A vindication of The reasonableness of Christianity, &c. from Mr. Edwards's reflections Locke, John, 1632-1704. 1695 Approx. 52 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 25 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2003-01 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A48904 Wing L2769 ESTC R18275 11871393 ocm 11871393 50134 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A48904) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 50134) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 501:11) A vindication of The reasonableness of Christianity, &c. from Mr. Edwards's reflections Locke, John, 1632-1704. [3], 40, [4] p. Printed for Awnsham and John Churchil, London : 1695. Advertisement on p. [1]-[4] at end. Appears in his The reasonableness of Christianity. London, 1696. Reproduction of original in Union Theological Seminary Library, New York. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Christianity. 2002-06 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2002-06 Aptara Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2002-07 Kirk Davis Sampled and proofread 2002-07 Kirk Davis Text and markup reviewed and edited 2002-08 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion A VINDICATION OF THE REASONABLENESS OF Christianity , &c. A VINDICATION OF THE REASONABLENESS OF Christianity , &c. From Mr. Edwards's REFLECTIONS . LONDON : Printed for Awnsham and Iohn Churchil , at the Black Swan in Pater-Noster-Row . 1695. A VINDICATION OF THE REASONABLENESS OF Christianity , &c. MY Book had not been long out , before it fell under the Correction of the Author of a Treatise , Entituled , Some Thoughts concerning the several Causes and Occasions of Atheism , especially in the present Age. No contemptible Adversary I 'le assure you ; since , as it seems , he has got the Faculty to heigthen every thing that displeases him into the Capital Crime of Atheism ; And breaths against those who come in his way a Pestilential Air , whereby every the least Distemper is turned into the Plague , and becomes Mortal . For whoever does not just say after Mr. Ed's . cannot 't is evident escape being an Atheist , or a promoter of Atheism . I cannot but approve of any ones Zeal to Guard and Secure that great and Fundamental Article of all Religion and Morality , That there is a God : But Atheism being a Crime , which for its Madness as well as Guilt , ought to shut a Man out of all Sober and Civil Society , should be very warily charged on any one by deductions and Consequences which he himself does not own , or at least do not manifestly and unavoidably flow from what he asserts . This Caution , Charity , I think , obliges us to : And our Author would possibly think himself hardly dealt with , if , for neglecting some of those Rules he himself gives , p. 31. & 34. against Atheism , he should be pronounced a promoter of it : As rational a Charge , I imagine , as some of those he makes ; And as fitly put together , as the Treatise of the Reasonableness of Christianity , &c. brought in among the causes of Atheism . However I shall not much complain of him , since he joyns me , p. 104. with no worse Company than two Eminently Pious and Learned * Prelates of our Church , whom he makes favourers of the same Conceit , as he calls it . But what has that Conceit to do with Atheism ? Very much . That Conceit is of Kin to Socinianism , and Socinianism to Atheism . Let us hear Mr. Ed's . himself . He says , p. 113. I am all over Socinianized : and therefore my Book fit to be placed among the Causes of Atheism . For in the 64. and following Pages , he endeavours to shew , That a Socinian is an Atheist , or lest that should seem harsh , one that favours the Cause of Atheism , p. 75. For so he has been pleased to mollifie , now it is published as a Treatise , what was much more harsh , and much more confident in it , when it was Preached as a Sermon . In this abatement he seems a little to comply with his own Advice against his fourth Cause of Atheism ; which we have in these words , pag. 34. Wherefore that we may effectually prevent this folly in our selves , let us banish Presumption , Confidence , and Self-conceit ; let us extirpate all Pride and Arrogance : Let us not List our selves in the Number of Caprioious Opiniators . I shall leave the Socinians themselves to answer his Charge against them , and shall Examine his Proof of my being a Socinian . It stands thus , pag. 112. When he [ the Author of the Reasonableness of Christianity , &c. ] proceeds to mention the Advantages and Benefits of Christ's coming into the World , and appearing in the Flesh , he hath not one Syllable of his satisfying for us , or by his Death purchasing Life or Salvation , or any thing that sounds like it . This and several other things shew that he is all over Socinianized . Which in effect is , that because I have not set down all that this Author perhaps would have done , therefore I am a Socinian . But what if I should say , I set down as much as my Argument required , and yet am no Socinian ? Would he from my silence and omission give me the Lye , and say , I am one ? Surmizes that may be over-turned by a single denial , are poor Arguments , and such as some Men would be ashamed of : At least , if they are to be permitted to Men of this Gentleman's Skill and Zeal , who knows how to make a good use of Conjectures , Suspicions , and Uncharitable Censures in the Cause of God ; yet even there too ( if the Cause of God can need such Arts ) they require a good Memory to keep them from recoiling upon the Author . He might have taken notice of these words in my Book , pag. 107. From this estate of Death Jesus CHRIST RESTORES all Mankind to Life . And a little lower , The Life which Jesus Christ restores to all Men. And p. 205. He that hath incurred Death for his own Transgression , cannot LAY DOWN HIS LIFE FOR ANOTHER , as our Saviour professes he did . This methinks SOUNDS SOMETHING : LIKE Christ's purchasing Life for us by his Death . But this Reverend Gentleman has an Answer ready ; It was not in the place he would have had it in : It was not where I mention the