id sid tid token lemma pos kim 1 1 Bohyun Bohyun NNP kim 1 2 Kim Kim NNP kim 1 3 , , , kim 1 4 AI AI NNP kim 1 5 and and CC kim 1 6 Its -PRON- PRP$ kim 1 7 Moral Moral NNP kim 1 8 Concerns Concerns NNPS kim 1 9 AI AI NNP kim 1 10 and and CC kim 1 11 Its -PRON- PRP$ kim 1 12 Moral Moral NNP kim 1 13 Concerns Concerns NNPS kim 1 14 Bohyun Bohyun NNP kim 1 15 Kim Kim NNP kim 1 16 1 1 CD kim 1 17 . . . kim 2 1 Automating automate VBG kim 2 2 Decisions Decisions NNPS kim 2 3 and and CC kim 2 4 Actions Actions NNPS kim 2 5 The the DT kim 2 6 goal goal NN kim 2 7 of of IN kim 2 8 artificial artificial JJ kim 2 9 intelligence intelligence NN kim 2 10 ( ( -LRB- kim 2 11 AI AI NNP kim 2 12 ) ) -RRB- kim 2 13 as as IN kim 2 14 a a DT kim 2 15 discipline discipline NN kim 2 16 is be VBZ kim 2 17 to to TO kim 2 18 create create VB kim 2 19 an an DT kim 2 20 artificial artificial JJ kim 2 21 system system NN kim 2 22 – – : kim 2 23 whether whether IN kim 2 24 it -PRON- PRP kim 2 25 be be VB kim 2 26 a a DT kim 2 27 piece piece NN kim 2 28 of of IN kim 2 29 software software NN kim 2 30 or or CC kim 2 31 a a DT kim 2 32 machine machine NN kim 2 33 with with IN kim 2 34 a a DT kim 2 35 physical physical JJ kim 2 36 body body NN kim 2 37 – – : kim 2 38 that that DT kim 2 39 is be VBZ kim 2 40 as as RB kim 2 41 intelligent intelligent JJ kim 2 42 as as IN kim 2 43 a a DT kim 2 44 human human NN kim 2 45 in in IN kim 2 46 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 2 47 performance performance NN kim 2 48 , , , kim 2 49 either either CC kim 2 50 broadly broadly RB kim 2 51 in in IN kim 2 52 all all DT kim 2 53 areas area NNS kim 2 54 of of IN kim 2 55 human human JJ kim 2 56 activities activity NNS kim 2 57 or or CC kim 2 58 narrowly narrowly RB kim 2 59 in in IN kim 2 60 a a DT kim 2 61 specific specific JJ kim 2 62 activity activity NN kim 2 63 , , , kim 2 64 such such JJ kim 2 65 as as IN kim 2 66 playing play VBG kim 2 67 chess chess NN kim 2 68 or or CC kim 2 69 driving driving NN kim 2 70 . . . kim 3 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 3 2 footnoteRef:0 footnoteref:0 NN kim 3 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 3 4 The the DT kim 3 5 actual actual JJ kim 3 6 capability capability NN kim 3 7 of of IN kim 3 8 most most JJS kim 3 9 AI AI NNP kim 3 10 systems system NNS kim 3 11 remained remain VBD kim 3 12 far far RB kim 3 13 below below IN kim 3 14 this this DT kim 3 15 ambitious ambitious JJ kim 3 16 goal goal NN kim 3 17 for for IN kim 3 18 a a DT kim 3 19 long long JJ kim 3 20 time time NN kim 3 21 . . . kim 4 1 But but CC kim 4 2 with with IN kim 4 3 recent recent JJ kim 4 4 successes success NNS kim 4 5 with with IN kim 4 6 machine machine NN kim 4 7 learning learning NN kim 4 8 and and CC kim 4 9 deep deep JJ kim 4 10 learning learning NN kim 4 11 , , , kim 4 12 the the DT kim 4 13 performance performance NN kim 4 14 of of IN kim 4 15 some some DT kim 4 16 AI AI NNP kim 4 17 programs program NNS kim 4 18 has have VBZ kim 4 19 started start VBN kim 4 20 surpassing surpass VBG kim 4 21 that that DT kim 4 22 of of IN kim 4 23 humans human NNS kim 4 24 . . . kim 5 1 In in IN kim 5 2 2016 2016 CD kim 5 3 , , , kim 5 4 an an DT kim 5 5 AI AI NNP kim 5 6 program program NN kim 5 7 developed develop VBN kim 5 8 with with IN kim 5 9 the the DT kim 5 10 deep deep JJ kim 5 11 learning learning NN kim 5 12 method method NN kim 5 13 , , , kim 5 14 AlphaGo AlphaGo NNP kim 5 15 , , , kim 5 16 astonished astonish VBD kim 5 17 even even RB kim 5 18 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 5 19 creators creator NNS kim 5 20 by by IN kim 5 21 winning win VBG kim 5 22 four four CD kim 5 23 out out IN kim 5 24 of of IN kim 5 25 five five CD kim 5 26 Go Go NNP kim 5 27 matches match NNS kim 5 28 with with IN kim 5 29 the the DT kim 5 30 eighteen eighteen CD kim 5 31 - - HYPH kim 5 32 time time NN kim 5 33 world world NN kim 5 34 champion champion NN kim 5 35 , , , kim 5 36   _SP kim 5 37 Sedol Sedol NNP kim 5 38 Lee Lee NNP kim 5 39 . . . kim 6 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 6 2 footnoteRef:1 footnoteRef:1 NNP kim 6 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 6 4 In in IN kim 6 5 2020 2020 CD kim 6 6 , , , kim 6 7 Google Google NNP kim 6 8 ’s ’s NNP kim 6 9 DeepMind DeepMind NNP kim 6 10 unveiled unveil VBD kim 6 11 Atari57 Atari57 NNP kim 6 12 , , , kim 6 13 a a DT kim 6 14 deep deep JJ kim 6 15 reinforcement reinforcement NN kim 6 16 learning learn VBG kim 6 17 algorithm algorithm NN kim 6 18 that that WDT kim 6 19 reached reach VBD kim 6 20 superhuman superhuman JJ kim 6 21 levels level NNS kim 6 22 of of IN kim 6 23 play play NN kim 6 24 in in IN kim 6 25 57 57 CD kim 6 26 classic classic JJ kim 6 27 Atari Atari NNP kim 6 28 games game NNS kim 6 29 . . . kim 7 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 7 2 footnoteRef:2 footnoteRef:2 VBN kim 7 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 7 4 [ [ -LRB- kim 7 5 0 0 CD kim 7 6 : : : kim 7 7 Note note VB kim 7 8 that that IN kim 7 9 by by IN kim 7 10 ‘ ' `` kim 7 11 as as RB kim 7 12 intelligent intelligent JJ kim 7 13 as as IN kim 7 14 a a DT kim 7 15 human human NN kim 7 16 , , , kim 7 17 ’ ' '' kim 7 18 I -PRON- PRP kim 7 19 simply simply RB kim 7 20 mean mean VBP kim 7 21 human human JJ kim 7 22 - - HYPH kim 7 23 level level NN kim 7 24 AI ai NN kim 7 25 , , , kim 7 26 or or CC kim 7 27 more more RBR kim 7 28 accurately accurately RB kim 7 29 , , , kim 7 30 AI AI NNP kim 7 31 at at IN kim 7 32 human human JJ kim 7 33 - - HYPH kim 7 34 level level NN kim 7 35 performance performance NN kim 7 36 . . . kim 8 1 By by IN kim 8 2 ‘ ' `` kim 8 3 as as RB kim 8 4 intelligent intelligent JJ kim 8 5 as as IN kim 8 6 a a DT kim 8 7 human human NN kim 8 8 , , , kim 8 9 ’ ' '' kim 8 10 I -PRON- PRP kim 8 11 do do VBP kim 8 12 not not RB kim 8 13 mean mean VB kim 8 14 general(/strong general(/strong . kim 8 15 ) ) -RRB- kim 8 16 AI AI NNP kim 8 17 . . . kim 9 1 General General NNP kim 9 2 AI AI NNP kim 9 3 – – : kim 9 4 also also RB kim 9 5 known know VBN kim 9 6 as as IN kim 9 7 ‘ ' `` kim 9 8 artificial artificial JJ kim 9 9 general general JJ kim 9 10 intelligence intelligence NN kim 9 11 ( ( -LRB- kim 9 12 AGI AGI NNP kim 9 13 ) ) -RRB- kim 9 14 ’ ' '' kim 9 15 and and CC kim 9 16 ‘ ' `` kim 9 17 strong strong JJ kim 9 18 AI AI NNP kim 9 19 ’ ' '' kim 9 20 – – : kim 9 21 refers refer VBZ kim 9 22 to to IN kim 9 23 the the DT kim 9 24 ability ability NN kim 9 25 to to TO kim 9 26 adapt adapt VB kim 9 27 to to TO kim 9 28 achieve achieve VB kim 9 29 any any DT kim 9 30 goals goal NNS kim 9 31 ; ; : kim 9 32 it -PRON- PRP kim 9 33 does do VBZ kim 9 34 not not RB kim 9 35 refer refer VB kim 9 36 to to IN kim 9 37 human human JJ kim 9 38 - - HYPH kim 9 39 level level NN kim 9 40 performance performance NN kim 9 41 in in IN kim 9 42 achieving achieve VBG kim 9 43 one one CD kim 9 44 particular particular JJ kim 9 45 goal goal NN kim 9 46 . . . kim 10 1 An an DT kim 10 2 AI AI NNP kim 10 3 system system NN kim 10 4 developed develop VBD kim 10 5 to to TO kim 10 6 perform perform VB kim 10 7 one one CD kim 10 8 specific specific JJ kim 10 9 type type NN kim 10 10 of of IN kim 10 11 activity activity NN kim 10 12 or or CC kim 10 13 activities activity NNS kim 10 14 in in IN kim 10 15 one one CD kim 10 16 specific specific JJ kim 10 17 domain domain NN kim 10 18 is be VBZ kim 10 19 called call VBN kim 10 20 a a DT kim 10 21 ‘ ' `` kim 10 22 narrow narrow JJ kim 10 23 ( ( -LRB- kim 10 24 /weak /weak NFP kim 10 25 ) ) -RRB- kim 10 26 AI AI NNP kim 10 27 ’ ' '' kim 10 28 system system NN kim 10 29 . . . kim 10 30 ] ] -RRB- kim 11 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 11 2 1 1 CD kim 11 3 : : : kim 11 4 AlphaGo alphago PRP kim 11 5 can can MD kim 11 6 be be VB kim 11 7 said say VBN kim 11 8 to to TO kim 11 9 be be VB kim 11 10 “ " `` kim 11 11 as as RB kim 11 12 intelligent intelligent JJ kim 11 13 as as IN kim 11 14 humans human NNS kim 11 15 , , , kim 11 16 ” " '' kim 11 17 but but CC kim 11 18 only only RB kim 11 19 in in IN kim 11 20 playing play VBG kim 11 21 Go Go NNP kim 11 22 , , , kim 11 23 where where WRB kim 11 24 it -PRON- PRP kim 11 25 exceeds exceed VBZ kim 11 26 human human JJ kim 11 27 capability capability NN kim 11 28 . . . kim 12 1 So so CC kim 12 2 , , , kim 12 3 it -PRON- PRP kim 12 4 does do VBZ kim 12 5 not not RB kim 12 6 qualify qualify VB kim 12 7 as as IN kim 12 8 general general JJ kim 12 9 / / SYM kim 12 10 strong strong JJ kim 12 11 AI AI NNP kim 12 12 in in IN kim 12 13 spite spite NN kim 12 14 of of IN kim 12 15 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 12 16 human human JJ kim 12 17 - - HYPH kim 12 18 level level NN kim 12 19 intelligence intelligence NN kim 12 20 in in IN kim 12 21 Go go NN kim 12 22 - - HYPH kim 12 23 playing playing NN kim 12 24 . . . kim 13 1 It -PRON- PRP kim 13 2 is be VBZ kim 13 3 to to TO kim 13 4 be be VB kim 13 5 noted note VBN kim 13 6 that that IN kim 13 7 general(/strong general(/strong NN kim 13 8 ) ) -RRB- kim 13 9 AI AI NNP kim 13 10 and and CC kim 13 11 narrow(/weak narrow(/weak JJ kim 13 12 ) ) -RRB- kim 13 13 AI AI NNP kim 13 14 signify signify VB kim 13 15 the the DT kim 13 16 difference difference NN kim 13 17 in in IN kim 13 18 the the DT kim 13 19 scope scope NN kim 13 20 of of IN kim 13 21 AI AI NNP kim 13 22 capability capability NN kim 13 23 . . . kim 14 1 General(/strong General(/strong NFP kim 14 2 ) ) -RRB- kim 14 3 AI AI NNP kim 14 4 is be VBZ kim 14 5 a a DT kim 14 6 broader broad JJR kim 14 7 concept concept NN kim 14 8 than than IN kim 14 9 human human NN kim 14 10 - - HYPH kim 14 11 like like JJ kim 14 12 intelligence intelligence NN kim 14 13 , , , kim 14 14 either either CC kim 14 15 with with IN kim 14 16 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 14 17 carbon carbon NN kim 14 18 - - HYPH kim 14 19 based base VBN kim 14 20 substrate substrate NN kim 14 21 or or CC kim 14 22 with with IN kim 14 23 human human NN kim 14 24 - - HYPH kim 14 25 like like JJ kim 14 26 understanding understanding NN kim 14 27 that that WDT kim 14 28 relies rely VBZ kim 14 29 on on IN kim 14 30 what what WP kim 14 31 we -PRON- PRP kim 14 32 regard regard VBP kim 14 33 as as IN kim 14 34 uniquely uniquely RB kim 14 35 human human JJ kim 14 36 cognitive cognitive JJ kim 14 37 states state NNS kim 14 38 such such JJ kim 14 39 as as IN kim 14 40 consciousness consciousness NN kim 14 41 , , , kim 14 42 qualia quale NNS kim 14 43 , , , kim 14 44 emotions emotion NNS kim 14 45 , , , kim 14 46 and and CC kim 14 47 so so RB kim 14 48 on on RB kim 14 49 . . . kim 15 1 For for IN kim 15 2 more more RBR kim 15 3 helpful helpful JJ kim 15 4 descriptions description NNS kim 15 5 of of IN kim 15 6 common common JJ kim 15 7 terms term NNS kim 15 8 in in IN kim 15 9 AI AI NNP kim 15 10 , , , kim 15 11 see see VB kim 15 12 Tegmark Tegmark NNP kim 15 13 2017 2017 CD kim 15 14 , , , kim 15 15 39 39 CD kim 15 16 . . . kim 16 1 For for IN kim 16 2 more more JJR kim 16 3 on on IN kim 16 4 the the DT kim 16 5 match match NN kim 16 6 between between IN kim 16 7 AlphaGo AlphaGo NNP kim 16 8 and and CC kim 16 9 Sedol Sedol NNP kim 16 10 Lee Lee NNP kim 16 11 , , , kim 16 12 see see VB kim 16 13 Koch Koch NNP kim 16 14 2016 2016 CD kim 16 15 . . . kim 16 16 ] ] -RRB- kim 17 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 17 2 2 2 CD kim 17 3 : : : kim 17 4 Deep deep JJ kim 17 5 reinforcement reinforcement NN kim 17 6 learning learning NN kim 17 7 is be VBZ kim 17 8 a a DT kim 17 9 type type NN kim 17 10 of of IN kim 17 11 deep deep JJ kim 17 12 learning learning NN kim 17 13 that that WDT kim 17 14 is be VBZ kim 17 15 goal goal NN kim 17 16 - - HYPH kim 17 17 oriented orient VBN kim 17 18 and and CC kim 17 19 reward reward NN kim 17 20 - - HYPH kim 17 21 based base VBN kim 17 22 . . . kim 18 1 See see VB kim 18 2 Heaven Heaven NNP kim 18 3 2020 2020 CD kim 18 4 . . . kim 18 5 ] ] -RRB- kim 19 1 Early early JJ kim 19 2 symbolic symbolic JJ kim 19 3 AI AI NNP kim 19 4 systems system NNS kim 19 5 determined determine VBD kim 19 6 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 19 7 outputs output NNS kim 19 8 based base VBN kim 19 9 upon upon IN kim 19 10 given give VBN kim 19 11 rules rule NNS kim 19 12 and and CC kim 19 13 logical logical JJ kim 19 14 inference inference NN kim 19 15 . . . kim 20 1 AI AI NNP kim 20 2 algorithms algorithm NNS kim 20 3 in in IN kim 20 4 these these DT kim 20 5 rule rule NN kim 20 6 - - HYPH kim 20 7 based base VBN kim 20 8 systems system NNS kim 20 9 , , , kim 20 10 also also RB kim 20 11 known know VBN kim 20 12 as as IN kim 20 13 good good JJ kim 20 14 old old JJ kim 20 15 - - HYPH kim 20 16 fashioned fashioned JJ kim 20 17 AI AI NNP kim 20 18 ( ( -LRB- kim 20 19 GOFAI GOFAI NNP kim 20 20 ) ) -RRB- kim 20 21 , , , kim 20 22 were be VBD kim 20 23 pre pre VBN kim 20 24 - - VBN kim 20 25 determined determined JJ kim 20 26 , , , kim 20 27 predictable predictable JJ kim 20 28 , , , kim 20 29 and and CC kim 20 30 transparent transparent JJ kim 20 31 . . . kim 21 1 On on IN kim 21 2 the the DT kim 21 3 other other JJ kim 21 4 hand hand NN kim 21 5 , , , kim 21 6 machine machine NN kim 21 7 learning learning NN kim 21 8 , , , kim 21 9 another another DT kim 21 10 approach approach NN kim 21 11 in in IN kim 21 12 AI AI NNP kim 21 13 , , , kim 21 14 enables enable VBZ kim 21 15 an an DT kim 21 16 AI ai NN kim 21 17 algorithm algorithm NN kim 21 18 to to TO kim 21 19 evolve evolve VB kim 21 20 . . . kim 22 1 It -PRON- PRP kim 22 2 learns learn VBZ kim 22 3 to to TO kim 22 4 adjust adjust VB kim 22 5 itself -PRON- PRP kim 22 6 to to TO kim 22 7 identify identify VB kim 22 8 certain certain JJ kim 22 9 patterns pattern NNS kim 22 10 through through IN kim 22 11 the the DT kim 22 12 so so RB kim 22 13 - - HYPH kim 22 14 called call VBN kim 22 15 ‘ ' `` kim 22 16 training training NN kim 22 17 ’ ' '' kim 22 18 process process NN kim 22 19 , , , kim 22 20 which which WDT kim 22 21 relies rely VBZ kim 22 22 on on IN kim 22 23 a a DT kim 22 24 large large JJ kim 22 25 amount amount NN kim 22 26 of of IN kim 22 27 data datum NNS kim 22 28 and and CC kim 22 29 statistics statistic NNS kim 22 30 . . . kim 23 1 Deep deep JJ kim 23 2 learning learning NN kim 23 3 , , , kim 23 4 one one CD kim 23 5 of of IN kim 23 6 the the DT kim 23 7 widely widely RB kim 23 8 - - HYPH kim 23 9 used use VBN kim 23 10 techniques technique NNS kim 23 11 in in IN kim 23 12 machine machine NN kim 23 13 learning learning NN kim 23 14 , , , kim 23 15 further further JJ kim 23 16 refines refine NNS kim 23 17 this this DT kim 23 18 training training NN kim 23 19 process process NN kim 23 20 using use VBG kim 23 21 a a DT kim 23 22 ‘ ' `` kim 23 23 neural neural JJ kim 23 24 network network NN kim 23 25 . . . kim 23 26 ’[footnoteRef:3 ’[footnoteref:3 ADD kim 23 27 ] ] -RRB- kim 23 28 Machine machine NN kim 23 29 learning learning NN kim 23 30 and and CC kim 23 31 deep deep JJ kim 23 32 learning learning NN kim 23 33 have have VBP kim 23 34 brought bring VBN kim 23 35 significant significant JJ kim 23 36 improvements improvement NNS kim 23 37 to to IN kim 23 38 the the DT kim 23 39 performance performance NN kim 23 40 of of IN kim 23 41 AI AI NNP kim 23 42 systems system NNS kim 23 43 in in IN kim 23 44 areas area NNS kim 23 45 such such JJ kim 23 46 as as IN kim 23 47 translation translation NN kim 23 48 , , , kim 23 49 speech speech NN kim 23 50 recognition recognition NN kim 23 51 , , , kim 23 52 and and CC kim 23 53 detecting detect VBG kim 23 54 objects object NNS kim 23 55 and and CC kim 23 56 predicting predict VBG kim 23 57 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 23 58 movements movement NNS kim 23 59 . . . kim 24 1 Some some DT kim 24 2 people people NNS kim 24 3 assume assume VBP kim 24 4 that that IN kim 24 5 machine machine NN kim 24 6 learning learn VBG kim 24 7 completely completely RB kim 24 8 replaced replace VBD kim 24 9 GOFAI GOFAI NNP kim 24 10 , , , kim 24 11 but but CC kim 24 12 this this DT kim 24 13 is be VBZ kim 24 14 a a DT kim 24 15 misunderstanding misunderstanding NN kim 24 16 . . . kim 25 1 Symbolic symbolic JJ kim 25 2 reasoning reasoning NN kim 25 3 and and CC kim 25 4 machine machine NN kim 25 5 learning learning NN kim 25 6 are be VBP kim 25 7 two two CD kim 25 8 distinct distinct JJ kim 25 9 but but CC kim 25 10 not not RB kim 25 11 mutually mutually RB kim 25 12 exclusive exclusive JJ kim 25 13 approaches approach NNS kim 25 14 , , , kim 25 15 and and CC kim 25 16 they -PRON- PRP kim 25 17 can can MD kim 25 18 be be VB kim 25 19 used use VBN kim 25 20 together together RB kim 25 21 ( ( -LRB- kim 25 22 Knight Knight NNP kim 25 23 2019a 2019a CD kim 25 24 ) ) -RRB- kim 25 25 . . . kim 26 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 26 2 3 3 CD kim 26 3 : : : kim 26 4 Machine machine NN kim 26 5 learning learning NN kim 26 6 and and CC kim 26 7 deep deep JJ kim 26 8 learning learning NN kim 26 9 have have VBP kim 26 10 gained gain VBN kim 26 11 momentum momentum NN kim 26 12 as as IN kim 26 13 the the DT kim 26 14 cost cost NN kim 26 15 of of IN kim 26 16 high high JJ kim 26 17 - - HYPH kim 26 18 performance performance NN kim 26 19 computing computing NN kim 26 20 has have VBZ kim 26 21 gone go VBN kim 26 22 down down RB kim 26 23 and and CC kim 26 24 large large JJ kim 26 25 data data NN kim 26 26 sets set NNS kim 26 27 have have VBP kim 26 28 become become VBN kim 26 29 available available JJ kim 26 30 . . . kim 27 1 For for IN kim 27 2 example example NN kim 27 3 , , , kim 27 4 the the DT kim 27 5 data datum NNS kim 27 6 in in IN kim 27 7 the the DT kim 27 8 ImageNet ImageNet NNP kim 27 9 contains contain VBZ kim 27 10 more more JJR kim 27 11 than than IN kim 27 12 14 14 CD kim 27 13 million million CD kim 27 14 hand hand NN kim 27 15 - - HYPH kim 27 16 annotated annotate VBN kim 27 17 images image NNS kim 27 18 . . . kim 28 1 The the DT kim 28 2 ImageNet ImageNet NNP kim 28 3 data datum NNS kim 28 4 have have VBP kim 28 5 been be VBN kim 28 6 used use VBN kim 28 7 for for IN kim 28 8 the the DT kim 28 9 well well RB kim 28 10 - - HYPH kim 28 11 known know VBN kim 28 12 annual annual JJ kim 28 13 AI AI NNP kim 28 14 competition competition NN kim 28 15 for for IN kim 28 16 object object NN kim 28 17 detection detection NN kim 28 18 and and CC kim 28 19 image image NN kim 28 20 classification classification NN kim 28 21 at at IN kim 28 22 large large JJ kim 28 23 scale scale NN kim 28 24 from from IN kim 28 25 2010 2010 CD kim 28 26 to to IN kim 28 27 2017 2017 CD kim 28 28 . . . kim 29 1 See see VB kim 29 2 http://www.image-net.org/challenges/LSVRC/. http://www.image-net.org/challenges/lsvrc/. NN kim 29 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 30 1 With with IN kim 30 2 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 30 3 limited limit VBN kim 30 4 intelligence intelligence NN kim 30 5 and and CC kim 30 6 fully fully RB kim 30 7 deterministic deterministic JJ kim 30 8 nature nature NN kim 30 9 , , , kim 30 10 early early JJ kim 30 11 rule rule NN kim 30 12 - - HYPH kim 30 13 based base VBN kim 30 14 symbolic symbolic JJ kim 30 15 AI AI NNP kim 30 16 systems system NNS kim 30 17 raised raise VBD kim 30 18 few few JJ kim 30 19 ethical ethical JJ kim 30 20 concerns concern NNS kim 30 21 . . . kim 31 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 31 2 footnoteRef:4 footnoteRef:4 NNS kim 31 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 31 4 AI AI NNP kim 31 5 systems system NNS kim 31 6 that that IN kim 31 7 near near RB kim 31 8 or or CC kim 31 9 surpass surpass VB kim 31 10 human human JJ kim 31 11 capability capability NN kim 31 12 , , , kim 31 13 on on IN kim 31 14 the the DT kim 31 15 other other JJ kim 31 16 hand hand NN kim 31 17 , , , kim 31 18 are be VBP kim 31 19 likely likely JJ kim 31 20 to to TO kim 31 21 be be VB kim 31 22 given give VBN kim 31 23 the the DT kim 31 24 autonomy autonomy NN kim 31 25 to to TO kim 31 26 make make VB kim 31 27 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 31 28 own own JJ kim 31 29 decisions decision NNS kim 31 30 without without IN kim 31 31 humans human NNS kim 31 32 , , , kim 31 33 even even RB kim 31 34 when when WRB kim 31 35 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 31 36 workings working NNS kim 31 37 are be VBP kim 31 38 not not RB kim 31 39 entirely entirely RB kim 31 40 transparent transparent JJ kim 31 41 , , , kim 31 42 and and CC kim 31 43 some some DT kim 31 44 of of IN kim 31 45 those those DT kim 31 46 decisions decision NNS kim 31 47 are be VBP kim 31 48 distinctively distinctively RB kim 31 49 moral moral JJ kim 31 50 in in IN kim 31 51 character character NN kim 31 52 . . . kim 32 1 As as IN kim 32 2 humans human NNS kim 32 3 , , , kim 32 4 we -PRON- PRP kim 32 5 are be VBP kim 32 6 trained train VBN kim 32 7 to to TO kim 32 8 recognize recognize VB kim 32 9 situations situation NNS kim 32 10 that that WDT kim 32 11 demand demand VBP kim 32 12 moral moral JJ kim 32 13 decision decision NN kim 32 14 - - HYPH kim 32 15 making making NN kim 32 16 . . . kim 33 1 But but CC kim 33 2 how how WRB kim 33 3 would would MD kim 33 4 an an DT kim 33 5 AI ai NN kim 33 6 system system NN kim 33 7 be be VB kim 33 8 able able JJ kim 33 9 to to TO kim 33 10 do do VB kim 33 11 so so RB kim 33 12 , , , kim 33 13 and and CC kim 33 14 should should MD kim 33 15 they -PRON- PRP kim 33 16 be be VB kim 33 17 allowed allow VBN kim 33 18 to to IN kim 33 19 ? ? . kim 34 1 With with IN kim 34 2 self self NN kim 34 3 - - HYPH kim 34 4 driving drive VBG kim 34 5 cars car NNS kim 34 6 and and CC kim 34 7 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 34 8 weapons weapon NNS kim 34 9 systems system NNS kim 34 10 under under IN kim 34 11 active active JJ kim 34 12 development development NN kim 34 13 and and CC kim 34 14 testing testing NN kim 34 15 , , , kim 34 16 these these DT kim 34 17 are be VBP kim 34 18 no no RB kim 34 19 longer long RBR kim 34 20 idle idle JJ kim 34 21 questions question NNS kim 34 22 . . . kim 35 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 35 2 4 4 CD kim 35 3 : : : kim 35 4 For for IN kim 35 5 an an DT kim 35 6 excellent excellent JJ kim 35 7 history history NN kim 35 8 of of IN kim 35 9 AI AI NNP kim 35 10 research research NN kim 35 11 , , , kim 35 12 see see VB kim 35 13 chapter chapter NN kim 35 14 1 1 CD kim 35 15 , , , kim 35 16 “ " `` kim 35 17 What what WP kim 35 18 is be VBZ kim 35 19 Artificial Artificial NNP kim 35 20 Intelligence Intelligence NNP kim 35 21 , , , kim 35 22 ” " '' kim 35 23 of of IN kim 35 24 Boden Boden NNP kim 35 25 2016 2016 CD kim 35 26 , , , kim 35 27 1 1 CD kim 35 28 - - SYM kim 35 29 20 20 CD kim 35 30 . . . kim 35 31 ] ] -RRB- kim 36 1 2 2 LS kim 36 2 . . . kim 37 1 The the DT kim 37 2 Trolley Trolley NNP kim 37 3 Problem Problem NNP kim 37 4 Recent recent JJ kim 37 5 advances advance NNS kim 37 6 of of IN kim 37 7 AI AI NNP kim 37 8 , , , kim 37 9 such such JJ kim 37 10 as as IN kim 37 11 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 37 12 cars car NNS kim 37 13 , , , kim 37 14 have have VBP kim 37 15 brought bring VBN kim 37 16 new new JJ kim 37 17 interest interest NN kim 37 18 to to IN kim 37 19 the the DT kim 37 20 trolley trolley NN kim 37 21 problem problem NN kim 37 22 , , , kim 37 23 a a DT kim 37 24 thought thought NN kim 37 25 experiment experiment NN kim 37 26 introduced introduce VBN kim 37 27 by by IN kim 37 28 Philippa Philippa NNP kim 37 29 Foot Foot NNP kim 37 30 in in IN kim 37 31 1967 1967 CD kim 37 32 . . . kim 38 1 In in IN kim 38 2 the the DT kim 38 3 standard standard JJ kim 38 4 version version NN kim 38 5 of of IN kim 38 6 this this DT kim 38 7 problem problem NN kim 38 8 , , , kim 38 9 a a DT kim 38 10 runaway runaway JJ kim 38 11 trolley trolley NN kim 38 12 barrels barrel NNS kim 38 13 down down IN kim 38 14 a a DT kim 38 15 track track NN kim 38 16 where where WRB kim 38 17 five five CD kim 38 18 unsuspecting unsuspecting JJ kim 38 19 people people NNS kim 38 20 are be VBP kim 38 21 standing stand VBG kim 38 22 . . . kim 39 1 You -PRON- PRP kim 39 2 happen happen VBP kim 39 3 to to TO kim 39 4 be be VB kim 39 5 standing stand VBG kim 39 6 next next RB kim 39 7 to to IN kim 39 8 a a DT kim 39 9 lever lever NN kim 39 10 that that WDT kim 39 11 switches switch VBZ kim 39 12 the the DT kim 39 13 trolley trolley NN kim 39 14 onto onto IN kim 39 15 a a DT kim 39 16 different different JJ kim 39 17 track track NN kim 39 18 , , , kim 39 19 where where WRB kim 39 20 there there EX kim 39 21 is be VBZ kim 39 22 only only RB kim 39 23 one one CD kim 39 24 person person NN kim 39 25 . . . kim 40 1 Those those DT kim 40 2 who who WP kim 40 3 are be VBP kim 40 4 on on IN kim 40 5 either either DT kim 40 6 track track NN kim 40 7 will will MD kim 40 8 be be VB kim 40 9 killed kill VBN kim 40 10 if if IN kim 40 11 the the DT kim 40 12 trolley trolley NN kim 40 13 heads head VBZ kim 40 14 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 40 15 way way NN kim 40 16 . . . kim 41 1 Should Should MD kim 41 2 you -PRON- PRP kim 41 3 pull pull VB kim 41 4 the the DT kim 41 5 lever lever NN kim 41 6 , , , kim 41 7 so so IN kim 41 8 that that IN kim 41 9 the the DT kim 41 10 runaway runaway JJ kim 41 11 trolley trolley NN kim 41 12 would would MD kim 41 13 kill kill VB kim 41 14 one one CD kim 41 15 person person NN kim 41 16 instead instead RB kim 41 17 of of IN kim 41 18 five five CD kim 41 19 ? ? . kim 42 1 Unlike unlike IN kim 42 2 people people NNS kim 42 3 , , , kim 42 4 a a DT kim 42 5 machine machine NN kim 42 6 does do VBZ kim 42 7 not not RB kim 42 8 panic panic VB kim 42 9 or or CC kim 42 10 freeze freeze VB kim 42 11 and and CC kim 42 12 simply simply RB kim 42 13 follows follow VBZ kim 42 14 and and CC kim 42 15 executes execute VBZ kim 42 16 the the DT kim 42 17 given give VBN kim 42 18 instruction instruction NN kim 42 19 . . . kim 43 1 So so RB kim 43 2 , , , kim 43 3 this this DT kim 43 4 opens open VBZ kim 43 5 up up RP kim 43 6 the the DT kim 43 7 possibility possibility NN kim 43 8 of of IN kim 43 9 building build VBG kim 43 10 an an DT kim 43 11 AI AI NNP kim 43 12 - - HYPH kim 43 13 powered power VBN kim 43 14 trolley trolley NN kim 43 15 that that WDT kim 43 16 can can MD kim 43 17 act act VB kim 43 18 morally morally RB kim 43 19 . . . kim 44 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 44 2 footnoteRef:5 footnoteRef:5 NNP kim 44 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 44 4 The the DT kim 44 5 question question NN kim 44 6 itself -PRON- PRP kim 44 7 remains remain VBZ kim 44 8 , , , kim 44 9 however however RB kim 44 10 . . . kim 45 1 Should Should MD kim 45 2 one one CD kim 45 3 program program NN kim 45 4 the the DT kim 45 5 AI ai NN kim 45 6 - - HYPH kim 45 7 powered