 1 6 Rot Rot NNP 9598 1 7 in in IN 9598 1 8 the the DT 9598 1 9 Repository repository NN 9598 1 10 : : : 9598 1 11 A a DT 9598 1 12 Case Case NNP 9598 1 13 Study Study NNP 9598 1 14 of of IN 9598 1 15 Electronic Electronic NNP 9598 1 16 These these DT 9598 1 17 s s NNS 9598 1 18 and and CC 9598 1 19 Dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 1 20 ( ( -LRB- 9598 1 21 ETDs ETDs NNP 9598 1 22 ) ) -RRB- 9598 1 23 in in IN 9598 1 24 an an DT 9598 1 25 Academic Academic NNP 9598 1 26 Library Library NNP 9598 1 27 Mia Mia NNP 9598 1 28 Massicotte Massicotte NNP 9598 1 29 and and CC 9598 1 30 Kathleen Kathleen NNP 9598 1 31 Botter Botter NNP 9598 1 32 INFORMATION INFORMATION VBD 9598 1 33 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 9598 1 34 AND and CC 9598 1 35 LIBRARIES library NNS 9598 1 36 | | JJ 9598 1 37 MARCH MARCH NNS 9598 1 38 2017 2017 CD 9598 1 39 11 11 CD 9598 1 40 ABSTRACT ABSTRACT NNP 9598 1 41 This this DT 9598 1 42 study study NN 9598 1 43 examines examine VBZ 9598 1 44 ETDs etd NNS 9598 1 45 deposited deposit VBN 9598 1 46 during during IN 9598 1 47 the the DT 9598 1 48 period period NN 9598 1 49 2011 2011 CD 9598 1 50 - - SYM 9598 1 51 2015 2015 CD 9598 1 52 in in IN 9598 1 53 an an DT 9598 1 54 institutional institutional JJ 9598 1 55 repository repository NN 9598 1 56 , , , 9598 1 57 to to TO 9598 1 58 determine determine VB 9598 1 59 the the DT 9598 1 60 degree degree NN 9598 1 61 to to TO 9598 1 62 which which WDT 9598 1 63 the the DT 9598 1 64 documents document NNS 9598 1 65 suffer suffer VBP 9598 1 66 from from IN 9598 1 67 reference reference NN 9598 1 68 rot rot NN 9598 1 69 , , , 9598 1 70 that that RB 9598 1 71 is is RB 9598 1 72 , , , 9598 1 73 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 1 74 plus plus CC 9598 1 75 content content NN 9598 1 76 drift drift NN 9598 1 77 . . . 9598 2 1 The the DT 9598 2 2 authors author NNS 9598 2 3 converted convert VBD 9598 2 4 and and CC 9598 2 5 examined examine VBD 9598 2 6 664 664 CD 9598 2 7 doctoral doctoral JJ 9598 2 8 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 2 9 in in IN 9598 2 10 total total NN 9598 2 11 , , , 9598 2 12 extracting extract VBG 9598 2 13 11,437 11,437 CD 9598 2 14 links link NNS 9598 2 15 , , , 9598 2 16 finding find VBG 9598 2 17 overall overall RB 9598 2 18 that that IN 9598 2 19 77 77 CD 9598 2 20 % % NN 9598 2 21 of of IN 9598 2 22 links link NNS 9598 2 23 were be VBD 9598 2 24 active active JJ 9598 2 25 , , , 9598 2 26 and and CC 9598 2 27 23 23 CD 9598 2 28 % % NN 9598 2 29 exhibited exhibit VBD 9598 2 30 linkrot linkrot NNS 9598 2 31 . . . 9598 3 1 A a DT 9598 3 2 stratified stratified JJ 9598 3 3 random random JJ 9598 3 4 sample sample NN 9598 3 5 of of IN 9598 3 6 49 49 CD 9598 3 7 ETDs etd NNS 9598 3 8 was be VBD 9598 3 9 performed perform VBN 9598 3 10 which which WDT 9598 3 11 produced produce VBD 9598 3 12 990 990 CD 9598 3 13 active active JJ 9598 3 14 links link NNS 9598 3 15 , , , 9598 3 16 which which WDT 9598 3 17 were be VBD 9598 3 18 then then RB 9598 3 19 checked check VBN 9598 3 20 for for IN 9598 3 21 content content NN 9598 3 22 drift drift NN 9598 3 23 based base VBN 9598 3 24 on on IN 9598 3 25 mementos memento NNS 9598 3 26 found find VBN 9598 3 27 in in IN 9598 3 28 the the DT 9598 3 29 Wayback Wayback NNP 9598 3 30 Machine Machine NNP 9598 3 31 . . . 9598 4 1 Mementos memento NNS 9598 4 2 were be VBD 9598 4 3 found find VBN 9598 4 4 for for IN 9598 4 5 77 77 CD 9598 4 6 % % NN 9598 4 7 of of IN 9598 4 8 links link NNS 9598 4 9 , , , 9598 4 10 and and CC 9598 4 11 approximately approximately RB 9598 4 12 half half NN 9598 4 13 of of IN 9598 4 14 these these DT 9598 4 15 , , , 9598 4 16 492 492 CD 9598 4 17 of of IN 9598 4 18 990 990 CD 9598 4 19 , , , 9598 4 20 exhibited exhibit VBD 9598 4 21 content content NN 9598 4 22 drift drift NN 9598 4 23 . . . 9598 5 1 The the DT 9598 5 2 results result NNS 9598 5 3 serve serve VBP 9598 5 4 to to TO 9598 5 5 emphasize emphasize VB 9598 5 6 not not RB 9598 5 7 only only RB 9598 5 8 the the DT 9598 5 9 necessity necessity NN 9598 5 10 of of IN 9598 5 11 broader broad JJR 9598 5 12 awareness awareness NN 9598 5 13 of of IN 9598 5 14 this this DT 9598 5 15 problem problem NN 9598 5 16 , , , 9598 5 17 but but CC 9598 5 18 also also RB 9598 5 19 to to TO 9598 5 20 stimulate stimulate VB 9598 5 21 action action NN 9598 5 22 on on IN 9598 5 23 the the DT 9598 5 24 preservation preservation NN 9598 5 25 front front NN 9598 5 26 . . . 9598 6 1 INTRODUCTION introduction VB 9598 6 2 A a DT 9598 6 3 significant significant JJ 9598 6 4 proportion proportion NN 9598 6 5 of of IN 9598 6 6 material material NN 9598 6 7 in in IN 9598 6 8 institutional institutional JJ 9598 6 9 repositories repository NNS 9598 6 10 is be VBZ 9598 6 11 comprised comprise VBN 9598 6 12 of of IN 9598 6 13 electronic electronic JJ 9598 6 14 these these DT 9598 6 15 s s NNS 9598 6 16 and and CC 9598 6 17 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 6 18 ( ( -LRB- 9598 6 19 ETDs ETDs NNP 9598 6 20 ) ) -RRB- 9598 6 21 , , , 9598 6 22 providing provide VBG 9598 6 23 academic academic JJ 9598 6 24 librarians librarian NNS 9598 6 25 with with IN 9598 6 26 a a DT 9598 6 27 rich rich JJ 9598 6 28 testbed testbed NN 9598 6 29 for for IN 9598 6 30 deepening deepen VBG 9598 6 31 our -PRON- PRP$ 9598 6 32 understanding understanding NN 9598 6 33 of of IN 9598 6 34 new new JJ 9598 6 35 paradigms paradigms NN 9598 6 36 in in IN 9598 6 37 scholarly scholarly JJ 9598 6 38 publishing publishing NN 9598 6 39 and and CC 9598 6 40 their -PRON- PRP$ 9598 6 41 implications implication NNS 9598 6 42 for for IN 9598 6 43 long long JJ 9598 6 44 - - HYPH 9598 6 45 term term NN 9598 6 46 digital digital JJ 9598 6 47 preservation preservation NN 9598 6 48 . . . 9598 7 1 While while IN 9598 7 2 academic academic JJ 9598 7 3 libraries library NNS 9598 7 4 have have VBP 9598 7 5 long long RB 9598 7 6 collected collect VBN 9598 7 7 and and CC 9598 7 8 preserved preserve VBN 9598 7 9 hard hard JJ 9598 7 10 copy copy VBP 9598 7 11 these these DT 9598 7 12 s s NNS 9598 7 13 and and CC 9598 7 14 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 7 15 of of IN 9598 7 16 the the DT 9598 7 17 parent parent NN 9598 7 18 institution institution NN 9598 7 19 , , , 9598 7 20 the the DT 9598 7 21 shift shift NN 9598 7 22 to to IN 9598 7 23 mandatory mandatory JJ 9598 7 24 electronic electronic JJ 9598 7 25 deposit deposit NN 9598 7 26 of of IN 9598 7 27 this this DT 9598 7 28 material material NN 9598 7 29 has have VBZ 9598 7 30 conferred confer VBN 9598 7 31 new new JJ 9598 7 32 obligations obligation NNS 9598 7 33 and and CC 9598 7 34 curatorial curatorial JJ 9598 7 35 functions function NNS 9598 7 36 not not RB 9598 7 37 previously previously RB 9598 7 38 incorporated incorporate VBN 9598 7 39 into into IN 9598 7 40 library library JJ 9598 7 41 workflows workflow NNS 9598 7 42 . . . 9598 8 1 By by IN 9598 8 2 highlighting highlight VBG 9598 8 3 ETDs etd NNS 9598 8 4 as as IN 9598 8 5 a a DT 9598 8 6 susceptible susceptible JJ 9598 8 7 collection collection NN 9598 8 8 deserving deserving NN 9598 8 9 of of IN 9598 8 10 specific specific JJ 9598 8 11 preservation preservation NN 9598 8 12 actions action NNS 9598 8 13 , , , 9598 8 14 we -PRON- PRP 9598 8 15 draw draw VBP 9598 8 16 attention attention NN 9598 8 17 to to IN 9598 8 18 some some DT 9598 8 19 unique unique JJ 9598 8 20 responsibilities responsibility NNS 9598 8 21 for for IN 9598 8 22 libraries library NNS 9598 8 23 housing housing NNP 9598 8 24 university university NNP 9598 8 25 - - HYPH 9598 8 26 produced produce VBN 9598 8 27 content content NN 9598 8 28 , , , 9598 8 29 particularly particularly RB 9598 8 30 as as IN 9598 8 31 scholarly scholarly JJ 9598 8 32 information information NN 9598 8 33 continues continue VBZ 9598 8 34 its -PRON- PRP$ 9598 8 35 shift shift NN 9598 8 36 away away RB 9598 8 37 from from IN 9598 8 38 commercial commercial JJ 9598 8 39 production production NN 9598 8 40 and and CC 9598 8 41 distribution distribution NN 9598 8 42 channels channel NNS 9598 8 43 . . . 9598 9 1 As as IN 9598 9 2 Teper Teper NNP 9598 9 3 and and CC 9598 9 4 Kraemer Kraemer NNP 9598 9 5 point point VBP 9598 9 6 out out RP 9598 9 7 in in IN 9598 9 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 9598 9 9 discussion discussion NN 9598 9 10 of of IN 9598 9 11 ETD ETD NNP 9598 9 12 program program NN 9598 9 13 goals goal NNS 9598 9 14 , , , 9598 9 15 “ " `` 9598 9 16 without without IN 9598 9 17 preservation preservation NN 9598 9 18 , , , 9598 9 19 long long JJ 9598 9 20 - - HYPH 9598 9 21 term term NN 9598 9 22 access access NN 9598 9 23 is be VBZ 9598 9 24 impossible impossible JJ 9598 9 25 ; ; : 9598 9 26 without without IN 9598 9 27 long long JJ 9598 9 28 - - HYPH 9598 9 29 term term NN 9598 9 30 access access NN 9598 9 31 , , , 9598 9 32 preservation preservation NN 9598 9 33 is be VBZ 9598 9 34 meaningless meaningless JJ 9598 9 35 . . . 9598 9 36 ”1 ”1 , 9598 9 37 What what WP 9598 9 38 Is be VBZ 9598 9 39 Reference Reference NNP 9598 9 40 Rot Rot NNP 9598 9 41 , , , 9598 9 42 And and CC 9598 9 43 Why why WRB 9598 9 44 Study study VB 9598 9 45 It -PRON- PRP 9598 9 46 ? ? . 9598 10 1 In in IN 9598 10 2 addition addition NN 9598 10 3 to to IN 9598 10 4 linkrot linkrot VB 9598 10 5 ( ( -LRB- 9598 10 6 where where WRB 9598 10 7 a a DT 9598 10 8 link link NN 9598 10 9 sends send VBZ 9598 10 10 the the DT 9598 10 11 user user NN 9598 10 12 to to IN 9598 10 13 a a DT 9598 10 14 webpage webpage NN 9598 10 15 which which WDT 9598 10 16 is be VBZ 9598 10 17 no no DT 9598 10 18 longer long RBR 9598 10 19 available available JJ 9598 10 20 ) ) -RRB- 9598 10 21 , , , 9598 10 22 Mia Mia NNP 9598 10 23 Massicotte Massicotte NNP 9598 10 24 ( ( -LRB- 9598 10 25 Mia.Massicotte@concordia.ca Mia.Massicotte@concordia.ca NNP 9598 10 26 ) ) -RRB- 9598 10 27 is be VBZ 9598 10 28 Systems system NNS 9598 10 29 Librarian Librarian NNP 9598 10 30 , , , 9598 10 31 Concordia Concordia NNP 9598 10 32 University University NNP 9598 10 33 Library Library NNP 9598 10 34 , , , 9598 10 35 Montreal Montreal NNP 9598 10 36 , , , 9598 10 37 Quebec Quebec NNP 9598 10 38 , , , 9598 10 39 Canada Canada NNP 9598 10 40 . . . 9598 11 1 Kathleen Kathleen NNP 9598 11 2 Botter Botter NNP 9598 11 3 ( ( -LRB- 9598 11 4 Kathleen.Botter@concordia.ca Kathleen.Botter@concordia.ca NNP 9598 11 5 ) ) -RRB- 9598 11 6 is be VBZ 9598 11 7 Systems system NNS 9598 11 8 Librarian Librarian NNP 9598 11 9 , , , 9598 11 10 Concordia Concordia NNP 9598 11 11 University University NNP 9598 11 12 Library Library NNP 9598 11 13 , , , 9598 11 14 Montreal Montreal NNP 9598 11 15 , , , 9598 11 16 Quebec Quebec NNP 9598 11 17 , , , 9598 11 18 Canada Canada NNP 9598 11 19 . . . 9598 12 1 A a DT 9598 12 2 CASE case NN 9598 12 3 STUDY STUDY NNP 9598 12 4 OF of IN 9598 12 5 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9598 12 6 THESES thesis NNS 9598 12 7 AND and CC 9598 12 8 DISSERTATIONS dissertation NNS 9598 12 9 ( ( -LRB- 9598 12 10 ETDS ETDS NNP 9598 12 11 ) ) -RRB- 9598 12 12 IN in IN 9598 12 13 AN an DT 9598 12 14 ACADEMIC ACADEMIC NNP 9598 12 15 LIBRARY LIBRARY NNP 9598 12 16 | | NNS 9598 12 17 MASSICOTTE MASSICOTTE NNP 9598 12 18 AND and CC 9598 12 19 BOTTER BOTTER NNP 9598 12 20 | | NNP 9598 12 21 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 NNP 9598 12 22 12 12 CD 9598 12 23 there there EX 9598 12 24 are be VBP 9598 12 25 webpages webpage NNS 9598 12 26 that that WDT 9598 12 27 remain remain VBP 9598 12 28 available available JJ 9598 12 29 , , , 9598 12 30 but but CC 9598 12 31 whose whose WP$ 9598 12 32 contents content NNS 9598 12 33 have have VBP 9598 12 34 undergone undergo VBN 9598 12 35 change change NN 9598 12 36 over over IN 9598 12 37 time-- time-- NN 9598 12 38 known know VBN 9598 12 39 as as IN 9598 12 40 content content NN 9598 12 41 drift drift NN 9598 12 42 . . . 9598 13 1 This this DT 9598 13 2 dual dual JJ 9598 13 3 phenomena phenomenon NNS 9598 13 4 of of IN 9598 13 5 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 13 6 plus plus CC 9598 13 7 content content NN 9598 13 8 drift drift NN 9598 13 9 has have VBZ 9598 13 10 been be VBN 9598 13 11 characterized characterize VBN 9598 13 12 as as IN 9598 13 13 reference reference NN 9598 13 14 rot rot NN 9598 13 15 by by IN 9598 13 16 the the DT 9598 13 17 Hiberlink Hiberlink NNP 9598 13 18 project project NN 9598 13 19 team,2 team,2 NNS 9598 13 20 and and CC 9598 13 21 has have VBZ 9598 13 22 important important JJ 9598 13 23 implications implication NNS 9598 13 24 for for IN 9598 13 25 digital digital JJ 9598 13 26 preservation preservation NN 9598 13 27 . . . 9598 14 1 Since since IN 9598 14 2 these these DT 9598 14 3 s s NNS 9598 14 4 and and CC 9598 14 5 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 14 6 are be VBP 9598 14 7 original original JJ 9598 14 8 works work NNS 9598 14 9 born bear VBN 9598 14 10 digital digital NNP 9598 14 11 by by IN 9598 14 12 virtue virtue NN 9598 14 13 of of IN 9598 14 14 mandatory mandatory JJ 9598 14 15 deposit deposit NN 9598 14 16 programs program NNS 9598 14 17 , , , 9598 14 18 a a DT 9598 14 19 university university NN 9598 14 20 ’s ’s POS 9598 14 21 ETD ETD NNP 9598 14 22 program program NN 9598 14 23 is be VBZ 9598 14 24 effectively effectively RB 9598 14 25 a a DT 9598 14 26 digital digital JJ 9598 14 27 publishing publishing NN 9598 14 28 initiative initiative NN 9598 14 29 , , , 9598 14 30 accompanied accompany VBN 9598 14 31 by by IN 9598 14 32 a a DT 9598 14 33 new new JJ 9598 14 34 universe universe NN 9598 14 35 of of IN 9598 14 36 responsibility responsibility NN 9598 14 37 for for IN 9598 14 38 its -PRON- PRP$ 9598 14 39 digital digital JJ 9598 14 40 preservation preservation NN 9598 14 41 . . . 9598 15 1 Due due IN 9598 15 2 to to IN 9598 15 3 the the DT 9598 15 4 specialized specialized JJ 9598 15 5 nature nature NN 9598 15 6 of of IN 9598 15 7 graduate graduate JJ 9598 15 8 - - HYPH 9598 15 9 level level NN 9598 15 10 research research NN 9598 15 11 , , , 9598 15 12 ETDs etd NNS 9598 15 13 frequently frequently RB 9598 15 14 include include VBP 9598 15 15 links link NNS 9598 15 16 to to IN 9598 15 17 resources resource NNS 9598 15 18 on on IN 9598 15 19 the the DT 9598 15 20 open open JJ 9598 15 21 web web NN 9598 15 22 , , , 9598 15 23 for for IN 9598 15 24 example example NN 9598 15 25 , , , 9598 15 26 personal personal JJ 9598 15 27 blogs blog NNS 9598 15 28 , , , 9598 15 29 project project NN 9598 15 30 websites website NNS 9598 15 31 , , , 9598 15 32 and and CC 9598 15 33 commercial commercial JJ 9598 15 34 entities entity NNS 9598 15 35 . . . 9598 16 1 Digital Digital NNP 9598 16 2 Object Object NNP 9598 16 3 Identifiers identifier NNS 9598 16 4 ( ( -LRB- 9598 16 5 DOIs DOIs NNP 9598 16 6 ) ) -RRB- 9598 16 7 , , , 9598 16 8 useful useful JJ 9598 16 9 in in IN 9598 16 10 the the DT 9598 16 11 context context NN 9598 16 12 of of IN 9598 16 13 published publish VBN 9598 16 14 literature literature NN 9598 16 15 , , , 9598 16 16 do do VBP 9598 16 17 not not RB 9598 16 18 apply apply VB 9598 16 19 to to IN 9598 16 20 URLs url NNS 9598 16 21 on on IN 9598 16 22 the the DT 9598 16 23 free free JJ 9598 16 24 web web NN 9598 16 25 , , , 9598 16 26 which which WDT 9598 16 27 are be VBP 9598 16 28 DOI doi NN 9598 16 29 - - HYPH 9598 16 30 indifferent indifferent JJ 9598 16 31 . . . 9598 17 1 Open open JJ 9598 17 2 web web NN 9598 17 3 links link NNS 9598 17 4 also also RB 9598 17 5 fall fall VBP 9598 17 6 outside outside IN 9598 17 7 the the DT 9598 17 8 scope scope NN 9598 17 9 of of IN 9598 17 10 preservation preservation NN 9598 17 11 initiatives initiative NNS 9598 17 12 such such JJ 9598 17 13 as as IN 9598 17 14 LOCKSS LOCKSS NNP 9598 17 15 ( ( -LRB- 9598 17 16 Lots lot NNS 9598 17 17 of of IN 9598 17 18 Copies copy NNS 9598 17 19 Keep Keep NNP 9598 17 20 Stuff Stuff NNP 9598 17 21 Safe)3 Safe)3 NNP 9598 17 22 which which WDT 9598 17 23 aim aim VBP 9598 17 24 to to TO 9598 17 25 safeguard safeguard VB 9598 17 26 the the DT 9598 17 27 published publish VBN 9598 17 28 literature literature NN 9598 17 29 . . . 9598 18 1 With with IN 9598 18 2 increasing increase VBG 9598 18 3 frequency frequency NN 9598 18 4 , , , 9598 18 5 researchers researcher NNS 9598 18 6 are be VBP 9598 18 7 citing cite VBG 9598 18 8 newer new JJR 9598 18 9 forms form NNS 9598 18 10 of of IN 9598 18 11 scholarship scholarship NN 9598 18 12 , , , 9598 18 13 which which WDT 9598 18 14 do do VBP 9598 18 15 not not RB 9598 18 16 readily readily RB 9598 18 17 fall fall VB 9598 18 18 under under IN 9598 18 19 the the DT 9598 18 20 rubric rubric NN 9598 18 21 of of IN 9598 18 22 published publish VBN 9598 18 23 literature literature NN 9598 18 24 . . . 9598 19 1 Moreover moreover RB 9598 19 2 , , , 9598 19 3 since since IN 9598 19 4 thesis thesis NN 9598 19 5 preparation preparation NN 9598 19 6 is be VBZ 9598 19 7 conducted conduct VBN 9598 19 8 over over IN 9598 19 9 a a DT 9598 19 10 period period NN 9598 19 11 of of IN 9598 19 12 time time NN 9598 19 13 typically typically RB 9598 19 14 measured measure VBN 9598 19 15 in in IN 9598 19 16 years year NNS 9598 19 17 , , , 9598 19 18 links link NNS 9598 19 19 cited cite VBD 9598 19 20 therein therein RB 9598 19 21 are be VBP 9598 19 22 likely likely JJ 9598 19 23 to to TO 9598 19 24 be be VB 9598 19 25 more more RBR 9598 19 26 vulnerable vulnerable JJ 9598 19 27 to to IN 9598 19 28 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 19 29 and and CC 9598 19 30 content content NN 9598 19 31 drift drift NN 9598 19 32 by by IN 9598 19 33 the the DT 9598 19 34 time time NN 9598 19 35 of of IN 9598 19 36 manuscript manuscript NN 9598 19 37 submission submission NN 9598 19 38 . . . 9598 20 1 Yet yet CC 9598 20 2 despite despite IN 9598 20 3 the the DT 9598 20 4 surfeit surfeit NN 9598 20 5 of of IN 9598 20 6 anecdotal anecdotal JJ 9598 20 7 daily daily JJ 9598 20 8 evidence evidence NN 9598 20 9 that that IN 9598 20 10 URLs url VBZ 9598 20 11 vanish vanish VBP 9598 20 12 and and CC 9598 20 13 result result VBP 9598 20 14 in in IN 9598 20 15 dead dead JJ 9598 20 16 links link NNS 9598 20 17 , , , 9598 20 18 Phillips Phillips NNP 9598 20 19 , , , 9598 20 20 Alemneh Alemneh NNP 9598 20 21 , , , 9598 20 22 and and CC 9598 20 23 Ayala Ayala NNP 9598 20 24 point point VBP 9598 20 25 out out RP 9598 20 26 that that IN 9598 20 27 “ " `` 9598 20 28 by by IN 9598 20 29 and and CC 9598 20 30 large large JJ 9598 20 31 academic academic JJ 9598 20 32 libraries library NNS 9598 20 33 are be VBP 9598 20 34 not not RB 9598 20 35 capturing capture VBG 9598 20 36 and and CC 9598 20 37 maintaining maintain VBG 9598 20 38 collections collection NNS 9598 20 39 of of IN 9598 20 40 web web NN 9598 20 41 resources resource NNS 9598 20 42 that that WDT 9598 20 43 provide provide VBP 9598 20 44 context context NN 9598 20 45 and and CC 9598 20 46 historical historical JJ 9598 20 47 reference reference NN 9598 20 48 points point NNS 9598 20 49 to to IN 9598 20 50 the the DT 9598 20 51 modern modern NN 9598 20 52 these these DT 9598 20 53 s s NNS 9598 20 54 and and CC 9598 20 55 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 20 56 held hold VBN 9598 20 57 in in IN 9598 20 58 their -PRON- PRP$ 9598 20 59 collections collection NNS 9598 20 60 . . . 9598 20 61 ”4 ”4 NNP 9598 20 62 Since since IN 9598 20 63 an an DT 9598 20 64 ETD ETD NNP 9598 20 65 comprises comprise VBZ 9598 20 66 a a DT 9598 20 67 unique unique JJ 9598 20 68 form form NN 9598 20 69 of of IN 9598 20 70 scholarly scholarly JJ 9598 20 71 output output NN 9598 20 72 produced produce VBN 9598 20 73 by by IN 9598 20 74 universities university NNS 9598 20 75 , , , 9598 20 76 and and CC 9598 20 77 simultaneously simultaneously RB 9598 20 78 satisfies satisfy VBZ 9598 20 79 the the DT 9598 20 80 parent parent NN 9598 20 81 institution institution NN 9598 20 82 's 's POS 9598 20 83 degree degree NN 9598 20 84 - - HYPH 9598 20 85 granting grant VBG 9598 20 86 apparatus apparatus NN 9598 20 87 , , , 9598 20 88 as as RB 9598 20 89 well well RB 9598 20 90 as as IN 9598 20 91 reflecting reflect VBG 9598 20 92 its -PRON- PRP$ 9598 20 93 academic academic JJ 9598 20 94 stature stature NN 9598 20 95 on on IN 9598 20 96 the the DT 9598 20 97 international international JJ 9598 20 98 stage stage NN 9598 20 99 , , , 9598 20 100 the the DT 9598 20 101 presence presence NN 9598 20 102 of of IN 9598 20 103 reference reference NN 9598 20 104 rot rot VB 9598 20 105 in in IN 9598 20 106 this this DT 9598 20 107 body body NN 9598 20 108 of of IN 9598 20 109 literature literature NN 9598 20 110 is be VBZ 9598 20 111 of of IN 9598 20 112 particular particular JJ 9598 20 113 concern concern NN 9598 20 114 and and CC 9598 20 115 worthy worthy JJ 9598 20 116 of of IN 9598 20 117 immediate immediate JJ 9598 20 118 attention attention NN 9598 20 119 . . . 9598 21 1 Smoking smoking NN 9598 21 2 Guns Guns NNP 9598 21 3 There there EX 9598 21 4 has have VBZ 9598 21 5 been be VBN 9598 21 6 no no DT 9598 21 7 shortage shortage NN 9598 21 8 of of IN 9598 21 9 evidence evidence NN 9598 21 10 reporting report VBG 9598 21 11 on on IN 9598 21 12 the the DT 9598 21 13 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 21 14 phenomena phenomenon NNS 9598 21 15 over over IN 9598 21 16 the the DT 9598 21 17 last last JJ 9598 21 18 two two CD 9598 21 19 decades decade NNS 9598 21 20 . . . 9598 22 1 Koehler Koehler NNP 9598 22 2 , , , 9598 22 3 whose whose WP$ 9598 22 4 initial initial JJ 9598 22 5 study study NN 9598 22 6 on on IN 9598 22 7 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 22 8 appeared appear VBD 9598 22 9 in in IN 9598 22 10 JASIS JASIS NNP 9598 22 11 in in IN 9598 22 12 1999 1999 CD 9598 22 13 , , , 9598 22 14 periodically periodically RB 9598 22 15 revisited revisit VBN 9598 22 16 , , , 9598 22 17 analyzed analyze VBN 9598 22 18 , , , 9598 22 19 and and CC 9598 22 20 reported report VBD 9598 22 21 on on IN 9598 22 22 the the DT 9598 22 23 same same JJ 9598 22 24 set set NN 9598 22 25 of of IN 9598 22 26 360 360 CD 9598 22 27 URLs url NNS 9598 22 28 collected collect VBN 9598 22 29 in in IN 9598 22 30 his -PRON- PRP$ 9598 22 31 original original JJ 9598 22 32 study.5,6,7 study.5,6,7 NNP 9598 22 33 In in IN 9598 22 34 2015 2015 CD 9598 22 35 , , , 9598 22 36 upon upon IN 9598 22 37 the the DT 9598 22 38 twenty twenty CD 9598 22 39 - - HYPH 9598 22 40 year year NN 9598 22 41 benchmark benchmark NN 9598 22 42 of of IN 9598 22 43 the the DT 9598 22 44 original original JJ 9598 22 45 data datum NNS 9598 22 46 collection collection NN 9598 22 47 , , , 9598 22 48 Oguz Oguz NNP 9598 22 49 and and CC 9598 22 50 Koehler Koehler NNP 9598 22 51 reported report VBD 9598 22 52 in in IN 9598 22 53 JASIS JASIS NNP 9598 22 54 that that IN 9598 22 55 only only RB 9598 22 56 2 2 CD 9598 22 57 of of IN 9598 22 58 the the DT 9598 22 59 original original JJ 9598 22 60 links link NNS 9598 22 61 remained remain VBD 9598 22 62 active.8 active.8 CD 9598 22 63 A a DT 9598 22 64 number number NN 9598 22 65 of of IN 9598 22 66 foundational foundational JJ 9598 22 67 studies study NNS 9598 22 68 , , , 9598 22 69 including include VBG 9598 22 70 Casserly Casserly NNP 9598 22 71 and and CC 9598 22 72 Bird,9 Bird,9 NNP 9598 22 73 Spinellis,10 Spinellis,10 NNP 9598 22 74 Sellitto,11 Sellitto,11 NNP 9598 22 75 Falagas Falagas NNP 9598 22 76 , , , 9598 22 77 Karveli Karveli NNP 9598 22 78 , , , 9598 22 79 and and CC 9598 22 80 Tritsaroli,12 Tritsaroli,12 NNP 9598 22 81 and and CC 9598 22 82 Wagner Wagner NNP 9598 22 83 et et NNP 9598 22 84 al.13 al.13 NNS 9598 22 85 have have VBP 9598 22 86 reported report VBN 9598 22 87 on on IN 9598 22 88 linkrot linkrot NNS 9598 22 89 occurring occur VBG 9598 22 90 in in IN 9598 22 91 professional professional JJ 9598 22 92 literature literature NN 9598 22 93 . . . 