id	sid	tid	token	lemma	pos
8691	1	1	Kaelbling	Kaelbling	NNP
8691	1	2	,	,	,
8691	1	3	Charles	Charles	NNP
8691	1	4	Franks	Franks	NNP
8691	1	5	and	and	CC
8691	1	6	the	the	DT
8691	1	7	Online	Online	NNP
8691	1	8	Distributed	Distributed	NNP
8691	1	9	Proofreading	Proofreading	NNP
8691	1	10	Team	Team	NNP
8691	1	11	THE	the	DT
8691	1	12	AMERICAN	AMERICAN	NNP
8691	1	13	JUDICIARY	judiciary	NN
8691	1	14	BY	by	IN
8691	1	15	SIMEON	SIMEON	NNP
8691	1	16	E.	E.	NNP
8691	1	17	BALDWIN	BALDWIN	NNP
8691	1	18	,	,	,
8691	1	19	LL.D.	LL.D.	NNP
8691	2	1	CONTENTS	content	NNS
8691	2	2	PART	PART	NNP
8691	2	3	CASES	case	NNS
8691	2	4	CITED	cite	VBD
8691	2	5	.	.	.
8691	3	1	I.	I.	NNP
8691	4	1	THE	the	DT
8691	4	2	NATURE	NATURE	NNP
8691	4	3	AND	and	CC
8691	4	4	SCOPE	scope	NN
8691	4	5	OF	of	IN
8691	4	6	THE	the	DT
8691	4	7	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	4	8	POWER	POWER	NNP
8691	4	9	IN	in	IN
8691	4	10	THE	the	DT
8691	4	11	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
8691	4	12	STATES	STATES	NNP
8691	4	13	.	.	.
8691	5	1	II	ii	CD
8691	5	2	.	.	.
8691	6	1	THE	the	DT
8691	6	2	ORGANIZATION	ORGANIZATION	NNP
8691	6	3	AND	and	CC
8691	6	4	PRACTICAL	PRACTICAL	NNP
8691	6	5	WORKING	WORKING	NNP
8691	6	6	OF	of	IN
8691	6	7	AMERICAN	AMERICAN	NNP
8691	6	8	COURTS	COURTS	NNP
8691	6	9	.	.	.
8691	7	1	_	_	NNP
8691	7	2	PART	PART	NNP
8691	7	3	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	7	4	_	_	NNP
8691	7	5	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
8691	7	6	I.	I.	NNP
8691	7	7	ENGLISH	ENGLISH	NNP
8691	7	8	ORIGIN	ORIGIN	NNS
8691	7	9	AND	and	CC
8691	7	10	EARLY	early	NN
8691	7	11	DEVELOPMENT	development	NN
8691	7	12	OF	of	IN
8691	7	13	THE	the	DT
8691	7	14	AMERICAN	AMERICAN	NNP
8691	7	15	JUDICIARY	JUDICIARY	NNP
8691	7	16	.	.	.
8691	8	1	II	ii	CD
8691	8	2	.	.	.
8691	9	1	THE	the	DT
8691	9	2	SEPARATION	SEPARATION	NNP
8691	9	3	OF	of	IN
8691	9	4	THE	the	DT
8691	9	5	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	9	6	POWER	POWER	NNS
8691	9	7	FROM	from	IN
8691	9	8	THE	the	DT
8691	9	9	LEGISLATIVE	legislative	NN
8691	9	10	AND	and	CC
8691	9	11	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
8691	9	12	IN	in	IN
8691	9	13	AMERICAN	AMERICAN	NNP
8691	9	14	CONSTITUTIONS	CONSTITUTIONS	NNP
8691	9	15	.	.	.
8691	10	1	III	iii	CD
8691	10	2	.	.	.
8691	11	1	THE	the	DT
8691	11	2	RELATIONS	relations	NN
8691	11	3	OF	of	IN
8691	11	4	THE	the	DT
8691	11	5	JUDICIARY	judiciary	NN
8691	11	6	TO	to	IN
8691	11	7	THE	the	DT
8691	11	8	POLITICAL	political	JJ
8691	11	9	DEPARTMENTS	department	NNS
8691	11	10	OF	of	IN
8691	11	11	GOVERNMENT	GOVERNMENT	NNP
8691	11	12	.	.	.
8691	12	1	IV	IV	NNP
8691	12	2	.	.	.
8691	13	1	THE	the	DT
8691	13	2	FORCE	FORCE	NNP
8691	13	3	OF	of	IN
8691	13	4	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	13	5	PRECEDENTS	precedent	NNS
8691	13	6	.	.	.
8691	14	1	V.	V.	NNP
8691	14	2	THE	the	DT
8691	14	3	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	14	4	POWER	POWER	NNP
8691	14	5	OF	of	IN
8691	14	6	DEVELOPING	develop	VBG
8691	14	7	UNWRITTEN	UNWRITTEN	NNP
8691	14	8	LAW	law	NN
8691	14	9	.	.	.
8691	15	1	VI	VI	NNP
8691	15	2	.	.	.
8691	16	1	THE	the	DT
8691	16	2	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	16	3	POWER	POWER	NNS
8691	16	4	OF	of	IN
8691	16	5	INTERPRETING	interpreting	NN
8691	16	6	AND	and	CC
8691	16	7	DEVELOPING	develop	VBG
8691	16	8	WRITTEN	WRITTEN	NNP
8691	16	9	LAW	LAW	NNP
8691	16	10	.	.	.
8691	17	1	VII	VII	NNP
8691	17	2	.	.	.
8691	18	1	THE	the	DT
8691	18	2	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	18	3	POWER	power	NN
8691	18	4	OF	of	IN
8691	18	5	DECLARING	declaring	NN
8691	18	6	WHAT	what	WP
8691	18	7	HAS	have	VBZ
8691	18	8	THE	the	DT
8691	18	9	FORM	form	NN
8691	18	10	OF	of	IN
8691	18	11	LAW	law	NN
8691	18	12	NOT	not	RB
8691	18	13	TO	to	TO
8691	18	14	BE	be	VB
8691	18	15	LAW	law	NN
8691	18	16	.	.	.
8691	19	1	_	_	NNP
8691	19	2	PART	PART	NNP
8691	19	3	II	II	NNP
8691	19	4	_	_	NNP
8691	19	5	VIII	VIII	NNP
8691	19	6	.	.	.
8691	20	1	THE	the	DT
8691	20	2	ORGANIZATION	ORGANIZATION	NNP
8691	20	3	OF	of	IN
8691	20	4	THE	the	DT
8691	20	5	COURTS	COURTS	NNP
8691	20	6	OF	of	IN
8691	20	7	THE	the	DT
8691	20	8	STATES	state	NNS
8691	20	9	.	.	.
8691	21	1	IX	ix	NN
8691	21	2	.	.	.
8691	22	1	THE	the	DT
8691	22	2	ORGANIZATION	ORGANIZATION	NNP
8691	22	3	OF	of	IN
8691	22	4	THE	the	DT
8691	22	5	COURTS	COURTS	NNP
8691	22	6	OF	of	IN
8691	22	7	THE	the	DT
8691	22	8	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
8691	22	9	STATES	STATES	NNP
8691	22	10	.	.	.
8691	23	1	X.	X.	NNP
8691	24	1	RELATIONS	relation	NNS
8691	24	2	OF	of	IN
8691	24	3	THE	the	DT
8691	24	4	STATE	STATE	NNP
8691	24	5	JUDICIARY	judiciary	NN
8691	24	6	TO	to	IN
8691	24	7	THE	the	DT
8691	24	8	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
8691	24	9	STATES	STATES	NNP
8691	24	10	,	,	,
8691	24	11	AND	and	CC
8691	24	12	OF	of	IN
8691	24	13	THE	the	DT
8691	24	14	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
8691	24	15	STATES	state	NNS
8691	24	16	JUDICIARY	judiciary	NN
8691	24	17	TO	to	IN
8691	24	18	THE	the	DT
8691	24	19	STATES	state	NNS
8691	24	20	.	.	.
8691	25	1	XI	XI	NNP
8691	25	2	.	.	.
8691	26	1	RELATIONS	relations	NN
8691	26	2	BETWEEN	between	IN
8691	26	3	THE	the	DT
8691	26	4	COURTS	COURTS	NNP
8691	26	5	OF	of	IN
8691	26	6	DIFFERENT	DIFFERENT	NNP
8691	26	7	STATES	state	NNS
8691	26	8	.	.	.
8691	27	1	XII	XII	NNP
8691	27	2	.	.	.
8691	28	1	TRIAL	trial	NN
8691	28	2	BY	by	IN
8691	28	3	JURY	jury	NN
8691	28	4	.	.	.
8691	29	1	XIII	XIII	NNP
8691	29	2	.	.	.
8691	30	1	FORMALITIES	formality	NNS
8691	30	2	IN	in	IN
8691	30	3	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	30	4	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
8691	30	5	.	.	.
8691	31	1	XIV	XIV	NNP
8691	31	2	.	.	.
8691	32	1	TRIAL	trial	NN
8691	32	2	COURTS	court	NNS
8691	32	3	FOR	for	IN
8691	32	4	CIVIL	civil	NN
8691	32	5	CAUSES	cause	NNS
8691	32	6	.	.	.
8691	33	1	XV	XV	NNP
8691	33	2	.	.	.
8691	34	1	PROBATE	probate	JJ
8691	34	2	COURTS	court	NNS
8691	34	3	.	.	.
8691	35	1	XVI	XVI	NNP
8691	35	2	.	.	.
8691	36	1	BANKRUPTCY	BANKRUPTCY	NNS
8691	36	2	AND	and	CC
8691	36	3	INSOLVENCY	insolvency	NN
8691	36	4	COURTS	court	NNS
8691	36	5	.	.	.
8691	37	1	XVII	XVII	NNP
8691	37	2	.	.	.
8691	38	1	CRIMINAL	CRIMINAL	NNP
8691	38	2	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
8691	38	3	.	.	.
8691	39	1	XVIII	xviii	NN
8691	39	2	.	.	.
8691	40	1	THE	the	DT
8691	40	2	EXERCISE	EXERCISE	NNP
8691	40	3	OF	of	IN
8691	40	4	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	40	5	FUNCTIONS	FUNCTIONS	NNP
8691	40	6	OUT	out	RB
8691	40	7	OF	of	IN
8691	40	8	COURT	court	NN
8691	40	9	.	.	.
8691	41	1	XIX	XIX	NNP
8691	41	2	.	.	.
8691	42	1	APPELLATE	APPELLATE	NNP
8691	42	2	COURTS	COURTS	NNP
8691	42	3	.	.	.
8691	43	1	XX	XX	NNP
8691	43	2	.	.	.
8691	44	1	THE	the	DT
8691	44	2	ENFORCEMENT	ENFORCEMENT	NNP
8691	44	3	OF	of	IN
8691	44	4	JUDGMENTS	judgment	NNS
8691	44	5	AND	and	CC
8691	44	6	PUNISHMENT	punishment	NN
8691	44	7	OF	of	IN
8691	44	8	CONTEMPTS	contempt	NNS
8691	44	9	OF	of	IN
8691	44	10	COURT	COURT	NNP
8691	44	11	.	.	.
8691	45	1	XXI	XXI	NNP
8691	45	2	.	.	.
8691	46	1	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	46	2	PROCEEDINGS	proceeding	NNS
8691	46	3	IN	in	IN
8691	46	4	TERRITORIES	territories	NN
8691	46	5	SUBJECT	subject	JJ
8691	46	6	TO	to	IN
8691	46	7	MARTIAL	MARTIAL	NNP
8691	46	8	LAW	law	NN
8691	46	9	.	.	.
8691	47	1	XXII	XXII	NNP
8691	47	2	.	.	.
8691	48	1	APPOINTMENT	APPOINTMENT	NNP
8691	48	2	,	,	,
8691	48	3	TENURE	tenure	NN
8691	48	4	OF	of	IN
8691	48	5	OFFICE	office	NN
8691	48	6	AND	and	CC
8691	48	7	COMPENSATION	COMPENSATION	NNP
8691	48	8	OF	of	IN
8691	48	9	JUDGES	JUDGES	NNP
8691	48	10	.	.	.
8691	49	1	XXIII	XXIII	NNP
8691	49	2	.	.	.
8691	50	1	THE	the	DT
8691	50	2	CHARACTER	CHARACTER	NNP
8691	50	3	OF	of	IN
8691	50	4	THE	the	DT
8691	50	5	BAR	BAR	NNP
8691	50	6	AND	and	CC
8691	50	7	ITS	its	PRP$
8691	50	8	RELATIONS	relations	NN
8691	50	9	TO	to	IN
8691	50	10	THE	the	DT
8691	50	11	BENCH	BENCH	NNP
8691	50	12	.	.	.
8691	51	1	XXIV	XXIV	NNP
8691	51	2	.	.	.
8691	52	1	THE	the	DT
8691	52	2	LAW	law	NN
8691	52	3	'S	's	POS
8691	52	4	DELAYS	delay	NNS
8691	52	5	.	.	.
8691	53	1	XXV	XXV	NNP
8691	53	2	.	.	.
8691	54	1	THE	the	DT
8691	54	2	ATTITUDE	attitude	NN
8691	54	3	OF	of	IN
8691	54	4	THE	the	DT
8691	54	5	PEOPLE	PEOPLE	NNS
8691	54	6	TOWARDS	towards	IN
8691	54	7	THE	the	DT
8691	54	8	JUDICIARY	judiciary	NN
8691	54	9	.	.	.
8691	55	1	INDEX	index	NN
8691	55	2	.	.	.
8691	56	1	*	*	NFP
8691	56	2	*	*	NFP
8691	56	3	*	*	NFP
8691	56	4	*	*	NFP
8691	56	5	*	*	NFP
8691	56	6	TABLE	TABLE	NNS
8691	56	7	OF	of	IN
8691	56	8	CASES	CASES	NNP
8691	56	9	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
8691	56	10	_	_	NNP
8691	56	11	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	12	_	_	NNP
8691	56	13	Booth	Booth	NNP
8691	56	14	Allinson	Allinson	NNP
8691	56	15	,	,	,
8691	56	16	Hale	Hale	NNP
8691	56	17	_	_	NNP
8691	56	18	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	19	_	_	NNP
8691	56	20	American	American	NNP
8691	56	21	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	56	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	56	23	_	_	NNP
8691	56	24	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	25	_	_	NNP
8691	56	26	Canter	Canter	NNP
8691	56	27	Ames	Ames	NNP
8691	56	28	_	_	NNP
8691	56	29	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	30	_	_	NNP
8691	56	31	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
8691	56	32	Ames	Ames	NNP
8691	56	33	,	,	,
8691	56	34	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
8691	56	35	_	_	NNP
8691	56	36	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	37	_	_	NNP
8691	56	38	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
8691	56	39	,	,	,
8691	56	40	_	_	NNP
8691	56	41	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	56	42	parte	parte	NN
8691	56	43	_	_	NNP
8691	56	44	Anthes	Anthes	NNP
8691	56	45	,	,	,
8691	56	46	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
8691	56	47	_	_	NNP
8691	56	48	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	49	_	_	NNP
8691	56	50	Bachert	Bachert	NNP
8691	56	51	_	_	NNP
8691	56	52	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	53	_	_	NNP
8691	56	54	Lehigh	Lehigh	NNP
8691	56	55	Coal	Coal	NNP
8691	56	56	and	and	CC
8691	56	57	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
8691	56	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	56	59	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
8691	56	60	,	,	,
8691	56	61	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
8691	56	62	_	_	NNP
8691	56	63	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	64	_	_	NNP
8691	56	65	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	56	66	,	,	,
8691	56	67	Bardes	Bardes	NNPS
8691	56	68	_	_	NNP
8691	56	69	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	70	_	_	NNP
8691	56	71	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	56	72	of	of	IN
8691	56	73	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	56	74	,	,	,
8691	56	75	Briscoe	Briscoe	NNP
8691	56	76	_	_	NNP
8691	56	77	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	78	_	_	NNP
8691	56	79	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	56	80	of	of	IN
8691	56	81	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	56	82	_	_	NNP
8691	56	83	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	84	_	_	NNP
8691	56	85	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
8691	56	86	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	56	87	of	of	IN
8691	56	88	the	the	DT
8691	56	89	U.	U.	NNP
8691	56	90	S.	S.	NNP
8691	56	91	,	,	,
8691	56	92	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
8691	56	93	_	_	NNP
8691	56	94	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	95	_	_	NNP
8691	56	96	Bardes	Bardes	NNPS
8691	56	97	_	_	NNP
8691	56	98	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	99	_	_	NNP
8691	56	100	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	56	101	Barrows	Barrows	NNPS
8691	56	102	_	_	NNP
8691	56	103	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	104	_	_	NNP
8691	56	105	Bell	Bell	NNP
8691	56	106	Batchelder	Batchelder	NNP
8691	56	107	_	_	NNP
8691	56	108	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	109	_	_	NNP
8691	56	110	Moore	Moore	NNP
8691	56	111	Baxter	Baxter	NNP
8691	56	112	_	_	NNP
8691	56	113	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	114	_	_	NNP
8691	56	115	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
8691	56	116	Baxter	Baxter	NNP
8691	56	117	,	,	,
8691	56	118	State	State	NNP
8691	56	119	_	_	NNP
8691	56	120	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	121	_	_	NNP
8691	56	122	Bean	Bean	NNP
8691	56	123	_	_	NNP
8691	56	124	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	125	_	_	NNP
8691	56	126	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
8691	56	127	Bean	Bean	NNP
8691	56	128	,	,	,
8691	56	129	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
8691	56	130	_	_	NNP
8691	56	131	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	132	_	_	NNP
8691	56	133	Beckham	Beckham	NNP
8691	56	134	,	,	,
8691	56	135	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
8691	56	136	_	_	NNP
8691	56	137	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	138	_	_	NNP
8691	56	139	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
8691	56	140	_	_	NNP
8691	56	141	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	142	_	_	NNP
8691	56	143	Bean	Bean	NNP
8691	56	144	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
8691	56	145	,	,	,
8691	56	146	Bean	Bean	NNP
8691	56	147	_	_	NNP
8691	56	148	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	149	_	_	NNP
8691	56	150	Bell	Bell	NNP
8691	56	151	,	,	,
8691	56	152	Barrows	Barrows	NNPS
8691	56	153	_	_	NNP
8691	56	154	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	155	_	_	NNP
8691	56	156	Bell	Bell	NNP
8691	56	157	's	's	POS
8691	56	158	Gap	Gap	NNP
8691	56	159	R.	R.	NNP
8691	56	160	R.	R.	NNP
8691	56	161	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	56	162	,	,	,
8691	56	163	McCloskey	McCloskey	NNP
8691	56	164	_	_	NNP
8691	56	165	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	166	_	_	NNP
8691	56	167	Bernard	Bernard	NNP
8691	56	168	,	,	,
8691	56	169	Coggs	Coggs	NNP
8691	56	170	_	_	NNP
8691	56	171	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	172	_	_	NNP
8691	56	173	Biddle	Biddle	NNP
8691	56	174	,	,	,
8691	56	175	Green	Green	NNP
8691	56	176	_	_	NNP
8691	56	177	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	178	_	_	NNP
8691	56	179	Bidwell	Bidwell	NNP
8691	56	180	,	,	,
8691	56	181	Downes	Downes	NNPS
8691	56	182	_	_	NNP
8691	56	183	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	184	_	_	NNP
8691	56	185	Bissell	Bissell	NNP
8691	56	186	_	_	NNP
8691	56	187	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	188	_	_	NNP
8691	56	189	Dickerson	Dickerson	NNP
8691	56	190	Blacker	Blacker	NNP
8691	56	191	,	,	,
8691	56	192	Board	Board	NNP
8691	56	193	of	of	IN
8691	56	194	Supervisors	Supervisors	NNPS
8691	56	195	_	_	NNP
8691	56	196	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	197	_	_	NNP
8691	56	198	Blair	Blair	NNP
8691	56	199	_	_	NNP
8691	56	200	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	201	_	_	NNP
8691	56	202	Williams	Williams	NNP
8691	56	203	Blake	Blake	NNP
8691	56	204	_	_	NNP
8691	56	205	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	206	_	_	NNP
8691	56	207	McClung	McClung	NNP
8691	56	208	Board	Board	NNP
8691	56	209	of	of	IN
8691	56	210	Supervisors	Supervisors	NNPS
8691	56	211	_	_	NNP
8691	56	212	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	213	_	_	NNP
8691	56	214	Blacker	Blacker	NNP
8691	56	215	Bodley	Bodley	NNP
8691	56	216	_	_	NNP
8691	56	217	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	218	_	_	NNP
8691	56	219	Gaither	Gaither	NNP
8691	56	220	Boffman	Boffman	NNP
8691	56	221	,	,	,
8691	56	222	Hickman	Hickman	NNP
8691	56	223	_	_	NNP
8691	56	224	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	225	_	_	NNP
8691	56	226	Bonham	Bonham	NNP
8691	56	227	's	's	POS
8691	56	228	case	case	NN
8691	56	229	Booth	Booth	NNP
8691	56	230	_	_	NNP
8691	56	231	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	232	_	_	NNP
8691	56	233	Clark	Clark	NNP
8691	56	234	Booth	Booth	NNP
8691	56	235	,	,	,
8691	56	236	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
8691	56	237	_	_	NNP
8691	56	238	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	239	_	_	NNP
8691	56	240	Borden	Borden	NNP
8691	56	241	,	,	,
8691	56	242	Luther	Luther	NNP
8691	56	243	_	_	NNP
8691	56	244	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	245	_	_	NNP
8691	56	246	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
8691	56	247	_	_	NNP
8691	56	248	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	249	_	_	NNP
8691	56	250	Middleton	Middleton	NNP
8691	56	251	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
8691	56	252	_	_	NNP
8691	56	253	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	254	_	_	NNP
8691	56	255	Thayer	Thayer	NNP
8691	56	256	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
8691	56	257	_	_	NNP
8691	56	258	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	259	_	_	NNP
8691	56	260	U.	U.	NNP
8691	56	261	S.	S.	NNP
8691	56	262	Bradburn	Bradburn	NNP
8691	56	263	,	,	,
8691	56	264	Mincey	Mincey	NNP
8691	56	265	_	_	NNP
8691	56	266	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	267	_	_	NNP
8691	56	268	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
8691	56	269	_	_	NNP
8691	56	270	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	271	_	_	NNP
8691	56	272	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
8691	56	273	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
8691	56	274	_	_	NNP
8691	56	275	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	276	_	_	NNP
8691	56	277	New	New	NNP
8691	56	278	Haven	Haven	NNP
8691	56	279	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
8691	56	280	,	,	,
8691	56	281	_	_	NNP
8691	56	282	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	56	283	parte	parte	NN
8691	56	284	_	_	NNP
8691	56	285	Brainerd	Brainerd	NNP
8691	56	286	,	,	,
8691	56	287	Fitch	Fitch	NNP
8691	56	288	_	_	NNP
8691	56	289	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	290	_	_	NNP
8691	56	291	Branch	Branch	NNP
8691	56	292	,	,	,
8691	56	293	_	_	NNP
8691	56	294	In	In	NNP
8691	56	295	re	re	NN
8691	56	296	_	_	NNP
8691	56	297	Brashears	Brashears	NNP
8691	56	298	,	,	,
8691	56	299	Lapsley	Lapsley	NNP
8691	56	300	_	_	NNP
8691	56	301	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	302	_	_	NNP
8691	56	303	Briggs	Briggs	NNP
8691	56	304	_	_	NNP
8691	56	305	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	306	_	_	NNP
8691	56	307	Garrett	Garrett	NNP
8691	56	308	Brine	Brine	NNP
8691	56	309	_	_	NNP
8691	56	310	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	311	_	_	NNP
8691	56	312	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	56	313	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	56	314	Briscoe	Briscoe	NNP
8691	56	315	_	_	NNP
8691	56	316	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	317	_	_	NNP
8691	56	318	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	56	319	of	of	IN
8691	56	320	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	56	321	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
8691	56	322	_	_	NNP
8691	56	323	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	324	_	_	NNP
8691	56	325	State	State	NNP
8691	56	326	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
8691	56	327	,	,	,
8691	56	328	Baxter	Baxter	NNP
8691	56	329	_	_	NNP
8691	56	330	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	331	_	_	NNP
8691	56	332	Brown	Brown	NNP
8691	56	333	,	,	,
8691	56	334	Kellogg	Kellogg	NNP
8691	56	335	_	_	NNP
8691	56	336	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	337	_	_	NNP
8691	56	338	Brown	Brown	NNP
8691	56	339	,	,	,
8691	56	340	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
8691	56	341	_	_	NNP
8691	56	342	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	343	_	_	NNP
8691	56	344	Bulkley	Bulkley	NNP
8691	56	345	,	,	,
8691	56	346	State	State	NNP
8691	56	347	_	_	NNP
8691	56	348	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	349	_	_	NNP
8691	56	350	Bull	Bull	NNP
8691	56	351	,	,	,
8691	56	352	Calder	Calder	NNP
8691	56	353	_	_	NNP
8691	56	354	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	355	_	_	NNP
8691	56	356	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
8691	56	357	_	_	NNP
8691	56	358	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	359	_	_	NNP
8691	56	360	Seligman	Seligman	NNP
8691	56	361	Burr	Burr	NNP
8691	56	362	's	's	POS
8691	56	363	Trial	Trial	NNP
8691	56	364	Burrows	Burrows	NNPS
8691	56	365	,	,	,
8691	56	366	Nudd	Nudd	NNP
8691	56	367	_	_	NNP
8691	56	368	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	369	_	_	NNP
8691	56	370	Bush	Bush	NNP
8691	56	371	,	,	,
8691	56	372	Perry	Perry	NNP
8691	56	373	_	_	NNP
8691	56	374	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	375	_	_	NNP
8691	56	376	Bushnell	Bushnell	NNP
8691	56	377	,	,	,
8691	56	378	_	_	NNP
8691	56	379	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	56	380	parte	parte	NN
8691	56	381	_	_	NNP
8691	56	382	Calder	Calder	NNP
8691	56	383	_	_	NNP
8691	56	384	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	385	_	_	NNP
8691	56	386	Bull	Bull	NNP
8691	56	387	California	California	NNP
8691	56	388	,	,	,
8691	56	389	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
8691	56	390	_	_	NNP
8691	56	391	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	392	_	_	NNP
8691	56	393	Call	Call	NNP
8691	56	394	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
8691	56	395	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	56	396	,	,	,
8691	56	397	Western	Western	NNP
8691	56	398	Union	Union	NNP
8691	56	399	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
8691	56	400	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	56	401	_	_	NNP
8691	56	402	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	403	_	_	NNP
8691	56	404	Calvin	Calvin	NNP
8691	56	405	_	_	NNP
8691	56	406	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	407	_	_	NNP
8691	56	408	Huntley	Huntley	NNP
8691	56	409	Canfield	Canfield	NNP
8691	56	410	_	_	NNP
8691	56	411	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	412	_	_	NNP
8691	56	413	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
8691	56	414	Canter	Canter	NNP
8691	56	415	,	,	,
8691	56	416	American	American	NNP
8691	56	417	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	56	418	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	56	419	_	_	NNP
8691	56	420	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	421	_	_	NNP
8691	56	422	Carriere	Carriere	NNP
8691	56	423	,	,	,
8691	56	424	Tua	Tua	NNP
8691	56	425	_	_	NNP
8691	56	426	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	427	_	_	NNP
8691	56	428	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
8691	56	429	Nation	Nation	NNP
8691	56	430	_	_	NNP
8691	56	431	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	432	_	_	NNP
8691	56	433	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	56	434	,	,	,
8691	56	435	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
8691	56	436	_	_	NNP
8691	56	437	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	438	_	_	NNP
8691	56	439	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	56	440	Christmas	Christmas	NNP
8691	56	441	_	_	NNP
8691	56	442	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	443	_	_	NNP
8691	56	444	Russell	Russell	NNP
8691	56	445	Church	Church	NNP
8691	56	446	_	_	NNP
8691	56	447	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	448	_	_	NNP
8691	56	449	Pearne	Pearne	NNP
8691	56	450	City	City	NNP
8691	56	451	of	of	IN
8691	56	452	South	South	NNP
8691	56	453	Bend	Bend	NNP
8691	56	454	_	_	NNP
8691	56	455	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	456	_	_	NNP
8691	56	457	Turner	Turner	NNP
8691	56	458	Claflin	Claflin	NNP
8691	56	459	_	_	NNP
8691	56	460	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	461	_	_	NNP
8691	56	462	Houseman	Houseman	NNP
8691	56	463	Clark	Clark	NNP
8691	56	464	,	,	,
8691	56	465	Booth	Booth	NNP
8691	56	466	_	_	NNP
8691	56	467	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	468	_	_	NNP
8691	56	469	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
8691	56	470	's	's	POS
8691	56	471	Appeal	Appeal	NNP
8691	56	472	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
8691	56	473	,	,	,
8691	56	474	Painesville	Painesville	NNP
8691	56	475	and	and	CC
8691	56	476	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
8691	56	477	R.	R.	NNP
8691	56	478	R.	R.	NNP
8691	56	479	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	56	480	,	,	,
8691	56	481	_	_	NNP
8691	56	482	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	483	_	_	NNP
8691	56	484	Pritschau	Pritschau	NNP
8691	56	485	Clymer	Clymer	NNP
8691	56	486	,	,	,
8691	56	487	Norris	Norris	NNP
8691	56	488	_	_	NNP
8691	56	489	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	490	_	_	NNP
8691	56	491	Cochran	Cochran	NNP
8691	56	492	,	,	,
8691	56	493	Gernon	Gernon	NNP
8691	56	494	_	_	NNP
8691	56	495	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	496	_	_	NNP
8691	56	497	Coffin	Coffin	NNP
8691	56	498	_	_	NNP
8691	56	499	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	500	_	_	NNP
8691	56	501	United	United	NNP
8691	56	502	States	States	NNP
8691	56	503	Coggs	Coggs	NNP
8691	56	504	_	_	NNP
8691	56	505	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	506	_	_	NNP
8691	56	507	Bernard	Bernard	NNP
8691	56	508	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
8691	56	509	_	_	NNP
8691	56	510	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	511	_	_	NNP
8691	56	512	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	56	513	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
8691	56	514	_	_	NNP
8691	56	515	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	516	_	_	NNP
8691	56	517	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
8691	56	518	Coler	Coler	NNP
8691	56	519	_	_	NNP
8691	56	520	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	521	_	_	NNP
8691	56	522	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
8691	56	523	Railway	Railway	NNP
8691	56	524	and	and	CC
8691	56	525	Power	Power	NNP
8691	56	526	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	56	527	Colt	Colt	NNP
8691	56	528	,	,	,
8691	56	529	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
8691	56	530	_	_	NNP
8691	56	531	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	532	_	_	NNP
8691	56	533	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
8691	56	534	_	_	NNP
8691	56	535	v.	v.	IN
8691	56	536	_	_	NNP
8691	56	537	Anthes	Anthes	NNP
8691	56	538	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	57	1	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
8691	57	2	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
8691	57	3	.	.	.
8691	58	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	2	,	,	,
8691	58	3	Ward	Ward	NNP
8691	58	4	_	_	NNP
8691	58	5	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	6	_	_	NNP
8691	58	7	Consul	Consul	NNP
8691	58	8	of	of	IN
8691	58	9	Spain	Spain	NNP
8691	58	10	_	_	NNP
8691	58	11	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	12	_	_	NNP
8691	58	13	Consul	Consul	NNP
8691	58	14	of	of	IN
8691	58	15	Great	Great	NNP
8691	58	16	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	58	17	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
8691	58	18	,	,	,
8691	58	19	Application	Application	NNP
8691	58	20	of	of	IN
8691	58	21	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
8691	58	22	,	,	,
8691	58	23	_	_	NNP
8691	58	24	In	In	NNP
8691	58	25	re	re	NN
8691	58	26	_	_	NNP
8691	58	27	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
8691	58	28	,	,	,
8691	58	29	In	in	IN
8691	58	30	the	the	DT
8691	58	31	matter	matter	NN
8691	58	32	of	of	IN
8691	58	33	Copass	Copass	NNP
8691	58	34	,	,	,
8691	58	35	Hall	Hall	NNP
8691	58	36	-	-	HYPH
8691	58	37	Moody	Moody	NNP
8691	58	38	Institute	Institute	NNP
8691	58	39	_	_	NNP
8691	58	40	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	41	_	_	NNP
8691	58	42	Croswell	Croswell	NNP
8691	58	43	,	,	,
8691	58	44	People	People	NNPS
8691	58	45	_	_	NNP
8691	58	46	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	47	_	_	NNP
8691	58	48	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
8691	58	49	,	,	,
8691	58	50	State	State	NNP
8691	58	51	_	_	NNP
8691	58	52	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	53	_	_	NNP
8691	58	54	Danbury	Danbury	NNP
8691	58	55	,	,	,
8691	58	56	Hoyt	Hoyt	NNP
8691	58	57	_	_	NNP
8691	58	58	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	59	_	_	NNP
8691	58	60	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
8691	58	61	College	College	NNP
8691	58	62	_	_	NNP
8691	58	63	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	64	_	_	NNP
8691	58	65	Woodward	Woodward	NNP
8691	58	66	Debs	Debs	NNP
8691	58	67	,	,	,
8691	58	68	U.	U.	NNP
8691	58	69	S.	S.	NNP
8691	58	70	_	_	NNP
8691	58	71	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	72	_	_	NNP
8691	58	73	Debs	Debs	NNP
8691	58	74	,	,	,
8691	58	75	_	_	NNP
8691	58	76	In	In	NNP
8691	58	77	re	re	NN
8691	58	78	_	_	NNP
8691	58	79	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
8691	58	80	,	,	,
8691	58	81	Lackawanna	Lackawanna	NNP
8691	58	82	and	and	CC
8691	58	83	Western	Western	NNP
8691	58	84	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	85	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	86	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	87	,	,	,
8691	58	88	Forepaugh	Forepaugh	NNP
8691	58	89	_	_	NNP
8691	58	90	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	91	_	_	NNP
8691	58	92	Demorest	Demorest	NNP
8691	58	93	,	,	,
8691	58	94	Hutkoff	Hutkoff	NNP
8691	58	95	,	,	,
8691	58	96	_	_	NNP
8691	58	97	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	98	_	_	NNP
8691	58	99	Dennison	Dennison	NNP
8691	58	100	,	,	,
8691	58	101	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	58	102	_	_	NNP
8691	58	103	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	104	_	_	NNP
8691	58	105	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
8691	58	106	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	58	107	_	_	NNP
8691	58	108	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	109	_	_	NNP
8691	58	110	Frankfort	Frankfort	NNP
8691	58	111	Dickerson	Dickerson	NNP
8691	58	112	,	,	,
8691	58	113	Bissell	Bissell	NNP
8691	58	114	_	_	NNP
8691	58	115	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	116	_	_	NNP
8691	58	117	Diggs	Diggs	NNP
8691	58	118	_	_	NNP
8691	58	119	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	120	_	_	NNP
8691	58	121	Wolcott	Wolcott	NNP
8691	58	122	Donoghue	Donoghue	NNP
8691	58	123	,	,	,
8691	58	124	Hanley	Hanley	NNP
8691	58	125	_	_	NNP
8691	58	126	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	127	_	_	NNP
8691	58	128	Dorr	Dorr	NNP
8691	58	129	_	_	NNP
8691	58	130	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	131	_	_	NNP
8691	58	132	United	United	NNP
8691	58	133	States	States	NNP
8691	58	134	Dorrance	Dorrance	NNP
8691	58	135	,	,	,
8691	58	136	Vanhorne	Vanhorne	NNP
8691	58	137	's	's	POS
8691	58	138	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
8691	58	139	,	,	,
8691	58	140	_	_	NNP
8691	58	141	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	142	_	_	NNP
8691	58	143	Dougherty	Dougherty	NNP
8691	58	144	,	,	,
8691	58	145	Lanark	Lanark	NNP
8691	58	146	_	_	NNP
8691	58	147	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	148	_	_	NNP
8691	58	149	Dow	Dow	NNP
8691	58	150	_	_	NNP
8691	58	151	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	152	_	_	NNP
8691	58	153	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	58	154	Downes	Downes	NNPS
8691	58	155	_	_	NNP
8691	58	156	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	157	_	_	NNP
8691	58	158	Bidwell	Bidwell	NNP
8691	58	159	Dred	Dred	NNP
8691	58	160	Scott	Scott	NNP
8691	58	161	_	_	NNP
8691	58	162	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	163	_	_	NNP
8691	58	164	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
8691	58	165	Drehman	Drehman	NNP
8691	58	166	_	_	NNP
8691	58	167	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	168	_	_	NNP
8691	58	169	Stifle	Stifle	NNP
8691	58	170	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
8691	58	171	,	,	,
8691	58	172	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	58	173	of	of	IN
8691	58	174	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	58	175	_	_	NNP
8691	58	176	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	177	_	_	NNP
8691	58	178	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
8691	58	179	,	,	,
8691	58	180	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	58	181	_	_	NNP
8691	58	182	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	183	_	_	NNP
8691	58	184	Dyson	Dyson	NNP
8691	58	185	_	_	NNP
8691	58	186	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	187	_	_	NNP
8691	58	188	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	58	189	Island	Island	NNP
8691	58	190	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	191	Eakin	Eakin	NNP
8691	58	192	_	_	NNP
8691	58	193	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	194	_	_	NNP
8691	58	195	Raub	Raub	NNP
8691	58	196	Eckrich	Eckrich	NNP
8691	58	197	_	_	NNP
8691	58	198	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	199	_	_	NNP
8691	58	200	St.	St.	NNP
8691	58	201	Louis	Louis	NNP
8691	58	202	Transit	Transit	NNP
8691	58	203	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	204	Ellington	Ellington	NNP
8691	58	205	,	,	,
8691	58	206	Miel	Miel	NNP
8691	58	207	_	_	NNP
8691	58	208	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	209	_	_	NNP
8691	58	210	Erdman	Erdman	NNP
8691	58	211	_	_	NNP
8691	58	212	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	213	_	_	NNP
8691	58	214	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
8691	58	215	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
8691	58	216	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	58	217	_	_	NNP
8691	58	218	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	219	_	_	NNP
8691	58	220	Rice	Rice	NNP
8691	58	221	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
8691	58	222	'	'	POS
8691	58	223	Loan	Loan	NNP
8691	58	224	and	and	CC
8691	58	225	Trust	Trust	NNP
8691	58	226	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	227	,	,	,
8691	58	228	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
8691	58	229	_	_	NNP
8691	58	230	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	231	_	_	NNP
8691	58	232	Faulkner	Faulkner	NNP
8691	58	233	_	_	NNP
8691	58	234	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	235	_	_	NNP
8691	58	236	Hart	Hart	NNP
8691	58	237	Finney	Finney	NNP
8691	58	238	_	_	NNP
8691	58	239	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	240	_	_	NNP
8691	58	241	Guy	Guy	NNP
8691	58	242	Fish	Fish	NNP
8691	58	243	_	_	NNP
8691	58	244	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	245	_	_	NNP
8691	58	246	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	58	247	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
8691	58	248	,	,	,
8691	58	249	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
8691	58	250	_	_	NNP
8691	58	251	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	252	_	_	NNP
8691	58	253	Fitch	Fitch	NNP
8691	58	254	_	_	NNP
8691	58	255	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	256	_	_	NNP
8691	58	257	Brainerd	Brainerd	NNP
8691	58	258	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
8691	58	259	_	_	NNP
8691	58	260	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	261	_	_	NNP
8691	58	262	Peck	Peck	NNP
8691	58	263	Flynn	Flynn	NNP
8691	58	264	_	_	NNP
8691	58	265	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	266	_	_	NNP
8691	58	267	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
8691	58	268	Forepaugh	Forepaugh	NNP
8691	58	269	_	_	NNP
8691	58	270	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	271	_	_	NNP
8691	58	272	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
8691	58	273	,	,	,
8691	58	274	Lackawanna	Lackawanna	NNP
8691	58	275	and	and	CC
8691	58	276	Western	Western	NNP
8691	58	277	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	278	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	279	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	280	Frankfort	Frankfort	NNP
8691	58	281	,	,	,
8691	58	282	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
8691	58	283	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	58	284	_	_	NNP
8691	58	285	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	286	_	_	NNP
8691	58	287	French	French	NNP
8691	58	288	_	_	NNP
8691	58	289	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	290	_	_	NNP
8691	58	291	Waterbury	Waterbury	NNP
8691	58	292	Frost	Frost	NNP
8691	58	293	_	_	NNP
8691	58	294	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	295	_	_	NNP
8691	58	296	Leighton	Leighton	NNP
8691	58	297	Gaither	Gaither	NNP
8691	58	298	,	,	,
8691	58	299	Bodley	Bodley	NNP
8691	58	300	_	_	NNP
8691	58	301	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	302	_	_	NNP
8691	58	303	Garland	Garland	NNP
8691	58	304	,	,	,
8691	58	305	_	_	NNP
8691	58	306	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	58	307	parte	parte	NN
8691	58	308	_	_	NNP
8691	58	309	Garrett	Garrett	NNP
8691	58	310	,	,	,
8691	58	311	Briggs	Briggs	NNP
8691	58	312	_	_	NNP
8691	58	313	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	314	_	_	NNP
8691	58	315	Genesee	Genesee	NNP
8691	58	316	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	58	317	,	,	,
8691	58	318	The	the	DT
8691	58	319	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	58	320	_	_	NNP
8691	58	321	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	322	_	_	NNP
8691	58	323	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
8691	58	324	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	58	325	,	,	,
8691	58	326	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
8691	58	327	Nation	Nation	NNP
8691	58	328	_	_	NNP
8691	58	329	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	330	_	_	NNP
8691	58	331	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	58	332	,	,	,
8691	58	333	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
8691	58	334	_	_	NNP
8691	58	335	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	336	_	_	NNP
8691	58	337	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	58	338	,	,	,
8691	58	339	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
8691	58	340	_	_	NNP
8691	58	341	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	342	_	_	NNP
8691	58	343	Gernon	Gernon	NNP
8691	58	344	_	_	NNP
8691	58	345	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	346	_	_	NNP
8691	58	347	Cochran	Cochran	NNP
8691	58	348	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
8691	58	349	_	_	NNP
8691	58	350	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	351	_	_	NNP
8691	58	352	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
8691	58	353	Goshen	Goshen	NNP
8691	58	354	_	_	NNP
8691	58	355	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	356	_	_	NNP
8691	58	357	Stonington	Stonington	NNP
8691	58	358	Gould	Gould	NNP
8691	58	359	_	_	NNP
8691	58	360	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	361	_	_	NNP
8691	58	362	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
8691	58	363	River	River	NNP
8691	58	364	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	365	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	366	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	367	Grady	Grady	NNP
8691	58	368	's	's	POS
8691	58	369	case	case	NN
8691	58	370	Grapeshot	Grapeshot	NNP
8691	58	371	,	,	,
8691	58	372	The	the	DT
8691	58	373	Gray	Gray	NNP
8691	58	374	,	,	,
8691	58	375	James	James	NNP
8691	58	376	_	_	NNP
8691	58	377	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	378	_	_	NNP
8691	58	379	Green	Green	NNP
8691	58	380	_	_	NNP
8691	58	381	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	382	_	_	NNP
8691	58	383	Biddle	Biddle	NNP
8691	58	384	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
8691	58	385	_	_	NNP
8691	58	386	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	387	_	_	NNP
8691	58	388	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
8691	58	389	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
8691	58	390	,	,	,
8691	58	391	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
8691	58	392	_	_	NNP
8691	58	393	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	394	_	_	NNP
8691	58	395	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
8691	58	396	,	,	,
8691	58	397	United	United	NNP
8691	58	398	States	States	NNP
8691	58	399	_	_	NNP
8691	58	400	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	401	_	_	NNP
8691	58	402	Grover	Grover	NNP
8691	58	403	&	&	CC
8691	58	404	Baker	Baker	NNP
8691	58	405	Sewing	Sewing	NNP
8691	58	406	Machine	Machine	NNP
8691	58	407	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	408	_	_	NNP
8691	58	409	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	410	_	_	NNP
8691	58	411	Radcliffe	Radcliffe	NNP
8691	58	412	Groves	Groves	NNP
8691	58	413	_	_	NNP
8691	58	414	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	415	_	_	NNP
8691	58	416	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
8691	58	417	Guy	Guy	NNP
8691	58	418	,	,	,
8691	58	419	Finney	Finney	NNP
8691	58	420	_	_	NNP
8691	58	421	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	422	_	_	NNP
8691	58	423	Hale	Hale	NNP
8691	58	424	_	_	NNP
8691	58	425	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	426	_	_	NNP
8691	58	427	Allinson	Allinson	NNP
8691	58	428	Hall	Hall	NNP
8691	58	429	-	-	HYPH
8691	58	430	Moody	Moody	NNP
8691	58	431	Institute	Institute	NNP
8691	58	432	_	_	NNP
8691	58	433	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	434	_	_	NNP
8691	58	435	Co	Co	NNP
8691	58	436	-	-	NN
8691	58	437	pass	pass	NNP
8691	58	438	Ham	Ham	NNP
8691	58	439	_	_	NNP
8691	58	440	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	441	_	_	NNP
8691	58	442	McClaws	McClaws	NNP
8691	58	443	Hanley	Hanley	NNP
8691	58	444	_	_	NNP
8691	58	445	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	446	_	_	NNP
8691	58	447	Donoghue	Donoghue	NNP
8691	58	448	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
8691	58	449	National	National	NNP
8691	58	450	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	58	451	_	_	NNP
8691	58	452	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	453	_	_	NNP
8691	58	454	Moyses	Moyses	NNPS
8691	58	455	Hans	Hans	NNP
8691	58	456	_	_	NNP
8691	58	457	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	458	_	_	NNP
8691	58	459	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	58	460	Harris	Harris	NNP
8691	58	461	,	,	,
8691	58	462	Norris	Norris	NNP
8691	58	463	_	_	NNP
8691	58	464	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	465	_	_	NNP
8691	58	466	Hart	Hart	NNP
8691	58	467	,	,	,
8691	58	468	Faulkner	Faulkner	NNP
8691	58	469	_	_	NNP
8691	58	470	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	471	_	_	NNP
8691	58	472	Hawes	Hawes	NNP
8691	58	473	_	_	NNP
8691	58	474	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	475	_	_	NNP
8691	58	476	Oakland	Oakland	NNP
8691	58	477	Hayburn	Hayburn	NNP
8691	58	478	's	's	POS
8691	58	479	Case	Case	NNP
8691	58	480	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
8691	58	481	_	_	NNP
8691	58	482	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	483	_	_	NNP
8691	58	484	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
8691	58	485	Heywood	Heywood	NNP
8691	58	486	,	,	,
8691	58	487	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
8691	58	488	_	_	NNP
8691	58	489	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	490	_	_	NNP
8691	58	491	Hickman	Hickman	NNP
8691	58	492	_	_	NNP
8691	58	493	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	494	_	_	NNP
8691	58	495	Boffman	Boffman	NNP
8691	58	496	Hildreth	Hildreth	NNP
8691	58	497	's	's	POS
8691	58	498	Heirs	Heirs	NNPS
8691	58	499	_	_	NNP
8691	58	500	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	501	_	_	NNP
8691	58	502	McIntire	McIntire	NNP
8691	58	503	's	's	POS
8691	58	504	Devisee	Devisee	NNP
8691	58	505	Hill	Hill	NNP
8691	58	506	_	_	NNP
8691	58	507	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	508	_	_	NNP
8691	58	509	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	58	510	Hill	Hill	NNP
8691	58	511	,	,	,
8691	58	512	Koehler	Koehler	NNP
8691	58	513	_	_	NNP
8691	58	514	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	515	_	_	NNP
8691	58	516	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
8691	58	517	,	,	,
8691	58	518	People	People	NNPS
8691	58	519	_	_	NNP
8691	58	520	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	521	_	_	NNP
8691	58	522	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
8691	58	523	_	_	NNP
8691	58	524	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	525	_	_	NNP
8691	58	526	Walton	Walton	NNP
8691	58	527	Houseman	Houseman	NNP
8691	58	528	,	,	,
8691	58	529	Claflin	Claflin	NNP
8691	58	530	_	_	NNP
8691	58	531	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	532	_	_	NNP
8691	58	533	Houser	Houser	NNP
8691	58	534	,	,	,
8691	58	535	State	State	NNP
8691	58	536	_	_	NNP
8691	58	537	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	538	_	_	NNP
8691	58	539	Howle	Howle	NNP
8691	58	540	,	,	,
8691	58	541	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
8691	58	542	Life	Life	NNP
8691	58	543	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	58	544	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	545	_	_	NNP
8691	58	546	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	547	_	_	NNP
8691	58	548	Hoyt	Hoyt	NNP
8691	58	549	_	_	NNP
8691	58	550	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	551	_	_	NNP
8691	58	552	Danbury	Danbury	NNP
8691	58	553	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
8691	58	554	River	River	NNP
8691	58	555	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	556	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	557	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	558	,	,	,
8691	58	559	Gould	Gould	NNP
8691	58	560	_	_	NNP
8691	58	561	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	562	_	_	NNP
8691	58	563	Huntley	Huntley	NNP
8691	58	564	,	,	,
8691	58	565	Calvin	Calvin	NNP
8691	58	566	_	_	NNP
8691	58	567	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	568	_	_	NNP
8691	58	569	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
8691	58	570	,	,	,
8691	58	571	_	_	NNP
8691	58	572	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	573	_	_	NNP
8691	58	574	California	California	NNP
8691	58	575	Hutkoff	Hutkoff	NNP
8691	58	576	_	_	NNP
8691	58	577	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	578	_	_	NNP
8691	58	579	Demorest	Demorest	NNP
8691	58	580	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	58	581	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	582	,	,	,
8691	58	583	Brine	Brine	NNP
8691	58	584	_	_	NNP
8691	58	585	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	586	_	_	NNP
8691	58	587	International	International	NNP
8691	58	588	Distillery	Distillery	NNP
8691	58	589	,	,	,
8691	58	590	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
8691	58	591	_	_	NNP
8691	58	592	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	593	_	_	NNP
8691	58	594	Irvine	Irvine	NNP
8691	58	595	_	_	NNP
8691	58	596	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	597	_	_	NNP
8691	58	598	Stone	Stone	NNP
8691	58	599	James	James	NNP
8691	58	600	_	_	NNP
8691	58	601	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	602	_	_	NNP
8691	58	603	Gray	Gray	NNP
8691	58	604	Jecker	Jecker	NNP
8691	58	605	_	_	NNP
8691	58	606	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	607	_	_	NNP
8691	58	608	Montgomery	Montgomery	NNP
8691	58	609	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	58	610	_	_	NNP
8691	58	611	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	612	_	_	NNP
8691	58	613	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
8691	58	614	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	58	615	_	_	NNP
8691	58	616	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	617	_	_	NNP
8691	58	618	People	People	NNP
8691	58	619	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	58	620	,	,	,
8691	58	621	Dow	Dow	NNP
8691	58	622	_	_	NNP
8691	58	623	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	624	_	_	NNP
8691	58	625	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	58	626	,	,	,
8691	58	627	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	58	628	_	_	NNP
8691	58	629	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	630	_	_	NNP
8691	58	631	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	58	632	,	,	,
8691	58	633	State	State	NNP
8691	58	634	_	_	NNP
8691	58	635	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	636	_	_	NNP
8691	58	637	Joint	Joint	NNP
8691	58	638	Traffic	Traffic	NNP
8691	58	639	Association	Association	NNP
8691	58	640	,	,	,
8691	58	641	United	United	NNP
8691	58	642	States	States	NNP
8691	58	643	_	_	NNP
8691	58	644	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	645	_	_	NNP
8691	58	646	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	58	647	,	,	,
8691	58	648	State	State	NNP
8691	58	649	_	_	NNP
8691	58	650	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	651	_	_	NNP
8691	58	652	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
8691	58	653	,	,	,
8691	58	654	Ames	Ames	NNP
8691	58	655	_	_	NNP
8691	58	656	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	657	_	_	NNP
8691	58	658	Katz	Katz	NNP
8691	58	659	_	_	NNP
8691	58	660	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	661	_	_	NNP
8691	58	662	Walkinshaw	Walkinshaw	NNP
8691	58	663	Kellogg	Kellogg	NNP
8691	58	664	_	_	NNP
8691	58	665	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	666	_	_	NNP
8691	58	667	Brown	Brown	NNP
8691	58	668	Kellogg	Kellogg	NNP
8691	58	669	_	_	NNP
8691	58	670	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	671	_	_	NNP
8691	58	672	Warmoth	Warmoth	NNP
8691	58	673	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	58	674	_	_	NNP
8691	58	675	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	676	_	_	NNP
8691	58	677	Dennison	Dennison	NNP
8691	58	678	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	58	679	,	,	,
8691	58	680	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
8691	58	681	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
8691	58	682	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	683	_	_	NNP
8691	58	684	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	685	_	_	NNP
8691	58	686	Kepner	Kepner	NNP
8691	58	687	_	_	NNP
8691	58	688	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	689	_	_	NNP
8691	58	690	U.	U.	NNP
8691	58	691	S.	S.	NNP
8691	58	692	Ketcham	Ketcham	NNP
8691	58	693	_	_	NNP
8691	58	694	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	695	_	_	NNP
8691	58	696	McNamara	McNamara	NNP
8691	58	697	Kilbourn	Kilbourn	NNP
8691	58	698	_	_	NNP
8691	58	699	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	700	_	_	NNP
8691	58	701	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
8691	58	702	Klein	Klein	NNP
8691	58	703	,	,	,
8691	58	704	U.	U.	NNP
8691	58	705	S.	S.	NNP
8691	58	706	_	_	NNP
8691	58	707	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	708	_	_	NNP
8691	58	709	Kneedler	Kneedler	NNP
8691	58	710	_	_	NNP
8691	58	711	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	712	_	_	NNP
8691	58	713	Lane	Lane	NNP
8691	58	714	Koehler	Koehler	NNP
8691	58	715	_	_	NNP
8691	58	716	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	717	_	_	NNP
8691	58	718	Hill	Hill	NNP
8691	58	719	Lachenmeyer	Lachenmeyer	NNP
8691	58	720	,	,	,
8691	58	721	Pepin	Pepin	NNP
8691	58	722	_	_	NNP
8691	58	723	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	724	_	_	NNP
8691	58	725	Lanark	Lanark	NNP
8691	58	726	_	_	NNP
8691	58	727	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	728	_	_	NNP
8691	58	729	Dougherty	Dougherty	NNP
8691	58	730	La	La	NNP
8691	58	731	Ninfa	Ninfa	NNP
8691	58	732	,	,	,
8691	58	733	The	the	DT
8691	58	734	Lane	Lane	NNP
8691	58	735	,	,	,
8691	58	736	Kneedler	Kneedler	NNP
8691	58	737	_	_	NNP
8691	58	738	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	739	_	_	NNP
8691	58	740	Lapsley	Lapsley	NNP
8691	58	741	_	_	NNP
8691	58	742	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	743	_	_	NNP
8691	58	744	Brashears	Brashears	NNP
8691	58	745	Lee	Lee	NNP
8691	58	746	,	,	,
8691	58	747	State	State	NNP
8691	58	748	_	_	NNP
8691	58	749	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	750	_	_	NNP
8691	58	751	Legal	Legal	NNP
8691	58	752	Tender	Tender	NNP
8691	58	753	Cases	Cases	NNPS
8691	58	754	,	,	,
8691	58	755	The	the	DT
8691	58	756	Lehigh	Lehigh	NNP
8691	58	757	Coal	Coal	NNP
8691	58	758	and	and	CC
8691	58	759	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
8691	58	760	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	761	,	,	,
8691	58	762	Bachert	Bachert	NNP
8691	58	763	_	_	NNP
8691	58	764	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	765	_	_	NNP
8691	58	766	Leighton	Leighton	NNP
8691	58	767	,	,	,
8691	58	768	Frost	Frost	NNP
8691	58	769	_	_	NNP
8691	58	770	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	771	_	_	NNP
8691	58	772	,	,	,
8691	58	773	Lennon	Lennon	NNP
8691	58	774	_	_	NNP
8691	58	775	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	776	_	_	NNP
8691	58	777	Rawitzer	Rawitzer	NNP
8691	58	778	,	,	,
8691	58	779	Letson	Letson	NNP
8691	58	780	,	,	,
8691	58	781	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
8691	58	782	,	,	,
8691	58	783	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
8691	58	784	and	and	CC
8691	58	785	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
8691	58	786	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	787	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	788	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	789	_	_	NNP
8691	58	790	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	791	_	_	NNP
8691	58	792	,	,	,
8691	58	793	Little	Little	NNP
8691	58	794	Charles	Charles	NNP
8691	58	795	,	,	,
8691	58	796	The	the	DT
8691	58	797	schooner	schooner	NN
8691	58	798	,	,	,
8691	58	799	U.	U.	NNP
8691	58	800	S.	S.	NNP
8691	58	801	_	_	NNP
8691	58	802	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	803	_	_	NNP
8691	58	804	,	,	,
8691	58	805	Loan	Loan	NNP
8691	58	806	Association	Association	NNP
8691	58	807	_	_	NNP
8691	58	808	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	809	_	_	NNP
8691	58	810	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
8691	58	811	,	,	,
8691	58	812	Loomis	Loomis	NNP
8691	58	813	_	_	NNP
8691	58	814	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	815	_	_	NNP
8691	58	816	Newhali	Newhali	NNP
8691	58	817	,	,	,
8691	58	818	Lottawanna	Lottawanna	NNP
8691	58	819	,	,	,
8691	58	820	The	the	DT
8691	58	821	,	,	,
8691	58	822	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	58	823	,	,	,
8691	58	824	Hans	Hans	NNP
8691	58	825	,	,	,
8691	58	826	_	_	NNP
8691	58	827	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	828	_	_	NNP
8691	58	829	,	,	,
8691	58	830	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
8691	58	831	,	,	,
8691	58	832	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
8691	58	833	and	and	CC
8691	58	834	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
8691	58	835	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	836	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	837	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	838	_	_	NNP
8691	58	839	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	840	_	_	NNP
8691	58	841	Letson	Letson	NNP
8691	58	842	,	,	,
8691	58	843	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
8691	58	844	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
8691	58	845	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	846	_	_	NNP
8691	58	847	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	848	_	_	NNP
8691	58	849	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	58	850	,	,	,
8691	58	851	Luke	Luke	NNP
8691	58	852	_	_	NNP
8691	58	853	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	854	_	_	NNP
8691	58	855	Lyde	Lyde	NNP
8691	58	856	,	,	,
8691	58	857	Luther	Luther	NNP
8691	58	858	_	_	NNP
8691	58	859	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	860	_	_	NNP
8691	58	861	Borden	Borden	NNP
8691	58	862	,	,	,
8691	58	863	Lyde	Lyde	NNP
8691	58	864	,	,	,
8691	58	865	Luke	Luke	NNP
8691	58	866	_	_	NNP
8691	58	867	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	868	_	_	NNP
8691	58	869	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
8691	58	870	,	,	,
8691	58	871	_	_	NNP
8691	58	872	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	58	873	parte	parte	NN
8691	58	874	_	_	NNP
8691	58	875	,	,	,
8691	58	876	McClaws	McClaws	NNP
8691	58	877	,	,	,
8691	58	878	Ham	Ham	NNP
8691	58	879	_	_	NNP
8691	58	880	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	881	_	_	NNP
8691	58	882	,	,	,
8691	58	883	McCloskey	McCloskey	NNP
8691	58	884	_	_	NNP
8691	58	885	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	886	_	_	NNP
8691	58	887	Bell	Bell	NNP
8691	58	888	's	's	POS
8691	58	889	Gap	Gap	NNP
8691	58	890	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	891	R.	R.	NNP
8691	58	892	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	58	893	,	,	,
8691	58	894	McClung	McClung	NNP
8691	58	895	,	,	,
8691	58	896	Blake	Blake	NNP
8691	58	897	_	_	NNP
8691	58	898	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	899	_	_	NNP
8691	58	900	,	,	,
8691	58	901	McConnaughy	McConnaughy	NNP
8691	58	902	,	,	,
8691	58	903	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
8691	58	904	_	_	NNP
8691	58	905	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	906	_	_	NNP
8691	58	907	,	,	,
8691	58	908	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
8691	58	909	_	_	NNP
8691	58	910	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	911	_	_	NNP
8691	58	912	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	58	913	,	,	,
8691	58	914	McDaniel	McDaniel	NNP
8691	58	915	,	,	,
8691	58	916	Terry	Terry	NNP
8691	58	917	_	_	NNP
8691	58	918	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	919	_	_	NNP
8691	58	920	,	,	,
8691	58	921	McDowell	McDowell	NNP
8691	58	922	_	_	NNP
8691	58	923	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	924	_	_	NNP
8691	58	925	Oyer	Oyer	NNP
8691	58	926	,	,	,
8691	58	927	McFarland	McFarland	NNP
8691	58	928	_	_	NNP
8691	58	929	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	930	_	_	NNP
8691	58	931	People	People	NNPS
8691	58	932	,	,	,
8691	58	933	McIntire	McIntire	NNP
8691	58	934	's	's	POS
8691	58	935	Devisee	Devisee	NNP
8691	58	936	,	,	,
8691	58	937	Hildreth	Hildreth	NNP
8691	58	938	's	's	POS
8691	58	939	Heirs	Heirs	NNP
8691	58	940	_	_	NNP
8691	58	941	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	942	_	_	NNP
8691	58	943	,	,	,
8691	58	944	M'Kim	M'Kim	NNP
8691	58	945	_	_	NNP
8691	58	946	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	947	_	_	NNP
8691	58	948	Voorhies	Voorhies	NNPS
8691	58	949	,	,	,
8691	58	950	McLeod	McLeod	NNP
8691	58	951	's	's	POS
8691	58	952	Case	Case	NNP
8691	58	953	,	,	,
8691	58	954	McNamara	McNamara	NNP
8691	58	955	,	,	,
8691	58	956	Ketcham	Ketcham	NNP
8691	58	957	_	_	NNP
8691	58	958	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	959	_	_	NNP
8691	58	960	,	,	,
8691	58	961	McVeigh	McVeigh	NNP
8691	58	962	_	_	NNP
8691	58	963	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	964	_	_	NNP
8691	58	965	Ripley	Ripley	NNP
8691	58	966	Madison	Madison	NNP
8691	58	967	,	,	,
8691	58	968	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
8691	58	969	_	_	NNP
8691	58	970	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	971	_	_	NNP
8691	58	972	,	,	,
8691	58	973	Main	Main	NNP
8691	58	974	,	,	,
8691	58	975	State	State	NNP
8691	58	976	_	_	NNP
8691	58	977	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	978	_	_	NNP
8691	58	979	,	,	,
8691	58	980	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
8691	58	981	_	_	NNP
8691	58	982	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	983	_	_	NNP
8691	58	984	Madison	Madison	NNP
8691	58	985	,	,	,
8691	58	986	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	58	987	,	,	,
8691	58	988	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
8691	58	989	_	_	NNP
8691	58	990	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	991	_	_	NNP
8691	58	992	,	,	,
8691	58	993	Mather	Mather	NNP
8691	58	994	,	,	,
8691	58	995	Rand	Rand	NNP
8691	58	996	_	_	NNP
8691	58	997	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	998	_	_	NNP
8691	58	999	,	,	,
8691	58	1000	Merriman	Merriman	NNP
8691	58	1001	_	_	NNP
8691	58	1002	v.	v.	IN
8691	58	1003	_	_	NNP
8691	58	1004	Social	Social	NNP
8691	58	1005	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
8691	58	1006	.	.	.
8691	59	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	59	2	,	,	,
8691	59	3	Merryman	Merryman	NNP
8691	59	4	,	,	,
8691	59	5	_	_	NNP
8691	59	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	59	7	parte	parte	NNP
8691	59	8	_	_	NNP
8691	59	9	,	,	,
8691	59	10	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
8691	59	11	Life	Life	NNP
8691	59	12	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	59	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	59	14	_	_	NNP
8691	59	15	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	16	_	_	NNP
8691	59	17	Howle	Howle	NNP
8691	59	18	,	,	,
8691	59	19	Mial	Mial	NNP
8691	59	20	_	_	NNP
8691	59	21	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	22	_	_	NNP
8691	59	23	Ellington	Ellington	NNP
8691	59	24	,	,	,
8691	59	25	Middleton	Middleton	NNP
8691	59	26	,	,	,
8691	59	27	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
8691	59	28	_	_	NNP
8691	59	29	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	30	_	_	NNP
8691	59	31	,	,	,
8691	59	32	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
8691	59	33	,	,	,
8691	59	34	_	_	NNP
8691	59	35	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	59	36	parte	parte	NNP
8691	59	37	_	_	NNP
8691	59	38	,	,	,
8691	59	39	Miln	Miln	NNP
8691	59	40	,	,	,
8691	59	41	New	New	NNP
8691	59	42	York	York	NNP
8691	59	43	_	_	NNP
8691	59	44	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	45	_	_	NNP
8691	59	46	,	,	,
8691	59	47	Mincey	Mincey	NNP
8691	59	48	_	_	NNP
8691	59	49	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	50	_	_	NNP
8691	59	51	Bradburn	Bradburn	NNP
8691	59	52	,	,	,
8691	59	53	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	59	54	_	_	NNP
8691	59	55	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	56	_	_	NNP
8691	59	57	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	59	58	,	,	,
8691	59	59	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
8691	59	60	,	,	,
8691	59	61	Canfield	Canfield	NNP
8691	59	62	_	_	NNP
8691	59	63	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	64	_	_	NNP
8691	59	65	,	,	,
8691	59	66	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
8691	59	67	,	,	,
8691	59	68	Erdman	Erdman	NNP
8691	59	69	_	_	NNP
8691	59	70	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	71	_	_	NNP
8691	59	72	,	,	,
8691	59	73	Montgomery	Montgomery	NNP
8691	59	74	,	,	,
8691	59	75	Jecker	Jecker	NNP
8691	59	76	_	_	NNP
8691	59	77	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	78	_	_	NNP
8691	59	79	,	,	,
8691	59	80	Moore	Moore	NNP
8691	59	81	,	,	,
8691	59	82	_	_	NNP
8691	59	83	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	59	84	parte	parte	NN
8691	59	85	_	_	NNP
8691	59	86	,	,	,
8691	59	87	Moore	Moore	NNP
8691	59	88	,	,	,
8691	59	89	Batchelder	Batchelder	NNP
8691	59	90	_	_	NNP
8691	59	91	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	92	_	_	NNP
8691	59	93	,	,	,
8691	59	94	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
8691	59	95	,	,	,
8691	59	96	Flynn	Flynn	NNP
8691	59	97	_	_	NNP
8691	59	98	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	99	_	_	NNP
8691	59	100	,	,	,
8691	59	101	Mormon	Mormon	NNP
8691	59	102	Church	Church	NNP
8691	59	103	_	_	NNP
8691	59	104	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	105	_	_	NNP
8691	59	106	United	United	NNP
8691	59	107	States	States	NNP
8691	59	108	,	,	,
8691	59	109	Morrill	Morrill	NNP
8691	59	110	,	,	,
8691	59	111	State	State	NNP
8691	59	112	_	_	NNP
8691	59	113	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	114	_	_	NNP
8691	59	115	,	,	,
8691	59	116	Moses	Moses	NNP
8691	59	117	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
8691	59	118	,	,	,
8691	59	119	The	the	DT
8691	59	120	,	,	,
8691	59	121	Moyses	Moyses	NNP
8691	59	122	,	,	,
8691	59	123	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
8691	59	124	National	National	NNP
8691	59	125	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	59	126	_	_	NNP
8691	59	127	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	128	_	_	NNP
8691	59	129	,	,	,
8691	59	130	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
8691	59	131	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
8691	59	132	Fund	Fund	NNP
8691	59	133	Life	Life	NNP
8691	59	134	Association	Association	NNP
8691	59	135	,	,	,
8691	59	136	Vincent	Vincent	NNP
8691	59	137	_	_	NNP
8691	59	138	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	139	_	_	NNP
8691	59	140	,	,	,
8691	59	141	Myers	Myers	NNP
8691	59	142	_	_	NNP
8691	59	143	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	144	_	_	NNP
8691	59	145	South	South	NNP
8691	59	146	Bethlehem	Bethlehem	NNP
8691	59	147	Nash	Nash	NNP
8691	59	148	,	,	,
8691	59	149	United	United	NNP
8691	59	150	States	States	NNP
8691	59	151	_	_	NNP
8691	59	152	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	153	_	_	NNP
8691	59	154	,	,	,
8691	59	155	Neagle	Neagle	NNP
8691	59	156	,	,	,
8691	59	157	_	_	NNP
8691	59	158	In	In	NNP
8691	59	159	re	re	NN
8691	59	160	_	_	NNP
8691	59	161	,	,	,
8691	59	162	Neff	Neff	NNP
8691	59	163	,	,	,
8691	59	164	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
8691	59	165	_	_	NNP
8691	59	166	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	167	_	_	NNP
8691	59	168	,	,	,
8691	59	169	Newhall	Newhall	NNP
8691	59	170	,	,	,
8691	59	171	Loomis	Loomis	NNP
8691	59	172	_	_	NNP
8691	59	173	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	174	_	_	NNP
8691	59	175	,	,	,
8691	59	176	New	New	NNP
8691	59	177	Haven	Haven	NNP
8691	59	178	,	,	,
8691	59	179	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
8691	59	180	_	_	NNP
8691	59	181	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	182	_	_	NNP
8691	59	183	,	,	,
8691	59	184	New	New	NNP
8691	59	185	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	59	186	_	_	NNP
8691	59	187	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	188	_	_	NNP
8691	59	189	New	New	NNP
8691	59	190	York	York	NNP
8691	59	191	,	,	,
8691	59	192	Newman	Newman	NNP
8691	59	193	,	,	,
8691	59	194	_	_	NNP
8691	59	195	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	59	196	parte	parte	NNP
8691	59	197	_	_	NNP
8691	59	198	,	,	,
8691	59	199	New	New	NNP
8691	59	200	York	York	NNP
8691	59	201	_	_	NNP
8691	59	202	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	203	_	_	NNP
8691	59	204	Miln	Miln	NNP
8691	59	205	,	,	,
8691	59	206	New	New	NNP
8691	59	207	York	York	NNP
8691	59	208	,	,	,
8691	59	209	New	New	NNP
8691	59	210	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	59	211	_	_	NNP
8691	59	212	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	213	_	_	NNP
8691	59	214	,	,	,
8691	59	215	New	New	NNP
8691	59	216	York	York	NNP
8691	59	217	and	and	CC
8691	59	218	New	New	NNP
8691	59	219	England	England	NNP
8691	59	220	R.	R.	NNP
8691	59	221	R.	R.	NNP
8691	59	222	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	59	223	,	,	,
8691	59	224	Rumsey	Rumsey	NNP
8691	59	225	_	_	NNP
8691	59	226	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	227	_	_	NNP
8691	59	228	,	,	,
8691	59	229	New	New	NNP
8691	59	230	York	York	NNP
8691	59	231	,	,	,
8691	59	232	New	New	NNP
8691	59	233	Haven	Haven	NNP
8691	59	234	and	and	CC
8691	59	235	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
8691	59	236	R.	R.	NNP
8691	59	237	R.	R.	NNP
8691	59	238	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	59	239	,	,	,
8691	59	240	Stack	Stack	NNP
8691	59	241	_	_	NNP
8691	59	242	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	243	_	_	NNP
8691	59	244	,	,	,
8691	59	245	Noble	Noble	NNP
8691	59	246	_	_	NNP
8691	59	247	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	248	_	_	NNP
8691	59	249	Union	Union	NNP
8691	59	250	River	River	NNP
8691	59	251	Logging	Logging	NNP
8691	59	252	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	59	253	,	,	,
8691	59	254	Norris	Norris	NNP
8691	59	255	_	_	NNP
8691	59	256	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	257	_	_	NNP
8691	59	258	Clymer	Clymer	NNP
8691	59	259	,	,	,
8691	59	260	Norris	Norris	NNP
8691	59	261	_	_	NNP
8691	59	262	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	263	_	_	NNP
8691	59	264	Harris	Harris	NNP
8691	59	265	,	,	,
8691	59	266	Northern	Northern	NNP
8691	59	267	Securities	Securities	NNPS
8691	59	268	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	59	269	_	_	NNP
8691	59	270	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	271	_	_	NNP
8691	59	272	United	United	NNP
8691	59	273	States	States	NNP
8691	59	274	,	,	,
8691	59	275	Norwalk	Norwalk	NNP
8691	59	276	Street	Street	NNP
8691	59	277	Railway	Railway	NNP
8691	59	278	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	59	279	's	's	POS
8691	59	280	Appeal	Appeal	NNP
8691	59	281	Nudd	Nudd	NNP
8691	59	282	_	_	NNP
8691	59	283	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	284	_	_	NNP
8691	59	285	Burrows	Burrows	NNP
8691	59	286	Oakland	Oakland	NNP
8691	59	287	,	,	,
8691	59	288	Hawes	Hawes	NNP
8691	59	289	_	_	NNP
8691	59	290	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	291	_	_	NNP
8691	59	292	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
8691	59	293	_	_	NNP
8691	59	294	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	295	_	_	NNP
8691	59	296	Saunders	Saunders	NNP
8691	59	297	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
8691	59	298	,	,	,
8691	59	299	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
8691	59	300	_	_	NNP
8691	59	301	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	302	_	_	NNP
8691	59	303	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	59	304	and	and	CC
8691	59	305	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	59	306	R.	R.	NNP
8691	59	307	R.	R.	NNP
8691	59	308	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	59	309	_	_	NNP
8691	59	310	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	311	_	_	NNP
8691	59	312	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
8691	59	313	Olcott	Olcott	NNP
8691	59	314	,	,	,
8691	59	315	People	People	NNP
8691	59	316	_	_	NNP
8691	59	317	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	318	_	_	NNP
8691	59	319	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
8691	59	320	_	_	NNP
8691	59	321	v.	v.	IN
8691	59	322	_	_	NNP
8691	59	323	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	59	324	of	of	IN
8691	59	325	the	the	DT
8691	59	326	U.	U.	NNP
8691	60	1	8	8	LS
8691	60	2	.	.	.
8691	61	1	Oyer	Oyer	NNP
8691	61	2	,	,	,
8691	61	3	McDowell	McDowell	NNP
8691	61	4	_	_	NNP
8691	61	5	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	6	_	_	NNP
8691	61	7	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
8691	61	8	_	_	NNP
8691	61	9	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	10	_	_	NNP
8691	61	11	Brown	Brown	NNP
8691	61	12	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
8691	61	13	,	,	,
8691	61	14	William	William	NNP
8691	61	15	Paul	Paul	NNP
8691	61	16	_	_	NNP
8691	61	17	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	18	_	_	NNP
8691	61	19	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	61	20	Pearne	Pearne	NNP
8691	61	21	,	,	,
8691	61	22	Church	Church	NNP
8691	61	23	_	_	NNP
8691	61	24	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	25	_	_	NNP
8691	61	26	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
8691	61	27	_	_	NNP
8691	61	28	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	29	_	_	NNP
8691	61	30	International	International	NNP
8691	61	31	Distillery	Distillery	NNP
8691	61	32	Pease	Pease	NNP
8691	61	33	,	,	,
8691	61	34	Starr	Starr	NNP
8691	61	35	_	_	NNP
8691	61	36	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	37	_	_	NNP
8691	61	38	Peck	Peck	NNP
8691	61	39	,	,	,
8691	61	40	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
8691	61	41	_	_	NNP
8691	61	42	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	43	_	_	NNP
8691	61	44	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
8691	61	45	_	_	NNP
8691	61	46	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	47	_	_	NNP
8691	61	48	McConnaughy	McConnaughy	NNP
8691	61	49	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
8691	61	50	_	_	NNP
8691	61	51	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	52	_	_	NNP
8691	61	53	Neff	Neff	NNP
8691	61	54	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	61	55	,	,	,
8691	61	56	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
8691	61	57	_	_	NNP
8691	61	58	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	59	_	_	NNP
8691	61	60	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	61	61	Coal	Coal	NNP
8691	61	62	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	61	63	,	,	,
8691	61	64	Sanderson	Sanderson	NNP
8691	61	65	_	_	NNP
8691	61	66	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	67	_	_	NNP
8691	61	68	People	People	NNPS
8691	61	69	_	_	NNP
8691	61	70	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	71	_	_	NNP
8691	61	72	Croswell	Croswell	NNP
8691	61	73	People	People	NNPS
8691	61	74	_	_	NNP
8691	61	75	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	76	_	_	NNP
8691	61	77	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
8691	61	78	People	People	NNPS
8691	61	79	_	_	NNP
8691	61	80	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	81	_	_	NNP
8691	61	82	Olcott	Olcott	NNP
8691	61	83	People	People	NNPS
8691	61	84	_	_	NNP
8691	61	85	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	86	_	_	NNP
8691	61	87	Webb	Webb	NNP
8691	61	88	People	People	NNP
8691	61	89	,	,	,
8691	61	90	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	61	91	_	_	NNP
8691	61	92	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	93	_	_	NNP
8691	61	94	People	People	NNPS
8691	61	95	,	,	,
8691	61	96	McFarland	McFarland	NNP
8691	61	97	_	_	NNP
8691	61	98	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	99	_	_	NNP
8691	61	100	Pepin	Pepin	NNP
8691	61	101	_	_	NNP
8691	61	102	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	103	_	_	NNP
8691	61	104	Lachenmeyer	Lachenmeyer	NNP
8691	61	105	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
8691	61	106	,	,	,
8691	61	107	United	United	NNP
8691	61	108	States	States	NNP
8691	61	109	_	_	NNP
8691	61	110	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	111	_	_	NNP
8691	61	112	Perry	Perry	NNP
8691	61	113	_	_	NNP
8691	61	114	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	115	_	_	NNP
8691	61	116	Bush	Bush	NNP
8691	61	117	,	,	,
8691	61	118	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	61	119	,	,	,
8691	61	120	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	61	121	_	_	NNP
8691	61	122	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	123	_	_	NNP
8691	61	124	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
8691	61	125	_	_	NNP
8691	61	126	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	127	_	_	NNP
8691	61	128	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
8691	61	129	'	'	POS
8691	61	130	Loan	Loan	NNP
8691	61	131	and	and	CC
8691	61	132	Trust	Trust	NNP
8691	61	133	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	61	134	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
8691	61	135	_	_	NNP
8691	61	136	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	137	_	_	NNP
8691	61	138	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	61	139	Pritschau	Pritschau	NNP
8691	61	140	,	,	,
8691	61	141	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
8691	61	142	,	,	,
8691	61	143	Painesville	Painesville	NNP
8691	61	144	and	and	CC
8691	61	145	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
8691	61	146	R.	R.	NNP
8691	61	147	R.	R.	NNP
8691	61	148	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	61	149	_	_	NNP
8691	61	150	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	151	_	_	NNP
8691	61	152	Radcliffe	Radcliffe	NNP
8691	61	153	,	,	,
8691	61	154	Grover	Grover	NNP
8691	61	155	&	&	CC
8691	61	156	Baker	Baker	NNP
8691	61	157	Sewing	Sewing	NNP
8691	61	158	Machine	Machine	NNP
8691	61	159	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	61	160	_	_	NNP
8691	61	161	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	162	_	_	NNP
8691	61	163	Rand	Rand	NNP
8691	61	164	_	_	NNP
8691	61	165	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	166	_	_	NNP
8691	61	167	Mather	Mather	NNP
8691	61	168	Raub	Raub	NNP
8691	61	169	,	,	,
8691	61	170	Eakin	Eakin	NNP
8691	61	171	_	_	NNP
8691	61	172	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	173	_	_	NNP
8691	61	174	Rawitzer	Rawitzer	NNP
8691	61	175	,	,	,
8691	61	176	Lennon	Lennon	NNP
8691	61	177	_	_	NNP
8691	61	178	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	179	_	_	NNP
8691	61	180	Reese	Reese	NNP
8691	61	181	,	,	,
8691	61	182	United	United	NNP
8691	61	183	States	States	NNP
8691	61	184	_	_	NNP
8691	61	185	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	186	_	_	NNP
8691	61	187	Regents	Regents	NNPS
8691	61	188	_	_	NNP
8691	61	189	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	190	_	_	NNP
8691	61	191	Williams	Williams	NNP
8691	61	192	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	61	193	Island	Island	NNP
8691	61	194	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	61	195	,	,	,
8691	61	196	Dyson	Dyson	NNP
8691	61	197	_	_	NNP
8691	61	198	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	199	_	_	NNP
8691	61	200	Rice	Rice	NNP
8691	61	201	,	,	,
8691	61	202	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
8691	61	203	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	61	204	_	_	NNP
8691	61	205	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	206	_	_	NNP
8691	61	207	Rich	Rich	NNP
8691	61	208	,	,	,
8691	61	209	Upshur	Upshur	NNP
8691	61	210	County	County	NNP
8691	61	211	_	_	NNP
8691	61	212	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	213	_	_	NNP
8691	61	214	Ripley	Ripley	NNP
8691	61	215	,	,	,
8691	61	216	McVeigh	McVeigh	NNP
8691	61	217	_	_	NNP
8691	61	218	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	219	_	_	NNP
8691	61	220	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
8691	61	221	'	'	POS
8691	61	222	Case	Case	NNP
8691	61	223	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
8691	61	224	_	_	NNP
8691	61	225	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	226	_	_	NNP
8691	61	227	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
8691	61	228	Robinson	Robinson	NNP
8691	61	229	,	,	,
8691	61	230	_	_	NNP
8691	61	231	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	61	232	parte	parte	NN
8691	61	233	_	_	NNP
8691	61	234	Royall	Royall	NNP
8691	61	235	,	,	,
8691	61	236	_	_	NNP
8691	61	237	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	61	238	parte	parte	NN
8691	61	239	_	_	NNP
8691	61	240	Rumsey	Rumsey	NNP
8691	61	241	_	_	NNP
8691	61	242	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	243	_	_	NNP
8691	61	244	New	New	NNP
8691	61	245	York	York	NNP
8691	61	246	and	and	CC
8691	61	247	New	New	NNP
8691	61	248	England	England	NNP
8691	61	249	R.	R.	NNP
8691	61	250	R.	R.	NNP
8691	61	251	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	61	252	Russell	Russell	NNP
8691	61	253	,	,	,
8691	61	254	Christmas	Christmas	NNP
8691	61	255	_	_	NNP
8691	61	256	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	257	_	_	NNP
8691	61	258	Rutgers	Rutgers	NNP
8691	61	259	_	_	NNP
8691	61	260	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	261	_	_	NNP
8691	61	262	Waddington	Waddington	NNP
8691	61	263	Sanderson	Sanderson	NNP
8691	61	264	_	_	NNP
8691	61	265	v.	v.	IN
8691	61	266	_	_	NNP
8691	61	267	Penn	Penn	NNP
8691	61	268	.	.	.
8691	62	1	Coal	Coal	NNP
8691	62	2	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	62	3	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
8691	62	4	,	,	,
8691	62	5	Dred	Dred	NNP
8691	62	6	Scott	Scott	NNP
8691	62	7	_	_	NNP
8691	62	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	62	9	_	_	NNP
8691	62	10	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
8691	62	11	,	,	,
8691	62	12	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
8691	62	13	_	_	NNP
8691	62	14	v.	v.	IN
8691	62	15	_	_	NNP
8691	62	16	Scott	Scott	NNP
8691	62	17	_	_	NNP
8691	62	18	v.	v.	IN
8691	62	19	_	_	NNP
8691	62	20	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
8691	62	21	Seligman	Seligman	NNP
8691	62	22	,	,	,
8691	62	23	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
8691	62	24	_	_	NNP
8691	62	25	v.	v.	IN
8691	62	26	_	_	NNP
8691	62	27	Shepherd	Shepherd	NNP
8691	62	28	,	,	,
8691	62	29	State	State	NNP
8691	62	30	_	_	NNP
8691	62	31	v.	v.	IN
8691	62	32	_	_	NNP
8691	62	33	Sheve	Sheve	NNP
8691	62	34	,	,	,
8691	62	35	U.	U.	NNP
8691	62	36	S.	S.	NNP
8691	62	37	_	_	NNP
8691	62	38	v.	v.	IN
8691	62	39	_	_	NNP
8691	62	40	Siebold	Siebold	NNP
8691	62	41	,	,	,
8691	62	42	_	_	NNP
8691	62	43	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	62	44	parte	parte	NN
8691	62	45	_	_	NNP
8691	62	46	Sims	Sims	NNP
8691	62	47	'	'	POS
8691	62	48	Case	Case	NNP
8691	62	49	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
8691	62	50	,	,	,
8691	62	51	Groves	Groves	NNPS
8691	62	52	_	_	NNP
8691	62	53	v.	v.	IN
8691	62	54	_	_	NNP
8691	62	55	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	62	56	,	,	,
8691	62	57	Fish	Fish	NNP
8691	62	58	_	_	NNP
8691	62	59	v.	v.	IN
8691	62	60	_	_	NNP
8691	62	61	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	62	62	,	,	,
8691	62	63	Hill	Hill	NNP
8691	62	64	_	_	NNP
8691	62	65	v.	v.	IN
8691	62	66	_	_	NNP
8691	62	67	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	62	68	,	,	,
8691	62	69	U.	U.	NNP
8691	62	70	S.	S.	NNP
8691	62	71	_	_	NNP
8691	62	72	v.	v.	IN
8691	62	73	_	_	NNP
8691	62	74	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
8691	62	75	_	_	NNP
8691	62	76	v.	v.	IN
8691	62	77	_	_	NNP
8691	62	78	Ames	Ames	NNP
8691	62	79	Social	Social	NNP
8691	62	80	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
8691	62	81	.	.	.
8691	63	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	63	2	,	,	,
8691	63	3	Merriman	Merriman	NNP
8691	63	4	_	_	NNP
8691	63	5	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	6	_	_	NNP
8691	63	7	South	South	NNP
8691	63	8	Bethlehem	Bethlehem	NNP
8691	63	9	,	,	,
8691	63	10	Myers	Myers	NNP
8691	63	11	_	_	NNP
8691	63	12	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	13	_	_	NNP
8691	63	14	Sparf	Sparf	NNP
8691	63	15	_	_	NNP
8691	63	16	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	17	_	_	NNP
8691	63	18	U.	U.	NNP
8691	63	19	S.	S.	NNP
8691	63	20	St.	St.	NNP
8691	63	21	Louis	Louis	NNP
8691	63	22	Transit	Transit	NNP
8691	63	23	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	63	24	,	,	,
8691	63	25	Eckrich	Eckrich	NNP
8691	63	26	_	_	NNP
8691	63	27	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	28	_	_	NNP
8691	63	29	Stack	Stack	NNP
8691	63	30	_	_	NNP
8691	63	31	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	32	_	_	NNP
8691	63	33	New	New	NNP
8691	63	34	York	York	NNP
8691	63	35	,	,	,
8691	63	36	New	New	NNP
8691	63	37	Haven	Haven	NNP
8691	63	38	and	and	CC
8691	63	39	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
8691	63	40	R.	R.	NNP
8691	63	41	R.	R.	NNP
8691	63	42	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	63	43	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
8691	63	44	_	_	NNP
8691	63	45	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	46	_	_	NNP
8691	63	47	Colt	Colt	NNP
8691	63	48	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
8691	63	49	,	,	,
8691	63	50	U.	U.	NNP
8691	63	51	S.	S.	NNP
8691	63	52	_	_	NNP
8691	63	53	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	54	_	_	NNP
8691	63	55	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
8691	63	56	,	,	,
8691	63	57	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	63	58	_	_	NNP
8691	63	59	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	60	_	_	NNP
8691	63	61	Starr	Starr	NNP
8691	63	62	_	_	NNP
8691	63	63	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	64	_	_	NNP
8691	63	65	Pease	Pease	NNP
8691	63	66	State	State	NNP
8691	63	67	_	_	NNP
8691	63	68	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	69	_	_	NNP
8691	63	70	Baxter	Baxter	NNP
8691	63	71	State	State	NNP
8691	63	72	_	_	NNP
8691	63	73	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	74	_	_	NNP
8691	63	75	Bulkley	Bulkley	NNP
8691	63	76	State	State	NNP
8691	63	77	_	_	NNP
8691	63	78	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	79	_	_	NNP
8691	63	80	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
8691	63	81	State	State	NNP
8691	63	82	_	_	NNP
8691	63	83	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	84	_	_	NNP
8691	63	85	Houser	Houser	NNP
8691	63	86	State	State	NNP
8691	63	87	_	_	NNP
8691	63	88	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	89	_	_	NNP
8691	63	90	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	63	91	State	State	NNP
8691	63	92	_	_	NNP
8691	63	93	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	94	_	_	NNP
8691	63	95	Judges	Judges	NNP
8691	63	96	State	State	NNP
8691	63	97	_	_	NNP
8691	63	98	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	99	_	_	NNP
8691	63	100	Lee	Lee	NNP
8691	63	101	State	State	NNP
8691	63	102	_	_	NNP
8691	63	103	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	104	_	_	NNP
8691	63	105	Main	Main	NNP
8691	63	106	State	State	NNP
8691	63	107	_	_	NNP
8691	63	108	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	109	_	_	NNP
8691	63	110	Morrill	Morrill	NNP
8691	63	111	State	State	NNP
8691	63	112	_	_	NNP
8691	63	113	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	114	_	_	NNP
8691	63	115	Shepherd	Shepherd	NNP
8691	63	116	State	State	NNP
8691	63	117	_	_	NNP
8691	63	118	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	119	_	_	NNP
8691	63	120	Travelers	Travelers	NNPS
8691	63	121	'	'	POS
8691	63	122	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	63	123	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	63	124	State	State	NNP
8691	63	125	_	_	NNP
8691	63	126	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	127	_	_	NNP
8691	63	128	Ward	Ward	NNP
8691	63	129	State	State	NNP
8691	63	130	_	_	NNP
8691	63	131	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	132	_	_	NNP
8691	63	133	Worden	Worden	NNP
8691	63	134	State	State	NNP
8691	63	135	,	,	,
8691	63	136	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
8691	63	137	_	_	NNP
8691	63	138	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	139	_	_	NNP
8691	63	140	Stephens	Stephens	NNP
8691	63	141	,	,	,
8691	63	142	petitioner	petitioner	NN
8691	63	143	Stifle	Stifle	NNP
8691	63	144	,	,	,
8691	63	145	Drehman	Drehman	NNP
8691	63	146	_	_	NNP
8691	63	147	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	148	_	_	NNP
8691	63	149	Stone	Stone	NNP
8691	63	150	,	,	,
8691	63	151	Irvine	Irvine	NNP
8691	63	152	_	_	NNP
8691	63	153	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	154	_	_	NNP
8691	63	155	Stonington	Stonington	NNP
8691	63	156	,	,	,
8691	63	157	Goshen	Goshen	NNP
8691	63	158	_	_	NNP
8691	63	159	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	160	_	_	NNP
8691	63	161	Swift	Swift	NNP
8691	63	162	_	_	NNP
8691	63	163	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	164	_	_	NNP
8691	63	165	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
8691	63	166	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
8691	63	167	Railway	Railway	NNP
8691	63	168	and	and	CC
8691	63	169	Power	Power	NNP
8691	63	170	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	63	171	,	,	,
8691	63	172	Coler	Coler	NNP
8691	63	173	_	_	NNP
8691	63	174	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	175	_	_	NNP
8691	63	176	Tassel	Tassel	NNP
8691	63	177	's	's	POS
8691	63	178	Case	Case	NNP
8691	63	179	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
8691	63	180	_	_	NNP
8691	63	181	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	182	_	_	NNP
8691	63	183	Beckham	Beckham	NNP
8691	63	184	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
8691	63	185	,	,	,
8691	63	186	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
8691	63	187	_	_	NNP
8691	63	188	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	189	_	_	NNP
8691	63	190	Terry	Terry	NNP
8691	63	191	_	_	NNP
8691	63	192	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	193	_	_	NNP
8691	63	194	McDaniel	McDaniel	NNP
8691	63	195	Thayer	Thayer	NNP
8691	63	196	,	,	,
8691	63	197	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
8691	63	198	_	_	NNP
8691	63	199	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	200	_	_	NNP
8691	63	201	The	the	DT
8691	63	202	Genesee	Genesee	NNP
8691	63	203	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	63	204	The	the	DT
8691	63	205	Grapeshot	grapeshot	NN
8691	63	206	The	the	DT
8691	63	207	La	La	NNP
8691	63	208	Ninfa	Ninfa	NNP
8691	63	209	The	the	DT
8691	63	210	Lottawanna	Lottawanna	NNP
8691	63	211	The	the	DT
8691	63	212	Moses	Moses	NNP
8691	63	213	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
8691	63	214	The	the	DT
8691	63	215	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
8691	63	216	Little	Little	NNP
8691	63	217	Charles	Charles	NNP
8691	63	218	,	,	,
8691	63	219	U.	U.	NNP
8691	63	220	S.	S.	NNP
8691	63	221	_	_	NNP
8691	63	222	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	223	_	_	NNP
8691	63	224	The	the	DT
8691	63	225	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
8691	63	226	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	63	227	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
8691	63	228	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	63	229	,	,	,
8691	63	230	The	the	DT
8691	63	231	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
8691	63	232	,	,	,
8691	63	233	Kilbourn	Kilbourn	NNP
8691	63	234	_	_	NNP
8691	63	235	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	236	_	_	NNP
8691	63	237	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
8691	63	238	,	,	,
8691	63	239	Loan	Loan	NNP
8691	63	240	Association	Association	NNP
8691	63	241	_	_	NNP
8691	63	242	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	243	_	_	NNP
8691	63	244	Trademark	Trademark	NNP
8691	63	245	Cases	Cases	NNPS
8691	63	246	Travelers	Travelers	NNPS
8691	63	247	'	'	POS
8691	63	248	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	63	249	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	63	250	,	,	,
8691	63	251	State	State	NNP
8691	63	252	_	_	NNP
8691	63	253	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	254	_	_	NNP
8691	63	255	Trevett	Trevett	NNP
8691	63	256	_	_	NNP
8691	63	257	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	258	_	_	NNP
8691	63	259	Weeden	Weeden	NNP
8691	63	260	Tua	Tua	NNP
8691	63	261	_	_	NNP
8691	63	262	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	263	_	_	NNP
8691	63	264	Carriere	Carriere	NNP
8691	63	265	Turner	Turner	NNP
8691	63	266	,	,	,
8691	63	267	City	City	NNP
8691	63	268	of	of	IN
8691	63	269	South	South	NNP
8691	63	270	Bend	Bend	NNP
8691	63	271	_	_	NNP
8691	63	272	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	273	_	_	NNP
8691	63	274	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
8691	63	275	,	,	,
8691	63	276	Swift	Swift	NNP
8691	63	277	_	_	NNP
8691	63	278	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	279	_	_	NNP
8691	63	280	Union	Union	NNP
8691	63	281	River	River	NNP
8691	63	282	Logging	Logging	NNP
8691	63	283	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	63	284	,	,	,
8691	63	285	Noble	Noble	NNP
8691	63	286	,	,	,
8691	63	287	_	_	NNP
8691	63	288	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	289	_	_	NNP
8691	63	290	United	United	NNP
8691	63	291	States	States	NNP
8691	63	292	_	_	NNP
8691	63	293	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	294	_	_	NNP
8691	63	295	Debs	Debs	NNP
8691	63	296	United	United	NNP
8691	63	297	States	States	NNP
8691	63	298	_	_	NNP
8691	63	299	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	300	_	_	NNP
8691	63	301	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
8691	63	302	United	United	NNP
8691	63	303	States	States	NNP
8691	63	304	_	_	NNP
8691	63	305	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	306	_	_	NNP
8691	63	307	Joint	Joint	NNP
8691	63	308	Traffic	Traffic	NNP
8691	63	309	Association	Association	NNP
8691	63	310	United	United	NNP
8691	63	311	States	States	NNP
8691	63	312	_	_	NNP
8691	63	313	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	314	_	_	NNP
8691	63	315	Klein	Klein	NNP
8691	63	316	United	United	NNP
8691	63	317	States	States	NNP
8691	63	318	_	_	NNP
8691	63	319	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	320	_	_	NNP
8691	63	321	Nash	Nash	NNP
8691	63	322	United	United	NNP
8691	63	323	States	States	NNP
8691	63	324	_	_	NNP
8691	63	325	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	326	_	_	NNP
8691	63	327	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
8691	63	328	United	United	NNP
8691	63	329	States	States	NNP
8691	63	330	_	_	NNP
8691	63	331	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	332	_	_	NNP
8691	63	333	The	the	DT
8691	63	334	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
8691	63	335	Little	little	JJ
8691	63	336	Charles	Charles	NNP
8691	63	337	United	United	NNP
8691	63	338	States	States	NNP
8691	63	339	_	_	NNP
8691	63	340	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	341	_	_	NNP
8691	63	342	Reese	Reese	NNP
8691	63	343	United	United	NNP
8691	63	344	States	States	NNP
8691	63	345	_	_	NNP
8691	63	346	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	347	_	_	NNP
8691	63	348	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
8691	63	349	United	United	NNP
8691	63	350	States	States	NNP
8691	63	351	_	_	NNP
8691	63	352	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	353	_	_	NNP
8691	63	354	Sheve	Sheve	NNP
8691	63	355	United	United	NNP
8691	63	356	States	States	NNP
8691	63	357	_	_	NNP
8691	63	358	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	359	_	_	NNP
8691	63	360	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	63	361	United	United	NNP
8691	63	362	States	States	NNP
8691	63	363	_	_	NNP
8691	63	364	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	365	_	_	NNP
8691	63	366	Sparf	Sparf	NNP
8691	63	367	United	United	NNP
8691	63	368	States	States	NNP
8691	63	369	_	_	NNP
8691	63	370	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	371	_	_	NNP
8691	63	372	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
8691	63	373	United	United	NNP
8691	63	374	States	States	NNP
8691	63	375	_	_	NNP
8691	63	376	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	377	_	_	NNP
8691	63	378	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
8691	63	379	United	United	NNP
8691	63	380	States	States	NNP
8691	63	381	_	_	NNP
8691	63	382	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	383	_	_	NNP
8691	63	384	Worrall	Worrall	NNP
8691	63	385	United	United	NNP
8691	63	386	States	States	NNP
8691	63	387	,	,	,
8691	63	388	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
8691	63	389	_	_	NNP
8691	63	390	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	391	_	_	NNP
8691	63	392	United	United	NNP
8691	63	393	States	States	NNP
8691	63	394	,	,	,
8691	63	395	Coffin	Coffin	NNP
8691	63	396	_	_	NNP
8691	63	397	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	398	_	_	NNP
8691	63	399	United	United	NNP
8691	63	400	States	States	NNP
8691	63	401	,	,	,
8691	63	402	Dorr	Dorr	NNP
8691	63	403	_	_	NNP
8691	63	404	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	405	_	_	NNP
8691	63	406	United	United	NNP
8691	63	407	States	States	NNP
8691	63	408	,	,	,
8691	63	409	Kepner	Kepner	NNP
8691	63	410	_	_	NNP
8691	63	411	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	412	_	_	NNP
8691	63	413	United	United	NNP
8691	63	414	States	States	NNP
8691	63	415	,	,	,
8691	63	416	Mormon	Mormon	NNP
8691	63	417	Church	Church	NNP
8691	63	418	_	_	NNP
8691	63	419	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	420	_	_	NNP
8691	63	421	United	United	NNP
8691	63	422	States	States	NNP
8691	63	423	,	,	,
8691	63	424	Northern	Northern	NNP
8691	63	425	Securities	Securities	NNPS
8691	63	426	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	63	427	_	_	NNP
8691	63	428	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	429	_	_	NNP
8691	63	430	Upshur	Upshur	NNP
8691	63	431	County	County	NNP
8691	63	432	_	_	NNP
8691	63	433	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	434	_	_	NNP
8691	63	435	Rich	Rich	NNP
8691	63	436	Vanhorne	Vanhorne	NNP
8691	63	437	's	's	POS
8691	63	438	lessee	lessee	NN
8691	63	439	_	_	NNP
8691	63	440	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	441	_	_	NNP
8691	63	442	Dorrance	Dorrance	NNP
8691	63	443	Vincent	Vincent	NNP
8691	63	444	_	_	NNP
8691	63	445	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	446	_	_	NNP
8691	63	447	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
8691	63	448	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
8691	63	449	Fund	Fund	NNP
8691	63	450	Life	Life	NNP
8691	63	451	Association	Association	NNP
8691	63	452	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	63	453	,	,	,
8691	63	454	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
8691	63	455	_	_	NNP
8691	63	456	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	457	_	_	NNP
8691	63	458	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	63	459	,	,	,
8691	63	460	Paul	Paul	NNP
8691	63	461	_	_	NNP
8691	63	462	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	463	_	_	NNP
8691	63	464	Voorhies	Voorhies	NNPS
8691	63	465	,	,	,
8691	63	466	M'Kim	M'Kim	NNP
8691	63	467	_	_	NNP
8691	63	468	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	469	_	_	NNP
8691	63	470	Waddington	Waddington	NNP
8691	63	471	,	,	,
8691	63	472	Rutgers	Rutgers	NNP
8691	63	473	_	_	NNP
8691	63	474	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	475	_	_	NNP
8691	63	476	Walkinshaw	Walkinshaw	NNP
8691	63	477	,	,	,
8691	63	478	Katz	Katz	NNP
8691	63	479	_	_	NNP
8691	63	480	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	481	_	_	NNP
8691	63	482	Walton	Walton	NNP
8691	63	483	,	,	,
8691	63	484	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
8691	63	485	_	_	NNP
8691	63	486	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	487	_	_	NNP
8691	63	488	Ward	Ward	NNP
8691	63	489	_	_	NNP
8691	63	490	v.	v.	IN
8691	63	491	_	_	NNP
8691	63	492	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	64	1	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
8691	64	2	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
8691	64	3	.	.	.
8691	65	1	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	65	2	,	,	,
8691	65	3	Ward	Ward	NNP
8691	65	4	,	,	,
8691	65	5	State	State	NNP
8691	65	6	_	_	NNP
8691	65	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	8	_	_	NNP
8691	65	9	,	,	,
8691	65	10	Warmoth	Warmoth	NNP
8691	65	11	,	,	,
8691	65	12	Kellogg	Kellogg	NNP
8691	65	13	_	_	NNP
8691	65	14	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	15	_	_	NNP
8691	65	16	,	,	,
8691	65	17	Waterbury	Waterbury	NNP
8691	65	18	,	,	,
8691	65	19	French	French	NNP
8691	65	20	_	_	NNP
8691	65	21	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	22	_	_	NNP
8691	65	23	,	,	,
8691	65	24	Webb	Webb	NNP
8691	65	25	,	,	,
8691	65	26	People	People	NNP
8691	65	27	_	_	NNP
8691	65	28	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	29	_	_	NNP
8691	65	30	,	,	,
8691	65	31	Weeden	Weeden	NNP
8691	65	32	,	,	,
8691	65	33	Trevett	Trevett	NNP
8691	65	34	_	_	NNP
8691	65	35	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	36	_	_	NNP
8691	65	37	,	,	,
8691	65	38	Western	Western	NNP
8691	65	39	Union	Union	NNP
8691	65	40	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
8691	65	41	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	65	42	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	43	Call	Call	NNP
8691	65	44	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
8691	65	45	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	65	46	,	,	,
8691	65	47	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	65	48	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	49	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	65	50	,	,	,
8691	65	51	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
8691	65	52	,	,	,
8691	65	53	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	65	54	and	and	CC
8691	65	55	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	65	56	R.	R.	NNP
8691	65	57	R.	R.	NNP
8691	65	58	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	65	59	,	,	,
8691	65	60	_	_	NNP
8691	65	61	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	62	_	_	NNP
8691	65	63	,	,	,
8691	65	64	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
8691	65	65	's	's	POS
8691	65	66	Appeal	appeal	NN
8691	65	67	,	,	,
8691	65	68	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
8691	65	69	v.	v.	CC
8691	65	70	Heywood	Heywood	NNP
8691	65	71	,	,	,
8691	65	72	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
8691	65	73	,	,	,
8691	65	74	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
8691	65	75	_	_	NNP
8691	65	76	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	77	_	_	NNP
8691	65	78	,	,	,
8691	65	79	Williams	Williams	NNP
8691	65	80	,	,	,
8691	65	81	Blair	Blair	NNP
8691	65	82	_	_	NNP
8691	65	83	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	84	_	_	NNP
8691	65	85	,	,	,
8691	65	86	Williams	Williams	NNP
8691	65	87	,	,	,
8691	65	88	Regents	Regents	NNP
8691	65	89	_	_	NNP
8691	65	90	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	91	_	_	NNP
8691	65	92	,	,	,
8691	65	93	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
8691	65	94	,	,	,
8691	65	95	U.	U.	NNP
8691	65	96	S.	S.	NNP
8691	65	97	_	_	NNP
8691	65	98	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	99	_	_	NNP
8691	65	100	,	,	,
8691	65	101	Wolcott	Wolcott	NNP
8691	65	102	,	,	,
8691	65	103	Diggs	Diggs	NNP
8691	65	104	_	_	NNP
8691	65	105	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	106	_	_	NNP
8691	65	107	,	,	,
8691	65	108	Woodward	Woodward	NNP
8691	65	109	,	,	,
8691	65	110	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
8691	65	111	College	College	NNP
8691	65	112	,	,	,
8691	65	113	_	_	NNP
8691	65	114	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	115	_	_	NNP
8691	65	116	,	,	,
8691	65	117	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
8691	65	118	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	119	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	65	120	,	,	,
8691	65	121	Worden	Worden	NNP
8691	65	122	,	,	,
8691	65	123	State	State	NNP
8691	65	124	_	_	NNP
8691	65	125	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	126	_	_	NNP
8691	65	127	,	,	,
8691	65	128	Worrall	Worrall	NNP
8691	65	129	,	,	,
8691	65	130	U.	U.	NNP
8691	65	131	S.	S.	NNP
8691	65	132	_	_	NNP
8691	65	133	v.	v.	IN
8691	65	134	_	_	NNP
8691	65	135	Additional	additional	JJ
8691	65	136	cases	case	NNS
8691	65	137	cited	cite	VBD
8691	65	138	in	in	IN
8691	65	139	Second	Second	NNP
8691	65	140	edition	edition	NN
8691	65	141	.	.	.
8691	66	1	Janvrin	Janvrin	NNP
8691	66	2	v.	v.	IN
8691	66	3	Revere	Revere	NNP
8691	66	4	Water	Water	NNP
8691	66	5	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	66	6	,	,	,
8691	66	7	Revere	Revere	NNP
8691	66	8	Water	Water	NNP
8691	66	9	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	66	10	,	,	,
8691	66	11	Janvrin	Janvrin	NNP
8691	66	12	,	,	,
8691	66	13	_	_	NNP
8691	66	14	v.	v.	IN
8691	66	15	_	_	NNP
8691	66	16	,	,	,
8691	66	17	O'Brien	O'Brien	NNP
8691	66	18	's	's	POS
8691	66	19	Petition	Petition	NNP
8691	66	20	,	,	,
8691	66	21	Seery	Seery	NNP
8691	66	22	v.	v.	IN
8691	66	23	Waterbury	Waterbury	NNP
8691	66	24	,	,	,
8691	66	25	Waterbury	Waterbury	NNP
8691	66	26	,	,	,
8691	66	27	Seery	Seery	NNP
8691	66	28	_	_	NNP
8691	66	29	v.	v.	IN
8691	66	30	_	_	NNP
8691	66	31	*	*	NFP
8691	66	32	*	*	NFP
8691	66	33	*	*	NFP
8691	66	34	*	*	NFP
8691	66	35	*	*	NFP
8691	66	36	PART	part	NN
8691	66	37	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	66	38	THE	the	DT
8691	66	39	NATURE	NATURE	NNS
8691	66	40	AND	and	CC
8691	66	41	SCOPE	scope	NN
8691	66	42	OF	of	IN
8691	66	43	THE	the	DT
8691	66	44	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	66	45	POWER	POWER	NNP
8691	66	46	IN	in	IN
8691	66	47	THE	the	DT
8691	66	48	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
8691	66	49	STATES	STATES	NNP
8691	66	50	*	*	NFP
8691	66	51	*	*	NFP
8691	66	52	*	*	NFP
8691	66	53	*	*	NFP
8691	66	54	*	*	NFP
8691	66	55	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	66	56	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	66	57	ENGLISH	english	VBP
8691	66	58	ORIGIN	ORIGIN	NNS
8691	66	59	AND	and	CC
8691	66	60	EARLY	early	NN
8691	66	61	DEVELOPMENT	development	NN
8691	66	62	OF	of	IN
8691	66	63	THE	the	DT
8691	66	64	AMERICAN	AMERICAN	NNP
8691	66	65	JUDICIARY	judiciary	NN
8691	66	66	No	no	DT
8691	66	67	government	government	NN
8691	66	68	can	can	MD
8691	66	69	live	live	VB
8691	66	70	and	and	CC
8691	66	71	flourish	flourish	VB
8691	66	72	without	without	IN
8691	66	73	having	have	VBG
8691	66	74	as	as	IN
8691	66	75	part	part	NN
8691	66	76	of	of	IN
8691	66	77	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	66	78	system	system	NN
8691	66	79	of	of	IN
8691	66	80	administration	administration	NN
8691	66	81	of	of	IN
8691	66	82	civil	civil	JJ
8691	66	83	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	66	84	some	some	DT
8691	66	85	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	66	86	human	human	JJ
8691	66	87	force	force	NN
8691	66	88	,	,	,
8691	66	89	invested	invest	VBN
8691	66	90	with	with	IN
8691	66	91	acknowledged	acknowledged	JJ
8691	66	92	and	and	CC
8691	66	93	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	66	94	authority	authority	NNP
8691	66	95	,	,	,
8691	66	96	and	and	CC
8691	66	97	always	always	RB
8691	66	98	in	in	IN
8691	66	99	a	a	DT
8691	66	100	position	position	NN
8691	66	101	to	to	TO
8691	66	102	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	66	103	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	66	104	promptly	promptly	RB
8691	66	105	and	and	CC
8691	66	106	efficiently	efficiently	RB
8691	66	107	,	,	,
8691	66	108	in	in	IN
8691	66	109	case	case	NN
8691	66	110	of	of	IN
8691	66	111	need	need	NN
8691	66	112	,	,	,
8691	66	113	on	on	IN
8691	66	114	any	any	DT
8691	66	115	proper	proper	JJ
8691	66	116	call	call	NN
8691	66	117	.	.	.
8691	67	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	67	2	must	must	MD
8691	67	3	be	be	VB
8691	67	4	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	67	5	in	in	IN
8691	67	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	67	7	character	character	NN
8691	67	8	.	.	.
8691	68	1	Only	only	RB
8691	68	2	what	what	WP
8691	68	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	68	4	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	68	5	will	will	MD
8691	68	6	have	have	VB
8691	68	7	the	the	DT
8691	68	8	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	68	9	of	of	IN
8691	68	10	the	the	DT
8691	68	11	people	people	NNS
8691	68	12	.	.	.
8691	69	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	69	2	must	must	MD
8691	69	3	always	always	RB
8691	69	4	be	be	VB
8691	69	5	ready	ready	JJ
8691	69	6	to	to	TO
8691	69	7	act	act	VB
8691	69	8	on	on	IN
8691	69	9	the	the	DT
8691	69	10	instant	instant	NN
8691	69	11	.	.	.
8691	70	1	The	the	DT
8691	70	2	unexpected	unexpected	JJ
8691	70	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	70	4	continually	continually	RB
8691	70	5	happening	happen	VBG
8691	70	6	,	,	,
8691	70	7	and	and	CC
8691	70	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	70	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	70	10	emergencies	emergency	NNS
8691	70	11	that	that	WDT
8691	70	12	put	put	VBP
8691	70	13	governments	government	NNS
8691	70	14	to	to	IN
8691	70	15	the	the	DT
8691	70	16	test	test	NN
8691	70	17	.	.	.
8691	71	1	The	the	DT
8691	71	2	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	71	3	holds	hold	VBZ
8691	71	4	this	this	DT
8691	71	5	position	position	NN
8691	71	6	in	in	IN
8691	71	7	the	the	DT
8691	71	8	United	United	NNP
8691	71	9	States	States	NNP
8691	71	10	.	.	.
8691	72	1	The	the	DT
8691	72	2	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	72	3	which	which	WDT
8691	72	4	underlie	underlie	VBP
8691	72	5	and	and	CC
8691	72	6	characterize	characterize	VB
8691	72	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	72	8	,	,	,
8691	72	9	both	both	DT
8691	72	10	of	of	IN
8691	72	11	the	the	DT
8691	72	12	United	United	NNP
8691	72	13	States	States	NNP
8691	72	14	and	and	CC
8691	72	15	of	of	IN
8691	72	16	each	each	DT
8691	72	17	of	of	IN
8691	72	18	the	the	DT
8691	72	19	States	States	NNPS
8691	72	20	,	,	,
8691	72	21	considered	consider	VBN
8691	72	22	by	by	IN
8691	72	23	itself,[Footnote	itself,[footnote	XX
8691	72	24	:	:	:
8691	72	25	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	72	26	do	do	VBP
8691	72	27	not	not	RB
8691	72	28	except	except	IN
8691	72	29	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	72	30	,	,	,
8691	72	31	for	for	IN
8691	72	32	trial	trial	NN
8691	72	33	by	by	IN
8691	72	34	jury	jury	NN
8691	72	35	and	and	CC
8691	72	36	other	other	JJ
8691	72	37	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	72	38	derived	derive	VBN
8691	72	39	from	from	IN
8691	72	40	the	the	DT
8691	72	41	common	common	JJ
8691	72	42	law	law	NN
8691	72	43	have	have	VBP
8691	72	44	profoundly	profoundly	RB
8691	72	45	affected	affect	VBN
8691	72	46	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	72	47	whole	whole	JJ
8691	72	48	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	72	49	system	system	NN
8691	72	50	.	.	.
8691	72	51	]	]	-RRB-
8691	73	1	are	be	VBP
8691	73	2	the	the	DT
8691	73	3	outgrowth	outgrowth	NN
8691	73	4	of	of	IN
8691	73	5	those	those	DT
8691	73	6	of	of	IN
8691	73	7	the	the	DT
8691	73	8	thirteen	thirteen	CD
8691	73	9	English	English	NNP
8691	73	10	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	73	11	on	on	IN
8691	73	12	the	the	DT
8691	73	13	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	73	14	coast	coast	NN
8691	73	15	,	,	,
8691	73	16	which	which	WDT
8691	73	17	declared	declare	VBD
8691	73	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	73	19	independence	independence	NN
8691	73	20	in	in	IN
8691	73	21	1776	1776	CD
8691	73	22	.	.	.
8691	74	1	The	the	DT
8691	74	2	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	74	3	charters	charter	NNS
8691	74	4	,	,	,
8691	74	5	whether	whether	IN
8691	74	6	of	of	IN
8691	74	7	the	the	DT
8691	74	8	proprietary	proprietary	JJ
8691	74	9	,	,	,
8691	74	10	provincial	provincial	JJ
8691	74	11	or	or	CC
8691	74	12	republican	republican	JJ
8691	74	13	type	type	NN
8691	74	14	,	,	,
8691	74	15	were	be	VBD
8691	74	16	all	all	DT
8691	74	17	equally	equally	RB
8691	74	18	charters	charter	NNS
8691	74	19	for	for	IN
8691	74	20	Englishmen	Englishmen	NNP
8691	74	21	,	,	,
8691	74	22	based	base	VBN
8691	74	23	on	on	IN
8691	74	24	the	the	DT
8691	74	25	common	common	JJ
8691	74	26	law	law	NN
8691	74	27	of	of	IN
8691	74	28	the	the	DT
8691	74	29	English	english	JJ
8691	74	30	people	people	NNS
8691	74	31	.	.	.
8691	75	1	So	so	RB
8691	75	2	far	far	RB
8691	75	3	as	as	IN
8691	75	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	75	5	granted	grant	VBD
8691	75	6	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	75	7	power	power	NN
8691	75	8	,	,	,
8691	75	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	75	10	was	be	VBD
8691	75	11	generally	generally	RB
8691	75	12	declared	declare	VBN
8691	75	13	that	that	IN
8691	75	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	75	15	should	should	MD
8691	75	16	be	be	VB
8691	75	17	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	75	18	in	in	IN
8691	75	19	conformity	conformity	NN
8691	75	20	,	,	,
8691	75	21	so	so	RB
8691	75	22	far	far	RB
8691	75	23	as	as	IN
8691	75	24	might	may	MD
8691	75	25	be	be	VB
8691	75	26	practicable	practicable	JJ
8691	75	27	,	,	,
8691	75	28	with	with	IN
8691	75	29	the	the	DT
8691	75	30	laws	law	NNS
8691	75	31	of	of	IN
8691	75	32	England	England	NNP
8691	75	33	.	.	.
8691	76	1	The	the	DT
8691	76	2	proviso	proviso	NN
8691	76	3	to	to	IN
8691	76	4	this	this	DT
8691	76	5	effect	effect	NN
8691	76	6	in	in	IN
8691	76	7	the	the	DT
8691	76	8	roving	rove	VBG
8691	76	9	patent	patent	NN
8691	76	10	given	give	VBN
8691	76	11	by	by	IN
8691	76	12	Queen	Queen	NNP
8691	76	13	Elizabeth	Elizabeth	NNP
8691	76	14	to	to	IN
8691	76	15	Sir	Sir	NNP
8691	76	16	Walter	Walter	NNP
8691	76	17	Raleigh	Raleigh	NNP
8691	76	18	may	may	MD
8691	76	19	be	be	VB
8691	76	20	taken	take	VBN
8691	76	21	as	as	IN
8691	76	22	a	a	DT
8691	76	23	type	type	NN
8691	76	24	:	:	:
8691	76	25	"	"	``
8691	76	26	so	so	RB
8691	76	27	always	always	RB
8691	76	28	as	as	IN
8691	76	29	the	the	DT
8691	76	30	said	say	VBN
8691	76	31	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	76	32	,	,	,
8691	76	33	lawes	lawes	NNP
8691	76	34	,	,	,
8691	76	35	and	and	CC
8691	76	36	ordinances	ordinance	NNS
8691	76	37	may	may	MD
8691	76	38	be	be	VB
8691	76	39	,	,	,
8691	76	40	as	as	RB
8691	76	41	neere	neere	RB
8691	76	42	as	as	IN
8691	76	43	conveniently	conveniently	RB
8691	76	44	may	may	MD
8691	76	45	be	be	VB
8691	76	46	,	,	,
8691	76	47	agreeable	agreeable	JJ
8691	76	48	to	to	IN
8691	76	49	the	the	DT
8691	76	50	forme	forme	NN
8691	76	51	of	of	IN
8691	76	52	the	the	DT
8691	76	53	lawes	lawes	NN
8691	76	54	,	,	,
8691	76	55	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	76	56	,	,	,
8691	76	57	government	government	NN
8691	76	58	,	,	,
8691	76	59	or	or	CC
8691	76	60	pollicie	pollicie	NN
8691	76	61	of	of	IN
8691	76	62	England	England	NNP
8691	76	63	.	.	.
8691	77	1	"	"	``
8691	77	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	77	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	77	4	:	:	:
8691	77	5	Poore	Poore	NNP
8691	77	6	,	,	,
8691	77	7	"	"	``
8691	77	8	Charters	Charters	NNPS
8691	77	9	and	and	CC
8691	77	10	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	77	11	,	,	,
8691	77	12	"	"	''
8691	77	13	II	ii	CD
8691	77	14	,	,	,
8691	77	15	1381	1381	CD
8691	77	16	.	.	.
8691	77	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	78	1	In	in	IN
8691	78	2	the	the	DT
8691	78	3	Southern	Southern	NNP
8691	78	4	New	New	NNP
8691	78	5	England	England	NNP
8691	78	6	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	78	7	,	,	,
8691	78	8	when	when	WRB
8691	78	9	first	first	RB
8691	78	10	settled	settle	VBN
8691	78	11	,	,	,
8691	78	12	the	the	DT
8691	78	13	common	common	JJ
8691	78	14	law	law	NN
8691	78	15	of	of	IN
8691	78	16	England	England	NNP
8691	78	17	was	be	VBD
8691	78	18	disowned	disown	VBN
8691	78	19	.	.	.
8691	79	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	79	2	made	make	VBD
8691	79	3	the	the	DT
8691	79	4	little	little	JJ
8691	79	5	law	law	NN
8691	79	6	which	which	WDT
8691	79	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	79	8	needed	need	VBD
8691	79	9	for	for	IN
8691	79	10	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	79	11	,	,	,
8691	79	12	and	and	CC
8691	79	13	as	as	IN
8691	79	14	cases	case	NNS
8691	79	15	which	which	WDT
8691	79	16	this	this	DT
8691	79	17	might	may	MD
8691	79	18	not	not	RB
8691	79	19	provide	provide	VB
8691	79	20	for	for	IN
8691	79	21	arose	arose	NN
8691	79	22	,	,	,
8691	79	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	79	24	were	be	VBD
8691	79	25	to	to	TO
8691	79	26	be	be	VB
8691	79	27	decided	decide	VBN
8691	79	28	by	by	IN
8691	79	29	such	such	JJ
8691	79	30	rules	rule	NNS
8691	79	31	as	as	IN
8691	79	32	the	the	DT
8691	79	33	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
8691	79	34	might	may	MD
8691	79	35	think	think	VB
8691	79	36	right	right	RB
8691	79	37	and	and	CC
8691	79	38	warranted	warrant	VBN
8691	79	39	by	by	IN
8691	79	40	the	the	DT
8691	79	41	precepts	precept	NNS
8691	79	42	found	find	VBN
8691	79	43	in	in	IN
8691	79	44	the	the	DT
8691	79	45	Bible	Bible	NNP
8691	79	46	.	.	.
8691	80	1	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	80	2	continued	continue	VBD
8691	80	3	to	to	TO
8691	80	4	insist	insist	VB
8691	80	5	on	on	IN
8691	80	6	this	this	DT
8691	80	7	view	view	NN
8691	80	8	,	,	,
8691	80	9	with	with	IN
8691	80	10	general	general	JJ
8691	80	11	consistency	consistency	NN
8691	80	12	,	,	,
8691	80	13	until	until	IN
8691	80	14	the	the	DT
8691	80	15	days	day	NNS
8691	80	16	of	of	IN
8691	80	17	the	the	DT
8691	80	18	Stamp	Stamp	NNP
8691	80	19	Act	Act	NNP
8691	80	20	,	,	,
8691	80	21	when	when	WRB
8691	80	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	80	23	became	become	VBD
8691	80	24	the	the	DT
8691	80	25	interest	interest	NN
8691	80	26	of	of	IN
8691	80	27	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	80	28	people	people	NNS
8691	80	29	to	to	TO
8691	80	30	claim	claim	VB
8691	80	31	the	the	DT
8691	80	32	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	80	33	of	of	IN
8691	80	34	the	the	DT
8691	80	35	principles	principle	NNS
8691	80	36	of	of	IN
8691	80	37	the	the	DT
8691	80	38	English	English	NNP
8691	80	39	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	80	40	and	and	CC
8691	80	41	of	of	IN
8691	80	42	the	the	DT
8691	80	43	common	common	JJ
8691	80	44	law	law	NN
8691	80	45	,	,	,
8691	80	46	on	on	IN
8691	80	47	which	which	WDT
8691	80	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	80	49	was	be	VBD
8691	80	50	built	build	VBN
8691	80	51	up	up	RP
8691	80	52	.	.	.
8691	81	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	81	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	81	3	:	:	:
8691	81	4	Colonial	Colonial	NNP
8691	81	5	Records	Records	NNPS
8691	81	6	of	of	IN
8691	81	7	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	81	8	,	,	,
8691	81	9	1689	1689	CD
8691	81	10	-	-	SYM
8691	81	11	1706	1706	CD
8691	81	12	,	,	,
8691	81	13	261	261	CD
8691	81	14	;	;	:
8691	81	15	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	82	1	Stat	Stat	NNP
8691	82	2	.	.	.
8691	82	3	,	,	,
8691	82	4	ed	ed	NNP
8691	82	5	.	.	.
8691	83	1	of	of	IN
8691	83	2	1769	1769	CD
8691	83	3	,	,	,
8691	83	4	1	1	CD
8691	83	5	.	.	.
8691	84	1	_	_	NNP
8691	84	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
8691	84	3	.	.	.
8691	84	4	_	_	NNP
8691	84	5	citations	citation	NNS
8691	84	6	by	by	IN
8691	84	7	D.	D.	NNP
8691	84	8	Davenport	Davenport	NNP
8691	84	9	,	,	,
8691	84	10	_	_	NNP
8691	84	11	arguendo	arguendo	NNP
8691	84	12	,	,	,
8691	84	13	_	_	NNP
8691	84	14	in	in	IN
8691	84	15	Flynn	Flynn	NNP
8691	84	16	_	_	NNP
8691	84	17	v.	v.	IN
8691	84	18	_	_	NNP
8691	84	19	Morgan	Morgan	NNP
8691	84	20	,	,	,
8691	84	21	55	55	CD
8691	84	22	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	84	23	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	84	24	,	,	,
8691	84	25	132	132	CD
8691	84	26	-	-	SYM
8691	84	27	134	134	CD
8691	84	28	,	,	,
8691	84	29	from	from	IN
8691	84	30	MSS	MSS	NNP
8691	84	31	.	.	.
8691	85	1	in	in	IN
8691	85	2	the	the	DT
8691	85	3	State	State	NNP
8691	85	4	archives	archive	NNS
8691	85	5	.	.	.
8691	85	6	]	]	-RRB-
8691	86	1	In	in	IN
8691	86	2	early	early	JJ
8691	86	3	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	86	4	the	the	DT
8691	86	5	written	write	VBN
8691	86	6	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	86	7	often	often	RB
8691	86	8	referred	refer	VBD
8691	86	9	to	to	IN
8691	86	10	the	the	DT
8691	86	11	Bible	Bible	NNP
8691	86	12	,	,	,
8691	86	13	quoting	quote	VBG
8691	86	14	a	a	DT
8691	86	15	text	text	NN
8691	86	16	from	from	IN
8691	86	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	86	18	as	as	IN
8691	86	19	an	an	DT
8691	86	20	authority	authority	NN
8691	86	21	,	,	,
8691	86	22	just	just	RB
8691	86	23	as	as	IN
8691	86	24	citations	citation	NNS
8691	86	25	now	now	RB
8691	86	26	might	may	MD
8691	86	27	be	be	VB
8691	86	28	made	make	VBN
8691	86	29	in	in	IN
8691	86	30	a	a	DT
8691	86	31	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	86	32	's	's	POS
8691	86	33	brief	brief	NN
8691	86	34	from	from	IN
8691	86	35	a	a	DT
8691	86	36	legal	legal	JJ
8691	86	37	treatise	treatise	NN
8691	86	38	or	or	CC
8691	86	39	reported	report	VBN
8691	86	40	case	case	NN
8691	86	41	.	.	.
8691	87	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	87	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	87	3	:	:	:
8691	87	4	Publications	publication	NNS
8691	87	5	of	of	IN
8691	87	6	the	the	DT
8691	87	7	Colonial	Colonial	NNP
8691	87	8	Society	Society	NNP
8691	87	9	of	of	IN
8691	87	10	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	87	11	,	,	,
8691	87	12	III	III	NNP
8691	87	13	,	,	,
8691	87	14	324	324	CD
8691	87	15	.	.	.
8691	87	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	88	1	As	as	IN
8691	88	2	was	be	VBD
8691	88	3	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
8691	88	4	in	in	IN
8691	88	5	the	the	DT
8691	88	6	Raleigh	Raleigh	NNP
8691	88	7	patent	patent	NN
8691	88	8	,	,	,
8691	88	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	88	10	was	be	VBD
8691	88	11	found	find	VBN
8691	88	12	from	from	IN
8691	88	13	the	the	DT
8691	88	14	first	first	JJ
8691	88	15	and	and	CC
8691	88	16	everywhere	everywhere	RB
8691	88	17	that	that	IN
8691	88	18	if	if	IN
8691	88	19	the	the	DT
8691	88	20	common	common	JJ
8691	88	21	law	law	NN
8691	88	22	was	be	VBD
8691	88	23	to	to	TO
8691	88	24	be	be	VB
8691	88	25	applied	apply	VBN
8691	88	26	to	to	IN
8691	88	27	the	the	DT
8691	88	28	rough	rough	JJ
8691	88	29	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	88	30	of	of	IN
8691	88	31	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	88	32	life	life	NN
8691	88	33	some	some	DT
8691	88	34	modifications	modification	NNS
8691	88	35	were	be	VBD
8691	88	36	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	88	37	.	.	.
8691	89	1	These	these	DT
8691	89	2	the	the	DT
8691	89	3	colonists	colonist	NNS
8691	89	4	were	be	VBD
8691	89	5	,	,	,
8691	89	6	in	in	IN
8691	89	7	the	the	DT
8691	89	8	main	main	JJ
8691	89	9	,	,	,
8691	89	10	left	leave	VBD
8691	89	11	free	free	JJ
8691	89	12	to	to	TO
8691	89	13	make	make	VB
8691	89	14	at	at	IN
8691	89	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	89	16	pleasure	pleasure	NN
8691	89	17	.	.	.
8691	90	1	Much	much	JJ
8691	90	2	of	of	IN
8691	90	3	this	this	DT
8691	90	4	work	work	NN
8691	90	5	came	come	VBD
8691	90	6	to	to	TO
8691	90	7	be	be	VB
8691	90	8	done	do	VBN
8691	90	9	by	by	IN
8691	90	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	90	11	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	90	12	assemblies	assembly	NNS
8691	90	13	;	;	:
8691	90	14	more	more	JJR
8691	90	15	by	by	IN
8691	90	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	90	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	90	18	.	.	.
8691	91	1	The	the	DT
8691	91	2	assemblies	assembly	NNS
8691	91	3	sat	sit	VBD
8691	91	4	but	but	CC
8691	91	5	for	for	IN
8691	91	6	a	a	DT
8691	91	7	few	few	JJ
8691	91	8	days	day	NNS
8691	91	9	in	in	IN
8691	91	10	the	the	DT
8691	91	11	year	year	NN
8691	91	12	:	:	:
8691	91	13	the	the	DT
8691	91	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	91	15	were	be	VBD
8691	91	16	always	always	RB
8691	91	17	open	open	JJ
8691	91	18	to	to	IN
8691	91	19	suitors	suitor	NNS
8691	91	20	,	,	,
8691	91	21	and	and	CC
8691	91	22	sessions	session	NNS
8691	91	23	of	of	IN
8691	91	24	the	the	DT
8691	91	25	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	91	26	ones	one	NNS
8691	91	27	were	be	VBD
8691	91	28	frequent	frequent	JJ
8691	91	29	.	.	.
8691	92	1	The	the	DT
8691	92	2	assemblies	assembly	NNS
8691	92	3	,	,	,
8691	92	4	however	however	RB
8691	92	5	,	,	,
8691	92	6	were	be	VBD
8691	92	7	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	92	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	92	9	.	.	.
8691	93	1	At	at	IN
8691	93	2	first	first	RB
8691	93	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	93	4	kept	keep	VBD
8691	93	5	in	in	IN
8691	93	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	93	7	own	own	JJ
8691	93	8	hands	hand	NNS
8691	93	9	a	a	DT
8691	93	10	large	large	JJ
8691	93	11	share	share	NN
8691	93	12	of	of	IN
8691	93	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	93	14	power	power	NN
8691	93	15	.	.	.
8691	94	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	94	2	acted	act	VBD
8691	94	3	as	as	IN
8691	94	4	the	the	DT
8691	94	5	early	early	JJ
8691	94	6	parliaments	parliament	NNS
8691	94	7	of	of	IN
8691	94	8	England	England	NNP
8691	94	9	had	have	VBD
8691	94	10	acted	act	VBN
8691	94	11	,	,	,
8691	94	12	both	both	CC
8691	94	13	as	as	IN
8691	94	14	a	a	DT
8691	94	15	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	94	16	and	and	CC
8691	94	17	a	a	DT
8691	94	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	94	19	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	94	20	.	.	.
8691	95	1	In	in	IN
8691	95	2	several	several	JJ
8691	95	3	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	95	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	95	5	long	long	RB
8691	95	6	kept	keep	VBD
8691	95	7	to	to	IN
8691	95	8	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	95	9	the	the	DT
8691	95	10	right	right	NN
8691	95	11	of	of	IN
8691	95	12	deciding	decide	VBG
8691	95	13	private	private	JJ
8691	95	14	controversies	controversy	NNS
8691	95	15	on	on	IN
8691	95	16	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	95	17	principles	principle	NNS
8691	95	18	.	.	.
8691	96	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	96	2	sat	sit	VBD
8691	96	3	as	as	IN
8691	96	4	a	a	DT
8691	96	5	court	court	NN
8691	96	6	of	of	IN
8691	96	7	review	review	NN
8691	96	8	,	,	,
8691	96	9	to	to	TO
8691	96	10	grant	grant	VB
8691	96	11	new	new	JJ
8691	96	12	trials	trial	NNS
8691	96	13	or	or	CC
8691	96	14	review	review	NN
8691	96	15	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	96	16	.	.	.
8691	97	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	97	2	passed	pass	VBD
8691	97	3	acts	act	NNS
8691	97	4	of	of	IN
8691	97	5	attainder	attainder	NN
8691	97	6	.	.	.
8691	98	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	98	2	settled	settle	VBD
8691	98	3	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
8691	98	4	estates	estate	NNS
8691	98	5	.	.	.
8691	99	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	99	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	99	3	:	:	:
8691	99	4	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
8691	99	5	's	's	POS
8691	99	6	Appeal	appeal	NN
8691	99	7	,	,	,
8691	99	8	45	45	CD
8691	99	9	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	99	10	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	99	11	,	,	,
8691	99	12	306	306	CD
8691	99	13	,	,	,
8691	99	14	314	314	CD
8691	99	15	.	.	.
8691	99	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	100	1	This	this	DT
8691	100	2	mingling	mingling	NN
8691	100	3	of	of	IN
8691	100	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	100	5	with	with	IN
8691	100	6	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	100	7	functions	function	NNS
8691	100	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	100	9	a	a	DT
8691	100	10	thing	thing	NN
8691	100	11	to	to	TO
8691	100	12	be	be	VB
8691	100	13	tolerated	tolerate	VBN
8691	100	14	only	only	RB
8691	100	15	while	while	IN
8691	100	16	the	the	DT
8691	100	17	foundations	foundation	NNS
8691	100	18	of	of	IN
8691	100	19	a	a	DT
8691	100	20	government	government	NN
8691	100	21	are	be	VBP
8691	100	22	being	be	VBG
8691	100	23	laid	lay	VBN
8691	100	24	.	.	.
8691	101	1	As	as	IN
8691	101	2	the	the	DT
8691	101	3	Roman	roman	JJ
8691	101	4	plebeian	plebeian	NN
8691	101	5	,	,	,
8691	101	6	in	in	IN
8691	101	7	the	the	DT
8691	101	8	days	day	NNS
8691	101	9	before	before	IN
8691	101	10	the	the	DT
8691	101	11	Twelve	Twelve	NNP
8691	101	12	Tables	Tables	NNPS
8691	101	13	,	,	,
8691	101	14	clamored	clamor	VBD
8691	101	15	for	for	IN
8691	101	16	a	a	DT
8691	101	17	known	known	JJ
8691	101	18	and	and	CC
8691	101	19	certain	certain	JJ
8691	101	20	law	law	NN
8691	101	21	,	,	,
8691	101	22	so	so	CC
8691	101	23	the	the	DT
8691	101	24	common	common	JJ
8691	101	25	people	people	NNS
8691	101	26	of	of	IN
8691	101	27	the	the	DT
8691	101	28	early	early	JJ
8691	101	29	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	101	30	insisted	insist	VBD
8691	101	31	that	that	IN
8691	101	32	from	from	IN
8691	101	33	a	a	DT
8691	101	34	similar	similar	JJ
8691	101	35	want	want	NN
8691	101	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	101	37	held	hold	VBD
8691	101	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	101	39	rights	right	NNS
8691	101	40	too	too	RB
8691	101	41	much	much	RB
8691	101	42	at	at	IN
8691	101	43	the	the	DT
8691	101	44	will	will	NN
8691	101	45	of	of	IN
8691	101	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	101	47	rulers	ruler	NNS
8691	101	48	.	.	.
8691	102	1	In	in	IN
8691	102	2	the	the	DT
8691	102	3	colony	colony	NN
8691	102	4	of	of	IN
8691	102	5	New	New	NNP
8691	102	6	Haven	Haven	NNP
8691	102	7	a	a	DT
8691	102	8	code	code	NN
8691	102	9	was	be	VBD
8691	102	10	early	early	RB
8691	102	11	framed	frame	VBN
8691	102	12	;	;	:
8691	102	13	but	but	CC
8691	102	14	there	there	RB
8691	102	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	102	16	built	build	VBD
8691	102	17	on	on	IN
8691	102	18	a	a	DT
8691	102	19	written	write	VBN
8691	102	20	law	law	NN
8691	102	21	--	--	:
8691	102	22	the	the	DT
8691	102	23	Bible	Bible	NNP
8691	102	24	.	.	.
8691	103	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	103	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	103	3	:	:	:
8691	103	4	New	New	NNP
8691	103	5	Haven	Haven	NNP
8691	103	6	Colony	Colony	NNP
8691	103	7	Records	Records	NNPS
8691	103	8	,	,	,
8691	103	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	103	10	,	,	,
8691	103	11	12	12	CD
8691	103	12	,	,	,
8691	103	13	115	115	CD
8691	103	14	,	,	,
8691	103	15	116	116	CD
8691	103	16	;	;	:
8691	103	17	II	II	NNP
8691	103	18	,	,	,
8691	103	19	569	569	CD
8691	103	20	,	,	,
8691	103	21	570	570	CD
8691	103	22	.	.	.
8691	103	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	104	1	In	in	IN
8691	104	2	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	104	3	,	,	,
8691	104	4	where	where	WRB
8691	104	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	104	6	were	be	VBD
8691	104	7	more	more	RBR
8691	104	8	anxious	anxious	JJ
8691	104	9	to	to	TO
8691	104	10	avoid	avoid	VB
8691	104	11	conflict	conflict	NN
8691	104	12	with	with	IN
8691	104	13	the	the	DT
8691	104	14	common	common	JJ
8691	104	15	law	law	NN
8691	104	16	,	,	,
8691	104	17	the	the	DT
8691	104	18	problem	problem	NN
8691	104	19	was	be	VBD
8691	104	20	a	a	DT
8691	104	21	serious	serious	JJ
8691	104	22	one	one	NN
8691	104	23	.	.	.
8691	105	1	Winthrop	Winthrop	NNP
8691	105	2	,	,	,
8691	105	3	writing	write	VBG
8691	105	4	in	in	IN
8691	105	5	1639	1639	CD
8691	105	6	,	,	,
8691	105	7	describes	describe	VBZ
8691	105	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	105	9	with	with	IN
8691	105	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	105	11	usual	usual	JJ
8691	105	12	clearness	clearness	NN
8691	105	13	and	and	CC
8691	105	14	discrimination	discrimination	NN
8691	105	15	thus	thus	RB
8691	105	16	:	:	:
8691	105	17	"	"	``
8691	105	18	The	the	DT
8691	105	19	people	people	NNS
8691	105	20	had	have	VBD
8691	105	21	long	long	RB
8691	105	22	desired	desire	VBN
8691	105	23	a	a	DT
8691	105	24	body	body	NN
8691	105	25	of	of	IN
8691	105	26	laws	law	NNS
8691	105	27	,	,	,
8691	105	28	and	and	CC
8691	105	29	thought	think	VBD
8691	105	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	105	31	condition	condition	NN
8691	105	32	very	very	RB
8691	105	33	unsafe	unsafe	JJ
8691	105	34	while	while	IN
8691	105	35	so	so	RB
8691	105	36	much	much	JJ
8691	105	37	power	power	NN
8691	105	38	rested	rest	VBN
8691	105	39	in	in	IN
8691	105	40	the	the	DT
8691	105	41	discretion	discretion	NN
8691	105	42	of	of	IN
8691	105	43	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
8691	105	44	....	....	.
8691	105	45	Two	two	CD
8691	105	46	great	great	JJ
8691	105	47	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	105	48	there	there	EX
8691	105	49	were	be	VBD
8691	105	50	,	,	,
8691	105	51	which	which	WDT
8691	105	52	caused	cause	VBD
8691	105	53	most	most	JJS
8691	105	54	of	of	IN
8691	105	55	the	the	DT
8691	105	56	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
8691	105	57	and	and	CC
8691	105	58	some	some	DT
8691	105	59	of	of	IN
8691	105	60	the	the	DT
8691	105	61	elders	elder	NNS
8691	105	62	not	not	RB
8691	105	63	to	to	TO
8691	105	64	be	be	VB
8691	105	65	very	very	RB
8691	105	66	forward	forward	RB
8691	105	67	in	in	IN
8691	105	68	this	this	DT
8691	105	69	matter	matter	NN
8691	105	70	.	.	.
8691	106	1	One	one	CD
8691	106	2	was	be	VBD
8691	106	3	want	want	NN
8691	106	4	of	of	IN
8691	106	5	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	106	6	experience	experience	NN
8691	106	7	of	of	IN
8691	106	8	the	the	DT
8691	106	9	nature	nature	NN
8691	106	10	and	and	CC
8691	106	11	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	106	12	of	of	IN
8691	106	13	the	the	DT
8691	106	14	people	people	NNS
8691	106	15	,	,	,
8691	106	16	considered	consider	VBN
8691	106	17	with	with	IN
8691	106	18	the	the	DT
8691	106	19	condition	condition	NN
8691	106	20	of	of	IN
8691	106	21	the	the	DT
8691	106	22	country	country	NN
8691	106	23	and	and	CC
8691	106	24	other	other	JJ
8691	106	25	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	106	26	,	,	,
8691	106	27	which	which	WDT
8691	106	28	made	make	VBD
8691	106	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	106	30	conceive	conceive	VB
8691	106	31	that	that	IN
8691	106	32	such	such	JJ
8691	106	33	laws	law	NNS
8691	106	34	would	would	MD
8691	106	35	be	be	VB
8691	106	36	fittest	fit	JJS
8691	106	37	for	for	IN
8691	106	38	us	-PRON-	PRP
8691	106	39	which	which	WDT
8691	106	40	should	should	MD
8691	106	41	arise	arise	VB
8691	106	42	_	_	NNP
8691	106	43	pro	pro	FW
8691	106	44	re	re	NN
8691	106	45	nata	nata	NNP
8691	106	46	_	_	NNP
8691	106	47	upon	upon	IN
8691	106	48	occasions	occasion	NNS
8691	106	49	,	,	,
8691	106	50	etc	etc	FW
8691	106	51	.	.	FW
8691	106	52	,	,	,
8691	106	53	and	and	CC
8691	106	54	so	so	RB
8691	106	55	the	the	DT
8691	106	56	laws	law	NNS
8691	106	57	of	of	IN
8691	106	58	England	England	NNP
8691	106	59	and	and	CC
8691	106	60	other	other	JJ
8691	106	61	states	state	NNS
8691	106	62	grew	grow	VBD
8691	106	63	,	,	,
8691	106	64	and	and	CC
8691	106	65	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	106	66	the	the	DT
8691	106	67	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	106	68	laws	law	NNS
8691	106	69	of	of	IN
8691	106	70	England	England	NNP
8691	106	71	are	be	VBP
8691	106	72	called	call	VBN
8691	106	73	customs	custom	NNS
8691	106	74	,	,	,
8691	106	75	consuetudines	consuetudine	NNS
8691	106	76	.	.	.
8691	107	1	2	2	LS
8691	107	2	.	.	.
8691	108	1	For	for	IN
8691	108	2	that	that	IN
8691	108	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	108	4	would	would	MD
8691	108	5	professedly	professedly	RB
8691	108	6	transgress	transgress	VB
8691	108	7	the	the	DT
8691	108	8	limits	limit	NNS
8691	108	9	of	of	IN
8691	108	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	108	11	charter	charter	NN
8691	108	12	,	,	,
8691	108	13	which	which	WDT
8691	108	14	provide	provide	VBP
8691	108	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	108	16	shall	shall	MD
8691	108	17	make	make	VB
8691	108	18	no	no	DT
8691	108	19	laws	law	NNS
8691	108	20	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
8691	108	21	to	to	IN
8691	108	22	the	the	DT
8691	108	23	laws	law	NNS
8691	108	24	of	of	IN
8691	108	25	England	England	NNP
8691	108	26	,	,	,
8691	108	27	and	and	CC
8691	108	28	that	that	IN
8691	108	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	108	30	were	be	VBD
8691	108	31	assured	assure	VBN
8691	108	32	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	108	33	must	must	MD
8691	108	34	do	do	VB
8691	108	35	.	.	.
8691	109	1	But	but	CC
8691	109	2	to	to	TO
8691	109	3	raise	raise	VB
8691	109	4	up	up	RP
8691	109	5	laws	law	NNS
8691	109	6	by	by	IN
8691	109	7	practice	practice	NN
8691	109	8	and	and	CC
8691	109	9	custom	custom	NN
8691	109	10	had	have	VBD
8691	109	11	been	be	VBN
8691	109	12	no	no	DT
8691	109	13	transgression	transgression	NN
8691	109	14	.	.	.
8691	110	1	"	"	``
8691	110	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	110	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	110	4	:	:	:
8691	110	5	Winthrop	Winthrop	NNP
8691	110	6	,	,	,
8691	110	7	"	"	``
8691	110	8	History	history	NN
8691	110	9	of	of	IN
8691	110	10	New	New	NNP
8691	110	11	England	England	NNP
8691	110	12	,	,	,
8691	110	13	"	"	``
8691	110	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	110	15	,	,	,
8691	110	16	322	322	CD
8691	110	17	.	.	.
8691	110	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	111	1	The	the	DT
8691	111	2	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	111	3	toward	toward	IN
8691	111	4	partial	partial	JJ
8691	111	5	codification	codification	NN
8691	111	6	proved	prove	VBD
8691	111	7	too	too	RB
8691	111	8	strong	strong	JJ
8691	111	9	to	to	TO
8691	111	10	be	be	VB
8691	111	11	resisted	resist	VBN
8691	111	12	,	,	,
8691	111	13	and	and	CC
8691	111	14	all	all	PDT
8691	111	15	the	the	DT
8691	111	16	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	111	17	soon	soon	RB
8691	111	18	had	have	VBD
8691	111	19	a	a	DT
8691	111	20	substantial	substantial	JJ
8691	111	21	body	body	NN
8691	111	22	of	of	IN
8691	111	23	written	write	VBN
8691	111	24	law	law	NN
8691	111	25	published	publish	VBN
8691	111	26	in	in	IN
8691	111	27	official	official	JJ
8691	111	28	form	form	NN
8691	111	29	.	.	.
8691	112	1	The	the	DT
8691	112	2	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	112	3	of	of	IN
8691	112	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	112	5	power	power	NN
8691	112	6	by	by	IN
8691	112	7	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	112	8	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	112	9	was	be	VBD
8691	112	10	steadily	steadily	RB
8691	112	11	contracting	contract	VBG
8691	112	12	throughout	throughout	IN
8691	112	13	the	the	DT
8691	112	14	century	century	NN
8691	112	15	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	112	16	the	the	DT
8691	112	17	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	112	18	.	.	.
8691	113	1	Where	where	WRB
8691	113	2	there	there	EX
8691	113	3	were	be	VBD
8691	113	4	Governors	governor	NNS
8691	113	5	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	113	6	by	by	IN
8691	113	7	the	the	DT
8691	113	8	crown	crown	NN
8691	113	9	,	,	,
8691	113	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	113	11	discouraged	discourage	VBD
8691	113	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	113	13	.	.	.
8691	114	1	The	the	DT
8691	114	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	114	3	were	be	VBD
8691	114	4	correspondingly	correspondingly	RB
8691	114	5	strengthened	strengthen	VBN
8691	114	6	.	.	.
8691	115	1	Law	Law	NNP
8691	115	2	became	become	VBD
8691	115	3	better	well	RBR
8691	115	4	understood	understand	VBD
8691	115	5	and	and	CC
8691	115	6	more	more	RBR
8691	115	7	wisely	wisely	RB
8691	115	8	applied	apply	VBN
8691	115	9	.	.	.
8691	116	1	A	a	DT
8691	116	2	large	large	JJ
8691	116	3	body	body	NN
8691	116	4	of	of	IN
8691	116	5	local	local	JJ
8691	116	6	statute	statute	NN
8691	116	7	law	law	NN
8691	116	8	had	have	VBD
8691	116	9	grown	grow	VBN
8691	116	10	up	up	RP
8691	116	11	by	by	IN
8691	116	12	1750	1750	CD
8691	116	13	,	,	,
8691	116	14	much	much	JJ
8691	116	15	of	of	IN
8691	116	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	116	17	already	already	RB
8691	116	18	venerable	venerable	JJ
8691	116	19	by	by	IN
8691	116	20	antiquity	antiquity	NN
8691	116	21	,	,	,
8691	116	22	and	and	CC
8691	116	23	intimately	intimately	RB
8691	116	24	interwoven	interwoven	JJ
8691	116	25	with	with	IN
8691	116	26	the	the	DT
8691	116	27	life	life	NN
8691	116	28	of	of	IN
8691	116	29	the	the	DT
8691	116	30	people	people	NNS
8691	116	31	.	.	.
8691	117	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	117	2	form	form	NN
8691	117	3	and	and	CC
8691	117	4	color	color	NN
8691	117	5	differed	differ	VBN
8691	117	6	in	in	IN
8691	117	7	different	different	JJ
8691	117	8	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	117	9	.	.	.
8691	118	1	Religious	religious	JJ
8691	118	2	views	view	NNS
8691	118	3	and	and	CC
8691	118	4	preferences	preference	NNS
8691	118	5	had	have	VBD
8691	118	6	had	have	VBN
8691	118	7	a	a	DT
8691	118	8	large	large	JJ
8691	118	9	effect	effect	NN
8691	118	10	in	in	IN
8691	118	11	shaping	shape	VBG
8691	118	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	118	13	.	.	.
8691	119	1	So	so	RB
8691	119	2	had	have	VBD
8691	119	3	influences	influence	NNS
8691	119	4	proceeding	proceed	VBG
8691	119	5	from	from	IN
8691	119	6	the	the	DT
8691	119	7	civil	civil	JJ
8691	119	8	war	war	NN
8691	119	9	,	,	,
8691	119	10	the	the	DT
8691	119	11	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
8691	119	12	,	,	,
8691	119	13	and	and	CC
8691	119	14	the	the	DT
8691	119	15	Restoration	Restoration	NNP
8691	119	16	.	.	.
8691	120	1	Yet	yet	CC
8691	120	2	at	at	IN
8691	120	3	bottom	bottom	NN
8691	120	4	there	there	EX
8691	120	5	was	be	VBD
8691	120	6	the	the	DT
8691	120	7	same	same	JJ
8691	120	8	substructure	substructure	NN
8691	120	9	in	in	IN
8691	120	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	120	11	as	as	IN
8691	120	12	in	in	IN
8691	120	13	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	120	14	,	,	,
8691	120	15	in	in	IN
8691	120	16	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	120	17	as	as	IN
8691	120	18	in	in	IN
8691	120	19	New	New	NNP
8691	120	20	York	York	NNP
8691	120	21	.	.	.
8691	121	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	121	2	was	be	VBD
8691	121	3	the	the	DT
8691	121	4	common	common	JJ
8691	121	5	law	law	NN
8691	121	6	of	of	IN
8691	121	7	England	England	NNP
8691	121	8	as	as	IN
8691	121	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	121	10	existed	exist	VBD
8691	121	11	in	in	IN
8691	121	12	the	the	DT
8691	121	13	days	day	NNS
8691	121	14	of	of	IN
8691	121	15	the	the	DT
8691	121	16	last	last	JJ
8691	121	17	of	of	IN
8691	121	18	the	the	DT
8691	121	19	Tudor	Tudor	NNP
8691	121	20	and	and	CC
8691	121	21	first	first	RB
8691	121	22	of	of	IN
8691	121	23	the	the	DT
8691	121	24	Stuart	Stuart	NNP
8691	121	25	reigns	reign	NNS
8691	121	26	.	.	.
8691	122	1	This	this	DT
8691	122	2	had	have	VBD
8691	122	3	been	be	VBN
8691	122	4	built	build	VBN
8691	122	5	into	into	IN
8691	122	6	the	the	DT
8691	122	7	foundations	foundation	NNS
8691	122	8	of	of	IN
8691	122	9	American	american	JJ
8691	122	10	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	122	11	and	and	CC
8691	122	12	kept	keep	VBD
8691	122	13	firm	firm	JJ
8691	122	14	in	in	IN
8691	122	15	place	place	NN
8691	122	16	,	,	,
8691	122	17	not	not	RB
8691	122	18	only	only	RB
8691	122	19	because	because	IN
8691	122	20	the	the	DT
8691	122	21	colonists	colonist	NNS
8691	122	22	were	be	VBD
8691	122	23	habituated	habituate	VBN
8691	122	24	to	to	TO
8691	122	25	it[Footnote	it[footnote	VB
8691	122	26	:	:	:
8691	122	27	Fitch	fitch	VB
8691	122	28	_	_	NNP
8691	122	29	v.	v.	IN
8691	122	30	_	_	NNP
8691	122	31	Brainerd	Brainerd	NNP
8691	122	32	,	,	,
8691	122	33	2	2	CD
8691	122	34	Day	Day	NNP
8691	122	35	's	's	POS
8691	122	36	(	(	-LRB-
8691	122	37	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	122	38	)	)	-RRB-
8691	122	39	Reports	report	NNS
8691	122	40	,	,	,
8691	122	41	163	163	CD
8691	122	42	,	,	,
8691	122	43	189	189	CD
8691	122	44	.	.	.
8691	122	45	]	]	-RRB-
8691	123	1	and	and	CC
8691	123	2	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	123	3	both	both	DT
8691	123	4	English	english	JJ
8691	123	5	subjects	subject	NNS
8691	123	6	and	and	CC
8691	123	7	the	the	DT
8691	123	8	descendants	descendant	NNS
8691	123	9	of	of	IN
8691	123	10	Englishmen	Englishmen	NNPS
8691	123	11	of	of	IN
8691	123	12	those	those	DT
8691	123	13	days	day	NNS
8691	123	14	,	,	,
8691	123	15	but	but	CC
8691	123	16	largely	largely	RB
8691	123	17	by	by	IN
8691	123	18	force	force	NN
8691	123	19	of	of	IN
8691	123	20	the	the	DT
8691	123	21	British	british	JJ
8691	123	22	system	system	NN
8691	123	23	of	of	IN
8691	123	24	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	123	25	government	government	NN
8691	123	26	through	through	IN
8691	123	27	the	the	DT
8691	123	28	Lords	Lords	NNPS
8691	123	29	of	of	IN
8691	123	30	Trade	Trade	NNP
8691	123	31	and	and	CC
8691	123	32	Plantations	Plantations	NNP
8691	123	33	.	.	.
8691	124	1	The	the	DT
8691	124	2	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	124	3	_	_	NNP
8691	124	4	aula	aula	NNP
8691	124	5	regis	regis	NNP
8691	124	6	_	_	NNP
8691	124	7	,	,	,
8691	124	8	in	in	IN
8691	124	9	which	which	WDT
8691	124	10	the	the	DT
8691	124	11	king	king	NN
8691	124	12	dispensed	dispense	VBD
8691	124	13	justice	justice	NN
8691	124	14	at	at	IN
8691	124	15	first	first	JJ
8691	124	16	hand	hand	NN
8691	124	17	,	,	,
8691	124	18	had	have	VBD
8691	124	19	survived	survive	VBN
8691	124	20	in	in	IN
8691	124	21	another	another	DT
8691	124	22	form	form	NN
8691	124	23	in	in	IN
8691	124	24	the	the	DT
8691	124	25	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	124	26	known	know	VBN
8691	124	27	as	as	IN
8691	124	28	the	the	DT
8691	124	29	King	King	NNP
8691	124	30	in	in	IN
8691	124	31	Council	Council	NNP
8691	124	32	.	.	.
8691	125	1	This	this	DT
8691	125	2	,	,	,
8691	125	3	so	so	RB
8691	125	4	far	far	RB
8691	125	5	as	as	IN
8691	125	6	the	the	DT
8691	125	7	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	125	8	were	be	VBD
8691	125	9	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	125	10	,	,	,
8691	125	11	was	be	VBD
8691	125	12	represented	represent	VBN
8691	125	13	by	by	IN
8691	125	14	a	a	DT
8691	125	15	standing	stand	VBG
8691	125	16	committee	committee	NN
8691	125	17	of	of	IN
8691	125	18	the	the	DT
8691	125	19	Privy	Privy	NNP
8691	125	20	Council	Council	NNP
8691	125	21	.	.	.
8691	126	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	126	2	was	be	VBD
8691	126	3	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	126	4	the	the	DT
8691	126	5	same	same	JJ
8691	126	6	thing	thing	NN
8691	126	7	as	as	IN
8691	126	8	the	the	DT
8691	126	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	126	10	of	of	IN
8691	126	11	Star	Star	NNP
8691	126	12	Chamber	Chamber	NNP
8691	126	13	,	,	,
8691	126	14	but	but	CC
8691	126	15	since	since	IN
8691	126	16	1640	1640	CD
8691	126	17	without	without	IN
8691	126	18	the	the	DT
8691	126	19	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
8691	126	20	penal	penal	JJ
8691	126	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	126	22	which	which	WDT
8691	126	23	gave	give	VBD
8691	126	24	that	that	DT
8691	126	25	so	so	RB
8691	126	26	evil	evil	JJ
8691	126	27	a	a	DT
8691	126	28	reputation	reputation	NN
8691	126	29	for	for	IN
8691	126	30	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	126	31	.	.	.
8691	127	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	127	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	127	3	:	:	:
8691	127	4	Maitland	Maitland	NNP
8691	127	5	,	,	,
8691	127	6	"	"	''
8691	127	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	127	8	and	and	CC
8691	127	9	Police	Police	NNPS
8691	127	10	,	,	,
8691	127	11	"	"	''
8691	127	12	5	5	CD
8691	127	13	.	.	.
8691	127	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	128	1	This	this	DT
8691	128	2	committee	committee	NN
8691	128	3	was	be	VBD
8691	128	4	after	after	IN
8691	128	5	this	this	DT
8691	128	6	restriction	restriction	NN
8691	128	7	of	of	IN
8691	128	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	128	9	powers	power	NNS
8691	128	10	known	know	VBN
8691	128	11	as	as	IN
8691	128	12	the	the	DT
8691	128	13	Lords	Lords	NNPS
8691	128	14	of	of	IN
8691	128	15	Trade	Trade	NNP
8691	128	16	and	and	CC
8691	128	17	Plantations,[Footnote	Plantations,[Footnote	NNP
8691	128	18	:	:	:
8691	128	19	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	128	20	was	be	VBD
8691	128	21	afterward	afterward	RB
8691	128	22	and	and	CC
8691	128	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	128	24	now	now	RB
8691	128	25	called	call	VBN
8691	128	26	the	the	DT
8691	128	27	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	128	28	Committee	Committee	NNP
8691	128	29	of	of	IN
8691	128	30	the	the	DT
8691	128	31	Privy	Privy	NNP
8691	128	32	Council	Council	NNP
8691	128	33	.	.	.
8691	128	34	]	]	-RRB-
8691	129	1	and	and	CC
8691	129	2	by	by	IN
8691	129	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	129	4	authority	authority	NN
8691	129	5	from	from	IN
8691	129	6	the	the	DT
8691	129	7	time	time	NN
8691	129	8	when	when	WRB
8691	129	9	England	England	NNP
8691	129	10	first	first	RB
8691	129	11	had	have	VBD
8691	129	12	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	129	13	of	of	IN
8691	129	14	any	any	DT
8691	129	15	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	129	16	importance	importance	NN
8691	129	17	(	(	-LRB-
8691	129	18	and	and	CC
8691	129	19	those	those	DT
8691	129	20	in	in	IN
8691	129	21	America	America	NNP
8691	129	22	were	be	VBD
8691	129	23	the	the	DT
8691	129	24	first	first	JJ
8691	129	25	)	)	-RRB-
8691	129	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	129	27	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	129	28	could	could	MD
8691	129	29	be	be	VB
8691	129	30	set	set	VBN
8691	129	31	aside	aside	RB
8691	129	32	and	and	CC
8691	129	33	the	the	DT
8691	129	34	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	129	35	of	of	IN
8691	129	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	129	37	courts	court	NNS
8691	129	38	,	,	,
8691	129	39	when	when	WRB
8691	129	40	of	of	IN
8691	129	41	any	any	DT
8691	129	42	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	129	43	magnitude	magnitude	NN
8691	129	44	and	and	CC
8691	129	45	importance	importance	NN
8691	129	46	,	,	,
8691	129	47	reversed	reverse	VBN
8691	129	48	.	.	.
8691	130	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	130	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	130	3	:	:	:
8691	130	4	See	see	VB
8691	130	5	Paper	Paper	NNP
8691	130	6	on	on	IN
8691	130	7	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	130	8	to	to	IN
8691	130	9	the	the	DT
8691	130	10	Lords	Lords	NNPS
8691	130	11	of	of	IN
8691	130	12	Trade	Trade	NNP
8691	130	13	from	from	IN
8691	130	14	Colonial	Colonial	NNP
8691	130	15	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	130	16	,	,	,
8691	130	17	by	by	IN
8691	130	18	Harold	Harold	NNP
8691	130	19	D.	D.	NNP
8691	130	20	Hazeltine	Hazeltine	NNP
8691	130	21	,	,	,
8691	130	22	Report	Report	NNP
8691	130	23	of	of	IN
8691	130	24	the	the	DT
8691	130	25	American	American	NNP
8691	130	26	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	130	27	Association	Association	NNP
8691	130	28	for	for	IN
8691	130	29	1894	1894	CD
8691	130	30	,	,	,
8691	130	31	299	299	CD
8691	130	32	.	.	.
8691	130	33	]	]	-RRB-
8691	131	1	This	this	DT
8691	131	2	revisory	revisory	JJ
8691	131	3	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	131	4	,	,	,
8691	131	5	though	though	IN
8691	131	6	questioned	question	VBN
8691	131	7	and	and	CC
8691	131	8	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	131	9	evaded	evade	VBN
8691	131	10	or	or	CC
8691	131	11	thwarted	thwart	VBN
8691	131	12	by	by	IN
8691	131	13	the	the	DT
8691	131	14	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	131	15	governments	government	NNS
8691	131	16	,	,	,
8691	131	17	became	become	VBD
8691	131	18	solidly	solidly	RB
8691	131	19	established	establish	VBN
8691	131	20	long	long	RB
8691	131	21	before	before	IN
8691	131	22	the	the	DT
8691	131	23	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	131	24	.	.	.
8691	132	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	132	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	132	3	:	:	:
8691	132	4	"	"	``
8691	132	5	Two	two	CD
8691	132	6	Centuries	Centuries	NNPS
8691	132	7	'	'	POS
8691	132	8	Growth	Growth	NNP
8691	132	9	of	of	IN
8691	132	10	American	American	NNP
8691	132	11	Law	Law	NNP
8691	132	12	,	,	,
8691	132	13	"	"	''
8691	132	14	12	12	CD
8691	132	15	,	,	,
8691	132	16	18	18	CD
8691	132	17	,	,	,
8691	132	18	264	264	CD
8691	132	19	.	.	.
8691	132	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	133	1	In	in	IN
8691	133	2	but	but	CC
8691	133	3	one	one	CD
8691	133	4	case	case	NN
8691	133	5	did	do	VBD
8691	133	6	a	a	DT
8691	133	7	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	133	8	court	court	NN
8691	133	9	formally	formally	RB
8691	133	10	ignore	ignore	VB
8691	133	11	a	a	DT
8691	133	12	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	133	13	of	of	IN
8691	133	14	reversal	reversal	NN
8691	133	15	.	.	.
8691	134	1	This	this	DT
8691	134	2	was	be	VBD
8691	134	3	in	in	IN
8691	134	4	1738	1738	CD
8691	134	5	,	,	,
8691	134	6	when	when	WRB
8691	134	7	the	the	DT
8691	134	8	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	134	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	134	10	of	of	IN
8691	134	11	Judicature	Judicature	NNP
8691	134	12	of	of	IN
8691	134	13	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	134	14	,	,	,
8691	134	15	at	at	IN
8691	134	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	134	17	sittings	sitting	NNS
8691	134	18	in	in	IN
8691	134	19	York	York	NNP
8691	134	20	County	County	NNP
8691	134	21	,	,	,
8691	134	22	in	in	IN
8691	134	23	what	what	WP
8691	134	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	134	25	now	now	RB
8691	134	26	the	the	DT
8691	134	27	State	State	NNP
8691	134	28	of	of	IN
8691	134	29	Maine	Maine	NNP
8691	134	30	,	,	,
8691	134	31	disobeyed	disobey	VBD
8691	134	32	an	an	DT
8691	134	33	order	order	NN
8691	134	34	of	of	IN
8691	134	35	the	the	DT
8691	134	36	King	King	NNP
8691	134	37	in	in	IN
8691	134	38	Council	Council	NNP
8691	134	39	made	make	VBD
8691	134	40	on	on	IN
8691	134	41	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	134	42	from	from	IN
8691	134	43	one	one	CD
8691	134	44	of	of	IN
8691	134	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	134	46	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	134	47	,	,	,
8691	134	48	and	and	CC
8691	134	49	when	when	WRB
8691	134	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	134	51	was	be	VBD
8691	134	52	repeated	repeat	VBN
8691	134	53	a	a	DT
8691	134	54	year	year	NN
8691	134	55	later	later	RB
8691	134	56	,	,	,
8691	134	57	adhered	adhere	VBN
8691	134	58	to	to	IN
8691	134	59	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	134	60	original	original	JJ
8691	134	61	position	position	NN
8691	134	62	.	.	.
8691	135	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	135	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	135	3	:	:	:
8691	135	4	Frost	Frost	NNP
8691	135	5	_	_	NNP
8691	135	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	135	7	_	_	NNP
8691	135	8	Leighton	Leighton	NNP
8691	135	9	,	,	,
8691	135	10	Publications	Publications	NNPS
8691	135	11	of	of	IN
8691	135	12	the	the	DT
8691	135	13	Colonial	Colonial	NNP
8691	135	14	Society	Society	NNP
8691	135	15	of	of	IN
8691	135	16	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	135	17	,	,	,
8691	135	18	III	III	NNP
8691	135	19	,	,	,
8691	135	20	246	246	CD
8691	135	21	.	.	.
8691	135	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	136	1	The	the	DT
8691	136	2	amount	amount	NN
8691	136	3	involved	involve	VBN
8691	136	4	was	be	VBD
8691	136	5	trifling	trifle	VBG
8691	136	6	,	,	,
8691	136	7	and	and	CC
8691	136	8	the	the	DT
8691	136	9	Lords	Lords	NNPS
8691	136	10	of	of	IN
8691	136	11	Trade	Trade	NNP
8691	136	12	and	and	CC
8691	136	13	Plantations	Plantations	NNP
8691	136	14	made	make	VBD
8691	136	15	no	no	DT
8691	136	16	further	further	JJ
8691	136	17	effort	effort	NN
8691	136	18	to	to	TO
8691	136	19	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	136	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	136	21	order	order	NN
8691	136	22	.	.	.
8691	137	1	The	the	DT
8691	137	2	natural	natural	JJ
8691	137	3	effect	effect	NN
8691	137	4	of	of	IN
8691	137	5	this	this	DT
8691	137	6	court	court	NN
8691	137	7	of	of	IN
8691	137	8	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	137	9	at	at	IN
8691	137	10	London	London	NNP
8691	137	11	was	be	VBD
8691	137	12	to	to	TO
8691	137	13	keep	keep	VB
8691	137	14	the	the	DT
8691	137	15	public	public	JJ
8691	137	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	137	17	of	of	IN
8691	137	18	the	the	DT
8691	137	19	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	137	20	in	in	IN
8691	137	21	line	line	NN
8691	137	22	with	with	IN
8691	137	23	the	the	DT
8691	137	24	common	common	JJ
8691	137	25	law	law	NN
8691	137	26	of	of	IN
8691	137	27	England	England	NNP
8691	137	28	,	,	,
8691	137	29	so	so	RB
8691	137	30	far	far	RB
8691	137	31	as	as	IN
8691	137	32	related	relate	VBN
8691	137	33	to	to	IN
8691	137	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	137	35	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	137	36	principles	principle	NNS
8691	137	37	.	.	.
8691	138	1	A	a	DT
8691	138	2	certain	certain	JJ
8691	138	3	uniformity	uniformity	NN
8691	138	4	of	of	IN
8691	138	5	result	result	NN
8691	138	6	was	be	VBD
8691	138	7	thus	thus	RB
8691	138	8	secured	secure	VBN
8691	138	9	.	.	.
8691	139	1	American	american	JJ
8691	139	2	law	law	NN
8691	139	3	,	,	,
8691	139	4	in	in	IN
8691	139	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	139	6	substantial	substantial	JJ
8691	139	7	framework	framework	NN
8691	139	8	,	,	,
8691	139	9	was	be	VBD
8691	139	10	not	not	RB
8691	139	11	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	139	12	to	to	TO
8691	139	13	vary	vary	VB
8691	139	14	from	from	IN
8691	139	15	English	english	JJ
8691	139	16	law	law	NN
8691	139	17	in	in	IN
8691	139	18	any	any	DT
8691	139	19	case	case	NN
8691	139	20	where	where	WRB
8691	139	21	agreement	agreement	NN
8691	139	22	was	be	VBD
8691	139	23	reasonably	reasonably	RB
8691	139	24	practicable	practicable	JJ
8691	139	25	.	.	.
8691	140	1	There	there	EX
8691	140	2	was	be	VBD
8691	140	3	a	a	DT
8691	140	4	central	central	JJ
8691	140	5	power	power	NN
8691	140	6	at	at	IN
8691	140	7	London	London	NNP
8691	140	8	ever	ever	RB
8691	140	9	ready	ready	JJ
8691	140	10	to	to	TO
8691	140	11	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	140	12	the	the	DT
8691	140	13	charter	charter	NN
8691	140	14	rule	rule	NN
8691	140	15	.	.	.
8691	141	1	The	the	DT
8691	141	2	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	141	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	141	4	,	,	,
8691	141	5	if	if	IN
8691	141	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	141	7	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	141	8	were	be	VBD
8691	141	9	to	to	TO
8691	141	10	stand	stand	VB
8691	141	11	,	,	,
8691	141	12	must	must	MD
8691	141	13	proceed	proceed	VB
8691	141	14	in	in	IN
8691	141	15	conformity	conformity	NN
8691	141	16	to	to	IN
8691	141	17	the	the	DT
8691	141	18	British	british	JJ
8691	141	19	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	141	20	.	.	.
8691	142	1	Justice	justice	NN
8691	142	2	must	must	MD
8691	142	3	be	be	VB
8691	142	4	administered	administer	VBN
8691	142	5	by	by	IN
8691	142	6	due	due	JJ
8691	142	7	course	course	NN
8691	142	8	of	of	IN
8691	142	9	law	law	NN
8691	142	10	,	,	,
8691	142	11	and	and	CC
8691	142	12	to	to	TO
8691	142	13	find	find	VB
8691	142	14	out	out	RP
8691	142	15	what	what	WP
8691	142	16	that	that	DT
8691	142	17	due	due	JJ
8691	142	18	course	course	NN
8691	142	19	was	be	VBD
8691	142	20	the	the	DT
8691	142	21	judges	judge	NNS
8691	142	22	were	be	VBD
8691	142	23	forced	force	VBN
8691	142	24	to	to	TO
8691	142	25	study	study	VB
8691	142	26	the	the	DT
8691	142	27	English	english	JJ
8691	142	28	law	law	NN
8691	142	29	-	-	HYPH
8691	142	30	books	book	NNS
8691	142	31	.	.	.
8691	143	1	When	when	WRB
8691	143	2	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
8691	143	3	's	's	POS
8691	143	4	Commentaries	Commentaries	NNPS
8691	143	5	were	be	VBD
8691	143	6	first	first	RB
8691	143	7	published	publish	VBN
8691	143	8	,	,	,
8691	143	9	more	more	JJR
8691	143	10	copies	copy	NNS
8691	143	11	were	be	VBD
8691	143	12	sold	sell	VBN
8691	143	13	in	in	IN
8691	143	14	America	America	NNP
8691	143	15	than	than	IN
8691	143	16	in	in	IN
8691	143	17	England	England	NNP
8691	143	18	.	.	.
8691	144	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	144	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	144	3	:	:	:
8691	144	4	"	"	``
8691	144	5	Two	two	CD
8691	144	6	Centuries	Centuries	NNPS
8691	144	7	'	'	POS
8691	144	8	Growth	Growth	NNP
8691	144	9	of	of	IN
8691	144	10	American	American	NNP
8691	144	11	Law	Law	NNP
8691	144	12	,	,	,
8691	144	13	"	"	''
8691	144	14	20	20	CD
8691	144	15	.	.	.
8691	144	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	145	1	The	the	DT
8691	145	2	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	145	3	bench	bench	NN
8691	145	4	was	be	VBD
8691	145	5	weaker	weak	JJR
8691	145	6	than	than	IN
8691	145	7	the	the	DT
8691	145	8	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	145	9	bar	bar	NN
8691	145	10	.	.	.
8691	146	1	Judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	146	2	station	station	NN
8691	146	3	was	be	VBD
8691	146	4	at	at	IN
8691	146	5	first	first	RB
8691	146	6	always	always	RB
8691	146	7	,	,	,
8691	146	8	and	and	CC
8691	146	9	later	later	RB
8691	146	10	often	often	RB
8691	146	11	,	,	,
8691	146	12	a	a	DT
8691	146	13	mere	mere	JJ
8691	146	14	incident	incident	NN
8691	146	15	of	of	IN
8691	146	16	political	political	JJ
8691	146	17	office	office	NN
8691	146	18	.	.	.
8691	147	1	When	when	WRB
8691	147	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	147	3	were	be	VBD
8691	147	4	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	147	5	whose	whose	WP$
8691	147	6	functions	function	NNS
8691	147	7	were	be	VBD
8691	147	8	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	147	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	147	10	,	,	,
8691	147	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	147	12	selection	selection	NN
8691	147	13	was	be	VBD
8691	147	14	largely	largely	RB
8691	147	15	dictated	dictate	VBN
8691	147	16	by	by	IN
8691	147	17	political	political	JJ
8691	147	18	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	147	19	or	or	CC
8691	147	20	executive	executive	NN
8691	147	21	favor	favor	NN
8691	147	22	.	.	.
8691	148	1	Few	few	JJ
8691	148	2	of	of	IN
8691	148	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	148	4	were	be	VBD
8691	148	5	really	really	RB
8691	148	6	learned	learn	VBN
8691	148	7	in	in	IN
8691	148	8	the	the	DT
8691	148	9	law	law	NN
8691	148	10	.	.	.
8691	149	1	Of	of	IN
8691	149	2	the	the	DT
8691	149	3	bar	bar	NN
8691	149	4	many	many	JJ
8691	149	5	were	be	VBD
8691	149	6	.	.	.
8691	150	1	That	that	DT
8691	150	2	of	of	IN
8691	150	3	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	150	4	did	do	VBD
8691	150	5	not	not	RB
8691	150	6	conceal	conceal	VB
8691	150	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	150	8	disapprobation	disapprobation	NN
8691	150	9	when	when	WRB
8691	150	10	Lieutenant	Lieutenant	NNP
8691	150	11	-	-	HYPH
8691	150	12	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	150	13	Hutchinson	Hutchinson	NNP
8691	150	14	,	,	,
8691	150	15	although	although	IN
8691	150	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	150	17	had	have	VBD
8691	150	18	never	never	RB
8691	150	19	been	be	VBN
8691	150	20	a	a	DT
8691	150	21	member	member	NN
8691	150	22	of	of	IN
8691	150	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	150	24	,	,	,
8691	150	25	was	be	VBD
8691	150	26	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	150	27	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	150	28	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	150	29	in	in	IN
8691	150	30	1760	1760	CD
8691	150	31	.	.	.
8691	151	1	None	none	NN
8691	151	2	of	of	IN
8691	151	3	the	the	DT
8691	151	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	151	5	of	of	IN
8691	151	6	the	the	DT
8691	151	7	first	first	JJ
8691	151	8	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	151	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	151	10	in	in	IN
8691	151	11	that	that	DT
8691	151	12	colony	colony	NN
8691	151	13	were	be	VBD
8691	151	14	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	151	15	.	.	.
8691	152	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	152	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	152	3	:	:	:
8691	152	4	Winsor	winsor	NN
8691	152	5	,	,	,
8691	152	6	"	"	''
8691	152	7	Narrative	narrative	JJ
8691	152	8	and	and	CC
8691	152	9	Critical	critical	JJ
8691	152	10	History	history	NN
8691	152	11	of	of	IN
8691	152	12	America	America	NNP
8691	152	13	,	,	,
8691	152	14	"	"	``
8691	152	15	V	V	NNP
8691	152	16	,	,	,
8691	152	17	166	166	CD
8691	152	18	.	.	.
8691	152	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	153	1	In	in	IN
8691	153	2	some	some	DT
8691	153	3	of	of	IN
8691	153	4	the	the	DT
8691	153	5	others	other	NNS
8691	153	6	the	the	DT
8691	153	7	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	153	8	was	be	VBD
8691	153	9	the	the	DT
8691	153	10	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	153	11	,	,	,
8691	153	12	and	and	CC
8691	153	13	in	in	IN
8691	153	14	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	153	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	153	16	was	be	VBD
8691	153	17	at	at	IN
8691	153	18	one	one	CD
8691	153	19	time	time	NN
8691	153	20	the	the	DT
8691	153	21	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	153	22	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	153	23	also	also	RB
8691	153	24	.	.	.
8691	154	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	154	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	154	3	:	:	:
8691	154	4	Steiner	Steiner	NNP
8691	154	5	,	,	,
8691	154	6	"	"	``
8691	154	7	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	154	8	's	's	POS
8691	154	9	First	First	NNP
8691	154	10	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	154	11	,	,	,
8691	154	12	"	"	''
8691	154	13	Reports	report	NNS
8691	154	14	of	of	IN
8691	154	15	American	American	NNP
8691	154	16	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	154	17	Association	Association	NNP
8691	154	18	for	for	IN
8691	154	19	1901	1901	CD
8691	154	20	,	,	,
8691	154	21	211	211	CD
8691	154	22	;	;	:
8691	154	23	Osgood	osgood	NN
8691	154	24	,	,	,
8691	154	25	"	"	``
8691	154	26	The	the	DT
8691	154	27	American	American	NNP
8691	154	28	Colonies	Colonies	NNPS
8691	154	29	in	in	IN
8691	154	30	the	the	DT
8691	154	31	Seventeenth	Seventeenth	NNP
8691	154	32	Century	Century	NNP
8691	154	33	,	,	,
8691	154	34	"	"	''
8691	154	35	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	154	36	,	,	,
8691	154	37	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	154	38	.	.	.
8691	155	1	II	ii	CD
8691	155	2	;	;	:
8691	155	3	II	II	NNP
8691	155	4	,	,	,
8691	155	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	155	6	.	.	.
8691	156	1	XII	XII	NNP
8691	156	2	.	.	.
8691	156	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	157	1	In	in	IN
8691	157	2	several	several	JJ
8691	157	3	the	the	DT
8691	157	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	157	5	were	be	VBD
8691	157	6	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	157	7	during	during	IN
8691	157	8	the	the	DT
8691	157	9	king	king	NN
8691	157	10	's	's	POS
8691	157	11	pleasure	pleasure	NN
8691	157	12	,	,	,
8691	157	13	and	and	CC
8691	157	14	the	the	DT
8691	157	15	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	157	16	removed	remove	VBD
8691	157	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	157	18	at	at	IN
8691	157	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	157	20	discretion	discretion	NN
8691	157	21	,	,	,
8691	157	22	without	without	IN
8691	157	23	any	any	DT
8691	157	24	notice	notice	NN
8691	157	25	or	or	CC
8691	157	26	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	157	27	.	.	.
8691	158	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	158	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	158	3	:	:	:
8691	158	4	Bancroft	Bancroft	NNP
8691	158	5	,	,	,
8691	158	6	"	"	``
8691	158	7	History	history	NN
8691	158	8	of	of	IN
8691	158	9	the	the	DT
8691	158	10	United	United	NNP
8691	158	11	States	States	NNP
8691	158	12	,	,	,
8691	158	13	"	"	''
8691	158	14	II	ii	CD
8691	158	15	,	,	,
8691	158	16	279	279	CD
8691	158	17	.	.	.
8691	159	1	A	a	DT
8691	159	2	notable	notable	JJ
8691	159	3	instance	instance	NN
8691	159	4	of	of	IN
8691	159	5	a	a	DT
8691	159	6	removal	removal	NN
8691	159	7	in	in	IN
8691	159	8	consequence	consequence	NN
8691	159	9	in	in	IN
8691	159	10	part	part	NN
8691	159	11	,	,	,
8691	159	12	at	at	IN
8691	159	13	least	least	JJS
8691	159	14	,	,	,
8691	159	15	of	of	IN
8691	159	16	a	a	DT
8691	159	17	decision	decision	NN
8691	159	18	as	as	IN
8691	159	19	to	to	IN
8691	159	20	the	the	DT
8691	159	21	royal	royal	NN
8691	159	22	prerogative	prerogative	NN
8691	159	23	,	,	,
8691	159	24	not	not	RB
8691	159	25	relished	relish	VBN
8691	159	26	by	by	IN
8691	159	27	the	the	DT
8691	159	28	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	159	29	,	,	,
8691	159	30	was	be	VBD
8691	159	31	the	the	DT
8691	159	32	case	case	NN
8691	159	33	of	of	IN
8691	159	34	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	159	35	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	159	36	Lewis	Lewis	NNP
8691	159	37	Morris	Morris	NNP
8691	159	38	of	of	IN
8691	159	39	New	New	NNP
8691	159	40	York	York	NNP
8691	159	41	,	,	,
8691	159	42	in	in	IN
8691	159	43	1733	1733	CD
8691	159	44	.	.	.
8691	160	1	Documents	document	NNS
8691	160	2	relating	relate	VBG
8691	160	3	to	to	IN
8691	160	4	the	the	DT
8691	160	5	Colonial	Colonial	NNP
8691	160	6	History	History	NNP
8691	160	7	of	of	IN
8691	160	8	New	New	NNP
8691	160	9	York	York	NNP
8691	160	10	,	,	,
8691	160	11	V	V	NNP
8691	160	12	,	,	,
8691	160	13	948	948	CD
8691	160	14	;	;	:
8691	160	15	VI	VI	NNP
8691	160	16	,	,	,
8691	160	17	4	4	CD
8691	160	18	,	,	,
8691	160	19	8	8	CD
8691	160	20	,	,	,
8691	160	21	951	951	CD
8691	160	22	.	.	.
8691	160	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	161	1	In	in	IN
8691	161	2	those	those	DT
8691	161	3	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	161	4	which	which	WDT
8691	161	5	were	be	VBD
8691	161	6	provided	provide	VBN
8691	161	7	by	by	IN
8691	161	8	charter	charter	NN
8691	161	9	with	with	IN
8691	161	10	a	a	DT
8691	161	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	161	12	of	of	IN
8691	161	13	Assistants	Assistants	NNPS
8691	161	14	,	,	,
8691	161	15	this	this	DT
8691	161	16	body	body	NN
8691	161	17	soon	soon	RB
8691	161	18	came	come	VBD
8691	161	19	to	to	TO
8691	161	20	act	act	VB
8691	161	21	as	as	IN
8691	161	22	a	a	DT
8691	161	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	161	24	court	court	NN
8691	161	25	.	.	.
8691	162	1	This	this	DT
8691	162	2	took	take	VBD
8691	162	3	place	place	NN
8691	162	4	in	in	IN
8691	162	5	the	the	DT
8691	162	6	colony	colony	NN
8691	162	7	of	of	IN
8691	162	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	162	9	Bay	Bay	NNP
8691	162	10	as	as	RB
8691	162	11	soon	soon	RB
8691	162	12	as	as	IN
8691	162	13	the	the	DT
8691	162	14	seat	seat	NN
8691	162	15	of	of	IN
8691	162	16	the	the	DT
8691	162	17	company	company	NN
8691	162	18	's	's	POS
8691	162	19	government	government	NN
8691	162	20	was	be	VBD
8691	162	21	transferred	transfer	VBN
8691	162	22	from	from	IN
8691	162	23	England	England	NNP
8691	162	24	to	to	IN
8691	162	25	America	America	NNP
8691	162	26	,	,	,
8691	162	27	and	and	CC
8691	162	28	took	take	VBD
8691	162	29	place	place	NN
8691	162	30	as	as	IN
8691	162	31	a	a	DT
8691	162	32	matter	matter	NN
8691	162	33	of	of	IN
8691	162	34	course	course	NN
8691	162	35	.	.	.
8691	163	1	Divisional	divisional	JJ
8691	163	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	163	3	were	be	VBD
8691	163	4	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	163	5	held	hold	VBN
8691	163	6	by	by	IN
8691	163	7	part	part	NN
8691	163	8	of	of	IN
8691	163	9	the	the	DT
8691	163	10	assistants	assistant	NNS
8691	163	11	,	,	,
8691	163	12	with	with	IN
8691	163	13	original	original	JJ
8691	163	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	163	15	of	of	IN
8691	163	16	minor	minor	JJ
8691	163	17	causes	cause	NNS
8691	163	18	,	,	,
8691	163	19	and	and	CC
8691	163	20	all	all	DT
8691	163	21	sat	sit	VBD
8691	163	22	semi	semi	RB
8691	163	23	-	-	RB
8691	163	24	annually	annually	RB
8691	163	25	,	,	,
8691	163	26	or	or	CC
8691	163	27	oftener	oftener	RB
8691	163	28	,	,	,
8691	163	29	to	to	TO
8691	163	30	try	try	VB
8691	163	31	larger	large	JJR
8691	163	32	ones	one	NNS
8691	163	33	and	and	CC
8691	163	34	hear	hear	VBP
8691	163	35	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	163	36	.	.	.
8691	164	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	164	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	164	3	:	:	:
8691	164	4	Noble	noble	JJ
8691	164	5	,	,	,
8691	164	6	"	"	''
8691	164	7	Records	Records	NNPS
8691	164	8	of	of	IN
8691	164	9	the	the	DT
8691	164	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	164	11	of	of	IN
8691	164	12	Assistants	Assistants	NNPS
8691	164	13	of	of	IN
8691	164	14	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	164	15	Bay	Bay	NNP
8691	164	16	,	,	,
8691	164	17	"	"	``
8691	164	18	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	164	19	,	,	,
8691	164	20	Preface	Preface	NNP
8691	164	21	;	;	:
8691	164	22	Publications	publication	NNS
8691	164	23	of	of	IN
8691	164	24	the	the	DT
8691	164	25	Colonial	Colonial	NNP
8691	164	26	Society	Society	NNP
8691	164	27	of	of	IN
8691	164	28	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	164	29	,	,	,
8691	164	30	III	III	NNP
8691	164	31	,	,	,
8691	164	32	317	317	CD
8691	164	33	.	.	.
8691	164	34	]	]	-RRB-
8691	165	1	In	in	IN
8691	165	2	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	165	3	,	,	,
8691	165	4	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	165	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	165	6	was	be	VBD
8691	165	7	originally	originally	RB
8691	165	8	retained	retain	VBN
8691	165	9	by	by	IN
8691	165	10	the	the	DT
8691	165	11	General	General	NNP
8691	165	12	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	165	13	,	,	,
8691	165	14	but	but	CC
8691	165	15	when	when	WRB
8691	165	16	the	the	DT
8691	165	17	docket	docket	NN
8691	165	18	became	become	VBD
8691	165	19	too	too	RB
8691	165	20	crowded	crowded	JJ
8691	165	21	,	,	,
8691	165	22	resort	resort	NN
8691	165	23	was	be	VBD
8691	165	24	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	165	25	had	have	VBN
8691	165	26	to	to	IN
8691	165	27	the	the	DT
8691	165	28	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	165	29	of	of	IN
8691	165	30	a	a	DT
8691	165	31	special	special	JJ
8691	165	32	and	and	CC
8691	165	33	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	165	34	commission	commission	NN
8691	165	35	of	of	IN
8691	165	36	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	165	37	to	to	TO
8691	165	38	clear	clear	VB
8691	165	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	165	40	off	off	RP
8691	165	41	.	.	.
8691	166	1	As	as	RB
8691	166	2	early	early	RB
8691	166	3	as	as	IN
8691	166	4	1719	1719	CD
8691	166	5	,	,	,
8691	166	6	one	one	CD
8691	166	7	was	be	VBD
8691	166	8	constituted	constitute	VBN
8691	166	9	for	for	IN
8691	166	10	this	this	DT
8691	166	11	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	166	12	to	to	TO
8691	166	13	hold	hold	VB
8691	166	14	office	office	NN
8691	166	15	for	for	IN
8691	166	16	two	two	CD
8691	166	17	years	year	NNS
8691	166	18	.	.	.
8691	167	1	No	no	DT
8691	167	2	colony	colony	NN
8691	167	3	set	set	VBD
8691	167	4	up	up	RP
8691	167	5	a	a	DT
8691	167	6	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	167	7	supreme	supreme	JJ
8691	167	8	court	court	NN
8691	167	9	with	with	IN
8691	167	10	full	full	JJ
8691	167	11	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	167	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	167	13	.	.	.
8691	168	1	None	none	NN
8691	168	2	probably	probably	RB
8691	168	3	cared	care	VBD
8691	168	4	to	to	TO
8691	168	5	do	do	VB
8691	168	6	this	this	DT
8691	168	7	,	,	,
8691	168	8	and	and	CC
8691	168	9	none	none	NN
8691	168	10	probably	probably	RB
8691	168	11	thought	think	VBD
8691	168	12	that	that	IN
8691	168	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	168	14	could	could	MD
8691	168	15	.	.	.
8691	169	1	The	the	DT
8691	169	2	Lords	Lords	NNPS
8691	169	3	of	of	IN
8691	169	4	Trade	Trade	NNP
8691	169	5	and	and	CC
8691	169	6	Plantations	Plantations	NNP
8691	169	7	would	would	MD
8691	169	8	have	have	VB
8691	169	9	rightly	rightly	RB
8691	169	10	thought	think	VBN
8691	169	11	such	such	PDT
8691	169	12	a	a	DT
8691	169	13	step	step	NN
8691	169	14	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	169	15	consistent	consistent	JJ
8691	169	16	with	with	IN
8691	169	17	the	the	DT
8691	169	18	maintenance	maintenance	NN
8691	169	19	of	of	IN
8691	169	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	169	21	revisory	revisory	NN
8691	169	22	and	and	CC
8691	169	23	controlling	control	VBG
8691	169	24	powers	power	NNS
8691	169	25	.	.	.