power VBN kim 45 8 trolley trolley NN kim 45 9 to to TO kim 45 10 swerve swerve VB kim 45 11 or or CC kim 45 12 stay stay VB kim 45 13 on on RP kim 45 14 course course NN kim 45 15 ? ? . kim 46 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 46 2 5 5 CD kim 46 3 : : : kim 46 4 Programming programming NN kim 46 5 here here RB kim 46 6 does do VBZ kim 46 7 not not RB kim 46 8 exclusively exclusively RB kim 46 9 mean mean VB kim 46 10 a a DT kim 46 11 deep deep JJ kim 46 12 learning learning NN kim 46 13 or or CC kim 46 14 machine machine NN kim 46 15 learning learning NN kim 46 16 approach approach NN kim 46 17 . . . kim 46 18 ] ] -RRB- kim 47 1 Different different JJ kim 47 2 moral moral JJ kim 47 3 theories theory NNS kim 47 4 , , , kim 47 5 such such JJ kim 47 6 as as IN kim 47 7 virtue virtue NN kim 47 8 ethics ethic NNS kim 47 9 , , , kim 47 10 contractarianism contractarianism NN kim 47 11 , , , kim 47 12 and and CC kim 47 13 moral moral JJ kim 47 14 relativism relativism NN kim 47 15 , , , kim 47 16 take take VBP kim 47 17 different different JJ kim 47 18 positions position NNS kim 47 19 . . . kim 48 1 Here here RB kim 48 2 , , , kim 48 3 I -PRON- PRP kim 48 4 will will MD kim 48 5 consider consider VB kim 48 6 utilitarianism utilitarianism NN kim 48 7 and and CC kim 48 8 deontology deontology NN kim 48 9 since since IN kim 48 10 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 48 11 tenets tenet NNS kim 48 12 are be VBP kim 48 13 relatively relatively RB kim 48 14 straightforward straightforward JJ kim 48 15 and and CC kim 48 16 most most JJS kim 48 17 AI AI NNP kim 48 18 developers developer NNS kim 48 19 are be VBP kim 48 20 likely likely JJ kim 48 21 to to TO kim 48 22 look look VB kim 48 23 towards towards IN kim 48 24 those those DT kim 48 25 two two CD kim 48 26 moral moral JJ kim 48 27 theories theory NNS kim 48 28 for for IN kim 48 29 guidance guidance NN kim 48 30 and and CC kim 48 31 insight insight NN kim 48 32 . . . kim 49 1 Utilitarianism Utilitarianism NNP kim 49 2 argues argue VBZ kim 49 3 that that IN kim 49 4 the the DT kim 49 5 utility utility NN kim 49 6 of of IN kim 49 7 an an DT kim 49 8 action action NN kim 49 9 is be VBZ kim 49 10 what what WP kim 49 11 makes make VBZ kim 49 12 an an DT kim 49 13 action action NN kim 49 14 moral moral JJ kim 49 15 . . . kim 50 1 In in IN kim 50 2 this this DT kim 50 3 view view NN kim 50 4 , , , kim 50 5 what what WP kim 50 6 generates generate VBZ kim 50 7 the the DT kim 50 8 greatest great JJS kim 50 9 amount amount NN kim 50 10 of of IN kim 50 11 good good JJ kim 50 12 is be VBZ kim 50 13 the the DT kim 50 14 most most RBS kim 50 15 moral moral JJ kim 50 16 thing thing NN kim 50 17 to to TO kim 50 18 do do VB kim 50 19 . . . kim 51 1 If if IN kim 51 2 one one PRP kim 51 3 regards regard VBZ kim 51 4 five five CD kim 51 5 human human JJ kim 51 6 lives life NNS kim 51 7 as as IN kim 51 8 a a DT kim 51 9 greater great JJR kim 51 10 good good NN kim 51 11 than than IN kim 51 12 one one CD kim 51 13 , , , kim 51 14 then then RB kim 51 15 one one CD kim 51 16 acts act VBZ kim 51 17 morally morally RB kim 51 18 by by IN kim 51 19 pulling pull VBG kim 51 20 the the DT kim 51 21 lever lever NN kim 51 22 and and CC kim 51 23 diverting divert VBG kim 51 24 the the DT kim 51 25 trolley trolley NN kim 51 26 to to IN kim 51 27 the the DT kim 51 28 other other JJ kim 51 29 track track NN kim 51 30 . . . kim 52 1 By by IN kim 52 2 contrast contrast NN kim 52 3 , , , kim 52 4 deontology deontology NN kim 52 5 claims claim VBZ kim 52 6 that that IN kim 52 7 what what WP kim 52 8 determines determine VBZ kim 52 9 whether whether IN kim 52 10 an an DT kim 52 11 action action NN kim 52 12 is be VBZ kim 52 13 morally morally RB kim 52 14 right right JJ kim 52 15 or or CC kim 52 16 wrong wrong JJ kim 52 17 is be VBZ kim 52 18 not not RB kim 52 19 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 52 20 utility utility NN kim 52 21 but but CC kim 52 22 moral moral JJ kim 52 23 rules rule NNS kim 52 24 . . . kim 53 1 If if IN kim 53 2 an an DT kim 53 3 action action NN kim 53 4 is be VBZ kim 53 5 in in IN kim 53 6 accordance accordance NN kim 53 7 with with IN kim 53 8 those those DT kim 53 9 rules rule NNS kim 53 10 , , , kim 53 11 then then RB kim 53 12 the the DT kim 53 13 action action NN kim 53 14 is be VBZ kim 53 15 morally morally RB kim 53 16 right right JJ kim 53 17 . . . kim 54 1 Otherwise otherwise RB kim 54 2 , , , kim 54 3 it -PRON- PRP kim 54 4 is be VBZ kim 54 5 morally morally RB kim 54 6 wrong wrong JJ kim 54 7 . . . kim 55 1 If if IN kim 55 2 not not RB kim 55 3 to to TO kim 55 4 kill kill VB kim 55 5 another another DT kim 55 6 human human NN kim 55 7 being being NN kim 55 8 is be VBZ kim 55 9 one one CD kim 55 10 of of IN kim 55 11 those those DT kim 55 12 moral moral JJ kim 55 13 rules rule NNS kim 55 14 , , , kim 55 15 then then RB kim 55 16 killing kill VBG kim 55 17 someone someone NN kim 55 18 is be VBZ kim 55 19 morally morally RB kim 55 20 wrong wrong JJ kim 55 21 even even RB kim 55 22 if if IN kim 55 23 it -PRON- PRP kim 55 24 is be VBZ kim 55 25 to to TO kim 55 26 save save VB kim 55 27 more more JJR kim 55 28 lives life NNS kim 55 29 . . . kim 56 1 Note note VB kim 56 2 that that IN kim 56 3 these these DT kim 56 4 are be VBP kim 56 5 highly highly RB kim 56 6 simplified simplified JJ kim 56 7 accounts account NNS kim 56 8 of of IN kim 56 9 utilitarianism utilitarianism NN kim 56 10 and and CC kim 56 11 deontology deontology NN kim 56 12 . . . kim 57 1 The the DT kim 57 2 good good NN kim 57 3 in in IN kim 57 4 utilitarianism utilitarianism NN kim 57 5 can can MD kim 57 6 be be VB kim 57 7 interpreted interpret VBN kim 57 8 in in IN kim 57 9 many many JJ kim 57 10 different different JJ kim 57 11 ways way NNS kim 57 12 , , , kim 57 13 and and CC kim 57 14 the the DT kim 57 15 issue issue NN kim 57 16 of of IN kim 57 17 conflicting conflict VBG kim 57 18 moral moral JJ kim 57 19 rules rule NNS kim 57 20 is be VBZ kim 57 21 a a DT kim 57 22 perennial perennial JJ kim 57 23 problem problem NN kim 57 24 that that IN kim 57 25 deontological deontological JJ kim 57 26 ethics ethic NNS kim 57 27 grapples grapple VBZ kim 57 28 with with IN kim 57 29 . . . kim 58 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 58 2 footnoteRef:6 footnoteref:6 NN kim 58 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 58 4 For for IN kim 58 5 our -PRON- PRP$ kim 58 6 purpose purpose NN kim 58 7 , , , kim 58 8 however however RB kim 58 9 , , , kim 58 10 these these DT kim 58 11 simplified simplify VBN kim 58 12 accounts account NNS kim 58 13 are be VBP kim 58 14 sufficient sufficient JJ kim 58 15 to to TO kim 58 16 highlight highlight VB kim 58 17 the the DT kim 58 18 aspects aspect NNS kim 58 19 in in IN kim 58 20 which which WDT kim 58 21 the the DT kim 58 22 utilitarian utilitarian NN kim 58 23 and and CC kim 58 24 the the DT kim 58 25 deontological deontological JJ kim 58 26 position position NN kim 58 27 appeal appeal VBP kim 58 28 to to IN kim 58 29 and and CC kim 58 30 go go VB kim 58 31 against against IN kim 58 32 our -PRON- PRP$ kim 58 33 moral moral JJ kim 58 34 intuition intuition NN kim 58 35 . . . kim 59 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 59 2 6 6 CD kim 59 3 : : : kim 59 4 For for IN kim 59 5 an an DT kim 59 6 overview overview NN kim 59 7 , , , kim 59 8 see see VB kim 59 9 Sinnott Sinnott NNP kim 59 10 - - HYPH kim 59 11 Armstrong Armstrong NNP kim 59 12 2019 2019 CD kim 59 13 and and CC kim 59 14 Alexander Alexander NNP kim 59 15 and and CC kim 59 16 Moore Moore NNP kim 59 17 2016 2016 CD kim 59 18 . . . kim 59 19 ] ] -RRB- kim 60 1 If if IN kim 60 2 a a DT kim 60 3 trolley trolley NN kim 60 4 can can MD kim 60 5 not not RB kim 60 6 be be VB kim 60 7 stopped stop VBN kim 60 8 , , , kim 60 9 saving save VBG kim 60 10 five five CD kim 60 11 lives life NNS kim 60 12 over over IN kim 60 13 one one NN kim 60 14 seems seem VBZ kim 60 15 to to TO kim 60 16 be be VB kim 60 17 a a DT kim 60 18 right right JJ kim 60 19 thing thing NN kim 60 20 to to TO kim 60 21 do do VB kim 60 22 . . . kim 61 1 Utilitarianism Utilitarianism NNP kim 61 2 appears appear VBZ kim 61 3 to to TO kim 61 4 get get VB kim 61 5 things thing NNS kim 61 6 right right JJ kim 61 7 in in IN kim 61 8 this this DT kim 61 9 respect respect NN kim 61 10 . . . kim 62 1 However however RB kim 62 2 , , , kim 62 3 it -PRON- PRP kim 62 4 is be VBZ kim 62 5 hard hard JJ kim 62 6 to to TO kim 62 7 dispute dispute VB kim 62 8 that that IN kim 62 9 killing kill VBG kim 62 10 people people NNS kim 62 11 is be VBZ kim 62 12 wrong wrong JJ kim 62 13 . . . kim 63 1 If if IN kim 63 2 killing killing NN kim 63 3 is be VBZ kim 63 4 morally morally RB kim 63 5 wrong wrong JJ kim 63 6 no no RB kim 63 7 matter matter RB kim 63 8 what what WP kim 63 9 , , , kim 63 10 deontology deontology NN kim 63 11 seems seem VBZ kim 63 12 to to TO kim 63 13 make make VB kim 63 14 more more JJR kim 63 15 sense sense NN kim 63 16 . . . kim 64 1 With with IN kim 64 2 moral moral JJ kim 64 3 theories theory NNS kim 64 4 , , , kim 64 5 things thing NNS kim 64 6 seem seem VBP kim 64 7 to to TO kim 64 8 get get VB kim 64 9 more more RBR kim 64 10 confusing confusing JJ kim 64 11 . . . kim 65 1 Consider consider VB kim 65 2 the the DT kim 65 3 case case NN kim 65 4 in in IN kim 65 5 which which WDT kim 65 6 one one NN kim 65 7 freezes freeze VBZ kim 65 8 and and CC kim 65 9 fails fail VBZ kim 65 10 to to TO kim 65 11 pull pull VB kim 65 12 the the DT kim 65 13 level level NN kim 65 14 . . . kim 66 1 According accord VBG kim 66 2 to to IN kim 66 3 utilitarianism utilitarianism NN kim 66 4 , , , kim 66 5 this this DT kim 66 6 would would MD kim 66 7 be be VB kim 66 8 morally morally RB kim 66 9 wrong wrong JJ kim 66 10 because because IN kim 66 11 it -PRON- PRP kim 66 12 fails fail VBZ kim 66 13 to to TO kim 66 14 maximize maximize VB kim 66 15 the the DT kim 66 16 greatest great JJS kim 66 17 good good JJ kim 66 18 , , , kim 66 19 i.e. i.e. FW kim 67 1 human human JJ kim 67 2 lives life NNS kim 67 3 . . . kim 68 1 But but CC kim 68 2 how how WRB kim 68 3 far far RB kim 68 4 should should MD kim 68 5 one one PRP kim 68 6 go go VB kim 68 7 to to TO kim 68 8 maximize maximize VB kim 68 9 the the DT kim 68 10 good good NN kim 68 11 ? ? . kim 69 1 Suppose suppose VB kim 69 2 there there EX kim 69 3 is be VBZ kim 69 4 a a DT kim 69 5 very very RB kim 69 6 large large JJ kim 69 7 person person NN kim 69 8 on on IN kim 69 9 a a DT kim 69 10 footbridge footbridge NN kim 69 11 over over IN kim 69 12 the the DT kim 69 13 trolley trolley NN kim 69 14 track track NN kim 69 15 and and CC kim 69 16 one one NN kim 69 17 pushes push VBZ kim 69 18 that that DT kim 69 19 person person NN kim 69 20 off off IN kim 69 21 the the DT kim 69 22 footbridge footbridge NN kim 69 23 onto onto IN kim 69 24 the the DT kim 69 25 track track NN kim 69 26 , , , kim 69 27 thus thus RB kim 69 28 stopping stop VBG kim 69 29 the the DT kim 69 30 trolley trolley NN kim 69 31 and and CC kim 69 32 saving save VBG kim 69 33 the the DT kim 69 34 five five CD kim 69 35 people people NNS kim 69 36 . . . kim 70 1 Would Would MD kim 70 2 this this DT kim 70 3 count count VB kim 70 4 as as IN kim 70 5 a a DT kim 70 6 right right JJ kim 70 7 thing thing NN kim 70 8 to to TO kim 70 9 do do VB kim 70 10 ? ? . kim 71 1 Utilitarianism Utilitarianism NNP kim 71 2 may may MD kim 71 3 argue argue VB kim 71 4 that that DT kim 71 5 . . . kim 72 1 But but CC kim 72 2 in in IN kim 72 3 real real JJ kim 72 4 life life NN kim 72 5 , , , kim 72 6 many many JJ kim 72 7 might may MD kim 72 8 consider consider VB kim 72 9 throwing throw VBG kim 72 10 a a DT kim 72 11 person person NN kim 72 12 morally morally RB kim 72 13 wrong wrong JJ kim 72 14 but but CC kim 72 15 pulling pull VBG kim 72 16 the the DT kim 72 17 lever lever NN kim 72 18 morally morally RB kim 72 19 permissible permissible JJ kim 72 20 . . . kim 73 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 73 2 footnoteRef:7 footnoteref:7 NN kim 73 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 73 4 [ [ -LRB- kim 73 5 7 7 CD kim 73 6 : : : kim 73 7 For for IN kim 73 8 an an DT kim 73 9 empirical empirical JJ kim 73 10 study study NN kim 73 11 on on IN kim 73 12 this this DT kim 73 13 , , , kim 73 14 see see VB kim 73 15 Cushman Cushman NNP kim 73 16 , , , kim 73 17 Young Young NNP kim 73 18 , , , kim 73 19 and and CC kim 73 20 Hauser Hauser NNP kim 73 21 2006 2006 CD kim 73 22 . . . kim 74 1 For for IN kim 74 2 the the DT kim 74 3 results result NNS kim 74 4 of of IN kim 74 5 a a DT kim 74 6 similar similar JJ kim 74 7 survey survey NN kim 74 8 that that WDT kim 74 9 involves involve VBZ kim 74 10 an an DT kim 74 11 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 74 12 car car NN kim 74 13 instead instead RB kim 74 14 of of IN kim 74 15 a a DT kim 74 16 trolley trolley NN kim 74 17 , , , kim 74 18 see see VB kim 74 19 Bonnefon Bonnefon NNP kim 74 20 , , , kim 74 21 Shariff Shariff NNP kim 74 22 , , , kim 74 23 and and CC kim 74 24 Rahwan Rahwan NNP kim 74 25 2016 2016 CD kim 74 26 . . . kim 74 27 ] ] -RRB- kim 75 1 The the DT kim 75 2 problem problem NN kim 75 3 with with IN kim 75 4 utilitarianism utilitarianism NN kim 75 5 is be VBZ kim 75 6 that that IN kim 75 7 it -PRON- PRP kim 75 8 treats treat VBZ kim 75 9 the the DT kim 75 10 good good JJ kim 75 11 as as IN kim 75 12 something something NN kim 75 13 inherently inherently RB kim 75 14 quantifiable quantifiable JJ kim 75 15 , , , kim 75 16 comparable comparable JJ kim 75 17 , , , kim 75 18 calculable calculable JJ kim 75 19 , , , kim 75 20 and and CC kim 75 21 additive additive NNP kim 75 22 . . . kim 76 1 But but CC kim 76 2 not not RB kim 76 3 all all DT kim 76 4 considerations consideration NNS kim 76 5 that that WDT kim 76 6 we -PRON- PRP kim 76 7 have have VBP kim 76 8 to to TO kim 76 9 factor factor VB kim 76 10 into into IN kim 76 11 moral moral JJ kim 76 12 decision decision NN kim 76 13 - - HYPH kim 76 14 making making NN kim 76 15 are be VBP kim 76 16 measurable measurable JJ kim 76 17 in in IN kim 76 18 numbers number NNS kim 76 19 . . . kim 77 1 What what WP kim 77 2 if if IN kim 77 3 the the DT kim 77 4 five five CD kim 77 5 people people NNS kim 77 6 on on IN kim 77 7 the the DT kim 77 8 track track NN kim 77 9 are be VBP kim 77 10 helpless helpless JJ kim 77 11 babies baby NNS kim 77 12 or or CC kim 77 13 murderers murderer NNS kim 77 14 who who WP kim 77 15 just just RB kim 77 16 escaped escape VBD kim 77 17 from from IN kim 77 18 the the DT kim 77 19 prison prison NN kim 77 20 ? ? . kim 78 1 Would Would MD kim 78 2 or or CC kim 78 3 should should MD kim 78 4 that that DT kim 78 5 affect affect VB kim 78 6 our -PRON- PRP$ kim 78 7 decision decision NN kim 78 8 ? ? . kim 79 1 Some some DT kim 79 2 of of IN kim 79 3 us -PRON- PRP kim 79 4 would would MD kim 79 5 surely surely RB kim 79 6 hesitate hesitate VB kim 79 7 saving save VBG kim 79 8 the the DT kim 79 9 lives life NNS kim 79 10 of of IN kim 79 11 five five CD kim 79 12 murderers murderer NNS kim 79 13 by by IN kim 79 14 sacrificing sacrifice VBG kim 79 15 one one CD kim 79 16 innocent innocent JJ kim 79 17 baby baby NN kim 79 18 . . . kim 80 1 But but CC kim 80 2 what what WP kim 80 3 if if IN kim 80 4 things thing NNS kim 80 5 were be VBD kim 80 6 different different JJ kim 80 7 and and CC kim 80 8 we -PRON- PRP kim 80 9 were be VBD kim 80 10 comparing compare VBG kim 80 11 five five CD kim 80 12 school school NN kim 80 13 children child NNS kim 80 14 versus versus IN kim 80 15 one one CD kim 80 16 baby baby NN kim 80 17 or or CC kim 80 18 five five CD kim 80 19 babies baby NNS kim 80 20 versus versus IN kim 80 21 one one CD kim 80 22 schoolchild schoolchild NN kim 80 23 ? ? . kim 81 1 No no DT kim 81 2 one one NN kim 81 3 can can MD kim 81 4 say say VB kim 81 5 for for IN kim 81 6 sure sure JJ kim 81 7 what what WP kim 81 8 is be VBZ kim 81 9 the the DT kim 81 10 morally morally RB kim 81 11 right right JJ kim 81 12 action action NN kim 81 13 in in IN kim 81 14 those those DT kim 81 15 cases case NNS kim 81 16 . . . kim 82 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 82 2 footnoteRef:8 footnoteref:8 NN kim 82 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 82 4 [ [ -LRB- kim 82 5 8 8 CD kim 82 6 : : : kim 82 7 For for IN kim 82 8 an an DT kim 82 9 attempt attempt NN kim 82 10 to to TO kim 82 11 identify identify VB kim 82 12 moral moral JJ kim 82 13 principles principle NNS kim 82 14 behind behind IN kim 82 15 our -PRON- PRP$ kim 82 16 moral moral JJ kim 82 17 intuition intuition NN kim 82 18 in in IN kim 82 19 different different JJ kim 82 20 versions version NNS kim 82 21 of of IN kim 82 22 the the DT kim 82 23 trolley trolley NN kim 82 24 problem problem NN kim 82 25 and and CC kim 82 26 other other JJ kim 82 27 similar similar JJ kim 82 28 cases case NNS kim 82 29 , , , kim 82 30 see see VB kim 82 31 Thomson Thomson NNP kim 82 32 1976 1976 CD kim 82 33 . . . kim 82 34 ] ] -RRB- kim 83 1 While while IN kim 83 2 the the DT kim 83 3 utilitarian utilitarian JJ kim 83 4 position position NN kim 83 5 appears appear VBZ kim 83 6 less less RBR kim 83 7 persuasive persuasive JJ kim 83 8 in in IN kim 83 9 light light NN kim 83 10 of of IN kim 83 11 these these DT kim 83 12 considerations consideration NNS kim 83 13 , , , kim 83 14 deontology deontology NN kim 83 15 does do VBZ kim 83 16 n’t not RB kim 83 17 fare fare VB kim 83 18 too too RB kim 83 19 well well RB kim 83 20 , , , kim 83 21 either either RB kim 83 22 . . . kim 84 1 Deontology deontology NN kim 84 2 emphasizes emphasize VBZ kim 84 3 one one PRP kim 84 4 ’s ’s NN kim 84 5 duty duty NN kim 84 6 to to TO kim 84 7 observe observe VB kim 84 8 moral moral JJ kim 84 9 rules rule NNS kim 84 10 . . . kim 85 1 But but CC kim 85 2 what what WP kim 85 3 if if IN kim 85 4 those those DT kim 85 5 moral moral JJ kim 85 6 rules rule NNS kim 85 7 conflict conflict NN kim 85 8 with with IN kim 85 9 one one CD kim 85 10 another another DT kim 85 11 ? ? . kim 86 1 Between between IN kim 86 2 the the DT kim 86 3 two two CD kim 86 4 moral moral JJ kim 86 5 rules rule NNS kim 86 6 , , , kim 86 7 “ " `` kim 86 8 do do VB kim 86 9 not not RB kim 86 10 kill kill VB kim 86 11 a a DT kim 86 12 person person NN kim 86 13 ” " '' kim 86 14 and and CC kim 86 15 “ " `` kim 86 16 save save VB kim 86 17 lives life NNS kim 86 18 , , , kim 86 19 ” " '' kim 86 20 which which WDT kim 86 21 one one PRP kim 86 22 should should MD kim 86 23 trump trump VB kim 86 24 the the DT kim 86 25 other other JJ kim 86 26 ? ? . kim 87 1 The the DT kim 87 2 conflict conflict NN kim 87 3 among among IN kim 87 4 values value NNS kim 87 5 is be VBZ kim 87 6 common common JJ kim 87 7 in in IN kim 87 8 life life NN kim 87 9 , , , kim 87 10 and and CC kim 87 11 deontology deontology NN kim 87 12 faces face VBZ kim 87 13 difficulty difficulty NN kim 87 14 in in IN kim 87 15 guiding guide VBG kim 87 16 how how WRB kim 87 17 an an DT kim 87 18 intelligent intelligent JJ kim 87 19 agent agent NN kim 87 20 is be VBZ kim 87 21 to to TO kim 87 22 act act VB kim 87 23 in in IN kim 87 24 a a DT kim 87 25 tricky tricky JJ kim 87 26 situation situation NN kim 87 27 like like IN kim 87 28 the the DT kim 87 29 trolley trolley NN kim 87 30 problem problem NN kim 87 31 . . . kim 88 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 88 2 footnoteRef:9 footnoteRef:9 NNP kim 88 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 88 4 [ [ -LRB- kim 88 5 9 9 CD kim 88 6 : : : kim 88 7 Some some DT kim 88 8 moral moral JJ kim 88 9 philosophers philosopher NNS kim 88 10 doubt doubt VBP kim 88 11 the the DT kim 88 12 value value NN kim 88 13 of of IN kim 88 14 our -PRON- PRP$ kim 88 15 moral moral JJ kim 88 16 intuition intuition NN kim 88 17 in in IN kim 88 18 constructing construct VBG kim 88 19 a a DT kim 88 20 moral moral JJ kim 88 21 theory theory NN kim 88 22 . . . kim 89 1 See see VB kim 89 2 Singer singer NN kim 89 3 2005 2005 CD kim 89 4 , , , kim 89 5 for for IN kim 89 6 example example NN kim 89 7 . . . kim 90 1 But but CC kim 90 2 a a DT kim 90 3 moral moral JJ kim 90 4 theory theory NN kim 90 5 that that IN kim 90 6 clashes clash NNS kim 90 7 with with IN kim 90 8 common common JJ kim 90 9 moral moral JJ kim 90 10 intuition intuition NN kim 90 11 is be VBZ kim 90 12 unlikely unlikely JJ kim 90 13 to to TO kim 90 14 be be VB kim 90 15 sought seek VBN kim 90 16 out out RP kim 90 17 as as IN kim 90 18 a a DT kim 90 19 guide guide NN kim 90 20 to to IN kim 90 21 making make VBG kim 90 22 an an DT kim 90 23 ethical ethical JJ kim 90 24 decision decision NN kim 90 25 . . . kim 90 26 ] ] -RRB- kim 91 1 3 3 LS kim 91 2 . . . kim 92 1 Understanding understand VBG kim 92 2 What what WP kim 92 3 Ethics Ethics NNP kim 92 4 Has have VBZ kim 92 5 to to TO kim 92 6 Offer offer VB kim 92 7 Due due IN kim 92 8 to to IN kim 92 9 the the DT kim 92 10 high high JJ kim 92 11 stakes stake NNS kim 92 12 involved involve VBN kim 92 13 , , , kim 92 14 AI AI NNP kim 92 15 - - HYPH kim 92 16 powered power VBN kim 92 17 military military JJ kim 92 18 robots robot NNS kim 92 19 and and CC kim 92 20 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 92 21 weapons weapon NNS kim 92 22 systems system NNS kim 92 23 can can MD kim 92 24 present present VB kim 92 25 the the DT kim 92 26 moral moral JJ kim 92 27 dilemma dilemma NN kim 92 28 in in IN kim 92 29 the the DT kim 92 30 trolley trolley NN kim 92 31 problem problem NN kim 92 32 more more RBR kim 92 33 convincingly convincingly RB kim 92 34 . . . kim 93 1 Suppose suppose VB kim 93 2 that that IN kim 93 3 some some DT kim 93 4 engineers engineer NNS kim 93 5 , , , kim 93 6 following follow VBG kim 93 7 utilitarianism utilitarianism NN kim 93 8 and and CC kim 93 9 interpreting interpret VBG kim 93 10 victory victory NN kim 93 11 as as IN kim 93 12 the the DT kim 93 13 ultimate ultimate JJ kim 93 14 good good JJ kim 93 15 / / SYM kim 93 16 utility utility NN kim 93 17 , , , kim 93 18 wish wish VBP kim 93 19 to to TO kim 93 20 program program VB kim 93 21 an an DT kim 93 22 unmanned unmanned JJ kim 93 23 aerial aerial JJ kim 93 24 vehicle vehicle NN kim 93 25 ( ( -LRB- kim 93 26 UAV UAV NNP kim 93 27 ) ) -RRB- kim 93 28 to to TO kim 93 29 autonomously autonomously RB kim 93 30 drop drop VB kim 93 31 bombs bomb NNS kim 93 32 in in IN kim 93 33 order order NN kim 93 34 to to TO kim 93 35 maximize maximize VB kim 93 36 the the DT kim 93 37 chances chance NNS kim 93 38 of of IN kim 93 39 victory victory NN kim 93 40 . . . kim 94 1 That that DT kim 94 2 may may MD kim 94 3 result result VB kim 94 4 in in IN kim 94 5 sacrificing sacrifice VBG kim 94 6 a a DT kim 94 7 greater great JJR kim 94 8 number number NN kim 94 9 of of IN kim 94 10 civilians civilian NNS kim 94 11 than than IN kim 94 12 necessary necessary JJ kim 94 13 , , , kim 94 14 and and CC kim 94 15 many many JJ kim 94 16 will will MD kim 94 17 consider consider VB kim 94 18 this this DT kim 94 19 to to TO kim 94 20 be be VB kim 94 21 morally morally RB kim 94 22 wrong wrong JJ kim 94 23 . . . kim 95 1 Now now RB kim 95 2 imagine imagine VB kim 95 3 different different JJ kim 95 4 engineers engineer NNS kim 95 5 who who WP kim 95 6 , , , kim 95 7 adopting adopt VBG kim 95 8 deontology deontology NN kim 95 9 and and CC kim 95 10 following follow VBG kim 95 11 the the DT kim 95 12 moral moral JJ kim 95 13 principle principle NN kim 95 14 of of IN kim 95 15 not not RB kim 95 16 killing kill VBG kim 95 17 people people NNS kim 95 18 , , , kim 95 19 program program VB kim 95 20 a a DT kim 95 21 UAV UAV NNP kim 95 22 to to TO kim 95 23 autonomously autonomously RB kim 95 24 act act VB kim 95 25 in in IN kim 95 26 a a DT kim 95 27 manner manner NN kim 95 28 that that WDT kim 95 29 minimizes minimize VBZ kim 95 30 casualties casualty NNS kim 95 31 . . . kim 96 1 This this DT kim 96 2 may may MD kim 96 3 lead lead VB kim 96 4 to to IN kim 96 5 defeat defeat NN kim 96 6 on on IN kim 96 7 the the DT kim 96 8 battlefield battlefield NN kim 96 9 , , , kim 96 10 because because IN kim 96 11 minimizing minimize VBG kim 96 12 casualties casualty NNS kim 96 13 may may MD kim 96 14 not not RB kim 96 15 be be VB kim 96 16 always always RB kim 96 17 advantageous advantageous JJ kim 96 18 to to IN kim 96 19 winning win VBG kim 96 20 a a DT kim 96 21 war war NN kim 96 22 . . . kim 97 1 These these DT kim 97 2 considerations consideration NNS kim 97 3 suggest suggest VBP kim 97 4 that that IN kim 97 5 philosophical philosophical JJ kim 97 6 insights insight NNS kim 97 7 from from IN kim 97 8 utilitarianism utilitarianism NN kim 97 9 and and CC kim 97 10 deontology deontology NN kim 97 11 may may MD kim 97 12 provide provide VB kim 97 13 little little JJ kim 97 14 practical practical JJ kim 97 15 guidance guidance NN kim 97 16 on on IN kim 97 17 how how WRB kim 97 18 to to TO kim 97 19 program program VB kim 97 20 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 97 21 AI AI NNP kim 97 22 systems system NNS kim 97 23 to to TO kim 97 24 act act VB kim 97 25 morally morally RB kim 97 26 . . . kim 98 1 Ethicists ethicist NNS kim 98 2 seek seek VBP kim 98 3 abstract abstract JJ kim 98 4 principles principle NNS kim 98 5 that that WDT kim 98 6 can can MD kim 98 7 be be VB kim 98 8 generalized generalize VBN kim 98 9 . . . kim 99 1 For for IN kim 99 2 this this DT kim 99 3 reason reason NN kim 99 4 , , , kim 99 5 they -PRON- PRP kim 99 6 are be VBP kim 99 7 interested interested JJ kim 99 8 in in IN kim 99 9 borderline borderline NN kim 99 10 cases case NNS kim 99 11 that that WDT kim 99 12 reveal reveal VBP kim 99 13 subtle subtle JJ kim 99 14 differences difference NNS kim 99 15 in in IN kim 99 16 our -PRON- PRP$ kim 99 17 moral moral JJ kim 99 18 intuition intuition NN kim 99 19 and and CC kim 99 20 varying vary VBG kim 99 21 moral moral JJ kim 99 22 theories theory NNS kim 99 23 . . . kim 100 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ kim 100 2 goal goal NN kim 100 3 is be VBZ kim 100 4 to to TO kim 100 5 define define VB kim 100 6 what what WP kim 100 7 is be VBZ kim 100 8 moral moral JJ kim 100 9 and and CC kim 100 10 investigate investigate VB kim 100 11 how how WRB kim 100 12 moral moral JJ kim 100 13 reasoning reasoning NN kim 100 14 works work NNS kim 100 15 or or CC kim 100 16 should should MD kim 100 17 work work VB kim 100 18 . . . kim 101 1 By by IN kim 101 2 contrast contrast NN kim 101 3 , , , kim 101 4 engineers engineer NNS kim 101 5 and and CC kim 101 6 programmers programmer NNS kim 101 7 pursue pursue VBP kim 101 8 practical practical JJ kim 101 9 solutions solution NNS kim 101 10 to to IN kim 101 11 real real JJ kim 101 12 - - HYPH kim 101 13 life life NN kim 101 14 problems problem NNS kim 101 15 and and CC kim 101 16 look look VB kim 101 17 for for IN kim 101 18 guidelines