9598 23 1 Sanderson Sanderson NNP 9598 23 2 , , , 9598 23 3 Phillips Phillips NNP 9598 23 4 , , , 9598 23 5 and and CC 9598 23 6 Van Van NNP 9598 23 7 de de FW 9598 23 8 Sompel Sompel NNP 9598 23 9 provide provide VBP 9598 23 10 a a DT 9598 23 11 table table NN 9598 23 12 of of IN 9598 23 13 17 17 CD 9598 23 14 well well RB 9598 23 15 - - HYPH 9598 23 16 known know VBN 9598 23 17 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 23 18 studies study NNS 9598 23 19 , , , 9598 23 20 comparing compare VBG 9598 23 21 overall overall JJ 9598 23 22 benchmarks benchmark NNS 9598 23 23 , , , 9598 23 24 and and CC 9598 23 25 supplying supply VBG 9598 23 26 a a DT 9598 23 27 succinct succinct JJ 9598 23 28 summary summary NN 9598 23 29 of of IN 9598 23 30 the the DT 9598 23 31 scope scope NN 9598 23 32 of of IN 9598 23 33 each each DT 9598 23 34 study.14 study.14 NNP 9598 23 35 Linkrot Linkrot NNP 9598 23 36 also also RB 9598 23 37 gained gain VBD 9598 23 38 further far RBR 9598 23 39 important important JJ 9598 23 40 exposure exposure NN 9598 23 41 with with IN 9598 23 42 the the DT 9598 23 43 Harvard Harvard NNP 9598 23 44 Law Law NNP 9598 23 45 School School NNP 9598 23 46 study study NN 9598 23 47 by by IN 9598 23 48 Zittrain Zittrain NNP 9598 23 49 , , , 9598 23 50 Albert Albert NNP 9598 23 51 , , , 9598 23 52 and and CC 9598 23 53 Lessig Lessig NNP 9598 23 54 , , , 9598 23 55 which which WDT 9598 23 56 found find VBD 9598 23 57 that that IN 9598 23 58 70 70 CD 9598 23 59 % % NN 9598 23 60 of of IN 9598 23 61 3 3 CD 9598 23 62 Harvard Harvard NNP 9598 23 63 law law NN 9598 23 64 journal journal NN 9598 23 65 references reference NNS 9598 23 66 , , , 9598 23 67 and and CC 9598 23 68 49.9 49.9 CD 9598 23 69 % % NN 9598 23 70 of of IN 9598 23 71 URLs url NNS 9598 23 72 in in IN 9598 23 73 Supreme Supreme NNP 9598 23 74 Court Court NNP 9598 23 75 opinions opinion NNS 9598 23 76 examined examine VBD 9598 23 77 , , , 9598 23 78 no no RB 9598 23 79 longer long RBR 9598 23 80 pointed point VBD 9598 23 81 to to IN 9598 23 82 their -PRON- PRP$ 9598 23 83 originally originally RB 9598 23 84 cited cite VBN 9598 23 85 sources.15 sources.15 NNP 9598 23 86 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 9598 23 87 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 9598 23 88 AND and CC 9598 23 89 LIBRARIES library NNS 9598 23 90 | | NNP 9598 23 91 MARCH MARCH NNS 9598 23 92 2017 2017 CD 9598 23 93 13 13 CD 9598 23 94 Members member NNS 9598 23 95 of of IN 9598 23 96 the the DT 9598 23 97 Hiberlink Hiberlink NNP 9598 23 98 project project NN 9598 23 99 , , , 9598 23 100 which which WDT 9598 23 101 set set VBD 9598 23 102 out out RP 9598 23 103 to to TO 9598 23 104 examine examine VB 9598 23 105 “ " `` 9598 23 106 a a DT 9598 23 107 vast vast JJ 9598 23 108 corpus corpus NN 9598 23 109 of of IN 9598 23 110 online online JJ 9598 23 111 scholarly scholarly JJ 9598 23 112 publication publication NN 9598 23 113 in in IN 9598 23 114 order order NN 9598 23 115 to to TO 9598 23 116 assess assess VB 9598 23 117 what what WP 9598 23 118 links link NNS 9598 23 119 still still RB 9598 23 120 work work VBP 9598 23 121 as as IN 9598 23 122 intended intend VBN 9598 23 123 and and CC 9598 23 124 what what WP 9598 23 125 web web NN 9598 23 126 content content NN 9598 23 127 has have VBZ 9598 23 128 been be VBN 9598 23 129 successfully successfully RB 9598 23 130 archived archive VBN 9598 23 131 using use VBG 9598 23 132 text text NN 9598 23 133 mining mining NN 9598 23 134 and and CC 9598 23 135 information information NN 9598 23 136 extracting extracting NN 9598 23 137 tools tool NNS 9598 23 138 ” " '' 9598 23 139 have have VBP 9598 23 140 been be VBN 9598 23 141 pivotal pivotal JJ 9598 23 142 in in IN 9598 23 143 making make VBG 9598 23 144 the the DT 9598 23 145 case case NN 9598 23 146 for for IN 9598 23 147 reference reference NN 9598 23 148 rot.16 rot.16 NNS 9598 23 149 Hiberlink Hiberlink NNP 9598 23 150 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 9598 23 151 that that IN 9598 23 152 failure failure NN 9598 23 153 to to TO 9598 23 154 link link VB 9598 23 155 to to IN 9598 23 156 cited cite VBN 9598 23 157 sources source NNS 9598 23 158 was be VBD 9598 23 159 due due JJ 9598 23 160 not not RB 9598 23 161 only only RB 9598 23 162 to to TO 9598 23 163 linkrot linkrot VB 9598 23 164 , , , 9598 23 165 but but CC 9598 23 166 also also RB 9598 23 167 to to IN 9598 23 168 web web NN 9598 23 169 page page NN 9598 23 170 content content NN 9598 23 171 which which WDT 9598 23 172 changed change VBD 9598 23 173 over over IN 9598 23 174 time.17 time.17 NNP 9598 23 175 A a DT 9598 23 176 new new JJ 9598 23 177 dimension dimension NN 9598 23 178 of of IN 9598 23 179 the the DT 9598 23 180 digital digital JJ 9598 23 181 preservation preservation NN 9598 23 182 universe universe NN 9598 23 183 was be VBD 9598 23 184 thrown throw VBN 9598 23 185 into into IN 9598 23 186 sharp sharp JJ 9598 23 187 relief relief NN 9598 23 188 with with IN 9598 23 189 follow follow VB 9598 23 190 - - HYPH 9598 23 191 up up NN 9598 23 192 study study NN 9598 23 193 by by IN 9598 23 194 Klein Klein NNP 9598 23 195 et et NNP 9598 23 196 al al NNP 9598 23 197 . . . 9598 24 1 ( ( -LRB- 9598 24 2 2014 2014 CD 9598 24 3 ) ) -RRB- 9598 24 4 , , , 9598 24 5 which which WDT 9598 24 6 examined examine VBD 9598 24 7 one one CD 9598 24 8 million million CD 9598 24 9 web web NN 9598 24 10 references reference NNS 9598 24 11 extracted extract VBN 9598 24 12 from from IN 9598 24 13 3.5 3.5 CD 9598 24 14 million million CD 9598 24 15 Science Science NNP 9598 24 16 , , , 9598 24 17 Technology Technology NNP 9598 24 18 , , , 9598 24 19 and and CC 9598 24 20 Medicine Medicine NNP 9598 24 21 ( ( -LRB- 9598 24 22 STM STM NNP 9598 24 23 ) ) -RRB- 9598 24 24 articles article NNS 9598 24 25 published publish VBN 9598 24 26 in in IN 9598 24 27 Elsevier Elsevier NNP 9598 24 28 , , , 9598 24 29 PubMed PubMed NNP 9598 24 30 Central Central NNP 9598 24 31 , , , 9598 24 32 and and CC 9598 24 33 ArXiv ArXiv NNP 9598 24 34 , , , 9598 24 35 between between IN 9598 24 36 the the DT 9598 24 37 years year NNS 9598 24 38 1997 1997 CD 9598 24 39 and and CC 9598 24 40 2012 2012 CD 9598 24 41 . . . 9598 25 1 The the DT 9598 25 2 study study NN 9598 25 3 concluded conclude VBD 9598 25 4 that that IN 9598 25 5 one one CD 9598 25 6 in in IN 9598 25 7 five five CD 9598 25 8 articles article NNS 9598 25 9 suffers suffer VBZ 9598 25 10 from from IN 9598 25 11 reference reference NN 9598 25 12 rot.18 rot.18 NN 9598 25 13 Though though IN 9598 25 14 the the DT 9598 25 15 study study NN 9598 25 16 focused focus VBD 9598 25 17 on on IN 9598 25 18 STM STM NNP 9598 25 19 articles article NNS 9598 25 20 , , , 9598 25 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 9598 25 22 authors author NNS 9598 25 23 drew draw VBD 9598 25 24 attention attention NN 9598 25 25 to to IN 9598 25 26 these these DT 9598 25 27 s s NNS 9598 25 28 and and CC 9598 25 29 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 25 30 as as IN 9598 25 31 a a DT 9598 25 32 susceptible susceptible JJ 9598 25 33 class class NN 9598 25 34 of of IN 9598 25 35 material material NN 9598 25 36 . . . 9598 26 1 Analyzing analyze VBG 9598 26 2 the the DT 9598 26 3 same same JJ 9598 26 4 set set NN 9598 26 5 of of IN 9598 26 6 links link NNS 9598 26 7 extracted extract VBN 9598 26 8 from from IN 9598 26 9 this this DT 9598 26 10 large large JJ 9598 26 11 STM STM NNP 9598 26 12 corpus corpus NN 9598 26 13 , , , 9598 26 14 Jones Jones NNP 9598 26 15 et et NNP 9598 26 16 al al NNP 9598 26 17 . . . 9598 27 1 ( ( -LRB- 9598 27 2 2016 2016 CD 9598 27 3 ) ) -RRB- 9598 27 4 recently recently RB 9598 27 5 reported report VBD 9598 27 6 that that IN 9598 27 7 75 75 CD 9598 27 8 % % NN 9598 27 9 of of IN 9598 27 10 referenced referenced JJ 9598 27 11 open open JJ 9598 27 12 web web NN 9598 27 13 pages page NNS 9598 27 14 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 9598 27 15 changes change NNS 9598 27 16 in in IN 9598 27 17 content.19 content.19 NNP 9598 27 18 ETDs etd NNS 9598 27 19 — — : 9598 27 20 A a DT 9598 27 21 Susceptible susceptible JJ 9598 27 22 Collection collection NN 9598 27 23 The the DT 9598 27 24 digital digital JJ 9598 27 25 preservation preservation NN 9598 27 26 part part NN 9598 27 27 of of IN 9598 27 28 institutionally institutionally RB 9598 27 29 mandated mandate VBN 9598 27 30 ETD ETD NNP 9598 27 31 deposit deposit NN 9598 27 32 has have VBZ 9598 27 33 yet yet RB 9598 27 34 to to TO 9598 27 35 have have VB 9598 27 36 its -PRON- PRP$ 9598 27 37 dots dot NNS 9598 27 38 fully fully RB 9598 27 39 connected connect VBN 9598 27 40 to to IN 9598 27 41 the the DT 9598 27 42 rest rest NN 9598 27 43 of of IN 9598 27 44 the the DT 9598 27 45 diagram diagram NN 9598 27 46 . . . 9598 28 1 After after IN 9598 28 2 four four CD 9598 28 3 years year NNS 9598 28 4 of of IN 9598 28 5 research research NN 9598 28 6 into into IN 9598 28 7 academic academic JJ 9598 28 8 institutions institution NNS 9598 28 9 ’ ’ POS 9598 28 10 ETD ETD NNP 9598 28 11 programs program NNS 9598 28 12 , , , 9598 28 13 Halbert Halbert NNP 9598 28 14 , , , 9598 28 15 Skinner Skinner NNP 9598 28 16 , , , 9598 28 17 and and CC 9598 28 18 Schultz Schultz NNP 9598 28 19 reported report VBD 9598 28 20 that that IN 9598 28 21 close close RB 9598 28 22 to to TO 9598 28 23 75 75 CD 9598 28 24 % % NN 9598 28 25 of of IN 9598 28 26 respondents respondent NNS 9598 28 27 surveyed survey VBN 9598 28 28 had have VBD 9598 28 29 no no DT 9598 28 30 preservation preservation NN 9598 28 31 plan plan NN 9598 28 32 for for IN 9598 28 33 their -PRON- PRP$ 9598 28 34 ETD ETD NNP 9598 28 35 collections.20 collections.20 NNP 9598 28 36 Despite despite IN 9598 28 37 the the DT 9598 28 38 prevalence prevalence NN 9598 28 39 of of IN 9598 28 40 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 28 41 studies study NNS 9598 28 42 , , , 9598 28 43 linkrot linkrot VBZ 9598 28 44 in in IN 9598 28 45 ETDs etd NNS 9598 28 46 has have VBZ 9598 28 47 not not RB 9598 28 48 been be VBN 9598 28 49 subjected subject VBN 9598 28 50 to to IN 9598 28 51 similar similar JJ 9598 28 52 scrutiny scrutiny NN 9598 28 53 , , , 9598 28 54 and and CC 9598 28 55 the the DT 9598 28 56 implications implication NNS 9598 28 57 of of IN 9598 28 58 disappearance disappearance NN 9598 28 59 of of IN 9598 28 60 content content NN 9598 28 61 is be VBZ 9598 28 62 underappreciated underappreciated JJ 9598 28 63 . . . 9598 29 1 While while IN 9598 29 2 mandatory mandatory JJ 9598 29 3 deposit deposit NN 9598 29 4 programs program NNS 9598 29 5 have have VBP 9598 29 6 become become VBN 9598 29 7 relatively relatively RB 9598 29 8 commonplace commonplace JJ 9598 29 9 , , , 9598 29 10 focus focus NN 9598 29 11 has have VBZ 9598 29 12 largely largely RB 9598 29 13 remained remain VBN 9598 29 14 on on IN 9598 29 15 policy policy NN 9598 29 16 and and CC 9598 29 17 implementation implementation NN 9598 29 18 aspects aspect NNS 9598 29 19 , , , 9598 29 20 metadata metadata NN 9598 29 21 quality quality NN 9598 29 22 , , , 9598 29 23 interoperability interoperability NN 9598 29 24 and and CC 9598 29 25 conformance conformance NN 9598 29 26 to to IN 9598 29 27 standards.21,22 standards.21,22 NNP 9598 29 28 There there EX 9598 29 29 are be VBP 9598 29 30 few few JJ 9598 29 31 studies study NNS 9598 29 32 which which WDT 9598 29 33 focus focus VBP 9598 29 34 on on IN 9598 29 35 institutional institutional JJ 9598 29 36 repository repository JJ 9598 29 37 link link NN 9598 29 38 content content NN 9598 29 39 . . . 9598 30 1 The the DT 9598 30 2 study study NN 9598 30 3 conducted conduct VBN 9598 30 4 by by IN 9598 30 5 Sanderson Sanderson NNP 9598 30 6 , , , 9598 30 7 Philips Philips NNP 9598 30 8 , , , 9598 30 9 and and CC 9598 30 10 Van Van NNP 9598 30 11 de de FW 9598 30 12 Sompel Sompel NNP 9598 30 13 ( ( -LRB- 9598 30 14 2011 2011 CD 9598 30 15 ) ) -RRB- 9598 30 16 was be VBD 9598 30 17 a a DT 9598 30 18 large large JJ 9598 30 19 - - HYPH 9598 30 20 scale scale NN 9598 30 21 examination examination NN 9598 30 22 of of IN 9598 30 23 two two CD 9598 30 24 repositories.23 repositories.23 NNP 9598 30 25 400,144 400,144 CD 9598 30 26 papers paper NNS 9598 30 27 deposited deposit VBN 9598 30 28 in in IN 9598 30 29 ArXiv ArXiv NNP 9598 30 30 , , , 9598 30 31 and and CC 9598 30 32 3,595 3,595 CD 9598 30 33 papers paper NNS 9598 30 34 in in IN 9598 30 35 the the DT 9598 30 36 University University NNP 9598 30 37 of of IN 9598 30 38 North North NNP 9598 30 39 Texas Texas NNP 9598 30 40 ( ( -LRB- 9598 30 41 UNT UNT NNP 9598 30 42 ) ) -RRB- 9598 30 43 digital digital JJ 9598 30 44 library library NN 9598 30 45 repository repository NN 9598 30 46 were be VBD 9598 30 47 studied study VBN 9598 30 48 , , , 9598 30 49 and and CC 9598 30 50 more more JJR 9598 30 51 than than IN 9598 30 52 160,000 160,000 CD 9598 30 53 URLs url NNS 9598 30 54 examined examine VBN 9598 30 55 . . . 9598 31 1 Links link NNS 9598 31 2 were be VBD 9598 31 3 analyzed analyze VBN 9598 31 4 for for IN 9598 31 5 persistence persistence NN 9598 31 6 and and CC 9598 31 7 the the DT 9598 31 8 availability availability NN 9598 31 9 of of IN 9598 31 10 mementos memento NNS 9598 31 11 , , , 9598 31 12 that that RB 9598 31 13 is is RB 9598 31 14 , , , 9598 31 15 whether whether IN 9598 31 16 prior prior JJ 9598 31 17 versions version NNS 9598 31 18 of of IN 9598 31 19 the the DT 9598 31 20 page page NN 9598 31 21 existed exist VBD 9598 31 22 in in IN 9598 31 23 a a DT 9598 31 24 public public JJ 9598 31 25 web web NN 9598 31 26 archive archive NN 9598 31 27 , , , 9598 31 28 such such JJ 9598 31 29 as as IN 9598 31 30 the the DT 9598 31 31 Internet Internet NNP 9598 31 32 Archive Archive NNP 9598 31 33 's 's POS 9598 31 34 Wayback Wayback NNP 9598 31 35 Machine Machine NNP 9598 31 36 . . . 9598 32 1 For for IN 9598 32 2 72 72 CD 9598 32 3 % % NN 9598 32 4 of of IN 9598 32 5 UNT UNT NNP 9598 32 6 URLs URLs NNPS 9598 32 7 , , , 9598 32 8 either either CC 9598 32 9 mementos memento NNS 9598 32 10 were be VBD 9598 32 11 available available JJ 9598 32 12 , , , 9598 32 13 or or CC 9598 32 14 the the DT 9598 32 15 resource resource NN 9598 32 16 still still RB 9598 32 17 existed exist VBD 9598 32 18 at at IN 9598 32 19 its -PRON- PRP$ 9598 32 20 original original JJ 9598 32 21 location location NN 9598 32 22 , , , 9598 32 23 or or CC 9598 32 24 both both DT 9598 32 25 . . . 9598 33 1 Although although IN 9598 33 2 54 54 CD 9598 33 3 % % NN 9598 33 4 ( ( -LRB- 9598 33 5 9,880 9,880 CD 9598 33 6 ) ) -RRB- 9598 33 7 were be VBD 9598 33 8 available available JJ 9598 33 9 in in IN 9598 33 10 one one CD 9598 33 11 or or CC 9598 33 12 more more JJR 9598 33 13 international international JJ 9598 33 14 web web NN 9598 33 15 archives archive NNS 9598 33 16 , , , 9598 33 17 28 28 CD 9598 33 18 % % NN 9598 33 19 ( ( -LRB- 9598 33 20 5,073 5,073 CD 9598 33 21 ) ) -RRB- 9598 33 22 of of IN 9598 33 23 UNT UNT NNP 9598 33 24 's 's POS 9598 33 25 ETD ETD NNP 9598 33 26 links link NNS 9598 33 27 were be VBD 9598 33 28 found find VBN 9598 33 29 to to IN 9598 33 30 no no RB 9598 33 31 longer longer RB 9598 33 32 exist exist VB 9598 33 33 , , , 9598 33 34 nor nor CC 9598 33 35 had have VBD 9598 33 36 they -PRON- PRP 9598 33 37 been be VBN 9598 33 38 archived archive VBN 9598 33 39 by by IN 9598 33 40 the the DT 9598 33 41 international international JJ 9598 33 42 archival archival NNP 9598 33 43 community community NN 9598 33 44 . . . 9598 34 1 Phillips Phillips NNP 9598 34 2 , , , 9598 34 3 Alemneh Alemneh NNP 9598 34 4 , , , 9598 34 5 and and CC 9598 34 6 Ayhala Ayhala NNP 9598 34 7 looked look VBD 9598 34 8 at at IN 9598 34 9 overall overall JJ 9598 34 10 general general JJ 9598 34 11 patterns pattern NNS 9598 34 12 and and CC 9598 34 13 trends trend NNS 9598 34 14 of of IN 9598 34 15 URL URL NNP 9598 34 16 references reference NNS 9598 34 17 in in IN 9598 34 18 repository repository JJ 9598 34 19 ETDs etd NNS 9598 34 20 , , , 9598 34 21 examining examine VBG 9598 34 22 4,335 4,335 CD 9598 34 23 ETDs etd NNS 9598 34 24 between between IN 9598 34 25 the the DT 9598 34 26 years year NNS 9598 34 27 1999 1999 CD 9598 34 28 - - SYM 9598 34 29 2012 2012 CD 9598 34 30 in in IN 9598 34 31 the the DT 9598 34 32 UNT UNT NNP 9598 34 33 repository.24 repository.24 NNP 9598 34 34 The the DT 9598 34 35 team team NN 9598 34 36 analyzed analyze VBD 9598 34 37 26,683 26,683 CD 9598 34 38 unique unique JJ 9598 34 39 URLs url NNS 9598 34 40 in in IN 9598 34 41 2,713 2,713 CD 9598 34 42 ETDs etd NNS 9598 34 43 containing contain VBG 9598 34 44 one one CD 9598 34 45 or or CC 9598 34 46 more more JJR 9598 34 47 links link NNS 9598 34 48 , , , 9598 34 49 finding find VBG 9598 34 50 an an DT 9598 34 51 overall overall JJ 9598 34 52 average average NN 9598 34 53 of of IN 9598 34 54 10.58 10.58 CD 9598 34 55 unique unique JJ 9598 34 56 URLs url NNS 9598 34 57 per per IN 9598 34 58 ETD etd NN 9598 34 59 with with IN 9598 34 60 one one CD 9598 34 61 or or CC 9598 34 62 more more JJR 9598 34 63 links link NNS 9598 34 64 . . . 9598 35 1 The the DT 9598 35 2 UNT UNT NNP 9598 35 3 team team NN 9598 35 4 provided provide VBD 9598 35 5 a a DT 9598 35 6 A A NNP 9598 35 7 CASE case NN 9598 35 8 STUDY STUDY NNP 9598 35 9 OF of IN 9598 35 10 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9598 35 11 THESES thesis NNS 9598 35 12 AND and CC 9598 35 13 DISSERTATIONS dissertation NNS 9598 35 14 ( ( -LRB- 9598 35 15 ETDS ETDS NNP 9598 35 16 ) ) -RRB- 9598 35 17 IN in IN 9598 35 18 AN an DT 9598 35 19 ACADEMIC ACADEMIC NNP 9598 35 20 LIBRARY LIBRARY NNP 9598 35 21 | | NNS 9598 35 22 MASSICOTTE MASSICOTTE NNP 9598 35 23 AND and CC 9598 35 24 BOTTER BOTTER NNP 9598 35 25 | | NNP 9598 35 26 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 NNP 9598 35 27 14 14 CD 9598 35 28 breakdown breakdown NN 9598 35 29 of of IN 9598 35 30 domain domain NN 9598 35 31 and and CC 9598 35 32 subdomain subdomain VB 9598 35 33 occurrence occurrence NN 9598 35 34 frequency frequency NN 9598 35 35 , , , 9598 35 36 and and CC 9598 35 37 indicated indicate VBD 9598 35 38 areas area NNS 9598 35 39 of of IN 9598 35 40 future future JJ 9598 35 41 investigation investigation NN 9598 35 42 into into IN 9598 35 43 content content NN 9598 35 44 - - HYPH 9598 35 45 based base VBN 9598 35 46 URL url NN 9598 35 47 linking link VBG 9598 35 48 patterns pattern NNS 9598 35 49 of of IN 9598 35 50 ETDs etd NNS 9598 35 51 . . . 9598 36 1 ETD ETD NNP 9598 36 2 link link NNP 9598 36 3 decay decay NNP 9598 36 4 was be VBD 9598 36 5 studied study VBN 9598 36 6 by by IN 9598 36 7 Sife Sife NNP 9598 36 8 and and CC 9598 36 9 Bernard Bernard NNP 9598 36 10 , , , 9598 36 11 who who WP 9598 36 12 performed perform VBD 9598 36 13 a a DT 9598 36 14 citation citation NN 9598 36 15 analysis analysis NN 9598 36 16 on on IN 9598 36 17 URLs URLs NNPS 9598 36 18 in in IN 9598 36 19 83 83 CD 9598 36 20 these these DT 9598 36 21 s s NNPS 9598 36 22 published publish VBN 9598 36 23 between between IN 9598 36 24 2007 2007 CD 9598 36 25 and and CC 9598 36 26 2011 2011 CD 9598 36 27 at at IN 9598 36 28 Tanzania Tanzania NNP 9598 36 29 's 's POS 9598 36 30 Sokoine Sokoine NNP 9598 36 31 National National NNP 9598 36 32 Agricultural Agricultural NNP 9598 36 33 Library.25 library.25 CD 9598 36 34 15,468 15,468 CD 9598 36 35 citations citation NNS 9598 36 36 were be VBD 9598 36 37 examined examine VBN 9598 36 38 , , , 9598 36 39 9.6 9.6 CD 9598 36 40 % % NN 9598 36 41 ( ( -LRB- 9598 36 42 1,487 1,487 CD 9598 36 43 ) ) -RRB- 9598 36 44 of of IN 9598 36 45 which which WDT 9598 36 46 were be VBD 9598 36 47 open open JJ 9598 36 48 web web NN 9598 36 49 citations citation NNS 9598 36 50 . . . 9598 37 1 URLs url NNS 9598 37 2 were be VBD 9598 37 3 considered consider VBN 9598 37 4 active active JJ 9598 37 5 if if IN 9598 37 6 found find VBN 9598 37 7 at at IN 9598 37 8 the the DT 9598 37 9 original original JJ 9598 37 10 location location NN 9598 37 11 , , , 9598 37 12 or or CC 9598 37 13 available available JJ 9598 37 14 after after IN 9598 37 15 a a DT 9598 37 16 URL url NN 9598 37 17 redirect redirect NN 9598 37 18 . . . 9598 38 1 The the DT 9598 38 2 authors author NNS 9598 38 3 manually manually RB 9598 38 4 tested test VBD 9598 38 5 URLs url NNS 9598 38 6 over over IN 9598 38 7 a a DT 9598 38 8 period period NN 9598 38 9 of of IN 9598 38 10 seven seven CD 9598 38 11 days day NNS 9598 38 12 to to TO 9598 38 13 record record VB 9598 38 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 9598 38 15 accessibility accessibility NN 9598 38 16 , , , 9598 38 17 noting note VBG 9598 38 18 down down IN 9598 38 19 inaccessible inaccessible JJ 9598 38 20 URLs url NNS 9598 38 21 error error NN 9598 38 22 messages message NNS 9598 38 23 and and CC 9598 38 24 domains domain NNS 9598 38 25 , , , 9598 38 26 and and CC 9598 38 27 analyzing analyze VBG 9598 38 28 the the DT 9598 38 29 types type NNS 9598 38 30 of of IN 9598 38 31 errors error NNS 9598 38 32 encountered encounter VBD 9598 38 33 . . . 9598 39 1 The the DT 9598 39 2 authors author NNS 9598 39 3 calculated calculate VBD 9598 39 4 that that IN 9598 39 5 it -PRON- PRP 9598 39 6 took take VBD 9598 39 7 only only RB 9598 39 8 2.5 2.5 CD 9598 39 9 years year NNS 9598 39 10 for for IN 9598 39 11 half half NN 9598 39 12 of of IN 9598 39 13 the the DT 9598 39 14 web web NN 9598 39 15 citations citation NNS 9598 39 16 to to TO 9598 39 17 disappear disappear VB 9598 39 18 . . . 9598 40 1 At at IN 9598 40 2 the the DT 9598 40 3 ETD2014 etd2014 NN 9598 40 4 conference,26 conference,26 , 9598 40 5 an an DT 9598 40 6 important important JJ 9598 40 7 study study NN 9598 40 8 of of IN 9598 40 9 7,500 7,500 CD 9598 40 10 ETDs etd NNS 9598 40 11 in in IN 9598 40 12 5 5 CD 9598 40 13 U.S. U.S. NNP 9598 40 14 universities university NNS 9598 40 15 was be VBD 9598 40 16 presented present VBN 9598 40 17 . . . 9598 41 1 Of of IN 9598 41 2 6,400 6,400 CD 9598 41 3 ETDs etd NNS 9598 41 4 defended defend VBD 9598 41 5 between between IN 9598 41 6 2003 2003 CD 9598 41 7 and and CC 9598 41 8 2010 2010 CD 9598 41 9 , , , 9598 41 10 approximately approximately RB 9598 41 11 18 18 CD 9598 41 12 % % NN 9598 41 13 of of IN 9598 41 14 open open JJ 9598 41 15 web web NN 9598 41 16 link link NN 9598 41 17 content content NN 9598 41 18 was be VBD 9598 41 19 confirmed confirm VBN 9598 41 20 as as IN 9598 41 21 lost lose VBN 9598 41 22 , , , 9598 41 23 and and CC 9598 41 24 a a DT 9598 41 25 further further JJ 9598 41 26 34 34 CD 9598 41 27 % % NN 9598 41 28 at at IN 9598 41 29 risk risk NN 9598 41 30 of of IN 9598 41 31 loss loss NN 9598 41 32 , , , 9598 41 33 that that RB 9598 41 34 is is RB 9598 41 35 , , , 9598 41 36 live live JJ 9598 41 37 links link NNS 9598 41 38 which which WDT 9598 41 39 lacked lack VBD 9598 41 40 an an DT 9598 41 41 archived archived JJ 9598 41 42 copy.27 copy.27 NNP 9598 41 43 Though though IN 9598 41 44 the the DT 9598 41 45 results result NNS 9598 41 46 of of IN 9598 41 47 that that DT 9598 41 48 particular particular JJ 9598 41 49 study study NN 9598 41 50 have have VBP 9598 41 51 not not RB 9598 41 52 been be VBN 9598 41 53 formally formally RB 9598 41 54 published publish VBN 9598 41 55 , , , 9598 41 56 it -PRON- PRP 9598 41 57 was be VBD 9598 41 58 briefly briefly RB 9598 41 59 summarized summarize VBN 9598 41 60 in in IN 9598 41 61 a a DT 9598 41 62 session session NN 9598 41 63 held hold VBN 9598 41 64 at at IN 9598 41 65 the the DT 9598 41 66 38th 38th JJ 9598 41 67 UKSG UKSG NNP 9598 41 68 Annual Annual NNP 9598 41 69 Conference Conference NNP 9598 41 70 in in IN 9598 41 71 Glasgow Glasgow NNP 9598 41 72 , , , 9598 41 73 Scotland Scotland NNP 9598 41 74 in in IN 9598 41 75 March March NNP 9598 41 76 2015 2015 CD 9598 41 77 , , , 9598 41 78 an an DT 9598 41 79 account account NN 9598 41 80 of of IN 9598 41 81 which which WDT 9598 41 82 was be VBD 9598 41 83 subsequently subsequently RB 9598 41 84 published publish VBN 9598 41 85 by by IN 9598 41 86 Burnhill Burnhill NNP 9598 41 87 , , , 9598 41 88 Mewissen Mewissen NNP 9598 41 89 , , , 9598 41 90 and and CC 9598 41 91 Wincewicz Wincewicz NNP 9598 41 92 in in IN 9598 41 93 Insights.28 insights.28 NN 9598 41 94 Given give VBN 9598 41 95 the the DT 9598 41 96 scarcity scarcity NN 9598 41 97 of of IN 9598 41 98 published publish VBN 9598 41 99 literature literature NN 9598 41 100 on on IN 9598 41 101 link link NN 9598 41 102 content content NN 9598 41 103 as as IN 9598 41 104 found find VBN 9598 41 105 in in IN 9598 41 106 ETDs ETDs NNP 9598 41 107 , , , 9598 41 108 this this DT 9598 41 109 present present JJ 9598 41 110 study study NN 9598 41 111 which which WDT 9598 41 112 examines examine VBZ 9598 41 113 reference reference NN 9598 41 114 rot rot VBP 9598 41 115 in in IN 9598 41 116 ETDs etd NNS 9598 41 117 in in IN 9598 41 118 an an DT 9598 41 119 academic academic JJ 9598 41 120 institutional institutional JJ 9598 41 121 repository repository NN 9598 41 122 is be VBZ 9598 41 123 unique unique JJ 9598 41 124 , , , 9598 41 125 draws draw VBZ 9598 41 126 attention attention NN 9598 41 127 to to IN 9598 41 128 an an DT 9598 41 129 important important JJ 9598 41 130 digital digital JJ 9598 41 131 collection collection NN 9598 41 132 which which WDT 9598 41 133 is be VBZ 9598 41 134 vulnerable vulnerable JJ 9598 41 135 to to IN 9598 41 136 loss loss NN 9598 41 137 , , , 9598 41 138 and and CC 9598 41 139 highlights highlight NNS 9598 41 140 need need VBP 9598 41 141 for for IN 9598 41 142 action action NN 9598 41 143 . . . 9598 42 1 BACKGROUND background NN 9598 42 2 AND and CC 9598 42 3 CONTEXT CONTEXT NNP 9598 42 4 Concordia Concordia NNP 9598 42 5 University University NNP 9598 42 6 is be VBZ 9598 42 7 a a DT 9598 42 8 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 9598 42 9 university university NN 9598 42 10 located locate VBN 9598 42 11 in in IN 9598 42 12 Montreal Montreal NNP 9598 42 13 , , , 9598 42 14 with with IN 9598 42 15 a a DT 9598 42 16 student student NN 9598 42 17 population population NN 9598 42 18 of of IN 9598 42 19 43,903 43,903 CD 9598 42 20 full full JJ 9598 42 21 - - HYPH 9598 42 22 time time NN 9598 42 23 equivalents equivalent NNS 9598 42 24 in in IN 9598 42 25 2015 2015 CD 9598 42 26 , , , 9598 42 27 of of IN 9598 42 28 which which WDT 9598 42 29 7,835 7,835 CD 9598 42 30 were be VBD 9598 42 31 graduate graduate JJ 9598 42 32 students student NNS 9598 42 33 . . . 9598 43 1 27 27 CD 9598 43 2 PhD phd NN 9598 43 3 programs program NNS 9598 43 4 were be VBD 9598 43 5 offered offer VBN 9598 43 6 in in IN 9598 43 7 2015,29 2015,29 CD 9598 43 8 and and CC 9598 43 9 43 43 CD 9598 43 10 programs program NNS 9598 43 11 at at IN 9598 43 12 the the DT 9598 43 13 Masters Masters NNP 9598 43 14 level level NN 9598 43 15 . . . 