8691	170	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	170	2	would	would	MD
8691	170	3	have	have	VB
8691	170	4	been	be	VBN
8691	170	5	too	too	RB
8691	170	6	costly	costly	JJ
8691	170	7	to	to	TO
8691	170	8	allow	allow	VB
8691	170	9	two	two	CD
8691	170	10	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	170	11	;	;	:
8691	170	12	and	and	CC
8691	170	13	for	for	IN
8691	170	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	170	15	to	to	TO
8691	170	16	reverse	reverse	VB
8691	170	17	a	a	DT
8691	170	18	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	170	19	of	of	IN
8691	170	20	a	a	DT
8691	170	21	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	170	22	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	170	23	court	court	NNP
8691	170	24	would	would	MD
8691	170	25	have	have	VB
8691	170	26	been	be	VBN
8691	170	27	more	more	RBR
8691	170	28	distasteful	distasteful	JJ
8691	170	29	to	to	IN
8691	170	30	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	170	31	than	than	IN
8691	170	32	the	the	DT
8691	170	33	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	170	34	of	of	IN
8691	170	35	a	a	DT
8691	170	36	similar	similar	JJ
8691	170	37	power	power	NN
8691	170	38	as	as	IN
8691	170	39	to	to	IN
8691	170	40	a	a	DT
8691	170	41	court	court	NN
8691	170	42	professedly	professedly	RB
8691	170	43	of	of	IN
8691	170	44	superior	superior	JJ
8691	170	45	,	,	,
8691	170	46	not	not	RB
8691	170	47	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	170	48	,	,	,
8691	170	49	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	170	50	.	.	.
8691	171	1	New	New	NNP
8691	171	2	York	York	NNP
8691	171	3	had	have	VBD
8691	171	4	a	a	DT
8691	171	5	court	court	NN
8691	171	6	named	name	VBN
8691	171	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	171	8	,	,	,
8691	171	9	but	but	CC
8691	171	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	171	11	business	business	NN
8691	171	12	was	be	VBD
8691	171	13	largely	largely	RB
8691	171	14	the	the	DT
8691	171	15	trial	trial	NN
8691	171	16	of	of	IN
8691	171	17	original	original	JJ
8691	171	18	causes	cause	NNS
8691	171	19	,	,	,
8691	171	20	and	and	CC
8691	171	21	the	the	DT
8691	171	22	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	171	23	and	and	CC
8691	171	24	Council	Council	NNP
8691	171	25	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	171	26	the	the	DT
8691	171	27	right	right	NN
8691	171	28	of	of	IN
8691	171	29	reviewing	review	VBG
8691	171	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	171	31	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	171	32	.	.	.
8691	172	1	The	the	DT
8691	172	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	172	3	in	in	IN
8691	172	4	1765	1765	CD
8691	172	5	denied	deny	VBD
8691	172	6	the	the	DT
8691	172	7	existence	existence	NN
8691	172	8	of	of	IN
8691	172	9	such	such	PDT
8691	172	10	a	a	DT
8691	172	11	right	right	NN
8691	172	12	,	,	,
8691	172	13	but	but	CC
8691	172	14	the	the	DT
8691	172	15	King	King	NNP
8691	172	16	in	in	IN
8691	172	17	Council	Council	NNP
8691	172	18	decided	decide	VBD
8691	172	19	against	against	IN
8691	172	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	172	21	.	.	.
8691	173	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	173	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	173	3	:	:	:
8691	173	4	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
8691	173	5	,	,	,
8691	173	6	"	"	''
8691	173	7	Life	Life	NNP
8691	173	8	of	of	IN
8691	173	9	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	173	10	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
8691	173	11	,	,	,
8691	173	12	"	"	``
8691	173	13	26	26	CD
8691	173	14	.	.	.
8691	173	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	174	1	As	as	RB
8691	174	2	soon	soon	RB
8691	174	3	as	as	IN
8691	174	4	regular	regular	JJ
8691	174	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	174	6	,	,	,
8691	174	7	not	not	RB
8691	174	8	members	member	NNS
8691	174	9	of	of	IN
8691	174	10	other	other	JJ
8691	174	11	departments	department	NNS
8691	174	12	of	of	IN
8691	174	13	the	the	DT
8691	174	14	government	government	NN
8691	174	15	,	,	,
8691	174	16	were	be	VBD
8691	174	17	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	174	18	for	for	IN
8691	174	19	the	the	DT
8691	174	20	highest	high	JJS
8691	174	21	court	court	NN
8691	174	22	,	,	,
8691	174	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	174	24	were	be	VBD
8691	174	25	generally	generally	RB
8691	174	26	required	require	VBN
8691	174	27	to	to	TO
8691	174	28	perform	perform	VB
8691	174	29	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	174	30	duty	duty	NN
8691	174	31	in	in	IN
8691	174	32	the	the	DT
8691	174	33	various	various	JJ
8691	174	34	counties	county	NNS
8691	174	35	during	during	IN
8691	174	36	part	part	NN
8691	174	37	of	of	IN
8691	174	38	each	each	DT
8691	174	39	year	year	NN
8691	174	40	.	.	.
8691	175	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	175	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	175	3	:	:	:
8691	175	4	See	see	VB
8691	175	5	"	"	``
8691	175	6	Am	Am	NNP
8691	175	7	.	.	.
8691	176	1	Hist	hist	NN
8691	176	2	.	.	.
8691	177	1	Review	review	VB
8691	177	2	,	,	,
8691	177	3	"	"	''
8691	177	4	III	iii	CD
8691	177	5	,	,	,
8691	177	6	44	44	CD
8691	177	7	.	.	.
8691	177	8	]	]	-RRB-
8691	178	1	This	this	DT
8691	178	2	was	be	VBD
8691	178	3	a	a	DT
8691	178	4	leading	lead	VBG
8691	178	5	feature	feature	NN
8691	178	6	of	of	IN
8691	178	7	the	the	DT
8691	178	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	178	9	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	178	10	set	set	VBD
8691	178	11	up	up	RP
8691	178	12	in	in	IN
8691	178	13	1686	1686	CD
8691	178	14	under	under	IN
8691	178	15	Sir	Sir	NNP
8691	178	16	Edmund	Edmund	NNP
8691	178	17	Andros	Andros	NNP
8691	178	18	for	for	IN
8691	178	19	the	the	DT
8691	178	20	"	"	``
8691	178	21	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
8691	178	22	of	of	IN
8691	178	23	New	New	NNP
8691	178	24	England	England	NNP
8691	178	25	.	.	.
8691	179	1	"	"	``
8691	179	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	179	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	179	4	:	:	:
8691	179	5	Col	Col	NNP
8691	179	6	.	.	NNP
8691	179	7	Rec	Rec	NNP
8691	179	8	.	.	.
8691	180	1	of	of	IN
8691	180	2	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	180	3	,	,	,
8691	180	4	III	III	NNP
8691	180	5	,	,	,
8691	180	6	402	402	CD
8691	180	7	,	,	,
8691	180	8	411	411	CD
8691	180	9	.	.	.
8691	180	10	]	]	-RRB-
8691	181	1	South	South	NNP
8691	181	2	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	181	3	,	,	,
8691	181	4	for	for	IN
8691	181	5	a	a	DT
8691	181	6	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	181	7	years	year	NNS
8691	181	8	,	,	,
8691	181	9	centered	center	VBD
8691	181	10	all	all	PDT
8691	181	11	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	181	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	181	13	business	business	NN
8691	181	14	at	at	IN
8691	181	15	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
8691	181	16	.	.	.
8691	182	1	No	no	DT
8691	182	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	182	3	sat	sit	VBD
8691	182	4	anywhere	anywhere	RB
8691	182	5	else	else	RB
8691	182	6	and	and	CC
8691	182	7	all	all	PDT
8691	182	8	the	the	DT
8691	182	9	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	182	10	in	in	IN
8691	182	11	the	the	DT
8691	182	12	State	state	NN
8691	182	13	resided	reside	VBD
8691	182	14	in	in	IN
8691	182	15	the	the	DT
8691	182	16	city	city	NN
8691	182	17	.	.	.
8691	183	1	In	in	IN
8691	183	2	the	the	DT
8691	183	3	latter	latter	JJ
8691	183	4	part	part	NN
8691	183	5	of	of	IN
8691	183	6	the	the	DT
8691	183	7	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
8691	183	8	century	century	NN
8691	183	9	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	183	10	followed	follow	VBD
8691	183	11	the	the	DT
8691	183	12	other	other	JJ
8691	183	13	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	183	14	in	in	IN
8691	183	15	establishing	establish	VBG
8691	183	16	a	a	DT
8691	183	17	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	183	18	system	system	NN
8691	183	19	and	and	CC
8691	183	20	county	county	NN
8691	183	21	courts	court	NNS
8691	183	22	.	.	.
8691	184	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	184	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	184	3	:	:	:
8691	184	4	Morse	morse	NN
8691	184	5	,	,	,
8691	184	6	"	"	''
8691	184	7	American	American	NNP
8691	184	8	Universal	Universal	NNP
8691	184	9	Geography	Geography	NNP
8691	184	10	,	,	,
8691	184	11	"	"	''
8691	184	12	ed	ed	NN
8691	184	13	.	.	.
8691	185	1	1796	1796	CD
8691	185	2	,	,	,
8691	185	3	690	690	CD
8691	185	4	;	;	:
8691	185	5	Osgood	osgood	NN
8691	185	6	,	,	,
8691	185	7	"	"	``
8691	185	8	The	the	DT
8691	185	9	American	American	NNP
8691	185	10	Colonies	Colonies	NNPS
8691	185	11	in	in	IN
8691	185	12	the	the	DT
8691	185	13	Seventeenth	Seventeenth	NNP
8691	185	14	Century	Century	NNP
8691	185	15	,	,	,
8691	185	16	"	"	''
8691	185	17	II	ii	CD
8691	185	18	,	,	,
8691	185	19	279	279	CD
8691	185	20	,	,	,
8691	185	21	300	300	CD
8691	185	22	.	.	.
8691	185	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	186	1	There	there	EX
8691	186	2	was	be	VBD
8691	186	3	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	186	4	some	some	DT
8691	186	5	little	little	JJ
8691	186	6	approach	approach	NN
8691	186	7	to	to	IN
8691	186	8	English	english	JJ
8691	186	9	form	form	NN
8691	186	10	when	when	WRB
8691	186	11	the	the	DT
8691	186	12	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	186	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	186	14	went	go	VBD
8691	186	15	on	on	IN
8691	186	16	the	the	DT
8691	186	17	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	186	18	.	.	.
8691	187	1	In	in	IN
8691	187	2	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	187	3	the	the	DT
8691	187	4	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	187	5	or	or	CC
8691	187	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	187	7	deputy	deputy	NN
8691	187	8	was	be	VBD
8691	187	9	accustomed	accustom	VBN
8691	187	10	to	to	TO
8691	187	11	come	come	VB
8691	187	12	out	out	RP
8691	187	13	from	from	IN
8691	187	14	the	the	DT
8691	187	15	court	court	NN
8691	187	16	town	town	NN
8691	187	17	to	to	TO
8691	187	18	meet	meet	VB
8691	187	19	the	the	DT
8691	187	20	judges	judge	NNS
8691	187	21	as	as	IN
8691	187	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	187	23	approached	approach	VBD
8691	187	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	187	25	,	,	,
8691	187	26	to	to	TO
8691	187	27	open	open	VB
8691	187	28	a	a	DT
8691	187	29	term	term	NN
8691	187	30	of	of	IN
8691	187	31	court	court	NN
8691	187	32	.	.	.
8691	188	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	188	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	188	3	:	:	:
8691	188	4	"	"	``
8691	188	5	Life	Life	NNP
8691	188	6	and	and	CC
8691	188	7	Works	Works	NNP
8691	188	8	of	of	IN
8691	188	9	John	John	NNP
8691	188	10	Adams	Adams	NNP
8691	188	11	,	,	,
8691	188	12	"	"	``
8691	188	13	II	II	NNP
8691	188	14	,	,	,
8691	188	15	280	280	CD
8691	188	16	.	.	.
8691	189	1	See	see	VB
8691	189	2	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	189	3	.	.	.
8691	190	1	XIII	XIII	NNP
8691	190	2	.	.	.
8691	190	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	191	1	Acts	act	NNS
8691	191	2	of	of	IN
8691	191	3	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
8691	191	4	directly	directly	RB
8691	191	5	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	191	6	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	191	7	in	in	IN
8691	191	8	American	american	JJ
8691	191	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	191	10	,	,	,
8691	191	11	and	and	CC
8691	191	12	unifying	unify	VBG
8691	191	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	191	14	methods	method	NNS
8691	191	15	in	in	IN
8691	191	16	some	some	DT
8691	191	17	particulars	particular	NNS
8691	191	18	,	,	,
8691	191	19	were	be	VBD
8691	191	20	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	191	21	passed	pass	VBN
8691	191	22	during	during	IN
8691	191	23	the	the	DT
8691	191	24	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	191	25	era	era	NN
8691	191	26	.	.	.
8691	192	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	192	2	was	be	VBD
8691	192	3	the	the	DT
8691	192	4	Act	Act	NNP
8691	192	5	of	of	IN
8691	192	6	1732	1732	CD
8691	192	7	(	(	-LRB-
8691	192	8	V	V	NNP
8691	192	9	,	,	,
8691	192	10	Geo	Geo	NNP
8691	192	11	.	.	.
8691	193	1	II	II	NNP
8691	193	2	,	,	,
8691	193	3	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	193	4	.	.	.
8691	194	1	VII	VII	NNP
8691	194	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	194	3	,	,	,
8691	194	4	making	make	VBG
8691	194	5	affidavits	affidavit	NNS
8691	194	6	taken	take	VBN
8691	194	7	in	in	IN
8691	194	8	England	England	NNP
8691	194	9	admissible	admissible	JJ
8691	194	10	in	in	IN
8691	194	11	any	any	DT
8691	194	12	suit	suit	NN
8691	194	13	in	in	IN
8691	194	14	an	an	DT
8691	194	15	American	american	JJ
8691	194	16	colony	colony	NN
8691	194	17	to	to	TO
8691	194	18	which	which	WDT
8691	194	19	an	an	DT
8691	194	20	Englishman	Englishman	NNP
8691	194	21	might	may	MD
8691	194	22	be	be	VB
8691	194	23	a	a	DT
8691	194	24	party	party	NN
8691	194	25	,	,	,
8691	194	26	and	and	CC
8691	194	27	providing	provide	VBG
8691	194	28	that	that	IN
8691	194	29	all	all	DT
8691	194	30	American	american	JJ
8691	194	31	real	real	JJ
8691	194	32	estate	estate	NN
8691	194	33	(	(	-LRB-
8691	194	34	including	include	VBG
8691	194	35	negro	negro	JJ
8691	194	36	slaves	slave	NNS
8691	194	37	employed	employ	VBN
8691	194	38	upon	upon	IN
8691	194	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	194	40	)	)	-RRB-
8691	194	41	should	should	MD
8691	194	42	be	be	VB
8691	194	43	subject	subject	JJ
8691	194	44	to	to	TO
8691	194	45	be	be	VB
8691	194	46	levied	levy	VBN
8691	194	47	on	on	IN
8691	194	48	for	for	IN
8691	194	49	any	any	DT
8691	194	50	debts	debt	NNS
8691	194	51	of	of	IN
8691	194	52	the	the	DT
8691	194	53	owner	owner	NN
8691	194	54	,	,	,
8691	194	55	although	although	IN
8691	194	56	real	real	JJ
8691	194	57	estate	estate	NN
8691	194	58	in	in	IN
8691	194	59	England	England	NNP
8691	194	60	could	could	MD
8691	194	61	only	only	RB
8691	194	62	be	be	VB
8691	194	63	taken	take	VBN
8691	194	64	for	for	IN
8691	194	65	debts	debt	NNS
8691	194	66	of	of	IN
8691	194	67	a	a	DT
8691	194	68	particular	particular	JJ
8691	194	69	kind	kind	NN
8691	194	70	.	.	.
8691	195	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	195	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	195	3	:	:	:
8691	195	4	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	195	5	promptly	promptly	RB
8691	195	6	passed	pass	VBD
8691	195	7	a	a	DT
8691	195	8	statute	statute	NN
8691	195	9	extending	extend	VBG
8691	195	10	the	the	DT
8691	195	11	new	new	JJ
8691	195	12	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	195	13	thus	thus	RB
8691	195	14	given	give	VBN
8691	195	15	,	,	,
8691	195	16	so	so	IN
8691	195	17	as	as	IN
8691	195	18	to	to	TO
8691	195	19	authorize	authorize	VB
8691	195	20	the	the	DT
8691	195	21	sale	sale	NN
8691	195	22	of	of	IN
8691	195	23	land	land	NN
8691	195	24	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	195	25	to	to	IN
8691	195	26	the	the	DT
8691	195	27	estate	estate	NN
8691	195	28	of	of	IN
8691	195	29	a	a	DT
8691	195	30	deceased	deceased	JJ
8691	195	31	person	person	NN
8691	195	32	,	,	,
8691	195	33	to	to	TO
8691	195	34	pay	pay	VB
8691	195	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	195	36	debts	debt	NNS
8691	195	37	,	,	,
8691	195	38	if	if	IN
8691	195	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	195	40	did	do	VBD
8691	195	41	not	not	RB
8691	195	42	leave	leave	VB
8691	195	43	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	195	44	personal	personal	JJ
8691	195	45	estate	estate	NN
8691	195	46	for	for	IN
8691	195	47	that	that	DT
8691	195	48	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	195	49	.	.	.
8691	196	1	Col	Col	NNP
8691	196	2	.	.	NNP
8691	196	3	Rec	Rec	NNP
8691	196	4	.	.	.
8691	197	1	of	of	IN
8691	197	2	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	197	3	,	,	,
8691	197	4	VII	VII	NNP
8691	197	5	,	,	,
8691	197	6	444	444	CD
8691	197	7	.	.	.
8691	197	8	]	]	-RRB-
8691	198	1	Other	other	JJ
8691	198	2	English	english	JJ
8691	198	3	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	198	4	,	,	,
8691	198	5	passed	pass	VBN
8691	198	6	after	after	IN
8691	198	7	the	the	DT
8691	198	8	settlement	settlement	NN
8691	198	9	of	of	IN
8691	198	10	the	the	DT
8691	198	11	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	198	12	,	,	,
8691	198	13	and	and	CC
8691	198	14	not	not	RB
8691	198	15	in	in	IN
8691	198	16	terms	term	NNS
8691	198	17	applying	apply	VBG
8691	198	18	to	to	IN
8691	198	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	198	20	,	,	,
8691	198	21	were	be	VBD
8691	198	22	often	often	RB
8691	198	23	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	198	24	here	here	RB
8691	198	25	,	,	,
8691	198	26	either	either	CC
8691	198	27	by	by	IN
8691	198	28	the	the	DT
8691	198	29	enactment	enactment	NN
8691	198	30	of	of	IN
8691	198	31	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	198	32	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	198	33	to	to	IN
8691	198	34	the	the	DT
8691	198	35	same	same	JJ
8691	198	36	effect	effect	NN
8691	198	37	or	or	CC
8691	198	38	by	by	IN
8691	198	39	incorporation	incorporation	NN
8691	198	40	into	into	IN
8691	198	41	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	198	42	common	common	JJ
8691	198	43	law	law	NN
8691	198	44	by	by	IN
8691	198	45	tacit	tacit	JJ
8691	198	46	consent	consent	NN
8691	198	47	,	,	,
8691	198	48	as	as	IN
8691	198	49	interpreted	interpret	VBN
8691	198	50	by	by	IN
8691	198	51	the	the	DT
8691	198	52	courts	court	NNS
8691	198	53	.	.	.
8691	199	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	199	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	199	3	:	:	:
8691	199	4	State	State	NNP
8691	199	5	_	_	NNP
8691	199	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	199	7	_	_	NNP
8691	199	8	Ward	Ward	NNP
8691	199	9	,	,	,
8691	199	10	43	43	CD
8691	199	11	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	199	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	199	13	,	,	,
8691	199	14	489	489	CD
8691	199	15	,	,	,
8691	199	16	494	494	CD
8691	199	17	.	.	.
8691	199	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	200	1	The	the	DT
8691	200	2	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	200	3	of	of	IN
8691	200	4	the	the	DT
8691	200	5	writ	writ	NNP
8691	200	6	of	of	IN
8691	200	7	_	_	NNP
8691	200	8	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	200	9	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	200	10	_	_	NNP
8691	200	11	,	,	,
8691	200	12	which	which	WDT
8691	200	13	,	,	,
8691	200	14	though	though	IN
8691	200	15	issuable	issuable	JJ
8691	200	16	at	at	IN
8691	200	17	common	common	JJ
8691	200	18	law	law	NN
8691	200	19	,	,	,
8691	200	20	really	really	RB
8691	200	21	first	first	RB
8691	200	22	took	take	VBD
8691	200	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	200	24	present	present	JJ
8691	200	25	shape	shape	NN
8691	200	26	in	in	IN
8691	200	27	1679	1679	CD
8691	200	28	,	,	,
8691	200	29	by	by	IN
8691	200	30	the	the	DT
8691	200	31	Act	Act	NNP
8691	200	32	of	of	IN
8691	200	33	31	31	CD
8691	200	34	Charles	Charles	NNP
8691	200	35	II	II	NNP
8691	200	36	,	,	,
8691	200	37	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	200	38	.	.	.
8691	201	1	II	II	NNP
8691	201	2	,	,	,
8691	201	3	was	be	VBD
8691	201	4	thought	think	VBN
8691	201	5	in	in	IN
8691	201	6	this	this	DT
8691	201	7	country	country	NN
8691	201	8	,	,	,
8691	201	9	though	though	IN
8691	201	10	not	not	RB
8691	201	11	by	by	IN
8691	201	12	the	the	DT
8691	201	13	Lords	Lords	NNPS
8691	201	14	of	of	IN
8691	201	15	Trade	Trade	NNP
8691	201	16	and	and	CC
8691	201	17	Plantations	Plantations	NNP
8691	201	18	,	,	,
8691	201	19	to	to	TO
8691	201	20	be	be	VB
8691	201	21	a	a	DT
8691	201	22	privilege	privilege	NN
8691	201	23	of	of	IN
8691	201	24	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	201	25	,	,	,
8691	201	26	as	as	IN
8691	201	27	British	british	JJ
8691	201	28	subjects	subject	NNS
8691	201	29	.	.	.
8691	202	1	In	in	IN
8691	202	2	some	some	DT
8691	202	3	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	202	4	this	this	DT
8691	202	5	statute	statute	NN
8691	202	6	was	be	VBD
8691	202	7	re	re	VBN
8691	202	8	-	-	VBN
8691	202	9	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	202	10	,	,	,
8691	202	11	or	or	CC
8691	202	12	,	,	,
8691	202	13	as	as	IN
8691	202	14	in	in	IN
8691	202	15	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	202	16	,	,	,
8691	202	17	rights	right	NNS
8691	202	18	under	under	IN
8691	202	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	202	20	conceded	concede	VBD
8691	202	21	under	under	IN
8691	202	22	the	the	DT
8691	202	23	royal	royal	JJ
8691	202	24	prerogative	prerogative	NN
8691	202	25	.	.	.
8691	203	1	In	in	IN
8691	203	2	others	other	NNS
8691	203	3	,	,	,
8691	203	4	as	as	IN
8691	203	5	in	in	IN
8691	203	6	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	203	7	,	,	,
8691	203	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	203	9	was	be	VBD
8691	203	10	treated	treat	VBN
8691	203	11	as	as	IN
8691	203	12	being	be	VBG
8691	203	13	,	,	,
8691	203	14	by	by	IN
8691	203	15	tacit	tacit	JJ
8691	203	16	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	203	17	,	,	,
8691	203	18	the	the	DT
8691	203	19	birthright	birthright	NN
8691	203	20	of	of	IN
8691	203	21	the	the	DT
8691	203	22	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
8691	203	23	.	.	.
8691	204	1	In	in	IN
8691	204	2	the	the	DT
8691	204	3	"	"	``
8691	204	4	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
8691	204	5	and	and	CC
8691	204	6	Resolves	Resolves	NNPS
8691	204	7	"	"	''
8691	204	8	of	of	IN
8691	204	9	the	the	DT
8691	204	10	first	first	JJ
8691	204	11	Continental	Continental	NNP
8691	204	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	204	13	,	,	,
8691	204	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	204	15	assert	assert	VBP
8691	204	16	"	"	''
8691	204	17	that	that	IN
8691	204	18	the	the	DT
8691	204	19	respective	respective	JJ
8691	204	20	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	204	21	are	be	VBP
8691	204	22	entitled	entitle	VBN
8691	204	23	to	to	IN
8691	204	24	the	the	DT
8691	204	25	Common	Common	NNP
8691	204	26	Law	Law	NNP
8691	204	27	of	of	IN
8691	204	28	England	England	NNP
8691	204	29	,	,	,
8691	204	30	"	"	''
8691	204	31	and	and	CC
8691	204	32	in	in	IN
8691	204	33	the	the	DT
8691	204	34	address	address	NN
8691	204	35	to	to	IN
8691	204	36	the	the	DT
8691	204	37	people	people	NNS
8691	204	38	of	of	IN
8691	204	39	Great	Great	NNP
8691	204	40	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	204	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	204	42	complain	complain	VBP
8691	204	43	that	that	IN
8691	204	44	the	the	DT
8691	204	45	English	english	JJ
8691	204	46	settlers	settler	NNS
8691	204	47	in	in	IN
8691	204	48	Canada	Canada	NNP
8691	204	49	"	"	``
8691	204	50	are	be	VBP
8691	204	51	now	now	RB
8691	204	52	the	the	DT
8691	204	53	subjects	subject	NNS
8691	204	54	of	of	IN
8691	204	55	an	an	DT
8691	204	56	arbitrary	arbitrary	JJ
8691	204	57	Government	Government	NNP
8691	204	58	,	,	,
8691	204	59	deprived	deprive	VBN
8691	204	60	of	of	IN
8691	204	61	Trial	Trial	NNP
8691	204	62	by	by	IN
8691	204	63	Jury	Jury	NNP
8691	204	64	,	,	,
8691	204	65	and	and	CC
8691	204	66	when	when	WRB
8691	204	67	imprisoned	imprison	VBN
8691	204	68	can	can	MD
8691	204	69	not	not	RB
8691	204	70	claim	claim	VB
8691	204	71	the	the	DT
8691	204	72	Benefit	Benefit	NNP
8691	204	73	of	of	IN
8691	204	74	the	the	DT
8691	204	75	_	_	NNP
8691	204	76	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
8691	204	77	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
8691	204	78	_	_	NNP
8691	204	79	Act	Act	NNP
8691	204	80	,	,	,
8691	204	81	that	that	DT
8691	204	82	great	great	JJ
8691	204	83	Bulwark	Bulwark	NNP
8691	204	84	and	and	CC
8691	204	85	Palladium	Palladium	NNP
8691	204	86	of	of	IN
8691	204	87	English	English	NNP
8691	204	88	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
8691	204	89	.	.	.
8691	205	1	"	"	``
8691	205	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	205	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	205	4	:	:	:
8691	205	5	Journals	journal	NNS
8691	205	6	of	of	IN
8691	205	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	205	8	,	,	,
8691	205	9	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	205	10	,	,	,
8691	205	11	29	29	CD
8691	205	12	,	,	,
8691	205	13	44	44	CD
8691	205	14	.	.	.
8691	206	1	A.	A.	NNP
8691	206	2	H.	H.	NNP
8691	206	3	Carpenter	Carpenter	NNP
8691	206	4	,	,	,
8691	206	5	"	"	``
8691	206	6	Habeas	Habeas	NNP
8691	206	7	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
8691	206	8	in	in	IN
8691	206	9	the	the	DT
8691	206	10	Colonies	Colonies	NNPS
8691	206	11	,	,	,
8691	206	12	"	"	``
8691	206	13	American	American	NNP
8691	206	14	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	206	15	Review	Review	NNP
8691	206	16	,	,	,
8691	206	17	VIII	VIII	NNP
8691	206	18	,	,	,
8691	206	19	18	18	CD
8691	206	20	.	.	.
8691	206	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	207	1	The	the	DT
8691	207	2	same	same	JJ
8691	207	3	sentiments	sentiment	NNS
8691	207	4	dictated	dictate	VBD
8691	207	5	the	the	DT
8691	207	6	terms	term	NNS
8691	207	7	of	of	IN
8691	207	8	the	the	DT
8691	207	9	Ordinance	Ordinance	NNP
8691	207	10	of	of	IN
8691	207	11	1787	1787	CD
8691	207	12	,	,	,
8691	207	13	under	under	IN
8691	207	14	which	which	WDT
8691	207	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	207	16	first	first	JJ
8691	207	17	Territories	Territories	NNPS
8691	207	18	were	be	VBD
8691	207	19	to	to	TO
8691	207	20	be	be	VB
8691	207	21	organized	organize	VBN
8691	207	22	.	.	.
8691	208	1	One	one	CD
8691	208	2	of	of	IN
8691	208	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	208	4	leading	lead	VBG
8691	208	5	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	208	6	was	be	VBD
8691	208	7	this	this	DT
8691	208	8	:	:	:
8691	208	9	ART	art	NN
8691	208	10	.	.	.
8691	209	1	2	2	LS
8691	209	2	.	.	.
8691	210	1	The	the	DT
8691	210	2	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
8691	210	3	of	of	IN
8691	210	4	the	the	DT
8691	210	5	said	say	VBN
8691	210	6	territory	territory	NN
8691	210	7	shall	shall	MD
8691	210	8	always	always	RB
8691	210	9	be	be	VB
8691	210	10	entitled	entitle	VBN
8691	210	11	to	to	IN
8691	210	12	the	the	DT
8691	210	13	benefits	benefit	NNS
8691	210	14	of	of	IN
8691	210	15	the	the	DT
8691	210	16	writ	writ	NNP
8691	210	17	of	of	IN
8691	210	18	_	_	NNP
8691	210	19	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	210	20	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	210	21	_	_	NNP
8691	210	22	,	,	,
8691	210	23	and	and	CC
8691	210	24	of	of	IN
8691	210	25	the	the	DT
8691	210	26	trial	trial	NN
8691	210	27	by	by	IN
8691	210	28	jury	jury	NN
8691	210	29	;	;	:
8691	210	30	of	of	IN
8691	210	31	a	a	DT
8691	210	32	proportionate	proportionate	NN
8691	210	33	representation	representation	NN
8691	210	34	of	of	IN
8691	210	35	the	the	DT
8691	210	36	people	people	NNS
8691	210	37	in	in	IN
8691	210	38	the	the	DT
8691	210	39	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	210	40	,	,	,
8691	210	41	and	and	CC
8691	210	42	of	of	IN
8691	210	43	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	210	44	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	210	45	according	accord	VBG
8691	210	46	to	to	IN
8691	210	47	the	the	DT
8691	210	48	course	course	NN
8691	210	49	of	of	IN
8691	210	50	the	the	DT
8691	210	51	common	common	JJ
8691	210	52	law	law	NN
8691	210	53	.	.	.
8691	211	1	A	a	DT
8691	211	2	recognized	recognize	VBN
8691	211	3	system	system	NN
8691	211	4	of	of	IN
8691	211	5	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	211	6	had	have	VBD
8691	211	7	,	,	,
8691	211	8	under	under	IN
8691	211	9	the	the	DT
8691	211	10	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	211	11	and	and	CC
8691	211	12	from	from	IN
8691	211	13	the	the	DT
8691	211	14	causes	cause	NNS
8691	211	15	which	which	WDT
8691	211	16	had	have	VBD
8691	211	17	been	be	VBN
8691	211	18	stated	state	VBN
8691	211	19	,	,	,
8691	211	20	begun	begin	VBN
8691	211	21	to	to	TO
8691	211	22	grow	grow	VB
8691	211	23	up	up	RP
8691	211	24	before	before	IN
8691	211	25	the	the	DT
8691	211	26	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	211	27	.	.	.
8691	212	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	212	2	might	may	MD
8691	212	3	fairly	fairly	RB
8691	212	4	be	be	VB
8691	212	5	called	call	VBN
8691	212	6	American	American	NNP
8691	212	7	,	,	,
8691	212	8	but	but	CC
8691	212	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	212	10	was	be	VBD
8691	212	11	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
8691	212	12	English	English	NNP
8691	212	13	by	by	IN
8691	212	14	heredity	heredity	NN
8691	212	15	,	,	,
8691	212	16	and	and	CC
8691	212	17	had	have	VBD
8691	212	18	been	be	VBN
8691	212	19	shaped	shape	VBN
8691	212	20	by	by	IN
8691	212	21	a	a	DT
8691	212	22	long	long	JJ
8691	212	23	succession	succession	NN
8691	212	24	of	of	IN
8691	212	25	English	english	JJ
8691	212	26	influences	influence	NNS
8691	212	27	,	,	,
8691	212	28	and	and	CC
8691	212	29	steadied	steady	VBN
8691	212	30	by	by	IN
8691	212	31	the	the	DT
8691	212	32	firm	firm	JJ
8691	212	33	hand	hand	NN
8691	212	34	of	of	IN
8691	212	35	English	english	JJ
8691	212	36	power	power	NN
8691	212	37	.	.	.
8691	213	1	The	the	DT
8691	213	2	Revolutionary	Revolutionary	NNP
8691	213	3	War	War	NNP
8691	213	4	made	make	VBD
8691	213	5	everything	everything	NN
8691	213	6	connected	connect	VBN
8691	213	7	with	with	IN
8691	213	8	the	the	DT
8691	213	9	law	law	NN
8691	213	10	of	of	IN
8691	213	11	England	England	NNP
8691	213	12	distasteful	distasteful	JJ
8691	213	13	to	to	IN
8691	213	14	the	the	DT
8691	213	15	people	people	NNS
8691	213	16	at	at	IN
8691	213	17	large	large	JJ
8691	213	18	.	.	.
8691	214	1	The	the	DT
8691	214	2	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	214	3	knew	know	VBD
8691	214	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	214	5	value	value	NN
8691	214	6	:	:	:
8691	214	7	the	the	DT
8691	214	8	community	community	NN
8691	214	9	did	do	VBD
8691	214	10	not	not	RB
8691	214	11	.	.	.
8691	215	1	Public	public	JJ
8691	215	2	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	215	3	favored	favor	VBD
8691	215	4	an	an	DT
8691	215	5	American	american	JJ
8691	215	6	law	law	NN
8691	215	7	for	for	IN
8691	215	8	America	America	NNP
8691	215	9	.	.	.
8691	216	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	216	2	was	be	VBD
8691	216	3	quickened	quicken	VBN
8691	216	4	by	by	IN
8691	216	5	the	the	DT
8691	216	6	unfriendly	unfriendly	JJ
8691	216	7	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	216	8	toward	toward	IN
8691	216	9	the	the	DT
8691	216	10	mother	mother	NN
8691	216	11	country	country	NN
8691	216	12	which	which	WDT
8691	216	13	became	become	VBD
8691	216	14	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	216	15	toward	toward	IN
8691	216	16	the	the	DT
8691	216	17	close	close	NN
8691	216	18	of	of	IN
8691	216	19	the	the	DT
8691	216	20	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
8691	216	21	century	century	NN
8691	216	22	and	and	CC
8691	216	23	culminated	culminate	VBD
8691	216	24	in	in	IN
8691	216	25	the	the	DT
8691	216	26	War	War	NNP
8691	216	27	of	of	IN
8691	216	28	1812	1812	CD
8691	216	29	.	.	.
8691	217	1	Several	several	JJ
8691	217	2	of	of	IN
8691	217	3	the	the	DT
8691	217	4	States	States	NNPS
8691	217	5	,	,	,
8691	217	6	New	New	NNP
8691	217	7	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	217	8	leading	lead	VBG
8691	217	9	off	off	RB
8691	217	10	,	,	,
8691	217	11	passed	pass	VBN
8691	217	12	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	217	13	forbidding	forbid	VBG
8691	217	14	the	the	DT
8691	217	15	citation	citation	NN
8691	217	16	,	,	,
8691	217	17	in	in	IN
8691	217	18	the	the	DT
8691	217	19	argument	argument	NN
8691	217	20	of	of	IN
8691	217	21	causes	cause	NNS
8691	217	22	,	,	,
8691	217	23	of	of	IN
8691	217	24	any	any	DT
8691	217	25	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	217	26	of	of	IN
8691	217	27	the	the	DT
8691	217	28	English	English	NNP
8691	217	29	courts	court	NNS
8691	217	30	made	make	VBN
8691	217	31	since	since	IN
8691	217	32	the	the	DT
8691	217	33	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
8691	217	34	of	of	IN
8691	217	35	Independence	Independence	NNP
8691	217	36	.	.	.
8691	218	1	Under	under	IN
8691	218	2	one	one	CD
8691	218	3	of	of	IN
8691	218	4	these	these	DT
8691	218	5	Henry	Henry	NNP
8691	218	6	Clay	Clay	NNP
8691	218	7	,	,	,
8691	218	8	in	in	IN
8691	218	9	1808	1808	CD
8691	218	10	,	,	,
8691	218	11	was	be	VBD
8691	218	12	stopped	stop	VBN
8691	218	13	by	by	IN
8691	218	14	the	the	DT
8691	218	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	218	16	Court	Court	NNP
8691	218	17	of	of	IN
8691	218	18	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	218	19	when	when	WRB
8691	218	20	reading	read	VBG
8691	218	21	in	in	IN
8691	218	22	argument	argument	NN
8691	218	23	from	from	IN
8691	218	24	an	an	DT
8691	218	25	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	218	26	of	of	IN
8691	218	27	Lord	Lord	NNP
8691	218	28	Ellenborough;[Footnote	ellenborough;[footnote	ADD
8691	218	29	:	:	:
8691	218	30	Hickman	Hickman	NNP
8691	218	31	_	_	NNP
8691	218	32	v.	v.	IN
8691	218	33	_	_	NNP
8691	218	34	Boffman	Boffman	NNP
8691	218	35	,	,	,
8691	218	36	Hardin	Hardin	NNP
8691	218	37	's	's	POS
8691	218	38	Rep.	Rep.	NNP
8691	218	39	,	,	,
8691	218	40	348	348	CD
8691	218	41	,	,	,
8691	218	42	364	364	CD
8691	218	43	.	.	.
8691	218	44	]	]	-RRB-
8691	219	1	but	but	CC
8691	219	2	after	after	IN
8691	219	3	a	a	DT
8691	219	4	few	few	JJ
8691	219	5	years	year	NNS
8691	219	6	,	,	,
8691	219	7	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	219	8	of	of	IN
8691	219	9	this	this	DT
8691	219	10	kind	kind	NN
8691	219	11	,	,	,
8691	219	12	while	while	IN
8691	219	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	219	14	might	may	MD
8691	219	15	remain	remain	VB
8691	219	16	formally	formally	RB
8691	219	17	unrepealed	unrepealed	JJ
8691	219	18	,	,	,
8691	219	19	was	be	VBD
8691	219	20	treated	treat	VBN
8691	219	21	as	as	IN
8691	219	22	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
8691	219	23	both	both	CC
8691	219	24	by	by	IN
8691	219	25	court	court	NN
8691	219	26	and	and	CC
8691	219	27	bar	bar	NN
8691	219	28	.	.	.
8691	220	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	220	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	220	3	:	:	:
8691	220	4	Statutes	statute	NNS
8691	220	5	of	of	IN
8691	220	6	New	New	NNP
8691	220	7	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	220	8	,	,	,
8691	220	9	ed	ed	NNP
8691	220	10	.	.	.
8691	221	1	of	of	IN
8691	221	2	1800	1800	CD
8691	221	3	,	,	,
8691	221	4	p.	p.	NN
8691	221	5	436	436	CD
8691	221	6	(	(	-LRB-
8691	221	7	1799	1799	CD
8691	221	8	)	)	-RRB-
8691	221	9	;	;	:
8691	221	10	Morehead	Morehead	NNP
8691	221	11	and	and	CC
8691	221	12	Brown	Brown	NNP
8691	221	13	,	,	,
8691	221	14	"	"	``
8691	221	15	Digest	Digest	NNP
8691	221	16	of	of	IN
8691	221	17	the	the	DT
8691	221	18	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	221	19	of	of	IN
8691	221	20	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	221	21	,	,	,
8691	221	22	"	"	''
8691	221	23	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	221	24	,	,	,
8691	221	25	613	613	CD
8691	221	26	(	(	-LRB-
8691	221	27	1807	1807	CD
8691	221	28	)	)	-RRB-
8691	221	29	.	.	.
8691	221	30	]	]	-RRB-
8691	222	1	In	in	IN
8691	222	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	222	3	held	hold	VBN
8691	222	4	by	by	IN
8691	222	5	unlearned	unlearned	JJ
8691	222	6	judges	judge	NNS
8691	222	7	,	,	,
8691	222	8	also	also	RB
8691	222	9	,	,	,
8691	222	10	English	english	JJ
8691	222	11	law	law	NN
8691	222	12	-	-	HYPH
8691	222	13	books	book	NNS
8691	222	14	were	be	VBD
8691	222	15	lightly	lightly	RB
8691	222	16	considered	consider	VBN
8691	222	17	.	.	.
8691	223	1	One	one	CD
8691	223	2	of	of	IN
8691	223	3	this	this	DT
8691	223	4	kind	kind	NN
8691	223	5	was	be	VBD
8691	223	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	223	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	223	8	Livermore	Livermore	NNP
8691	223	9	,	,	,
8691	223	10	of	of	IN
8691	223	11	New	New	NNP
8691	223	12	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	223	13	.	.	.
8691	224	1	Shortly	shortly	RB
8691	224	2	after	after	IN
8691	224	3	the	the	DT
8691	224	4	close	close	NN
8691	224	5	of	of	IN
8691	224	6	the	the	DT
8691	224	7	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	224	8	,	,	,
8691	224	9	while	while	IN
8691	224	10	presiding	preside	VBG
8691	224	11	on	on	IN
8691	224	12	the	the	DT
8691	224	13	bench	bench	NN
8691	224	14	,	,	,
8691	224	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	224	16	stopped	stop	VBD
8691	224	17	a	a	DT
8691	224	18	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	224	19	who	who	WP
8691	224	20	was	be	VBD
8691	224	21	reading	read	VBG
8691	224	22	from	from	IN
8691	224	23	one	one	CD
8691	224	24	with	with	IN
8691	224	25	the	the	DT
8691	224	26	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	224	27	whether	whether	IN
8691	224	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	224	29	thought	think	VBD
8691	224	30	that	that	IN
8691	224	31	the	the	DT
8691	224	32	members	member	NNS
8691	224	33	of	of	IN
8691	224	34	the	the	DT
8691	224	35	court	court	NN
8691	224	36	did	do	VBD
8691	224	37	not	not	RB
8691	224	38	"	"	``
8691	224	39	understand	understand	VB
8691	224	40	the	the	DT
8691	224	41	principles	principle	NNS
8691	224	42	of	of	IN
8691	224	43	justice	justice	NN
8691	224	44	as	as	RB
8691	224	45	well	well	RB
8691	224	46	as	as	IN
8691	224	47	the	the	DT
8691	224	48	old	old	JJ
8691	224	49	wigged	wigged	JJ
8691	224	50	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	224	51	of	of	IN
8691	224	52	the	the	DT
8691	224	53	dark	dark	JJ
8691	224	54	ages	age	NNS
8691	224	55	did	do	VBD
8691	224	56	.	.	.
8691	225	1	"	"	``
8691	225	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	225	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	225	4	:	:	:
8691	225	5	"	"	``
8691	225	6	Memoir	Memoir	NNP
8691	225	7	of	of	IN
8691	225	8	Jeremiah	Jeremiah	NNP
8691	225	9	Mason	Mason	NNP
8691	225	10	Mason	Mason	NNP
8691	225	11	,	,	,
8691	225	12	"	"	``
8691	225	13	29	29	CD
8691	225	14	.	.	.
8691	225	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	226	1	But	but	CC
8691	226	2	whether	whether	IN
8691	226	3	cited	cite	VBD
8691	226	4	or	or	CC
8691	226	5	not	not	RB
8691	226	6	from	from	IN
8691	226	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	226	8	original	original	JJ
8691	226	9	sources	source	NNS
8691	226	10	,	,	,
8691	226	11	the	the	DT
8691	226	12	settled	settle	VBN
8691	226	13	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
8691	226	14	of	of	IN
8691	226	15	English	english	JJ
8691	226	16	law	law	NN
8691	226	17	were	be	VBD
8691	226	18	sure	sure	JJ
8691	226	19	in	in	IN
8691	226	20	the	the	DT
8691	226	21	end	end	NN
8691	226	22	to	to	TO
8691	226	23	permeate	permeate	VB
8691	226	24	both	both	CC
8691	226	25	bar	bar	NN
8691	226	26	and	and	CC
8691	226	27	bench	bench	NN
8691	226	28	in	in	IN
8691	226	29	every	every	DT
8691	226	30	State	State	NNP
8691	226	31	.	.	.
8691	227	1	The	the	DT
8691	227	2	Roman	roman	JJ
8691	227	3	law	law	NN
8691	227	4	and	and	CC
8691	227	5	the	the	DT
8691	227	6	law	law	NN
8691	227	7	of	of	IN
8691	227	8	nations	nation	NNS
8691	227	9	were	be	VBD
8691	227	10	studied	study	VBN
8691	227	11	in	in	IN
8691	227	12	preparation	preparation	NN
8691	227	13	for	for	IN
8691	227	14	admission	admission	NN
8691	227	15	to	to	IN
8691	227	16	the	the	DT
8691	227	17	American	american	JJ
8691	227	18	bar	bar	NN
8691	227	19	more	more	RBR
8691	227	20	generally	generally	RB
8691	227	21	and	and	CC
8691	227	22	more	more	RBR
8691	227	23	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
8691	227	24	in	in	IN
8691	227	25	the	the	DT
8691	227	26	years	year	NNS
8691	227	27	immediately	immediately	RB
8691	227	28	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	227	29	and	and	CC
8691	227	30	following	follow	VBG
8691	227	31	the	the	DT
8691	227	32	Revolutionary	revolutionary	JJ
8691	227	33	era	era	NN
8691	227	34	than	than	IN
8691	227	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	227	36	have	have	VBP
8691	227	37	been	be	VBN
8691	227	38	since	since	RB
8691	227	39	.	.	.
8691	228	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	228	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	228	3	:	:	:
8691	228	4	See	see	VB
8691	228	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	228	6	.	.	.
8691	229	1	XXIII	xxiii	NN
8691	229	2	.	.	.
8691	229	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	230	1	The	the	DT
8691	230	2	law	law	NN
8691	230	3	student	student	NN
8691	230	4	was	be	VBD
8691	230	5	also	also	RB
8691	230	6	set	set	VBN
8691	230	7	then	then	RB
8691	230	8	to	to	IN
8691	230	9	reading	read	VBG
8691	230	10	more	more	JJR
8691	230	11	books	book	NNS
8691	230	12	on	on	IN
8691	230	13	English	english	JJ
8691	230	14	law	law	NN
8691	230	15	than	than	IN
8691	230	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	230	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	230	18	now	now	RB
8691	230	19	.	.	.
8691	231	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	231	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	231	3	:	:	:
8691	231	4	See	see	VB
8691	231	5	Report	Report	NNP
8691	231	6	of	of	IN
8691	231	7	the	the	DT
8691	231	8	American	American	NNP
8691	231	9	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	231	10	Association	Association	NNP
8691	231	11	for	for	IN
8691	231	12	1903	1903	CD
8691	231	13	,	,	,
8691	231	14	p.	p.	NN
8691	232	1	675	675	CD
8691	232	2	.	.	.
8691	232	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	233	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	233	2	learned	learn	VBD
8691	233	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	233	4	profession	profession	NN
8691	233	5	by	by	IN
8691	233	6	the	the	DT
8691	233	7	eye	eye	NN
8691	233	8	and	and	CC
8691	233	9	not	not	RB
8691	233	10	by	by	IN
8691	233	11	the	the	DT
8691	233	12	ear	ear	NN
8691	233	13	.	.	.
8691	234	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	234	2	only	only	JJ
8691	234	3	lectures	lecture	NNS
8691	234	4	were	be	VBD
8691	234	5	the	the	DT
8691	234	6	occasional	occasional	JJ
8691	234	7	arguments	argument	NNS
8691	234	8	on	on	IN
8691	234	9	a	a	DT
8691	234	10	demurrer	demurrer	NN
8691	234	11	or	or	CC
8691	234	12	writ	writ	NN
8691	234	13	of	of	IN
8691	234	14	error	error	NN
8691	234	15	which	which	WDT
8691	234	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	234	17	might	may	MD
8691	234	18	hear	hear	VB
8691	234	19	in	in	IN
8691	234	20	the	the	DT
8691	234	21	court	court	NN
8691	234	22	room	room	NN
8691	234	23	,	,	,
8691	234	24	and	and	CC
8691	234	25	these	these	DT
8691	234	26	were	be	VBD
8691	234	27	a	a	DT
8691	234	28	reiteration	reiteration	NN
8691	234	29	of	of	IN
8691	234	30	rules	rule	NNS
8691	234	31	laid	lay	VBN
8691	234	32	down	down	RP
8691	234	33	in	in	IN
8691	234	34	English	english	JJ
8691	234	35	law	law	NN
8691	234	36	-	-	HYPH
8691	234	37	books	book	NNS
8691	234	38	.	.	.
8691	235	1	The	the	DT
8691	235	2	reason	reason	NN
8691	235	3	why	why	WRB
8691	235	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	235	5	read	read	VBD
8691	235	6	more	more	RBR
8691	235	7	of	of	IN
8691	235	8	Roman	roman	JJ
8691	235	9	law	law	NN
8691	235	10	than	than	IN
8691	235	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	235	12	now	now	RB
8691	235	13	required	require	VBN
8691	235	14	in	in	IN
8691	235	15	legal	legal	JJ
8691	235	16	education	education	NN
8691	235	17	was	be	VBD
8691	235	18	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	235	19	that	that	IN
8691	235	20	there	there	EX
8691	235	21	was	be	VBD
8691	235	22	more	more	JJR
8691	235	23	time	time	NN
8691	235	24	for	for	IN
8691	235	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	235	26	,	,	,
8691	235	27	since	since	IN
8691	235	28	of	of	IN
8691	235	29	English	english	JJ
8691	235	30	law	law	NN
8691	235	31	reports	report	VBZ
8691	235	32	there	there	EX
8691	235	33	were	be	VBD
8691	235	34	then	then	RB
8691	235	35	few	few	JJ
8691	235	36	,	,	,
8691	235	37	and	and	CC
8691	235	38	of	of	IN
8691	235	39	American	american	JJ
8691	235	40	none	none	NN
8691	235	41	.	.	.
8691	236	1	When	when	WRB
8691	236	2	the	the	DT
8691	236	3	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	236	4	broke	break	VBD
8691	236	5	out	out	RP
8691	236	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	236	7	also	also	RB
8691	236	8	became	become	VBD
8691	236	9	important	important	JJ
8691	236	10	in	in	IN
8691	236	11	helping	help	VBG
8691	236	12	to	to	TO
8691	236	13	explain	explain	VB
8691	236	14	the	the	DT
8691	236	15	practice	practice	NN
8691	236	16	in	in	IN
8691	236	17	prize	prize	NN
8691	236	18	courts	court	NNS
8691	236	19	.	.	.
8691	237	1	These	these	DT
8691	237	2	were	be	VBD
8691	237	3	set	set	VBN
8691	237	4	up	up	RP
8691	237	5	(	(	-LRB-
8691	237	6	or	or	CC
8691	237	7	existing	exist	VBG
8691	237	8	common	common	JJ
8691	237	9	law	law	NN
8691	237	10	courts	court	NNS
8691	237	11	invested	invest	VBN
8691	237	12	with	with	IN
8691	237	13	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	237	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	237	15	)	)	-RRB-
8691	237	16	in	in	IN
8691	237	17	all	all	PDT
8691	237	18	the	the	DT
8691	237	19	States	States	NNPS
8691	237	20	,	,	,
8691	237	21	and	and	CC
8691	237	22	American	american	JJ
8691	237	23	privateers	privateer	NNS
8691	237	24	gave	give	VBD
8691	237	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	237	26	not	not	RB
8691	237	27	a	a	DT
8691	237	28	little	little	JJ
8691	237	29	business	business	NN
8691	237	30	.	.	.
8691	238	1	In	in	IN
8691	238	2	order	order	NN
8691	238	3	to	to	TO
8691	238	4	secure	secure	VB
8691	238	5	uniformity	uniformity	NN
8691	238	6	of	of	IN
8691	238	7	decision	decision	NN
8691	238	8	in	in	IN
8691	238	9	matters	matter	NNS
8691	238	10	so	so	RB
8691	238	11	directly	directly	RB
8691	238	12	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	238	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	238	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	238	15	relations	relation	NNS
8691	238	16	,	,	,
8691	238	17	the	the	DT
8691	238	18	Continental	Continental	NNP
8691	238	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	238	20	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	238	21	the	the	DT
8691	238	22	right	right	NN
8691	238	23	to	to	TO
8691	238	24	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	238	25	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	238	26	functions	function	NNS
8691	238	27	,	,	,
8691	238	28	through	through	IN
8691	238	29	a	a	DT
8691	238	30	standing	stand	VBG
8691	238	31	committee	committee	NN
8691	238	32	of	of	IN
8691	238	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	238	34	members	member	NNS
8691	238	35	,	,	,
8691	238	36	and	and	CC
8691	238	37	in	in	IN
8691	238	38	1780	1780	CD
8691	238	39	organized	organize	VBD
8691	238	40	a	a	DT
8691	238	41	formal	formal	JJ
8691	238	42	court	court	NN
8691	238	43	for	for	IN
8691	238	44	the	the	DT
8691	238	45	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	238	46	,	,	,
8691	238	47	styled	style	VBN
8691	238	48	"	"	``
8691	238	49	The	the	DT
8691	238	50	Court	Court	NNP
8691	238	51	of	of	IN
8691	238	52	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	238	53	in	in	IN
8691	238	54	Cases	case	NNS
8691	238	55	of	of	IN
8691	238	56	Capture	Capture	NNP
8691	238	57	.	.	.
8691	238	58	"	"	''
8691	239	1	Three	three	CD
8691	239	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	239	3	were	be	VBD
8691	239	4	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	239	5	and	and	CC
8691	239	6	provided	provide	VBN
8691	239	7	with	with	IN
8691	239	8	a	a	DT
8691	239	9	register	register	NN
8691	239	10	and	and	CC
8691	239	11	seal	seal	NN
8691	239	12	.	.	.
8691	240	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	240	2	held	hold	VBD
8691	240	3	terms	term	NNS
8691	240	4	at	at	IN
8691	240	5	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
8691	240	6	,	,	,
8691	240	7	New	New	NNP
8691	240	8	York	York	NNP
8691	240	9	,	,	,
8691	240	10	Philadelphia	Philadelphia	NNP
8691	240	11	and	and	CC
8691	240	12	Richmond	Richmond	NNP
8691	240	13	during	during	IN
8691	240	14	the	the	DT
8691	240	15	next	next	JJ
8691	240	16	six	six	CD
8691	240	17	years	year	NNS
8691	240	18	.	.	.
8691	241	1	On	on	IN
8691	241	2	an	an	DT
8691	241	3	average	average	NN
8691	241	4	about	about	RB
8691	241	5	ten	ten	CD
8691	241	6	cases	case	NNS
8691	241	7	were	be	VBD
8691	241	8	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	241	9	of	of	IN
8691	241	10	annually	annually	RB
8691	241	11	,	,	,
8691	241	12	and	and	CC
8691	241	13	the	the	DT
8691	241	14	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	241	15	were	be	VBD
8691	241	16	generally	generally	RB
8691	241	17	conceded	concede	VBN
8691	241	18	to	to	TO
8691	241	19	have	have	VB
8691	241	20	been	be	VBN
8691	241	21	fair	fair	JJ
8691	241	22	and	and	CC
8691	241	23	well	well	RB
8691	241	24	supported	support	VBN
8691	241	25	by	by	IN
8691	241	26	the	the	DT
8691	241	27	rules	rule	NNS
8691	241	28	of	of	IN
8691	241	29	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	241	30	and	and	CC
8691	241	31	the	the	DT
8691	241	32	law	law	NN
8691	241	33	of	of	IN
8691	241	34	nations	nation	NNS
8691	241	35	.	.	.
8691	242	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	242	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	242	3	:	:	:
8691	242	4	See	see	VB
8691	242	5	Jameson	Jameson	NNP
8691	242	6	,	,	,
8691	242	7	"	"	''
8691	242	8	Essays	essay	NNS
8691	242	9	on	on	IN
8691	242	10	the	the	DT
8691	242	11	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	242	12	History	history	NN
8691	242	13	of	of	IN
8691	242	14	the	the	DT
8691	242	15	United	United	NNP
8691	242	16	States	States	NNP
8691	242	17	,	,	,
8691	242	18	"	"	``
8691	242	19	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	242	20	;	;	:
8691	242	21	J.	J.	NNP
8691	242	22	C.	C.	NNP
8691	242	23	Bancroft	Bancroft	NNP
8691	242	24	Davis	Davis	NNP
8691	242	25	,	,	,
8691	242	26	"	"	''
8691	242	27	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	242	28	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	242	29	Prior	prior	RB
8691	242	30	to	to	IN
8691	242	31	the	the	DT
8691	242	32	Adoption	Adoption	NNP
8691	242	33	of	of	IN
8691	242	34	the	the	DT
8691	242	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	242	36	,	,	,
8691	242	37	"	"	''
8691	242	38	131	131	CD
8691	242	39	United	United	NNP
8691	242	40	States	States	NNP
8691	242	41	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	242	42	,	,	,
8691	242	43	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
8691	242	44	,	,	,
8691	242	45	XIX	XIX	NNP
8691	242	46	.	.	.
8691	242	47	]	]	-RRB-
8691	243	1	The	the	DT
8691	243	2	influence	influence	NN
8691	243	3	of	of	IN
8691	243	4	French	french	JJ
8691	243	5	ideas	idea	NNS
8691	243	6	was	be	VBD
8691	243	7	strong	strong	JJ
8691	243	8	in	in	IN
8691	243	9	shaping	shape	VBG
8691	243	10	constructive	constructive	JJ
8691	243	11	work	work	NN
8691	243	12	in	in	IN
8691	243	13	American	american	JJ
8691	243	14	politics	politic	NNS
8691	243	15	,	,	,
8691	243	16	as	as	IN
8691	243	17	the	the	DT
8691	243	18	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	243	19	passed	pass	VBD
8691	243	20	into	into	IN
8691	243	21	States	state	NNS
8691	243	22	;	;	:
8691	243	23	but	but	CC
8691	243	24	aside	aside	RB
8691	243	25	from	from	IN
8691	243	26	the	the	DT
8691	243	27	separation	separation	NN
8691	243	28	of	of	IN
8691	243	29	the	the	DT
8691	243	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	243	31	department	department	NN
8691	243	32	from	from	IN
8691	243	33	the	the	DT
8691	243	34	executive	executive	JJ
8691	243	35	and	and	CC
8691	243	36	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	243	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	243	38	had	have	VBD
8691	243	39	little	little	JJ
8691	243	40	effect	effect	NN
8691	243	41	upon	upon	IN
8691	243	42	the	the	DT
8691	243	43	courts	court	NNS
8691	243	44	until	until	IN
8691	243	45	the	the	DT
8691	243	46	opening	opening	NN
8691	243	47	of	of	IN
8691	243	48	the	the	DT
8691	243	49	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	243	50	century	century	NN
8691	243	51	.	.	.
8691	244	1	Then	then	RB
8691	244	2	the	the	DT
8691	244	3	principles	principle	NNS
8691	244	4	of	of	IN
8691	244	5	the	the	DT
8691	244	6	Roman	roman	JJ
8691	244	7	law	law	NN
8691	244	8	,	,	,
8691	244	9	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	244	10	as	as	IN
8691	244	11	presented	present	VBN
8691	244	12	and	and	CC
8691	244	13	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
8691	244	14	by	by	IN
8691	244	15	the	the	DT
8691	244	16	French	french	JJ
8691	244	17	jurists	jurist	NNS
8691	244	18	,	,	,
8691	244	19	were	be	VBD
8691	244	20	seized	seize	VBN
8691	244	21	upon	upon	IN
8691	244	22	by	by	IN
8691	244	23	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	244	24	and	and	CC
8691	244	25	Story	Story	NNP
8691	244	26	,	,	,
8691	244	27	and	and	CC
8691	244	28	served	serve	VBD
8691	244	29	greatly	greatly	RB
8691	244	30	to	to	TO
8691	244	31	expand	expand	VB
8691	244	32	and	and	CC
8691	244	33	enrich	enrich	VB
8691	244	34	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	244	35	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	244	36	.	.	.
8691	245	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	245	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	245	3	:	:	:
8691	245	4	"	"	``
8691	245	5	Memoirs	Memoirs	NNPS
8691	245	6	and	and	CC
8691	245	7	Letters	Letters	NNPS
8691	245	8	of	of	IN
8691	245	9	James	James	NNP
8691	245	10	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	245	11	,	,	,
8691	245	12	"	"	``
8691	245	13	117	117	CD
8691	245	14	.	.	.
8691	245	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	246	1	The	the	DT
8691	246	2	course	course	NN
8691	246	3	of	of	IN
8691	246	4	events	event	NNS
8691	246	5	which	which	WDT
8691	246	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	246	7	been	be	VBN
8691	246	8	sketched	sketch	VBN
8691	246	9	left	leave	VBN
8691	246	10	certain	certain	JJ
8691	246	11	ideas	idea	NNS
8691	246	12	in	in	IN
8691	246	13	regard	regard	NN
8691	246	14	to	to	IN
8691	246	15	the	the	DT
8691	246	16	position	position	NN
8691	246	17	and	and	CC
8691	246	18	powers	power	NNS
8691	246	19	of	of	IN
8691	246	20	the	the	DT
8691	246	21	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	246	22	with	with	IN
8691	246	23	respect	respect	NN
8691	246	24	to	to	IN
8691	246	25	the	the	DT
8691	246	26	other	other	JJ
8691	246	27	branches	branch	NNS
8691	246	28	of	of	IN
8691	246	29	the	the	DT
8691	246	30	government	government	NN
8691	246	31	firmly	firmly	RB
8691	246	32	imbedded	imbed	VBD
8691	246	33	in	in	IN
8691	246	34	the	the	DT
8691	246	35	American	american	JJ
8691	246	36	mind	mind	NN
8691	246	37	.	.	.
8691	247	1	These	these	DT
8691	247	2	may	may	MD
8691	247	3	be	be	VB
8691	247	4	thus	thus	RB
8691	247	5	summarized	summarize	VBN
8691	247	6	:	:	:
8691	247	7	Judges	judge	NNS
8691	247	8	were	be	VBD
8691	247	9	to	to	TO
8691	247	10	proceed	proceed	VB
8691	247	11	according	accord	VBG
8691	247	12	to	to	IN
8691	247	13	established	establish	VBN
8691	247	14	rules	rule	NNS
8691	247	15	,	,	,
8691	247	16	so	so	RB
8691	247	17	far	far	RB
8691	247	18	as	as	IN
8691	247	19	established	establish	VBN
8691	247	20	rules	rule	NNS
8691	247	21	might	may	MD
8691	247	22	exist	exist	VB
8691	247	23	.	.	.
8691	248	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	248	2	were	be	VBD
8691	248	3	to	to	TO
8691	248	4	proceed	proceed	VB
8691	248	5	in	in	IN
8691	248	6	analogy	analogy	NN
8691	248	7	to	to	IN
8691	248	8	established	establish	VBN
8691	248	9	rules	rule	NNS
8691	248	10	as	as	IN
8691	248	11	to	to	IN
8691	248	12	points	point	NNS
8691	248	13	which	which	WDT
8691	248	14	no	no	DT
8691	248	15	established	establish	VBN
8691	248	16	rule	rule	NN
8691	248	17	might	may	MD
8691	248	18	cover	cover	VB
8691	248	19	.	.	.
8691	249	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	249	2	were	be	VBD
8691	249	3	to	to	TO
8691	249	4	look	look	VB
8691	249	5	to	to	IN
8691	249	6	the	the	DT
8691	249	7	common	common	JJ
8691	249	8	law	law	NN
8691	249	9	and	and	CC
8691	249	10	political	political	JJ
8691	249	11	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	249	12	of	of	IN
8691	249	13	England	England	NNP
8691	249	14	to	to	TO
8691	249	15	determine	determine	VB
8691	249	16	what	what	WP
8691	249	17	rules	rule	NNS
8691	249	18	were	be	VBD
8691	249	19	established	establish	VBN
8691	249	20	,	,	,
8691	249	21	as	as	IN
8691	249	22	to	to	IN
8691	249	23	points	point	NNS
8691	249	24	not	not	RB
8691	249	25	covered	cover	VBN
8691	249	26	by	by	IN
8691	249	27	local	local	JJ
8691	249	28	usage	usage	NN
8691	249	29	or	or	CC
8691	249	30	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	249	31	.	.	.
8691	250	1	Local	local	JJ
8691	250	2	usage	usage	NN
8691	250	3	or	or	CC
8691	250	4	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	250	5	might	may	MD
8691	250	6	,	,	,
8691	250	7	within	within	IN
8691	250	8	certain	certain	JJ
8691	250	9	limits	limit	NNS
8691	250	10	,	,	,
8691	250	11	depart	depart	VBP
8691	250	12	from	from	IN
8691	250	13	the	the	DT
8691	250	14	common	common	JJ
8691	250	15	law	law	NN
8691	250	16	and	and	CC
8691	250	17	even	even	RB
8691	250	18	from	from	IN
8691	250	19	the	the	DT
8691	250	20	political	political	JJ
8691	250	21	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	250	22	of	of	IN
8691	250	23	England	England	NNP
8691	250	24	.	.	.
8691	251	1	There	there	EX
8691	251	2	were	be	VBD
8691	251	3	limits	limit	NNS
8691	251	4	to	to	IN
8691	251	5	such	such	JJ
8691	251	6	departure	departure	NN
8691	251	7	,	,	,
8691	251	8	and	and	CC
8691	251	9	a	a	DT
8691	251	10	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	251	11	statute	statute	NN
8691	251	12	or	or	CC
8691	251	13	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	251	14	which	which	WDT
8691	251	15	transgressed	transgress	VBD
8691	251	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	251	17	could	could	MD
8691	251	18	be	be	VB
8691	251	19	annulled	annul	VBN
8691	251	20	or	or	CC
8691	251	21	set	set	VBN
8691	251	22	aside	aside	RB
8691	251	23	by	by	IN
8691	251	24	a	a	DT
8691	251	25	higher	high	JJR
8691	251	26	authority	authority	NN
8691	251	27	.	.	.
8691	252	1	This	this	DT
8691	252	2	higher	high	JJR
8691	252	3	authority	authority	NN
8691	252	4	might	may	MD
8691	252	5	be	be	VB
8691	252	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	252	7	or	or	CC
8691	252	8	political	political	JJ
8691	252	9	,	,	,
8691	252	10	or	or	CC
8691	252	11	one	one	CD
8691	252	12	which	which	WDT
8691	252	13	shared	share	VBD
8691	252	14	both	both	DT
8691	252	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	252	16	and	and	CC
8691	252	17	political	political	JJ
8691	252	18	functions	function	NNS
8691	252	19	.	.	.
8691	253	1	*	*	NFP
8691	253	2	*	*	NFP
8691	253	3	*	*	NFP
8691	253	4	*	*	NFP
8691	253	5	*	*	NFP
8691	253	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	253	7	II	II	NNP
8691	253	8	THE	the	DT
8691	253	9	SEPARATION	SEPARATION	NNP
8691	253	10	OF	of	IN
8691	253	11	THE	the	DT
8691	253	12	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	253	13	POWER	POWER	NNS
8691	253	14	FROM	from	IN
8691	253	15	THE	the	DT
8691	253	16	LEGISLATIVE	legislative	NN
8691	253	17	AND	and	CC
8691	253	18	EXECUTIVE	executive	NN
8691	253	19	IN	in	IN
8691	253	20	AMERICAN	AMERICAN	NNP
8691	253	21	CONSTITUTIONS	CONSTITUTIONS	NNP
8691	253	22	From	from	IN
8691	253	23	the	the	DT
8691	253	24	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	253	25	system	system	NN
8691	253	26	of	of	IN
8691	253	27	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	253	28	by	by	IN
8691	253	29	which	which	WDT
8691	253	30	all	all	PDT
8691	253	31	the	the	DT
8691	253	32	powers	power	NNS
8691	253	33	of	of	IN
8691	253	34	government	government	NN
8691	253	35	were	be	VBD
8691	253	36	at	at	IN
8691	253	37	times	time	NNS
8691	253	38	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	253	39	to	to	IN
8691	253	40	the	the	DT
8691	253	41	modern	modern	JJ
8691	253	42	American	American	NNP
8691	253	43	State	State	NNP
8691	253	44	,	,	,
8691	253	45	with	with	IN
8691	253	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	253	47	professed	professed	JJ
8691	253	48	division	division	NN
8691	253	49	of	of	IN
8691	253	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	253	51	into	into	IN
8691	253	52	three	three	CD
8691	253	53	parts	part	NNS
8691	253	54	,	,	,
8691	253	55	and	and	CC
8691	253	56	assignment	assignment	NN
8691	253	57	of	of	IN
8691	253	58	each	each	DT
8691	253	59	to	to	IN
8691	253	60	a	a	DT
8691	253	61	distinct	distinct	JJ
8691	253	62	department	department	NN
8691	253	63	,	,	,
8691	253	64	was	be	VBD
8691	253	65	a	a	DT
8691	253	66	long	long	JJ
8691	253	67	step	step	NN
8691	253	68	.	.	.
8691	254	1	So	so	RB
8691	254	2	far	far	RB
8691	254	3	as	as	IN
8691	254	4	the	the	DT
8691	254	5	United	United	NNP
8691	254	6	States	States	NNP
8691	254	7	were	be	VBD
8691	254	8	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	254	9	,	,	,
8691	254	10	the	the	DT
8691	254	11	weakness	weakness	NN
8691	254	12	of	of	IN
8691	254	13	the	the	DT
8691	254	14	government	government	NN
8691	254	15	under	under	IN
8691	254	16	the	the	DT
8691	254	17	Articles	Articles	NNPS
8691	254	18	of	of	IN
8691	254	19	Confederation	Confederation	NNP
8691	254	20	had	have	VBD
8691	254	21	been	be	VBN
8691	254	22	universally	universally	RB
8691	254	23	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
8691	254	24	and	and	CC
8691	254	25	was	be	VBD
8691	254	26	generally	generally	RB
8691	254	27	thought	think	VBN
8691	254	28	to	to	TO
8691	254	29	come	come	VB
8691	254	30	in	in	IN
8691	254	31	part	part	NN
8691	254	32	from	from	IN
8691	254	33	throwing	throw	VBG
8691	254	34	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	254	35	powers	power	NNS
8691	254	36	the	the	DT
8691	254	37	States	States	NNPS
8691	254	38	had	have	VBD
8691	254	39	granted	grant	VBN
8691	254	40	,	,	,
8691	254	41	in	in	IN
8691	254	42	a	a	DT
8691	254	43	mass	mass	NN
8691	254	44	,	,	,
8691	254	45	into	into	IN
8691	254	46	the	the	DT
8691	254	47	hands	hand	NNS
8691	254	48	of	of	IN
8691	254	49	the	the	DT
8691	254	50	Continental	Continental	NNP
8691	254	51	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	254	52	.	.	.
8691	255	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
8691	255	2	,	,	,
8691	255	3	the	the	DT
8691	255	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	255	5	of	of	IN
8691	255	6	the	the	DT
8691	255	7	United	United	NNP
8691	255	8	States	States	NNP
8691	255	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	255	10	not	not	RB
8691	255	11	framed	frame	VBN
8691	255	12	upon	upon	IN
8691	255	13	the	the	DT
8691	255	14	principles	principle	NNS
8691	255	15	of	of	IN
8691	255	16	a	a	DT
8691	255	17	strict	strict	JJ
8691	255	18	tripartite	tripartite	JJ
8691	255	19	division	division	NN
8691	255	20	.	.	.
8691	256	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	256	2	places	place	VBZ
8691	256	3	the	the	DT
8691	256	4	executive	executive	JJ
8691	256	5	power	power	NN
8691	256	6	in	in	IN
8691	256	7	the	the	DT
8691	256	8	hands	hand	NNS
8691	256	9	of	of	IN
8691	256	10	the	the	DT
8691	256	11	President	President	NNP
8691	256	12	,	,	,
8691	256	13	all	all	PDT
8691	256	14	the	the	DT
8691	256	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	256	16	powers	power	NNS
8691	256	17	which	which	WDT
8691	256	18	were	be	VBD
8691	256	19	granted	grant	VBN
8691	256	20	by	by	IN
8691	256	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	256	22	in	in	IN
8691	256	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	256	24	,	,	,
8691	256	25	and	and	CC
8691	256	26	the	the	DT
8691	256	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	256	28	power	power	NN
8691	256	29	in	in	IN
8691	256	30	certain	certain	JJ
8691	256	31	courts	court	NNS
8691	256	32	;	;	:
8691	256	33	but	but	CC
8691	256	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	256	35	does	do	VBZ
8691	256	36	not	not	RB
8691	256	37	follow	follow	VB
8691	256	38	the	the	DT
8691	256	39	earlier	early	JJR
8691	256	40	State	State	NNP
8691	256	41	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	256	42	in	in	IN
8691	256	43	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	256	44	that	that	IN
8691	256	45	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	256	46	was	be	VBD
8691	256	47	vested	vest	VBN
8691	256	48	in	in	IN
8691	256	49	either	either	DT
8691	256	50	of	of	IN
8691	256	51	these	these	DT
8691	256	52	three	three	CD
8691	256	53	depositaries	depositary	NNS
8691	256	54	was	be	VBD
8691	256	55	and	and	CC
8691	256	56	must	must	MD
8691	256	57	always	always	RB
8691	256	58	be	be	VB
8691	256	59	different	different	JJ
8691	256	60	in	in	IN
8691	256	61	kind	kind	NN
8691	256	62	from	from	IN
8691	256	63	that	that	DT
8691	256	64	vested	vest	VBN
8691	256	65	in	in	IN
8691	256	66	any	any	DT
8691	256	67	other	other	JJ
8691	256	68	of	of	IN
8691	256	69	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	256	70	.	.	.
8691	257	1	On	on	IN
8691	257	2	this	this	DT
8691	257	3	point	point	NN
8691	257	4	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	257	5	set	set	VBD
8691	257	6	the	the	DT
8691	257	7	fashion	fashion	NN
8691	257	8	,	,	,
8691	257	9	but	but	CC
8691	257	10	the	the	DT
8691	257	11	sonorous	sonorous	JJ
8691	257	12	phrase	phrase	NN
8691	257	13	of	of	IN
8691	257	14	the	the	DT
8691	257	15	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	257	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	257	17	of	of	IN
8691	257	18	1780	1780	CD
8691	257	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	257	20	the	the	DT
8691	257	21	most	most	RBS
8691	257	22	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	257	23	,	,	,
8691	257	24	in	in	IN
8691	257	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	257	26	declaration	declaration	NN
8691	257	27	(	(	-LRB-
8691	257	28	Part	Part	NNP
8691	257	29	the	the	DT
8691	257	30	First	first	JJ
8691	257	31	,	,	,
8691	257	32	Art	art	NN
8691	257	33	.	.	.
8691	258	1	XXX	XXX	NNP
8691	258	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	258	3	that	that	IN
8691	258	4	"	"	``
8691	258	5	in	in	IN
8691	258	6	the	the	DT
8691	258	7	government	government	NN
8691	258	8	of	of	IN
8691	258	9	this	this	DT
8691	258	10	commonwealth	commonwealth	NN
8691	258	11	,	,	,
8691	258	12	the	the	DT
8691	258	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	258	14	department	department	NN
8691	258	15	shall	shall	MD
8691	258	16	never	never	RB
8691	258	17	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	258	18	the	the	DT
8691	258	19	executive	executive	JJ
8691	258	20	and	and	CC
8691	258	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	258	22	powers	power	NNS
8691	258	23	,	,	,
8691	258	24	or	or	CC
8691	258	25	either	either	DT
8691	258	26	of	of	IN
8691	258	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	258	28	;	;	:
8691	258	29	the	the	DT
8691	258	30	executive	executive	NN
8691	258	31	shall	shall	MD
8691	258	32	never	never	RB
8691	258	33	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	258	34	the	the	DT
8691	258	35	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	258	36	and	and	CC
8691	258	37	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	258	38	powers	power	NNS
8691	258	39	,	,	,
8691	258	40	or	or	CC
8691	258	41	either	either	DT
8691	258	42	of	of	IN
8691	258	43	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	258	44	;	;	:
8691	258	45	the	the	DT
8691	258	46	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	258	47	shall	shall	MD
8691	258	48	never	never	RB
8691	258	49	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	258	50	the	the	DT
8691	258	51	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	258	52	and	and	CC
8691	258	53	executive	executive	JJ
8691	258	54	powers	power	NNS
8691	258	55	,	,	,
8691	258	56	or	or	CC
8691	258	57	either	either	DT
8691	258	58	of	of	IN
8691	258	59	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	258	60	;	;	:
8691	258	61	to	to	IN
8691	258	62	the	the	DT
8691	258	63	end	end	NN
8691	258	64	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	258	65	may	may	MD
8691	258	66	be	be	VB
8691	258	67	a	a	DT
8691	258	68	government	government	NN
8691	258	69	of	of	IN
8691	258	70	laws	law	NNS
8691	258	71	,	,	,
8691	258	72	and	and	CC
8691	258	73	not	not	RB
8691	258	74	of	of	IN
8691	258	75	men	man	NNS
8691	258	76	.	.	.
8691	259	1	"	"	``
8691	259	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	259	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	259	4	:	:	:
8691	259	5	The	the	DT
8691	259	6	last	last	JJ
8691	259	7	declaration	declaration	NN
8691	259	8	of	of	IN
8691	259	9	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	259	10	was	be	VBD
8691	259	11	taken	take	VBN
8691	259	12	from	from	IN
8691	259	13	Harrington	Harrington	NNP
8691	259	14	's	's	POS
8691	259	15	_	_	NNP
8691	259	16	Oceana	Oceana	NNP
8691	259	17	_	_	NNP
8691	259	18	,	,	,
8691	259	19	in	in	IN
8691	259	20	which	which	WDT
8691	259	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	259	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	259	23	said	say	VBN
8691	259	24	that	that	IN
8691	259	25	while	while	IN
8691	259	26	a	a	DT
8691	259	27	monarchy	monarchy	NN
8691	259	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	259	29	an	an	DT
8691	259	30	empire	empire	NN
8691	259	31	of	of	IN
8691	259	32	men	man	NNS
8691	259	33	,	,	,
8691	259	34	"	"	''
8691	259	35	a	a	DT
8691	259	36	commonwealth	commonwealth	NN
8691	259	37	is	be	VBZ
8691	259	38	an	an	DT
8691	259	39	empire	empire	NN
8691	259	40	of	of	IN
8691	259	41	laws	law	NNS
8691	259	42	and	and	CC
8691	259	43	not	not	RB
8691	259	44	of	of	IN
8691	259	45	men	man	NNS
8691	259	46	.	.	.
8691	259	47	"	"	''
8691	260	1	Works	Works	NNP
8691	260	2	,	,	,
8691	260	3	London	London	NNP
8691	260	4	ed	ed	NNP
8691	260	5	.	.	NNP
8691	260	6	,	,	,
8691	260	7	35	35	CD
8691	260	8	,	,	,
8691	260	9	42	42	CD
8691	260	10	,	,	,
8691	260	11	224	224	CD
8691	260	12	.	.	.
8691	260	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	261	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	261	2	was	be	VBD
8691	261	3	from	from	IN
8691	261	4	an	an	DT
8691	261	5	unwillingness	unwillingness	NN
8691	261	6	to	to	TO
8691	261	7	commit	commit	VB
8691	261	8	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	261	9	to	to	IN
8691	261	10	such	such	PDT
8691	261	11	a	a	DT
8691	261	12	principle	principle	NN
8691	261	13	that	that	IN
8691	261	14	the	the	DT
8691	261	15	people	people	NNS
8691	261	16	of	of	IN
8691	261	17	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	261	18	and	and	CC
8691	261	19	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	261	20	Island	Island	NNP
8691	261	21	preferred	prefer	VBD
8691	261	22	for	for	IN
8691	261	23	many	many	JJ
8691	261	24	years	year	NNS
8691	261	25	to	to	TO
8691	261	26	be	be	VB
8691	261	27	governed	govern	VBN
8691	261	28	in	in	IN
8691	261	29	the	the	DT
8691	261	30	old	old	JJ
8691	261	31	way	way	NN
8691	261	32	by	by	IN
8691	261	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	261	34	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	261	35	,	,	,
8691	261	36	without	without	IN
8691	261	37	a	a	DT
8691	261	38	written	write	VBN
8691	261	39	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	261	40	.	.	.
8691	262	1	During	during	IN
8691	262	2	this	this	DT
8691	262	3	period	period	NN
8691	262	4	,	,	,
8691	262	5	the	the	DT
8691	262	6	General	General	NNP
8691	262	7	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	262	8	of	of	IN
8691	262	9	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	262	10	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
8691	262	11	exercised	exercise	VBD
8691	262	12	the	the	DT
8691	262	13	power	power	NN
8691	262	14	of	of	IN
8691	262	15	setting	set	VBG
8691	262	16	aside	aside	RP
8691	262	17	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	262	18	of	of	IN
8691	262	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	262	20	,	,	,
8691	262	21	and	and	CC
8691	262	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	262	23	right	right	NN
8691	262	24	to	to	TO
8691	262	25	do	do	VB
8691	262	26	so	so	RB
8691	262	27	was	be	VBD
8691	262	28	sustained	sustain	VBN
8691	262	29	by	by	IN
8691	262	30	the	the	DT
8691	262	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	262	32	Court	Court	NNP
8691	262	33	of	of	IN
8691	262	34	the	the	DT
8691	262	35	United	United	NNP
8691	262	36	States	States	NNP
8691	262	37	.	.	.
8691	263	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	263	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	263	3	:	:	:
8691	263	4	Calder	Calder	NNP
8691	263	5	_	_	NNP
8691	263	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	263	7	_	_	NNP
8691	263	8	Bull	Bull	NNP
8691	263	9	,	,	,
8691	263	10	2	2	CD
8691	263	11	Root	Root	NNP
8691	263	12	's	's	POS
8691	263	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	263	14	,	,	,
8691	263	15	350	350	CD
8691	263	16	;	;	:
8691	263	17	3	3	CD
8691	263	18	Dallas	Dallas	NNP
8691	263	19	'	'	POS
8691	263	20	Reports	report	NNS
8691	263	21	,	,	,
8691	263	22	386	386	CD
8691	263	23	.	.	.
8691	263	24	]	]	-RRB-
8691	264	1	The	the	DT
8691	264	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	264	3	of	of	IN
8691	264	4	the	the	DT
8691	264	5	United	United	NNP
8691	264	6	States	States	NNP
8691	264	7	were	be	VBD
8691	264	8	called	call	VBN
8691	264	9	upon	upon	IN
8691	264	10	at	at	IN
8691	264	11	an	an	DT
8691	264	12	early	early	JJ
8691	264	13	day	day	NN
8691	264	14	to	to	TO
8691	264	15	determine	determine	VB
8691	264	16	how	how	WRB
8691	264	17	far	far	RB
8691	264	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	264	19	could	could	MD
8691	264	20	invest	invest	VB
8691	264	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	264	22	with	with	IN
8691	264	23	functions	function	NNS
8691	264	24	that	that	WDT
8691	264	25	were	be	VBD
8691	264	26	not	not	RB
8691	264	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	264	28	or	or	CC
8691	264	29	not	not	RB
8691	264	30	to	to	TO
8691	264	31	be	be	VB
8691	264	32	performed	perform	VBN
8691	264	33	in	in	IN
8691	264	34	a	a	DT
8691	264	35	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	264	36	manner	manner	NN
8691	264	37	.	.	.
8691	265	1	An	an	DT
8691	265	2	act	act	NN
8691	265	3	was	be	VBD
8691	265	4	passed	pass	VBN
8691	265	5	requiring	require	VBG
8691	265	6	the	the	DT
8691	265	7	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	265	8	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	265	9	to	to	TO
8691	265	10	pass	pass	VB
8691	265	11	upon	upon	IN
8691	265	12	claims	claim	NNS
8691	265	13	for	for	IN
8691	265	14	invalid	invalid	JJ
8691	265	15	pensions	pension	NNS
8691	265	16	,	,	,
8691	265	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	265	18	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	265	19	to	to	TO
8691	265	20	be	be	VB
8691	265	21	subject	subject	JJ
8691	265	22	to	to	IN
8691	265	23	review	review	NN
8691	265	24	by	by	IN
8691	265	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	265	26	.	.	.
8691	266	1	The	the	DT
8691	266	2	performance	performance	NN
8691	266	3	of	of	IN
8691	266	4	this	this	DT
8691	266	5	duty	duty	NN
8691	266	6	was	be	VBD
8691	266	7	declined	decline	VBN
8691	266	8	,	,	,
8691	266	9	and	and	CC
8691	266	10	the	the	DT
8691	266	11	attempt	attempt	NN
8691	266	12	to	to	TO
8691	266	13	put	put	VB
8691	266	14	a	a	DT
8691	266	15	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	266	16	of	of	IN
8691	266	17	a	a	DT
8691	266	18	court	court	NN
8691	266	19	under	under	IN
8691	266	20	the	the	DT
8691	266	21	control	control	NN
8691	266	22	of	of	IN
8691	266	23	the	the	DT
8691	266	24	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	266	25	made	make	VBD
8691	266	26	the	the	DT
8691	266	27	refusal	refusal	NN
8691	266	28	so	so	RB
8691	266	29	plainly	plainly	RB
8691	266	30	proper	proper	JJ
8691	266	31	that	that	IN
8691	266	32	the	the	DT
8691	266	33	act	act	NN
8691	266	34	was	be	VBD
8691	266	35	repealed	repeal	VBN
8691	266	36	at	at	IN
8691	266	37	the	the	DT
8691	266	38	next	next	JJ
8691	266	39	session	session	NN
8691	266	40	.	.	.
8691	267	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	267	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	267	3	:	:	:
8691	267	4	Hayburn	Hayburn	NNP
8691	267	5	's	's	POS
8691	267	6	Case	Case	NNP
8691	267	7	,	,	,
8691	267	8	2	2	CD
8691	267	9	Dallas	Dallas	NNP
8691	267	10	'	'	POS
8691	267	11	Reports	report	NNS
8691	267	12	,	,	,
8691	267	13	409	409	CD
8691	267	14	.	.	.
8691	267	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	268	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	268	2	was	be	VBD
8691	268	3	easier	easy	JJR
8691	268	4	for	for	IN
8691	268	5	the	the	DT
8691	268	6	United	United	NNP
8691	268	7	States	States	NNP
8691	268	8	to	to	TO
8691	268	9	maintain	maintain	VB
8691	268	10	from	from	IN
8691	268	11	the	the	DT
8691	268	12	first	first	JJ
8691	268	13	this	this	DT
8691	268	14	general	general	JJ
8691	268	15	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	268	16	for	for	IN
8691	268	17	the	the	DT
8691	268	18	division	division	NN
8691	268	19	of	of	IN
8691	268	20	power	power	NN
8691	268	21	than	than	IN
8691	268	22	for	for	IN
8691	268	23	the	the	DT
8691	268	24	early	early	JJ
8691	268	25	States	state	NNS
8691	268	26	.	.	.
8691	269	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	269	2	people	people	NNS
8691	269	3	had	have	VBD
8691	269	4	grown	grow	VBN
8691	269	5	up	up	RP
8691	269	6	under	under	IN
8691	269	7	too	too	RB
8691	269	8	different	different	JJ
8691	269	9	a	a	DT
8691	269	10	plan	plan	NN
8691	269	11	of	of	IN
8691	269	12	government	government	NN
8691	269	13	.	.	.
8691	270	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	270	2	had	have	VBD
8691	270	3	become	become	VBN
8691	270	4	so	so	RB
8691	270	5	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	270	6	to	to	IN
8691	270	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	270	8	that	that	IN
8691	270	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	270	10	could	could	MD
8691	270	11	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	270	12	believe	believe	VB
8691	270	13	that	that	IN
8691	270	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	270	15	had	have	VBD
8691	270	16	been	be	VBN
8691	270	17	abolished	abolish	VBN
8691	270	18	.	.	.
8691	271	1	Tradition	tradition	NN
8691	271	2	for	for	IN
8691	271	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	271	4	interpreted	interpret	VBD
8691	271	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	271	6	new	new	JJ
8691	271	7	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	271	8	and	and	CC
8691	271	9	overmastered	overmaster	VBN
8691	271	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	271	11	.	.	.
8691	272	1	The	the	DT
8691	272	2	State	state	NN
8691	272	3	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	272	4	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	272	5	continued	continue	VBD
8691	272	6	for	for	IN
8691	272	7	a	a	DT
8691	272	8	time	time	NN
8691	272	9	to	to	TO
8691	272	10	claim	claim	VB
8691	272	11	some	some	DT
8691	272	12	control	control	NN
8691	272	13	over	over	IN
8691	272	14	the	the	DT
8691	272	15	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	272	16	,	,	,
8691	272	17	or	or	CC
8691	272	18	at	at	IN
8691	272	19	least	least	JJS
8691	272	20	a	a	DT
8691	272	21	right	right	NN
8691	272	22	to	to	IN
8691	272	23	criticise	criticise	VB
8691	272	24	and	and	CC
8691	272	25	censure	censure	VB
8691	272	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	272	27	doings	doing	NNS
8691	272	28	.	.	.
8691	273	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	273	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	273	3	:	:	:
8691	273	4	See	see	VB
8691	273	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	273	6	.	.	.
8691	274	1	VII	VII	NNP
8691	274	2	.	.	.
8691	274	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	275	1	In	in	IN
8691	275	2	many	many	JJ
8691	275	3	of	of	IN
8691	275	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	275	5	State	State	NNP
8691	275	6	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	275	7	,	,	,
8691	275	8	after	after	IN
8691	275	9	providing	provide	VBG
8691	275	10	for	for	IN
8691	275	11	a	a	DT
8691	275	12	distribution	distribution	NN
8691	275	13	of	of	IN
8691	275	14	powers	power	NNS
8691	275	15	between	between	IN
8691	275	16	three	three	CD
8691	275	17	separate	separate	JJ
8691	275	18	departments	department	NNS
8691	275	19	,	,	,
8691	275	20	instead	instead	RB
8691	275	21	of	of	IN
8691	275	22	absolutely	absolutely	RB
8691	275	23	prohibiting	prohibit	VBG
8691	275	24	any	any	DT
8691	275	25	of	of	IN
8691	275	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	275	27	from	from	IN
8691	275	28	exercising	exercise	VBG
8691	275	29	any	any	DT
8691	275	30	power	power	NN
8691	275	31	properly	properly	RB
8691	275	32	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	275	33	to	to	IN
8691	275	34	either	either	DT
8691	275	35	of	of	IN
8691	275	36	the	the	DT
8691	275	37	others	other	NNS
8691	275	38	,	,	,
8691	275	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	275	40	is	be	VBZ
8691	275	41	declared	declare	VBN
8691	275	42	that	that	IN
8691	275	43	this	this	DT
8691	275	44	shall	shall	MD
8691	275	45	not	not	RB
8691	275	46	be	be	VB
8691	275	47	done	do	VBN
8691	275	48	,	,	,
8691	275	49	except	except	IN
8691	275	50	as	as	IN
8691	275	51	may	may	MD
8691	275	52	be	be	VB
8691	275	53	expressly	expressly	RB
8691	275	54	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	275	55	in	in	IN
8691	275	56	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	275	57	articles	article	NNS
8691	275	58	.	.	.
8691	276	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	276	2	a	a	DT
8691	276	3	declaration	declaration	NN
8691	276	4	was	be	VBD
8691	276	5	proposed	propose	VBN
8691	276	6	in	in	IN
8691	276	7	the	the	DT
8691	276	8	draft	draft	NN
8691	276	9	of	of	IN
8691	276	10	the	the	DT
8691	276	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	276	12	of	of	IN
8691	276	13	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	276	14	,	,	,
8691	276	15	reported	report	VBD
8691	276	16	to	to	IN
8691	276	17	the	the	DT
8691	276	18	convention	convention	NN
8691	276	19	which	which	WDT
8691	276	20	framed	frame	VBD
8691	276	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	276	22	in	in	IN
8691	276	23	1818	1818	CD
8691	276	24	;	;	:
8691	276	25	but	but	CC
8691	276	26	on	on	IN
8691	276	27	objection	objection	NN
8691	276	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	276	29	was	be	VBD
8691	276	30	struck	strike	VBN
8691	276	31	out	out	RP
8691	276	32	.	.	.
8691	277	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	277	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	277	3	:	:	:
8691	277	4	Journal	Journal	NNP
8691	277	5	of	of	IN
8691	277	6	the	the	DT
8691	277	7	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
8691	277	8	Convention	Convention	NNP
8691	277	9	of	of	IN
8691	277	10	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	277	11	,	,	,
8691	277	12	pp	pp	NNP
8691	277	13	.	.	.
8691	278	1	78	78	CD
8691	278	2	,	,	,
8691	278	3	55	55	CD
8691	278	4	.	.	.
8691	278	5	]	]	-RRB-
8691	279	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	279	2	was	be	VBD
8691	279	3	thought	think	VBN
8691	279	4	better	well	RBR
8691	279	5	to	to	TO
8691	279	6	leave	leave	VB
8691	279	7	the	the	DT
8691	279	8	relations	relation	NNS
8691	279	9	of	of	IN
8691	279	10	the	the	DT
8691	279	11	departments	department	NNS
8691	279	12	to	to	IN
8691	279	13	each	each	DT
8691	279	14	other	other	JJ
8691	279	15	to	to	TO
8691	279	16	be	be	VB
8691	279	17	worked	work	VBN
8691	279	18	out	out	RP
8691	279	19	in	in	IN
8691	279	20	practice	practice	NN
8691	279	21	,	,	,
8691	279	22	and	and	CC
8691	279	23	for	for	IN
8691	279	24	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	279	25	eighty	eighty	CD
8691	279	26	years	year	NNS
8691	279	27	afterward	afterward	RB
8691	279	28	the	the	DT
8691	279	29	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	279	30	continued	continue	VBD
8691	279	31	to	to	TO
8691	279	32	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	279	33	some	some	DT
8691	279	34	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	279	35	power	power	NN
8691	279	36	.	.	.
8691	280	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	280	2	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	280	3	gave	give	VBD
8691	280	4	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	280	5	relief	relief	NN
8691	280	6	to	to	TO
8691	280	7	carry	carry	VB
8691	280	8	out	out	RP
8691	280	9	a	a	DT
8691	280	10	charitable	charitable	JJ
8691	280	11	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	280	12	in	in	IN
8691	280	13	a	a	DT
8691	280	14	will	will	NN
8691	280	15	,	,	,
8691	280	16	which	which	WDT
8691	280	17	would	would	MD
8691	280	18	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	280	19	fail	fail	VB
8691	280	20	.	.	.
8691	281	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	281	2	interfered	interfere	VBD
8691	281	3	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
8691	281	4	in	in	IN
8691	281	5	probate	probate	JJ
8691	281	6	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	281	7	.	.	.
8691	282	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	282	2	released	release	VBD
8691	282	3	sureties	surety	NNS
8691	282	4	in	in	IN
8691	282	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	282	6	recognizances	recognizance	NNS
8691	282	7	.	.	.
8691	283	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	283	2	set	set	VBD
8691	283	3	aside	aside	RP
8691	283	4	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	283	5	.	.	.
8691	284	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	284	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	284	3	:	:	:
8691	284	4	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
8691	284	5	's	's	POS
8691	284	6	Appeal	appeal	NN
8691	284	7	,	,	,
8691	284	8	45	45	CD
8691	284	9	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	284	10	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	284	11	,	,	,
8691	284	12	306	306	CD
8691	284	13	,	,	,
8691	284	14	315	315	CD
8691	284	15	;	;	:
8691	284	16	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
8691	284	17	_	_	NNP
8691	284	18	v.	v.	IN
8691	284	19	_	_	NNP
8691	284	20	Colt	Colt	NNP
8691	284	21	,	,	,
8691	284	22	5	5	CD
8691	284	23	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	284	24	's	's	POS
8691	284	25	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	284	26	,	,	,
8691	284	27	119	119	CD
8691	284	28	.	.	.
8691	284	29	]	]	-RRB-
8691	285	1	A	a	DT
8691	285	2	decision	decision	NN
8691	285	3	of	of	IN
8691	285	4	the	the	DT
8691	285	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	285	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	285	7	of	of	IN
8691	285	8	Errors	Errors	NNPS
8691	285	9	sanctioned	sanction	VBD
8691	285	10	the	the	DT
8691	285	11	practice;[Footnote	practice;[footnote	NN
8691	285	12	:	:	:
8691	285	13	Starr	Starr	NNP
8691	285	14	_	_	NNP
8691	285	15	v.	v.	IN
8691	285	16	_	_	NNP
8691	285	17	Pease	Pease	NNP
8691	285	18	,	,	,
8691	285	19	8	8	CD
8691	285	20	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	285	21	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	285	22	,	,	,
8691	285	23	541	541	CD
8691	285	24	,	,	,
8691	285	25	547	547	CD
8691	285	26	.	.	.
8691	285	27	]	]	-RRB-
8691	286	1	but	but	CC
8691	286	2	in	in	IN
8691	286	3	1898	1898	CD
8691	286	4	the	the	DT
8691	286	5	court	court	NN
8691	286	6	overruled	overrule	VBD
8691	286	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	286	8	former	former	JJ
8691	286	9	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	286	10	,	,	,
8691	286	11	and	and	CC
8691	286	12	held	hold	VBD
8691	286	13	that	that	IN
8691	286	14	as	as	IN
8691	286	15	the	the	DT
8691	286	16	three	three	CD
8691	286	17	departments	department	NNS
8691	286	18	were	be	VBD
8691	286	19	made	make	VBN
8691	286	20	separate	separate	JJ
8691	286	21	and	and	CC
8691	286	22	distinct	distinct	JJ
8691	286	23	,	,	,
8691	286	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	286	25	needed	need	VBD
8691	286	26	no	no	DT
8691	286	27	express	express	JJ
8691	286	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	286	29	declaration	declaration	NN
8691	286	30	to	to	TO
8691	286	31	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	286	32	either	either	CC
8691	286	33	from	from	IN
8691	286	34	invading	invade	VBG
8691	286	35	the	the	DT
8691	286	36	province	province	NN
8691	286	37	of	of	IN
8691	286	38	the	the	DT
8691	286	39	other	other	JJ
8691	286	40	,	,	,
8691	286	41	and	and	CC
8691	286	42	so	so	IN
8691	286	43	that	that	IN
8691	286	44	no	no	DT
8691	286	45	power	power	NN
8691	286	46	not	not	RB
8691	286	47	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	286	48	in	in	IN
8691	286	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	286	50	nature	nature	NN
8691	286	51	could	could	MD
8691	286	52	be	be	VB
8691	286	53	conferred	confer	VBN
8691	286	54	upon	upon	IN
8691	286	55	the	the	DT
8691	286	56	courts	court	NNS
8691	286	57	.	.	.
8691	287	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	287	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	287	3	:	:	:
8691	287	4	Norwalk	Norwalk	NNP
8691	287	5	Street	Street	NNP
8691	287	6	Railway	Railway	NNP
8691	287	7	Company	Company	NNP
8691	287	8	's	's	POS
8691	287	9	Appeal	Appeal	NNP
8691	287	10	,	,	,
8691	287	11	69	69	CD
8691	287	12	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	287	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	287	14	,	,	,
8691	287	15	576	576	CD
8691	287	16	;	;	:
8691	287	17	37	37	CD
8691	287	18	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	287	19	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	287	20	,	,	,
8691	287	21	1080	1080	CD
8691	287	22	.	.	.
8691	287	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	288	1	But	but	CC
8691	288	2	may	may	MD
8691	288	3	not	not	RB
8691	288	4	a	a	DT
8691	288	5	power	power	NN
8691	288	6	be	be	VB
8691	288	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	288	8	in	in	IN
8691	288	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	288	10	nature	nature	NN
8691	288	11	and	and	CC
8691	288	12	yet	yet	CC
8691	288	13	not	not	RB
8691	288	14	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	288	15	so	so	RB
8691	288	16	?	?	.
8691	289	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	289	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	289	3	practically	practically	RB
8691	289	4	impossible	impossible	JJ
8691	289	5	to	to	TO
8691	289	6	establish	establish	VB
8691	289	7	in	in	IN
8691	289	8	every	every	DT
8691	289	9	instance	instance	NN
8691	289	10	a	a	DT
8691	289	11	plain	plain	JJ
8691	289	12	line	line	NN
8691	289	13	of	of	IN
8691	289	14	demarcation	demarcation	NN
8691	289	15	between	between	IN
8691	289	16	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	289	17	,	,	,
8691	289	18	executive	executive	JJ
8691	289	19	and	and	CC
8691	289	20	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	289	21	functions	function	NNS
8691	289	22	.	.	.
8691	290	1	Courts	court	NNS
8691	290	2	,	,	,
8691	290	3	for	for	IN
8691	290	4	instance	instance	NN
8691	290	5	,	,	,
8691	290	6	make	make	VB
8691	290	7	rules	rule	NNS
8691	290	8	of	of	IN
8691	290	9	practice	practice	NN
8691	290	10	.	.	.
8691	291	1	In	in	IN
8691	291	2	one	one	CD
8691	291	3	sense	sense	NN
8691	291	4	this	this	DT
8691	291	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	291	6	a	a	DT
8691	291	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	291	8	act	act	NN
8691	291	9	,	,	,
8691	291	10	because	because	IN
8691	291	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	291	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	291	13	one	one	CD
8691	291	14	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
8691	291	15	for	for	IN
8691	291	16	the	the	DT
8691	291	17	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	291	18	.	.	.
8691	292	1	In	in	IN
8691	292	2	another	another	DT
8691	292	3	point	point	NN
8691	292	4	of	of	IN
8691	292	5	view	view	NN
8691	292	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	292	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	292	8	an	an	DT
8691	292	9	act	act	NN
8691	292	10	of	of	IN
8691	292	11	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	292	12	.	.	.
8691	293	1	In	in	IN
8691	293	2	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	293	3	does	do	VBZ
8691	293	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	293	5	resemble	resemble	VB
8691	293	6	the	the	DT
8691	293	7	act	act	NN
8691	293	8	of	of	IN
8691	293	9	judging	judge	VBG
8691	293	10	a	a	DT
8691	293	11	litigated	litigated	JJ
8691	293	12	cause	cause	NN
8691	293	13	.	.	.
8691	294	1	Impeachments	impeachment	NNS
8691	294	2	are	be	VBP
8691	294	3	both	both	DT
8691	294	4	political	political	JJ
8691	294	5	and	and	CC
8691	294	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	294	7	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	294	8	,	,	,
8691	294	9	but	but	CC
8691	294	10	American	american	JJ
8691	294	11	constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	294	12	leave	leave	VBP
8691	294	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	294	14	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	294	15	to	to	IN
8691	294	16	the	the	DT
8691	294	17	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	294	18	department	department	NN
8691	294	19	.	.	.
8691	295	1	Franchises	franchise	NNS
8691	295	2	to	to	TO
8691	295	3	exist	exist	VB
8691	295	4	as	as	IN
8691	295	5	an	an	DT
8691	295	6	artificial	artificial	JJ
8691	295	7	person	person	NN
8691	295	8	are	be	VBP
8691	295	9	the	the	DT
8691	295	10	proper	proper	JJ
8691	295	11	subjects	subject	NNS
8691	295	12	of	of	IN
8691	295	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	295	14	grant	grant	NN
8691	295	15	,	,	,
8691	295	16	but	but	CC
8691	295	17	with	with	IN
8691	295	18	the	the	DT
8691	295	19	growing	grow	VBG
8691	295	20	insistence	insistence	NN
8691	295	21	in	in	IN
8691	295	22	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	295	23	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNP
8691	295	24	on	on	IN
8691	295	25	absolute	absolute	JJ
8691	295	26	equality	equality	NN
8691	295	27	of	of	IN
8691	295	28	right	right	NN
8691	295	29	,	,	,
8691	295	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	295	31	are	be	VBP
8691	295	32	now	now	RB
8691	295	33	almost	almost	RB
8691	295	34	everywhere	everywhere	RB
8691	295	35	given	give	VBN
8691	295	36	only	only	RB
8691	295	37	by	by	IN
8691	295	38	general	general	JJ
8691	295	39	laws	law	NNS
8691	295	40	.	.	.
8691	296	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	296	2	a	a	DT
8691	296	3	law	law	NN
8691	296	4	will	will	MD
8691	296	5	offer	offer	VB
8691	296	6	incorporation	incorporation	NN
8691	296	7	for	for	IN
8691	296	8	certain	certain	JJ
8691	296	9	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	296	10	to	to	IN
8691	296	11	any	any	DT
8691	296	12	who	who	WP
8691	296	13	choose	choose	VBP
8691	296	14	to	to	TO
8691	296	15	avail	avail	VB
8691	296	16	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	296	17	of	of	IN
8691	296	18	the	the	DT
8691	296	19	privilege	privilege	NN
8691	296	20	by	by	IN
8691	296	21	fulfilling	fulfil	VBG
8691	296	22	certain	certain	JJ
8691	296	23	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	296	24	and	and	CC
8691	296	25	filing	file	VBG
8691	296	26	certain	certain	JJ
8691	296	27	papers	paper	NNS
8691	296	28	in	in	IN
8691	296	29	a	a	DT
8691	296	30	public	public	JJ
8691	296	31	office	office	NN
8691	296	32	.	.	.
8691	297	1	But	but	CC
8691	297	2	what	what	WP
8691	297	3	shall	shall	MD
8691	297	4	be	be	VB
8691	297	5	the	the	DT
8691	297	6	nature	nature	NN
8691	297	7	of	of	IN
8691	297	8	this	this	DT
8691	297	9	office	office	NN
8691	297	10	,	,	,
8691	297	11	and	and	CC
8691	297	12	who	who	WP
8691	297	13	shall	shall	MD
8691	297	14	decide	decide	VB
8691	297	15	whether	whether	IN
8691	297	16	these	these	DT
8691	297	17	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	297	18	have	have	VBP
8691	297	19	been	be	VBN
8691	297	20	fulfilled	fulfil	VBN
8691	297	21	and	and	CC
8691	297	22	these	these	DT
8691	297	23	papers	paper	NNS
8691	297	24	filed	file	VBN
8691	297	25	?	?	.
8691	298	1	The	the	DT
8691	298	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	298	3	may	may	MD
8691	298	4	select	select	VB
8691	298	5	an	an	DT
8691	298	6	executive	executive	NN
8691	298	7	,	,	,
8691	298	8	a	a	DT
8691	298	9	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	298	10	,	,	,
8691	298	11	or	or	CC
8691	298	12	a	a	DT
8691	298	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	298	14	office	office	NN
8691	298	15	.	.	.
8691	299	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	299	2	may	may	MD
8691	299	3	entrust	entrust	VB
8691	299	4	this	this	DT
8691	299	5	power	power	NN
8691	299	6	of	of	IN
8691	299	7	decision	decision	NN
8691	299	8	to	to	IN
8691	299	9	an	an	DT
8691	299	10	executive	executive	NN
8691	299	11	,	,	,
8691	299	12	a	a	DT
8691	299	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	299	14	,	,	,
8691	299	15	or	or	CC
8691	299	16	a	a	DT
8691	299	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	299	18	officer	officer	NN
8691	299	19	.	.	.
8691	300	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	300	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	300	3	,	,	,
8691	300	4	in	in	IN
8691	300	5	fact	fact	NN
8691	300	6	,	,	,
8691	300	7	in	in	IN
8691	300	8	some	some	DT
8691	300	9	States	States	NNP
8691	300	10	,	,	,
8691	300	11	entrusted	entrust	VBD
8691	300	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	300	13	to	to	IN
8691	300	14	a	a	DT
8691	300	15	court	court	NN
8691	300	16	,	,	,
8691	300	17	and	and	CC
8691	300	18	authorized	authorize	VBD
8691	300	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	300	20	,	,	,
8691	300	21	if	if	IN
8691	300	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	300	23	decided	decide	VBD
8691	300	24	in	in	IN
8691	300	25	favor	favor	NN
8691	300	26	of	of	IN
8691	300	27	those	those	DT
8691	300	28	claiming	claim	VBG
8691	300	29	incorporation	incorporation	NN
8691	300	30	,	,	,
8691	300	31	not	not	RB
8691	300	32	only	only	RB
8691	300	33	to	to	TO
8691	300	34	record	record	VB
8691	300	35	the	the	DT
8691	300	36	decision	decision	NN
8691	300	37	,	,	,
8691	300	38	but	but	CC
8691	300	39	to	to	TO
8691	300	40	issue	issue	VB
8691	300	41	the	the	DT
8691	300	42	paper	paper	NN
8691	300	43	which	which	WDT
8691	300	44	shows	show	VBZ
8691	300	45	that	that	IN
8691	300	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	300	47	are	be	VBP
8691	300	48	entitled	entitle	VBN
8691	300	49	to	to	TO
8691	300	50	possess	possess	VB
8691	300	51	and	and	CC
8691	300	52	enjoy	enjoy	VB
8691	300	53	the	the	DT
8691	300	54	franchise	franchise	NN
8691	300	55	.	.	.
8691	301	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	301	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	301	3	safe	safe	JJ
8691	301	4	to	to	TO
8691	301	5	assert	assert	VB
8691	301	6	that	that	IN
8691	301	7	in	in	IN
8691	301	8	no	no	DT
8691	301	9	State	state	NN
8691	301	10	are	be	VBP
8691	301	11	the	the	DT
8691	301	12	functions	function	NNS
8691	301	13	of	of	IN
8691	301	14	the	the	DT
8691	301	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	301	16	purely	purely	RB
8691	301	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	301	18	.	.	.
8691	302	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	302	2	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	302	3	to	to	IN
8691	302	4	the	the	DT
8691	302	5	administration	administration	NN
8691	302	6	of	of	IN
8691	302	7	the	the	DT
8691	302	8	methods	method	NNS
8691	302	9	of	of	IN
8691	302	10	political	political	JJ
8691	302	11	government	government	NN
8691	302	12	are	be	VBP
8691	302	13	in	in	IN
8691	302	14	all	all	DT
8691	302	15	intrusted	intrust	VBN
8691	302	16	to	to	IN
8691	302	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	302	18	officers	officer	NNS
8691	302	19	either	either	CC
8691	302	20	originally	originally	RB
8691	302	21	or	or	CC
8691	302	22	by	by	IN
8691	302	23	way	way	NN
8691	302	24	of	of	IN
8691	302	25	review	review	NN
8691	302	26	.	.	.
8691	303	1	Some	some	DT
8691	303	2	of	of	IN
8691	303	3	these	these	DT
8691	303	4	concern	concern	NN
8691	303	5	such	such	JJ
8691	303	6	matters	matter	NNS
8691	303	7	of	of	IN
8691	303	8	internal	internal	JJ
8691	303	9	police	police	NNS
8691	303	10	,	,	,
8691	303	11	as	as	IN
8691	303	12	the	the	DT
8691	303	13	enforcement	enforcement	NN
8691	303	14	of	of	IN
8691	303	15	laws	law	NNS
8691	303	16	to	to	TO
8691	303	17	preserve	preserve	VB
8691	303	18	the	the	DT
8691	303	19	public	public	JJ
8691	303	20	health	health	NN
8691	303	21	or	or	CC
8691	303	22	to	to	TO
8691	303	23	regulate	regulate	VB
8691	303	24	the	the	DT
8691	303	25	sale	sale	NN
8691	303	26	of	of	IN
8691	303	27	intoxicating	intoxicate	VBG
8691	303	28	liquors	liquor	NNS
8691	303	29	,	,	,
8691	303	30	and	and	CC
8691	303	31	the	the	DT
8691	303	32	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	303	33	and	and	CC
8691	303	34	repair	repair	NN
8691	303	35	of	of	IN
8691	303	36	highways	highway	NNS
8691	303	37	.	.	.
8691	304	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	304	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	304	3	:	:	:
8691	304	4	Application	Application	NNP
8691	304	5	of	of	IN
8691	304	6	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
8691	304	7	,	,	,
8691	304	8	22	22	CD
8691	304	9	New	New	NNP
8691	304	10	York	York	NNP
8691	304	11	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	304	12	,	,	,
8691	304	13	67	67	CD
8691	304	14	,	,	,
8691	304	15	82	82	CD
8691	304	16	,	,	,
8691	304	17	84	84	CD
8691	304	18	;	;	:
8691	304	19	Norwalk	Norwalk	NNP
8691	304	20	Street	Street	NNP
8691	304	21	Railway	Railway	NNP
8691	304	22	Company	Company	NNP
8691	304	23	's	's	POS
8691	304	24	Appeal	Appeal	NNP
8691	304	25	,	,	,
8691	304	26	69	69	CD
8691	304	27	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	304	28	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	304	29	,	,	,
8691	304	30	576	576	CD
8691	304	31	;	;	:
8691	304	32	37	37	CD
8691	304	33	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	304	34	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	304	35	,	,	,
8691	304	36	1080	1080	CD
8691	304	37	;	;	:
8691	304	38	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
8691	304	39	_	_	NNP
8691	304	40	v.	v.	IN
8691	304	41	_	_	NNP
8691	304	42	New	New	NNP
8691	304	43	Haven	Haven	NNP
8691	304	44	,	,	,
8691	304	45	73	73	CD
8691	304	46	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	304	47	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	304	48	,	,	,
8691	304	49	646	646	CD
8691	304	50	;	;	:
8691	304	51	48	48	CD
8691	304	52	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	304	53	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	304	54	,	,	,
8691	304	55	960	960	CD
8691	304	56	;	;	:
8691	304	57	Upshur	Upshur	NNP
8691	304	58	County	County	NNP
8691	304	59	_	_	NNP
8691	304	60	v.	v.	IN
8691	304	61	_	_	NNP
8691	304	62	Rich	Rich	NNP
8691	304	63	,	,	,
8691	304	64	135	135	CD
8691	304	65	U.	U.	NNP
8691	304	66	S.	S.	NNP
8691	304	67	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	304	68	,	,	,
8691	304	69	467	467	CD
8691	304	70	,	,	,
8691	304	71	477	477	CD
8691	304	72	;	;	:
8691	304	73	Janvrin	Janvrin	NNP
8691	304	74	_	_	NNP
8691	304	75	v.	v.	IN
8691	304	76	_	_	NNP
8691	304	77	Revere	Revere	NNP
8691	304	78	Water	Water	NNP
8691	304	79	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	304	80	,	,	,
8691	304	81	174	174	CD
8691	304	82	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	305	1	Rep.	Rep.	NNP
8691	305	2	514	514	CD
8691	305	3	;	;	:
8691	305	4	55	55	CD
8691	305	5	North	North	NNP
8691	305	6	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
8691	305	7	Rep.	Rep.	NNP
8691	306	1	381	381	CD
8691	306	2	.	.	.
8691	306	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	307	1	Instead	instead	RB
8691	307	2	of	of	IN
8691	307	3	creating	create	VBG
8691	307	4	a	a	DT
8691	307	5	system	system	NN
8691	307	6	of	of	IN
8691	307	7	bureaus	bureaus	NN
8691	307	8	and	and	CC
8691	307	9	prefects	prefect	NNS
8691	307	10	,	,	,
8691	307	11	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	307	12	have	have	VBP
8691	307	13	adhered	adhere	VBN
8691	307	14	to	to	IN
8691	307	15	the	the	DT
8691	307	16	English	english	JJ
8691	307	17	plan	plan	NN
8691	307	18	of	of	IN
8691	307	19	administering	administer	VBG
8691	307	20	local	local	JJ
8691	307	21	and	and	CC
8691	307	22	county	county	NN
8691	307	23	concerns	concern	NNS
8691	307	24	through	through	IN
8691	307	25	justices	justice	NNS
8691	307	26	of	of	IN
8691	307	27	the	the	DT
8691	307	28	peace	peace	NN
8691	307	29	,	,	,
8691	307	30	courts	court	NNS
8691	307	31	of	of	IN
8691	307	32	quarter	quarter	NN
8691	307	33	-	-	HYPH
8691	307	34	sessions	session	NNS
8691	307	35	,	,	,
8691	307	36	and	and	CC
8691	307	37	county	county	NN
8691	307	38	or	or	CC
8691	307	39	parish	parish	NN
8691	307	40	courts	court	NNS
8691	307	41	.	.	.
8691	308	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	308	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	308	3	:	:	:
8691	308	4	See	see	VB
8691	308	5	Maitland	Maitland	NNP
8691	308	6	,	,	,
8691	308	7	"	"	''
8691	308	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	308	9	and	and	CC
8691	308	10	Police	Police	NNPS
8691	308	11	,	,	,
8691	308	12	"	"	''
8691	308	13	85	85	CD
8691	308	14	.	.	.
8691	308	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	309	1	Of	of	IN
8691	309	2	the	the	DT
8691	309	3	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	309	4	committed	commit	VBN
8691	309	5	to	to	IN
8691	309	6	such	such	JJ
8691	309	7	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	309	8	some	some	DT
8691	309	9	pertain	pertain	NN
8691	309	10	to	to	IN
8691	309	11	the	the	DT
8691	309	12	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	309	13	of	of	IN
8691	309	14	elections	election	NNS
8691	309	15	,	,	,
8691	309	16	and	and	CC
8691	309	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	309	18	are	be	VBP
8691	309	19	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	309	20	empowered	empower	VBN
8691	309	21	to	to	TO
8691	309	22	appoint	appoint	VB
8691	309	23	election	election	NN
8691	309	24	officers	officer	NNS
8691	309	25	or	or	CC
8691	309	26	clerks	clerk	NNS
8691	309	27	,	,	,
8691	309	28	because	because	IN
8691	309	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	309	30	is	be	VBZ
8691	309	31	felt	feel	VBN
8691	309	32	that	that	IN
8691	309	33	thus	thus	RB
8691	309	34	a	a	DT
8691	309	35	wise	wise	JJ
8691	309	36	impartiality	impartiality	NN
8691	309	37	in	in	IN
8691	309	38	selection	selection	NN
8691	309	39	can	can	MD
8691	309	40	best	best	RB
8691	309	41	be	be	VB
8691	309	42	attained	attain	VBN
8691	309	43	.	.	.
8691	310	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	310	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	310	3	:	:	:
8691	310	4	People	People	NNS
8691	310	5	_	_	NNP
8691	310	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	310	7	_	_	NNP
8691	310	8	Hoffman	Hoffman	NNP
8691	310	9	,	,	,
8691	310	10	116	116	CD
8691	310	11	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
8691	310	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	310	13	,	,	,
8691	310	14	587	587	CD
8691	310	15	;	;	:
8691	310	16	5	5	CD
8691	310	17	Northeastern	northeastern	JJ
8691	310	18	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	310	19	,	,	,
8691	310	20	596	596	CD
8691	310	21	;	;	:
8691	310	22	56	56	CD
8691	310	23	American	American	NNP
8691	310	24	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	310	25	,	,	,
8691	310	26	793	793	CD
8691	310	27	;	;	:
8691	310	28	_	_	NNP
8691	310	29	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	310	30	parte	parte	NN
8691	310	31	_	_	NNP
8691	310	32	Siebold	Siebold	NNP
8691	310	33	,	,	,
8691	310	34	100	100	CD
8691	310	35	U.	U.	NNP
8691	310	36	S.	S.	NNP
8691	310	37	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	310	38	,	,	,
8691	310	39	371	371	CD
8691	310	40	,	,	,
8691	310	41	397	397	CD
8691	310	42	.	.	.
8691	310	43	]	]	-RRB-
8691	311	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	311	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	311	3	vital	vital	JJ
8691	311	4	to	to	IN
8691	311	5	the	the	DT
8691	311	6	proper	proper	JJ
8691	311	7	working	working	NN
8691	311	8	of	of	IN
8691	311	9	government	government	NN
8691	311	10	under	under	IN
8691	311	11	a	a	DT
8691	311	12	written	write	VBN
8691	311	13	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	311	14	that	that	IN
8691	311	15	these	these	DT
8691	311	16	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	311	17	restrictions	restriction	NNS
8691	311	18	on	on	IN
8691	311	19	the	the	DT
8691	311	20	powers	power	NNS
8691	311	21	of	of	IN
8691	311	22	the	the	DT
8691	311	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	311	24	should	should	MD
8691	311	25	not	not	RB
8691	311	26	be	be	VB
8691	311	27	too	too	RB
8691	311	28	strictly	strictly	RB
8691	311	29	interpreted	interpret	VBN
8691	311	30	.	.	.
8691	312	1	Every	every	DT
8691	312	2	step	step	NN
8691	312	3	in	in	IN
8691	312	4	the	the	DT
8691	312	5	progress	progress	NN
8691	312	6	of	of	IN
8691	312	7	civilization	civilization	NN
8691	312	8	makes	make	VBZ
8691	312	9	this	this	DT
8691	312	10	the	the	DT
8691	312	11	more	more	RBR
8691	312	12	obvious	obvious	JJ
8691	312	13	.	.	.
8691	313	1	No	no	DT
8691	313	2	absolute	absolute	JJ
8691	313	3	trinity	trinity	NN
8691	313	4	of	of	IN
8691	313	5	governmental	governmental	JJ
8691	313	6	form	form	NN
8691	313	7	can	can	MD
8691	313	8	be	be	VB
8691	313	9	maintained	maintain	VBN
8691	313	10	in	in	IN
8691	313	11	human	human	JJ
8691	313	12	society	society	NN
8691	313	13	,	,	,
8691	313	14	as	as	IN
8691	313	15	the	the	DT
8691	313	16	relations	relation	NNS
8691	313	17	of	of	IN
8691	313	18	each	each	DT
8691	313	19	individual	individual	NN
8691	313	20	to	to	IN
8691	313	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	313	22	fellows	fellow	NNS
8691	313	23	,	,	,
8691	313	24	and	and	CC
8691	313	25	of	of	IN
8691	313	26	the	the	DT
8691	313	27	State	State	NNP
8691	313	28	to	to	IN
8691	313	29	all	all	DT
8691	313	30	,	,	,
8691	313	31	become	become	VB
8691	313	32	,	,	,
8691	313	33	and	and	CC
8691	313	34	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	313	35	become	become	VB
8691	313	36	,	,	,
8691	313	37	more	more	RBR
8691	313	38	numerous	numerous	JJ
8691	313	39	and	and	CC
8691	313	40	complicated	complicated	JJ
8691	313	41	.	.	.
8691	314	1	In	in	IN
8691	314	2	every	every	DT
8691	314	3	State	State	NNP
8691	314	4	that	that	DT
8691	314	5	department	department	NN
8691	314	6	which	which	WDT
8691	314	7	in	in	IN
8691	314	8	practice	practice	NN
8691	314	9	proves	prove	VBZ
8691	314	10	the	the	DT
8691	314	11	strongest	strong	JJS
8691	314	12	will	will	MD
8691	314	13	push	push	VB
8691	314	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	314	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	314	16	furthest	furthest	NN
8691	314	17	.	.	.
8691	315	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	315	2	may	may	MD
8691	315	3	be	be	VB
8691	315	4	said	say	VBN
8691	315	5	,	,	,
8691	315	6	in	in	IN
8691	315	7	view	view	NN
8691	315	8	of	of	IN
8691	315	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	315	10	now	now	RB
8691	315	11	established	establish	VBN
8691	315	12	power	power	NN
8691	315	13	to	to	TO
8691	315	14	decide	decide	VB
8691	315	15	between	between	IN
8691	315	16	higher	high	JJR
8691	315	17	and	and	CC
8691	315	18	lower	low	JJR
8691	315	19	forms	form	NNS
8691	315	20	of	of	IN
8691	315	21	law,[Footnote	law,[footnote	NN
8691	315	22	:	:	:
8691	315	23	See	see	VB
8691	315	24	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	315	25	.	.	.
8691	316	1	VII	VII	NNP
8691	316	2	.	.	.
8691	316	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	317	1	that	that	IN
8691	317	2	the	the	DT
8691	317	3	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	317	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	317	5	proved	prove	VBN
8691	317	6	the	the	DT
8691	317	7	strongest	strong	JJS
8691	317	8	.	.	.
8691	318	1	The	the	DT
8691	318	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	318	3	,	,	,
8691	318	4	as	as	IN
8691	318	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	318	6	been	be	VBN
8691	318	7	stated	state	VBN
8691	318	8	,	,	,
8691	318	9	have	have	VBP
8691	318	10	found	find	VBN
8691	318	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	318	12	a	a	DT
8691	318	13	convenient	convenient	JJ
8691	318	14	depositary	depositary	NN
8691	318	15	of	of	IN
8691	318	16	many	many	JJ
8691	318	17	quasi	quasi	JJ
8691	318	18	-	-	JJ
8691	318	19	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	318	20	and	and	CC
8691	318	21	quasi	quasi	JJ
8691	318	22	-	-	JJ
8691	318	23	executive	executive	JJ
8691	318	24	functions	function	NNS
8691	318	25	,	,	,
8691	318	26	and	and	CC
8691	318	27	this	this	DT
8691	318	28	also	also	RB
8691	318	29	has	have	VBZ
8691	318	30	largely	largely	RB
8691	318	31	increased	increase	VBN
8691	318	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	318	33	power	power	NN
8691	318	34	.	.	.
8691	319	1	The	the	DT
8691	319	2	theory	theory	NN
8691	319	3	of	of	IN
8691	319	4	the	the	DT
8691	319	5	French	french	JJ
8691	319	6	philosophers	philosopher	NNS
8691	319	7	that	that	IN
8691	319	8	all	all	PDT
8691	319	9	the	the	DT
8691	319	10	powers	power	NNS
8691	319	11	of	of	IN
8691	319	12	government	government	NN
8691	319	13	could	could	MD
8691	319	14	be	be	VB
8691	319	15	divided	divide	VBN
8691	319	16	into	into	IN
8691	319	17	three	three	CD
8691	319	18	parts	part	NNS
8691	319	19	,	,	,
8691	319	20	each	each	DT
8691	319	21	bearing	bear	VBG
8691	319	22	a	a	DT
8691	319	23	name	name	NN
8691	319	24	descriptive	descriptive	NN
8691	319	25	only	only	RB
8691	319	26	of	of	IN
8691	319	27	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	319	28	,	,	,
8691	319	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	319	30	not	not	RB
8691	319	31	supported	support	VBN
8691	319	32	by	by	IN
8691	319	33	the	the	DT
8691	319	34	practical	practical	JJ
8691	319	35	experience	experience	NN
8691	319	36	of	of	IN
8691	319	37	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	319	38	.	.	.
8691	320	1	There	there	EX
8691	320	2	are	be	VBP
8691	320	3	functions	function	NNS
8691	320	4	that	that	WDT
8691	320	5	might	may	MD
8691	320	6	as	as	RB
8691	320	7	well	well	RB
8691	320	8	be	be	VB
8691	320	9	assigned	assign	VBN
8691	320	10	to	to	IN
8691	320	11	one	one	CD
8691	320	12	of	of	IN
8691	320	13	these	these	DT
8691	320	14	parts	part	NNS
8691	320	15	as	as	IN
8691	320	16	to	to	IN
8691	320	17	another	another	DT
8691	320	18	,	,	,
8691	320	19	or	or	CC
8691	320	20	made	make	VBN
8691	320	21	into	into	IN
8691	320	22	a	a	DT
8691	320	23	fourth	fourth	JJ
8691	320	24	and	and	CC
8691	320	25	called	call	VBN
8691	320	26	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	320	27	.	.	.
8691	321	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	321	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	321	3	:	:	:
8691	321	4	Under	under	IN
8691	321	5	authority	authority	NN
8691	321	6	of	of	IN
8691	321	7	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	321	8	present	present	JJ
8691	321	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	321	10	,	,	,
8691	321	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	321	12	in	in	IN
8691	321	13	1904	1904	CD
8691	321	14	organized	organize	VBD
8691	321	15	a	a	DT
8691	321	16	State	State	NNP
8691	321	17	Commission	Commission	NNP
8691	321	18	for	for	IN
8691	321	19	the	the	DT
8691	321	20	Supervision	Supervision	NNP
8691	321	21	of	of	IN
8691	321	22	Corporations	Corporations	NNPS
8691	321	23	,	,	,
8691	321	24	which	which	WDT
8691	321	25	has	have	VBZ
8691	321	26	both	both	CC
8691	321	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	321	28	and	and	CC
8691	321	29	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	321	30	functions	function	NNS
8691	321	31	.	.	.
8691	321	32	]	]	-RRB-
8691	322	1	The	the	DT
8691	322	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	322	3	of	of	IN
8691	322	4	the	the	DT
8691	322	5	United	United	NNP
8691	322	6	States	States	NNP
8691	322	7	recognizes	recognize	VBZ
8691	322	8	this	this	DT
8691	322	9	in	in	IN
8691	322	10	effect	effect	NN
8691	322	11	.	.	.
8691	323	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	323	2	makes	make	VBZ
8691	323	3	the	the	DT
8691	323	4	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	323	5	an	an	DT
8691	323	6	executive	executive	JJ
8691	323	7	council	council	NN
8691	323	8	,	,	,
8691	323	9	as	as	RB
8691	323	10	well	well	RB
8691	323	11	as	as	IN
8691	323	12	a	a	DT
8691	323	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	323	14	chamber	chamber	NN
8691	323	15	.	.	.
8691	324	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	324	2	allows	allow	VBZ
8691	324	3	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	324	4	to	to	TO
8691	324	5	vest	vest	VB
8691	324	6	the	the	DT
8691	324	7	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	324	8	of	of	IN
8691	324	9	any	any	DT
8691	324	10	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	324	11	officers	officer	NNS
8691	324	12	in	in	IN
8691	324	13	the	the	DT
8691	324	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	324	15	(	(	-LRB-
8691	324	16	Art	art	NN
8691	324	17	.	.	.
8691	325	1	II	II	NNP
8691	325	2	,	,	,
8691	325	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	325	4	.	.	.
8691	326	1	3	3	LS
8691	326	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	326	3	.	.	.
8691	327	1	In	in	IN
8691	327	2	practice	practice	NN
8691	327	3	this	this	DT
8691	327	4	power	power	NN
8691	327	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	327	6	been	be	VBN
8691	327	7	freely	freely	RB
8691	327	8	used	use	VBN
8691	327	9	.	.	.
8691	328	1	The	the	DT
8691	328	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	328	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	328	4	of	of	IN
8691	328	5	the	the	DT
8691	328	6	United	United	NNP
8691	328	7	States	States	NNP
8691	328	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	328	9	had	have	VBN
8691	328	10	occasion	occasion	NN
8691	328	11	to	to	TO
8691	328	12	consider	consider	VB
8691	328	13	this	this	DT
8691	328	14	question	question	NN
8691	328	15	in	in	IN
8691	328	16	connection	connection	NN
8691	328	17	with	with	IN
8691	328	18	the	the	DT
8691	328	19	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	328	20	defining	define	VBG
8691	328	21	the	the	DT
8691	328	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	328	23	of	of	IN
8691	328	24	the	the	DT
8691	328	25	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	328	26	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	328	27	.	.	.
8691	329	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	329	2	extends	extend	VBZ
8691	329	3	to	to	IN
8691	329	4	certain	certain	JJ
8691	329	5	"	"	``
8691	329	6	suits	suit	NNS
8691	329	7	.	.	.
8691	329	8	"	"	''
8691	330	1	But	but	CC
8691	330	2	what	what	WP
8691	330	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	330	4	a	a	DT
8691	330	5	suit	suit	NN
8691	330	6	?	?	.
8691	331	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	331	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	331	3	not	not	RB
8691	331	4	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	331	5	a	a	DT
8691	331	6	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	331	7	at	at	IN
8691	331	8	common	common	JJ
8691	331	9	law	law	NN
8691	331	10	or	or	CC
8691	331	11	in	in	IN
8691	331	12	equity	equity	NN
8691	331	13	or	or	CC
8691	331	14	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	331	15	.	.	.
8691	332	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	332	2	may	may	MD
8691	332	3	be	be	VB
8691	332	4	a	a	DT
8691	332	5	statutory	statutory	JJ
8691	332	6	process	process	NN
8691	332	7	.	.	.
8691	333	1	"	"	``
8691	333	2	Even	even	RB
8691	333	3	,	,	,
8691	333	4	"	"	''
8691	333	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	333	6	say	say	VBP
8691	333	7	,	,	,
8691	333	8	"	"	''
8691	333	9	an	an	DT
8691	333	10	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	333	11	from	from	IN
8691	333	12	an	an	DT
8691	333	13	assessment	assessment	NN
8691	333	14	,	,	,
8691	333	15	if	if	IN
8691	333	16	referred	refer	VBN
8691	333	17	to	to	IN
8691	333	18	a	a	DT
8691	333	19	court	court	NN
8691	333	20	and	and	CC
8691	333	21	jury	jury	NN
8691	333	22	,	,	,
8691	333	23	or	or	CC
8691	333	24	merely	merely	RB
8691	333	25	to	to	IN
8691	333	26	a	a	DT
8691	333	27	court	court	NN
8691	333	28	,	,	,
8691	333	29	to	to	TO
8691	333	30	be	be	VB
8691	333	31	proceeded	proceed	VBN
8691	333	32	in	in	IN
8691	333	33	according	accord	VBG
8691	333	34	to	to	IN
8691	333	35	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	333	36	methods	method	NNS
8691	333	37	,	,	,
8691	333	38	may	may	MD
8691	333	39	become	become	VB
8691	333	40	a	a	DT
8691	333	41	suit	suit	NN
8691	333	42	within	within	IN
8691	333	43	the	the	DT
8691	333	44	act	act	NN
8691	333	45	of	of	IN
8691	333	46	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	333	47	.	.	.
8691	334	1	"	"	``
8691	334	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	334	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	334	4	:	:	:
8691	334	5	Upshur	Upshur	NNP
8691	334	6	County	County	NNP
8691	334	7	_	_	NNP
8691	334	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	334	9	_	_	NNP
8691	334	10	Rich	Rich	NNP
8691	334	11	,	,	,
8691	334	12	135	135	CD
8691	334	13	U.	U.	NNP
8691	334	14	S.	S.	NNP
8691	334	15	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	334	16	,	,	,
8691	334	17	467	467	CD
8691	334	18	,	,	,
8691	334	19	473	473	CD
8691	334	20	.	.	.
8691	334	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	335	1	So	so	RB
8691	335	2	in	in	IN
8691	335	3	regard	regard	NN
8691	335	4	to	to	IN
8691	335	5	a	a	DT
8691	335	6	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	335	7	by	by	IN
8691	335	8	the	the	DT
8691	335	9	government	government	NN
8691	335	10	to	to	TO
8691	335	11	take	take	VB
8691	335	12	land	land	NN
8691	335	13	for	for	IN
8691	335	14	public	public	JJ
8691	335	15	use	use	NN
8691	335	16	on	on	IN
8691	335	17	payment	payment	NN
8691	335	18	of	of	IN
8691	335	19	due	due	JJ
8691	335	20	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	335	21	,	,	,
8691	335	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	335	23	observe	observe	VBP
8691	335	24	that	that	IN
8691	335	25	"	"	``
8691	335	26	the	the	DT
8691	335	27	general	general	JJ
8691	335	28	rule	rule	NN
8691	335	29	with	with	IN
8691	335	30	regard	regard	NN
8691	335	31	to	to	IN
8691	335	32	cases	case	NNS
8691	335	33	of	of	IN
8691	335	34	this	this	DT
8691	335	35	sort	sort	NN
8691	335	36	is	be	VBZ
8691	335	37	,	,	,
8691	335	38	that	that	IN
8691	335	39	the	the	DT
8691	335	40	initial	initial	JJ
8691	335	41	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	335	42	of	of	IN
8691	335	43	appraisement	appraisement	NN
8691	335	44	by	by	IN
8691	335	45	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
8691	335	46	is	be	VBZ
8691	335	47	an	an	DT
8691	335	48	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	335	49	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	335	50	,	,	,
8691	335	51	and	and	CC
8691	335	52	not	not	RB
8691	335	53	a	a	DT
8691	335	54	suit	suit	NN
8691	335	55	;	;	:
8691	335	56	but	but	CC
8691	335	57	that	that	IN
8691	335	58	if	if	IN
8691	335	59	an	an	DT
8691	335	60	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	335	61	is	be	VBZ
8691	335	62	taken	take	VBN
8691	335	63	to	to	IN
8691	335	64	a	a	DT
8691	335	65	court	court	NN
8691	335	66	,	,	,
8691	335	67	and	and	CC
8691	335	68	a	a	DT
8691	335	69	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	335	70	is	be	VBZ
8691	335	71	there	there	RB
8691	335	72	instituted	institute	VBN
8691	335	73	between	between	IN
8691	335	74	parties	party	NNS
8691	335	75	,	,	,
8691	335	76	then	then	RB
8691	335	77	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	335	78	becomes	become	VBZ
8691	335	79	a	a	DT
8691	335	80	suit	suit	NN
8691	335	81	within	within	IN
8691	335	82	the	the	DT
8691	335	83	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	335	84	of	of	IN
8691	335	85	this	this	DT
8691	335	86	act	act	NN
8691	335	87	of	of	IN
8691	335	88	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	335	89	.	.	.
8691	336	1	"	"	``
8691	336	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	336	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	336	4	:	:	:
8691	336	5	_	_	NNP
8691	336	6	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
8691	336	7	_	_	NNP
8691	336	8	.	.	NNP
8691	336	9	,	,	,
8691	336	10	475	475	CD
8691	336	11	.	.	.
8691	336	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	337	1	In	in	IN
8691	337	2	one	one	CD
8691	337	3	point	point	NN
8691	337	4	of	of	IN
8691	337	5	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	337	6	importance	importance	NN
8691	337	7	express	express	VBP
8691	337	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	337	9	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	337	10	generally	generally	RB
8691	337	11	narrow	narrow	VBP
8691	337	12	the	the	DT
8691	337	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	337	14	of	of	IN
8691	337	15	American	American	NNP
8691	337	16	,	,	,
8691	337	17	as	as	IN
8691	337	18	compared	compare	VBN
8691	337	19	with	with	IN
8691	337	20	English	english	JJ
8691	337	21	courts	court	NNS
8691	337	22	.	.	.
8691	338	1	Each	each	DT
8691	338	2	house	house	NN
8691	338	3	of	of	IN
8691	338	4	the	the	DT
8691	338	5	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	338	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	338	7	made	make	VBN
8691	338	8	the	the	DT
8691	338	9	final	final	JJ
8691	338	10	judge	judge	NN
8691	338	11	of	of	IN
8691	338	12	the	the	DT
8691	338	13	returns	return	NNS
8691	338	14	and	and	CC
8691	338	15	qualifications	qualification	NNS
8691	338	16	of	of	IN
8691	338	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	338	18	members	member	NNS
8691	338	19	.	.	.
8691	339	1	In	in	IN
8691	339	2	England	England	NNP
8691	339	3	,	,	,
8691	339	4	election	election	NN
8691	339	5	contests	contest	NNS
8691	339	6	as	as	IN
8691	339	7	to	to	IN
8691	339	8	a	a	DT
8691	339	9	seat	seat	NN
8691	339	10	in	in	IN
8691	339	11	the	the	DT
8691	339	12	House	House	NNP
8691	339	13	of	of	IN
8691	339	14	Commons	Commons	NNP
8691	339	15	has	have	VBZ
8691	339	16	been	be	VBN
8691	339	17	made	make	VBN
8691	339	18	by	by	IN
8691	339	19	Act	Act	NNP
8691	339	20	of	of	IN
8691	339	21	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
8691	339	22	the	the	DT
8691	339	23	subject	subject	NN
8691	339	24	of	of	IN
8691	339	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	339	26	determination	determination	NN
8691	339	27	.	.	.
8691	340	1	This	this	DT
8691	340	2	avoids	avoid	VBZ
8691	340	3	partizan	partizan	NN
8691	340	4	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	340	5	and	and	CC
8691	340	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	340	7	so	so	RB
8691	340	8	far	far	RB
8691	340	9	good	good	JJ
8691	340	10	.	.	.
8691	341	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	341	2	diminishes	diminish	VBZ
8691	341	3	,	,	,
8691	341	4	however	however	RB
8691	341	5	,	,	,
8691	341	6	the	the	DT
8691	341	7	independence	independence	NN
8691	341	8	of	of	IN
8691	341	9	the	the	DT
8691	341	10	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	341	11	house	house	NN
8691	341	12	in	in	IN
8691	341	13	which	which	WDT
8691	341	14	the	the	DT
8691	341	15	seat	seat	NN
8691	341	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	341	17	contested	contest	VBN
8691	341	18	.	.	.
8691	342	1	This	this	DT
8691	342	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	342	3	jealously	jealously	RB
8691	342	4	guarded	guard	VBN
8691	342	5	by	by	IN
8691	342	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	342	7	traditions	tradition	NNS
8691	342	8	as	as	RB
8691	342	9	well	well	RB
8691	342	10	as	as	IN
8691	342	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	342	12	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	342	13	.	.	.
8691	343	1	The	the	DT
8691	343	2	practice	practice	NN
8691	343	3	of	of	IN
8691	343	4	wearing	wear	VBG
8691	343	5	hats	hat	NNS
8691	343	6	during	during	IN
8691	343	7	the	the	DT
8691	343	8	sessions	session	NNS
8691	343	9	of	of	IN
8691	343	10	the	the	DT
8691	343	11	House	House	NNP
8691	343	12	of	of	IN
8691	343	13	Commons	Commons	NNP
8691	343	14	was	be	VBD
8691	343	15	an	an	DT
8691	343	16	expression	expression	NN
8691	343	17	of	of	IN
8691	343	18	the	the	DT
8691	343	19	early	early	JJ
8691	343	20	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	343	21	of	of	IN
8691	343	22	the	the	DT
8691	343	23	English	English	NNP
8691	343	24	Commons	Commons	NNP
8691	343	25	on	on	IN
8691	343	26	this	this	DT
8691	343	27	subject	subject	NN
8691	343	28	.	.	.
8691	344	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	344	2	would	would	MD
8691	344	3	not	not	RB
8691	344	4	uncover	uncover	VB
8691	344	5	before	before	IN
8691	344	6	speaker	speaker	NN
8691	344	7	or	or	CC
8691	344	8	king	king	NN
8691	344	9	.	.	.
8691	345	1	In	in	IN
8691	345	2	some	some	DT
8691	345	3	of	of	IN
8691	345	4	the	the	DT
8691	345	5	early	early	JJ
8691	345	6	American	american	JJ
8691	345	7	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	345	8	the	the	DT
8691	345	9	same	same	JJ
8691	345	10	thing	thing	NN
8691	345	11	was	be	VBD
8691	345	12	done	do	VBN
8691	345	13	.	.	.
8691	346	1	Hats	hat	NNS
8691	346	2	were	be	VBD
8691	346	3	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	346	4	worn	wear	VBN
8691	346	5	in	in	IN
8691	346	6	the	the	DT
8691	346	7	House	House	NNP
8691	346	8	of	of	IN
8691	346	9	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
8691	346	10	at	at	IN
8691	346	11	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	346	12	as	as	RB
8691	346	13	late	late	RB
8691	346	14	as	as	IN
8691	346	15	the	the	DT
8691	346	16	second	second	JJ
8691	346	17	quarter	quarter	NN
8691	346	18	of	of	IN
8691	346	19	the	the	DT
8691	346	20	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	346	21	century	century	NN
8691	346	22	.	.	.
8691	347	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	347	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	347	3	:	:	:
8691	347	4	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
8691	347	5	,	,	,
8691	347	6	"	"	''
8691	347	7	Life	Life	NNP
8691	347	8	of	of	IN
8691	347	9	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	347	10	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
8691	347	11	,	,	,
8691	347	12	"	"	``
8691	347	13	301	301	CD
8691	347	14	.	.	.
8691	348	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	348	2	were	be	VBD
8691	348	3	worn	wear	VBN
8691	348	4	in	in	IN
8691	348	5	the	the	DT
8691	348	6	Continental	Continental	NNP
8691	348	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	348	8	on	on	IN
8691	348	9	occasions	occasion	NNS
8691	348	10	of	of	IN
8691	348	11	ceremony	ceremony	NN
8691	348	12	.	.	.
8691	349	1	McMaster	McMaster	NNP
8691	349	2	,	,	,
8691	349	3	"	"	``
8691	349	4	History	history	NN
8691	349	5	of	of	IN
8691	349	6	the	the	DT
8691	349	7	People	People	NNS
8691	349	8	of	of	IN
8691	349	9	the	the	DT
8691	349	10	United	United	NNP
8691	349	11	States	States	NNP
8691	349	12	,	,	,
8691	349	13	"	"	``
8691	349	14	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	349	15	,	,	,
8691	349	16	105	105	CD
8691	349	17	.	.	.
8691	349	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	350	1	On	on	IN
8691	350	2	the	the	DT
8691	350	3	other	other	JJ
8691	350	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	350	5	,	,	,
8691	350	6	American	american	JJ
8691	350	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	350	8	interfere	interfere	VBP
8691	350	9	more	more	RBR
8691	350	10	readily	readily	RB
8691	350	11	than	than	IN
8691	350	12	the	the	DT
8691	350	13	English	English	NNP
8691	350	14	to	to	TO
8691	350	15	protect	protect	VB
8691	350	16	a	a	DT
8691	350	17	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	350	18	from	from	IN
8691	350	19	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	350	20	by	by	IN
8691	350	21	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	350	22	authority	authority	NN
8691	350	23	.	.	.
8691	351	1	Each	each	DT
8691	351	2	house	house	NN
8691	351	3	of	of	IN
8691	351	4	the	the	DT
8691	351	5	British	british	JJ
8691	351	6	parliament	parliament	NN
8691	351	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	351	8	large	large	JJ
8691	351	9	inherited	inherit	VBN
8691	351	10	powers	power	NNS
8691	351	11	over	over	IN
8691	351	12	those	those	DT
8691	351	13	who	who	WP
8691	351	14	may	may	MD
8691	351	15	treat	treat	VB
8691	351	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	351	17	with	with	IN
8691	351	18	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	351	19	.	.	.
8691	352	1	Each	each	DT
8691	352	2	house	house	NN
8691	352	3	of	of	IN
8691	352	4	an	an	DT
8691	352	5	American	american	JJ
8691	352	6	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	352	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	352	8	some	some	DT
8691	352	9	powers	power	NNS
8691	352	10	of	of	IN
8691	352	11	this	this	DT
8691	352	12	description	description	NN
8691	352	13	,	,	,
8691	352	14	but	but	CC
8691	352	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	352	16	are	be	VBP
8691	352	17	far	far	RB
8691	352	18	narrower	narrow	JJR
8691	352	19	ones	one	NNS
8691	352	20	.	.	.
8691	353	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	353	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	353	3	:	:	:
8691	353	4	Kilbourn	Kilbourn	NNP
8691	353	5	_	_	NNP
8691	353	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	353	7	_	_	NNP
8691	353	8	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
8691	353	9	,	,	,
8691	353	10	103	103	CD
8691	353	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	353	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	353	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	353	14	,	,	,
8691	353	15	168	168	CD
8691	353	16	.	.	.
8691	353	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	354	1	*	*	NFP
8691	354	2	*	*	NFP
8691	354	3	*	*	NFP
8691	354	4	*	*	NFP
8691	354	5	*	*	NFP
8691	354	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	354	7	III	iii	CD
8691	354	8	THE	the	DT
8691	354	9	RELATIONS	relations	NN
8691	354	10	OF	of	IN
8691	354	11	THE	the	DT
8691	354	12	JUDICIARY	judiciary	NN
8691	354	13	TO	to	IN
8691	354	14	THE	the	DT
8691	354	15	POLITICAL	political	JJ
8691	354	16	DEPARTMENTS	department	NNS
8691	354	17	OF	of	IN
8691	354	18	GOVERNMENT	GOVERNMENT	NNP
8691	354	19	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	354	20	of	of	IN
8691	354	21	Claims	Claims	NNPS
8691	354	22	are	be	VBP
8691	354	23	the	the	DT
8691	354	24	only	only	JJ
8691	354	25	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	354	26	special	special	JJ
8691	354	27	courts	court	NNS
8691	354	28	for	for	IN
8691	354	29	the	the	DT
8691	354	30	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	354	31	of	of	IN
8691	354	32	causes	cause	NNS
8691	354	33	arising	arise	VBG
8691	354	34	from	from	IN
8691	354	35	the	the	DT
8691	354	36	acts	act	NNS
8691	354	37	of	of	IN
8691	354	38	public	public	JJ
8691	354	39	officials	official	NNS
8691	354	40	.	.	.
8691	355	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	355	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	355	3	:	:	:
8691	355	4	One	one	PRP
8691	355	5	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	355	6	for	for	IN
8691	355	7	the	the	DT
8691	355	8	United	United	NNP
8691	355	9	States	States	NNP
8691	355	10	;	;	:
8691	355	11	and	and	CC
8691	355	12	one	one	CD
8691	355	13	for	for	IN
8691	355	14	New	New	NNP
8691	355	15	York	York	NNP
8691	355	16	.	.	.
8691	355	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	356	1	The	the	DT
8691	356	2	system	system	NN
8691	356	3	of	of	IN
8691	356	4	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	356	5	law	law	NN
8691	356	6	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	356	7	on	on	IN
8691	356	8	the	the	DT
8691	356	9	Continent	Continent	NNP
8691	356	10	of	of	IN
8691	356	11	Europe	Europe	NNP
8691	356	12	,	,	,
8691	356	13	by	by	IN
8691	356	14	which	which	WDT
8691	356	15	all	all	DT
8691	356	16	such	such	JJ
8691	356	17	matters	matter	NNS
8691	356	18	are	be	VBP
8691	356	19	withheld	withhold	VBN
8691	356	20	from	from	IN
8691	356	21	the	the	DT
8691	356	22	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	356	23	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	356	24	,	,	,
8691	356	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	356	26	totally	totally	RB
8691	356	27	unknown	unknown	JJ
8691	356	28	here	here	RB
8691	356	29	.	.	.
8691	357	1	If	if	IN
8691	357	2	the	the	DT
8691	357	3	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
8691	357	4	of	of	IN
8691	357	5	War	War	NNP
8691	357	6	of	of	IN
8691	357	7	the	the	DT
8691	357	8	United	United	NNP
8691	357	9	States	States	NNP
8691	357	10	should	should	MD
8691	357	11	do	do	VB
8691	357	12	some	some	DT
8691	357	13	act	act	NN
8691	357	14	to	to	IN
8691	357	15	a	a	DT
8691	357	16	private	private	JJ
8691	357	17	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	357	18	,	,	,
8691	357	19	which	which	WDT
8691	357	20	may	may	MD
8691	357	21	be	be	VB
8691	357	22	justified	justify	VBN
8691	357	23	by	by	IN
8691	357	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	357	25	official	official	JJ
8691	357	26	powers	power	NNS
8691	357	27	,	,	,
8691	357	28	but	but	CC
8691	357	29	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	357	30	would	would	MD
8691	357	31	not	not	RB
8691	357	32	be	be	VB
8691	357	33	,	,	,
8691	357	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	357	35	may	may	MD
8691	357	36	be	be	VB
8691	357	37	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	357	38	to	to	TO
8691	357	39	answer	answer	VB
8691	357	40	for	for	IN
8691	357	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	357	42	before	before	IN
8691	357	43	any	any	DT
8691	357	44	civil	civil	JJ
8691	357	45	court	court	NN
8691	357	46	having	have	VBG
8691	357	47	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	357	48	of	of	IN
8691	357	49	the	the	DT
8691	357	50	parties	party	NNS
8691	357	51	.	.	.
8691	358	1	So	so	CC
8691	358	2	may	may	MD
8691	358	3	even	even	RB
8691	358	4	the	the	DT
8691	358	5	President	President	NNP
8691	358	6	of	of	IN
8691	358	7	the	the	DT
8691	358	8	United	United	NNP
8691	358	9	States	States	NNP
8691	358	10	be	be	VB
8691	358	11	sued	sue	VBN
8691	358	12	after	after	IN
8691	358	13	the	the	DT
8691	358	14	expiration	expiration	NN
8691	358	15	of	of	IN
8691	358	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	358	17	term	term	NN
8691	358	18	.	.	.
8691	359	1	The	the	DT
8691	359	2	President	President	NNP
8691	359	3	,	,	,
8691	359	4	while	while	IN
8691	359	5	President	President	NNP
8691	359	6	,	,	,
8691	359	7	however	however	RB
8691	359	8	,	,	,
8691	359	9	can	can	MD
8691	359	10	not	not	RB
8691	359	11	be	be	VB
8691	359	12	compelled	compel	VBN
8691	359	13	to	to	TO
8691	359	14	obey	obey	VB
8691	359	15	a	a	DT
8691	359	16	summons	summon	NNS
8691	359	17	to	to	TO
8691	359	18	appear	appear	VB
8691	359	19	in	in	IN
8691	359	20	court	court	NN
8691	359	21	.	.	.
8691	360	1	The	the	DT
8691	360	2	country	country	NN
8691	360	3	can	can	MD
8691	360	4	not	not	RB
8691	360	5	spare	spare	VB
8691	360	6	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	360	7	to	to	TO
8691	360	8	go	go	VB
8691	360	9	here	here	RB
8691	360	10	and	and	CC
8691	360	11	there	there	RB
8691	360	12	in	in	IN
8691	360	13	obedience	obedience	NN
8691	360	14	to	to	IN
8691	360	15	a	a	DT
8691	360	16	writ	writ	NN
8691	360	17	.	.	.
8691	361	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	361	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	361	3	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	361	4	issued	issue	VBD
8691	361	5	one	one	CD
8691	361	6	against	against	IN
8691	361	7	President	President	NNP
8691	361	8	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	361	9	,	,	,
8691	361	10	directing	direct	VBG
8691	361	11	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	361	12	to	to	TO
8691	361	13	appear	appear	VB
8691	361	14	at	at	IN
8691	361	15	the	the	DT
8691	361	16	trial	trial	NN
8691	361	17	of	of	IN
8691	361	18	Aaron	Aaron	NNP
8691	361	19	Burr	Burr	NNP
8691	361	20	and	and	CC
8691	361	21	bring	bring	VB
8691	361	22	with	with	IN
8691	361	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	361	24	a	a	DT
8691	361	25	certain	certain	JJ
8691	361	26	paper	paper	NN
8691	361	27	.	.	.
8691	362	1	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	362	2	declined	decline	VBD
8691	362	3	to	to	TO
8691	362	4	obey	obey	VB
8691	362	5	,	,	,
8691	362	6	and	and	CC
8691	362	7	there	there	EX
8691	362	8	was	be	VBD
8691	362	9	no	no	DT
8691	362	10	attempt	attempt	NN
8691	362	11	to	to	TO
8691	362	12	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	362	13	the	the	DT
8691	362	14	subpoena	subpoena	NN
8691	362	15	.	.	.
8691	363	1	Had	have	VBD
8691	363	2	there	there	EX
8691	363	3	been	be	VBN
8691	363	4	,	,	,
8691	363	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	363	6	would	would	MD
8691	363	7	have	have	VB
8691	363	8	been	be	VBN
8691	363	9	found	find	VBN
8691	363	10	that	that	IN
8691	363	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	363	12	had	have	VBD
8691	363	13	taken	take	VBN
8691	363	14	measures	measure	NNS
8691	363	15	for	for	IN
8691	363	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	363	17	protection	protection	NN
8691	363	18	.	.	.
8691	364	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	364	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	364	3	:	:	:
8691	364	4	Thayer	Thayer	NNP
8691	364	5	,	,	,
8691	364	6	"	"	''
8691	364	7	John	John	NNP
8691	364	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	364	9	,	,	,
8691	364	10	"	"	''
8691	364	11	79	79	CD
8691	364	12	.	.	.
8691	364	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	365	1	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	365	2	's	's	POS
8691	365	3	action	action	NN
8691	365	4	was	be	VBD
8691	365	5	based	base	VBN
8691	365	6	on	on	IN
8691	365	7	an	an	DT
8691	365	8	admission	admission	NN
8691	365	9	by	by	IN
8691	365	10	the	the	DT
8691	365	11	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	365	12	for	for	IN
8691	365	13	the	the	DT
8691	365	14	government	government	NN
8691	365	15	that	that	WDT
8691	365	16	a	a	DT
8691	365	17	summons	summon	NNS
8691	365	18	to	to	TO
8691	365	19	testify	testify	VB
8691	365	20	could	could	MD
8691	365	21	lawfully	lawfully	RB
8691	365	22	issue	issue	VB
8691	365	23	,	,	,
8691	365	24	though	though	IN
8691	365	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	365	26	denied	deny	VBD
8691	365	27	that	that	IN
8691	365	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	365	29	could	could	MD
8691	365	30	be	be	VB
8691	365	31	accompanied	accompany	VBN
8691	365	32	by	by	IN
8691	365	33	a	a	DT
8691	365	34	direction	direction	NN
8691	365	35	to	to	TO
8691	365	36	produce	produce	VB
8691	365	37	documents	document	NNS
8691	365	38	.	.	.
8691	366	1	This	this	DT
8691	366	2	admission	admission	NN
8691	366	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	366	4	now	now	RB
8691	366	5	generally	generally	RB
8691	366	6	thought	think	VBN
8691	366	7	by	by	IN
8691	366	8	the	the	DT
8691	366	9	legal	legal	JJ
8691	366	10	profession	profession	NN
8691	366	11	to	to	TO
8691	366	12	have	have	VB
8691	366	13	been	be	VBN
8691	366	14	ill	ill	RB
8691	366	15	-	-	HYPH
8691	366	16	advised	advise	VBN
8691	366	17	.	.	.
8691	367	1	If	if	IN
8691	367	2	the	the	DT
8691	367	3	President	President	NNP
8691	367	4	could	could	MD
8691	367	5	be	be	VB
8691	367	6	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	367	7	at	at	RB
8691	367	8	all	all	RB
8691	367	9	,	,	,
8691	367	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	367	11	could	could	MD
8691	367	12	be	be	VB
8691	367	13	compelled	compel	VBN
8691	367	14	to	to	TO
8691	367	15	obey	obey	VB
8691	367	16	the	the	DT
8691	367	17	summons	summon	NNS
8691	367	18	,	,	,
8691	367	19	and	and	CC
8691	367	20	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	367	21	could	could	MD
8691	367	22	be	be	VB
8691	367	23	more	more	RBR
8691	367	24	unseemly	unseemly	JJ
8691	367	25	or	or	CC
8691	367	26	inadmissible	inadmissible	JJ
8691	367	27	than	than	IN
8691	367	28	an	an	DT
8691	367	29	attempt	attempt	NN
8691	367	30	of	of	IN
8691	367	31	that	that	DT
8691	367	32	nature	nature	NN
8691	367	33	by	by	IN
8691	367	34	the	the	DT
8691	367	35	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	367	36	against	against	IN
8691	367	37	the	the	DT
8691	367	38	executive	executive	JJ
8691	367	39	power	power	NN
8691	367	40	of	of	IN
8691	367	41	the	the	DT
8691	367	42	United	United	NNP
8691	367	43	States	States	NNP
8691	367	44	.	.	.
8691	368	1	But	but	CC
8691	368	2	while	while	IN
8691	368	3	there	there	EX
8691	368	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	368	5	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	368	6	like	like	IN
8691	368	7	an	an	DT
8691	368	8	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	368	9	court	court	NN
8691	368	10	for	for	IN
8691	368	11	the	the	DT
8691	368	12	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	368	13	of	of	IN
8691	368	14	causes	cause	NNS
8691	368	15	against	against	IN
8691	368	16	individuals	individual	NNS
8691	368	17	in	in	IN
8691	368	18	the	the	DT
8691	368	19	United	United	NNP
8691	368	20	States	States	NNP
8691	368	21	,	,	,
8691	368	22	considered	consider	VBN
8691	368	23	as	as	IN
8691	368	24	a	a	DT
8691	368	25	collection	collection	NN
8691	368	26	of	of	IN
8691	368	27	States	States	NNP
8691	368	28	or	or	CC
8691	368	29	of	of	IN
8691	368	30	people	people	NNS
8691	368	31	within	within	IN
8691	368	32	those	those	DT
8691	368	33	States	state	NNS
8691	368	34	,	,	,
8691	368	35	more	more	JJR
8691	368	36	freedom	freedom	NN
8691	368	37	has	have	VBZ
8691	368	38	been	be	VBN
8691	368	39	used	use	VBN
8691	368	40	by	by	IN
8691	368	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	368	42	in	in	IN
8691	368	43	providing	provide	VBG
8691	368	44	for	for	IN
8691	368	45	the	the	DT
8691	368	46	Territories	Territories	NNPS
8691	368	47	.	.	.
8691	369	1	This	this	DT
8691	369	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	369	3	been	be	VBN
8691	369	4	conspicuously	conspicuously	RB
8691	369	5	the	the	DT
8691	369	6	case	case	NN
8691	369	7	in	in	IN
8691	369	8	regard	regard	NN
8691	369	9	to	to	IN
8691	369	10	the	the	DT
8691	369	11	Philippines	Philippines	NNP
8691	369	12	.	.	.
8691	370	1	By	by	IN
8691	370	2	the	the	DT
8691	370	3	Act	Act	NNP
8691	370	4	of	of	IN
8691	370	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	370	6	of	of	IN
8691	370	7	July	July	NNP
8691	370	8	1	1	CD
8691	370	9	,	,	,
8691	370	10	1902	1902	CD
8691	370	11	,	,	,
8691	370	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	370	13	were	be	VBD
8691	370	14	left	leave	VBN
8691	370	15	under	under	IN
8691	370	16	the	the	DT
8691	370	17	supervision	supervision	NN
8691	370	18	of	of	IN
8691	370	19	the	the	DT
8691	370	20	War	War	NNP
8691	370	21	Department	Department	NNP
8691	370	22	,	,	,
8691	370	23	in	in	IN
8691	370	24	which	which	WDT
8691	370	25	there	there	EX
8691	370	26	was	be	VBD
8691	370	27	constituted	constitute	VBN
8691	370	28	a	a	DT
8691	370	29	"	"	``
8691	370	30	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
8691	370	31	of	of	IN
8691	370	32	Insular	Insular	NNP
8691	370	33	Affairs	Affairs	NNPS
8691	370	34	,	,	,
8691	370	35	"	"	''
8691	370	36	the	the	DT
8691	370	37	business	business	NN
8691	370	38	assigned	assign	VBN
8691	370	39	to	to	TO
8691	370	40	which	which	WDT
8691	370	41	"	"	``
8691	370	42	shall	shall	MD
8691	370	43	embrace	embrace	VB
8691	370	44	all	all	DT
8691	370	45	matters	matter	NNS
8691	370	46	pertaining	pertain	VBG
8691	370	47	to	to	IN
8691	370	48	civil	civil	JJ
8691	370	49	government	government	NN
8691	370	50	in	in	IN
8691	370	51	the	the	DT
8691	370	52	island	island	NN
8691	370	53	possessions	possession	NNS
8691	370	54	of	of	IN
8691	370	55	the	the	DT
8691	370	56	United	United	NNP
8691	370	57	States	States	NNP
8691	370	58	subject	subject	JJ
8691	370	59	to	to	IN
8691	370	60	the	the	DT
8691	370	61	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	370	62	of	of	IN
8691	370	63	the	the	DT
8691	370	64	War	War	NNP
8691	370	65	Department	Department	NNP
8691	370	66	;	;	:
8691	370	67	and	and	CC
8691	370	68	the	the	DT
8691	370	69	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
8691	370	70	of	of	IN
8691	370	71	War	War	NNP
8691	370	72	is	be	VBZ
8691	370	73	hereby	hereby	NNP
8691	370	74	authorized	authorize	VBN
8691	370	75	to	to	TO
8691	370	76	detail	detail	VB
8691	370	77	an	an	DT
8691	370	78	officer	officer	NN
8691	370	79	of	of	IN
8691	370	80	the	the	DT
8691	370	81	army	army	NN
8691	370	82	whom	whom	WP
8691	370	83	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	370	84	may	may	MD
8691	370	85	consider	consider	VB
8691	370	86	especially	especially	RB
8691	370	87	well	well	RB
8691	370	88	qualified	qualified	JJ
8691	370	89	to	to	TO
8691	370	90	act	act	VB
8691	370	91	under	under	IN
8691	370	92	the	the	DT
8691	370	93	authority	authority	NN
8691	370	94	of	of	IN
8691	370	95	the	the	DT
8691	370	96	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
8691	370	97	of	of	IN
8691	370	98	War	War	NNP
8691	370	99	as	as	IN
8691	370	100	the	the	DT
8691	370	101	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	370	102	of	of	IN
8691	370	103	said	say	VBD
8691	370	104	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
8691	370	105	.	.	.
8691	370	106	"	"	''
8691	371	1	The	the	DT
8691	371	2	officer	officer	NN
8691	371	3	filling	fill	VBG
8691	371	4	the	the	DT
8691	371	5	position	position	NN
8691	371	6	of	of	IN
8691	371	7	chief	chief	NN
8691	371	8	published	publish	VBN
8691	371	9	in	in	IN
8691	371	10	1904	1904	CD
8691	371	11	this	this	DT
8691	371	12	account	account	NN
8691	371	13	of	of	IN
8691	371	14	the	the	DT
8691	371	15	practical	practical	JJ
8691	371	16	working	working	NN
8691	371	17	of	of	IN
8691	371	18	the	the	DT
8691	371	19	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	371	20	made	make	VBN
8691	371	21	for	for	IN
8691	371	22	the	the	DT
8691	371	23	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	371	24	of	of	IN
8691	371	25	matters	matter	NNS
8691	371	26	of	of	IN
8691	371	27	legal	legal	JJ
8691	371	28	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	371	29	occurring	occur	VBG
8691	371	30	on	on	IN
8691	371	31	the	the	DT
8691	371	32	islands	island	NNS
8691	371	33	:	:	:
8691	371	34	"	"	``
8691	371	35	The	the	DT
8691	371	36	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	371	37	of	of	IN
8691	371	38	a	a	DT
8691	371	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	371	40	system	system	NN
8691	371	41	in	in	IN
8691	371	42	the	the	DT
8691	371	43	Philippines	Philippines	NNP
8691	371	44	affords	afford	VBZ
8691	371	45	a	a	DT
8691	371	46	means	means	NN
8691	371	47	for	for	IN
8691	371	48	the	the	DT
8691	371	49	adjudication	adjudication	NN
8691	371	50	of	of	IN
8691	371	51	litigated	litigate	VBN
8691	371	52	questions	question	NNS
8691	371	53	between	between	IN
8691	371	54	the	the	DT
8691	371	55	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
8691	371	56	and	and	CC
8691	371	57	of	of	IN
8691	371	58	many	many	JJ
8691	371	59	questions	question	NNS
8691	371	60	respecting	respect	VBG
8691	371	61	the	the	DT
8691	371	62	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	371	63	and	and	CC
8691	371	64	authority	authority	NN
8691	371	65	of	of	IN
8691	371	66	officials	official	NNS
8691	371	67	of	of	IN
8691	371	68	that	that	DT
8691	371	69	government	government	NN
8691	371	70	.	.	.
8691	372	1	Whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	372	2	possible	possible	JJ
8691	372	3	,	,	,
8691	372	4	controversies	controversy	NNS
8691	372	5	are	be	VBP
8691	372	6	referred	refer	VBN
8691	372	7	to	to	IN
8691	372	8	those	those	DT
8691	372	9	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	372	10	.	.	.
8691	373	1	In	in	IN
8691	373	2	some	some	DT
8691	373	3	instances	instance	NNS
8691	373	4	questions	question	NNS
8691	373	5	have	have	VBP
8691	373	6	arisen	arise	VBN
8691	373	7	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	373	8	the	the	DT
8691	373	9	action	action	NN
8691	373	10	or	or	CC
8691	373	11	authority	authority	NN
8691	373	12	of	of	IN
8691	373	13	officers	officer	NNS
8691	373	14	of	of	IN
8691	373	15	the	the	DT
8691	373	16	executive	executive	JJ
8691	373	17	department	department	NN
8691	373	18	of	of	IN
8691	373	19	that	that	DT
8691	373	20	government	government	NN
8691	373	21	in	in	IN
8691	373	22	matters	matter	NNS
8691	373	23	controlled	control	VBN
8691	373	24	by	by	IN
8691	373	25	the	the	DT
8691	373	26	discretion	discretion	NN
8691	373	27	of	of	IN
8691	373	28	the	the	DT
8691	373	29	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	373	30	branch	branch	NN
8691	373	31	and	and	CC
8691	373	32	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	373	33	the	the	DT
8691	373	34	administration	administration	NN
8691	373	35	of	of	IN
8691	373	36	civil	civil	JJ
8691	373	37	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	373	38	.	.	.
8691	374	1	These	these	DT
8691	374	2	questions	question	NNS
8691	374	3	are	be	VBP
8691	374	4	considered	consider	VBN
8691	374	5	and	and	CC
8691	374	6	determined	determine	VBN
8691	374	7	by	by	IN
8691	374	8	the	the	DT
8691	374	9	War	War	NNP
8691	374	10	Department	Department	NNP
8691	374	11	,	,	,
8691	374	12	upon	upon	IN
8691	374	13	investigation	investigation	NN
8691	374	14	and	and	CC
8691	374	15	report	report	NN
8691	374	16	by	by	IN
8691	374	17	the	the	DT
8691	374	18	law	law	NN
8691	374	19	officer	officer	NN
8691	374	20	.	.	.
8691	375	1	"	"	``
8691	375	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	375	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	375	4	:	:	:
8691	375	5	_	_	NNP
8691	375	6	National	National	NNP
8691	375	7	Geographic	Geographic	NNP
8691	375	8	Magazine	Magazine	NNP
8691	375	9	_	_	NNP
8691	375	10	for	for	IN
8691	375	11	June	June	NNP
8691	375	12	,	,	,
8691	375	13	1904	1904	CD
8691	375	14	,	,	,
8691	375	15	p.	p.	NN
8691	376	1	251	251	CD
8691	376	2	.	.	.
8691	376	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	377	1	Under	under	IN
8691	377	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	377	3	American	american	JJ
8691	377	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	377	5	system	system	NN
8691	377	6	,	,	,
8691	377	7	the	the	DT
8691	377	8	only	only	JJ
8691	377	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	377	10	of	of	IN
8691	377	11	an	an	DT
8691	377	12	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	377	13	or	or	CC
8691	377	14	political	political	JJ
8691	377	15	nature	nature	NN
8691	377	16	for	for	IN
8691	377	17	calling	call	VBG
8691	377	18	public	public	JJ
8691	377	19	officers	officer	NNS
8691	377	20	directly	directly	RB
8691	377	21	to	to	TO
8691	377	22	account	account	VB
8691	377	23	for	for	IN
8691	377	24	a	a	DT
8691	377	25	breach	breach	NN
8691	377	26	of	of	IN
8691	377	27	public	public	JJ
8691	377	28	duty	duty	NN
8691	377	29	are	be	VBP
8691	377	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	377	31	courts	court	NNS
8691	377	32	of	of	IN
8691	377	33	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	377	34	.	.	.
8691	378	1	These	these	DT
8691	378	2	act	act	VBP
8691	378	3	only	only	RB
8691	378	4	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	378	5	,	,	,
8691	378	6	and	and	CC
8691	378	7	when	when	WRB
8691	378	8	specially	specially	RB
8691	378	9	convened	convene	VBN
8691	378	10	for	for	IN
8691	378	11	the	the	DT
8691	378	12	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	378	13	of	of	IN
8691	378	14	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	378	15	charges	charge	NNS
8691	378	16	against	against	IN
8691	378	17	a	a	DT
8691	378	18	particular	particular	JJ
8691	378	19	individual	individual	NN
8691	378	20	.	.	.
8691	379	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	379	2	do	do	VBP
8691	379	3	not	not	RB
8691	379	4	grant	grant	VB
8691	379	5	relief	relief	NN
8691	379	6	to	to	IN
8691	379	7	any	any	DT
8691	379	8	party	party	NN
8691	379	9	injured	injure	VBN
8691	379	10	by	by	IN
8691	379	11	the	the	DT
8691	379	12	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
8691	379	13	acts	act	NNS
8691	379	14	which	which	WDT
8691	379	15	are	be	VBP
8691	379	16	the	the	DT
8691	379	17	subject	subject	NN
8691	379	18	of	of	IN
8691	379	19	the	the	DT
8691	379	20	accusation	accusation	NN
8691	379	21	.	.	.
8691	380	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	380	2	sit	sit	VBP
8691	380	3	only	only	RB
8691	380	4	to	to	TO
8691	380	5	punish	punish	VB
8691	380	6	the	the	DT
8691	380	7	public	public	JJ
8691	380	8	wrong	wrong	NN
8691	380	9	.	.	.
8691	381	1	In	in	IN
8691	381	2	constituting	constitute	VBG
8691	381	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	381	4	of	of	IN
8691	381	5	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	381	6	,	,	,
8691	381	7	the	the	DT
8691	381	8	control	control	NN
8691	381	9	of	of	IN
8691	381	10	the	the	DT
8691	381	11	cause	cause	NN
8691	381	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	381	13	generally	generally	RB
8691	381	14	given	give	VBN
8691	381	15	to	to	IN
8691	381	16	officers	officer	NNS
8691	381	17	of	of	IN
8691	381	18	the	the	DT
8691	381	19	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	381	20	department	department	NN
8691	381	21	,	,	,
8691	381	22	but	but	CC
8691	381	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	381	24	officers	officer	NNS
8691	381	25	are	be	VBP
8691	381	26	often	often	RB
8691	381	27	joined	join	VBN
8691	381	28	with	with	IN
8691	381	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	381	30	.	.	.
8691	382	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	382	2	a	a	DT
8691	382	3	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	382	4	was	be	VBD
8691	382	5	long	long	RB
8691	382	6	maintained	maintain	VBN
8691	382	7	in	in	IN
8691	382	8	New	New	NNP
8691	382	9	York	York	NNP
8691	382	10	,	,	,
8691	382	11	of	of	IN
8691	382	12	which	which	WDT
8691	382	13	the	the	DT
8691	382	14	senators	senator	NNS
8691	382	15	formed	form	VBD
8691	382	16	the	the	DT
8691	382	17	majority	majority	NN
8691	382	18	,	,	,
8691	382	19	but	but	CC
8691	382	20	in	in	IN
8691	382	21	which	which	WDT
8691	382	22	the	the	DT
8691	382	23	chancellor	chancellor	NN
8691	382	24	and	and	CC
8691	382	25	judges	judge	NNS
8691	382	26	of	of	IN
8691	382	27	the	the	DT
8691	382	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	382	29	Court	Court	NNP
8691	382	30	also	also	RB
8691	382	31	sat	sit	VBD
8691	382	32	.	.	.
8691	383	1	The	the	DT
8691	383	2	first	first	JJ
8691	383	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	383	4	of	of	IN
8691	383	5	South	South	NNP
8691	383	6	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	383	7	,	,	,
8691	383	8	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	383	9	in	in	IN
8691	383	10	1778	1778	CD
8691	383	11	,	,	,
8691	383	12	contained	contain	VBD
8691	383	13	a	a	DT
8691	383	14	similar	similar	JJ
8691	383	15	provision	provision	NN
8691	383	16	(	(	-LRB-
8691	383	17	Art	art	NN
8691	383	18	.	.	.
8691	384	1	XXIII	XXIII	NNP
8691	384	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	384	3	.	.	.
8691	385	1	In	in	IN
8691	385	2	most	most	JJS
8691	385	3	States	state	NNS
8691	385	4	the	the	DT
8691	385	5	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	385	6	alone	alone	RB
8691	385	7	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
8691	385	8	the	the	DT
8691	385	9	court	court	NN
8691	385	10	for	for	IN
8691	385	11	trying	try	VBG
8691	385	12	impeachments	impeachment	NNS
8691	385	13	,	,	,
8691	385	14	but	but	CC
8691	385	15	should	should	MD
8691	385	16	the	the	DT
8691	385	17	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	385	18	be	be	VB
8691	385	19	thus	thus	RB
8691	385	20	brought	bring	VBN
8691	385	21	before	before	IN
8691	385	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	385	23	,	,	,
8691	385	24	the	the	DT
8691	385	25	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	385	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	385	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	385	28	added	add	VBN
8691	385	29	to	to	IN
8691	385	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	385	31	,	,	,
8691	385	32	and	and	CC
8691	385	33	presides	preside	NNS
8691	385	34	.	.	.
8691	386	1	A	a	DT
8691	386	2	similar	similar	JJ
8691	386	3	provision	provision	NN
8691	386	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	386	5	contained	contain	VBN
8691	386	6	in	in	IN
8691	386	7	the	the	DT
8691	386	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	386	9	of	of	IN
8691	386	10	the	the	DT
8691	386	11	United	United	NNP
8691	386	12	States	States	NNP
8691	386	13	as	as	IN
8691	386	14	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	386	15	the	the	DT
8691	386	16	President	President	NNP
8691	386	17	.	.	.
8691	387	1	The	the	DT
8691	387	2	main	main	JJ
8691	387	3	reason	reason	NN
8691	387	4	for	for	IN
8691	387	5	putting	put	VBG
8691	387	6	such	such	PDT
8691	387	7	a	a	DT
8691	387	8	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	387	9	under	under	IN
8691	387	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	387	11	direction	direction	NN
8691	387	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	387	13	to	to	TO
8691	387	14	avoid	avoid	VB
8691	387	15	giving	give	VBG
8691	387	16	the	the	DT
8691	387	17	second	second	JJ
8691	387	18	in	in	IN
8691	387	19	rank	rank	NN
8691	387	20	of	of	IN
8691	387	21	the	the	DT
8691	387	22	executive	executive	JJ
8691	387	23	magistracy	magistracy	NN
8691	387	24	,	,	,
8691	387	25	whose	whose	WP$
8691	387	26	function	function	NN
8691	387	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	387	28	generally	generally	RB
8691	387	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	387	30	to	to	TO
8691	387	31	preside	preside	VB
8691	387	32	over	over	IN
8691	387	33	the	the	DT
8691	387	34	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	387	35	,	,	,
8691	387	36	a	a	DT
8691	387	37	position	position	NN
8691	387	38	of	of	IN
8691	387	39	authority	authority	NN
8691	387	40	over	over	IN
8691	387	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	387	42	chief	chief	NN
8691	387	43	,	,	,
8691	387	44	in	in	IN
8691	387	45	a	a	DT
8691	387	46	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	387	47	which	which	WDT
8691	387	48	,	,	,
8691	387	49	if	if	IN
8691	387	50	successful	successful	JJ
8691	387	51	,	,	,
8691	387	52	would	would	MD
8691	387	53	put	put	VB
8691	387	54	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	387	55	in	in	IN
8691	387	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	387	57	place	place	NN
8691	387	58	.	.	.
8691	388	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	388	2	also	also	RB
8691	388	3	,	,	,
8691	388	4	of	of	IN
8691	388	5	course	course	NN
8691	388	6	,	,	,
8691	388	7	tends	tend	VBZ
8691	388	8	to	to	TO
8691	388	9	promote	promote	VB
8691	388	10	a	a	DT
8691	388	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	388	12	in	in	IN
8691	388	13	accordance	accordance	NN
8691	388	14	with	with	IN
8691	388	15	all	all	PDT
8691	388	16	the	the	DT
8691	388	17	rules	rule	NNS
8691	388	18	of	of	IN
8691	388	19	law	law	NN
8691	388	20	.	.	.
8691	389	1	The	the	DT
8691	389	2	court	court	NN
8691	389	3	in	in	IN
8691	389	4	such	such	PDT
8691	389	5	a	a	DT
8691	389	6	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	389	7	can	can	MD
8691	389	8	not	not	RB
8691	389	9	be	be	VB
8691	389	10	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	389	11	as	as	IN
8691	389	12	fully	fully	RB
8691	389	13	organized	organize	VBN
8691	389	14	until	until	IN
8691	389	15	the	the	DT
8691	389	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	389	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	389	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	389	19	present	present	JJ
8691	389	20	.	.	.
8691	390	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	390	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	390	3	then	then	RB
8691	390	4	first	first	RB
8691	390	5	competent	competent	JJ
8691	390	6	to	to	TO
8691	390	7	prescribe	prescribe	VB
8691	390	8	the	the	DT
8691	390	9	rules	rule	NNS
8691	390	10	to	to	TO
8691	390	11	govern	govern	VB
8691	390	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	390	13	during	during	IN
8691	390	14	the	the	DT
8691	390	15	progress	progress	NN
8691	390	16	of	of	IN
8691	390	17	the	the	DT
8691	390	18	cause	cause	NN
8691	390	19	.	.	.
8691	391	1	This	this	DT
8691	391	2	was	be	VBD
8691	391	3	the	the	DT
8691	391	4	ruling	ruling	NN
8691	391	5	of	of	IN
8691	391	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	391	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	391	8	Chase	Chase	NNP
8691	391	9	on	on	IN
8691	391	10	the	the	DT
8691	391	11	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	391	12	of	of	IN
8691	391	13	President	President	NNP
8691	391	14	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	391	15	,	,	,
8691	391	16	which	which	WDT
8691	391	17	was	be	VBD
8691	391	18	tacitly	tacitly	RB
8691	391	19	acquiesced	acquiesce	VBN
8691	391	20	in	in	IN
8691	391	21	by	by	IN
8691	391	22	the	the	DT
8691	391	23	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	391	24	.	.	.
8691	392	1	New	New	NNP
8691	392	2	York	York	NNP
8691	392	3	originally	originally	RB
8691	392	4	not	not	RB
8691	392	5	only	only	RB
8691	392	6	gave	give	VBD
8691	392	7	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	392	8	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	392	9	a	a	DT
8691	392	10	share	share	NN
8691	392	11	in	in	IN
8691	392	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	392	13	power	power	NN
8691	392	14	,	,	,
8691	392	15	but	but	CC
8691	392	16	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	392	17	judges	judge	VBZ
8691	392	18	a	a	DT
8691	392	19	share	share	NN
8691	392	20	in	in	IN
8691	392	21	that	that	DT
8691	392	22	of	of	IN
8691	392	23	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	392	24	.	.	.
8691	393	1	Her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	393	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	393	3	of	of	IN
8691	393	4	1777	1777	CD
8691	393	5	provided	provide	VBD
8691	393	6	for	for	IN
8691	393	7	a	a	DT
8691	393	8	council	council	NN
8691	393	9	of	of	IN
8691	393	10	revision	revision	NN
8691	393	11	,	,	,
8691	393	12	consisting	consist	VBG
8691	393	13	of	of	IN
8691	393	14	the	the	DT
8691	393	15	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	393	16	,	,	,
8691	393	17	the	the	DT
8691	393	18	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	393	19	,	,	,
8691	393	20	and	and	CC
8691	393	21	the	the	DT
8691	393	22	judges	judge	NNS
8691	393	23	of	of	IN
8691	393	24	the	the	DT
8691	393	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	393	26	Court	Court	NNP
8691	393	27	,	,	,
8691	393	28	to	to	IN
8691	393	29	whom	whom	WP
8691	393	30	all	all	DT
8691	393	31	bills	bill	NNS
8691	393	32	which	which	WDT
8691	393	33	passed	pass	VBD
8691	393	34	the	the	DT
8691	393	35	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	393	36	and	and	CC
8691	393	37	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	393	38	should	should	MD
8691	393	39	be	be	VB
8691	393	40	presented	present	VBN
8691	393	41	for	for	IN
8691	393	42	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	393	43	;	;	:
8691	393	44	and	and	CC
8691	393	45	that	that	IN
8691	393	46	if	if	IN
8691	393	47	a	a	DT
8691	393	48	majority	majority	NN
8691	393	49	of	of	IN
8691	393	50	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	393	51	should	should	MD
8691	393	52	deem	deem	VB
8691	393	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	393	54	improper	improper	JJ
8691	393	55	that	that	IN
8691	393	56	any	any	DT
8691	393	57	such	such	JJ
8691	393	58	bill	bill	NN
8691	393	59	should	should	MD
8691	393	60	become	become	VB
8691	393	61	a	a	DT
8691	393	62	law	law	NN
8691	393	63	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	393	64	should	should	MD
8691	393	65	within	within	IN
8691	393	66	ten	ten	CD
8691	393	67	days	day	NNS
8691	393	68	return	return	VB
8691	393	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	393	70	with	with	IN
8691	393	71	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	393	72	objections	objection	NNS
8691	393	73	to	to	IN
8691	393	74	the	the	DT
8691	393	75	house	house	NN
8691	393	76	in	in	IN
8691	393	77	which	which	WDT
8691	393	78	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	393	79	originated	originate	VBD
8691	393	80	,	,	,
8691	393	81	which	which	WDT
8691	393	82	should	should	MD
8691	393	83	enter	enter	VB
8691	393	84	the	the	DT
8691	393	85	objections	objection	NNS
8691	393	86	at	at	IN
8691	393	87	large	large	JJ
8691	393	88	in	in	IN
8691	393	89	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	393	90	minutes	minute	NNS
8691	393	91	,	,	,
8691	393	92	and	and	CC
8691	393	93	proceed	proceed	VB
8691	393	94	to	to	TO
8691	393	95	reconsider	reconsider	VB
8691	393	96	the	the	DT
8691	393	97	bill	bill	NN
8691	393	98	;	;	,
8691	393	99	and	and	CC
8691	393	100	that	that	IN
8691	393	101	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	393	102	should	should	MD
8691	393	103	not	not	RB
8691	393	104	become	become	VB
8691	393	105	a	a	DT
8691	393	106	law	law	NN
8691	393	107	unless	unless	IN
8691	393	108	re	re	JJ
8691	393	109	-	-	VBN
8691	393	110	passed	pass	VBN
8691	393	111	by	by	IN
8691	393	112	a	a	DT
8691	393	113	vote	vote	NN
8691	393	114	of	of	IN
8691	393	115	two	two	CD
8691	393	116	-	-	HYPH
8691	393	117	thirds	third	NNS
8691	393	118	of	of	IN
8691	393	119	the	the	DT
8691	393	120	members	member	NNS
8691	393	121	of	of	IN
8691	393	122	each	each	DT
8691	393	123	house	house	NN
8691	393	124	.	.	.
8691	394	1	For	for	IN
8691	394	2	forty	forty	CD
8691	394	3	years	year	NNS
8691	394	4	this	this	DT
8691	394	5	remained	remain	VBD
8691	394	6	the	the	DT
8691	394	7	law	law	NN
8691	394	8	,	,	,
8691	394	9	and	and	CC
8691	394	10	the	the	DT
8691	394	11	Council	Council	NNP
8691	394	12	of	of	IN
8691	394	13	Revision	Revision	NNP
8691	394	14	contained	contain	VBN
8691	394	15	from	from	IN
8691	394	16	time	time	NN
8691	394	17	to	to	IN
8691	394	18	time	time	NN
8691	394	19	judges	judge	NNS
8691	394	20	of	of	IN
8691	394	21	great	great	JJ
8691	394	22	ability	ability	NN
8691	394	23	,	,	,
8691	394	24	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	394	25	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	394	26	being	be	VBG
8691	394	27	one	one	CD
8691	394	28	.	.	.
8691	395	1	During	during	IN
8691	395	2	this	this	DT
8691	395	3	period	period	NN
8691	395	4	6,590	6,590	CD
8691	395	5	bills	bill	NNS
8691	395	6	in	in	IN
8691	395	7	all	all	DT
8691	395	8	were	be	VBD
8691	395	9	passed	pass	VBN
8691	395	10	.	.	.
8691	396	1	One	one	CD
8691	396	2	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	396	3	and	and	CC
8691	396	4	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	396	5	-	-	HYPH
8691	396	6	eight	eight	CD
8691	396	7	of	of	IN
8691	396	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	396	9	were	be	VBD
8691	396	10	returned	return	VBN
8691	396	11	by	by	IN
8691	396	12	the	the	DT
8691	396	13	Council	Council	NNP
8691	396	14	with	with	IN
8691	396	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	396	16	objections	objection	NNS
8691	396	17	,	,	,
8691	396	18	and	and	CC
8691	396	19	only	only	RB
8691	396	20	seventeen	seventeen	CD
8691	396	21	of	of	IN
8691	396	22	these	these	DT
8691	396	23	received	receive	VBD
8691	396	24	the	the	DT
8691	396	25	two	two	CD
8691	396	26	-	-	HYPH
8691	396	27	thirds	third	NNS
8691	396	28	vote	vote	NN
8691	396	29	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	396	30	to	to	TO
8691	396	31	re	re	VB
8691	396	32	-	-	VB
8691	396	33	enact	enact	VB
8691	396	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	396	35	.	.	.
8691	397	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	397	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	397	3	:	:	:
8691	397	4	Poore	Poore	NNP
8691	397	5	,	,	,
8691	397	6	"	"	``
8691	397	7	Charters	Charters	NNPS
8691	397	8	and	and	CC
8691	397	9	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	397	10	,	,	,
8691	397	11	"	"	''
8691	397	12	II	ii	CD
8691	397	13	,	,	,
8691	397	14	1332	1332	CD
8691	397	15	,	,	,
8691	397	16	1333	1333	CD
8691	397	17	,	,	,
8691	397	18	note	note	NN
8691	397	19	.	.	.