Advantages and Benefits of Christ's coming . And therefore , I not having one Syllable of Christ's Purchasing Life and Salvation for us by his Death , or any thing that sounds like it ; this , and several other things that might be offered , shew that I am all over Socinianized . A very clear and ingenuous Proof , and let him enjoy it . But what will become of me , that I have not mentioned Satisfaction ! Possibly this Reverend Gentleman would have had Charity enough for a known Writer of the Brotherhood , to have found it by an Inuendo in those words above quoted , of laying down his Life for another . But every thing is to be strained here the other way . For the Author of the Reasonableness of Christianity , &c. is of necessity to be represented as a Socinian ; or else his Book may be read , and the Truths in it , which Mr. Ed's . likes not , be received , and People put upon examining . Thus one , as full of Happy Conjectures and Suspicions as this Gentleman , might be apt to Argue . But what if the Author designed his Treatise , as the Title shews , chiefly for those who were not yet throughly or firmly Christians ; proposing to work on those who either wholly disbelieved or doubted of the truth of the Christian Religion ? Would any one blame his Prudence , if he mentioned only those Advantages which all Christians are agreed in ? Might he not remember and observe that Command of the Apostle , Rom. 14. 1. Him that is weak in the Faith receive ye , but not to doubtful disputations , without being a Socinian ? Did he amiss , that he offered to the belief of those who stood off , that , and only that which our Saviour and his Apostles preached for the reducing the unconverted World ? And would any one think he in earnest went about to perswade Men to be Christians , who should use that as an Argument to recommend the Gospel , which he has observed Men to lay hold on as an Objection against it ? To urge such Points of Controversie as necessary Articles of Faith , when we see our Saviour and the Apostles in their Preaching urged them not as necessary to be believed , to make Men Christians , is ( by our own Authority ) to add Prejudices to Prejudices , and to block up our own way to those Men whom we would have access to , and prevail upon . But some Men had rather you should write Booty , and cross your own design of removing mens Prejudices to Christianity , than leave out one tittle of what they put into their Systems . To such I say ; Convince but Men of the Mission of Jesus Christ ; make them but see the Truth , Simplicity , and Reasonableness of what he himself Taught , and required to be believed by his Followers ; and you need not doubt , but , being once fully perswaded of his Doctrine , and the Advantages which all Christians agree are received by him , such Converts will not lay by the Scriptures ; but by a constant Reading and Study of them , get all the Light they can from this Divine Revelation ; and nourish themselves up in the words of Faith , and of good Doctrin , as St. Paul speaks to Timothy . But some Men will not bear it , that any one should speak of Religion , but according to the Model that they themselves have made of it . Nay , though he proposes it upon the very Terms , and in the very Words which our Saviour and his Apostles preached it in , yet he shall not escape Censures , and the severest Insinuations . To deviate in the least , or to omit any thing contained in their Articles , is Heresie under the most invidious Names in fashion , and 't is well if he escapes being a down-right Atheist . Whether this be the way for Teachers to make themselves hearkened to , as Men in earnest in Religion , and really concerned for the Salvation of mens Souls , I leave them to consider . What success it has had towards perswading Men of the Truth of Christianity , their own Complaints of the prevalency of Atheism on the one hand , and the Number of Deists on the other , sufficiently shew . Another thing laid to my Charge , p. 105. & 107. is my forgetting , or rather wilful omitting some plain and obvious Passages , and some Famous Testimonies in the Evangelists ; namely , Mat. 28. 19. Go teach all Nations , baptizing them in the Name of the Father , and of the Son , and of the Holy Ghost . And Iohn 1. 1. In the beginning was the Word , and the Word was with God , and the Word was God. And verse 14. And the Word was made Flesh. Mine it seems in this Book , are all sins of Omission . And yet when it came out , the buz , and flutter , and noise which was made , and the Reports which were raised , would have perswaded the World that it subverted all Morality , and was designed against the Christian Religion . I must confess Discourses of this kind , which I met with spread up and down , at first amazed me ; knowing the sincerity of those Thoughts which perswaded me to publish it , ( not without some hope of doing some Service to decaying Piety , and mistaken and slandered Christianity . ) I satisfied my self against those Heats with this assurance , that if there was any thing in my Book , against what any one called Religion , it was not against the Religion contained in the Gospel . And for that I appeal to all Mankind . But to return to Mr. Ed's in particular , I must take leave to tell him , that if omitting plain and obvious Passages , and famous Testimonies in the Evangelists , be a fault in me , I wonder why he , among so many of this kind that I am guilty of , mentions so few . For I must acknowledge I have omitted more , nay , many more , that are plain and obvious Passages , and famous Testimonies in the Evangelists , than those he takes notice of . But if I have left out none of those Passages or Testimonies which contain what our Saviour and his Apostles preached , and required assent to , to make men Believers , I shall think my Omissions ( let them be what they will ) no faults in the present case . What ever Doctrines Mr. Edwards would have to be believed , if they are such as our Saviour and his Apostles required to be believed to make a Man a Christian , he will be sure to find them in those Preachings and Famous Testimonies of our Saviour and his Apostles that I have quoted . And if they are not there , he may rest satisfied , that they were not proposed by our Saviour and his Apostles , as necessary to be believed , to make Men Christ's Disciples . If the Omission of other Texts in the Evangelists ( which are all true also , and no one of them to be disbelieved ) be a fault , it might have been expected that Mr. Edwards should have accused me for leaving out Mat. 1. 