9598 44 1 Faculties faculty NNS 9598 44 2 of of IN 9598 44 3 Arts Arts NNPS 9598 44 4 and and CC 9598 44 5 Science Science NNP 9598 44 6 , , , 9598 44 7 Engineering Engineering NNP 9598 44 8 and and CC 9598 44 9 Computer Computer NNP 9598 44 10 Science Science NNP 9598 44 11 , , , 9598 44 12 Fine Fine NNP 9598 44 13 Arts Arts NNPS 9598 44 14 , , , 9598 44 15 and and CC 9598 44 16 Business business NN 9598 44 17 have have VBP 9598 44 18 a a DT 9598 44 19 thesis thesis NN 9598 44 20 requirement requirement NN 9598 44 21 , , , 9598 44 22 and and CC 9598 44 23 produce produce VB 9598 44 24 upwards upward NNS 9598 44 25 of of IN 9598 44 26 350 350 CD 9598 44 27 Masters master NNS 9598 44 28 and and CC 9598 44 29 150 150 CD 9598 44 30 PhD phd NN 9598 44 31 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 44 32 annually annually RB 9598 44 33 . . . 9598 45 1 The the DT 9598 45 2 broad broad JJ 9598 45 3 disciplines discipline NNS 9598 45 4 , , , 9598 45 5 and and CC 9598 45 6 the the DT 9598 45 7 departmental departmental JJ 9598 45 8 clusters cluster NNS 9598 45 9 used use VBN 9598 45 10 in in IN 9598 45 11 this this DT 9598 45 12 study study NN 9598 45 13 are be VBP 9598 45 14 shown show VBN 9598 45 15 in in IN 9598 45 16 Table table NN 9598 45 17 1 1 CD 9598 45 18 . . . 9598 46 1 Prior prior RB 9598 46 2 to to IN 9598 46 3 the the DT 9598 46 4 thesis thesis NN 9598 46 5 deposit deposit NN 9598 46 6 mandate mandate NN 9598 46 7 , , , 9598 46 8 Concordia Concordia NNP 9598 46 9 University University NNP 9598 46 10 Library Library NNP 9598 46 11 housed house VBD 9598 46 12 hard hard JJ 9598 46 13 copy copy NN 9598 46 14 versions version NNS 9598 46 15 of of IN 9598 46 16 these these DT 9598 46 17 s s NNS 9598 46 18 and and CC 9598 46 19 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 46 20 in in IN 9598 46 21 the the DT 9598 46 22 collection collection NN 9598 46 23 . . . 9598 47 1 In in IN 9598 47 2 2009 2009 CD 9598 47 3 , , , 9598 47 4 the the DT 9598 47 5 Library Library NNP 9598 47 6 launched launch VBD 9598 47 7 Spectrum Spectrum NNP 9598 47 8 , , , 9598 47 9 Concordia Concordia NNP 9598 47 10 ’s ’s POS 9598 47 11 Eprints Eprints NNP 9598 47 12 institutional institutional JJ 9598 47 13 repository repository NN 9598 47 14 , , , 9598 47 15 playing play VBG 9598 47 16 a a DT 9598 47 17 leadership leadership NN 9598 47 18 role role NN 9598 47 19 in in IN 9598 47 20 Spectrum Spectrum NNP 9598 47 21 's 's POS 9598 47 22 implementation implementation NN 9598 47 23 and and CC 9598 47 24 policy policy NN 9598 47 25 development development NN 9598 47 26 , , , 9598 47 27 and and CC 9598 47 28 providing provide VBG 9598 47 29 training training NN 9598 47 30 and and CC 9598 47 31 support support NN 9598 47 32 to to IN 9598 47 33 the the DT 9598 47 34 School School NNP 9598 47 35 of of IN 9598 47 36 Graduate Graduate NNP 9598 47 37 Studies Studies NNPS 9598 47 38 regarding regard VBG 9598 47 39 submission submission NN 9598 47 40 and and CC 9598 47 41 management management NN 9598 47 42 of of IN 9598 47 43 these these DT 9598 47 44 s s XX 9598 47 45 for for IN 9598 47 46 deposit deposit NN 9598 47 47 . . . 9598 48 1 Following follow VBG 9598 48 2 a a DT 9598 48 3 successful successful JJ 9598 48 4 pilot pilot NN 9598 48 5 project project NN 9598 48 6 , , , 9598 48 7 the the DT 9598 48 8 Graduate Graduate NNP 9598 48 9 Studies Studies NNPS 9598 48 10 Office Office NNP 9598 48 11 ceased cease VBD 9598 48 12 accepting accept VBG 9598 48 13 paper paper NN 9598 48 14 manuscripts manuscript NNS 9598 48 15 , , , 9598 48 16 and and CC 9598 48 17 mandated mandate VBD 9598 48 18 electronic electronic JJ 9598 48 19 deposit deposit NN 9598 48 20 of of IN 9598 48 21 all all PDT 9598 48 22 these these DT 9598 48 23 s s NNS 9598 48 24 and and CC 9598 48 25 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 48 26 into into IN 9598 48 27 Spectrum Spectrum NNP 9598 48 28 as as IN 9598 48 29 of of IN 9598 48 30 spring spring NN 9598 48 31 2011 2011 CD 9598 48 32 . . . 9598 49 1 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 9598 49 2 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 9598 49 3 AND and CC 9598 49 4 LIBRARIES library NNS 9598 49 5 | | NNP 9598 49 6 MARCH MARCH NNS 9598 49 7 2017 2017 CD 9598 49 8 15 15 CD 9598 49 9 Discipline Discipline NNP 9598 49 10 Department Department NNP 9598 49 11 Discipline Discipline NNP 9598 49 12 Department Department NNP 9598 49 13 Arts Arts NNPS 9598 49 14 Applied Applied NNP 9598 49 15 Linguistics Linguistics NNP 9598 49 16 Communication Communication NNP 9598 49 17 Economics Economics NNP 9598 49 18 Educational Educational NNP 9598 49 19 Technology Technology NNP 9598 49 20 History history NN 9598 49 21 Hist Hist NNP 9598 49 22 and and CC 9598 49 23 Phil Phil NNP 9598 49 24 of of IN 9598 49 25 Religion Religion NNP 9598 49 26 Humanities humanitie VBZ 9598 49 27 Philosophy Philosophy NNP 9598 49 28 Sociology Sociology NNP 9598 49 29 Political Political NNP 9598 49 30 Science Science NNP 9598 49 31 Psychology Psychology NNP 9598 49 32 Religion Religion NNP 9598 49 33 Business Business NNP 9598 49 34 * * NFP 9598 49 35 Decision Decision NNP 9598 49 36 Sciences Sciences NNPS 9598 49 37 and and CC 9598 49 38 MIS MIS NNP 9598 49 39 Finance Finance NNP 9598 49 40 Management Management NNP 9598 49 41 Marketing Marketing NNP 9598 49 42 Engineering Engineering NNP 9598 49 43 * * NFP 9598 49 44 * * NFP 9598 49 45 Building Building NNP 9598 49 46 Engineering Engineering NNP 9598 49 47 Civil Civil NNP 9598 49 48 Engineering Engineering NNP 9598 49 49 Computer Computer NNP 9598 49 50 Science Science NNP 9598 49 51 Comp Comp NNP 9598 49 52 Sci Sci NNP 9598 49 53 & & CC 9598 49 54 Software Software NNP 9598 49 55 Eng Eng NNP 9598 49 56 Electrical Electrical NNP 9598 49 57 and and CC 9598 49 58 Comp Comp NNP 9598 49 59 Eng Eng NNP 9598 49 60 Industrial Industrial NNP 9598 49 61 Engineering Engineering NNP 9598 49 62 Info Info NNP 9598 49 63 Systems Systems NNPS 9598 49 64 Security Security NNP 9598 49 65 Mechanical Mechanical NNP 9598 49 66 Engineering Engineering NNP 9598 49 67 Fine Fine NNP 9598 49 68 Arts Arts NNPS 9598 49 69 Art art NN 9598 49 70 Education education NN 9598 49 71 Art art NN 9598 49 72 History history NN 9598 49 73 Film Film NNP 9598 49 74 and and CC 9598 49 75 Moving Moving NNP 9598 49 76 Image Image NNP 9598 49 77 Studies Studies NNPS 9598 49 78 Industrial Industrial NNP 9598 49 79 Design Design NNP 9598 49 80 Fine Fine NNP 9598 49 81 Arts art VBZ 9598 49 82 Performing perform VBG 9598 49 83 Arts art NNS 9598 49 84 Science Science NNP 9598 49 85 Biology Biology NNP 9598 49 86 Chemistry Chemistry NNP 9598 49 87 Mathematics Mathematics NNP 9598 49 88 Physics Physics NNP 9598 49 89 Exercise Exercise NNP 9598 49 90 Science science NN 9598 49 91 Table table NN 9598 49 92 1 1 CD 9598 49 93 . . . 9598 50 1 Summary summary NN 9598 50 2 of of IN 9598 50 3 departmental departmental JJ 9598 50 4 clusters cluster NNS 9598 50 5 used use VBN 9598 50 6 in in IN 9598 50 7 this this DT 9598 50 8 study study NN 9598 50 9 * * NFP 9598 50 10 John John NNP 9598 50 11 Molson Molson NNP 9598 50 12 School School NNP 9598 50 13 of of IN 9598 50 14 Business Business NNP 9598 50 15 * * NFP 9598 50 16 * * NFP 9598 50 17 Engineering Engineering NNP 9598 50 18 & & CC 9598 50 19 Computer Computer NNP 9598 50 20 Science Science NNP 9598 50 21 METHODOLOGY METHODOLOGY NNP 9598 50 22 We -PRON- PRP 9598 50 23 concentrated concentrate VBD 9598 50 24 on on IN 9598 50 25 PhD phd NN 9598 50 26 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 50 27 ( ( -LRB- 9598 50 28 henceforth henceforth RB 9598 50 29 ETDs etd NNS 9598 50 30 ) ) -RRB- 9598 50 31 in in IN 9598 50 32 Spectrum Spectrum NNP 9598 50 33 in in IN 9598 50 34 order order NN 9598 50 35 to to TO 9598 50 36 limit limit VB 9598 50 37 the the DT 9598 50 38 scope scope NN 9598 50 39 of of IN 9598 50 40 the the DT 9598 50 41 project project NN 9598 50 42 ; ; : 9598 50 43 Master Master NNP 9598 50 44 's 's POS 9598 50 45 these these DT 9598 50 46 s s POS 9598 50 47 were be VBD 9598 50 48 excluded exclude VBN 9598 50 49 . . . 9598 51 1 A a DT 9598 51 2 5-year 5-year CD 9598 51 3 period period NN 9598 51 4 was be VBD 9598 51 5 chosen choose VBN 9598 51 6 , , , 9598 51 7 beginning begin VBG 9598 51 8 with with IN 9598 51 9 the the DT 9598 51 10 first first JJ 9598 51 11 semester semester NN 9598 51 12 of of IN 9598 51 13 mandatory mandatory JJ 9598 51 14 deposit deposit NN 9598 51 15 , , , 9598 51 16 spring spring NN 9598 51 17 2011 2011 CD 9598 51 18 , , , 9598 51 19 through through IN 9598 51 20 fall fall NN 9598 51 21 2015 2015 CD 9598 51 22 , , , 9598 51 23 a a DT 9598 51 24 total total NN 9598 51 25 of of IN 9598 51 26 720 720 CD 9598 51 27 ETDs etd NNS 9598 51 28 . . . 9598 52 1 Since since IN 9598 52 2 Concordia Concordia NNP 9598 52 3 ETDs etd NNS 9598 52 4 are be VBP 9598 52 5 released release VBN 9598 52 6 for for IN 9598 52 7 publication publication NN 9598 52 8 immediately immediately RB 9598 52 9 following follow VBG 9598 52 10 convocation convocation NN 9598 52 11 , , , 9598 52 12 the the DT 9598 52 13 University University NNP 9598 52 14 's 's POS 9598 52 15 official official JJ 9598 52 16 convocation convocation NN 9598 52 17 dates date NNS 9598 52 18 were be VBD 9598 52 19 used use VBN 9598 52 20 to to TO 9598 52 21 identify identify VB 9598 52 22 the the DT 9598 52 23 set set NN 9598 52 24 of of IN 9598 52 25 documents document NNS 9598 52 26 to to TO 9598 52 27 be be VB 9598 52 28 downloaded download VBN 9598 52 29 and and CC 9598 52 30 examined examine VBN 9598 52 31 . . . 9598 53 1 We -PRON- PRP 9598 53 2 proceeded proceed VBD 9598 53 3 in in IN 9598 53 4 phases phase NNS 9598 53 5 : : : 9598 53 6 first first JJ 9598 53 7 downloading download VBG 9598 53 8 ETDs etd NNS 9598 53 9 from from IN 9598 53 10 Spectrum Spectrum NNP 9598 53 11 and and CC 9598 53 12 converting convert VBG 9598 53 13 to to IN 9598 53 14 a a DT 9598 53 15 text text NN 9598 53 16 format format NN 9598 53 17 that that WDT 9598 53 18 could could MD 9598 53 19 be be VB 9598 53 20 examined examine VBN 9598 53 21 for for IN 9598 53 22 patterns pattern NNS 9598 53 23 ; ; : 9598 53 24 then then RB 9598 53 25 extracting extract VBG 9598 53 26 links link NNS 9598 53 27 from from IN 9598 53 28 each each DT 9598 53 29 and and CC 9598 53 30 testing testing NN 9598 53 31 programmatically programmatically RB 9598 53 32 A a DT 9598 53 33 CASE case NN 9598 53 34 STUDY STUDY NNP 9598 53 35 OF of IN 9598 53 36 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9598 53 37 THESES thesis NNS 9598 53 38 AND and CC 9598 53 39 DISSERTATIONS dissertation NNS 9598 53 40 ( ( -LRB- 9598 53 41 ETDS ETDS NNP 9598 53 42 ) ) -RRB- 9598 53 43 IN in IN 9598 53 44 AN an DT 9598 53 45 ACADEMIC ACADEMIC NNP 9598 53 46 LIBRARY LIBRARY NNP 9598 53 47 | | NNS 9598 53 48 MASSICOTTE MASSICOTTE NNP 9598 53 49 AND and CC 9598 53 50 BOTTER BOTTER NNP 9598 53 51 | | NNP 9598 53 52 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 NNP 9598 53 53 16 16 CD 9598 53 54 for for IN 9598 53 55 linkrot linkrot NNS 9598 53 56 ; ; : 9598 53 57 then then RB 9598 53 58 drawing draw VBG 9598 53 59 a a DT 9598 53 60 stratified stratified JJ 9598 53 61 random random JJ 9598 53 62 sample sample NN 9598 53 63 of of IN 9598 53 64 active active JJ 9598 53 65 URLs url NNS 9598 53 66 and and CC 9598 53 67 visiting visit VBG 9598 53 68 them -PRON- PRP 9598 53 69 to to TO 9598 53 70 determine determine VB 9598 53 71 if if IN 9598 53 72 content content NN 9598 53 73 drift drift NN 9598 53 74 had have VBD 9598 53 75 taken take VBN 9598 53 76 place place NN 9598 53 77 . . . 9598 54 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 9598 54 2 methodology methodology NN 9598 54 3 for for IN 9598 54 4 link link NN 9598 54 5 extraction extraction NN 9598 54 6 was be VBD 9598 54 7 similar similar JJ 9598 54 8 to to IN 9598 54 9 those those DT 9598 54 10 described describe VBN 9598 54 11 by by IN 9598 54 12 Klein Klein NNP 9598 54 13 et et NNP 9598 54 14 al al NNP 9598 54 15 . . NNP 9598 54 16 ,30 ,30 NNP 9598 54 17 and and CC 9598 54 18 Zhou Zhou NNP 9598 54 19 , , , 9598 54 20 Tobin Tobin NNP 9598 54 21 , , , 9598 54 22 and and CC 9598 54 23 Grover.31 Grover.31 NNP 9598 54 24 During during IN 9598 54 25 the the DT 9598 54 26 dissertation dissertation NN 9598 54 27 download download NN 9598 54 28 stage stage NN 9598 54 29 , , , 9598 54 30 36 36 CD 9598 54 31 ETDs etd NNS 9598 54 32 with with IN 9598 54 33 embargoed embargoed JJ 9598 54 34 content content NN 9598 54 35 were be VBD 9598 54 36 encountered encounter VBN 9598 54 37 and and CC 9598 54 38 eliminated eliminate VBN 9598 54 39 . . . 9598 55 1 ETDs etd NNS 9598 55 2 were be VBD 9598 55 3 then then RB 9598 55 4 converted convert VBN 9598 55 5 from from IN 9598 55 6 existing exist VBG 9598 55 7 PDF PDF NNP 9598 55 8 / / , 9598 55 9 A a DT 9598 55 10 format format NN 9598 55 11 to to IN 9598 55 12 xml xml NNP 9598 55 13 . . . 9598 56 1 A a DT 9598 56 2 further further JJ 9598 56 3 20 20 CD 9598 56 4 documents document NNS 9598 56 5 failed fail VBD 9598 56 6 to to TO 9598 56 7 convert convert VB 9598 56 8 due due IN 9598 56 9 to to IN 9598 56 10 nonstandard nonstandard NN 9598 56 11 or or CC 9598 56 12 complex complex JJ 9598 56 13 formatting formatting NN 9598 56 14 which which WDT 9598 56 15 resulted result VBD 9598 56 16 in in IN 9598 56 17 unreadable unreadable JJ 9598 56 18 , , , 9598 56 19 garbled garbled JJ 9598 56 20 characters character NNS 9598 56 21 . . . 9598 57 1 These these DT 9598 57 2 documents document NNS 9598 57 3 resisted resist VBD 9598 57 4 multiple multiple JJ 9598 57 5 conversion conversion NN 9598 57 6 attempts attempt NNS 9598 57 7 , , , 9598 57 8 and and CC 9598 57 9 since since IN 9598 57 10 they -PRON- PRP 9598 57 11 could could MD 9598 57 12 not not RB 9598 57 13 be be VB 9598 57 14 mined mine VBN 9598 57 15 , , , 9598 57 16 had have VBD 9598 57 17 to to TO 9598 57 18 be be VB 9598 57 19 eliminated eliminate VBN 9598 57 20 . . . 9598 58 1 A a DT 9598 58 2 final final JJ 9598 58 3 total total NN 9598 58 4 of of IN 9598 58 5 664 664 CD 9598 58 6 ETDs etd NNS 9598 58 7 were be VBD 9598 58 8 successfully successfully RB 9598 58 9 converted convert VBN 9598 58 10 using use VBG 9598 58 11 three three CD 9598 58 12 different different JJ 9598 58 13 tools tool NNS 9598 58 14 : : : 9598 58 15 97 97 CD 9598 58 16 % % NN 9598 58 17 ( ( -LRB- 9598 58 18 644 644 CD 9598 58 19 ) ) -RRB- 9598 58 20 were be VBD 9598 58 21 converted convert VBN 9598 58 22 using use VBG 9598 58 23 PDFtoHTML,32 PDFtoHTML,32 NNP 9598 58 24 the the DT 9598 58 25 remaining remain VBG 9598 58 26 3 3 CD 9598 58 27 % % NN 9598 58 28 by by IN 9598 58 29 either either DT 9598 58 30 givemetext givemetext NN 9598 58 31 ( ( -LRB- 9598 58 32 14)33 14)33 CD 9598 58 33 or or CC 9598 58 34 Adobe Adobe NNP 9598 58 35 Acrobat Acrobat NNP 9598 58 36 ( ( -LRB- 9598 58 37 3 3 CD 9598 58 38 ) ) -RRB- 9598 58 39 . . . 9598 59 1 A a DT 9598 59 2 spot spot NN 9598 59 3 check check NN 9598 59 4 of of IN 9598 59 5 documents document NNS 9598 59 6 was be VBD 9598 59 7 sufficient sufficient JJ 9598 59 8 evidence evidence NN 9598 59 9 that that IN 9598 59 10 many many JJ 9598 59 11 links link NNS 9598 59 12 occurred occur VBD 9598 59 13 throughout throughout IN 9598 59 14 the the DT 9598 59 15 text text NN 9598 59 16 body body NN 9598 59 17 . . . 9598 60 1 Since since IN 9598 60 2 we -PRON- PRP 9598 60 3 intended intend VBD 9598 60 4 to to TO 9598 60 5 extract extract VB 9598 60 6 URLs url NNS 9598 60 7 to to IN 9598 60 8 the the DT 9598 60 9 open open JJ 9598 60 10 web web NN 9598 60 11 , , , 9598 60 12 we -PRON- PRP 9598 60 13 wanted want VBD 9598 60 14 to to TO 9598 60 15 err err VB 9598 60 16 on on IN 9598 60 17 the the DT 9598 60 18 side side NN 9598 60 19 of of IN 9598 60 20 detecting detect VBG 9598 60 21 more more JJR 9598 60 22 links link NNS 9598 60 23 , , , 9598 60 24 rather rather RB 9598 60 25 than than IN 9598 60 26 easily easily RB 9598 60 27 - - HYPH 9598 60 28 identifiable identifiable JJ 9598 60 29 well well RB 9598 60 30 - - HYPH 9598 60 31 formed form VBN 9598 60 32 URLs url NNS 9598 60 33 . . . 9598 61 1 Links link NNS 9598 61 2 were be VBD 9598 61 3 mined mine VBN 9598 61 4 from from IN 9598 61 5 the the DT 9598 61 6 body body NN 9598 61 7 of of IN 9598 61 8 the the DT 9598 61 9 text text NN 9598 61 10 in in IN 9598 61 11 a a DT 9598 61 12 manner manner NN 9598 61 13 similar similar JJ 9598 61 14 to to IN 9598 61 15 the the DT 9598 61 16 study study NN 9598 61 17 carried carry VBN 9598 61 18 out out RP 9598 61 19 at at IN 9598 61 20 UNT.34 UNT.34 NNP 9598 61 21 We -PRON- PRP 9598 61 22 wanted want VBD 9598 61 23 a a DT 9598 61 24 regular regular JJ 9598 61 25 expression expression NN 9598 61 26 which which WDT 9598 61 27 would would MD 9598 61 28 catch catch VB 9598 61 29 as as IN 9598 61 30 many many JJ 9598 61 31 URLs url NNS 9598 61 32 as as IN 9598 61 33 possible possible JJ 9598 61 34 , , , 9598 61 35 expecting expect VBG 9598 61 36 to to TO 9598 61 37 manually manually RB 9598 61 38 clean clean VB 9598 61 39 the the DT 9598 61 40 link link NN 9598 61 41 output output NN 9598 61 42 before before IN 9598 61 43 further further JJ 9598 61 44 processing processing NN 9598 61 45 . . . 9598 62 1 We -PRON- PRP 9598 62 2 tested test VBD 9598 62 3 multiple multiple NN 9598 62 4 regular regular JJ 9598 62 5 expressions35 expressions35 NN 9598 62 6 against against IN 9598 62 7 a a DT 9598 62 8 small small JJ 9598 62 9 sample sample NN 9598 62 10 of of IN 9598 62 11 our -PRON- PRP$ 9598 62 12 converted converted JJ 9598 62 13 ETDs etd NNS 9598 62 14 and and CC 9598 62 15 compared compare VBD 9598 62 16 the the DT 9598 62 17 results result NNS 9598 62 18 . . . 9598 63 1 We -PRON- PRP 9598 63 2 selected select VBD 9598 63 3 one one CD 9598 63 4 which which WDT 9598 63 5 seemed seem VBD 9598 63 6 well well RB 9598 63 7 - - HYPH 9598 63 8 suited suit VBN 9598 63 9 for for IN 9598 63 10 our -PRON- PRP$ 9598 63 11 purpose purpose NN 9598 63 12 , , , 9598 63 13 as as IN 9598 63 14 it -PRON- PRP 9598 63 15 was be VBD 9598 63 16 liberal liberal JJ 9598 63 17 in in IN 9598 63 18 detecting detect VBG 9598 63 19 links link NNS 9598 63 20 throughout throughout IN 9598 63 21 the the DT 9598 63 22 text text NN 9598 63 23 , , , 9598 63 24 was be VBD 9598 63 25 able able JJ 9598 63 26 to to TO 9598 63 27 extract extract VB 9598 63 28 links link NNS 9598 63 29 which which WDT 9598 63 30 contained contain VBD 9598 63 31 obvious obvious JJ 9598 63 32 omissions omission NNS 9598 63 33 and and CC 9598 63 34 problems problem NNS 9598 63 35 — — : 9598 63 36 for for IN 9598 63 37 example example NN 9598 63 38 , , , 9598 63 39 those those DT 9598 63 40 that that WDT 9598 63 41 lacked lack VBD 9598 63 42 http:// http:// JJ 9598 63 43 prefixes prefix NNS 9598 63 44 — — : 9598 63 45 but but CC 9598 63 46 also also RB 9598 63 47 caught catch VBD 9598 63 48 non non JJ 9598 63 49 - - JJ 9598 63 50 obvious obvious JJ 9598 63 51 errors error NNS 9598 63 52 , , , 9598 63 53 such such JJ 9598 63 54 as as IN 9598 63 55 ellipses ellipsis NNS 9598 63 56 in in IN 9598 63 57 long long JJ 9598 63 58 URLs url NNS 9598 63 59 . . . 9598 64 1 We -PRON- PRP 9598 64 2 considered consider VBD 9598 64 3 how how WRB 9598 64 4 de- de- RB 9598 64 5 duplication duplication NN 9598 64 6 of of IN 9598 64 7 extracted extract VBN 9598 64 8 links link NNS 9598 64 9 might may MD 9598 64 10 affect affect VB 9598 64 11 the the DT 9598 64 12 outcome outcome NN 9598 64 13 , , , 9598 64 14 and and CC 9598 64 15 opted opt VBD 9598 64 16 to to TO 9598 64 17 count count VB 9598 64 18 each each DT 9598 64 19 link link NN 9598 64 20 as as IN 9598 64 21 an an DT 9598 64 22 individual individual JJ 9598 64 23 instance instance NN 9598 64 24 . . . 9598 65 1 Manual manual JJ 9598 65 2 cleanup cleanup NN 9598 65 3 included include VBD 9598 65 4 catching catch VBG 9598 65 5 URLs url NNS 9598 65 6 that that WDT 9598 65 7 broke break VBD 9598 65 8 across across IN 9598 65 9 new new JJ 9598 65 10 lines line NNS 9598 65 11 , , , 9598 65 12 identifying identify VBG 9598 65 13 false false JJ 9598 65 14 hits hit NNS 9598 65 15 such such JJ 9598 65 16 as as IN 9598 65 17 titles title NNS 9598 65 18 containing contain VBG 9598 65 19 colons colon NNS 9598 65 20 and and CC 9598 65 21 DOIs doi NNS 9598 65 22 , , , 9598 65 23 and and CC 9598 65 24 adding add VBG 9598 65 25 escape escape NN 9598 65 26 encoding encode VBG 9598 65 27 characters character NNS 9598 65 28 for for IN 9598 65 29 " " `` 9598 65 30 & & CC 9598 65 31 " " '' 9598 65 32 and and CC 9598 65 33 " " `` 9598 65 34 % % NN 9598 65 35 " " '' 9598 65 36 in in IN 9598 65 37 order order NN 9598 65 38 to to TO 9598 65 39 generate generate VB 9598 65 40 a a DT 9598 65 41 clean clean JJ 9598 65 42 URL url NN 9598 65 43 for for IN 9598 65 44 use use NN 9598 65 45 in in IN 9598 65 46 the the DT 9598 65 47 next next JJ 9598 65 48 step step NN 9598 65 49 of of IN 9598 65 50 the the DT 9598 65 51 process process NN 9598 65 52 . . . 9598 66 1 METHODOLOGY methodology NN 9598 66 2 — — : 9598 66 3 Linkrot Linkrot NNP 9598 66 4 collection collection NN 9598 66 5 A a DT 9598 66 6 script script NN 9598 66 7 programmatically programmatically RB 9598 66 8 used use VBD 9598 66 9 the the DT 9598 66 10 cURL curl NN 9598 66 11 command command NN 9598 66 12 line line NN 9598 66 13 tool tool NN 9598 66 14 to to TO 9598 66 15 visit visit VB 9598 66 16 each each DT 9598 66 17 link link NN 9598 66 18 and and CC 9598 66 19 fetch fetch VB 9598 66 20 the the DT 9598 66 21 http http JJ 9598 66 22 response response NN 9598 66 23 code code NN 9598 66 24 in in IN 9598 66 25 return.36 return.36 NNP 9598 66 26 An an DT 9598 66 27 output output NN 9598 66 28 listing listing NN 9598 66 29 was be VBD 9598 66 30 produced produce VBN 9598 66 31 for for IN 9598 66 32 each each DT 9598 66 33 doctoral doctoral JJ 9598 66 34 dissertation dissertation NN 9598 66 35 , , , 9598 66 36 comprised comprise VBN 9598 66 37 of of IN 9598 66 38 the the DT 9598 66 39 original original JJ 9598 66 40 URLs url NNS 9598 66 41 , , , 9598 66 42 the the DT 9598 66 43 final final JJ 9598 66 44 URLs url NNS 9598 66 45 , , , 9598 66 46 and and CC 9598 66 47 the the DT 9598 66 48 http http JJ 9598 66 49 response response NN 9598 66 50 codes code NNS 9598 66 51 . . . 9598 67 1 Link link VB 9598 67 2 output output NN 9598 67 3 for for IN 9598 67 4 each each DT 9598 67 5 of of IN 9598 67 6 the the DT 9598 67 7 converted convert VBN 9598 67 8 664 664 CD 9598 67 9 ETDs etd NNS 9598 67 10 was be VBD 9598 67 11 collected collect VBN 9598 67 12 from from IN 9598 67 13 December December NNP 9598 67 14 2015 2015 CD 9598 67 15 to to IN 9598 67 16 January January NNP 9598 67 17 2016 2016 CD 9598 67 18 , , , 9598 67 19 with with IN 9598 67 20 the the DT 9598 67 21 fall fall NN 9598 67 22 2015 2015 CD 9598 67 23 semester semester NN 9598 67 24 checked check VBN 9598 67 25 in in IN 9598 67 26 March March NNP 9598 67 27 2016 2016 CD 9598 67 28 . . . 9598 68 1 76 76 CD 9598 68 2 % % NN 9598 68 3 ( ( -LRB- 9598 68 4 504 504 CD 9598 68 5 of of IN 9598 68 6 664 664 CD 9598 68 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 68 8 of of IN 9598 68 9 ETDs etd NNS 9598 68 10 contained contain VBD 9598 68 11 one one CD 9598 68 12 or or CC 9598 68 13 more more JJR 9598 68 14 links link NNS 9598 68 15 , , , 9598 68 16 the the DT 9598 68 17 highest high JJS 9598 68 18 number number NN 9598 68 19 of of IN 9598 68 20 links link NNS 9598 68 21 ( ( -LRB- 9598 68 22 5,946 5,946 CD 9598 68 23 ) ) -RRB- 9598 68 24 falling fall VBG 9598 68 25 into into IN 9598 68 26 the the DT 9598 68 27 Arts Arts NNP 9598 68 28 group group NN 9598 68 29 . . . 9598 69 1 24 24 CD 9598 69 2 % % NN 9598 69 3 ( ( -LRB- 9598 69 4 160 160 CD 9598 69 5 of of IN 9598 69 6 664 664 CD 9598 69 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 69 8 of of IN 9598 69 9 ETDs etd NNS 9598 69 10 contained contain VBD 9598 69 11 no no DT 9598 69 12 links link NNS 9598 69 13 . . . 9598 70 1 For for IN 9598 70 2 the the DT 9598 70 3 5-year 5-year CD 9598 70 4 period period NN 9598 70 5 , , , 9598 70 6 the the DT 9598 70 7 broad broad JJ 9598 70 8 discipline discipline NN 9598 70 9 breakdown breakdown NN 9598 70 10 of of IN 9598 70 11 documents document NNS 9598 70 12 examined examine VBN 9598 70 13 , , , 9598 70 14 the the DT 9598 70 15 number number NN 9598 70 16 of of IN 9598 70 17 ETDs etd NNS 9598 70 18 with with IN 9598 70 19 links link NNS 9598 70 20 , , , 9598 70 21 and and CC 9598 70 22 the the DT 9598 70 23 number number NN 9598 70 24 of of IN 9598 70 25 links link NNS 9598 70 26 extracted extract VBN 9598 70 27 are be VBP 9598 70 28 shown show VBN 9598 70 29 in in IN 9598 70 30 Table Table NNP 9598 70 31 2 2 CD 9598 70 32 . . . 9598 71 1 Converted convert VBN 9598 71 2 ETDs etd NNS 9598 71 3 by by IN 9598 71 4 publication publication NN 9598 71 5 year year NN 9598 71 6 , , , 9598 71 7 broken break VBN 9598 71 8 out out RP 9598 71 9 by by IN 9598 71 10 broad broad JJ 9598 71 11 disciplines discipline NNS 9598 71 12 , , , 9598 71 13 are be VBP 9598 71 14 shown show VBN 9598 71 15 in in IN 9598 71 16 Figure Figure NNP 9598 71 17 1 1 CD 9598 71 18 . . . 