id sid tid token lemma pos cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 1 1 key key NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 1 2 : : : cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 1 cord-024077 cord-024077 NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 2 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 3 7o3qhfk3 7o3qhfk3 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 4 authors author NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 5 : : : cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 6 Behrens Behrens NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 7 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 8 Kevin Kevin NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 9 G. G. NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 10 title title NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 11 : : : cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 12 Clinical clinical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 13 Ethical ethical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 14 Challenges challenge NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 15 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 16 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 17 Covid-19 Covid-19 NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 18 Crisis Crisis NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 19 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 20 South South NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 21 Africa Africa NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 22 date date NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 23 : : : cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 24 2020 2020 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 25 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 26 04 04 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 27 - - SYM cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 28 17 17 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 29 journal journal NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 30 : : : cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 31 nan nan NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 32 DOI DOI NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 2 33 : : : cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 3 1 10.18772/26180197.2020.v2nsia5 10.18772/26180197.2020.v2nsia5 NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 3 2 sha sha NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 3 3 : : : cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 4 1 bde48d2d7518ea6cdc74f363833e8d98e968852a bde48d2d7518ea6cdc74f363833e8d98e968852a NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 4 2 doc_id doc_id NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 4 3 : : : cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 4 4 24077 24077 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 4 5 cord_uid cord_uid NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 4 6 : : : cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 5 1 7o3qhfk3 7o3qhfk3 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 1 nan nan NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 2 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 3 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 4 critical critical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 5 need need NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 6 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 7 an an DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 8 ethical ethical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 9 obligation obligation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 10 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 11 ethics ethic NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 12 guidelines guideline NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 13 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 14 decision decision NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 15 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 16 making make VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 17 about about IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 18 treatment treatment NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 19 allocation allocation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 20 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 21 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 22 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 23 place place NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 24 before before IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 25 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 26 pandemic pandemic NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 27 reaches reach VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 28 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 29 level level NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 30 where where WRB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 31 tragic tragic JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 32 choices choice NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 33 need need VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 34 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 35 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 36 made make VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 6 37 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 1 The the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 2 question question NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 3 now now RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 4 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 5 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 6 what what WP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 7 would would MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 8 an an DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 9 ethically ethically RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 10 sound sound JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 11 policy policy NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 12 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 13 rationing rationing NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 14 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 15 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 16 health health NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 7 17 emergency emergency NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 8 1 look look VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 8 2 like like IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 8 3 ? ? . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 1 In in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 2 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 3 recently recently RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 4 published publish VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 5 paper paper NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 6 entitled entitle VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 7 " " `` cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 8 Fair fair JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 9 allocation allocation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 10 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 11 scarce scarce JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 12 medical medical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 13 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 14 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 15 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 16 time time NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 17 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 18 Covid-19 Covid-19 NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 19 " " '' cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 20 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 21 Emanuel Emanuel NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 22 et et NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 23 al al NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 9 24 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 1 write write VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 2 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 3 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 4 literature literature NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 5 on on IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 6 resource resource NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 7 allocation allocation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 8 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 9 pandemics pandemic NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 10 emphasizes emphasize VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 11 four four CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 12 main main JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 13 values value NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 14 that that WDT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 15 should should MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 16 inform inform VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 17 policies policy NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 18 : : : cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 19 " " `` cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 20 Maximizing maximize VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 21 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 22 benefits benefit NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 23 produced produce VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 24 by by IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 25 scarce scarce JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 26 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 27 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 28 treating treat VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 29 people people NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 30 equally equally RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 31 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 32 promoting promote VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 33 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 34 rewarding rewarding JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 35 instrumental instrumental JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 36 value value NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 37 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 38 giving give VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 39 priority priority NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 40 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 41 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 42 worst bad JJS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 43 off off NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 44 " " '' cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 10 45 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 2 2 2 LS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 3 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 4 They -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 5 go go VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 6 on on RP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 7 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 8 make make VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 9 six six CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 10 recommendations recommendation NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 11 derived derive VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 12 from from IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 13 these these DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 14 four four CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 15 principles principle NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 11 16 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 2 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 3 not not RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 4 possible possible JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 5 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 6 discuss discuss VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 7 these these DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 8 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 9 any any DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 10 detail detail NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 11 here here RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 12 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 13 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 14 only only RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 15 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 16 four four CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 17 most most RBS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 18 pertinent pertinent JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 19 recommendations recommendation NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 20 will will MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 21 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 22 briefly briefly RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 23 discussed discuss VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 24 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 25 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 26 following following NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 12 27 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 13 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 13 2 2 2 LS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 13 3 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 2 first first JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 3 recommendation recommendation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 4 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 5 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 6 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 7 most most RBS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 8 important important JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 9 value value NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 10 when when WRB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 11 faced face VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 12 with with IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 13 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 14 pandemic pandemic NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 15 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 16 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 17 maximizing maximizing NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 18 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 19 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 20 benefits benefit NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 21 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 22 scarce scarce JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 23 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 14 24 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 1 They -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 2 assert assert VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 3 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 4 " " '' cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 5 priority priority NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 6 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 7 limited limited JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 8 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 9 should should MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 10 aim aim VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 11 both both DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 12 at at IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 13 saving save VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 14 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 15 most most JJS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 16 lives life NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 17 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 18 at at IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 19 maximizing maximize VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 20 improvements improvement NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 21 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 22 individuals individual NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 23 ' ' POS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 24 post post JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 25 - - JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 26 treatment treatment JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 27 length length NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 28 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 29 life".(2 life".(2 NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 15 30 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 1 Given give VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 2 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 3 lack lack NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 4 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 5 time time NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 6 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 7 information information NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 8 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 9 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 10 pandemic pandemic NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 11 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 12 they -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 13 go go VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 14 on on RP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 15 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 16 claim claim VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 17 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 18 it -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 19 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 20 " " `` cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 21 justifiable justifiable JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 22 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 23 give give VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 24 priority priority NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 25 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 26 maximizing maximize VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 27 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 28 number number NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 29 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 30 patients patient NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 31 that that WDT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 32 survive survive VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 33 treatment treatment NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 34 with with IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 35 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 36 reasonable reasonable JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 37 life life NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 38 expectancy expectancy NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 39 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 40 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 41 regard regard VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 42 maximizing maximize VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 43 improvements improvement NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 44 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 45 length length NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 46 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 47 life life NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 48 as as IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 49 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 50 subordinate subordinate JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 51 aim".(2 aim".(2 NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 16 52 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 17 1 Several several JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 17 2 recent recent JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 17 3 publications publication NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 17 4 broadly broadly RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 17 5 agree agree VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 17 6 with with IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 17 7 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 17 8 position.(3 position.(3 NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 17 9 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 17 10 6 6 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 17 11 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 18 1 Emanuel Emanuel NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 18 2 et et NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 18 3 al al NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 18 4 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 1 acknowledge acknowledge VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 2 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 3 there there EX cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 4 are be VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 5 many many JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 6 possible possible JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 7 ways way NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 8 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 9 seeking seek VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 10 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 11 balance balance NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 12 between between IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 13 saving save VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 14 more more JJR cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 15 lives life NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 16 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 17 saving save VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 18 more more JJR cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 19 life life NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 20 years year NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 21 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 22 but but CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 23 whatever whatever WDT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 24 means mean NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 25 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 26 balancing balance VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 27 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 28 chosen choose VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 29 ought ought MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 30 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 31 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 32 applied apply VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 33 consistently consistently RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 19 34 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 20 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 20 2 2 2 LS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 20 3 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 1 This this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 2 recommendation recommendation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 3 applies apply VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 4 as as RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 5 much much JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 6 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 7 South South NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 8 Africa Africa NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 9 as as IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 10 anywhere anywhere RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 11 else else RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 21 12 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 1 The the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 2 biggest big JJS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 3 challenge challenge NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 4 it -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 5 presents present VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 6 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 7 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 8 context context NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 9 relates relate VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 10 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 11 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 12 existing exist VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 13 inequalities inequality NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 14 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 15 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 16 healthcare healthcare NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 17 system system NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 18 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 19 where where WRB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 20 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 21 private private JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 22 sector sector NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 23 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 24 far far RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 25 better well RBR cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 26 resourced resourced JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 27 than than IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 28 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 29 public public JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 