8691	397	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	398	1	An	an	DT
8691	398	2	obvious	obvious	JJ
8691	398	3	objection	objection	NN
8691	398	4	to	to	IN
8691	398	5	this	this	DT
8691	398	6	method	method	NN
8691	398	7	of	of	IN
8691	398	8	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	398	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	398	10	that	that	IN
8691	398	11	the	the	DT
8691	398	12	judges	judge	NNS
8691	398	13	who	who	WP
8691	398	14	,	,	,
8691	398	15	as	as	IN
8691	398	16	members	member	NNS
8691	398	17	of	of	IN
8691	398	18	a	a	DT
8691	398	19	council	council	NN
8691	398	20	of	of	IN
8691	398	21	revision	revision	NN
8691	398	22	,	,	,
8691	398	23	find	find	VB
8691	398	24	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	398	25	objectionable	objectionable	JJ
8691	398	26	in	in	IN
8691	398	27	a	a	DT
8691	398	28	bill	bill	NN
8691	398	29	presented	present	VBN
8691	398	30	for	for	IN
8691	398	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	398	32	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
8691	398	33	,	,	,
8691	398	34	must	must	MD
8691	398	35	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	398	36	have	have	VB
8691	398	37	a	a	DT
8691	398	38	certain	certain	JJ
8691	398	39	pride	pride	NN
8691	398	40	of	of	IN
8691	398	41	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	398	42	to	to	TO
8691	398	43	conquer	conquer	VB
8691	398	44	before	before	RB
8691	398	45	,	,	,
8691	398	46	should	should	MD
8691	398	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	398	48	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	398	49	become	become	VB
8691	398	50	afterward	afterward	RB
8691	398	51	the	the	DT
8691	398	52	subject	subject	NN
8691	398	53	of	of	IN
8691	398	54	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	398	55	before	before	IN
8691	398	56	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	398	57	,	,	,
8691	398	58	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	398	59	could	could	MD
8691	398	60	be	be	VB
8691	398	61	in	in	IN
8691	398	62	a	a	DT
8691	398	63	frame	frame	NN
8691	398	64	of	of	IN
8691	398	65	mind	mind	NN
8691	398	66	to	to	TO
8691	398	67	render	render	VB
8691	398	68	an	an	DT
8691	398	69	unprejudiced	unprejudiced	JJ
8691	398	70	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	398	71	.	.	.
8691	399	1	One	one	CD
8691	399	2	of	of	IN
8691	399	3	the	the	DT
8691	399	4	bills	bill	NNS
8691	399	5	which	which	WDT
8691	399	6	came	come	VBD
8691	399	7	under	under	IN
8691	399	8	the	the	DT
8691	399	9	eye	eye	NN
8691	399	10	of	of	IN
8691	399	11	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	399	12	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	399	13	as	as	IN
8691	399	14	a	a	DT
8691	399	15	member	member	NN
8691	399	16	of	of	IN
8691	399	17	the	the	DT
8691	399	18	Council	Council	NNP
8691	399	19	was	be	VBD
8691	399	20	afterward	afterward	RB
8691	399	21	the	the	DT
8691	399	22	source	source	NN
8691	399	23	of	of	IN
8691	399	24	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	399	25	before	before	IN
8691	399	26	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	399	27	in	in	IN
8691	399	28	court	court	NN
8691	399	29	.	.	.
8691	400	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	400	2	adhered	adhere	VBD
8691	400	3	to	to	IN
8691	400	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	400	5	original	original	JJ
8691	400	6	views	view	NNS
8691	400	7	,	,	,
8691	400	8	but	but	CC
8691	400	9	was	be	VBD
8691	400	10	overruled	overrule	VBN
8691	400	11	by	by	IN
8691	400	12	the	the	DT
8691	400	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	400	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	400	15	of	of	IN
8691	400	16	the	the	DT
8691	400	17	United	United	NNP
8691	400	18	States	States	NNP
8691	400	19	.	.	.
8691	401	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	401	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	401	3	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	401	4	gave	give	VBD
8691	401	5	the	the	DT
8691	401	6	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	401	7	,	,	,
8691	401	8	and	and	CC
8691	401	9	half	half	NN
8691	401	10	apologetically	apologetically	RB
8691	401	11	alluded	allude	VBN
8691	401	12	to	to	IN
8691	401	13	this	this	DT
8691	401	14	circumstance	circumstance	NN
8691	401	15	in	in	IN
8691	401	16	these	these	DT
8691	401	17	words	word	NNS
8691	401	18	:	:	:
8691	401	19	The	the	DT
8691	401	20	State	State	NNP
8691	401	21	of	of	IN
8691	401	22	New	New	NNP
8691	401	23	York	York	NNP
8691	401	24	maintains	maintain	VBZ
8691	401	25	the	the	DT
8691	401	26	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	401	27	of	of	IN
8691	401	28	these	these	DT
8691	401	29	laws	law	NNS
8691	401	30	;	;	:
8691	401	31	and	and	CC
8691	401	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	401	33	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	401	34	,	,	,
8691	401	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	401	36	council	council	NN
8691	401	37	of	of	IN
8691	401	38	revision	revision	NN
8691	401	39	,	,	,
8691	401	40	and	and	CC
8691	401	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	401	42	judges	judge	NNS
8691	401	43	,	,	,
8691	401	44	have	have	VBP
8691	401	45	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
8691	401	46	concurred	concur	VBN
8691	401	47	in	in	IN
8691	401	48	this	this	DT
8691	401	49	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	401	50	.	.	.
8691	402	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	402	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	402	3	supported	support	VBN
8691	402	4	by	by	IN
8691	402	5	great	great	JJ
8691	402	6	names	name	NNS
8691	402	7	--	--	:
8691	402	8	by	by	IN
8691	402	9	names	name	NNS
8691	402	10	which	which	WDT
8691	402	11	have	have	VBP
8691	402	12	all	all	PDT
8691	402	13	the	the	DT
8691	402	14	titles	title	NNS
8691	402	15	to	to	TO
8691	402	16	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	402	17	that	that	DT
8691	402	18	virtue	virtue	NN
8691	402	19	,	,	,
8691	402	20	intelligence	intelligence	NN
8691	402	21	,	,	,
8691	402	22	and	and	CC
8691	402	23	office	office	NN
8691	402	24	can	can	MD
8691	402	25	bestow	bestow	VB
8691	402	26	.	.	.
8691	403	1	No	no	DT
8691	403	2	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	403	3	can	can	MD
8691	403	4	approach	approach	VB
8691	403	5	the	the	DT
8691	403	6	decision	decision	NN
8691	403	7	of	of	IN
8691	403	8	this	this	DT
8691	403	9	question	question	NN
8691	403	10	without	without	IN
8691	403	11	feeling	feel	VBG
8691	403	12	a	a	DT
8691	403	13	just	just	RB
8691	403	14	and	and	CC
8691	403	15	real	real	JJ
8691	403	16	respect	respect	NN
8691	403	17	for	for	IN
8691	403	18	that	that	DT
8691	403	19	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	403	20	which	which	WDT
8691	403	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	403	22	sustained	sustain	VBN
8691	403	23	by	by	IN
8691	403	24	such	such	JJ
8691	403	25	authority	authority	NN
8691	403	26	;	;	:
8691	403	27	but	but	CC
8691	403	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	403	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	403	30	the	the	DT
8691	403	31	province	province	NN
8691	403	32	of	of	IN
8691	403	33	this	this	DT
8691	403	34	court	court	NN
8691	403	35	,	,	,
8691	403	36	while	while	IN
8691	403	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	403	38	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	403	39	,	,	,
8691	403	40	not	not	RB
8691	403	41	to	to	TO
8691	403	42	bow	bow	VB
8691	403	43	to	to	IN
8691	403	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	403	45	implicitly	implicitly	RB
8691	403	46	;	;	:
8691	403	47	and	and	CC
8691	403	48	the	the	DT
8691	403	49	judges	judge	NNS
8691	403	50	must	must	MD
8691	403	51	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	403	52	,	,	,
8691	403	53	in	in	IN
8691	403	54	the	the	DT
8691	403	55	examination	examination	NN
8691	403	56	of	of	IN
8691	403	57	the	the	DT
8691	403	58	subject	subject	NN
8691	403	59	,	,	,
8691	403	60	that	that	IN
8691	403	61	understanding	understanding	NN
8691	403	62	which	which	WDT
8691	403	63	Providence	Providence	NNP
8691	403	64	has	have	VBZ
8691	403	65	bestowed	bestow	VBN
8691	403	66	upon	upon	IN
8691	403	67	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	403	68	,	,	,
8691	403	69	with	with	IN
8691	403	70	that	that	DT
8691	403	71	independence	independence	NN
8691	403	72	which	which	WDT
8691	403	73	the	the	DT
8691	403	74	people	people	NNS
8691	403	75	of	of	IN
8691	403	76	the	the	DT
8691	403	77	United	United	NNP
8691	403	78	States	States	NNP
8691	403	79	expect	expect	VBP
8691	403	80	from	from	IN
8691	403	81	this	this	DT
8691	403	82	department	department	NN
8691	403	83	of	of	IN
8691	403	84	the	the	DT
8691	403	85	government	government	NN
8691	403	86	.	.	.
8691	404	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	404	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	404	3	:	:	:
8691	404	4	Gibbons	Gibbons	NNP
8691	404	5	_	_	NNP
8691	404	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	404	7	_	_	NNP
8691	404	8	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
8691	404	9	,	,	,
8691	404	10	9	9	CD
8691	404	11	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	404	12	's	's	POS
8691	404	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	404	14	,	,	,
8691	404	15	1	1	CD
8691	404	16	.	.	.
8691	404	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	405	1	A	a	DT
8691	405	2	device	device	NN
8691	405	3	for	for	IN
8691	405	4	obtaining	obtain	VBG
8691	405	5	the	the	DT
8691	405	6	same	same	JJ
8691	405	7	end	end	NN
8691	405	8	--	--	:
8691	405	9	the	the	DT
8691	405	10	views	view	NNS
8691	405	11	of	of	IN
8691	405	12	the	the	DT
8691	405	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	405	14	in	in	IN
8691	405	15	advance	advance	NN
8691	405	16	of	of	IN
8691	405	17	the	the	DT
8691	405	18	enactment	enactment	NN
8691	405	19	of	of	IN
8691	405	20	a	a	DT
8691	405	21	law	law	NN
8691	405	22	--	--	:
8691	405	23	in	in	IN
8691	405	24	a	a	DT
8691	405	25	different	different	JJ
8691	405	26	way	way	NN
8691	405	27	,	,	,
8691	405	28	has	have	VBZ
8691	405	29	been	be	VBN
8691	405	30	from	from	IN
8691	405	31	the	the	DT
8691	405	32	first	first	JJ
8691	405	33	quite	quite	RB
8691	405	34	common	common	JJ
8691	405	35	.	.	.
8691	406	1	This	this	DT
8691	406	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	406	3	for	for	IN
8691	406	4	the	the	DT
8691	406	5	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	406	6	to	to	TO
8691	406	7	ask	ask	VB
8691	406	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	406	9	specially	specially	RB
8691	406	10	for	for	IN
8691	406	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	406	12	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	406	13	as	as	IN
8691	406	14	to	to	IN
8691	406	15	the	the	DT
8691	406	16	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	406	17	of	of	IN
8691	406	18	a	a	DT
8691	406	19	bill	bill	NN
8691	406	20	before	before	IN
8691	406	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	406	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	406	23	put	put	VBN
8691	406	24	upon	upon	IN
8691	406	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	406	26	passage	passage	NN
8691	406	27	.	.	.
8691	407	1	An	an	DT
8691	407	2	analogous	analogous	JJ
8691	407	3	practice	practice	NN
8691	407	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	407	5	always	always	RB
8691	407	6	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	407	7	in	in	IN
8691	407	8	England	England	NNP
8691	407	9	,	,	,
8691	407	10	and	and	CC
8691	407	11	was	be	VBD
8691	407	12	followed	follow	VBN
8691	407	13	in	in	IN
8691	407	14	several	several	JJ
8691	407	15	of	of	IN
8691	407	16	the	the	DT
8691	407	17	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	407	18	.	.	.
8691	408	1	Some	some	DT
8691	408	2	of	of	IN
8691	408	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	408	4	State	State	NNP
8691	408	5	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	408	6	expressly	expressly	RB
8691	408	7	authorize	authorize	VBP
8691	408	8	such	such	JJ
8691	408	9	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	408	10	.	.	.
8691	409	1	In	in	IN
8691	409	2	the	the	DT
8691	409	3	absence	absence	NN
8691	409	4	of	of	IN
8691	409	5	such	such	JJ
8691	409	6	authority	authority	NN
8691	409	7	,	,	,
8691	409	8	the	the	DT
8691	409	9	judges	judge	NNS
8691	409	10	can	can	MD
8691	409	11	properly	properly	RB
8691	409	12	decline	decline	VB
8691	409	13	to	to	TO
8691	409	14	comply	comply	VB
8691	409	15	with	with	IN
8691	409	16	the	the	DT
8691	409	17	request	request	NN
8691	409	18	.	.	.
8691	410	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	410	2	always	always	RB
8691	410	3	asks	ask	VBZ
8691	410	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	410	5	to	to	TO
8691	410	6	prejudge	prejudge	VB
8691	410	7	a	a	DT
8691	410	8	question	question	NN
8691	410	9	which	which	WDT
8691	410	10	may	may	MD
8691	410	11	later	later	RB
8691	410	12	come	come	VB
8691	410	13	before	before	IN
8691	410	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	410	15	in	in	IN
8691	410	16	court	court	NN
8691	410	17	,	,	,
8691	410	18	and	and	CC
8691	410	19	to	to	TO
8691	410	20	prejudge	prejudge	VB
8691	410	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	410	22	without	without	IN
8691	410	23	hearing	hear	VBG
8691	410	24	any	any	DT
8691	410	25	of	of	IN
8691	410	26	the	the	DT
8691	410	27	parties	party	NNS
8691	410	28	whom	whom	WP
8691	410	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	410	30	may	may	MD
8691	410	31	affect	affect	VB
8691	410	32	injuriously	injuriously	RB
8691	410	33	.	.	.
8691	411	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	411	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	411	3	:	:	:
8691	411	4	See	see	VB
8691	411	5	the	the	DT
8691	411	6	Reply	Reply	NNP
8691	411	7	of	of	IN
8691	411	8	the	the	DT
8691	411	9	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	411	10	of	of	IN
8691	411	11	the	the	DT
8691	411	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	411	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	411	14	of	of	IN
8691	411	15	the	the	DT
8691	411	16	General	General	NNP
8691	411	17	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	411	18	,	,	,
8691	411	19	33	33	CD
8691	411	20	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	411	21	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	411	22	,	,	,
8691	411	23	586	586	CD
8691	411	24	.	.	.
8691	411	25	]	]	-RRB-
8691	412	1	President	President	NNP
8691	412	2	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	412	3	,	,	,
8691	412	4	in	in	IN
8691	412	5	1793	1793	CD
8691	412	6	,	,	,
8691	412	7	brought	bring	VBD
8691	412	8	a	a	DT
8691	412	9	matter	matter	NN
8691	412	10	of	of	IN
8691	412	11	this	this	DT
8691	412	12	kind	kind	NN
8691	412	13	before	before	IN
8691	412	14	the	the	DT
8691	412	15	justices	justice	NNS
8691	412	16	of	of	IN
8691	412	17	the	the	DT
8691	412	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	412	19	Court	Court	NNP
8691	412	20	of	of	IN
8691	412	21	the	the	DT
8691	412	22	United	United	NNP
8691	412	23	States	States	NNP
8691	412	24	.	.	.
8691	413	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	413	2	was	be	VBD
8691	413	3	during	during	IN
8691	413	4	the	the	DT
8691	413	5	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	413	6	with	with	IN
8691	413	7	M.	M.	NNP
8691	413	8	Genet	Genet	NNP
8691	413	9	,	,	,
8691	413	10	the	the	DT
8691	413	11	French	french	JJ
8691	413	12	minister	minister	NN
8691	413	13	,	,	,
8691	413	14	as	as	IN
8691	413	15	to	to	IN
8691	413	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	413	17	right	right	NN
8691	413	18	to	to	TO
8691	413	19	refit	refit	VB
8691	413	20	a	a	DT
8691	413	21	captured	capture	VBN
8691	413	22	English	English	NNP
8691	413	23	merchantman	merchantman	NN
8691	413	24	as	as	IN
8691	413	25	a	a	DT
8691	413	26	privateer	privateer	NN
8691	413	27	at	at	IN
8691	413	28	an	an	DT
8691	413	29	American	american	JJ
8691	413	30	port	port	NN
8691	413	31	,	,	,
8691	413	32	and	and	CC
8691	413	33	then	then	RB
8691	413	34	send	send	VB
8691	413	35	her	-PRON-	PRP
8691	413	36	out	out	RP
8691	413	37	for	for	IN
8691	413	38	a	a	DT
8691	413	39	cruise	cruise	NN
8691	413	40	.	.	.
8691	414	1	By	by	IN
8691	414	2	the	the	DT
8691	414	3	advice	advice	NN
8691	414	4	of	of	IN
8691	414	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	414	6	Cabinet	Cabinet	NNP
8691	414	7	,	,	,
8691	414	8	the	the	DT
8691	414	9	President	President	NNP
8691	414	10	asked	ask	VBD
8691	414	11	the	the	DT
8691	414	12	justices	justice	NNS
8691	414	13	a	a	DT
8691	414	14	series	series	NN
8691	414	15	of	of	IN
8691	414	16	questions	question	NNS
8691	414	17	comprehending	comprehend	VBG
8691	414	18	all	all	PDT
8691	414	19	the	the	DT
8691	414	20	subjects	subject	NNS
8691	414	21	of	of	IN
8691	414	22	difference	difference	NN
8691	414	23	as	as	IN
8691	414	24	to	to	IN
8691	414	25	the	the	DT
8691	414	26	proper	proper	JJ
8691	414	27	exposition	exposition	NN
8691	414	28	of	of	IN
8691	414	29	the	the	DT
8691	414	30	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	414	31	of	of	IN
8691	414	32	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	414	33	treaties	treaty	NNS
8691	414	34	with	with	IN
8691	414	35	France	France	NNP
8691	414	36	under	under	IN
8691	414	37	which	which	WDT
8691	414	38	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	414	39	minister	minister	NN
8691	414	40	made	make	VBD
8691	414	41	claim	claim	NN
8691	414	42	.	.	.
8691	415	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	415	2	replied	reply	VBD
8691	415	3	that	that	IN
8691	415	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	415	5	deemed	deem	VBD
8691	415	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	415	7	improper	improper	JJ
8691	415	8	to	to	TO
8691	415	9	enter	enter	VB
8691	415	10	the	the	DT
8691	415	11	field	field	NN
8691	415	12	of	of	IN
8691	415	13	politics	politic	NNS
8691	415	14	by	by	IN
8691	415	15	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	415	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	415	17	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	415	18	on	on	IN
8691	415	19	questions	question	NNS
8691	415	20	not	not	RB
8691	415	21	growing	grow	VBG
8691	415	22	out	out	IN
8691	415	23	of	of	IN
8691	415	24	some	some	DT
8691	415	25	case	case	NN
8691	415	26	actually	actually	RB
8691	415	27	before	before	IN
8691	415	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	415	29	.	.	.
8691	416	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	416	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	416	3	:	:	:
8691	416	4	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	416	5	,	,	,
8691	416	6	"	"	``
8691	416	7	Life	Life	NNP
8691	416	8	of	of	IN
8691	416	9	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	416	10	,	,	,
8691	416	11	"	"	``
8691	416	12	V	V	NNP
8691	416	13	,	,	,
8691	416	14	433	433	CD
8691	416	15	,	,	,
8691	416	16	441	441	CD
8691	416	17	.	.	.
8691	416	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	417	1	No	no	DT
8691	417	2	further	further	JJ
8691	417	3	request	request	NN
8691	417	4	of	of	IN
8691	417	5	this	this	DT
8691	417	6	kind	kind	NN
8691	417	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	417	8	since	since	RB
8691	417	9	been	be	VBN
8691	417	10	made	make	VBN
8691	417	11	by	by	IN
8691	417	12	any	any	DT
8691	417	13	of	of	IN
8691	417	14	the	the	DT
8691	417	15	political	political	JJ
8691	417	16	departments	department	NNS
8691	417	17	to	to	IN
8691	417	18	a	a	DT
8691	417	19	court	court	NN
8691	417	20	of	of	IN
8691	417	21	the	the	DT
8691	417	22	United	United	NNP
8691	417	23	States	States	NNP
8691	417	24	,	,	,
8691	417	25	except	except	IN
8691	417	26	such	such	JJ
8691	417	27	as	as	IN
8691	417	28	have	have	VBP
8691	417	29	been	be	VBN
8691	417	30	addressed	address	VBN
8691	417	31	to	to	IN
8691	417	32	the	the	DT
8691	417	33	Court	Court	NNP
8691	417	34	of	of	IN
8691	417	35	Claims	Claims	NNPS
8691	417	36	.	.	.
8691	418	1	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
8691	418	2	,	,	,
8691	418	3	in	in	IN
8691	418	4	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	418	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	418	6	(	(	-LRB-
8691	418	7	Art	art	NN
8691	418	8	.	.	.
8691	419	1	V	V	NNP
8691	419	2	,	,	,
8691	419	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	419	4	.	.	.
8691	420	1	25	25	CD
8691	420	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	420	3	,	,	,
8691	420	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	420	5	sought	seek	VBN
8691	420	6	to	to	TO
8691	420	7	give	give	VB
8691	420	8	the	the	DT
8691	420	9	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	420	10	the	the	DT
8691	420	11	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	420	12	of	of	IN
8691	420	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	420	14	advice	advice	NN
8691	420	15	at	at	IN
8691	420	16	the	the	DT
8691	420	17	opening	opening	NN
8691	420	18	of	of	IN
8691	420	19	each	each	DT
8691	420	20	session	session	NN
8691	420	21	as	as	IN
8691	420	22	to	to	IN
8691	420	23	what	what	WDT
8691	420	24	laws	law	NNS
8691	420	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	420	26	might	may	MD
8691	420	27	be	be	VB
8691	420	28	desirable	desirable	JJ
8691	420	29	to	to	TO
8691	420	30	enact	enact	VB
8691	420	31	.	.	.
8691	421	1	The	the	DT
8691	421	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	421	3	of	of	IN
8691	421	4	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	421	5	trial	trial	NN
8691	421	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	421	7	are	be	VBP
8691	421	8	annually	annually	RB
8691	421	9	to	to	TO
8691	421	10	report	report	VB
8691	421	11	to	to	IN
8691	421	12	those	those	DT
8691	421	13	of	of	IN
8691	421	14	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	421	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	421	16	Court	Court	NNP
8691	421	17	such	such	JJ
8691	421	18	defects	defect	NNS
8691	421	19	and	and	CC
8691	421	20	omissions	omission	NNS
8691	421	21	in	in	IN
8691	421	22	the	the	DT
8691	421	23	laws	law	NNS
8691	421	24	as	as	IN
8691	421	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	421	26	knowledge	knowledge	NN
8691	421	27	and	and	CC
8691	421	28	experience	experience	NN
8691	421	29	may	may	MD
8691	421	30	suggest	suggest	VB
8691	421	31	,	,	,
8691	421	32	and	and	CC
8691	421	33	the	the	DT
8691	421	34	latter	latter	JJ
8691	421	35	,	,	,
8691	421	36	after	after	IN
8691	421	37	considering	consider	VBG
8691	421	38	these	these	DT
8691	421	39	suggestions	suggestion	NNS
8691	421	40	,	,	,
8691	421	41	are	be	VBP
8691	421	42	then	then	RB
8691	421	43	,	,	,
8691	421	44	within	within	IN
8691	421	45	the	the	DT
8691	421	46	next	next	JJ
8691	421	47	five	five	CD
8691	421	48	months	month	NNS
8691	421	49	,	,	,
8691	421	50	to	to	TO
8691	421	51	report	report	VB
8691	421	52	to	to	IN
8691	421	53	the	the	DT
8691	421	54	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	421	55	such	such	JJ
8691	421	56	defects	defect	NNS
8691	421	57	and	and	CC
8691	421	58	omissions	omission	NNS
8691	421	59	,	,	,
8691	421	60	both	both	CC
8691	421	61	in	in	IN
8691	421	62	the	the	DT
8691	421	63	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	421	64	and	and	CC
8691	421	65	in	in	IN
8691	421	66	the	the	DT
8691	421	67	laws	law	NNS
8691	421	68	,	,	,
8691	421	69	as	as	IN
8691	421	70	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	421	71	may	may	MD
8691	421	72	find	find	VB
8691	421	73	to	to	TO
8691	421	74	exist	exist	VB
8691	421	75	.	.	.
8691	422	1	The	the	DT
8691	422	2	duty	duty	NN
8691	422	3	of	of	IN
8691	422	4	the	the	DT
8691	422	5	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	422	6	,	,	,
8691	422	7	in	in	IN
8691	422	8	the	the	DT
8691	422	9	course	course	NN
8691	422	10	of	of	IN
8691	422	11	lawsuits	lawsuit	NNS
8691	422	12	,	,	,
8691	422	13	to	to	TO
8691	422	14	compare	compare	VB
8691	422	15	a	a	DT
8691	422	16	statute	statute	NN
8691	422	17	,	,	,
8691	422	18	the	the	DT
8691	422	19	validity	validity	NN
8691	422	20	of	of	IN
8691	422	21	which	which	WDT
8691	422	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	422	23	called	call	VBN
8691	422	24	in	in	IN
8691	422	25	question	question	NN
8691	422	26	,	,	,
8691	422	27	with	with	IN
8691	422	28	the	the	DT
8691	422	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	422	30	,	,	,
8691	422	31	and	and	CC
8691	422	32	by	by	IN
8691	422	33	the	the	DT
8691	422	34	decision	decision	NN
8691	422	35	indirectly	indirectly	RB
8691	422	36	to	to	TO
8691	422	37	affect	affect	VB
8691	422	38	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	422	39	,	,	,
8691	422	40	is	be	VBZ
8691	422	41	treated	treat	VBN
8691	422	42	of	of	IN
8691	422	43	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
8691	422	44	.	.	.
8691	423	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	423	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	423	3	:	:	:
8691	423	4	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	423	5	.	.	.
8691	424	1	VII	VII	NNP
8691	424	2	.	.	.
8691	424	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	425	1	The	the	DT
8691	425	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	425	3	of	of	IN
8691	425	4	the	the	DT
8691	425	5	United	United	NNP
8691	425	6	States	States	NNP
8691	425	7	,	,	,
8691	425	8	in	in	IN
8691	425	9	controversies	controversy	NNS
8691	425	10	involving	involve	VBG
8691	425	11	matters	matter	NNS
8691	425	12	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	425	13	the	the	DT
8691	425	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	425	15	relations	relation	NNS
8691	425	16	of	of	IN
8691	425	17	the	the	DT
8691	425	18	general	general	JJ
8691	425	19	government	government	NN
8691	425	20	,	,	,
8691	425	21	acknowledge	acknowledge	VBP
8691	425	22	in	in	IN
8691	425	23	a	a	DT
8691	425	24	certain	certain	JJ
8691	425	25	degree	degree	NN
8691	425	26	a	a	DT
8691	425	27	dependence	dependence	NN
8691	425	28	upon	upon	IN
8691	425	29	the	the	DT
8691	425	30	executive	executive	JJ
8691	425	31	department	department	NN
8691	425	32	.	.	.
8691	426	1	If	if	IN
8691	426	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	426	3	have	have	VBP
8691	426	4	a	a	DT
8691	426	5	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	426	6	to	to	TO
8691	426	7	construe	construe	VB
8691	426	8	,	,	,
8691	426	9	any	any	DT
8691	426	10	construction	construction	NN
8691	426	11	of	of	IN
8691	426	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	426	13	as	as	IN
8691	426	14	to	to	IN
8691	426	15	the	the	DT
8691	426	16	point	point	NN
8691	426	17	in	in	IN
8691	426	18	question	question	NN
8691	426	19	already	already	RB
8691	426	20	given	give	VBN
8691	426	21	by	by	IN
8691	426	22	the	the	DT
8691	426	23	State	State	NNP
8691	426	24	Department	Department	NNP
8691	426	25	will	will	MD
8691	426	26	be	be	VB
8691	426	27	followed	follow	VBN
8691	426	28	,	,	,
8691	426	29	unless	unless	IN
8691	426	30	plainly	plainly	RB
8691	426	31	wrong	wrong	JJ
8691	426	32	.	.	.
8691	427	1	If	if	IN
8691	427	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	427	3	becomes	become	VBZ
8691	427	4	material	material	NN
8691	427	5	to	to	TO
8691	427	6	determine	determine	VB
8691	427	7	whether	whether	IN
8691	427	8	a	a	DT
8691	427	9	certain	certain	JJ
8691	427	10	country	country	NN
8691	427	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	427	12	subject	subject	JJ
8691	427	13	to	to	IN
8691	427	14	a	a	DT
8691	427	15	certain	certain	JJ
8691	427	16	power	power	NN
8691	427	17	,	,	,
8691	427	18	and	and	CC
8691	427	19	the	the	DT
8691	427	20	President	President	NNP
8691	427	21	of	of	IN
8691	427	22	the	the	DT
8691	427	23	United	United	NNP
8691	427	24	States	States	NNP
8691	427	25	has	have	VBZ
8691	427	26	dealt	deal	VBN
8691	427	27	with	with	IN
8691	427	28	that	that	DT
8691	427	29	question	question	NN
8691	427	30	(	(	-LRB-
8691	427	31	as	as	IN
8691	427	32	by	by	IN
8691	427	33	recognizing	recognize	VBG
8691	427	34	or	or	CC
8691	427	35	refusing	refuse	VBG
8691	427	36	to	to	TO
8691	427	37	recognize	recognize	VB
8691	427	38	a	a	DT
8691	427	39	minister	minister	NN
8691	427	40	accredited	accredit	VBN
8691	427	41	to	to	IN
8691	427	42	the	the	DT
8691	427	43	United	United	NNP
8691	427	44	States	States	NNP
8691	427	45	)	)	-RRB-
8691	427	46	,	,	,
8691	427	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	427	48	action	action	NN
8691	427	49	will	will	MD
8691	427	50	be	be	VB
8691	427	51	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	427	52	as	as	IN
8691	427	53	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	427	54	.	.	.
8691	428	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	428	2	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	428	3	would	would	MD
8691	428	4	have	have	VB
8691	428	5	like	like	UH
8691	428	6	weight	weight	NN
8691	428	7	if	if	IN
8691	428	8	taken	take	VBN
8691	428	9	within	within	IN
8691	428	10	the	the	DT
8691	428	11	limits	limit	NNS
8691	428	12	of	of	IN
8691	428	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	428	14	authority	authority	NN
8691	428	15	with	with	IN
8691	428	16	respect	respect	NN
8691	428	17	to	to	IN
8691	428	18	the	the	DT
8691	428	19	government	government	NN
8691	428	20	of	of	IN
8691	428	21	one	one	CD
8691	428	22	of	of	IN
8691	428	23	the	the	DT
8691	428	24	United	United	NNP
8691	428	25	States	States	NNP
8691	428	26	.	.	.
8691	429	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	429	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	429	3	:	:	:
8691	429	4	Luther	Luther	NNP
8691	429	5	_	_	NNP
8691	429	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	429	7	_	_	NNP
8691	429	8	Borden	Borden	NNP
8691	429	9	,	,	,
8691	429	10	7	7	CD
8691	429	11	Howard	Howard	NNP
8691	429	12	's	's	POS
8691	429	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	429	14	,	,	,
8691	429	15	1	1	CD
8691	429	16	.	.	.
8691	429	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	430	1	When	when	WRB
8691	430	2	questions	question	NNS
8691	430	3	of	of	IN
8691	430	4	this	this	DT
8691	430	5	nature	nature	NN
8691	430	6	arise	arise	VBP
8691	430	7	in	in	IN
8691	430	8	a	a	DT
8691	430	9	lawsuit	lawsuit	NN
8691	430	10	between	between	IN
8691	430	11	private	private	JJ
8691	430	12	parties	party	NNS
8691	430	13	,	,	,
8691	430	14	the	the	DT
8691	430	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	430	16	can	can	MD
8691	430	17	,	,	,
8691	430	18	without	without	IN
8691	430	19	notice	notice	NN
8691	430	20	to	to	IN
8691	430	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	430	22	,	,	,
8691	430	23	seek	seek	VB
8691	430	24	information	information	NN
8691	430	25	by	by	IN
8691	430	26	communicating	communicate	VBG
8691	430	27	directly	directly	RB
8691	430	28	with	with	IN
8691	430	29	the	the	DT
8691	430	30	Department	Department	NNP
8691	430	31	of	of	IN
8691	430	32	State	State	NNP
8691	430	33	.	.	.
8691	431	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	431	2	will	will	MD
8691	431	3	be	be	VB
8691	431	4	given	give	VBN
8691	431	5	by	by	IN
8691	431	6	a	a	DT
8691	431	7	letter	letter	NN
8691	431	8	or	or	CC
8691	431	9	certificate	certificate	NN
8691	431	10	,	,	,
8691	431	11	and	and	CC
8691	431	12	this	this	DT
8691	431	13	will	will	MD
8691	431	14	be	be	VB
8691	431	15	received	receive	VBN
8691	431	16	as	as	IN
8691	431	17	a	a	DT
8691	431	18	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	431	19	mode	mode	NN
8691	431	20	of	of	IN
8691	431	21	proof	proof	NN
8691	431	22	or	or	CC
8691	431	23	as	as	IN
8691	431	24	aiding	aid	VBG
8691	431	25	the	the	DT
8691	431	26	court	court	NN
8691	431	27	in	in	IN
8691	431	28	taking	take	VBG
8691	431	29	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	431	30	notice	notice	NN
8691	431	31	of	of	IN
8691	431	32	historical	historical	JJ
8691	431	33	facts	fact	NNS
8691	431	34	.	.	.
8691	432	1	So	so	IN
8691	432	2	an	an	DT
8691	432	3	official	official	JJ
8691	432	4	letter	letter	NN
8691	432	5	or	or	CC
8691	432	6	certificate	certificate	NN
8691	432	7	from	from	IN
8691	432	8	the	the	DT
8691	432	9	minister	minister	NN
8691	432	10	or	or	CC
8691	432	11	consul	consul	NN
8691	432	12	of	of	IN
8691	432	13	a	a	DT
8691	432	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	432	15	power	power	NN
8691	432	16	can	can	MD
8691	432	17	be	be	VB
8691	432	18	received	receive	VBN
8691	432	19	and	and	CC
8691	432	20	used	use	VBN
8691	432	21	as	as	IN
8691	432	22	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	432	23	as	as	IN
8691	432	24	to	to	IN
8691	432	25	facts	fact	NNS
8691	432	26	in	in	IN
8691	432	27	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	432	28	peculiarly	peculiarly	RB
8691	432	29	within	within	IN
8691	432	30	the	the	DT
8691	432	31	knowledge	knowledge	NN
8691	432	32	of	of	IN
8691	432	33	that	that	DT
8691	432	34	government	government	NN
8691	432	35	.	.	.
8691	433	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	433	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	433	3	:	:	:
8691	433	4	Gernon	Gernon	NNP
8691	433	5	_	_	NNP
8691	433	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	433	7	_	_	NNP
8691	433	8	Cochran	Cochran	NNP
8691	433	9	,	,	,
8691	433	10	Bee	Bee	NNP
8691	433	11	's	's	POS
8691	433	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	433	13	,	,	,
8691	433	14	209	209	CD
8691	433	15	.	.	.
8691	433	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	434	1	In	in	IN
8691	434	2	prize	prize	NN
8691	434	3	cases	case	NNS
8691	434	4	,	,	,
8691	434	5	which	which	WDT
8691	434	6	must	must	MD
8691	434	7	all	all	DT
8691	434	8	be	be	VB
8691	434	9	brought	bring	VBN
8691	434	10	before	before	IN
8691	434	11	the	the	DT
8691	434	12	District	District	NNP
8691	434	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	434	14	,	,	,
8691	434	15	an	an	DT
8691	434	16	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	434	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	434	18	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	434	19	directly	directly	RB
8691	434	20	to	to	IN
8691	434	21	the	the	DT
8691	434	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	434	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	434	24	of	of	IN
8691	434	25	the	the	DT
8691	434	26	United	United	NNP
8691	434	27	States	States	NNP
8691	434	28	,	,	,
8691	434	29	although	although	IN
8691	434	30	the	the	DT
8691	434	31	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	434	32	of	of	IN
8691	434	33	the	the	DT
8691	434	34	District	District	NNP
8691	434	35	Court	Court	NNP
8691	434	36	generally	generally	RB
8691	434	37	are	be	VBP
8691	434	38	reviewable	reviewable	JJ
8691	434	39	only	only	RB
8691	434	40	in	in	IN
8691	434	41	an	an	DT
8691	434	42	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
8691	434	43	court	court	NN
8691	434	44	.	.	.
8691	435	1	This	this	DT
8691	435	2	secures	secure	VBZ
8691	435	3	a	a	DT
8691	435	4	prompt	prompt	JJ
8691	435	5	decision	decision	NN
8691	435	6	by	by	IN
8691	435	7	the	the	DT
8691	435	8	highest	high	JJS
8691	435	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	435	10	authority	authority	NN
8691	435	11	of	of	IN
8691	435	12	a	a	DT
8691	435	13	question	question	NN
8691	435	14	which	which	WDT
8691	435	15	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	435	16	affects	affect	VBZ
8691	435	17	,	,	,
8691	435	18	in	in	IN
8691	435	19	some	some	DT
8691	435	20	degree	degree	NN
8691	435	21	,	,	,
8691	435	22	the	the	DT
8691	435	23	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	435	24	relations	relation	NNS
8691	435	25	of	of	IN
8691	435	26	the	the	DT
8691	435	27	United	United	NNP
8691	435	28	States	States	NNP
8691	435	29	.	.	.
8691	436	1	But	but	CC
8691	436	2	there	there	EX
8691	436	3	may	may	MD
8691	436	4	be	be	VB
8691	436	5	cases	case	NNS
8691	436	6	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	436	7	a	a	DT
8691	436	8	vessel	vessel	NN
8691	436	9	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	436	10	as	as	IN
8691	436	11	a	a	DT
8691	436	12	prize	prize	NN
8691	436	13	which	which	WDT
8691	436	14	are	be	VBP
8691	436	15	not	not	RB
8691	436	16	brought	bring	VBN
8691	436	17	to	to	TO
8691	436	18	secure	secure	VB
8691	436	19	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	436	20	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
8691	436	21	and	and	CC
8691	436	22	so	so	RB
8691	436	23	are	be	VBP
8691	436	24	not	not	RB
8691	436	25	prize	prize	NN
8691	436	26	cases	case	NNS
8691	436	27	.	.	.
8691	437	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	437	2	may	may	MD
8691	437	3	even	even	RB
8691	437	4	to	to	IN
8691	437	5	a	a	DT
8691	437	6	greater	great	JJR
8691	437	7	extent	extent	NN
8691	437	8	affect	affect	VB
8691	437	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	437	10	relations	relation	NNS
8691	437	11	to	to	IN
8691	437	12	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	437	13	governments	government	NNS
8691	437	14	.	.	.
8691	438	1	How	how	WRB
8691	438	2	far	far	RB
8691	438	3	can	can	MD
8691	438	4	the	the	DT
8691	438	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	438	6	,	,	,
8691	438	7	in	in	IN
8691	438	8	dealing	deal	VBG
8691	438	9	with	with	IN
8691	438	10	these	these	DT
8691	438	11	,	,	,
8691	438	12	govern	govern	VB
8691	438	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	438	14	action	action	NN
8691	438	15	by	by	IN
8691	438	16	that	that	DT
8691	438	17	of	of	IN
8691	438	18	the	the	DT
8691	438	19	executive	executive	NN
8691	438	20	?	?	.
8691	439	1	This	this	DT
8691	439	2	question	question	NN
8691	439	3	came	come	VBD
8691	439	4	up	up	RP
8691	439	5	for	for	IN
8691	439	6	decision	decision	NN
8691	439	7	shortly	shortly	RB
8691	439	8	after	after	IN
8691	439	9	the	the	DT
8691	439	10	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	439	11	of	of	IN
8691	439	12	the	the	DT
8691	439	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	439	14	.	.	.
8691	440	1	Great	Great	NNP
8691	440	2	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	440	3	and	and	CC
8691	440	4	Spain	Spain	NNP
8691	440	5	were	be	VBD
8691	440	6	at	at	IN
8691	440	7	war	war	NN
8691	440	8	.	.	.
8691	441	1	A	a	DT
8691	441	2	British	british	JJ
8691	441	3	man	man	NN
8691	441	4	-	-	HYPH
8691	441	5	of	of	IN
8691	441	6	-	-	HYPH
8691	441	7	war	war	NN
8691	441	8	brought	bring	VBN
8691	441	9	a	a	DT
8691	441	10	Spanish	spanish	JJ
8691	441	11	felucca	felucca	NN
8691	441	12	into	into	IN
8691	441	13	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
8691	441	14	,	,	,
8691	441	15	claiming	claim	VBG
8691	441	16	her	-PRON-	PRP
8691	441	17	as	as	IN
8691	441	18	a	a	DT
8691	441	19	prize	prize	NN
8691	441	20	,	,	,
8691	441	21	and	and	CC
8691	441	22	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	441	23	was	be	VBD
8691	441	24	advertised	advertise	VBN
8691	441	25	for	for	IN
8691	441	26	sale	sale	NN
8691	441	27	.	.	.
8691	442	1	No	no	DT
8691	442	2	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	442	3	to	to	TO
8691	442	4	have	have	VB
8691	442	5	her	-PRON-	PRP
8691	442	6	adjudicated	adjudicate	VBN
8691	442	7	a	a	DT
8691	442	8	lawful	lawful	JJ
8691	442	9	prize	prize	NN
8691	442	10	had	have	VBD
8691	442	11	been	be	VBN
8691	442	12	taken	take	VBN
8691	442	13	before	before	IN
8691	442	14	any	any	DT
8691	442	15	court	court	NN
8691	442	16	.	.	.
8691	443	1	The	the	DT
8691	443	2	Spanish	spanish	JJ
8691	443	3	consul	consul	NN
8691	443	4	applied	apply	VBD
8691	443	5	to	to	IN
8691	443	6	the	the	DT
8691	443	7	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	443	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	443	9	for	for	IN
8691	443	10	an	an	DT
8691	443	11	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	443	12	against	against	IN
8691	443	13	the	the	DT
8691	443	14	sale	sale	NN
8691	443	15	,	,	,
8691	443	16	claiming	claim	VBG
8691	443	17	that	that	DT
8691	443	18	for	for	IN
8691	443	19	the	the	DT
8691	443	20	United	United	NNP
8691	443	21	States	States	NNP
8691	443	22	to	to	TO
8691	443	23	permit	permit	VB
8691	443	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	443	25	would	would	MD
8691	443	26	be	be	VB
8691	443	27	a	a	DT
8691	443	28	breach	breach	NN
8691	443	29	of	of	IN
8691	443	30	neutrality	neutrality	NN
8691	443	31	and	and	CC
8691	443	32	contrary	contrary	NN
8691	443	33	to	to	IN
8691	443	34	the	the	DT
8691	443	35	law	law	NN
8691	443	36	of	of	IN
8691	443	37	nations	nation	NNS
8691	443	38	.	.	.
8691	444	1	The	the	DT
8691	444	2	British	british	JJ
8691	444	3	consul	consul	NN
8691	444	4	resisted	resist	VBD
8691	444	5	the	the	DT
8691	444	6	application	application	NN
8691	444	7	on	on	IN
8691	444	8	the	the	DT
8691	444	9	ground	ground	NN
8691	444	10	that	that	IN
8691	444	11	a	a	DT
8691	444	12	sale	sale	NN
8691	444	13	could	could	MD
8691	444	14	not	not	RB
8691	444	15	be	be	VB
8691	444	16	forbidden	forbid	VBN
8691	444	17	in	in	IN
8691	444	18	the	the	DT
8691	444	19	absence	absence	NN
8691	444	20	of	of	IN
8691	444	21	any	any	DT
8691	444	22	act	act	NN
8691	444	23	of	of	IN
8691	444	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	444	25	on	on	IN
8691	444	26	the	the	DT
8691	444	27	subject	subject	NN
8691	444	28	,	,	,
8691	444	29	except	except	IN
8691	444	30	by	by	IN
8691	444	31	the	the	DT
8691	444	32	President	President	NNP
8691	444	33	.	.	.
8691	445	1	The	the	DT
8691	445	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	445	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	445	4	,	,	,
8691	445	5	who	who	WP
8691	445	6	sat	sit	VBD
8691	445	7	in	in	IN
8691	445	8	the	the	DT
8691	445	9	case	case	NN
8691	445	10	,	,	,
8691	445	11	gave	give	VBD
8691	445	12	the	the	DT
8691	445	13	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	445	14	,	,	,
8691	445	15	which	which	WDT
8691	445	16	was	be	VBD
8691	445	17	that	that	IN
8691	445	18	there	there	EX
8691	445	19	could	could	MD
8691	445	20	be	be	VB
8691	445	21	no	no	DT
8691	445	22	lawful	lawful	JJ
8691	445	23	sale	sale	NN
8691	445	24	without	without	IN
8691	445	25	the	the	DT
8691	445	26	permission	permission	NN
8691	445	27	of	of	IN
8691	445	28	the	the	DT
8691	445	29	United	United	NNP
8691	445	30	States	States	NNP
8691	445	31	;	;	:
8691	445	32	that	that	IN
8691	445	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	445	34	was	be	VBD
8691	445	35	a	a	DT
8691	445	36	matter	matter	NN
8691	445	37	proper	proper	JJ
8691	445	38	to	to	TO
8691	445	39	be	be	VB
8691	445	40	dealt	deal	VBN
8691	445	41	with	with	IN
8691	445	42	by	by	IN
8691	445	43	the	the	DT
8691	445	44	President	President	NNP
8691	445	45	;	;	:
8691	445	46	that	that	IN
8691	445	47	the	the	DT
8691	445	48	court	court	NN
8691	445	49	would	would	MD
8691	445	50	not	not	RB
8691	445	51	say	say	VB
8691	445	52	how	how	WRB
8691	445	53	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	445	54	should	should	MD
8691	445	55	deal	deal	VB
8691	445	56	with	with	IN
8691	445	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	445	58	;	;	:
8691	445	59	but	but	CC
8691	445	60	that	that	IN
8691	445	61	an	an	DT
8691	445	62	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	445	63	might	may	MD
8691	445	64	issue	issue	VB
8691	445	65	to	to	TO
8691	445	66	stop	stop	VB
8691	445	67	the	the	DT
8691	445	68	sale	sale	NN
8691	445	69	until	until	IN
8691	445	70	further	further	JJ
8691	445	71	order	order	NN
8691	445	72	,	,	,
8691	445	73	unless	unless	IN
8691	445	74	permission	permission	NN
8691	445	75	should	should	MD
8691	445	76	be	be	VB
8691	445	77	sooner	soon	RBR
8691	445	78	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	445	79	from	from	IN
8691	445	80	the	the	DT
8691	445	81	President	President	NNP
8691	445	82	.	.	.
8691	446	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	446	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	446	3	:	:	:
8691	446	4	Consul	Consul	NNP
8691	446	5	of	of	IN
8691	446	6	Spain	Spain	NNP
8691	446	7	_	_	NNP
8691	446	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	446	9	_	_	NNP
8691	446	10	Consul	Consul	NNP
8691	446	11	of	of	IN
8691	446	12	Great	Great	NNP
8691	446	13	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	446	14	,	,	,
8691	446	15	Bee	Bee	NNP
8691	446	16	's	's	POS
8691	446	17	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	446	18	,	,	,
8691	446	19	263	263	CD
8691	446	20	.	.	.
8691	446	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	447	1	Here	here	RB
8691	447	2	,	,	,
8691	447	3	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	447	4	,	,	,
8691	447	5	an	an	DT
8691	447	6	act	act	NN
8691	447	7	which	which	WDT
8691	447	8	might	may	MD
8691	447	9	have	have	VB
8691	447	10	been	be	VBN
8691	447	11	a	a	DT
8691	447	12	_	_	NNP
8691	447	13	casus	casus	NNP
8691	447	14	belli	belli	NNP
8691	447	15	_	_	NNP
8691	447	16	was	be	VBD
8691	447	17	stayed	stay	VBN
8691	447	18	by	by	IN
8691	447	19	a	a	DT
8691	447	20	court	court	NN
8691	447	21	until	until	IN
8691	447	22	and	and	CC
8691	447	23	unless	unless	IN
8691	447	24	the	the	DT
8691	447	25	Executive	Executive	NNP
8691	447	26	should	should	MD
8691	447	27	intervene	intervene	VB
8691	447	28	and	and	CC
8691	447	29	permit	permit	VB
8691	447	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	447	31	.	.	.
8691	448	1	The	the	DT
8691	448	2	extradition	extradition	NN
8691	448	3	of	of	IN
8691	448	4	criminals	criminal	NNS
8691	448	5	under	under	IN
8691	448	6	a	a	DT
8691	448	7	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	448	8	on	on	IN
8691	448	9	the	the	DT
8691	448	10	demand	demand	NN
8691	448	11	of	of	IN
8691	448	12	a	a	DT
8691	448	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	448	14	government	government	NN
8691	448	15	presents	present	VBZ
8691	448	16	a	a	DT
8691	448	17	debatable	debatable	JJ
8691	448	18	ground	ground	NN
8691	448	19	in	in	IN
8691	448	20	respect	respect	NN
8691	448	21	to	to	IN
8691	448	22	the	the	DT
8691	448	23	subject	subject	NN
8691	448	24	now	now	RB
8691	448	25	under	under	IN
8691	448	26	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	448	27	.	.	.
8691	449	1	The	the	DT
8691	449	2	surrender	surrender	NN
8691	449	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	449	4	an	an	DT
8691	449	5	executive	executive	JJ
8691	449	6	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	449	7	and	and	CC
8691	449	8	a	a	DT
8691	449	9	political	political	JJ
8691	449	10	act	act	NN
8691	449	11	.	.	.
8691	450	1	But	but	CC
8691	450	2	the	the	DT
8691	450	3	laws	law	NNS
8691	450	4	may	may	MD
8691	450	5	provide	provide	VB
8691	450	6	for	for	IN
8691	450	7	a	a	DT
8691	450	8	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
8691	450	9	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	450	10	before	before	IN
8691	450	11	a	a	DT
8691	450	12	court	court	NN
8691	450	13	into	into	IN
8691	450	14	the	the	DT
8691	450	15	propriety	propriety	NN
8691	450	16	of	of	IN
8691	450	17	complying	comply	VBG
8691	450	18	with	with	IN
8691	450	19	the	the	DT
8691	450	20	demand	demand	NN
8691	450	21	.	.	.
8691	451	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	451	2	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	451	3	provide	provide	VBP
8691	451	4	for	for	IN
8691	451	5	a	a	DT
8691	451	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	451	7	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	451	8	by	by	IN
8691	451	9	writ	writ	NN
8691	451	10	of	of	IN
8691	451	11	_	_	NNP
8691	451	12	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	451	13	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	451	14	_	_	NNP
8691	451	15	to	to	TO
8691	451	16	release	release	VB
8691	451	17	any	any	DT
8691	451	18	one	one	NN
8691	451	19	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	451	20	in	in	IN
8691	451	21	such	such	PDT
8691	451	22	a	a	DT
8691	451	23	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	451	24	if	if	IN
8691	451	25	held	hold	VBN
8691	451	26	without	without	IN
8691	451	27	due	due	JJ
8691	451	28	cause	cause	NN
8691	451	29	.	.	.
8691	452	1	Is	be	VBZ
8691	452	2	the	the	DT
8691	452	3	court	court	NN
8691	452	4	before	before	IN
8691	452	5	which	which	WDT
8691	452	6	either	either	DT
8691	452	7	of	of	IN
8691	452	8	these	these	DT
8691	452	9	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	452	10	may	may	MD
8691	452	11	be	be	VB
8691	452	12	had	have	VBN
8691	452	13	at	at	IN
8691	452	14	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	452	15	to	to	TO
8691	452	16	receive	receive	VB
8691	452	17	advice	advice	NN
8691	452	18	or	or	CC
8691	452	19	submit	submit	NN
8691	452	20	to	to	IN
8691	452	21	instructions	instruction	NNS
8691	452	22	from	from	IN
8691	452	23	the	the	DT
8691	452	24	President	President	NNP
8691	452	25	of	of	IN
8691	452	26	the	the	DT
8691	452	27	United	United	NNP
8691	452	28	States	States	NNP
8691	452	29	?	?	.
8691	453	1	This	this	DT
8691	453	2	question	question	NN
8691	453	3	stirred	stir	VBD
8691	453	4	the	the	DT
8691	453	5	country	country	NN
8691	453	6	to	to	IN
8691	453	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	453	8	depths	depth	NNS
8691	453	9	in	in	IN
8691	453	10	1799	1799	CD
8691	453	11	.	.	.
8691	454	1	Great	Great	NNP
8691	454	2	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	454	3	applied	apply	VBD
8691	454	4	to	to	IN
8691	454	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	454	6	government	government	NN
8691	454	7	for	for	IN
8691	454	8	the	the	DT
8691	454	9	extradition	extradition	NN
8691	454	10	of	of	IN
8691	454	11	a	a	DT
8691	454	12	seaman	seaman	NN
8691	454	13	who	who	WP
8691	454	14	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	454	15	to	to	TO
8691	454	16	be	be	VB
8691	454	17	an	an	DT
8691	454	18	American	american	JJ
8691	454	19	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	454	20	and	and	CC
8691	454	21	was	be	VBD
8691	454	22	charged	charge	VBN
8691	454	23	with	with	IN
8691	454	24	committing	commit	VBG
8691	454	25	murder	murder	NN
8691	454	26	on	on	IN
8691	454	27	a	a	DT
8691	454	28	British	british	JJ
8691	454	29	man	man	NN
8691	454	30	-	-	HYPH
8691	454	31	of	of	IN
8691	454	32	-	-	HYPH
8691	454	33	war	war	NN
8691	454	34	.	.	.
8691	455	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	455	2	was	be	VBD
8691	455	3	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	455	4	in	in	IN
8691	455	5	South	South	NNP
8691	455	6	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	455	7	,	,	,
8691	455	8	under	under	IN
8691	455	9	a	a	DT
8691	455	10	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	455	11	from	from	IN
8691	455	12	the	the	DT
8691	455	13	District	District	NNP
8691	455	14	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	455	15	,	,	,
8691	455	16	and	and	CC
8691	455	17	lodged	lodge	VBD
8691	455	18	in	in	IN
8691	455	19	jail	jail	NN
8691	455	20	.	.	.
8691	456	1	There	there	EX
8691	456	2	was	be	VBD
8691	456	3	a	a	DT
8691	456	4	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	456	5	of	of	IN
8691	456	6	extradition	extradition	NN
8691	456	7	between	between	IN
8691	456	8	the	the	DT
8691	456	9	two	two	CD
8691	456	10	powers	power	NNS
8691	456	11	covering	cover	VBG
8691	456	12	cases	case	NNS
8691	456	13	of	of	IN
8691	456	14	murder	murder	NN
8691	456	15	,	,	,
8691	456	16	but	but	CC
8691	456	17	no	no	DT
8691	456	18	particular	particular	JJ
8691	456	19	machinery	machinery	NN
8691	456	20	had	have	VBD
8691	456	21	been	be	VBN
8691	456	22	provided	provide	VBN
8691	456	23	for	for	IN
8691	456	24	regulating	regulate	VBG
8691	456	25	the	the	DT
8691	456	26	surrender	surrender	NN
8691	456	27	.	.	.
8691	457	1	The	the	DT
8691	457	2	British	british	JJ
8691	457	3	consul	consul	NN
8691	457	4	asked	ask	VBD
8691	457	5	the	the	DT
8691	457	6	judge	judge	NN
8691	457	7	who	who	WP
8691	457	8	had	have	VBD
8691	457	9	made	make	VBN
8691	457	10	the	the	DT
8691	457	11	commitment	commitment	NN
8691	457	12	to	to	TO
8691	457	13	order	order	VB
8691	457	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	457	15	delivery	delivery	NN
8691	457	16	to	to	IN
8691	457	17	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	457	18	.	.	.
8691	458	1	The	the	DT
8691	458	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	458	3	doubted	doubt	VBD
8691	458	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	458	5	power	power	NN
8691	458	6	to	to	TO
8691	458	7	do	do	VB
8691	458	8	so	so	RB
8691	458	9	.	.	.
8691	459	1	Thereupon	thereupon	RB
8691	459	2	the	the	DT
8691	459	3	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
8691	459	4	of	of	IN
8691	459	5	State	State	NNP
8691	459	6	,	,	,
8691	459	7	by	by	IN
8691	459	8	authority	authority	NN
8691	459	9	of	of	IN
8691	459	10	the	the	DT
8691	459	11	President	President	NNP
8691	459	12	,	,	,
8691	459	13	wrote	write	VBD
8691	459	14	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	459	15	that	that	IN
8691	459	16	the	the	DT
8691	459	17	President	President	NNP
8691	459	18	advised	advise	VBD
8691	459	19	and	and	CC
8691	459	20	requested	request	VBD
8691	459	21	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	459	22	to	to	TO
8691	459	23	make	make	VB
8691	459	24	the	the	DT
8691	459	25	surrender	surrender	NN
8691	459	26	,	,	,
8691	459	27	if	if	IN
8691	459	28	satisfied	satisfy	VBN
8691	459	29	with	with	IN
8691	459	30	the	the	DT
8691	459	31	proofs	proof	NNS
8691	459	32	of	of	IN
8691	459	33	criminality	criminality	NN
8691	459	34	,	,	,
8691	459	35	as	as	IN
8691	459	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	459	37	(	(	-LRB-
8691	459	38	the	the	DT
8691	459	39	President	President	NNP
8691	459	40	)	)	-RRB-
8691	459	41	was	be	VBD
8691	459	42	of	of	IN
8691	459	43	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	459	44	that	that	IN
8691	459	45	any	any	DT
8691	459	46	crime	crime	NN
8691	459	47	committed	commit	VBN
8691	459	48	on	on	IN
8691	459	49	a	a	DT
8691	459	50	man	man	NN
8691	459	51	-	-	HYPH
8691	459	52	of	of	IN
8691	459	53	-	-	HYPH
8691	459	54	war	war	NN
8691	459	55	was	be	VBD
8691	459	56	committed	commit	VBN
8691	459	57	within	within	IN
8691	459	58	the	the	DT
8691	459	59	territory	territory	NN
8691	459	60	of	of	IN
8691	459	61	the	the	DT
8691	459	62	power	power	NN
8691	459	63	to	to	TO
8691	459	64	which	which	WDT
8691	459	65	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	459	66	belonged	belong	VBD
8691	459	67	.	.	.
8691	460	1	The	the	DT
8691	460	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	460	3	complied	comply	VBD
8691	460	4	with	with	IN
8691	460	5	this	this	DT
8691	460	6	request	request	NN
8691	460	7	,	,	,
8691	460	8	after	after	IN
8691	460	9	a	a	DT
8691	460	10	public	public	JJ
8691	460	11	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	460	12	on	on	IN
8691	460	13	a	a	DT
8691	460	14	writ	writ	NN
8691	460	15	of	of	IN
8691	460	16	_	_	NNP
8691	460	17	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	460	18	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	460	19	_	_	NNP
8691	460	20	,	,	,
8691	460	21	under	under	IN
8691	460	22	which	which	WDT
8691	460	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	460	24	ordered	order	VBD
8691	460	25	the	the	DT
8691	460	26	man	man	NN
8691	460	27	in	in	IN
8691	460	28	question	question	NN
8691	460	29	to	to	TO
8691	460	30	be	be	VB
8691	460	31	brought	bring	VBN
8691	460	32	before	before	IN
8691	460	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	460	34	,	,	,
8691	460	35	and	and	CC
8691	460	36	in	in	IN
8691	460	37	the	the	DT
8691	460	38	course	course	NN
8691	460	39	of	of	IN
8691	460	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	460	41	this	this	DT
8691	460	42	letter	letter	NN
8691	460	43	was	be	VBD
8691	460	44	shown	show	VBN
8691	460	45	to	to	IN
8691	460	46	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	460	47	on	on	IN
8691	460	48	both	both	DT
8691	460	49	sides	side	NNS
8691	460	50	.	.	.
8691	461	1	The	the	DT
8691	461	2	surrender	surrender	NN
8691	461	3	became	become	VBD
8691	461	4	at	at	IN
8691	461	5	once	once	IN
8691	461	6	the	the	DT
8691	461	7	subject	subject	NN
8691	461	8	of	of	IN
8691	461	9	heated	heated	JJ
8691	461	10	debates	debate	NNS
8691	461	11	in	in	IN
8691	461	12	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	461	13	,	,	,
8691	461	14	but	but	CC
8691	461	15	the	the	DT
8691	461	16	President	President	NNP
8691	461	17	's	's	POS
8691	461	18	course	course	NN
8691	461	19	was	be	VBD
8691	461	20	ably	ably	RB
8691	461	21	and	and	CC
8691	461	22	conclusively	conclusively	RB
8691	461	23	defended	defend	VBN
8691	461	24	by	by	IN
8691	461	25	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	461	26	on	on	IN
8691	461	27	the	the	DT
8691	461	28	floor	floor	NN
8691	461	29	of	of	IN
8691	461	30	the	the	DT
8691	461	31	House,[Footnote	House,[Footnote	NNP
8691	461	32	:	:	:
8691	461	33	United	United	NNP
8691	461	34	States	States	NNP
8691	461	35	_	_	NNP
8691	461	36	v.	v.	IN
8691	461	37	_	_	NNP
8691	461	38	Nash	Nash	NNP
8691	461	39	_	_	NNP
8691	461	40	alias	alia	NNS
8691	461	41	_	_	NNP
8691	461	42	Robins	Robins	NNP
8691	461	43	,	,	,
8691	461	44	Bee	Bee	NNP
8691	461	45	's	's	POS
8691	461	46	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	461	47	,	,	,
8691	461	48	266	266	CD
8691	461	49	;	;	:
8691	461	50	Robbins	Robbins	NNP
8691	461	51	'	'	POS
8691	461	52	Case	Case	NNP
8691	461	53	,	,	,
8691	461	54	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
8691	461	55	's	's	POS
8691	461	56	State	State	NNP
8691	461	57	Trials	Trials	NNPS
8691	461	58	,	,	,
8691	461	59	392	392	CD
8691	461	60	.	.	.
8691	461	61	]	]	-RRB-
8691	462	1	and	and	CC
8691	462	2	the	the	DT
8691	462	3	course	course	NN
8691	462	4	pursued	pursue	VBN
8691	462	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	462	6	since	since	IN
8691	462	7	been	be	VBN
8691	462	8	followed	follow	VBN
8691	462	9	in	in	IN
8691	462	10	substance	substance	NN
8691	462	11	by	by	IN
8691	462	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	462	13	extradition	extradition	NN
8691	462	14	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	462	15	.	.	.
8691	463	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	463	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	463	3	:	:	:
8691	463	4	United	United	NNP
8691	463	5	States	States	NNP
8691	463	6	Revised	Revised	NNP
8691	463	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	463	8	,	,	,
8691	463	9	Secs	Secs	NNP
8691	463	10	.	.	.
8691	464	1	5270	5270	CD
8691	464	2	,	,	,
8691	464	3	5272	5272	CD
8691	464	4	.	.	.
8691	464	5	]	]	-RRB-
8691	465	1	These	these	DT
8691	465	2	provide	provide	VBP
8691	465	3	for	for	IN
8691	465	4	a	a	DT
8691	465	5	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	465	6	of	of	IN
8691	465	7	a	a	DT
8691	465	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	465	9	character	character	NN
8691	465	10	,	,	,
8691	465	11	and	and	CC
8691	465	12	then	then	RB
8691	465	13	,	,	,
8691	465	14	if	if	IN
8691	465	15	that	that	DT
8691	465	16	results	result	VBZ
8691	465	17	in	in	IN
8691	465	18	a	a	DT
8691	465	19	determination	determination	NN
8691	465	20	that	that	IN
8691	465	21	a	a	DT
8691	465	22	surrender	surrender	NN
8691	465	23	should	should	MD
8691	465	24	be	be	VB
8691	465	25	made	make	VBN
8691	465	26	,	,	,
8691	465	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	465	28	may	may	MD
8691	465	29	be	be	VB
8691	465	30	ordered	order	VBN
8691	465	31	on	on	IN
8691	465	32	a	a	DT
8691	465	33	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	465	34	from	from	IN
8691	465	35	the	the	DT
8691	465	36	State	State	NNP
8691	465	37	Department	Department	NNP
8691	465	38	.	.	.
8691	466	1	On	on	IN
8691	466	2	the	the	DT
8691	466	3	other	other	JJ
8691	466	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	466	5	,	,	,
8691	466	6	the	the	DT
8691	466	7	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
8691	466	8	provision	provision	NN
8691	466	9	of	of	IN
8691	466	10	the	the	DT
8691	466	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	466	12	of	of	IN
8691	466	13	the	the	DT
8691	466	14	United	United	NNP
8691	466	15	States	States	NNP
8691	466	16	which	which	WDT
8691	466	17	makes	make	VBZ
8691	466	18	treaties	treaty	NNS
8691	466	19	the	the	DT
8691	466	20	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	466	21	law	law	NNP
8691	466	22	of	of	IN
8691	466	23	the	the	DT
8691	466	24	land	land	NN
8691	466	25	calls	call	VBZ
8691	466	26	upon	upon	IN
8691	466	27	the	the	DT
8691	466	28	courts	court	NNS
8691	466	29	to	to	TO
8691	466	30	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	466	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	466	32	according	accord	VBG
8691	466	33	to	to	IN
8691	466	34	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	466	35	interpretation	interpretation	NN
8691	466	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	466	37	may	may	MD
8691	466	38	conclude	conclude	VB
8691	466	39	to	to	TO
8691	466	40	give	give	VB
8691	466	41	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	466	42	,	,	,
8691	466	43	even	even	RB
8691	466	44	if	if	IN
8691	466	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	466	46	should	should	MD
8691	466	47	differ	differ	VB
8691	466	48	from	from	IN
8691	466	49	that	that	DT
8691	466	50	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	466	51	by	by	IN
8691	466	52	the	the	DT
8691	466	53	President	President	NNP
8691	466	54	or	or	CC
8691	466	55	the	the	DT
8691	466	56	State	State	NNP
8691	466	57	Department	Department	NNP
8691	466	58	.	.	.
8691	467	1	If	if	IN
8691	467	2	a	a	DT
8691	467	3	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	467	4	prescribes	prescribe	VBZ
8691	467	5	a	a	DT
8691	467	6	rule	rule	NN
8691	467	7	by	by	IN
8691	467	8	which	which	WDT
8691	467	9	the	the	DT
8691	467	10	rights	right	NNS
8691	467	11	of	of	IN
8691	467	12	private	private	JJ
8691	467	13	individuals	individual	NNS
8691	467	14	are	be	VBP
8691	467	15	to	to	TO
8691	467	16	be	be	VB
8691	467	17	determined	determine	VBN
8691	467	18	,	,	,
8691	467	19	and	and	CC
8691	467	20	those	those	DT
8691	467	21	rights	right	NNS
8691	467	22	are	be	VBP
8691	467	23	such	such	JJ
8691	467	24	as	as	IN
8691	467	25	can	can	MD
8691	467	26	be	be	VB
8691	467	27	appropriately	appropriately	RB
8691	467	28	made	make	VBN
8691	467	29	the	the	DT
8691	467	30	subject	subject	NN
8691	467	31	of	of	IN
8691	467	32	a	a	DT
8691	467	33	lawsuit	lawsuit	NN
8691	467	34	,	,	,
8691	467	35	the	the	DT
8691	467	36	court	court	NN
8691	467	37	before	before	IN
8691	467	38	which	which	WDT
8691	467	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	467	40	may	may	MD
8691	467	41	be	be	VB
8691	467	42	brought	bring	VBN
8691	467	43	has	have	VBZ
8691	467	44	as	as	IN
8691	467	45	full	full	JJ
8691	467	46	authority	authority	NN
8691	467	47	to	to	TO
8691	467	48	construe	construe	VB
8691	467	49	the	the	DT
8691	467	50	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	467	51	as	as	IN
8691	467	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	467	53	would	would	MD
8691	467	54	have	have	VB
8691	467	55	to	to	TO
8691	467	56	construe	construe	VB
8691	467	57	an	an	DT
8691	467	58	act	act	NN
8691	467	59	of	of	IN
8691	467	60	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	467	61	,	,	,
8691	467	62	were	be	VBD
8691	467	63	the	the	DT
8691	467	64	matter	matter	NN
8691	467	65	in	in	IN
8691	467	66	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	467	67	one	one	CD
8691	467	68	of	of	IN
8691	467	69	a	a	DT
8691	467	70	statutory	statutory	JJ
8691	467	71	nature	nature	NN
8691	467	72	.	.	.
8691	468	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	468	2	can	can	MD
8691	468	3	not	not	RB
8691	468	4	be	be	VB
8691	468	5	appropriately	appropriately	RB
8691	468	6	made	make	VBN
8691	468	7	the	the	DT
8691	468	8	subject	subject	NN
8691	468	9	of	of	IN
8691	468	10	a	a	DT
8691	468	11	lawsuit	lawsuit	NN
8691	468	12	so	so	RB
8691	468	13	long	long	RB
8691	468	14	as	as	IN
8691	468	15	the	the	DT
8691	468	16	questions	question	NNS
8691	468	17	involved	involve	VBN
8691	468	18	are	be	VBP
8691	468	19	under	under	IN
8691	468	20	active	active	JJ
8691	468	21	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	468	22	in	in	IN
8691	468	23	the	the	DT
8691	468	24	course	course	NN
8691	468	25	of	of	IN
8691	468	26	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
8691	468	27	negotiation	negotiation	NN
8691	468	28	and	and	CC
8691	468	29	pending	pende	VBG
8691	468	30	for	for	IN
8691	468	31	decision	decision	NN
8691	468	32	before	before	IN
8691	468	33	the	the	DT
8691	468	34	President	President	NNP
8691	468	35	.	.	.
8691	469	1	Let	let	VB
8691	469	2	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	469	3	,	,	,
8691	469	4	however	however	RB
8691	469	5	,	,	,
8691	469	6	once	once	RB
8691	469	7	make	make	VB
8691	469	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	469	9	decision	decision	NN
8691	469	10	and	and	CC
8691	469	11	the	the	DT
8691	469	12	doors	door	NNS
8691	469	13	of	of	IN
8691	469	14	the	the	DT
8691	469	15	court	court	NN
8691	469	16	fly	fly	VB
8691	469	17	open	open	RB
8691	469	18	.	.	.
8691	470	1	These	these	DT
8691	470	2	principles	principle	NNS
8691	470	3	are	be	VBP
8691	470	4	well	well	RB
8691	470	5	illustrated	illustrate	VBN
8691	470	6	by	by	IN
8691	470	7	some	some	DT
8691	470	8	incidents	incident	NNS
8691	470	9	of	of	IN
8691	470	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	470	11	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	470	12	with	with	IN
8691	470	13	Great	Great	NNP
8691	470	14	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	470	15	over	over	IN
8691	470	16	the	the	DT
8691	470	17	seal	seal	NN
8691	470	18	fisheries	fishery	NNS
8691	470	19	in	in	IN
8691	470	20	Behring	Behring	NNP
8691	470	21	Sea	Sea	NNP
8691	470	22	.	.	.
8691	471	1	There	there	EX
8691	471	2	was	be	VBD
8691	471	3	a	a	DT
8691	471	4	serious	serious	JJ
8691	471	5	dispute	dispute	NN
8691	471	6	between	between	IN
8691	471	7	the	the	DT
8691	471	8	two	two	CD
8691	471	9	governments	government	NNS
8691	471	10	as	as	IN
8691	471	11	to	to	IN
8691	471	12	the	the	DT
8691	471	13	limits	limit	NNS
8691	471	14	of	of	IN
8691	471	15	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	471	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	471	17	over	over	IN
8691	471	18	the	the	DT
8691	471	19	waters	water	NNS
8691	471	20	adjacent	adjacent	JJ
8691	471	21	to	to	IN
8691	471	22	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
8691	471	23	.	.	.
8691	472	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	472	2	maintained	maintain	VBD
8691	472	3	that	that	IN
8691	472	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	472	5	ran	run	VBD
8691	472	6	to	to	IN
8691	472	7	the	the	DT
8691	472	8	middle	middle	NN
8691	472	9	of	of	IN
8691	472	10	Behring	Behring	NNP
8691	472	11	's	's	POS
8691	472	12	Straits	Straits	NNPS
8691	472	13	and	and	CC
8691	472	14	from	from	IN
8691	472	15	the	the	DT
8691	472	16	meridian	meridian	NN
8691	472	17	of	of	IN
8691	472	18	172Â	172â	CD
8691	472	19	°	°	,
8691	472	20	to	to	IN
8691	472	21	that	that	DT
8691	472	22	of	of	IN
8691	472	23	193Â	193â	CD
8691	472	24	°	°	,
8691	472	25	west	west	NNP
8691	472	26	longitude	longitude	NN
8691	472	27	.	.	.
8691	473	1	Great	Great	NNP
8691	473	2	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	473	3	contended	contend	VBD
8691	473	4	for	for	IN
8691	473	5	the	the	DT
8691	473	6	three	three	CD
8691	473	7	-	-	HYPH
8691	473	8	mile	mile	NN
8691	473	9	limit	limit	NN
8691	473	10	.	.	.
8691	474	1	Pending	pende	VBG
8691	474	2	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
8691	474	3	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
8691	474	4	as	as	IN
8691	474	5	to	to	IN
8691	474	6	this	this	DT
8691	474	7	point	point	NN
8691	474	8	,	,	,
8691	474	9	one	one	CD
8691	474	10	of	of	IN
8691	474	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	474	12	revenue	revenue	NN
8691	474	13	cruisers	cruiser	NNS
8691	474	14	seized	seize	VBD
8691	474	15	a	a	DT
8691	474	16	Canadian	canadian	JJ
8691	474	17	vessel	vessel	NN
8691	474	18	which	which	WDT
8691	474	19	was	be	VBD
8691	474	20	engaged	engage	VBN
8691	474	21	in	in	IN
8691	474	22	seal	seal	NN
8691	474	23	fishing	fishing	NN
8691	474	24	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	474	25	sixty	sixty	CD
8691	474	26	miles	mile	NNS
8691	474	27	from	from	IN
8691	474	28	the	the	DT
8691	474	29	Alaskan	alaskan	JJ
8691	474	30	coast	coast	NN
8691	474	31	,	,	,
8691	474	32	and	and	CC
8691	474	33	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	474	34	was	be	VBD
8691	474	35	condemned	condemn	VBN
8691	474	36	,	,	,
8691	474	37	on	on	IN
8691	474	38	a	a	DT
8691	474	39	libel	libel	NN
8691	474	40	by	by	IN
8691	474	41	the	the	DT
8691	474	42	United	United	NNP
8691	474	43	States	States	NNP
8691	474	44	,	,	,
8691	474	45	by	by	IN
8691	474	46	an	an	DT
8691	474	47	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	474	48	court	court	NN
8691	474	49	in	in	IN
8691	474	50	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
8691	474	51	.	.	.
8691	475	1	The	the	DT
8691	475	2	owner	owner	NN
8691	475	3	in	in	IN
8691	475	4	1891	1891	CD
8691	475	5	applied	apply	VBD
8691	475	6	to	to	IN
8691	475	7	the	the	DT
8691	475	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	475	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	475	10	of	of	IN
8691	475	11	the	the	DT
8691	475	12	United	United	NNP
8691	475	13	States	States	NNP
8691	475	14	for	for	IN
8691	475	15	a	a	DT
8691	475	16	writ	writ	NN
8691	475	17	to	to	TO
8691	475	18	prohibit	prohibit	VB
8691	475	19	the	the	DT
8691	475	20	enforcement	enforcement	NN
8691	475	21	of	of	IN
8691	475	22	this	this	DT
8691	475	23	decree	decree	NN
8691	475	24	of	of	IN
8691	475	25	confiscation	confiscation	NN
8691	475	26	.	.	.
8691	476	1	The	the	DT
8691	476	2	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
8691	476	3	-	-	HYPH
8691	476	4	General	General	NNP
8691	476	5	of	of	IN
8691	476	6	Canada	Canada	NNP
8691	476	7	filed	file	VBD
8691	476	8	in	in	IN
8691	476	9	this	this	DT
8691	476	10	suit	suit	NN
8691	476	11	papers	paper	NNS
8691	476	12	in	in	IN
8691	476	13	aid	aid	NN
8691	476	14	of	of	IN
8691	476	15	the	the	DT
8691	476	16	application	application	NN
8691	476	17	,	,	,
8691	476	18	stating	state	VBG
8691	476	19	that	that	IN
8691	476	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	476	21	did	do	VBD
8691	476	22	so	so	RB
8691	476	23	with	with	IN
8691	476	24	the	the	DT
8691	476	25	knowledge	knowledge	NN
8691	476	26	and	and	CC
8691	476	27	approval	approval	NN
8691	476	28	of	of	IN
8691	476	29	the	the	DT
8691	476	30	imperial	imperial	JJ
8691	476	31	government	government	NN
8691	476	32	,	,	,
8691	476	33	and	and	CC
8691	476	34	that	that	IN
8691	476	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	476	36	would	would	MD
8691	476	37	be	be	VB
8691	476	38	represented	represent	VBN
8691	476	39	by	by	IN
8691	476	40	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	476	41	employed	employ	VBN
8691	476	42	by	by	IN
8691	476	43	the	the	DT
8691	476	44	British	British	NNP
8691	476	45	minister	minister	NNP
8691	476	46	resident	resident	NN
8691	476	47	.	.	.
8691	477	1	The	the	DT
8691	477	2	writ	writ	NNP
8691	477	3	was	be	VBD
8691	477	4	refused	refuse	VBN
8691	477	5	on	on	IN
8691	477	6	technical	technical	JJ
8691	477	7	grounds	ground	NNS
8691	477	8	,	,	,
8691	477	9	but	but	CC
8691	477	10	the	the	DT
8691	477	11	court	court	NN
8691	477	12	,	,	,
8691	477	13	through	through	IN
8691	477	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	477	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	477	16	Fuller	Fuller	NNP
8691	477	17	,	,	,
8691	477	18	made	make	VBD
8691	477	19	these	these	DT
8691	477	20	observations	observation	NNS
8691	477	21	as	as	IN
8691	477	22	to	to	IN
8691	477	23	the	the	DT
8691	477	24	merits	merit	NNS
8691	477	25	of	of	IN
8691	477	26	the	the	DT
8691	477	27	cause	cause	NN
8691	477	28	:	:	:
8691	477	29	In	in	IN
8691	477	30	this	this	DT
8691	477	31	case	case	NN
8691	477	32	,	,	,
8691	477	33	Her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	477	34	Britannic	Britannic	NNP
8691	477	35	Majesty	Majesty	NNP
8691	477	36	's	's	POS
8691	477	37	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
8691	477	38	-	-	HYPH
8691	477	39	General	General	NNP
8691	477	40	of	of	IN
8691	477	41	Canada	Canada	NNP
8691	477	42	has	have	VBZ
8691	477	43	presented	present	VBN
8691	477	44	,	,	,
8691	477	45	with	with	IN
8691	477	46	the	the	DT
8691	477	47	knowledge	knowledge	NN
8691	477	48	and	and	CC
8691	477	49	approval	approval	NN
8691	477	50	of	of	IN
8691	477	51	the	the	DT
8691	477	52	Imperial	imperial	JJ
8691	477	53	government	government	NN
8691	477	54	of	of	IN
8691	477	55	Great	Great	NNP
8691	477	56	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	477	57	,	,	,
8691	477	58	a	a	DT
8691	477	59	suggestion	suggestion	NN
8691	477	60	on	on	IN
8691	477	61	behalf	behalf	NN
8691	477	62	of	of	IN
8691	477	63	the	the	DT
8691	477	64	claimant	claimant	NN
8691	477	65	.	.	.
8691	478	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	478	2	represents	represent	VBZ
8691	478	3	no	no	DT
8691	478	4	property	property	NN
8691	478	5	interest	interest	NN
8691	478	6	in	in	IN
8691	478	7	the	the	DT
8691	478	8	vessel	vessel	NN
8691	478	9	,	,	,
8691	478	10	as	as	IN
8691	478	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	478	12	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	478	13	done	do	VBN
8691	478	14	by	by	IN
8691	478	15	consuls	consul	NNS
8691	478	16	,	,	,
8691	478	17	but	but	CC
8691	478	18	only	only	RB
8691	478	19	a	a	DT
8691	478	20	public	public	JJ
8691	478	21	political	political	JJ
8691	478	22	interest	interest	NN
8691	478	23	.	.	.
8691	479	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	479	2	are	be	VBP
8691	479	3	not	not	RB
8691	479	4	insensible	insensible	JJ
8691	479	5	to	to	IN
8691	479	6	the	the	DT
8691	479	7	courtesy	courtesy	NN
8691	479	8	implied	imply	VBN
8691	479	9	in	in	IN
8691	479	10	the	the	DT
8691	479	11	willingness	willingness	NN
8691	479	12	thus	thus	RB
8691	479	13	manifested	manifest	VBD
8691	479	14	that	that	IN
8691	479	15	this	this	DT
8691	479	16	court	court	NN
8691	479	17	should	should	MD
8691	479	18	proceed	proceed	VB
8691	479	19	to	to	IN
8691	479	20	a	a	DT
8691	479	21	decision	decision	NN
8691	479	22	on	on	IN
8691	479	23	the	the	DT
8691	479	24	main	main	JJ
8691	479	25	question	question	NN
8691	479	26	argued	argue	VBD
8691	479	27	for	for	IN
8691	479	28	the	the	DT
8691	479	29	petitioner	petitioner	NN
8691	479	30	;	;	:
8691	479	31	nor	nor	CC
8691	479	32	do	do	VBP
8691	479	33	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	479	34	permit	permit	VB
8691	479	35	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	479	36	to	to	TO
8691	479	37	doubt	doubt	VB
8691	479	38	that	that	IN
8691	479	39	under	under	IN
8691	479	40	such	such	JJ
8691	479	41	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	479	42	the	the	DT
8691	479	43	decision	decision	NN
8691	479	44	would	would	MD
8691	479	45	receive	receive	VB
8691	479	46	all	all	PDT
8691	479	47	the	the	DT
8691	479	48	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	479	49	that	that	IN
8691	479	50	the	the	DT
8691	479	51	utmost	utmost	JJ
8691	479	52	good	good	JJ
8691	479	53	faith	faith	NN
8691	479	54	would	would	MD
8691	479	55	require	require	VB
8691	479	56	;	;	:
8691	479	57	but	but	CC
8691	479	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	479	59	is	be	VBZ
8691	479	60	very	very	RB
8691	479	61	clear	clear	JJ
8691	479	62	that	that	IN
8691	479	63	,	,	,
8691	479	64	presented	present	VBN
8691	479	65	as	as	IN
8691	479	66	a	a	DT
8691	479	67	political	political	JJ
8691	479	68	question	question	NN
8691	479	69	merely	merely	RB
8691	479	70	,	,	,
8691	479	71	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	479	72	would	would	MD
8691	479	73	not	not	RB
8691	479	74	fall	fall	VB
8691	479	75	within	within	IN
8691	479	76	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	479	77	province	province	NN
8691	479	78	to	to	TO
8691	479	79	determine	determine	VB
8691	479	80	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	479	81	....	....	.
8691	479	82	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	479	83	are	be	VBP
8691	479	84	not	not	RB
8691	479	85	to	to	TO
8691	479	86	be	be	VB
8691	479	87	understood	understand	VBN
8691	479	88	,	,	,
8691	479	89	however	however	RB
8691	479	90	,	,	,
8691	479	91	as	as	IN
8691	479	92	underrating	underrate	VBG
8691	479	93	the	the	DT
8691	479	94	weight	weight	NN
8691	479	95	of	of	IN
8691	479	96	the	the	DT
8691	479	97	argument	argument	NN
8691	479	98	that	that	IN
8691	479	99	in	in	IN
8691	479	100	a	a	DT
8691	479	101	case	case	NN
8691	479	102	involving	involve	VBG
8691	479	103	private	private	JJ
8691	479	104	rights	right	NNS
8691	479	105	,	,	,
8691	479	106	the	the	DT
8691	479	107	court	court	NN
8691	479	108	may	may	MD
8691	479	109	be	be	VB
8691	479	110	obliged	oblige	VBN
8691	479	111	,	,	,
8691	479	112	if	if	IN
8691	479	113	those	those	DT
8691	479	114	rights	right	NNS
8691	479	115	are	be	VBP
8691	479	116	dependent	dependent	JJ
8691	479	117	upon	upon	IN
8691	479	118	the	the	DT
8691	479	119	construction	construction	NN
8691	479	120	of	of	IN
8691	479	121	acts	act	NNS
8691	479	122	of	of	IN
8691	479	123	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	479	124	or	or	CC
8691	479	125	of	of	IN
8691	479	126	a	a	DT
8691	479	127	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	479	128	,	,	,
8691	479	129	and	and	CC
8691	479	130	the	the	DT
8691	479	131	case	case	NN
8691	479	132	turns	turn	VBZ
8691	479	133	upon	upon	IN
8691	479	134	a	a	DT
8691	479	135	question	question	NN
8691	479	136	,	,	,
8691	479	137	public	public	JJ
8691	479	138	in	in	IN
8691	479	139	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	479	140	nature	nature	NN
8691	479	141	,	,	,
8691	479	142	which	which	WDT
8691	479	143	has	have	VBZ
8691	479	144	not	not	RB
8691	479	145	been	be	VBN
8691	479	146	determined	determine	VBN
8691	479	147	by	by	IN
8691	479	148	the	the	DT
8691	479	149	political	political	JJ
8691	479	150	departments	department	NNS
8691	479	151	in	in	IN
8691	479	152	the	the	DT
8691	479	153	form	form	NN
8691	479	154	of	of	IN
8691	479	155	a	a	DT
8691	479	156	law	law	NN
8691	479	157	specifically	specifically	RB
8691	479	158	settling	settle	VBG
8691	479	159	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	479	160	,	,	,
8691	479	161	or	or	CC
8691	479	162	authorizing	authorize	VBG
8691	479	163	the	the	DT
8691	479	164	executive	executive	NN
8691	479	165	to	to	TO
8691	479	166	do	do	VB
8691	479	167	so	so	RB
8691	479	168	,	,	,
8691	479	169	to	to	TO
8691	479	170	render	render	VB
8691	479	171	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	479	172	,	,	,
8691	479	173	"	"	``
8691	479	174	since	since	IN
8691	479	175	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	479	176	have	have	VBP
8691	479	177	no	no	DT
8691	479	178	more	more	RBR
8691	479	179	right	right	JJ
8691	479	180	to	to	TO
8691	479	181	decline	decline	VB
8691	479	182	the	the	DT
8691	479	183	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	479	184	which	which	WDT
8691	479	185	is	be	VBZ
8691	479	186	given	give	VBN
8691	479	187	than	than	IN
8691	479	188	to	to	TO
8691	479	189	usurp	usurp	VB
8691	479	190	that	that	DT
8691	479	191	which	which	WDT
8691	479	192	is	be	VBZ
8691	479	193	not	not	RB
8691	479	194	given	give	VBN
8691	479	195	.	.	.
8691	480	1	"	"	``
8691	480	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	480	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	480	4	:	:	:
8691	480	5	_	_	NNP
8691	480	6	In	In	NNP
8691	480	7	re	re	NN
8691	480	8	_	_	NNP
8691	480	9	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
8691	480	10	,	,	,
8691	480	11	143	143	CD
8691	480	12	United	United	NNP
8691	480	13	States	States	NNP
8691	480	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	480	15	,	,	,
8691	480	16	472	472	CD
8691	480	17	,	,	,
8691	480	18	503	503	CD
8691	480	19	.	.	.
8691	480	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	481	1	In	in	IN
8691	481	2	the	the	DT
8691	481	3	following	following	JJ
8691	481	4	year	year	NN
8691	481	5	a	a	DT
8691	481	6	convention	convention	NN
8691	481	7	was	be	VBD
8691	481	8	concluded	conclude	VBN
8691	481	9	between	between	IN
8691	481	10	the	the	DT
8691	481	11	United	United	NNP
8691	481	12	States	States	NNP
8691	481	13	and	and	CC
8691	481	14	Great	Great	NNP
8691	481	15	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	481	16	for	for	IN
8691	481	17	the	the	DT
8691	481	18	submission	submission	NN
8691	481	19	of	of	IN
8691	481	20	the	the	DT
8691	481	21	question	question	NN
8691	481	22	of	of	IN
8691	481	23	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	481	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	481	25	over	over	IN
8691	481	26	Behring	Behring	NNP
8691	481	27	's	's	POS
8691	481	28	Sea	Sea	NNP
8691	481	29	to	to	IN
8691	481	30	arbitration	arbitration	NN
8691	481	31	.	.	.
8691	482	1	The	the	DT
8691	482	2	arbitration	arbitration	NN
8691	482	3	took	take	VBD
8691	482	4	place	place	NN
8691	482	5	and	and	CC
8691	482	6	the	the	DT
8691	482	7	award	award	NN
8691	482	8	supported	support	VBD
8691	482	9	the	the	DT
8691	482	10	British	british	JJ
8691	482	11	contention	contention	NN
8691	482	12	.	.	.
8691	483	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	483	2	passed	pass	VBD
8691	483	3	an	an	DT
8691	483	4	act	act	NN
8691	483	5	to	to	TO
8691	483	6	give	give	VB
8691	483	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	483	8	full	full	JJ
8691	483	9	effect	effect	NN
8691	483	10	.	.	.
8691	484	1	The	the	DT
8691	484	2	convention	convention	NN
8691	484	3	provided	provide	VBN
8691	484	4	in	in	IN
8691	484	5	terms	term	NNS
8691	484	6	that	that	IN
8691	484	7	"	"	``
8691	484	8	the	the	DT
8691	484	9	high	high	JJ
8691	484	10	contracting	contract	VBG
8691	484	11	parties	party	NNS
8691	484	12	engage	engage	VBP
8691	484	13	to	to	TO
8691	484	14	consider	consider	VB
8691	484	15	the	the	DT
8691	484	16	result	result	NN
8691	484	17	of	of	IN
8691	484	18	the	the	DT
8691	484	19	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	484	20	of	of	IN
8691	484	21	the	the	DT
8691	484	22	tribunal	tribunal	NNP
8691	484	23	of	of	IN
8691	484	24	arbitration	arbitration	NN
8691	484	25	as	as	IN
8691	484	26	a	a	DT
8691	484	27	full	full	JJ
8691	484	28	,	,	,
8691	484	29	perfect	perfect	JJ
8691	484	30	and	and	CC
8691	484	31	final	final	JJ
8691	484	32	settlement	settlement	NN
8691	484	33	of	of	IN
8691	484	34	all	all	PDT
8691	484	35	the	the	DT
8691	484	36	questions	question	NNS
8691	484	37	referred	refer	VBD
8691	484	38	to	to	IN
8691	484	39	by	by	IN
8691	484	40	the	the	DT
8691	484	41	arbitrators	arbitrator	NNS
8691	484	42	.	.	.
8691	484	43	"	"	''
8691	485	1	In	in	IN
8691	485	2	July	July	NNP
8691	485	3	,	,	,
8691	485	4	1891	1891	CD
8691	485	5	,	,	,
8691	485	6	before	before	IN
8691	485	7	the	the	DT
8691	485	8	award	award	NN
8691	485	9	was	be	VBD
8691	485	10	made	make	VBN
8691	485	11	,	,	,
8691	485	12	an	an	DT
8691	485	13	American	american	JJ
8691	485	14	vessel	vessel	NN
8691	485	15	engaged	engage	VBN
8691	485	16	in	in	IN
8691	485	17	the	the	DT
8691	485	18	seal	seal	NN
8691	485	19	fishery	fishery	NN
8691	485	20	outside	outside	IN
8691	485	21	the	the	DT
8691	485	22	three	three	CD
8691	485	23	-	-	HYPH
8691	485	24	mile	mile	NN
8691	485	25	limit	limit	NN
8691	485	26	was	be	VBD
8691	485	27	seized	seize	VBN
8691	485	28	by	by	IN
8691	485	29	one	one	CD
8691	485	30	of	of	IN
8691	485	31	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	485	32	revenue	revenue	NN
8691	485	33	cutters	cutter	NNS
8691	485	34	.	.	.
8691	486	1	A	a	DT
8691	486	2	libel	libel	NN
8691	486	3	was	be	VBD
8691	486	4	filed	file	VBN
8691	486	5	by	by	IN
8691	486	6	the	the	DT
8691	486	7	United	United	NNP
8691	486	8	States	States	NNP
8691	486	9	in	in	IN
8691	486	10	the	the	DT
8691	486	11	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	486	12	court	court	NN
8691	486	13	for	for	IN
8691	486	14	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
8691	486	15	and	and	CC
8691	486	16	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	486	17	was	be	VBD
8691	486	18	condemned	condemn	VBN
8691	486	19	.	.	.
8691	487	1	Her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	487	2	owners	owner	NNS
8691	487	3	appealed	appeal	VBD
8691	487	4	to	to	IN
8691	487	5	the	the	DT
8691	487	6	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	487	7	Court	Court	NNP
8691	487	8	of	of	IN
8691	487	9	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	487	10	,	,	,
8691	487	11	on	on	IN
8691	487	12	the	the	DT
8691	487	13	ground	ground	NN
8691	487	14	that	that	IN
8691	487	15	the	the	DT
8691	487	16	seizure	seizure	NN
8691	487	17	was	be	VBD
8691	487	18	made	make	VBN
8691	487	19	outside	outside	IN
8691	487	20	of	of	IN
8691	487	21	the	the	DT
8691	487	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	487	23	of	of	IN
8691	487	24	the	the	DT
8691	487	25	United	United	NNP
8691	487	26	States	States	NNP
8691	487	27	.	.	.
8691	488	1	If	if	IN
8691	488	2	so	so	RB
8691	488	3	,	,	,
8691	488	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	488	5	were	be	VBD
8691	488	6	entitled	entitle	VBN
8691	488	7	to	to	IN
8691	488	8	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	488	9	release	release	NN
8691	488	10	.	.	.
8691	489	1	The	the	DT
8691	489	2	court	court	NN
8691	489	3	held	hold	VBD
8691	489	4	that	that	IN
8691	489	5	the	the	DT
8691	489	6	limits	limit	NNS
8691	489	7	of	of	IN
8691	489	8	this	this	DT
8691	489	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	489	10	were	be	VBD
8691	489	11	conclusively	conclusively	RB
8691	489	12	settled	settle	VBN
8691	489	13	by	by	IN
8691	489	14	the	the	DT
8691	489	15	award	award	NN
8691	489	16	,	,	,
8691	489	17	and	and	CC
8691	489	18	thus	thus	RB
8691	489	19	adverted	advert	VBN
8691	489	20	to	to	IN
8691	489	21	the	the	DT
8691	489	22	claim	claim	NN
8691	489	23	that	that	IN
8691	489	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	489	25	should	should	MD
8691	489	26	treat	treat	VB
8691	489	27	the	the	DT
8691	489	28	case	case	NN
8691	489	29	as	as	IN
8691	489	30	the	the	DT
8691	489	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	489	32	Court	Court	NNP
8691	489	33	of	of	IN
8691	489	34	the	the	DT
8691	489	35	United	United	NNP
8691	489	36	States	States	NNP
8691	489	37	had	have	VBD
8691	489	38	dealt	deal	VBN
8691	489	39	with	with	IN
8691	489	40	that	that	DT
8691	489	41	which	which	WDT
8691	489	42	followed	follow	VBD
8691	489	43	the	the	DT
8691	489	44	seizure	seizure	NN
8691	489	45	of	of	IN
8691	489	46	the	the	DT
8691	489	47	year	year	NN
8691	489	48	before	before	RB
8691	489	49	:	:	:
8691	489	50	This	this	DT
8691	489	51	question	question	NN
8691	489	52	has	have	VBZ
8691	489	53	been	be	VBN
8691	489	54	settled	settle	VBN
8691	489	55	by	by	IN
8691	489	56	the	the	DT
8691	489	57	award	award	NN
8691	489	58	of	of	IN
8691	489	59	the	the	DT
8691	489	60	arbitrators	arbitrator	NNS
8691	489	61	,	,	,
8691	489	62	and	and	CC
8691	489	63	this	this	DT
8691	489	64	settlement	settlement	NN
8691	489	65	must	must	MD
8691	489	66	be	be	VB
8691	489	67	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	489	68	"	"	''
8691	489	69	as	as	IN
8691	489	70	final	final	JJ
8691	489	71	.	.	.
8691	489	72	"	"	''
8691	490	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	490	2	follows	follow	VBZ
8691	490	3	therefrom	therefrom	NN
8691	490	4	that	that	IN
8691	490	5	the	the	DT
8691	490	6	words	word	NNS
8691	490	7	"	"	''
8691	490	8	in	in	IN
8691	490	9	the	the	DT
8691	490	10	waters	water	NNS
8691	490	11	thereof	thereof	RB
8691	490	12	,	,	,
8691	490	13	"	"	``
8691	490	14	as	as	IN
8691	490	15	used	use	VBN
8691	490	16	in	in	IN
8691	490	17	section	section	NN
8691	490	18	1956	1956	CD
8691	490	19	,	,	,
8691	490	20	and	and	CC
8691	490	21	the	the	DT
8691	490	22	words	word	NNS
8691	490	23	"	"	``
8691	490	24	dominion	dominion	NN
8691	490	25	of	of	IN
8691	490	26	the	the	DT
8691	490	27	United	United	NNP
8691	490	28	States	States	NNP
8691	490	29	in	in	IN
8691	490	30	the	the	DT
8691	490	31	waters	water	NNS
8691	490	32	of	of	IN
8691	490	33	Behring	Behring	NNP
8691	490	34	Sea	Sea	NNP
8691	490	35	,	,	,
8691	490	36	"	"	''
8691	490	37	in	in	IN
8691	490	38	the	the	DT
8691	490	39	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	490	40	thereto	thereto	NN
8691	490	41	,	,	,
8691	490	42	must	must	MD
8691	490	43	be	be	VB
8691	490	44	construed	construe	VBN
8691	490	45	to	to	TO
8691	490	46	mean	mean	VB
8691	490	47	the	the	DT
8691	490	48	waters	water	NNS
8691	490	49	within	within	IN
8691	490	50	three	three	CD
8691	490	51	miles	mile	NNS
8691	490	52	from	from	IN
8691	490	53	the	the	DT
8691	490	54	shores	shore	NNS
8691	490	55	of	of	IN
8691	490	56	Alaska	Alaska	NNP
8691	490	57	.	.	.
8691	491	1	In	in	IN
8691	491	2	coming	come	VBG
8691	491	3	to	to	IN
8691	491	4	this	this	DT
8691	491	5	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	491	6	,	,	,
8691	491	7	this	this	DT
8691	491	8	court	court	NN
8691	491	9	does	do	VBZ
8691	491	10	not	not	RB
8691	491	11	decide	decide	VB
8691	491	12	the	the	DT
8691	491	13	question	question	NN
8691	491	14	adversely	adversely	RB
8691	491	15	to	to	IN
8691	491	16	the	the	DT
8691	491	17	political	political	JJ
8691	491	18	department	department	NN
8691	491	19	of	of	IN
8691	491	20	the	the	DT
8691	491	21	government	government	NN
8691	491	22	.	.	.
8691	492	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	492	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	492	3	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
8691	492	4	true	true	JJ
8691	492	5	,	,	,
8691	492	6	as	as	IN
8691	492	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	492	8	been	be	VBN
8691	492	9	decided	decide	VBN
8691	492	10	by	by	IN
8691	492	11	the	the	DT
8691	492	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	492	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	492	14	,	,	,
8691	492	15	that	that	IN
8691	492	16	,	,	,
8691	492	17	in	in	IN
8691	492	18	pending	pende	VBG
8691	492	19	controversies	controversy	NNS
8691	492	20	,	,	,
8691	492	21	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
8691	492	22	questions	question	NNS
8691	492	23	which	which	WDT
8691	492	24	are	be	VBP
8691	492	25	undecided	undecided	JJ
8691	492	26	must	must	MD
8691	492	27	be	be	VB
8691	492	28	met	meet	VBN
8691	492	29	by	by	IN
8691	492	30	the	the	DT
8691	492	31	political	political	JJ
8691	492	32	department	department	NN
8691	492	33	of	of	IN
8691	492	34	the	the	DT
8691	492	35	government	government	NN
8691	492	36	.	.	.
8691	493	1	"	"	``
8691	493	2	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	493	3	are	be	VBP
8691	493	4	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	493	5	the	the	DT
8691	493	6	sphere	sphere	NN
8691	493	7	of	of	IN
8691	493	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	493	9	cognizance	cognizance	NN
8691	493	10	,	,	,
8691	493	11	"	"	''
8691	493	12	and	and	CC
8691	493	13	"	"	``
8691	493	14	if	if	IN
8691	493	15	a	a	DT
8691	493	16	wrong	wrong	NN
8691	493	17	has	have	VBZ
8691	493	18	been	be	VBN
8691	493	19	done	do	VBN
8691	493	20	,	,	,
8691	493	21	the	the	DT
8691	493	22	power	power	NN
8691	493	23	of	of	IN
8691	493	24	redress	redress	NNP
8691	493	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	493	26	with	with	IN
8691	493	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	493	28	,	,	,
8691	493	29	not	not	RB
8691	493	30	with	with	IN
8691	493	31	the	the	DT
8691	493	32	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	493	33	.	.	.
8691	493	34	"	"	''
8691	494	1	The	the	DT
8691	494	2	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
8691	494	3	Tobacco	Tobacco	NNP
8691	494	4	,	,	,
8691	494	5	11	11	CD
8691	494	6	Wall	Wall	NNP
8691	494	7	.	.	.
8691	494	8	,	,	,
8691	494	9	616	616	CD
8691	494	10	-	-	SYM
8691	494	11	621	621	CD
8691	494	12	.	.	.
8691	495	1	But	but	CC
8691	495	2	in	in	IN
8691	495	3	the	the	DT
8691	495	4	present	present	JJ
8691	495	5	case	case	NN
8691	495	6	there	there	EX
8691	495	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	495	8	no	no	DT
8691	495	9	pending	pende	VBG
8691	495	10	question	question	NN
8691	495	11	left	leave	VBD
8691	495	12	undetermined	undetermined	JJ
8691	495	13	for	for	IN
8691	495	14	the	the	DT
8691	495	15	political	political	JJ
8691	495	16	department	department	NN
8691	495	17	to	to	TO
8691	495	18	decide	decide	VB
8691	495	19	.	.	.
8691	496	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	496	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	496	3	been	be	VBN
8691	496	4	settled	settle	VBN
8691	496	5	.	.	.
8691	497	1	The	the	DT
8691	497	2	award	award	NN
8691	497	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	497	4	to	to	TO
8691	497	5	be	be	VB
8691	497	6	construed	construe	VBN
8691	497	7	as	as	IN
8691	497	8	a	a	DT
8691	497	9	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	497	10	which	which	WDT
8691	497	11	has	have	VBZ
8691	497	12	become	become	VBN
8691	497	13	final	final	JJ
8691	497	14	.	.	.
8691	498	1	A	a	DT
8691	498	2	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	498	3	when	when	WRB
8691	498	4	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	498	5	and	and	CC
8691	498	6	agreed	agree	VBD
8691	498	7	to	to	TO
8691	498	8	becomes	become	VBZ
8691	498	9	the	the	DT
8691	498	10	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	498	11	law	law	NNP
8691	498	12	of	of	IN
8691	498	13	the	the	DT
8691	498	14	land	land	NN
8691	498	15	.	.	.
8691	499	1	...	...	NFP
8691	500	1	The	the	DT
8691	500	2	duty	duty	NN
8691	500	3	of	of	IN
8691	500	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	500	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	500	6	to	to	TO
8691	500	7	construe	construe	VB
8691	500	8	and	and	CC
8691	500	9	give	give	VB
8691	500	10	effect	effect	NN
8691	500	11	to	to	IN
8691	500	12	the	the	DT
8691	500	13	latest	late	JJS
8691	500	14	expression	expression	NN
8691	500	15	of	of	IN
8691	500	16	the	the	DT
8691	500	17	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
8691	500	18	will	will	MD
8691	500	19	;	;	:
8691	500	20	hence	hence	RB
8691	500	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	500	22	follows	follow	VBZ
8691	500	23	that	that	IN
8691	500	24	,	,	,
8691	500	25	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	500	26	may	may	MD
8691	500	27	have	have	VB
8691	500	28	been	be	VBN
8691	500	29	the	the	DT
8691	500	30	contention	contention	NN
8691	500	31	of	of	IN
8691	500	32	the	the	DT
8691	500	33	government	government	NN
8691	500	34	at	at	IN
8691	500	35	the	the	DT
8691	500	36	time	time	NN
8691	500	37	_	_	NNP
8691	500	38	in	in	IN
8691	500	39	re	re	NNP
8691	500	40	_	_	NNP
8691	500	41	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
8691	500	42	was	be	VBD
8691	500	43	decided	decide	VBN
8691	500	44	,	,	,
8691	500	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	500	46	has	have	VBZ
8691	500	47	receded	recede	VBN
8691	500	48	therefrom	therefrom	NNP
8691	500	49	since	since	IN
8691	500	50	the	the	DT
8691	500	51	award	award	NN
8691	500	52	was	be	VBD
8691	500	53	rendered	render	VBN
8691	500	54	,	,	,
8691	500	55	by	by	IN
8691	500	56	an	an	DT
8691	500	57	agreement	agreement	NN
8691	500	58	to	to	TO
8691	500	59	accept	accept	VB
8691	500	60	the	the	DT
8691	500	61	same	same	JJ
8691	500	62	"	"	``
8691	500	63	as	as	IN
8691	500	64	a	a	DT
8691	500	65	full	full	JJ
8691	500	66	,	,	,
8691	500	67	complete	complete	JJ
8691	500	68	,	,	,
8691	500	69	and	and	CC
8691	500	70	final	final	JJ
8691	500	71	settlement	settlement	NN
8691	500	72	of	of	IN
8691	500	73	all	all	DT
8691	500	74	questions	question	NNS
8691	500	75	referred	refer	VBD
8691	500	76	to	to	IN
8691	500	77	by	by	IN
8691	500	78	the	the	DT
8691	500	79	arbitrators	arbitrator	NNS
8691	500	80	,	,	,
8691	500	81	"	"	''
8691	500	82	and	and	CC
8691	500	83	from	from	IN
8691	500	84	the	the	DT
8691	500	85	further	further	JJ
8691	500	86	fact	fact	NN
8691	500	87	that	that	IN
8691	500	88	the	the	DT
8691	500	89	government	government	NN
8691	500	90	since	since	IN
8691	500	91	the	the	DT
8691	500	92	rendition	rendition	NN
8691	500	93	of	of	IN
8691	500	94	the	the	DT
8691	500	95	award	award	NN
8691	500	96	has	have	VBZ
8691	500	97	passed	pass	VBN
8691	500	98	"	"	``
8691	500	99	an	an	DT
8691	500	100	act	act	NN
8691	500	101	to	to	TO
8691	500	102	give	give	VB
8691	500	103	effect	effect	NN
8691	500	104	to	to	IN
8691	500	105	the	the	DT
8691	500	106	award	award	NN
8691	500	107	rendered	render	VBN
8691	500	108	by	by	IN
8691	500	109	the	the	DT
8691	500	110	tribunal	tribunal	NNP
8691	500	111	of	of	IN
8691	500	112	arbitration	arbitration	NN
8691	500	113	.	.	.
8691	501	1	"	"	``
8691	501	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	501	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	501	4	:	:	:
8691	501	5	The	the	DT
8691	501	6	La	La	NNP
8691	501	7	Ninfa	Ninfa	NNP
8691	501	8	,	,	,
8691	501	9	75	75	CD
8691	501	10	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	501	11	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	501	12	,	,	,
8691	501	13	513	513	CD
8691	501	14	,	,	,
8691	501	15	517	517	CD
8691	501	16	.	.	.
8691	501	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	502	1	The	the	DT
8691	502	2	degree	degree	NN
8691	502	3	of	of	IN
8691	502	4	confiscation	confiscation	NN
8691	502	5	was	be	VBD
8691	502	6	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	502	7	reviewed	review	VBN
8691	502	8	.	.	.
8691	503	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	503	2	will	will	MD
8691	503	3	be	be	VB
8691	503	4	noticed	notice	VBN
8691	503	5	that	that	IN
8691	503	6	this	this	DT
8691	503	7	result	result	NN
8691	503	8	was	be	VBD
8691	503	9	reached	reach	VBN
8691	503	10	in	in	IN
8691	503	11	a	a	DT
8691	503	12	suit	suit	NN
8691	503	13	by	by	IN
8691	503	14	the	the	DT
8691	503	15	United	United	NNP
8691	503	16	States	States	NNP
8691	503	17	in	in	IN
8691	503	18	one	one	CD
8691	503	19	of	of	IN
8691	503	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	503	21	own	own	JJ
8691	503	22	courts	court	NNS
8691	503	23	,	,	,
8691	503	24	in	in	IN
8691	503	25	which	which	WDT
8691	503	26	the	the	DT
8691	503	27	claim	claim	NN
8691	503	28	of	of	IN
8691	503	29	the	the	DT
8691	503	30	government	government	NN
8691	503	31	was	be	VBD
8691	503	32	one	one	CD
8691	503	33	of	of	IN
8691	503	34	territorial	territorial	JJ
8691	503	35	boundary	boundary	NN
8691	503	36	,	,	,
8691	503	37	and	and	CC
8691	503	38	yet	yet	RB
8691	503	39	that	that	IN
8691	503	40	the	the	DT
8691	503	41	court	court	NN
8691	503	42	overruled	overrule	VBD
8691	503	43	the	the	DT
8691	503	44	claim	claim	NN
8691	503	45	and	and	CC
8691	503	46	threw	throw	VBD
8691	503	47	out	out	RP
8691	503	48	the	the	DT
8691	503	49	suit	suit	NN
8691	503	50	on	on	IN
8691	503	51	the	the	DT
8691	503	52	strength	strength	NN
8691	503	53	of	of	IN
8691	503	54	an	an	DT
8691	503	55	award	award	NN
8691	503	56	made	make	VBN
8691	503	57	in	in	IN
8691	503	58	pursuance	pursuance	NN
8691	503	59	of	of	IN
8691	503	60	the	the	DT
8691	503	61	law	law	NN
8691	503	62	of	of	IN
8691	503	63	the	the	DT
8691	503	64	land	land	NN
8691	503	65	.	.	.
8691	504	1	The	the	DT
8691	504	2	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	504	3	was	be	VBD
8691	504	4	the	the	DT
8691	504	5	law	law	NN
8691	504	6	.	.	.
8691	505	1	This	this	DT
8691	505	2	law	law	NN
8691	505	3	provided	provide	VBD
8691	505	4	for	for	IN
8691	505	5	the	the	DT
8691	505	6	award	award	NN
8691	505	7	and	and	CC
8691	505	8	made	make	VBD
8691	505	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	505	10	,	,	,
8691	505	11	whichever	whichever	WDT
8691	505	12	view	view	NN
8691	505	13	should	should	MD
8691	505	14	be	be	VB
8691	505	15	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	505	16	,	,	,
8691	505	17	final	final	JJ
8691	505	18	.	.	.
8691	506	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	506	2	was	be	VBD
8691	506	3	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	506	4	for	for	IN
8691	506	5	the	the	DT
8691	506	6	court	court	NN
8691	506	7	to	to	TO
8691	506	8	accept	accept	VB
8691	506	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	506	10	as	as	IN
8691	506	11	final	final	JJ
8691	506	12	,	,	,
8691	506	13	even	even	RB
8691	506	14	against	against	IN
8691	506	15	the	the	DT
8691	506	16	resistance	resistance	NN
8691	506	17	of	of	IN
8691	506	18	the	the	DT
8691	506	19	political	political	JJ
8691	506	20	department	department	NN
8691	506	21	of	of	IN
8691	506	22	the	the	DT
8691	506	23	government	government	NN
8691	506	24	,	,	,
8691	506	25	and	and	CC
8691	506	26	do	do	VB
8691	506	27	justice	justice	NN
8691	506	28	accordingly	accordingly	RB
8691	506	29	.	.	.
8691	507	1	The	the	DT
8691	507	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	507	3	before	before	IN
8691	507	4	the	the	DT
8691	507	5	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	507	6	,	,	,
8691	507	7	and	and	CC
8691	507	8	in	in	IN
8691	507	9	some	some	DT
8691	507	10	States	States	NNP
8691	507	11	for	for	IN
8691	507	12	half	half	PDT
8691	507	13	a	a	DT
8691	507	14	century	century	NN
8691	507	15	after	after	IN
8691	507	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	507	17	,	,	,
8691	507	18	served	serve	VBD
8691	507	19	as	as	IN
8691	507	20	a	a	DT
8691	507	21	kind	kind	NN
8691	507	22	of	of	IN
8691	507	23	political	political	JJ
8691	507	24	mouthpiece	mouthpiece	NN
8691	507	25	.	.	.
8691	508	1	The	the	DT
8691	508	2	institution	institution	NN
8691	508	3	of	of	IN
8691	508	4	the	the	DT
8691	508	5	grand	grand	NN
8691	508	6	jury[Footnote	jury[footnote	XX
8691	508	7	:	:	:
8691	508	8	See	see	VB
8691	508	9	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	508	10	.	.	.
8691	509	1	XVII	XVII	NNP
8691	509	2	.	.	.
8691	509	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	510	1	afforded	afford	VBD
8691	510	2	the	the	DT
8691	510	3	means	mean	NNS
8691	510	4	.	.	.
8691	511	1	Those	those	DT
8691	511	2	composing	compose	VBG
8691	511	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	511	4	are	be	VBP
8691	511	5	personally	personally	RB
8691	511	6	selected	select	VBN
8691	511	7	by	by	IN
8691	511	8	the	the	DT
8691	511	9	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	511	10	from	from	IN
8691	511	11	the	the	DT
8691	511	12	principal	principal	JJ
8691	511	13	men	man	NNS
8691	511	14	in	in	IN
8691	511	15	the	the	DT
8691	511	16	county	county	NN
8691	511	17	.	.	.
8691	512	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	512	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	512	3	the	the	DT
8691	512	4	duty	duty	NN
8691	512	5	of	of	IN
8691	512	6	the	the	DT
8691	512	7	court	court	NN
8691	512	8	to	to	TO
8691	512	9	instruct	instruct	VB
8691	512	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	512	11	at	at	IN
8691	512	12	the	the	DT
8691	512	13	opening	opening	NN
8691	512	14	of	of	IN
8691	512	15	the	the	DT
8691	512	16	term	term	NN
8691	512	17	which	which	WDT
8691	512	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	512	19	are	be	VBP
8691	512	20	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	512	21	to	to	TO
8691	512	22	attend	attend	VB
8691	512	23	as	as	IN
8691	512	24	to	to	IN
8691	512	25	the	the	DT
8691	512	26	law	law	NN
8691	512	27	and	and	CC
8691	512	28	practice	practice	NN
8691	512	29	governing	govern	VBG
8691	512	30	the	the	DT
8691	512	31	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	512	32	of	of	IN
8691	512	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	512	34	functions	function	NNS
8691	512	35	.	.	.
8691	513	1	Frequently	frequently	RB
8691	513	2	this	this	DT
8691	513	3	charge	charge	NN
8691	513	4	was	be	VBD
8691	513	5	prefaced	preface	VBN
8691	513	6	by	by	IN
8691	513	7	an	an	DT
8691	513	8	harangue	harangue	NN
8691	513	9	from	from	IN
8691	513	10	the	the	DT
8691	513	11	judge	judge	NN
8691	513	12	on	on	IN
8691	513	13	the	the	DT
8691	513	14	social	social	JJ
8691	513	15	,	,	,
8691	513	16	moral	moral	JJ
8691	513	17	,	,	,
8691	513	18	religious	religious	JJ
8691	513	19	or	or	CC
8691	513	20	political	political	JJ
8691	513	21	questions	question	NNS
8691	513	22	of	of	IN
8691	513	23	the	the	DT
8691	513	24	day	day	NN
8691	513	25	.	.	.
8691	514	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	514	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	514	3	:	:	:
8691	514	4	"	"	``
8691	514	5	Life	Life	NNP
8691	514	6	and	and	CC
8691	514	7	Works	Works	NNP
8691	514	8	of	of	IN
8691	514	9	John	John	NNP
8691	514	10	Adams	Adams	NNP
8691	514	11	,	,	,
8691	514	12	"	"	``
8691	514	13	II	II	NNP
8691	514	14	,	,	,
8691	514	15	169	169	CD
8691	514	16	.	.	.
8691	514	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	515	1	To	to	IN
8691	515	2	this	this	DT
8691	515	3	the	the	DT
8691	515	4	grand	grand	JJ
8691	515	5	jury	jury	NN
8691	515	6	were	be	VBD
8691	515	7	not	not	RB
8691	515	8	backward	backward	JJ
8691	515	9	in	in	IN
8691	515	10	responding	respond	VBG
8691	515	11	with	with	IN
8691	515	12	compliments	compliment	NNS
8691	515	13	and	and	CC
8691	515	14	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	515	15	presentments	presentment	NNS
8691	515	16	.	.	.
8691	516	1	In	in	IN
8691	516	2	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	516	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	516	4	went	go	VBD
8691	516	5	even	even	RB
8691	516	6	further	further	RB
8691	516	7	in	in	IN
8691	516	8	1774	1774	CD
8691	516	9	.	.	.
8691	517	1	The	the	DT
8691	517	2	House	House	NNP
8691	517	3	of	of	IN
8691	517	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
8691	517	5	of	of	IN
8691	517	6	the	the	DT
8691	517	7	Provincial	Provincial	NNP
8691	517	8	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	517	9	impeached	impeach	VBD
8691	517	10	the	the	DT
8691	517	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	517	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	517	13	for	for	IN
8691	517	14	accepting	accept	VBG
8691	517	15	a	a	DT
8691	517	16	salary	salary	NN
8691	517	17	from	from	IN
8691	517	18	the	the	DT
8691	517	19	Crown	Crown	NNP
8691	517	20	instead	instead	RB
8691	517	21	of	of	IN
8691	517	22	relying	rely	VBG
8691	517	23	on	on	IN
8691	517	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	517	25	grants	grant	NNS
8691	517	26	,	,	,
8691	517	27	as	as	IN
8691	517	28	had	have	VBD
8691	517	29	been	be	VBN
8691	517	30	the	the	DT
8691	517	31	practice	practice	NN
8691	517	32	.	.	.
8691	518	1	The	the	DT
8691	518	2	Council	Council	NNP
8691	518	3	before	before	IN
8691	518	4	which	which	WDT
8691	518	5	the	the	DT
8691	518	6	articles	article	NNS
8691	518	7	were	be	VBD
8691	518	8	exhibited	exhibit	VBN
8691	518	9	declined	decline	VBD
8691	518	10	to	to	TO
8691	518	11	entertain	entertain	VB
8691	518	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	518	13	.	.	.
8691	519	1	The	the	DT
8691	519	2	people	people	NNS
8691	519	3	,	,	,
8691	519	4	however	however	RB
8691	519	5	,	,	,
8691	519	6	felt	feel	VBD
8691	519	7	that	that	IN
8691	519	8	the	the	DT
8691	519	9	House	House	NNP
8691	519	10	was	be	VBD
8691	519	11	right	right	JJ
8691	519	12	,	,	,
8691	519	13	and	and	CC
8691	519	14	this	this	DT
8691	519	15	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	519	16	was	be	VBD
8691	519	17	manifested	manifest	VBN
8691	519	18	at	at	IN
8691	519	19	the	the	DT
8691	519	20	next	next	JJ
8691	519	21	sessions	session	NNS
8691	519	22	of	of	IN
8691	519	23	the	the	DT
8691	519	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	519	25	by	by	IN
8691	519	26	the	the	DT
8691	519	27	grand	grand	NNP
8691	519	28	and	and	CC
8691	519	29	petit	petit	NNP
8691	519	30	juries	jury	NNS
8691	519	31	in	in	IN
8691	519	32	every	every	DT
8691	519	33	county	county	NN
8691	519	34	.	.	.
8691	520	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	520	2	refused	refuse	VBD
8691	520	3	to	to	TO
8691	520	4	take	take	VB
8691	520	5	the	the	DT
8691	520	6	oaths	oath	NNS
8691	520	7	and	and	CC
8691	520	8	stated	state	VBD
8691	520	9	that	that	IN
8691	520	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	520	11	could	could	MD
8691	520	12	not	not	RB
8691	520	13	take	take	VB
8691	520	14	part	part	NN
8691	520	15	in	in	IN
8691	520	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	520	17	presided	preside	VBN
8691	520	18	over	over	RP
8691	520	19	by	by	IN
8691	520	20	a	a	DT
8691	520	21	judge	judge	NN
8691	520	22	who	who	WP
8691	520	23	was	be	VBD
8691	520	24	under	under	IN
8691	520	25	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	520	26	.	.	.
8691	521	1	No	no	DT
8691	521	2	business	business	NN
8691	521	3	was	be	VBD
8691	521	4	done	do	VBN
8691	521	5	in	in	IN
8691	521	6	court	court	NN
8691	521	7	until	until	IN
8691	521	8	the	the	DT
8691	521	9	following	follow	VBG
8691	521	10	year	year	NN
8691	521	11	,	,	,
8691	521	12	when	when	WRB
8691	521	13	,	,	,
8691	521	14	after	after	IN
8691	521	15	the	the	DT
8691	521	16	battle	battle	NN
8691	521	17	of	of	IN
8691	521	18	Lexington	Lexington	NNP
8691	521	19	,	,	,
8691	521	20	new	new	JJ
8691	521	21	judges	judge	NNS
8691	521	22	were	be	VBD
8691	521	23	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	521	24	by	by	IN
8691	521	25	the	the	DT
8691	521	26	Council	Council	NNP
8691	521	27	.	.	.
8691	522	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	522	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	522	3	:	:	:
8691	522	4	"	"	``
8691	522	5	Life	Life	NNP
8691	522	6	and	and	CC
8691	522	7	Works	Works	NNP
8691	522	8	of	of	IN
8691	522	9	John	John	NNP
8691	522	10	Adams	Adams	NNP
8691	522	11	,	,	,
8691	522	12	"	"	``
8691	522	13	II	II	NNP
8691	522	14	,	,	,
8691	522	15	332	332	CD
8691	522	16	;	;	:
8691	522	17	X	x	NN
8691	522	18	,	,	,
8691	522	19	240	240	CD
8691	522	20	;	;	:
8691	522	21	"	"	``
8691	522	22	Principles	Principles	NNPS
8691	522	23	and	and	CC
8691	522	24	Acts	Acts	NNPS
8691	522	25	of	of	IN
8691	522	26	the	the	DT
8691	522	27	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	522	28	,	,	,
8691	522	29	"	"	''
8691	522	30	100	100	CD
8691	522	31	.	.	.
8691	522	32	]	]	-RRB-
8691	523	1	Sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	523	2	the	the	DT
8691	523	3	laws	law	NNS
8691	523	4	of	of	IN
8691	523	5	the	the	DT
8691	523	6	State	State	NNP
8691	523	7	were	be	VBD
8691	523	8	criticised	criticise	VBN
8691	523	9	in	in	IN
8691	523	10	this	this	DT
8691	523	11	way	way	NN
8691	523	12	by	by	IN
8691	523	13	judge	judge	NN
8691	523	14	and	and	CC
8691	523	15	jury	jury	NN
8691	523	16	.	.	.
8691	524	1	In	in	IN
8691	524	2	December	December	NNP
8691	524	3	,	,	,
8691	524	4	1788	1788	CD
8691	524	5	,	,	,
8691	524	6	a	a	DT
8691	524	7	grand	grand	JJ
8691	524	8	jury	jury	NN
8691	524	9	in	in	IN
8691	524	10	South	South	NNP
8691	524	11	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	524	12	made	make	VBD
8691	524	13	this	this	DT
8691	524	14	presentment	presentment	NN
8691	524	15	:	:	:
8691	524	16	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	524	17	present	present	VBP
8691	524	18	as	as	IN
8691	524	19	a	a	DT
8691	524	20	grievance	grievance	NN
8691	524	21	of	of	IN
8691	524	22	the	the	DT
8691	524	23	greatest	great	JJS
8691	524	24	magnitude	magnitude	NN
8691	524	25	the	the	DT
8691	524	26	many	many	JJ
8691	524	27	late	late	JJ
8691	524	28	interferences	interference	NNS
8691	524	29	of	of	IN
8691	524	30	the	the	DT
8691	524	31	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	524	32	of	of	IN
8691	524	33	the	the	DT
8691	524	34	State	State	NNP
8691	524	35	in	in	IN
8691	524	36	private	private	JJ
8691	524	37	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	524	38	between	between	IN
8691	524	39	debtor	debtor	NN
8691	524	40	and	and	CC
8691	524	41	creditor	creditor	NN
8691	524	42	.	.	.
8691	525	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	525	2	should	should	MD
8691	525	3	be	be	VB
8691	525	4	wanting	want	VBG
8691	525	5	in	in	IN
8691	525	6	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	525	7	duty	duty	NN
8691	525	8	to	to	IN
8691	525	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	525	10	country	country	NN
8691	525	11	and	and	CC
8691	525	12	regardless	regardless	RB
8691	525	13	of	of	IN
8691	525	14	the	the	DT
8691	525	15	obligation	obligation	NN
8691	525	16	of	of	IN
8691	525	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	525	18	solemn	solemn	JJ
8691	525	19	oath	oath	NN
8691	525	20	and	and	CC
8691	525	21	the	the	DT
8691	525	22	high	high	JJ
8691	525	23	trust	trust	NN
8691	525	24	at	at	IN
8691	525	25	this	this	DT
8691	525	26	time	time	NN
8691	525	27	devolving	devolve	VBG
8691	525	28	upon	upon	IN
8691	525	29	us	-PRON-	PRP
8691	525	30	by	by	IN
8691	525	31	operation	operation	NN
8691	525	32	of	of	IN
8691	525	33	the	the	DT
8691	525	34	laws	law	NNS
8691	525	35	of	of	IN
8691	525	36	the	the	DT
8691	525	37	land	land	NN
8691	525	38	,	,	,
8691	525	39	did	do	VBD
8691	525	40	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	525	41	omit	omit	VB
8691	525	42	this	this	DT
8691	525	43	occasion	occasion	NN
8691	525	44	between	between	IN
8691	525	45	the	the	DT
8691	525	46	expiration	expiration	NN
8691	525	47	of	of	IN
8691	525	48	one	one	CD
8691	525	49	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	525	50	and	and	CC
8691	525	51	the	the	DT
8691	525	52	meeting	meeting	NN
8691	525	53	of	of	IN
8691	525	54	a	a	DT
8691	525	55	new	new	JJ
8691	525	56	representative	representative	JJ
8691	525	57	body	body	NN
8691	525	58	,	,	,
8691	525	59	to	to	TO
8691	525	60	express	express	VB
8691	525	61	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	525	62	utter	utter	JJ
8691	525	63	abhorrence	abhorrence	NN
8691	525	64	of	of	IN
8691	525	65	such	such	JJ
8691	525	66	interferences	interference	NNS
8691	525	67	.	.	.
8691	526	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	526	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	526	3	:	:	:
8691	526	4	"	"	``
8691	526	5	American	American	NNP
8691	526	6	Museum	Museum	NNP
8691	526	7	,	,	,
8691	526	8	"	"	''
8691	526	9	VII	VII	NNP
8691	526	10	,	,	,
8691	526	11	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
8691	526	12	II	II	NNP
8691	526	13	,	,	,
8691	526	14	10	10	CD
8691	526	15	.	.	.
8691	527	1	_	_	NNP
8691	527	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
8691	527	3	.	.	.
8691	528	1	ibid	ibid	NNP
8691	528	2	.	.	.
8691	528	3	_	_	NNP
8691	528	4	,	,	,
8691	528	5	19	19	CD
8691	528	6	.	.	.
8691	528	7	]	]	-RRB-
8691	529	1	In	in	IN
8691	529	2	a	a	DT
8691	529	3	similar	similar	JJ
8691	529	4	way	way	NN
8691	529	5	unpopular	unpopular	JJ
8691	529	6	treaties[Footnote	treaties[Footnote	''
8691	529	7	:	:	:
8691	529	8	McMaster	McMaster	NNP
8691	529	9	,	,	,
8691	529	10	"	"	``
8691	529	11	History	history	NN
8691	529	12	of	of	IN
8691	529	13	the	the	DT
8691	529	14	People	People	NNS
8691	529	15	of	of	IN
8691	529	16	the	the	DT
8691	529	17	United	United	NNP
8691	529	18	States	States	NNP
8691	529	19	,	,	,
8691	529	20	"	"	''
8691	529	21	II	ii	CD
8691	529	22	,	,	,
8691	529	23	229	229	CD
8691	529	24	.	.	.
8691	529	25	]	]	-RRB-
8691	530	1	or	or	CC
8691	530	2	acts	act	NNS
8691	530	3	of	of	IN
8691	530	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	530	5	were	be	VBD
8691	530	6	formerly	formerly	RB
8691	530	7	attacked	attack	VBN
8691	530	8	.	.	.
8691	531	1	In	in	IN
8691	531	2	1819	1819	CD
8691	531	3	,	,	,
8691	531	4	the	the	DT
8691	531	5	action	action	NN
8691	531	6	of	of	IN
8691	531	7	the	the	DT
8691	531	8	House	House	NNP
8691	531	9	of	of	IN
8691	531	10	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
8691	531	11	as	as	IN
8691	531	12	to	to	IN
8691	531	13	the	the	DT
8691	531	14	introduction	introduction	NN
8691	531	15	of	of	IN
8691	531	16	slavery	slavery	NN
8691	531	17	in	in	IN
8691	531	18	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
8691	531	19	was	be	VBD
8691	531	20	the	the	DT
8691	531	21	subject	subject	NN
8691	531	22	of	of	IN
8691	531	23	a	a	DT
8691	531	24	warm	warm	JJ
8691	531	25	protest	protest	NN
8691	531	26	from	from	IN
8691	531	27	a	a	DT
8691	531	28	grand	grand	JJ
8691	531	29	jury	jury	NN
8691	531	30	in	in	IN
8691	531	31	that	that	DT
8691	531	32	territory	territory	NN
8691	531	33	,	,	,
8691	531	34	which	which	WDT
8691	531	35	closed	close	VBD
8691	531	36	thus	thus	RB
8691	531	37	:	:	:
8691	531	38	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	531	39	hope	hope	VBP
8691	531	40	those	those	DT
8691	531	41	restrictions	restriction	NNS
8691	531	42	will	will	MD
8691	531	43	never	never	RB
8691	531	44	more	more	RBR
8691	531	45	be	be	VB
8691	531	46	attempted	attempt	VBN
8691	531	47	;	;	:
8691	531	48	and	and	CC
8691	531	49	,	,	,
8691	531	50	if	if	IN
8691	531	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	531	52	should	should	MD
8691	531	53	,	,	,
8691	531	54	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	531	55	hope	hope	VBP
8691	531	56	by	by	IN
8691	531	57	the	the	DT
8691	531	58	assistance	assistance	NN
8691	531	59	of	of	IN
8691	531	60	the	the	DT
8691	531	61	genius	genius	NN
8691	531	62	of	of	IN
8691	531	63	'	'	CD
8691	531	64	76	76	CD
8691	531	65	and	and	CC
8691	531	66	the	the	DT
8691	531	67	interposition	interposition	NN
8691	531	68	of	of	IN
8691	531	69	Divine	Divine	NNP
8691	531	70	Providence	Providence	NNP
8691	531	71	to	to	TO
8691	531	72	find	find	VB
8691	531	73	means	mean	NNS
8691	531	74	to	to	TO
8691	531	75	protect	protect	VB
8691	531	76	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	531	77	rights	right	NNS
8691	531	78	.	.	.
8691	532	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	532	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	532	3	:	:	:
8691	532	4	Niles	Niles	NNP
8691	532	5	'	'	POS
8691	532	6	Register	Register	NNP
8691	532	7	,	,	,
8691	532	8	XVII	XVII	NNP
8691	532	9	,	,	,
8691	532	10	71	71	CD
8691	532	11	.	.	.
8691	532	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	533	1	The	the	DT
8691	533	2	protective	protective	JJ
8691	533	3	tariffs	tariff	NNS
8691	533	4	of	of	IN
8691	533	5	the	the	DT
8691	533	6	United	United	NNP
8691	533	7	States	States	NNP
8691	533	8	were	be	VBD
8691	533	9	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	533	10	presented	present	VBN
8691	533	11	as	as	IN
8691	533	12	grievances	grievance	NNS
8691	533	13	in	in	IN
8691	533	14	the	the	DT
8691	533	15	South	South	NNP
8691	533	16	during	during	IN
8691	533	17	the	the	DT
8691	533	18	years	year	NNS
8691	533	19	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	533	20	the	the	DT
8691	533	21	nullification	nullification	NN
8691	533	22	movement	movement	NN
8691	533	23	in	in	IN
8691	533	24	South	South	NNP
8691	533	25	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	533	26	.	.	.
8691	534	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	534	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	534	3	:	:	:
8691	534	4	U.	U.	NNP
8691	535	1	B.	B.	NNP
8691	535	2	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
8691	535	3	,	,	,
8691	535	4	"	"	''
8691	535	5	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	535	6	and	and	CC
8691	535	7	State	State	NNP
8691	535	8	Rights	Rights	NNPS
8691	535	9	,	,	,
8691	535	10	"	"	''
8691	535	11	Report	Report	NNP
8691	535	12	of	of	IN
8691	535	13	the	the	DT
8691	535	14	American	American	NNP
8691	535	15	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	535	16	Association	Association	NNP
8691	535	17	for	for	IN
8691	535	18	1901	1901	CD
8691	535	19	,	,	,
8691	535	20	II	II	NNP
8691	535	21	,	,	,
8691	535	22	117	117	CD
8691	535	23	.	.	.
8691	535	24	]	]	-RRB-
8691	536	1	In	in	IN
8691	536	2	1825	1825	CD
8691	536	3	,	,	,
8691	536	4	a	a	DT
8691	536	5	grand	grand	JJ
8691	536	6	jury	jury	NN
8691	536	7	in	in	IN
8691	536	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	536	9	presented	present	VBD
8691	536	10	as	as	IN
8691	536	11	a	a	DT
8691	536	12	grievance	grievance	NN
8691	536	13	the	the	DT
8691	536	14	suspension	suspension	NN
8691	536	15	of	of	IN
8691	536	16	Commodore	Commodore	NNP
8691	536	17	Porter	Porter	NNP
8691	536	18	from	from	IN
8691	536	19	duty	duty	NN
8691	536	20	for	for	IN
8691	536	21	six	six	CD
8691	536	22	months	month	NNS
8691	536	23	under	under	IN
8691	536	24	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	536	25	of	of	IN
8691	536	26	a	a	DT
8691	536	27	naval	naval	JJ
8691	536	28	court	court	NN
8691	536	29	martial	martial	NN
8691	536	30	,	,	,
8691	536	31	approved	approve	VBN
8691	536	32	by	by	IN
8691	536	33	the	the	DT
8691	536	34	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
8691	536	35	of	of	IN
8691	536	36	the	the	DT
8691	536	37	Navy	Navy	NNP
8691	536	38	.	.	.
8691	537	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	537	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	537	3	:	:	:
8691	537	4	Niles	Niles	NNP
8691	537	5	'	'	POS
8691	537	6	Register	register	NN
8691	537	7	,	,	,
8691	537	8	XXIX	XXIX	NNP
8691	537	9	,	,	,
8691	537	10	103	103	CD
8691	537	11	.	.	.
8691	537	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	538	1	In	in	IN
8691	538	2	1827	1827	CD
8691	538	3	,	,	,
8691	538	4	a	a	DT
8691	538	5	grand	grand	JJ
8691	538	6	jury	jury	NN
8691	538	7	in	in	IN
8691	538	8	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
8691	538	9	presented	present	VBD
8691	538	10	a	a	DT
8691	538	11	"	"	``
8691	538	12	protest	protest	NN
8691	538	13	against	against	IN
8691	538	14	the	the	DT
8691	538	15	bold	bold	JJ
8691	538	16	and	and	CC
8691	538	17	daring	daring	JJ
8691	538	18	usurpations	usurpation	NNS
8691	538	19	of	of	IN
8691	538	20	power	power	NN
8691	538	21	by	by	IN
8691	538	22	the	the	DT
8691	538	23	present	present	JJ
8691	538	24	Executive	Executive	NNP
8691	538	25	of	of	IN
8691	538	26	the	the	DT
8691	538	27	United	United	NNP
8691	538	28	States	States	NNP
8691	538	29	"	"	''
8691	538	30	(	(	-LRB-
8691	538	31	John	John	NNP
8691	538	32	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
8691	538	33	Adams	Adams	NNP
8691	538	34	)	)	-RRB-
8691	538	35	,	,	,
8691	538	36	and	and	CC
8691	538	37	stated	state	VBD
8691	538	38	that	that	IN
8691	538	39	"	"	``
8691	538	40	being	be	VBG
8691	538	41	decidedly	decidedly	RB
8691	538	42	opposed	opposed	JJ
8691	538	43	to	to	IN
8691	538	44	the	the	DT
8691	538	45	present	present	JJ
8691	538	46	administration	administration	NN
8691	538	47	,	,	,
8691	538	48	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	538	49	have	have	VBP
8691	538	50	for	for	IN
8691	538	51	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	538	52	resolved	resolve	VBN
8691	538	53	to	to	TO
8691	538	54	oppose	oppose	VB
8691	538	55	all	all	PDT
8691	538	56	those	those	DT
8691	538	57	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	538	58	have	have	VBP
8691	538	59	just	just	RB
8691	538	60	reason	reason	NN
8691	538	61	to	to	TO
8691	538	62	suspect	suspect	VB
8691	538	63	to	to	TO
8691	538	64	be	be	VB
8691	538	65	friendly	friendly	JJ
8691	538	66	thereto	thereto	NN
8691	538	67	,	,	,
8691	538	68	and	and	CC
8691	538	69	recommend	recommend	VB
8691	538	70	the	the	DT
8691	538	71	same	same	JJ
8691	538	72	course	course	NN
8691	538	73	to	to	IN
8691	538	74	all	all	DT
8691	538	75	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	538	76	fellow	fellow	JJ
8691	538	77	-	-	HYPH
8691	538	78	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	538	79	of	of	IN
8691	538	80	Blount	Blount	NNP
8691	538	81	County	County	NNP
8691	538	82	.	.	.
8691	539	1	"	"	``
8691	539	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	539	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	539	4	:	:	:
8691	539	5	Niles	Niles	NNP
8691	539	6	'	'	POS
8691	539	7	Register	register	NN
8691	539	8	,	,	,
8691	539	9	XXXII	XXXII	NNP
8691	539	10	,	,	,
8691	539	11	366	366	CD
8691	539	12	.	.	.
8691	539	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	540	1	In	in	IN
8691	540	2	1777	1777	CD
8691	540	3	,	,	,
8691	540	4	the	the	DT
8691	540	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	540	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	540	7	of	of	IN
8691	540	8	South	South	NNP
8691	540	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	540	10	began	begin	VBD
8691	540	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	540	12	charge	charge	NN
8691	540	13	to	to	IN
8691	540	14	a	a	DT
8691	540	15	grand	grand	JJ
8691	540	16	jury	jury	NN
8691	540	17	with	with	IN
8691	540	18	a	a	DT
8691	540	19	long	long	JJ
8691	540	20	statement	statement	NN
8691	540	21	of	of	IN
8691	540	22	the	the	DT
8691	540	23	justice	justice	NN
8691	540	24	of	of	IN
8691	540	25	the	the	DT
8691	540	26	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	540	27	,	,	,
8691	540	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	540	29	military	military	JJ
8691	540	30	successes	success	NNS
8691	540	31	,	,	,
8691	540	32	and	and	CC
8691	540	33	the	the	DT
8691	540	34	duties	duty	NNS
8691	540	35	of	of	IN
8691	540	36	patriotism	patriotism	NN
8691	540	37	.	.	.
8691	541	1	The	the	DT
8691	541	2	court	court	NN
8691	541	3	thereupon	thereupon	RB
8691	541	4	ordered	order	VBD
8691	541	5	"	"	``
8691	541	6	That	that	IN
8691	541	7	the	the	DT
8691	541	8	political	political	JJ
8691	541	9	part	part	NN
8691	541	10	of	of	IN
8691	541	11	the	the	DT
8691	541	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	541	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	541	14	's	's	POS
8691	541	15	charge	charge	NN
8691	541	16	"	"	``
8691	541	17	be	be	VB
8691	541	18	forthwith	forthwith	NNP
8691	541	19	printed	print	VBN
8691	541	20	.	.	.
8691	542	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	542	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	542	3	:	:	:
8691	542	4	Principles	principle	NNS
8691	542	5	and	and	CC
8691	542	6	Acts	Acts	NNPS
8691	542	7	of	of	IN
8691	542	8	the	the	DT
8691	542	9	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	542	10	,	,	,
8691	542	11	347	347	CD
8691	542	12	.	.	.
8691	542	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	543	1	In	in	IN
8691	543	2	1790	1790	CD
8691	543	3	,	,	,
8691	543	4	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	543	5	Grimke	Grimke	NNP
8691	543	6	of	of	IN
8691	543	7	the	the	DT
8691	543	8	same	same	JJ
8691	543	9	State	State	NNP
8691	543	10	took	take	VBD
8691	543	11	advantage	advantage	NN
8691	543	12	of	of	IN
8691	543	13	a	a	DT
8691	543	14	similar	similar	JJ
8691	543	15	occasion	occasion	NN
8691	543	16	to	to	TO
8691	543	17	comment	comment	VB
8691	543	18	with	with	IN
8691	543	19	severity	severity	NN
8691	543	20	on	on	IN
8691	543	21	those	those	DT
8691	543	22	who	who	WP
8691	543	23	had	have	VBD
8691	543	24	opposed	oppose	VBN
8691	543	25	the	the	DT
8691	543	26	ratification	ratification	NN
8691	543	27	of	of	IN
8691	543	28	the	the	DT
8691	543	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	543	30	of	of	IN
8691	543	31	the	the	DT
8691	543	32	United	United	NNP
8691	543	33	States	States	NNP
8691	543	34	.	.	.
8691	544	1	Jealousy	Jealousy	NNP
8691	544	2	had	have	VBD
8691	544	3	done	do	VBN
8691	544	4	much	much	JJ
8691	544	5	to	to	TO
8691	544	6	poison	poison	VB
8691	544	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	544	8	minds	mind	NNS
8691	544	9	,	,	,
8691	544	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	544	11	said	say	VBD
8691	544	12	,	,	,
8691	544	13	"	"	``
8691	544	14	for	for	IN
8691	544	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	544	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	544	17	observable	observable	JJ
8691	544	18	that	that	IN
8691	544	19	throughout	throughout	IN
8691	544	20	the	the	DT
8691	544	21	whole	whole	NN
8691	544	22	of	of	IN
8691	544	23	the	the	DT
8691	544	24	United	United	NNP
8691	544	25	States	States	NNP
8691	544	26	a	a	DT
8691	544	27	majority	majority	NN
8691	544	28	of	of	IN
8691	544	29	the	the	DT
8691	544	30	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	544	31	of	of	IN
8691	544	32	the	the	DT
8691	544	33	opposition	opposition	NN
8691	544	34	to	to	IN
8691	544	35	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	544	36	newly	newly	RB
8691	544	37	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	544	38	government	government	NN
8691	544	39	are	be	VBP
8691	544	40	not	not	RB
8691	544	41	natives	native	NNS
8691	544	42	of	of	IN
8691	544	43	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	544	44	soil	soil	NN
8691	544	45	;	;	:
8691	544	46	hence	hence	RB
8691	544	47	this	this	DT
8691	544	48	pernicious	pernicious	JJ
8691	544	49	quality	quality	NN
8691	544	50	of	of	IN
8691	544	51	the	the	DT
8691	544	52	mind	mind	NN
8691	544	53	displays	display	VBZ
8691	544	54	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	544	55	more	more	RBR
8691	544	56	widely	widely	RB
8691	544	57	in	in	IN
8691	544	58	America	America	NNP
8691	544	59	.	.	.
8691	545	1	"	"	``
8691	545	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	545	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	545	4	:	:	:
8691	545	5	"	"	``
8691	545	6	American	American	NNP
8691	545	7	Museum	Museum	NNP
8691	545	8	,	,	,
8691	545	9	"	"	''
8691	545	10	VIII	VIII	NNP
8691	545	11	,	,	,
8691	545	12	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
8691	545	13	II	II	NNP
8691	545	14	,	,	,
8691	545	15	33	33	CD
8691	545	16	.	.	.
8691	545	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	546	1	In	in	IN
8691	546	2	1798	1798	CD
8691	546	3	,	,	,
8691	546	4	when	when	WRB
8691	546	5	Elbridge	Elbridge	NNP
8691	546	6	Gerry	Gerry	NNP
8691	546	7	was	be	VBD
8691	546	8	the	the	DT
8691	546	9	Republican	republican	JJ
8691	546	10	candidate	candidate	NN
8691	546	11	for	for	IN
8691	546	12	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	546	13	of	of	IN
8691	546	14	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	546	15	,	,	,
8691	546	16	a	a	DT
8691	546	17	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
8691	546	18	newspaper	newspaper	NN
8691	546	19	reported	report	VBD
8691	546	20	approvingly	approvingly	RB
8691	546	21	a	a	DT
8691	546	22	charge	charge	NN
8691	546	23	of	of	IN
8691	546	24	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	546	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	546	26	Dana	Dana	NNP
8691	546	27	of	of	IN
8691	546	28	that	that	DT
8691	546	29	State	State	NNP
8691	546	30	.	.	.
8691	547	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	547	2	had	have	VBD
8691	547	3	been	be	VBN
8691	547	4	an	an	DT
8691	547	5	ardent	ardent	JJ
8691	547	6	politician	politician	NN
8691	547	7	before	before	IN
8691	547	8	going	go	VBG
8691	547	9	on	on	IN
8691	547	10	the	the	DT
8691	547	11	bench	bench	NN
8691	547	12	and	and	CC
8691	547	13	had	have	VBD
8691	547	14	declined	decline	VBN
8691	547	15	a	a	DT
8691	547	16	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	547	17	as	as	IN
8691	547	18	minister	minister	NN
8691	547	19	to	to	IN
8691	547	20	France	France	NNP
8691	547	21	during	during	IN
8691	547	22	the	the	DT
8691	547	23	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	547	24	year	year	NN
8691	547	25	.	.	.
8691	548	1	"	"	``
8691	548	2	The	the	DT
8691	548	3	learned	learned	JJ
8691	548	4	judge	judge	NN
8691	548	5	,	,	,
8691	548	6	"	"	''
8691	548	7	said	say	VBD
8691	548	8	the	the	DT
8691	548	9	Boston	Boston	NNP
8691	548	10	_	_	NNP
8691	548	11	Centinel	Centinel	NNP
8691	548	12	_	_	NNP
8691	548	13	,	,	,
8691	548	14	"	"	``
8691	548	15	in	in	IN
8691	548	16	a	a	DT
8691	548	17	forcible	forcible	JJ
8691	548	18	manner	manner	NN
8691	548	19	proved	prove	VBD
8691	548	20	the	the	DT
8691	548	21	existence	existence	NN
8691	548	22	of	of	IN
8691	548	23	a	a	DT
8691	548	24	French	french	JJ
8691	548	25	faction	faction	NN
8691	548	26	in	in	IN
8691	548	27	the	the	DT
8691	548	28	bosom	bosom	NN
8691	548	29	of	of	IN
8691	548	30	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	548	31	country	country	NN
8691	548	32	and	and	CC
8691	548	33	exposed	expose	VBD
8691	548	34	the	the	DT
8691	548	35	French	french	JJ
8691	548	36	system	system	NN
8691	548	37	among	among	IN
8691	548	38	us	-PRON-	PRP
8691	548	39	from	from	IN
8691	548	40	the	the	DT
8691	548	41	quintumvirate	quintumvirate	NN
8691	548	42	of	of	IN
8691	548	43	Paris	Paris	NNP
8691	548	44	to	to	IN
8691	548	45	the	the	DT
8691	548	46	Vice	Vice	NNP
8691	548	47	-	-	HYPH
8691	548	48	President	President	NNP
8691	548	49	and	and	CC
8691	548	50	minority	minority	NN
8691	548	51	of	of	IN
8691	548	52	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	548	53	as	as	IN
8691	548	54	apostles	apostle	NNS
8691	548	55	of	of	IN
8691	548	56	atheism	atheism	NN
8691	548	57	and	and	CC
8691	548	58	anarchy	anarchy	NN
8691	548	59	,	,	,
8691	548	60	bloodshed	bloodshed	NN
8691	548	61	and	and	CC
8691	548	62	plunder	plunder	VB
8691	548	63	.	.	.
8691	549	1	"	"	``
8691	549	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	549	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	549	4	:	:	:
8691	549	5	Centinel	Centinel	NNP
8691	549	6	of	of	IN
8691	549	7	Nov.	November	NNP
8691	549	8	28	28	CD
8691	549	9	,	,	,
8691	549	10	1798	1798	CD
8691	549	11	,	,	,
8691	549	12	quoted	quote	VBN
8691	549	13	in	in	IN
8691	549	14	Austin	Austin	NNP
8691	549	15	,	,	,
8691	549	16	"	"	``
8691	549	17	Memoirs	Memoirs	NNPS
8691	549	18	of	of	IN
8691	549	19	Elbridge	Elbridge	NNP
8691	549	20	Gerry	Gerry	NNP
8691	549	21	,	,	,
8691	549	22	"	"	``
8691	549	23	II	ii	CD
8691	549	24	,	,	,
8691	549	25	296	296	CD
8691	549	26	,	,	,
8691	549	27	note	note	NN
8691	549	28	.	.	.
8691	549	29	]	]	-RRB-
8691	550	1	In	in	IN
8691	550	2	1800	1800	CD
8691	550	3	,	,	,
8691	550	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	550	5	Chase	Chase	NNP
8691	550	6	of	of	IN
8691	550	7	the	the	DT
8691	550	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	550	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	550	10	of	of	IN
8691	550	11	the	the	DT
8691	550	12	United	United	NNP
8691	550	13	States	States	NNP
8691	550	14	made	make	VBD
8691	550	15	several	several	JJ
8691	550	16	charges	charge	NNS
8691	550	17	in	in	IN
8691	550	18	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	550	19	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	550	20	less	less	RBR
8691	550	21	objectionable	objectionable	JJ
8691	550	22	,	,	,
8691	550	23	one	one	CD
8691	550	24	of	of	IN
8691	550	25	which	which	WDT
8691	550	26	was	be	VBD
8691	550	27	afterward	afterward	RB
8691	550	28	unsuccessfully	unsuccessfully	RB
8691	550	29	set	set	VBN
8691	550	30	up	up	RP
8691	550	31	by	by	IN
8691	550	32	the	the	DT
8691	550	33	House	House	NNP
8691	550	34	of	of	IN
8691	550	35	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
8691	550	36	as	as	IN
8691	550	37	a	a	DT
8691	550	38	ground	ground	NN
8691	550	39	of	of	IN
8691	550	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	550	41	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	550	42	.	.	.
8691	551	1	The	the	DT
8691	551	2	article	article	NN
8691	551	3	stating	state	VBG
8691	551	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	551	5	described	describe	VBD
8691	551	6	the	the	DT
8691	551	7	charge	charge	NN
8691	551	8	as	as	IN
8691	551	9	"	"	``
8691	551	10	an	an	DT
8691	551	11	intemperate	intemperate	NN
8691	551	12	and	and	CC
8691	551	13	inflammatory	inflammatory	JJ
8691	551	14	political	political	JJ
8691	551	15	harangue	harangue	NN
8691	551	16	with	with	IN
8691	551	17	intent	intent	NN
8691	551	18	to	to	TO
8691	551	19	excite	excite	VB
8691	551	20	the	the	DT
8691	551	21	fears	fear	NNS
8691	551	22	and	and	CC
8691	551	23	resentment	resentment	NN
8691	551	24	of	of	IN
8691	551	25	the	the	DT
8691	551	26	said	say	VBN
8691	551	27	grand	grand	JJ
8691	551	28	jury	jury	NN
8691	551	29	and	and	CC
8691	551	30	of	of	IN
8691	551	31	the	the	DT
8691	551	32	good	good	JJ
8691	551	33	people	people	NNS
8691	551	34	of	of	IN
8691	551	35	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	551	36	against	against	IN
8691	551	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	551	38	state	state	NN
8691	551	39	government	government	NN
8691	551	40	and	and	CC
8691	551	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	551	42	.	.	.
8691	551	43	"	"	''
8691	552	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	552	2	had	have	VBD
8691	552	3	,	,	,
8691	552	4	indeed	indeed	RB
8691	552	5	,	,	,
8691	552	6	used	use	VBD
8691	552	7	this	this	DT
8691	552	8	language	language	NN
8691	552	9	:	:	:
8691	552	10	You	-PRON-	PRP
8691	552	11	know	know	VBP
8691	552	12	,	,	,
8691	552	13	gentlemen	gentleman	NNS
8691	552	14	,	,	,
8691	552	15	that	that	IN
8691	552	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	552	17	State	state	NN
8691	552	18	and	and	CC
8691	552	19	national	national	JJ
8691	552	20	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	552	21	were	be	VBD
8691	552	22	framed	frame	VBN
8691	552	23	to	to	TO
8691	552	24	secure	secure	VB
8691	552	25	to	to	IN
8691	552	26	every	every	DT
8691	552	27	member	member	NN
8691	552	28	of	of	IN
8691	552	29	the	the	DT
8691	552	30	society	society	NN
8691	552	31	,	,	,
8691	552	32	equal	equal	JJ
8691	552	33	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	552	34	and	and	CC
8691	552	35	equal	equal	JJ
8691	552	36	rights	right	NNS
8691	552	37	;	;	:
8691	552	38	but	but	CC
8691	552	39	the	the	DT
8691	552	40	late	late	JJ
8691	552	41	alteration	alteration	NN
8691	552	42	of	of	IN
8691	552	43	the	the	DT
8691	552	44	federal	federal	JJ
8691	552	45	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	552	46	by	by	IN
8691	552	47	the	the	DT
8691	552	48	abolition	abolition	NN
8691	552	49	of	of	IN
8691	552	50	the	the	DT
8691	552	51	office	office	NN
8691	552	52	of	of	IN
8691	552	53	the	the	DT
8691	552	54	sixteen	sixteen	NNP
8691	552	55	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	552	56	judges	judge	NNS
8691	552	57	,	,	,
8691	552	58	and	and	CC
8691	552	59	the	the	DT
8691	552	60	recent	recent	JJ
8691	552	61	change	change	NN
8691	552	62	in	in	IN
8691	552	63	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	552	64	State	State	NNP
8691	552	65	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	552	66	,	,	,
8691	552	67	by	by	IN
8691	552	68	the	the	DT
8691	552	69	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	552	70	of	of	IN
8691	552	71	universal	universal	JJ
8691	552	72	suffrage	suffrage	NN
8691	552	73	,	,	,
8691	552	74	and	and	CC
8691	552	75	the	the	DT
8691	552	76	further	further	JJ
8691	552	77	alteration	alteration	NN
8691	552	78	that	that	WDT
8691	552	79	is	be	VBZ
8691	552	80	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
8691	552	81	in	in	IN
8691	552	82	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	552	83	State	State	NNP
8691	552	84	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	552	85	(	(	-LRB-
8691	552	86	if	if	IN
8691	552	87	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	552	88	)	)	-RRB-
8691	552	89	will	will	MD
8691	552	90	,	,	,
8691	552	91	in	in	IN
8691	552	92	my	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	552	93	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	552	94	,	,	,
8691	552	95	take	take	VB
8691	552	96	away	away	RB
8691	552	97	all	all	DT
8691	552	98	security	security	NN
8691	552	99	for	for	IN
8691	552	100	property	property	NN
8691	552	101	and	and	CC
8691	552	102	personal	personal	JJ
8691	552	103	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	552	104	.	.	.
8691	553	1	The	the	DT
8691	553	2	independence	independence	NN
8691	553	3	of	of	IN
8691	553	4	the	the	DT
8691	553	5	national	national	JJ
8691	553	6	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	553	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	553	8	already	already	RB
8691	553	9	shaken	shake	VBN
8691	553	10	to	to	IN
8691	553	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	553	12	foundation	foundation	NN
8691	553	13	,	,	,
8691	553	14	and	and	CC
8691	553	15	the	the	DT
8691	553	16	virtue	virtue	NN
8691	553	17	of	of	IN
8691	553	18	the	the	DT
8691	553	19	people	people	NNS
8691	553	20	alone	alone	RB
8691	553	21	can	can	MD
8691	553	22	restore	restore	VB
8691	553	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	553	24	.	.	.
8691	554	1	The	the	DT
8691	554	2	independence	independence	NN
8691	554	3	of	of	IN
8691	554	4	the	the	DT
8691	554	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	554	6	of	of	IN
8691	554	7	this	this	DT
8691	554	8	State	state	NN
8691	554	9	will	will	MD
8691	554	10	be	be	VB
8691	554	11	entirely	entirely	RB
8691	554	12	destroyed	destroy	VBN
8691	554	13	if	if	IN
8691	554	14	the	the	DT
8691	554	15	bill	bill	NN
8691	554	16	for	for	IN
8691	554	17	the	the	DT
8691	554	18	abolition	abolition	NN
8691	554	19	of	of	IN
8691	554	20	the	the	DT
8691	554	21	two	two	CD
8691	554	22	supreme	supreme	JJ
8691	554	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	554	24	should	should	MD
8691	554	25	be	be	VB
8691	554	26	ratified	ratify	VBN
8691	554	27	by	by	IN
8691	554	28	the	the	DT
8691	554	29	next	next	JJ
8691	554	30	general	general	NNP
8691	554	31	assembly	assembly	NNP
8691	554	32	.	.	.
8691	555	1	The	the	DT
8691	555	2	change	change	NN
8691	555	3	of	of	IN
8691	555	4	the	the	DT
8691	555	5	State	State	NNP
8691	555	6	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	555	7	,	,	,
8691	555	8	by	by	IN
8691	555	9	allowing	allow	VBG
8691	555	10	universal	universal	JJ
8691	555	11	suffrage	suffrage	NN
8691	555	12	,	,	,
8691	555	13	will	will	MD
8691	555	14	,	,	,
8691	555	15	in	in	IN
8691	555	16	my	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	555	17	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	555	18	,	,	,
8691	555	19	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	555	20	and	and	CC
8691	555	21	rapidly	rapidly	RB
8691	555	22	destroy	destroy	VB
8691	555	23	all	all	DT
8691	555	24	protection	protection	NN
8691	555	25	to	to	IN
8691	555	26	property	property	NN
8691	555	27	,	,	,
8691	555	28	and	and	CC
8691	555	29	all	all	DT
8691	555	30	security	security	NN
8691	555	31	to	to	IN
8691	555	32	personal	personal	JJ
8691	555	33	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	555	34	;	;	:
8691	555	35	and	and	CC
8691	555	36	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	555	37	republican	republican	JJ
8691	555	38	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	555	39	will	will	MD
8691	555	40	sink	sink	VB
8691	555	41	into	into	IN
8691	555	42	a	a	DT
8691	555	43	mobocracy	mobocracy	NN
8691	555	44	,	,	,
8691	555	45	the	the	DT
8691	555	46	worst	bad	JJS
8691	555	47	of	of	IN
8691	555	48	all	all	DT
8691	555	49	possible	possible	JJ
8691	555	50	governments	government	NNS
8691	555	51	.	.	.
8691	556	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	556	2	can	can	MD
8691	556	3	only	only	RB
8691	556	4	lament	lament	VB
8691	556	5	that	that	IN
8691	556	6	the	the	DT
8691	556	7	main	main	JJ
8691	556	8	pillar	pillar	NN
8691	556	9	of	of	IN
8691	556	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	556	11	State	State	NNP
8691	556	12	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	556	13	has	have	VBZ
8691	556	14	already	already	RB
8691	556	15	been	be	VBN
8691	556	16	thrown	throw	VBN
8691	556	17	down	down	RP
8691	556	18	by	by	IN
8691	556	19	the	the	DT
8691	556	20	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	556	21	of	of	IN
8691	556	22	universal	universal	JJ
8691	556	23	suffrage	suffrage	NN
8691	556	24	.	.	.
8691	557	1	By	by	IN
8691	557	2	this	this	DT
8691	557	3	shock	shock	NN
8691	557	4	alone	alone	RB
8691	557	5	the	the	DT
8691	557	6	whole	whole	JJ
8691	557	7	building	building	NN
8691	557	8	totters	totter	NNS
8691	557	9	to	to	IN
8691	557	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	557	11	base	base	NN
8691	557	12	and	and	CC
8691	557	13	will	will	MD
8691	557	14	crumble	crumble	VB
8691	557	15	into	into	IN
8691	557	16	ruins	ruin	NNS
8691	557	17	before	before	IN
8691	557	18	many	many	JJ
8691	557	19	years	year	NNS
8691	557	20	elapse	elapse	VBP
8691	557	21	,	,	,
8691	557	22	unless	unless	IN
8691	557	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	557	24	be	be	VB
8691	557	25	restored	restore	VBN
8691	557	26	to	to	IN
8691	557	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	557	28	original	original	JJ
8691	557	29	state	state	NN
8691	557	30	.	.	.
8691	558	1	All	all	DT
8691	558	2	this	this	DT
8691	558	3	was	be	VBD
8691	558	4	less	less	RBR
8691	558	5	indefensible	indefensible	JJ
8691	558	6	under	under	IN
8691	558	7	the	the	DT
8691	558	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	558	9	practice	practice	NN
8691	558	10	of	of	IN
8691	558	11	a	a	DT
8691	558	12	century	century	NN
8691	558	13	ago	ago	RB
8691	558	14	than	than	IN
8691	558	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	558	16	would	would	MD
8691	558	17	be	be	VB
8691	558	18	now	now	RB
8691	558	19	,	,	,
8691	558	20	and	and	CC
8691	558	21	there	there	EX
8691	558	22	were	be	VBD
8691	558	23	not	not	RB
8691	558	24	enough	enough	JJ
8691	558	25	votes	vote	NNS
8691	558	26	of	of	IN
8691	558	27	Guilty	Guilty	NNP
8691	558	28	on	on	IN
8691	558	29	the	the	DT
8691	558	30	article	article	NN
8691	558	31	of	of	IN
8691	558	32	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	558	33	founded	found	VBD
8691	558	34	upon	upon	IN
8691	558	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	558	36	to	to	TO
8691	558	37	secure	secure	VB
8691	558	38	a	a	DT
8691	558	39	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	558	40	.	.	.
8691	559	1	In	in	IN
8691	559	2	the	the	DT
8691	559	3	same	same	JJ
8691	559	4	year	year	NN
8691	559	5	,	,	,
8691	559	6	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	559	7	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
8691	559	8	Addison	Addison	NNP
8691	559	9	of	of	IN
8691	559	10	the	the	DT
8691	559	11	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	559	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	559	13	of	of	IN
8691	559	14	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	559	15	was	be	VBD
8691	559	16	charging	charge	VBG
8691	559	17	a	a	DT
8691	559	18	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	559	19	grand	grand	JJ
8691	559	20	jury	jury	NN
8691	559	21	that	that	IN
8691	559	22	the	the	DT
8691	559	23	Jeffersonians	Jeffersonians	NNPS
8691	559	24	had	have	VBD
8691	559	25	assumed	assume	VBN
8691	559	26	a	a	DT
8691	559	27	name	name	NN
8691	559	28	that	that	WDT
8691	559	29	did	do	VBD
8691	559	30	not	not	RB
8691	559	31	belong	belong	VB
8691	559	32	to	to	IN
8691	559	33	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	559	34	.	.	.
8691	560	1	"	"	``
8691	560	2	Such	such	JJ
8691	560	3	men	man	NNS
8691	560	4	,	,	,
8691	560	5	"	"	''
8691	560	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	560	7	said	say	VBD
8691	560	8	,	,	,
8691	560	9	"	"	``
8691	560	10	disgrace	disgrace	VB
8691	560	11	the	the	DT
8691	560	12	name	name	NN
8691	560	13	of	of	IN
8691	560	14	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
8691	560	15	by	by	IN
8691	560	16	exclusively	exclusively	RB
8691	560	17	assuming	assume	VBG
8691	560	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	560	19	.	.	.
8691	561	1	In	in	IN
8691	561	2	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	561	3	sheep	sheep	NNS
8691	561	4	's	's	POS
8691	561	5	clothing	clothing	NN
8691	561	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	561	7	are	be	VBP
8691	561	8	ravening	raven	VBG
8691	561	9	wolves	wolf	NNS
8691	561	10	.	.	.
8691	562	1	"	"	``
8691	562	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	562	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	562	4	:	:	:
8691	562	5	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
8691	562	6	's	's	POS
8691	562	7	State	State	NNP
8691	562	8	Trials	Trials	NNPS
8691	562	9	,	,	,
8691	562	10	47	47	CD
8691	562	11	,	,	,
8691	562	12	note	note	NN
8691	562	13	.	.	.
8691	562	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	563	1	For	for	IN
8691	563	2	this	this	DT
8691	563	3	,	,	,
8691	563	4	among	among	IN
8691	563	5	other	other	JJ
8691	563	6	things	thing	NNS
8691	563	7	,	,	,
8691	563	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	563	9	was	be	VBD
8691	563	10	very	very	RB
8691	563	11	properly	properly	RB
8691	563	12	impeached	impeach	VBN
8691	563	13	and	and	CC
8691	563	14	removed	remove	VBN
8691	563	15	in	in	IN
8691	563	16	1803	1803	CD
8691	563	17	,	,	,
8691	563	18	after	after	IN
8691	563	19	the	the	DT
8691	563	20	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
8691	563	21	came	come	VBD
8691	563	22	into	into	IN
8691	563	23	power	power	NN
8691	563	24	in	in	IN
8691	563	25	that	that	DT
8691	563	26	State	State	NNP
8691	563	27	.	.	.
8691	564	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	564	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	564	3	:	:	:
8691	564	4	McMaster	McMaster	NNP
8691	564	5	,	,	,
8691	564	6	"	"	``
8691	564	7	History	history	NN
8691	564	8	of	of	IN
8691	564	9	the	the	DT
8691	564	10	People	People	NNS
8691	564	11	of	of	IN
8691	564	12	the	the	DT
8691	564	13	United	United	NNP
8691	564	14	States	States	NNP
8691	564	15	,	,	,
8691	564	16	"	"	``
8691	564	17	III	iii	CD
8691	564	18	,	,	,
8691	564	19	154	154	CD
8691	564	20	.	.	.
8691	564	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	565	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	565	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	565	3	difficult	difficult	JJ
8691	565	4	for	for	IN
8691	565	5	the	the	DT
8691	565	6	American	American	NNP
8691	565	7	of	of	IN
8691	565	8	the	the	DT
8691	565	9	twentieth	twentieth	JJ
8691	565	10	century	century	NN
8691	565	11	to	to	TO
8691	565	12	conceive	conceive	VB
8691	565	13	how	how	WRB
8691	565	14	honorable	honorable	JJ
8691	565	15	men	man	NNS
8691	565	16	could	could	MD
8691	565	17	so	so	RB
8691	565	18	have	have	VB
8691	565	19	abused	abuse	VBN
8691	565	20	official	official	JJ
8691	565	21	position	position	NN
8691	565	22	.	.	.
8691	566	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	566	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	566	3	:	:	:
8691	566	4	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
8691	566	5	's	's	POS
8691	566	6	State	State	NNP
8691	566	7	Trials	Trials	NNPS
8691	566	8	,	,	,
8691	566	9	376	376	CD
8691	566	10	.	.	.
8691	567	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	567	2	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	567	3	made	make	VBD
8691	567	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	567	5	a	a	DT
8691	567	6	rule	rule	NN
8691	567	7	not	not	RB
8691	567	8	to	to	TO
8691	567	9	enter	enter	VB
8691	567	10	into	into	IN
8691	567	11	any	any	DT
8691	567	12	political	political	JJ
8691	567	13	questions	question	NNS
8691	567	14	in	in	IN
8691	567	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	567	16	charges	charge	NNS
8691	567	17	unless	unless	IN
8691	567	18	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	567	19	for	for	IN
8691	567	20	the	the	DT
8691	567	21	guidance	guidance	NN
8691	567	22	of	of	IN
8691	567	23	the	the	DT
8691	567	24	grand	grand	JJ
8691	567	25	jury	jury	NN
8691	567	26	in	in	IN
8691	567	27	the	the	DT
8691	567	28	work	work	NN
8691	567	29	before	before	IN
8691	567	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	567	31	,	,	,
8691	567	32	and	and	CC
8691	567	33	until	until	IN
8691	567	34	1817	1817	CD
8691	567	35	,	,	,
8691	567	36	when	when	WRB
8691	567	37	party	party	NN
8691	567	38	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	567	39	had	have	VBD
8691	567	40	moderated	moderate	VBN
8691	567	41	,	,	,
8691	567	42	not	not	RB
8691	567	43	to	to	TO
8691	567	44	give	give	VB
8691	567	45	out	out	RP
8691	567	46	copies	copy	NNS
8691	567	47	of	of	IN
8691	567	48	any	any	DT
8691	567	49	charges	charge	NNS
8691	567	50	for	for	IN
8691	567	51	publication	publication	NN
8691	567	52	.	.	.
8691	568	1	Niles	Niles	NNP
8691	568	2	'	'	POS
8691	568	3	Register	Register	NNP
8691	568	4	,	,	,
8691	568	5	XIII	XIII	NNP
8691	568	6	,	,	,
8691	568	7	169	169	CD
8691	568	8	.	.	.
8691	568	9	]	]	-RRB-
8691	569	1	The	the	DT
8691	569	2	cause	cause	NN
8691	569	3	lies	lie	VBZ
8691	569	4	in	in	IN
8691	569	5	the	the	DT
8691	569	6	extreme	extreme	JJ
8691	569	7	rancor	rancor	NN
8691	569	8	which	which	WDT
8691	569	9	then	then	RB
8691	569	10	embittered	embitter	VBD
8691	569	11	politics	politic	NNS
8691	569	12	and	and	CC
8691	569	13	debased	debase	VBD
8691	569	14	society	society	NN
8691	569	15	.	.	.
8691	570	1	Federalists	federalist	NNS
8691	570	2	and	and	CC
8691	570	3	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
8691	570	4	were	be	VBD
8691	570	5	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	570	6	on	on	IN
8691	570	7	speaking	speak	VBG
8691	570	8	terms	term	NNS
8691	570	9	.	.	.
8691	571	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	571	2	who	who	WP
8691	571	3	were	be	VBD
8691	571	4	actively	actively	RB
8691	571	5	engaged	engage	VBN
8691	571	6	in	in	IN
8691	571	7	politics	politic	NNS
8691	571	8	felt	feel	VBD
8691	571	9	compelled	compel	VBN
8691	571	10	to	to	TO
8691	571	11	carry	carry	VB
8691	571	12	a	a	DT
8691	571	13	sword	sword	NN
8691	571	14	cane	cane	NN
8691	571	15	for	for	IN
8691	571	16	defence	defence	NN
8691	571	17	if	if	IN
8691	571	18	attacked	attack	VBN
8691	571	19	.	.	.
8691	572	1	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	572	2	Addison	Addison	NNP
8691	572	3	's	's	POS
8691	572	4	charge	charge	NN
8691	572	5	brought	bring	VBD
8691	572	6	out	out	RP
8691	572	7	an	an	DT
8691	572	8	open	open	JJ
8691	572	9	letter	letter	NN
8691	572	10	to	to	IN
8691	572	11	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	572	12	in	in	IN
8691	572	13	a	a	DT
8691	572	14	Pittsburgh	Pittsburgh	NNP
8691	572	15	newspaper	newspaper	NN
8691	572	16	,	,	,
8691	572	17	signed	sign	VBN
8691	572	18	by	by	IN
8691	572	19	a	a	DT
8691	572	20	Republican	Republican	NNP
8691	572	21	who	who	WP
8691	572	22	was	be	VBD
8691	572	23	on	on	IN
8691	572	24	the	the	DT
8691	572	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	572	26	bench	bench	NN
8691	572	27	of	of	IN
8691	572	28	the	the	DT
8691	572	29	State	State	NNP
8691	572	30	,	,	,
8691	572	31	expressing	express	VBG
8691	572	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	572	33	astonishment	astonishment	NN
8691	572	34	that	that	IN
8691	572	35	the	the	DT
8691	572	36	people	people	NNS
8691	572	37	who	who	WP
8691	572	38	heard	hear	VBD
8691	572	39	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	572	40	"	"	``
8691	572	41	were	be	VBD
8691	572	42	not	not	RB
8691	572	43	fired	fire	VBN
8691	572	44	with	with	IN
8691	572	45	sudden	sudden	JJ
8691	572	46	indignation	indignation	NN
8691	572	47	and	and	CC
8691	572	48	did	do	VBD
8691	572	49	not	not	RB
8691	572	50	drag	drag	VB
8691	572	51	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	572	52	from	from	IN
8691	572	53	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	572	54	seat	seat	NN
8691	572	55	and	and	CC
8691	572	56	tread	tread	VBP
8691	572	57	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	572	58	under	under	IN
8691	572	59	foot	foot	NN
8691	572	60	.	.	.
8691	573	1	"	"	``
8691	573	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	573	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	573	4	:	:	:
8691	573	5	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
8691	573	6	's	's	POS
8691	573	7	State	State	NNP
8691	573	8	Trials	Trials	NNPS
8691	573	9	,	,	,
8691	573	10	47	47	CD
8691	573	11	,	,	,
8691	573	12	note	note	NN
8691	573	13	.	.	.
8691	573	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	574	1	On	on	IN
8691	574	2	the	the	DT
8691	574	3	other	other	JJ
8691	574	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	574	5	,	,	,
8691	574	6	at	at	IN
8691	574	7	a	a	DT
8691	574	8	political	political	JJ
8691	574	9	banquet	banquet	NN
8691	574	10	of	of	IN
8691	574	11	the	the	DT
8691	574	12	Boston	Boston	NNP
8691	574	13	Federalists	Federalists	NNPS
8691	574	14	,	,	,
8691	574	15	at	at	IN
8691	574	16	about	about	IN
8691	574	17	the	the	DT
8691	574	18	same	same	JJ
8691	574	19	time	time	NN
8691	574	20	,	,	,
8691	574	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	574	22	approval	approval	NN
8691	574	23	of	of	IN
8691	574	24	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	574	25	Dana	Dana	NNP
8691	574	26	's	's	POS
8691	574	27	charges	charge	NNS
8691	574	28	to	to	IN
8691	574	29	grand	grand	JJ
8691	574	30	juries	jury	NNS
8691	574	31	was	be	VBD
8691	574	32	manifested	manifest	VBN
8691	574	33	by	by	IN
8691	574	34	this	this	DT
8691	574	35	toast	toast	NN
8691	574	36	:	:	:
8691	574	37	"	"	``
8691	574	38	The	the	DT
8691	574	39	Honorable	honorable	JJ
8691	574	40	Francis	Francis	NNP
8691	574	41	Dana	Dana	NNP
8691	574	42	,	,	,
8691	574	43	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	574	44	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	574	45	of	of	IN
8691	574	46	the	the	DT
8691	574	47	learned	learn	VBN
8691	574	48	Associate	Associate	NNP
8691	574	49	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	574	50	of	of	IN
8691	574	51	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	574	52	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	574	53	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	574	54	Court	Court	NNP
8691	574	55	.	.	.
8691	575	1	While	while	IN
8691	575	2	the	the	DT
8691	575	3	political	political	JJ
8691	575	4	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	575	5	delivered	deliver	VBN
8691	575	6	from	from	IN
8691	575	7	the	the	DT
8691	575	8	bench	bench	NN
8691	575	9	are	be	VBP
8691	575	10	dictated	dictate	VBN
8691	575	11	by	by	IN
8691	575	12	intelligence	intelligence	NN
8691	575	13	,	,	,
8691	575	14	integrity	integrity	NN
8691	575	15	and	and	CC
8691	575	16	patriotism	patriotism	NN
8691	575	17	,	,	,
8691	575	18	may	may	MD
8691	575	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	575	20	be	be	VB
8691	575	21	as	as	RB
8691	575	22	highly	highly	RB
8691	575	23	respected	respected	JJ
8691	575	24	as	as	IN
8691	575	25	have	have	VBP
8691	575	26	ever	ever	RB
8691	575	27	been	be	VBN
8691	575	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	575	29	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	575	30	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	575	31	.	.	.
8691	576	1	"	"	``
8691	576	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	576	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	576	4	:	:	:
8691	576	5	Austin	Austin	NNP
8691	576	6	,	,	,
8691	576	7	"	"	``
8691	576	8	Life	Life	NNP
8691	576	9	of	of	IN
8691	576	10	Elbridge	Elbridge	NNP
8691	576	11	Gerry	Gerry	NNP
8691	576	12	,	,	,
8691	576	13	"	"	``
8691	576	14	II	ii	CD
8691	576	15	,	,	,
8691	576	16	297	297	CD
8691	576	17	,	,	,
8691	576	18	note	note	NN
8691	576	19	.	.	.
8691	576	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	577	1	The	the	DT
8691	577	2	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	577	3	may	may	MD
8691	577	4	,	,	,
8691	577	5	and	and	CC
8691	577	6	often	often	RB
8691	577	7	do	do	VBP
8691	577	8	,	,	,
8691	577	9	command	command	VB
8691	577	10	and	and	CC
8691	577	11	compel	compel	VB
8691	577	12	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	577	13	executive	executive	JJ
8691	577	14	officers	officer	NNS
8691	577	15	to	to	TO
8691	577	16	do	do	VB
8691	577	17	specific	specific	JJ
8691	577	18	official	official	JJ
8691	577	19	acts	act	NNS
8691	577	20	which	which	WDT
8691	577	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	577	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	577	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	577	24	plain	plain	JJ
8691	577	25	duty	duty	NN
8691	577	26	to	to	TO
8691	577	27	perform	perform	VB
8691	577	28	,	,	,
8691	577	29	or	or	CC
8691	577	30	issue	issue	VB
8691	577	31	an	an	DT
8691	577	32	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	577	33	to	to	TO
8691	577	34	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	577	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	577	36	doing	do	VBG
8691	577	37	an	an	DT
8691	577	38	official	official	JJ
8691	577	39	act	act	NN
8691	577	40	which	which	WDT
8691	577	41	is	be	VBZ
8691	577	42	plainly	plainly	RB
8691	577	43	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	577	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	577	45	powers	power	NNS
8691	577	46	.	.	.
8691	578	1	Heads	head	NNS
8691	578	2	of	of	IN
8691	578	3	Departments	Departments	NNPS
8691	578	4	of	of	IN
8691	578	5	the	the	DT
8691	578	6	State	State	NNP
8691	578	7	or	or	CC
8691	578	8	the	the	DT
8691	578	9	United	United	NNP
8691	578	10	States	States	NNP
8691	578	11	are	be	VBP
8691	578	12	subject	subject	JJ
8691	578	13	to	to	IN
8691	578	14	this	this	DT
8691	578	15	power	power	NN
8691	578	16	.	.	.
8691	579	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	579	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	579	3	:	:	:
8691	579	4	Noble	Noble	NNP
8691	579	5	_	_	NNP
8691	579	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	579	7	_	_	NNP
8691	579	8	Union	Union	NNP
8691	579	9	River	River	NNP
8691	579	10	Logging	Logging	NNP
8691	579	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	579	12	,	,	,
8691	579	13	147	147	CD
8691	579	14	U.	U.	NNP
8691	579	15	S.	S.	NNP
8691	579	16	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	579	17	,	,	,
8691	579	18	165	165	CD
8691	579	19	;	;	:
8691	579	20	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
8691	579	21	_	_	NNP
8691	579	22	v.	v.	IN
8691	579	23	_	_	NNP
8691	579	24	Ames	Ames	NNP
8691	579	25	,	,	,
8691	579	26	169	169	CD
8691	579	27	U.	U.	NNP
8691	579	28	S.	S.	NNP
8691	579	29	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	579	30	,	,	,
8691	579	31	466	466	CD
8691	579	32	.	.	.
8691	579	33	]	]	-RRB-
8691	580	1	So	so	RB
8691	580	2	in	in	IN
8691	580	3	the	the	DT
8691	580	4	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	580	5	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	580	6	are	be	VBP
8691	580	7	Governors	Governors	NNPS
8691	580	8	of	of	IN
8691	580	9	States	States	NNPS
8691	580	10	acting	act	VBG
8691	580	11	under	under	IN
8691	580	12	a	a	DT
8691	580	13	law	law	NN
8691	580	14	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
8691	580	15	to	to	IN
8691	580	16	the	the	DT
8691	580	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	580	18	of	of	IN
8691	580	19	the	the	DT
8691	580	20	United	United	NNP
8691	580	21	States	States	NNP
8691	580	22	.	.	.
8691	581	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	581	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	581	3	:	:	:
8691	581	4	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
8691	581	5	_	_	NNP
8691	581	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	581	7	_	_	NNP
8691	581	8	McConnaughy	McConnaughy	NNP
8691	581	9	,	,	,
8691	581	10	140	140	CD
8691	581	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	581	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	581	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	581	14	,	,	,
8691	581	15	1	1	CD
8691	581	16	.	.	.
8691	581	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	582	1	No	no	DT
8691	582	2	such	such	JJ
8691	582	3	writ	writ	NN
8691	582	4	will	will	MD
8691	582	5	be	be	VB
8691	582	6	issued	issue	VBN
8691	582	7	,	,	,
8691	582	8	however	however	RB
8691	582	9	,	,	,
8691	582	10	when	when	WRB
8691	582	11	the	the	DT
8691	582	12	case	case	NN
8691	582	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	582	14	of	of	IN
8691	582	15	a	a	DT
8691	582	16	political	political	JJ
8691	582	17	nature	nature	NN
8691	582	18	and	and	CC
8691	582	19	involves	involve	VBZ
8691	582	20	the	the	DT
8691	582	21	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	582	22	of	of	IN
8691	582	23	any	any	DT
8691	582	24	official	official	JJ
8691	582	25	discretion,[Footnote	discretion,[Footnote	NNP
8691	582	26	:	:	:
8691	582	27	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	582	28	_	_	NNP
8691	582	29	v.	v.	IN
8691	582	30	_	_	NNP
8691	582	31	Stanton	Stanton	NNP
8691	582	32	,	,	,
8691	582	33	6	6	CD
8691	582	34	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	582	35	's	's	POS
8691	582	36	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	582	37	,	,	,
8691	582	38	50	50	CD
8691	582	39	.	.	.
8691	582	40	]	]	-RRB-
8691	583	1	nor	nor	CC
8691	583	2	under	under	IN
8691	583	3	any	any	DT
8691	583	4	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	583	5	against	against	IN
8691	583	6	the	the	DT
8691	583	7	President	President	NNP
8691	583	8	of	of	IN
8691	583	9	the	the	DT
8691	583	10	United	United	NNP
8691	583	11	States	States	NNP
8691	583	12	.	.	.
8691	584	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	584	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	584	3	:	:	:
8691	584	4	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	584	5	_	_	NNP
8691	584	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	584	7	_	_	NNP
8691	584	8	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	584	9	,	,	,
8691	584	10	4	4	CD
8691	584	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	584	12	's	's	POS
8691	584	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	584	14	,	,	,
8691	584	15	475	475	CD
8691	584	16	.	.	.
8691	584	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	585	1	As	as	IN
8691	585	2	to	to	IN
8691	585	3	whether	whether	IN
8691	585	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	585	5	can	can	MD
8691	585	6	in	in	IN
8691	585	7	some	some	DT
8691	585	8	cases	case	NNS
8691	585	9	be	be	VB
8691	585	10	granted	grant	VBN
8691	585	11	by	by	IN
8691	585	12	a	a	DT
8691	585	13	State	State	NNP
8691	585	14	court	court	NN
8691	585	15	against	against	IN
8691	585	16	the	the	DT
8691	585	17	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	585	18	there	there	EX
8691	585	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	585	20	a	a	DT
8691	585	21	conflict	conflict	NN
8691	585	22	of	of	IN
8691	585	23	authority	authority	NN
8691	585	24	.	.	.
8691	586	1	The	the	DT
8691	586	2	development	development	NN
8691	586	3	of	of	IN
8691	586	4	party	party	NN
8691	586	5	government	government	NN
8691	586	6	in	in	IN
8691	586	7	the	the	DT
8691	586	8	United	United	NNP
8691	586	9	States	States	NNP
8691	586	10	has	have	VBZ
8691	586	11	led	lead	VBN
8691	586	12	of	of	IN
8691	586	13	recent	recent	JJ
8691	586	14	years	year	NNS
8691	586	15	to	to	IN
8691	586	16	much	much	JJ
8691	586	17	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	586	18	for	for	IN
8691	586	19	the	the	DT
8691	586	20	regulation	regulation	NN
8691	586	21	of	of	IN
8691	586	22	party	party	NN
8691	586	23	conventions	convention	NNS
8691	586	24	and	and	CC
8691	586	25	party	party	NN
8691	586	26	organization	organization	NN
8691	586	27	in	in	IN
8691	586	28	the	the	DT
8691	586	29	interest	interest	NN
8691	586	30	of	of	IN
8691	586	31	fair	fair	JJ
8691	586	32	dealing	dealing	NN
8691	586	33	and	and	CC
8691	586	34	public	public	JJ
8691	586	35	order	order	NN
8691	586	36	.	.	.
8691	587	1	Statutes	statute	NNS
8691	587	2	of	of	IN
8691	587	3	this	this	DT
8691	587	4	nature	nature	NN
8691	587	5	relating	relate	VBG
8691	587	6	to	to	IN
8691	587	7	the	the	DT
8691	587	8	form	form	NN
8691	587	9	and	and	CC
8691	587	10	heading	heading	NN
8691	587	11	of	of	IN
8691	587	12	ballots	ballot	NNS
8691	587	13	for	for	IN
8691	587	14	use	use	NN
8691	587	15	at	at	IN
8691	587	16	popular	popular	JJ
8691	587	17	elections	election	NNS
8691	587	18	are	be	VBP
8691	587	19	common	common	JJ
8691	587	20	.	.	.
8691	588	1	If	if	IN
8691	588	2	conflicting	conflict	VBG
8691	588	3	factions	faction	NNS
8691	588	4	contend	contend	VBP
8691	588	5	for	for	IN
8691	588	6	the	the	DT
8691	588	7	right	right	NN
8691	588	8	of	of	IN
8691	588	9	issuing	issue	VBG
8691	588	10	ballots	ballot	NNS
8691	588	11	in	in	IN
8691	588	12	the	the	DT
8691	588	13	name	name	NN
8691	588	14	of	of	IN
8691	588	15	the	the	DT
8691	588	16	same	same	JJ
8691	588	17	party	party	NN
8691	588	18	,	,	,
8691	588	19	the	the	DT
8691	588	20	courts	court	NNS
8691	588	21	may	may	MD
8691	588	22	be	be	VB
8691	588	23	called	call	VBN
8691	588	24	upon	upon	IN
8691	588	25	to	to	TO
8691	588	26	decide	decide	VB
8691	588	27	between	between	IN
8691	588	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	588	29	on	on	IN
8691	588	30	an	an	DT
8691	588	31	application	application	NN
8691	588	32	for	for	IN
8691	588	33	an	an	DT
8691	588	34	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	588	35	or	or	CC
8691	588	36	writ	writ	NN
8691	588	37	of	of	IN
8691	588	38	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
8691	588	39	.	.	.
8691	589	1	The	the	DT
8691	589	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	589	3	,	,	,
8691	589	4	however	however	RB
8691	589	5	,	,	,
8691	589	6	may	may	MD
8691	589	7	provide	provide	VB
8691	589	8	that	that	IN
8691	589	9	some	some	DT
8691	589	10	standing	stand	VBG
8691	589	11	agency	agency	NN
8691	589	12	or	or	CC
8691	589	13	committee	committee	NN
8691	589	14	of	of	IN
8691	589	15	a	a	DT
8691	589	16	party	party	NN
8691	589	17	shall	shall	MD
8691	589	18	decide	decide	VB
8691	589	19	finally	finally	RB
8691	589	20	upon	upon	IN
8691	589	21	any	any	DT
8691	589	22	such	such	JJ
8691	589	23	conflicting	conflicting	JJ
8691	589	24	claims	claim	NNS
8691	589	25	,	,	,
8691	589	26	and	and	CC
8691	589	27	in	in	IN
8691	589	28	such	such	JJ
8691	589	29	case	case	NN
8691	589	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	589	31	decision	decision	NN
8691	589	32	will	will	MD
8691	589	33	be	be	VB
8691	589	34	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	589	35	upon	upon	IN
8691	589	36	the	the	DT
8691	589	37	courts	court	NNS
8691	589	38	.	.	.
8691	590	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	590	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	590	3	:	:	:
8691	590	4	State	State	NNP
8691	590	5	_	_	NNP
8691	590	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	590	7	_	_	NNP
8691	590	8	Houser	Houser	NNP
8691	590	9	,	,	,
8691	590	10	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
8691	590	11	Reports	report	VBZ
8691	590	12	;	;	:
8691	590	13	100	100	CD
8691	590	14	Northwestern	northwestern	JJ
8691	590	15	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	590	16	,	,	,
8691	590	17	964	964	CD
8691	590	18	.	.	.
8691	590	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	591	1	When	when	WRB
8691	591	2	title	title	NN
8691	591	3	to	to	IN
8691	591	4	a	a	DT
8691	591	5	political	political	JJ
8691	591	6	office	office	NN
8691	591	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	591	8	contested	contest	VBN
8691	591	9	,	,	,
8691	591	10	the	the	DT
8691	591	11	courts	court	NNS
8691	591	12	,	,	,
8691	591	13	unless	unless	IN
8691	591	14	there	there	EX
8691	591	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	591	16	some	some	DT
8691	591	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	591	18	provision	provision	NN
8691	591	19	to	to	IN
8691	591	20	the	the	DT
8691	591	21	contrary	contrary	NN
8691	591	22	,	,	,
8691	591	23	may	may	MD
8691	591	24	be	be	VB
8691	591	25	appealed	appeal	VBN
8691	591	26	to	to	IN
8691	591	27	for	for	IN
8691	591	28	a	a	DT
8691	591	29	decision	decision	NN
8691	591	30	.	.	.
8691	592	1	This	this	DT
8691	592	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	592	3	true	true	JJ
8691	592	4	even	even	RB
8691	592	5	in	in	IN
8691	592	6	respect	respect	NN
8691	592	7	to	to	IN
8691	592	8	the	the	DT
8691	592	9	office	office	NN
8691	592	10	of	of	IN
8691	592	11	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	592	12	.	.	.
