La Canadian Association for Publishing in Philosophy annonce qu'elle a entrepris 
la publication, en plus du Canadian Journal of Philosophy, d'une serie de monog-

F LA PHILOSOPHIE A U CANADA H ^ 
Q PHILOSOPHY IN CANADA £ 

La serie comprendra des oeuvres dans tous les domaines de la philosophie, en 
anglais ou en frangais. Elle donnera la preference a des oeuvres canadiennes, et, 
au moins au commencement, aux monographies d'une longueur de 15,000 a 
35,000 mots —trop longues pour etre des articles de revue, trop courtes pour etre 
des livres de tattle normale. Les manuscrits, une fois rediges, doivent presenter 
les qualites requises pour obtenir une subvention du Conseil Canadien de Re-
cherche sur les Humanites. Ms devront premierement etre envoyes a: 

David Braybrooke 
Department of Philosophy 
Dalhousie University 
Halifax, Nouvelle-Ecosse, 

qui aura qualite de directeur de la serie pour la C.A.P.P., avec la collaboration 
d'autres membres de son department. 

Les premieres monographies a etre publiees seront 
(1) Charles B. Daniels et (2) George Englebretsen 

(University of Victoria), (Bishop's University) 
The Evaluation of Ethical Theories Speaking of Persons, 

suivies de pres — nous I'esperons — de deux monographies ecrites par des 
auteurs francophones. 

TheCanadian Association for Publishing in Philosophy wishes to announce that it 
is undertaking to publish, in addition to the Canadian Journal of Philosophy, a 
monograph series, 

F PHILOSOPHY IN CANADA T Q Q 
LA PHILOSOPHIE A U CANADA y ^ 

O O 
which will include works in any field of philosophy, in French or English. Priority 
will be given to Canadian material, all else being equal; and at least initially to 
monographs of between 15,000 words and 35,000 —too long for journal articles, 
too short to be books of ordinary size. Manuscripts will have to qualify after 
editing for subventions from the Humanities Research Council of Canada. They 
should be submitted in the first instance t o : 

David Braybrooke 
Department of Philosophy 
Dalhousie University 
Halifax, Nova Scotia, 

who with the collaboration of other members of his department will edit the 
series on behalf of the C.A.P.P. 

The first monographs to be published will be 
(1) Charles B. Daniels and (2) George Englebretsen 

(University of Victoria), (Bishop's University), 
The Evaluation of Ethical Theories Speaking of Persons, 

to be followed shortly, it is hoped, by two monographs by francophone authors. 



March 1975 Volume 1, number 3 
Jacques Barzun 

Quentin Bell 
John C. Cawelti 

Frederick Crews 
E. D . Hirsch, Jr. 

John Holloway 

Martin Price 

Edward Wasiolek 

Biography and Criticism—A Misalliance 
Disputed 

The Art Critic and the Art Historian 
Myths of Violence in American Popular 

Culture 
Reductionism and Its Discontents 
Stylistics and Synonymity 
Narrative Structure and Text Structure: 

Isherwood's A Meeting by the River and 
Muriel Spark's The Prime of Miss Jean 
Brodie 

People of the Book: Character in Forster's 
A Passage to India 

Wanted: A New Contextualism 

ARTISTS O N CRITICISM 
OF THEIR ART 

Eugene Ionesco 
(interviewed by Gabriel Jacobs) 

REVIEW ARTICLE A. Walton Litz 
Recollecting Jane Austen 

Critical Inquiry published quarterly 
• Please enter my subscription at the charter rate 
marked below, beginning with the inaugural issue, 
September 1974 

Charter rates:' 
Institutions, USA 
Individuals, USA 

1 year 2 years 
• $10.50 • $19.50 
• $ 7.50 • $13.50 

Other countries add $1.00 for each year's subscription 
to cover postage. 

Name 
Address. ; ; 
City -State. _Zip_ 

Please mail with your check or purchase order to 
Critical Inquiry, The University of Chicago Press, 
11030 Langley Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60628 

HP & 

m&i 



Stettgarter Hegel 
Kongress 1975 

From May 28th until May 30th 1975 a congress of the Interna-
tional Hegel Association will take place in Stuttgart, Germany, 
under the title 'Is systematic Philosophy possible?'. 

Eight Colloquia are offered, three of them with a historical, five 
of them with a systematic orientation. Among the speakers are 
David Armstrong (Sydney), Michael Dummett (Oxford), John 
Findlay (Boston), Jiirgen Habermas (Starnberg), Paul Lorenzen 
(Erlangen), T. I. Oiserman (Moscow) and Jules Vuillemin 
(Paris). 

