Meditations upon the marks of the true Church of Christ: or, Motives of credibility in behalf of the true religion: and, the easiest way to finde it out. / By H.W. H. W. 1655 Approx. 318 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 142 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2009-10 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A96976 Wing W36A Thomason E1666_1 ESTC R208388 99867343 99867343 119650 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A96976) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 119650) Images scanned from microfilm: (Thomason Tracts ; 209:E1666[1]) Meditations upon the marks of the true Church of Christ: or, Motives of credibility in behalf of the true religion: and, the easiest way to finde it out. / By H.W. H. W. Wilkinson, Henry, 1610-1675, [16], 266, [2] p. [s.n.], Paris, : Printed, with licence. 1655. Sometimes attributed to Henry Wilkinson. Annotation on Thomason copy: after initials: "Papist"; at foot of page: "August. 25.". Reproduction of the original in the British Library. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Catholic Church -- Apologetic works -- Early works to 1800. 2008-01 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2008-08 SPi Global Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2008-12 Taryn Hakala Sampled and proofread 2008-12 Taryn Hakala Text and markup reviewed and edited 2009-02 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion Meditations UPON THE MARKS of the True CHURCH of CHRIST : OR , Motives of Credibility In behalf of the True Religion : And , the easiest way to finde it out . By H. W. Testimonia tua credibilia facta sunt nimis . Thy testimonies are made too credible . Psal . 92.7 . Lord , if that which we believe be an errour , you have deceived us ; for this doctrine is confirmed by those signes , which could not be done but by you : Ricardus de S. Victore 1.1 , de Trinitate c. 2. Paris , Printed , with Licence . 1655. The Preface IF the Enemy of mankinde did not shew unto Sectaries the face of Religion in a false Glass ; in which he makes the very Spouse of Christ ( she that is so beautifull , with so lovely features , and of so comely a comportment in her self ) appear to the deluded eyes of so many souls ill-favoured , ugly , and in a manner monstruous ; and on the contrary sets out other Sects ( though never so contemptable in themselves ) for beauties , most gracious and attractive : disputes and ●●arrels about Religion would be soon composed : for the naturall comlinesse of the one , and the uglinesse of the others ( covered onely with a painted exteriour ) would easily discover themselves . My endeavour therefore shall be to unbeguile these people , and shew them both parties , as they are in their own native colours : for effecting of which , I have chosen a new medium , or at least a new manner ofproposing the old : many Elaborate works have been published in Vindication of the true Faith , and in confutation of falshood ; which undoubtedly were convincing enough : but because both experience , and the ingenuous acknowledgement of many , teach , that though the intellect in many thousands rest convinced ; yet the will holds back , and will not execute what the understanding dictates ought to be done : Therefore I ( resolving not to be backward in contributing my endeavours towards the common good ) thought it not a misse to handle this great businesse of Religion , by way of Meditation ( rather than by that of argumentation ; ) as being the most efficacious way to move the will ; besides , its being the most clear and easie way of propounding things to the understanding : especially , since the subject I take in hand , is both spiritual , and proper for Meditation ; to wit , the marks of the church . For who can doubt but Sanctity of life and Doctrine ; the gift of Miracles and of Prophesying ; conversion of Souls , Martyrdome , and the like , are a very connaturall matter for Meditation . But as the best masters of spirit advise , that in delivering matter to Meditate upon , some points , or considerations be suggested to the exercitant , thereby to facilitate the businesse for him ; and yet that all that may be considered upon such a subject , be not ambitiously introduced , least the others understanding be prevented and forestalled : So have I in this little work endeavoured to proceed ; setting down upon each matter only some chief considerations , which may give the Reader occasion to search further himself . I have also added some affections and Colloquies thereby to further the motions of the will. As for the matter of the ensuing Meditations , to wit , the Marks of the Church ; this I may truly say of them , that as they are in themselves a most noble matter , and most worthy of a Christians Meditation and Study : so are they of all other , the most facile 〈◊〉 forcible means , whereby to finde out the true Church : That Catholick who hath a desire to make a quick dispatch of his Adversary , let him encounter him with these Weapons : they are an unknown treasure , and not unlike to Aristoles Topicks , in that they are as it were common places , or fountains , out of which reasons and arguments , both to impugn false Sects , and also to defend the Orthodox Religion , are easily at any time drawn : Art thou demanded the reason , why thou art a Catholick ? Answer : Because that Religion hath the marks of Christs true church upon it ; and consequently is it . Art thou desirous to find out that onely soul-saving Faith of Christ ? look where thou canst finde these marks , and there thou hast it ; and where these are wanting ; assuredly , there the true Church is not : Hast thou a mind truly to understand how incomparable a benefit God hath bestowed upon thee , in making thee a member of that church , out of w ch no salvatiō can be hoped for ; read and meditate this matter , which will inform thee . Roman Catholicks indeed have more and clearer texts out of the propheticall & & apostolick writers , than any other Sect can introduce in their own behalf ; yet the latter have always evasions , either by appealing from one sentence to another , or else by insisting upon their own private exposition ; reduce them therefore to this matter of the marks of the Church , and you will soon have them fast . One thing is worthy , yea necessary to be well understood by all : and this is that the marks of the Church ( which are the motives in point of religion ) may be considered two ways ; to wit , either as they are antecedent to faith ; or as they are subsequent , and things themselves believed with divine faith : for all christians , who receive the the scriptures for divine , must believe with divine faith , that Christ gave to his church the gift of working miracles , & of prophesyings & that the church is but one , and antienter than all other Sects amongst christians ; that in it there are holy members ; that its doctrin is holy , and efficacious to convert souls ; that it hath continued ever since christs time , & shal do stil untill the world have an end ; that the prophesies of the old law are fulfilled by christ , and his church : all these , or the most of them , must be believed as divine truths by christians ; for they are expressed in the holy scripture ; as will appear in the first point of the succeeding meditations . So that sectaries must believe the true Church to be , where these marks are . But the same things may be also considered as they are preceding divine Faith , and go before it ; yea , or wholly independent of it ; and in this acception only they are motives of credibility ; yet most powerfully perswasive : For by demonstrating to Athiests , Pagans , or other non-Christians , out of humane history , and out of the scriptures ( received only for books of humane authority , yet held by thousands of prudent , and learned men for authenticall , and of great credit ) that such and such prodigious things , or miracles ( and the like may be urged in strange predictions of future things contingent fulfilled , in a strange contempt of worldly things , and in some other such like rareties ) are recounted by so many authors of the greatest humane authority : this cannot but convince them , that there is a Deity ; that this Diety rules the World by a most wise Providence ; that the same Deity ( by order of good consequence ) is to be worshipped by some form of Religion ; and that that is in all likelihood , yea in all certainty , the most credible and true , the professors of which are conspicuous by such things , as out reach the ability of nature or art : for such persons question lesse have conference , and hold correspondence with God : and de facto , Insidels were brought to embrace the Catholick Faith , by these motives , as the cheifest inducements . The truth is , That it is not only in all mens opinion morally , but as many learned Divines teach metaphysically impossible , that that Religion should be false , which God hath confirmed with his own Hand and Seal ; I mean , with these Arguments , Motives , and Marks , which the absolute power of God onely could produce : for otherwise it would follow , that God should induce men into error , and be the author of falshood ; a thing which implies a contradiction , and is incompatible with the goodnes and veracity of God : and would make the divine will repugnant to it self , by commanding men to serve him in the true Religion , and yet leading them to a false one , by the whole complex of such , and so extraordinary motives as these are . Thus much for the instruction , and conviction of non-christians , and such as do not admit the holy scripture to be the word of God. Concerning which people I adde , that when any of them are come so far , as to believe with humane faith ( which may be in every ones power to do ) that these motives convince that to be the true church , which is confirmed by those divine signes ; and when they do accept of that Church for such : God will undoubtedly raise their humane Faith up to be divine ; by infusing into them the auxiliary forces of his supernatural grace , and light , with the habit of divine faith . Now for the better understanding how from humane faith , a man may ascend to an act of divine faith : Note the distinction betwixt these four principles , into which an act of faith may be resolved . First the extrinsical motives : and these are not , nor can they be the efficient cause of an act of divine faith : but they are dispositions : that is they are motives , or cause why that Religion , or such a point , is accepted on for the truth . Secondly , The Authority of the Churchs and she doth onely propound what is to be believed , and gives order and direction how to proceed in the carriage of belief . Thirdly , The Veracity of God revealing to the Church , and by the Church to us , divine truths : and this is the formall object , or cause , why the understanding assents to such a thing as a divine truth : for therefore we believe that such Books are Divine , because God hath revealed to the Church , that they are so . Fourthly , The habit of Divine Faith , together with divine grace : and these are the efficient cause of an act of Divine Faith. All these four principles intervene in the analysis of theologicall Faith ; but with subordination to one another , and not as so many independent first principles of Faith : for the first , immediate , and indemonstrable cause of mans assent , is God revealing ; though the cause of accepting such a faith must be the motives of credibility . I conclude this Preface , with giving the Reader notice , that before I begin with the Meditations of the particular Marks ( of which I have chosen out onely 16. ) I thought fit to premise 4 Meditations , which are both of most necessary subjects in themselves , as also preparatives for the more fruitfull perusage of those which follow : And for a clearer demonstration to Sectaries , that such and such are put for marks of Christs Church by scripture it self ; I have of set purpose cited the proofs universally out of the Protestants own Bible . A Table of the severall Meditations following : MEd. 1. Of the end of Man. Page 1 Med. 2. Of divine Faith. Page 11 Med. 3. Of Christs true Church . Page 22 Med. 4. Of the Marks in generall . Page 33 Med. 5. Of Miracles . Page 46 Med. 6. Of Sanctity of Life Page 57 Med. 7. Of Holinesse of Doctrine . Page 73 Med. 8. Of the Conversion of nations . Page 91 Med. 9. Of the Vninterupted , and Apostolical Succession of the Pastors of the Church . Page 106 10. Of the antiquity of the true church Page 123 Med. 11. Of Vnity in matters of Faith and Religion . Page 143 Med. 12. Of the Amplitude , and Extent of the Dominions of Christs Church . Page 156 Med. 13. Of the Name of Catholick , and whose it is by right . Page 167 Med. 14. Of the gift of Prophesie . Page 176 15. Of easy Decission of Controversies . Page 186 16. Of Persecution , and Martyrdome . Page 198 Med. 17. Of the Prophecies , and Promises , and Figures of the old Law fulfilled in Christes Church . Page 208 Med. 18. Of Temporal blessings Miraculously bestowed on the Defenders and Propagators of the Catholick Religion . Page 219 Med. 19. Of the Disasters , and Vnhappy ends of the Opposers and Enemies , of the Roman Church . Page 233 M. 20. Of the Confession of Adversaries . Page 249 Of the end of Man. The first Meditation , and a ground to those which follow after . Of the End of Man. Of the means to attain it , and of the Use , which is to be made of that means . The first Point . COnsider first , how the Almighty , drawing man by the act of creation , out of the darksome abysse of that non-entity , or nothing , in which , hee had laine from all eternity past , without any reall being ; and bringing him into the light of life , now a rational and noble creature ; placed him in this inferiour world : but for what end ? to spend precious time in searching after sensull pleasures ? in hunting after honours ? in scraping up riches ? No , the end for which God created thee ( man ) was more sublime than so ; it was a supernatural end ; an end of the highest perfection , and the most to be wished for that can possibly be : to serve God in this life , and to enjoy eternally the beatisicall Vision of him in the life to come ; this was that which God intended in creating thee ; do thou prefix to thy self the same end , if thou will be happy . Consider , Secondly ( for the better understanding of this mainly fundamental point ) that this end hath two parts , or is twofold . So sayes St. Paul , Ye have your fruit unto sanctification , but your end eternall life : And our Saviour intimateth the same in these Divine words : Matt. 6. 33. Seek first the kingdome of God , and his righteousnesse ; so that here 's sanctity and eternall beatitude : the one is to be practised in this life ; the other shall be purchased in the next : the one is finis maximus ; and the other is the remote end : and as the self same thing may be both the end , and the means also , respectively : so here holinesse of life , though it be really mans end in this life ( for he is created to serve God in this life ; ) yet in respect of the finall end , which is eternally to enjoy that insinite goodnesse , the former is onely the means , by which the latter is attainable . Gather out of this Fundamentall point , a strong resolution , and effectuall desire , from henceforth to make the consideration of this so noble end , thy serious and frequent Study : Yet first by reading and meditating upon that subject , a perfect knowledge of it ; from which will arise a high conceipt and esteem of the same : and then the will must needs produce its acts : such are a longing , and languishing desire of seeing and enjoying that infinite Majesty ; a great love and affection towards the service of God ; frequent and servent acts of gratitude ; resolute and efficacious purposes , humble and devout petitions for divine grace , and perseverance : The Will being thus moved , she , as Queen , will give order to all the executive powers , that they b●stirre themselves about the performance of all that is conducing to that finall end ; and in abandoning whatsoever is prejndiciall to the same . Be ever blessed , O thou great Creator of this little world Man : thine is the work ; thine be the glory : O my ungratefull forgetfulnesse of this , and thy other benefits : Grant me ( Lord ) a large measure of thy grace , for the reformation of my life : for from bence forward , thou shalt be the object of all my actions ; the end of all my creation shall be the rule of all my operations : thy divine will shall be the copy after which I l'e write , the White at which I l'e shoot , the Compasse with which I l'e saile , and the Pole Star at which I l'e look : grant me still the strong gaile of thy grace ; till I arrive at Heavens Haven , Amen . The second Point . Consider first , That as the goodnes of God hath created man for a supernatural end ; so hath he liberally provided him of all the necessary requisites , which can be wished for that purpose : All these created things ( of which some administer Food , others Cloathing ; some delight man , others assist him ; some serve for his instruction , and others for his necessary correction ) are means to help him forward on his great journey ; if they be used with reference to his end ; and as a Physician uses drugs , of which he prescribes neither more nor lefse than is needfull : but mans end being beyond natures reach alone , God hath also supplied him with plenty of supernatural means ; all which are contained in that generall one , the true Church : out of which , as there are no helps , so no hopes of attaining to that end : no salvation without serving God ; no serving God , but by true worship ; no true worship ( faith Lactantius very well ) but in the true Catholike Church : Seek it , finde it . Consider Secondly , The particular helps , which are contained in this general one , The Church : enter in , and to thy comfort , take a view of the many and marveilous means , which ( like precious treasures , or sacred relicks ) Christ hath laid up in store within it . 1. Faith ( without which its impossible to please God ) not humane and fallible ; but divine , and undoubtedly true . 2 A Law , which comprehends in it those divine ordinations & precepts , which all must obserue that will enter into life . 3 Evengelicall Counsels ; which , though they be only for noble voluntiers ; yet by means of them a man may live farre more remote from sin , and border nearer upon perfection . 4 A forme of worship most Religious , Decent , Majesticall : and in which the two essential parts of man , both soule , and body , serve God like a God , by the exercise of the acts of Religion ( the cheif of all the moral Vertues ) both interiour , and exteriour ; such are Prayer , Sacrifice , Vowes , Adoration , Devotion and others . 5 The harmonious quier of the infused Vertues , and gifts of the Holy Ghost ; by the exercise of whose acts the soule makes a kind of heavenly musick . 6 Most ample promises of a manifold reward in those glorious mansions of heaven for the true servants of God ; and most severe ( though wholsome ) threats of never ending punishments for the bad : both which , like sharp Spurs are for to makeus fly from the occasions of sin , and strive to make haste in the course of a virtuous life . 7 The holy Sacraments , which are like sacred Conduits , through which the living waters of divine grace ( of which our Saviour spoke to the Samaritan woman ) and the merits of our dear Redeemer flow out of his sacred side , into mans soul . 8 The Holy Scriptures , with these three circumstances , of being truly canonicall , authentically translated , and infallibly expounded . 9 Examples of eminent sanctity , in men made of flesh and blood as we are . 10 True hearts ease , and peace of mind , which made David ( Psal . 118. ) run the way of Gods Commandements ; and which Christ promiseth onely to those of his Church ; saying , My Peace I leave to you : these are the true , solid , and supernatural means ; which our liberall Lord , hath left in his Church , to help us to what we were created for . The third Point . Consider now what use is to be made of this so admirable means , and provision for mans supernatural end : and first those , who are already incorporated members of the true Church , have reason to render praises to God eternally , for so facilitating the work of their Salvation by these ample means : Secondly , an oblation ( and that a great one ) is upon them , of corresponding with their indeavours towards a diligent application , and a well ordered use of those means ; for assuredly they shall be responsible to God for the interest of those so many , and great Talents , with which they are intrusted . Of you ( O Catholiks ) may that heavenly Husbandman , once more admiring , say : What could I do more for my Vineyard , and have not done it ? As for those , who are not members of the true Church of Christ : whereof some content themselves with the bare extrinsecall denomination of a Protestant , Presbyterian , or Independent ; not troubling themselves with the tenents of these Sects ; nay , nor so much as knowing how many , or what they are : Others , are of a Religion ut sic ; a Platonick Idea they have in their heads , and that 's all : of some one they are , but of no one in particular : others ( like individua Vaga ) run from Sect to Sect , will be of every Religion ; & are carried about with every whirlwinde of new Doctrine : and others ( to omit other varieties of new fashioned Sects in these our mad times ) content themselves with Negations ; shewing the little better than non-existency of their Religion , by the onely Negatives of the Roman Catholike affirmative Tenents . All these ( I say ) and such as are not members of Christs true Church , or doubt how the case stands with them in point of religion ; let them ask , and answer themselves , whether or no , they seriously love , and long for life eternal : if they affirm it : then let them love , seek for , and finde out the true Church ; for that alone is the means to acquire that happy end : if they be carelesse , indifferent , or ungrounded in point of religion ; evident it is , that their love of heaven is not efficacious , but a meer velleity for , qui vult sinem , vult & media : he that loves the end , must love the means . Hence inferre , of what infinite moment is deliberation , and choice of Religion : to hit right , or misse that mark , is to hazard the winning , or losing heaven : Heaven is the Wager , Resolution shoots the Arrow , the true Church is the white , let deliberation take right aym , and earnestly beg the direction of the Almighty , ( who hath also bent his how and prepared it ) by saying , Lord , demonstrate unto me thy wayes , and teach me thy paths : send forth thy light and thy truth , that they may lead me unto thy holy mountain and into the Tabernacles of thy Church . Amen . The Second Meditation . Of Divine Faith. The first Point . Consider first , what Faith is , both in respect of the habit and the act : Habitual Faith , is a supernatural vertue , infused by God into the soule of man , by which his understanding is illuminated , inabled , and inclined to believe stedfastly all those things to be true , which God hath revealed to his Church : It differs much from other intellectuall habits : as from Science , which relyes on the evidence of the thing , Faith on Authority , to wit , of God : From opinion , doubtfulnesse , suspicion ; which do not satissie the understanding ; Faith convinceth it , from civil , or humane faith , which is subject to error ; but Theologicall and divine Faith is that , cui non potest subesse falsum : no falshood dare insinuate it self into the company of Divine Faith : Actuall Faith , is no other thing but the exercise , or act proceeding from the habit of Faith : it is a firm assent of the understanding , believing such particulars revealed by God ( to wit , that one and the self same nature and essence of God , is in three distinct persons ; that Christ is both God and man , and yet not two , but only one thing ; that there is heaven , that there is hell , and the like ) to be true : so that the material things believed are the objects of those acts . Consider secondly , The insallible certainty , which an act of divine faith hath in it : the certainty of it hangs upon these two cardinal attributes of divine wisdome and goodnesse : by the former of which , we are warranted that God cannot by ignorance be deceived ; by the second , we are secured that he will not deceive , by revealing that for a truth , which is false ; since both these perfections are in him infinite : This infinite authority therefore of God revealing , being the motive , or formal object of an act of faith ( for therefore we believe such a thing to be true , because God hath revealed it ) makes these acts most true . Gather hence what an admirable benefit the gift of divine Faith is ; and not the habit onely , but the acts also are such ; since to the producing of every one of them , is required a congruous cogitation , and a pious affection of the will ( besides the application of mans endeavour ) both which are favours from Almighty God. Purpose a frequent exercise of producing acts of Faith , about those holy misteries , which God hath revealed to his Church , thou that art a member of it . The second Point . Consider now the necessity of this virtue of Divine Faith ; first , from the Testimonies of holy Scripture : without faith ( faith Saint Paul ) it is impossible to please God. He that shall be found at his death devoid of this virtue , shall not onely not please God ( a misery great enough ) but shall moreover inevitably incur the greatest of all miseries , eternal damnation : He that will not believe shall be condemned ; fearfull words , but spoken by Christ himself : heavy news for such as die not Catholicks ; but told by truth it self . Hence resolve , that as the means to please God , is to begin by true Faith , so the means to get true Faith , is by becoming a Member of the true Church . Consider also , that as the eye is the light of the body , and the understanding the natural eye and light of the Soule ; so Divine Faith , is the supernatural light of the understanding : Nisi credideritis non intelligetis : what say you ( Socinians ) to this Oracle of divine Truth ? unlesse you believe : what ? The mysteries of the Kingdom of God , and amongst the rest , the possibility , and actuall gift of infallible Faith ; How ? With Divine Faith : What will follow ? Non intelliget is ; you shall have no understanding of those arcana , or sacred secrets , into which Faith dives : true it is , that humane faith , and natural reason ( drawn from the consideration of those things , which are marks of the true Church ) are previous conditions , & prerequisite to divine Faith , whose acts are rational , and it an intellectual habit : but this is not to make natural reason the formal object , or basis , and ultimate resolution of maters of faith : Mans intellect hath but a small sphere of activity in Order to a perception of divine things , but so sarre forth as it is elevated by Divine Faith : As for us , who hope we are true believers , let not us content our selves with humane . Faith , but petition Gods divine Majesty for that Faith , which is his heavenly gift , Lord , adauge nobis fidem ; increase in us Faith ; true faith ; infallible Faith , divine Faith , make us strong in faith , that by it we may know thee , and whom thou sent Jesus Christ . Gather out of this point , one reason ( amongst others ) why many Sectaries are so bad Paraphrastes , and expounders of Scripture , and why they hold such Paradoxes , and improbable opinions in these main matters of Faith : To wit , because they want divine and Theological fith : so true that truth is , unlesse ye will believe , ye shall not understand . The third Point . Consider now what is to be believed ; and how we are to proceed in the exercise of the virtue of faith : this will be facilitated by understanding the precepts of Faith , which are two : the one Affirmative , the other Negative . The Affirmative Precept , obligeth every one to believe actually and expresly some particular points of Faith ; and the rest implicitly , or in general ; that is , all whatsoever the holy Catholike Church believes : yet so in general ; that every one is bound to be in a readinesse and disposition , to embrace and assent to the other particulars , when and accordingly , as they shall be sufficiently propounded by the true Church . Now for a better information of what particulars are expresly to be believed ; Note , that of these materiall objects , or points of Faith , some are so essentially requisite to salvation , that a pure non-knowledgement , or not believing them expresly , and in particular , is destructive of salvation : these are called necessary necessitate medii : such are these two , which Saint Paul mentions in these words : but without faith it is impossible to please God ; for he that cometh to God , must believe that he is , ( to wit , that there is a God ) and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him . Here it is expresly set down , that there is no coming to God , no enjoying him , without believing that there is a God , and that he is a rewarder : and these two are to be believed by all , even Ethnicks and Infidels : But those to whom the Evangelicall law hath been sufficiently propounded , must believe ( besides these two ) Christ and the blessed Trinity . Other things are onely necessarily to be known , and expresly to be believed , necessitate proecepti ; that is by reason of a precept obliging thereunto ; such are the Creed , the Ten Commandements , and those of the Church , our Lords Prayer , and the Sacraments : Now lgnorance or want of actuall belief of these , is not inconsistent with salvation : though negligence in that point is seldom without sin . The Negative precept of Faith , is of a sarre different nature from the affirmative ; and obligeth all Christians not to deny , or disbelieve any one point of Faith , sufficiently proposed by the Church , as a truth revealed by God : This admits no limitation , or latitude ; the affirmative precept ariseth from the material Points or Objects ; from which also ( as they are more or lesse necessary to be expresly known , and believed ) ariseth that distinction of them into points Fundamental and not Fundamental : but the negativeprecept is taken from the formal Object , which is the infallible testimony of God revealing ; which being the same in allpoints , it makes all fundamentalls a like : and here the forementioned distinction hath no place . Hence may be inferred what a misery it is to deny , or disbelieve any one point , which the Church proposeth as a revealed truth : It belongs undoubtedly to the goodness of Gods providence over his Church and m●ns souls , to leave us some infallible means by which we may know clearly , and infallibly , what he hath revealed , and what points we are to believe . First , because otherwise men would be perpetually perplexed , full of frights and fears , and alwaies doubtful what were revealed , and to be believed , what not : Secondly , God commands us to belive under pain of damnation ; therefore to disbelieve any one Proposall of the Church is dangerous because a disbeliever of even any one point is neerer incurring that dreadfull sentence , than he who disbelieves nothing : The Tenents of Roman Catholikes are affirmative ; those of Sectaries are almost all negative ; and consequently not acts of belief : Hence also they are in greater danger of that Sentence above mentioned ; were not that also a hard sentence , and repugnant to the sweet mercy of God , unlesse he should by some means declare unto usplainly and clearly , what particulars we were to believe under so dreadful a penalty ? The scripture , so obscure in many places , so subject to various Interpretations , and one of the things which are to be believed it self , cannot be this easie means ; for it hath never yet , nor can possibly end the many main Controverfies about points of Faith so long in agitation : This is a Demonstration therefore , that the Churches living , and clear voice , must do the deed ; What She sayes is true , is so ? O what a misery , and madnes is it then , to disbelieve , or deny any one point that she propounds as a divine Revelation : One point alone denied makes an Heretick , divests that soul , and deprives it of all divine Faith : For the proposition of the Church being of the same authority in that , as in all the rest ; either She is to be believed in all , or in none : and as he that is guilty of the breach of one Commandement , is guilty of all ; for he violates that supream legislative power of God : so he that denies giving credit to one proposition of the Church , denies her Authority , and is guilty of all the rest : What he believes then , is upon some humane ground , and with humane Faith ; Domine , ad quemibimus ? To whom Lord shall we have recourse in our doubts of Faith ? Dic Eccleiae , Tell the Church ; hear her : The least deviation in matter of Faith is dangerous ; but easily avoidable , if you will hear her : She was of some years growth , when the Scriptures were not in being : and that these were divine dictates , not forged fables , we had it upon trust from her : Why then is not her word taken in all other points , as well as in that mainly Fundamental one ? What strange inconsequence is this , to believe her to be an Infallible Propounder in some particulars , but not so in others ? The Third Meditation , which is , Of Christs true Church . The first Point . COnsider first , that as there is a God ; whose existency , and operations , all men may read in the pages of the Elements , and in the great Volume of the Universe ; whose creation and conservation , are a Physicall demonstration of a deity ; to which may be added moral arguments ; as the opinion and consent of all Nations , and of all the wise ones of the world ; prodigious miracles , apparitions of spirits , prophecies , heathenish oracles , sudden and unheard of punishments , and the like : which have made all , excepting some Atheists , co 〈…〉 ed believers that there is a God : 〈…〉 this is a Patent verity , so also is 〈◊〉 which came out of the golden mouth of Saint Chrysostome , to wit , Siest Deus , est colendus ; if there be a God ( as it is undoubtedly true there is ) then he is to be Worshipped ; nature hath made a great connexion betwixt these two ; the conspiring consent of all Nations , not onely the civillized , but even the most barbarout , exhibited some kinde of Worship to their Gods ; the Heathens had their Temples , the Jews Synagogues , and the Christians have their Churches for that end . Consider secondly , that as the want or neglect of divine Worship inclines to Atheisme ; so by this may be gathered what in all likelihood will at leng●h become of these modern sects in our Nation , once so religious : From the Protestants , their form of Worship is taken away by Act of Parliament ; others will have none , and the rest will not somuch as have Churches . O Times ! O Tragedies ! what will this come to , but down right Atheisme ? unlesse they repent , and return to that Mother Church , from which they had their first tincture of Christianity ; which Jesus for thy mercies sake effect . The second Point . Consider first , how that the Son of God descended from heaven , and invested himself with humane nature , thereby to work that great work of mans eternal salvation : but by what means , and after what manner ? One drop of his deified blood was a more than sufficient ransome for the whole World : any one of those theandrical actions of his was a sufficient summe for the purchase of eternal felicity for all mankind : for what end then was it , that he spent all the moments , which were contained in thirty three years so preciously ? Why , did he shed every drop ( even till water issued out of his sacred side ) of that his royall blood ? The holy Doctours will tell us , that he did this for two ends , in order to us : First , to make himself a perfect Prototypon ( for man to imitate ) of all perfection , by the long exercise of all virtues ; of which he left so many , and so rare examples : The second was , that he might Found a Church , adorn it with all the requisites , proprieties , and priviledges which might beseem such a Church of such a Founder ; and that he might leave in it the infinite treasures of his merits , to be dispenced out by the Pastors of it ; and by means of the holy Sacraments applied to each member of the same . St Paul saies ( and that in most weighty words ) That the Church is such a thing as cost Christ the spending of his precious blood : which argues , that it is a rarer thing than Sectaries make it to be . Consider secondly , What this Church is : It is a body , a morall , or politick body ; the members whereof are men , as the members of a Common wealth , or a City , or a Colledge are : Christs true Church therefore is a Congregation of People , called out ( for so the Greek word 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 imports ) from others that are not of it , and united together in the same belief , and profession of all the verities revealed by Christ , and in the Communion of the same Sacraments , and worship , and under the obedience and government of lawfull Pastors ( which must descend lineally from Christ and his Apostles , by a legall and continued succession ) whereof one is the Head , governing under Christ , and his Vicar . Consider thirdly , some inferences which may be drawn from what hath been considered : and first , a knowledge of who are members of Christs true Church , and who are not : Three things are requisite in the members thereof : 1. One and the same Faith and Belief of all revealed truths , and disbelief of no one ; to wit , in those who are come to the use of Reason , and have them sufficiently propounded : Now for want of this Unity of Belief all Hereticks are excluded and Infidels . 