30 sector sector NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 22 31 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 1 Organs organ NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 2 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 3 State State NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 4 ought ought MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 5 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 6 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 7 considering consider VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 8 ways way NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 9 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 10 which which WDT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 11 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 12 total total JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 13 pool pool NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 14 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 15 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 16 available available JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 17 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 18 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 19 country country NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 20 can can MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 21 best best RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 22 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 23 employed employ VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 24 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 25 maximize maximize VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 26 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 27 benefits benefit NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 28 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 29 all all DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 30 citizens citizen NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 31 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 32 not not RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 33 only only RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 34 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 35 privileged privileged JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 23 36 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 1 This this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 2 can can MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 3 only only RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 4 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 5 achieved achieve VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 6 through through IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 7 intense intense JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 8 cooperation cooperation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 9 between between IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 10 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 11 two two CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 12 health health NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 13 sectors sector NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 24 14 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 1 The the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 2 second second JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 3 recommendation recommendation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 4 responds respond VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 5 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 6 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 7 value value NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 8 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 9 " " `` cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 10 promoting promote VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 11 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 12 rewarding rewarding JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 13 instrumental instrumental JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 14 value".(2 value".(2 NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 25 15 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 26 1 Emanuel Emanuel NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 26 2 et et NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 26 3 al al NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 26 4 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 27 1 submit submit VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 1 that that DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 2 health health NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 3 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 4 care care NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 5 workers worker NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 6 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 7 other other JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 8 front front JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 9 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 10 line line NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 11 carers carer NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 12 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 13 workers worker NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 14 who who WP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 15 keep keep VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 16 infrastructure infrastructure NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 17 running running NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 18 should should MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 19 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 20 granted grant VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 21 priority priority NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 22 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 23 treatment treatment NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 24 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 25 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 26 allocation allocation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 27 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 28 vaccines vaccine NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 28 29 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 1 The the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 2 reason reason NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 3 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 4 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 5 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 6 not not RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 7 because because IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 8 these these DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 9 individuals individual NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 10 are be VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 11 more more RBR cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 12 worthy worthy JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 13 than than IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 14 others other NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 15 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 16 it -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 17 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 18 because because IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 19 they -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 20 are be VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 21 instrumentally instrumentally RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 22 important important JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 23 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 24 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 25 response response NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 26 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 27 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 28 pandemic pandemic NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 29 29 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 1 Also also RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 2 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 3 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 4 assurance assurance NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 5 could could MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 6 encourage encourage VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 7 health health NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 8 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 9 care care NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 10 workers worker NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 11 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 12 accept accept VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 13 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 14 higher high JJR cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 15 risks risk NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 16 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 17 continue continue VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 18 caring care VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 19 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 20 patients patient NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 21 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 22 these these DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 23 circumstances.(2 circumstances.(2 NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 30 24 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 1 Prioritizing prioritize VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 2 health health NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 3 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 4 care care NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 5 workers worker NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 6 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 7 even even RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 8 more more RBR cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 9 justified justified JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 10 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 11 South South NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 12 Africa Africa NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 13 where where WRB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 14 we -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 15 already already RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 16 have have VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 17 such such PDT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 18 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 19 shortage shortage NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 20 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 21 qualified qualified JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 22 practitioners practitioner NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 31 23 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 1 The the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 2 authors author NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 3 also also RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 4 warn warn VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 5 against against IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 6 possible possible JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 7 abuses abuse NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 8 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 9 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 10 principle principle NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 11 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 12 giving give VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 13 regard regard NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 14 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 15 instrumental instrumental JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 16 value value NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 17 by by IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 18 " " `` cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 19 prioritizing prioritize VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 20 wealthy wealthy JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 21 or or CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 22 famous famous JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 23 persons person NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 24 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 25 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 26 politically politically RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 27 powerful powerful JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 28 above above IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 29 first first JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 30 responders responder NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 31 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 32 medical medical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 33 staff staff NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 34 … … NFP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 32 35 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 33 1 Such such JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 33 2 abuses abuse NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 33 3 will will MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 33 4 undermine undermine VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 33 5 trust trust NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 33 6 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 33 7 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 33 8 allocation allocation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 33 9 framework".