key: cord-305165-3twlnkac
authors: Bourgueil, E.; Hutet, E.; Cariolet, R.; Vannier, P.
title: Experimental infection of pigs with the porcine respiratory coronavirus (PRCV): measure of viral excretion
date: 1992-04-30
journal: Veterinary Microbiology
DOI: 10.1016/0378-1135(92)90136-h
sha: 
doc_id: 305165
cord_uid: 3twlnkac

Abstract Twelve pigs were experimentally infected with a porcine respiratory coronavirus (PRCV) by the oronasal route. Viral excretion was measured daily by two means-deep nasal swabs and air samples obtained in a cyclone sampler. Clinical signs were very slight on infected pigs. Airborne virus could be recovered from day 1 to day 6 post-infection in the cyclone sampler as well as in petri dishes placed in the same loose-box. Viral titres obtained from nasal swabs were significantly correlated with those obtained from air samples. Different collection media were compared. The most efficient media for the collection of infectious viral particles contained a protective agent such as foetal calf serum.

Respiratory disorders due to viruses are the main problems recorded in areas of intensive porcine production. Common causes of the disease includes pseudorabies virus (PRV), influenza viruses and the porcine respiratory coronavirus (PRCV), the latter being first detected in different European countries in 1983-1984 (Brown et al., 1986; Duret et al., 1988; Pensaert et al., 1986) . Serological studies have demonstrated a close relationship between PRCV and transmissible gastroenteritis virus (TGEV) with the viruses being distinguished from each other only by the use of monoclonal antibodies (Laude et al., 1988; Garwes et al., 1988) . Recently, Rasschaert et al. (1990) compared the genomic organization of each virus and showed that PRCV had various nucleotide deletions when compared to TGEV. No conclusion could be made concerning the genomic modification (s) controlling the phenotypic difference observed between the viruses, namely the impaired multiplication of PRCV in the digestive tract. Until now, great attention has been given to clinical disorders induced by PRCV in the field (Jestin et al., 1987; Brown and Cartwright, 1986) and under experimental conditions (Vannier, 1990; Pensaert et al., 1986; O'Toole et al., 1989) , but nothing is known about excretion and airborne transmission of the virus. In order to better understand that aspect of the epidemiology of PRCV, we studied excretion of the virus in pigs experimentally infected with the virus.

Twenty one pigs from hysterectomy-derived sows were used. They were divided into two groups. One of twelve pigs was kept for experimental infection, and the other of nine pigs was used as control. The pigs were infected at 12 weeks old and an average weight of 41 kg. Each group was kept totally isolated from the other.

The strain isolated in France was used (Duret et al., 1988 ) as described by Vannier (1990) . This strain was derived from nasal swab liquid, amplified by three passages in swine testis (ST) cell line, kindly provided by Dr. Brun from Rh6ne-M6rieux-Lyon. The cytopathic effect (CPE), induced by the virus, was neutralized by hyperimmune sera, specific for TGE virus and PRCV. The viral suspension was adjusted to an infectious titre of 106 TCIDso/ml. Each pig received 5 ml of the preparation by nasal (2 ml in each nostril ) and oral routes ( 1 ml). The day of administration of virus was considered as day zero (D0).

From day 1 to day 8 post-infection, air samples were obtained with a stainless-steel cyclone sampler, constructed according to the model described by Errington and Powell ( 1969 ) . The air-flow rate of the apparatus was 3001 per minute. The airborne particles collected were eluted from the walls of the apparatus by addition of a collection medium with a peristaltic pump, adjusted to a flow-rate of 2 ml per minute. The cyclone sampler was placed about 1 m above floor level, between the two fiat-decks each of which contained six pigs.

Four collection media were tested: Medium 1 contained phosphate buffered saline (pH 7.2 ) and buffer HEPES (20 mM); Medium 2 was medium 1 plus 10% foetal calf serum (FCS); Medium 3 was medium 1 plus 0.5% gelatine and Medium 4 was medium 3 plus 10% FCS.

Each medium was supplemented with penicillin 100 IU/ml, streptomycin 0.1 mg/ml and neomycin 50 IU/ml. Petri dishes, containing 10 ml of each collecting fluid, were placed daily in each isolation unit at about 20 cm above floor level for 60 min. Parallelly, the cyclone sampler operated during 15 min for each medium. Ventilation of the loosebox was maintained during the sampling period.