Information can be obtained from: 

Secretary of the Association, 
Philosophisches Seminar der tJniversitat, 

69 Heidelberg, Marsiliusplatz 1, Germany. 

Mathematical Logic for Non-Mathematicians 

John UJoocJ/ 
A concise, lively introduction to contemporary logic for use primarily 
at the undergraduate level. Professor James Ford of Laurentian Univer-
sity says, "John Woods has provided a distinctive and useful approach 
to logic . . . a student who has been introduced to modern logic through 
this book will have no difficulty in relating its vocabulary and symbol-
ism to more advanced standard works in the field . . . It is J o h n Woods' 
contention that logic is interesting. It is, and can be seen to be so in the 
pages of Proofand Truth." 

J o h n Woods received his Bachelor's and Master's degrees at the Uni-
versity of Toronto and his Doctorate at the University of Michigan. He 
has been Visiting Scholar at Stanford University and is now teaching at 
the University of Victoria, Victoria, B.C. 
208 pages. Paperbound ISBN 0-88778-080-6 $3.95 

Peter Martin Associates 
35 Britain Street 

Toronto, Ontario M5A 1R7 



Methodology and Science 
Interdisciplinary Journal for t h e Empirical S t u d y 

of t h e Foundations of Science and their M e t h o d o l o g y 

1975 — 8 t h year 

• General Advisory Committee: S. Bloembergen, Max Euwe, S. Hofstra, Gerald Holton, 
Norman M. Martin, Josephine Mehlberg, Henry Mehlberg, Arne Naess, Sir K. R. 
Popper, Herman Tennessen, Wolfgang Yourgrau. 

• Editorial Committee: P. H. Esser, General Semantics, E. de Leede, Statistics, W. A. T. 
Meuwese, Psychology, I. Pels, Economics, P. C. Stouthard, Sociology. 

• The Journal publishes articles on signifies, methodology and new research results in 
the various disciplines, book reviews, events, announcements and biographical 
notices. Volumes 2 and 3 (1969 & 1970) contained excerpts in English translation from 
the Handbook "Analytic and Synthetic Signifies" published in 1947/48 by the late 
Professor G. Mannoury, the Netherlands mathematician who was an active member 
of the early Netherlands Signific Movement. 

• Subscriptions, orders for back volumes, manuscripts, etc., should be sent t o : Dr. P. H. 
Esser, Editor and Secretary, Methodology and Science, Beelslaan 20, Haarlem, 
Netherlands. 

• Annual subcription price (4 issues): Dfl 60.00 plus Dfl 10.00 outside the Netherlands. 

C A N A D I A N J O U R N A L 
O F P H I L O S O P H Y 

Published by the Canadian Association for Publishing in Philosophy 

A n n o u n c e s t h e p u b l i c a t i o n of SUPPLEMENTARY VOLUME NO. I, 
P A R T S 1 & 2. E a c h p a r t consists of a set of original essays in a 
special a r e a . P u b l i c a t i o n d a t e late 1974. 

P A R T 1 NEW E S S A Y S IN THE HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY, 
T e r e n c e P e n e l h u m a n d R o g e r A . S h i n e r ( e d s ) . C O N T R I -
B U T O R S : F . C. W h i t e , Michael K u b a r a , T. M. L e n n o n , 
D a v i d P a l m e r , E. M. C u r l e y , J o h n B r i c k e , Nelson P o t t e r , 
J o n a t h a n H a r r i s o n . 

P A R T 2 NEW E S S A Y S IN THE PHILOSOPHY OF MIND, J o h n 
K i n g - F a r l o w a n d R o g e r A . S h i n e r ( e d s ) . C O N T R I B U T O R S : 
H a r o l d Morick, L. H . Davis, D . A. B r o w n e , J . L. M a r t i n , 
R o l a n d P u c c e t t i , L. F . Mucciolo, J . S. Clegg, C h a r l e s E. 
M a r k s . 

P R I C E : T o i n s t i t u t i o n a l s u b s c r i b e r s a n d casual p u r c h a s e r s — $7 e a c h 
p a r t o r $12 t h e p a i r . F r e e to i n d i v i d u a l ($10) a n d s t u d e n t 
($5) s u b s c r i b e r s t o t h e C J . P . 