18. to 23. and Mat. 17. 24. 35. 50. 60. for these are plain and obvious Passages , and famous Testimonies in the Evangelists ; and such whereon these Articles of the Apostles Creed , viz. Born of the Virgin Mary , suffered under Pontius Pilate , was crucified , dead , and buried , are founded . These being Articles of the Apostles Creed , are look'd upon as Fundamental Doctrines : And one would wonder why Mr. Edwards so quietly passes by their Omission ; did it not appear that he was so intent on fixing his Imputation of Socinianism upon me , that rather than miss that , he was content to drop the other Articles of his Creed . For I must observe to him , that if he had blamed me for the Omission of the places last quoted out of St. Matthew ( as he had as much reason as for any other ) it would planily have appeared how idle and ill-grounded his charging Socinianism on me was . But at any rate he was to give the Book an ill Name . Not because it was Socinian . For he has no more reason to charge it with Socinianism for the Omissions he mentions , than the Apostles Creed . 'T is therefore well for the Compilers of that Creed , that they lived not in Mr. Edwards's days : For he would no doubt have found them all over Socinianized , for omitting the Texts he quotes , and the Doctrines he collects out of Ioh. 1. & Ioh. 14. p. 107 , 108. Socinianism then is not the fault of the Book , whatever else it be . For I repeat it again , there is not one word of Socinianism in it . I that am not so good at Conjectures as Mr. Edwards , shall leave it to him to say ; or to those who can bear the plainness and simplicity of the Gospel , to guess , what its fault is . Some Men are shrewd guessers , and others would be thought to be so : But he must be carried far by his forward Inclination , who does not take notice , that the World is apt to think him a Diviner , for any thing rather than for the sake of Truth , who sets up his own Suspicions against the direct Evidence of things ; and pretends to know other mens Thoughts and Reasons better than they themselves . I had said , that the Epistles being writ to those who were already Believers , could not be supposed to be writ to them to teach them Fundamentals , without which they could not be Believers . And the Reason I gave why I had not gone through the Writings in the Epistles , to Collect the Fundamental Articles of Faith , as I had through the Preachings of our Saviour and his Apostles , was , Because those Fundamental Articles were in those Epistles promiscuously , and without distinction , mixed with other Truths . And therefore we shall find and discern those great and necessary Points best in the Preachings , of our Saviour and the Apostles , to those who were yet ignorant of the Faith , and unconverted . This , as far as I know my own thoughts , was the reason why I did ( as Mr. Edwards complains , p. 109. ) not proceed to the Epistles , and not give an Account of them , as I had done of the Gospels and Acts. This I imagined I had in the close of my Book so fully and clearly expressed , particularly p. 125. that I supposed no body , how willing soever , could have mistaken me . But this Gentleman is so much better acquainted with me than I am with my self ; sees so deeply into my Heart , and knows so perfectly every thing that passes there ; that he with assurance tells the World , p. 109. That I purposely omitted the Epistolary Writings of the Apostles , because they are fraught with other Fundamental Doctrines beside that one which I mention . And then he goes on to enumerate those Fundamental Articles , p. 110 , 111. viz. The Corruption and Degeneracy of Humane Nature , with the true Original of it ( the Defection of our first Parents ) the Propagation of Sin and Mortality , our Restoration and Reconciliation by Christ's Blood , the Eminency and Excellency of his Priesthood , the Efficacy of his Death , the full Satisfaction made thereby to Divine Iustice , and his being made an All sufficient Sacrifice for Sin. Christ's Righteousness , our Iustification by it , Election , Adoption , Sanctification , Saving Faith , The Nature of the Gospel , The New Covenant , The Riches of God's Mercy in the way of Salvation by Iesus Christ , The certainty of the Resurrection of Humane Bodies , and of the future Glory . Give me leave now to ask you seriously whether these , which you have here set down under the Title of Fundamental Doctrines , are such ( when reduced to Propositions ) that every one of them is required to be believed to make a Man a Christian , and such , as without the actual belief thereof , he cannot be saved . If they are not so every one of them , you may call them Fundamental Doctrines as much as you please , they are not of those Doctrines of Faith I was speaking of , which are only such as are required to be actually believed to make a Man a Christian. If you say , some of them are such necessary Points of Faith , and others not , you by this specious List of well-sounding , but unexplained terms arbitrarily collected , only make good what I have said , viz. That the necessary Articles of Faith are in the Epistles promiscuously delivered with other Truths , and therefore they cannot be distinguished but by some other mark than being barely found in the Epistles . If you say , that they are all of them necessary Articles of Faith , I shall then desire you to reduce them to so many plain Doctrines , and then prove them to be every one of them required to be believed by every Christian Man to make him a Member of the Christian Church . For to begin with the first , 't is not enough to tell us , as you do , that the Corruption and Degeneracy of Humane Nature , with the true