2. Communion together in the same Sacraments , and form of worship ; for want of this Catecumens ( such as are onely in preparation for Baptism ) are not yet members of it . 3. Obedience and subjection to lawfull Pastors ; and for want of this Schismaticks are excluded : And here now , you ( poore souls ) of so many several Sects ; try what you are by these touch-stones . Gather out of the precedent point three things ; first , how dangerous it is in matters of Faith to follow their own judgment , and private interpretation of Scripture : 2. What a misery it is to make no use of the holy Sacraments : 3 What madnes it is to take for the directours & guides of their souls , men who can give no account of their lawfull Calling and Mission ; but instead of Letters Patents from some higher spiritual Superiour , bring onely their own bare word to prove what are . The third Point . Consider now the rare excellency , and nature of the Church of Christ : this may be evidenced by 3 things most worthy to be remembred and meditated upon : The 1. whereof is the marks of it , which are rare endowments , privileges , & proprieties , distinguishing it most clearly from all other sects whatsoever ; these marks are handled in the ensuing meditations : The 2. is the manifold & admirable means & helps , which it affords those who are members of it , in order to their easie procuring their eternal salvation , ten of these ( most full of comfort ) are briefly handled in the second point of the first Meditation . The third thing , is the brave Elegium's , and great Characters , by which the holy Scriptures most deservedly extoll it . This Church is stiled ( and that by Truth it self ) the Kingdome of Christ ; yea , the Kingdome of heaven : this is the body of Christ , and the Spouse of that heavenly Bridegroom : Christ cals this his Dove , his beloved , his perfect one , his onely one ; this is his Vineyard , and his Harvest : this is his House : the House of God , the Temple of God , the Tabernacle of God , and the City of God : This is a high Mount , the Mount of our Lord in the top of Mountains , mount Sion , and a holy Mountain : This for its Light is that Candle upon a Candlestick , fair as the Moon , choice as the Sun ; that Woman cloathed with the Sun : this ( for the means , and marks it hath ) is a holy way , and so direct a way , that even fools shal not err therein : This for its ability to confute and conquer Heresies , is , an Army set in battell ray : This for its infallibility , is a Pillar and Firmament ; it is a House built by the Wise man upon a Rock ; in sine , it is the Church of Christ , against which all the Forces of Hell shall never prevail : For which , O may thy name be ever glorified , O King of glory ; and since thou art a Lord strong , and powerfull , a Lord strong in battaile ; diffipate those Nations which will have Wars , wars against thy Church , thy City founded upon a rock , and situated upon a hill ; or rather , since thy mercies are above all thy works , gather together ( thou good Shepheard ) these dispersed , ( if not lost ) sheep , and reduce them back into the sheepfold of thy Church , Amen . Collect out of this point , First , how great the ingratitude of those is towards Christ , who derogate from the honour of his Church , either by laying false aspersions upon it of corruption , defection , and teaching false doctrine ; or at least bear not that respect and reverence towards it , which they ought , both in regard of its excellency , and Christs charity in founding it . Secondly , how great reason there is , that every one , that is not a member of it , but of some other Sect ( though they imagine themselves to be truly of the true Church ) do notwithstanding parallel their Sect with that Church , of which the Scriptures give such noble characters : assuredly if passion , partiality , prejudicate opinion , and love of worldly things be laid aside , reason will tell them , they are wrong : and since notwithstanding some one ( for there can be but one ) of the different religions now on foot in Europe , must be it ; ( for Christ hath a true Church upon earth ) the result of that deliberation will be , that the Roman Catholikes alone have it . The fourth Point . Having considered that there is a Church , what that Church is , and the qualities of it ; the fourth thing remains to be considered , to wit , for what that Church is . Consider therefore that the end and intention , which Christ prefixed to himself , when he founded the Catholike Church , was the glory of God , and the salvation of Soules : These two are like the two Poles ; for all the created Universe move for them : these are that negotium seculorum , that work of ages ; that primum or first and chiefest thing , which must be sought for ; that unum necessarium , for which all other things must be set aside . But consider withall , that this Church is founded for the salvation of Mankinde , not so , as a thing indifferent , but as essentially requisite , and out of which no salvation can be had ; thus speak the Fathers , thus the Scriptures , and thus the Figures , which represent the Church : All that were not within the Ark of Noah , perished in the Deluge ; the member , which is cut off from the body , cannot live , the branch which is not united to the Vine Tree can bring forth no fruit , must needs wither ; is onely fit for the fire : the Sheep which remain not in this Sheepfold will be devoured by the hellish Wolves . And none received that mysterious penny ( the Symbol of eternall reward ) but those that laboured in the VINEYARD . It s of infinite consequence therefore , whether or no the Sect you are on , be the true Church , pray , read , meditate , conserre , compare Sect with Sect , till you finde out the true Church : for ( as truly said Saint Cyprian , and Saint Austin ) He shall not have God for his Father , who will not have the Church for his Mother ; to wit , the true Church ; Christ's Church . Do thou therefore ( O my soule ) study the matter of the salvation , and glorifying God well : The Catholick Church is the school , in which the Holy Ghost presides as chief Professor ; in it onely all truth is taught ; none elswhere , nor true divinity out of that schoole ; that long and hard lesson ( thy life led here ) thou must give an exact account of , both in the particular examen , at thy death ; and in the generall , at the day of doom : learn a pace by living , that thou may attain to an intuitive knowledge of God , and obtain the praemium of eternal life . Amen . The fourth Meditation . Of the Marks in general of Christs true Church . The first Point . COnsider first , what is meant by the Marks of the Church ; a mark in general is that by which we know a thing , and are able to distinguish it from other things , by the direction of that mark : so the divine Wisdome set certain marks upon his Church , by means of which it might be made notorious and easie to be found out , as also by the same means easily discernable from all other Sects whatsoever . Consider secondly , that the marks of the true Church must needs have one propriety , and that is clarity : They must be things ( though they be rare and extraordinary ) yet clear : known , apparent , and free from obscurity and uncertainty in themselves : and therefore they are called signes and notes ; by reason of their facility of being observed and taken notice of ; but if they be defective in this , they are no marks , but things as much subject to be questioned and controverted , as that very thing ( to wit the Church , or its infallible authority ) whose marks they are pretended to be : but miracles , prophesies , and strange conversions of Nations ; also Unity , Sanctity , Universality , and Apostolical succession ( which foure last are mentioned in the Nicen Creed : ) these are plainly convincing arguments and marks , by which Christs Church may be found out , and distinguished from all false Sects that have them not . Hence inferre , that all modern Sects shew themselves guilty of maintaining a bad cause ; and that Christs true Church is not amongst them ; because they assigne no such marks as these above mentioned ; but other obscure things and points controverted betwixt them and the Roman Catholikes : Such are lawfull administration of the Sacraments , and sincere preaching of the Word of God , and the like : these are no marks , but we must finde out where these are , by the forementioned marks : they make themselves , by this , guilty also of another fault , which is called petitio principii , or begging the question ; by taking that for an argument in their own behalf , which very thing is the question to be argued . For by the marks of the Church , as we must finde it out ; so must we find out who are true Pastors also , when this question is urged apart . The second Point . Consider now the necessity of these marks : First , from the holy Scriptures , Exod. 3. God gave Moses order to undertake that great enterprize of bringing the Israelites out of their Aegyptian bondage : To which Moses made reply , alledging his own insufficiency : Upon which God confirmed this his extraordinary Embassadours Commission , with the gifts ( as it were with his great Seale ) of working Miracles ; which he made use of to the astonishment of both Nations ; all being convinced thereby , that he was a man of God : nor did God send any other of his Prophets upon any great designe , but he authorized them with the gift of miracles , prophecy , eminent sanctity , or some one of them ; by means of which , credit was given to their words , that they were the words of God , revealed to them . Christ our Saviour made use of the same means , as necessary to induce the Jews to believe what he was , and that his doctrine was divine ; the same power and confirmation he gave to his Apostles , Disciples and their successours , as wholly necessary for the propagation of the Gospel : and certainly , there could be no ground for thinking , that ever the mysteries of Christian Faith should seem probable to Insidels ; unlesse the preachers of Christs doctrine were qualified with these divine Priviledges . Consider secondly , the necessity of these marks , from this : God exacts of man prudence in his moral actions ; much more in the main one ; such as are deliberation , and choice in point of Religion ; on the election of which his eternal interest depends ; and certainly that man proceeds not prudently , who fals rashly upon any Sect or Religion , without well grounded motives ; witnesse the divine wisdom , which sayes , He who believes soon , is light of heart : That is , fickle , inconsiderate , imprudent , mark this prudentiall point , you Novellists ; examine , what motives hold you in the way you are in , and what marks of the true Church your sect hath . Ponder further the necessity ( at least convenience ) of a true understanding and comprehension of the marks , and signes of the true Church ; from this , if these two quaeries ( which be the marks of the true Church ; and in what Sect or Religion are they to be found ? ) were sully answered , as by the divine assistance they shall be in this Treatise ; then it would clearly appear , which were the true Church , and so all doubts and controversies would vanish , or be composed easily . Gather hence , how much conducing and necessary , in order to a setled security of minde , and a prudent choice of Religion , is a sober , and mature search after the marks of Christs Church : especially for those , who are not yet confined to any determinate Sect ; and for those , who professing some one in particular ; yet fear that all is not well with them ; for those also who finde none of these Marks upon the Church they are in . Enter into a serious consideration with thy self , about these two queries ( thou that loves thy soules security ) seek , and thou shalt find , to wit , the true Church by its marks and signes ; Say with David : Now have I begun ; this change is the work of the right hand of him , that is on high : I have been mindefull of the works of the Lord ; I will be mindfull from the very beginning of thy wonderfull things ; and I will meditate upon all thy workes . And after a diligent inquiry made for finding out of the marks and signes of Christs Church in your own Sect ; you will at length conclude with these words of the same Prophet , Psalm 73. 10. We have not seen our signes : ( there are none upon this our Church ) now there is no Prophet ; none amongst us , whose doctrine we are certain is from God , soul-saving , secure . The third Point . Consider now the sufficiency of the signes and marks , by which God gives testimony , that the doctrine of Christs Church is truly Orthodox : Of this the Prophet David ( who by an anticipated knowledge , which he had by divine instinct of the whole frame , and composure of Christs Church ) uttered these most pat and pithy words , Testimonia tua credibilia facta sunt nimis ; Thy testimonies are made too credible : By which Hebraisme nimis , he means , that they are very credible ; and that that Church ( which is illustrated and confirmed with the testimonies of such marks , as can be imprinted upon it by God only ) deserves to be credited in all things : Our Saviour himself sent no other demonstration to Saint John of his being the Messias , but this , Go and tell John what ye have heard and seen ; the blind see , the lame walke , the leprous are clensed , the deaf hear , the dead rise ; and he urged the same argument , when he said that the Jews had not been guilty of sin ( to wit of infidelity and disbelieving his doctrine ) if he had not effected amongst them works , which no other mortall man was able to do : The blind man ( who together with his corporal eyes , had also those of his soul opened by Christ ) urged the same argument against them ; averring that it was a thing unheard of since the creation of the world , that a man could give sight to the blind , unlesse God were with him : And Nicodemus yeelded to the like argument , by his ingenious and voluntary acknowledgement , that our Saviour was a teacher sent by God , because no man could do those miracles , which he did , unlesse God were with him : so that the sufficiency of these marks is perfectly established out of Scripture it self . Ponder secondly , how reason dictates that greater inducements , and powerfuller perswasives cannot be brought to conciliate authority , and esteem , to a Religion , than the above mentioned marks are : for they are above the ability and reach of nature : onely God , or such as to whom God delegates this power , can cause so prodigious effects . Saint Austin and the holy Fathers , urged these marks , as strong maximes against all Heresies , as they sprung up ; yea , they themselves were kept within the bosome of the Catholike Church by these strong and sweet chains ; as appeared by their Writings . Adde to this , the conversions of Ethnick and idolatrous Nations : what was it else , but the forcible and powerfull charms ( if they may be be so termed ) of these strange priviledges and prerogatives , with which the preachers of Christian doctrine to them were endowed , which drew them from infidelity ( yea and barbarity ) to Christianity . The fourth Point . Consider lastly , some inferences , which may be drawn out of the precedent points : First , those that are already members of the Catholike Church , have much to thank God for , in being made members of that Church , which is so very conspicuous with these rare endowments , and proprieties . Secondly , since these marks ( here-briefly touched , but in the ensuing pages , more particularly to be looked into apart ) are on the one side so necessary , and on the other so sufficient , and satisfactory to reason : it behoves every Protestant , Presbyterian , Independent , Anabaptist , and all these late Euthusiasticks , to try the truth of their severall Sects by these touchstones . Thirdly , That he who makes a search after the true Religion , by the direction of these marks , proceeds most prudently , and cannot be obnoxious to errour in his enquiry . Fourthly , that this is both the most convincing , and also the most easie way of composing all Controversies : for by this you may easily discover the true Church ; which being found out , all are obliged to embrace it , and 〈…〉 and to its verdict in all things : and the Scripture ( whose obscure texts abused , and variously interpreted , have given occasion of these , and of all Heresies ) will by this means need no searching into . Lastly , For a preparation to the ensuing meditations , infer what dictamen , and disposition a man is to come with , that will benefit his soul by reading them : First , he must observe that there is a great difference betwixt Affirmative and Negative Propositions in this subject : for it is evident , that that Sect or Religion is not the true Church , which is devoid of these marks : why ? because they are inseparable from the true Church ; as will hereafter appear out of the first points of many of the Meditations . Yet on the contrary , you must not think , that wheresoever any of these marks is to be found , there is the true RELIGION : for God can give a man power to work miracles , or prophesie truly , though he be of a false Sect , but not in confirmation of that false Sect : So Julian the Apostate , going to sacrifice to the heathenish Gods , and terrified with the sudden apparition of the devill , he instantly drive him away by making the signe of the crosse , which he had learned when he was a Catholike ; thus writes St. Greg. Naz. and Nicephorus recounts , that the Persians bore the signe of the Crosse graven upon their Foreheads , in memory of their being delivered from the plague , by arming themselves ( as they were taught by the Christians ) with the same signe : Now these examples make nothing against Roman Catholikes , but confirm their tenent . Secondly , he must come with indifferency ; otherwise he cannot be an impartial and fit judge ; without any prejudicate opinion , without passion , and without obstinate resolution of persisting where he is , be his Sect what it will be ; for this were affected ignorance , which is malice ; and such an one is he , of whom God complains , saying , Noluit intelligere ut beue ageret ; He would not understand whereby to do well ; this is dangerous , this hath too great affinity with hardnesse of heart , the greatest of all miseries , and punishments in this life : but read them with a desire of your own profit and spiritual good , and then you will find just cause to say with King David to Almighty God ; Testimonia tua credibilia facta sunt nimis ; thy testimonies ( to wit the testimonies and marks of thy Church ) are made too credible ; that is very credible ; meaning thereby , that the Church ( in behalf of which God gives these signes and testimonies ) deserves to be credited in whatsoever she propounds . Yet it is worth taking notice of , that the protestant translatours of the Bible , interpret the forementioned words of the Psalme ( 93 with them ) thus : Thy testimonies are very sure ; using here their wonted manner of explicating places that savour Catholike Tenents equivocally , obscurely , or two largely , and without the restrictions , which the places require : For these words do not expresse the motives of credibility , as the former do . The Fifth Meditation . Of Miracles . The first Point . COnsider first , that Miracles are a mark of Christs true Church : These signes ( sayes our Saviour of his Church ) shall follow them that believe in me : in my name shall they cast out Devils , they shall speake with new tongues , they shall take up Serpents ; and if they drink any deadly thing , it shall not hurt them ; they shall lay hands on the sick , and they shall recover : Here 's the promise of that power , and behold the performance of it : Matt. 16.20 . They went forth and preached every where , the Lord working with them , and confirming their word with signes following : And that this power of working Miracles was to remaine perpetually in the Church , it is acknowledged by the Protestants ( in their Bible , Printed Anno 1576. ) in their Comment in the Margent upon these words of S. John , He that believes in me , the works that I doe , he shall doe , and greater : These words are clear ; their glosse sayes thus of that place and promise : This is referred to the whole Body of the Church in which this vertue doth shine for ever : So that this perpetuity of the Churches being priviledged with this power ( an admirable gift of Gods providence ) is by this clearly proved . Ponder Secondly , the necessity of miracles : as also the sufficiency of them in order to convince , that that doctrine is from God , which is confirmed with them ; both which two things are proved by scripture and reason , in the second and third point of the precedent Meditation . The second Point . Consider now how apparently this mark of Miracles is to be found amongst the Roman Catholicks : for the better understanding of which , these four things following are most worthy to be well pondered . First , The Authours who relate them , or wrote in defence of them , or urge them as an argument against Heathens and Hereticks : Such are St. Ireneus , in his Books against Hereticks ; S. Basil , who writes of the miracles of S. Gregory Thaumaturgus ; Saint Gregory Nyssen , in the life of the same Saint ; S. Athanasius , in the life of S. Anthony ; S. Hierom , who wrote the lives of many Saints ; Eusebius Russinus , Nicephorus , and Socrates ; S. Ambrose , who relates the miracles , which happened at the finding of the bodies of the Saints ' Gervasius and Protasius martyrs ; St. Gregory the great , in his Books of Diologues ; Venerable Bede in his five Books of the Church of England ; S. Bernard , who writ the life of S. Malachy ; S. Bonaventure , who writ the life of S. Francis , and our own Country men , who lived since the Conquest ; Malmesbury , Hoveden , Huntington , Paris , Westminster , Doctour Harpsfield , and Doctor Stapleton . Now reflect upon this , that these authours are such , as that many of them are acknowledged for Saints and Doctours the Church , even by all Sects whatsoever : out of which it follows , that they cannot be suspected of ignorance , lying or faining these miracles , which they recount : Yea , they themselves teach , that imposture , and forgery in point of Miracles , is a grievous sin . Consider secondly , the persons that wrought Miracles ; such were S. Gregory Thaumaturgus , S. Anthony , S. Hillarion , S. Pacovius , S. Nicolas , S. Martin , S. Boniface , S. Remigius , S. Augustine the Apostle of England , S. Cuthbert , S. Oswald , S. Guthlack , S. Omer , S. Bertin , S. Malachy , S. Bernard , S. Francis , and Saint Dominick , and many hundreds more ; of which the very Adversaries of the Roman Catholikes acknowledge many of them for Saints , and workers of Miracles : concerning which the Magdeburgian Centurists , in the 13. chap. of every Century give a clear testimony : And in this last Age , Hackluit ( a Protestant , and a great admirer of S. Francis Xaverius the Jesuite ) writes of this blessed man , that he wrought Miracles , and so does Hartwell ( in his Epistle to his book of the kingdome of Congo in Africa , speaking of the conversion of it ) wrote of the same man and other Roman Priests : Now concerning the miraculous prodigies , which these men did , Histories ( writ by the forementioned Doctors ) are so clear , that they cannot be denyed , without disavouching all humane faith , history and authority ; and to say , or suspect , that these blessed men had any recourse to the Devil , or commerce , and assistance from him , were intolerable impiety : What can light have to do with darknesse ? Sanctity with inveterate and confirmed malice ? Saints with Devils ? they are irreconcileable enemies ; continuall Antagonists : Now that these Saints were all Roman Catholicks , it is undoubtedly true : First , because the Writers of their Lives , and their Acts testisfie it . Secondly , because their Adversaries , the Centurists and others , ingeniously confesse it of most of them . Thirdly , Because Sectaries would challenge them , and their Miracles to themselves ( thereby to strengthen their own faction ) if any probability appeared , which might perswade , that they were no Roman Catholikes . Consider thirdly , The nature and excellency of these their miraculous operations : No Sympathy or Antipathy ; no Judiciary Astrology , or Art Magick ; no Sorcery or ability of the wicked Spirits , can produce so prodigious effects : True it is , the Devils are not by force of their Damnation devested of their natural abilities , but can do strange things : yet as St. Austin in his Books of the Trinity , and the Angelicall Doctor St. Thomas of Aquin , and others well versed in Philosophy & Theology affirm ; they cannot give sight to those that are born blind , nor streighten distorted limbs , nor cure paralyticks , nor give life to the dead ; nay , nor cure diseases , but by application of natural medicines ; nor will Devils put their associates out of their possession of mens bodies ; but rather indent with one another , and plot both to keep their holds they have , and to make new entries into others : Catholicke Priests only are they that can , and have outed these impious usurpers in all ages : Nor will these wicked spirits concur to the preserving the dead bodies of Saints uncorrupted ; at which so many devout Prayers , long Watches , large Alms , were offered up to God in honour of his Saints ; and by occasion of which Monasteries , Colleges , Churches , Chappels , and Hospitals were founded . O the wonders ( and by occasion of them the good Works ) that were wrought at the Shrines of S. Thomas of Canterbury , S. Hugh , S. Edward , S. John of Beverley , and S. Cuthbert : this one Saints body remained incorrupt , and intire every limb and joynt , with the hair on the head , and Episcopal weed on , for the long Tract of eight hundred and forty years ; till the sad daies of King Henry the eight caused the demolishing of that rare and rich Shrine , and the conveyance of that body into an obscure Cave : onely that Ring , so long wedded to that Saints finger , of all the riches of that Shrine , came into good hands , and is now with the right Reverend Lord ( Richard Smith ) Bishop of Calcedon , as I heare : The translation of this one Saints body to Durham , what arguments for the Roman Religion there dos it not afford : For out of the brambles and bushes of a woody hill rise a City , and Episcopall See , in which sate 37 Bishops , all obedient to the See of Rome , and Roman Catholikes every one of them . Consider fourthly , the number and multitude of these forementioned Saints Miracles ; how numerous ( and in a manner numberlesse ) the Miracles were , may be best gathered from the number of the Saints ; Six Tomes filled with Saints lives , hath one man alone ; hence how many Miracles ; since almost each Saint wrought so many : Ponder this ! Admire this ! Gloria haec est omnibus Sanctis ejus ; this glory of working miracles is proper onely to the Saints of Gods Church ; and therefore those , who have been priviledged with power to work these , are the Saints of his Church . The third Point . Consider now , what confirmation any of these modern Sects hath from Miracles , none at all : Luther and Calvin knew full well , that Miracles were great marks , & signes of true doctrine , and therefore to authorize themselves , they attempted these ; Luther began to dispossesse a certain Wench a spiritual daughter of his ; but insteed of delivering her from the injury , himself fell into his hands ; for the Devill setting upon him , almost kild him , as Staphysus , eye witnesses report : His second attempt , was to raise from death a man drowned in the river Elbe ( Nesenus by name : ) he comes to the place with a retinue of his new Prosellytes and others , he views the body , mutters some obscure words , seconded with various changes of his countenance , but the man stirred not ; at which Luther went away , not a little confounded . Calvin agreed underhand with a poore man , called Bruley ( upon promise of some temporal succour ) that he should fain himself sick , and seemingly grow worse and worse , and at length die ; all this begun to be acted as was agreed upon ; Calvin is called to the poor mans house ; he comes with a great deal of gravity and resentment , people flock apace , and a greater blind is made , just as the man dies Calvin takes hold of his hand , and conjures him in the name of God to rise ; but by the just judgement of God the man proves to be really dead : the poor mans wife ( conscious of their combining together ) charges Calvin with the death of her husband , and discovers to Calvins shame , the whole designe ; and thus stands the case with Sectaries in point of Miracles : no , no ; God will not with his seal confirm lyes , heresies , blasphemies . The fourth Point . Consider now some sequels derived out of the former points ; first , one of the main reasons why Sectaries calumniate , & inveigh so much against some Miracles ( for many they cannot deny ) done by the Roman Catholikes , is because they have none themselves : and by good consequence they have not the true Church amongst them ; since they have not this mark , which the Scripture attributes to Christs Church : Secondly , that the above mentioned holy fathers were all Roman Catholicks , even for this very reason ( if there were no other ) to wit , because they recount the Miracles of other Saints , praise them and urge them as an impregnable argument against Hereticks ; this thing is most worthy of consideration : Thirdly , that the Church of Christ , is onely amongst the Roman Catholicks ; since onely true miracles ( many and most strange ones ) were done by them , and are done by them even in these our dayes . And now thou ( O Lord ) who art wonderfull in thy Saints , work thy wonted wonders , and restore sight to those souls , who have the eyes of their under standings so in a manner put out by ignorance , passion , or malice , that they cannot see this mark of mighty Miracles upon thy Church : Open with that thy Ephphata , those Ears that will not hear thy Church , which thou commands ( upon pain of being reputed no better than Heathenish ) should be heard : Say to the lame , Rise and Walk ; direct the footsteps of those that stray , even out of that in which fools cannot go amisse ; that so all may return to thy Church , their best House and Home , Amen . The sixth Meditation . Of Sanctity of life . The first Point . COnsider first , that sanctity and perfection ( which consists in a perfect accomplishment of the divine Will , and a conformity of humane will to it ) is a mark of Christs true Church : The holy Scriptures are most copious in the proof of this : Sanctity becomes thy House ( O Lord ) unto the length of dayes ; to wit , for ever : thus King David expresses this mark ; immediately after that of miracles , and the other marks , in these words ; Testimonia tua credibilia facta sunt nimis , to those that are members of Christs Church , saies Saint Paul , The Temple of God is holy , which ( Temple ) you are : and God himself sayes , Beye holy , because I am holy ; our Saviour inculcated this truth often : Ye have not chosen me , but I have chosen you , and ordained you that you go and bring forth fruit , and that your fruit should remain : and again he sayes in plain terms , that by their fruits you shall know them : Man is the Tree ( saies S. Austin ) and his actions are the fruit ; in fine our Lord sayes to all the members of his Church ; Be ye perfect , even as your heavenly father is perfect : Hence appears evidently , that sanctity and perfection , is a mark of Christs true Church : And Hence must be inferred , that where this is wanting , there the true Church of Christ hath no being ; where this is truly found , there is the true Church discovered : Be thou therefore an impartial judge in this point of Sanctity ; without which ( in some degree ) there is no salvation to be hoped for 1 beg the assistance of divine grace , that no self ends , or worldly interests ; no prejudice or passion may disturbe thee , or hinder thee in this search after true Sanctity , and the Communion of Saints , which are onely to be found in the holy Catholike Church . The second Point . To understand how truly true Sanctity and perfection hath been taken to heart alwayes amongst Roman Catholicks , Consider these three things following ; First , the means their Religion affords them , for the acquiring of true Sanctity ; Secondly , The use they make of such means : Thirdly , The number and multitude of their Saints . Consider therefore , 1. That all the helps and requisites , which the study of perfection can stand in need of , are to be had amongst them ; to acquire the benefits of divine grace and justification , as also to increase the same , and to recover them again being lost , As 1. The holy Sacraments are the main means ; now , who makes any doubt , but that the Roman Catholicks make most frequent and Religious use of these ; but especially the holy SACRAMENT of the ALTAR , and that of Confession ( which is alwayes accompanied with the exercise of many Acts of other vertues , as humility , sorrow , good purposes , victory over ones self , Faith , Hope and Charity ) they find by daily experience to be great helps to vertue . 