9598 72 1 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 9598 72 2 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 9598 72 3 AND and CC 9598 72 4 LIBRARIES library NNS 9598 72 5 | | NNP 9598 72 6 MARCH MARCH NNS 9598 72 7 2017 2017 CD 9598 72 8 17 17 CD 9598 72 9 Discipline Discipline NNP 9598 72 10 Number number NN 9598 72 11 of of IN 9598 72 12 PhD phd NN 9598 72 13 ETDs etd NNS 9598 72 14 in in IN 9598 72 15 Spectrum Spectrum NNP 9598 72 16 ETDs ETDs NNP 9598 72 17 converted converted JJ 9598 72 18 * * NFP 9598 72 19 Contain contain VB 9598 72 20 no no DT 9598 72 21 links link NNS 9598 72 22 Contain contain NN 9598 72 23 links link NNS 9598 72 24 Number number NN 9598 72 25 of of IN 9598 72 26 links link NNS 9598 72 27 extracted extract VBD 9598 72 28 Arts Arts NNP 9598 72 29 210 210 CD 9598 72 30 195 195 CD 9598 72 31 31 31 CD 9598 72 32 164 164 CD 9598 72 33 5,946 5,946 CD 9598 72 34 Business business NN 9598 72 35 45 45 CD 9598 72 36 43 43 CD 9598 72 37 12 12 CD 9598 72 38 31 31 CD 9598 72 39 210 210 CD 9598 72 40 Engineering engineering NN 9598 72 41 351 351 CD 9598 72 42 326 326 CD 9598 72 43 82 82 CD 9598 72 44 244 244 CD 9598 72 45 3,259 3,259 CD 9598 72 46 Fine Fine NNP 9598 72 47 Arts Arts NNP 9598 72 48 28 28 CD 9598 72 49 25 25 CD 9598 72 50 2 2 CD 9598 72 51 23 23 CD 9598 72 52 1,728 1,728 CD 9598 72 53 Science science NN 9598 72 54 86 86 CD 9598 72 55 75 75 CD 9598 72 56 33 33 CD 9598 72 57 42 42 CD 9598 72 58 294 294 CD 9598 72 59 Total Total NNP 9598 72 60 720 720 CD 9598 72 61 664 664 CD 9598 72 62 160 160 CD 9598 72 63 504 504 CD 9598 72 64 11,437 11,437 CD 9598 72 65 Table table NN 9598 72 66 2 2 CD 9598 72 67 . . . 9598 73 1 5-year 5-year CD 9598 73 2 period period NN 9598 73 3 , , , 9598 73 4 2011 2011 CD 9598 73 5 - - SYM 9598 73 6 2015 2015 CD 9598 73 7 , , , 9598 73 8 summary summary NN 9598 73 9 of of IN 9598 73 10 documents document NNS 9598 73 11 examined examine VBN 9598 73 12 and and CC 9598 73 13 links link NNS 9598 73 14 extracted extract VBN 9598 73 15 * * NFP 9598 73 16 56 56 CD 9598 73 17 documents document NNS 9598 73 18 in in IN 9598 73 19 total total NN 9598 73 20 eliminated eliminate VBN 9598 73 21 ( ( -LRB- 9598 73 22 36 36 CD 9598 73 23 embargoed embargoed RB 9598 73 24 ; ; : 9598 73 25 plus plus CC 9598 73 26 20 20 CD 9598 73 27 which which WDT 9598 73 28 failed fail VBD 9598 73 29 to to TO 9598 73 30 convert convert VB 9598 73 31 ) ) -RRB- 9598 73 32 . . . 9598 74 1 Figure figure NN 9598 74 2 1 1 CD 9598 74 3 . . . 9598 75 1 Converted convert VBN 9598 75 2 ETDs etd NNS 9598 75 3 by by IN 9598 75 4 publication publication NN 9598 75 5 year year NN 9598 75 6 and and CC 9598 75 7 broad broad JJ 9598 75 8 discipline discipline NN 9598 75 9 A a DT 9598 75 10 CASE case NN 9598 75 11 STUDY STUDY NNP 9598 75 12 OF of IN 9598 75 13 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9598 75 14 THESES thesis NNS 9598 75 15 AND and CC 9598 75 16 DISSERTATIONS dissertation NNS 9598 75 17 ( ( -LRB- 9598 75 18 ETDS ETDS NNP 9598 75 19 ) ) -RRB- 9598 75 20 IN in IN 9598 75 21 AN an DT 9598 75 22 ACADEMIC ACADEMIC NNP 9598 75 23 LIBRARY LIBRARY NNP 9598 75 24 | | NNS 9598 75 25 MASSICOTTE MASSICOTTE NNP 9598 75 26 AND and CC 9598 75 27 BOTTER BOTTER NNP 9598 75 28 | | NNP 9598 75 29 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 NNP 9598 75 30 18 18 CD 9598 75 31 The the DT 9598 75 32 11,437 11,437 CD 9598 75 33 links link NNS 9598 75 34 extracted extract VBN 9598 75 35 were be VBD 9598 75 36 checked check VBN 9598 75 37 for for IN 9598 75 38 linkrot linkrot NNS 9598 75 39 , , , 9598 75 40 each each DT 9598 75 41 link link NN 9598 75 42 accessed access VBN 9598 75 43 and and CC 9598 75 44 its -PRON- PRP$ 9598 75 45 http http JJ 9598 75 46 response response NN 9598 75 47 code code NN 9598 75 48 recorded record VBN 9598 75 49 . . . 9598 76 1 77 77 CD 9598 76 2 % % NN 9598 76 3 ( ( -LRB- 9598 76 4 8,834 8,834 CD 9598 76 5 of of IN 9598 76 6 11,437 11,437 CD 9598 76 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 76 8 of of IN 9598 76 9 links link NNS 9598 76 10 returned return VBD 9598 76 11 an an DT 9598 76 12 active active JJ 9598 76 13 2xx 2xx JJ 9598 76 14 http http JJ 9598 76 15 response response NN 9598 76 16 code code NN 9598 76 17 . . . 9598 77 1 23 23 CD 9598 77 2 % % NN 9598 77 3 ( ( -LRB- 9598 77 4 2,603 2,603 CD 9598 77 5 ) ) -RRB- 9598 77 6 of of IN 9598 77 7 links link NNS 9598 77 8 could could MD 9598 77 9 not not RB 9598 77 10 be be VB 9598 77 11 reached reach VBN 9598 77 12 , , , 9598 77 13 returning return VBG 9598 77 14 a a DT 9598 77 15 response response NN 9598 77 16 code code NN 9598 77 17 other other JJ 9598 77 18 than than IN 9598 77 19 in in IN 9598 77 20 the the DT 9598 77 21 2xx 2xx JJ 9598 77 22 range range NN 9598 77 23 . . . 9598 78 1 This this DT 9598 78 2 includes include VBZ 9598 78 3 102 102 CD 9598 78 4 links link NNS 9598 78 5 in in IN 9598 78 6 the the DT 9598 78 7 3xx 3xx JJ 9598 78 8 range range NN 9598 78 9 which which WDT 9598 78 10 failed fail VBD 9598 78 11 to to TO 9598 78 12 reach reach VB 9598 78 13 a a DT 9598 78 14 destination destination NN 9598 78 15 after after IN 9598 78 16 50 50 CD 9598 78 17 redirects redirect NNS 9598 78 18 and and CC 9598 78 19 were be VBD 9598 78 20 considered consider VBN 9598 78 21 linkrot linkrot NNS 9598 78 22 . . . 9598 79 1 Numbers number NNS 9598 79 2 of of IN 9598 79 3 links link NNS 9598 79 4 , , , 9598 79 5 total total JJ 9598 79 6 link link NN 9598 79 7 response response NN 9598 79 8 , , , 9598 79 9 and and CC 9598 79 10 link link VB 9598 79 11 response response NN 9598 79 12 by by IN 9598 79 13 year year NN 9598 79 14 broken break VBN 9598 79 15 down down RP 9598 79 16 by by IN 9598 79 17 broad broad JJ 9598 79 18 discipline discipline NN 9598 79 19 are be VBP 9598 79 20 shown show VBN 9598 79 21 in in IN 9598 79 22 Figure Figure NNP 9598 79 23 2 2 CD 9598 79 24 , , , 9598 79 25 with with IN 9598 79 26 accompanying accompany VBG 9598 79 27 data datum NNS 9598 79 28 provided provide VBN 9598 79 29 in in IN 9598 79 30 Table table NN 9598 79 31 3 3 CD 9598 79 32 and and CC 9598 79 33 discussed discuss VBN 9598 79 34 in in IN 9598 79 35 the the DT 9598 79 36 findings finding NNS 9598 79 37 section section NN 9598 79 38 . . . 9598 80 1 Figure figure NN 9598 80 2 2 2 CD 9598 80 3 . . . 9598 81 1 Link link VB 9598 81 2 HTTP http JJ 9598 81 3 response response NN 9598 81 4 codes code NNS 9598 81 5 , , , 9598 81 6 by by IN 9598 81 7 broad broad JJ 9598 81 8 discipline discipline NN 9598 81 9 and and CC 9598 81 10 year year NN 9598 81 11 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 9598 81 12 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 9598 81 13 AND and CC 9598 81 14 LIBRARIES library NNS 9598 81 15 | | NNP 9598 81 16 MARCH MARCH NNS 9598 81 17 2017 2017 CD 9598 81 18 19 19 CD 9598 81 19 Discipline discipline NN 9598 81 20 HTTP HTTP NNP 9598 81 21 response response NN 9598 81 22 code code NN 9598 81 23 2011 2011 CD 9598 81 24 2012 2012 CD 9598 81 25 2013 2013 CD 9598 81 26 2014 2014 CD 9598 81 27 2015 2015 CD 9598 81 28 Total total JJ 9598 81 29 % % NN 9598 81 30 Active Active NNP 9598 81 31 & & CC 9598 81 32 Rotten Rotten NNP 9598 81 33 * * NFP 9598 81 34 * * NFP 9598 81 35 Arts art NNS 9598 81 36 2xx 2xx JJ 9598 81 37 691 691 CD 9598 81 38 864 864 CD 9598 81 39 800 800 CD 9598 81 40 1,108 1,108 CD 9598 81 41 1,093 1,093 CD 9598 81 42 4,556 4,556 CD 9598 81 43 77 77 CD 9598 81 44 % % NN 9598 81 45 all all DT 9598 81 46 other other JJ 9598 81 47 * * NFP 9598 81 48 320 320 CD 9598 81 49 428 428 CD 9598 81 50 131 131 CD 9598 81 51 293 293 CD 9598 81 52 218 218 CD 9598 81 53 1,390 1,390 CD 9598 81 54 23 23 CD 9598 81 55 % % NN 9598 81 56 Business business NN 9598 81 57 2xx 2xx NN 9598 81 58 14 14 CD 9598 81 59 52 52 CD 9598 81 60 17 17 CD 9598 81 61 22 22 CD 9598 81 62 50 50 CD 9598 81 63 155 155 CD 9598 81 64 74 74 CD 9598 81 65 % % NN 9598 81 66 all all DT 9598 81 67 other other JJ 9598 81 68 9 9 CD 9598 81 69 19 19 CD 9598 81 70 5 5 CD 9598 81 71 9 9 CD 9598 81 72 13 13 CD 9598 81 73 55 55 CD 9598 81 74 26 26 CD 9598 81 75 % % NN 9598 81 76 Engineering engineering NN 9598 81 77 2xx 2xx JJ 9598 81 78 302 302 CD 9598 81 79 702 702 CD 9598 81 80 638 638 CD 9598 81 81 482 482 CD 9598 81 82 404 404 CD 9598 81 83 2,528 2,528 CD 9598 81 84 78 78 CD 9598 81 85 % % NN 9598 81 86 all all DT 9598 81 87 other other JJ 9598 81 88 134 134 CD 9598 81 89 172 172 CD 9598 81 90 180 180 CD 9598 81 91 196 196 CD 9598 81 92 49 49 CD 9598 81 93 731 731 CD 9598 81 94 22 22 CD 9598 81 95 % % NN 9598 81 96 Fine Fine NNP 9598 81 97 Arts Arts NNP 9598 81 98 2xx 2xx NN 9598 81 99 165 165 CD 9598 81 100 143 143 CD 9598 81 101 504 504 CD 9598 81 102 467 467 CD 9598 81 103 94 94 CD 9598 81 104 1,373 1,373 CD 9598 81 105 79 79 CD 9598 81 106 % % NN 9598 81 107 all all DT 9598 81 108 other other JJ 9598 81 109 74 74 CD 9598 81 110 56 56 CD 9598 81 111 118 118 CD 9598 81 112 98 98 CD 9598 81 113 9 9 CD 9598 81 114 355 355 CD 9598 81 115 21 21 CD 9598 81 116 % % NN 9598 81 117 Science Science NNP 9598 81 118 2xx 2xx NN 9598 81 119 77 77 CD 9598 81 120 34 34 CD 9598 81 121 58 58 CD 9598 81 122 39 39 CD 9598 81 123 14 14 CD 9598 81 124 222 222 CD 9598 81 125 76 76 CD 9598 81 126 % % NN 9598 81 127 all all DT 9598 81 128 other other JJ 9598 81 129 25 25 CD 9598 81 130 23 23 CD 9598 81 131 10 10 CD 9598 81 132 11 11 CD 9598 81 133 3 3 CD 9598 81 134 72 72 CD 9598 81 135 24 24 CD 9598 81 136 % % NN 9598 81 137 Subtotal subtotal JJ 9598 81 138 2xx 2xx JJ 9598 81 139 1,249 1,249 CD 9598 81 140 1,795 1,795 CD 9598 81 141 2,017 2,017 CD 9598 81 142 2,118 2,118 CD 9598 81 143 1,655 1,655 CD 9598 81 144 8,834 8,834 CD 9598 81 145 77 77 CD 9598 81 146 % % NN 9598 81 147 active active JJ 9598 81 148 all all DT 9598 81 149 other other JJ 9598 81 150 562 562 CD 9598 81 151 698 698 CD 9598 81 152 444 444 CD 9598 81 153 607 607 CD 9598 81 154 292 292 CD 9598 81 155 2,603 2,603 CD 9598 81 156 23 23 CD 9598 81 157 % % NN 9598 81 158 rotten rotten JJ 9598 81 159 % % NN 9598 81 160 Rotten Rotten NNP 9598 81 161 31 31 CD 9598 81 162 % % NN 9598 81 163 28 28 CD 9598 81 164 % % NN 9598 81 165 18 18 CD 9598 81 166 % % NN 9598 81 167 22 22 CD 9598 81 168 % % NN 9598 81 169 15 15 CD 9598 81 170 % % NN 9598 81 171 23 23 CD 9598 81 172 % % NN 9598 81 173 Total total JJ 9598 81 174 1,811 1,811 CD 9598 81 175 2,493 2,493 CD 9598 81 176 2,461 2,461 CD 9598 81 177 2,725 2,725 CD 9598 81 178 1,947 1,947 CD 9598 81 179 11,437 11,437 CD 9598 81 180 100 100 CD 9598 81 181 % % NN 9598 81 182 Table table NN 9598 81 183 3 3 CD 9598 81 184 . . . 9598 82 1 Breakdown breakdown NN 9598 82 2 by by IN 9598 82 3 year year NN 9598 82 4 and and CC 9598 82 5 discipline discipline NN 9598 82 6 showing show VBG 9598 82 7 active active JJ 9598 82 8 ( ( -LRB- 9598 82 9 2xx 2xx JJ 9598 82 10 ) ) -RRB- 9598 82 11 and and CC 9598 82 12 rotten rotten JJ 9598 82 13 ( ( -LRB- 9598 82 14 all all DT 9598 82 15 others other NNS 9598 82 16 ) ) -RRB- 9598 82 17 response response NN 9598 82 18 codes code NNS 9598 82 19 * * NFP 9598 82 20 All all DT 9598 82 21 other other JJ 9598 82 22 = = NFP 9598 82 23 0 0 NFP 9598 82 24 , , , 9598 82 25 1xx 1xx JJ 9598 82 26 , , , 9598 82 27 3xx 3xx JJ 9598 82 28 ( ( -LRB- 9598 82 29 unresolved unresolved JJ 9598 82 30 after after IN 9598 82 31 50 50 CD 9598 82 32 redirects redirect NNS 9598 82 33 ) ) -RRB- 9598 82 34 , , , 9598 82 35 4xx 4xx JJ 9598 82 36 and and CC 9598 82 37 5xx 5xx JJ 9598 82 38 response response NN 9598 82 39 codes code NNS 9598 82 40 combined combine VBN 9598 82 41 * * NFP 9598 82 42 * * NFP 9598 82 43 Active active JJ 9598 82 44 and and CC 9598 82 45 rotten rotten JJ 9598 82 46 rates rate NNS 9598 82 47 based base VBN 9598 82 48 on on IN 9598 82 49 total total JJ 9598 82 50 links link NNS 9598 82 51 per per IN 9598 82 52 discipline discipline NN 9598 82 53 METHODOLOGY METHODOLOGY NNP 9598 82 54 — — : 9598 82 55 Content Content NNP 9598 82 56 Drift Drift NNP 9598 82 57 For for IN 9598 82 58 the the DT 9598 82 59 content content JJ 9598 82 60 drift drift NN 9598 82 61 phase phase NN 9598 82 62 , , , 9598 82 63 we -PRON- PRP 9598 82 64 wanted want VBD 9598 82 65 to to TO 9598 82 66 sample sample VB 9598 82 67 documents document NNS 9598 82 68 from from IN 9598 82 69 each each DT 9598 82 70 of of IN 9598 82 71 the the DT 9598 82 72 five five CD 9598 82 73 disciplines discipline NNS 9598 82 74 . . . 9598 83 1 ETDs etd NNS 9598 83 2 which which WDT 9598 83 3 did do VBD 9598 83 4 not not RB 9598 83 5 contain contain VB 9598 83 6 any any DT 9598 83 7 links link NNS 9598 83 8 were be VBD 9598 83 9 excluded exclude VBN 9598 83 10 from from IN 9598 83 11 the the DT 9598 83 12 sample sample NN 9598 83 13 . . . 9598 84 1 Using use VBG 9598 84 2 only only JJ 9598 84 3 documents document NNS 9598 84 4 with with IN 9598 84 5 one one CD 9598 84 6 or or CC 9598 84 7 more more RBR 9598 84 8 active active JJ 9598 84 9 links link NNS 9598 84 10 , , , 9598 84 11 a a DT 9598 84 12 stratified stratify VBN 9598 84 13 random random JJ 9598 84 14 sample sample NN 9598 84 15 of of IN 9598 84 16 10 10 CD 9598 84 17 % % NN 9598 84 18 was be VBD 9598 84 19 drawn draw VBN 9598 84 20 for for IN 9598 84 21 a a DT 9598 84 22 final final JJ 9598 84 23 sample sample NN 9598 84 24 of of IN 9598 84 25 49 49 CD 9598 84 26 ETDs etd NNS 9598 84 27 containing contain VBG 9598 84 28 a a DT 9598 84 29 total total NN 9598 84 30 of of IN 9598 84 31 990 990 CD 9598 84 32 links link NNS 9598 84 33 . . . 9598 85 1 A a DT 9598 85 2 snippet snippet NN 9598 85 3 of of IN 9598 85 4 text text NN 9598 85 5 surrounding surround VBG 9598 85 6 each each DT 9598 85 7 link link NN 9598 85 8 was be VBD 9598 85 9 then then RB 9598 85 10 also also RB 9598 85 11 extracted extract VBN 9598 85 12 from from IN 9598 85 13 each each DT 9598 85 14 ETD ETD NNP 9598 85 15 , , , 9598 85 16 along along IN 9598 85 17 with with IN 9598 85 18 any any DT 9598 85 19 " " `` 9598 85 20 date date NN 9598 85 21 accessed access VBN 9598 85 22 " " '' 9598 85 23 or or CC 9598 85 24 " " `` 9598 85 25 date date NN 9598 85 26 viewed view VBN 9598 85 27 " " '' 9598 85 28 information information NN 9598 85 29 if if IN 9598 85 30 present present NN 9598 85 31 . . . 9598 86 1 Each each DT 9598 86 2 link link NN 9598 86 3 was be VBD 9598 86 4 manually manually RB 9598 86 5 visited visit VBN 9598 86 6 , , , 9598 86 7 assessed assess VBN 9598 86 8 for for IN 9598 86 9 content content NN 9598 86 10 drift drift NN 9598 86 11 , , , 9598 86 12 and and CC 9598 86 13 observations observation NNS 9598 86 14 recorded record VBN 9598 86 15 . . . 9598 87 1 The the DT 9598 87 2 breakdown breakdown NN 9598 87 3 of of IN 9598 87 4 the the DT 9598 87 5 content content NN 9598 87 6 drift drift NN 9598 87 7 sample sample NN 9598 87 8 is be VBZ 9598 87 9 shown show VBN 9598 87 10 in in IN 9598 87 11 Table table NN 9598 87 12 4 4 CD 9598 87 13 . . . 9598 88 1 A a DT 9598 88 2 CASE case NN 9598 88 3 STUDY STUDY NNP 9598 88 4 OF of IN 9598 88 5 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9598 88 6 THESES thesis NNS 9598 88 7 AND and CC 9598 88 8 DISSERTATIONS dissertation NNS 9598 88 9 ( ( -LRB- 9598 88 10 ETDS ETDS NNP 9598 88 11 ) ) -RRB- 9598 88 12 IN in IN 9598 88 13 AN an DT 9598 88 14 ACADEMIC ACADEMIC NNP 9598 88 15 LIBRARY LIBRARY NNP 9598 88 16 | | NNS 9598 88 17 MASSICOTTE MASSICOTTE NNP 9598 88 18 AND and CC 9598 88 19 BOTTER BOTTER NNP 9598 88 20 | | NNP 9598 88 21 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 NNP 9598 88 22 20 20 CD 9598 88 23 Discipline discipline NN 9598 88 24 ETDs etd NNS 9598 88 25 with with IN 9598 88 26 links link NNS 9598 88 27 ETDs etd NNS 9598 88 28 with with IN 9598 88 29 active active JJ 9598 88 30 links link NNS 9598 88 31 ( ( -LRB- 9598 88 32 2xx 2xx JJ 9598 88 33 ) ) -RRB- 9598 88 34 ETDs etd NNS 9598 88 35 sampled sample VBN 9598 88 36 for for IN 9598 88 37 content content NN 9598 88 38 drift drift NN 9598 88 39 * * NFP 9598 88 40 Number number NN 9598 88 41 of of IN 9598 88 42 links link NNS 9598 88 43 extracted extract VBN 9598 88 44 for for IN 9598 88 45 sample sample NN 9598 88 46 Arts Arts NNP 9598 88 47 164 164 CD 9598 88 48 156 156 CD 9598 88 49 16 16 CD 9598 88 50 668 668 CD 9598 88 51 Business business NN 9598 88 52 31 31 CD 9598 88 53 28 28 CD 9598 88 54 3 3 CD 9598 88 55 12 12 CD 9598 88 56 Engineering Engineering NNP 9598 88 57 244 244 CD 9598 88 58 235 235 CD 9598 88 59 24 24 CD 9598 88 60 154 154 CD 9598 88 61 Fine Fine NNP 9598 88 62 Arts Arts NNP 9598 88 63 23 23 CD 9598 88 64 23 23 CD 9598 88 65 2 2 CD 9598 88 66 136 136 CD 9598 88 67 Science science NN 9598 88 68 42 42 CD 9598 88 69 40 40 CD 9598 88 70 4 4 CD 9598 88 71 20 20 CD 9598 88 72 Total total NN 9598 88 73 504 504 CD 9598 88 74 482 482 CD 9598 88 75 49 49 CD 9598 88 76 990 990 CD 9598 88 77 Table table NN 9598 88 78 4 4 CD 9598 88 79 . . . 9598 89 1 Breakdown breakdown NN 9598 89 2 of of IN 9598 89 3 sample sample NN 9598 89 4 pool pool NN 9598 89 5 of of IN 9598 89 6 ETDs etd NNS 9598 89 7 for for IN 9598 89 8 content content NN 9598 89 9 drift drift NN 9598 89 10 analysis analysis NN 9598 89 11 * * NFP 9598 89 12 10 10 CD 9598 89 13 % % NN 9598 89 14 sample sample NN 9598 89 15 drawn draw VBN 9598 89 16 from from IN 9598 89 17 each each DT 9598 89 18 discipline discipline NN 9598 89 19 ’s ’s POS 9598 89 20 pool pool NN 9598 89 21 of of IN 9598 89 22 ETDs etd NNS 9598 89 23 ; ; , 9598 89 24 only only RB 9598 89 25 ETDs etd NNS 9598 89 26 with with IN 9598 89 27 URLs url NNS 9598 89 28 relevant relevant JJ 9598 89 29 for for IN 9598 89 30 content content NN 9598 89 31 drift drift NN 9598 89 32 assessment assessment NN 9598 89 33 . . . 9598 90 1 Visited visited JJ 9598 90 2 links link NNS 9598 90 3 were be VBD 9598 90 4 benchmarked benchmarke VBN 9598 90 5 against against IN 9598 90 6 the the DT 9598 90 7 existence existence NN 9598 90 8 of of IN 9598 90 9 a a DT 9598 90 10 memento memento NN 9598 90 11 -- -- : 9598 90 12 an an DT 9598 90 13 archived archived JJ 9598 90 14 snapshot snapshot NN 9598 90 15 of of IN 9598 90 16 that that DT 9598 90 17 page page NN 9598 90 18 located locate VBN 9598 90 19 in in IN 9598 90 20 the the DT 9598 90 21 Wayback Wayback NNP 9598 90 22 Machine.37 Machine.37 NNP 9598 90 23 Since since IN 9598 90 24 the the DT 9598 90 25 University University NNP 9598 90 26 sets set VBZ 9598 90 27 a a DT 9598 90 28 strict strict JJ 9598 90 29 thesis thesis NN 9598 90 30 submission submission NN 9598 90 31 deadline deadline NN 9598 90 32 of of IN 9598 90 33 3 3 CD 9598 90 34 months month NNS 9598 90 35 prior prior RB 9598 90 36 to to IN 9598 90 37 convocation convocation NN 9598 90 38 , , , 9598 90 39 mementos memento NNS 9598 90 40 prior prior RB 9598 90 41 to to IN 9598 90 42 submission submission NN 9598 90 43 deadline deadline NN 9598 90 44 would would MD 9598 90 45 be be VB 9598 90 46 sought seek VBN 9598 90 47 . . . 9598 91 1 Based base VBN 9598 91 2 on on IN 9598 91 3 the the DT 9598 91 4 occurrences occurrence NNS 9598 91 5 of of IN 9598 91 6 " " `` 9598 91 7 date date NN 9598 91 8 accessed access VBN 9598 91 9 " " '' 9598 91 10 and and CC 9598 91 11 discursive discursive JJ 9598 91 12 information information NN 9598 91 13 found find VBN 9598 91 14 in in IN 9598 91 15 the the DT 9598 91 16 snippets snippet NNS 9598 91 17 , , , 9598 91 18 we -PRON- PRP 9598 91 19 arrived arrive VBD 9598 91 20 at at IN 9598 91 21 the the DT 9598 91 22 supposition supposition NN 9598 91 23 that that WDT 9598 91 24 links link NNS 9598 91 25 were be VBD 9598 91 26 likely likely JJ 9598 91 27 to to TO 9598 91 28 have have VB 9598 91 29 been be VBN 9598 91 30 checked check VBN 9598 91 31 the the DT 9598 91 32 closer close JJR 9598 91 33 the the DT 9598 91 34 student student NN 9598 91 35 approached approach VBD 9598 91 36 final final JJ 9598 91 37 stages stage NNS 9598 91 38 of of IN 9598 91 39 manuscript manuscript NN 9598 91 40 preparation preparation NN 9598 91 41 , , , 9598 91 42 although although IN 9598 91 43 this this DT 9598 91 44 is be VBZ 9598 91 45 not not RB 9598 91 46 verifiable verifiable JJ 9598 91 47 . . . 9598 92 1 We -PRON- PRP 9598 92 2 set set VBD 9598 92 3 ourselves -PRON- PRP 9598 92 4 a a DT 9598 92 5 soft soft JJ 9598 92 6 window window NN 9598 92 7 for for IN 9598 92 8 locating locate VBG 9598 92 9 an an DT 9598 92 10 archived archived JJ 9598 92 11 snapshot snapshot NN 9598 92 12 using use VBG 9598 92 13 a a DT 9598 92 14 date date NN 9598 92 15 6 6 CD 9598 92 16 months month NNS 9598 92 17 prior prior RB 9598 92 18 to to IN 9598 92 19 the the DT 9598 92 20 convocation convocation NN 9598 92 21 date date NN 9598 92 22 as as IN 9598 92 23 the the DT 9598 92 24 benchmark benchmark NN 9598 92 25 ; ; : 9598 92 26 that that RB 9598 92 27 is is RB 9598 92 28 , , , 9598 92 29 for for IN 9598 92 30 each each DT 9598 92 31 semester semester NN 9598 92 32 's 's POS 9598 92 33 deadline deadline NN 9598 92 34 date date NN 9598 92 35 , , , 9598 92 36 an an DT 9598 92 37 additional additional JJ 9598 92 38 3 3 CD 9598 92 39 months month NNS 9598 92 40 was be VBD 9598 92 41 added add VBN 9598 92 42 , , , 9598 92 43 arriving arrive VBG 9598 92 44 at at IN 9598 92 45 a a DT 9598 92 46 6-months 6-months CD 9598 92 47 - - HYPH 9598 92 48 prior prior RB 9598 92 49 - - HYPH 9598 92 50 to to IN 9598 92 51 - - HYPH 9598 92 52 publication publication NN 9598 92 53 marker marker NN 9598 92 54 . . . 9598 93 1 Since since IN 9598 93 2 programmatic programmatic JJ 9598 93 3 analysis analysis NN 9598 93 4 of of IN 9598 93 5 990 990 CD 9598 93 6 links link NNS 9598 93 7 required require VBN 9598 93 8 time time NN 9598 93 9 , , , 9598 93 10 expertise expertise NN 9598 93 11 , , , 9598 93 12 and and CC 9598 93 13 resources resource NNS 9598 93 14 not not RB 9598 93 15 available available JJ 9598 93 16 to to IN 9598 93 17 us -PRON- PRP 9598 93 18 , , , 9598 93 19 we -PRON- PRP 9598 93 20 approached approach VBD 9598 93 21 the the DT 9598 93 22 problem problem NN 9598 93 23 heuristically heuristically RB 9598 93 24 . . . 9598 94 1 Assuming assume VBG 9598 94 2 that that IN 9598 94 3 online online JJ 9598 94 4 consultations consultation NNS 9598 94 5 are be VBP 9598 94 6 not not RB 9598 94 7 linear linear JJ 9598 94 8 , , , 9598 94 9 active active JJ 9598 94 10 links link NNS 9598 94 11 occurring occur VBG 9598 94 12 multiple multiple JJ 9598 94 13 times time NNS 9598 94 14 in in IN 9598 94 15 a a DT 9598 94 16 document document NN 9598 94 17 were be VBD 9598 94 18 given give VBN 9598 94 19 equal equal JJ 9598 94 20 weight weight NN 9598 94 21 . . . 9598 95 1 Each each DT 9598 95 2 link link NN 9598 95 3 was be VBD 9598 95 4 manually manually RB 9598 95 5 checked check VBN 9598 95 6 in in IN 9598 95 7 the the DT 9598 95 8 Wayback Wayback NNP 9598 95 9 Machine Machine NNP 9598 95 10 using use VBG 9598 95 11 " " `` 9598 95 12 date date NN 9598 95 13 viewed view VBN 9598 95 14 " " '' 9598 95 15 if if IN 9598 95 16 provided provide VBN 9598 95 17 ; ; : 9598 95 18 if if IN 9598 95 19 no no DT 9598 95 20 date date NN 9598 95 21 was be VBD 9598 95 22 provided provide VBN 9598 95 23 ( ( -LRB- 9598 95 24 the the DT 9598 95 25 majority majority NN 9598 95 26 of of IN 9598 95 27 cases case NNS 9598 95 28 ) ) -RRB- 9598 95 29 , , , 9598 95 30 Wayback Wayback NNP 9598 95 31 was be VBD 9598 95 32 checked check VBN 9598 95 33 to to TO 9598 95 34 see see VB 9598 95 35 if if IN 9598 95 36 an an DT 9598 95 37 archived archived JJ 9598 95 38 version version NN 9598 95 39 existed exist VBD 9598 95 40 as as RB 9598 95 41 close close JJ 9598 95 42 to to IN 9598 95 43 our -PRON- PRP$ 9598 95 44 6 6 CD 9598 95 45 month month NN 9598 95 46 soft soft JJ 9598 95 47 marker marker NN 9598 95 48 as as IN 9598 95 49 possible possible JJ 9598 95 50 . . . 9598 96 1 If if IN 9598 96 2 a a DT 9598 96 3 memento memento NN 9598 96 4 was be VBD 9598 96 5 not not RB 9598 96 6 found find VBN 9598 96 7 within within IN 9598 96 8 a a DT 9598 96 9 month month NN 9598 96 10 earlier early RBR 9598 96 11 / / RBR 9598 96 12 later later RB 9598 96 13 than than IN 9598 96 14 the the DT 9598 96 15 soft soft JJ 9598 96 16 marker marker NN 9598 96 17 , , , 9598 96 18 then then RB 9598 96 19 the the DT 9598 96 20 nearest near JJS 9598 96 21 neighboring neighboring NN 9598 96 22 older old JJR 9598 96 23 memento memento NNP 9598 96 24 was be VBD 9598 96 25 selected select VBN 9598 96 26 , , , 9598 96 27 if if IN 9598 96 28 one one CD 9598 96 29 existed exist VBD 9598 96 30 . . . 9598 97 1 The the DT 9598 97 2 original original JJ 9598 97 3 URL url NN 9598 97 4 , , , 9598 97 5 the the DT 9598 97 6 date date NN 9598 97 7 the the DT 9598 97 8 URL url NN 9598 97 9 was be VBD 9598 97 10 visited visit VBN 9598 97 11 , , , 9598 97 12 and and CC 9598 97 13 whether whether IN 9598 97 14 a a DT 9598 97 15 snapshot snapshot NN 9598 97 16 was be VBD 9598 97 17 located locate VBN 9598 97 18 in in IN 9598 97 19 Wayback Wayback NNP 9598 97 20 was be VBD 9598 97 21 recorded record VBN 9598 97 22 . . . 9598 98 1 All all DT 9598 98 2 links link NNS 9598 98 3 were be VBD 9598 98 4 checked check VBN 9598 98 5 during during IN 9598 98 6 July July NNP 9598 98 7 - - HYPH 9598 98 8 August August NNP 9598 98 9 2016 2016 CD 9598 98 10 . . . 