guideline NNS kim 101 19 that that WDT kim 101 20 will will MD kim 101 21 help help VB kim 101 22 with with IN kim 101 23 implementing implement VBG kim 101 24 those those DT kim 101 25 solutions solution NNS kim 101 26 . . . kim 102 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ kim 102 2 focus focus NN kim 102 3 is be VBZ kim 102 4 on on IN kim 102 5 creating create VBG kim 102 6 a a DT kim 102 7 set set NN kim 102 8 of of IN kim 102 9 constraints constraint NNS kim 102 10 and and CC kim 102 11 if if IN kim 102 12 - - HYPH kim 102 13 then then RB kim 102 14 statements statement NNS kim 102 15 , , , kim 102 16 which which WDT kim 102 17 will will MD kim 102 18 allow allow VB kim 102 19 a a DT kim 102 20 machine machine NN kim 102 21 to to TO kim 102 22 identify identify VB kim 102 23 and and CC kim 102 24 process process VB kim 102 25 morally morally RB kim 102 26 relevant relevant JJ kim 102 27 considerations consideration NNS kim 102 28 , , , kim 102 29 so so IN kim 102 30 that that IN kim 102 31 it -PRON- PRP kim 102 32 can can MD kim 102 33 determine determine VB kim 102 34 and and CC kim 102 35 execute execute VB kim 102 36 an an DT kim 102 37 action action NN kim 102 38 that that WDT kim 102 39 is be VBZ kim 102 40 not not RB kim 102 41 only only RB kim 102 42 rational rational JJ kim 102 43 but but CC kim 102 44 also also RB kim 102 45 ethical ethical JJ kim 102 46 in in IN kim 102 47 the the DT kim 102 48 given give VBN kim 102 49 situation situation NN kim 102 50 . . . kim 103 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 103 2 footnoteRef:10 footnoteref:10 CD kim 103 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 103 4 [ [ -LRB- kim 103 5 10 10 CD kim 103 6 : : : kim 103 7 Note note VB kim 103 8 that that IN kim 103 9 this this DT kim 103 10 moral moral JJ kim 103 11 decision decision NN kim 103 12 - - HYPH kim 103 13 making make VBG kim 103 14 process process NN kim 103 15 can can MD kim 103 16 be be VB kim 103 17 modeled model VBN kim 103 18 as as IN kim 103 19 rule rule NN kim 103 20 - - HYPH kim 103 21 based base VBN kim 103 22 , , , kim 103 23 as as IN kim 103 24 in in IN kim 103 25 a a DT kim 103 26 symbolic symbolic JJ kim 103 27 AI ai NN kim 103 28 system system NN kim 103 29 , , , kim 103 30 although although IN kim 103 31 it -PRON- PRP kim 103 32 does do VBZ kim 103 33 not not RB kim 103 34 have have VB kim 103 35 to to TO kim 103 36 be be VB kim 103 37 . . . kim 104 1 It -PRON- PRP kim 104 2 can can MD kim 104 3 be be VB kim 104 4 based base VBN kim 104 5 upon upon IN kim 104 6 a a DT kim 104 7 machine machine NN kim 104 8 learning learning NN kim 104 9 approach approach NN kim 104 10 . . . kim 105 1 It -PRON- PRP kim 105 2 is be VBZ kim 105 3 also also RB kim 105 4 possible possible JJ kim 105 5 to to TO kim 105 6 combine combine VB kim 105 7 both both DT kim 105 8 . . . kim 106 1 See see VB kim 106 2 Vincent Vincent NNP kim 106 3 Conitzer Conitzer NNP kim 106 4 et et NNP kim 106 5 al al NNP kim 106 6 . . . kim 107 1 2017 2017 CD kim 107 2 . . . kim 107 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 108 1 On on IN kim 108 2 the the DT kim 108 3 other other JJ kim 108 4 hand hand NN kim 108 5 , , , kim 108 6 military military JJ kim 108 7 commanders commander NNS kim 108 8 and and CC kim 108 9 soldiers soldier NNS kim 108 10 might may MD kim 108 11 aim aim VB kim 108 12 to to TO kim 108 13 end end VB kim 108 14 a a DT kim 108 15 conflict conflict NN kim 108 16 , , , kim 108 17 bring bring VB kim 108 18 peace peace NN kim 108 19 , , , kim 108 20 and and CC kim 108 21 facilitate facilitate VB kim 108 22 restoring restore VBG kim 108 23 and and CC kim 108 24 establishing establish VBG kim 108 25 universally universally RB kim 108 26 recognized recognize VBN kim 108 27 human human JJ kim 108 28 values value NNS kim 108 29 such such JJ kim 108 30 as as IN kim 108 31 freedom freedom NN kim 108 32 , , , kim 108 33 equality equality NN kim 108 34 , , , kim 108 35 justice justice NN kim 108 36 , , , kim 108 37 and and CC kim 108 38 self self NN kim 108 39 - - HYPH kim 108 40 determination determination NN kim 108 41 . . . kim 109 1 In in IN kim 109 2 order order NN kim 109 3 to to TO kim 109 4 achieve achieve VB kim 109 5 this this DT kim 109 6 goal goal NN kim 109 7 , , , kim 109 8 they -PRON- PRP kim 109 9 must must MD kim 109 10 make make VB kim 109 11 the the DT kim 109 12 best good JJS kim 109 13 strategic strategic JJ kim 109 14 decisions decision NNS kim 109 15 and and CC kim 109 16 take take VB kim 109 17 the the DT kim 109 18 most most RBS kim 109 19 appropriate appropriate JJ kim 109 20 actions action NNS kim 109 21 . . . kim 110 1 In in IN kim 110 2 deciding decide VBG kim 110 3 on on IN kim 110 4 those those DT kim 110 5 actions action NNS kim 110 6 , , , kim 110 7 they -PRON- PRP kim 110 8 are be VBP kim 110 9 also also RB kim 110 10 responsible responsible JJ kim 110 11 for for IN kim 110 12 abiding abide VBG kim 110 13 by by IN kim 110 14 the the DT kim 110 15 principles principle NNS kim 110 16 of of IN kim 110 17 jus jus NN kim 110 18 in in IN kim 110 19 bello bello NN kim 110 20 and and CC kim 110 21 for for IN kim 110 22 not not RB kim 110 23 abdicating abdicate VBG kim 110 24 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 110 25 moral moral JJ kim 110 26 responsibility responsibility NN kim 110 27 , , , kim 110 28 protecting protect VBG kim 110 29 civilians civilian NNS kim 110 30 and and CC kim 110 31 minimizing minimize VBG kim 110 32 harm harm NN kim 110 33 , , , kim 110 34 violence violence NN kim 110 35 , , , kim 110 36 and and CC kim 110 37 destruction destruction NN kim 110 38 as as RB kim 110 39 much much RB kim 110 40 as as IN kim 110 41 possible possible JJ kim 110 42 . . . kim 111 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 111 2 footnoteRef:11 footnoteRef:11 NNP kim 111 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 111 4 The the DT kim 111 5 goal goal NN kim 111 6 of of IN kim 111 7 military military JJ kim 111 8 commanders commander NNS kim 111 9 and and CC kim 111 10 soldiers soldier NNS kim 111 11 , , , kim 111 12 therefore therefore RB kim 111 13 , , , kim 111 14 differs differ NNS kim 111 15 from from IN kim 111 16 those those DT kim 111 17 of of IN kim 111 18 moral moral JJ kim 111 19 philosophers philosopher NNS kim 111 20 or or CC kim 111 21 of of IN kim 111 22 the the DT kim 111 23 engineers engineer NNS kim 111 24 of of IN kim 111 25 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 111 26 weapons weapon NNS kim 111 27 . . . kim 112 1 They -PRON- PRP kim 112 2 are be VBP kim 112 3 obligated obligate VBN kim 112 4 to to TO kim 112 5 make make VB kim 112 6 quick quick JJ kim 112 7 decisions decision NNS kim 112 8 in in IN kim 112 9 a a DT kim 112 10 life life NN kim 112 11 - - HYPH kim 112 12 or or CC kim 112 13 - - HYPH kim 112 14 death death NN kim 112 15 situation situation NN kim 112 16 while while IN kim 112 17 working work VBG kim 112 18 with with IN kim 112 19 AI AI NNP kim 112 20 - - HYPH kim 112 21 powered power VBN kim 112 22 military military JJ kim 112 23 systems system NNS kim 112 24 . . . kim 113 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 113 2 11 11 CD kim 113 3 : : : kim 113 4 For for IN kim 113 5 the the DT kim 113 6 principles principle NNS kim 113 7 of of IN kim 113 8 jus jus NN kim 113 9 in in IN kim 113 10 bello bello NN kim 113 11 , , , kim 113 12 see see VB kim 113 13 International International NNP kim 113 14 Committee Committee NNP kim 113 15 of of IN kim 113 16 the the DT kim 113 17 Red Red NNP kim 113 18 Cross Cross NNP kim 113 19 2015 2015 CD kim 113 20 . . . kim 113 21 ] ] -RRB- kim 114 1 These these DT kim 114 2 different different JJ kim 114 3 goals goal NNS kim 114 4 and and CC kim 114 5 interests interest NNS kim 114 6 explain explain VBP kim 114 7 why why WRB kim 114 8 moral moral JJ kim 114 9 philosophers philosopher NNS kim 114 10 ’ ’ POS kim 114 11 discussion discussion NN kim 114 12 on on IN kim 114 13 the the DT kim 114 14 trolley trolley NN kim 114 15 problem problem NN kim 114 16 may may MD kim 114 17 be be VB kim 114 18 disappointing disappointing JJ kim 114 19 to to IN kim 114 20 AI AI NNP kim 114 21 programmers programmer NNS kim 114 22 or or CC kim 114 23 military military JJ kim 114 24 commanders commander NNS kim 114 25 and and CC kim 114 26 soldiers soldier NNS kim 114 27 . . . kim 115 1 Ethics ethic NNS kim 115 2 does do VBZ kim 115 3 not not RB kim 115 4 provide provide VB kim 115 5 an an DT kim 115 6 easy easy JJ kim 115 7 answer answer NN kim 115 8 to to IN kim 115 9 the the DT kim 115 10 question question NN kim 115 11 of of IN kim 115 12 how how WRB kim 115 13 one one PRP kim 115 14 should should MD kim 115 15 program program VB kim 115 16 moral moral JJ kim 115 17 decision decision NN kim 115 18 - - HYPH kim 115 19 making making NN kim 115 20 into into IN kim 115 21 intelligent intelligent JJ kim 115 22 machines machine NNS kim 115 23 . . . kim 116 1 Nor nor CC kim 116 2 does do VBZ kim 116 3 it -PRON- PRP kim 116 4 prescribe prescribe VB kim 116 5 the the DT kim 116 6 right right JJ kim 116 7 moral moral JJ kim 116 8 decision decision NN kim 116 9 in in IN kim 116 10 a a DT kim 116 11 battlefield battlefield NN kim 116 12 . . . kim 117 1 But but CC kim 117 2 taking take VBG kim 117 3 this this DT kim 117 4 as as IN kim 117 5 a a DT kim 117 6 shortcoming shortcoming NN kim 117 7 of of IN kim 117 8 ethics ethic NNS kim 117 9 is be VBZ kim 117 10 missing miss VBG kim 117 11 the the DT kim 117 12 point point NN kim 117 13 . . . kim 118 1 The the DT kim 118 2 role role NN kim 118 3 of of IN kim 118 4 moral moral JJ kim 118 5 philosophy philosophy NN kim 118 6 is be VBZ kim 118 7 not not RB kim 118 8 to to TO kim 118 9 make make VB kim 118 10 decision decision NN kim 118 11 - - HYPH kim 118 12 making make VBG kim 118 13 easier easy JJR kim 118 14 but but CC kim 118 15 to to TO kim 118 16 highlight highlight VB kim 118 17 and and CC kim 118 18 articulate articulate VB kim 118 19 the the DT kim 118 20 difficulty difficulty NN kim 118 21 and and CC kim 118 22 complexity complexity NN kim 118 23 involved involve VBN kim 118 24 in in IN kim 118 25 it -PRON- PRP kim 118 26 . . . kim 119 1 4 4 LS kim 119 2 . . . kim 120 1 Ethical ethical JJ kim 120 2 Challenges Challenges NNPS kim 120 3 from from IN kim 120 4 Autonomous Autonomous NNP kim 120 5 AI AI NNP kim 120 6 Systems Systems NNP kim 120 7 The the DT kim 120 8 complexity complexity NN kim 120 9 of of IN kim 120 10 ethical ethical JJ kim 120 11 questions question NNS kim 120 12 means mean VBZ kim 120 13 that that IN kim 120 14 dealing deal VBG kim 120 15 with with IN kim 120 16 the the DT kim 120 17 morality morality NN kim 120 18 of of IN kim 120 19 an an DT kim 120 20 action action NN kim 120 21 by by IN kim 120 22 an an DT kim 120 23 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 120 24 AI ai NN kim 120 25 system system NN kim 120 26 will will MD kim 120 27 require require VB kim 120 28 more more JJR kim 120 29 than than IN kim 120 30 a a DT kim 120 31 clever clever JJ kim 120 32 engineering engineering NN kim 120 33 or or CC kim 120 34 programming programming NN kim 120 35 solution solution NN kim 120 36 . . . kim 121 1 The the DT kim 121 2 fact fact NN kim 121 3 that that IN kim 121 4 ethics ethic NNS kim 121 5 does do VBZ kim 121 6 not not RB kim 121 7 eliminate eliminate VB kim 121 8 the the DT kim 121 9 inherent inherent JJ kim 121 10 ambiguity ambiguity NN kim 121 11 in in IN kim 121 12 many many JJ kim 121 13 moral moral JJ kim 121 14 decisions decision NNS kim 121 15 should should MD kim 121 16 not not RB kim 121 17 lead lead VB kim 121 18 to to IN kim 121 19 the the DT kim 121 20 dismissal dismissal NN kim 121 21 of of IN kim 121 22 ethical ethical JJ kim 121 23 challenges challenge NNS kim 121 24 from from IN kim 121 25 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 121 26 AI AI NNP kim 121 27 systems system NNS kim 121 28 . . . kim 122 1 By by IN kim 122 2 injecting inject VBG kim 122 3 the the DT kim 122 4 capacity capacity NN kim 122 5 for for IN kim 122 6 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 122 7 decision decision NN kim 122 8 - - HYPH kim 122 9 making making NN kim 122 10 into into IN kim 122 11 major major JJ kim 122 12 systems system NNS kim 122 13 and and CC kim 122 14 tools tool NNS kim 122 15 , , , kim 122 16 AI AI NNP kim 122 17 can can MD kim 122 18 fundamentally fundamentally RB kim 122 19 transform transform VB kim 122 20 any any DT kim 122 21 given give VBN kim 122 22 field field NN kim 122 23 . . . kim 123 1 For for IN kim 123 2 example example NN kim 123 3 , , , kim 123 4 AI AI NNP kim 123 5 - - HYPH kim 123 6 powered power VBN kim 123 7 military military JJ kim 123 8 robots robot NNS kim 123 9 are be VBP kim 123 10 not not RB kim 123 11 just just RB kim 123 12 another another DT kim 123 13 kind kind NN kim 123 14 of of IN kim 123 15 weapon weapon NN kim 123 16 . . . kim 124 1 When when WRB kim 124 2 widely widely RB kim 124 3 deployed deploy VBN kim 124 4 , , , kim 124 5 they -PRON- PRP kim 124 6 can can MD kim 124 7 change change VB kim 124 8 the the DT kim 124 9 nature nature NN kim 124 10 of of IN kim 124 11 war war NN kim 124 12 itself -PRON- PRP kim 124 13 . . . kim 125 1 Described describe VBN kim 125 2 below below IN kim 125 3 are be VBP kim 125 4 some some DT kim 125 5 of of IN kim 125 6 the the DT kim 125 7 significant significant JJ kim 125 8 ethical ethical JJ kim 125 9 challenges challenge NNS kim 125 10 that that WDT kim 125 11 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 125 12 AI AI NNP kim 125 13 systems system NNS kim 125 14 such such JJ kim 125 15 as as IN kim 125 16 military military JJ kim 125 17 robots robot NNS kim 125 18 present present JJ kim 125 19 . . . kim 126 1 ( ( -LRB- kim 126 2 a a LS kim 126 3 ) ) -RRB- kim 126 4 Moral moral JJ kim 126 5 desensitization desensitization NN kim 126 6 AI ai NN kim 126 7 - - HYPH kim 126 8 powered power VBN kim 126 9 military military JJ kim 126 10 robots robot NNS kim 126 11 go go VBP kim 126 12 further further RB kim 126 13 than than IN kim 126 14 any any DT kim 126 15 remotely remotely RB kim 126 16 - - HYPH kim 126 17 operated operate VBN kim 126 18 weapons weapon NNS kim 126 19 . . . kim 127 1 They -PRON- PRP kim 127 2 can can MD kim 127 3 identify identify VB kim 127 4 a a DT kim 127 5 target target NN kim 127 6 and and CC kim 127 7 initiate initiate VB kim 127 8 an an DT kim 127 9 attack attack NN kim 127 10 on on IN kim 127 11 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 127 12 own own JJ kim 127 13 . . . kim 128 1 Due due IN kim 128 2 to to IN kim 128 3 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 128 4 autonomy autonomy NN kim 128 5 , , , kim 128 6 military military JJ kim 128 7 robots robot NNS kim 128 8 can can MD kim 128 9 significantly significantly RB kim 128 10 increase increase VB kim 128 11 the the DT kim 128 12 distance distance NN kim 128 13 between between IN kim 128 14 the the DT kim 128 15 party party NN kim 128 16 that that WDT kim 128 17 kills kill VBZ kim 128 18 and and CC kim 128 19 the the DT kim 128 20 party party NN kim 128 21 that that WDT kim 128 22 gets get VBZ kim 128 23 killed kill VBN kim 128 24 ( ( -LRB- kim 128 25 Sharkey Sharkey NNP kim 128 26 2012 2012 CD kim 128 27 ) ) -RRB- kim 128 28 . . . kim 129 1 This this DT kim 129 2 increase increase NN kim 129 3 , , , kim 129 4 however however RB kim 129 5 , , , kim 129 6 may may MD kim 129 7 lead lead VB kim 129 8 people people NNS kim 129 9 to to TO kim 129 10 surrender surrender VB kim 129 11 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 129 12 own own JJ kim 129 13 moral moral JJ kim 129 14 responsibility responsibility NN kim 129 15 to to IN kim 129 16 a a DT kim 129 17 machine machine NN kim 129 18 , , , kim 129 19 thereby thereby RB kim 129 20 resulting result VBG kim 129 21 in in IN kim 129 22 the the DT kim 129 23 loss loss NN kim 129 24 of of IN kim 129 25 humanity humanity NN kim 129 26 , , , kim 129 27 which which WDT kim 129 28 is be VBZ kim 129 29 a a DT kim 129 30 serious serious JJ kim 129 31 moral moral JJ kim 129 32 risk risk NN kim 129 33 ( ( -LRB- kim 129 34 Davis Davis NNP kim 129 35 2007 2007 CD kim 129 36 ) ) -RRB- kim 129 37 . . . kim 130 1 The the DT kim 130 2 more more RBR kim 130 3 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 130 4 military military JJ kim 130 5 robots robot NNS kim 130 6 become become VBP kim 130 7 , , , kim 130 8 the the DT kim 130 9 less less JJR kim 130 10 responsibility responsibility NN kim 130 11 for for IN kim 130 12 life life NN kim 130 13 - - HYPH kim 130 14 or or CC kim 130 15 - - HYPH kim 130 16 death death NN kim 130 17 decisions decision NNS kim 130 18 may may MD kim 130 19 come come VB kim 130 20 to to TO kim 130 21 rest rest VB kim 130 22 with with IN kim 130 23 humans human NNS kim 130 24 . . . kim 131 1 ( ( -LRB- kim 131 2 b b NN kim 131 3 ) ) -RRB- kim 131 4 Unintended Unintended NNP kim 131 5 outcomes outcome NNS kim 131 6 As as IN kim 131 7 military military JJ kim 131 8 robots robot NNS kim 131 9 make make VBP kim 131 10 killing kill VBG kim 131 11 easier easy JJR kim 131 12 , , , kim 131 13 small small JJ kim 131 14 conflicts conflict NNS kim 131 15 may may MD kim 131 16 more more RBR kim 131 17 quickly quickly RB kim 131 18 escalate escalate VB kim 131 19 to to IN kim 131 20 a a DT kim 131 21 war war NN kim 131 22 . . . kim 132 1 The the DT kim 132 2 side side NN kim 132 3 that that WDT kim 132 4 deploys deploy VBZ kim 132 5 AI ai NN kim 132 6 - - HYPH kim 132 7 powered power VBN kim 132 8 military military JJ kim 132 9 robots robot NNS kim 132 10 is be VBZ kim 132 11 likely likely JJ kim 132 12 to to TO kim 132 13 suffer suffer VB kim 132 14 fewer few JJR kim 132 15 casualties casualty NNS kim 132 16 itself -PRON- PRP kim 132 17 while while IN kim 132 18 inflicting inflict VBG kim 132 19 more more JJR kim 132 20 casualties casualty NNS kim 132 21 on on IN kim 132 22 the the DT kim 132 23 enemy enemy NN kim 132 24 side side NN kim 132 25 . . . kim 133 1 This this DT kim 133 2 may may MD kim 133 3 make make VB kim 133 4 the the DT kim 133 5 military military NN kim 133 6 more more RBR kim 133 7 inclined inclined JJ kim 133 8 to to TO kim 133 9 start start VB kim 133 10 a a DT kim 133 11 war war NN kim 133 12 . . . kim 134 1 Ironically ironically RB kim 134 2 , , , kim 134 3 when when WRB kim 134 4 everyone everyone NN kim 134 5 thinks think VBZ kim 134 6 and and CC kim 134 7 acts act VBZ kim 134 8 this this DT kim 134 9 way way NN kim 134 10 , , , kim 134 11 the the DT kim 134 12 number number NN kim 134 13 of of IN kim 134 14 wars war NNS kim 134 15 and and CC kim 134 16 the the DT kim 134 17 overall overall JJ kim 134 18 amount amount NN kim 134 19 of of IN kim 134 20 violence violence NN kim 134 21 and and CC kim 134 22 destruction destruction NN kim 134 23 in in IN kim 134 24 the the DT kim 134 25 world world NN kim 134 26 will will MD kim 134 27 only only RB kim 134 28 increase increase VB kim 134 29 . . . kim 135 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 135 2 footnoteRef:12 footnoteref:12 NN kim 135 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 135 4 [ [ -LRB- kim 135 5 12 12 CD kim 135 6 : : : kim 135 7 Kahn Kahn NNP kim 135 8 ( ( -LRB- kim 135 9 2012 2012 CD kim 135 10 ) ) -RRB- kim 135 11 also also RB kim 135 12 argues argue VBZ kim 135 13 that that IN kim 135 14 the the DT kim 135 15 resulting result VBG kim 135 16 increase increase NN kim 135 17 in in IN kim 135 18 the the DT kim 135 19 number number NN kim 135 20 of of IN kim 135 21 wars war NNS kim 135 22 by by IN kim 135 23 the the DT kim 135 24 use use NN kim 135 25 of of IN kim 135 26 military military JJ kim 135 27 robots robot NNS kim 135 28 will will MD kim 135 29 be be VB kim 135 30 morally morally RB kim 135 31 bad bad JJ kim 135 32 . . . kim 135 33 ] ] -RRB- kim 136 1 ( ( -LRB- kim 136 2 c c NN kim 136 3 ) ) -RRB- kim 136 4 Surrender surrender NN kim 136 5 of of IN kim 136 6 moral moral JJ kim 136 7 agency agency NN kim 136 8 Military military JJ kim 136 9 robots robot NNS kim 136 10 may may MD kim 136 11 fail fail VB kim 136 12 to to TO kim 136 13 distinguish distinguish VB kim 136 14 innocents innocent NNS kim 136 15 from from IN kim 136 16 combatants combatant NNS kim 136 17 and and CC kim 136 18 kill kill VB kim 136 19 the the DT kim 136 20 former former JJ kim 136 21 . . . kim 137 1 In in IN kim 137 2 such such PDT kim 137 3 a a DT kim 137 4 case case NN kim 137 5 , , , kim 137 6 can can MD kim 137 7 we -PRON- PRP kim 137 8 be be VB kim 137 9 justified justify VBN kim 137 10 in in IN kim 137 11 letting let VBG kim 137 12 robots robot NNS kim 137 13 take take VB kim 137 14 the the DT kim 137 15 lives life NNS kim 137 16 of of IN kim 137 17 other other JJ kim 137 18 human human JJ kim 137 19 beings being NNS kim 137 20 ? ? . kim 138 1 Some some DT kim 138 2 may may MD kim 138 3 argue argue VB kim 138 4 that that IN kim 138 5 only only RB kim 138 6 humans human NNS kim 138 7 should should MD kim 138 8 decide decide VB kim 138 9 to to TO kim 138 10 kill kill VB kim 138 11 other other JJ kim 138 12 humans human NNS kim 138 13 , , , kim 138 14 not not RB kim 138 15 machines machine NNS kim 138 16 ( ( -LRB- kim 138 17 Davis Davis NNP kim 138 18 2007 2007 CD kim 138 19 ) ) -RRB- kim 138 20 . . . kim 139 1 Is be VBZ kim 139 2 it -PRON- PRP kim 139 3 permissible permissible JJ kim 139 4 for for IN kim 139 5 people people NNS kim 139 6 to to TO kim 139 7 delegate delegate VB kim 139 8 such such PDT kim 139 9 a a DT kim 139 10 decision decision NN kim 139 11 to to IN kim 139 12 robots robot NNS kim 139 13 ? ? . kim 140 1 ( ( -LRB- kim 140 2 d d LS kim 140 3 ) ) -RRB- kim 140 4 Opacity opacity NN kim 140 5 in in IN kim 140 6 decision decision NN kim 140 7 - - HYPH kim 140 8 making make VBG kim 140 9 Machine Machine NNP kim 140 10 learning learning NN kim 140 11 is be VBZ kim 140 12 used use VBN kim 140 13 to to TO kim 140 14 build build VB kim 140 15 many many JJ kim 140 16 AI AI NNP kim 140 17 systems system NNS kim 140 18 today today NN kim 140 19 . . . kim 141 1 Instead instead RB kim 141 2 of of IN kim 141 3 prescribing prescribe VBG kim 141 4 a a DT kim 141 5 pre pre JJ kim 141 6 - - JJ kim 141 7 determined determined JJ kim 141 8 algorithm algorithm NN kim 141 9 , , , kim 141 10 a a DT kim 141 11 machine machine NN kim 141 12 learning learning NN kim 141 13 system system NN kim 141 14 goes go VBZ kim 141 15 through through IN kim 141 16 a a DT kim 141 17 so so RB kim 141 18 - - HYPH kim 141 19 called call VBN kim 141 20 ‘ ' `` kim 141 21 training training NN kim 141 22 ’ ' '' kim 141 23 process process NN kim 141 24 in in IN kim 141 25 order order NN kim 141 26 to to TO kim 141 27 produce produce VB kim 141 28 the the DT kim 141 29 final final JJ kim 141 30 algorithm algorithm NN kim 141 31 from from IN kim 141 32 a a DT kim 141 33 large large JJ kim 141 34 amount amount NN kim 141 35 of of IN kim 141 36 data datum NNS kim 141 37 . . . kim 142 1 For for IN kim 142 2 example example NN kim 142 3 , , , kim 142 4 a a DT kim 142 5 machine machine NN kim 142 6 learning learning NN kim 142 7 system system NN kim 142 8 may may MD kim 142 9 generate generate VB kim 142 10 an an DT kim 142 11 algorithm algorithm NN kim 142 12 that that WDT kim 142 13 successfully successfully RB kim 142 14 recognizes recognize VBZ kim 142 15 cats cat NNS kim 142 16 in in IN kim 142 17 a a DT kim 142 18 photo photo NN kim 142 19 after after IN kim 142 20 going go VBG kim 142 21 through through IN kim 142 22 millions million NNS kim 142 23 of of IN kim 142 24 photos photo NNS kim 142 25 that that WDT kim 142 26 show show VBP kim 142 27 cats cat NNS kim 142 28 in in IN kim 142 29 many many JJ kim 142 30 different different JJ kim 142 31 postures posture NNS kim 142 32 from from IN kim 142 33 various various JJ kim 142 34 angles angle NNS kim 142 35 . . . kim 143 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 143 2 footnoteRef:13 footnoteref:13 NN kim 143 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 143 4 But but CC kim 143 5 the the DT kim 143 6 resulting result VBG kim 143 7 algorithm algorithm NN kim 143 8 is be VBZ kim 143 9 a a DT kim 143 10 complex complex JJ kim 143 11 mathematical mathematical JJ kim 143 12 formula formula NN kim 143 13 and and CC kim 143 14 not not RB kim 143 15 something something NN kim 143 16 that that WDT kim 143 17 humans human NNS kim 143 18 can can MD kim 143 19 easily easily RB kim 143 20 decipher decipher VB kim 143 21 . . . kim 144 1 This this DT kim 144 2 means mean VBZ kim 144 3 that that IN kim 144 4 the the DT kim 144 5 inner inner JJ kim 144 6 workings working NNS kim 144 7 of of IN kim 144 8 a a DT kim 144 9 machine machine NN kim 144 10 learning learn VBG kim 144 11 AI ai NN kim 144 12 system system NN kim 144 13 and and CC kim 144 14 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 144 15 decision decision NN kim 144 16 - - HYPH kim 144 17 making make VBG kim 144 18 process process NN kim 144 19 is be VBZ kim 144 20 opaque opaque JJ kim 144 21 to to IN kim 144 22 human human JJ kim 144 23 understanding understanding NN kim 144 24 , , , kim 144 25 even even RB kim 144 26 to to IN kim 144 27 those those DT kim 144 28 who who WP kim 144 29 built build VBD kim 144 30 the the DT kim 144 31 system system NN kim 144 32 itself -PRON- PRP kim 144 33 ( ( -LRB- kim 144 34 Knight Knight NNP kim 144 35 2017 2017 CD kim 144 36 ) ) -RRB- kim 144 37 . . . kim 145 1 In in IN kim 145 2 cases case NNS kim 145 3 where where WRB kim 145 4 the the DT kim 145 5 actions action NNS kim 145 6 of of IN kim 145 7 an an DT kim 145 8 AI AI NNP kim 145 9 system system NN kim 145 10 can can MD kim 145 11 have have VB kim 145 12 grave grave JJ kim 145 13 consequences consequence NNS kim 145 14 such such JJ kim 145 15 as as IN kim 145 16 a a DT kim 145 17 military military JJ kim 145 18 robot robot NN kim 145 19 , , , kim 145 20 such such JJ kim 145 21 opacity opacity NN kim 145 22 becomes become VBZ kim 145 23 a a DT kim 145 24 serious serious JJ kim 145 25 problem problem NN kim 145 26 . . . kim 146 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 146 2 footnoteRef:14 footnoteRef:14 NNP kim 146 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 146 4 In in IN kim 146 5 spite spite NN kim 146 6 of of IN kim 146 7 these these DT kim 146 8 ethical ethical JJ kim 146 9 concerns concern NNS kim 146 10 , , , kim 146 11 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 146 12 AI AI NNP kim 146 13 systems system NNS kim 146 14 are be VBP kim 146 15 likely likely JJ kim 146 16 to to TO kim 146 17 continue continue VB kim 146 18 to to TO kim 146 19 be be VB kim 146 20 developed develop VBN kim 146 21 and and CC kim 146 22 adopted adopt VBN kim 146 23 in in IN kim 146 24 many many JJ kim 146 25 areas