2. Their form of worship , and that divine Sacrifice of holy Masse ( which all antiquity ever honoured ) is both a motive to all acts of vertue , a means to obtain vertue , and a work upon which all vertues attend : it is both impretatory and propitiatory in the highest degree . 3. Another great furtherer , & most efficacious means to vertue , is Prayer , both mentall and vocall ; to the good and frequent performance of which , as the Roman Catholicks are most conformable to the Counsell of our Saviour , by being most addicted to it of all other sorts of people ; so have they most excellent instructions given them by holy and learned men . 4. Fasting , ( so much commended , and extolled by holy scripture in the lovers of it ) how can it but be very conducing to vertue ; since it weakens vertues adversaries ( the rebellion of the Flesh , inordinate passions , and the malignant humours both of body and soul ) so much , as experience teaches , the Roman Catholicks surpasse all others in this . 5. Another great advantage they have above all others , and that is the direction of their spiritual Pastors , and Ghostly Fathers ; upon , whom as there is a most strict charge laid , that they have care of their spirituall children , so they discharge that duty most exactly . 6. The Doctrine they teach ( especially that of good Works , Works of Supererogation , Penance , and Satisfaction ) is a great spurre and mover to perfection . 7. To omit other instrumental causes of vertue and devotion , that admirable and plainly divine invention , and institution of Religious Orders ( differing one from another in their manner of living , but most unanimous in beliving ) is plainly an admirable means to get vertue by ; yea , that state of life is properly the schoole of perfection it self ; and by these you see how abundantly the Roman Catholicks are supplied with means for attaining to sanctity : to these also may be added other particular helps , mentioned in the second point of the first Meditation . Consider secondly , how Catholicks correspond with these great helps they have for the expulsion of Vice , and purchase of Vertue : The Church commands each one that 's come to the years of discretion , to approach once a year to the holy Communion , but commends a more frequent accesse : What do they do ? hundreds in every great Town , yea , thousands in some , repaire not once a year , but once every week to that divine banquet : they are commanded to confesse their sins to the Priests ( whose power to forgive sins was most assuredly given by Christ , in these expresse and clear words , Whose soever sins ye remit , are remitted unto them . ) Once a year : yet thousands of them go to that Sacrament once every week : They are commanded to be present at holy Masse every Sunday and Holyday ; yet besides these dayes , thousands of them in every great Town perform that act of Religion every day ; is not this a true compliance with the forementioned means ? Are not these works of Supererogation a fair way to perfection ? These instances alone , argue how much these people are addicted to prayer , what good they get by their spirituall directors , and how they fulfill that doctrine of good Works ; As for Fasting ( that soveraigne antidote against the sins of the Flesh ) Roman Catholicks are admired by all Sectaries for this ; as for upright dealing in civill contracts ; they have the repute of being generally the left injurious or unjust : nor does any sort of peoples word go further than theirs , even in treating with those who are averse from their opinions : And truly to see so many of them ( families of great worth ) in this our Nation , live so contentedly amongst the ruines of their great Fortunes , which they might have kept intire in great part by once going with those of a different Religion to Church , or swallowing over that one Oath , yet would not ; this must needs argue a great fidelity to their religious Principles , and a great esteem of vertue and piety in them ; as for these holy inhabitants of religious Monasteries , they live as if they would win heaven ( which suffers force ) even by very violence ; such is their study of persection , so intense their prayers , so protracted their fastings , so long their watchings , & so continual their study of self denial , carrying their crosses , and following their Saviour ( the things so much recommended by him to all ) by an exact imitation of heroicall vertues . Who now can deny but the Roman Catholicks take to heart the study of perfection , and that science of the Saints , which is sanctity . Compare these and Sectaries together , and see what sequels follow . Consider thirdly , the number of their Saints : behold a short Catalogue of some few of them in every Age , besides the Apostles , Disciples , and others , these following lived in the first Age , Saint Dennis , Linus , Cletus , Clement , Martialis , Thecla and others . 2. Ignatius , Policarp , Justine , Vincent , Irenaeus , Eleutherius , Lucius , Felicitas . 3. Tiburtius , Valerianus , Cecily , Barbara , Agnes , Agatha , Laurence , Xirtus , George , S. Gregory Thaum . 4. Nicholas , Antony , Hilarion , Hellen , Athanasius , Hilary , Basil , Gregory Naz. Hierom , Ambrose , Epiphanius . 5. Chrysostome , Augustine , Paulinus , Alexius , Vrsula , Lutrick , Leo , Germanus , Simeon Stelites . 6. Columbe , Columbane , Genovesa , Siverius , Leonard , Leander , Hermingildus , Gregory the great . 7. Isidore , Aidan , Edwin , Oswald , Cuthbert , Theodore , Benedict , Ebbe , Cesarius , Lambert , Eugenius . 8. Bede , S. John Damascen , Germanus , Cuthlack , Grimwald , Hubert . 9. Sabinus , Geroldus , Ludgerus , Rumoldus , Nicetas , Rembertus , Swithin . 10. Wenceslaus , Dunstan , Bruno , Odocluniacensis , Romaldus , Elphegus , Guibert . 11. Henry the Emperour , Edward Conf. Lanfrank , Anselme , Stanislaus , Ivo , Bruno Carthusianus , Robert. 12. Malachy , Bernard , William , Norbert , S. Thomas of Canterbury , S. Hugh Bishop of Lincolne . 13. Dominick , Francis , Mary Ognes , Thomas Aquinas , Bonaventure , Gertrude . 14. Roche , Christina Sumlensis , Gertrude ab Oesten , Catharine of Sienna . 15. Bernardinus senensis , Viucentius , Laurence , Justinian , Antoninus , Colecta . Francis of Paula , Ignatius , Loyola , Francis Xaverius , Philip Nereus , Teresa , Carolus Borom . To these , many thousands more might be added ; yea , the English Martyrologe alone affords us Saints of our own Country , for every day in the year . Now that these were Saints , and also Roman Catholicks , it is evident : First , because all the whole Roman Church ( not any one expressing in the least the contrary ) acknowledgeth them for such ; and upon that score honoureth them . Secondly , because their written lives , and Ecclesiasticall History do evidently evince the same . Thirdly , the practice of their lives and their opinions , demonstrate that they were Roman Catholicks ; for they all honoured and obeyed the Pope , as supream head of the Church next after Christ ; they practised Invocation of Saints , Prayer for the faithfull departed , saying , or hearing holy Masse , Priestly power to remit sins , and other tenents now held by Roman Catholicks ; yea , their very enemies , the Magdeburgian Centurists , acknowledge many of them for Saints , even of the latest of them ( as S. Bernard , S. Malachy , S. Dominick , S. Francis and others ) and grant that they held these foresaid opinions . The third Point . Consider now the state and condition of other Sectaries in point of sanctity : First , they have no means to acquire it , whilest they remain as they are : They deny that Priests have power to forgive sins , and consequently make no use of that Sacrament ; their Communion they grant is but bare bread , and consequently it cannot sanctifie them ; for publick worship , there is none now in any sect in England : a Psalm is all that is now extant of publick service amongst them , and that rejected by most ; and for private prayer , certainly they spend little time in it , at least they do nothing that 's comparable to what the RomanCatholicks generally perform ; much lesse will they pretend to come neer these in Fasting : In brief , their doctrine is exclusive of works of supererogation , Merit , Mortification , and Satisfaction ; how then can it be but destructive of true Sanctity ; yea , and salvation : in fine , all the means they pretend to get sanctity by , is faith alone : this medium of faith , the Roman Catholicks have ; and besides it , all the other comfortable helps mentioned before : Who can now but be afraid of the ones condition , and admire the other . Consider secondly , what Saints they have ; they will not now surely own that Calender of John for any more ; since Father Parsons examination proves it a ridiculous false thing ; the chief of their forefathers were Luther , Calvin , Beza and such like ; what lives led they ? Scandalous , and exorbitantly bad . Luther himself , ingeniously confesseth , that when he was a Papist , he said Maffe , and that devoutly for many years ; that he lived in his Monastery ( for he was once an Augustine Friar ) punishing his body with Watching , Fasting , and Prayer ; by which he followed the counsell and example of our Saviour ; that he kept Poverty , Chastity , and Obedience ; and that he honour'd the Pope out of meer Conscience : Well , at length , he begun a new Sect ; did this make him continue his former piety ? Did he increase it ? Did he become a Saint ? Behold what he did ; he casheer'd Fasting , Prayer , Watching , his Vows , his Monastery and the Pope ; and instead of these took a Nun ( called Catherine Bore ) for his Concubine ; and gave himself wholly to Lust , Gluttony , drinking of Wine , and sensuality : What he writ , was conformable to the temper , which these Vices put him in to ; and so he persisted to his dying day . Calvin was not onely given to lust , but to lust against nature , to wit , Sodomy ; for which his Shoulder was burnt with a mark of a Lilly at Noyon in France . Beza kept not onely a Concubine , but a Boy also to satisfie his lust ; with both which he was so transported , that he could not forbeare to expresse the same in wanton and scandalous Verses , which are extant amongst his other Works : As for these mens followers and adherents ; Luther himself fayes ( upon the Gospel for the first Sunday in Advent ) of his ; that they were become worser livers , than they were whilest they remained Papists . Erasmus , in his Epistle to Vultu rius Neocomus , gives the same character of them ; and Jacobus Andraeus , a famous Lutheran , in his 4. Sermon upon the 21. of S. Luke , sayes , To the end that all the world may know that they are no Papists , nor attribute any thing to good works , they do no good works at all ; and indeed experience teacheth , that those , who turn from being Papists , do not become Saints , but Sensualists . The fourth Point . Consider now what may be gathered out of the precedent points : First , either these modern Sectaries acknowledge Luther , Calvin , Beza , or others of their times , for their first Founders , or not ; if they do , then they admit men of scandalous lives for their Founders , and so the Religion or fruit sprung from these b●d trees cannot be good : If they disavouch them , then they be like the Acephalists , members without a head , and without Ancestors : for they cannot lay claim to the Saints mentioned in the second point ; since they so little resemble them either in belief or life : Secondly the reason why due respect to the Saints in heaven is neither taught , nor practised by them ; to wit , because they have had none of their own ; and because the true Saints indeed were Roman Catholicks : thirdly , seeing that the opposition of contraries , and their repugnancy , appears more clearly when they are paralell'd together ; compare the Roman religion and the best of these later sects together in point of virtue , and sanctity , which is the cream & quintessence of mans felicity in this life : then make a prudent choice , and side with that party where there is most Sanctity , and by good consequence most hopes of salvation ; then with the Cherubins , and Seraphins cry out ; Holy , holy , holy , Lord God of Sabbath , Son of God , since you bid us be perfect , as your heavenly Father is perfect : Heavenly Father since you bid us be holy , because you are holy ; grant us what you command , and command what your good pleasure is : My heart is ready , O God , my heart is ready : Help me Lord to remove the obstacles , and apply the means aright ; that being freed from the enemies of my conversion , I may serve thee in sanctity and justice all the dayes of my life , Amen . The Seventh Meditation . Of holinesse of Doctrine . The first Point . Consider I. that Christs true Church hath ( as it must needs have ) amongst other marks , that of holy doctrine , and such as becomes Christs Church : it must teach nothing against Piety , Verity , Reason , Equity , or good manners : but on the contrary , all things in it must be conformable to Piety and Vertue , as truly they are : The holy Ghost speaking by the mouth of the Prophet David , confirms this truth , gives the Churches doctrine many great Elogium's in that long , but most sweet Psalm 119. The law of the Lord is immaculate ; that is without spot , or blemish of falshood , or impiety : The precept of the Lord is Lucid : that is bright , shining , and like a light to shew us the true way to serve God , and save our soules : The testimony of the Lord is faithfull : and Saint Paul cals it a sound doctrine ; by which Metaphor he intimates , that as that body cannot be judged sound & healthfull , which is seased upon by any disease ; so that Doctrine , Faith , or Church , cannot be wholsome , and soul-saving , which hath adhearing to it any maxime , or assertion false or favouring vice ; but there needs no proof of this ; for it is called the word of God : And the doctrine of Christs Church must needs proceed originally from Christ ; who will not permit his Church to teach impious or false doctrine . Consider secondly of how great concernment it is for men of understanding , to have sometimes for the subject of their most serious and retired thoughts , the consideration of what doctrine is taught by the different Sects now on foot in England ; and to mark which , and how far they are pec cant against piety : And thou who tenders the good of thy soule , weigh their tenents , and those of the Roman Catholicks , with an equall ballance ( but let not the love , or sear of thy temporal interests meddle with the scales ) and after exact notice taken of them all , cast thy selfe without more adoe into the arms of that religion , which seems to teach that doctrine which is conducing to piety , andthy souls eternal felicity . The second Point . To understand how agreeable to Piety , and Verity , the doctrine of the Roman Catholicks is , take these three considerations for matter of the frequent meditation : The first , is , That tenents of the Roman Catholicks ( about those matters , which are controverted betwixt them and other Sectaries ) are more beseeming Almighty God and his Church ; much more advantagious to the honour of both ; and greater expressions of divine perfections , than the adversary opinions are : Is it not better to have more means for obtaining divine grace ( and consequently more Sacraments , the instrumentall causes of it ) than fewer ? to receive the real body & blood of Christ , is not that a more noble memorial of Christs a thing more beneficiall to man , and more honourable to God , than a bit of Bread onely , and a sup of Wine ? Is it not farre more beneficial for frail and sinfull men , that Christ give Priests power to remit , and forgive them their sins , than otherwise ? that the Church of Christ be conspicuous and visible in all Ages ; that it be liable to no defectibility , or fallibility ; that it have easie and accessible means for the decision of Controversies ; that some stately and majesticall form of worship be exhibited to the divine Majesty ; as also that a sacrifice of some rare thing ( such as is the precious body & blood of Christ ) be offered daily to that infinite deity ; that there be an Ecclesiastical Hierarchy , ascending by different degrees up , till it come to one supream head , to whom all are to yeeld obedience : do not these make more for the Churches perfection , Gods honour and glory , than the contrary ? Frame to thy self a lively Idea of the congruity of these particulars with Gods and his Churches greater honour ; look upon these instances with a judicious eye ; and conclude , that in case it were doubtfull , whether the affirmative or negative opinion were truer in these points ; yet since one of the two must be embraced , choose that which is most conducing to the honour of God and his Church . The second consideration is , that the opinions of the Roman Catholicks ( these in particular now urged , and others which will be mentioned hereafter ) are more suitable and consonant to the holy scriptures , than their contradictories are : For the better intelligence of which , observe these two rules , whereof the first is , clear places of scripture must be preferred in point of proof before hard and obscure ones : the other is , many texts of Scripture must be a greater argument than fewer , caeteris paribus : these two rules can be rejected by none , but such as ( conscious of their own unjust plea ) will come to no try all at all : Now conformably to these rules , it is apparently evident , that Roman Catholicks bring more and clearer places out of the scriptures , to establish the truth of the forementioned opinions , and others which they hold , than their adversaries can possibly bring to the contrary : Read any Catholick book of Controversie , and you will see the truth of what is here affirmed ; and by the way note also how this consideration strengthens and fortifies the truth of the former . The third consideration is , that the tenents of Roman Catholicks are more conducing to the security of mens salvation , than the Negative opinions are : in this corruption of humane nature ( vitiated by that Original sin of our protoparent Adam ) the flesh wages war continually against the spirit , and the inferiour against the superiour portion of the soul ; and the issue of the war would be the undoing of the nobler part , unlesse it had continuall recruits and supplyes , both of auxiliary forces from heaven , and made use also of Fasting , Watching , and self-denial , and other asperities , and mortifications : for these are the ordinary arms , with which the rebellious passions & vicious inclinations must be curb'd ; these are the things so much recomended in the scriptures both Propheticall and Apostolicall ; these are the things recommended unto us all by Christ himself , when he bid us deny our selves , take up our crosses & follow him ; as also when he bid us go in the narrow way , and enter in at the strait gate : Now this is the very doctrine of Roman Catholicks , and only of them : They both in their Pulpits , and with their pennes inculcate these vertues continually ; witnesse the many rare Treatises written by their Priests upon that subject ; as also of the angelical vertue Chastity ; and of the Sacrament of Confession , which is accompanied with the exercise of most virtuous acts of Contrition , Penance purposes of emendation , of satisfying for injuries done , and removing the occasions of relapses ; all which vertues , as they are contrary to self-ease , & the wild liberty of flesh and blood , so they keep off sin , & secure salvation so much the more : and thus you see how their doctrine teaches to decline from evill by the aforesaid means ; & as for doing good , which is the second part of the works of Christian duty ; it is most certain that their doctrine favours this , and leads to this most effectually ; for they teach that the commandements of God may be kept , and that the difficulty of observing them is not insuperable ; They teach , that man hath a free liberty of will , not onely to doe evill , but good also : They teach that mans works ( done in vertue of Christs merits , and united with them ) may be good and meritory of an increase of grace and glory : These opinions cannot but animate a man towards the keeping of divine precepts , and doing all the good he can ; and consequently bring a greater security of salvation : Which if thou takest to heart truly , thou must like , love and embrace this doctrine . The third Point . Consider now , whether or no , the doctrine of other Sectaries ( now swarming in England ) be holy and wholsome ; and how helpfull it is to the saving of soules : this will appear by a short survey made of those particulars , which are commonly held by them all : first , behold what a pitiful , poor , and naked thing they make the Church of Christ : ( by w ch Church is here meant , not this or that Church , which either Roman Catholicks , or other Sects call Christs Church and theirs ; but prescinding from controversie about whose , or where it is ; we mean the Church of Christ secundum se ; and which all Sects must grant Christ hath upon earth : ) this they devest of all the ornaments , which become it , and the founder of it . They deny it to be of infallible authority ; and say , it can , and hath erred ; they will not admit it to be the judge of Controversies , nay , nor to have been in all ages visible : they deny that Priests have power to remit sins , which is contrary to the expresse words of Christ , and contrary to the Book of Common Prayer ; and they averre that Christ hath not left his real and true body and blood to be received by Christians ; nor that there is in the Church any true proper or propitiatory sacrifice ; and since sacrifice is so great an act of Religion as it is , by depriving the Church of Christ of this , they undervalue the Church , and monarchicall government ( which even Aristotle a heathen could define to be the best for keeping of order ) they deny Christs Church : a man would think that God ( who does all things in number , weight , and measure ) should have made the Church a master-piece of his wisdome , power , and goodnesse : the Roman Catholicks indeed say it is so ; but other Sectaries deprive it not of comely ornaments onely , but even requisites ; and have lest in it nothing but one Sacrament , to wit , baptisme ( for their other things is but bare Bread and Wine ) and that now omitted and abused by many ; no form of Worship , but some one of their ill translated Psalms , and that not used by all ; and Preaching , common to all sorts ( and even Sexes ) of People . Secondly , they teach things which are plainly paradoxical , and asystata ; things not onely repugnant to most clear texts of Scripture , but quite destructive of good Works , and by consequence of the means for salvation : for by their private spirit , and each mans own interpretation of scripture , they measure and square out the whole busines of Faith and Religion : in this if they erre ( and how can they be free from errours ? ) they not onely run hazard of but plainly incur damnation ; for he that will not believe shall be condemned . Amay with this pernicious and presumptuous tenent , let the Church be your guide ; hear Her , Shee 's exposed to no illusions of self-conceipt , or of the wicked spirits , whose transfiguring themselves into angels of light she can discover , you cannot . They deny also that man can merit by his good Works ; a tenent evidently contrary to all places of scripture in which the word reward is extant : for merit and reward are correlatives ; they inferre one another : to say that Christ , amongst the other things he merited , merited also this , that mans good works ( done in relation to hi● passion , and in vertue of it ) should be meritorious , does not this more extoll Christs merits , and magnifie them more , than the negative opinion does ? many stupendious benefits , favors , and means for mans salvation Christ our Savior merited , & amongst the rest this . They deny Free will ( at least to do good ) in man : O imposture ! What 's this but a cloak for malice ; an occasion ( if not invitation , & allurement ) to sin ; and a stumbling block laid in the way , for all to break their necks over : this was a trick of Luthers and Calvins devising : who after they had shamefully fallen into some enormous sins of the fltsh ( as they did ) began to broach this doctrine , conformable to the lives they had begun , and intended to lead ; thereby to save themselves from the indeleable stain of sacriledge , Apostacy and infamy ; and because companions contribute to lessen the miseries of disgrace and dishonour , by how many the more there be that participate of them ; therefore they indeavoured by this hellish herefie to inveagle others to adhere to them . Many of them hold that the Commandements of God cannot possibly be kept , O blasphemy ! What 's this , but to impeach the divine Majesty of tyranny : Can that goodnesse , that infinite , wise , legislator impose laws under pain of damnations which are impossible to be kept ? stand astonisbed you heavens at this . And to omlt other their assertions dishonourable to Christian Religion , they hold that an act of Faith alone , works that great work of mans justification : that great change ( which the Prophet David cals the work of the right hand of him that is on high ) of a soul transferred from the state of being found guilty of mortal fin , and by it of eternal punishment , to the state of grace , divine adoption , and right to the eternal inheritance of the kingdom of heaven ; to attribute this stupendious effect to one act of faith alone , as the cause either efficient , or formall of it , is an incredible paradox ; yea , an impossibility ; besides the bad sequels which thence result : that by which a man is formally justified is justice , intrinsecally inherent in the soul ; to wit sanctifying grace ; and this is bestowed upon him for Christs justice , to wit his merits ; nor can Faith alone be the efficient cause of mans justification , or sanctification ; it is indeed a disposition , but so is fear , penance , hopes and an act of the love of God ; by which act the soul is much more unired to God , than by an act of Faith : of mans justification therefore , the efficient cause is God , the formall cause divine grace , and the meritory cause is Christ ; to wit , by his merits and passion . The bad sequels are many which that opinion of faith alone justifying brings : first , it hinders the exercise of many other vertues , much recommended unto us in the holy Scripture ; as filiall fear offending God , sorrow for having offended him , and good purposes of amendment : secondly , it is a great let and impediment to good Works , and the study of vertue : for if I can be satisfied and consequently saved , by producing one act of Faith only ; what need is there of spending my time , and taking pains to pray , fast , watch , do penance , give alms ? What need you take pains about self-denyal , carrying my Crosse , and following my Saviour by imitating his vertues , the three things he recommends unto us ; the practice of which , since that opinion hinders it , who does not see how pernicious it is : thirdly , it lays open a wide gate for all licenciousnesse , sin , and wickednesse ; for if with an act of faith onely , you can repair and redress all the misery which sin brings to my soul ; why should I not feed all my senses with their delightfull objects , follow the instinct of my flesh , give the bridle to my passions , and sacrifice my time , my body , my thoughts and my endeavours wholly to sensuality . Ah deer Redeemer ! Now I see the reason of that your pitifull complaint : Supra dorsum meum fabricaverunt peccatores ; upon my back sinners have built : I see who they are that insteed of carrying their crosses after you , and in imitation of you , build upon your back , and lay not onely all their obligations to Christian duties upon your sacred shoulders , by omitting them ; but heap sin upon sin ( by offending more freely ) and lay these upon you also : For what do they else , who under pretence of magnifying your merits , deny all merits of mans best works , by denying Freewill to do good , do no good ; & by extolling the ability of Faith alone , give occasion of remisnesse in vertue , of falling into vice , and of making shipwrack of all true faith . The fourth point . Consider now in order to a rectifying of thy judgement in matter of belief , and for the better managing of thy life , what may be inferred out of the precedent points , and amongst other things , first some peculiar differences , betwixt the Doctrine of Romane Catholicks , and that of Sectaries ; the one is most conformable to the holy Scriptures , and our Saviours doctrine and example ; the other is contrary to these : the ones Doctrine favours and honours the church of Christ , by teaching that which is most beseeming almighty God , and it : the other by attributing all to an act of faith , makes the Church an imperfect , yea , a needlesse thing ; for all the other priviledges and proprieties of it , as also the means it hath conducing to salvation , are superfluous , if an act onely of faith will do all . The one teacheth to fulfill both parts of Christian duty , ( decline from evil and do good ) and prescribes the means : the other gives occasion to sinne freely , and puts a barre against vertue : the one hath a pleasant taste at first , and seemingly rellisheth well , but in the operation proves rank poyson to the soul : the other seems harsh , and hath somewhat of the bitter in it , but in effect it proves a true cordiall ; the teachers of the one are those ( of whom our Saviour bids us beware ) that come in the sheeps cloathing of soft indulgent and condescending Doctrine , but the effects of it proves them to be interiourly ravenous wolves ; the others are like good shepherds ; who restrain , yet feed their sheep , and govern them well . In fine , the one doctrine leads to the narrow way , and strait gate which leads to life ; the other points out the broad way , and wide gate , which leads to perdition . Inferre secondly , that since these tenents of Sectaries , make many become Sensualists ; and Syren-like have a sweet sound pleasing to the ear ; yet destroy and kill : those therefore that desire to escape all danger , must imitate Ulisses , whose companions being inveigled by the charms of Circe , were metamorphosed into Hogs , ( an excellent Hieroglyphick of some Sects , and the effects they produce : ) but Ulisses himself by stopping his ears , miss'd the hearing of her bewitching voyce , and by that means got safe away . If you shun not the occasions of hearing bad language , and dangerous Doctrine ; Saint James his words ( He that loves danger shall perish therein ) will be verified in you . Where your eternal interest is concern'd , seek the greatest security and adhere to that Doctrine which most favours fanctity ; which the more you shall love , the more shall you resemble the holy of holies , Christ himself . The eighth Meditation . Of the Conversion of Nations by the efficacy of Doctrine . The first Point . COnsider first , how that the great Commander of the world in chief Christ Jesus , resolving to reduce into that one Kingdome of his Church , all those Nations , which the rebellious Princes of darknes had kept enthral'd in the slavery of infidelity ; for the effecting of this great designe ; first made choice of twelve men ( which he called his Apostles ) who were to be seconded by new supplies from time to time , till that great conquest were finished : the arms ( because the war was a spirituall one , in which souls were more looked after , and esteemed a greater booty , than bodies ) were to be such as that noble Champion Saint Paul gives us a list of : to wit , Verity for the sword belt or scarfe ; the breast plate justice ; the shield of faith , the helmet of salvation , and the sword was to be the word of God : this he calls the Armour of God. This word was the sword which was to doe the deed . Of this the same Saint Paul said , that the word of God was Efficacious , and more penetrating than any two edged sword : and of it our Saviour meant , when he said ; I will give you a mouth , and Wisdome , against which all your adversaries shall not be able to resist . And he expressed their Commission in these words : Goe , teach all Nations baptizing them . Consider secondly , what may be hence infer'd as undenyable . First , that efficacy of Doctrine , and the conversion of souls thereby , is a signe , and mark of Christs true Church : for at this aimed king David , when he said , that the Law of the Lord was not only immaculate , but converting soules . Secondly , that that Church was and is the true Church of Christ , which hath in all ages , and doth still prosecute the same work of converting soules . The second Point . Consider now the efficacy of the Roman Catholick doctrine . And first a priori , as from the cause . Mans intellective faculty aimes at truth , and seeks to perfect it selfe in the knowledge thereof , as being it 's naturall object ; and for the rationall appetite , the will , good is that which it hunts after . Now certaine it is that the Church of Rome teacheth the most noble , and sublime things , that can be studyed or conceived . Such are the nature of the Divine effence , and its perfections ; the eternall beatitude of man , and the most comfortable , and efficacious means to obtaine it , and how to remove the letts and impediments to the purchase of it . Add to these the excellency of Christs Church , and its holy Sacraments and Sacrifice , together with the doctrine contained in the Second point of the former meditation . And as for the verity of this Catholick doctrine , it is grounded upon the greatest authority that can be exacted , yea , or wished for ; to wit , the veracity of God , and the testimony of that Church , which undoubtedly deserves more credite , than any single person , or particular Sect in the world ; that is , the Church of the Roman Catholicks , dispersed over all the world ; Now , these things so great , and so beneficial to mans soul , established also by so unquestionable authority , how can they but move the will , that is , the rational appetite of man : the sensitive indeed ( a thing not more excellent in man , than in bruits ) finds the effects of Luther and Calvin's doctrine more agreeable to it : but speaking of the soul as rational , in loves that which is truly good ; Quid enim fortius desiderat anima quam veritatem ? As truly said Saint Austin , Tract , 26. in Joan. Consider secondly , the efficacy of this doctrine , à posteriori , or from its effects : the forcible attractivenesse of this converted all that have been converted : after the successefull labours of the Apostles , and Disciples of Christ , other Apostolicall men put for ward the work ; and amongst the first , was holy Pantenus , who converted many Indians : soon after which , the Scythians , Dacians , Nemians , and Morines ( of which Paulinus writeth ) were brought into the Church ; as also the Armenians and Hurmes , as Saint Hierom recounteth : In the fifth Age , the Scots were converted by Saint Palladius , a man born in Rome , and sent from Rome by Pope Celestine into Scotland , to preach the Faith of Christ to that Nation : This is recorded by Prosper , Bede , and Baronius ; soon after , Saint Remigius and Saint Vaus , authorized both by the same power of the Bishop of Rome , brought the French Nation to embrace the Catholick Faith ; at which time Clodoveus their King , received the first tincture of Christianity by being baprized by Saint Remigius . As for our own Nation England , ( whose the conversions patently convince these late Sects of Novelty and falshood ) the first time of its being enlightned by Christs Gospel , was in the Apostles time ; the second illustration of it was ; when Pope Eleutherius sent the men of God Fugatius and Damianas thither ; who baptized King Lucius , and converted his Subjects : And thirdly , it was totally converted , by whom ? By St. Austin , and his companions Justus , Mellitus , Laurence and others : Whence they ? From Rome : By whose order ? Saint Gregories the Pope : And here is matter for amazement , when a man reflects how ungratfully our English off-spring ( like an unnatural brood ) defiles the Nest from which it had its Christian Birth . O England ! remember the relation which is , or ought to be , between Rome and thee : Whence ariseth this aversion , and bitternes of many of thy children , apainst those supream Prelates , whose predecessor was once to thee a second Saviour ? Remember the dayes of old ; and return to thy self , and say ; Convert my soul , O Lord , for I have sinned against thee ; nor doe I deserve thee for my father , since I have been so disobedient to thy Church , my Mother . From Rome , and by order of that incomparable lover of our English Nation St. Gregory , came these men , who made England Catholick ; and so Catholick , that it from that time became able to make other Nations Catholick also : For the two Ewaldi brothers , ( commonly called Albus and Niger ) converted Westphaly ; Saint Willibrord converted Frizeland ; and Saint Boniface almost all Germany : These bleffed men were Monks , ( as S. Austin and his companions were ) by profession , English by Nation , and their Doctrine in all points , according to what the Roman Catholicks now teach . Now to passe further , multitudes of Spanyards , were converted by Andonius : the Flemmings by Saint Eligius ; those of Franconia by S. Kilian ; the Danes & Sweads by Ausgravius , the Bulgarians by Joanieius ; the Moravians by Withgumgus ; after these follows those of Russia , who were converted by means of the Emperour Basilius ; and the Polonians by Aegidius Tusculanus , sent thither for that end , by Pope John the 13. after these followed the Hungarians , brought in by holy Adelbert ; and the Sclavonians by an other Adelbert : to these succeeded the Pomeranians and those of Norway ; both which Nations were made Catholick by Nicholas the English Monk , a man of great vertue , who was afterwards chosen for Pope , and called Adrian the fourth ; to these may be added the Livonians and Li●uanians , the former of which were converted by Medardes , the later by the Knights of Saint Mary . All these Nations , in order as they are here specified , were converted by these men ( who were all Roman Catholicks ) to that very same faith , which the Roman Church now professeth : Nor were these all that were Converts of the Roman Catholicks ; the Tartarians with their Emperour Cassanes , were made members of that Church ; yea , and the great Turk Azatines embraced the same faith ; and of Jews and Sardzens , that blessed Saint Vincentius , a Dominican Friar converted 25 thousand to the same Catholick faith , not many years before Luthers time : and thus it is manifest , that the Doctrine of the Church of Rome is efficacious ; since by it Nations in all Ages have been converted from Infidelity to Christianity . The third Point . Consider first , what Nations ( Ethnicks or other non-Christians ) have been converted by Hereticks to Christianity , not any one ; in all these many Ages , from Christs time unto Luthers , not any one Sect converted so much as any one Kingdome , Country , or Province of Infidels to the faith of Christ ; yea , or to their own Sect : Take a view of the whole body of Ecclesiasticall history , and you shall not finde one : and this consideration alone , me thinks , might be a sufficient conviction of the fals-hood of all sects whatsoever ; and a confirmation of the truth of the Roman faith . Sectaries have labored much to bring some one instance in opposition to this so generall a Thesis ; and cite one Freculphus , who seems to say , that the Goths became of Pagans immediately Arians : Miserable Sectaries ! that can finde but one example to impugne the Papists withall , and in that one favour the condenmed Arians , thereby to oppose Catholichy : Yea , and this one instance is false also , as Master Southwel proves in his Analysis , out of S. Austin , Theodoret , Sozomenus , Orosius , Nicephorus , Baronius , and others . Consider secondly , what insidels have been converted to Christianity by Luther or Calvin , or any other Sectaries which succeeded them : name any one Pagan Nation , Province , or Town of their converting from paganisme to Christianisme , or even to any of their own Sects , he that can : And yet in the very dayes of Luther and Calvin , Roman Catholicks ( and those such as Sectaries hate , even for this every reason of their great zeal , to wit , Jesuits ) have converted many ; how many ? That one blessed Saint Francis Xaverius sent by the Pope of Rome , Paul the third , into the East Indies , to convert souls ; laboured there incessantly for the space of ten years , and converted three hundred thousand souls to the Christian Faith ; thus writes Bosius the Oratorian ; the same in effect writ many more : Nay , his signes of Apostleship struck astonishment , even into the enemies of Catholick Religion ; amongst whom Hackluit ( well versed in the Indian affairs ) cals him a godly Professor , the painfull Doctour of the Indian Nation , and one endued with all spirituall blessings : so true it is , that vertue and verity force their own praises even from enemies : Now if one man in ten years time converted 300000. how many hundred thousand may be converted in above a hundred years , not by one , but by many hundred of them , who are now there ( sent by the like authority , enabled with the like talents of vertue , and learning , and carried on with the same motives ) seeking most earnestly in Africa , America , India , and China , for those truly precious pearls ( immortall souls ) for the adorning of the heavenly Hierusalem , with what successe , you may learn of their great enemy and Protestant , Symon Lythus , who sayes , that the Jesuits have filled Asia , Africa , and America , with their Idols : How great a Panegyrist he proves by thus disparaging them , and their Religion , let prudence judge . Thus Luther and Calvin should have imployed the heat of their zeal in converting Ethnicks , as these others did ; who begun their work about the same time that they begun theirs ; and whom God raised up , ( as the greatest Prelate of the world upon occasion affirmed ) to oppose them : Had Luther and Calvin set forth for the Indies to propagatt Christianity , perhaps posferity would have preferred them before these ancient Heroes , which went to setch the golden Fleece : but ( as well said Tertullian of the old Hereticks , their sorefathers ) These mens work was not to convert Aliens to Jesus Christ , but to pervert his domesticks ; mark these words , Protestants : they drew indeed thousands from the practice of their antient ( yea the onely in Europe then extant ) Religion , and from the love of Chastity , Fasting , Consession , Pennance and Satisfaction for their sins , and from the love of good works and hatred of sin , to all licenciousnes and wicked liberty ; but this was to pervert , not to convert ; to this no efficacy of doctrine or divine grace was requisite ; any proposal or the least pretence was a sufficient alarum for frail people , to run after the maximes of liberty and sensuality ; to which self inclination carried them : It s easie going with the stream , or down bank ; but to clime up the mount of Christian persection , Hic labour , hoe opus est . The fourth Point . Consider lastly , what resultancies arise , and may be gathered out of these foregoing Points : Amongsts others , one is , that the Church of Rome hath been apparently visible in all ages : An other , that since Christ must have a true Church upon earth , and since one of the marks of it is ( appears by the scriptures ) conversion of Nations , by the doctrine : and since no other Sect hath this mark , the Church of Rome ( which hath alwayes had it ) must be , and is Christs true Church : a third , that when any are converted to the Roman church from insidelity or heresie , they amend their lives , and live more vertuously than before : But those that were Roman Catholicks , when they fall , and betake themselves to any other Sect , they grow worse and worse ; as we see it sals out by experience in almost every one that revolts from the Catholicks to any other Sect ; and the reason of this is clear , because liberty and temporall ends are their motive , not any quarrel they have against the probability and truth of the Catholick Tenents : If I stay with the Catholicks , I must not onely confesse my sins and be truly sorry for them ; but I must also seriously purpose amendment of my life , and repair what soever dammages my neighbours same or fortune have suffered by my malignant tongue , or fraudulent dealing : Wave these obligations , and go once to Church , and by this I may evade the misery of sequestration , and live free from sears ; siding with the Sect most countenanced , and cryed up , will secure me and mine : With such thoughts the wicked spirits inveagle those fraile ones , which ( like unto Fishes ) at first sight , lay hold on the bait , but mind not the hook ; no efficacy of doctrine moves such men : But thou , Rationalist , be thou led with motives grounded upon eternity ; and let that doctrine , which all Nations have experienced to be efficacious , finde no resistance in thee , and thou heavenly Physician ( who said that the healthfull had no need of such artists but the sick onely ) look upon the distempers of this distracted Nation in point of Religion : England , that when time was , lent Evangelical light to so many others , sits now in darknesse , and in the shadow of death ; but thou , who art the way , make her walk in thee : thou that art the truth , make her believe in thee ; that since thou art life , she may live in thee , till all Nations meet in the Unity of Faith , AMEN . Of the uninterrupted and Apostolical succession of the Pastors of the Church . The first Point . COnsider first , that as Christ our Saviour founded the Catholick Church , so as that it should last to the end of the world ; so also he ordained , that in it there should be lawfull Pastors , succeeding one another , so long as the Church was to continue ; this the scripture teacheth in expresse terms : He gave some Apostles , and some Prophets , and other some Evangelists , and other some Pastors and Doctors , to the consummation of the Saints , unto the work of the ministery , unto the edifying of the body of Christ , until we meet al in the unity of faith . Consider secondly , that this continued succession was to be propagated by a legall descent from Christs Apostles , both scripture and reason proves this truth : for if all true members of the Church , must ( like living stones ) be built upon the foundation of the Apostles , ( to the end that all the building fitly framed together , may grow unto a holy Temple in the Lord ) much more necessarily must the Pastors be built upon them ; and as that family ceases , & is extinguished , when once the line of descendents from the first of that family , is by death interrupted ; so the lineal ( but morall or politick ) descent of Pastors from the Apostles ceases and is extinct , when such an interruption is made , as that Pastors cease to have their spirituall birth to their Functions by that legitimate consecration and jurisdiction , which is derived from the Apostles ; the want of which also in the first of a new Episcopal See , illegitimate him and all his descendents ; now that this descent from the Apostles be legall , it requires a calling from God or Vocation ; No man takes to himself this honour , but he that is called of God , as Aaron was ; this vocation is the door , in at which every shepherd ( that is a true one ) must enter in to the sheepfold of Christs Church : for he that entreth not by the door into the sheepfold , but climbeth up some other may , the same is a thief & a robber , saies the good shepherd Christ : a severe césure for such as are not true Priests , and get into the Office of Pastors onely by self-intrusion , or by the deputation only of some secular power , devoid of all Ecclesiastical jurisdiction . Consider thirdly , the manner of this legall Calling , which Saint Paul sayes must be from God , as Aaron was ; divine calling , or vocation , is twofold , extraordinary , and ordinary : the former is , when God by himself immediately cals one , as he did the Prophets , Moses and the rest : and this extraordinary manner of calling was absolutely necessary in the first plantation of the Church : For the first Pastors , ( to wit the Apostles ) could not be called otherwise ; because they were the very first themselves . The Ordinary calling is also from God ; but not done by him immediatly , but by the concurrance of others : The first , of the line of those which were ordinarily called , was called after the extraordinary manner , by God immediately ; so was Aaron called ; but Aarons successors were ordained by others : so the Apostles ( who were called extraordinarily ) ordained other Bishops and Priests ; and these Bishops afterwards made others , according to the order prescribed by Christ , to be held in his Church ; and thus both vocations were truly from God. Now to understand the better what the lawfull calling of a true Bishop or Priest is ; and by this means , to be able the better to distinguish who are lawfull Pastors , and who not : Consider , these things ; first , the Election , or designation of the Person , and this belongs properly to Church men ; though the People , or secular Princes , have been sometimes permitted to depute , and propose to the Church such persons as they desired & thought sit ; but this makes not a man either Bishop or Priest : the next thing after Election or Approbation , is Consecration , or Ordination ; and this act is to be performed onely by Bishops : this act is it which makes a true Bishop or Priest ; and without this consecration , all the Princes of the world , by any their deputation of persons to Episcopall , or Priestly Function , can never make them true Bishops or Priests . The third thing is Jurisdiction , which is given by a Superiour Prelate to the Consecrated person , and this is called Mission ; for he is sent with faculties to govern souls , and feed them with the holy Sacraments , and the word of God. These faculties ( for so they are called ) are the Priests Commission ; and the giving of them with lesser , or greater limits , as also the assigning him these subjects in particular , and not others , is only in the hands of Spiritual Prelats , and in no temporall Princes power whatsoever . Gather out of the premisses ; First , that that Church cannot possibly be Christs Church which wants Bishops : Secondly that these are only true Bishops , and Priests ; who are lawfully descended from the Apostles : Thirdly that those only are legally descended from the Apostles , who have these two things , Succession , and Consecration ; both Apostolicke . A true Pastor must succeed to some one of the Apostles , ether immediatly , as Saint Liuus succeeded Saint Peter , and as Saint Policarpe succeeded Saint John : or else mediatly , as S. Ignatius succeeded S. Evodius , who was ordained Bishop by S. Peter : his Consecration also must be Aposto lick ; that is , this Priest must be consecrated by a Bishop , which Bishop must be consecrated by other Bishops , and these by others , till at length an assent by degrees be made up to the Apostles . Fourthly , that Spiritual dignity is of a far higher nature than temporal , both by reason of its lineal descent ( and that never interrupted ) from Christ ; as also by reason of its Function , which is about things Speritual and Divine . The second Point . To under stand how lawfully the pastors of the Church of Rome are called ; Consider first that the Protestants doe not stand in denial of this , but plainly grant it : yea they pretend for the lawfulnes of their own calling no greater argument then that they have their succession from the Church of Rome ; conscious , to wit , that there can be no true power , either of order , or Jurisdiction , nor any true legislative power Ecclesiasticall at all , but it must descend by succession from Christ , and his Apostles ; and this they acknowledge the Church of Rome to have ; pretending with all that themselves are united to the same line of Communication in that Apostolick succession . Consider secondly , this their lawfull calling confirmed by this Negative Argument : Christ must have , and hath a Visible Church upon earth somewhere ; this Church must have a Visible succession of Pastors ; for this is the main thing in which chiefly the visibility of the Church appears ; since where the succession of Pastors ceaseth , there the flock is lest ungoverned , unfed , exposed to dispersion and perishing ; and thus the Church would come to faile , not onely in visibility , but even in its existency : Now this Visible succession must be derived from the Apostles , and that without ever being interrupted ; otherwise the Church would not be Apostolick , ( contrary to the scripture , and the Nicene Creed ) nor remain the same unto the end of the world ; contrary to our Saviours promise , and St. Pauls forementioned words : And since there is not any sect which either doth or can with any shew of probability pretend to have a See Apostolick , or a never interrupted visible succession from the Apostles , but onely in the Church of Rome ; there it must be , and consequently their calling ( yea only theirs ) lawfull : True it is , the Greek Church had Apostolick Sees ; to wit , at Hierusalem , Antioch , and Alexandria ; each of which had an Apostle or Evangelist , for its first Bishop : but for the space of these last nine hundred years ( since the begining of which time , the Persians , Sarazens and Turks have kept possession of those Countries ) the succession in these hath been obscure , interrupted , as good as none : And this by the just judgement of God , for the Schisme and persidiousnes of the Greek Church ; as also to make the Roman See Apostolick , more clearly to appear to be the Mother and Mistress of all Churches . Consider thirdly , that the lawfull Calling of Pastors amongst the Roman Catholicks is , further positively demonstrable from the succession of their Popes . For the better understanding of which , note first , That the ancient Fathers were most exact in registering the names of the Popes , as they succeeded one another ; so did Saint Ireneus , Tertullian , Eusebius , S. Austin , S. Hierom and others ; the like diligence hath been used by other Roman Catholicks in all succeeding ages , even to this present Popes dayes , who is called Innocent the 10. and is the two hundred thirty and nine from S. Peter . Note secondly , that the forementioned holy Fathers , used to produce the succession of Popes , as an impregnable argument to prove that to be the onely true Religion , which had these chief Pastors on its side : Now if the succession of twenty or thirty of them , were of such force ( in the judgment of these learned Doctors ) to convince Hereticks ; how forcible an argument against these modern Sects , must a long Catalogue of 239 make . Note thirdly , that none were ever acknowledged by the Roman church for true and lawfull Bishops or Priests , but such as were ordained either immediately by the Apostles , or by their successors ; now conformablely to these truths , here noted ; this follows , and is most certain , that from every true Pri●st now living ( by passing from the Bishops which consecrated them , to those that ordained these , and so on upward ) a line of spiritual pedegree uninterruptedly ascends to the very Apostles . This orderly series or scale of succession proves evidently the Pastors of the Roman Religion to be lawfully called and sent . Here 's solidity , here 's security ; those that will get out of their labyrinths of errours , doubts , or fears , must do it by the conduct of this line : begin , go on ; this is your way to the Apostles and Christ . The third Point . Consider now , how the case stands with other Sects , in point of lawfull calling ; and first for Luther , the ringleader of all modern sects ; that his calling was not extraordinary , it is certain ; for he could never shew his extraordinary Commission , to wit , Miracles , the gist of Prophecy , or these other supernatuall endowments , which God alwayes gave to his Prophets and Apostles , whom he sent extraordinarily ; and that this exacting of Miracles in this case is most just and reasonable ; it is hence proved , if some new upstart should pretend he were immediately sent by God to preach against such or such a Sect ; the onely means that Sect could use for silencing and confuting such an one , were to demand Miracles of him : and if some new impostor should pretend he were Christ ; or urge his being sent extraordinarily to Preach against Christ , or any other mystery of Faith , which were believed by all Christians ( as the mystery of the Incarnation , or Passion , the reality of supernatural Faith , and divine grace , or the like ) against such a fictitious pretender , not onely Roman Catholicks , but all other Sects amongst Christians , also ought to bid him shew his Commission sealed with Miracles . As for Luthers ordinary calling ; true it is , he was lawfully ordained Priest by the Church of Rome ; but a Priest cannot ordain other Priests , much lesse Bishops : so that no succession could be propagated by him : It is true also , that he had jurisdiction ( which must flow from the spring head of all true ecclesiasticall jurisdiction , Christ and his Vicar ; and was lawfully sent ( after his being consecrated ) to govern and seed souls : but his faculties , or commission were given him with these limits and conditions , which not only the Ecclesiastical Prelat , but even sense and reason requires ; to wit , that he should use that power for the edification , and not to the destruction of that Church which gave him it ; that he should Preach and Teach her doctrine , that he should administer her Sacraments ; but he went beyond his Commission , yea , quite contrary to it ; he preached doctrine contradictory to that of the Church ; he taught her doctrine was false in many of the mainest points , and that her Sacraments were not so many , and so efficacious causes of grace , as they were ; he could have no commission for this : yea , his revolt and rebellion against the Church quite annull'd his former Commission ; and devested him of all the faculties which had been delegated formerly to him : as for Episcopacy , though some of his clients stiled him Bishop of Wittenberg , ( as Oecolampadius , whose Grave stone expresseth him the first Bishop of Basil , and Zuinglius of Tigur , and Calvin of Geneva ) yet neither he , nor these other ever gave out , or pretended they had Episeopall Consecration , or jurisdiction from the Roman Church or from any precedent Bishops : so that what they acted in this kinde was by a usurped power and invalid . Consider secondly , the calling of the English Ministry ; the Protestant titular Bishops urged alwayes against their Catholick Antagonists , that they were true Bishops : their proof was because they were consecrated by the old Catholick Bishops : Mark here ( for your comfort ) Catholicks ; that your Bishops , and by consequence your Priests , are acknowledged for true and lawfull , even by their adversaries : But you ( Protestants ) mark in order to your amendment , that this very means ( and the onely argument , by which they must prove , themselves lawful Bishops ) which they make use of to establish your cause , destroys it ; and with all confirms that the Roman Catholicks , are the onely true Church : For since that main thing which Christ gave his Church , ( to wit , power to ordain Bishops and Priests , and to send them to seed souls with the word of God , and the Sacraments ) is granted to be in the Church of Rome ; it follows evidently , that it is the true Church of Christ ; and that its doctrine and Sacraments are onely true : for Christ could not give that Church commission to Preach doctrin contrary to his ; nor could the Church ( which confessedly hath this power ) ordain others , and give them commission to Preach against it self : Hence also it followeth ( if these supposed Protestant Bishops were ordained by the old Catholick ones ) by going against their commission , and preaching and acting against that Church , which gave them their power ; first , that their former true commission ceased , and was annulled : Secondly , that Protestants and their Bishops were , and still are guilty of Schisme , by not holding communion with the Church of Rome , and thirdly , that they are guilty of heresie ( these Bishops and ministers , to wit ) in believing and teaching Doctrine contrary to the Roman Church , which they say , gave them their power . Fourthly , that they incurred the Ecclesiasticall censures , for the forementioned reasons , and consequently , could not give orders lawfully ; so that their Successors were not lawfully ordained . Fifthly , that since the Protestant Bishops , neither used the true form , nor matter , in the consecration of their later Bishops and Ministers , with which the first of them was supposed to have been consecrated with , by the old Catholick Bishops , even upon this score , the later were no true Bishops nor Priests . Sixthly , that since none can lawfully succeed in a Bishoprick , unlesse the former Bishop be either dead , or canonically deposed ; even upon this ground all the first of the Protestant Prelates were unlawfull ; because the old Bishops were living and not deposed , when the later usurped their Sees , or were intruded by others . But the truth is , these first Protestants took to themselves that Ecclesiastical honour , without being called by God , as Aaron was ; and took upon them the Office of preaching , without being sent ; contrary to the words of Saint Paul. It must not be presumed , but positively proved by them , that they were consecrated by the old true Bishops , and that they succeeded them legally : they must be able to prove , when , where , and by what Catholick Bishops they were consecrated , and what faculties and commission they had : All other Catholick Priests can demonstrate in behalf of their Apostolical calling , all these particular circumstances , but the Protestants could never yet prove their lawful calling thus ; and yet are obliged to do it , otherwise they are to be looked upon , as having got into the sheepfold , not by entring in at the doore , but by elimbing up another way . And indeed , the Catholicks urge ( which they are not liged to do ) very positive , and probable arguments to convince the Protestants unlawful calling , and that they had not any consecration or jurisdiction from them . For first , the Catholick Bishops , all of them absolutely refused to consecrate any of the Protestants , who seeing this , and not hoping to obtain it of them by proceeding in a fair way , aimed at the getting of it by underhand dealing ; but that good old and infirm Bishop ( of whom they thought to have taken orders , without discovering that they were Protestants ) having got some hints of their designe , rejected them : their next plot was the producing of a Register , in which were set down the names of divers Protestants , ordained Bishops by such , and such Catholick Prelates : but the forging and fraud of this Register , was soon laid open by the Catholick party ; and so that attempt ceased . The next Machine they moved , was by an Order from the Court , that so many Divines and Lawyers , should enter into consultation , and resolve whether some new form of making Clergy-men , might not be found out , without dependence of the Church of Rome ; but the ridiculousnesse of this adynaton , soon made that conventicle desist from proceeding further in that way : at length therefore , they resolved to ordain each other , without more ado ; which seven or eight of them ventured upon , all on one day , not after the ancient , Catholick manner , publickly and solemnly in the Church at high masse , and in the eyes of many hundreds of people , but privately in an Inne , and without any witnesses . And lastly , Queen Elisabeth and the Parliament , ordained that all who had the Queens Letters Patents for to be Bishops , should by the people be acknowledged for true Bishops , notwithstanding what soever defect might have happened in the consecration of them . Now these instances ( and particularly the last ) plainly intimate , that all was not well with these Protestant Bishops in point of lawfull calling . The fourth Point . Out of the precedent points many fruitful consequences may be gathered : and first , that that Sect which wants Pastors lawfully called , cannot possibly be the true Church of Christ . 2. That none can be lawfully called , unlesse they be consecrated by Bishops , lineally descended from the Apostles . 3. That since there must be a See Apostolick somewhere ( for otherwise , Apostolical succession cannot be derived down from age to age , till the world end , as the Scripture sayes it must ) and since there is no other but the See of Rome , which can with the least shew of probability , pretend to have a succession of Bishops , uninterruptedly continued from the Apostles time to these our dayes , the Romane See must be the Apostolick : this being so , as most assuredly it is , change that simister opinion ( you misled men ) which you have had of the Church of Rome , so long ; away with that contumelious language , with which you vilifie and slander it , lay aside passion and prejudice , then let the Romane Religion be paralell'd with any one , or all other Sects , and after your second thoughts upon this subject , you will assuredly frame a better conceipt of that so long continued , and so well grounded faith : Gather fourthly , that the Church of Rome , hath been alwayes visible , which is proved by its continuall succession of chief Pastors . Fifthly , that since Christ must have a Visible Church upon earth , and since no other but the Roman hath been visiblely conspicuous in all ages ; it must be Christs Church ; love it therefore , honour it , adhere to it . Sixthly , since there is no true religion without true Priesthood ; no true Priesthood without true consecration , and that by Bishops Apostolically descended ; and since there are none of those among these later sects ; what hopes , what comfort , what security ( yea , or probability ) of salvation amongst these ? O Chief Priest Christ , O thou , whom God hath anointed with the olye of gladnesse before thy fellows ; be thou ever blessed for sending them , as thy Father sent thee : be ever praised for giving that eternall Priest hood , according to the order of Melchisedech to them , which thy Father gave thee : Silence ( we beseech thee ) all false and lying prophets , that say ; the Lord saith , and the Lord hath not sent them , Send labourers into thy Vinyard ; and make the fruits of their labours many and great , to thy glory , Amen . The Tenth Meditation . Of Antiquity . The first Point . Consider first , that antiquity is a mark of Christs Church : this is most clear out of scripture , all those places in which the indefectibility and infallibility of the Church is foretold , promised or intimated ; prove also the Antiquity of it : And I will make this my covenant , saith the Lord my spirit , that is upon thee , and my words which I have put in thy mouth , shall not depart out of thy mouth , nor out of the mouth of thy seed , nor out of the mouth of thy seeds seed , from hence forth for ever . A most ample promise of the Churches antiquity and never failing : Vpon thy wals , O Hierusalem , have I set watchmen all the day and all the night for ever , they shall not be silent : These so significant words , cannot be verified upon the City of Hierusalem ( since it hath been destroyed ) but of Christs Church : Behold , I am with you all the dayes , even untill the consummation of the world ; most expresse words of our Saviour , who also said , That after the sower had sown good seed , then came the enemy and sowed cockle upon it : the good seed of Catholick doctrine was first sowen by Christ , and afterwards the devill sowed the cockle of false doctrine and heresie upon it . Confider secondly , the antiquity of Christs Church , gathered from other reason : And first its very names import thus much , it is called the Church of Christ ; because he founded it when in mortall flesh he conversed with men ; and therefore it would imply a contradiction to grant it to be Christs Church , and yet deny it antiquity : it is also called Catholick , not onely because it imbraceth all places , but all times also ; and it is called Apostolick , because it begun in the Apostles , retains their doctrine , and keeps their succession . 