id sid tid token lemma pos 37350 1 1 University University NNP 37350 1 2 of of IN 37350 1 3 Kansas Kansas NNP 37350 1 4 Publications Publications NNPS 37350 1 5 Museum Museum NNP 37350 1 6 of of IN 37350 1 7 Natural Natural NNP 37350 1 8 History History NNP 37350 1 9 Volume Volume NNP 37350 1 10 12 12 CD 37350 1 11 , , , 37350 1 12 No no UH 37350 1 13 . . . 37350 2 1 2 2 CD 37350 2 2 , , , 37350 2 3 pp pp NNP 37350 2 4 . . . 37350 3 1 155 155 CD 37350 3 2 - - SYM 37350 3 3 180 180 CD 37350 3 4 , , , 37350 3 5 10 10 CD 37350 3 6 figs fig NNS 37350 3 7 . . . 37350 4 1 -----------July -----------July : 37350 4 2 10 10 CD 37350 4 3 , , , 37350 4 4 1959 1959 CD 37350 4 5 - - SYM 37350 4 6 -------------- -------------- NFP 37350 4 7 The the DT 37350 4 8 Ancestry Ancestry NNP 37350 4 9 of of IN 37350 4 10 Modern Modern NNP 37350 4 11 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 4 12 : : : 37350 4 13 A a DT 37350 4 14 Review Review NNP 37350 4 15 of of IN 37350 4 16 the the DT 37350 4 17 Evidence Evidence NNP 37350 4 18 BY by IN 37350 4 19 THEODORE THEODORE NNP 37350 4 20 H. H. NNP 37350 4 21 EATON EATON NNP 37350 4 22 , , , 37350 4 23 JR JR NNP 37350 4 24 . . . 37350 4 25 University University NNP 37350 4 26 of of IN 37350 4 27 Kansas Kansas NNP 37350 4 28 Lawrence Lawrence NNP 37350 4 29 1959 1959 CD 37350 4 30 University University NNP 37350 4 31 of of IN 37350 4 32 Kansas Kansas NNP 37350 4 33 Publications Publications NNP 37350 4 34 , , , 37350 4 35 Museum Museum NNP 37350 4 36 of of IN 37350 4 37 Natural Natural NNP 37350 4 38 History History NNP 37350 4 39 Editors Editors NNPS 37350 4 40 : : : 37350 4 41 E. E. NNP 37350 4 42 Raymond Raymond NNP 37350 4 43 Hall Hall NNP 37350 4 44 , , , 37350 4 45 Chairman Chairman NNP 37350 4 46 , , , 37350 4 47 Henry Henry NNP 37350 4 48 S. S. NNP 37350 4 49 Fitch Fitch NNP 37350 4 50 , , , 37350 4 51 Robert Robert NNP 37350 4 52 W. W. NNP 37350 4 53 Wilson Wilson NNP 37350 4 54 Volume Volume NNP 37350 4 55 12 12 CD 37350 4 56 , , , 37350 4 57 No no UH 37350 4 58 . . . 37350 5 1 2 2 CD 37350 5 2 , , , 37350 5 3 pp pp NNP 37350 5 4 . . . 37350 6 1 155 155 CD 37350 6 2 - - SYM 37350 6 3 180 180 CD 37350 6 4 Published publish VBN 37350 6 5 July July NNP 37350 6 6 10 10 CD 37350 6 7 , , , 37350 6 8 1959 1959 CD 37350 6 9 University University NNP 37350 6 10 of of IN 37350 6 11 Kansas Kansas NNP 37350 6 12 Lawrence Lawrence NNP 37350 6 13 , , , 37350 6 14 Kansas Kansas NNP 37350 6 15 PRINTED print VBD 37350 6 16 IN in IN 37350 6 17 THE the DT 37350 6 18 STATE STATE NNP 37350 6 19 PRINTING printing NN 37350 6 20 PLANT PLANT NNP 37350 6 21 TOPEKA TOPEKA NNP 37350 6 22 , , , 37350 6 23 KANSAS KANSAS NNP 37350 6 24 1959 1959 CD 37350 6 25 [ [ -LRB- 37350 6 26 Illustration illustration NN 37350 6 27 ] ] -RRB- 37350 6 28 27 27 CD 37350 6 29 - - HYPH 37350 6 30 8362 8362 CD 37350 6 31 [ [ -LRB- 37350 6 32 Transcriber Transcriber NNP 37350 6 33 's 's POS 37350 6 34 Notes note NNS 37350 6 35 : : : 37350 6 36 Several several JJ 37350 6 37 typos typo NNS 37350 6 38 have have VBP 37350 6 39 been be VBN 37350 6 40 regulated regulate VBN 37350 6 41 . . . 37350 7 1 One one CD 37350 7 2 typo typo NN 37350 7 3 of of IN 37350 7 4 " " `` 37350 7 5 ancester ancester NN 37350 7 6 " " '' 37350 7 7 for for IN 37350 7 8 " " `` 37350 7 9 ancestor ancestor NN 37350 7 10 " " '' 37350 7 11 was be VBD 37350 7 12 corrected correct VBN 37350 7 13 . . . 37350 8 1 One one CD 37350 8 2 instance instance NN 37350 8 3 of of IN 37350 8 4 " " `` 37350 8 5 salamanderlike salamanderlike NN 37350 8 6 " " '' 37350 8 7 corrected correct VBN 37350 8 8 to to TO 37350 8 9 " " `` 37350 8 10 salamaner salamaner VB 37350 8 11 - - HYPH 37350 8 12 like like JJ 37350 8 13 " " '' 37350 8 14 . . . 37350 8 15 ] ] -RRB- 37350 9 1 The the DT 37350 9 2 Ancestry Ancestry NNP 37350 9 3 of of IN 37350 9 4 Modern Modern NNP 37350 9 5 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 9 6 : : : 37350 9 7 A a DT 37350 9 8 Review Review NNP 37350 9 9 of of IN 37350 9 10 the the DT 37350 9 11 Evidence Evidence NNP 37350 9 12 BY by IN 37350 9 13 THEODORE THEODORE NNP 37350 9 14 H. H. NNP 37350 9 15 EATON EATON NNP 37350 9 16 , , , 37350 9 17 JR JR NNP 37350 9 18 . . . 37350 9 19 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION NNP 37350 9 20 In in IN 37350 9 21 trying try VBG 37350 9 22 to to TO 37350 9 23 determine determine VB 37350 9 24 the the DT 37350 9 25 ancestral ancestral JJ 37350 9 26 relationships relationship NNS 37350 9 27 of of IN 37350 9 28 modern modern JJ 37350 9 29 orders order NNS 37350 9 30 of of IN 37350 9 31 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 9 32 it -PRON- PRP 37350 9 33 is be VBZ 37350 9 34 not not RB 37350 9 35 possible possible JJ 37350 9 36 to to TO 37350 9 37 select select VB 37350 9 38 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 37350 9 39 structural structural JJ 37350 9 40 ancestors ancestor NNS 37350 9 41 among among IN 37350 9 42 a a DT 37350 9 43 wealth wealth NN 37350 9 44 of of IN 37350 9 45 fossils fossil NNS 37350 9 46 , , , 37350 9 47 since since IN 37350 9 48 very very RB 37350 9 49 few few JJ 37350 9 50 of of IN 37350 9 51 the the DT 37350 9 52 known know VBN 37350 9 53 fossils fossil NNS 37350 9 54 could could MD 37350 9 55 even even RB 37350 9 56 be be VB 37350 9 57 considered consider VBN 37350 9 58 possible possible JJ 37350 9 59 , , , 37350 9 60 and and CC 37350 9 61 scarcely scarcely RB 37350 9 62 any any DT 37350 9 63 are be VBP 37350 9 64 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 37350 9 65 , , , 37350 9 66 for for IN 37350 9 67 such such PDT 37350 9 68 a a DT 37350 9 69 selection selection NN 37350 9 70 . . . 37350 10 1 The the DT 37350 10 2 nearest near JJS 37350 10 3 approach approach NN 37350 10 4 thus thus RB 37350 10 5 far far RB 37350 10 6 to to IN 37350 10 7 a a DT 37350 10 8 solution solution NN 37350 10 9 of of IN 37350 10 10 the the DT 37350 10 11 problem problem NN 37350 10 12 in in IN 37350 10 13 this this DT 37350 10 14 manner manner NN 37350 10 15 has have VBZ 37350 10 16 been be VBN 37350 10 17 made make VBN 37350 10 18 with with IN 37350 10 19 reference reference NN 37350 10 20 to to IN 37350 10 21 the the DT 37350 10 22 Anura Anura NNP 37350 10 23 . . . 37350 11 1 Watson Watson NNP 37350 11 2 's 's POS 37350 11 3 paper paper NN 37350 11 4 ( ( -LRB- 37350 11 5 1940 1940 CD 37350 11 6 ) ) -RRB- 37350 11 7 , , , 37350 11 8 with with IN 37350 11 9 certain certain JJ 37350 11 10 modifications modification NNS 37350 11 11 made make VBD 37350 11 12 necessary necessary JJ 37350 11 13 by by IN 37350 11 14 Gregory Gregory NNP 37350 11 15 ( ( -LRB- 37350 11 16 1950 1950 CD 37350 11 17 ) ) -RRB- 37350 11 18 , , , 37350 11 19 provides provide VBZ 37350 11 20 the the DT 37350 11 21 paleontological paleontological JJ 37350 11 22 evidence evidence NN 37350 11 23 so so RB 37350 11 24 far far RB 37350 11 25 available available JJ 37350 11 26 on on IN 37350 11 27 the the DT 37350 11 28 origin origin NN 37350 11 29 of of IN 37350 11 30 frogs frog NNS 37350 11 31 . . . 37350 12 1 It -PRON- PRP 37350 12 2 shows show VBZ 37350 12 3 that that IN 37350 12 4 several several JJ 37350 12 5 features feature NNS 37350 12 6 of of IN 37350 12 7 the the DT 37350 12 8 skeleton skeleton NN 37350 12 9 of of IN 37350 12 10 frogs frog NNS 37350 12 11 , , , 37350 12 12 such such JJ 37350 12 13 as as IN 37350 12 14 the the DT 37350 12 15 enlargement enlargement NN 37350 12 16 of of IN 37350 12 17 the the DT 37350 12 18 interpterygoid interpterygoid JJ 37350 12 19 spaces space NNS 37350 12 20 and and CC 37350 12 21 orbits orbit NNS 37350 12 22 , , , 37350 12 23 reduction reduction NN 37350 12 24 of of IN 37350 12 25 the the DT 37350 12 26 more more RBR 37350 12 27 posterior posterior JJ 37350 12 28 dermal dermal JJ 37350 12 29 bones bone NNS 37350 12 30 of of IN 37350 12 31 the the DT 37350 12 32 skull skull NN 37350 12 33 , , , 37350 12 34 and and CC 37350 12 35 downward downward JJ 37350 12 36 spread spread NN 37350 12 37 of of IN 37350 12 38 the the DT 37350 12 39 neural neural JJ 37350 12 40 arches arch NNS 37350 12 41 lateral lateral JJ 37350 12 42 to to IN 37350 12 43 the the DT 37350 12 44 notochord notochord NN 37350 12 45 , , , 37350 12 46 were be VBD 37350 12 47 already already RB 37350 12 48 apparent apparent JJ 37350 12 49 in in IN 37350 12 50 the the DT 37350 12 51 Pennsylvanian Pennsylvanian NNP 37350 12 52 _ _ NNP 37350 12 53 Amphibamus Amphibamus NNP 37350 12 54 _ _ NNP 37350 12 55 ( ( -LRB- 37350 12 56 Fig Fig NNP 37350 12 57 . . . 37350 13 1 1 1 LS 37350 13 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 13 3 , , , 37350 13 4 with with IN 37350 13 5 which which WDT 37350 13 6 Gregory Gregory NNP 37350 13 7 synonymized synonymize VBD 37350 13 8 _ _ NNP 37350 13 9 Miobatrachus Miobatrachus NNP 37350 13 10 _ _ NNP 37350 13 11 and and CC 37350 13 12 _ _ NNP 37350 13 13 Mazonerpeton Mazonerpeton NNP 37350 13 14 _ _ NNP 37350 13 15 . . . 37350 14 1 But but CC 37350 14 2 between between IN 37350 14 3 the the DT 37350 14 4 Pennsylvanian pennsylvanian JJ 37350 14 5 and and CC 37350 14 6 the the DT 37350 14 7 Triassic Triassic NNP 37350 14 8 ( ( -LRB- 37350 14 9 the the DT 37350 14 10 age age NN 37350 14 11 of of IN 37350 14 12 the the DT 37350 14 13 earliest early JJS 37350 14 14 known know VBN 37350 14 15 frog frog NN 37350 14 16 , , , 37350 14 17 _ _ NNP 37350 14 18 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 14 19 _ _ NNP 37350 14 20 ) ) -RRB- 37350 14 21 there there EX 37350 14 22 was be VBD 37350 14 23 a a DT 37350 14 24 great great JJ 37350 14 25 lapse lapse NN 37350 14 26 of of IN 37350 14 27 time time NN 37350 14 28 , , , 37350 14 29 and and CC 37350 14 30 that that IN 37350 14 31 which which WDT 37350 14 32 passed pass VBD 37350 14 33 between between IN 37350 14 34 any any DT 37350 14 35 conceivable conceivable JJ 37350 14 36 Paleozoic paleozoic JJ 37350 14 37 ancestor ancestor NN 37350 14 38 of of IN 37350 14 39 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 14 40 and and CC 37350 14 41 the the DT 37350 14 42 earliest early JJS 37350 14 43 satisfactory satisfactory JJ 37350 14 44 representative representative NN 37350 14 45 of of IN 37350 14 46 this this DT 37350 14 47 order order NN 37350 14 48 ( ( -LRB- 37350 14 49 in in IN 37350 14 50 the the DT 37350 14 51 Cretaceous Cretaceous NNP 37350 14 52 ) ) -RRB- 37350 14 53 was be VBD 37350 14 54 much much RB 37350 14 55 longer long JJR 37350 14 56 still still RB 37350 14 57 . . . 37350 15 1 The the DT 37350 15 2 Apoda Apoda NNP 37350 15 3 , , , 37350 15 4 so so RB 37350 15 5 far far RB 37350 15 6 as as IN 37350 15 7 known know VBN 37350 15 8 , , , 37350 15 9 have have VBP 37350 15 10 no no DT 37350 15 11 fossil fossil NN 37350 15 12 record record NN 37350 15 13 . . . 37350 16 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 37350 16 2 it -PRON- PRP 37350 16 3 should should MD 37350 16 4 be be VB 37350 16 5 possible possible JJ 37350 16 6 , , , 37350 16 7 first first RB 37350 16 8 , , , 37350 16 9 to to TO 37350 16 10 survey survey VB 37350 16 11 those those DT 37350 16 12 characters character NNS 37350 16 13 of of IN 37350 16 14 modern modern JJ 37350 16 15 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 16 16 that that WDT 37350 16 17 might may MD 37350 16 18 afford afford VB 37350 16 19 some some DT 37350 16 20 comparison comparison NN 37350 16 21 with with IN 37350 16 22 the the DT 37350 16 23 early early JJ 37350 16 24 fossils fossil NNS 37350 16 25 , , , 37350 16 26 and and CC 37350 16 27 second second RB 37350 16 28 , , , 37350 16 29 to to TO 37350 16 30 discover discover VB 37350 16 31 among among IN 37350 16 32 the the DT 37350 16 33 known know VBN 37350 16 34 Paleozoic paleozoic JJ 37350 16 35 kinds kind NNS 37350 16 36 those those DT 37350 16 37 which which WDT 37350 16 38 are be VBP 37350 16 39 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37350 16 40 unspecialized unspecialized JJ 37350 16 41 to to TO 37350 16 42 permit permit VB 37350 16 43 derivation derivation NN 37350 16 44 of of IN 37350 16 45 the the DT 37350 16 46 modern modern JJ 37350 16 47 patterns pattern NNS 37350 16 48 . . . 37350 17 1 Further further JJ 37350 17 2 circumstantial circumstantial JJ 37350 17 3 evidence evidence NN 37350 17 4 may may MD 37350 17 5 be be VB 37350 17 6 obtained obtain VBN 37350 17 7 by by IN 37350 17 8 examining examine VBG 37350 17 9 some some DT 37350 17 10 features feature NNS 37350 17 11 of of IN 37350 17 12 Recent Recent NNP 37350 17 13 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 17 14 which which WDT 37350 17 15 could could MD 37350 17 16 not not RB 37350 17 17 readily readily RB 37350 17 18 be be VB 37350 17 19 compared compare VBN 37350 17 20 with with IN 37350 17 21 anything anything NN 37350 17 22 in in IN 37350 17 23 the the DT 37350 17 24 fossils fossil NNS 37350 17 25 ; ; : 37350 17 26 such such JJ 37350 17 27 are be VBP 37350 17 28 the the DT 37350 17 29 embryonic embryonic JJ 37350 17 30 development development NN 37350 17 31 of of IN 37350 17 32 the the DT 37350 17 33 soft soft JJ 37350 17 34 structures structure NNS 37350 17 35 , , , 37350 17 36 including include VBG 37350 17 37 cartilaginous cartilaginous JJ 37350 17 38 stages stage NNS 37350 17 39 of of IN 37350 17 40 the the DT 37350 17 41 skeleton skeleton NN 37350 17 42 , , , 37350 17 43 the the DT 37350 17 44 development development NN 37350 17 45 and and CC 37350 17 46 various various JJ 37350 17 47 specializations specialization NNS 37350 17 48 of of IN 37350 17 49 the the DT 37350 17 50 ear ear NN 37350 17 51 mechanism mechanism NN 37350 17 52 , , , 37350 17 53 adaptive adaptive JJ 37350 17 54 characters character NNS 37350 17 55 associated associate VBN 37350 17 56 with with IN 37350 17 57 aquatic aquatic JJ 37350 17 58 and and CC 37350 17 59 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37350 17 60 life life NN 37350 17 61 , , , 37350 17 62 and and CC 37350 17 63 so so RB 37350 17 64 on on RB 37350 17 65 . . . 37350 18 1 COMPARISON comparison NN 37350 18 2 OF of IN 37350 18 3 MODERN MODERN NNS 37350 18 4 ORDERS order NNS 37350 18 5 WITH with IN 37350 18 6 THE the DT 37350 18 7 LABYRINTHODONTS labyrinthodont NNS 37350 18 8 AND and CC 37350 18 9 LEPOSPONDYLS LEPOSPONDYLS NNP 37350 18 10 [ [ -LRB- 37350 18 11 Illustration illustration NN 37350 18 12 : : : 37350 18 13 Fig Fig NNP 37350 18 14 . . . 37350 19 1 1 1 LS 37350 19 2 . . . 37350 20 1 _ _ NNP 37350 20 2 Saurerpeton Saurerpeton NNP 37350 20 3 _ _ NNP 37350 20 4 ( ( -LRB- 37350 20 5 × × NN 37350 20 6 1/2 1/2 CD 37350 20 7 , , , 37350 20 8 after after IN 37350 20 9 Romer Romer NNP 37350 20 10 , , , 37350 20 11 1930 1930 CD 37350 20 12 , , , 37350 20 13 fig fig NN 37350 20 14 . . . 37350 21 1 6 6 CD 37350 21 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 21 3 ; ; : 37350 21 4 _ _ NNP 37350 21 5 Amphibamus Amphibamus NNP 37350 21 6 _ _ NNP 37350 21 7 , , , 37350 21 8 the the DT 37350 21 9 palatal palatal JJ 37350 21 10 view view NN 37350 21 11 × × NNP 37350 21 12 2 2 CD 37350 21 13 - - SYM 37350 21 14 1/4 1/4 CD 37350 21 15 , , , 37350 21 16 from from IN 37350 21 17 Watson Watson NNP 37350 21 18 , , , 37350 21 19 1940 1940 CD 37350 21 20 , , , 37350 21 21 fig fig NN 37350 21 22 . . . 37350 22 1 4 4 LS 37350 22 2 ( ( -LRB- 37350 22 3 as as IN 37350 22 4 _ _ NNP 37350 22 5 Miobatrachus Miobatrachus NNP 37350 22 6 _ _ NNP 37350 22 7 ) ) -RRB- 37350 22 8 , , , 37350 22 9 the the DT 37350 22 10 dorsal dorsal NN 37350 22 11 view view NN 37350 22 12 × × ADD 37350 22 13 2 2 CD 37350 22 14 - - SYM 37350 22 15 1/2 1/2 CD 37350 22 16 , , , 37350 22 17 from from IN 37350 22 18 Gregory Gregory NNP 37350 22 19 's 's POS 37350 22 20 revised revised JJ 37350 22 21 figure figure NN 37350 22 22 of of IN 37350 22 23 _ _ NNP 37350 22 24 Amphibamus Amphibamus NNP 37350 22 25 _ _ NNP 37350 22 26 ( ( -LRB- 37350 22 27 1950 1950 CD 37350 22 28 , , , 37350 22 29 Fig Fig NNP 37350 22 30 . . . 37350 23 1 1 1 LS 37350 23 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 23 3 ; ; : 37350 23 4 _ _ NNP 37350 23 5 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 23 6 _ _ NNP 37350 23 7 , , , 37350 23 8 × × NN 37350 23 9 1 1 CD 37350 23 10 , , , 37350 23 11 from from IN 37350 23 12 Watson Watson NNP 37350 23 13 , , , 37350 23 14 1940 1940 CD 37350 23 15 , , , 37350 23 16 fig fig NN 37350 23 17 . . . 37350 24 1 18 18 CD 37350 24 2 , , , 37350 24 3 19 19 CD 37350 24 4 . . . 37350 24 5 ] ] -RRB- 37350 25 1 In in IN 37350 25 2 both both CC 37350 25 3 Anura Anura NNP 37350 25 4 and and CC 37350 25 5 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 25 6 the the DT 37350 25 7 skull skull NN 37350 25 8 is be VBZ 37350 25 9 short short JJ 37350 25 10 , , , 37350 25 11 broad broad JJ 37350 25 12 , , , 37350 25 13 relatively relatively RB 37350 25 14 flat flat JJ 37350 25 15 , , , 37350 25 16 with with IN 37350 25 17 reduced reduced JJ 37350 25 18 pterygoids pterygoid NNS 37350 25 19 that that WDT 37350 25 20 diverge diverge VBP 37350 25 21 laterally laterally RB 37350 25 22 from from IN 37350 25 23 the the DT 37350 25 24 parasphenoids parasphenoid NNS 37350 25 25 leaving leave VBG 37350 25 26 large large JJ 37350 25 27 interpterygoid interpterygoid JJ 37350 25 28 vacuities vacuity NNS 37350 25 29 , , , 37350 25 30 and and CC 37350 25 31 with with IN 37350 25 32 large large JJ 37350 25 33 orbits orbit NNS 37350 25 34 . . . 37350 26 1 ( ( -LRB- 37350 26 2 These these DT 37350 26 3 statements statement NNS 37350 26 4 do do VBP 37350 26 5 not not RB 37350 26 6 apply apply VB 37350 26 7 to to IN 37350 26 8 certain certain JJ 37350 26 9 larval larval NN 37350 26 10 or or CC 37350 26 11 perennibranchiate perennibranchiate VB 37350 26 12 forms form NNS 37350 26 13 . . . 37350 26 14 ) ) -RRB- 37350 27 1 The the DT 37350 27 2 skull skull NN 37350 27 3 in in IN 37350 27 4 both both DT 37350 27 5 orders order NNS 37350 27 6 has have VBZ 37350 27 7 lost lose VBN 37350 27 8 a a DT 37350 27 9 number number NN 37350 27 10 of of IN 37350 27 11 primitive primitive JJ 37350 27 12 dermal dermal JJ 37350 27 13 bones bone NNS 37350 27 14 in in IN 37350 27 15 the the DT 37350 27 16 posterior posterior NN 37350 27 17 part part NN 37350 27 18 ; ; : 37350 27 19 these these DT 37350 27 20 are be VBP 37350 27 21 : : : 37350 27 22 basioccipital basioccipital JJ 37350 27 23 , , , 37350 27 24 supraoccipital supraoccipital JJ 37350 27 25 , , , 37350 27 26 postparietal postparietal JJ 37350 27 27 , , , 37350 27 28 intertemporal intertemporal JJ 37350 27 29 , , , 37350 27 30 supratemporal supratemporal JJ 37350 27 31 , , , 37350 27 32 and and CC 37350 27 33 tabular tabular JJ 37350 27 34 . . . 37350 28 1 The the DT 37350 28 2 exoccipitals exoccipital NNS 37350 28 3 form form VBP 37350 28 4 the the DT 37350 28 5 two two CD 37350 28 6 condyles condyle NNS 37350 28 7 but but CC 37350 28 8 there there EX 37350 28 9 are be VBP 37350 28 10 no no DT 37350 28 11 foramina foramina NN 37350 28 12 for for IN 37350 28 13 the the DT 37350 28 14 11th 11th JJ 37350 28 15 and and CC 37350 28 16 12th 12th JJ 37350 28 17 nerves nerve NNS 37350 28 18 , , , 37350 28 19 since since IN 37350 28 20 these these DT 37350 28 21 are be VBP 37350 28 22 not not RB 37350 28 23 separate separate JJ 37350 28 24 in in IN 37350 28 25 modern modern JJ 37350 28 26 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 28 27 . . . 37350 29 1 The the DT 37350 29 2 opisthotic opisthotic NN 37350 29 3 is be VBZ 37350 29 4 missing miss VBG 37350 29 5 in in IN 37350 29 6 all all DT 37350 29 7 except except IN 37350 29 8 Proteidae Proteidae NNP 37350 29 9 ( ( -LRB- 37350 29 10 but but CC 37350 29 11 see see VB 37350 29 12 discussion discussion NN 37350 29 13 of of IN 37350 29 14 the the DT 37350 29 15 ear ear NN 37350 29 16 ) ) -RRB- 37350 29 17 . . . 37350 30 1 Although although IN 37350 30 2 the the DT 37350 30 3 skull skull NN 37350 30 4 is be VBZ 37350 30 5 normally normally RB 37350 30 6 autostylic autostylic JJ 37350 30 7 , , , 37350 30 8 a a DT 37350 30 9 movable movable JJ 37350 30 10 basipterygoid basipterygoid JJ 37350 30 11 articulation articulation NN 37350 30 12 is be VBZ 37350 30 13 present present JJ 37350 30 14 among among IN 37350 30 15 Hynobiid Hynobiid NNP 37350 30 16 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 30 17 and and CC 37350 30 18 in in IN 37350 30 19 at at RB 37350 30 20 least least JJS 37350 30 21 the the DT 37350 30 22 metamorphic metamorphic JJ 37350 30 23 stages stage NNS 37350 30 24 of of IN 37350 30 25 primitive primitive JJ 37350 30 26 frogs frog NNS 37350 30 27 , , , 37350 30 28 and and CC 37350 30 29 therefore therefore RB 37350 30 30 should should MD 37350 30 31 be be VB 37350 30 32 expected expect VBN 37350 30 33 in in IN 37350 30 34 their -PRON- PRP$ 37350 30 35 ancestors ancestor NNS 37350 30 36 . . . 37350 31 1 The the DT 37350 31 2 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 31 3 are be VBP 37350 31 4 , , , 37350 31 5 of of IN 37350 31 6 course course NN 37350 31 7 , , , 37350 31 8 complete complete JJ 37350 31 9 ; ; : 37350 31 10 see see VB 37350 31 11 discussion discussion NN 37350 31 12 in in IN 37350 31 13 later late JJR 37350 31 14 section section NN 37350 31 15 . . . 37350 32 1 The the DT 37350 32 2 quadratojugal quadratojugal NN 37350 32 3 , , , 37350 32 4 lost lose VBN 37350 32 5 in in IN 37350 32 6 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 32 7 , , , 37350 32 8 is be VBZ 37350 32 9 retained retain VBN 37350 32 10 in in IN 37350 32 11 frogs frog NNS 37350 32 12 , , , 37350 32 13 and and CC 37350 32 14 conversely conversely RB 37350 32 15 the the DT 37350 32 16 lacrimal lacrimal NN 37350 32 17 , , , 37350 32 18 absent absent JJ 37350 32 19 in in IN 37350 32 20 frogs frog NNS 37350 32 21 , , , 37350 32 22 occurs occur VBZ 37350 32 23 in in IN 37350 32 24 a a DT 37350 32 25 few few JJ 37350 32 26 primitive primitive JJ 37350 32 27 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 32 28 . . . 37350 33 1 The the DT 37350 33 2 situation situation NN 37350 33 3 in in IN 37350 33 4 Apoda Apoda NNP 37350 33 5 is be VBZ 37350 33 6 different different JJ 37350 33 7 , , , 37350 33 8 but but CC 37350 33 9 postfrontal postfrontal JJ 37350 33 10 and and CC 37350 33 11 jugal jugal NNP 37350 33 12 should should MD 37350 33 13 be be VB 37350 33 14 noted note VBN 37350 33 15 as as IN 37350 33 16 bones bone NNS 37350 33 17 retained retain VBN 37350 33 18 in in IN 37350 33 19 this this DT 37350 33 20 order order NN 37350 33 21 while while IN 37350 33 22 lost lose VBN 37350 33 23 in in IN 37350 33 24 the the DT 37350 33 25 others other NNS 37350 33 26 . . . 37350 34 1 Thus thus RB 37350 34 2 , , , 37350 34 3 in in IN 37350 34 4 spite spite NN 37350 34 5 of of IN 37350 34 6 minor minor JJ 37350 34 7 differences difference NNS 37350 34 8 , , , 37350 34 9 the the DT 37350 34 10 above above JJ 37350 34 11 list list NN 37350 34 12 shows show VBZ 37350 34 13 that that IN 37350 34 14 there there EX 37350 34 15 are be VBP 37350 34 16 numerous numerous JJ 37350 34 17 and and CC 37350 34 18 detailed detailed JJ 37350 34 19 similarities similarity NNS 37350 34 20 between between IN 37350 34 21 Anura Anura NNP 37350 34 22 and and CC 37350 34 23 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 34 24 with with IN 37350 34 25 respect respect NN 37350 34 26 to to IN 37350 34 27 the the DT 37350 34 28 features feature NNS 37350 34 29 in in IN 37350 34 30 which which WDT 37350 34 31 they -PRON- PRP 37350 34 32 differ differ VBP 37350 34 33 from from IN 37350 34 34 the the DT 37350 34 35 Paleozoic Paleozoic NNP 37350 34 36 orders order NNS 37350 34 37 . . . 37350 35 1 Pusey Pusey NNP 37350 35 2 ( ( -LRB- 37350 35 3 1943 1943 CD 37350 35 4 ) ) -RRB- 37350 35 5 listed list VBN 37350 35 6 26 26 CD 37350 35 7 characters character NNS 37350 35 8 which which WDT 37350 35 9 _ _ NNP 37350 35 10 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 35 11 _ _ NNP 37350 35 12 shares share NNS 37350 35 13 with with IN 37350 35 14 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 35 15 but but CC 37350 35 16 not not RB 37350 35 17 with with IN 37350 35 18 more more RBR 37350 35 19 advanced advanced JJ 37350 35 20 frogs frog NNS 37350 35 21 ; ; : 37350 35 22 a a DT 37350 35 23 few few JJ 37350 35 24 of of IN 37350 35 25 these these DT 37350 35 26 might may MD 37350 35 27 be be VB 37350 35 28 coincidental coincidental JJ 37350 35 29 , , , 37350 35 30 but but CC 37350 35 31 most most JJS 37350 35 32 of of IN 37350 35 33 them -PRON- PRP 37350 35 34 are be VBP 37350 35 35 of of IN 37350 35 36 some some DT 37350 35 37 complexity complexity NN 37350 35 38 and and CC 37350 35 39 must must MD 37350 35 40 be be VB 37350 35 41 taken take VBN 37350 35 42 to to TO 37350 35 43 indicate indicate VB 37350 35 44 relationship relationship NN 37350 35 45 . . . 37350 36 1 The the DT 37350 36 2 main main JJ 37350 36 3 adaptive adaptive JJ 37350 36 4 specializations specialization NNS 37350 36 5 of of IN 37350 36 6 Anura Anura NNP 37350 36 7 , , , 37350 36 8 however however RB 37350 36 9 , , , 37350 36 10 including include VBG 37350 36 11 loss loss NN 37350 36 12 of of IN 37350 36 13 the the DT 37350 36 14 adult adult NN 37350 36 15 tail tail NN 37350 36 16 , , , 37350 36 17 extreme extreme JJ 37350 36 18 reduction reduction NN 37350 36 19 in in IN 37350 36 20 number number NN 37350 36 21 of of IN 37350 36 22 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 36 23 , , , 37350 36 24 formation formation NN 37350 36 25 of of IN 37350 36 26 urostyle urostyle NN 37350 36 27 , , , 37350 36 28 elongation elongation NN 37350 36 29 of of IN 37350 36 30 the the DT 37350 36 31 ilium ilium NN 37350 36 32 and and CC 37350 36 33 lengthening lengthening NN 37350 36 34 of of IN 37350 36 35 the the DT 37350 36 36 hind hind NN 37350 36 37 legs leg NNS 37350 36 38 , , , 37350 36 39 must must MD 37350 36 40 have have VB 37350 36 41 appeared appear VBN 37350 36 42 at at IN 37350 36 43 a a DT 37350 36 44 later later JJ 37350 36 45 time time NN 37350 36 46 than than IN 37350 36 47 the the DT 37350 36 48 separation separation NN 37350 36 49 of of IN 37350 36 50 that that DT 37350 36 51 order order NN 37350 36 52 from from IN 37350 36 53 any any DT 37350 36 54 possible possible JJ 37350 36 55 common common JJ 37350 36 56 stem stem NN 37350 36 57 with with IN 37350 36 58 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 36 59 , , , 37350 36 60 although although IN 37350 36 61 they -PRON- PRP 37350 36 62 are be VBP 37350 36 63 only only RB 37350 36 64 partially partially RB 37350 36 65 developed develop VBN 37350 36 66 in in IN 37350 36 67 the the DT 37350 36 68 Triassic Triassic NNP 37350 36 69 _ _ NNP 37350 36 70 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 36 71 _ _ NNP 37350 36 72 . . . 37350 37 1 Turning turn VBG 37350 37 2 to to IN 37350 37 3 the the DT 37350 37 4 Paleozoic Paleozoic NNP 37350 37 5 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 37 6 , , , 37350 37 7 there there EX 37350 37 8 are be VBP 37350 37 9 two two CD 37350 37 10 groups group NNS 37350 37 11 in in IN 37350 37 12 which which WDT 37350 37 13 some some DT 37350 37 14 likelihood likelihood NN 37350 37 15 of of IN 37350 37 16 a a DT 37350 37 17 relationship relationship NN 37350 37 18 with with IN 37350 37 19 modern modern JJ 37350 37 20 order order NN 37350 37 21 exists exist VBZ 37350 37 22 . . . 37350 38 1 In in IN 37350 38 2 the the DT 37350 38 3 Pennsylvanian Pennsylvanian NNP 37350 38 4 Trimerorhachoidea Trimerorhachoidea NNP 37350 38 5 ( ( -LRB- 37350 38 6 Labyrinthodontia Labyrinthodontia NNP 37350 38 7 , , , 37350 38 8 order order NN 37350 38 9 Temnospondyli Temnospondyli NNP 37350 38 10 ) ) -RRB- 37350 38 11 some some DT 37350 38 12 members member NNS 37350 38 13 , , , 37350 38 14 such such JJ 37350 38 15 as as IN 37350 38 16 _ _ NNP 37350 38 17 Eugyrinus Eugyrinus NNP 37350 38 18 _ _ NNP 37350 38 19 , , , 37350 38 20 _ _ NNP 37350 38 21 Saurerpeton Saurerpeton NNP 37350 38 22 _ _ NNP 37350 38 23 , , , 37350 38 24 and and CC 37350 38 25 notably notably RB 37350 38 26 _ _ NNP 37350 38 27 Amphibamus Amphibamus NNP 37350 38 28 _ _ NNP 37350 38 29 ( ( -LRB- 37350 38 30 Fig Fig NNP 37350 38 31 . . . 37350 39 1 1 1 LS 37350 39 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 39 3 had have VBD 37350 39 4 short short JJ 37350 39 5 , , , 37350 39 6 broad broad JJ 37350 39 7 heads head NNS 37350 39 8 , , , 37350 39 9 an an DT 37350 39 10 expansion expansion NN 37350 39 11 of of IN 37350 39 12 palatal palatal JJ 37350 39 13 and and CC 37350 39 14 orbital orbital JJ 37350 39 15 openings opening NNS 37350 39 16 , , , 37350 39 17 posterior posterior RB 37350 39 18 widening widening NN 37350 39 19 of of IN 37350 39 20 the the DT 37350 39 21 parasphenoid parasphenoid NN 37350 39 22 associated associate VBN 37350 39 23 with with IN 37350 39 24 divergence divergence NN 37350 39 25 of of IN 37350 39 26 the the DT 37350 39 27 pterygoids pterygoid NNS 37350 39 28 , , , 37350 39 29 a a DT 37350 39 30 movable movable JJ 37350 39 31 basipterygoid basipterygoid NN 37350 39 32 articulation articulation NN 37350 39 33 , , , 37350 39 34 and and CC 37350 39 35 reduction reduction NN 37350 39 36 in in IN 37350 39 37 size size NN 37350 39 38 ( ( -LRB- 37350 39 39 but but CC 37350 39 40 not not RB 37350 39 41 loss loss NN 37350 39 42 ) ) -RRB- 37350 39 43 of of IN 37350 39 44 the the DT 37350 39 45 more more RBR 37350 39 46 posterior posterior JJ 37350 39 47 dermal dermal JJ 37350 39 48 bones bone NNS 37350 39 49 of of IN 37350 39 50 the the DT 37350 39 51 skull skull NN 37350 39 52 . . . 37350 40 1 In in IN 37350 40 2 recognition recognition NN 37350 40 3 of of IN 37350 40 4 Watson Watson NNP 37350 40 5 's 's POS 37350 40 6 ( ( -LRB- 37350 40 7 1940 1940 CD 37350 40 8 ) ) -RRB- 37350 40 9 evidence evidence NN 37350 40 10 that that IN 37350 40 11 these these DT 37350 40 12 animals animal NNS 37350 40 13 make make VBP 37350 40 14 quite quite RB 37350 40 15 suitable suitable JJ 37350 40 16 structural structural JJ 37350 40 17 ancestors ancestor NNS 37350 40 18 of of IN 37350 40 19 frogs frog NNS 37350 40 20 , , , 37350 40 21 Romer Romer NNP 37350 40 22 ( ( -LRB- 37350 40 23 1945 1945 CD 37350 40 24 ) ) -RRB- 37350 40 25 placed place VBD 37350 40 26 _ _ NNP 37350 40 27 Amphibamus Amphibamus NNP 37350 40 28 _ _ NNP 37350 40 29 in in IN 37350 40 30 an an DT 37350 40 31 order order NN 37350 40 32 , , , 37350 40 33 Eoanura Eoanura NNP 37350 40 34 , , , 37350 40 35 but but CC 37350 40 36 Gregory Gregory NNP 37350 40 37 ( ( -LRB- 37350 40 38 1950 1950 CD 37350 40 39 ) ) -RRB- 37350 40 40 indicated indicate VBD 37350 40 41 that that IN 37350 40 42 it -PRON- PRP 37350 40 43 might may MD 37350 40 44 better well RBR 37350 40 45 be be VB 37350 40 46 left leave VBN 37350 40 47 with with IN 37350 40 48 the the DT 37350 40 49 temnospondyls temnospondyls NN 37350 40 50 . . . 37350 41 1 Association Association NNP 37350 41 2 of of IN 37350 41 3 the the DT 37350 41 4 urodele urodele JJ 37350 41 5 stem stem NN 37350 41 6 with with IN 37350 41 7 this this DT 37350 41 8 group group NN 37350 41 9 does do VBZ 37350 41 10 not not RB 37350 41 11 seem seem VB 37350 41 12 to to TO 37350 41 13 have have VB 37350 41 14 been be VBN 37350 41 15 proposed propose VBN 37350 41 16 hitherto hitherto VBN 37350 41 17 . . . 37350 42 1 The the DT 37350 42 2 other other JJ 37350 42 3 group group NN 37350 42 4 of of IN 37350 42 5 Paleozoic Paleozoic NNP 37350 42 6 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 42 7 that that WDT 37350 42 8 has have VBZ 37350 42 9 been be VBN 37350 42 10 considered consider VBN 37350 42 11 probably probably RB 37350 42 12 ancestral ancestral JJ 37350 42 13 to to IN 37350 42 14 any any DT 37350 42 15 modern modern JJ 37350 42 16 type type NN 37350 42 17 is be VBZ 37350 42 18 the the DT 37350 42 19 subclass subclass NN 37350 42 20 Lepospondyli Lepospondyli NNP 37350 42 21 , , , 37350 42 22 containing contain VBG 37350 42 23 three three CD 37350 42 24 orders order NNS 37350 42 25 , , , 37350 42 26 Aistopoda Aistopoda NNP 37350 42 27 , , , 37350 42 28 Nectridia Nectridia NNP 37350 42 29 and and CC 37350 42 30 Microsauria Microsauria NNP 37350 42 31 . . . 37350 43 1 In in IN 37350 43 2 these these DT 37350 43 3 the the DT 37350 43 4 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 43 5 are be VBP 37350 43 6 complete complete JJ 37350 43 7 ( ( -LRB- 37350 43 8 holospondylous holospondylous JJ 37350 43 9 ) ) -RRB- 37350 43 10 , , , 37350 43 11 the the DT 37350 43 12 centra centra NNP 37350 43 13 presumably presumably RB 37350 43 14 formed form VBN 37350 43 15 by by IN 37350 43 16 cylindrical cylindrical JJ 37350 43 17 ossification ossification NN 37350 43 18 around around IN 37350 43 19 the the DT 37350 43 20 notochord notochord NN 37350 43 21 , , , 37350 43 22 and and CC 37350 43 23 there there EX 37350 43 24 is be VBZ 37350 43 25 no no DT 37350 43 26 evidence evidence NN 37350 43 27 as as IN 37350 43 28 to to IN 37350 43 29 the the DT 37350 43 30 contributions contribution NNS 37350 43 31 from from IN 37350 43 32 embryonic embryonic JJ 37350 43 33 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 43 34 units unit NNS 37350 43 35 . . . 