area NNS kim 146 26 as as IN kim 146 27 a a DT kim 146 28 way way NN kim 146 29 to to TO kim 146 30 increase increase VB kim 146 31 efficiency efficiency NN kim 146 32 and and CC kim 146 33 lower low JJR kim 146 34 cost cost NN kim 146 35 . . . kim 147 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 147 2 13 13 CD kim 147 3 : : : kim 147 4 Google Google NNP kim 147 5 ’s ’s POS kim 147 6 research research NN kim 147 7 team team NN kim 147 8 created create VBD kim 147 9 an an DT kim 147 10 AI AI NNP kim 147 11 algorithm algorithm NN kim 147 12 that that WDT kim 147 13 learned learn VBD kim 147 14 how how WRB kim 147 15 to to TO kim 147 16 recognize recognize VB kim 147 17 a a DT kim 147 18 cat cat NN kim 147 19 in in IN kim 147 20 2012 2012 CD kim 147 21 . . . kim 148 1 The the DT kim 148 2 neural neural JJ kim 148 3 network network NN kim 148 4 behind behind IN kim 148 5 this this DT kim 148 6 algorithm algorithm NN kim 148 7 had have VBD kim 148 8 an an DT kim 148 9 array array NN kim 148 10 of of IN kim 148 11 16,000 16,000 CD kim 148 12 processors processor NNS kim 148 13 and and CC kim 148 14 more more JJR kim 148 15 than than IN kim 148 16 one one CD kim 148 17 billion billion CD kim 148 18 connections connection NNS kim 148 19 , , , kim 148 20 and and CC kim 148 21 unlabeled unlabeled JJ kim 148 22 random random JJ kim 148 23 thumbnail thumbnail NN kim 148 24 images image NNS kim 148 25 from from IN kim 148 26 10 10 CD kim 148 27 million million CD kim 148 28 YouTube YouTube NNP kim 148 29 videos video NNS kim 148 30 allowed allow VBD kim 148 31 this this DT kim 148 32 algorithm algorithm NN kim 148 33 to to TO kim 148 34 learn learn VB kim 148 35 to to TO kim 148 36 identify identify VB kim 148 37 cats cat NNS kim 148 38 by by IN kim 148 39 itself -PRON- PRP kim 148 40 . . . kim 149 1 See see VB kim 149 2 Markoff Markoff NNP kim 149 3 2012 2012 CD kim 149 4 and and CC kim 149 5 Liat Liat NNP kim 149 6 2012 2012 CD kim 149 7 . . . kim 149 8 ] ] -RRB- kim 150 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 150 2 14 14 CD kim 150 3 : : : kim 150 4 This this DT kim 150 5 black black JJ kim 150 6 - - HYPH kim 150 7 box box NN kim 150 8 nature nature NN kim 150 9 of of IN kim 150 10 AI AI NNP kim 150 11 systems system NNS kim 150 12 powered power VBN kim 150 13 by by IN kim 150 14 machine machine NN kim 150 15 learning learning NN kim 150 16 has have VBZ kim 150 17 raised raise VBN kim 150 18 great great JJ kim 150 19 concern concern NN kim 150 20 among among IN kim 150 21 many many JJ kim 150 22 AI AI NNP kim 150 23 researchers researcher NNS kim 150 24 in in IN kim 150 25 recent recent JJ kim 150 26 years year NNS kim 150 27 . . . kim 151 1 This this DT kim 151 2 is be VBZ kim 151 3 problematic problematic JJ kim 151 4 in in IN kim 151 5 all all DT kim 151 6 areas area NNS kim 151 7 where where WRB kim 151 8 these these DT kim 151 9 AI AI NNP kim 151 10 systems system NNS kim 151 11 are be VBP kim 151 12 used use VBN kim 151 13 for for IN kim 151 14 decision decision NN kim 151 15 - - HYPH kim 151 16 making making NN kim 151 17 , , , kim 151 18 not not RB kim 151 19 just just RB kim 151 20 in in IN kim 151 21 military military JJ kim 151 22 operations operation NNS kim 151 23 . . . kim 152 1 The the DT kim 152 2 gravity gravity NN kim 152 3 of of IN kim 152 4 decisions decision NNS kim 152 5 made make VBN kim 152 6 in in IN kim 152 7 a a DT kim 152 8 military military JJ kim 152 9 operation operation NN kim 152 10 makes make VBZ kim 152 11 this this DT kim 152 12 problem problem NN kim 152 13 even even RB kim 152 14 more more RBR kim 152 15 troublesome troublesome JJ kim 152 16 . . . kim 153 1 Fortunately fortunately RB kim 153 2 , , , kim 153 3 some some DT kim 153 4 AI AI NNP kim 153 5 researchers researcher NNS kim 153 6 including include VBG kim 153 7 those those DT kim 153 8 in in IN kim 153 9 the the DT kim 153 10 US US NNP kim 153 11 Department Department NNP kim 153 12 of of IN kim 153 13 Defense Defense NNP kim 153 14 are be VBP kim 153 15 actively actively RB kim 153 16 working work VBG kim 153 17 to to TO kim 153 18 make make VB kim 153 19 AI AI NNP kim 153 20 systems system NNS kim 153 21 explainable explainable JJ kim 153 22 . . . kim 154 1 But but CC kim 154 2 until until IN kim 154 3 such such JJ kim 154 4 research research NN kim 154 5 bears bear VBZ kim 154 6 fruit fruit NN kim 154 7 and and CC kim 154 8 AI AI NNP kim 154 9 systems system NNS kim 154 10 become become VBP kim 154 11 fully fully RB kim 154 12 explainable explainable JJ kim 154 13 , , , kim 154 14 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 154 15 military military JJ kim 154 16 use use NN kim 154 17 means mean VBZ kim 154 18 accepting accept VBG kim 154 19 many many JJ kim 154 20 unknown unknown JJ kim 154 21 variables variable NNS kim 154 22 and and CC kim 154 23 unforeseeable unforeseeable JJ kim 154 24 consequences consequence NNS kim 154 25 . . . kim 155 1 See see VB kim 155 2 Turek Turek NNP kim 155 3 n.d n.d NNP kim 155 4 .. .. NFP kim 155 5 ] ] -RRB- kim 155 6 5 5 CD kim 155 7 . . . kim 156 1 AI AI NNP kim 156 2 Applications Applications NNPS kim 156 3 for for IN kim 156 4 Libraries library NNS kim 156 5 Do do VBP kim 156 6 these these DT kim 156 7 ethical ethical JJ kim 156 8 concerns concern NNS kim 156 9 outlined outline VBN kim 156 10 above above IN kim 156 11 apply apply VBP kim 156 12 to to IN kim 156 13 libraries library NNS kim 156 14 ? ? . kim 157 1 To to TO kim 157 2 answer answer VB kim 157 3 that that DT kim 157 4 , , , kim 157 5 let let VB kim 157 6 us -PRON- PRP kim 157 7 first first RB kim 157 8 take take VB kim 157 9 a a DT kim 157 10 look look NN kim 157 11 at at IN kim 157 12 how how WRB kim 157 13 AI AI NNP kim 157 14 , , , kim 157 15 particularly particularly RB kim 157 16 machine machine NN kim 157 17 learning learning NN kim 157 18 , , , kim 157 19 may may MD kim 157 20 apply apply VB kim 157 21 to to IN kim 157 22 library library NN kim 157 23 services service NNS kim 157 24 and and CC kim 157 25 operations operation NNS kim 157 26 . . . kim 158 1 AI AI NNP kim 158 2 - - HYPH kim 158 3 powered power VBN kim 158 4 digital digital JJ kim 158 5 assistants assistant NNS kim 158 6 are be VBP kim 158 7 likely likely JJ kim 158 8 to to TO kim 158 9 mediate mediate VB kim 158 10 a a DT kim 158 11 library library NN kim 158 12 user user NN kim 158 13 ’s ’s POS kim 158 14 information information NN kim 158 15 search search NN kim 158 16 , , , kim 158 17 discovery discovery NN kim 158 18 , , , kim 158 19 and and CC kim 158 20 retrieval retrieval NN kim 158 21 activities activity NNS kim 158 22 in in IN kim 158 23 the the DT kim 158 24 near near JJ kim 158 25 future future NN kim 158 26 . . . kim 159 1 In in IN kim 159 2 recent recent JJ kim 159 3 years year NNS kim 159 4 , , , kim 159 5 machine machine NN kim 159 6 learning learning NN kim 159 7 and and CC kim 159 8 deep deep JJ kim 159 9 learning learning NN kim 159 10 have have VBP kim 159 11 brought bring VBN kim 159 12 significant significant JJ kim 159 13 improvement improvement NN kim 159 14 to to IN kim 159 15 natural natural JJ kim 159 16 language language NN kim 159 17 processing processing NN kim 159 18 ( ( -LRB- kim 159 19 NLP NLP NNP kim 159 20 ) ) -RRB- kim 159 21 , , , kim 159 22 which which WDT kim 159 23 deals deal VBZ kim 159 24 with with IN kim 159 25 analyzing analyze VBG kim 159 26 large large JJ kim 159 27 amounts amount NNS kim 159 28 of of IN kim 159 29 natural natural JJ kim 159 30 language language NN kim 159 31 data datum NNS kim 159 32 to to TO kim 159 33 make make VB kim 159 34 the the DT kim 159 35 interaction interaction NN kim 159 36 between between IN kim 159 37 people people NNS kim 159 38 and and CC kim 159 39 machines machine NNS kim 159 40 in in IN kim 159 41 natural natural JJ kim 159 42 languages language NNS kim 159 43 possible possible JJ kim 159 44 . . . kim 160 1 For for IN kim 160 2 instance instance NN kim 160 3 , , , kim 160 4 Google Google NNP kim 160 5 Assistant Assistant NNP kim 160 6 ’s ’s POS kim 160 7 new new JJ kim 160 8 feature feature NN kim 160 9 ‘ ' `` kim 160 10 duplex duplex NN kim 160 11 ’ ' '' kim 160 12 was be VBD kim 160 13 shown show VBN kim 160 14 to to TO kim 160 15 successfully successfully RB kim 160 16 make make VB kim 160 17 a a DT kim 160 18 phone phone NN kim 160 19 reservation reservation NN kim 160 20 with with IN kim 160 21 restaurant restaurant NN kim 160 22 staff staff NN kim 160 23 in in IN kim 160 24 2018 2018 CD kim 160 25 ( ( -LRB- kim 160 26 Welch Welch NNP kim 160 27 2018 2018 CD kim 160 28 ) ) -RRB- kim 160 29 . . . kim 161 1 Google Google NNP kim 161 2 ’s ’s POS kim 161 3 real real JJ kim 161 4 - - HYPH kim 161 5 time time NN kim 161 6 translation translation NN kim 161 7 capability capability NN kim 161 8 for for IN kim 161 9 40 40 CD kim 161 10 different different JJ kim 161 11 languages language NNS kim 161 12 is be VBZ kim 161 13 planned plan VBN kim 161 14 to to TO kim 161 15 become become VB kim 161 16 part part NN kim 161 17 of of IN kim 161 18 the the DT kim 161 19 features feature NNS kim 161 20 for for IN kim 161 21 all all DT kim 161 22 headphones headphone NNS kim 161 23 equipped equip VBN kim 161 24 with with IN kim 161 25 Google Google NNP kim 161 26 Assistant Assistant NNP kim 161 27 ( ( -LRB- kim 161 28 Le Le NNP kim 161 29 and and CC kim 161 30 Schuster Schuster NNP kim 161 31 2016 2016 CD kim 161 32 , , , kim 161 33 Porter Porter NNP kim 161 34 2018 2018 CD kim 161 35 ) ) -RRB- kim 161 36 . . . kim 162 1 As as IN kim 162 2 digital digital JJ kim 162 3 assistants assistant NNS kim 162 4 become become VBP kim 162 5 capable capable JJ kim 162 6 of of IN kim 162 7 handling handle VBG kim 162 8 more more RBR kim 162 9 sophisticated sophisticated JJ kim 162 10 language language NN kim 162 11 tasks task NNS kim 162 12 , , , kim 162 13 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 162 14 use use NN kim 162 15 as as IN kim 162 16 a a DT kim 162 17 flexible flexible JJ kim 162 18 voice voice NN kim 162 19 user user NN kim 162 20 interface interface NN kim 162 21 will will MD kim 162 22 only only RB kim 162 23 increase increase VB kim 162 24 . . . kim 163 1 Such such JJ kim 163 2 digital digital JJ kim 163 3 assistants assistant NNS kim 163 4 will will MD kim 163 5 directly directly RB kim 163 6 interact interact VB kim 163 7 with with IN kim 163 8 library library JJ kim 163 9 systems system NNS kim 163 10 and and CC kim 163 11 applications application NNS kim 163 12 , , , kim 163 13 automatically automatically RB kim 163 14 interpret interpret VB kim 163 15 a a DT kim 163 16 query query NN kim 163 17 , , , kim 163 18 and and CC kim 163 19 return return VB kim 163 20 results result NNS kim 163 21 that that WDT kim 163 22 they -PRON- PRP kim 163 23 deem deem VBP kim 163 24 to to TO kim 163 25 be be VB kim 163 26 most most RBS kim 163 27 relevant relevant JJ kim 163 28 . . . kim 164 1 Those those DT kim 164 2 digital digital JJ kim 164 3 assistants assistant NNS kim 164 4 can can MD kim 164 5 also also RB kim 164 6 be be VB kim 164 7 equipped equip VBN kim 164 8 to to TO kim 164 9 handle handle VB kim 164 10 the the DT kim 164 11 library library NN kim 164 12 ’s ’s , kim 164 13 traditional traditional JJ kim 164 14 reference reference NN kim 164 15 or or CC kim 164 16 readers reader NNS kim 164 17 ’ ’ POS kim 164 18 advisory advisory JJ kim 164 19 service service NN kim 164 20 . . . kim 165 1 Integrated integrate VBN kim 165 2 into into IN kim 165 3 a a DT kim 165 4 humanoid humanoid JJ kim 165 5 robot robot NN kim 165 6 body body NN kim 165 7 , , , kim 165 8 they -PRON- PRP kim 165 9 may may MD kim 165 10 even even RB kim 165 11 greet greet VB kim 165 12 library library JJ kim 165 13 patrons patron NNS kim 165 14 at at IN kim 165 15 the the DT kim 165 16 entrance entrance NN kim 165 17 and and CC kim 165 18 answer answer VB kim 165 19 directional directional JJ kim 165 20 questions question NNS kim 165 21 about about IN kim 165 22 the the DT kim 165 23 library library NN kim 165 24 building building NN kim 165 25 . . . kim 166 1 Cataloging catalog VBG kim 166 2 , , , kim 166 3 abstracting abstracting NN kim 166 4 , , , kim 166 5 and and CC kim 166 6 indexing indexing NN kim 166 7 are be VBP kim 166 8 other other JJ kim 166 9 areas area NNS kim 166 10 where where WRB kim 166 11 AI AI NNP kim 166 12 will will MD kim 166 13 be be VB kim 166 14 actively actively RB kim 166 15 utilized utilize VBN kim 166 16 . . . kim 167 1 Currently currently RB kim 167 2 , , , kim 167 3 those those DT kim 167 4 tasks task NNS kim 167 5 are be VBP kim 167 6 performed perform VBN kim 167 7 by by IN kim 167 8 skilled skilled JJ kim 167 9 professionals professional NNS kim 167 10 . . . kim 168 1 But but CC kim 168 2 as as IN kim 168 3 AI AI NNP kim 168 4 applications application NNS kim 168 5 become become VBP kim 168 6 more more RBR kim 168 7 sophisticated sophisticated JJ kim 168 8 , , , kim 168 9 we -PRON- PRP kim 168 10 may may MD kim 168 11 see see VB kim 168 12 many many JJ kim 168 13 of of IN kim 168 14 those those DT kim 168 15 tasks task NNS kim 168 16 partially partially RB kim 168 17 or or CC kim 168 18 fully fully RB kim 168 19 automated automate VBN kim 168 20 and and CC kim 168 21 handed hand VBD kim 168 22 over over RP kim 168 23 to to IN kim 168 24 AI AI NNP kim 168 25 systems system NNS kim 168 26 . . . kim 169 1 Machine machine NN kim 169 2 learning learning NN kim 169 3 and and CC kim 169 4 deep deep JJ kim 169 5 learning learning NN kim 169 6 can can MD kim 169 7 be be VB kim 169 8 used use VBN kim 169 9 to to TO kim 169 10 extract extract VB kim 169 11 key key JJ kim 169 12 information information NN kim 169 13 from from IN kim 169 14 a a DT kim 169 15 large large JJ kim 169 16 number number NN kim 169 17 of of IN kim 169 18 documents document NNS kim 169 19 or or CC kim 169 20 from from IN kim 169 21 information information NN kim 169 22 - - HYPH kim 169 23 rich rich JJ kim 169 24 visual visual JJ kim 169 25 materials material NNS kim 169 26 such such JJ kim 169 27 as as IN kim 169 28 maps map NNS kim 169 29 and and CC kim 169 30 video video NN kim 169 31 recordings recording NNS kim 169 32 , , , kim 169 33 and and CC kim 169 34 generate generate VB kim 169 35 metadata metadata NN kim 169 36 or or CC kim 169 37 a a DT kim 169 38 summary summary NN kim 169 39 . . . kim 170 1 Since since IN kim 170 2 machine machine NN kim 170 3 learning learning NN kim 170 4 is be VBZ kim 170 5 new new JJ kim 170 6 to to IN kim 170 7 libraries library NNS kim 170 8 , , , kim 170 9 there there EX kim 170 10 are be VBP kim 170 11 a a DT kim 170 12 relatively relatively RB kim 170 13 small small JJ kim 170 14 number number NN kim 170 15 of of IN kim 170 16 machine machine NN kim 170 17 learning learning NN kim 170 18 applications application NNS kim 170 19 developed develop VBN kim 170 20 for for IN kim 170 21 libraries library NNS kim 170 22 ’ ’ POS kim 170 23 use use NN kim 170 24 . . . kim 171 1 They -PRON- PRP kim 171 2 are be VBP kim 171 3 likely likely JJ kim 171 4 to to TO kim 171 5 grow grow VB kim 171 6 in in IN kim 171 7 number number NN kim 171 8 . . . kim 172 1 Yewno Yewno NNP kim 172 2 , , , kim 172 3 Quartolio Quartolio NNP kim 172 4 , , , kim 172 5 and and CC kim 172 6 Iris.ai iris.ai NN kim 172 7 are be VBP kim 172 8 examples example NNS kim 172 9 of of IN kim 172 10 the the DT kim 172 11 vendor vendor NN kim 172 12 products product NNS kim 172 13 developed develop VBN kim 172 14 with with IN kim 172 15 machine machine NN kim 172 16 learning learning NN kim 172 17 and and CC kim 172 18 deep deep JJ kim 172 19 learning learning NN kim 172 20 techniques technique NNS kim 172 21 . . . kim 173 1 Yewno Yewno NNP kim 173 2 Discover Discover NNP kim 173 3 displays display VBZ kim 173 4 the the DT kim 173 5 connections connection NNS kim 173 6 between between IN kim 173 7 different different JJ kim 173 8 concepts concept NNS kim 173 9 or or CC kim 173 10 works work NNS kim 173 11 in in IN kim 173 12 library library NN kim 173 13 materials material NNS kim 173 14 . . . kim 174 1 Quartolio quartolio JJ kim 174 2 targets target NNS kim 174 3 researchers researcher NNS kim 174 4 looking look VBG kim 174 5 to to TO kim 174 6 discover discover VB kim 174 7 untapped untapped JJ kim 174 8 research research NN kim 174 9 opportunities opportunity NNS kim 174 10 based base VBN kim 174 11 upon upon IN kim 174 12 a a DT kim 174 13 large large JJ kim 174 14 amount amount NN kim 174 15 of of IN kim 174 16 data datum NNS kim 174 17 that that WDT kim 174 18 includes include VBZ kim 174 19 articles article NNS kim 174 20 , , , kim 174 21 clinical clinical JJ kim 174 22 trials trial NNS kim 174 23 , , , kim 174 24 patents patent NNS kim 174 25 , , , kim 174 26 and and CC kim 174 27 notes note NNS kim 174 28 . . . kim 175 1 Similarly similarly RB kim 175 2 , , , kim 175 3 Iris.ai Iris.ai NNP kim 175 4 helps help VBZ kim 175 5 researchers researcher NNS kim 175 6 identify identify VB kim 175 7 and and CC kim 175 8 review review VB kim 175 9 a a DT kim 175 10 large large JJ kim 175 11 amount amount NN kim 175 12 of of IN kim 175 13 research research NN kim 175 14 papers paper NNS kim 175 15 and and CC kim 175 16 patents patent NNS kim 175 17 and and CC kim 175 18 extracts extract VBZ kim 175 19 key key JJ kim 175 20 information information NN kim 175 21 from from IN kim 175 22 them -PRON- PRP kim 175 23 . . . kim 176 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 176 2 footnoteRef:15 footnoteref:15 CD kim 176 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 176 4 Kira Kira NNP kim 176 5 identifies identifie NNS kim 176 6 , , , kim 176 7 extracts extract VBZ kim 176 8 , , , kim 176 9 and and CC kim 176 10 analyzes analyze VBZ kim 176 11 text text NN kim 176 12 in in IN kim 176 13 contracts contract NNS kim 176 14 and and CC kim 176 15 other other JJ kim 176 16 legal legal JJ kim 176 17 documents document NNS kim 176 18 . . . kim 177 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 177 2 footnoteRef:16 footnoteRef:16 NNP kim 177 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 177 4 None none NN kim 177 5 of of IN kim 177 6 these these DT kim 177 7 applications application NNS kim 177 8 performs perform VBZ kim 177 9 fully fully RB kim 177 10 automated automate VBN kim 177 11 decision decision NN kim 177 12 - - HYPH kim 177 13 making making NN kim 177 14 nor nor CC kim 177 15 incorporates incorporate VBZ kim 177 16 the the DT kim 177 17 digital digital JJ kim 177 18 assistant assistant NN kim 177 19 feature feature NN kim 177 20 . . . kim 178 1 But but CC kim 178 2 this this DT kim 178 3 is be VBZ kim 178 4 an an DT kim 178 5 area area NN kim 178 6 where where WRB kim 178 7 information information NN kim 178 8 systems system NNS kim 178 9 vendors vendor NNS kim 178 10 are be VBP kim 178 11 increasingly increasingly RB kim 178 12 focusing focus VBG kim 178 13 . . . kim 179 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 179 2 15 15 CD kim 179 3 : : : kim 179 4 See see VB kim 179 5 https://www.yewno.com/education https://www.yewno.com/education CD kim 179 6 , , , kim 179 7 https://quartolio.com/ https://quartolio.com/ CD kim 179 8 , , , kim 179 9 and and CC kim 179 10 https://iris.ai/. https://iris.ai/. VBN kim 179 11 ] ] -RRB- kim 180 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 180 2 16 16 CD kim 180 3 : : : kim 180 4 See see VB kim 180 5 https://kirasystems.com/. https://kirasystems.com/. NNP kim 181 1 Law law NN kim 181 2 firms firm NNS kim 181 3 are be VBP kim 181 4 adopting adopt VBG kim 181 5 similar similar JJ kim 181 6 products product NNS kim 181 7 to to TO kim 181 8 automate automate VB kim 181 9 and and CC kim 181 10 expedite expedite VB kim 181 11 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 181 12 legal legal JJ kim 181 13 work work NN kim 181 14 , , , kim 181 15 and and CC kim 181 16 law law NN kim 181 17 librarians librarian NNS kim 181 18 are be VBP kim 181 19 discussing discuss VBG kim 181 20 how how WRB kim 181 21 the the DT kim 181 22 use use NN kim 181 23 of of IN kim 181 24 AI AI NNP kim 181 25 may may MD kim 181 26 change change VB kim 181 27 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 181 28 work work NN kim 181 29 . . . kim 182 1 See see VB kim 182 2 Marr Marr NNP kim 182 3 2018 2018 CD kim 182 4 and and CC kim 182 5 Talley Talley NNP kim 182 6 2016 2016 CD kim 182 7 . . . kim 182 8 ] ] -RRB- kim 183 1 Libraries library NNS kim 183 2 themselves -PRON- PRP kim 183 3 are be VBP kim 183 4 also also RB kim 183 5 experimenting experiment VBG kim 183 6 with with IN kim 183 7 AI AI NNP kim 183 8 to to TO kim 183 9 test test VB kim 183 10 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 183 11 potential potential NN kim 183 12 for for IN kim 183 13 library library NN kim 183 14 services service NNS kim 183 15 and and CC kim 183 16 operations operation NNS kim 183 17 . . . kim 184 1 Some some DT kim 184 2 are be VBP kim 184 3 focusing focus VBG kim 184 4 on on IN kim 184 5 using use VBG kim 184 6 AI AI NNP kim 184 7 , , , kim 184 8 particularly particularly RB kim 184 9 the the DT kim 184 10 voice voice NN kim 184 11 user user NN kim 184 12 interface interface NN kim 184 13 aspect aspect NN kim 184 14 of of IN kim 184 15 the the DT kim 184 16 digital digital JJ kim 184 17 assistant assistant NN kim 184 18 , , , kim 184 19 in in IN kim 184 20 order order NN kim 184 21 to to TO kim 184 22 improve improve VB kim 184 23 existing exist VBG kim 184 24 services service NNS kim 184 25 . . . kim 185 1 The the DT kim 185 2 University University NNP kim 185 3 of of IN kim 185 4 Oklahoma Oklahoma NNP kim 185 5 Libraries library NNS kim 185 6 have have VBP kim 185 7 been be VBN kim 185 8 building build VBG kim 185 9 an an DT kim 185 10 Alexa alexa JJ kim 185 11 application application NN kim 185 12 to to TO kim 185 13 provide provide VB kim 185 14 basic basic JJ kim 185 15 reference reference NN kim 185 16 service service NN kim 185 17 to to IN kim 185 18 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 185 19 students student NNS kim 185 20 . . . kim 186 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 186 2 footnoteRef:17 footnoteRef:17 NNP kim 186 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 186 4 At at IN kim 186 5 the the DT kim 186 6 University University NNP kim 186 7 of of IN kim 186 8 Pretoria Pretoria NNP kim 186 9 Library Library NNP kim 186 10 in in IN kim 186 11 South South NNP kim 186 12 Africa Africa NNP kim 186 13 , , , kim 186 14 a a DT kim 186 15 robot robot NN kim 186 16 named name VBN kim 186 17 ‘ ' `` kim 186 18 Libby Libby NNP kim 186 19 ’ ' '' kim 186 20 already already RB kim 186 21 interacts interact VBZ kim 186 22 with with IN kim 186 23 patrons patron NNS kim 186 24 by by IN kim 186 25 providing provide VBG kim 186 26 guidance guidance NN kim 186 27 , , , kim 186 28 answering answer VBG kim 186 29 questions question NNS kim 186 30 , , , kim 186 31 conducting conduct VBG kim 186 32 surveys survey NNS kim 186 33 , , , kim 186 34 and and CC kim 186 35 displaying display VBG kim 186 36 marketing marketing NN kim 186 37 videos video NNS kim 186 38 ( ( -LRB- kim 186 39 Mahlangu Mahlangu NNP kim 186 40 2019 2019 CD kim 186 41 ) ) -RRB- kim 186 42 . . . kim 187 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 187 2 17 17 CD kim 187 3 : : : kim 187 4 University University NNP kim 187 5 of of IN kim 187 6 Oklahoma Oklahoma NNP kim 187 7 Libraries Libraries NNPS kim 187 8 are be VBP kim 187 9 building build VBG kim 187 10 an an DT kim 187 11 Alexa alexa JJ kim 187 12 application application NN kim 187 13 that that WDT kim 187 14 will will MD kim 187 15 provide provide VB kim 187 16 some some DT kim 187 17 basic basic JJ kim 187 18 reference reference NN kim 187 19 service service NN kim 187 20 to to IN kim 187 21 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 187 22 students student NNS kim 187 23 . . . kim 188 1 Also also RB kim 188 2 , , , kim 188 3 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 188 4 PAIR PAIR NNP kim 188 5 registry registry NN kim 188 6 attempts attempt VBZ kim 188 7 to to TO kim 188 8 compile compile VB kim 188 9 all all DT kim 188 10 AI ai NN kim 188 11 - - HYPH kim 188 12 related relate VBN kim 188 13 projects project NNS kim 188 14 at at IN kim 188 15 libraries library NNS kim 188 16 . . . kim 189 1 See see VB kim 189 2 https://pair.libraries.ou.edu https://pair.libraries.ou.edu NN kim 189 3 . . . kim 189 4 ] ] -RRB- kim 190 1 Other other JJ kim 190 2 libraries library NNS kim 190 3 are be VBP kim 190 4 applying apply VBG kim 190 5 AI AI NNP kim 190 6 to to IN kim 190 7 extracting extract VBG kim 190 8 information information NN kim 190 9 and and CC kim 190 10 automating automate VBG kim 190 11 metadata metadata NN kim 190 12 generation generation NN kim 190 13 for for IN kim 190 14 digital digital JJ kim 190 15 materials material NNS kim 190 16 to to TO kim 190 17 enhance enhance VB kim 190 18 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 190 19 discovery discovery NN kim 190 20 and and CC kim 190 21 use use NN kim 190 22 . . . kim 191 1 The the DT kim 191 2 Library Library NNP kim 191 3 of of IN kim 191 4 Congress Congress NNP kim 191 5 has have VBZ kim 191 6 worked work VBN kim 191 7 on on IN kim 191 8 detecting detect VBG kim 191 9 features feature NNS kim 191 10 , , , kim 191 11 such such JJ kim 191 12 as as IN kim 191 13 railroads railroad NNS kim 191 14 in in IN kim 191 15 maps map NNS kim 191 16 , , , kim 191 17 using use VBG kim 191 18 the the DT kim 191 19 convolutional convolutional JJ kim 191 20 neural neural JJ kim 191 21 network network NN kim 191 22 model model NN kim 191 23 , , , kim 191 24 and and CC kim 191 25 issued issue VBD kim 191 26 a a DT kim 191 27 solicitation solicitation NN kim 191 28 for for IN kim 191 29 a a DT kim 191 30 machine machine NN kim 191 31 learning learning NN kim 191 32 and and CC kim 191 33 deep deep JJ kim 191 34 learning learning NN kim 191 35 pilot pilot NN kim 191 36 program program NN kim 191 37 that that WDT kim 191 38 will will MD kim 191 39 maximize maximize VB kim 191 40 the the DT kim 191 41 use use NN kim 191 42 of of IN kim 191 43 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 191 44 digital digital JJ kim 191 45 collections collection NNS kim 191 46 in in IN kim 191 47 2019 2019 CD kim 191 48 . . . kim 192 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 192 2 footnoteRef:18 footnoteRef:18 NNP kim 192 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 192 4 Indiana Indiana NNP kim 192 5 University University NNP kim 192 6 Libraries Libraries NNPS kim 192 7 , , , kim 192 8 AVP AVP NNP kim 192 9 , , , kim 192 10 University University NNP kim 192 11 of of IN kim 192 12 Texas Texas NNP kim 192 13 Austin Austin NNP kim 192 14 School School NNP kim 192 15 of of IN kim 192 16 