Original of it , ( the Defection of our first Parents ) the Propagation of Sin and Mortality , is one of the great Heads of Christian Divinity . But you are to tell us what are the Propositions we are required to believe concerning this matter : For nothing can be an Article of Faith , but some Proposition ; and then it will remain to be proved , that these Articles are necessary to be believed to Salvation . The Apostles Creed was taken , in the first Ages of the Church , to contain all things necessary to Salvation ; I mean , necessary to be believed : But you have now better thought on it , and are pleased to enlarge it , and we , no doubt , are bound to submit to your Orthodoxy . The List of Materials for his Creed ( for the Articles are not yet formed ) Mr. Ed's . closes , p. 111. with these words : These are the Matters of Faith contained in the Epistles , and they are Essential and Integral parts of the Gospel it self . What , just these ? Neither more nor less ? If you are sure of it , pray let us have them speedily , for the Reconciling of Differences in the Christian Church , which has been so cruelly torn about the Articles of the Christian Faith , to the great Reproach of Christian Charity , and Scandal of our true Religion . Mr. Ed's . having thus , with two learned Terms of Essential and Integral Parts , sufficiently proved the Matter in Question , viz. That all those , he has set down , are Articles of Faith necessary to be believed to make a Man a Christian , he grows warm at my omission of them . This I cannot complain of as unnatural : The Spirit of Creed-making always arising from an heat of Zeal for our own Opinions , and warm Endeavours , by all ways possible to decry and bear down those who differ in a tittle from us . What then could I expect more gentle and candid , than what Mr. Ed's . has subjoyned in these words ? And therefore it is no wonder , that our Author , being sensible of this ( viz. That the Points he has named were Essential and Integral parts of the Gospel ) would not vouchsafe to give us an Abstract of those inspired Writings [ the Epistles ] but passes them by with some Contempt . Sir , when your Angry Fit is over , and the abatement of your Passion has given way to the return of your Sincerity , I shall beg you to read this passage in 297 pag. of my Book . These Holy Writers ( viz. the Pen-men of the Scriptures ) INSPIRED from above , writ nothing but Truth , and in most places very weighty Truths to us now , for the expounding , clearing , and confirming of the Christian Doctrine ; and establishing those in it who had embraced it . And again , pag. 299. The other parts of DIVINE REVELATION are Objects of Faith , and are so to be received . They are Truths , of which none that is once known to be such , i. e. revealed , may or ought to be disbelieved . And if this does not satisfie you that I have as high a Veneration for the Epistles , as you or any one can have , I require you to publish to the World those passages which shew my Contempt of them . In the mean time I shall desire my Reader to examine what I have writ concerning the Epistles , which is all contained between p. 290 and 301 of my Book ; And then to Judge , whether I have made bold with the Epistles in what I have said of them , or this Gentleman made bold with Truth in what he has writ of me . Humane Frailty will not , I see , easily quit its hold ; What it loses in one part , it will be ready to regain in another ; and not be hindred from taking Reprizals , even on the most Priviledged sort of Men. Mr. Ed's . who is entrenched in Orthodoxy , and so is as safe in Matters of Faith almost as Infallibility it self , is yet as apt to Err as others in Matter of Fact. But he has not yet done with me about the Epistles : All his fine Draught of my slighting that part of the Scripture will be lost , unless the last strokes compleat it into Socinianism . In his following words you have the Conclusion of the whole Matter . His words are these . And more especially , if I may Conjecture , ( by all means , Sir ; Conjecturing is your proper Talent ; you have hitherto done nothing else ; And I will say that for you , you have a lucky Hand at it . ) He doth this , ( i. e. pass by the Epistles with Contempt ) because he knew that there are so many and frequent , and those so illustrious and eminent Attestations to the Doctrine of the ever to be adored Trinity , in these Epistles . Truly , Sir , if you will permit me to know what I know , as well as you do allow your self to conjecture what you please , you are out for this once . The Reason why I went not through the Epistles , as I did the Gospels and the Acts , was that very Reason I printed , and that will be found so sufficient a one to all considerate Readers , that I believe they will think you need not strain your Conjectures for another . And if you think it be so easie to distinguish Fundamentals from not Fundamentals in the Epistles , I desire you to try your Skill again , in giving the World a perfect Collection of Propositions out of the Epistles , that contain all that is required , and no more than what is absolutely required to be believed by all Christians , without which Faith they cannot be of Christ's Church . For I tell you , notwithstanding the shew you have made , you have not yet done it , nor will you affirm that you have . His next Page , viz. 112. is made up of the same , which he calls , Not Uncharitable Conjectures . I expound , he says , Iohn 14. 