37350 44 1 It -PRON- PRP 37350 44 2 is be VBZ 37350 44 3 important important JJ 37350 44 4 to to TO 37350 44 5 note note VB 37350 44 6 at at IN 37350 44 7 this this DT 37350 44 8 point point NN 37350 44 9 that that WDT 37350 44 10 precisely precisely RB 37350 44 11 the the DT 37350 44 12 same same JJ 37350 44 13 statement statement NN 37350 44 14 can can MD 37350 44 15 be be VB 37350 44 16 made make VBN 37350 44 17 regarding regard VBG 37350 44 18 the the DT 37350 44 19 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 44 20 of of IN 37350 44 21 _ _ NNP 37350 44 22 adults adult NNS 37350 44 23 _ _ NNP 37350 44 24 of of IN 37350 44 25 all all DT 37350 44 26 three three CD 37350 44 27 Recent recent JJ 37350 44 28 orders order NNS 37350 44 29 , , , 37350 44 30 yet yet CC 37350 44 31 for for IN 37350 44 32 all all DT 37350 44 33 of of IN 37350 44 34 them -PRON- PRP 37350 44 35 , , , 37350 44 36 as as IN 37350 44 37 shown show VBN 37350 44 38 in in IN 37350 44 39 a a DT 37350 44 40 later later JJ 37350 44 41 section section NN 37350 44 42 , , , 37350 44 43 we -PRON- PRP 37350 44 44 have have VBP 37350 44 45 ample ample JJ 37350 44 46 evidence evidence NN 37350 44 47 of of IN 37350 44 48 the the DT 37350 44 49 part part NN 37350 44 50 played play VBN 37350 44 51 by by IN 37350 44 52 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 44 53 elements element NNS 37350 44 54 in in IN 37350 44 55 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 44 56 development development NN 37350 44 57 . . . 37350 45 1 Therefore therefore RB 37350 45 2 ( ( -LRB- 37350 45 3 a a LS 37350 45 4 ) ) -RRB- 37350 45 5 we -PRON- PRP 37350 45 6 can can MD 37350 45 7 not not RB 37350 45 8 say say VB 37350 45 9 that that IN 37350 45 10 there there EX 37350 45 11 were be VBD 37350 45 12 no no DT 37350 45 13 such such JJ 37350 45 14 elements element NNS 37350 45 15 in in IN 37350 45 16 embryonic embryonic JJ 37350 45 17 stages stage NNS 37350 45 18 of of IN 37350 45 19 lepospondyls lepospondyls NN 37350 45 20 , , , 37350 45 21 and and CC 37350 45 22 ( ( -LRB- 37350 45 23 b b NN 37350 45 24 ) ) -RRB- 37350 45 25 it -PRON- PRP 37350 45 26 would would MD 37350 45 27 take take VB 37350 45 28 more more JJR 37350 45 29 than than IN 37350 45 30 the the DT 37350 45 31 evidence evidence NN 37350 45 32 from from IN 37350 45 33 adult adult NN 37350 45 34 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 45 35 to to TO 37350 45 36 relate relate VB 37350 45 37 a a DT 37350 45 38 particular particular JJ 37350 45 39 modern modern JJ 37350 45 40 order order NN 37350 45 41 ( ( -LRB- 37350 45 42 for for IN 37350 45 43 example example NN 37350 45 44 , , , 37350 45 45 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 45 46 ) ) -RRB- 37350 45 47 to to IN 37350 45 48 the the DT 37350 45 49 Lepospondyli Lepospondyli NNP 37350 45 50 . . . 37350 46 1 Vague vague JJ 37350 46 2 similarities similarity NNS 37350 46 3 to to IN 37350 46 4 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 46 5 have have VBP 37350 46 6 been be VBN 37350 46 7 noted note VBN 37350 46 8 by by IN 37350 46 9 many many JJ 37350 46 10 authors author NNS 37350 46 11 in in IN 37350 46 12 the the DT 37350 46 13 Nectridia Nectridia NNP 37350 46 14 , , , 37350 46 15 Aistopoda Aistopoda NNP 37350 46 16 and and CC 37350 46 17 Microsauria Microsauria NNP 37350 46 18 , , , 37350 46 19 but but CC 37350 46 20 these these DT 37350 46 21 are be VBP 37350 46 22 not not RB 37350 46 23 detailed detailed JJ 37350 46 24 and and CC 37350 46 25 refer refer VB 37350 46 26 mainly mainly RB 37350 46 27 to to IN 37350 46 28 the the DT 37350 46 29 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 46 30 . . . 37350 47 1 The the DT 37350 47 2 skulls skull NNS 37350 47 3 do do VBP 37350 47 4 not not RB 37350 47 5 show show VB 37350 47 6 , , , 37350 47 7 either either CC 37350 47 8 dorsally dorsally RB 37350 47 9 or or CC 37350 47 10 in in IN 37350 47 11 the the DT 37350 47 12 palate palate NN 37350 47 13 , , , 37350 47 14 any any DT 37350 47 15 striking striking JJ 37350 47 16 resemblance resemblance NN 37350 47 17 to to IN 37350 47 18 those those DT 37350 47 19 of of IN 37350 47 20 generalized generalize VBN 37350 47 21 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 47 22 , , , 37350 47 23 and and CC 37350 47 24 certainly certainly RB 37350 47 25 most most RBS 37350 47 26 known know VBN 37350 47 27 lepospondyls lepospondyls NN 37350 47 28 are be VBP 37350 47 29 too too RB 37350 47 30 specialized specialized JJ 37350 47 31 to to TO 37350 47 32 serve serve VB 37350 47 33 as as IN 37350 47 34 the the DT 37350 47 35 source source NN 37350 47 36 of of IN 37350 47 37 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 47 38 . . . 37350 48 1 It -PRON- PRP 37350 48 2 is be VBZ 37350 48 3 true true JJ 37350 48 4 that that IN 37350 48 5 the the DT 37350 48 6 elongate elongate NN 37350 48 7 bodies body NNS 37350 48 8 , , , 37350 48 9 small small JJ 37350 48 10 limbs limb NNS 37350 48 11 , , , 37350 48 12 and and CC 37350 48 13 apparent apparent JJ 37350 48 14 aquatic aquatic JJ 37350 48 15 habitus habitus NN 37350 48 16 of of IN 37350 48 17 some some DT 37350 48 18 lepospondyls lepospondyls NNP 37350 48 19 accord accord NN 37350 48 20 well well UH 37350 48 21 with with IN 37350 48 22 our -PRON- PRP$ 37350 48 23 usual usual JJ 37350 48 24 picture picture NN 37350 48 25 of of IN 37350 48 26 a a DT 37350 48 27 salamander salamander JJ 37350 48 28 , , , 37350 48 29 but but CC 37350 48 30 such such PDT 37350 48 31 a a DT 37350 48 32 form form NN 37350 48 33 and and CC 37350 48 34 way way NN 37350 48 35 of of IN 37350 48 36 life life NN 37350 48 37 have have VBP 37350 48 38 appeared appear VBN 37350 48 39 in in IN 37350 48 40 many many JJ 37350 48 41 early early JJ 37350 48 42 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 48 43 , , , 37350 48 44 including include VBG 37350 48 45 the the DT 37350 48 46 labyrinthodonts labyrinthodont NNS 37350 48 47 . . . 37350 49 1 The the DT 37350 49 2 family family NN 37350 49 3 Lysorophidae Lysorophidae NNP 37350 49 4 ( ( -LRB- 37350 49 5 Fig fig NN 37350 49 6 . . . 37350 50 1 2 2 LS 37350 50 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 50 3 , , , 37350 50 4 usually usually RB 37350 50 5 placed place VBN 37350 50 6 among among IN 37350 50 7 microsaurs microsaur NNS 37350 50 8 , , , 37350 50 9 is be VBZ 37350 50 10 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37350 50 11 close close JJ 37350 50 12 in in IN 37350 50 13 skull skull NN 37350 50 14 structure structure NN 37350 50 15 to to IN 37350 50 16 the the DT 37350 50 17 Apoda Apoda NNP 37350 50 18 to to TO 37350 50 19 be be VB 37350 50 20 a a DT 37350 50 21 possible possible JJ 37350 50 22 ancestor ancestor NN 37350 50 23 of of IN 37350 50 24 these these DT 37350 50 25 , , , 37350 50 26 but but CC 37350 50 27 it -PRON- PRP 37350 50 28 probably probably RB 37350 50 29 has have VBZ 37350 50 30 nothing nothing NN 37350 50 31 to to TO 37350 50 32 do do VB 37350 50 33 with with IN 37350 50 34 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 50 35 , , , 37350 50 36 by by IN 37350 50 37 reason reason NN 37350 50 38 of of IN 37350 50 39 the the DT 37350 50 40 numerous numerous JJ 37350 50 41 morphological morphological JJ 37350 50 42 specializations specialization NNS 37350 50 43 that that WDT 37350 50 44 were be VBD 37350 50 45 associated associate VBN 37350 50 46 with with IN 37350 50 47 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 50 48 snakelike snakelike JJ 37350 50 49 habitus habitus NN 37350 50 50 . . . 37350 51 1 [ [ -LRB- 37350 51 2 Illustration illustration NN 37350 51 3 : : : 37350 51 4 Fig Fig NNP 37350 51 5 . . . 37350 52 1 2 2 LS 37350 52 2 . . . 37350 53 1 _ _ NNP 37350 53 2 Lysorophus Lysorophus NNP 37350 53 3 tricarinatus tricarinatus NN 37350 53 4 _ _ NNP 37350 53 5 , , , 37350 53 6 lateral lateral JJ 37350 53 7 and and CC 37350 53 8 posterior posterior JJ 37350 53 9 views view NNS 37350 53 10 × × ADD 37350 53 11 2 2 CD 37350 53 12 - - SYM 37350 53 13 1/2 1/2 CD 37350 53 14 , , , 37350 53 15 modified modify VBN 37350 53 16 after after IN 37350 53 17 Sollas Sollas NNP 37350 53 18 , , , 37350 53 19 1920 1920 CD 37350 53 20 , , , 37350 53 21 Figs fig NNS 37350 53 22 . . . 37350 54 1 8 8 CD 37350 54 2 and and CC 37350 54 3 12 12 CD 37350 54 4 , , , 37350 54 5 respectively respectively RB 37350 54 6 ; ; : 37350 54 7 palatal palatal JJ 37350 54 8 view view NN 37350 54 9 after after IN 37350 54 10 Broom Broom NNP 37350 54 11 , , , 37350 54 12 1918 1918 CD 37350 54 13 , , , 37350 54 14 × × NNP 37350 54 15 1 1 CD 37350 54 16 - - SYM 37350 54 17 1/2 1/2 CD 37350 54 18 . . . 37350 55 1 For for IN 37350 55 2 explanation explanation NN 37350 55 3 of of IN 37350 55 4 abbreviations abbreviation NNS 37350 55 5 see see VBP 37350 55 6 Fig Fig NNP 37350 55 7 . . . 37350 56 1 3 3 LS 37350 56 2 . . . 37350 56 3 ] ] -RRB- 37350 57 1 McDowell McDowell NNP 37350 57 2 's 's POS 37350 57 3 ( ( -LRB- 37350 57 4 1958 1958 CD 37350 57 5 ) ) -RRB- 37350 57 6 suggestion suggestion NN 37350 57 7 that that IN 37350 57 8 it -PRON- PRP 37350 57 9 would would MD 37350 57 10 be be VB 37350 57 11 profitable profitable JJ 37350 57 12 to to TO 37350 57 13 look look VB 37350 57 14 among among IN 37350 57 15 the the DT 37350 57 16 Seymouriamorpha Seymouriamorpha NNP 37350 57 17 for for IN 37350 57 18 the the DT 37350 57 19 ancestors ancestor NNS 37350 57 20 of of IN 37350 57 21 frogs frog NNS 37350 57 22 seems seem VBZ 37350 57 23 to to TO 37350 57 24 be be VB 37350 57 25 based base VBN 37350 57 26 upon upon IN 37350 57 27 a a DT 37350 57 28 few few JJ 37350 57 29 details detail NNS 37350 57 30 of of IN 37350 57 31 apparent apparent JJ 37350 57 32 resemblance resemblance NN 37350 57 33 rather rather RB 37350 57 34 than than IN 37350 57 35 a a DT 37350 57 36 comprehensive comprehensive JJ 37350 57 37 view view NN 37350 57 38 of of IN 37350 57 39 the the DT 37350 57 40 major major JJ 37350 57 41 characters character NNS 37350 57 42 of of IN 37350 57 43 the the DT 37350 57 44 animals animal NNS 37350 57 45 . . . 37350 58 1 In in IN 37350 58 2 most most JJS 37350 58 3 points point NNS 37350 58 4 which which WDT 37350 58 5 he -PRON- PRP 37350 58 6 mentions mention VBZ 37350 58 7 ( ( -LRB- 37350 58 8 limb limb NN 37350 58 9 girdles girdle NNS 37350 58 10 , , , 37350 58 11 form form NN 37350 58 12 of of IN 37350 58 13 ear ear NN 37350 58 14 , , , 37350 58 15 pterygoid pterygoid JJ 37350 58 16 articulation articulation NN 37350 58 17 ) ) -RRB- 37350 58 18 the the DT 37350 58 19 present present JJ 37350 58 20 writer writer NN 37350 58 21 does do VBZ 37350 58 22 not not RB 37350 58 23 see see VB 37350 58 24 a a DT 37350 58 25 closer close JJR 37350 58 26 similarity similarity NN 37350 58 27 of of IN 37350 58 28 frogs frog NNS 37350 58 29 to to IN 37350 58 30 Seymouriamorpha Seymouriamorpha NNP 37350 58 31 than than IN 37350 58 32 to to IN 37350 58 33 Temnospondyli Temnospondyli NNP 37350 58 34 . . . 37350 59 1 Still still RB 37350 59 2 other other JJ 37350 59 3 opinions opinion NNS 37350 59 4 have have VBP 37350 59 5 been be VBN 37350 59 6 expressed express VBN 37350 59 7 . . . 37350 60 1 Herre Herre NNP 37350 60 2 ( ( -LRB- 37350 60 3 1935 1935 CD 37350 60 4 ) ) -RRB- 37350 60 5 , , , 37350 60 6 for for IN 37350 60 7 instance instance NN 37350 60 8 , , , 37350 60 9 concludes conclude VBZ 37350 60 10 " " `` 37350 60 11 on on IN 37350 60 12 anatomical anatomical JJ 37350 60 13 , , , 37350 60 14 biological biological JJ 37350 60 15 and and CC 37350 60 16 paleontological paleontological JJ 37350 60 17 grounds ground NNS 37350 60 18 " " '' 37350 60 19 that that IN 37350 60 20 the the DT 37350 60 21 orders order NNS 37350 60 22 of of IN 37350 60 23 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 60 24 , , , 37350 60 25 Anura Anura NNP 37350 60 26 , , , 37350 60 27 Apoda Apoda NNP 37350 60 28 and and CC 37350 60 29 Stegocephali Stegocephali NNP 37350 60 30 were be VBD 37350 60 31 all all DT 37350 60 32 independently independently RB 37350 60 33 evolved evolve VBN 37350 60 34 from from IN 37350 60 35 fish fish NN 37350 60 36 , , , 37350 60 37 but but CC 37350 60 38 beyond beyond IN 37350 60 39 citing cite VBG 37350 60 40 the the DT 37350 60 41 opinions opinion NNS 37350 60 42 of of IN 37350 60 43 a a DT 37350 60 44 number number NN 37350 60 45 of of IN 37350 60 46 other other JJ 37350 60 47 authors author NNS 37350 60 48 he -PRON- PRP 37350 60 49 does do VBZ 37350 60 50 not not RB 37350 60 51 present present VB 37350 60 52 tangible tangible JJ 37350 60 53 evidence evidence NN 37350 60 54 for for IN 37350 60 55 this this DT 37350 60 56 extreme extreme JJ 37350 60 57 polyphyletic polyphyletic JJ 37350 60 58 interpretation interpretation NN 37350 60 59 . . . 37350 61 1 More more RBR 37350 61 2 notable notable JJ 37350 61 3 are be VBP 37350 61 4 the the DT 37350 61 5 views view NNS 37350 61 6 of of IN 37350 61 7 several several JJ 37350 61 8 Scandinavian scandinavian JJ 37350 61 9 workers worker NNS 37350 61 10 ( ( -LRB- 37350 61 11 Säve Säve NNP 37350 61 12 - - HYPH 37350 61 13 Söderbergh Söderbergh NNP 37350 61 14 , , , 37350 61 15 1934 1934 CD 37350 61 16 ; ; : 37350 61 17 Jarvik Jarvik NNP 37350 61 18 , , , 37350 61 19 1942 1942 CD 37350 61 20 ; ; : 37350 61 21 Holmgren Holmgren NNP 37350 61 22 , , , 37350 61 23 1933 1933 CD 37350 61 24 , , , 37350 61 25 1939 1939 CD 37350 61 26 , , , 37350 61 27 1949a 1949a CD 37350 61 28 , , , 37350 61 29 b b NN 37350 61 30 ) ) -RRB- 37350 61 31 , , , 37350 61 32 of of IN 37350 61 33 whom whom WP 37350 61 34 Jarvik Jarvik NNP 37350 61 35 , , , 37350 61 36 in in IN 37350 61 37 a a DT 37350 61 38 thorough thorough JJ 37350 61 39 analysis analysis NN 37350 61 40 of of IN 37350 61 41 the the DT 37350 61 42 ethmoid ethmoid JJ 37350 61 43 region region NN 37350 61 44 , , , 37350 61 45 would would MD 37350 61 46 derive derive VB 37350 61 47 the the DT 37350 61 48 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 61 49 from from IN 37350 61 50 Porolepid Porolepid NNP 37350 61 51 Crossopterygii Crossopterygii NNP 37350 61 52 , , , 37350 61 53 and and CC 37350 61 54 all all DT 37350 61 55 other other JJ 37350 61 56 tetrapods tetrapod NNS 37350 61 57 from from IN 37350 61 58 the the DT 37350 61 59 Rhipidistia Rhipidistia NNP 37350 61 60 ; ; : 37350 61 61 Säve Säve NNP 37350 61 62 - - HYPH 37350 61 63 Söderbergh Söderbergh NNP 37350 61 64 and and CC 37350 61 65 Holmgren Holmgren NNP 37350 61 66 , , , 37350 61 67 the the DT 37350 61 68 latter latter JJ 37350 61 69 using use VBG 37350 61 70 the the DT 37350 61 71 structure structure NN 37350 61 72 of of IN 37350 61 73 carpus carpus NNP 37350 61 74 and and CC 37350 61 75 tarsus tarsus NNP 37350 61 76 , , , 37350 61 77 see see VB 37350 61 78 a a DT 37350 61 79 relationship relationship NN 37350 61 80 of of IN 37350 61 81 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 61 82 to to IN 37350 61 83 Dipnoi Dipnoi NNP 37350 61 84 , , , 37350 61 85 but but CC 37350 61 86 accept accept VB 37350 61 87 the the DT 37350 61 88 derivation derivation NN 37350 61 89 of of IN 37350 61 90 labyrinthodonts labyrinthodont NNS 37350 61 91 and and CC 37350 61 92 other other JJ 37350 61 93 tetrapods tetrapod NNS 37350 61 94 from from IN 37350 61 95 Rhipidistia Rhipidistia NNP 37350 61 96 . . . 37350 62 1 All all DT 37350 62 2 of of IN 37350 62 3 this this DT 37350 62 4 work work NN 37350 62 5 is be VBZ 37350 62 6 most most RBS 37350 62 7 detailed detailed JJ 37350 62 8 and and CC 37350 62 9 laborious laborious JJ 37350 62 10 , , , 37350 62 11 and and CC 37350 62 12 has have VBZ 37350 62 13 produced produce VBN 37350 62 14 a a DT 37350 62 15 great great JJ 37350 62 16 quantity quantity NN 37350 62 17 of of IN 37350 62 18 data datum NNS 37350 62 19 useful useful JJ 37350 62 20 to to IN 37350 62 21 morphologists morphologist NNS 37350 62 22 , , , 37350 62 23 but but CC 37350 62 24 the the DT 37350 62 25 diphyletic diphyletic JJ 37350 62 26 theory theory NN 37350 62 27 is be VBZ 37350 62 28 not not RB 37350 62 29 widely widely RB 37350 62 30 adopted adopt VBN 37350 62 31 ; ; : 37350 62 32 the the DT 37350 62 33 evidence evidence NN 37350 62 34 adduced adduce VBD 37350 62 35 for for IN 37350 62 36 it -PRON- PRP 37350 62 37 seems seem VBZ 37350 62 38 to to TO 37350 62 39 consist consist VB 37350 62 40 largely largely RB 37350 62 41 of of IN 37350 62 42 minutiae minutia NNS 37350 62 43 which which WDT 37350 62 44 , , , 37350 62 45 taken take VBN 37350 62 46 by by IN 37350 62 47 themselves -PRON- PRP 37350 62 48 , , , 37350 62 49 are be VBP 37350 62 50 inconclusive inconclusive JJ 37350 62 51 , , , 37350 62 52 or or CC 37350 62 53 lend lend VB 37350 62 54 themselves -PRON- PRP 37350 62 55 to to IN 37350 62 56 other other JJ 37350 62 57 interpretation interpretation NN 37350 62 58 . . . 37350 63 1 For for IN 37350 63 2 instance instance NN 37350 63 3 Holmgren Holmgren NNP 37350 63 4 's 's POS 37350 63 5 numerous numerous JJ 37350 63 6 figures figure NNS 37350 63 7 of of IN 37350 63 8 embryonic embryonic JJ 37350 63 9 limbs limb NNS 37350 63 10 of of IN 37350 63 11 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 63 12 show show VBP 37350 63 13 patterns pattern NNS 37350 63 14 of of IN 37350 63 15 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 63 16 elements element NNS 37350 63 17 that that IN 37350 63 18 he -PRON- PRP 37350 63 19 would would MD 37350 63 20 trace trace VB 37350 63 21 to to IN 37350 63 22 the the DT 37350 63 23 Dipnoan Dipnoan NNP 37350 63 24 type type NN 37350 63 25 of of IN 37350 63 26 fin fin NN 37350 63 27 , , , 37350 63 28 yet yet CC 37350 63 29 it -PRON- PRP 37350 63 30 is be VBZ 37350 63 31 difficult difficult JJ 37350 63 32 to to TO 37350 63 33 see see VB 37350 63 34 that that IN 37350 63 35 the the DT 37350 63 36 weight weight NN 37350 63 37 of of IN 37350 63 38 evidence evidence NN 37350 63 39 requires require VBZ 37350 63 40 this this DT 37350 63 41 , , , 37350 63 42 when when WRB 37350 63 43 the the DT 37350 63 44 pattern pattern NN 37350 63 45 does do VBZ 37350 63 46 not not RB 37350 63 47 differ differ VB 37350 63 48 in in IN 37350 63 49 any any DT 37350 63 50 fundamental fundamental JJ 37350 63 51 manner manner NN 37350 63 52 from from IN 37350 63 53 those those DT 37350 63 54 seen see VBN 37350 63 55 in in IN 37350 63 56 other other JJ 37350 63 57 embryonic embryonic JJ 37350 63 58 tetrapods tetrapod NNS 37350 63 59 , , , 37350 63 60 and and CC 37350 63 61 the the DT 37350 63 62 differences difference NNS 37350 63 63 that that WDT 37350 63 64 do do VBP 37350 63 65 appear appear VB 37350 63 66 may may MD 37350 63 67 well well RB 37350 63 68 be be VB 37350 63 69 taken take VBN 37350 63 70 to to TO 37350 63 71 have have VB 37350 63 72 ontogenetic ontogenetic JJ 37350 63 73 rather rather RB 37350 63 74 than than IN 37350 63 75 phylogenetic phylogenetic JJ 37350 63 76 meaning meaning NN 37350 63 77 . . . 37350 64 1 Further further RB 37350 64 2 , , , 37350 64 3 the the DT 37350 64 4 Dipnoan Dipnoan NNP 37350 64 5 specialization specialization NN 37350 64 6 of of IN 37350 64 7 dental dental JJ 37350 64 8 plates plate NNS 37350 64 9 and and CC 37350 64 10 autostylic autostylic JJ 37350 64 11 jaw jaw NN 37350 64 12 suspension suspension NN 37350 64 13 , , , 37350 64 14 already already RB 37350 64 15 accomplished accomplish VBN 37350 64 16 early early RB 37350 64 17 in in IN 37350 64 18 the the DT 37350 64 19 Devonian Devonian NNP 37350 64 20 , , , 37350 64 21 would would MD 37350 64 22 seem seem VB 37350 64 23 to to TO 37350 64 24 exclude exclude VB 37350 64 25 Dipnoi Dipnoi NNP 37350 64 26 from from IN 37350 64 27 possible possible JJ 37350 64 28 ancestry ancestry NN 37350 64 29 of of IN 37350 64 30 the the DT 37350 64 31 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 64 32 , , , 37350 64 33 an an DT 37350 64 34 order order NN 37350 64 35 unknown unknown JJ 37350 64 36 prior prior RB 37350 64 37 to to IN 37350 64 38 the the DT 37350 64 39 Mesozoic Mesozoic NNP 37350 64 40 , , , 37350 64 41 in in IN 37350 64 42 which which WDT 37350 64 43 the the DT 37350 64 44 teeth tooth NNS 37350 64 45 are be VBP 37350 64 46 essentially essentially RB 37350 64 47 similar similar JJ 37350 64 48 to to IN 37350 64 49 those those DT 37350 64 50 of of IN 37350 64 51 late late JJ 37350 64 52 Paleozoic Paleozoic NNP 37350 64 53 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 64 54 , , , 37350 64 55 and and CC 37350 64 56 the the DT 37350 64 57 jaw jaw NN 37350 64 58 suspension suspension NN 37350 64 59 is be VBZ 37350 64 60 not not RB 37350 64 61 yet yet RB 37350 64 62 in in IN 37350 64 63 all all DT 37350 64 64 members member NNS 37350 64 65 autostylic autostylic JJ 37350 64 66 . . . 37350 65 1 THE the DT 37350 65 2 EAR EAR NNP 37350 65 3 [ [ -LRB- 37350 65 4 Illustration illustration NN 37350 65 5 : : : 37350 65 6 Fig Fig NNP 37350 65 7 . . . 37350 66 1 3 3 LS 37350 66 2 . . . 37350 67 1 Occipital occipital JJ 37350 67 2 region region NN 37350 67 3 of of IN 37350 67 4 skulls skull NNS 37350 67 5 of of IN 37350 67 6 _ _ NNP 37350 67 7 Megalocephalus Megalocephalus NNP 37350 67 8 brevicornis brevicornis NNP 37350 67 9 _ _ NNP 37350 67 10 ( ( -LRB- 37350 67 11 × × CD 37350 67 12 3/10 3/10 CD 37350 67 13 , , , 37350 67 14 after after IN 37350 67 15 Watson Watson NNP 37350 67 16 , , , 37350 67 17 1926 1926 CD 37350 67 18 , , , 37350 67 19 as as IN 37350 67 20 _ _ NNP 37350 67 21 Orthosaurus Orthosaurus NNP 37350 67 22 _ _ NNP 37350 67 23 ) ) -RRB- 37350 67 24 , , , 37350 67 25 _ _ NNP 37350 67 26 Dvinosaurus Dvinosaurus NNP 37350 67 27 _ _ NNP 37350 67 28 ( ( -LRB- 37350 67 29 × × NN 37350 67 30 1/4 1/4 CD 37350 67 31 , , , 37350 67 32 modified modify VBN 37350 67 33 after after IN 37350 67 34 Bystrow Bystrow NNP 37350 67 35 , , , 37350 67 36 1938 1938 CD 37350 67 37 ; ; : 37350 67 38 the the DT 37350 67 39 lower low JJR 37350 67 40 figure figure NN 37350 67 41 after after IN 37350 67 42 Sushkin Sushkin NNP 37350 67 43 , , , 37350 67 44 1936 1936 CD 37350 67 45 ) ) -RRB- 37350 67 46 , , , 37350 67 47 and and CC 37350 67 48 _ _ NNP 37350 67 49 Necturus Necturus NNP 37350 67 50 maculosus maculosus NN 37350 67 51 _ _ NNP 37350 67 52 ( ( -LRB- 37350 67 53 × × NNP 37350 67 54 3 3 CD 37350 67 55 , , , 37350 67 56 original original JJ 37350 67 57 , , , 37350 67 58 from from IN 37350 67 59 K. K. NNP 37350 67 60 U. U. NNP 37350 67 61 , , , 37350 67 62 No no UH 37350 67 63 . . . 37350 68 1 3471 3471 CD 37350 68 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 68 3 . . . 37350 69 1 Abbreviations abbreviation NNS 37350 69 2 Used use VBN 37350 69 3 in in IN 37350 69 4 Figures figure NNS 37350 69 5 b'd.c.--basidorsal b'd.c.--basidorsal NNP 37350 69 6 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 69 7 ( ( -LRB- 37350 69 8 neural neural JJ 37350 69 9 arch arch NNP 37350 69 10 ) ) -RRB- 37350 69 11 b'oc.--basioccipital b'oc.--basioccipital NFP 37350 69 12 ce._{1 ce._{1 NNP 37350 69 13 - - HYPH 37350 69 14 4}--centrale_{1 4}--centrale_{1 CD 37350 69 15 - - HYPH 37350 69 16 4 4 CD 37350 69 17 } } -RRB- 37350 69 18 ch.--ceratohyal ch.--ceratohyal NNP 37350 69 19 clav.--clavicle clav.--clavicle NNP 37350 69 20 clei.--cleithrum clei.--cleithrum NNP 37350 69 21 cor.--coracoid cor.--coracoid NNP 37350 69 22 d.c._{1 d.c._{1 NN 37350 69 23 - - HYPH 37350 69 24 4}--distal 4}--distal NNP 37350 69 25 carpal_{1 carpal_{1 NNP 37350 69 26 - - HYPH 37350 69 27 4 4 NNP 37350 69 28 } } -RRB- 37350 69 29 diap.--diapophysis diap.--diapophysis NN 37350 69 30 exoc.--exoccipital exoc.--exoccipital NNP 37350 69 31 ep.--episternum ep.--episternum . 37350 69 32 hyost.--hyostapes hyost.--hyostapes NNP 37350 69 33 i.--intermedium i.--intermedium NNP 37350 69 34 Mk.--Meckel Mk.--Meckel NNP 37350 69 35 's 's POS 37350 69 36 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 69 37 n.--notochord n.--notochord : 37350 69 38 om.--omosternum om.--omosternum XX 37350 69 39 op.--operculum op.--operculum NNP 37350 69 40 opis.--opisthotic opis.--opisthotic NNP 37350 69 41 par.--parietal par.--parietal NNP 37350 69 42 par par NN 37350 69 43 . . . 37350 70 1 proc.--paroccipital proc.--paroccipital JJ 37350 70 2 process process NN 37350 70 3 peri peri NN 37350 70 4 . . . 37350 71 1 cent.--perichordal cent.--perichordal NN 37350 71 2 centrum centrum NN 37350 71 3 p'p.--postparietal p'p.--postparietal NN 37350 71 4 prep.--prepollex prep.--prepollex NN 37350 71 5 pro.--prootic pro.--prootic NNP 37350 71 6 p'sp.--parasphenoid p'sp.--parasphenoid CD 37350 71 7 pt.--pterygoid pt.--pterygoid CD 37350 71 8 p.t.f.--post p.t.f.--post RBS 37350 71 9 - - HYPH 37350 71 10 temporal temporal JJ 37350 71 11 fossa fossa JJ 37350 71 12 postzyg.--postzygapophysis postzyg.--postzygapophysis NNP 37350 71 13 qj.--quadratojugal qj.--quadratojugal NNP 37350 71 14 qu.--quadrate qu.--quadrate : 37350 71 15 ra.--radiale ra.--radiale NNP 37350 71 16 r.hy.--hyomandibular r.hy.--hyomandibular NNP 37350 71 17 ramus ramus NN 37350 71 18 of of IN 37350 71 19 VII VII NNP 37350 71 20 rib rib NNP 37350 71 21 - - HYPH 37350 71 22 b.--rib b.--rib NN 37350 71 23 - - HYPH 37350 71 24 bearer bearer NN 37350 71 25 r.md.--mandibular r.md.--mandibular NNP 37350 71 26 ramus ramus NN 37350 71 27 of of IN 37350 71 28 VII VII NNP 37350 71 29 sc.--scapula sc.--scapula NNP 37350 71 30 sc'cor.--scapulocoracoid sc'cor.--scapulocoracoid JJ 37350 71 31 s'd.--supradorsal s'd.--supradorsal NN 37350 71 32 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 71 33 s'd.(postzyg s'd.(postzyg NNP 37350 71 34 . . . 37350 71 35 ) ) -RRB- 37350 72 1 --supradorsal --supradorsal NNP 37350 72 2 ( ( -LRB- 37350 72 3 postzygapophysis postzygapophysis NNP 37350 72 4 ) ) -RRB- 37350 72 5 soc.--supraoccipital soc.--supraoccipital NNP 37350 72 6 sp.c.--spinal sp.c.--spinal NN 37350 72 7 cord cord NN 37350 72 8 sq.--squamosal sq.--squamosal IN 37350 72 9 s'sc.--suprascapula s'sc.--suprascapula UH 37350 72 10 s't.--supratemporal s't.--supratemporal CD 37350 72 11 sta.--stapes sta.--stapes NNP 37350 72 12 ster.--sternum ster.--sternum NNP 37350 72 13 tab.--tabular tab.--tabular NNP 37350 72 14 uln.--ulnare uln.--ulnare JJ 37350 72 15 v.a.--vertebral v.a.--vertebral CD 37350 72 16 artery artery NN 37350 72 17 xiph.--xiphisternum xiph.--xiphisternum NNP 37350 72 18 I I NNP 37350 72 19 , , , 37350 72 20 IV IV NNP 37350 72 21 -- -- : 37350 72 22 digits digit VBZ 37350 72 23 I I NNP 37350 72 24 and and CC 37350 72 25 IV IV NNP 37350 72 26 V V NNP 37350 72 27 , , , 37350 72 28 VII VII NNP 37350 72 29 , , , 37350 72 30 X X NNP 37350 72 31 , , , 37350 72 32 XII XII NNP 37350 72 33 -- -- : 37350 72 34 foramina foramina NN 37350 72 35 for for IN 37350 72 36 cranial cranial JJ 37350 72 37 nerves nerve NNS 37350 72 38 of of IN 37350 72 39 these these DT 37350 72 40 numbers number NNS 37350 72 41 ( ( -LRB- 37350 72 42 in in IN 37350 72 43 Fig Fig NNP 37350 72 44 . . . 37350 73 1 4 4 LS 37350 73 2 , , , 37350 73 3 VII VII NNP 37350 73 4 is be VBZ 37350 73 5 the the DT 37350 73 6 facial facial JJ 37350 73 7 nerve nerve NN 37350 73 8 ) ) -RRB- 37350 73 9 ] ] -RRB- 37350 73 10 In in IN 37350 73 11 temnospondylous temnospondylous JJ 37350 73 12 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 73 13 the the DT 37350 73 14 tympanum tympanum NN 37350 73 15 generally generally RB 37350 73 16 occupied occupy VBD 37350 73 17 an an DT 37350 73 18 otic otic JJ 37350 73 19 notch notch NN 37350 73 20 , , , 37350 73 21 at at IN 37350 73 22 a a DT 37350 73 23 high high JJ 37350 73 24 level level NN 37350 73 25 on on IN 37350 73 26 the the DT 37350 73 27 skull skull NN 37350 73 28 , , , 37350 73 29 bordered border VBN 37350 73 30 dorsomedially dorsomedially RB 37350 73 31 by by IN 37350 73 32 the the DT 37350 73 33 tabular tabular JJ 37350 73 34 and and CC 37350 73 35 ventrolaterally ventrolaterally RB 37350 73 36 by by IN 37350 73 37 the the DT 37350 73 38 squamosal squamosal NN 37350 73 39 . . . 37350 74 1 In in IN 37350 74 2 this this DT 37350 74 3 position position NN 37350 74 4 the the DT 37350 74 5 tympanum tympanum NN 37350 74 6 could could MD 37350 74 7 receive receive VB 37350 74 8 airborne airborne JJ 37350 74 9 sounds sound NNS 37350 74 10 whether whether IN 37350 74 11 the the DT 37350 74 12 animal animal NN 37350 74 13 were be VBD 37350 74 14 entirely entirely RB 37350 74 15 on on IN 37350 74 16 land land NN 37350 74 17 or or CC 37350 74 18 lying lie VBG 37350 74 19 nearly nearly RB 37350 74 20 submerged submerge VBN 37350 74 21 with with IN 37350 74 22 only only RB 37350 74 23 the the DT 37350 74 24 upper upper JJ 37350 74 25 part part NN 37350 74 26 of of IN 37350 74 27 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 74 28 head head NN 37350 74 29 exposed expose VBN 37350 74 30 . . . 37350 75 1 Among among IN 37350 75 2 those those DT 37350 75 3 Anura Anura NNP 37350 75 4 in in IN 37350 75 5 which which WDT 37350 75 6 the the DT 37350 75 7 ear ear NN 37350 75 8 is be VBZ 37350 75 9 not not RB 37350 75 10 reduced reduce VBN 37350 75 11 the the DT 37350 75 12 same same JJ 37350 75 13 is be VBZ 37350 75 14 true true JJ 37350 75 15 , , , 37350 75 16 except except IN 37350 75 17 that that IN 37350 75 18 the the DT 37350 75 19 tabular tabular NN 37350 75 20 is be VBZ 37350 75 21 lost lose VBN 37350 75 22 . . . 37350 76 1 In in IN 37350 76 2 Temnospondyli Temnospondyli NNP 37350 76 3 ( ( -LRB- 37350 76 4 Fig fig NN 37350 76 5 . . . 37350 77 1 3 3 LS 37350 77 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 77 3 the the DT 37350 77 4 posterior posterior NN 37350 77 5 wall wall NN 37350 77 6 of of IN 37350 77 7 the the DT 37350 77 8 otic otic JJ 37350 77 9 capsule capsule NN 37350 77 10 was be VBD 37350 77 11 usually usually RB 37350 77 12 formed form VBN 37350 77 13 by by IN 37350 77 14 the the DT 37350 77 15 opisthotic opisthotic NN 37350 77 16 , , , 37350 77 17 which which WDT 37350 77 18 extended extend VBD 37350 77 19 up up RP 37350 77 20 and and CC 37350 77 21 outward outward RB 37350 77 22 as as IN 37350 77 23 a a DT 37350 77 24 buttress buttress NN 37350 77 25 from from IN 37350 77 26 the the DT 37350 77 27 exoccipital exoccipital NN 37350 77 28 to to IN 37350 77 29 the the DT 37350 77 30 tabular tabular JJ 37350 77 31 , , , 37350 77 32 and and CC 37350 77 33 sometimes sometimes RB 37350 77 34 showed show VBD 37350 77 35 a a DT 37350 77 36 paroccipital paroccipital JJ 37350 77 37 process process NN 37350 77 38 for for IN 37350 77 39 the the DT 37350 77 40 insertion insertion NN 37350 77 41 , , , 37350 77 42 presumably presumably RB 37350 77 43 , , , 37350 77 44 of of IN 37350 77 45 a a DT 37350 77 46 slip slip NN 37350 77 47 or or CC 37350 77 48 tendon tendon NNP 37350 77 49 of of IN 37350 77 50 the the DT 37350 77 51 anterior anterior NNP 37350 77 52 axial axial NNP 37350 77 53 musculature musculature NN 37350 77 54 . . . 37350 78 1 The the DT 37350 78 2 stapes stape NNS 37350 78 3 , , , 37350 78 4 in in IN 37350 78 5 addition addition NN 37350 78 6 to to IN 37350 78 7 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 78 8 foot foot NN 37350 78 9 in in IN 37350 78 10 the the DT 37350 78 11 fenestra fenestra NNP 37350 78 12 ovalis ovalis NNP 37350 78 13 and and CC 37350 78 14 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 78 15 tympanic tympanic JJ 37350 78 16 or or CC 37350 78 17 extrastapedial extrastapedial JJ 37350 78 18 process process NN 37350 78 19 to to IN 37350 78 20 the the DT 37350 78 21 tympanum tympanum NN 37350 78 22 , , , 37350 78 23 bore bear VBD 37350 78 24 a a DT 37350 78 25 dorsal dorsal NN 37350 78 26 process process NN 37350 78 27 ( ( -LRB- 37350 78 28 or or CC 37350 78 29 ligament ligament VBP 37350 78 30 ) ) -RRB- 37350 78 31 to to IN 37350 78 32 the the DT 37350 78 33 tabular tabular JJ 37350 78 34 , , , 37350 78 35 an an DT 37350 78 36 " " `` 37350 78 37 internal internal JJ 37350 78 38 " " '' 37350 78 39 process process NN 37350 78 40 ( ( -LRB- 37350 78 41 or or CC 37350 78 42 ligament ligament CC 37350 78 43 ) ) -RRB- 37350 78 44 to to IN 37350 78 45 the the DT 37350 78 46 quadrate quadrate NN 37350 78 47 or or CC 37350 78 48 an an DT 37350 78 49 adjacent adjacent JJ 37350 78 50 part part NN 37350 78 51 of of IN 37350 78 52 the the DT 37350 78 53 squamosal squamosal NN 37350 78 54 , , , 37350 78 55 and and CC 37350 78 56 a a DT 37350 78 57 ligament ligament NN 37350 78 58 to to IN 37350 78 59 the the DT 37350 78 60 ceratohyal ceratohyal NN 37350 78 61 . . . 