2. Reason , dictates to all , that truth is precedent in time to falshood , which is nothing else but a denyall of truth ; and consequently posteriour in time to it ; for the Father of lyes brought falshood into the world , when he tempted our first Parents , after their creation in the state of Grace and Knowledge of Truth , 3. The holy Fathers alwayes urged this mark of the antiquity of the Catholick Church , against the Novellismes of the Hereticks , and their comming after that the Church of Christ was begun : so did Saint Austin urge this mark against the Manicheans ; and Saint Hierom in his Epistle to Pammachius . Hence infer , first , that that Sect cannot possible be , yea or conceived to be Christs true Church , w ch begun in such or such a year after that Christs Church was instituted : Why ? because this posteriority of times argues diversity , which excludes identity . Secondly , that that sect cannot possibly be the true Church of Christ , which ( though it began in Christs , or his Apostles time ) yet hath not continued , but is now annihilated , and why ? because its antiquity ( which must not onely be derived from Christs time , but the same must also be , without interruption continued , till the worlds end ) is come to an end , Christs Church having still its being . The second point . Consider now the Antiquity of the Church of Rome , by which Church is understood , not onely that Congregation of the faithfull , which in the City of Rome , and the adjacent places , adhere to that Supream Bishop ; but all others also , dispersed , over all the earth , that are united to the Church of Rome , by the same belief , by communion in the same Sacraments , and by obedience to the same Supream head under Christ : the Antiquity therefore of this Church , is first demonstrated out of the Scripture it self . Saint Paul writ that famous Epistle of his , to the Church of Rome , in which he gives the members thereof many great Elogiums : To all that be in Rome , beloved of God , called Saints ; and again , your faith is spoken of throughout the whole world . When Saint Paul was come near to Rome , the faithful ( for even then , there were Christians at Rome , at Puteoli and thereabouts , before Saint Pauls coming thither ) went out of Rome to meet him and his fellow prisoners , as far as Appii forum : He began presently upon his arrival to preach ; ; in sine , he preached the faith of Christ in Rome , without any disturbance , for two whole years together . Of the Church of Rome , Saint Peter also makes mention , in these words , The Church which is in Babylon , salutes you : so that both the Antiquity ( and truth also ) of the Romane faith , is demonstrated out of Scripture . Consider secondly , the Antiquity of the Romane Church , continued , & conserved uninterrupted in all ages since its being founded in the Apostles time . First , at all times , in every age , there hath been apparent a visible body of Professours of the Roman faith , this is evinced clearly by that brief Catalogue of Saints , put down in the sixth Meditation ; as also by the never interrupted , Apostolick Succession of chief Pastors , treated in the preceding Meditation . 2. The faith and Doctrine , held now by the Church of Rome , accords most perfectly with the faith , and Doctrine of the Holy Fathers in all points : this truth hath been of purpose moved at large , by many learned writers , nor can Sectaries instance any one particular thing , w ch the Roman Catholicks now hold as a point of faith , which was not held by the Holy Fathers ; yea , every particular point is granted , even by Protestants themselves , to have been the Doctrine or practice of the holy Fathers . 3. Going out , or separation is specified in the Scripture , and by the holy Fathers , as a note of novelty , and heresie : now certain it is , that Sectaries could never assign any known time in which the Church of Rome , went out and separated it self from any Society of Christians , antienter than it self , and this they grant , which is a signe , it is the antiontest of all Churches still , and the only true . 4. Of all sects , of Hereticke , the beginning of them , withall the notable circumstances , is known & set down by writers : No known beginning since the Apostles time , of this Roman Religion , which now is extant , was ever mentioned by any authour whatsoever , nor can be ; and this the very Adverfaries grant , which is a sign , that it is the most antient of all Religions , and the very same , which was established in Rome , by the Apostles . 5. since all Sectaries grant , that the Romane Religion , remained truly Catholick and Orthodox , for many hundred years after the Apostles time ; it is , and must be granted by all , to be still the same , unlesse evidence ( and that convincing ) can be brought in against it , out of good and warrantable authours , when Rome lost its true Religion , in what point it did erre against its former true faith , who taught that false saith first , and what number adheard to it at first , who stood in opposition against it , who condemned it , and what body of people stuck still to the true Religion ( for Christs true Church , was still visible somewhere ) and to what countrey , or town did any of them repair , ( for Rome stood still for the Pope , and he in it ) to exercise the true Religion in ; certain it is , that most of all these circumstances would have been most exactly recorded , if any such thing had happened : that the Vicar of Christ should promulge an Heresie to be believed by the whole Church , and that the true Church , should lose its true faith ( which had been the greatest change , and strangest point of news that ever the world had heard of since Christs time ) and no one Authour at least recount the circumst-nces of that great wonder , is plainly incredible : especially since the particular points and passages of all other heresies , yea of all considerable points of news done in any Nation , are alwayes commended to posterity by some Writers , at least by some one : the deep silence of all kinde of Authors in this businesse , till Luthers time , condemns this wretched Apostata , ( and all that band against the Church of Rome , upon that ungrounded and impious supposition ) of deadly sin , of schisme , of Hesie ; and obligeth all ( whom invincible ignorance excuseth not ) under pain of the same sins , to return to the communion of the Church of Rome again . Ponder further the antiquity ( and consequently the verity of the Roman Church , upon this ground : She was once in possession ( yea for many ages ) of the honourable title of being the most ancient and true Church : Now this is her most just plea ; she hath still possession ( and melior est conditio possidentis ) of what her adversaries ( once her children ) grant was long hers by right : Now by what law ( surely neither by the civill nor natural ) can she be thrust out of possession ; since her adversaries ( who are the Plaintiffs in this unjust action ) can prove nothing against her ? Deniall serves the Defendant ; the other must positively prove that which they can never prove . Ponder lastly , the Antiquity of the Roman Catholick Religion , from the common sense , or consent of all people ; from which arose that phrase of the Vulgar sort , calling it the old Religion . All these considerations questionless convince , that the Roman Catholicks are the most antient , ( and consequently the true ) Religion ; for here the one infers the other : Si hi tacuerint lapides clamabunt ; if these arguments proclaim not with a voice loud enough the antiquity of the Roman Religion , the very stones will speak in its behalf ; all ancient monuments , even Gravestones and Church Windows ; all Abbies , Collegies , Churches , and Chappels ( of which many lye buried in their own ruines for this Religions sake ) and crosses ( now groveling upon the ground for their too much favouring the antient Religion ) are strong witnesses of this truth . Thou therefore that art wavering , and carried about with every winde of doctrine , harken to what the ancient of daies sayes to the of this ancient Religion : Stand in the wayes , and see , and inquire of the old paths , which is the good way , and walk therein . The third Point . To understand the better , that none but Roman Catholicks can justly pretend Apostolick antiquity ; consider , first that rule which S. Hierom gives , as a touch stone to try heresies by : to reduce an heresie to its first beginning , is to confute it : this is it , and it is well grounded in reason , and Saint Irenaeus before him used the same rule , and by it confuted the Valentineans and Marcionists . Consider secondly , this other proof of heresies novelty and salshood ; to wit , going out , and separation ; the scriptures make going out , a distinctive mark of Hereticks : Saint John speaking of Hereticks , sayes , They went out from us , 1 Jo. 2. 19. Saint Jude , sayes , These are they which segregate themselves . Jud. 19. Saint Paul sayes , Out of our own selves shall arise men speaking perverse things , to draw away disciples after themselves , Act. 20. 30. And the Apostles together in Councel , said , We have heard that certain going forth from us have troubled you , with words subverting your souls : Act. 15. 24. And our Saviour gave us all his expresse admonition against being seduced by Hereticks in these words ; Go ye not out : Mat. 24. 26. So that going out is a badge or character of an Heretick and Novelist . Hence inser , that since Berengarius , Waldo , Wyckliffe , Hus , Luther , Carolstadius , Peter Maryr , Bucer , Oecolampadius , Ochinus , Zuinglius , Calvin and Beza ( who had all been originally Rom●n Catholicks ) went out from that Church , they are convicted to be Novelists , Hereticks , and Schismaticks : and since both their going out of the Church of Rome is confessed by all , and easily made manifest ; even by this alone their heresies , are easily reduced to their first beginnings , and consequently according to Saint Hieromes rule confuted . As for Luther , who led the Van of all these troups of modern Sectaries , he in the year 1517. went out of the Church of Rome , and began a new sect : and in the year 1529. he and his adherent● gave to themselves & their own posterity the name of Protestants ; a name never heard of before : the occasion of the imposition of that new name was taken by their protesting against that decree , which was made against them at the Dyet in Germany . Luther was presently writ against , and confuted , by many learned men in all Catholick Countries ; his Doctrine and he were condemned first by Pope Leo the tenth , and afterward by the Councel of Trent : so that Luthers going out , and the beginning of his new Sect , are most certainly known , and recounted by many . Yea the falshood and novelty of Luthers doctrine , as also his going out of the Roman Church , and that the said Church of Rome is Christs true Church , is plainly demonstrated further by this thing , which is most worthy to be taken notice of : At that time when Luther began his new sect , there were not in the world any Religions but these ; the Roman , Paganisme , Judaisme , Mahometisme , the relicks of Nestorianisme in Greece , and some Hussites in Germany : some one of these was Christs true Church ; for he had a visible Church upon earth ; Therefore the Roman must be it ; for even the Lutherans deny that any of the other could be it . Hence infer , first , that Luther could not but know that he went out and separated himself from Christs Church , by forsaking all Churches , one of which he knew must be it : Secondly , that he could not but know that the Roman Church was it : thirdly , that supposing the Church of Rome were it ( which must be supposed , or else the denyers must say , Christ had no true Church upon earth , ) it could not be guilty of any Heresie or Idolatry , nor give any just cause to Luther of going out of it ; and consequently by his revolt from the communion of it , he incurred the sin of schisme ; by teaching doctrine contrary to it , he fell into the sin of heresie : Fourthly , that all that entered into that schismaticall league with him , and embraced his opinions , were guilty of the same sins ; so far forth as ignorance did not make their acts involuntary : Fifthly , that that schisme unlawfully begun by Luther , cannot be lawfully continued by others : and therefore all that are not Roman Catholicks expose themselves to evident danger of their souls , unless they return to the communion of the Roman Church . The fourth Point . Consider now , what may be drawn out of all the precedent points : first , that antiquity is not onely a mark of the true Church ; but it is one by which even the most ignorant soules may easily finde out , which is the true Church ; and which are late sects , and consequently false ; for a smal enquiry will bring them to the knowledge of which Religion is of the longest standing , and a far lesse will discover unto them which are of the latest ; for of Luther , above mention is made : Calvin begun at Geneva , anno 1538. and Protestant Religion in England begun under Queen Elizabeth ( though some symptoms of falling into it , were difcovered in her predecessor Edward the sixth his dayes , ) as is evident , out of John Stows Chronicle , and other Protestant Writers ; as also out of the Stature book : 2. That since according to Saint Austins rule , ( which is , that if there be any thing practised in the Church universally , and no time of its being introduced can be assigned ; that thing is to be supposed to have its first origin from the Apostles times ) no known beginning of the Roman Catholick Religion since the daies of the Apostles can be specified , it must be the true Religion : On the contrary , since both the going out from the Roman Church , and also the first beginnings of all later Sects are easily demonstrable ; none of these can be true or a soul saving Religion . 3. That all who are not Roman . Catholicks ( for these know it ) have great reason , yea are obliged , to inform themselves about the requisitenesse of antiquity in point of Religion : For by a neglect of this , they expose themselves to the danger of making an imprudent choice ; to the great prejudice of their soules , whereas a compliance with this obligation of searching after the antiquity of Religion , will bring them easily to a perfect insight into the defectivenesse and falshood of all , save only that Religion of the Roman Catholicks . Inquire therefore of the old paths , you who are out of that way , which your Ancestors held for above eight hundred years together in England , before Luther was born : you who have left the true worship of God , and sacrifice to the Idols of your own fancies , learn that lesson well which Moses reads to you : Do ye thus requite the Lord , O foolish people and unwise ? remember the dayes of old ; consider the years of many generations : ask thy Father , and he will shew thee ; thy Elders , and they will tell thee : What ? The ancient being , and truth of the Catholick Religion , and the non-entity of these late ones of our miserable times . The Eleventh Meditation . Of Unity . The first Point . Consider first , that the true Church of Christ is but one : The Scriptures , Councels , Fathers , History , and Reason , prove this truth ; imprint in thy minde the many divine Oracles , with which the true God of Wisdome hath confirmed this : One is my Dove , my perfect one ; Cant. 6. One God , one Faith , one Baptisme , one body , one spirit ; sayes Saint Paul , Ephes . 4. who also recommends to all Christians most earnestly , that they will stand fast in one spirit , with one minde : Phil. 1.27 . and that they will be like minded , having the same love , being of one accord , and one minde : Phil. 2.2 . in all which places , and many more , he exhorts to unity in Faith , Judgment , and opinion : Our Saviour every where speaks of his Church in the singular number ; ( tell the Church , upon this rock will I build my Church ! ) intimating thereby , it is but one : the General Councell of Nice and Constantinople ( received by Protestants ) define , and professe in their Creed , that the Catholick Church is but one ; the holy Fathers all unanimously fight for the unity of Christs Church against Hereticks and schismaticks ; and History delivers unto posterity , the continued succession of Popes Bishops , Priests , Doctours , Confessors , Virgins and Martyrs , for fifteen centuries of years together and more ; all whose lives , deaths , books and blood , have published , signed and sealed their attestations , that there is but one Church , the Roman Church , which is the Catholick Church . Consider secondly , and that seriously , what forces natural reason brings to establish this Unity ; verity it self is but one , and that indivisible ; and propositions contradictory cannot possibly be both true : how then can Sects , or Religions contradicting one another in one and the self same points , be more than one of them true ? Different Nations , people of different callings and qualities , may meet in conjunction together , and make one and the same body in Faith , and Religion ; as it happened in the Primitive Church : But different Sects , and People of a contrary beliefe about the self same material objects , or points of Faith ( for example about the real presence of Christs body in the Eucharist about Justification , about Purgatory , about the infallible Authority of the Church and such like ) cannot possible be both true , whilest they remain both contradictory : for that would destroy that Principle which naturall Reason dictates to all men , which is , that the same thing cannot be and not be at the same time : the same point cannot be true and false ; nor the Negative and Affirmative opinion about the same point both true and false together . Hence infer , First , that of all Sects and Opinions contradicting one another , there can be but one True. Make a search for this , finde it out , embrace it . Secondly , that this Unity of Faith and Religion requires ; that all the members belive all , and every one ( at least implicitly ) of the particular Points proposed by the true Church ; and disbelieve no one of them . Thirdly , that no other different sect is of the same church with Roman Catholicks . Fourthly , that those who call themselves Protestants , Presbiterians , Independants or the like , are not members of these Sects , unlesse they believe the same body of Articles : which since few of them doe ; nay nor so much as know what , or how many tenents are to be believed by them ; yea since there is no certaine number , or summe of points to be believed , in the same sence and meaning , amongst any of them ; let the world judge in what a lamantable condition thousands of these poor souls are . The second Point . Consider now the Vnity in all things belonging to Faith and Religion , which is amongst the Roman Catholicks : First the summe , or body of Articles amongst them is one , and the same , through the whol world ; these in these source classes or branches ( the Apostles creed , the Athanasian creed , the Nicen creed , and the profession of Faith decreed by the Counsel of Trent , and published by order of Pius the fourth Pope ) all what the Roman Catholicks believe is contained . Secondly , there is a most perfect Unity amongst them in believing what 's contained in the forementioned summe : the knowledge and explicit beliefe of which ( conformably to what was treated of this subject in the meditation of Faith ) is to be measured according to the capassity of the persons , and the things more or lesse sufficiently propounded to be believed : By reason of which two things , it fals out here ( as it cannot possible be otherwise in Christs Church whether this or some other be it ) that some know and believe more than others explicitly and distinctly ( which is not against true Unity , in believing all points of Faith ) yet the most ignorant and simple amongst the vulgar , are taught , and do believe the most important Points explicitly , and in particular ; and all the rest they believe in general , assenting to al whatsoever the Church believeth ; but they disbelieve no one thing : Now by believing in this manner , and disbelieve nothing , the simple ones embrace the whole summe of that faith ; as truly as the most learned doe : Now by this meanes every one of that Church believes all , every one believes the same ; every one knowes what is to be believed , and what the other members of that Church believe : no one amongst them disbelieves what the rest believe ; no one believes what the rest deny , no one denies what the rest professe : Now what greater Unity , either in the things to be believed , or in the Persons believing can be desired than this ? Consider secondly , the admirable Vnity and concord which is amongst the Roman Cotholicks , in all the other things which concerne their Religion . As for the Scriptures , they have all the world over the same Canon ; that is the same catalogue or nūber of divine books , with every chapter , line or verse , they have the same adition , to wit the vulgar , the which only they have bin accustomed almost since Saint Hieroms time , which is above twelve hundred years : they have all the same rule or way , and means for expounding it , to wit , the Church by the Pope , the general Counsels , and the holy Doctours ; and they have all the same sence and interpretation of it , in those hard places , which chiefty contain the Mysteries , and points of Faith : heer 's Unity indeed . As for the function of Preaching the word of God to the People , their Unity is wonderful ; all that are admited to that office ( for none takes it upon him on his owne accord ) have their Commission , and are sent either immediatly , or mediatly from one ; to wit the supream Bishop in the world , the Pope : and in the exercise of Preaching , no one of them teacheth different points of Faith , or teacheth otherwise of matters of Faith than the rest doe . As for Sacraments , they are in that point so united , that all of them unanimously hold there are seven , and that they were all of a divine Institution , and confer grace ; as for the manner of administrating the Sacraments , their rule and order , in that is the same in each several Nation : as for their form of worship , and Lyturgie ( which is Masse , most religious and majesticall every where ) their practice is most uniform : As for their Ceremonies ( great incitements to devotion ) they keep a great decorum in the use of them ; and that variety is not without great uniformity : and as for Prayer , as the Priests have every one a set portion of their breviary , to be recited every day ; so for the lay peoples comfort , and devotion , most excellent prayers ( and those many ) have been composed by that Church ; and the self same are used by all the members of that Church , where ever they reside in any part of the world : Nor are these Enthusiastes of our times for their prayer , extempore , to be compared with the Roman Catholicks , who perform that kinde of Prayer , both more discreetly , more frequently and more religiously : in fine , their Unity , and uniformity appears in the whole composure and carriage of their religious affairs : they have unity in their Fasts , and unity in their solemn Feasts ; which as they are proscribed for all , so are they observed by all : One chief Pastor hath a general care over them all ; one living judge of Controversies ( to wit , the Pope , and the general Councels ) gives a disinitive sentence , which is obeyed by all ; every one prayes for all ; and a mutuall participation of merits ( for each one of them may say with David : I am partaker with all that fear thee ) Psal . 116.63 . and the benefit of the communion of Saints , is both proper to each one , and common to them all . O most sweet harmony ! made by such Vnity , in so great a variety : here is nothing out of tune , no discords , nothing harsh , all parts conspire , all accord ; this is true Church musick indeed : but what wonder ? since this consort is made upon the ground or foundation of the Apostles and Prophets . The third Point . Consider now what Unity can be found amongst other Sects ; pick out the most probable , and plausible of them , from amongst the rest : will you finde it one , and uniform in all the particulars mentioned in the former Point ? no not in any one . None of these sects hath one and the same body of articles : some things ( as the Sacraments , Scripture , and that the twelve Articles were made by the Apostles ) they must believe , which are not expressed , either in Scripture or in the Creed : what , and how many these things were , they never yet resolved : nor do they agree in the meaning of the twelve Articles : they admit what latitude and liberty in believing they please : they neither agree about the Canon of Scripture ; for some admit parts of it , which others reject : nor have they one authentical Edition , but a multiplicity : nor one and the true sense ; but every one follows his own private interpretation : hence is it , that their Ministers cannot be unanimous , and preach all the same doctrine : they cannot agree about the number , or nature of the Sacraments : for some admit fewer , others more ; and these are instrumentall causes of grace , withsome bare elements with others : in form of worship , they come nearer a nullity than unity : for nothing now but a Psalm ( and that not liked of by many ) is used in most of the Churches : they have not one head of their Church , but are become Acephalist● ; or if otherwise , every man ( at least Minister ) when he pleaseth , makes himself head of a faith particular to himself , or his houshold : nor have they one ( yea , any ) judge of Controversies ; but in that every man is his own Master ; whence it cometh , that how many men , so many minds are there : even about going , or not to Church ( in which exteriour action alone , many place their whole Religion , without any regard , who preacheth , or what is his doctrine ) they are various ; so like it , others are aversed from it ; some go and others forbear : in fine , no uniformity , nor unity , but a kinde of multiformity appears even in the most famous Sects amongsts them ; which be it what it will , is more like that Proteus ( Hieroglyphick of each modern Sect ) metamorphising himself now into one shape , now into another , then any way resembles the perfectly one mysticall body of Christs true Church . The fourth Point . Out of these former points , gather , first , a perfect knowledge , and a lively apprehension of the far different condition of Roman Catholicks , from that of Sectaries in point of Religion ; the one hath an admirable Systema of Faith and Religion ; the other a confused Chaos of disagreeing fancies , and judgments onely : the one hath unity mixed with a most gratefull variety ; the other neither unity nor variety : the one hath a summe of things to be believed , which is one and the same for all persons and places ; the other hath nothing fixt or settled in point of belief . 2. Since the Roman Catholicks have in a most perfect manner this mark of Unity , so much mentioned in the holy Scriptures ; and no other sect hath any thing that is considerable of it : the former ought to be embraced by all , as the true Church of Christ , and the rest forsaken , as false and Heretical sects : 3. Since the substance of the two former points , parallel'd together , cannot but work strongly upon an impartial and disingaged judgment and will ; prosecute ( draw Christian soul ) this comparison with a desire of the truth , and thy souls good ; and at length thou wilt finde that onely the Roman Catholicks are that populus unius labii ; a people of one lip ; saying , and believing every one the same thing in matters of Religion and Faith : you will find that Saint Pauls exhortation to the Corinthians ( I beseech you that ye all speak the same thing , and that there be no schismes among you ; but that ye be perfectly knit together in the same mind , and in the same judgment ) is truly fulfilled by them . We acknowledge ( sweet Saviour ) that your amorous prayer to your heavenly for your Churches Unity ( Neither pray I for these ( Apostles of mine ) alone , but for them also which shall believe in me through their word ; that they all may be one ) we acknowledge that it was beard , and also is fulfilled by the members of the Roman Church , and by them onely ; and that in such manner , as forceth us to admire , and cry out with the Prophet O quàm bonum ac jucundum eft habitare fratres in unum , O how good and pleasant a thing it is , for brethren to dwell together in unity : Psal . 133.1 . The Twelfth Meditation . Of the Amplitude and extent of the Dominions of Christ Church . The first Point . COnsider first , the Predictions of the Prophets concerning the great extent and Amplitude of the kingdome of Christs Church : Of it said David , It shall rule from sea to sea ; Psal . 71 . To it spoke God , by the same Prophet , I will give unto thee Nations for thy Inheritance , and for thy possession the bounds of the earth : Psal . 2 . Of it spoke Esay , The Nation and kingdome which will not serve thee shall perish : Isa . 6 . And to it spoke the same , Kings shall be thy nursing Fathers , and Queens thy nursing Mothers , Isa . 49.23 . Upon which place the English Bible makes this glossa : Kings shall be converted to the Gospel , and bestow their power and authority , for the preservation of the Church : Daniel , also hath most strange Predictions , and representations of the greatnesse of the Kingdom of Christs Church , in the interpretation of the meaning of that statua ; and the same thing is prefigured in the four beasts , representing the same foure Monarchies ; after which the monarchy of Christs Church was to succeed and surpasse them all . Consider 2d . that since this kingdom of Christ ( whose great dominions are here promised & foretold ) must be now some where extant and visible upon earth : that Church ( whether it prove the Roman Catholick , or some other sect ) which hath not this Amplitude , salendour and greatness of limits and bounds , cannot be it ; but on the contrary , that to w ch most Nations , Kings and Princes have yeelded to , have honored & acknowledged for the kingdome of Christ , that must be and no other , Christs true Church . The second Point . Consider first , the amplitude of the Church of Rome , from that time ( to wit of Saint Gregory the great ) about which Sectaries say , it ceased to be any longer the true Church of Christ : for their imputations & aspersions , with which they endeavour to brand the Church of Rome , must be granted to be most unjust slanders , and it to be still the true Church , if this mark and the others attributed to Christs Church by the scriptures , be still apparent upon it . In the time of Saint Gregory , therefore almost all parts of the world obeyed the Church of Rome , and communicated with it ; this appears evidently by the Epistles of that holy Doctour to the Bishops both of the Orientall and Western Churches ; Constantinople with the other Patriarchal Seas obeyed then the Church of Rome : the Bishops of Greece yeelded to it ; to it the Churches of Asia , to it the Churches of Affrica submitted ; all these stood true to the Church of Rome ; and when they revolted from it , they fell not only into schisme , but into heresie also ( to wit , the deniall of divinity to the holy Ghost ) which is the ordinary sequel & punishment of schisme ( witnes England ) from the Church of Rome : and so by denying due Allegiance to that See , they became , by the judgments of God , to be made subject to the Turk . To the See of Rome therefore all these Nations in point of Religion were then subject : Adde to these Italy , Spain , Sicily , France , Scotland , and England ; which were all under the same obedience : After the death of that holy Pope , new Nations came in with their voluntary subjection to the Roman See apace : Flaunders , with the other Low Countryes and adjacent places , and Germany with its adherent Provinces ; and after these Denmark and Sweathland , Russia , Norway , Poland , Hungary and Transylvania : All these Kingdoms and Countries , with their Kings and Princes , became voluntary subjects to the See of Rome ; and so persisted many hundred years ; till Luthers licentious doctrine began to seduce Germany , and to give occasion of new heresies , and many revolts both from their tenporal Princes , their Spiritual Prelats , and their true and Antient Religion : Such is the nature of heresy . Consider secondly , how far the limits and bounds of the Roman Religion extend themselves in these our dayes ; all Italy , Venice , Sicily , Spaine , and Portugal , with many other adjacent Hands , are intirely Roman Catholick ; France ( excepting some places ) hath every Towne and Province of the same Religion ; of the seventeen Provinces , the far greater part , is intirely Catholicke ; and of Germany , more than three parts are Faithful professours of the same Roman Faith : as also of Poland , and Hungary ; add to these the many hundred thousands of Roman Catholicks mixt promiscuously amongst other Sectaries in England , Holland , Sweathland , Denmark , the revolted Townes in Germany , and Switzerland , and other the like places : And then Consider , whether this be not that mark of Magnitude , and far extended bounds promised by the Prophets to Christs Church . Let us passe further , And first into Affrica ; all which Simon Lathus the Protestant sayes , the Jesuits have filled with their Idols ; he means that they have planted the Roman Religion every where in it : From thence let us passe over the main Ocean every way ( and further then ever any earthly Empire went ) to the East Indies , to the west America , to the north in Japan , and to the south in Brasil ; and from thence into the furthest and vastest Kingdom in the world , China : into all these have the Roman Priests advanced the royal Standard of Christs Crosse : Fables ( which had the liberty to attribute to their Heroes , and Baccus , and Hercules , what feats and travails they pleased ) never fained so much as these men have really affected , in their extending the dominions of the Roman Faith : Caesar and Alexander , never went near where these are now Preaching Christianity ; nor had the old Roman Empire near so great Dimensions of longitude and latitude , as the Spiritual Empire of the Church of Rome now hath ; and it dayly gets ground , and continually dilates it selfe ; for these more then Herculean labourers , there find still plus ultra : O that our natives of England , were but spectators awhile of the infatigable and succesful labours , of these Roman Priests ; they would see in them most clearly these signa Apostolatus those signes of Apostle-ship , signes of truly Apostolical men ; which would make them have an other manner of opinion of them , and the Religion they all preach . But one thing more is most worthy of a mature consideration , and that is , that the Roman Catholicks in these foreign Nations , are not confined to a private exercise of their Religion , as Catholicks in England are ; but there are whole Townes , yea Countryes ( and those many ) intirely Catholick , and without any mixture of Infidels ; and in these there are Churches , many , and richly adorned ; and Collegies ( as at Goa , Mexico , and in many places besides ) in which the studies of Humanity , Philosophy , and Divinity are taught : And in this posture are Catholick affairs , in these many and vast Nations , converted to Christianity by Roman Priests . Hence we infer , that it was thee ( Rome ) and thy Faith , to which these large promisses of Nations , for thy inheritance were made ; for in thee only they have bin performed : And since the bounds of the earth are given to thee , who can deny but they were promissed to thee ? The third Point . Consider now , and make a survey of the greatest and most populous Sect , now extant in Europe : But if the distinction of Sects , be taken from the different body of Articles , or different number of points of Faith , as really it must ; there will be no proportion or degree of comparison , betwixt the Roman Catholicks and any one Sect left : For he that will hold that the number of Roman Catholicks in Holland or England , is as Copious , as any one sect ( taken according to this true distinction , of sect from sect ) in either Nation , holds a very probable opinion : But take all Sects now on foot amongst Christian Countries , & Conglobate them all into one by aggregation ; yet their dominions would not out reach , yea equalize the above mentioned bounds of the Roman Church ; Look upon the compendium of the earth , either the Map or Globe , and your eye will satisfy your understanding in this point . As for great Personages amongst Sectaries ; What , and how many Magnificent Benefactors hath any of these Sects or all together had ? As for the Religion of the , Roman Catholicks , Kings indeed hath been its nursing Fathers & Queens its nursing Mothers ; such were Constantine and Hellen , such were Lucius , Ethelbert , Inas , Ethelred , Oswald , Alfred , Edward and many others in England such were Lewis in France , Richardus in Spaine , Casimer in Poland , Stephen in Hungary , Wenceslaus in Bohemia , Canutus in Denmark , Henry and many of the house of Austria , in the Empire : In fine , such were Cimegundis , Blanch , the Elizabeths of Hungary , and Portingal , with many more of that sex . O royal souls , be ever Crowned with Glory , for managing your earthly Crownes so well , towards the maintaining of the Church of Christ : Well did you know , that to serve Christ was to reigne ; and that so to reigne , was the means to reigne eternally : The great ones which ruled where Sectaries swarmed ( such were the Duke of Saxony , the King of Denmark , Queen Elizabeth , the Palsgrave , the Landgrave of Hesse , the Prince of Orange , the King of Sweathland : ) what Universities , what Bishopricks , what Abbeyes , what Churches , Chappels and Altars , have they founded ? yea , rather what have they not destroyed ? Now confer dominions , parallel Princes , and compare Religions together ; and then chose according to equity and prudence . The fourth Point . Out of what hath been here handled , make these reflections , in order to thy Spiritual profit : First , that since large extent of limits , hath been promissed to Christs Church ; and since it is patently apparent that only the Roman Church hath this Amplitude ; none but it can be Christs true Church . Secondly , that since the Scriptures in the first point cited , ( with other places in Isay and Daniel ) as also the great promisses made by God to Abraham and Davids posterity , must be understood of Christs Church , as the Apostles and holy Doctours averre : What an argument of inveterate hatered is it against the Roman Church ( in which only these promisses are fulfiled ) to say ( as some body to their own shame , and their Auditory's injury have both said and preached ) that this Magnificency and greatnesse of the Romon Church , argues it to be the Kingdom of Antichrist : No , no : the Roman Church is thy Kingdom , ( Christ ) This collection of converted Nations , is that which was blessed in the seed of Abraham : This is that Kingdom , whose largenesse , and eternal duration Daniel fore-saw : this is that holy mount Sion , which David fore told Christ should be King of : Raigne therefore ( O King of Kings ) in this thy Kingdom for ever , Amen . The thirteenth Meditation . Of the name of Catholick . The first Point . Consider first , that this noble Surname Catholick , is one of the many Marks , which distinguish the true Church from every particular Sect of hereticks . The Apostles themselves , gave Christs Church this significant name ; for it is specified in that Article of our beliefe : I believe in the holy Catholick Church . The Counsel of Nice also in that Creed , puts this as a Mark of the true Church , together with the other three : Vnam , Sanctam , Catholicam & Apostolicam Ecclesiam . And the Athanasion Creed gives the true Faith the same honorable Appellation . Consider secondly , that the holy Fathers made use of this nam● Catholick ( amongst other marks ) thereby to prove against hereticks ; 1. that the Roman Church was the true Church , because it kept still that name . 