8691	593	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	593	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	593	3	:	:	:
8691	593	4	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
8691	593	5	_	_	NNP
8691	593	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	593	7	_	_	NNP
8691	593	8	Thayer	Thayer	NNP
8691	593	9	,	,	,
8691	593	10	143	143	CD
8691	593	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	593	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	593	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	593	14	,	,	,
8691	593	15	135	135	CD
8691	593	16	;	;	:
8691	593	17	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
8691	593	18	_	_	NNP
8691	593	19	v.	v.	IN
8691	593	20	_	_	NNP
8691	593	21	Beckham	Beckham	NNP
8691	593	22	,	,	,
8691	593	23	178	178	CD
8691	593	24	U.	U.	NNP
8691	593	25	S.	S.	NNP
8691	593	26	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	593	27	,	,	,
8691	593	28	548	548	CD
8691	593	29	;	;	:
8691	593	30	State	State	NNP
8691	593	31	_	_	NNP
8691	593	32	v.	v.	IN
8691	593	33	_	_	NNP
8691	593	34	Bulkeley	Bulkeley	NNP
8691	593	35	,	,	,
8691	593	36	61	61	CD
8691	593	37	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	593	38	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	593	39	,	,	,
8691	593	40	287	287	CD
8691	593	41	.	.	.
8691	593	42	]	]	-RRB-
8691	594	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	594	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	594	3	a	a	DT
8691	594	4	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	594	5	which	which	WDT
8691	594	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	594	7	been	be	VBN
8691	594	8	,	,	,
8691	594	9	though	though	IN
8691	594	10	in	in	IN
8691	594	11	rare	rare	JJ
8691	594	12	instances	instance	NNS
8691	594	13	,	,	,
8691	594	14	abused	abuse	VBN
8691	594	15	for	for	IN
8691	594	16	party	party	NN
8691	594	17	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	594	18	.	.	.
8691	595	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	595	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	595	3	:	:	:
8691	595	4	Such	such	PDT
8691	595	5	a	a	DT
8691	595	6	case	case	NN
8691	595	7	was	be	VBD
8691	595	8	the	the	DT
8691	595	9	issue	issue	NN
8691	595	10	by	by	IN
8691	595	11	a	a	DT
8691	595	12	District	District	NNP
8691	595	13	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	595	14	of	of	IN
8691	595	15	the	the	DT
8691	595	16	United	United	NNP
8691	595	17	States	States	NNP
8691	595	18	in	in	IN
8691	595	19	1872	1872	CD
8691	595	20	of	of	IN
8691	595	21	an	an	DT
8691	595	22	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	595	23	-	-	HYPH
8691	595	24	order	order	NN
8691	595	25	under	under	IN
8691	595	26	which	which	WDT
8691	595	27	the	the	DT
8691	595	28	Marshal	Marshal	NNP
8691	595	29	took	take	VBD
8691	595	30	possession	possession	NN
8691	595	31	of	of	IN
8691	595	32	the	the	DT
8691	595	33	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	595	34	State	State	NNP
8691	595	35	-	-	HYPH
8691	595	36	house	house	NNP
8691	595	37	,	,	,
8691	595	38	and	and	CC
8691	595	39	excluded	exclude	VBD
8691	595	40	those	those	DT
8691	595	41	claiming	claim	VBG
8691	595	42	to	to	TO
8691	595	43	be	be	VB
8691	595	44	the	the	DT
8691	595	45	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	595	46	of	of	IN
8691	595	47	the	the	DT
8691	595	48	State	State	NNP
8691	595	49	.	.	.
8691	596	1	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
8691	596	2	,	,	,
8691	596	3	"	"	``
8691	596	4	A	a	DT
8691	596	5	Political	Political	NNP
8691	596	6	Crime	Crime	NNP
8691	596	7	,	,	,
8691	596	8	"	"	''
8691	596	9	347	347	CD
8691	596	10	_	_	NNP
8691	596	11	et	et	NNP
8691	596	12	seq	seq	NN
8691	596	13	.	.	.
8691	596	14	_	_	NNP
8691	596	15	;	;	:
8691	596	16	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	596	17	Report	Report	NNP
8691	596	18	,	,	,
8691	596	19	457	457	CD
8691	596	20	,	,	,
8691	596	21	Forty	forty	CD
8691	596	22	-	-	HYPH
8691	596	23	second	second	NN
8691	596	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	596	25	,	,	,
8691	596	26	third	third	JJ
8691	596	27	session	session	NN
8691	596	28	.	.	.
8691	596	29	]	]	-RRB-
8691	597	1	The	the	DT
8691	597	2	right	right	NN
8691	597	3	of	of	IN
8691	597	4	the	the	DT
8691	597	5	Governors	Governors	NNPS
8691	597	6	,	,	,
8691	597	7	which	which	WDT
8691	597	8	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	597	9	under	under	IN
8691	597	10	the	the	DT
8691	597	11	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	597	12	of	of	IN
8691	597	13	several	several	JJ
8691	597	14	States	state	NNS
8691	597	15	,	,	,
8691	597	16	to	to	TO
8691	597	17	ask	ask	VB
8691	597	18	the	the	DT
8691	597	19	judges	judge	NNS
8691	597	20	of	of	IN
8691	597	21	the	the	DT
8691	597	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	597	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	597	24	for	for	IN
8691	597	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	597	26	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	597	27	on	on	IN
8691	597	28	any	any	DT
8691	597	29	question	question	NN
8691	597	30	of	of	IN
8691	597	31	law	law	NN
8691	597	32	,	,	,
8691	597	33	may	may	MD
8691	597	34	throw	throw	VB
8691	597	35	upon	upon	IN
8691	597	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	597	37	the	the	DT
8691	597	38	delicate	delicate	JJ
8691	597	39	task	task	NN
8691	597	40	of	of	IN
8691	597	41	deciding	decide	VBG
8691	597	42	in	in	IN
8691	597	43	a	a	DT
8691	597	44	collateral	collateral	JJ
8691	597	45	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	597	46	who	who	WP
8691	597	47	is	be	VBZ
8691	597	48	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	597	49	,	,	,
8691	597	50	if	if	IN
8691	597	51	the	the	DT
8691	597	52	title	title	NN
8691	597	53	to	to	IN
8691	597	54	the	the	DT
8691	597	55	office	office	NN
8691	597	56	is	be	VBZ
8691	597	57	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	597	58	by	by	IN
8691	597	59	two	two	CD
8691	597	60	.	.	.
8691	598	1	This	this	DT
8691	598	2	was	be	VBD
8691	598	3	the	the	DT
8691	598	4	case	case	NN
8691	598	5	in	in	IN
8691	598	6	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	598	7	in	in	IN
8691	598	8	1869	1869	CD
8691	598	9	.	.	.
8691	599	1	The	the	DT
8691	599	2	House	House	NNP
8691	599	3	of	of	IN
8691	599	4	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
8691	599	5	had	have	VBD
8691	599	6	commenced	commence	VBN
8691	599	7	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	599	8	of	of	IN
8691	599	9	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	599	10	against	against	IN
8691	599	11	the	the	DT
8691	599	12	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	599	13	.	.	.
8691	600	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	600	2	was	be	VBD
8691	600	3	on	on	IN
8691	600	4	the	the	DT
8691	600	5	first	first	JJ
8691	600	6	day	day	NN
8691	600	7	of	of	IN
8691	600	8	a	a	DT
8691	600	9	special	special	JJ
8691	600	10	session	session	NN
8691	600	11	of	of	IN
8691	600	12	the	the	DT
8691	600	13	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	600	14	.	.	.
8691	601	1	There	there	EX
8691	601	2	could	could	MD
8691	601	3	be	be	VB
8691	601	4	no	no	DT
8691	601	5	such	such	JJ
8691	601	6	session	session	NN
8691	601	7	unless	unless	IN
8691	601	8	a	a	DT
8691	601	9	quorum	quorum	NN
8691	601	10	was	be	VBD
8691	601	11	present	present	JJ
8691	601	12	in	in	IN
8691	601	13	each	each	DT
8691	601	14	house	house	NN
8691	601	15	.	.	.
8691	602	1	There	there	EX
8691	602	2	were	be	VBD
8691	602	3	but	but	RB
8691	602	4	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	602	5	Senators	senator	NNS
8691	602	6	in	in	IN
8691	602	7	attendance	attendance	NN
8691	602	8	.	.	.
8691	603	1	The	the	DT
8691	603	2	Lieutenant	Lieutenant	NNP
8691	603	3	-	-	HYPH
8691	603	4	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	603	5	regarded	regard	VBD
8691	603	6	the	the	DT
8691	603	7	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	603	8	as	as	IN
8691	603	9	regular	regular	JJ
8691	603	10	,	,	,
8691	603	11	and	and	CC
8691	603	12	assumed	assume	VBN
8691	603	13	to	to	TO
8691	603	14	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	603	15	the	the	DT
8691	603	16	office	office	NN
8691	603	17	of	of	IN
8691	603	18	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	603	19	pending	pende	VBG
8691	603	20	the	the	DT
8691	603	21	trial	trial	NN
8691	603	22	.	.	.
8691	604	1	The	the	DT
8691	604	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	604	3	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	604	4	that	that	IN
8691	604	5	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	604	6	Senators	Senators	NNPS
8691	604	7	were	be	VBD
8691	604	8	not	not	RB
8691	604	9	a	a	DT
8691	604	10	quorum	quorum	NN
8691	604	11	,	,	,
8691	604	12	and	and	CC
8691	604	13	that	that	IN
8691	604	14	the	the	DT
8691	604	15	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	604	16	were	be	VBD
8691	604	17	void	void	JJ
8691	604	18	.	.	.
8691	605	1	On	on	IN
8691	605	2	these	these	DT
8691	605	3	points	point	NNS
8691	605	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	605	5	requested	request	VBD
8691	605	6	the	the	DT
8691	605	7	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	605	8	of	of	IN
8691	605	9	the	the	DT
8691	605	10	Justices	Justices	NNPS
8691	605	11	of	of	IN
8691	605	12	the	the	DT
8691	605	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	605	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	605	15	,	,	,
8691	605	16	and	and	CC
8691	605	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	605	18	gave	give	VBD
8691	605	19	one	one	CD
8691	605	20	supporting	support	VBG
8691	605	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	605	22	contentions	contention	NNS
8691	605	23	.	.	.
8691	606	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	606	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	606	3	:	:	:
8691	606	4	12	12	CD
8691	606	5	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	606	6	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	606	7	,	,	,
8691	606	8	653	653	CD
8691	606	9	.	.	.
8691	606	10	]	]	-RRB-
8691	607	1	A	a	DT
8691	607	2	few	few	JJ
8691	607	3	weeks	week	NNS
8691	607	4	later	later	RB
8691	607	5	a	a	DT
8691	607	6	regular	regular	JJ
8691	607	7	session	session	NN
8691	607	8	was	be	VBD
8691	607	9	held	hold	VBN
8691	607	10	,	,	,
8691	607	11	at	at	IN
8691	607	12	which	which	WDT
8691	607	13	a	a	DT
8691	607	14	quorum	quorum	NN
8691	607	15	was	be	VBD
8691	607	16	present	present	JJ
8691	607	17	in	in	IN
8691	607	18	each	each	DT
8691	607	19	house	house	NN
8691	607	20	,	,	,
8691	607	21	and	and	CC
8691	607	22	the	the	DT
8691	607	23	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	607	24	of	of	IN
8691	607	25	the	the	DT
8691	607	26	special	special	JJ
8691	607	27	session	session	NN
8691	607	28	were	be	VBD
8691	607	29	treated	treat	VBN
8691	607	30	as	as	IN
8691	607	31	void	void	JJ
8691	607	32	.	.	.
8691	608	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	608	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	608	3	:	:	:
8691	608	4	S.	S.	NNP
8691	608	5	S.	S.	NNP
8691	608	6	Cox	Cox	NNP
8691	608	7	,	,	,
8691	608	8	"	"	``
8691	608	9	Three	Three	NNP
8691	608	10	Decades	Decades	NNPS
8691	608	11	of	of	IN
8691	608	12	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	608	13	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
8691	608	14	,	,	,
8691	608	15	"	"	''
8691	608	16	518	518	CD
8691	608	17	,	,	,
8691	608	18	520	520	CD
8691	608	19	.	.	.
8691	608	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	609	1	In	in	IN
8691	609	2	the	the	DT
8691	609	3	early	early	JJ
8691	609	4	days	day	NNS
8691	609	5	of	of	IN
8691	609	6	the	the	DT
8691	609	7	United	United	NNP
8691	609	8	States	States	NNP
8691	609	9	,	,	,
8691	609	10	under	under	IN
8691	609	11	the	the	DT
8691	609	12	present	present	JJ
8691	609	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	609	14	,	,	,
8691	609	15	the	the	DT
8691	609	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	609	17	Justices	Justices	NNPS
8691	609	18	of	of	IN
8691	609	19	the	the	DT
8691	609	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	609	21	Court	Court	NNP
8691	609	22	of	of	IN
8691	609	23	the	the	DT
8691	609	24	United	United	NNP
8691	609	25	States	States	NNP
8691	609	26	at	at	IN
8691	609	27	times	time	NNS
8691	609	28	filled	fill	VBN
8691	609	29	also	also	RB
8691	609	30	a	a	DT
8691	609	31	political	political	JJ
8691	609	32	office	office	NN
8691	609	33	,	,	,
8691	609	34	and	and	CC
8691	609	35	so	so	RB
8691	609	36	were	be	VBD
8691	609	37	invested	invest	VBN
8691	609	38	at	at	IN
8691	609	39	the	the	DT
8691	609	40	same	same	JJ
8691	609	41	time	time	NN
8691	609	42	with	with	IN
8691	609	43	political	political	JJ
8691	609	44	and	and	CC
8691	609	45	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	609	46	functions	function	NNS
8691	609	47	.	.	.
8691	610	1	John	John	NNP
8691	610	2	Jay	Jay	NNP
8691	610	3	,	,	,
8691	610	4	the	the	DT
8691	610	5	first	first	JJ
8691	610	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	610	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	610	8	,	,	,
8691	610	9	while	while	IN
8691	610	10	holding	hold	VBG
8691	610	11	that	that	DT
8691	610	12	office	office	NN
8691	610	13	,	,	,
8691	610	14	was	be	VBD
8691	610	15	made	make	VBN
8691	610	16	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	610	17	Envoy	Envoy	NNP
8691	610	18	Extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
8691	610	19	to	to	IN
8691	610	20	Great	Great	NNP
8691	610	21	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	610	22	,	,	,
8691	610	23	and	and	CC
8691	610	24	spent	spend	VBD
8691	610	25	a	a	DT
8691	610	26	year	year	NN
8691	610	27	abroad	abroad	RB
8691	610	28	in	in	IN
8691	610	29	that	that	DT
8691	610	30	capacity	capacity	NN
8691	610	31	.	.	.
8691	611	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	611	2	acceptance	acceptance	NN
8691	611	3	of	of	IN
8691	611	4	the	the	DT
8691	611	5	position	position	NN
8691	611	6	,	,	,
8691	611	7	however	however	RB
8691	611	8	,	,	,
8691	611	9	occasioned	occasion	VBD
8691	611	10	general	general	JJ
8691	611	11	and	and	CC
8691	611	12	unfavorable	unfavorable	JJ
8691	611	13	comment	comment	NN
8691	611	14	.	.	.
8691	612	1	John	John	NNP
8691	612	2	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	612	3	was	be	VBD
8691	612	4	both	both	DT
8691	612	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	612	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	612	7	and	and	CC
8691	612	8	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
8691	612	9	of	of	IN
8691	612	10	State	State	NNP
8691	612	11	for	for	IN
8691	612	12	five	five	CD
8691	612	13	weeks	week	NNS
8691	612	14	,	,	,
8691	612	15	during	during	IN
8691	612	16	which	which	WDT
8691	612	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	612	18	held	hold	VBD
8691	612	19	one	one	CD
8691	612	20	term	term	NN
8691	612	21	of	of	IN
8691	612	22	the	the	DT
8691	612	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	612	24	Court	Court	NNP
8691	612	25	.	.	.
8691	613	1	Oliver	Oliver	NNP
8691	613	2	Ellsworth	Ellsworth	NNP
8691	613	3	was	be	VBD
8691	613	4	both	both	DT
8691	613	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	613	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	613	7	and	and	CC
8691	613	8	minister	minister	NN
8691	613	9	to	to	IN
8691	613	10	France	France	NNP
8691	613	11	at	at	IN
8691	613	12	the	the	DT
8691	613	13	same	same	JJ
8691	613	14	time	time	NN
8691	613	15	,	,	,
8691	613	16	and	and	CC
8691	613	17	for	for	IN
8691	613	18	a	a	DT
8691	613	19	period	period	NN
8691	613	20	of	of	IN
8691	613	21	over	over	IN
8691	613	22	a	a	DT
8691	613	23	year	year	NN
8691	613	24	,	,	,
8691	613	25	during	during	IN
8691	613	26	which	which	WDT
8691	613	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	613	28	held	hold	VBD
8691	613	29	one	one	CD
8691	613	30	term	term	NN
8691	613	31	of	of	IN
8691	613	32	court	court	NN
8691	613	33	.	.	.
8691	614	1	Nothing	nothing	NN
8691	614	2	of	of	IN
8691	614	3	this	this	DT
8691	614	4	kind	kind	NN
8691	614	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	614	6	since	since	IN
8691	614	7	occurred	occur	VBN
8691	614	8	,	,	,
8691	614	9	nor	nor	CC
8691	614	10	would	would	MD
8691	614	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	614	12	now	now	RB
8691	614	13	be	be	VB
8691	614	14	thought	think	VBN
8691	614	15	consistent	consistent	JJ
8691	614	16	with	with	IN
8691	614	17	the	the	DT
8691	614	18	proprieties	propriety	NNS
8691	614	19	of	of	IN
8691	614	20	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	614	21	office	office	NN
8691	614	22	.	.	.
8691	615	1	When	when	WRB
8691	615	2	the	the	DT
8691	615	3	result	result	NN
8691	615	4	of	of	IN
8691	615	5	the	the	DT
8691	615	6	election	election	NN
8691	615	7	of	of	IN
8691	615	8	the	the	DT
8691	615	9	President	President	NNP
8691	615	10	and	and	CC
8691	615	11	Vice	Vice	NNP
8691	615	12	-	-	HYPH
8691	615	13	President	President	NNP
8691	615	14	of	of	IN
8691	615	15	the	the	DT
8691	615	16	United	United	NNP
8691	615	17	States	States	NNP
8691	615	18	was	be	VBD
8691	615	19	contested	contest	VBN
8691	615	20	in	in	IN
8691	615	21	1877	1877	CD
8691	615	22	,	,	,
8691	615	23	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	615	24	,	,	,
8691	615	25	as	as	IN
8691	615	26	a	a	DT
8691	615	27	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	615	28	makeshift	makeshift	NN
8691	615	29	,	,	,
8691	615	30	bridged	bridge	VBD
8691	615	31	over	over	IN
8691	615	32	the	the	DT
8691	615	33	difficulty	difficulty	NN
8691	615	34	by	by	IN
8691	615	35	creating	create	VBG
8691	615	36	a	a	DT
8691	615	37	commission	commission	NN
8691	615	38	of	of	IN
8691	615	39	fifteen	fifteen	CD
8691	615	40	,	,	,
8691	615	41	five	five	CD
8691	615	42	from	from	IN
8691	615	43	each	each	DT
8691	615	44	house	house	NN
8691	615	45	and	and	CC
8691	615	46	five	five	CD
8691	615	47	from	from	IN
8691	615	48	the	the	DT
8691	615	49	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	615	50	Court	Court	NNP
8691	615	51	,	,	,
8691	615	52	to	to	TO
8691	615	53	decide	decide	VB
8691	615	54	upon	upon	IN
8691	615	55	the	the	DT
8691	615	56	returns	return	NNS
8691	615	57	.	.	.
8691	616	1	Four	four	CD
8691	616	2	of	of	IN
8691	616	3	the	the	DT
8691	616	4	justices	justice	NNS
8691	616	5	were	be	VBD
8691	616	6	especially	especially	RB
8691	616	7	selected	select	VBN
8691	616	8	by	by	IN
8691	616	9	the	the	DT
8691	616	10	act	act	NN
8691	616	11	passed	pass	VBD
8691	616	12	for	for	IN
8691	616	13	this	this	DT
8691	616	14	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	616	15	,	,	,
8691	616	16	two	two	CD
8691	616	17	of	of	IN
8691	616	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	616	19	being	be	VBG
8691	616	20	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
8691	616	21	and	and	CC
8691	616	22	two	two	CD
8691	616	23	Democrats	Democrats	NNPS
8691	616	24	,	,	,
8691	616	25	and	and	CC
8691	616	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	616	27	were	be	VBD
8691	616	28	directed	direct	VBN
8691	616	29	to	to	TO
8691	616	30	choose	choose	VB
8691	616	31	the	the	DT
8691	616	32	fifth	fifth	NN
8691	616	33	.	.	.
8691	617	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	617	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	617	3	:	:	:
8691	617	4	19	19	CD
8691	617	5	United	United	NNP
8691	617	6	States	States	NNP
8691	617	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	617	8	at	at	IN
8691	617	9	Large	Large	NNP
8691	617	10	,	,	,
8691	617	11	228	228	CD
8691	617	12	.	.	.
8691	617	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	618	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	618	2	agreed	agree	VBD
8691	618	3	on	on	IN
8691	618	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	618	5	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
8691	618	6	,	,	,
8691	618	7	a	a	DT
8691	618	8	Republican	Republican	NNP
8691	618	9	.	.	.
8691	619	1	The	the	DT
8691	619	2	Congressional	congressional	JJ
8691	619	3	members	member	NNS
8691	619	4	were	be	VBD
8691	619	5	equally	equally	RB
8691	619	6	divided	divide	VBN
8691	619	7	politically	politically	RB
8691	619	8	.	.	.
8691	620	1	The	the	DT
8691	620	2	result	result	NN
8691	620	3	proved	prove	VBD
8691	620	4	to	to	TO
8691	620	5	be	be	VB
8691	620	6	that	that	IN
8691	620	7	on	on	IN
8691	620	8	every	every	DT
8691	620	9	important	important	JJ
8691	620	10	question	question	NN
8691	620	11	in	in	IN
8691	620	12	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	620	13	every	every	DT
8691	620	14	Republican	Republican	NNP
8691	620	15	voted	vote	VBD
8691	620	16	for	for	IN
8691	620	17	the	the	DT
8691	620	18	view	view	NN
8691	620	19	favorable	favorable	JJ
8691	620	20	to	to	IN
8691	620	21	the	the	DT
8691	620	22	Republican	republican	JJ
8691	620	23	candidates	candidate	NNS
8691	620	24	and	and	CC
8691	620	25	every	every	DT
8691	620	26	Democrat	Democrat	NNP
8691	620	27	voted	vote	VBD
8691	620	28	for	for	IN
8691	620	29	the	the	DT
8691	620	30	other	other	JJ
8691	620	31	.	.	.
8691	621	1	The	the	DT
8691	621	2	country	country	NN
8691	621	3	could	could	MD
8691	621	4	not	not	RB
8691	621	5	fail	fail	VB
8691	621	6	to	to	TO
8691	621	7	see	see	VB
8691	621	8	that	that	IN
8691	621	9	judges	judge	NNS
8691	621	10	,	,	,
8691	621	11	as	as	RB
8691	621	12	well	well	RB
8691	621	13	as	as	IN
8691	621	14	other	other	JJ
8691	621	15	public	public	JJ
8691	621	16	men	man	NNS
8691	621	17	,	,	,
8691	621	18	may	may	MD
8691	621	19	be	be	VB
8691	621	20	insensibly	insensibly	RB
8691	621	21	influenced	influence	VBN
8691	621	22	by	by	IN
8691	621	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	621	24	political	political	JJ
8691	621	25	affiliations	affiliation	NNS
8691	621	26	,	,	,
8691	621	27	and	and	CC
8691	621	28	regarded	regard	VBD
8691	621	29	the	the	DT
8691	621	30	whole	whole	JJ
8691	621	31	matter	matter	NN
8691	621	32	as	as	IN
8691	621	33	a	a	DT
8691	621	34	new	new	JJ
8691	621	35	proof	proof	NN
8691	621	36	of	of	IN
8691	621	37	the	the	DT
8691	621	38	wisdom	wisdom	NN
8691	621	39	of	of	IN
8691	621	40	separating	separate	VBG
8691	621	41	the	the	DT
8691	621	42	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	621	43	from	from	IN
8691	621	44	any	any	DT
8691	621	45	unjudicial	unjudicial	JJ
8691	621	46	participation	participation	NN
8691	621	47	in	in	IN
8691	621	48	the	the	DT
8691	621	49	decision	decision	NN
8691	621	50	of	of	IN
8691	621	51	political	political	JJ
8691	621	52	issues	issue	NNS
8691	621	53	.	.	.
8691	622	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	622	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	622	3	:	:	:
8691	622	4	See	see	VB
8691	622	5	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
8691	622	6	,	,	,
8691	622	7	"	"	``
8691	622	8	Division	Division	NNP
8691	622	9	and	and	CC
8691	622	10	Reunion	Reunion	NNP
8691	622	11	,	,	,
8691	622	12	"	"	''
8691	622	13	286	286	CD
8691	622	14	;	;	:
8691	622	15	S.	S.	NNP
8691	622	16	S.	S.	NNP
8691	622	17	Cox	Cox	NNP
8691	622	18	,	,	,
8691	622	19	"	"	``
8691	622	20	Three	Three	NNP
8691	622	21	Decades	Decades	NNPS
8691	622	22	of	of	IN
8691	622	23	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	622	24	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
8691	622	25	,	,	,
8691	622	26	"	"	''
8691	622	27	655	655	CD
8691	622	28	;	;	:
8691	622	29	Pomeroy	Pomeroy	NNP
8691	622	30	,	,	,
8691	622	31	"	"	``
8691	622	32	Some	some	DT
8691	622	33	Account	Account	NNP
8691	622	34	of	of	IN
8691	622	35	the	the	DT
8691	622	36	Work	Work	NNP
8691	622	37	of	of	IN
8691	622	38	Stephen	Stephen	NNP
8691	622	39	J.	J.	NNP
8691	623	1	Field	field	NN
8691	623	2	,	,	,
8691	623	3	"	"	''
8691	623	4	440	440	CD
8691	623	5	.	.	.
8691	623	6	]	]	-RRB-
8691	624	1	Justices	justice	NNS
8691	624	2	of	of	IN
8691	624	3	the	the	DT
8691	624	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	624	5	Court	Court	NNP
8691	624	6	have	have	VBP
8691	624	7	since	since	IN
8691	624	8	sat	sit	VBN
8691	624	9	on	on	IN
8691	624	10	international	international	JJ
8691	624	11	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	624	12	of	of	IN
8691	624	13	arbitration	arbitration	NN
8691	624	14	,	,	,
8691	624	15	but	but	CC
8691	624	16	this	this	DT
8691	624	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	624	18	,	,	,
8691	624	19	or	or	CC
8691	624	20	should	should	MD
8691	624	21	be	be	VB
8691	624	22	,	,	,
8691	624	23	a	a	DT
8691	624	24	strictly	strictly	RB
8691	624	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	624	26	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	624	27	.	.	.
8691	625	1	In	in	IN
8691	625	2	the	the	DT
8691	625	3	State	State	NNP
8691	625	4	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	625	5	,	,	,
8691	625	6	the	the	DT
8691	625	7	judges	judge	NNS
8691	625	8	of	of	IN
8691	625	9	the	the	DT
8691	625	10	highest	high	JJS
8691	625	11	courts	court	NNS
8691	625	12	are	be	VBP
8691	625	13	now	now	RB
8691	625	14	often	often	RB
8691	625	15	expressly	expressly	RB
8691	625	16	forbidden	forbid	VBN
8691	625	17	to	to	TO
8691	625	18	accept	accept	VB
8691	625	19	other	other	JJ
8691	625	20	office,[Footnote	office,[footnote	CD
8691	625	21	:	:	:
8691	625	22	See	see	VB
8691	625	23	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	625	24	XXII	XXII	NNP
8691	625	25	.	.	.
8691	625	26	]	]	-RRB-
8691	626	1	but	but	CC
8691	626	2	in	in	IN
8691	626	3	the	the	DT
8691	626	4	absence	absence	NN
8691	626	5	of	of	IN
8691	626	6	such	such	PDT
8691	626	7	a	a	DT
8691	626	8	prohibition	prohibition	NN
8691	626	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	626	10	would	would	MD
8691	626	11	be	be	VB
8691	626	12	considered	consider	VBN
8691	626	13	as	as	RB
8691	626	14	unbecoming	unbecoming	JJ
8691	626	15	.	.	.
8691	627	1	Formerly	formerly	RB
8691	627	2	and	and	CC
8691	627	3	during	during	IN
8691	627	4	the	the	DT
8691	627	5	first	first	JJ
8691	627	6	third	third	NN
8691	627	7	of	of	IN
8691	627	8	the	the	DT
8691	627	9	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	627	10	century	century	NN
8691	627	11	this	this	DT
8691	627	12	was	be	VBD
8691	627	13	in	in	IN
8691	627	14	many	many	JJ
8691	627	15	States	States	NNPS
8691	627	16	not	not	RB
8691	627	17	so	so	RB
8691	627	18	.	.	.
8691	628	1	Some	some	DT
8691	628	2	were	be	VBD
8691	628	3	then	then	RB
8691	628	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	628	5	because	because	IN
8691	628	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	628	7	held	hold	VBD
8691	628	8	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	628	9	office	office	NN
8691	628	10	and	and	CC
8691	628	11	as	as	IN
8691	628	12	an	an	DT
8691	628	13	incident	incident	NN
8691	628	14	of	of	IN
8691	628	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	628	16	.	.	.
8691	629	1	Others	other	NNS
8691	629	2	did	do	VBD
8691	629	3	not	not	RB
8691	629	4	hesitate	hesitate	VB
8691	629	5	to	to	TO
8691	629	6	accept	accept	VB
8691	629	7	political	political	JJ
8691	629	8	positions	position	NNS
8691	629	9	.	.	.
8691	630	1	Of	of	IN
8691	630	2	the	the	DT
8691	630	3	six	six	CD
8691	630	4	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
8691	630	5	electors	elector	NNS
8691	630	6	chosen	choose	VBN
8691	630	7	in	in	IN
8691	630	8	New	New	NNP
8691	630	9	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	630	10	at	at	IN
8691	630	11	the	the	DT
8691	630	12	presidential	presidential	JJ
8691	630	13	election	election	NN
8691	630	14	of	of	IN
8691	630	15	1800	1800	CD
8691	630	16	,	,	,
8691	630	17	three	three	CD
8691	630	18	were	be	VBD
8691	630	19	judges	judge	NNS
8691	630	20	of	of	IN
8691	630	21	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	630	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	630	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	630	24	.	.	.
8691	631	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	631	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	631	3	:	:	:
8691	631	4	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
8691	631	5	's	's	POS
8691	631	6	State	State	NNP
8691	631	7	Trials	Trials	NNPS
8691	631	8	,	,	,
8691	631	9	47	47	CD
8691	631	10	.	.	.
8691	631	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	632	1	Judges	judge	NNS
8691	632	2	have	have	VBP
8691	632	3	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	632	4	taken	take	VBN
8691	632	5	part	part	NN
8691	632	6	in	in	IN
8691	632	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	632	8	conventions	convention	NNS
8691	632	9	of	of	IN
8691	632	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	632	11	States	state	NNS
8691	632	12	.	.	.
8691	633	1	In	in	IN
8691	633	2	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	633	3	,	,	,
8691	633	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	633	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	633	6	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	633	7	was	be	VBD
8691	633	8	a	a	DT
8691	633	9	member	member	NN
8691	633	10	of	of	IN
8691	633	11	that	that	DT
8691	633	12	of	of	IN
8691	633	13	1829	1829	CD
8691	633	14	,	,	,
8691	633	15	and	and	CC
8691	633	16	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	633	17	Underwood	Underwood	NNP
8691	633	18	of	of	IN
8691	633	19	the	the	DT
8691	633	20	District	District	NNP
8691	633	21	Court	Court	NNP
8691	633	22	presided	preside	VBD
8691	633	23	over	over	IN
8691	633	24	that	that	DT
8691	633	25	of	of	IN
8691	633	26	1867	1867	CD
8691	633	27	.	.	.
8691	634	1	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	634	2	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	634	3	and	and	CC
8691	634	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	634	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	634	6	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
8691	634	7	were	be	VBD
8691	634	8	members	member	NNS
8691	634	9	of	of	IN
8691	634	10	that	that	DT
8691	634	11	of	of	IN
8691	634	12	1821	1821	CD
8691	634	13	in	in	IN
8691	634	14	New	New	NNP
8691	634	15	York	York	NNP
8691	634	16	.	.	.
8691	635	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	635	2	may	may	MD
8691	635	3	well	well	RB
8691	635	4	be	be	VB
8691	635	5	doubted	doubt	VBN
8691	635	6	if	if	IN
8691	635	7	the	the	DT
8691	635	8	advantages	advantage	NNS
8691	635	9	to	to	TO
8691	635	10	be	be	VB
8691	635	11	gained	gain	VBN
8691	635	12	by	by	IN
8691	635	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	635	14	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	635	15	in	in	IN
8691	635	16	such	such	PDT
8691	635	17	a	a	DT
8691	635	18	position	position	NN
8691	635	19	are	be	VBP
8691	635	20	not	not	RB
8691	635	21	outweighed	outweigh	VBN
8691	635	22	by	by	IN
8691	635	23	the	the	DT
8691	635	24	evil	evil	NN
8691	635	25	of	of	IN
8691	635	26	exposing	expose	VBG
8691	635	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	635	28	to	to	IN
8691	635	29	criticism	criticism	NN
8691	635	30	as	as	IN
8691	635	31	dictated	dictate	VBN
8691	635	32	by	by	IN
8691	635	33	selfish	selfish	JJ
8691	635	34	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	635	35	.	.	.
8691	636	1	A	a	DT
8691	636	2	member	member	NN
8691	636	3	of	of	IN
8691	636	4	the	the	DT
8691	636	5	New	New	NNP
8691	636	6	York	York	NNP
8691	636	7	convention	convention	NN
8691	636	8	thus	thus	RB
8691	636	9	alluded	allude	VBD
8691	636	10	upon	upon	IN
8691	636	11	the	the	DT
8691	636	12	floor	floor	NN
8691	636	13	to	to	IN
8691	636	14	the	the	DT
8691	636	15	measures	measure	NNS
8691	636	16	supported	support	VBN
8691	636	17	by	by	IN
8691	636	18	the	the	DT
8691	636	19	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	636	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	636	21	and	and	CC
8691	636	22	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	636	23	:	:	:
8691	636	24	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	636	25	regretted	regret	VBD
8691	636	26	that	that	IN
8691	636	27	such	such	PDT
8691	636	28	an	an	DT
8691	636	29	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	636	30	and	and	CC
8691	636	31	plan	plan	NN
8691	636	32	had	have	VBD
8691	636	33	been	be	VBN
8691	636	34	proposed	propose	VBN
8691	636	35	by	by	IN
8691	636	36	the	the	DT
8691	636	37	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	636	38	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	636	39	.	.	.
8691	637	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	637	2	must	must	MD
8691	637	3	have	have	VB
8691	637	4	arisen	arise	VBN
8691	637	5	from	from	IN
8691	637	6	the	the	DT
8691	637	7	politics	politic	NNS
8691	637	8	of	of	IN
8691	637	9	the	the	DT
8691	637	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	637	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	637	12	.	.	.
8691	638	1	The	the	DT
8691	638	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	638	3	of	of	IN
8691	638	4	that	that	DT
8691	638	5	court	court	NN
8691	638	6	had	have	VBD
8691	638	7	been	be	VBN
8691	638	8	occupied	occupy	VBN
8691	638	9	so	so	RB
8691	638	10	much	much	JJ
8691	638	11	in	in	IN
8691	638	12	politics	politic	NNS
8691	638	13	that	that	IN
8691	638	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	638	15	had	have	VBD
8691	638	16	been	be	VBN
8691	638	17	compelled	compel	VBN
8691	638	18	to	to	TO
8691	638	19	press	press	VB
8691	638	20	upon	upon	IN
8691	638	21	the	the	DT
8691	638	22	public	public	NN
8691	638	23	a	a	DT
8691	638	24	system	system	NN
8691	638	25	that	that	WDT
8691	638	26	had	have	VBD
8691	638	27	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	638	28	else	else	RB
8691	638	29	to	to	TO
8691	638	30	recommend	recommend	VB
8691	638	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	638	32	than	than	IN
8691	638	33	such	such	PDT
8691	638	34	a	a	DT
8691	638	35	relief	relief	NN
8691	638	36	to	to	IN
8691	638	37	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	638	38	from	from	IN
8691	638	39	the	the	DT
8691	638	40	burthen	burthen	NN
8691	638	41	of	of	IN
8691	638	42	official	official	JJ
8691	638	43	duties	duty	NNS
8691	638	44	as	as	IN
8691	638	45	would	would	MD
8691	638	46	leave	leave	VB
8691	638	47	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	638	48	to	to	IN
8691	638	49	the	the	DT
8691	638	50	free	free	JJ
8691	638	51	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	638	52	of	of	IN
8691	638	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	638	54	electioneering	electioneer	VBG
8691	638	55	qualifications	qualification	NNS
8691	638	56	.	.	.
8691	639	1	But	but	CC
8691	639	2	for	for	IN
8691	639	3	this	this	DT
8691	639	4	,	,	,
8691	639	5	the	the	DT
8691	639	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	639	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	639	8	might	may	MD
8691	639	9	have	have	VB
8691	639	10	shown	show	VBN
8691	639	11	a	a	DT
8691	639	12	Holt	Holt	NNP
8691	639	13	,	,	,
8691	639	14	or	or	CC
8691	639	15	a	a	DT
8691	639	16	Mansfield	Mansfield	NNP
8691	639	17	.	.	.
8691	640	1	The	the	DT
8691	640	2	elevated	elevated	JJ
8691	640	3	character	character	NN
8691	640	4	of	of	IN
8691	640	5	the	the	DT
8691	640	6	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	640	7	had	have	VBD
8691	640	8	been	be	VBN
8691	640	9	often	often	RB
8691	640	10	asserted	assert	VBN
8691	640	11	and	and	CC
8691	640	12	alluded	allude	VBN
8691	640	13	to	to	IN
8691	640	14	.	.	.
8691	641	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	641	2	meant	mean	VBD
8691	641	3	no	no	DT
8691	641	4	disrespect	disrespect	NN
8691	641	5	to	to	IN
8691	641	6	that	that	DT
8691	641	7	honorable	honorable	JJ
8691	641	8	gentleman	gentleman	NN
8691	641	9	.	.	.
8691	642	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	642	2	respected	respect	VBD
8691	642	3	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	642	4	as	as	RB
8691	642	5	highly	highly	RB
8691	642	6	as	as	IN
8691	642	7	any	any	DT
8691	642	8	man	man	NN
8691	642	9	when	when	WRB
8691	642	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	642	11	confined	confine	VBD
8691	642	12	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	642	13	to	to	IN
8691	642	14	the	the	DT
8691	642	15	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	642	16	of	of	IN
8691	642	17	the	the	DT
8691	642	18	official	official	JJ
8691	642	19	duties	duty	NNS
8691	642	20	of	of	IN
8691	642	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	642	22	office	office	NN
8691	642	23	;	;	:
8691	642	24	but	but	CC
8691	642	25	when	when	WRB
8691	642	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	642	27	stepped	step	VBD
8691	642	28	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	642	29	that	that	DT
8691	642	30	line	line	NN
8691	642	31	;	;	:
8691	642	32	when	when	WRB
8691	642	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	642	34	became	become	VBD
8691	642	35	a	a	DT
8691	642	36	politician	politician	NN
8691	642	37	,	,	,
8691	642	38	instead	instead	RB
8691	642	39	of	of	IN
8691	642	40	being	be	VBG
8691	642	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	642	42	fancied	fancied	JJ
8691	642	43	oak	oak	NN
8691	642	44	,	,	,
8691	642	45	which	which	WDT
8691	642	46	,	,	,
8691	642	47	planted	plant	VBN
8691	642	48	deeply	deeply	RB
8691	642	49	in	in	IN
8691	642	50	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	642	51	soil	soil	NN
8691	642	52	,	,	,
8691	642	53	extended	extend	VBD
8691	642	54	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	642	55	branches	branch	NNS
8691	642	56	from	from	IN
8691	642	57	Maine	Maine	NNP
8691	642	58	to	to	IN
8691	642	59	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
8691	642	60	,	,	,
8691	642	61	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	642	62	rather	rather	RB
8691	642	63	resembled	resemble	VBD
8691	642	64	the	the	DT
8691	642	65	Bohon	Bohon	NNP
8691	642	66	Upas	Upas	NNP
8691	642	67	of	of	IN
8691	642	68	Java	Java	NNP
8691	642	69	,	,	,
8691	642	70	that	that	IN
8691	642	71	destroyed	destroy	VBD
8691	642	72	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	642	73	sought	seek	VBD
8691	642	74	for	for	IN
8691	642	75	shelter	shelter	NN
8691	642	76	or	or	CC
8691	642	77	protection	protection	NN
8691	642	78	in	in	IN
8691	642	79	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	642	80	shade	shade	NN
8691	642	81	.	.	.
8691	643	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	643	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	643	3	:	:	:
8691	643	4	Reports	report	NNS
8691	643	5	of	of	IN
8691	643	6	the	the	DT
8691	643	7	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNPS
8691	643	8	and	and	CC
8691	643	9	Debates	Debates	NNPS
8691	643	10	of	of	IN
8691	643	11	the	the	DT
8691	643	12	Convention	Convention	NNP
8691	643	13	of	of	IN
8691	643	14	1821	1821	CD
8691	643	15	,	,	,
8691	643	16	615	615	CD
8691	643	17	.	.	.
8691	643	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	644	1	The	the	DT
8691	644	2	pardoning	pardon	VBG
8691	644	3	power	power	NN
8691	644	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	644	5	essentially	essentially	RB
8691	644	6	of	of	IN
8691	644	7	a	a	DT
8691	644	8	political	political	JJ
8691	644	9	nature	nature	NN
8691	644	10	.	.	.
8691	645	1	Judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	645	2	officers	officer	NNS
8691	645	3	are	be	VBP
8691	645	4	to	to	TO
8691	645	5	do	do	VB
8691	645	6	justice	justice	NN
8691	645	7	.	.	.
8691	646	1	Mercy	mercy	NN
8691	646	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	646	3	an	an	DT
8691	646	4	act	act	NN
8691	646	5	of	of	IN
8691	646	6	policy	policy	NN
8691	646	7	or	or	CC
8691	646	8	grace	grace	NN
8691	646	9	.	.	.
8691	647	1	A	a	DT
8691	647	2	pardon	pardon	NN
8691	647	3	after	after	IN
8691	647	4	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	647	5	presupposes	presuppose	VBZ
8691	647	6	guilt	guilt	NN
8691	647	7	.	.	.
8691	648	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
8691	648	2	,	,	,
8691	648	3	in	in	IN
8691	648	4	a	a	DT
8691	648	5	few	few	JJ
8691	648	6	States	state	NNS
8691	648	7	this	this	DT
8691	648	8	royal	royal	JJ
8691	648	9	prerogative	prerogative	NN
8691	648	10	of	of	IN
8691	648	11	pardoning	pardoning	NN
8691	648	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	648	13	been	be	VBN
8691	648	14	committed	commit	VBN
8691	648	15	to	to	IN
8691	648	16	a	a	DT
8691	648	17	board	board	NN
8691	648	18	of	of	IN
8691	648	19	officers	officer	NNS
8691	648	20	,	,	,
8691	648	21	headed	head	VBN
8691	648	22	by	by	IN
8691	648	23	the	the	DT
8691	648	24	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	648	25	,	,	,
8691	648	26	of	of	IN
8691	648	27	which	which	WDT
8691	648	28	some	some	DT
8691	648	29	of	of	IN
8691	648	30	the	the	DT
8691	648	31	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	648	32	are	be	VBP
8691	648	33	members	member	NNS
8691	648	34	.	.	.
8691	649	1	There	there	EX
8691	649	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	649	3	this	this	DT
8691	649	4	advantage	advantage	NN
8691	649	5	in	in	IN
8691	649	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	649	7	,	,	,
8691	649	8	that	that	IN
8691	649	9	judges	judge	NNS
8691	649	10	know	know	VBP
8691	649	11	best	well	RBS
8691	649	12	how	how	WRB
8691	649	13	fully	fully	RB
8691	649	14	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	649	15	of	of	IN
8691	649	16	extenuation	extenuation	NN
8691	649	17	are	be	VBP
8691	649	18	always	always	RB
8691	649	19	taken	take	VBN
8691	649	20	into	into	IN
8691	649	21	account	account	NN
8691	649	22	by	by	IN
8691	649	23	the	the	DT
8691	649	24	court	court	NN
8691	649	25	before	before	IN
8691	649	26	pronouncing	pronounce	VBG
8691	649	27	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	649	28	,	,	,
8691	649	29	and	and	CC
8691	649	30	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	649	31	can	can	MD
8691	649	32	not	not	RB
8691	649	33	but	but	RB
8691	649	34	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	649	35	a	a	DT
8691	649	36	restraining	restrain	VBG
8691	649	37	power	power	NN
8691	649	38	against	against	IN
8691	649	39	the	the	DT
8691	649	40	influences	influence	NNS
8691	649	41	of	of	IN
8691	649	42	mere	mere	JJ
8691	649	43	sentimental	sentimental	JJ
8691	649	44	promptings	prompting	NNS
8691	649	45	to	to	TO
8691	649	46	inconsiderate	inconsiderate	VB
8691	649	47	clemency	clemency	NN
8691	649	48	.	.	.
8691	650	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	650	2	may	may	MD
8691	650	3	be	be	VB
8691	650	4	said	say	VBN
8691	650	5	,	,	,
8691	650	6	in	in	IN
8691	650	7	general	general	JJ
8691	650	8	,	,	,
8691	650	9	that	that	IN
8691	650	10	the	the	DT
8691	650	11	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	650	12	towards	towards	IN
8691	650	13	keeping	keep	VBG
8691	650	14	the	the	DT
8691	650	15	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	650	16	apart	apart	RB
8691	650	17	from	from	IN
8691	650	18	any	any	DT
8691	650	19	active	active	JJ
8691	650	20	connection	connection	NN
8691	650	21	with	with	IN
8691	650	22	the	the	DT
8691	650	23	executive	executive	JJ
8691	650	24	department	department	NN
8691	650	25	has	have	VBZ
8691	650	26	steadily	steadily	RB
8691	650	27	increased	increase	VBN
8691	650	28	since	since	IN
8691	650	29	the	the	DT
8691	650	30	first	first	JJ
8691	650	31	quarter	quarter	NN
8691	650	32	of	of	IN
8691	650	33	the	the	DT
8691	650	34	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	650	35	century	century	NN
8691	650	36	.	.	.
8691	651	1	When	when	WRB
8691	651	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	651	3	position	position	NN
8691	651	4	as	as	IN
8691	651	5	a	a	DT
8691	651	6	neutral	neutral	JJ
8691	651	7	power	power	NN
8691	651	8	,	,	,
8691	651	9	in	in	IN
8691	651	10	1793	1793	CD
8691	651	11	,	,	,
8691	651	12	involved	involve	VBD
8691	651	13	us	-PRON-	PRP
8691	651	14	in	in	IN
8691	651	15	serious	serious	JJ
8691	651	16	questions	question	NNS
8691	651	17	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	651	18	the	the	DT
8691	651	19	rights	right	NNS
8691	651	20	of	of	IN
8691	651	21	Great	Great	NNP
8691	651	22	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	651	23	and	and	CC
8691	651	24	France	France	NNP
8691	651	25	,	,	,
8691	651	26	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	651	27	's	's	POS
8691	651	28	cabinet	cabinet	NN
8691	651	29	advised	advise	VBD
8691	651	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	651	31	that	that	IN
8691	651	32	the	the	DT
8691	651	33	ministers	minister	NNS
8691	651	34	of	of	IN
8691	651	35	those	those	DT
8691	651	36	countries	country	NNS
8691	651	37	be	be	VB
8691	651	38	informed	inform	VBN
8691	651	39	that	that	IN
8691	651	40	the	the	DT
8691	651	41	points	point	NNS
8691	651	42	involved	involve	VBN
8691	651	43	would	would	MD
8691	651	44	be	be	VB
8691	651	45	referred	refer	VBN
8691	651	46	to	to	IN
8691	651	47	persons	person	NNS
8691	651	48	learned	learn	VBN
8691	651	49	in	in	IN
8691	651	50	the	the	DT
8691	651	51	law	law	NN
8691	651	52	,	,	,
8691	651	53	and	and	CC
8691	651	54	that	that	IN
8691	651	55	with	with	IN
8691	651	56	this	this	DT
8691	651	57	in	in	IN
8691	651	58	view	view	NN
8691	651	59	the	the	DT
8691	651	60	Justices	Justices	NNPS
8691	651	61	of	of	IN
8691	651	62	the	the	DT
8691	651	63	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	651	64	Court	Court	NNP
8691	651	65	of	of	IN
8691	651	66	the	the	DT
8691	651	67	United	United	NNP
8691	651	68	States	States	NNP
8691	651	69	be	be	VB
8691	651	70	invited	invite	VBN
8691	651	71	to	to	TO
8691	651	72	come	come	VB
8691	651	73	to	to	IN
8691	651	74	the	the	DT
8691	651	75	capitol	capitol	NN
8691	651	76	,	,	,
8691	651	77	six	six	CD
8691	651	78	days	day	NNS
8691	651	79	later	later	RB
8691	651	80	,	,	,
8691	651	81	"	"	''
8691	651	82	to	to	TO
8691	651	83	give	give	VB
8691	651	84	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	651	85	advice	advice	NN
8691	651	86	on	on	IN
8691	651	87	certain	certain	JJ
8691	651	88	matters	matter	NNS
8691	651	89	of	of	IN
8691	651	90	public	public	JJ
8691	651	91	concern	concern	NN
8691	651	92	,	,	,
8691	651	93	which	which	WDT
8691	651	94	will	will	MD
8691	651	95	be	be	VB
8691	651	96	referred	refer	VBN
8691	651	97	to	to	IN
8691	651	98	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	651	99	by	by	IN
8691	651	100	the	the	DT
8691	651	101	President	President	NNP
8691	651	102	.	.	.
8691	652	1	"	"	``
8691	652	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	652	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	652	4	:	:	:
8691	652	5	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	652	6	's	's	POS
8691	652	7	Writings	Writings	NNP
8691	652	8	,	,	,
8691	652	9	Library	Library	NNP
8691	652	10	Ed	Ed	NNP
8691	652	11	.	.	.
8691	652	12	,	,	,
8691	652	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	652	14	,	,	,
8691	652	15	370	370	CD
8691	652	16	.	.	.
8691	652	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	653	1	Nothing	nothing	NN
8691	653	2	of	of	IN
8691	653	3	this	this	DT
8691	653	4	nature	nature	NN
8691	653	5	would	would	MD
8691	653	6	now	now	RB
8691	653	7	be	be	VB
8691	653	8	dreamed	dream	VBN
8691	653	9	of	of	IN
8691	653	10	,	,	,
8691	653	11	under	under	IN
8691	653	12	any	any	DT
8691	653	13	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	653	14	.	.	.
8691	654	1	*	*	NFP
8691	654	2	*	*	NFP
8691	654	3	*	*	NFP
8691	654	4	*	*	NFP
8691	654	5	*	*	NFP
8691	654	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	654	7	IV	IV	NNP
8691	654	8	THE	the	DT
8691	654	9	FORCE	FORCE	NNP
8691	654	10	OF	of	IN
8691	654	11	JUDICIAL	judicial	NN
8691	654	12	PRECEDENTS	precedent	NNS
8691	654	13	The	the	DT
8691	654	14	antipathy	antipathy	NN
8691	654	15	to	to	IN
8691	654	16	legal	legal	JJ
8691	654	17	codification	codification	NN
8691	654	18	,	,	,
8691	654	19	which	which	WDT
8691	654	20	,	,	,
8691	654	21	until	until	IN
8691	654	22	recent	recent	JJ
8691	654	23	years	year	NNS
8691	654	24	,	,	,
8691	654	25	was	be	VBD
8691	654	26	a	a	DT
8691	654	27	characteristic	characteristic	JJ
8691	654	28	both	both	DT
8691	654	29	of	of	IN
8691	654	30	the	the	DT
8691	654	31	English	english	JJ
8691	654	32	and	and	CC
8691	654	33	American	american	JJ
8691	654	34	bar	bar	NN
8691	654	35	,	,	,
8691	654	36	and	and	CC
8691	654	37	still	still	RB
8691	654	38	prevails	prevail	VBZ
8691	654	39	,	,	,
8691	654	40	though	though	RB
8691	654	41	with	with	IN
8691	654	42	diminishing	diminish	VBG
8691	654	43	force	force	NN
8691	654	44	,	,	,
8691	654	45	has	have	VBZ
8691	654	46	given	give	VBN
8691	654	47	,	,	,
8691	654	48	and	and	CC
8691	654	49	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	654	50	given	give	VBN
8691	654	51	,	,	,
8691	654	52	great	great	JJ
8691	654	53	force	force	NN
8691	654	54	to	to	IN
8691	654	55	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	654	56	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	654	57	.	.	.
8691	655	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	655	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	655	3	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	655	4	through	through	IN
8691	655	5	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	655	6	that	that	IN
8691	655	7	with	with	IN
8691	655	8	us	-PRON-	PRP
8691	655	9	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	655	10	law	law	NN
8691	655	11	passes	pass	VBZ
8691	655	12	into	into	IN
8691	655	13	written	write	VBN
8691	655	14	law	law	NN
8691	655	15	.	.	.
8691	656	1	Precedent	precedent	NN
8691	656	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	656	3	a	a	DT
8691	656	4	fruit	fruit	NN
8691	656	5	of	of	IN
8691	656	6	reason	reason	NN
8691	656	7	ripened	ripen	VBN
8691	656	8	by	by	IN
8691	656	9	time	time	NN
8691	656	10	.	.	.
8691	657	1	Time	time	NN
8691	657	2	,	,	,
8691	657	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	657	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	657	5	been	be	VBN
8691	657	6	said	say	VBN
8691	657	7	,	,	,
8691	657	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	657	9	the	the	DT
8691	657	10	daughter	daughter	NN
8691	657	11	of	of	IN
8691	657	12	Antiquity	Antiquity	NNP
8691	657	13	and	and	CC
8691	657	14	takes	take	VBZ
8691	657	15	place	place	NN
8691	657	16	after	after	IN
8691	657	17	Reason	Reason	NNP
8691	657	18	,	,	,
8691	657	19	which	which	WDT
8691	657	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	657	21	the	the	DT
8691	657	22	daughter	daughter	NN
8691	657	23	of	of	IN
8691	657	24	Eternity	eternity	NN
8691	657	25	.	.	.
8691	658	1	Precedent	precedent	NN
8691	658	2	rests	rest	VBZ
8691	658	3	on	on	IN
8691	658	4	both	both	DT
8691	658	5	.	.	.
8691	659	1	A	a	DT
8691	659	2	legal	legal	JJ
8691	659	3	code	code	NN
8691	659	4	framed	frame	VBN
8691	659	5	in	in	IN
8691	659	6	any	any	DT
8691	659	7	American	American	NNP
8691	659	8	State	State	NNP
8691	659	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	659	10	little	little	RB
8691	659	11	more	more	JJR
8691	659	12	than	than	IN
8691	659	13	the	the	DT
8691	659	14	orderly	orderly	JJ
8691	659	15	statement	statement	NN
8691	659	16	of	of	IN
8691	659	17	what	what	WP
8691	659	18	American	american	JJ
8691	659	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	659	20	have	have	VBP
8691	659	21	decided	decide	VBN
8691	659	22	the	the	DT
8691	659	23	law	law	NN
8691	659	24	to	to	TO
8691	659	25	be	be	VB
8691	659	26	on	on	IN
8691	659	27	certain	certain	JJ
8691	659	28	points	point	NNS
8691	659	29	.	.	.
8691	660	1	When	when	WRB
8691	660	2	reason	reason	NN
8691	660	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	660	4	set	set	VBN
8691	660	5	to	to	TO
8691	660	6	work	work	VB
8691	660	7	upon	upon	IN
8691	660	8	the	the	DT
8691	660	9	solution	solution	NN
8691	660	10	of	of	IN
8691	660	11	a	a	DT
8691	660	12	problem	problem	NN
8691	660	13	growing	grow	VBG
8691	660	14	out	out	IN
8691	660	15	of	of	IN
8691	660	16	the	the	DT
8691	660	17	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	660	18	of	of	IN
8691	660	19	daily	daily	JJ
8691	660	20	life	life	NN
8691	660	21	,	,	,
8691	660	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	660	23	often	often	RB
8691	660	24	happens	happen	VBZ
8691	660	25	that	that	IN
8691	660	26	two	two	CD
8691	660	27	minds	mind	NNS
8691	660	28	will	will	MD
8691	660	29	pursue	pursue	VB
8691	660	30	different	different	JJ
8691	660	31	paths	path	NNS
8691	660	32	and	and	CC
8691	660	33	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	660	34	come	come	VB
8691	660	35	to	to	IN
8691	660	36	different	different	JJ
8691	660	37	results	result	NNS
8691	660	38	.	.	.
8691	661	1	Not	not	RB
8691	661	2	infrequently	infrequently	RB
8691	661	3	neither	neither	DT
8691	661	4	result	result	NN
8691	661	5	can	can	MD
8691	661	6	fairly	fairly	RB
8691	661	7	be	be	VB
8691	661	8	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	661	9	untenable	untenable	JJ
8691	661	10	.	.	.
8691	662	1	An	an	DT
8691	662	2	English	english	JJ
8691	662	3	judge	judge	NN
8691	662	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	662	5	said	say	VBN
8691	662	6	that	that	IN
8691	662	7	nine	nine	CD
8691	662	8	-	-	HYPH
8691	662	9	tenths	tenth	NNS
8691	662	10	of	of	IN
8691	662	11	the	the	DT
8691	662	12	cases	case	NNS
8691	662	13	which	which	WDT
8691	662	14	had	have	VBD
8691	662	15	ever	ever	RB
8691	662	16	gone	go	VBN
8691	662	17	to	to	TO
8691	662	18	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	662	19	in	in	IN
8691	662	20	the	the	DT
8691	662	21	highest	high	JJS
8691	662	22	courts	court	NNS
8691	662	23	of	of	IN
8691	662	24	England	England	NNP
8691	662	25	might	may	MD
8691	662	26	have	have	VB
8691	662	27	been	be	VBN
8691	662	28	decided	decide	VBN
8691	662	29	the	the	DT
8691	662	30	other	other	JJ
8691	662	31	way	way	NN
8691	662	32	without	without	IN
8691	662	33	any	any	DT
8691	662	34	violence	violence	NN
8691	662	35	to	to	IN
8691	662	36	the	the	DT
8691	662	37	principles	principle	NNS
8691	662	38	of	of	IN
8691	662	39	the	the	DT
8691	662	40	common	common	JJ
8691	662	41	law	law	NN
8691	662	42	.	.	.
8691	663	1	Every	every	DT
8691	663	2	lawsuit	lawsuit	NN
8691	663	3	looks	look	VBZ
8691	663	4	to	to	IN
8691	663	5	two	two	CD
8691	663	6	results	result	NNS
8691	663	7	:	:	:
8691	663	8	to	to	TO
8691	663	9	end	end	VB
8691	663	10	a	a	DT
8691	663	11	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	663	12	,	,	,
8691	663	13	and	and	CC
8691	663	14	to	to	TO
8691	663	15	end	end	VB
8691	663	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	663	17	justly	justly	RB
8691	663	18	;	;	:
8691	663	19	and	and	CC
8691	663	20	in	in	IN
8691	663	21	the	the	DT
8691	663	22	administration	administration	NN
8691	663	23	of	of	IN
8691	663	24	human	human	JJ
8691	663	25	government	government	NN
8691	663	26	the	the	DT
8691	663	27	first	first	JJ
8691	663	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	663	29	almost	almost	RB
8691	663	30	as	as	RB
8691	663	31	important	important	JJ
8691	663	32	as	as	IN
8691	663	33	the	the	DT
8691	663	34	last	last	JJ
8691	663	35	.	.	.
8691	664	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	664	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	664	3	:	:	:
8691	664	4	Hoyt	Hoyt	NNP
8691	664	5	_	_	NNP
8691	664	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	664	7	_	_	NNP
8691	664	8	Danbury	Danbury	NNP
8691	664	9	,	,	,
8691	664	10	69	69	CD
8691	664	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	664	12	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	664	13	,	,	,
8691	664	14	341	341	CD
8691	664	15	,	,	,
8691	664	16	349	349	CD
8691	664	17	.	.	.
8691	664	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	665	1	Certainty	Certainty	NNP
8691	665	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	665	3	of	of	IN
8691	665	4	the	the	DT
8691	665	5	essence	essence	NN
8691	665	6	of	of	IN
8691	665	7	justice	justice	NN
8691	665	8	;	;	:
8691	665	9	but	but	CC
8691	665	10	among	among	IN
8691	665	11	men	man	NNS
8691	665	12	and	and	CC
8691	665	13	as	as	IN
8691	665	14	administered	administer	VBN
8691	665	15	by	by	IN
8691	665	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	665	17	governments	government	NNS
8691	665	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	665	19	can	can	MD
8691	665	20	only	only	RB
8691	665	21	be	be	VB
8691	665	22	such	such	JJ
8691	665	23	certainty	certainty	NN
8691	665	24	as	as	IN
8691	665	25	may	may	MD
8691	665	26	be	be	VB
8691	665	27	attained	attain	VBN
8691	665	28	by	by	IN
8691	665	29	an	an	DT
8691	665	30	impartial	impartial	JJ
8691	665	31	,	,	,
8691	665	32	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
8691	665	33	,	,	,
8691	665	34	and	and	CC
8691	665	35	well	well	RB
8691	665	36	-	-	HYPH
8691	665	37	trained	train	VBN
8691	665	38	judge	judge	NN
8691	665	39	.	.	.
8691	666	1	If	if	IN
8691	666	2	such	such	PDT
8691	666	3	a	a	DT
8691	666	4	judge	judge	NN
8691	666	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	666	6	,	,	,
8691	666	7	after	after	IN
8691	666	8	a	a	DT
8691	666	9	proper	proper	JJ
8691	666	10	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	666	11	,	,	,
8691	666	12	declared	declare	VBD
8691	666	13	what	what	WP
8691	666	14	,	,	,
8691	666	15	under	under	IN
8691	666	16	a	a	DT
8691	666	17	particular	particular	JJ
8691	666	18	set	set	NN
8691	666	19	of	of	IN
8691	666	20	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	666	21	,	,	,
8691	666	22	the	the	DT
8691	666	23	law	law	NN
8691	666	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	666	25	which	which	WDT
8691	666	26	determines	determine	VBZ
8691	666	27	the	the	DT
8691	666	28	rights	right	NNS
8691	666	29	of	of	IN
8691	666	30	the	the	DT
8691	666	31	parties	party	NNS
8691	666	32	interested	interested	JJ
8691	666	33	,	,	,
8691	666	34	this	this	DT
8691	666	35	declaration	declaration	NN
8691	666	36	makes	make	VBZ
8691	666	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	666	38	certain	certain	JJ
8691	666	39	,	,	,
8691	666	40	once	once	RB
8691	666	41	and	and	CC
8691	666	42	forever	forever	RB
8691	666	43	,	,	,
8691	666	44	as	as	RB
8691	666	45	far	far	RB
8691	666	46	as	as	IN
8691	666	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	666	48	are	be	VBP
8691	666	49	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	666	50	,	,	,
8691	666	51	and	and	CC
8691	666	52	helps	help	VBZ
8691	666	53	to	to	TO
8691	666	54	make	make	VB
8691	666	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	666	56	certain	certain	JJ
8691	666	57	as	as	IN
8691	666	58	to	to	IN
8691	666	59	any	any	DT
8691	666	60	others	other	NNS
8691	666	61	in	in	IN
8691	666	62	the	the	DT
8691	666	63	future	future	NN
8691	666	64	between	between	IN
8691	666	65	whom	whom	WP
8691	666	66	there	there	EX
8691	666	67	is	be	VBZ
8691	666	68	a	a	DT
8691	666	69	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	666	70	under	under	IN
8691	666	71	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	666	72	that	that	WDT
8691	666	73	are	be	VBP
8691	666	74	similar	similar	JJ
8691	666	75	.	.	.
8691	667	1	If	if	IN
8691	667	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	667	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	667	4	the	the	DT
8691	667	5	declaration	declaration	NN
8691	667	6	of	of	IN
8691	667	7	a	a	DT
8691	667	8	court	court	NN
8691	667	9	of	of	IN
8691	667	10	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	667	11	authority	authority	NNP
8691	667	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	667	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	667	14	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	667	15	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	667	16	as	as	IN
8691	667	17	of	of	IN
8691	667	18	binding	bind	VBG
8691	667	19	force	force	NN
8691	667	20	by	by	IN
8691	667	21	any	any	DT
8691	667	22	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	667	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	667	24	of	of	IN
8691	667	25	the	the	DT
8691	667	26	same	same	JJ
8691	667	27	government	government	NN
8691	667	28	,	,	,
8691	667	29	and	and	CC
8691	667	30	treated	treat	VBN
8691	667	31	with	with	IN
8691	667	32	great	great	JJ
8691	667	33	respect	respect	NN
8691	667	34	and	and	CC
8691	667	35	as	as	IN
8691	667	36	high	high	JJ
8691	667	37	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	667	38	of	of	IN
8691	667	39	the	the	DT
8691	667	40	law	law	NN
8691	667	41	by	by	IN
8691	667	42	any	any	DT
8691	667	43	other	other	JJ
8691	667	44	of	of	IN
8691	667	45	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	667	46	superior	superior	JJ
8691	667	47	courts	court	NNS
8691	667	48	,	,	,
8691	667	49	as	as	RB
8691	667	50	well	well	RB
8691	667	51	as	as	IN
8691	667	52	by	by	IN
8691	667	53	courts	court	NNS
8691	667	54	of	of	IN
8691	667	55	other	other	JJ
8691	667	56	States	States	NNP
8691	667	57	before	before	IN
8691	667	58	which	which	WDT
8691	667	59	a	a	DT
8691	667	60	similar	similar	JJ
8691	667	61	question	question	NN
8691	667	62	may	may	MD
8691	667	63	be	be	VB
8691	667	64	presented	present	VBN
8691	667	65	.	.	.
8691	668	1	A	a	DT
8691	668	2	decision	decision	NN
8691	668	3	on	on	IN
8691	668	4	a	a	DT
8691	668	5	point	point	NN
8691	668	6	of	of	IN
8691	668	7	law	law	NN
8691	668	8	by	by	IN
8691	668	9	the	the	DT
8691	668	10	highest	high	JJS
8691	668	11	court	court	NN
8691	668	12	in	in	IN
8691	668	13	a	a	DT
8691	668	14	State	state	NN
8691	668	15	does	do	VBZ
8691	668	16	not	not	RB
8691	668	17	,	,	,
8691	668	18	however	however	RB
8691	668	19	,	,	,
8691	668	20	bind	bind	VB
8691	668	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	668	22	lower	low	JJR
8691	668	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	668	24	as	as	RB
8691	668	25	absolutely	absolutely	RB
8691	668	26	as	as	IN
8691	668	27	would	would	MD
8691	668	28	a	a	DT
8691	668	29	statute	statute	NN
8691	668	30	.	.	.
8691	669	1	An	an	DT
8691	669	2	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	669	3	court	court	NN
8691	669	4	may	may	MD
8691	669	5	disregard	disregard	VB
8691	669	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	669	7	and	and	CC
8691	669	8	decide	decide	VB
8691	669	9	the	the	DT
8691	669	10	same	same	JJ
8691	669	11	point	point	NN
8691	669	12	another	another	DT
8691	669	13	way	way	NN
8691	669	14	if	if	IN
8691	669	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	669	16	be	be	VB
8691	669	17	fully	fully	RB
8691	669	18	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
8691	669	19	that	that	IN
8691	669	20	the	the	DT
8691	669	21	action	action	NN
8691	669	22	taken	take	VBN
8691	669	23	by	by	IN
8691	669	24	the	the	DT
8691	669	25	court	court	NN
8691	669	26	above	above	IN
8691	669	27	was	be	VBD
8691	669	28	ill	ill	RB
8691	669	29	-	-	HYPH
8691	669	30	considered	consider	VBN
8691	669	31	and	and	CC
8691	669	32	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
8691	669	33	.	.	.
8691	670	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	670	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	670	3	possible	possible	JJ
8691	670	4	that	that	IN
8691	670	5	in	in	IN
8691	670	6	such	such	JJ
8691	670	7	event	event	NN
8691	670	8	,	,	,
8691	670	9	on	on	IN
8691	670	10	reconsideration	reconsideration	NN
8691	670	11	,	,	,
8691	670	12	the	the	DT
8691	670	13	court	court	NN
8691	670	14	of	of	IN
8691	670	15	last	last	JJ
8691	670	16	resort	resort	NN
8691	670	17	may	may	MD
8691	670	18	reverse	reverse	VB
8691	670	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	670	20	original	original	JJ
8691	670	21	position	position	NN
8691	670	22	.	.	.
8691	671	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	671	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	671	3	:	:	:
8691	671	4	A	a	DT
8691	671	5	good	good	JJ
8691	671	6	instance	instance	NN
8691	671	7	of	of	IN
8691	671	8	this	this	DT
8691	671	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	671	10	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	671	11	by	by	IN
8691	671	12	the	the	DT
8691	671	13	case	case	NN
8691	671	14	of	of	IN
8691	671	15	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	671	16	_	_	NNP
8691	671	17	v.	v.	IN
8691	671	18	_	_	NNP
8691	671	19	People	People	NNP
8691	671	20	,	,	,
8691	671	21	140	140	CD
8691	671	22	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
8691	671	23	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	671	24	,	,	,
8691	671	25	350	350	CD
8691	671	26	;	;	:
8691	671	27	29	29	CD
8691	671	28	Northeastern	northeastern	JJ
8691	671	29	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	671	30	,	,	,
8691	671	31	895	895	CD
8691	671	32	.	.	.
8691	672	1	In	in	IN
8691	672	2	McFarland	McFarland	NNP
8691	672	3	_	_	NNP
8691	672	4	v.	v.	IN
8691	672	5	_	_	NNP
8691	672	6	People	People	NNPS
8691	672	7	,	,	,
8691	672	8	72	72	CD
8691	672	9	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
8691	672	10	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	672	11	,	,	,
8691	672	12	368	368	CD
8691	672	13	,	,	,
8691	672	14	the	the	DT
8691	672	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	672	16	Court	Court	NNP
8691	672	17	had	have	VBD
8691	672	18	stated	state	VBN
8691	672	19	in	in	IN
8691	672	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	672	21	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	672	22	,	,	,
8691	672	23	that	that	IN
8691	672	24	if	if	IN
8691	672	25	two	two	CD
8691	672	26	unimpeached	unimpeached	JJ
8691	672	27	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	672	28	gave	give	VBD
8691	672	29	the	the	DT
8691	672	30	only	only	JJ
8691	672	31	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	672	32	as	as	IN
8691	672	33	to	to	IN
8691	672	34	a	a	DT
8691	672	35	certain	certain	JJ
8691	672	36	point	point	NN
8691	672	37	material	material	NN
8691	672	38	to	to	IN
8691	672	39	the	the	DT
8691	672	40	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	672	41	's	's	POS
8691	672	42	case	case	NN
8691	672	43	,	,	,
8691	672	44	and	and	CC
8691	672	45	testified	testify	VBD
8691	672	46	in	in	IN
8691	672	47	contradiction	contradiction	NN
8691	672	48	of	of	IN
8691	672	49	each	each	DT
8691	672	50	other	other	JJ
8691	672	51	,	,	,
8691	672	52	the	the	DT
8691	672	53	case	case	NN
8691	672	54	failed	fail	VBD
8691	672	55	for	for	IN
8691	672	56	want	want	NN
8691	672	57	of	of	IN
8691	672	58	proof	proof	NN
8691	672	59	.	.	.
8691	673	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	673	2	years	year	NNS
8691	673	3	later	later	RB
8691	673	4	a	a	DT
8691	673	5	charge	charge	NN
8691	673	6	to	to	IN
8691	673	7	the	the	DT
8691	673	8	jury	jury	NN
8691	673	9	to	to	IN
8691	673	10	this	this	DT
8691	673	11	effect	effect	NN
8691	673	12	was	be	VBD
8691	673	13	asked	ask	VBN
8691	673	14	and	and	CC
8691	673	15	refused	refuse	VBN
8691	673	16	in	in	IN
8691	673	17	an	an	DT
8691	673	18	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	673	19	court	court	NN
8691	673	20	.	.	.
8691	674	1	An	an	DT
8691	674	2	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	674	3	was	be	VBD
8691	674	4	taken	take	VBN
8691	674	5	to	to	IN
8691	674	6	the	the	DT
8691	674	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	674	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	674	9	,	,	,
8691	674	10	and	and	CC
8691	674	11	there	there	RB
8691	674	12	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	674	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	674	14	Schofield	Schofield	NNP
8691	674	15	,	,	,
8691	674	16	the	the	DT
8691	674	17	author	author	NN
8691	674	18	of	of	IN
8691	674	19	the	the	DT
8691	674	20	original	original	JJ
8691	674	21	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	674	22	,	,	,
8691	674	23	thus	thus	RB
8691	674	24	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	674	25	of	of	IN
8691	674	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	674	27	:	:	:
8691	674	28	"	"	``
8691	674	29	Although	although	IN
8691	674	30	in	in	IN
8691	674	31	McFarland	McFarland	NNP
8691	674	32	_	_	NNP
8691	674	33	v.	v.	IN
8691	674	34	_	_	NNP
8691	674	35	People	People	NNPS
8691	674	36	,	,	,
8691	674	37	72	72	CD
8691	674	38	III	iii	CD
8691	674	39	.	.	NN
8691	674	40	,	,	,
8691	674	41	368	368	CD
8691	674	42	,	,	,
8691	674	43	the	the	DT
8691	674	44	writer	writer	NN
8691	674	45	of	of	IN
8691	674	46	this	this	DT
8691	674	47	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	674	48	expressed	express	VBD
8691	674	49	the	the	DT
8691	674	50	belief	belief	NN
8691	674	51	that	that	IN
8691	674	52	a	a	DT
8691	674	53	similar	similar	JJ
8691	674	54	instruction	instruction	NN
8691	674	55	was	be	VBD
8691	674	56	free	free	JJ
8691	674	57	of	of	IN
8691	674	58	legal	legal	JJ
8691	674	59	objection	objection	NN
8691	674	60	,	,	,
8691	674	61	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	674	62	remarks	remark	NNS
8691	674	63	in	in	IN
8691	674	64	that	that	DT
8691	674	65	respect	respect	NN
8691	674	66	were	be	VBD
8691	674	67	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
8691	674	68	to	to	IN
8691	674	69	a	a	DT
8691	674	70	determination	determination	NN
8691	674	71	of	of	IN
8691	674	72	the	the	DT
8691	674	73	case	case	NN
8691	674	74	then	then	RB
8691	674	75	before	before	IN
8691	674	76	the	the	DT
8691	674	77	court	court	NN
8691	674	78	,	,	,
8691	674	79	and	and	CC
8691	674	80	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	674	81	were	be	VBD
8691	674	82	made	make	VBN
8691	674	83	without	without	IN
8691	674	84	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	674	85	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	674	86	,	,	,
8691	674	87	and	and	CC
8691	674	88	are	be	VBP
8691	674	89	manifestly	manifestly	RB
8691	674	90	inaccurate	inaccurate	JJ
8691	674	91	.	.	.
8691	675	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	675	2	are	be	VBP
8691	675	3	now	now	RB
8691	675	4	overruled	overrule	VBN
8691	675	5	.	.	.
8691	676	1	The	the	DT
8691	676	2	question	question	NN
8691	676	3	of	of	IN
8691	676	4	competency	competency	NN
8691	676	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	676	6	one	one	CD
8691	676	7	of	of	IN
8691	676	8	law	law	NN
8691	676	9	,	,	,
8691	676	10	and	and	CC
8691	676	11	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	676	12	for	for	IN
8691	676	13	the	the	DT
8691	676	14	court	court	NN
8691	676	15	;	;	:
8691	676	16	but	but	CC
8691	676	17	the	the	DT
8691	676	18	question	question	NN
8691	676	19	of	of	IN
8691	676	20	credibility,--that	credibility,--that	NNP
8691	676	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	676	22	,	,	,
8691	676	23	of	of	IN
8691	676	24	worthiness	worthiness	NN
8691	676	25	of	of	IN
8691	676	26	belief,--and	belief,--and	NNP
8691	676	27	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	676	28	the	the	DT
8691	676	29	effect	effect	NN
8691	676	30	of	of	IN
8691	676	31	the	the	DT
8691	676	32	competent	competent	JJ
8691	676	33	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	676	34	of	of	IN
8691	676	35	each	each	DT
8691	676	36	witness	witness	NN
8691	676	37	,	,	,
8691	676	38	is	be	VBZ
8691	676	39	one	one	CD
8691	676	40	of	of	IN
8691	676	41	fact	fact	NN
8691	676	42	,	,	,
8691	676	43	and	and	CC
8691	676	44	for	for	IN
8691	676	45	the	the	DT
8691	676	46	jury	jury	NN
8691	676	47	.	.	.
8691	676	48	"	"	''
8691	676	49	]	]	-RRB-
8691	677	1	If	if	IN
8691	677	2	not	not	RB
8691	677	3	,	,	,
8691	677	4	that	that	IN
8691	677	5	acquires	acquire	NNS
8691	677	6	by	by	IN
8691	677	7	this	this	DT
8691	677	8	attack	attack	NN
8691	677	9	a	a	DT
8691	677	10	double	double	JJ
8691	677	11	force	force	NN
8691	677	12	.	.	.
8691	678	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	678	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	678	3	Bleckley	Bleckley	NNP
8691	678	4	of	of	IN
8691	678	5	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	678	6	once	once	RB
8691	678	7	remarked	remark	VBD
8691	678	8	that	that	IN
8691	678	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	678	10	of	of	IN
8691	678	11	last	last	JJ
8691	678	12	resort	resort	NN
8691	678	13	lived	live	VBN
8691	678	14	by	by	IN
8691	678	15	correcting	correct	VBG
8691	678	16	the	the	DT
8691	678	17	errors	error	NNS
8691	678	18	of	of	IN
8691	678	19	others	other	NNS
8691	678	20	and	and	CC
8691	678	21	adhering	adhere	VBG
8691	678	22	to	to	IN
8691	678	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	678	24	own	own	JJ
8691	678	25	.	.	.
8691	679	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
8691	679	2	,	,	,
8691	679	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	679	4	have	have	VBP
8691	679	5	often	often	RB
8691	679	6	,	,	,
8691	679	7	years	year	NNS
8691	679	8	after	after	IN
8691	679	9	formally	formally	RB
8691	679	10	announcing	announce	VBG
8691	679	11	a	a	DT
8691	679	12	certain	certain	JJ
8691	679	13	legal	legal	JJ
8691	679	14	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	679	15	in	in	IN
8691	679	16	one	one	CD
8691	679	17	of	of	IN
8691	679	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	679	19	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	679	20	,	,	,
8691	679	21	declared	declare	VBD
8691	679	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	679	23	to	to	TO
8691	679	24	be	be	VB
8691	679	25	unsound	unsound	JJ
8691	679	26	,	,	,
8691	679	27	and	and	CC
8691	679	28	overruled	overrule	VBD
8691	679	29	the	the	DT
8691	679	30	case	case	NN
8691	679	31	in	in	IN
8691	679	32	which	which	WDT
8691	679	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	679	34	was	be	VBD
8691	679	35	laid	lay	VBN
8691	679	36	down	down	RP
8691	679	37	.	.	.
8691	680	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	680	2	do	do	VBP
8691	680	3	this	this	DT
8691	680	4	,	,	,
8691	680	5	however	however	RB
8691	680	6	,	,	,
8691	680	7	with	with	IN
8691	680	8	natural	natural	JJ
8691	680	9	and	and	CC
8691	680	10	proper	proper	JJ
8691	680	11	reluctance	reluctance	NN
8691	680	12	,	,	,
8691	680	13	and	and	CC
8691	680	14	never	never	RB
8691	680	15	if	if	IN
8691	680	16	this	this	DT
8691	680	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	680	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	680	19	one	one	CD
8691	680	20	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	680	21	private	private	JJ
8691	680	22	rights	right	NNS
8691	680	23	of	of	IN
8691	680	24	property	property	NN
8691	680	25	and	and	CC
8691	680	26	has	have	VBZ
8691	680	27	been	be	VBN
8691	680	28	followed	follow	VBN
8691	680	29	for	for	IN
8691	680	30	so	so	RB
8691	680	31	long	long	RB
8691	680	32	a	a	DT
8691	680	33	course	course	NN
8691	680	34	of	of	IN
8691	680	35	time	time	NN
8691	680	36	that	that	WDT
8691	680	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	680	38	may	may	MD
8691	680	39	be	be	VB
8691	680	40	considered	consider	VBN
8691	680	41	as	as	IN
8691	680	42	a	a	DT
8691	680	43	rule	rule	NN
8691	680	44	on	on	IN
8691	680	45	which	which	WDT
8691	680	46	the	the	DT
8691	680	47	people	people	NNS
8691	680	48	have	have	VBP
8691	680	49	relied	rely	VBN
8691	680	50	in	in	IN
8691	680	51	exchanging	exchange	VBG
8691	680	52	values	value	NNS
8691	680	53	and	and	CC
8691	680	54	transferring	transfer	VBG
8691	680	55	titles	title	NNS
8691	680	56	.	.	.
8691	681	1	The	the	DT
8691	681	2	public	public	NN
8691	681	3	,	,	,
8691	681	4	however	however	RB
8691	681	5	,	,	,
8691	681	6	have	have	VBP
8691	681	7	rights	right	NNS
8691	681	8	to	to	TO
8691	681	9	be	be	VB
8691	681	10	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	681	11	as	as	RB
8691	681	12	fully	fully	RB
8691	681	13	as	as	IN
8691	681	14	individuals	individual	NNS
8691	681	15	,	,	,
8691	681	16	and	and	CC
8691	681	17	if	if	IN
8691	681	18	a	a	DT
8691	681	19	right	right	NN
8691	681	20	of	of	IN
8691	681	21	private	private	JJ
8691	681	22	ownership	ownership	NN
8691	681	23	has	have	VBZ
8691	681	24	been	be	VBN
8691	681	25	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
8691	681	26	to	to	TO
8691	681	27	exist	exist	VB
8691	681	28	,	,	,
8691	681	29	which	which	WDT
8691	681	30	involves	involve	VBZ
8691	681	31	a	a	DT
8691	681	32	public	public	JJ
8691	681	33	loss	loss	NN
8691	681	34	,	,	,
8691	681	35	the	the	DT
8691	681	36	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	681	37	thus	thus	RB
8691	681	38	created	create	VBN
8691	681	39	might	may	MD
8691	681	40	be	be	VB
8691	681	41	overruled	overrule	VBN
8691	681	42	with	with	IN
8691	681	43	less	less	JJR
8691	681	44	hesitation	hesitation	NN
8691	681	45	than	than	IN
8691	681	46	one	one	PRP
8691	681	47	would	would	MD
8691	681	48	be	be	VB
8691	681	49	determining	determine	VBG
8691	681	50	rights	right	NNS
8691	681	51	and	and	CC
8691	681	52	correlative	correlative	JJ
8691	681	53	obligations	obligation	NNS
8691	681	54	that	that	WDT
8691	681	55	were	be	VBD
8691	681	56	purely	purely	RB
8691	681	57	private	private	JJ
8691	681	58	.	.	.
8691	682	1	Thus	thus	RB
8691	682	2	the	the	DT
8691	682	3	North	North	NNP
8691	682	4	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	682	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	682	6	for	for	IN
8691	682	7	seventy	seventy	CD
8691	682	8	years	year	NNS
8691	682	9	held	hold	VBN
8691	682	10	that	that	IN
8691	682	11	a	a	DT
8691	682	12	public	public	JJ
8691	682	13	office	office	NN
8691	682	14	was	be	VBD
8691	682	15	the	the	DT
8691	682	16	private	private	JJ
8691	682	17	property	property	NN
8691	682	18	of	of	IN
8691	682	19	the	the	DT
8691	682	20	incumbent	incumbent	NN
8691	682	21	.	.	.
8691	683	1	No	no	DT
8691	683	2	other	other	JJ
8691	683	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	683	4	in	in	IN
8691	683	5	the	the	DT
8691	683	6	United	United	NNP
8691	683	7	States	States	NNP
8691	683	8	took	take	VBD
8691	683	9	that	that	DT
8691	683	10	view	view	NN
8691	683	11	,	,	,
8691	683	12	and	and	CC
8691	683	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	683	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	683	15	,	,	,
8691	683	16	by	by	IN
8691	683	17	a	a	DT
8691	683	18	recent	recent	JJ
8691	683	19	decision	decision	NN
8691	683	20	,	,	,
8691	683	21	been	be	VBN
8691	683	22	repudiated	repudiate	VBN
8691	683	23	in	in	IN
8691	683	24	North	North	NNP
8691	683	25	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	683	26	.	.	.
8691	684	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	684	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	684	3	:	:	:
8691	684	4	Mial	Mial	NNP
8691	684	5	_	_	NNP
8691	684	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	684	7	_	_	NNP
8691	684	8	Ellington	Ellington	NNP
8691	684	9	,	,	,
8691	684	10	134	134	CD
8691	684	11	North	North	NNP
8691	684	12	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	684	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	684	14	,	,	,
8691	684	15	131	131	CD
8691	684	16	;	;	:
8691	684	17	46	46	CD
8691	684	18	Southeastern	southeastern	JJ
8691	684	19	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	684	20	,	,	,
8691	684	21	961	961	CD
8691	684	22	;	;	:
8691	684	23	65	65	CD
8691	684	24	Lawyers	Lawyers	NNPS
8691	684	25	'	'	POS
8691	684	26	Reports	report	NNS
8691	684	27	Annotated	annotate	VBD
8691	684	28	,	,	,
8691	684	29	697	697	CD
8691	684	30	.	.	.
8691	684	31	]	]	-RRB-
8691	685	1	Still	still	RB
8691	685	2	more	more	JJR
8691	685	3	are	be	VBP
8691	685	4	public	public	JJ
8691	685	5	interests	interest	NNS
8691	685	6	to	to	TO
8691	685	7	be	be	VB
8691	685	8	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	685	9	when	when	WRB
8691	685	10	a	a	DT
8691	685	11	question	question	NN
8691	685	12	arises	arise	VBZ
8691	685	13	as	as	IN
8691	685	14	to	to	IN
8691	685	15	reversing	reverse	VBG
8691	685	16	a	a	DT
8691	685	17	decision	decision	NN
8691	685	18	as	as	IN
8691	685	19	to	to	IN
8691	685	20	the	the	DT
8691	685	21	proper	proper	JJ
8691	685	22	construction	construction	NN
8691	685	23	of	of	IN
8691	685	24	a	a	DT
8691	685	25	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	685	26	provision	provision	NN
8691	685	27	.	.	.
8691	686	1	If	if	IN
8691	686	2	a	a	DT
8691	686	3	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	686	4	mistake	mistake	NN
8691	686	5	be	be	VB
8691	686	6	made	make	VBN
8691	686	7	in	in	IN
8691	686	8	construing	construe	VBG
8691	686	9	a	a	DT
8691	686	10	statute	statute	NN
8691	686	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	686	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	686	13	easily	easily	RB
8691	686	14	remedied	remedie	VBN
8691	686	15	.	.	.
8691	687	1	The	the	DT
8691	687	2	next	next	JJ
8691	687	3	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	687	4	can	can	MD
8691	687	5	amend	amend	VB
8691	687	6	the	the	DT
8691	687	7	law	law	NN
8691	687	8	.	.	.
8691	688	1	But	but	CC
8691	688	2	a	a	DT
8691	688	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	688	4	can	can	MD
8691	688	5	only	only	RB
8691	688	6	be	be	VB
8691	688	7	amended	amend	VBN
8691	688	8	with	with	IN
8691	688	9	extreme	extreme	JJ
8691	688	10	difficulty	difficulty	NN
8691	688	11	and	and	CC
8691	688	12	by	by	IN
8691	688	13	a	a	DT
8691	688	14	slow	slow	JJ
8691	688	15	process	process	NN
8691	688	16	.	.	.
8691	689	1	If	if	IN
8691	689	2	the	the	DT
8691	689	3	court	court	NN
8691	689	4	falls	fall	VBZ
8691	689	5	into	into	IN
8691	689	6	error	error	NN
8691	689	7	as	as	IN
8691	689	8	to	to	IN
8691	689	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	689	10	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	689	11	,	,	,
8691	689	12	the	the	DT
8691	689	13	correction	correction	NN
8691	689	14	must	must	MD
8691	689	15	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	689	16	come	come	VB
8691	689	17	from	from	IN
8691	689	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	689	19	own	own	JJ
8691	689	20	action	action	NN
8691	689	21	or	or	CC
8691	689	22	not	not	RB
8691	689	23	at	at	RB
8691	689	24	all	all	RB
8691	689	25	.	.	.
8691	690	1	Hence	hence	RB
8691	690	2	an	an	DT
8691	690	3	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	690	4	on	on	IN
8691	690	5	a	a	DT
8691	690	6	matter	matter	NN
8691	690	7	of	of	IN
8691	690	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	690	9	construction	construction	NN
8691	690	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	690	11	less	less	JJR
8691	690	12	to	to	TO
8691	690	13	be	be	VB
8691	690	14	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	690	15	as	as	IN
8691	690	16	a	a	DT
8691	690	17	final	final	JJ
8691	690	18	and	and	CC
8691	690	19	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	690	20	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	690	21	than	than	IN
8691	690	22	one	one	CD
8691	690	23	rendered	render	VBN
8691	690	24	on	on	IN
8691	690	25	a	a	DT
8691	690	26	matter	matter	NN
8691	690	27	of	of	IN
8691	690	28	mere	mere	JJ
8691	690	29	private	private	JJ
8691	690	30	right	right	NN
8691	690	31	.	.	.
8691	691	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	691	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	691	3	been	be	VBN
8691	691	4	the	the	DT
8691	691	5	position	position	NN
8691	691	6	of	of	IN
8691	691	7	some	some	DT
8691	691	8	American	american	JJ
8691	691	9	statesmen	statesman	NNS
8691	691	10	and	and	CC
8691	691	11	jurists	jurist	NNS
8691	691	12	that	that	IN
8691	691	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	691	14	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	691	15	on	on	IN
8691	691	16	points	point	NNS
8691	691	17	of	of	IN
8691	691	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	691	19	construction	construction	NN
8691	691	20	were	be	VBD
8691	691	21	not	not	RB
8691	691	22	binding	bind	VBG
8691	691	23	upon	upon	IN
8691	691	24	the	the	DT
8691	691	25	executive	executive	JJ
8691	691	26	or	or	CC
8691	691	27	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	691	28	department	department	NN
8691	691	29	of	of	IN
8691	691	30	the	the	DT
8691	691	31	government	government	NN
8691	691	32	.	.	.
8691	692	1	President	President	NNP
8691	692	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	692	3	asserted	assert	VBD
8691	692	4	this	this	DT
8691	692	5	with	with	IN
8691	692	6	great	great	JJ
8691	692	7	force	force	NN
8691	692	8	in	in	IN
8691	692	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	692	10	message	message	NN
8691	692	11	to	to	IN
8691	692	12	the	the	DT
8691	692	13	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	692	14	of	of	IN
8691	692	15	July	July	NNP
8691	692	16	10	10	CD
8691	692	17	,	,	,
8691	692	18	1832	1832	CD
8691	692	19	,	,	,
8691	692	20	disapproving	disapprove	VBG
8691	692	21	the	the	DT
8691	692	22	re	re	NN
8691	692	23	-	-	NN
8691	692	24	charter	charter	NN
8691	692	25	of	of	IN
8691	692	26	the	the	DT
8691	692	27	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	692	28	of	of	IN
8691	692	29	the	the	DT
8691	692	30	United	United	NNP
8691	692	31	States	States	NNP
8691	692	32	.	.	.
8691	693	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	693	2	conceded	concede	VBD
8691	693	3	,	,	,
8691	693	4	however	however	RB
8691	693	5	,	,	,
8691	693	6	that	that	IN
8691	693	7	a	a	DT
8691	693	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	693	9	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	693	10	may	may	MD
8691	693	11	be	be	VB
8691	693	12	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	693	13	when	when	WRB
8691	693	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	693	15	has	have	VBZ
8691	693	16	received	receive	VBN
8691	693	17	the	the	DT
8691	693	18	settled	settle	VBN
8691	693	19	acquiescence	acquiescence	NN
8691	693	20	of	of	IN
8691	693	21	the	the	DT
8691	693	22	people	people	NNS
8691	693	23	and	and	CC
8691	693	24	the	the	DT
8691	693	25	States	States	NNPS
8691	693	26	.	.	.
8691	694	1	But	but	CC
8691	694	2	while	while	IN
8691	694	3	such	such	JJ
8691	694	4	acquiescence	acquiescence	NN
8691	694	5	may	may	MD
8691	694	6	strengthen	strengthen	VB
8691	694	7	the	the	DT
8691	694	8	authority	authority	NN
8691	694	9	of	of	IN
8691	694	10	a	a	DT
8691	694	11	decision	decision	NN
8691	694	12	,	,	,
8691	694	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	694	14	can	can	MD
8691	694	15	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	694	16	be	be	VB
8691	694	17	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	694	18	as	as	IN
8691	694	19	that	that	DT
8691	694	20	which	which	WDT
8691	694	21	gives	give	VBZ
8691	694	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	694	23	authority	authority	NN
8691	694	24	.	.	.
8691	695	1	That	that	DT
8691	695	2	comes	come	VBZ
8691	695	3	from	from	IN
8691	695	4	the	the	DT
8691	695	5	fact	fact	NN
8691	695	6	that	that	IN
8691	695	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	695	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	695	9	an	an	DT
8691	695	10	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	695	11	of	of	IN
8691	695	12	the	the	DT
8691	695	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	695	14	power	power	NN
8691	695	15	of	of	IN
8691	695	16	the	the	DT
8691	695	17	government	government	NN
8691	695	18	in	in	IN
8691	695	19	a	a	DT
8691	695	20	case	case	NN
8691	695	21	for	for	IN
8691	695	22	the	the	DT
8691	695	23	disposal	disposal	NN
8691	695	24	of	of	IN
8691	695	25	which	which	WDT
8691	695	26	this	this	DT
8691	695	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	695	28	power	power	NN
8691	695	29	has	have	VBZ
8691	695	30	been	be	VBN
8691	695	31	properly	properly	RB
8691	695	32	invoked	invoke	VBN
8691	695	33	.	.	.
8691	696	1	The	the	DT
8691	696	2	decision	decision	NN
8691	696	3	of	of	IN
8691	696	4	the	the	DT
8691	696	5	court	court	NN
8691	696	6	in	in	IN
8691	696	7	McCulloch	McCulloch	NNP
8691	696	8	_	_	NNP
8691	696	9	v.	v.	IN
8691	696	10	_	_	NNP
8691	696	11	Maryland[Footnote	maryland[footnote	NN
8691	696	12	:	:	:
8691	696	13	4	4	CD
8691	696	14	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	696	15	's	's	POS
8691	696	16	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	696	17	,	,	,
8691	696	18	316	316	CD
8691	696	19	.	.	.
8691	697	1	See	see	VB
8691	697	2	Willoughby	willoughby	NN
8691	697	3	,	,	,
8691	697	4	"	"	''
8691	697	5	The	the	DT
8691	697	6	American	American	NNP
8691	697	7	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
8691	697	8	System	System	NNP
8691	697	9	,	,	,
8691	697	10	"	"	''
8691	697	11	44	44	CD
8691	697	12	,	,	,
8691	697	13	123	123	CD
8691	697	14	.	.	.
8691	697	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	698	1	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
8691	698	2	settled	settle	VBN
8691	698	3	forever	forever	RB
8691	698	4	,	,	,
8691	698	5	as	as	IN
8691	698	6	between	between	IN
8691	698	7	the	the	DT
8691	698	8	cashier	cashier	NN
8691	698	9	of	of	IN
8691	698	10	the	the	DT
8691	698	11	bank	bank	NN
8691	698	12	and	and	CC
8691	698	13	the	the	DT
8691	698	14	State	State	NNP
8691	698	15	of	of	IN
8691	698	16	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	698	17	,	,	,
8691	698	18	that	that	IN
8691	698	19	the	the	DT
8691	698	20	bank	bank	NN
8691	698	21	was	be	VBD
8691	698	22	a	a	DT
8691	698	23	lawful	lawful	JJ
8691	698	24	institution	institution	NN
8691	698	25	.	.	.
8691	699	1	That	that	IN
8691	699	2	in	in	IN
8691	699	3	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
8691	699	4	_	_	NNP
8691	699	5	v.	v.	IN
8691	699	6	_	_	NNP
8691	699	7	The	the	DT
8691	699	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	699	9	of	of	IN
8691	699	10	the	the	DT
8691	699	11	United	United	NNP
8691	699	12	States[Footnote	states[footnote	NN
8691	699	13	:	:	:
8691	699	14	9	9	CD
8691	699	15	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	699	16	's	's	POS
8691	699	17	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	699	18	,	,	,
8691	699	19	738	738	CD
8691	699	20	.	.	.
8691	699	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	700	1	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VBD
8691	700	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	700	3	as	as	IN
8691	700	4	between	between	IN
8691	700	5	the	the	DT
8691	700	6	bank	bank	NN
8691	700	7	and	and	CC
8691	700	8	the	the	DT
8691	700	9	Treasurer	Treasurer	NNP
8691	700	10	of	of	IN
8691	700	11	the	the	DT
8691	700	12	State	State	NNP
8691	700	13	of	of	IN
8691	700	14	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	700	15	.	.	.
8691	701	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	701	2	would	would	MD
8691	701	3	be	be	VB
8691	701	4	intolerable	intolerable	JJ
8691	701	5	if	if	IN
8691	701	6	such	such	JJ
8691	701	7	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	701	8	were	be	VBD
8691	701	9	not	not	RB
8691	701	10	in	in	IN
8691	701	11	effect	effect	NN
8691	701	12	equally	equally	RB
8691	701	13	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	701	14	for	for	IN
8691	701	15	the	the	DT
8691	701	16	determination	determination	NN
8691	701	17	of	of	IN
8691	701	18	all	all	DT
8691	701	19	controversies	controversy	NNS
8691	701	20	between	between	IN
8691	701	21	all	all	DT
8691	701	22	men	man	NNS
8691	701	23	and	and	CC
8691	701	24	all	all	DT
8691	701	25	States	state	NNS
8691	701	26	growing	grow	VBG
8691	701	27	out	out	IN
8691	701	28	of	of	IN
8691	701	29	the	the	DT
8691	701	30	creation	creation	NN
8691	701	31	of	of	IN
8691	701	32	such	such	PDT
8691	701	33	a	a	DT
8691	701	34	corporation	corporation	NN
8691	701	35	.	.	.
8691	702	1	Practically	practically	RB
8691	702	2	,	,	,
8691	702	3	then	then	RB
8691	702	4	,	,	,
8691	702	5	the	the	DT
8691	702	6	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	702	7	of	of	IN
8691	702	8	the	the	DT
8691	702	9	executive	executive	JJ
8691	702	10	department	department	NN
8691	702	11	to	to	IN
8691	702	12	the	the	DT
8691	702	13	contrary	contrary	NN
8691	702	14	could	could	MD
8691	702	15	only	only	RB
8691	702	16	be	be	VB
8691	702	17	of	of	IN
8691	702	18	importance	importance	NN
8691	702	19	in	in	IN
8691	702	20	such	such	PDT
8691	702	21	a	a	DT
8691	702	22	case	case	NN
8691	702	23	as	as	IN
8691	702	24	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	702	25	had	have	VBD
8691	702	26	in	in	IN
8691	702	27	hand	hand	NN
8691	702	28	;	;	:
8691	702	29	that	that	RB
8691	702	30	is	is	RB
8691	702	31	,	,	,
8691	702	32	in	in	IN
8691	702	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	702	34	influencing	influence	VBG
8691	702	35	executive	executive	JJ
8691	702	36	action	action	NN
8691	702	37	in	in	IN
8691	702	38	approving	approve	VBG
8691	702	39	or	or	CC
8691	702	40	disapproving	disapprove	VBG
8691	702	41	some	some	DT
8691	702	42	proposed	propose	VBN
8691	702	43	measure	measure	NN
8691	702	44	of	of	IN
8691	702	45	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	702	46	.	.	.
8691	703	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	703	2	could	could	MD
8691	703	3	not	not	RB
8691	703	4	disturb	disturb	VB
8691	703	5	the	the	DT
8691	703	6	past	past	NN
8691	703	7	.	.	.
8691	704	1	The	the	DT
8691	704	2	authority	authority	NN
8691	704	3	of	of	IN
8691	704	4	a	a	DT
8691	704	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	704	6	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	704	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	704	8	weakened	weaken	VBN
8691	704	9	if	if	IN
8691	704	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	704	11	comes	come	VBZ
8691	704	12	from	from	IN
8691	704	13	a	a	DT
8691	704	14	divided	divide	VBN
8691	704	15	court	court	NN
8691	704	16	,	,	,
8691	704	17	and	and	CC
8691	704	18	especially	especially	RB
8691	704	19	if	if	IN
8691	704	20	a	a	DT
8691	704	21	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	704	22	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	704	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	704	24	filed	file	VBN
8691	704	25	in	in	IN
8691	704	26	behalf	behalf	NN
8691	704	27	of	of	IN
8691	704	28	the	the	DT
8691	704	29	minority	minority	NN
8691	704	30	.	.	.
8691	705	1	A	a	DT
8691	705	2	silent	silent	JJ
8691	705	3	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	705	4	indicates	indicate	VBZ
8691	705	5	that	that	IN
8691	705	6	the	the	DT
8691	705	7	judge	judge	NN
8691	705	8	from	from	IN
8691	705	9	whom	whom	WP
8691	705	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	705	11	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
8691	705	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	705	13	not	not	RB
8691	705	14	so	so	RB
8691	705	15	impressed	impressed	JJ
8691	705	16	by	by	IN
8691	705	17	the	the	DT
8691	705	18	fact	fact	NN
8691	705	19	,	,	,
8691	705	20	or	or	CC
8691	705	21	the	the	DT
8691	705	22	importance	importance	NN
8691	705	23	to	to	IN
8691	705	24	the	the	DT
8691	705	25	public	public	NN
8691	705	26	,	,	,
8691	705	27	of	of	IN
8691	705	28	what	what	WP
8691	705	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	705	30	deems	deem	VBZ
8691	705	31	the	the	DT
8691	705	32	error	error	NN
8691	705	33	of	of	IN
8691	705	34	the	the	DT
8691	705	35	majority	majority	NN
8691	705	36	that	that	WDT
8691	705	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	705	38	thinks	think	VBZ
8691	705	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	705	40	worth	worth	JJ
8691	705	41	while	while	IN
8691	705	42	to	to	TO
8691	705	43	express	express	VB
8691	705	44	the	the	DT
8691	705	45	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	705	46	which	which	WDT
8691	705	47	lead	lead	VBP
8691	705	48	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	705	49	to	to	TO
8691	705	50	differ	differ	VB
8691	705	51	from	from	IN
8691	705	52	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	705	53	.	.	.
8691	706	1	No	no	DT
8691	706	2	departure	departure	NN
8691	706	3	from	from	IN
8691	706	4	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	706	5	in	in	IN
8691	706	6	any	any	DT
8691	706	7	American	american	JJ
8691	706	8	court	court	NN
8691	706	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	706	10	ever	ever	RB
8691	706	11	awakened	awaken	VBN
8691	706	12	so	so	RB
8691	706	13	much	much	JJ
8691	706	14	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	706	15	as	as	IN
8691	706	16	that	that	DT
8691	706	17	by	by	IN
8691	706	18	the	the	DT
8691	706	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	706	20	Court	Court	NNP
8691	706	21	of	of	IN
8691	706	22	the	the	DT
8691	706	23	United	United	NNP
8691	706	24	States	States	NNP
8691	706	25	in	in	IN
8691	706	26	1872	1872	CD
8691	706	27	,	,	,
8691	706	28	when	when	WRB
8691	706	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	706	30	decided	decide	VBD
8691	706	31	that	that	IN
8691	706	32	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	706	33	could	could	MD
8691	706	34	make	make	VB
8691	706	35	government	government	NN
8691	706	36	notes	note	NNS
8691	706	37	a	a	DT
8691	706	38	legal	legal	JJ
8691	706	39	tender	tender	NN
8691	706	40	for	for	IN
8691	706	41	debts	debt	NNS
8691	706	42	contracted	contract	VBN
8691	706	43	before	before	IN
8691	706	44	the	the	DT
8691	706	45	law	law	NN
8691	706	46	was	be	VBD
8691	706	47	passed	pass	VBN
8691	706	48	.	.	.
8691	707	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	707	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	707	3	:	:	:
8691	707	4	The	the	DT
8691	707	5	Legal	Legal	NNP
8691	707	6	Tender	Tender	NNP
8691	707	7	Cases	Cases	NNPS
8691	707	8	,	,	,
8691	707	9	12	12	CD
8691	707	10	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	707	11	's	's	POS
8691	707	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	707	13	,	,	,
8691	707	14	457	457	CD
8691	707	15	,	,	,
8691	707	16	529	529	CD
8691	707	17	.	.	.
8691	707	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	708	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	708	2	had	have	VBD
8691	708	3	held	hold	VBN
8691	708	4	precisely	precisely	RB
8691	708	5	the	the	DT
8691	708	6	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	708	7	two	two	CD
8691	708	8	years	year	NNS
8691	708	9	before,[Footnote	before,[footnote	CD
8691	708	10	:	:	:
8691	708	11	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
8691	708	12	_	_	NNP
8691	708	13	v.	v.	IN
8691	708	14	_	_	NNP
8691	708	15	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
8691	708	16	,	,	,
8691	708	17	8	8	CD
8691	708	18	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	708	19	's	's	POS
8691	708	20	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	708	21	,	,	,
8691	708	22	603	603	CD
8691	708	23	.	.	.
8691	708	24	]	]	-RRB-
8691	709	1	but	but	CC
8691	709	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	709	3	was	be	VBD
8691	709	4	by	by	IN
8691	709	5	a	a	DT
8691	709	6	bare	bare	JJ
8691	709	7	majority	majority	NN
8691	709	8	and	and	CC
8691	709	9	in	in	IN
8691	709	10	the	the	DT
8691	709	11	face	face	NN
8691	709	12	of	of	IN
8691	709	13	a	a	DT
8691	709	14	strong	strong	JJ
8691	709	15	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	709	16	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	709	17	.	.	.
8691	710	1	In	in	IN
8691	710	2	the	the	DT
8691	710	3	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	710	4	filed	file	VBN
8691	710	5	in	in	IN
8691	710	6	the	the	DT
8691	710	7	second	second	JJ
8691	710	8	case	case	NN
8691	710	9	stress	stress	NN
8691	710	10	was	be	VBD
8691	710	11	laid	lay	VBN
8691	710	12	upon	upon	IN
8691	710	13	this	this	DT
8691	710	14	division	division	NN
8691	710	15	of	of	IN
8691	710	16	the	the	DT
8691	710	17	court	court	NN
8691	710	18	.	.	.
8691	711	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	711	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	711	3	:	:	:
8691	711	4	12	12	CD
8691	711	5	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	711	6	's	's	POS
8691	711	7	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	711	8	,	,	,
8691	711	9	553	553	CD
8691	711	10	,	,	,
8691	711	11	569	569	CD
8691	711	12	.	.	.
8691	712	1	See	see	VB
8691	712	2	George	George	NNP
8691	712	3	F.	F.	NNP
8691	712	4	Hoar	Hoar	NNP
8691	712	5	,	,	,
8691	712	6	"	"	``
8691	712	7	Autobiography	Autobiography	NNP
8691	712	8	,	,	,
8691	712	9	"	"	''
8691	712	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	712	11	,	,	,
8691	712	12	286	286	CD
8691	712	13	.	.	.
8691	712	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	713	1	The	the	DT
8691	713	2	word	word	NN
8691	713	3	"	"	``
8691	713	4	established	establish	VBN
8691	713	5	"	"	''
8691	713	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	713	7	often	often	RB
8691	713	8	used	use	VBN
8691	713	9	to	to	TO
8691	713	10	describe	describe	VB
8691	713	11	the	the	DT
8691	713	12	kind	kind	NN
8691	713	13	of	of	IN
8691	713	14	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	713	15	to	to	IN
8691	713	16	which	which	WDT
8691	713	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	713	18	are	be	VBP
8691	713	19	bound	bind	VBN
8691	713	20	to	to	IN
8691	713	21	adhere	adhere	NNP
8691	713	22	.	.	.
8691	714	1	What	what	WP
8691	714	2	serves	serve	VBZ
8691	714	3	to	to	TO
8691	714	4	establish	establish	VB
8691	714	5	one	one	CD
8691	714	6	?	?	.
8691	715	1	Long	long	JJ
8691	715	2	popular	popular	JJ
8691	715	3	usage	usage	NN
8691	715	4	,	,	,
8691	715	5	repeated	repeat	VBD
8691	715	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	715	7	affirmations	affirmation	NNS
8691	715	8	,	,	,
8691	715	9	and	and	CC
8691	715	10	general	general	JJ
8691	715	11	recognition	recognition	NN
8691	715	12	by	by	IN
8691	715	13	approved	approve	VBN
8691	715	14	writers	writer	NNS
8691	715	15	on	on	IN
8691	715	16	legal	legal	JJ
8691	715	17	topics	topic	NNS
8691	715	18	.	.	.
8691	716	1	Of	of	IN
8691	716	2	these	these	DT
8691	716	3	,	,	,
8691	716	4	in	in	IN
8691	716	5	fact	fact	NN
8691	716	6	,	,	,
8691	716	7	the	the	DT
8691	716	8	last	last	JJ
8691	716	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	716	10	probably	probably	RB
8691	716	11	the	the	DT
8691	716	12	most	most	RBS
8691	716	13	powerful	powerful	JJ
8691	716	14	.	.	.
8691	717	1	Lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	717	2	and	and	CC
8691	717	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	717	4	,	,	,
8691	717	5	in	in	IN
8691	717	6	countries	country	NNS
8691	717	7	without	without	IN
8691	717	8	codes	code	NNS
8691	717	9	,	,	,
8691	717	10	get	get	VB
8691	717	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	717	12	law	law	NN
8691	717	13	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	717	14	from	from	IN
8691	717	15	the	the	DT
8691	717	16	standard	standard	JJ
8691	717	17	text	text	NN
8691	717	18	-	-	HYPH
8691	717	19	books	book	NNS
8691	717	20	.	.	.
8691	718	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	718	2	authors	author	NNS
8691	718	3	as	as	IN
8691	718	4	Coke	Coke	NNP
8691	718	5	,	,	,
8691	718	6	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
8691	718	7	,	,	,
8691	718	8	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	718	9	and	and	CC
8691	718	10	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
8691	718	11	are	be	VBP
8691	718	12	freely	freely	RB
8691	718	13	cited	cite	VBN
8691	718	14	and	and	CC
8691	718	15	relied	rely	VBN
8691	718	16	on	on	RP
8691	718	17	as	as	IN
8691	718	18	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	718	19	by	by	IN
8691	718	20	the	the	DT
8691	718	21	highest	high	JJS
8691	718	22	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	718	23	.	.	.
8691	719	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	719	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	719	3	:	:	:
8691	719	4	See	see	VB
8691	719	5	,	,	,
8691	719	6	for	for	IN
8691	719	7	instance	instance	NN
8691	719	8	,	,	,
8691	719	9	Western	Western	NNP
8691	719	10	Union	Union	NNP
8691	719	11	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
8691	719	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	719	13	_	_	NNP
8691	719	14	v.	v.	IN
8691	719	15	_	_	NNP
8691	719	16	Call	Call	NNP
8691	719	17	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
8691	719	18	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	719	19	,	,	,
8691	719	20	181	181	CD
8691	719	21	United	United	NNP
8691	719	22	States	States	NNP
8691	719	23	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	719	24	,	,	,
8691	719	25	101	101	CD
8691	719	26	;	;	:
8691	719	27	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
8691	719	28	Ferry	Ferry	NNP
8691	719	29	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	719	30	_	_	NNP
8691	719	31	v.	v.	IN
8691	719	32	_	_	NNP
8691	719	33	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	719	34	,	,	,
8691	719	35	188	188	CD
8691	719	36	United	United	NNP
8691	719	37	States	States	NNP
8691	719	38	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	719	39	,	,	,
8691	719	40	394	394	CD
8691	719	41	,	,	,
8691	719	42	397	397	CD
8691	719	43	.	.	.
8691	719	44	]	]	-RRB-
8691	720	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	720	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	720	3	by	by	IN
8691	720	4	the	the	DT
8691	720	5	writings	writing	NNS
8691	720	6	of	of	IN
8691	720	7	such	such	JJ
8691	720	8	men	man	NNS
8691	720	9	that	that	IN
8691	720	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	720	11	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	720	12	are	be	VBP
8691	720	13	sifted	sift	VBN
8691	720	14	and	and	CC
8691	720	15	legal	legal	JJ
8691	720	16	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
8691	720	17	finally	finally	RB
8691	720	18	clothed	clothe	VBN
8691	720	19	in	in	IN
8691	720	20	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
8691	720	21	terms	term	NNS
8691	720	22	and	and	CC
8691	720	23	arranged	arrange	VBN
8691	720	24	in	in	IN
8691	720	25	scientific	scientific	JJ
8691	720	26	order	order	NN
8691	720	27	.	.	.
8691	721	1	The	the	DT
8691	721	2	English	English	NNP
8691	721	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	721	4	long	long	RB
8691	721	5	ago	ago	RB
8691	721	6	declared	declare	VBD
8691	721	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	721	8	to	to	TO
8691	721	9	be	be	VB
8691	721	10	a	a	DT
8691	721	11	rule	rule	NN
8691	721	12	of	of	IN
8691	721	13	law	law	NN
8691	721	14	to	to	TO
8691	721	15	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	721	16	perpetuities	perpetuity	NNS
8691	721	17	that	that	WDT
8691	721	18	no	no	DT
8691	721	19	estate	estate	NN
8691	721	20	in	in	IN
8691	721	21	lands	land	NNS
8691	721	22	could	could	MD
8691	721	23	be	be	VB
8691	721	24	created	create	VBN
8691	721	25	which	which	WDT
8691	721	26	was	be	VBD
8691	721	27	not	not	RB
8691	721	28	to	to	TO
8691	721	29	commence	commence	VB
8691	721	30	within	within	IN
8691	721	31	the	the	DT
8691	721	32	compass	compass	NN
8691	721	33	of	of	IN
8691	721	34	a	a	DT
8691	721	35	life	life	NN
8691	721	36	or	or	CC
8691	721	37	lives	life	NNS
8691	721	38	of	of	IN
8691	721	39	persons	person	NNS
8691	721	40	then	then	RB
8691	721	41	existing	exist	VBG
8691	721	42	,	,	,
8691	721	43	with	with	IN
8691	721	44	an	an	DT
8691	721	45	exception	exception	NN
8691	721	46	intended	intend	VBN
8691	721	47	to	to	TO
8691	721	48	favor	favor	VB
8691	721	49	a	a	DT
8691	721	50	minor	minor	JJ
8691	721	51	heir	heir	NN
8691	721	52	.	.	.
8691	722	1	American	american	JJ
8691	722	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	722	3	accepted	accept	VBD
8691	722	4	this	this	DT
8691	722	5	rule	rule	NN
8691	722	6	,	,	,
8691	722	7	but	but	CC
8691	722	8	some	some	DT
8691	722	9	of	of	IN
8691	722	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	722	11	construed	construe	VBD
8691	722	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	722	13	as	as	IN
8691	722	14	meaning	mean	VBG
8691	722	15	that	that	IN
8691	722	16	no	no	DT
8691	722	17	estate	estate	NN
8691	722	18	in	in	IN
8691	722	19	lands	land	NNS
8691	722	20	could	could	MD
8691	722	21	be	be	VB
8691	722	22	created	create	VBN
8691	722	23	which	which	WDT
8691	722	24	was	be	VBD
8691	722	25	to	to	TO
8691	722	26	continue	continue	VB
8691	722	27	after	after	IN
8691	722	28	the	the	DT
8691	722	29	expiration	expiration	NN
8691	722	30	of	of	IN
8691	722	31	such	such	PDT
8691	722	32	a	a	DT
8691	722	33	period	period	NN
8691	722	34	.	.	.
8691	723	1	This	this	DT
8691	723	2	construction	construction	NN
8691	723	3	was	be	VBD
8691	723	4	shown	show	VBN
8691	723	5	by	by	IN
8691	723	6	Professor	Professor	NNP
8691	723	7	John	John	NNP
8691	723	8	C.	C.	NNP
8691	723	9	Gray	Gray	NNP
8691	723	10	,	,	,
8691	723	11	in	in	IN
8691	723	12	a	a	DT
8691	723	13	work	work	NN
8691	723	14	on	on	IN
8691	723	15	"	"	``
8691	723	16	Perpetuities	Perpetuities	NNPS
8691	723	17	,	,	,
8691	723	18	"	"	''
8691	723	19	to	to	TO
8691	723	20	be	be	VB
8691	723	21	unwarranted	unwarranted	JJ
8691	723	22	,	,	,
8691	723	23	and	and	CC
8691	723	24	since	since	IN
8691	723	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	723	26	publication	publication	NN
8691	723	27	the	the	DT
8691	723	28	cases	case	NNS
8691	723	29	which	which	WDT
8691	723	30	had	have	VBD
8691	723	31	proceeded	proceed	VBN
8691	723	32	on	on	IN
8691	723	33	that	that	DT
8691	723	34	basis	basis	NN
8691	723	35	have	have	VBP
8691	723	36	been	be	VBN
8691	723	37	generally	generally	RB
8691	723	38	treated	treat	VBN
8691	723	39	as	as	IN
8691	723	40	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
8691	723	41	.	.	.
8691	724	1	The	the	DT
8691	724	2	nature	nature	NN
8691	724	3	of	of	IN
8691	724	4	a	a	DT
8691	724	5	legal	legal	JJ
8691	724	6	presumption	presumption	NN
8691	724	7	,	,	,
8691	724	8	also	also	RB
8691	724	9	,	,	,
8691	724	10	had	have	VBD
8691	724	11	been	be	VBN
8691	724	12	misconceived	misconceive	VBN
8691	724	13	by	by	IN
8691	724	14	several	several	JJ
8691	724	15	American	american	JJ
8691	724	16	courts	court	NNS
8691	724	17	.	.	.
8691	725	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	725	2	had	have	VBD
8691	725	3	been	be	VBN
8691	725	4	treated	treat	VBN
8691	725	5	as	as	IN
8691	725	6	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	725	7	of	of	IN
8691	725	8	facts	fact	NNS
8691	725	9	.	.	.
8691	726	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	726	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	726	3	:	:	:
8691	726	4	Coffin	Coffin	NNP
8691	726	5	_	_	NNP
8691	726	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	726	7	_	_	NNP
8691	726	8	United	United	NNP
8691	726	9	States	States	NNP
8691	726	10	,	,	,
8691	726	11	156	156	CD
8691	726	12	United	United	NNP
8691	726	13	States	States	NNP
8691	726	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	726	15	,	,	,
8691	726	16	432	432	CD
8691	726	17	.	.	.
8691	726	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	727	1	Professor	Professor	NNP
8691	727	2	J.	J.	NNP
8691	728	1	B.	B.	NNP
8691	728	2	Thayer	Thayer	NNP
8691	728	3	,	,	,
8691	728	4	in	in	IN
8691	728	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	728	6	"	"	``
8691	728	7	Preliminary	Preliminary	NNP
8691	728	8	Treatise	Treatise	NNP
8691	728	9	on	on	IN
8691	728	10	Evidence,"[Footnote	evidence,"[footnote	NN
8691	728	11	:	:	:
8691	728	12	Pages	page	NNS
8691	728	13	337	337	CD
8691	728	14	,	,	,
8691	728	15	566	566	CD
8691	728	16	-	-	SYM
8691	728	17	575	575	CD
8691	728	18	.	.	.
8691	728	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	729	1	argued	argue	VBD
8691	729	2	so	so	RB
8691	729	3	forcibly	forcibly	RB
8691	729	4	against	against	IN
8691	729	5	this	this	DT
8691	729	6	view	view	NN
8691	729	7	that	that	IN
8691	729	8	in	in	IN
8691	729	9	at	at	RB
8691	729	10	least	least	RBS
8691	729	11	one	one	CD
8691	729	12	State	state	NN
8691	729	13	a	a	DT
8691	729	14	decision	decision	NN
8691	729	15	in	in	IN
8691	729	16	which	which	WDT
8691	729	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	729	18	had	have	VBD
8691	729	19	been	be	VBN
8691	729	20	taken	take	VBN
8691	729	21	has	have	VBZ
8691	729	22	been	be	VBN
8691	729	23	formally	formally	RB
8691	729	24	overruled	overrule	VBN
8691	729	25	.	.	.
8691	730	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	730	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	730	3	:	:	:
8691	730	4	Vincent	Vincent	NNP
8691	730	5	_	_	NNP
8691	730	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	730	7	_	_	NNP
8691	730	8	Mutual	Mutual	NNP
8691	730	9	Reserve	Reserve	NNP
8691	730	10	Fund	Fund	NNP
8691	730	11	Life	Life	NNP
8691	730	12	Association	Association	NNP
8691	730	13	,	,	,
8691	730	14	77	77	CD
8691	730	15	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	730	16	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	730	17	,	,	,
8691	730	18	281	281	CD
8691	730	19	,	,	,
8691	730	20	291	291	CD
8691	730	21	;	;	:
8691	730	22	58	58	CD
8691	730	23	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	730	24	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	730	25	,	,	,
8691	730	26	963	963	CD
8691	730	27	.	.	.
8691	730	28	]	]	-RRB-
8691	731	1	The	the	DT
8691	731	2	Court	Court	NNP
8691	731	3	of	of	IN
8691	731	4	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	731	5	of	of	IN
8691	731	6	New	New	NNP
8691	731	7	York	York	NNP
8691	731	8	once	once	RB
8691	731	9	held	hold	VBN
8691	731	10	in	in	IN
8691	731	11	a	a	DT
8691	731	12	carefully	carefully	RB
8691	731	13	prepared	prepared	JJ
8691	731	14	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	731	15	that	that	IN
8691	731	16	a	a	DT
8691	731	17	railroad	railroad	NN
8691	731	18	might	may	MD
8691	731	19	be	be	VB
8691	731	20	built	build	VBN
8691	731	21	along	along	IN
8691	731	22	the	the	DT
8691	731	23	shore	shore	NN
8691	731	24	of	of	IN
8691	731	25	a	a	DT
8691	731	26	navigable	navigable	JJ
8691	731	27	river	river	NN
8691	731	28	,	,	,
8691	731	29	under	under	IN
8691	731	30	authority	authority	NN
8691	731	31	from	from	IN
8691	731	32	the	the	DT
8691	731	33	State	State	NNP
8691	731	34	,	,	,
8691	731	35	without	without	IN
8691	731	36	first	first	RB
8691	731	37	making	make	VBG
8691	731	38	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	731	39	to	to	IN
8691	731	40	the	the	DT
8691	731	41	riparian	riparian	JJ
8691	731	42	proprietors	proprietor	NNS
8691	731	43	,	,	,
8691	731	44	whose	whose	WP$
8691	731	45	access	access	NN
8691	731	46	to	to	IN
8691	731	47	the	the	DT
8691	731	48	waters	water	NNS
8691	731	49	might	may	MD
8691	731	50	thus	thus	RB
8691	731	51	be	be	VB
8691	731	52	obstructed	obstruct	VBN
8691	731	53	.	.	.
8691	732	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	732	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	732	3	:	:	:
8691	732	4	Gould	Gould	NNP
8691	732	5	_	_	NNP
8691	732	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	732	7	_	_	NNP
8691	732	8	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
8691	732	9	River	River	NNP
8691	732	10	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
8691	732	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	732	12	,	,	,
8691	732	13	6	6	CD
8691	732	14	New	New	NNP
8691	732	15	York	York	NNP
8691	732	16	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	732	17	,	,	,
8691	732	18	522	522	CD
8691	732	19	.	.	.
8691	732	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	733	1	In	in	IN
8691	733	2	a	a	DT
8691	733	3	text	text	NN
8691	733	4	-	-	HYPH
8691	733	5	book	book	NN
8691	733	6	written	write	VBN
8691	733	7	by	by	IN
8691	733	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	733	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	733	10	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
8691	733	11	,	,	,
8691	733	12	this	this	DT
8691	733	13	decision	decision	NN
8691	733	14	was	be	VBD
8691	733	15	justly	justly	RB
8691	733	16	criticised,[Footnote	criticised,[footnote	CD
8691	733	17	:	:	:
8691	733	18	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
8691	733	19	on	on	IN
8691	733	20	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
8691	733	21	Limitations	Limitations	NNPS
8691	733	22	,	,	,
8691	733	23	670	670	CD
8691	733	24	.	.	.
8691	733	25	]	]	-RRB-
8691	734	1	and	and	CC
8691	734	2	not	not	RB
8691	734	3	long	long	RB
8691	734	4	after	after	IN
8691	734	5	the	the	DT
8691	734	6	publication	publication	NN
8691	734	7	of	of	IN
8691	734	8	that	that	DT
8691	734	9	work	work	NN
8691	734	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	734	11	was	be	VBD
8691	734	12	formally	formally	RB
8691	734	13	overruled	overrule	VBN
8691	734	14	.	.	.
8691	735	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	735	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	735	3	:	:	:
8691	735	4	Rumsey	Rumsey	NNP
8691	735	5	_	_	NNP
8691	735	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	735	7	_	_	NNP
8691	735	8	New	New	NNP
8691	735	9	York	York	NNP
8691	735	10	and	and	CC
8691	735	11	New	New	NNP
8691	735	12	England	England	NNP
8691	735	13	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
8691	735	14	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	735	15	,	,	,
8691	735	16	133	133	CD
8691	735	17	New	New	NNP
8691	735	18	York	York	NNP
8691	735	19	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	735	20	,	,	,
8691	735	21	79	79	CD
8691	735	22	;	;	:
8691	735	23	30	30	CD
8691	735	24	Northeastern	northeastern	JJ
8691	735	25	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	735	26	,	,	,
8691	735	27	654	654	CD
8691	735	28	;	;	:
8691	735	29	15	15	CD
8691	735	30	Lawyers	Lawyers	NNPS
8691	735	31	'	'	POS
8691	735	32	Reports	report	NNS
8691	735	33	Annotated	annotate	VBD
8691	735	34	,	,	,
8691	735	35	618	618	CD
8691	735	36	.	.	.
8691	735	37	]	]	-RRB-
8691	736	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	736	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	736	3	safe	safe	JJ
8691	736	4	to	to	TO
8691	736	5	say	say	VB
8691	736	6	that	that	IN
8691	736	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	736	8	fate	fate	NN
8691	736	9	was	be	VBD
8691	736	10	largely	largely	RB
8691	736	11	the	the	DT
8691	736	12	result	result	NN
8691	736	13	of	of	IN
8691	736	14	the	the	DT
8691	736	15	comments	comment	NNS
8691	736	16	thus	thus	RB
8691	736	17	made	make	VBN
8691	736	18	by	by	IN
8691	736	19	a	a	DT
8691	736	20	distinguished	distinguished	JJ
8691	736	21	jurist	jurist	NN
8691	736	22	,	,	,
8691	736	23	whose	whose	WP$
8691	736	24	only	only	JJ
8691	736	25	motive	motive	NN
8691	736	26	could	could	MD
8691	736	27	be	be	VB
8691	736	28	to	to	TO
8691	736	29	maintain	maintain	VB
8691	736	30	the	the	DT
8691	736	31	integrity	integrity	NN
8691	736	32	and	and	CC
8691	736	33	consistency	consistency	NN
8691	736	34	of	of	IN
8691	736	35	legal	legal	JJ
8691	736	36	science	science	NN
8691	736	37	.	.	.
8691	737	1	The	the	DT
8691	737	2	general	general	JJ
8691	737	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	737	4	of	of	IN
8691	737	5	the	the	DT
8691	737	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	737	7	,	,	,
8691	737	8	which	which	WDT
8691	737	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	737	10	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	737	11	expressed	express	VBN
8691	737	12	by	by	IN
8691	737	13	the	the	DT
8691	737	14	rule	rule	NN
8691	737	15	"	"	``
8691	737	16	_	_	NNP
8691	737	17	stare	stare	NN
8691	737	18	decisis	decisis	NN
8691	737	19	_	_	NNP
8691	737	20	,	,	,
8691	737	21	"	"	``
8691	737	22	was	be	VBD
8691	737	23	never	never	RB
8691	737	24	better	well	RBR
8691	737	25	stated	state	VBN
8691	737	26	than	than	IN
8691	737	27	by	by	IN
8691	737	28	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	737	29	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	737	30	Black	Black	NNP
8691	737	31	of	of	IN
8691	737	32	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	737	33	,	,	,
8691	737	34	in	in	IN
8691	737	35	these	these	DT
8691	737	36	words	word	NNS
8691	737	37	:	:	:
8691	737	38	When	when	WRB
8691	737	39	a	a	DT
8691	737	40	point	point	NN
8691	737	41	has	have	VBZ
8691	737	42	been	be	VBN
8691	737	43	solemnly	solemnly	RB
8691	737	44	ruled	rule	VBN
8691	737	45	by	by	IN
8691	737	46	the	the	DT
8691	737	47	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	737	48	of	of	IN
8691	737	49	the	the	DT
8691	737	50	last	last	JJ
8691	737	51	resort	resort	NN
8691	737	52	,	,	,
8691	737	53	after	after	IN
8691	737	54	full	full	JJ
8691	737	55	argument	argument	NN
8691	737	56	and	and	CC
8691	737	57	with	with	IN
8691	737	58	the	the	DT
8691	737	59	assent	assent	NN
8691	737	60	of	of	IN
8691	737	61	all	all	PDT
8691	737	62	the	the	DT
8691	737	63	judges	judge	NNS
8691	737	64	,	,	,
8691	737	65	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	737	66	have	have	VBP
8691	737	67	the	the	DT
8691	737	68	highest	high	JJS
8691	737	69	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	737	70	which	which	WDT
8691	737	71	can	can	MD
8691	737	72	be	be	VB
8691	737	73	procured	procure	VBN
8691	737	74	in	in	IN
8691	737	75	favor	favor	NN
8691	737	76	of	of	IN
8691	737	77	the	the	DT
8691	737	78	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	737	79	law	law	NN
8691	737	80	.	.	.
8691	738	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	738	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	738	3	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	738	4	said	say	VBN
8691	738	5	that	that	IN
8691	738	6	this	this	DT
8691	738	7	adherence	adherence	NN
8691	738	8	to	to	IN
8691	738	9	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	738	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	738	11	slavish	slavish	JJ
8691	738	12	;	;	:
8691	738	13	that	that	IN
8691	738	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	738	15	fetters	fetter	VBZ
8691	738	16	the	the	DT
8691	738	17	mind	mind	NN
8691	738	18	of	of	IN
8691	738	19	the	the	DT
8691	738	20	judge	judge	NN
8691	738	21	,	,	,
8691	738	22	and	and	CC
8691	738	23	compels	compel	VBZ
8691	738	24	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	738	25	to	to	TO
8691	738	26	decide	decide	VB
8691	738	27	without	without	IN
8691	738	28	reference	reference	NN
8691	738	29	to	to	IN
8691	738	30	principle	principle	NN
8691	738	31	.	.	.
8691	739	1	But	but	CC
8691	739	2	let	let	VB
8691	739	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	739	4	be	be	VB
8691	739	5	remembered	remember	VBN
8691	739	6	that	that	IN
8691	739	7	_	_	NNP
8691	739	8	stare	stare	NN
8691	739	9	decisis	decisis	NN
8691	739	10	_	_	NNP
8691	739	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	739	12	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	739	13	a	a	DT
8691	739	14	principle	principle	NN
8691	739	15	of	of	IN
8691	739	16	great	great	JJ
8691	739	17	magnitude	magnitude	NN
8691	739	18	and	and	CC
8691	739	19	importance	importance	NN
8691	739	20	....	....	.
8691	739	21	A	a	DT
8691	739	22	palpable	palpable	JJ
8691	739	23	mistake	mistake	NN
8691	739	24	,	,	,
8691	739	25	violating	violate	VBG
8691	739	26	justice	justice	NN
8691	739	27	,	,	,
8691	739	28	reason	reason	NN
8691	739	29	and	and	CC
8691	739	30	law	law	NN
8691	739	31	,	,	,
8691	739	32	must	must	MD
8691	739	33	be	be	VB
8691	739	34	corrected	correct	VBN
8691	739	35	,	,	,
8691	739	36	no	no	RB
8691	739	37	matter	matter	RB
8691	739	38	by	by	IN
8691	739	39	whom	whom	WP
8691	739	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	739	41	may	may	MD
8691	739	42	have	have	VB
8691	739	43	been	be	VBN
8691	739	44	made	make	VBN
8691	739	45	.	.	.
8691	740	1	There	there	EX
8691	740	2	are	be	VBP
8691	740	3	cases	case	NNS
8691	740	4	in	in	IN
8691	740	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	740	6	books	book	NNS
8691	740	7	which	which	WDT
8691	740	8	bear	bear	VBP
8691	740	9	such	such	JJ
8691	740	10	marks	mark	NNS
8691	740	11	of	of	IN
8691	740	12	haste	haste	NN
8691	740	13	and	and	CC
8691	740	14	inattention	inattention	NN
8691	740	15	,	,	,
8691	740	16	that	that	IN
8691	740	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	740	18	demand	demand	VBP
8691	740	19	reconsideration	reconsideration	NN
8691	740	20	.	.	.
8691	741	1	There	there	EX
8691	741	2	are	be	VBP
8691	741	3	some	some	DT
8691	741	4	which	which	WDT
8691	741	5	must	must	MD
8691	741	6	be	be	VB
8691	741	7	disregarded	disregard	VBN
8691	741	8	,	,	,
8691	741	9	because	because	IN
8691	741	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	741	11	can	can	MD
8691	741	12	not	not	RB
8691	741	13	be	be	VB
8691	741	14	reconciled	reconcile	VBN
8691	741	15	with	with	IN
8691	741	16	others	other	NNS
8691	741	17	.	.	.
8691	742	1	There	there	EX
8691	742	2	are	be	VBP
8691	742	3	old	old	JJ
8691	742	4	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	742	5	of	of	IN
8691	742	6	which	which	WDT
8691	742	7	the	the	DT
8691	742	8	authority	authority	NN
8691	742	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	742	10	become	become	VBN
8691	742	11	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
8691	742	12	,	,	,
8691	742	13	by	by	IN
8691	742	14	a	a	DT
8691	742	15	total	total	JJ
8691	742	16	alteration	alteration	NN
8691	742	17	in	in	IN
8691	742	18	the	the	DT
8691	742	19	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	742	20	of	of	IN
8691	742	21	the	the	DT
8691	742	22	country	country	NN
8691	742	23	and	and	CC
8691	742	24	the	the	DT
8691	742	25	progress	progress	NN
8691	742	26	of	of	IN
8691	742	27	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	742	28	.	.	.
8691	743	1	_	_	NNP
8691	743	2	Tempora	Tempora	NNP
8691	743	3	mutantur	mutantur	NN
8691	743	4	_	_	NNP
8691	743	5	.	.	.
8691	744	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	744	2	change	change	VBP
8691	744	3	with	with	IN
8691	744	4	the	the	DT
8691	744	5	change	change	NN
8691	744	6	of	of	IN
8691	744	7	the	the	DT
8691	744	8	times	time	NNS
8691	744	9	,	,	,
8691	744	10	as	as	RB
8691	744	11	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	744	12	as	as	IN
8691	744	13	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	744	14	move	move	VBP
8691	744	15	with	with	IN
8691	744	16	the	the	DT
8691	744	17	motion	motion	NN
8691	744	18	of	of	IN
8691	744	19	the	the	DT
8691	744	20	earth	earth	NN
8691	744	21	.	.	.
8691	745	1	But	but	CC
8691	745	2	in	in	IN
8691	745	3	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	745	4	cases	case	NNS
8691	745	5	,	,	,
8691	745	6	to	to	TO
8691	745	7	set	set	VB
8691	745	8	up	up	RP
8691	745	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	745	10	mere	mere	JJ
8691	745	11	notions	notion	NNS
8691	745	12	above	above	IN
8691	745	13	the	the	DT
8691	745	14	principles	principle	NNS
8691	745	15	which	which	WDT
8691	745	16	the	the	DT
8691	745	17	country	country	NN
8691	745	18	has	have	VBZ
8691	745	19	been	be	VBN
8691	745	20	acting	act	VBG
8691	745	21	upon	upon	IN
8691	745	22	as	as	IN
8691	745	23	settled	settle	VBN
8691	745	24	and	and	CC
8691	745	25	established	establish	VBN
8691	745	26	,	,	,
8691	745	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	745	28	to	to	TO
8691	745	29	make	make	VB
8691	745	30	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	745	31	not	not	RB
8691	745	32	the	the	DT
8691	745	33	ministers	minister	NNS
8691	745	34	and	and	CC
8691	745	35	agents	agent	NNS
8691	745	36	of	of	IN
8691	745	37	the	the	DT
8691	745	38	law	law	NN
8691	745	39	,	,	,
8691	745	40	but	but	CC
8691	745	41	the	the	DT
8691	745	42	masters	master	NNS
8691	745	43	of	of	IN
8691	745	44	the	the	DT
8691	745	45	law	law	NN
8691	745	46	and	and	CC
8691	745	47	the	the	DT
8691	745	48	tyrants	tyrant	NNS
8691	745	49	of	of	IN
8691	745	50	the	the	DT
8691	745	51	people	people	NNS
8691	745	52	.	.	.
8691	746	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	746	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	746	3	:	:	:
8691	746	4	McDowell	McDowell	NNP
8691	746	5	_	_	NNP
8691	746	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	746	7	_	_	NNP
8691	746	8	Oyer	Oyer	NNP
8691	746	9	,	,	,
8691	746	10	9	9	CD
8691	746	11	Harris	Harris	NNP
8691	746	12	'	'	POS
8691	746	13	Reports	report	NNS
8691	746	14	,	,	,
8691	746	15	423	423	CD
8691	746	16	.	.	.
8691	746	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	747	1	Generally	generally	RB
8691	747	2	,	,	,
8691	747	3	overruling	overrule	VBG
8691	747	4	a	a	DT
8691	747	5	former	former	JJ
8691	747	6	decision	decision	NN
8691	747	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	747	8	due	due	JJ
8691	747	9	to	to	IN
8691	747	10	a	a	DT
8691	747	11	change	change	NN
8691	747	12	of	of	IN
8691	747	13	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	747	14	,	,	,
8691	747	15	which	which	WDT
8691	747	16	has	have	VBZ
8691	747	17	given	give	VBN
8691	747	18	the	the	DT
8691	747	19	court	court	NN
8691	747	20	a	a	DT
8691	747	21	new	new	JJ
8691	747	22	view	view	NN
8691	747	23	-	-	HYPH
8691	747	24	point	point	NN
8691	747	25	.	.	.
8691	748	1	A	a	DT
8691	748	2	marked	marked	JJ
8691	748	3	instance	instance	NN
8691	748	4	of	of	IN
8691	748	5	this	this	DT
8691	748	6	occurred	occur	VBD
8691	748	7	in	in	IN
8691	748	8	1851	1851	CD
8691	748	9	,	,	,
8691	748	10	in	in	IN
8691	748	11	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	748	12	before	before	IN
8691	748	13	the	the	DT
8691	748	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	748	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	748	16	of	of	IN
8691	748	17	the	the	DT
8691	748	18	United	United	NNP
8691	748	19	States	States	NNP
8691	748	20	.	.	.
8691	749	1	More	More	JJR
8691	749	2	than	than	IN
8691	749	3	a	a	DT
8691	749	4	quarter	quarter	NN
8691	749	5	of	of	IN
8691	749	6	a	a	DT
8691	749	7	century	century	NN
8691	749	8	before	before	RB
8691	749	9	,	,	,
8691	749	10	a	a	DT
8691	749	11	suit	suit	NN
8691	749	12	in	in	IN
8691	749	13	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	749	14	for	for	IN
8691	749	15	seamen	seaman	NNS
8691	749	16	's	's	POS
8691	749	17	wages	wage	NNS
8691	749	18	on	on	IN
8691	749	19	an	an	DT
8691	749	20	inland	inland	JJ
8691	749	21	river	river	NN
8691	749	22	had	have	VBD
8691	749	23	been	be	VBN
8691	749	24	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
8691	749	25	by	by	IN
8691	749	26	the	the	DT
8691	749	27	District	District	NNP
8691	749	28	Court	Court	NNP
8691	749	29	of	of	IN
8691	749	30	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	749	31	for	for	IN
8691	749	32	want	want	NN
8691	749	33	of	of	IN
8691	749	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	749	35	,	,	,
8691	749	36	and	and	CC
8691	749	37	on	on	IN
8691	749	38	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	749	39	this	this	DT
8691	749	40	action	action	NN
8691	749	41	had	have	VBD
8691	749	42	been	be	VBN
8691	749	43	affirmed	affirm	VBN
8691	749	44	.	.	.
8691	750	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	750	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	750	3	Story	Story	NNP
8691	750	4	gave	give	VBD
8691	750	5	the	the	DT
8691	750	6	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	750	7	of	of	IN
8691	750	8	the	the	DT
8691	750	9	court	court	NN
8691	750	10	,	,	,
8691	750	11	and	and	CC
8691	750	12	said	say	VBD
8691	750	13	that	that	IN
8691	750	14	a	a	DT
8691	750	15	court	court	NN
8691	750	16	of	of	IN
8691	750	17	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	750	18	could	could	MD
8691	750	19	only	only	RB
8691	750	20	take	take	VB
8691	750	21	cognizance	cognizance	NN
8691	750	22	of	of	IN
8691	750	23	such	such	PDT
8691	750	24	a	a	DT
8691	750	25	claim	claim	NN
8691	750	26	when	when	WRB
8691	750	27	the	the	DT
8691	750	28	services	service	NNS
8691	750	29	were	be	VBD
8691	750	30	rendered	render	VBN
8691	750	31	at	at	IN
8691	750	32	sea	sea	NN
8691	750	33	or	or	CC
8691	750	34	upon	upon	IN
8691	750	35	waters	water	NNS
8691	750	36	within	within	IN
8691	750	37	the	the	DT
8691	750	38	ebb	ebb	NN
8691	750	39	and	and	CC
8691	750	40	flow	flow	NN
8691	750	41	of	of	IN
8691	750	42	the	the	DT
8691	750	43	tide	tide	NN
8691	750	44	.	.	.
8691	751	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	751	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	751	3	:	:	:
8691	751	4	The	the	DT
8691	751	5	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
8691	751	6	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	751	7	,	,	,
8691	751	8	10	10	CD
8691	751	9	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	751	10	's	's	POS
8691	751	11	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	751	12	,	,	,
8691	751	13	428	428	CD
8691	751	14	.	.	.
8691	751	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	752	1	This	this	DT
8691	752	2	was	be	VBD
8691	752	3	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
8691	752	4	a	a	DT
8691	752	5	true	true	JJ
8691	752	6	statement	statement	NN
8691	752	7	of	of	IN
8691	752	8	what	what	WP
8691	752	9	had	have	VBD
8691	752	10	always	always	RB
8691	752	11	been	be	VBN
8691	752	12	the	the	DT
8691	752	13	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	752	14	of	of	IN
8691	752	15	both	both	CC
8691	752	16	English	english	JJ
8691	752	17	and	and	CC
8691	752	18	American	american	JJ
8691	752	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	752	20	.	.	.
8691	753	1	But	but	CC
8691	753	2	out	out	IN
8691	753	3	of	of	IN
8691	753	4	what	what	WP
8691	753	5	did	do	VBD
8691	753	6	this	this	DT
8691	753	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	753	8	spring	spring	NN
8691	753	9	?	?	.
8691	754	1	From	from	IN
8691	754	2	the	the	DT
8691	754	3	fact	fact	NN
8691	754	4	that	that	IN
8691	754	5	in	in	IN
8691	754	6	England	England	NNP
8691	754	7	there	there	EX
8691	754	8	were	be	VBD
8691	754	9	no	no	DT
8691	754	10	navigable	navigable	JJ
8691	754	11	waters	water	NNS
8691	754	12	except	except	IN
8691	754	13	those	those	DT
8691	754	14	in	in	IN
8691	754	15	which	which	WDT
8691	754	16	the	the	DT
8691	754	17	tide	tide	NN
8691	754	18	ebbed	ebb	VBD
8691	754	19	and	and	CC
8691	754	20	flowed	flow	VBD
8691	754	21	,	,	,
8691	754	22	and	and	CC
8691	754	23	that	that	IN
8691	754	24	in	in	IN
8691	754	25	the	the	DT
8691	754	26	United	United	NNP
8691	754	27	States	States	NNP
8691	754	28	,	,	,
8691	754	29	up	up	IN
8691	754	30	to	to	IN
8691	754	31	that	that	DT
8691	754	32	time	time	NN
8691	754	33	,	,	,
8691	754	34	there	there	EX
8691	754	35	were	be	VBD
8691	754	36	none	none	NN
8691	754	37	of	of	IN
8691	754	38	a	a	DT
8691	754	39	different	different	JJ
8691	754	40	kind	kind	NN
8691	754	41	which	which	WDT
8691	754	42	had	have	VBD
8691	754	43	been	be	VBN
8691	754	44	largely	largely	RB
8691	754	45	used	use	VBN
8691	754	46	for	for	IN
8691	754	47	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	754	48	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	754	49	.	.	.
8691	755	1	Twenty	twenty	CD
8691	755	2	years	year	NNS
8691	755	3	passed	pass	VBD
8691	755	4	.	.	.
8691	756	1	Steam	steam	NN
8691	756	2	navigation	navigation	NN
8691	756	3	had	have	VBD
8691	756	4	opened	open	VBN
8691	756	5	the	the	DT
8691	756	6	great	great	JJ
8691	756	7	lakes	lake	NNS
8691	756	8	and	and	CC
8691	756	9	the	the	DT
8691	756	10	great	great	JJ
8691	756	11	rivers	river	NNS
8691	756	12	of	of	IN
8691	756	13	the	the	DT
8691	756	14	country	country	NN
8691	756	15	to	to	IN
8691	756	16	a	a	DT
8691	756	17	profitable	profitable	JJ
8691	756	18	carrying	carrying	NN
8691	756	19	trade	trade	NN
8691	756	20	.	.	.
8691	757	1	The	the	DT
8691	757	2	day	day	NN
8691	757	3	was	be	VBD
8691	757	4	dawning	dawn	VBG
8691	757	5	when	when	WRB
8691	757	6	the	the	DT
8691	757	7	bulk	bulk	NN
8691	757	8	of	of	IN
8691	757	9	American	american	JJ
8691	757	10	shipping	shipping	NN
8691	757	11	was	be	VBD
8691	757	12	to	to	TO
8691	757	13	be	be	VB
8691	757	14	employed	employ	VBN
8691	757	15	upon	upon	IN
8691	757	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	757	17	.	.	.
8691	758	1	A	a	DT
8691	758	2	suit	suit	NN
8691	758	3	in	in	IN
8691	758	4	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	758	5	was	be	VBD
8691	758	6	brought	bring	VBN
8691	758	7	against	against	IN
8691	758	8	a	a	DT
8691	758	9	ship	ship	NN
8691	758	10	for	for	IN
8691	758	11	sinking	sink	VBG
8691	758	12	another	another	DT
8691	758	13	on	on	IN
8691	758	14	Lake	Lake	NNP
8691	758	15	Ontario	Ontario	NNP
8691	758	16	.	.	.
8691	759	1	The	the	DT
8691	759	2	defendants	defendant	NNS
8691	759	3	put	put	VBD
8691	759	4	in	in	RP
8691	759	5	an	an	DT
8691	759	6	answer	answer	NN
8691	759	7	relying	rely	VBG
8691	759	8	on	on	IN
8691	759	9	the	the	DT
8691	759	10	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	759	11	laid	lay	VBN
8691	759	12	down	down	RP
8691	759	13	by	by	IN
8691	759	14	Story	story	NN
8691	759	15	.	.	.
8691	760	1	The	the	DT
8691	760	2	District	District	NNP
8691	760	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	760	4	overruled	overrule	VBD
8691	760	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	760	6	.	.	.
8691	761	1	The	the	DT
8691	761	2	case	case	NN
8691	761	3	came	come	VBD
8691	761	4	by	by	IN
8691	761	5	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	761	6	to	to	IN
8691	761	7	the	the	DT
8691	761	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	761	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	761	10	,	,	,
8691	761	11	and	and	CC
8691	761	12	in	in	IN
8691	761	13	an	an	DT
8691	761	14	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	761	15	by	by	IN
8691	761	16	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	761	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	761	18	Taney	Taney	NNP
8691	761	19	the	the	DT
8691	761	20	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	761	21	was	be	VBD
8691	761	22	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
8691	761	23	.	.	.
8691	762	1	"	"	``
8691	762	2	The	the	DT
8691	762	3	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	762	4	,	,	,
8691	762	5	"	"	''
8691	762	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	762	7	said	say	VBD
8691	762	8	,	,	,
8691	762	9	referring	refer	VBG
8691	762	10	to	to	IN
8691	762	11	the	the	DT
8691	762	12	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	762	13	of	of	IN
8691	762	14	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	762	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	762	16	Story	Story	NNP
8691	762	17	,	,	,
8691	762	18	"	"	''
8691	762	19	that	that	IN
8691	762	20	this	this	DT
8691	762	21	definition	definition	NN
8691	762	22	of	of	IN
8691	762	23	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	762	24	powers	power	NNS
8691	762	25	was	be	VBD
8691	762	26	narrower	narrow	JJR
8691	762	27	than	than	IN
8691	762	28	the	the	DT
8691	762	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	762	30	contemplated	contemplate	VBD
8691	762	31	,	,	,
8691	762	32	has	have	VBZ
8691	762	33	been	be	VBN
8691	762	34	growing	grow	VBG
8691	762	35	stronger	strong	JJR
8691	762	36	every	every	DT
8691	762	37	day	day	NN
8691	762	38	with	with	IN
8691	762	39	the	the	DT
8691	762	40	growing	grow	VBG
8691	762	41	commerce	commerce	NN
8691	762	42	on	on	IN
8691	762	43	the	the	DT
8691	762	44	lakes	lake	NNS
8691	762	45	and	and	CC
8691	762	46	navigable	navigable	JJ
8691	762	47	rivers	river	NNS
8691	762	48	of	of	IN
8691	762	49	the	the	DT
8691	762	50	western	western	JJ
8691	762	51	States	state	NNS
8691	762	52	....	....	.
8691	763	1	These	these	DT
8691	763	2	lakes	lake	NNS
8691	763	3	are	be	VBP
8691	763	4	in	in	IN
8691	763	5	truth	truth	NN
8691	763	6	inland	inland	NN
8691	763	7	seas	sea	NNS
8691	763	8	.	.	.
8691	764	1	Different	different	JJ
8691	764	2	States	States	NNP
8691	764	3	border	border	NN
8691	764	4	on	on	IN
8691	764	5	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	764	6	on	on	IN
8691	764	7	one	one	CD
8691	764	8	side	side	NN
8691	764	9	and	and	CC
8691	764	10	a	a	DT
8691	764	11	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	764	12	nation	nation	NN
8691	764	13	on	on	IN
8691	764	14	the	the	DT
8691	764	15	other	other	JJ
8691	764	16	.	.	.
8691	765	1	A	a	DT
8691	765	2	great	great	JJ
8691	765	3	and	and	CC
8691	765	4	growing	grow	VBG
8691	765	5	commerce	commerce	NN
8691	765	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	765	7	carried	carry	VBN
8691	765	8	on	on	RP
8691	765	9	upon	upon	IN
8691	765	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	765	11	between	between	IN
8691	765	12	different	different	JJ
8691	765	13	States	state	NNS
8691	765	14	and	and	CC
8691	765	15	a	a	DT
8691	765	16	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	765	17	nation	nation	NN
8691	765	18	,	,	,
8691	765	19	which	which	WDT
8691	765	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	765	21	subject	subject	JJ
8691	765	22	to	to	IN
8691	765	23	all	all	PDT
8691	765	24	the	the	DT
8691	765	25	incidents	incident	NNS
8691	765	26	and	and	CC
8691	765	27	hazards	hazard	NNS
8691	765	28	that	that	WDT
8691	765	29	attend	attend	VBP
8691	765	30	commerce	commerce	NN
8691	765	31	on	on	IN
8691	765	32	the	the	DT
8691	765	33	ocean	ocean	NN
8691	765	34	.	.	.
8691	766	1	Hostile	hostile	JJ
8691	766	2	fleets	fleet	NNS
8691	766	3	have	have	VBP
8691	766	4	encountered	encounter	VBN
8691	766	5	on	on	IN
8691	766	6	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	766	7	and	and	CC
8691	766	8	prizes	prize	NNS
8691	766	9	been	be	VBN
8691	766	10	made	make	VBN
8691	766	11	,	,	,
8691	766	12	and	and	CC
8691	766	13	every	every	DT
8691	766	14	reason	reason	NN
8691	766	15	which	which	WDT
8691	766	16	existed	exist	VBD
8691	766	17	for	for	IN
8691	766	18	the	the	DT
8691	766	19	grant	grant	NN
8691	766	20	of	of	IN
8691	766	21	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	766	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	766	23	to	to	IN
8691	766	24	the	the	DT
8691	766	25	general	general	JJ
8691	766	26	government	government	NN
8691	766	27	on	on	IN
8691	766	28	the	the	DT
8691	766	29	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	766	30	seas	seas	NNPS
8691	766	31	applies	apply	VBZ
8691	766	32	with	with	IN
8691	766	33	equal	equal	JJ
8691	766	34	force	force	NN
8691	766	35	to	to	IN
8691	766	36	the	the	DT
8691	766	37	lakes	lake	NNS
8691	766	38	.	.	.
8691	767	1	There	there	EX
8691	767	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	767	3	an	an	DT
8691	767	4	equal	equal	JJ
8691	767	5	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	767	6	for	for	IN
8691	767	7	the	the	DT
8691	767	8	instance	instance	NN
8691	767	9	and	and	CC
8691	767	10	for	for	IN
8691	767	11	the	the	DT
8691	767	12	prize	prize	NN
8691	767	13	power	power	NN
8691	767	14	of	of	IN
8691	767	15	the	the	DT
8691	767	16	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	767	17	court	court	NN
8691	767	18	to	to	TO
8691	767	19	administer	administer	VB
8691	767	20	international	international	JJ
8691	767	21	law	law	NN
8691	767	22	,	,	,
8691	767	23	and	and	CC
8691	767	24	if	if	IN
8691	767	25	the	the	DT
8691	767	26	one	one	NN
8691	767	27	can	can	MD
8691	767	28	not	not	RB
8691	767	29	be	be	VB
8691	767	30	established	establish	VBN
8691	767	31	neither	neither	CC
8691	767	32	can	can	MD
8691	767	33	the	the	DT
8691	767	34	other	other	JJ
8691	767	35	....	....	.
8691	768	1	The	the	DT
8691	768	2	case	case	NN
8691	768	3	of	of	IN
8691	768	4	the	the	DT
8691	768	5	_	_	NNP
8691	768	6	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
8691	768	7	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	768	8	_	_	NNP
8691	768	9	did	do	VBD
8691	768	10	not	not	RB
8691	768	11	decide	decide	VB
8691	768	12	any	any	DT
8691	768	13	question	question	NN
8691	768	14	of	of	IN
8691	768	15	property	property	NN
8691	768	16	or	or	CC
8691	768	17	lay	lie	VBD
8691	768	18	down	down	RP
8691	768	19	any	any	DT
8691	768	20	rule	rule	NN
8691	768	21	by	by	IN
8691	768	22	which	which	WDT
8691	768	23	the	the	DT
8691	768	24	right	right	NN
8691	768	25	of	of	IN
8691	768	26	property	property	NN
8691	768	27	should	should	MD
8691	768	28	be	be	VB
8691	768	29	determined	determine	VBN
8691	768	30	....	....	.
8691	769	1	The	the	DT
8691	769	2	rights	right	NNS
8691	769	3	of	of	IN
8691	769	4	property	property	NN
8691	769	5	and	and	CC
8691	769	6	of	of	IN
8691	769	7	parties	party	NNS
8691	769	8	will	will	MD
8691	769	9	be	be	VB
8691	769	10	the	the	DT
8691	769	11	same	same	JJ
8691	769	12	by	by	IN
8691	769	13	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	769	14	court	court	NN
8691	769	15	the	the	DT
8691	769	16	law	law	NN
8691	769	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	769	18	administered	administer	VBN
8691	769	19	.	.	.
8691	770	1	And	and	CC
8691	770	2	as	as	IN
8691	770	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	770	4	are	be	VBP
8691	770	5	convinced	convinced	JJ
8691	770	6	that	that	IN
8691	770	7	the	the	DT
8691	770	8	former	former	JJ
8691	770	9	decision	decision	NN
8691	770	10	was	be	VBD
8691	770	11	founded	found	VBN
8691	770	12	in	in	IN
8691	770	13	error	error	NN
8691	770	14	,	,	,
8691	770	15	and	and	CC
8691	770	16	that	that	IN
8691	770	17	the	the	DT
8691	770	18	error	error	NN
8691	770	19	,	,	,
8691	770	20	if	if	IN
8691	770	21	not	not	RB
8691	770	22	corrected	correct	VBN
8691	770	23	,	,	,
8691	770	24	must	must	MD
8691	770	25	produce	produce	VB
8691	770	26	serious	serious	JJ
8691	770	27	public	public	NN
8691	770	28	as	as	RB
8691	770	29	well	well	RB
8691	770	30	as	as	IN
8691	770	31	private	private	JJ
8691	770	32	inconvenience	inconvenience	NN
8691	770	33	and	and	CC
8691	770	34	loss	loss	NN
8691	770	35	,	,	,
8691	770	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	770	37	becomes	become	VBZ
8691	770	38	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	770	39	duty	duty	NN
8691	770	40	not	not	RB
8691	770	41	to	to	TO
8691	770	42	perpetuate	perpetuate	VB
8691	770	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	770	44	.	.	.
8691	771	1	"	"	``
8691	771	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	771	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	771	4	:	:	:
8691	771	5	The	the	DT
8691	771	6	Genesee	Genesee	NNP
8691	771	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	771	8	,	,	,
8691	771	9	12	12	CD
8691	771	10	Howard	Howard	NNP
8691	771	11	's	's	POS
8691	771	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	771	13	,	,	,
8691	771	14	443	443	CD
8691	771	15	,	,	,
8691	771	16	451	451	CD
8691	771	17	.	.	.
8691	771	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	772	1	But	but	CC
8691	772	2	without	without	IN
8691	772	3	any	any	DT
8691	772	4	change	change	NN
8691	772	5	of	of	IN
8691	772	6	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	772	7	,	,	,
8691	772	8	the	the	DT
8691	772	9	proper	proper	JJ
8691	772	10	desire	desire	NN
8691	772	11	of	of	IN
8691	772	12	all	all	DT
8691	772	13	American	american	JJ
8691	772	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	772	15	to	to	TO
8691	772	16	keep	keep	VB
8691	772	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	772	18	common	common	JJ
8691	772	19	law	law	NN
8691	772	20	in	in	IN
8691	772	21	harmony	harmony	NN
8691	772	22	with	with	IN
8691	772	23	that	that	DT
8691	772	24	of	of	IN
8691	772	25	the	the	DT
8691	772	26	other	other	JJ
8691	772	27	States	States	NNPS
8691	772	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	772	29	often	often	RB
8691	772	30	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	772	31	to	to	TO
8691	772	32	induce	induce	VB
8691	772	33	the	the	DT
8691	772	34	abandonment	abandonment	NN
8691	772	35	of	of	IN
8691	772	36	a	a	DT
8691	772	37	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	772	38	once	once	RB
8691	772	39	distinctly	distinctly	RB
8691	772	40	asserted	assert	VBN
8691	772	41	.	.	.
8691	773	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	773	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	773	3	:	:	:
8691	773	4	City	City	NNP
8691	773	5	of	of	IN
8691	773	6	South	South	NNP
8691	773	7	Bend	Bend	NNP
8691	773	8	_	_	NNP
8691	773	9	v.	v.	IN
8691	773	10	_	_	NNP
8691	773	11	Turner	Turner	NNP
8691	773	12	,	,	,
8691	773	13	156	156	CD
8691	773	14	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
8691	773	15	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	773	16	,	,	,
8691	773	17	418	418	CD
8691	773	18	;	;	:
8691	773	19	60	60	CD
8691	773	20	Northeastern	northeastern	JJ
8691	773	21	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	773	22	,	,	,
8691	773	23	271	271	CD
8691	773	24	.	.	.
8691	773	25	]	]	-RRB-
8691	774	1	The	the	DT
8691	774	2	consistency	consistency	NN
8691	774	3	of	of	IN
8691	774	4	American	american	JJ
8691	774	5	law	law	NN
8691	774	6	as	as	IN
8691	774	7	a	a	DT
8691	774	8	whole	whole	NN
8691	774	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	774	10	immeasurably	immeasurably	RB
8691	774	11	more	more	RBR
8691	774	12	important	important	JJ
8691	774	13	than	than	IN
8691	774	14	the	the	DT
8691	774	15	consistency	consistency	NN
8691	774	16	of	of	IN
8691	774	17	the	the	DT
8691	774	18	law	law	NN
8691	774	19	of	of	IN
8691	774	20	any	any	DT
8691	774	21	single	single	JJ
8691	774	22	State	state	NN
8691	774	23	.	.	.
8691	775	1	Sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	775	2	a	a	DT
8691	775	3	court	court	NN
8691	775	4	of	of	IN
8691	775	5	last	last	JJ
8691	775	6	resort	resort	NN
8691	775	7	treats	treat	VBZ
8691	775	8	a	a	DT
8691	775	9	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	775	10	which	which	WDT
8691	775	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	775	12	had	have	VBD
8691	775	13	formerly	formerly	RB
8691	775	14	asserted	assert	VBN
8691	775	15	as	as	RB
8691	775	16	manifestly	manifestly	RB
8691	775	17	unsound	unsound	JJ
8691	775	18	and	and	CC
8691	775	19	abandons	abandon	VBZ
8691	775	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	775	21	without	without	IN
8691	775	22	stopping	stop	VBG
8691	775	23	to	to	TO
8691	775	24	give	give	VB
8691	775	25	a	a	DT
8691	775	26	reason	reason	NN
8691	775	27	or	or	CC
8691	775	28	even	even	RB
8691	775	29	to	to	TO
8691	775	30	overrule	overrule	VB
8691	775	31	the	the	DT
8691	775	32	decision	decision	NN
8691	775	33	which	which	WDT
8691	775	34	first	first	RB
8691	775	35	announced	announce	VBD
8691	775	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	775	37	.	.	.
8691	776	1	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
8691	776	2	for	for	IN
8691	776	3	a	a	DT
8691	776	4	long	long	JJ
8691	776	5	generation	generation	NN
8691	776	6	adopted	adopt	VBD
8691	776	7	the	the	DT
8691	776	8	rule	rule	NN
8691	776	9	that	that	IN
8691	776	10	if	if	IN
8691	776	11	an	an	DT
8691	776	12	injury	injury	NN
8691	776	13	occurred	occur	VBD
8691	776	14	to	to	IN
8691	776	15	one	one	CD
8691	776	16	man	man	NN
8691	776	17	through	through	IN
8691	776	18	the	the	DT
8691	776	19	concurring	concur	VBG
8691	776	20	negligence	negligence	NN
8691	776	21	of	of	IN
8691	776	22	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	776	23	and	and	CC
8691	776	24	another	another	DT
8691	776	25	,	,	,
8691	776	26	but	but	CC
8691	776	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	776	28	negligence	negligence	NN
8691	776	29	was	be	VBD
8691	776	30	slighter	slighter	JJ
8691	776	31	than	than	IN
8691	776	32	that	that	DT
8691	776	33	of	of	IN
8691	776	34	the	the	DT
8691	776	35	other	other	JJ
8691	776	36	,	,	,
8691	776	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	776	38	might	may	MD
8691	776	39	hold	hold	VB
8691	776	40	the	the	DT
8691	776	41	latter	latter	JJ
8691	776	42	responsible	responsible	JJ
8691	776	43	for	for	IN
8691	776	44	the	the	DT
8691	776	45	damages	damage	NNS
8691	776	46	suffered	suffer	VBD
8691	776	47	.	.	.
8691	777	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	777	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	777	3	:	:	:
8691	777	4	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
8691	777	5	,	,	,
8691	777	6	"	"	``
8691	777	7	American	american	JJ
8691	777	8	Law	Law	NNP
8691	777	9	,	,	,
8691	777	10	"	"	''
8691	777	11	255	255	CD
8691	777	12	,	,	,
8691	777	13	1027	1027	CD
8691	777	14	.	.	.
8691	777	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	778	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	778	2	was	be	VBD
8691	778	3	not	not	RB
8691	778	4	a	a	DT
8691	778	5	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	778	6	justified	justify	VBN
8691	778	7	by	by	IN
8691	778	8	the	the	DT
8691	778	9	common	common	JJ
8691	778	10	law	law	NN
8691	778	11	nor	nor	CC
8691	778	12	generally	generally	RB
8691	778	13	held	hold	VBN
8691	778	14	in	in	IN
8691	778	15	this	this	DT
8691	778	16	country	country	NN
8691	778	17	,	,	,
8691	778	18	and	and	CC
8691	778	19	in	in	IN
8691	778	20	1894	1894	CD
8691	778	21	the	the	DT
8691	778	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	778	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	778	24	of	of	IN
8691	778	25	the	the	DT
8691	778	26	State	State	NNP
8691	778	27	refused	refuse	VBD
8691	778	28	to	to	TO
8691	778	29	recognize	recognize	VB
8691	778	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	778	31	,	,	,
8691	778	32	with	with	IN
8691	778	33	little	little	JJ
8691	778	34	or	or	CC
8691	778	35	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	778	36	more	more	JJR
8691	778	37	than	than	IN
8691	778	38	this	this	DT
8691	778	39	brief	brief	NN
8691	778	40	_	_	NNP
8691	778	41	ipse	ipse	NNP
8691	778	42	dixit	dixit	NNP
8691	778	43	_	_	NNP
8691	778	44	:	:	:
8691	778	45	"	"	``
8691	778	46	The	the	DT
8691	778	47	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	778	48	of	of	IN
8691	778	49	comparative	comparative	JJ
8691	778	50	negligence	negligence	NN
8691	778	51	is	be	VBZ
8691	778	52	no	no	RB
8691	778	53	longer	long	RBR
8691	778	54	the	the	DT
8691	778	55	law	law	NN
8691	778	56	of	of	IN
8691	778	57	this	this	DT
8691	778	58	court	court	NN
8691	778	59	.	.	.
8691	779	1	"	"	``
8691	779	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	779	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	779	4	:	:	:
8691	779	5	Lanark	Lanark	NNP
8691	779	6	_	_	NNP
8691	779	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	779	8	_	_	NNP
8691	779	9	Dougherty	Dougherty	NNP
8691	779	10	,	,	,
8691	779	11	153	153	CD
8691	779	12	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
8691	779	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	779	14	,	,	,
8691	779	15	163	163	CD
8691	779	16	;	;	:
8691	779	17	38	38	CD
8691	779	18	Northeastern	northeastern	JJ
8691	779	19	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	779	20	,	,	,
8691	779	21	892	892	CD
8691	779	22	.	.	.
8691	779	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	780	1	Occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	780	2	a	a	DT
8691	780	3	case	case	NN
8691	780	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	780	5	overruled	overrule	VBN
8691	780	6	because	because	IN
8691	780	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	780	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	780	9	been	be	VBN
8691	780	10	forgotten	forget	VBN
8691	780	11	.	.	.
8691	781	1	An	an	DT
8691	781	2	early	early	JJ
8691	781	3	decision	decision	NN
8691	781	4	in	in	IN
8691	781	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	781	6	(	(	-LRB-
8691	781	7	Loomis	Loomis	NNP
8691	781	8	_	_	NNP
8691	781	9	v.	v.	IN
8691	781	10	_	_	NNP
8691	781	11	Newhall[Footnote	newhall[footnote	NN
8691	781	12	:	:	:
8691	781	13	15	15	CD
8691	781	14	Pickering	Pickering	NNP
8691	781	15	's	's	POS
8691	781	16	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	781	17	,	,	,
8691	781	18	159	159	CD
8691	781	19	.	.	.
8691	781	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	781	21	)	)	-RRB-
8691	782	1	had	have	VBD
8691	782	2	affirmed	affirm	VBN
8691	782	3	the	the	DT
8691	782	4	position	position	NN
8691	782	5	that	that	IN
8691	782	6	if	if	IN
8691	782	7	a	a	DT
8691	782	8	statute	statute	NN
8691	782	9	required	require	VBD
8691	782	10	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	782	11	of	of	IN
8691	782	12	a	a	DT
8691	782	13	certain	certain	JJ
8691	782	14	kind	kind	NN
8691	782	15	to	to	TO
8691	782	16	be	be	VB
8691	782	17	put	put	VBN
8691	782	18	in	in	IN
8691	782	19	writing	writing	NN
8691	782	20	,	,	,
8691	782	21	and	and	CC
8691	782	22	a	a	DT
8691	782	23	contract	contract	NN
8691	782	24	of	of	IN
8691	782	25	that	that	DT
8691	782	26	kind	kind	NN
8691	782	27	,	,	,
8691	782	28	but	but	CC
8691	782	29	embracing	embrace	VBG
8691	782	30	also	also	RB
8691	782	31	a	a	DT
8691	782	32	different	different	JJ
8691	782	33	and	and	CC
8691	782	34	distinct	distinct	JJ
8691	782	35	matter	matter	NN
8691	782	36	not	not	RB
8691	782	37	touched	touch	VBN
8691	782	38	by	by	IN
8691	782	39	the	the	DT
8691	782	40	statute	statute	NN
8691	782	41	,	,	,
8691	782	42	was	be	VBD
8691	782	43	made	make	VBN
8691	782	44	orally	orally	RB
8691	782	45	,	,	,
8691	782	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	782	47	was	be	VBD
8691	782	48	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	782	49	void	void	JJ
8691	782	50	.	.	.
8691	783	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	783	2	a	a	DT
8691	783	3	rule	rule	NN
8691	783	4	was	be	VBD
8691	783	5	illogical	illogical	JJ
8691	783	6	and	and	CC
8691	783	7	unsound	unsound	JJ
8691	783	8	,	,	,
8691	783	9	and	and	CC
8691	783	10	in	in	IN
8691	783	11	a	a	DT
8691	783	12	later	later	JJ
8691	783	13	decision	decision	NN
8691	783	14	the	the	DT
8691	783	15	same	same	JJ
8691	783	16	court	court	NN
8691	783	17	,	,	,
8691	783	18	forgetting	forget	VBG
8691	783	19	that	that	IN
8691	783	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	783	21	had	have	VBD
8691	783	22	indorsed	indorse	VBN
8691	783	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	783	24	,	,	,
8691	783	25	said	say	VBD
8691	783	26	so	so	RB
8691	783	27	,	,	,
8691	783	28	and	and	CC
8691	783	29	said	say	VBD
8691	783	30	so	so	RB
8691	783	31	when	when	WRB
8691	783	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	783	33	was	be	VBD
8691	783	34	not	not	RB
8691	783	35	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	783	36	to	to	IN
8691	783	37	the	the	DT
8691	783	38	decision	decision	NN
8691	783	39	.	.	.
8691	784	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	784	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	784	3	:	:	:
8691	784	4	Irvine	Irvine	NNP
8691	784	5	_	_	NNP
8691	784	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	784	7	_	_	NNP
8691	784	8	Stone	Stone	NNP
8691	784	9	,	,	,
8691	784	10	6	6	CD
8691	784	11	Cushing	Cushing	NNP
8691	784	12	's	's	POS
8691	784	13	Reports	report	NNS
8691	784	14	,	,	,
8691	784	15	508	508	CD
8691	784	16	,	,	,
8691	784	17	510	510	CD
8691	784	18	.	.	.
8691	784	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	785	1	Subsequently	subsequently	RB
8691	785	2	,	,	,
8691	785	3	both	both	CC
8691	785	4	these	these	DT
8691	785	5	cases	case	NNS
8691	785	6	having	have	VBG
8691	785	7	been	be	VBN
8691	785	8	brought	bring	VBN
8691	785	9	to	to	IN
8691	785	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	785	11	attention	attention	NN
8691	785	12	,	,	,
8691	785	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	785	14	affirmed	affirm	VBD
8691	785	15	the	the	DT
8691	785	16	latter	latter	JJ
8691	785	17	,	,	,
8691	785	18	though	though	IN
8691	785	19	remarking	remark	VBG
8691	785	20	that	that	IN
8691	785	21	"	"	``
8691	785	22	what	what	WP
8691	785	23	was	be	VBD
8691	785	24	there	there	RB
8691	785	25	said	say	VBD
8691	785	26	on	on	IN
8691	785	27	this	this	DT
8691	785	28	point	point	NN
8691	785	29	was	be	VBD
8691	785	30	not	not	RB
8691	785	31	essential	essential	JJ
8691	785	32	to	to	IN
8691	785	33	the	the	DT
8691	785	34	decision	decision	NN
8691	785	35	of	of	IN
8691	785	36	that	that	DT
8691	785	37	case	case	NN
8691	785	38	,	,	,
8691	785	39	and	and	CC
8691	785	40	would	would	MD
8691	785	41	have	have	VB
8691	785	42	been	be	VBN
8691	785	43	omitted	omit	VBN
8691	785	44	or	or	CC
8691	785	45	modified	modify	VBN
8691	785	46	if	if	IN
8691	785	47	Loomis	Loomis	NNP
8691	785	48	_	_	NNP
8691	785	49	v.	v.	IN
8691	785	50	_	_	NNP
8691	785	51	Newhall	Newhall	NNP
8691	785	52	had	have	VBD
8691	785	53	been	be	VBN
8691	785	54	then	then	RB
8691	785	55	remembered	remember	VBN
8691	785	56	.	.	.
8691	786	1	"	"	``
8691	786	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	786	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	786	4	:	:	:
8691	786	5	Rand	Rand	NNP
8691	786	6	_	_	NNP
8691	786	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	786	8	_	_	NNP
8691	786	9	Mather	Mather	NNP
8691	786	10	,	,	,
8691	786	11	11	11	CD
8691	786	12	Cushing	Cushing	NNP
8691	786	13	's	's	POS
8691	786	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	786	15	,	,	,
8691	786	16	1	1	CD
8691	786	17	,	,	,
8691	786	18	5	5	CD
8691	786	19	.	.	.
8691	786	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	787	1	The	the	DT
8691	787	2	authority	authority	NN
8691	787	3	of	of	IN
8691	787	4	an	an	DT
8691	787	5	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	787	6	as	as	IN
8691	787	7	a	a	DT
8691	787	8	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	787	9	on	on	IN
8691	787	10	any	any	DT
8691	787	11	point	point	NN
8691	787	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	787	13	always	always	RB
8691	787	14	proportioned	proportion	VBN
8691	787	15	to	to	IN
8691	787	16	the	the	DT
8691	787	17	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	787	18	of	of	IN
8691	787	19	determining	determine	VBG
8691	787	20	that	that	DT
8691	787	21	point	point	NN
8691	787	22	in	in	IN
8691	787	23	order	order	NN
8691	787	24	to	to	TO
8691	787	25	support	support	VB
8691	787	26	the	the	DT
8691	787	27	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	787	28	which	which	WDT
8691	787	29	was	be	VBD
8691	787	30	rendered	render	VBN
8691	787	31	.	.	.
8691	788	1	Some	some	DT
8691	788	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	788	3	write	write	VBP
8691	788	4	treatises	treatise	NNS
8691	788	5	instead	instead	RB
8691	788	6	of	of	IN
8691	788	7	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	788	8	or	or	CC
8691	788	9	in	in	IN
8691	788	10	addition	addition	NN
8691	788	11	to	to	IN
8691	788	12	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	788	13	.	.	.
8691	789	1	Whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	789	2	goes	go	VBZ
8691	789	3	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	789	4	that	that	DT
8691	789	5	which	which	WDT
8691	789	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	789	7	required	require	VBN
8691	789	8	to	to	TO
8691	789	9	show	show	VB
8691	789	10	that	that	IN
8691	789	11	the	the	DT
8691	789	12	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	789	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	789	14	the	the	DT
8691	789	15	legal	legal	JJ
8691	789	16	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	789	17	from	from	IN
8691	789	18	the	the	DT
8691	789	19	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
8691	789	20	facts	fact	NNS
8691	789	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	789	22	styled	style	VBN
8691	789	23	in	in	IN
8691	789	24	law	law	NN
8691	789	25	language	language	NN
8691	789	26	_	_	NNP
8691	789	27	obiter	obiter	NN
8691	789	28	dictum	dictum	NN
8691	789	29	_	_	NNP
8691	789	30	.	.	.
8691	790	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	790	2	may	may	MD
8691	790	3	be	be	VB
8691	790	4	interesting	interesting	JJ
8691	790	5	and	and	CC
8691	790	6	even	even	RB
8691	790	7	persuasive	persuasive	JJ
8691	790	8	,	,	,
8691	790	9	but	but	CC
8691	790	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	790	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	790	12	not	not	RB
8691	790	13	an	an	DT
8691	790	14	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
8691	790	15	statement	statement	NN
8691	790	16	of	of	IN
8691	790	17	law	law	NN
8691	790	18	.	.	.
8691	791	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	791	2	may	may	MD
8691	791	3	grow	grow	VB
8691	791	4	to	to	TO
8691	791	5	be	be	VB
8691	791	6	such	such	JJ
8691	791	7	by	by	IN
8691	791	8	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	791	9	in	in	IN
8691	791	10	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	791	11	cases	case	NNS
8691	791	12	.	.	.
8691	792	1	The	the	DT
8691	792	2	Court	Court	NNP
8691	792	3	of	of	IN
8691	792	4	King	King	NNP
8691	792	5	's	's	POS
8691	792	6	Bench	Bench	NNP
8691	792	7	in	in	IN
8691	792	8	England	England	NNP
8691	792	9	was	be	VBD
8691	792	10	called	call	VBN
8691	792	11	on	on	RP
8691	792	12	,	,	,
8691	792	13	at	at	IN
8691	792	14	the	the	DT
8691	792	15	beginning	beginning	NN
8691	792	16	of	of	IN
8691	792	17	the	the	DT
8691	792	18	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
8691	792	19	century	century	NN
8691	792	20	,	,	,
8691	792	21	to	to	TO
8691	792	22	say	say	VB
8691	792	23	whether	whether	IN
8691	792	24	if	if	IN
8691	792	25	a	a	DT
8691	792	26	man	man	NN
8691	792	27	undertook	undertake	VBD
8691	792	28	as	as	IN
8691	792	29	a	a	DT
8691	792	30	friendly	friendly	JJ
8691	792	31	act	act	NN
8691	792	32	,	,	,
8691	792	33	and	and	CC
8691	792	34	not	not	RB
8691	792	35	for	for	IN
8691	792	36	pay	pay	NN
8691	792	37	,	,	,
8691	792	38	to	to	TO
8691	792	39	cart	cart	VB
8691	792	40	another	another	DT
8691	792	41	's	's	POS
8691	792	42	goods	good	NNS
8691	792	43	,	,	,
8691	792	44	and	and	CC
8691	792	45	did	do	VBD
8691	792	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	792	47	carelessly	carelessly	RB
8691	792	48	,	,	,
8691	792	49	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	792	50	was	be	VBD
8691	792	51	bound	bind	VBN
8691	792	52	to	to	TO
8691	792	53	answer	answer	VB
8691	792	54	for	for	IN
8691	792	55	any	any	DT
8691	792	56	damage	damage	NN
8691	792	57	that	that	WDT
8691	792	58	might	may	MD
8691	792	59	result	result	VB
8691	792	60	.	.	.
8691	793	1	There	there	EX
8691	793	2	were	be	VBD
8691	793	3	four	four	CD
8691	793	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	793	5	who	who	WP
8691	793	6	heard	hear	VBD
8691	793	7	the	the	DT
8691	793	8	case	case	NN
8691	793	9	,	,	,
8691	793	10	of	of	IN
8691	793	11	whom	whom	WP
8691	793	12	three	three	CD
8691	793	13	gave	give	VBD
8691	793	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	793	15	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	793	16	.	.	.
8691	794	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	794	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	794	3	:	:	:
8691	794	4	Coggs	Coggs	NNP
8691	794	5	_	_	NNP
8691	794	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	794	7	_	_	NNP
8691	794	8	Bernard	Bernard	NNP
8691	794	9	,	,	,
8691	794	10	Lord	Lord	NNP
8691	794	11	Raymond	Raymond	NNP
8691	794	12	's	's	POS
8691	794	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	794	14	,	,	,
8691	794	15	909	909	CD
8691	794	16	.	.	.
8691	794	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	795	1	Two	two	CD
8691	795	2	of	of	IN
8691	795	3	these	these	DT
8691	795	4	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	795	5	were	be	VBD
8691	795	6	confined	confine	VBN
8691	795	7	to	to	IN
8691	795	8	the	the	DT
8691	795	9	precise	precise	JJ
8691	795	10	point	point	NN
8691	795	11	of	of	IN
8691	795	12	law	law	NN
8691	795	13	on	on	IN
8691	795	14	which	which	WDT
8691	795	15	the	the	DT
8691	795	16	case	case	NN
8691	795	17	turned	turn	VBD
8691	795	18	.	.	.
8691	796	1	In	in	IN
8691	796	2	the	the	DT
8691	796	3	third	third	JJ
8691	796	4	,	,	,
8691	796	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	796	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	796	7	Holt	Holt	NNP
8691	796	8	seized	seize	VBD
8691	796	9	the	the	DT
8691	796	10	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	796	11	to	to	TO
8691	796	12	lay	lay	VB
8691	796	13	down	down	RP
8691	796	14	the	the	DT
8691	796	15	law	law	NN
8691	796	16	of	of	IN
8691	796	17	England	England	NNP
8691	796	18	as	as	IN
8691	796	19	to	to	IN
8691	796	20	all	all	DT
8691	796	21	sorts	sort	NNS
8691	796	22	of	of	IN
8691	796	23	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	796	24	arising	arise	VBG
8691	796	25	out	out	IN
8691	796	26	of	of	IN
8691	796	27	the	the	DT
8691	796	28	reception	reception	NN
8691	796	29	by	by	IN
8691	796	30	one	one	CD
8691	796	31	man	man	NN
8691	796	32	of	of	IN
8691	796	33	the	the	DT
8691	796	34	goods	good	NNS
8691	796	35	of	of	IN
8691	796	36	another	another	DT
8691	796	37	.	.	.
8691	797	1	This	this	DT
8691	797	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	797	3	did	do	VBD
8691	797	4	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	797	5	by	by	IN
8691	797	6	setting	set	VBG
8691	797	7	forth	forth	RP
8691	797	8	what	what	WP
8691	797	9	were	be	VBD
8691	797	10	the	the	DT
8691	797	11	rules	rule	NNS
8691	797	12	of	of	IN
8691	797	13	the	the	DT
8691	797	14	Roman	roman	JJ
8691	797	15	law	law	NN
8691	797	16	on	on	IN
8691	797	17	the	the	DT
8691	797	18	subject	subject	NN
8691	797	19	,	,	,
8691	797	20	but	but	CC
8691	797	21	not	not	RB
8691	797	22	referring	refer	VBG
8691	797	23	to	to	IN
8691	797	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	797	25	Roman	roman	JJ
8691	797	26	origin	origin	NN
8691	797	27	,	,	,
8691	797	28	and	and	CC
8691	797	29	quoting	quote	VBG
8691	797	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	797	31	,	,	,
8691	797	32	so	so	RB
8691	797	33	far	far	RB
8691	797	34	as	as	IN
8691	797	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	797	36	could	could	MD
8691	797	37	,	,	,
8691	797	38	from	from	IN
8691	797	39	Bracton	Bracton	NNP
8691	797	40	,	,	,
8691	797	41	an	an	DT
8691	797	42	English	english	JJ
8691	797	43	legal	legal	JJ
8691	797	44	writer	writer	NN
8691	797	45	of	of	IN
8691	797	46	the	the	DT
8691	797	47	thirteenth	thirteenth	JJ
8691	797	48	century	century	NN
8691	797	49	,	,	,
8691	797	50	who	who	WP
8691	797	51	had	have	VBD
8691	797	52	also	also	RB
8691	797	53	stated	state	VBN
8691	797	54	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	797	55	as	as	IN
8691	797	56	English	English	NNP
8691	797	57	law	law	NN
8691	797	58	.	.	.
8691	798	1	For	for	IN
8691	798	2	four	four	CD
8691	798	3	or	or	CC
8691	798	4	five	five	CD
8691	798	5	centuries	century	NNS
8691	798	6	these	these	DT
8691	798	7	rules	rule	NNS
8691	798	8	had	have	VBD
8691	798	9	been	be	VBN
8691	798	10	laid	lay	VBN
8691	798	11	down	down	RP
8691	798	12	in	in	IN
8691	798	13	an	an	DT
8691	798	14	unofficial	unofficial	JJ
8691	798	15	treatise	treatise	NN
8691	798	16	,	,	,
8691	798	17	but	but	CC
8691	798	18	the	the	DT
8691	798	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	798	20	had	have	VBD
8691	798	21	not	not	RB
8691	798	22	fully	fully	RB
8691	798	23	recognized	recognize	VBN
8691	798	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	798	25	.	.	.
8691	799	1	Now	now	RB
8691	799	2	the	the	DT
8691	799	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	799	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	799	5	of	of	IN
8691	799	6	England	England	NNP
8691	799	7	had	have	VBD
8691	799	8	given	give	VBN
8691	799	9	such	such	JJ
8691	799	10	recognition	recognition	NN
8691	799	11	in	in	IN
8691	799	12	the	the	DT
8691	799	13	amplest	amplest	NN
8691	799	14	manner	manner	NN
8691	799	15	.	.	.
8691	800	1	Meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
8691	800	2	the	the	DT
8691	800	3	trade	trade	NN
8691	800	4	of	of	IN
8691	800	5	England	England	NNP
8691	800	6	had	have	VBD
8691	800	7	reached	reach	VBN
8691	800	8	a	a	DT
8691	800	9	point	point	NN
8691	800	10	at	at	IN
8691	800	11	which	which	WDT
8691	800	12	some	some	DT
8691	800	13	definite	definite	JJ
8691	800	14	rules	rule	NNS
8691	800	15	on	on	IN
8691	800	16	all	all	PDT
8691	800	17	these	these	DT
8691	800	18	matters	matter	NNS
8691	800	19	had	have	VBD
8691	800	20	become	become	VBN
8691	800	21	of	of	IN
8691	800	22	the	the	DT
8691	800	23	utmost	utmost	JJ
8691	800	24	importance	importance	NN
8691	800	25	.	.	.
8691	801	1	The	the	DT
8691	801	2	bar	bar	NN
8691	801	3	were	be	VBD
8691	801	4	only	only	RB
8691	801	5	too	too	RB
8691	801	6	glad	glad	JJ
8691	801	7	to	to	TO
8691	801	8	advise	advise	VB
8691	801	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	801	10	clients	client	NNS
8691	801	11	in	in	IN
8691	801	12	accordance	accordance	NN
8691	801	13	with	with	IN
8691	801	14	Lord	Lord	NNP
8691	801	15	Holt	Holt	NNP
8691	801	16	's	's	POS
8691	801	17	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	801	18	.	.	.
8691	802	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	802	2	was	be	VBD
8691	802	3	not	not	RB
8691	802	4	long	long	JJ
8691	802	5	before	before	IN
8691	802	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	802	7	was	be	VBD
8691	802	8	universally	universally	RB
8691	802	9	practiced	practice	VBN
8691	802	10	upon	upon	IN
8691	802	11	,	,	,
8691	802	12	and	and	CC
8691	802	13	no	no	DT
8691	802	14	case	case	NN
8691	802	15	in	in	IN
8691	802	16	the	the	DT
8691	802	17	English	english	JJ
8691	802	18	language	language	NN
8691	802	19	touching	touching	JJ
8691	802	20	contract	contract	NN
8691	802	21	relations	relation	NNS
8691	802	22	of	of	IN
8691	802	23	that	that	DT
8691	802	24	nature	nature	NN
8691	802	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	802	26	of	of	IN
8691	802	27	greater	great	JJR
8691	802	28	importance	importance	NN
8691	802	29	as	as	IN
8691	802	30	a	a	DT
8691	802	31	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	802	32	.	.	.
8691	803	1	Yet	yet	CC
8691	803	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	803	3	became	become	VBD
8691	803	4	such	such	JJ
8691	803	5	not	not	RB
8691	803	6	because	because	IN
8691	803	7	of	of	IN
8691	803	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	803	9	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
8691	803	10	authority	authority	NN
8691	803	11	as	as	IN
8691	803	12	a	a	DT
8691	803	13	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	803	14	,	,	,
8691	803	15	so	so	RB
8691	803	16	much	much	RB
8691	803	17	as	as	IN
8691	803	18	on	on	IN
8691	803	19	account	account	NN
8691	803	20	of	of	IN
8691	803	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	803	22	orderly	orderly	JJ
8691	803	23	and	and	CC
8691	803	24	scientific	scientific	JJ
8691	803	25	statement	statement	NN
8691	803	26	of	of	IN
8691	803	27	a	a	DT
8691	803	28	whole	whole	JJ
8691	803	29	body	body	NN
8691	803	30	of	of	IN
8691	803	31	law	law	NN
8691	803	32	of	of	IN
8691	803	33	a	a	DT
8691	803	34	kind	kind	NN
8691	803	35	that	that	WDT
8691	803	36	the	the	DT
8691	803	37	people	people	NNS
8691	803	38	needed	need	VBD
8691	803	39	and	and	CC
8691	803	40	for	for	IN
8691	803	41	the	the	DT
8691	803	42	origin	origin	NN
8691	803	43	of	of	IN
8691	803	44	which	which	WDT
8691	803	45	--	--	:
8691	803	46	whether	whether	IN
8691	803	47	at	at	IN
8691	803	48	Rome	Rome	NNP
8691	803	49	or	or	CC
8691	803	50	London	London	NNP
8691	803	51	--	--	:
8691	803	52	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	803	53	cared	care	VBD
8691	803	54	little	little	JJ
8691	803	55	,	,	,
8691	803	56	so	so	RB
8691	803	57	long	long	RB
8691	803	58	as	as	IN
8691	803	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	803	60	had	have	VBD
8691	803	61	been	be	VBN
8691	803	62	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	803	63	by	by	IN
8691	803	64	the	the	DT
8691	803	65	highest	high	JJS
8691	803	66	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	803	67	authority	authority	NN
8691	803	68	in	in	IN
8691	803	69	the	the	DT
8691	803	70	realm	realm	NN
8691	803	71	.	.	.