(2 framework".(2 NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 33 10 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 1 This this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 2 warning warning NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 3 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 4 particularly particularly RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 5 pertinent pertinent JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 6 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 7 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 8 context context NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 9 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 10 which which WDT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 11 corruption corruption NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 12 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 13 nepotism nepotism NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 14 are be VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 15 rife rife JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 34 16 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 1 Policies policy NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 2 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 3 procedures procedure NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 4 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 5 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 6 allocation allocation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 7 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 8 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 9 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 10 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 11 crisis crisis NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 12 need need VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 13 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 14 clearly clearly RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 15 emphasize emphasize VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 16 equity equity NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 17 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 18 fairness fairness NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 19 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 20 exclude exclude VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 21 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 22 prioritizing prioritizing NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 23 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 24 persons person NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 25 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 26 high high JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 27 social social JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 28 status status NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 29 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 30 solely solely RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 31 on on IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 32 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 33 grounds ground NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 34 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 35 their -PRON- PRP$ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 36 status status NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 35 37 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 1 Recommendation recommendation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 2 three three CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 3 deals deal NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 4 with with IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 5 handling handle VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 6 patients patient NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 7 whose whose WP$ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 8 prognosis prognosis NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 9 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 10 much much RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 11 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 12 same same JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 36 13 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 1 The the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 2 authors author NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 3 assert assert VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 4 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 5 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 6 best good JJS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 7 way way NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 8 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 9 ensure ensure VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 10 equality equality NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 11 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 12 these these DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 13 cases case NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 14 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 15 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 16 use use VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 17 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 18 random random JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 19 method method NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 20 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 21 allocation allocation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 22 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 23 such such JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 24 as as IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 25 lottery lottery NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 37 26 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 1 They -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 2 reject reject VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 3 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 4 first first RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 5 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 6 come come VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 7 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 8 first first RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 9 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 10 served serve VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 11 process process NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 12 on on IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 13 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 14 grounds ground NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 15 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 16 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 17 advantages advantage VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 18 those those DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 19 closest close JJS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 20 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 21 health health NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 22 facilities facility NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 23 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 24 could could MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 25 encourage encourage VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 26 crowding crowd VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 27 at at IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 28 facilities facility NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 29 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 30 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 31 time time NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 32 when when WRB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 33 social social JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 34 distancing distancing NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 35 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 36 crucial.(2 crucial.(2 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 38 37 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 1 This this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 2 recommendation recommendation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 3 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 4 particularly particularly RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 5 apt apt JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 6 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 7 South South NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 8 Africa Africa NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 9 where where WRB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 10 transport transport NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 11 challenges challenge NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 12 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 13 distance distance NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 14 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 15 health health NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 16 facilities facility NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 17 already already RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 18 severely severely RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 19 disadvantage disadvantage VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 20 some some DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 21 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 22 our -PRON- PRP$ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 23 most most RBS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 24 vulnerable vulnerable JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 25 citizens citizen NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 39 26 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 1 Recommendation recommendation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 2 six six CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 3 asserts assert VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 4 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 5 fairness fairness NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 6 requires require VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 7 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 8 " " `` cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 9 there there EX cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 10 should should MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 11 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 12 no no DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 13 difference difference NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 14 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 15 allocating allocate VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 16 scarce scarce JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 17 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 18 between between IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 19 patients patient NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 20 with with IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 21 Covid-19 covid-19 NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 22 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 23 those those DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 24 with with IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 25 other other JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 26 medical medical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 27 conditions".(2 conditions".