Information Information NNP kim 192 17 , , , kim 192 18 and and CC kim 192 19 the the DT kim 192 20 New New NNP kim 192 21 York York NNP kim 192 22 Public Public NNP kim 192 23 Library Library NNP kim 192 24 are be VBP kim 192 25 jointly jointly RB kim 192 26 developing develop VBG kim 192 27 the the DT kim 192 28 Audiovisual Audiovisual NNP kim 192 29 Metadata Metadata NNP kim 192 30 Platform Platform NNP kim 192 31 ( ( -LRB- kim 192 32 AMP AMP NNP kim 192 33 ) ) -RRB- kim 192 34 , , , kim 192 35 using use VBG kim 192 36 many many JJ kim 192 37 AI ai NN kim 192 38 tools tool NNS kim 192 39 in in IN kim 192 40 order order NN kim 192 41 to to TO kim 192 42 automatically automatically RB kim 192 43 generate generate VB kim 192 44 metadata metadata NN kim 192 45 for for IN kim 192 46 audiovisual audiovisual JJ kim 192 47 materials material NNS kim 192 48 , , , kim 192 49 which which WDT kim 192 50 collection collection NN kim 192 51 managers manager NNS kim 192 52 can can MD kim 192 53 use use VB kim 192 54 to to TO kim 192 55 supplement supplement VB kim 192 56 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 192 57 archival archival NN kim 192 58 description description NN kim 192 59 and and CC kim 192 60 processing processing NN kim 192 61 workflows workflow NNS kim 192 62 . . . kim 193 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 193 2 footnoteRef:19 footnoteref:19 NN kim 193 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 193 4 [ [ -LRB- kim 193 5 18 18 CD kim 193 6 : : : kim 193 7 See see VB kim 193 8 Blewer Blewer NNP kim 193 9 , , , kim 193 10 Kim Kim NNP kim 193 11 , , , kim 193 12 and and CC kim 193 13 Phetteplace Phetteplace NNP kim 193 14 2018 2018 CD kim 193 15 and and CC kim 193 16 Price Price NNP kim 193 17 2019 2019 CD kim 193 18 . . . kim 193 19 ] ] -RRB- kim 194 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 194 2 19 19 CD kim 194 3 : : : kim 194 4 The the DT kim 194 5 AMP AMP NNP kim 194 6 wiki wiki NN kim 194 7 is be VBZ kim 194 8 https://wiki.dlib.indiana.edu/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=531699941 https://wiki.dlib.indiana.edu/pages/viewpage.action?pageid=531699941 NN kim 194 9 . . . kim 195 1 The the DT kim 195 2 Audiovisual audiovisual JJ kim 195 3 Metadata metadata NN kim 195 4 Platform platform NN kim 195 5 Pilot pilot NN kim 195 6 Development Development NNP kim 195 7 ( ( -LRB- kim 195 8 AMPPD AMPPD NNP kim 195 9 ) ) -RRB- kim 195 10 project project NN kim 195 11 was be VBD kim 195 12 presented present VBN kim 195 13 at at IN kim 195 14 Code4Lib Code4Lib NNP kim 195 15 2020 2020 CD kim 195 16 ( ( -LRB- kim 195 17 Averkamp Averkamp NNP kim 195 18 and and CC kim 195 19 Hardesty Hardesty NNP kim 195 20 2020 2020 CD kim 195 21 ) ) -RRB- kim 195 22 . . . kim 195 23 ] ] -RRB- kim 196 1 Some some DT kim 196 2 libraries library NNS kim 196 3 are be VBP kim 196 4 also also RB kim 196 5 testing test VBG kim 196 6 out out RP kim 196 7 AI AI NNP kim 196 8 as as IN kim 196 9 a a DT kim 196 10 tool tool NN kim 196 11 for for IN kim 196 12 evaluating evaluate VBG kim 196 13 services service NNS kim 196 14 and and CC kim 196 15 operations operation NNS kim 196 16 . . . kim 197 1 The the DT kim 197 2 University University NNP kim 197 3 of of IN kim 197 4 Rochester Rochester NNP kim 197 5 Libraries Libraries NNP kim 197 6 applied apply VBD kim 197 7 deep deep JJ kim 197 8 learning learning NN kim 197 9 to to IN kim 197 10 the the DT kim 197 11 library library NN kim 197 12 ’s ’s POS kim 197 13 space space NN kim 197 14 assessment assessment NN kim 197 15 to to TO kim 197 16 determine determine VB kim 197 17 the the DT kim 197 18 optimal optimal JJ kim 197 19 staffing staffing NN kim 197 20 level level NN kim 197 21 and and CC kim 197 22 building building NN kim 197 23 hours hour NNS kim 197 24 . . . kim 198 1 The the DT kim 198 2 University University NNP kim 198 3 of of IN kim 198 4 Illinois Illinois NNP kim 198 5 Urbana Urbana NNP kim 198 6 - - HYPH kim 198 7 Champaign Champaign NNP kim 198 8 Libraries Libraries NNPS kim 198 9 used use VBD kim 198 10 machine machine NN kim 198 11 learning learn VBG kim 198 12 to to TO kim 198 13 conduct conduct VB kim 198 14 sentiment sentiment NN kim 198 15 analysis analysis NN kim 198 16 on on IN kim 198 17 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 198 18 reference reference NN kim 198 19 chat chat NN kim 198 20 log log NN kim 198 21 ( ( -LRB- kim 198 22 Blewer Blewer NNP kim 198 23 , , , kim 198 24 Kim Kim NNP kim 198 25 , , , kim 198 26 and and CC kim 198 27 Phetteplace Phetteplace NNP kim 198 28 2018 2018 CD kim 198 29 ) ) -RRB- kim 198 30 . . . kim 199 1 6 6 CD kim 199 2 . . . kim 200 1 Ethical ethical JJ kim 200 2 Challenges Challenges NNPS kim 200 3 from from IN kim 200 4 the the DT kim 200 5 Personalized Personalized NNP kim 200 6 and and CC kim 200 7 Automated Automated NNP kim 200 8 Information Information NNP kim 200 9 Environment Environment NNP kim 200 10 Do do VBP kim 200 11 these these DT kim 200 12 current current JJ kim 200 13 and and CC kim 200 14 future future JJ kim 200 15 AI AI NNP kim 200 16 applications application NNS kim 200 17 for for IN kim 200 18 libraries library NNS kim 200 19 pose pose VBP kim 200 20 ethical ethical JJ kim 200 21 challenges challenge NNS kim 200 22 similar similar JJ kim 200 23 to to IN kim 200 24 those those DT kim 200 25 that that WDT kim 200 26 we -PRON- PRP kim 200 27 discussed discuss VBD kim 200 28 earlier early RBR kim 200 29 ? ? . kim 201 1 Since since IN kim 201 2 information information NN kim 201 3 query query NN kim 201 4 , , , kim 201 5 discovery discovery NN kim 201 6 , , , kim 201 7 and and CC kim 201 8 retrieval retrieval NN kim 201 9 rarely rarely RB kim 201 10 involve involve VBP kim 201 11 life life NN kim 201 12 - - HYPH kim 201 13 or or CC kim 201 14 - - HYPH kim 201 15 death death NN kim 201 16 situations situation NNS kim 201 17 , , , kim 201 18 stakes stake NNS kim 201 19 seem seem VBP kim 201 20 to to TO kim 201 21 be be VB kim 201 22 certainly certainly RB kim 201 23 lower low JJR kim 201 24 . . . kim 202 1 But but CC kim 202 2 an an DT kim 202 3 AI ai NN kim 202 4 - - HYPH kim 202 5 driven drive VBN kim 202 6 automated automated JJ kim 202 7 information information NN kim 202 8 environment environment NN kim 202 9 does do VBZ kim 202 10 raise raise VB kim 202 11 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 202 12 own own JJ kim 202 13 distinct distinct JJ kim 202 14 ethical ethical JJ kim 202 15 challenges challenge NNS kim 202 16 . . . kim 203 1 ( ( -LRB- kim 203 2 i i NN kim 203 3 ) ) -RRB- kim 203 4 Intellectual intellectual JJ kim 203 5 isolation isolation NN kim 203 6 and and CC kim 203 7 bigotry bigotry NN kim 203 8 hampering hamper VBG kim 203 9 civic civic JJ kim 203 10 discourse discourse NN kim 203 11 Many many JJ kim 203 12 AI AI NNP kim 203 13 applications application NNS kim 203 14 that that WDT kim 203 15 assist assist VBP kim 203 16 with with IN kim 203 17 information information NN kim 203 18 seeking seek VBG kim 203 19 activities activity NNS kim 203 20 promise promise VBP kim 203 21 a a DT kim 203 22 higher high JJR kim 203 23 level level NN kim 203 24 of of IN kim 203 25 personalization personalization NN kim 203 26 . . . kim 204 1 But but CC kim 204 2 a a DT kim 204 3 highly highly RB kim 204 4 personalized personalized JJ kim 204 5 information information NN kim 204 6 environment environment NN kim 204 7 often often RB kim 204 8 traps trap VBZ kim 204 9 people people NNS kim 204 10 in in IN kim 204 11 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 204 12 own own JJ kim 204 13 so so RB kim 204 14 - - HYPH kim 204 15 called call VBN kim 204 16 ‘ ' `` kim 204 17 filter filter NN kim 204 18 bubble bubble NN kim 204 19 , , , kim 204 20 ’ ' '' kim 204 21 as as IN kim 204 22 we -PRON- PRP kim 204 23 have have VBP kim 204 24 been be VBN kim 204 25 increasingly increasingly RB kim 204 26 seeing see VBG kim 204 27 in in IN kim 204 28 today today NN kim 204 29 ’s ’s POS kim 204 30 social social JJ kim 204 31 media medium NNS kim 204 32 channels channel NNS kim 204 33 , , , kim 204 34 news news NN kim 204 35 websites website NNS kim 204 36 , , , kim 204 37 and and CC kim 204 38 commercial commercial JJ kim 204 39 search search NN kim 204 40 engines engine NNS kim 204 41 , , , kim 204 42 where where WRB kim 204 43 such such JJ kim 204 44 personalization personalization NN kim 204 45 is be VBZ kim 204 46 provided provide VBN kim 204 47 by by IN kim 204 48 machine machine NN kim 204 49 learning learning NN kim 204 50 and and CC kim 204 51 deep deep JJ kim 204 52 learning learning NN kim 204 53 . . . kim 205 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 205 2 footnoteRef:20 footnoteRef:20 NNP kim 205 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 205 4 Sophisticated Sophisticated NNP kim 205 5 AI AI NNP kim 205 6 algorithms algorithm NNS kim 205 7 are be VBP kim 205 8 already already RB kim 205 9 curating curate VBG kim 205 10 and and CC kim 205 11 pushing push VBG kim 205 12 information information NN kim 205 13 feeds feed VBZ kim 205 14 based base VBN kim 205 15 upon upon IN kim 205 16 the the DT kim 205 17 person person NN kim 205 18 ’s ’s POS kim 205 19 past past JJ kim 205 20 search search NN kim 205 21 and and CC kim 205 22 click click VB kim 205 23 behavior behavior NN kim 205 24 . . . kim 206 1 The the DT kim 206 2 result result NN kim 206 3 is be VBZ kim 206 4 that that IN kim 206 5 information information NN kim 206 6 seekers seeker NNS kim 206 7 are be VBP kim 206 8 provided provide VBN kim 206 9 with with IN kim 206 10 information information NN kim 206 11 that that WDT kim 206 12 conforms conform VBZ kim 206 13 and and CC kim 206 14 reinforces reinforce VBZ kim 206 15 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 206 16 existing exist VBG kim 206 17 beliefs belief NNS kim 206 18 and and CC kim 206 19 interests interest NNS kim 206 20 . . . kim 207 1 Views view NNS kim 207 2 that that WDT kim 207 3 are be VBP kim 207 4 novel novel JJ kim 207 5 or or CC kim 207 6 contrast contrast NN kim 207 7 with with IN kim 207 8 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 207 9 existing exist VBG kim 207 10 beliefs belief NNS kim 207 11 are be VBP kim 207 12 increasingly increasingly RB kim 207 13 suppressed suppress VBN kim 207 14 and and CC kim 207 15 become become VBN kim 207 16 invisible invisible JJ kim 207 17 without without IN kim 207 18 them -PRON- PRP kim 207 19 even even RB kim 207 20 realizing realize VBG kim 207 21 . . . kim 208 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 208 2 20 20 CD kim 208 3 : : : kim 208 4 See see VB kim 208 5 Pariser Pariser NNP kim 208 6 2012 2012 CD kim 208 7 . . . kim 208 8 ] ] -RRB- kim 209 1 Such such JJ kim 209 2 lack lack NN kim 209 3 of of IN kim 209 4 exposure exposure NN kim 209 5 to to IN kim 209 6 opposing oppose VBG kim 209 7 views view NNS kim 209 8 leads lead VBZ kim 209 9 information information NN kim 209 10 users user NNS kim 209 11 to to IN kim 209 12 intellectual intellectual JJ kim 209 13 isolation isolation NN kim 209 14 and and CC kim 209 15 even even RB kim 209 16 bigotry bigotry NN kim 209 17 . . . kim 210 1 Highly highly RB kim 210 2 personalized personalized JJ kim 210 3 information information NN kim 210 4 environments environment NNS kim 210 5 powered power VBN kim 210 6 by by IN kim 210 7 AI AI NNP kim 210 8 can can MD kim 210 9 actively actively RB kim 210 10 restrict restrict VB kim 210 11 ways way NNS kim 210 12 in in IN kim 210 13 which which WDT kim 210 14 people people NNS kim 210 15 develop develop VBP kim 210 16 balanced balanced JJ kim 210 17 and and CC kim 210 18 informed informed JJ kim 210 19 opinions opinion NNS kim 210 20 , , , kim 210 21 thereby thereby RB kim 210 22 intensifying intensify VBG kim 210 23 and and CC kim 210 24 perpetuating perpetuate VBG kim 210 25 social social JJ kim 210 26 discord discord NN kim 210 27 and and CC kim 210 28 disrupting disrupt VBG kim 210 29 civic civic JJ kim 210 30 discourse discourse NN kim 210 31 . . . kim 211 1 Such such JJ kim 211 2 social social JJ kim 211 3 discord discord NN kim 211 4 and and CC kim 211 5 disruption disruption NN kim 211 6 in in IN kim 211 7 civil civil JJ kim 211 8 discourse discourse NN kim 211 9 is be VBZ kim 211 10 likely likely JJ kim 211 11 to to TO kim 211 12 disproportionately disproportionately RB kim 211 13 affect affect VB kim 211 14 those those DT kim 211 15 with with IN kim 211 16 least least JJS kim 211 17 privileges privilege NNS kim 211 18 . . . kim 212 1 In in IN kim 212 2 this this DT kim 212 3 sense sense NN kim 212 4 , , , kim 212 5 intellectual intellectual JJ kim 212 6 isolation isolation NN kim 212 7 and and CC kim 212 8 bigotry bigotry NN kim 212 9 has have VBZ kim 212 10 a a DT kim 212 11 distinctly distinctly RB kim 212 12 moral moral JJ kim 212 13 impact impact NN kim 212 14 on on IN kim 212 15 society society NN kim 212 16 . . . kim 213 1 ( ( -LRB- kim 213 2 ii ii NNP kim 213 3 ) ) -RRB- kim 213 4 Weakening Weakening NNP kim 213 5 of of IN kim 213 6 cognitive cognitive JJ kim 213 7 agency agency NN kim 213 8 and and CC kim 213 9 autonomy autonomy NN kim 213 10 We -PRON- PRP kim 213 11 have have VBP kim 213 12 seen see VBN kim 213 13 earlier early RBR kim 213 14 that that IN kim 213 15 AI AI NNP kim 213 16 - - HYPH kim 213 17 powered power VBN kim 213 18 digital digital JJ kim 213 19 assistants assistant NNS kim 213 20 are be VBP kim 213 21 likely likely JJ kim 213 22 to to TO kim 213 23 mediate mediate VB kim 213 24 people people NNS kim 213 25 ’s ’s POS kim 213 26 information information NN kim 213 27 search search NN kim 213 28 , , , kim 213 29 discovery discovery NN kim 213 30 , , , kim 213 31 and and CC kim 213 32 retrieval retrieval NN kim 213 33 activities activity NNS kim 213 34 in in IN kim 213 35 the the DT kim 213 36 near near JJ kim 213 37 future future NN kim 213 38 . . . kim 214 1 As as IN kim 214 2 those those DT kim 214 3 digital digital JJ kim 214 4 assistants assistant NNS kim 214 5 become become VBP kim 214 6 more more RBR kim 214 7 capable capable JJ kim 214 8 , , , kim 214 9 they -PRON- PRP kim 214 10 will will MD kim 214 11 go go VB kim 214 12 beyond beyond IN kim 214 13 listing list VBG kim 214 14 available available JJ kim 214 15 information information NN kim 214 16 . . . kim 215 1 They -PRON- PRP kim 215 2 will will MD kim 215 3 further further RB kim 215 4 choose choose VB kim 215 5 what what WP kim 215 6 they -PRON- PRP kim 215 7 deem deem VBP kim 215 8 to to TO kim 215 9 be be VB kim 215 10 most most RBS kim 215 11 relevant relevant JJ kim 215 12 to to IN kim 215 13 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 215 14 users user NNS kim 215 15 and and CC kim 215 16 proceed proceed VB kim 215 17 to to TO kim 215 18 recommend recommend VB kim 215 19 or or CC kim 215 20 autonomously autonomously RB kim 215 21 execute execute VB kim 215 22 the the DT kim 215 23 best good JJS kim 215 24 course course NN kim 215 25 of of IN kim 215 26 action action NN kim 215 27 . . . kim 216 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 216 2 footnoteRef:21 footnoteRef:21 NNP kim 216 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 216 4 Other other JJ kim 216 5 AI ai NN kim 216 6 - - HYPH kim 216 7 driven drive VBN kim 216 8 features feature NNS kim 216 9 , , , kim 216 10 such such JJ kim 216 11 as as IN kim 216 12 extracting extract VBG kim 216 13 key key JJ kim 216 14 information information NN kim 216 15 or or CC kim 216 16 generating generate VBG kim 216 17 a a DT kim 216 18 summary summary NN kim 216 19 of of IN kim 216 20 a a DT kim 216 21 large large JJ kim 216 22 amount amount NN kim 216 23 of of IN kim 216 24 information information NN kim 216 25 , , , kim 216 26 are be VBP kim 216 27 also also RB kim 216 28 likely likely JJ kim 216 29 to to TO kim 216 30 be be VB kim 216 31 included include VBN kim 216 32 in in IN kim 216 33 future future JJ kim 216 34 information information NN kim 216 35 systems system NNS kim 216 36 , , , kim 216 37 and and CC kim 216 38 they -PRON- PRP kim 216 39 may may MD kim 216 40 deliver deliver VB kim 216 41 key key JJ kim 216 42 information information NN kim 216 43 or or CC kim 216 44 summaries summary NNS kim 216 45 even even RB kim 216 46 before before IN kim 216 47 the the DT kim 216 48 request request NN kim 216 49 is be VBZ kim 216 50 made make VBN kim 216 51 , , , kim 216 52 based base VBN kim 216 53 upon upon IN kim 216 54 constant constant JJ kim 216 55 monitoring monitoring NN kim 216 56 of of IN kim 216 57 the the DT kim 216 58 user user NN kim 216 59 ’s ’s POS kim 216 60 activities activity NNS kim 216 61 . . . kim 217 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 217 2 21 21 CD kim 217 3 : : : kim 217 4 Please please UH kim 217 5 note note VB kim 217 6 that that IN kim 217 7 this this DT kim 217 8 is be VBZ kim 217 9 a a DT kim 217 10 simplified simplified JJ kim 217 11 scenario scenario NN kim 217 12 . . . kim 218 1 The the DT kim 218 2 features feature NNS kim 218 3 can can MD kim 218 4 also also RB kim 218 5 be be VB kim 218 6 built build VBN kim 218 7 in in IN kim 218 8 the the DT kim 218 9 information information NN kim 218 10 system system NN kim 218 11 itself -PRON- PRP kim 218 12 rather rather RB kim 218 13 than than IN kim 218 14 the the DT kim 218 15 agent agent NN kim 218 16 . . . kim 218 17 ] ] -RRB- kim 219 1 In in IN kim 219 2 such such PDT kim 219 3 a a DT kim 219 4 scenario scenario NN kim 219 5 , , , kim 219 6 an an DT kim 219 7 information information NN kim 219 8 seeker seeker NN kim 219 9 ’s ’s POS kim 219 10 cognitive cognitive JJ kim 219 11 agency agency NN kim 219 12 is be VBZ kim 219 13 likely likely JJ kim 219 14 to to TO kim 219 15 suffer suffer VB kim 219 16 a a DT kim 219 17 loss loss NN kim 219 18 . . . kim 220 1 Crucial crucial JJ kim 220 2 to to IN kim 220 3 cognitive cognitive JJ kim 220 4 agency agency NN kim 220 5 is be VBZ kim 220 6 the the DT kim 220 7 mental mental JJ kim 220 8 capacity capacity NN kim 220 9 to to TO kim 220 10 critically critically RB kim 220 11 review review VB kim 220 12 a a DT kim 220 13 variety variety NN kim 220 14 of of IN kim 220 15 information information NN kim 220 16 , , , kim 220 17 judge judge VBP kim 220 18 what what WP kim 220 19 is be VBZ kim 220 20 and and CC kim 220 21 is be VBZ kim 220 22 not not RB kim 220 23 relevant relevant JJ kim 220 24 , , , kim 220 25 and and CC kim 220 26 interpret interpret VB kim 220 27 how how WRB kim 220 28 they -PRON- PRP kim 220 29 relate relate VBP kim 220 30 to to IN kim 220 31 other other JJ kim 220 32 existing exist VBG kim 220 33 beliefs belief NNS kim 220 34 and and CC kim 220 35 opinions opinion NNS kim 220 36 . . . kim 221 1 If if IN kim 221 2 AI AI NNP kim 221 3 assumes assume VBZ kim 221 4 those those DT kim 221 5 tasks task NNS kim 221 6 , , , kim 221 7 the the DT kim 221 8 opportunities opportunity NNS kim 221 9 for for IN kim 221 10 information information NN kim 221 11 seekers seeker NNS kim 221 12 to to TO kim 221 13 exercise exercise VB kim 221 14 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 221 15 own own JJ kim 221 16 cognitive cognitive JJ kim 221 17 agency agency NN kim 221 18 will will MD kim 221 19 surely surely RB kim 221 20 decrease decrease VB kim 221 21 . . . kim 222 1 Cognitive cognitive JJ kim 222 2 deskilling deskilling NN kim 222 3 and and CC kim 222 4 the the DT kim 222 5 subsequent subsequent JJ kim 222 6 weakening weakening NN kim 222 7 of of IN kim 222 8 people people NNS kim 222 9 ’s ’s POS kim 222 10 agency agency NN kim 222 11 in in IN kim 222 12 the the DT kim 222 13 AI AI NNP kim 222 14 -powered -powere VBN kim 222 15 automated automate VBN kim 222 16 information information NN kim 222 17 environment environment NN kim 222 18 presents present VBZ kim 222 19 an an DT kim 222 20 ethical ethical JJ kim 222 21 challenge challenge NN kim 222 22 because because IN kim 222 23 such such JJ kim 222 24 agency agency NN kim 222 25 is be VBZ kim 222 26 necessary necessary JJ kim 222 27 for for IN kim 222 28 a a DT kim 222 29 person person NN kim 222 30 to to TO kim 222 31 be be VB kim 222 32 a a DT kim 222 33 fully fully RB kim 222 34 functioning function VBG kim 222 35 moral moral JJ kim 222 36 agent agent NN kim 222 37 in in IN kim 222 38 society society NN kim 222 39 . . . kim 223 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 223 2 footnoteRef:22 footnoteref:22 NN kim 223 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 223 4 [ [ -LRB- kim 223 5 22 22 CD kim 223 6 : : : kim 223 7 Outside outside IN kim 223 8 of of IN kim 223 9 the the DT kim 223 10 automated automated JJ kim 223 11 information information NN kim 223 12 environment environment NN kim 223 13 , , , kim 223 14 AI AI NNP kim 223 15 has have VBZ kim 223 16 a a DT kim 223 17 strong strong JJ kim 223 18 potential potential NN kim 223 19 to to TO kim 223 20 engender engender VB kim 223 21 moral moral JJ kim 223 22 deskilling deskilling NN kim 223 23 . . . kim 224 1 Vallor Vallor NNP kim 224 2 ( ( -LRB- kim 224 3 2015 2015 CD kim 224 4 ) ) -RRB- kim 224 5 points point VBZ kim 224 6 out out RP kim 224 7 that that IN kim 224 8 automated automate VBN kim 224 9 weapons weapon NNS kim 224 10 will will MD kim 224 11 lead lead VB kim 224 12 to to IN kim 224 13 soldiers soldier NNS kim 224 14 ’ ’ POS kim 224 15 moral moral JJ kim 224 16 deskilling deskilling NN kim 224 17 in in IN kim 224 18 the the DT kim 224 19 use use NN kim 224 20 of of IN kim 224 21 military military JJ kim 224 22 force force NN kim 224 23 ; ; : kim 224 24 new new JJ kim 224 25 media medium NNS kim 224 26 practices practice NNS kim 224 27 of of IN kim 224 28 multitasking multitasking NN kim 224 29 may may MD kim 224 30 result result VB kim 224 31 in in IN kim 224 32 deskilling deskille VBG kim 224 33 in in IN kim 224 34 moral moral JJ kim 224 35 attention attention NN kim 224 36 ; ; : kim 224 37 and and CC kim 224 38 social social JJ kim 224 39 robots robot NNS kim 224 40 can can MD kim 224 41 cause cause VB kim 224 42 moral moral JJ kim 224 43 deskilling deskilling NN kim 224 44 in in IN kim 224 45 practices practice NNS kim 224 46 of of IN kim 224 47 human human JJ kim 224 48 caregiving caregiving NN kim 224 49 . . . kim 224 50 ] ] -RRB- kim 225 1 ( ( -LRB- kim 225 2 iii iii NNP kim 225 3 ) ) -RRB- kim 225 4 Social social JJ kim 225 5 impact impact NN kim 225 6 of of IN kim 225 7 scholarship scholarship NN kim 225 8 and and CC kim 225 9 research research NN kim 225 10 from from IN kim 225 11 flawed flawed JJ kim 225 12 AI AI NNP kim 225 13 algorithms algorithm NNS kim 225 14 Previously previously RB kim 225 15 , , , kim 225 16 we -PRON- PRP kim 225 17 have have VBP kim 225 18 seen see VBN kim 225 19 that that IN kim 225 20 deep deep JJ kim 225 21 learning learning NN kim 225 22 applications application NNS kim 225 23 are be VBP kim 225 24 opaque opaque JJ kim 225 25 to to IN kim 225 26 human human JJ kim 225 27 understanding understanding NN kim 225 28 . . . kim 226 1 This this DT kim 226 2 lack lack NN kim 226 3 of of IN kim 226 4 transparency transparency NN kim 226 5 and and CC kim 226 6 explainability explainability NN kim 226 7 raises raise VBZ kim 226 8 the the DT kim 226 9 question question NN kim 226 10 of of IN kim 226 11 whether whether IN kim 226 12 it -PRON- PRP kim 226 13 is be VBZ kim 226 14 moral moral JJ kim 226 15 to to TO kim 226 16 rely rely VB kim 226 17 on on IN kim 226 18 AI AI NNP kim 226 19 - - HYPH kim 226 20 powered power VBN kim 226 21 military military JJ kim 226 22 robots robot NNS kim 226 23 for for IN kim 226 24 life life NN kim 226 25 - - HYPH kim 226 26 or or CC kim 226 27 - - HYPH kim 226 28 death death NN kim 226 29 decisions decision NNS kim 226 30 . . . kim 227 1 Does do VBZ kim 227 2 the the DT kim 227 3 AI ai NN kim 227 4 - - HYPH kim 227 5 powered power VBN kim 227 6 information information NN kim 227 7 environment environment NN kim 227 8 have have VBP kim 227 9 a a DT kim 227 10 similar similar JJ kim 227 11 problem problem NN kim 227 12 ? ? . kim 228 1 As as IN kim 228 2 explained explain VBN kim 228 3 in in IN kim 228 4 the the DT kim 228 5 beginning beginning NN kim 228 6 of of IN kim 228 7 this this DT kim 228 8 chapter chapter NN kim 228 9 , , , kim 228 10 machine machine NN kim 228 11 learning learning NN kim 228 12 applications application NNS kim 228 13 base base VBP kim 228 14 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 228 15 recommendations recommendation NNS kim 228 16 and and CC kim 228 17 predictions prediction NNS kim 228 18 upon upon IN kim 228 19 the the DT kim 228 20 patterns pattern NNS kim 228 21 in in IN kim 228 22 past past JJ kim 228 23 data datum NNS kim 228 24 . . . kim 229 1 Their -PRON- PRP$ kim 229 2 predictions prediction NNS kim 229 3 and and CC kim 229 4 recommendations recommendation NNS kim 229 5 are be VBP kim 229 6 in in IN kim 229 7 this this DT kim 229 8 sense sense NN kim 229 9 inherently inherently RB kim 229 10 conservative conservative JJ kim 229 11 and and CC kim 229 12 become become VBP kim 229 13 outdated outdated JJ kim 229 14 when when WRB kim 229 15 they -PRON- PRP kim 229 16 fail fail VBP kim 229 17 to to TO kim 229 18 reflect reflect VB kim 229 19 the the DT kim 229 20 new new JJ kim 229 21 social social JJ kim 229 22 views view NNS kim 229 23 and and CC kim 229 24 material material NN kim 229 25 conditions condition NNS kim 229 26 that that WDT kim 229 27 no no RB kim 229 28 longer long RBR kim 229 29 fit fit VBP kim 229 30 the the DT kim 229 31 past past JJ kim 229 32 patterns pattern NNS kim 229 33 . . . kim 230 1 Furthermore furthermore RB kim 230 2 , , , kim 230 3 each each DT kim 230 4 data data NN kim 230 5 set set NN kim 230 6 is be VBZ kim 230 7 a a DT kim 230 8 social social JJ kim 230 9 construct construct NN kim 230 10 that that WDT kim 230 11 reflects reflect VBZ kim 230 12 particular particular JJ kim 230 13 values value NNS kim 230 14 and and CC kim 230 15 choices choice NNS kim 230 16 such such JJ kim 230 17 as as IN kim 230 18 who who WP kim 230 19 decided decide VBD kim 230 20 to to TO kim 230 21 collect collect VB kim 230 22 the the DT kim 230 23 data datum NNS kim 230 24 and and CC kim 230 25 for for IN kim 230 26 what what WDT kim 230 27 purpose purpose NN kim 230 28 ; ; : kim 230 29 who who WP kim 230 30 labeled label VBD kim 230 31 data datum NNS kim 230 32 ; ; : kim 230 33 what what WDT kim 230 34 criteria criterion NNS kim 230 35 or or CC kim 230 36 beliefs belief NNS kim 230 37 guided guide VBD kim 230 38 such such JJ kim 230 39 labeling labeling NN kim 230 40 ; ; : kim 230 41 what what WP kim 230 42 taxonomies taxonomy NNS kim 230 43 were be VBD kim 230 44 used use VBN kim 230 45 and and CC kim 230 46 why why WRB kim 230 47 ( ( -LRB- kim 230 48 Davis Davis NNP kim 230 49 2020 2020 CD kim 230 50 ) ) -RRB- kim 230 51 . . . kim 231 1 No