37350 79 1 Some some DT 37350 79 2 of of IN 37350 79 3 these these DT 37350 79 4 attachments attachment NNS 37350 79 5 might may MD 37350 79 6 be be VB 37350 79 7 reduced reduce VBN 37350 79 8 or or CC 37350 79 9 absent absent JJ 37350 79 10 in in IN 37350 79 11 special special JJ 37350 79 12 cases case NNS 37350 79 13 , , , 37350 79 14 but but CC 37350 79 15 they -PRON- PRP 37350 79 16 seem seem VBP 37350 79 17 to to TO 37350 79 18 have have VB 37350 79 19 been be VBN 37350 79 20 the the DT 37350 79 21 ones one NNS 37350 79 22 originally originally RB 37350 79 23 present present JJ 37350 79 24 both both DT 37350 79 25 phylogenetically phylogenetically RB 37350 79 26 and and CC 37350 79 27 embryonically embryonically RB 37350 79 28 in in IN 37350 79 29 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 79 30 . . . 37350 80 1 Among among IN 37350 80 2 typical typical JJ 37350 80 3 frogs frog NNS 37350 80 4 ( ( -LRB- 37350 80 5 Fig fig NN 37350 80 6 . . . 37350 81 1 4 4 LS 37350 81 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 81 3 the the DT 37350 81 4 base base NN 37350 81 5 , , , 37350 81 6 or or CC 37350 81 7 otostapes otostape NNS 37350 81 8 , , , 37350 81 9 is be VBZ 37350 81 10 present present JJ 37350 81 11 and and CC 37350 81 12 bony bony NNP 37350 81 13 , , , 37350 81 14 the the DT 37350 81 15 extrastapedial extrastapedial JJ 37350 81 16 process process NN 37350 81 17 ( ( -LRB- 37350 81 18 extracolumella extracolumella NN 37350 81 19 , , , 37350 81 20 or or CC 37350 81 21 hyostapes hyostape NNS 37350 81 22 ) ) -RRB- 37350 81 23 is be VBZ 37350 81 24 usually usually RB 37350 81 25 cartilaginous cartilaginous JJ 37350 81 26 , , , 37350 81 27 the the DT 37350 81 28 dorsal dorsal NN 37350 81 29 process process NN 37350 81 30 ( ( -LRB- 37350 81 31 processus processus NNP 37350 81 32 paroticus paroticus NNP 37350 81 33 ) ) -RRB- 37350 81 34 is be VBZ 37350 81 35 of of IN 37350 81 36 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 81 37 or or CC 37350 81 38 ligament ligament NN 37350 81 39 , , , 37350 81 40 but but CC 37350 81 41 the the DT 37350 81 42 other other JJ 37350 81 43 two two CD 37350 81 44 attachments attachment NNS 37350 81 45 are be VBP 37350 81 46 absent absent JJ 37350 81 47 in in IN 37350 81 48 the the DT 37350 81 49 adult adult NN 37350 81 50 . . . 37350 82 1 The the DT 37350 82 2 exoccipital exoccipital JJ 37350 82 3 extends extend VBZ 37350 82 4 laterally laterally RB 37350 82 5 , , , 37350 82 6 occupying occupy VBG 37350 82 7 the the DT 37350 82 8 posterior posterior NN 37350 82 9 face face NN 37350 82 10 of of IN 37350 82 11 the the DT 37350 82 12 otic otic JJ 37350 82 13 capsule capsule NN 37350 82 14 . . . 37350 83 1 Between between IN 37350 83 2 it -PRON- PRP 37350 83 3 and and CC 37350 83 4 the the DT 37350 83 5 otostapes otostape NNS 37350 83 6 is be VBZ 37350 83 7 a a DT 37350 83 8 small small JJ 37350 83 9 disc disc NN 37350 83 10 , , , 37350 83 11 usually usually RB 37350 83 12 ossified ossify VBN 37350 83 13 , , , 37350 83 14 the the DT 37350 83 15 operculum operculum NN 37350 83 16 , , , 37350 83 17 which which WDT 37350 83 18 normally normally RB 37350 83 19 fits fit VBZ 37350 83 20 loosely loosely RB 37350 83 21 in in IN 37350 83 22 a a DT 37350 83 23 portion portion NN 37350 83 24 of of IN 37350 83 25 the the DT 37350 83 26 fenestral fenestral JJ 37350 83 27 membrane membrane NN 37350 83 28 , , , 37350 83 29 and and CC 37350 83 30 is be VBZ 37350 83 31 developed develop VBN 37350 83 32 from from IN 37350 83 33 the the DT 37350 83 34 otic otic JJ 37350 83 35 capsule capsule NN 37350 83 36 . . . 37350 84 1 The the DT 37350 84 2 opercularis opercularis NN 37350 84 3 muscle muscle NN 37350 84 4 extends extend VBZ 37350 84 5 from from IN 37350 84 6 this this DT 37350 84 7 disc disc NN 37350 84 8 to to IN 37350 84 9 the the DT 37350 84 10 suprascapula suprascapula NN 37350 84 11 , , , 37350 84 12 in in IN 37350 84 13 many many JJ 37350 84 14 but but CC 37350 84 15 by by IN 37350 84 16 no no DT 37350 84 17 means means NN 37350 84 18 all all DT 37350 84 19 families family NNS 37350 84 20 of of IN 37350 84 21 Anura Anura NNP 37350 84 22 . . . 37350 85 1 [ [ -LRB- 37350 85 2 Illustration illustration NN 37350 85 3 : : : 37350 85 4 Fig Fig NNP 37350 85 5 . . . 37350 86 1 4 4 LS 37350 86 2 . . . 37350 87 1 Diagram diagram NN 37350 87 2 of of IN 37350 87 3 middle middle JJ 37350 87 4 ear ear NN 37350 87 5 structures structure NNS 37350 87 6 in in IN 37350 87 7 _ _ NNP 37350 87 8 Rana Rana NNP 37350 87 9 _ _ NNP 37350 87 10 ( ( -LRB- 37350 87 11 upper upper JJ 37350 87 12 figure figure NN 37350 87 13 , , , 37350 87 14 after after IN 37350 87 15 Stadtmüller Stadtmüller NNP 37350 87 16 , , , 37350 87 17 1936 1936 CD 37350 87 18 , , , 37350 87 19 and and CC 37350 87 20 lower lower RBR 37350 87 21 left leave VBN 37350 87 22 after after IN 37350 87 23 DeBeer DeBeer NNP 37350 87 24 , , , 37350 87 25 1937 1937 CD 37350 87 26 ) ) -RRB- 37350 87 27 , , , 37350 87 28 and and CC 37350 87 29 _ _ NNP 37350 87 30 Ambystoma Ambystoma NNP 37350 87 31 _ _ NNP 37350 87 32 ( ( -LRB- 37350 87 33 lower lower RBR 37350 87 34 right right RB 37350 87 35 , , , 37350 87 36 after after IN 37350 87 37 DeBeer DeBeer NNP 37350 87 38 , , , 37350 87 39 1937 1937 CD 37350 87 40 ) ) -RRB- 37350 87 41 ; ; : 37350 87 42 all all DT 37350 87 43 × × NN 37350 87 44 4 4 CD 37350 87 45 . . . 37350 88 1 For for IN 37350 88 2 explanation explanation NN 37350 88 3 of of IN 37350 88 4 abbreviations abbreviation NNS 37350 88 5 see see VBP 37350 88 6 Fig Fig NNP 37350 88 7 . . . 37350 89 1 3 3 LS 37350 89 2 . . . 37350 89 3 ] ] -RRB- 37350 90 1 Among among IN 37350 90 2 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 90 3 ( ( -LRB- 37350 90 4 Fig Fig NNP 37350 90 5 . . . 37350 91 1 4 4 LS 37350 91 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 91 3 the the DT 37350 91 4 middle middle JJ 37350 91 5 ear ear NN 37350 91 6 cavity cavity NN 37350 91 7 and and CC 37350 91 8 tympanum tympanum NN 37350 91 9 are be VBP 37350 91 10 lacking lack VBG 37350 91 11 , , , 37350 91 12 and and CC 37350 91 13 the the DT 37350 91 14 stapes stape NNS 37350 91 15 ( ( -LRB- 37350 91 16 columella columella NNP 37350 91 17 ) ) -RRB- 37350 91 18 consists consist VBZ 37350 91 19 of of IN 37350 91 20 no no DT 37350 91 21 more more JJR 37350 91 22 than than IN 37350 91 23 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 91 24 footplate footplate NN 37350 91 25 and and CC 37350 91 26 the the DT 37350 91 27 stylus stylus NN 37350 91 28 , , , 37350 91 29 which which WDT 37350 91 30 is be VBZ 37350 91 31 attached attach VBN 37350 91 32 to to IN 37350 91 33 the the DT 37350 91 34 border border NN 37350 91 35 of of IN 37350 91 36 the the DT 37350 91 37 squamosal squamosal NN 37350 91 38 , , , 37350 91 39 thus thus RB 37350 91 40 corresponding correspond VBG 37350 91 41 to to IN 37350 91 42 the the DT 37350 91 43 " " `` 37350 91 44 internal internal JJ 37350 91 45 " " '' 37350 91 46 process process NN 37350 91 47 . . . 37350 92 1 In in IN 37350 92 2 families family NNS 37350 92 3 in in IN 37350 92 4 which which WDT 37350 92 5 individuals individual NNS 37350 92 6 metamorphose metamorphose VBP 37350 92 7 and and CC 37350 92 8 become become VBP 37350 92 9 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37350 92 10 ( ( -LRB- 37350 92 11 Hynobiidae Hynobiidae NNP 37350 92 12 , , , 37350 92 13 Ambystomidae Ambystomidae NNP 37350 92 14 , , , 37350 92 15 Salamandridae Salamandridae NNP 37350 92 16 , , , 37350 92 17 Plethodontidae Plethodontidae NNP 37350 92 18 ) ) -RRB- 37350 92 19 , , , 37350 92 20 an an DT 37350 92 21 operculum operculum NN 37350 92 22 and and CC 37350 92 23 opercularis opercularis JJ 37350 92 24 muscle muscle NN 37350 92 25 appear appear VBP 37350 92 26 in in IN 37350 92 27 the the DT 37350 92 28 adult adult NN 37350 92 29 , , , 37350 92 30 just just RB 37350 92 31 as as IN 37350 92 32 in in IN 37350 92 33 frogs frog NNS 37350 92 34 , , , 37350 92 35 except except IN 37350 92 36 that that IN 37350 92 37 in in IN 37350 92 38 Plethodontidae Plethodontidae NNP 37350 92 39 , , , 37350 92 40 the the DT 37350 92 41 most most RBS 37350 92 42 progressive progressive JJ 37350 92 43 family family NN 37350 92 44 , , , 37350 92 45 the the DT 37350 92 46 operculum operculum NN 37350 92 47 fuses fuse VBZ 37350 92 48 with with IN 37350 92 49 the the DT 37350 92 50 footplate footplate NN 37350 92 51 of of IN 37350 92 52 the the DT 37350 92 53 stapes stape NNS 37350 92 54 . . . 37350 93 1 Among among IN 37350 93 2 neotenous neotenous JJ 37350 93 3 or or CC 37350 93 4 perennibranchiate perennibranchiate NN 37350 93 5 urodeles urodele NNS 37350 93 6 there there EX 37350 93 7 is be VBZ 37350 93 8 no no DT 37350 93 9 separate separate JJ 37350 93 10 operculum operculum NN 37350 93 11 or or CC 37350 93 12 opercularis opercularis NN 37350 93 13 . . . 37350 94 1 The the DT 37350 94 2 evidence evidence NN 37350 94 3 given give VBN 37350 94 4 by by IN 37350 94 5 Reed Reed NNP 37350 94 6 ( ( -LRB- 37350 94 7 1915 1915 CD 37350 94 8 ) ) -RRB- 37350 94 9 for for IN 37350 94 10 fusion fusion NN 37350 94 11 of of IN 37350 94 12 the the DT 37350 94 13 operculum operculum NN 37350 94 14 with with IN 37350 94 15 the the DT 37350 94 16 columella columella NN 37350 94 17 in in IN 37350 94 18 _ _ NNP 37350 94 19 Necturus Necturus NNP 37350 94 20 _ _ NNP 37350 94 21 appears appear VBZ 37350 94 22 inconclusive inconclusive JJ 37350 94 23 , , , 37350 94 24 in in IN 37350 94 25 spite spite NN 37350 94 26 of of IN 37350 94 27 the the DT 37350 94 28 great great JJ 37350 94 29 care care NN 37350 94 30 with with IN 37350 94 31 which which WDT 37350 94 32 his -PRON- PRP$ 37350 94 33 observations observation NNS 37350 94 34 were be VBD 37350 94 35 made make VBN 37350 94 36 . . . 37350 95 1 On on IN 37350 95 2 the the DT 37350 95 3 other other JJ 37350 95 4 hand hand NN 37350 95 5 , , , 37350 95 6 _ _ NNP 37350 95 7 Necturus Necturus NNP 37350 95 8 _ _ NNP 37350 95 9 and and CC 37350 95 10 _ _ NNP 37350 95 11 Proteus Proteus NNP 37350 95 12 _ _ NNP 37350 95 13 alone alone RB 37350 95 14 among among IN 37350 95 15 living live VBG 37350 95 16 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 95 17 have have VBP 37350 95 18 a a DT 37350 95 19 distinct distinct JJ 37350 95 20 opisthotic opisthotic NN 37350 95 21 on on IN 37350 95 22 the the DT 37350 95 23 posterior posterior NN 37350 95 24 wall wall NN 37350 95 25 of of IN 37350 95 26 the the DT 37350 95 27 otic otic JJ 37350 95 28 capsule capsule NN 37350 95 29 ( ( -LRB- 37350 95 30 Fig fig NN 37350 95 31 . . . 37350 96 1 3 3 LS 37350 96 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 96 3 , , , 37350 96 4 as as IN 37350 96 5 do do VBP 37350 96 6 the the DT 37350 96 7 Cretaceous Cretaceous NNP 37350 96 8 _ _ NNP 37350 96 9 Hylaeobatrachus Hylaeobatrachus NNP 37350 96 10 _ _ NNP 37350 96 11 and and CC 37350 96 12 the the DT 37350 96 13 Eocene Eocene NNP 37350 96 14 _ _ NNP 37350 96 15 Palaeoproteus Palaeoproteus NNP 37350 96 16 _ _ NNP 37350 96 17 . . . 37350 97 1 Probably probably RB 37350 97 2 these these DT 37350 97 3 Proteidae Proteidae NNP 37350 97 4 should should MD 37350 97 5 be be VB 37350 97 6 regarded regard VBN 37350 97 7 as as IN 37350 97 8 primitive primitive JJ 37350 97 9 in in IN 37350 97 10 this this DT 37350 97 11 respect respect NN 37350 97 12 , , , 37350 97 13 although although IN 37350 97 14 many many JJ 37350 97 15 other other JJ 37350 97 16 features feature NNS 37350 97 17 may may MD 37350 97 18 be be VB 37350 97 19 attributed attribute VBN 37350 97 20 to to IN 37350 97 21 neoteny neoteny NN 37350 97 22 . . . 37350 98 1 There there EX 37350 98 2 is be VBZ 37350 98 3 a a DT 37350 98 4 contrast contrast NN 37350 98 5 between between IN 37350 98 6 Anura Anura NNP 37350 98 7 and and CC 37350 98 8 most most JJS 37350 98 9 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 98 10 in in IN 37350 98 11 the the DT 37350 98 12 relative relative JJ 37350 98 13 positions position NNS 37350 98 14 of of IN 37350 98 15 the the DT 37350 98 16 stapes stape NNS 37350 98 17 and and CC 37350 98 18 facial facial JJ 37350 98 19 nerve nerve NN 37350 98 20 , , , 37350 98 21 as as IN 37350 98 22 shown show VBN 37350 98 23 in in IN 37350 98 24 DeBeer DeBeer NNP 37350 98 25 's 's POS 37350 98 26 ( ( -LRB- 37350 98 27 1937 1937 CD 37350 98 28 ) ) -RRB- 37350 98 29 diagrams diagram NNS 37350 98 30 . . . 37350 99 1 In in IN 37350 99 2 the the DT 37350 99 3 latter latter JJ 37350 99 4 ( ( -LRB- 37350 99 5 _ _ NNP 37350 99 6 Ambystoma Ambystoma NNP 37350 99 7 _ _ NNP 37350 99 8 ) ) -RRB- 37350 99 9 the the DT 37350 99 10 nerve nerve NN 37350 99 11 is be VBZ 37350 99 12 beneath beneath JJ 37350 99 13 , , , 37350 99 14 and and CC 37350 99 15 in in IN 37350 99 16 the the DT 37350 99 17 former former JJ 37350 99 18 ( ( -LRB- 37350 99 19 _ _ NNP 37350 99 20 Rana Rana NNP 37350 99 21 _ _ NNP 37350 99 22 ) ) -RRB- 37350 99 23 above above RB 37350 99 24 , , , 37350 99 25 the the DT 37350 99 26 stapes stape NNS 37350 99 27 . . . 37350 100 1 Judging judge VBG 37350 100 2 by by IN 37350 100 3 figures figure NNS 37350 100 4 of of IN 37350 100 5 _ _ NNP 37350 100 6 Neoceratodus Neoceratodus NNP 37350 100 7 _ _ NNP 37350 100 8 , , , 37350 100 9 _ _ NNP 37350 100 10 Hypogeophis Hypogeophis NNP 37350 100 11 _ _ NNP 37350 100 12 , , , 37350 100 13 and and CC 37350 100 14 several several JJ 37350 100 15 types type NNS 37350 100 16 of of IN 37350 100 17 reptiles reptile NNS 37350 100 18 and and CC 37350 100 19 mammals mammal NNS 37350 100 20 , , , 37350 100 21 the the DT 37350 100 22 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 100 23 are be VBP 37350 100 24 exceptional exceptional JJ 37350 100 25 . . . 37350 101 1 _ _ NNP 37350 101 2 Necturus Necturus NNP 37350 101 3 _ _ NNP 37350 101 4 , , , 37350 101 5 however however RB 37350 101 6 , , , 37350 101 7 has have VBZ 37350 101 8 the the DT 37350 101 9 nerve nerve NN 37350 101 10 passing pass VBG 37350 101 11 above above IN 37350 101 12 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 101 13 stapes stape NNS 37350 101 14 , , , 37350 101 15 and and CC 37350 101 16 this this DT 37350 101 17 may may MD 37350 101 18 be be VB 37350 101 19 primitive primitive JJ 37350 101 20 in in IN 37350 101 21 the the DT 37350 101 22 same same JJ 37350 101 23 sense sense NN 37350 101 24 as as IN 37350 101 25 the the DT 37350 101 26 persistent persistent JJ 37350 101 27 opisthotic opisthotic NN 37350 101 28 . . . 37350 102 1 There there EX 37350 102 2 can can MD 37350 102 3 be be VB 37350 102 4 , , , 37350 102 5 of of IN 37350 102 6 course course NN 37350 102 7 , , , 37350 102 8 no no DT 37350 102 9 question question NN 37350 102 10 of of IN 37350 102 11 the the DT 37350 102 12 nerve nerve NN 37350 102 13 having have VBG 37350 102 14 worked work VBN 37350 102 15 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 102 16 way way NN 37350 102 17 through through IN 37350 102 18 or or CC 37350 102 19 over over IN 37350 102 20 the the DT 37350 102 21 obstructing obstruct VBG 37350 102 22 stapes stape NNS 37350 102 23 in in IN 37350 102 24 order order NN 37350 102 25 to to TO 37350 102 26 come come VB 37350 102 27 below below IN 37350 102 28 it -PRON- PRP 37350 102 29 in in IN 37350 102 30 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 102 31 ; ; : 37350 102 32 rather rather RB 37350 102 33 , , , 37350 102 34 the the DT 37350 102 35 peripheral peripheral JJ 37350 102 36 growth growth NN 37350 102 37 of of IN 37350 102 38 neuron neuron NN 37350 102 39 fibers fiber NNS 37350 102 40 in in IN 37350 102 41 the the DT 37350 102 42 embryo embryo NN 37350 102 43 must must MD 37350 102 44 simply simply RB 37350 102 45 pursue pursue VB 37350 102 46 a a DT 37350 102 47 slightly slightly RB 37350 102 48 different different JJ 37350 102 49 course course NN 37350 102 50 among among IN 37350 102 51 the the DT 37350 102 52 partially partially RB 37350 102 53 differentiated differentiate VBN 37350 102 54 mesenchyme mesenchyme NNS 37350 102 55 in in IN 37350 102 56 the the DT 37350 102 57 two two CD 37350 102 58 contrasting contrast VBG 37350 102 59 patterns pattern NNS 37350 102 60 . . . 37350 103 1 Although although IN 37350 103 2 DeBeer DeBeer NNP 37350 103 3 ( ( -LRB- 37350 103 4 1937 1937 CD 37350 103 5 ) ) -RRB- 37350 103 6 shows show VBZ 37350 103 7 in in IN 37350 103 8 his -PRON- PRP$ 37350 103 9 figure figure NN 37350 103 10 of of IN 37350 103 11 _ _ NNP 37350 103 12 Hypogeophis Hypogeophis NNP 37350 103 13 _ _ NNP 37350 103 14 ( ( -LRB- 37350 103 15 one one CD 37350 103 16 of of IN 37350 103 17 the the DT 37350 103 18 Apoda Apoda NNP 37350 103 19 ) ) -RRB- 37350 103 20 an an DT 37350 103 21 operculum operculum NN 37350 103 22 , , , 37350 103 23 this this DT 37350 103 24 is be VBZ 37350 103 25 apparently apparently RB 37350 103 26 a a DT 37350 103 27 mistake mistake NN 37350 103 28 . . . 37350 104 1 The the DT 37350 104 2 stapes stape NNS 37350 104 3 has have VBZ 37350 104 4 a a DT 37350 104 5 large large JJ 37350 104 6 footplate footplate NN 37350 104 7 , , , 37350 104 8 and and CC 37350 104 9 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 104 10 stylus stylus JJ 37350 104 11 articulates articulate VBZ 37350 104 12 with with IN 37350 104 13 the the DT 37350 104 14 quadrate quadrate NN 37350 104 15 , , , 37350 104 16 but but CC 37350 104 17 no no DT 37350 104 18 true true JJ 37350 104 19 operculum operculum NN 37350 104 20 or or CC 37350 104 21 opercularis opercularis NNP 37350 104 22 has have VBZ 37350 104 23 been be VBN 37350 104 24 described describe VBN 37350 104 25 in in IN 37350 104 26 the the DT 37350 104 27 Apoda Apoda NNP 37350 104 28 . . . 37350 105 1 The the DT 37350 105 2 facial facial JJ 37350 105 3 nerve nerve NN 37350 105 4 passes pass VBZ 37350 105 5 above above IN 37350 105 6 the the DT 37350 105 7 stapes stape NNS 37350 105 8 . . . 37350 106 1 It -PRON- PRP 37350 106 2 does do VBZ 37350 106 3 not not RB 37350 106 4 seem seem VB 37350 106 5 necessary necessary JJ 37350 106 6 to to TO 37350 106 7 regard regard VB 37350 106 8 the the DT 37350 106 9 conditions condition NNS 37350 106 10 in in IN 37350 106 11 this this DT 37350 106 12 order order NN 37350 106 13 as as IN 37350 106 14 related relate VBN 37350 106 15 directly directly RB 37350 106 16 to to IN 37350 106 17 those those DT 37350 106 18 of of IN 37350 106 19 either either DT 37350 106 20 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 106 21 or or CC 37350 106 22 frogs frog NNS 37350 106 23 , , , 37350 106 24 but but CC 37350 106 25 a a DT 37350 106 26 reduction reduction NN 37350 106 27 of of IN 37350 106 28 the the DT 37350 106 29 stapes stape NNS 37350 106 30 comparable comparable JJ 37350 106 31 to to IN 37350 106 32 that that DT 37350 106 33 in in IN 37350 106 34 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 106 35 has have VBZ 37350 106 36 occurred occur VBN 37350 106 37 . . . 37350 107 1 The the DT 37350 107 2 presence presence NN 37350 107 3 in in IN 37350 107 4 both both DT 37350 107 5 frogs frog NNS 37350 107 6 and and CC 37350 107 7 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37350 107 8 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 107 9 of of IN 37350 107 10 a a DT 37350 107 11 special special JJ 37350 107 12 mechanism mechanism NN 37350 107 13 involving involve VBG 37350 107 14 the the DT 37350 107 15 opercularis opercularis NNP 37350 107 16 muscle muscle NN 37350 107 17 and and CC 37350 107 18 an an DT 37350 107 19 operculum operculum NN 37350 107 20 cut cut VBN 37350 107 21 out out RP 37350 107 22 in in IN 37350 107 23 identical identical JJ 37350 107 24 fashion fashion NN 37350 107 25 from from IN 37350 107 26 the the DT 37350 107 27 wall wall NN 37350 107 28 of of IN 37350 107 29 the the DT 37350 107 30 otic otic JJ 37350 107 31 capsule capsule NN 37350 107 32 behind behind IN 37350 107 33 the the DT 37350 107 34 stapes stape NNS 37350 107 35 seems seem VBZ 37350 107 36 to to TO 37350 107 37 require require VB 37350 107 38 some some DT 37350 107 39 other other JJ 37350 107 40 explanation explanation NN 37350 107 41 than than IN 37350 107 42 that that DT 37350 107 43 of of IN 37350 107 44 a a DT 37350 107 45 chance chance NN 37350 107 46 convergence convergence NN 37350 107 47 or or CC 37350 107 48 parallelism parallelism NN 37350 107 49 . . . 37350 108 1 Although although IN 37350 108 2 the the DT 37350 108 3 stapes stape NNS 37350 108 4 and and CC 37350 108 5 otic otic JJ 37350 108 6 region region NN 37350 108 7 are be VBP 37350 108 8 readily readily RB 37350 108 9 visible visible JJ 37350 108 10 in in IN 37350 108 11 a a DT 37350 108 12 number number NN 37350 108 13 of of IN 37350 108 14 labyrinthodonts labyrinthodont NNS 37350 108 15 and and CC 37350 108 16 lepospondyls lepospondyls NNP 37350 108 17 , , , 37350 108 18 no no DT 37350 108 19 indication indication NN 37350 108 20 of of IN 37350 108 21 an an DT 37350 108 22 operculum operculum NN 37350 108 23 seems seem VBZ 37350 108 24 to to TO 37350 108 25 be be VB 37350 108 26 reported report VBN 37350 108 27 among among IN 37350 108 28 them -PRON- PRP 37350 108 29 . . . 37350 109 1 But but CC 37350 109 2 in in IN 37350 109 3 the the DT 37350 109 4 Triassic Triassic NNP 37350 109 5 _ _ NNP 37350 109 6 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 109 7 _ _ NNP 37350 109 8 ( ( -LRB- 37350 109 9 Fig Fig NNP 37350 109 10 . . . 37350 110 1 1 1 LS 37350 110 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 110 3 , , , 37350 110 4 which which WDT 37350 110 5 is be VBZ 37350 110 6 unmistakably unmistakably RB 37350 110 7 a a DT 37350 110 8 frog frog NN 37350 110 9 in in IN 37350 110 10 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 110 11 skull skull NN 37350 110 12 , , , 37350 110 13 pelvis pelvis NNP 37350 110 14 and and CC 37350 110 15 some some DT 37350 110 16 other other JJ 37350 110 17 features feature NNS 37350 110 18 , , , 37350 110 19 Piveteau Piveteau NNP 37350 110 20 ( ( -LRB- 37350 110 21 1937 1937 CD 37350 110 22 ) ) -RRB- 37350 110 23 has have VBZ 37350 110 24 shown show VBN 37350 110 25 , , , 37350 110 26 immediately immediately RB 37350 110 27 behind behind IN 37350 110 28 the the DT 37350 110 29 foot foot NN 37350 110 30 of of IN 37350 110 31 the the DT 37350 110 32 stapes stape NNS 37350 110 33 , , , 37350 110 34 a a DT 37350 110 35 small small JJ 37350 110 36 bony bony NN 37350 110 37 tubercle tubercle NN 37350 110 38 , , , 37350 110 39 which which WDT 37350 110 40 he -PRON- PRP 37350 110 41 and and CC 37350 110 42 Watson Watson NNP 37350 110 43 ( ( -LRB- 37350 110 44 1940 1940 CD 37350 110 45 ) ) -RRB- 37350 110 46 designated designate VBN 37350 110 47 opisthotic opisthotic JJ 37350 110 48 . . . 37350 111 1 Very very RB 37350 111 2 clearly clearly RB 37350 111 3 it -PRON- PRP 37350 111 4 served serve VBD 37350 111 5 for for IN 37350 111 6 insertion insertion NN 37350 111 7 of of IN 37350 111 8 a a DT 37350 111 9 muscle muscle NN 37350 111 10 , , , 37350 111 11 and and CC 37350 111 12 it -PRON- PRP 37350 111 13 is be VBZ 37350 111 14 equally equally RB 37350 111 15 clear clear JJ 37350 111 16 that that IN 37350 111 17 the the DT 37350 111 18 bone bone NN 37350 111 19 is be VBZ 37350 111 20 a a DT 37350 111 21 reduced reduced JJ 37350 111 22 opisthotic opisthotic NN 37350 111 23 , , , 37350 111 24 carrying carry VBG 37350 111 25 the the DT 37350 111 26 paroccipital paroccipital JJ 37350 111 27 process process NN 37350 111 28 already already RB 37350 111 29 mentioned mention VBN 37350 111 30 as as IN 37350 111 31 characteristic characteristic JJ 37350 111 32 of of IN 37350 111 33 it -PRON- PRP 37350 111 34 in in IN 37350 111 35 some some DT 37350 111 36 temnospondyls temnospondyls NN 37350 111 37 . . . 37350 112 1 Since since IN 37350 112 2 the the DT 37350 112 3 remainder remainder NN 37350 112 4 of of IN 37350 112 5 the the DT 37350 112 6 posterior posterior NN 37350 112 7 wall wall NN 37350 112 8 of of IN 37350 112 9 the the DT 37350 112 10 otic otic JJ 37350 112 11 capsule capsule NN 37350 112 12 consists consist VBZ 37350 112 13 of of IN 37350 112 14 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 112 15 , , , 37350 112 16 meeting meet VBG 37350 112 17 the the DT 37350 112 18 exoccipital exoccipital NN 37350 112 19 , , , 37350 112 20 it -PRON- PRP 37350 112 21 may may MD 37350 112 22 be be VB 37350 112 23 that that IN 37350 112 24 the the DT 37350 112 25 opisthotic opisthotic NN 37350 112 26 becomes become VBZ 37350 112 27 the the DT 37350 112 28 operculum operculum NN 37350 112 29 in in IN 37350 112 30 frogs frog NNS 37350 112 31 . . . 37350 113 1 _ _ NNP 37350 113 2 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 113 3 _ _ NNP 37350 113 4 was be VBD 37350 113 5 too too RB 37350 113 6 far far RB 37350 113 7 specialized specialize VBN 37350 113 8 in in IN 37350 113 9 the the DT 37350 113 10 Anuran Anuran NNP 37350 113 11 direction direction NN 37350 113 12 , , , 37350 113 13 although although IN 37350 113 14 it -PRON- PRP 37350 113 15 still still RB 37350 113 16 had have VBD 37350 113 17 a a DT 37350 113 18 tail tail NN 37350 113 19 , , , 37350 113 20 and and CC 37350 113 21 the the DT 37350 113 22 forelegs foreleg NNS 37350 113 23 and and CC 37350 113 24 hind hind NN 37350 113 25 legs leg NNS 37350 113 26 were be VBD 37350 113 27 nearly nearly RB 37350 113 28 the the DT 37350 113 29 same same JJ 37350 113 30 size size NN 37350 113 31 , , , 37350 113 32 to to TO 37350 113 33 be be VB 37350 113 34 considered consider VBN 37350 113 35 a a DT 37350 113 36 possible possible JJ 37350 113 37 ancestor ancestor NN 37350 113 38 of of IN 37350 113 39 the the DT 37350 113 40 Urodeles Urodeles NNP 37350 113 41 . . . 37350 114 1 But but CC 37350 114 2 at at IN 37350 114 3 one one CD 37350 114 4 stage stage NN 37350 114 5 in in IN 37350 114 6 the the DT 37350 114 7 general general JJ 37350 114 8 reduction reduction NN 37350 114 9 of of IN 37350 114 10 the the DT 37350 114 11 skull skull NN 37350 114 12 in in IN 37350 114 13 the the DT 37350 114 14 ancestry ancestry NN 37350 114 15 of of IN 37350 114 16 both both DT 37350 114 17 groups group NNS 37350 114 18 , , , 37350 114 19 a a DT 37350 114 20 condition condition NN 37350 114 21 similar similar JJ 37350 114 22 to to IN 37350 114 23 that that DT 37350 114 24 in in IN 37350 114 25 _ _ NNP 37350 114 26 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 114 27 _ _ NNP 37350 114 28 may may MD 37350 114 29 have have VB 37350 114 30 characterized characterize VBN 37350 114 31 the the DT 37350 114 32 otic otic JJ 37350 114 33 region region NN 37350 114 34 , , , 37350 114 35 long long RB 37350 114 36 before before IN 37350 114 37 the the DT 37350 114 38 Triassic Triassic NNP 37350 114 39 . . . 37350 115 1 In in IN 37350 115 2 the the DT 37350 115 3 argument argument NN 37350 115 4 thus thus RB 37350 115 5 far far RB 37350 115 6 we -PRON- PRP 37350 115 7 have have VBP 37350 115 8 considered consider VBN 37350 115 9 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37350 115 10 , , , 37350 115 11 adult adult NN 37350 115 12 amphibians amphibian NNS 37350 115 13 , , , 37350 115 14 since since IN 37350 115 15 it -PRON- PRP 37350 115 16 is be VBZ 37350 115 17 only only RB 37350 115 18 in in IN 37350 115 19 these these DT 37350 115 20 that that WDT 37350 115 21 either either CC 37350 115 22 the the DT 37350 115 23 normal normal JJ 37350 115 24 middle middle JJ 37350 115 25 ear ear NN 37350 115 26 and and CC 37350 115 27 tympanum tympanum FW 37350 115 28 , , , 37350 115 29 or or CC 37350 115 30 the the DT 37350 115 31 opercular opercular JJ 37350 115 32 apparatus apparatus NN 37350 115 33 , , , 37350 115 34 is be VBZ 37350 115 35 present present JJ 37350 115 36 . . . 37350 116 1 But but CC 37350 116 2 among among IN 37350 116 3 the the DT 37350 116 4 urodeles urodele NNS 37350 116 5 several several JJ 37350 116 6 neotenic neotenic JJ 37350 116 7 types type NNS 37350 116 8 occur occur VBP 37350 116 9 ( ( -LRB- 37350 116 10 this this DT 37350 116 11 term term NN 37350 116 12 applies apply VBZ 37350 116 13 also also RB 37350 116 14 to to IN 37350 116 15 the the DT 37350 116 16 perennibranchs perennibranchs NN 37350 116 17 ) ) -RRB- 37350 116 18 . . . 37350 117 1 For for IN 37350 117 2 most most JJS 37350 117 3 of of IN 37350 117 4 these these DT 37350 117 5 there there EX 37350 117 6 is be VBZ 37350 117 7 nothing nothing NN 37350 117 8 about about IN 37350 117 9 the the DT 37350 117 10 otic otic JJ 37350 117 11 region region NN 37350 117 12 that that WDT 37350 117 13 would would MD 37350 117 14 be be VB 37350 117 15 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 37350 117 16 with with IN 37350 117 17 derivation derivation NN 37350 117 18 , , , 37350 117 19 by by IN 37350 117 20 neoteny neoteny NN 37350 117 21 , , , 37350 117 22 from from IN 37350 117 23 known know VBN 37350 117 24 families family NNS 37350 117 25 in in IN 37350 117 26 which which WDT 37350 117 27 adults adult NNS 37350 117 28 are be VBP 37350 117 29 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37350 117 30 ; ; : 37350 117 31 for for IN 37350 117 32 example example NN 37350 117 33 , , , 37350 117 34 _ _ NNP 37350 117 35 Cryptobranchus Cryptobranchus NNP 37350 117 36 _ _ NNP 37350 117 37 could could MD 37350 117 38 have have VB 37350 117 39 had have VBN 37350 117 40 a a DT 37350 117 41 Hynobiid Hynobiid NNP 37350 117 42 - - HYPH 37350 117 43 like like JJ 37350 117 44 ancestor ancestor NN 37350 117 45 . . . 37350 118 1 But but CC 37350 118 2 this this DT 37350 118 3 , , , 37350 118 4 as as IN 37350 118 5 mentioned mention VBN 37350 118 6 above above RB 37350 118 7 , , , 37350 118 8 does do VBZ 37350 118 9 not not RB 37350 118 10 hold hold VB 37350 118 11 for for IN 37350 118 12 the the DT 37350 118 13 Proteidae Proteidae NNP 37350 118 14 , , , 37350 118 15 which which WDT 37350 118 16 possess possess VBP 37350 118 17 an an DT 37350 118 18 opisthotic opisthotic NN 37350 118 19 of of IN 37350 118 20 relatively relatively RB 37350 118 21 large large JJ 37350 118 22 size size NN 37350 118 23 , , , 37350 118 24 distinctly distinctly RB 37350 118 25 separate separate JJ 37350 118 26 from from IN 37350 118 27 the the DT 37350 118 28 exoccipital exoccipital JJ 37350 118 29 and and CC 37350 118 30 prootic prootic JJ 37350 118 31 . . . 37350 119 1 Either either CC 37350 119 2 this this DT 37350 119 3 bone bone NN 37350 119 4 is be VBZ 37350 119 5 a a DT 37350 119 6 neomorph neomorph NN 37350 119 7 , , , 37350 119 8 which which WDT 37350 119 9 seems seem VBZ 37350 119 10 improbable improbable JJ 37350 119 11 , , , 37350 119 12 or or CC 37350 119 13 there there EX 37350 119 14 has have VBZ 37350 119 15 not not RB 37350 119 16 been be VBN 37350 119 17 in in IN 37350 119 18 the the DT 37350 119 19 ancestry ancestry NN 37350 119 20 of of IN 37350 119 21 this this DT 37350 119 22 particular particular JJ 37350 119 23 family family NN 37350 119 24 an an DT 37350 119 25 episode episode NN 37350 119 26 of of IN 37350 119 27 reduction reduction NN 37350 119 28 comparable comparable JJ 37350 119 29 to to IN 37350 119 30 that that DT 37350 119 31 seen see VBN 37350 119 32 in in IN 37350 119 33 the the DT 37350 119 34 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37350 119 35 families family NNS 37350 119 36 , , , 37350 119 37 where where WRB 37350 119 38 there there EX 37350 119 39 is be VBZ 37350 119 40 an an DT 37350 119 41 operculum operculum NN 37350 119 42 instead instead RB 37350 119 43 of of IN 37350 119 44 a a DT 37350 119 45 normal normal JJ 37350 119 46 opisthotic opisthotic NN 37350 119 47 . . . 37350 120 1 Therefore therefore RB 37350 120 2 the the DT 37350 120 3 Proteidae Proteidae NNP 37350 120 4 probably probably RB 37350 120 5 are be VBP 37350 120 6 not not RB 37350 120 7 derived derive VBN 37350 120 8 from from IN 37350 120 9 the the DT 37350 120 10 general general JJ 37350 120 11 stem stem NN 37350 120 12 of of IN 37350 120 13 other other JJ 37350 120 14 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 120 15 , , , 37350 120 16 but but CC 37350 120 17 diverged diverge VBD 37350 120 18 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37350 120 19 long long RB 37350 120 20 ago ago RB 37350 120 21 that that IN 37350 120 22 the the DT 37350 120 23 bones bone NNS 37350 120 24 of of IN 37350 120 25 the the DT 37350 120 26 otic otic JJ 37350 120 27 region region NN 37350 120 28 were be VBD 37350 120 29 reduced reduce VBN 37350 120 30 on on IN 37350 120 31 a a DT 37350 120 32 different different JJ 37350 120 33 pattern pattern NN 37350 120 34 . . . 37350 121 1 They -PRON- PRP 37350 121 2 need nee MD 37350 121 3 not not RB 37350 121 4 be be VB 37350 121 5 removed remove VBN 37350 121 6 from from IN 37350 121 7 the the DT 37350 121 8 order order NN 37350 121 9 , , , 37350 121 10 but but CC 37350 121 11 , , , 37350 121 12 in in IN 37350 121 13 this this DT 37350 121 14 respect respect NN 37350 121 15 , , , 37350 121 16 recognized recognize VBD 37350 121 17 as as IN 37350 121 18 more more RBR 37350 121 19 primitive primitive JJ 37350 121 20 than than IN 37350 121 21 any any DT 37350 121 22 other other JJ 37350 121 23 existing exist VBG 37350 121 24 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 121 25 or or CC 37350 121 26 Anura Anura NNP 37350 121 27 . . . 