9598 99 1 If if IN 9598 99 2 the the DT 9598 99 3 initial initial JJ 9598 99 4 web web NN 9598 99 5 browser browser NN 9598 99 6 failed fail VBD 9598 99 7 to to TO 9598 99 8 access access VB 9598 99 9 , , , 9598 99 10 a a DT 9598 99 11 second second JJ 9598 99 12 and and CC 9598 99 13 sometimes sometimes RB 9598 99 14 third third JJ 9598 99 15 browser browser NN 9598 99 16 was be VBD 9598 99 17 tried try VBN 9598 99 18 , , , 9598 99 19 using use VBG 9598 99 20 Safari Safari NNP 9598 99 21 , , , 9598 99 22 Chrome Chrome NNP 9598 99 23 , , , 9598 99 24 and and CC 9598 99 25 Internet internet NN 9598 99 26 Explorer Explorer NNP 9598 99 27 ( ( -LRB- 9598 99 28 IE IE NNP 9598 99 29 ) ) -RRB- 9598 99 30 in in IN 9598 99 31 that that DT 9598 99 32 order order NN 9598 99 33 . . . 9598 100 1 Unsuccessful unsuccessful JJ 9598 100 2 attempts attempt NNS 9598 100 3 to to TO 9598 100 4 reach reach VB 9598 100 5 Wayback Wayback NNP 9598 100 6 were be VBD 9598 100 7 rechecked rechecke VBN 9598 100 8 in in IN 9598 100 9 September September NNP 9598 100 10 . . . 9598 101 1 The the DT 9598 101 2 question question NN 9598 101 3 as as IN 9598 101 4 to to IN 9598 101 5 whether whether IN 9598 101 6 , , , 9598 101 7 and and CC 9598 101 8 to to IN 9598 101 9 what what WP 9598 101 10 degree degree NN 9598 101 11 content content NN 9598 101 12 drift drift NN 9598 101 13 had have VBD 9598 101 14 occurred occur VBN 9598 101 15 was be VBD 9598 101 16 assessed assess VBN 9598 101 17 , , , 9598 101 18 and and CC 9598 101 19 is be VBZ 9598 101 20 discussed discuss VBN 9598 101 21 in in IN 9598 101 22 the the DT 9598 101 23 next next JJ 9598 101 24 section section NN 9598 101 25 . . . 9598 102 1 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 9598 102 2 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 9598 102 3 AND and CC 9598 102 4 LIBRARIES library NNS 9598 102 5 | | NNP 9598 102 6 MARCH MARCH NNS 9598 102 7 2017 2017 CD 9598 102 8 21 21 CD 9598 102 9 FINDINGS finding NNS 9598 102 10 AND and CC 9598 102 11 DISCUSSION discussion NN 9598 102 12 Linkrot Linkrot NNP 9598 102 13 Findings Findings NNPS 9598 102 14 Of of IN 9598 102 15 664 664 CD 9598 102 16 ETDs etd NNS 9598 102 17 examined examine VBD 9598 102 18 for for IN 9598 102 19 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 102 20 , , , 9598 102 21 77 77 CD 9598 102 22 % % NN 9598 102 23 of of IN 9598 102 24 links link NNS 9598 102 25 tested test VBN 9598 102 26 returned return VBD 9598 102 27 an an DT 9598 102 28 active active JJ 9598 102 29 http http JJ 9598 102 30 response response NN 9598 102 31 code code NN 9598 102 32 in in IN 9598 102 33 the the DT 9598 102 34 2xx 2xx JJ 9598 102 35 range range NN 9598 102 36 -- -- : 9598 102 37 roughly roughly RB 9598 102 38 three three CD 9598 102 39 - - HYPH 9598 102 40 quarters quarter NNS 9598 102 41 overall overall RB 9598 102 42 . . . 9598 103 1 Numbers number NNS 9598 103 2 of of IN 9598 103 3 links link NNS 9598 103 4 by by IN 9598 103 5 broad broad JJ 9598 103 6 discipline discipline NN 9598 103 7 varied vary VBD 9598 103 8 greatly greatly RB 9598 103 9 , , , 9598 103 10 as as IN 9598 103 11 shown show VBN 9598 103 12 in in IN 9598 103 13 Figure figure NN 9598 103 14 2 2 CD 9598 103 15 ( ( -LRB- 9598 103 16 healthy healthy JJ 9598 103 17 links link NNS 9598 103 18 in in IN 9598 103 19 green green JJ 9598 103 20 , , , 9598 103 21 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 103 22 shown show VBN 9598 103 23 in in IN 9598 103 24 red red NN 9598 103 25 ) ) -RRB- 9598 103 26 . . . 9598 104 1 Linkrot Linkrot NNP 9598 104 2 rates rate NNS 9598 104 3 ranged range VBD 9598 104 4 from from IN 9598 104 5 21 21 CD 9598 104 6 % % NN 9598 104 7 in in IN 9598 104 8 Fine Fine NNP 9598 104 9 Arts Arts NNP 9598 104 10 , , , 9598 104 11 to to IN 9598 104 12 26 26 CD 9598 104 13 % % NN 9598 104 14 in in IN 9598 104 15 Business Business NNP 9598 104 16 , , , 9598 104 17 as as IN 9598 104 18 seen see VBN 9598 104 19 in in IN 9598 104 20 last last JJ 9598 104 21 column column NN 9598 104 22 of of IN 9598 104 23 Table table NN 9598 104 24 3 3 CD 9598 104 25 . . . 9598 105 1 It -PRON- PRP 9598 105 2 should should MD 9598 105 3 be be VB 9598 105 4 noted note VBN 9598 105 5 that that IN 9598 105 6 2xx 2xx JJ 9598 105 7 response response NN 9598 105 8 codes code NNS 9598 105 9 are be VBP 9598 105 10 also also RB 9598 105 11 returned return VBN 9598 105 12 for for IN 9598 105 13 pages page NNS 9598 105 14 that that WDT 9598 105 15 disguise disguise VBP 9598 105 16 themselves -PRON- PRP 9598 105 17 as as IN 9598 105 18 active active JJ 9598 105 19 links link NNS 9598 105 20 . . . 9598 106 1 For for IN 9598 106 2 example example NN 9598 106 3 , , , 9598 106 4 a a DT 9598 106 5 URL url NN 9598 106 6 returns return VBZ 9598 106 7 an an DT 9598 106 8 active active JJ 9598 106 9 status status NN 9598 106 10 code code NN 9598 106 11 when when WRB 9598 106 12 a a DT 9598 106 13 domain domain NN 9598 106 14 has have VBZ 9598 106 15 been be VBN 9598 106 16 parked park VBN 9598 106 17 ( ( -LRB- 9598 106 18 e.g. e.g. RB 9598 107 1 purchased purchase VBN 9598 107 2 to to TO 9598 107 3 reserve reserve VB 9598 107 4 the the DT 9598 107 5 space space NN 9598 107 6 ) ) -RRB- 9598 107 7 , , , 9598 107 8 or or CC 9598 107 9 when when WRB 9598 107 10 a a DT 9598 107 11 customized customize VBN 9598 107 12 404-page 404-page CD 9598 107 13 - - HYPH 9598 107 14 not not RB 9598 107 15 - - HYPH 9598 107 16 found find VBN 9598 107 17 is be VBZ 9598 107 18 encountered encounter VBN 9598 107 19 . . . 9598 108 1 Since since IN 9598 108 2 we -PRON- PRP 9598 108 3 had have VBD 9598 108 4 no no DT 9598 108 5 mechanism mechanism NN 9598 108 6 in in IN 9598 108 7 place place NN 9598 108 8 to to TO 9598 108 9 treat treat VB 9598 108 10 false false JJ 9598 108 11 positives positive NNS 9598 108 12 , , , 9598 108 13 these these DT 9598 108 14 were be VBD 9598 108 15 flagged flag VBN 9598 108 16 during during IN 9598 108 17 the the DT 9598 108 18 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 108 19 phase phase NN 9598 108 20 as as IN 9598 108 21 candidates candidate NNS 9598 108 22 for for IN 9598 108 23 subsequent subsequent JJ 9598 108 24 content content NN 9598 108 25 drift drift NN 9598 108 26 analysis analysis NN 9598 108 27 . . . 9598 109 1 23 23 CD 9598 109 2 % % NN 9598 109 3 ( ( -LRB- 9598 109 4 2,604 2,604 CD 9598 109 5 of of IN 9598 109 6 11,437 11,437 CD 9598 109 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 109 8 of of IN 9598 109 9 all all DT 9598 109 10 links link NNS 9598 109 11 , , , 9598 109 12 returned return VBD 9598 109 13 a a DT 9598 109 14 response response NN 9598 109 15 code code NN 9598 109 16 of of IN 9598 109 17 something something NN 9598 109 18 other other JJ 9598 109 19 than than IN 9598 109 20 in in IN 9598 109 21 the the DT 9598 109 22 2xx 2xx JJ 9598 109 23 - - HYPH 9598 109 24 range range NN 9598 109 25 and and CC 9598 109 26 considered consider VBN 9598 109 27 linkrot linkrot NNS 9598 109 28 -- -- : 9598 109 29 roughly roughly RB 9598 109 30 one one CD 9598 109 31 - - HYPH 9598 109 32 quarter quarter NN 9598 109 33 . . . 9598 110 1 Response response NN 9598 110 2 codes code NNS 9598 110 3 in in IN 9598 110 4 the the DT 9598 110 5 4xx 4xx JJ 9598 110 6 range range NN 9598 110 7 alone alone RB 9598 110 8 , , , 9598 110 9 including include VBG 9598 110 10 404-page 404-page CD 9598 110 11 - - HYPH 9598 110 12 not not RB 9598 110 13 - - HYPH 9598 110 14 found find VBN 9598 110 15 errors error NNS 9598 110 16 , , , 9598 110 17 comprised comprise VBD 9598 110 18 17 17 CD 9598 110 19 % % NN 9598 110 20 ( ( -LRB- 9598 110 21 1,916 1,916 CD 9598 110 22 of of IN 9598 110 23 11,437 11,437 CD 9598 110 24 ) ) -RRB- 9598 110 25 of of IN 9598 110 26 all all DT 9598 110 27 links link NNS 9598 110 28 . . . 9598 111 1 Table table NN 9598 111 2 5 5 CD 9598 111 3 shows show VBZ 9598 111 4 the the DT 9598 111 5 breakdown breakdown NN 9598 111 6 of of IN 9598 111 7 the the DT 9598 111 8 total total JJ 9598 111 9 number number NN 9598 111 10 of of IN 9598 111 11 links link NNS 9598 111 12 that that WDT 9598 111 13 were be VBD 9598 111 14 visited visit VBN 9598 111 15 in in IN 9598 111 16 the the DT 9598 111 17 spring spring NN 9598 111 18 of of IN 9598 111 19 2016 2016 CD 9598 111 20 for for IN 9598 111 21 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 111 22 determination determination NN 9598 111 23 . . . 9598 112 1 HTTP http JJ 9598 112 2 response response NN 9598 112 3 code code NN 9598 112 4 category category NN 9598 112 5 Meaning Meaning NNP 9598 112 6 of of IN 9598 112 7 http http NNP 9598 112 8 response response NN 9598 112 9 code code NN 9598 112 10 * * NFP 9598 112 11 Number number NN 9598 112 12 of of IN 9598 112 13 links link NNS 9598 112 14 Percent percent NN 9598 112 15 of of IN 9598 112 16 total total JJ 9598 112 17 links link NNS 9598 112 18 ( ( -LRB- 9598 112 19 % % NN 9598 112 20 ) ) -RRB- 9598 112 21 0 0 NFP 9598 112 22 Empty empty JJ 9598 112 23 response response NN 9598 112 24 * * NFP 9598 112 25 * * NFP 9598 112 26 507 507 CD 9598 112 27 4 4 CD 9598 112 28 % % NN 9598 112 29 1xx 1xx JJ 9598 112 30 Informational informational JJ 9598 112 31 2 2 CD 9598 112 32 0 0 CD 9598 112 33 % % NN 9598 112 34 2xx 2xx JJ 9598 112 35 Successful successful JJ 9598 112 36 8,834 8,834 CD 9598 112 37 77 77 CD 9598 112 38 % % NN 9598 112 39 3xx 3xx JJ 9598 112 40 Redirection† Redirection† NNP 9598 112 41 102 102 CD 9598 112 42 1 1 CD 9598 112 43 % % NN 9598 112 44 4xx 4xx NNP 9598 112 45 Client Client NNP 9598 112 46 error error NN 9598 112 47 1,916 1,916 CD 9598 112 48 17 17 CD 9598 112 49 % % NN 9598 112 50 5xx 5xx JJ 9598 112 51 Server Server NNP 9598 112 52 error error NN 9598 112 53 76 76 CD 9598 112 54 1 1 CD 9598 112 55 % % NN 9598 112 56 Total Total NNP 9598 112 57 11,437 11,437 CD 9598 112 58 100 100 CD 9598 112 59 % % NN 9598 112 60 Table table NN 9598 112 61 5 5 CD 9598 112 62 . . . 9598 113 1 Breakdown breakdown NN 9598 113 2 of of IN 9598 113 3 HTTP http JJ 9598 113 4 response response NN 9598 113 5 codes code NNS 9598 113 6 received receive VBD 9598 113 7 * * NFP 9598 113 8 We -PRON- PRP 9598 113 9 used use VBD 9598 113 10 http http NNS 9598 113 11 protocol protocol JJ 9598 113 12 definitions definition NNS 9598 113 13 at at IN 9598 113 14 http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616-sec10.html http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616-sec10.html NNS 9598 113 15 * * NFP 9598 113 16 * * NFP 9598 113 17 unofficial unofficial JJ 9598 113 18 http http JJ 9598 113 19 response response NN 9598 113 20 code code NN 9598 113 21 due due IN 9598 113 22 to to IN 9598 113 23 request request NN 9598 113 24 timing timing NN 9598 113 25 out out RP 9598 113 26 † † NN 9598 113 27 failure failure NN 9598 113 28 to to TO 9598 113 29 resolve resolve VB 9598 113 30 after after IN 9598 113 31 50 50 CD 9598 113 32 redirects redirect VBZ 9598 113 33 Http Http NNP 9598 113 34 responses response NNS 9598 113 35 ranged range VBN 9598 113 36 from from IN 9598 113 37 a a DT 9598 113 38 high high JJ 9598 113 39 of of IN 9598 113 40 85 85 CD 9598 113 41 % % NN 9598 113 42 active active NN 9598 113 43 in in IN 9598 113 44 2015 2015 CD 9598 113 45 , , , 9598 113 46 to to IN 9598 113 47 a a DT 9598 113 48 low low NN 9598 113 49 of of IN 9598 113 50 69 69 CD 9598 113 51 % % NN 9598 113 52 active active JJ 9598 113 53 in in IN 9598 113 54 2011 2011 CD 9598 113 55 , , , 9598 113 56 the the DT 9598 113 57 oldest old JJS 9598 113 58 publication publication NN 9598 113 59 year year NN 9598 113 60 . . . 9598 114 1 To to TO 9598 114 2 put put VB 9598 114 3 it -PRON- PRP 9598 114 4 differently differently RB 9598 114 5 , , , 9598 114 6 the the DT 9598 114 7 most most RBS 9598 114 8 recent recent JJ 9598 114 9 year year NN 9598 114 10 exhibited exhibit VBD 9598 114 11 a a DT 9598 114 12 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 114 13 rate rate NN 9598 114 14 of of IN 9598 114 15 15 15 CD 9598 114 16 % % NN 9598 114 17 . . . 9598 115 1 Consistent consistent JJ 9598 115 2 with with IN 9598 115 3 other other JJ 9598 115 4 studies study NNS 9598 115 5 , , , 9598 115 6 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 115 7 manifests manifest VBZ 9598 115 8 itself -PRON- PRP 9598 115 9 quickly quickly RB 9598 115 10 after after IN 9598 115 11 publication publication NN 9598 115 12 and and CC 9598 115 13 increases increase NNS 9598 115 14 over over IN 9598 115 15 time time NN 9598 115 16 , , , 9598 115 17 as as IN 9598 115 18 indicated indicate VBN 9598 115 19 by by IN 9598 115 20 percentages percentage NNS 9598 115 21 shown show VBN 9598 115 22 in in IN 9598 115 23 Figure Figure NNP 9598 115 24 2 2 CD 9598 115 25 . . . 9598 116 1 Content Content NNP 9598 116 2 Drift Drift NNP 9598 116 3 Findings Findings NNPS 9598 116 4 Of of IN 9598 116 5 the the DT 9598 116 6 990 990 CD 9598 116 7 links link NNS 9598 116 8 visited visit VBN 9598 116 9 to to TO 9598 116 10 check check VB 9598 116 11 for for IN 9598 116 12 the the DT 9598 116 13 presence presence NN 9598 116 14 of of IN 9598 116 15 content content NN 9598 116 16 drift drift NN 9598 116 17 , , , 9598 116 18 764 764 CD 9598 116 19 ( ( -LRB- 9598 116 20 400 400 CD 9598 116 21 + + SYM 9598 116 22 364 364 CD 9598 116 23 ) ) -RRB- 9598 116 24 , , , 9598 116 25 or or CC 9598 116 26 77 77 CD 9598 116 27 % % NN 9598 116 28 , , , 9598 116 29 had have VBD 9598 116 30 a a DT 9598 116 31 Wayback Wayback NNP 9598 116 32 memento memento NN 9598 116 33 compared compare VBN 9598 116 34 226 226 CD 9598 116 35 ( ( -LRB- 9598 116 36 92 92 CD 9598 116 37 + + SYM 9598 116 38 134 134 CD 9598 116 39 ) ) -RRB- 9598 116 40 , , , 9598 116 41 or or CC 9598 116 42 23 23 CD 9598 116 43 % % NN 9598 116 44 , , , 9598 116 45 which which WDT 9598 116 46 did do VBD 9598 116 47 not not RB 9598 116 48 . . . 9598 117 1 Slightly slightly RB 9598 117 2 more more JJR 9598 117 3 than than IN 9598 117 4 half half NN 9598 117 5 of of IN 9598 117 6 links link NNS 9598 117 7 with with IN 9598 117 8 mementos memento NNS 9598 117 9 , , , 9598 117 10 52 52 CD 9598 117 11 % % NN 9598 117 12 ( ( -LRB- 9598 117 13 400 400 CD 9598 117 14 of of IN 9598 117 15 764 764 CD 9598 117 16 ) ) -RRB- 9598 117 17 , , , 9598 117 18 demonstrated demonstrate VBD 9598 117 19 some some DT 9598 117 20 level level NN 9598 117 21 of of IN 9598 117 22 content content NN 9598 117 23 drift drift NN 9598 117 24 when when WRB 9598 117 25 the the DT 9598 117 26 A A NNP 9598 117 27 CASE case NN 9598 117 28 STUDY STUDY NNP 9598 117 29 OF of IN 9598 117 30 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9598 117 31 THESES thesis NNS 9598 117 32 AND and CC 9598 117 33 DISSERTATIONS dissertation NNS 9598 117 34 ( ( -LRB- 9598 117 35 ETDS ETDS NNP 9598 117 36 ) ) -RRB- 9598 117 37 IN in IN 9598 117 38 AN an DT 9598 117 39 ACADEMIC ACADEMIC NNP 9598 117 40 LIBRARY LIBRARY NNP 9598 117 41 | | NNS 9598 117 42 MASSICOTTE MASSICOTTE NNP 9598 117 43 AND and CC 9598 117 44 BOTTER BOTTER NNP 9598 117 45 | | NNP 9598 117 46 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 NNP 9598 117 47 22 22 CD 9598 117 48 memento memento NNS 9598 117 49 was be VBD 9598 117 50 compared compare VBN 9598 117 51 to to IN 9598 117 52 the the DT 9598 117 53 current current JJ 9598 117 54 active active JJ 9598 117 55 link link NN 9598 117 56 , , , 9598 117 57 while while IN 9598 117 58 48 48 CD 9598 117 59 % % NN 9598 117 60 ( ( -LRB- 9598 117 61 364 364 CD 9598 117 62 of of IN 9598 117 63 764 764 CD 9598 117 64 ) ) -RRB- 9598 117 65 with with IN 9598 117 66 mementos memento NNS 9598 117 67 did do VBD 9598 117 68 not not RB 9598 117 69 exhibit exhibit VB 9598 117 70 content content NN 9598 117 71 drift drift NN 9598 117 72 . . . 9598 118 1 The the DT 9598 118 2 presence presence NN 9598 118 3 of of IN 9598 118 4 content content NN 9598 118 5 drift drift NN 9598 118 6 by by IN 9598 118 7 discipline discipline NN 9598 118 8 , , , 9598 118 9 with with IN 9598 118 10 / / SYM 9598 118 11 without without IN 9598 118 12 mementos memento NNS 9598 118 13 showing show VBG 9598 118 14 numbers number NNS 9598 118 15 of of IN 9598 118 16 links link NNS 9598 118 17 tested test VBN 9598 118 18 , , , 9598 118 19 appears appear VBZ 9598 118 20 in in IN 9598 118 21 Table Table NNP 9598 118 22 6 6 CD 9598 118 23 . . . 9598 119 1 Discipline discipline NN 9598 119 2 Number number NN 9598 119 3 of of IN 9598 119 4 links link NNS 9598 119 5 tested test VBN 9598 119 6 Content Content NNP 9598 119 7 Drift Drift NNP 9598 119 8 detected detect VBD 9598 119 9 No No NNP 9598 119 10 Content Content NNP 9598 119 11 Drift Drift NNP 9598 119 12 Memento Memento NNP 9598 119 13 found find VBD 9598 119 14 Memento Memento NNP 9598 119 15 not not RB 9598 119 16 found find VBD 9598 119 17 Total Total NNP 9598 119 18 Memento Memento NNP 9598 119 19 found find VBD 9598 119 20 Memento Memento NNP 9598 119 21 not not RB 9598 119 22 found find VBD 9598 119 23 Total total JJ 9598 119 24 Arts art NNS 9598 119 25 668 668 CD 9598 119 26 261 261 CD 9598 119 27 60 60 CD 9598 119 28 321 321 CD 9598 119 29 254 254 CD 9598 119 30 93 93 CD 9598 119 31 347 347 CD 9598 119 32 Business business NN 9598 119 33 12 12 CD 9598 119 34 5 5 CD 9598 119 35 0 0 CD 9598 119 36 5 5 CD 9598 119 37 4 4 CD 9598 119 38 3 3 CD 9598 119 39 7 7 CD 9598 119 40 Engineering Engineering NNP 9598 119 41 154 154 CD 9598 119 42 74 74 CD 9598 119 43 10 10 CD 9598 119 44 84 84 CD 9598 119 45 55 55 CD 9598 119 46 15 15 CD 9598 119 47 70 70 CD 9598 119 48 Fine Fine NNP 9598 119 49 Arts Arts NNP 9598 119 50 136 136 CD 9598 119 51 55 55 CD 9598 119 52 22 22 CD 9598 119 53 77 77 CD 9598 119 54 38 38 CD 9598 119 55 21 21 CD 9598 119 56 59 59 CD 9598 119 57 Science science NN 9598 119 58 20 20 CD 9598 119 59 5 5 CD 9598 119 60 0 0 CD 9598 119 61 5 5 CD 9598 119 62 13 13 CD 9598 119 63 2 2 CD 9598 119 64 15 15 CD 9598 119 65 Total total JJ 9598 119 66 990 990 CD 9598 119 67 400 400 CD 9598 119 68 92 92 CD 9598 119 69 492 492 CD 9598 119 70 364 364 CD 9598 119 71 134 134 CD 9598 119 72 498 498 CD 9598 119 73 Table table NN 9598 119 74 6 6 CD 9598 119 75 . . . 9598 120 1 Presence Presence NNP 9598 120 2 of of IN 9598 120 3 Content Content NNP 9598 120 4 Drift Drift NNP 9598 120 5 by by IN 9598 120 6 Discipline Discipline NNP 9598 120 7 , , , 9598 120 8 with with IN 9598 120 9 / / SYM 9598 120 10 without without IN 9598 120 11 mementos memento NNS 9598 120 12 For for IN 9598 120 13 links link NNS 9598 120 14 that that WDT 9598 120 15 had have VBD 9598 120 16 no no DT 9598 120 17 memento memento NN 9598 120 18 in in IN 9598 120 19 Wayback Wayback NNP 9598 120 20 , , , 9598 120 21 content content NN 9598 120 22 drift drift NN 9598 120 23 assessment assessment NN 9598 120 24 was be VBD 9598 120 25 based base VBN 9598 120 26 on on IN 9598 120 27 the the DT 9598 120 28 presence presence NN 9598 120 29 of of IN 9598 120 30 an an DT 9598 120 31 observable observable JJ 9598 120 32 date date NN 9598 120 33 in in IN 9598 120 34 the the DT 9598 120 35 current current JJ 9598 120 36 active active JJ 9598 120 37 link link NN 9598 120 38 , , , 9598 120 39 including include VBG 9598 120 40 copyright copyright NN 9598 120 41 , , , 9598 120 42 and/or and/or CC 9598 120 43 other other JJ 9598 120 44 details detail NNS 9598 120 45 which which WDT 9598 120 46 positively positively RB 9598 120 47 correlated correlate VBD 9598 120 48 against against IN 9598 120 49 our -PRON- PRP$ 9598 120 50 extracted extract VBN 9598 120 51 snippet snippet NNP 9598 120 52 information information NN 9598 120 53 . . . 9598 121 1 For for IN 9598 121 2 example example NN 9598 121 3 , , , 9598 121 4 some some DT 9598 121 5 links link NNS 9598 121 6 retrieved retrieve VBD 9598 121 7 a a DT 9598 121 8 .pdf .pdf NN 9598 121 9 or or CC 9598 121 10 other other JJ 9598 121 11 static static JJ 9598 121 12 file file NN 9598 121 13 which which WDT 9598 121 14 correlated correlate VBD 9598 121 15 with with IN 9598 121 16 the the DT 9598 121 17 snippet snippet NNS 9598 121 18 , , , 9598 121 19 there there EX 9598 121 20 being be VBG 9598 121 21 no no DT 9598 121 22 reason reason NN 9598 121 23 to to TO 9598 121 24 conclude conclude VB 9598 121 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 9598 121 26 content content NN 9598 121 27 had have VBD 9598 121 28 undergone undergo VBN 9598 121 29 change change NN 9598 121 30 since since IN 9598 121 31 publication publication NN 9598 121 32 , , , 9598 121 33 despite despite IN 9598 121 34 the the DT 9598 121 35 lack lack NN 9598 121 36 of of IN 9598 121 37 a a DT 9598 121 38 memento memento NN 9598 121 39 . . . 9598 122 1 Snippets snippet NNS 9598 122 2 were be VBD 9598 122 3 also also RB 9598 122 4 used use VBN 9598 122 5 in in IN 9598 122 6 cases case NNS 9598 122 7 where where WRB 9598 122 8 a a DT 9598 122 9 robots.txt robots.txt CD 9598 122 10 file file NN 9598 122 11 at at IN 9598 122 12 the the DT 9598 122 13 target target NN 9598 122 14 URL URL NNP 9598 122 15 had have VBD 9598 122 16 prevented prevent VBN 9598 122 17 Wayback Wayback NNP 9598 122 18 from from IN 9598 122 19 creating create VBG 9598 122 20 a a DT 9598 122 21 memento memento NN 9598 122 22 . . . 9598 123 1 Occasional occasional JJ 9598 123 2 examination examination NN 9598 123 3 of of IN 9598 123 4 the the DT 9598 123 5 dissertation dissertation NN 9598 123 6 text text NN 9598 123 7 was be VBD 9598 123 8 conducted conduct VBN 9598 123 9 to to TO 9598 123 10 validate validate VB 9598 123 11 information information NN 9598 123 12 extracted extract VBN 9598 123 13 in in IN 9598 123 14 the the DT 9598 123 15 snippet snippet NN 9598 123 16 . . . 9598 124 1 The the DT 9598 124 2 23 23 CD 9598 124 3 % % NN 9598 124 4 ( ( -LRB- 9598 124 5 226 226 CD 9598 124 6 ) ) -RRB- 9598 124 7 which which WDT 9598 124 8 lacked lack VBD 9598 124 9 mementos memento NNS 9598 124 10 remain remain VBP 9598 124 11 at at IN 9598 124 12 significant significant JJ 9598 124 13 risk risk NN 9598 124 14 and and CC 9598 124 15 will will MD 9598 124 16 fall fall VB 9598 124 17 prey prey NN 9598 124 18 to to IN 9598 124 19 further further JJ 9598 124 20 drift drift NN 9598 124 21 as as IN 9598 124 22 time time NN 9598 124 23 passes pass VBZ 9598 124 24 . . . 9598 125 1 As as IN 9598 125 2 seen see VBN 9598 125 3 in in IN 9598 125 4 Table table NN 9598 125 5 7 7 CD 9598 125 6 , , , 9598 125 7 of of IN 9598 125 8 492 492 CD 9598 125 9 URLs url NNS 9598 125 10 manifesting manifest VBG 9598 125 11 content content NN 9598 125 12 drift drift NN 9598 125 13 , , , 9598 125 14 11 11 CD 9598 125 15 % % NN 9598 125 16 ( ( -LRB- 9598 125 17 54 54 CD 9598 125 18 of of IN 9598 125 19 492 492 CD 9598 125 20 ) ) -RRB- 9598 125 21 were be VBD 9598 125 22 completely completely RB 9598 125 23 lost lose VBN 9598 125 24 , , , 9598 125 25 linking link VBG 9598 125 26 to to IN 9598 125 27 web web NN 9598 125 28 domains domain NNS 9598 125 29 that that WDT 9598 125 30 had have VBD 9598 125 31 been be VBN 9598 125 32 sold sell VBN 9598 125 33 or or CC 9598 125 34 were be VBD 9598 125 35 currently currently RB 9598 125 36 up up IN 9598 125 37 for for IN 9598 125 38 sale sale NN 9598 125 39 , , , 9598 125 40 and and CC 9598 125 41 webpages webpage NNS 9598 125 42 replaced replace VBD 9598 125 43 or or CC 9598 125 44 removed remove VBN 9598 125 45 . . . 9598 126 1 9 9 CD 9598 126 2 % % NN 9598 126 3 ( ( -LRB- 9598 126 4 42 42 CD 9598 126 5 of of IN 9598 126 6 492 492 CD 9598 126 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 126 8 of of IN 9598 126 9 web web NN 9598 126 10 pages page NNS 9598 126 11 exhibited exhibit VBD 9598 126 12 major major JJ 9598 126 13 change change NN 9598 126 14 such such JJ 9598 126 15 that that IN 9598 126 16 there there EX 9598 126 17 was be VBD 9598 126 18 little little JJ 9598 126 19 correlation correlation NN 9598 126 20 with with IN 9598 126 21 snippets snippet NNS 9598 126 22 , , , 9598 126 23 or or CC 9598 126 24 where where WRB 9598 126 25 website website NN 9598 126 26 overhauls overhaul NNS 9598 126 27 made make VBD 9598 126 28 assessment assessment NN 9598 126 29 difficult difficult JJ 9598 126 30 , , , 9598 126 31 but but CC 9598 126 32 not not RB 9598 126 33 impossible impossible JJ 9598 126 34 . . . 9598 127 1 36 36 CD 9598 127 2 % % NN 9598 127 3 ( ( -LRB- 9598 127 4 179 179 CD 9598 127 5 of of IN 9598 127 6 492 492 CD 9598 127 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 127 8 web web NN 9598 127 9 links link NNS 9598 127 10 exhibited exhibit VBD 9598 127 11 minor minor JJ 9598 127 12 drift drift NN 9598 127 13 , , , 9598 127 14 primarily primarily RB 9598 127 15 pages page NNS 9598 127 16 that that WDT 9598 127 17 differed differ VBD 9598 127 18 somewhat somewhat RB 9598 127 19 from from IN 9598 127 20 a a DT 9598 127 21 memento memento NN 9598 127 22 in in IN 9598 127 23 visual visual JJ 9598 127 24 appearance appearance NN 9598 127 25 , , , 9598 127 26 such such JJ 9598 127 27 as as IN 9598 127 28 header header NN 9598 127 29 and and CC 9598 127 30 footer footer NN 9598 127 31 differences difference NNS 9598 127 32 , , , 9598 127 33 changes change NNS 9598 127 34 in in IN 9598 127 35 background background NN 9598 127 36 theme theme NN 9598 127 37 or or CC 9598 127 38 style style NN 9598 127 39 , , , 9598 127 40 or or CC 9598 127 41 changes change NNS 9598 127 42 in in IN 9598 127 43 navigation navigation NN 9598 127 44 or or CC 9598 127 45 search search NN 9598 127 46 functionality functionality NN 9598 127 47 which which WDT 9598 127 48 did do VBD 9598 127 49 not not RB 9598 127 50 represent represent VB 9598 127 51 a a DT 9598 127 52 high high JJ 9598 127 53 degree degree NN 9598 127 54 of of IN 9598 127 55 impairment impairment NN 9598 127 56 . . . 