no DT kim 231 2 data data NN kim 231 3 set set NN kim 231 4 can can MD kim 231 5 capture capture VB kim 231 6 all all PDT kim 231 7 the the DT kim 231 8 variables variable NNS kim 231 9 and and CC kim 231 10 elements element NNS kim 231 11 of of IN kim 231 12 the the DT kim 231 13 phenomenon phenomenon NN kim 231 14 that that WDT kim 231 15 it -PRON- PRP kim 231 16 describes describe VBZ kim 231 17 . . . kim 232 1 Furthermore furthermore RB kim 232 2 , , , kim 232 3 data data NN kim 232 4 sets set NNS kim 232 5 used use VBN kim 232 6 for for IN kim 232 7 training train VBG kim 232 8 machine machine NN kim 232 9 learning learning NN kim 232 10 and and CC kim 232 11 deep deep JJ kim 232 12 learning learning NN kim 232 13 algorithms algorithm NNS kim 232 14 may may MD kim 232 15 not not RB kim 232 16 be be VB kim 232 17 representational representational JJ kim 232 18 samples sample NNS kim 232 19 for for IN kim 232 20 all all DT kim 232 21 relevant relevant JJ kim 232 22 subgroups subgroup NNS kim 232 23 . . . kim 233 1 In in IN kim 233 2 such such PDT kim 233 3 a a DT kim 233 4 case case NN kim 233 5 , , , kim 233 6 an an DT kim 233 7 algorithm algorithm NN kim 233 8 will will MD kim 233 9 not not RB kim 233 10 be be VB kim 233 11 able able JJ kim 233 12 to to TO kim 233 13 perform perform VB kim 233 14 equally equally RB kim 233 15 well well RB kim 233 16 in in IN kim 233 17 all all DT kim 233 18 subgroups subgroup NNS kim 233 19 . . . kim 234 1 Creating create VBG kim 234 2 a a DT kim 234 3 large large JJ kim 234 4 data data NN kim 234 5 set set NN kim 234 6 is be VBZ kim 234 7 also also RB kim 234 8 costly costly JJ kim 234 9 . . . kim 235 1 Consequently consequently RB kim 235 2 , , , kim 235 3 developers developer NNS kim 235 4 often often RB kim 235 5 simply simply RB kim 235 6 take take VBP kim 235 7 data data NN kim 235 8 sets set NNS kim 235 9 that that WDT kim 235 10 are be VBP kim 235 11 available available JJ kim 235 12 to to IN kim 235 13 them -PRON- PRP kim 235 14 . . . kim 236 1 Those those DT kim 236 2 data data NN kim 236 3 sets set NNS kim 236 4 are be VBP kim 236 5 likely likely JJ kim 236 6 to to TO kim 236 7 come come VB kim 236 8 with with IN kim 236 9 inherent inherent JJ kim 236 10 limitations limitation NNS kim 236 11 such such JJ kim 236 12 as as IN kim 236 13 omissions omission NNS kim 236 14 , , , kim 236 15 inaccuracies inaccuracy NNS kim 236 16 , , , kim 236 17 errors error NNS kim 236 18 , , , kim 236 19 and and CC kim 236 20 hidden hide VBN kim 236 21 biases bias NNS kim 236 22 . . . kim 237 1 AI AI NNP kim 237 2 algorithms algorithm NNS kim 237 3 trained train VBD kim 237 4 with with IN kim 237 5 these these DT kim 237 6 flawed flawed JJ kim 237 7 data data NN kim 237 8 sets set NNS kim 237 9 can can MD kim 237 10 fail fail VB kim 237 11 unexpectedly unexpectedly RB kim 237 12 , , , kim 237 13 revealing reveal VBG kim 237 14 those those DT kim 237 15 limitations limitation NNS kim 237 16 in in IN kim 237 17 the the DT kim 237 18 data data NN kim 237 19 sets set NNS kim 237 20 . . . kim 238 1 For for IN kim 238 2 example example NN kim 238 3 , , , kim 238 4 it -PRON- PRP kim 238 5 has have VBZ kim 238 6 been be VBN kim 238 7 reported report VBN kim 238 8 that that IN kim 238 9 the the DT kim 238 10 success success NN kim 238 11 rate rate NN kim 238 12 of of IN kim 238 13 a a DT kim 238 14 facial facial JJ kim 238 15 recognition recognition NN kim 238 16 algorithm algorithm NN kim 238 17 plunges plunge NNS kim 238 18 from from IN kim 238 19 99 99 CD kim 238 20 % % NN kim 238 21 to to TO kim 238 22 35 35 CD kim 238 23 % % NN kim 238 24 when when WRB kim 238 25 the the DT kim 238 26 group group NN kim 238 27 of of IN kim 238 28 subjects subject NNS kim 238 29 changes change NNS kim 238 30 from from IN kim 238 31 white white JJ kim 238 32 men man NNS kim 238 33 to to IN kim 238 34 dark dark JJ kim 238 35 - - HYPH kim 238 36 skinned skinned JJ kim 238 37 women woman NNS kim 238 38 because because IN kim 238 39 it -PRON- PRP kim 238 40 was be VBD kim 238 41 trained train VBN kim 238 42 mostly mostly RB kim 238 43 with with IN kim 238 44 the the DT kim 238 45 photographs photograph NNS kim 238 46 of of IN kim 238 47 white white JJ kim 238 48 men man NNS kim 238 49 ( ( -LRB- kim 238 50 Lohr Lohr NNP kim 238 51 2018 2018 CD kim 238 52 ) ) -RRB- kim 238 53 . . . kim 239 1 Adopting adopt VBG kim 239 2 such such PDT kim 239 3 a a DT kim 239 4 faulty faulty JJ kim 239 5 algorithm algorithm NN kim 239 6 for for IN kim 239 7 any any DT kim 239 8 real real JJ kim 239 9 - - HYPH kim 239 10 life life NN kim 239 11 use use NN kim 239 12 at at IN kim 239 13 a a DT kim 239 14 large large JJ kim 239 15 scale scale NN kim 239 16 would would MD kim 239 17 be be VB kim 239 18 entirely entirely RB kim 239 19 unethical unethical JJ kim 239 20 . . . kim 240 1 For for IN kim 240 2 the the DT kim 240 3 context context NN kim 240 4 of of IN kim 240 5 libraries library NNS kim 240 6 , , , kim 240 7 imagine imagine VB kim 240 8 using use VBG kim 240 9 such such PDT kim 240 10 a a DT kim 240 11 face face NN kim 240 12 - - HYPH kim 240 13 recognition recognition NN kim 240 14 algorithm algorithm NN kim 240 15 to to TO kim 240 16 generate generate VB kim 240 17 metadata metadata NN kim 240 18 for for IN kim 240 19 digitized digitized JJ kim 240 20 historical historical JJ kim 240 21 photographs photograph NNS kim 240 22 , , , kim 240 23 or or CC kim 240 24 a a DT kim 240 25 similarly similarly RB kim 240 26 flawed flawed JJ kim 240 27 audio audio JJ kim 240 28 transcription transcription NN kim 240 29 algorithm algorithm NNP kim 240 30 to to TO kim 240 31 transcribe transcribe VB kim 240 32 archival archival NNP kim 240 33 audio audio NNP kim 240 34 recordings recording NNS kim 240 35 . . . kim 241 1 Just just RB kim 241 2 like like IN kim 241 3 those those DT kim 241 4 faulty faulty JJ kim 241 5 algorithms algorithm NNS kim 241 6 , , , kim 241 7 an an DT kim 241 8 AI AI NNP kim 241 9 - - HYPH kim 241 10 powered power VBN kim 241 11 automated automated JJ kim 241 12 information information NN kim 241 13 environment environment NN kim 241 14 can can MD kim 241 15 provide provide VB kim 241 16 information information NN kim 241 17 , , , kim 241 18 recommendations recommendation NNS kim 241 19 , , , kim 241 20 and and CC kim 241 21 predictions prediction NNS kim 241 22 affected affect VBN kim 241 23 by by IN kim 241 24 similar similar JJ kim 241 25 limitations limitation NNS kim 241 26 existing exist VBG kim 241 27 in in IN kim 241 28 many many JJ kim 241 29 data datum NNS kim 241 30 sets set NNS kim 241 31 . . . kim 242 1 The the DT kim 242 2 more more RBR kim 242 3 seamless seamless NN kim 242 4 such such PDT kim 242 5 an an DT kim 242 6 information information NN kim 242 7 environment environment NN kim 242 8 is be VBZ kim 242 9 , , , kim 242 10 the the DT kim 242 11 more more RBR kim 242 12 invisible invisible JJ kim 242 13 those those DT kim 242 14 limitations limitation NNS kim 242 15 become become VBP kim 242 16 . . . kim 243 1 Automated automate VBN kim 243 2 information information NN kim 243 3 systems system NNS kim 243 4 from from IN kim 243 5 libraries library NNS kim 243 6 may may MD kim 243 7 not not RB kim 243 8 be be VB kim 243 9 involved involve VBN kim 243 10 in in IN kim 243 11 decisions decision NNS kim 243 12 that that WDT kim 243 13 have have VBP kim 243 14 a a DT kim 243 15 direct direct JJ kim 243 16 and and CC kim 243 17 immediate immediate JJ kim 243 18 impact impact NN kim 243 19 on on IN kim 243 20 people people NNS kim 243 21 ’s ’s POS kim 243 22 lives life NNS kim 243 23 , , , kim 243 24 such such JJ kim 243 25 as as IN kim 243 26 setting set VBG kim 243 27 a a DT kim 243 28 bail bail NN kim 243 29 amount amount NN kim 243 30 or or CC kim 243 31 determining determine VBG kim 243 32 the the DT kim 243 33 Medicaid Medicaid NNP kim 243 34 payment payment NN kim 243 35 to to TO kim 243 36 be be VB kim 243 37 paid,[footnoteRef:23 paid,[footnoteref:23 CD kim 243 38 ] ] -RRB- kim 243 39 but but CC kim 243 40 automated automate VBD kim 243 41 information information NN kim 243 42 systems system NNS kim 243 43 that that WDT kim 243 44 are be VBP kim 243 45 widely widely RB kim 243 46 adopted adopt VBN kim 243 47 and and CC kim 243 48 used use VBN kim 243 49 for for IN kim 243 50 research research NN kim 243 51 and and CC kim 243 52 scholarship scholarship NN kim 243 53 will will MD kim 243 54 impact impact VB kim 243 55 real real JJ kim 243 56 - - HYPH kim 243 57 life life NN kim 243 58 policies policy NNS kim 243 59 and and CC kim 243 60 regulations regulation NNS kim 243 61 in in IN kim 243 62 areas area NNS kim 243 63 such such JJ kim 243 64 as as IN kim 243 65 healthcare healthcare NN kim 243 66 and and CC kim 243 67 the the DT kim 243 68 economy economy NN kim 243 69 . . . kim 244 1 Undiscovered undiscovered JJ kim 244 2 flaws flaw NNS kim 244 3 will will MD kim 244 4 undermine undermine VB kim 244 5 the the DT kim 244 6 validity validity NN kim 244 7 of of IN kim 244 8 the the DT kim 244 9 scholarly scholarly JJ kim 244 10 output output NN kim 244 11 that that WDT kim 244 12 utilized utilize VBD kim 244 13 those those DT kim 244 14 automated automate VBN kim 244 15 information information NN kim 244 16 systems system NNS kim 244 17 and and CC kim 244 18 can can MD kim 244 19 further far RBR kim 244 20 inflict inflict VB kim 244 21 serious serious JJ kim 244 22 harm harm NN kim 244 23 on on IN kim 244 24 certain certain JJ kim 244 25 groups group NNS kim 244 26 of of IN kim 244 27 people people NNS kim 244 28 through through IN kim 244 29 those those DT kim 244 30 policies policy NNS kim 244 31 and and CC kim 244 32 regulations regulation NNS kim 244 33 . . . kim 245 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 245 2 23 23 CD kim 245 3 : : : kim 245 4 See see VB kim 245 5 Tashea Tashea NNP kim 245 6 2017 2017 CD kim 245 7 and and CC kim 245 8 Stanley Stanley NNP kim 245 9 2017 2017 CD kim 245 10 . . . kim 245 11 ] ] -RRB- kim 246 1 7 7 LS kim 246 2 . . . kim 247 1 Moral Moral NNP kim 247 2 Intelligence Intelligence NNP kim 247 3 and and CC kim 247 4 Rethinking rethink VBG kim 247 5 the the DT kim 247 6 Role Role NNP kim 247 7 of of IN kim 247 8 AI AI NNP kim 247 9 In in IN kim 247 10 this this DT kim 247 11 chapter chapter NN kim 247 12 , , , kim 247 13 I -PRON- PRP kim 247 14 discussed discuss VBD kim 247 15 four four CD kim 247 16 significant significant JJ kim 247 17 ethical ethical JJ kim 247 18 challenges challenge NNS kim 247 19 that that IN kim 247 20 automating automate VBG kim 247 21 decisions decision NNS kim 247 22 and and CC kim 247 23 actions action NNS kim 247 24 with with IN kim 247 25 AI AI NNP kim 247 26 presents present NNS kim 247 27 : : : kim 247 28 ( ( -LRB- kim 247 29 a a DT kim 247 30 ) ) -RRB- kim 247 31 moral moral JJ kim 247 32 desensitization desensitization NN kim 247 33 ; ; , kim 247 34 ( ( -LRB- kim 247 35 b b NN kim 247 36 ) ) -RRB- kim 247 37 unintended unintended JJ kim 247 38 outcomes outcome NNS kim 247 39 ; ; , kim 247 40 ( ( -LRB- kim 247 41 c c NN kim 247 42 ) ) -RRB- kim 247 43 surrender surrender NN kim 247 44 of of IN kim 247 45 moral moral JJ kim 247 46 agency agency NN kim 247 47 ; ; : kim 247 48 ( ( -LRB- kim 247 49 d d NN kim 247 50 ) ) -RRB- kim 247 51 opacity opacity NN kim 247 52 in in IN kim 247 53 decision decision NN kim 247 54 - - HYPH kim 247 55 making making NN kim 247 56 . . . kim 248 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 248 2 footnoteRef:24 footnoteRef:24 NNP kim 248 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 248 4 I -PRON- PRP kim 248 5 also also RB kim 248 6 examined examine VBD kim 248 7 somewhat somewhat RB kim 248 8 different different JJ kim 248 9 but but CC kim 248 10 equally equally RB kim 248 11 significant significant JJ kim 248 12 ethical ethical JJ kim 248 13 challenges challenge NNS kim 248 14 in in IN kim 248 15 relation relation NN kim 248 16 to to IN kim 248 17 the the DT kim 248 18 AI AI NNP kim 248 19 - - HYPH kim 248 20 powered power VBN kim 248 21 automated automated JJ kim 248 22 information information NN kim 248 23 environment environment NN kim 248 24 , , , kim 248 25 which which WDT kim 248 26 is be VBZ kim 248 27 likely likely JJ kim 248 28 to to TO kim 248 29 surround surround VB kim 248 30 us -PRON- PRP kim 248 31 in in IN kim 248 32 the the DT kim 248 33 future future NN kim 248 34 : : : kim 248 35 ( ( -LRB- kim 248 36 i i NN kim 248 37 ) ) -RRB- kim 248 38 intellectual intellectual JJ kim 248 39 isolation isolation NN kim 248 40 and and CC kim 248 41 bigotry bigotry NN kim 248 42 hampering hamper VBG kim 248 43 civic civic JJ kim 248 44 discourse discourse NN kim 248 45 ; ; : kim 248 46 ( ( -LRB- kim 248 47 ii ii NN kim 248 48 ) ) -RRB- kim 248 49 weakening weaken VBG kim 248 50 of of IN kim 248 51 cognitive cognitive JJ kim 248 52 agency agency NN kim 248 53 and and CC kim 248 54 autonomy autonomy NN kim 248 55 ; ; , kim 248 56 ( ( -LRB- kim 248 57 iii iii NNP kim 248 58 ) ) -RRB- kim 248 59 social social JJ kim 248 60 impact impact NN kim 248 61 of of IN kim 248 62 scholarship scholarship NN kim 248 63 and and CC kim 248 64 research research NN kim 248 65 based base VBN kim 248 66 upon upon IN kim 248 67 flawed flawed JJ kim 248 68 AI AI NNP kim 248 69 algorithms algorithm NNS kim 248 70 . . . kim 249 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 249 2 24 24 CD kim 249 3 : : : kim 249 4 This this DT kim 249 5 is be VBZ kim 249 6 by by IN kim 249 7 no no DT kim 249 8 means means NN kim 249 9 an an DT kim 249 10 exhaustive exhaustive JJ kim 249 11 list list NN kim 249 12 . . . kim 250 1 User user NN kim 250 2 privacy privacy NN kim 250 3 and and CC kim 250 4 potential potential JJ kim 250 5 surveillance surveillance NN kim 250 6 are be VBP kim 250 7 examples example NNS kim 250 8 of of IN kim 250 9 other other JJ kim 250 10 important important JJ kim 250 11 ethical ethical JJ kim 250 12 challenges challenge NNS kim 250 13 , , , kim 250 14 which which WDT kim 250 15 I -PRON- PRP kim 250 16 do do VBP kim 250 17 not not RB kim 250 18 discuss discuss VB kim 250 19 here here RB kim 250 20 . . . kim 250 21 ] ] -RRB- kim 251 1 The the DT kim 251 2 challenges challenge NNS kim 251 3 related relate VBN kim 251 4 to to IN kim 251 5 the the DT kim 251 6 AI AI NNP kim 251 7 - - HYPH kim 251 8 powered power VBN kim 251 9 automated automated JJ kim 251 10 information information NN kim 251 11 environment environment NN kim 251 12 are be VBP kim 251 13 relevant relevant JJ kim 251 14 to to IN kim 251 15 libraries library NNS kim 251 16 , , , kim 251 17 which which WDT kim 251 18 will will MD kim 251 19 soon soon RB kim 251 20 be be VB kim 251 21 acquiring acquire VBG kim 251 22 , , , kim 251 23 building build VBG kim 251 24 , , , kim 251 25 customizing customizing NN kim 251 26 , , , kim 251 27 and and CC kim 251 28 implementing implement VBG kim 251 29 many many JJ kim 251 30 personalized personalize VBN kim 251 31 and and CC kim 251 32 automated automate VBD kim 251 33 information information NN kim 251 34 systems system NNS kim 251 35 for for IN kim 251 36 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 251 37 users user NNS kim 251 38 . . . kim 252 1 At at IN kim 252 2 present present NN kim 252 3 , , , kim 252 4 libraries library NNS kim 252 5 are be VBP kim 252 6 at at IN kim 252 7 an an DT kim 252 8 early early JJ kim 252 9 stage stage NN kim 252 10 in in IN kim 252 11 developing develop VBG kim 252 12 AI ai NN kim 252 13 applications application NNS kim 252 14 and and CC kim 252 15 applying apply VBG kim 252 16 machine machine NN kim 252 17 learning learning NN kim 252 18 and and CC kim 252 19 deep deep JJ kim 252 20 learning learning NN kim 252 21 techniques technique NNS kim 252 22 to to TO kim 252 23 improve improve VB kim 252 24 library library JJ kim 252 25 services service NNS kim 252 26 , , , kim 252 27 systems system NNS kim 252 28 , , , kim 252 29 and and CC kim 252 30 operations operation NNS kim 252 31 . . . kim 253 1 But but CC kim 253 2 the the DT kim 253 3 general general JJ kim 253 4 issues issue NNS kim 253 5 of of IN kim 253 6 hidden hide VBN kim 253 7 biases bias NNS kim 253 8 and and CC kim 253 9 the the DT kim 253 10 lack lack NN kim 253 11 of of IN kim 253 12 explainability explainability NN kim 253 13 in in IN kim 253 14 machine machine NN kim 253 15 learning learning NN kim 253 16 and and CC kim 253 17 deep deep JJ kim 253 18 learning learning NN kim 253 19 are be VBP kim 253 20 quickly quickly RB kim 253 21 gaining gain VBG kim 253 22 awareness awareness NN kim 253 23 in in IN kim 253 24 the the DT kim 253 25 library library NN kim 253 26 community community NN kim 253 27 . . . kim 254 1 As as IN kim 254 2 we -PRON- PRP kim 254 3 have have VBP kim 254 4 seen see VBN kim 254 5 in in IN kim 254 6 the the DT kim 254 7 trolley trolley NN kim 254 8 problem problem NN kim 254 9 , , , kim 254 10 whether whether IN kim 254 11 a a DT kim 254 12 certain certain JJ kim 254 13 action action NN kim 254 14 is be VBZ kim 254 15 moral moral JJ kim 254 16 or or CC kim 254 17 not not RB kim 254 18 is be VBZ kim 254 19 a a DT kim 254 20 line line NN kim 254 21 that that WDT kim 254 22 can can MD kim 254 23 not not RB kim 254 24 be be VB kim 254 25 drawn draw VBN kim 254 26 with with IN kim 254 27 absolute absolute JJ kim 254 28 clarity clarity NN kim 254 29 . . . kim 255 1 It -PRON- PRP kim 255 2 is be VBZ kim 255 3 entirely entirely RB kim 255 4 possible possible JJ kim 255 5 for for IN kim 255 6 fully fully RB kim 255 7 - - HYPH kim 255 8 functioning function VBG kim 255 9 moral moral JJ kim 255 10 agents agent NNS kim 255 11 to to TO kim 255 12 make make VB kim 255 13 different different JJ kim 255 14 judgements judgement NNS kim 255 15 in in IN kim 255 16 a a DT kim 255 17 particular particular JJ kim 255 18 situation situation NN kim 255 19 . . . kim 256 1 Additionally additionally RB kim 256 2 , , , kim 256 3 there there EX kim 256 4 is be VBZ kim 256 5 also also RB kim 256 6 the the DT kim 256 7 matter matter NN kim 256 8 of of IN kim 256 9 morality morality NN kim 256 10 that that IN kim 256 11 our -PRON- PRP$ kim 256 12 tools tool NNS kim 256 13 and and CC kim 256 14 systems system NNS kim 256 15 display display NN kim 256 16 . . . kim 257 1 This this DT kim 257 2 is be VBZ kim 257 3 called call VBN kim 257 4 machine machine NN kim 257 5 morality morality NN kim 257 6 in in IN kim 257 7 relation relation NN kim 257 8 to to IN kim 257 9 AI AI NNP kim 257 10 systems system NNS kim 257 11 , , , kim 257 12 since since IN kim 257 13 AI AI NNP kim 257 14 systems system NNS kim 257 15 are be VBP kim 257 16 intelligent intelligent JJ kim 257 17 machines machine NNS kim 257 18 . . . kim 258 1 Wallach Wallach NNP kim 258 2 and and CC kim 258 3 Allen Allen NNP kim 258 4 ( ( -LRB- kim 258 5 2009 2009 CD kim 258 6 ) ) -RRB- kim 258 7 argue argue VBP kim 258 8 that that IN kim 258 9 there there EX kim 258 10 are be VBP kim 258 11 three three CD kim 258 12 distinct distinct JJ kim 258 13 levels level NNS kim 258 14 of of IN kim 258 15 machine machine NN kim 258 16 morality morality NN kim 258 17 : : : kim 258 18 operational operational JJ kim 258 19 morality morality NN kim 258 20 , , , kim 258 21 functional functional JJ kim 258 22 morality morality NN kim 258 23 , , , kim 258 24 and and CC kim 258 25 full full JJ kim 258 26 moral moral JJ kim 258 27 agency agency NN kim 258 28 ( ( -LRB- kim 258 29 26 26 CD kim 258 30 ) ) -RRB- kim 258 31 . . . kim 259 1 Operational operational JJ kim 259 2 morality morality NN kim 259 3 is be VBZ kim 259 4 found find VBN kim 259 5 in in IN kim 259 6 systems system NNS kim 259 7 that that WDT kim 259 8 are be VBP kim 259 9 low low JJ kim 259 10 in in IN kim 259 11 both both CC kim 259 12 autonomy autonomy NN kim 259 13 and and CC kim 259 14 ethical ethical JJ kim 259 15 sensitivity sensitivity NN kim 259 16 . . . kim 260 1 At at IN kim 260 2 this this DT kim 260 3 level level NN kim 260 4 of of IN kim 260 5 machine machine NN kim 260 6 morality morality NN kim 260 7 , , , kim 260 8 a a DT kim 260 9 machine machine NN kim 260 10 or or CC kim 260 11 a a DT kim 260 12 tool tool NN kim 260 13 is be VBZ kim 260 14 given give VBN kim 260 15 a a DT kim 260 16 mechanism mechanism NN kim 260 17 that that WDT kim 260 18 prevents prevent VBZ kim 260 19 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 260 20 immoral immoral JJ kim 260 21 use use NN kim 260 22 , , , kim 260 23 but but CC kim 260 24 the the DT kim 260 25 mechanism mechanism NN kim 260 26 is be VBZ kim 260 27 within within IN kim 260 28 the the DT kim 260 29 full full JJ kim 260 30 control control NN kim 260 31 of of IN kim 260 32 the the DT kim 260 33 machine machine NN kim 260 34 or or CC kim 260 35 the the DT kim 260 36 tool tool NN kim 260 37 ’s ’s POS kim 260 38 designers designer NNS kim 260 39 and and CC kim 260 40 users user NNS kim 260 41 . . . kim 261 1 Such such JJ kim 261 2 operational operational JJ kim 261 3 morality morality NN kim 261 4 exists exist VBZ kim 261 5 in in IN kim 261 6 a a DT kim 261 7 gun gun NN kim 261 8 with with IN kim 261 9 a a DT kim 261 10 childproof childproof JJ kim 261 11 safety safety NN kim 261 12 mechanism mechanism NN kim 261 13 , , , kim 261 14 for for IN kim 261 15 example example NN kim 261 16 . . . kim 262 1 A a DT kim 262 2 gun gun NN kim 262 3 with with IN kim 262 4 a a DT kim 262 5 safety safety NN kim 262 6 mechanism mechanism NN kim 262 7 is be VBZ kim 262 8 hardly hardly RB kim 262 9 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 262 10 nor nor CC kim 262 11 sensitive sensitive JJ kim 262 12 to to IN kim 262 13 any any DT kim 262 14 ethical ethical JJ kim 262 15 concerns concern NNS kim 262 16 related relate VBN kim 262 17 to to IN kim 262 18 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 262 19 use use NN kim 262 20 . . . kim 263 1 By by IN kim 263 2 contrast contrast NN kim 263 3 , , , kim 263 4 machines machine NNS kim 263 5 with with IN kim 263 6 functional functional JJ kim 263 7 morality morality NN kim 263 8 do do VBP kim 263 9 possess possess VB kim 263 10 a a DT kim 263 11 certain certain JJ kim 263 12 level level NN kim 263 13 of of IN kim 263 14 autonomy autonomy NN kim 263 15 and and CC kim 263 16 ethical ethical JJ kim 263 17 sensitivity sensitivity NN kim 263 18 . . . kim 264 1 They -PRON- PRP kim 264 2 may may MD kim 264 3 include include VB kim 264 4 an an DT kim 264 5 AI AI NNP kim 264 6 system system NN kim 264 7 with with IN kim 264 8 significant significant JJ kim 264 9 autonomy autonomy NN kim 264 10 but but CC kim 264 11 little little JJ kim 264 12 ethical ethical JJ kim 264 13 sensitivity sensitivity NN kim 264 14 or or CC kim 264 15 an an DT kim 264 16 AI AI NNP kim 264 17 system system NN kim 264 18 with with IN kim 264 19 little little JJ kim 264 20 autonomy autonomy NN kim 264 21 but but CC kim 264 22 high high JJ kim 264 23 ethical ethical JJ kim 264 24 sensitivity sensitivity NN kim 264 25 . . . kim 265 1 An an DT kim 265 2 autonomous autonomous JJ kim 265 3 drone drone NN kim 265 4 would would MD kim 265 5 fall fall VB kim 265 6 under under IN kim 265 7 the the DT kim 265 8 former former JJ kim 265 9 category category NN kim 265 10 , , , kim 265 11 while while IN kim 265 12 MedEthEx medethex NN kim 265 13 , , , kim 265 14 an an DT kim 265 15 ethical ethical JJ kim 265 16 decision decision NN kim 265 17 - - HYPH kim 265 18 support support NN kim 265 19 AI AI NNP kim 265 20 recommendation recommendation NN kim 265 21 system system NN kim 265 22 for for IN kim 265 23 clinicians clinician NNS kim 265 24 , , , kim 265 25 would would MD kim 265 26 be be VB kim 265 27 of of IN kim 265 28 the the DT kim 265 29 latter latter JJ kim 265 30 . . . kim 266 1 Lastly lastly RB kim 266 2 , , , kim 266 3 systems system NNS kim 266 4 with with IN kim 266 5 high high JJ kim 266 6 autonomy autonomy NN kim 266 7 and and CC kim 266 8 high high JJ kim 266 9 ethical ethical JJ kim 266 10 sensitivity sensitivity NN kim 266 11 can can MD kim 266 12 be be VB kim 266 13 regarded regard VBN kim 266 14 as as IN kim 266 15 having have VBG kim 266 16 full full JJ kim 266 17 moral moral JJ kim 266 18 agency agency NN kim 266 19 , , , kim 266 20 as as RB kim 266 21 much much RB kim 266 22 as as IN kim 266 23 humans human NNS kim 266 24 do do VBP kim 266 25 . . . kim 267 1 This this DT kim 267 2 means mean VBZ kim 267 3 that that IN kim 267 4 those those DT kim 267 5 systems system NNS kim 267 6 would would MD kim 267 7 have have VB kim 267 8 a a DT kim 267 9 mental mental JJ kim 267 10 representation representation NN kim 267 11 of of IN kim 267 12 values value NNS kim 267 13 and and CC kim 267 14 the the DT kim 267 15 capacity capacity NN kim 267 16 for for IN kim 267 17 moral moral JJ kim 267 18 reasoning reasoning NN kim 267 19 . . . kim 268 1 Such such JJ kim 268 2 machines machine NNS kim 268 3 can can MD kim 268 4 be be VB kim 268 5 held hold VBN kim 268 6 morally morally RB kim 268 7 responsible responsible JJ kim 268 8 for for IN kim 268 9 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 268 10 actions action NNS kim 268 11 . . . kim 269 1 We -PRON- PRP kim 269 2 do do VBP kim 269 3 not not RB kim 269 4 know know VB kim 269 5 whether whether IN kim 269 6 AI AI NNP kim 269 7 will will MD kim 269 8 be be VB kim 269 9 able able JJ kim 269 10 to to TO kim 269 11 produce produce VB kim 269 12 such such PDT kim 269 13 a a DT kim 269 14 machine machine NN kim 269 15 with with IN kim 269 16 full full JJ kim 269 17 moral moral JJ kim 269 18 agency agency NN kim 269 19 . . . kim 270 1 If if IN kim 270 2 the the DT kim 270 3 current current JJ kim 270 4 direction direction NN kim 270 5 to to TO kim 270 6 automate automate VB kim 270 7 more more JJR kim 270 8 and and CC kim 270 9 more more JJR kim 270 10 human human JJ kim 270 11 tasks task NNS kim 270 12 for for IN kim 270 13 cost cost NN kim 270 14 savings saving NNS kim 270 15 and and CC kim 270 16 efficiency efficiency NN kim 270 17 at at IN kim 270 18 scale scale NN kim 270 19 continues continue VBZ kim 270 20 , , , kim 270 21 however however RB kim 270 22 , , , kim 270 23 most most JJS kim 270 24 of of IN kim 270 25 the the DT kim 270 26 more more RBR kim 270 27 sophisticated sophisticated JJ kim 270 28 AI AI NNP kim 270 29 applications application NNS kim 270 30 to to TO kim 270 31 come come VB kim 270 32 will will MD kim 270 33 be be VB kim 270 34 of of IN kim 270 35 the the DT kim 270 36 kind kind NN kim 270 37 with with IN kim 270 38 functional functional JJ kim 270 39 morality morality NN kim 270 40 , , , kim 270 41 particularly particularly RB kim 270 42 the the DT kim 270 43 kind kind NN kim 270 44 that that WDT kim 270 45 combines combine VBZ kim 270 46 a a DT kim 270 47 relatively relatively RB kim 270 48 high high JJ kim 270 49 level level NN kim 270 50 of of