9. &c. after the Antitrinitarian Mode : And I make Christ and Adam to be Sons of God , in the same sense , and by their Birth , as the Racovians generally do . I know not but it may be true , that the Antitrinitarians and Racovians understand those places as I do : But 't is more than I know that they do so . I took not my sense of those Texts from those Writers , but from the Scripture it self , giving Light to it 's own meaning , by one place compared with another : What in this way appears to me its true meaning , I shall not decline , because I am told , that it is so understood by the Racovians , whom I never yet read ; nor embrace the contrary , though the generality of Divines I more converse with , should declare for it . If the sense wherein I understand those Texts be a mistake , I shall be beholding to you if you will set me right . But they are not Popular Authorities , or Frightful Names , whereby I judge of Truth or Falshood . You will now no doubt applaud your Conjectures ; The Point is gained , and I am openly a Socinian , since I will not disown that I think the Son of God was a Phrase that among the Iews in our Saviour's time was used for the Messiah , though the Socinians understand it in the same sense ; And therefore I must certainly be of their Perswasion in every thing else . I admire the acuteness , force , and fairness of your Reasoning , and so I leave you to Triumph in your Conjectures . Only I must desire you to take notice , that that Ornament of our Church , and every way Eminent Prelate , the late Arch-Bishop of Canterbury , understood that Phrase in the same sense that I do , without being a Socinian . You may read what he says concerning Nathanael , in his first Serm. of Sincerity , published this year . His words are these , p. 4. And being satisfied that he [ our Saviour ] was the Messiah , he presently owned him for such , calling him the SON OF GOD , and the King of Israel . Though this Gentleman know my Thoughts as perfectly as if he had for several years past lain in my Bosom , yet he is mightily at a loss about my Person : As if it at all concerned the Truth contained in my Book , what Hand it came from . However the Gentleman is mightily perplexed about the Author . Why , Sir ? What if it were writ by a Scribler of Bartholomew Fair Drolls , with all that flourish of Declamatory Rhetorick , and all that smartness of Wit and Jest about Capt. Tom , Vnitarins , Vnits , and Cyphers , &c. Which are to be found between 115 and 123 Pages of a Book that came out during the merry time of Rope-Dancing , and Puppet-Plays ? What is Truth , would , I hope , nevertheless be Truth in it , however odly sprused up by such an Author : Though perhaps 't is likely some would be apt to say , such Merriment became not the Gravity of my Subject , and that I writ not in the stile of a Graduate in Divinity . I confess , ( as Mr. Ed's . rightly says ) my fault lyes on the other side , in a want of Vivacity and Elevation : And I cannot wonder that one of his Character and Palate , should find out and complain of my flatness , which has so over-charged my Book with plain and direct Texts of Scripture in a matter capable of no other Proofs . But yet I must acknowledge his excess of Civility to me ; He shews me more kindness than I could expect or wish , since he prefers what I say to him my self , to what is offered to him from the Word of God ; and makes me this Complement , that I begin to mend , about the Close ; i. e. when I leave off quoting of Scripture : And the dull work was done , of going through the History of the Evangelists and Acts , which he computes , p. 105. to take up three quarters of my Book . Does not all this deserve at least that I should in return take some care of his Credit ? Which I know not how better to do , than by entreating him , that when he takes next in hand such a Subject as this is , wherein the Salvation of Souls is concerned , he would treat it a little more seriously , and with a little more Candor ; left Men should find in his Writings another cause of Atheism , which in this Treatise he has not thought fit , to mention . Ostentation of Wit in general he has made a Cause of Atheism p. 28. But the World will tell him , That frothy light Discourses concerning the Serious Matters of Religion ; and Ostentation of triflng and misbecoming Wit in those who come as Ambassadors from God , under the Title of Successors of the Apostles , in the great Commission of the Gospel , is none of the least Causes of Atheism . Some Men have so peculiar a way of Arguing , that one may see it influences them in the repeating another Man's Reasoning , and seldom fails to make it their own . In the next Paragraph ▪ I find these words : What makes him contend for one single Article , with the exclusion of all the rest ? He pretends it is this , That all Men ought to understand their Religion . This , I confess , is a Reasoning I did not think of ; nor would it hardly , I fear , have been used but by one , who had first took up his Opinion from the Recommendation of Fashion or Interest , and then sought Topicks to make it good . Perhaps the deference due to your Character excused you from the trouble of quoting the Page where I pretend , as you say ; and it is so little like my way of Reasoning , that I shall not look for it in a Book where I remember nothing of it , and where , without your Direction , I fear the Reader will scarce find it . Though I have not that vivacity of Thought , that elevation of Mind , which Mr. Ed's . demands , yet common sense would have kept me from contending that there is but one Article , because all Men ought to understand their Religion . Numbers of Propositions may be harder to be remembred , but 't is the abstruseness of the Notions , or obscurity , inconsistency , or doubtfulness of the Terms or Expressions that makes them hard to be understood : And one single Proposition may more perplex the Understanding than twenty other . But where did you find I contended for one single Article , so as to exclude all the rest ? You might have remembred , that I say , p. 44. That the Article of the One only true God , was also necessary to be believed . This might have satisfied you , that I did not so contend for one Article of Faith , as to be at defiance with more than one . However you insist on the word one with great vigour ▪ from p. 108. to 121. And you did well , you had else lost all the force of that killing stroke , reserved for the Close , in that sharp Jest of Vnitarians , and a clinch or two more of great moment . Having found by a careful perusal of the Preachings of our Saviour and his Apostles , that the Religion they proposed , consisted in that short , plain , easie , and intelligible Summary which I set down , p. 301. in these words : Believing Jesus to be the Saviour promised , and taking him now raised from the Dead , and constituted the Lord and Judge of Men , to be their King and Ruler . I could not forbear magnifying the Wisdom and Goodness of God ( which infinitely exceeds the thoughts of ignorant , vain , and narrow-minded Man ) in these following words . The All-Merciful God seems herein to have consulted the Poor of this World , and the Bulk of Mankind : THESE ARE ARTICLES that the Labouring and Illiterate Man may comprehend . Having thus plainly mentioned more than one Article , I might have taken it amiss , that Mr. Ed's . should be at so much pains as he is , to blame me for contending for one Article ; because I thought more than one could not be understood ; had he not had many fine things to say in his declamation upon one Article , which affords him so much Matter , that less than seven pages could not hold it . Only here and there , as Men of Oratory often do , he mistakes the business , as p. 115. where he says , I urge , that there must be nothing in Christianity , that is not plain and exactly levelled to all mens Mother Wit. I desire to know where I said so , or that the very manner of every thing in Christianity must be clear and intelligible , every thing must be presently comprehended by the weakest Noddle , or else it 's no part of Religion , especially of Christianity ; As he has it , p. 119. I am sure it is not in pag. 255. 289. 292. of my Book : These , therefore to convince him that I am of another Opinion , I shall desire some body to read to Mr. Edwards : For he himself reads my Book with such Spectacles , as make him find Meanings and Words in it , neither of which I put there . He should have remembred , that I speak not of all the Doctrines of Christianity , nor all that is published to the World in it ; but of those Truths only , which are absolutely required to be believed to make any one a Christian. And these I find are so plain and easie , that I see no Reason why every body , with me , should not Magnifie the Goodness and Condescension of the Almighty ; who having out of his free Grace proposed a new Law of Faith to sinful and lost Man , hath by that Law required no harder terms , nothing as absolutely necessary to be believed , but what is suited to Vulgar Capacities , and the Comprehension of Illiterate Men. You are a little out again , p. 118. where you Ironically say , as if it were my sense , Let us have but one Article , though it be with defiance to all the rest . Jesting apart , Sir. This is a serious Truth , That what our Saviour and his Apostles preached , and admitted Men into the Church for believing , is all that is absolutely required to make a Man a Christian. But this is without any Defiance of all the rest , taught in the Word of God. This excludes not the belief of any one of those many other Truths contained in the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments , which it is the Duty of every Christian to study , and thereby build himself up on our most Holy Faith ; receiving with stedfast Belief , and ready Obedience all those things which the Spirit of Truth hath therein revealed . But that all the rest of the inspired Writings , or , if you please , Articles , are of equal necessity to be believed to make a Man a Christian , with what was preached by our Saviour and his Apostles ; that I deny . A Man , as I have shewn , may be a Christian and a Believer without actually believing them ; Because those whom our Saviour and his Apostles , by their Preaching and Discourses , converted to the Faith , were made Christians and Believers barely upon the receiving what they preached to them . I hope it is no derogation to the Christian Religion , to say , that the Fundamentals of it , i. e. all that is necessary to be believed in it by all Men , is easie to be understood by all Men. This I thought my self authorized to say by the very easie , and very intelligible Articles insisted on by our Saviour and his Apostles , which contain nothing but what could be understood by the bulk of Mankind ; a Term which , I know not why , Mr. Ed's . p. 117. is offended at , and thereupon is , after his fashion , sharp upon me about Captain Tom and his Myrmidons , for whom he tells me I am going to make a Religion . The making of Religions and Creeds I leave to others . I only set down the Christian Religion , as I find our Saviour and his Apostles preached it , and preached it to , and left it for the Ignorant and unlearned Multitude . For I hope you do not think , how contemptibly soever you speak of the Venerable Mob , as you are pleased to dignifie them , p. 117. that the Bulk of Mankind , or in your Phrase , the Rabble , are not concerned in Religion , or ought not to understand it , in order to their Salvation . Nor are you , I hope , acquainted with any , who are of that Muscovite Divine's Mind , who to one , that was talking to him about Religion , and the other World , replyed , That for the Czar indeed , and Bojars , they might be permitted to raise their hopes to Heaven ; But that for such Poor Wretches as he , they were not to think of Salvation . I remember the Pharisees treated the Common People with Contempt , and said , Have any of the Rulers , or of the Pharisees believed in him ? But this People , who knoweth not the Law , are cursed . But yet these , who in the Censure of the Pharisees were cursed , were some of the Poor , or if you please to have it so , the Mobb , to whom the Gospel was preached by our Saviour , as he tells Iohn's Disciples , Matth. XI . 5. Pardon me , Sir , that I have here laid these Examples and Considerations before you ; a little to prevail with you , not to let loose such a Torrent of Wit and Eloquence against the Bulk of Mankind another time ; and that for a meer Fancy of your own : For I do not see how they here came in your way ; but that you were resolved to set up something to have a fling at , and shew your Parts , in what you call your Different * strain , though besides the purpose . I know no body was going to ask the Mob what you must believe ? And as for me , I suppose you will take my word for it , that I think no Mob , ( no , not your Venerable Mob ) is to be asked , what I am to believe ; Nor that Articles of Faith are to be received by the Vote of Club-men , or any other sort of Men you will name instead of them . In the following words , pag. 115. you ask , Whether a Man may not understand those Articles of Faith which you mentioned out of the Gospels and Epistles , if they be explained to him , as well as that one I speak of ? 