(2 NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 40 28 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 1 Since since IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 2 we -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 3 already already RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 4 have have VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 5 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 6 high high JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 7 burden burden NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 8 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 9 disease disease NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 10 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 11 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 12 country country NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 13 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 14 it -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 15 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 16 clear clear JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 17 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 18 there there EX cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 19 will will MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 20 continue continue VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 21 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 22 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 23 patients patient NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 24 that that WDT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 25 will will MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 26 face face VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 27 serious serious JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 28 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 29 life life NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 30 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 31 threatening threaten VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 32 conditions condition NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 33 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 34 not not RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 35 related relate VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 36 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 37 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 38 corona corona NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 39 virus virus NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 41 40 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 1 They -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 2 have have VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 3 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 4 same same JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 5 right right NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 6 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 7 fair fair JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 8 treatment treatment NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 9 as as IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 10 Covid-19 covid-19 NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 11 patients patient NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 42 12 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 1 Another another DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 2 important important JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 3 recommendation recommendation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 4 made make VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 5 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 6 several several JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 7 recent recent JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 8 publications publication NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 9 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 10 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 11 treating treat VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 12 clinicians clinician NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 13 should should MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 14 not not RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 15 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 16 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 17 decision decision NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 18 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 19 makers maker NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 20 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 21 rationing rationing NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 22 processes process NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 23 at at RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 24 all all RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 25 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 26 but but CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 27 rather rather RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 28 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 29 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 30 multidisciplinary multidisciplinary JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 31 triage triage NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 32 team team NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 33 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 34 experts expert NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 35 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 36 appointed appoint VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 37 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 38 fulfil fulfil VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 39 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 40 role.(4 role.(4 NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 41 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 42 6 6 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 43 43 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 1 The the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 2 Critical Critical NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 3 Care Care NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 4 Society Society NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 5 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 6 South South NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 7 Africa Africa NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 8 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 9 CCSSA CCSSA NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 10 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 11 acknowledges acknowledge VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 12 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 13 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 14 may may MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 15 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 16 difficult difficult JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 17 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 18 many many JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 19 contexts context NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 20 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 21 South South NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 22 Africa Africa NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 23 but but CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 24 advises advise VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 25 finding find VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 26 other other JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 27 ways way NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 28 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 29 ensuring ensure VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 30 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 31 treating treat VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 32 clinicians clinician NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 33 are be VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 34 kept keep VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 35 at at IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 36 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 37 remove remove NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 38 from from IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 39 these these DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 40 decisions decision NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 41 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 42 such such JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 43 as as IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 44 co co JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 45 - - JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 46 opting opting JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 47 experts expert NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 48 from from IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 49 other other JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 50 institutions institution NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 51 or or CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 52 geographical geographical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 53 areas area NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 54 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 55 perform perform VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 56 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 57 task task NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 44 58 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 45 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 45 2 6 6 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 45 3 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 1 Recent recent JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 2 publications publication NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 3 also also RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 4 raise raise VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 5 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 6 ethically ethically RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 7 fraught fraught JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 8 issue issue NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 9 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 10 possibly possibly RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 11 needing need VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 12 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 13 make make VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 14 decisions decision NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 15 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 16 discharging discharge VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 17 patients patient NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 18 from from IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 19 ICU ICU NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 20 beds bed NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 21 or or CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 22 ventilators ventilator NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 23 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 24 make make VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 25 way way NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 26 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 27 other other JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 28 patients patient NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 29 with with IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 30 better well JJR cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 31 prognoses prognosis NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 32 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 33 despite despite IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 34 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 35 risk risk NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 36 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 37 critical critical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 38 consequences consequence NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 46 39 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 1 Generally generally RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 2 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 3 they -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 4 propose propose VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 5 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 6 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 7 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 8 not not RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 9 only only RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 10 ethically ethically RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 11 justified justified JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 12 but but CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 47 13 also also RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 48 1 it -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 48 2 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 48 3 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 48 4 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 48 5 fact fact NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 48 6 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 48 7 morally morally RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 48 8 obligatory obligatory JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 