8691	804	1	On	on	IN
8691	804	2	the	the	DT
8691	804	3	other	other	JJ
8691	804	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	804	5	,	,	,
8691	804	6	the	the	DT
8691	804	7	greatest	great	JJS
8691	804	8	judges	judge	NNS
8691	804	9	have	have	VBP
8691	804	10	often	often	RB
8691	804	11	,	,	,
8691	804	12	in	in	IN
8691	804	13	delivering	deliver	VBG
8691	804	14	the	the	DT
8691	804	15	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	804	16	of	of	IN
8691	804	17	the	the	DT
8691	804	18	court	court	NN
8691	804	19	,	,	,
8691	804	20	asserted	assert	VBD
8691	804	21	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
8691	804	22	the	the	DT
8691	804	23	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	804	24	of	of	IN
8691	804	25	which	which	WDT
8691	804	26	was	be	VBD
8691	804	27	not	not	RB
8691	804	28	essential	essential	JJ
8691	804	29	to	to	IN
8691	804	30	the	the	DT
8691	804	31	decision	decision	NN
8691	804	32	,	,	,
8691	804	33	and	and	CC
8691	804	34	later	later	RB
8691	804	35	retracted	retract	VBD
8691	804	36	the	the	DT
8691	804	37	assertion	assertion	NN
8691	804	38	on	on	IN
8691	804	39	fuller	full	JJR
8691	804	40	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	804	41	or	or	CC
8691	804	42	seen	see	VBN
8691	804	43	the	the	DT
8691	804	44	court	court	NN
8691	804	45	in	in	IN
8691	804	46	a	a	DT
8691	804	47	later	later	JJ
8691	804	48	case	case	NN
8691	804	49	retract	retract	VB
8691	804	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	804	51	for	for	IN
8691	804	52	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	804	53	.	.	.
8691	805	1	Two	two	CD
8691	805	2	of	of	IN
8691	805	3	the	the	DT
8691	805	4	great	great	JJ
8691	805	5	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	805	6	of	of	IN
8691	805	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	805	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	805	9	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	805	10	are	be	VBP
8691	805	11	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
8691	805	12	_	_	NNP
8691	805	13	v.	v.	IN
8691	805	14	_	_	NNP
8691	805	15	Madison[Footnote	madison[footnote	NN
8691	805	16	:	:	:
8691	805	17	1	1	CD
8691	805	18	Cranch	Cranch	NNP
8691	805	19	's	's	POS
8691	805	20	Reports	report	NNS
8691	805	21	,	,	,
8691	805	22	137	137	CD
8691	805	23	.	.	.
8691	805	24	]	]	-RRB-
8691	806	1	and	and	CC
8691	806	2	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
8691	806	3	_	_	NNP
8691	806	4	v.	v.	IN
8691	806	5	_	_	NNP
8691	806	6	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	806	7	.	.	.
8691	807	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	807	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	807	3	:	:	:
8691	807	4	6	6	CD
8691	807	5	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	807	6	's	's	POS
8691	807	7	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	807	8	,	,	,
8691	807	9	264	264	CD
8691	807	10	.	.	.
8691	807	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	808	1	In	in	IN
8691	808	2	the	the	DT
8691	808	3	first	first	JJ
8691	808	4	the	the	DT
8691	808	5	court	court	NN
8691	808	6	held	hold	VBD
8691	808	7	that	that	IN
8691	808	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	808	9	had	have	VBD
8691	808	10	no	no	DT
8691	808	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	808	12	to	to	TO
8691	808	13	command	command	VB
8691	808	14	the	the	DT
8691	808	15	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
8691	808	16	of	of	IN
8691	808	17	State	State	NNP
8691	808	18	to	to	TO
8691	808	19	deliver	deliver	VB
8691	808	20	a	a	DT
8691	808	21	commission	commission	NN
8691	808	22	executed	execute	VBN
8691	808	23	under	under	IN
8691	808	24	the	the	DT
8691	808	25	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	808	26	administration	administration	NN
8691	808	27	,	,	,
8691	808	28	because	because	IN
8691	808	29	,	,	,
8691	808	30	although	although	IN
8691	808	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	808	32	had	have	VBD
8691	808	33	assumed	assume	VBN
8691	808	34	to	to	TO
8691	808	35	confer	confer	VB
8691	808	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	808	37	,	,	,
8691	808	38	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	808	39	had	have	VBD
8691	808	40	no	no	DT
8691	808	41	power	power	NN
8691	808	42	to	to	TO
8691	808	43	do	do	VB
8691	808	44	so	so	RB
8691	808	45	;	;	:
8691	808	46	and	and	CC
8691	808	47	in	in	IN
8691	808	48	defending	defend	VBG
8691	808	49	this	this	DT
8691	808	50	position	position	NN
8691	808	51	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	808	52	observed	observe	VBD
8691	808	53	that	that	IN
8691	808	54	the	the	DT
8691	808	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	808	56	defined	define	VBD
8691	808	57	the	the	DT
8691	808	58	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	808	59	of	of	IN
8691	808	60	the	the	DT
8691	808	61	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	808	62	Court	Court	NNP
8691	808	63	over	over	IN
8691	808	64	cases	case	NNS
8691	808	65	brought	bring	VBN
8691	808	66	there	there	RB
8691	808	67	in	in	IN
8691	808	68	the	the	DT
8691	808	69	first	first	JJ
8691	808	70	instance	instance	NN
8691	808	71	,	,	,
8691	808	72	and	and	CC
8691	808	73	that	that	IN
8691	808	74	in	in	IN
8691	808	75	this	this	DT
8691	808	76	clause	clause	NN
8691	808	77	of	of	IN
8691	808	78	the	the	DT
8691	808	79	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	808	80	affirmative	affirmative	JJ
8691	808	81	words	word	NNS
8691	808	82	had	have	VBD
8691	808	83	the	the	DT
8691	808	84	force	force	NN
8691	808	85	of	of	IN
8691	808	86	negative	negative	JJ
8691	808	87	words	word	NNS
8691	808	88	so	so	RB
8691	808	89	far	far	RB
8691	808	90	as	as	IN
8691	808	91	to	to	TO
8691	808	92	exclude	exclude	VB
8691	808	93	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	808	94	over	over	IN
8691	808	95	any	any	DT
8691	808	96	other	other	JJ
8691	808	97	cases	case	NNS
8691	808	98	than	than	IN
8691	808	99	those	those	DT
8691	808	100	specifically	specifically	RB
8691	808	101	mentioned	mention	VBN
8691	808	102	.	.	.
8691	809	1	In	in	IN
8691	809	2	the	the	DT
8691	809	3	second	second	JJ
8691	809	4	case	case	NN
8691	809	5	this	this	DT
8691	809	6	observation	observation	NN
8691	809	7	was	be	VBD
8691	809	8	relied	rely	VBN
8691	809	9	on	on	RP
8691	809	10	by	by	IN
8691	809	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	809	12	to	to	TO
8691	809	13	defeat	defeat	VB
8691	809	14	the	the	DT
8691	809	15	power	power	NN
8691	809	16	of	of	IN
8691	809	17	the	the	DT
8691	809	18	court	court	NN
8691	809	19	to	to	TO
8691	809	20	review	review	VB
8691	809	21	a	a	DT
8691	809	22	State	State	NNP
8691	809	23	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	809	24	.	.	.
8691	810	1	But	but	CC
8691	810	2	,	,	,
8691	810	3	said	say	VBD
8691	810	4	the	the	DT
8691	810	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	810	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	810	7	,	,	,
8691	810	8	"	"	``
8691	810	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	810	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	810	11	a	a	DT
8691	810	12	maxim	maxim	NN
8691	810	13	not	not	RB
8691	810	14	to	to	TO
8691	810	15	be	be	VB
8691	810	16	disregarded	disregard	VBN
8691	810	17	that	that	IN
8691	810	18	general	general	JJ
8691	810	19	expressions	expression	NNS
8691	810	20	in	in	IN
8691	810	21	every	every	DT
8691	810	22	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	810	23	are	be	VBP
8691	810	24	to	to	TO
8691	810	25	be	be	VB
8691	810	26	taken	take	VBN
8691	810	27	in	in	IN
8691	810	28	connection	connection	NN
8691	810	29	with	with	IN
8691	810	30	the	the	DT
8691	810	31	case	case	NN
8691	810	32	in	in	IN
8691	810	33	which	which	WDT
8691	810	34	those	those	DT
8691	810	35	expressions	expression	NNS
8691	810	36	are	be	VBP
8691	810	37	used	use	VBN
8691	810	38	.	.	.
8691	811	1	If	if	IN
8691	811	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	811	3	go	go	VBP
8691	811	4	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	811	5	the	the	DT
8691	811	6	case	case	NN
8691	811	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	811	8	may	may	MD
8691	811	9	be	be	VB
8691	811	10	respected	respect	VBN
8691	811	11	,	,	,
8691	811	12	but	but	CC
8691	811	13	ought	ought	MD
8691	811	14	not	not	RB
8691	811	15	to	to	TO
8691	811	16	control	control	VB
8691	811	17	the	the	DT
8691	811	18	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	811	19	in	in	IN
8691	811	20	a	a	DT
8691	811	21	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	811	22	suit	suit	NN
8691	811	23	when	when	WRB
8691	811	24	the	the	DT
8691	811	25	very	very	JJ
8691	811	26	point	point	NN
8691	811	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	811	28	presented	present	VBN
8691	811	29	for	for	IN
8691	811	30	decision	decision	NN
8691	811	31	....	....	.
8691	812	1	In	in	IN
8691	812	2	the	the	DT
8691	812	3	case	case	NN
8691	812	4	of	of	IN
8691	812	5	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
8691	812	6	_	_	NNP
8691	812	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	812	8	_	_	NNP
8691	812	9	Madison	Madison	NNP
8691	812	10	,	,	,
8691	812	11	the	the	DT
8691	812	12	single	single	JJ
8691	812	13	question	question	NN
8691	812	14	before	before	IN
8691	812	15	the	the	DT
8691	812	16	court	court	NN
8691	812	17	,	,	,
8691	812	18	so	so	RB
8691	812	19	far	far	RB
8691	812	20	as	as	IN
8691	812	21	that	that	DT
8691	812	22	case	case	NN
8691	812	23	can	can	MD
8691	812	24	be	be	VB
8691	812	25	applied	apply	VBN
8691	812	26	to	to	IN
8691	812	27	this	this	DT
8691	812	28	,	,	,
8691	812	29	was	be	VBD
8691	812	30	whether	whether	IN
8691	812	31	the	the	DT
8691	812	32	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	812	33	could	could	MD
8691	812	34	give	give	VB
8691	812	35	this	this	DT
8691	812	36	court	court	NN
8691	812	37	original	original	JJ
8691	812	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	812	39	in	in	IN
8691	812	40	a	a	DT
8691	812	41	case	case	NN
8691	812	42	in	in	IN
8691	812	43	which	which	WDT
8691	812	44	the	the	DT
8691	812	45	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	812	46	had	have	VBD
8691	812	47	clearly	clearly	RB
8691	812	48	not	not	RB
8691	812	49	given	give	VBN
8691	812	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	812	51	,	,	,
8691	812	52	and	and	CC
8691	812	53	in	in	IN
8691	812	54	which	which	WDT
8691	812	55	no	no	RB
8691	812	56	doubt	doubt	RB
8691	812	57	respecting	respect	VBG
8691	812	58	the	the	DT
8691	812	59	construction	construction	NN
8691	812	60	of	of	IN
8691	812	61	the	the	DT
8691	812	62	article	article	NN
8691	812	63	could	could	MD
8691	812	64	possibly	possibly	RB
8691	812	65	be	be	VB
8691	812	66	raised	raise	VBN
8691	812	67	.	.	.
8691	813	1	The	the	DT
8691	813	2	court	court	NN
8691	813	3	decided	decide	VBD
8691	813	4	,	,	,
8691	813	5	and	and	CC
8691	813	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	813	7	think	think	VBP
8691	813	8	very	very	RB
8691	813	9	properly	properly	RB
8691	813	10	,	,	,
8691	813	11	that	that	IN
8691	813	12	the	the	DT
8691	813	13	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	813	14	could	could	MD
8691	813	15	not	not	RB
8691	813	16	give	give	VB
8691	813	17	original	original	JJ
8691	813	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	813	19	in	in	IN
8691	813	20	such	such	PDT
8691	813	21	a	a	DT
8691	813	22	case	case	NN
8691	813	23	.	.	.
8691	814	1	But	but	CC
8691	814	2	in	in	IN
8691	814	3	the	the	DT
8691	814	4	reasoning	reasoning	NN
8691	814	5	of	of	IN
8691	814	6	the	the	DT
8691	814	7	court	court	NN
8691	814	8	in	in	IN
8691	814	9	support	support	NN
8691	814	10	of	of	IN
8691	814	11	this	this	DT
8691	814	12	decision	decision	NN
8691	814	13	some	some	DT
8691	814	14	expressions	expression	NNS
8691	814	15	are	be	VBP
8691	814	16	used	use	VBN
8691	814	17	which	which	WDT
8691	814	18	go	go	VBP
8691	814	19	far	far	RB
8691	814	20	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	814	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	814	22	....	....	.
8691	815	1	The	the	DT
8691	815	2	general	general	JJ
8691	815	3	expressions	expression	NNS
8691	815	4	in	in	IN
8691	815	5	the	the	DT
8691	815	6	case	case	NN
8691	815	7	of	of	IN
8691	815	8	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
8691	815	9	_	_	NNP
8691	815	10	v.	v.	IN
8691	815	11	_	_	NNP
8691	815	12	Madison	Madison	NNP
8691	815	13	must	must	MD
8691	815	14	be	be	VB
8691	815	15	understood	understand	VBN
8691	815	16	with	with	IN
8691	815	17	the	the	DT
8691	815	18	limitations	limitation	NNS
8691	815	19	which	which	WDT
8691	815	20	are	be	VBP
8691	815	21	given	give	VBN
8691	815	22	to	to	IN
8691	815	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	815	24	in	in	IN
8691	815	25	this	this	DT
8691	815	26	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	815	27	;	;	:
8691	815	28	limitations	limitation	NNS
8691	815	29	which	which	WDT
8691	815	30	in	in	IN
8691	815	31	no	no	DT
8691	815	32	degree	degree	NN
8691	815	33	affect	affect	VB
8691	815	34	the	the	DT
8691	815	35	decision	decision	NN
8691	815	36	in	in	IN
8691	815	37	that	that	DT
8691	815	38	case	case	NN
8691	815	39	or	or	CC
8691	815	40	the	the	DT
8691	815	41	tenor	tenor	NN
8691	815	42	of	of	IN
8691	815	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	815	44	reasoning	reasoning	NN
8691	815	45	.	.	.
8691	815	46	"	"	''
8691	816	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	816	2	then	then	RB
8691	816	3	proceeded	proceed	VBD
8691	816	4	to	to	TO
8691	816	5	dispose	dispose	VB
8691	816	6	of	of	IN
8691	816	7	the	the	DT
8691	816	8	case	case	NN
8691	816	9	in	in	IN
8691	816	10	hand	hand	NN
8691	816	11	by	by	IN
8691	816	12	saying	say	VBG
8691	816	13	that	that	IN
8691	816	14	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	816	15	having	have	VBG
8691	816	16	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	816	17	an	an	DT
8691	816	18	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
8691	816	19	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	816	20	against	against	IN
8691	816	21	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
8691	816	22	,	,	,
8691	816	23	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
8691	816	24	had	have	VBD
8691	816	25	a	a	DT
8691	816	26	right	right	NN
8691	816	27	to	to	TO
8691	816	28	appeal	appeal	VB
8691	816	29	,	,	,
8691	816	30	and	and	CC
8691	816	31	the	the	DT
8691	816	32	suit	suit	NN
8691	816	33	still	still	RB
8691	816	34	remained	remain	VBD
8691	816	35	a	a	DT
8691	816	36	suit	suit	NN
8691	816	37	by	by	IN
8691	816	38	a	a	DT
8691	816	39	State	State	NNP
8691	816	40	against	against	IN
8691	816	41	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	816	42	and	and	CC
8691	816	43	not	not	RB
8691	816	44	by	by	IN
8691	816	45	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	816	46	against	against	IN
8691	816	47	a	a	DT
8691	816	48	State	state	NN
8691	816	49	.	.	.
8691	817	1	Unfortunately	unfortunately	RB
8691	817	2	,	,	,
8691	817	3	here	here	RB
8691	817	4	again	again	RB
8691	817	5	came	come	VBD
8691	817	6	in	in	RP
8691	817	7	next	next	IN
8691	817	8	an	an	DT
8691	817	9	_	_	NNP
8691	817	10	obiter	obiter	NN
8691	817	11	dictum	dictum	NN
8691	817	12	_	_	NNP
8691	817	13	.	.	.
8691	818	1	If	if	IN
8691	818	2	,	,	,
8691	818	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	818	4	said	say	VBD
8691	818	5	,	,	,
8691	818	6	this	this	DT
8691	818	7	were	be	VBD
8691	818	8	not	not	RB
8691	818	9	so	so	RB
8691	818	10	,	,	,
8691	818	11	there	there	EX
8691	818	12	was	be	VBD
8691	818	13	another	another	DT
8691	818	14	principle	principle	NN
8691	818	15	equally	equally	RB
8691	818	16	decisive	decisive	JJ
8691	818	17	in	in	IN
8691	818	18	support	support	NN
8691	818	19	of	of	IN
8691	818	20	the	the	DT
8691	818	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	818	22	,	,	,
8691	818	23	namely	namely	RB
8691	818	24	,	,	,
8691	818	25	that	that	IN
8691	818	26	the	the	DT
8691	818	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	818	28	gave	give	VBD
8691	818	29	the	the	DT
8691	818	30	United	United	NNP
8691	818	31	States	States	NNP
8691	818	32	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	818	33	power	power	NN
8691	818	34	over	over	IN
8691	818	35	all	all	DT
8691	818	36	cases	case	NNS
8691	818	37	arising	arise	VBG
8691	818	38	under	under	IN
8691	818	39	the	the	DT
8691	818	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	818	41	or	or	CC
8691	818	42	laws	law	NNS
8691	818	43	of	of	IN
8691	818	44	the	the	DT
8691	818	45	United	United	NNP
8691	818	46	States	States	NNP
8691	818	47	without	without	IN
8691	818	48	respect	respect	NN
8691	818	49	to	to	IN
8691	818	50	parties	party	NNS
8691	818	51	.	.	.
8691	819	1	Nearly	nearly	RB
8691	819	2	a	a	DT
8691	819	3	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	819	4	years	year	NNS
8691	819	5	later	later	RB
8691	819	6	a	a	DT
8691	819	7	State	state	NN
8691	819	8	was	be	VBD
8691	819	9	sued	sue	VBN
8691	819	10	in	in	IN
8691	819	11	the	the	DT
8691	819	12	courts	court	NNS
8691	819	13	of	of	IN
8691	819	14	the	the	DT
8691	819	15	United	United	NNP
8691	819	16	States	States	NNP
8691	819	17	on	on	IN
8691	819	18	a	a	DT
8691	819	19	cause	cause	NN
8691	819	20	of	of	IN
8691	819	21	action	action	NN
8691	819	22	arising	arise	VBG
8691	819	23	under	under	IN
8691	819	24	the	the	DT
8691	819	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	819	26	,	,	,
8691	819	27	and	and	CC
8691	819	28	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
8691	819	29	_	_	NNP
8691	819	30	v.	v.	IN
8691	819	31	_	_	NNP
8691	819	32	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	819	33	was	be	VBD
8691	819	34	relied	rely	VBN
8691	819	35	on	on	IN
8691	819	36	as	as	IN
8691	819	37	a	a	DT
8691	819	38	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	819	39	.	.	.
8691	820	1	"	"	``
8691	820	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	820	3	must	must	MD
8691	820	4	be	be	VB
8691	820	5	conceded	concede	VBN
8691	820	6	,	,	,
8691	820	7	"	"	``
8691	820	8	was	be	VBD
8691	820	9	the	the	DT
8691	820	10	reply	reply	NN
8691	820	11	of	of	IN
8691	820	12	the	the	DT
8691	820	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	820	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	820	15	,	,	,
8691	820	16	"	"	''
8691	820	17	that	that	IN
8691	820	18	the	the	DT
8691	820	19	last	last	JJ
8691	820	20	observation	observation	NN
8691	820	21	of	of	IN
8691	820	22	the	the	DT
8691	820	23	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	820	24	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	820	25	does	do	VBZ
8691	820	26	favor	favor	VB
8691	820	27	the	the	DT
8691	820	28	argument	argument	NN
8691	820	29	of	of	IN
8691	820	30	the	the	DT
8691	820	31	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	820	32	.	.	.
8691	821	1	But	but	CC
8691	821	2	the	the	DT
8691	821	3	observation	observation	NN
8691	821	4	was	be	VBD
8691	821	5	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
8691	821	6	to	to	IN
8691	821	7	the	the	DT
8691	821	8	decision	decision	NN
8691	821	9	,	,	,
8691	821	10	and	and	CC
8691	821	11	in	in	IN
8691	821	12	that	that	DT
8691	821	13	sense	sense	NN
8691	821	14	extra	extra	JJ
8691	821	15	-	-	:
8691	821	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	821	17	,	,	,
8691	821	18	and	and	CC
8691	821	19	though	though	IN
8691	821	20	made	make	VBN
8691	821	21	by	by	IN
8691	821	22	one	one	CD
8691	821	23	who	who	WP
8691	821	24	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	821	25	used	use	VBD
8691	821	26	words	word	NNS
8691	821	27	without	without	IN
8691	821	28	due	due	JJ
8691	821	29	reflection	reflection	NN
8691	821	30	,	,	,
8691	821	31	ought	ought	MD
8691	821	32	not	not	RB
8691	821	33	to	to	TO
8691	821	34	outweigh	outweigh	VB
8691	821	35	the	the	DT
8691	821	36	important	important	JJ
8691	821	37	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	821	38	referred	refer	VBD
8691	821	39	to	to	TO
8691	821	40	which	which	WDT
8691	821	41	lead	lead	VB
8691	821	42	to	to	IN
8691	821	43	a	a	DT
8691	821	44	different	different	JJ
8691	821	45	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	821	46	.	.	.
8691	822	1	"	"	``
8691	822	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	822	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	822	4	:	:	:
8691	822	5	Hans	Hans	NNP
8691	822	6	_	_	NNP
8691	822	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	822	8	_	_	NNP
8691	822	9	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	822	10	,	,	,
8691	822	11	134	134	CD
8691	822	12	United	United	NNP
8691	822	13	States	States	NNP
8691	822	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	822	15	,	,	,
8691	822	16	1	1	CD
8691	822	17	,	,	,
8691	822	18	20	20	CD
8691	822	19	.	.	.
8691	822	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	823	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	823	2	may	may	MD
8691	823	3	be	be	VB
8691	823	4	added	add	VBN
8691	823	5	that	that	IN
8691	823	6	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	823	7	on	on	IN
8691	823	8	a	a	DT
8691	823	9	point	point	NN
8691	823	10	not	not	RB
8691	823	11	material	material	JJ
8691	823	12	to	to	IN
8691	823	13	the	the	DT
8691	823	14	cause	cause	NN
8691	823	15	are	be	VBP
8691	823	16	generally	generally	RB
8691	823	17	made	make	VBN
8691	823	18	without	without	IN
8691	823	19	the	the	DT
8691	823	20	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	823	21	of	of	IN
8691	823	22	previous	previous	JJ
8691	823	23	argument	argument	NN
8691	823	24	by	by	IN
8691	823	25	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	823	26	.	.	.
8691	824	1	The	the	DT
8691	824	2	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	824	3	will	will	MD
8691	824	4	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	824	5	address	address	VB
8691	824	6	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	824	7	to	to	IN
8691	824	8	the	the	DT
8691	824	9	controlling	control	VBG
8691	824	10	questions	question	NNS
8691	824	11	,	,	,
8691	824	12	and	and	CC
8691	824	13	if	if	IN
8691	824	14	well	well	RB
8691	824	15	trained	trained	JJ
8691	824	16	will	will	MD
8691	824	17	see	see	VB
8691	824	18	what	what	WP
8691	824	19	these	these	DT
8691	824	20	are	be	VBP
8691	824	21	quite	quite	RB
8691	824	22	as	as	RB
8691	824	23	clearly	clearly	RB
8691	824	24	as	as	IN
8691	824	25	the	the	DT
8691	824	26	court	court	NN
8691	824	27	.	.	.
8691	825	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	825	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	825	3	the	the	DT
8691	825	4	argument	argument	NN
8691	825	5	at	at	IN
8691	825	6	the	the	DT
8691	825	7	bar	bar	NN
8691	825	8	,	,	,
8691	825	9	in	in	IN
8691	825	10	which	which	WDT
8691	825	11	different	different	JJ
8691	825	12	views	view	NNS
8691	825	13	of	of	IN
8691	825	14	law	law	NN
8691	825	15	are	be	VBP
8691	825	16	presented	present	VBN
8691	825	17	and	and	CC
8691	825	18	each	each	DT
8691	825	19	defended	defend	VBN
8691	825	20	by	by	IN
8691	825	21	men	man	NNS
8691	825	22	of	of	IN
8691	825	23	learning	learning	NN
8691	825	24	and	and	CC
8691	825	25	ability	ability	NN
8691	825	26	,	,	,
8691	825	27	which	which	WDT
8691	825	28	enables	enable	VBZ
8691	825	29	the	the	DT
8691	825	30	judge	judge	NN
8691	825	31	,	,	,
8691	825	32	after	after	IN
8691	825	33	hearing	hear	VBG
8691	825	34	both	both	DT
8691	825	35	sides	side	NNS
8691	825	36	and	and	CC
8691	825	37	weighing	weigh	VBG
8691	825	38	all	all	DT
8691	825	39	that	that	WDT
8691	825	40	is	be	VBZ
8691	825	41	said	say	VBN
8691	825	42	in	in	IN
8691	825	43	behalf	behalf	NN
8691	825	44	of	of	IN
8691	825	45	one	one	CD
8691	825	46	against	against	IN
8691	825	47	all	all	DT
8691	825	48	that	that	WDT
8691	825	49	is	be	VBZ
8691	825	50	said	say	VBN
8691	825	51	in	in	IN
8691	825	52	behalf	behalf	NN
8691	825	53	of	of	IN
8691	825	54	the	the	DT
8691	825	55	other	other	JJ
8691	825	56	,	,	,
8691	825	57	to	to	TO
8691	825	58	come	come	VB
8691	825	59	to	to	IN
8691	825	60	the	the	DT
8691	825	61	true	true	JJ
8691	825	62	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	825	63	.	.	.
8691	826	1	The	the	DT
8691	826	2	Romans	Romans	NNPS
8691	826	3	recognized	recognize	VBD
8691	826	4	this	this	DT
8691	826	5	in	in	IN
8691	826	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	826	7	rule	rule	NN
8691	826	8	as	as	IN
8691	826	9	to	to	IN
8691	826	10	the	the	DT
8691	826	11	force	force	NN
8691	826	12	of	of	IN
8691	826	13	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	826	14	in	in	IN
8691	826	15	a	a	DT
8691	826	16	matter	matter	NN
8691	826	17	of	of	IN
8691	826	18	customary	customary	JJ
8691	826	19	law	law	NN
8691	826	20	.	.	.
8691	827	1	The	the	DT
8691	827	2	first	first	JJ
8691	827	3	thing	thing	NN
8691	827	4	to	to	TO
8691	827	5	ask	ask	VB
8691	827	6	was	be	VBD
8691	827	7	whether	whether	IN
8691	827	8	"	"	``
8691	827	9	_	_	NNP
8691	827	10	contradicto	contradicto	NNP
8691	827	11	aliquando	aliquando	NNP
8691	827	12	judicio	judicio	NNP
8691	827	13	consuetudo	consuetudo	NNP
8691	827	14	firmata	firmata	NNP
8691	827	15	sit	sit	NNP
8691	827	16	_	_	NNP
8691	827	17	.	.	.
8691	828	1	"	"	``
8691	828	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	828	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	828	4	:	:	:
8691	828	5	"	"	``
8691	828	6	Digest	Digest	NNP
8691	828	7	,	,	,
8691	828	8	"	"	''
8691	828	9	1	1	CD
8691	828	10	,	,	,
8691	828	11	3	3	CD
8691	828	12	,	,	,
8691	828	13	_	_	NNP
8691	828	14	de	de	NNP
8691	828	15	legibus	legibus	NNP
8691	828	16	_	_	NNP
8691	828	17	,	,	,
8691	828	18	etc	etc	FW
8691	828	19	.	.	FW
8691	828	20	,	,	,
8691	828	21	34	34	CD
8691	828	22	.	.	.
8691	828	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	829	1	The	the	DT
8691	829	2	retrospective	retrospective	JJ
8691	829	3	effect	effect	NN
8691	829	4	which	which	WDT
8691	829	5	a	a	DT
8691	829	6	refusal	refusal	NN
8691	829	7	to	to	TO
8691	829	8	follow	follow	VB
8691	829	9	a	a	DT
8691	829	10	former	former	JJ
8691	829	11	decision	decision	NN
8691	829	12	may	may	MD
8691	829	13	have	have	VB
8691	829	14	in	in	IN
8691	829	15	disturbing	disturb	VBG
8691	829	16	vested	vested	JJ
8691	829	17	rights	right	NNS
8691	829	18	being	be	VBG
8691	829	19	one	one	CD
8691	829	20	of	of	IN
8691	829	21	the	the	DT
8691	829	22	most	most	RBS
8691	829	23	cogent	cogent	JJ
8691	829	24	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	829	25	for	for	IN
8691	829	26	adhering	adhere	VBG
8691	829	27	to	to	IN
8691	829	28	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	829	29	,	,	,
8691	829	30	there	there	EX
8691	829	31	is	be	VBZ
8691	829	32	less	less	JJR
8691	829	33	objection	objection	NN
8691	829	34	to	to	IN
8691	829	35	departing	depart	VBG
8691	829	36	from	from	IN
8691	829	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	829	38	when	when	WRB
8691	829	39	the	the	DT
8691	829	40	decision	decision	NN
8691	829	41	can	can	MD
8691	829	42	be	be	VB
8691	829	43	so	so	RB
8691	829	44	limited	limited	JJ
8691	829	45	as	as	IN
8691	829	46	to	to	TO
8691	829	47	have	have	VB
8691	829	48	only	only	RB
8691	829	49	a	a	DT
8691	829	50	future	future	JJ
8691	829	51	operation	operation	NN
8691	829	52	.	.	.
8691	830	1	This	this	DT
8691	830	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	830	3	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	830	4	feasible	feasible	JJ
8691	830	5	.	.	.
8691	831	1	Thus	thus	RB
8691	831	2	the	the	DT
8691	831	3	High	High	NNP
8691	831	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	831	5	of	of	IN
8691	831	6	Errors	Errors	NNPS
8691	831	7	and	and	CC
8691	831	8	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	831	9	of	of	IN
8691	831	10	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	831	11	by	by	IN
8691	831	12	an	an	DT
8691	831	13	early	early	JJ
8691	831	14	decision	decision	NN
8691	831	15	held	hold	VBN
8691	831	16	that	that	IN
8691	831	17	on	on	IN
8691	831	18	the	the	DT
8691	831	19	dissolution	dissolution	NN
8691	831	20	of	of	IN
8691	831	21	a	a	DT
8691	831	22	bank	bank	NN
8691	831	23	all	all	PDT
8691	831	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	831	25	rights	right	NNS
8691	831	26	and	and	CC
8691	831	27	liabilities	liability	NNS
8691	831	28	were	be	VBD
8691	831	29	extinguished	extinguish	VBN
8691	831	30	.	.	.
8691	832	1	Thirty	thirty	CD
8691	832	2	years	year	NNS
8691	832	3	later	later	RBR
8691	832	4	the	the	DT
8691	832	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	832	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	832	7	of	of	IN
8691	832	8	the	the	DT
8691	832	9	same	same	JJ
8691	832	10	State	State	NNP
8691	832	11	overruled	overrule	VBD
8691	832	12	that	that	DT
8691	832	13	decision	decision	NN
8691	832	14	,	,	,
8691	832	15	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	832	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	832	17	"	"	``
8691	832	18	condemned	condemn	VBN
8691	832	19	by	by	IN
8691	832	20	reason	reason	NN
8691	832	21	and	and	CC
8691	832	22	the	the	DT
8691	832	23	principles	principle	NNS
8691	832	24	of	of	IN
8691	832	25	modern	modern	JJ
8691	832	26	and	and	CC
8691	832	27	enlightened	enlighten	VBN
8691	832	28	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	832	29	,	,	,
8691	832	30	"	"	''
8691	832	31	but	but	CC
8691	832	32	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
8691	832	33	applied	apply	VBD
8691	832	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	832	35	as	as	IN
8691	832	36	a	a	DT
8691	832	37	controlling	control	VBG
8691	832	38	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	832	39	to	to	IN
8691	832	40	a	a	DT
8691	832	41	case	case	NN
8691	832	42	arising	arise	VBG
8691	832	43	out	out	IN
8691	832	44	of	of	IN
8691	832	45	the	the	DT
8691	832	46	dissolution	dissolution	NN
8691	832	47	of	of	IN
8691	832	48	a	a	DT
8691	832	49	bank	bank	NN
8691	832	50	which	which	WDT
8691	832	51	had	have	VBD
8691	832	52	been	be	VBN
8691	832	53	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
8691	832	54	previously	previously	RB
8691	832	55	to	to	IN
8691	832	56	the	the	DT
8691	832	57	time	time	NN
8691	832	58	when	when	WRB
8691	832	59	the	the	DT
8691	832	60	original	original	JJ
8691	832	61	decision	decision	NN
8691	832	62	was	be	VBD
8691	832	63	made	make	VBN
8691	832	64	.	.	.
8691	833	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	833	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	833	3	:	:	:
8691	833	4	1	1	CD
8691	833	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	833	6	of	of	IN
8691	833	7	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	833	8	_	_	NNP
8691	833	9	v.	v.	IN
8691	833	10	_	_	NNP
8691	833	11	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
8691	833	12	,	,	,
8691	833	13	56	56	CD
8691	833	14	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	833	15	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	833	16	,	,	,
8691	833	17	165	165	CD
8691	833	18	.	.	.
8691	833	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	834	1	The	the	DT
8691	834	2	effect	effect	NN
8691	834	3	of	of	IN
8691	834	4	overruling	overrule	VBG
8691	834	5	a	a	DT
8691	834	6	former	former	JJ
8691	834	7	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	834	8	may	may	MD
8691	834	9	also	also	RB
8691	834	10	be	be	VB
8691	834	11	limited	limit	VBN
8691	834	12	by	by	IN
8691	834	13	the	the	DT
8691	834	14	dual	dual	JJ
8691	834	15	character	character	NN
8691	834	16	of	of	IN
8691	834	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	834	18	government	government	NN
8691	834	19	.	.	.
8691	835	1	The	the	DT
8691	835	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	835	3	of	of	IN
8691	835	4	the	the	DT
8691	835	5	United	United	NNP
8691	835	6	States	States	NNP
8691	835	7	follow	follow	VBP
8691	835	8	the	the	DT
8691	835	9	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	835	10	of	of	IN
8691	835	11	the	the	DT
8691	835	12	State	State	NNP
8691	835	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	835	14	in	in	IN
8691	835	15	the	the	DT
8691	835	16	determination	determination	NN
8691	835	17	of	of	IN
8691	835	18	matters	matter	NNS
8691	835	19	of	of	IN
8691	835	20	State	State	NNP
8691	835	21	law	law	NN
8691	835	22	.	.	.
8691	836	1	If	if	IN
8691	836	2	a	a	DT
8691	836	3	State	State	NNP
8691	836	4	law	law	NN
8691	836	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	836	6	held	hold	VBN
8691	836	7	by	by	IN
8691	836	8	the	the	DT
8691	836	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	836	10	of	of	IN
8691	836	11	the	the	DT
8691	836	12	State	State	NNP
8691	836	13	to	to	TO
8691	836	14	have	have	VB
8691	836	15	a	a	DT
8691	836	16	particular	particular	JJ
8691	836	17	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	836	18	and	and	CC
8691	836	19	effect	effect	NN
8691	836	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	836	21	will	will	MD
8691	836	22	be	be	VB
8691	836	23	accorded	accord	VBN
8691	836	24	the	the	DT
8691	836	25	same	same	JJ
8691	836	26	in	in	IN
8691	836	27	the	the	DT
8691	836	28	federal	federal	JJ
8691	836	29	courts	court	NNS
8691	836	30	.	.	.
8691	837	1	But	but	CC
8691	837	2	if	if	IN
8691	837	3	a	a	DT
8691	837	4	federal	federal	JJ
8691	837	5	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	837	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	837	7	for	for	IN
8691	837	8	that	that	DT
8691	837	9	reason	reason	NN
8691	837	10	rendered	render	VBN
8691	837	11	in	in	IN
8691	837	12	a	a	DT
8691	837	13	certain	certain	JJ
8691	837	14	form	form	NN
8691	837	15	,	,	,
8691	837	16	and	and	CC
8691	837	17	there	there	EX
8691	837	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	837	19	no	no	DT
8691	837	20	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	837	21	,	,	,
8691	837	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	837	23	settles	settle	VBZ
8691	837	24	the	the	DT
8691	837	25	rights	right	NNS
8691	837	26	of	of	IN
8691	837	27	the	the	DT
8691	837	28	parties	party	NNS
8691	837	29	to	to	IN
8691	837	30	the	the	DT
8691	837	31	suit	suit	NN
8691	837	32	forever	forever	RB
8691	837	33	,	,	,
8691	837	34	even	even	RB
8691	837	35	should	should	MD
8691	837	36	the	the	DT
8691	837	37	State	State	NNP
8691	837	38	courts	court	NNS
8691	837	39	afterward	afterward	RB
8691	837	40	reverse	reverse	VBP
8691	837	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	837	42	former	former	JJ
8691	837	43	rulings	ruling	NNS
8691	837	44	as	as	IN
8691	837	45	being	be	VBG
8691	837	46	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
8691	837	47	.	.	.
8691	838	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	838	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	838	3	:	:	:
8691	838	4	2	2	CD
8691	838	5	Deposit	Deposit	NNP
8691	838	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	838	7	_	_	NNP
8691	838	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	838	9	_	_	NNP
8691	838	10	Frankfort	Frankfort	NNP
8691	838	11	,	,	,
8691	838	12	191	191	CD
8691	838	13	United	United	NNP
8691	838	14	States	States	NNP
8691	838	15	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	838	16	,	,	,
8691	838	17	499	499	CD
8691	838	18	.	.	.
8691	838	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	839	1	De	De	NNP
8691	839	2	Tocqueville	Tocqueville	NNP
8691	839	3	,	,	,
8691	839	4	in	in	IN
8691	839	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	839	6	estimate	estimate	NN
8691	839	7	of	of	IN
8691	839	8	the	the	DT
8691	839	9	American	american	JJ
8691	839	10	bar,[Footnote	bar,[footnote	NN
8691	839	11	:	:	:
8691	839	12	3	3	LS
8691	839	13	"	"	``
8691	839	14	Democracy	Democracy	NNP
8691	839	15	in	in	IN
8691	839	16	America	America	NNP
8691	839	17	,	,	,
8691	839	18	"	"	''
8691	839	19	II	II	NNP
8691	839	20	,	,	,
8691	839	21	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	839	22	.	.	.
8691	840	1	XVI	XVI	NNP
8691	840	2	.	.	.
8691	840	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	841	1	speaks	speak	VBZ
8691	841	2	of	of	IN
8691	841	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	841	4	as	as	IN
8691	841	5	devoted	devoted	JJ
8691	841	6	to	to	IN
8691	841	7	investigating	investigate	VBG
8691	841	8	what	what	WP
8691	841	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	841	10	been	be	VBN
8691	841	11	done	do	VBN
8691	841	12	rather	rather	RB
8691	841	13	than	than	IN
8691	841	14	what	what	WP
8691	841	15	ought	ought	MD
8691	841	16	to	to	TO
8691	841	17	be	be	VB
8691	841	18	done	do	VBN
8691	841	19	;	;	:
8691	841	20	to	to	IN
8691	841	21	the	the	DT
8691	841	22	pursuit	pursuit	NN
8691	841	23	of	of	IN
8691	841	24	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	841	25	rather	rather	RB
8691	841	26	than	than	IN
8691	841	27	of	of	IN
8691	841	28	reason	reason	NN
8691	841	29	.	.	.
8691	842	1	In	in	IN
8691	842	2	a	a	DT
8691	842	3	very	very	RB
8691	842	4	limited	limited	JJ
8691	842	5	sense	sense	NN
8691	842	6	this	this	DT
8691	842	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	842	8	true	true	JJ
8691	842	9	.	.	.
8691	843	1	Where	where	WRB
8691	843	2	codes	code	NNS
8691	843	3	are	be	VBP
8691	843	4	wanting	want	VBG
8691	843	5	,	,	,
8691	843	6	former	former	JJ
8691	843	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	843	8	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	843	9	must	must	MD
8691	843	10	serve	serve	VB
8691	843	11	in	in	IN
8691	843	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	843	13	place	place	NN
8691	843	14	.	.	.
8691	844	1	But	but	CC
8691	844	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	844	3	would	would	MD
8691	844	4	be	be	VB
8691	844	5	a	a	DT
8691	844	6	mistake	mistake	NN
8691	844	7	to	to	TO
8691	844	8	suppose	suppose	VB
8691	844	9	that	that	IN
8691	844	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	844	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	844	12	a	a	DT
8691	844	13	large	large	JJ
8691	844	14	part	part	NN
8691	844	15	of	of	IN
8691	844	16	the	the	DT
8691	844	17	business	business	NN
8691	844	18	of	of	IN
8691	844	19	American	american	JJ
8691	844	20	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	844	21	to	to	TO
8691	844	22	search	search	VB
8691	844	23	out	out	RP
8691	844	24	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	844	25	for	for	IN
8691	844	26	the	the	DT
8691	844	27	guidance	guidance	NN
8691	844	28	of	of	IN
8691	844	29	the	the	DT
8691	844	30	courts	court	NNS
8691	844	31	.	.	.
8691	845	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	845	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	845	3	,	,	,
8691	845	4	after	after	IN
8691	845	5	any	any	DT
8691	845	6	facts	fact	NNS
8691	845	7	in	in	IN
8691	845	8	dispute	dispute	NN
8691	845	9	are	be	VBP
8691	845	10	once	once	RB
8691	845	11	settled	settle	VBN
8691	845	12	,	,	,
8691	845	13	depend	depend	VB
8691	845	14	on	on	IN
8691	845	15	the	the	DT
8691	845	16	application	application	NN
8691	845	17	of	of	IN
8691	845	18	the	the	DT
8691	845	19	simplest	simple	JJS
8691	845	20	processes	process	NNS
8691	845	21	of	of	IN
8691	845	22	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	845	23	reasoning	reasoning	NN
8691	845	24	.	.	.
8691	846	1	No	no	DT
8691	846	2	aid	aid	NN
8691	846	3	from	from	IN
8691	846	4	the	the	DT
8691	846	5	past	past	NN
8691	846	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	846	7	needed	need	VBN
8691	846	8	for	for	IN
8691	846	9	this	this	DT
8691	846	10	and	and	CC
8691	846	11	none	none	NN
8691	846	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	846	13	to	to	TO
8691	846	14	be	be	VB
8691	846	15	had	have	VBN
8691	846	16	.	.	.
8691	847	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	847	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	847	3	been	be	VBN
8691	847	4	well	well	RB
8691	847	5	said	say	VBN
8691	847	6	by	by	IN
8691	847	7	an	an	DT
8691	847	8	English	English	NNP
8691	847	9	judge[Footnote	judge[footnote	NN
8691	847	10	:	:	:
8691	847	11	1	1	CD
8691	847	12	James	James	NNP
8691	847	13	,	,	,
8691	847	14	L.	L.	NNP
8691	847	15	J.	J.	NNP
8691	847	16	,	,	,
8691	847	17	in	in	IN
8691	847	18	1875	1875	CD
8691	847	19	,	,	,
8691	847	20	Law	Law	NNP
8691	847	21	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	847	22	,	,	,
8691	847	23	10	10	CD
8691	847	24	Chancery	Chancery	NNP
8691	847	25	Appeal	Appeal	NNP
8691	847	26	Cases	case	NNS
8691	847	27	,	,	,
8691	847	28	526	526	CD
8691	847	29	.	.	.
8691	847	30	]	]	-RRB-
8691	848	1	that	that	IN
8691	848	2	the	the	DT
8691	848	3	clearer	clear	JJR
8691	848	4	a	a	DT
8691	848	5	thing	thing	NN
8691	848	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	848	7	the	the	DT
8691	848	8	more	more	RBR
8691	848	9	difficult	difficult	JJ
8691	848	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	848	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	848	12	to	to	TO
8691	848	13	find	find	VB
8691	848	14	any	any	DT
8691	848	15	express	express	JJ
8691	848	16	authority	authority	NN
8691	848	17	or	or	CC
8691	848	18	any	any	DT
8691	848	19	_	_	NNP
8691	848	20	dictum	dictum	NN
8691	848	21	_	_	NNP
8691	848	22	exactly	exactly	RB
8691	848	23	to	to	IN
8691	848	24	the	the	DT
8691	848	25	point	point	NN
8691	848	26	.	.	.
8691	849	1	Nor	nor	CC
8691	849	2	,	,	,
8691	849	3	if	if	IN
8691	849	4	there	there	EX
8691	849	5	be	be	VB
8691	849	6	one	one	CD
8691	849	7	,	,	,
8691	849	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	849	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	849	10	to	to	TO
8691	849	11	be	be	VB
8691	849	12	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	849	13	without	without	IN
8691	849	14	regard	regard	NN
8691	849	15	to	to	IN
8691	849	16	the	the	DT
8691	849	17	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	849	18	out	out	IN
8691	849	19	of	of	IN
8691	849	20	which	which	WDT
8691	849	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	849	22	arose	arise	VBD
8691	849	23	or	or	CC
8691	849	24	the	the	DT
8691	849	25	end	end	NN
8691	849	26	to	to	TO
8691	849	27	be	be	VB
8691	849	28	effected	effect	VBN
8691	849	29	by	by	IN
8691	849	30	the	the	DT
8691	849	31	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	849	32	.	.	.
8691	850	1	A	a	DT
8691	850	2	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	850	3	may	may	MD
8691	850	4	indeed	indeed	RB
8691	850	5	be	be	VB
8691	850	6	used	use	VBN
8691	850	7	slavishly	slavishly	RB
8691	850	8	,	,	,
8691	850	9	but	but	CC
8691	850	10	so	so	RB
8691	850	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	850	12	may	may	MD
8691	850	13	be	be	VB
8691	850	14	used	use	VBN
8691	850	15	in	in	IN
8691	850	16	the	the	DT
8691	850	17	free	free	JJ
8691	850	18	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	850	19	in	in	IN
8691	850	20	which	which	WDT
8691	850	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	850	22	was	be	VBD
8691	850	23	conceived	conceive	VBN
8691	850	24	.	.	.
8691	851	1	Many	many	PDT
8691	851	2	an	an	DT
8691	851	3	argument	argument	NN
8691	851	4	at	at	IN
8691	851	5	the	the	DT
8691	851	6	bar	bar	NN
8691	851	7	,	,	,
8691	851	8	however	however	RB
8691	851	9	,	,	,
8691	851	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	851	11	ruined	ruin	VBN
8691	851	12	by	by	IN
8691	851	13	an	an	DT
8691	851	14	excessive	excessive	JJ
8691	851	15	anxiety	anxiety	NN
8691	851	16	to	to	TO
8691	851	17	repeat	repeat	VB
8691	851	18	the	the	DT
8691	851	19	_	_	NNP
8691	851	20	ipsissima	ipsissima	NNP
8691	851	21	verba	verba	NNP
8691	851	22	_	_	NNP
8691	851	23	of	of	IN
8691	851	24	some	some	DT
8691	851	25	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	851	26	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	851	27	,	,	,
8691	851	28	when	when	WRB
8691	851	29	the	the	DT
8691	851	30	soul	soul	NN
8691	851	31	of	of	IN
8691	851	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	851	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	851	34	the	the	DT
8691	851	35	only	only	JJ
8691	851	36	thing	thing	NN
8691	851	37	of	of	IN
8691	851	38	value	value	NN
8691	851	39	.	.	.
8691	852	1	And	and	CC
8691	852	2	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	852	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	852	4	are	be	VBP
8691	852	5	chargeable	chargeable	JJ
8691	852	6	with	with	IN
8691	852	7	pursuing	pursue	VBG
8691	852	8	the	the	DT
8691	852	9	letter	letter	NN
8691	852	10	of	of	IN
8691	852	11	some	some	DT
8691	852	12	of	of	IN
8691	852	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	852	14	former	former	JJ
8691	852	15	deliverances	deliverance	NNS
8691	852	16	rather	rather	RB
8691	852	17	than	than	IN
8691	852	18	the	the	DT
8691	852	19	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	852	20	which	which	WDT
8691	852	21	called	call	VBD
8691	852	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	852	23	forth	forth	RB
8691	852	24	and	and	CC
8691	852	25	gave	give	VBD
8691	852	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	852	27	all	all	PDT
8691	852	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	852	29	vitality	vitality	NN
8691	852	30	.	.	.
8691	853	1	*	*	NFP
8691	853	2	*	*	NFP
8691	853	3	*	*	NFP
8691	853	4	*	*	NFP
8691	853	5	*	*	NFP
8691	853	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	853	7	V	v	NN
8691	853	8	THE	the	DT
8691	853	9	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	853	10	POWER	POWER	NNS
8691	853	11	OF	of	IN
8691	853	12	DEVELOPING	develop	VBG
8691	853	13	UNWRITTEN	UNWRITTEN	NNP
8691	853	14	LAW	law	NN
8691	853	15	The	the	DT
8691	853	16	English	english	JJ
8691	853	17	common	common	JJ
8691	853	18	law	law	NN
8691	853	19	was	be	VBD
8691	853	20	and	and	CC
8691	853	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	853	22	an	an	DT
8691	853	23	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	853	24	law	law	NN
8691	853	25	.	.	.
8691	854	1	To	to	TO
8691	854	2	find	find	VB
8691	854	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	854	4	one	one	PRP
8691	854	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	854	6	to	to	TO
8691	854	7	look	look	VB
8691	854	8	in	in	IN
8691	854	9	legal	legal	JJ
8691	854	10	treatises	treatise	NNS
8691	854	11	and	and	CC
8691	854	12	reports	report	NNS
8691	854	13	of	of	IN
8691	854	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	854	15	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	854	16	.	.	.
8691	855	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	855	2	historical	historical	JJ
8691	855	3	development	development	NN
8691	855	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	855	5	been	be	VBN
8691	855	6	not	not	RB
8691	855	7	unlike	unlike	IN
8691	855	8	that	that	DT
8691	855	9	of	of	IN
8691	855	10	Rome	Rome	NNP
8691	855	11	.	.	.
8691	856	1	In	in	IN
8691	856	2	Rome	Rome	NNP
8691	856	3	,	,	,
8691	856	4	as	as	IN
8691	856	5	in	in	IN
8691	856	6	England	England	NNP
8691	856	7	,	,	,
8691	856	8	there	there	EX
8691	856	9	were	be	VBD
8691	856	10	in	in	IN
8691	856	11	early	early	JJ
8691	856	12	times	time	NNS
8691	856	13	written	write	VBN
8691	856	14	enactments	enactment	NNS
8691	856	15	or	or	CC
8691	856	16	governmental	governmental	JJ
8691	856	17	declarations	declaration	NNS
8691	856	18	of	of	IN
8691	856	19	standing	stand	VBG
8691	856	20	rules	rule	NNS
8691	856	21	on	on	IN
8691	856	22	but	but	CC
8691	856	23	few	few	JJ
8691	856	24	points	point	NNS
8691	856	25	.	.	.
8691	857	1	Some	some	DT
8691	857	2	of	of	IN
8691	857	3	these	these	DT
8691	857	4	writings	writing	NNS
8691	857	5	were	be	VBD
8691	857	6	of	of	IN
8691	857	7	special	special	JJ
8691	857	8	importance	importance	NN
8691	857	9	,	,	,
8691	857	10	such	such	JJ
8691	857	11	as	as	IN
8691	857	12	the	the	DT
8691	857	13	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	857	14	tables	table	NNS
8691	857	15	of	of	IN
8691	857	16	Rome	Rome	NNP
8691	857	17	and	and	CC
8691	857	18	the	the	DT
8691	857	19	_	_	NNP
8691	857	20	Magna	Magna	NNPS
8691	857	21	Charta	Charta	NNP
8691	857	22	_	_	NNP
8691	857	23	of	of	IN
8691	857	24	England	England	NNP
8691	857	25	.	.	.
8691	858	1	These	these	DT
8691	858	2	were	be	VBD
8691	858	3	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	858	4	as	as	IN
8691	858	5	so	so	RB
8691	858	6	bound	bind	VBN
8691	858	7	up	up	RP
8691	858	8	with	with	IN
8691	858	9	the	the	DT
8691	858	10	very	very	JJ
8691	858	11	life	life	NN
8691	858	12	of	of	IN
8691	858	13	the	the	DT
8691	858	14	people	people	NNS
8691	858	15	as	as	IN
8691	858	16	to	to	TO
8691	858	17	have	have	VB
8691	858	18	a	a	DT
8691	858	19	place	place	NN
8691	858	20	by	by	IN
8691	858	21	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	858	22	,	,	,
8691	858	23	and	and	CC
8691	858	24	a	a	DT
8691	858	25	superior	superior	JJ
8691	858	26	force	force	NN
8691	858	27	to	to	IN
8691	858	28	anything	anything	NN
8691	858	29	to	to	IN
8691	858	30	the	the	DT
8691	858	31	contrary	contrary	NN
8691	858	32	to	to	IN
8691	858	33	which	which	WDT
8691	858	34	the	the	DT
8691	858	35	free	free	JJ
8691	858	36	consent	consent	NN
8691	858	37	of	of	IN
8691	858	38	the	the	DT
8691	858	39	people	people	NNS
8691	858	40	was	be	VBD
8691	858	41	not	not	RB
8691	858	42	formally	formally	RB
8691	858	43	given	give	VBN
8691	858	44	.	.	.
8691	859	1	But	but	CC
8691	859	2	in	in	IN
8691	859	3	general	general	JJ
8691	859	4	Romans	Romans	NNPS
8691	859	5	and	and	CC
8691	859	6	Englishmen	Englishmen	NNP
8691	859	7	preferred	prefer	VBD
8691	859	8	to	to	TO
8691	859	9	make	make	VB
8691	859	10	custom	custom	NN
8691	859	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	859	12	law	law	NN
8691	859	13	,	,	,
8691	859	14	and	and	CC
8691	859	15	to	to	TO
8691	859	16	let	let	VB
8691	859	17	this	this	DT
8691	859	18	law	law	NN
8691	859	19	grow	grow	VB
8691	859	20	"	"	``
8691	859	21	not	not	RB
8691	859	22	with	with	IN
8691	859	23	observation	observation	NN
8691	859	24	,	,	,
8691	859	25	"	"	''
8691	859	26	but	but	CC
8691	859	27	insensibly	insensibly	RB
8691	859	28	from	from	IN
8691	859	29	day	day	NN
8691	859	30	to	to	IN
8691	859	31	day	day	NN
8691	859	32	as	as	IN
8691	859	33	the	the	DT
8691	859	34	needs	need	NNS
8691	859	35	of	of	IN
8691	859	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	859	37	social	social	JJ
8691	859	38	organization	organization	NN
8691	859	39	might	may	MD
8691	859	40	be	be	VB
8691	859	41	found	find	VBN
8691	859	42	to	to	TO
8691	859	43	require	require	VB
8691	859	44	.	.	.
8691	860	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	860	2	was	be	VBD
8691	860	3	a	a	DT
8691	860	4	wise	wise	JJ
8691	860	5	preference	preference	NN
8691	860	6	,	,	,
8691	860	7	and	and	CC
8691	860	8	founded	found	VBN
8691	860	9	on	on	IN
8691	860	10	a	a	DT
8691	860	11	better	well	JJR
8691	860	12	philosophy	philosophy	NN
8691	860	13	than	than	IN
8691	860	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	860	15	knew	know	VBD
8691	860	16	--	--	:
8691	860	17	than	than	IN
8691	860	18	the	the	DT
8691	860	19	world	world	NN
8691	860	20	knew	know	VBD
8691	860	21	,	,	,
8691	860	22	until	until	IN
8691	860	23	the	the	DT
8691	860	24	theory	theory	NN
8691	860	25	of	of	IN
8691	860	26	evolution	evolution	NN
8691	860	27	was	be	VBD
8691	860	28	demonstrated	demonstrate	VBN
8691	860	29	by	by	IN
8691	860	30	Darwin	Darwin	NNP
8691	860	31	and	and	CC
8691	860	32	applied	apply	VBD
8691	860	33	to	to	IN
8691	860	34	governmental	governmental	JJ
8691	860	35	science	science	NN
8691	860	36	by	by	IN
8691	860	37	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
8691	860	38	.	.	.
8691	861	1	A	a	DT
8691	861	2	customary	customary	JJ
8691	861	3	law	law	NN
8691	861	4	for	for	IN
8691	861	5	a	a	DT
8691	861	6	people	people	NNS
8691	861	7	of	of	IN
8691	861	8	advancing	advance	VBG
8691	861	9	civilization	civilization	NN
8691	861	10	and	and	CC
8691	861	11	power	power	NN
8691	861	12	must	must	MD
8691	861	13	expand	expand	VB
8691	861	14	with	with	IN
8691	861	15	corresponding	correspond	VBG
8691	861	16	rapidity	rapidity	NN
8691	861	17	.	.	.
8691	862	1	There	there	EX
8691	862	2	will	will	MD
8691	862	3	soon	soon	RB
8691	862	4	be	be	VB
8691	862	5	disputes	dispute	NNS
8691	862	6	as	as	IN
8691	862	7	to	to	IN
8691	862	8	what	what	WP
8691	862	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	862	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	862	11	on	on	IN
8691	862	12	certain	certain	JJ
8691	862	13	points	point	NNS
8691	862	14	and	and	CC
8691	862	15	a	a	DT
8691	862	16	demand	demand	NN
8691	862	17	for	for	IN
8691	862	18	some	some	DT
8691	862	19	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
8691	862	20	information	information	NN
8691	862	21	as	as	IN
8691	862	22	to	to	IN
8691	862	23	this	this	DT
8691	862	24	.	.	.
8691	863	1	In	in	IN
8691	863	2	Rome	Rome	NNP
8691	863	3	,	,	,
8691	863	4	the	the	DT
8691	863	5	priests	priest	NNS
8691	863	6	gave	give	VBD
8691	863	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	863	8	at	at	IN
8691	863	9	first	first	RB
8691	863	10	,	,	,
8691	863	11	and	and	CC
8691	863	12	then	then	RB
8691	863	13	the	the	DT
8691	863	14	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	863	15	.	.	.
8691	864	1	In	in	IN
8691	864	2	England	England	NNP
8691	864	3	,	,	,
8691	864	4	the	the	DT
8691	864	5	priests	priest	NNS
8691	864	6	never	never	RB
8691	864	7	gave	give	VBD
8691	864	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	864	9	,	,	,
8691	864	10	as	as	IN
8691	864	11	priests	priest	NNS
8691	864	12	.	.	.
8691	865	1	There	there	EX
8691	865	2	was	be	VBD
8691	865	3	no	no	DT
8691	865	4	sacred	sacred	JJ
8691	865	5	college	college	NN
8691	865	6	of	of	IN
8691	865	7	law	law	NN
8691	865	8	.	.	.
8691	866	1	Priests	priest	NNS
8691	866	2	took	take	VBD
8691	866	3	part	part	NN
8691	866	4	in	in	IN
8691	866	5	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	866	6	.	.	.
8691	867	1	A	a	DT
8691	867	2	priest	priest	NN
8691	867	3	,	,	,
8691	867	4	at	at	IN
8691	867	5	the	the	DT
8691	867	6	king	king	NN
8691	867	7	's	's	POS
8691	867	8	right	right	JJ
8691	867	9	hand	hand	NN
8691	867	10	,	,	,
8691	867	11	was	be	VBD
8691	867	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	867	13	spokesman	spokesman	NN
8691	867	14	in	in	IN
8691	867	15	doing	do	VBG
8691	867	16	equity	equity	NN
8691	867	17	.	.	.
8691	868	1	But	but	CC
8691	868	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	868	3	was	be	VBD
8691	868	4	from	from	IN
8691	868	5	the	the	DT
8691	868	6	first	first	JJ
8691	868	7	the	the	DT
8691	868	8	king	king	NN
8691	868	9	as	as	IN
8691	868	10	a	a	DT
8691	868	11	judge	judge	NN
8691	868	12	,	,	,
8691	868	13	or	or	CC
8691	868	14	the	the	DT
8691	868	15	king	king	NN
8691	868	16	's	's	POS
8691	868	17	judges	judge	NNS
8691	868	18	deputed	depute	VBN
8691	868	19	by	by	IN
8691	868	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	868	21	and	and	CC
8691	868	22	sitting	sit	VBG
8691	868	23	for	for	IN
8691	868	24	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	868	25	,	,	,
8691	868	26	who	who	WP
8691	868	27	settled	settle	VBD
8691	868	28	controverted	controvert	VBN
8691	868	29	questions	question	NNS
8691	868	30	of	of	IN
8691	868	31	common	common	JJ
8691	868	32	law	law	NN
8691	868	33	.	.	.
8691	869	1	For	for	IN
8691	869	2	the	the	DT
8691	869	3	Roman	Roman	NNP
8691	869	4	and	and	CC
8691	869	5	for	for	IN
8691	869	6	the	the	DT
8691	869	7	Englishman	Englishman	NNP
8691	869	8	the	the	DT
8691	869	9	first	first	JJ
8691	869	10	representatives	representative	NNS
8691	869	11	of	of	IN
8691	869	12	government	government	NN
8691	869	13	who	who	WP
8691	869	14	could	could	MD
8691	869	15	be	be	VB
8691	869	16	called	call	VBN
8691	869	17	judges	judge	NNS
8691	869	18	were	be	VBD
8691	869	19	primarily	primarily	RB
8691	869	20	and	and	CC
8691	869	21	principally	principally	RB
8691	869	22	executive	executive	JJ
8691	869	23	officers	officer	NNS
8691	869	24	.	.	.
8691	870	1	The	the	DT
8691	870	2	Roman	Roman	NNP
8691	870	3	_	_	NNP
8691	870	4	prÃ	prÃ	NNP
8691	870	5	¦	¦	NNP
8691	870	6	tor	tor	NN
8691	870	7	_	_	NNP
8691	870	8	was	be	VBD
8691	870	9	not	not	RB
8691	870	10	given	give	VBN
8691	870	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	870	12	functions	function	NNS
8691	870	13	because	because	IN
8691	870	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	870	15	had	have	VBD
8691	870	16	legal	legal	JJ
8691	870	17	attainments	attainment	NNS
8691	870	18	.	.	.
8691	871	1	The	the	DT
8691	871	2	_	_	NNP
8691	871	3	aula	aula	NNP
8691	871	4	regis	regi	VBZ
8691	871	5	_	_	NNP
8691	871	6	of	of	IN
8691	871	7	early	early	JJ
8691	871	8	England	England	NNP
8691	871	9	was	be	VBD
8691	871	10	composed	compose	VBN
8691	871	11	of	of	IN
8691	871	12	the	the	DT
8691	871	13	great	great	JJ
8691	871	14	officers	officer	NNS
8691	871	15	of	of	IN
8691	871	16	state	state	NN
8691	871	17	.	.	.
8691	872	1	The	the	DT
8691	872	2	chief	chief	JJ
8691	872	3	justiciar	justiciar	NN
8691	872	4	,	,	,
8691	872	5	however	however	RB
8691	872	6	,	,	,
8691	872	7	soon	soon	RB
8691	872	8	ceased	cease	VBD
8691	872	9	to	to	TO
8691	872	10	be	be	VB
8691	872	11	prime	prime	JJ
8691	872	12	minister	minister	NN
8691	872	13	.	.	.
8691	873	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	873	2	associates	associate	NNS
8691	873	3	on	on	IN
8691	873	4	the	the	DT
8691	873	5	bench	bench	NN
8691	873	6	,	,	,
8691	873	7	as	as	IN
8691	873	8	law	law	NN
8691	873	9	became	become	VBD
8691	873	10	a	a	DT
8691	873	11	recognized	recognize	VBN
8691	873	12	profession	profession	NN
8691	873	13	,	,	,
8691	873	14	came	come	VBD
8691	873	15	to	to	TO
8691	873	16	be	be	VB
8691	873	17	chosen	choose	VBN
8691	873	18	largely	largely	RB
8691	873	19	for	for	IN
8691	873	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	873	21	fitness	fitness	NN
8691	873	22	for	for	IN
8691	873	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	873	24	work	work	NN
8691	873	25	and	and	CC
8691	873	26	to	to	TO
8691	873	27	be	be	VB
8691	873	28	kept	keep	VBN
8691	873	29	at	at	IN
8691	873	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	873	31	during	during	IN
8691	873	32	the	the	DT
8691	873	33	king	king	NN
8691	873	34	's	's	POS
8691	873	35	pleasure	pleasure	NN
8691	873	36	.	.	.
8691	874	1	At	at	IN
8691	874	2	Rome	Rome	NNP
8691	874	3	,	,	,
8691	874	4	on	on	IN
8691	874	5	the	the	DT
8691	874	6	contrary	contrary	NN
8691	874	7	,	,	,
8691	874	8	the	the	DT
8691	874	9	prÃ	prã	JJ
8691	874	10	¦	¦	NN
8691	874	11	torship	torship	NN
8691	874	12	remained	remain	VBD
8691	874	13	a	a	DT
8691	874	14	political	political	JJ
8691	874	15	place	place	NN
8691	874	16	,	,	,
8691	874	17	held	hold	VBN
8691	874	18	for	for	IN
8691	874	19	a	a	DT
8691	874	20	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	874	21	term	term	NN
8691	874	22	,	,	,
8691	874	23	and	and	CC
8691	874	24	a	a	DT
8691	874	25	brief	brief	JJ
8691	874	26	one	one	NN
8691	874	27	.	.	.
8691	875	1	Information	information	NN
8691	875	2	as	as	IN
8691	875	3	to	to	IN
8691	875	4	the	the	DT
8691	875	5	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	875	6	law	law	NN
8691	875	7	applicable	applicable	JJ
8691	875	8	to	to	IN
8691	875	9	any	any	DT
8691	875	10	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	875	11	between	between	IN
8691	875	12	parties	party	NNS
8691	875	13	had	have	VBD
8691	875	14	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	875	15	to	to	TO
8691	875	16	be	be	VB
8691	875	17	sought	seek	VBN
8691	875	18	from	from	IN
8691	875	19	others	other	NNS
8691	875	20	.	.	.
8691	876	1	The	the	DT
8691	876	2	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	876	3	could	could	MD
8691	876	4	give	give	VB
8691	876	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	876	6	;	;	:
8691	876	7	and	and	CC
8691	876	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	876	9	was	be	VBD
8691	876	10	to	to	IN
8691	876	11	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	876	12	,	,	,
8691	876	13	not	not	RB
8691	876	14	to	to	IN
8691	876	15	the	the	DT
8691	876	16	judges	judge	NNS
8691	876	17	,	,	,
8691	876	18	that	that	DT
8691	876	19	resort	resort	NN
8691	876	20	was	be	VBD
8691	876	21	had	have	VBN
8691	876	22	.	.	.
8691	877	1	The	the	DT
8691	877	2	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	877	3	of	of	IN
8691	877	4	a	a	DT
8691	877	5	great	great	JJ
8691	877	6	jurist	jurist	NN
8691	877	7	was	be	VBD
8691	877	8	for	for	IN
8691	877	9	Rome	Rome	NNP
8691	877	10	what	what	WP
8691	877	11	the	the	DT
8691	877	12	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	877	13	of	of	IN
8691	877	14	a	a	DT
8691	877	15	judge	judge	NN
8691	877	16	was	be	VBD
8691	877	17	for	for	IN
8691	877	18	England	England	NNP
8691	877	19	.	.	.
8691	878	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	878	2	was	be	VBD
8691	878	3	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	878	4	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	878	5	as	as	IN
8691	878	6	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	878	7	not	not	RB
8691	878	8	only	only	RB
8691	878	9	by	by	IN
8691	878	10	the	the	DT
8691	878	11	people	people	NNS
8691	878	12	but	but	CC
8691	878	13	by	by	IN
8691	878	14	the	the	DT
8691	878	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	878	16	.	.	.
8691	879	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	879	2	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	879	3	profess	profess	JJ
8691	879	4	to	to	TO
8691	879	5	state	state	VB
8691	879	6	what	what	WP
8691	879	7	the	the	DT
8691	879	8	law	law	NN
8691	879	9	was	be	VBD
8691	879	10	by	by	IN
8691	879	11	which	which	WDT
8691	879	12	rights	right	NNS
8691	879	13	accrued	accrue	VBN
8691	879	14	out	out	IN
8691	879	15	of	of	IN
8691	879	16	a	a	DT
8691	879	17	past	past	JJ
8691	879	18	transaction	transaction	NN
8691	879	19	.	.	.
8691	880	1	In	in	IN
8691	880	2	fact	fact	NN
8691	880	3	,	,	,
8691	880	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	880	5	often	often	RB
8691	880	6	do	do	VBP
8691	880	7	much	much	RB
8691	880	8	more	more	JJR
8691	880	9	.	.	.
8691	881	1	By	by	IN
8691	881	2	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	881	3	that	that	DT
8691	881	4	to	to	TO
8691	881	5	be	be	VB
8691	881	6	the	the	DT
8691	881	7	law	law	NN
8691	881	8	,	,	,
8691	881	9	and	and	CC
8691	881	10	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	881	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	881	12	with	with	IN
8691	881	13	authority	authority	NN
8691	881	14	,	,	,
8691	881	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	881	16	are	be	VBP
8691	881	17	the	the	DT
8691	881	18	first	first	JJ
8691	881	19	to	to	TO
8691	881	20	make	make	VB
8691	881	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	881	22	certain	certain	JJ
8691	881	23	that	that	IN
8691	881	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	881	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	881	26	the	the	DT
8691	881	27	law	law	NN
8691	881	28	.	.	.
8691	882	1	The	the	DT
8691	882	2	difference	difference	NN
8691	882	3	between	between	IN
8691	882	4	this	this	DT
8691	882	5	and	and	CC
8691	882	6	making	make	VBG
8691	882	7	law	law	NN
8691	882	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	882	9	not	not	RB
8691	882	10	great	great	JJ
8691	882	11	.	.	.
8691	883	1	The	the	DT
8691	883	2	Romans	Romans	NNPS
8691	883	3	at	at	IN
8691	883	4	first	first	RB
8691	883	5	accorded	accord	VBN
8691	883	6	authority	authority	NN
8691	883	7	to	to	IN
8691	883	8	the	the	DT
8691	883	9	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	883	10	(	(	-LRB-
8691	883	11	_	_	NNP
8691	883	12	responsa	responsa	NNP
8691	883	13	_	_	NNP
8691	883	14	)	)	-RRB-
8691	883	15	of	of	IN
8691	883	16	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	883	17	only	only	RB
8691	883	18	because	because	IN
8691	883	19	of	of	IN
8691	883	20	the	the	DT
8691	883	21	standing	standing	NN
8691	883	22	and	and	CC
8691	883	23	reputation	reputation	NN
8691	883	24	of	of	IN
8691	883	25	those	those	DT
8691	883	26	who	who	WP
8691	883	27	gave	give	VBD
8691	883	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	883	29	.	.	.
8691	884	1	Later	later	RB
8691	884	2	the	the	DT
8691	884	3	emperors	emperor	NNS
8691	884	4	gave	give	VBD
8691	884	5	an	an	DT
8691	884	6	official	official	JJ
8691	884	7	character	character	NN
8691	884	8	and	and	CC
8691	884	9	weight	weight	NN
8691	884	10	to	to	IN
8691	884	11	the	the	DT
8691	884	12	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	884	13	of	of	IN
8691	884	14	certain	certain	JJ
8691	884	15	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	884	16	of	of	IN
8691	884	17	the	the	DT
8691	884	18	past	past	NN
8691	884	19	.	.	.
8691	885	1	The	the	DT
8691	885	2	English	English	NNP
8691	885	3	always	always	RB
8691	885	4	accorded	accord	VBD
8691	885	5	authority	authority	NN
8691	885	6	to	to	IN
8691	885	7	the	the	DT
8691	885	8	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	885	9	of	of	IN
8691	885	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	885	11	judges	judge	NNS
8691	885	12	,	,	,
8691	885	13	because	because	IN
8691	885	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	885	15	spoke	speak	VBD
8691	885	16	for	for	IN
8691	885	17	the	the	DT
8691	885	18	state	state	NN
8691	885	19	.	.	.
8691	886	1	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	886	2	from	from	IN
8691	886	3	the	the	DT
8691	886	4	first	first	JJ
8691	886	5	have	have	VBP
8691	886	6	done	do	VBN
8691	886	7	the	the	DT
8691	886	8	same	same	JJ
8691	886	9	.	.	.
8691	887	1	American	american	JJ
8691	887	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	887	3	have	have	VBP
8691	887	4	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	887	5	these	these	DT
8691	887	6	powers	power	NNS
8691	887	7	of	of	IN
8691	887	8	ascertaining	ascertain	VBG
8691	887	9	and	and	CC
8691	887	10	developing	develop	VBG
8691	887	11	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	887	12	law	law	NN
8691	887	13	even	even	RB
8691	887	14	more	more	RBR
8691	887	15	freely	freely	RB
8691	887	16	than	than	IN
8691	887	17	English	english	JJ
8691	887	18	judges	judge	NNS
8691	887	19	.	.	.
8691	888	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	888	2	were	be	VBD
8691	888	3	forced	force	VBN
8691	888	4	to	to	IN
8691	888	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	888	6	as	as	IN
8691	888	7	a	a	DT
8691	888	8	result	result	NN
8691	888	9	of	of	IN
8691	888	10	applying	apply	VBG
8691	888	11	the	the	DT
8691	888	12	common	common	JJ
8691	888	13	law	law	NN
8691	888	14	of	of	IN
8691	888	15	one	one	CD
8691	888	16	people	people	NNS
8691	888	17	to	to	IN
8691	888	18	another	another	DT
8691	888	19	people	people	NNS
8691	888	20	inhabiting	inhabit	VBG
8691	888	21	another	another	DT
8691	888	22	part	part	NN
8691	888	23	of	of	IN
8691	888	24	the	the	DT
8691	888	25	world	world	NN
8691	888	26	and	and	CC
8691	888	27	living	live	VBG
8691	888	28	under	under	IN
8691	888	29	very	very	RB
8691	888	30	different	different	JJ
8691	888	31	social	social	JJ
8691	888	32	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	888	33	.	.	.
8691	889	1	In	in	IN
8691	889	2	doing	do	VBG
8691	889	3	this	this	DT
8691	889	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	889	5	was	be	VBD
8691	889	6	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	889	7	to	to	TO
8691	889	8	reject	reject	VB
8691	889	9	not	not	RB
8691	889	10	a	a	DT
8691	889	11	little	little	JJ
8691	889	12	of	of	IN
8691	889	13	what	what	WP
8691	889	14	for	for	IN
8691	889	15	England	England	NNP
8691	889	16	had	have	VBD
8691	889	17	already	already	RB
8691	889	18	been	be	VBN
8691	889	19	definitely	definitely	RB
8691	889	20	settled	settle	VBN
8691	889	21	and	and	CC
8691	889	22	universally	universally	RB
8691	889	23	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	889	24	.	.	.
8691	890	1	The	the	DT
8691	890	2	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	890	3	of	of	IN
8691	890	4	the	the	DT
8691	890	5	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	890	6	and	and	CC
8691	890	7	States	States	NNP
8691	890	8	rejected	reject	VBD
8691	890	9	much	much	RB
8691	890	10	,	,	,
8691	890	11	but	but	CC
8691	890	12	the	the	DT
8691	890	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	890	14	rejected	reject	VBD
8691	890	15	more	more	RBR
8691	890	16	.	.	.
8691	891	1	The	the	DT
8691	891	2	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	891	3	also	also	RB
8691	891	4	added	add	VBD
8691	891	5	much	much	RB
8691	891	6	,	,	,
8691	891	7	but	but	CC
8691	891	8	the	the	DT
8691	891	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	891	10	added	add	VBD
8691	891	11	yet	yet	RB
8691	891	12	more	more	JJR
8691	891	13	.	.	.
8691	892	1	Usages	usage	NNS
8691	892	2	grow	grow	VB
8691	892	3	up	up	RP
8691	892	4	rapidly	rapidly	RB
8691	892	5	in	in	IN
8691	892	6	new	new	JJ
8691	892	7	settlements	settlement	NNS
8691	892	8	and	and	CC
8691	892	9	along	along	IN
8691	892	10	frontiers	frontier	NNS
8691	892	11	bounded	bound	VBN
8691	892	12	by	by	IN
8691	892	13	territory	territory	NN
8691	892	14	held	hold	VBN
8691	892	15	by	by	IN
8691	892	16	savages	savage	NNS
8691	892	17	.	.	.
8691	893	1	Of	of	IN
8691	893	2	such	such	JJ
8691	893	3	usages	usage	NNS
8691	893	4	,	,	,
8691	893	5	under	under	IN
8691	893	6	the	the	DT
8691	893	7	rulings	ruling	NNS
8691	893	8	of	of	IN
8691	893	9	the	the	DT
8691	893	10	courts	court	NNS
8691	893	11	,	,	,
8691	893	12	many	many	JJ
8691	893	13	were	be	VBD
8691	893	14	soon	soon	RB
8691	893	15	crystallized	crystallize	VBN
8691	893	16	into	into	IN
8691	893	17	law	law	NN
8691	893	18	.	.	.
8691	894	1	New	new	JJ
8691	894	2	inventions	invention	NNS
8691	894	3	and	and	CC
8691	894	4	new	new	JJ
8691	894	5	political	political	JJ
8691	894	6	conceptions	conception	NNS
8691	894	7	in	in	IN
8691	894	8	the	the	DT
8691	894	9	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
8691	894	10	century	century	NN
8691	894	11	began	begin	VBD
8691	894	12	to	to	TO
8691	894	13	change	change	VB
8691	894	14	the	the	DT
8691	894	15	face	face	NN
8691	894	16	of	of	IN
8691	894	17	the	the	DT
8691	894	18	civilized	civilized	JJ
8691	894	19	world	world	NN
8691	894	20	.	.	.
8691	895	1	The	the	DT
8691	895	2	common	common	JJ
8691	895	3	law	law	NN
8691	895	4	as	as	IN
8691	895	5	to	to	IN
8691	895	6	agency	agency	NN
8691	895	7	had	have	VBD
8691	895	8	to	to	TO
8691	895	9	be	be	VB
8691	895	10	adapted	adapt	VBN
8691	895	11	to	to	IN
8691	895	12	the	the	DT
8691	895	13	operations	operation	NNS
8691	895	14	of	of	IN
8691	895	15	business	business	NN
8691	895	16	corporations	corporation	NNS
8691	895	17	;	;	:
8691	895	18	that	that	IN
8691	895	19	as	as	IN
8691	895	20	to	to	IN
8691	895	21	highways	highway	NNS
8691	895	22	to	to	IN
8691	895	23	railroads	railroad	NNS
8691	895	24	;	;	:
8691	895	25	that	that	IN
8691	895	26	as	as	IN
8691	895	27	to	to	IN
8691	895	28	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	895	29	by	by	IN
8691	895	30	mail	mail	NN
8691	895	31	to	to	IN
8691	895	32	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	895	33	by	by	IN
8691	895	34	telegram	telegram	NN
8691	895	35	,	,	,
8691	895	36	and	and	CC
8691	895	37	later	later	RB
8691	895	38	to	to	IN
8691	895	39	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	895	40	by	by	IN
8691	895	41	telephone	telephone	NN
8691	895	42	.	.	.
8691	896	1	The	the	DT
8691	896	2	whole	whole	JJ
8691	896	3	law	law	NN
8691	896	4	of	of	IN
8691	896	5	master	master	NN
8691	896	6	and	and	CC
8691	896	7	servant	servant	NN
8691	896	8	,	,	,
8691	896	9	which	which	WDT
8691	896	10	for	for	IN
8691	896	11	the	the	DT
8691	896	12	English	english	JJ
8691	896	13	people	people	NNS
8691	896	14	was	be	VBD
8691	896	15	bottomed	bottom	VBN
8691	896	16	on	on	IN
8691	896	17	the	the	DT
8691	896	18	relation	relation	NN
8691	896	19	of	of	IN
8691	896	20	land	land	NN
8691	896	21	-	-	HYPH
8691	896	22	owner	owner	NN
8691	896	23	and	and	CC
8691	896	24	serf	serf	NN
8691	896	25	,	,	,
8691	896	26	was	be	VBD
8691	896	27	to	to	TO
8691	896	28	be	be	VB
8691	896	29	recast	recast	VBN
8691	896	30	.	.	.
8691	897	1	Public	public	JJ
8691	897	2	assemblies	assembly	NNS
8691	897	3	were	be	VBD
8691	897	4	to	to	TO
8691	897	5	be	be	VB
8691	897	6	regulated	regulate	VBN
8691	897	7	and	and	CC
8691	897	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	897	9	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	897	10	published	publish	VBN
8691	897	11	with	with	IN
8691	897	12	greater	great	JJR
8691	897	13	regard	regard	NN
8691	897	14	to	to	IN
8691	897	15	public	public	NN
8691	897	16	and	and	CC
8691	897	17	less	less	JJR
8691	897	18	to	to	TO
8691	897	19	private	private	JJ
8691	897	20	interest	interest	NN
8691	897	21	.	.	.
8691	898	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	898	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	898	3	:	:	:
8691	898	4	Barrows	Barrows	NNP
8691	898	5	_	_	NNP
8691	898	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	898	7	_	_	NNP
8691	898	8	Bell	Bell	NNP
8691	898	9	,	,	,
8691	898	10	7	7	CD
8691	898	11	Gray	Gray	NNP
8691	898	12	's	's	POS
8691	898	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	898	14	,	,	,
8691	898	15	301	301	CD
8691	898	16	;	;	:
8691	898	17	66	66	CD
8691	898	18	American	American	NNP
8691	898	19	Decisions	Decisions	NNPS
8691	898	20	,	,	,
8691	898	21	479	479	CD
8691	898	22	.	.	.
8691	898	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	899	1	Along	along	IN
8691	899	2	all	all	PDT
8691	899	3	these	these	DT
8691	899	4	lines	line	NNS
8691	899	5	and	and	CC
8691	899	6	many	many	JJ
8691	899	7	others	other	NNS
8691	899	8	the	the	DT
8691	899	9	American	american	JJ
8691	899	10	courts	court	NNS
8691	899	11	have	have	VBP
8691	899	12	now	now	RB
8691	899	13	for	for	IN
8691	899	14	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	899	15	three	three	CD
8691	899	16	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	899	17	years	year	NNS
8691	899	18	been	be	VBN
8691	899	19	quarrying	quarry	VBG
8691	899	20	out	out	RP
8691	899	21	American	american	JJ
8691	899	22	law	law	NN
8691	899	23	from	from	IN
8691	899	24	the	the	DT
8691	899	25	mine	mine	NN
8691	899	26	of	of	IN
8691	899	27	the	the	DT
8691	899	28	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	899	29	law	law	NN
8691	899	30	of	of	IN
8691	899	31	the	the	DT
8691	899	32	people	people	NNS
8691	899	33	within	within	IN
8691	899	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	899	35	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	899	36	.	.	.
8691	900	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	900	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	900	3	been	be	VBN
8691	900	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	900	5	natural	natural	JJ
8691	900	6	endeavor	endeavor	NN
8691	900	7	to	to	TO
8691	900	8	make	make	VB
8691	900	9	each	each	DT
8691	900	10	part	part	NN
8691	900	11	of	of	IN
8691	900	12	the	the	DT
8691	900	13	new	new	JJ
8691	900	14	system	system	NN
8691	900	15	of	of	IN
8691	900	16	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	900	17	which	which	WDT
8691	900	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	900	19	were	be	VBD
8691	900	20	gradually	gradually	RB
8691	900	21	building	build	VBG
8691	900	22	up	up	RP
8691	900	23	harmonious	harmonious	RB
8691	900	24	with	with	IN
8691	900	25	every	every	DT
8691	900	26	other	other	JJ
8691	900	27	and	and	CC
8691	900	28	to	to	TO
8691	900	29	give	give	VB
8691	900	30	a	a	DT
8691	900	31	certain	certain	JJ
8691	900	32	symmetry	symmetry	NN
8691	900	33	to	to	IN
8691	900	34	the	the	DT
8691	900	35	whole	whole	NN
8691	900	36	.	.	.
8691	901	1	This	this	DT
8691	901	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	901	3	forced	force	VBN
8691	901	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	901	5	to	to	TO
8691	901	6	deduce	deduce	VB
8691	901	7	rule	rule	NN
8691	901	8	from	from	IN
8691	901	9	rule	rule	NN
8691	901	10	and	and	CC
8691	901	11	principle	principle	NN
8691	901	12	from	from	IN
8691	901	13	principle	principle	NN
8691	901	14	with	with	IN
8691	901	15	a	a	DT
8691	901	16	freedom	freedom	NN
8691	901	17	for	for	IN
8691	901	18	which	which	WDT
8691	901	19	in	in	IN
8691	901	20	older	old	JJR
8691	901	21	countries	country	NNS
8691	901	22	of	of	IN
8691	901	23	settled	settle	VBN
8691	901	24	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	901	25	there	there	EX
8691	901	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	901	27	less	less	JJR
8691	901	28	occasion	occasion	NN
8691	901	29	.	.	.
8691	902	1	The	the	DT
8691	902	2	process	process	NN
8691	902	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	902	4	gone	go	VBN
8691	902	5	on	on	RP
8691	902	6	during	during	IN
8691	902	7	the	the	DT
8691	902	8	last	last	JJ
8691	902	9	fifty	fifty	CD
8691	902	10	years	year	NNS
8691	902	11	with	with	IN
8691	902	12	ever	ever	RB
8691	902	13	-	-	HYPH
8691	902	14	increasing	increase	VBG
8691	902	15	rapidity	rapidity	NN
8691	902	16	,	,	,
8691	902	17	and	and	CC
8691	902	18	for	for	IN
8691	902	19	two	two	CD
8691	902	20	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	902	21	.	.	.
8691	903	1	There	there	EX
8691	903	2	have	have	VBP
8691	903	3	been	be	VBN
8691	903	4	more	more	RBR
8691	903	5	novel	novel	JJ
8691	903	6	questions	question	NNS
8691	903	7	to	to	TO
8691	903	8	meet	meet	VB
8691	903	9	and	and	CC
8691	903	10	there	there	EX
8691	903	11	has	have	VBZ
8691	903	12	been	be	VBN
8691	903	13	a	a	DT
8691	903	14	greater	great	JJR
8691	903	15	wealth	wealth	NN
8691	903	16	of	of	IN
8691	903	17	suggestion	suggestion	NN
8691	903	18	and	and	CC
8691	903	19	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	903	20	at	at	IN
8691	903	21	command	command	NN
8691	903	22	.	.	.
8691	904	1	Not	not	RB
8691	904	2	a	a	DT
8691	904	3	little	little	JJ
8691	904	4	,	,	,
8691	904	5	however	however	RB
8691	904	6	,	,	,
8691	904	7	of	of	IN
8691	904	8	the	the	DT
8691	904	9	development	development	NN
8691	904	10	of	of	IN
8691	904	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	904	12	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	904	13	law	law	NN
8691	904	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	904	15	been	be	VBN
8691	904	16	and	and	CC
8691	904	17	remains	remain	VBZ
8691	904	18	of	of	IN
8691	904	19	a	a	DT
8691	904	20	local	local	JJ
8691	904	21	character	character	NN
8691	904	22	.	.	.
8691	905	1	This	this	DT
8691	905	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	905	3	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	905	4	true	true	JJ
8691	905	5	of	of	IN
8691	905	6	that	that	DT
8691	905	7	of	of	IN
8691	905	8	the	the	DT
8691	905	9	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
8691	905	10	States	States	NNPS
8691	905	11	,	,	,
8691	905	12	both	both	CC
8691	905	13	on	on	IN
8691	905	14	account	account	NN
8691	905	15	of	of	IN
8691	905	16	climatic	climatic	JJ
8691	905	17	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	905	18	and	and	CC
8691	905	19	historical	historical	JJ
8691	905	20	antecedents	antecedent	NNS
8691	905	21	.	.	.
8691	906	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	906	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	906	3	:	:	:
8691	906	4	Katz	Katz	NNP
8691	906	5	_	_	NNP
8691	906	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	906	7	_	_	NNP
8691	906	8	Walkinshaw	Walkinshaw	NNP
8691	906	9	,	,	,
8691	906	10	141	141	CD
8691	906	11	California	California	NNP
8691	906	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	906	13	,	,	,
8691	906	14	116	116	CD
8691	906	15	.	.	.
8691	906	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	907	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	907	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	907	3	Field	Field	NNP
8691	907	4	of	of	IN
8691	907	5	the	the	DT
8691	907	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	907	7	Court	Court	NNP
8691	907	8	of	of	IN
8691	907	9	California	California	NNP
8691	907	10	,	,	,
8691	907	11	afterward	afterward	RB
8691	907	12	so	so	RB
8691	907	13	long	long	RB
8691	907	14	a	a	DT
8691	907	15	member	member	NN
8691	907	16	of	of	IN
8691	907	17	the	the	DT
8691	907	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	907	19	Court	Court	NNP
8691	907	20	of	of	IN
8691	907	21	the	the	DT
8691	907	22	United	United	NNP
8691	907	23	States	States	NNP
8691	907	24	,	,	,
8691	907	25	did	do	VBD
8691	907	26	both	both	DT
8691	907	27	a	a	DT
8691	907	28	constructive	constructive	JJ
8691	907	29	and	and	CC
8691	907	30	a	a	DT
8691	907	31	destructive	destructive	JJ
8691	907	32	work	work	NN
8691	907	33	in	in	IN
8691	907	34	shaping	shape	VBG
8691	907	35	the	the	DT
8691	907	36	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	907	37	of	of	IN
8691	907	38	that	that	DT
8691	907	39	State	State	NNP
8691	907	40	.	.	.
8691	908	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	908	2	found	find	VBD
8691	908	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	908	4	seated	seat	VBN
8691	908	5	in	in	IN
8691	908	6	a	a	DT
8691	908	7	land	land	NN
8691	908	8	on	on	IN
8691	908	9	which	which	WDT
8691	908	10	certain	certain	JJ
8691	908	11	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	908	12	of	of	IN
8691	908	13	civil	civil	JJ
8691	908	14	law	law	NN
8691	908	15	origin	origin	NN
8691	908	16	had	have	VBD
8691	908	17	been	be	VBN
8691	908	18	impressed	impressed	JJ
8691	908	19	for	for	IN
8691	908	20	centuries	century	NNS
8691	908	21	and	and	CC
8691	908	22	into	into	IN
8691	908	23	which	which	WDT
8691	908	24	other	other	JJ
8691	908	25	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	908	26	of	of	IN
8691	908	27	common	common	JJ
8691	908	28	law	law	NN
8691	908	29	origin	origin	NN
8691	908	30	had	have	VBD
8691	908	31	been	be	VBN
8691	908	32	introduced	introduce	VBN
8691	908	33	in	in	IN
8691	908	34	recent	recent	JJ
8691	908	35	years	year	NNS
8691	908	36	.	.	.
8691	909	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	909	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	909	3	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	909	4	molded	mold	VBD
8691	909	5	these	these	DT
8691	909	6	into	into	IN
8691	909	7	one	one	CD
8691	909	8	mass	mass	NN
8691	909	9	,	,	,
8691	909	10	rejecting	reject	VBG
8691	909	11	something	something	NN
8691	909	12	from	from	IN
8691	909	13	each	each	DT
8691	909	14	and	and	CC
8691	909	15	retaining	retain	VBG
8691	909	16	something	something	NN
8691	909	17	from	from	IN
8691	909	18	each	each	DT
8691	909	19	.	.	.
8691	910	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	910	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	910	3	:	:	:
8691	910	4	Pomeroy	Pomeroy	NNP
8691	910	5	,	,	,
8691	910	6	"	"	``
8691	910	7	Some	some	DT
8691	910	8	Account	Account	NNP
8691	910	9	of	of	IN
8691	910	10	the	the	DT
8691	910	11	Work	Work	NNP
8691	910	12	of	of	IN
8691	910	13	Stephen	Stephen	NNP
8691	910	14	J.	J.	NNP
8691	911	1	Field	field	NN
8691	911	2	,	,	,
8691	911	3	"	"	''
8691	911	4	38	38	CD
8691	911	5	,	,	,
8691	911	6	45	45	CD
8691	911	7	.	.	.
8691	911	8	]	]	-RRB-
8691	912	1	Some	some	DT
8691	912	2	of	of	IN
8691	912	3	the	the	DT
8691	912	4	results	result	NNS
8691	912	5	of	of	IN
8691	912	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	912	7	creative	creative	JJ
8691	912	8	touch	touch	NN
8691	912	9	have	have	VBP
8691	912	10	been	be	VBN
8691	912	11	the	the	DT
8691	912	12	foundation	foundation	NN
8691	912	13	of	of	IN
8691	912	14	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	912	15	in	in	IN
8691	912	16	distant	distant	JJ
8691	912	17	States	state	NNS
8691	912	18	,	,	,
8691	912	19	but	but	CC
8691	912	20	most	most	JJS
8691	912	21	were	be	VBD
8691	912	22	so	so	RB
8691	912	23	dependent	dependent	JJ
8691	912	24	on	on	IN
8691	912	25	local	local	JJ
8691	912	26	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	912	27	and	and	CC
8691	912	28	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	912	29	as	as	IN
8691	912	30	to	to	TO
8691	912	31	be	be	VB
8691	912	32	incapable	incapable	JJ
8691	912	33	of	of	IN
8691	912	34	transplantation	transplantation	NN
8691	912	35	.	.	.
8691	913	1	But	but	CC
8691	913	2	as	as	IN
8691	913	3	to	to	IN
8691	913	4	all	all	DT
8691	913	5	questions	question	NNS
8691	913	6	of	of	IN
8691	913	7	general	general	JJ
8691	913	8	concern	concern	NN
8691	913	9	which	which	WDT
8691	913	10	can	can	MD
8691	913	11	be	be	VB
8691	913	12	answered	answer	VBN
8691	913	13	from	from	IN
8691	913	14	analogies	analogy	NNS
8691	913	15	drawn	draw	VBN
8691	913	16	from	from	IN
8691	913	17	the	the	DT
8691	913	18	common	common	JJ
8691	913	19	law	law	NN
8691	913	20	,	,	,
8691	913	21	the	the	DT
8691	913	22	judges	judge	NNS
8691	913	23	of	of	IN
8691	913	24	each	each	DT
8691	913	25	State	state	NN
8691	913	26	--	--	:
8691	913	27	and	and	CC
8691	913	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	913	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	913	30	the	the	DT
8691	913	31	State	State	NNP
8691	913	32	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	913	33	on	on	IN
8691	913	34	which	which	WDT
8691	913	35	the	the	DT
8691	913	36	burden	burden	NN
8691	913	37	of	of	IN
8691	913	38	developing	develop	VBG
8691	913	39	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	913	40	law	law	NN
8691	913	41	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	913	42	rests	rest	VBZ
8691	913	43	--	--	:
8691	913	44	now	now	RB
8691	913	45	find	find	VBP
8691	913	46	in	in	IN
8691	913	47	the	the	DT
8691	913	48	reported	report	VBN
8691	913	49	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	913	50	of	of	IN
8691	913	51	the	the	DT
8691	913	52	courts	court	NNS
8691	913	53	of	of	IN
8691	913	54	last	last	JJ
8691	913	55	resort	resort	NN
8691	913	56	in	in	IN
8691	913	57	all	all	PDT
8691	913	58	the	the	DT
8691	913	59	other	other	JJ
8691	913	60	States	state	NNS
8691	913	61	a	a	DT
8691	913	62	fertile	fertile	JJ
8691	913	63	source	source	NN
8691	913	64	of	of	IN
8691	913	65	supply	supply	NN
8691	913	66	when	when	WRB
8691	913	67	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	913	68	are	be	VBP
8691	913	69	looking	look	VBG
8691	913	70	for	for	IN
8691	913	71	a	a	DT
8691	913	72	rule	rule	NN
8691	913	73	to	to	TO
8691	913	74	fit	fit	VB
8691	913	75	a	a	DT
8691	913	76	case	case	NN
8691	913	77	for	for	IN
8691	913	78	which	which	WDT
8691	913	79	the	the	DT
8691	913	80	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	913	81	law	law	NN
8691	913	82	made	make	VBD
8691	913	83	no	no	DT
8691	913	84	direct	direct	JJ
8691	913	85	provision	provision	NN
8691	913	86	.	.	.
8691	914	1	Keen	keen	JJ
8691	914	2	intellects	intellect	NNS
8691	914	3	from	from	IN
8691	914	4	the	the	DT
8691	914	5	bench	bench	NN
8691	914	6	,	,	,
8691	914	7	aided	aid	VBN
8691	914	8	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	914	9	by	by	IN
8691	914	10	keener	keen	JJR
8691	914	11	ones	one	NNS
8691	914	12	from	from	IN
8691	914	13	the	the	DT
8691	914	14	bar	bar	NN
8691	914	15	in	in	IN
8691	914	16	forty	forty	CD
8691	914	17	-	-	HYPH
8691	914	18	five	five	CD
8691	914	19	different	different	JJ
8691	914	20	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
8691	914	21	,	,	,
8691	914	22	are	be	VBP
8691	914	23	discussing	discuss	VBG
8691	914	24	the	the	DT
8691	914	25	problems	problem	NNS
8691	914	26	of	of	IN
8691	914	27	the	the	DT
8691	914	28	day	day	NN
8691	914	29	as	as	IN
8691	914	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	914	31	appear	appear	VBP
8691	914	32	mirrored	mirror	VBN
8691	914	33	in	in	IN
8691	914	34	litigated	litigate	VBN
8691	914	35	causes	cause	NNS
8691	914	36	.	.	.
8691	915	1	What	what	WP
8691	915	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	915	3	a	a	DT
8691	915	4	new	new	JJ
8691	915	5	question	question	NN
8691	915	6	in	in	IN
8691	915	7	one	one	CD
8691	915	8	State	state	NN
8691	915	9	was	be	VBD
8691	915	10	set	set	VBN
8691	915	11	at	at	IN
8691	915	12	rest	rest	NN
8691	915	13	ten	ten	CD
8691	915	14	years	year	NNS
8691	915	15	or	or	CC
8691	915	16	ten	ten	CD
8691	915	17	days	day	NNS
8691	915	18	ago	ago	RB
8691	915	19	by	by	IN
8691	915	20	a	a	DT
8691	915	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	915	22	decision	decision	NN
8691	915	23	in	in	IN
8691	915	24	another	another	DT
8691	915	25	.	.	.
8691	916	1	If	if	IN
8691	916	2	the	the	DT
8691	916	3	decision	decision	NN
8691	916	4	was	be	VBD
8691	916	5	a	a	DT
8691	916	6	just	just	JJ
8691	916	7	and	and	CC
8691	916	8	logical	logical	JJ
8691	916	9	deduction	deduction	NN
8691	916	10	from	from	IN
8691	916	11	accepted	accepted	JJ
8691	916	12	principles	principle	NNS
8691	916	13	of	of	IN
8691	916	14	the	the	DT
8691	916	15	older	old	JJR
8691	916	16	law	law	NN
8691	916	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	916	18	will	will	MD
8691	916	19	probably	probably	RB
8691	916	20	be	be	VB
8691	916	21	followed	follow	VBN
8691	916	22	everywhere	everywhere	RB
8691	916	23	.	.	.
8691	917	1	If	if	IN
8691	917	2	unjust	unjust	JJ
8691	917	3	and	and	CC
8691	917	4	illogical	illogical	JJ
8691	917	5	,	,	,
8691	917	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	917	7	very	very	JJ
8691	917	8	faults	fault	NNS
8691	917	9	will	will	MD
8691	917	10	serve	serve	VB
8691	917	11	to	to	TO
8691	917	12	guard	guard	VB
8691	917	13	other	other	JJ
8691	917	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	917	15	to	to	IN
8691	917	16	better	well	JJR
8691	917	17	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	917	18	.	.	.
8691	918	1	How	how	WRB
8691	918	2	far	far	RB
8691	918	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	918	4	advance	advance	VBP
8691	918	5	along	along	IN
8691	918	6	these	these	DT
8691	918	7	paths	path	NNS
8691	918	8	depends	depend	VBZ
8691	918	9	greatly	greatly	RB
8691	918	10	on	on	IN
8691	918	11	the	the	DT
8691	918	12	character	character	NN
8691	918	13	of	of	IN
8691	918	14	the	the	DT
8691	918	15	bar	bar	NN
8691	918	16	.	.	.
8691	919	1	A	a	DT
8691	919	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	919	3	rarely	rarely	RB
8691	919	4	initiates	initiate	VBZ
8691	919	5	anything	anything	NN
8691	919	6	.	.	.
8691	920	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	920	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	920	3	apt	apt	JJ
8691	920	4	to	to	TO
8691	920	5	fall	fall	VB
8691	920	6	into	into	IN
8691	920	7	a	a	DT
8691	920	8	mistake	mistake	NN
8691	920	9	if	if	IN
8691	920	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	920	11	does	do	VBZ
8691	920	12	.	.	.
8691	921	1	The	the	DT
8691	921	2	business	business	NN
8691	921	3	which	which	WDT
8691	921	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	921	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	921	6	to	to	TO
8691	921	7	do	do	VB
8691	921	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	921	9	brought	bring	VBN
8691	921	10	before	before	IN
8691	921	11	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	921	12	by	by	IN
8691	921	13	others	other	NNS
8691	921	14	.	.	.
8691	922	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	922	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	922	3	brought	bring	VBN
8691	922	4	before	before	IN
8691	922	5	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	922	6	in	in	IN
8691	922	7	the	the	DT
8691	922	8	best	good	JJS
8691	922	9	way	way	NN
8691	922	10	to	to	TO
8691	922	11	throw	throw	VB
8691	922	12	all	all	DT
8691	922	13	possible	possible	JJ
8691	922	14	light	light	NN
8691	922	15	upon	upon	IN
8691	922	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	922	17	,	,	,
8691	922	18	because	because	IN
8691	922	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	922	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	922	21	set	set	VBN
8691	922	22	before	before	IN
8691	922	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	922	24	from	from	IN
8691	922	25	two	two	CD
8691	922	26	opposite	opposite	JJ
8691	922	27	points	point	NNS
8691	922	28	of	of	IN
8691	922	29	view	view	NN
8691	922	30	by	by	IN
8691	922	31	two	two	CD
8691	922	32	antagonists	antagonist	NNS
8691	922	33	,	,	,
8691	922	34	each	each	DT
8691	922	35	strenuously	strenuously	RB
8691	922	36	endeavoring	endeavor	VBG
8691	922	37	to	to	TO
8691	922	38	detect	detect	VB
8691	922	39	a	a	DT
8691	922	40	flaw	flaw	NN
8691	922	41	in	in	IN
8691	922	42	the	the	DT
8691	922	43	reasoning	reasoning	NN
8691	922	44	of	of	IN
8691	922	45	the	the	DT
8691	922	46	other	other	JJ
8691	922	47	.	.	.
8691	923	1	These	these	DT
8691	923	2	two	two	CD
8691	923	3	men	man	NNS
8691	923	4	have	have	VBP
8691	923	5	previously	previously	RB
8691	923	6	given	give	VBN
8691	923	7	the	the	DT
8691	923	8	subject	subject	NN
8691	923	9	in	in	IN
8691	923	10	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	923	11	much	much	JJ
8691	923	12	careful	careful	JJ
8691	923	13	thought	thought	NN
8691	923	14	.	.	.
8691	924	1	What	what	WP
8691	924	2	views	view	NNS
8691	924	3	neither	neither	CC
8691	924	4	presents	present	NNS
8691	924	5	are	be	VBP
8691	924	6	generally	generally	RB
8691	924	7	not	not	RB
8691	924	8	worth	worth	JJ
8691	924	9	presenting	present	VBG
8691	924	10	.	.	.
8691	925	1	As	as	IN
8691	925	2	was	be	VBD
8691	925	3	said	say	VBN
8691	925	4	in	in	IN
8691	925	5	the	the	DT
8691	925	6	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	925	7	chapter	chapter	NN
8691	925	8	,	,	,
8691	925	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	925	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	925	11	only	only	RB
8691	925	12	in	in	IN
8691	925	13	the	the	DT
8691	925	14	plainest	plain	JJS
8691	925	15	case	case	NN
8691	925	16	that	that	IN
8691	925	17	a	a	DT
8691	925	18	judge	judge	NN
8691	925	19	can	can	MD
8691	925	20	properly	properly	RB
8691	925	21	or	or	CC
8691	925	22	safely	safely	RB
8691	925	23	base	base	VB
8691	925	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	925	25	decision	decision	NN
8691	925	26	on	on	IN
8691	925	27	a	a	DT
8691	925	28	position	position	NN
8691	925	29	not	not	RB
8691	925	30	suggested	suggest	VBN
8691	925	31	at	at	IN
8691	925	32	the	the	DT
8691	925	33	bar	bar	NN
8691	925	34	or	or	CC
8691	925	35	as	as	IN
8691	925	36	to	to	IN
8691	925	37	the	the	DT
8691	925	38	soundness	soundness	NN
8691	925	39	of	of	IN
8691	925	40	which	which	WDT
8691	925	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	925	42	has	have	VBZ
8691	925	43	not	not	RB
8691	925	44	asked	ask	VBN
8691	925	45	the	the	DT
8691	925	46	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	925	47	of	of	IN
8691	925	48	the	the	DT
8691	925	49	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	925	50	at	at	IN
8691	925	51	the	the	DT
8691	925	52	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	925	53	.	.	.
8691	926	1	The	the	DT
8691	926	2	development	development	NN
8691	926	3	of	of	IN
8691	926	4	law	law	NN
8691	926	5	,	,	,
8691	926	6	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	926	7	,	,	,
8691	926	8	whether	whether	IN
8691	926	9	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	926	10	or	or	CC
8691	926	11	written	write	VBN
8691	926	12	,	,	,
8691	926	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	926	14	primarily	primarily	RB
8691	926	15	the	the	DT
8691	926	16	work	work	NN
8691	926	17	of	of	IN
8691	926	18	the	the	DT
8691	926	19	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	926	20	.	.	.
8691	927	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	927	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	927	3	the	the	DT
8691	927	4	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	927	5	by	by	IN
8691	927	6	the	the	DT
8691	927	7	judge	judge	NN
8691	927	8	of	of	IN
8691	927	9	what	what	WP
8691	927	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	927	11	proposed	propose	VBN
8691	927	12	at	at	IN
8691	927	13	the	the	DT
8691	927	14	bar	bar	NN
8691	927	15	.	.	.
8691	928	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	928	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	928	3	:	:	:
8691	928	4	See	see	VB
8691	928	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	928	6	.	.	.
8691	929	1	VI	VI	NNP
8691	929	2	,	,	,
8691	929	3	X.	X.	NNP
8691	929	4	]	]	-RRB-
8691	930	1	There	there	EX
8691	930	2	are	be	VBP
8691	930	3	obvious	obvious	JJ
8691	930	4	limits	limit	NNS
8691	930	5	to	to	IN
8691	930	6	this	this	DT
8691	930	7	power	power	NN
8691	930	8	of	of	IN
8691	930	9	developing	develop	VBG
8691	930	10	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	930	11	law	law	NN
8691	930	12	.	.	.
8691	931	1	The	the	DT
8691	931	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	931	3	are	be	VBP
8691	931	4	not	not	RB
8691	931	5	to	to	TO
8691	931	6	push	push	VB
8691	931	7	forward	forward	RB
8691	931	8	into	into	IN
8691	931	9	a	a	DT
8691	931	10	place	place	NN
8691	931	11	more	more	RBR
8691	931	12	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
8691	931	13	for	for	IN
8691	931	14	the	the	DT
8691	931	15	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	931	16	to	to	TO
8691	931	17	occupy	occupy	VB
8691	931	18	.	.	.
8691	932	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	932	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	932	3	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
8691	932	4	of	of	IN
8691	932	5	the	the	DT
8691	932	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	932	7	Court	Court	NNP
8691	932	8	of	of	IN
8691	932	9	the	the	DT
8691	932	10	United	United	NNP
8691	932	11	States	States	NNP
8691	932	12	,	,	,
8691	932	13	when	when	WRB
8691	932	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	932	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	932	16	of	of	IN
8691	932	17	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	932	18	,	,	,
8691	932	19	stated	state	VBD
8691	932	20	with	with	IN
8691	932	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	932	22	usual	usual	JJ
8691	932	23	elegance	elegance	NN
8691	932	24	and	and	CC
8691	932	25	force	force	VB
8691	932	26	the	the	DT
8691	932	27	bounds	bound	NNS
8691	932	28	within	within	IN
8691	932	29	which	which	WDT
8691	932	30	,	,	,
8691	932	31	as	as	IN
8691	932	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	932	33	seemed	seem	VBD
8691	932	34	to	to	IN
8691	932	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	932	36	,	,	,
8691	932	37	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	932	38	authority	authority	NN
8691	932	39	should	should	MD
8691	932	40	be	be	VB
8691	932	41	kept	keep	VBN
8691	932	42	.	.	.
8691	933	1	In	in	IN
8691	933	2	a	a	DT
8691	933	3	common	common	JJ
8691	933	4	law	law	NN
8691	933	5	suit	suit	NN
8691	933	6	against	against	IN
8691	933	7	a	a	DT
8691	933	8	railroad	railroad	NN
8691	933	9	company	company	NN
8691	933	10	for	for	IN
8691	933	11	damages	damage	NNS
8691	933	12	suffered	suffer	VBN
8691	933	13	by	by	IN
8691	933	14	an	an	DT
8691	933	15	accident	accident	NN
8691	933	16	on	on	IN
8691	933	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	933	18	road	road	NN
8691	933	19	,	,	,
8691	933	20	the	the	DT
8691	933	21	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	933	22	had	have	VBD
8691	933	23	asked	ask	VBN
8691	933	24	the	the	DT
8691	933	25	trial	trial	NN
8691	933	26	court	court	NN
8691	933	27	to	to	TO
8691	933	28	order	order	VB
8691	933	29	the	the	DT
8691	933	30	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	933	31	to	to	TO
8691	933	32	submit	submit	VB
8691	933	33	to	to	IN
8691	933	34	an	an	DT
8691	933	35	examination	examination	NN
8691	933	36	of	of	IN
8691	933	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	933	38	person	person	NN
8691	933	39	by	by	IN
8691	933	40	a	a	DT
8691	933	41	physician	physician	NN
8691	933	42	whom	whom	WP
8691	933	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	933	44	named	name	VBD
8691	933	45	,	,	,
8691	933	46	for	for	IN
8691	933	47	the	the	DT
8691	933	48	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	933	49	of	of	IN
8691	933	50	determining	determine	VBG
8691	933	51	what	what	WDT
8691	933	52	injuries	injury	NNS
8691	933	53	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	933	54	had	have	VBD
8691	933	55	really	really	RB
8691	933	56	suffered	suffer	VBN
8691	933	57	.	.	.
8691	934	1	"	"	``
8691	934	2	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	934	3	agree	agree	VBP
8691	934	4	,	,	,
8691	934	5	"	"	''
8691	934	6	said	say	VBD
8691	934	7	the	the	DT
8691	934	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	934	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	934	10	,	,	,
8691	934	11	"	"	''
8691	934	12	that	that	IN
8691	934	13	in	in	IN
8691	934	14	view	view	NN
8691	934	15	of	of	IN
8691	934	16	the	the	DT
8691	934	17	great	great	JJ
8691	934	18	increase	increase	NN
8691	934	19	of	of	IN
8691	934	20	actions	action	NNS
8691	934	21	for	for	IN
8691	934	22	personal	personal	JJ
8691	934	23	injuries	injury	NNS
8691	934	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	934	25	may	may	MD
8691	934	26	be	be	VB
8691	934	27	desirable	desirable	JJ
8691	934	28	that	that	IN
8691	934	29	the	the	DT
8691	934	30	courts	court	NNS
8691	934	31	should	should	MD
8691	934	32	have	have	VB
8691	934	33	the	the	DT
8691	934	34	power	power	NN
8691	934	35	in	in	IN
8691	934	36	dispute	dispute	NN
8691	934	37	.	.	.
8691	935	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	935	2	appreciate	appreciate	VBP
8691	935	3	the	the	DT
8691	935	4	ease	ease	NN
8691	935	5	with	with	IN
8691	935	6	which	which	WDT
8691	935	7	,	,	,
8691	935	8	if	if	IN
8691	935	9	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	935	10	were	be	VBD
8691	935	11	careless	careless	JJ
8691	935	12	or	or	CC
8691	935	13	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
8691	935	14	of	of	IN
8691	935	15	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	935	16	,	,	,
8691	935	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	935	18	might	may	MD
8691	935	19	deem	deem	VB
8691	935	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	935	21	enlightened	enlighten	VBN
8691	935	22	to	to	TO
8691	935	23	assume	assume	VB
8691	935	24	that	that	IN
8691	935	25	power	power	NN
8691	935	26	.	.	.
8691	936	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	936	2	do	do	VBP
8691	936	3	not	not	RB
8691	936	4	forget	forget	VB
8691	936	5	the	the	DT
8691	936	6	continuous	continuous	JJ
8691	936	7	process	process	NN
8691	936	8	of	of	IN
8691	936	9	developing	develop	VBG
8691	936	10	the	the	DT
8691	936	11	law	law	NN
8691	936	12	that	that	WDT
8691	936	13	goes	go	VBZ
8691	936	14	on	on	RP
8691	936	15	through	through	IN
8691	936	16	the	the	DT
8691	936	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	936	18	in	in	IN
8691	936	19	the	the	DT
8691	936	20	form	form	NN
8691	936	21	of	of	IN
8691	936	22	deduction	deduction	NN
8691	936	23	or	or	CC
8691	936	24	deny	deny	VB
8691	936	25	that	that	IN
8691	936	26	in	in	IN
8691	936	27	a	a	DT
8691	936	28	clear	clear	JJ
8691	936	29	case	case	NN
8691	936	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	936	31	might	may	MD
8691	936	32	be	be	VB
8691	936	33	possible	possible	JJ
8691	936	34	even	even	RB
8691	936	35	to	to	TO
8691	936	36	break	break	VB
8691	936	37	away	away	RB
8691	936	38	from	from	IN
8691	936	39	a	a	DT
8691	936	40	line	line	NN
8691	936	41	of	of	IN
8691	936	42	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	936	43	in	in	IN
8691	936	44	favor	favor	NN
8691	936	45	of	of	IN
8691	936	46	some	some	DT
8691	936	47	rule	rule	NN
8691	936	48	generally	generally	RB
8691	936	49	admitted	admit	VBD
8691	936	50	to	to	TO
8691	936	51	be	be	VB
8691	936	52	based	base	VBN
8691	936	53	upon	upon	IN
8691	936	54	a	a	DT
8691	936	55	deeper	deep	JJR
8691	936	56	insight	insight	NN
8691	936	57	into	into	IN
8691	936	58	the	the	DT
8691	936	59	present	present	JJ
8691	936	60	wants	want	NNS
8691	936	61	of	of	IN
8691	936	62	society	society	NN
8691	936	63	.	.	.
8691	937	1	But	but	CC
8691	937	2	the	the	DT
8691	937	3	improvements	improvement	NNS
8691	937	4	made	make	VBN
8691	937	5	by	by	IN
8691	937	6	the	the	DT
8691	937	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	937	8	are	be	VBP
8691	937	9	made	make	VBN
8691	937	10	,	,	,
8691	937	11	almost	almost	RB
8691	937	12	invariably	invariably	RB
8691	937	13	,	,	,
8691	937	14	by	by	IN
8691	937	15	very	very	RB
8691	937	16	slow	slow	JJ
8691	937	17	degrees	degree	NNS
8691	937	18	and	and	CC
8691	937	19	by	by	IN
8691	937	20	very	very	RB
8691	937	21	short	short	JJ
8691	937	22	steps	step	NNS
8691	937	23	.	.	.
8691	938	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	938	2	general	general	JJ
8691	938	3	duty	duty	NN
8691	938	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	938	5	not	not	RB
8691	938	6	to	to	TO
8691	938	7	change	change	VB
8691	938	8	,	,	,
8691	938	9	but	but	CC
8691	938	10	to	to	TO
8691	938	11	work	work	VB
8691	938	12	out	out	RP
8691	938	13	,	,	,
8691	938	14	the	the	DT
8691	938	15	principles	principle	NNS
8691	938	16	already	already	RB
8691	938	17	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
8691	938	18	by	by	IN
8691	938	19	the	the	DT
8691	938	20	practice	practice	NN
8691	938	21	of	of	IN
8691	938	22	the	the	DT
8691	938	23	past	past	NN
8691	938	24	.	.	.
8691	939	1	No	no	DT
8691	939	2	one	one	NN
8691	939	3	supposes	suppose	VBZ
8691	939	4	that	that	IN
8691	939	5	a	a	DT
8691	939	6	judge	judge	NN
8691	939	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	939	8	at	at	IN
8691	939	9	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	939	10	to	to	TO
8691	939	11	decide	decide	VB
8691	939	12	with	with	IN
8691	939	13	sole	sole	JJ
8691	939	14	reference	reference	NN
8691	939	15	even	even	RB
8691	939	16	to	to	IN
8691	939	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	939	18	strongest	strong	JJS
8691	939	19	convictions	conviction	NNS
8691	939	20	of	of	IN
8691	939	21	policy	policy	NN
8691	939	22	and	and	CC
8691	939	23	right	right	NN
8691	939	24	.	.	.
8691	940	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	940	2	duty	duty	NN
8691	940	3	in	in	IN
8691	940	4	general	general	JJ
8691	940	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	940	6	to	to	TO
8691	940	7	develop	develop	VB
8691	940	8	the	the	DT
8691	940	9	principles	principle	NNS
8691	940	10	which	which	WDT
8691	940	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	940	12	finds	find	VBZ
8691	940	13	with	with	IN
8691	940	14	such	such	JJ
8691	940	15	consistency	consistency	NN
8691	940	16	as	as	IN
8691	940	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	940	18	may	may	MD
8691	940	19	be	be	VB
8691	940	20	able	able	JJ
8691	940	21	to	to	TO
8691	940	22	attain	attain	VB
8691	940	23	....	....	.
8691	941	1	In	in	IN
8691	941	2	the	the	DT
8691	941	3	present	present	JJ
8691	941	4	case	case	NN
8691	941	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	941	6	perceive	perceive	VBP
8691	941	7	no	no	DT
8691	941	8	such	such	JJ
8691	941	9	pressing	pressing	JJ
8691	941	10	need	need	NN
8691	941	11	of	of	IN
8691	941	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	941	13	anticipating	anticipate	VBG
8691	941	14	the	the	DT
8691	941	15	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	941	16	as	as	IN
8691	941	17	to	to	TO
8691	941	18	justify	justify	VB
8691	941	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	941	20	departure	departure	NN
8691	941	21	from	from	IN
8691	941	22	what	what	WP
8691	941	23	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	941	24	can	can	MD
8691	941	25	not	not	RB
8691	941	26	doubt	doubt	VB
8691	941	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	941	28	the	the	DT
8691	941	29	settled	settled	JJ
8691	941	30	tradition	tradition	NN
8691	941	31	of	of	IN
8691	941	32	the	the	DT
8691	941	33	common	common	JJ
8691	941	34	law	law	NN
8691	941	35	to	to	IN
8691	941	36	a	a	DT
8691	941	37	point	point	NN
8691	941	38	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	941	39	that	that	DT
8691	941	40	which	which	WDT
8691	941	41	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	941	42	believe	believe	VBP
8691	941	43	to	to	TO
8691	941	44	have	have	VB
8691	941	45	been	be	VBN
8691	941	46	reached	reach	VBN
8691	941	47	by	by	IN
8691	941	48	equity	equity	NN
8691	941	49	,	,	,
8691	941	50	and	and	CC
8691	941	51	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	941	52	any	any	DT
8691	941	53	to	to	TO
8691	941	54	which	which	WDT
8691	941	55	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	941	56	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	941	57	dealing	deal	VBG
8691	941	58	with	with	IN
8691	941	59	kindred	kindred	JJ
8691	941	60	subjects	subject	NNS
8691	941	61	ever	ever	RB
8691	941	62	have	have	VBP
8691	941	63	seen	see	VBN
8691	941	64	fit	fit	JJ
8691	941	65	to	to	TO
8691	941	66	go	go	VB
8691	941	67	.	.	.
8691	942	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	942	2	will	will	MD
8691	942	3	be	be	VB
8691	942	4	seen	see	VBN
8691	942	5	that	that	IN
8691	942	6	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	942	7	put	put	VBP
8691	942	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	942	9	decision	decision	NN
8691	942	10	,	,	,
8691	942	11	not	not	RB
8691	942	12	upon	upon	IN
8691	942	13	the	the	DT
8691	942	14	impolicy	impolicy	NN
8691	942	15	of	of	IN
8691	942	16	admitting	admit	VBG
8691	942	17	such	such	PDT
8691	942	18	a	a	DT
8691	942	19	power	power	NN
8691	942	20	,	,	,
8691	942	21	but	but	CC
8691	942	22	on	on	IN
8691	942	23	the	the	DT
8691	942	24	ground	ground	NN
8691	942	25	that	that	IN
8691	942	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	942	27	would	would	MD
8691	942	28	be	be	VB
8691	942	29	too	too	RB
8691	942	30	great	great	JJ
8691	942	31	a	a	DT
8691	942	32	step	step	NN
8691	942	33	of	of	IN
8691	942	34	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	942	35	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	942	36	to	to	TO
8691	942	37	be	be	VB
8691	942	38	justified	justify	VBN
8691	942	39	by	by	IN
8691	942	40	the	the	DT
8691	942	41	necessities	necessity	NNS
8691	942	42	of	of	IN
8691	942	43	the	the	DT
8691	942	44	case	case	NN
8691	942	45	.	.	.
8691	943	1	"	"	``
8691	943	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	943	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	943	4	:	:	:
8691	943	5	Stack	Stack	NNP
8691	943	6	_	_	NNP
8691	943	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	943	8	_	_	NNP
8691	943	9	New	New	NNP
8691	943	10	York	York	NNP
8691	943	11	,	,	,
8691	943	12	New	New	NNP
8691	943	13	Haven	Haven	NNP
8691	943	14	and	and	CC
8691	943	15	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
8691	943	16	Railroad	Railroad	NNP
8691	943	17	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	943	18	,	,	,
8691	943	19	177	177	CD
8691	943	20	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	943	21	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	943	22	,	,	,
8691	943	23	155	155	CD
8691	943	24	;	;	:
8691	943	25	58	58	CD
8691	943	26	Northeastern	northeastern	JJ
8691	943	27	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	943	28	,	,	,
8691	943	29	686	686	CD
8691	943	30	.	.	.
8691	943	31	]	]	-RRB-
8691	944	1	The	the	DT
8691	944	2	theory	theory	NN
8691	944	3	of	of	IN
8691	944	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	944	5	power	power	NN
8691	944	6	thus	thus	RB
8691	944	7	stated	state	VBD
8691	944	8	carries	carry	VBZ
8691	944	9	implications	implication	NNS
8691	944	10	that	that	WDT
8691	944	11	would	would	MD
8691	944	12	not	not	RB
8691	944	13	be	be	VB
8691	944	14	universally	universally	RB
8691	944	15	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	944	16	.	.	.
8691	945	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	945	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	945	3	intimated	intimate	VBN
8691	945	4	that	that	IN
8691	945	5	if	if	IN
8691	945	6	the	the	DT
8691	945	7	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	945	8	had	have	VBD
8691	945	9	seemed	seem	VBN
8691	945	10	strong	strong	JJ
8691	945	11	enough	enough	RB
8691	945	12	to	to	TO
8691	945	13	call	call	VB
8691	945	14	for	for	IN
8691	945	15	the	the	DT
8691	945	16	order	order	NN
8691	945	17	asked	ask	VBD
8691	945	18	for	for	IN
8691	945	19	in	in	IN
8691	945	20	the	the	DT
8691	945	21	trial	trial	NN
8691	945	22	court	court	NN
8691	945	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	945	24	ought	ought	MD
8691	945	25	to	to	TO
8691	945	26	have	have	VB
8691	945	27	been	be	VBN
8691	945	28	granted	grant	VBN
8691	945	29	,	,	,
8691	945	30	although	although	IN
8691	945	31	not	not	RB
8691	945	32	justified	justify	VBN
8691	945	33	by	by	IN
8691	945	34	any	any	DT
8691	945	35	settled	settle	VBN
8691	945	36	rule	rule	NN
8691	945	37	or	or	CC
8691	945	38	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
8691	945	39	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	945	40	,	,	,
8691	945	41	nor	nor	CC
8691	945	42	by	by	IN
8691	945	43	any	any	DT
8691	945	44	clear	clear	JJ
8691	945	45	analogy	analogy	NN
8691	945	46	from	from	IN
8691	945	47	such	such	PDT
8691	945	48	a	a	DT
8691	945	49	rule	rule	NN
8691	945	50	or	or	CC
8691	945	51	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	945	52	.	.	.
8691	946	1	This	this	DT
8691	946	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	946	3	a	a	DT
8691	946	4	view	view	NN
8691	946	5	taken	take	VBN
8691	946	6	,	,	,
8691	946	7	though	though	IN
8691	946	8	with	with	IN
8691	946	9	less	less	JJR
8691	946	10	caution	caution	NN
8691	946	11	and	and	CC
8691	946	12	qualification	qualification	NN
8691	946	13	,	,	,
8691	946	14	in	in	IN
8691	946	15	a	a	DT
8691	946	16	work	work	NN
8691	946	17	written	write	VBN
8691	946	18	by	by	IN
8691	946	19	the	the	DT
8691	946	20	same	same	JJ
8691	946	21	hand	hand	NN
8691	946	22	many	many	JJ
8691	946	23	years	year	NNS
8691	946	24	before	before	RB
8691	946	25	,	,	,
8691	946	26	which	which	WDT
8691	946	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	946	28	recognized	recognize	VBN
8691	946	29	as	as	IN
8691	946	30	a	a	DT
8691	946	31	legal	legal	JJ
8691	946	32	classic	classic	NN
8691	946	33	on	on	IN
8691	946	34	both	both	DT
8691	946	35	sides	side	NNS
8691	946	36	of	of	IN
8691	946	37	the	the	DT
8691	946	38	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	946	39	.	.	.
8691	947	1	In	in	IN
8691	947	2	"	"	``
8691	947	3	The	the	DT
8691	947	4	Common	common	JJ
8691	947	5	Law,"[Footnote	law,"[footnote	NN
8691	947	6	:	:	:
8691	947	7	Pp	Pp	NNP
8691	947	8	.	.	.
8691	948	1	35	35	CD
8691	948	2	,	,	,
8691	948	3	36	36	CD
8691	948	4	.	.	.
8691	948	5	]	]	-RRB-
8691	949	1	after	after	IN
8691	949	2	discussing	discuss	VBG
8691	949	3	some	some	DT
8691	949	4	of	of	IN
8691	949	5	the	the	DT
8691	949	6	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	949	7	which	which	WDT
8691	949	8	actuate	actuate	VBP
8691	949	9	judges	judge	NNS
8691	949	10	in	in	IN
8691	949	11	assuming	assume	VBG
8691	949	12	to	to	TO
8691	949	13	unfold	unfold	VB
8691	949	14	the	the	DT
8691	949	15	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	949	16	law	law	NN
8691	949	17	,	,	,
8691	949	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	949	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	949	20	stated	state	VBN
8691	949	21	thus	thus	RB
8691	949	22	:	:	:
8691	949	23	The	the	DT
8691	949	24	very	very	JJ
8691	949	25	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	949	26	which	which	WDT
8691	949	27	judges	judge	VBZ
8691	949	28	most	most	RBS
8691	949	29	rarely	rarely	RB
8691	949	30	mention	mention	VBP
8691	949	31	,	,	,
8691	949	32	and	and	CC
8691	949	33	always	always	RB
8691	949	34	with	with	IN
8691	949	35	an	an	DT
8691	949	36	apology	apology	NN
8691	949	37	,	,	,
8691	949	38	are	be	VBP
8691	949	39	the	the	DT
8691	949	40	secret	secret	JJ
8691	949	41	root	root	NN
8691	949	42	from	from	IN
8691	949	43	which	which	WDT
8691	949	44	the	the	DT
8691	949	45	law	law	NN
8691	949	46	draws	draw	VBZ
8691	949	47	all	all	PDT
8691	949	48	the	the	DT
8691	949	49	juices	juice	NNS
8691	949	50	of	of	IN
8691	949	51	life	life	NN
8691	949	52	.	.	.
8691	950	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	950	2	mean	mean	VBP
8691	950	3	,	,	,
8691	950	4	of	of	IN
8691	950	5	course	course	NN
8691	950	6	,	,	,
8691	950	7	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	950	8	of	of	IN
8691	950	9	what	what	WP
8691	950	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	950	11	expedient	expedient	NN
8691	950	12	for	for	IN
8691	950	13	the	the	DT
8691	950	14	community	community	NN
8691	950	15	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	950	16	.	.	.
8691	951	1	Every	every	DT
8691	951	2	important	important	JJ
8691	951	3	principle	principle	NN
8691	951	4	which	which	WDT
8691	951	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	951	6	developed	develop	VBN
8691	951	7	by	by	IN
8691	951	8	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	951	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	951	10	in	in	IN
8691	951	11	fact	fact	NN
8691	951	12	and	and	CC
8691	951	13	at	at	IN
8691	951	14	bottom	bottom	NN
8691	951	15	the	the	DT
8691	951	16	result	result	NN
8691	951	17	of	of	IN
8691	951	18	more	more	JJR
8691	951	19	or	or	CC
8691	951	20	less	less	RBR
8691	951	21	definitely	definitely	RB
8691	951	22	understood	understand	VBN
8691	951	23	views	view	NNS
8691	951	24	of	of	IN
8691	951	25	public	public	JJ
8691	951	26	policy	policy	NN
8691	951	27	:	:	:
8691	951	28	most	most	RBS
8691	951	29	generally	generally	RB
8691	951	30	,	,	,
8691	951	31	to	to	TO
8691	951	32	be	be	VB
8691	951	33	sure	sure	JJ
8691	951	34	,	,	,
8691	951	35	under	under	IN
8691	951	36	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	951	37	practice	practice	NN
8691	951	38	and	and	CC
8691	951	39	traditions	tradition	VBZ
8691	951	40	the	the	DT
8691	951	41	unconscious	unconscious	JJ
8691	951	42	result	result	NN
8691	951	43	of	of	IN
8691	951	44	instinctive	instinctive	JJ
8691	951	45	preferences	preference	NNS
8691	951	46	and	and	CC
8691	951	47	inarticulate	inarticulate	JJ
8691	951	48	convictions	conviction	NNS
8691	951	49	,	,	,
8691	951	50	but	but	CC
8691	951	51	none	none	NN
8691	951	52	the	the	DT
8691	951	53	less	less	RBR
8691	951	54	traceable	traceable	JJ
8691	951	55	to	to	IN
8691	951	56	views	view	NNS
8691	951	57	of	of	IN
8691	951	58	public	public	JJ
8691	951	59	policy	policy	NN
8691	951	60	in	in	IN
8691	951	61	the	the	DT
8691	951	62	last	last	JJ
8691	951	63	analysis	analysis	NN
8691	951	64	....	....	.
8691	952	1	The	the	DT
8691	952	2	truth	truth	NN
8691	952	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	952	4	that	that	IN
8691	952	5	the	the	DT
8691	952	6	law	law	NN
8691	952	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	952	8	always	always	RB
8691	952	9	approaching	approach	VBG
8691	952	10	and	and	CC
8691	952	11	never	never	RB
8691	952	12	reaching	reach	VBG
8691	952	13	consistency	consistency	NN
8691	952	14	.	.	.
8691	953	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	953	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	953	3	forever	forever	RB
8691	953	4	adopting	adopt	VBG
8691	953	5	new	new	JJ
8691	953	6	principles	principle	NNS
8691	953	7	from	from	IN
8691	953	8	life	life	NN
8691	953	9	at	at	IN
8691	953	10	one	one	CD
8691	953	11	end	end	NN
8691	953	12	,	,	,
8691	953	13	and	and	CC
8691	953	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	953	15	always	always	RB
8691	953	16	retains	retain	VBZ
8691	953	17	old	old	JJ
8691	953	18	ones	one	NNS
8691	953	19	from	from	IN
8691	953	20	history	history	NN
8691	953	21	at	at	IN
8691	953	22	the	the	DT
8691	953	23	other	other	JJ
8691	953	24	,	,	,
8691	953	25	which	which	WDT
8691	953	26	have	have	VBP
8691	953	27	not	not	RB
8691	953	28	yet	yet	RB
8691	953	29	been	be	VBN
8691	953	30	absorbed	absorb	VBN
8691	953	31	or	or	CC
8691	953	32	sloughed	slough	VBN
8691	953	33	off	off	RP
8691	953	34	.	.	.
8691	954	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	954	2	will	will	MD
8691	954	3	become	become	VB
8691	954	4	entirely	entirely	RB
8691	954	5	consistent	consistent	JJ
8691	954	6	only	only	RB
8691	954	7	when	when	WRB
8691	954	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	954	9	ceases	cease	VBZ
8691	954	10	to	to	TO
8691	954	11	grow	grow	VB
8691	954	12	.	.	.
8691	955	1	Courts	court	NNS
8691	955	2	enter	enter	VBP
8691	955	3	on	on	IN
8691	955	4	a	a	DT
8691	955	5	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
8691	955	6	ground	ground	NN
8691	955	7	when	when	WRB
8691	955	8	,	,	,
8691	955	9	to	to	TO
8691	955	10	justify	justify	VB
8691	955	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	955	12	action	action	NN
8691	955	13	,	,	,
8691	955	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	955	15	rely	rely	VBP
8691	955	16	on	on	IN
8691	955	17	any	any	DT
8691	955	18	rule	rule	NN
8691	955	19	of	of	IN
8691	955	20	public	public	JJ
8691	955	21	policy	policy	NN
8691	955	22	not	not	RB
8691	955	23	stated	state	VBN
8691	955	24	in	in	IN
8691	955	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	955	26	or	or	CC
8691	955	27	statute	statute	NN
8691	955	28	and	and	CC
8691	955	29	unknown	unknown	JJ
8691	955	30	to	to	IN
8691	955	31	the	the	DT
8691	955	32	common	common	JJ
8691	955	33	law	law	NN
8691	955	34	.	.	.
8691	956	1	If	if	IN
8691	956	2	such	such	JJ
8691	956	3	was	be	VBD
8691	956	4	once	once	RB
8691	956	5	the	the	DT
8691	956	6	habit	habit	NN
8691	956	7	of	of	IN
8691	956	8	the	the	DT
8691	956	9	English	english	JJ
8691	956	10	courts	court	NNS
8691	956	11	,	,	,
8691	956	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	956	13	was	be	VBD
8691	956	14	because	because	IN
8691	956	15	of	of	IN
8691	956	16	social	social	JJ
8691	956	17	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	956	18	with	with	IN
8691	956	19	which	which	WDT
8691	956	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	956	21	had	have	VBD
8691	956	22	to	to	TO
8691	956	23	deal	deal	VB
8691	956	24	which	which	WDT
8691	956	25	no	no	RB
8691	956	26	longer	longer	RB
8691	956	27	exist	exist	VBP
8691	956	28	either	either	CC
8691	956	29	in	in	IN
8691	956	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	956	31	country	country	NN
8691	956	32	or	or	CC
8691	956	33	in	in	IN
8691	956	34	ours	-PRON-	PRP
8691	956	35	.	.	.
8691	957	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	957	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	957	3	for	for	IN
8691	957	4	the	the	DT
8691	957	5	judge	judge	NN
8691	957	6	to	to	TO
8691	957	7	adapt	adapt	VB
8691	957	8	old	old	JJ
8691	957	9	principles	principle	NNS
8691	957	10	rather	rather	RB
8691	957	11	than	than	IN
8691	957	12	adopt	adopt	VB
8691	957	13	new	new	JJ
8691	957	14	ones	one	NNS
8691	957	15	.	.	.
8691	958	1	What	what	WP
8691	958	2	one	one	CD
8691	958	3	man	man	NN
8691	958	4	thinks	think	VBZ
8691	958	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	958	6	public	public	JJ
8691	958	7	policy	policy	NN
8691	958	8	another	another	DT
8691	958	9	,	,	,
8691	958	10	equally	equally	RB
8691	958	11	clear	clear	RB
8691	958	12	-	-	HYPH
8691	958	13	headed	headed	JJ
8691	958	14	and	and	CC
8691	958	15	well	well	RB
8691	958	16	-	-	HYPH
8691	958	17	informed	inform	VBN
8691	958	18	,	,	,
8691	958	19	may	may	MD
8691	958	20	not	not	RB
8691	958	21	.	.	.
8691	959	1	The	the	DT
8691	959	2	safe	safe	JJ
8691	959	3	course	course	NN
8691	959	4	for	for	IN
8691	959	5	the	the	DT
8691	959	6	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	959	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	959	8	to	to	TO
8691	959	9	rely	rely	VB
8691	959	10	on	on	IN
8691	959	11	the	the	DT
8691	959	12	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	959	13	to	to	TO
8691	959	14	declare	declare	VB
8691	959	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	959	16	,	,	,
8691	959	17	so	so	RB
8691	959	18	far	far	RB
8691	959	19	as	as	IN
8691	959	20	the	the	DT
8691	959	21	common	common	JJ
8691	959	22	law	law	NN
8691	959	23	does	do	VBZ
8691	959	24	not	not	RB
8691	959	25	.	.	.
8691	960	1	If	if	IN
8691	960	2	,	,	,
8691	960	3	however	however	RB
8691	960	4	,	,	,
8691	960	5	the	the	DT
8691	960	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	960	7	of	of	IN
8691	960	8	a	a	DT
8691	960	9	State	state	NN
8691	960	10	are	be	VBP
8691	960	11	called	call	VBN
8691	960	12	upon	upon	IN
8691	960	13	for	for	IN
8691	960	14	the	the	DT
8691	960	15	first	first	JJ
8691	960	16	time	time	NN
8691	960	17	to	to	TO
8691	960	18	declare	declare	VB
8691	960	19	what	what	WP
8691	960	20	any	any	DT
8691	960	21	rule	rule	NN
8691	960	22	of	of	IN
8691	960	23	the	the	DT
8691	960	24	common	common	JJ
8691	960	25	law	law	NN
8691	960	26	,	,	,
8691	960	27	governing	govern	VBG
8691	960	28	a	a	DT
8691	960	29	past	past	JJ
8691	960	30	transaction	transaction	NN
8691	960	31	,	,	,
8691	960	32	is	be	VBZ
8691	960	33	,	,	,
8691	960	34	or	or	CC
8691	960	35	at	at	IN
8691	960	36	a	a	DT
8691	960	37	given	give	VBN
8691	960	38	time	time	NN
8691	960	39	was	be	VBD
8691	960	40	,	,	,
8691	960	41	in	in	IN
8691	960	42	that	that	DT
8691	960	43	State	State	NNP
8691	960	44	,	,	,
8691	960	45	and	and	CC
8691	960	46	this	this	DT
8691	960	47	be	be	VB
8691	960	48	a	a	DT
8691	960	49	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
8691	960	50	question	question	NN
8691	960	51	,	,	,
8691	960	52	the	the	DT
8691	960	53	decision	decision	NN
8691	960	54	virtually	virtually	RB
8691	960	55	calls	call	VBZ
8691	960	56	for	for	IN
8691	960	57	the	the	DT
8691	960	58	making	making	NN
8691	960	59	of	of	IN
8691	960	60	a	a	DT
8691	960	61	new	new	JJ
8691	960	62	rule	rule	NN
8691	960	63	,	,	,
8691	960	64	though	though	IN
8691	960	65	under	under	IN
8691	960	66	the	the	DT
8691	960	67	form	form	NN
8691	960	68	of	of	IN
8691	960	69	applying	apply	VBG
8691	960	70	an	an	DT
8691	960	71	old	old	JJ
8691	960	72	one	one	NN
8691	960	73	,	,	,
8691	960	74	and	and	CC
8691	960	75	that	that	DT
8691	960	76	will	will	MD
8691	960	77	be	be	VB
8691	960	78	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	960	79	which	which	WDT
8691	960	80	may	may	MD
8691	960	81	be	be	VB
8691	960	82	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	960	83	best	well	RBS
8691	960	84	calculated	calculate	VBN
8691	960	85	to	to	TO
8691	960	86	do	do	VB
8691	960	87	justice	justice	NN
8691	960	88	in	in	IN
8691	960	89	cases	case	NNS
8691	960	90	of	of	IN
8691	960	91	that	that	DT
8691	960	92	particular	particular	JJ
8691	960	93	character	character	NN
8691	960	94	.	.	.
8691	961	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	961	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	961	3	:	:	:
8691	961	4	Seery	Seery	NNP
8691	961	5	_	_	NNP
8691	961	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	961	7	_	_	NNP
8691	961	8	Waterbury	Waterbury	NNP
8691	961	9	,	,	,
8691	961	10	82	82	CD
8691	961	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	961	12	,	,	,
8691	961	13	567	567	CD
8691	961	14	,	,	,
8691	961	15	571	571	CD
8691	961	16	;	;	:
8691	961	17	74	74	CD
8691	961	18	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	961	19	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	961	20	,	,	,
8691	961	21	908	908	CD
8691	961	22	.	.	.
8691	961	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	962	1	*	*	NFP
8691	962	2	*	*	NFP
8691	962	3	*	*	NFP
8691	962	4	*	*	NFP
8691	962	5	*	*	NFP
8691	962	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	962	7	VI	VI	NNP
8691	962	8	THE	the	DT
8691	962	9	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	962	10	POWER	power	NN
8691	962	11	OF	of	IN
8691	962	12	INTERPRETING	interpreting	NN
8691	962	13	AND	and	CC
8691	962	14	DEVELOPING	develop	VBG
8691	962	15	WRITTEN	WRITTEN	NNP
8691	962	16	LAW	LAW	NNP
8691	962	17	As	as	IN
8691	962	18	governments	government	NNS
8691	962	19	must	must	MD
8691	962	20	provide	provide	VB
8691	962	21	some	some	DT
8691	962	22	authority	authority	NN
8691	962	23	to	to	TO
8691	962	24	declare	declare	VB
8691	962	25	what	what	WP
8691	962	26	the	the	DT
8691	962	27	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	962	28	law	law	NN
8691	962	29	governing	govern	VBG
8691	962	30	any	any	DT
8691	962	31	transaction	transaction	NN
8691	962	32	was	be	VBD
8691	962	33	,	,	,
8691	962	34	so	so	RB
8691	962	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	962	36	must	must	MD
8691	962	37	provide	provide	VB
8691	962	38	some	some	DT
8691	962	39	authority	authority	NN
8691	962	40	to	to	TO
8691	962	41	declare	declare	VB
8691	962	42	what	what	WP
8691	962	43	the	the	DT
8691	962	44	written	written	JJ
8691	962	45	law	law	NN
8691	962	46	governing	govern	VBG
8691	962	47	any	any	DT
8691	962	48	transaction	transaction	NN
8691	962	49	means	mean	VBZ
8691	962	50	.	.	.
8691	963	1	Few	few	JJ
8691	963	2	statements	statement	NNS
8691	963	3	of	of	IN
8691	963	4	any	any	DT
8691	963	5	rule	rule	NN
8691	963	6	or	or	CC
8691	963	7	principle	principle	NN
8691	963	8	can	can	MD
8691	963	9	be	be	VB
8691	963	10	written	write	VBN
8691	963	11	out	out	RP
8691	963	12	in	in	IN
8691	963	13	such	such	PDT
8691	963	14	a	a	DT
8691	963	15	way	way	NN
8691	963	16	as	as	IN
8691	963	17	to	to	TO
8691	963	18	convey	convey	VB
8691	963	19	exactly	exactly	RB
8691	963	20	the	the	DT
8691	963	21	same	same	JJ
8691	963	22	impression	impression	NN
8691	963	23	to	to	IN
8691	963	24	every	every	DT
8691	963	25	mind	mind	NN
8691	963	26	.	.	.
8691	964	1	Thought	thought	NN
8691	964	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	964	3	subtler	subtler	NNP
8691	964	4	than	than	IN
8691	964	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	964	6	expression	expression	NN
8691	964	7	.	.	.
8691	965	1	The	the	DT
8691	965	2	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	965	3	of	of	IN
8691	965	4	written	write	VBN
8691	965	5	laws	law	NNS
8691	965	6	will	will	MD
8691	965	7	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	965	8	often	often	RB
8691	965	9	be	be	VB
8691	965	10	questioned	question	VBN
8691	965	11	.	.	.
8691	966	1	An	an	DT
8691	966	2	answer	answer	NN
8691	966	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	966	4	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	966	5	attempted	attempt	VBN
8691	966	6	by	by	IN
8691	966	7	the	the	DT
8691	966	8	authority	authority	NN
8691	966	9	from	from	IN
8691	966	10	which	which	WDT
8691	966	11	the	the	DT
8691	966	12	law	law	NN
8691	966	13	proceeded	proceed	VBD
8691	966	14	.	.	.
8691	967	1	A	a	DT
8691	967	2	king	king	NN
8691	967	3	declares	declare	VBZ
8691	967	4	what	what	WP
8691	967	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	967	6	intended	intend	VBD
8691	967	7	by	by	IN
8691	967	8	the	the	DT
8691	967	9	terms	term	NNS
8691	967	10	of	of	IN
8691	967	11	an	an	DT
8691	967	12	ambiguous	ambiguous	JJ
8691	967	13	edict	edict	NN
8691	967	14	.	.	.
8691	968	1	A	a	DT
8691	968	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	968	3	passes	pass	VBZ
8691	968	4	an	an	DT
8691	968	5	act	act	NN
8691	968	6	to	to	TO
8691	968	7	declare	declare	VB
8691	968	8	the	the	DT
8691	968	9	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	968	10	of	of	IN
8691	968	11	a	a	DT
8691	968	12	previous	previous	JJ
8691	968	13	one	one	CD
8691	968	14	.	.	.
8691	969	1	But	but	CC
8691	969	2	meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
8691	969	3	rights	right	NNS
8691	969	4	have	have	VBP
8691	969	5	accrued	accrue	VBN
8691	969	6	.	.	.
8691	970	1	Something	something	NN
8691	970	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	970	3	been	be	VBN
8691	970	4	done	do	VBN
8691	970	5	in	in	IN
8691	970	6	reliance	reliance	NN
8691	970	7	upon	upon	IN
8691	970	8	a	a	DT
8691	970	9	certain	certain	JJ
8691	970	10	construction	construction	NN
8691	970	11	of	of	IN
8691	970	12	the	the	DT
8691	970	13	law	law	NN
8691	970	14	.	.	.
8691	971	1	If	if	IN
8691	971	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	971	3	was	be	VBD
8691	971	4	a	a	DT
8691	971	5	right	right	JJ
8691	971	6	construction	construction	NN
8691	971	7	,	,	,
8691	971	8	then	then	RB
8691	971	9	what	what	WP
8691	971	10	was	be	VBD
8691	971	11	done	do	VBN
8691	971	12	was	be	VBD
8691	971	13	lawful	lawful	JJ
8691	971	14	,	,	,
8691	971	15	and	and	CC
8691	971	16	no	no	DT
8691	971	17	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	971	18	explanation	explanation	NN
8691	971	19	of	of	IN
8691	971	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	971	21	intentions	intention	NNS
8691	971	22	by	by	IN
8691	971	23	the	the	DT
8691	971	24	lawgiver	lawgiver	NN
8691	971	25	can	can	MD
8691	971	26	change	change	VB
8691	971	27	this	this	DT
8691	971	28	fact	fact	NN
8691	971	29	.	.	.
8691	972	1	Laws	law	NNS
8691	972	2	are	be	VBP
8691	972	3	addressed	address	VBN
8691	972	4	to	to	IN
8691	972	5	the	the	DT
8691	972	6	community	community	NN
8691	972	7	at	at	IN
8691	972	8	large	large	JJ
8691	972	9	,	,	,
8691	972	10	and	and	CC
8691	972	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	972	12	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	972	13	must	must	MD
8691	972	14	be	be	VB
8691	972	15	determined	determine	VBN
8691	972	16	once	once	RB
8691	972	17	for	for	IN
8691	972	18	all	all	DT
8691	972	19	from	from	IN
8691	972	20	the	the	DT
8691	972	21	language	language	NN
8691	972	22	used	use	VBN
8691	972	23	,	,	,
8691	972	24	however	however	RB
8691	972	25	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
8691	972	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	972	27	may	may	MD
8691	972	28	have	have	VB
8691	972	29	been	be	VBN
8691	972	30	to	to	TO
8691	972	31	express	express	VB
8691	972	32	the	the	DT
8691	972	33	real	real	JJ
8691	972	34	design	design	NN
8691	972	35	of	of	IN
8691	972	36	those	those	DT
8691	972	37	who	who	WP
8691	972	38	enacted	enact	VBD
8691	972	39	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	972	40	,	,	,
8691	972	41	unless	unless	IN
8691	972	42	that	that	DT
8691	972	43	design	design	NN
8691	972	44	so	so	RB
8691	972	45	clearly	clearly	RB
8691	972	46	appears	appear	VBZ
8691	972	47	,	,	,
8691	972	48	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
8691	972	49	an	an	DT
8691	972	50	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
8691	972	51	choice	choice	NN
8691	972	52	of	of	IN
8691	972	53	words	word	NNS
8691	972	54	,	,	,
8691	972	55	as	as	IN
8691	972	56	to	to	TO
8691	972	57	compel	compel	VB
8691	972	58	an	an	DT
8691	972	59	interpretation	interpretation	NN
8691	972	60	against	against	IN
8691	972	61	the	the	DT
8691	972	62	letter	letter	NN
8691	972	63	but	but	CC
8691	972	64	in	in	IN
8691	972	65	obedience	obedience	NN
8691	972	66	to	to	IN
8691	972	67	the	the	DT
8691	972	68	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	972	69	of	of	IN
8691	972	70	the	the	DT
8691	972	71	enactment	enactment	NN
8691	972	72	.	.	.
8691	973	1	A	a	DT
8691	973	2	"	"	``
8691	973	3	declaratory	declaratory	JJ
8691	973	4	statute"--one	statute"--one	NN
8691	973	5	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	973	6	what	what	WP
8691	973	7	a	a	DT
8691	973	8	previous	previous	JJ
8691	973	9	statute	statute	NN
8691	973	10	meant	mean	VBD
8691	973	11	--	--	:
8691	973	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	973	13	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	973	14	,	,	,
8691	973	15	if	if	IN
8691	973	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	973	17	gives	give	VBZ
8691	973	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	973	19	a	a	DT
8691	973	20	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	973	21	unwarranted	unwarranted	JJ
8691	973	22	by	by	IN
8691	973	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	973	24	terms	term	NNS
8691	973	25	when	when	WRB
8691	973	26	so	so	RB
8691	973	27	interpreted	interpret	VBN
8691	973	28	,	,	,
8691	973	29	only	only	RB
8691	973	30	effectual	effectual	JJ
8691	973	31	as	as	IN
8691	973	32	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	973	33	future	future	JJ
8691	973	34	transactions	transaction	NNS
8691	973	35	.	.	.
8691	974	1	As	as	IN
8691	974	2	to	to	IN
8691	974	3	the	the	DT
8691	974	4	past	past	NN
8691	974	5	,	,	,
8691	974	6	the	the	DT
8691	974	7	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	974	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	974	9	for	for	IN
8691	974	10	the	the	DT
8691	974	11	courts	court	NNS
8691	974	12	,	,	,
8691	974	13	and	and	CC
8691	974	14	while	while	IN
8691	974	15	such	such	PDT
8691	974	16	a	a	DT
8691	974	17	statute	statute	NN
8691	974	18	may	may	MD
8691	974	19	aid	aid	VB
8691	974	20	,	,	,
8691	974	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	974	22	can	can	MD
8691	974	23	not	not	RB
8691	974	24	control	control	VB
8691	974	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	974	26	.	.	.
8691	975	1	Are	be	VBP
8691	975	2	the	the	DT
8691	975	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	975	4	to	to	TO
8691	975	5	send	send	VB
8691	975	6	such	such	JJ
8691	975	7	questions	question	NNS
8691	975	8	to	to	IN
8691	975	9	a	a	DT
8691	975	10	jury	jury	NN
8691	975	11	or	or	CC
8691	975	12	shall	shall	MD
8691	975	13	the	the	DT
8691	975	14	judges	judge	NNS
8691	975	15	decide	decide	VB
8691	975	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	975	17	?	?	.
8691	976	1	The	the	DT
8691	976	2	answer	answer	NN
8691	976	3	must	must	MD
8691	976	4	be	be	VB
8691	976	5	determined	determine	VBN
8691	976	6	by	by	IN
8691	976	7	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	976	8	applicable	applicable	JJ
8691	976	9	to	to	IN
8691	976	10	every	every	DT
8691	976	11	sort	sort	NN
8691	976	12	of	of	IN
8691	976	13	written	write	VBN
8691	976	14	paper	paper	NN
8691	976	15	.	.	.
8691	977	1	If	if	IN
8691	977	2	the	the	DT
8691	977	3	true	true	JJ
8691	977	4	construction	construction	NN
8691	977	5	of	of	IN
8691	977	6	an	an	DT
8691	977	7	ambiguous	ambiguous	JJ
8691	977	8	document	document	NN
8691	977	9	be	be	VB
8691	977	10	left	leave	VBN
8691	977	11	to	to	IN
8691	977	12	juries	jury	NNS
8691	977	13	,	,	,
8691	977	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	977	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	977	16	evident	evident	JJ
8691	977	17	that	that	IN
8691	977	18	there	there	EX
8691	977	19	would	would	MD
8691	977	20	be	be	VB
8691	977	21	no	no	DT
8691	977	22	certainty	certainty	NN
8691	977	23	that	that	IN
8691	977	24	different	different	JJ
8691	977	25	results	result	NNS
8691	977	26	would	would	MD
8691	977	27	not	not	RB
8691	977	28	be	be	VB
8691	977	29	reached	reach	VBN
8691	977	30	in	in	IN
8691	977	31	different	different	JJ
8691	977	32	cases	case	NNS
8691	977	33	,	,	,
8691	977	34	and	and	CC
8691	977	35	probable	probable	JJ
8691	977	36	that	that	DT
8691	977	37	unanimity	unanimity	NN
8691	977	38	would	would	MD
8691	977	39	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	977	40	be	be	VB
8691	977	41	attainable	attainable	JJ
8691	977	42	.	.	.
8691	978	1	If	if	IN
8691	978	2	left	leave	VBN
8691	978	3	to	to	IN
8691	978	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	978	5	,	,	,
8691	978	6	a	a	DT
8691	978	7	decision	decision	NN
8691	978	8	will	will	MD
8691	978	9	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	978	10	be	be	VB
8691	978	11	reached	reach	VBN
8691	978	12	and	and	CC
8691	978	13	,	,	,
8691	978	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	978	15	may	may	MD
8691	978	16	be	be	VB
8691	978	17	presumed	presume	VBN
8691	978	18	,	,	,
8691	978	19	be	be	VB
8691	978	20	reasoned	reason	VBN
8691	978	21	out	out	RP
8691	978	22	with	with	IN
8691	978	23	care	care	NN
8691	978	24	,	,	,
8691	978	25	while	while	IN
8691	978	26	if	if	IN
8691	978	27	the	the	DT
8691	978	28	matter	matter	NN
8691	978	29	be	be	VB
8691	978	30	one	one	CD
8691	978	31	of	of	IN
8691	978	32	public	public	JJ
8691	978	33	importance	importance	NN
8691	978	34	the	the	DT
8691	978	35	grounds	ground	NNS
8691	978	36	on	on	IN
8691	978	37	which	which	WDT
8691	978	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	978	39	proceed	proceed	VBP
8691	978	40	will	will	MD
8691	978	41	be	be	VB
8691	978	42	so	so	RB
8691	978	43	expressed	express	VBN
8691	978	44	as	as	IN
8691	978	45	to	to	TO
8691	978	46	furnish	furnish	VB
8691	978	47	a	a	DT
8691	978	48	guide	guide	NN
8691	978	49	to	to	IN
8691	978	50	others	other	NNS
8691	978	51	toward	toward	IN
8691	978	52	the	the	DT
8691	978	53	same	same	JJ
8691	978	54	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	978	55	.	.	.
8691	979	1	The	the	DT
8691	979	2	construction	construction	NN
8691	979	3	of	of	IN
8691	979	4	all	all	DT
8691	979	5	writings	writing	NNS
8691	979	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	979	7	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	979	8	,	,	,
8691	979	9	by	by	IN
8691	979	10	the	the	DT
8691	979	11	Anglo	anglo	JJ
8691	979	12	-	-	HYPH
8691	979	13	American	american	JJ
8691	979	14	common	common	JJ
8691	979	15	law	law	NN
8691	979	16	,	,	,
8691	979	17	as	as	IN
8691	979	18	by	by	IN
8691	979	19	the	the	DT
8691	979	20	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	979	21	system	system	NN
8691	979	22	of	of	IN
8691	979	23	most	most	JJS
8691	979	24	countries	country	NNS
8691	979	25	,	,	,
8691	979	26	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	979	27	,	,	,
8691	979	28	in	in	IN
8691	979	29	case	case	NN
8691	979	30	of	of	IN
8691	979	31	a	a	DT
8691	979	32	question	question	NN
8691	979	33	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	979	34	litigated	litigate	VBN
8691	979	35	rights	right	NNS
8691	979	36	,	,	,
8691	979	37	to	to	TO
8691	979	38	belong	belong	VB
8691	979	39	of	of	IN
8691	979	40	right	right	NN
8691	979	41	to	to	IN
8691	979	42	the	the	DT
8691	979	43	judges	judge	NNS
8691	979	44	.	.	.
8691	980	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	980	2	possession	possession	NN
8691	980	3	of	of	IN
8691	980	4	this	this	DT
8691	980	5	power	power	NN
8691	980	6	in	in	IN
8691	980	7	the	the	DT
8691	980	8	United	United	NNP
8691	980	9	States	States	NNP
8691	980	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	980	11	especially	especially	RB
8691	980	12	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	980	13	in	in	IN
8691	980	14	respect	respect	NN
8691	980	15	to	to	IN
8691	980	16	written	write	VBN
8691	980	17	law	law	NN
8691	980	18	.	.	.
8691	981	1	In	in	IN
8691	981	2	every	every	DT
8691	981	3	government	government	NN
8691	981	4	there	there	EX
8691	981	5	must	must	MD
8691	981	6	be	be	VB
8691	981	7	some	some	DT
8691	981	8	human	human	JJ
8691	981	9	voice	voice	NN
8691	981	10	speaking	speak	VBG
8691	981	11	with	with	IN
8691	981	12	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	981	13	authority	authority	NNP
8691	981	14	.	.	.
8691	982	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	982	2	may	may	MD
8691	982	3	be	be	VB
8691	982	4	that	that	DT
8691	982	5	of	of	IN
8691	982	6	one	one	CD
8691	982	7	man	man	NN
8691	982	8	or	or	CC
8691	982	9	of	of	IN
8691	982	10	many	many	JJ
8691	982	11	men	man	NNS
8691	982	12	.	.	.
8691	983	1	The	the	DT
8691	983	2	essential	essential	JJ
8691	983	3	thing	thing	NN
8691	983	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	983	5	that	that	IN
8691	983	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	983	7	should	should	MD
8691	983	8	be	be	VB
8691	983	9	a	a	DT
8691	983	10	personal	personal	JJ
8691	983	11	utterance	utterance	NN
8691	983	12	,	,	,
8691	983	13	proceeding	proceed	VBG
8691	983	14	from	from	IN
8691	983	15	persons	person	NNS
8691	983	16	to	to	IN
8691	983	17	whom	whom	WP
8691	983	18	,	,	,
8691	983	19	by	by	IN
8691	983	20	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
8691	983	21	law	law	NN
8691	983	22	or	or	CC
8691	983	23	custom	custom	NN
8691	983	24	,	,	,
8691	983	25	submission	submission	NN
8691	983	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	983	27	due	due	JJ
8691	983	28	,	,	,
8691	983	29	and	and	CC
8691	983	30	one	one	CD
8691	983	31	that	that	WDT
8691	983	32	,	,	,
8691	983	33	if	if	IN
8691	983	34	need	need	NN
8691	983	35	be	be	VB
8691	983	36	,	,	,
8691	983	37	can	can	MD
8691	983	38	be	be	VB
8691	983	39	enforced	enforce	VBN
8691	983	40	by	by	IN
8691	983	41	the	the	DT
8691	983	42	whole	whole	JJ
8691	983	43	power	power	NN
8691	983	44	of	of	IN
8691	983	45	the	the	DT
8691	983	46	State	State	NNP
8691	983	47	.	.	.
8691	984	1	The	the	DT
8691	984	2	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	984	3	principle	principle	NN
8691	984	4	of	of	IN
8691	984	5	American	american	JJ
8691	984	6	government	government	NN
8691	984	7	,	,	,
8691	984	8	as	as	IN
8691	984	9	laid	lay	VBN
8691	984	10	down	down	RP
8691	984	11	in	in	IN
8691	984	12	the	the	DT
8691	984	13	words	word	NNS
8691	984	14	of	of	IN
8691	984	15	Harrington	Harrington	NNP
8691	984	16	in	in	IN
8691	984	17	the	the	DT
8691	984	18	oldest	old	JJS
8691	984	19	of	of	IN
8691	984	20	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	984	21	State	State	NNP
8691	984	22	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	984	23	,	,	,
8691	984	24	after	after	IN
8691	984	25	which	which	WDT
8691	984	26	many	many	JJ
8691	984	27	of	of	IN
8691	984	28	the	the	DT
8691	984	29	rest	rest	NN
8691	984	30	,	,	,
8691	984	31	and	and	CC
8691	984	32	that	that	DT
8691	984	33	of	of	IN
8691	984	34	the	the	DT
8691	984	35	United	United	NNP
8691	984	36	States	States	NNP
8691	984	37	as	as	RB
8691	984	38	well	well	RB
8691	984	39	,	,	,
8691	984	40	have	have	VBP
8691	984	41	been	be	VBN
8691	984	42	largely	largely	RB
8691	984	43	patterned	pattern	VBN
8691	984	44	,	,	,
8691	984	45	is	be	VBZ
8691	984	46	that	that	IN
8691	984	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	984	48	is	be	VBZ
8691	984	49	one	one	CD
8691	984	50	of	of	IN
8691	984	51	"	"	``
8691	984	52	laws	law	NNS
8691	984	53	and	and	CC
8691	984	54	not	not	RB
8691	984	55	of	of	IN
8691	984	56	men	man	NNS
8691	984	57	.	.	.
8691	985	1	"	"	``
8691	985	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	985	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	985	4	:	:	:
8691	985	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	985	6	of	of	IN
8691	985	7	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	985	8	,	,	,
8691	985	9	Part	Part	NNP
8691	985	10	the	the	DT
8691	985	11	First	first	JJ
8691	985	12	,	,	,
8691	985	13	Art	art	NN
8691	985	14	.	.	.
8691	986	1	XXX	XXX	NNP
8691	986	2	,	,	,
8691	986	3	quoted	quote	VBD
8691	986	4	more	more	RBR
8691	986	5	fully	fully	RB
8691	986	6	in	in	IN
8691	986	7	Chapter	Chapter	NNP
8691	986	8	II	II	NNP
8691	986	9	.	.	.
8691	986	10	]	]	-RRB-
8691	987	1	Laws	law	NNS
8691	987	2	,	,	,
8691	987	3	however	however	RB
8691	987	4	,	,	,
8691	987	5	must	must	MD
8691	987	6	be	be	VB
8691	987	7	administered	administer	VBN
8691	987	8	by	by	IN
8691	987	9	men	man	NNS
8691	987	10	.	.	.
8691	988	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	988	2	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	988	3	,	,	,
8691	988	4	if	if	IN
8691	988	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	988	6	be	be	VB
8691	988	7	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
8691	988	8	,	,	,
8691	988	9	must	must	MD
8691	988	10	be	be	VB
8691	988	11	determined	determine	VBN
8691	988	12	by	by	IN
8691	988	13	men	man	NNS
8691	988	14	.	.	.
8691	989	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	989	2	must	must	MD
8691	989	3	be	be	VB
8691	989	4	the	the	DT
8691	989	5	subject	subject	NN
8691	989	6	,	,	,
8691	989	7	as	as	IN
8691	989	8	the	the	DT
8691	989	9	same	same	JJ
8691	989	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	989	11	twice	twice	RB
8691	989	12	affirms	affirm	VBZ
8691	989	13	,	,	,
8691	989	14	of	of	IN
8691	989	15	"	"	``
8691	989	16	impartial	impartial	JJ
8691	989	17	interpretation	interpretation	NN
8691	989	18	.	.	.
8691	990	1	"	"	``
8691	990	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	990	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	990	4	:	:	:
8691	990	5	_	_	NNP
8691	990	6	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	990	7	d	d	NNP
8691	990	8	_	_	NNP
8691	990	9	.	.	NNP
8691	990	10	,	,	,
8691	990	11	Preamble	Preamble	NNP
8691	990	12	,	,	,
8691	990	13	and	and	CC
8691	990	14	Part	Part	NNP
8691	990	15	the	the	DT
8691	990	16	First	first	JJ
8691	990	17	,	,	,
8691	990	18	Art	art	NN
8691	990	19	.	.	.
8691	991	1	XXIX	XXIX	NNP
8691	991	2	.	.	.
8691	991	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	992	1	This	this	DT
8691	992	2	interpretation	interpretation	NN
8691	992	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	992	4	really	really	RB
8691	992	5	what	what	WP
8691	992	6	gives	give	VBZ
8691	992	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	992	8	force	force	NN
8691	992	9	.	.	.
8691	993	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	993	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	993	3	the	the	DT
8691	993	4	personal	personal	JJ
8691	993	5	utterance	utterance	NN
8691	993	6	of	of	IN
8691	993	7	one	one	CD
8691	993	8	speaking	speak	VBG
8691	993	9	for	for	IN
8691	993	10	the	the	DT
8691	993	11	State	State	NNP
8691	993	12	,	,	,
8691	993	13	and	and	CC
8691	993	14	who	who	WP
8691	993	15	speaks	speak	VBZ
8691	993	16	the	the	DT
8691	993	17	last	last	JJ
8691	993	18	word	word	NN
8691	993	19	.	.	.
8691	994	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	994	2	was	be	VBD
8691	994	3	simply	simply	RB
8691	994	4	following	follow	VBG
8691	994	5	English	english	JJ
8691	994	6	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	994	7	to	to	TO
8691	994	8	give	give	VB
8691	994	9	this	this	DT
8691	994	10	power	power	NN
8691	994	11	to	to	IN
8691	994	12	the	the	DT
8691	994	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	994	14	as	as	IN
8691	994	15	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	994	16	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	994	17	enactments	enactment	NNS
8691	994	18	.	.	.
8691	995	1	But	but	CC
8691	995	2	the	the	DT
8691	995	3	principle	principle	NN
8691	995	4	which	which	WDT
8691	995	5	required	require	VBD
8691	995	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	995	7	inevitably	inevitably	RB
8691	995	8	extended	extend	VBD
8691	995	9	with	with	IN
8691	995	10	equal	equal	JJ
8691	995	11	force	force	NN
8691	995	12	to	to	IN
8691	995	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	995	14	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	995	15	.	.	.
8691	996	1	The	the	DT
8691	996	2	people	people	NNS
8691	996	3	who	who	WP
8691	996	4	adopt	adopt	VBP
8691	996	5	written	write	VBN
8691	996	6	constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	996	7	for	for	IN
8691	996	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	996	9	government	government	NN
8691	996	10	put	put	VBD
8691	996	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	996	12	work	work	NN
8691	996	13	in	in	IN
8691	996	14	a	a	DT
8691	996	15	form	form	NN
8691	996	16	which	which	WDT
8691	996	17	must	must	MD
8691	996	18	often	often	RB
8691	996	19	give	give	VB
8691	996	20	rise	rise	NN
8691	996	21	to	to	IN
8691	996	22	questions	question	NNS
8691	996	23	as	as	IN
8691	996	24	to	to	IN
8691	996	25	what	what	WP
8691	996	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	996	27	intended	intend	VBD
8691	996	28	to	to	TO
8691	996	29	express	express	VB
8691	996	30	.	.	.
8691	997	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	997	2	rely	rely	VBP
8691	997	3	on	on	IN
8691	997	4	the	the	DT
8691	997	5	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	997	6	to	to	TO
8691	997	7	secure	secure	VB
8691	997	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	997	9	enforcement	enforcement	NN
8691	997	10	,	,	,
8691	997	11	and	and	CC
8691	997	12	the	the	DT
8691	997	13	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	997	14	must	must	MD
8691	997	15	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	997	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	997	17	according	accord	VBG
8691	997	18	to	to	IN
8691	997	19	what	what	WP
8691	997	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	997	21	understands	understand	VBZ
8691	997	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	997	23	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	997	24	to	to	TO
8691	997	25	be	be	VB
8691	997	26	.	.	.
8691	998	1	There	there	EX
8691	998	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	998	3	but	but	CC
8691	998	4	a	a	DT
8691	998	5	step	step	NN
8691	998	6	from	from	IN
8691	998	7	interpretation	interpretation	NN
8691	998	8	to	to	IN
8691	998	9	enlargement	enlargement	NN
8691	998	10	.	.	.
8691	999	1	Every	every	DT
8691	999	2	statute	statute	NN
8691	999	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	999	4	passed	pass	VBN
8691	999	5	to	to	TO
8691	999	6	accomplish	accomplish	VB
8691	999	7	something	something	NN
8691	999	8	.	.	.
8691	1000	1	If	if	IN
8691	1000	2	the	the	DT
8691	1000	3	object	object	NN
8691	1000	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1000	5	clear	clear	JJ
8691	1000	6	,	,	,
8691	1000	7	the	the	DT
8691	1000	8	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1000	9	of	of	IN
8691	1000	10	Anglo	anglo	JJ
8691	1000	11	-	-	HYPH
8691	1000	12	American	american	JJ
8691	1000	13	law	law	NN
8691	1000	14	allow	allow	VBP
8691	1000	15	the	the	DT
8691	1000	16	court	court	NN
8691	1000	17	that	that	WDT
8691	1000	18	may	may	MD
8691	1000	19	be	be	VB
8691	1000	20	called	call	VBN
8691	1000	21	on	on	RP
8691	1000	22	to	to	TO
8691	1000	23	apply	apply	VB
8691	1000	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1000	25	to	to	TO
8691	1000	26	extend	extend	VB
8691	1000	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1000	28	operation	operation	NN
8691	1000	29	to	to	IN
8691	1000	30	cases	case	NNS
8691	1000	31	within	within	IN
8691	1000	32	the	the	DT
8691	1000	33	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1000	34	evidently	evidently	RB
8691	1000	35	intended	intend	VBD
8691	1000	36	,	,	,
8691	1000	37	although	although	IN
8691	1000	38	the	the	DT
8691	1000	39	language	language	NN
8691	1000	40	used	use	VBN
8691	1000	41	is	be	VBZ
8691	1000	42	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
8691	1000	43	fully	fully	RB
8691	1000	44	to	to	TO
8691	1000	45	express	express	VB
8691	1000	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1000	47	.	.	.
8691	1001	1	This	this	DT
8691	1001	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1001	3	styled	style	VBN
8691	1001	4	giving	give	VBG
8691	1001	5	effect	effect	NN
8691	1001	6	to	to	IN
8691	1001	7	"	"	``
8691	1001	8	the	the	DT
8691	1001	9	equity	equity	NN
8691	1001	10	of	of	IN
8691	1001	11	the	the	DT
8691	1001	12	statute	statute	NN
8691	1001	13	.	.	.
8691	1001	14	"	"	''
8691	1002	1	Even	even	RB
8691	1002	2	violence	violence	NN
8691	1002	3	can	can	MD
8691	1002	4	be	be	VB
8691	1002	5	done	do	VBN
8691	1002	6	to	to	IN
8691	1002	7	the	the	DT
8691	1002	8	words	word	NNS
8691	1002	9	,	,	,
8691	1002	10	if	if	IN
8691	1002	11	so	so	RB
8691	1002	12	only	only	RB
8691	1002	13	can	can	MD
8691	1002	14	this	this	DT
8691	1002	15	judge	judge	NN
8691	1002	16	-	-	HYPH
8691	1002	17	discovered	discover	VBN
8691	1002	18	intent	intent	NN
8691	1002	19	be	be	VB
8691	1002	20	made	make	VBN
8691	1002	21	effectual	effectual	JJ
8691	1002	22	.	.	.
8691	1003	1	The	the	DT
8691	1003	2	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1003	3	governing	govern	VBG
8691	1003	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1003	5	interpretation	interpretation	NN
8691	1003	6	of	of	IN
8691	1003	7	statute	statute	NN
8691	1003	8	law	law	NN
8691	1003	9	fill	fill	VB
8691	1003	10	a	a	DT
8691	1003	11	good	good	JJ
8691	1003	12	-	-	HYPH
8691	1003	13	sized	sized	JJ
8691	1003	14	volume	volume	NN
8691	1003	15	.	.	.
8691	1004	1	As	as	IN
8691	1004	2	the	the	DT
8691	1004	3	Roman	roman	JJ
8691	1004	4	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	1004	5	worked	work	VBD
8691	1004	6	out	out	RP
8691	1004	7	by	by	IN
8691	1004	8	force	force	NN
8691	1004	9	of	of	IN
8691	1004	10	logic	logic	NN
8691	1004	11	and	and	CC
8691	1004	12	analogy	analogy	NN
8691	1004	13	an	an	DT
8691	1004	14	extensive	extensive	JJ
8691	1004	15	system	system	NN
8691	1004	16	of	of	IN
8691	1004	17	private	private	JJ
8691	1004	18	law	law	NN
8691	1004	19	from	from	IN
8691	1004	20	the	the	DT
8691	1004	21	meagre	meagre	JJ
8691	1004	22	fabric	fabric	NN
8691	1004	23	of	of	IN
8691	1004	24	the	the	DT
8691	1004	25	Twelve	Twelve	NNP
8691	1004	26	Tables	Tables	NNPS
8691	1004	27	,	,	,
8691	1004	28	so	so	CC
8691	1004	29	under	under	IN
8691	1004	30	the	the	DT
8691	1004	31	lead	lead	NN
8691	1004	32	of	of	IN
8691	1004	33	American	american	JJ
8691	1004	34	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	1004	35	American	american	JJ
8691	1004	36	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1004	37	have	have	VBP
8691	1004	38	applied	apply	VBN
8691	1004	39	the	the	DT
8691	1004	40	processes	process	NNS
8691	1004	41	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	1004	42	in	in	IN
8691	1004	43	the	the	DT
8691	1004	44	development	development	NN
8691	1004	45	of	of	IN
8691	1004	46	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	1004	47	law	law	NN
8691	1004	48	to	to	IN
8691	1004	49	the	the	DT
8691	1004	50	development	development	NN
8691	1004	51	of	of	IN
8691	1004	52	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1004	53	written	write	VBN
8691	1004	54	law	law	NN
8691	1004	55	,	,	,
8691	1004	56	both	both	CC
8691	1004	57	statutory	statutory	JJ
8691	1004	58	and	and	CC
8691	1004	59	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1004	60	.	.	.
8691	1005	1	Carlyle	Carlyle	NNP
8691	1005	2	said	say	VBD
8691	1005	3	that	that	IN
8691	1005	4	the	the	DT
8691	1005	5	Roman	roman	JJ
8691	1005	6	republic	republic	NN
8691	1005	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1005	8	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	1005	9	so	so	RB
8691	1005	10	long	long	RB
8691	1005	11	a	a	DT
8691	1005	12	day	day	NN
8691	1005	13	because	because	IN
8691	1005	14	on	on	IN
8691	1005	15	emergencies	emergency	NNS
8691	1005	16	the	the	DT
8691	1005	17	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	1005	18	was	be	VBD
8691	1005	19	suspended	suspend	VBN
8691	1005	20	by	by	IN
8691	1005	21	a	a	DT
8691	1005	22	dictatorship	dictatorship	NN
8691	1005	23	.	.	.
8691	1006	1	The	the	DT
8691	1006	2	American	american	JJ
8691	1006	3	republics	republic	NNS
8691	1006	4	have	have	VBP
8691	1006	5	a	a	DT
8691	1006	6	right	right	NN
8691	1006	7	,	,	,
8691	1006	8	upon	upon	IN
8691	1006	9	this	this	DT
8691	1006	10	theory	theory	NN
8691	1006	11	,	,	,
8691	1006	12	to	to	IN
8691	1006	13	a	a	DT
8691	1006	14	still	still	RB
8691	1006	15	longer	long	JJR
8691	1006	16	one	one	CD
8691	1006	17	.	.	.
8691	1007	1	With	with	IN
8691	1007	2	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1007	3	the	the	DT
8691	1007	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1007	5	need	nee	MD
8691	1007	6	not	not	RB
8691	1007	7	be	be	VB
8691	1007	8	temporarily	temporarily	RB
8691	1007	9	set	set	VBN
8691	1007	10	aside	aside	RB
8691	1007	11	on	on	IN
8691	1007	12	an	an	DT
8691	1007	13	emergency	emergency	NN
8691	1007	14	.	.	.
8691	1008	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1008	2	may	may	MD
8691	1008	3	simply	simply	RB
8691	1008	4	be	be	VB
8691	1008	5	permanently	permanently	RB
8691	1008	6	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
8691	1008	7	or	or	CC
8691	1008	8	limited	limit	VBN
8691	1008	9	by	by	IN
8691	1008	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1008	11	construction	construction	NN
8691	1008	12	.	.	.
8691	1009	1	A	a	DT
8691	1009	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1009	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1009	4	the	the	DT
8691	1009	5	garment	garment	NN
8691	1009	6	which	which	WDT
8691	1009	7	a	a	DT
8691	1009	8	nation	nation	NN
8691	1009	9	wears	wear	VBZ
8691	1009	10	.	.	.
8691	1010	1	Whether	whether	IN
8691	1010	2	written	write	VBN
8691	1010	3	or	or	CC
8691	1010	4	unwritten	unwritten	VB
8691	1010	5	,	,	,
8691	1010	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1010	7	must	must	MD
8691	1010	8	grow	grow	VB
8691	1010	9	with	with	IN
8691	1010	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1010	11	growth	growth	NN
8691	1010	12	.	.	.
8691	1011	1	As	as	IN
8691	1011	2	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1011	3	Bryce	Bryce	NNP
8691	1011	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	1011	5	put	put	VBN
8691	1011	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1011	7	:	:	:
8691	1011	8	"	"	``
8691	1011	9	Human	human	JJ
8691	1011	10	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	1011	11	being	be	VBG
8691	1011	12	what	what	WP
8691	1011	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1011	14	are	be	VBP
8691	1011	15	,	,	,
8691	1011	16	there	there	EX
8691	1011	17	must	must	MD
8691	1011	18	be	be	VB
8691	1011	19	a	a	DT
8691	1011	20	loophole	loophole	NN
8691	1011	21	for	for	IN
8691	1011	22	expansion	expansion	NN
8691	1011	23	or	or	CC
8691	1011	24	extension	extension	NN
8691	1011	25	in	in	IN
8691	1011	26	some	some	DT
8691	1011	27	part	part	NN
8691	1011	28	of	of	IN
8691	1011	29	every	every	DT
8691	1011	30	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	1011	31	of	of	IN
8691	1011	32	government	government	NN
8691	1011	33	;	;	:
8691	1011	34	and	and	CC
8691	1011	35	if	if	IN
8691	1011	36	the	the	DT
8691	1011	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1011	38	is	be	VBZ
8691	1011	39	Rigid	rigid	JJ
8691	1011	40	,	,	,
8691	1011	41	Flexibility	Flexibility	NNP
8691	1011	42	must	must	MD
8691	1011	43	be	be	VB
8691	1011	44	supplied	supply	VBN
8691	1011	45	from	from	IN
8691	1011	46	the	the	DT
8691	1011	47	minds	mind	NNS
8691	1011	48	of	of	IN
8691	1011	49	the	the	DT
8691	1011	50	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	1011	51	.	.	.
8691	1012	1	"	"	``
8691	1012	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1012	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1012	4	:	:	:
8691	1012	5	"	"	``
8691	1012	6	Studies	study	NNS
8691	1012	7	in	in	IN
8691	1012	8	History	history	NN
8691	1012	9	and	and	CC
8691	1012	10	Jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	1012	11	,	,	,
8691	1012	12	"	"	''
8691	1012	13	197	197	CD
8691	1012	14	.	.	.
8691	1012	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1013	1	The	the	DT
8691	1013	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1013	3	of	of	IN
8691	1013	4	the	the	DT
8691	1013	5	United	United	NNP
8691	1013	6	States	States	NNP
8691	1013	7	declares	declare	VBZ
8691	1013	8	that	that	IN
8691	1013	9	no	no	DT
8691	1013	10	State	state	NN
8691	1013	11	shall	shall	MD
8691	1013	12	pass	pass	VB
8691	1013	13	any	any	DT
8691	1013	14	law	law	NN
8691	1013	15	impairing	impair	VBG
8691	1013	16	the	the	DT
8691	1013	17	obligation	obligation	NN
8691	1013	18	of	of	IN
8691	1013	19	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	1013	20	.	.	.
8691	1014	1	This	this	DT
8691	1014	2	proposition	proposition	NN
8691	1014	3	being	be	VBG
8691	1014	4	the	the	DT
8691	1014	5	major	major	JJ
8691	1014	6	premise	premise	NN
8691	1014	7	,	,	,
8691	1014	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1014	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1014	10	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1014	11	added	add	VBD
8691	1014	12	the	the	DT
8691	1014	13	minor	minor	JJ
8691	1014	14	premise	premise	NN
8691	1014	15	that	that	IN
8691	1014	16	every	every	DT
8691	1014	17	charter	charter	NN
8691	1014	18	of	of	IN
8691	1014	19	a	a	DT
8691	1014	20	private	private	JJ
8691	1014	21	corporation	corporation	NN
8691	1014	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	1014	23	a	a	DT
8691	1014	24	contract	contract	NN
8691	1014	25	,	,	,
8691	1014	26	and	and	CC
8691	1014	27	completed	complete	VBD
8691	1014	28	the	the	DT
8691	1014	29	syllogism	syllogism	NN
8691	1014	30	by	by	IN
8691	1014	31	the	the	DT
8691	1014	32	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	1014	33	that	that	IN
8691	1014	34	no	no	DT
8691	1014	35	State	state	NN
8691	1014	36	can	can	MD
8691	1014	37	pass	pass	VB
8691	1014	38	any	any	DT
8691	1014	39	law	law	NN
8691	1014	40	impairing	impair	VBG
8691	1014	41	the	the	DT
8691	1014	42	obligation	obligation	NN
8691	1014	43	of	of	IN
8691	1014	44	such	such	JJ
8691	1014	45	charters	charter	NNS
8691	1014	46	.	.	.
8691	1015	1	The	the	DT
8691	1015	2	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	1015	3	who	who	WP
8691	1015	4	opposed	oppose	VBD
8691	1015	5	this	this	DT
8691	1015	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1015	7	urged	urge	VBD
8691	1015	8	that	that	IN
8691	1015	9	every	every	DT
8691	1015	10	one	one	NN
8691	1015	11	must	must	MD
8691	1015	12	acknowledge	acknowledge	VB
8691	1015	13	that	that	IN
8691	1015	14	neither	neither	CC
8691	1015	15	the	the	DT
8691	1015	16	men	man	NNS
8691	1015	17	who	who	WP
8691	1015	18	framed	frame	VBD
8691	1015	19	the	the	DT
8691	1015	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1015	21	nor	nor	CC
8691	1015	22	the	the	DT
8691	1015	23	people	people	NNS
8691	1015	24	who	who	WP
8691	1015	25	adopted	adopt	VBD
8691	1015	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1015	27	ever	ever	RB
8691	1015	28	thought	think	VBD
8691	1015	29	that	that	IN
8691	1015	30	the	the	DT
8691	1015	31	word	word	NN
8691	1015	32	"	"	``
8691	1015	33	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	1015	34	,	,	,
8691	1015	35	"	"	''
8691	1015	36	as	as	IN
8691	1015	37	so	so	RB
8691	1015	38	used	used	JJ
8691	1015	39	,	,	,
8691	1015	40	embraced	embraced	JJ
8691	1015	41	"	"	``
8691	1015	42	charters	charter	NNS
8691	1015	43	.	.	.
8691	1015	44	"	"	''
8691	1016	1	Be	be	VB
8691	1016	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1016	3	so	so	RB
8691	1016	4	,	,	,
8691	1016	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1016	6	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1016	7	's	's	POS
8691	1016	8	answer	answer	NN
8691	1016	9	,	,	,
8691	1016	10	that	that	WDT
8691	1016	11	proves	prove	VBZ
8691	1016	12	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	1016	13	unless	unless	IN
8691	1016	14	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1016	15	can	can	MD
8691	1016	16	go	go	VB
8691	1016	17	farther	farther	RB
8691	1016	18	and	and	CC
8691	1016	19	satisfy	satisfy	VB
8691	1016	20	the	the	DT
8691	1016	21	court	court	NN
8691	1016	22	that	that	IN
8691	1016	23	if	if	IN
8691	1016	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1016	25	had	have	VBD
8691	1016	26	contemplated	contemplate	VBN
8691	1016	27	the	the	DT
8691	1016	28	construction	construction	NN
8691	1016	29	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1016	30	put	put	VBP
8691	1016	31	upon	upon	IN
8691	1016	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1016	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1016	34	would	would	MD
8691	1016	35	have	have	VB
8691	1016	36	used	use	VBN
8691	1016	37	words	word	NNS
8691	1016	38	to	to	TO
8691	1016	39	exclude	exclude	VB
8691	1016	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1016	41	.	.	.
8691	1017	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1017	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1017	3	:	:	:
8691	1017	4	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
8691	1017	5	College	College	NNP
8691	1017	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1017	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	1017	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1017	9	Woodward	Woodward	NNP
8691	1017	10	,	,	,
8691	1017	11	4	4	CD
8691	1017	12	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	1017	13	's	's	POS
8691	1017	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1017	15	,	,	,
8691	1017	16	518	518	CD
8691	1017	17	.	.	.
8691	1017	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1018	1	The	the	DT
8691	1018	2	acquisition	acquisition	NN
8691	1018	3	of	of	IN
8691	1018	4	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1018	5	territory	territory	NN
8691	1018	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1018	7	a	a	DT
8691	1018	8	matter	matter	NN
8691	1018	9	not	not	RB
8691	1018	10	especially	especially	RB
8691	1018	11	provided	provide	VBN
8691	1018	12	for	for	IN
8691	1018	13	in	in	IN
8691	1018	14	the	the	DT
8691	1018	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1018	16	of	of	IN
8691	1018	17	the	the	DT
8691	1018	18	United	United	NNP
8691	1018	19	States	States	NNP
8691	1018	20	.	.	.
8691	1019	1	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	1019	2	hesitated	hesitate	VBD
8691	1019	3	to	to	TO
8691	1019	4	make	make	VB
8691	1019	5	the	the	DT
8691	1019	6	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	1019	7	purchase	purchase	NN
8691	1019	8	on	on	IN
8691	1019	9	this	this	DT
8691	1019	10	account	account	NN
8691	1019	11	,	,	,
8691	1019	12	and	and	CC
8691	1019	13	was	be	VBD
8691	1019	14	quite	quite	RB
8691	1019	15	inclined	inclined	JJ
8691	1019	16	to	to	TO
8691	1019	17	think	think	VB
8691	1019	18	,	,	,
8691	1019	19	when	when	WRB
8691	1019	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1019	21	did	do	VBD
8691	1019	22	make	make	VB
8691	1019	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1019	24	,	,	,
8691	1019	25	that	that	IN
8691	1019	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1019	27	had	have	VBD
8691	1019	28	transcended	transcend	VBN
8691	1019	29	the	the	DT
8691	1019	30	bounds	bound	NNS
8691	1019	31	of	of	IN
8691	1019	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1019	33	authority	authority	NN
8691	1019	34	.	.	.
8691	1020	1	The	the	DT
8691	1020	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1020	3	gave	give	VBD
8691	1020	4	the	the	DT
8691	1020	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1020	6	a	a	DT
8691	1020	7	different	different	JJ
8691	1020	8	interpretation	interpretation	NN
8691	1020	9	,	,	,
8691	1020	10	and	and	CC
8691	1020	11	stamped	stamp	VBD
8691	1020	12	this	this	DT
8691	1020	13	upon	upon	IN
8691	1020	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1020	15	as	as	RB
8691	1020	16	permanently	permanently	RB
8691	1020	17	as	as	IN
8691	1020	18	if	if	IN
8691	1020	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1020	20	had	have	VBD
8691	1020	21	been	be	VBN
8691	1020	22	a	a	DT
8691	1020	23	birthmark	birthmark	NN
8691	1020	24	.	.	.
8691	1021	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1021	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1021	3	done	do	VBN
8691	1021	4	by	by	IN
8691	1021	5	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1021	6	in	in	IN
8691	1021	7	a	a	DT
8691	1021	8	single	single	JJ
8691	1021	9	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	1021	10	.	.	.