37350 122 1 A a DT 37350 122 2 recent recent JJ 37350 122 3 paper paper NN 37350 122 4 by by IN 37350 122 5 Hecht Hecht NNP 37350 122 6 ( ( -LRB- 37350 122 7 1957 1957 CD 37350 122 8 ) ) -RRB- 37350 122 9 discusses discuss VBZ 37350 122 10 many many JJ 37350 122 11 features feature NNS 37350 122 12 of of IN 37350 122 13 _ _ NNP 37350 122 14 Necturus Necturus NNP 37350 122 15 _ _ NNP 37350 122 16 and and CC 37350 122 17 _ _ NNP 37350 122 18 Proteus Proteus NNP 37350 122 19 _ _ NNP 37350 122 20 , , , 37350 122 21 and and CC 37350 122 22 shows show VBZ 37350 122 23 that that IN 37350 122 24 they -PRON- PRP 37350 122 25 are be VBP 37350 122 26 remote remote JJ 37350 122 27 from from IN 37350 122 28 each each DT 37350 122 29 other other JJ 37350 122 30 ; ; : 37350 122 31 his -PRON- PRP$ 37350 122 32 evidence evidence NN 37350 122 33 does do VBZ 37350 122 34 not not RB 37350 122 35 seem seem VB 37350 122 36 to to TO 37350 122 37 prove prove VB 37350 122 38 , , , 37350 122 39 however however RB 37350 122 40 , , , 37350 122 41 that that IN 37350 122 42 they -PRON- PRP 37350 122 43 were be VBD 37350 122 44 of of IN 37350 122 45 independent independent JJ 37350 122 46 origin origin NN 37350 122 47 or or CC 37350 122 48 that that IN 37350 122 49 they -PRON- PRP 37350 122 50 need need VBP 37350 122 51 be be VB 37350 122 52 placed place VBN 37350 122 53 in in IN 37350 122 54 separate separate JJ 37350 122 55 families family NNS 37350 122 56 . . . 37350 123 1 VERTEBRAE vertebrae NN 37350 123 2 AND and CC 37350 123 3 RIBS RIBS NNP 37350 123 4 Development Development NNP 37350 123 5 of of IN 37350 123 6 the the DT 37350 123 7 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 123 8 and and CC 37350 123 9 ribs rib NNS 37350 123 10 of of IN 37350 123 11 Recent Recent NNP 37350 123 12 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 123 13 has have VBZ 37350 123 14 been be VBN 37350 123 15 studied study VBN 37350 123 16 by by IN 37350 123 17 Gamble Gamble NNP 37350 123 18 ( ( -LRB- 37350 123 19 1922 1922 CD 37350 123 20 ) ) -RRB- 37350 123 21 , , , 37350 123 22 Naef Naef NNP 37350 123 23 ( ( -LRB- 37350 123 24 1929 1929 CD 37350 123 25 ) ) -RRB- 37350 123 26 , , , 37350 123 27 Mookerjee Mookerjee NNP 37350 123 28 ( ( -LRB- 37350 123 29 1930 1930 CD 37350 123 30 a a DT 37350 123 31 , , , 37350 123 32 b b NN 37350 123 33 ) ) -RRB- 37350 123 34 , , , 37350 123 35 Gray Gray NNP 37350 123 36 ( ( -LRB- 37350 123 37 1930 1930 CD 37350 123 38 ) ) -RRB- 37350 123 39 and and CC 37350 123 40 Emelianov Emelianov NNP 37350 123 41 ( ( -LRB- 37350 123 42 1936 1936 CD 37350 123 43 ) ) -RRB- 37350 123 44 , , , 37350 123 45 among among IN 37350 123 46 others other NNS 37350 123 47 . . . 37350 124 1 MacBride MacBride NNP 37350 124 2 ( ( -LRB- 37350 124 3 1932 1932 CD 37350 124 4 ) ) -RRB- 37350 124 5 and and CC 37350 124 6 Remane Remane NNP 37350 124 7 ( ( -LRB- 37350 124 8 1938 1938 CD 37350 124 9 ) ) -RRB- 37350 124 10 provide provide VB 37350 124 11 good good JJ 37350 124 12 summaries summary NNS 37350 124 13 . . . 37350 125 1 In in IN 37350 125 2 this this DT 37350 125 3 section section NN 37350 125 4 reference reference NN 37350 125 5 will will MD 37350 125 6 be be VB 37350 125 7 made make VBN 37350 125 8 to to IN 37350 125 9 the the DT 37350 125 10 embryonic embryonic JJ 37350 125 11 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 125 12 cartilages cartilage NNS 37350 125 13 by by IN 37350 125 14 the the DT 37350 125 15 names name NNS 37350 125 16 used use VBN 37350 125 17 for for IN 37350 125 18 them -PRON- PRP 37350 125 19 in in IN 37350 125 20 these these DT 37350 125 21 studies study NNS 37350 125 22 , , , 37350 125 23 although although IN 37350 125 24 the the DT 37350 125 25 concept concept NN 37350 125 26 of of IN 37350 125 27 " " `` 37350 125 28 arcualia arcualia NNP 37350 125 29 " " '' 37350 125 30 is be VBZ 37350 125 31 currently currently RB 37350 125 32 considered consider VBN 37350 125 33 of of IN 37350 125 34 little little JJ 37350 125 35 value value NN 37350 125 36 in in IN 37350 125 37 comparative comparative JJ 37350 125 38 anatomy anatomy NN 37350 125 39 . . . 37350 126 1 [ [ -LRB- 37350 126 2 Illustration illustration NN 37350 126 3 : : : 37350 126 4 Fig Fig NNP 37350 126 5 . . . 37350 127 1 5 5 CD 37350 127 2 . . . 37350 128 1 Development development NN 37350 128 2 of of IN 37350 128 3 Anuran Anuran NNP 37350 128 4 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 128 5 . . . 37350 129 1 Upper upper JJ 37350 129 2 left left NN 37350 129 3 , , , 37350 129 4 late late JJ 37350 129 5 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 129 6 of of IN 37350 129 7 _ _ NNP 37350 129 8 Xenopus Xenopus NNP 37350 129 9 laevis laevis NN 37350 129 10 _ _ NNP 37350 129 11 ; ; : 37350 129 12 lower low JJR 37350 129 13 left left JJ 37350 129 14 , , , 37350 129 15 same same JJ 37350 129 16 just just RB 37350 129 17 after after IN 37350 129 18 metamorphosis metamorphosis NN 37350 129 19 ; ; : 37350 129 20 upper upper JJ 37350 129 21 right right NN 37350 129 22 , , , 37350 129 23 diagram diagram NN 37350 129 24 of of IN 37350 129 25 general general JJ 37350 129 26 components component NNS 37350 129 27 of of IN 37350 129 28 primitive primitive JJ 37350 129 29 Anuran Anuran NNP 37350 129 30 vertebra vertebra NNS 37350 129 31 . . . 37350 130 1 ( ( -LRB- 37350 130 2 After after IN 37350 130 3 MacBride MacBride NNP 37350 130 4 , , , 37350 130 5 1932 1932 CD 37350 130 6 , , , 37350 130 7 Figs fig NNS 37350 130 8 . . . 37350 131 1 35 35 CD 37350 131 2 , , , 37350 131 3 38 38 CD 37350 131 4 , , , 37350 131 5 47D 47d CD 37350 131 6 , , , 37350 131 7 respectively respectively RB 37350 131 8 . . . 37350 131 9 ) ) -RRB- 37350 132 1 Lower lower RBR 37350 132 2 right right JJ 37350 132 3 , , , 37350 132 4 section section NN 37350 132 5 through through IN 37350 132 6 anterior anterior JJ 37350 132 7 portion portion NN 37350 132 8 of of IN 37350 132 9 urostyle urostyle NNS 37350 132 10 , , , 37350 132 11 immediately immediately RB 37350 132 12 posterior posterior RB 37350 132 13 to to IN 37350 132 14 sacral sacral JJ 37350 132 15 vertebra vertebra NNS 37350 132 16 , , , 37350 132 17 in in IN 37350 132 18 transforming transform VBG 37350 132 19 _ _ NNP 37350 132 20 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 132 21 truei truei NN 37350 132 22 _ _ NNP 37350 132 23 ( ( -LRB- 37350 132 24 original original JJ 37350 132 25 , , , 37350 132 26 from from IN 37350 132 27 specimen speciman NNS 37350 132 28 collected collect VBN 37350 132 29 on on IN 37350 132 30 Olympic Olympic NNP 37350 132 31 Peninsula Peninsula NNP 37350 132 32 , , , 37350 132 33 Washington Washington NNP 37350 132 34 ) ) -RRB- 37350 132 35 . . . 37350 133 1 All all DT 37350 133 2 × × NNS 37350 133 3 20 20 CD 37350 133 4 approx approx NN 37350 133 5 . . . 37350 134 1 For for IN 37350 134 2 explanation explanation NN 37350 134 3 of of IN 37350 134 4 abbreviations abbreviation NNS 37350 134 5 see see VBP 37350 134 6 Fig Fig NNP 37350 134 7 . . . 37350 135 1 3 3 LS 37350 135 2 . . . 37350 135 3 ] ] -RRB- 37350 136 1 The the DT 37350 136 2 centrum centrum NN 37350 136 3 in in IN 37350 136 4 Anura Anura NNP 37350 136 5 ( ( -LRB- 37350 136 6 Fig fig NN 37350 136 7 . . . 37350 137 1 5 5 LS 37350 137 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 137 3 is be VBZ 37350 137 4 formed form VBN 37350 137 5 in in IN 37350 137 6 the the DT 37350 137 7 perichordal perichordal NN 37350 137 8 sheath sheath NN 37350 137 9 ( ( -LRB- 37350 137 10 _ _ NNP 37350 137 11 Rana Rana NNP 37350 137 12 _ _ NNP 37350 137 13 , , , 37350 137 14 _ _ NNP 37350 137 15 Bufo Bufo NNP 37350 137 16 _ _ NNP 37350 137 17 ) ) -RRB- 37350 137 18 or or CC 37350 137 19 only only RB 37350 137 20 in in IN 37350 137 21 the the DT 37350 137 22 dorsal dorsal NN 37350 137 23 portion portion NN 37350 137 24 thereof thereof RB 37350 137 25 ( ( -LRB- 37350 137 26 _ _ NNP 37350 137 27 Bombinator Bombinator NNP 37350 137 28 _ _ NNP 37350 137 29 , , , 37350 137 30 _ _ NNP 37350 137 31 Xenopus Xenopus NNP 37350 137 32 _ _ NNP 37350 137 33 ) ) -RRB- 37350 137 34 . . . 37350 138 1 The the DT 37350 138 2 neural neural JJ 37350 138 3 arch arch NN 37350 138 4 develops develop VBZ 37350 138 5 from from IN 37350 138 6 the the DT 37350 138 7 basidorsal basidorsal NN 37350 138 8 cartilages cartilage NNS 37350 138 9 that that WDT 37350 138 10 rest rest VBP 37350 138 11 upon upon IN 37350 138 12 , , , 37350 138 13 and and CC 37350 138 14 at at IN 37350 138 15 first first RB 37350 138 16 are be VBP 37350 138 17 entirely entirely RB 37350 138 18 distinct distinct JJ 37350 138 19 from from IN 37350 138 20 , , , 37350 138 21 the the DT 37350 138 22 perichordal perichordal NN 37350 138 23 sheath sheath NN 37350 138 24 . . . 37350 139 1 Ribs Ribs NNP 37350 139 2 , , , 37350 139 3 present present JJ 37350 139 4 as as IN 37350 139 5 separate separate JJ 37350 139 6 cartilages cartilage NNS 37350 139 7 associated associate VBN 37350 139 8 with with IN 37350 139 9 the the DT 37350 139 10 2nd 2nd JJ 37350 139 11 , , , 37350 139 12 3rd 3rd JJ 37350 139 13 and and CC 37350 139 14 4th 4th JJ 37350 139 15 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 139 16 in in IN 37350 139 17 the the DT 37350 139 18 larvae larvae NN 37350 139 19 of of IN 37350 139 20 _ _ NNP 37350 139 21 Xenopus Xenopus NNP 37350 139 22 _ _ NNP 37350 139 23 and and CC 37350 139 24 _ _ NNP 37350 139 25 Bombinator Bombinator NNP 37350 139 26 _ _ NNP 37350 139 27 , , , 37350 139 28 fuse fuse NN 37350 139 29 with with IN 37350 139 30 lateral lateral JJ 37350 139 31 processes process NNS 37350 139 32 ( ( -LRB- 37350 139 33 diapophyses diapophysis NNS 37350 139 34 ) ) -RRB- 37350 139 35 of of IN 37350 139 36 the the DT 37350 139 37 neural neural JJ 37350 139 38 arches arch NNS 37350 139 39 at at IN 37350 139 40 metamorphosis metamorphosis NN 37350 139 41 , , , 37350 139 42 but but CC 37350 139 43 in in IN 37350 139 44 _ _ NNP 37350 139 45 Leiopelma Leiopelma NNP 37350 139 46 _ _ NNP 37350 139 47 and and CC 37350 139 48 _ _ NNP 37350 139 49 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 139 50 _ _ NNP 37350 139 51 the the DT 37350 139 52 ribs rib NNS 37350 139 53 remain remain VBP 37350 139 54 freely freely RB 37350 139 55 articulated articulate VBN 37350 139 56 in in IN 37350 139 57 the the DT 37350 139 58 adult adult NN 37350 139 59 . . . 37350 140 1 Basiventral basiventral JJ 37350 140 2 arcualia arcualia NNS 37350 140 3 have have VBP 37350 140 4 been be VBN 37350 140 5 supposed suppose VBN 37350 140 6 to to TO 37350 140 7 be be VB 37350 140 8 represented represent VBN 37350 140 9 by by IN 37350 140 10 the the DT 37350 140 11 hypochord hypochord NN 37350 140 12 , , , 37350 140 13 a a DT 37350 140 14 median median JJ 37350 140 15 rod rod NN 37350 140 16 of of IN 37350 140 17 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 140 18 beneath beneath IN 37350 140 19 the the DT 37350 140 20 shrinking shrink VBG 37350 140 21 notochord notochord NN 37350 140 22 in in IN 37350 140 23 the the DT 37350 140 24 postsacral postsacral JJ 37350 140 25 region region NN 37350 140 26 , , , 37350 140 27 which which WDT 37350 140 28 at at IN 37350 140 29 metamorphosis metamorphosis NN 37350 140 30 ossifies ossify VBZ 37350 140 31 to to TO 37350 140 32 produce produce VB 37350 140 33 the the DT 37350 140 34 bulk bulk NN 37350 140 35 of of IN 37350 140 36 the the DT 37350 140 37 urostyle urostyle NNS 37350 140 38 . . . 37350 141 1 Fig fig NN 37350 141 2 . . . 37350 142 1 5 5 CD 37350 142 2 , , , 37350 142 3 lower lower RBR 37350 142 4 right right JJ 37350 142 5 , , , 37350 142 6 a a DT 37350 142 7 transverse transverse JJ 37350 142 8 section section NN 37350 142 9 taken take VBN 37350 142 10 immediately immediately RB 37350 142 11 posterior posterior RB 37350 142 12 to to IN 37350 142 13 the the DT 37350 142 14 sacral sacral JJ 37350 142 15 ribs rib NNS 37350 142 16 in in IN 37350 142 17 a a DT 37350 142 18 transforming transform VBG 37350 142 19 specimen speciman NNS 37350 142 20 of of IN 37350 142 21 _ _ NNP 37350 142 22 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 142 23 _ _ NNP 37350 142 24 , , , 37350 142 25 shows show VBZ 37350 142 26 that that IN 37350 142 27 the the DT 37350 142 28 " " `` 37350 142 29 hypochord hypochord NN 37350 142 30 " " '' 37350 142 31 is be VBZ 37350 142 32 a a DT 37350 142 33 mass mass NN 37350 142 34 of of IN 37350 142 35 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 142 36 formed form VBN 37350 142 37 in in IN 37350 142 38 the the DT 37350 142 39 perichordal perichordal NN 37350 142 40 sheath sheath NN 37350 142 41 itself -PRON- PRP 37350 142 42 , , , 37350 142 43 and and CC 37350 142 44 very very RB 37350 142 45 obviously obviously RB 37350 142 46 is be VBZ 37350 142 47 derived derive VBN 37350 142 48 from from IN 37350 142 49 the the DT 37350 142 50 ventral ventral JJ 37350 142 51 part part NN 37350 142 52 of of IN 37350 142 53 postsacral postsacral JJ 37350 142 54 perichordal perichordal NN 37350 142 55 centra centra NNP 37350 142 56 ; ; : 37350 142 57 there there EX 37350 142 58 are be VBP 37350 142 59 , , , 37350 142 60 then then RB 37350 142 61 , , , 37350 142 62 no no DT 37350 142 63 basiventral basiventral JJ 37350 142 64 arcualia arcualia NNP 37350 142 65 , , , 37350 142 66 and and CC 37350 142 67 the the DT 37350 142 68 discrete discrete JJ 37350 142 69 hypochord hypochord NN 37350 142 70 shown show VBN 37350 142 71 in in IN 37350 142 72 MacBride MacBride NNP 37350 142 73 's 's POS 37350 142 74 diagram diagram NN 37350 142 75 ( ( -LRB- 37350 142 76 Fig fig NN 37350 142 77 . . . 37350 143 1 5 5 CD 37350 143 2 , , , 37350 143 3 upper upper JJ 37350 143 4 right right NN 37350 143 5 ) ) -RRB- 37350 143 6 of of IN 37350 143 7 a a DT 37350 143 8 frog frog JJ 37350 143 9 vertebra vertebra NN 37350 143 10 does do VBZ 37350 143 11 not not RB 37350 143 12 actually actually RB 37350 143 13 occur occur VB 37350 143 14 below below IN 37350 143 15 the the DT 37350 143 16 centrum centrum NN 37350 143 17 , , , 37350 143 18 but but CC 37350 143 19 only only RB 37350 143 20 below below IN 37350 143 21 the the DT 37350 143 22 notochord notochord NN 37350 143 23 in in IN 37350 143 24 the the DT 37350 143 25 postsacral postsacral JJ 37350 143 26 region region NN 37350 143 27 . . . 37350 144 1 [ [ -LRB- 37350 144 2 Illustration illustration NN 37350 144 3 : : : 37350 144 4 Fig Fig NNP 37350 144 5 . . . 37350 145 1 6 6 CD 37350 145 2 . . . 37350 146 1 Development development NN 37350 146 2 of of IN 37350 146 3 Urodele Urodele NNP 37350 146 4 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 146 5 . . . 37350 147 1 Upper upper JJ 37350 147 2 figures figure NNS 37350 147 3 , , , 37350 147 4 _ _ NNP 37350 147 5 Triton Triton NNP 37350 147 6 _ _ NNP 37350 147 7 : : : 37350 147 8 at at IN 37350 147 9 left left NN 37350 147 10 , , , 37350 147 11 larva larva NNP 37350 147 12 at at IN 37350 147 13 20 20 CD 37350 147 14 mm mm NNS 37350 147 15 . . NNP 37350 147 16 , , , 37350 147 17 at at IN 37350 147 18 right right NN 37350 147 19 , , , 37350 147 20 diagram diagram NN 37350 147 21 of of IN 37350 147 22 components component NNS 37350 147 23 of of IN 37350 147 24 vertebra vertebra NNP 37350 147 25 ( ( -LRB- 37350 147 26 from from IN 37350 147 27 MacBride MacBride NNP 37350 147 28 , , , 37350 147 29 1932 1932 CD 37350 147 30 , , , 37350 147 31 figs fig NNS 37350 147 32 . . . 37350 148 1 17 17 CD 37350 148 2 , , , 37350 148 3 47C 47c CD 37350 148 4 ) ) -RRB- 37350 148 5 . . . 37350 149 1 Middle middle JJ 37350 149 2 figures figure NNS 37350 149 3 , , , 37350 149 4 _ _ NNP 37350 149 5 Molge Molge NNP 37350 149 6 vulgaris vulgaris NNP 37350 149 7 _ _ NNP 37350 149 8 larva larva NN 37350 149 9 : : : 37350 149 10 left leave VBN 37350 149 11 , , , 37350 149 12 at at IN 37350 149 13 18 18 CD 37350 149 14 mm mm NNS 37350 149 15 . . . 37350 150 1 ; ; : 37350 150 2 middle middle JJ 37350 150 3 , , , 37350 150 4 at at IN 37350 150 5 20 20 CD 37350 150 6 - - SYM 37350 150 7 22 22 CD 37350 150 8 mm mm NN 37350 150 9 . . . 37350 151 1 ; ; : 37350 151 2 right right UH 37350 151 3 , , , 37350 151 4 at at IN 37350 151 5 25 25 CD 37350 151 6 mm mm NNS 37350 151 7 . . . 37350 152 1 ( ( -LRB- 37350 152 2 from from IN 37350 152 3 Emelianov Emelianov NNP 37350 152 4 , , , 37350 152 5 1936 1936 CD 37350 152 6 , , , 37350 152 7 figs fig NNS 37350 152 8 . . . 37350 153 1 33 33 CD 37350 153 2 , , , 37350 153 3 36 36 CD 37350 153 4 , , , 37350 153 5 38 38 CD 37350 153 6 respectively respectively RB 37350 153 7 ) ) -RRB- 37350 153 8 . . . 37350 154 1 Lower low JJR 37350 154 2 figures figure NNS 37350 154 3 , , , 37350 154 4 _ _ NNP 37350 154 5 Necturus Necturus NNP 37350 154 6 maculosus maculosus NN 37350 154 7 _ _ NNP 37350 154 8 larva larva NN 37350 154 9 : : : 37350 154 10 left leave VBN 37350 154 11 , , , 37350 154 12 at at IN 37350 154 13 21 21 CD 37350 154 14 mm mm NNS 37350 154 15 . . . 37350 155 1 ; ; : 37350 155 2 right right UH 37350 155 3 , , , 37350 155 4 at at IN 37350 155 5 20 20 CD 37350 155 6 mm mm NNS 37350 155 7 . . . 37350 156 1 ( ( -LRB- 37350 156 2 from from IN 37350 156 3 MacBride MacBride NNP 37350 156 4 , , , 37350 156 5 1932 1932 CD 37350 156 6 , , , 37350 156 7 figs fig NNS 37350 156 8 . . . 37350 157 1 41.5 41.5 CD 37350 157 2 , , , 37350 157 3 41.3 41.3 CD 37350 157 4 respectively respectively RB 37350 157 5 , , , 37350 157 6 after after IN 37350 157 7 Gamble Gamble NNP 37350 157 8 , , , 37350 157 9 1922 1922 CD 37350 157 10 ) ) -RRB- 37350 157 11 . . . 37350 158 1 All all DT 37350 158 2 × × NNS 37350 158 3 20 20 CD 37350 158 4 approx approx NN 37350 158 5 . . . 37350 159 1 For for IN 37350 159 2 explanation explanation NN 37350 159 3 of of IN 37350 159 4 abbreviations abbreviation NNS 37350 159 5 see see VBP 37350 159 6 Fig Fig NNP 37350 159 7 . . . 37350 160 1 3 3 LS 37350 160 2 . . . 37350 160 3 ] ] -RRB- 37350 161 1 In in IN 37350 161 2 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 161 3 ( ( -LRB- 37350 161 4 Fig Fig NNP 37350 161 5 . . . 37350 162 1 6 6 LS 37350 162 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 162 3 the the DT 37350 162 4 pattern pattern NN 37350 162 5 of of IN 37350 162 6 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 162 7 and and CC 37350 162 8 rib rib NN 37350 162 9 development development NN 37350 162 10 is be VBZ 37350 162 11 more more RBR 37350 162 12 complex complex JJ 37350 162 13 , , , 37350 162 14 and and CC 37350 162 15 there there EX 37350 162 16 has have VBZ 37350 162 17 been be VBN 37350 162 18 much much JJ 37350 162 19 controversy controversy NN 37350 162 20 over over IN 37350 162 21 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 162 22 interpretation interpretation NN 37350 162 23 . . . 37350 163 1 Neural neural JJ 37350 163 2 arches arch NNS 37350 163 3 and and CC 37350 163 4 perichordal perichordal NN 37350 163 5 centra centra NNP 37350 163 6 form form NN 37350 163 7 in in IN 37350 163 8 the the DT 37350 163 9 same same JJ 37350 163 10 manner manner NN 37350 163 11 as as IN 37350 163 12 in in IN 37350 163 13 frogs frog NNS 37350 163 14 , , , 37350 163 15 but but CC 37350 163 16 with with IN 37350 163 17 the the DT 37350 163 18 addition addition NN 37350 163 19 in in IN 37350 163 20 certain certain JJ 37350 163 21 cases case NNS 37350 163 22 ( ( -LRB- 37350 163 23 _ _ NNP 37350 163 24 Triton Triton NNP 37350 163 25 _ _ NNP 37350 163 26 ) ) -RRB- 37350 163 27 of of IN 37350 163 28 a a DT 37350 163 29 median median JJ 37350 163 30 supradorsal supradorsal NN 37350 163 31 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 163 32 , , , 37350 163 33 which which WDT 37350 163 34 gives give VBZ 37350 163 35 rise rise NN 37350 163 36 to to IN 37350 163 37 the the DT 37350 163 38 zygapophyses zygapophyse NNS 37350 163 39 of of IN 37350 163 40 each each DT 37350 163 41 neural neural JJ 37350 163 42 arch arch NN 37350 163 43 . . . 37350 164 1 Difficulty difficulty NN 37350 164 2 comes come VBZ 37350 164 3 , , , 37350 164 4 however however RB 37350 164 5 , , , 37350 164 6 in in IN 37350 164 7 understanding understand VBG 37350 164 8 the the DT 37350 164 9 relationship relationship NN 37350 164 10 of of IN 37350 164 11 the the DT 37350 164 12 ribs rib NNS 37350 164 13 to to IN 37350 164 14 the the DT 37350 164 15 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 164 16 . . . 37350 165 1 Each each DT 37350 165 2 rib rib NN 37350 165 3 , , , 37350 165 4 usually usually RB 37350 165 5 two two CD 37350 165 6 - - HYPH 37350 165 7 headed head VBN 37350 165 8 , , , 37350 165 9 articulates articulate VBZ 37350 165 10 with with IN 37350 165 11 a a DT 37350 165 12 " " `` 37350 165 13 transverse transverse JJ 37350 165 14 process process NN 37350 165 15 " " '' 37350 165 16 that that IN 37350 165 17 in in IN 37350 165 18 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 165 19 early early JJ 37350 165 20 development development NN 37350 165 21 seems seem VBZ 37350 165 22 to to TO 37350 165 23 be be VB 37350 165 24 separate separate JJ 37350 165 25 from from IN 37350 165 26 both both CC 37350 165 27 the the DT 37350 165 28 vertebra vertebra NNS 37350 165 29 and and CC 37350 165 30 the the DT 37350 165 31 rib rib NN 37350 165 32 , , , 37350 165 33 and and CC 37350 165 34 is be VBZ 37350 165 35 therefore therefore RB 37350 165 36 known know VBN 37350 165 37 , , , 37350 165 38 noncommittally noncommittally RB 37350 165 39 , , , 37350 165 40 as as IN 37350 165 41 " " `` 37350 165 42 rib rib NN 37350 165 43 - - HYPH 37350 165 44 bearer bearer NN 37350 165 45 . . . 37350 165 46 " " '' 37350 166 1 This this DT 37350 166 2 lies lie VBZ 37350 166 3 laterally laterally RB 37350 166 4 from from IN 37350 166 5 the the DT 37350 166 6 centrum centrum NN 37350 166 7 , , , 37350 166 8 neural neural JJ 37350 166 9 arch arch NNP 37350 166 10 , , , 37350 166 11 and and CC 37350 166 12 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 166 13 artery artery NN 37350 166 14 ; ; : 37350 166 15 upon upon IN 37350 166 16 fusing fuse VBG 37350 166 17 with with IN 37350 166 18 the the DT 37350 166 19 vertebra vertebra NN 37350 166 20 it -PRON- PRP 37350 166 21 therefore therefore RB 37350 166 22 encloses enclose VBZ 37350 166 23 the the DT 37350 166 24 artery artery NN 37350 166 25 in in IN 37350 166 26 a a DT 37350 166 27 foramen foraman NNS 37350 166 28 separate separate JJ 37350 166 29 from from IN 37350 166 30 the the DT 37350 166 31 one one CD 37350 166 32 between between IN 37350 166 33 the the DT 37350 166 34 capitulum capitulum NN 37350 166 35 and and CC 37350 166 36 tuberculum tuberculum NN 37350 166 37 of of IN 37350 166 38 the the DT 37350 166 39 rib rib NN 37350 166 40 ( ( -LRB- 37350 166 41 the the DT 37350 166 42 usual usual JJ 37350 166 43 location location NN 37350 166 44 of of IN 37350 166 45 the the DT 37350 166 46 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 166 47 artery artery NN 37350 166 48 ) ) -RRB- 37350 166 49 . . . 37350 167 1 At at RB 37350 167 2 least least JJS 37350 167 3 four four CD 37350 167 4 different different JJ 37350 167 5 interpretations interpretation NNS 37350 167 6 of of IN 37350 167 7 these these DT 37350 167 8 structures structure NNS 37350 167 9 have have VBP 37350 167 10 been be VBN 37350 167 11 suggested suggest VBN 37350 167 12 : : : 37350 167 13 ( ( -LRB- 37350 167 14 1 1 LS 37350 167 15 ) ) -RRB- 37350 167 16 Naef Naef NNP 37350 167 17 ( ( -LRB- 37350 167 18 1929 1929 CD 37350 167 19 ) ) -RRB- 37350 167 20 considered consider VBD 37350 167 21 the the DT 37350 167 22 rib rib NN 37350 167 23 - - HYPH 37350 167 24 bearer bearer NN 37350 167 25 a a DT 37350 167 26 derivative derivative NN 37350 167 27 of of IN 37350 167 28 the the DT 37350 167 29 basiventral basiventral NN 37350 167 30 , , , 37350 167 31 which which WDT 37350 167 32 , , , 37350 167 33 by by IN 37350 167 34 spreading spread VBG 37350 167 35 laterally laterally RB 37350 167 36 and and CC 37350 167 37 dorsally dorsally RB 37350 167 38 to to TO 37350 167 39 meet meet VB 37350 167 40 the the DT 37350 167 41 neural neural JJ 37350 167 42 arch arch NNP 37350 167 43 , , , 37350 167 44 enclosed enclose VBD 37350 167 45 the the DT 37350 167 46 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 167 47 artery artery NN 37350 167 48 . . . 37350 168 1 He -PRON- PRP 37350 168 2 then then RB 37350 168 3 supposed suppose VBD 37350 168 4 that that IN 37350 168 5 by by IN 37350 168 6 reduction reduction NN 37350 168 7 of of IN 37350 168 8 the the DT 37350 168 9 rib rib NN 37350 168 10 - - HYPH 37350 168 11 bearer bearer NN 37350 168 12 in in IN 37350 168 13 other other JJ 37350 168 14 tetrapods tetrapod NNS 37350 168 15 ( ( -LRB- 37350 168 16 frogs frog NNS 37350 168 17 and and CC 37350 168 18 amniotes amniote NNS 37350 168 19 ) ) -RRB- 37350 168 20 the the DT 37350 168 21 vertebrarterial vertebrarterial JJ 37350 168 22 foramen foraman NNS 37350 168 23 and and CC 37350 168 24 costal costal JJ 37350 168 25 foramen foraman NNS 37350 168 26 were be VBD 37350 168 27 brought bring VBN 37350 168 28 together together RB 37350 168 29 in in IN 37350 168 30 a a DT 37350 168 31 single single JJ 37350 168 32 foramen foraman NNS 37350 168 33 transversarium transversarium NN 37350 168 34 . . . 37350 169 1 The the DT 37350 169 2 implication implication NN 37350 169 3 is be VBZ 37350 169 4 that that IN 37350 169 5 the the DT 37350 169 6 Urodele Urodele NNP 37350 169 7 condition condition NN 37350 169 8 is be VBZ 37350 169 9 primitive primitive JJ 37350 169 10 , , , 37350 169 11 but but CC 37350 169 12 it -PRON- PRP 37350 169 13 can can MD 37350 169 14 not not RB 37350 169 15 now now RB 37350 169 16 be be VB 37350 169 17 supposed suppose VBN 37350 169 18 that that IN 37350 169 19 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 169 20 are be VBP 37350 169 21 ancestral ancestral JJ 37350 169 22 to to IN 37350 169 23 any any DT 37350 169 24 other other JJ 37350 169 25 group group NN 37350 169 26 , , , 37350 169 27 and and CC 37350 169 28 the the DT 37350 169 29 rib rib NN 37350 169 30 - - HYPH 37350 169 31 bearer bearer NN 37350 169 32 is be VBZ 37350 169 33 most most RBS 37350 169 34 probably probably RB 37350 169 35 a a DT 37350 169 36 specialization specialization NN 37350 169 37 limited limit VBN 37350 169 38 to to IN 37350 169 39 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 169 40 . . . 37350 170 1 This this DT 37350 170 2 does do VBZ 37350 170 3 not not RB 37350 170 4 , , , 37350 170 5 of of IN 37350 170 6 course course NN 37350 170 7 , , , 37350 170 8 invalidate invalidate VB 37350 170 9 the the DT 37350 170 10 first first JJ 37350 170 11 part part NN 37350 170 12 of of IN 37350 170 13 his -PRON- PRP$ 37350 170 14 interpretation interpretation NN 37350 170 15 . . . 37350 171 1 ( ( -LRB- 37350 171 2 2 2 LS 37350 171 3 ) ) -RRB- 37350 171 4 Remane Remane NNP 37350 171 5 ( ( -LRB- 37350 171 6 1938 1938 CD 37350 171 7 ) ) -RRB- 37350 171 8 , , , 37350 171 9 noting note VBG 37350 171 10 that that IN 37350 171 11 rib rib NN 37350 171 12 insertions insertion NNS 37350 171 13 of of IN 37350 171 14 early early JJ 37350 171 15 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 171 16 are be VBP 37350 171 17 essentially essentially RB 37350 171 18 as as IN 37350 171 19 in in IN 37350 171 20 Amniota Amniota NNP 37350 171 21 , , , 37350 171 22 argued argue VBD 37350 171 23 that that IN 37350 171 24 the the DT 37350 171 25 rib rib NN 37350 171 26 - - HYPH 37350 171 27 bearer bearer NN 37350 171 28 is be VBZ 37350 171 29 not not RB 37350 171 30 from from IN 37350 171 31 the the DT 37350 171 32 basiventral basiventral NN 37350 171 33 but but CC 37350 171 34 is be VBZ 37350 171 35 a a DT 37350 171 36 neomorph neomorph NN 37350 171 37 which which WDT 37350 171 38 originates originate VBZ 37350 171 39 directly directly RB 37350 171 40 from from IN 37350 171 41 the the DT 37350 171 42 neural neural JJ 37350 171 43 arch arch NN 37350 171 44 and and CC 37350 171 45 grows grow VBZ 37350 171 46 ventrally ventrally RB 37350 171 47 . . . 37350 172 1 This this DT 37350 172 2 he -PRON- PRP 37350 172 3 inferred infer VBD 37350 172 4 mainly mainly RB 37350 172 5 from from IN 37350 172 6 Gamble Gamble NNP 37350 172 7 's 's POS 37350 172 8 ( ( -LRB- 37350 172 9 1922 1922 CD 37350 172 10 ) ) -RRB- 37350 172 11 observation observation NN 37350 172 12 on on IN 37350 172 13 _ _ NNP 37350 172 14 Necturus Necturus NNP 37350 172 15 _ _ NNP 37350 172 16 , , , 37350 172 17 but but CC 37350 172 18 his -PRON- PRP$ 37350 172 19 assumption assumption NN 37350 172 20 that that IN 37350 172 21 _ _ NNP 37350 172 22 Necturus Necturus NNP 37350 172 23 _ _ NNP 37350 172 24 is be VBZ 37350 172 25 more more RBR 37350 172 26 primitive primitive JJ 37350 172 27 than than IN 37350 172 28 other other JJ 37350 172 29 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 172 30 ( ( -LRB- 37350 172 31 such such JJ 37350 172 32 as as IN 37350 172 33 the the DT 37350 172 34 Salamandridae Salamandridae NNP 37350 172 35 ) ) -RRB- 37350 172 36 , , , 37350 172 37 where where WRB 37350 172 38 the the DT 37350 172 39 pattern pattern NN 37350 172 40 differs differ VBZ 37350 172 41 from from IN 37350 172 42 this this DT 37350 172 43 , , , 37350 172 44 is be VBZ 37350 172 45 not not RB 37350 172 46 necessarily necessarily RB 37350 172 47 correct correct JJ 37350 172 48 . . . 37350 173 1 Rather rather RB 37350 173 2 , , , 37350 173 3 the the DT 37350 173 4 perennibranchs perennibranch NNS 37350 173 5 are be VBP 37350 173 6 distinguished distinguish VBN 37350 173 7 mainly mainly RB 37350 173 8 by by IN 37350 173 9 their -PRON- PRP$ 37350 173 10 neotenous neotenous JJ 37350 173 11 features feature NNS 37350 173 12 , , , 37350 173 13 and and CC 37350 173 14 their -PRON- PRP$ 37350 173 15 development development NN 37350 173 16 is be VBZ 37350 173 17 likely likely JJ 37350 173 18 to to TO 37350 173 19 show show VB 37350 173 20 simplifications simplification NNS 37350 173 21 which which WDT 37350 173 22 are be VBP 37350 173 23 not not RB 37350 173 24 necessarily necessarily RB 37350 173 25 primitive primitive JJ 37350 173 26 . . . 37350 174 1 The the DT 37350 174 2 suggestion suggestion NN 37350 174 3 of of IN 37350 174 4 a a DT 37350 174 5 " " `` 37350 174 6 neomorph neomorph NN 37350 174 7 " " '' 37350 174 8 ought ought MD 37350 174 9 not not RB 37350 174 10 to to TO 37350 174 11 be be VB 37350 174 12 made make VBN 37350 174 13 except except IN 37350 174 14 as as IN 37350 174 15 a a DT 37350 174 16 last last JJ 37350 174 17 resort resort NN 37350 174 18 , , , 37350 174 19 for for IN 37350 174 20 it -PRON- PRP 37350 174 21 is be VBZ 37350 174 22 simply simply RB 37350 174 23 an an DT 37350 174 24 acknowledgment acknowledgment NN 37350 174 25 that that IN 37350 174 26 the the DT 37350 174 27 author author NN 37350 174 28 does do VBZ 37350 174 29 not not RB 37350 174 30 recognize recognize VB 37350 174 31 homology homology NN 37350 174 32 with with IN 37350 174 33 any any DT 37350 174 34 structure structure NN 37350 174 35 already already RB 37350 174 36 known know VBN 37350 174 37 ; ; : 37350 174 38 sometimes sometimes RB 37350 174 39 further further JJ 37350 174 40 information information NN 37350 174 41 will will MD 37350 174 42 make make VB 37350 174 43 such such JJ 37350 174 44 recognition recognition NN 37350 174 45 possible possible JJ 37350 174 46 . . . 37350 175 1 ( ( -LRB- 37350 175 2 3 3 LS 37350 175 3 ) ) -RRB- 37350 175 4 Gray Gray NNP 37350 175 5 ( ( -LRB- 37350 175 6 1930 1930 CD 37350 175 7 ) ) -RRB- 37350 175 8 , , , 37350 175 9 using use VBG 37350 175 10 _ _ NNP 37350 175 11 Molge Molge NNP 37350 175 12 taeniatus taeniatus NNP 37350 175 13 _ _ NNP 37350 175 14 , , , 37350 175 15 concluded conclude VBD 37350 175 16 that that IN 37350 175 17 the the DT 37350 175 18 normal normal JJ 37350 175 19 capitulum capitulum NN 37350 175 20 of of IN 37350 175 21 the the DT 37350 175 22 rib rib NN 37350 175 23 was be VBD 37350 175 24 lost lose VBN 37350 175 25 , , , 37350 175 26 but but CC 37350 175 27 that that IN 37350 175 28 the the DT 37350 175 29 tuberculum tuberculum NN 37350 175 30 bifurcated bifurcate VBD 37350 175 31 to to TO 37350 175 32 make make VB 37350 175 33 the the DT 37350 175 34 two two CD 37350 175 35 heads head NNS 37350 175 36 seen see VBN 37350 175 37 in in IN 37350 175 38 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 175 39 , , , 37350 175 40 thus thus RB 37350 175 41 accounting account VBG 37350 175 42 for for IN 37350 175 43 the the DT 37350 175 44 failure failure NN 37350 175 45 of of IN 37350 175 46 the the DT 37350 175 47 costal costal JJ 37350 175 48 foramen foraman NNS 37350 175 49 to to TO 37350 175 50 coincide coincide VB 37350 175 51 with with IN 37350 175 52 that that DT 37350 175 53 of of IN 37350 175 54 the the DT 37350 175 55 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 175 56 artery artery NN 37350 175 57 . . . 