IN kim 270 51 autonomy autonomy NN kim 270 52 and and CC kim 270 53 a a DT kim 270 54 lower low JJR kim 270 55 level level NN kim 270 56 of of IN kim 270 57 ethical ethical JJ kim 270 58 sensitivity sensitivity NN kim 270 59 . . . kim 271 1 In in IN kim 271 2 the the DT kim 271 3 beginning beginning NN kim 271 4 of of IN kim 271 5 this this DT kim 271 6 chapter chapter NN kim 271 7 , , , kim 271 8 I -PRON- PRP kim 271 9 mentioned mention VBD kim 271 10 that that IN kim 271 11 the the DT kim 271 12 goal goal NN kim 271 13 of of IN kim 271 14 AI AI NNP kim 271 15 is be VBZ kim 271 16 to to TO kim 271 17 create create VB kim 271 18 an an DT kim 271 19 artificial artificial JJ kim 271 20 system system NN kim 271 21 – – : kim 271 22 whether whether IN kim 271 23 it -PRON- PRP kim 271 24 be be VB kim 271 25 a a DT kim 271 26 piece piece NN kim 271 27 of of IN kim 271 28 software software NN kim 271 29 or or CC kim 271 30 a a DT kim 271 31 machine machine NN kim 271 32 with with IN kim 271 33 a a DT kim 271 34 physical physical JJ kim 271 35 body body NN kim 271 36 – – : kim 271 37 that that DT kim 271 38 is be VBZ kim 271 39 as as RB kim 271 40 intelligent intelligent JJ kim 271 41 as as IN kim 271 42 a a DT kim 271 43 human human NN kim 271 44 in in IN kim 271 45 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 271 46 performance performance NN kim 271 47 , , , kim 271 48 either either CC kim 271 49 broadly broadly RB kim 271 50 in in IN kim 271 51 all all DT kim 271 52 areas area NNS kim 271 53 of of IN kim 271 54 human human JJ kim 271 55 activities activity NNS kim 271 56 or or CC kim 271 57 narrowly narrowly RB kim 271 58 in in IN kim 271 59 a a DT kim 271 60 specific specific JJ kim 271 61 activity activity NN kim 271 62 , , , kim 271 63 such such JJ kim 271 64 as as IN kim 271 65 playing play VBG kim 271 66 chess chess NN kim 271 67 or or CC kim 271 68 driving driving NN kim 271 69 . . . kim 272 1 But but CC kim 272 2 what what WP kim 272 3 does do VBZ kim 272 4 “ " `` kim 272 5 as as RB kim 272 6 intelligent intelligent JJ kim 272 7 as as IN kim 272 8 a a DT kim 272 9 human human NN kim 272 10 ” " '' kim 272 11 exactly exactly RB kim 272 12 mean mean VB kim 272 13 ? ? . kim 273 1 If if IN kim 273 2 morality morality NN kim 273 3 is be VBZ kim 273 4 an an DT kim 273 5 integral integral JJ kim 273 6 component component NN kim 273 7 of of IN kim 273 8 human human JJ kim 273 9 - - HYPH kim 273 10 level level NN kim 273 11 intelligence intelligence NN kim 273 12 , , , kim 273 13 AI AI NNP kim 273 14 research research NN kim 273 15 needs need VBZ kim 273 16 to to TO kim 273 17 pay pay VB kim 273 18 more more JJR kim 273 19 attention attention NN kim 273 20 to to IN kim 273 21 intelligence intelligence NN kim 273 22 , , , kim 273 23 not not RB kim 273 24 just just RB kim 273 25 in in IN kim 273 26 accomplishing accomplish VBG kim 273 27 a a DT kim 273 28 goal goal NN kim 273 29 but but CC kim 273 30 also also RB kim 273 31 in in IN kim 273 32 doing do VBG kim 273 33 so so RB kim 273 34 ethically ethically RB kim 273 35 . . . kim 274 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 274 2 footnoteRef:25 footnoteRef:25 NNP kim 274 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 274 4 In in IN kim 274 5 that that DT kim 274 6 light light NN kim 274 7 , , , kim 274 8 it -PRON- PRP kim 274 9 is be VBZ kim 274 10 meaningful meaningful JJ kim 274 11 to to TO kim 274 12 ask ask VB kim 274 13 what what WDT kim 274 14 level level NN kim 274 15 of of IN kim 274 16 autonomy autonomy NN kim 274 17 and and CC kim 274 18 ethical ethical JJ kim 274 19 sensitivity sensitivity NN kim 274 20 a a DT kim 274 21 given give VBN kim 274 22 AI ai NN kim 274 23 system system NN kim 274 24 is be VBZ kim 274 25 equipped equip VBN kim 274 26 with with IN kim 274 27 , , , kim 274 28 and and CC kim 274 29 what what WDT kim 274 30 level level NN kim 274 31 of of IN kim 274 32 machine machine NN kim 274 33 morality morality NN kim 274 34 is be VBZ kim 274 35 appropriate appropriate JJ kim 274 36 for for IN kim 274 37 its -PRON- PRP$ kim 274 38 purpose purpose NN kim 274 39 . . . kim 275 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 275 2 25 25 CD kim 275 3 : : : kim 275 4 Here here RB kim 275 5 , , , kim 275 6 I -PRON- PRP kim 275 7 regard regard VBP kim 275 8 intelligence intelligence NN kim 275 9 as as IN kim 275 10 the the DT kim 275 11 ability ability NN kim 275 12 to to TO kim 275 13 accomplish accomplish VB kim 275 14 complex complex JJ kim 275 15 goals goal NNS kim 275 16 following follow VBG kim 275 17 Tegmark Tegmark NNP kim 275 18 2017 2017 CD kim 275 19 . . . kim 276 1 For for IN kim 276 2 more more JJR kim 276 3 discussion discussion NN kim 276 4 on on IN kim 276 5 intelligence intelligence NN kim 276 6 and and CC kim 276 7 goals goal NNS kim 276 8 , , , kim 276 9 see see VB kim 276 10 Chapter chapter NN kim 276 11 2 2 CD kim 276 12 and and CC kim 276 13 Chapter Chapter NNP kim 276 14 7 7 CD kim 276 15 . . . kim 276 16 ] ] -RRB- kim 277 1 In in IN kim 277 2 designing design VBG kim 277 3 an an DT kim 277 4 AI AI NNP kim 277 5 system system NN kim 277 6 , , , kim 277 7 it -PRON- PRP kim 277 8 would would MD kim 277 9 be be VB kim 277 10 also also RB kim 277 11 helpful helpful JJ kim 277 12 to to TO kim 277 13 determine determine VB kim 277 14 what what WDT kim 277 15 level level NN kim 277 16 of of IN kim 277 17 autonomy autonomy NN kim 277 18 and and CC kim 277 19 ethical ethical JJ kim 277 20 sensitivity sensitivity NN kim 277 21 would would MD kim 277 22 be be VB kim 277 23 best well RBS kim 277 24 suited suit VBN kim 277 25 for for IN kim 277 26 the the DT kim 277 27 purpose purpose NN kim 277 28 of of IN kim 277 29 the the DT kim 277 30 system system NN kim 277 31 and and CC kim 277 32 whether whether IN kim 277 33 it -PRON- PRP kim 277 34 is be VBZ kim 277 35 feasible feasible JJ kim 277 36 to to TO kim 277 37 provide provide VB kim 277 38 that that DT kim 277 39 level level NN kim 277 40 of of IN kim 277 41 machine machine NN kim 277 42 morality morality NN kim 277 43 for for IN kim 277 44 the the DT kim 277 45 system system NN kim 277 46 in in IN kim 277 47 question question NN kim 277 48 . . . kim 278 1 The the DT kim 278 2 narrower narrow JJR kim 278 3 the the DT kim 278 4 function function NN kim 278 5 or or CC kim 278 6 the the DT kim 278 7 domain domain NN kim 278 8 of of IN kim 278 9 an an DT kim 278 10 AI AI NNP kim 278 11 system system NN kim 278 12 is be VBZ kim 278 13 , , , kim 278 14 the the DT kim 278 15 easier easy JJR kim 278 16 it -PRON- PRP kim 278 17 will will MD kim 278 18 be be VB kim 278 19 to to TO kim 278 20 equip equip VB kim 278 21 it -PRON- PRP kim 278 22 with with IN kim 278 23 an an DT kim 278 24 appropriate appropriate JJ kim 278 25 level level NN kim 278 26 of of IN kim 278 27 autonomy autonomy NN kim 278 28 and and CC kim 278 29 ethical ethical JJ kim 278 30 sensitivity sensitivity NN kim 278 31 . . . kim 279 1 In in IN kim 279 2 evaluating evaluate VBG kim 279 3 and and CC kim 279 4 designing design VBG kim 279 5 an an DT kim 279 6 AI AI NNP kim 279 7 system system NN kim 279 8 , , , kim 279 9 it -PRON- PRP kim 279 10 will will MD kim 279 11 be be VB kim 279 12 important important JJ kim 279 13 to to TO kim 279 14 test test VB kim 279 15 the the DT kim 279 16 actual actual JJ kim 279 17 outcome outcome NN kim 279 18 against against IN kim 279 19 the the DT kim 279 20 anticipated anticipated JJ kim 279 21 outcome outcome NN kim 279 22 in in IN kim 279 23 different different JJ kim 279 24 types type NNS kim 279 25 of of IN kim 279 26 cases case NNS kim 279 27 in in IN kim 279 28 order order NN kim 279 29 to to TO kim 279 30 identify identify VB kim 279 31 potential potential JJ kim 279 32 problems problem NNS kim 279 33 . . . kim 280 1 System system NN kim 280 2 - - HYPH kim 280 3 wide wide JJ kim 280 4 audits audits NN kim 280 5 to to TO kim 280 6 detect detect VB kim 280 7 well well RB kim 280 8 - - HYPH kim 280 9 known know VBN kim 280 10 biases bias NNS kim 280 11 , , , kim 280 12 such such JJ kim 280 13 as as IN kim 280 14 gender gender NN kim 280 15 discrimination discrimination NN kim 280 16 or or CC kim 280 17 racism racism NN kim 280 18 can can MD kim 280 19 serve serve VB kim 280 20 as as IN kim 280 21 an an DT kim 280 22 effective effective JJ kim 280 23 strategy strategy NN kim 280 24 . . . kim 281 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 281 2 footnoteRef:26 footnoteRef:26 NNP kim 281 3 ] ] -RRB- kim 281 4 Other other JJ kim 281 5 undetected undetected JJ kim 281 6 problems problem NNS kim 281 7 may may MD kim 281 8 surface surface VB kim 281 9 only only RB kim 281 10 after after IN kim 281 11 the the DT kim 281 12 AI AI NNP kim 281 13 system system NN kim 281 14 is be VBZ kim 281 15 deployed deploy VBN kim 281 16 . . . kim 282 1 Having have VBG kim 282 2 a a DT kim 282 3 mechanism mechanism NN kim 282 4 to to TO kim 282 5 continually continually RB kim 282 6 test test VB kim 282 7 an an DT kim 282 8 AI AI NNP kim 282 9 algorithm algorithm NN kim 282 10 to to TO kim 282 11 identify identify VB kim 282 12 those those DT kim 282 13 unnoticed unnoticed JJ kim 282 14 problems problem NNS kim 282 15 and and CC kim 282 16 feeding feed VBG kim 282 17 the the DT kim 282 18 test test NN kim 282 19 result result VB kim 282 20 back back RB kim 282 21 into into IN kim 282 22 the the DT kim 282 23 algorithm algorithm NN kim 282 24 for for IN kim 282 25 retraining retraining NN kim 282 26 will will MD kim 282 27 be be VB kim 282 28 another another DT kim 282 29 way way NN kim 282 30 to to TO kim 282 31 deal deal VB kim 282 32 with with IN kim 282 33 algorithmic algorithmic JJ kim 282 34 biases bias NNS kim 282 35 . . . kim 283 1 Those those DT kim 283 2 who who WP kim 283 3 build build VBP kim 283 4 AI AI NNP kim 283 5 systems system NNS kim 283 6 will will MD kim 283 7 also also RB kim 283 8 benefit benefit VB kim 283 9 from from IN kim 283 10 consulting consult VBG kim 283 11 existing exist VBG kim 283 12 principles principle NNS kim 283 13 and and CC kim 283 14 guidelines guideline NNS kim 283 15 such such JJ kim 283 16 as as IN kim 283 17 FAT FAT NNP kim 283 18 / / SYM kim 283 19 ML ML NNP kim 283 20 ’s ’s POS kim 283 21 “ " `` kim 283 22 Principles principle NNS kim 283 23 for for IN kim 283 24 Accountable Accountable NNP kim 283 25 Algorithms Algorithms NNP kim 283 26 and and CC kim 283 27 a a DT kim 283 28 Social Social NNP kim 283 29 Impact Impact NNP kim 283 30 Statement Statement NNP kim 283 31 for for IN kim 283 32 Algorithms Algorithms NNP kim 283 33 . . . kim 283 34 ”[footnoteRef:27 ”[footnoteRef:27 '' kim 283 35 ] ] -RRB- kim 283 36 [ [ -LRB- kim 283 37 26 26 CD kim 283 38 : : : kim 283 39 These these DT kim 283 40 audits audit NNS kim 283 41 are be VBP kim 283 42 far far RB kim 283 43 from from IN kim 283 44 foolproof foolproof JJ kim 283 45 , , , kim 283 46 but but CC kim 283 47 the the DT kim 283 48 detection detection NN kim 283 49 of of IN kim 283 50 hidden hidden JJ kim 283 51 biases bias NNS kim 283 52 will will MD kim 283 53 be be VB kim 283 54 crucial crucial JJ kim 283 55 in in IN kim 283 56 making make VBG kim 283 57 AI AI NNP kim 283 58 algorithms algorithm NNS kim 283 59 more more RBR kim 283 60 accountable accountable JJ kim 283 61 and and CC kim 283 62 their -PRON- PRP$ kim 283 63 decisions decision NNS kim 283 64 more more RBR kim 283 65 ethical ethical JJ kim 283 66 . . . kim 284 1 A a DT kim 284 2 debiasing debiasing JJ kim 284 3 algorithm algorithm NN kim 284 4 can can MD kim 284 5 also also RB kim 284 6 be be VB kim 284 7 used use VBN kim 284 8 during during IN kim 284 9 the the DT kim 284 10 training training NN kim 284 11 stage stage NN kim 284 12 of of IN kim 284 13 an an DT kim 284 14 AI AI NNP kim 284 15 algorithm algorithm NN kim 284 16 to to TO kim 284 17 reduce reduce VB kim 284 18 hidden hide VBN kim 284 19 biases bias NNS kim 284 20 in in IN kim 284 21 training training NN kim 284 22 data datum NNS kim 284 23 . . . kim 285 1 See see VB kim 285 2 Amini Amini NNP kim 285 3 et et NNP kim 285 4 al al NNP kim 285 5 . . . kim 286 1 2019 2019 CD kim 286 2 , , , kim 286 3 Knight Knight NNP kim 286 4 2019b 2019b CD kim 286 5 , , , kim 286 6 and and CC kim 286 7 Courtland Courtland NNP kim 286 8 2018 2018 CD kim 286 9 . . . kim 286 10 ] ] -RRB- kim 287 1 [ [ -LRB- kim 287 2 27 27 CD kim 287 3 : : : kim 287 4 See see VB kim 287 5 https://www.fatml.org/resources/principles-for-accountable-algorithms https://www.fatml.org/resources/principles-for-accountable-algorithms NNP kim 287 6 . . . kim 288 1 Other other JJ kim 288 2 principles principle NNS kim 288 3 and and CC kim 288 4 guidelines guideline NNS kim 288 5 include include VBP kim 288 6 “ " `` kim 288 7 Ethics Ethics NNP kim 288 8 Guidelines Guidelines NNPS kim 288 9 for for IN kim 288 10 Trustworthy Trustworthy NNP kim 288 11 AI AI NNP kim 288 12 ” " '' kim 288 13 ( ( -LRB- kim 288 14 https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/news/ethics-guidelines-trustworthy-ai https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/news/ethics-guidelines-trustworthy-ai NNP kim 288 15 ) ) -RRB- kim 288 16 and and CC kim 288 17 “ " `` kim 288 18 Algorithmic Algorithmic NNP kim 288 19 Impact Impact NNP kim 288 20 Assessments assessment NNS kim 288 21 : : : kim 288 22 A a DT kim 288 23 Practical Practical NNP kim 288 24 Framework Framework NNP kim 288 25 For for IN kim 288 26 Public Public NNP kim 288 27 Agency Agency NNP kim 288 28 Accountability Accountability NNP kim 288 29 ” " '' kim 288 30 ( ( -LRB- kim 288 31 https://ainowinstitute.org/aiareport2018.pdf https://ainowinstitute.org/aiareport2018.pdf NNP kim 288 32 ) ) -RRB- kim 288 33 . . . kim 288 34 ] ] -RRB- kim 289 1 We -PRON- PRP kim 289 2 may may MD kim 289 3 also also RB kim 289 4 want want VB kim 289 5 to to TO kim 289 6 rethink rethink VB kim 289 7 how how WRB kim 289 8 and and CC kim 289 9 where where WRB kim 289 10 we -PRON- PRP kim 289 11 apply apply VBP kim 289 12 AI AI NNP kim 289 13 . . . kim 290 1 We -PRON- PRP kim 290 2 and and CC kim 290 3 our -PRON- PRP$ kim 290 4 society society NN kim 290 5 do do VBP kim 290 6 not not RB kim 290 7 have have VB kim 290 8 to to TO kim 290 9 use use VB kim 290 10 AI AI NNP kim 290 11 to to TO kim 290 12 equip equip VB kim 290 13 all all PDT kim 290 14 our -PRON- PRP$ kim 290 15 systems system NNS kim 290 16 and and CC kim 290 17 machines machine NNS kim 290 18 with with IN kim 290 19 human- human- NN kim 290 20 or or CC kim 290 21 superhuman superhuman JJ kim 290 22 - - HYPH kim 290 23 level level NN kim 290 24 of of IN kim 290 25 performance performance NN kim 290 26 . . . kim 291 1 This this DT kim 291 2 is be VBZ kim 291 3 particularly particularly RB kim 291 4 so so RB kim 291 5 if if IN kim 291 6 the the DT kim 291 7 pursuit pursuit NN kim 291 8 of of IN kim 291 9 such such JJ kim 291 10 human- human- NN kim 291 11 or or CC kim 291 12 superhuman superhuman JJ kim 291 13 - - HYPH kim 291 14 level level NN kim 291 15 performance performance NN kim 291 16 is be VBZ kim 291 17 likely likely JJ kim 291 18 to to TO kim 291 19 increase increase VB kim 291 20 the the DT kim 291 21 possibility possibility NN kim 291 22 of of IN kim 291 23 the the DT kim 291 24 AI AI NNP kim 291 25 algorithms algorithm NNS kim 291 26 making make VBG kim 291 27 unethical unethical JJ kim 291 28 decisions decision NNS kim 291 29 that that WDT kim 291 30 negatively negatively RB kim 291 31 impact impact VBP kim 291 32 a a DT kim 291 33 significant significant JJ kim 291 34 number number NN kim 291 35 of of IN kim 291 36 people people NNS kim 291 37 . . . kim 292 1 We -PRON- PRP kim 292 2 do do VBP kim 292 3 not not RB kim 292 4 have have VB kim 292 5 to to TO kim 292 6 task task NN kim 292 7 AI AI NNP kim 292 8 with with IN kim 292 9 automating automate VBG kim 292 10 away away RP kim 292 11 human human JJ kim 292 12 work work NN kim 292 13 and and CC kim 292 14 decisions decision NNS kim 292 15 as as RB kim 292 16 much much RB kim 292 17 as as IN kim 292 18 possible possible JJ kim 292 19 . . . kim 293 1 What what WP kim 293 2 if if IN kim 293 3 we -PRON- PRP kim 293 4 reframe reframe VBP kim 293 5 AI AI NNP kim 293 6 ’s ’s POS kim 293 7 role role NN kim 293 8 in in IN kim 293 9 the the DT kim 293 10 context context NN kim 293 11 of of IN kim 293 12 assisting assist VBG kim 293 13 people people NNS kim 293 14 rather rather RB kim 293 15 than than IN kim 293 16 replacing replace VBG kim 293 17 them -PRON- PRP kim 293 18 , , , kim 293 19 so so IN kim 293 20 that that IN kim 293 21 people people NNS kim 293 22 can can MD kim 293 23 become become VB kim 293 24 more more RBR kim 293 25 intelligent intelligent JJ kim 293 26 and and CC kim 293 27 more more RBR kim 293 28 capable capable JJ kim 293 29 where where WRB kim 293 30 they -PRON- PRP kim 293 31 struggle struggle VBP kim 293 32 or or CC kim 293 33 experience experience NN kim 293 34 disadvantages disadvantage NNS kim 293 35 , , , kim 293 36 such such JJ kim 293 37 as as IN kim 293 38 critical critical JJ kim 293 39 thinking thinking NN kim 293 40 , , , kim 293 41 civic civic JJ kim 293 42 participation participation NN kim 293 43 , , , kim 293 44 healthy healthy JJ kim 293 45 living living NN kim 293 46 , , , kim 293 47 financial financial JJ kim 293 48 literacy literacy NN kim 293 49 , , , kim 293 50 dyslexia dyslexia NNP kim 293 51 , , , kim 293 52 or or CC kim 293 53 hearing hearing NN kim 293 54 loss loss NN kim 293 55 ? ? . kim 294 1 What what WDT kim 294 2 kind kind NN kim 294 3 of of IN kim 294 4 AI ai NN kim 294 5 - - HYPH kim 294 6 driven drive VBN kim 294 7 information information NN kim 294 8 systems system NNS kim 294 9 and and CC kim 294 10 environments environment NNS kim 294 11 would would MD kim 294 12 be be VB kim 294 13 created create VBN kim 294 14 if if IN kim 294 15 libraries library NNS kim 294 16 approach approach VBP kim 294 17 AI AI NNP kim 294 18 with with IN kim 294 19 such such JJ kim 294 20 intention intention NN kim 294 21 from from IN kim 294 22 the the DT kim 294 23 beginning beginning NN kim 294 24 ? ? . kim 295 1 References References NNP kim 295 2 Alexander Alexander NNP kim 295 3 , , , kim 295 4 Larry Larry NNP kim 295 5 , , , kim 295 6 and and CC kim 295 7 Michael Michael NNP kim 295 8 Moore Moore NNP kim 295 9 . . . kim 296 1 2016 2016 CD kim 296 2 . . . kim 297 1 “ " `` kim 297 2 Deontological Deontological NNP kim 297 3 Ethics Ethics NNPS kim 297 4 . . . kim 297 5 ” " '' kim 297 6 In in IN kim 297 7 The the DT kim 297 8 Stanford Stanford NNP kim 297 9 Encyclopedia Encyclopedia NNP kim 297 10 of of IN kim 297 11 Philosophy Philosophy NNP kim 297 12 , , , kim 297 13 edited edit VBN kim 297 14 by by IN kim 297 15 Edward Edward NNP kim 297 16 N. N. NNP kim 297 17 Zalta Zalta NNP kim 297 18 , , , kim 297 19 Winter Winter NNP kim 297 20 2016 2016 CD kim 297 21 . . . kim 298 1 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP kim 298 2 Research Research NNP kim 298 3 Lab Lab NNP kim 298 4 , , , kim 298 5 Stanford Stanford NNP kim 298 6 University University NNP kim 298 7 . . . kim 299 1 https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2016/entries/ethics-deontological/. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2016/entries/ethics-deontological/. NNP kim 300 1 Amini Amini NNP kim 300 2 , , , kim 300 3 Alexander Alexander NNP kim 300 4 , , , kim 300 5 Ava Ava NNP kim 300 6 P. P. NNP kim 300 7 Soleimany Soleimany NNP kim 300 8 , , , kim 300 9 Wilko Wilko NNP kim 300 10 Schwarting Schwarting NNP kim 300 11 , , , kim 300 12 Sangeeta Sangeeta NNP kim 300 13 N. N. NNP kim 300 14 Bhatia Bhatia NNP kim 300 15 , , , kim 300 16 and and CC kim 300 17 Daniela Daniela NNP kim 300 18 Rus Rus NNP kim 300 19 . . . kim 301 1 2019 2019 CD kim 301 2 . . . kim 302 1 “ " `` kim 302 2 Uncovering uncover VBG kim 302 3 and and CC kim 302 4 Mitigating Mitigating NNP kim 302 5 Algorithmic Algorithmic NNP kim 302 6 Bias Bias NNP kim 302 7 through through IN kim 302 8 Learned learn VBN kim 302 9 Latent Latent NNP kim 302 10 Structure Structure NNP kim 302 11 . . . kim 302 12 ” " '' kim 302 13 In in IN kim 302 14 Proceedings Proceedings NNP kim 302 15 of of IN kim 302 16 the the DT kim 302 17 2019 2019 CD kim 302 18 AAAI AAAI NNP kim 302 19 / / SYM kim 302 20 ACM ACM NNP kim 302 21 Conference Conference NNP kim 302 22 on on IN kim 302 23 AI AI NNP kim 302 24 , , , kim 302 25 Ethics Ethics NNP kim 302 26 , , , kim 302 27 and and CC kim 302 28 Society Society NNP kim 302 29 , , , kim 302 30 289–295 289–295 CD kim 302 31 . . . kim 303 1 AIES AIES NNP kim 303 2 ’ ’ POS kim 303 3 19 19 CD kim 303 4 . . . kim 304 1 New New NNP kim 304 2 York York NNP kim 304 3 , , , kim 304 4 NY NY NNP kim 304 5 , , , kim 304 6 USA USA NNP kim 304 7 : : : kim 304 8 Association Association NNP kim 304 9 for for IN kim 304 10 Computing Computing NNP kim 304 11 Machinery Machinery NNP kim 304 12 . . . kim 305 1 https://doi.org/10.1145/3306618.3314243 https://doi.org/10.1145/3306618.3314243 ADD kim 305 2 . . . kim 306 1 Averkamp Averkamp NNP kim 306 2 , , , kim 306 3 Shawn Shawn NNP kim 306 4 , , , kim 306 5 and and CC kim 306 6 Julie Julie NNP kim 306 7 Hardesty Hardesty NNP kim 306 8 . . . kim 307 1 2020 2020 CD kim 307 2 . . . kim 308 1 “ " `` kim 308 2 AI AI NNP kim 308 3 Is be VBZ kim 308 4 Such such PDT kim 308 5 a a DT kim 308 6 Tool tool NN kim 308 7 : : : kim 308 8 Keeping keep VBG kim 308 9 Your -PRON- PRP$ kim 308 10 Machine machine NN kim 308 11 Learning Learning NNP kim 308 12 Outputs Outputs NNPS kim 308 13 in in IN kim 308 14 Check Check NNP kim 308 15 . . . kim 308 16 ” " '' kim 308 17 Presented present VBN kim 308 18 at at IN kim 308 19 the the DT kim 308 20 Code4lib Code4lib NNP kim 308 21 Conference Conference NNP kim 308 22 , , , kim 308 23 Pittsburgh Pittsburgh NNP kim 308 24 , , , kim 308 25 PA PA NNP kim 308 26 , , , kim 308 27 March March NNP kim 308 28 11 11 CD kim 308 29 . . . kim 308 30 https://2020.code4lib.org/talks/AI-is-such-a-tool-Keeping-your-machine-learning-outputs-in-check https://2020.code4lib.org/talks/ai-is-such-a-tool-keeping-your-machine-learning-outputs-in-check CD kim 308 31 . . . kim 309 1 Blewer Blewer NNP kim 309 2 , , , kim 309 3 Ashley Ashley NNP kim 309 4 , , , kim 309 5 Bohyun Bohyun NNP kim 309 6 Kim Kim NNP kim 309 7 , , , kim 309 8 and and CC kim 309 9 Eric Eric NNP kim 309 10 Phetteplace Phetteplace NNP kim 309 11 . . . kim 310 1 2018 2018 CD kim 310 2 . . . kim 311 1 “ " `` kim 311 2 Reflections reflection NNS kim 311 3 on on IN kim 311 4 Code4Lib Code4Lib NNP kim 311 5 2018 2018 CD kim 311 6 . . . kim 311 7 ” " '' kim 311 8 ACRL ACRL NNP kim 311 9 TechConnect TechConnect NNP kim 311 10 ( ( -LRB- kim 311 11 blog blog NN kim 311 12 ) ) -RRB- kim 311 13 . . . kim 312 1 March March NNP kim 312 2 12 12 CD kim 312 3 , , , kim 312 4 2018 2018 CD kim 312 5 . . . kim 312 6 https://acrl.ala.org/techconnect/post/reflections-on-code4lib-2018/. https://acrl.ala.org/techconnect/post/reflections-on-code4lib-2018/. NNP kim 313 1 Boden Boden NNP kim 313 2 , , , kim 313 3 Margaret Margaret NNP kim 313 4 A. A. NNP kim 314 1 2016 2016 CD kim 314 2 . . . kim 315 1 AI ai NN kim 315 2 : : : kim 315 3 Its -PRON- PRP$ kim 315 4 Nature Nature NNP kim 315 5 and and CC kim 315 6 Future Future NNP kim 315 7 . . . kim 316 1 Oxford oxford NN kim 316 2 : : : kim 316 3 Oxford Oxford NNP kim 316 4 University University NNP kim 316 5 Press Press NNP kim 316 6 . . . kim 317 1 Bonnefon Bonnefon NNP kim 317 2 , , , kim 317 3 Jean Jean NNP kim 317 4 - - HYPH kim 317 5 François François NNP kim 317 6 , , , kim 317 7 Azim Azim NNP kim 317 8 Shariff Shariff NNP kim 317 9 , , , kim 317 10 and and CC kim 317 11 Iyad Iyad NNP kim 317 12 Rahwan Rahwan NNP kim 317 13 . . . kim 318 1 2016 2016 CD kim 318 2 . . . kim 319 1 “ " `` kim 319 2 The the DT kim 319 3 Social Social NNP kim 319 4 Dilemma Dilemma NNP kim 319 5 of of IN kim 319 6 Autonomous Autonomous NNP kim 319 7 Vehicles Vehicles NNPS kim 319 8 . . . kim 319 9 ” " '' kim 319 10 Science science NN kim 319 11 352 352 CD kim 319 12 ( ( -LRB- kim 319 13 6293 6293 CD kim 319 14 ) ) -RRB- kim 319 15 : : : kim 319 16 1573–76 1573–76 LS kim 319 17 . . . kim 320 1 https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aaf2654 https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aaf2654 NNP kim 320 2 . . . kim 321 1 Clark Clark NNP kim 321 2 , , , kim 321 3 Liat Liat NNP kim 321 4 . . . kim 322 1 2012 2012 CD kim 322 2 . . . kim 323 1 “ " `` kim 323 2 Google Google NNP kim 323 3 ’s ’s NNP kim 323 4 Artificial Artificial NNP kim 323 5 Brain Brain NNP kim 323 6 Learns learn VBZ kim 323 7 to to TO kim 323 8 Find find VB kim 323 9 Cat cat NN kim 323 10 Videos video NNS kim 323 11 . . . kim 323 12 ” " '' kim 323 13 Wired wire VBN kim 323 14 , , , kim 323 15 June June NNP kim 323 16 26 26 CD kim 323 17 , , , kim 323 18 2012 2012 CD kim 323 19 . . . kim 323 20 https://www.wired.com/2012/06/google-x-neural-network/. https://www.wired.com/2012/06/google-x-neural-network/. NNP kim 324 1 Conitzer Conitzer NNP kim 324 2 , , , kim 324 3 Vincent Vincent NNP kim 324 4 , , , kim 324 5 Walter Walter NNP kim 324 6 Sinnott Sinnott NNP kim 324 7 - - HYPH kim 324 8 Armstrong Armstrong NNP kim 324 9 , , , kim 324 10 Jana Jana NNP kim 324 11 Schaich Schaich NNP kim 324 12 Borg Borg NNP kim 324 13 , , , kim 324 14 Yuan Yuan NNP kim 324 15 Deng Deng NNP kim 324 16 , , , kim 324 17 and and CC kim 324 18 Max Max NNP kim 324 19 Kramer Kramer NNP kim 324 20 . . . kim 325 1 2017 2017 CD kim 325 2 . . . kim 326 1 “ " `` kim 326 2 Moral moral JJ kim 326 3 Decision decision NN kim 326 4 Making make VBG kim 326 5 Frameworks Frameworks NNP kim 326 6 for for IN kim 326 7 Artificial Artificial NNP kim 326 8 Intelligence Intelligence NNP kim 326 9 . . . kim 326 10 ” " '' kim 326 11 In in IN kim 326 12 Proceedings Proceedings NNP kim 326 13 of of IN kim 326 14 the the DT kim 326 15 Thirty Thirty NNP kim 326 16 - - HYPH kim 326 17 First First NNP kim 326 18 AAAI AAAI NNP kim 326 19 Conference Conference NNP kim 326 20 on on IN kim 326 21 Artificial Artificial NNP kim 326 22 Intelligence Intelligence NNP kim 326 23 , , , kim 326 24 4831–4835 4831–4835 CD kim 326 25 . . . kim 327 1 AAAI’17 aaai’17 UH kim 327 2 . . . kim 328 1 San San NNP kim 328 2 Francisco Francisco NNP kim 328 3 , , , kim 328 4 California California NNP kim 328 5 , , , kim 328 6 USA USA NNP kim 328 7 : : : kim 328 8 AAAI AAAI NNP kim 328 9 Press Press NNP kim 328 10 . . . kim 329 1 Courtland Courtland NNP kim 329 2 , , , kim 329 3 Rachel Rachel NNP kim 329 4 . . . kim 330 1 2018 2018 CD kim 330 2 . . . kim 331 1 “ " `` kim 331 2 Bias Bias NNP kim 331 3 Detectives detective NNS kim 331 4 : : : kim 331 5 The the DT kim 331 6 Researchers researcher NNS kim 331 7 Striving strive VBG kim 331 8 to to TO kim 331 9 Make make VB kim 331 10 Algorithms Algorithms NNP kim 331 