2. That Hereticks were not members of the true Church ; because they were called not by this , but by some other name . 3. That they themselves were members of the true Church ; because they were members of that Church which had alwaies borne that name : For Saint Austin after that he had summ'd up many excellent marks and motives , which like forcible chaines held him in the Roman Church , and made him believe it was the true Church ; he thus concludes : Lastly the very name of Catholick holds me in this Church : thus argued he against the Manicheans . And Pacianus one of the Nicen Fathers sayes ; Christian is my name , and Catholick my surname . And Hereticks in all ages ( whom the modern sectaries imitate in this as in other things ) aimed at this name ( which they see was a mark of the true Church ) with hopes therby to conciliate to their doctrine an opinion of its being true , if they could get it christned by the name of Catholick . The second Point . Consider now , that this honorable name is theirs by right , and only theirs , who have and do adhear to the Church of Rome ; the reasons are : First , because ever since the Primative Church , they have held it as their birth-right , and part of that inheritance , which their Ancestors , the Apostles ( to whom they only succeeded as lawfull heires ) left them : And though many attempts have bin made , by heretical pretenders , to put them out of the possession of this ; yet they were never able to effect it : so that now the Roman Catholicks hold it , both by title of inheritance , and also by title of prescription ; not of years only , but ages . Secondly , it is the Roman Catholicks only ; because in them only is verified that which the name Catholick imports : The word Catholick is a Greek word , and it signifies Vniversal ; now this Universallity may be taken either with reference to time , or place , or doctrine , or communion , all and every one of these several acceptions pleads , yea and proves that title to be theirs who hold with the Roman Church ; for that Religion only stretcheth it selfe out to all times , by its Antiquity ; embraceth all Places by its Amplitude or extension of bounds ; its Faith and Doctrine is universally one , and the same for all persons ; and its communication betwixt the members and the head , is also universally one , and the same . Thirdly the generality of all sorts and Sects of people , have in all ages been of this minde ; and upon occasion expressed the same in words , that by Catholicks are meant those who are in communion with the Church of Rome . Fourthly , even the by-name Papist , proves them Catholicks : for by calling one Papist , they mean ( as really the word argues ) one who joines in communion with the Pope , and is under obedience to him : Now the Pope is one of that never interrupted line of Saint Peters successours ; and consequently chief pastor under Christ of the Catholick Church . Fiftly , the name of Roman-Catholick ( which every one willingly gives them ) proves the same that the former reason proves ; & the intention also which Sectaries have , in calling these Roman Catholicks , argues the same : for they do it , First to prevent Roman Catholicks from ingrosing the name Catholick wholy to themselves : Secondly , out of hopes that these will rest content , with the title of Roman Catholicks , and not impugne others when at any time they terme themselves Catholick , with some such restrictive adjective as Protestant , added to the word Catholick . The third Point . Consider and ponder , the reason why Sectaries have no right to that honorable and Antient appellation of Catholicks : The first is , because there is no congruity betwixt the signification of the word Catholick and any one of these sects , for they are not Universall in any of the four wayes mentioned in the former point ; much lesse in them all . Secondly , they can pretend no more why they should be called Catholicks , than the Donatists , Arians , or other Sects could formerly : which not withstanding were opposed and confuted in this very point , by Saint Austin , S. Hierom , Saint Chrysostom ; as also by Pacianus , S. Athanasius , S. Cyrill , and Justin . Thirdly , The practice of all sorts of people ( yea of those who are of the particular Sects themselves ) is to give Sectaries their names , either from the authors name , who first broached that Sect ; as the Arians , Pelagians , Donatists , Montanists , Manicheans , Lutherans , Calvenists and others : or , else from some principall Tenent which they maintain ; Hence the Monothelites , Protestants , Puritans , Independents , and Presbyterians have their names ; or from some exploit , or genious of the persons ; as the Iconaclasts , Geuses , Quakers : none ever gave these the name of Catholick . Fourthly , Sectaries do not , nor dare they own the name of Catholick at such times , as fidelity to their Religion most requires ; as first , when they are brought before any Justice , Judge , or Tribunal , either upon score of Religion , or to give evidence in Court upon any other action : true it is , in time of disputation about the name Catholick , who should have the best title to it ; then being constrained by their Adversaries to a forc't put , and positive answer to the question ; they will let fall these , or the like propositions ; we are Catholicks as well as you ; we are all Catholicks ; all Christians are Catholicks : ungroundedly spoken , and sooner said than proved ; unlesse taking the question for the argument be good proof . In like manner , when any Protestant , Presbyterian , Independent , or the like ( being about to die ) is desired to declare himself in point of Religion ; he will not say thus ; I die a Catholick , for the spectatours and auditours would immediately conclude that he dyed a Papist ; but he would declare himself thus : I die a Protestant , Presbyterian , or the like ; or I die a member of the Church of England ; which is in effect to say , he dies a Protestant : and thus the titular Archbishop of Canterburie Mr. Laud and some other great Personages that died the same death , before and after him , declared themselves , at that instant , which was both most unseasonable for dissembling , and at which period a man should be serious , if ever ; and yet these great Persons , to hold an argument , whilest they were in discourse upon who had the best claim to the honourable title of Catholick , would undoubtedly have stood for it themselves . The fourth Point . Out of these former points make these ensuing reflections : first , that the name Catholick is , and hath been alwayes esteemed by venerable antiquity , a mark of the true Church ; yea even Sectaries alwayes esteemed it so , & upon that account would somtimes challenge it , thereby to Patronize and vent their new fashioned Religions the sooner . 2. That those who desire to be accounted Catholicks by all Sects and sorts of people ; yea , and ( which is better ) by God himself ; must joyn with those whom they call Roman Catholicks , in the same Belief , Communion and obedience , to the spiritual Prelates . 3. That the denominations of Catholick , Papist , or Roman Catholick , are in substance all one thing , and as it were termini convertibiles , or synonima . Now to the ●nd a man may be saved , since it is not sufficient to bear onely the extrinsecall appellation of a Catholick , but he must lead a life conformable to that name and Religion : therefore , Grant ( good Lord ) a large contribution of thy grace , both to all aliens from thy Church , that they may become members of it ; and to those also who are adopted into that honourable family already , that they may speake by a good life what they professe in their belief . Amen . The fourteenth Meditation . Of the Gift of Prophecy . The first Point . FOr a perfect information , and understanding of this truth , that the priviledge of prophesying is a mark of Christs Church ; Consider first the infallible testimony of Gods word ; Your sons and your daughters shall prophecy , and your young men shall see visions , Joel 2. Behold Gods promise by his Prophet : and that this was made to the Church of Christ , witnesse the Prince of the Apostles Saint Peter ; who cites these very words of Joel , Acts 2. to prove what 's here intended : Nor is Saint Paul inferiour to Saint Peter in the proof of this point : for in his induction of the graces given to the Church Gratis , he ranks the gift of Prophesie amongst the rest : so that no doubt can be made of this truth . Consider secondly , the excellency of this endowment , and how sufficiently able it is to notifie unto us which is the true Church : Prophets are called videntes , by reason of that kind of intuitive knowledge which they have of future things , not as at a distance onely , but as actually present ; they need no such window in mans breasts , as that momus wished for , thereby to see into mens hearts : they anticipate what the succession of time brings to others ; and the celestiall secrets which others have from the second or third hand , they have them immediately from the divine Wisdom ; and certainly the knowledge of future things contingent is not attainable either by the nature or art of man ; it can only be had from God : and who have it , may deservedly be held for great correspondents with him : and this truth is expressed to the full in these words following : Declare the things that are to come , and we shall know that ye are Gods : Isa . 41. Now if these by this gift of Prophesie become as it were Gods , or men of God : certainly that must be the Church of God , which is highly endowed with the same gift . The second point . Consider now how eminent the Roman Church hath been at all times in this point ; and to say nothing of the predictions of Saint Gregory Thaumaturgus , mentioned by Saint Basil , in his book of the Holy Ghost cap. 29. Of Saint Anthony , recounted by Saint Athanasius , the Writer of his Life : of the Abbot John , of whom Saint Austin in in his Book of the City of God , makes honourable mention , cap. 26. And to passe with silence the Saints of the Primitive Church famous in this kinde ; we will come to those times , and persons , which Protestants themselves acknowledge for papistical ; the argument will be the stronger by this supposition . Saint Benedict , the spiritual Father of many thousand Monks , amongst his other strange Prophesies , foretold Totilas King of the Goths , that he should enter the City of Rome , then crosse the Seas homeward , and that he should depart this life , after the period of nine years should be expired : all these things Saint Gregory sayes , he knew to have been effected , Lib. 2. dial . c. 25. Saint Cuthbert foretold the totall rout of Egfrid King of the Northumbers his Army , by the Picts , and the Kings death amongst the rest in the field ; and this the year before it hapened ; and the next year , upon the approach of the time , and a disaster prenunciated , he went on purpose to Carlile to comfort the Queen , Egfrids wife , and to be with her against that fatall day : there in spirit he saw the whole tragedy , as it was acted a far off in the Country of the Picts , and related the same to the Queen : the same Saint foretold his own Election to be Bishop , with the time when , and other circumstances : he foretold his own departure out of this life , to the holy Ermit Herebert ; who earnestly requesting the Saint , that he would negotiate with the divine Majesty for his passage together with his ; presently the Saint replyed , that his petition was granted ; and indeed one and the same day carried them both out of this mortal life together : He foretold ( but with the qualifying particle perhaps , out of his humility ) that after his death men should have recourse to his body , as to an asylum ; it proved so , and that for the space of eight hundred and forty years : These predictions with many more , Venerable Bede recounts in a particular Book ( extant in his Tomes ) of S. Cuthberts life . King Edward the Confessor ( whilest he was hearing Mass upon Whitsunday ) saw the King of Denmark fall into the Sea ( as he was going out of a Long-boat into the Admiral ) and drown ; by which accident that his intended invasion of England with that Navy was spoiled . Saint Hugh Bishop of Lincolne ( whilst he was yet Prior of the Charterhouse Monks at Witham ) next under God delivered King Henry the second , out of a dangerous Tempest at Sea : for that King in that great danger had most earnestly wished for the assistance of Saint Hugh his prayers ; immediately upon which the fearfull storm ceased , to the great astonishment of the King , and increase of his reverent respect to the man of God. Saint Bernard being requested by a Noble mans son , that he would pray for the conversion of his Father , returned him this answer : be not perplexed ; be not perlexed , I shall bury him in this Monastery of Clarevall a perfect Monk ; and so it fell out : he foretold also the conversions of foure more . Saint Francis foretold the Captains of the Christian Army , that if they gave the Sarazens battail upon their intended day , they should loose the field : they took little notice of the holy mans Caveat , ingaged with the enemy , and were defeated . Saint Dominick , falling sick at Bolonia , called for the Religious Fryars of the Convent there ; and exhorting them to the study of perfection , told them he should die of that sicknesse ; and yet it was far from mortal then . Saint Ignatius , founder of the order of the ●ociety of Jesus , foretold that Francis Borgia , then Duke of Gandia , should forsake the world , become religious , and General of the forementioned order : so he died ; and is now beautisied . Hence infer that the Roman Church is highly priviledged with this Prerogative , and gift of prophesie ; for these blessed men are known by all to have lived and dyed Roman Catholicks : As for the Writers of their lives , or Prophesies , Saint Athanasius , S. Austin , S. Gregory , Venerable Bede , S. Bonaventure and other Authors of known fidelity ; with what face can they be suspected either of feigning or recountting these things without an assured knowledge of the truth of them . The third Point . Consider first , ( for prevention of objections against the gift of prophesies being an argument , that the Roman Church is the true Church ) that though God may , or have revealed things to come by persons not known to be of the true Church , or in his favours ; as he did by Balaam Number 24. v. 17. foretell the Star which appeared at our Saviours birth ; and by the Sybils , whose acrostick Poem is full of most clear predictions about our Saviour : Yet he will never permit a thing contingent to be foretold , and fulfilled , in confirmation of a fals religion : Besides , this makes nothing against the intent of this Meditation ; which is to shew , first , that the gift of prophesie is a mark of Christs true Church ; and this is proved by scripture : 2. That this gift is found to be eminent in the Roman Church ; and so it appears evidently proved in this point going before : 3. That that Sect cannot possibly be the true Church , which is destitute of this gift ; because it wants this mark , which is inseparable from the true Church : for the Negative here ( as in all other marks ) admits no latitude ; but excludes all sects devoid of these marks , from possibility of being the true Church : and to understand how truly Sectaries are destitute of the gift of Prophesie . Consider secondly , that in reall truth they could never instance any particular Prophesies , delivered by members of their Sects in confirmation of their doctrine ; nor indeed have they any person endowed with the gift of any true prophesie at all : True it is , that Luther prophesied once , that if he lived but to preach his doctrine two years longer , the Pope , Cardinals , Bishops , Monks , Nuns , Towers , Bels , and Masses , would all vanish away : he preached afterwards , according to his manner , not onely two years , but almost twenty two ; yet these things are al extant ; none of them vanished : hence infer that Luther proved himself a false prophet by this , and his doctrine false : according to what is Writ in Deuteronomy , cap. 18. of false prophets : and that of Jeremy : Thy Prophets ( England ) have seen false and foolish things , Lam. 2. Calvin , indeed prognosticated more truly , ( but to the destruction of his own Sect ) in these words : Concerning posterity I am so anxious , that I dare not think of it ; for unlesse God send marvellous succour from heaven , I seem to see extream barbarousnesse hang over the world : and I pray God our children may not erelong feel , that this is rather a prophesie than a conjecture : Thou hadst had ( Calvin ) no need of such fear , if thy sect had been that Church , which Christ built upon that rock ; for the gates of Hell would not have been able to prevail against it : But conformably to what Gamaliel said ; since thine is the work of man ; thy prophesie will be accomplished ; it will come to nothing : And he that will apply to the Protestant ( what Hooker appropriated to the Puritan ) King Davids words of the life of man , and withall summon up the years betwixt the establishing of Protestant Religion by Queen Elizabeths Parliament , and the abolishing of the same , by this late parliament : will sinde a kinde of prophesie of the ruine of it , in these the royal prophets words : The dayes of our years are threescore years and ten ; and if by reason of of strength they be fourscore years , yet is their strength labour and sorrow ; for it is soon cut off : Psal . 90. Thus speaks the Protestant Bible , and thus out of this point it appears , that Sectaries have not that gift of prophesie , which is promised by scripture to Christs Church , as a mark of it . The fifteenth Meditation . Of Easie decision of Controversies . The first Point . COnsider first , what means the divine wisdome provided the Jewish religion with , in order to deciding of Controversies amongst them . In Deuteronomy 17. God declared in expresse terms many particulars concerning this matter : and first he appoints for judge of the hardest controversies , not the scripture , as Sectaries doe ; but the Priests , ( a living judge ) and particularly the chief Priest . Secondly , he commands all to stand to the definitive sentence of that judge , even upon pain of death , v. 12. And thirdly , he promiseth that that judges definition , verdict and decree , shall be infallibly true , v. 9 , 10 , 11. but particularly in these words : He shall shew thee the truth of judgement , judicii veritatem ; which words in the Protestant Bible are falsly translated ; the sentence of judgement . Consider secondly , the necessity of a living judge : No form of Government ( be it Monareby , Aristocracy , or Democracy ) can subsist in an orderly being without it : No suit either in Civil , or Canon Law , no action of debt , or dammage can come to a tryal , no sentence can be passed upon any person , or cause , without the voice of a living judge ; two Counsellors cannot without a Judge , as Umpire , put a final period to any one cause ( for example in the Court of Chancery ) so , as that both parties shall understand , and acknowledge it to be decided : much lesse will the Plaintiffe and Defendant end their quarrell by themselves alone , without a Judge ; for each one would still plead for himself : the dead letters of the written law can never sufficiently expound either the legislatours mind , or it is own meaning : nor shal men at any time understand by it alone who is cast , who hath got the better : in fine , all injustices and outrages , would be committed ; and no malefactours punished , without a living judge ; and that such an one , as from whose sentence , there is no appeal : Now if these instances prove ( as they do most effectually ) the requisitnesse of a living judge , for the upholding of all true civill judicature and government : much more is a living judge necessary in ecclesiasticall ; in which matters of Faith and Religion , and consequently of eternal moment , are to be tryed . The second Point . To understand how easie and efficacious means the true Church of Christ hath for the composing of Controversies : Consider first , that it belongs to the divine providence ( which extends it selfe to a care over every the least individuum of the most contemptible species amongst natural things ) not to let his Church want any thing of those which are required ad melius esse , much more to supply it with what 's absolutely necessary ; as means clear and easie for the judging of Controversies is . Secondly , what perfection the Jewish Synagogue had in this kinde , that à fortiori , is to be supposed in Christs Church ; for it was but the handmaid , this the Spouse ; if the shaddow , this the Sun ; if the type , this the reall thing prefigured ; if it had a living judge , an infallible judge ( who was to shew the truth of judgment ) and a judge to whose final sentence that people was to stand , upon pain of death : shall the Church of Christ ( in which the most weighty controversies of divine Faith and eternal salvation , are raised every foot by Hereticks ) want such means ? Assuredly no. Consider thirdly , the many Texts of Scripture ( yea and as clear in the confirmation of this , as of any point whatsoever ) by which the Church of Christ is impowred with an infallible authority for deciding Controversies , even of the highest nature : All power is given to me in heaven and in earth ; goe ye therefore and teach all Nations , Mat. 28. in which words , the emphasis of that particle theresore intimateth , that a powerfull Commission was given them , and consequently of teaching without danger of erring ; and that it was not given to them onely , but also to their successors , the ensuing words ( Behold I am with you alwayes , even unto the end of the world , Luke 10. ) Convince , He that beareth you , beareth me ; and be that despiseth you , despiseth me : If he will not hear the Church , let him be to thee as a heathen and Publican : Matt. 18.17 . Our Saviour sayes of his Church , that the gates of hell shall not prevail against it : Mat. 16. And he sayes in most significant words that the holy Ghost shall teach the Church all truth , Jo. 16. O divine spirit , since you cannot but perform ( what our Saviour promised ) this teaching of the Church all truth ; what do they deserve that accuse it of truth ? And indeed either the verity of Christs promise , or the fidelity of the holy Ghosts performance , is questioned when the true Churches Infallible Authority is doubted of , or its erring avouched . The third Point . Consider now , that since the true Church of Christ ( where ever it be now ) hath his infallible power of resolving all doubts in matters of Faith ; as the forementioned places of scripture ( besides many more ) confirm : and since some one of the various religions now extant in the world must be Christs true Church , and have this power ; for still there is a Church , and it the Ground and Pillar of Truth , Tim. 1.3 . let us see what Church sympathizeth best , or rather is ( as some one must be ) identified with Christs true Church in this point , and by good consequence in all others . First , therefore this infallible judge , and composer of all controversies in Christs Church formerly , could be no other , than either the head of it , or some representative body of the Church , or both joyntly together ; no other means of having a living judge can more probably , yea or possibly be affigned ; for all the mombers of the church , men , women & children cannot be collected together into one consult ; we see also that a Parliament , in w ch some one is president above the is the representative body of a Kingdom , or Common wealth : and what it ( being a law full one ) acts , is the act of the whole Nation : we know more over , that in the primitive Church this judge was no other , but such an one as is here intended , to wit , the chief pastor and head of the Church , or a General Councel , or both ; and by such a judge was Arius condemned , to wit , by the Councel of Nice , in which Hosius ( Bishop of Corduba in Spain ) was Presidentin the place of Pope Silvester , who sent him and confirmed the acts of that Councel : So was Macedonius condemned in the first Councel of Constantinople : So Nestorius in the Ephesine Councel : so Eutiches in the Councel of Calcedon : so in all suceeding ages , Controversies ( as they rise ) were decided , and Hereticks condemned after the foresaid manner : therefore that living judge , so necessary , must be such an one . Consider secondly , that the same praxis hath alwayes been held in the Roman Church , and is held still ; eighteen general Councels have been called and confirmed by the supream Bishops or Popes of Rome ; the first whereof was the Nicene Councel , and the last the Councel of Trent , in which sate six Cardinalls , four Legates , three Patriarks , thirty two Archbishops , and Bishops two hundred and twenty eight , besides Abbots , Generals of Religious orders , and a great number of divines , sent by such Bishops , as for infirmity , or other just reasons , could not be present : And that this Councell was not of as great Authority as any of the first four were , can never be proved ; all that can be urged against this Councell , must be grounded upon that false , and ungrounded ( but dreadfull , fince all Sectaries venter their salvation upon , on the same ) supposition , that the Roman Church hath fallen from the true and Primitive Faith. Prove this your supposition ( you miserable men ) which you could never yet prove , or be converted ; or loose your souls ; of which you run a most desperate hazard , by forsaking that Church ( which is acknowledged by your selves to have been once the true Church ) meerly upon Luthers hare word that it hath lost the true faith . Consider thirdly , that since there is no other Church now in the world ; but the Roman Church , which holds the same way and manner of deciding controversies which the Primitivs church held ; nay , nor hath any means to procure such a judge ( for want of a head , to call and confirm a Generall Councel , and Bishops to consult , enact , and see that the inferiour Pastours put in execution what was enacted ) Hence it follows , that the Roman Church is the onely true Church of Christ . The fourth Point . Consider lastly , that since Sectaries reject the authority of the Popes , nor can have General Councels , and consequently no living judge ; they must fly either to scripture alone , or to the private spirit . As for the scripture ; first , it cannot perform the Office of a Judge ; which is clearly to pronounce sentence , so that both parties which contest about the thing controverted may understand and acknowledge who is cast , who hath got the better . 2. There is a difference betwixt the written laws , and the judge in civill matters ; the one is the rule acording to which the judg must give sentence ; but the other ( to wit the judge ) must give the sentence ; he is the mouth of the law , and must interpret its , land the legislatours mind : now the same Analogy and comparison holds betwixt the holy scripture ( and the written law of God ) and the ecclesiastical judge . 3. About the scriture it self , arise many controversies , which have been long agitated to and fro ; as what Books are Canonical , which Apocriphal ; the Roman Catholicks say the books of Judith , Toby , Wisdome , Ecclesiasticus , the first and second of the Macchabees , are canonicall scripture ; the Protestants deny them to be so : Now , how shall this great controversie be decided : the scripture cannot give sentence , for it hath not a living voice ; in like manner , about the sense and meaning of many places of the canonical scriptures , many long quarels have been amongst different Sectaries themselves , and betwixt them and Roman Catholicks ; the scripture it self can never compose these controversies , for want of a living voice . 4 The old Hereticks had never been convinced , nor condemned , i● the scripture had been appointed for judge : for still they wou'd have had evasions ; the scripture neither did , nor could give sentence against them ; but the Church , by the Pope and General Councels . As for the private spirit , this must either be supposed to be an infallible judge , or not , if not ; Sectaries can never have their controversies truly decided ; for this judge may erre , give a false resolution , and so expose poore soules to an evident danger of frequently believing that to be a point of divine Faith , which is not so ; or the contrary : If infallible , what shameful presumption will it be , to challenge to your own particular person such an assistance of the Holy Ghost , as by it you shall infallibly judge a right , in whatsoever point of Controversie ; and yet deny this to the whol body of the Roman Church . 2. The question is , whether that private spirit be the holy Ghost , or a wicked spirit , or your own spirit , to wit , your own judgment , or fancy : How shall this question be determined ? O miserably misled souls , of such Sectaries ; do you not see in what labyrinths of errours , and miseries you wilfully involve your selves ? Is not this to walk in a circle , like the wicked ? But since you will be so heare the word of the Lord , Wo be to the foolish Prophets , who follow their own spirit : Ezcek 13. Mark these words well , and amend ; least your folly in following your own spirit bring you to eternal wo. But O thou infinite goodnesse , God , send forth thy ( pirit ; that these deluded souls may become new creatures : make them members of that Church , to which only the spirit of truth teacheth all truth , Amen . The sixteenth Meditation . Of Persecution and Martyrdom . The first Point . COnsider the many and clear Texts of the holy scripture , in which our Saviour doth denunciate to his Apostles and Disciples , and in them to the succeeding members of his church , that for their professing , and propagating of his faith , they shall undergo persecutions of all forts ; yea , death it self . Beware of men , for they will deliver you up to the Councels ; and ye shal be brought before Governours , and Kings , for my sake ; Mat. 10.17 , 18. And ye shall be bated of all men for my name sake , v. 22. But when they persecute you in this City , fly into another : v. 23. The time cometh , that who soever killeth you , will think be doth God service : Matt. 16.2 . They shall lay hands on you , & persecute you , delivering you up to the Synagogues , and into prisons , Luke 21. v. 12. And some of you they shall cause to be put to death . v. 16. Gather hence , first , that God permits ( for he could hinder it , if it pleased him ) his Church to be persecuted ; to wit by the Devil and his Emissaries , wicked men . Secondly , that persecution is a mark of Christs Church , and much more martyrdome : Thirdly , that to fly in time of persecution is lawfull ; till God dispose the circumstances for their sufferings . The second Point . Consider first , that what our Saviour foretold , begun soon to be verificd ; of men that persecuted Christs church , the Jews , Pagan Princes & hereticks are the chief . The Jews not onely persecuted Christ ( whom they hanged on a crosse ) and his Apostles and Disciples , before his Passion ; but after his sacred death , they were most bitter and violent against the young flock of his church ; as may be read in the Acts of the Aposeles ; yea their sacrilegious and savage handling , and abusing the blessed sacrament & other holy things , when they laid hands on them by stelth , as also their very crucifying of even Christian chrildren ; argues an implacable and incredible hatred of them against christian religion . 