37350 176 1 This this DT 37350 176 2 answer answer NN 37350 176 3 , , , 37350 176 4 too too RB 37350 176 5 , , , 37350 176 6 seems seem VBZ 37350 176 7 to to TO 37350 176 8 entail entail VB 37350 176 9 an an DT 37350 176 10 unprovable unprovable JJ 37350 176 11 assumption assumption NN 37350 176 12 which which WDT 37350 176 13 should should MD 37350 176 14 not not RB 37350 176 15 be be VB 37350 176 16 made make VBN 37350 176 17 without without IN 37350 176 18 explicit explicit JJ 37350 176 19 evidence evidence NN 37350 176 20 . . . 37350 177 1 ( ( -LRB- 37350 177 2 4 4 LS 37350 177 3 ) ) -RRB- 37350 177 4 Finally finally RB 37350 177 5 , , , 37350 177 6 Emelianov Emelianov NNP 37350 177 7 ( ( -LRB- 37350 177 8 1936 1936 CD 37350 177 9 ) ) -RRB- 37350 177 10 regarded regard VBD 37350 177 11 the the DT 37350 177 12 rib rib NN 37350 177 13 - - HYPH 37350 177 14 bearer bearer NN 37350 177 15 as as IN 37350 177 16 a a DT 37350 177 17 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 37350 177 18 _ _ NNP 37350 177 19 ventral ventral JJ 37350 177 20 _ _ NNP 37350 177 21 rib rib NN 37350 177 22 , , , 37350 177 23 on on IN 37350 177 24 account account NN 37350 177 25 of of IN 37350 177 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 177 27 relationship relationship NN 37350 177 28 to to IN 37350 177 29 the the DT 37350 177 30 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 177 31 artery artery NN 37350 177 32 , , , 37350 177 33 and and CC 37350 177 34 considered consider VBD 37350 177 35 the the DT 37350 177 36 actual actual JJ 37350 177 37 rib rib NN 37350 177 38 to to TO 37350 177 39 be be VB 37350 177 40 a a DT 37350 177 41 neomorph neomorph NN 37350 177 42 in in IN 37350 177 43 the the DT 37350 177 44 _ _ NNP 37350 177 45 dorsal dorsal NN 37350 177 46 _ _ NNP 37350 177 47 position position NN 37350 177 48 characteristic characteristic JJ 37350 177 49 of of IN 37350 177 50 tetrapod tetrapod NNP 37350 177 51 ribs ribs NNP 37350 177 52 in in IN 37350 177 53 general general JJ 37350 177 54 . . . 37350 178 1 This this DT 37350 178 2 argument argument NN 37350 178 3 would would MD 37350 178 4 fit fit VB 37350 178 5 the the DT 37350 178 6 ontogenetic ontogenetic JJ 37350 178 7 picture picture NN 37350 178 8 satisfactorily satisfactorily RB 37350 178 9 , , , 37350 178 10 provided provide VBN 37350 178 11 that that IN 37350 178 12 ( ( -LRB- 37350 178 13 _ _ NNP 37350 178 14 a a DT 37350 178 15 _ _ NN 37350 178 16 ) ) -RRB- 37350 178 17 there there EX 37350 178 18 were be VBD 37350 178 19 some some DT 37350 178 20 evidence evidence NN 37350 178 21 of of IN 37350 178 22 ventral ventral NN 37350 178 23 , , , 37350 178 24 rather rather RB 37350 178 25 than than IN 37350 178 26 dorsal dorsal NN 37350 178 27 , , , 37350 178 28 ribs rib NNS 37350 178 29 in in IN 37350 178 30 early early JJ 37350 178 31 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 178 32 , , , 37350 178 33 and and CC 37350 178 34 ( ( -LRB- 37350 178 35 _ _ NNP 37350 178 36 b b NNP 37350 178 37 _ _ NNP 37350 178 38 ) ) -RRB- 37350 178 39 we -PRON- PRP 37350 178 40 accept accept VBP 37350 178 41 the the DT 37350 178 42 invention invention NN 37350 178 43 of of IN 37350 178 44 another another DT 37350 178 45 neomorph neomorph NN 37350 178 46 in in IN 37350 178 47 modern modern JJ 37350 178 48 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 178 49 as as IN 37350 178 50 an an DT 37350 178 51 unavoidable unavoidable JJ 37350 178 52 necessity necessity NN 37350 178 53 . . . 37350 179 1 Emelianov Emelianov NNP 37350 179 2 's 's POS 37350 179 3 conclusion conclusion NN 37350 179 4 ( ( -LRB- 37350 179 5 p. p. NN 37350 179 6 258 258 CD 37350 179 7 ) ) -RRB- 37350 179 8 should should MD 37350 179 9 be be VB 37350 179 10 quoted quote VBN 37350 179 11 here here RB 37350 179 12 ( ( -LRB- 37350 179 13 translation translation NN 37350 179 14 ) ) -RRB- 37350 179 15 : : : 37350 179 16 " " `` 37350 179 17 The the DT 37350 179 18 ribs rib NNS 37350 179 19 of of IN 37350 179 20 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 179 21 are be VBP 37350 179 22 shown show VBN 37350 179 23 to to TO 37350 179 24 be be VB 37350 179 25 upper upper JJ 37350 179 26 ribs rib NNS 37350 179 27 , , , 37350 179 28 yet yet CC 37350 179 29 we -PRON- PRP 37350 179 30 find find VBP 37350 179 31 besides besides IN 37350 179 32 these these DT 37350 179 33 in in IN 37350 179 34 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 179 35 rudimentary rudimentary JJ 37350 179 36 lower low JJR 37350 179 37 ribs rib NNS 37350 179 38 fused fuse VBN 37350 179 39 with with IN 37350 179 40 the the DT 37350 179 41 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 179 42 column column NN 37350 179 43 . . . 37350 180 1 The the DT 37350 180 2 ribs rib NNS 37350 180 3 of of IN 37350 180 4 Apoda Apoda NNP 37350 180 5 are be VBP 37350 180 6 lower low JJR 37350 180 7 ribs rib NNS 37350 180 8 . . . 37350 181 1 In in IN 37350 181 2 Anura Anura NNP 37350 181 3 ribs rib NNS 37350 181 4 fail fail VBP 37350 181 5 to to TO 37350 181 6 develop develop VB 37350 181 7 fully fully RB 37350 181 8 , , , 37350 181 9 but but CC 37350 181 10 as as IN 37350 181 11 rare rare JJ 37350 181 12 exceptions exception NNS 37350 181 13 rudiments rudiment NNS 37350 181 14 of of IN 37350 181 15 upper upper JJ 37350 181 16 ribs rib NNS 37350 181 17 appear appear VBP 37350 181 18 . . . 37350 181 19 " " '' 37350 182 1 Of of IN 37350 182 2 these these DT 37350 182 3 various various JJ 37350 182 4 interpretations interpretation NNS 37350 182 5 , , , 37350 182 6 that that DT 37350 182 7 of of IN 37350 182 8 Naef Naef NNP 37350 182 9 seems seem VBZ 37350 182 10 to to TO 37350 182 11 involve involve VB 37350 182 12 the the DT 37350 182 13 minimum minimum NN 37350 182 14 of of IN 37350 182 15 novelty novelty NN 37350 182 16 , , , 37350 182 17 namely namely RB 37350 182 18 , , , 37350 182 19 that that IN 37350 182 20 the the DT 37350 182 21 rib rib NN 37350 182 22 - - HYPH 37350 182 23 bearer bearer NN 37350 182 24 is be VBZ 37350 182 25 the the DT 37350 182 26 basiventral basiventral JJ 37350 182 27 , , , 37350 182 28 expanded expanded JJ 37350 182 29 and and CC 37350 182 30 external external JJ 37350 182 31 to to IN 37350 182 32 the the DT 37350 182 33 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 182 34 artery artery NN 37350 182 35 . . . 37350 183 1 It -PRON- PRP 37350 183 2 is be VBZ 37350 183 3 not not RB 37350 183 4 necessary necessary JJ 37350 183 5 to to TO 37350 183 6 take take VB 37350 183 7 this this DT 37350 183 8 modification modification NN 37350 183 9 as as IN 37350 183 10 the the DT 37350 183 11 ancestral ancestral JJ 37350 183 12 condition condition NN 37350 183 13 in in IN 37350 183 14 tetrapods tetrapod NNS 37350 183 15 , , , 37350 183 16 of of IN 37350 183 17 course course NN 37350 183 18 . . . 37350 184 1 The the DT 37350 184 2 basiventral basiventral NN 37350 184 3 ( ( -LRB- 37350 184 4 = = SYM 37350 184 5 intercentrum intercentrum NN 37350 184 6 ) ) -RRB- 37350 184 7 would would MD 37350 184 8 merely merely RB 37350 184 9 have have VB 37350 184 10 expanded expand VBN 37350 184 11 sufficiently sufficiently RB 37350 184 12 to to TO 37350 184 13 provide provide VB 37350 184 14 a a DT 37350 184 15 diapophysis diapophysis NN 37350 184 16 for for IN 37350 184 17 the the DT 37350 184 18 tuberculum tuberculum NN 37350 184 19 as as RB 37350 184 20 well well RB 37350 184 21 as as IN 37350 184 22 the the DT 37350 184 23 ( ( -LRB- 37350 184 24 primitive primitive JJ 37350 184 25 ) ) -RRB- 37350 184 26 facet facet NNP 37350 184 27 for for IN 37350 184 28 the the DT 37350 184 29 capitulum capitulum NN 37350 184 30 . . . 37350 185 1 No no DT 37350 185 2 neomorph neomorph NN 37350 185 3 appears appear VBZ 37350 185 4 under under IN 37350 185 5 this this DT 37350 185 6 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37350 185 7 , , , 37350 185 8 which which WDT 37350 185 9 has have VBZ 37350 185 10 the the DT 37350 185 11 distinct distinct JJ 37350 185 12 advantage advantage NN 37350 185 13 of of IN 37350 185 14 simplicity simplicity NN 37350 185 15 . . . 37350 186 1 Figures figure NNS 37350 186 2 of of IN 37350 186 3 early early JJ 37350 186 4 stages stage NNS 37350 186 5 in in IN 37350 186 6 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 186 7 development development NN 37350 186 8 by by IN 37350 186 9 the the DT 37350 186 10 authors author NNS 37350 186 11 mentioned mention VBD 37350 186 12 show show VBP 37350 186 13 that that IN 37350 186 14 the the DT 37350 186 15 basidorsals basidorsal NNS 37350 186 16 chondrify chondrify VBP 37350 186 17 first first RB 37350 186 18 , , , 37350 186 19 as as IN 37350 186 20 neural neural JJ 37350 186 21 arches arch NNS 37350 186 22 , , , 37350 186 23 while while IN 37350 186 24 a a DT 37350 186 25 separate separate JJ 37350 186 26 mass mass NN 37350 186 27 of of IN 37350 186 28 mesenchyme mesenchyme NNS 37350 186 29 lies lie VBZ 37350 186 30 externally externally RB 37350 186 31 and and CC 37350 186 32 ventrally ventrally RB 37350 186 33 from from IN 37350 186 34 these these DT 37350 186 35 . . . 37350 187 1 This this DT 37350 187 2 mesenchyme mesenchyme NNS 37350 187 3 may may MD 37350 187 4 chondrify chondrify VB 37350 187 5 either either CC 37350 187 6 in in IN 37350 187 7 one one CD 37350 187 8 piece piece NN 37350 187 9 ( ( -LRB- 37350 187 10 on on IN 37350 187 11 each each DT 37350 187 12 side side NN 37350 187 13 ) ) -RRB- 37350 187 14 or or CC 37350 187 15 in in IN 37350 187 16 two two CD 37350 187 17 ; ; : 37350 187 18 in in IN 37350 187 19 _ _ NNP 37350 187 20 Molge Molge NNP 37350 187 21 _ _ NNP 37350 187 22 the the DT 37350 187 23 part part NN 37350 187 24 adjacent adjacent JJ 37350 187 25 to to IN 37350 187 26 the the DT 37350 187 27 centrum centrum NN 37350 187 28 is be VBZ 37350 187 29 ossified ossify VBN 37350 187 30 in in IN 37350 187 31 the the DT 37350 187 32 20-mm 20-mm CD 37350 187 33 . . . 37350 188 1 larva larva NNP 37350 188 2 , , , 37350 188 3 and and CC 37350 188 4 subsequently subsequently RB 37350 188 5 unites unite VBZ 37350 188 6 with with IN 37350 188 7 the the DT 37350 188 8 more more JJR 37350 188 9 dorsal dorsal NN 37350 188 10 and and CC 37350 188 11 lateral lateral JJ 37350 188 12 cartilaginous cartilaginous JJ 37350 188 13 part part NN 37350 188 14 , , , 37350 188 15 while while IN 37350 188 16 the the DT 37350 188 17 rib rib NN 37350 188 18 , , , 37350 188 19 appearing appear VBG 37350 188 20 farther farther RB 37350 188 21 out out RB 37350 188 22 , , , 37350 188 23 grows grow VBZ 37350 188 24 inward inward RB 37350 188 25 to to TO 37350 188 26 meet meet VB 37350 188 27 this this DT 37350 188 28 composite composite JJ 37350 188 29 " " `` 37350 188 30 rib rib NN 37350 188 31 - - NN 37350 188 32 bearer bearer NN 37350 188 33 . . . 37350 188 34 " " '' 37350 189 1 In in IN 37350 189 2 _ _ NNP 37350 189 3 Necturus Necturus NNP 37350 189 4 _ _ NNP 37350 189 5 the the DT 37350 189 6 mesenchyme mesenchyme NNS 37350 189 7 below below IN 37350 189 8 the the DT 37350 189 9 neural neural JJ 37350 189 10 arch arch JJ 37350 189 11 differentiates differentiate NNS 37350 189 12 into into IN 37350 189 13 a a DT 37350 189 14 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 189 15 below below IN 37350 189 16 the the DT 37350 189 17 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 189 18 artery artery NN 37350 189 19 ( ( -LRB- 37350 189 20 position position NN 37350 189 21 proper proper JJ 37350 189 22 to to IN 37350 189 23 a a DT 37350 189 24 basiventral basiventral NN 37350 189 25 ) ) -RRB- 37350 189 26 , , , 37350 189 27 a a DT 37350 189 28 bridge bridge NN 37350 189 29 between between IN 37350 189 30 this this DT 37350 189 31 and and CC 37350 189 32 the the DT 37350 189 33 neural neural JJ 37350 189 34 arch arch NN 37350 189 35 , , , 37350 189 36 and and CC 37350 189 37 a a DT 37350 189 38 rib rib NN 37350 189 39 , , , 37350 189 40 the the DT 37350 189 41 latter latter JJ 37350 189 42 two two CD 37350 189 43 chondrifying chondrify VBG 37350 189 44 later later RB 37350 189 45 than than IN 37350 189 46 the the DT 37350 189 47 " " `` 37350 189 48 basiventral basiventral JJ 37350 189 49 " " '' 37350 189 50 proper proper JJ 37350 189 51 . . . 37350 190 1 In in IN 37350 190 2 the the DT 37350 190 3 " " `` 37350 190 4 axolotl axolotl NN 37350 190 5 " " '' 37350 190 6 ( ( -LRB- 37350 190 7 presumably presumably RB 37350 190 8 _ _ NNP 37350 190 9 Ambystoma Ambystoma NNP 37350 190 10 tigrinum tigrinum NN 37350 190 11 _ _ NNP 37350 190 12 ) ) -RRB- 37350 190 13 the the DT 37350 190 14 rib rib NN 37350 190 15 - - HYPH 37350 190 16 bearer bearer NN 37350 190 17 grows grow VBZ 37350 190 18 downward downward RB 37350 190 19 from from IN 37350 190 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 190 21 first first JJ 37350 190 22 center center NN 37350 190 23 of of IN 37350 190 24 chondrification chondrification NN 37350 190 25 at at IN 37350 190 26 the the DT 37350 190 27 side side NN 37350 190 28 of of IN 37350 190 29 the the DT 37350 190 30 neural neural JJ 37350 190 31 arch arch NN 37350 190 32 ( ( -LRB- 37350 190 33 Emelianov Emelianov NNP 37350 190 34 , , , 37350 190 35 1936 1936 CD 37350 190 36 ) ) -RRB- 37350 190 37 . . . 37350 191 1 Thus thus RB 37350 191 2 it -PRON- PRP 37350 191 3 appears appear VBZ 37350 191 4 that that IN 37350 191 5 the the DT 37350 191 6 simplest simple JJS 37350 191 7 hypothesis hypothesis NN 37350 191 8 to to TO 37350 191 9 account account VB 37350 191 10 for for IN 37350 191 11 the the DT 37350 191 12 rib rib NN 37350 191 13 - - HYPH 37350 191 14 bearer bearer NN 37350 191 15 is be VBZ 37350 191 16 that that DT 37350 191 17 ( ( -LRB- 37350 191 18 _ _ NNP 37350 191 19 a a DT 37350 191 20 _ _ NNP 37350 191 21 ) ) -RRB- 37350 191 22 it -PRON- PRP 37350 191 23 is be VBZ 37350 191 24 the the DT 37350 191 25 basiventral basiventral NN 37350 191 26 , , , 37350 191 27 ( ( -LRB- 37350 191 28 _ _ NNP 37350 191 29 b b NNP 37350 191 30 _ _ NNP 37350 191 31 ) ) -RRB- 37350 191 32 it -PRON- PRP 37350 191 33 is be VBZ 37350 191 34 recognizable recognizable JJ 37350 191 35 just just RB 37350 191 36 before before IN 37350 191 37 chondrification chondrification NN 37350 191 38 as as IN 37350 191 39 a a DT 37350 191 40 mass mass NN 37350 191 41 of of IN 37350 191 42 mesenchyme mesenchyme NNS 37350 191 43 in in IN 37350 191 44 contact contact NN 37350 191 45 with with IN 37350 191 46 both both CC 37350 191 47 the the DT 37350 191 48 notochordal notochordal JJ 37350 191 49 sheath sheath NN 37350 191 50 and and CC 37350 191 51 the the DT 37350 191 52 basidorsal basidorsal NN 37350 191 53 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 191 54 , , , 37350 191 55 ( ( -LRB- 37350 191 56 _ _ NNP 37350 191 57 c c NNP 37350 191 58 _ _ NNP 37350 191 59 ) ) -RRB- 37350 191 60 it -PRON- PRP 37350 191 61 may may MD 37350 191 62 chondrify chondrify VB 37350 191 63 or or CC 37350 191 64 ossify ossify VB 37350 191 65 first first RB 37350 191 66 in in IN 37350 191 67 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 191 68 ventral ventral JJ 37350 191 69 portion portion NN 37350 191 70 or or CC 37350 191 71 in in IN 37350 191 72 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 191 73 dorsal dorsal NN 37350 191 74 portion portion NN 37350 191 75 , , , 37350 191 76 the the DT 37350 191 77 two two CD 37350 191 78 then then RB 37350 191 79 joining join VBG 37350 191 80 before before IN 37350 191 81 it -PRON- PRP 37350 191 82 fuses fuse VBZ 37350 191 83 with with IN 37350 191 84 the the DT 37350 191 85 rest rest NN 37350 191 86 of of IN 37350 191 87 the the DT 37350 191 88 vertebra vertebra NN 37350 191 89 , , , 37350 191 90 ( ( -LRB- 37350 191 91 _ _ NNP 37350 191 92 d d NNP 37350 191 93 _ _ NNP 37350 191 94 ) ) -RRB- 37350 191 95 the the DT 37350 191 96 enclosure enclosure NN 37350 191 97 of of IN 37350 191 98 the the DT 37350 191 99 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 191 100 artery artery NN 37350 191 101 is be VBZ 37350 191 102 a a DT 37350 191 103 consequence consequence NN 37350 191 104 of of IN 37350 191 105 the the DT 37350 191 106 extension extension NN 37350 191 107 of of IN 37350 191 108 the the DT 37350 191 109 basiventral basiventral NN 37350 191 110 beyond beyond IN 37350 191 111 the the DT 37350 191 112 position position NN 37350 191 113 occupied occupy VBN 37350 191 114 by by IN 37350 191 115 it -PRON- PRP 37350 191 116 in in IN 37350 191 117 primitive primitive JJ 37350 191 118 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 191 119 , , , 37350 191 120 and and CC 37350 191 121 ( ( -LRB- 37350 191 122 _ _ NNP 37350 191 123 e e NNP 37350 191 124 _ _ NNP 37350 191 125 ) ) -RRB- 37350 191 126 there there EX 37350 191 127 is be VBZ 37350 191 128 no no DT 37350 191 129 indication indication NN 37350 191 130 that that IN 37350 191 131 this this DT 37350 191 132 took take VBD 37350 191 133 place place NN 37350 191 134 in in IN 37350 191 135 other other JJ 37350 191 136 orders order NNS 37350 191 137 than than IN 37350 191 138 the the DT 37350 191 139 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 191 140 . . . 37350 192 1 It -PRON- PRP 37350 192 2 seems seem VBZ 37350 192 3 that that IN 37350 192 4 the the DT 37350 192 5 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 192 6 in in IN 37350 192 7 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 192 8 have have VBP 37350 192 9 at at IN 37350 192 10 least least JJS 37350 192 11 the the DT 37350 192 12 following follow VBG 37350 192 13 components component NNS 37350 192 14 : : : 37350 192 15 perichordal perichordal NN 37350 192 16 centra centra NNP 37350 192 17 , , , 37350 192 18 separate separate JJ 37350 192 19 basidorsal basidorsal NN 37350 192 20 cartilages cartilage NNS 37350 192 21 , , , 37350 192 22 and and CC 37350 192 23 basiventrals basiventral NNS 37350 192 24 , , , 37350 192 25 which which WDT 37350 192 26 are be VBP 37350 192 27 somewhat somewhat RB 37350 192 28 specialized specialized JJ 37350 192 29 in in IN 37350 192 30 their -PRON- PRP$ 37350 192 31 manner manner NN 37350 192 32 of of IN 37350 192 33 development development NN 37350 192 34 . . . 37350 193 1 The the DT 37350 193 2 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 193 3 of of IN 37350 193 4 Anura Anura NNP 37350 193 5 develop develop VB 37350 193 6 in in IN 37350 193 7 the the DT 37350 193 8 fashion fashion NN 37350 193 9 just just RB 37350 193 10 described describe VBN 37350 193 11 except except IN 37350 193 12 that that IN 37350 193 13 basiventrals basiventral NNS 37350 193 14 are be VBP 37350 193 15 lacking lack VBG 37350 193 16 . . . 37350 194 1 It -PRON- PRP 37350 194 2 would would MD 37350 194 3 seem seem VB 37350 194 4 no no DT 37350 194 5 more more RBR 37350 194 6 difficult difficult JJ 37350 194 7 to to TO 37350 194 8 accept accept VB 37350 194 9 the the DT 37350 194 10 derivation derivation NN 37350 194 11 of of IN 37350 194 12 salamander salamander JJ 37350 194 13 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 194 14 from from IN 37350 194 15 the the DT 37350 194 16 temnospondylous temnospondylous JJ 37350 194 17 type type NN 37350 194 18 than than IN 37350 194 19 it -PRON- PRP 37350 194 20 is be VBZ 37350 194 21 in in IN 37350 194 22 the the DT 37350 194 23 case case NN 37350 194 24 of of IN 37350 194 25 frogs frog NNS 37350 194 26 , , , 37350 194 27 if if IN 37350 194 28 other other JJ 37350 194 29 evidence evidence NN 37350 194 30 points point VBZ 37350 194 31 to to IN 37350 194 32 such such PDT 37350 194 33 an an DT 37350 194 34 ancestry ancestry NN 37350 194 35 . . . 37350 195 1 [ [ -LRB- 37350 195 2 Illustration illustration NN 37350 195 3 : : : 37350 195 4 Fig Fig NNP 37350 195 5 . . . 37350 196 1 7 7 LS 37350 196 2 . . . 37350 197 1 Vertebrae Vertebrae NNP 37350 197 2 of of IN 37350 197 3 _ _ NNP 37350 197 4 Eusthenopteron Eusthenopteron NNP 37350 197 5 _ _ NNP 37350 197 6 ( ( -LRB- 37350 197 7 ×1 ×1 RB 37350 197 8 ) ) -RRB- 37350 197 9 and and CC 37350 197 10 _ _ NNP 37350 197 11 Ichthyostega Ichthyostega NNP 37350 197 12 _ _ NNP 37350 197 13 ( ( -LRB- 37350 197 14 ×2/3 ×2/3 UH 37350 197 15 , , , 37350 197 16 after after IN 37350 197 17 Jarvik Jarvik NNP 37350 197 18 , , , 37350 197 19 1952 1952 CD 37350 197 20 ) ) -RRB- 37350 197 21 , , , 37350 197 22 _ _ NNP 37350 197 23 Trimerorhachis Trimerorhachis NNP 37350 197 24 _ _ NNP 37350 197 25 ( ( -LRB- 37350 197 26 ×1 ×1 RB 37350 197 27 - - : 37350 197 28 1/2 1/2 CD 37350 197 29 , , , 37350 197 30 after after IN 37350 197 31 Case Case NNP 37350 197 32 ) ) -RRB- 37350 197 33 , , , 37350 197 34 and and CC 37350 197 35 _ _ NNP 37350 197 36 Amphibamus Amphibamus NNP 37350 197 37 _ _ NNP 37350 197 38 ( ( -LRB- 37350 197 39 ×10 ×10 NNP 37350 197 40 , , , 37350 197 41 after after IN 37350 197 42 Watson Watson NNP 37350 197 43 , , , 37350 197 44 1940 1940 CD 37350 197 45 ) ) -RRB- 37350 197 46 in in IN 37350 197 47 lateral lateral JJ 37350 197 48 and and CC 37350 197 49 end end VB 37350 197 50 views view NNS 37350 197 51 ; ; : 37350 197 52 the the DT 37350 197 53 two two CD 37350 197 54 lower low JJR 37350 197 55 right right JJ 37350 197 56 - - HYPH 37350 197 57 hand hand NN 37350 197 58 figures figure NNS 37350 197 59 are be VBP 37350 197 60 from from IN 37350 197 61 Watson Watson NNP 37350 197 62 ( ( -LRB- 37350 197 63 1940 1940 CD 37350 197 64 , , , 37350 197 65 as as IN 37350 197 66 _ _ NNP 37350 197 67 Miobatrachus Miobatrachus NNP 37350 197 68 _ _ NNP 37350 197 69 ) ) -RRB- 37350 197 70 ; ; : 37350 197 71 the the DT 37350 197 72 lower low JJR 37350 197 73 left left NN 37350 197 74 is be VBZ 37350 197 75 from from IN 37350 197 76 a a DT 37350 197 77 cast cast NN 37350 197 78 of of IN 37350 197 79 the the DT 37350 197 80 " " `` 37350 197 81 _ _ NNP 37350 197 82 Miobatrachus Miobatrachus NNP 37350 197 83 _ _ NNP 37350 197 84 " " `` 37350 197 85 specimen speciman NNS 37350 197 86 in in IN 37350 197 87 Chicago Chicago NNP 37350 197 88 Natural Natural NNP 37350 197 89 History History NNP 37350 197 90 Museum Museum NNP 37350 197 91 , , , 37350 197 92 No no UH 37350 197 93 . . . 37350 198 1 2000 2000 CD 37350 198 2 , , , 37350 198 3 in in IN 37350 198 4 the the DT 37350 198 5 presacral presacral JJ 37350 198 6 region region NN 37350 198 7 ( ( -LRB- 37350 198 8 original original JJ 37350 198 9 , , , 37350 198 10 ×10 ×10 ADD 37350 198 11 ) ) -RRB- 37350 198 12 . . . 37350 198 13 ] ] -RRB- 37350 199 1 Fig fig NN 37350 199 2 . . . 37350 200 1 7 7 LS 37350 200 2 , , , 37350 200 3 lower lower RBR 37350 200 4 right right JJ 37350 200 5 , , , 37350 200 6 is be VBZ 37350 200 7 Watson Watson NNP 37350 200 8 's 's POS 37350 200 9 ( ( -LRB- 37350 200 10 1940 1940 CD 37350 200 11 ) ) -RRB- 37350 200 12 illustration illustration NN 37350 200 13 of of IN 37350 200 14 the the DT 37350 200 15 anterior anterior NNP 37350 200 16 trunk trunk NNP 37350 200 17 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 200 18 of of IN 37350 200 19 _ _ NNP 37350 200 20 Amphibamus Amphibamus NNP 37350 200 21 _ _ NNP 37350 200 22 ( ( -LRB- 37350 200 23 _ _ NNP 37350 200 24 Miobatrachus Miobatrachus NNP 37350 200 25 _ _ NNP 37350 200 26 ) ) -RRB- 37350 200 27 , , , 37350 200 28 in in IN 37350 200 29 which which WDT 37350 200 30 the the DT 37350 200 31 intercentrum intercentrum NN 37350 200 32 is be VBZ 37350 200 33 shown show VBN 37350 200 34 as as IN 37350 200 35 a a DT 37350 200 36 single single JJ 37350 200 37 median median JJ 37350 200 38 piece piece NN 37350 200 39 . . . 37350 201 1 Fig fig NN 37350 201 2 . . . 37350 202 1 7 7 LS 37350 202 2 , , , 37350 202 3 lower lower RBR 37350 202 4 left leave VBN 37350 202 5 , , , 37350 202 6 shows show VBZ 37350 202 7 two two CD 37350 202 8 of of IN 37350 202 9 the the DT 37350 202 10 more more RBR 37350 202 11 posterior posterior NNP 37350 202 12 trunk trunk NN 37350 202 13 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 202 14 seen see VBN 37350 202 15 as as IN 37350 202 16 impressions impression NNS 37350 202 17 in in IN 37350 202 18 a a DT 37350 202 19 cast cast NN 37350 202 20 of of IN 37350 202 21 the the DT 37350 202 22 type type NN 37350 202 23 of of IN 37350 202 24 " " `` 37350 202 25 _ _ NNP 37350 202 26 Miobatrachus Miobatrachus NNP 37350 202 27 romeri romeri NNP 37350 202 28 _ _ NNP 37350 202 29 ; ; : 37350 202 30 " " `` 37350 202 31 evidently evidently RB 37350 202 32 the the DT 37350 202 33 inter inter NNP 37350 202 34 - - JJ 37350 202 35 centra centra NNP 37350 202 36 were be VBD 37350 202 37 paired pair VBN 37350 202 38 at at IN 37350 202 39 about about IN 37350 202 40 the the DT 37350 202 41 level level NN 37350 202 42 of of IN 37350 202 43 the the DT 37350 202 44 16th 16th JJ 37350 202 45 vertebra vertebra NN 37350 202 46 , , , 37350 202 47 and and CC 37350 202 48 relatively relatively RB 37350 202 49 large large JJ 37350 202 50 . . . 37350 203 1 Gregory Gregory NNP 37350 203 2 's 's POS 37350 203 3 ( ( -LRB- 37350 203 4 1950 1950 CD 37350 203 5 ) ) -RRB- 37350 203 6 figure figure NN 37350 203 7 of of IN 37350 203 8 the the DT 37350 203 9 type type NN 37350 203 10 specimen speciman NNS 37350 203 11 of of IN 37350 203 12 " " `` 37350 203 13 _ _ NNP 37350 203 14 Mazonerpeton Mazonerpeton NNP 37350 203 15 _ _ NNP 37350 203 16 " " '' 37350 203 17 ( ( -LRB- 37350 203 18 also also RB 37350 203 19 equivalent equivalent JJ 37350 203 20 to to IN 37350 203 21 _ _ NNP 37350 203 22 Amphibamus Amphibamus NNP 37350 203 23 _ _ NNP 37350 203 24 ) ) -RRB- 37350 203 25 shows show VBZ 37350 203 26 the the DT 37350 203 27 anterior anterior NNP 37350 203 28 trunk trunk NNP 37350 203 29 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 203 30 in in IN 37350 203 31 relation relation NN 37350 203 32 to to IN 37350 203 33 the the DT 37350 203 34 ribs rib NNS 37350 203 35 essentially essentially RB 37350 203 36 as as IN 37350 203 37 they -PRON- PRP 37350 203 38 appear appear VBP 37350 203 39 to to IN 37350 203 40 me -PRON- PRP 37350 203 41 in in IN 37350 203 42 the the DT 37350 203 43 cast cast NN 37350 203 44 of of IN 37350 203 45 _ _ NNP 37350 203 46 Miobatrachus Miobatrachus NNP 37350 203 47 _ _ NNP 37350 203 48 , , , 37350 203 49 and and CC 37350 203 50 rather rather RB 37350 203 51 differently differently RB 37350 203 52 from from IN 37350 203 53 Watson Watson NNP 37350 203 54 's 's POS 37350 203 55 figure figure NN 37350 203 56 of of IN 37350 203 57 the the DT 37350 203 58 latter latter JJ 37350 203 59 . . . 37350 204 1 Gregory Gregory NNP 37350 204 2 is be VBZ 37350 204 3 probably probably RB 37350 204 4 right right RB 37350 204 5 in in IN 37350 204 6 considering consider VBG 37350 204 7 the the DT 37350 204 8 specimens specimen NNS 37350 204 9 to to TO 37350 204 10 represent represent VB 37350 204 11 various various JJ 37350 204 12 degrees degree NNS 37350 204 13 of of IN 37350 204 14 immaturity immaturity NN 37350 204 15 . . . 37350 205 1 So so RB 37350 205 2 far far RB 37350 205 3 as as IN 37350 205 4 present present JJ 37350 205 5 information information NN 37350 205 6 goes go VBZ 37350 205 7 , , , 37350 205 8 then then RB 37350 205 9 , , , 37350 205 10 the the DT 37350 205 11 vertebrae vertebra NNS 37350 205 12 of of IN 37350 205 13 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 205 14 and and CC 37350 205 15 frogs frog NNS 37350 205 16 show show VBP 37350 205 17 no no DT 37350 205 18 _ _ NNP 37350 205 19 clear clear JJ 37350 205 20 _ _ NNP 37350 205 21 evidence evidence NN 37350 205 22 of of IN 37350 205 23 derivation derivation NN 37350 205 24 from from IN 37350 205 25 those those DT 37350 205 26 of of IN 37350 205 27 any any DT 37350 205 28 particular particular JJ 37350 205 29 group group NN 37350 205 30 among among IN 37350 205 31 the the DT 37350 205 32 early early JJ 37350 205 33 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 205 34 , , , 37350 205 35 but but CC 37350 205 36 their -PRON- PRP$ 37350 205 37 features feature NNS 37350 205 38 are be VBP 37350 205 39 not not RB 37350 205 40 inconsistent inconsistent JJ 37350 205 41 with with IN 37350 205 42 a a DT 37350 205 43 simplification simplification NN 37350 205 44 of of IN 37350 205 45 the the DT 37350 205 46 pattern pattern NN 37350 205 47 of of IN 37350 205 48 Temnospondyli Temnospondyli NNP 37350 205 49 . . . 37350 206 1 [ [ -LRB- 37350 206 2 Illustration illustration NN 37350 206 3 : : : 37350 206 4 Fig Fig NNP 37350 206 5 . . . 37350 207 1 8 8 LS 37350 207 2 . . . 37350 208 1 Pectoral pectoral JJ 37350 208 2 girdles girdle NNS 37350 208 3 of of IN 37350 208 4 _ _ NNP 37350 208 5 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 208 6 _ _ NNP 37350 208 7 ( ( -LRB- 37350 208 8 after after IN 37350 208 9 Piveteau Piveteau NNP 37350 208 10 , , , 37350 208 11 1937 1937 CD 37350 208 12 ) ) -RRB- 37350 208 13 , , , 37350 208 14 _ _ NNP 37350 208 15 Notobatrachus Notobatrachus NNP 37350 208 16 _ _ NNP 37350 208 17 ( ( -LRB- 37350 208 18 after after IN 37350 208 19 Stipanicic Stipanicic NNP 37350 208 20 and and CC 37350 208 21 Reig Reig NNP 37350 208 22 , , , 37350 208 23 1956 1956 CD 37350 208 24 ) ) -RRB- 37350 208 25 , , , 37350 208 26 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 208 27 ( ( -LRB- 37350 208 28 after after IN 37350 208 29 Ritland Ritland NNP 37350 208 30 , , , 37350 208 31 1955 1955 CD 37350 208 32 a a NN 37350 208 33 ) ) -RRB- 37350 208 34 and and CC 37350 208 35 _ _ NNP 37350 208 36 Rana Rana NNP 37350 208 37 _ _ NNP 37350 208 38 ( ( -LRB- 37350 208 39 original original JJ 37350 208 40 ) ) -RRB- 37350 208 41 ; ; , 37350 208 42 all all DT 37350 208 43 ×2 ×2 XX 37350 208 44 . . . 37350 209 1 For for IN 37350 209 2 explanation explanation NN 37350 209 3 of of IN 37350 209 4 abbreviations abbreviation NNS 37350 209 5 see see VBP 37350 209 6 Fig Fig NNP 37350 209 7 . . . 37350 210 1 3 3 LS 37350 210 2 . . . 37350 210 3 ] ] -RRB- 37350 211 1 PECTORAL PECTORAL NNP 37350 211 2 GIRDLE GIRDLE NNP 37350 211 3 Hecht Hecht NNP 37350 211 4 and and CC 37350 211 5 Ruibal Ruibal NNP 37350 211 6 ( ( -LRB- 37350 211 7 Copeia Copeia NNP 37350 211 8 , , , 37350 211 9 1928:242 1928:242 CD 37350 211 10 ) ) -RRB- 37350 211 11 make make VBP 37350 211 12 a a DT 37350 211 13 strong strong JJ 37350 211 14 point point NN 37350 211 15 of of IN 37350 211 16 the the DT 37350 211 17 nature nature NN 37350 211 18 of of IN 37350 211 19 the the DT 37350 211 20 pectoral pectoral JJ 37350 211 21 girdle girdle NN 37350 211 22 in in IN 37350 211 23 _ _ NNP 37350 211 24 Notobatrachus Notobatrachus NNP 37350 211 25 _ _ NNP 37350 211 26 , , , 37350 211 27 as as IN 37350 211 28 described describe VBN 37350 211 29 recently recently RB 37350 211 30 by by IN 37350 211 31 Stipanicic Stipanicic NNP 37350 211 32 and and CC 37350 211 33 Reig Reig NNP 37350 211 34 ( ( -LRB- 37350 211 35 1955 1955 CD 37350 211 36 , , , 37350 211 37 1956 1956 CD 37350 211 38 ) ) -RRB- 37350 211 39 from from IN 37350 211 40 the the DT 37350 211 41 Jurassic Jurassic NNP 37350 211 42 of of IN 37350 211 43 Patagonia Patagonia NNP 37350 211 44 , , , 37350 211 45 and and CC 37350 211 46 quite quite RB 37350 211 47 rightly rightly RB 37350 211 48 recommend recommend VBP 37350 211 49 that that IN 37350 211 50 the the DT 37350 211 51 significance significance NN 37350 211 52 of of IN 37350 211 53 the the DT 37350 211 54 arciferal arciferal JJ 37350 211 55 and and CC 37350 211 56 firmisternal firmisternal JJ 37350 211 57 types type NNS 37350 211 58 of of IN 37350 211 59 girdle girdle NN 37350 211 60 be be VB 37350 211 61 restudied restudie VBN 37350 211 62 . . . 37350 212 1 That that DT 37350 212 2 of of IN 37350 212 3 _ _ NNP 37350 212 4 Notobatrachus Notobatrachus NNP 37350 212 5 _ _ NNP 37350 212 6 is be VBZ 37350 212 7 said say VBN 37350 212 8 to to TO 37350 212 9 be be VB 37350 212 10 firmisternal firmisternal JJ 37350 212 11 ; ; : 37350 212 12 in in IN 37350 212 13 view view NN 37350 212 14 of of IN 37350 212 15 the the DT 37350 212 16 arciferal arciferal JJ 37350 212 17 condition condition NN 37350 212 18 in in IN 37350 212 19 the the DT 37350 212 20 supposedly supposedly RB 37350 212 21 primitive primitive JJ 37350 212 22 _ _ NNP 37350 212 23 Leiopelma Leiopelma NNP 37350 212 24 _ _ NNP 37350 212 25 , , , 37350 212 26 _ _ NNP 37350 212 27 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 212 28 _ _ NNP 37350 212 29 , , , 37350 212 30 _ _ NNP 37350 212 31 Bombinator Bombinator NNP 37350 212 32 _ _ NNP 37350 212 33 , , , 37350 212 34 etc etc FW 37350 212 35 . . FW 37350 212 36 , , , 37350 212 37 this this DT 37350 212 38 comes come VBZ 37350 212 39 as as IN 37350 212 40 a a DT 37350 212 41 surprise surprise NN 37350 212 42 . . . 