11 Fair Fair NNP kim 331 12 . . . kim 331 13 ” " '' kim 331 14 Nature nature NN kim 331 15 558 558 CD kim 331 16 ( ( -LRB- kim 331 17 7710 7710 CD kim 331 18 ) ) -RRB- kim 331 19 : : : kim 331 20 357–60 357–60 CD kim 331 21 . . . kim 332 1 https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-018-05469-3 https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-018-05469-3 ADD kim 332 2 . . . kim 333 1 Cushman Cushman NNP kim 333 2 , , , kim 333 3 Fiery Fiery NNP kim 333 4 , , , kim 333 5 Liane Liane NNP kim 333 6 Young Young NNP kim 333 7 , , , kim 333 8 and and CC kim 333 9 Marc Marc NNP kim 333 10 Hauser Hauser NNP kim 333 11 . . . kim 334 1 2006 2006 CD kim 334 2 . . . kim 335 1 “ " `` kim 335 2 The the DT kim 335 3 Role Role NNP kim 335 4 of of IN kim 335 5 Conscious Conscious NNP kim 335 6 Reasoning Reasoning NNP kim 335 7 and and CC kim 335 8 Intuition Intuition NNP kim 335 9 in in IN kim 335 10 Moral Moral NNP kim 335 11 Judgment Judgment NNP kim 335 12 : : : kim 335 13 Testing test VBG kim 335 14 Three three CD kim 335 15 Principles principle NNS kim 335 16 of of IN kim 335 17 Harm harm NN kim 335 18 . . . kim 335 19 ” " '' kim 335 20 Psychological Psychological NNP kim 335 21 Science Science NNP kim 335 22 17 17 CD kim 335 23 ( ( -LRB- kim 335 24 12 12 CD kim 335 25 ) ) -RRB- kim 335 26 : : : kim 335 27 1082–89 1082–89 LS kim 335 28 . . . kim 336 1 Davis Davis NNP kim 336 2 , , , kim 336 3 Daniel Daniel NNP kim 336 4 L. L. NNP kim 336 5 2007 2007 CD kim 336 6 . . . kim 337 1 “ " `` kim 337 2 Who who WP kim 337 3 Decides decide VBZ kim 337 4 : : : kim 337 5 Man man NN kim 337 6 or or CC kim 337 7 Machine machine NN kim 337 8 ? ? . kim 337 9 ” " '' kim 337 10 Armed Armed NNP kim 337 11 Forces Forces NNPS kim 337 12 Journal Journal NNP kim 337 13 , , , kim 337 14 November November NNP kim 337 15 . . . kim 338 1 http://armedforcesjournal.com/who-decides-man-or-machine/. http://armedforcesjournal.com/who-decides-man-or-machine/. NNP kim 339 1 Davis Davis NNP kim 339 2 , , , kim 339 3 Hannah Hannah NNP kim 339 4 . . . kim 340 1 2020 2020 CD kim 340 2 . . . kim 341 1 “ " `` kim 341 2 A a DT kim 341 3 Dataset dataset NN kim 341 4 Is be VBZ kim 341 5 a a DT kim 341 6 Worldview worldview NN kim 341 7 . . . kim 341 8 ” " '' kim 341 9 Towards towards IN kim 341 10 Data Data NNP kim 341 11 Science Science NNP kim 341 12 . . . kim 342 1 March March NNP kim 342 2 5 5 CD kim 342 3 , , , kim 342 4 2020 2020 CD kim 342 5 . . . kim 342 6 https://towardsdatascience.com/a-dataset-is-a-worldview-5328216dd44d https://towardsdatascience.com/a-dataset-is-a-worldview-5328216dd44d ADD kim 342 7 . . . kim 343 1 Foot Foot NNP kim 343 2 , , , kim 343 3 Philippa Philippa NNP kim 343 4 . . . kim 344 1 1967 1967 CD kim 344 2 . . . kim 345 1 “ " `` kim 345 2 The the DT kim 345 3 Problem problem NN kim 345 4 of of IN kim 345 5 Abortion abortion NN kim 345 6 and and CC kim 345 7 the the DT kim 345 8 Doctrine Doctrine NNP kim 345 9 of of IN kim 345 10 Double Double NNP kim 345 11 Effect Effect NNP kim 345 12 . . . kim 345 13 ” " '' kim 345 14 Oxford Oxford NNP kim 345 15 Review Review NNP kim 345 16 5 5 CD kim 345 17 : : : kim 345 18 5–15 5–15 CD kim 345 19 . . . kim 346 1 Heaven Heaven NNP kim 346 2 , , , kim 346 3 Will Will NNP kim 346 4 Douglas Douglas NNP kim 346 5 . . . kim 347 1 2020 2020 CD kim 347 2 . . . kim 348 1 “ " `` kim 348 2 DeepMind DeepMind NNP kim 348 3 ’s ’s , kim 348 4 AI ai NN kim 348 5 Can Can MD kim 348 6 Now now RB kim 348 7 Play play VB kim 348 8 All all DT kim 348 9 57 57 CD kim 348 10 Atari Atari NNP kim 348 11 Games Games NNPS kim 348 12 — — : kim 348 13 but but CC kim 348 14 It -PRON- PRP kim 348 15 ’s ’ VBZ kim 348 16 Still still RB kim 348 17 Not not RB kim 348 18 Versatile versatile JJ kim 348 19 Enough enough RB kim 348 20 . . . kim 348 21 ” " '' kim 348 22 MIT MIT NNP kim 348 23 Technology Technology NNP kim 348 24 Review Review NNP kim 348 25 , , , kim 348 26 April April NNP kim 348 27 1 1 CD kim 348 28 , , , kim 348 29 2020 2020 CD kim 348 30 . . . kim 348 31 https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/04/01/974997/deepminds-ai-57-atari-games-but-its-still-not-versatile-enough/. https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/04/01/974997/deepminds-ai-57-atari-games-but-its-still-not-versatile-enough/. NNP kim 349 1 International International NNP kim 349 2 Committee Committee NNP kim 349 3 of of IN kim 349 4 the the DT kim 349 5 Red Red NNP kim 349 6 Cross Cross NNP kim 349 7 . . . kim 350 1 2015 2015 CD kim 350 2 . . . kim 351 1 “ " `` kim 351 2 What what WP kim 351 3 Are be VBP kim 351 4 Jus Jus NNP kim 351 5 Ad Ad NNP kim 351 6 Bellum Bellum NNP kim 351 7 and and CC kim 351 8 Jus Jus NNP kim 351 9 in in IN kim 351 10 Bello Bello NNP kim 351 11 ? ? . kim 351 12 , , , kim 351 13 ” " '' kim 351 14 September September NNP kim 351 15 . . . kim 352 1 https://www.icrc.org/en/document/what-are-jus-ad-bellum-and-jus-bello-0 https://www.icrc.org/en/document/what-are-jus-ad-bellum-and-jus-bello-0 NNP kim 352 2 . . . kim 353 1 Kahn Kahn NNP kim 353 2 , , , kim 353 3 Leonard Leonard NNP kim 353 4 . . . kim 354 1 2012 2012 CD kim 354 2 . . . kim 355 1 “ " `` kim 355 2 Military military JJ kim 355 3 Robots Robots NNP kim 355 4 and and CC kim 355 5 The the DT kim 355 6 Likelihood Likelihood NNP kim 355 7 of of IN kim 355 8 Armed Armed NNP kim 355 9 Combat Combat NNP kim 355 10 . . . kim 355 11 ” " '' kim 355 12 In in IN kim 355 13 Robot Robot NNP kim 355 14 Ethics Ethics NNP kim 355 15 : : : kim 355 16 The the DT kim 355 17 Ethical Ethical NNP kim 355 18 and and CC kim 355 19 Social Social NNP kim 355 20 Implications Implications NNPS kim 355 21 of of IN kim 355 22 Robotics Robotics NNPS kim 355 23 , , , kim 355 24 edited edit VBN kim 355 25 by by IN kim 355 26 Patrick Patrick NNP kim 355 27 Lin Lin NNP kim 355 28 , , , kim 355 29 Keith Keith NNP kim 355 30 Abney Abney NNP kim 355 31 , , , kim 355 32 and and CC kim 355 33 George George NNP kim 355 34 A. A. NNP kim 355 35 Bekey Bekey NNP kim 355 36 , , , kim 355 37 274–92 274–92 CD kim 355 38 . . . kim 356 1 Intelligent intelligent JJ kim 356 2 Robotics Robotics NNPS kim 356 3 and and CC kim 356 4 Autonomous Autonomous NNP kim 356 5 Agents Agents NNPS kim 356 6 . . . kim 357 1 Cambridge Cambridge NNP kim 357 2 , , , kim 357 3 Mass. Massachusetts NNP kim 358 1 : : : kim 358 2 MIT MIT NNP kim 358 3 Press Press NNP kim 358 4 . . . kim 359 1 Knight Knight NNP kim 359 2 , , , kim 359 3 Will Will NNP kim 359 4 . . . kim 360 1 2017 2017 CD kim 360 2 . . . kim 361 1 “ " `` kim 361 2 The the DT kim 361 3 Dark Dark NNP kim 361 4 Secret Secret NNP kim 361 5 at at IN kim 361 6 the the DT kim 361 7 Heart heart NN kim 361 8 of of IN kim 361 9 AI AI NNP kim 361 10 . . . kim 361 11 ” " '' kim 361 12 MIT MIT NNP kim 361 13 Technology Technology NNP kim 361 14 Review Review NNP kim 361 15 , , , kim 361 16 April April NNP kim 361 17 11 11 CD kim 361 18 , , , kim 361 19 2017 2017 CD kim 361 20 . . . kim 361 21 https://www.technologyreview.com/2017/04/11/5113/the-dark-secret-at-the-heart-of-ai/. https://www.technologyreview.com/2017/04/11/5113/the-dark-secret-at-the-heart-of-ai/. CD kim 362 1 — — : kim 362 2 — — : kim 362 3 — — : kim 362 4 . . . kim 363 1 2019a 2019a CD kim 363 2 . . . kim 364 1 “ " `` kim 364 2 Two two CD kim 364 3 Rival rival JJ kim 364 4 AI AI NNP kim 364 5 Approaches approach NNS kim 364 6 Combine combine VBP kim 364 7 to to TO kim 364 8 Let let VB kim 364 9 Machines machine NNS kim 364 10 Learn learn VB kim 364 11 about about IN kim 364 12 the the DT kim 364 13 World World NNP kim 364 14 like like IN kim 364 15 a a DT kim 364 16 Child child NN kim 364 17 . . . kim 364 18 ” " '' kim 364 19 MIT MIT NNP kim 364 20 Technology Technology NNP kim 364 21 Review Review NNP kim 364 22 , , , kim 364 23 April April NNP kim 364 24 8 8 CD kim 364 25 , , , kim 364 26 2019 2019 CD kim 364 27 . . . kim 364 28 https://www.technologyreview.com/2019/04/08/103223/two-rival-ai-approaches-combine-to-let-machines-learn-about-the-world-like-a-child/. https://www.technologyreview.com/2019/04/08/103223/two-rival-ai-approaches-combine-to-let-machines-learn-about-the-world-like-a-child/. NNP kim 365 1 — — : kim 365 2 — — : kim 365 3 — — : kim 365 4 . . . kim 366 1 2019b 2019b CD kim 366 2 . . . kim 367 1 “ " `` kim 367 2 AI AI NNP kim 367 3 Is be VBZ kim 367 4 Biased bias VBN kim 367 5 . . . kim 368 1 Here here RB kim 368 2 ’s ’ VBZ kim 368 3 How how WRB kim 368 4 Scientists scientist NNS kim 368 5 Are be VBP kim 368 6 Trying try VBG kim 368 7 to to TO kim 368 8 Fix fix VB kim 368 9 It -PRON- PRP kim 368 10 . . . kim 368 11 ” " '' kim 368 12 Wired wire VBN kim 368 13 , , , kim 368 14 December December NNP kim 368 15 19 19 CD kim 368 16 , , , kim 368 17 2019 2019 CD kim 368 18 . . . kim 368 19 https://www.wired.com/story/ai-biased-how-scientists-trying-fix/. https://www.wired.com/story/ai-biased-how-scientists-trying-fix/. NNP kim 369 1 Koch Koch NNP kim 369 2 , , , kim 369 3 Christof Christof NNP kim 369 4 . . . kim 370 1 2016 2016 CD kim 370 2 . . . kim 371 1 “ " `` kim 371 2 How how WRB kim 371 3 the the DT kim 371 4 Computer Computer NNP kim 371 5 Beat beat VBP kim 371 6 the the DT kim 371 7 Go Go NNP kim 371 8 Master Master NNP kim 371 9 . . . kim 371 10 ” " '' kim 371 11 Scientific scientific JJ kim 371 12 American American NNP kim 371 13 . . . kim 372 1 March March NNP kim 372 2 19 19 CD kim 372 3 , , , kim 372 4 2016 2016 CD kim 372 5 . . . kim 372 6 https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-the-computer-beat-the-go-master/. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-the-computer-beat-the-go-master/. ADD kim 373 1 Le Le NNP kim 373 2 , , , kim 373 3 Quoc Quoc NNP kim 373 4 V. V. NNP kim 373 5 , , , kim 373 6 and and CC kim 373 7 Mike Mike NNP kim 373 8 Schuster Schuster NNP kim 373 9 . . . kim 374 1 2016 2016 CD kim 374 2 . . . kim 375 1 “ " `` kim 375 2 A a DT kim 375 3 Neural Neural NNP kim 375 4 Network Network NNP kim 375 5 for for IN kim 375 6 Machine Machine NNP kim 375 7 Translation Translation NNP kim 375 8 , , , kim 375 9 at at IN kim 375 10 Production Production NNP kim 375 11 Scale Scale NNP kim 375 12 . . . kim 375 13 ” " '' kim 375 14 Google Google NNP kim 375 15 AI AI NNP kim 375 16 Blog Blog NNP kim 375 17 ( ( -LRB- kim 375 18 blog blog NN kim 375 19 ) ) -RRB- kim 375 20 . . . kim 376 1 September September NNP kim 376 2 27 27 CD kim 376 3 , , , kim 376 4 2016 2016 CD kim 376 5 . . . kim 376 6 http://ai.googleblog.com/2016/09/a-neural-network-for-machine.html http://ai.googleblog.com/2016/09/a-neural-network-for-machine.html NNP kim 376 7 . . . kim 377 1 Lohr Lohr NNP kim 377 2 , , , kim 377 3 Steve Steve NNP kim 377 4 . . . kim 378 1 2018 2018 CD kim 378 2 . . . kim 379 1 “ " `` kim 379 2 Facial facial JJ kim 379 3 Recognition Recognition NNP kim 379 4 Is be VBZ kim 379 5 Accurate accurate JJ kim 379 6 , , , kim 379 7 If if IN kim 379 8 You -PRON- PRP kim 379 9 ’re be VBP kim 379 10 a a DT kim 379 11 White White NNP kim 379 12 Guy Guy NNP kim 379 13 . . . kim 379 14 ” " '' kim 379 15 New New NNP kim 379 16 York York NNP kim 379 17 Times Times NNP kim 379 18 , , , kim 379 19 February February NNP kim 379 20 9 9 CD kim 379 21 , , , kim 379 22 2018 2018 CD kim 379 23 . . . kim 379 24 https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/09/technology/facial-recognition-race-artificial-intelligence.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/09/technology/facial-recognition-race-artificial-intelligence.html NNP kim 379 25 . . . kim 380 1 Mahlangu Mahlangu NNP kim 380 2 , , , kim 380 3 Isaac Isaac NNP kim 380 4 . . . kim 381 1 2019 2019 CD kim 381 2 . . . kim 382 1 “ " `` kim 382 2 Meet Meet NNP kim 382 3 Libby Libby NNP kim 382 4 - - , kim 382 5 the the DT kim 382 6 New New NNP kim 382 7 Robot Robot NNP kim 382 8 Library Library NNP kim 382 9 Assistant Assistant NNP kim 382 10 at at IN kim 382 11 the the DT kim 382 12 University University NNP kim 382 13 of of IN kim 382 14 Pretoria Pretoria NNP kim 382 15 ’s ’s NNP kim 382 16 Hatfield Hatfield NNP kim 382 17 Campus Campus NNP kim 382 18 . . . kim 382 19 ” " '' kim 382 20 SowetanLIVE sowetanlive CD kim 382 21 . . . kim 383 1 June June NNP kim 383 2 4 4 CD kim 383 3 , , , kim 383 4 2019 2019 CD kim 383 5 . . . kim 383 6 https://www.sowetanlive.co.za/news/south-africa/2019-06-04-meet-libby-the-new-robot-library-assistant-at-the-university-of-pretorias-hatfield-campus/. https://www.sowetanlive.co.za/news/south-africa/2019-06-04-meet-libby-the-new-robot-library-assistant-at-the-university-of-pretorias-hatfield-campus/. . kim 384 1 Markoff Markoff NNP kim 384 2 , , , kim 384 3 John John NNP kim 384 4 . . . kim 385 1 2012 2012 CD kim 385 2 . . . kim 386 1 “ " `` kim 386 2 How how WRB kim 386 3 Many many JJ kim 386 4 Computers computer NNS kim 386 5 to to TO kim 386 6 Identify identify VB kim 386 7 a a DT kim 386 8 Cat cat NN kim 386 9 ? ? . kim 387 1 16,000 16,000 CD kim 387 2 . . . kim 387 3 ” " '' kim 387 4 New New NNP kim 387 5 York York NNP kim 387 6 Times Times NNP kim 387 7 , , , kim 387 8 June June NNP kim 387 9 25 25 CD kim 387 10 , , , kim 387 11 2012 2012 CD kim 387 12 . . . kim 388 1 Marr Marr NNP kim 388 2 , , , kim 388 3 Bernard Bernard NNP kim 388 4 . . . kim 389 1 2018 2018 CD kim 389 2 . . . kim 390 1 “ " `` kim 390 2 How how WRB kim 390 3 AI AI NNP kim 390 4 And and CC kim 390 5 Machine Machine NNP kim 390 6 Learning Learning NNP kim 390 7 Are be VBP kim 390 8 Transforming transform VBG kim 390 9 Law Law NNP kim 390 10 Firms firm NNS kim 390 11 And and CC kim 390 12 The the DT kim 390 13 Legal Legal NNP kim 390 14 Sector Sector NNP kim 390 15 . . . kim 390 16 ” " '' kim 390 17 Forbes Forbes NNP kim 390 18 , , , kim 390 19 May May NNP kim 390 20 23 23 CD kim 390 21 , , , kim 390 22 2018 2018 CD kim 390 23 . . . kim 390 24 https://www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2018/05/23/how-ai-and-machine-learning-are-transforming-law-firms-and-the-legal-sector/. https://www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2018/05/23/how-ai-and-machine-learning-are-transforming-law-firms-and-the-legal-sector/. NNP kim 391 1 Pariser Pariser NNP kim 391 2 , , , kim 391 3 Eli Eli NNP kim 391 4 . . . kim 392 1 2011 2011 CD kim 392 2 . . . kim 393 1 The the DT kim 393 2 Filter Filter NNP kim 393 3 Bubble bubble NN kim 393 4 : : : kim 393 5 How how WRB kim 393 6 the the DT kim 393 7 New New NNP kim 393 8 Personalized Personalized NNP kim 393 9 Web web NN kim 393 10 Is be VBZ kim 393 11 Changing change VBG kim 393 12 What what WP kim 393 13 We -PRON- PRP kim 393 14 Read read VBP kim 393 15 and and CC kim 393 16 How how WRB kim 393 17 We -PRON- PRP kim 393 18 Think think VBP kim 393 19 . . . kim 394 1 New New NNP kim 394 2 York York NNP kim 394 3 : : : kim 394 4 Penguin Penguin NNP kim 394 5 Press Press NNP kim 394 6 . . . kim 395 1 Porter Porter NNP kim 395 2 , , , kim 395 3 Jon Jon NNP kim 395 4 . . . kim 396 1 2018 2018 CD kim 396 2 . . . kim 397 1 “ " `` kim 397 2 The the DT kim 397 3 Pixel Pixel NNP kim 397 4 Buds Buds NNPS kim 397 5 ’ ’ POS kim 397 6 Translation translation NN kim 397 7 Feature feature NN kim 397 8 Is be VBZ kim 397 9 Coming come VBG kim 397 10 to to IN kim 397 11 All all DT kim 397 12 Headphones Headphones NNPS kim 397 13 with with IN kim 397 14 Google Google NNP kim 397 15 Assistant Assistant NNP kim 397 16 . . . kim 397 17 ” " '' kim 397 18 The the DT kim 397 19 Verge Verge NNP kim 397 20 . . . kim 398 1 October October NNP kim 398 2 15 15 CD kim 398 3 , , , kim 398 4 2018 2018 CD kim 398 5 . . . kim 398 6 https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2018/10/15/17978298/pixel-buds-google-translate-google-assistant-headphones https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2018/10/15/17978298/pixel-buds-google-translate-google-assistant-headphones NNP kim 398 7 . . . kim 399 1 Price price NN kim 399 2 , , , kim 399 3 Gary Gary NNP kim 399 4 . . . kim 400 1 2019 2019 CD kim 400 2 . . . kim 401 1 “ " `` kim 401 2 The the DT kim 401 3 Library Library NNP kim 401 4 of of IN kim 401 5 Congress Congress NNP kim 401 6 Posts Posts NNPS kim 401 7 Solicitation Solicitation NNP kim 401 8 For for IN kim 401 9 a a DT kim 401 10 Machine Machine NNP kim 401 11 Learning Learning NNP kim 401 12 / / SYM kim 401 13 Deep Deep NNP kim 401 14 Learning Learning NNP kim 401 15 Pilot Pilot NNP kim 401 16 Program Program NNP kim 401 17 to to TO kim 401 18 ‘ ' `` kim 401 19 Maximize maximize VB kim 401 20 the the DT kim 401 21 Use Use NNP kim 401 22 of of IN kim 401 23 Its -PRON- PRP$ kim 401 24 Digital Digital NNP kim 401 25 Collection Collection NNP kim 401 26 . . . kim 401 27 ’ ' '' kim 401 28 ” " '' kim 401 29 LJ LJ NNP kim 401 30 InfoDOCKET InfoDOCKET NNP kim 401 31 . . . kim 402 1 June June NNP kim 402 2 13 13 CD kim 402 3 , , , kim 402 4 2019 2019 CD kim 402 5 . . . kim 402 6 https://www.infodocket.com/2019/06/13/library-of-congress-posts-solicitation-for-a-machine-learning-deep-learning-pilot-program-to-maximize-the-use-of-its-digital-collection-library-is-looking-for-r/. https://www.infodocket.com/2019/06/13/library-of-congress-posts-solicitation-for-a-machine-learning-deep-learning-pilot-program-to-maximize-the-use-of-its-digital-collection-library-is-looking-for-r/. JJ kim 403 1 Sharkey Sharkey NNP kim 403 2 , , , kim 403 3 Noel Noel NNP kim 403 4 . . . kim 404 1 2012 2012 CD kim 404 2 . . . kim 405 1 “ " `` kim 405 2 Killing kill VBG kim 405 3 Made make VBN kim 405 4 Easy Easy NNP kim 405 5 : : : kim 405 6 From from IN kim 405 7 Joysticks Joysticks NNP kim 405 8 to to IN kim 405 9 Politics politic NNS kim 405 10 . . . kim 405 11 ” " '' kim 405 12 In in IN kim 405 13 Robot Robot NNP kim 405 14 Ethics Ethics NNP kim 405 15 : : : kim 405 16 The the DT kim 405 17 Ethical Ethical NNP kim 405 18 and and CC kim 405 19 Social Social NNP kim 405 20 Implications Implications NNPS kim 405 21 of of IN kim 405 22 Robotics Robotics NNPS kim 405 23 , , , kim 405 24 edited edit VBN kim 405 25 by by IN kim 405 26 Patrick Patrick NNP kim 405 27 Lin Lin NNP kim 405 28 , , , kim 405 29 Keith Keith NNP kim 405 30 Abney Abney NNP kim 405 31 , , , kim 405 32 and and CC kim 405 33 George George NNP kim 405 34 A. A. NNP kim 405 35 Bekey Bekey NNP kim 405 36 , , , kim 405 37 111–28 111–28 CD kim 405 38 . . . kim 406 1 Intelligent intelligent JJ kim 406 2 Robotics Robotics NNPS kim 406 3 and and CC kim 406 4 Autonomous Autonomous NNP kim 406 5 Agents Agents NNPS kim 406 6 . . . kim 407 1 Cambridge Cambridge NNP kim 407 2 , , , kim 407 3 Mass. Massachusetts NNP kim 408 1 : : : kim 408 2 MIT MIT NNP kim 408 3 Press Press NNP kim 408 4 .. .. . kim 408 5 Singer singer NN kim 408 6 , , , kim 408 7 Peter Peter NNP kim 408 8 . . . kim 409 1 2005 2005 CD kim 409 2 . . . kim 410 1 “ " `` kim 410 2 Ethics Ethics NNPS kim 410 3 and and CC kim 410 4 Intuitions Intuitions NNPS kim 410 5 . . . kim 410 6 ” " '' kim 410 7 The the DT kim 410 8 Journal Journal NNP kim 410 9 of of IN kim 410 10 Ethics Ethics NNP kim 410 11 9 9 CD kim 410 12 ( ( -LRB- kim 410 13 3/4 3/4 CD kim 410 14 ) ) -RRB- kim 410 15 : : : kim 410 16 331–52 331–52 CD kim 410 17 . . . kim 411 1 Sinnott Sinnott NNP kim 411 2 - - HYPH kim 411 3 Armstrong Armstrong NNP kim 411 4 , , , kim 411 5 Walter Walter NNP kim 411 6 . . . kim 412 1 2019 2019 CD kim 412 2 . . . kim 413 1 “ " `` kim 413 2 Consequentialism consequentialism NN kim 413 3 . . . kim 413 4 ” " '' kim 413 5 In in IN kim 413 6 The the DT kim 413 7 Stanford Stanford NNP kim 413 8 Encyclopedia Encyclopedia NNP kim 413 9 of of IN kim 413 10 Philosophy Philosophy NNP kim 413 11 , , , kim 413 12 edited edit VBN kim 413 13 by by IN kim 413 14 Edward Edward NNP kim 413 15 N. N. NNP kim 413 16 Zalta Zalta NNP kim 413 17 , , , kim 413 18 Summer Summer NNP kim 413 19 2019 2019 CD kim 413 20 . . . kim 414 1 Metaphysics Metaphysics NNP kim 414 2 Research Research NNP kim 414 3 Lab Lab NNP kim 414 4 , , , kim 414 5 Stanford Stanford NNP kim 414 6 University University NNP kim 414 7 . . . kim 415 1 https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2019/entries/consequentialism/. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2019/entries/consequentialism/. ADD kim 416 1 Stanley Stanley NNP kim 416 2 , , , kim 416 3 Jay Jay NNP kim 416 4 . . . kim 417 1 2017 2017 CD kim 417 2 . . . kim 418 1 “ " `` kim 418 2 Pitfalls pitfall NNS kim 418 3 of of IN kim 418 4 Artificial Artificial NNP kim 418 5 Intelligence Intelligence NNP kim 418 6 Decisionmaking Decisionmaking NNP kim 418 7 Highlighted highlight VBN kim 418 8 In in IN kim 418 9 Idaho Idaho NNP kim 418 10 ACLU ACLU NNP kim 418 11 Case Case NNP kim 418 12 . . . kim 418 13 ” " '' kim 418 14 American American NNP kim 418 15 Civil Civil NNP kim 418 16 Liberties Liberties NNPS kim 418 17 Union Union NNP kim 418 18 ( ( -LRB- kim 418 19 blog blog NN kim 418 20 ) ) -RRB- kim 418 21 . . . kim 419 1 June June NNP kim 419 2 2 2 CD kim 419 3 , , , kim 419 4 2017 2017 CD kim 419 5 . . . kim 419 6 https://www.aclu.org/blog/privacy-technology/pitfalls-artificial-intelligence-decisionmaking-highlighted-idaho-aclu-case https://www.aclu.org/blog/privacy-technology/pitfalls-artificial-intelligence-decisionmaking-highlighted-idaho-aclu-case NNS kim 419 7 . . . kim 420 1 Talley Talley NNP kim 420 2 , , , kim 420 3 Nancy Nancy NNP kim 420 4 B. B. NNP kim 421 1 2016 2016 CD kim 421 2 . . . kim 422 1 “ " `` kim 422 2 Imagining imagine VBG kim 422 3 the the DT kim 422 4 Use Use NNP kim 422 5 of of IN kim 422 6 Intelligent Intelligent NNP kim 422 7 Agents Agents NNPS kim 422 8 and and CC kim 422 9 Artificial Artificial NNP kim 422 10 Intelligence Intelligence NNP kim 422 11 in in IN kim 422 12 Academic Academic NNP kim 422 13 Law Law NNP kim 422 14 Libraries Libraries NNPS kim 422 15 . . . kim 422 16 ” " '' kim 422 17 Law Law NNP kim 422 18 Library Library NNP kim 422 19 Journal Journal NNP kim 422 20 108 108 CD kim 422 21 ( ( -LRB- kim 422 22 3 3 CD kim 422 23 ) ) -RRB- kim 422 24 : : : kim 422 25 383–402 383–402 CD kim 422 26 . . . kim 423 1 Tashea Tashea NNP kim 423 2 , , , kim 423 3 Jason Jason NNP kim 423 4 . . . kim 424 1 2017 2017 CD kim 424 2 . . . kim 425 1 “ " `` kim 425 2 Courts court NNS kim 425 3 Are be VBP kim 425 4 Using use VBG kim 425 5 AI ai NN kim 425 6 to to IN kim 425 7 Sentence Sentence NNP kim 425 8 Criminals Criminals NNPS kim 425 9 . . . kim 426 1 That that DT kim 426 2 Must Must MD kim 426 3 Stop stop VB kim 426 4 Now now RB kim 426 5 . . . kim 426 6 ” " '' kim 426 7 Wired wire VBN kim 426 8 , , , kim 426 9 April April NNP kim 426 10 17 17 CD kim 426 11 , , , kim 426 12 2017 2017 CD kim 426 13 . . . kim 426 14 https://www.wired.com/2017/04/courts-using-ai-sentence-criminals-must-stop-now/. https://www.wired.com/2017/04/courts-using-ai-sentence-criminals-must-stop-now/. CD kim 427 1 Tegmark Tegmark NNP kim 427 2 , , , kim 427 3 Max Max NNP kim 427 4 . . . kim 428 1 2017 2017 CD kim 428 2 . . . kim 429 1 Life life NN kim 429 2 3.0 3.0 CD kim 429 3 : : : kim 429 4 Being be VBG kim 429 5 Human human NN kim 429 6 in in IN kim 429 7 the the DT kim 429 8 Age Age NNP kim 429 9 of of IN kim 429 10 Artificial Artificial NNP kim 429 11 Intelligence Intelligence NNP kim 429 12 . . . kim 430 1 New New NNP kim 430 2 York York NNP kim 430 3 : : : kim 430 4 Alfred Alfred NNP kim 430 5 Knopf Knopf NNP kim 430 6 . . . kim 431 1 Thomson Thomson NNP kim 431 2 , , , kim 431 3 Judith Judith NNP kim 431 4 Jarvis Jarvis NNP kim 431 5 . . . kim 432 1 1976 1976 CD kim 432 2 . . . kim 433 1 “ " `` kim 433 2 Killing kill VBG kim 433 3 , , , kim 433 4 Letting Letting NNP kim 433 5 Die Die NNP kim 433 6 , , , kim 433 7 and and CC kim 433 8 the the DT kim 433 9 Trolley Trolley NNP kim 433 10 Problem Problem NNP kim 433 11 . . . kim 433 12 ” " '' kim 433 13 The the DT kim 433 14 Monist Monist NNP kim 433 15 59 59 CD kim 433 16 ( ( -LRB- kim 433 17 2 2 CD kim 433 18 ) ) -RRB- kim 433 19 : : : kim 433 20 204–17 204–17 CD kim 433 21 . . . kim 434 1 Turek Turek NNP kim 434 2 , , , kim 434 3 Matt Matt NNP kim 434 4 . . . kim 435 1 n.d n.d NNP kim 435 2 . . . kim 435 3 “ " `` kim 435 4 Explainable Explainable NNP kim 435 5 Artificial Artificial NNP kim 435 6 Intelligence Intelligence NNP kim 435 7 . . . kim 435 8 ” " '' kim 435 9 Defense Defense NNP kim 435 10 Advanced Advanced NNP kim 435 11 Research Research NNP kim 435 12 Projects Projects NNPS kim 435 13 Agency Agency NNP kim 435 14 . . . kim 436 1 https://www.darpa.mil/program/explainable-artificial-intelligence https://www.darpa.mil/program/explainable-artificial-intelligence NNP kim 436 2 . . . kim 437 1 Vallor Vallor NNP kim 437 2 , , , kim 437 3 Shannon Shannon NNP kim 437 4 . . . kim 438 1 2015 2015 CD kim 438 2 . . . kim 439 1 “ " `` kim 439 2 Moral Moral NNP kim 439 3 Deskilling Deskilling NNP kim 439 4 and and CC kim 439 5 Upskilling upskille VBG kim 439 6 in in IN kim 439 7 a a DT kim 439 8 New New NNP kim 439 9 Machine Machine NNP kim 439 10 Age Age NNP kim 439 11 : : : kim 439 12 Reflections reflection NNS kim 439 13 on on IN kim 439 14 the the DT kim 439 15 Ambiguous ambiguous JJ kim 439 16 Future Future NNP kim 439 17 of of IN kim 439 18 Character Character NNP kim 439 19 . . . kim 439 20 ” " '' kim 439 21 Philosophy Philosophy NNP kim 439 22 & & CC kim 439 23 Technology Technology NNP kim 439 24 28 28 CD kim 439 25 ( ( -LRB- kim 439 26 1 1 CD kim 439 27 ) ) -RRB- kim 439 28 : : : kim 439 29 107–24 107–24 CD kim 439 30 . . . kim 440 1 https://doi.org/10.1007/s13347-014-0156-9 https://doi.org/10.1007/s13347-014-0156-9 CD kim 440 2 . . . kim 441 1 Wallach Wallach NNP kim 441 2 , , , kim 441 3 Wendell Wendell NNP kim 441 4 . . . kim 442 1 2009 2009 CD kim 442 2 . . . kim 443 1 Moral Moral NNP kim 443 2 Machines Machines NNPS kim 443 3 Teaching Teaching NNP kim 443 4 Robots Robots NNP kim 443 5 Right right RB kim 443 6 from from IN kim 443 7 Wrong wrong NN kim 443 8 . . . kim 444 1 Oxford Oxford NNP kim 444 2 : : : kim 444 3 University University NNP kim 444 4 Press Press NNP kim 444 5 . . . kim 445 1 Welch Welch NNP kim 445 2 , , , kim 445 3 Chris Chris NNP kim 445 4 . . . kim 446 1 2018 2018 CD kim 446 2 . . . kim 447 1 “ " `` kim 447 2 Google Google NNP kim 447 3 Just just RB kim 447 4 Gave give VBD kim 447 5 a a DT kim 447 6 Stunning Stunning NNP kim 447 7 Demo Demo NNP kim 447 8 of of IN kim 447 9 Assistant Assistant NNP kim 447 10 Making make VBG kim 447 11 an an DT kim 447 12 Actual actual JJ kim 447 13 Phone Phone NNP kim 447 14 Call call NN kim 447 15 . . . kim 447 16 ” " '' kim 447 17 The the DT kim 447 18 Verge Verge NNP kim 447 19 . . . kim 448 1 May May NNP kim 448 2 8 8 CD kim 448 3 , , , kim 448 4 2018 2018 CD kim 448 5 . . . kim 448 6 https://www.theverge.com/2018/5/8/17332070/google-assistant-makes-phone-call-demo-duplex-io-2018 https://www.theverge.com/2018/5/8/17332070/google-assistant-makes-phone-call-demo-duplex-io-2018 NNP kim 448 7 . . .