O R D E R F R O M : CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, E d i t -
orial a n d B u s i n e s s Office, T h e U n i v e r s i t y of A l b e r t a , 
E d m o n t o n , A l b e r t a , C a n a d a T6G 2E1. 



Philosophy 
The Journal of the Royal Institute of Philosophy 

Edited by Renford Bambrough 

Vol. 50 No. 191 
Editorial: Fifty Years of Philosophy 
Philosophy and Mr. Stoppard 
Rationality and Understanding 
A Kind of Necessary Truth 
Taking Liberties with Will 
The Ontological Argument 
Discussion New Books 

January 1975 

Jonathan Bennett 
Gordon Reddiford 
Norman J. Brown 

Richard Bryden 
James Cargile 

Notebook 

Single Parts £2.00 (US $6.00 U.S.A. and Canada) 
1975 Subscription £6.50 (US $19.50 U.S.A. and Canada) 

CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS 
Bentley House, 200 Euston Road, London NW1 2DB 

American Branch: 32 East 57th Street, New York, N.Y. 10022 

Religious Studies 
Volume 10, Number 4, December 1974 

ROBERT MORGAN 
PHILIP SHERRARD 

R. L. FRANKLIN 
DAVID L. GOSLING 
WENDELL C. BEANE 
CHRISTOPHER CHERRY 

MARGARET CHATTERJEE 

J. A. HARVIE 
R. L. STURCH 
Reviews 

CONTENTS 
The New Testament in Religious Studies 

The Tradition and the Traditions: 
The Confrontation of Religious Doctrines 

Religion and Religions 
Christian Response Within Hinduism 
Buddhist Causality and Compassion 

Understanding 
Understanding Religious Belief 
Does the Analysis of Religious 
Language Rest on a Mistake? 

A Russian View of Immortality 
The Problem of the Divine Eternity 

£3.50 net (US $10.50 in U.S.A. and Canada) 
1974 Subscription Price £10.50 net (US $32.50 in U.S.A. and Canada) 

CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS 
Bentley House, 200 Euston Road, London NW1 2DB 

American Branch: 32 East 57th Street, New York, N.Y. 10022 



INTERPRETATION 
A Journal of Political Philosophy 

" G " Building, Room 101 — Queens College —Flushing, New York 11367 

Editors: Seth G. Benardete, Hilail Gildin, Howard B. White 
Consulting Editors: John Hallowell, Wilhelm Hennis, Erich Hula, Arnaldo Momigliano, 

Michael Oakeshott, Leo Strauss (1899-1973). Kenneth W. Thompson 
Executive Editor: Hilail Gildin Managing Editor: Ann McArdle 

Volume IV, Issue 2 
Homeric Honor and Thucydidean Necessity Thomas Engeman 
Theory and Practice in the Founding of 
the Republic William B. Allen 
Intellectual Biography as a Form of the 
History of Ideas Robert R. Orr 
Atheistic Freedom and the International 
Society for the Suppression of Savage Customs: 
An Interpretation of Conrad's "Heart of Darkness" Harry Neumann 

INTERPRETATION appears three times a year. Annual subscription rate: Guilders 36 for 
institutions and libraries, Guilders 28.80 for individuals 

Order f r o m : M A R T I N U S NIJHOFF, Lange V o o r h o u t 9 - 1 1 , 
P.O.B. 269, T h e H a g u e , N e t h e r l a n d s 

SOCIAL THEbRY AND PRACTICE 
A n International and Interdisciplinary Journal of Social Philosophy 

Volume 2, Number 4 Fall 1973 

The Concept of Physical Violence in Moral and Political Affairs, Robert L. Holmes 
Mill's Forgotten Science of Ethology, Nicholas Capaldi 
The Concept of Political Freedom, William T. Blackstone 
Philosophy and Social Planning in Yugoslavia, Jack F . Padgett 
The Rehumanization of Work, Robert L. Armstrong 
The Orthodox Theory of Civil Disobedience, Gene G. James 
Books Received 

SOCIAL THEORY AND PRACTICE is published by the Department of Philosophy, Florida 
State University, and appears twice a year, Spring and Fall, with four issues constituting a 
single volume. Subscriptions: Libraries—$21.00 a volume, $6.00 an issue; Individuals—$10.00 
volume, $3.00 an issue. Countries other than U.S.A., Canada, and Mexico, add $.60 postage a 
volume, $.15 an issue. 

S O C I A L T H E O R Y A N D P R A C T I C E 
Department of Philosophy 
Florida State University 

Tallahassee, Florida 32306 U.S.A.