9598 128 1 7 7 CD 9598 128 2 % % NN 9598 128 3 ( ( -LRB- 9598 128 4 34 34 CD 9598 128 5 of of IN 9598 128 6 492 492 CD 9598 128 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 128 8 linked link VBN 9598 128 9 to to IN 9598 128 10 continually continually RB 9598 128 11 updating update VBG 9598 128 12 websites website NNS 9598 128 13 , , , 9598 128 14 such such JJ 9598 128 15 as as IN 9598 128 16 Wikipedia Wikipedia NNP 9598 128 17 and and CC 9598 128 18 news news NN 9598 128 19 organizations organization NNS 9598 128 20 , , , 9598 128 21 and and CC 9598 128 22 7 7 CD 9598 128 23 % % NN 9598 128 24 ( ( -LRB- 9598 128 25 35 35 CD 9598 128 26 of of IN 9598 128 27 492 492 CD 9598 128 28 ) ) -RRB- 9598 128 29 were be VBD 9598 128 30 customized customize VBN 9598 128 31 404-page 404-page CD 9598 128 32 - - HYPH 9598 128 33 not- not- NN 9598 128 34 found find VBN 9598 128 35 , , , 9598 128 36 distinctive distinctive JJ 9598 128 37 enough enough RB 9598 128 38 to to TO 9598 128 39 warrant warrant VB 9598 128 40 separate separate JJ 9598 128 41 categories category NNS 9598 128 42 . . . 9598 129 1 A a DT 9598 129 2 full full JJ 9598 129 3 30 30 CD 9598 129 4 % % NN 9598 129 5 ( ( -LRB- 9598 129 6 148 148 CD 9598 129 7 of of IN 9598 129 8 492 492 CD 9598 129 9 ) ) -RRB- 9598 129 10 exhibited exhibit VBD 9598 129 11 a a DT 9598 129 12 multiplicity multiplicity NN 9598 129 13 of of IN 9598 129 14 changes change NNS 9598 129 15 of of IN 9598 129 16 uncertain uncertain JJ 9598 129 17 nature nature NN 9598 129 18 which which WDT 9598 129 19 we -PRON- PRP 9598 129 20 grouped group VBD 9598 129 21 together together RB 9598 129 22 , , , 9598 129 23 such such JJ 9598 129 24 as as IN 9598 129 25 pages page NNS 9598 129 26 where where WRB 9598 129 27 graphic graphic JJ 9598 129 28 or or CC 9598 129 29 audio audio JJ 9598 129 30 components component NNS 9598 129 31 had have VBD 9598 129 32 been be VBN 9598 129 33 removed remove VBN 9598 129 34 or or CC 9598 129 35 could could MD 9598 129 36 not not RB 9598 129 37 be be VB 9598 129 38 retrieved retrieve VBN 9598 129 39 , , , 9598 129 40 broken broken JJ 9598 129 41 javascript javascript NN 9598 129 42 that that WDT 9598 129 43 impeded impede VBD 9598 129 44 access access NN 9598 129 45 , , , 9598 129 46 browser browser NN 9598 129 47 failure failure NN 9598 129 48 , , , 9598 129 49 mementos memento NNS 9598 129 50 not not RB 9598 129 51 accessible accessible JJ 9598 129 52 after after IN 9598 129 53 repeated repeat VBN 9598 129 54 attempts attempt NNS 9598 129 55 -- -- : 9598 129 56 indicative indicative JJ 9598 129 57 of of IN 9598 129 58 a a DT 9598 129 59 range range NN 9598 129 60 of of IN 9598 129 61 issues issue NNS 9598 129 62 affecting affect VBG 9598 129 63 the the DT 9598 129 64 quality quality NN 9598 129 65 of of IN 9598 129 66 web web NN 9598 129 67 archives archive NNS 9598 129 68 and and CC 9598 129 69 hence hence RB 9598 129 70 preservation.38 preservation.38 NNP 9598 129 71 The the DT 9598 129 72 types type NNS 9598 129 73 of of IN 9598 129 74 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 9598 129 75 TECHNOLOGY TECHNOLOGY NNP 9598 129 76 AND and CC 9598 129 77 LIBRARIES library NNS 9598 129 78 | | NNP 9598 129 79 MARCH MARCH NNS 9598 129 80 2017 2017 CD 9598 129 81 23 23 CD 9598 129 82 content content NN 9598 129 83 drift drift NN 9598 129 84 encountered encounter VBD 9598 129 85 , , , 9598 129 86 broken break VBN 9598 129 87 down down RP 9598 129 88 by by IN 9598 129 89 broad broad JJ 9598 129 90 discipline discipline NN 9598 129 91 and and CC 9598 129 92 numbers number NNS 9598 129 93 of of IN 9598 129 94 links link NNS 9598 129 95 , , , 9598 129 96 and and CC 9598 129 97 percentage percentage NN 9598 129 98 , , , 9598 129 99 is be VBZ 9598 129 100 shown show VBN 9598 129 101 in in IN 9598 129 102 Table Table NNP 9598 129 103 7 7 CD 9598 129 104 . . . 9598 130 1 Type type NN 9598 130 2 of of IN 9598 130 3 content content NN 9598 130 4 drift drift NN 9598 130 5 Arts Arts NNP 9598 130 6 Business Business NNP 9598 130 7 Engineeri Engineeri NNP 9598 130 8 ng ng UH 9598 130 9 Fine Fine NNP 9598 130 10 Arts Arts NNP 9598 130 11 Science Science NNP 9598 130 12 Total total JJ 9598 130 13 % % NN 9598 130 14 of of IN 9598 130 15 type type NN 9598 130 16 Lost lose VBN 9598 130 17 45 45 CD 9598 130 18 0 0 CD 9598 130 19 3 3 CD 9598 130 20 6 6 CD 9598 130 21 0 0 CD 9598 130 22 54 54 CD 9598 130 23 11 11 CD 9598 130 24 % % NN 9598 130 25 Major major JJ 9598 130 26 but but CC 9598 130 27 findable findable JJ 9598 130 28 22 22 CD 9598 130 29 0 0 CD 9598 130 30 9 9 CD 9598 130 31 9 9 CD 9598 130 32 2 2 CD 9598 130 33 42 42 CD 9598 130 34 9 9 CD 9598 130 35 % % NN 9598 130 36 Minor minor NN 9598 130 37 – – : 9598 130 38 redesigned redesign VBN 9598 130 39 but but CC 9598 130 40 recognizable recognizable JJ 9598 130 41 128 128 CD 9598 130 42 2 2 CD 9598 130 43 30 30 CD 9598 130 44 17 17 CD 9598 130 45 2 2 CD 9598 130 46 179 179 CD 9598 130 47 36 36 CD 9598 130 48 % % NN 9598 130 49 Ongoing ongoing JJ 9598 130 50 updating update VBG 9598 130 51 website website NN 9598 130 52 25 25 CD 9598 130 53 3 3 CD 9598 130 54 5 5 CD 9598 130 55 0 0 CD 9598 130 56 1 1 CD 9598 130 57 34 34 CD 9598 130 58 7 7 CD 9598 130 59 % % NN 9598 130 60 Custom Custom NNP 9598 130 61 404 404 CD 9598 130 62 23 23 CD 9598 130 63 0 0 CD 9598 130 64 4 4 CD 9598 130 65 8 8 CD 9598 130 66 0 0 CD 9598 130 67 35 35 CD 9598 130 68 7 7 CD 9598 130 69 % % NN 9598 130 70 Other other JJ 9598 130 71 78 78 CD 9598 130 72 0 0 CD 9598 130 73 33 33 CD 9598 130 74 37 37 CD 9598 130 75 0 0 CD 9598 130 76 148 148 CD 9598 130 77 30 30 CD 9598 130 78 % % NN 9598 130 79 Total total JJ 9598 130 80 321 321 CD 9598 130 81 5 5 CD 9598 130 82 84 84 CD 9598 130 83 77 77 CD 9598 130 84 5 5 CD 9598 130 85 492 492 CD 9598 130 86 100 100 CD 9598 130 87 % % NN 9598 130 88 Table table NN 9598 130 89 7 7 CD 9598 130 90 . . . 9598 131 1 Types type NNS 9598 131 2 of of IN 9598 131 3 content content NN 9598 131 4 drift drift NN 9598 131 5 encountered encounter VBN 9598 131 6 , , , 9598 131 7 number number NN 9598 131 8 of of IN 9598 131 9 links link NNS 9598 131 10 by by IN 9598 131 11 broad broad JJ 9598 131 12 discipline discipline NN 9598 131 13 Though though IN 9598 131 14 difficulties difficulty NNS 9598 131 15 encountered encounter VBN 9598 131 16 during during IN 9598 131 17 content content NN 9598 131 18 drift drift NN 9598 131 19 assessment assessment NN 9598 131 20 made make VBD 9598 131 21 further further JJ 9598 131 22 extrapolation extrapolation NN 9598 131 23 problematic problematic NN 9598 131 24 , , , 9598 131 25 the the DT 9598 131 26 presence presence NN 9598 131 27 of of IN 9598 131 28 reference reference NN 9598 131 29 rot rot NNP 9598 131 30 was be VBD 9598 131 31 confirmed confirm VBN 9598 131 32 . . . 9598 132 1 Our -PRON- PRP$ 9598 132 2 10 10 CD 9598 132 3 % % NN 9598 132 4 stratified stratify VBD 9598 132 5 random random JJ 9598 132 6 sample sample NN 9598 132 7 examined examine VBD 9598 132 8 990 990 CD 9598 132 9 active active JJ 9598 132 10 links link NNS 9598 132 11 , , , 9598 132 12 finding find VBG 9598 132 13 that that DT 9598 132 14 roughly roughly RB 9598 132 15 half half NN 9598 132 16 ( ( -LRB- 9598 132 17 492 492 CD 9598 132 18 of of IN 9598 132 19 990 990 CD 9598 132 20 ) ) -RRB- 9598 132 21 manifested manifest VBD 9598 132 22 some some DT 9598 132 23 degree degree NN 9598 132 24 of of IN 9598 132 25 content content NN 9598 132 26 drift drift NN 9598 132 27 . . . 9598 133 1 For for IN 9598 133 2 364 364 CD 9598 133 3 links link NNS 9598 133 4 , , , 9598 133 5 or or CC 9598 133 6 36 36 CD 9598 133 7 % % NN 9598 133 8 overall overall NN 9598 133 9 , , , 9598 133 10 a a DT 9598 133 11 benchmark benchmark NN 9598 133 12 memento memento NN 9598 133 13 was be VBD 9598 133 14 found find VBN 9598 133 15 and and CC 9598 133 16 no no DT 9598 133 17 content content JJ 9598 133 18 drift drift NN 9598 133 19 detected detect VBD 9598 133 20 . . . 9598 134 1 Although although IN 9598 134 2 many many JJ 9598 134 3 content content NN 9598 134 4 drift drift NN 9598 134 5 changes change NNS 9598 134 6 can can MD 9598 134 7 arguably arguably RB 9598 134 8 be be VB 9598 134 9 characterized characterize VBN 9598 134 10 as as IN 9598 134 11 minor minor JJ 9598 134 12 , , , 9598 134 13 it -PRON- PRP 9598 134 14 is be VBZ 9598 134 15 not not RB 9598 134 16 possible possible JJ 9598 134 17 to to TO 9598 134 18 ascertain ascertain VB 9598 134 19 where where WRB 9598 134 20 the the DT 9598 134 21 content content NN 9598 134 22 drift drift NN 9598 134 23 scale scale NN 9598 134 24 tips tip NNS 9598 134 25 irremediably irremediably RB 9598 134 26 for for IN 9598 134 27 any any DT 9598 134 28 particular particular JJ 9598 134 29 reader reader NN 9598 134 30 . . . 9598 135 1 What what WP 9598 135 2 can can MD 9598 135 3 be be VB 9598 135 4 said say VBN 9598 135 5 with with IN 9598 135 6 certainty certainty NN 9598 135 7 is be VBZ 9598 135 8 that that IN 9598 135 9 11 11 CD 9598 135 10 % % NN 9598 135 11 of of IN 9598 135 12 active active JJ 9598 135 13 links link NNS 9598 135 14 which which WDT 9598 135 15 did do VBD 9598 135 16 not not RB 9598 135 17 exhibit exhibit VB 9598 135 18 linkrot linkrot NNS 9598 135 19 , , , 9598 135 20 and and CC 9598 135 21 were be VBD 9598 135 22 quite quite RB 9598 135 23 live live JJ 9598 135 24 and and CC 9598 135 25 accessible accessible JJ 9598 135 26 , , , 9598 135 27 fell fall VBD 9598 135 28 into into IN 9598 135 29 a a DT 9598 135 30 small small JJ 9598 135 31 but but CC 9598 135 32 unsettling unsettling JJ 9598 135 33 group group NN 9598 135 34 where where WRB 9598 135 35 the the DT 9598 135 36 context context NN 9598 135 37 of of IN 9598 135 38 the the DT 9598 135 39 cited cite VBN 9598 135 40 web web NN 9598 135 41 source source NN 9598 135 42 is be VBZ 9598 135 43 irrevocably irrevocably RB 9598 135 44 lost lose VBN 9598 135 45 . . . 9598 136 1 Of of IN 9598 136 2 the the DT 9598 136 3 498 498 CD 9598 136 4 links link NNS 9598 136 5 which which WDT 9598 136 6 did do VBD 9598 136 7 not not RB 9598 136 8 exhibit exhibit VB 9598 136 9 any any DT 9598 136 10 evidence evidence NN 9598 136 11 of of IN 9598 136 12 content content NN 9598 136 13 drift drift NN 9598 136 14 , , , 9598 136 15 134 134 CD 9598 136 16 , , , 9598 136 17 approximately approximately RB 9598 136 18 one one CD 9598 136 19 - - HYPH 9598 136 20 third third NN 9598 136 21 , , , 9598 136 22 have have VBP 9598 136 23 no no DT 9598 136 24 memento memento NN 9598 136 25 archived archive VBN 9598 136 26 and and CC 9598 136 27 continue continue VB 9598 136 28 to to TO 9598 136 29 remain remain VB 9598 136 30 at at IN 9598 136 31 high high JJ 9598 136 32 risk risk NN 9598 136 33 . . . 9598 137 1 A a DT 9598 137 2 focused focused JJ 9598 137 3 and and CC 9598 137 4 deeper deep JJR 9598 137 5 analysis analysis NN 9598 137 6 of of IN 9598 137 7 active active JJ 9598 137 8 links link NNS 9598 137 9 which which WDT 9598 137 10 might may MD 9598 137 11 lead lead VB 9598 137 12 to to IN 9598 137 13 a a DT 9598 137 14 typology typology NN 9598 137 15 of of IN 9598 137 16 content content NN 9598 137 17 drift drift NN 9598 137 18 types type NNS 9598 137 19 would would MD 9598 137 20 be be VB 9598 137 21 a a DT 9598 137 22 possible possible JJ 9598 137 23 area area NN 9598 137 24 of of IN 9598 137 25 future future JJ 9598 137 26 study study NN 9598 137 27 , , , 9598 137 28 though though IN 9598 137 29 even even RB 9598 137 30 the the DT 9598 137 31 well well RB 9598 137 32 - - HYPH 9598 137 33 resourced resource VBN 9598 137 34 study study NN 9598 137 35 by by IN 9598 137 36 Jones Jones NNP 9598 137 37 et et NNP 9598 137 38 al al NNP 9598 137 39 . . . 9598 138 1 which which WDT 9598 138 2 utilized utilize VBD 9598 138 3 a a DT 9598 138 4 strict strict JJ 9598 138 5 " " `` 9598 138 6 ground ground NN 9598 138 7 truth truth NN 9598 138 8 " " '' 9598 138 9 for for IN 9598 138 10 comparing compare VBG 9598 138 11 textual textual JJ 9598 138 12 mementos memento NNS 9598 138 13 over over IN 9598 138 14 time time NN 9598 138 15 , , , 9598 138 16 points point VBZ 9598 138 17 out out RP 9598 138 18 that that IN 9598 138 19 classifying classify VBG 9598 138 20 links link NNS 9598 138 21 would would MD 9598 138 22 certainly certainly RB 9598 138 23 be be VB 9598 138 24 challenging.39 challenging.39 NNP 9598 138 25 A a DT 9598 138 26 larger large JJR 9598 138 27 sample sample NN 9598 138 28 size size NN 9598 138 29 might may MD 9598 138 30 also also RB 9598 138 31 allow allow VB 9598 138 32 closer close JJR 9598 138 33 analysis analysis NN 9598 138 34 of of IN 9598 138 35 disciplinary disciplinary JJ 9598 138 36 differences difference NNS 9598 138 37 , , , 9598 138 38 which which WDT 9598 138 39 may may MD 9598 138 40 lead lead VB 9598 138 41 to to IN 9598 138 42 a a DT 9598 138 43 better well JJR 9598 138 44 understanding understanding NN 9598 138 45 of of IN 9598 138 46 these these DT 9598 138 47 types type NNS 9598 138 48 of of IN 9598 138 49 content content NN 9598 138 50 drift drift NN 9598 138 51 variations variation NNS 9598 138 52 . . . 9598 139 1 CONCLUSION CONCLUSION NNP 9598 139 2 Reference Reference NNP 9598 139 3 rot rot VBP 9598 139 4 in in IN 9598 139 5 the the DT 9598 139 6 form form NN 9598 139 7 of of IN 9598 139 8 linkrot linkrot NNP 9598 139 9 and and CC 9598 139 10 content content NN 9598 139 11 drift drift NN 9598 139 12 were be VBD 9598 139 13 observed observe VBN 9598 139 14 in in IN 9598 139 15 ETDs ETDs NNP 9598 139 16 in in IN 9598 139 17 Spectrum Spectrum NNP 9598 139 18 , , , 9598 139 19 our -PRON- PRP$ 9598 139 20 institutional institutional JJ 9598 139 21 repository repository NN 9598 139 22 , , , 9598 139 23 and and CC 9598 139 24 this this DT 9598 139 25 confirmation confirmation NN 9598 139 26 should should MD 9598 139 27 give give VB 9598 139 28 pause pause NN 9598 139 29 for for IN 9598 139 30 those those DT 9598 139 31 charged charge VBN 9598 139 32 with with IN 9598 139 33 A a DT 9598 139 34 CASE case NN 9598 139 35 STUDY STUDY NNP 9598 139 36 OF of IN 9598 139 37 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9598 139 38 THESES thesis NNS 9598 139 39 AND and CC 9598 139 40 DISSERTATIONS dissertation NNS 9598 139 41 ( ( -LRB- 9598 139 42 ETDS ETDS NNP 9598 139 43 ) ) -RRB- 9598 139 44 IN in IN 9598 139 45 AN an DT 9598 139 46 ACADEMIC ACADEMIC NNP 9598 139 47 LIBRARY LIBRARY NNP 9598 139 48 | | NNS 9598 139 49 MASSICOTTE MASSICOTTE NNP 9598 139 50 AND and CC 9598 139 51 BOTTER BOTTER NNP 9598 139 52 | | NNP 9598 139 53 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 NNP 9598 139 54 24 24 CD 9598 139 55 stewardship stewardship NN 9598 139 56 of of IN 9598 139 57 ETD ETD NNP 9598 139 58 collections collection NNS 9598 139 59 . . . 9598 140 1 These these DT 9598 140 2 s s NNS 9598 140 3 and and CC 9598 140 4 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 140 5 have have VBP 9598 140 6 long long RB 9598 140 7 been be VBN 9598 140 8 viewed view VBN 9598 140 9 as as IN 9598 140 10 material material NN 9598 140 11 which which WDT 9598 140 12 contribute contribute VBP 9598 140 13 overall overall RB 9598 140 14 to to IN 9598 140 15 academic academic JJ 9598 140 16 scholarly scholarly JJ 9598 140 17 output output NN 9598 140 18 , , , 9598 140 19 and and CC 9598 140 20 carry carry VB 9598 140 21 unique unique JJ 9598 140 22 status status NN 9598 140 23 within within IN 9598 140 24 the the DT 9598 140 25 academy academy NN 9598 140 26 . . . 9598 141 1 In in IN 9598 141 2 August August NNP 9598 141 3 2016 2016 CD 9598 141 4 , , , 9598 141 5 OpenDOAR OpenDOAR NNP 9598 141 6 registered register VBD 9598 141 7 1600 1600 CD 9598 141 8 institutional institutional JJ 9598 141 9 repositories repository NNS 9598 141 10 with with IN 9598 141 11 ETDs,40 etds,40 NN 9598 141 12 up up RB 9598 141 13 from from IN 9598 141 14 1,100 1,100 CD 9598 141 15 institutions institution NNS 9598 141 16 as as IN 9598 141 17 reported report VBN 9598 141 18 in in IN 9598 141 19 2012 2012 CD 9598 141 20 by by IN 9598 141 21 grey grey NNP 9598 141 22 literature literature NN 9598 141 23 specialist specialist NN 9598 141 24 Schoepfel.41 schoepfel.41 NN 9598 141 25 Academic academic JJ 9598 141 26 libraries library NNS 9598 141 27 have have VBP 9598 141 28 , , , 9598 141 29 in in IN 9598 141 30 large large JJ 9598 141 31 part part NN 9598 141 32 , , , 9598 141 33 facilitated facilitate VBD 9598 141 34 the the DT 9598 141 35 transition transition NN 9598 141 36 from from IN 9598 141 37 paper paper NN 9598 141 38 to to IN 9598 141 39 ETD ETD NNP 9598 141 40 with with IN 9598 141 41 widespread widespread JJ 9598 141 42 adoption adoption NN 9598 141 43 of of IN 9598 141 44 institutional institutional JJ 9598 141 45 repository repository NN 9598 141 46 deposit deposit NN 9598 141 47 programs program NNS 9598 141 48 , , , 9598 141 49 and and CC 9598 141 50 along along IN 9598 141 51 with with IN 9598 141 52 that that DT 9598 141 53 adoption adoption NN 9598 141 54 comes come VBZ 9598 141 55 a a DT 9598 141 56 range range NN 9598 141 57 of of IN 9598 141 58 long long JJ 9598 141 59 - - HYPH 9598 141 60 term term NN 9598 141 61 preservation preservation NN 9598 141 62 issues issue NNS 9598 141 63 . . . 9598 142 1 Yet yet RB 9598 142 2 as as IN 9598 142 3 Ohio Ohio NNP 9598 142 4 State State NNP 9598 142 5 ’s ’s NNP 9598 142 6 Strategic Strategic NNP 9598 142 7 Digital Digital NNP 9598 142 8 Initiatives Initiatives NNPS 9598 142 9 Working Working NNP 9598 142 10 Group Group NNP 9598 142 11 pointed point VBD 9598 142 12 out out RP 9598 142 13 , , , 9598 142 14 “ " `` 9598 142 15 Even even RB 9598 142 16 in in IN 9598 142 17 digital digital JJ 9598 142 18 library library NN 9598 142 19 communities community NNS 9598 142 20 , , , 9598 142 21 preservation preservation NN 9598 142 22 all all DT 9598 142 23 too too RB 9598 142 24 often often RB 9598 142 25 stands stand VBZ 9598 142 26 in in IN 9598 142 27 for for IN 9598 142 28 or or CC 9598 142 29 is be VBZ 9598 142 30 used use VBN 9598 142 31 interchangeably interchangeably RB 9598 142 32 with with IN 9598 142 33 byte byte NN 9598 142 34 level level NN 9598 142 35 backup backup NN 9598 142 36 of of IN 9598 142 37 content content NN 9598 142 38 . . . 9598 142 39 ”42 ”42 NN 9598 142 40 For for IN 9598 142 41 long long JJ 9598 142 42 - - HYPH 9598 142 43 term term NN 9598 142 44 access access NN 9598 142 45 , , , 9598 142 46 focus focus NN 9598 142 47 can can MD 9598 142 48 productively productively RB 9598 142 49 be be VB 9598 142 50 shifted shift VBN 9598 142 51 to to TO 9598 142 52 offset offset VB 9598 142 53 the the DT 9598 142 54 immediate immediate JJ 9598 142 55 threat threat NN 9598 142 56 of of IN 9598 142 57 incompleteness incompleteness NN 9598 142 58 and and CC 9598 142 59 inadequate inadequate JJ 9598 142 60 capture.43 capture.43 NNP 9598 142 61 Not not RB 9598 142 62 much much JJ 9598 142 63 has have VBZ 9598 142 64 changed change VBN 9598 142 65 since since IN 9598 142 66 Hedstrom Hedstrom NNP 9598 142 67 wrote write VBD 9598 142 68 back back RB 9598 142 69 in in IN 9598 142 70 1997 1997 CD 9598 142 71 : : : 9598 142 72 “ " `` 9598 142 73 With with IN 9598 142 74 few few JJ 9598 142 75 exceptions exception NNS 9598 142 76 , , , 9598 142 77 digital digital JJ 9598 142 78 library library NN 9598 142 79 research research NN 9598 142 80 has have VBZ 9598 142 81 focussed focusse VBN 9598 142 82 on on IN 9598 142 83 architectures architecture NNS 9598 142 84 and and CC 9598 142 85 systems system NNS 9598 142 86 for for IN 9598 142 87 information information NN 9598 142 88 organization organization NNP 9598 142 89 and and CC 9598 142 90 retrieval retrieval NN 9598 142 91 , , , 9598 142 92 presentation presentation NN 9598 142 93 and and CC 9598 142 94 visualization visualization NN 9598 142 95 , , , 9598 142 96 and and CC 9598 142 97 administration administration NN 9598 142 98 of of IN 9598 142 99 intellectual intellectual JJ 9598 142 100 property property NN 9598 142 101 rights right NNS 9598 142 102 … … NFP 9598 142 103 The the DT 9598 142 104 critical critical JJ 9598 142 105 role role NN 9598 142 106 of of IN 9598 142 107 digital digital JJ 9598 142 108 libraries library NNS 9598 142 109 and and CC 9598 142 110 archives archive NNS 9598 142 111 in in IN 9598 142 112 ensuring ensure VBG 9598 142 113 the the DT 9598 142 114 future future JJ 9598 142 115 accessibility accessibility NN 9598 142 116 of of IN 9598 142 117 information information NN 9598 142 118 with with IN 9598 142 119 enduring endure VBG 9598 142 120 value value NN 9598 142 121 has have VBZ 9598 142 122 taken take VBN 9598 142 123 a a DT 9598 142 124 back back JJ 9598 142 125 seat seat NN 9598 142 126 to to IN 9598 142 127 enhancing enhance VBG 9598 142 128 access access NN 9598 142 129 to to IN 9598 142 130 current current JJ 9598 142 131 and and CC 9598 142 132 actively actively RB 9598 142 133 used use VBN 9598 142 134 materials material NNS 9598 142 135 . . . 9598 142 136 ”44 ”44 NN 9598 142 137 Our -PRON- PRP$ 9598 142 138 understanding understanding NN 9598 142 139 and and CC 9598 142 140 discussion discussion NN 9598 142 141 of of IN 9598 142 142 digital digital JJ 9598 142 143 preservation preservation NN 9598 142 144 must must MD 9598 142 145 be be VB 9598 142 146 broadened broaden VBN 9598 142 147 , , , 9598 142 148 and and CC 9598 142 149 attention attention NN 9598 142 150 turned turn VBD 9598 142 151 to to IN 9598 142 152 this this DT 9598 142 153 key key JJ 9598 142 154 area area NN 9598 142 155 of of IN 9598 142 156 responsibility responsibility NN 9598 142 157 in in IN 9598 142 158 the the DT 9598 142 159 preservation preservation NN 9598 142 160 life life NN 9598 142 161 - - HYPH 9598 142 162 cycle cycle NN 9598 142 163 . . . 9598 143 1 The the DT 9598 143 2 authors author NNS 9598 143 3 maintain maintain VBP 9598 143 4 that that IN 9598 143 5 ETD ETD NNP 9598 143 6 content content NN 9598 143 7 and and CC 9598 143 8 link link NN 9598 143 9 preservation preservation NN 9598 143 10 is be VBZ 9598 143 11 an an DT 9598 143 12 editorial editorial NN 9598 143 13 , , , 9598 143 14 not not RB 9598 143 15 individual individual JJ 9598 143 16 , , , 9598 143 17 imperative imperative JJ 9598 143 18 . . . 9598 144 1 Encouraging encourage VBG 9598 144 2 individual individual JJ 9598 144 3 authors author NNS 9598 144 4 to to TO 9598 144 5 perform perform VB 9598 144 6 their -PRON- PRP$ 9598 144 7 own own JJ 9598 144 8 archiving archiving NN 9598 144 9 is be VBZ 9598 144 10 doomed doom VBN 9598 144 11 to to TO 9598 144 12 fall fall VB 9598 144 13 short short RB 9598 144 14 of of IN 9598 144 15 even even RB 9598 144 16 reasonable reasonable JJ 9598 144 17 expectations expectation NNS 9598 144 18 . . . 9598 145 1 Instituting instituting NN 9598 145 2 measures measure NNS 9598 145 3 such such JJ 9598 145 4 as as IN 9598 145 5 Perma Perma NNP 9598 145 6 , , , 9598 145 7 a a DT 9598 145 8 distributed distributed JJ 9598 145 9 , , , 9598 145 10 redundant redundant JJ 9598 145 11 method method NN 9598 145 12 of of IN 9598 145 13 capturing capture VBG 9598 145 14 and and CC 9598 145 15 archiving archive VBG 9598 145 16 web web NN 9598 145 17 site site NN 9598 145 18 content content NN 9598 145 19 as as IN 9598 145 20 part part NN 9598 145 21 of of IN 9598 145 22 the the DT 9598 145 23 citation citation NN 9598 145 24 process process NN 9598 145 25 must must MD 9598 145 26 be be VB 9598 145 27 pro pro JJ 9598 145 28 - - : 9598 145 29 actively actively RB 9598 145 30 sought seek VBN 9598 145 31 and and CC 9598 145 32 built build VBN 9598 145 33 into into IN 9598 145 34 library library NN 9598 145 35 , , , 9598 145 36 and and CC 9598 145 37 hence hence RB 9598 145 38 repository repository NN 9598 145 39 , , , 9598 145 40 workflows.45 workflows.45 NNP 9598 145 41 Browser Browser NNP 9598 145 42 plugins plugin NNS 9598 145 43 and and CC 9598 145 44 automated automate VBN 9598 145 45 solutions solution NNS 9598 145 46 which which WDT 9598 145 47 use use VBP 9598 145 48 the the DT 9598 145 49 Memento Memento NNP 9598 145 50 protocol protocol NN 9598 145 51 for for IN 9598 145 52 capturing capture VBG 9598 145 53 and and CC 9598 145 54 archiving archive VBG 9598 145 55 web web NN 9598 145 56 site site NN 9598 145 57 content content NN 9598 145 58 as as IN 9598 145 59 part part NN 9598 145 60 of of IN 9598 145 61 the the DT 9598 145 62 citation citation NN 9598 145 63 process process NN 9598 145 64 do do VBP 9598 145 65 exist,46 exist,46 NNP 9598 145 66 but but CC 9598 145 67 naturally naturally RB 9598 145 68 have have VB 9598 145 69 to to TO 9598 145 70 be be VB 9598 145 71 implemented implement VBN 9598 145 72 before before IN 9598 145 73 they -PRON- PRP 9598 145 74 can can MD 9598 145 75 take take VB 9598 145 76 effect effect NN 9598 145 77 . . . 9598 146 1 Either either DT 9598 146 2 way way NN 9598 146 3 , , , 9598 146 4 efforts effort NNS 9598 146 5 to to TO 9598 146 6 operationalize operationalize VB 9598 146 7 existing existing JJ 9598 146 8 mechanisms mechanism NNS 9598 146 9 which which WDT 9598 146 10 are be VBP 9598 146 11 designed design VBN 9598 146 12 to to TO 9598 146 13 reduce reduce VB 9598 146 14 future future JJ 9598 146 15 loss loss NN 9598 146 16 would would MD 9598 146 17 be be VB 9598 146 18 extremely extremely RB 9598 146 19 productive productive JJ 9598 146 20 . . . 