2. As for the Pagan Princes , Nero , Demitian , Trajan , Aurelian , Maximean , Dioclesian , and Galerian , with many others ; how cruelly and barbarously did they torture Christians : In Rome alone , three hundred thousand Christians were martyred ; amongst which were twenty seven Popes ; and the sacred bodies of 180000 of them were buried in that famous Churchyard of Saint Calistus Pope and Martyr . Now if in the City of Rome alone , so many were martyred ; to what an immense number , would all that suffered for the same cause , in all other parts of the world , if they were added to these , amount . 3. And for the Hereticks , it is their main maxime , and a principle in which generally all the sects of them are united , to oppose and band against the Roman Church ; their heads and judgements look all severall ways , but in this point they are tyed together : out of this opposition , sprung hatred , and this egged them on to persecute Catholicks , which they did most bitterly : The Arian Emperours , the Kings of the Huns , Gothes , and Wandels , and Martyrdome sent many thousands of Catholicks martyrs to heaven : nor were they a few hundreds that were put to death for the same religion , under Henry the eighth King of England , and Queen Elizabeth : And could thou be so cruell ( England ) as to see thy own bowels , so often unbowelled at Tyburn , and not yet repent ? Not yet give over seeing thine shed thy own blood ? and this for thee ? For the old religion , the true religion , thy religion ? The third Point . Consider the admirable effects which the Divine Providence hath drawn out of these sufferings of Martyrs : the first effect ( and that a happy one ) was an increase thereby of Catholick religion , that very medium which the enemies of the Church took for the destroying of it , the same the Divine Wisdome made use of as an instrumental cause , for the greater propagation of it : The Church is not lestned by persecutions , but augmented ; saith St. Leo : Ser. I. de Petro & Pau. What lopping produceth in the Vines , that persecution effecteth in the Church , saith Saint Persecution Justin , The blood of Martyrs is the seed of the Church , in Triphon : saith Tertullian in his Apologetick cap. ult . and Saint Cyprian both said it & sealed the truth of it with his blood . King James also is said to have often repeated these Saint Cyprians words ; sanguis martyrum semen ecclesia ; and upon reflection of the truth of them , to have often expressed his mislike of shedding Priests blood . The blood of Tiburtius and Valerianus , of Faustinus and Jovita , of Saint Clement , Saint Thecla , and Saint Katherine ; shed for the Faith of Christ , drew a far greater number , than they were , to believe in him : did not the death of Saint Lucia the Roman widdow double ( in Geminianus and others converted ) what the Church was robbed of by her death ? Was not the number of Faithfull B lievers , as much augmented in the conversion of Adauctus , as it was diminished by the death of happy Felix ? And did not the Curch gaine ( by loosing Saint Januarius ) almost five thousand ? For so many were converted at his martyrdome . Read the Martyrs sufferings , those who love to read rare things , and they will be convinced ( of what even the Apostata Julian was convinced ) that the sequell of persecuting Christians is the multiplication of Christians . Consider a second effect of suffering for such a cause ; and that is the great glory , which doth acrew both to God , and to the sufferers thereby . God cannot regale man more in this mortal life , than to make him a Martyr : and man cannot perform a greater point of service for God , than by suffering as becomes a Martyr : for no man bath greater charity than such an one : In Martyrdome God compleateth man with the greatest of his favours ; and in the same man complieth with God in the superlative degree of his indeavours . O strange and most perfect circle of perfect love , Persecution betwixt God and man in martyrdom ! out of the Ocean of infinite love flows this felicity into man , by a strange participation ; and from it runs back into the same abysse by a pure intention . O strange reciprocation , and unheard of communication betwixt God & man in martyrdome : O martyrdome ! a felicity which none conceives , but he who receives it ; a secret which no man knows , but from God , who tels it ; a word which none understands , but from him who gives it ; and a favour which none can deserve ; but let all desire it . Pardon me , said one , I know what 's good for me ; fire , crosse , beasts , breaking of my bones , disjoynting of my limbs , brusing of my body , and all the torments that the Devill can inflict , come upon me , so be that I may enjoy Christ . O myrrour of martyrdome , blessed Bishop Ignatius : if to us thy words seem so sweet ; how sweet were thy thoughts , when thou uttered these words ; when thou suffered what thou longed for ; when thou enjoyed the reward of what thou suffered ? Answer thou , O my soul ; at least guesse what a case that enamoured bea rt was in then : think , ruminate , meditate with desire , humility , sorrow : and purpose to be often that in affection , which thou cannot ( till God please ) be in effect . The third Point . Ponder first , that all who are out of the true Church , are incapable ( whilest they remain so ) of this great purchase of martyrdome : for without Catholick and true faith , it is impossible to please God ; and without pleasing God , as little possible to be a martyr : Now those who are not members of Christs true Church , cannot have true faith , whilest they remain so . Hence infer , that though Sectaries suffer upon score of Religion , as some of severall Sects have ; yet none of them are martvrs : for as amongst severall Sects of believers , there can be but one true Church ; so amongst several sorts of sufferers , there 's one only of them can be true martyrs : the reason of this is contained in these words of Saint Austin ; Non poena , sed causa facit martyrem : not the punishment which a man suffers , but the cause for which be suffereth , makes a Martyr : Let him suffer torments and death , never so willingly , and that upon account of Religion ; yet he can be no martyr , unlesse his Religion be the true one : Occidi potest , coronari non potest ; sayes that holy Father . Infer secondly , that he who will deny the Primitive Martyrs to have been of the same Religion with the Roman Catholicks which now are , must positively prove in what , and when the Roman Church ( which was once the true Church even by the Confession of all Sectaries ) did fall from being the true Church : This fall , this change , this transition is inconceptible ; and yet Sectaries are obliged to prove it , or else return to that Church again . Ponder secondly , that in case it were supposed that Sectaries might be capable of being truly Martyrs : yet no one sect , no nor all sects together , ( out of all which Fox makes his Martyrs ) could make up a Martyrologe comparable to what is in the Church of Rome . Gather out of the precedent points , first , that the mark of Martyrdome is only to be found in the Roman church and consequently that it is the true church . Secondly , that the martyrs of the Primitive Church , and those Roman Catholicks , that suffered under King Henry the eighth , Queen Elizabeth , and her successors , were all of one Church , all Roman Catholicks , all true Martyrs : for Sectaries could never yet prove any innovation in matters of faith , or false doctrine introduced , by the Church of Rome : add to the former those martyrs ( all Catholick Priests , and in number 21 ) who have suffered in England since the year 1640 till this present year 1654 inclusive . Hail King of Martyrs , Christ ; the meritory , and exemplar cause of all true martyrdome ; we magnifie thee in these thy martyrs ; noble Champions , and pious Prodigals of their blood for thee : Please ( if it be thy blessed pleasure ) that in this thy cause my unworthy self , with many more , may have some share of these sweet sufferings ; and if not dye for thee , at least dye for not dying for thee . The seventeenth Meditation . Of Prophesies and promises , and the figures of the old law fulfilled in the true Church . The first Point . COnsider first , that not only the the Prophets of the old law , but Christ himself also foretold many things of great concernment , which were to be verisied , and fulfilled in his Church , or by it : in these prophesies also many large promises of ample privilegies and prerogatives made in reference to the same Church , were included ; which were afterwards accomplished : And Saint Paul often in his Epistles intimateth that the Jewish Synagogue with its sacrificies and ceremonies was a Symbol or Figure of Christs church , and its proprieties . So that no sect amongst Christians can or indeed doth deny these truths , in affirming of which the scriptures are so clear and copious . Consider secondly , that the fulfilling of these prophesies is to be brought against Turks , Jews , Pagans , and particularly Atheists ( too to many of which are now abroad under the notion of Sectaries ; and indeed this confusion of modern Sects produceth Atheists ) as efficacious arguments to convince them of the unreasonablenes and stolidity of their infidelity , and to bring them to Christianity : for though they deny our scriptures to contain oracles of Divine Truth : yet they admit them ( or at least may be brought by discourse to admit them ) as worthy to be ranked amongst the best monuments of humane History : Now this their humane authority is sufficient to convince and move them ; if it be effectually shewed ( for example to an Atheist ) that such & such things were foretold by Isay or Daniel , ( Authors to whom all the best wits amongst Christians give credit ; and that the said predictions are recorded to have been fulfilled by Authors of the greatest repute . Prophesies fulfilled . The second Point . Consider first , some of the chief Prophesies fulfilled , and by whom : the four Monarchies ( to wit , the Chaldean , that of the Persians and Medes , the Grecian , and the Roman ) like rivers running one into another , at length lost themselves in their Ocean ; the Monarchy of Christs Kingdome , to wit , his Church : the great extent of which its never being overcome , its superiority and predominance over all other Kingdomes , and its perpetual durance , are foretold by Daniel , cap. 2. but particularly in the 44. verse , this is apparently fulfilled in the Church of Rome yet , and in no other Sect. The Preaching of Christs Gospel to the Gentiles , and the Conversion of them , is foretold in many places of scripture : but mark the words of Isa . cap. 66. v. 19. I will send of those which shall be saved , of them to the Gentiles into Affrica , and Lydia , into Italy and Greece , unto the Ilands a far off , that have not heard of my same , neither have seen my glory , and they shall declare my glory to the Gentiles : These names are left in the Protestant Bible untranslated out of the Hebrew ; which is strange , and argues that the Translatours had no minde that a place so particularly expressing the conversion of the Gentiles by the Church of Rome , should be intelligible . Call to minde ( you enemies of the Church of Rome ) the religious submission , humble g●nuflexions , inclinations of the body , and exteriour reverence and comportment ( even of the greatest personages ) exhibited to Priests , Prelates and Popes : Then read these words of Isa . c.49.v.23 . Kings shall be thy nursing Fathers , and Queens thy nursing mothers ; they shall bow down to thee , with their face towards the earth , and lick up the dust of thy feet : and in the 60. cap. verse 14. The sons also of them that afflicted thee , shall come bending unto thee ; and all they that dispised thee , shall how themselves down at the soles of thy feet . Now consider , whether these places do not foretell , and in a manner describe the forementioned exteriour reverences . Malachy Prophesieth of Christs Church thus ; In every place a pure offering is sacrificed , and offered to my name ; The sacrifice of holy Masse ( so acknowledged and reverenced , by all the holy Fathers ) is daily offered to God , by every Priest almost extant in any part of the world ; and by it , is fulfilled that prophesie . Adde to these the gist of working Miracles , the gist of prophesie , the unity , antiquity , amplitude , sanctity , and some other Marks ( of the Roman Church onely ) mentioned in the first points of the particular meditations : all these you will finde to be prophesied and fulfilled onely in the Roman Church . The blessed Virgin Mary , in her Canticle Magnificat , prophesied of her sacred self in these words : For behold , from benceforth all generations shall call me blessed : Now as it is evident , that all generation of Roman Catholicks have complyed with this prophesie : so Sectaries may be ashamed to exhibit no kinde of honour to her ; nay not so much as this , or any other honorable appellation ; but rather speak undervaluingly , and disrespectfully of her ; whom not withstanding the whol torrent and generality of the holy Fathers extols , with such Elogium's , and that deservedly ; both in respect of her being the mother of God , Queen Mother to the King of Kings ; as also in regard that her life was the perfectest copy , that ever was taken out of the Prototypon of all perfection , Christ her son and our Lord : The Roman Catholicks ( consonant to the ancient Fathers , and consequently both of the same Religion , by reason of their Union in this , and other opinions ) honour this great Theotocos , as such a personage ; whereas most of these modern Sectaries ( Nestorian-like ) make no more of her , than if she were one of the vulgar : yet all England , for almost 900 years together , as all Catholick countries doe still ) honoured her with due respect and reverence . Consider secondly , that the Types and figures of the old law ( which were representations of what was afterwards to be in the Church of Christ ) are fulfilled in the Church of the Romane Catholicks ; and in that only : For the Synagogue , as it was a figure of Christs Church , so the Alters , Pri●sthood , Sacrifices , ( which being correlatives , infer one another ; as the want of any of them , argues the want of true Worship and Religion ) were types , not only of the pri●st hood and sacrifice , which Christ himself exercised , and offered , when he was amongst men in mortall flesh ; but also of the daily sacrifices and eternall priesthood which he left , and ordered to be exercised , and offered in his Church : now since there must be some analogy and similitude betwixt the thing prefigured and the figure ; such as is clearly to be seen in the priesthood and sacrifice of Masse daily offered in the church of Rome ; ( of which other Sects have nothing , that can any way answer to those former types : ) It follow evidently , that the Church of the Romane Catholicks is that which was prefigured by these , and consequently is Christs true Church . As for particulars : the Manna of the Israelites , with its proprietits , was a type of the Sacrament of the reall body of Chrift , and its effects ; this is truly fulfilled in the Roman Religion . Sectaries in this point still Judaize ; and of Christs reall body have still only a figure ; for they acknowledge their Bread and Communion to be no more : Nor is it so good a figure of Christs reall body , as the Jews Manna was ; of which also , as some of it was alwayes kept in the Tabernacle , so is the holy Eucharist kept in the Tabernacle in Catholick Churches . Melchisedecks Bread and Wine , was a figure of Christs reall body and blood : Secturies have still nothing but his bare Bread and Wine ; they are still in the figure : but Roman Catholicks have the reall thing ; they have reall priests and offer up to God the real body and blood of Christ , though in a mysticall manner . The Jews Pascall Lambe , was both a Sacrament and Sacrifice ; so is the holy Eucharist : and as the Pascal Lambe was offered in memory , and in thanksgiving for the benefit of their deliverance out of the AEgyptian thraldome ; so the reall Body and Blood of Christ is offered up ( when the priest , by the power which Christ hath given him , consecrateth it in Masse ) in remembrance and thanksgiving for the benefit of man's being redeemed by Christ , from the more than Egyptian bondage of sin ; and therefore it is called Eucharist , which signifies thanksgiving , and it the sacrifice of Thanksgiving : Is not this a better and more honourable remembrance of Christs passion , than a bit of meer Bread , and a sup of Wine ? The devout Ceremony of making the signe of the Crosse ( used , and commended by the holy Fathers , and all ancient Christians ) was plainly represented and commended to us all , by that Thau in Ezekiel cap 9. and by the Angels signing the Servants of God , in the Revelations , cap. 7. v. 3. This as the rest is fulfilled perfectly only by the Church of Rome . Gather hence ; that since the prophesies and types , also the great promises contained in these prophesies , are fulfilled in the Roman Church , and in it only ; it follows evidently , that it is Christs true Church . The third Point . Consider now , the sad condition of Sectaries ; argued out of their having no share at all in this full table of sweet and comfortable promises , foretold by the prophets : for this evidently shews that they are not the Church of Christ , nor members of it : On the contrary , they have just reason to fear , that the heavy denounciations and threats of the prophets ( for in this kinde onely they are like to fulfill prophesies ; ) will fall upon them : for as their novell opinions ( fond and prophane images of their own fancies , made by their private spirit ) have some semblance of those Idols , to which the Jews ( sometimes falling from the worship of the true God ) Sacrificed : So let these modern imitatours of them take heed , they be not delivered over to a reprobate sense , and the like spirituall punishment with them . And can you still persist in that perversnesse ? away with these fancies ; yeeld to truth ; and say with the repenting Jewes ( and in this they may by you be well imitated ) Signa nostra non videmus , jam non est propheta : Psal . 73. v. 10. We acknowledge we have no signes , nor miracles in behalf of our sects : We grant there are no propheticall men amongst us : We see not the marks of Christs Church upon our Sects : We confesse the prophesies are not fulfilled by us : And therefore from hence forth we will resolve , and choose rather to be abject in the house of God , his Church , than to dwell in the Tabernacks of sinners , of Sectaries any longer . The eighteenth Meditation . Of temporal blessings and felicities , miraculously bestowed on the Defenders and Propagators of the Catholick Religion The first Point . To understand how temporall felicity may be one mark , amongst the rest , which discovers the Church of Christ from all other Sects : Consider first , the difference betwixt the ordinary and extraordinary providence of God : The first is that , whose effects we see and feel , in the production , conservation , and operation of creatures : It appears also in the effects of mans morality , industry , or art ; and in the natural effects of all secondary causes : The second appears to us chiefly in effects which are surpassing the forces of naturall causes : the one confers riches , honours , victories , kingdomes , and the like , after that manner which we have daily experience , see , or hear of : By me Kings do raigne ; Prover . 8. vers . 15. sayes God ; and he cals them Ministers of his Kingdome , Wisdome 6. vers . 5. and Saint Paul sayes , There is no power but from God , Rom. 13. By the other he give principalities , and victories miraculously , when , and to whom he pleases ; and without the cocourse of secondary causes any way proportionable to those prodigious effects : Thus he gave the Jews Victories most miraculously ; as to Josu , Gedeon , Judas , Machabeus and others : which , as they were extraordinary signes both of the Divine Protection over the Synagogue , as also that it was then the true Religion : so the same Argument holds in behalf of the Church of Christ ; that that people is it , on which God bestows the like victories and benefits after a miraculous manner . Consider secondly , ( for the avoiding of errour in the weaker understandings ) that these temporall felicities are not to be supposed a mark of Christs Church in themselves ; but onely so far forth as they are conferred after a miraculous manner : for certain it is , that poverty is as conducing a means to eternal salvation , as riches : yea , heaven is far casilier attainable by poverty ( if it be imbraced not only patiently , but willingly ) than by riches : yet they are in themselves both gifts originally arifing from the hand of God : The Lord hath given , the Lord hath taken away ; sayes Job chap. 1. The Lord maketh poore and enricheth ; he bringeth low and lifteth up , 1 King. 2. v. 7. Poverty and honesty are from God : Eccles . 11.24 . He humbles this man , and he exalteth that man , Psal . chap. 74. So that there is no doubt of this : But we speak here of the manner of Gods dispensing out these temporals ; which , when it is miraculous , it argues which Religion is most favoured by Almighty God , and consequently is his . Hence infer , that this mark is not any way repugnant to that other of persecution : for different circumstances of time , place , and persons , remove this difficulty ; the Jews , though they were often miraculously protected by God ; yet at other times he permited them to be sore persecuted ; as by Antiochus and others . The second Point . Consider now ( by induction of examples ) how highly the Roman Church and its members , have been favoured by Almighty God in a miraculous way . Constantine the Emperour ( and honour of England , his native country ) was a Roman Catholick well known by his great reverence to the Pope , to the Saints , and their Relicks , and to the signe of the Crosse ; and his example methinks might move all England to reverence the same : God gave him the Empire after a miraculous manner ; for as he were upon his march ( going out of England towards Italy ) with small forces , against Maxentius the Tyrant , who had in his Army a hundred and seventy foot , with eighteen thousand horse ; espyed in the ayre about mid-day a faire Crosse , with this inscription upon it : In hoc vince ; overcome by means of this : the next night , our Saviour appeared to him , and shewed him the same Crosse , and gave him order to bear that signe in his Banner , and so he should be victorious : He did so , overcame the Tyrant , and then became Christian : After which , he was victorious in all his other Battails also , by means of our Saviours promise made to him , if he carried that figne of the Crosse : which he did alwayes carry in his Standard , ( called the Labarum ) causing it to be transferred alwayes to that quarter of the Army , which was most weakned by the Enemy ; and the fight of it added new courage to the one , by which the other were soon defeated . Theodosius the elder , a pious and Catholick Emperour , gave a strange defeat to the Tyrant Eugenius , & Potius orando , quam pugnando , saith Saint Austin : for before the battail began , he had implored the Divine assistance by long prayer ; and the effect was , that in the beginning of the conflict , on a sudden comes so prodious a storm of wind , that it drive the enemies Dartsback upon themselves , with the slaughter of many of them , and even forced their weapons out of their hands : Thus writes Saint Austin de civit . l. 5 . cap. 26. And even Claudian the pagan Poet sings the same in a poem to Honorius : l. 5 . c. 24. And Theodoret writes that Saint Iohn , and Saint Philip Apostles appeared mounted upon White horses , and fighting for Theodosius in his army against his enemies . An immense army of Sarazens came to force Theodosius the younger , to raise his siege of Nisibis in Asia : but God struct into them so strong an imagination of the Christian Army's setting upon them on all sides ; that a hundred thousand of them threw themselves headlong into the great river Euphrates , and so were drowned . Heraclius the Emperour , often worsted by the Persian forces and brought in a manner to despair of ever recruiting ; betook himself to implore the divine aide , by much fasting , prayer , and pennace : at length he was admonished from God to fall upon the Persians with the small forces he had ; and with these , he defeated three huge Armies of them , one after another , and recovered the holy Crosse of Chirst . England had no few of such examples . Venerable Bede recounts a famous victory , lib. 3. c. 2. which King Oswald got against the Pagan King Cadwallus , in the battell , he had for his Ensigne , the sign of the Crosse ; and the victory was so much attributed to a heavenly assistance ; as that the place was called Heavens field ; now corruptly Haden field . Alfred King of the west Saxons , got so miraculous a victory over the Danes , Anno 880. by means of Saint Cuthbert ( who bid him encounter with the enemy , notwithstanding his forces were small ; and told him when , how and in what place he should sight them ) that many of the nobler sort of the Danish Army were Biptized and Converted upon it : yea , the same Saint Cuthbert told Alfred , that his posterity should rule over all England : which in Athelstane , and King Edward was fulfilled . When Godfrey of Bullen with the Christian army was besieged in Antioch by a huge Army of Truks , Sarazens and Persians , and brought to extreme famin ; S. Andrew appearing to a devout Priest in the army , bid him tell the Captains of the army , that digging in such a place in S. Peters Church , they should finde the Spear which pearced our Saviours side ; and that Sallying out with that borne before them , they should get the Victory : All was performed as S. Andrew revealed it ; and an absolute Victory was got . And the next year that Christian army besieged Hierusalem : but having for a month together made many assaults , and still repulsed ; some Souldiers began to shrink a way , and passing towards mount Olivet , they saw a man in glittering armour on the top of it , who with his hand giving them a signe to goe back ; this made them returne , and with the news give so comfortable an allarum to the army , that presently a new attact was given , and the town taken . Godfry Bullen and Eustathius his brother being the first two that entred the City . Alphonso the first King of Portingall , animated by our Saviour ( who appearing to him crucified , promised him the victory ) with 4000 . set upon 400000. Sarazens , led by five kings , and totally defeated them : the gratefull king , in memory of the 5 wounds with which our Saviour crucified appeared to him , added to his arms ( which were before only a whitefield ) five Escuchons in form of a plain crosse Azure . Alphonsus the 8. King of Castile in Spain , fought a set battell with Memelius King of the Sarazens ; and encouraged with a Crosse , which appeared in the ayr , and the Sarazents dismayed at the first sight of the picture of the blefsed Virgin Mary ( patronesse of Toledo ) which was painted on the Spanish Ensigne ; slew two hundred thousand of the Sarazens , twenty five men only in the Catholick army being slain . Thus Writes Rodorick Archbishop of Toledo , an eye witnesse of it , as being then present to animate the Army . The ever honoured House of Austria , hath been priviledged with many miraculous favours from Almighty God ; the first of that House , who was Emperour , was Rodulphus the Duke of Haspurge : he , seeing a Priest carrying the blessed Sacrament towards a Village , in which a sick person lay , piously importuned the Priest to ride rather upon his Horse , than to go in the foul way ; then he ran by the Horse side like a foot boy : at their departure the Priest with his benediction gave him a good omen , that God would reward him and his , for that fact : On he goes his intended journey , which was to visit a prophetical woman : She at the first sight of him ( having by revelation known what had past ) told him , that his humble devotion to the blessed Sacrament , was so pleasing to God , that he and all his posterity should be rewarded for it : She bid him therefore take notice of the number nine , and its being expired : In fine , at the end of nine years , the princes of Germany met about chosing a new Emperour , and all unanimously choosed him : in whose family it still remains . Of the same family was Charls the fifth , who amongst his many famous victories , got one miraculously with a few men against a great Army of his rebellious Subjects , who by Luthers instigation were gathered together , and had put themselves into a fighting posture against their prince , and in defence of Luthers Reformation . And his son , John of Austria , was General , Anno 1571. when that miraculous victory against the Turks at Lepanto , was got ; which was both revealed to Pius Quintus pope , many dayes beforehand , and also at the very time of the battel : At the beginning of it , the wind savoured the Turks , but instantly calmed ; then suddenly a strong and favourable winde rise , which so pestered the Turks ; bringing also all the smoak from the Catholick Guns and Muskets upon them ; that by the end of four hours , not full 200 Gallies ( against 300 of the Turks ) so fought , that the Turkish Hali Bassa with 3000 were slain , 3000 prisoners , 130. Gallies taken , 15000. Christians ( who had been slaves ) redeemed , and 80 Gallies sunk ; with no losse at all , in a manner of the Catholick side . To conclude , a strange miracle it was , that preservation of many thousands of the Spanish foot , in the Isle of Bomel , from being starved , drowned , or taken every man ; if a prodigious winde had not in a short space frozen the Sea there : so , that the Holland ships could not move , but the Spanyards marched away upon the Ice : the thing made the Holland Generall Holach , say , that God had been too much that day a Spanyard . Gather hence , first , that since the forementioned Princes , and their Armies ( on which God bestowed these victories ) were Roman Catholicks ; as all history evidently shews : and since the victories bestowed on them were above the forces of nature , or humane endeavours , and pollicy ; and none such were ever obtained by any other sect : it evidently follows , that the religion of these Roman Catholicks is the true religion : 2 that these examples ( related by authors of good credit , and those many ) evidently prove against atheists , and such as in cline that way , that there is a God ; and that god by his providence rules the world ; and that ther is no such thing in the world as Fortune , or Fate : those things w ch seem casual , are only so in regard of secondary causes ; nothing is casual in respect of the prime cause , God : this mans adverse fortune , and the others successeful endeavors ; this mans want ; & the others plenty ; this mans health , and others infirmities ; are all from the hand of God , his gists ; and the one as well as the other matter for vertue and means to salvation , if they be used well , & with a rectified intention ▪ The third Point . Consider first , that Sectaries ( even all put together ) cannot make it appear , that they have received any miraculous favours , like to the above mentioned , either in confirmation of any of their sects , or any other way : Gods providence hath permitted the Sarazens & Turks to prevail much against Christians , and to possesse themselves of many Countries , in which catholick Religion had formerly flourished ; yet this doth not argue that God loves them better than the Christians ; or thereby approves of their Alcaron . In like manner , in the Wars betwixt Catholicks and Sectaries ; the latter as they have often received the worse , so have they often been prevalent against the other ; ( yet never but upon some great advantage ) and are now in possession of many Towns and Countries , which were sormerly Catholick : but this is no more a divine approbation of their Tenents and Doctrine , than the Turkish Temporall successe , pleads the truth of their Religion ; in both cases ( of the prospirity of Turks and Sectaries , as also of what dammages they have inferred to Catholicks ) these are only ordinary ( and experienced in all ages ) effects of the divine providence ; which humbles this man and exalts that man ; Quia calix in manu domini virimeri plenus mixto , & inclinavit ex hoc in hoc . Psal . 74. But these miraculous effects are plainly a divine confirmation of Religion : And thus must all Sectaries argue against Insidels inbehalf of Christianity , and their own Sects ; by denying that their worldly prosperity proves them to be in favour with God , and of the true Religion ; and yet convincing them that these prodigious effects are arguments of true Religion , and of Gods great protection : for they are so indeed . And therefore thou may truly say ( O holy Church ) with the holy Prophet : I will not fear thousands of people , that have set themselves against me round about . psal . 3.6 . Though an host should encampe against me , my heart shall not fear ; though war should rise against me ; in this will I be confident . ps . 