8691	1022	1	"	"	``
8691	1022	2	The	the	DT
8691	1022	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1022	4	,	,	,
8691	1022	5	"	"	''
8691	1022	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1022	7	observed	observe	VBD
8691	1022	8	,	,	,
8691	1022	9	"	"	''
8691	1022	10	confers	confer	NNS
8691	1022	11	absolutely	absolutely	RB
8691	1022	12	on	on	IN
8691	1022	13	the	the	DT
8691	1022	14	government	government	NN
8691	1022	15	of	of	IN
8691	1022	16	the	the	DT
8691	1022	17	Union	Union	NNP
8691	1022	18	the	the	DT
8691	1022	19	powers	power	NNS
8691	1022	20	of	of	IN
8691	1022	21	making	make	VBG
8691	1022	22	war	war	NN
8691	1022	23	and	and	CC
8691	1022	24	of	of	IN
8691	1022	25	making	make	VBG
8691	1022	26	treaties	treaty	NNS
8691	1022	27	:	:	:
8691	1022	28	consequently	consequently	RB
8691	1022	29	that	that	IN
8691	1022	30	government	government	NN
8691	1022	31	possesses	possess	VBZ
8691	1022	32	the	the	DT
8691	1022	33	power	power	NN
8691	1022	34	of	of	IN
8691	1022	35	acquiring	acquire	VBG
8691	1022	36	territory	territory	NN
8691	1022	37	either	either	CC
8691	1022	38	by	by	IN
8691	1022	39	conquest	conquest	NN
8691	1022	40	or	or	CC
8691	1022	41	by	by	IN
8691	1022	42	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	1022	43	.	.	.
8691	1023	1	"	"	``
8691	1023	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1023	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1023	4	:	:	:
8691	1023	5	American	American	NNP
8691	1023	6	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	1023	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1023	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1023	9	v.	v.	IN
8691	1023	10	_	_	NNP
8691	1023	11	Canter	Canter	NNP
8691	1023	12	,	,	,
8691	1023	13	1	1	CD
8691	1023	14	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1023	15	'	'	POS
8691	1023	16	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1023	17	,	,	,
8691	1023	18	511	511	CD
8691	1023	19	,	,	,
8691	1023	20	542	542	CD
8691	1023	21	.	.	.
8691	1023	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1024	1	In	in	IN
8691	1024	2	the	the	DT
8691	1024	3	course	course	NN
8691	1024	4	of	of	IN
8691	1024	5	the	the	DT
8691	1024	6	same	same	JJ
8691	1024	7	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1024	8	,	,	,
8691	1024	9	the	the	DT
8691	1024	10	great	great	JJ
8691	1024	11	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1024	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1024	13	led	lead	VBD
8691	1024	14	the	the	DT
8691	1024	15	way	way	NN
8691	1024	16	toward	toward	IN
8691	1024	17	the	the	DT
8691	1024	18	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1024	19	,	,	,
8691	1024	20	to	to	TO
8691	1024	21	be	be	VB
8691	1024	22	developed	develop	VBN
8691	1024	23	later	later	RB
8691	1024	24	,	,	,
8691	1024	25	that	that	IN
8691	1024	26	the	the	DT
8691	1024	27	manner	manner	NN
8691	1024	28	in	in	IN
8691	1024	29	which	which	WDT
8691	1024	30	such	such	JJ
8691	1024	31	territory	territory	NN
8691	1024	32	was	be	VBD
8691	1024	33	to	to	TO
8691	1024	34	be	be	VB
8691	1024	35	held	hold	VBN
8691	1024	36	and	and	CC
8691	1024	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1024	38	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
8691	1024	39	governed	govern	VBN
8691	1024	40	need	nee	MD
8691	1024	41	not	not	RB
8691	1024	42	be	be	VB
8691	1024	43	such	such	JJ
8691	1024	44	as	as	IN
8691	1024	45	the	the	DT
8691	1024	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1024	47	prescribed	prescribe	VBD
8691	1024	48	for	for	IN
8691	1024	49	the	the	DT
8691	1024	50	territory	territory	NN
8691	1024	51	within	within	IN
8691	1024	52	one	one	CD
8691	1024	53	of	of	IN
8691	1024	54	the	the	DT
8691	1024	55	United	United	NNP
8691	1024	56	States	States	NNP
8691	1024	57	.	.	.
8691	1025	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1025	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1025	3	to	to	TO
8691	1025	4	be	be	VB
8691	1025	5	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
8691	1025	6	by	by	IN
8691	1025	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1025	8	under	under	IN
8691	1025	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1025	10	power	power	NN
8691	1025	11	"	"	''
8691	1025	12	to	to	TO
8691	1025	13	make	make	VB
8691	1025	14	all	all	DT
8691	1025	15	needful	needful	JJ
8691	1025	16	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1025	17	and	and	CC
8691	1025	18	regulations	regulation	NNS
8691	1025	19	respecting	respect	VBG
8691	1025	20	the	the	DT
8691	1025	21	territory	territory	NN
8691	1025	22	or	or	CC
8691	1025	23	other	other	JJ
8691	1025	24	property	property	NN
8691	1025	25	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	1025	26	to	to	IN
8691	1025	27	the	the	DT
8691	1025	28	United	United	NNP
8691	1025	29	States	States	NNP
8691	1025	30	.	.	.
8691	1025	31	"	"	''
8691	1026	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1026	2	had	have	VBD
8691	1026	3	set	set	VBN
8691	1026	4	up	up	RP
8691	1026	5	a	a	DT
8691	1026	6	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
8691	1026	7	Council	Council	NNP
8691	1026	8	in	in	IN
8691	1026	9	the	the	DT
8691	1026	10	Territory	Territory	NNP
8691	1026	11	of	of	IN
8691	1026	12	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	1026	13	,	,	,
8691	1026	14	and	and	CC
8691	1026	15	the	the	DT
8691	1026	16	Legislative	Legislative	NNP
8691	1026	17	Council	Council	NNP
8691	1026	18	had	have	VBD
8691	1026	19	established	establish	VBN
8691	1026	20	a	a	DT
8691	1026	21	court	court	NN
8691	1026	22	of	of	IN
8691	1026	23	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	1026	24	,	,	,
8691	1026	25	with	with	IN
8691	1026	26	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1026	27	holding	hold	VBG
8691	1026	28	office	office	NN
8691	1026	29	for	for	IN
8691	1026	30	four	four	CD
8691	1026	31	years	year	NNS
8691	1026	32	.	.	.
8691	1027	1	The	the	DT
8691	1027	2	case	case	NN
8691	1027	3	in	in	IN
8691	1027	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	1027	5	turned	turn	VBD
8691	1027	6	upon	upon	IN
8691	1027	7	the	the	DT
8691	1027	8	effect	effect	NN
8691	1027	9	of	of	IN
8691	1027	10	a	a	DT
8691	1027	11	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1027	12	of	of	IN
8691	1027	13	that	that	DT
8691	1027	14	court	court	NN
8691	1027	15	.	.	.
8691	1028	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1028	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1028	3	contended	contend	VBN
8691	1028	4	at	at	IN
8691	1028	5	the	the	DT
8691	1028	6	bar	bar	NN
8691	1028	7	that	that	IN
8691	1028	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1028	9	had	have	VBD
8691	1028	10	no	no	DT
8691	1028	11	effect	effect	NN
8691	1028	12	,	,	,
8691	1028	13	because	because	IN
8691	1028	14	by	by	IN
8691	1028	15	the	the	DT
8691	1028	16	express	express	JJ
8691	1028	17	terms	term	NNS
8691	1028	18	of	of	IN
8691	1028	19	the	the	DT
8691	1028	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1028	21	the	the	DT
8691	1028	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1028	23	power	power	NN
8691	1028	24	of	of	IN
8691	1028	25	the	the	DT
8691	1028	26	United	United	NNP
8691	1028	27	States	States	NNP
8691	1028	28	extended	extend	VBD
8691	1028	29	to	to	IN
8691	1028	30	all	all	DT
8691	1028	31	cases	case	NNS
8691	1028	32	of	of	IN
8691	1028	33	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	1028	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1028	35	,	,	,
8691	1028	36	and	and	CC
8691	1028	37	must	must	MD
8691	1028	38	be	be	VB
8691	1028	39	vested	vest	VBN
8691	1028	40	in	in	IN
8691	1028	41	one	one	CD
8691	1028	42	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1028	43	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1028	44	and	and	CC
8691	1028	45	such	such	JJ
8691	1028	46	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	1028	47	courts	court	NNS
8691	1028	48	as	as	IN
8691	1028	49	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1028	50	might	may	MD
8691	1028	51	ordain	ordain	VB
8691	1028	52	.	.	.
8691	1029	1	"	"	``
8691	1029	2	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1029	3	have	have	VBP
8691	1029	4	only	only	RB
8691	1029	5	,	,	,
8691	1029	6	"	"	''
8691	1029	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1029	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1029	9	's	's	POS
8691	1029	10	reply	reply	NN
8691	1029	11	,	,	,
8691	1029	12	"	"	``
8691	1029	13	to	to	TO
8691	1029	14	pursue	pursue	VB
8691	1029	15	this	this	DT
8691	1029	16	subject	subject	JJ
8691	1029	17	one	one	CD
8691	1029	18	step	step	NN
8691	1029	19	further	far	RBR
8691	1029	20	to	to	TO
8691	1029	21	perceive	perceive	VB
8691	1029	22	that	that	IN
8691	1029	23	this	this	DT
8691	1029	24	provision	provision	NN
8691	1029	25	of	of	IN
8691	1029	26	the	the	DT
8691	1029	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1029	28	does	do	VBZ
8691	1029	29	not	not	RB
8691	1029	30	apply	apply	VB
8691	1029	31	to	to	IN
8691	1029	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1029	33	.	.	.
8691	1030	1	The	the	DT
8691	1030	2	next	next	JJ
8691	1030	3	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	1030	4	declares	declare	VBZ
8691	1030	5	that	that	IN
8691	1030	6	'	'	``
8691	1030	7	the	the	DT
8691	1030	8	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1030	9	both	both	DT
8691	1030	10	of	of	IN
8691	1030	11	the	the	DT
8691	1030	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1030	13	and	and	CC
8691	1030	14	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	1030	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	1030	16	shall	shall	MD
8691	1030	17	hold	hold	VB
8691	1030	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1030	19	offices	office	NNS
8691	1030	20	during	during	IN
8691	1030	21	good	good	JJ
8691	1030	22	behaviour	behaviour	NN
8691	1030	23	.	.	.
8691	1030	24	'	'	''
8691	1031	1	The	the	DT
8691	1031	2	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	1031	3	of	of	IN
8691	1031	4	the	the	DT
8691	1031	5	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	1031	6	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1031	7	of	of	IN
8691	1031	8	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	1031	9	hold	hold	VBP
8691	1031	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1031	11	offices	office	NNS
8691	1031	12	for	for	IN
8691	1031	13	four	four	CD
8691	1031	14	years	year	NNS
8691	1031	15	.	.	.
8691	1032	1	These	these	DT
8691	1032	2	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1032	3	,	,	,
8691	1032	4	then	then	RB
8691	1032	5	,	,	,
8691	1032	6	are	be	VBP
8691	1032	7	not	not	RB
8691	1032	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1032	9	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1032	10	in	in	IN
8691	1032	11	which	which	WDT
8691	1032	12	the	the	DT
8691	1032	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1032	14	power	power	NN
8691	1032	15	conferred	confer	VBN
8691	1032	16	by	by	IN
8691	1032	17	the	the	DT
8691	1032	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1032	19	on	on	IN
8691	1032	20	the	the	DT
8691	1032	21	general	general	JJ
8691	1032	22	government	government	NN
8691	1032	23	can	can	MD
8691	1032	24	be	be	VB
8691	1032	25	deposited	deposit	VBN
8691	1032	26	.	.	.
8691	1033	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1033	2	are	be	VBP
8691	1033	3	incapable	incapable	JJ
8691	1033	4	of	of	IN
8691	1033	5	receiving	receive	VBG
8691	1033	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1033	7	.	.	.
8691	1034	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1034	2	are	be	VBP
8691	1034	3	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1034	4	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1034	5	,	,	,
8691	1034	6	created	create	VBN
8691	1034	7	in	in	IN
8691	1034	8	virtue	virtue	NN
8691	1034	9	of	of	IN
8691	1034	10	the	the	DT
8691	1034	11	general	general	JJ
8691	1034	12	right	right	NN
8691	1034	13	of	of	IN
8691	1034	14	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1034	15	which	which	WDT
8691	1034	16	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	1034	17	in	in	IN
8691	1034	18	the	the	DT
8691	1034	19	government	government	NN
8691	1034	20	,	,	,
8691	1034	21	or	or	CC
8691	1034	22	in	in	IN
8691	1034	23	virtue	virtue	NN
8691	1034	24	of	of	IN
8691	1034	25	that	that	DT
8691	1034	26	clause	clause	NN
8691	1034	27	which	which	WDT
8691	1034	28	enables	enable	VBZ
8691	1034	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1034	30	to	to	TO
8691	1034	31	make	make	VB
8691	1034	32	all	all	DT
8691	1034	33	needful	needful	JJ
8691	1034	34	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1034	35	and	and	CC
8691	1034	36	regulations	regulation	NNS
8691	1034	37	respecting	respect	VBG
8691	1034	38	the	the	DT
8691	1034	39	territory	territory	NN
8691	1034	40	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	1034	41	to	to	IN
8691	1034	42	the	the	DT
8691	1034	43	United	United	NNP
8691	1034	44	States	States	NNP
8691	1034	45	.	.	.
8691	1035	1	The	the	DT
8691	1035	2	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1035	3	with	with	IN
8691	1035	4	which	which	WDT
8691	1035	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1035	6	are	be	VBP
8691	1035	7	invested	invest	VBN
8691	1035	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	1035	9	not	not	RB
8691	1035	10	a	a	DT
8691	1035	11	part	part	NN
8691	1035	12	of	of	IN
8691	1035	13	that	that	DT
8691	1035	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1035	15	power	power	NN
8691	1035	16	which	which	WDT
8691	1035	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	1035	18	defined	define	VBN
8691	1035	19	in	in	IN
8691	1035	20	the	the	DT
8691	1035	21	third	third	JJ
8691	1035	22	article	article	NN
8691	1035	23	of	of	IN
8691	1035	24	the	the	DT
8691	1035	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1035	26	,	,	,
8691	1035	27	but	but	CC
8691	1035	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	1035	29	conferred	confer	VBN
8691	1035	30	by	by	IN
8691	1035	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1035	32	in	in	IN
8691	1035	33	the	the	DT
8691	1035	34	execution	execution	NN
8691	1035	35	of	of	IN
8691	1035	36	those	those	DT
8691	1035	37	general	general	JJ
8691	1035	38	powers	power	NNS
8691	1035	39	which	which	WDT
8691	1035	40	that	that	WDT
8691	1035	41	body	body	NN
8691	1035	42	possesses	possess	VBZ
8691	1035	43	over	over	IN
8691	1035	44	the	the	DT
8691	1035	45	territories	territory	NNS
8691	1035	46	of	of	IN
8691	1035	47	the	the	DT
8691	1035	48	United	United	NNP
8691	1035	49	States	States	NNP
8691	1035	50	.	.	.
8691	1036	1	Although	although	IN
8691	1036	2	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	1036	3	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1036	4	can	can	MD
8691	1036	5	be	be	VB
8691	1036	6	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	1036	7	in	in	IN
8691	1036	8	the	the	DT
8691	1036	9	States	States	NNPS
8691	1036	10	in	in	IN
8691	1036	11	those	those	DT
8691	1036	12	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1036	13	only	only	RB
8691	1036	14	which	which	WDT
8691	1036	15	are	be	VBP
8691	1036	16	established	establish	VBN
8691	1036	17	in	in	IN
8691	1036	18	pursuance	pursuance	NN
8691	1036	19	of	of	IN
8691	1036	20	the	the	DT
8691	1036	21	third	third	JJ
8691	1036	22	article	article	NN
8691	1036	23	of	of	IN
8691	1036	24	the	the	DT
8691	1036	25	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1036	26	,	,	,
8691	1036	27	the	the	DT
8691	1036	28	same	same	JJ
8691	1036	29	limitation	limitation	NN
8691	1036	30	does	do	VBZ
8691	1036	31	not	not	RB
8691	1036	32	extend	extend	VB
8691	1036	33	to	to	IN
8691	1036	34	the	the	DT
8691	1036	35	territories	territory	NNS
8691	1036	36	.	.	.
8691	1037	1	In	in	IN
8691	1037	2	legislating	legislate	VBG
8691	1037	3	for	for	IN
8691	1037	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1037	5	,	,	,
8691	1037	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1037	7	exercises	exercise	VBZ
8691	1037	8	the	the	DT
8691	1037	9	combined	combined	JJ
8691	1037	10	powers	power	NNS
8691	1037	11	of	of	IN
8691	1037	12	the	the	DT
8691	1037	13	general	general	JJ
8691	1037	14	and	and	CC
8691	1037	15	of	of	IN
8691	1037	16	a	a	DT
8691	1037	17	State	State	NNP
8691	1037	18	government	government	NN
8691	1037	19	.	.	.
8691	1038	1	"	"	``
8691	1038	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1038	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1038	4	:	:	:
8691	1038	5	'	'	''
8691	1038	6	American	American	NNP
8691	1038	7	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	1038	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1038	9	_	_	NNP
8691	1038	10	v.	v.	IN
8691	1038	11	_	_	NNP
8691	1038	12	Canter	Canter	NNP
8691	1038	13	,	,	,
8691	1038	14	1	1	CD
8691	1038	15	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1038	16	'	'	POS
8691	1038	17	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1038	18	,	,	,
8691	1038	19	511	511	CD
8691	1038	20	,	,	,
8691	1038	21	546	546	CD
8691	1038	22	.	.	.
8691	1038	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1039	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1039	2	will	will	MD
8691	1039	3	be	be	VB
8691	1039	4	perceived	perceive	VBN
8691	1039	5	that	that	IN
8691	1039	6	the	the	DT
8691	1039	7	argument	argument	NN
8691	1039	8	here	here	RB
8691	1039	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1039	10	that	that	IN
8691	1039	11	the	the	DT
8691	1039	12	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	1039	13	court	court	NN
8691	1039	14	did	do	VBD
8691	1039	15	not	not	RB
8691	1039	16	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	1039	17	any	any	DT
8691	1039	18	of	of	IN
8691	1039	19	the	the	DT
8691	1039	20	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1039	21	power	power	NN
8691	1039	22	of	of	IN
8691	1039	23	the	the	DT
8691	1039	24	United	United	NNP
8691	1039	25	States	States	NNP
8691	1039	26	because	because	IN
8691	1039	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1039	28	could	could	MD
8691	1039	29	not	not	RB
8691	1039	30	,	,	,
8691	1039	31	and	and	CC
8691	1039	32	that	that	IN
8691	1039	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1039	34	could	could	MD
8691	1039	35	not	not	RB
8691	1039	36	because	because	IN
8691	1039	37	the	the	DT
8691	1039	38	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1039	39	were	be	VBD
8691	1039	40	not	not	RB
8691	1039	41	commissioned	commission	VBN
8691	1039	42	for	for	IN
8691	1039	43	life	life	NN
8691	1039	44	.	.	.
8691	1040	1	This	this	DT
8691	1040	2	left	leave	VBD
8691	1040	3	unanswered	unanswere	VBD
8691	1040	4	the	the	DT
8691	1040	5	deeper	deep	JJR
8691	1040	6	question	question	NN
8691	1040	7	whether	whether	IN
8691	1040	8	any	any	DT
8691	1040	9	act	act	NN
8691	1040	10	of	of	IN
8691	1040	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1040	12	could	could	MD
8691	1040	13	serve	serve	VB
8691	1040	14	to	to	TO
8691	1040	15	support	support	VB
8691	1040	16	a	a	DT
8691	1040	17	court	court	NN
8691	1040	18	existing	exist	VBG
8691	1040	19	under	under	IN
8691	1040	20	authority	authority	NN
8691	1040	21	of	of	IN
8691	1040	22	the	the	DT
8691	1040	23	United	United	NNP
8691	1040	24	States	States	NNP
8691	1040	25	,	,	,
8691	1040	26	the	the	DT
8691	1040	27	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1040	28	of	of	IN
8691	1040	29	which	which	WDT
8691	1040	30	were	be	VBD
8691	1040	31	to	to	TO
8691	1040	32	hold	hold	VB
8691	1040	33	office	office	NN
8691	1040	34	only	only	RB
8691	1040	35	for	for	IN
8691	1040	36	a	a	DT
8691	1040	37	term	term	NN
8691	1040	38	of	of	IN
8691	1040	39	years	year	NNS
8691	1040	40	.	.	.
8691	1041	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1041	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1041	3	assumed	assume	VBN
8691	1041	4	that	that	IN
8691	1041	5	the	the	DT
8691	1041	6	provision	provision	NN
8691	1041	7	for	for	IN
8691	1041	8	a	a	DT
8691	1041	9	life	life	NN
8691	1041	10	tenure	tenure	NN
8691	1041	11	did	do	VBD
8691	1041	12	not	not	RB
8691	1041	13	apply	apply	VB
8691	1041	14	to	to	IN
8691	1041	15	the	the	DT
8691	1041	16	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	1041	17	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1041	18	,	,	,
8691	1041	19	because	because	IN
8691	1041	20	if	if	IN
8691	1041	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1041	22	did	do	VBD
8691	1041	23	the	the	DT
8691	1041	24	court	court	NN
8691	1041	25	would	would	MD
8691	1041	26	be	be	VB
8691	1041	27	illegally	illegally	RB
8691	1041	28	constituted	constitute	VBN
8691	1041	29	.	.	.
8691	1042	1	Whether	whether	IN
8691	1042	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1042	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1042	4	legally	legally	RB
8691	1042	5	or	or	CC
8691	1042	6	illegally	illegally	RB
8691	1042	7	constituted	constituted	JJ
8691	1042	8	was	be	VBD
8691	1042	9	not	not	RB
8691	1042	10	discussed	discuss	VBN
8691	1042	11	,	,	,
8691	1042	12	except	except	IN
8691	1042	13	for	for	IN
8691	1042	14	the	the	DT
8691	1042	15	general	general	JJ
8691	1042	16	reference	reference	NN
8691	1042	17	to	to	IN
8691	1042	18	the	the	DT
8691	1042	19	power	power	NN
8691	1042	20	of	of	IN
8691	1042	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1042	22	to	to	TO
8691	1042	23	legislate	legislate	VB
8691	1042	24	for	for	IN
8691	1042	25	the	the	DT
8691	1042	26	territories	territory	NNS
8691	1042	27	and	and	CC
8691	1042	28	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	1042	29	the	the	DT
8691	1042	30	rights	right	NNS
8691	1042	31	of	of	IN
8691	1042	32	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1042	33	over	over	IN
8691	1042	34	territory	territory	NN
8691	1042	35	newly	newly	RB
8691	1042	36	acquired	acquire	VBN
8691	1042	37	by	by	IN
8691	1042	38	contest	contest	NN
8691	1042	39	or	or	CC
8691	1042	40	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	1042	41	.	.	.
8691	1043	1	On	on	IN
8691	1043	2	this	this	DT
8691	1043	3	decision	decision	NN
8691	1043	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	1043	5	been	be	VBN
8691	1043	6	built	build	VBN
8691	1043	7	up	up	RP
8691	1043	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1043	9	present	present	JJ
8691	1043	10	system	system	NN
8691	1043	11	of	of	IN
8691	1043	12	governing	govern	VBG
8691	1043	13	territorial	territorial	JJ
8691	1043	14	dependencies	dependency	NNS
8691	1043	15	at	at	IN
8691	1043	16	the	the	DT
8691	1043	17	will	will	NN
8691	1043	18	of	of	IN
8691	1043	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1043	20	.	.	.
8691	1044	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1044	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1044	3	:	:	:
8691	1044	4	Mormon	Mormon	NNP
8691	1044	5	Church	Church	NNP
8691	1044	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1044	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	1044	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1044	9	United	United	NNP
8691	1044	10	States	States	NNP
8691	1044	11	,	,	,
8691	1044	12	136	136	CD
8691	1044	13	United	United	NNP
8691	1044	14	States	States	NNP
8691	1044	15	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1044	16	,	,	,
8691	1044	17	1	1	CD
8691	1044	18	,	,	,
8691	1044	19	43	43	CD
8691	1044	20	;	;	:
8691	1044	21	Dorr	Dorr	NNP
8691	1044	22	_	_	NNP
8691	1044	23	vs.	vs.	IN
8691	1044	24	_	_	NNP
8691	1044	25	United	United	NNP
8691	1044	26	States	States	NNP
8691	1044	27	,	,	,
8691	1044	28	195	195	CD
8691	1044	29	United	United	NNP
8691	1044	30	States	States	NNP
8691	1044	31	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1044	32	,	,	,
8691	1044	33	138	138	CD
8691	1044	34	,	,	,
8691	1044	35	141	141	CD
8691	1044	36	.	.	.
8691	1044	37	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1045	1	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1045	2	's	's	POS
8691	1045	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1045	4	the	the	DT
8691	1045	5	last	last	JJ
8691	1045	6	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	1045	7	made	make	VBN
8691	1045	8	to	to	IN
8691	1045	9	the	the	DT
8691	1045	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1045	11	bench	bench	NN
8691	1045	12	from	from	IN
8691	1045	13	the	the	DT
8691	1045	14	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
8691	1045	15	party	party	NN
8691	1045	16	.	.	.
8691	1046	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1046	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1046	3	not	not	RB
8691	1046	4	many	many	JJ
8691	1046	5	years	year	NNS
8691	1046	6	before	before	IN
8691	1046	7	that	that	DT
8691	1046	8	party	party	NN
8691	1046	9	disappeared	disappear	VBD
8691	1046	10	from	from	IN
8691	1046	11	the	the	DT
8691	1046	12	face	face	NN
8691	1046	13	of	of	IN
8691	1046	14	the	the	DT
8691	1046	15	earth	earth	NN
8691	1046	16	.	.	.
8691	1047	1	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	1047	2	put	put	VBD
8691	1047	3	three	three	CD
8691	1047	4	men	man	NNS
8691	1047	5	there	there	RB
8691	1047	6	representing	represent	VBG
8691	1047	7	the	the	DT
8691	1047	8	other	other	JJ
8691	1047	9	school	school	NN
8691	1047	10	of	of	IN
8691	1047	11	political	political	JJ
8691	1047	12	doctrine,[Footnote	doctrine,[Footnote	NNP
8691	1047	13	:	:	:
8691	1047	14	Among	among	IN
8691	1047	15	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	1047	16	's	's	POS
8691	1047	17	papers	paper	NNS
8691	1047	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	1047	19	a	a	DT
8691	1047	20	description	description	NN
8691	1047	21	of	of	IN
8691	1047	22	five	five	CD
8691	1047	23	men	man	NNS
8691	1047	24	whom	whom	WP
8691	1047	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1047	26	especially	especially	RB
8691	1047	27	considered	consider	VBD
8691	1047	28	with	with	IN
8691	1047	29	reference	reference	NN
8691	1047	30	to	to	IN
8691	1047	31	filling	fill	VBG
8691	1047	32	the	the	DT
8691	1047	33	first	first	JJ
8691	1047	34	vacancy	vacancy	NN
8691	1047	35	which	which	WDT
8691	1047	36	occurred	occur	VBD
8691	1047	37	during	during	IN
8691	1047	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1047	39	administration	administration	NN
8691	1047	40	.	.	.
8691	1048	1	Politics	politic	NNS
8691	1048	2	figures	figure	NNS
8691	1048	3	largely	largely	RB
8691	1048	4	in	in	IN
8691	1048	5	the	the	DT
8691	1048	6	sketch	sketch	NN
8691	1048	7	of	of	IN
8691	1048	8	each	each	DT
8691	1048	9	.	.	.
8691	1049	1	As	as	IN
8691	1049	2	to	to	IN
8691	1049	3	William	William	NNP
8691	1049	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	1049	5	,	,	,
8691	1049	6	whom	whom	WP
8691	1049	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1049	8	selected	select	VBD
8691	1049	9	,	,	,
8691	1049	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1049	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	1049	12	noted	note	VBN
8691	1049	13	that	that	IN
8691	1049	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1049	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	1049	16	of	of	IN
8691	1049	17	"	"	``
8691	1049	18	republican	republican	JJ
8691	1049	19	convictions	conviction	NNS
8691	1049	20	and	and	CC
8691	1049	21	of	of	IN
8691	1049	22	good	good	JJ
8691	1049	23	nerves	nerve	NNS
8691	1049	24	in	in	IN
8691	1049	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1049	26	political	political	JJ
8691	1049	27	principles	principle	NNS
8691	1049	28	.	.	.
8691	1049	29	"	"	''
8691	1050	1	American	American	NNP
8691	1050	2	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1050	3	Review	Review	NNP
8691	1050	4	,	,	,
8691	1050	5	III	III	NNP
8691	1050	6	,	,	,
8691	1050	7	282	282	CD
8691	1050	8	.	.	.
8691	1050	9	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1051	1	and	and	CC
8691	1051	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1051	3	appointments	appointment	NNS
8691	1051	4	were	be	VBD
8691	1051	5	followed	follow	VBN
8691	1051	6	by	by	IN
8691	1051	7	others	other	NNS
8691	1051	8	of	of	IN
8691	1051	9	a	a	DT
8691	1051	10	similar	similar	JJ
8691	1051	11	nature	nature	NN
8691	1051	12	,	,	,
8691	1051	13	until	until	IN
8691	1051	14	in	in	IN
8691	1051	15	1830	1830	CD
8691	1051	16	,	,	,
8691	1051	17	after	after	IN
8691	1051	18	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1051	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1051	20	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
8691	1051	21	had	have	VBD
8691	1051	22	taken	take	VBN
8691	1051	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1051	24	seat	seat	NN
8691	1051	25	,	,	,
8691	1051	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1051	27	became	become	VBD
8691	1051	28	evident	evident	JJ
8691	1051	29	that	that	IN
8691	1051	30	the	the	DT
8691	1051	31	nationalizing	nationalize	VBG
8691	1051	32	tendencies	tendency	NNS
8691	1051	33	which	which	WDT
8691	1051	34	the	the	DT
8691	1051	35	great	great	JJ
8691	1051	36	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1051	37	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1051	38	from	from	IN
8691	1051	39	the	the	DT
8691	1051	40	beginning	beginning	NN
8691	1051	41	of	of	IN
8691	1051	42	the	the	DT
8691	1051	43	century	century	NN
8691	1051	44	had	have	VBD
8691	1051	45	impressed	impress	VBN
8691	1051	46	upon	upon	IN
8691	1051	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1051	48	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	1051	49	were	be	VBD
8691	1051	50	likely	likely	JJ
8691	1051	51	soon	soon	RB
8691	1051	52	to	to	TO
8691	1051	53	cease	cease	VB
8691	1051	54	.	.	.
8691	1052	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1052	2	apprehended	apprehend	VBD
8691	1052	3	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1052	4	that	that	IN
8691	1052	5	the	the	DT
8691	1052	6	court	court	NN
8691	1052	7	would	would	MD
8691	1052	8	come	come	VB
8691	1052	9	to	to	TO
8691	1052	10	decline	decline	VB
8691	1052	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1052	12	in	in	IN
8691	1052	13	the	the	DT
8691	1052	14	cases	case	NNS
8691	1052	15	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	1052	16	presented	present	VBD
8691	1052	17	over	over	IN
8691	1052	18	writs	writ	NNS
8691	1052	19	of	of	IN
8691	1052	20	error	error	NN
8691	1052	21	to	to	TO
8691	1052	22	reverse	reverse	VB
8691	1052	23	the	the	DT
8691	1052	24	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1052	25	of	of	IN
8691	1052	26	State	State	NNP
8691	1052	27	courts	court	NNS
8691	1052	28	.	.	.
8691	1053	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1053	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1053	3	:	:	:
8691	1053	4	Proceedings	proceedings	NN
8691	1053	5	:	:	:
8691	1053	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	1053	7	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1053	8	Society	Society	NNP
8691	1053	9	,	,	,
8691	1053	10	2d	2d	NNP
8691	1053	11	Series	Series	NNP
8691	1053	12	,	,	,
8691	1053	13	XIV	XIV	NNP
8691	1053	14	,	,	,
8691	1053	15	342	342	CD
8691	1053	16	.	.	.
8691	1053	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1054	1	In	in	IN
8691	1054	2	the	the	DT
8691	1054	3	following	following	JJ
8691	1054	4	year	year	NN
8691	1054	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1054	6	thought	think	VBD
8691	1054	7	seriously	seriously	RB
8691	1054	8	of	of	IN
8691	1054	9	resigning	resign	VBG
8691	1054	10	.	.	.
8691	1055	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1055	2	disliked	dislike	VBD
8691	1055	3	,	,	,
8691	1055	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1055	5	wrote	write	VBD
8691	1055	6	to	to	IN
8691	1055	7	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1055	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1055	9	Story	Story	NNP
8691	1055	10	,	,	,
8691	1055	11	to	to	TO
8691	1055	12	leave	leave	VB
8691	1055	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1055	14	almost	almost	RB
8691	1055	15	alone	alone	JJ
8691	1055	16	to	to	TO
8691	1055	17	represent	represent	VB
8691	1055	18	the	the	DT
8691	1055	19	old	old	JJ
8691	1055	20	school	school	NN
8691	1055	21	of	of	IN
8691	1055	22	thought	thought	NN
8691	1055	23	,	,	,
8691	1055	24	but	but	CC
8691	1055	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1055	26	adds	add	VBZ
8691	1055	27	,	,	,
8691	1055	28	"	"	``
8691	1055	29	the	the	DT
8691	1055	30	solemn	solemn	JJ
8691	1055	31	convictions	conviction	NNS
8691	1055	32	of	of	IN
8691	1055	33	my	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1055	34	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1055	35	,	,	,
8691	1055	36	sustained	sustain	VBN
8691	1055	37	by	by	IN
8691	1055	38	some	some	DT
8691	1055	39	pride	pride	NN
8691	1055	40	of	of	IN
8691	1055	41	character	character	NN
8691	1055	42	,	,	,
8691	1055	43	admonish	admonish	VB
8691	1055	44	me	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1055	45	not	not	RB
8691	1055	46	to	to	TO
8691	1055	47	hazard	hazard	VB
8691	1055	48	the	the	DT
8691	1055	49	disgrace	disgrace	NN
8691	1055	50	of	of	IN
8691	1055	51	continuing	continue	VBG
8691	1055	52	in	in	IN
8691	1055	53	office	office	NN
8691	1055	54	a	a	DT
8691	1055	55	mere	mere	JJ
8691	1055	56	inefficient	inefficient	JJ
8691	1055	57	pageant	pageant	NN
8691	1055	58	.	.	.
8691	1056	1	"	"	``
8691	1056	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1056	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1056	4	:	:	:
8691	1056	5	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
8691	1056	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	1056	7	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1056	8	Society	Society	NNP
8691	1056	9	,	,	,
8691	1056	10	2d	2d	NNP
8691	1056	11	Series	Series	NNP
8691	1056	12	,	,	,
8691	1056	13	XIV	XIV	NNP
8691	1056	14	,	,	,
8691	1056	15	347	347	CD
8691	1056	16	.	.	.
8691	1056	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1057	1	The	the	DT
8691	1057	2	next	next	JJ
8691	1057	3	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1057	4	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1057	5	,	,	,
8691	1057	6	while	while	IN
8691	1057	7	far	far	RB
8691	1057	8	from	from	IN
8691	1057	9	being	be	VBG
8691	1057	10	of	of	IN
8691	1057	11	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1057	12	's	's	POS
8691	1057	13	school	school	NN
8691	1057	14	,	,	,
8691	1057	15	was	be	VBD
8691	1057	16	not	not	RB
8691	1057	17	one	one	CD
8691	1057	18	to	to	TO
8691	1057	19	attempt	attempt	VB
8691	1057	20	to	to	TO
8691	1057	21	overthrow	overthrow	VB
8691	1057	22	what	what	WP
8691	1057	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1057	24	had	have	VBD
8691	1057	25	done	do	VBN
8691	1057	26	.	.	.
8691	1058	1	In	in	IN
8691	1058	2	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
8691	1058	3	_	_	NNP
8691	1058	4	v.	v.	IN
8691	1058	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1058	6	Booth,[Footnote	Booth,[Footnote	NNP
8691	1058	7	:	:	:
8691	1058	8	21	21	CD
8691	1058	9	Howard	Howard	NNP
8691	1058	10	's	's	POS
8691	1058	11	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1058	12	,	,	,
8691	1058	13	506	506	CD
8691	1058	14	.	.	.
8691	1058	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1059	1	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1059	2	insisted	insist	VBD
8691	1059	3	on	on	IN
8691	1059	4	the	the	DT
8691	1059	5	supremacy	supremacy	NN
8691	1059	6	of	of	IN
8691	1059	7	the	the	DT
8691	1059	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	1059	9	of	of	IN
8691	1059	10	the	the	DT
8691	1059	11	United	United	NNP
8691	1059	12	States	States	NNP
8691	1059	13	over	over	IN
8691	1059	14	those	those	DT
8691	1059	15	of	of	IN
8691	1059	16	the	the	DT
8691	1059	17	States	States	NNPS
8691	1059	18	with	with	IN
8691	1059	19	the	the	DT
8691	1059	20	utmost	utmost	JJ
8691	1059	21	firmness	firmness	NN
8691	1059	22	,	,	,
8691	1059	23	and	and	CC
8691	1059	24	defended	defend	VBD
8691	1059	25	the	the	DT
8691	1059	26	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1059	27	on	on	IN
8691	1059	28	principle	principle	NN
8691	1059	29	with	with	IN
8691	1059	30	force	force	NN
8691	1059	31	and	and	CC
8691	1059	32	ability	ability	NN
8691	1059	33	.	.	.
8691	1060	1	The	the	DT
8691	1060	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1060	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1060	4	,	,	,
8691	1060	5	however	however	RB
8691	1060	6	,	,	,
8691	1060	7	under	under	IN
8691	1060	8	Taney	Taney	NNP
8691	1060	9	,	,	,
8691	1060	10	was	be	VBD
8691	1060	11	not	not	RB
8691	1060	12	looked	look	VBN
8691	1060	13	on	on	RP
8691	1060	14	with	with	IN
8691	1060	15	much	much	JJ
8691	1060	16	favor	favor	NN
8691	1060	17	by	by	IN
8691	1060	18	the	the	DT
8691	1060	19	survivors	survivor	NNS
8691	1060	20	of	of	IN
8691	1060	21	the	the	DT
8691	1060	22	old	old	JJ
8691	1060	23	Federalists	federalist	NNS
8691	1060	24	.	.	.
8691	1061	1	"	"	``
8691	1061	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1061	3	do	do	VBP
8691	1061	4	not	not	RB
8691	1061	5	,	,	,
8691	1061	6	"	"	''
8691	1061	7	wrote	write	VBD
8691	1061	8	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	1061	9	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	1061	10	in	in	IN
8691	1061	11	1845	1845	CD
8691	1061	12	to	to	IN
8691	1061	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1061	14	Story	Story	NNP
8691	1061	15	,	,	,
8691	1061	16	"	"	``
8691	1061	17	regard	regard	VBP
8691	1061	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1061	19	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	1061	20	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1061	21	yours	yours	PRP$
8691	1061	22	always	always	RB
8691	1061	23	excepted	except	VBN
8691	1061	24	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1061	25	with	with	IN
8691	1061	26	much	much	JJ
8691	1061	27	reverence	reverence	NN
8691	1061	28	,	,	,
8691	1061	29	and	and	CC
8691	1061	30	for	for	IN
8691	1061	31	a	a	DT
8691	1061	32	number	number	NN
8691	1061	33	of	of	IN
8691	1061	34	the	the	DT
8691	1061	35	associates	associate	NNS
8691	1061	36	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1061	37	feel	feel	VBP
8691	1061	38	habitual	habitual	JJ
8691	1061	39	scorn	scorn	JJ
8691	1061	40	and	and	CC
8691	1061	41	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	1061	42	.	.	.
8691	1062	1	"	"	``
8691	1062	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1062	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1062	4	:	:	:
8691	1062	5	Proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1062	6	of	of	IN
8691	1062	7	the	the	DT
8691	1062	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	1062	9	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1062	10	Society	Society	NNP
8691	1062	11	,	,	,
8691	1062	12	2d	2d	NNP
8691	1062	13	Series	Series	NNP
8691	1062	14	,	,	,
8691	1062	15	XIV	XIV	NNP
8691	1062	16	,	,	,
8691	1062	17	420	420	CD
8691	1062	18	.	.	.
8691	1062	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1063	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1063	2	State	state	NN
8691	1063	3	constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	1063	4	generally	generally	RB
8691	1063	5	guarantee	guarantee	VBP
8691	1063	6	the	the	DT
8691	1063	7	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	1063	8	against	against	IN
8691	1063	9	deprivation	deprivation	NN
8691	1063	10	of	of	IN
8691	1063	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1063	12	rights	right	NNS
8691	1063	13	without	without	IN
8691	1063	14	"	"	``
8691	1063	15	due	due	JJ
8691	1063	16	process	process	NN
8691	1063	17	of	of	IN
8691	1063	18	law	law	NN
8691	1063	19	"	"	''
8691	1063	20	or	or	CC
8691	1063	21	"	"	``
8691	1063	22	due	due	JJ
8691	1063	23	course	course	NN
8691	1063	24	of	of	IN
8691	1063	25	law	law	NN
8691	1063	26	.	.	.
8691	1063	27	"	"	''
8691	1064	1	A	a	DT
8691	1064	2	similar	similar	JJ
8691	1064	3	provision	provision	NN
8691	1064	4	was	be	VBD
8691	1064	5	made	make	VBN
8691	1064	6	for	for	IN
8691	1064	7	the	the	DT
8691	1064	8	United	United	NNP
8691	1064	9	States	States	NNP
8691	1064	10	by	by	IN
8691	1064	11	the	the	DT
8691	1064	12	fifth	fifth	JJ
8691	1064	13	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	1064	14	to	to	IN
8691	1064	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1064	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1064	17	,	,	,
8691	1064	18	and	and	CC
8691	1064	19	since	since	IN
8691	1064	20	1868	1868	CD
8691	1064	21	the	the	DT
8691	1064	22	fourteenth	fourteenth	NNP
8691	1064	23	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	1064	24	has	have	VBZ
8691	1064	25	established	establish	VBN
8691	1064	26	the	the	DT
8691	1064	27	same	same	JJ
8691	1064	28	rule	rule	NN
8691	1064	29	inflexibly	inflexibly	RB
8691	1064	30	for	for	IN
8691	1064	31	every	every	DT
8691	1064	32	State	state	NN
8691	1064	33	.	.	.
8691	1065	1	What	what	WP
8691	1065	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1065	3	due	due	JJ
8691	1065	4	process	process	NN
8691	1065	5	of	of	IN
8691	1065	6	law	law	NN
8691	1065	7	?	?	.
8691	1066	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1066	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1066	3	for	for	IN
8691	1066	4	the	the	DT
8691	1066	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	1066	6	to	to	TO
8691	1066	7	say	say	VB
8691	1066	8	,	,	,
8691	1066	9	and	and	CC
8691	1066	10	while	while	IN
8691	1066	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1066	12	have	have	VBP
8691	1066	13	cautiously	cautiously	RB
8691	1066	14	refrained	refrain	VBN
8691	1066	15	from	from	IN
8691	1066	16	assuming	assume	VBG
8691	1066	17	to	to	TO
8691	1066	18	give	give	VB
8691	1066	19	any	any	DT
8691	1066	20	precise	precise	JJ
8691	1066	21	and	and	CC
8691	1066	22	exhaustive	exhaustive	JJ
8691	1066	23	definition	definition	NN
8691	1066	24	,	,	,
8691	1066	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1066	26	have	have	VBP
8691	1066	27	,	,	,
8691	1066	28	in	in	IN
8691	1066	29	many	many	JJ
8691	1066	30	instances	instance	NNS
8691	1066	31	,	,	,
8691	1066	32	enforced	enforce	VBD
8691	1066	33	the	the	DT
8691	1066	34	guaranty	guaranty	NN
8691	1066	35	at	at	IN
8691	1066	36	the	the	DT
8691	1066	37	cost	cost	NN
8691	1066	38	of	of	IN
8691	1066	39	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	1066	40	some	some	DT
8691	1066	41	statute	statute	NN
8691	1066	42	which	which	WDT
8691	1066	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1066	44	held	hold	VBD
8691	1066	45	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
8691	1066	46	with	with	IN
8691	1066	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1066	48	to	to	TO
8691	1066	49	be	be	VB
8691	1066	50	no	no	DT
8691	1066	51	law	law	NN
8691	1066	52	.	.	.
8691	1067	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1067	2	have	have	VBP
8691	1067	3	also	also	RB
8691	1067	4	,	,	,
8691	1067	5	and	and	CC
8691	1067	6	much	much	RB
8691	1067	7	more	more	RBR
8691	1067	8	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	1067	9	,	,	,
8691	1067	10	supported	support	VBD
8691	1067	11	some	some	DT
8691	1067	12	act	act	NN
8691	1067	13	of	of	IN
8691	1067	14	government	government	NN
8691	1067	15	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	1067	16	to	to	TO
8691	1067	17	contravene	contravene	VB
8691	1067	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1067	19	,	,	,
8691	1067	20	and	and	CC
8691	1067	21	which	which	WDT
8691	1067	22	,	,	,
8691	1067	23	according	accord	VBG
8691	1067	24	to	to	IN
8691	1067	25	the	the	DT
8691	1067	26	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	1067	27	common	common	JJ
8691	1067	28	law	law	NN
8691	1067	29	of	of	IN
8691	1067	30	England	England	NNP
8691	1067	31	,	,	,
8691	1067	32	would	would	MD
8691	1067	33	contravene	contravene	VB
8691	1067	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1067	35	,	,	,
8691	1067	36	because	because	IN
8691	1067	37	in	in	IN
8691	1067	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1067	39	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1067	40	this	this	DT
8691	1067	41	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	1067	42	law	law	NN
8691	1067	43	had	have	VBD
8691	1067	44	been	be	VBN
8691	1067	45	outgrown	outgrow	VBN
8691	1067	46	.	.	.
8691	1068	1	Sir	Sir	NNP
8691	1068	2	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	1068	3	Coke	Coke	NNP
8691	1068	4	,	,	,
8691	1068	5	whom	whom	WP
8691	1068	6	no	no	UH
8691	1068	7	expounder	expounder	NN
8691	1068	8	of	of	IN
8691	1068	9	the	the	DT
8691	1068	10	English	english	JJ
8691	1068	11	common	common	JJ
8691	1068	12	law	law	NN
8691	1068	13	outranks	outrank	VBZ
8691	1068	14	in	in	IN
8691	1068	15	authority	authority	NN
8691	1068	16	,	,	,
8691	1068	17	in	in	IN
8691	1068	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1068	19	"	"	``
8691	1068	20	Institutes	Institutes	NNP
8691	1068	21	,	,	,
8691	1068	22	"	"	''
8691	1068	23	in	in	IN
8691	1068	24	treating	treating	NN
8691	1068	25	of	of	IN
8691	1068	26	_	_	NNP
8691	1068	27	Magna	Magna	NNPS
8691	1068	28	Charta	Charta	NNP
8691	1068	29	_	_	NNP
8691	1068	30	,	,	,
8691	1068	31	referred	refer	VBD
8691	1068	32	to	to	IN
8691	1068	33	the	the	DT
8691	1068	34	phrase	phrase	NN
8691	1068	35	_	_	NNP
8691	1068	36	per	per	IN
8691	1068	37	legem	legem	NNP
8691	1068	38	terrae	terrae	NNP
8691	1068	39	_	_	NNP
8691	1068	40	,	,	,
8691	1068	41	as	as	IN
8691	1068	42	equivalent	equivalent	JJ
8691	1068	43	to	to	IN
8691	1068	44	"	"	``
8691	1068	45	by	by	IN
8691	1068	46	the	the	DT
8691	1068	47	law	law	NN
8691	1068	48	of	of	IN
8691	1068	49	the	the	DT
8691	1068	50	land	land	NN
8691	1068	51	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1068	52	that	that	RB
8691	1068	53	is	is	RB
8691	1068	54	,	,	,
8691	1068	55	to	to	TO
8691	1068	56	speak	speak	VB
8691	1068	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1068	58	once	once	RB
8691	1068	59	for	for	IN
8691	1068	60	all	all	DT
8691	1068	61	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1068	62	by	by	IN
8691	1068	63	the	the	DT
8691	1068	64	due	due	JJ
8691	1068	65	course	course	NN
8691	1068	66	and	and	CC
8691	1068	67	process	process	NN
8691	1068	68	of	of	IN
8691	1068	69	law	law	NN
8691	1068	70	.	.	.
8691	1068	71	"	"	''
8691	1069	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1069	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1069	3	incontestable	incontestable	JJ
8691	1069	4	that	that	DT
8691	1069	5	due	due	JJ
8691	1069	6	course	course	NN
8691	1069	7	and	and	CC
8691	1069	8	process	process	NN
8691	1069	9	of	of	IN
8691	1069	10	law	law	NN
8691	1069	11	in	in	IN
8691	1069	12	England	England	NNP
8691	1069	13	at	at	IN
8691	1069	14	the	the	DT
8691	1069	15	time	time	NN
8691	1069	16	when	when	WRB
8691	1069	17	the	the	DT
8691	1069	18	American	american	JJ
8691	1069	19	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	1069	20	were	be	VBD
8691	1069	21	planted	plant	VBN
8691	1069	22	was	be	VBD
8691	1069	23	understood	understand	VBN
8691	1069	24	to	to	TO
8691	1069	25	require	require	VB
8691	1069	26	the	the	DT
8691	1069	27	action	action	NN
8691	1069	28	of	of	IN
8691	1069	29	a	a	DT
8691	1069	30	grand	grand	JJ
8691	1069	31	jury	jury	NN
8691	1069	32	before	before	IN
8691	1069	33	any	any	DT
8691	1069	34	one	one	NN
8691	1069	35	could	could	MD
8691	1069	36	be	be	VB
8691	1069	37	put	put	VBN
8691	1069	38	on	on	IN
8691	1069	39	trial	trial	NN
8691	1069	40	for	for	IN
8691	1069	41	a	a	DT
8691	1069	42	felony	felony	NN
8691	1069	43	.	.	.
8691	1070	1	Some	some	DT
8691	1070	2	of	of	IN
8691	1070	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1070	4	States	state	NNS
8691	1070	5	have	have	VBP
8691	1070	6	abolished	abolish	VBN
8691	1070	7	grand	grand	JJ
8691	1070	8	juries	jury	NNS
8691	1070	9	in	in	IN
8691	1070	10	whole	whole	NN
8691	1070	11	or	or	CC
8691	1070	12	part	part	NN
8691	1070	13	.	.	.
8691	1071	1	To	to	TO
8691	1071	2	review	review	VB
8691	1071	3	a	a	DT
8691	1071	4	capital	capital	NN
8691	1071	5	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	1071	6	for	for	IN
8691	1071	7	murder	murder	NN
8691	1071	8	in	in	IN
8691	1071	9	one	one	CD
8691	1071	10	of	of	IN
8691	1071	11	these	these	DT
8691	1071	12	States	state	NNS
8691	1071	13	,	,	,
8691	1071	14	a	a	DT
8691	1071	15	writ	writ	NN
8691	1071	16	of	of	IN
8691	1071	17	error	error	NN
8691	1071	18	was	be	VBD
8691	1071	19	prayed	pray	VBN
8691	1071	20	out	out	RP
8691	1071	21	from	from	IN
8691	1071	22	the	the	DT
8691	1071	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1071	24	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1071	25	of	of	IN
8691	1071	26	the	the	DT
8691	1071	27	United	United	NNP
8691	1071	28	States	States	NNP
8691	1071	29	in	in	IN
8691	1071	30	1883	1883	CD
8691	1071	31	.	.	.
8691	1072	1	The	the	DT
8691	1072	2	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	1072	3	of	of	IN
8691	1072	4	the	the	DT
8691	1072	5	State	State	NNP
8691	1072	6	law	law	NN
8691	1072	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1072	8	sustained	sustain	VBN
8691	1072	9	.	.	.
8691	1073	1	In	in	IN
8691	1073	2	disposing	dispose	VBG
8691	1073	3	of	of	IN
8691	1073	4	the	the	DT
8691	1073	5	case	case	NN
8691	1073	6	the	the	DT
8691	1073	7	court	court	NN
8691	1073	8	did	do	VBD
8691	1073	9	not	not	RB
8691	1073	10	controvert	controvert	VB
8691	1073	11	the	the	DT
8691	1073	12	position	position	NN
8691	1073	13	that	that	IN
8691	1073	14	by	by	IN
8691	1073	15	the	the	DT
8691	1073	16	English	english	JJ
8691	1073	17	common	common	JJ
8691	1073	18	law	law	NN
8691	1073	19	no	no	DT
8691	1073	20	man	man	NN
8691	1073	21	could	could	MD
8691	1073	22	be	be	VB
8691	1073	23	tried	try	VBN
8691	1073	24	for	for	IN
8691	1073	25	murder	murder	NN
8691	1073	26	unless	unless	IN
8691	1073	27	on	on	IN
8691	1073	28	a	a	DT
8691	1073	29	presentment	presentment	NN
8691	1073	30	or	or	CC
8691	1073	31	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	1073	32	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1073	33	from	from	IN
8691	1073	34	a	a	DT
8691	1073	35	grand	grand	JJ
8691	1073	36	jury	jury	NN
8691	1073	37	.	.	.
8691	1074	1	But	but	CC
8691	1074	2	,	,	,
8691	1074	3	said	say	VBD
8691	1074	4	the	the	DT
8691	1074	5	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1074	6	,	,	,
8691	1074	7	while	while	IN
8691	1074	8	that	that	DT
8691	1074	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1074	10	due	due	JJ
8691	1074	11	process	process	NN
8691	1074	12	of	of	IN
8691	1074	13	law	law	NN
8691	1074	14	which	which	WDT
8691	1074	15	had	have	VBD
8691	1074	16	the	the	DT
8691	1074	17	sanction	sanction	NN
8691	1074	18	of	of	IN
8691	1074	19	settled	settle	VBN
8691	1074	20	usage	usage	NN
8691	1074	21	,	,	,
8691	1074	22	both	both	CC
8691	1074	23	in	in	IN
8691	1074	24	England	England	NNP
8691	1074	25	and	and	CC
8691	1074	26	in	in	IN
8691	1074	27	this	this	DT
8691	1074	28	country	country	NN
8691	1074	29	,	,	,
8691	1074	30	at	at	IN
8691	1074	31	the	the	DT
8691	1074	32	time	time	NN
8691	1074	33	when	when	WRB
8691	1074	34	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1074	35	early	early	JJ
8691	1074	36	American	american	JJ
8691	1074	37	constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	1074	38	were	be	VBD
8691	1074	39	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1074	40	in	in	IN
8691	1074	41	the	the	DT
8691	1074	42	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
8691	1074	43	century	century	NN
8691	1074	44	,	,	,
8691	1074	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1074	46	by	by	IN
8691	1074	47	no	no	DT
8691	1074	48	means	means	NN
8691	1074	49	follows	follow	VBZ
8691	1074	50	that	that	IN
8691	1074	51	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	1074	52	else	else	RB
8691	1074	53	can	can	MD
8691	1074	54	be	be	VB
8691	1074	55	.	.	.
8691	1075	1	To	to	TO
8691	1075	2	hold	hold	VB
8691	1075	3	that	that	IN
8691	1075	4	every	every	DT
8691	1075	5	feature	feature	NN
8691	1075	6	of	of	IN
8691	1075	7	such	such	JJ
8691	1075	8	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	1075	9	"	"	``
8691	1075	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	1075	11	essential	essential	JJ
8691	1075	12	to	to	IN
8691	1075	13	due	due	JJ
8691	1075	14	process	process	NN
8691	1075	15	of	of	IN
8691	1075	16	law	law	NN
8691	1075	17	would	would	MD
8691	1075	18	be	be	VB
8691	1075	19	to	to	TO
8691	1075	20	deny	deny	VB
8691	1075	21	every	every	DT
8691	1075	22	quality	quality	NN
8691	1075	23	of	of	IN
8691	1075	24	the	the	DT
8691	1075	25	law	law	NN
8691	1075	26	but	but	CC
8691	1075	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1075	28	age	age	NN
8691	1075	29	,	,	,
8691	1075	30	and	and	CC
8691	1075	31	to	to	TO
8691	1075	32	render	render	VB
8691	1075	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1075	34	incapable	incapable	JJ
8691	1075	35	of	of	IN
8691	1075	36	progress	progress	NN
8691	1075	37	or	or	CC
8691	1075	38	improvement	improvement	NN
8691	1075	39	.	.	.
8691	1076	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1076	2	would	would	MD
8691	1076	3	be	be	VB
8691	1076	4	to	to	TO
8691	1076	5	stamp	stamp	VB
8691	1076	6	upon	upon	IN
8691	1076	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1076	8	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	1076	9	the	the	DT
8691	1076	10	unchangeableness	unchangeableness	NN
8691	1076	11	attributed	attribute	VBD
8691	1076	12	to	to	IN
8691	1076	13	the	the	DT
8691	1076	14	laws	law	NNS
8691	1076	15	of	of	IN
8691	1076	16	the	the	DT
8691	1076	17	Medes	Medes	NNP
8691	1076	18	and	and	CC
8691	1076	19	Persians	Persians	NNPS
8691	1076	20	....	....	.
8691	1077	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1077	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1077	3	most	most	RBS
8691	1077	4	consonant	consonant	JJ
8691	1077	5	to	to	IN
8691	1077	6	the	the	DT
8691	1077	7	true	true	JJ
8691	1077	8	philosophy	philosophy	NN
8691	1077	9	of	of	IN
8691	1077	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1077	11	historical	historical	JJ
8691	1077	12	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1077	13	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	1077	14	to	to	TO
8691	1077	15	say	say	VB
8691	1077	16	that	that	IN
8691	1077	17	the	the	DT
8691	1077	18	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	1077	19	of	of	IN
8691	1077	20	personal	personal	JJ
8691	1077	21	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	1077	22	and	and	CC
8691	1077	23	individual	individual	NN
8691	1077	24	right	right	NN
8691	1077	25	,	,	,
8691	1077	26	which	which	WDT
8691	1077	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1077	28	embodied	embody	VBD
8691	1077	29	,	,	,
8691	1077	30	was	be	VBD
8691	1077	31	preserved	preserve	VBN
8691	1077	32	and	and	CC
8691	1077	33	developed	develop	VBN
8691	1077	34	by	by	IN
8691	1077	35	a	a	DT
8691	1077	36	progressive	progressive	JJ
8691	1077	37	growth	growth	NN
8691	1077	38	and	and	CC
8691	1077	39	wise	wise	JJ
8691	1077	40	adaptation	adaptation	NN
8691	1077	41	to	to	IN
8691	1077	42	new	new	JJ
8691	1077	43	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	1077	44	and	and	CC
8691	1077	45	situations	situation	NNS
8691	1077	46	of	of	IN
8691	1077	47	the	the	DT
8691	1077	48	forms	form	NNS
8691	1077	49	and	and	CC
8691	1077	50	processes	process	NNS
8691	1077	51	found	find	VBD
8691	1077	52	fit	fit	JJ
8691	1077	53	to	to	TO
8691	1077	54	give	give	VB
8691	1077	55	,	,	,
8691	1077	56	from	from	IN
8691	1077	57	time	time	NN
8691	1077	58	to	to	IN
8691	1077	59	time	time	NN
8691	1077	60	,	,	,
8691	1077	61	new	new	JJ
8691	1077	62	expression	expression	NN
8691	1077	63	and	and	CC
8691	1077	64	greater	great	JJR
8691	1077	65	effect	effect	NN
8691	1077	66	to	to	IN
8691	1077	67	modern	modern	JJ
8691	1077	68	ideas	idea	NNS
8691	1077	69	of	of	IN
8691	1077	70	self	self	NN
8691	1077	71	-	-	HYPH
8691	1077	72	government	government	NN
8691	1077	73	....	....	.
8691	1078	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1078	2	follows	follow	VBZ
8691	1078	3	that	that	IN
8691	1078	4	any	any	DT
8691	1078	5	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1078	6	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1078	7	enforced	enforce	VBN
8691	1078	8	by	by	IN
8691	1078	9	public	public	JJ
8691	1078	10	authority	authority	NN
8691	1078	11	,	,	,
8691	1078	12	whether	whether	IN
8691	1078	13	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
8691	1078	14	by	by	IN
8691	1078	15	age	age	NN
8691	1078	16	and	and	CC
8691	1078	17	custom	custom	NN
8691	1078	18	or	or	CC
8691	1078	19	newly	newly	RB
8691	1078	20	devised	devise	VBN
8691	1078	21	in	in	IN
8691	1078	22	the	the	DT
8691	1078	23	discretion	discretion	NN
8691	1078	24	of	of	IN
8691	1078	25	the	the	DT
8691	1078	26	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1078	27	power	power	NN
8691	1078	28	in	in	IN
8691	1078	29	furtherance	furtherance	NN
8691	1078	30	of	of	IN
8691	1078	31	the	the	DT
8691	1078	32	general	general	JJ
8691	1078	33	public	public	JJ
8691	1078	34	good	good	NN
8691	1078	35	,	,	,
8691	1078	36	which	which	WDT
8691	1078	37	regards	regard	VBZ
8691	1078	38	and	and	CC
8691	1078	39	preserves	preserve	NNS
8691	1078	40	these	these	DT
8691	1078	41	principles	principle	NNS
8691	1078	42	of	of	IN
8691	1078	43	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	1078	44	and	and	CC
8691	1078	45	justice	justice	NN
8691	1078	46	,	,	,
8691	1078	47	must	must	MD
8691	1078	48	be	be	VB
8691	1078	49	held	hold	VBN
8691	1078	50	to	to	TO
8691	1078	51	be	be	VB
8691	1078	52	due	due	JJ
8691	1078	53	process	process	NN
8691	1078	54	of	of	IN
8691	1078	55	law	law	NN
8691	1078	56	.	.	.
8691	1079	1	"	"	``
8691	1079	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1079	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	1079	4	:	:	:
8691	1079	5	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
8691	1079	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1079	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	1079	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1079	9	California	California	NNP
8691	1079	10	,	,	,
8691	1079	11	110	110	CD
8691	1079	12	United	United	NNP
8691	1079	13	States	States	NNP
8691	1079	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1079	15	,	,	,
8691	1079	16	513	513	CD
8691	1079	17	,	,	,
8691	1079	18	528	528	CD
8691	1079	19	,	,	,
8691	1079	20	529	529	CD
8691	1079	21	,	,	,
8691	1079	22	530	530	CD
8691	1079	23	,	,	,
8691	1079	24	537	537	CD
8691	1079	25	.	.	.
8691	1079	26	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1080	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	1080	2	of	of	IN
8691	1080	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1080	4	State	State	NNP
8691	1080	5	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	1080	6	specify	specify	VBP
8691	1080	7	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1080	8	rights	right	NNS
8691	1080	9	as	as	IN
8691	1080	10	inherent	inherent	JJ
8691	1080	11	and	and	CC
8691	1080	12	indefeasible	indefeasible	JJ
8691	1080	13	,	,	,
8691	1080	14	and	and	CC
8691	1080	15	among	among	IN
8691	1080	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1080	17	that	that	IN
8691	1080	18	"	"	``
8691	1080	19	of	of	IN
8691	1080	20	acquiring	acquire	VBG
8691	1080	21	,	,	,
8691	1080	22	possessing	possess	VBG
8691	1080	23	,	,	,
8691	1080	24	and	and	CC
8691	1080	25	protecting	protect	VBG
8691	1080	26	property	property	NN
8691	1080	27	.	.	.
8691	1080	28	"	"	''
8691	1081	1	What	what	WP
8691	1081	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1081	3	property	property	NN
8691	1081	4	?	?	.
8691	1082	1	American	american	JJ
8691	1082	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1082	3	have	have	VBP
8691	1082	4	said	say	VBN
8691	1082	5	that	that	IN
8691	1082	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1082	7	includes	include	VBZ
8691	1082	8	the	the	DT
8691	1082	9	right	right	NN
8691	1082	10	of	of	IN
8691	1082	11	every	every	DT
8691	1082	12	one	one	NN
8691	1082	13	to	to	TO
8691	1082	14	work	work	VB
8691	1082	15	for	for	IN
8691	1082	16	others	other	NNS
8691	1082	17	at	at	IN
8691	1082	18	such	such	JJ
8691	1082	19	wages	wage	NNS
8691	1082	20	as	as	IN
8691	1082	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1082	22	may	may	MD
8691	1082	23	choose	choose	VB
8691	1082	24	to	to	TO
8691	1082	25	accept	accept	VB
8691	1082	26	.	.	.
8691	1083	1	One	one	CD
8691	1083	2	of	of	IN
8691	1083	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1083	4	,	,	,
8691	1083	5	in	in	IN
8691	1083	6	supporting	support	VBG
8691	1083	7	a	a	DT
8691	1083	8	decree	decree	NN
8691	1083	9	for	for	IN
8691	1083	10	an	an	DT
8691	1083	11	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	1083	12	against	against	IN
8691	1083	13	combined	combine	VBN
8691	1083	14	action	action	NN
8691	1083	15	by	by	IN
8691	1083	16	a	a	DT
8691	1083	17	labor	labor	NN
8691	1083	18	union	union	NN
8691	1083	19	to	to	TO
8691	1083	20	deprive	deprive	VB
8691	1083	21	non	non	JJ
8691	1083	22	-	-	JJ
8691	1083	23	union	union	JJ
8691	1083	24	men	man	NNS
8691	1083	25	of	of	IN
8691	1083	26	a	a	DT
8691	1083	27	chance	chance	NN
8691	1083	28	to	to	TO
8691	1083	29	work	work	VB
8691	1083	30	,	,	,
8691	1083	31	by	by	IN
8691	1083	32	force	force	NN
8691	1083	33	or	or	CC
8691	1083	34	intimidation	intimidation	NN
8691	1083	35	,	,	,
8691	1083	36	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
8691	1083	37	a	a	DT
8691	1083	38	statute	statute	NN
8691	1083	39	abrogating	abrogate	VBG
8691	1083	40	the	the	DT
8691	1083	41	common	common	JJ
8691	1083	42	law	law	NN
8691	1083	43	rule	rule	NN
8691	1083	44	making	make	VBG
8691	1083	45	such	such	JJ
8691	1083	46	acts	act	NNS
8691	1083	47	a	a	DT
8691	1083	48	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1083	49	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
8691	1083	50	,	,	,
8691	1083	51	has	have	VBZ
8691	1083	52	put	put	VBN
8691	1083	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1083	54	thus	thus	RB
8691	1083	55	:	:	:
8691	1083	56	The	the	DT
8691	1083	57	right	right	NN
8691	1083	58	to	to	IN
8691	1083	59	the	the	DT
8691	1083	60	free	free	JJ
8691	1083	61	use	use	NN
8691	1083	62	of	of	IN
8691	1083	63	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1083	64	hands	hand	NNS
8691	1083	65	is	be	VBZ
8691	1083	66	the	the	DT
8691	1083	67	workman	workman	NN
8691	1083	68	's	's	POS
8691	1083	69	property	property	NN
8691	1083	70	,	,	,
8691	1083	71	as	as	RB
8691	1083	72	much	much	RB
8691	1083	73	as	as	IN
8691	1083	74	the	the	DT
8691	1083	75	rich	rich	JJ
8691	1083	76	man	man	NN
8691	1083	77	's	's	POS
8691	1083	78	right	right	NN
8691	1083	79	to	to	IN
8691	1083	80	the	the	DT
8691	1083	81	undisturbed	undisturbed	JJ
8691	1083	82	income	income	NN
8691	1083	83	from	from	IN
8691	1083	84	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1083	85	factory	factory	NN
8691	1083	86	,	,	,
8691	1083	87	houses	house	NNS
8691	1083	88	,	,	,
8691	1083	89	and	and	CC
8691	1083	90	lands	land	NNS
8691	1083	91	.	.	.
8691	1084	1	By	by	IN
8691	1084	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1084	3	work	work	NN
8691	1084	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1084	5	earns	earn	VBZ
8691	1084	6	present	present	JJ
8691	1084	7	subsistence	subsistence	NN
8691	1084	8	for	for	IN
8691	1084	9	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1084	10	and	and	CC
8691	1084	11	family	family	NN
8691	1084	12	.	.	.
8691	1085	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1085	2	savings	saving	NNS
8691	1085	3	may	may	MD
8691	1085	4	result	result	VB
8691	1085	5	in	in	IN
8691	1085	6	accumulations	accumulation	NNS
8691	1085	7	which	which	WDT
8691	1085	8	will	will	MD
8691	1085	9	make	make	VB
8691	1085	10	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1085	11	as	as	RB
8691	1085	12	rich	rich	JJ
8691	1085	13	in	in	IN
8691	1085	14	houses	house	NNS
8691	1085	15	and	and	CC
8691	1085	16	lands	land	NNS
8691	1085	17	as	as	IN
8691	1085	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1085	19	employer	employer	NN
8691	1085	20	.	.	.
8691	1086	1	This	this	DT
8691	1086	2	right	right	NN
8691	1086	3	of	of	IN
8691	1086	4	acquiring	acquire	VBG
8691	1086	5	property	property	NN
8691	1086	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1086	7	an	an	DT
8691	1086	8	inherent	inherent	JJ
8691	1086	9	,	,	,
8691	1086	10	indefeasible	indefeasible	JJ
8691	1086	11	right	right	NN
8691	1086	12	of	of	IN
8691	1086	13	the	the	DT
8691	1086	14	workman	workman	NN
8691	1086	15	.	.	.
8691	1087	1	To	to	TO
8691	1087	2	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	1087	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1087	4	,	,	,
8691	1087	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1087	6	must	must	MD
8691	1087	7	have	have	VB
8691	1087	8	the	the	DT
8691	1087	9	unrestricted	unrestricted	JJ
8691	1087	10	privilege	privilege	NN
8691	1087	11	of	of	IN
8691	1087	12	working	work	VBG
8691	1087	13	for	for	IN
8691	1087	14	such	such	JJ
8691	1087	15	employer	employer	NN
8691	1087	16	as	as	IN
8691	1087	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1087	18	chooses	choose	VBZ
8691	1087	19	,	,	,
8691	1087	20	at	at	IN
8691	1087	21	such	such	JJ
8691	1087	22	wages	wage	NNS
8691	1087	23	as	as	IN
8691	1087	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1087	25	chooses	choose	VBZ
8691	1087	26	to	to	TO
8691	1087	27	accept	accept	VB
8691	1087	28	.	.	.
8691	1088	1	This	this	DT
8691	1088	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1088	3	one	one	CD
8691	1088	4	of	of	IN
8691	1088	5	the	the	DT
8691	1088	6	rights	right	NNS
8691	1088	7	guaranteed	guarantee	VBN
8691	1088	8	to	to	IN
8691	1088	9	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1088	10	by	by	IN
8691	1088	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1088	12	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
8691	1088	13	of	of	IN
8691	1088	14	Rights	Rights	NNPS
8691	1088	15	.	.	.
8691	1089	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1089	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1089	3	a	a	DT
8691	1089	4	right	right	NN
8691	1089	5	of	of	IN
8691	1089	6	which	which	WDT
8691	1089	7	the	the	DT
8691	1089	8	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1089	9	can	can	MD
8691	1089	10	not	not	RB
8691	1089	11	deprive	deprive	VB
8691	1089	12	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1089	13	,	,	,
8691	1089	14	one	one	CD
8691	1089	15	which	which	WDT
8691	1089	16	the	the	DT
8691	1089	17	law	law	NN
8691	1089	18	of	of	IN
8691	1089	19	no	no	DT
8691	1089	20	trades	trade	NNS
8691	1089	21	union	union	NN
8691	1089	22	can	can	MD
8691	1089	23	take	take	VB
8691	1089	24	from	from	IN
8691	1089	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1089	26	,	,	,
8691	1089	27	and	and	CC
8691	1089	28	one	one	CD
8691	1089	29	which	which	WDT
8691	1089	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1089	31	is	be	VBZ
8691	1089	32	the	the	DT
8691	1089	33	bounden	bounden	JJ
8691	1089	34	duty	duty	NN
8691	1089	35	of	of	IN
8691	1089	36	the	the	DT
8691	1089	37	courts	court	NNS
8691	1089	38	to	to	TO
8691	1089	39	protect	protect	VB
8691	1089	40	.	.	.
8691	1090	1	The	the	DT
8691	1090	2	one	one	CD
8691	1090	3	most	most	RBS
8691	1090	4	concerned	concerned	JJ
8691	1090	5	in	in	IN
8691	1090	6	jealously	jealously	RB
8691	1090	7	maintaining	maintain	VBG
8691	1090	8	this	this	DT
8691	1090	9	freedom	freedom	NN
8691	1090	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	1090	11	the	the	DT
8691	1090	12	workman	workman	NN
8691	1090	13	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1090	14	.	.	.
8691	1091	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1091	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	1091	3	:	:	:
8691	1091	4	Erdman	Erdman	NNP
8691	1091	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1091	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1091	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1091	8	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
8691	1091	9	,	,	,
8691	1091	10	207	207	CD
8691	1091	11	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	1091	12	State	State	NNP
8691	1091	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1091	14	,	,	,
8691	1091	15	79	79	CD
8691	1091	16	;	;	:
8691	1091	17	56	56	CD
8691	1091	18	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	1091	19	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	1091	20	,	,	,
8691	1091	21	331	331	CD
8691	1091	22	.	.	.
8691	1091	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1092	1	But	but	CC
8691	1092	2	,	,	,
8691	1092	3	as	as	IN
8691	1092	4	already	already	RB
8691	1092	5	suggested	suggest	VBN
8691	1092	6	in	in	IN
8691	1092	7	the	the	DT
8691	1092	8	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	1092	9	chapter	chapter	NN
8691	1092	10	,	,	,
8691	1092	11	the	the	DT
8691	1092	12	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1092	13	whose	whose	WP$
8691	1092	14	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	1092	15	have	have	VBP
8691	1092	16	vitalized	vitalize	VBN
8691	1092	17	and	and	CC
8691	1092	18	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
8691	1092	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1092	20	written	write	VBN
8691	1092	21	law	law	NN
8691	1092	22	by	by	IN
8691	1092	23	reading	read	VBG
8691	1092	24	into	into	IN
8691	1092	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1092	26	some	some	DT
8691	1092	27	new	new	JJ
8691	1092	28	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	1092	29	or	or	CC
8691	1092	30	application	application	NN
8691	1092	31	have	have	VBP
8691	1092	32	but	but	CC
8691	1092	33	echoed	echo	VBN
8691	1092	34	the	the	DT
8691	1092	35	voice	voice	NN
8691	1092	36	of	of	IN
8691	1092	37	the	the	DT
8691	1092	38	bar	bar	NN
8691	1092	39	.	.	.
8691	1093	1	The	the	DT
8691	1093	2	greatest	great	JJS
8691	1093	3	achievements	achievement	NNS
8691	1093	4	of	of	IN
8691	1093	5	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1093	6	in	in	IN
8691	1093	7	this	this	DT
8691	1093	8	direction	direction	NN
8691	1093	9	were	be	VBD
8691	1093	10	really	really	RB
8691	1093	11	but	but	CC
8691	1093	12	a	a	DT
8691	1093	13	statement	statement	NN
8691	1093	14	of	of	IN
8691	1093	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1093	16	approbation	approbation	NN
8691	1093	17	of	of	IN
8691	1093	18	positions	position	NNS
8691	1093	19	laid	lay	VBN
8691	1093	20	down	down	RP
8691	1093	21	before	before	IN
8691	1093	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1093	23	by	by	IN
8691	1093	24	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
8691	1093	25	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	1093	26	.	.	.
8691	1094	1	In	in	IN
8691	1094	2	the	the	DT
8691	1094	3	early	early	JJ
8691	1094	4	stages	stage	NNS
8691	1094	5	of	of	IN
8691	1094	6	the	the	DT
8691	1094	7	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
8691	1094	8	College	College	NNP
8691	1094	9	case	case	NN
8691	1094	10	,	,	,
8691	1094	11	when	when	WRB
8691	1094	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1094	13	was	be	VBD
8691	1094	14	before	before	IN
8691	1094	15	the	the	DT
8691	1094	16	State	State	NNP
8691	1094	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	1094	18	in	in	IN
8691	1094	19	New	New	NNP
8691	1094	20	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	1094	21	,	,	,
8691	1094	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1094	23	was	be	VBD
8691	1094	24	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	1094	25	and	and	CC
8691	1094	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1094	27	associates	associate	NNS
8691	1094	28	,	,	,
8691	1094	29	Jeremiah	Jeremiah	NNP
8691	1094	30	Mason	Mason	NNP
8691	1094	31	and	and	CC
8691	1094	32	Jeremiah	Jeremiah	NNP
8691	1094	33	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	1094	34	,	,	,
8691	1094	35	both	both	DT
8691	1094	36	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	1094	37	of	of	IN
8691	1094	38	the	the	DT
8691	1094	39	highest	high	JJS
8691	1094	40	rank	rank	NN
8691	1094	41	,	,	,
8691	1094	42	who	who	WP
8691	1094	43	first	first	RB
8691	1094	44	put	put	VBD
8691	1094	45	forward	forward	RP
8691	1094	46	the	the	DT
8691	1094	47	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1094	48	that	that	IN
8691	1094	49	the	the	DT
8691	1094	50	charter	charter	NN
8691	1094	51	of	of	IN
8691	1094	52	a	a	DT
8691	1094	53	private	private	JJ
8691	1094	54	corporation	corporation	NN
8691	1094	55	was	be	VBD
8691	1094	56	a	a	DT
8691	1094	57	contract	contract	NN
8691	1094	58	;	;	:
8691	1094	59	and	and	CC
8691	1094	60	when	when	WRB
8691	1094	61	the	the	DT
8691	1094	62	cause	cause	NN
8691	1094	63	came	come	VBD
8691	1094	64	before	before	IN
8691	1094	65	the	the	DT
8691	1094	66	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1094	67	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1094	68	of	of	IN
8691	1094	69	the	the	DT
8691	1094	70	United	United	NNP
8691	1094	71	States	States	NNP
8691	1094	72	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1094	73	fell	fall	VBD
8691	1094	74	to	to	IN
8691	1094	75	the	the	DT
8691	1094	76	lot	lot	NN
8691	1094	77	of	of	IN
8691	1094	78	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	1094	79	to	to	TO
8691	1094	80	bring	bring	VB
8691	1094	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1094	82	to	to	IN
8691	1094	83	the	the	DT
8691	1094	84	attention	attention	NN
8691	1094	85	of	of	IN
8691	1094	86	the	the	DT
8691	1094	87	great	great	JJ
8691	1094	88	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1094	89	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1094	90	.	.	.
8691	1095	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1095	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1095	3	:	:	:
8691	1095	4	"	"	``
8691	1095	5	Works	work	NNS
8691	1095	6	of	of	IN
8691	1095	7	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
8691	1095	8	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	1095	9	,	,	,
8691	1095	10	"	"	``
8691	1095	11	V	V	NNP
8691	1095	12	,	,	,
8691	1095	13	497	497	CD
8691	1095	14	.	.	.
8691	1095	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1096	1	So	so	RB
8691	1096	2	in	in	IN
8691	1096	3	the	the	DT
8691	1096	4	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	1096	5	case	case	NN
8691	1096	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1096	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1096	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1096	9	,	,	,
8691	1096	10	in	in	IN
8691	1096	11	supporting	support	VBG
8691	1096	12	the	the	DT
8691	1096	13	cause	cause	NN
8691	1096	14	of	of	IN
8691	1096	15	the	the	DT
8691	1096	16	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	1096	17	party	party	NN
8691	1096	18	,	,	,
8691	1096	19	who	who	WP
8691	1096	20	suggested	suggest	VBD
8691	1096	21	that	that	IN
8691	1096	22	the	the	DT
8691	1096	23	Territory	Territory	NNP
8691	1096	24	of	of	IN
8691	1096	25	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	1096	26	,	,	,
8691	1096	27	though	though	IN
8691	1096	28	owned	own	VBN
8691	1096	29	by	by	IN
8691	1096	30	the	the	DT
8691	1096	31	United	United	NNP
8691	1096	32	States	States	NNP
8691	1096	33	,	,	,
8691	1096	34	was	be	VBD
8691	1096	35	no	no	DT
8691	1096	36	part	part	NN
8691	1096	37	of	of	IN
8691	1096	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1096	39	.	.	.
8691	1097	1	"	"	``
8691	1097	2	By	by	IN
8691	1097	3	the	the	DT
8691	1097	4	law	law	NN
8691	1097	5	of	of	IN
8691	1097	6	England	England	NNP
8691	1097	7	,	,	,
8691	1097	8	"	"	''
8691	1097	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1097	10	went	go	VBD
8691	1097	11	on	on	RP
8691	1097	12	to	to	TO
8691	1097	13	say	say	VB
8691	1097	14	,	,	,
8691	1097	15	"	"	''
8691	1097	16	when	when	WRB
8691	1097	17	possession	possession	NN
8691	1097	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	1097	19	taken	take	VBN
8691	1097	20	of	of	IN
8691	1097	21	territories	territory	NNS
8691	1097	22	,	,	,
8691	1097	23	the	the	DT
8691	1097	24	king	king	NN
8691	1097	25	,	,	,
8691	1097	26	_	_	NNP
8691	1097	27	Jure	Jure	NNP
8691	1097	28	Corona	Corona	NNP
8691	1097	29	_	_	NNP
8691	1097	30	,	,	,
8691	1097	31	has	have	VBZ
8691	1097	32	the	the	DT
8691	1097	33	power	power	NN
8691	1097	34	of	of	IN
8691	1097	35	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	1097	36	until	until	IN
8691	1097	37	parliament	parliament	NN
8691	1097	38	shall	shall	MD
8691	1097	39	interfere	interfere	VB
8691	1097	40	.	.	.
8691	1098	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1098	2	have	have	VBP
8691	1098	3	the	the	DT
8691	1098	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1098	5	Jus	Jus	NNP
8691	1098	6	Corona	Corona	NNP
8691	1098	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1098	8	in	in	IN
8691	1098	9	this	this	DT
8691	1098	10	case	case	NN
8691	1098	11	,	,	,
8691	1098	12	and	and	CC
8691	1098	13	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	1098	14	was	be	VBD
8691	1098	15	to	to	TO
8691	1098	16	be	be	VB
8691	1098	17	governed	govern	VBN
8691	1098	18	by	by	IN
8691	1098	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1098	20	as	as	IN
8691	1098	21	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1098	22	thought	think	VBD
8691	1098	23	proper	proper	JJ
8691	1098	24	.	.	.
8691	1099	1	"	"	``
8691	1099	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1099	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1099	4	:	:	:
8691	1099	5	American	American	NNP
8691	1099	6	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	1099	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1099	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1099	9	v.	v.	IN
8691	1099	10	_	_	NNP
8691	1099	11	Canter	Canter	NNP
8691	1099	12	,	,	,
8691	1099	13	1	1	CD
8691	1099	14	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1099	15	'	'	POS
8691	1099	16	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1099	17	,	,	,
8691	1099	18	611	611	CD
8691	1099	19	,	,	,
8691	1099	20	538	538	CD
8691	1099	21	.	.	.
8691	1099	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1100	1	This	this	DT
8691	1100	2	argument	argument	NN
8691	1100	3	did	do	VBD
8691	1100	4	not	not	RB
8691	1100	5	spend	spend	VB
8691	1100	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1100	7	force	force	NN
8691	1100	8	in	in	IN
8691	1100	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1100	10	effect	effect	NN
8691	1100	11	on	on	IN
8691	1100	12	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1100	13	.	.	.
8691	1101	1	When	when	WRB
8691	1101	2	,	,	,
8691	1101	3	after	after	IN
8691	1101	4	the	the	DT
8691	1101	5	lapse	lapse	NN
8691	1101	6	of	of	IN
8691	1101	7	two	two	CD
8691	1101	8	generations	generation	NNS
8691	1101	9	,	,	,
8691	1101	10	greater	great	JJR
8691	1101	11	problems	problem	NNS
8691	1101	12	of	of	IN
8691	1101	13	the	the	DT
8691	1101	14	relations	relation	NNS
8691	1101	15	of	of	IN
8691	1101	16	the	the	DT
8691	1101	17	United	United	NNP
8691	1101	18	States	States	NNP
8691	1101	19	to	to	TO
8691	1101	20	territory	territory	NN
8691	1101	21	newly	newly	RB
8691	1101	22	acquired	acquire	VBN
8691	1101	23	from	from	IN
8691	1101	24	Spain	Spain	NNP
8691	1101	25	arose	arise	VBD
8691	1101	26	,	,	,
8691	1101	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1101	28	was	be	VBD
8691	1101	29	,	,	,
8691	1101	30	as	as	IN
8691	1101	31	has	have	VBZ
8691	1101	32	been	be	VBN
8691	1101	33	said	say	VBN
8691	1101	34	above	above	RB
8691	1101	35	,	,	,
8691	1101	36	made	make	VBD
8691	1101	37	one	one	CD
8691	1101	38	of	of	IN
8691	1101	39	the	the	DT
8691	1101	40	cornerstones	cornerstone	NNS
8691	1101	41	of	of	IN
8691	1101	42	the	the	DT
8691	1101	43	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1101	44	of	of	IN
8691	1101	45	the	the	DT
8691	1101	46	same	same	JJ
8691	1101	47	court	court	NN
8691	1101	48	which	which	WDT
8691	1101	49	determined	determine	VBD
8691	1101	50	what	what	WP
8691	1101	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1101	52	were	be	VBD
8691	1101	53	.	.	.
8691	1102	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1102	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1102	3	:	:	:
8691	1102	4	Downes	Downes	NNPS
8691	1102	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1102	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1102	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1102	8	Bidwell	Bidwell	NNP
8691	1102	9	,	,	,
8691	1102	10	182	182	CD
8691	1102	11	United	United	NNP
8691	1102	12	States	States	NNP
8691	1102	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1102	14	,	,	,
8691	1102	15	244	244	CD
8691	1102	16	,	,	,
8691	1102	17	265	265	CD
8691	1102	18	.	.	.
8691	1102	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1103	1	So	so	RB
8691	1103	2	in	in	IN
8691	1103	3	the	the	DT
8691	1103	4	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
8691	1103	5	case	case	NN
8691	1103	6	,	,	,
8691	1103	7	which	which	WDT
8691	1103	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	1103	9	been	be	VBN
8691	1103	10	described	describe	VBN
8691	1103	11	at	at	IN
8691	1103	12	length	length	NN
8691	1103	13	,	,	,
8691	1103	14	no	no	DT
8691	1103	15	description	description	NN
8691	1103	16	of	of	IN
8691	1103	17	due	due	JJ
8691	1103	18	process	process	NN
8691	1103	19	of	of	IN
8691	1103	20	law	law	NN
8691	1103	21	was	be	VBD
8691	1103	22	found	find	VBN
8691	1103	23	better	well	JJR
8691	1103	24	and	and	CC
8691	1103	25	none	none	NN
8691	1103	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	1103	27	better	well	JJR
8691	1103	28	than	than	IN
8691	1103	29	that	that	DT
8691	1103	30	given	give	VBN
8691	1103	31	by	by	IN
8691	1103	32	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	1103	33	so	so	RB
8691	1103	34	many	many	JJ
8691	1103	35	years	year	NNS
8691	1103	36	before	before	RB
8691	1103	37	in	in	IN
8691	1103	38	the	the	DT
8691	1103	39	Dartmouth	Dartmouth	NNP
8691	1103	40	College	College	NNP
8691	1103	41	case	case	NN
8691	1103	42	.	.	.
8691	1104	1	The	the	DT
8691	1104	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1104	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1104	4	of	of	IN
8691	1104	5	New	New	NNP
8691	1104	6	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	1104	7	,	,	,
8691	1104	8	from	from	IN
8691	1104	9	whose	whose	WP$
8691	1104	10	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1104	11	that	that	WDT
8691	1104	12	cause	cause	NN
8691	1104	13	came	come	VBD
8691	1104	14	up	up	RP
8691	1104	15	by	by	IN
8691	1104	16	writ	writ	NN
8691	1104	17	of	of	IN
8691	1104	18	error	error	NN
8691	1104	19	,	,	,
8691	1104	20	had	have	VBD
8691	1104	21	held	hold	VBN
8691	1104	22	--	--	:
8691	1104	23	and	and	CC
8691	1104	24	on	on	IN
8691	1104	25	that	that	DT
8691	1104	26	point	point	NN
8691	1104	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1104	28	decision	decision	NN
8691	1104	29	was	be	VBD
8691	1104	30	final	final	JJ
8691	1104	31	--	--	:
8691	1104	32	that	that	IN
8691	1104	33	the	the	DT
8691	1104	34	change	change	NN
8691	1104	35	in	in	IN
8691	1104	36	the	the	DT
8691	1104	37	college	college	NN
8691	1104	38	charter	charter	NN
8691	1104	39	was	be	VBD
8691	1104	40	no	no	DT
8691	1104	41	violation	violation	NN
8691	1104	42	of	of	IN
8691	1104	43	the	the	DT
8691	1104	44	bill	bill	NN
8691	1104	45	of	of	IN
8691	1104	46	rights	right	NNS
8691	1104	47	embodied	embody	VBN
8691	1104	48	in	in	IN
8691	1104	49	the	the	DT
8691	1104	50	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1104	51	of	of	IN
8691	1104	52	that	that	DT
8691	1104	53	state	state	NN
8691	1104	54	.	.	.
8691	1105	1	This	this	DT
8691	1105	2	,	,	,
8691	1105	3	following	follow	VBG
8691	1105	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1105	5	Magna	Magna	NNPS
8691	1105	6	Charta	Charta	NNP
8691	1105	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1105	8	,	,	,
8691	1105	9	provided	provide	VBN
8691	1105	10	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1105	11	Part	Part	NNP
8691	1105	12	I	I	NNP
8691	1105	13	,	,	,
8691	1105	14	Art	art	NN
8691	1105	15	.	.	.
8691	1106	1	15	15	LS
8691	1106	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1106	3	that	that	IN
8691	1106	4	no	no	DT
8691	1106	5	subject	subject	NN
8691	1106	6	should	should	MD
8691	1106	7	be	be	VB
8691	1106	8	"	"	``
8691	1106	9	despoiled	despoil	VBN
8691	1106	10	or	or	CC
8691	1106	11	deprived	deprive	VBN
8691	1106	12	of	of	IN
8691	1106	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1106	14	property	property	NN
8691	1106	15	,	,	,
8691	1106	16	immunities	immunity	NNS
8691	1106	17	,	,	,
8691	1106	18	or	or	CC
8691	1106	19	privileges	privilege	NNS
8691	1106	20	,	,	,
8691	1106	21	put	put	VBD
8691	1106	22	out	out	IN
8691	1106	23	of	of	IN
8691	1106	24	the	the	DT
8691	1106	25	protection	protection	NN
8691	1106	26	of	of	IN
8691	1106	27	the	the	DT
8691	1106	28	law	law	NN
8691	1106	29	,	,	,
8691	1106	30	exiled	exile	VBN
8691	1106	31	,	,	,
8691	1106	32	or	or	CC
8691	1106	33	deprived	deprive	VBN
8691	1106	34	of	of	IN
8691	1106	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1106	36	life	life	NN
8691	1106	37	,	,	,
8691	1106	38	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	1106	39	or	or	CC
8691	1106	40	estate	estate	NN
8691	1106	41	,	,	,
8691	1106	42	but	but	CC
8691	1106	43	by	by	IN
8691	1106	44	the	the	DT
8691	1106	45	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1106	46	of	of	IN
8691	1106	47	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1106	48	peers	peer	NNS
8691	1106	49	or	or	CC
8691	1106	50	the	the	DT
8691	1106	51	law	law	NN
8691	1106	52	of	of	IN
8691	1106	53	the	the	DT
8691	1106	54	land	land	NN
8691	1106	55	.	.	.
8691	1106	56	"	"	''
8691	1107	1	_	_	NNP
8691	1107	2	Magna	Magna	NNP
8691	1107	3	Charta	Charta	NNP
8691	1107	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1107	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1107	6	wrung	wrung	JJ
8691	1107	7	from	from	IN
8691	1107	8	a	a	DT
8691	1107	9	tyrant	tyrant	NN
8691	1107	10	king	king	NN
8691	1107	11	.	.	.
8691	1108	1	So	so	RB
8691	1108	2	,	,	,
8691	1108	3	said	say	VBD
8691	1108	4	the	the	DT
8691	1108	5	State	State	NNP
8691	1108	6	court	court	NN
8691	1108	7	,	,	,
8691	1108	8	this	this	DT
8691	1108	9	article	article	NN
8691	1108	10	was	be	VBD
8691	1108	11	inserted	insert	VBN
8691	1108	12	to	to	TO
8691	1108	13	protect	protect	VB
8691	1108	14	the	the	DT
8691	1108	15	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1108	16	against	against	IN
8691	1108	17	the	the	DT
8691	1108	18	abuse	abuse	NN
8691	1108	19	of	of	IN
8691	1108	20	the	the	DT
8691	1108	21	executive	executive	JJ
8691	1108	22	power	power	NN
8691	1108	23	.	.	.
8691	1109	1	When	when	WRB
8691	1109	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1109	3	speaks	speak	VBZ
8691	1109	4	of	of	IN
8691	1109	5	the	the	DT
8691	1109	6	law	law	NN
8691	1109	7	of	of	IN
8691	1109	8	the	the	DT
8691	1109	9	land	land	NN
8691	1109	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1109	11	means	mean	VBZ
8691	1109	12	the	the	DT
8691	1109	13	law	law	NN
8691	1109	14	of	of	IN
8691	1109	15	New	New	NNP
8691	1109	16	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	1109	17	,	,	,
8691	1109	18	and	and	CC
8691	1109	19	that	that	DT
8691	1109	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	1109	21	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	1109	22	the	the	DT
8691	1109	23	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1109	24	of	of	IN
8691	1109	25	New	New	NNP
8691	1109	26	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	1109	27	chooses	choose	VBZ
8691	1109	28	to	to	TO
8691	1109	29	enact	enact	VB
8691	1109	30	,	,	,
8691	1109	31	so	so	RB
8691	1109	32	long	long	RB
8691	1109	33	as	as	IN
8691	1109	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1109	35	contravenes	contravene	VBZ
8691	1109	36	no	no	DT
8691	1109	37	other	other	JJ
8691	1109	38	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1109	39	provision	provision	NN
8691	1109	40	.	.	.
8691	1110	1	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	1110	2	,	,	,
8691	1110	3	in	in	IN
8691	1110	4	paving	pave	VBG
8691	1110	5	the	the	DT
8691	1110	6	way	way	NN
8691	1110	7	toward	toward	IN
8691	1110	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1110	9	claim	claim	NN
8691	1110	10	that	that	IN
8691	1110	11	the	the	DT
8691	1110	12	charter	charter	NN
8691	1110	13	was	be	VBD
8691	1110	14	a	a	DT
8691	1110	15	contract	contract	NN
8691	1110	16	,	,	,
8691	1110	17	and	and	CC
8691	1110	18	,	,	,
8691	1110	19	as	as	IN
8691	1110	20	a	a	DT
8691	1110	21	vested	vested	JJ
8691	1110	22	right	right	NN
8691	1110	23	of	of	IN
8691	1110	24	property	property	NN
8691	1110	25	,	,	,
8691	1110	26	inviolable	inviolable	JJ
8691	1110	27	by	by	IN
8691	1110	28	a	a	DT
8691	1110	29	State	State	NNP
8691	1110	30	,	,	,
8691	1110	31	alluded	allude	VBD
8691	1110	32	to	to	IN
8691	1110	33	the	the	DT
8691	1110	34	sacredness	sacredness	NN
8691	1110	35	of	of	IN
8691	1110	36	all	all	DT
8691	1110	37	rights	right	NNS
8691	1110	38	under	under	IN
8691	1110	39	the	the	DT
8691	1110	40	guaranties	guaranty	NNS
8691	1110	41	to	to	TO
8691	1110	42	be	be	VB
8691	1110	43	found	find	VBN
8691	1110	44	in	in	IN
8691	1110	45	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1110	46	American	american	JJ
8691	1110	47	system	system	NN
8691	1110	48	of	of	IN
8691	1110	49	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1110	50	government	government	NN
8691	1110	51	.	.	.
8691	1111	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1111	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1111	3	not	not	RB
8691	1111	4	surprising	surprising	JJ
8691	1111	5	that	that	IN
8691	1111	6	the	the	DT
8691	1111	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1111	8	of	of	IN
8691	1111	9	the	the	DT
8691	1111	10	United	United	NNP
8691	1111	11	States	States	NNP
8691	1111	12	should	should	MD
8691	1111	13	protect	protect	VB
8691	1111	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1111	15	in	in	IN
8691	1111	16	the	the	DT
8691	1111	17	way	way	NN
8691	1111	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1111	19	asserted	assert	VBD
8691	1111	20	.	.	.
8691	1112	1	All	all	PDT
8691	1112	2	the	the	DT
8691	1112	3	States	States	NNPS
8691	1112	4	,	,	,
8691	1112	5	and	and	CC
8691	1112	6	New	New	NNP
8691	1112	7	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	1112	8	among	among	IN
8691	1112	9	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1112	10	,	,	,
8691	1112	11	had	have	VBD
8691	1112	12	done	do	VBN
8691	1112	13	the	the	DT
8691	1112	14	same	same	JJ
8691	1112	15	in	in	IN
8691	1112	16	placing	place	VBG
8691	1112	17	the	the	DT
8691	1112	18	great	great	JJ
8691	1112	19	features	feature	NNS
8691	1112	20	of	of	IN
8691	1112	21	_	_	NNP
8691	1112	22	Magna	Magna	NNPS
8691	1112	23	Charta	Charta	NNP
8691	1112	24	_	_	NNP
8691	1112	25	in	in	IN
8691	1112	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1112	27	bills	bill	NNS
8691	1112	28	of	of	IN
8691	1112	29	rights	right	NNS
8691	1112	30	.	.	.
8691	1113	1	What	what	WP
8691	1113	2	,	,	,
8691	1113	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1113	4	asked	ask	VBD
8691	1113	5	,	,	,
8691	1113	6	was	be	VBD
8691	1113	7	this	this	DT
8691	1113	8	law	law	NN
8691	1113	9	of	of	IN
8691	1113	10	the	the	DT
8691	1113	11	land	land	NN
8691	1113	12	by	by	IN
8691	1113	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1113	14	all	all	DT
8691	1113	15	things	thing	NNS
8691	1113	16	were	be	VBD
8691	1113	17	to	to	TO
8691	1113	18	be	be	VB
8691	1113	19	tried	try	VBN
8691	1113	20	and	and	CC
8691	1113	21	judged	judge	VBN
8691	1113	22	?	?	.
8691	1114	1	This	this	DT
8691	1114	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1114	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1114	4	answer	answer	NN
8691	1114	5	:	:	:
8691	1114	6	"	"	``
8691	1114	7	By	by	IN
8691	1114	8	the	the	DT
8691	1114	9	law	law	NN
8691	1114	10	of	of	IN
8691	1114	11	the	the	DT
8691	1114	12	land	land	NN
8691	1114	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	1114	14	most	most	RBS
8691	1114	15	clearly	clearly	RB
8691	1114	16	intended	intend	VBN
8691	1114	17	the	the	DT
8691	1114	18	general	general	JJ
8691	1114	19	law	law	NN
8691	1114	20	;	;	:
8691	1114	21	a	a	DT
8691	1114	22	law	law	NN
8691	1114	23	which	which	WDT
8691	1114	24	hears	hear	VBZ
8691	1114	25	before	before	IN
8691	1114	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1114	27	condemns	condemn	VBZ
8691	1114	28	;	;	:
8691	1114	29	which	which	WDT
8691	1114	30	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
8691	1114	31	upon	upon	IN
8691	1114	32	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	1114	33	,	,	,
8691	1114	34	and	and	CC
8691	1114	35	renders	render	VBZ
8691	1114	36	judgment	judgment	VBP
8691	1114	37	only	only	RB
8691	1114	38	after	after	IN
8691	1114	39	trial	trial	NN
8691	1114	40	.	.	.
8691	1115	1	The	the	DT
8691	1115	2	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	1115	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1115	4	that	that	IN
8691	1115	5	every	every	DT
8691	1115	6	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	1115	7	shall	shall	MD
8691	1115	8	hold	hold	VB
8691	1115	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1115	10	life	life	NN
8691	1115	11	,	,	,
8691	1115	12	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	1115	13	,	,	,
8691	1115	14	property	property	NN
8691	1115	15	and	and	CC
8691	1115	16	immunities	immunity	NNS
8691	1115	17	under	under	IN
8691	1115	18	the	the	DT
8691	1115	19	protection	protection	NN
8691	1115	20	of	of	IN
8691	1115	21	the	the	DT
8691	1115	22	general	general	JJ
8691	1115	23	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1115	24	which	which	WDT
8691	1115	25	govern	govern	VBP
8691	1115	26	society	society	NN
8691	1115	27	.	.	.
8691	1116	1	Everything	everything	NN
8691	1116	2	which	which	WDT
8691	1116	3	may	may	MD
8691	1116	4	pass	pass	VB
8691	1116	5	under	under	IN
8691	1116	6	the	the	DT
8691	1116	7	form	form	NN
8691	1116	8	of	of	IN
8691	1116	9	an	an	DT
8691	1116	10	enactment	enactment	NN
8691	1116	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	1116	12	not	not	RB
8691	1116	13	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1116	14	to	to	TO
8691	1116	15	be	be	VB
8691	1116	16	considered	consider	VBN
8691	1116	17	the	the	DT
8691	1116	18	law	law	NN
8691	1116	19	of	of	IN
8691	1116	20	the	the	DT
8691	1116	21	land	land	NN
8691	1116	22	.	.	.
8691	1117	1	If	if	IN
8691	1117	2	this	this	DT
8691	1117	3	were	be	VBD
8691	1117	4	so	so	RB
8691	1117	5	,	,	,
8691	1117	6	acts	act	NNS
8691	1117	7	of	of	IN
8691	1117	8	attainder	attainder	NN
8691	1117	9	,	,	,
8691	1117	10	bills	bill	NNS
8691	1117	11	of	of	IN
8691	1117	12	pains	pain	NNS
8691	1117	13	and	and	CC
8691	1117	14	penalties	penalty	NNS
8691	1117	15	,	,	,
8691	1117	16	acts	act	NNS
8691	1117	17	of	of	IN
8691	1117	18	confiscation	confiscation	NN
8691	1117	19	,	,	,
8691	1117	20	acts	act	VBZ
8691	1117	21	reversing	reverse	VBG
8691	1117	22	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1117	23	,	,	,
8691	1117	24	and	and	CC
8691	1117	25	acts	act	VBZ
8691	1117	26	directly	directly	RB
8691	1117	27	transferring	transfer	VBG
8691	1117	28	one	one	CD
8691	1117	29	man	man	NN
8691	1117	30	's	's	POS
8691	1117	31	estate	estate	NN
8691	1117	32	to	to	IN
8691	1117	33	another	another	DT
8691	1117	34	,	,	,
8691	1117	35	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1117	36	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1117	37	,	,	,
8691	1117	38	decrees	decree	NNS
8691	1117	39	and	and	CC
8691	1117	40	forfeitures	forfeiture	NNS
8691	1117	41	in	in	IN
8691	1117	42	all	all	DT
8691	1117	43	possible	possible	JJ
8691	1117	44	forms	form	NNS
8691	1117	45	,	,	,
8691	1117	46	would	would	MD
8691	1117	47	be	be	VB
8691	1117	48	the	the	DT
8691	1117	49	law	law	NN
8691	1117	50	of	of	IN
8691	1117	51	the	the	DT
8691	1117	52	land	land	NN
8691	1117	53	.	.	.
8691	1118	1	"	"	``
8691	1118	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1118	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1118	4	:	:	:
8691	1118	5	"	"	``
8691	1118	6	Works	work	NNS
8691	1118	7	of	of	IN
8691	1118	8	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
8691	1118	9	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	1118	10	,	,	,
8691	1118	11	"	"	``
8691	1118	12	V	V	NNP
8691	1118	13	,	,	,
8691	1118	14	486	486	CD
8691	1118	15	.	.	.
8691	1118	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1119	1	In	in	IN
8691	1119	2	the	the	DT
8691	1119	3	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1119	4	by	by	IN
8691	1119	5	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1119	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1119	7	Mathews	Mathews	NNP
8691	1119	8	in	in	IN
8691	1119	9	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
8691	1119	10	_	_	NNP
8691	1119	11	v.	v.	IN
8691	1119	12	_	_	NNP
8691	1119	13	California	California	NNP
8691	1119	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1119	15	observes	observe	VBZ
8691	1119	16	:	:	:
8691	1119	17	"	"	``
8691	1119	18	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1119	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	1119	20	not	not	RB
8691	1119	21	every	every	DT
8691	1119	22	act	act	NN
8691	1119	23	,	,	,
8691	1119	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1119	25	in	in	IN
8691	1119	26	form	form	NN
8691	1119	27	,	,	,
8691	1119	28	that	that	RB
8691	1119	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	1119	30	law	law	NN
8691	1119	31	.	.	.
8691	1120	1	Law	Law	NNP
8691	1120	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1120	3	something	something	NN
8691	1120	4	more	more	JJR
8691	1120	5	than	than	IN
8691	1120	6	mere	mere	JJ
8691	1120	7	will	will	MD
8691	1120	8	exerted	exert	VBN
8691	1120	9	as	as	IN
8691	1120	10	an	an	DT
8691	1120	11	act	act	NN
8691	1120	12	of	of	IN
8691	1120	13	power	power	NN
8691	1120	14	.	.	.
8691	1121	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1121	2	must	must	MD
8691	1121	3	be	be	VB
8691	1121	4	not	not	RB
8691	1121	5	a	a	DT
8691	1121	6	special	special	JJ
8691	1121	7	rule	rule	NN
8691	1121	8	for	for	IN
8691	1121	9	a	a	DT
8691	1121	10	particular	particular	JJ
8691	1121	11	person	person	NN
8691	1121	12	or	or	CC
8691	1121	13	a	a	DT
8691	1121	14	particular	particular	JJ
8691	1121	15	case	case	NN
8691	1121	16	,	,	,
8691	1121	17	but	but	CC
8691	1121	18	,	,	,
8691	1121	19	in	in	IN
8691	1121	20	the	the	DT
8691	1121	21	language	language	NN
8691	1121	22	of	of	IN
8691	1121	23	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1121	24	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	1121	25	,	,	,
8691	1121	26	in	in	IN
8691	1121	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1121	28	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	1121	29	definition	definition	NN
8691	1121	30	,	,	,
8691	1121	31	'	'	''
8691	1121	32	the	the	DT
8691	1121	33	general	general	JJ
8691	1121	34	law	law	NN
8691	1121	35	,	,	,
8691	1121	36	a	a	DT
8691	1121	37	law	law	NN
8691	1121	38	which	which	WDT
8691	1121	39	hears	hear	VBZ
8691	1121	40	before	before	IN
8691	1121	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1121	42	condemns	condemn	VBZ
8691	1121	43	,	,	,
8691	1121	44	which	which	WDT
8691	1121	45	proceeds	proceed	VBZ
8691	1121	46	upon	upon	IN
8691	1121	47	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	1121	48	,	,	,
8691	1121	49	and	and	CC
8691	1121	50	renders	render	VBZ
8691	1121	51	judgment	judgment	VBP
8691	1121	52	only	only	RB
8691	1121	53	after	after	IN
8691	1121	54	trial	trial	NN
8691	1121	55	,	,	,
8691	1121	56	'	'	''
8691	1121	57	so	so	RB
8691	1121	58	'	'	''
8691	1121	59	that	that	IN
8691	1121	60	every	every	DT
8691	1121	61	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	1121	62	shall	shall	MD
8691	1121	63	hold	hold	VB
8691	1121	64	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1121	65	life	life	NN
8691	1121	66	,	,	,
8691	1121	67	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	1121	68	,	,	,
8691	1121	69	property	property	NN
8691	1121	70	and	and	CC
8691	1121	71	immunities	immunity	NNS
8691	1121	72	under	under	IN
8691	1121	73	the	the	DT
8691	1121	74	protection	protection	NN
8691	1121	75	of	of	IN
8691	1121	76	the	the	DT
8691	1121	77	general	general	JJ
8691	1121	78	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1121	79	which	which	WDT
8691	1121	80	govern	govern	VBP
8691	1121	81	society	society	NN
8691	1121	82	.	.	.
8691	1121	83	'	'	''
8691	1121	84	"	"	''
8691	1122	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1122	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1122	3	:	:	:
8691	1122	4	Hurtado	Hurtado	NNP
8691	1122	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1122	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1122	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1122	8	California	California	NNP
8691	1122	9	,	,	,
8691	1122	10	110	110	CD
8691	1122	11	United	United	NNP
8691	1122	12	States	States	NNP
8691	1122	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1122	14	,	,	,
8691	1122	15	516	516	CD
8691	1122	16	,	,	,
8691	1122	17	535	535	CD
8691	1122	18	.	.	.
8691	1122	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1123	1	Other	other	JJ
8691	1123	2	instances	instance	NNS
8691	1123	3	might	may	MD
8691	1123	4	be	be	VB
8691	1123	5	mentioned	mention	VBN
8691	1123	6	,	,	,
8691	1123	7	equally	equally	RB
8691	1123	8	conspicuous	conspicuous	JJ
8691	1123	9	,	,	,
8691	1123	10	which	which	WDT
8691	1123	11	will	will	MD
8691	1123	12	entitle	entitle	VB
8691	1123	13	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	1123	14	to	to	IN
8691	1123	15	the	the	DT
8691	1123	16	name	name	NN
8691	1123	17	given	give	VBN
8691	1123	18	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1123	19	by	by	IN
8691	1123	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1123	21	contemporaries	contemporary	NNS
8691	1123	22	of	of	IN
8691	1123	23	"	"	``
8691	1123	24	the	the	DT
8691	1123	25	expounder	expounder	NN
8691	1123	26	of	of	IN
8691	1123	27	the	the	DT
8691	1123	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1123	29	.	.	.
8691	1124	1	"	"	``
8691	1124	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1124	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1124	4	:	:	:
8691	1124	5	See	see	VB
8691	1124	6	Article	Article	NNP
8691	1124	7	by	by	IN
8691	1124	8	Everett	Everett	NNP
8691	1124	9	P.	P.	NNP
8691	1124	10	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
8691	1124	11	on	on	IN
8691	1124	12	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
8691	1124	13	Law	Law	NNP
8691	1124	14	of	of	IN
8691	1124	15	the	the	DT
8691	1124	16	United	United	NNP
8691	1124	17	States	States	NNP
8691	1124	18	as	as	IN
8691	1124	19	Moulded	mould	VBN
8691	1124	20	by	by	IN
8691	1124	21	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
8691	1124	22	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	1124	23	,	,	,
8691	1124	24	in	in	IN
8691	1124	25	Yale	Yale	NNP
8691	1124	26	Law	Law	NNP
8691	1124	27	Journal	Journal	NNP
8691	1124	28	,	,	,
8691	1124	29	Vol	Vol	NNP
8691	1124	30	.	.	.
8691	1125	1	XIII	XIII	NNP
8691	1125	2	,	,	,
8691	1125	3	p.	p.	NN
8691	1125	4	366	366	CD
8691	1125	5	,	,	,
8691	1125	6	and	and	CC
8691	1125	7	in	in	IN
8691	1125	8	the	the	DT
8691	1125	9	27th	27th	JJ
8691	1125	10	Annual	Annual	NNP
8691	1125	11	Report	Report	NNP
8691	1125	12	of	of	IN
8691	1125	13	the	the	DT
8691	1125	14	New	New	NNP
8691	1125	15	York	York	NNP
8691	1125	16	State	State	NNP
8691	1125	17	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	1125	18	Association	Association	NNP
8691	1125	19	.	.	.
8691	1125	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1126	1	No	no	DT
8691	1126	2	one	one	CD
8691	1126	3	American	american	JJ
8691	1126	4	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	1126	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	1126	6	done	do	VBN
8691	1126	7	as	as	RB
8691	1126	8	much	much	JJ
8691	1126	9	in	in	IN
8691	1126	10	that	that	DT
8691	1126	11	direction	direction	NN
8691	1126	12	,	,	,
8691	1126	13	but	but	CC
8691	1126	14	there	there	EX
8691	1126	15	are	be	VBP
8691	1126	16	few	few	JJ
8691	1126	17	of	of	IN
8691	1126	18	the	the	DT
8691	1126	19	greater	great	JJR
8691	1126	20	ones	one	NNS
8691	1126	21	who	who	WP
8691	1126	22	have	have	VBP
8691	1126	23	not	not	RB
8691	1126	24	done	do	VBN
8691	1126	25	something	something	NN
8691	1126	26	.	.	.
8691	1127	1	As	as	IN
8691	1127	2	,	,	,
8691	1127	3	however	however	RB
8691	1127	4	,	,	,
8691	1127	5	the	the	DT
8691	1127	6	glory	glory	NN
8691	1127	7	of	of	IN
8691	1127	8	a	a	DT
8691	1127	9	battle	battle	NN
8691	1127	10	won	win	VBN
8691	1127	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	1127	12	for	for	IN
8691	1127	13	the	the	DT
8691	1127	14	commander	commander	NN
8691	1127	15	of	of	IN
8691	1127	16	the	the	DT
8691	1127	17	victorious	victorious	JJ
8691	1127	18	forces	force	NNS
8691	1127	19	,	,	,
8691	1127	20	so	so	CC
8691	1127	21	the	the	DT
8691	1127	22	glory	glory	NN
8691	1127	23	of	of	IN
8691	1127	24	adding	add	VBG
8691	1127	25	a	a	DT
8691	1127	26	new	new	JJ
8691	1127	27	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	1127	28	to	to	IN
8691	1127	29	a	a	DT
8691	1127	30	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	1127	31	at	at	IN
8691	1127	32	a	a	DT
8691	1127	33	vital	vital	JJ
8691	1127	34	point	point	NN
8691	1127	35	is	be	VBZ
8691	1127	36	,	,	,
8691	1127	37	with	with	IN
8691	1127	38	the	the	DT
8691	1127	39	public	public	NN
8691	1127	40	,	,	,
8691	1127	41	always	always	RB
8691	1127	42	for	for	IN
8691	1127	43	the	the	DT
8691	1127	44	judge	judge	NN
8691	1127	45	whose	whose	WP$
8691	1127	46	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1127	47	is	be	VBZ
8691	1127	48	the	the	DT
8691	1127	49	first	first	JJ
8691	1127	50	to	to	TO
8691	1127	51	announce	announce	VB
8691	1127	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1127	53	.	.	.
8691	1128	1	Who	who	WP
8691	1128	2	announced	announce	VBD
8691	1128	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1128	4	to	to	IN
8691	1128	5	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1128	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1128	7	never	never	RB
8691	1128	8	know	know	VBP
8691	1128	9	or	or	CC
8691	1128	10	soon	soon	RB
8691	1128	11	forget	forget	VB
8691	1128	12	.	.	.
8691	1129	1	The	the	DT
8691	1129	2	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
8691	1129	3	possession	possession	NN
8691	1129	4	by	by	IN
8691	1129	5	the	the	DT
8691	1129	6	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	1129	7	of	of	IN
8691	1129	8	the	the	DT
8691	1129	9	power	power	NN
8691	1129	10	to	to	TO
8691	1129	11	interpret	interpret	VB
8691	1129	12	written	write	VBN
8691	1129	13	law	law	NN
8691	1129	14	,	,	,
8691	1129	15	and	and	CC
8691	1129	16	thus	thus	RB
8691	1129	17	to	to	TO
8691	1129	18	delimit	delimit	VB
8691	1129	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1129	20	effect	effect	NN
8691	1129	21	,	,	,
8691	1129	22	has	have	VBZ
8691	1129	23	led	lead	VBN
8691	1129	24	to	to	IN
8691	1129	25	a	a	DT
8691	1129	26	serious	serious	JJ
8691	1129	27	abuse	abuse	NN
8691	1129	28	in	in	IN
8691	1129	29	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1129	30	methods	method	NNS
8691	1129	31	of	of	IN
8691	1129	32	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	1129	33	.	.	.
8691	1130	1	Statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1130	2	are	be	VBP
8691	1130	3	often	often	RB
8691	1130	4	favorably	favorably	RB
8691	1130	5	reported	report	VBN
8691	1130	6	and	and	CC
8691	1130	7	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	1130	8	,	,	,
8691	1130	9	both	both	DT
8691	1130	10	in	in	IN
8691	1130	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1130	12	and	and	CC
8691	1130	13	the	the	DT
8691	1130	14	State	State	NNP
8691	1130	15	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	1130	16	,	,	,
8691	1130	17	which	which	WDT
8691	1130	18	are	be	VBP
8691	1130	19	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	1130	20	to	to	TO
8691	1130	21	be	be	VB
8691	1130	22	either	either	DT
8691	1130	23	of	of	IN
8691	1130	24	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
8691	1130	25	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	1130	26	or	or	CC
8691	1130	27	to	to	TO
8691	1130	28	contain	contain	VB
8691	1130	29	expressions	expression	NNS
8691	1130	30	of	of	IN
8691	1130	31	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
8691	1130	32	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	1130	33	,	,	,
8691	1130	34	on	on	IN
8691	1130	35	the	the	DT
8691	1130	36	plea	plea	NN
8691	1130	37	that	that	WDT
8691	1130	38	those	those	DT
8691	1130	39	are	be	VBP
8691	1130	40	questions	question	NNS
8691	1130	41	for	for	IN
8691	1130	42	the	the	DT
8691	1130	43	courts	court	NNS
8691	1130	44	to	to	TO
8691	1130	45	settle	settle	VB
8691	1130	46	.	.	.
8691	1131	1	This	this	DT
8691	1131	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	1131	3	been	be	VBN
8691	1131	4	aptly	aptly	RB
8691	1131	5	termed	term	VBN
8691	1131	6	the	the	DT
8691	1131	7	method	method	NN
8691	1131	8	of	of	IN
8691	1131	9	the	the	DT
8691	1131	10	"	"	``
8691	1131	11	_	_	NNP
8691	1131	12	referendum	referendum	NN
8691	1131	13	_	_	NNP
8691	1131	14	to	to	IN
8691	1131	15	the	the	DT
8691	1131	16	courts	court	NNS
8691	1131	17	in	in	IN
8691	1131	18	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	1131	19	.	.	.
8691	1132	1	"	"	``
8691	1132	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1132	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1132	4	:	:	:
8691	1132	5	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
8691	1132	6	Thacher	Thacher	NNP
8691	1132	7	,	,	,
8691	1132	8	Address	address	NN
8691	1132	9	before	before	IN
8691	1132	10	the	the	DT
8691	1132	11	State	State	NNP
8691	1132	12	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	1132	13	Association	Association	NNP
8691	1132	14	of	of	IN
8691	1132	15	New	New	NNP
8691	1132	16	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	1132	17	,	,	,
8691	1132	18	1903	1903	CD
8691	1132	19	.	.	.
8691	1132	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1133	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1133	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1133	3	unfair	unfair	JJ
8691	1133	4	to	to	IN
8691	1133	5	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1133	6	,	,	,
8691	1133	7	so	so	RB
8691	1133	8	far	far	RB
8691	1133	9	as	as	IN
8691	1133	10	any	any	DT
8691	1133	11	question	question	NN
8691	1133	12	of	of	IN
8691	1133	13	the	the	DT
8691	1133	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1133	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	1133	16	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	1133	17	,	,	,
8691	1133	18	since	since	IN
8691	1133	19	as	as	RB
8691	1133	20	soon	soon	RB
8691	1133	21	as	as	IN
8691	1133	22	the	the	DT
8691	1133	23	measure	measure	NN
8691	1133	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	1133	25	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	1133	26	a	a	DT
8691	1133	27	presumption	presumption	NN
8691	1133	28	arises	arise	VBZ
8691	1133	29	that	that	IN
8691	1133	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1133	31	is	be	VBZ
8691	1133	32	not	not	RB
8691	1133	33	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1133	34	.	.	.
8691	1134	1	The	the	DT
8691	1134	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1134	3	will	will	MD
8691	1134	4	not	not	RB
8691	1134	5	hold	hold	VB
8691	1134	6	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	1134	7	without	without	IN
8691	1134	8	strong	strong	JJ
8691	1134	9	grounds	ground	NNS
8691	1134	10	.	.	.
8691	1135	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1135	2	comes	come	VBZ
8691	1135	3	to	to	IN
8691	1135	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1135	5	with	with	IN
8691	1135	6	the	the	DT
8691	1135	7	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	1135	8	of	of	IN
8691	1135	9	a	a	DT
8691	1135	10	full	full	JJ
8691	1135	11	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1135	12	endorsement	endorsement	NN
8691	1135	13	.	.	.
8691	1136	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1136	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1136	3	unfair	unfair	JJ
8691	1136	4	to	to	IN
8691	1136	5	the	the	DT
8691	1136	6	people	people	NNS
8691	1136	7	,	,	,
8691	1136	8	both	both	CC
8691	1136	9	as	as	IN
8691	1136	10	to	to	IN
8691	1136	11	questions	question	NNS
8691	1136	12	of	of	IN
8691	1136	13	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	1136	14	and	and	CC
8691	1136	15	of	of	IN
8691	1136	16	interpretation	interpretation	NN
8691	1136	17	.	.	.
8691	1137	1	A	a	DT
8691	1137	2	statute	statute	NN
8691	1137	3	can	can	MD
8691	1137	4	be	be	VB
8691	1137	5	so	so	RB
8691	1137	6	drawn	draw	VBN
8691	1137	7	as	as	IN
8691	1137	8	to	to	TO
8691	1137	9	need	need	VB
8691	1137	10	no	no	DT
8691	1137	11	interpretation	interpretation	NN
8691	1137	12	,	,	,
8691	1137	13	or	or	CC
8691	1137	14	none	none	NN
8691	1137	15	the	the	DT
8691	1137	16	outcome	outcome	NN
8691	1137	17	of	of	IN
8691	1137	18	which	which	WDT
8691	1137	19	can	can	MD
8691	1137	20	be	be	VB
8691	1137	21	a	a	DT
8691	1137	22	matter	matter	NN
8691	1137	23	of	of	IN
8691	1137	24	doubt	doubt	NN
8691	1137	25	to	to	IN
8691	1137	26	any	any	DT
8691	1137	27	competent	competent	JJ
8691	1137	28	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	1137	29	.	.	.
8691	1138	1	A	a	DT
8691	1138	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1138	3	abandons	abandon	VBZ
8691	1138	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1138	5	function	function	NN
8691	1138	6	when	when	WRB
8691	1138	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1138	8	enacts	enact	VBZ
8691	1138	9	what	what	WP
8691	1138	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1138	11	does	do	VBZ
8691	1138	12	not	not	RB
8691	1138	13	understand	understand	VB
8691	1138	14	.	.	.
8691	1139	1	The	the	DT
8691	1139	2	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
8691	1139	3	Anti	Anti	NNP
8691	1139	4	-	-	NNP
8691	1139	5	Trust	Trust	NNP
8691	1139	6	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1139	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1139	8	an	an	DT
8691	1139	9	instance	instance	NN
8691	1139	10	of	of	IN
8691	1139	11	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	1139	12	of	of	IN
8691	1139	13	this	this	DT
8691	1139	14	character	character	NN
8691	1139	15	.	.	.
8691	1140	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1140	2	forbids	forbid	VBZ
8691	1140	3	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	1140	4	"	"	''
8691	1140	5	in	in	IN
8691	1140	6	restraint	restraint	NN
8691	1140	7	of	of	IN
8691	1140	8	trade	trade	NN
8691	1140	9	or	or	CC
8691	1140	10	commerce	commerce	NN
8691	1140	11	"	"	''
8691	1140	12	between	between	IN
8691	1140	13	the	the	DT
8691	1140	14	States	States	NNP
8691	1140	15	.	.	.
8691	1141	1	When	when	WRB
8691	1141	2	the	the	DT
8691	1141	3	bill	bill	NN
8691	1141	4	was	be	VBD
8691	1141	5	reported	report	VBN
8691	1141	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1141	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1141	8	objected	object	VBN
8691	1141	9	in	in	IN
8691	1141	10	the	the	DT
8691	1141	11	House	House	NNP
8691	1141	12	of	of	IN
8691	1141	13	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
8691	1141	14	that	that	WDT
8691	1141	15	these	these	DT
8691	1141	16	terms	term	NNS
8691	1141	17	were	be	VBD
8691	1141	18	vague	vague	JJ
8691	1141	19	and	and	CC
8691	1141	20	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
8691	1141	21	.	.	.
8691	1142	1	The	the	DT
8691	1142	2	chairman	chairman	NN
8691	1142	3	of	of	IN
8691	1142	4	the	the	DT
8691	1142	5	committee	committee	NN
8691	1142	6	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1142	7	stated	state	VBD
8691	1142	8	that	that	IN
8691	1142	9	just	just	RB
8691	1142	10	what	what	WP
8691	1142	11	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	1142	12	will	will	MD
8691	1142	13	be	be	VB
8691	1142	14	in	in	IN
8691	1142	15	restraint	restraint	NN
8691	1142	16	of	of	IN
8691	1142	17	such	such	JJ
8691	1142	18	commerce	commerce	NN
8691	1142	19	would	would	MD
8691	1142	20	not	not	RB
8691	1142	21	and	and	CC
8691	1142	22	could	could	MD
8691	1142	23	not	not	RB
8691	1142	24	be	be	VB
8691	1142	25	known	know	VBN
8691	1142	26	until	until	IN
8691	1142	27	the	the	DT
8691	1142	28	courts	court	NNS
8691	1142	29	had	have	VBD
8691	1142	30	construed	construe	VBN
8691	1142	31	and	and	CC
8691	1142	32	interpreted	interpret	VBD
8691	1142	33	the	the	DT
8691	1142	34	phrase	phrase	NN
8691	1142	35	.	.	.
8691	1143	1	The	the	DT
8691	1143	2	real	real	JJ
8691	1143	3	intent	intent	NN
8691	1143	4	of	of	IN
8691	1143	5	those	those	DT
8691	1143	6	who	who	WP
8691	1143	7	inserted	insert	VBD
8691	1143	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1143	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1143	10	that	that	IN
8691	1143	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1143	12	should	should	MD
8691	1143	13	not	not	RB
8691	1143	14	embrace	embrace	VB
8691	1143	15	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	1143	16	which	which	WDT
8691	1143	17	were	be	VBD
8691	1143	18	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	1143	19	and	and	CC
8691	1143	20	not	not	RB
8691	1143	21	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	1143	22	to	to	IN
8691	1143	23	public	public	JJ
8691	1143	24	policy	policy	NN
8691	1143	25	.	.	.
8691	1144	1	A	a	DT
8691	1144	2	similar	similar	JJ
8691	1144	3	term	term	NN
8691	1144	4	in	in	IN
8691	1144	5	the	the	DT
8691	1144	6	English	English	NNP
8691	1144	7	Railway	Railway	NNP
8691	1144	8	and	and	CC
8691	1144	9	Canals	Canals	NNP
8691	1144	10	Traffic	Traffic	NNP
8691	1144	11	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1144	12	had	have	VBD
8691	1144	13	received	receive	VBN
8691	1144	14	that	that	DT
8691	1144	15	interpretation	interpretation	NN
8691	1144	16	in	in	IN
8691	1144	17	the	the	DT
8691	1144	18	English	english	JJ
8691	1144	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	1144	20	,	,	,
8691	1144	21	and	and	CC
8691	1144	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1144	23	supposed	suppose	VBD
8691	1144	24	that	that	IN
8691	1144	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1144	26	courts	court	NNS
8691	1144	27	would	would	MD
8691	1144	28	follow	follow	VB
8691	1144	29	those	those	DT
8691	1144	30	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	1144	31	.	.	.
8691	1145	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1145	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1145	3	:	:	:
8691	1145	4	George	George	NNP
8691	1145	5	F.	F.	NNP
8691	1145	6	Hoar	Hoar	NNP
8691	1145	7	,	,	,
8691	1145	8	"	"	``
8691	1145	9	Autobiography	Autobiography	NNP
8691	1145	10	,	,	,
8691	1145	11	"	"	''
8691	1145	12	II	ii	CD
8691	1145	13	,	,	,
8691	1145	14	364	364	CD
8691	1145	15	.	.	.
8691	1145	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1146	1	The	the	DT
8691	1146	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1146	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1146	4	of	of	IN
8691	1146	5	the	the	DT
8691	1146	6	United	United	NNP
8691	1146	7	States	States	NNP
8691	1146	8	did	do	VBD
8691	1146	9	construe	construe	VB
8691	1146	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1146	11	as	as	IN
8691	1146	12	embracing	embrace	VBG
8691	1146	13	all	all	DT
8691	1146	14	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	1146	15	in	in	IN
8691	1146	16	restraint	restraint	NN
8691	1146	17	of	of	IN
8691	1146	18	inter	inter	JJ
8691	1146	19	-	-	JJ
8691	1146	20	State	state	JJ
8691	1146	21	trade	trade	NN
8691	1146	22	,	,	,
8691	1146	23	whether	whether	IN
8691	1146	24	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	1146	25	or	or	CC
8691	1146	26	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
8691	1146	27	,	,	,
8691	1146	28	fair	fair	JJ
8691	1146	29	or	or	CC
8691	1146	30	unfair	unfair	JJ
8691	1146	31	.	.	.
8691	1147	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1147	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1147	3	:	:	:
8691	1147	4	United	United	NNP
8691	1147	5	States	States	NNP
8691	1147	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1147	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	1147	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1147	9	Joint	Joint	NNP
8691	1147	10	Traffic	Traffic	NNP
8691	1147	11	Association	Association	NNP
8691	1147	12	,	,	,
8691	1147	13	171	171	CD
8691	1147	14	United	United	NNP
8691	1147	15	States	States	NNP
8691	1147	16	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1147	17	,	,	,
8691	1147	18	505	505	CD
8691	1147	19	,	,	,
8691	1147	20	570	570	CD
8691	1147	21	.	.	.
8691	1147	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1148	1	One	one	CD
8691	1148	2	of	of	IN
8691	1148	3	the	the	DT
8691	1148	4	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1148	5	who	who	WP
8691	1148	6	concurred	concur	VBD
8691	1148	7	in	in	IN
8691	1148	8	that	that	DT
8691	1148	9	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1148	10	,	,	,
8691	1148	11	in	in	IN
8691	1148	12	a	a	DT
8691	1148	13	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	1148	14	case	case	NN
8691	1148	15	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1148	16	under	under	IN
8691	1148	17	the	the	DT
8691	1148	18	same	same	JJ
8691	1148	19	statute	statute	NN
8691	1148	20	intimated	intimate	VBD
8691	1148	21	that	that	IN
8691	1148	22	on	on	IN
8691	1148	23	reconsideration	reconsideration	NN
8691	1148	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1148	25	thought	think	VBD
8691	1148	26	the	the	DT
8691	1148	27	view	view	NN
8691	1148	28	that	that	WDT
8691	1148	29	had	have	VBD
8691	1148	30	been	be	VBN
8691	1148	31	thus	thus	RB
8691	1148	32	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1148	33	was	be	VBD
8691	1148	34	wrong	wrong	JJ
8691	1148	35	.	.	.
8691	1149	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1149	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1149	3	:	:	:
8691	1149	4	Northern	Northern	NNP
8691	1149	5	Securities	Securities	NNPS
8691	1149	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1149	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1149	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	1149	9	_	_	NNP
8691	1149	10	United	United	NNP
8691	1149	11	States	States	NNP
8691	1149	12	,	,	,
8691	1149	13	193	193	CD
8691	1149	14	United	United	NNP
8691	1149	15	States	States	NNP
8691	1149	16	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1149	17	,	,	,
8691	1149	18	197	197	CD
8691	1149	19	,	,	,
8691	1149	20	361	361	CD
8691	1149	21	.	.	.
8691	1149	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1150	1	The	the	DT
8691	1150	2	addition	addition	NN
8691	1150	3	by	by	IN
8691	1150	4	those	those	DT
8691	1150	5	who	who	WP
8691	1150	6	drafted	draft	VBD
8691	1150	7	the	the	DT
8691	1150	8	bill	bill	NN
8691	1150	9	of	of	IN
8691	1150	10	three	three	CD
8691	1150	11	or	or	CC
8691	1150	12	four	four	CD
8691	1150	13	words	word	NNS
8691	1150	14	to	to	TO
8691	1150	15	make	make	VB
8691	1150	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1150	17	intended	intend	VBN
8691	1150	18	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	1150	19	clear	clear	JJ
8691	1150	20	would	would	MD
8691	1150	21	have	have	VB
8691	1150	22	avoided	avoid	VBN
8691	1150	23	a	a	DT
8691	1150	24	result	result	NN
8691	1150	25	unexpected	unexpected	JJ
8691	1150	26	by	by	IN
8691	1150	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1150	28	and	and	CC
8691	1150	29	probably	probably	RB
8691	1150	30	undesired	undesired	JJ
8691	1150	31	,	,	,
8691	1150	32	and	and	CC
8691	1150	33	relieved	relieve	VBD
8691	1150	34	the	the	DT
8691	1150	35	court	court	NN
8691	1150	36	from	from	IN
8691	1150	37	deciding	decide	VBG
8691	1150	38	questions	question	NNS
8691	1150	39	of	of	IN
8691	1150	40	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
8691	1150	41	construction	construction	NN
8691	1150	42	involving	involve	VBG
8691	1150	43	important	important	JJ
8691	1150	44	political	political	JJ
8691	1150	45	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	1150	46	and	and	CC
8691	1150	47	immense	immense	JJ
8691	1150	48	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
8691	1150	49	interests	interest	NNS
8691	1150	50	.	.	.
8691	1151	1	*	*	NFP
8691	1151	2	*	*	NFP
8691	1151	3	*	*	NFP
8691	1151	4	*	*	NFP
8691	1151	5	*	*	NFP
8691	1151	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	1151	7	VII	vii	NN
8691	1151	8	THE	the	DT
8691	1151	9	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	1151	10	POWER	power	NN
8691	1151	11	OF	of	IN
8691	1151	12	DECLARING	declaring	NN
8691	1151	13	WHAT	what	WP
8691	1151	14	HAS	have	VBZ
8691	1151	15	THE	the	DT
8691	1151	16	FORM	form	NN
8691	1151	17	OF	of	IN
8691	1151	18	LAW	law	NN
8691	1151	19	NOT	not	RB
8691	1151	20	TO	to	TO
8691	1151	21	BE	be	VB
8691	1151	22	LAW	LAW	NNP
8691	1151	23	Government	Government	NNP
8691	1151	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	1151	25	a	a	DT
8691	1151	26	device	device	NN
8691	1151	27	for	for	IN
8691	1151	28	applying	apply	VBG
8691	1151	29	the	the	DT
8691	1151	30	power	power	NN
8691	1151	31	of	of	IN
8691	1151	32	all	all	DT
8691	1151	33	to	to	TO
8691	1151	34	secure	secure	VB
8691	1151	35	the	the	DT
8691	1151	36	rights	right	NNS
8691	1151	37	of	of	IN
8691	1151	38	each	each	DT
8691	1151	39	.	.	.
8691	1152	1	Any	any	DT
8691	1152	2	government	government	NN
8691	1152	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1152	4	good	good	JJ
8691	1152	5	in	in	IN
8691	1152	6	which	which	WDT
8691	1152	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1152	8	are	be	VBP
8691	1152	9	thus	thus	RB
8691	1152	10	effectually	effectually	RB
8691	1152	11	secured	secure	VBN
8691	1152	12	.	.	.
8691	1153	1	That	that	DT
8691	1153	2	government	government	NN
8691	1153	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1153	4	best	good	JJS
8691	1153	5	in	in	IN
8691	1153	6	which	which	WDT
8691	1153	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1153	8	are	be	VBP
8691	1153	9	so	so	RB
8691	1153	10	secured	secured	JJ
8691	1153	11	with	with	IN
8691	1153	12	the	the	DT
8691	1153	13	least	least	JJS
8691	1153	14	show	show	NN
8691	1153	15	of	of	IN
8691	1153	16	force	force	NN
8691	1153	17	.	.	.
8691	1154	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1154	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1154	3	not	not	RB
8691	1154	4	too	too	RB
8691	1154	5	much	much	JJ
8691	1154	6	to	to	TO
8691	1154	7	say	say	VB
8691	1154	8	that	that	IN
8691	1154	9	this	this	DT
8691	1154	10	result	result	NN
8691	1154	11	has	have	VBZ
8691	1154	12	been	be	VBN
8691	1154	13	worked	work	VBN
8691	1154	14	out	out	RP
8691	1154	15	in	in	IN
8691	1154	16	practice	practice	NN
8691	1154	17	most	most	RBS
8691	1154	18	effectually	effectually	RB
8691	1154	19	by	by	IN
8691	1154	20	the	the	DT
8691	1154	21	American	american	JJ
8691	1154	22	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	1154	23	through	through	IN
8691	1154	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1154	25	mode	mode	NN
8691	1154	26	of	of	IN
8691	1154	27	enforcing	enforce	VBG
8691	1154	28	written	write	VBN
8691	1154	29	constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	1154	30	.	.	.
8691	1155	1	How	how	WRB
8691	1155	2	far	far	RB
8691	1155	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1155	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	1155	5	gone	go	VBN
8691	1155	6	in	in	IN
8691	1155	7	developing	develop	VBG
8691	1155	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1155	9	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	1155	10	and	and	CC
8691	1155	11	building	building	NN
8691	1155	12	upon	upon	IN
8691	1155	13	the	the	DT
8691	1155	14	foundations	foundation	NNS
8691	1155	15	which	which	WDT
8691	1155	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1155	17	furnish	furnish	VBP
8691	1155	18	has	have	VBZ
8691	1155	19	been	be	VBN
8691	1155	20	made	make	VBN
8691	1155	21	the	the	DT
8691	1155	22	subject	subject	NN
8691	1155	23	of	of	IN
8691	1155	24	discussion	discussion	NN
8691	1155	25	in	in	IN
8691	1155	26	the	the	DT
8691	1155	27	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	1155	28	chapter	chapter	NN
8691	1155	29	.	.	.
8691	1156	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1156	2	remains	remain	VBZ
8691	1156	3	to	to	TO
8691	1156	4	consider	consider	VB
8691	1156	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1156	6	office	office	NN
8691	1156	7	of	of	IN
8691	1156	8	adjudging	adjudging	NN
8691	1156	9	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1156	10	which	which	WDT
8691	1156	11	come	come	VBP
8691	1156	12	in	in	IN
8691	1156	13	conflict	conflict	NN
8691	1156	14	with	with	IN
8691	1156	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1156	16	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	1156	17	,	,	,
8691	1156	18	as	as	IN
8691	1156	19	thus	thus	RB
8691	1156	20	determined	determine	VBN
8691	1156	21	,	,	,
8691	1156	22	to	to	TO
8691	1156	23	be	be	VB
8691	1156	24	void	void	JJ
8691	1156	25	.	.	.
8691	1157	1	The	the	DT
8691	1157	2	idea	idea	NN
8691	1157	3	of	of	IN
8691	1157	4	a	a	DT
8691	1157	5	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	1157	6	authority	authority	NNP
8691	1157	7	exercising	exercise	VBG
8691	1157	8	the	the	DT
8691	1157	9	function	function	NN
8691	1157	10	of	of	IN
8691	1157	11	setting	set	VBG
8691	1157	12	aside	aside	RB
8691	1157	13	acts	act	NNS
8691	1157	14	of	of	IN
8691	1157	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1157	16	bodies	body	NNS
8691	1157	17	which	which	WDT
8691	1157	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1157	19	deemed	deem	VBD
8691	1157	20	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
8691	1157	21	with	with	IN
8691	1157	22	a	a	DT
8691	1157	23	higher	high	JJR
8691	1157	24	law	law	NN
8691	1157	25	was	be	VBD
8691	1157	26	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	1157	27	to	to	IN
8691	1157	28	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	1157	29	from	from	IN
8691	1157	30	an	an	DT
8691	1157	31	early	early	JJ
8691	1157	32	period	period	NN
8691	1157	33	of	of	IN
8691	1157	34	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1157	35	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	1157	36	history	history	NN
8691	1157	37	.	.	.
8691	1158	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1158	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1158	3	:	:	:
8691	1158	4	See	see	VB
8691	1158	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	1158	6	.	.	.
8691	1159	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1159	2	;	;	:
8691	1159	3	Dicey	Dicey	NNP
8691	1159	4	,	,	,
8691	1159	5	"	"	''
8691	1159	6	Law	Law	NNP
8691	1159	7	of	of	IN
8691	1159	8	the	the	DT
8691	1159	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1159	10	,	,	,
8691	1159	11	"	"	''
8691	1159	12	152	152	CD
8691	1159	13	;	;	:
8691	1159	14	"	"	''
8691	1159	15	Two	two	CD
8691	1159	16	Centuries	Centuries	NNPS
8691	1159	17	Growth	Growth	NNP
8691	1159	18	of	of	IN
8691	1159	19	American	American	NNP
8691	1159	20	Law	Law	NNP
8691	1159	21	,	,	,
8691	1159	22	"	"	''
8691	1159	23	12	12	CD
8691	1159	24	,	,	,
8691	1159	25	19	19	CD
8691	1159	26	.	.	.
8691	1159	27	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1160	1	The	the	DT
8691	1160	2	charter	charter	NN
8691	1160	3	of	of	IN
8691	1160	4	each	each	DT
8691	1160	5	colony	colony	NN
8691	1160	6	served	serve	VBD
8691	1160	7	the	the	DT
8691	1160	8	office	office	NN
8691	1160	9	of	of	IN
8691	1160	10	a	a	DT
8691	1160	11	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	1160	12	.	.	.
8691	1161	1	The	the	DT
8691	1161	2	Lords	Lords	NNPS
8691	1161	3	of	of	IN
8691	1161	4	Trade	Trade	NNP
8691	1161	5	and	and	CC
8691	1161	6	Plantations	Plantations	NNP
8691	1161	7	exercised	exercise	VBD
8691	1161	8	the	the	DT
8691	1161	9	power	power	NN
8691	1161	10	of	of	IN
8691	1161	11	enforcing	enforce	VBG
8691	1161	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1161	13	observance	observance	NN
8691	1161	14	.	.	.
8691	1162	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1162	2	did	do	VBD
8691	1162	3	in	in	IN
8691	1162	4	effect	effect	NN
8691	1162	5	what	what	WP
8691	1162	6	,	,	,
8691	1162	7	as	as	IN
8691	1162	8	the	the	DT
8691	1162	9	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	1162	10	passed	pass	VBD
8691	1162	11	into	into	IN
8691	1162	12	independent	independent	JJ
8691	1162	13	States	States	NNP
8691	1162	14	with	with	IN
8691	1162	15	written	write	VBN
8691	1162	16	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	1162	17	,	,	,
8691	1162	18	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	1162	19	became	become	VBD
8691	1162	20	the	the	DT
8691	1162	21	function	function	NN
8691	1162	22	of	of	IN
8691	1162	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1162	24	own	own	JJ
8691	1162	25	courts	court	NNS
8691	1162	26	of	of	IN
8691	1162	27	last	last	JJ
8691	1162	28	resort	resort	NN
8691	1162	29	.	.	.
8691	1163	1	The	the	DT
8691	1163	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1163	3	,	,	,
8691	1163	4	like	like	IN
8691	1163	5	the	the	DT
8691	1163	6	charter	charter	NN
8691	1163	7	,	,	,
8691	1163	8	was	be	VBD
8691	1163	9	the	the	DT
8691	1163	10	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	1163	11	law	law	NNP
8691	1163	12	of	of	IN
8691	1163	13	the	the	DT
8691	1163	14	land	land	NN
8691	1163	15	.	.	.
8691	1164	1	Whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	1164	2	statutes	statute	VBZ
8691	1164	3	the	the	DT
8691	1164	4	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1164	5	of	of	IN
8691	1164	6	a	a	DT
8691	1164	7	State	state	NN
8691	1164	8	might	may	MD
8691	1164	9	pass	pass	VB
8691	1164	10	,	,	,
8691	1164	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1164	12	passed	pass	VBD
8691	1164	13	as	as	IN
8691	1164	14	the	the	DT
8691	1164	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1164	16	representative	representative	NN
8691	1164	17	of	of	IN
8691	1164	18	the	the	DT
8691	1164	19	people	people	NNS
8691	1164	20	of	of	IN
8691	1164	21	that	that	DT
8691	1164	22	State	State	NNP
8691	1164	23	.	.	.
8691	1165	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1165	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1165	3	not	not	RB
8691	1165	4	made	make	VBN
8691	1165	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1165	6	plenary	plenary	JJ
8691	1165	7	representative	representative	NN
8691	1165	8	.	.	.
8691	1166	1	Every	every	DT
8691	1166	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1166	3	contained	contain	VBD
8691	1166	4	some	some	DT
8691	1166	5	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	1166	6	restricting	restrict	VBG
8691	1166	7	the	the	DT
8691	1166	8	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1166	9	power	power	NN
8691	1166	10	.	.	.
8691	1167	1	If	if	IN
8691	1167	2	any	any	DT
8691	1167	3	particular	particular	JJ
8691	1167	4	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1167	5	action	action	NN
8691	1167	6	transgressed	transgress	VBD
8691	1167	7	these	these	DT
8691	1167	8	restrictions	restriction	NNS
8691	1167	9	,	,	,
8691	1167	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1167	11	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	1167	12	went	go	VBD
8691	1167	13	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	1167	14	the	the	DT
8691	1167	15	authority	authority	NN
8691	1167	16	of	of	IN
8691	1167	17	the	the	DT
8691	1167	18	body	body	NN
8691	1167	19	from	from	IN
8691	1167	20	which	which	WDT
8691	1167	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1167	22	emanated	emanate	VBD
8691	1167	23	.	.	.
8691	1168	1	The	the	DT
8691	1168	2	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	1168	3	Committee	Committee	NNP
8691	1168	4	of	of	IN
8691	1168	5	the	the	DT
8691	1168	6	Privy	Privy	NNP
8691	1168	7	Council	Council	NNP
8691	1168	8	,	,	,
8691	1168	9	which	which	WDT
8691	1168	10	now	now	RB
8691	1168	11	exercises	exercise	VBZ
8691	1168	12	the	the	DT
8691	1168	13	functions	function	NNS
8691	1168	14	formerly	formerly	RB
8691	1168	15	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	1168	16	to	to	IN
8691	1168	17	the	the	DT
8691	1168	18	Lords	Lords	NNPS
8691	1168	19	of	of	IN
8691	1168	20	Trade	Trade	NNP
8691	1168	21	and	and	CC
8691	1168	22	Plantations	Plantations	NNP
8691	1168	23	,	,	,
8691	1168	24	and	and	CC
8691	1168	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	1168	26	in	in	IN
8691	1168	27	fact	fact	NN
8691	1168	28	the	the	DT
8691	1168	29	same	same	JJ
8691	1168	30	body	body	NN
8691	1168	31	,	,	,
8691	1168	32	deals	deal	NNS
8691	1168	33	in	in	IN
8691	1168	34	a	a	DT
8691	1168	35	similar	similar	JJ
8691	1168	36	way	way	NN
8691	1168	37	today	today	NN
8691	1168	38	with	with	IN
8691	1168	39	questions	question	NNS
8691	1168	40	of	of	IN
8691	1168	41	a	a	DT
8691	1168	42	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1168	43	character	character	NN
8691	1168	44	.	.	.
8691	1169	1	If	if	IN
8691	1169	2	one	one	CD
8691	1169	3	of	of	IN
8691	1169	4	the	the	DT
8691	1169	5	provinces	province	NNS
8691	1169	6	included	include	VBN
8691	1169	7	in	in	IN
8691	1169	8	the	the	DT
8691	1169	9	Dominion	dominion	NN
8691	1169	10	of	of	IN
8691	1169	11	Canada	Canada	NNP
8691	1169	12	should	should	MD
8691	1169	13	in	in	IN
8691	1169	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1169	15	local	local	JJ
8691	1169	16	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	1169	17	infringe	infringe	VBP
8691	1169	18	upon	upon	IN
8691	1169	19	a	a	DT
8691	1169	20	field	field	NN
8691	1169	21	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	1169	22	to	to	IN
8691	1169	23	the	the	DT
8691	1169	24	Dominion	Dominion	NNP
8691	1169	25	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
8691	1169	26	,	,	,
8691	1169	27	this	this	DT
8691	1169	28	committee	committee	NN
8691	1169	29	can	can	MD
8691	1169	30	"	"	``
8691	1169	31	humbly	humbly	RB
8691	1169	32	advise	advise	VB
8691	1169	33	the	the	DT
8691	1169	34	king	king	NN
8691	1169	35	"	"	''
8691	1169	36	that	that	IN
8691	1169	37	the	the	DT
8691	1169	38	act	act	NN
8691	1169	39	in	in	IN
8691	1169	40	question	question	NN
8691	1169	41	is	be	VBZ
8691	1169	42	for	for	IN
8691	1169	43	that	that	DT
8691	1169	44	reason	reason	NN
8691	1169	45	void	void	NN
8691	1169	46	.	.	.
8691	1170	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1170	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1170	3	:	:	:
8691	1170	4	In	in	IN
8691	1170	5	July	July	NNP
8691	1170	6	,	,	,
8691	1170	7	1903	1903	CD
8691	1170	8	,	,	,
8691	1170	9	for	for	IN
8691	1170	10	instance	instance	NN
8691	1170	11	,	,	,
8691	1170	12	an	an	DT
8691	1170	13	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1170	14	of	of	IN
8691	1170	15	the	the	DT
8691	1170	16	Province	Province	NNP
8691	1170	17	of	of	IN
8691	1170	18	Ontario	Ontario	NNP
8691	1170	19	,	,	,
8691	1170	20	entitled	entitle	VBD
8691	1170	21	the	the	DT
8691	1170	22	"	"	``
8691	1170	23	Lord	Lord	NNP
8691	1170	24	's	's	POS
8691	1170	25	Day	Day	NNP
8691	1170	26	Profanation	Profanation	NNP
8691	1170	27	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1170	28	,	,	,
8691	1170	29	"	"	''
8691	1170	30	was	be	VBD
8691	1170	31	thus	thus	RB
8691	1170	32	declared	declare	VBN
8691	1170	33	_	_	NNP
8691	1170	34	ultra	ultra	JJ
8691	1170	35	vires	vis	NNS
8691	1170	36	_	_	NNP
8691	1170	37	.	.	.
8691	1170	38	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1171	1	The	the	DT
8691	1171	2	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	1171	3	found	find	VBD
8691	1171	4	the	the	DT
8691	1171	5	new	new	RB
8691	1171	6	-	-	HYPH
8691	1171	7	made	make	VBN
8691	1171	8	States	state	NNS
8691	1171	9	of	of	IN
8691	1171	10	the	the	DT
8691	1171	11	Union	Union	NNP
8691	1171	12	without	without	IN
8691	1171	13	this	this	DT
8691	1171	14	safeguard	safeguard	NN
8691	1171	15	against	against	IN
8691	1171	16	a	a	DT
8691	1171	17	statute	statute	NN
8691	1171	18	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
8691	1171	19	to	to	IN
8691	1171	20	a	a	DT
8691	1171	21	higher	high	JJR
8691	1171	22	law	law	NN
8691	1171	23	.	.	.
8691	1172	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1172	2	had	have	VBD
8691	1172	3	enjoyed	enjoy	VBN
8691	1172	4	as	as	IN
8691	1172	5	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	1172	6	the	the	DT
8691	1172	7	advantage	advantage	NN
8691	1172	8	which	which	WDT
8691	1172	9	Burke	Burke	NNP
8691	1172	10	declared	declare	VBD
8691	1172	11	was	be	VBD
8691	1172	12	an	an	DT
8691	1172	13	ideal	ideal	NN
8691	1172	14	in	in	IN
8691	1172	15	government	government	NN
8691	1172	16	.	.	.
8691	1173	1	"	"	``
8691	1173	2	The	the	DT
8691	1173	3	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	1173	4	authority	authority	NNP
8691	1173	5	,	,	,
8691	1173	6	"	"	''
8691	1173	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1173	8	said	say	VBD
8691	1173	9	,	,	,
8691	1173	10	"	"	``
8691	1173	11	ought	ought	MD
8691	1173	12	to	to	TO
8691	1173	13	make	make	VB
8691	1173	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1173	15	judicature	judicature	NN
8691	1173	16	,	,	,
8691	1173	17	as	as	IN
8691	1173	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1173	19	were	be	VBD
8691	1173	20	,	,	,
8691	1173	21	something	something	NN
8691	1173	22	exterior	exterior	JJ
8691	1173	23	to	to	IN
8691	1173	24	the	the	DT
8691	1173	25	State	State	NNP
8691	1173	26	.	.	.
8691	1173	27	"	"	''
8691	1174	1	The	the	DT
8691	1174	2	supreme	supreme	JJ
8691	1174	3	judicature	judicature	NN
8691	1174	4	for	for	IN
8691	1174	5	America	America	NNP
8691	1174	6	had	have	VBD
8691	1174	7	been	be	VBN
8691	1174	8	in	in	IN
8691	1174	9	England	England	NNP
8691	1174	10	.	.	.
8691	1175	1	There	there	EX
8691	1175	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1175	3	now	now	RB
8691	1175	4	no	no	DT
8691	1175	5	King	King	NNP
8691	1175	6	in	in	IN
8691	1175	7	Council	Council	NNP
8691	1175	8	with	with	IN
8691	1175	9	power	power	NN
8691	1175	10	to	to	TO
8691	1175	11	set	set	VB
8691	1175	12	a	a	DT
8691	1175	13	statute	statute	NN
8691	1175	14	aside	aside	RB
8691	1175	15	forthwith	forthwith	NN
8691	1175	16	by	by	IN
8691	1175	17	an	an	DT
8691	1175	18	executive	executive	JJ
8691	1175	19	order	order	NN
8691	1175	20	.	.	.
8691	1176	1	But	but	CC
8691	1176	2	the	the	DT
8691	1176	3	other	other	JJ
8691	1176	4	function	function	NN
8691	1176	5	of	of	IN
8691	1176	6	the	the	DT
8691	1176	7	King	King	NNP
8691	1176	8	in	in	IN
8691	1176	9	Council	Council	NNP
8691	1176	10	,	,	,
8691	1176	11	that	that	DT
8691	1176	12	of	of	IN
8691	1176	13	acting	act	VBG
8691	1176	14	as	as	IN
8691	1176	15	a	a	DT
8691	1176	16	court	court	NN
8691	1176	17	of	of	IN
8691	1176	18	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1176	19	from	from	IN
8691	1176	20	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	1176	21	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1176	22	,	,	,
8691	1176	23	had	have	VBD
8691	1176	24	been	be	VBN
8691	1176	25	simply	simply	RB
8691	1176	26	transferred	transfer	VBN
8691	1176	27	to	to	IN
8691	1176	28	new	new	JJ
8691	1176	29	hands	hand	NNS
8691	1176	30	.	.	.
8691	1177	1	The	the	DT
8691	1177	2	State	State	NNP
8691	1177	3	into	into	IN
8691	1177	4	which	which	WDT
8691	1177	5	the	the	DT
8691	1177	6	colony	colony	NN
8691	1177	7	had	have	VBD
8691	1177	8	been	be	VBN
8691	1177	9	converted	convert	VBN
8691	1177	10	now	now	RB
8691	1177	11	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	1177	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1177	13	for	for	IN
8691	1177	14	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1177	15	and	and	CC
8691	1177	16	through	through	IN
8691	1177	17	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1177	18	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	1177	19	.	.	.
8691	1178	1	The	the	DT
8691	1178	2	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1178	3	of	of	IN
8691	1178	4	a	a	DT
8691	1178	5	court	court	NN
8691	1178	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1178	7	the	the	DT
8691	1178	8	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1178	9	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	1178	10	from	from	IN
8691	1178	11	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1178	12	facts	fact	NNS
8691	1178	13	.	.	.
8691	1179	1	Unless	unless	IN
8691	1179	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1179	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1179	4	a	a	DT
8691	1179	5	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1179	6	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	1179	7	from	from	IN
8691	1179	8	the	the	DT
8691	1179	9	facts	fact	NNS
8691	1179	10	on	on	IN
8691	1179	11	which	which	WDT
8691	1179	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1179	13	purports	purport	VBZ
8691	1179	14	to	to	TO
8691	1179	15	rest	rest	VB
8691	1179	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1179	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	1179	18	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
8691	1179	19	,	,	,
8691	1179	20	and	and	CC
8691	1179	21	,	,	,
8691	1179	22	if	if	IN
8691	1179	23	there	there	EX
8691	1179	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	1179	25	any	any	DT
8691	1179	26	higher	high	JJR
8691	1179	27	court	court	NN
8691	1179	28	of	of	IN
8691	1179	29	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1179	30	,	,	,
8691	1179	31	can	can	MD
8691	1179	32	be	be	VB
8691	1179	33	reversed	reverse	VBN
8691	1179	34	.	.	.
8691	1180	1	If	if	IN
8691	1180	2	such	such	PDT
8691	1180	3	a	a	DT
8691	1180	4	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1180	5	depends	depend	VBZ
8691	1180	6	upon	upon	IN
8691	1180	7	a	a	DT
8691	1180	8	statute	statute	NN
8691	1180	9	which	which	WDT
8691	1180	10	justifies	justify	VBZ
8691	1180	11	or	or	CC
8691	1180	12	forbids	forbid	VBZ
8691	1180	13	the	the	DT
8691	1180	14	act	act	NN
8691	1180	15	or	or	CC
8691	1180	16	omission	omission	NN
8691	1180	17	which	which	WDT
8691	1180	18	constituted	constitute	VBD
8691	1180	19	the	the	DT
8691	1180	20	cause	cause	NN
8691	1180	21	of	of	IN
8691	1180	22	action	action	NN
8691	1180	23	,	,	,
8691	1180	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1180	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	1180	26	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1180	27	or	or	CC
8691	1180	28	illegal	illegal	JJ
8691	1180	29	according	accord	VBG
8691	1180	30	as	as	IN
8691	1180	31	this	this	DT
8691	1180	32	statute	statute	NN
8691	1180	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	1180	34	or	or	CC
8691	1180	35	is	be	VBZ
8691	1180	36	not	not	RB
8691	1180	37	law	law	NN
8691	1180	38	.	.	.
8691	1181	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1181	2	can	can	MD
8691	1181	3	not	not	RB
8691	1181	4	be	be	VB
8691	1181	5	law	law	NN
8691	1181	6	if	if	IN
8691	1181	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1181	8	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	1181	9	contravene	contravene	VBP
8691	1181	10	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1181	11	laid	lay	VBN
8691	1181	12	down	down	RP
8691	1181	13	by	by	IN
8691	1181	14	the	the	DT
8691	1181	15	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1181	16	of	of	IN
8691	1181	17	the	the	DT
8691	1181	18	State	State	NNP
8691	1181	19	to	to	TO
8691	1181	20	restrict	restrict	VB
8691	1181	21	the	the	DT
8691	1181	22	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1181	23	power	power	NN
8691	1181	24	.	.	.
8691	1182	1	The	the	DT
8691	1182	2	court	court	NN
8691	1182	3	which	which	WDT
8691	1182	4	tries	try	VBZ
8691	1182	5	the	the	DT
8691	1182	6	cause	cause	NN
8691	1182	7	must	must	MD
8691	1182	8	meet	meet	VB
8691	1182	9	this	this	DT
8691	1182	10	question	question	NN
8691	1182	11	whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	1182	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1182	13	arises	arise	VBZ
8691	1182	14	like	like	IN
8691	1182	15	any	any	DT
8691	1182	16	other	other	JJ
8691	1182	17	and	and	CC
8691	1182	18	decide	decide	VB
8691	1182	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1182	20	.	.	.
8691	1183	1	A	a	DT
8691	1183	2	court	court	NN
8691	1183	3	of	of	IN
8691	1183	4	law	law	NN
8691	1183	5	must	must	MD
8691	1183	6	be	be	VB
8691	1183	7	governed	govern	VBN
8691	1183	8	by	by	IN
8691	1183	9	law	law	NN
8691	1183	10	.	.	.
8691	1184	1	What	what	WP
8691	1184	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	1184	3	the	the	DT
8691	1184	4	form	form	NN
8691	1184	5	of	of	IN
8691	1184	6	law	law	NN
8691	1184	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1184	8	not	not	RB
8691	1184	9	law	law	NN
8691	1184	10	,	,	,
8691	1184	11	in	in	IN
8691	1184	12	a	a	DT
8691	1184	13	country	country	NN
8691	1184	14	governed	govern	VBN
8691	1184	15	by	by	IN
8691	1184	16	a	a	DT
8691	1184	17	written	write	VBN
8691	1184	18	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	1184	19	,	,	,
8691	1184	20	unless	unless	IN
8691	1184	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1184	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	1184	23	consistent	consistent	JJ
8691	1184	24	with	with	IN
8691	1184	25	all	all	DT
8691	1184	26	which	which	WDT
8691	1184	27	that	that	IN
8691	1184	28	instrument	instrument	NN
8691	1184	29	provides	provide	VBZ
8691	1184	30	.	.	.
8691	1185	1	The	the	DT
8691	1185	2	first	first	JJ
8691	1185	3	decision	decision	NN
8691	1185	4	of	of	IN
8691	1185	5	an	an	DT
8691	1185	6	American	american	JJ
8691	1185	7	court	court	NN
8691	1185	8	bottomed	bottom	VBN
8691	1185	9	on	on	IN
8691	1185	10	these	these	DT
8691	1185	11	principles	principle	NNS
8691	1185	12	was	be	VBD
8691	1185	13	probably	probably	RB
8691	1185	14	rendered	render	VBN
8691	1185	15	as	as	RB
8691	1185	16	early	early	RB
8691	1185	17	as	as	IN
8691	1185	18	1780	1780	CD
8691	1185	19	,	,	,
8691	1185	20	and	and	CC
8691	1185	21	in	in	IN
8691	1185	22	New	New	NNP
8691	1185	23	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	1185	24	.	.	.
8691	1186	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1186	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	1186	3	:	:	:
8691	1186	4	Holmes	Holmes	NNP
8691	1186	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1186	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1186	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1186	8	Walton	Walton	NNP
8691	1186	9	,	,	,
8691	1186	10	IV	IV	NNP
8691	1186	11	_	_	NNP
8691	1186	12	American	American	NNP
8691	1186	13	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1186	14	Review	Review	NNP
8691	1186	15	_	_	NNP
8691	1186	16	,	,	,
8691	1186	17	456	456	CD
8691	1186	18	.	.	.
8691	1186	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1187	1	One	one	CD
8691	1187	2	of	of	IN
8691	1187	3	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1187	4	greatest	great	JJS
8691	1187	5	statesmen	statesman	NNS
8691	1187	6	,	,	,
8691	1187	7	who	who	WP
8691	1187	8	after	after	IN
8691	1187	9	taking	take	VBG
8691	1187	10	a	a	DT
8691	1187	11	distinguished	distinguished	JJ
8691	1187	12	part	part	NN
8691	1187	13	in	in	IN
8691	1187	14	framing	frame	VBG
8691	1187	15	the	the	DT
8691	1187	16	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1187	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1187	18	became	become	VBD
8691	1187	19	a	a	DT
8691	1187	20	justice	justice	NN
8691	1187	21	of	of	IN
8691	1187	22	the	the	DT
8691	1187	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1187	24	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1187	25	of	of	IN
8691	1187	26	the	the	DT
8691	1187	27	United	United	NNP
8691	1187	28	States	States	NNP
8691	1187	29	,	,	,
8691	1187	30	vigorously	vigorously	RB
8691	1187	31	enforced	enforce	VBD
8691	1187	32	the	the	DT
8691	1187	33	same	same	JJ
8691	1187	34	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1187	35	on	on	IN
8691	1187	36	the	the	DT
8691	1187	37	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1187	38	fifteen	fifteen	CD
8691	1187	39	years	year	NNS
8691	1187	40	later	later	RB
8691	1187	41	in	in	IN
8691	1187	42	trying	try	VBG
8691	1187	43	a	a	DT
8691	1187	44	cause	cause	NN
8691	1187	45	turning	turn	VBG
8691	1187	46	on	on	RP
8691	1187	47	the	the	DT
8691	1187	48	unconstitutionally	unconstitutionally	JJ
8691	1187	49	of	of	IN
8691	1187	50	a	a	DT
8691	1187	51	confirming	confirm	VBG
8691	1187	52	act	act	NN
8691	1187	53	passed	pass	VBN
8691	1187	54	by	by	IN
8691	1187	55	the	the	DT
8691	1187	56	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1187	57	of	of	IN
8691	1187	58	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	1187	59	.	.	.
8691	1188	1	"	"	``
8691	1188	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1188	3	take	take	VBP
8691	1188	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1188	5	,	,	,
8691	1188	6	"	"	''
8691	1188	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1188	8	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
8691	1188	9	said	say	VBD
8691	1188	10	in	in	IN
8691	1188	11	charging	charge	VBG
8691	1188	12	the	the	DT
8691	1188	13	jury	jury	NN
8691	1188	14	,	,	,
8691	1188	15	"	"	``
8691	1188	16	to	to	TO
8691	1188	17	be	be	VB
8691	1188	18	a	a	DT
8691	1188	19	clear	clear	JJ
8691	1188	20	position	position	NN
8691	1188	21	that	that	IN
8691	1188	22	if	if	IN
8691	1188	23	a	a	DT
8691	1188	24	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1188	25	act	act	NN
8691	1188	26	oppugns	oppugn	VBZ
8691	1188	27	a	a	DT
8691	1188	28	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1188	29	principle	principle	NN
8691	1188	30	the	the	DT
8691	1188	31	former	former	JJ
8691	1188	32	must	must	MD
8691	1188	33	give	give	VB
8691	1188	34	way	way	NN
8691	1188	35	and	and	CC
8691	1188	36	be	be	VB
8691	1188	37	rejected	reject	VBN
8691	1188	38	on	on	IN
8691	1188	39	the	the	DT
8691	1188	40	score	score	NN
8691	1188	41	of	of	IN
8691	1188	42	repugnance	repugnance	NN
8691	1188	43	.	.	.
8691	1189	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1189	2	hold	hold	VBP
8691	1189	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1189	4	to	to	TO
8691	1189	5	be	be	VB
8691	1189	6	a	a	DT
8691	1189	7	position	position	NN
8691	1189	8	equally	equally	RB
8691	1189	9	clear	clear	JJ
8691	1189	10	and	and	CC
8691	1189	11	sound	sound	VBP
8691	1189	12	that	that	IN
8691	1189	13	in	in	IN
8691	1189	14	such	such	JJ
8691	1189	15	case	case	NN
8691	1189	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1189	17	will	will	MD
8691	1189	18	be	be	VB
8691	1189	19	the	the	DT
8691	1189	20	duty	duty	NN
8691	1189	21	of	of	IN
8691	1189	22	the	the	DT
8691	1189	23	court	court	NN
8691	1189	24	to	to	TO
8691	1189	25	adhere	adhere	VB
8691	1189	26	to	to	IN
8691	1189	27	the	the	DT
8691	1189	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1189	29	,	,	,
8691	1189	30	and	and	CC
8691	1189	31	to	to	TO
8691	1189	32	declare	declare	VB
8691	1189	33	the	the	DT
8691	1189	34	act	act	NN
8691	1189	35	null	null	NN
8691	1189	36	and	and	CC
8691	1189	37	void	void	JJ
8691	1189	38	.	.	.
8691	1190	1	"	"	``
8691	1190	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1190	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1190	4	:	:	:
8691	1190	5	Vanhorne	Vanhorne	NNP
8691	1190	6	's	's	POS
8691	1190	7	Lessee	Lessee	NNP
8691	1190	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1190	9	v.	v.	IN
8691	1190	10	_	_	NNP
8691	1190	11	Dorrance	Dorrance	NNP
8691	1190	12	,	,	,
8691	1190	13	2	2	CD
8691	1190	14	Dallas	Dallas	NNP
8691	1190	15	'	'	POS
8691	1190	16	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1190	17	,	,	,
8691	1190	18	304	304	CD
8691	1190	19	,	,	,
8691	1190	20	309	309	CD
8691	1190	21	,	,	,
8691	1190	22	316	316	CD
8691	1190	23	.	.	.
8691	1190	24	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1191	1	The	the	DT
8691	1191	2	accession	accession	NN
8691	1191	3	of	of	IN
8691	1191	4	the	the	DT
8691	1191	5	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
8691	1191	6	to	to	IN
8691	1191	7	power	power	NN
8691	1191	8	in	in	IN
8691	1191	9	1801	1801	CD
8691	1191	10	,	,	,
8691	1191	11	only	only	RB
8691	1191	12	to	to	TO
8691	1191	13	find	find	VB
8691	1191	14	the	the	DT
8691	1191	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	1191	16	of	of	IN
8691	1191	17	the	the	DT
8691	1191	18	country	country	NN
8691	1191	19	controlled	control	VBN
8691	1191	20	by	by	IN
8691	1191	21	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1191	22	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	1191	23	from	from	IN
8691	1191	24	the	the	DT
8691	1191	25	ranks	rank	NNS
8691	1191	26	of	of	IN
8691	1191	27	the	the	DT
8691	1191	28	Federalists	Federalists	NNPS
8691	1191	29	,	,	,
8691	1191	30	was	be	VBD
8691	1191	31	the	the	DT
8691	1191	32	occasion	occasion	NN
8691	1191	33	of	of	IN
8691	1191	34	new	new	JJ
8691	1191	35	attacks	attack	NNS
8691	1191	36	upon	upon	IN
8691	1191	37	the	the	DT
8691	1191	38	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1191	39	thus	thus	RB
8691	1191	40	laid	lay	VBD
8691	1191	41	down	down	RP
8691	1191	42	.	.	.
8691	1192	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1192	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1192	3	vigorously	vigorously	RB
8691	1192	4	denied	deny	VBN
8691	1192	5	by	by	IN
8691	1192	6	Senator	Senator	NNP
8691	1192	7	Breckenridge	Breckenridge	NNP
8691	1192	8	of	of	IN
8691	1192	9	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1192	10	,	,	,
8691	1192	11	afterward	afterward	RB
8691	1192	12	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
8691	1192	13	-	-	HYPH
8691	1192	14	General	General	NNP
8691	1192	15	of	of	IN
8691	1192	16	the	the	DT
8691	1192	17	United	United	NNP
8691	1192	18	States	States	NNP
8691	1192	19	,	,	,
8691	1192	20	in	in	IN
8691	1192	21	the	the	DT
8691	1192	22	debates	debate	NNS
8691	1192	23	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	1192	24	the	the	DT
8691	1192	25	repeal	repeal	NN
8691	1192	26	of	of	IN
8691	1192	27	the	the	DT
8691	1192	28	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
8691	1192	29	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1192	30	of	of	IN
8691	1192	31	1801	1801	CD
8691	1192	32	.	.	.
8691	1193	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1193	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1193	3	:	:	:
8691	1193	4	Elliot	Elliot	NNP
8691	1193	5	's	's	POS
8691	1193	6	Debates	Debates	NNPS
8691	1193	7	,	,	,
8691	1193	8	IV	IV	NNP
8691	1193	9	,	,	,
8691	1193	10	444	444	CD
8691	1193	11	.	.	.
8691	1193	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1194	1	A	a	DT
8691	1194	2	year	year	NN
8691	1194	3	later	later	RB
8691	1194	4	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1194	5	in	in	IN
8691	1194	6	1803	1803	CD
8691	1194	7	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1194	8	the	the	DT
8691	1194	9	question	question	NN
8691	1194	10	came	come	VBD
8691	1194	11	for	for	IN
8691	1194	12	the	the	DT
8691	1194	13	first	first	JJ
8691	1194	14	time	time	NN
8691	1194	15	before	before	IN
8691	1194	16	the	the	DT
8691	1194	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1194	18	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1194	19	of	of	IN
8691	1194	20	the	the	DT
8691	1194	21	United	United	NNP
8691	1194	22	States	States	NNP
8691	1194	23	,	,	,
8691	1194	24	and	and	CC
8691	1194	25	the	the	DT
8691	1194	26	same	same	JJ
8691	1194	27	positions	position	NNS
8691	1194	28	advanced	advance	VBN
8691	1194	29	by	by	IN
8691	1194	30	Patterson	Patterson	NNP
8691	1194	31	were	be	VBD
8691	1194	32	taken	take	VBN
8691	1194	33	in	in	IN
8691	1194	34	what	what	WP
8691	1194	35	is	be	VBZ
8691	1194	36	known	know	VBN
8691	1194	37	as	as	IN
8691	1194	38	the	the	DT
8691	1194	39	leading	leading	JJ
8691	1194	40	case	case	NN
8691	1194	41	upon	upon	IN
8691	1194	42	this	this	DT
8691	1194	43	subject	subject	NN
8691	1194	44	by	by	IN
8691	1194	45	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1194	46	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1194	47	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1194	48	.	.	.
8691	1195	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1195	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1195	3	:	:	:
8691	1195	4	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
8691	1195	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1195	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1195	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1195	8	Madison	Madison	NNP
8691	1195	9	,	,	,
8691	1195	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1195	11	Cranch	Cranch	NNP
8691	1195	12	's	's	POS
8691	1195	13	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1195	14	,	,	,
8691	1195	15	137	137	CD
8691	1195	16	.	.	.
8691	1196	1	See	see	VB
8691	1196	2	Willoughby	willoughby	NN
8691	1196	3	,	,	,
8691	1196	4	"	"	''
8691	1196	5	The	the	DT
8691	1196	6	American	American	NNP
8691	1196	7	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
8691	1196	8	System	System	NNP
8691	1196	9	,	,	,
8691	1196	10	"	"	''
8691	1196	11	39	39	CD
8691	1196	12	.	.	.
8691	1196	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1197	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1197	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1197	3	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
8691	1197	4	that	that	IN
8691	1197	5	the	the	DT
8691	1197	6	action	action	NN
8691	1197	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1197	8	one	one	CD
8691	1197	9	involving	involve	VBG
8691	1197	10	a	a	DT
8691	1197	11	matter	matter	NN
8691	1197	12	of	of	IN
8691	1197	13	practical	practical	JJ
8691	1197	14	politics	politic	NNS
8691	1197	15	,	,	,
8691	1197	16	in	in	IN
8691	1197	17	which	which	WDT
8691	1197	18	the	the	DT
8691	1197	19	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1197	20	sought	seek	VBD
8691	1197	21	the	the	DT
8691	1197	22	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	1197	23	of	of	IN
8691	1197	24	a	a	DT
8691	1197	25	commission	commission	NN
8691	1197	26	the	the	DT
8691	1197	27	issue	issue	NN
8691	1197	28	of	of	IN
8691	1197	29	which	which	WDT
8691	1197	30	had	have	VBD
8691	1197	31	been	be	VBN
8691	1197	32	directed	direct	VBN
8691	1197	33	by	by	IN
8691	1197	34	President	President	NNP
8691	1197	35	Adams	Adams	NNP
8691	1197	36	at	at	IN
8691	1197	37	the	the	DT
8691	1197	38	close	close	NN
8691	1197	39	of	of	IN
8691	1197	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1197	41	term	term	NN
8691	1197	42	,	,	,
8691	1197	43	but	but	CC
8691	1197	44	which	which	WDT
8691	1197	45	was	be	VBD
8691	1197	46	withheld	withhold	VBN
8691	1197	47	by	by	IN
8691	1197	48	the	the	DT
8691	1197	49	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
8691	1197	50	of	of	IN
8691	1197	51	State	State	NNP
8691	1197	52	under	under	IN
8691	1197	53	President	President	NNP
8691	1197	54	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	1197	55	.	.	.
8691	1198	1	Party	party	NN
8691	1198	2	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	1198	3	ran	run	VBD
8691	1198	4	high	high	RB
8691	1198	5	at	at	IN
8691	1198	6	this	this	DT
8691	1198	7	time	time	NN
8691	1198	8	.	.	.
8691	1199	1	The	the	DT
8691	1199	2	views	view	NNS
8691	1199	3	of	of	IN
8691	1199	4	Breckenridge	Breckenridge	NNP
8691	1199	5	were	be	VBD
8691	1199	6	shared	share	VBN
8691	1199	7	by	by	IN
8691	1199	8	many	many	JJ
8691	1199	9	,	,	,
8691	1199	10	and	and	CC
8691	1199	11	the	the	DT
8691	1199	12	supremacy	supremacy	NN
8691	1199	13	of	of	IN
8691	1199	14	the	the	DT
8691	1199	15	judicial	judicial	NNP
8691	1199	16	department	department	NN
8691	1199	17	,	,	,
8691	1199	18	which	which	WDT
8691	1199	19	this	this	DT
8691	1199	20	prerogative	prerogative	NN
8691	1199	21	,	,	,
8691	1199	22	if	if	IN
8691	1199	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1199	24	possessed	possess	VBD
8691	1199	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1199	26	,	,	,
8691	1199	27	seemed	seem	VBD
8691	1199	28	to	to	TO
8691	1199	29	imply	imply	VB
8691	1199	30	,	,	,
8691	1199	31	was	be	VBD
8691	1199	32	distasteful	distasteful	JJ
8691	1199	33	to	to	IN
8691	1199	34	a	a	DT
8691	1199	35	large	large	JJ
8691	1199	36	part	part	NN
8691	1199	37	of	of	IN
8691	1199	38	the	the	DT
8691	1199	39	people	people	NNS
8691	1199	40	.	.	.
8691	1200	1	An	an	DT
8691	1200	2	eminent	eminent	JJ
8691	1200	3	judge	judge	NN
8691	1200	4	of	of	IN
8691	1200	5	a	a	DT
8691	1200	6	State	State	NNP
8691	1200	7	court	court	NN
8691	1200	8	,	,	,
8691	1200	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1200	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1200	11	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
8691	1200	12	of	of	IN
8691	1200	13	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	1200	14	,	,	,
8691	1200	15	as	as	RB
8691	1200	16	late	late	JJ
8691	1200	17	as	as	IN
8691	1200	18	1825	1825	CD
8691	1200	19	,	,	,
8691	1200	20	in	in	IN
8691	1200	21	a	a	DT
8691	1200	22	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	1200	23	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1200	24	,	,	,
8691	1200	25	combated	combat	VBN
8691	1200	26	at	at	IN
8691	1200	27	length	length	NN
8691	1200	28	the	the	DT
8691	1200	29	reasoning	reasoning	NN
8691	1200	30	of	of	IN
8691	1200	31	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1200	32	as	as	IN
8691	1200	33	weak	weak	JJ
8691	1200	34	and	and	CC
8691	1200	35	inconclusive	inconclusive	JJ
8691	1200	36	.	.	.
8691	1201	1	If	if	IN
8691	1201	2	,	,	,
8691	1201	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1201	4	said	say	VBD
8691	1201	5	,	,	,
8691	1201	6	the	the	DT
8691	1201	7	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	1201	8	had	have	VBD
8691	1201	9	the	the	DT
8691	1201	10	power	power	NN
8691	1201	11	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	1201	12	,	,	,
8691	1201	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1201	14	would	would	MD
8691	1201	15	be	be	VB
8691	1201	16	a	a	DT
8691	1201	17	political	political	JJ
8691	1201	18	power	power	NN
8691	1201	19	.	.	.
8691	1202	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1202	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1202	3	system	system	NN
8691	1202	4	was	be	VBD
8691	1202	5	patterned	pattern	VBN
8691	1202	6	after	after	IN
8691	1202	7	that	that	DT
8691	1202	8	of	of	IN
8691	1202	9	England	England	NNP
8691	1202	10	.	.	.
8691	1203	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1203	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1203	3	had	have	VBD
8691	1203	4	,	,	,
8691	1203	5	as	as	IN
8691	1203	6	such	such	JJ
8691	1203	7	,	,	,
8691	1203	8	no	no	DT
8691	1203	9	power	power	NN
8691	1203	10	not	not	RB
8691	1203	11	given	give	VBN
8691	1203	12	by	by	IN
8691	1203	13	the	the	DT
8691	1203	14	common	common	JJ
8691	1203	15	law	law	NN
8691	1203	16	.	.	.
8691	1204	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1204	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1204	3	conceded	concede	VBN
8691	1204	4	that	that	IN
8691	1204	5	English	english	JJ
8691	1204	6	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1204	7	could	could	MD
8691	1204	8	not	not	RB
8691	1204	9	hold	hold	VB
8691	1204	10	an	an	DT
8691	1204	11	act	act	NN
8691	1204	12	of	of	IN
8691	1204	13	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
8691	1204	14	void	void	JJ
8691	1204	15	because	because	IN
8691	1204	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1204	17	departed	depart	VBD
8691	1204	18	from	from	IN
8691	1204	19	the	the	DT
8691	1204	20	British	british	JJ
8691	1204	21	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	1204	22	.	.	.
8691	1205	1	No	no	DT
8691	1205	2	more	more	JJR
8691	1205	3	could	could	MD
8691	1205	4	American	american	JJ
8691	1205	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1205	6	hold	hold	VB
8691	1205	7	an	an	DT
8691	1205	8	act	act	NN
8691	1205	9	of	of	IN
8691	1205	10	a	a	DT
8691	1205	11	State	State	NNP
8691	1205	12	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1205	13	void	void	JJ
8691	1205	14	because	because	IN
8691	1205	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1205	16	departed	depart	VBD
8691	1205	17	from	from	IN
8691	1205	18	the	the	DT
8691	1205	19	State	State	NNP
8691	1205	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1205	21	,	,	,
8691	1205	22	unless	unless	IN
8691	1205	23	that	that	DT
8691	1205	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1205	25	in	in	IN
8691	1205	26	plain	plain	JJ
8691	1205	27	terms	term	NNS
8691	1205	28	gave	give	VBD
8691	1205	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1205	30	such	such	PDT
8691	1205	31	a	a	DT
8691	1205	32	power	power	NN
8691	1205	33	.	.	.
8691	1206	1	The	the	DT
8691	1206	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1206	3	of	of	IN
8691	1206	4	the	the	DT
8691	1206	5	United	United	NNP
8691	1206	6	States	States	NNP
8691	1206	7	did	do	VBD
8691	1206	8	give	give	VB
8691	1206	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1206	10	,	,	,
8691	1206	11	political	political	JJ
8691	1206	12	though	though	IN
8691	1206	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1206	14	was	be	VBD
8691	1206	15	,	,	,
8691	1206	16	to	to	IN
8691	1206	17	all	all	DT
8691	1206	18	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1206	19	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1206	20	Art	art	NN
8691	1206	21	.	.	.
8691	1207	1	XI	XI	NNP
8691	1207	2	,	,	,
8691	1207	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	1207	4	.	.	.
8691	1208	1	2	2	LS
8691	1208	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1208	3	,	,	,
8691	1208	4	and	and	CC
8691	1208	5	a	a	DT
8691	1208	6	State	State	NNP
8691	1208	7	statute	statute	NN
8691	1208	8	which	which	WDT
8691	1208	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1208	10	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	1208	11	to	to	IN
8691	1208	12	that	that	DT
8691	1208	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1208	14	might	may	MD
8691	1208	15	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1208	16	properly	properly	RB
8691	1208	17	be	be	VB
8691	1208	18	declared	declare	VBN
8691	1208	19	void	void	JJ
8691	1208	20	by	by	IN
8691	1208	21	the	the	DT
8691	1208	22	courts	court	NNS
8691	1208	23	.	.	.
8691	1209	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1209	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1209	3	:	:	:
8691	1209	4	Eakin	Eakin	NNP
8691	1209	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1209	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1209	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1209	8	Raub	Raub	NNP
8691	1209	9	,	,	,
8691	1209	10	12	12	CD
8691	1209	11	Sergeant	Sergeant	NNP
8691	1209	12	and	and	CC
8691	1209	13	Rawle	Rawle	NNP
8691	1209	14	's	's	POS
8691	1209	15	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1209	16	,	,	,
8691	1209	17	330	330	CD
8691	1209	18	.	.	.
8691	1209	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1210	1	Later	later	RB
8691	1210	2	in	in	IN
8691	1210	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1210	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1210	5	career	career	NN
8691	1210	6	Gibson	Gibson	NNP
8691	1210	7	abandoned	abandon	VBD
8691	1210	8	this	this	DT
8691	1210	9	position	position	NN
8691	1210	10	,	,	,
8691	1210	11	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1210	12	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1210	13	:	:	:
8691	1210	14	Norris	Norris	NNP
8691	1210	15	_	_	NNP
8691	1210	16	v.	v.	IN
8691	1210	17	_	_	NNP
8691	1210	18	Clymer	Clymer	NNP
8691	1210	19	,	,	,
8691	1210	20	2	2	CD
8691	1210	21	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	1210	22	State	State	NNP
8691	1210	23	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1210	24	,	,	,
8691	1210	25	281	281	CD
8691	1210	26	.	.	.
8691	1210	27	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1211	1	and	and	CC
8691	1211	2	the	the	DT
8691	1211	3	ground	ground	NN
8691	1211	4	taken	take	VBN
8691	1211	5	by	by	IN
8691	1211	6	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1211	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	1211	8	been	be	VBN
8691	1211	9	since	since	IN
8691	1211	10	1845	1845	CD
8691	1211	11	universally	universally	RB
8691	1211	12	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	1211	13	.	.	.
8691	1212	1	The	the	DT
8691	1212	2	last	last	JJ
8691	1212	3	official	official	JJ
8691	1212	4	attack	attack	NN
8691	1212	5	upon	upon	IN
8691	1212	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1212	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1212	8	made	make	VBN
8691	1212	9	in	in	IN
8691	1212	10	1831	1831	CD
8691	1212	11	,	,	,
8691	1212	12	at	at	IN
8691	1212	13	the	the	DT
8691	1212	14	time	time	NN
8691	1212	15	when	when	WRB
8691	1212	16	the	the	DT
8691	1212	17	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	1212	18	against	against	IN
8691	1212	19	protective	protective	JJ
8691	1212	20	tariffs	tariff	NNS
8691	1212	21	was	be	VBD
8691	1212	22	strong	strong	JJ
8691	1212	23	in	in	IN
8691	1212	24	the	the	DT
8691	1212	25	South	South	NNP
8691	1212	26	,	,	,
8691	1212	27	and	and	CC
8691	1212	28	South	South	NNP
8691	1212	29	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	1212	30	was	be	VBD
8691	1212	31	known	know	VBN
8691	1212	32	to	to	TO
8691	1212	33	be	be	VB
8691	1212	34	meditating	meditate	VBG
8691	1212	35	opposition	opposition	NN
8691	1212	36	to	to	IN
8691	1212	37	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1212	38	enforcement	enforcement	NN
8691	1212	39	.	.	.
8691	1213	1	The	the	DT
8691	1213	2	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	1213	3	committee	committee	NN
8691	1213	4	of	of	IN
8691	1213	5	the	the	DT
8691	1213	6	House	House	NNP
8691	1213	7	of	of	IN
8691	1213	8	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
8691	1213	9	reported	report	VBD
8691	1213	10	a	a	DT
8691	1213	11	bill	bill	NN
8691	1213	12	to	to	TO
8691	1213	13	repeal	repeal	VB
8691	1213	14	the	the	DT
8691	1213	15	section	section	NN
8691	1213	16	of	of	IN
8691	1213	17	the	the	DT
8691	1213	18	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
8691	1213	19	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1213	20	which	which	WDT
8691	1213	21	gave	give	VBD
8691	1213	22	the	the	DT
8691	1213	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1213	24	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1213	25	of	of	IN
8691	1213	26	the	the	DT
8691	1213	27	United	United	NNP
8691	1213	28	States	States	NNP
8691	1213	29	the	the	DT
8691	1213	30	right	right	NN
8691	1213	31	to	to	TO
8691	1213	32	reverse	reverse	VB
8691	1213	33	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1213	34	of	of	IN
8691	1213	35	State	state	NN
8691	1213	36	courts	court	NNS
8691	1213	37	that	that	IN
8691	1213	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1213	39	might	may	MD
8691	1213	40	deem	deem	VB
8691	1213	41	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	1213	42	to	to	IN
8691	1213	43	the	the	DT
8691	1213	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1213	45	of	of	IN
8691	1213	46	the	the	DT
8691	1213	47	United	United	NNP
8691	1213	48	States	States	NNP
8691	1213	49	.	.	.
8691	1214	1	The	the	DT
8691	1214	2	report	report	NN
8691	1214	3	said	say	VBD
8691	1214	4	that	that	IN
8691	1214	5	such	such	PDT
8691	1214	6	a	a	DT
8691	1214	7	grant	grant	NN
8691	1214	8	was	be	VBD
8691	1214	9	unwarranted	unwarranted	JJ
8691	1214	10	by	by	IN
8691	1214	11	the	the	DT
8691	1214	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1214	13	and	and	CC
8691	1214	14	"	"	``
8691	1214	15	a	a	DT
8691	1214	16	much	much	RB
8691	1214	17	greater	great	JJR
8691	1214	18	outrage	outrage	NN
8691	1214	19	upon	upon	IN
8691	1214	20	the	the	DT
8691	1214	21	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	1214	22	principles	principle	NNS
8691	1214	23	of	of	IN
8691	1214	24	theoretical	theoretical	JJ
8691	1214	25	and	and	CC
8691	1214	26	practical	practical	JJ
8691	1214	27	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	1214	28	as	as	IN
8691	1214	29	established	establish	VBN
8691	1214	30	here	here	RB
8691	1214	31	than	than	IN
8691	1214	32	the	the	DT
8691	1214	33	odious	odious	JJ
8691	1214	34	writ	writ	NN
8691	1214	35	of	of	IN
8691	1214	36	_	_	NNP
8691	1214	37	quo	quo	NNP
8691	1214	38	warranto	warranto	NNP
8691	1214	39	_	_	NNP
8691	1214	40	as	as	IN
8691	1214	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1214	42	was	be	VBD
8691	1214	43	used	use	VBN
8691	1214	44	in	in	IN
8691	1214	45	England	England	NNP
8691	1214	46	by	by	IN
8691	1214	47	a	a	DT
8691	1214	48	tyrannical	tyrannical	JJ
8691	1214	49	king	king	NN
8691	1214	50	to	to	TO
8691	1214	51	destroy	destroy	VB
8691	1214	52	the	the	DT
8691	1214	53	right	right	NN
8691	1214	54	of	of	IN
8691	1214	55	corporations	corporation	NNS
8691	1214	56	.	.	.
8691	1214	57	"	"	''
8691	1215	1	The	the	DT
8691	1215	2	House	House	NNP
8691	1215	3	,	,	,
8691	1215	4	however	however	RB
8691	1215	5	,	,	,
8691	1215	6	rejected	reject	VBD
8691	1215	7	the	the	DT
8691	1215	8	bill	bill	NN
8691	1215	9	by	by	IN
8691	1215	10	a	a	DT
8691	1215	11	very	very	RB
8691	1215	12	large	large	JJ
8691	1215	13	majority	majority	NN
8691	1215	14	.	.	.