9598 147 1 Responsibility responsibility NN 9598 147 2 for for IN 9598 147 3 insuring insure VBG 9598 147 4 not not RB 9598 147 5 only only RB 9598 147 6 current current JJ 9598 147 7 , , , 9598 147 8 but but CC 9598 147 9 continuing continue VBG 9598 147 10 future future JJ 9598 147 11 access access NN 9598 147 12 to to IN 9598 147 13 ETD ETD NNP 9598 147 14 content content NN 9598 147 15 rests rest NNS 9598 147 16 with with IN 9598 147 17 those those DT 9598 147 18 who who WP 9598 147 19 maintain maintain VBP 9598 147 20 curatorial curatorial JJ 9598 147 21 function function NN 9598 147 22 of of IN 9598 147 23 the the DT 9598 147 24 repository repository NN 9598 147 25 . . . 9598 148 1 Academic academic JJ 9598 148 2 librarians librarian NNS 9598 148 3 have have VBP 9598 148 4 assumed assume VBN 9598 148 5 a a DT 9598 148 6 prominent prominent JJ 9598 148 7 and and CC 9598 148 8 de de FW 9598 148 9 facto facto FW 9598 148 10 role role NN 9598 148 11 as as IN 9598 148 12 curators curator NNS 9598 148 13 , , , 9598 148 14 facilitating facilitate VBG 9598 148 15 the the DT 9598 148 16 role role NN 9598 148 17 of of IN 9598 148 18 university university NN 9598 148 19 publication publication NN 9598 148 20 and and CC 9598 148 21 emphasizing emphasize VBG 9598 148 22 its -PRON- PRP$ 9598 148 23 break break NN 9598 148 24 away away RB 9598 148 25 from from IN 9598 148 26 previous previous JJ 9598 148 27 ties tie NNS 9598 148 28 with with IN 9598 148 29 commercial commercial JJ 9598 148 30 entities entity NNS 9598 148 31 . . . 9598 149 1 We -PRON- PRP 9598 149 2 collectively collectively RB 9598 149 3 bear bear VBP 9598 149 4 greater great JJR 9598 149 5 responsibility responsibility NN 9598 149 6 for for IN 9598 149 7 this this DT 9598 149 8 body body NN 9598 149 9 of of IN 9598 149 10 scholarly scholarly JJ 9598 149 11 work work NN 9598 149 12 , , , 9598 149 13 and and CC 9598 149 14 need need VBP 9598 149 15 to to TO 9598 149 16 move move VB 9598 149 17 forward forward RB 9598 149 18 from from IN 9598 149 19 a a DT 9598 149 20 position position NN 9598 149 21 of of IN 9598 149 22 benign benign JJ 9598 149 23 neglect neglect NN 9598 149 24 to to IN 9598 149 25 one one CD 9598 149 26 of of IN 9598 149 27 informed inform VBN 9598 149 28 curation curation NN 9598 149 29 and and CC 9598 149 30 pro pro JJ 9598 149 31 - - JJ 9598 149 32 active active JJ 9598 149 33 preservation preservation NN 9598 149 34 of of IN 9598 149 35 an an DT 9598 149 36 important important JJ 9598 149 37 collection collection NN 9598 149 38 of of IN 9598 149 39 scholarly scholarly JJ 9598 149 40 output output NN 9598 149 41 which which WDT 9598 149 42 is be VBZ 9598 149 43 at at IN 9598 149 44 risk risk NN 9598 149 45 . . . 9598 150 1 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 9598 150 2 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 9598 150 3 AND and CC 9598 150 4 LIBRARIES library NNS 9598 150 5 | | NNP 9598 150 6 MARCH MARCH NNS 9598 150 7 2017 2017 CD 9598 150 8 25 25 CD 9598 150 9 REFERENCES reference NNS 9598 150 10 1 1 CD 9598 150 11 . . . 9598 151 1 Thomas Thomas NNP 9598 151 2 H. H. NNP 9598 151 3 Teper Teper NNP 9598 151 4 and and CC 9598 151 5 Beth Beth NNP 9598 151 6 Kraemer Kraemer NNP 9598 151 7 , , , 9598 151 8 “ " `` 9598 151 9 Long Long NNP 9598 151 10 - - HYPH 9598 151 11 Term Term NNP 9598 151 12 Retention Retention NNP 9598 151 13 of of IN 9598 151 14 Electronic Electronic NNP 9598 151 15 These these DT 9598 151 16 s s NNS 9598 151 17 and and CC 9598 151 18 Dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 151 19 , , , 9598 151 20 ” " '' 9598 151 21 College College NNP 9598 151 22 & & CC 9598 151 23 Research Research NNP 9598 151 24 Libraries Libraries NNP 9598 151 25 63 63 CD 9598 151 26 , , , 9598 151 27 no no UH 9598 151 28 . . . 9598 152 1 1 1 LS 9598 152 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 152 3 January January NNP 9598 152 4 1 1 CD 9598 152 5 , , , 9598 152 6 2002 2002 CD 9598 152 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 152 8 , , , 9598 152 9 64 64 CD 9598 152 10 , , , 9598 152 11 https://doi.org/10.5860/crl.63.1.61 https://doi.org/10.5860/crl.63.1.61 NNP 9598 152 12 . . . 9598 153 1 2 2 CD 9598 153 2 The the DT 9598 153 3 term term NN 9598 153 4 “ " `` 9598 153 5 reference reference NN 9598 153 6 rot rot NNP 9598 153 7 ” " '' 9598 153 8 was be VBD 9598 153 9 introduced introduce VBN 9598 153 10 by by IN 9598 153 11 the the DT 9598 153 12 Hiberlink Hiberlink NNP 9598 153 13 team team NN 9598 153 14 . . . 9598 154 1 “ " `` 9598 154 2 Hiberlink hiberlink NN 9598 154 3 – – : 9598 154 4 About about IN 9598 154 5 , , , 9598 154 6 ” " '' 9598 154 7 accessed access VBD 9598 154 8 March March NNP 9598 154 9 31 31 CD 9598 154 10 , , , 9598 154 11 2016 2016 CD 9598 154 12 , , , 9598 154 13 http://hiberlink.org/about.html http://hiberlink.org/about.html NNP 9598 154 14 . . . 9598 155 1 3 3 LS 9598 155 2 . . . 9598 156 1 LOCKSS LOCKSS NNP 9598 156 2 : : : 9598 156 3 Lots lot NNS 9598 156 4 of of IN 9598 156 5 Copies copy NNS 9598 156 6 Keep keep VBP 9598 156 7 Stuff Stuff NNP 9598 156 8 Safe Safe NNP 9598 156 9 , , , 9598 156 10 accessed access VBD 9598 156 11 December December NNP 9598 156 12 6 6 CD 9598 156 13 , , , 9598 156 14 2016 2016 CD 9598 156 15 , , , 9598 156 16 http://www.lockss.org/about/what-is-lockss/. http://www.lockss.org/about/what-is-lockss/. NNP 9598 157 1 4 4 LS 9598 157 2 . . . 9598 158 1 Mark Mark NNP 9598 158 2 Edward Edward NNP 9598 158 3 Phillips Phillips NNP 9598 158 4 , , , 9598 158 5 Daniel Daniel NNP 9598 158 6 Gelaw Gelaw NNP 9598 158 7 Alemneh Alemneh NNP 9598 158 8 , , , 9598 158 9 and and CC 9598 158 10 Brenda Brenda NNP 9598 158 11 Reyes Reyes NNP 9598 158 12 Ayala Ayala NNP 9598 158 13 , , , 9598 158 14 “ " `` 9598 158 15 Analysis Analysis NNP 9598 158 16 of of IN 9598 158 17 URL URL NNP 9598 158 18 References References NNPS 9598 158 19 in in IN 9598 158 20 ETDs etd NNS 9598 158 21 : : : 9598 158 22 A a DT 9598 158 23 Case Case NNP 9598 158 24 Study Study NNP 9598 158 25 at at IN 9598 158 26 the the DT 9598 158 27 University University NNP 9598 158 28 of of IN 9598 158 29 North North NNP 9598 158 30 Texas Texas NNP 9598 158 31 , , , 9598 158 32 ” " '' 9598 158 33 Library Library NNP 9598 158 34 Management Management NNP 9598 158 35 35 35 CD 9598 158 36 , , , 9598 158 37 no no UH 9598 158 38 . . . 9598 159 1 4/5 4/5 LS 9598 159 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 159 3 June June NNP 9598 159 4 3 3 CD 9598 159 5 , , , 9598 159 6 2014 2014 CD 9598 159 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 159 8 , , , 9598 159 9 294 294 CD 9598 159 10 , , , 9598 159 11 https://doi.org/10.1108/LM-08-2013-0073 https://doi.org/10.1108/LM-08-2013-0073 NNP 9598 159 12 . . . 9598 160 1 5 5 CD 9598 160 2 . . . 9598 161 1 Wallace Wallace NNP 9598 161 2 Koehler Koehler NNP 9598 161 3 , , , 9598 161 4 “ " `` 9598 161 5 An an DT 9598 161 6 Analysis Analysis NNP 9598 161 7 of of IN 9598 161 8 Web Web NNP 9598 161 9 Page Page NNP 9598 161 10 and and CC 9598 161 11 Web web NN 9598 161 12 Site Site NNP 9598 161 13 Constancy Constancy NNP 9598 161 14 and and CC 9598 161 15 Permanence Permanence NNP 9598 161 16 , , , 9598 161 17 ” " '' 9598 161 18 Journal Journal NNP 9598 161 19 of of IN 9598 161 20 the the DT 9598 161 21 American American NNP 9598 161 22 Society Society NNP 9598 161 23 for for IN 9598 161 24 Information Information NNP 9598 161 25 Science Science NNP 9598 161 26 50 50 CD 9598 161 27 , , , 9598 161 28 no no UH 9598 161 29 . . . 9598 162 1 2 2 LS 9598 162 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 162 3 January January NNP 9598 162 4 1 1 CD 9598 162 5 , , , 9598 162 6 1999 1999 CD 9598 162 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 162 8 : : : 9598 162 9 162–80 162–80 CD 9598 162 10 , , , 9598 162 11 https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1097-4571(1999)50:2<162::AID-ASI7>3.0.CO;2-B. https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1097-4571(1999)50:2<162::AID-ASI7>3.0.CO;2-B. NNP 9598 163 1 6 6 CD 9598 163 2 . . . 9598 164 1 Wallace Wallace NNP 9598 164 2 Koehler Koehler NNP 9598 164 3 , , , 9598 164 4 “ " `` 9598 164 5 Web web NN 9598 164 6 Page Page NNP 9598 164 7 Change Change NNP 9598 164 8 and and CC 9598 164 9 Persistence Persistence NNP 9598 164 10 — — : 9598 164 11 a a DT 9598 164 12 Four Four NNP 9598 164 13 - - HYPH 9598 164 14 Year Year NNP 9598 164 15 Longitudinal Longitudinal NNP 9598 164 16 Study Study NNP 9598 164 17 , , , 9598 164 18 ” " '' 9598 164 19 Journal Journal NNP 9598 164 20 of of IN 9598 164 21 the the DT 9598 164 22 American American NNP 9598 164 23 Society Society NNP 9598 164 24 for for IN 9598 164 25 Information Information NNP 9598 164 26 Science Science NNP 9598 164 27 & & CC 9598 164 28 Technology Technology NNP 9598 164 29 53 53 CD 9598 164 30 , , , 9598 164 31 no no UH 9598 164 32 . . . 9598 165 1 2 2 LS 9598 165 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 165 3 January January NNP 9598 165 4 15 15 CD 9598 165 5 , , , 9598 165 6 2002 2002 CD 9598 165 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 165 8 : : : 9598 165 9 162–71 162–71 CD 9598 165 10 , , , 9598 165 11 http://doi.org/10.1002/asi.10018 http://doi.org/10.1002/asi.10018 NNP 9598 165 12 . . . 9598 166 1 7 7 LS 9598 166 2 . . . 9598 167 1 Wallace Wallace NNP 9598 167 2 Koehler Koehler NNP 9598 167 3 , , , 9598 167 4 " " '' 9598 167 5 A a DT 9598 167 6 longitudinal longitudinal JJ 9598 167 7 study study NN 9598 167 8 of of IN 9598 167 9 Web web NN 9598 167 10 pages page NNS 9598 167 11 continued continue VBD 9598 167 12 : : : 9598 167 13 a a DT 9598 167 14 consideration consideration NN 9598 167 15 of of IN 9598 167 16 document document NN 9598 167 17 persistence persistence NN 9598 167 18 . . . 9598 167 19 " " '' 9598 168 1 Information Information NNP 9598 168 2 Research Research NNP 9598 168 3 9 9 CD 9598 168 4 , , , 9598 168 5 no no UH 9598 168 6 . . . 9598 169 1 2 2 CD 9598 169 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 169 3 2004 2004 CD 9598 169 4 ) ) -RRB- 9598 169 5 : : : 9598 169 6 9 9 CD 9598 169 7 - - SYM 9598 169 8 2 2 CD 9598 169 9 , , , 9598 169 10 http://www.informationr.net/ir/9- http://www.informationr.net/ir/9- NNP 9598 169 11 2 2 CD 9598 169 12 / / SYM 9598 169 13 paper174.html paper174.html NN 9598 169 14 . . . 9598 170 1 8 8 LS 9598 170 2 . . . 9598 171 1 Fatih Fatih NNP 9598 171 2 Oguz Oguz NNP 9598 171 3 and and CC 9598 171 4 Wallace Wallace NNP 9598 171 5 Koehler Koehler NNP 9598 171 6 , , , 9598 171 7 “ " `` 9598 171 8 URL URL NNP 9598 171 9 Decay Decay NNP 9598 171 10 at at IN 9598 171 11 Year year NN 9598 171 12 20 20 CD 9598 171 13 : : : 9598 171 14 A a DT 9598 171 15 Research Research NNP 9598 171 16 Note note NN 9598 171 17 , , , 9598 171 18 ” " '' 9598 171 19 Journal Journal NNP 9598 171 20 of of IN 9598 171 21 the the DT 9598 171 22 Association Association NNP 9598 171 23 for for IN 9598 171 24 Information Information NNP 9598 171 25 Science Science NNP 9598 171 26 and and CC 9598 171 27 Technology Technology NNP 9598 171 28 67 67 CD 9598 171 29 , , , 9598 171 30 no no UH 9598 171 31 . . . 9598 172 1 2 2 LS 9598 172 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 172 3 February February NNP 9598 172 4 1 1 CD 9598 172 5 , , , 9598 172 6 2016 2016 CD 9598 172 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 172 8 : : : 9598 172 9 477–79 477–79 CD 9598 172 10 , , , 9598 172 11 https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.23561 https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.23561 NNP 9598 172 12 . . . 9598 173 1 9 9 CD 9598 173 2 . . . 9598 174 1 Mary Mary NNP 9598 174 2 F. F. NNP 9598 174 3 Casserly Casserly NNP 9598 174 4 and and CC 9598 174 5 James James NNP 9598 174 6 Bird Bird NNP 9598 174 7 , , , 9598 174 8 “ " `` 9598 174 9 Web Web NNP 9598 174 10 Citation Citation NNP 9598 174 11 Availability availability NN 9598 174 12 : : : 9598 174 13 Analysis Analysis NNP 9598 174 14 and and CC 9598 174 15 Implications Implications NNPS 9598 174 16 for for IN 9598 174 17 Scholarship scholarship NN 9598 174 18 , , , 9598 174 19 ” " '' 9598 174 20 College College NNP 9598 174 21 and and CC 9598 174 22 Research Research NNP 9598 174 23 Libraries Libraries NNP 9598 174 24 64 64 CD 9598 174 25 , , , 9598 174 26 no no UH 9598 174 27 . . . 9598 175 1 4 4 LS 9598 175 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 175 3 July July NNP 9598 175 4 2003 2003 CD 9598 175 5 ) ) -RRB- 9598 175 6 : : : 9598 175 7 300–317 300–317 CD 9598 175 8 , , , 9598 175 9 http://crl.acrl.org/content/64/4/300.full.pdf http://crl.acrl.org/content/64/4/300.full.pdf ADD 9598 175 10 . . . 9598 176 1 10 10 CD 9598 176 2 . . . 9598 177 1 Diomidis Diomidis NNP 9598 177 2 Spinellis Spinellis NNP 9598 177 3 , , , 9598 177 4 “ " `` 9598 177 5 The the DT 9598 177 6 Decay Decay NNP 9598 177 7 and and CC 9598 177 8 Failures Failures NNPS 9598 177 9 of of IN 9598 177 10 Web web NN 9598 177 11 References reference NNS 9598 177 12 , , , 9598 177 13 ” " '' 9598 177 14 Communications communication NNS 9598 177 15 of of IN 9598 177 16 the the DT 9598 177 17 ACM ACM NNP 9598 177 18 46 46 CD 9598 177 19 , , , 9598 177 20 no no UH 9598 177 21 . . . 9598 178 1 1 1 LS 9598 178 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 178 3 January January NNP 9598 178 4 2003 2003 CD 9598 178 5 ) ) -RRB- 9598 178 6 : : : 9598 178 7 71–77 71–77 LS 9598 178 8 , , , 9598 178 9 https://doi.org/10.1145/602421.602422 https://doi.org/10.1145/602421.602422 ADD 9598 178 10 . . . 9598 179 1 11 11 CD 9598 179 2 . . . 9598 180 1 Carmine Carmine NNP 9598 180 2 Sellitto Sellitto NNP 9598 180 3 , , , 9598 180 4 “ " `` 9598 180 5 A a DT 9598 180 6 Study Study NNP 9598 180 7 of of IN 9598 180 8 Missing Missing NNP 9598 180 9 Web web NN 9598 180 10 - - HYPH 9598 180 11 Cites Cites NNPS 9598 180 12 in in IN 9598 180 13 Scholarly Scholarly NNP 9598 180 14 Articles Articles NNPS 9598 180 15 : : : 9598 180 16 Towards towards IN 9598 180 17 an an DT 9598 180 18 Evaluation Evaluation NNP 9598 180 19 Framework Framework NNP 9598 180 20 , , , 9598 180 21 ” " '' 9598 180 22 Journal Journal NNP 9598 180 23 of of IN 9598 180 24 Information Information NNP 9598 180 25 Science Science NNP 9598 180 26 30 30 CD 9598 180 27 , , , 9598 180 28 no no UH 9598 180 29 . . . 9598 181 1 6 6 LS 9598 181 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 181 3 December December NNP 9598 181 4 1 1 CD 9598 181 5 , , , 9598 181 6 2004 2004 CD 9598 181 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 181 8 : : : 9598 181 9 484–95 484–95 CD 9598 181 10 , , , 9598 181 11 https://doi.org/10.1177/0165551504047822 https://doi.org/10.1177/0165551504047822 ADD 9598 181 12 . . . 9598 182 1 A a DT 9598 182 2 CASE case NN 9598 182 3 STUDY STUDY NNP 9598 182 4 OF of IN 9598 182 5 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9598 182 6 THESES thesis NNS 9598 182 7 AND and CC 9598 182 8 DISSERTATIONS dissertation NNS 9598 182 9 ( ( -LRB- 9598 182 10 ETDS ETDS NNP 9598 182 11 ) ) -RRB- 9598 182 12 IN in IN 9598 182 13 AN an DT 9598 182 14 ACADEMIC ACADEMIC NNP 9598 182 15 LIBRARY LIBRARY NNP 9598 182 16 | | NNS 9598 182 17 MASSICOTTE MASSICOTTE NNP 9598 182 18 AND and CC 9598 182 19 BOTTER BOTTER NNP 9598 182 20 | | NNP 9598 182 21 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 NNP 9598 182 22 26 26 CD 9598 182 23 12 12 CD 9598 182 24 . . . 9598 183 1 Matthew Matthew NNP 9598 183 2 E. E. NNP 9598 183 3 Falagas Falagas NNP 9598 183 4 , , , 9598 183 5 Efthymia Efthymia NNP 9598 183 6 A. A. NNP 9598 183 7 Karveli Karveli NNP 9598 183 8 , , , 9598 183 9 and and CC 9598 183 10 Vassiliki Vassiliki NNP 9598 183 11 I. I. NNP 9598 183 12 Tritsaroli Tritsaroli NNP 9598 183 13 , , , 9598 183 14 “ " `` 9598 183 15 The the DT 9598 183 16 Risk risk NN 9598 183 17 of of IN 9598 183 18 Using use VBG 9598 183 19 the the DT 9598 183 20 Internet internet NN 9598 183 21 as as IN 9598 183 22 Reference Reference NNP 9598 183 23 Resource Resource NNP 9598 183 24 : : : 9598 183 25 A a DT 9598 183 26 Comparative Comparative NNP 9598 183 27 Study Study NNP 9598 183 28 , , , 9598 183 29 ” " '' 9598 183 30 International International NNP 9598 183 31 Journal Journal NNP 9598 183 32 of of IN 9598 183 33 Medical Medical NNP 9598 183 34 Informatics Informatics NNP 9598 183 35 77 77 CD 9598 183 36 , , , 9598 183 37 no no UH 9598 183 38 . . . 9598 184 1 4 4 LS 9598 184 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 184 3 April April NNP 9598 184 4 2008 2008 CD 9598 184 5 ) ) -RRB- 9598 184 6 : : : 9598 184 7 280–86 280–86 CD 9598 184 8 , , , 9598 184 9 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2007.07.001 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2007.07.001 ADD 9598 184 10 . . . 9598 185 1 13 13 CD 9598 185 2 . . . 9598 186 1 Cassie Cassie NNP 9598 186 2 Wagner Wagner NNP 9598 186 3 et et FW 9598 186 4 al al NNP 9598 186 5 . . NNP 9598 186 6 , , , 9598 186 7 “ " `` 9598 186 8 Disappearing Disappearing NNP 9598 186 9 Act Act NNP 9598 186 10 : : : 9598 186 11 Decay Decay NNP 9598 186 12 of of IN 9598 186 13 Uniform Uniform NNP 9598 186 14 Resource Resource NNP 9598 186 15 Locators Locators NNPS 9598 186 16 in in IN 9598 186 17 Health Health NNP 9598 186 18 Care Care NNP 9598 186 19 Management Management NNP 9598 186 20 Journals Journals NNPS 9598 186 21 , , , 9598 186 22 ” " '' 9598 186 23 Journal Journal NNP 9598 186 24 of of IN 9598 186 25 the the DT 9598 186 26 Medical Medical NNP 9598 186 27 Library Library NNP 9598 186 28 Association Association NNP 9598 186 29 97 97 CD 9598 186 30 , , , 9598 186 31 no no UH 9598 186 32 . . . 9598 187 1 2 2 LS 9598 187 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 187 3 April April NNP 9598 187 4 2009 2009 CD 9598 187 5 ) ) -RRB- 9598 187 6 : : : 9598 187 7 122 122 CD 9598 187 8 – – SYM 9598 187 9 30 30 CD 9598 187 10 , , , 9598 187 11 https://doi.org/10.3163/1536-5050.97.2.009 https://doi.org/10.3163/1536-5050.97.2.009 CD 9598 187 12 . . . 9598 188 1 14 14 CD 9598 188 2 . . . 9598 189 1 Robert Robert NNP 9598 189 2 Sanderson Sanderson NNP 9598 189 3 , , , 9598 189 4 Mark Mark NNP 9598 189 5 Phillips Phillips NNP 9598 189 6 , , , 9598 189 7 and and CC 9598 189 8 Herbert Herbert NNP 9598 189 9 Van Van NNP 9598 189 10 de de FW 9598 189 11 Sompel Sompel NNP 9598 189 12 , , , 9598 189 13 “ " `` 9598 189 14 Analyzing analyze VBG 9598 189 15 the the DT 9598 189 16 Persistence Persistence NNP 9598 189 17 of of IN 9598 189 18 Referenced Referenced NNP 9598 189 19 Web Web NNP 9598 189 20 Resources Resources NNPS 9598 189 21 with with IN 9598 189 22 Memento Memento NNP 9598 189 23 , , , 9598 189 24 ” " '' 9598 189 25 arXiv:1105.3459 arxiv:1105.3459 RB 9598 189 26 [ [ -LRB- 9598 189 27 Cs Cs NNP 9598 189 28 ] ] -RRB- 9598 189 29 , , , 9598 189 30 May May NNP 9598 189 31 17 17 CD 9598 189 32 , , , 9598 189 33 2011 2011 CD 9598 189 34 , , , 9598 189 35 http://arxiv.org/abs/1105.3459 http://arxiv.org/abs/1105.3459 NNP 9598 189 36 . . . 9598 190 1 15 15 CD 9598 190 2 . . . 9598 191 1 Jonathan Jonathan NNP 9598 191 2 Zittrain Zittrain NNP 9598 191 3 , , , 9598 191 4 Kendra Kendra NNP 9598 191 5 Albert Albert NNP 9598 191 6 , , , 9598 191 7 and and CC 9598 191 8 Lawrence Lawrence NNP 9598 191 9 Lessig Lessig NNP 9598 191 10 , , , 9598 191 11 “ " `` 9598 191 12 Perma Perma NNP 9598 191 13 : : : 9598 191 14 Scoping scope VBG 9598 191 15 and and CC 9598 191 16 Addressing address VBG 9598 191 17 the the DT 9598 191 18 Problem problem NN 9598 191 19 of of IN 9598 191 20 Link Link NNP 9598 191 21 and and CC 9598 191 22 Reference Reference NNP 9598 191 23 Rot Rot NNP 9598 191 24 in in IN 9598 191 25 Legal Legal NNP 9598 191 26 Citations Citations NNPS 9598 191 27 , , , 9598 191 28 ” " '' 9598 191 29 Legal Legal NNP 9598 191 30 Information Information NNP 9598 191 31 Management Management NNP 9598 191 32 14 14 CD 9598 191 33 , , , 9598 191 34 no no UH 9598 191 35 . . . 9598 192 1 2 2 LS 9598 192 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 192 3 June June NNP 9598 192 4 2014 2014 CD 9598 192 5 ) ) -RRB- 9598 192 6 : : : 9598 192 7 88–99 88–99 NN 9598 192 8 , , , 9598 192 9 https://doi.org/10.1017/S1472669614000255 https://doi.org/10.1017/S1472669614000255 NNP 9598 192 10 . . . 9598 193 1 16 16 CD 9598 193 2 . . . 9598 194 1 “ " `` 9598 194 2 Hiberlink hiberlink NN 9598 194 3 - - HYPH 9598 194 4 About about NN 9598 194 5 , , , 9598 194 6 ” " '' 9598 194 7 accessed access VBD 9598 194 8 March March NNP 9598 194 9 31 31 CD 9598 194 10 , , , 9598 194 11 2016 2016 CD 9598 194 12 , , , 9598 194 13 http://hiberlink.org/about.html http://hiberlink.org/about.html NNP 9598 194 14 . . . 9598 195 1 17 17 CD 9598 195 2 . . . 9598 196 1 “ " `` 9598 196 2 Hiberlink hiberlink VB 9598 196 3 - - : 9598 196 4 Our -PRON- PRP$ 9598 196 5 Research Research NNP 9598 196 6 , , , 9598 196 7 ” " '' 9598 196 8 accessed access VBD 9598 196 9 March March NNP 9598 196 10 31 31 CD 9598 196 11 , , , 9598 196 12 2016 2016 CD 9598 196 13 , , , 9598 196 14 http://hiberlink.org/research.html http://hiberlink.org/research.html NNP 9598 196 15 . . . 9598 197 1 18 18 CD 9598 197 2 . . . 9598 198 1 Martin Martin NNP 9598 198 2 Klein Klein NNP 9598 198 3 , , , 9598 198 4 Herbert Herbert NNP 9598 198 5 Van Van NNP 9598 198 6 de de FW 9598 198 7 Sompel Sompel NNP 9598 198 8 , , , 9598 198 9 Robert Robert NNP 9598 198 10 Sanderson Sanderson NNP 9598 198 11 , , , 9598 198 12 Harihar Harihar NNP 9598 198 13 Shankar Shankar NNP 9598 198 14 , , , 9598 198 15 Lyudmila Lyudmila NNP 9598 198 16 Balakireva Balakireva NNP 9598 198 17 , , , 9598 198 18 Ke Ke NNP 9598 198 19 Zhou Zhou NNP 9598 198 20 , , , 9598 198 21 Richard Richard NNP 9598 198 22 Tobin Tobin NNP 9598 198 23 . . . 9598 199 1 “ " `` 9598 199 2 Scholarly Scholarly NNP 9598 199 3 Context Context NNP 9598 199 4 Not not RB 9598 199 5 Found find VBN 9598 199 6 : : : 9598 199 7 One one CD 9598 199 8 in in IN 9598 199 9 Five five CD 9598 199 10 Articles article NNS 9598 199 11 Suffers Suffers NNPS 9598 199 12 from from IN 9598 199 13 Reference Reference NNP 9598 199 14 Rot Rot NNP 9598 199 15 , , , 9598 199 16 ” " '' 9598 199 17 PLoS plos ADD 9598 199 18 One one CD 9598 199 19 9 9 CD 9598 199 20 , , , 9598 199 21 no no UH 9598 199 22 . . . 9598 200 1 12 12 CD 9598 200 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 200 3 December December NNP 9598 200 4 26 26 CD 9598 200 5 , , , 9598 200 6 2014 2014 CD 9598 200 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 200 8 , , , 9598 200 9 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0115253 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0115253 NNP 9598 200 10 . . . 9598 201 1 19 19 CD 9598 201 2 . . . 9598 202 1 Shawn Shawn NNP 9598 202 2 M. M. NNP 9598 202 3 Jones Jones NNP 9598 202 4 , , , 9598 202 5 Herbert Herbert NNP 9598 202 6 Van Van NNP 9598 202 7 de de FW 9598 202 8 Sompel Sompel NNP 9598 202 9 , , , 9598 202 10 Harihar Harihar NNP 9598 202 11 Shankar Shankar NNP 9598 202 12 , , , 9598 202 13 Martin Martin NNP 9598 202 14 Klein Klein NNP 9598 202 15 , , , 9598 202 16 Richard Richard NNP 9598 202 17 Tobin Tobin NNP 9598 202 18 , , , 9598 202 19 Claire Claire NNP 9598 202 20 Grover Grover NNP 9598 202 21 . . . 9598 203 1 “ " `` 9598 203 2 Scholarly Scholarly NNP 9598 203 3 Context Context NNP 9598 203 4 Adrift Adrift NNP 9598 203 5 : : : 9598 203 6 Three three CD 9598 203 7 out out IN 9598 203 8 of of IN 9598 203 9 Four four CD 9598 203 10 URI URI NNP 9598 203 11 References reference NNS 9598 203 12 Lead lead VBP 9598 203 13 to to IN 9598 203 14 Changed change VBN 9598 203 15 Content Content NNP 9598 203 16 , , , 9598 203 17 ” " '' 9598 203 18 PLOS plos VB 9598 203 19 ONE one CD 9598 203 20 11 11 CD 9598 203 21 , , , 9598 203 22 no no UH 9598 203 23 . . . 9598 204 1 12 12 CD 9598 204 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 204 3 December December NNP 9598 204 4 2 2 CD 9598 204 5 , , , 9598 204 6 2016 2016 CD 9598 204 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 204 8 : : : 9598 204 9 e0167475 e0167475 NN 9598 204 10 , , , 9598 204 11 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0167475 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0167475 JJ 9598 204 12 . . . 9598 205 1 20 20 CD 9598 205 2 . . . 9598 206 1 Martin Martin NNP 9598 206 2 Halbert Halbert NNP 9598 206 3 , , , 9598 206 4 Katherine Katherine NNP 9598 206 5 Skinner Skinner NNP 9598 206 6 , , , 9598 206 7 and and CC 9598 206 8 Matt Matt NNP 9598 206 9 Schultz Schultz NNP 9598 206 10 , , , 9598 206 11 “ " `` 9598 206 12 Preserving preserve VBG 9598 206 13 Electronic Electronic NNP 9598 206 14 These these DT 9598 206 15 s s NNS 9598 206 16 and and CC 9598 206 17 Dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 206 18 : : : 9598 206 19 Findings finding NNS 9598 206 20 of of IN 9598 206 21 the the DT 9598 206 22 Lifecycle Lifecycle NNP 9598 206 23 Management Management NNP 9598 206 24 for for IN 9598 206 25 ETDs ETDs NNP 9598 206 26 Project Project NNP 9598 206 27 , , , 9598 206 28 ” " '' 9598 206 29 Text Text NNP 9598 206 30 , , , 9598 206 31 ( ( -LRB- 9598 206 32 August August NNP 9598 206 33 6 6 CD 9598 206 34 , , , 9598 206 35 2015 2015 CD 9598 206 36 ) ) -RRB- 9598 206 37 , , , 9598 206 38 2 2 CD 9598 206 39 , , , 9598 206 40 http://educopia.org/presentations/preserving-electronic-theses-and- http://educopia.org/presentations/preserving-electronic-theses-and- NNP 9598 206 41 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 206 42 - - HYPH 9598 206 43 findings finding NNS 9598 206 44 - - HYPH 9598 206 45 lifecycle lifecycle NN 9598 206 46 - - HYPH 9598 206 47 management management NN 9598 206 48 - - HYPH 9598 206 49 etds etds NN 9598 206 50 . . . 