Deep nasal swabs (about 10 cm) were collected from each pig, beginning on day 1 after infection and continuing for the next seven days. Each swab was weighed before and after collection in order to adjust the viral titres to a standard weight of 100 mg of mucus. Just after their collection, the cotton swabs were placed in 2 ml of minimum essential medium (MEM), supplemented with penicillin 100 IU/ml, streptomycin 0.1 mg/ml and with amphotericin B (125 pg/ml). Swabs were then stored at -70°C until titration on ST cells in microtitre plates. Infectious viral titre was determined according the method of Kaerber ( 1931 ) and expressed in TCIDso/100 mg of nasal mucus.

Air samples were assayed on 24 h-old monolayers of ST cell line in 6-well plates (Falcon). Areas with CPE were counted and plaque forming units (PFUs) were calculated after 3 d at 37°C under 5% CO2 and staining of the cell monolayer with methyl violet. Viral titres were expressed by the loglo value of PFU/m 3 of air. Samples were usually inoculated onto the cells a few hours after their collection. These results were compared with those obtained from deep nasal swabs.

Blood samples were collected weekly from all pigs, starting one day before infection and continuing for the next three weeks. Porcine respiratory coronavirus and TGEV neutralizing antibodies were assayed using the technique described by Toma and Benet (1976) on ST cells. Antibodies titres were expressed by the inverse value of the highest serum dilution neutralizing 100 TCIDso of the PRCV strain used for challenge.

Clinical signs and, in particular, respiratory signs and rectal temperature were recorded daily. Each pig was weighed at DO and D7, D 14 and D21 after infection. Weight losses following infection and the duration of hyperthermia were the main criteria for evaluating the effects of the virus.

Three weeks after the experimental infection, the 12 pigs were slaughtered and necropsied.

Only 9 of 12 pigs developed hyperthermia (rectal temperature > 40 °C ) 24 hours after infection. Such temperatures were recorded only at D1 and D3. At that time, all animals were prostrated. Subsequently some animals, and not always the same ones, developed rectal temperatures reaching 40 ° C. Control animals developed no clinical signs of infection with PRCV.

From DO to D7, the difference of mean growth rates calculated between control and infected animals was statistically significant (P< 0.01 ), with control pigs reaching a mean growth rate of 1095.24 g ( SD = 185.6 ) compared to infected pigs with only 726.19 g (SD= 174.5). After D7, no difference between each group was noticed.

Antibody titres detected in pigs in each group are recorded in Table 1 . All pigs seroconverted 2 weeks after infection, whereas control animals remained seronegative.

The quantities of airborne virus recovered from the isolated unit containing infected pigs are shown in Table 2 . Virus was recovered for 6 days after infection with the highest recoveries between days 2 and 4.

The quantity of virus recovered each day varied with the collection medium used. Media 3 and 4 collected airborne viral particles for the longest period post-infection (until D6). A statistical comparison of both media demonstrated that medium 4 gave the best results, in relation to the duration of viral detection and quantity of virus recovered. A high correlation rate (r= 0.83 ) was found between viral titres obtained from air samples collected with that medium and the amount of virus in nasal swabs (see tables 1 and 

Medium 2 was the most efficient considering the amount of virus collected, though virus was not detected before day 6. Table 4 records viral recoveries respectively obtained with each collection medium placed in settling plates. This collection method gave better results than the cyclone sampler i.e.: infectious virus could be detected from D1 to D6 with media 3 and 4, from D1 to D5 with medium 2 and only during the 3 days that followed infection in the case of medium 1. 

Lungs of slaughtered animals were observed individually. No lesions were seen in control pigs or infected pigs.

Our results underline the difficulty of inducing severe disorders with PRCV in pigs under experimental conditions. Indeed, animals presented only slight clinical signs (hyperthermia, loss of weight) for a short period. This phenomenon was observed previously by authors such as Pensaert et al. (1986 ), O'Toole et al. (1989 , Van Niewstadt et al. (1989) and Vannier (1990) . The good health of the animals used in the experiments could explain the absence of respiratory disorders. This is frequently observed with other viruses with respiratory tropism despite the absence of evident clinical signs, viral excretion occured during the test period.

The experimental procedure tested here has been used successfully by workers such as Donaldson et al. (1983) and Sellers and Parker (1969) respectively with Aujeszky's disease virus and with foot-and-mouth disease virus. Their findings showed differences in viral amounts excreted by infected pigs as detected in an all-glass cyclone sampler. Our results on the PRCV model are quite similar: airborne infectious virus could be recovered from air samples from D 1 to D6 post-infection and in quantities closely related to those found in deep nasal cavity.