8691	1216	1	A	a	DT
8691	1216	2	proper	proper	JJ
8691	1216	3	regard	regard	NN
8691	1216	4	for	for	IN
8691	1216	5	the	the	DT
8691	1216	6	coordination	coordination	NN
8691	1216	7	of	of	IN
8691	1216	8	the	the	DT
8691	1216	9	departments	department	NNS
8691	1216	10	of	of	IN
8691	1216	11	government	government	NN
8691	1216	12	forbids	forbid	NNS
8691	1216	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	1216	14	to	to	TO
8691	1216	15	declare	declare	VB
8691	1216	16	that	that	IN
8691	1216	17	a	a	DT
8691	1216	18	statute	statute	NN
8691	1216	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	1216	20	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
8691	1216	21	with	with	IN
8691	1216	22	the	the	DT
8691	1216	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1216	24	unless	unless	IN
8691	1216	25	the	the	DT
8691	1216	26	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
8691	1216	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	1216	28	plain	plain	JJ
8691	1216	29	.	.	.
8691	1217	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1217	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	1217	3	been	be	VBN
8691	1217	4	judicially	judicially	RB
8691	1217	5	asserted	assert	VBN
8691	1217	6	that	that	IN
8691	1217	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1217	8	must	must	MD
8691	1217	9	be	be	VB
8691	1217	10	plain	plain	JJ
8691	1217	11	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	1217	12	a	a	DT
8691	1217	13	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	1217	14	doubt	doubt	NN
8691	1217	15	,	,	,
8691	1217	16	thus	thus	RB
8691	1217	17	applying	apply	VBG
8691	1217	18	a	a	DT
8691	1217	19	rule	rule	NN
8691	1217	20	of	of	IN
8691	1217	21	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	1217	22	which	which	WDT
8691	1217	23	governs	govern	VBZ
8691	1217	24	the	the	DT
8691	1217	25	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	1217	26	of	of	IN
8691	1217	27	a	a	DT
8691	1217	28	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1217	29	cause	cause	NN
8691	1217	30	.	.	.
8691	1218	1	As	as	IN
8691	1218	2	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1218	3	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	1218	4	a	a	DT
8691	1218	5	statute	statute	NN
8691	1218	6	inconsistent	inconsistent	NN
8691	1218	7	are	be	VBP
8691	1218	8	often	often	RB
8691	1218	9	rendered	render	VBN
8691	1218	10	by	by	IN
8691	1218	11	a	a	DT
8691	1218	12	divided	divide	VBN
8691	1218	13	court	court	NN
8691	1218	14	,	,	,
8691	1218	15	this	this	DT
8691	1218	16	position	position	NN
8691	1218	17	seems	seem	VBZ
8691	1218	18	practically	practically	RB
8691	1218	19	untenable	untenable	JJ
8691	1218	20	.	.	.
8691	1219	1	The	the	DT
8691	1219	2	majority	majority	NN
8691	1219	3	must	must	MD
8691	1219	4	concede	concede	VB
8691	1219	5	that	that	IN
8691	1219	6	there	there	EX
8691	1219	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1219	8	a	a	DT
8691	1219	9	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	1219	10	doubt	doubt	NN
8691	1219	11	whether	whether	IN
8691	1219	12	the	the	DT
8691	1219	13	statute	statute	NN
8691	1219	14	may	may	MD
8691	1219	15	not	not	RB
8691	1219	16	be	be	VB
8691	1219	17	consistent	consistent	JJ
8691	1219	18	with	with	IN
8691	1219	19	the	the	DT
8691	1219	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1219	21	,	,	,
8691	1219	22	since	since	IN
8691	1219	23	some	some	DT
8691	1219	24	of	of	IN
8691	1219	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1219	26	associates	associate	NNS
8691	1219	27	either	either	CC
8691	1219	28	must	must	MD
8691	1219	29	have	have	VB
8691	1219	30	such	such	PDT
8691	1219	31	a	a	DT
8691	1219	32	doubt	doubt	NN
8691	1219	33	,	,	,
8691	1219	34	or	or	CC
8691	1219	35	go	go	VB
8691	1219	36	further	far	RBR
8691	1219	37	and	and	CC
8691	1219	38	hold	hold	VB
8691	1219	39	that	that	IN
8691	1219	40	there	there	EX
8691	1219	41	is	be	VBZ
8691	1219	42	no	no	DT
8691	1219	43	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
8691	1219	44	between	between	IN
8691	1219	45	the	the	DT
8691	1219	46	two	two	CD
8691	1219	47	documents	document	NNS
8691	1219	48	.	.	.
8691	1220	1	This	this	DT
8691	1220	2	right	right	NN
8691	1220	3	of	of	IN
8691	1220	4	a	a	DT
8691	1220	5	court	court	NN
8691	1220	6	to	to	TO
8691	1220	7	set	set	VB
8691	1220	8	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1220	9	up	up	RP
8691	1220	10	against	against	IN
8691	1220	11	a	a	DT
8691	1220	12	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1220	13	,	,	,
8691	1220	14	and	and	CC
8691	1220	15	of	of	IN
8691	1220	16	a	a	DT
8691	1220	17	court	court	NN
8691	1220	18	of	of	IN
8691	1220	19	one	one	CD
8691	1220	20	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	1220	21	to	to	TO
8691	1220	22	set	set	VB
8691	1220	23	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1220	24	up	up	RP
8691	1220	25	against	against	IN
8691	1220	26	the	the	DT
8691	1220	27	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1220	28	of	of	IN
8691	1220	29	another	another	DT
8691	1220	30	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	1220	31	,	,	,
8691	1220	32	is	be	VBZ
8691	1220	33	something	something	NN
8691	1220	34	which	which	WDT
8691	1220	35	no	no	DT
8691	1220	36	other	other	JJ
8691	1220	37	country	country	NN
8691	1220	38	in	in	IN
8691	1220	39	the	the	DT
8691	1220	40	world	world	NN
8691	1220	41	would	would	MD
8691	1220	42	tolerate	tolerate	VB
8691	1220	43	.	.	.
8691	1221	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1221	2	rests	rest	VBZ
8691	1221	3	on	on	IN
8691	1221	4	solid	solid	JJ
8691	1221	5	reason	reason	NN
8691	1221	6	,	,	,
8691	1221	7	but	but	CC
8691	1221	8	as	as	IN
8691	1221	9	the	the	DT
8691	1221	10	Due	Due	NNP
8691	1221	11	de	de	FW
8691	1221	12	Noailles	Noailles	NNP
8691	1221	13	has	have	VBZ
8691	1221	14	said	say	VBD
8691	1221	15	,	,	,
8691	1221	16	"	"	``
8691	1221	17	Un	Un	NNP
8691	1221	18	semblable	semblable	JJ
8691	1221	19	raisonnement	raisonnement	NN
8691	1221	20	ne	ne	NNP
8691	1221	21	ferait	ferait	NNP
8691	1221	22	pas	pas	NNP
8691	1221	23	fortune	fortune	NNP
8691	1221	24	aupres	aupre	VBZ
8691	1221	25	des	des	NNP
8691	1221	26	rÃ	rÃ	NNP
8691	1221	27	©	©	NNP
8691	1221	28	publicans	publican	NNS
8691	1221	29	d'Europe	d'Europe	NNP
8691	1221	30	,	,	,
8691	1221	31	fort	fort	NNP
8691	1221	32	chatouilleux	chatouilleux	NNP
8691	1221	33	sur	sur	NNP
8691	1221	34	le	le	NNP
8691	1221	35	chapitre	chapitre	NNP
8691	1221	36	de	de	NNP
8691	1221	37	la	la	NNP
8691	1221	38	puissance	puissance	NNP
8691	1221	39	lÃ	lÃ	NNP
8691	1221	40	©	©	RB
8691	1221	41	gislative	gislative	VBN
8691	1221	42	.	.	.
8691	1222	1	C'est	C'est	NNP
8691	1222	2	que	que	NNP
8691	1222	3	la	la	NNP
8691	1222	4	notion	notion	NN
8691	1222	5	de	de	NN
8691	1222	6	l'Ã	l'Ã	NNP
8691	1222	7	�	�	NNP
8691	1222	8	tat	tat	NNP
8691	1222	9	diffère	diffère	NNP
8691	1222	10	d'une	d'une	VBZ
8691	1222	11	façon	façon	NNP
8691	1222	12	essentielle	essentielle	FW
8691	1222	13	sur	sur	FW
8691	1222	14	les	les	FW
8691	1222	15	deux	deux	FW
8691	1222	16	rives	rive	NNS
8691	1222	17	de	de	IN
8691	1222	18	l'Atlantique	l'Atlantique	NNP
8691	1222	19	.	.	.
8691	1223	1	"	"	``
8691	1223	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1223	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	1223	4	:	:	:
8691	1223	5	Cent	Cent	NNP
8691	1223	6	Ans	Ans	NNP
8691	1223	7	de	de	NNP
8691	1223	8	RÃ	RÃ	NNP
8691	1223	9	©	©	NNP
8691	1223	10	publique	publique	NN
8691	1223	11	aux	aux	NN
8691	1223	12	Ã	ã	NN
8691	1223	13	�	�	NNP
8691	1223	14	tats	tat	NNS
8691	1223	15	-	-	:
8691	1223	16	Unis	Unis	NNP
8691	1223	17	,	,	,
8691	1223	18	II	II	NNP
8691	1223	19	,	,	,
8691	1223	20	145	145	CD
8691	1223	21	.	.	.
8691	1223	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1224	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1224	2	people	people	NNS
8691	1224	3	have	have	VBP
8691	1224	4	been	be	VBN
8691	1224	5	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
8691	1224	6	with	with	IN
8691	1224	7	the	the	DT
8691	1224	8	interposition	interposition	NN
8691	1224	9	of	of	IN
8691	1224	10	the	the	DT
8691	1224	11	courts	court	NNS
8691	1224	12	to	to	TO
8691	1224	13	defend	defend	VB
8691	1224	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1224	15	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	1224	16	from	from	IN
8691	1224	17	executive	executive	JJ
8691	1224	18	or	or	CC
8691	1224	19	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1224	20	attack	attack	NN
8691	1224	21	,	,	,
8691	1224	22	because	because	IN
8691	1224	23	these	these	DT
8691	1224	24	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	1224	25	stand	stand	VBP
8691	1224	26	for	for	IN
8691	1224	27	something	something	NN
8691	1224	28	in	in	IN
8691	1224	29	which	which	WDT
8691	1224	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1224	31	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
8691	1224	32	believe	believe	VBP
8691	1224	33	.	.	.
8691	1225	1	President	President	NNP
8691	1225	2	Hadley	Hadley	NNP
8691	1225	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	1225	4	well	well	RB
8691	1225	5	said	say	VBN
8691	1225	6	that	that	IN
8691	1225	7	"	"	``
8691	1225	8	a	a	DT
8691	1225	9	written	write	VBN
8691	1225	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1225	11	serves	serve	VBZ
8691	1225	12	much	much	RB
8691	1225	13	the	the	DT
8691	1225	14	same	same	JJ
8691	1225	15	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1225	16	in	in	IN
8691	1225	17	public	public	JJ
8691	1225	18	law	law	NN
8691	1225	19	which	which	WDT
8691	1225	20	a	a	DT
8691	1225	21	fence	fence	NN
8691	1225	22	serves	serve	VBZ
8691	1225	23	in	in	IN
8691	1225	24	the	the	DT
8691	1225	25	definition	definition	NN
8691	1225	26	and	and	CC
8691	1225	27	protection	protection	NN
8691	1225	28	of	of	IN
8691	1225	29	private	private	JJ
8691	1225	30	rights	right	NNS
8691	1225	31	to	to	IN
8691	1225	32	real	real	JJ
8691	1225	33	estate	estate	NN
8691	1225	34	.	.	.
8691	1226	1	A	a	DT
8691	1226	2	fence	fence	NN
8691	1226	3	does	do	VBZ
8691	1226	4	not	not	RB
8691	1226	5	make	make	VB
8691	1226	6	a	a	DT
8691	1226	7	boundary	boundary	NN
8691	1226	8	;	;	:
8691	1226	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1226	10	marks	mark	VBZ
8691	1226	11	one	one	CD
8691	1226	12	.	.	.
8691	1227	1	If	if	IN
8691	1227	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1227	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1227	4	set	set	VBN
8691	1227	5	where	where	WRB
8691	1227	6	a	a	DT
8691	1227	7	boundary	boundary	JJ
8691	1227	8	line	line	NN
8691	1227	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	1227	10	previously	previously	RB
8691	1227	11	existed	exist	VBN
8691	1227	12	by	by	IN
8691	1227	13	tradition	tradition	NN
8691	1227	14	and	and	CC
8691	1227	15	agreement	agreement	NN
8691	1227	16	,	,	,
8691	1227	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1227	18	forms	form	VBZ
8691	1227	19	an	an	DT
8691	1227	20	exceedingly	exceedingly	RB
8691	1227	21	convenient	convenient	JJ
8691	1227	22	means	mean	NNS
8691	1227	23	of	of	IN
8691	1227	24	defending	defend	VBG
8691	1227	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1227	26	against	against	IN
8691	1227	27	encroachments	encroachment	NNS
8691	1227	28	.	.	.
8691	1228	1	If	if	IN
8691	1228	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1228	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1228	4	set	set	VBN
8691	1228	5	near	near	IN
8691	1228	6	the	the	DT
8691	1228	7	boundary	boundary	NN
8691	1228	8	and	and	CC
8691	1228	9	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	1228	10	to	to	TO
8691	1228	11	stay	stay	VB
8691	1228	12	there	there	RB
8691	1228	13	unchallenged	unchallenged	JJ
8691	1228	14	,	,	,
8691	1228	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1228	16	may	may	MD
8691	1228	17	in	in	IN
8691	1228	18	time	time	NN
8691	1228	19	become	become	VB
8691	1228	20	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1228	21	the	the	DT
8691	1228	22	accepted	accepted	JJ
8691	1228	23	boundary	boundary	NN
8691	1228	24	.	.	.
8691	1229	1	But	but	CC
8691	1229	2	if	if	IN
8691	1229	3	the	the	DT
8691	1229	4	attempt	attempt	NN
8691	1229	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	1229	6	made	make	VBN
8691	1229	7	to	to	TO
8691	1229	8	establish	establish	VB
8691	1229	9	a	a	DT
8691	1229	10	factitious	factitious	JJ
8691	1229	11	boundary	boundary	NN
8691	1229	12	by	by	IN
8691	1229	13	the	the	DT
8691	1229	14	mere	mere	JJ
8691	1229	15	act	act	NN
8691	1229	16	of	of	IN
8691	1229	17	setting	set	VBG
8691	1229	18	up	up	RP
8691	1229	19	a	a	DT
8691	1229	20	fence	fence	NN
8691	1229	21	the	the	DT
8691	1229	22	effort	effort	NN
8691	1229	23	fails	fail	VBZ
8691	1229	24	.	.	.
8691	1230	1	"	"	``
8691	1230	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1230	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	1230	4	:	:	:
8691	1230	5	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
8691	1230	6	and	and	CC
8691	1230	7	Responsibility	Responsibility	NNP
8691	1230	8	,	,	,
8691	1230	9	30	30	CD
8691	1230	10	.	.	.
8691	1230	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1231	1	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	1231	2	took	take	VBD
8691	1231	3	principles	principle	NNS
8691	1231	4	and	and	CC
8691	1231	5	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	1231	6	with	with	IN
8691	1231	7	which	which	WDT
8691	1231	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1231	9	had	have	VBD
8691	1231	10	become	become	VBN
8691	1231	11	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	1231	12	in	in	IN
8691	1231	13	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	1231	14	days	day	NNS
8691	1231	15	and	and	CC
8691	1231	16	made	make	VBD
8691	1231	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1231	18	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	1231	19	out	out	IN
8691	1231	20	of	of	IN
8691	1231	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1231	22	.	.	.
8691	1232	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1232	2	attachment	attachment	NN
8691	1232	3	to	to	IN
8691	1232	4	what	what	WP
8691	1232	5	the	the	DT
8691	1232	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1232	7	provides	provide	VBZ
8691	1232	8	goes	go	VBZ
8691	1232	9	behind	behind	IN
8691	1232	10	the	the	DT
8691	1232	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1232	12	to	to	IN
8691	1232	13	the	the	DT
8691	1232	14	rock	rock	NN
8691	1232	15	of	of	IN
8691	1232	16	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	1232	17	custom	custom	NN
8691	1232	18	and	and	CC
8691	1232	19	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	1232	20	on	on	IN
8691	1232	21	which	which	WDT
8691	1232	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1232	23	rests	rest	VBZ
8691	1232	24	,	,	,
8691	1232	25	the	the	DT
8691	1232	26	common	common	JJ
8691	1232	27	heritage	heritage	NN
8691	1232	28	of	of	IN
8691	1232	29	all	all	PDT
8691	1232	30	the	the	DT
8691	1232	31	States	States	NNPS
8691	1232	32	.	.	.
8691	1233	1	There	there	EX
8691	1233	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1233	3	an	an	DT
8691	1233	4	obvious	obvious	JJ
8691	1233	5	reason	reason	NN
8691	1233	6	for	for	IN
8691	1233	7	the	the	DT
8691	1233	8	unwillingness	unwillingness	NN
8691	1233	9	of	of	IN
8691	1233	10	the	the	DT
8691	1233	11	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	1233	12	to	to	TO
8691	1233	13	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	1233	14	the	the	DT
8691	1233	15	power	power	NN
8691	1233	16	under	under	IN
8691	1233	17	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	1233	18	unless	unless	IN
8691	1233	19	in	in	IN
8691	1233	20	case	case	NN
8691	1233	21	of	of	IN
8691	1233	22	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	1233	23	.	.	.
8691	1234	1	The	the	DT
8691	1234	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1234	3	presumably	presumably	RB
8691	1234	4	does	do	VBZ
8691	1234	5	only	only	RB
8691	1234	6	what	what	WP
8691	1234	7	the	the	DT
8691	1234	8	public	public	JJ
8691	1234	9	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	1234	10	of	of	IN
8691	1234	11	the	the	DT
8691	1234	12	day	day	NN
8691	1234	13	justifies	justifie	NNS
8691	1234	14	or	or	CC
8691	1234	15	demands	demand	NNS
8691	1234	16	.	.	.
8691	1235	1	One	one	CD
8691	1235	2	branch	branch	NN
8691	1235	3	of	of	IN
8691	1235	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1235	5	,	,	,
8691	1235	6	at	at	IN
8691	1235	7	least	least	JJS
8691	1235	8	,	,	,
8691	1235	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1235	10	the	the	DT
8691	1235	11	direct	direct	JJ
8691	1235	12	representative	representative	NN
8691	1235	13	of	of	IN
8691	1235	14	the	the	DT
8691	1235	15	people	people	NNS
8691	1235	16	.	.	.
8691	1236	1	To	to	TO
8691	1236	2	defeat	defeat	VB
8691	1236	3	the	the	DT
8691	1236	4	operation	operation	NN
8691	1236	5	of	of	IN
8691	1236	6	a	a	DT
8691	1236	7	statute	statute	NN
8691	1236	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	1236	9	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1236	10	always	always	RB
8691	1236	11	presumably	presumably	RB
8691	1236	12	an	an	DT
8691	1236	13	unpopular	unpopular	JJ
8691	1236	14	thing	thing	NN
8691	1236	15	to	to	TO
8691	1236	16	do	do	VB
8691	1236	17	,	,	,
8691	1236	18	and	and	CC
8691	1236	19	if	if	IN
8691	1236	20	in	in	IN
8691	1236	21	any	any	DT
8691	1236	22	case	case	NN
8691	1236	23	there	there	EX
8691	1236	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	1236	25	known	know	VBN
8691	1236	26	to	to	TO
8691	1236	27	be	be	VB
8691	1236	28	truth	truth	NN
8691	1236	29	behind	behind	IN
8691	1236	30	the	the	DT
8691	1236	31	presumption	presumption	NN
8691	1236	32	,	,	,
8691	1236	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1236	34	requires	require	VBZ
8691	1236	35	,	,	,
8691	1236	36	as	as	IN
8691	1236	37	the	the	DT
8691	1236	38	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
8691	1236	39	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1236	40	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	1236	41	:	:	:
8691	1236	42	No	no	UH
8691	1236	43	.	.	.
8691	1237	1	LXXVIII	LXXVIII	NNP
8691	1237	2	.	.	.
8691	1237	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1238	1	put	put	VB
8691	1238	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1238	3	,	,	,
8691	1238	4	"	"	''
8691	1238	5	an	an	DT
8691	1238	6	uncommon	uncommon	JJ
8691	1238	7	portion	portion	NN
8691	1238	8	of	of	IN
8691	1238	9	fortitude	fortitude	NN
8691	1238	10	in	in	IN
8691	1238	11	the	the	DT
8691	1238	12	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1238	13	to	to	TO
8691	1238	14	do	do	VB
8691	1238	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1238	16	duty	duty	NN
8691	1238	17	as	as	IN
8691	1238	18	faithful	faithful	JJ
8691	1238	19	guardians	guardian	NNS
8691	1238	20	of	of	IN
8691	1238	21	the	the	DT
8691	1238	22	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	1238	23	.	.	.
8691	1238	24	"	"	''
8691	1239	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1239	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1239	3	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	1239	4	that	that	IN
8691	1239	5	an	an	DT
8691	1239	6	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	1239	7	court	court	NN
8691	1239	8	declares	declare	VBZ
8691	1239	9	a	a	DT
8691	1239	10	statute	statute	NN
8691	1239	11	void	void	NN
8691	1239	12	.	.	.
8691	1240	1	The	the	DT
8691	1240	2	mere	mere	JJ
8691	1240	3	fact	fact	NN
8691	1240	4	that	that	IN
8691	1240	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1240	6	was	be	VBD
8691	1240	7	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	1240	8	by	by	IN
8691	1240	9	the	the	DT
8691	1240	10	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1240	11	imports	import	VBZ
8691	1240	12	the	the	DT
8691	1240	13	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1240	14	of	of	IN
8691	1240	15	that	that	DT
8691	1240	16	body	body	NN
8691	1240	17	that	that	WDT
8691	1240	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1240	19	was	be	VBD
8691	1240	20	within	within	IN
8691	1240	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1240	22	powers	power	NNS
8691	1240	23	;	;	:
8691	1240	24	and	and	CC
8691	1240	25	such	such	PDT
8691	1240	26	an	an	DT
8691	1240	27	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1240	28	of	of	IN
8691	1240	29	a	a	DT
8691	1240	30	department	department	NN
8691	1240	31	of	of	IN
8691	1240	32	government	government	NN
8691	1240	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	1240	34	entitled	entitle	VBN
8691	1240	35	to	to	IN
8691	1240	36	great	great	JJ
8691	1240	37	respect	respect	NN
8691	1240	38	.	.	.
8691	1241	1	If	if	IN
8691	1241	2	a	a	DT
8691	1241	3	different	different	JJ
8691	1241	4	,	,	,
8691	1241	5	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1241	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1241	7	to	to	TO
8691	1241	8	prevail	prevail	VB
8691	1241	9	,	,	,
8691	1241	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1241	11	should	should	MD
8691	1241	12	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	1241	13	be	be	VB
8691	1241	14	first	first	RB
8691	1241	15	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	1241	16	by	by	IN
8691	1241	17	the	the	DT
8691	1241	18	highest	high	JJS
8691	1241	19	authority	authority	NN
8691	1241	20	that	that	WDT
8691	1241	21	can	can	MD
8691	1241	22	speak	speak	VB
8691	1241	23	for	for	IN
8691	1241	24	the	the	DT
8691	1241	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1241	26	department	department	NN
8691	1241	27	.	.	.
8691	1242	1	So	so	RB
8691	1242	2	far	far	RB
8691	1242	3	,	,	,
8691	1242	4	however	however	RB
8691	1242	5	,	,	,
8691	1242	6	as	as	IN
8691	1242	7	the	the	DT
8691	1242	8	question	question	NN
8691	1242	9	of	of	IN
8691	1242	10	power	power	NN
8691	1242	11	or	or	CC
8691	1242	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1242	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	1242	14	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	1242	15	,	,	,
8691	1242	16	a	a	DT
8691	1242	17	justice	justice	NN
8691	1242	18	of	of	IN
8691	1242	19	the	the	DT
8691	1242	20	peace	peace	NN
8691	1242	21	,	,	,
8691	1242	22	in	in	IN
8691	1242	23	trying	try	VBG
8691	1242	24	a	a	DT
8691	1242	25	five	five	CD
8691	1242	26	-	-	HYPH
8691	1242	27	dollar	dollar	NN
8691	1242	28	case	case	NN
8691	1242	29	,	,	,
8691	1242	30	has	have	VBZ
8691	1242	31	the	the	DT
8691	1242	32	same	same	JJ
8691	1242	33	authority	authority	NN
8691	1242	34	to	to	TO
8691	1242	35	disregard	disregard	VB
8691	1242	36	a	a	DT
8691	1242	37	statute	statute	NN
8691	1242	38	,	,	,
8691	1242	39	whether	whether	IN
8691	1242	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1242	41	be	be	VB
8691	1242	42	one	one	CD
8691	1242	43	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	1242	44	by	by	IN
8691	1242	45	the	the	DT
8691	1242	46	State	State	NNP
8691	1242	47	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1242	48	or	or	CC
8691	1242	49	by	by	IN
8691	1242	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1242	51	,	,	,
8691	1242	52	if	if	IN
8691	1242	53	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1242	54	deems	deem	VBZ
8691	1242	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1242	56	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1242	57	,	,	,
8691	1242	58	which	which	WDT
8691	1242	59	belongs	belong	VBZ
8691	1242	60	to	to	IN
8691	1242	61	the	the	DT
8691	1242	62	full	full	JJ
8691	1242	63	bench	bench	NN
8691	1242	64	of	of	IN
8691	1242	65	the	the	DT
8691	1242	66	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1242	67	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1242	68	of	of	IN
8691	1242	69	the	the	DT
8691	1242	70	United	United	NNP
8691	1242	71	States	States	NNP
8691	1242	72	.	.	.
8691	1243	1	If	if	IN
8691	1243	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1243	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1243	4	wrong	wrong	JJ
8691	1243	5	,	,	,
8691	1243	6	the	the	DT
8691	1243	7	only	only	JJ
8691	1243	8	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1243	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1243	10	by	by	IN
8691	1243	11	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1243	12	.	.	.
8691	1244	1	The	the	DT
8691	1244	2	number	number	NN
8691	1244	3	of	of	IN
8691	1244	4	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1244	5	which	which	WDT
8691	1244	6	have	have	VBP
8691	1244	7	been	be	VBN
8691	1244	8	judicially	judicially	RB
8691	1244	9	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	1244	10	in	in	IN
8691	1244	11	whole	whole	JJ
8691	1244	12	or	or	CC
8691	1244	13	part	part	NN
8691	1244	14	invalid	invalid	JJ
8691	1244	15	in	in	IN
8691	1244	16	the	the	DT
8691	1244	17	United	United	NNP
8691	1244	18	States	States	NNP
8691	1244	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	1244	20	very	very	RB
8691	1244	21	large	large	JJ
8691	1244	22	.	.	.
8691	1245	1	Among	among	IN
8691	1245	2	the	the	DT
8691	1245	3	Acts	Acts	NNPS
8691	1245	4	of	of	IN
8691	1245	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1245	6	which	which	WDT
8691	1245	7	have	have	VBP
8691	1245	8	fallen	fall	VBN
8691	1245	9	in	in	IN
8691	1245	10	this	this	DT
8691	1245	11	manner	manner	NN
8691	1245	12	and	and	CC
8691	1245	13	have	have	VBP
8691	1245	14	been	be	VBN
8691	1245	15	made	make	VBN
8691	1245	16	the	the	DT
8691	1245	17	subject	subject	NN
8691	1245	18	of	of	IN
8691	1245	19	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
8691	1245	20	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	1245	21	may	may	MD
8691	1245	22	be	be	VB
8691	1245	23	mentioned	mention	VBN
8691	1245	24	the	the	DT
8691	1245	25	provision	provision	NN
8691	1245	26	in	in	IN
8691	1245	27	the	the	DT
8691	1245	28	original	original	JJ
8691	1245	29	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
8691	1245	30	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1245	31	giving	give	VBG
8691	1245	32	the	the	DT
8691	1245	33	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1245	34	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1245	35	of	of	IN
8691	1245	36	the	the	DT
8691	1245	37	United	United	NNP
8691	1245	38	States	States	NNP
8691	1245	39	greater	great	JJR
8691	1245	40	original	original	JJ
8691	1245	41	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1245	42	than	than	IN
8691	1245	43	the	the	DT
8691	1245	44	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1245	45	provided;[Footnote	provided;[Footnote	''
8691	1245	46	:	:	:
8691	1245	47	Marbury	Marbury	NNP
8691	1245	48	_	_	NNP
8691	1245	49	v.	v.	IN
8691	1245	50	_	_	NNP
8691	1245	51	Madison	Madison	NNP
8691	1245	52	,	,	,
8691	1245	53	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1245	54	Cranch	Cranch	NNP
8691	1245	55	's	's	POS
8691	1245	56	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1245	57	,	,	,
8691	1245	58	137	137	CD
8691	1245	59	.	.	.
8691	1245	60	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1246	1	the	the	DT
8691	1246	2	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1246	3	of	of	IN
8691	1246	4	1865	1865	CD
8691	1246	5	,	,	,
8691	1246	6	excluding	exclude	VBG
8691	1246	7	from	from	IN
8691	1246	8	practice	practice	NN
8691	1246	9	in	in	IN
8691	1246	10	the	the	DT
8691	1246	11	United	United	NNP
8691	1246	12	States	States	NNP
8691	1246	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	1246	14	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	1246	15	who	who	WP
8691	1246	16	could	could	MD
8691	1246	17	not	not	RB
8691	1246	18	take	take	VB
8691	1246	19	the	the	DT
8691	1246	20	"	"	``
8691	1246	21	iron	iron	NN
8691	1246	22	-	-	HYPH
8691	1246	23	clad	clothe	VBN
8691	1246	24	oath	oath	NN
8691	1246	25	"	"	''
8691	1246	26	that	that	IN
8691	1246	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1246	28	had	have	VBD
8691	1246	29	not	not	RB
8691	1246	30	supported	support	VBN
8691	1246	31	the	the	DT
8691	1246	32	South	South	NNP
8691	1246	33	in	in	IN
8691	1246	34	the	the	DT
8691	1246	35	Civil	civil	JJ
8691	1246	36	War;[Footnote	war;[footnote	CD
8691	1246	37	:	:	:
8691	1246	38	_	_	NNP
8691	1246	39	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	1246	40	parte	parte	NN
8691	1246	41	_	_	NNP
8691	1246	42	Garland	Garland	NNP
8691	1246	43	,	,	,
8691	1246	44	4	4	CD
8691	1246	45	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	1246	46	's	's	POS
8691	1246	47	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1246	48	,	,	,
8691	1246	49	333	333	CD
8691	1246	50	.	.	.
8691	1246	51	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1247	1	the	the	DT
8691	1247	2	Legal	Legal	NNP
8691	1247	3	Tender	Tender	NNP
8691	1247	4	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1247	5	of	of	IN
8691	1247	6	1866;[Footnote	1866;[footnote	CD
8691	1247	7	:	:	:
8691	1247	8	Hepburn	Hepburn	NNP
8691	1247	9	_	_	NNP
8691	1247	10	v.	v.	IN
8691	1247	11	_	_	NNP
8691	1247	12	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
8691	1247	13	,	,	,
8691	1247	14	8	8	CD
8691	1247	15	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	1247	16	's	's	POS
8691	1247	17	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1247	18	,	,	,
8691	1247	19	603	603	CD
8691	1247	20	,	,	,
8691	1247	21	overruled	overrule	VBN
8691	1247	22	in	in	IN
8691	1247	23	the	the	DT
8691	1247	24	Legal	Legal	NNP
8691	1247	25	Tender	Tender	NNP
8691	1247	26	Cases	Cases	NNPS
8691	1247	27	,	,	,
8691	1247	28	12	12	CD
8691	1247	29	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	1247	30	's	's	POS
8691	1247	31	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1247	32	,	,	,
8691	1247	33	457	457	CD
8691	1247	34	.	.	.
8691	1247	35	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1248	1	the	the	DT
8691	1248	2	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1248	3	of	of	IN
8691	1248	4	1870	1870	CD
8691	1248	5	,	,	,
8691	1248	6	to	to	TO
8691	1248	7	protect	protect	VB
8691	1248	8	the	the	DT
8691	1248	9	colored	color	VBN
8691	1248	10	voter;[Footnote	voter;[footnote	NN
8691	1248	11	:	:	:
8691	1248	12	United	United	NNP
8691	1248	13	States	States	NNP
8691	1248	14	_	_	NNP
8691	1248	15	v.	v.	IN
8691	1248	16	_	_	NNP
8691	1248	17	Reese	Reese	NNP
8691	1248	18	,	,	,
8691	1248	19	92	92	CD
8691	1248	20	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1248	21	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1248	22	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1248	23	,	,	,
8691	1248	24	214	214	CD
8691	1248	25	.	.	.
8691	1248	26	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1249	1	the	the	DT
8691	1249	2	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	1249	3	Rights	Rights	NNPS
8691	1249	4	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1249	5	of	of	IN
8691	1249	6	1875;[Footnote	1875;[footnote	CD
8691	1249	7	:	:	:
8691	1249	8	United	United	NNP
8691	1249	9	States	States	NNP
8691	1249	10	_	_	NNP
8691	1249	11	v.	v.	IN
8691	1249	12	_	_	NNP
8691	1249	13	Stanley	Stanley	NNP
8691	1249	14	,	,	,
8691	1249	15	109	109	CD
8691	1249	16	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1249	17	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1249	18	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1249	19	,	,	,
8691	1249	20	3	3	CD
8691	1249	21	.	.	.
8691	1249	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1250	1	the	the	DT
8691	1250	2	Trade	Trade	NNP
8691	1250	3	Mark	Mark	NNP
8691	1250	4	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1250	5	of	of	IN
8691	1250	6	1876,[Footnote	1876,[footnote	CD
8691	1250	7	:	:	:
8691	1250	8	The	the	DT
8691	1250	9	Trade	Trade	NNP
8691	1250	10	Mark	Mark	NNP
8691	1250	11	Cases	Cases	NNP
8691	1250	12	,	,	,
8691	1250	13	100	100	CD
8691	1250	14	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1250	15	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1250	16	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1250	17	,	,	,
8691	1250	18	82	82	CD
8691	1250	19	.	.	.
8691	1250	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1251	1	and	and	CC
8691	1251	2	the	the	DT
8691	1251	3	Income	Income	NNP
8691	1251	4	Tax	Tax	NNP
8691	1251	5	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1251	6	of	of	IN
8691	1251	7	1894	1894	CD
8691	1251	8	.	.	.
8691	1252	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1252	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1252	3	:	:	:
8691	1252	4	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
8691	1252	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1252	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1252	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1252	8	Farmers	Farmers	NNP
8691	1252	9	'	'	POS
8691	1252	10	Loan	Loan	NNP
8691	1252	11	and	and	CC
8691	1252	12	Trust	Trust	NNP
8691	1252	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1252	14	,	,	,
8691	1252	15	157	157	CD
8691	1252	16	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1252	17	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1252	18	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1252	19	,	,	,
8691	1252	20	429	429	CD
8691	1252	21	.	.	.
8691	1252	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1253	1	Fifteen	fifteen	CD
8691	1253	2	others	other	NNS
8691	1253	3	of	of	IN
8691	1253	4	less	less	JJR
8691	1253	5	importance	importance	NN
8691	1253	6	have	have	VBP
8691	1253	7	fallen	fall	VBN
8691	1253	8	by	by	IN
8691	1253	9	the	the	DT
8691	1253	10	same	same	JJ
8691	1253	11	sword	sword	NN
8691	1253	12	.	.	.
8691	1254	1	The	the	DT
8691	1254	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1254	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1254	4	of	of	IN
8691	1254	5	the	the	DT
8691	1254	6	United	United	NNP
8691	1254	7	States	States	NNP
8691	1254	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	1254	9	also	also	RB
8691	1254	10	set	set	VBN
8691	1254	11	aside	aside	RB
8691	1254	12	in	in	IN
8691	1254	13	the	the	DT
8691	1254	14	same	same	JJ
8691	1254	15	manner	manner	NN
8691	1254	16	,	,	,
8691	1254	17	as	as	IN
8691	1254	18	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
8691	1254	19	with	with	IN
8691	1254	20	the	the	DT
8691	1254	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1254	22	of	of	IN
8691	1254	23	the	the	DT
8691	1254	24	United	United	NNP
8691	1254	25	States	States	NNP
8691	1254	26	,	,	,
8691	1254	27	over	over	IN
8691	1254	28	two	two	CD
8691	1254	29	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	1254	30	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1254	31	passed	pass	VBN
8691	1254	32	by	by	IN
8691	1254	33	States	States	NNP
8691	1254	34	.	.	.
8691	1255	1	Of	of	IN
8691	1255	2	the	the	DT
8691	1255	3	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	1255	4	-	-	HYPH
8691	1255	5	one	one	CD
8691	1255	6	acts	act	NNS
8691	1255	7	of	of	IN
8691	1255	8	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1255	9	thus	thus	RB
8691	1255	10	declared	declare	VBD
8691	1255	11	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1255	12	,	,	,
8691	1255	13	the	the	DT
8691	1255	14	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	1255	15	as	as	IN
8691	1255	16	to	to	IN
8691	1255	17	all	all	DT
8691	1255	18	but	but	IN
8691	1255	19	two	two	CD
8691	1255	20	were	be	VBD
8691	1255	21	rendered	render	VBN
8691	1255	22	after	after	IN
8691	1255	23	1830	1830	CD
8691	1255	24	;	;	:
8691	1255	25	of	of	IN
8691	1255	26	the	the	DT
8691	1255	27	State	state	NN
8691	1255	28	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1255	29	all	all	DT
8691	1255	30	but	but	CC
8691	1255	31	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	1255	32	-	-	HYPH
8691	1255	33	six	six	CD
8691	1255	34	.	.	.
8691	1256	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1256	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1256	3	:	:	:
8691	1256	4	Condensed	condense	VBN
8691	1256	5	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1256	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1256	7	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1256	8	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1256	9	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1256	10	'	'	POS
8691	1256	11	Ed	Ed	NNP
8691	1256	12	.	.	.
8691	1257	1	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1257	2	,	,	,
8691	1257	3	325	325	CD
8691	1257	4	.	.	.
8691	1257	5	note	note	VB
8691	1257	6	a	a	DT
8691	1257	7	;	;	:
8691	1257	8	see	see	VB
8691	1257	9	also	also	RB
8691	1257	10	131	131	CD
8691	1257	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1257	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1257	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1257	14	,	,	,
8691	1257	15	ccxxxv	ccxxxv	NNS
8691	1257	16	.	.	.
8691	1257	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1258	1	The	the	DT
8691	1258	2	fourteenth	fourteenth	JJ
8691	1258	3	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	1258	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	1258	5	added	add	VBN
8691	1258	6	largely	largely	RB
8691	1258	7	to	to	IN
8691	1258	8	the	the	DT
8691	1258	9	list	list	NN
8691	1258	10	of	of	IN
8691	1258	11	the	the	DT
8691	1258	12	latter	latter	JJ
8691	1258	13	since	since	IN
8691	1258	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1258	15	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	1258	16	in	in	IN
8691	1258	17	1868	1868	CD
8691	1258	18	.	.	.
8691	1259	1	State	state	NN
8691	1259	2	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1259	3	set	set	VBN
8691	1259	4	aside	aside	RB
8691	1259	5	by	by	IN
8691	1259	6	the	the	DT
8691	1259	7	State	State	NNP
8691	1259	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	1259	9	since	since	IN
8691	1259	10	1780	1780	CD
8691	1259	11	as	as	IN
8691	1259	12	in	in	IN
8691	1259	13	violation	violation	NN
8691	1259	14	of	of	IN
8691	1259	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1259	16	respective	respective	JJ
8691	1259	17	State	state	NN
8691	1259	18	constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	1259	19	number	number	NN
8691	1259	20	thousands	thousand	NNS
8691	1259	21	.	.	.
8691	1260	1	In	in	IN
8691	1260	2	the	the	DT
8691	1260	3	year	year	NN
8691	1260	4	from	from	IN
8691	1260	5	October	October	NNP
8691	1260	6	1	1	CD
8691	1260	7	,	,	,
8691	1260	8	1902	1902	CD
8691	1260	9	,	,	,
8691	1260	10	to	to	IN
8691	1260	11	October	October	NNP
8691	1260	12	1	1	CD
8691	1260	13	,	,	,
8691	1260	14	1903	1903	CD
8691	1260	15	,	,	,
8691	1260	16	the	the	DT
8691	1260	17	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	1260	18	of	of	IN
8691	1260	19	forty	forty	CD
8691	1260	20	-	-	HYPH
8691	1260	21	four	four	CD
8691	1260	22	States	States	NNPS
8691	1260	23	and	and	CC
8691	1260	24	fully	fully	RB
8691	1260	25	organized	organize	VBN
8691	1260	26	Territories	Territories	NNPS
8691	1260	27	of	of	IN
8691	1260	28	the	the	DT
8691	1260	29	United	United	NNP
8691	1260	30	States	States	NNP
8691	1260	31	were	be	VBD
8691	1260	32	in	in	IN
8691	1260	33	session	session	NN
8691	1260	34	and	and	CC
8691	1260	35	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	1260	36	14,400	14,400	CD
8691	1260	37	new	new	JJ
8691	1260	38	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1260	39	were	be	VBD
8691	1260	40	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	1260	41	.	.	.
8691	1261	1	During	during	IN
8691	1261	2	the	the	DT
8691	1261	3	same	same	JJ
8691	1261	4	year	year	NN
8691	1261	5	fifty	fifty	CD
8691	1261	6	State	State	NNP
8691	1261	7	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1261	8	were	be	VBD
8691	1261	9	declared	declare	VBN
8691	1261	10	in	in	IN
8691	1261	11	whole	whole	JJ
8691	1261	12	or	or	CC
8691	1261	13	part	part	NN
8691	1261	14	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1261	15	by	by	IN
8691	1261	16	courts	court	NNS
8691	1261	17	of	of	IN
8691	1261	18	last	last	JJ
8691	1261	19	resort	resort	NN
8691	1261	20	.	.	.
8691	1262	1	Three	three	CD
8691	1262	2	of	of	IN
8691	1262	3	these	these	DT
8691	1262	4	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	1262	5	were	be	VBD
8691	1262	6	rendered	render	VBN
8691	1262	7	by	by	IN
8691	1262	8	the	the	DT
8691	1262	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1262	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1262	11	of	of	IN
8691	1262	12	the	the	DT
8691	1262	13	United	United	NNP
8691	1262	14	States	States	NNP
8691	1262	15	.	.	.
8691	1263	1	Five	five	CD
8691	1263	2	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1263	3	of	of	IN
8691	1263	4	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
8691	1263	5	and	and	CC
8691	1263	6	as	as	IN
8691	1263	7	many	many	JJ
8691	1263	8	of	of	IN
8691	1263	9	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
8691	1263	10	were	be	VBD
8691	1263	11	thus	thus	RB
8691	1263	12	set	set	VBN
8691	1263	13	aside	aside	RB
8691	1263	14	;	;	:
8691	1263	15	three	three	CD
8691	1263	16	each	each	DT
8691	1263	17	of	of	IN
8691	1263	18	California	California	NNP
8691	1263	19	,	,	,
8691	1263	20	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
8691	1263	21	and	and	CC
8691	1263	22	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	1263	23	;	;	:
8691	1263	24	two	two	CD
8691	1263	25	each	each	DT
8691	1263	26	of	of	IN
8691	1263	27	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	1263	28	,	,	,
8691	1263	29	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
8691	1263	30	,	,	,
8691	1263	31	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	1263	32	,	,	,
8691	1263	33	Montana	Montana	NNP
8691	1263	34	,	,	,
8691	1263	35	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
8691	1263	36	,	,	,
8691	1263	37	New	New	NNP
8691	1263	38	York	York	NNP
8691	1263	39	,	,	,
8691	1263	40	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
8691	1263	41	and	and	CC
8691	1263	42	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
8691	1263	43	,	,	,
8691	1263	44	and	and	CC
8691	1263	45	one	one	CD
8691	1263	46	each	each	DT
8691	1263	47	of	of	IN
8691	1263	48	those	those	DT
8691	1263	49	of	of	IN
8691	1263	50	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1263	51	,	,	,
8691	1263	52	Maine	Maine	NNP
8691	1263	53	,	,	,
8691	1263	54	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
8691	1263	55	,	,	,
8691	1263	56	Minnesota	Minnesota	NNP
8691	1263	57	,	,	,
8691	1263	58	New	New	NNP
8691	1263	59	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	1263	60	,	,	,
8691	1263	61	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1263	62	,	,	,
8691	1263	63	South	South	NNP
8691	1263	64	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	1263	65	,	,	,
8691	1263	66	South	South	NNP
8691	1263	67	Dakota	Dakota	NNP
8691	1263	68	,	,	,
8691	1263	69	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
8691	1263	70	,	,	,
8691	1263	71	Texas	Texas	NNP
8691	1263	72	,	,	,
8691	1263	73	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
8691	1263	74	,	,	,
8691	1263	75	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	1263	76	and	and	CC
8691	1263	77	West	West	NNP
8691	1263	78	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	1263	79	.	.	.
8691	1264	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1264	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1264	3	:	:	:
8691	1264	4	Bulletin	Bulletin	NNP
8691	1264	5	No	no	UH
8691	1264	6	.	.	.
8691	1265	1	86	86	CD
8691	1265	2	,	,	,
8691	1265	3	New	New	NNP
8691	1265	4	York	York	NNP
8691	1265	5	State	State	NNP
8691	1265	6	Library	Library	NNP
8691	1265	7	,	,	,
8691	1265	8	"	"	``
8691	1265	9	Comparative	Comparative	NNP
8691	1265	10	Summary	Summary	NNP
8691	1265	11	and	and	CC
8691	1265	12	Index	Index	NNP
8691	1265	13	of	of	IN
8691	1265	14	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
8691	1265	15	,	,	,
8691	1265	16	1903	1903	CD
8691	1265	17	,	,	,
8691	1265	18	"	"	``
8691	1265	19	273	273	CD
8691	1265	20	,	,	,
8691	1265	21	281	281	CD
8691	1265	22	.	.	.
8691	1265	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1266	1	On	on	IN
8691	1266	2	the	the	DT
8691	1266	3	average	average	NN
8691	1266	4	probably	probably	RB
8691	1266	5	as	as	RB
8691	1266	6	many	many	JJ
8691	1266	7	as	as	IN
8691	1266	8	one	one	CD
8691	1266	9	statute	statute	NN
8691	1266	10	out	out	IN
8691	1266	11	of	of	IN
8691	1266	12	every	every	DT
8691	1266	13	three	three	CD
8691	1266	14	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	1266	15	that	that	WDT
8691	1266	16	are	be	VBP
8691	1266	17	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	1266	18	from	from	IN
8691	1266	19	year	year	NN
8691	1266	20	to	to	IN
8691	1266	21	year	year	NN
8691	1266	22	are	be	VBP
8691	1266	23	thus	thus	RB
8691	1266	24	judicially	judicially	RB
8691	1266	25	annulled	annul	VBN
8691	1266	26	.	.	.
8691	1267	1	The	the	DT
8691	1267	2	declaration	declaration	NN
8691	1267	3	by	by	IN
8691	1267	4	a	a	DT
8691	1267	5	court	court	NN
8691	1267	6	that	that	IN
8691	1267	7	a	a	DT
8691	1267	8	statute	statute	NN
8691	1267	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1267	10	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1267	11	and	and	CC
8691	1267	12	void	void	JJ
8691	1267	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	1267	14	only	only	RB
8691	1267	15	a	a	DT
8691	1267	16	step	step	NN
8691	1267	17	in	in	IN
8691	1267	18	a	a	DT
8691	1267	19	cause	cause	NN
8691	1267	20	.	.	.
8691	1268	1	In	in	IN
8691	1268	2	the	the	DT
8691	1268	3	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1268	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1268	5	may	may	MD
8691	1268	6	not	not	RB
8691	1268	7	be	be	VB
8691	1268	8	found	find	VBN
8691	1268	9	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1268	10	or	or	CC
8691	1268	11	proper	proper	JJ
8691	1268	12	even	even	RB
8691	1268	13	to	to	TO
8691	1268	14	allude	allude	VB
8691	1268	15	to	to	IN
8691	1268	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1268	17	.	.	.
8691	1269	1	But	but	CC
8691	1269	2	the	the	DT
8691	1269	3	order	order	NN
8691	1269	4	of	of	IN
8691	1269	5	the	the	DT
8691	1269	6	court	court	NN
8691	1269	7	which	which	WDT
8691	1269	8	the	the	DT
8691	1269	9	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1269	10	contains	contain	NNS
8691	1269	11	must	must	MD
8691	1269	12	be	be	VB
8691	1269	13	executed	execute	VBN
8691	1269	14	precisely	precisely	RB
8691	1269	15	as	as	IN
8691	1269	16	if	if	IN
8691	1269	17	no	no	DT
8691	1269	18	such	such	JJ
8691	1269	19	statute	statute	NN
8691	1269	20	had	have	VBD
8691	1269	21	ever	ever	RB
8691	1269	22	been	be	VBN
8691	1269	23	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	1269	24	.	.	.
8691	1270	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1270	2	may	may	MD
8691	1270	3	,	,	,
8691	1270	4	in	in	IN
8691	1270	5	effect	effect	NN
8691	1270	6	,	,	,
8691	1270	7	be	be	VB
8691	1270	8	directed	direct	VBN
8691	1270	9	against	against	IN
8691	1270	10	the	the	DT
8691	1270	11	State	State	NNP
8691	1270	12	whose	whose	WP$
8691	1270	13	statute	statute	NN
8691	1270	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	1270	15	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	1270	16	void	void	JJ
8691	1270	17	if	if	IN
8691	1270	18	the	the	DT
8691	1270	19	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1270	20	complains	complain	VBZ
8691	1270	21	of	of	IN
8691	1270	22	action	action	NN
8691	1270	23	taken	take	VBN
8691	1270	24	under	under	IN
8691	1270	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1270	26	which	which	WDT
8691	1270	27	has	have	VBZ
8691	1270	28	deprived	deprive	VBN
8691	1270	29	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1270	30	of	of	IN
8691	1270	31	property	property	NN
8691	1270	32	and	and	CC
8691	1270	33	put	put	VBD
8691	1270	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1270	35	in	in	IN
8691	1270	36	the	the	DT
8691	1270	37	hands	hand	NNS
8691	1270	38	of	of	IN
8691	1270	39	public	public	JJ
8691	1270	40	officers	officer	NNS
8691	1270	41	,	,	,
8691	1270	42	or	or	CC
8691	1270	43	seeks	seek	VBZ
8691	1270	44	a	a	DT
8691	1270	45	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1270	46	to	to	TO
8691	1270	47	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	1270	48	a	a	DT
8691	1270	49	threatened	threaten	VBN
8691	1270	50	wrong	wrong	NN
8691	1270	51	.	.	.
8691	1271	1	The	the	DT
8691	1271	2	State	State	NNP
8691	1271	3	of	of	IN
8691	1271	4	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	1271	5	in	in	IN
8691	1271	6	1819	1819	CD
8691	1271	7	passed	pass	VBD
8691	1271	8	a	a	DT
8691	1271	9	statute	statute	NN
8691	1271	10	reciting	recite	VBG
8691	1271	11	that	that	IN
8691	1271	12	a	a	DT
8691	1271	13	branch	branch	NN
8691	1271	14	of	of	IN
8691	1271	15	the	the	DT
8691	1271	16	United	United	NNP
8691	1271	17	States	States	NNP
8691	1271	18	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	1271	19	was	be	VBD
8691	1271	20	transacting	transact	VBG
8691	1271	21	business	business	NN
8691	1271	22	there	there	RB
8691	1271	23	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	1271	24	to	to	IN
8691	1271	25	the	the	DT
8691	1271	26	law	law	NN
8691	1271	27	of	of	IN
8691	1271	28	the	the	DT
8691	1271	29	State	State	NNP
8691	1271	30	,	,	,
8691	1271	31	and	and	CC
8691	1271	32	imposing	impose	VBG
8691	1271	33	a	a	DT
8691	1271	34	tax	tax	NN
8691	1271	35	upon	upon	IN
8691	1271	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1271	37	,	,	,
8691	1271	38	in	in	IN
8691	1271	39	case	case	NN
8691	1271	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1271	41	continued	continue	VBD
8691	1271	42	to	to	TO
8691	1271	43	do	do	VB
8691	1271	44	so	so	RB
8691	1271	45	,	,	,
8691	1271	46	of	of	IN
8691	1271	47	$	$	$
8691	1271	48	50,000	50,000	CD
8691	1271	49	a	a	DT
8691	1271	50	year	year	NN
8691	1271	51	,	,	,
8691	1271	52	to	to	TO
8691	1271	53	be	be	VB
8691	1271	54	collected	collect	VBN
8691	1271	55	by	by	IN
8691	1271	56	the	the	DT
8691	1271	57	auditor	auditor	NN
8691	1271	58	and	and	CC
8691	1271	59	paid	pay	VBD
8691	1271	60	over	over	RP
8691	1271	61	to	to	IN
8691	1271	62	the	the	DT
8691	1271	63	treasurer	treasurer	NN
8691	1271	64	.	.	.
8691	1272	1	The	the	DT
8691	1272	2	auditor	auditor	NN
8691	1272	3	subsequently	subsequently	RB
8691	1272	4	sent	send	VBD
8691	1272	5	a	a	DT
8691	1272	6	man	man	NN
8691	1272	7	to	to	IN
8691	1272	8	the	the	DT
8691	1272	9	bank	bank	NN
8691	1272	10	who	who	WP
8691	1272	11	forcibly	forcibly	RB
8691	1272	12	seized	seize	VBD
8691	1272	13	and	and	CC
8691	1272	14	carried	carry	VBN
8691	1272	15	off	off	RP
8691	1272	16	$	$	$
8691	1272	17	98,000	98,000	CD
8691	1272	18	in	in	IN
8691	1272	19	specie	specie	NN
8691	1272	20	.	.	.
8691	1273	1	This	this	DT
8691	1273	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1273	3	given	give	VBN
8691	1273	4	to	to	IN
8691	1273	5	the	the	DT
8691	1273	6	State	State	NNP
8691	1273	7	treasurer	treasurer	NN
8691	1273	8	,	,	,
8691	1273	9	who	who	WP
8691	1273	10	kept	keep	VBD
8691	1273	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1273	12	in	in	IN
8691	1273	13	the	the	DT
8691	1273	14	treasury	treasury	NN
8691	1273	15	in	in	IN
8691	1273	16	a	a	DT
8691	1273	17	trunk	trunk	NN
8691	1273	18	by	by	IN
8691	1273	19	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1273	20	.	.	.
8691	1274	1	The	the	DT
8691	1274	2	bank	bank	NN
8691	1274	3	sued	sue	VBD
8691	1274	4	all	all	DT
8691	1274	5	three	three	CD
8691	1274	6	for	for	IN
8691	1274	7	the	the	DT
8691	1274	8	money	money	NN
8691	1274	9	in	in	IN
8691	1274	10	the	the	DT
8691	1274	11	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1274	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1274	13	,	,	,
8691	1274	14	setting	set	VBG
8691	1274	15	forth	forth	RP
8691	1274	16	all	all	PDT
8691	1274	17	these	these	DT
8691	1274	18	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1274	19	at	at	IN
8691	1274	20	length	length	NN
8691	1274	21	.	.	.
8691	1275	1	Judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1275	2	went	go	VBD
8691	1275	3	against	against	IN
8691	1275	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1275	5	and	and	CC
8691	1275	6	,	,	,
8691	1275	7	with	with	IN
8691	1275	8	a	a	DT
8691	1275	9	slight	slight	JJ
8691	1275	10	modification	modification	NN
8691	1275	11	,	,	,
8691	1275	12	was	be	VBD
8691	1275	13	affirmed	affirm	VBN
8691	1275	14	by	by	IN
8691	1275	15	the	the	DT
8691	1275	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1275	17	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1275	18	of	of	IN
8691	1275	19	the	the	DT
8691	1275	20	United	United	NNP
8691	1275	21	States	States	NNP
8691	1275	22	.	.	.
8691	1276	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1276	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1276	3	held	hold	VBN
8691	1276	4	by	by	IN
8691	1276	5	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1276	6	in	in	IN
8691	1276	7	giving	give	VBG
8691	1276	8	the	the	DT
8691	1276	9	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1276	10	that	that	IN
8691	1276	11	the	the	DT
8691	1276	12	statute	statute	NN
8691	1276	13	was	be	VBD
8691	1276	14	void	void	JJ
8691	1276	15	;	;	:
8691	1276	16	that	that	IN
8691	1276	17	the	the	DT
8691	1276	18	money	money	NN
8691	1276	19	had	have	VBD
8691	1276	20	never	never	RB
8691	1276	21	become	become	VBN
8691	1276	22	mingled	mingle	VBN
8691	1276	23	with	with	IN
8691	1276	24	the	the	DT
8691	1276	25	funds	fund	NNS
8691	1276	26	of	of	IN
8691	1276	27	the	the	DT
8691	1276	28	State	State	NNP
8691	1276	29	;	;	:
8691	1276	30	and	and	CC
8691	1276	31	that	that	IN
8691	1276	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1276	33	were	be	VBD
8691	1276	34	liable	liable	JJ
8691	1276	35	for	for	IN
8691	1276	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1276	37	precisely	precisely	RB
8691	1276	38	as	as	IN
8691	1276	39	if	if	IN
8691	1276	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1276	41	were	be	VBD
8691	1276	42	private	private	JJ
8691	1276	43	individuals	individual	NNS
8691	1276	44	who	who	WP
8691	1276	45	had	have	VBD
8691	1276	46	wrongfully	wrongfully	RB
8691	1276	47	seized	seize	VBN
8691	1276	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1276	49	.	.	.
8691	1277	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1277	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1277	3	:	:	:
8691	1277	4	Osborn	Osborn	NNP
8691	1277	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1277	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1277	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1277	8	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	1277	9	of	of	IN
8691	1277	10	the	the	DT
8691	1277	11	United	United	NNP
8691	1277	12	States	States	NNP
8691	1277	13	,	,	,
8691	1277	14	9	9	CD
8691	1277	15	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	1277	16	's	's	POS
8691	1277	17	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1277	18	,	,	,
8691	1277	19	738	738	CD
8691	1277	20	.	.	.
8691	1277	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1278	1	These	these	DT
8691	1278	2	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1278	3	awakened	awaken	VBD
8691	1278	4	great	great	JJ
8691	1278	5	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	1278	6	in	in	IN
8691	1278	7	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	1278	8	,	,	,
8691	1278	9	and	and	CC
8691	1278	10	became	become	VBD
8691	1278	11	the	the	DT
8691	1278	12	subject	subject	NN
8691	1278	13	of	of	IN
8691	1278	14	much	much	JJ
8691	1278	15	criticism	criticism	NN
8691	1278	16	throughout	throughout	IN
8691	1278	17	the	the	DT
8691	1278	18	country	country	NN
8691	1278	19	by	by	IN
8691	1278	20	those	those	DT
8691	1278	21	adhering	adhere	VBG
8691	1278	22	to	to	IN
8691	1278	23	the	the	DT
8691	1278	24	Democratic	democratic	JJ
8691	1278	25	party	party	NN
8691	1278	26	.	.	.
8691	1279	1	The	the	DT
8691	1279	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1279	3	of	of	IN
8691	1279	4	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	1279	5	adopted	adopt	VBD
8691	1279	6	resolutions	resolution	NNS
8691	1279	7	denouncing	denounce	VBG
8691	1279	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1279	9	as	as	IN
8691	1279	10	unauthorized	unauthorized	JJ
8691	1279	11	by	by	IN
8691	1279	12	the	the	DT
8691	1279	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1279	14	of	of	IN
8691	1279	15	the	the	DT
8691	1279	16	United	United	NNP
8691	1279	17	States	States	NNP
8691	1279	18	,	,	,
8691	1279	19	and	and	CC
8691	1279	20	directed	direct	VBD
8691	1279	21	the	the	DT
8691	1279	22	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1279	23	to	to	TO
8691	1279	24	forward	forward	VB
8691	1279	25	a	a	DT
8691	1279	26	copy	copy	NN
8691	1279	27	to	to	IN
8691	1279	28	the	the	DT
8691	1279	29	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1279	30	of	of	IN
8691	1279	31	every	every	DT
8691	1279	32	other	other	JJ
8691	1279	33	State	State	NNP
8691	1279	34	with	with	IN
8691	1279	35	a	a	DT
8691	1279	36	request	request	NN
8691	1279	37	for	for	IN
8691	1279	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1279	39	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1279	40	on	on	IN
8691	1279	41	the	the	DT
8691	1279	42	subject	subject	NN
8691	1279	43	.	.	.
8691	1280	1	The	the	DT
8691	1280	2	replies	reply	NNS
8691	1280	3	varied	vary	VBD
8691	1280	4	in	in	IN
8691	1280	5	tone	tone	NN
8691	1280	6	according	accord	VBG
8691	1280	7	to	to	IN
8691	1280	8	the	the	DT
8691	1280	9	political	political	JJ
8691	1280	10	predilections	predilection	NNS
8691	1280	11	of	of	IN
8691	1280	12	the	the	DT
8691	1280	13	party	party	NN
8691	1280	14	then	then	RB
8691	1280	15	in	in	IN
8691	1280	16	control	control	NN
8691	1280	17	of	of	IN
8691	1280	18	the	the	DT
8691	1280	19	State	State	NNP
8691	1280	20	addressed	address	VBD
8691	1280	21	.	.	.
8691	1281	1	Still	still	RB
8691	1281	2	closer	close	RBR
8691	1281	3	does	do	VBZ
8691	1281	4	a	a	DT
8691	1281	5	court	court	NN
8691	1281	6	come	come	VB
8691	1281	7	to	to	IN
8691	1281	8	collision	collision	NN
8691	1281	9	with	with	IN
8691	1281	10	the	the	DT
8691	1281	11	political	political	JJ
8691	1281	12	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1281	13	of	of	IN
8691	1281	14	the	the	DT
8691	1281	15	State	state	NN
8691	1281	16	when	when	WRB
8691	1281	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1281	18	commands	command	VBZ
8691	1281	19	a	a	DT
8691	1281	20	public	public	JJ
8691	1281	21	officer	officer	NN
8691	1281	22	to	to	TO
8691	1281	23	do	do	VB
8691	1281	24	something	something	NN
8691	1281	25	in	in	IN
8691	1281	26	violation	violation	NN
8691	1281	27	of	of	IN
8691	1281	28	a	a	DT
8691	1281	29	statute	statute	NN
8691	1281	30	which	which	WDT
8691	1281	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1281	32	pronounces	pronounce	VBZ
8691	1281	33	void	void	JJ
8691	1281	34	,	,	,
8691	1281	35	or	or	CC
8691	1281	36	not	not	RB
8691	1281	37	to	to	TO
8691	1281	38	do	do	VB
8691	1281	39	something	something	NN
8691	1281	40	which	which	WDT
8691	1281	41	such	such	JJ
8691	1281	42	a	a	DT
8691	1281	43	statute	statute	NN
8691	1281	44	requires	require	VBZ
8691	1281	45	.	.	.
8691	1282	1	A	a	DT
8691	1282	2	striking	striking	JJ
8691	1282	3	instance	instance	NN
8691	1282	4	of	of	IN
8691	1282	5	this	this	DT
8691	1282	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1282	7	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	1282	8	by	by	IN
8691	1282	9	the	the	DT
8691	1282	10	power	power	NN
8691	1282	11	to	to	TO
8691	1282	12	nullify	nullify	VB
8691	1282	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1282	14	gerrymanders	gerrymander	NNS
8691	1282	15	.	.	.
8691	1283	1	The	the	DT
8691	1283	2	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	1283	3	of	of	IN
8691	1283	4	almost	almost	RB
8691	1283	5	every	every	DT
8691	1283	6	State	state	NN
8691	1283	7	provide	provide	VBP
8691	1283	8	that	that	IN
8691	1283	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1283	10	shall	shall	MD
8691	1283	11	be	be	VB
8691	1283	12	districted	district	VBN
8691	1283	13	from	from	IN
8691	1283	14	time	time	NN
8691	1283	15	to	to	IN
8691	1283	16	time	time	NN
8691	1283	17	by	by	IN
8691	1283	18	the	the	DT
8691	1283	19	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1283	20	for	for	IN
8691	1283	21	the	the	DT
8691	1283	22	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1283	23	of	of	IN
8691	1283	24	electing	elect	VBG
8691	1283	25	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1283	26	officers	officer	NNS
8691	1283	27	or	or	CC
8691	1283	28	local	local	JJ
8691	1283	29	representatives	representative	NNS
8691	1283	30	,	,	,
8691	1283	31	and	and	CC
8691	1283	32	that	that	IN
8691	1283	33	this	this	DT
8691	1283	34	shall	shall	MD
8691	1283	35	be	be	VB
8691	1283	36	so	so	RB
8691	1283	37	done	do	VBN
8691	1283	38	as	as	IN
8691	1283	39	to	to	TO
8691	1283	40	make	make	VB
8691	1283	41	the	the	DT
8691	1283	42	districts	district	NNS
8691	1283	43	as	as	IN
8691	1283	44	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	1283	45	equal	equal	JJ
8691	1283	46	in	in	IN
8691	1283	47	population	population	NN
8691	1283	48	as	as	IN
8691	1283	49	conveniently	conveniently	RB
8691	1283	50	may	may	MD
8691	1283	51	be	be	VB
8691	1283	52	,	,	,
8691	1283	53	and	and	CC
8691	1283	54	composed	compose	VBN
8691	1283	55	of	of	IN
8691	1283	56	contiguous	contiguous	JJ
8691	1283	57	territory	territory	NN
8691	1283	58	.	.	.
8691	1284	1	If	if	IN
8691	1284	2	a	a	DT
8691	1284	3	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1284	4	undertakes	undertake	VBZ
8691	1284	5	to	to	TO
8691	1284	6	construct	construct	VB
8691	1284	7	districts	district	NNS
8691	1284	8	by	by	IN
8691	1284	9	any	any	DT
8691	1284	10	other	other	JJ
8691	1284	11	rule	rule	NN
8691	1284	12	,	,	,
8691	1284	13	the	the	DT
8691	1284	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	1284	15	can	can	MD
8691	1284	16	compel	compel	VB
8691	1284	17	those	those	DT
8691	1284	18	charged	charge	VBN
8691	1284	19	with	with	IN
8691	1284	20	the	the	DT
8691	1284	21	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	1284	22	of	of	IN
8691	1284	23	elections	election	NNS
8691	1284	24	to	to	TO
8691	1284	25	disregard	disregard	VB
8691	1284	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1284	27	and	and	CC
8691	1284	28	to	to	TO
8691	1284	29	hold	hold	VB
8691	1284	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1284	31	according	accord	VBG
8691	1284	32	to	to	IN
8691	1284	33	the	the	DT
8691	1284	34	districts	district	NNS
8691	1284	35	previously	previously	RB
8691	1284	36	established	establish	VBN
8691	1284	37	under	under	IN
8691	1284	38	the	the	DT
8691	1284	39	former	former	JJ
8691	1284	40	law	law	NN
8691	1284	41	.	.	.
8691	1285	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1285	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1285	3	:	:	:
8691	1285	4	State	State	NNP
8691	1285	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1285	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1285	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1285	8	Cunningham	Cunningham	NNP
8691	1285	9	,	,	,
8691	1285	10	83	83	CD
8691	1285	11	Wis.	Wisconsin	NNP
8691	1285	12	,	,	,
8691	1285	13	90	90	CD
8691	1285	14	;	;	SYM
8691	1285	15	53	53	CD
8691	1285	16	Northwestern	northwestern	JJ
8691	1285	17	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	1285	18	,	,	,
8691	1285	19	35	35	CD
8691	1285	20	;	;	:
8691	1285	21	17	17	CD
8691	1285	22	Lawyers	Lawyers	NNPS
8691	1285	23	'	'	POS
8691	1285	24	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1285	25	Annotated	annotate	VBD
8691	1285	26	,	,	,
8691	1285	27	145	145	CD
8691	1285	28	;	;	:
8691	1285	29	35	35	CD
8691	1285	30	American	American	NNP
8691	1285	31	State	State	NNP
8691	1285	32	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1285	33	,	,	,
8691	1285	34	29	29	CD
8691	1285	35	;	;	:
8691	1285	36	Board	Board	NNP
8691	1285	37	of	of	IN
8691	1285	38	Supervisors	Supervisors	NNPS
8691	1285	39	_	_	NNP
8691	1285	40	v.	v.	IN
8691	1285	41	_	_	NNP
8691	1285	42	Blacker	Blacker	NNP
8691	1285	43	,	,	,
8691	1285	44	92	92	CD
8691	1285	45	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
8691	1285	46	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1285	47	,	,	,
8691	1285	48	638	638	CD
8691	1285	49	;	;	:
8691	1285	50	52	52	CD
8691	1285	51	Northwestern	northwestern	JJ
8691	1285	52	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	1285	53	,	,	,
8691	1285	54	951	951	CD
8691	1285	55	;	;	:
8691	1285	56	16	16	CD
8691	1285	57	Lawyers	Lawyers	NNPS
8691	1285	58	'	'	POS
8691	1285	59	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1285	60	Annotated	annotate	VBD
8691	1285	61	,	,	,
8691	1285	62	432	432	CD
8691	1285	63	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
8691	1285	64	_	_	NNP
8691	1285	65	v.	v.	IN
8691	1285	66	_	_	NNP
8691	1285	67	State	State	NNP
8691	1285	68	152	152	CD
8691	1285	69	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
8691	1285	70	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1285	71	;	;	:
8691	1285	72	70	70	CD
8691	1285	73	Northeastern	northeastern	JJ
8691	1285	74	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	1285	75	,	,	,
8691	1285	76	980	980	CD
8691	1285	77	.	.	.
8691	1285	78	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1286	1	But	but	CC
8691	1286	2	however	however	RB
8691	1286	3	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1286	4	may	may	MD
8691	1286	5	be	be	VB
8691	1286	6	the	the	DT
8691	1286	7	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	1286	8	from	from	IN
8691	1286	9	the	the	DT
8691	1286	10	premises	premise	NNS
8691	1286	11	,	,	,
8691	1286	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1286	13	can	can	MD
8691	1286	14	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	1286	15	be	be	VB
8691	1286	16	agreeable	agreeable	JJ
8691	1286	17	to	to	IN
8691	1286	18	the	the	DT
8691	1286	19	authors	author	NNS
8691	1286	20	of	of	IN
8691	1286	21	a	a	DT
8691	1286	22	law	law	NN
8691	1286	23	which	which	WDT
8691	1286	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1286	25	serves	serve	VBZ
8691	1286	26	to	to	TO
8691	1286	27	destroy	destroy	VB
8691	1286	28	.	.	.
8691	1287	1	In	in	IN
8691	1287	2	effect	effect	NN
8691	1287	3	,	,	,
8691	1287	4	though	though	IN
8691	1287	5	not	not	RB
8691	1287	6	in	in	IN
8691	1287	7	theory	theory	NN
8691	1287	8	,	,	,
8691	1287	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1287	10	subordinates	subordinate	VBZ
8691	1287	11	one	one	CD
8691	1287	12	department	department	NN
8691	1287	13	of	of	IN
8691	1287	14	government	government	NN
8691	1287	15	to	to	IN
8691	1287	16	another	another	DT
8691	1287	17	.	.	.
8691	1288	1	The	the	DT
8691	1288	2	practical	practical	JJ
8691	1288	3	result	result	NN
8691	1288	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1288	5	to	to	TO
8691	1288	6	give	give	VB
8691	1288	7	the	the	DT
8691	1288	8	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	1288	9	a	a	DT
8691	1288	10	superior	superior	JJ
8691	1288	11	power	power	NN
8691	1288	12	to	to	IN
8691	1288	13	the	the	DT
8691	1288	14	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1288	15	in	in	IN
8691	1288	16	determining	determine	VBG
8691	1288	17	what	what	WP
8691	1288	18	laws	law	NNS
8691	1288	19	the	the	DT
8691	1288	20	latter	latter	JJ
8691	1288	21	can	can	MD
8691	1288	22	enact	enact	VB
8691	1288	23	.	.	.
8691	1289	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1289	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1289	3	not	not	RB
8691	1289	4	a	a	DT
8691	1289	5	right	right	NN
8691	1289	6	of	of	IN
8691	1289	7	veto	veto	NN
8691	1289	8	,	,	,
8691	1289	9	but	but	CC
8691	1289	10	in	in	IN
8691	1289	11	a	a	DT
8691	1289	12	case	case	NN
8691	1289	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1289	14	calls	call	VBZ
8691	1289	15	for	for	IN
8691	1289	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1289	17	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	1289	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1289	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	1289	20	an	an	DT
8691	1289	21	equal	equal	JJ
8691	1289	22	right	right	NN
8691	1289	23	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	1289	24	in	in	IN
8691	1289	25	a	a	DT
8691	1289	26	different	different	JJ
8691	1289	27	way	way	NN
8691	1289	28	.	.	.
8691	1290	1	In	in	IN
8691	1290	2	the	the	DT
8691	1290	3	first	first	JJ
8691	1290	4	instance	instance	NN
8691	1290	5	of	of	IN
8691	1290	6	a	a	DT
8691	1290	7	resort	resort	NN
8691	1290	8	to	to	IN
8691	1290	9	it[Footnote	it[footnote	NN
8691	1290	10	:	:	:
8691	1290	11	See	see	VB
8691	1290	12	p.	p.	NN
8691	1291	1	100	100	CD
8691	1291	2	.	.	.
8691	1291	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1292	1	the	the	DT
8691	1292	2	section	section	NN
8691	1292	3	of	of	IN
8691	1292	4	the	the	DT
8691	1292	5	New	New	NNP
8691	1292	6	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	1292	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1292	8	of	of	IN
8691	1292	9	1776	1776	CD
8691	1292	10	confirming	confirm	VBG
8691	1292	11	the	the	DT
8691	1292	12	right	right	NN
8691	1292	13	of	of	IN
8691	1292	14	trial	trial	NN
8691	1292	15	by	by	IN
8691	1292	16	jury	jury	NN
8691	1292	17	was	be	VBD
8691	1292	18	held	hold	VBN
8691	1292	19	by	by	IN
8691	1292	20	the	the	DT
8691	1292	21	full	full	JJ
8691	1292	22	bench	bench	NN
8691	1292	23	of	of	IN
8691	1292	24	the	the	DT
8691	1292	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1292	26	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1292	27	to	to	TO
8691	1292	28	render	render	VB
8691	1292	29	a	a	DT
8691	1292	30	statute	statute	NN
8691	1292	31	void	void	NN
8691	1292	32	which	which	WDT
8691	1292	33	authorized	authorize	VBD
8691	1292	34	a	a	DT
8691	1292	35	trial	trial	NN
8691	1292	36	without	without	IN
8691	1292	37	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1292	38	before	before	IN
8691	1292	39	a	a	DT
8691	1292	40	jury	jury	NN
8691	1292	41	of	of	IN
8691	1292	42	six	six	CD
8691	1292	43	,	,	,
8691	1292	44	on	on	IN
8691	1292	45	a	a	DT
8691	1292	46	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1292	47	for	for	IN
8691	1292	48	the	the	DT
8691	1292	49	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
8691	1292	50	of	of	IN
8691	1292	51	goods	good	NNS
8691	1292	52	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1292	53	in	in	RP
8691	1292	54	from	from	IN
8691	1292	55	British	british	JJ
8691	1292	56	territory	territory	NN
8691	1292	57	or	or	CC
8691	1292	58	the	the	DT
8691	1292	59	British	british	JJ
8691	1292	60	military	military	JJ
8691	1292	61	lines	line	NNS
8691	1292	62	.	.	.
8691	1293	1	This	this	DT
8691	1293	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1293	3	an	an	DT
8691	1293	4	unwelcome	unwelcome	JJ
8691	1293	5	decision	decision	NN
8691	1293	6	to	to	IN
8691	1293	7	many	many	JJ
8691	1293	8	who	who	WP
8691	1293	9	were	be	VBD
8691	1293	10	interested	interested	JJ
8691	1293	11	in	in	IN
8691	1293	12	such	such	JJ
8691	1293	13	seizures	seizure	NNS
8691	1293	14	,	,	,
8691	1293	15	and	and	CC
8691	1293	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1293	17	sent	send	VBD
8691	1293	18	in	in	IN
8691	1293	19	several	several	JJ
8691	1293	20	petitions	petition	NNS
8691	1293	21	to	to	IN
8691	1293	22	the	the	DT
8691	1293	23	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1293	24	for	for	IN
8691	1293	25	redress	redress	NN
8691	1293	26	.	.	.
8691	1294	1	No	no	DT
8691	1294	2	action	action	NN
8691	1294	3	criticising	criticise	VBG
8691	1294	4	the	the	DT
8691	1294	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1294	6	,	,	,
8691	1294	7	however	however	RB
8691	1294	8	,	,	,
8691	1294	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1294	10	taken	take	VBN
8691	1294	11	by	by	IN
8691	1294	12	that	that	DT
8691	1294	13	body	body	NN
8691	1294	14	.	.	.
8691	1295	1	Four	four	CD
8691	1295	2	years	year	NNS
8691	1295	3	later	later	RB
8691	1295	4	the	the	DT
8691	1295	5	Mayor	Mayor	NNP
8691	1295	6	's	's	POS
8691	1295	7	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1295	8	of	of	IN
8691	1295	9	New	New	NNP
8691	1295	10	York	York	NNP
8691	1295	11	,	,	,
8691	1295	12	in	in	IN
8691	1295	13	the	the	DT
8691	1295	14	case	case	NN
8691	1295	15	of	of	IN
8691	1295	16	Rutgers	Rutgers	NNP
8691	1295	17	_	_	NNP
8691	1295	18	v.	v.	IN
8691	1295	19	_	_	NNP
8691	1295	20	Waddington	Waddington	NNP
8691	1295	21	,	,	,
8691	1295	22	held	hold	VBD
8691	1295	23	that	that	IN
8691	1295	24	an	an	DT
8691	1295	25	act	act	NN
8691	1295	26	of	of	IN
8691	1295	27	the	the	DT
8691	1295	28	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1295	29	of	of	IN
8691	1295	30	that	that	DT
8691	1295	31	State	State	NNP
8691	1295	32	,	,	,
8691	1295	33	if	if	IN
8691	1295	34	given	give	VBN
8691	1295	35	the	the	DT
8691	1295	36	effect	effect	NN
8691	1295	37	which	which	WDT
8691	1295	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1295	39	was	be	VBD
8691	1295	40	plainly	plainly	RB
8691	1295	41	intended	intend	VBN
8691	1295	42	to	to	TO
8691	1295	43	secure	secure	VB
8691	1295	44	,	,	,
8691	1295	45	would	would	MD
8691	1295	46	be	be	VB
8691	1295	47	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	1295	48	to	to	IN
8691	1295	49	the	the	DT
8691	1295	50	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1295	51	of	of	IN
8691	1295	52	the	the	DT
8691	1295	53	State	State	NNP
8691	1295	54	,	,	,
8691	1295	55	and	and	CC
8691	1295	56	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1295	57	allowed	allow	VBD
8691	1295	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1295	59	so	so	RB
8691	1295	60	limited	limit	VBD
8691	1295	61	an	an	DT
8691	1295	62	operation	operation	NN
8691	1295	63	as	as	IN
8691	1295	64	virtually	virtually	RB
8691	1295	65	to	to	TO
8691	1295	66	annul	annul	VB
8691	1295	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1295	68	.	.	.
8691	1296	1	The	the	DT
8691	1296	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1296	3	retorted	retort	VBN
8691	1296	4	by	by	IN
8691	1296	5	resolutions	resolution	NNS
8691	1296	6	of	of	IN
8691	1296	7	censure	censure	NN
8691	1296	8	.	.	.
8691	1297	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1297	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1297	3	:	:	:
8691	1297	4	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
8691	1297	5	,	,	,
8691	1297	6	"	"	''
8691	1297	7	Life	Life	NNP
8691	1297	8	of	of	IN
8691	1297	9	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	1297	10	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
8691	1297	11	,	,	,
8691	1297	12	"	"	``
8691	1297	13	49	49	CD
8691	1297	14	-	-	SYM
8691	1297	15	51	51	CD
8691	1297	16	.	.	.
8691	1297	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1298	1	What	what	WP
8691	1298	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1298	3	probably	probably	RB
8691	1298	4	the	the	DT
8691	1298	5	second	second	JJ
8691	1298	6	instance	instance	NN
8691	1298	7	of	of	IN
8691	1298	8	the	the	DT
8691	1298	9	actual	actual	JJ
8691	1298	10	use	use	NN
8691	1298	11	of	of	IN
8691	1298	12	the	the	DT
8691	1298	13	power	power	NN
8691	1298	14	in	in	IN
8691	1298	15	question	question	NN
8691	1298	16	arose	arise	VBD
8691	1298	17	in	in	IN
8691	1298	18	1786	1786	CD
8691	1298	19	,	,	,
8691	1298	20	out	out	IN
8691	1298	21	of	of	IN
8691	1298	22	a	a	DT
8691	1298	23	statute	statute	NN
8691	1298	24	of	of	IN
8691	1298	25	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	1298	26	Island	Island	NNP
8691	1298	27	passed	pass	VBD
8691	1298	28	to	to	TO
8691	1298	29	support	support	VB
8691	1298	30	the	the	DT
8691	1298	31	credit	credit	NN
8691	1298	32	of	of	IN
8691	1298	33	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1298	34	paper	paper	NN
8691	1298	35	money	money	NN
8691	1298	36	of	of	IN
8691	1298	37	that	that	DT
8691	1298	38	year	year	NN
8691	1298	39	's	's	POS
8691	1298	40	issue	issue	NN
8691	1298	41	.	.	.
8691	1299	1	Any	any	DT
8691	1299	2	one	one	NN
8691	1299	3	declining	decline	VBG
8691	1299	4	to	to	TO
8691	1299	5	receive	receive	VB
8691	1299	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1299	7	in	in	IN
8691	1299	8	payment	payment	NN
8691	1299	9	for	for	IN
8691	1299	10	goods	good	NNS
8691	1299	11	sold	sell	VBN
8691	1299	12	at	at	IN
8691	1299	13	par	par	NN
8691	1299	14	was	be	VBD
8691	1299	15	to	to	TO
8691	1299	16	be	be	VB
8691	1299	17	liable	liable	JJ
8691	1299	18	to	to	IN
8691	1299	19	a	a	DT
8691	1299	20	_	_	NNP
8691	1299	21	qui	qui	NN
8691	1299	22	tum	tum	NN
8691	1299	23	_	_	NNP
8691	1299	24	action	action	NN
8691	1299	25	,	,	,
8691	1299	26	to	to	TO
8691	1299	27	be	be	VB
8691	1299	28	tried	try	VBN
8691	1299	29	without	without	IN
8691	1299	30	a	a	DT
8691	1299	31	jury	jury	NN
8691	1299	32	.	.	.
8691	1300	1	Counsel	counsel	NN
8691	1300	2	for	for	IN
8691	1300	3	a	a	DT
8691	1300	4	man	man	NN
8691	1300	5	sued	sue	VBN
8691	1300	6	in	in	IN
8691	1300	7	such	such	PDT
8691	1300	8	a	a	DT
8691	1300	9	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1300	10	put	put	VBN
8691	1300	11	in	in	IN
8691	1300	12	a	a	DT
8691	1300	13	plea	plea	NN
8691	1300	14	that	that	WDT
8691	1300	15	the	the	DT
8691	1300	16	act	act	NN
8691	1300	17	was	be	VBD
8691	1300	18	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1300	19	and	and	CC
8691	1300	20	so	so	RB
8691	1300	21	void	void	JJ
8691	1300	22	.	.	.
8691	1301	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1301	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1301	3	:	:	:
8691	1301	4	Trevett	Trevett	NNP
8691	1301	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1301	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1301	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1301	8	Weeden	Weeden	NNP
8691	1301	9	.	.	.
8691	1302	1	See	see	VB
8691	1302	2	Coxe	Coxe	NNP
8691	1302	3	,	,	,
8691	1302	4	"	"	''
8691	1302	5	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	1302	6	Power	Power	NNP
8691	1302	7	and	and	CC
8691	1302	8	Unconstitutional	Unconstitutional	NNP
8691	1302	9	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
8691	1302	10	,	,	,
8691	1302	11	"	"	''
8691	1302	12	234	234	CD
8691	1302	13	,	,	,
8691	1302	14	237	237	CD
8691	1302	15	.	.	.
8691	1302	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1303	1	The	the	DT
8691	1303	2	court	court	NN
8691	1303	3	,	,	,
8691	1303	4	which	which	WDT
8691	1303	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1303	6	composed	compose	VBN
8691	1303	7	of	of	IN
8691	1303	8	five	five	CD
8691	1303	9	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1303	10	,	,	,
8691	1303	11	threw	throw	VBD
8691	1303	12	out	out	RP
8691	1303	13	the	the	DT
8691	1303	14	action	action	NN
8691	1303	15	on	on	IN
8691	1303	16	this	this	DT
8691	1303	17	ground	ground	NN
8691	1303	18	,	,	,
8691	1303	19	treating	treat	VBG
8691	1303	20	the	the	DT
8691	1303	21	charter	charter	NN
8691	1303	22	from	from	IN
8691	1303	23	Charles	Charles	NNP
8691	1303	24	II	II	NNP
8691	1303	25	and	and	CC
8691	1303	26	the	the	DT
8691	1303	27	long	long	JJ
8691	1303	28	usage	usage	NN
8691	1303	29	under	under	IN
8691	1303	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1303	31	as	as	IN
8691	1303	32	having	have	VBG
8691	1303	33	established	establish	VBN
8691	1303	34	trial	trial	NN
8691	1303	35	by	by	IN
8691	1303	36	jury	jury	NN
8691	1303	37	as	as	IN
8691	1303	38	a	a	DT
8691	1303	39	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	1303	40	and	and	CC
8691	1303	41	indefeasible	indefeasible	JJ
8691	1303	42	right	right	NN
8691	1303	43	.	.	.
8691	1304	1	The	the	DT
8691	1304	2	General	General	NNP
8691	1304	3	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	1304	4	shortly	shortly	RB
8691	1304	5	afterward	afterward	RB
8691	1304	6	summoned	summon	VBD
8691	1304	7	the	the	DT
8691	1304	8	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1304	9	before	before	IN
8691	1304	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1304	11	to	to	TO
8691	1304	12	account	account	VB
8691	1304	13	for	for	IN
8691	1304	14	this	this	DT
8691	1304	15	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1304	16	.	.	.
8691	1305	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1305	2	appeared	appear	VBD
8691	1305	3	and	and	CC
8691	1305	4	stated	state	VBD
8691	1305	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1305	6	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	1305	7	for	for	IN
8691	1305	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1305	9	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	1305	10	,	,	,
8691	1305	11	protesting	protest	VBG
8691	1305	12	also	also	RB
8691	1305	13	against	against	IN
8691	1305	14	the	the	DT
8691	1305	15	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	1305	16	of	of	IN
8691	1305	17	any	any	DT
8691	1305	18	resolution	resolution	NN
8691	1305	19	for	for	IN
8691	1305	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1305	21	removal	removal	NN
8691	1305	22	from	from	IN
8691	1305	23	office	office	NN
8691	1305	24	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1305	25	which	which	WDT
8691	1305	26	had	have	VBD
8691	1305	27	been	be	VBN
8691	1305	28	suggested	suggest	VBN
8691	1305	29	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1305	30	until	until	IN
8691	1305	31	after	after	IN
8691	1305	32	a	a	DT
8691	1305	33	formal	formal	JJ
8691	1305	34	trial	trial	NN
8691	1305	35	.	.	.
8691	1306	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1306	2	were	be	VBD
8691	1306	3	not	not	RB
8691	1306	4	impeached	impeach	VBN
8691	1306	5	,	,	,
8691	1306	6	but	but	CC
8691	1306	7	at	at	IN
8691	1306	8	the	the	DT
8691	1306	9	ensuing	ensue	VBG
8691	1306	10	session	session	NN
8691	1306	11	,	,	,
8691	1306	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1306	13	terms	term	NNS
8691	1306	14	of	of	IN
8691	1306	15	office	office	NN
8691	1306	16	having	have	VBG
8691	1306	17	expired	expire	VBN
8691	1306	18	,	,	,
8691	1306	19	the	the	DT
8691	1306	20	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	1306	21	chose	choose	VBD
8691	1306	22	others	other	NNS
8691	1306	23	in	in	IN
8691	1306	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1306	25	place	place	NN
8691	1306	26	.	.	.
8691	1307	1	Not	not	RB
8691	1307	2	far	far	RB
8691	1307	3	from	from	IN
8691	1307	4	the	the	DT
8691	1307	5	same	same	JJ
8691	1307	6	time	time	NN
8691	1307	7	the	the	DT
8691	1307	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1307	9	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	1307	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1307	11	of	of	IN
8691	1307	12	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	1307	13	pronounced	pronounce	VBD
8691	1307	14	a	a	DT
8691	1307	15	statute	statute	NN
8691	1307	16	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1307	17	,	,	,
8691	1307	18	but	but	CC
8691	1307	19	there	there	RB
8691	1307	20	the	the	DT
8691	1307	21	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1307	22	displayed	display	VBD
8691	1307	23	no	no	DT
8691	1307	24	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	1307	25	,	,	,
8691	1307	26	and	and	CC
8691	1307	27	at	at	IN
8691	1307	28	the	the	DT
8691	1307	29	next	next	JJ
8691	1307	30	session	session	NN
8691	1307	31	unanimously	unanimously	RB
8691	1307	32	repealed	repeal	VBD
8691	1307	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1307	34	.	.	.
8691	1308	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1308	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1308	3	:	:	:
8691	1308	4	This	this	DT
8691	1308	5	,	,	,
8691	1308	6	no	no	RB
8691	1308	7	doubt	doubt	RB
8691	1308	8	,	,	,
8691	1308	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1308	10	one	one	CD
8691	1308	11	of	of	IN
8691	1308	12	the	the	DT
8691	1308	13	instances	instance	NNS
8691	1308	14	of	of	IN
8691	1308	15	the	the	DT
8691	1308	16	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	1308	17	of	of	IN
8691	1308	18	this	this	DT
8691	1308	19	power	power	NN
8691	1308	20	referred	refer	VBN
8691	1308	21	to	to	IN
8691	1308	22	by	by	IN
8691	1308	23	Elbridge	Elbridge	NNP
8691	1308	24	Gerry	Gerry	NNP
8691	1308	25	in	in	IN
8691	1308	26	the	the	DT
8691	1308	27	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	1308	28	Convention	Convention	NNP
8691	1308	29	of	of	IN
8691	1308	30	1787	1787	CD
8691	1308	31	.	.	.
8691	1309	1	Elliot	Elliot	NNP
8691	1309	2	's	's	POS
8691	1309	3	Debates	debate	NNS
8691	1309	4	,	,	,
8691	1309	5	V	V	NNP
8691	1309	6	,	,	,
8691	1309	7	151	151	CD
8691	1309	8	.	.	.
8691	1310	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1310	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1310	3	described	describe	VBN
8691	1310	4	in	in	IN
8691	1310	5	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
8691	1310	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	1310	7	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1310	8	Society	Society	NNP
8691	1310	9	,	,	,
8691	1310	10	XVII	XVII	NNP
8691	1310	11	,	,	,
8691	1310	12	507	507	CD
8691	1310	13	.	.	.
8691	1310	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1311	1	In	in	IN
8691	1311	2	1808	1808	CD
8691	1311	3	,	,	,
8691	1311	4	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	1311	5	Calvin	Calvin	NNP
8691	1311	6	Pease	Pease	NNP
8691	1311	7	of	of	IN
8691	1311	8	the	the	DT
8691	1311	9	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	1311	10	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1311	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1311	12	was	be	VBD
8691	1311	13	impeached	impeach	VBN
8691	1311	14	for	for	IN
8691	1311	15	holding	hold	VBG
8691	1311	16	a	a	DT
8691	1311	17	law	law	NN
8691	1311	18	of	of	IN
8691	1311	19	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	1311	20	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1311	21	.	.	.
8691	1312	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1312	2	avowed	avow	VBD
8691	1312	3	the	the	DT
8691	1312	4	act	act	NN
8691	1312	5	,	,	,
8691	1312	6	and	and	CC
8691	1312	7	insisted	insist	VBD
8691	1312	8	that	that	IN
8691	1312	9	as	as	IN
8691	1312	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1312	11	was	be	VBD
8691	1312	12	a	a	DT
8691	1312	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1312	14	one	one	NN
8691	1312	15	the	the	DT
8691	1312	16	soundness	soundness	NN
8691	1312	17	or	or	CC
8691	1312	18	unsoundness	unsoundness	NN
8691	1312	19	of	of	IN
8691	1312	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1312	21	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	1312	22	could	could	MD
8691	1312	23	not	not	RB
8691	1312	24	be	be	VB
8691	1312	25	inquired	inquire	VBN
8691	1312	26	into	into	IN
8691	1312	27	as	as	IN
8691	1312	28	a	a	DT
8691	1312	29	ground	ground	NN
8691	1312	30	of	of	IN
8691	1312	31	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	1312	32	.	.	.
8691	1313	1	The	the	DT
8691	1313	2	result	result	NN
8691	1313	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1313	4	an	an	DT
8691	1313	5	acquittal	acquittal	NN
8691	1313	6	.	.	.
8691	1314	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1314	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1314	3	:	:	:
8691	1314	4	Foster	Foster	NNP
8691	1314	5	,	,	,
8691	1314	6	"	"	''
8691	1314	7	Commentaries	commentary	NNS
8691	1314	8	on	on	IN
8691	1314	9	the	the	DT
8691	1314	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1314	11	of	of	IN
8691	1314	12	the	the	DT
8691	1314	13	United	United	NNP
8691	1314	14	States	States	NNP
8691	1314	15	,	,	,
8691	1314	16	"	"	``
8691	1314	17	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1314	18	,	,	,
8691	1314	19	691	691	CD
8691	1314	20	.	.	.
8691	1314	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1315	1	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1315	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1315	3	the	the	DT
8691	1315	4	only	only	JJ
8691	1315	5	one	one	CD
8691	1315	6	of	of	IN
8691	1315	7	the	the	DT
8691	1315	8	original	original	JJ
8691	1315	9	States	state	NNS
8691	1315	10	which	which	WDT
8691	1315	11	set	set	VBD
8691	1315	12	up	up	RP
8691	1315	13	no	no	DT
8691	1315	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1315	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1315	16	at	at	IN
8691	1315	17	the	the	DT
8691	1315	18	beginning	beginning	NN
8691	1315	19	of	of	IN
8691	1315	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1315	21	statehood	statehood	NN
8691	1315	22	.	.	.
8691	1316	1	Her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1316	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1316	3	established	establish	VBD
8691	1316	4	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1316	5	Art	art	NN
8691	1316	6	.	.	.
8691	1317	1	III	III	NNP
8691	1317	2	,	,	,
8691	1317	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	1317	4	.	.	.
8691	1318	1	1	1	LS
8691	1318	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1318	3	a	a	DT
8691	1318	4	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	1318	5	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1318	6	,	,	,
8691	1318	7	and	and	CC
8691	1318	8	left	leave	VBD
8691	1318	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1318	10	to	to	IN
8691	1318	11	the	the	DT
8691	1318	12	General	General	NNP
8691	1318	13	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	1318	14	to	to	TO
8691	1318	15	give	give	VB
8691	1318	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1318	17	,	,	,
8691	1318	18	if	if	IN
8691	1318	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1318	20	thought	think	VBD
8691	1318	21	best	well	RBS
8691	1318	22	,	,	,
8691	1318	23	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	1318	24	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1318	25	.	.	.
8691	1319	1	The	the	DT
8691	1319	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1319	3	were	be	VBD
8691	1319	4	subsequently	subsequently	RB
8691	1319	5	by	by	IN
8691	1319	6	statute	statute	NN
8691	1319	7	authorized	authorize	VBN
8691	1319	8	to	to	TO
8691	1319	9	sit	sit	VB
8691	1319	10	_	_	NNP
8691	1319	11	in	in	IN
8691	1319	12	banc	banc	NNP
8691	1319	13	_	_	NNP
8691	1319	14	and	and	CC
8691	1319	15	hear	hear	VB
8691	1319	16	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	1319	17	.	.	.
8691	1320	1	In	in	IN
8691	1320	2	1815	1815	CD
8691	1320	3	,	,	,
8691	1320	4	while	while	IN
8691	1320	5	so	so	RB
8691	1320	6	sitting	sit	VBG
8691	1320	7	,	,	,
8691	1320	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1320	9	declared	declare	VBD
8691	1320	10	a	a	DT
8691	1320	11	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1320	12	statute	statute	NN
8691	1320	13	of	of	IN
8691	1320	14	the	the	DT
8691	1320	15	State	State	NNP
8691	1320	16	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1320	17	and	and	CC
8691	1320	18	void	void	JJ
8691	1320	19	.	.	.
8691	1321	1	The	the	DT
8691	1321	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1321	3	showed	show	VBD
8691	1321	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1321	5	resentment	resentment	NN
8691	1321	6	by	by	IN
8691	1321	7	a	a	DT
8691	1321	8	set	set	NN
8691	1321	9	of	of	IN
8691	1321	10	resolutions	resolution	NNS
8691	1321	11	,	,	,
8691	1321	12	of	of	IN
8691	1321	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1321	14	the	the	DT
8691	1321	15	parts	part	NNS
8691	1321	16	material	material	NN
8691	1321	17	in	in	IN
8691	1321	18	this	this	DT
8691	1321	19	connection	connection	NN
8691	1321	20	read	read	VB
8691	1321	21	thus	thus	RB
8691	1321	22	:	:	:
8691	1321	23	Whereas	whereas	IN
8691	1321	24	,	,	,
8691	1321	25	John	John	NNP
8691	1321	26	McPherson	McPherson	NNP
8691	1321	27	Berrien	Berrien	NNP
8691	1321	28	,	,	,
8691	1321	29	Robert	Robert	NNP
8691	1321	30	Walker	Walker	NNP
8691	1321	31	,	,	,
8691	1321	32	Young	Young	NNP
8691	1321	33	Gresham	Gresham	NNP
8691	1321	34	and	and	CC
8691	1321	35	Stephen	Stephen	NNP
8691	1321	36	W.	W.	NNP
8691	1321	37	Harris	Harris	NNP
8691	1321	38	,	,	,
8691	1321	39	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1321	40	of	of	IN
8691	1321	41	the	the	DT
8691	1321	42	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	1321	43	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1321	44	,	,	,
8691	1321	45	did	do	VBD
8691	1321	46	,	,	,
8691	1321	47	on	on	IN
8691	1321	48	the	the	DT
8691	1321	49	13th	13th	JJ
8691	1321	50	day	day	NN
8691	1321	51	of	of	IN
8691	1321	52	January	January	NNP
8691	1321	53	,	,	,
8691	1321	54	1815	1815	CD
8691	1321	55	,	,	,
8691	1321	56	assemble	assemble	VB
8691	1321	57	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1321	58	together	together	RB
8691	1321	59	in	in	IN
8691	1321	60	the	the	DT
8691	1321	61	city	city	NN
8691	1321	62	of	of	IN
8691	1321	63	Augusta	Augusta	NNP
8691	1321	64	,	,	,
8691	1321	65	pretending	pretend	VBG
8691	1321	66	to	to	TO
8691	1321	67	be	be	VB
8691	1321	68	in	in	IN
8691	1321	69	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1321	70	convention	convention	NN
8691	1321	71	,	,	,
8691	1321	72	and	and	CC
8691	1321	73	assuming	assume	VBG
8691	1321	74	to	to	IN
8691	1321	75	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1321	76	...	...	NFP
8691	1321	77	the	the	DT
8691	1321	78	power	power	NN
8691	1321	79	to	to	TO
8691	1321	80	determine	determine	VB
8691	1321	81	on	on	IN
8691	1321	82	the	the	DT
8691	1321	83	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	1321	84	of	of	IN
8691	1321	85	laws	law	NNS
8691	1321	86	passed	pass	VBN
8691	1321	87	by	by	IN
8691	1321	88	the	the	DT
8691	1321	89	general	general	NNP
8691	1321	90	assembly	assembly	NNP
8691	1321	91	,	,	,
8691	1321	92	and	and	CC
8691	1321	93	did	do	VBD
8691	1321	94	declare	declare	VB
8691	1321	95	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1321	96	acts	act	NNS
8691	1321	97	of	of	IN
8691	1321	98	the	the	DT
8691	1321	99	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1321	100	to	to	TO
8691	1321	101	be	be	VB
8691	1321	102	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1321	103	and	and	CC
8691	1321	104	void	void	JJ
8691	1321	105	;	;	,
8691	1321	106	and	and	CC
8691	1321	107	...	...	:
8691	1321	108	the	the	DT
8691	1321	109	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
8691	1321	110	power	power	NN
8691	1321	111	of	of	IN
8691	1321	112	determining	determine	VBG
8691	1321	113	upon	upon	IN
8691	1321	114	the	the	DT
8691	1321	115	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	1321	116	of	of	IN
8691	1321	117	acts	act	NNS
8691	1321	118	of	of	IN
8691	1321	119	the	the	DT
8691	1321	120	state	state	NN
8691	1321	121	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1321	122	,	,	,
8691	1321	123	if	if	IN
8691	1321	124	yielded	yield	VBN
8691	1321	125	by	by	IN
8691	1321	126	the	the	DT
8691	1321	127	general	general	NNP
8691	1321	128	assembly	assembly	NNP
8691	1321	129	whilst	whilst	IN
8691	1321	130	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1321	131	is	be	VBZ
8691	1321	132	not	not	RB
8691	1321	133	given	give	VBN
8691	1321	134	by	by	IN
8691	1321	135	the	the	DT
8691	1321	136	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	1321	137	or	or	CC
8691	1321	138	laws	law	NNS
8691	1321	139	of	of	IN
8691	1321	140	the	the	DT
8691	1321	141	state	state	NN
8691	1321	142	,	,	,
8691	1321	143	would	would	MD
8691	1321	144	be	be	VB
8691	1321	145	an	an	DT
8691	1321	146	abandonment	abandonment	NN
8691	1321	147	of	of	IN
8691	1321	148	the	the	DT
8691	1321	149	dearest	dear	JJS
8691	1321	150	rights	right	NNS
8691	1321	151	and	and	CC
8691	1321	152	liberties	liberty	NNS
8691	1321	153	of	of	IN
8691	1321	154	the	the	DT
8691	1321	155	people	people	NNS
8691	1321	156	,	,	,
8691	1321	157	which	which	WDT
8691	1321	158	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1321	159	,	,	,
8691	1321	160	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1321	161	representatives	representative	NNS
8691	1321	162	,	,	,
8691	1321	163	are	be	VBP
8691	1321	164	bound	bind	VBN
8691	1321	165	to	to	TO
8691	1321	166	guard	guard	VB
8691	1321	167	and	and	CC
8691	1321	168	protect	protect	VB
8691	1321	169	inviolate	inviolate	NN
8691	1321	170	;	;	:
8691	1321	171	Be	be	VB
8691	1321	172	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1321	173	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1321	174	resolved	resolve	VBN
8691	1321	175	,	,	,
8691	1321	176	That	that	IN
8691	1321	177	the	the	DT
8691	1321	178	members	member	NNS
8691	1321	179	of	of	IN
8691	1321	180	this	this	DT
8691	1321	181	general	general	JJ
8691	1321	182	assembly	assembly	NNP
8691	1321	183	view	view	NN
8691	1321	184	,	,	,
8691	1321	185	with	with	IN
8691	1321	186	deep	deep	JJ
8691	1321	187	concern	concern	NN
8691	1321	188	and	and	CC
8691	1321	189	regret	regret	NN
8691	1321	190	,	,	,
8691	1321	191	the	the	DT
8691	1321	192	aforesaid	aforesaid	JJ
8691	1321	193	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	1321	194	of	of	IN
8691	1321	195	the	the	DT
8691	1321	196	said	say	VBN
8691	1321	197	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1321	198	...	...	NFP
8691	1321	199	and	and	CC
8691	1321	200	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1321	201	can	can	MD
8691	1321	202	not	not	RB
8691	1321	203	refrain	refrain	VB
8691	1321	204	from	from	IN
8691	1321	205	an	an	DT
8691	1321	206	expression	expression	NN
8691	1321	207	of	of	IN
8691	1321	208	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1321	209	entire	entire	JJ
8691	1321	210	disapprobation	disapprobation	NN
8691	1321	211	of	of	IN
8691	1321	212	the	the	DT
8691	1321	213	power	power	NN
8691	1321	214	assumed	assume	VBN
8691	1321	215	by	by	IN
8691	1321	216	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1321	217	of	of	IN
8691	1321	218	determining	determine	VBG
8691	1321	219	upon	upon	IN
8691	1321	220	the	the	DT
8691	1321	221	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	1321	222	of	of	IN
8691	1321	223	laws	law	NNS
8691	1321	224	regularly	regularly	RB
8691	1321	225	passed	pass	VBN
8691	1321	226	by	by	IN
8691	1321	227	the	the	DT
8691	1321	228	general	general	NNP
8691	1321	229	assembly	assembly	NNP
8691	1321	230	,	,	,
8691	1321	231	as	as	IN
8691	1321	232	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
8691	1321	233	by	by	IN
8691	1321	234	the	the	DT
8691	1321	235	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	1321	236	of	of	IN
8691	1321	237	this	this	DT
8691	1321	238	state	state	NN
8691	1321	239	;	;	:
8691	1321	240	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1321	241	do	do	VBP
8691	1321	242	,	,	,
8691	1321	243	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1321	244	,	,	,
8691	1321	245	solemnly	solemnly	RB
8691	1321	246	declare	declare	VBP
8691	1321	247	and	and	CC
8691	1321	248	protest	protest	VBP
8691	1321	249	against	against	IN
8691	1321	250	the	the	DT
8691	1321	251	aforesaid	aforesaid	JJ
8691	1321	252	assumption	assumption	NN
8691	1321	253	of	of	IN
8691	1321	254	powers	power	NNS
8691	1321	255	,	,	,
8691	1321	256	as	as	IN
8691	1321	257	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	1321	258	by	by	IN
8691	1321	259	the	the	DT
8691	1321	260	said	say	VBN
8691	1321	261	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1321	262	,	,	,
8691	1321	263	and	and	CC
8691	1321	264	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1321	265	do	do	VBP
8691	1321	266	,	,	,
8691	1321	267	with	with	IN
8691	1321	268	heartfelt	heartfelt	JJ
8691	1321	269	sensibility	sensibility	NN
8691	1321	270	,	,	,
8691	1321	271	deprecate	deprecate	VB
8691	1321	272	the	the	DT
8691	1321	273	serious	serious	JJ
8691	1321	274	and	and	CC
8691	1321	275	distressing	distressing	JJ
8691	1321	276	consequences	consequence	NNS
8691	1321	277	which	which	WDT
8691	1321	278	followed	follow	VBD
8691	1321	279	such	such	JJ
8691	1321	280	decision	decision	NN
8691	1321	281	;	;	:
8691	1321	282	yet	yet	CC
8691	1321	283	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1321	284	forbear	forbear	VBP
8691	1321	285	to	to	TO
8691	1321	286	look	look	VB
8691	1321	287	with	with	IN
8691	1321	288	severity	severity	NN
8691	1321	289	on	on	IN
8691	1321	290	the	the	DT
8691	1321	291	past	past	NN
8691	1321	292	,	,	,
8691	1321	293	in	in	IN
8691	1321	294	consequence	consequence	NN
8691	1321	295	of	of	IN
8691	1321	296	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1321	297	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	1321	298	,	,	,
8691	1321	299	calculated	calculate	VBN
8691	1321	300	in	in	IN
8691	1321	301	some	some	DT
8691	1321	302	measure	measure	NN
8691	1321	303	to	to	TO
8691	1321	304	extenuate	extenuate	VB
8691	1321	305	the	the	DT
8691	1321	306	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	1321	307	of	of	IN
8691	1321	308	the	the	DT
8691	1321	309	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1321	310	,	,	,
8691	1321	311	and	and	CC
8691	1321	312	hope	hope	VBP
8691	1321	313	that	that	IN
8691	1321	314	for	for	IN
8691	1321	315	the	the	DT
8691	1321	316	future	future	NN
8691	1321	317	this	this	DT
8691	1321	318	explicit	explicit	JJ
8691	1321	319	expression	expression	NN
8691	1321	320	of	of	IN
8691	1321	321	public	public	JJ
8691	1321	322	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1321	323	will	will	MD
8691	1321	324	be	be	VB
8691	1321	325	obeyed	obey	VBN
8691	1321	326	.	.	.
8691	1322	1	In	in	IN
8691	1322	2	1821	1821	CD
8691	1322	3	a	a	DT
8691	1322	4	case	case	NN
8691	1322	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1322	6	argued	argue	VBN
8691	1322	7	before	before	IN
8691	1322	8	the	the	DT
8691	1322	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1322	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1322	11	of	of	IN
8691	1322	12	the	the	DT
8691	1322	13	United	United	NNP
8691	1322	14	States	States	NNP
8691	1322	15	involving	involve	VBG
8691	1322	16	the	the	DT
8691	1322	17	validity	validity	NN
8691	1322	18	of	of	IN
8691	1322	19	a	a	DT
8691	1322	20	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1322	21	statute	statute	NN
8691	1322	22	passed	pass	VBD
8691	1322	23	to	to	TO
8691	1322	24	protect	protect	VB
8691	1322	25	occupants	occupant	NNS
8691	1322	26	of	of	IN
8691	1322	27	land	land	NN
8691	1322	28	who	who	WP
8691	1322	29	had	have	VBD
8691	1322	30	made	make	VBN
8691	1322	31	valuable	valuable	JJ
8691	1322	32	improvements	improvement	NNS
8691	1322	33	upon	upon	IN
8691	1322	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1322	35	in	in	IN
8691	1322	36	good	good	JJ
8691	1322	37	faith	faith	NN
8691	1322	38	,	,	,
8691	1322	39	in	in	IN
8691	1322	40	case	case	NN
8691	1322	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1322	42	should	should	MD
8691	1322	43	be	be	VB
8691	1322	44	subsequently	subsequently	RB
8691	1322	45	proved	prove	VBN
8691	1322	46	to	to	TO
8691	1322	47	belong	belong	VB
8691	1322	48	to	to	IN
8691	1322	49	some	some	DT
8691	1322	50	one	one	NN
8691	1322	51	else	else	RB
8691	1322	52	.	.	.
8691	1323	1	The	the	DT
8691	1323	2	occupant	occupant	NN
8691	1323	3	had	have	VBD
8691	1323	4	employed	employ	VBN
8691	1323	5	no	no	DT
8691	1323	6	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	1323	7	,	,	,
8691	1323	8	and	and	CC
8691	1323	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1323	10	was	be	VBD
8691	1323	11	surmised	surmise	VBN
8691	1323	12	that	that	IN
8691	1323	13	the	the	DT
8691	1323	14	court	court	NN
8691	1323	15	would	would	MD
8691	1323	16	decide	decide	VB
8691	1323	17	against	against	IN
8691	1323	18	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1323	19	.	.	.
8691	1324	1	The	the	DT
8691	1324	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1324	3	of	of	IN
8691	1324	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1324	5	called	call	VBD
8691	1324	6	the	the	DT
8691	1324	7	attention	attention	NN
8691	1324	8	of	of	IN
8691	1324	9	the	the	DT
8691	1324	10	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1324	11	to	to	IN
8691	1324	12	this	this	DT
8691	1324	13	,	,	,
8691	1324	14	and	and	CC
8691	1324	15	advised	advise	VBD
8691	1324	16	the	the	DT
8691	1324	17	employment	employment	NN
8691	1324	18	of	of	IN
8691	1324	19	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	1324	20	to	to	TO
8691	1324	21	defend	defend	VB
8691	1324	22	the	the	DT
8691	1324	23	law	law	NN
8691	1324	24	.	.	.
8691	1325	1	The	the	DT
8691	1325	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1325	3	responded	respond	VBD
8691	1325	4	by	by	IN
8691	1325	5	resolving	resolve	VBG
8691	1325	6	"	"	``
8691	1325	7	that	that	IN
8691	1325	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1325	9	consider	consider	VBP
8691	1325	10	an	an	DT
8691	1325	11	adjudication	adjudication	NN
8691	1325	12	,	,	,
8691	1325	13	that	that	IN
8691	1325	14	the	the	DT
8691	1325	15	laws	law	NNS
8691	1325	16	in	in	IN
8691	1325	17	question	question	NN
8691	1325	18	are	be	VBP
8691	1325	19	void	void	JJ
8691	1325	20	,	,	,
8691	1325	21	incompatible	incompatible	JJ
8691	1325	22	with	with	IN
8691	1325	23	the	the	DT
8691	1325	24	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1325	25	powers	power	NNS
8691	1325	26	of	of	IN
8691	1325	27	this	this	DT
8691	1325	28	state	state	NN
8691	1325	29	,	,	,
8691	1325	30	and	and	CC
8691	1325	31	highly	highly	RB
8691	1325	32	injurious	injurious	JJ
8691	1325	33	to	to	IN
8691	1325	34	the	the	DT
8691	1325	35	best	good	JJS
8691	1325	36	interests	interest	NNS
8691	1325	37	of	of	IN
8691	1325	38	the	the	DT
8691	1325	39	people	people	NNS
8691	1325	40	;	;	:
8691	1325	41	and	and	CC
8691	1325	42	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1325	43	do	do	VBP
8691	1325	44	,	,	,
8691	1325	45	in	in	IN
8691	1325	46	the	the	DT
8691	1325	47	name	name	NN
8691	1325	48	of	of	IN
8691	1325	49	the	the	DT
8691	1325	50	commonwealth	commonwealth	NN
8691	1325	51	of	of	IN
8691	1325	52	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1325	53	,	,	,
8691	1325	54	and	and	CC
8691	1325	55	the	the	DT
8691	1325	56	good	good	JJ
8691	1325	57	people	people	NNS
8691	1325	58	thereof	thereof	RB
8691	1325	59	,	,	,
8691	1325	60	solemnly	solemnly	RB
8691	1325	61	remonstrate	remonstrate	NN
8691	1325	62	and	and	CC
8691	1325	63	protest	protest	VBP
8691	1325	64	against	against	IN
8691	1325	65	any	any	DT
8691	1325	66	such	such	JJ
8691	1325	67	adjudication	adjudication	NN
8691	1325	68	,	,	,
8691	1325	69	"	"	``
8691	1325	70	but	but	CC
8691	1325	71	that	that	IN
8691	1325	72	two	two	CD
8691	1325	73	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
8691	1325	74	should	should	MD
8691	1325	75	be	be	VB
8691	1325	76	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	1325	77	"	"	``
8691	1325	78	to	to	TO
8691	1325	79	attend	attend	VB
8691	1325	80	the	the	DT
8691	1325	81	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1325	82	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1325	83	of	of	IN
8691	1325	84	the	the	DT
8691	1325	85	United	United	NNP
8691	1325	86	States	States	NNP
8691	1325	87	at	at	IN
8691	1325	88	the	the	DT
8691	1325	89	next	next	JJ
8691	1325	90	term	term	NN
8691	1325	91	and	and	CC
8691	1325	92	oppose	oppose	VBP
8691	1325	93	any	any	DT
8691	1325	94	decision	decision	NN
8691	1325	95	that	that	WDT
8691	1325	96	may	may	MD
8691	1325	97	be	be	VB
8691	1325	98	attempted	attempt	VBN
8691	1325	99	to	to	TO
8691	1325	100	be	be	VB
8691	1325	101	procured	procure	VBN
8691	1325	102	from	from	IN
8691	1325	103	the	the	DT
8691	1325	104	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1325	105	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1325	106	,	,	,
8691	1325	107	that	that	IN
8691	1325	108	those	those	DT
8691	1325	109	laws	law	NNS
8691	1325	110	are	be	VBP
8691	1325	111	void	void	JJ
8691	1325	112	in	in	IN
8691	1325	113	such	such	JJ
8691	1325	114	manner	manner	NN
8691	1325	115	as	as	IN
8691	1325	116	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1325	117	may	may	MD
8691	1325	118	deem	deem	VB
8691	1325	119	most	most	RBS
8691	1325	120	respectful	respectful	JJ
8691	1325	121	to	to	IN
8691	1325	122	the	the	DT
8691	1325	123	court	court	NN
8691	1325	124	and	and	CC
8691	1325	125	most	most	RBS
8691	1325	126	consistent	consistent	JJ
8691	1325	127	with	with	IN
8691	1325	128	the	the	DT
8691	1325	129	dignity	dignity	NN
8691	1325	130	of	of	IN
8691	1325	131	this	this	DT
8691	1325	132	state	state	NN
8691	1325	133	.	.	.
8691	1326	1	"	"	``
8691	1326	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1326	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1326	4	:	:	:
8691	1326	5	Niles	Niles	NNP
8691	1326	6	'	'	POS
8691	1326	7	Register	Register	NNP
8691	1326	8	,	,	,
8691	1326	9	XXI	XXI	NNP
8691	1326	10	,	,	,
8691	1326	11	190	190	CD
8691	1326	12	,	,	,
8691	1326	13	404	404	CD
8691	1326	14	,	,	,
8691	1326	15	405	405	CD
8691	1326	16	.	.	.
8691	1326	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1327	1	The	the	DT
8691	1327	2	case	case	NN
8691	1327	3	had	have	VBD
8691	1327	4	already	already	RB
8691	1327	5	been	be	VBN
8691	1327	6	heard	hear	VBN
8691	1327	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1327	8	ex	ex	NNP
8691	1327	9	parte	parte	NNP
8691	1327	10	_	_	NNP
8691	1327	11	,	,	,
8691	1327	12	and	and	CC
8691	1327	13	the	the	DT
8691	1327	14	court	court	NN
8691	1327	15	soon	soon	RB
8691	1327	16	proceeded	proceed	VBD
8691	1327	17	to	to	TO
8691	1327	18	give	give	VB
8691	1327	19	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1327	20	that	that	IN
8691	1327	21	the	the	DT
8691	1327	22	statute	statute	NN
8691	1327	23	in	in	IN
8691	1327	24	question	question	NN
8691	1327	25	was	be	VBD
8691	1327	26	void	void	JJ
8691	1327	27	.	.	.
8691	1328	1	The	the	DT
8691	1328	2	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1328	3	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
8691	1328	4	employed	employ	VBN
8691	1328	5	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	1328	6	,	,	,
8691	1328	7	who	who	WP
8691	1328	8	moved	move	VBD
8691	1328	9	for	for	IN
8691	1328	10	a	a	DT
8691	1328	11	reargument	reargument	NN
8691	1328	12	,	,	,
8691	1328	13	and	and	CC
8691	1328	14	obtained	obtain	VBD
8691	1328	15	one	one	CD
8691	1328	16	,	,	,
8691	1328	17	but	but	CC
8691	1328	18	with	with	IN
8691	1328	19	the	the	DT
8691	1328	20	same	same	JJ
8691	1328	21	result	result	NN
8691	1328	22	.	.	.
8691	1329	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1329	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1329	3	:	:	:
8691	1329	4	Green	Green	NNP
8691	1329	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1329	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1329	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1329	8	Biddle	Biddle	NNP
8691	1329	9	,	,	,
8691	1329	10	8	8	CD
8691	1329	11	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	1329	12	's	's	POS
8691	1329	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1329	14	,	,	,
8691	1329	15	1	1	CD
8691	1329	16	.	.	.
8691	1329	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1330	1	The	the	DT
8691	1330	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1330	3	at	at	IN
8691	1330	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1330	5	next	next	JJ
8691	1330	6	session	session	NN
8691	1330	7	discussed	discuss	VBD
8691	1330	8	the	the	DT
8691	1330	9	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1330	10	in	in	IN
8691	1330	11	the	the	DT
8691	1330	12	case	case	NN
8691	1330	13	and	and	CC
8691	1330	14	resolved	resolve	VBD
8691	1330	15	"	"	``
8691	1330	16	that	that	IN
8691	1330	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1330	18	do	do	VBP
8691	1330	19	most	most	RBS
8691	1330	20	solemnly	solemnly	RB
8691	1330	21	protest	protest	VB
8691	1330	22	against	against	IN
8691	1330	23	the	the	DT
8691	1330	24	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
8691	1330	25	promulgated	promulgate	VBN
8691	1330	26	in	in	IN
8691	1330	27	that	that	DT
8691	1330	28	decision	decision	NN
8691	1330	29	as	as	IN
8691	1330	30	ruinous	ruinous	JJ
8691	1330	31	in	in	IN
8691	1330	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1330	33	practical	practical	JJ
8691	1330	34	effects	effect	NNS
8691	1330	35	to	to	IN
8691	1330	36	the	the	DT
8691	1330	37	good	good	JJ
8691	1330	38	people	people	NNS
8691	1330	39	of	of	IN
8691	1330	40	this	this	DT
8691	1330	41	commonwealth	commonwealth	NN
8691	1330	42	and	and	CC
8691	1330	43	subversive	subversive	JJ
8691	1330	44	of	of	IN
8691	1330	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1330	46	dearest	dear	JJS
8691	1330	47	and	and	CC
8691	1330	48	most	most	RBS
8691	1330	49	valuable	valuable	JJ
8691	1330	50	political	political	JJ
8691	1330	51	rights	right	NNS
8691	1330	52	.	.	.
8691	1331	1	"	"	``
8691	1331	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1331	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1331	4	:	:	:
8691	1331	5	Niles	Niles	NNP
8691	1331	6	'	'	POS
8691	1331	7	Register	Register	NNP
8691	1331	8	,	,	,
8691	1331	9	XXV	XXV	NNP
8691	1331	10	,	,	,
8691	1331	11	275	275	CD
8691	1331	12	.	.	.
8691	1331	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1332	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1332	2	then	then	RB
8691	1332	3	took	take	VBD
8691	1332	4	up	up	RP
8691	1332	5	two	two	CD
8691	1332	6	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	1332	7	of	of	IN
8691	1332	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1332	9	own	own	JJ
8691	1332	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1332	11	of	of	IN
8691	1332	12	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1332	13	,	,	,
8691	1332	14	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	1332	15	other	other	JJ
8691	1332	16	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1332	17	of	of	IN
8691	1332	18	the	the	DT
8691	1332	19	State	State	NNP
8691	1332	20	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1332	21	and	and	CC
8691	1332	22	void	void	JJ
8691	1332	23	,	,	,
8691	1332	24	and	and	CC
8691	1332	25	resolved	resolve	VBD
8691	1332	26	"	"	``
8691	1332	27	that	that	IN
8691	1332	28	in	in	IN
8691	1332	29	the	the	DT
8691	1332	30	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1332	31	of	of	IN
8691	1332	32	this	this	DT
8691	1332	33	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1332	34	the	the	DT
8691	1332	35	decision	decision	NN
8691	1332	36	of	of	IN
8691	1332	37	the	the	DT
8691	1332	38	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1332	39	of	of	IN
8691	1332	40	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1332	41	of	of	IN
8691	1332	42	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1332	43	in	in	IN
8691	1332	44	the	the	DT
8691	1332	45	cases	case	NNS
8691	1332	46	of	of	IN
8691	1332	47	Blair	Blair	NNP
8691	1332	48	against	against	IN
8691	1332	49	Williams[Footnote	williams[footnote	NN
8691	1332	50	:	:	:
8691	1332	51	4	4	CD
8691	1332	52	Littell	Littell	NNP
8691	1332	53	's	's	POS
8691	1332	54	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1332	55	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1332	56	,	,	,
8691	1332	57	34	34	CD
8691	1332	58	.	.	.
8691	1332	59	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1333	1	and	and	CC
8691	1333	2	Lapsley	Lapsley	NNP
8691	1333	3	against	against	IN
8691	1333	4	Brashears[Footnote	Brashears[Footnote	NNS
8691	1333	5	:	:	:
8691	1333	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1333	7	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
8691	1333	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1333	9	.	.	NNP
8691	1333	10	,	,	,
8691	1333	11	47	47	CD
8691	1333	12	.	.	.
8691	1333	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1334	1	are	be	VBP
8691	1334	2	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
8691	1334	3	,	,	,
8691	1334	4	and	and	CC
8691	1334	5	the	the	DT
8691	1334	6	laws	law	NNS
8691	1334	7	declared	declare	VBD
8691	1334	8	therein	therein	RB
8691	1334	9	to	to	TO
8691	1334	10	be	be	VB
8691	1334	11	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1334	12	are	be	VBP
8691	1334	13	,	,	,
8691	1334	14	in	in	IN
8691	1334	15	the	the	DT
8691	1334	16	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1334	17	of	of	IN
8691	1334	18	this	this	DT
8691	1334	19	present	present	JJ
8691	1334	20	General	General	NNP
8691	1334	21	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	1334	22	,	,	,
8691	1334	23	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1334	24	and	and	CC
8691	1334	25	valid	valid	JJ
8691	1334	26	acts	act	NNS
8691	1334	27	.	.	.
8691	1335	1	"	"	``
8691	1335	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1335	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1335	4	:	:	:
8691	1335	5	Niles	Niles	NNP
8691	1335	6	'	'	POS
8691	1335	7	Register	Register	NNP
8691	1335	8	,	,	,
8691	1335	9	XXV	XXV	NNP
8691	1335	10	,	,	,
8691	1335	11	275	275	CD
8691	1335	12	.	.	.
8691	1335	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1336	1	The	the	DT
8691	1336	2	next	next	JJ
8691	1336	3	step	step	NN
8691	1336	4	was	be	VBD
8691	1336	5	to	to	TO
8691	1336	6	endeavor	endeavor	VB
8691	1336	7	to	to	TO
8691	1336	8	remove	remove	VB
8691	1336	9	the	the	DT
8691	1336	10	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1336	11	,	,	,
8691	1336	12	but	but	CC
8691	1336	13	the	the	DT
8691	1336	14	two	two	CD
8691	1336	15	-	-	HYPH
8691	1336	16	thirds	third	NNS
8691	1336	17	vote	vote	NN
8691	1336	18	required	require	VBN
8691	1336	19	by	by	IN
8691	1336	20	the	the	DT
8691	1336	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1336	22	to	to	TO
8691	1336	23	support	support	VB
8691	1336	24	an	an	DT
8691	1336	25	address	address	NN
8691	1336	26	to	to	IN
8691	1336	27	the	the	DT
8691	1336	28	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1336	29	for	for	IN
8691	1336	30	that	that	DT
8691	1336	31	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1336	32	could	could	MD
8691	1336	33	not	not	RB
8691	1336	34	be	be	VB
8691	1336	35	secured	secure	VBN
8691	1336	36	.	.	.
8691	1337	1	At	at	IN
8691	1337	2	the	the	DT
8691	1337	3	next	next	JJ
8691	1337	4	session	session	NN
8691	1337	5	,	,	,
8691	1337	6	in	in	IN
8691	1337	7	1824	1824	CD
8691	1337	8	,	,	,
8691	1337	9	the	the	DT
8691	1337	10	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1337	11	were	be	VBD
8691	1337	12	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	1337	13	to	to	TO
8691	1337	14	show	show	VB
8691	1337	15	cause	cause	IN
8691	1337	16	why	why	WRB
8691	1337	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1337	18	should	should	MD
8691	1337	19	not	not	RB
8691	1337	20	be	be	VB
8691	1337	21	removed	remove	VBN
8691	1337	22	.	.	.
8691	1338	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1338	2	defended	defend	VBD
8691	1338	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1338	4	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	1338	5	so	so	RB
8691	1338	6	well	well	RB
8691	1338	7	that	that	IN
8691	1338	8	the	the	DT
8691	1338	9	two	two	CD
8691	1338	10	-	-	HYPH
8691	1338	11	thirds	third	NNS
8691	1338	12	vote	vote	NN
8691	1338	13	of	of	IN
8691	1338	14	each	each	DT
8691	1338	15	house	house	NN
8691	1338	16	required	require	VBN
8691	1338	17	by	by	IN
8691	1338	18	the	the	DT
8691	1338	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1338	20	could	could	MD
8691	1338	21	not	not	RB
8691	1338	22	be	be	VB
8691	1338	23	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	1338	24	.	.	.
8691	1339	1	By	by	IN
8691	1339	2	a	a	DT
8691	1339	3	majority	majority	NN
8691	1339	4	vote	vote	NN
8691	1339	5	the	the	DT
8691	1339	6	court	court	NN
8691	1339	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1339	8	then	then	RB
8691	1339	9	abolished	abolish	VBN
8691	1339	10	,	,	,
8691	1339	11	a	a	DT
8691	1339	12	new	new	JJ
8691	1339	13	one	one	CD
8691	1339	14	set	set	VBN
8691	1339	15	up	up	RP
8691	1339	16	by	by	IN
8691	1339	17	the	the	DT
8691	1339	18	same	same	JJ
8691	1339	19	name	name	NN
8691	1339	20	,	,	,
8691	1339	21	and	and	CC
8691	1339	22	four	four	CD
8691	1339	23	new	new	JJ
8691	1339	24	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1339	25	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	1339	26	.	.	.
8691	1340	1	The	the	DT
8691	1340	2	old	old	JJ
8691	1340	3	court	court	NN
8691	1340	4	refused	refuse	VBD
8691	1340	5	to	to	TO
8691	1340	6	recognize	recognize	VB
8691	1340	7	the	the	DT
8691	1340	8	validity	validity	NN
8691	1340	9	of	of	IN
8691	1340	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1340	11	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1340	12	.	.	.
8691	1341	1	The	the	DT
8691	1341	2	new	new	JJ
8691	1341	3	one	one	CD
8691	1341	4	assumed	assume	VBD
8691	1341	5	to	to	TO
8691	1341	6	organize	organize	VB
8691	1341	7	and	and	CC
8691	1341	8	to	to	TO
8691	1341	9	do	do	VB
8691	1341	10	business	business	NN
8691	1341	11	.	.	.
8691	1342	1	At	at	IN
8691	1342	2	the	the	DT
8691	1342	3	next	next	JJ
8691	1342	4	election	election	NN
8691	1342	5	the	the	DT
8691	1342	6	question	question	NN
8691	1342	7	which	which	WDT
8691	1342	8	court	court	NN
8691	1342	9	ought	ought	MD
8691	1342	10	to	to	TO
8691	1342	11	be	be	VB
8691	1342	12	recognized	recognize	VBN
8691	1342	13	was	be	VBD
8691	1342	14	the	the	DT
8691	1342	15	dominant	dominant	JJ
8691	1342	16	one	one	CD
8691	1342	17	.	.	.
8691	1343	1	The	the	DT
8691	1343	2	result	result	NN
8691	1343	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1343	4	that	that	IN
8691	1343	5	the	the	DT
8691	1343	6	friends	friend	NNS
8691	1343	7	of	of	IN
8691	1343	8	the	the	DT
8691	1343	9	old	old	JJ
8691	1343	10	court	court	NN
8691	1343	11	gained	gain	VBD
8691	1343	12	control	control	NN
8691	1343	13	of	of	IN
8691	1343	14	the	the	DT
8691	1343	15	House	House	NNP
8691	1343	16	and	and	CC
8691	1343	17	those	those	DT
8691	1343	18	of	of	IN
8691	1343	19	the	the	DT
8691	1343	20	new	new	JJ
8691	1343	21	court	court	NN
8691	1343	22	that	that	DT
8691	1343	23	of	of	IN
8691	1343	24	the	the	DT
8691	1343	25	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	1343	26	,	,	,
8691	1343	27	one	one	CD
8691	1343	28	of	of	IN
8691	1343	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1343	30	being	be	VBG
8691	1343	31	also	also	RB
8691	1343	32	chosen	choose	VBN
8691	1343	33	as	as	IN
8691	1343	34	the	the	DT
8691	1343	35	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1343	36	.	.	.
8691	1344	1	The	the	DT
8691	1344	2	new	new	JJ
8691	1344	3	court	court	NN
8691	1344	4	now	now	RB
8691	1344	5	got	get	VBD
8691	1344	6	possession	possession	NN
8691	1344	7	of	of	IN
8691	1344	8	most	most	JJS
8691	1344	9	of	of	IN
8691	1344	10	the	the	DT
8691	1344	11	papers	paper	NNS
8691	1344	12	of	of	IN
8691	1344	13	the	the	DT
8691	1344	14	old	old	JJ
8691	1344	15	court	court	NN
8691	1344	16	.	.	.
8691	1345	1	The	the	DT
8691	1345	2	latter	latter	JJ
8691	1345	3	ordered	order	VBD
8691	1345	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1345	5	sergeant	sergeant	NN
8691	1345	6	to	to	TO
8691	1345	7	bring	bring	VB
8691	1345	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1345	9	back	back	RB
8691	1345	10	.	.	.
8691	1346	1	The	the	DT
8691	1346	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1346	3	made	make	VBD
8691	1346	4	preparations	preparation	NNS
8691	1346	5	to	to	TO
8691	1346	6	use	use	VB
8691	1346	7	military	military	JJ
8691	1346	8	force	force	NN
8691	1346	9	to	to	TO
8691	1346	10	resist	resist	VB
8691	1346	11	the	the	DT
8691	1346	12	execution	execution	NN
8691	1346	13	of	of	IN
8691	1346	14	this	this	DT
8691	1346	15	order	order	NN
8691	1346	16	.	.	.
8691	1347	1	At	at	IN
8691	1347	2	last	last	JJ
8691	1347	3	,	,	,
8691	1347	4	in	in	IN
8691	1347	5	1826	1826	CD
8691	1347	6	,	,	,
8691	1347	7	an	an	DT
8691	1347	8	act	act	NN
8691	1347	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1347	10	passed	pass	VBN
8691	1347	11	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1347	12	Session	Session	NNP
8691	1347	13	Laws	Laws	NNPS
8691	1347	14	,	,	,
8691	1347	15	p.	p.	NN
8691	1347	16	13	13	CD
8691	1347	17	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1347	18	over	over	IN
8691	1347	19	the	the	DT
8691	1347	20	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1347	21	's	's	POS
8691	1347	22	veto	veto	NN
8691	1347	23	,	,	,
8691	1347	24	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	1347	25	the	the	DT
8691	1347	26	acts	act	NNS
8691	1347	27	abolishing	abolish	VBG
8691	1347	28	the	the	DT
8691	1347	29	old	old	JJ
8691	1347	30	court	court	NN
8691	1347	31	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1347	32	and	and	CC
8691	1347	33	void	void	JJ
8691	1347	34	.	.	.
8691	1348	1	The	the	DT
8691	1348	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1348	3	thereupon	thereupon	RB
8691	1348	4	appointed	appoint	VBD
8691	1348	5	a	a	DT
8691	1348	6	warm	warm	JJ
8691	1348	7	champion	champion	NN
8691	1348	8	of	of	IN
8691	1348	9	the	the	DT
8691	1348	10	new	new	JJ
8691	1348	11	court	court	NN
8691	1348	12	chief	chief	NN
8691	1348	13	justice	justice	NN
8691	1348	14	of	of	IN
8691	1348	15	the	the	DT
8691	1348	16	old	old	JJ
8691	1348	17	one	one	NN
8691	1348	18	to	to	TO
8691	1348	19	fill	fill	VB
8691	1348	20	a	a	DT
8691	1348	21	vacancy	vacancy	NN
8691	1348	22	which	which	WDT
8691	1348	23	had	have	VBD
8691	1348	24	occurred	occur	VBN
8691	1348	25	on	on	IN
8691	1348	26	that	that	DT
8691	1348	27	bench	bench	NN
8691	1348	28	,	,	,
8691	1348	29	and	and	CC
8691	1348	30	for	for	IN
8691	1348	31	the	the	DT
8691	1348	32	first	first	JJ
8691	1348	33	time	time	NN
8691	1348	34	for	for	IN
8691	1348	35	two	two	CD
8691	1348	36	years	year	NNS
8691	1348	37	the	the	DT
8691	1348	38	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1348	39	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	1348	40	of	of	IN
8691	1348	41	the	the	DT
8691	1348	42	State	State	NNP
8691	1348	43	was	be	VBD
8691	1348	44	on	on	IN
8691	1348	45	a	a	DT
8691	1348	46	proper	proper	JJ
8691	1348	47	footing	footing	NN
8691	1348	48	.	.	.
8691	1349	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1349	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1349	3	:	:	:
8691	1349	4	Niles	Niles	NNP
8691	1349	5	'	'	POS
8691	1349	6	Register	register	NN
8691	1349	7	,	,	,
8691	1349	8	XXXI	XXXI	NNP
8691	1349	9	,	,	,
8691	1349	10	324	324	CD
8691	1349	11	;	;	:
8691	1349	12	McMaster	McMaster	NNP
8691	1349	13	"	"	``
8691	1349	14	History	history	NN
8691	1349	15	of	of	IN
8691	1349	16	the	the	DT
8691	1349	17	People	People	NNS
8691	1349	18	of	of	IN
8691	1349	19	the	the	DT
8691	1349	20	United	United	NNP
8691	1349	21	States	States	NNP
8691	1349	22	,	,	,
8691	1349	23	"	"	``
8691	1349	24	V	V	NNP
8691	1349	25	,	,	,
8691	1349	26	162	162	CD
8691	1349	27	-	-	SYM
8691	1349	28	166	166	CD
8691	1349	29	;	;	:
8691	1349	30	"	"	``
8691	1349	31	The	The	NNP
8691	1349	32	Old	Old	NNP
8691	1349	33	and	and	CC
8691	1349	34	the	the	DT
8691	1349	35	New	New	NNP
8691	1349	36	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1349	37	,	,	,
8691	1349	38	in	in	IN
8691	1349	39	The	the	DT
8691	1349	40	Green	Green	NNP
8691	1349	41	Bag	Bag	NNP
8691	1349	42	,	,	,
8691	1349	43	"	"	''
8691	1349	44	XVI	XVI	NNP
8691	1349	45	,	,	,
8691	1349	46	520	520	CD
8691	1349	47	.	.	.
8691	1349	48	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1350	1	Meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
8691	1350	2	both	both	DT
8691	1350	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1350	4	had	have	VBD
8691	1350	5	been	be	VBN
8691	1350	6	sitting	sit	VBG
8691	1350	7	and	and	CC
8691	1350	8	disposing	dispose	VBG
8691	1350	9	of	of	IN
8691	1350	10	cases	case	NNS
8691	1350	11	.	.	.
8691	1351	1	New	new	JJ
8691	1351	2	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	1351	3	from	from	IN
8691	1351	4	the	the	DT
8691	1351	5	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	1351	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	1351	7	had	have	VBD
8691	1351	8	been	be	VBN
8691	1351	9	entered	enter	VBN
8691	1351	10	in	in	IN
8691	1351	11	the	the	DT
8691	1351	12	one	one	NN
8691	1351	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1351	14	the	the	DT
8691	1351	15	appellant	appellant	NN
8691	1351	16	's	's	POS
8691	1351	17	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	1351	18	thought	think	VBD
8691	1351	19	most	most	RBS
8691	1351	20	likely	likely	JJ
8691	1351	21	to	to	TO
8691	1351	22	stand	stand	VB
8691	1351	23	as	as	IN
8691	1351	24	the	the	DT
8691	1351	25	rightful	rightful	JJ
8691	1351	26	authority	authority	NN
8691	1351	27	.	.	.
8691	1352	1	The	the	DT
8691	1352	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1352	3	of	of	IN
8691	1352	4	the	the	DT
8691	1352	5	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	1352	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	1352	7	were	be	VBD
8691	1352	8	in	in	IN
8691	1352	9	despair	despair	NN
8691	1352	10	when	when	WRB
8691	1352	11	the	the	DT
8691	1352	12	mandates	mandate	NNS
8691	1352	13	of	of	IN
8691	1352	14	the	the	DT
8691	1352	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1352	16	of	of	IN
8691	1352	17	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1352	18	came	come	VBD
8691	1352	19	down	down	RP
8691	1352	20	,	,	,
8691	1352	21	and	and	CC
8691	1352	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1352	23	were	be	VBD
8691	1352	24	called	call	VBN
8691	1352	25	upon	upon	IN
8691	1352	26	to	to	TO
8691	1352	27	determine	determine	VB
8691	1352	28	whether	whether	IN
8691	1352	29	to	to	TO
8691	1352	30	obey	obey	VB
8691	1352	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1352	32	.	.	.
8691	1353	1	Some	some	DT
8691	1353	2	held	hold	VBD
8691	1353	3	that	that	IN
8691	1353	4	the	the	DT
8691	1353	5	new	new	JJ
8691	1353	6	court	court	NN
8691	1353	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1353	8	a	a	DT
8691	1353	9	_	_	NNP
8691	1353	10	de	de	FW
8691	1353	11	facto	facto	FW
8691	1353	12	court	court	NN
8691	1353	13	_	_	NNP
8691	1353	14	,	,	,
8691	1353	15	and	and	CC
8691	1353	16	to	to	TO
8691	1353	17	be	be	VB
8691	1353	18	respected	respect	VBN
8691	1353	19	accordingly	accordingly	RB
8691	1353	20	.	.	.
8691	1354	1	The	the	DT
8691	1354	2	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
8691	1354	3	decision	decision	NN
8691	1354	4	fell	fall	VBD
8691	1354	5	to	to	IN
8691	1354	6	the	the	DT
8691	1354	7	old	old	JJ
8691	1354	8	court	court	NN
8691	1354	9	,	,	,
8691	1354	10	which	which	WDT
8691	1354	11	,	,	,
8691	1354	12	after	after	IN
8691	1354	13	the	the	DT
8691	1354	14	repealing	repeal	VBG
8691	1354	15	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1354	16	of	of	IN
8691	1354	17	1826	1826	CD
8691	1354	18	,	,	,
8691	1354	19	held	hold	VBD
8691	1354	20	that	that	IN
8691	1354	21	there	there	EX
8691	1354	22	could	could	MD
8691	1354	23	be	be	VB
8691	1354	24	no	no	DT
8691	1354	25	such	such	JJ
8691	1354	26	thing	thing	NN
8691	1354	27	as	as	IN
8691	1354	28	a	a	DT
8691	1354	29	_	_	NNP
8691	1354	30	de	de	FW
8691	1354	31	facto	facto	FW
8691	1354	32	_	_	NNP
8691	1354	33	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1354	34	of	of	IN
8691	1354	35	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1354	36	so	so	RB
8691	1354	37	long	long	RB
8691	1354	38	as	as	IN
8691	1354	39	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1354	40	government	government	NN
8691	1354	41	was	be	VBD
8691	1354	42	maintained	maintain	VBN
8691	1354	43	and	and	CC
8691	1354	44	the	the	DT
8691	1354	45	_	_	NNP
8691	1354	46	de	de	NNP
8691	1354	47	jure	jure	NNP
8691	1354	48	_	_	NNP
8691	1354	49	court	court	NN
8691	1354	50	was	be	VBD
8691	1354	51	in	in	IN
8691	1354	52	the	the	DT
8691	1354	53	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	1354	54	of	of	IN
8691	1354	55	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1354	56	functions	function	NNS
8691	1354	57	.	.	.
8691	1355	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1355	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1355	3	:	:	:
8691	1355	4	Hildreth	Hildreth	NNP
8691	1355	5	's	's	POS
8691	1355	6	Heirs	Heirs	NNP
8691	1355	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1355	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	1355	9	_	_	NNP
8691	1355	10	M'Intire	M'Intire	NNP
8691	1355	11	's	's	POS
8691	1355	12	Devisee	Devisee	NNP
8691	1355	13	,	,	,
8691	1355	14	1	1	CD
8691	1355	15	,	,	,
8691	1355	16	J.	J.	NNP
8691	1355	17	J.	J.	NNP
8691	1355	18	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1355	19	's	's	POS
8691	1355	20	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1355	21	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1355	22	,	,	,
8691	1355	23	206	206	CD
8691	1355	24	.	.	.
8691	1355	25	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1356	1	The	the	DT
8691	1356	2	same	same	JJ
8691	1356	3	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	1356	4	of	of	IN
8691	1356	5	jealousy	jealousy	NN
8691	1356	6	still	still	RB
8691	1356	7	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	1356	8	manifests	manifest	VBZ
8691	1356	9	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1356	10	in	in	IN
8691	1356	11	a	a	DT
8691	1356	12	less	less	RBR
8691	1356	13	outspoken	outspoken	JJ
8691	1356	14	but	but	CC
8691	1356	15	more	more	JJR
8691	1356	16	effective	effective	JJ
8691	1356	17	fashion	fashion	NN
8691	1356	18	.	.	.
8691	1357	1	If	if	IN
8691	1357	2	a	a	DT
8691	1357	3	question	question	NN
8691	1357	4	of	of	IN
8691	1357	5	political	political	JJ
8691	1357	6	importance	importance	NN
8691	1357	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1357	8	likely	likely	JJ
8691	1357	9	to	to	TO
8691	1357	10	come	come	VB
8691	1357	11	before	before	IN
8691	1357	12	a	a	DT
8691	1357	13	court	court	NN
8691	1357	14	,	,	,
8691	1357	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1357	16	may	may	MD
8691	1357	17	be	be	VB
8691	1357	18	within	within	IN
8691	1357	19	the	the	DT
8691	1357	20	power	power	NN
8691	1357	21	of	of	IN
8691	1357	22	the	the	DT
8691	1357	23	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1357	24	to	to	TO
8691	1357	25	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	1357	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1357	27	by	by	IN
8691	1357	28	a	a	DT
8691	1357	29	change	change	NN
8691	1357	30	in	in	IN
8691	1357	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1357	32	statutory	statutory	JJ
8691	1357	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1357	34	.	.	.
8691	1358	1	In	in	IN
8691	1358	2	this	this	DT
8691	1358	3	way	way	NN
8691	1358	4	the	the	DT
8691	1358	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1358	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1358	7	of	of	IN
8691	1358	8	the	the	DT
8691	1358	9	United	United	NNP
8691	1358	10	States	States	NNP
8691	1358	11	was	be	VBD
8691	1358	12	kept	keep	VBN
8691	1358	13	from	from	IN
8691	1358	14	passing	pass	VBG
8691	1358	15	on	on	IN
8691	1358	16	the	the	DT
8691	1358	17	validity	validity	NN
8691	1358	18	of	of	IN
8691	1358	19	the	the	DT
8691	1358	20	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
8691	1358	21	Acts	Acts	NNPS
8691	1358	22	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	1358	23	by	by	IN
8691	1358	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1358	25	at	at	IN
8691	1358	26	the	the	DT
8691	1358	27	close	close	NN
8691	1358	28	of	of	IN
8691	1358	29	the	the	DT
8691	1358	30	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	1358	31	War	War	NNP
8691	1358	32	,	,	,
8691	1358	33	in	in	IN
8691	1358	34	a	a	DT
8691	1358	35	case	case	NN
8691	1358	36	which	which	WDT
8691	1358	37	was	be	VBD
8691	1358	38	actually	actually	RB
8691	1358	39	pending	pende	VBG
8691	1358	40	.	.	.
8691	1359	1	Under	under	IN
8691	1359	2	these	these	DT
8691	1359	3	Acts	act	NNS
8691	1359	4	a	a	DT
8691	1359	5	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	1359	6	newspaper	newspaper	NN
8691	1359	7	editor	editor	NN
8691	1359	8	was	be	VBD
8691	1359	9	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	1359	10	in	in	IN
8691	1359	11	1867	1867	CD
8691	1359	12	by	by	IN
8691	1359	13	military	military	JJ
8691	1359	14	order	order	NN
8691	1359	15	on	on	IN
8691	1359	16	account	account	NN
8691	1359	17	of	of	IN
8691	1359	18	an	an	DT
8691	1359	19	article	article	NN
8691	1359	20	which	which	WDT
8691	1359	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1359	22	had	have	VBD
8691	1359	23	published	publish	VBN
8691	1359	24	reflecting	reflect	VBG
8691	1359	25	on	on	IN
8691	1359	26	the	the	DT
8691	1359	27	policy	policy	NN
8691	1359	28	of	of	IN
8691	1359	29	the	the	DT
8691	1359	30	government	government	NN
8691	1359	31	,	,	,
8691	1359	32	and	and	CC
8691	1359	33	held	hold	VBN
8691	1359	34	for	for	IN
8691	1359	35	trial	trial	NN
8691	1359	36	before	before	IN
8691	1359	37	a	a	DT
8691	1359	38	military	military	JJ
8691	1359	39	commission	commission	NN
8691	1359	40	.	.	.
8691	1360	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1360	2	appealed	appeal	VBD
8691	1360	3	to	to	IN
8691	1360	4	the	the	DT
8691	1360	5	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1360	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1360	7	of	of	IN
8691	1360	8	the	the	DT
8691	1360	9	United	United	NNP
8691	1360	10	States	States	NNP
8691	1360	11	for	for	IN
8691	1360	12	the	the	DT
8691	1360	13	District	District	NNP
8691	1360	14	of	of	IN
8691	1360	15	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	1360	16	for	for	IN
8691	1360	17	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	1360	18	on	on	IN
8691	1360	19	a	a	DT
8691	1360	20	writ	writ	NN
8691	1360	21	of	of	IN
8691	1360	22	_	_	NNP
8691	1360	23	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	1360	24	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	1360	25	_	_	NNP
8691	1360	26	.	.	.
8691	1361	1	Judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1361	2	went	go	VBD
8691	1361	3	against	against	IN
8691	1361	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1361	5	,	,	,
8691	1361	6	and	and	CC
8691	1361	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1361	8	appealed	appeal	VBD
8691	1361	9	to	to	IN
8691	1361	10	the	the	DT
8691	1361	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1361	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1361	13	of	of	IN
8691	1361	14	the	the	DT
8691	1361	15	United	United	NNP
8691	1361	16	States	States	NNP
8691	1361	17	.	.	.
8691	1362	1	The	the	DT
8691	1362	2	court	court	NN
8691	1362	3	,	,	,
8691	1362	4	on	on	IN
8691	1362	5	August	August	NNP
8691	1362	6	1	1	CD
8691	1362	7	,	,	,
8691	1362	8	held	hold	VBD
8691	1362	9	that	that	IN
8691	1362	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1362	11	had	have	VBD
8691	1362	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1362	13	to	to	TO
8691	1362	14	review	review	VB
8691	1362	15	the	the	DT
8691	1362	16	decision	decision	NN
8691	1362	17	and	and	CC
8691	1362	18	to	to	TO
8691	1362	19	decide	decide	VB
8691	1362	20	whether	whether	IN
8691	1362	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1362	22	could	could	MD
8691	1362	23	be	be	VB
8691	1362	24	tried	try	VBN
8691	1362	25	before	before	IN
8691	1362	26	such	such	PDT
8691	1362	27	a	a	DT
8691	1362	28	commission	commission	NN
8691	1362	29	.	.	.
8691	1363	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1363	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1363	3	:	:	:
8691	1363	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1363	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	1363	6	parte	parte	NN
8691	1363	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1363	8	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
8691	1363	9	,	,	,
8691	1363	10	6	6	CD
8691	1363	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	1363	12	's	's	POS
8691	1363	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1363	14	,	,	,
8691	1363	15	318	318	CD
8691	1363	16	,	,	,
8691	1363	17	327	327	CD
8691	1363	18	.	.	.
8691	1363	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1364	1	The	the	DT
8691	1364	2	cause	cause	NN
8691	1364	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1364	4	then	then	RB
8691	1364	5	heard	hear	VBN
8691	1364	6	on	on	IN
8691	1364	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1364	8	merits	merit	NNS
8691	1364	9	and	and	CC
8691	1364	10	all	all	PDT
8691	1364	11	the	the	DT
8691	1364	12	questions	question	NNS
8691	1364	13	involved	involve	VBN
8691	1364	14	discussed	discuss	VBN
8691	1364	15	at	at	IN
8691	1364	16	length	length	NN
8691	1364	17	,	,	,
8691	1364	18	four	four	CD
8691	1364	19	days	day	NNS
8691	1364	20	being	be	VBG
8691	1364	21	devoted	devote	VBN
8691	1364	22	to	to	IN
8691	1364	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1364	24	.	.	.
8691	1365	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1365	2	apprehended	apprehend	VBD
8691	1365	3	a	a	DT
8691	1365	4	decision	decision	NN
8691	1365	5	that	that	IN
8691	1365	6	the	the	DT
8691	1365	7	Reconstruction	Reconstruction	NNP
8691	1365	8	Acts	Acts	NNPS
8691	1365	9	were	be	VBD
8691	1365	10	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1365	11	,	,	,
8691	1365	12	and	and	CC
8691	1365	13	before	before	IN
8691	1365	14	one	one	CD
8691	1365	15	was	be	VBD
8691	1365	16	arrived	arrive	VBN
8691	1365	17	at	at	IN
8691	1365	18	,	,	,
8691	1365	19	during	during	IN
8691	1365	20	the	the	DT
8691	1365	21	same	same	JJ
8691	1365	22	month	month	NN
8691	1365	23	,	,	,
8691	1365	24	passed	pass	VBD
8691	1365	25	an	an	DT
8691	1365	26	act	act	NN
8691	1365	27	repealing	repeal	VBG
8691	1365	28	the	the	DT
8691	1365	29	right	right	NN
8691	1365	30	of	of	IN
8691	1365	31	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1365	32	in	in	IN
8691	1365	33	such	such	JJ
8691	1365	34	cases	case	NNS
8691	1365	35	from	from	IN
8691	1365	36	the	the	DT
8691	1365	37	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1365	38	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1365	39	.	.	.
8691	1366	1	The	the	DT
8691	1366	2	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1366	3	of	of	IN
8691	1366	4	this	this	DT
8691	1366	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1366	6	obvious	obvious	JJ
8691	1366	7	,	,	,
8691	1366	8	but	but	CC
8691	1366	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1366	10	was	be	VBD
8691	1366	11	none	none	NN
8691	1366	12	the	the	DT
8691	1366	13	less	less	RBR
8691	1366	14	effective	effective	JJ
8691	1366	15	,	,	,
8691	1366	16	and	and	CC
8691	1366	17	the	the	DT
8691	1366	18	court	court	NN
8691	1366	19	,	,	,
8691	1366	20	without	without	IN
8691	1366	21	deciding	decide	VBG
8691	1366	22	the	the	DT
8691	1366	23	case	case	NN
8691	1366	24	,	,	,
8691	1366	25	dismissed	dismiss	VBD
8691	1366	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1366	27	for	for	IN
8691	1366	28	want	want	NN
8691	1366	29	of	of	IN
8691	1366	30	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1366	31	.	.	.
8691	1367	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1367	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1367	3	:	:	:
8691	1367	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1367	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	1367	6	parte	parte	NN
8691	1367	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1367	8	McCardle	McCardle	NNP
8691	1367	9	,	,	,
8691	1367	10	7	7	CD
8691	1367	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	1367	12	's	's	POS
8691	1367	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1367	14	,	,	,
8691	1367	15	506	506	CD
8691	1367	16	.	.	.
8691	1367	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1368	1	A	a	DT
8691	1368	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1368	3	whose	whose	WP$
8691	1368	4	work	work	NN
8691	1368	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	1368	6	been	be	VBN
8691	1368	7	set	set	VBN
8691	1368	8	aside	aside	RB
8691	1368	9	by	by	IN
8691	1368	10	the	the	DT
8691	1368	11	courts	court	NNS
8691	1368	12	as	as	IN
8691	1368	13	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1368	14	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	1368	15	asks	ask	VBZ
8691	1368	16	,	,	,
8691	1368	17	in	in	IN
8691	1368	18	effect	effect	NN
8691	1368	19	,	,	,
8691	1368	20	for	for	IN
8691	1368	21	a	a	DT
8691	1368	22	reconsideration	reconsideration	NN
8691	1368	23	of	of	IN
8691	1368	24	the	the	DT
8691	1368	25	question	question	NN
8691	1368	26	by	by	IN
8691	1368	27	passing	pass	VBG
8691	1368	28	another	another	DT
8691	1368	29	law	law	NN
8691	1368	30	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	1368	31	of	of	IN
8691	1368	32	the	the	DT
8691	1368	33	same	same	JJ
8691	1368	34	nature	nature	NN
8691	1368	35	,	,	,
8691	1368	36	although	although	IN
8691	1368	37	expressed	express	VBN
8691	1368	38	in	in	IN
8691	1368	39	somewhat	somewhat	RB
8691	1368	40	different	different	JJ
8691	1368	41	terms	term	NNS
8691	1368	42	.	.	.
8691	1369	1	This	this	DT
8691	1369	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1369	3	oftenest	oftenest	RBS
8691	1369	4	done	do	VBN
8691	1369	5	when	when	WRB
8691	1369	6	the	the	DT
8691	1369	7	decision	decision	NN
8691	1369	8	was	be	VBD
8691	1369	9	made	make	VBN
8691	1369	10	by	by	IN
8691	1369	11	a	a	DT
8691	1369	12	divided	divide	VBN
8691	1369	13	court	court	NN
8691	1369	14	or	or	CC
8691	1369	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	1369	16	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	1369	17	to	to	IN
8691	1369	18	the	the	DT
8691	1369	19	weight	weight	NN
8691	1369	20	of	of	IN
8691	1369	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1369	22	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1369	23	in	in	IN
8691	1369	24	other	other	JJ
8691	1369	25	States	States	NNPS
8691	1369	26	.	.	.
8691	1370	1	Early	early	RB
8691	1370	2	in	in	IN
8691	1370	3	the	the	DT
8691	1370	4	history	history	NN
8691	1370	5	of	of	IN
8691	1370	6	California	California	NNP
8691	1370	7	,	,	,
8691	1370	8	for	for	IN
8691	1370	9	instance	instance	NN
8691	1370	10	,	,	,
8691	1370	11	a	a	DT
8691	1370	12	statute	statute	NN
8691	1370	13	was	be	VBD
8691	1370	14	passed	pass	VBN
8691	1370	15	making	make	VBG
8691	1370	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1370	17	a	a	DT
8691	1370	18	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
8691	1370	19	to	to	TO
8691	1370	20	keep	keep	VB
8691	1370	21	open	open	JJ
8691	1370	22	any	any	DT
8691	1370	23	store	store	NN
8691	1370	24	,	,	,
8691	1370	25	shop	shop	NN
8691	1370	26	or	or	CC
8691	1370	27	factory	factory	NN
8691	1370	28	,	,	,
8691	1370	29	or	or	CC
8691	1370	30	to	to	TO
8691	1370	31	sell	sell	VB
8691	1370	32	goods	good	NNS
8691	1370	33	,	,	,
8691	1370	34	on	on	IN
8691	1370	35	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
8691	1370	36	.	.	.
8691	1371	1	The	the	DT
8691	1371	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1371	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1371	4	of	of	IN
8691	1371	5	the	the	DT
8691	1371	6	State	state	NN
8691	1371	7	held	hold	VBD
8691	1371	8	this	this	DT
8691	1371	9	to	to	TO
8691	1371	10	be	be	VB
8691	1371	11	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	1371	12	to	to	IN
8691	1371	13	the	the	DT
8691	1371	14	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	1371	15	in	in	IN
8691	1371	16	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1371	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1371	18	that	that	IN
8691	1371	19	all	all	DT
8691	1371	20	men	man	NNS
8691	1371	21	had	have	VBD
8691	1371	22	the	the	DT
8691	1371	23	inalienable	inalienable	JJ
8691	1371	24	right	right	NN
8691	1371	25	of	of	IN
8691	1371	26	acquiring	acquire	VBG
8691	1371	27	property	property	NN
8691	1371	28	,	,	,
8691	1371	29	and	and	CC
8691	1371	30	that	that	IN
8691	1371	31	the	the	DT
8691	1371	32	free	free	JJ
8691	1371	33	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	1371	34	of	of	IN
8691	1371	35	religious	religious	JJ
8691	1371	36	profession	profession	NN
8691	1371	37	should	should	MD
8691	1371	38	be	be	VB
8691	1371	39	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	1371	40	without	without	IN
8691	1371	41	discrimination	discrimination	NN
8691	1371	42	or	or	CC
8691	1371	43	preference	preference	NN
8691	1371	44	.	.	.
8691	1372	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	1372	2	of	of	IN
8691	1372	3	the	the	DT
8691	1372	4	other	other	JJ
8691	1372	5	States	States	NNPS
8691	1372	6	had	have	VBD
8691	1372	7	similar	similar	JJ
8691	1372	8	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1372	9	,	,	,
8691	1372	10	and	and	CC
8691	1372	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1372	12	courts	court	NNS
8691	1372	13	had	have	VBD
8691	1372	14	supported	support	VBN
8691	1372	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1372	16	validity	validity	NN
8691	1372	17	.	.	.
8691	1373	1	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	1373	2	Stephen	Stephen	NNP
8691	1373	3	J.	J.	NNP
8691	1374	1	Field	field	NN
8691	1374	2	,	,	,
8691	1374	3	then	then	RB
8691	1374	4	on	on	IN
8691	1374	5	the	the	DT
8691	1374	6	California	California	NNP
8691	1374	7	bench	bench	NN
8691	1374	8	,	,	,
8691	1374	9	dissented	dissent	VBN
8691	1374	10	in	in	IN
8691	1374	11	a	a	DT
8691	1374	12	vigorous	vigorous	JJ
8691	1374	13	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1374	14	.	.	.
8691	1375	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1375	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1375	3	:	:	:
8691	1375	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1375	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	1375	6	parte	parte	NN
8691	1375	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1375	8	Newman	Newman	NNP
8691	1375	9	,	,	,
8691	1375	10	9	9	CD
8691	1375	11	California	California	NNP
8691	1375	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1375	13	,	,	,
8691	1375	14	502	502	CD
8691	1375	15	.	.	.
8691	1375	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1376	1	Three	three	CD
8691	1376	2	years	year	NNS
8691	1376	3	later	later	RB
8691	1376	4	the	the	DT
8691	1376	5	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1376	6	,	,	,
8691	1376	7	unconvinced	unconvince	VBN
8691	1376	8	by	by	IN
8691	1376	9	the	the	DT
8691	1376	10	reasoning	reasoning	NN
8691	1376	11	of	of	IN
8691	1376	12	the	the	DT
8691	1376	13	majority	majority	NN
8691	1376	14	of	of	IN
8691	1376	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1376	16	associates	associate	NNS
8691	1376	17	,	,	,
8691	1376	18	passed	pass	VBD
8691	1376	19	a	a	DT
8691	1376	20	new	new	JJ
8691	1376	21	Sunday	Sunday	NNP
8691	1376	22	law	law	NN
8691	1376	23	,	,	,
8691	1376	24	which	which	WDT
8691	1376	25	did	do	VBD
8691	1376	26	not	not	RB
8691	1376	27	differ	differ	VB
8691	1376	28	materially	materially	RB
8691	1376	29	from	from	IN
8691	1376	30	the	the	DT
8691	1376	31	other	other	JJ
8691	1376	32	,	,	,
8691	1376	33	and	and	CC
8691	1376	34	after	after	IN
8691	1376	35	a	a	DT
8691	1376	36	few	few	JJ
8691	1376	37	months	month	NNS
8691	1376	38	the	the	DT
8691	1376	39	court	court	NN
8691	1376	40	overruled	overrule	VBD
8691	1376	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1376	42	former	former	JJ
8691	1376	43	decision	decision	NN
8691	1376	44	,	,	,
8691	1376	45	on	on	IN
8691	1376	46	the	the	DT
8691	1376	47	very	very	JJ
8691	1376	48	ground	ground	NN
8691	1376	49	taken	take	VBN
8691	1376	50	by	by	IN
8691	1376	51	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	1376	52	Field	Field	NNP
8691	1376	53	.	.	.
8691	1377	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1377	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1377	3	:	:	:
8691	1377	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1377	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	1377	6	parte	parte	NN
8691	1377	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1377	8	Andrews	Andrews	NNP
8691	1377	9	,	,	,
8691	1377	10	18	18	CD
8691	1377	11	California	California	NNP
8691	1377	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1377	13	,	,	,
8691	1377	14	679	679	CD
8691	1377	15	.	.	.
8691	1377	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1378	1	Any	any	DT
8691	1378	2	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	1378	3	from	from	IN
8691	1378	4	a	a	DT
8691	1378	5	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1378	6	setting	set	VBG
8691	1378	7	aside	aside	RP
8691	1378	8	a	a	DT
8691	1378	9	statute	statute	NN
8691	1378	10	greatly	greatly	RB
8691	1378	11	weakens	weaken	VBZ
8691	1378	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1378	13	force	force	NN
8691	1378	14	.	.	.
8691	1379	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1379	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	1379	3	also	also	RB
8691	1379	4	much	much	RB
8691	1379	5	less	less	JJR
8691	1379	6	claim	claim	NN
8691	1379	7	to	to	IN
8691	1379	8	public	public	JJ
8691	1379	9	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	1379	10	if	if	IN
8691	1379	11	all	all	PDT
8691	1379	12	the	the	DT
8691	1379	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1379	14	on	on	IN
8691	1379	15	the	the	DT
8691	1379	16	bench	bench	NN
8691	1379	17	did	do	VBD
8691	1379	18	not	not	RB
8691	1379	19	participate	participate	VB
8691	1379	20	in	in	IN
8691	1379	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1379	22	.	.	.
8691	1380	1	In	in	IN
8691	1380	2	1825	1825	CD
8691	1380	3	,	,	,
8691	1380	4	the	the	DT
8691	1380	5	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1380	6	of	of	IN
8691	1380	7	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1380	8	of	of	IN
8691	1380	9	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1380	10	declined	decline	VBD
8691	1380	11	to	to	TO
8691	1380	12	follow	follow	VB
8691	1380	13	a	a	DT
8691	1380	14	decision	decision	NN
8691	1380	15	of	of	IN
8691	1380	16	the	the	DT
8691	1380	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1380	18	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1380	19	of	of	IN
8691	1380	20	the	the	DT
8691	1380	21	United	United	NNP
8691	1380	22	States	States	NNP
8691	1380	23	,	,	,
8691	1380	24	which	which	WDT
8691	1380	25	held	hold	VBD
8691	1380	26	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1380	27	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1380	28	of	of	IN
8691	1380	29	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1380	30	to	to	TO
8691	1380	31	be	be	VB
8691	1380	32	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	1380	33	to	to	IN
8691	1380	34	the	the	DT
8691	1380	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1380	36	of	of	IN
8691	1380	37	the	the	DT
8691	1380	38	United	United	NNP
8691	1380	39	States	States	NNP
8691	1380	40	.	.	.
8691	1381	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1381	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1381	3	:	:	:
8691	1381	4	Green	Green	NNP
8691	1381	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1381	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1381	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1381	8	Biddle	Biddle	NNP
8691	1381	9	,	,	,
8691	1381	10	8	8	CD
8691	1381	11	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	1381	12	's	's	POS
8691	1381	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1381	14	,	,	,
8691	1381	15	1	1	CD
8691	1381	16	.	.	.
8691	1381	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1382	1	The	the	DT
8691	1382	2	reason	reason	NN
8691	1382	3	stated	state	VBD
8691	1382	4	for	for	IN
8691	1382	5	this	this	DT
8691	1382	6	was	be	VBD
8691	1382	7	that	that	IN
8691	1382	8	the	the	DT
8691	1382	9	decision	decision	NN
8691	1382	10	was	be	VBD
8691	1382	11	not	not	RB
8691	1382	12	concurred	concur	VBN
8691	1382	13	in	in	RP
8691	1382	14	by	by	IN
8691	1382	15	a	a	DT
8691	1382	16	majority	majority	NN
8691	1382	17	of	of	IN
8691	1382	18	the	the	DT
8691	1382	19	court	court	NN
8691	1382	20	.	.	.
8691	1383	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1383	2	had	have	VBD
8691	1383	3	been	be	VBN
8691	1383	4	made	make	VBN
8691	1383	5	by	by	IN
8691	1383	6	a	a	DT
8691	1383	7	majority	majority	NN
8691	1383	8	of	of	IN
8691	1383	9	a	a	DT
8691	1383	10	quorum	quorum	NN
8691	1383	11	,	,	,
8691	1383	12	but	but	CC
8691	1383	13	not	not	RB
8691	1383	14	by	by	IN
8691	1383	15	a	a	DT
8691	1383	16	majority	majority	NN
8691	1383	17	of	of	IN
8691	1383	18	the	the	DT
8691	1383	19	whole	whole	JJ
8691	1383	20	court	court	NN
8691	1383	21	.	.	.
8691	1384	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1384	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1384	3	:	:	:
8691	1384	4	Bodley	Bodley	NNP
8691	1384	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1384	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1384	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1384	8	Gaither	Gaither	NNP
8691	1384	9	,	,	,
8691	1384	10	3	3	CD
8691	1384	11	Monroe	Monroe	NNP
8691	1384	12	's	's	POS
8691	1384	13	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1384	14	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1384	15	,	,	,
8691	1384	16	57	57	CD
8691	1384	17	.	.	.
8691	1384	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1385	1	After	after	IN
8691	1385	2	this	this	DT
8691	1385	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1385	4	became	become	VBD
8691	1385	5	the	the	DT
8691	1385	6	practice	practice	NN
8691	1385	7	of	of	IN
8691	1385	8	the	the	DT
8691	1385	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1385	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1385	11	under	under	IN
8691	1385	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1385	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1385	14	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1385	15	not	not	RB
8691	1385	16	to	to	TO
8691	1385	17	give	give	VB
8691	1385	18	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1385	19	in	in	IN
8691	1385	20	any	any	DT
8691	1385	21	case	case	NN
8691	1385	22	involving	involve	VBG
8691	1385	23	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1385	24	questions	question	NNS
8691	1385	25	,	,	,
8691	1385	26	unless	unless	IN
8691	1385	27	a	a	DT
8691	1385	28	majority	majority	NN
8691	1385	29	of	of	IN
8691	1385	30	the	the	DT
8691	1385	31	court	court	NN
8691	1385	32	concurred	concur	VBN
8691	1385	33	in	in	IN
8691	1385	34	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1385	35	in	in	IN
8691	1385	36	regard	regard	NN
8691	1385	37	to	to	IN
8691	1385	38	these	these	DT
8691	1385	39	.	.	.
8691	1386	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1386	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1386	3	:	:	:
8691	1386	4	New	New	NNP
8691	1386	5	York	York	NNP
8691	1386	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1386	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	1386	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1386	9	Miln	Miln	NNP
8691	1386	10	,	,	,
8691	1386	11	8	8	CD
8691	1386	12	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1386	13	'	'	POS
8691	1386	14	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1386	15	,	,	,
8691	1386	16	118	118	CD
8691	1386	17	,	,	,
8691	1386	18	122	122	CD
8691	1386	19	.	.	.
8691	1386	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1387	1	Several	several	JJ
8691	1387	2	American	american	JJ
8691	1387	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1387	4	have	have	VBP
8691	1387	5	asserted	assert	VBN
8691	1387	6	the	the	DT
8691	1387	7	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1387	8	that	that	IN
8691	1387	9	the	the	DT
8691	1387	10	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	1387	11	can	can	MD
8691	1387	12	disregard	disregard	VB
8691	1387	13	a	a	DT
8691	1387	14	statute	statute	NN
8691	1387	15	which	which	WDT
8691	1387	16	plainly	plainly	RB
8691	1387	17	violates	violate	VBZ
8691	1387	18	the	the	DT
8691	1387	19	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	1387	20	principles	principle	NNS
8691	1387	21	of	of	IN
8691	1387	22	natural	natural	JJ
8691	1387	23	justice	justice	NN
8691	1387	24	,	,	,
8691	1387	25	although	although	IN
8691	1387	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1387	27	may	may	MD
8691	1387	28	not	not	RB
8691	1387	29	contravene	contravene	VB
8691	1387	30	any	any	DT
8691	1387	31	particular	particular	JJ
8691	1387	32	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1387	33	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	1387	34	.	.	.
8691	1388	1	The	the	DT
8691	1388	2	English	english	JJ
8691	1388	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1388	4	now	now	RB
8691	1388	5	claim	claim	VBP
8691	1388	6	no	no	DT
8691	1388	7	such	such	JJ
8691	1388	8	power	power	NN
8691	1388	9	,	,	,
8691	1388	10	although	although	IN
8691	1388	11	Sir	Sir	NNP
8691	1388	12	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	1388	13	Coke	Coke	NNP
8691	1388	14	,	,	,
8691	1388	15	in	in	IN
8691	1388	16	one	one	CD
8691	1388	17	of	of	IN
8691	1388	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1388	19	discursive	discursive	JJ
8691	1388	20	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	1388	21	,	,	,
8691	1388	22	very	very	RB
8691	1388	23	little	little	JJ
8691	1388	24	of	of	IN
8691	1388	25	which	which	WDT
8691	1388	26	was	be	VBD
8691	1388	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1388	28	for	for	IN
8691	1388	29	the	the	DT
8691	1388	30	determination	determination	NN
8691	1388	31	of	of	IN
8691	1388	32	the	the	DT
8691	1388	33	cause	cause	NN
8691	1388	34	,	,	,
8691	1388	35	asserted	assert	VBD
8691	1388	36	that	that	IN
8691	1388	37	an	an	DT
8691	1388	38	act	act	NN
8691	1388	39	of	of	IN
8691	1388	40	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
8691	1388	41	"	"	''
8691	1388	42	against	against	IN
8691	1388	43	common	common	JJ
8691	1388	44	right	right	NN
8691	1388	45	and	and	CC
8691	1388	46	reason	reason	NN
8691	1388	47	"	"	''
8691	1388	48	could	could	MD
8691	1388	49	be	be	VB
8691	1388	50	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
8691	1388	51	void	void	JJ
8691	1388	52	at	at	IN
8691	1388	53	common	common	JJ
8691	1388	54	law	law	NN
8691	1388	55	.	.	.
8691	1389	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1389	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1389	3	:	:	:
8691	1389	4	Dr.	Dr.	NNP
8691	1389	5	Bonham	Bonham	NNP
8691	1389	6	's	's	POS
8691	1389	7	Case	Case	NNP
8691	1389	8	,	,	,
8691	1389	9	8	8	CD
8691	1389	10	Coke	Coke	NNP
8691	1389	11	's	's	POS
8691	1389	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1389	13	,	,	,
8691	1389	14	114	114	CD
8691	1389	15	,	,	,
8691	1389	16	118	118	CD
8691	1389	17	.	.	.
8691	1389	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1390	1	So	so	RB
8691	1390	2	far	far	RB
8691	1390	3	as	as	IN
8691	1390	4	there	there	EX
8691	1390	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1390	6	any	any	DT
8691	1390	7	previous	previous	JJ
8691	1390	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1390	9	authority	authority	NN
8691	1390	10	for	for	IN
8691	1390	11	this	this	DT
8691	1390	12	position	position	NN
8691	1390	13	,	,	,
8691	1390	14	however	however	RB
8691	1390	15	,	,	,
8691	1390	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1390	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	1390	18	believed	believe	VBN
8691	1390	19	that	that	IN
8691	1390	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1390	21	can	can	MD
8691	1390	22	only	only	RB
8691	1390	23	be	be	VB
8691	1390	24	found	find	VBN
8691	1390	25	in	in	IN
8691	1390	26	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	1390	27	made	make	VBN
8691	1390	28	before	before	IN
8691	1390	29	the	the	DT
8691	1390	30	Reformation	Reformation	NNP
8691	1390	31	,	,	,
8691	1390	32	on	on	IN
8691	1390	33	questions	question	NNS
8691	1390	34	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1390	35	from	from	IN
8691	1390	36	interference	interference	NN
8691	1390	37	by	by	IN
8691	1390	38	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
8691	1390	39	with	with	IN
8691	1390	40	rights	right	NNS
8691	1390	41	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	1390	42	under	under	IN
8691	1390	43	the	the	DT
8691	1390	44	Church	Church	NNP
8691	1390	45	of	of	IN
8691	1390	46	Rome	Rome	NNP
8691	1390	47	.	.	.
8691	1391	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	1391	2	questions	question	NNS
8691	1391	3	were	be	VBD
8691	1391	4	of	of	IN
8691	1391	5	the	the	DT
8691	1391	6	nature	nature	NN
8691	1391	7	of	of	IN
8691	1391	8	those	those	DT
8691	1391	9	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1391	10	under	under	IN
8691	1391	11	a	a	DT
8691	1391	12	written	write	VBN
8691	1391	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1391	14	.	.	.
8691	1392	1	The	the	DT
8691	1392	2	law	law	NN
8691	1392	3	of	of	IN
8691	1392	4	the	the	DT
8691	1392	5	church	church	NN
8691	1392	6	within	within	IN
8691	1392	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1392	8	province	province	NN
8691	1392	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1392	10	then	then	RB
8691	1392	11	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	1392	12	as	as	IN
8691	1392	13	a	a	DT
8691	1392	14	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	1392	15	law	law	NN
8691	1392	16	.	.	.
8691	1393	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1393	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1393	3	:	:	:
8691	1393	4	Coxe	Coxe	NNP
8691	1393	5	,	,	,
8691	1393	6	"	"	''
8691	1393	7	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	1393	8	Power	Power	NNP
8691	1393	9	and	and	CC
8691	1393	10	Unconstitutional	Unconstitutional	NNP
8691	1393	11	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
8691	1393	12	,	,	,
8691	1393	13	"	"	''
8691	1393	14	'	'	''
8691	1393	15	147	147	CD
8691	1393	16	,	,	,
8691	1393	17	_	_	NNP
8691	1393	18	et	et	NNP
8691	1393	19	seq	seq	NN
8691	1393	20	_	_	NNP
8691	1393	21	.	.	.
8691	1393	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1394	1	The	the	DT
8691	1394	2	rule	rule	NN
8691	1394	3	laid	lay	VBD
8691	1394	4	down	down	RP
8691	1394	5	by	by	IN
8691	1394	6	Sir	Sir	NNP
8691	1394	7	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	1394	8	Coke	Coke	NNP
8691	1394	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1394	10	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	1394	11	by	by	IN
8691	1394	12	the	the	DT
8691	1394	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1394	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1394	15	of	of	IN
8691	1394	16	South	South	NNP
8691	1394	17	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	1394	18	in	in	IN
8691	1394	19	two	two	CD
8691	1394	20	early	early	JJ
8691	1394	21	cases,[Footnote	cases,[footnote	CD
8691	1394	22	:	:	:
8691	1394	23	Ham	Ham	NNP
8691	1394	24	_	_	NNP
8691	1394	25	v.	v.	IN
8691	1394	26	_	_	NNP
8691	1394	27	M'Claws	M'Claws	NNP
8691	1394	28	,	,	,
8691	1394	29	1	1	CD
8691	1394	30	Bay	Bay	NNP
8691	1394	31	's	's	POS
8691	1394	32	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1394	33	,	,	,
8691	1394	34	98	98	CD
8691	1394	35	;	;	:
8691	1394	36	Bowman	Bowman	NNP
8691	1394	37	_	_	NNP
8691	1394	38	v.	v.	IN
8691	1394	39	_	_	NNP
8691	1394	40	Middleton	Middleton	NNP
8691	1394	41	,	,	,
8691	1394	42	_	_	NNP
8691	1394	43	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
8691	1394	44	_	_	NNP
8691	1394	45	.	.	NNP
8691	1394	46	,	,	,
8691	1394	47	252	252	CD
8691	1394	48	.	.	.
8691	1394	49	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1395	1	and	and	CC
8691	1395	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	1395	3	been	be	VBN
8691	1395	4	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	1395	5	repeated	repeat	VBN
8691	1395	6	in	in	IN
8691	1395	7	some	some	DT
8691	1395	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1395	9	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	1395	10	in	in	IN
8691	1395	11	other	other	JJ
8691	1395	12	States	States	NNPS
8691	1395	13	.	.	.
8691	1396	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1396	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1396	3	:	:	:
8691	1396	4	See	see	VB
8691	1396	5	Goshen	Goshen	NNP
8691	1396	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1396	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	1396	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1396	9	Stonington	Stonington	NNP
8691	1396	10	,	,	,
8691	1396	11	4	4	CD
8691	1396	12	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	1396	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1396	14	,	,	,
8691	1396	15	209	209	CD
8691	1396	16	,	,	,
8691	1396	17	225	225	CD
8691	1396	18	,	,	,
8691	1396	19	and	and	CC
8691	1396	20	Regents	Regents	NNPS
8691	1396	21	_	_	NNP
8691	1396	22	v.	v.	IN
8691	1396	23	_	_	NNP
8691	1396	24	Williams	Williams	NNP
8691	1396	25	,	,	,
8691	1396	26	9	9	CD
8691	1396	27	Gill	Gill	NNP
8691	1396	28	&	&	CC
8691	1396	29	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	1396	30	's	's	POS
8691	1396	31	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1396	32	,	,	,
8691	1396	33	365	365	CD
8691	1396	34	,	,	,
8691	1396	35	31	31	CD
8691	1396	36	American	American	NNP
8691	1396	37	Decisions	Decisions	NNPS
8691	1396	38	,	,	,
8691	1396	39	72	72	CD
8691	1396	40	.	.	.
8691	1396	41	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1397	1	In	in	IN
8691	1397	2	the	the	DT
8691	1397	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1397	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1397	5	of	of	IN
8691	1397	6	the	the	DT
8691	1397	7	United	United	NNP
8691	1397	8	States	States	NNP
8691	1397	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1397	10	authority	authority	NN
8691	1397	11	was	be	VBD
8691	1397	12	emphatically	emphatically	RB
8691	1397	13	denied	deny	VBN
8691	1397	14	by	by	IN
8691	1397	15	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1397	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1397	17	Iredell	Iredell	NNP
8691	1397	18	,	,	,
8691	1397	19	near	near	IN
8691	1397	20	the	the	DT
8691	1397	21	close	close	NN
8691	1397	22	of	of	IN
8691	1397	23	the	the	DT
8691	1397	24	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
8691	1397	25	century,[Footnote	century,[Footnote	NNP
8691	1397	26	:	:	:
8691	1397	27	Calder	Calder	NNP
8691	1397	28	_	_	NNP
8691	1397	29	v.	v.	IN
8691	1397	30	_	_	NNP
8691	1397	31	Bull	Bull	NNP
8691	1397	32	,	,	,
8691	1397	33	3	3	CD
8691	1397	34	Dallas	Dallas	NNP
8691	1397	35	'	'	POS
8691	1397	36	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1397	37	,	,	,
8691	1397	38	386	386	CD
8691	1397	39	,	,	,
8691	1397	40	399	399	CD
8691	1397	41	.	.	.
8691	1397	42	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1398	1	but	but	CC
8691	1398	2	in	in	IN
8691	1398	3	1874	1874	CD
8691	1398	4	the	the	DT
8691	1398	5	full	full	JJ
8691	1398	6	court	court	NN
8691	1398	7	only	only	RB
8691	1398	8	one	one	CD
8691	1398	9	member	member	NN
8691	1398	10	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	1398	11	,	,	,
8691	1398	12	held	hold	VBD
8691	1398	13	a	a	DT
8691	1398	14	State	State	NNP
8691	1398	15	statute	statute	NN
8691	1398	16	void	void	NN
8691	1398	17	which	which	WDT
8691	1398	18	authorized	authorize	VBD
8691	1398	19	cities	city	NNS
8691	1398	20	to	to	TO
8691	1398	21	issue	issue	VB
8691	1398	22	bonds	bond	NNS
8691	1398	23	in	in	IN
8691	1398	24	aid	aid	NN
8691	1398	25	of	of	IN
8691	1398	26	private	private	JJ
8691	1398	27	manufacturing	manufacturing	NN
8691	1398	28	enterprises	enterprise	NNS
8691	1398	29	,	,	,
8691	1398	30	because	because	IN
8691	1398	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1398	32	could	could	MD
8691	1398	33	only	only	RB
8691	1398	34	be	be	VB
8691	1398	35	discharged	discharge	VBN
8691	1398	36	by	by	IN
8691	1398	37	taxation	taxation	NN
8691	1398	38	,	,	,
8691	1398	39	and	and	CC
8691	1398	40	to	to	TO
8691	1398	41	tax	tax	VB
8691	1398	42	for	for	IN
8691	1398	43	such	such	PDT
8691	1398	44	a	a	DT
8691	1398	45	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1398	46	would	would	MD
8691	1398	47	be	be	VB
8691	1398	48	taking	take	VBG
8691	1398	49	property	property	NN
8691	1398	50	from	from	IN
8691	1398	51	all	all	RB
8691	1398	52	for	for	IN
8691	1398	53	the	the	DT
8691	1398	54	good	good	NN
8691	1398	55	of	of	IN
8691	1398	56	one	one	CD
8691	1398	57	.	.	.
8691	1399	1	That	that	DT
8691	1399	2	,	,	,
8691	1399	3	said	say	VBD
8691	1399	4	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1399	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1399	6	Miller	Miller	NNP
8691	1399	7	in	in	IN
8691	1399	8	delivering	deliver	VBG
8691	1399	9	the	the	DT
8691	1399	10	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1399	11	,	,	,
8691	1399	12	"	"	``
8691	1399	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	1399	14	none	none	NN
8691	1399	15	the	the	DT
8691	1399	16	less	less	RBR
8691	1399	17	a	a	DT
8691	1399	18	robbery	robbery	NN
8691	1399	19	because	because	IN
8691	1399	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1399	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	1399	22	done	do	VBN
8691	1399	23	under	under	IN
8691	1399	24	the	the	DT
8691	1399	25	forms	form	NNS
8691	1399	26	of	of	IN
8691	1399	27	law	law	NN
8691	1399	28	and	and	CC
8691	1399	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	1399	30	called	call	VBN
8691	1399	31	taxation	taxation	NN
8691	1399	32	.	.	.
8691	1400	1	This	this	DT
8691	1400	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1400	3	not	not	RB
8691	1400	4	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	1400	5	.	.	.
8691	1401	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1401	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1401	3	a	a	DT
8691	1401	4	decree	decree	NN
8691	1401	5	under	under	IN
8691	1401	6	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1401	7	form	form	NN
8691	1401	8	.	.	.
8691	1402	1	"	"	``
8691	1402	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1402	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	1402	4	:	:	:
8691	1402	5	Loan	Loan	NNP
8691	1402	6	Association	Association	NNP
8691	1402	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1402	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	1402	9	_	_	NNP
8691	1402	10	Topeka	Topeka	NNP
8691	1402	11	,	,	,
8691	1402	12	20	20	CD
8691	1402	13	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	1402	14	's	's	POS
8691	1402	15	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1402	16	,	,	,
8691	1402	17	655	655	CD
8691	1402	18	,	,	,
8691	1402	19	664	664	CD
8691	1402	20	;	;	:
8691	1402	21	approved	approve	VBN
8691	1402	22	in	in	IN
8691	1402	23	Parkersburg	Parkersburg	NNP
8691	1402	24	_	_	NNP
8691	1402	25	v.	v.	IN
8691	1402	26	_	_	NNP
8691	1402	27	Brown	Brown	NNP
8691	1402	28	,	,	,
8691	1402	29	106	106	CD
8691	1402	30	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1402	31	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1402	32	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1402	33	,	,	,
8691	1402	34	487	487	CD
8691	1402	35	,	,	,
8691	1402	36	501	501	CD
8691	1402	37	.	.	.
8691	1402	38	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1403	1	This	this	DT
8691	1403	2	view	view	NN
8691	1403	3	of	of	IN
8691	1403	4	the	the	DT
8691	1403	5	law	law	NN
8691	1403	6	had	have	VBD
8691	1403	7	been	be	VBN
8691	1403	8	forcibly	forcibly	RB
8691	1403	9	,	,	,
8691	1403	10	though	though	IN
8691	1403	11	tentatively	tentatively	RB
8691	1403	12	,	,	,
8691	1403	13	put	put	VBN
8691	1403	14	shortly	shortly	RB
8691	1403	15	after	after	IN
8691	1403	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1403	17	came	come	VBD
8691	1403	18	to	to	IN
8691	1403	19	the	the	DT
8691	1403	20	bench	bench	NN
8691	1403	21	by	by	IN
8691	1403	22	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1403	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1403	24	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1403	25	in	in	IN
8691	1403	26	a	a	DT
8691	1403	27	leading	leading	JJ
8691	1403	28	case,[Footnote	case,[footnote	CD
8691	1403	29	:	:	:
8691	1403	30	Fletcher	Fletcher	NNP
8691	1403	31	_	_	NNP
8691	1403	32	v.	v.	IN
8691	1403	33	_	_	NNP
8691	1403	34	Peck	Peck	NNP
8691	1403	35	,	,	,
8691	1403	36	6	6	CD
8691	1403	37	Cranch	Cranch	NNP
8691	1403	38	's	's	POS
8691	1403	39	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1403	40	,	,	,
8691	1403	41	87	87	CD
8691	1403	42	.	.	.
8691	1403	43	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1404	1	but	but	CC
8691	1404	2	one	one	CD
8691	1404	3	in	in	IN
8691	1404	4	which	which	WDT
8691	1404	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1404	6	was	be	VBD
8691	1404	7	not	not	RB
8691	1404	8	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1404	9	to	to	TO
8691	1404	10	decide	decide	VB
8691	1404	11	whether	whether	IN
8691	1404	12	the	the	DT
8691	1404	13	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1404	14	was	be	VBD
8691	1404	15	sound	sound	JJ
8691	1404	16	.	.	.
8691	1405	1	"	"	``
8691	1405	2	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1405	3	may	may	MD
8691	1405	4	well	well	RB
8691	1405	5	be	be	VB
8691	1405	6	doubted	doubt	VBN
8691	1405	7	,	,	,
8691	1405	8	"	"	''
8691	1405	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1405	10	observed	observe	VBD
8691	1405	11	,	,	,
8691	1405	12	"	"	``
8691	1405	13	whether	whether	IN
8691	1405	14	the	the	DT
8691	1405	15	nature	nature	NN
8691	1405	16	of	of	IN
8691	1405	17	society	society	NN
8691	1405	18	and	and	CC
8691	1405	19	of	of	IN
8691	1405	20	government	government	NN
8691	1405	21	does	do	VBZ
8691	1405	22	not	not	RB
8691	1405	23	prescribe	prescribe	VB
8691	1405	24	some	some	DT
8691	1405	25	limits	limit	NNS
8691	1405	26	to	to	IN
8691	1405	27	the	the	DT
8691	1405	28	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1405	29	power	power	NN
8691	1405	30	;	;	:
8691	1405	31	and	and	CC
8691	1405	32	,	,	,
8691	1405	33	if	if	IN
8691	1405	34	any	any	DT
8691	1405	35	be	be	VB
8691	1405	36	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
8691	1405	37	,	,	,
8691	1405	38	where	where	WRB
8691	1405	39	are	be	VBP
8691	1405	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1405	41	to	to	TO
8691	1405	42	be	be	VB
8691	1405	43	found	find	VBN
8691	1405	44	,	,	,
8691	1405	45	if	if	IN
8691	1405	46	the	the	DT
8691	1405	47	property	property	NN
8691	1405	48	of	of	IN
8691	1405	49	an	an	DT
8691	1405	50	individual	individual	NN
8691	1405	51	,	,	,
8691	1405	52	fairly	fairly	RB
8691	1405	53	and	and	CC
8691	1405	54	honestly	honestly	RB
8691	1405	55	acquired	acquire	VBN
8691	1405	56	,	,	,
8691	1405	57	may	may	MD
8691	1405	58	be	be	VB
8691	1405	59	seized	seize	VBN
8691	1405	60	without	without	IN
8691	1405	61	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	1405	62	?	?	.