37350 213 1 Is be VBZ 37350 213 2 the the DT 37350 213 3 firmisternal firmisternal JJ 37350 213 4 girdle girdle NN 37350 213 5 , , , 37350 213 6 as as IN 37350 213 7 seen see VBN 37350 213 8 in in IN 37350 213 9 _ _ NNP 37350 213 10 Rana Rana NNP 37350 213 11 _ _ NNP 37350 213 12 , , , 37350 213 13 _ _ NNP 37350 213 14 Bufo Bufo NNP 37350 213 15 _ _ NNP 37350 213 16 , , , 37350 213 17 and and CC 37350 213 18 others other NNS 37350 213 19 , , , 37350 213 20 actually actually RB 37350 213 21 the the DT 37350 213 22 ancestral ancestral JJ 37350 213 23 type type NN 37350 213 24 , , , 37350 213 25 and and CC 37350 213 26 has have VBZ 37350 213 27 the the DT 37350 213 28 arciferal arciferal JJ 37350 213 29 been be VBN 37350 213 30 derived derive VBN 37350 213 31 from from IN 37350 213 32 something something NN 37350 213 33 like like IN 37350 213 34 this this DT 37350 213 35 ? ? . 37350 214 1 In in IN 37350 214 2 the the DT 37350 214 3 figures figure NNS 37350 214 4 given give VBN 37350 214 5 by by IN 37350 214 6 Stipanicic Stipanicic NNP 37350 214 7 and and CC 37350 214 8 Reig Reig NNP 37350 214 9 the the DT 37350 214 10 ossified ossified JJ 37350 214 11 parts part NNS 37350 214 12 of of IN 37350 214 13 the the DT 37350 214 14 girdle girdle NN 37350 214 15 are be VBP 37350 214 16 figured figure VBN 37350 214 17 in in IN 37350 214 18 detail detail NN 37350 214 19 ( ( -LRB- 37350 214 20 Fig fig NN 37350 214 21 . . . 37350 215 1 8) 8) CD 37350 215 2 and and CC 37350 215 3 Reig Reig NNP 37350 215 4 's 's POS 37350 215 5 discussion discussion NN 37350 215 6 of of IN 37350 215 7 it -PRON- PRP 37350 215 8 is be VBZ 37350 215 9 thorough thorough JJ 37350 215 10 . . . 37350 216 1 The the DT 37350 216 2 decision decision NN 37350 216 3 to to TO 37350 216 4 call call VB 37350 216 5 it -PRON- PRP 37350 216 6 firmisternal firmisternal JJ 37350 216 7 was be VBD 37350 216 8 taken take VBN 37350 216 9 with with IN 37350 216 10 some some DT 37350 216 11 hesitancy hesitancy NN 37350 216 12 , , , 37350 216 13 for for IN 37350 216 14 no no DT 37350 216 15 median median JJ 37350 216 16 elements element NNS 37350 216 17 are be VBP 37350 216 18 indicated indicate VBN 37350 216 19 , , , 37350 216 20 and and CC 37350 216 21 the the DT 37350 216 22 position position NN 37350 216 23 and and CC 37350 216 24 shape shape NN 37350 216 25 of of IN 37350 216 26 those those DT 37350 216 27 seen see VBN 37350 216 28 is be VBZ 37350 216 29 closely closely RB 37350 216 30 similar similar JJ 37350 216 31 to to IN 37350 216 32 the the DT 37350 216 33 ossified ossified JJ 37350 216 34 parts part NNS 37350 216 35 in in IN 37350 216 36 _ _ NNP 37350 216 37 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 216 38 _ _ NNP 37350 216 39 and and CC 37350 216 40 _ _ NNP 37350 216 41 Leiopelma Leiopelma NNP 37350 216 42 _ _ NNP 37350 216 43 ; ; : 37350 216 44 there there EX 37350 216 45 is be VBZ 37350 216 46 no no DT 37350 216 47 bony bony NNP 37350 216 48 sternum sternum NN 37350 216 49 or or CC 37350 216 50 omosternum omosternum JJ 37350 216 51 . . . 37350 217 1 It -PRON- PRP 37350 217 2 is be VBZ 37350 217 3 safe safe JJ 37350 217 4 to to TO 37350 217 5 suppose suppose VB 37350 217 6 that that IN 37350 217 7 some some DT 37350 217 8 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 217 9 lay lie VBD 37350 217 10 in in IN 37350 217 11 the the DT 37350 217 12 midline midline NN 37350 217 13 between between IN 37350 217 14 the the DT 37350 217 15 clavicles clavicle NNS 37350 217 16 and and CC 37350 217 17 coracoids coracoid NNS 37350 217 18 , , , 37350 217 19 but but CC 37350 217 20 there there EX 37350 217 21 is be VBZ 37350 217 22 no no DT 37350 217 23 evidence evidence NN 37350 217 24 as as IN 37350 217 25 to to IN 37350 217 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 217 27 extent extent NN 37350 217 28 , , , 37350 217 29 rigidity rigidity NN 37350 217 30 , , , 37350 217 31 or or CC 37350 217 32 degree degree NN 37350 217 33 of of IN 37350 217 34 overlapping overlapping NN 37350 217 35 if if IN 37350 217 36 any any DT 37350 217 37 . . . 37350 218 1 Apparently apparently RB 37350 218 2 , , , 37350 218 3 then then RB 37350 218 4 , , , 37350 218 5 there there EX 37350 218 6 is be VBZ 37350 218 7 not not RB 37350 218 8 sufficient sufficient JJ 37350 218 9 reason reason NN 37350 218 10 to to TO 37350 218 11 infer infer VB 37350 218 12 that that IN 37350 218 13 this this DT 37350 218 14 Jurassic Jurassic NNP 37350 218 15 frog frog NN 37350 218 16 had have VBD 37350 218 17 a a DT 37350 218 18 pectoral pectoral JJ 37350 218 19 girdle girdle NN 37350 218 20 comparable comparable JJ 37350 218 21 with with IN 37350 218 22 the the DT 37350 218 23 modern modern JJ 37350 218 24 firmisternal firmisternal JJ 37350 218 25 type type NN 37350 218 26 . . . 37350 219 1 Piveteau Piveteau NNP 37350 219 2 ( ( -LRB- 37350 219 3 1955:261 1955:261 CD 37350 219 4 ) ) -RRB- 37350 219 5 remarks remark NNS 37350 219 6 that that IN 37350 219 7 the the DT 37350 219 8 only only JJ 37350 219 9 living live VBG 37350 219 10 Anuran Anuran NNP 37350 219 11 that that WDT 37350 219 12 can can MD 37350 219 13 be be VB 37350 219 14 compared compare VBN 37350 219 15 usefully usefully RB 37350 219 16 with with IN 37350 219 17 _ _ NNP 37350 219 18 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 219 19 _ _ NNP 37350 219 20 ( ( -LRB- 37350 219 21 Triassic Triassic NNP 37350 219 22 ) ) -RRB- 37350 219 23 with with IN 37350 219 24 regard regard NN 37350 219 25 to to IN 37350 219 26 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 219 27 pectoral pectoral JJ 37350 219 28 girdle girdle NN 37350 219 29 is be VBZ 37350 219 30 _ _ NNP 37350 219 31 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 219 32 _ _ NNP 37350 219 33 . . . 37350 220 1 Again again RB 37350 220 2 , , , 37350 220 3 the the DT 37350 220 4 extent extent NN 37350 220 5 of of IN 37350 220 6 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 220 7 in in IN 37350 220 8 _ _ NNP 37350 220 9 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 220 10 _ _ NNP 37350 220 11 ( ( -LRB- 37350 220 12 Fig Fig NNP 37350 220 13 . . . 37350 221 1 8) 8) CD 37350 221 2 can can MD 37350 221 3 only only RB 37350 221 4 be be VB 37350 221 5 inferred infer VBN 37350 221 6 , , , 37350 221 7 and and CC 37350 221 8 there there EX 37350 221 9 are be VBP 37350 221 10 no no DT 37350 221 11 median median JJ 37350 221 12 elements element NNS 37350 221 13 . . . 37350 222 1 The the DT 37350 222 2 agreement agreement NN 37350 222 3 with with IN 37350 222 4 _ _ NNP 37350 222 5 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 222 6 _ _ NNP 37350 222 7 includes include VBZ 37350 222 8 the the DT 37350 222 9 presence presence NN 37350 222 10 , , , 37350 222 11 in in IN 37350 222 12 both both DT 37350 222 13 , , , 37350 222 14 of of IN 37350 222 15 a a DT 37350 222 16 separate separate JJ 37350 222 17 coracoid coracoid JJ 37350 222 18 ossification ossification NN 37350 222 19 situated situate VBN 37350 222 20 posterior posterior RB 37350 222 21 to to IN 37350 222 22 the the DT 37350 222 23 ossified ossified JJ 37350 222 24 " " `` 37350 222 25 scapulocoracoid scapulocoracoid NN 37350 222 26 " " '' 37350 222 27 ( ( -LRB- 37350 222 28 actually actually RB 37350 222 29 scapula scapula JJ 37350 222 30 ) ) -RRB- 37350 222 31 . . . 37350 223 1 This this DT 37350 223 2 ossification ossification NN 37350 223 3 is be VBZ 37350 223 4 evidently evidently RB 37350 223 5 that that IN 37350 223 6 shown show VBN 37350 223 7 in in IN 37350 223 8 _ _ NNP 37350 223 9 Notobatrachus Notobatrachus NNP 37350 223 10 _ _ NNP 37350 223 11 as as IN 37350 223 12 " " `` 37350 223 13 coracoid coracoid NN 37350 223 14 . . . 37350 223 15 " " '' 37350 224 1 Direct direct JJ 37350 224 2 comparison comparison NN 37350 224 3 of of IN 37350 224 4 the the DT 37350 224 5 three three CD 37350 224 6 genera genera NN 37350 224 7 with with IN 37350 224 8 one one CD 37350 224 9 another another DT 37350 224 10 suggests suggest VBZ 37350 224 11 that that IN 37350 224 12 if if IN 37350 224 13 we -PRON- PRP 37350 224 14 use use VBP 37350 224 15 the the DT 37350 224 16 term term NN 37350 224 17 arciferal arciferal JJ 37350 224 18 for for IN 37350 224 19 any any DT 37350 224 20 , , , 37350 224 21 we -PRON- PRP 37350 224 22 should should MD 37350 224 23 use use VB 37350 224 24 it -PRON- PRP 37350 224 25 for for IN 37350 224 26 all all DT 37350 224 27 . . . 37350 225 1 In in IN 37350 225 2 the the DT 37350 225 3 remote remote JJ 37350 225 4 predecessor predecessor NN 37350 225 5 of of IN 37350 225 6 Anura Anura NNP 37350 225 7 , , , 37350 225 8 _ _ NNP 37350 225 9 Amphibamus Amphibamus NNP 37350 225 10 _ _ NNP 37350 225 11 of of IN 37350 225 12 the the DT 37350 225 13 Pennsylvanian Pennsylvanian NNP 37350 225 14 , , , 37350 225 15 the the DT 37350 225 16 pectoral pectoral JJ 37350 225 17 girdle girdle NN 37350 225 18 was be VBD 37350 225 19 less less RBR 37350 225 20 substantial substantial JJ 37350 225 21 than than IN 37350 225 22 in in IN 37350 225 23 many many JJ 37350 225 24 of of IN 37350 225 25 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 225 26 contemporaries contemporary NNS 37350 225 27 , , , 37350 225 28 but but CC 37350 225 29 it -PRON- PRP 37350 225 30 contained contain VBD 37350 225 31 the the DT 37350 225 32 primitive primitive JJ 37350 225 33 median median JJ 37350 225 34 interclavicle interclavicle NN 37350 225 35 in in IN 37350 225 36 addition addition NN 37350 225 37 to to IN 37350 225 38 the the DT 37350 225 39 clavicle clavicle NNP 37350 225 40 , , , 37350 225 41 cleithrum cleithrum NN 37350 225 42 , , , 37350 225 43 and and CC 37350 225 44 scapulocoracoid scapulocoracoid VB 37350 225 45 . . . 37350 226 1 ( ( -LRB- 37350 226 2 The the DT 37350 226 3 figure figure NN 37350 226 4 of of IN 37350 226 5 Watson Watson NNP 37350 226 6 , , , 37350 226 7 1940 1940 CD 37350 226 8 , , , 37350 226 9 and and CC 37350 226 10 that that IN 37350 226 11 by by IN 37350 226 12 Gregory Gregory NNP 37350 226 13 , , , 37350 226 14 1950 1950 CD 37350 226 15 , , , 37350 226 16 are be VBP 37350 226 17 of of IN 37350 226 18 individuals individual NNS 37350 226 19 of of IN 37350 226 20 different different JJ 37350 226 21 ages age NNS 37350 226 22 , , , 37350 226 23 the the DT 37350 226 24 latter latter JJ 37350 226 25 being be VBG 37350 226 26 older old JJR 37350 226 27 . . . 37350 226 28 ) ) -RRB- 37350 227 1 It -PRON- PRP 37350 227 2 is be VBZ 37350 227 3 clear clear JJ 37350 227 4 that that IN 37350 227 5 the the DT 37350 227 6 paired pair VBN 37350 227 7 elements element NNS 37350 227 8 of of IN 37350 227 9 such such PDT 37350 227 10 a a DT 37350 227 11 girdle girdle NN 37350 227 12 were be VBD 37350 227 13 held hold VBN 37350 227 14 rigid rigid JJ 37350 227 15 by by IN 37350 227 16 their -PRON- PRP$ 37350 227 17 attachment attachment NN 37350 227 18 to to IN 37350 227 19 the the DT 37350 227 20 interclavicle interclavicle NN 37350 227 21 , , , 37350 227 22 _ _ NNP 37350 227 23 via via IN 37350 227 24 _ _ NNP 37350 227 25 the the DT 37350 227 26 clavicles clavicle NNS 37350 227 27 . . . 37350 228 1 Subsequent subsequent JJ 37350 228 2 elimination elimination NN 37350 228 3 of of IN 37350 228 4 the the DT 37350 228 5 interclavicle interclavicle NN 37350 228 6 in in IN 37350 228 7 the the DT 37350 228 8 Anuran Anuran NNP 37350 228 9 line line NN 37350 228 10 of of IN 37350 228 11 descent descent NN 37350 228 12 , , , 37350 228 13 and and CC 37350 228 14 decrease decrease NN 37350 228 15 of of IN 37350 228 16 ossification ossification NN 37350 228 17 , , , 37350 228 18 left leave VBD 37350 228 19 a a DT 37350 228 20 girdle girdle NN 37350 228 21 like like IN 37350 228 22 that that DT 37350 228 23 of of IN 37350 228 24 _ _ NNP 37350 228 25 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 228 26 _ _ NNP 37350 228 27 , , , 37350 228 28 _ _ NNP 37350 228 29 Notobatrachus Notobatrachus NNP 37350 228 30 _ _ NNP 37350 228 31 , , , 37350 228 32 _ _ NNP 37350 228 33 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 228 34 _ _ NNP 37350 228 35 and and CC 37350 228 36 _ _ NNP 37350 228 37 Leiopelma Leiopelma NNP 37350 228 38 _ _ NNP 37350 228 39 . . . 37350 229 1 But but CC 37350 229 2 in in IN 37350 229 3 several several JJ 37350 229 4 advanced advanced JJ 37350 229 5 families family NNS 37350 229 6 a a DT 37350 229 7 more more RBR 37350 229 8 rigid rigid JJ 37350 229 9 median median NN 37350 229 10 " " '' 37350 229 11 sternum sternum NNP 37350 229 12 , , , 37350 229 13 " " '' 37350 229 14 of of IN 37350 229 15 one one CD 37350 229 16 or or CC 37350 229 17 two two CD 37350 229 18 bony bony NN 37350 229 19 pieces piece NNS 37350 229 20 plus plus CC 37350 229 21 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 229 22 , , , 37350 229 23 is be VBZ 37350 229 24 developed develop VBN 37350 229 25 secondarily secondarily RB 37350 229 26 , , , 37350 229 27 possibly possibly RB 37350 229 28 ( ( -LRB- 37350 229 29 as as IN 37350 229 30 Cope Cope NNP 37350 229 31 , , , 37350 229 32 1889 1889 CD 37350 229 33 : : SYM 37350 229 34 247 247 CD 37350 229 35 , , , 37350 229 36 suggested suggest VBN 37350 229 37 ) ) -RRB- 37350 229 38 in in IN 37350 229 39 correlation correlation NN 37350 229 40 with with IN 37350 229 41 axillary axillary JJ 37350 229 42 amplexus amplexus NN 37350 229 43 . . . 37350 230 1 Among among IN 37350 230 2 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 230 3 no no DT 37350 230 4 dermal dermal JJ 37350 230 5 bones bone NNS 37350 230 6 occur occur VBP 37350 230 7 in in IN 37350 230 8 the the DT 37350 230 9 pectoral pectoral JJ 37350 230 10 girdle girdle NN 37350 230 11 . . . 37350 231 1 There there EX 37350 231 2 is be VBZ 37350 231 3 usually usually RB 37350 231 4 a a DT 37350 231 5 scapulocoracoid scapulocoracoid NN 37350 231 6 ossified ossify VBN 37350 231 7 as as IN 37350 231 8 a a DT 37350 231 9 single single JJ 37350 231 10 piece piece NN 37350 231 11 , , , 37350 231 12 from from IN 37350 231 13 which which WDT 37350 231 14 a a DT 37350 231 15 thin thin JJ 37350 231 16 cartilaginous cartilaginous JJ 37350 231 17 suprascapula suprascapula NN 37350 231 18 extends extend VBZ 37350 231 19 dorsally dorsally RB 37350 231 20 and and CC 37350 231 21 a a DT 37350 231 22 broad broad JJ 37350 231 23 cartilaginous cartilaginous JJ 37350 231 24 coracoid coracoid NN 37350 231 25 plate plate NN 37350 231 26 extends extend VBZ 37350 231 27 medially medially RB 37350 231 28 , , , 37350 231 29 overlapping overlap VBG 37350 231 30 the the DT 37350 231 31 one one NN 37350 231 32 from from IN 37350 231 33 the the DT 37350 231 34 opposite opposite JJ 37350 231 35 side side NN 37350 231 36 ; ; : 37350 231 37 a a DT 37350 231 38 precoracoid precoracoid JJ 37350 231 39 lobe lobe NN 37350 231 40 of of IN 37350 231 41 this this DT 37350 231 42 reaches reach VBZ 37350 231 43 forward forward RB 37350 231 44 on on IN 37350 231 45 either either DT 37350 231 46 side side NN 37350 231 47 , , , 37350 231 48 and and CC 37350 231 49 a a DT 37350 231 50 median median JJ 37350 231 51 , , , 37350 231 52 posterior posterior JJ 37350 231 53 " " `` 37350 231 54 sternum sternum FW 37350 231 55 " " '' 37350 231 56 of of IN 37350 231 57 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 231 58 may may MD 37350 231 59 make make VB 37350 231 60 contact contact NN 37350 231 61 with with IN 37350 231 62 the the DT 37350 231 63 edges edge NNS 37350 231 64 of of IN 37350 231 65 the the DT 37350 231 66 two two CD 37350 231 67 coracoids coracoid NNS 37350 231 68 . . . 37350 232 1 In in IN 37350 232 2 _ _ NNP 37350 232 3 Siren Siren NNP 37350 232 4 _ _ NNP 37350 232 5 and and CC 37350 232 6 _ _ NNP 37350 232 7 Amphiuma Amphiuma NNP 37350 232 8 _ _ NNP 37350 232 9 two two CD 37350 232 10 centers center NNS 37350 232 11 of of IN 37350 232 12 ossification ossification NN 37350 232 13 are be VBP 37350 232 14 found find VBN 37350 232 15 for for IN 37350 232 16 each each DT 37350 232 17 scapulocoracoid scapulocoracoid NN 37350 232 18 , , , 37350 232 19 and and CC 37350 232 20 in in IN 37350 232 21 _ _ NNP 37350 232 22 Triton Triton NNP 37350 232 23 _ _ NNP 37350 232 24 and and CC 37350 232 25 _ _ NNP 37350 232 26 Salamandra Salamandra NNP 37350 232 27 _ _ NNP 37350 232 28 three three CD 37350 232 29 . . . 37350 233 1 Probably probably RB 37350 233 2 the the DT 37350 233 3 more more JJR 37350 233 4 dorsal dorsal NN 37350 233 5 and and CC 37350 233 6 lateral lateral JJ 37350 233 7 of of IN 37350 233 8 these these DT 37350 233 9 represents represent VBZ 37350 233 10 the the DT 37350 233 11 primitive primitive JJ 37350 233 12 scapula scapula NN 37350 233 13 and and CC 37350 233 14 the the DT 37350 233 15 other other JJ 37350 233 16 one one NN 37350 233 17 ( ( -LRB- 37350 233 18 or or CC 37350 233 19 two two CD 37350 233 20 ) ) -RRB- 37350 233 21 the the DT 37350 233 22 primitive primitive JJ 37350 233 23 coracoid coracoid NN 37350 233 24 . . . 37350 234 1 Comparing compare VBG 37350 234 2 the the DT 37350 234 3 girdle girdle NN 37350 234 4 of of IN 37350 234 5 a a DT 37350 234 6 salamander salamander NN 37350 234 7 with with IN 37350 234 8 that that DT 37350 234 9 of of IN 37350 234 10 a a DT 37350 234 11 frog frog NN 37350 234 12 , , , 37350 234 13 the the DT 37350 234 14 closest close JJS 37350 234 15 similarity similarity NN 37350 234 16 can can MD 37350 234 17 be be VB 37350 234 18 seen see VBN 37350 234 19 between between IN 37350 234 20 _ _ NNP 37350 234 21 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 234 22 _ _ NNP 37350 234 23 and and CC 37350 234 24 a a DT 37350 234 25 salamander salamander NN 37350 234 26 in in IN 37350 234 27 which which WDT 37350 234 28 the the DT 37350 234 29 scapula scapula NN 37350 234 30 and and CC 37350 234 31 coracoid coracoid NN 37350 234 32 ossify ossify VB 37350 234 33 separately separately RB 37350 234 34 . . . 37350 235 1 Both both DT 37350 235 2 have have VBP 37350 235 3 the the DT 37350 235 4 median median JJ 37350 235 5 " " `` 37350 235 6 sternum sternum FW 37350 235 7 " " '' 37350 235 8 in in IN 37350 235 9 contact contact NN 37350 235 10 with with IN 37350 235 11 the the DT 37350 235 12 coracoid coracoid JJ 37350 235 13 plates plate NNS 37350 235 14 . . . 37350 236 1 The the DT 37350 236 2 major major JJ 37350 236 3 difference difference NN 37350 236 4 , , , 37350 236 5 of of IN 37350 236 6 course course NN 37350 236 7 , , , 37350 236 8 is be VBZ 37350 236 9 the the DT 37350 236 10 lack lack NN 37350 236 11 of of IN 37350 236 12 clavicle clavicle NNP 37350 236 13 and and CC 37350 236 14 cleithrum cleithrum NN 37350 236 15 in in IN 37350 236 16 the the DT 37350 236 17 salamander salamander NN 37350 236 18 . . . 37350 237 1 CARPUS CARPUS NNP 37350 237 2 AND and CC 37350 237 3 TARSUS TARSUS NNP 37350 237 4 In in IN 37350 237 5 _ _ NNP 37350 237 6 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 237 7 _ _ NNP 37350 237 8 ( ( -LRB- 37350 237 9 Ritland Ritland NNP 37350 237 10 , , , 37350 237 11 1955a 1955a CD 37350 237 12 ; ; , 37350 237 13 cleared clear VBN 37350 237 14 and and CC 37350 237 15 stained stain VBN 37350 237 16 specimens specimen NNS 37350 237 17 of of IN 37350 237 18 nearly nearly RB 37350 237 19 grown grow VBN 37350 237 20 males male NNS 37350 237 21 ) ) -RRB- 37350 237 22 distal distal JJ 37350 237 23 carpals carpal NNS 37350 237 24 1 1 CD 37350 237 25 , , , 37350 237 26 2 2 CD 37350 237 27 , , , 37350 237 28 3 3 CD 37350 237 29 and and CC 37350 237 30 4 4 CD 37350 237 31 are be VBP 37350 237 32 present present JJ 37350 237 33 and and CC 37350 237 34 separate separate JJ 37350 237 35 , , , 37350 237 36 increasing increase VBG 37350 237 37 in in IN 37350 237 38 size size NN 37350 237 39 in in IN 37350 237 40 the the DT 37350 237 41 order order NN 37350 237 42 given give VBN 37350 237 43 ( ( -LRB- 37350 237 44 Fig fig NN 37350 237 45 . . . 37350 238 1 9 9 LS 37350 238 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 238 3 . . . 37350 239 1 A a DT 37350 239 2 prepollex prepollex NN 37350 239 3 rests rest VBZ 37350 239 4 against against IN 37350 239 5 centrale centrale NNP 37350 239 6 1 1 CD 37350 239 7 ; ; : 37350 239 8 centralia centralia NNP 37350 239 9 2 2 CD 37350 239 10 and and CC 37350 239 11 3 3 CD 37350 239 12 are be VBP 37350 239 13 fused fuse VBN 37350 239 14 ; ; : 37350 239 15 the the DT 37350 239 16 radiale radiale JJ 37350 239 17 fuses fuse NNS 37350 239 18 with with IN 37350 239 19 centrale centrale NNP 37350 239 20 4 4 CD 37350 239 21 , , , 37350 239 22 and and CC 37350 239 23 the the DT 37350 239 24 intermedium intermedium JJ 37350 239 25 fuses fuse NNS 37350 239 26 with with IN 37350 239 27 the the DT 37350 239 28 ulnare ulnare NNP 37350 239 29 ; ; : 37350 239 30 radius radius NN 37350 239 31 and and CC 37350 239 32 ulna ulna NNP 37350 239 33 are be VBP 37350 239 34 fused fuse VBN 37350 239 35 with with IN 37350 239 36 each each DT 37350 239 37 other other JJ 37350 239 38 as as IN 37350 239 39 in in IN 37350 239 40 other other JJ 37350 239 41 frogs frog NNS 37350 239 42 . . . 37350 240 1 The the DT 37350 240 2 digits digit NNS 37350 240 3 ( ( -LRB- 37350 240 4 and and CC 37350 240 5 metacarpals metacarpal NNS 37350 240 6 ) ) -RRB- 37350 240 7 are be VBP 37350 240 8 considered consider VBN 37350 240 9 by by IN 37350 240 10 Ritland Ritland NNP 37350 240 11 to to TO 37350 240 12 be be VB 37350 240 13 1 1 CD 37350 240 14 - - SYM 37350 240 15 4 4 CD 37350 240 16 , , , 37350 240 17 in in IN 37350 240 18 addition addition NN 37350 240 19 to to IN 37350 240 20 the the DT 37350 240 21 prepollex prepollex NN 37350 240 22 , , , 37350 240 23 rather rather RB 37350 240 24 than than IN 37350 240 25 2 2 CD 37350 240 26 - - SYM 37350 240 27 5 5 CD 37350 240 28 . . . 37350 241 1 [ [ -LRB- 37350 241 2 Illustration illustration NN 37350 241 3 : : : 37350 241 4 Fig Fig NNP 37350 241 5 . . . 37350 242 1 9 9 CD 37350 242 2 . . . 37350 243 1 Skeleton Skeleton NNP 37350 243 2 of of IN 37350 243 3 fore fore NN 37350 243 4 foot foot NN 37350 243 5 of of IN 37350 243 6 _ _ NNP 37350 243 7 Notobatrachus Notobatrachus NNP 37350 243 8 _ _ NNP 37350 243 9 ( ( -LRB- 37350 243 10 after after IN 37350 243 11 Stipanicic Stipanicic NNP 37350 243 12 and and CC 37350 243 13 Reig Reig NNP 37350 243 14 , , , 37350 243 15 1956 1956 CD 37350 243 16 , , , 37350 243 17 terminology terminology NN 37350 243 18 revised revise VBN 37350 243 19 ) ) -RRB- 37350 243 20 and and CC 37350 243 21 _ _ NNP 37350 243 22 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 243 23 _ _ NNP 37350 243 24 ( ( -LRB- 37350 243 25 after after IN 37350 243 26 Ritland Ritland NNP 37350 243 27 , , , 37350 243 28 1955 1955 CD 37350 243 29 a a DT 37350 243 30 ) ) -RRB- 37350 243 31 ; ; : 37350 243 32 all all DT 37350 243 33 ×5 ×5 XX 37350 243 34 . . . 37350 244 1 For for IN 37350 244 2 explanation explanation NN 37350 244 3 of of IN 37350 244 4 abbreviations abbreviation NNS 37350 244 5 see see VBP 37350 244 6 Fig Fig NNP 37350 244 7 . . . 37350 245 1 3 3 LS 37350 245 2 . . . 37350 245 3 ] ] -RRB- 37350 246 1 In in IN 37350 246 2 the the DT 37350 246 3 Jurassic Jurassic NNP 37350 246 4 _ _ NNP 37350 246 5 Notobatrachus Notobatrachus NNP 37350 246 6 _ _ NNP 37350 246 7 Stipanicic Stipanicic NNP 37350 246 8 and and CC 37350 246 9 Reig Reig NNP 37350 246 10 ( ( -LRB- 37350 246 11 1956 1956 CD 37350 246 12 ) ) -RRB- 37350 246 13 have have VBP 37350 246 14 shown show VBN 37350 246 15 the the DT 37350 246 16 carpus carpus NN 37350 246 17 with with IN 37350 246 18 surprising surprising JJ 37350 246 19 clarity clarity NN 37350 246 20 ( ( -LRB- 37350 246 21 Fig fig NN 37350 246 22 . . . 37350 247 1 9 9 LS 37350 247 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 247 3 . . . 37350 248 1 If if IN 37350 248 2 their -PRON- PRP$ 37350 248 3 nomenclature nomenclature NN 37350 248 4 of of IN 37350 248 5 the the DT 37350 248 6 parts part NNS 37350 248 7 be be VB 37350 248 8 revised revise VBN 37350 248 9 , , , 37350 248 10 we -PRON- PRP 37350 248 11 obtain obtain VBP 37350 248 12 a a DT 37350 248 13 fairly fairly RB 37350 248 14 close close JJ 37350 248 15 resemblance resemblance NN 37350 248 16 to to IN 37350 248 17 _ _ NNP 37350 248 18 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 248 19 _ _ NNP 37350 248 20 , , , 37350 248 21 except except IN 37350 248 22 that that IN 37350 248 23 centralia centralia NNP 37350 248 24 2 2 CD 37350 248 25 and and CC 37350 248 26 3 3 CD 37350 248 27 are be VBP 37350 248 28 not not RB 37350 248 29 fused fuse VBN 37350 248 30 , , , 37350 248 31 distal distal JJ 37350 248 32 carpals carpal NNS 37350 248 33 1 1 CD 37350 248 34 and and CC 37350 248 35 2 2 CD 37350 248 36 do do VBP 37350 248 37 not not RB 37350 248 38 show show VB 37350 248 39 ( ( -LRB- 37350 248 40 which which WDT 37350 248 41 would would MD 37350 248 42 easily easily RB 37350 248 43 be be VB 37350 248 44 understood understand VBN 37350 248 45 if if IN 37350 248 46 they -PRON- PRP 37350 248 47 were be VBD 37350 248 48 of of IN 37350 248 49 the the DT 37350 248 50 size size NN 37350 248 51 of of IN 37350 248 52 those those DT 37350 248 53 in in IN 37350 248 54 _ _ NNP 37350 248 55 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 248 56 _ _ NNP 37350 248 57 , , , 37350 248 58 or or CC 37350 248 59 not not RB 37350 248 60 ossified ossify VBN 37350 248 61 ) ) -RRB- 37350 248 62 , , , 37350 248 63 and and CC 37350 248 64 the the DT 37350 248 65 intermedium intermedium NN 37350 248 66 remains remain VBZ 37350 248 67 separate separate JJ 37350 248 68 from from IN 37350 248 69 the the DT 37350 248 70 ulnare ulnare NNP 37350 248 71 . . . 37350 249 1 In in IN 37350 249 2 _ _ NNP 37350 249 3 Salamandra Salamandra NNP 37350 249 4 _ _ NNP 37350 249 5 ( ( -LRB- 37350 249 6 Francis Francis NNP 37350 249 7 , , , 37350 249 8 1934 1934 CD 37350 249 9 ; ; : 37350 249 10 Nauck Nauck NNP 37350 249 11 , , , 37350 249 12 1938 1938 CD 37350 249 13 ) ) -RRB- 37350 249 14 distal distal JJ 37350 249 15 carpals carpal NNS 37350 249 16 1 1 CD 37350 249 17 and and CC 37350 249 18 2 2 CD 37350 249 19 are be VBP 37350 249 20 fused fuse VBN 37350 249 21 in in IN 37350 249 22 both both DT 37350 249 23 larva larva NN 37350 249 24 and and CC 37350 249 25 adult adult NN 37350 249 26 , , , 37350 249 27 and and CC 37350 249 28 3 3 CD 37350 249 29 and and CC 37350 249 30 4 4 CD 37350 249 31 are be VBP 37350 249 32 separate separate JJ 37350 249 33 ; ; : 37350 249 34 the the DT 37350 249 35 radiale radiale NN 37350 249 36 , , , 37350 249 37 intermedium intermedium JJ 37350 249 38 and and CC 37350 249 39 ulnare ulnare NNP 37350 249 40 are be VBP 37350 249 41 separate separate JJ 37350 249 42 in in IN 37350 249 43 the the DT 37350 249 44 larva larva NN 37350 249 45 but but CC 37350 249 46 the the DT 37350 249 47 latter latter JJ 37350 249 48 two two CD 37350 249 49 fuse fuse NN 37350 249 50 in in IN 37350 249 51 the the DT 37350 249 52 adult adult NN 37350 249 53 ; ; : 37350 249 54 centrale centrale NNP 37350 249 55 1 1 CD 37350 249 56 ( ( -LRB- 37350 249 57 labelled label VBN 37350 249 58 prepollical prepollical JJ 37350 249 59 cartilage cartilage NN 37350 249 60 by by IN 37350 249 61 Francis Francis NNP 37350 249 62 ) ) -RRB- 37350 249 63 and and CC 37350 249 64 centrale centrale NNP 37350 249 65 2 2 CD 37350 249 66 are be VBP 37350 249 67 separate separate JJ 37350 249 68 . . . 37350 250 1 Francis Francis NNP 37350 250 2 considers consider VBZ 37350 250 3 the the DT 37350 250 4 digits digit NNS 37350 250 5 ( ( -LRB- 37350 250 6 and and CC 37350 250 7 metacarpals metacarpal NNS 37350 250 8 ) ) -RRB- 37350 250 9 to to TO 37350 250 10 be be VB 37350 250 11 1 1 CD 37350 250 12 - - SYM 37350 250 13 4 4 CD 37350 250 14 . . . 37350 251 1 Apparently apparently RB 37350 251 2 the the DT 37350 251 3 arrangement arrangement NN 37350 251 4 here here RB 37350 251 5 indicated indicate VBD 37350 251 6 for for IN 37350 251 7 the the DT 37350 251 8 larva larva NN 37350 251 9 is be VBZ 37350 251 10 characteristic characteristic JJ 37350 251 11 of of IN 37350 251 12 other other JJ 37350 251 13 larval larval JJ 37350 251 14 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 251 15 , , , 37350 251 16 except except IN 37350 251 17 where where WRB 37350 251 18 further further RB 37350 251 19 reduced reduce VBN 37350 251 20 , , , 37350 251 21 and and CC 37350 251 22 reduction reduction NN 37350 251 23 below below IN 37350 251 24 the the DT 37350 251 25 number number NN 37350 251 26 given give VBN 37350 251 27 for for IN 37350 251 28 the the DT 37350 251 29 adult adult NN 37350 251 30 is be VBZ 37350 251 31 common common JJ 37350 251 32 in in IN 37350 251 33 other other JJ 37350 251 34 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37350 251 35 forms form NNS 37350 251 36 . . . 37350 252 1 The the DT 37350 252 2 radius radius NN 37350 252 3 and and CC 37350 252 4 ulna ulna NN 37350 252 5 are be VBP 37350 252 6 , , , 37350 252 7 of of IN 37350 252 8 course course NN 37350 252 9 , , , 37350 252 10 separate separate JJ 37350 252 11 . . . 37350 253 1 The the DT 37350 253 2 ossification ossification NN 37350 253 3 of of IN 37350 253 4 carpals carpal NNS 37350 253 5 is be VBZ 37350 253 6 more more RBR 37350 253 7 likely likely JJ 37350 253 8 to to TO 37350 253 9 be be VB 37350 253 10 complete complete JJ 37350 253 11 in in IN 37350 253 12 adult adult NN 37350 253 13 frogs frog NNS 37350 253 14 than than IN 37350 253 15 in in IN 37350 253 16 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 253 17 , , , 37350 253 18 but but CC 37350 253 19 some some DT 37350 253 20 ossification ossification NN 37350 253 21 of of IN 37350 253 22 all all DT 37350 253 23 parts part NNS 37350 253 24 named name VBN 37350 253 25 is be VBZ 37350 253 26 found find VBN 37350 253 27 in in IN 37350 253 28 several several JJ 37350 253 29 of of IN 37350 253 30 the the DT 37350 253 31 latter latter JJ 37350 253 32 . . . 37350 254 1 A a DT 37350 254 2 common common JJ 37350 254 3 ancestor ancestor NN 37350 254 4 of of IN 37350 254 5 frogs frog NNS 37350 254 6 and and CC 37350 254 7 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 254 8 could could MD 37350 254 9 be be VB 37350 254 10 expected expect VBN 37350 254 11 to to TO 37350 254 12 have have VB 37350 254 13 the the DT 37350 254 14 following follow VBG 37350 254 15 elements element NNS 37350 254 16 present present JJ 37350 254 17 and and CC 37350 254 18 ossified ossify VBN 37350 254 19 in in IN 37350 254 20 the the DT 37350 254 21 adult adult NN 37350 254 22 : : : 37350 254 23 distal distal JJ 37350 254 24 carpals carpal NNS 37350 254 25 1 1 CD 37350 254 26 - - SYM 37350 254 27 4 4 CD 37350 254 28 separate separate JJ 37350 254 29 ; ; : 37350 254 30 3 3 CD 37350 254 31 centralia centralia NNP 37350 254 32 ; ; : 37350 254 33 radiale radiale NNP 37350 254 34 , , , 37350 254 35 intermedium intermedium JJ 37350 254 36 and and CC 37350 254 37 ulnare ulnare NNP 37350 254 38 separate separate JJ 37350 254 39 . . . 37350 255 1 Comparison comparison NN 37350 255 2 with with IN 37350 255 3 fossils fossil NNS 37350 255 4 older old JJR 37350 255 5 than than IN 37350 255 6 _ _ NNP 37350 255 7 Notobatrachus Notobatrachus NNP 37350 255 8 _ _ NNP 37350 255 9 is be VBZ 37350 255 10 fruitless fruitless JJ 37350 255 11 on on IN 37350 255 12 these these DT 37350 255 13 points point NNS 37350 255 14 , , , 37350 255 15 unless unless IN 37350 255 16 we -PRON- PRP 37350 255 17 go go VBP 37350 255 18 back back RB 37350 255 19 to to IN 37350 255 20 forms form NNS 37350 255 21 too too RB 37350 255 22 distant distant JJ 37350 255 23 to to TO 37350 255 24 have have VB 37350 255 25 any any DT 37350 255 26 special special JJ 37350 255 27 value value NN 37350 255 28 , , , 37350 255 29 such such JJ 37350 255 30 as as IN 37350 255 31 _ _ NNP 37350 255 32 Eryops Eryops NNP 37350 255 33 _ _ NNP 37350 255 34 . . . 37350 256 1 This this DT 37350 256 2 is be VBZ 37350 256 3 because because IN 37350 256 4 of of IN 37350 256 5 inadequate inadequate JJ 37350 256 6 preservation preservation NN 37350 256 7 and and CC 37350 256 8 because because IN 37350 256 9 the the DT 37350 256 10 elements element NNS 37350 256 11 are be VBP 37350 256 12 not not RB 37350 256 13 fully fully RB 37350 256 14 ossified ossify VBN 37350 256 15 in in IN 37350 256 16 many many JJ 37350 256 17 immature immature JJ 37350 256 18 specimens specimen NNS 37350 256 19 . . . 37350 257 1 For for IN 37350 257 2 the the DT 37350 257 3 purpose purpose NN 37350 257 4 of of IN 37350 257 5 this this DT 37350 257 6 review review NN 37350 257 7 there there EX 37350 257 8 is be VBZ 37350 257 9 no no DT 37350 257 10 special special JJ 37350 257 11 value value NN 37350 257 12 in in IN 37350 257 13 a a DT 37350 257 14 comparison comparison NN 37350 257 15 of of IN 37350 257 16 the the DT 37350 257 17 tarsi tarsi NN 37350 257 18 of of IN 37350 257 19 frogs frog NNS 37350 257 20 and and CC 37350 257 21 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 257 22 , , , 37350 257 23 since since IN 37350 257 24 the the DT 37350 257 25 leaping leap VBG 37350 257 26 adaptation adaptation NN 37350 257 27 of of IN 37350 257 28 the the DT 37350 257 29 former former JJ 37350 257 30 leaves leave NNS 37350 257 31 very very RB 37350 257 32 little little JJ 37350 257 33 common common JJ 37350 257 34 pattern pattern NN 37350 257 35 between between IN 37350 257 36 them -PRON- PRP 37350 257 37 . . . 