9598 207 1 21 21 CD 9598 207 2 . . . 9598 208 1 For for IN 9598 208 2 a a DT 9598 208 3 recent recent JJ 9598 208 4 overview overview NN 9598 208 5 , , , 9598 208 6 see see VB 9598 208 7 Sarah Sarah NNP 9598 208 8 Potvin Potvin NNP 9598 208 9 and and CC 9598 208 10 Santi Santi NNP 9598 208 11 Thompson Thompson NNP 9598 208 12 , , , 9598 208 13 “ " `` 9598 208 14 An an DT 9598 208 15 Analysis Analysis NNP 9598 208 16 of of IN 9598 208 17 Evolving Evolving NNP 9598 208 18 Metadata Metadata NNP 9598 208 19 Influences Influences NNPS 9598 208 20 , , , 9598 208 21 Standards Standards NNPS 9598 208 22 , , , 9598 208 23 and and CC 9598 208 24 Practices Practices NNPS 9598 208 25 in in IN 9598 208 26 Electronic Electronic NNP 9598 208 27 These these DT 9598 208 28 s s NNS 9598 208 29 and and CC 9598 208 30 Dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 208 31 , , , 9598 208 32 ” " '' 9598 208 33 Library Library NNP 9598 208 34 Resources Resources NNP 9598 208 35 & & CC 9598 208 36 Technical Technical NNP 9598 208 37 Services Services NNP 9598 208 38 60 60 CD 9598 208 39 , , , 9598 208 40 no no UH 9598 208 41 . . . 9598 209 1 2 2 LS 9598 209 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 209 3 March March NNP 9598 209 4 31 31 CD 9598 209 5 , , , 9598 209 6 2016 2016 CD 9598 209 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 209 8 : : : 9598 209 9 99–114 99–114 NNP 9598 209 10 , , , 9598 209 11 https://doi.org/10.5860/lrts.60n2.99 https://doi.org/10.5860/lrts.60n2.99 NNP 9598 209 12 . . . 9598 210 1 22 22 CD 9598 210 2 . . . 9598 211 1 Joy Joy NNP 9598 211 2 M. M. NNP 9598 211 3 Perrin Perrin NNP 9598 211 4 , , , 9598 211 5 Heidi Heidi NNP 9598 211 6 M. M. NNP 9598 211 7 Winkler Winkler NNP 9598 211 8 , , , 9598 211 9 and and CC 9598 211 10 Le Le NNP 9598 211 11 Yang Yang NNP 9598 211 12 , , , 9598 211 13 “ " `` 9598 211 14 Digital Digital NNP 9598 211 15 Preservation Preservation NNP 9598 211 16 Challenges Challenges NNPS 9598 211 17 with with IN 9598 211 18 an an DT 9598 211 19 ETD ETD NNP 9598 211 20 Collection Collection NNP 9598 211 21 — — : 9598 211 22 A a DT 9598 211 23 Case Case NNP 9598 211 24 Study Study NNP 9598 211 25 at at IN 9598 211 26 Texas Texas NNP 9598 211 27 Tech Tech NNP 9598 211 28 University University NNP 9598 211 29 , , , 9598 211 30 ” " '' 9598 211 31 The the DT 9598 211 32 Journal Journal NNP 9598 211 33 of of IN 9598 211 34 Academic Academic NNP 9598 211 35 Librarianship Librarianship NNP 9598 211 36 41 41 CD 9598 211 37 , , , 9598 211 38 no no UH 9598 211 39 . . . 9598 212 1 1 1 LS 9598 212 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 212 3 January January NNP 9598 212 4 2015 2015 CD 9598 212 5 ) ) -RRB- 9598 212 6 : : : 9598 212 7 98–104 98–104 CD 9598 212 8 , , , 9598 212 9 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.acalib.2014.11.002 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.acalib.2014.11.002 ADD 9598 212 10 . . . 9598 213 1 23 23 CD 9598 213 2 . . . 9598 214 1 Sanderson Sanderson NNP 9598 214 2 , , , 9598 214 3 Phillips Phillips NNP 9598 214 4 , , , 9598 214 5 and and CC 9598 214 6 Van Van NNP 9598 214 7 de de FW 9598 214 8 Sompel Sompel NNP 9598 214 9 , , , 9598 214 10 “ " `` 9598 214 11 Analyzing analyze VBG 9598 214 12 the the DT 9598 214 13 Persistence Persistence NNP 9598 214 14 of of IN 9598 214 15 Referenced Referenced NNP 9598 214 16 Web Web NNP 9598 214 17 Resources Resources NNPS 9598 214 18 with with IN 9598 214 19 Memento Memento NNP 9598 214 20 , , , 9598 214 21 ” " '' 9598 214 22 http://arxiv.org/abs/1105.3459 http://arxiv.org/abs/1105.3459 NNP 9598 214 23 . . . 9598 215 1 INFORMATION INFORMATION NNP 9598 215 2 TECHNOLOGY technology NN 9598 215 3 AND and CC 9598 215 4 LIBRARIES library NNS 9598 215 5 | | NNP 9598 215 6 MARCH MARCH NNS 9598 215 7 2017 2017 CD 9598 215 8 27 27 CD 9598 215 9 24 24 CD 9598 215 10 . . . 9598 216 1 Phillips Phillips NNP 9598 216 2 , , , 9598 216 3 Alemneh Alemneh NNP 9598 216 4 , , , 9598 216 5 and and CC 9598 216 6 Ayala Ayala NNP 9598 216 7 , , , 9598 216 8 " " `` 9598 216 9 Analysis Analysis NNP 9598 216 10 of of IN 9598 216 11 URL URL NNP 9598 216 12 references reference NNS 9598 216 13 , , , 9598 216 14 " " `` 9598 216 15 https://doi.org/10.1108/LM-08- https://doi.org/10.1108/LM-08- NNP 9598 216 16 2013 2013 CD 9598 216 17 - - SYM 9598 216 18 0073 0073 CD 9598 216 19 . . . 9598 217 1 25 25 CD 9598 217 2 . . . 9598 218 1 Alfred Alfred NNP 9598 218 2 S. S. NNP 9598 218 3 Sife Sife NNP 9598 218 4 and and CC 9598 218 5 Ronald Ronald NNP 9598 218 6 Bernard Bernard NNP 9598 218 7 , , , 9598 218 8 “ " `` 9598 218 9 Persistence Persistence NNP 9598 218 10 and and CC 9598 218 11 Decay Decay NNP 9598 218 12 of of IN 9598 218 13 Web web NN 9598 218 14 Citations Citations NNPS 9598 218 15 Used use VBN 9598 218 16 in in IN 9598 218 17 These these DT 9598 218 18 s s NNS 9598 218 19 and and CC 9598 218 20 Dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 218 21 Available available JJ 9598 218 22 at at IN 9598 218 23 the the DT 9598 218 24 Sokoine Sokoine NNP 9598 218 25 National National NNP 9598 218 26 Agricultural Agricultural NNP 9598 218 27 Library Library NNP 9598 218 28 , , , 9598 218 29 Tanzania Tanzania NNP 9598 218 30 , , , 9598 218 31 ” " '' 9598 218 32 International International NNP 9598 218 33 Journal Journal NNP 9598 218 34 of of IN 9598 218 35 Education Education NNP 9598 218 36 and and CC 9598 218 37 Development Development NNP 9598 218 38 Using Using NNP 9598 218 39 Information Information NNP 9598 218 40 and and CC 9598 218 41 Communication Communication NNP 9598 218 42 Technology Technology NNP 9598 218 43 9 9 CD 9598 218 44 , , , 9598 218 45 no no UH 9598 218 46 . . . 9598 219 1 2 2 CD 9598 219 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 219 3 2013 2013 CD 9598 219 4 ) ) -RRB- 9598 219 5 : : : 9598 219 6 85–94 85–94 CD 9598 219 7 , , , 9598 219 8 http://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1071354 http://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1071354 NNP 9598 219 9 . . . 9598 220 1 26 26 CD 9598 220 2 . . . 9598 221 1 “ " `` 9598 221 2 ETD2014 ETD2014 NNP 9598 221 3 — — : 9598 221 4 University University NNP 9598 221 5 of of IN 9598 221 6 Leicester Leicester NNP 9598 221 7 , , , 9598 221 8 ” " '' 9598 221 9 University University NNP 9598 221 10 of of IN 9598 221 11 Leicester Leicester NNP 9598 221 12 , , , 9598 221 13 accessed access VBD 9598 221 14 January January NNP 9598 221 15 27 27 CD 9598 221 16 , , , 9598 221 17 2016 2016 CD 9598 221 18 , , , 9598 221 19 http://www2.le.ac.uk/library/downloads/etd2014 http://www2.le.ac.uk/library/downloads/etd2014 ADD 9598 221 20 . . . 9598 222 1 27 27 CD 9598 222 2 . . . 9598 223 1 EDINA EDINA NNP 9598 223 2 , , , 9598 223 3 University University NNP 9598 223 4 of of IN 9598 223 5 Edinburgh Edinburgh NNP 9598 223 6 , , , 9598 223 7 “ " `` 9598 223 8 Reference Reference NNP 9598 223 9 Rot Rot NNP 9598 223 10 : : : 9598 223 11 Threat Threat NNP 9598 223 12 and and CC 9598 223 13 Remedy remedy NN 9598 223 14 , , , 9598 223 15 ” " '' 9598 223 16 ( ( -LRB- 9598 223 17 Education Education NNP 9598 223 18 , , , 9598 223 19 04:54:38 04:54:38 CD 9598 223 20 UTC UTC NNP 9598 223 21 ) ) -RRB- 9598 223 22 , , , 9598 223 23 http://www.slideshare.net/edinadocumentationofficer/reference-rot-and-linked- http://www.slideshare.net/edinadocumentationofficer/reference-rot-and-linked- NNP 9598 223 24 data data NN 9598 223 25 - - HYPH 9598 223 26 threat threat NN 9598 223 27 - - HYPH 9598 223 28 and and CC 9598 223 29 - - HYPH 9598 223 30 remedy remedy NN 9598 223 31 . . . 9598 224 1 28 28 CD 9598 224 2 . . . 9598 225 1 Peter Peter NNP 9598 225 2 Burnhill Burnhill NNP 9598 225 3 , , , 9598 225 4 Muriel Muriel NNP 9598 225 5 Mewissen Mewissen NNP 9598 225 6 , , , 9598 225 7 and and CC 9598 225 8 Richard Richard NNP 9598 225 9 Wincewicz Wincewicz NNP 9598 225 10 , , , 9598 225 11 “ " `` 9598 225 12 Reference Reference NNP 9598 225 13 Rot Rot NNP 9598 225 14 in in IN 9598 225 15 Scholarly Scholarly NNP 9598 225 16 Statement Statement NNP 9598 225 17 : : : 9598 225 18 Threat Threat NNP 9598 225 19 and and CC 9598 225 20 Remedy remedy NN 9598 225 21 , , , 9598 225 22 ” " '' 9598 225 23 Insights insight VBZ 9598 225 24 the the DT 9598 225 25 UKSG UKSG NNP 9598 225 26 Journal Journal NNP 9598 225 27 28 28 CD 9598 225 28 , , , 9598 225 29 no no UH 9598 225 30 . . . 9598 226 1 2 2 LS 9598 226 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 226 3 July July NNP 9598 226 4 7 7 CD 9598 226 5 , , , 9598 226 6 2015 2015 CD 9598 226 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 226 8 : : : 9598 226 9 55–61 55–61 NN 9598 226 10 , , , 9598 226 11 https://doi.org/10.1629/uksg.237 https://doi.org/10.1629/uksg.237 NNP 9598 226 12 . . . 9598 227 1 29 29 CD 9598 227 2 . . . 9598 228 1 Concordia Concordia NNP 9598 228 2 University University NNP 9598 228 3 University University NNP 9598 228 4 Graduate Graduate NNP 9598 228 5 Programs Programs NNP 9598 228 6 , , , 9598 228 7 accessed access VBD 9598 228 8 April April NNP 9598 228 9 7 7 CD 9598 228 10 , , , 9598 228 11 2016 2016 CD 9598 228 12 , , , 9598 228 13 http://www.concordia.ca/academics/graduate.html http://www.concordia.ca/academics/graduate.html NNP 9598 228 14 . . . 9598 229 1 30 30 CD 9598 229 2 . . . 9598 230 1 Klein Klein NNP 9598 230 2 et et NNP 9598 230 3 al al NNP 9598 230 4 . . NNP 9598 230 5 , , , 9598 230 6 " " `` 9598 230 7 Scholarly Scholarly NNP 9598 230 8 Context Context NNP 9598 230 9 Not not RB 9598 230 10 Found find VBN 9598 230 11 , , , 9598 230 12 " " '' 9598 230 13 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0115253 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0115253 VB 9598 230 14 . . . 9598 231 1 31 31 CD 9598 231 2 . . . 9598 232 1 Ke Ke NNP 9598 232 2 Zhou Zhou NNP 9598 232 3 , , , 9598 232 4 Richard Richard NNP 9598 232 5 Tobin Tobin NNP 9598 232 6 , , , 9598 232 7 and and CC 9598 232 8 Claire Claire NNP 9598 232 9 Grover Grover NNP 9598 232 10 , , , 9598 232 11 “ " `` 9598 232 12 Extraction extraction NN 9598 232 13 and and CC 9598 232 14 Analysis Analysis NNP 9598 232 15 of of IN 9598 232 16 Referenced Referenced NNP 9598 232 17 Web Web NNP 9598 232 18 Links Links NNPS 9598 232 19 in in IN 9598 232 20 Large large JJ 9598 232 21 - - HYPH 9598 232 22 Scale scale NN 9598 232 23 Scholarly Scholarly NNP 9598 232 24 Articles Articles NNPS 9598 232 25 , , , 9598 232 26 ” " '' 9598 232 27 in in IN 9598 232 28 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 9598 232 29 of of IN 9598 232 30 the the DT 9598 232 31 14th 14th JJ 9598 232 32 ACM ACM NNP 9598 232 33 / / SYM 9598 232 34 IEEE IEEE NNP 9598 232 35 - - HYPH 9598 232 36 CS CS NNP 9598 232 37 Joint Joint NNP 9598 232 38 Conference Conference NNP 9598 232 39 on on IN 9598 232 40 Digital Digital NNP 9598 232 41 Libraries Libraries NNPS 9598 232 42 , , , 9598 232 43 JCDL JCDL NNP 9598 232 44 ’ ' '' 9598 232 45 14 14 CD 9598 232 46 ( ( -LRB- 9598 232 47 Piscataway Piscataway NNP 9598 232 48 , , , 9598 232 49 NJ NJ NNP 9598 232 50 , , , 9598 232 51 USA USA NNP 9598 232 52 : : : 9598 232 53 IEEE IEEE NNP 9598 232 54 Press Press NNP 9598 232 55 , , , 9598 232 56 2014 2014 CD 9598 232 57 ) ) -RRB- 9598 232 58 , , , 9598 232 59 451–452 451–452 CD 9598 232 60 , , , 9598 232 61 http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=2740769.2740863 http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=2740769.2740863 ADD 9598 232 62 . . . 9598 233 1 32 32 CD 9598 233 2 . . . 9598 234 1 Pdftohtml Pdftohtml NNP 9598 234 2 v0.38 v0.38 VBP 9598 234 3 win32 win32 NNP 9598 234 4 , , , 9598 234 5 meshko meshko JJ 9598 234 6 ( ( -LRB- 9598 234 7 Mikhail Mikhail NNP 9598 234 8 Kruk Kruk NNP 9598 234 9 ) ) -RRB- 9598 234 10 , , , 9598 234 11 http://pdftohtml.sourceforge.net/ http://pdftohtml.sourceforge.net/ NNP 9598 234 12 accessed access VBD 9598 234 13 September September NNP 9598 234 14 20 20 CD 9598 234 15 , , , 9598 234 16 2015 2015 CD 9598 234 17 . . . 9598 235 1 ( ( -LRB- 9598 235 2 Actual actual JJ 9598 235 3 download download NN 9598 235 4 is be VBZ 9598 235 5 at at IN 9598 235 6 http://sourceforge.net/projects/pdftohtml/ http://sourceforge.net/projects/pdftohtml/ NNP 9598 235 7 ) ) -RRB- 9598 235 8 . . . 9598 236 1 33 33 CD 9598 236 2 . . . 9598 237 1 Give give VB 9598 237 2 me -PRON- PRP 9598 237 3 text text NN 9598 237 4 ! ! . 9598 238 1 Open open JJ 9598 238 2 Knowledge Knowledge NNP 9598 238 3 International International NNP 9598 238 4 , , , 9598 238 5 accessed access VBD 9598 238 6 October October NNP 9598 238 7 26 26 CD 9598 238 8 , , , 9598 238 9 2015-March 2015-march CD 9598 238 10 7 7 CD 9598 238 11 , , , 9598 238 12 2016 2016 CD 9598 238 13 , , , 9598 238 14 http://givemetext.okfnlabs.org/. http://givemetext.okfnlabs.org/. NNP 9598 239 1 34 34 CD 9598 239 2 . . . 9598 240 1 Phillips Phillips NNP 9598 240 2 , , , 9598 240 3 Alemneh Alemneh NNP 9598 240 4 , , , 9598 240 5 and and CC 9598 240 6 Ayala Ayala NNP 9598 240 7 , , , 9598 240 8 " " `` 9598 240 9 Analysis Analysis NNP 9598 240 10 of of IN 9598 240 11 URL URL NNP 9598 240 12 references reference NNS 9598 240 13 , , , 9598 240 14 " " `` 9598 240 15 https://doi.org/10.1108/LM-08- https://doi.org/10.1108/LM-08- NNP 9598 240 16 2013 2013 CD 9598 240 17 - - SYM 9598 240 18 0073 0073 CD 9598 240 19 . . . 9598 241 1 35 35 CD 9598 241 2 . . . 9598 242 1 “ " `` 9598 242 2 In in IN 9598 242 3 Search Search NNP 9598 242 4 of of IN 9598 242 5 the the DT 9598 242 6 Perfect Perfect NNP 9598 242 7 URL URL NNP 9598 242 8 Validation Validation NNP 9598 242 9 Regex Regex NNP 9598 242 10 , , , 9598 242 11 ” " '' 9598 242 12 accessed access VBD 9598 242 13 December December NNP 9598 242 14 7 7 CD 9598 242 15 , , , 9598 242 16 2015 2015 CD 9598 242 17 , , , 9598 242 18 https://mathiasbynens.be/demo/url-regex https://mathiasbynens.be/demo/url-regex ADD 9598 242 19 . . . 9598 243 1 We -PRON- PRP 9598 243 2 selected select VBD 9598 243 3 " " '' 9598 243 4 @gruber @gruber FW 9598 243 5 v2 v2 NN 9598 243 6 " " '' 9598 243 7 for for IN 9598 243 8 our -PRON- PRP$ 9598 243 9 extraction extraction NN 9598 243 10 . . . 9598 244 1 36 36 CD 9598 244 2 . . . 9598 244 3 cURL curl NN 9598 244 4 v7.45.0 v7.45.0 NN 9598 244 5 , , , 9598 244 6 " " '' 9598 244 7 command command NN 9598 244 8 line line NN 9598 244 9 tool tool NN 9598 244 10 and and CC 9598 244 11 library library NN 9598 244 12 for for IN 9598 244 13 transferring transfer VBG 9598 244 14 data datum NNS 9598 244 15 with with IN 9598 244 16 URLs url NNS 9598 244 17 , , , 9598 244 18 " " '' 9598 244 19 accessed access VBD 9598 244 20 October October NNP 9598 244 21 18 18 CD 9598 244 22 , , , 9598 244 23 2015 2015 CD 9598 244 24 , , , 9598 244 25 http://curl.haxx.se/. http://curl.haxx.se/. NNP 9598 245 1 37 37 CD 9598 245 2 . . . 9598 246 1 We -PRON- PRP 9598 246 2 have have VBP 9598 246 3 used use VBN 9598 246 4 the the DT 9598 246 5 term term NN 9598 246 6 " " `` 9598 246 7 memento memento NN 9598 246 8 " " '' 9598 246 9 in in IN 9598 246 10 lowercase lowercase NN 9598 246 11 to to TO 9598 246 12 denote denote VB 9598 246 13 a a DT 9598 246 14 snapshot snapshot JJ 9598 246 15 souvenir souvenir NN 9598 246 16 page page NN 9598 246 17 , , , 9598 246 18 to to TO 9598 246 19 distinguish distinguish VB 9598 246 20 from from IN 9598 246 21 an an DT 9598 246 22 automated automate VBN 9598 246 23 service service NN 9598 246 24 utilizing utilize VBG 9598 246 25 the the DT 9598 246 26 Memento Memento NNP 9598 246 27 protocol protocol NN 9598 246 28 . . . 9598 247 1 A a DT 9598 247 2 CASE case NN 9598 247 3 STUDY STUDY NNP 9598 247 4 OF of IN 9598 247 5 ELECTRONIC ELECTRONIC NNP 9598 247 6 THESES thesis NNS 9598 247 7 AND and CC 9598 247 8 DISSERTATIONS dissertation NNS 9598 247 9 ( ( -LRB- 9598 247 10 ETDS ETDS NNP 9598 247 11 ) ) -RRB- 9598 247 12 IN in IN 9598 247 13 AN an DT 9598 247 14 ACADEMIC ACADEMIC NNP 9598 247 15 LIBRARY LIBRARY NNP 9598 247 16 | | NNS 9598 247 17 MASSICOTTE MASSICOTTE NNP 9598 247 18 AND and CC 9598 247 19 BOTTER BOTTER NNP 9598 247 20 | | NNP 9598 247 21 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 https://doi.org/10.6017/ital.v36i1.9598 NNP 9598 247 22 28 28 CD 9598 247 23 38 38 CD 9598 247 24 . . . 9598 248 1 For for IN 9598 248 2 a a DT 9598 248 3 good good JJ 9598 248 4 overview overview NN 9598 248 5 of of IN 9598 248 6 the the DT 9598 248 7 types type NNS 9598 248 8 of of IN 9598 248 9 problems problem NNS 9598 248 10 , , , 9598 248 11 see see VB 9598 248 12 Michael Michael NNP 9598 248 13 L. L. NNP 9598 248 14 Nelson Nelson NNP 9598 248 15 , , , 9598 248 16 Scott Scott NNP 9598 248 17 G. G. NNP 9598 248 18 Ainsworth Ainsworth NNP 9598 248 19 , , , 9598 248 20 Justin Justin NNP 9598 248 21 F. F. NNP 9598 248 22 Brunelle Brunelle NNP 9598 248 23 , , , 9598 248 24 Mat Mat NNP 9598 248 25 Kelly Kelly NNP 9598 248 26 , , , 9598 248 27 Hany Hany NNP 9598 248 28 SalahEldeen SalahEldeen NNP 9598 248 29 and and CC 9598 248 30 Michele Michele NNP 9598 248 31 Weigle Weigle NNP 9598 248 32 , , , 9598 248 33 " " `` 9598 248 34 Assessing assess VBG 9598 248 35 the the DT 9598 248 36 Quality Quality NNP 9598 248 37 of of IN 9598 248 38 Web Web NNP 9598 248 39 Archives Archives NNPS 9598 248 40 " " '' 9598 248 41 1 1 CD 9598 248 42 vol vol NNP 9598 248 43 . . NNP 9598 248 44 , , , 9598 248 45 Computer Computer NNP 9598 248 46 Science Science NNP 9598 248 47 Presentations Presentations NNPS 9598 248 48 , , , 9598 248 49 Book book NN 9598 248 50 8 8 CD 9598 248 51 ( ( -LRB- 9598 248 52 Old Old NNP 9598 248 53 Dominion Dominion NNP 9598 248 54 University University NNP 9598 248 55 . . . 9598 249 1 ODU ODU NNP 9598 249 2 Digital Digital NNP 9598 249 3 Commons Commons NNP 9598 249 4 , , , 9598 249 5 2014 2014 CD 9598 249 6 ) ) -RRB- 9598 249 7 . . . 9598 250 1 http://digitalcommons.odu.edu/computerscience_presentations/8 http://digitalcommons.odu.edu/computerscience_presentations/8 NNP 9598 250 2 . . . 9598 251 1 39 39 CD 9598 251 2 . . . 9598 252 1 Shawn Shawn NNP 9598 252 2 M. M. NNP 9598 252 3 Jones Jones NNP 9598 252 4 , , , 9598 252 5 et et NNP 9598 252 6 al al NNP 9598 252 7 . . . 9598 253 1 “ " `` 9598 253 2 Scholarly Scholarly NNP 9598 253 3 Context Context NNP 9598 253 4 Adrift Adrift NNP 9598 253 5 , , , 9598 253 6 " " '' 9598 253 7 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0167475 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0167475 FW 9598 253 8 . . . 9598 254 1 40 40 CD 9598 254 2 . . . 9598 255 1 OpenDOAR opendoar UH 9598 255 2 search search NN 9598 255 3 of of IN 9598 255 4 Institutional Institutional NNP 9598 255 5 Repositories Repositories NNP 9598 255 6 with with IN 9598 255 7 These these DT 9598 255 8 s s XX 9598 255 9 at at IN 9598 255 10 http://www.opendoar.org/find.php http://www.opendoar.org/find.php NNP 9598 255 11 , , , 9598 255 12 accessed access VBD 9598 255 13 August August NNP 9598 255 14 26 26 CD 9598 255 15 , , , 9598 255 16 2016 2016 CD 9598 255 17 . . . 9598 256 1 41 41 CD 9598 256 2 . . . 9598 257 1 Joachim Joachim NNP 9598 257 2 Schöpfel Schöpfel NNP 9598 257 3 , , , 9598 257 4 " " `` 9598 257 5 Adding add VBG 9598 257 6 value value NN 9598 257 7 to to IN 9598 257 8 electronic electronic VB 9598 257 9 these these DT 9598 257 10 s s NNS 9598 257 11 and and CC 9598 257 12 dissertations dissertation NNS 9598 257 13 in in IN 9598 257 14 institutional institutional JJ 9598 257 15 repositories repository NNS 9598 257 16 . . . 9598 257 17 " " '' 9598 258 1 D D NNP 9598 258 2 - - HYPH 9598 258 3 Lib Lib NNP 9598 258 4 Magazine Magazine NNP 9598 258 5 19 19 CD 9598 258 6 , , , 9598 258 7 no no UH 9598 258 8 . . . 9598 259 1 3 3 CD 9598 259 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 259 3 2013 2013 CD 9598 259 4 ) ) -RRB- 9598 259 5 : : : 9598 259 6 1 1 LS 9598 259 7 . . . 9598 259 8 https://doi.org/10.1045/march2013- https://doi.org/10.1045/march2013- NNP 9598 259 9 schopfel schopfel NNP 9598 259 10 . . . 9598 260 1 42 42 CD 9598 260 2 . . . 9598 261 1 Strategic Strategic NNP 9598 261 2 Digital Digital NNP 9598 261 3 Initiatives Initiatives NNPS 9598 261 4 Working Working NNP 9598 261 5 Group Group NNP 9598 261 6 . . . 9598 262 1 Implementation implementation NN 9598 262 2 of of IN 9598 262 3 a a DT 9598 262 4 Modern Modern NNP 9598 262 5 Digital Digital NNP 9598 262 6 Library Library NNP 9598 262 7 at at IN 9598 262 8 The the DT 9598 262 9 Ohio Ohio NNP 9598 262 10 State State NNP 9598 262 11 University University NNP 9598 262 12 . . . 9598 263 1 ( ( -LRB- 9598 263 2 Apr Apr NNP 9598 263 3 2014 2014 CD 9598 263 4 ) ) -RRB- 9598 263 5 . . . 9598 264 1 https://library.osu.edu/documents/SDIWG/sdiwg_white_paper.pdf https://library.osu.edu/documents/sdiwg/sdiwg_white_paper.pdf ADD 9598 264 2 . . . 9598 265 1 ( ( -LRB- 9598 265 2 Published publish VBN 9598 265 3 ) ) -RRB- 9598 265 4 . . . 9598 266 1 43 43 CD 9598 266 2 . . . 9598 267 1 Tim Tim NNP 9598 267 2 Gollins Gollins NNP 9598 267 3 . . . 9598 268 1 “ " `` 9598 268 2 Parsimonious Parsimonious NNP 9598 268 3 Preservation Preservation NNP 9598 268 4 : : : 9598 268 5 Preventing prevent VBG 9598 268 6 Pointless Pointless NNP 9598 268 7 Processes process NNS 9598 268 8 ! ! . 9598 269 1 ( ( -LRB- 9598 269 2 The the DT 9598 269 3 Small Small NNP 9598 269 4 Simple Simple NNP 9598 269 5 Steps Steps NNPS 9598 269 6 That that WDT 9598 269 7 Take take VBP 9598 269 8 Digital Digital NNP 9598 269 9 Preservation Preservation NNP 9598 269 10 a a DT 9598 269 11 Long Long NNP 9598 269 12 Way way NN 9598 269 13 Forward forward RB 9598 269 14 ) ) -RRB- 9598 269 15 , , , 9598 269 16 ” " '' 9598 269 17 in in IN 9598 269 18 Online Online NNP 9598 269 19 Information Information NNP 9598 269 20 Proceedings Proceedings NNP 9598 269 21 UK UK NNP 9598 269 22 National National NNP 9598 269 23 Archives Archives NNPS 9598 269 24 , , , 9598 269 25 2009 2009 CD 9598 269 26 . . . 9598 270 1 Available available JJ 9598 270 2 at at IN 9598 270 3 http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/information-management/parsimonious- http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/information-management/parsimonious- NNP 9598 270 4 preservation.pdf preservation.pdf NNP 9598 270 5 . . . 9598 271 1 44 44 CD 9598 271 2 . . . 9598 272 1 Margaret Margaret NNP 9598 272 2 Hedstrom Hedstrom NNP 9598 272 3 , , , 9598 272 4 " " '' 9598 272 5 Digital Digital NNP 9598 272 6 preservation preservation NN 9598 272 7 : : : 9598 272 8 a a DT 9598 272 9 time time NN 9598 272 10 bomb bomb NN 9598 272 11 for for IN 9598 272 12 digital digital JJ 9598 272 13 libraries library NNS 9598 272 14 . . . 9598 272 15 " " '' 9598 273 1 Computers computer NNS 9598 273 2 and and CC 9598 273 3 the the DT 9598 273 4 Humanities Humanities NNPS 9598 273 5 31 31 CD 9598 273 6 , , , 9598 273 7 no no UH 9598 273 8 . . . 9598 274 1 3 3 CD 9598 274 2 ( ( -LRB- 9598 274 3 1997 1997 CD 9598 274 4 ) ) -RRB- 9598 274 5 : : : 9598 274 6 189 189 CD 9598 274 7 - - SYM 9598 274 8 202 202 CD 9598 274 9 . . . 9598 274 10 https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1000676723815 https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1000676723815 NNP 9598 274 11 . . . 9598 275 1 45 45 CD 9598 275 2 . . . 9598 276 1 Zittrain Zittrain NNP 9598 276 2 , , , 9598 276 3 Albert Albert NNP 9598 276 4 , , , 9598 276 5 and and CC 9598 276 6 Lessig Lessig NNPS 9598 276 7 , , , 9598 276 8 " " `` 9598 276 9 Perma Perma NNP 9598 276 10 , , , 9598 276 11 " " '' 9598 276 12 https://doi.org/10.1017/S1472669614000255 https://doi.org/10.1017/s1472669614000255 JJ 9598 276 13 . . . 9598 277 1 46 46 CD 9598 277 2 . . . 9598 278 1 Herbert Herbert NNP 9598 278 2 Van Van NNP 9598 278 3 de de FW 9598 278 4 Sompel Sompel NNP 9598 278 5 , , , 9598 278 6 Michael Michael NNP 9598 278 7 L. L. NNP 9598 278 8 Nelson Nelson NNP 9598 278 9 , , , 9598 278 10 Robert Robert NNP 9598 278 11 Sanderson Sanderson NNP 9598 278 12 , , , 9598 278 13 Lyudmila Lyudmila NNP 9598 278 14 L. L. NNP 9598 278 15 Balakireva Balakireva NNP 9598 278 16 , , , 9598 278 17 Scott Scott NNP 9598 278 18 Ainsworth Ainsworth NNP 9598 278 19 , , , 9598 278 20 and and CC 9598 278 21 Harihar Harihar NNP 9598 278 22 Shankar Shankar NNP 9598 278 23 , , , 9598 278 24 “ " `` 9598 278 25 Memento memento NN 9598 278 26 : : : 9598 278 27 Time Time NNP 9598 278 28 Travel Travel NNP 9598 278 29 for for IN 9598 278 30 the the DT 9598 278 31 Web web NN 9598 278 32 , , , 9598 278 33 ” " '' 9598 278 34 arXiv:0911.1112 arxiv:0911.1112 NN 9598 278 35 [ [ -LRB- 9598 278 36 Cs Cs NNP 9598 278 37 ] ] -RRB- 9598 278 38 , , , 9598 278 39 November November NNP 9598 278 40 5 5 CD 9598 278 41 , , , 9598 278 42 2009 2009 CD 9598 278 43 , , , 9598 278 44 http://arxiv.org/abs/0911.1112 http://arxiv.org/abs/0911.1112 NNP 9598 278 45 . . .