48 9 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 2 2 2 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 3 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 4 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 5 4 4 LS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 6 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 7 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 8 5 5 LS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 9 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 10 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 11 6 6 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 49 12 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 50 1 Furthermore furthermore RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 50 2 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 50 3 Emanuel Emanuel NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 50 4 et et NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 50 5 al al NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 50 6 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 1 claim claim VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 2 that that IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 3 " " `` cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 4 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 5 decision decision NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 6 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 7 withdraw withdraw VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 8 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 9 scarce scarce JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 10 resource resource NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 11 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 12 save save VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 13 others other NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 14 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 15 not not RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 16 an an DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 17 act act NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 18 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 19 killing killing NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 20 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 21 does do VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 22 not not RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 23 require require VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 24 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 25 patient patient NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 26 's 's POS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 27 consent consent NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 28 " " '' cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 51 29 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 1 By by IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 2 now now RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 3 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 4 it -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 5 has have VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 6 become become VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 7 commonplace commonplace JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 8 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 9 make make VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 10 decisions decision NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 11 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 12 withdraw withdraw VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 13 life life NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 14 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 15 sustaining sustain VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 16 treatment treatment NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 17 where where WRB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 18 patient patient JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 19 or or CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 20 proxy proxy JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 21 consent consent NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 22 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 23 given give VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 24 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 25 or or CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 26 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 27 with with IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 28 or or CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 29 without without IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 30 consent consent NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 31 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 32 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 33 cases case NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 34 where where WRB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 35 continued continued JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 36 treatment treatment NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 37 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 38 futile futile JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 52 39 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 1 Decisions decision NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 2 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 3 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 4 nature nature NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 5 are be VBP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 6 made make VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 7 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 8 South South NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 9 Africa Africa NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 10 all all PDT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 11 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 12 time time NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 53 13 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 1 It -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 2 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 3 rare rare JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 4 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 5 make make VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 6 decisions decision NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 7 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 8 withdraw withdraw VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 9 treatment treatment NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 10 that that WDT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 11 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 12 not not RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 13 futile futile JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 14 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 15 order order NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 16 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 17 make make VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 18 way way NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 19 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 20 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 21 patient patient NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 22 with with IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 23 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 24 better well JJR cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 25 prognosis prognosis NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 54 26 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 1 However however RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 2 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 3 this this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 4 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 5 clearly clearly RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 6 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 7 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 8 line line NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 9 with with IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 10 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 11 principle principle NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 12 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 13 saving save VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 14 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 15 most most JJS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 16 lives life NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 17 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 18 maximizing maximize VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 19 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 20 benefits benefit NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 21 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 22 scarce scarce JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 23 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 24 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 25 an an DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 26 emergency emergency NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 55 27 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 1 If if IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 2 decisions decision NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 3 like like IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 4 these these DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 5 will will MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 6 need need VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 7 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 8 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 9 made make VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 10 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 11 it -PRON- PRP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 12 only only RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 13 serves serve VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 14 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 15 amplify amplify VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 16 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 17 need need NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 18 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 19 treating treat VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 20 physicians physician NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 21 to to TO cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 22 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 23 protected protect VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 24 by by IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 25 giving give VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 26 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 27 responsibility responsibility NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 28 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 29 triage triage NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 30 decisions decision NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 31 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 32 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 33 separate separate JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 34 committee committee NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 56 35 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 1 Furthermore furthermore RB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 2 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 3 patients patient NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 4 from from IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 5 whom whom WP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 6 treatment treatment NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 7 is be VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 8 withdrawn withdraw VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 9 should should MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 10 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 11 provided provide VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 12 with with IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 13 appropriate appropriate JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 14 palliative palliative JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 15 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 16 supportive supportive JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 17 care care NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 57 18 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 58 1 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 58 2 4 4 LS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 58 3 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 58 4 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 58 5 5 5 LS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 58 6 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 58 7 ( ( -LRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 58 8 6 6 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 58 9 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 1 This this DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 2 short short JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 3 article article NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 4 provides provide VBZ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 5 little little JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 6 more more JJR cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 7 than than IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 8 some some DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 9 general general JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 10 principles principle NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 11 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 12 recommendations recommendation NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 59 13 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 1 For for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 2 an an DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 3 excellent excellent JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 4 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 5 adaptable adaptable JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 6 example example NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 7 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 8 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 9 practical practical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 10 rationing rationing NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 11 procedure procedure NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 12 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 13 South South NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 14 Africa Africa NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 15 , , , cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 16 see see VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 17 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 18 CCSSA CCSSA NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 19 recommendations(6 recommendations(6 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 20 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 21 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 22 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 23 useful useful JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 24 summary summary NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 25 flow flow NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 26 chart.(7 chart.(7 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 60 27 ) ) -RRB- cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 1 Additional additional JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 2 ethics ethic NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 3 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 4 related relate VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 5 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 6 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 7 crisis crisis NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 8 can can MD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 9 be be VB cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 10 found find VBN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 11 at at IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 12 https://www.thehastingscenter https://www.thehastingscenter NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 61 13 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 1 org org NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 2 / / SYM cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 3 ethics ethic NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 4 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 5 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 6 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 7 on on IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 8 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 9 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 10 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 11 coronavirus/ coronavirus/ NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 12 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 13 https:// https:// NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 14 www.nuffieldbioethics.org/topics/health-and-society/ www.nuffieldbioethics.org/topics/health-and-society/ NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 15 covid-19 covid-19 NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 62 16 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 1 Ethical ethical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 2 framework framework NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 3 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 4 healthcare healthcare NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 5 institutions institution NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 6 and and CC cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 7 guidelines guideline NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 8 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 9 institutional institutional JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 10 ethics ethic NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 11 services service NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 12 responding respond VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 13 to to IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 14 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 15 Coronavirus Coronavirus NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 16 epidemic epidemic NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 63 17 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 1 The the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 2 Hasting Hasting NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 3 Center Center NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 4 Fair Fair NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 5 allocation allocation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 6 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 7 scarce scarce JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 8 medical medical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 9 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 10 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 11 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 12 time time NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 13 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 14 Covid-19 Covid-19 NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 15 New New NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 16 York York NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 17 State State NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 18 Department Department NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 19 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 64 20 Health Health NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 1 The the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 2 toughest tough JJS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 3 triage triage NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 4 -allocating -allocate VBG cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 5 ventilators ventilator NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 6 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 7 a a DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 8 pandemic pandemic NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 9 COVID-19 covid-19 CD cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 10 pandemic pandemic NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 11 : : : cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 12 triage triage NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 13 for for IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 14 intensive intensive JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 15 care care NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 16 treatment treatment NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 17 under under IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 18 resource resource NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 19 scarcity scarcity NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 20 Allocation allocation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 21 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 22 scarce scarce JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 23 critical critical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 24 care care NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 25 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 26 during during IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 27 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 28 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 29 public public JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 30 health health NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 31 emergency emergency NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 32 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 33 South South NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 34 Africa Africa NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 65 35 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 66 1 < < XX cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 67 1 https:// https:// NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 67 2 cr cr NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 68 1 itic itic NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 68 2 alc alc NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 68 3 are.org.z are.org.z NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 1 a a LS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 2 / / SYM cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 3 wp wp NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 4 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 5 content content NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 6 / / SYM cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 7 uploads/2020/04/ uploads/2020/04/ NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 8 Allocation allocation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 9 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 10 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 11 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 12 Scarce Scarce NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 13 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 14 Critical Critical NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 15 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 16 Care Care NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 17 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 18 Resources Resources NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 19 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 20 During during IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 21 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 22 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 23 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 24 COVID-19-Public COVID-19-Public NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 25 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 26 Health Health NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 27 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 28 Emergency Emergency NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 29 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 30 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 31 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 32 South South NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 33 - - HYPH cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 34 Africa Africa NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 69 35 . . . cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 70 1 pdf pdf NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 71 1 > > XX cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 1 Summary summary NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 2 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 3 allocation allocation NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 4 of of IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 5 scarce scarce JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 6 critical critical JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 7 care care NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 8 resources resource NNS cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 9 during during IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 10 the the DT cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 11 COVID-19 COVID-19 NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 12 public public JJ cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 13 health health NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 14 emergency emergency NN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 15 in in IN cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 16 South South NNP cord-024077-7o3qhfk3 72 17 Africa Africa NNP