37350 258 1 Even even RB 37350 258 2 in in IN 37350 258 3 _ _ NNP 37350 258 4 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 258 5 _ _ NNP 37350 258 6 , , , 37350 258 7 where where WRB 37350 258 8 the the DT 37350 258 9 legs leg NNS 37350 258 10 were be VBD 37350 258 11 not not RB 37350 258 12 yet yet RB 37350 258 13 conspicuously conspicuously RB 37350 258 14 lengthened lengthen VBN 37350 258 15 , , , 37350 258 16 the the DT 37350 258 17 tibiale tibiale NN 37350 258 18 and and CC 37350 258 19 fibulare fibulare NNP 37350 258 20 ( ( -LRB- 37350 258 21 " " `` 37350 258 22 astragalus astragalus JJ 37350 258 23 " " '' 37350 258 24 and and CC 37350 258 25 " " `` 37350 258 26 calcaneum calcaneum JJ 37350 258 27 " " '' 37350 258 28 respectively respectively RB 37350 258 29 ) ) -RRB- 37350 258 30 were be VBD 37350 258 31 already already RB 37350 258 32 considerably considerably RB 37350 258 33 elongated elongate VBN 37350 258 34 . . . 37350 259 1 The the DT 37350 259 2 carpus carpus NNP 37350 259 3 and and CC 37350 259 4 tarsus tarsus NNP 37350 259 5 of of IN 37350 259 6 _ _ NNP 37350 259 7 Amphibamus Amphibamus NNP 37350 259 8 _ _ NNP 37350 259 9 are be VBP 37350 259 10 as as RB 37350 259 11 yet yet RB 37350 259 12 undecipherable undecipherable JJ 37350 259 13 . . . 37350 260 1 THE the DT 37350 260 2 LARVA larva NN 37350 260 3 Considering consider VBG 37350 260 4 the the DT 37350 260 5 postembryonic postembryonic JJ 37350 260 6 developmental developmental JJ 37350 260 7 stages stage NNS 37350 260 8 of of IN 37350 260 9 modern modern JJ 37350 260 10 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 260 11 , , , 37350 260 12 there there EX 37350 260 13 can can MD 37350 260 14 be be VB 37350 260 15 no no DT 37350 260 16 doubt doubt NN 37350 260 17 that that IN 37350 260 18 a a DT 37350 260 19 gill gill RB 37350 260 20 - - HYPH 37350 260 21 bearing bear VBG 37350 260 22 , , , 37350 260 23 four four CD 37350 260 24 - - HYPH 37350 260 25 legged legged JJ 37350 260 26 larva larva NN 37350 260 27 of of IN 37350 260 28 a a DT 37350 260 29 salamander salamander JJ 37350 260 30 , , , 37350 260 31 in in IN 37350 260 32 which which WDT 37350 260 33 lateral lateral JJ 37350 260 34 line line NN 37350 260 35 pores pore NNS 37350 260 36 and and CC 37350 260 37 a a DT 37350 260 38 gular gular JJ 37350 260 39 fold fold NN 37350 260 40 are be VBP 37350 260 41 present present JJ 37350 260 42 , , , 37350 260 43 represents represent VBZ 37350 260 44 much much RB 37350 260 45 more more RBR 37350 260 46 closely closely RB 37350 260 47 the the DT 37350 260 48 type type NN 37350 260 49 of of IN 37350 260 50 larva larva NN 37350 260 51 found find VBN 37350 260 52 in in IN 37350 260 53 labyrinthodonts labyrinthodont NNS 37350 260 54 than than IN 37350 260 55 does do VBZ 37350 260 56 the the DT 37350 260 57 limbless limbless NN 37350 260 58 , , , 37350 260 59 plant plant NN 37350 260 60 - - HYPH 37350 260 61 nibbling nibble VBG 37350 260 62 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 260 63 of of IN 37350 260 64 the the DT 37350 260 65 Anura Anura NNP 37350 260 66 . . . 37350 261 1 Salamander Salamander NNP 37350 261 2 - - HYPH 37350 261 3 like like JJ 37350 261 4 larvae larvae NN 37350 261 5 of of IN 37350 261 6 labyrinthodonts labyrinthodont NNS 37350 261 7 are be VBP 37350 261 8 well well RB 37350 261 9 known known JJ 37350 261 10 , , , 37350 261 11 especially especially RB 37350 261 12 those those DT 37350 261 13 formerly formerly RB 37350 261 14 supposed suppose VBN 37350 261 15 to to TO 37350 261 16 comprise comprise VB 37350 261 17 the the DT 37350 261 18 order order NN 37350 261 19 Branchiosauria Branchiosauria NNP 37350 261 20 . . . 37350 262 1 Many many JJ 37350 262 2 , , , 37350 262 3 perhaps perhaps RB 37350 262 4 the the DT 37350 262 5 majority majority NN 37350 262 6 of of IN 37350 262 7 , , , 37350 262 8 labyrinthodonts labyrinthodont NNS 37350 262 9 show show VBP 37350 262 10 some some DT 37350 262 11 features feature NNS 37350 262 12 associated associate VBN 37350 262 13 with with IN 37350 262 14 aquatic aquatic JJ 37350 262 15 life life NN 37350 262 16 even even RB 37350 262 17 when when WRB 37350 262 18 full full RB 37350 262 19 - - HYPH 37350 262 20 grown grown JJ 37350 262 21 , , , 37350 262 22 as as IN 37350 262 23 do do VBP 37350 262 24 the the DT 37350 262 25 lepospondyls lepospondyls NN 37350 262 26 . . . 37350 263 1 These these DT 37350 263 2 features feature NNS 37350 263 3 may may MD 37350 263 4 include include VB 37350 263 5 impressions impression NNS 37350 263 6 of of IN 37350 263 7 sensory sensory JJ 37350 263 8 canals canal NNS 37350 263 9 on on IN 37350 263 10 the the DT 37350 263 11 dermal dermal JJ 37350 263 12 bones bone NNS 37350 263 13 of of IN 37350 263 14 the the DT 37350 263 15 skull skull NN 37350 263 16 , , , 37350 263 17 persistence persistence NN 37350 263 18 of of IN 37350 263 19 visceral visceral JJ 37350 263 20 arches arch NNS 37350 263 21 , , , 37350 263 22 reduction reduction NN 37350 263 23 in in IN 37350 263 24 size size NN 37350 263 25 of of IN 37350 263 26 appendages appendage NNS 37350 263 27 , , , 37350 263 28 and and CC 37350 263 29 failure failure NN 37350 263 30 of of IN 37350 263 31 tarsal tarsal NN 37350 263 32 and and CC 37350 263 33 carpal carpal NN 37350 263 34 elements element NNS 37350 263 35 to to TO 37350 263 36 ossify ossify VB 37350 263 37 . . . 37350 264 1 In in IN 37350 264 2 fact fact NN 37350 264 3 , , , 37350 264 4 it -PRON- PRP 37350 264 5 appears appear VBZ 37350 264 6 that that DT 37350 264 7 very very RB 37350 264 8 few few JJ 37350 264 9 of of IN 37350 264 10 the the DT 37350 264 11 Paleozoic Paleozoic NNP 37350 264 12 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 264 13 were be VBD 37350 264 14 successful successful JJ 37350 264 15 in in IN 37350 264 16 establishing establish VBG 37350 264 17 themselves -PRON- PRP 37350 264 18 as as IN 37350 264 19 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37350 264 20 animals animal NNS 37350 264 21 even even RB 37350 264 22 as as IN 37350 264 23 adults adult NNS 37350 264 24 . . . 37350 265 1 Nevertheless nevertheless RB 37350 265 2 , , , 37350 265 3 in in IN 37350 265 4 the the DT 37350 265 5 ancestry ancestry NN 37350 265 6 of of IN 37350 265 7 Anura Anura NNP 37350 265 8 , , , 37350 265 9 and and CC 37350 265 10 that that DT 37350 265 11 of of IN 37350 265 12 at at IN 37350 265 13 least least JJS 37350 265 14 the the DT 37350 265 15 Hynobiid Hynobiid NNP 37350 265 16 , , , 37350 265 17 Ambystomid Ambystomid NNP 37350 265 18 , , , 37350 265 19 Salamandrid Salamandrid NNP 37350 265 20 and and CC 37350 265 21 Plethodontid Plethodontid NNP 37350 265 22 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 265 23 , , , 37350 265 24 there there EX 37350 265 25 must must MD 37350 265 26 certainly certainly RB 37350 265 27 have have VB 37350 265 28 been be VBN 37350 265 29 a a DT 37350 265 30 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37350 265 31 adult adult NN 37350 265 32 , , , 37350 265 33 transforming transform VBG 37350 265 34 from from IN 37350 265 35 an an DT 37350 265 36 aquatic aquatic JJ 37350 265 37 larva larva NN 37350 265 38 . . . 37350 266 1 The the DT 37350 266 2 leaping leaping NN 37350 266 3 mechanism mechanism NN 37350 266 4 of of IN 37350 266 5 Anura Anura NNP 37350 266 6 , , , 37350 266 7 shown show VBN 37350 266 8 in in IN 37350 266 9 so so RB 37350 266 10 many many JJ 37350 266 11 features feature NNS 37350 266 12 of of IN 37350 266 13 their -PRON- PRP$ 37350 266 14 anatomy anatomy NN 37350 266 15 , , , 37350 266 16 is be VBZ 37350 266 17 perhaps perhaps RB 37350 266 18 to to TO 37350 266 19 be be VB 37350 266 20 explained explain VBN 37350 266 21 as as IN 37350 266 22 a a DT 37350 266 23 device device NN 37350 266 24 for for IN 37350 266 25 sudden sudden JJ 37350 266 26 escape escape NN 37350 266 27 from from IN 37350 266 28 land land NN 37350 266 29 into into IN 37350 266 30 the the DT 37350 266 31 water water NN 37350 266 32 , , , 37350 266 33 but but CC 37350 266 34 it -PRON- PRP 37350 266 35 was be VBD 37350 266 36 not not RB 37350 266 37 yet yet RB 37350 266 38 perfected perfect VBN 37350 266 39 in in IN 37350 266 40 the the DT 37350 266 41 Triassic Triassic NNP 37350 266 42 _ _ NNP 37350 266 43 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 266 44 _ _ NNP 37350 266 45 or or CC 37350 266 46 the the DT 37350 266 47 Jurassic Jurassic NNP 37350 266 48 _ _ NNP 37350 266 49 Notobatrachus Notobatrachus NNP 37350 266 50 _ _ NNP 37350 266 51 . . . 37350 267 1 The the DT 37350 267 2 middle middle JJ 37350 267 3 ear ear NN 37350 267 4 , , , 37350 267 5 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 267 6 sound sound NN 37350 267 7 - - HYPH 37350 267 8 transmitting transmitting NN 37350 267 9 mechanism mechanism NN 37350 267 10 , , , 37350 267 11 and and CC 37350 267 12 the the DT 37350 267 13 tympanum tympanum NN 37350 267 14 , , , 37350 267 15 well well RB 37350 267 16 developed develop VBN 37350 267 17 in in IN 37350 267 18 most most JJS 37350 267 19 Anura Anura NNP 37350 267 20 , , , 37350 267 21 are be VBP 37350 267 22 readily readily RB 37350 267 23 derived derive VBN 37350 267 24 from from IN 37350 267 25 those those DT 37350 267 26 of of IN 37350 267 27 early early JJ 37350 267 28 labyrinthodonts labyrinthodont NNS 37350 267 29 , , , 37350 267 30 and and CC 37350 267 31 are be VBP 37350 267 32 presumably presumably RB 37350 267 33 effective effective JJ 37350 267 34 for for IN 37350 267 35 hearing hear VBG 37350 267 36 airborne airborne JJ 37350 267 37 sounds sound VBZ 37350 267 38 whether whether IN 37350 267 39 on on IN 37350 267 40 land land NN 37350 267 41 or or CC 37350 267 42 while while IN 37350 267 43 floating float VBG 37350 267 44 in in IN 37350 267 45 the the DT 37350 267 46 water water NN 37350 267 47 . . . 37350 268 1 Reduction reduction NN 37350 268 2 of of IN 37350 268 3 these these DT 37350 268 4 organs organ NNS 37350 268 5 in in IN 37350 268 6 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 268 7 may may MD 37350 268 8 be be VB 37350 268 9 correlated correlate VBN 37350 268 10 with with IN 37350 268 11 their -PRON- PRP$ 37350 268 12 customary customary JJ 37350 268 13 restriction restriction NN 37350 268 14 to to TO 37350 268 15 subsurface subsurface VB 37350 268 16 habitats habitat NNS 37350 268 17 and and CC 37350 268 18 inability inability NN 37350 268 19 to to TO 37350 268 20 maintain maintain VB 37350 268 21 a a DT 37350 268 22 floating floating JJ 37350 268 23 position position NN 37350 268 24 while while IN 37350 268 25 in in IN 37350 268 26 water water NN 37350 268 27 . . . 37350 269 1 Some some DT 37350 269 2 light light NN 37350 269 3 may may MD 37350 269 4 be be VB 37350 269 5 shed shed VBN 37350 269 6 on on IN 37350 269 7 the the DT 37350 269 8 significance significance NN 37350 269 9 of of IN 37350 269 10 the the DT 37350 269 11 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 269 12 of of IN 37350 269 13 Anura Anura NNP 37350 269 14 by by IN 37350 269 15 considering consider VBG 37350 269 16 the the DT 37350 269 17 early early JJ 37350 269 18 stages stage NNS 37350 269 19 of of IN 37350 269 20 the the DT 37350 269 21 ribbed rib VBN 37350 269 22 frogs frog NNS 37350 269 23 , , , 37350 269 24 Liopelmidae Liopelmidae NNP 37350 269 25 . . . 37350 270 1 _ _ NNP 37350 270 2 Leiopelma Leiopelma NNP 37350 270 3 _ _ NNP 37350 270 4 and and CC 37350 270 5 _ _ NNP 37350 270 6 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 270 7 _ _ NNP 37350 270 8 are be VBP 37350 270 9 so so RB 37350 270 10 closely closely RB 37350 270 11 similar similar JJ 37350 270 12 in in IN 37350 270 13 the the DT 37350 270 14 adult adult NN 37350 270 15 that that IN 37350 270 16 there there EX 37350 270 17 is be VBZ 37350 270 18 no no DT 37350 270 19 doubt doubt NN 37350 270 20 that that IN 37350 270 21 they -PRON- PRP 37350 270 22 belong belong VBP 37350 270 23 in in IN 37350 270 24 one one CD 37350 270 25 family family NN 37350 270 26 , , , 37350 270 27 primitive primitive JJ 37350 270 28 in in IN 37350 270 29 some some DT 37350 270 30 respects respect NNS 37350 270 31 ( ( -LRB- 37350 270 32 including include VBG 37350 270 33 articulated articulate VBN 37350 270 34 ribs rib NNS 37350 270 35 ; ; , 37350 270 36 pyriformis pyriformis NNP 37350 270 37 and and CC 37350 270 38 caudalipuboischiotibialis caudalipuboischiotibialis NNP 37350 270 39 muscles muscle NNS 37350 270 40 ) ) -RRB- 37350 270 41 but but CC 37350 270 42 not not RB 37350 270 43 in in IN 37350 270 44 others other NNS 37350 270 45 ( ( -LRB- 37350 270 46 absence absence NN 37350 270 47 of of IN 37350 270 48 tympanum tympanum NN 37350 270 49 and and CC 37350 270 50 middle middle JJ 37350 270 51 ear ear NN 37350 270 52 ) ) -RRB- 37350 270 53 . . . 37350 271 1 In in IN 37350 271 2 both both DT 37350 271 3 genera genera NN 37350 271 4 the the DT 37350 271 5 eggs egg NNS 37350 271 6 are be VBP 37350 271 7 large large JJ 37350 271 8 , , , 37350 271 9 5 5 CD 37350 271 10 mm mm CD 37350 271 11 . . . 37350 272 1 in in IN 37350 272 2 _ _ NNP 37350 272 3 Leiopelma Leiopelma NNP 37350 272 4 _ _ NNP 37350 272 5 , , , 37350 272 6 4.5 4.5 CD 37350 272 7 mm mm CD 37350 272 8 . . . 37350 273 1 in in IN 37350 273 2 _ _ NNP 37350 273 3 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 273 4 _ _ NNP 37350 273 5 , , , 37350 273 6 and and CC 37350 273 7 unpigmented unpigmented JJ 37350 273 8 ; ; : 37350 273 9 but but CC 37350 273 10 at at IN 37350 273 11 this this DT 37350 273 12 point point NN 37350 273 13 the the DT 37350 273 14 resemblance resemblance NN 37350 273 15 ends end VBZ 37350 273 16 . . . 37350 274 1 [ [ -LRB- 37350 274 2 Illustration illustration NN 37350 274 3 : : : 37350 274 4 Fig Fig NNP 37350 274 5 . . . 37350 275 1 10 10 CD 37350 275 2 . . . 37350 276 1 _ _ NNP 37350 276 2 Leiopelma Leiopelma NNP 37350 276 3 hochstetteri hochstetteri NN 37350 276 4 _ _ NNP 37350 276 5 larva larva NNP 37350 276 6 , , , 37350 276 7 lateral lateral JJ 37350 276 8 and and CC 37350 276 9 ventral ventral JJ 37350 276 10 ( ( -LRB- 37350 276 11 after after IN 37350 276 12 Stephenson Stephenson NNP 37350 276 13 , , , 37350 276 14 1955 1955 CD 37350 276 15 ) ) -RRB- 37350 276 16 , , , 37350 276 17 ×4 ×4 NFP 37350 276 18 . . . 37350 276 19 ] ] -RRB- 37350 277 1 Stephenson Stephenson NNP 37350 277 2 ( ( -LRB- 37350 277 3 1955 1955 CD 37350 277 4 ) ) -RRB- 37350 277 5 showed show VBD 37350 277 6 that that IN 37350 277 7 embryos embryo NNS 37350 277 8 of of IN 37350 277 9 _ _ NNP 37350 277 10 L. L. NNP 37350 278 1 hochstetteri hochstetteri NNP 37350 278 2 _ _ NNP 37350 278 3 develop develop VBP 37350 278 4 equally equally RB 37350 278 5 well well RB 37350 278 6 on on IN 37350 278 7 land land NN 37350 278 8 ( ( -LRB- 37350 278 9 in in IN 37350 278 10 damp damp JJ 37350 278 11 places place NNS 37350 278 12 ) ) -RRB- 37350 278 13 or or CC 37350 278 14 in in IN 37350 278 15 the the DT 37350 278 16 water water NN 37350 278 17 , , , 37350 278 18 and and CC 37350 278 19 that that IN 37350 278 20 embryos embryo NNS 37350 278 21 prematurely prematurely RB 37350 278 22 released release VBN 37350 278 23 from from IN 37350 278 24 egg egg NN 37350 278 25 capsules capsule NNS 37350 278 26 develop develop VBP 37350 278 27 successfully successfully RB 37350 278 28 in in IN 37350 278 29 the the DT 37350 278 30 water water NN 37350 278 31 . . . 37350 279 1 The the DT 37350 279 2 larvae larvae JJ 37350 279 3 possess possess VBP 37350 279 4 both both CC 37350 279 5 pairs pair NNS 37350 279 6 of of IN 37350 279 7 legs leg NNS 37350 279 8 ( ( -LRB- 37350 279 9 Fig fig NN 37350 279 10 . . . 37350 280 1 10 10 LS 37350 280 2 ) ) -RRB- 37350 280 3 and and CC 37350 280 4 a a DT 37350 280 5 broad broad JJ 37350 280 6 gular gular JJ 37350 280 7 fold fold RB 37350 280 8 similar similar JJ 37350 280 9 to to IN 37350 280 10 that that DT 37350 280 11 of of IN 37350 280 12 larval larval NN 37350 280 13 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 280 14 . . . 37350 281 1 In in IN 37350 281 2 _ _ NNP 37350 281 3 L. L. NNP 37350 282 1 hochstetteri hochstetteri NNP 37350 282 2 _ _ NNP 37350 282 3 the the DT 37350 282 4 fold fold NN 37350 282 5 grows grow VBZ 37350 282 6 back back RB 37350 282 7 over over IN 37350 282 8 the the DT 37350 282 9 forelegs foreleg NNS 37350 282 10 temporarily temporarily RB 37350 282 11 , , , 37350 282 12 but but CC 37350 282 13 remains remain VBZ 37350 282 14 free free JJ 37350 282 15 from from IN 37350 282 16 the the DT 37350 282 17 body body NN 37350 282 18 and and CC 37350 282 19 presently presently RB 37350 282 20 the the DT 37350 282 21 legs leg NNS 37350 282 22 reappear reappear NN 37350 282 23 , , , 37350 282 24 whereas whereas IN 37350 282 25 in in IN 37350 282 26 _ _ NNP 37350 282 27 L. L. NNP 37350 283 1 archeyi archeyi NNP 37350 283 2 _ _ NNP 37350 283 3 the the DT 37350 283 4 forelegs foreleg NNS 37350 283 5 are be VBP 37350 283 6 not not RB 37350 283 7 covered cover VBN 37350 283 8 at at IN 37350 283 9 any any DT 37350 283 10 time time NN 37350 283 11 . . . 37350 284 1 No no DT 37350 284 2 branchial branchial JJ 37350 284 3 chamber chamber NN 37350 284 4 or or CC 37350 284 5 spiracle spiracle NNP 37350 284 6 is be VBZ 37350 284 7 formed form VBN 37350 284 8 . . . 37350 285 1 Of of RB 37350 285 2 course course RB 37350 285 3 direct direct JJ 37350 285 4 development development NN 37350 285 5 , , , 37350 285 6 without without IN 37350 285 7 a a DT 37350 285 8 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 285 9 , , , 37350 285 10 occurs occur VBZ 37350 285 11 in in IN 37350 285 12 several several JJ 37350 285 13 other other JJ 37350 285 14 groups group NNS 37350 285 15 of of IN 37350 285 16 Anura Anura NNP 37350 285 17 , , , 37350 285 18 but but CC 37350 285 19 in in IN 37350 285 20 each each DT 37350 285 21 case case NN 37350 285 22 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37350 285 23 adaptations adaptation NNS 37350 285 24 are be VBP 37350 285 25 obvious obvious JJ 37350 285 26 . . . 37350 286 1 This this DT 37350 286 2 is be VBZ 37350 286 3 not not RB 37350 286 4 true true JJ 37350 286 5 of of IN 37350 286 6 _ _ NNP 37350 286 7 Leiopelma Leiopelma NNP 37350 286 8 _ _ NNP 37350 286 9 , , , 37350 286 10 which which WDT 37350 286 11 Stephenson Stephenson NNP 37350 286 12 regards regard VBZ 37350 286 13 as as IN 37350 286 14 more more RBR 37350 286 15 nearly nearly RB 37350 286 16 comparable comparable JJ 37350 286 17 with with IN 37350 286 18 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 286 19 in in IN 37350 286 20 its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 286 21 development development NN 37350 286 22 than than IN 37350 286 23 with with IN 37350 286 24 other other JJ 37350 286 25 Anura Anura NNP 37350 286 26 , , , 37350 286 27 and and CC 37350 286 28 he -PRON- PRP 37350 286 29 sees see VBZ 37350 286 30 in in IN 37350 286 31 it -PRON- PRP 37350 286 32 a a DT 37350 286 33 " " `` 37350 286 34 primary primary JJ 37350 286 35 and and CC 37350 286 36 amphibious amphibious JJ 37350 286 37 " " '' 37350 286 38 mode mode NN 37350 286 39 instead instead RB 37350 286 40 of of IN 37350 286 41 a a DT 37350 286 42 terrestrial terrestrial JJ 37350 286 43 specialization specialization NN 37350 286 44 . . . 37350 287 1 The the DT 37350 287 2 _ _ NNP 37350 287 3 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 287 4 _ _ NNP 37350 287 5 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 287 6 bears bear VBZ 37350 287 7 no no DT 37350 287 8 outward outward JJ 37350 287 9 resemblance resemblance NN 37350 287 10 to to IN 37350 287 11 the the DT 37350 287 12 larva larva NN 37350 287 13 of of IN 37350 287 14 _ _ NNP 37350 287 15 Leiopelma Leiopelma NNP 37350 287 16 _ _ NNP 37350 287 17 , , , 37350 287 18 but but CC 37350 287 19 is be VBZ 37350 287 20 a a DT 37350 287 21 normal normal JJ 37350 287 22 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 287 23 in in IN 37350 287 24 form form NN 37350 287 25 , , , 37350 287 26 although although IN 37350 287 27 sluggish sluggish JJ 37350 287 28 in in IN 37350 287 29 activity activity NN 37350 287 30 . . . 37350 288 1 Its -PRON- PRP$ 37350 288 2 greatly greatly RB 37350 288 3 expanded expand VBD 37350 288 4 labial labial JJ 37350 288 5 folds fold NNS 37350 288 6 bear bear VBP 37350 288 7 numerous numerous JJ 37350 288 8 rows row NNS 37350 288 9 of of IN 37350 288 10 horny horny NN 37350 288 11 epidermal epidermal JJ 37350 288 12 " " '' 37350 288 13 teeth tooth NNS 37350 288 14 , , , 37350 288 15 " " '' 37350 288 16 which which WDT 37350 288 17 , , , 37350 288 18 with with IN 37350 288 19 the the DT 37350 288 20 lips lip NNS 37350 288 21 , , , 37350 288 22 serve serve VB 37350 288 23 to to TO 37350 288 24 anchor anchor VB 37350 288 25 the the DT 37350 288 26 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 288 27 to to IN 37350 288 28 stones stone NNS 37350 288 29 in in IN 37350 288 30 the the DT 37350 288 31 swift swift JJ 37350 288 32 water water NN 37350 288 33 of of IN 37350 288 34 mountain mountain NNP 37350 288 35 brooks brook NNS 37350 288 36 . . . 37350 289 1 Noble Noble NNP 37350 289 2 ( ( -LRB- 37350 289 3 1927 1927 CD 37350 289 4 ) ) -RRB- 37350 289 5 noticed notice VBD 37350 289 6 that that IN 37350 289 7 particles particle NNS 37350 289 8 of of IN 37350 289 9 food food NN 37350 289 10 were be VBD 37350 289 11 taken take VBN 37350 289 12 in in RP 37350 289 13 through through IN 37350 289 14 the the DT 37350 289 15 external external JJ 37350 289 16 nares naris NNS 37350 289 17 , , , 37350 289 18 and and CC 37350 289 19 that that IN 37350 289 20 a a DT 37350 289 21 current current NN 37350 289 22 of of IN 37350 289 23 water water NN 37350 289 24 passed pass VBN 37350 289 25 through through IN 37350 289 26 these these DT 37350 289 27 openings opening NNS 37350 289 28 and and CC 37350 289 29 out out RB 37350 289 30 by by IN 37350 289 31 way way NN 37350 289 32 of of IN 37350 289 33 the the DT 37350 289 34 median median JJ 37350 289 35 spiracle spiracle NNP 37350 289 36 . . . 37350 290 1 It -PRON- PRP 37350 290 2 appears appear VBZ 37350 290 3 that that IN 37350 290 4 any any DT 37350 290 5 action action NN 37350 290 6 by by IN 37350 290 7 the the DT 37350 290 8 teeth tooth NNS 37350 290 9 and and CC 37350 290 10 jaws jaw NNS 37350 290 11 in in IN 37350 290 12 scraping scrape VBG 37350 290 13 algae algae NN 37350 290 14 from from IN 37350 290 15 the the DT 37350 290 16 rocks rock NNS 37350 290 17 ( ( -LRB- 37350 290 18 which which WDT 37350 290 19 were be VBD 37350 290 20 bare bare JJ 37350 290 21 in in IN 37350 290 22 the the DT 37350 290 23 stream stream NN 37350 290 24 where where WRB 37350 290 25 I -PRON- PRP 37350 290 26 have have VBP 37350 290 27 collected collect VBN 37350 290 28 _ _ NNP 37350 290 29 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 290 30 _ _ NNP 37350 290 31 ) ) -RRB- 37350 290 32 would would MD 37350 290 33 be be VB 37350 290 34 quite quite RB 37350 290 35 incidental incidental JJ 37350 290 36 , , , 37350 290 37 and and CC 37350 290 38 that that IN 37350 290 39 the the DT 37350 290 40 lips lip NNS 37350 290 41 and and CC 37350 290 42 teeth tooth NNS 37350 290 43 must must MD 37350 290 44 be be VB 37350 290 45 primarily primarily RB 37350 290 46 a a DT 37350 290 47 clinging cling VBG 37350 290 48 mechanism mechanism NN 37350 290 49 . . . 37350 291 1 Certain certain JJ 37350 291 2 other other JJ 37350 291 3 mountain mountain NN 37350 291 4 brook brook NN 37350 291 5 tadpoles tadpole NNS 37350 291 6 ( ( -LRB- 37350 291 7 for for IN 37350 291 8 example example NN 37350 291 9 , , , 37350 291 10 _ _ NNP 37350 291 11 Borborocoetes Borborocoetes NNP 37350 291 12 _ _ NNP 37350 291 13 ) ) -RRB- 37350 291 14 show show VBP 37350 291 15 similar similar JJ 37350 291 16 devices device NNS 37350 291 17 , , , 37350 291 18 but but CC 37350 291 19 these these DT 37350 291 20 are be VBP 37350 291 21 developed develop VBN 37350 291 22 independently independently RB 37350 291 23 , , , 37350 291 24 as as IN 37350 291 25 specializations specialization NNS 37350 291 26 from from IN 37350 291 27 the the DT 37350 291 28 usual usual JJ 37350 291 29 sort sort NN 37350 291 30 of of IN 37350 291 31 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 291 32 . . . 37350 292 1 May May MD 37350 292 2 it -PRON- PRP 37350 292 3 not not RB 37350 292 4 be be VB 37350 292 5 that that IN 37350 292 6 closure closure NN 37350 292 7 of of IN 37350 292 8 the the DT 37350 292 9 gill gill JJ 37350 292 10 - - HYPH 37350 292 11 chamber chamber NN 37350 292 12 by by IN 37350 292 13 the the DT 37350 292 14 opercular opercular NNP 37350 292 15 ( ( -LRB- 37350 292 16 = = SYM 37350 292 17 gular gular JJ 37350 292 18 ) ) -RRB- 37350 292 19 fold fold RB 37350 292 20 , , , 37350 292 21 retardation retardation NN 37350 292 22 of of IN 37350 292 23 limb limb NN 37350 292 24 development development NN 37350 292 25 , , , 37350 292 26 expansion expansion NN 37350 292 27 of of IN 37350 292 28 the the DT 37350 292 29 lips lip NNS 37350 292 30 , , , 37350 292 31 growth growth NN 37350 292 32 of of IN 37350 292 33 parallel parallel JJ 37350 292 34 rows row NNS 37350 292 35 of of IN 37350 292 36 horny horny NN 37350 292 37 teeth tooth NNS 37350 292 38 , , , 37350 292 39 and and CC 37350 292 40 other other JJ 37350 292 41 correlated correlate VBD 37350 292 42 features feature NNS 37350 292 43 that that WDT 37350 292 44 make make VBP 37350 292 45 a a DT 37350 292 46 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 292 47 , , , 37350 292 48 were be VBD 37350 292 49 brought bring VBN 37350 292 50 about about RP 37350 292 51 as as IN 37350 292 52 an an DT 37350 292 53 adaptation adaptation NN 37350 292 54 of of IN 37350 292 55 the the DT 37350 292 56 primitive primitive JJ 37350 292 57 Anuran Anuran NNP 37350 292 58 larva larva VBZ 37350 292 59 to to IN 37350 292 60 a a DT 37350 292 61 swift swift JJ 37350 292 62 - - HYPH 37350 292 63 stream stream NN 37350 292 64 habitat habitat NN 37350 292 65 , , , 37350 292 66 and and CC 37350 292 67 that that IN 37350 292 68 this this DT 37350 292 69 " " `` 37350 292 70 basic basic JJ 37350 292 71 patent patent NN 37350 292 72 " " '' 37350 292 73 then then RB 37350 292 74 later later RB 37350 292 75 served serve VBD 37350 292 76 to to TO 37350 292 77 admit admit VB 37350 292 78 the the DT 37350 292 79 tadpoles tadpole NNS 37350 292 80 of of IN 37350 292 81 descendant descendant JJ 37350 292 82 types type NNS 37350 292 83 to to IN 37350 292 84 an an DT 37350 292 85 alga alga RB 37350 292 86 - - HYPH 37350 292 87 scraping scrape VBG 37350 292 88 habit habit NN 37350 292 89 in in IN 37350 292 90 quiet quiet JJ 37350 292 91 water water NN 37350 292 92 as as RB 37350 292 93 well well RB 37350 292 94 ? ? . 37350 293 1 The the DT 37350 293 2 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 293 3 , , , 37350 293 4 as as IN 37350 293 5 a a DT 37350 293 6 unique unique JJ 37350 293 7 larval larval NN 37350 293 8 type type NN 37350 293 9 among among IN 37350 293 10 vertebrates vertebrate NNS 37350 293 11 , , , 37350 293 12 bears bear VBZ 37350 293 13 the the DT 37350 293 14 hallmarks hallmark NNS 37350 293 15 of of IN 37350 293 16 an an DT 37350 293 17 abrupt abrupt JJ 37350 293 18 adaptive adaptive JJ 37350 293 19 shift shift NN 37350 293 20 , , , 37350 293 21 such such JJ 37350 293 22 as as IN 37350 293 23 might may MD 37350 293 24 have have VB 37350 293 25 occurred occur VBN 37350 293 26 within within IN 37350 293 27 the the DT 37350 293 28 limits limit NNS 37350 293 29 of of IN 37350 293 30 a a DT 37350 293 31 single single JJ 37350 293 32 family family NN 37350 293 33 , , , 37350 293 34 and and CC 37350 293 35 it -PRON- PRP 37350 293 36 seems seem VBZ 37350 293 37 difficult difficult JJ 37350 293 38 to to TO 37350 293 39 imagine imagine VB 37350 293 40 the the DT 37350 293 41 enclosed enclose VBN 37350 293 42 branchial branchial NNP 37350 293 43 chamber chamber NN 37350 293 44 , , , 37350 293 45 the the DT 37350 293 46 tooth tooth NN 37350 293 47 - - HYPH 37350 293 48 rows row NNS 37350 293 49 , , , 37350 293 50 and and CC 37350 293 51 lips lip NNS 37350 293 52 of of IN 37350 293 53 a a DT 37350 293 54 familiar familiar JJ 37350 293 55 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 293 56 as as IN 37350 293 57 having have VBG 37350 293 58 evolved evolve VBN 37350 293 59 without without IN 37350 293 60 some some DT 37350 293 61 kind kind NN 37350 293 62 of of IN 37350 293 63 suctorial suctorial JJ 37350 293 64 function function NN 37350 293 65 along along IN 37350 293 66 the the DT 37350 293 67 way way NN 37350 293 68 . . . 37350 294 1 SUMMARY SUMMARY NNP 37350 294 2 The the DT 37350 294 3 Anura Anura NNP 37350 294 4 probably probably RB 37350 294 5 originated originate VBD 37350 294 6 among among IN 37350 294 7 temnospondylous temnospondylous JJ 37350 294 8 labyrinthodonts labyrinthodont NNS 37350 294 9 , , , 37350 294 10 through through IN 37350 294 11 a a DT 37350 294 12 line line NN 37350 294 13 represented represent VBN 37350 294 14 approximately approximately RB 37350 294 15 by by IN 37350 294 16 _ _ NNP 37350 294 17 Eugyrinus Eugyrinus NNP 37350 294 18 _ _ NNP 37350 294 19 , , , 37350 294 20 _ _ NNP 37350 294 21 Amphibamus Amphibamus NNP 37350 294 22 _ _ NNP 37350 294 23 , , , 37350 294 24 and and CC 37350 294 25 the the DT 37350 294 26 Triassic Triassic NNP 37350 294 27 frog frog NN 37350 294 28 _ _ NNP 37350 294 29 Protobatrachus Protobatrachus NNP 37350 294 30 _ _ NNP 37350 294 31 , , , 37350 294 32 as as IN 37350 294 33 shown show VBN 37350 294 34 by by IN 37350 294 35 Watson Watson NNP 37350 294 36 , , , 37350 294 37 Piveteau Piveteau NNP 37350 294 38 and and CC 37350 294 39 others other NNS 37350 294 40 . . . 37350 295 1 The the DT 37350 295 2 known known JJ 37350 295 3 Paleozoic Paleozoic NNP 37350 295 4 lepospondyls lepospondyls NN 37350 295 5 do do VBP 37350 295 6 not not RB 37350 295 7 show show VB 37350 295 8 clear clear JJ 37350 295 9 indications indication NNS 37350 295 10 of of IN 37350 295 11 a a DT 37350 295 12 relationship relationship NN 37350 295 13 with with IN 37350 295 14 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 295 15 , , , 37350 295 16 but but CC 37350 295 17 _ _ NNP 37350 295 18 Lysorophus Lysorophus NNP 37350 295 19 _ _ NNP 37350 295 20 may may MD 37350 295 21 well well RB 37350 295 22 be be VB 37350 295 23 on on IN 37350 295 24 the the DT 37350 295 25 ancestral ancestral JJ 37350 295 26 stem stem NN 37350 295 27 of of IN 37350 295 28 the the DT 37350 295 29 Apoda Apoda NNP 37350 295 30 . . . 37350 296 1 Between between IN 37350 296 2 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 296 3 and and CC 37350 296 4 Anura Anura NNP 37350 296 5 there there EX 37350 296 6 are be VBP 37350 296 7 numerous numerous JJ 37350 296 8 resemblances resemblance NNS 37350 296 9 which which WDT 37350 296 10 seem seem VBP 37350 296 11 to to TO 37350 296 12 indicate indicate VB 37350 296 13 direct direct JJ 37350 296 14 relationship relationship NN 37350 296 15 through through IN 37350 296 16 a a DT 37350 296 17 common common JJ 37350 296 18 stock stock NN 37350 296 19 : : : 37350 296 20 ( ( -LRB- 37350 296 21 1 1 LS 37350 296 22 ) ) -RRB- 37350 296 23 a a DT 37350 296 24 similar similar JJ 37350 296 25 reduction reduction NN 37350 296 26 of of IN 37350 296 27 dermal dermal JJ 37350 296 28 bones bone NNS 37350 296 29 of of IN 37350 296 30 the the DT 37350 296 31 skull skull NN 37350 296 32 and and CC 37350 296 33 expansion expansion NN 37350 296 34 of of IN 37350 296 35 palatal palatal JJ 37350 296 36 vacuities vacuity NNS 37350 296 37 ; ; , 37350 296 38 ( ( -LRB- 37350 296 39 2 2 LS 37350 296 40 ) ) -RRB- 37350 296 41 movable movable JJ 37350 296 42 basipterygoid basipterygoid JJ 37350 296 43 articulation articulation NN 37350 296 44 in in IN 37350 296 45 primitive primitive JJ 37350 296 46 members member NNS 37350 296 47 of of IN 37350 296 48 both both DT 37350 296 49 orders order NNS 37350 296 50 ; ; : 37350 296 51 ( ( -LRB- 37350 296 52 3 3 LS 37350 296 53 ) ) -RRB- 37350 296 54 an an DT 37350 296 55 operculum operculum NN 37350 296 56 formed form VBN 37350 296 57 in in IN 37350 296 58 the the DT 37350 296 59 otic otic JJ 37350 296 60 capsule capsule NN 37350 296 61 , , , 37350 296 62 with with IN 37350 296 63 opercularis opercularis JJ 37350 296 64 muscle muscle NN 37350 296 65 ; ; , 37350 296 66 ( ( -LRB- 37350 296 67 4 4 LS 37350 296 68 ) ) -RRB- 37350 296 69 many many JJ 37350 296 70 details detail NNS 37350 296 71 of of IN 37350 296 72 cranial cranial JJ 37350 296 73 development development NN 37350 296 74 , , , 37350 296 75 cranial cranial JJ 37350 296 76 muscles muscle NNS 37350 296 77 , , , 37350 296 78 and and CC 37350 296 79 thigh thigh NN 37350 296 80 muscles muscle NNS 37350 296 81 , , , 37350 296 82 especially especially RB 37350 296 83 between between IN 37350 296 84 _ _ NNP 37350 296 85 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 296 86 _ _ NNP 37350 296 87 and and CC 37350 296 88 the the DT 37350 296 89 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 296 90 , , , 37350 296 91 as as IN 37350 296 92 shown show VBN 37350 296 93 by by IN 37350 296 94 Pusey Pusey NNP 37350 296 95 and and CC 37350 296 96 Noble Noble NNP 37350 296 97 ; ; : 37350 296 98 ( ( -LRB- 37350 296 99 5 5 LS 37350 296 100 ) ) -RRB- 37350 296 101 essentially essentially RB 37350 296 102 similar similar JJ 37350 296 103 manner manner NN 37350 296 104 of of IN 37350 296 105 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 296 106 development development NN 37350 296 107 , , , 37350 296 108 quite quite RB 37350 296 109 consistent consistent JJ 37350 296 110 with with IN 37350 296 111 derivation derivation NN 37350 296 112 of of IN 37350 296 113 both both DT 37350 296 114 orders order NNS 37350 296 115 from from IN 37350 296 116 Temnospondyli Temnospondyli NNP 37350 296 117 ; ; : 37350 296 118 ( ( -LRB- 37350 296 119 6 6 LS 37350 296 120 ) ) -RRB- 37350 296 121 presence presence NN 37350 296 122 in in IN 37350 296 123 the the DT 37350 296 124 larva larva NN 37350 296 125 of of IN 37350 296 126 _ _ NNP 37350 296 127 Leiopelma Leiopelma NNP 37350 296 128 _ _ NNP 37350 296 129 of of IN 37350 296 130 a a DT 37350 296 131 salamander salamander JJ 37350 296 132 - - HYPH 37350 296 133 like like JJ 37350 296 134 gular gular JJ 37350 296 135 fold fold NNP 37350 296 136 , , , 37350 296 137 four four CD 37350 296 138 limbs limb NNS 37350 296 139 , , , 37350 296 140 and and CC 37350 296 141 no no DT 37350 296 142 suggestion suggestion NN 37350 296 143 of of IN 37350 296 144 modification modification NN 37350 296 145 from from IN 37350 296 146 a a DT 37350 296 147 tadpole tadpole NN 37350 296 148 ( ( -LRB- 37350 296 149 Stephenson Stephenson NNP 37350 296 150 ) ) -RRB- 37350 296 151 . . . 