'T is as the Articles are , and as they are explained . There are Articles that have been some Hundreds of Years explaining ; Which , there are many , and those not of the most illiterate , who profess , they do not yet understand . And to instance in no other but He descended into Hell , the learned are not yet agreed in the sense of it , the great pains has been taken to explain it . Next , I ask , who are to explain your Articles ? The Papists will explain some of them one way , and the Reformed another . The Remonstrants and Anti-Remonstrants give them different senses . And probably the Trinitarians and Vnitarians will profess , that they understand not each others explications . And at last , I think it may be doubted whether any Articles , which need mens Explications , can be so clearly and certainly understood , as one which is made so very plain by the Scripture it self , as not to need any Explication at all . Such is this , That Jesus is the Messiah . For though you learnedly tell us , that Messiah is a Hebrew word , and no better understood by the Vulgar than Arabick ; Yet I guess it is so fully explained in the New Testament , and in those places I have quoted out of it , that no body , who can understand any ordinary Sentence in the Scripture , can be at a loss about it : And 't is plain it needs no other Explication than what our Saviour and the Apostles gave it in their Preaching ; for as they preached it men received it , and that sufficed to make them Believers . To conclude , when I heard that this Learned Gentleman , who had a Name for his study of the Scriptures , and Writings on them , had done me the Honour to consider my Treatise , I promised my self , that his Degree , Calling , and Fame in the World , would have secured to me something of weight in his Remarques , which might have convinced me of my Mistakes ; and if he had found any in it , justified my quitting of them . But having examined what in his concerns my Book , I , to my wonder , find , that he has only taken pains to give it an ill Name ; without so much as attempting to refute any one Position in it , how much soever he is pleased to make a noise against several Propositions ; which he might be free with , because they are his own : And I have no reason to take it amiss , if he has shewn his Zeal and Skill against them . He has been so favourable to what is mine , as not to use any one Argument against any Passage in my Book . This , which I take for a Publick Testimony of his Approbation , I shall return him my Thanks for , when I know whether I owe it to his Mistake , Conviction , or Kindness . But if he writ only for his Bookseller's sake , he alone ought to thank him . AFter the foregoing Papers were sent to the Press , The Witnesses to Christianity , of the Reverend and Learned Dr. Patrick , now Lord Bishop of Ely , fell into my hands . I regretted the not having seen it before I writ my Treatise of the Reasonableness of Christianity , &c. I should then possibly , by the Light given me by so good a Guide , and so great a Man , with more confidence directly have fallen into the knowledge of Christianity ; which in the way I sought it , in its source , required the comparing of Texts with Texts , and the more than once reading over the Evangelists and Acts , besides other parts of Scripture . But I had the ill luck not to see that Treatise till so few hours since , that I have had time only to read as far as the end of the Introduction , or first Chapter : And there Mr. Ed's . may find , that this Pious Bishop ( whose Writings shew he Studies , as well as his Life that he believes the Scriptures ) owns what Mr. Ed's . is pleased to call a plausible Conceit , which , he says , I give over and over again in these formal words , viz. That nothing is required to be believed by any Christian Man but this , That Iesus is the Messiah . The Liberty Mr. Ed's . takes in other places deserves not it should be taken upon his word , that these formal words are to be found over and over again in my Book , unless he had quoted the Pages . But I will set him down the formal words which are to be found in this Reverend Prelate's Book , p. 14. To be the Son of God , and to be Christ , being but different expressions of the same thing . And p. 10. It is the very same thing to believe that Iesus is the Christ , and to believe that Iesus is the Son of God ; Express it how you please . This ALONE is the Faith which can regenerate a Man , and put a Divine Spirit into him ; that is , makes him a Conquerour over the World , as Iesus was . I have quoted only these few words ; but Mr. Ed's if he pleases , or any body else , may , in this first Chapter , satisfie himself more fully , that the Design of it is to shew , that in our Saviour's time , Son of God was a known and received Name or Appellation of the Messiah , and so used in the Holy Writers . And that the Faith that was to make Men Christians , was only the believing that Iesus is the Messiah . 