Environmental conditions, i.e. relative humidity (RH) and temperature (T), are of prime importance on virus stability, once exhaled into air (Cox, 1989) . These parameters remained constant during the whole sampling period (RH = 47%, T = 20 ° C) in our experimental buildings and appeared to be suitable for maintaining the infectivity of PRCV.

Enveloped viruses, like coronaviruses, herpes viruses , Schoenbaum et al., 1990 and myxoviruses (Schaffer et al., 1976) , are known to be very sensitive to such environmental factors, mainly because of their outer phospholipid bilayer membranes. Phase changes occur when they are submitted to rehydration after desiccation, impaining or inactivating them. Indeed, lipid-containing viruses are well-known to be less stable at high RH.

The composition of the collection medium also seemed to be important for efficient collection of virus by cyclone sampling. Indeed, as demonstrated by Stolze and Kaaden ( 1989 ) for Sindbis and vesicular stomatitis virus, the addition of proteins or cryoprotective agents to samPling media improved the efficiency of collection of infectious virus. This was also demonstrated in the present study. Media 2 and 4, containing foetal calf serum, and gelatine + foetal calf serum respectively, produced the best viral recovery rates. A synergistic effect between each component could contribute to the stabilizing properties of these media during air sampling with the cyclone apparatus and with the petri-dishes.

Viral recoveries obtained with the settling-plates were relatively high, compared to those obtained with the cyclone device, suggesting that a major proportion of the airborne infectivity generated by the group of pigs was rapidly sedimenting, i.e., associated with large particles.

We did not attempt to measure the size of particles exhaled by the infected pigs. However data obtained by Robertson (1989) indicated that non-infected animals housed in the same isolation units generated large particles ( > 6 pm). This phenomenon is not surprising, considering the environmental atmosphere in which pigs were housed: food dust, faeces, skin squames and sneezing of animals, which is an important source of large aerosols.

The other important point of this study is the absence of correlation between viral excretion and clinical signs (mainly hyperthermia) i.e., the spread of PRCV among herd could be "silent". The relative vulnerability of the virus to environmental factors did not allow spreading in large amounts.

In conclusion, we can say that viral recovery directly from the air indicates airborne contamination better than viral titres calculated from nasal swabs. That latter collection technique reflects only a potential airborne viral quantity but not the real one.

The results we found with PRCV agree with Donaldson data with Aujeszky's Disease Virus (1983) but need some more investigation in field conditions. nowleged for the statistical treatment of experimental data. The Conseil G6-n6ral des C6tes d'Armor is also thanked for supplying the grant to the first author.

New porcine coronavirus?

Airborne bacteria and viruses Sci

Isolement, identification et pouvoir pathog6ne chez le porc d'un coronavirus apparent6 au virus de la Gastorent6rite transmissible

The survival of some airborne animal viruses in relation to relative humidity

Experimental Aujeszky's disease in pigs: excretion, survival and transmission of the virus

A cyclone separator for aerosol sampling in the feld

Differenciation of porcine coronavirus from transmissible gastroenteritis virus

Un nouveau coronavirus porcin

Beitrag zur kollektiven Behandlung pharmakologischer Reihenversuche

Caract6risation antig6nique du coronavirus respiratoire porcin ~ l'aide d'anticorps monoclonaux dirig6s contre le virus de la gastroent6rite transmissible

Pathogenicity of experimental infection with "pneumotropic" porcine coronavirus

Isolation of a porcine respiratory, non enteric coronavirus related to transmissible gastroenteritis

Porcine respiratory coronavirus differs from transmissible gastroenteritis virus by a few genomic deletions

Aerosol sampling in pig housing

Survival of airborne influenza virus: effects of propagating host, relative humidity, and composition of spray fluids

Survival of pseudorabies virus in aerosol

Airborne excretion of foot-and-mouth disease virus

Efficient medium for impingement and storage of enveloped viruses

Technique de recherche sur microplaques des anticorps neutralisant le virus de la Gastroent6rite Transmissible du porc. Rec. M6d. V6t

Disorders induced by the experimental infection of pigs with the porcine respiratory coronavirus

Infection with porcine respiratory coronavirus does not fully protect pigs against intestinal transmissible gastroenteritis virus

The excellent technical assistance of B. Beaurepaire and G. Benevent for caring for the animals was much appreciated. J.F. Pansart is greatfully ack-