37350 297 1 LITERATURE LITERATURE NNP 37350 297 2 CITED cite VBD 37350 297 3 Broom Broom NNP 37350 297 4 , , , 37350 297 5 R. R. NNP 37350 297 6 1918 1918 CD 37350 297 7 . . . 37350 298 1 Observations observation NNS 37350 298 2 on on IN 37350 298 3 the the DT 37350 298 4 genus genus NN 37350 298 5 _ _ NNP 37350 298 6 Lysorophus Lysorophus NNP 37350 298 7 _ _ NNP 37350 298 8 Cope Cope NNP 37350 298 9 . . . 37350 299 1 Ann Ann NNP 37350 299 2 . . . 37350 300 1 Mag mag JJ 37350 300 2 . . . 37350 301 1 Nat Nat NNP 37350 301 2 . . . 37350 302 1 Hist Hist NNP 37350 302 2 . . . 37350 302 3 , , , 37350 302 4 ( ( -LRB- 37350 302 5 9)2:232 9)2:232 CD 37350 302 6 - - HYPH 37350 302 7 239 239 CD 37350 302 8 . . . 37350 303 1 Bystrow Bystrow NNP 37350 303 2 , , , 37350 303 3 A. a. NN 37350 303 4 P. P. NNP 37350 303 5 1938 1938 CD 37350 303 6 . . . 37350 304 1 Dvinosaurus dvinosaurus JJ 37350 304 2 als als NN 37350 304 3 neotenische neotenische NN 37350 304 4 Form Form NNP 37350 304 5 der der NN 37350 304 6 Stegocephalen Stegocephalen NNP 37350 304 7 . . . 37350 305 1 Acta Acta NNP 37350 305 2 Zool Zool NNP 37350 305 3 . . NNP 37350 305 4 , , , 37350 305 5 19:209 19:209 CD 37350 305 6 - - SYM 37350 305 7 295 295 CD 37350 305 8 . . . 37350 306 1 Case case NN 37350 306 2 , , , 37350 306 3 E. E. NNP 37350 306 4 C. C. NNP 37350 306 5 1935 1935 CD 37350 306 6 . . . 37350 307 1 Description description NN 37350 307 2 of of IN 37350 307 3 a a DT 37350 307 4 collection collection NN 37350 307 5 of of IN 37350 307 6 associated associate VBN 37350 307 7 skeletons skeleton NNS 37350 307 8 of of IN 37350 307 9 _ _ NNP 37350 307 10 Trimerorhachis Trimerorhachis NNP 37350 307 11 _ _ NNP 37350 307 12 . . . 37350 308 1 Contrib Contrib NNP 37350 308 2 . . . 37350 309 1 Mus mus NN 37350 309 2 . . . 37350 310 1 Pal Pal NNP 37350 310 2 . . . 37350 311 1 Univ Univ NNP 37350 311 2 . . . 37350 312 1 Michigan Michigan NNP 37350 312 2 , , , 37350 312 3 4:227 4:227 CD 37350 312 4 - - SYM 37350 312 5 274 274 CD 37350 312 6 . . . 37350 313 1 Cope cope VB 37350 313 2 , , , 37350 313 3 E. E. NNP 37350 313 4 D. D. NNP 37350 313 5 1889 1889 CD 37350 313 6 . . . 37350 314 1 The the DT 37350 314 2 Batrachia Batrachia NNP 37350 314 3 of of IN 37350 314 4 North North NNP 37350 314 5 America America NNP 37350 314 6 . . . 37350 315 1 Bull Bull NNP 37350 315 2 . . . 37350 316 1 U. U. NNP 37350 316 2 S. S. NNP 37350 316 3 Nat Nat NNP 37350 316 4 . . . 37350 317 1 Mus Mus NNP 37350 317 2 . . . 37350 317 3 , , , 37350 317 4 34:1 34:1 CD 37350 317 5 - - SYM 37350 317 6 525 525 CD 37350 317 7 . . . 37350 317 8 de de NNP 37350 317 9 Beer Beer NNP 37350 317 10 , , , 37350 317 11 G. G. NNP 37350 317 12 R. R. NNP 37350 317 13 1937 1937 CD 37350 317 14 . . . 37350 318 1 The the DT 37350 318 2 development development NN 37350 318 3 of of IN 37350 318 4 the the DT 37350 318 5 vertebrate vertebrate NN 37350 318 6 skull skull NN 37350 318 7 . . . 37350 319 1 Pp Pp NNP 37350 319 2 . . . 37350 320 1 xxiii xxiii NN 37350 320 2 + + CC 37350 320 3 552 552 CD 37350 320 4 . . . 37350 321 1 Oxford Oxford NNP 37350 321 2 , , , 37350 321 3 Clarendon Clarendon NNP 37350 321 4 Press Press NNP 37350 321 5 . . . 37350 322 1 de de NNP 37350 322 2 Villiers Villiers NNP 37350 322 3 , , , 37350 322 4 C. C. NNP 37350 322 5 G. G. NNP 37350 322 6 S. S. NNP 37350 322 7 1934 1934 CD 37350 322 8 . . . 37350 323 1 Studies study NNS 37350 323 2 of of IN 37350 323 3 the the DT 37350 323 4 cranial cranial JJ 37350 323 5 anatomy anatomy NN 37350 323 6 of of IN 37350 323 7 _ _ NNP 37350 323 8 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 323 9 truei truei NN 37350 323 10 _ _ NNP 37350 323 11 Stejneger Stejneger NNP 37350 323 12 , , , 37350 323 13 the the DT 37350 323 14 American american JJ 37350 323 15 " " `` 37350 323 16 Liopelmid Liopelmid NNP 37350 323 17 . . . 37350 323 18 " " '' 37350 324 1 Bull Bull NNP 37350 324 2 . . . 37350 325 1 Mus mus NN 37350 325 2 . . . 37350 326 1 Comp Comp NNP 37350 326 2 . . . 37350 327 1 Zool Zool NNP 37350 327 2 . . NNP 37350 327 3 , , , 37350 327 4 77:1 77:1 CD 37350 327 5 - - SYM 37350 327 6 38 38 CD 37350 327 7 . . . 37350 328 1 Emelianov Emelianov NNP 37350 328 2 , , , 37350 328 3 S. S. NNP 37350 328 4 W. W. NNP 37350 328 5 1936 1936 CD 37350 328 6 . . . 37350 329 1 Die Die NNP 37350 329 2 Morphologie Morphologie NNP 37350 329 3 der der VB 37350 329 4 Tetrapodenrippen Tetrapodenrippen NNP 37350 329 5 . . . 37350 330 1 Zool Zool NNP 37350 330 2 . . . 37350 331 1 Jahrb Jahrb NNP 37350 331 2 . . . 37350 332 1 ( ( -LRB- 37350 332 2 Anat Anat NNP 37350 332 3 . . . 37350 333 1 ) ) -RRB- 37350 333 2 , , , 37350 333 3 62:173 62:173 CD 37350 333 4 - - SYM 37350 333 5 274 274 CD 37350 333 6 . . . 37350 334 1 Francis Francis NNP 37350 334 2 , , , 37350 334 3 E. E. NNP 37350 334 4 T. T. NNP 37350 334 5 B. B. NNP 37350 335 1 1934 1934 CD 37350 335 2 . . . 37350 336 1 The the DT 37350 336 2 anatomy anatomy NN 37350 336 3 of of IN 37350 336 4 the the DT 37350 336 5 salamander salamander JJ 37350 336 6 . . . 37350 337 1 Pp Pp NNP 37350 337 2 . . . 37350 338 1 xxxi xxxi NNP 37350 338 2 + + CC 37350 338 3 381 381 CD 37350 338 4 . . . 37350 339 1 Oxford Oxford NNP 37350 339 2 , , , 37350 339 3 Clarendon Clarendon NNP 37350 339 4 Press Press NNP 37350 339 5 . . . 37350 340 1 Gamble Gamble NNP 37350 340 2 , , , 37350 340 3 D. D. NNP 37350 340 4 L. L. NNP 37350 340 5 1922 1922 CD 37350 340 6 . . . 37350 341 1 The the DT 37350 341 2 morphology morphology NN 37350 341 3 of of IN 37350 341 4 the the DT 37350 341 5 ribs rib NNS 37350 341 6 and and CC 37350 341 7 the the DT 37350 341 8 transverse transverse JJ 37350 341 9 processes process NNS 37350 341 10 of of IN 37350 341 11 _ _ NNP 37350 341 12 Necturus Necturus NNP 37350 341 13 maculatus maculatus NN 37350 341 14 _ _ NNP 37350 341 15 . . . 37350 342 1 Jour Jour NNP 37350 342 2 . . . 37350 343 1 Morph Morph NNP 37350 343 2 . . NNP 37350 343 3 , , , 37350 343 4 36:537 36:537 CD 37350 343 5 - - SYM 37350 343 6 566 566 CD 37350 343 7 . . . 37350 344 1 Gray Gray NNP 37350 344 2 , , , 37350 344 3 P. P. NNP 37350 344 4 1930 1930 CD 37350 344 5 . . . 37350 345 1 On on IN 37350 345 2 the the DT 37350 345 3 attachments attachment NNS 37350 345 4 of of IN 37350 345 5 the the DT 37350 345 6 Urodele Urodele NNP 37350 345 7 rib rib NN 37350 345 8 to to IN 37350 345 9 the the DT 37350 345 10 vertebra vertebra NNS 37350 345 11 and and CC 37350 345 12 their -PRON- PRP$ 37350 345 13 homologies homology NNS 37350 345 14 with with IN 37350 345 15 the the DT 37350 345 16 capitulum capitulum NN 37350 345 17 and and CC 37350 345 18 tuberculum tuberculum NN 37350 345 19 of of IN 37350 345 20 the the DT 37350 345 21 Amniote Amniote NNP 37350 345 22 rib rib NN 37350 345 23 . . . 37350 346 1 Proc Proc NNP 37350 346 2 . . . 37350 347 1 Zool Zool NNP 37350 347 2 . . . 37350 348 1 Soc Soc NNP 37350 348 2 . . . 37350 349 1 London London NNP 37350 349 2 , , , 37350 349 3 1930(1931):907 1930(1931):907 CD 37350 349 4 - - SYM 37350 349 5 911 911 CD 37350 349 6 . . . 37350 350 1 Gregory Gregory NNP 37350 350 2 , , , 37350 350 3 J. J. NNP 37350 350 4 T. T. NNP 37350 350 5 1950 1950 CD 37350 350 6 . . . 37350 351 1 Tetrapods tetrapod NNS 37350 351 2 from from IN 37350 351 3 the the DT 37350 351 4 Pennsylvanian pennsylvanian JJ 37350 351 5 nodules nodule NNS 37350 351 6 from from IN 37350 351 7 Mazon Mazon NNP 37350 351 8 Creek Creek NNP 37350 351 9 , , , 37350 351 10 Illinois Illinois NNP 37350 351 11 . . . 37350 352 1 Am Am NNP 37350 352 2 . . . 37350 353 1 Jour Jour NNP 37350 353 2 . . . 37350 354 1 Sci Sci NNP 37350 354 2 . . NNP 37350 354 3 , , , 37350 354 4 248:833 248:833 CD 37350 354 5 - - SYM 37350 354 6 873 873 CD 37350 354 7 . . . 37350 355 1 Hecht Hecht NNP 37350 355 2 , , , 37350 355 3 M. M. NNP 37350 355 4 E. E. NNP 37350 355 5 1957 1957 CD 37350 355 6 . . . 37350 356 1 A a DT 37350 356 2 case case NN 37350 356 3 of of IN 37350 356 4 parallel parallel JJ 37350 356 5 evolution evolution NN 37350 356 6 in in IN 37350 356 7 salamanders salamander NNS 37350 356 8 . . . 37350 357 1 Proc Proc NNP 37350 357 2 . . . 37350 358 1 Zool Zool NNP 37350 358 2 . . . 37350 359 1 Soc Soc NNP 37350 359 2 . . . 37350 360 1 Calcutta Calcutta NNP 37350 360 2 , , , 37350 360 3 Mookerjee Mookerjee NNP 37350 360 4 Mem.:283 Mem.:283 NNP 37350 360 5 - - HYPH 37350 360 6 292 292 CD 37350 360 7 . . . 37350 361 1 Holmgren Holmgren NNP 37350 361 2 , , , 37350 361 3 N. N. NNP 37350 361 4 1933 1933 CD 37350 361 5 . . . 37350 362 1 On on IN 37350 362 2 the the DT 37350 362 3 origin origin NN 37350 362 4 of of IN 37350 362 5 the the DT 37350 362 6 tetrapod tetrapod NNP 37350 362 7 limb limb NN 37350 362 8 . . . 37350 363 1 Acta Acta NNP 37350 363 2 Zool Zool NNP 37350 363 3 . . NNP 37350 363 4 , , , 37350 363 5 14:185 14:185 CD 37350 363 6 - - SYM 37350 363 7 295 295 CD 37350 363 8 . . . 37350 364 1 1939 1939 CD 37350 364 2 . . . 37350 365 1 Contributions contribution NNS 37350 365 2 to to IN 37350 365 3 the the DT 37350 365 4 question question NN 37350 365 5 of of IN 37350 365 6 the the DT 37350 365 7 origin origin NN 37350 365 8 of of IN 37350 365 9 the the DT 37350 365 10 tetrapod tetrapod NNP 37350 365 11 limb limb NN 37350 365 12 . . . 37350 366 1 Acta Acta NNP 37350 366 2 Zool Zool NNP 37350 366 3 . . NNP 37350 366 4 , , , 37350 366 5 20:89 20:89 CD 37350 366 6 - - SYM 37350 366 7 124 124 CD 37350 366 8 . . . 37350 367 1 1949a 1949a CD 37350 367 2 . . . 37350 368 1 Contributions contribution NNS 37350 368 2 to to IN 37350 368 3 the the DT 37350 368 4 question question NN 37350 368 5 of of IN 37350 368 6 the the DT 37350 368 7 origin origin NN 37350 368 8 of of IN 37350 368 9 tetrapods tetrapod NNS 37350 368 10 . . . 37350 369 1 Acta Acta NNP 37350 369 2 Zool Zool NNP 37350 369 3 . . NNP 37350 369 4 , , , 37350 369 5 30:459 30:459 CD 37350 369 6 - - SYM 37350 369 7 484 484 CD 37350 369 8 . . . 37350 370 1 1949b 1949b LS 37350 370 2 . . . 37350 371 1 On on IN 37350 371 2 the the DT 37350 371 3 tetrapod tetrapod NNP 37350 371 4 limb limb NN 37350 371 5 problem problem NN 37350 371 6 again again RB 37350 371 7 . . . 37350 372 1 Acta Acta NNP 37350 372 2 Zool Zool NNP 37350 372 3 . . NNP 37350 372 4 , , , 37350 372 5 30:485 30:485 CD 37350 372 6 - - SYM 37350 372 7 508 508 CD 37350 372 8 . . . 37350 373 1 Herre Herre NNP 37350 373 2 , , , 37350 373 3 W. W. NNP 37350 373 4 1935 1935 CD 37350 373 5 . . . 37350 374 1 Die die VB 37350 374 2 Schwanzlurche Schwanzlurche NNP 37350 374 3 der der NNP 37350 374 4 mitteleocänen mitteleocänen NN 37350 374 5 ( ( -LRB- 37350 374 6 oberlutetischen oberlutetischen RB 37350 374 7 ) ) -RRB- 37350 374 8 Braunkohle Braunkohle NNP 37350 374 9 des des FW 37350 374 10 Geiseltales Geiseltales NNP 37350 374 11 und und RB 37350 374 12 die die VBP 37350 374 13 Phylogenie Phylogenie NNP 37350 374 14 der der VB 37350 374 15 Urodelen Urodelen NNP 37350 374 16 unter unter NN 37350 374 17 Einschluss Einschluss NNP 37350 374 18 der der NN 37350 374 19 fossilen fossilen NN 37350 374 20 Formen forman NNS 37350 374 21 . . . 37350 375 1 Zoologica Zoologica NNP 37350 375 2 , , , 37350 375 3 33:87 33:87 CD 37350 375 4 , , , 37350 375 5 1 1 CD 37350 375 6 - - SYM 37350 375 7 5 5 CD 37350 375 8 . . . 37350 376 1 Jarvik Jarvik NNP 37350 376 2 , , , 37350 376 3 E. E. NNP 37350 376 4 1942 1942 CD 37350 376 5 . . . 37350 377 1 On on IN 37350 377 2 the the DT 37350 377 3 structure structure NN 37350 377 4 of of IN 37350 377 5 the the DT 37350 377 6 snout snout NN 37350 377 7 of of IN 37350 377 8 Crossopterygians Crossopterygians NNPS 37350 377 9 and and CC 37350 377 10 lower low JJR 37350 377 11 gnathostomes gnathostome NNS 37350 377 12 in in IN 37350 377 13 general general JJ 37350 377 14 . . . 37350 378 1 Zool Zool NNP 37350 378 2 . . . 37350 379 1 Bidrag Bidrag NNP 37350 379 2 fran fran NNP 37350 379 3 Upsala Upsala NNP 37350 379 4 , , , 37350 379 5 21:235 21:235 CD 37350 379 6 - - SYM 37350 379 7 675 675 CD 37350 379 8 . . . 37350 380 1 1952 1952 CD 37350 380 2 . . . 37350 381 1 On on IN 37350 381 2 the the DT 37350 381 3 fish fish NN 37350 381 4 - - HYPH 37350 381 5 like like JJ 37350 381 6 tail tail NN 37350 381 7 in in IN 37350 381 8 the the DT 37350 381 9 Ichthyostegid Ichthyostegid NNP 37350 381 10 Stegocephalians Stegocephalians NNPS 37350 381 11 . . . 37350 382 1 Meddelelser meddelelser NN 37350 382 2 on on IN 37350 382 3 Grønland Grønland NNP 37350 382 4 , , , 37350 382 5 114(12):1 114(12):1 CD 37350 382 6 - - SYM 37350 382 7 90 90 CD 37350 382 8 . . . 37350 383 1 Mookerjee Mookerjee NNP 37350 383 2 , , , 37350 383 3 H.K. H.K. NNP 37350 384 1 1930a 1930a CD 37350 384 2 . . . 37350 385 1 On on IN 37350 385 2 the the DT 37350 385 3 development development NN 37350 385 4 of of IN 37350 385 5 the the DT 37350 385 6 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 385 7 column column NN 37350 385 8 of of IN 37350 385 9 the the DT 37350 385 10 Urodela Urodela NNP 37350 385 11 . . . 37350 386 1 Phil Phil NNP 37350 386 2 . . . 37350 387 1 Trans tran NNS 37350 387 2 . . . 37350 388 1 Roy Roy NNP 37350 388 2 . . . 37350 389 1 Soc Soc NNP 37350 389 2 . . . 37350 390 1 London London NNP 37350 390 2 , , , 37350 390 3 B B NNP 37350 390 4 218:415 218:415 CD 37350 390 5 - - SYM 37350 390 6 446 446 CD 37350 390 7 . . . 37350 391 1 1930b 1930b CD 37350 391 2 . . . 37350 392 1 On on IN 37350 392 2 the the DT 37350 392 3 development development NN 37350 392 4 of of IN 37350 392 5 the the DT 37350 392 6 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 392 7 column column NN 37350 392 8 of of IN 37350 392 9 the the DT 37350 392 10 Anura Anura NNP 37350 392 11 . . . 37350 393 1 Philos Philos NNP 37350 393 2 . . . 37350 394 1 Trans tran NNS 37350 394 2 . . . 37350 395 1 Royal Royal NNP 37350 395 2 Soc Soc NNP 37350 395 3 . . . 37350 396 1 London London NNP 37350 396 2 , , , 37350 396 3 B B NNP 37350 396 4 219:165 219:165 CD 37350 396 5 - - SYM 37350 396 6 196 196 CD 37350 396 7 . . . 37350 397 1 MacBride MacBride NNP 37350 397 2 , , , 37350 397 3 E.W. E.W. NNP 37350 398 1 1932 1932 CD 37350 398 2 . . . 37350 399 1 Recent recent JJ 37350 399 2 work work NN 37350 399 3 on on IN 37350 399 4 the the DT 37350 399 5 development development NN 37350 399 6 of of IN 37350 399 7 the the DT 37350 399 8 vertebral vertebral JJ 37350 399 9 column column NN 37350 399 10 . . . 37350 400 1 Cambridge Cambridge NNP 37350 400 2 , , , 37350 400 3 Biol Biol NNP 37350 400 4 . . . 37350 401 1 Rev. Rev. NNP 37350 401 2 , , , 37350 401 3 7:108 7:108 NNP 37350 401 4 - - HYPH 37350 401 5 148 148 CD 37350 401 6 . . . 37350 402 1 McDowell McDowell NNP 37350 402 2 , , , 37350 402 3 S.B. S.B. NNP 37350 403 1 1958 1958 CD 37350 403 2 . . . 37350 404 1 Are be VBP 37350 404 2 the the DT 37350 404 3 frogs frog NNS 37350 404 4 specialized specialize VBN 37350 404 5 seymouriamorphs seymouriamorph NNS 37350 404 6 ? ? . 37350 405 1 ( ( -LRB- 37350 405 2 Abstract Abstract NNP 37350 405 3 ) ) -RRB- 37350 405 4 Anat Anat NNP 37350 405 5 . . . 37350 406 1 Rec Rec NNP 37350 406 2 . . NNP 37350 406 3 , , , 37350 406 4 132(3):472 132(3):472 NNP 37350 406 5 . . . 37350 407 1 Naef Naef NNP 37350 407 2 , , , 37350 407 3 A. a. NN 37350 408 1 1929 1929 CD 37350 408 2 . . . 37350 409 1 Notizen Notizen NNP 37350 409 2 zur zur NNP 37350 409 3 Morphologie Morphologie NNP 37350 409 4 und und JJ 37350 409 5 Stammesgeschichte Stammesgeschichte NNP 37350 409 6 der der VB 37350 409 7 Wirbeltiere wirbeltiere RB 37350 409 8 . . . 37350 410 1 15 15 CD 37350 410 2 . . . 37350 411 1 Dreissig Dreissig NNP 37350 411 2 Thesen Thesen NNP 37350 411 3 über über NN 37350 411 4 Wirbelsäule Wirbelsäule NNP 37350 411 5 und und NN 37350 411 6 Rippen Rippen NNP 37350 411 7 , , , 37350 411 8 insbesondere insbesondere RB 37350 411 9 bei bei NNP 37350 411 10 den den NNP 37350 411 11 Tetrapoden Tetrapoden NNP 37350 411 12 . . . 37350 412 1 Zool Zool NNP 37350 412 2 . . . 37350 413 1 Jahrb Jahrb NNP 37350 413 2 . . NNP 37350 413 3 , , , 37350 413 4 50:581 50:581 CD 37350 413 5 - - SYM 37350 413 6 600 600 CD 37350 413 7 . . . 37350 414 1 Noble Noble NNP 37350 414 2 , , , 37350 414 3 G. G. NNP 37350 414 4 K. K. NNP 37350 414 5 1922 1922 CD 37350 414 6 . . . 37350 415 1 The the DT 37350 415 2 phylogeny phylogeny NN 37350 415 3 of of IN 37350 415 4 the the DT 37350 415 5 Salientia Salientia NNP 37350 415 6 ; ; : 37350 415 7 I. I. NNP 37350 416 1 The the DT 37350 416 2 osteology osteology NN 37350 416 3 and and CC 37350 416 4 the the DT 37350 416 5 thigh thigh NN 37350 416 6 musculature musculature NN 37350 416 7 ; ; : 37350 416 8 their -PRON- PRP$ 37350 416 9 bearing bearing NN 37350 416 10 on on IN 37350 416 11 classification classification NN 37350 416 12 and and CC 37350 416 13 phylogeny phylogeny NN 37350 416 14 . . . 37350 417 1 Bull Bull NNP 37350 417 2 . . . 37350 418 1 Amer amer NN 37350 418 2 . . . 37350 419 1 Mus mus NN 37350 419 2 . . . 37350 420 1 Nat Nat NNP 37350 420 2 . . . 37350 421 1 Hist Hist NNP 37350 421 2 . . . 37350 421 3 , , , 37350 421 4 46:1 46:1 CD 37350 421 5 - - SYM 37350 421 6 87 87 CD 37350 421 7 . . . 37350 422 1 1927 1927 CD 37350 422 2 . . . 37350 423 1 The the DT 37350 423 2 value value NN 37350 423 3 of of IN 37350 423 4 life life NN 37350 423 5 - - HYPH 37350 423 6 history history NN 37350 423 7 data datum NNS 37350 423 8 in in IN 37350 423 9 the the DT 37350 423 10 study study NN 37350 423 11 of of IN 37350 423 12 the the DT 37350 423 13 evolution evolution NN 37350 423 14 of of IN 37350 423 15 the the DT 37350 423 16 Amphibia Amphibia NNP 37350 423 17 . . . 37350 424 1 Annals Annals NNP 37350 424 2 New New NNP 37350 424 3 York York NNP 37350 424 4 Acad Acad NNP 37350 424 5 . . . 37350 425 1 Sci Sci NNP 37350 425 2 . . NNP 37350 425 3 , , , 37350 425 4 30:31 30:31 CD 37350 425 5 - - SYM 37350 425 6 128 128 CD 37350 425 7 . . . 37350 426 1 Piveteau Piveteau NNP 37350 426 2 , , , 37350 426 3 J. J. NNP 37350 427 1 1937 1937 CD 37350 427 2 . . . 37350 428 1 Un Un NNP 37350 428 2 Amphibien Amphibien NNP 37350 428 3 du du NNP 37350 428 4 Trias Trias NNP 37350 428 5 inférieur inférieur JJ 37350 428 6 . . . 37350 429 1 Essai Essai NNP 37350 429 2 sur sur FW 37350 429 3 l'origine l'origine FW 37350 429 4 et et FW 37350 429 5 l'évolution l'évolution NN 37350 429 6 des des NNP 37350 429 7 Amphibiens Amphibiens NNP 37350 429 8 Anoures Anoures NNPS 37350 429 9 . . . 37350 430 1 Annales Annales NNP 37350 430 2 de de NNP 37350 430 3 Paléontologie Paléontologie NNP 37350 430 4 , , , 37350 430 5 26:135 26:135 CD 37350 430 6 - - SYM 37350 430 7 176 176 CD 37350 430 8 . . . 37350 431 1 1955 1955 CD 37350 431 2 . . . 37350 432 1 Anoura Anoura NNP 37350 432 2 . . . 37350 433 1 In in IN 37350 433 2 : : : 37350 433 3 Traité Traité NNP 37350 433 4 de de NNP 37350 433 5 Paléontologie Paléontologie NNP 37350 433 6 , , , 37350 433 7 5:250 5:250 NNP 37350 433 8 - - HYPH 37350 433 9 274 274 CD 37350 433 10 . . . 37350 434 1 J. J. NNP 37350 434 2 Piveteau Piveteau NNP 37350 434 3 , , , 37350 434 4 Masson Masson NNP 37350 434 5 et et NNP 37350 434 6 Cie Cie NNP 37350 434 7 , , , 37350 434 8 Paris Paris NNP 37350 434 9 . . . 37350 435 1 Pusey Pusey NNP 37350 435 2 , , , 37350 435 3 H. H. NNP 37350 435 4 K. K. NNP 37350 435 5 1943 1943 CD 37350 435 6 . . . 37350 436 1 On on IN 37350 436 2 the the DT 37350 436 3 head head NN 37350 436 4 of of IN 37350 436 5 the the DT 37350 436 6 liopelmid liopelmid JJ 37350 436 7 frog frog NN 37350 436 8 , , , 37350 436 9 _ _ NNP 37350 436 10 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 436 11 truei truei NN 37350 436 12 _ _ NNP 37350 436 13 . . . 37350 437 1 I. I. NNP 37350 438 1 The the DT 37350 438 2 chondrocranium chondrocranium NN 37350 438 3 , , , 37350 438 4 jaws jaw NNS 37350 438 5 , , , 37350 438 6 arches arch NNS 37350 438 7 , , , 37350 438 8 and and CC 37350 438 9 muscles muscle NNS 37350 438 10 of of IN 37350 438 11 a a DT 37350 438 12 partly partly RB 37350 438 13 grown grow VBN 37350 438 14 larva larva NN 37350 438 15 . . . 37350 439 1 Quart Quart NNP 37350 439 2 . . . 37350 440 1 Jour Jour NNP 37350 440 2 . . . 37350 441 1 Micr Micr NNP 37350 441 2 . . . 37350 442 1 Sci Sci NNP 37350 442 2 . . NNP 37350 442 3 , , , 37350 442 4 84:105 84:105 CD 37350 442 5 - - SYM 37350 442 6 185 185 CD 37350 442 7 . . . 37350 443 1 Reed Reed NNP 37350 443 2 , , , 37350 443 3 H. H. NNP 37350 443 4 D. D. NNP 37350 443 5 1915 1915 CD 37350 443 6 . . . 37350 444 1 The the DT 37350 444 2 sound sound NN 37350 444 3 - - HYPH 37350 444 4 transmitting transmit VBG 37350 444 5 apparatus apparatus NN 37350 444 6 in in IN 37350 444 7 Necturus Necturus NNP 37350 444 8 . . . 37350 445 1 Anat Anat NNP 37350 445 2 . . . 37350 446 1 Rec Rec NNP 37350 446 2 . . NNP 37350 446 3 , , , 37350 446 4 9:581 9:581 CD 37350 446 5 - - SYM 37350 446 6 590 590 CD 37350 446 7 . . . 37350 447 1 Remane Remane NNP 37350 447 2 , , , 37350 447 3 A. a. NN 37350 448 1 1936 1936 CD 37350 448 2 . . . 37350 449 1 Wirbelsäule wirbelsäule RB 37350 449 2 und und UH 37350 449 3 ihre ihre NN 37350 449 4 Abkömmlinge Abkömmlinge NNP 37350 449 5 . . . 37350 450 1 In in IN 37350 450 2 : : : 37350 450 3 Handbuch Handbuch NNP 37350 450 4 der der NN 37350 450 5 vergleichenden vergleichenden VB 37350 450 6 Anatomie Anatomie NNP 37350 450 7 der der VBP 37350 450 8 Wirbeltiere Wirbeltiere NNP 37350 450 9 , , , 37350 450 10 L. L. NNP 37350 450 11 Bolk Bolk NNP 37350 450 12 _ _ NNP 37350 450 13 et et NNP 37350 450 14 al al NNP 37350 450 15 . . NNP 37350 450 16 _ _ NNP 37350 450 17 , , , 37350 450 18 4:1 4:1 CD 37350 450 19 - - SYM 37350 450 20 206 206 CD 37350 450 21 . . . 37350 451 1 Urban Urban NNP 37350 451 2 and and CC 37350 451 3 Schwarzenberg Schwarzenberg NNP 37350 451 4 , , , 37350 451 5 Berlin Berlin NNP 37350 451 6 , , , 37350 451 7 Vienna Vienna NNP 37350 451 8 . . . 37350 452 1 Ritland Ritland NNP 37350 452 2 , , , 37350 452 3 R. R. NNP 37350 452 4 M. M. NNP 37350 452 5 1955a 1955a NNS 37350 452 6 . . . 37350 453 1 Studies study NNS 37350 453 2 on on IN 37350 453 3 the the DT 37350 453 4 post post JJ 37350 453 5 - - JJ 37350 453 6 cranial cranial JJ 37350 453 7 morphology morphology NN 37350 453 8 of of IN 37350 453 9 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 453 10 truei truei NN 37350 453 11 . . . 37350 454 1 I. I. NNP 37350 454 2 Skeleton Skeleton NNP 37350 454 3 and and CC 37350 454 4 spinal spinal JJ 37350 454 5 nerves nerve NNS 37350 454 6 . . . 37350 455 1 Jour Jour NNP 37350 455 2 . . . 37350 456 1 Morph Morph NNP 37350 456 2 . . NNP 37350 456 3 , , , 37350 456 4 97:119 97:119 CD 37350 456 5 - - HYPH 37350 456 6 174 174 CD 37350 456 7 . . . 37350 457 1 1955b 1955b CD 37350 457 2 . . . 37350 458 1 Studies study NNS 37350 458 2 on on IN 37350 458 3 the the DT 37350 458 4 post post JJ 37350 458 5 - - JJ 37350 458 6 cranial cranial JJ 37350 458 7 morphology morphology NN 37350 458 8 of of IN 37350 458 9 Ascaphus Ascaphus NNP 37350 458 10 truei truei NN 37350 458 11 . . . 37350 459 1 II ii CD 37350 459 2 . . . 37350 460 1 Myology myology NN 37350 460 2 . . . 37350 461 1 Jour Jour NNP 37350 461 2 . . . 37350 462 1 Morph Morph NNP 37350 462 2 . . . 37350 462 3 , , , 37350 462 4 97:215 97:215 CD 37350 462 5 - - HYPH 37350 462 6 282 282 CD 37350 462 7 . . . 37350 463 1 Romer Romer NNP 37350 463 2 , , , 37350 463 3 A. A. NNP 37350 463 4 S. S. NNP 37350 463 5 1945 1945 CD 37350 463 6 . . . 37350 464 1 Vertebrate vertebrate JJ 37350 464 2 paleontology paleontology NN 37350 464 3 . . . 37350 465 1 2nd 2nd NNP 37350 465 2 edition edition NNP 37350 465 3 . . . 37350 466 1 Pp Pp NNP 37350 466 2 . . . 37350 467 1 viii viii RB 37350 467 2 + + CC 37350 467 3 687 687 CD 37350 467 4 . . . 37350 468 1 Univ Univ NNP 37350 468 2 . . . 37350 469 1 Chicago Chicago NNP 37350 469 2 Press Press NNP 37350 469 3 . . . 37350 470 1 1947 1947 CD 37350 470 2 . . . 37350 470 3 Review Review NNP 37350 470 4 of of IN 37350 470 5 the the DT 37350 470 6 Labyrinthodontia Labyrinthodontia NNP 37350 470 7 . . . 37350 471 1 Bull Bull NNP 37350 471 2 . . . 37350 472 1 Mus mus NN 37350 472 2 . . . 37350 473 1 Comp Comp NNP 37350 473 2 . . . 37350 474 1 Zool Zool NNP 37350 474 2 . . NNP 37350 474 3 , , , 37350 474 4 99:3 99:3 CD 37350 474 5 - - SYM 37350 474 6 368 368 CD 37350 474 7 . . . 37350 475 1 Säve Säve NNP 37350 475 2 - - HYPH 37350 475 3 Söderbergh Söderbergh NNP 37350 475 4 , , , 37350 475 5 G. G. NNP 37350 475 6 1934 1934 CD 37350 475 7 . . . 37350 476 1 Some some DT 37350 476 2 points point NNS 37350 476 3 of of IN 37350 476 4 view view NN 37350 476 5 concerning concern VBG 37350 476 6 the the DT 37350 476 7 evolution evolution NN 37350 476 8 of of IN 37350 476 9 the the DT 37350 476 10 vertebrates vertebrate NNS 37350 476 11 and and CC 37350 476 12 the the DT 37350 476 13 classification classification NN 37350 476 14 of of IN 37350 476 15 this this DT 37350 476 16 group group NN 37350 476 17 . . . 37350 477 1 Arkiv Arkiv NNP 37350 477 2 för för NNP 37350 477 3 Zoologi Zoologi NNP 37350 477 4 , , , 37350 477 5 26A:1 26a:1 CD 37350 477 6 - - SYM 37350 477 7 20 20 CD 37350 477 8 . . . 37350 478 1 Stadtmüller Stadtmüller NNP 37350 478 2 , , , 37350 478 3 F. F. NNP 37350 478 4 1936 1936 CD 37350 478 5 . . . 37350 479 1 Kranium Kranium NNP 37350 479 2 und und JJ 37350 479 3 Visceralskelett Visceralskelett NNP 37350 479 4 der der FW 37350 479 5 Stegocephalen Stegocephalen NNP 37350 479 6 und und NN 37350 479 7 Amphibien Amphibien NNP 37350 479 8 . . . 37350 480 1 In in IN 37350 480 2 : : : 37350 480 3 Handbuch Handbuch NNP 37350 480 4 der der NN 37350 480 5 vergleichenden vergleichenden VB 37350 480 6 Anatomie Anatomie NNP 37350 480 7 der der VBP 37350 480 8 Wirbeltiere wirbeltiere RB 37350 480 9 , , , 37350 480 10 by by IN 37350 480 11 L. L. NNP 37350 480 12 Bolk Bolk NNP 37350 480 13 _ _ NNP 37350 480 14 et et NNP 37350 480 15 al al NNP 37350 480 16 . . NNP 37350 480 17 _ _ NNP 37350 480 18 , , , 37350 480 19 4:501 4:501 CD 37350 480 20 - - SYM 37350 480 21 698 698 CD 37350 480 22 . . . 37350 481 1 Stephenson Stephenson NNP 37350 481 2 , , , 37350 481 3 N. N. NNP 37350 481 4 G. G. NNP 37350 481 5 1955 1955 CD 37350 481 6 . . . 37350 482 1 On on IN 37350 482 2 the the DT 37350 482 3 development development NN 37350 482 4 of of IN 37350 482 5 the the DT 37350 482 6 frog frog NN 37350 482 7 , , , 37350 482 8 _ _ NNP 37350 482 9 Leiopelma Leiopelma NNP 37350 482 10 hochstetteri hochstetteri NN 37350 482 11 _ _ NNP 37350 482 12 Fitzinger Fitzinger NNP 37350 482 13 . . . 37350 483 1 Proc Proc NNP 37350 483 2 . . . 37350 484 1 Zool Zool NNP 37350 484 2 . . . 37350 485 1 Soc Soc NNP 37350 485 2 . . . 37350 486 1 London London NNP 37350 486 2 , , , 37350 486 3 124(4):785 124(4):785 CD 37350 486 4 - - SYM 37350 486 5 795 795 CD 37350 486 6 . . . 37350 487 1 Stipanicic Stipanicic NNP 37350 487 2 , , , 37350 487 3 P. P. NNP 37350 487 4 N. N. NNP 37350 487 5 and and CC 37350 487 6 Reig Reig NNP 37350 487 7 , , , 37350 487 8 O. O. NNP 37350 488 1 A. A. NNP 37350 489 1 1955 1955 CD 37350 489 2 . . . 37350 490 1 Breve Breve NNP 37350 490 2 noticia noticia NNP 37350 490 3 sobre sobre NNP 37350 490 4 el el NNP 37350 490 5 hallazgo hallazgo NNP 37350 490 6 de de NNP 37350 490 7 anuros anuros NNP 37350 490 8 en en NNP 37350 490 9 el el NNP 37350 490 10 denominado denominado NNP 37350 490 11 " " `` 37350 490 12 Complejo Complejo NNP 37350 490 13 Porfirico Porfirico NNP 37350 490 14 de de NNP 37350 490 15 la la NNP 37350 490 16 Patagonia Patagonia NNP 37350 490 17 Extraandina Extraandina NNP 37350 490 18 , , , 37350 490 19 " " '' 37350 490 20 con con FW 37350 490 21 consideraciones consideracione VBZ 37350 490 22 acerca acerca NNP 37350 490 23 de de NNP 37350 490 24 la la NNP 37350 490 25 composicion composicion NNP 37350 490 26 geologica geologica NNP 37350 490 27 del del NNP 37350 490 28 mismo mismo NNP 37350 490 29 . . . 37350 491 1 Revista Revista NNP 37350 491 2 de de NNP 37350 491 3 la la NNP 37350 491 4 Asoc Asoc NNP 37350 491 5 . . . 37350 492 1 Geol Geol NNP 37350 492 2 . . . 37350 493 1 Argentina Argentina NNP 37350 493 2 , , , 37350 493 3 10(4):215 10(4):215 CD 37350 493 4 - - SYM 37350 493 5 233 233 CD 37350 493 6 . . . 37350 494 1 1956 1956 CD 37350 494 2 . . . 37350 495 1 El El NNP 37350 495 2 " " `` 37350 495 3 complejo complejo JJ 37350 495 4 porfirico porfirico NN 37350 495 5 de de NNP 37350 495 6 la la NNP 37350 495 7 Patagonia Patagonia NNP 37350 495 8 extraandina extraandina NNP 37350 495 9 " " `` 37350 495 10 y y NNP 37350 495 11 su su NNP 37350 495 12 fauna fauna NNP 37350 495 13 de de NNP 37350 495 14 Anuros Anuros NNP 37350 495 15 . . . 37350 496 1 Acta Acta NNP 37350 496 2 Geol Geol NNP 37350 496 3 . . . 37350 497 1 Lilloana Lilloana NNP 37350 497 2 ( ( -LRB- 37350 497 3 Univ Univ NNP 37350 497 4 . . . 37350 498 1 Nac Nac NNP 37350 498 2 . . . 37350 499 1 del del NNP 37350 499 2 Tucuman Tucuman NNP 37350 499 3 ) ) -RRB- 37350 499 4 , , , 37350 499 5 1:185 1:185 CD 37350 499 6 - - SYM 37350 499 7 297 297 CD 37350 499 8 . . . 37350 500 1 Sushkin Sushkin NNP 37350 500 2 , , , 37350 500 3 P. P. NNP 37350 500 4 P. P. NNP 37350 500 5 1936 1936 CD 37350 500 6 . . . 37350 501 1 Notes note NNS 37350 501 2 on on IN 37350 501 3 the the DT 37350 501 4 pro pro JJ 37350 501 5 - - JJ 37350 501 6 Jurassic Jurassic NNP 37350 501 7 Tetrapoda Tetrapoda NNP 37350 501 8 from from IN 37350 501 9 U. U. NNP 37350 501 10 S. S. NNP 37350 501 11 S. S. NNP 37350 501 12 R. R. NNP 37350 501 13 III III NNP 37350 501 14 . . . 37350 502 1 Dvinosaurus Dvinosaurus NNP 37350 502 2 Amalitzky Amalitzky NNP 37350 502 3 , , , 37350 502 4 a a DT 37350 502 5 perennibranchiate perennibranchiate NN 37350 502 6 stegocephalian stegocephalian NN 37350 502 7 from from IN 37350 502 8 the the DT 37350 502 9 Upper Upper NNP 37350 502 10 Permian Permian NNP 37350 502 11 of of IN 37350 502 12 North North NNP 37350 502 13 Dvina Dvina NNP 37350 502 14 . . . 37350 503 1 Trav trav NN 37350 503 2 . . . 37350 504 1 Inst inst RB 37350 504 2 . . . 37350 505 1 Pal Pal NNP 37350 505 2 . . . 37350 506 1 Acad Acad NNS 37350 506 2 . . . 37350 507 1 Sci Sci NNP 37350 507 2 . . . 37350 508 1 URSS URSS NNP 37350 508 2 , , , 37350 508 3 5:43 5:43 CD 37350 508 4 - - SYM 37350 508 5 91 91 CD 37350 508 6 . . . 37350 509 1 Watson Watson NNP 37350 509 2 , , , 37350 509 3 D. D. NNP 37350 509 4 M. M. NNP 37350 509 5 S. S. NNP 37350 509 6 1940 1940 CD 37350 509 7 . . . 37350 510 1 The the DT 37350 510 2 origin origin NN 37350 510 3 of of IN 37350 510 4 frogs frog NNS 37350 510 5 . . . 37350 511 1 Trans tran NNS 37350 511 2 . . . 37350 512 1 Roy Roy NNP 37350 512 2 . . . 37350 513 1 Soc Soc NNP 37350 513 2 . . . 37350 514 1 Edinburgh Edinburgh NNP 37350 514 2 , , , 37350 514 3 40(7):195 40(7):195 CD 37350 514 4 - - SYM 37350 514 5 231 231 CD 37350 514 6 . . . 37350 515 1 _ _ NNP 37350 515 2 Transmitted Transmitted NNP 37350 515 3 April April NNP 37350 515 4 7 7 CD 37350 515 5 , , , 37350 515 6 1959 1959 CD 37350 515 7 . . . 37350 515 8 _ _ NNP