'T is to the truth of this Proposition that he examines his Witnesses , as he speaks , pag. 21. And this , if I mistake not , in his Epist. Dedicatory he calls Christianity . Fol. A. 3. where he calls them Witnesses to Christianity . But these two Propositions , viz. That SON of God in the Gospel stands for Messiah ; And that the Faith which alone makes Men Christians , is the believing Iesus to be the Messiah ; displeases Mr. Ed's . so much in my Book , that he thinks himself Authorized from them to charge me with Socinianism , and want of Sincerity . How he will be pleased to treat this Reverend Prelate whilest he is alive ( for the Dead may with good Manners be made bold with ) must be left to his decisive Authority . This I am sure , which way soever he determine , he must for the future either afford me more good Company , or fairer Quarter . FINIS . Books lately Printed for , and Sold by A. & J. Churchill , at the Black Swan in Pater-Noster-Row . A View of Universal History , from the Creation , to the Year of Christ 1695. wherein the most memorable Persons and Things in the known Kingdoms and Countries of the World , are set down in several Columns by way of Synchronism , according to their proper Centuries and Years : By Francis Tallents , sometime Fellow of Magdalen-College , Cambridge . The whole graven in 16 Copper-Plates , each 15 Inches deep , and 22 broad ; bound up into Books , the Sheets lined . A Work of great Exactness and Curiosity . Price 16 s. Camden's Britannia , newly Translated into English , with large Additions and Improvements . By Edmund Gibson , of Queens-College in Oxford . The General History of the Air. By Robert Boyle , Esq Quarto . A Compleat Journal of the Votes , Speeches , and Debates , both of the House of Lords and House of Commons , throughout the whole Reign of Queen Elizabeth . Collected by Sir Simonds Dewes , Baronet , and Published by Paul Bowes , of the Middle-Temple , Esq The 2d . Edition . Fol. The Works of the famous Nicholas Machiavel , Citizen and Secretary of Florence . Written Originally in Italian , and from thence faithfully Translated into English. Fol. Mr. Lock 's Essay concerning Humane Understanding . The Third Edition , with large Additions . Fol. — His Thoughts of Education . Octavo The Fables of Aesop and other Mithologists● ; made English by Sir Roger L' Estrange , Kt. Fol. Two Treatises of Government : The first an Answer to Filmer's Patriarcha . The latter an Essay concerning the true Original , Extent , and End of Civil Government . Octavo . Notitia Monastica : Or , A short History of the Religious Houses in England and Wales , &c. By Thomas Tanner , A. B. Octavo . The Resurrection of the ( same ) Body , asserted from the Tradition of the Heathens , the Ancient Jews , and the Primitive Church : With an Answer to the Objections brought against it . By Humphry Hody , D. D. Bishop Wilkins of Prayer and Preaching ; Enlarged by the Bishop of Norwich , and Dr. Williams . Octavo . Considerations about lowering the Interest , and raising the Value of Money . Octavo . Short Observations on a Printed Paper , entituled , For encouraging the Coining Silver Money in England , and after for keeping it here . Octavo . Sir William Temple's History of the Netherlands . Octavo . — Miscellanea . Octavo . Dr. Gibson's Anatomy of Humane Bodies , with Figures . Octavo . Dr. Patrick's New Version of all the Psalms of David in Metre . Twelves . Two Treatises of Natural Religion . Octavo , Gentleman's Religion , with the Grounds and Reasons of it . In which the Truth of Christianity in general is vindicated ; its Simplicity asserted ; and some Introductory Rules for the discovering of its particular Doctrines and Precepts , are proposed . By a Private Gentleman . The Novels and Tales of the Renowned Iohn Boccacio , the first Refiner of Italian Prose ; containing an Hundred Curious Novels : By seven Honourable Ladies , and three Noble Gentlemen , Framed in Ten Days . The Fifth Edition much Corrected and Amended . Logica : Sive , Ars Ratiocinandi . Ontologia : Sive , De Ente in Genere . Pneumatologia , seu Despiritibus . Auctore Ioanne Clerico . Twelves . The Lives of the Popes , from the time of our Saviour Jesus Christ , to the Reign of Sixtus IV. Written Originally in Latin by Baptista Platina , Native of Cremona , and Translated into English : And the same History continued from the Year 1471. to this present time ; wherein the most Remarkable Passages of Christendom , both in Church and State , are treated of , and described . By Sir Paul Rycaut , Kt. The Second Edition corrected . The Meditations of Marcus Aurelius Antoninus , the Roman Emperour , concerning Himself . Treating of a Natural Man's Happiness ; wherein it consisteth , and of the means to attain unto it . Translated out of the Original Greek , with Notes ; by Merio Casaubon , D. D. The Fifth Edition . To which is added , The Life of Antoninus , with some Remarks upon the whole . By Monsieur and Madam Dacier . Never before in English. Octavo . Sermons Preached by Dr. R. Leighton , late A. Bp. of Glasgow . Published at the Desire of his Friends after his Death , from his Papers written with his own Hand . The Second Edition . Octavo . The Roman History , written in Latin by Titus Livius , with the Supplements of the Learned Iohn Freinshemius , and Iohn Dujatius . From the Foundation of Rome , to the middle of the Reign of Augustus . Faithfully done into English . Fol. Books Printed for A. & J. Churchill . Anicius Manlius Severinus Boetius , of the Consolation of Philosophy . In Five Books . Made English by the Right Honourable Richard Lord Viscount Preston . Octavo . Sir Richard Baker's Chronicle of the Kings of England , continued down to this Time. The Reasonableness of CHRISTIANITY , as delivered in the Scriptures . Octavo . Prince Arthur ; an Heroick Poem . In Ten Books . By R. Blackmore , M. D. Fellow of the College of Physicians , London . Fol. The Christians defence against the fear of Death , with seasonable Directions how to prepare themselves to Dye well . Written originally in French , by Charte Drilincourt , of Paris , and translated into English by M. D. Assigny , B. D. Third Edition . The Royal Grammar , containing a new and easie Method for the speedy attaining the Latin Tongue . A Guide to Surveyers of the Highways , shewing that Office and Duty , with Cases and Resolutions in Law relating to the same ; with an abstract of the Laws for repair of Highways and Bridges . By G. Meriton . Three several Letters for Toleration , 40. Bishop Hopkins Sermons , 3 Vol. — Lords Prayer 40. — Commandments , 40. Leyburn's Cursus Mathematicus , Fol. Seldens Table Talk. Debates of Oxford and Westmin . Parliaments . FINIS . Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A48904-e150 * Bp. Taylor , and the Author of The Naked Truth . * Preface .