27.3 . The nineteenth Meditation . Of the Disasters and unhappy ends of the opposers and enemies of the Roman Church . The first Point . AS victories , and other temporall blessings , miraculously bestowed upon the defenders , & propagators of the Roman religion ; so extraordinary , and prodigious punishments inflicted upon the persecutors of the same , are signes and arguments that that is the true Catholick Church of Christ ; consider therefore , first that though God permit the wicked livers , and those and those that seek the ruine of his Church , to go long unpunished ; yet to convince the world that this is meerly'a permission of his ( thereby to give the just matter for merit , and the bad time to reclaim themselves , & repent ) and that he can lay his heavy hand hard on where he pleases ; he lets men have frequent experiment that he hath a reserve of miraculous punishments , which he lets flie ( like his thunderbolts out of the Clouds ) at them , and especially at the enemies of his Church , Scismaticks , Heretick , and Persecuters . Consider secondly , that those punishments are twofold ; some are such , as cannot be conceived to be otherwise then by miracle : as when God punished the Madianites by the mutuall slaughter of one another : others , tho not transcending the forces of natural causes ; yet are such , and accompanied with such circumstances ; as that it appears evidently , that God thereby punisheth extraordinarily . Such were the punishments of Herod ( he that in killing the holy innocents , aymed at the killing of our Saviour ; ) who was consumed by Vermin , and so dyed ; having first killed his own wife and children , and attempted to kill himself : And of Pilate , who killed himself , as Eusebius recounts : As also of the other Herod , the Tetrarch , who beheaded S. John Biptist , and treated our Saviour as a fool : he was thrust out of his king dom , sent into banishment , and in it lived and died with a great deal of misery . Consider thirdly , that amongst other signes , by which the world might easily know that the only true religion before Christs time was that of the Jewes , one was ( and that a principall one ) the exemplar , and extraordinary punishments , which God exacted upon those who were irreligiously in jurious to the same : Such were those nine plagues , which were laid upon the Aegyptians for oppressing that faithfull people ; the Philistians for handling the Ark of the Testament unworthily , suffered many calamities ; the Bethsamits , for their irreverent looking only at that Ark , contrary to Gods comand , were punished with the death of 70. men of prime quality , and 80000. of the vulgar sort : Antiochus for the out cryes , and Sacrileges which he committed in his persecution of the Jewes , was struck with most abominable diseases , and devoured by vermine : Baltbasar , for his Sacrileges committed in Hierusalem , and prophane abuse of the sacred Vessels , in the very heat of his banquet , read the dismal sentence of his losse of life and Kingdom , ( which was put in execution that very night ) written miraculously by singers which appeared upon the wall ; and Heliodorus ( to omit many more ) besides other scourges , was cruelly whipped by two young men ( sent by God ) for his sacrilegeous attempt of robbing the temple of Hierusalem . Hence inser , that if such like punishments can be shewed to have been laid upon the enemies , and persecutors of the Roman religion ; it must by the same consequence be judged to be the true Church of Christ . The second Point . Consider therefore first the tragical end of those Pagan Emperours that persecuted the Catholick Church , of the first 24 of them , which sat at the sterne of the Roman Empire , betwixt the time of Augustus Cesar and Constantine the great ; as there was scarce 4. of them which did not persecute ( & that most cruelly most of them ) the Catholick Church ; so hardly four of them escaped the revenging hand of God , and most miserable ends ; some of them were selfe murderers ; others were massacred by those very men ( or their affociats ) whom they had raised up to the highest step of honour in the Court , or Militia : and others were destroyed by horrible diseases , judged even in the opinion of their own Pagan physitians , more then naturall . After their times , and when Rome was free , and intirely Catholick , two reniarkable Examples of punishment ( inslicted upon two armies , which attempted to make Rome , & Constantinople , the subject of their barbarous cruelry ) happened . Radagaisus King of the Goths , marched with an Army of two hundred thousand men ( armed no lesse with malicious intentions against Religion , then with other weapons ) towards Rome , and faced the City with those formidable forces , the Romans to prevent this sudden storming their City , armed themselves with what speed they could ( but considing chiefly in that , which S. Paul cal's the Armor of God ) and with their small number went out to fight that mighty Army , behold what happened : on a sudden that vast army was struck by the divine power with such an amazment and stupidity , and so disabled from fighting ; that the Romans falling upon it , totally routed , and destroyed it , together with that King , who with his sons was slain amongst the rest : and of the Romans not so much as any one man kiled , or wounded : this is related ( and counted for a miraculous punishment ) by S. Austine himselfe , who was living at the same time : and not twenty years after : Roylas ( with a puissant army of Scythians Anno 425. ) coming with the same intention to Constantinople ; as he made his approach towards the City then filled with fears and frights , as may well be imagined ; behold fire and thunderbolts at Gods command fell upon that huge Army & totally destroyed it ; lo , two famous Examples of Gods heavy hand upon the enemies of the Caltolick religion . Consider secondly what punishments befell some of those Emperors and Princes , who after that they had been or were Christians , became injurious to the same Religion : Julian for his apostasie from the true Church , and his malicious persecuting the same , at length fighting against the Persians , received a morall wound with a lance , from what hand it came , no man about him could tell ; but himselfe acknowledged that it were a stroak from heaven , by his casting handfuls of his own blood furiously into the ayre : and saying to our Saviour ; Vicisti Galilee : thou hast overcome , O Galilean : after which the earth opening swallowed up his body ; as S. Gregory Nazianzen writes in an oration of Saint Athanasius . Valens the Arian Emperour , persecuting the same Religion , was many wayes punished by Almighty God , and at last he was burnt alive by the Goths . The Emperour Anastasius , , who both opposed the Church of Rome , & favoured the Eutychian heresie , was slain with a Thunder bolt . Leo Iconomachus the Emperour caused the people of Constantinople to take all the pictures and images out of the Churches , and burn them in the market-place : Presently after which fact , the plague invaded that City , and destroyed in a short time three hundred thousand persons : This happened about the year 719. in the time of Pope Gregory the second . The Emperour Zeno , an Eutichian heretick , Rome , was by Anastasius ( who succeeded him ) buried alive . Justinean the Emperour , after so many laudable facts of his , at length be gun the heresie of the Aphthartodocites , affirming ( out of an in discreet Zeal of our Saviours honour ) that his flesh was incorruptible before his passion : But whilest he was about making an Act for the receiving of this opinion , all the Empire over ; he was carried out of the world by sudden death . Heraclius the Emperour , after the great favour he had received of God , in that miraculous Victory against the Persians ; at length fell into the heresie of the Monotholites ; and dyed most miserably . Belizarius that great warrier , ( them which the world had no greater then ) was degraded , and devested of all his honorable offices which he had had under his Emperour Justinian , both his eyes were pulled out of his head , and he sunk down into so low a condition , as to sit a blind beggar , with these words still in his mouth : Give a bodwel to Bellizarius . Whence this great change ? from Justinians jealousie , that he affected his Empire as some say : But Belizarius himselfe , with many more , attributed that punnishment to the injury he had done the Vicar of Christ , Pope Silverius ; whom he unjustly sent into banishment by the Empresse Theodora's instigation . Theodorick the Arian King , a mongst the other mischiefs he had done the Church of Rome , killed Pope John the first , with a cruel imprisonment : at length a holy Saint in a vision saw that King led betwixt that Pope and Simmachus ( a noble Patrician whom the same Theodorick had unjustly killed ) towards the fiery pits of mount Etna , and thrown headlong into one of them : This is related by Saint Gregory ; who saies , that upon examination it was found , that the King dyed at that very time which the holy mans vision specified ; and by consequence argued the verity of it . Hunnericus , an other Arian King , and a great persecuter of the Roman Church ; was eaten up alive by vermin . After these astonishing examples of Pagan and Christian Princes , punnished for opposing the Church of Rome , and persecuting the same : Consider thirdly , what became of some of the Arch hereticks ; Arius , going to ease himselfe , voided out his bowels together with his excrements , and so dyed . Manicheus , was fleed alive by the King of Persia . Montanus , Theodotus , and their Women ( which pretended to have the gift of prophesie ) all hanged themselves . And Nestorius , his impious tongue ( which had denied that the blessed Virgin Mary was Mother of God ) was eaten away by Vermin , after he himselfe had been condemned by the Ephesine Counsel , and the blessed Virgin declared Theotocos , to wit , the mother of God. And this example me thinks , and the authority of that general Counsel , might move these later sectaries to bear more respect , than they doe , to that blessed Virgin Mary . The third Point Though the looking upon these examples , with a juditious and considerate eye , would sufficiently convince any man ; that the heavy hand of God hangs alwaies over the heads of the opposers , and enimies of the Roman Church ; which I suppose may without presumption be now called ( as it only is ) the Catholick Church , as onely having the true marks of Christs Church : yet the nearer wee deduce this argument down to wards these our dayes , the greater influence it will have upon many . Consider therefore First what befel the protoparents of all these later sects . Luther ( the Ring-leader of all the succeeding sectaries ) after aplentiful and merry-supper , in which he had exhilarated all his company with his discourse ( the drift of which was ordinarily to make the Pope , and papists ridiculous , and odious ) he went safe and sound to bed ; but was ceazed upon by sudden death before the morning came . Oecolampadius , going well in health to bed with his woman , was found next morning lying stone dead by her ; an untimely end ( as is to be feared ) for one who had been not onely a Priest , but was tyed also to the religious order of St. Briget with the triple cord of his three Vowes : some Suppose hee was killed by the Devil ; others write that hee killed himselfe . Nor was the end of Carolstadius less terrible : for of him the Ministers of Basil write : ( in their Funeral Epistle of him ( that hee was killed by the Devill he had been Archdeacon of Wittenberg , and a Priest ; but presently upon Luthers revolt sided with him , and took a Concubine . Zuinglius , ( who had been a Canon of Constance ) the incendiary of a bloody civill warre in his own Country , was at last massacred in one of the battels himself : his pretence was to extirpate Popery , and to plant the Reformed religion , as they called it : But Erasmus ( in his Epistle to Goclenius ) sayes plainly , That the aym of Zuinglius ( as also of Oecolampadius ) was tyranny ; and that they affected some temporall dominion : Osiander , before his miserable end , was suddenly struck dumb , like a beast ; as may be read in Prateolus : And Calvin's end was by being eaten up by Vermine ; the horrour of which punishment , and the frightfull terrours injected into his conscience , made him spend his last minutes ( as Hierom Bolsecus writes ) in execrations and blasphemous ejaculations , with invocation of the Devils . O dreadfull punishments ! tragicall and dismall deaths ! untimely ends ! so truly spoke St. Paul , when he said , It is a horrible thing to fall into the hands of God : Heb. 10.31 . so truly said David , that God is , Terrible in his counsels upon the sons of men : Psal . 66.5 . and can you still adhear to those your sects , which had such founders ? Still persecute the Church of Rome , and read such punishments ? Harken rather , to what the Prophet saies , and fulfill his words ; yea , the words of God : Love ye peace and verity , saith the Lord Omnipotent . Zach. 8 . Consider lastly , the unsuccessefull affairs , and finall ends of three secular Princes ; who in their several countries did most harm to Roman Catholicks : King Henry the eighth in England , William Nassaw in the Low countries , and Gustavus Adolphus in Germany ; they had been all three once Roman Catholicks ; and how sad enemies they proved afterwards to the persons , places , and practice of that Religion ( and yet not so much out of hatred of that religion , as to compasse their other designs ) few are ignorant : but they themselves were overwhelmed in the ruines they made ; and of the tragedies by them begun the Catastrophe , fell chiefly upon them : The one was delivered over to his own sensuality , and made a slave to it ; even his very body was metamorphized out of that of a man almost into that of a monster : he sunk still deeper into sin , till his souls danger grew almost desperate ; and all his latter years were full of punishments of his Schisme and Sacriledge . The second , when death rushed in at the windows of those wounds , which the bullets made in his breast , and carried him presently to render up the accounts of his Stewardship to God and his King ; was not the heavy hand of God upon him ? The third , , after an ocean of Innocent bloodshed in his unjust invasion of the Empire ; after such a ruine of Catholick Houses , Villages , Towns , Cities , Monasteries and Churches ; after such a ransack of Religion , and threats against Rome , and the Vicar of Christ himself ; to be killed , without a moments respite to repaire what was amisse ; was not this a fearfull scourge of God ? undoubtedly it was . Hence infer , that the whole complex of these examples proves evidently that the Roman Catholicks are the true Church of Christ ; and for this reason amongst others ; because God hath laid so remarkable punishments upon their enemies , and persecuters : Secondly , gather that these examples efficaciously prove against Atheists , that , there is a God , who punisheth wickednesse . Thirdly , infer what misery and punishment Luther made himself lyable to , for his giving the first Allarum to all the Heresies of these later times . O Luther , what got thou by imitating Lucifer ? thy pride , and disobedience to the true Church , was like his to God : thy fall from that state , which is a kinde of heaven upon earth , was like to his : and I fear thy doom is not unlike to his . The twentieth Meditation . Confession of the Adversaries . The first Point . FOr the Conclusion of this Work , let the subject of this last Meditation be , that which these late Sectaries grant in behalf of the Roman Church , and against themselves . Consider therefore , that the Sectaries since Luthers time , and particularly Protestants , do grant and acknowledge many things in behalf of the Roman Catholicks : First , they confesse that the Fathers and Doctours of the Primitive Church , believed and taught the same things which the Roman Catholicks now hold , and in which they and other sectaries differ : First , That Saint Peter was ordained , by Christ the head of the Apostles , and of the whole Church . 2. That the Bishop of Rome succeeded S. Peter in the Primacy of the whole Church . 3. That the Books of Toby , Judith , Esther , Wisdom , Ecclestasticus , and two first of the Machabees , were truly Canonicall scripture . 4. Traditions . 5. The reall presence and Transubstantiation . 6. That Masse was a sacrifice truly propitiatory for the living and the dead . 7. That Christ gave Priests power to forgive sins , and the necssity of auricular Confession . 8. Pardon or Indulgences . 9. Purgatory and Prayer for the dead . 10. Praying to Angels and Saints . 11. Placing Christs image , and his Saints in Churches , and reverencing them . 12. Reverence to the relicks of Martyrs and other Saints . 13. That such as were made Clergy-men could never afterwards marry . 14. That not only Faith , but also good works do truly justifie ; and that these are meritorious of grace and glory : These , and diverse other Tenents of the Roman Catholicks , are acknowledged by chief Protestant Writers to have been taught , believed , and practiced by the antient Fathers : That the protestant . Writers confesse these points ( which indeed is a strange thing , and utterly ruines their cause ) those learned and laborious works , to wit , the Protestants Apology ; the Progeny of Catholicks and Protestants ; as also many other Authors do most amply declare ; and cite the very words of all the chiefest Protestant Writers most faithfully about the the forementioned points . Secondly , they confesse that Roman Catholicks dying Roman Catholicks may be saved ; this , the most of all Sectaries grant , both in their Writings and in their ordinary discourse : truly as this acknowledgment ought to bring no smal comfort to Catholicks , when they reflect that they are of a religion , which even in the opinion of their Adversaries is soul-saving : so me thinks it should make a great impression upon others which are not Roman Catholicks , and move them to embrace that religion in which all parties think and say men may saved : and this acknowledgment did produce this effect in that honourable Lady , the Countesse of Buckingham ; which was present at that publick disputation betwixt Mr. Fisher a Jesuit , and Master White a Minister , held by the Kings order : For Mr. Fisher demanding of Mr. White , whether or no , he thought that one dying a Roman Catholick might be saved ? and he answering , that upon his soul , he thought such an one might be saved : presently upon this , she resolved to become a Roman Catholick ; and what she then purposed , she soon put in execution , as many thousands could witnesse . Thirdly , They confesse that Roman Catholicks do not erre in any fundamentall point of Faith ; and that they want none of the things essentially requisite to salvation : and therefore the most learned Adversaries grant that Roman Catholicks are a true Church , or members of the true Church , though not the true Church to wit alone : The consideration of this also ( as of the former ) cannot but comfort ROMAN CATHOLICKS , whilest they remain so : Now what a madnesse is it to fall from that Religion , in which all parties agree , that salvation may be had : Certainly a prudent man will not venter his temporal estate upon a probable security , if he can have a certainty ( provided also that it be lawful ) much lesse his eternall : No man can in conscience expose his soul to hazard ; if he may make sure work : For though in things which are necessary necessitate pracepti only , a probable opinion of Doctours will save a soul harmlesse ; yet in things which are absolutely necesfary , and means without which salvation cannot be had ( as the being a member of the true Church is ) the surest way is to be chosen . Fourthly , that very thing , which hath been by me prefixed to my self as the end of my endeavours , in these twenty Meditation ( which was to shew that the marks of Christs Church were to be found onely amongst the Roman Catholicks , and consequently that Christs true Church , was onely with them ) is by many of the chief protestants Writers granted , by granting those things which really are the marks of Christs true Church : They grant that S. Malachy , S. Bernard , S. Francis , S. Dominick & others , were Roman Catholicks , that they were Saints , and that they wrought Miracles ; they grant the mark of Antiquity ; and that no known beginning of the Roman Church since the Apostles time ( which is a convincing argument , that it begun in the Apostles time ) can be assigned : They grant that the Roman Church never went out of any Society of Christians , ancienter than it self : They grant that no particular time can be assigned , in which any innovation of Faith was introduced , or change made in the Church of Rome : which three things notwithstanding they ought not onely to deny ; but are obliged positively to prove the contrary ; or els grant that their forsaking the Church of Rome , and caluminating it , is most unjust ; as most certainly it is : Besides this , in granting ( as they do ) that the holy Fathers of the Primitive Church held the same forementioned opinions , which the now existent Roman Catholicks hold ; consequently they must grant these two to be both one ; as also the Roman Catholicks to have those , who were eminent in Sanctity , Miracles , Prophesie and the like , ( for the holy Fathers of the Primitive Church , were persons priviledged with all these great endowments ) and by good consequence to have the marks of Christs true Church : In brief , it hath been most amply proved by Catholick Authors ( as by the Protestants Apology , and other learned Books ) that the ablest protestant Writers grant those things to be amongst Roman Catholicks ; which are truly the marks of Christs Church : Read also the eleventh and thirteenth chapter in every Century of the Magdeburgians , and you will see how effectually the Protestants ( like good advocates ) plead the cause of the Roman Catholicks : who may truly say with Moses , Our enemies are judges , of the equity of our cause . The second Point . Consider now what things the Protestants acknowledge against themselves : And here a man may truly say ; Out of thy own mouth I judge thee , naughty servant . First they disclaim from the antient Fathers , and will not own them . That Luther , and Calvin , and the Centurists , doe so , it is well knowne to all that read theire workes . And that many of the English Protestant writers doe the same , their works do witnesse . True it is , many of them doe pretend to appeal to the Fathers ; but since as many , or more of them , doe not , but the contrary ; it appears by this that the Protestants are divided amongst themselves in this main point . Therefore , Mittam Egyptios , contra Egyptios , I will put the Egyptions , against the Egyptions , belongs to them . And since ( of the forementioned Protestant Authors , ) many do plainly censure , and condemne the Fathers for holding popish tenents ; hence also it followes , that they must grant them to bee all one with the now Roman Catholicks . Secondly , they grant that the ancient Fathers condemned in the ancient hereticks many opinions , which are held by the protestants themselves now a days : This is instanced at large by the author of the Progeny ; and others : that the assertions of the old hereticks were condemned ; and that notwithstanding the Protestants now hold the same , is evident ; and therefore they are forced to grant it ; in particular about the Sacraments , the Scriptures , Freewill , Faith , Good-works , Mariage of Priests , Monachism and divers other points . Thirdly , they grant that the four first generall Councels lawfully condemned Arius , Nestorius , Eutyches , and Macedonius , and that these were truly hereticks : and yet some of them erred but in one point . Therefore , since to deny any one point sufficiently propounded as a truth revealed by God , makes an heretick ; and this by the protestants own consession : let any prudent man judg whether the protestants do not expose their sules to evident danger ; First by denying so many points now held by the Roman catholicks , and the same held by the antient Fathers also . Secondly by not having amongst themselves one , and the same body , or number of things to bee believed : but on the contrary taking to themselves all liberty in believing ; and being actually so various , and disagreeing in matters of faith , as every where they are amongst them selves : and so by granting these former to have been truly hereticks , for their denial of some one point ( as they must grant it , seeing the four first general councells are received in England ) hence it followes that they condemne , and undo themselves , and their own cause . Founthly they grant that when Luther began , there was neither true preaching , nor true pastors , nor true doctrine in the world . Which thing though it be most false : yet by granting this , they grant that they themselves had no Church till Luther began , and what Church began then onely , could not be the true Church of Christ , for want of Antiquity , apostolical succession , Visibility and Indefectibility ; which proprieties Christs Church must have . True it is , that Prideaux ( as also some others ) troubled at this sequel , denyes the former proposition , & pretends that the protestant Church was visible in every age . But , first neither he , nor any other could ever yet prove any such visibility . Secondly , this argues that the protestants are here also , as in other points , at variance amongst themselves . Lastly they confess ( and in confessing this alone , they grant enough to undo themselves and establish the truth of the Roman Church ) that they went out from the Roman Catholicks . The thing indeed in it self is most true ; and it hath been often proved by Catholicks , that Waldo , Wicliffe , Hus , Luther , Calvin and the cheif of these new Reformado's were sirst Catholicks and members of the Roman Church , before their change : But the thing now to be considered is their own consession of this truth . As for Luther , he acknowledgeth in many places of his Works , that he had been a Papist , and went out from them . And Caloin sayes in plain terms , that he , and his departed from the Church of Rome , yea and from the whole world . Discessionem à tot mundo facere coactisumus . . Mr. Jewel , Fox , Rainolds , Mason and many more of them acknowledge their Church to have gone out of the Roman Church : so that nothing remains now but to take notice of what sequels result out of this , and their other ingenuous confessions . The third Point . Consider lastly , Some inferences which may be drawn out of the two former points : first by their granting that they went out of the Roman Church ( acknowledging also that those who dy in the same Church may besaved ) they evidently make themselves guilty of schisme . 2. granting in this manner Salvation to Roman Catholicks , whom they confesse also not to erre in fundamentals ( the latter of which is also inferred out of the former ) nor to want any of those things which are essntial requisites to salvation ; it followes that these other are not only guilty of Schisme ; but of heresie also , if they hold any thing ( as they hold many ) contradictory to these confessedly foule saving tenents of Roman Catholicks . 3. This grant of their going out from the Roman Catholicks ( which thing is evidently proved also in the third point of the meditation of antiquity ) this alone makes the protestant Religion guilty of novelty , and by consequence of falshood : for the true church of christ began in the time of the apostles : theirs comming after that time , could not be it , by reason of its posteriority ; but some other false sect . 4. The whole sum of what they have granted in behalf of the Roman catholicks , and against themselves , proves evidently , that the Roman catholicks are the only true church of christ . Since therfore in this great suite betwixt Sectaries ( especially Protestants ) and Roman catholicks about the true church of christ , and whose it is by right , we have not only proved that the marks of it and of that of the Roman catholicks , are all one ; and consequently that these two are not in reallity two but one and the same church : but our adversaries have moreover given us a judgement , by confessing in substance , that our claims are good , and their own ill grounded : what remaines but execution : not that which the ministers of divine justice doe upon the wicked ; which God avert : but that rather ( for such are my cordial wishes ) which the equity of this cause exacts to be done by convicted persons upon themselves ; by putting in execution that ( true conversion to the catholicke faith ) to which the evidence of these most credible testimonies ( the markes of the true church must needs incline an impartial reader . Confident I am that the substance of these meditations cannot but convince , that the markes of christs true church are to be found amongst the Roman Catholicks , and only amongst them . If passion , prejudicate opinions , & obstinacy be laid aside ; if self-ends , and temporal interests be not prevalent , and disturb reason ; undoubtedly the testimonies of these markes will make it give sentence for the catholicke party . Away with these fears of sequestration , or temporal incumbrances ; heaven is a happy purchase , though it cost you these ; yea life it selfe . Such premisses as the praxis of your belief and life prepare , such conclusions will death draw out in the end : Nor can either belief or life be good in a Religion which is bad . Choose therefore the best , whatsoever it cost ; since thy salvation depends upon thy Election in point of Religion : Mean while , Let this be the last ( though not the least ) of the sequels which may be drawn out of the precedent Meditations ; to wit , a cessasion of persecution . Can reason , yea can nature choose but cry out , in seeing Catholicks persecuted , where all Sects are tolerated ; and in beholding those mens blood shed , or sought for , even by those , for the good of whose souls these others are so piously prodigall of their own blood . England , England , which kill 's the Prophets , and with the averse affections of thy hard heart ston's those that are sent to thee . How often and how willingly would they have gathered thy children together ( as the Hen her Chickins ) under that shelter , which he wished for , who said ; Under the shade of thy wings protect me : but thou wouldest not . Behold thy house is left like a desert ; without Altar , without Priest , without Sacrifice ; stone upon stone , and scarce that some where . Alas ! The dayes will come , in which thou must repent thy not taking notice of the visites , which thy Saviour gave thee by his Servants . England , remember from whence thou hast fallen : do pennance ; and do thy first works : Return to thy self , and consider how many thousands in the house of thy Father abound with bread , the bread of Angels , their daily bread ; whilest thou perishes with famine : Rise , goe , and say : Father I have finned against heaven , and in thy sight ; now I am no more worthy to be called thy daughter , since I have forsaken thy Spouse my mother . And thou , O God of hosts , look down from heaven , and behold , and visite this vinyard ; and the Vineyard which thy right hand once planted ; let it by the same be again repaired ; to thy eternall glory . Amen . Soli Dei honor & gloria . ERRATA . PAge 2. line 25 read proximus , and marg . Rom. 6.22 . p. 3. l. 12 get , p. 4. l. 11 dele all . , p. 8. l. 9 an oblation , p. 14. marg . dele Isa . 7.9 , p. 16. l. 27 dele ment , p. 27. l. 13 , what they are , p. 28 marg . Elogium's , p. 40. l. 19 ingenuous , mar . del . Jo. 5.24 , p. 41. l. 10 machins p. 46. l. 20. Mar. 16.20 , p. 54. l. 10 the enemy , l. 13 eye witness reports , p. 55. l. 7 a great blunder is , l. 14 cambinding , p. 47. marg . 14.12 . p. 57. l. 1 Ephpheta , l 7 that way in , p. 58. marg . dele Lev. 15.16 , p. 61. l. 26 believing , p. 63. l. 18 least , p. 65. l. 13 r. Patrick , l. 15 Silverius , p. 68. l. 21. Iohn Fox , p. 85. marg . 76.11 , p. 86 . l. 20 besanctified , l. 25 need I , p. 87. l. 6 I can , p. 95. l. 3 Nervians , p. 103. l. 18 is ( as ap . p. 107. l. 16 itlegitimates , p. 121 l. 26 not by , p. 131. l. 11. proved at , p. 135. marg . 19. 40. p. 145. l. 12. possibly be . p. 146. l. 1. believe , l. 28 dele these , p. 148. l. 5. disbelieving , p. 149. l. 1. to the which , p. 153. l. 21 some like it , p. 155. l. 6. dear Christian , l. 21. father for , p. 161. l. 4. Lithus , p. 164. l. 28. Cunegundis , p. 179. l. 9. dele a , p. 182. l. 2. beatified , p. 190. l. 21.1 . untruth , p. 191. l. 2 this , p. 193. l. 18 dele on , p. 195. l. 10 dele and , p. 202 l. 1. Justin in Triphon , p. 204. l. 4. from him it , p. 212. l. 24. generations , p. 214. l. 8 Altars , p. 217 l. 18. denunciations , p. 222. l. 25 be was , p. 223 l. 1. seventy thousand , p. 224. l. 19 struck , p. 229 l. 25 Catholicks , p. 230. l. 6. on , p. 234. l. 15. dele and those , p. 236. l. 7 God inflicted , l. 19 the outragies , p. 240. l. 12 it was . Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A96976-e870 Rom. 6. 23. Mat. 6. 33. The Colloquie . Lib. 4.c.ult . div . Inst . Jo. 14.27 . Heb. 11 , 6. Mar. 16 , 16. Isa . 7.9 . Eph. 2.8 . Heb. 11. 6. Note Mar. 16.16 Note . Acts 20 , 28 The Churches Theologium's . Eccl. 19.4 . Psal . 76. Psal . 92. in Protest . 93 Matt. 11. Joh. 5.24 . Joh. 9. Joh. 3. Psal . 36. Ps . 92. Mar. 16. Jo. 14. 10. Lib. 2. c. 57. 1. de Spiritu Sancto c. 26 Strm : 91. Hackluit Navig vol 2. part . 2. p. 88. Hart. w●● . Lib. 3. c. 8.1 . p.q. 118. Haïpsfield , and the records at Duïham . Surius Psal . 149. Coclaeus in actis Luth. ann . 1523. Bolseus in vita Cal. & others . Note . The Collquie . Psal . 93. 1 Cor. 3.17 . Lev. 15.16 . Joh. 15.16 . Matt. 7. Matt. 5.48 . Jo. 20.23 . Mat 18 , 18 , Note . Note . Mat. 16. 24 Joh. 20.23 . Ps . 76. 10. Mat. 16. 24. colloquy . Note . Ephes . 6. Luke 21. Mat. 28. Psal . 119. An. 411. About the year 180. About the year 600. An. 1542. Tom. 1. 1. 6. de signis . Vol. 2.part . 2. pag. 31. In resp . altora contra Fac. Gretser . p. 333. Lib. de prascrip . Note . Note . The Colloquie . Ephes . 4. v. 11 , 12. Hphes . 2. 20 , and 21. Heb. 5. 4. Jo. 10. v. i. Heb. 5.4 . Rom. 10.15 John 10.1 Oglethorp , Bishop of Carlisle . ) Nagges-head in Cheapside . An. I. & . 8. Eliz. Note . Colloquie . Isa 59.21 . Isa . 62.6 . Mat. 28. Mat. 13. Lib. cont . cp . fund . cap. 4. Rom. 1.7 . v. 8. Acts 28. v. 13 , 14 , 15 , 16. v. 23. v. 30 , 31. Pet. 5.13 . Brerely and the progeny . Note . Note . Note . Luc. 19.39 . Jer. 6.16 . Epist . a d Cliteph . lib. 3. c. 4. Note . Note . Note . Eliz. an . I. & 8. Epist . 118 . Deut. 32. Note . Note . Med. 2. Note . Note . Cor. 1.10 . The Colloquy . 10.17.20 . 21. Printed an , 1576. Dan. 2. Dan. 7. Note Cor. 12.12 . Note . The Colloquie . L. contra Ep. fund . c. 4. Ep : ad Sympronianum . Note . Note . The colloquie . 1 Cor. 12 In vita S. Ed. Mafferis in vita . Surius in vita . S. Bonav , in vita . su ius . Ribad●u ix vita S.Ig. cochleus in aun . 1525. Acts 5. Psal . 89. juxta vulg . An. I , & 8. v. 8 , 9. Note . Note . Note . The Colloquie . S. Igna. Ep. ad Rom. Con. in Ps . 24. The Colloquie . Cor. 1.10 , 11 Note . Ps . 84. Anno 312. Euschius Metaphor . Baronius . Anno 394. Anno 420. Nicephor . Socrates . Rom. brev . Baron . Malmesh , Inguls . Polidore an . 1098. Paul. Aenil . Guil. Tyr. Baron . an . 1099. an . 1139. Audreas Resendius . an . 1212 An. 1273. aliis . An 1271. Daurolt . An. 1547. Bellar. Famian Strada . Note Note . Ascalonita . Joseph . l. 17 antiquit . c. 9 lib. 2. c. 7. & ult . Jos . l. 18 . c. 14 Num. 4. Mathab . Macha● An. 406. ut ●r●sins . l. 5 . c. 23 de civit . Theodoret l. 5 . c. 36 Socrates 1.7 c. 42. Anno 363. S. Herom . Theadoret . Socrates . Ruffinus . Cedren . Zoano●s Math. Palm . Zon. and enemy of the Church of cedren . Ev 〈…〉 Zona● Baronius L. 4. Dia● , c. 30. Victor l. ●● Coclcus in ●jus vita . King Heary she 8. Prince of Orange King of Sweathland Note Note See the Protestants Apology . Luke 1● , 22. Lect. 9 de visibil . Epist . 141. And Instit . lib. 4. c. 6. The Progeny 1 . 3.c.7 .