8691	1406	1	To	to	IN
8691	1406	2	the	the	DT
8691	1406	3	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1406	4	all	all	DT
8691	1406	5	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1406	6	power	power	NN
8691	1406	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1406	8	granted	grant	VBN
8691	1406	9	;	;	:
8691	1406	10	but	but	CC
8691	1406	11	the	the	DT
8691	1406	12	question	question	NN
8691	1406	13	whether	whether	IN
8691	1406	14	the	the	DT
8691	1406	15	act	act	NN
8691	1406	16	of	of	IN
8691	1406	17	transferring	transfer	VBG
8691	1406	18	the	the	DT
8691	1406	19	property	property	NN
8691	1406	20	of	of	IN
8691	1406	21	an	an	DT
8691	1406	22	individual	individual	NN
8691	1406	23	to	to	IN
8691	1406	24	the	the	DT
8691	1406	25	public	public	NN
8691	1406	26	be	be	VB
8691	1406	27	in	in	IN
8691	1406	28	the	the	DT
8691	1406	29	nature	nature	NN
8691	1406	30	of	of	IN
8691	1406	31	the	the	DT
8691	1406	32	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1406	33	power	power	NN
8691	1406	34	is	be	VBZ
8691	1406	35	well	well	RB
8691	1406	36	worthy	worthy	JJ
8691	1406	37	of	of	IN
8691	1406	38	serious	serious	JJ
8691	1406	39	reflection	reflection	NN
8691	1406	40	.	.	.
8691	1406	41	"	"	''
8691	1407	1	The	the	DT
8691	1407	2	weight	weight	NN
8691	1407	3	of	of	IN
8691	1407	4	American	american	JJ
8691	1407	5	authority	authority	NN
8691	1407	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1407	7	in	in	IN
8691	1407	8	favor	favor	NN
8691	1407	9	of	of	IN
8691	1407	10	the	the	DT
8691	1407	11	position	position	NN
8691	1407	12	taken	take	VBN
8691	1407	13	by	by	IN
8691	1407	14	Iredell	Iredell	NNP
8691	1407	15	.	.	.
8691	1408	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1408	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1408	3	:	:	:
8691	1408	4	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
8691	1408	5	's	's	POS
8691	1408	6	"	"	``
8691	1408	7	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
8691	1408	8	Limitations	limitation	NNS
8691	1408	9	,	,	,
8691	1408	10	"	"	''
8691	1408	11	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	1408	12	,	,	,
8691	1408	13	VII	VII	NNP
8691	1408	14	;	;	:
8691	1408	15	State	State	NNP
8691	1408	16	_	_	NNP
8691	1408	17	v.	v.	IN
8691	1408	18	_	_	NNP
8691	1408	19	Travelers	Travelers	NNPS
8691	1408	20	'	'	POS
8691	1408	21	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	1408	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1408	23	,	,	,
8691	1408	24	73	73	CD
8691	1408	25	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	1408	26	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1408	27	,	,	,
8691	1408	28	255	255	CD
8691	1408	29	,	,	,
8691	1408	30	283	283	CD
8691	1408	31	;	;	:
8691	1408	32	47	47	CD
8691	1408	33	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	1408	34	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	1408	35	,	,	,
8691	1408	36	299	299	CD
8691	1408	37	;	;	:
8691	1408	38	57	57	CD
8691	1408	39	Lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	1408	40	'	'	POS
8691	1408	41	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1408	42	Annotated	annotate	VBD
8691	1408	43	,	,	,
8691	1408	44	481	481	CD
8691	1408	45	.	.	.
8691	1408	46	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1409	1	Time	Time	NNP
8691	1409	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	1409	3	made	make	VBN
8691	1409	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1409	5	safer	safe	JJR
8691	1409	6	to	to	TO
8691	1409	7	stand	stand	VB
8691	1409	8	upon	upon	IN
8691	1409	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1409	10	,	,	,
8691	1409	11	for	for	IN
8691	1409	12	since	since	IN
8691	1409	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1409	14	spoke	speak	VBD
8691	1409	15	not	not	RB
8691	1409	16	only	only	RB
8691	1409	17	have	have	VB
8691	1409	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1409	19	State	state	NN
8691	1409	20	constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	1409	21	been	be	VBN
8691	1409	22	generally	generally	RB
8691	1409	23	expanded	expand	VBN
8691	1409	24	by	by	IN
8691	1409	25	adding	add	VBG
8691	1409	26	important	important	JJ
8691	1409	27	restrictions	restriction	NNS
8691	1409	28	on	on	IN
8691	1409	29	the	the	DT
8691	1409	30	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1409	31	power	power	NN
8691	1409	32	,	,	,
8691	1409	33	but	but	CC
8691	1409	34	the	the	DT
8691	1409	35	fourteenth	fourteenth	NNP
8691	1409	36	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	1409	37	has	have	VBZ
8691	1409	38	added	add	VBN
8691	1409	39	to	to	IN
8691	1409	40	the	the	DT
8691	1409	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1409	42	of	of	IN
8691	1409	43	the	the	DT
8691	1409	44	United	United	NNP
8691	1409	45	States	States	NNP
8691	1409	46	a	a	DT
8691	1409	47	prohibition	prohibition	NN
8691	1409	48	of	of	IN
8691	1409	49	State	state	NN
8691	1409	50	laws	law	NNS
8691	1409	51	depriving	deprive	VBG
8691	1409	52	any	any	DT
8691	1409	53	person	person	NN
8691	1409	54	of	of	IN
8691	1409	55	life	life	NN
8691	1409	56	,	,	,
8691	1409	57	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	1409	58	,	,	,
8691	1409	59	or	or	CC
8691	1409	60	property	property	NN
8691	1409	61	without	without	IN
8691	1409	62	due	due	JJ
8691	1409	63	process	process	NN
8691	1409	64	of	of	IN
8691	1409	65	law	law	NN
8691	1409	66	.	.	.
8691	1410	1	"	"	``
8691	1410	2	Due	due	JJ
8691	1410	3	process	process	NN
8691	1410	4	of	of	IN
8691	1410	5	law	law	NN
8691	1410	6	"	"	''
8691	1410	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1410	8	an	an	DT
8691	1410	9	elastic	elastic	JJ
8691	1410	10	term	term	NN
8691	1410	11	.	.	.
8691	1411	1	Requiring	require	VBG
8691	1411	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1411	3	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	1411	4	imports	import	VBZ
8691	1411	5	that	that	IN
8691	1411	6	no	no	DT
8691	1411	7	one	one	NN
8691	1411	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	1411	9	to	to	TO
8691	1411	10	be	be	VB
8691	1411	11	made	make	VBN
8691	1411	12	to	to	TO
8691	1411	13	suffer	suffer	VB
8691	1411	14	in	in	IN
8691	1411	15	person	person	NN
8691	1411	16	or	or	CC
8691	1411	17	property	property	NN
8691	1411	18	unless	unless	IN
8691	1411	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1411	20	has	have	VBZ
8691	1411	21	had	have	VBN
8691	1411	22	an	an	DT
8691	1411	23	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	1411	24	to	to	TO
8691	1411	25	claim	claim	VB
8691	1411	26	before	before	IN
8691	1411	27	an	an	DT
8691	1411	28	impartial	impartial	JJ
8691	1411	29	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	1411	30	the	the	DT
8691	1411	31	protection	protection	NN
8691	1411	32	of	of	IN
8691	1411	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1411	34	rights	right	NNS
8691	1411	35	by	by	IN
8691	1411	36	the	the	DT
8691	1411	37	settled	settled	JJ
8691	1411	38	law	law	NN
8691	1411	39	of	of	IN
8691	1411	40	the	the	DT
8691	1411	41	land	land	NN
8691	1411	42	.	.	.
8691	1412	1	The	the	DT
8691	1412	2	principle	principle	NN
8691	1412	3	of	of	IN
8691	1412	4	Roman	roman	JJ
8691	1412	5	law	law	NN
8691	1412	6	that	that	WDT
8691	1412	7	,	,	,
8691	1412	8	as	as	IN
8691	1412	9	custom	custom	NN
8691	1412	10	can	can	MD
8691	1412	11	make	make	VB
8691	1412	12	law	law	NN
8691	1412	13	,	,	,
8691	1412	14	so	so	CC
8691	1412	15	disuse	disuse	NN
8691	1412	16	can	can	MD
8691	1412	17	destroy	destroy	VB
8691	1412	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1412	19	has	have	VBZ
8691	1412	20	never	never	RB
8691	1412	21	been	be	VBN
8691	1412	22	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1412	23	in	in	IN
8691	1412	24	the	the	DT
8691	1412	25	United	United	NNP
8691	1412	26	States	States	NNP
8691	1412	27	.	.	.
8691	1413	1	No	no	DT
8691	1413	2	court	court	NN
8691	1413	3	,	,	,
8691	1413	4	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1413	5	,	,	,
8691	1413	6	will	will	MD
8691	1413	7	pronounce	pronounce	VB
8691	1413	8	a	a	DT
8691	1413	9	statute	statute	NN
8691	1413	10	not	not	RB
8691	1413	11	to	to	TO
8691	1413	12	have	have	VB
8691	1413	13	the	the	DT
8691	1413	14	force	force	NN
8691	1413	15	of	of	IN
8691	1413	16	law	law	NN
8691	1413	17	on	on	IN
8691	1413	18	the	the	DT
8691	1413	19	ground	ground	NN
8691	1413	20	that	that	IN
8691	1413	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1413	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	1413	23	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
8691	1413	24	.	.	.
8691	1414	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1414	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1414	3	:	:	:
8691	1414	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1414	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1414	6	Mason	Mason	NNP
8691	1414	7	of	of	IN
8691	1414	8	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
8691	1414	9	,	,	,
8691	1414	10	in	in	IN
8691	1414	11	1840	1840	CD
8691	1414	12	,	,	,
8691	1414	13	undertook	undertake	VBD
8691	1414	14	to	to	TO
8691	1414	15	import	import	VB
8691	1414	16	the	the	DT
8691	1414	17	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1414	18	into	into	IN
8691	1414	19	American	american	JJ
8691	1414	20	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	1414	21	,	,	,
8691	1414	22	but	but	CC
8691	1414	23	without	without	IN
8691	1414	24	effect	effect	NN
8691	1414	25	.	.	.
8691	1415	1	Hill	Hill	NNP
8691	1415	2	_	_	NNP
8691	1415	3	v.	v.	IN
8691	1415	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1415	5	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	1415	6	,	,	,
8691	1415	7	Morris	Morris	NNP
8691	1415	8	'	'	POS
8691	1415	9	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1415	10	,	,	,
8691	1415	11	70	70	CD
8691	1415	12	;	;	:
8691	1415	13	explained	explain	VBD
8691	1415	14	and	and	CC
8691	1415	15	limited	limit	VBN
8691	1415	16	in	in	IN
8691	1415	17	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
8691	1415	18	_	_	NNP
8691	1415	19	v.	v.	IN
8691	1415	20	_	_	NNP
8691	1415	21	International	International	NNP
8691	1415	22	Distillery	Distillery	NNP
8691	1415	23	,	,	,
8691	1415	24	72	72	CD
8691	1415	25	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
8691	1415	26	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1415	27	,	,	,
8691	1415	28	357	357	CD
8691	1415	29	.	.	.
8691	1415	30	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1416	1	*	*	NFP
8691	1416	2	*	*	NFP
8691	1416	3	*	*	NFP
8691	1416	4	*	*	NFP
8691	1416	5	*	*	NFP
8691	1416	6	PART	PART	NNP
8691	1416	7	II	II	NNP
8691	1416	8	THE	the	DT
8691	1416	9	ORGANIZATION	ORGANIZATION	NNP
8691	1416	10	AND	and	CC
8691	1416	11	PRACTICAL	practical	NN
8691	1416	12	WORKING	WORKING	NNP
8691	1416	13	OF	of	IN
8691	1416	14	AMERICAN	AMERICAN	NNP
8691	1416	15	COURTS	COURTS	NNP
8691	1416	16	*	*	NFP
8691	1416	17	*	*	NFP
8691	1416	18	*	*	NFP
8691	1416	19	*	*	NFP
8691	1416	20	*	*	NFP
8691	1416	21	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	1416	22	VIII	viii	NN
8691	1416	23	THE	the	DT
8691	1416	24	ORGANIZATION	organization	NN
8691	1416	25	OF	of	IN
8691	1416	26	THE	the	DT
8691	1416	27	COURTS	COURTS	NNP
8691	1416	28	OF	of	IN
8691	1416	29	THE	the	DT
8691	1416	30	STATES	state	NNS
8691	1416	31	The	the	DT
8691	1416	32	State	State	NNP
8691	1416	33	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	1416	34	differ	differ	VBP
8691	1416	35	fundamentally	fundamentally	RB
8691	1416	36	from	from	IN
8691	1416	37	that	that	DT
8691	1416	38	of	of	IN
8691	1416	39	the	the	DT
8691	1416	40	United	United	NNP
8691	1416	41	States	States	NNP
8691	1416	42	in	in	IN
8691	1416	43	respect	respect	NN
8691	1416	44	to	to	IN
8691	1416	45	the	the	DT
8691	1416	46	nature	nature	NN
8691	1416	47	of	of	IN
8691	1416	48	the	the	DT
8691	1416	49	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1416	50	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	1416	51	.	.	.
8691	1417	1	Each	each	DT
8691	1417	2	of	of	IN
8691	1417	3	the	the	DT
8691	1417	4	States	States	NNP
8691	1417	5	possesses	possess	VBZ
8691	1417	6	all	all	DT
8691	1417	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1417	8	powers	power	NNS
8691	1417	9	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	1417	10	to	to	IN
8691	1417	11	any	any	DT
8691	1417	12	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1417	13	,	,	,
8691	1417	14	except	except	IN
8691	1417	15	so	so	RB
8691	1417	16	far	far	RB
8691	1417	17	as	as	IN
8691	1417	18	the	the	DT
8691	1417	19	people	people	NNS
8691	1417	20	of	of	IN
8691	1417	21	the	the	DT
8691	1417	22	United	United	NNP
8691	1417	23	States	States	NNP
8691	1417	24	may	may	MD
8691	1417	25	have	have	VB
8691	1417	26	provided	provide	VBN
8691	1417	27	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	1417	28	in	in	IN
8691	1417	29	the	the	DT
8691	1417	30	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1417	31	of	of	IN
8691	1417	32	the	the	DT
8691	1417	33	United	United	NNP
8691	1417	34	States	States	NNP
8691	1417	35	.	.	.
8691	1418	1	The	the	DT
8691	1418	2	State	State	NNP
8691	1418	3	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	1418	4	do	do	VBP
8691	1418	5	not	not	RB
8691	1418	6	define	define	VB
8691	1418	7	those	those	DT
8691	1418	8	powers	power	NNS
8691	1418	9	.	.	.
8691	1419	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1419	2	simply	simply	RB
8691	1419	3	commit	commit	VBP
8691	1419	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1419	5	to	to	IN
8691	1419	6	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1419	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	1419	8	and	and	CC
8691	1419	9	officers	officer	NNS
8691	1419	10	.	.	.
8691	1420	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1420	2	general	general	JJ
8691	1420	3	language	language	NN
8691	1420	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1420	5	that	that	IN
8691	1420	6	the	the	DT
8691	1420	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1420	8	power	power	NN
8691	1420	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1420	10	vested	vest	VBN
8691	1420	11	in	in	IN
8691	1420	12	a	a	DT
8691	1420	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1420	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1420	15	and	and	CC
8691	1420	16	such	such	JJ
8691	1420	17	other	other	JJ
8691	1420	18	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	1420	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	1420	20	as	as	IN
8691	1420	21	may	may	MD
8691	1420	22	be	be	VB
8691	1420	23	created	create	VBN
8691	1420	24	by	by	IN
8691	1420	25	law	law	NN
8691	1420	26	.	.	.
8691	1421	1	On	on	IN
8691	1421	2	the	the	DT
8691	1421	3	other	other	JJ
8691	1421	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	1421	5	,	,	,
8691	1421	6	the	the	DT
8691	1421	7	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1421	8	of	of	IN
8691	1421	9	the	the	DT
8691	1421	10	United	United	NNP
8691	1421	11	States	States	NNP
8691	1421	12	defines	define	VBZ
8691	1421	13	the	the	DT
8691	1421	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1421	15	powers	power	NNS
8691	1421	16	of	of	IN
8691	1421	17	the	the	DT
8691	1421	18	United	United	NNP
8691	1421	19	States	States	NNP
8691	1421	20	exactly	exactly	RB
8691	1421	21	and	and	CC
8691	1421	22	within	within	IN
8691	1421	23	a	a	DT
8691	1421	24	somewhat	somewhat	RB
8691	1421	25	narrow	narrow	JJ
8691	1421	26	range	range	NN
8691	1421	27	,	,	,
8691	1421	28	investing	invest	VBG
8691	1421	29	the	the	DT
8691	1421	30	courts	court	NNS
8691	1421	31	of	of	IN
8691	1421	32	the	the	DT
8691	1421	33	United	United	NNP
8691	1421	34	States	States	NNP
8691	1421	35	with	with	IN
8691	1421	36	those	those	DT
8691	1421	37	powers	power	NNS
8691	1421	38	and	and	CC
8691	1421	39	no	no	DT
8691	1421	40	others	other	NNS
8691	1421	41	.	.	.
8691	1422	1	Hence	hence	RB
8691	1422	2	the	the	DT
8691	1422	3	States	state	NNS
8691	1422	4	require	require	VBP
8691	1422	5	a	a	DT
8691	1422	6	much	much	RB
8691	1422	7	more	more	RBR
8691	1422	8	complicated	complicated	JJ
8691	1422	9	and	and	CC
8691	1422	10	extensive	extensive	JJ
8691	1422	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1422	12	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	1422	13	than	than	IN
8691	1422	14	do	do	VB
8691	1422	15	the	the	DT
8691	1422	16	United	United	NNP
8691	1422	17	States	States	NNP
8691	1422	18	,	,	,
8691	1422	19	for	for	IN
8691	1422	20	not	not	RB
8691	1422	21	only	only	RB
8691	1422	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	1422	23	the	the	DT
8691	1422	24	great	great	JJ
8691	1422	25	mass	mass	NN
8691	1422	26	of	of	IN
8691	1422	27	litigated	litigate	VBN
8691	1422	28	cases	case	NNS
8691	1422	29	throughout	throughout	IN
8691	1422	30	the	the	DT
8691	1422	31	country	country	NN
8691	1422	32	to	to	TO
8691	1422	33	be	be	VB
8691	1422	34	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	1422	35	of	of	IN
8691	1422	36	by	by	IN
8691	1422	37	State	state	NN
8691	1422	38	courts	court	NNS
8691	1422	39	,	,	,
8691	1422	40	but	but	CC
8691	1422	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1422	42	must	must	MD
8691	1422	43	also	also	RB
8691	1422	44	pass	pass	VB
8691	1422	45	upon	upon	IN
8691	1422	46	by	by	IN
8691	1422	47	far	far	RB
8691	1422	48	the	the	DT
8691	1422	49	greatest	great	JJS
8691	1422	50	variety	variety	NN
8691	1422	51	of	of	IN
8691	1422	52	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1422	53	questions	question	NNS
8691	1422	54	.	.	.
8691	1423	1	In	in	IN
8691	1423	2	each	each	DT
8691	1423	3	State	state	NN
8691	1423	4	there	there	EX
8691	1423	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	1423	6	one	one	CD
8691	1423	7	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	1423	8	court	court	NN
8691	1423	9	of	of	IN
8691	1423	10	last	last	JJ
8691	1423	11	resort[Footnote	resort[footnote	NN
8691	1423	12	:	:	:
8691	1423	13	See	see	VB
8691	1423	14	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	1423	15	.	.	.
8691	1424	1	XIX	XIX	NNP
8691	1424	2	.	.	.
8691	1424	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1425	1	and	and	CC
8691	1425	2	several	several	JJ
8691	1425	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1425	4	for	for	IN
8691	1425	5	the	the	DT
8691	1425	6	trial	trial	NN
8691	1425	7	of	of	IN
8691	1425	8	original	original	JJ
8691	1425	9	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1425	10	.	.	.
8691	1426	1	Local	local	JJ
8691	1426	2	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1426	3	of	of	IN
8691	1426	4	the	the	DT
8691	1426	5	peace	peace	NN
8691	1426	6	are	be	VBP
8691	1426	7	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	1426	8	given	give	VBN
8691	1426	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1426	10	over	over	IN
8691	1426	11	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	1426	12	for	for	IN
8691	1426	13	petty	petty	JJ
8691	1426	14	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
8691	1426	15	,	,	,
8691	1426	16	and	and	CC
8691	1426	17	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1426	18	cases	case	NNS
8691	1426	19	involving	involve	VBG
8691	1426	20	small	small	JJ
8691	1426	21	amounts	amount	NNS
8691	1426	22	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1426	23	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	1426	24	over	over	IN
8691	1426	25	$	$	$
8691	1426	26	50	50	CD
8691	1426	27	or	or	CC
8691	1426	28	$	$	$
8691	1426	29	100	100	CD
8691	1426	30	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1426	31	,	,	,
8691	1426	32	which	which	WDT
8691	1426	33	do	do	VBP
8691	1426	34	not	not	RB
8691	1426	35	affect	affect	VB
8691	1426	36	title	title	NN
8691	1426	37	to	to	TO
8691	1426	38	land	land	NN
8691	1426	39	.	.	.
8691	1427	1	Then	then	RB
8691	1427	2	come	come	VB
8691	1427	3	County	County	NNP
8691	1427	4	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1427	5	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1427	6	often	often	RB
8691	1427	7	styled	style	VBN
8691	1427	8	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1427	9	of	of	IN
8691	1427	10	Common	Common	NNP
8691	1427	11	Pleas	Pleas	NNPS
8691	1427	12	or	or	CC
8691	1427	13	District	District	NNP
8691	1427	14	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1427	15	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1427	16	,	,	,
8691	1427	17	having	have	VBG
8691	1427	18	cognizance	cognizance	NN
8691	1427	19	of	of	IN
8691	1427	20	actions	action	NNS
8691	1427	21	involving	involve	VBG
8691	1427	22	greater	great	JJR
8691	1427	23	sums	sum	NNS
8691	1427	24	,	,	,
8691	1427	25	and	and	CC
8691	1427	26	to	to	TO
8691	1427	27	which	which	WDT
8691	1427	28	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	1427	29	from	from	IN
8691	1427	30	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1427	31	of	of	IN
8691	1427	32	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1427	33	of	of	IN
8691	1427	34	the	the	DT
8691	1427	35	peace	peace	NN
8691	1427	36	can	can	MD
8691	1427	37	be	be	VB
8691	1427	38	taken	take	VBN
8691	1427	39	.	.	.
8691	1428	1	These	these	DT
8691	1428	2	generally	generally	RB
8691	1428	3	have	have	VBP
8691	1428	4	both	both	DT
8691	1428	5	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1428	6	and	and	CC
8691	1428	7	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1428	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1428	9	.	.	.
8691	1429	1	A	a	DT
8691	1429	2	higher	high	JJR
8691	1429	3	court	court	NN
8691	1429	4	,	,	,
8691	1429	5	which	which	WDT
8691	1429	6	may	may	MD
8691	1429	7	be	be	VB
8691	1429	8	styled	style	VBN
8691	1429	9	a	a	DT
8691	1429	10	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	1429	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1429	12	,	,	,
8691	1429	13	or	or	CC
8691	1429	14	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1429	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1429	16	,	,	,
8691	1429	17	often	often	RB
8691	1429	18	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	1429	19	,	,	,
8691	1429	20	with	with	IN
8691	1429	21	unlimited	unlimited	JJ
8691	1429	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1429	23	as	as	IN
8691	1429	24	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	1429	25	values	value	NNS
8691	1429	26	in	in	IN
8691	1429	27	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	1429	28	,	,	,
8691	1429	29	and	and	CC
8691	1429	30	also	also	RB
8691	1429	31	as	as	IN
8691	1429	32	to	to	IN
8691	1429	33	crimes	crime	NNS
8691	1429	34	,	,	,
8691	1429	35	the	the	DT
8691	1429	36	County	County	NNP
8691	1429	37	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1429	38	in	in	IN
8691	1429	39	such	such	JJ
8691	1429	40	case	case	NN
8691	1429	41	having	have	VBG
8691	1429	42	a	a	DT
8691	1429	43	limited	limited	JJ
8691	1429	44	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1429	45	in	in	IN
8691	1429	46	these	these	DT
8691	1429	47	respects	respect	NNS
8691	1429	48	.	.	.
8691	1430	1	Municipal	municipal	JJ
8691	1430	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1430	3	are	be	VBP
8691	1430	4	to	to	TO
8691	1430	5	be	be	VB
8691	1430	6	found	find	VBN
8691	1430	7	in	in	IN
8691	1430	8	all	all	DT
8691	1430	9	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	1430	10	cities	city	NNS
8691	1430	11	and	and	CC
8691	1430	12	in	in	IN
8691	1430	13	many	many	JJ
8691	1430	14	of	of	IN
8691	1430	15	the	the	DT
8691	1430	16	lesser	less	JJR
8691	1430	17	municipalities	municipality	NNS
8691	1430	18	,	,	,
8691	1430	19	such	such	JJ
8691	1430	20	as	as	IN
8691	1430	21	towns	town	NNS
8691	1430	22	and	and	CC
8691	1430	23	boroughs	borough	NNS
8691	1430	24	.	.	.
8691	1431	1	City	City	NNP
8691	1431	2	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1431	3	often	often	RB
8691	1431	4	have	have	VBP
8691	1431	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1431	6	over	over	IN
8691	1431	7	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1431	8	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1431	9	to	to	TO
8691	1431	10	which	which	WDT
8691	1431	11	one	one	NN
8691	1431	12	residing	reside	VBG
8691	1431	13	in	in	IN
8691	1431	14	the	the	DT
8691	1431	15	city	city	NN
8691	1431	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	1431	17	a	a	DT
8691	1431	18	party	party	NN
8691	1431	19	,	,	,
8691	1431	20	or	or	CC
8691	1431	21	growing	grow	VBG
8691	1431	22	out	out	IN
8691	1431	23	of	of	IN
8691	1431	24	a	a	DT
8691	1431	25	transaction	transaction	NN
8691	1431	26	occurring	occur	VBG
8691	1431	27	within	within	IN
8691	1431	28	the	the	DT
8691	1431	29	city	city	NN
8691	1431	30	,	,	,
8691	1431	31	irrespective	irrespective	RB
8691	1431	32	of	of	IN
8691	1431	33	the	the	DT
8691	1431	34	amount	amount	NN
8691	1431	35	of	of	IN
8691	1431	36	the	the	DT
8691	1431	37	matter	matter	NN
8691	1431	38	in	in	IN
8691	1431	39	demand	demand	NN
8691	1431	40	.	.	.
8691	1432	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1432	2	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	1432	3	have	have	VBP
8691	1432	4	a	a	DT
8691	1432	5	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1432	6	side	side	NN
8691	1432	7	,	,	,
8691	1432	8	before	before	IN
8691	1432	9	which	which	WDT
8691	1432	10	convictions	conviction	NNS
8691	1432	11	may	may	MD
8691	1432	12	be	be	VB
8691	1432	13	had	have	VBN
8691	1432	14	for	for	IN
8691	1432	15	petty	petty	JJ
8691	1432	16	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
8691	1432	17	,	,	,
8691	1432	18	and	and	CC
8691	1432	19	those	those	DT
8691	1432	20	charged	charge	VBN
8691	1432	21	with	with	IN
8691	1432	22	higher	high	JJR
8691	1432	23	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	1432	24	bound	bind	VBN
8691	1432	25	over	over	RP
8691	1432	26	for	for	IN
8691	1432	27	trial	trial	NN
8691	1432	28	in	in	IN
8691	1432	29	some	some	DT
8691	1432	30	court	court	NN
8691	1432	31	of	of	IN
8691	1432	32	general	general	JJ
8691	1432	33	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1432	34	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1432	35	.	.	.
8691	1433	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1433	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1433	3	:	:	:
8691	1433	4	See	see	VB
8691	1433	5	Goodnow	Goodnow	NNP
8691	1433	6	,	,	,
8691	1433	7	"	"	``
8691	1433	8	City	City	NNP
8691	1433	9	Government	Government	NNP
8691	1433	10	in	in	IN
8691	1433	11	the	the	DT
8691	1433	12	United	United	NNP
8691	1433	13	States	States	NNP
8691	1433	14	,	,	,
8691	1433	15	"	"	``
8691	1433	16	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	1433	17	.	.	.
8691	1434	1	IX	ix	NN
8691	1434	2	.	.	.
8691	1434	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1435	1	For	for	IN
8691	1435	2	the	the	DT
8691	1435	3	settlement	settlement	NN
8691	1435	4	of	of	IN
8691	1435	5	the	the	DT
8691	1435	6	estates	estate	NNS
8691	1435	7	of	of	IN
8691	1435	8	deceased	deceased	JJ
8691	1435	9	persons	person	NNS
8691	1435	10	and	and	CC
8691	1435	11	the	the	DT
8691	1435	12	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	1435	13	and	and	CC
8691	1435	14	superintendence	superintendence	NN
8691	1435	15	of	of	IN
8691	1435	16	guardians	guardian	NNS
8691	1435	17	and	and	CC
8691	1435	18	similar	similar	JJ
8691	1435	19	agents	agent	NNS
8691	1435	20	of	of	IN
8691	1435	21	the	the	DT
8691	1435	22	law	law	NN
8691	1435	23	,	,	,
8691	1435	24	and	and	CC
8691	1435	25	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1435	26	in	in	IN
8691	1435	27	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	1435	28	,	,	,
8691	1435	29	there	there	EX
8691	1435	30	are	be	VBP
8691	1435	31	in	in	IN
8691	1435	32	many	many	JJ
8691	1435	33	States	States	NNPS
8691	1435	34	special	special	JJ
8691	1435	35	courts	court	NNS
8691	1435	36	,	,	,
8691	1435	37	known	know	VBN
8691	1435	38	as	as	IN
8691	1435	39	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1435	40	of	of	IN
8691	1435	41	Probate	Probate	NNP
8691	1435	42	,	,	,
8691	1435	43	Surrogate	Surrogate	NNP
8691	1435	44	's	's	POS
8691	1435	45	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1435	46	,	,	,
8691	1435	47	or	or	CC
8691	1435	48	Orphans	Orphans	NNPS
8691	1435	49	'	'	POS
8691	1435	50	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1435	51	,	,	,
8691	1435	52	and	and	CC
8691	1435	53	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1435	54	of	of	IN
8691	1435	55	Insolvency	Insolvency	NNP
8691	1435	56	.	.	.
8691	1436	1	In	in	IN
8691	1436	2	others	other	NNS
8691	1436	3	these	these	DT
8691	1436	4	functions	function	NNS
8691	1436	5	belong	belong	VBP
8691	1436	6	to	to	IN
8691	1436	7	the	the	DT
8691	1436	8	County	County	NNP
8691	1436	9	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1436	10	.	.	.
8691	1437	1	The	the	DT
8691	1437	2	early	early	JJ
8691	1437	3	practice	practice	NN
8691	1437	4	in	in	IN
8691	1437	5	this	this	DT
8691	1437	6	country	country	NN
8691	1437	7	favored	favor	VBD
8691	1437	8	having	have	VBG
8691	1437	9	several	several	JJ
8691	1437	10	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1437	11	hold	hold	VB
8691	1437	12	all	all	DT
8691	1437	13	trial	trial	NN
8691	1437	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	1437	15	,	,	,
8691	1437	16	whether	whether	IN
8691	1437	17	a	a	DT
8691	1437	18	jury	jury	NN
8691	1437	19	was	be	VBD
8691	1437	20	or	or	CC
8691	1437	21	was	be	VBD
8691	1437	22	not	not	RB
8691	1437	23	to	to	TO
8691	1437	24	be	be	VB
8691	1437	25	called	call	VBN
8691	1437	26	in	in	RP
8691	1437	27	.	.	.
8691	1438	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1438	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1438	3	a	a	DT
8691	1438	4	method	method	NN
8691	1438	5	wasteful	wasteful	JJ
8691	1438	6	of	of	IN
8691	1438	7	time	time	NN
8691	1438	8	and	and	CC
8691	1438	9	money	money	NN
8691	1438	10	.	.	.
8691	1439	1	In	in	IN
8691	1439	2	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	1439	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1439	4	survived	survive	VBD
8691	1439	5	for	for	IN
8691	1439	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1439	7	highest	high	JJS
8691	1439	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1439	9	nisi	nisi	NNP
8691	1439	10	prius	prius	NNP
8691	1439	11	_	_	NNP
8691	1439	12	court	court	NN
8691	1439	13	until	until	IN
8691	1439	14	1804	1804	CD
8691	1439	15	.	.	.
8691	1440	1	In	in	IN
8691	1440	2	many	many	JJ
8691	1440	3	States	state	NNS
8691	1440	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1440	5	endured	endure	VBD
8691	1440	6	much	much	RB
8691	1440	7	longer	long	JJR
8691	1440	8	for	for	IN
8691	1440	9	County	County	NNP
8691	1440	10	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1440	11	.	.	.
8691	1441	1	County	County	NNP
8691	1441	2	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1441	3	in	in	IN
8691	1441	4	some	some	DT
8691	1441	5	States	state	NNS
8691	1441	6	are	be	VBP
8691	1441	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	1441	8	only	only	RB
8691	1441	9	in	in	IN
8691	1441	10	name	name	NN
8691	1441	11	,	,	,
8691	1441	12	except	except	IN
8691	1441	13	,	,	,
8691	1441	14	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	1441	15	,	,	,
8691	1441	16	for	for	IN
8691	1441	17	some	some	DT
8691	1441	18	very	very	RB
8691	1441	19	limited	limited	JJ
8691	1441	20	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	1441	21	.	.	.
8691	1442	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1442	2	real	real	JJ
8691	1442	3	functions	function	NNS
8691	1442	4	are	be	VBP
8691	1442	5	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	1442	6	.	.	.
8691	1443	1	Some	some	DT
8691	1443	2	or	or	CC
8691	1443	3	all	all	DT
8691	1443	4	of	of	IN
8691	1443	5	those	those	DT
8691	1443	6	who	who	WP
8691	1443	7	hold	hold	VBP
8691	1443	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1443	9	are	be	VBP
8691	1443	10	often	often	RB
8691	1443	11	styled	style	VBN
8691	1443	12	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
8691	1443	13	,	,	,
8691	1443	14	and	and	CC
8691	1443	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1443	16	principal	principal	JJ
8691	1443	17	duties	duty	NNS
8691	1443	18	are	be	VBP
8691	1443	19	to	to	TO
8691	1443	20	manage	manage	VB
8691	1443	21	the	the	DT
8691	1443	22	general	general	JJ
8691	1443	23	business	business	NN
8691	1443	24	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	1443	25	of	of	IN
8691	1443	26	the	the	DT
8691	1443	27	county	county	NN
8691	1443	28	.	.	.
8691	1444	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1444	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1444	3	:	:	:
8691	1444	4	See	see	VB
8691	1444	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1444	6	of	of	IN
8691	1444	7	West	West	NNP
8691	1444	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	1444	9	,	,	,
8691	1444	10	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
8691	1444	11	of	of	IN
8691	1444	12	1880	1880	CD
8691	1444	13	;	;	:
8691	1444	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1444	15	of	of	IN
8691	1444	16	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
8691	1444	17	,	,	,
8691	1444	18	Art	Art	NNP
8691	1444	19	.	.	.
8691	1445	1	VII	VII	NNP
8691	1445	2	,	,	,
8691	1445	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	1445	4	.	.	.
8691	1446	1	12	12	CD
8691	1446	2	.	.	.
8691	1446	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1447	1	A	a	DT
8691	1447	2	statute	statute	NN
8691	1447	3	passed	pass	VBN
8691	1447	4	by	by	IN
8691	1447	5	Oregon	Oregon	NNP
8691	1447	6	in	in	IN
8691	1447	7	1903	1903	CD
8691	1447	8	indicates	indicate	VBZ
8691	1447	9	that	that	IN
8691	1447	10	those	those	DT
8691	1447	11	in	in	IN
8691	1447	12	that	that	DT
8691	1447	13	State	state	NN
8691	1447	14	are	be	VBP
8691	1447	15	not	not	RB
8691	1447	16	fountains	fountain	NNS
8691	1447	17	of	of	IN
8691	1447	18	law	law	NN
8691	1447	19	,	,	,
8691	1447	20	for	for	IN
8691	1447	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1447	22	requires	require	VBZ
8691	1447	23	the	the	DT
8691	1447	24	district	district	NN
8691	1447	25	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	1447	26	in	in	IN
8691	1447	27	each	each	DT
8691	1447	28	county	county	NN
8691	1447	29	,	,	,
8691	1447	30	or	or	CC
8691	1447	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1447	32	deputies	deputy	NNS
8691	1447	33	,	,	,
8691	1447	34	to	to	TO
8691	1447	35	advise	advise	VB
8691	1447	36	the	the	DT
8691	1447	37	County	County	NNP
8691	1447	38	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1447	39	"	"	''
8691	1447	40	on	on	IN
8691	1447	41	all	all	DT
8691	1447	42	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1447	43	questions	question	NNS
8691	1447	44	that	that	WDT
8691	1447	45	may	may	MD
8691	1447	46	arise	arise	VB
8691	1447	47	.	.	.
8691	1447	48	"	"	''
8691	1448	1	In	in	IN
8691	1448	2	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	1448	3	,	,	,
8691	1448	4	County	County	NNP
8691	1448	5	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1448	6	for	for	IN
8691	1448	7	a	a	DT
8691	1448	8	long	long	JJ
8691	1448	9	period	period	NN
8691	1448	10	were	be	VBD
8691	1448	11	held	hold	VBN
8691	1448	12	by	by	IN
8691	1448	13	all	all	PDT
8691	1448	14	the	the	DT
8691	1448	15	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1448	16	of	of	IN
8691	1448	17	the	the	DT
8691	1448	18	peace	peace	NN
8691	1448	19	in	in	IN
8691	1448	20	the	the	DT
8691	1448	21	county	county	NN
8691	1448	22	,	,	,
8691	1448	23	or	or	CC
8691	1448	24	such	such	JJ
8691	1448	25	of	of	IN
8691	1448	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1448	27	as	as	IN
8691	1448	28	might	may	MD
8691	1448	29	attend	attend	VB
8691	1448	30	.	.	.
8691	1449	1	These	these	DT
8691	1449	2	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
8691	1449	3	nominated	nominate	VBD
8691	1449	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1449	5	own	own	JJ
8691	1449	6	successors	successor	NNS
8691	1449	7	to	to	IN
8691	1449	8	the	the	DT
8691	1449	9	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1449	10	,	,	,
8691	1449	11	who	who	WP
8691	1449	12	almost	almost	RB
8691	1449	13	never	never	RB
8691	1449	14	refused	refuse	VBD
8691	1449	15	to	to	TO
8691	1449	16	commission	commission	VB
8691	1449	17	the	the	DT
8691	1449	18	person	person	NN
8691	1449	19	so	so	RB
8691	1449	20	recommended	recommend	VBD
8691	1449	21	.	.	.
8691	1450	1	The	the	DT
8691	1450	2	court	court	NN
8691	1450	3	also	also	RB
8691	1450	4	nominated	nominate	VBD
8691	1450	5	the	the	DT
8691	1450	6	officers	officer	NNS
8691	1450	7	of	of	IN
8691	1450	8	militia	militia	NN
8691	1450	9	below	below	IN
8691	1450	10	the	the	DT
8691	1450	11	rank	rank	NN
8691	1450	12	of	of	IN
8691	1450	13	General	General	NNP
8691	1450	14	,	,	,
8691	1450	15	and	and	CC
8691	1450	16	managed	manage	VBD
8691	1450	17	all	all	PDT
8691	1450	18	the	the	DT
8691	1450	19	county	county	NN
8691	1450	20	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	1450	21	,	,	,
8691	1450	22	besides	besides	IN
8691	1450	23	having	have	VBG
8691	1450	24	an	an	DT
8691	1450	25	extensive	extensive	JJ
8691	1450	26	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1450	27	and	and	CC
8691	1450	28	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1450	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1450	30	,	,	,
8691	1450	31	including	include	VBG
8691	1450	32	the	the	DT
8691	1450	33	power	power	NN
8691	1450	34	of	of	IN
8691	1450	35	acquittal	acquittal	NN
8691	1450	36	in	in	IN
8691	1450	37	cases	case	NNS
8691	1450	38	of	of	IN
8691	1450	39	felony	felony	NN
8691	1450	40	.	.	.
8691	1451	1	However	however	WRB
8691	1451	2	clumsy	clumsy	JJ
8691	1451	3	and	and	CC
8691	1451	4	ill	ill	RB
8691	1451	5	-	-	HYPH
8691	1451	6	ordered	order	VBN
8691	1451	7	such	such	PDT
8691	1451	8	a	a	DT
8691	1451	9	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	1451	10	appears	appear	VBZ
8691	1451	11	,	,	,
8691	1451	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1451	13	gave	give	VBD
8691	1451	14	general	general	JJ
8691	1451	15	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
8691	1451	16	for	for	IN
8691	1451	17	a	a	DT
8691	1451	18	long	long	JJ
8691	1451	19	course	course	NN
8691	1451	20	of	of	IN
8691	1451	21	years	year	NNS
8691	1451	22	,	,	,
8691	1451	23	partly	partly	RB
8691	1451	24	from	from	IN
8691	1451	25	a	a	DT
8691	1451	26	usage	usage	NN
8691	1451	27	on	on	IN
8691	1451	28	the	the	DT
8691	1451	29	part	part	NN
8691	1451	30	of	of	IN
8691	1451	31	the	the	DT
8691	1451	32	older	old	JJR
8691	1451	33	members	member	NNS
8691	1451	34	of	of	IN
8691	1451	35	the	the	DT
8691	1451	36	bar	bar	NN
8691	1451	37	who	who	WP
8691	1451	38	might	may	MD
8691	1451	39	be	be	VB
8691	1451	40	in	in	IN
8691	1451	41	attendance	attendance	NN
8691	1451	42	to	to	TO
8691	1451	43	volunteer	volunteer	VB
8691	1451	44	advice	advice	NN
8691	1451	45	as	as	IN
8691	1451	46	_	_	NNP
8691	1451	47	"	"	``
8691	1451	48	amci	amci	NN
8691	1451	49	curiae	curia	NNS
8691	1451	50	"	"	''
8691	1451	51	_	_	NNP
8691	1451	52	whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	1451	53	any	any	DT
8691	1451	54	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
8691	1451	55	question	question	NN
8691	1451	56	of	of	IN
8691	1451	57	law	law	NN
8691	1451	58	chanced	chance	VBD
8691	1451	59	to	to	TO
8691	1451	60	arise	arise	VB
8691	1451	61	.	.	.
8691	1452	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1452	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1452	3	:	:	:
8691	1452	4	Tucker	Tucker	NNP
8691	1452	5	,	,	,
8691	1452	6	"	"	``
8691	1452	7	Life	life	NN
8691	1452	8	of	of	IN
8691	1452	9	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
8691	1452	10	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	1452	11	,	,	,
8691	1452	12	"	"	``
8691	1452	13	II	ii	CD
8691	1452	14	,	,	,
8691	1452	15	378	378	CD
8691	1452	16	;	;	:
8691	1452	17	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
8691	1452	18	,	,	,
8691	1452	19	"	"	``
8691	1452	20	Memoirs	Memoirs	NNP
8691	1452	21	of	of	IN
8691	1452	22	William	William	NNP
8691	1452	23	Wirt	Wirt	NNP
8691	1452	24	,	,	,
8691	1452	25	"	"	``
8691	1452	26	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1452	27	,	,	,
8691	1452	28	59	59	CD
8691	1452	29	.	.	.
8691	1452	30	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1453	1	Even	even	RB
8691	1453	2	in	in	IN
8691	1453	3	States	States	NNP
8691	1453	4	where	where	WRB
8691	1453	5	County	County	NNP
8691	1453	6	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1453	7	have	have	VBP
8691	1453	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1453	9	of	of	IN
8691	1453	10	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	1453	11	lawsuits	lawsuit	NNS
8691	1453	12	the	the	DT
8691	1453	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1453	14	,	,	,
8691	1453	15	or	or	CC
8691	1453	16	a	a	DT
8691	1453	17	majority	majority	NN
8691	1453	18	of	of	IN
8691	1453	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1453	20	,	,	,
8691	1453	21	are	be	VBP
8691	1453	22	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	1453	23	without	without	IN
8691	1453	24	any	any	DT
8691	1453	25	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1453	26	training	training	NN
8691	1453	27	,	,	,
8691	1453	28	though	though	IN
8691	1453	29	this	this	DT
8691	1453	30	is	be	VBZ
8691	1453	31	now	now	RB
8691	1453	32	less	less	RBR
8691	1453	33	common	common	JJ
8691	1453	34	than	than	IN
8691	1453	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1453	36	once	once	RB
8691	1453	37	was	be	VBD
8691	1453	38	.	.	.
8691	1454	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1454	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1454	3	:	:	:
8691	1454	4	McMaster	McMaster	NNP
8691	1454	5	,	,	,
8691	1454	6	"	"	``
8691	1454	7	History	history	NN
8691	1454	8	of	of	IN
8691	1454	9	the	the	DT
8691	1454	10	People	People	NNS
8691	1454	11	of	of	IN
8691	1454	12	the	the	DT
8691	1454	13	United	United	NNP
8691	1454	14	States	States	NNP
8691	1454	15	,	,	,
8691	1454	16	"	"	``
8691	1454	17	III	iii	CD
8691	1454	18	,	,	,
8691	1454	19	154	154	CD
8691	1454	20	.	.	.
8691	1454	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1455	1	The	the	DT
8691	1455	2	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	1455	3	of	of	IN
8691	1455	4	the	the	DT
8691	1455	5	States	States	NNP
8691	1455	6	generally	generally	RB
8691	1455	7	require	require	VBP
8691	1455	8	the	the	DT
8691	1455	9	existence	existence	NN
8691	1455	10	of	of	IN
8691	1455	11	a	a	DT
8691	1455	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1455	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1455	14	of	of	IN
8691	1455	15	last	last	JJ
8691	1455	16	resort	resort	NN
8691	1455	17	,	,	,
8691	1455	18	and	and	CC
8691	1455	19	often	often	RB
8691	1455	20	specify	specify	VBP
8691	1455	21	also	also	RB
8691	1455	22	by	by	IN
8691	1455	23	name	name	NN
8691	1455	24	one	one	CD
8691	1455	25	or	or	CC
8691	1455	26	more	more	JJR
8691	1455	27	of	of	IN
8691	1455	28	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	1455	29	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1455	30	.	.	.
8691	1456	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	1456	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1456	3	stand	stand	VBP
8691	1456	4	on	on	IN
8691	1456	5	a	a	DT
8691	1456	6	firmer	firm	JJR
8691	1456	7	footing	footing	NN
8691	1456	8	than	than	IN
8691	1456	9	those	those	DT
8691	1456	10	created	create	VBN
8691	1456	11	by	by	IN
8691	1456	12	the	the	DT
8691	1456	13	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1456	14	under	under	IN
8691	1456	15	a	a	DT
8691	1456	16	general	general	JJ
8691	1456	17	power	power	NN
8691	1456	18	to	to	TO
8691	1456	19	establish	establish	VB
8691	1456	20	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	1456	21	courts	court	NNS
8691	1456	22	.	.	.
8691	1457	1	The	the	DT
8691	1457	2	power	power	NN
8691	1457	3	to	to	TO
8691	1457	4	establish	establish	VB
8691	1457	5	implies	imply	VBZ
8691	1457	6	a	a	DT
8691	1457	7	power	power	NN
8691	1457	8	to	to	TO
8691	1457	9	limit	limit	VB
8691	1457	10	and	and	CC
8691	1457	11	to	to	TO
8691	1457	12	destroy	destroy	VB
8691	1457	13	.	.	.
8691	1458	1	A	a	DT
8691	1458	2	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	1458	3	created	create	VBN
8691	1458	4	by	by	IN
8691	1458	5	a	a	DT
8691	1458	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1458	7	,	,	,
8691	1458	8	with	with	IN
8691	1458	9	functions	function	NNS
8691	1458	10	defined	define	VBN
8691	1458	11	in	in	IN
8691	1458	12	the	the	DT
8691	1458	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1458	14	,	,	,
8691	1458	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	1458	16	,	,	,
8691	1458	17	as	as	IN
8691	1458	18	to	to	IN
8691	1458	19	these	these	DT
8691	1458	20	and	and	CC
8691	1458	21	as	as	IN
8691	1458	22	to	to	IN
8691	1458	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1458	24	independence	independence	NN
8691	1458	25	of	of	IN
8691	1458	26	existence	existence	NN
8691	1458	27	and	and	CC
8691	1458	28	action	action	NN
8691	1458	29	,	,	,
8691	1458	30	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	1458	31	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1458	32	control	control	NN
8691	1458	33	.	.	.
8691	1459	1	The	the	DT
8691	1459	2	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
8691	1459	3	in	in	IN
8691	1459	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1459	5	were	be	VBD
8691	1459	6	within	within	IN
8691	1459	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1459	8	rights	right	NNS
8691	1459	9	when	when	WRB
8691	1459	10	,	,	,
8691	1459	11	in	in	IN
8691	1459	12	1802	1802	CD
8691	1459	13	,	,	,
8691	1459	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1459	15	repealed	repeal	VBD
8691	1459	16	the	the	DT
8691	1459	17	act	act	NN
8691	1459	18	passed	pass	VBN
8691	1459	19	by	by	IN
8691	1459	20	the	the	DT
8691	1459	21	Federalists	Federalists	NNPS
8691	1459	22	the	the	DT
8691	1459	23	year	year	NN
8691	1459	24	before	before	RB
8691	1459	25	to	to	TO
8691	1459	26	create	create	VB
8691	1459	27	a	a	DT
8691	1459	28	system	system	NN
8691	1459	29	of	of	IN
8691	1459	30	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1459	31	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1459	32	.	.	.
8691	1460	1	Those	those	DT
8691	1460	2	of	of	IN
8691	1460	3	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	1460	4	were	be	VBD
8691	1460	5	within	within	IN
8691	1460	6	theirs	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1460	7	when	when	WRB
8691	1460	8	,	,	,
8691	1460	9	in	in	IN
8691	1460	10	1811	1811	CD
8691	1460	11	,	,	,
8691	1460	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1460	13	abolished	abolish	VBD
8691	1460	14	the	the	DT
8691	1460	15	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	1460	16	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1460	17	of	of	IN
8691	1460	18	Common	Common	NNP
8691	1460	19	Pleas	Pleas	NNPS
8691	1460	20	of	of	IN
8691	1460	21	that	that	DT
8691	1460	22	State	state	NN
8691	1460	23	and	and	CC
8691	1460	24	created	create	VBD
8691	1460	25	a	a	DT
8691	1460	26	new	new	JJ
8691	1460	27	"	"	``
8691	1460	28	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1460	29	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1460	30	,	,	,
8691	1460	31	"	"	''
8691	1460	32	with	with	IN
8691	1460	33	fifteen	fifteen	CD
8691	1460	34	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1460	35	,	,	,
8691	1460	36	to	to	TO
8691	1460	37	take	take	VB
8691	1460	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1460	39	place	place	NN
8691	1460	40	.	.	.
8691	1461	1	Both	both	DT
8691	1461	2	would	would	MD
8691	1461	3	have	have	VB
8691	1461	4	been	be	VBN
8691	1461	5	glad	glad	JJ
8691	1461	6	to	to	TO
8691	1461	7	go	go	VB
8691	1461	8	farther	farther	RB
8691	1461	9	and	and	CC
8691	1461	10	reconstitute	reconstitute	VB
8691	1461	11	in	in	IN
8691	1461	12	some	some	DT
8691	1461	13	way	way	NN
8691	1461	14	the	the	DT
8691	1461	15	court	court	NN
8691	1461	16	of	of	IN
8691	1461	17	last	last	JJ
8691	1461	18	resort	resort	NN
8691	1461	19	,	,	,
8691	1461	20	which	which	WDT
8691	1461	21	was	be	VBD
8691	1461	22	filled	fill	VBN
8691	1461	23	with	with	IN
8691	1461	24	old	old	JJ
8691	1461	25	Federalists	federalist	NNS
8691	1461	26	.	.	.
8691	1462	1	Why	why	WRB
8691	1462	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1462	3	did	do	VBD
8691	1462	4	not	not	RB
8691	1462	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	1462	6	been	be	VBN
8691	1462	7	frankly	frankly	RB
8691	1462	8	stated	state	VBN
8691	1462	9	by	by	IN
8691	1462	10	one	one	CD
8691	1462	11	of	of	IN
8691	1462	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1462	13	in	in	IN
8691	1462	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1462	15	account	account	NN
8691	1462	16	of	of	IN
8691	1462	17	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1462	18	Gerry	Gerry	NNP
8691	1462	19	's	's	POS
8691	1462	20	administration	administration	NN
8691	1462	21	:	:	:
8691	1462	22	With	with	IN
8691	1462	23	the	the	DT
8691	1462	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1462	25	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	1462	26	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1462	27	the	the	DT
8691	1462	28	party	party	NN
8691	1462	29	did	do	VBD
8691	1462	30	not	not	RB
8691	1462	31	interfere	interfere	VB
8691	1462	32	.	.	.
8691	1463	1	In	in	IN
8691	1463	2	respect	respect	NN
8691	1463	3	for	for	IN
8691	1463	4	the	the	DT
8691	1463	5	authority	authority	NN
8691	1463	6	of	of	IN
8691	1463	7	the	the	DT
8691	1463	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1463	9	this	this	DT
8691	1463	10	forbearance	forbearance	NN
8691	1463	11	was	be	VBD
8691	1463	12	observed	observe	VBN
8691	1463	13	;	;	:
8691	1463	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1463	15	having	have	VBG
8691	1463	16	been	be	VBN
8691	1463	17	conceded	concede	VBN
8691	1463	18	after	after	IN
8691	1463	19	due	due	JJ
8691	1463	20	deliberation	deliberation	NN
8691	1463	21	by	by	IN
8691	1463	22	men	man	NNS
8691	1463	23	having	have	VBG
8691	1463	24	the	the	DT
8691	1463	25	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	1463	26	of	of	IN
8691	1463	27	the	the	DT
8691	1463	28	dominant	dominant	JJ
8691	1463	29	party	party	NN
8691	1463	30	that	that	WDT
8691	1463	31	neither	neither	CC
8691	1463	32	the	the	DT
8691	1463	33	court	court	NN
8691	1463	34	nor	nor	CC
8691	1463	35	the	the	DT
8691	1463	36	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1463	37	were	be	VBD
8691	1463	38	within	within	IN
8691	1463	39	the	the	DT
8691	1463	40	power	power	NN
8691	1463	41	of	of	IN
8691	1463	42	the	the	DT
8691	1463	43	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1463	44	.	.	.
8691	1464	1	The	the	DT
8691	1464	2	result	result	NN
8691	1464	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1464	4	very	very	RB
8691	1464	5	reluctantly	reluctantly	RB
8691	1464	6	acceded	accede	VBN
8691	1464	7	to	to	IN
8691	1464	8	,	,	,
8691	1464	9	for	for	IN
8691	1464	10	the	the	DT
8691	1464	11	imposing	imposing	JJ
8691	1464	12	influence	influence	NN
8691	1464	13	of	of	IN
8691	1464	14	that	that	DT
8691	1464	15	court	court	NN
8691	1464	16	had	have	VBD
8691	1464	17	been	be	VBN
8691	1464	18	felt	feel	VBN
8691	1464	19	in	in	IN
8691	1464	20	the	the	DT
8691	1464	21	political	political	JJ
8691	1464	22	agitation	agitation	NN
8691	1464	23	of	of	IN
8691	1464	24	the	the	DT
8691	1464	25	times	time	NNS
8691	1464	26	,	,	,
8691	1464	27	and	and	CC
8691	1464	28	some	some	DT
8691	1464	29	of	of	IN
8691	1464	30	the	the	DT
8691	1464	31	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1464	32	,	,	,
8691	1464	33	like	like	IN
8691	1464	34	some	some	DT
8691	1464	35	ministers	minister	NNS
8691	1464	36	of	of	IN
8691	1464	37	the	the	DT
8691	1464	38	gospel	gospel	NN
8691	1464	39	,	,	,
8691	1464	40	had	have	VBD
8691	1464	41	been	be	VBN
8691	1464	42	unwise	unwise	JJ
8691	1464	43	enough	enough	RB
8691	1464	44	to	to	TO
8691	1464	45	give	give	VB
8691	1464	46	to	to	IN
8691	1464	47	the	the	DT
8691	1464	48	extension	extension	NN
8691	1464	49	of	of	IN
8691	1464	50	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1464	51	political	political	JJ
8691	1464	52	feelings	feeling	NNS
8691	1464	53	the	the	DT
8691	1464	54	aid	aid	NN
8691	1464	55	directly	directly	RB
8691	1464	56	derived	derive	VBN
8691	1464	57	from	from	IN
8691	1464	58	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1464	59	official	official	JJ
8691	1464	60	authority	authority	NN
8691	1464	61	.	.	.
8691	1465	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1465	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1465	3	:	:	:
8691	1465	4	Austin	Austin	NNP
8691	1465	5	,	,	,
8691	1465	6	"	"	``
8691	1465	7	Life	Life	NNP
8691	1465	8	of	of	IN
8691	1465	9	Elbridge	Elbridge	NNP
8691	1465	10	Gerry	Gerry	NNP
8691	1465	11	,	,	,
8691	1465	12	"	"	``
8691	1465	13	II	ii	CD
8691	1465	14	,	,	,
8691	1465	15	339	339	CD
8691	1465	16	.	.	.
8691	1466	1	See	see	VB
8691	1466	2	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	1466	3	.	.	.
8691	1467	1	XXII	XXII	NNP
8691	1467	2	.	.	.
8691	1467	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1468	1	The	the	DT
8691	1468	2	weakest	weak	JJS
8691	1468	3	point	point	NN
8691	1468	4	in	in	IN
8691	1468	5	this	this	DT
8691	1468	6	system	system	NN
8691	1468	7	of	of	IN
8691	1468	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1468	9	organization	organization	NN
8691	1468	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	1468	11	the	the	DT
8691	1468	12	vesting	vesting	NN
8691	1468	13	of	of	IN
8691	1468	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1468	15	of	of	IN
8691	1468	16	small	small	JJ
8691	1468	17	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1468	18	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1468	19	in	in	IN
8691	1468	20	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1468	21	of	of	IN
8691	1468	22	the	the	DT
8691	1468	23	peace	peace	NN
8691	1468	24	.	.	.
8691	1469	1	Of	of	IN
8691	1469	2	these	these	DT
8691	1469	3	there	there	EX
8691	1469	4	are	be	VBP
8691	1469	5	generally	generally	RB
8691	1469	6	several	several	JJ
8691	1469	7	in	in	IN
8691	1469	8	each	each	DT
8691	1469	9	town	town	NN
8691	1469	10	,	,	,
8691	1469	11	having	have	VBG
8691	1469	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1469	13	over	over	IN
8691	1469	14	the	the	DT
8691	1469	15	whole	whole	JJ
8691	1469	16	county	county	NN
8691	1469	17	.	.	.
8691	1470	1	Some	some	DT
8691	1470	2	may	may	MD
8691	1470	3	be	be	VB
8691	1470	4	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	1470	5	.	.	.
8691	1471	1	None	none	NN
8691	1471	2	need	nee	MD
8691	1471	3	be	be	VB
8691	1471	4	,	,	,
8691	1471	5	and	and	CC
8691	1471	6	few	few	JJ
8691	1471	7	are	be	VBP
8691	1471	8	.	.	.
8691	1472	1	Any	any	DT
8691	1472	2	one	one	CD
8691	1472	3	of	of	IN
8691	1472	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1472	5	can	can	MD
8691	1472	6	try	try	VB
8691	1472	7	cases	case	NNS
8691	1472	8	.	.	.
8691	1473	1	Which	which	WDT
8691	1473	2	of	of	IN
8691	1473	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1473	4	shall	shall	MD
8691	1473	5	try	try	VB
8691	1473	6	any	any	DT
8691	1473	7	particular	particular	JJ
8691	1473	8	case	case	NN
8691	1473	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1473	10	left	leave	VBN
8691	1473	11	to	to	TO
8691	1473	12	be	be	VB
8691	1473	13	determined	determine	VBN
8691	1473	14	by	by	IN
8691	1473	15	the	the	DT
8691	1473	16	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	1473	17	who	who	WP
8691	1473	18	brings	bring	VBZ
8691	1473	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1473	20	.	.	.
8691	1474	1	Justices	justice	NNS
8691	1474	2	of	of	IN
8691	1474	3	the	the	DT
8691	1474	4	peace	peace	NN
8691	1474	5	can	can	MD
8691	1474	6	be	be	VB
8691	1474	7	trusted	trust	VBN
8691	1474	8	to	to	TO
8691	1474	9	dispose	dispose	VB
8691	1474	10	of	of	IN
8691	1474	11	petty	petty	JJ
8691	1474	12	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1474	13	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	1474	14	and	and	CC
8691	1474	15	to	to	TO
8691	1474	16	conduct	conduct	VB
8691	1474	17	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
8691	1474	18	examinations	examination	NNS
8691	1474	19	into	into	IN
8691	1474	20	charges	charge	NNS
8691	1474	21	of	of	IN
8691	1474	22	any	any	DT
8691	1474	23	offence	offence	NN
8691	1474	24	for	for	IN
8691	1474	25	the	the	DT
8691	1474	26	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1474	27	of	of	IN
8691	1474	28	determining	determine	VBG
8691	1474	29	whether	whether	IN
8691	1474	30	there	there	EX
8691	1474	31	is	be	VBZ
8691	1474	32	ground	ground	NN
8691	1474	33	for	for	IN
8691	1474	34	holding	hold	VBG
8691	1474	35	the	the	DT
8691	1474	36	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	1474	37	for	for	IN
8691	1474	38	trial	trial	NN
8691	1474	39	before	before	IN
8691	1474	40	a	a	DT
8691	1474	41	jury	jury	NN
8691	1474	42	,	,	,
8691	1474	43	although	although	IN
8691	1474	44	even	even	RB
8691	1474	45	here	here	RB
8691	1474	46	mischief	mischief	NN
8691	1474	47	often	often	RB
8691	1474	48	results	result	VBZ
8691	1474	49	from	from	IN
8691	1474	50	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1474	51	ignorance	ignorance	NN
8691	1474	52	of	of	IN
8691	1474	53	law	law	NN
8691	1474	54	,	,	,
8691	1474	55	and	and	CC
8691	1474	56	the	the	DT
8691	1474	57	sufferers	sufferer	NNS
8691	1474	58	have	have	VBP
8691	1474	59	little	little	JJ
8691	1474	60	means	mean	NNS
8691	1474	61	of	of	IN
8691	1474	62	redress	redress	NN
8691	1474	63	.	.	.
8691	1475	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1475	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1475	3	:	:	:
8691	1475	4	See	see	VB
8691	1475	5	McVeigh	McVeigh	NNP
8691	1475	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1475	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	1475	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1475	9	Ripley	Ripley	NNP
8691	1475	10	,	,	,
8691	1475	11	77	77	CD
8691	1475	12	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	1475	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1475	14	,	,	,
8691	1475	15	136	136	CD
8691	1475	16	;	;	:
8691	1475	17	58	58	CD
8691	1475	18	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	1475	19	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	1475	20	,	,	,
8691	1475	21	701	701	CD
8691	1475	22	.	.	.
8691	1475	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1476	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	1476	2	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	1476	3	are	be	VBP
8691	1476	4	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1476	5	by	by	IN
8691	1476	6	a	a	DT
8691	1476	7	public	public	JJ
8691	1476	8	officer	officer	NN
8691	1476	9	,	,	,
8691	1476	10	who	who	WP
8691	1476	11	will	will	MD
8691	1476	12	not	not	RB
8691	1476	13	be	be	VB
8691	1476	14	apt	apt	JJ
8691	1476	15	to	to	TO
8691	1476	16	select	select	VB
8691	1476	17	an	an	DT
8691	1476	18	incompetent	incompetent	JJ
8691	1476	19	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	1476	20	,	,	,
8691	1476	21	and	and	CC
8691	1476	22	has	have	VBZ
8691	1476	23	no	no	DT
8691	1476	24	strong	strong	JJ
8691	1476	25	motive	motive	NN
8691	1476	26	for	for	IN
8691	1476	27	choosing	choose	VBG
8691	1476	28	one	one	CD
8691	1476	29	specially	specially	RB
8691	1476	30	likely	likely	JJ
8691	1476	31	to	to	TO
8691	1476	32	give	give	VB
8691	1476	33	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1476	34	against	against	IN
8691	1476	35	the	the	DT
8691	1476	36	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	1476	37	.	.	.
8691	1477	1	But	but	CC
8691	1477	2	in	in	IN
8691	1477	3	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1477	4	cases	case	NNS
8691	1477	5	,	,	,
8691	1477	6	for	for	IN
8691	1477	7	the	the	DT
8691	1477	8	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	1477	9	who	who	WP
8691	1477	10	institutes	institute	VBZ
8691	1477	11	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1477	12	to	to	TO
8691	1477	13	pick	pick	VB
8691	1477	14	out	out	RP
8691	1477	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1477	16	judge	judge	NN
8691	1477	17	at	at	IN
8691	1477	18	will	will	NN
8691	1477	19	from	from	IN
8691	1477	20	a	a	DT
8691	1477	21	number	number	NN
8691	1477	22	who	who	WP
8691	1477	23	are	be	VBP
8691	1477	24	equally	equally	RB
8691	1477	25	competent	competent	JJ
8691	1477	26	to	to	TO
8691	1477	27	assume	assume	VB
8691	1477	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1477	29	,	,	,
8691	1477	30	and	and	CC
8691	1477	31	at	at	IN
8691	1477	32	the	the	DT
8691	1477	33	same	same	JJ
8691	1477	34	time	time	NN
8691	1477	35	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1477	36	as	as	IN
8691	1477	37	is	be	VBZ
8691	1477	38	generally	generally	RB
8691	1477	39	the	the	DT
8691	1477	40	law	law	NN
8691	1477	41	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1477	42	are	be	VBP
8691	1477	43	left	leave	VBN
8691	1477	44	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	1477	45	without	without	IN
8691	1477	46	salaries	salary	NNS
8691	1477	47	,	,	,
8691	1477	48	receiving	receive	VBG
8691	1477	49	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	1477	50	except	except	IN
8691	1477	51	fees	fee	NNS
8691	1477	52	for	for	IN
8691	1477	53	cases	case	NNS
8691	1477	54	actually	actually	RB
8691	1477	55	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1477	56	before	before	IN
8691	1477	57	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1477	58	,	,	,
8691	1477	59	is	be	VBZ
8691	1477	60	to	to	TO
8691	1477	61	place	place	VB
8691	1477	62	the	the	DT
8691	1477	63	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	1477	64	in	in	IN
8691	1477	65	a	a	DT
8691	1477	66	much	much	RB
8691	1477	67	less	less	RBR
8691	1477	68	favorable	favorable	JJ
8691	1477	69	position	position	NN
8691	1477	70	than	than	IN
8691	1477	71	the	the	DT
8691	1477	72	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1477	73	.	.	.
8691	1478	1	If	if	IN
8691	1478	2	the	the	DT
8691	1478	3	justice	justice	NN
8691	1478	4	decides	decide	VBZ
8691	1478	5	in	in	IN
8691	1478	6	favor	favor	NN
8691	1478	7	of	of	IN
8691	1478	8	the	the	DT
8691	1478	9	latter	latter	JJ
8691	1478	10	,	,	,
8691	1478	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1478	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	1478	13	obviously	obviously	RB
8691	1478	14	more	more	RBR
8691	1478	15	likely	likely	JJ
8691	1478	16	to	to	TO
8691	1478	17	get	get	VB
8691	1478	18	the	the	DT
8691	1478	19	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	1478	20	patronage	patronage	NN
8691	1478	21	of	of	IN
8691	1478	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1478	23	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	1478	24	.	.	.
8691	1479	1	In	in	IN
8691	1479	2	most	most	JJS
8691	1479	3	justice	justice	NN
8691	1479	4	suits	suit	NNS
8691	1479	5	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1479	6	does	do	VBZ
8691	1479	7	go	go	VB
8691	1479	8	for	for	IN
8691	1479	9	the	the	DT
8691	1479	10	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1479	11	,	,	,
8691	1479	12	and	and	CC
8691	1479	13	not	not	RB
8691	1479	14	infrequently	infrequently	RB
8691	1479	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1479	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	1479	17	to	to	TO
8691	1479	18	be	be	VB
8691	1479	19	feared	fear	VBN
8691	1479	20	that	that	IN
8691	1479	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1479	22	gets	get	VBZ
8691	1479	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1479	24	from	from	IN
8691	1479	25	that	that	DT
8691	1479	26	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	1479	27	.	.	.
8691	1480	1	Some	some	DT
8691	1480	2	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1480	3	rarely	rarely	RB
8691	1480	4	give	give	VBP
8691	1480	5	any	any	DT
8691	1480	6	other	other	JJ
8691	1480	7	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1480	8	.	.	.
8691	1481	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	1481	2	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	1481	3	bring	bring	VBP
8691	1481	4	all	all	PDT
8691	1481	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1481	6	cases	case	NNS
8691	1481	7	before	before	IN
8691	1481	8	one	one	CD
8691	1481	9	justice	justice	NN
8691	1481	10	,	,	,
8691	1481	11	and	and	CC
8691	1481	12	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	1481	13	fail	fail	VB
8691	1481	14	of	of	IN
8691	1481	15	success	success	NN
8691	1481	16	.	.	.
8691	1482	1	In	in	IN
8691	1482	2	1903	1903	CD
8691	1482	3	,	,	,
8691	1482	4	a	a	DT
8691	1482	5	justice	justice	NN
8691	1482	6	of	of	IN
8691	1482	7	the	the	DT
8691	1482	8	peace	peace	NN
8691	1482	9	in	in	IN
8691	1482	10	one	one	CD
8691	1482	11	of	of	IN
8691	1482	12	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1482	13	largest	large	JJS
8691	1482	14	cities	city	NNS
8691	1482	15	resigned	resign	VBD
8691	1482	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1482	17	office	office	NN
8691	1482	18	and	and	CC
8691	1482	19	made	make	VBD
8691	1482	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1482	21	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	1482	22	public	public	JJ
8691	1482	23	.	.	.
8691	1483	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1483	2	were	be	VBD
8691	1483	3	that	that	IN
8691	1483	4	no	no	DT
8691	1483	5	one	one	PRP
8691	1483	6	could	could	MD
8691	1483	7	afford	afford	VB
8691	1483	8	to	to	TO
8691	1483	9	hold	hold	VB
8691	1483	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1483	11	who	who	WP
8691	1483	12	was	be	VBD
8691	1483	13	not	not	RB
8691	1483	14	willing	willing	JJ
8691	1483	15	to	to	TO
8691	1483	16	stoop	stoop	VB
8691	1483	17	to	to	IN
8691	1483	18	unworthy	unworthy	JJ
8691	1483	19	practices	practice	NNS
8691	1483	20	.	.	.
8691	1484	1	Lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	1484	2	having	have	VBG
8691	1484	3	a	a	DT
8691	1484	4	large	large	JJ
8691	1484	5	collection	collection	NN
8691	1484	6	practice	practice	NN
8691	1484	7	,	,	,
8691	1484	8	who	who	WP
8691	1484	9	were	be	VBD
8691	1484	10	the	the	DT
8691	1484	11	best	good	JJS
8691	1484	12	customers	customer	NNS
8691	1484	13	at	at	IN
8691	1484	14	such	such	PDT
8691	1484	15	a	a	DT
8691	1484	16	shop	shop	NN
8691	1484	17	of	of	IN
8691	1484	18	justice	justice	NN
8691	1484	19	,	,	,
8691	1484	20	threw	throw	VBD
8691	1484	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1484	22	business	business	NN
8691	1484	23	where	where	WRB
8691	1484	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1484	25	could	could	MD
8691	1484	26	get	get	VB
8691	1484	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1484	28	done	do	VBN
8691	1484	29	most	most	RBS
8691	1484	30	cheaply	cheaply	RB
8691	1484	31	.	.	.
8691	1485	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1485	2	expected	expect	VBD
8691	1485	3	the	the	DT
8691	1485	4	justice	justice	NN
8691	1485	5	of	of	IN
8691	1485	6	the	the	DT
8691	1485	7	peace	peace	NN
8691	1485	8	whom	whom	WP
8691	1485	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1485	10	favored	favor	VBD
8691	1485	11	to	to	TO
8691	1485	12	favor	favor	VB
8691	1485	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1485	14	.	.	.
8691	1486	1	One	one	CD
8691	1486	2	way	way	NN
8691	1486	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1486	4	by	by	IN
8691	1486	5	making	make	VBG
8691	1486	6	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1486	7	a	a	DT
8691	1486	8	discount	discount	NN
8691	1486	9	on	on	IN
8691	1486	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1486	11	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1486	12	fees	fee	NNS
8691	1486	13	.	.	.
8691	1487	1	There	there	EX
8691	1487	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1487	3	a	a	DT
8691	1487	4	competition	competition	NN
8691	1487	5	among	among	IN
8691	1487	6	the	the	DT
8691	1487	7	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1487	8	for	for	IN
8691	1487	9	business	business	NN
8691	1487	10	on	on	IN
8691	1487	11	these	these	DT
8691	1487	12	terms	term	NNS
8691	1487	13	,	,	,
8691	1487	14	and	and	CC
8691	1487	15	the	the	DT
8691	1487	16	lowest	low	JJS
8691	1487	17	bidder	bidder	NN
8691	1487	18	generally	generally	RB
8691	1487	19	got	get	VBD
8691	1487	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1487	21	.	.	.
8691	1488	1	Blank	blank	JJ
8691	1488	2	writs	writ	NNS
8691	1488	3	of	of	IN
8691	1488	4	summons	summon	NNS
8691	1488	5	,	,	,
8691	1488	6	even	even	RB
8691	1488	7	,	,	,
8691	1488	8	signed	sign	VBN
8691	1488	9	by	by	IN
8691	1488	10	the	the	DT
8691	1488	11	justice	justice	NN
8691	1488	12	would	would	MD
8691	1488	13	be	be	VB
8691	1488	14	sold	sell	VBN
8691	1488	15	at	at	IN
8691	1488	16	so	so	RB
8691	1488	17	much	much	RB
8691	1488	18	a	a	DT
8691	1488	19	dozen	dozen	NN
8691	1488	20	,	,	,
8691	1488	21	to	to	TO
8691	1488	22	be	be	VB
8691	1488	23	filled	fill	VBN
8691	1488	24	in	in	RP
8691	1488	25	to	to	TO
8691	1488	26	suit	suit	VB
8691	1488	27	the	the	DT
8691	1488	28	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	1488	29	.	.	.
8691	1489	1	A	a	DT
8691	1489	2	system	system	NN
8691	1489	3	in	in	IN
8691	1489	4	which	which	WDT
8691	1489	5	such	such	JJ
8691	1489	6	things	thing	NNS
8691	1489	7	are	be	VBP
8691	1489	8	possible	possible	JJ
8691	1489	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1489	10	inherently	inherently	RB
8691	1489	11	vicious	vicious	JJ
8691	1489	12	,	,	,
8691	1489	13	and	and	CC
8691	1489	14	only	only	RB
8691	1489	15	endurable	endurable	JJ
8691	1489	16	because	because	IN
8691	1489	17	the	the	DT
8691	1489	18	defeated	defeat	VBN
8691	1489	19	party	party	NN
8691	1489	20	can	can	MD
8691	1489	21	always	always	RB
8691	1489	22	appeal	appeal	VB
8691	1489	23	and	and	CC
8691	1489	24	have	have	VB
8691	1489	25	a	a	DT
8691	1489	26	new	new	JJ
8691	1489	27	trial	trial	NN
8691	1489	28	before	before	IN
8691	1489	29	a	a	DT
8691	1489	30	higher	high	JJR
8691	1489	31	court	court	NN
8691	1489	32	.	.	.
8691	1490	1	That	that	DT
8691	1490	2	relief	relief	NN
8691	1490	3	,	,	,
8691	1490	4	however	however	RB
8691	1490	5	,	,	,
8691	1490	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1490	7	expensive	expensive	JJ
8691	1490	8	.	.	.
8691	1491	1	Judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1491	2	ought	ought	MD
8691	1491	3	to	to	TO
8691	1491	4	be	be	VB
8691	1491	5	just	just	RB
8691	1491	6	in	in	IN
8691	1491	7	the	the	DT
8691	1491	8	first	first	JJ
8691	1491	9	instance	instance	NN
8691	1491	10	,	,	,
8691	1491	11	and	and	CC
8691	1491	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1491	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	1491	14	the	the	DT
8691	1491	15	business	business	NN
8691	1491	16	of	of	IN
8691	1491	17	governments	government	NNS
8691	1491	18	to	to	TO
8691	1491	19	ensure	ensure	VB
8691	1491	20	this	this	DT
8691	1491	21	,	,	,
8691	1491	22	so	so	RB
8691	1491	23	far	far	RB
8691	1491	24	as	as	IN
8691	1491	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1491	26	reasonably	reasonably	RB
8691	1491	27	can	can	MD
8691	1491	28	.	.	.
8691	1492	1	The	the	DT
8691	1492	2	natural	natural	JJ
8691	1492	3	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1492	4	would	would	MD
8691	1492	5	seem	seem	VB
8691	1492	6	to	to	TO
8691	1492	7	be	be	VB
8691	1492	8	to	to	TO
8691	1492	9	have	have	VB
8691	1492	10	fewer	few	JJR
8691	1492	11	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1492	12	of	of	IN
8691	1492	13	the	the	DT
8691	1492	14	peace	peace	NN
8691	1492	15	who	who	WP
8691	1492	16	are	be	VBP
8691	1492	17	authorized	authorize	VBN
8691	1492	18	to	to	TO
8691	1492	19	try	try	VB
8691	1492	20	cases	case	NNS
8691	1492	21	and	and	CC
8691	1492	22	to	to	TO
8691	1492	23	pay	pay	VB
8691	1492	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1492	25	a	a	DT
8691	1492	26	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	1492	27	salary	salary	NN
8691	1492	28	.	.	.
8691	1493	1	Better	well	JJR
8691	1493	2	men	man	NNS
8691	1493	3	could	could	MD
8691	1493	4	thus	thus	RB
8691	1493	5	be	be	VB
8691	1493	6	had	have	VBN
8691	1493	7	and	and	CC
8691	1493	8	independence	independence	NN
8691	1493	9	of	of	IN
8691	1493	10	action	action	NN
8691	1493	11	promoted	promote	VBN
8691	1493	12	.	.	.
8691	1494	1	That	that	IN
8691	1494	2	this	this	DT
8691	1494	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1494	4	not	not	RB
8691	1494	5	done	do	VBN
8691	1494	6	comes	come	VBZ
8691	1494	7	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	1494	8	from	from	IN
8691	1494	9	the	the	DT
8691	1494	10	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	1494	11	that	that	IN
8691	1494	12	small	small	JJ
8691	1494	13	controversies	controversy	NNS
8691	1494	14	ought	ought	MD
8691	1494	15	to	to	TO
8691	1494	16	be	be	VB
8691	1494	17	settled	settle	VBN
8691	1494	18	by	by	IN
8691	1494	19	a	a	DT
8691	1494	20	neighborhood	neighborhood	NN
8691	1494	21	court	court	NN
8691	1494	22	;	;	:
8691	1494	23	that	that	IN
8691	1494	24	any	any	DT
8691	1494	25	man	man	NN
8691	1494	26	of	of	IN
8691	1494	27	good	good	JJ
8691	1494	28	common	common	JJ
8691	1494	29	sense	sense	NN
8691	1494	30	can	can	MD
8691	1494	31	generally	generally	RB
8691	1494	32	deal	deal	VB
8691	1494	33	with	with	IN
8691	1494	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1494	35	as	as	RB
8691	1494	36	well	well	RB
8691	1494	37	as	as	IN
8691	1494	38	a	a	DT
8691	1494	39	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	1494	40	;	;	:
8691	1494	41	and	and	CC
8691	1494	42	that	that	DT
8691	1494	43	to	to	TO
8691	1494	44	salary	salary	VB
8691	1494	45	every	every	DT
8691	1494	46	justice	justice	NN
8691	1494	47	would	would	MD
8691	1494	48	be	be	VB
8691	1494	49	an	an	DT
8691	1494	50	unreasonable	unreasonable	JJ
8691	1494	51	burden	burden	NN
8691	1494	52	to	to	TO
8691	1494	53	impose	impose	VB
8691	1494	54	on	on	IN
8691	1494	55	the	the	DT
8691	1494	56	taxpayer	taxpayer	NN
8691	1494	57	.	.	.
8691	1495	1	The	the	DT
8691	1495	2	system	system	NN
8691	1495	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1495	4	also	also	RB
8691	1495	5	an	an	DT
8691	1495	6	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	1495	7	one	one	CD
8691	1495	8	;	;	:
8691	1495	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1495	10	works	work	VBZ
8691	1495	11	well	well	RB
8691	1495	12	with	with	IN
8691	1495	13	honest	honest	JJ
8691	1495	14	men	man	NNS
8691	1495	15	;	;	:
8691	1495	16	and	and	CC
8691	1495	17	the	the	DT
8691	1495	18	people	people	NNS
8691	1495	19	have	have	VBP
8691	1495	20	an	an	DT
8691	1495	21	inherited	inherit	VBN
8691	1495	22	attachment	attachment	NN
8691	1495	23	for	for	IN
8691	1495	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1495	25	.	.	.
8691	1496	1	In	in	IN
8691	1496	2	a	a	DT
8691	1496	3	few	few	JJ
8691	1496	4	States	state	NNS
8691	1496	5	a	a	DT
8691	1496	6	sharp	sharp	JJ
8691	1496	7	line	line	NN
8691	1496	8	of	of	IN
8691	1496	9	division	division	NN
8691	1496	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	1496	11	drawn	draw	VBN
8691	1496	12	between	between	IN
8691	1496	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	1496	14	of	of	IN
8691	1496	15	law	law	NN
8691	1496	16	and	and	CC
8691	1496	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	1496	18	of	of	IN
8691	1496	19	equity	equity	NN
8691	1496	20	.	.	.
8691	1497	1	This	this	DT
8691	1497	2	distinction	distinction	NN
8691	1497	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1497	4	inherited	inherit	VBN
8691	1497	5	from	from	IN
8691	1497	6	England	England	NNP
8691	1497	7	,	,	,
8691	1497	8	though	though	IN
8691	1497	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1497	10	has	have	VBZ
8691	1497	11	been	be	VBN
8691	1497	12	for	for	IN
8691	1497	13	most	most	JJS
8691	1497	14	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	1497	15	abolished	abolish	VBD
8691	1497	16	there	there	RB
8691	1497	17	by	by	IN
8691	1497	18	the	the	DT
8691	1497	19	Judicature	Judicature	NNP
8691	1497	20	Acts	Acts	NNPS
8691	1497	21	of	of	IN
8691	1497	22	1873	1873	CD
8691	1497	23	and	and	CC
8691	1497	24	1875	1875	CD
8691	1497	25	.	.	.
8691	1498	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1498	2	originated	originate	VBD
8691	1498	3	in	in	IN
8691	1498	4	the	the	DT
8691	1498	5	royal	royal	JJ
8691	1498	6	prerogative	prerogative	NN
8691	1498	7	of	of	IN
8691	1498	8	interposing	interpose	VBG
8691	1498	9	to	to	TO
8691	1498	10	do	do	VB
8691	1498	11	justice	justice	NN
8691	1498	12	between	between	IN
8691	1498	13	private	private	JJ
8691	1498	14	individuals	individual	NNS
8691	1498	15	in	in	IN
8691	1498	16	cases	case	NNS
8691	1498	17	of	of	IN
8691	1498	18	an	an	DT
8691	1498	19	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
8691	1498	20	character	character	NN
8691	1498	21	when	when	WRB
8691	1498	22	the	the	DT
8691	1498	23	regular	regular	JJ
8691	1498	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	1498	25	had	have	VBD
8691	1498	26	no	no	DT
8691	1498	27	power	power	NN
8691	1498	28	to	to	TO
8691	1498	29	grant	grant	VB
8691	1498	30	the	the	DT
8691	1498	31	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1498	32	relief	relief	NN
8691	1498	33	.	.	.
8691	1499	1	The	the	DT
8691	1499	2	King	King	NNP
8691	1499	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1499	4	accustomed	accustom	VBN
8691	1499	5	to	to	TO
8691	1499	6	refer	refer	VB
8691	1499	7	requests	request	NNS
8691	1499	8	for	for	IN
8691	1499	9	such	such	JJ
8691	1499	10	action	action	NN
8691	1499	11	on	on	IN
8691	1499	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1499	13	part	part	NN
8691	1499	14	to	to	IN
8691	1499	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1499	16	principal	principal	JJ
8691	1499	17	secretary	secretary	NN
8691	1499	18	and	and	CC
8691	1499	19	councillor	councillor	NN
8691	1499	20	.	.	.
8691	1500	1	The	the	DT
8691	1500	2	next	next	JJ
8691	1500	3	step	step	NN
8691	1500	4	was	be	VBD
8691	1500	5	to	to	TO
8691	1500	6	address	address	VB
8691	1500	7	the	the	DT
8691	1500	8	request	request	NN
8691	1500	9	directly	directly	RB
8691	1500	10	to	to	IN
8691	1500	11	this	this	DT
8691	1500	12	officer	officer	NN
8691	1500	13	,	,	,
8691	1500	14	who	who	WP
8691	1500	15	was	be	VBD
8691	1500	16	styled	style	VBN
8691	1500	17	the	the	DT
8691	1500	18	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	1500	19	.	.	.
8691	1501	1	If	if	IN
8691	1501	2	a	a	DT
8691	1501	3	man	man	NN
8691	1501	4	were	be	VBD
8691	1501	5	acting	act	VBG
8691	1501	6	toward	toward	IN
8691	1501	7	another	another	DT
8691	1501	8	in	in	IN
8691	1501	9	a	a	DT
8691	1501	10	way	way	NN
8691	1501	11	that	that	WDT
8691	1501	12	was	be	VBD
8691	1501	13	against	against	IN
8691	1501	14	good	good	JJ
8691	1501	15	conscience	conscience	NN
8691	1501	16	,	,	,
8691	1501	17	though	though	IN
8691	1501	18	without	without	IN
8691	1501	19	absolutely	absolutely	RB
8691	1501	20	transgressing	transgress	VBG
8691	1501	21	any	any	DT
8691	1501	22	settled	settle	VBN
8691	1501	23	rule	rule	NN
8691	1501	24	of	of	IN
8691	1501	25	law	law	NN
8691	1501	26	,	,	,
8691	1501	27	the	the	DT
8691	1501	28	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	1501	29	could	could	MD
8691	1501	30	compel	compel	VB
8691	1501	31	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1501	32	to	to	TO
8691	1501	33	desist	desist	VB
8691	1501	34	.	.	.
8691	1502	1	If	if	IN
8691	1502	2	the	the	DT
8691	1502	3	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1502	4	title	title	NN
8691	1502	5	to	to	TO
8691	1502	6	land	land	NN
8691	1502	7	had	have	VBD
8691	1502	8	been	be	VBN
8691	1502	9	conveyed	convey	VBN
8691	1502	10	to	to	IN
8691	1502	11	one	one	CD
8691	1502	12	for	for	IN
8691	1502	13	the	the	DT
8691	1502	14	use	use	NN
8691	1502	15	of	of	IN
8691	1502	16	another	another	DT
8691	1502	17	,	,	,
8691	1502	18	and	and	CC
8691	1502	19	the	the	DT
8691	1502	20	holder	holder	NN
8691	1502	21	of	of	IN
8691	1502	22	this	this	DT
8691	1502	23	title	title	NN
8691	1502	24	refused	refuse	VBD
8691	1502	25	to	to	TO
8691	1502	26	recognize	recognize	VB
8691	1502	27	the	the	DT
8691	1502	28	beneficial	beneficial	JJ
8691	1502	29	interest	interest	NN
8691	1502	30	to	to	TO
8691	1502	31	serve	serve	VB
8691	1502	32	which	which	WDT
8691	1502	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1502	34	had	have	VBD
8691	1502	35	been	be	VBN
8691	1502	36	invested	invest	VBN
8691	1502	37	with	with	IN
8691	1502	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1502	39	,	,	,
8691	1502	40	the	the	DT
8691	1502	41	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	1502	42	could	could	MD
8691	1502	43	bring	bring	VB
8691	1502	44	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1502	45	to	to	TO
8691	1502	46	account	account	VB
8691	1502	47	,	,	,
8691	1502	48	although	although	IN
8691	1502	49	the	the	DT
8691	1502	50	common	common	JJ
8691	1502	51	law	law	NN
8691	1502	52	would	would	MD
8691	1502	53	give	give	VB
8691	1502	54	no	no	DT
8691	1502	55	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1502	56	.	.	.
8691	1503	1	Soon	soon	RB
8691	1503	2	,	,	,
8691	1503	3	whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	1503	4	a	a	DT
8691	1503	5	man	man	NN
8691	1503	6	seemed	seem	VBD
8691	1503	7	to	to	TO
8691	1503	8	have	have	VB
8691	1503	9	justice	justice	NN
8691	1503	10	on	on	IN
8691	1503	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1503	12	side	side	NN
8691	1503	13	,	,	,
8691	1503	14	but	but	CC
8691	1503	15	not	not	RB
8691	1503	16	law	law	NN
8691	1503	17	,	,	,
8691	1503	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1503	19	was	be	VBD
8691	1503	20	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	1503	21	a	a	DT
8691	1503	22	case	case	NN
8691	1503	23	for	for	IN
8691	1503	24	the	the	DT
8691	1503	25	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	1503	26	,	,	,
8691	1503	27	or	or	CC
8691	1503	28	a	a	DT
8691	1503	29	case	case	NN
8691	1503	30	in	in	IN
8691	1503	31	chancery	chancery	NN
8691	1503	32	.	.	.
8691	1504	1	Relief	relief	NN
8691	1504	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1504	3	given	give	VBN
8691	1504	4	because	because	IN
8691	1504	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1504	6	was	be	VBD
8691	1504	7	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	1504	8	to	to	TO
8691	1504	9	give	give	VB
8691	1504	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1504	11	,	,	,
8691	1504	12	and	and	CC
8691	1504	13	so	so	RB
8691	1504	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1504	15	was	be	VBD
8691	1504	16	called	call	VBN
8691	1504	17	relief	relief	NN
8691	1504	18	in	in	IN
8691	1504	19	equity	equity	NN
8691	1504	20	.	.	.
8691	1505	1	The	the	DT
8691	1505	2	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1505	3	expanded	expand	VBD
8691	1505	4	.	.	.
8691	1506	1	Wherever	wherever	WRB
8691	1506	2	there	there	EX
8691	1506	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1506	4	a	a	DT
8691	1506	5	right	right	NN
8691	1506	6	,	,	,
8691	1506	7	but	but	CC
8691	1506	8	no	no	DT
8691	1506	9	adequate	adequate	JJ
8691	1506	10	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1506	11	at	at	IN
8691	1506	12	law	law	NN
8691	1506	13	,	,	,
8691	1506	14	the	the	DT
8691	1506	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1506	16	of	of	IN
8691	1506	17	Chancery	Chancery	NNP
8691	1506	18	,	,	,
8691	1506	19	or	or	CC
8691	1506	20	,	,	,
8691	1506	21	as	as	IN
8691	1506	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1506	23	was	be	VBD
8691	1506	24	oftener	oftener	RB
8691	1506	25	called	call	VBN
8691	1506	26	,	,	,
8691	1506	27	of	of	IN
8691	1506	28	equity	equity	NN
8691	1506	29	,	,	,
8691	1506	30	was	be	VBD
8691	1506	31	recognized	recognize	VBN
8691	1506	32	as	as	RB
8691	1506	33	competent	competent	JJ
8691	1506	34	to	to	TO
8691	1506	35	step	step	VB
8691	1506	36	in	in	RB
8691	1506	37	and	and	CC
8691	1506	38	do	do	VB
8691	1506	39	justice	justice	NN
8691	1506	40	.	.	.
8691	1507	1	The	the	DT
8691	1507	2	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	1507	3	had	have	VBD
8691	1507	4	often	often	RB
8691	1507	5	been	be	VBN
8691	1507	6	an	an	DT
8691	1507	7	ecclesiastic	ecclesiastic	NN
8691	1507	8	.	.	.
8691	1508	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1508	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1508	3	apt	apt	JJ
8691	1508	4	to	to	TO
8691	1508	5	be	be	VB
8691	1508	6	more	more	RBR
8691	1508	7	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	1508	8	with	with	IN
8691	1508	9	canon	canon	NNP
8691	1508	10	law	law	NN
8691	1508	11	and	and	CC
8691	1508	12	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1508	13	law	law	NN
8691	1508	14	than	than	IN
8691	1508	15	with	with	IN
8691	1508	16	the	the	DT
8691	1508	17	common	common	JJ
8691	1508	18	law	law	NN
8691	1508	19	.	.	.
8691	1509	1	The	the	DT
8691	1509	2	justice	justice	NN
8691	1509	3	which	which	WDT
8691	1509	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1509	5	administered	administer	VBD
8691	1509	6	came	come	VBD
8691	1509	7	from	from	IN
8691	1509	8	the	the	DT
8691	1509	9	Crown	Crown	NNP
8691	1509	10	,	,	,
8691	1509	11	not	not	RB
8691	1509	12	from	from	IN
8691	1509	13	the	the	DT
8691	1509	14	people	people	NNS
8691	1509	15	.	.	.
8691	1510	1	The	the	DT
8691	1510	2	people	people	NNS
8691	1510	3	spoke	speak	VBD
8691	1510	4	through	through	IN
8691	1510	5	a	a	DT
8691	1510	6	jury	jury	NN
8691	1510	7	,	,	,
8691	1510	8	called	call	VBN
8691	1510	9	in	in	IN
8691	1510	10	law	law	NN
8691	1510	11	language	language	NN
8691	1510	12	"	"	''
8691	1510	13	the	the	DT
8691	1510	14	country	country	NN
8691	1510	15	.	.	.
8691	1510	16	"	"	''
8691	1511	1	The	the	DT
8691	1511	2	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	1511	3	spoke	speak	VBD
8691	1511	4	for	for	IN
8691	1511	5	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1511	6	.	.	.
8691	1512	1	If	if	IN
8691	1512	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1512	3	called	call	VBD
8691	1512	4	in	in	IN
8691	1512	5	the	the	DT
8691	1512	6	aid	aid	NN
8691	1512	7	of	of	IN
8691	1512	8	a	a	DT
8691	1512	9	jury	jury	NN
8691	1512	10	,	,	,
8691	1512	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1512	12	was	be	VBD
8691	1512	13	to	to	TO
8691	1512	14	advise	advise	VB
8691	1512	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1512	16	,	,	,
8691	1512	17	not	not	RB
8691	1512	18	,	,	,
8691	1512	19	as	as	IN
8691	1512	20	in	in	IN
8691	1512	21	a	a	DT
8691	1512	22	common	common	JJ
8691	1512	23	law	law	NN
8691	1512	24	court	court	NN
8691	1512	25	,	,	,
8691	1512	26	to	to	TO
8691	1512	27	make	make	VB
8691	1512	28	a	a	DT
8691	1512	29	final	final	JJ
8691	1512	30	decision	decision	NN
8691	1512	31	as	as	IN
8691	1512	32	to	to	IN
8691	1512	33	the	the	DT
8691	1512	34	question	question	NN
8691	1512	35	submitted	submit	VBN
8691	1512	36	to	to	IN
8691	1512	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1512	38	.	.	.
8691	1513	1	The	the	DT
8691	1513	2	result	result	NN
8691	1513	3	came	come	VBD
8691	1513	4	to	to	TO
8691	1513	5	be	be	VB
8691	1513	6	that	that	IN
8691	1513	7	for	for	IN
8691	1513	8	several	several	JJ
8691	1513	9	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	1513	10	years	year	NNS
8691	1513	11	,	,	,
8691	1513	12	embracing	embrace	VBG
8691	1513	13	the	the	DT
8691	1513	14	whole	whole	JJ
8691	1513	15	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	1513	16	period	period	NN
8691	1513	17	,	,	,
8691	1513	18	England	England	NNP
8691	1513	19	had	have	VBD
8691	1513	20	two	two	CD
8691	1513	21	distinct	distinct	JJ
8691	1513	22	sets	set	NNS
8691	1513	23	of	of	IN
8691	1513	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	1513	25	,	,	,
8691	1513	26	acting	act	VBG
8691	1513	27	under	under	IN
8691	1513	28	different	different	JJ
8691	1513	29	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1513	30	,	,	,
8691	1513	31	and	and	CC
8691	1513	32	each	each	DT
8691	1513	33	trying	try	VBG
8691	1513	34	a	a	DT
8691	1513	35	different	different	JJ
8691	1513	36	kind	kind	NN
8691	1513	37	of	of	IN
8691	1513	38	cases	case	NNS
8691	1513	39	.	.	.
8691	1514	1	Those	those	DT
8691	1514	2	involving	involve	VBG
8691	1514	3	questions	question	NNS
8691	1514	4	of	of	IN
8691	1514	5	trust	trust	NN
8691	1514	6	,	,	,
8691	1514	7	account	account	NN
8691	1514	8	,	,	,
8691	1514	9	fraud	fraud	NN
8691	1514	10	,	,	,
8691	1514	11	mistake	mistake	NN
8691	1514	12	or	or	CC
8691	1514	13	accident	accident	NN
8691	1514	14	,	,	,
8691	1514	15	were	be	VBD
8691	1514	16	the	the	DT
8691	1514	17	principal	principal	JJ
8691	1514	18	subjects	subject	NNS
8691	1514	19	of	of	IN
8691	1514	20	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	1514	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1514	22	.	.	.
8691	1515	1	Equity	equity	NN
8691	1515	2	also	also	RB
8691	1515	3	could	could	MD
8691	1515	4	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	1515	5	wrongs	wrong	NNS
8691	1515	6	,	,	,
8691	1515	7	while	while	IN
8691	1515	8	law	law	NN
8691	1515	9	could	could	MD
8691	1515	10	only	only	RB
8691	1515	11	punish	punish	VB
8691	1515	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1515	13	.	.	.
8691	1516	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1516	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1516	3	:	:	:
8691	1516	4	See	see	VB
8691	1516	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	1516	6	.	.	.
8691	1517	1	XX	XX	NNP
8691	1517	2	.	.	.
8691	1517	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1518	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1518	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1518	3	not	not	RB
8691	1518	4	,	,	,
8691	1518	5	however	however	RB
8691	1518	6	,	,	,
8691	1518	7	always	always	RB
8691	1518	8	easy	easy	JJ
8691	1518	9	to	to	TO
8691	1518	10	mark	mark	VB
8691	1518	11	the	the	DT
8691	1518	12	line	line	NN
8691	1518	13	between	between	IN
8691	1518	14	cases	case	NNS
8691	1518	15	,	,	,
8691	1518	16	and	and	CC
8691	1518	17	say	say	VB
8691	1518	18	which	which	WDT
8691	1518	19	belonged	belong	VBD
8691	1518	20	in	in	IN
8691	1518	21	the	the	DT
8691	1518	22	common	common	JJ
8691	1518	23	law	law	NN
8691	1518	24	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	1518	25	and	and	CC
8691	1518	26	which	which	WDT
8691	1518	27	in	in	IN
8691	1518	28	those	those	DT
8691	1518	29	of	of	IN
8691	1518	30	chancery	chancery	NN
8691	1518	31	.	.	.
8691	1519	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	1519	2	an	an	DT
8691	1519	3	action	action	NN
8691	1519	4	failed	fail	VBD
8691	1519	5	,	,	,
8691	1519	6	not	not	RB
8691	1519	7	because	because	IN
8691	1519	8	there	there	EX
8691	1519	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1519	10	no	no	DT
8691	1519	11	just	just	RB
8691	1519	12	cause	cause	NN
8691	1519	13	of	of	IN
8691	1519	14	action	action	NN
8691	1519	15	,	,	,
8691	1519	16	but	but	CC
8691	1519	17	because	because	IN
8691	1519	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1519	19	had	have	VBD
8691	1519	20	been	be	VBN
8691	1519	21	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1519	22	in	in	IN
8691	1519	23	the	the	DT
8691	1519	24	wrong	wrong	JJ
8691	1519	25	court	court	NN
8691	1519	26	.	.	.
8691	1520	1	In	in	IN
8691	1520	2	the	the	DT
8691	1520	3	American	american	JJ
8691	1520	4	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	1520	5	,	,	,
8691	1520	6	and	and	CC
8691	1520	7	for	for	IN
8691	1520	8	many	many	JJ
8691	1520	9	years	year	NNS
8691	1520	10	in	in	IN
8691	1520	11	the	the	DT
8691	1520	12	States	States	NNP
8691	1520	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1520	14	succeeded	succeed	VBD
8691	1520	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1520	16	,	,	,
8691	1520	17	these	these	DT
8691	1520	18	distinctions	distinction	NNS
8691	1520	19	of	of	IN
8691	1520	20	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	1520	21	were	be	VBD
8691	1520	22	generally	generally	RB
8691	1520	23	observed	observe	VBN
8691	1520	24	.	.	.
8691	1521	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1521	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1521	3	:	:	:
8691	1521	4	In	in	IN
8691	1521	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	1521	6	the	the	DT
8691	1521	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	1521	8	largely	largely	RB
8691	1521	9	disregarded	disregard	VBD
8691	1521	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1521	11	and	and	CC
8691	1521	12	asserted	assert	VBD
8691	1521	13	that	that	IN
8691	1521	14	equity	equity	NN
8691	1521	15	was	be	VBD
8691	1521	16	a	a	DT
8691	1521	17	part	part	NN
8691	1521	18	of	of	IN
8691	1521	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1521	20	common	common	JJ
8691	1521	21	law	law	NN
8691	1521	22	.	.	.
8691	1522	1	See	see	VB
8691	1522	2	Myers	Myers	NNP
8691	1522	3	_	_	NNP
8691	1522	4	v.	v.	IN
8691	1522	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1522	6	South	South	NNP
8691	1522	7	Bethlehem	Bethlehem	NNP
8691	1522	8	,	,	,
8691	1522	9	149	149	CD
8691	1522	10	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	1522	11	State	State	NNP
8691	1522	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1522	13	,	,	,
8691	1522	14	85	85	CD
8691	1522	15	,	,	,
8691	1522	16	24	24	CD
8691	1522	17	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	1522	18	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	1522	19	,	,	,
8691	1522	20	280	280	CD
8691	1522	21	.	.	.
8691	1522	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1523	1	In	in	IN
8691	1523	2	some	some	DT
8691	1523	3	there	there	EX
8691	1523	4	were	be	VBD
8691	1523	5	,	,	,
8691	1523	6	in	in	IN
8691	1523	7	some	some	DT
8691	1523	8	there	there	RB
8691	1523	9	still	still	RB
8691	1523	10	are	be	VBP
8691	1523	11	,	,	,
8691	1523	12	separate	separate	JJ
8691	1523	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	1523	14	of	of	IN
8691	1523	15	equity	equity	NN
8691	1523	16	held	hold	VBN
8691	1523	17	by	by	IN
8691	1523	18	a	a	DT
8691	1523	19	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	1523	20	,	,	,
8691	1523	21	aided	aid	VBN
8691	1523	22	,	,	,
8691	1523	23	if	if	IN
8691	1523	24	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1523	25	,	,	,
8691	1523	26	by	by	IN
8691	1523	27	Vice	Vice	NNP
8691	1523	28	-	-	HYPH
8691	1523	29	Chancellors	Chancellors	NNP
8691	1523	30	.	.	.
8691	1524	1	In	in	IN
8691	1524	2	others	other	NNS
8691	1524	3	two	two	CD
8691	1524	4	dockets	docket	NNS
8691	1524	5	or	or	CC
8691	1524	6	lists	list	NNS
8691	1524	7	of	of	IN
8691	1524	8	cases	case	NNS
8691	1524	9	were	be	VBD
8691	1524	10	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1524	11	and	and	CC
8691	1524	12	in	in	IN
8691	1524	13	a	a	DT
8691	1524	14	number	number	NN
8691	1524	15	of	of	IN
8691	1524	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1524	17	still	still	RB
8691	1524	18	are	be	VBP
8691	1524	19	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1524	20	kept	keep	VBN
8691	1524	21	in	in	IN
8691	1524	22	the	the	DT
8691	1524	23	same	same	JJ
8691	1524	24	court	court	NN
8691	1524	25	,	,	,
8691	1524	26	and	and	CC
8691	1524	27	the	the	DT
8691	1524	28	same	same	JJ
8691	1524	29	judge	judge	NN
8691	1524	30	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	1524	31	of	of	IN
8691	1524	32	those	those	DT
8691	1524	33	on	on	IN
8691	1524	34	one	one	CD
8691	1524	35	docket	docket	NN
8691	1524	36	as	as	IN
8691	1524	37	a	a	DT
8691	1524	38	court	court	NN
8691	1524	39	of	of	IN
8691	1524	40	equity	equity	NN
8691	1524	41	and	and	CC
8691	1524	42	of	of	IN
8691	1524	43	those	those	DT
8691	1524	44	on	on	IN
8691	1524	45	the	the	DT
8691	1524	46	other	other	JJ
8691	1524	47	as	as	IN
8691	1524	48	a	a	DT
8691	1524	49	court	court	NN
8691	1524	50	of	of	IN
8691	1524	51	law	law	NN
8691	1524	52	.	.	.
8691	1525	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	1525	2	a	a	DT
8691	1525	3	system	system	NN
8691	1525	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1525	5	intrinsically	intrinsically	RB
8691	1525	6	absurd	absurd	JJ
8691	1525	7	.	.	.
8691	1526	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1526	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	1526	3	been	be	VBN
8691	1526	4	maintained	maintain	VBN
8691	1526	5	by	by	IN
8691	1526	6	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	1526	7	States	States	NNP
8691	1526	8	yet	yet	RB
8691	1526	9	tolerate	tolerate	VBP
8691	1526	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1526	11	for	for	IN
8691	1526	12	two	two	CD
8691	1526	13	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	1526	14	:	:	:
8691	1526	15	because	because	IN
8691	1526	16	the	the	DT
8691	1526	17	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	1526	18	and	and	CC
8691	1526	19	the	the	DT
8691	1526	20	community	community	NN
8691	1526	21	are	be	VBP
8691	1526	22	used	use	VBN
8691	1526	23	to	to	IN
8691	1526	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1526	25	,	,	,
8691	1526	26	and	and	CC
8691	1526	27	because	because	IN
8691	1526	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1526	29	furnishes	furnish	VBZ
8691	1526	30	a	a	DT
8691	1526	31	convenient	convenient	JJ
8691	1526	32	test	test	NN
8691	1526	33	of	of	IN
8691	1526	34	any	any	DT
8691	1526	35	claim	claim	NN
8691	1526	36	of	of	IN
8691	1526	37	right	right	NN
8691	1526	38	to	to	IN
8691	1526	39	a	a	DT
8691	1526	40	jury	jury	NN
8691	1526	41	trial	trial	NN
8691	1526	42	.	.	.
8691	1527	1	All	all	DT
8691	1527	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1527	3	State	State	NNP
8691	1527	4	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	1527	5	have	have	VBP
8691	1527	6	some	some	DT
8691	1527	7	provision	provision	NN
8691	1527	8	for	for	IN
8691	1527	9	maintaining	maintain	VBG
8691	1527	10	such	such	JJ
8691	1527	11	rights	right	NNS
8691	1527	12	,	,	,
8691	1527	13	but	but	CC
8691	1527	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1527	15	do	do	VBP
8691	1527	16	not	not	RB
8691	1527	17	define	define	VB
8691	1527	18	the	the	DT
8691	1527	19	cases	case	NNS
8691	1527	20	in	in	IN
8691	1527	21	which	which	WDT
8691	1527	22	the	the	DT
8691	1527	23	right	right	NN
8691	1527	24	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	1527	25	.	.	.
8691	1528	1	That	that	DT
8691	1528	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1528	3	left	leave	VBN
8691	1528	4	to	to	IN
8691	1528	5	the	the	DT
8691	1528	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	1528	7	,	,	,
8691	1528	8	and	and	CC
8691	1528	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1528	10	rule	rule	NN
8691	1528	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	1528	12	that	that	IN
8691	1528	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1528	14	can	can	MD
8691	1528	15	not	not	RB
8691	1528	16	be	be	VB
8691	1528	17	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	1528	18	in	in	IN
8691	1528	19	cases	case	NNS
8691	1528	20	that	that	WDT
8691	1528	21	call	call	VBP
8691	1528	22	for	for	IN
8691	1528	23	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	1528	24	as	as	IN
8691	1528	25	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
8691	1528	26	from	from	IN
8691	1528	27	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1528	28	relief	relief	NN
8691	1528	29	.	.	.
8691	1529	1	In	in	IN
8691	1529	2	most	most	JJS
8691	1529	3	of	of	IN
8691	1529	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1529	5	States	States	NNPS
8691	1529	6	and	and	CC
8691	1529	7	Territories	Territories	NNPS
8691	1529	8	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1529	9	and	and	CC
8691	1529	10	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	1529	11	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1529	12	of	of	IN
8691	1529	13	action	action	NN
8691	1529	14	or	or	CC
8691	1529	15	defenses	defense	NNS
8691	1529	16	may	may	MD
8691	1529	17	now	now	RB
8691	1529	18	be	be	VB
8691	1529	19	joined	join	VBN
8691	1529	20	,	,	,
8691	1529	21	and	and	CC
8691	1529	22	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1529	23	and	and	CC
8691	1529	24	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	1529	25	relief	relief	NN
8691	1529	26	given	give	VBN
8691	1529	27	in	in	IN
8691	1529	28	one	one	CD
8691	1529	29	suit	suit	NN
8691	1529	30	.	.	.
8691	1530	1	This	this	DT
8691	1530	2	reform	reform	NN
8691	1530	3	in	in	IN
8691	1530	4	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	1530	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1530	6	largely	largely	RB
8691	1530	7	due	due	JJ
8691	1530	8	to	to	IN
8691	1530	9	the	the	DT
8691	1530	10	labors	labor	NNS
8691	1530	11	of	of	IN
8691	1530	12	David	David	NNP
8691	1530	13	Dudley	Dudley	NNP
8691	1530	14	Field	Field	NNP
8691	1530	15	,	,	,
8691	1530	16	and	and	CC
8691	1530	17	became	become	VBD
8691	1530	18	general	general	JJ
8691	1530	19	throughout	throughout	IN
8691	1530	20	the	the	DT
8691	1530	21	country	country	NN
8691	1530	22	during	during	IN
8691	1530	23	the	the	DT
8691	1530	24	last	last	JJ
8691	1530	25	half	half	NN
8691	1530	26	of	of	IN
8691	1530	27	the	the	DT
8691	1530	28	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	1530	29	century	century	NN
8691	1530	30	.	.	.
8691	1531	1	The	the	DT
8691	1531	2	result	result	NN
8691	1531	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	1531	4	been	be	VBN
8691	1531	5	that	that	IN
8691	1531	6	separate	separate	JJ
8691	1531	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	1531	8	of	of	IN
8691	1531	9	equity	equity	NN
8691	1531	10	are	be	VBP
8691	1531	11	now	now	RB
8691	1531	12	to	to	TO
8691	1531	13	be	be	VB
8691	1531	14	found	find	VBN
8691	1531	15	only	only	RB
8691	1531	16	in	in	IN
8691	1531	17	a	a	DT
8691	1531	18	few	few	JJ
8691	1531	19	States	state	NNS
8691	1531	20	.	.	.
8691	1532	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1532	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	1532	3	made	make	VBN
8691	1532	4	use	use	NN
8691	1532	5	of	of	IN
8691	1532	6	the	the	DT
8691	1532	7	State	State	NNP
8691	1532	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	1532	9	in	in	IN
8691	1532	10	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1532	11	cases	case	NNS
8691	1532	12	as	as	IN
8691	1532	13	part	part	NN
8691	1532	14	of	of	IN
8691	1532	15	the	the	DT
8691	1532	16	machinery	machinery	NN
8691	1532	17	of	of	IN
8691	1532	18	the	the	DT
8691	1532	19	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1532	20	government	government	NN
8691	1532	21	.	.	.
8691	1533	1	While	while	IN
8691	1533	2	by	by	IN
8691	1533	3	the	the	DT
8691	1533	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1533	5	"	"	``
8691	1533	6	the	the	DT
8691	1533	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1533	8	power	power	NN
8691	1533	9	of	of	IN
8691	1533	10	the	the	DT
8691	1533	11	United	United	NNP
8691	1533	12	States	States	NNP
8691	1533	13	"	"	''
8691	1533	14	can	can	MD
8691	1533	15	only	only	RB
8691	1533	16	be	be	VB
8691	1533	17	vested	vest	VBN
8691	1533	18	in	in	IN
8691	1533	19	the	the	DT
8691	1533	20	courts	court	NNS
8691	1533	21	of	of	IN
8691	1533	22	the	the	DT
8691	1533	23	United	United	NNP
8691	1533	24	States	States	NNP
8691	1533	25	,	,	,
8691	1533	26	the	the	DT
8691	1533	27	phrase	phrase	NN
8691	1533	28	as	as	IN
8691	1533	29	thus	thus	RB
8691	1533	30	used	use	VBN
8691	1533	31	refers	refer	VBZ
8691	1533	32	only	only	RB
8691	1533	33	to	to	IN
8691	1533	34	the	the	DT
8691	1533	35	power	power	NN
8691	1533	36	of	of	IN
8691	1533	37	judging	judge	VBG
8691	1533	38	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1533	39	in	in	IN
8691	1533	40	courts	court	NNS
8691	1533	41	of	of	IN
8691	1533	42	record	record	NN
8691	1533	43	.	.	.
8691	1534	1	State	state	NN
8691	1534	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1534	3	and	and	CC
8691	1534	4	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
8691	1534	5	can	can	MD
8691	1534	6	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1534	7	be	be	VB
8691	1534	8	given	give	VBN
8691	1534	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1534	10	by	by	IN
8691	1534	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1534	12	over	over	IN
8691	1534	13	any	any	DT
8691	1534	14	acts	act	NNS
8691	1534	15	in	in	IN
8691	1534	16	aid	aid	NN
8691	1534	17	of	of	IN
8691	1534	18	the	the	DT
8691	1534	19	functions	function	NNS
8691	1534	20	of	of	IN
8691	1534	21	the	the	DT
8691	1534	22	United	United	NNP
8691	1534	23	States	States	NNP
8691	1534	24	,	,	,
8691	1534	25	the	the	DT
8691	1534	26	supervision	supervision	NN
8691	1534	27	of	of	IN
8691	1534	28	which	which	WDT
8691	1534	29	may	may	MD
8691	1534	30	be	be	VB
8691	1534	31	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	1534	32	as	as	IN
8691	1534	33	ministerial	ministerial	JJ
8691	1534	34	,	,	,
8691	1534	35	or	or	CC
8691	1534	36	as	as	IN
8691	1534	37	incidental	incidental	JJ
8691	1534	38	to	to	IN
8691	1534	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1534	40	power	power	NN
8691	1534	41	rather	rather	RB
8691	1534	42	than	than	IN
8691	1534	43	a	a	DT
8691	1534	44	part	part	NN
8691	1534	45	of	of	IN
8691	1534	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1534	47	.	.	.
8691	1535	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1535	2	have	have	VBP
8691	1535	3	received	receive	VBN
8691	1535	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1535	5	in	in	IN
8691	1535	6	this	this	DT
8691	1535	7	way	way	NN
8691	1535	8	with	with	IN
8691	1535	9	respect	respect	NN
8691	1535	10	to	to	IN
8691	1535	11	such	such	JJ
8691	1535	12	matters	matter	NNS
8691	1535	13	as	as	IN
8691	1535	14	seizure	seizure	NN
8691	1535	15	of	of	IN
8691	1535	16	deserters	deserter	NNS
8691	1535	17	from	from	IN
8691	1535	18	a	a	DT
8691	1535	19	merchantman	merchantman	NN
8691	1535	20	,	,	,
8691	1535	21	the	the	DT
8691	1535	22	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	1535	23	and	and	CC
8691	1535	24	commitment	commitment	NN
8691	1535	25	or	or	CC
8691	1535	26	bail	bail	NN
8691	1535	27	of	of	IN
8691	1535	28	offenders	offender	NNS
8691	1535	29	against	against	IN
8691	1535	30	the	the	DT
8691	1535	31	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1535	32	laws	law	NNS
8691	1535	33	of	of	IN
8691	1535	34	the	the	DT
8691	1535	35	United	United	NNP
8691	1535	36	States	States	NNP
8691	1535	37	,	,	,
8691	1535	38	the	the	DT
8691	1535	39	taking	taking	NN
8691	1535	40	of	of	IN
8691	1535	41	affidavits	affidavit	NNS
8691	1535	42	and	and	CC
8691	1535	43	depositions	deposition	NNS
8691	1535	44	for	for	IN
8691	1535	45	use	use	NN
8691	1535	46	in	in	IN
8691	1535	47	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1535	48	before	before	IN
8691	1535	49	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1535	50	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	1535	51	,	,	,
8691	1535	52	and	and	CC
8691	1535	53	the	the	DT
8691	1535	54	naturalization	naturalization	NN
8691	1535	55	of	of	IN
8691	1535	56	aliens	alien	NNS
8691	1535	57	.	.	.
8691	1536	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1536	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1536	3	:	:	:
8691	1536	4	Robertson	Robertson	NNP
8691	1536	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1536	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1536	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1536	8	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
8691	1536	9	,	,	,
8691	1536	10	165	165	CD
8691	1536	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1536	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1536	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1536	14	,	,	,
8691	1536	15	275	275	CD
8691	1536	16	.	.	.
8691	1536	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1537	1	State	state	NN
8691	1537	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1537	3	also	also	RB
8691	1537	4	have	have	VBP
8691	1537	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1537	6	over	over	IN
8691	1537	7	any	any	DT
8691	1537	8	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1537	9	action	action	NN
8691	1537	10	to	to	TO
8691	1537	11	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1537	12	a	a	DT
8691	1537	13	right	right	NN
8691	1537	14	given	give	VBN
8691	1537	15	by	by	IN
8691	1537	16	the	the	DT
8691	1537	17	laws	law	NNS
8691	1537	18	of	of	IN
8691	1537	19	the	the	DT
8691	1537	20	United	United	NNP
8691	1537	21	States	States	NNP
8691	1537	22	,	,	,
8691	1537	23	unless	unless	IN
8691	1537	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1537	25	has	have	VBZ
8691	1537	26	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	1537	27	provided	provide	VBN
8691	1537	28	.	.	.
8691	1538	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1538	2	constitute	constitute	VBP
8691	1538	3	together	together	RB
8691	1538	4	with	with	IN
8691	1538	5	the	the	DT
8691	1538	6	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1538	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	1538	8	one	one	CD
8691	1538	9	general	general	JJ
8691	1538	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1538	11	system	system	NN
8691	1538	12	for	for	IN
8691	1538	13	the	the	DT
8691	1538	14	whole	whole	JJ
8691	1538	15	country	country	NN
8691	1538	16	.	.	.
8691	1539	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1539	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1539	3	:	:	:
8691	1539	4	Cluflin	Cluflin	NNP
8691	1539	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1539	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1539	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1539	8	Houseman	Houseman	NNP
8691	1539	9	,	,	,
8691	1539	10	93	93	CD
8691	1539	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1539	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1539	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1539	14	,	,	,
8691	1539	15	130	130	CD
8691	1539	16	,	,	,
8691	1539	17	137	137	CD
8691	1539	18	;	;	:
8691	1539	19	Calvin	Calvin	NNP
8691	1539	20	v.	v.	IN
8691	1539	21	Huntley	Huntley	NNP
8691	1539	22	,	,	,
8691	1539	23	178	178	CD
8691	1539	24	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	1540	1	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1540	2	,	,	,
8691	1540	3	29	29	CD
8691	1540	4	;	;	:
8691	1540	5	59	59	CD
8691	1540	6	Northeastern	northeastern	JJ
8691	1540	7	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	1540	8	,	,	,
8691	1540	9	435	435	CD
8691	1540	10	.	.	.
8691	1540	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1541	1	Almost	almost	RB
8691	1541	2	all	all	DT
8691	1541	3	American	american	JJ
8691	1541	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	1541	5	are	be	VBP
8691	1541	6	known	know	VBN
8691	1541	7	as	as	IN
8691	1541	8	"	"	``
8691	1541	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	1541	10	of	of	IN
8691	1541	11	record	record	NN
8691	1541	12	.	.	.
8691	1541	13	"	"	''
8691	1542	1	A	a	DT
8691	1542	2	court	court	NN
8691	1542	3	of	of	IN
8691	1542	4	record	record	NN
8691	1542	5	,	,	,
8691	1542	6	in	in	IN
8691	1542	7	modern	modern	JJ
8691	1542	8	parlance	parlance	NN
8691	1542	9	,	,	,
8691	1542	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	1542	11	one	one	CD
8691	1542	12	which	which	WDT
8691	1542	13	tries	try	VBZ
8691	1542	14	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1542	15	between	between	IN
8691	1542	16	parties	party	NNS
8691	1542	17	and	and	CC
8691	1542	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	1542	19	required	require	VBN
8691	1542	20	to	to	TO
8691	1542	21	keep	keep	VB
8691	1542	22	a	a	DT
8691	1542	23	full	full	JJ
8691	1542	24	official	official	JJ
8691	1542	25	and	and	CC
8691	1542	26	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	1542	27	record	record	NN
8691	1542	28	of	of	IN
8691	1542	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1542	30	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	1542	31	of	of	IN
8691	1542	32	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1542	33	.	.	.
8691	1543	1	For	for	IN
8691	1543	2	this	this	DT
8691	1543	3	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1543	4	most	most	JJS
8691	1543	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	1543	6	are	be	VBP
8691	1543	7	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	1543	8	with	with	IN
8691	1543	9	a	a	DT
8691	1543	10	recording	recording	NN
8691	1543	11	officer	officer	NN
8691	1543	12	,	,	,
8691	1543	13	called	call	VBD
8691	1543	14	the	the	DT
8691	1543	15	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	1543	16	.	.	.
8691	1544	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1544	2	record	record	NN
8691	1544	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1544	4	the	the	DT
8691	1544	5	only	only	JJ
8691	1544	6	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	1544	7	of	of	IN
8691	1544	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1544	9	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1544	10	and	and	CC
8691	1544	11	can	can	MD
8691	1544	12	not	not	RB
8691	1544	13	be	be	VB
8691	1544	14	contradicted	contradict	VBN
8691	1544	15	or	or	CC
8691	1544	16	impeached	impeach	VBN
8691	1544	17	in	in	IN
8691	1544	18	any	any	DT
8691	1544	19	collateral	collateral	JJ
8691	1544	20	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1544	21	.	.	.
8691	1545	1	If	if	IN
8691	1545	2	there	there	EX
8691	1545	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1545	4	any	any	DT
8691	1545	5	error	error	NN
8691	1545	6	in	in	IN
8691	1545	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1545	8	,	,	,
8691	1545	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1545	10	can	can	MD
8691	1545	11	only	only	RB
8691	1545	12	be	be	VB
8691	1545	13	shown	show	VBN
8691	1545	14	on	on	IN
8691	1545	15	a	a	DT
8691	1545	16	direct	direct	JJ
8691	1545	17	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1545	18	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1545	19	to	to	TO
8691	1545	20	correct	correct	VB
8691	1545	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1545	22	.	.	.
8691	1546	1	Justices	justice	NNS
8691	1546	2	of	of	IN
8691	1546	3	the	the	DT
8691	1546	4	peace	peace	NN
8691	1546	5	,	,	,
8691	1546	6	when	when	WRB
8691	1546	7	authorized	authorize	VBN
8691	1546	8	to	to	TO
8691	1546	9	try	try	VB
8691	1546	10	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1546	11	,	,	,
8691	1546	12	act	act	VB
8691	1546	13	only	only	RB
8691	1546	14	in	in	IN
8691	1546	15	small	small	JJ
8691	1546	16	matters	matter	NNS
8691	1546	17	and	and	CC
8691	1546	18	in	in	IN
8691	1546	19	a	a	DT
8691	1546	20	summary	summary	NN
8691	1546	21	way	way	NN
8691	1546	22	.	.	.
8691	1547	1	In	in	IN
8691	1547	2	most	most	JJS
8691	1547	3	States	state	NNS
8691	1547	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1547	5	are	be	VBP
8691	1547	6	not	not	RB
8691	1547	7	,	,	,
8691	1547	8	when	when	WRB
8691	1547	9	exercising	exercise	VBG
8691	1547	10	this	this	DT
8691	1547	11	function	function	NN
8691	1547	12	,	,	,
8691	1547	13	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	1547	14	to	to	TO
8691	1547	15	constitute	constitute	VB
8691	1547	16	a	a	DT
8691	1547	17	court	court	NN
8691	1547	18	of	of	IN
8691	1547	19	record	record	NN
8691	1547	20	.	.	.
8691	1548	1	Nor	nor	CC
8691	1548	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1548	3	any	any	DT
8691	1548	4	court	court	NN
8691	1548	5	,	,	,
8691	1548	6	even	even	RB
8691	1548	7	though	though	IN
8691	1548	8	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	1548	9	with	with	IN
8691	1548	10	a	a	DT
8691	1548	11	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	1548	12	,	,	,
8691	1548	13	if	if	IN
8691	1548	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1548	15	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1548	16	are	be	VBP
8691	1548	17	not	not	RB
8691	1548	18	recorded	record	VBN
8691	1548	19	in	in	IN
8691	1548	20	full	full	JJ
8691	1548	21	,	,	,
8691	1548	22	but	but	CC
8691	1548	23	simply	simply	RB
8691	1548	24	made	make	VBD
8691	1548	25	the	the	DT
8691	1548	26	subject	subject	NN
8691	1548	27	of	of	IN
8691	1548	28	brief	brief	JJ
8691	1548	29	notes	note	NNS
8691	1548	30	or	or	CC
8691	1548	31	minutes,[Footnote	minutes,[footnote	CD
8691	1548	32	:	:	:
8691	1548	33	Hutkoff	Hutkoff	NNP
8691	1548	34	_	_	NNP
8691	1548	35	v.	v.	IN
8691	1548	36	_	_	NNP
8691	1548	37	Demorest	Demorest	NNP
8691	1548	38	,	,	,
8691	1548	39	104	104	CD
8691	1548	40	N.	n.	NN
8691	1548	41	Y.	Y.	NNP
8691	1549	1	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1549	2	,	,	,
8691	1549	3	655	655	CD
8691	1549	4	;	;	:
8691	1549	5	10	10	CD
8691	1549	6	Northeastern	northeastern	JJ
8691	1549	7	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	1549	8	,	,	,
8691	1549	9	535	535	CD
8691	1549	10	.	.	.
8691	1549	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1550	1	unless	unless	IN
8691	1550	2	there	there	EX
8691	1550	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1550	4	a	a	DT
8691	1550	5	statute	statute	NN
8691	1550	6	or	or	CC
8691	1550	7	local	local	JJ
8691	1550	8	practice	practice	NN
8691	1550	9	giving	give	VBG
8691	1550	10	such	such	JJ
8691	1550	11	notes	note	NNS
8691	1550	12	or	or	CC
8691	1550	13	minutes	minute	VBZ
8691	1550	14	the	the	DT
8691	1550	15	effect	effect	NN
8691	1550	16	of	of	IN
8691	1550	17	a	a	DT
8691	1550	18	record	record	NN
8691	1550	19	.	.	.
8691	1551	1	A	a	DT
8691	1551	2	court	court	NN
8691	1551	3	of	of	IN
8691	1551	4	record	record	NN
8691	1551	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	1551	6	inherent	inherent	JJ
8691	1551	7	power	power	NN
8691	1551	8	to	to	TO
8691	1551	9	preserve	preserve	VB
8691	1551	10	order	order	NN
8691	1551	11	in	in	IN
8691	1551	12	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1551	13	before	before	IN
8691	1551	14	it[Footnote	it[footnote	NN
8691	1551	15	:	:	:
8691	1551	16	See	see	VB
8691	1551	17	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	1551	18	.	.	.
8691	1552	1	XX	XX	NNP
8691	1552	2	.	.	.
8691	1552	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1553	1	and	and	CC
8691	1553	2	,	,	,
8691	1553	3	unless	unless	IN
8691	1553	4	other	other	JJ
8691	1553	5	provision	provision	NN
8691	1553	6	be	be	VB
8691	1553	7	made	make	VBN
8691	1553	8	by	by	IN
8691	1553	9	law	law	NN
8691	1553	10	,	,	,
8691	1553	11	to	to	TO
8691	1553	12	appoint	appoint	VB
8691	1553	13	a	a	DT
8691	1553	14	crier	cri	JJR
8691	1553	15	or	or	CC
8691	1553	16	other	other	JJ
8691	1553	17	officer	officer	NN
8691	1553	18	to	to	TO
8691	1553	19	attend	attend	VB
8691	1553	20	upon	upon	IN
8691	1553	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1553	22	sessions	session	NNS
8691	1553	23	.	.	.
8691	1554	1	By	by	IN
8691	1554	2	statute	statute	NN
8691	1554	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1554	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1554	5	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	1554	6	made	make	VBN
8691	1554	7	the	the	DT
8691	1554	8	duty	duty	NN
8691	1554	9	of	of	IN
8691	1554	10	the	the	DT
8691	1554	11	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	1554	12	of	of	IN
8691	1554	13	the	the	DT
8691	1554	14	county	county	NN
8691	1554	15	to	to	TO
8691	1554	16	attend	attend	VB
8691	1554	17	all	all	DT
8691	1554	18	courts	court	NNS
8691	1554	19	of	of	IN
8691	1554	20	record	record	NN
8691	1554	21	,	,	,
8691	1554	22	either	either	CC
8691	1554	23	personally	personally	RB
8691	1554	24	or	or	CC
8691	1554	25	by	by	IN
8691	1554	26	deputy	deputy	NN
8691	1554	27	.	.	.
8691	1555	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1555	2	also	also	RB
8691	1555	3	executes	execute	VBZ
8691	1555	4	such	such	JJ
8691	1555	5	processes	process	NNS
8691	1555	6	as	as	IN
8691	1555	7	under	under	IN
8691	1555	8	the	the	DT
8691	1555	9	practice	practice	NN
8691	1555	10	of	of	IN
8691	1555	11	the	the	DT
8691	1555	12	court	court	NN
8691	1555	13	may	may	MD
8691	1555	14	be	be	VB
8691	1555	15	directed	direct	VBN
8691	1555	16	to	to	IN
8691	1555	17	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1555	18	.	.	.
8691	1556	1	Witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	1556	2	and	and	CC
8691	1556	3	jurors	juror	NNS
8691	1556	4	are	be	VBP
8691	1556	5	thus	thus	RB
8691	1556	6	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	1556	7	by	by	IN
8691	1556	8	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1556	9	to	to	TO
8691	1556	10	appear	appear	VB
8691	1556	11	before	before	IN
8691	1556	12	the	the	DT
8691	1556	13	court	court	NN
8691	1556	14	;	;	:
8691	1556	15	arrests	arrest	NNS
8691	1556	16	and	and	CC
8691	1556	17	attachments	attachment	NNS
8691	1556	18	of	of	IN
8691	1556	19	property	property	NN
8691	1556	20	are	be	VBP
8691	1556	21	made	make	VBN
8691	1556	22	;	;	:
8691	1556	23	and	and	CC
8691	1556	24	executions	execution	NNS
8691	1556	25	are	be	VBP
8691	1556	26	levied	levy	VBN
8691	1556	27	to	to	TO
8691	1556	28	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1556	29	final	final	JJ
8691	1556	30	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1556	31	.	.	.
8691	1557	1	*	*	NFP
8691	1557	2	*	*	NFP
8691	1557	3	*	*	NFP
8691	1557	4	*	*	NFP
8691	1557	5	*	*	NFP
8691	1557	6	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
8691	1557	7	IX	IX	NNP
8691	1557	8	THE	the	DT
8691	1557	9	ORGANIZATION	ORGANIZATION	NNP
8691	1557	10	OF	of	IN
8691	1557	11	THE	the	DT
8691	1557	12	COURTS	COURTS	NNP
8691	1557	13	OF	of	IN
8691	1557	14	THE	the	DT
8691	1557	15	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
8691	1557	16	STATES	STATES	NNP
8691	1557	17	The	the	DT
8691	1557	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1557	19	of	of	IN
8691	1557	20	the	the	DT
8691	1557	21	United	United	NNP
8691	1557	22	States	States	NNP
8691	1557	23	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1557	24	Art	art	NN
8691	1557	25	.	.	.
8691	1558	1	III	III	NNP
8691	1558	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1558	3	provides	provide	VBZ
8691	1558	4	that	that	IN
8691	1558	5	there	there	EX
8691	1558	6	must	must	MD
8691	1558	7	always	always	RB
8691	1558	8	be	be	VB
8691	1558	9	one	one	CD
8691	1558	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1558	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1558	12	of	of	IN
8691	1558	13	the	the	DT
8691	1558	14	United	United	NNP
8691	1558	15	States	States	NNP
8691	1558	16	.	.	.
8691	1559	1	The	the	DT
8691	1559	2	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	1559	3	of	of	IN
8691	1559	4	such	such	JJ
8691	1559	5	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	1559	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	1559	7	as	as	IN
8691	1559	8	may	may	MD
8691	1559	9	be	be	VB
8691	1559	10	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	1559	11	proper	proper	JJ
8691	1559	12	from	from	IN
8691	1559	13	time	time	NN
8691	1559	14	to	to	IN
8691	1559	15	time	time	NN
8691	1559	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	1559	17	left	leave	VBN
8691	1559	18	to	to	IN
8691	1559	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1559	20	.	.	.
8691	1560	1	The	the	DT
8691	1560	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1560	3	power	power	NN
8691	1560	4	of	of	IN
8691	1560	5	the	the	DT
8691	1560	6	United	United	NNP
8691	1560	7	States	States	NNP
8691	1560	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	1560	9	limited	limit	VBN
8691	1560	10	to	to	IN
8691	1560	11	cases	case	NNS
8691	1560	12	of	of	IN
8691	1560	13	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1560	14	kinds	kind	NNS
8691	1560	15	or	or	CC
8691	1560	16	between	between	IN
8691	1560	17	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1560	18	kinds	kind	NNS
8691	1560	19	of	of	IN
8691	1560	20	parties	party	NNS
8691	1560	21	.	.	.
8691	1561	1	Either	either	CC
8691	1561	2	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1561	3	1	1	LS
8691	1561	4	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1561	5	the	the	DT
8691	1561	6	subject	subject	NN
8691	1561	7	-	-	HYPH
8691	1561	8	matter	matter	NN
8691	1561	9	of	of	IN
8691	1561	10	the	the	DT
8691	1561	11	action	action	NN
8691	1561	12	must	must	MD
8691	1561	13	be	be	VB
8691	1561	14	of	of	IN
8691	1561	15	a	a	DT
8691	1561	16	kind	kind	NN
8691	1561	17	that	that	WDT
8691	1561	18	concerns	concern	VBZ
8691	1561	19	the	the	DT
8691	1561	20	whole	whole	JJ
8691	1561	21	nation	nation	NN
8691	1561	22	,	,	,
8691	1561	23	or	or	CC
8691	1561	24	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1561	25	2	2	LS
8691	1561	26	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1561	27	some	some	DT
8691	1561	28	party	party	NN
8691	1561	29	to	to	IN
8691	1561	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1561	31	must	must	MD
8691	1561	32	be	be	VB
8691	1561	33	or	or	CC
8691	1561	34	claim	claim	VB
8691	1561	35	under	under	IN
8691	1561	36	a	a	DT
8691	1561	37	political	political	JJ
8691	1561	38	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	1561	39	,	,	,
8691	1561	40	or	or	CC
8691	1561	41	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1561	42	3	3	LS
8691	1561	43	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1561	44	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1561	45	must	must	MD
8691	1561	46	be	be	VB
8691	1561	47	between	between	IN
8691	1561	48	a	a	DT
8691	1561	49	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	1561	50	of	of	IN
8691	1561	51	a	a	DT
8691	1561	52	State	State	NNP
8691	1561	53	of	of	IN
8691	1561	54	the	the	DT
8691	1561	55	Union	Union	NNP
8691	1561	56	and	and	CC
8691	1561	57	one	one	CD
8691	1561	58	of	of	IN
8691	1561	59	another	another	DT
8691	1561	60	of	of	IN
8691	1561	61	the	the	DT
8691	1561	62	States	States	NNPS
8691	1561	63	or	or	CC
8691	1561	64	of	of	IN
8691	1561	65	a	a	DT
8691	1561	66	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1561	67	country	country	NN
8691	1561	68	.	.	.
8691	1562	1	In	in	IN
8691	1562	2	a	a	DT
8691	1562	3	few	few	JJ
8691	1562	4	of	of	IN
8691	1562	5	the	the	DT
8691	1562	6	second	second	JJ
8691	1562	7	class	class	NN
8691	1562	8	the	the	DT
8691	1562	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1562	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1562	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	1562	12	given	give	VBN
8691	1562	13	original	original	JJ
8691	1562	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1562	15	:	:	:
8691	1562	16	in	in	IN
8691	1562	17	all	all	DT
8691	1562	18	others	other	NNS
8691	1562	19	of	of	IN
8691	1562	20	both	both	DT
8691	1562	21	classes	class	NNS
8691	1562	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1562	23	has	have	VBZ
8691	1562	24	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	1562	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1562	26	,	,	,
8691	1562	27	with	with	IN
8691	1562	28	such	such	JJ
8691	1562	29	exceptions	exception	NNS
8691	1562	30	as	as	IN
8691	1562	31	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1562	32	may	may	MD
8691	1562	33	think	think	VB
8691	1562	34	fit	fit	JJ
8691	1562	35	to	to	TO
8691	1562	36	make	make	VB
8691	1562	37	,	,	,
8691	1562	38	save	save	VB
8691	1562	39	only	only	RB
8691	1562	40	that	that	IN
8691	1562	41	no	no	DT
8691	1562	42	fact	fact	NN
8691	1562	43	tried	try	VBN
8691	1562	44	by	by	IN
8691	1562	45	a	a	DT
8691	1562	46	jury	jury	NN
8691	1562	47	can	can	MD
8691	1562	48	be	be	VB
8691	1562	49	thus	thus	RB
8691	1562	50	re	re	VBN
8691	1562	51	-	-	VBN
8691	1562	52	examined	examine	VBN
8691	1562	53	,	,	,
8691	1562	54	except	except	IN
8691	1562	55	so	so	RB
8691	1562	56	far	far	RB
8691	1562	57	as	as	IN
8691	1562	58	the	the	DT
8691	1562	59	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1562	60	of	of	IN
8691	1562	61	the	the	DT
8691	1562	62	common	common	JJ
8691	1562	63	law	law	NN
8691	1562	64	would	would	MD
8691	1562	65	have	have	VB
8691	1562	66	permitted	permit	VBN
8691	1562	67	.	.	.
8691	1563	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1563	2	original	original	JJ
8691	1563	3	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1563	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1563	5	confined	confine	VBN
8691	1563	6	to	to	IN
8691	1563	7	cases	case	NNS
8691	1563	8	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	1563	9	ambassadors	ambassador	NNS
8691	1563	10	,	,	,
8691	1563	11	ministers	minister	NNS
8691	1563	12	,	,	,
8691	1563	13	and	and	CC
8691	1563	14	consuls	consul	NNS
8691	1563	15	and	and	CC
8691	1563	16	those	those	DT
8691	1563	17	to	to	TO
8691	1563	18	which	which	WDT
8691	1563	19	a	a	DT
8691	1563	20	State	state	NN
8691	1563	21	shall	shall	MD
8691	1563	22	be	be	VB
8691	1563	23	a	a	DT
8691	1563	24	party	party	NN
8691	1563	25	.	.	.
8691	1564	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1564	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1564	3	not	not	RB
8691	1564	4	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	1564	5	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
8691	1564	6	as	as	IN
8691	1564	7	respects	respect	NNS
8691	1564	8	any	any	DT
8691	1564	9	of	of	IN
8691	1564	10	them,[Footnote	them,[footnote	CD
8691	1564	11	:	:	:
8691	1564	12	Ames	Ames	NNP
8691	1564	13	_	_	NNP
8691	1564	14	v.	v.	IN
8691	1564	15	_	_	NNP
8691	1564	16	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
8691	1564	17	,	,	,
8691	1564	18	111	111	CD
8691	1564	19	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1564	20	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1564	21	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1564	22	,	,	,
8691	1564	23	449	449	CD
8691	1564	24	,	,	,
8691	1564	25	469	469	CD
8691	1564	26	.	.	.
8691	1564	27	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1565	1	and	and	CC
8691	1565	2	by	by	IN
8691	1565	3	the	the	DT
8691	1565	4	eleventh	eleventh	NNP
8691	1565	5	amendment	amendment	NNP
8691	1565	6	to	to	IN
8691	1565	7	the	the	DT
8691	1565	8	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1565	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1565	10	so	so	RB
8691	1565	11	limited	limited	JJ
8691	1565	12	as	as	IN
8691	1565	13	not	not	RB
8691	1565	14	to	to	TO
8691	1565	15	include	include	VB
8691	1565	16	suits	suit	NNS
8691	1565	17	against	against	IN
8691	1565	18	a	a	DT
8691	1565	19	State	state	NN
8691	1565	20	by	by	IN
8691	1565	21	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1565	22	of	of	IN
8691	1565	23	any	any	DT
8691	1565	24	other	other	JJ
8691	1565	25	State	State	NNP
8691	1565	26	or	or	CC
8691	1565	27	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1565	28	government	government	NN
8691	1565	29	.	.	.
8691	1566	1	In	in	IN
8691	1566	2	point	point	NN
8691	1566	3	of	of	IN
8691	1566	4	fact	fact	NN
8691	1566	5	,	,	,
8691	1566	6	few	few	JJ
8691	1566	7	original	original	JJ
8691	1566	8	suits	suit	NNS
8691	1566	9	have	have	VBP
8691	1566	10	ever	ever	RB
8691	1566	11	been	be	VBN
8691	1566	12	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1566	13	before	before	IN
8691	1566	14	the	the	DT
8691	1566	15	court	court	NN
8691	1566	16	,	,	,
8691	1566	17	and	and	CC
8691	1566	18	almost	almost	RB
8691	1566	19	all	all	DT
8691	1566	20	of	of	IN
8691	1566	21	these	these	DT
8691	1566	22	have	have	VBP
8691	1566	23	been	be	VBN
8691	1566	24	instituted	institute	VBN
8691	1566	25	by	by	IN
8691	1566	26	or	or	CC
8691	1566	27	against	against	IN
8691	1566	28	States	States	NNP
8691	1566	29	.	.	.
8691	1567	1	The	the	DT
8691	1567	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1567	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1567	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1567	5	held	hold	VBN
8691	1567	6	at	at	IN
8691	1567	7	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	1567	8	.	.	.
8691	1568	1	There	there	EX
8691	1568	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1568	3	a	a	DT
8691	1568	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1568	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1568	6	with	with	IN
8691	1568	7	eight	eight	CD
8691	1568	8	associate	associate	NN
8691	1568	9	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1568	10	,	,	,
8691	1568	11	and	and	CC
8691	1568	12	each	each	DT
8691	1568	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	1568	14	also	also	RB
8691	1568	15	assigned	assign	VBN
8691	1568	16	for	for	IN
8691	1568	17	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1568	18	duty	duty	NN
8691	1568	19	as	as	IN
8691	1568	20	a	a	DT
8691	1568	21	judge	judge	NN
8691	1568	22	of	of	IN
8691	1568	23	the	the	DT
8691	1568	24	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1568	25	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1568	26	of	of	IN
8691	1568	27	the	the	DT
8691	1568	28	United	United	NNP
8691	1568	29	States	States	NNP
8691	1568	30	in	in	IN
8691	1568	31	one	one	CD
8691	1568	32	of	of	IN
8691	1568	33	nine	nine	CD
8691	1568	34	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1568	35	circuits	circuit	NNS
8691	1568	36	into	into	IN
8691	1568	37	which	which	WDT
8691	1568	38	the	the	DT
8691	1568	39	country	country	NN
8691	1568	40	is	be	VBZ
8691	1568	41	divided	divide	VBN
8691	1568	42	.	.	.
8691	1569	1	Originally	originally	RB
8691	1569	2	there	there	EX
8691	1569	3	were	be	VBD
8691	1569	4	but	but	CC
8691	1569	5	six	six	CD
8691	1569	6	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1569	7	,	,	,
8691	1569	8	and	and	CC
8691	1569	9	each	each	DT
8691	1569	10	was	be	VBD
8691	1569	11	required	require	VBN
8691	1569	12	to	to	TO
8691	1569	13	hold	hold	VB
8691	1569	14	two	two	CD
8691	1569	15	circuits	circuit	NNS
8691	1569	16	a	a	DT
8691	1569	17	year	year	NN
8691	1569	18	in	in	IN
8691	1569	19	each	each	DT
8691	1569	20	district	district	NN
8691	1569	21	in	in	IN
8691	1569	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1569	23	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1569	24	.	.	.
8691	1570	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1570	2	were	be	VBD
8691	1570	3	assigned	assign	VBN
8691	1570	4	to	to	IN
8691	1570	5	the	the	DT
8691	1570	6	circuits	circuit	NNS
8691	1570	7	in	in	IN
8691	1570	8	pairs	pair	NNS
8691	1570	9	,	,	,
8691	1570	10	and	and	CC
8691	1570	11	both	both	DT
8691	1570	12	sat	sit	VBD
8691	1570	13	together	together	RB
8691	1570	14	with	with	IN
8691	1570	15	the	the	DT
8691	1570	16	District	District	NNP
8691	1570	17	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	1570	18	.	.	.
8691	1571	1	The	the	DT
8691	1571	2	consequence	consequence	NN
8691	1571	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1571	4	that	that	IN
8691	1571	5	three	three	CD
8691	1571	6	-	-	HYPH
8691	1571	7	fourths	fourth	NNS
8691	1571	8	of	of	IN
8691	1571	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1571	10	time	time	NN
8691	1571	11	was	be	VBD
8691	1571	12	spent	spend	VBN
8691	1571	13	in	in	IN
8691	1571	14	traveling	travel	VBG
8691	1571	15	from	from	IN
8691	1571	16	one	one	CD
8691	1571	17	court	court	NN
8691	1571	18	town	town	NN
8691	1571	19	to	to	IN
8691	1571	20	another	another	DT
8691	1571	21	.	.	.
8691	1572	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1572	2	complained	complain	VBD
8691	1572	3	of	of	IN
8691	1572	4	this	this	DT
8691	1572	5	to	to	IN
8691	1572	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1572	7	through	through	IN
8691	1572	8	the	the	DT
8691	1572	9	President	President	NNP
8691	1572	10	in	in	IN
8691	1572	11	1792	1792	CD
8691	1572	12	,	,	,
8691	1572	13	and	and	CC
8691	1572	14	the	the	DT
8691	1572	15	next	next	JJ
8691	1572	16	year	year	NN
8691	1572	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1572	18	was	be	VBD
8691	1572	19	provided	provide	VBN
8691	1572	20	that	that	IN
8691	1572	21	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1572	22	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1572	23	might	may	MD
8691	1572	24	be	be	VB
8691	1572	25	held	hold	VBN
8691	1572	26	by	by	IN
8691	1572	27	one	one	CD
8691	1572	28	justice	justice	NN
8691	1572	29	,	,	,
8691	1572	30	alone	alone	RB
8691	1572	31	or	or	CC
8691	1572	32	with	with	IN
8691	1572	33	the	the	DT
8691	1572	34	District	District	NNP
8691	1572	35	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	1572	36	.	.	.
8691	1573	1	In	in	IN
8691	1573	2	1801	1801	CD
8691	1573	3	,	,	,
8691	1573	4	an	an	DT
8691	1573	5	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
8691	1573	6	reduction	reduction	NN
8691	1573	7	of	of	IN
8691	1573	8	the	the	DT
8691	1573	9	number	number	NN
8691	1573	10	to	to	IN
8691	1573	11	five	five	CD
8691	1573	12	was	be	VBD
8691	1573	13	provided	provide	VBN
8691	1573	14	for	for	IN
8691	1573	15	.	.	.
8691	1574	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1574	2	were	be	VBD
8691	1574	3	to	to	TO
8691	1574	4	devote	devote	VB
8691	1574	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1574	6	time	time	NN
8691	1574	7	entirely	entirely	RB
8691	1574	8	to	to	IN
8691	1574	9	the	the	DT
8691	1574	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1574	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1574	12	,	,	,
8691	1574	13	while	while	IN
8691	1574	14	the	the	DT
8691	1574	15	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1574	16	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1574	17	were	be	VBD
8691	1574	18	to	to	TO
8691	1574	19	be	be	VB
8691	1574	20	held	hold	VBN
8691	1574	21	by	by	IN
8691	1574	22	a	a	DT
8691	1574	23	new	new	JJ
8691	1574	24	set	set	NN
8691	1574	25	of	of	IN
8691	1574	26	eighteen	eighteen	CD
8691	1574	27	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1574	28	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	1574	29	.	.	.
8691	1575	1	In	in	IN
8691	1575	2	1802	1802	CD
8691	1575	3	,	,	,
8691	1575	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1575	5	had	have	VBD
8691	1575	6	only	only	RB
8691	1575	7	ten	ten	CD
8691	1575	8	cases	case	NNS
8691	1575	9	pending	pende	VBG
8691	1575	10	before	before	IN
8691	1575	11	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1575	12	,	,	,
8691	1575	13	and	and	CC
8691	1575	14	the	the	DT
8691	1575	15	average	average	NN
8691	1575	16	for	for	IN
8691	1575	17	some	some	DT
8691	1575	18	years	year	NNS
8691	1575	19	had	have	VBD
8691	1575	20	not	not	RB
8691	1575	21	exceeded	exceed	VBN
8691	1575	22	that	that	DT
8691	1575	23	number	number	NN
8691	1575	24	.	.	.
8691	1576	1	For	for	IN
8691	1576	2	this	this	DT
8691	1576	3	and	and	CC
8691	1576	4	other	other	JJ
8691	1576	5	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	1576	6	mentioned	mention	VBN
8691	1576	7	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
8691	1576	8	the	the	DT
8691	1576	9	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1576	10	of	of	IN
8691	1576	11	1801	1801	CD
8691	1576	12	was	be	VBD
8691	1576	13	repealed	repeal	VBN
8691	1576	14	by	by	IN
8691	1576	15	the	the	DT
8691	1576	16	next	next	JJ
8691	1576	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1576	18	.	.	.
8691	1577	1	In	in	IN
8691	1577	2	1807	1807	CD
8691	1577	3	,	,	,
8691	1577	4	another	another	DT
8691	1577	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1577	6	of	of	IN
8691	1577	7	the	the	DT
8691	1577	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1577	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1577	10	was	be	VBD
8691	1577	11	added	add	VBN
8691	1577	12	and	and	CC
8691	1577	13	two	two	CD
8691	1577	14	more	more	JJR
8691	1577	15	in	in	IN
8691	1577	16	1837	1837	CD
8691	1577	17	.	.	.
8691	1578	1	Each	each	DT
8691	1578	2	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1578	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	1578	4	a	a	DT
8691	1578	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1578	6	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	1578	7	of	of	IN
8691	1578	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1578	9	own	own	JJ
8691	1578	10	,	,	,
8691	1578	11	and	and	CC
8691	1578	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	1578	13	composed	compose	VBN
8691	1578	14	of	of	IN
8691	1578	15	a	a	DT
8691	1578	16	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1578	17	number	number	NN
8691	1578	18	of	of	IN
8691	1578	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1578	20	districts	district	NNS
8691	1578	21	.	.	.
8691	1579	1	Of	of	IN
8691	1579	2	these	these	DT
8691	1579	3	there	there	EX
8691	1579	4	are	be	VBP
8691	1579	5	in	in	IN
8691	1579	6	the	the	DT
8691	1579	7	whole	whole	JJ
8691	1579	8	United	United	NNP
8691	1579	9	States	States	NNP
8691	1579	10	about	about	IN
8691	1579	11	eighty	eighty	CD
8691	1579	12	.	.	.
8691	1580	1	The	the	DT
8691	1580	2	smaller	small	JJR
8691	1580	3	States	state	NNS
8691	1580	4	constitute	constitute	VBP
8691	1580	5	one	one	CD
8691	1580	6	district	district	NN
8691	1580	7	.	.	.
8691	1581	1	In	in	IN
8691	1581	2	the	the	DT
8691	1581	3	larger	large	JJR
8691	1581	4	ones	one	NNS
8691	1581	5	there	there	EX
8691	1581	6	are	be	VBP
8691	1581	7	several	several	JJ
8691	1581	8	.	.	.
8691	1582	1	Each	each	DT
8691	1582	2	district	district	NN
8691	1582	3	generally	generally	RB
8691	1582	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	1582	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1582	6	own	own	JJ
8691	1582	7	judge	judge	NN
8691	1582	8	,	,	,
8691	1582	9	called	call	VBN
8691	1582	10	the	the	DT
8691	1582	11	District	District	NNP
8691	1582	12	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	1582	13	,	,	,
8691	1582	14	and	and	CC
8691	1582	15	always	always	RB
8691	1582	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1582	17	own	own	JJ
8691	1582	18	court	court	NN
8691	1582	19	,	,	,
8691	1582	20	called	call	VBD
8691	1582	21	the	the	DT
8691	1582	22	District	District	NNP
8691	1582	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1582	24	of	of	IN
8691	1582	25	that	that	DT
8691	1582	26	district	district	NN
8691	1582	27	.	.	.
8691	1583	1	Each	each	DT
8691	1583	2	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1583	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	1583	4	several	several	JJ
8691	1583	5	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1583	6	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	1583	7	,	,	,
8691	1583	8	whose	whose	WP$
8691	1583	9	main	main	JJ
8691	1583	10	work	work	NN
8691	1583	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	1583	12	to	to	TO
8691	1583	13	sit	sit	VB
8691	1583	14	in	in	IN
8691	1583	15	a	a	DT
8691	1583	16	court	court	NN
8691	1583	17	held	hold	VBN
8691	1583	18	in	in	IN
8691	1583	19	each	each	DT
8691	1583	20	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1583	21	,	,	,
8691	1583	22	styled	style	VBD
8691	1583	23	the	the	DT
8691	1583	24	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1583	25	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1583	26	of	of	IN
8691	1583	27	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1583	28	.	.	.
8691	1584	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1584	2	can	can	MD
8691	1584	3	also	also	RB
8691	1584	4	hold	hold	VB
8691	1584	5	a	a	DT
8691	1584	6	District	District	NNP
8691	1584	7	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1584	8	.	.	.
8691	1585	1	Until	until	IN
8691	1585	2	1911	1911	CD
8691	1585	3	,	,	,
8691	1585	4	the	the	DT
8691	1585	5	District	District	NNP
8691	1585	6	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1585	7	had	have	VBD
8691	1585	8	a	a	DT
8691	1585	9	narrow	narrow	JJ
8691	1585	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1585	11	,	,	,
8691	1585	12	and	and	CC
8691	1585	13	there	there	EX
8691	1585	14	were	be	VBD
8691	1585	15	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1585	16	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1585	17	having	have	VBG
8691	1585	18	a	a	DT
8691	1585	19	wider	wide	JJR
8691	1585	20	one	one	NN
8691	1585	21	.	.	.
8691	1586	1	In	in	IN
8691	1586	2	1911	1911	CD
8691	1586	3	,	,	,
8691	1586	4	the	the	DT
8691	1586	5	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1586	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1586	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1586	8	abolished	abolish	VBN
8691	1586	9	,	,	,
8691	1586	10	and	and	CC
8691	1586	11	the	the	DT
8691	1586	12	District	District	NNP
8691	1586	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1586	14	now	now	RB
8691	1586	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	1586	16	the	the	DT
8691	1586	17	general	general	JJ
8691	1586	18	trial	trial	NN
8691	1586	19	court	court	NN
8691	1586	20	of	of	IN
8691	1586	21	the	the	DT
8691	1586	22	United	United	NNP
8691	1586	23	States	States	NNP
8691	1586	24	in	in	IN
8691	1586	25	the	the	DT
8691	1586	26	first	first	JJ
8691	1586	27	instance	instance	NN
8691	1586	28	.	.	.
8691	1587	1	Anyone	anyone	NN
8691	1587	2	can	can	MD
8691	1587	3	sue	sue	VB
8691	1587	4	there	there	RB
8691	1587	5	to	to	TO
8691	1587	6	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1587	7	a	a	DT
8691	1587	8	right	right	NN
8691	1587	9	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1587	10	under	under	IN
8691	1587	11	the	the	DT
8691	1587	12	laws	law	NNS
8691	1587	13	of	of	IN
8691	1587	14	the	the	DT
8691	1587	15	United	United	NNP
8691	1587	16	States	States	NNP
8691	1587	17	when	when	WRB
8691	1587	18	the	the	DT
8691	1587	19	amount	amount	NN
8691	1587	20	in	in	IN
8691	1587	21	dispute	dispute	NN
8691	1587	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	1587	23	more	more	JJR
8691	1587	24	than	than	IN
8691	1587	25	$	$	$
8691	1587	26	3,000	3,000	CD
8691	1587	27	.	.	.
8691	1588	1	Rights	right	NNS
8691	1588	2	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1588	3	under	under	IN
8691	1588	4	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1588	5	of	of	IN
8691	1588	6	these	these	DT
8691	1588	7	laws	law	NNS
8691	1588	8	can	can	MD
8691	1588	9	only	only	RB
8691	1588	10	be	be	VB
8691	1588	11	enforced	enforce	VBN
8691	1588	12	there	there	RB
8691	1588	13	,	,	,
8691	1588	14	and	and	CC
8691	1588	15	as	as	IN
8691	1588	16	to	to	IN
8691	1588	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1588	18	the	the	DT
8691	1588	19	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
8691	1588	20	limitation	limitation	NN
8691	1588	21	does	do	VBZ
8691	1588	22	not	not	RB
8691	1588	23	apply	apply	VB
8691	1588	24	.	.	.
8691	1589	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	1589	2	are	be	VBP
8691	1589	3	patent	patent	NN
8691	1589	4	-	-	HYPH
8691	1589	5	rights	right	NNS
8691	1589	6	and	and	CC
8691	1589	7	copyrights	copyright	NNS
8691	1589	8	.	.	.
8691	1590	1	Any	any	DT
8691	1590	2	suit	suit	NN
8691	1590	3	involving	involve	VBG
8691	1590	4	an	an	DT
8691	1590	5	amount	amount	NN
8691	1590	6	exceeding	exceed	VBG
8691	1590	7	$	$	$
8691	1590	8	3,000	3,000	CD
8691	1590	9	may	may	MD
8691	1590	10	be	be	VB
8691	1590	11	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1590	12	there	there	RB
8691	1590	13	when	when	WRB
8691	1590	14	the	the	DT
8691	1590	15	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	1590	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	1590	17	between	between	IN
8691	1590	18	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1590	19	of	of	IN
8691	1590	20	different	different	JJ
8691	1590	21	States	state	NNS
8691	1590	22	or	or	CC
8691	1590	23	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1590	24	of	of	IN
8691	1590	25	a	a	DT
8691	1590	26	State	state	NN
8691	1590	27	and	and	CC
8691	1590	28	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1590	29	of	of	IN
8691	1590	30	a	a	DT
8691	1590	31	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1590	32	country	country	NN
8691	1590	33	.	.	.
8691	1591	1	So	so	CC
8691	1591	2	may	may	MD
8691	1591	3	a	a	DT
8691	1591	4	suit	suit	NN
8691	1591	5	by	by	IN
8691	1591	6	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1591	7	of	of	IN
8691	1591	8	the	the	DT
8691	1591	9	same	same	JJ
8691	1591	10	State	State	NNP
8691	1591	11	claiming	claim	VBG
8691	1591	12	land	land	NN
8691	1591	13	under	under	IN
8691	1591	14	grants	grant	NNS
8691	1591	15	from	from	IN
8691	1591	16	different	different	JJ
8691	1591	17	States	state	NNS
8691	1591	18	,	,	,
8691	1591	19	without	without	IN
8691	1591	20	respect	respect	NN
8691	1591	21	to	to	IN
8691	1591	22	the	the	DT
8691	1591	23	value	value	NN
8691	1591	24	of	of	IN
8691	1591	25	the	the	DT
8691	1591	26	subject	subject	NN
8691	1591	27	of	of	IN
8691	1591	28	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	1591	29	.	.	.
8691	1592	1	Suits	suit	NNS
8691	1592	2	of	of	IN
8691	1592	3	any	any	DT
8691	1592	4	of	of	IN
8691	1592	5	these	these	DT
8691	1592	6	kinds	kind	NNS
8691	1592	7	which	which	WDT
8691	1592	8	are	be	VBP
8691	1592	9	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1592	10	in	in	RP
8691	1592	11	a	a	DT
8691	1592	12	State	State	NNP
8691	1592	13	court	court	NN
8691	1592	14	may	may	MD
8691	1592	15	,	,	,
8691	1592	16	at	at	IN
8691	1592	17	the	the	DT
8691	1592	18	option	option	NN
8691	1592	19	of	of	IN
8691	1592	20	the	the	DT
8691	1592	21	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	1592	22	,	,	,
8691	1592	23	be	be	VB
8691	1592	24	transferred	transfer	VBN
8691	1592	25	for	for	IN
8691	1592	26	trial	trial	NN
8691	1592	27	into	into	IN
8691	1592	28	the	the	DT
8691	1592	29	District	District	NNP
8691	1592	30	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1592	31	.	.	.
8691	1593	1	On	on	IN
8691	1593	2	filing	file	VBG
8691	1593	3	proper	proper	JJ
8691	1593	4	papers	paper	NNS
8691	1593	5	the	the	DT
8691	1593	6	case	case	NN
8691	1593	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1593	8	transferred	transfer	VBN
8691	1593	9	automatically	automatically	RB
8691	1593	10	.	.	.
8691	1594	1	The	the	DT
8691	1594	2	District	District	NNP
8691	1594	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1594	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	1594	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1594	6	also	also	RB
8691	1594	7	over	over	IN
8691	1594	8	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	1594	9	and	and	CC
8691	1594	10	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	1594	11	matters	matter	NNS
8691	1594	12	,	,	,
8691	1594	13	a	a	DT
8691	1594	14	few	few	JJ
8691	1594	15	other	other	JJ
8691	1594	16	kinds	kind	NNS
8691	1594	17	of	of	IN
8691	1594	18	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1594	19	cases	case	NNS
8691	1594	20	of	of	IN
8691	1594	21	minor	minor	JJ
8691	1594	22	importance	importance	NN
8691	1594	23	,	,	,
8691	1594	24	and	and	CC
8691	1594	25	of	of	IN
8691	1594	26	all	all	DT
8691	1594	27	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	1594	28	against	against	IN
8691	1594	29	the	the	DT
8691	1594	30	United	United	NNP
8691	1594	31	States	States	NNP
8691	1594	32	.	.	.
8691	1595	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1595	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1595	3	:	:	:
8691	1595	4	The	the	DT
8691	1595	5	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	1595	6	Code	Code	NNP
8691	1595	7	of	of	IN
8691	1595	8	the	the	DT
8691	1595	9	United	United	NNP
8691	1595	10	States	States	NNP
8691	1595	11	,	,	,
8691	1595	12	Chapter	Chapter	NNP
8691	1595	13	II	II	NNP
8691	1595	14	.	.	.
8691	1595	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1596	1	The	the	DT
8691	1596	2	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
8691	1596	3	limit	limit	NN
8691	1596	4	of	of	IN
8691	1596	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1596	6	was	be	VBD
8691	1596	7	for	for	IN
8691	1596	8	a	a	DT
8691	1596	9	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	1596	10	years	year	NNS
8691	1596	11	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	1596	12	at	at	IN
8691	1596	13	$	$	$
8691	1596	14	500	500	CD
8691	1596	15	.	.	.
8691	1597	1	The	the	DT
8691	1597	2	increase	increase	NN
8691	1597	3	to	to	IN
8691	1597	4	$	$	$
8691	1597	5	3,000	3,000	CD
8691	1597	6	was	be	VBD
8691	1597	7	due	due	JJ
8691	1597	8	partly	partly	RB
8691	1597	9	to	to	IN
8691	1597	10	the	the	DT
8691	1597	11	fact	fact	NN
8691	1597	12	that	that	IN
8691	1597	13	the	the	DT
8691	1597	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1597	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1597	16	was	be	VBD
8691	1597	17	overburdened	overburden	VBN
8691	1597	18	by	by	IN
8691	1597	19	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	1597	20	from	from	IN
8691	1597	21	the	the	DT
8691	1597	22	trial	trial	NN
8691	1597	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	1597	24	,	,	,
8691	1597	25	many	many	DT
8691	1597	26	of	of	IN
8691	1597	27	which	which	WDT
8691	1597	28	involved	involve	VBD
8691	1597	29	small	small	JJ
8691	1597	30	amounts	amount	NNS
8691	1597	31	,	,	,
8691	1597	32	and	and	CC
8691	1597	33	more	more	JJR
8691	1597	34	to	to	IN
8691	1597	35	a	a	DT
8691	1597	36	desire	desire	NN
8691	1597	37	to	to	TO
8691	1597	38	keep	keep	VB
8691	1597	39	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1597	40	power	power	NN
8691	1597	41	over	over	IN
8691	1597	42	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	1597	43	controversies	controversy	NNS
8691	1597	44	between	between	IN
8691	1597	45	man	man	NN
8691	1597	46	and	and	CC
8691	1597	47	man	man	NN
8691	1597	48	,	,	,
8691	1597	49	as	as	RB
8691	1597	50	far	far	RB
8691	1597	51	as	as	IN
8691	1597	52	practicable	practicable	JJ
8691	1597	53	,	,	,
8691	1597	54	in	in	IN
8691	1597	55	the	the	DT
8691	1597	56	hands	hand	NNS
8691	1597	57	of	of	IN
8691	1597	58	the	the	DT
8691	1597	59	State	State	NNP
8691	1597	60	courts	court	NNS
8691	1597	61	.	.	.
8691	1598	1	Early	early	RB
8691	1598	2	in	in	IN
8691	1598	3	the	the	DT
8691	1598	4	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	1598	5	century	century	NN
8691	1598	6	a	a	DT
8691	1598	7	practice	practice	NN
8691	1598	8	began	begin	VBD
8691	1598	9	of	of	IN
8691	1598	10	bringing	bring	VBG
8691	1598	11	suits	suit	NNS
8691	1598	12	in	in	IN
8691	1598	13	the	the	DT
8691	1598	14	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1598	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1598	16	of	of	IN
8691	1598	17	the	the	DT
8691	1598	18	United	United	NNP
8691	1598	19	States	States	NNP
8691	1598	20	,	,	,
8691	1598	21	which	which	WDT
8691	1598	22	purported	purport	VBD
8691	1598	23	to	to	TO
8691	1598	24	be	be	VB
8691	1598	25	between	between	IN
8691	1598	26	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1598	27	of	of	IN
8691	1598	28	different	different	JJ
8691	1598	29	States	state	NNS
8691	1598	30	,	,	,
8691	1598	31	but	but	CC
8691	1598	32	in	in	IN
8691	1598	33	which	which	WDT
8691	1598	34	the	the	DT
8691	1598	35	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1598	36	had	have	VBD
8691	1598	37	either	either	CC
8691	1598	38	changed	change	VBN
8691	1598	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1598	40	residence	residence	NN
8691	1598	41	for	for	IN
8691	1598	42	the	the	DT
8691	1598	43	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1598	44	of	of	IN
8691	1598	45	giving	give	VBG
8691	1598	46	the	the	DT
8691	1598	47	court	court	NN
8691	1598	48	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1598	49	or	or	CC
8691	1598	50	was	be	VBD
8691	1598	51	really	really	RB
8691	1598	52	suing	sue	VBG
8691	1598	53	for	for	IN
8691	1598	54	the	the	DT
8691	1598	55	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	1598	56	of	of	IN
8691	1598	57	a	a	DT
8691	1598	58	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	1598	59	of	of	IN
8691	1598	60	the	the	DT
8691	1598	61	same	same	JJ
8691	1598	62	State	State	NNP
8691	1598	63	with	with	IN
8691	1598	64	the	the	DT
8691	1598	65	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	1598	66	.	.	.
8691	1599	1	This	this	DT
8691	1599	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1599	3	due	due	JJ
8691	1599	4	to	to	IN
8691	1599	5	the	the	DT
8691	1599	6	high	high	JJ
8691	1599	7	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1599	8	entertained	entertain	VBN
8691	1599	9	of	of	IN
8691	1599	10	the	the	DT
8691	1599	11	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1599	12	judiciary[Footnote	judiciary[footnote	NN
8691	1599	13	:	:	:
8691	1599	14	Niles	Niles	NNP
8691	1599	15	'	'	POS
8691	1599	16	Register	register	NN
8691	1599	17	,	,	,
8691	1599	18	XXIX	XXIX	NNP
8691	1599	19	,	,	,
8691	1599	20	14	14	CD
8691	1599	21	.	.	.
8691	1599	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1600	1	and	and	CC
8691	1600	2	the	the	DT
8691	1600	3	desire	desire	NN
8691	1600	4	to	to	TO
8691	1600	5	bring	bring	VB
8691	1600	6	the	the	DT
8691	1600	7	cause	cause	NN
8691	1600	8	before	before	IN
8691	1600	9	a	a	DT
8691	1600	10	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1600	11	,	,	,
8691	1600	12	rather	rather	RB
8691	1600	13	than	than	IN
8691	1600	14	a	a	DT
8691	1600	15	State	State	NNP
8691	1600	16	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	1600	17	.	.	.
8691	1601	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	1601	2	a	a	DT
8691	1601	3	mode	mode	NN
8691	1601	4	of	of	IN
8691	1601	5	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1601	6	,	,	,
8691	1601	7	while	while	IN
8691	1601	8	within	within	IN
8691	1601	9	the	the	DT
8691	1601	10	letter	letter	NN
8691	1601	11	of	of	IN
8691	1601	12	the	the	DT
8691	1601	13	governing	govern	VBG
8691	1601	14	statute	statute	NN
8691	1601	15	,	,	,
8691	1601	16	was	be	VBD
8691	1601	17	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	1601	18	to	to	IN
8691	1601	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1601	20	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	1601	21	,	,	,
8691	1601	22	and	and	CC
8691	1601	23	little	little	RB
8691	1601	24	better	well	JJR
8691	1601	25	than	than	IN
8691	1601	26	a	a	DT
8691	1601	27	fraud	fraud	NN
8691	1601	28	.	.	.
8691	1602	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1602	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1602	3	also	also	RB
8691	1602	4	an	an	DT
8691	1602	5	evident	evident	JJ
8691	1602	6	perversion	perversion	NN
8691	1602	7	of	of	IN
8691	1602	8	the	the	DT
8691	1602	9	intent	intent	NN
8691	1602	10	of	of	IN
8691	1602	11	the	the	DT
8691	1602	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1602	13	,	,	,
8691	1602	14	and	and	CC
8691	1602	15	became	become	VBD
8691	1602	16	at	at	IN
8691	1602	17	last	last	RB
8691	1602	18	so	so	RB
8691	1602	19	far	far	RB
8691	1602	20	-	-	HYPH
8691	1602	21	spreading	spread	VBG
8691	1602	22	that	that	IN
8691	1602	23	both	both	DT
8691	1602	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1602	25	and	and	CC
8691	1602	26	the	the	DT
8691	1602	27	courts	court	NNS
8691	1602	28	used	use	VBD
8691	1602	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1602	30	best	good	JJS
8691	1602	31	endeavors	endeavor	NNS
8691	1602	32	to	to	TO
8691	1602	33	put	put	VB
8691	1602	34	an	an	DT
8691	1602	35	end	end	NN
8691	1602	36	to	to	IN
8691	1602	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1602	38	,	,	,
8691	1602	39	and	and	CC
8691	1602	40	with	with	IN
8691	1602	41	success	success	NN
8691	1602	42	.	.	.
8691	1603	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1603	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1603	3	:	:	:
8691	1603	4	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1603	5	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1603	6	Statutes	Statutes	NNP
8691	1603	7	at	at	IN
8691	1603	8	Large	Large	NNP
8691	1603	9	,	,	,
8691	1603	10	XVIII	xviii	NN
8691	1603	11	,	,	,
8691	1603	12	470	470	CD
8691	1603	13	;	;	:
8691	1603	14	Hawes	Hawes	NNP
8691	1603	15	_	_	NNP
8691	1603	16	v.	v.	IN
8691	1603	17	_	_	NNP
8691	1603	18	Oakland	Oakland	NNP
8691	1603	19	,	,	,
8691	1603	20	104	104	CD
8691	1603	21	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1603	22	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1603	23	,	,	,
8691	1603	24	450	450	CD
8691	1603	25	,	,	,
8691	1603	26	459	459	CD
8691	1603	27	.	.	.
8691	1603	28	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1604	1	Another	another	DT
8691	1604	2	cause	cause	NN
8691	1604	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1604	4	also	also	RB
8691	1604	5	effective	effective	JJ
8691	1604	6	in	in	IN
8691	1604	7	lessening	lessen	VBG
8691	1604	8	the	the	DT
8691	1604	9	docket	docket	NN
8691	1604	10	of	of	IN
8691	1604	11	the	the	DT
8691	1604	12	District	District	NNP
8691	1604	13	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1604	14	.	.	.
8691	1605	1	The	the	DT
8691	1605	2	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	1605	3	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	1605	4	prefers	prefer	VBZ
8691	1605	5	to	to	TO
8691	1605	6	sue	sue	VB
8691	1605	7	in	in	IN
8691	1605	8	a	a	DT
8691	1605	9	State	State	NNP
8691	1605	10	court	court	NN
8691	1605	11	,	,	,
8691	1605	12	when	when	WRB
8691	1605	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1605	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	1605	15	the	the	DT
8691	1605	16	choice	choice	NN
8691	1605	17	,	,	,
8691	1605	18	on	on	IN
8691	1605	19	account	account	NN
8691	1605	20	of	of	IN
8691	1605	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1605	22	greater	great	JJR
8691	1605	23	familiarity	familiarity	NN
8691	1605	24	with	with	IN
8691	1605	25	the	the	DT
8691	1605	26	practice	practice	NN
8691	1605	27	there	there	RB
8691	1605	28	.	.	.
8691	1606	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	1606	2	American	american	JJ
8691	1606	3	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	1606	4	have	have	VBP
8691	1606	5	never	never	RB
8691	1606	6	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1606	7	an	an	DT
8691	1606	8	action	action	NN
8691	1606	9	in	in	IN
8691	1606	10	a	a	DT
8691	1606	11	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1606	12	court	court	NN
8691	1606	13	.	.	.
8691	1607	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	1607	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	1607	3	which	which	WDT
8691	1607	4	could	could	MD
8691	1607	5	be	be	VB
8691	1607	6	so	so	RB
8691	1607	7	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1607	8	can	can	MD
8691	1607	9	also	also	RB
8691	1607	10	be	be	VB
8691	1607	11	and	and	CC
8691	1607	12	are	be	VBP
8691	1607	13	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1607	14	in	in	RP
8691	1607	15	a	a	DT
8691	1607	16	State	State	NNP
8691	1607	17	court	court	NN
8691	1607	18	.	.	.
8691	1608	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1608	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	1608	3	thus	thus	RB
8691	1608	4	far	far	RB
8691	1608	5	maintained	maintain	VBN
8691	1608	6	for	for	IN
8691	1608	7	the	the	DT
8691	1608	8	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1608	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	1608	10	the	the	DT
8691	1608	11	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	1608	12	distinction	distinction	NN
8691	1608	13	between	between	IN
8691	1608	14	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	1608	15	in	in	IN
8691	1608	16	law	law	NN
8691	1608	17	and	and	CC
8691	1608	18	in	in	IN
8691	1608	19	equity	equity	NN
8691	1608	20	explained	explain	VBN
8691	1608	21	in	in	IN
8691	1608	22	the	the	DT
8691	1608	23	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	1608	24	chapter	chapter	NN
8691	1608	25	.	.	.
8691	1609	1	There	there	EX
8691	1609	2	are	be	VBP
8691	1609	3	those	those	DT
8691	1609	4	who	who	WP
8691	1609	5	claim	claim	VBP
8691	1609	6	that	that	IN
8691	1609	7	the	the	DT
8691	1609	8	reference	reference	NN
8691	1609	9	in	in	IN
8691	1609	10	Art	art	NN
8691	1609	11	.	.	.
8691	1610	1	III	III	NNP
8691	1610	2	,	,	,
8691	1610	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	1610	4	.	.	.
8691	1611	1	2	2	CD
8691	1611	2	,	,	,
8691	1611	3	of	of	IN
8691	1611	4	the	the	DT
8691	1611	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1611	6	of	of	IN
8691	1611	7	the	the	DT
8691	1611	8	United	United	NNP
8691	1611	9	States	States	NNP
8691	1611	10	to	to	TO
8691	1611	11	"	"	``
8691	1611	12	cases	case	NNS
8691	1611	13	in	in	IN
8691	1611	14	law	law	NN
8691	1611	15	and	and	CC
8691	1611	16	equity	equity	NN
8691	1611	17	"	"	''
8691	1611	18	requires	require	VBZ
8691	1611	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1611	20	preservation	preservation	NN
8691	1611	21	;	;	:
8691	1611	22	but	but	CC
8691	1611	23	this	this	DT
8691	1611	24	seems	seem	VBZ
8691	1611	25	a	a	DT
8691	1611	26	strained	strained	JJ
8691	1611	27	construction	construction	NN
8691	1611	28	of	of	IN
8691	1611	29	the	the	DT
8691	1611	30	phrase	phrase	NN
8691	1611	31	.	.	.
8691	1612	1	Separate	separate	JJ
8691	1612	2	dockets	docket	NNS
8691	1612	3	are	be	VBP
8691	1612	4	kept	keep	VBN
8691	1612	5	in	in	IN
8691	1612	6	the	the	DT
8691	1612	7	District	District	NNP
8691	1612	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1612	9	of	of	IN
8691	1612	10	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1612	11	and	and	CC
8691	1612	12	of	of	IN
8691	1612	13	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	1612	14	actions	action	NNS
8691	1612	15	.	.	.
8691	1613	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1613	2	are	be	VBP
8691	1613	3	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1613	4	in	in	RP
8691	1613	5	different	different	JJ
8691	1613	6	form	form	NN
8691	1613	7	,	,	,
8691	1613	8	tried	try	VBD
8691	1613	9	in	in	IN
8691	1613	10	a	a	DT
8691	1613	11	different	different	JJ
8691	1613	12	way	way	NN
8691	1613	13	,	,	,
8691	1613	14	and	and	CC
8691	1613	15	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	1613	16	of	of	IN
8691	1613	17	by	by	IN
8691	1613	18	different	different	JJ
8691	1613	19	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1613	20	,	,	,
8691	1613	21	though	though	IN
8691	1613	22	by	by	IN
8691	1613	23	the	the	DT
8691	1613	24	same	same	JJ
8691	1613	25	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1613	26	and	and	CC
8691	1613	27	at	at	IN
8691	1613	28	the	the	DT
8691	1613	29	same	same	JJ
8691	1613	30	term	term	NN
8691	1613	31	of	of	IN
8691	1613	32	court	court	NN
8691	1613	33	.	.	.
8691	1614	1	As	as	IN
8691	1614	2	to	to	IN
8691	1614	3	equity	equity	NN
8691	1614	4	cases	case	NNS
8691	1614	5	,	,	,
8691	1614	6	the	the	DT
8691	1614	7	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1614	8	of	of	IN
8691	1614	9	the	the	DT
8691	1614	10	old	old	JJ
8691	1614	11	English	english	JJ
8691	1614	12	chancery	chancery	NN
8691	1614	13	practice	practice	NN
8691	1614	14	are	be	VBP
8691	1614	15	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	1614	16	followed	follow	VBN
8691	1614	17	.	.	.
8691	1615	1	In	in	IN
8691	1615	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	1615	3	of	of	IN
8691	1615	4	a	a	DT
8691	1615	5	common	common	JJ
8691	1615	6	law	law	NN
8691	1615	7	nature	nature	NN
8691	1615	8	,	,	,
8691	1615	9	the	the	DT
8691	1615	10	practice	practice	NN
8691	1615	11	existing	exist	VBG
8691	1615	12	at	at	IN
8691	1615	13	the	the	DT
8691	1615	14	time	time	NN
8691	1615	15	in	in	IN
8691	1615	16	regard	regard	NN
8691	1615	17	to	to	IN
8691	1615	18	those	those	DT
8691	1615	19	of	of	IN
8691	1615	20	a	a	DT
8691	1615	21	similar	similar	JJ
8691	1615	22	kind	kind	NN
8691	1615	23	in	in	IN
8691	1615	24	the	the	DT
8691	1615	25	courts	court	NNS
8691	1615	26	of	of	IN
8691	1615	27	the	the	DT
8691	1615	28	State	State	NNP
8691	1615	29	within	within	IN
8691	1615	30	which	which	WDT
8691	1615	31	the	the	DT
8691	1615	32	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1615	33	court	court	NN
8691	1615	34	may	may	MD
8691	1615	35	be	be	VB
8691	1615	36	held	hold	VBN
8691	1615	37	is	be	VBZ
8691	1615	38	to	to	TO
8691	1615	39	be	be	VB
8691	1615	40	followed	follow	VBN
8691	1615	41	,	,	,
8691	1615	42	as	as	RB
8691	1615	43	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	1615	44	as	as	IN
8691	1615	45	may	may	MD
8691	1615	46	be	be	VB
8691	1615	47	.	.	.
8691	1616	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1616	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1616	3	:	:	:
8691	1616	4	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1616	5	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1616	6	Revised	Revised	NNP
8691	1616	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	1616	8	,	,	,
8691	1616	9	§	§	NNP
8691	1616	10	914	914	CD
8691	1616	11	.	.	.
8691	1616	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1617	1	In	in	IN
8691	1617	2	fact	fact	NN
8691	1617	3	,	,	,
8691	1617	4	there	there	EX
8691	1617	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	1617	6	a	a	DT
8691	1617	7	departure	departure	NN
8691	1617	8	from	from	IN
8691	1617	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1617	10	in	in	IN
8691	1617	11	many	many	JJ
8691	1617	12	points	point	NNS
8691	1617	13	in	in	IN
8691	1617	14	most	most	JJS
8691	1617	15	States,[Footnote	states,[footnote	NN
8691	1617	16	:	:	:
8691	1617	17	See	see	VB
8691	1617	18	Nudd	Nudd	NNP
8691	1617	19	_	_	NNP
8691	1617	20	v.	v.	IN
8691	1617	21	_	_	NNP
8691	1617	22	Burrows	Burrows	NNP
8691	1617	23	,	,	,
8691	1617	24	91	91	CD
8691	1617	25	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1617	26	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1617	27	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1617	28	,	,	,
8691	1617	29	426	426	CD
8691	1617	30	.	.	.
8691	1617	31	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1618	1	and	and	CC
8691	1618	2	in	in	IN
8691	1618	3	vital	vital	JJ
8691	1618	4	ones	one	NNS
8691	1618	5	in	in	IN
8691	1618	6	those	those	DT
8691	1618	7	which	which	WDT
8691	1618	8	have	have	VBP
8691	1618	9	reformed	reform	VBN
8691	1618	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1618	11	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	1618	12	in	in	IN
8691	1618	13	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1618	14	actions	action	NNS
8691	1618	15	by	by	IN
8691	1618	16	fusing	fuse	VBG
8691	1618	17	remedies	remedy	NNS
8691	1618	18	at	at	IN
8691	1618	19	law	law	NN
8691	1618	20	with	with	IN
8691	1618	21	those	those	DT
8691	1618	22	in	in	IN
8691	1618	23	equity	equity	NN
8691	1618	24	.	.	.
8691	1619	1	If	if	IN
8691	1619	2	an	an	DT
8691	1619	3	action	action	NN
8691	1619	4	framed	frame	VBN
8691	1619	5	in	in	IN
8691	1619	6	this	this	DT
8691	1619	7	method	method	NN
8691	1619	8	be	be	VB
8691	1619	9	removed	remove	VBN
8691	1619	10	from	from	IN
8691	1619	11	a	a	DT
8691	1619	12	State	State	NNP
8691	1619	13	court	court	NN
8691	1619	14	to	to	IN
8691	1619	15	a	a	DT
8691	1619	16	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1619	17	court	court	NN
8691	1619	18	,	,	,
8691	1619	19	the	the	DT
8691	1619	20	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1619	21	must	must	MD
8691	1619	22	thereupon	thereupon	RB
8691	1619	23	split	split	VB
8691	1619	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1619	25	in	in	IN
8691	1619	26	two	two	CD
8691	1619	27	,	,	,
8691	1619	28	and	and	CC
8691	1619	29	present	present	VB
8691	1619	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1619	31	case	case	NN
8691	1619	32	at	at	IN
8691	1619	33	law	law	NN
8691	1619	34	on	on	IN
8691	1619	35	one	one	CD
8691	1619	36	set	set	NN
8691	1619	37	of	of	IN
8691	1619	38	papers	paper	NNS
8691	1619	39	and	and	CC
8691	1619	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1619	41	case	case	NN
8691	1619	42	in	in	IN
8691	1619	43	equity	equity	NN
8691	1619	44	on	on	IN
8691	1619	45	another	another	DT
8691	1619	46	.	.	.
8691	1620	1	The	the	DT
8691	1620	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1620	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1620	4	,	,	,
8691	1620	5	under	under	IN
8691	1620	6	power	power	NN
8691	1620	7	derived	derive	VBN
8691	1620	8	from	from	IN
8691	1620	9	acts	act	NNS
8691	1620	10	of	of	IN
8691	1620	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1620	12	,	,	,
8691	1620	13	has	have	VBZ
8691	1620	14	framed	frame	VBN
8691	1620	15	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1620	16	of	of	IN
8691	1620	17	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	1620	18	for	for	IN
8691	1620	19	the	the	DT
8691	1620	20	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	1620	21	trial	trial	NN
8691	1620	22	courts	court	NNS
8691	1620	23	of	of	IN
8691	1620	24	the	the	DT
8691	1620	25	United	United	NNP
8691	1620	26	States	States	NNP
8691	1620	27	in	in	IN
8691	1620	28	equity	equity	NN
8691	1620	29	and	and	CC
8691	1620	30	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	1620	31	cases	case	NNS
8691	1620	32	,	,	,
8691	1620	33	and	and	CC
8691	1620	34	the	the	DT
8691	1620	35	latter	latter	JJ
8691	1620	36	courts	court	NNS
8691	1620	37	have	have	VBP
8691	1620	38	supplemented	supplement	VBN
8691	1620	39	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1620	40	by	by	IN
8691	1620	41	further	further	JJ
8691	1620	42	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1620	43	of	of	IN
8691	1620	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1620	45	own	own	JJ
8691	1620	46	making	making	NN
8691	1620	47	.	.	.
8691	1621	1	The	the	DT
8691	1621	2	Equity	equity	NN
8691	1621	3	Rules	rule	NNS
8691	1621	4	promulgated	promulgate	VBN
8691	1621	5	by	by	IN
8691	1621	6	the	the	DT
8691	1621	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1621	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1621	9	were	be	VBD
8691	1621	10	revised	revise	VBN
8691	1621	11	in	in	IN
8691	1621	12	1912	1912	CD
8691	1621	13	,	,	,
8691	1621	14	and	and	CC
8691	1621	15	took	take	VBD
8691	1621	16	effect	effect	NN
8691	1621	17	as	as	IN
8691	1621	18	changed	change	VBN
8691	1621	19	in	in	IN
8691	1621	20	1913	1913	CD
8691	1621	21	.	.	.
8691	1622	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1622	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1622	3	:	:	:
8691	1622	4	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1622	5	are	be	VBP
8691	1622	6	printed	print	VBN
8691	1622	7	in	in	IN
8691	1622	8	Volume	Volume	NNP
8691	1622	9	226	226	CD
8691	1622	10	of	of	IN
8691	1622	11	the	the	DT
8691	1622	12	United	United	NNP
8691	1622	13	States	States	NNP
8691	1622	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1622	15	.	.	.
8691	1622	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1623	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1623	2	greatly	greatly	RB
8691	1623	3	simplify	simplify	VBP
8691	1623	4	the	the	DT
8691	1623	5	former	former	JJ
8691	1623	6	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	1623	7	.	.	.
8691	1624	1	Suits	suit	NNS
8691	1624	2	are	be	VBP
8691	1624	3	now	now	RB
8691	1624	4	tried	try	VBN
8691	1624	5	generally	generally	RB
8691	1624	6	on	on	IN
8691	1624	7	oral	oral	JJ
8691	1624	8	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	1624	9	taken	take	VBN
8691	1624	10	stenographically	stenographically	RB
8691	1624	11	in	in	IN
8691	1624	12	open	open	JJ
8691	1624	13	court	court	NN
8691	1624	14	.	.	.
8691	1625	1	Formerly	formerly	RB
8691	1625	2	the	the	DT
8691	1625	3	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	1625	4	was	be	VBD
8691	1625	5	usually	usually	RB
8691	1625	6	given	give	VBN
8691	1625	7	before	before	IN
8691	1625	8	officials	official	NNS
8691	1625	9	known	know	VBN
8691	1625	10	as	as	IN
8691	1625	11	examiners	examiner	NNS
8691	1625	12	or	or	CC
8691	1625	13	masters	master	NNS
8691	1625	14	in	in	IN
8691	1625	15	chancery	chancery	NN
8691	1625	16	.	.	.
8691	1626	1	The	the	DT
8691	1626	2	former	former	JJ
8691	1626	3	reported	report	VBD
8691	1626	4	the	the	DT
8691	1626	5	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	1626	6	at	at	IN
8691	1626	7	length	length	NN
8691	1626	8	to	to	IN
8691	1626	9	the	the	DT
8691	1626	10	trial	trial	NN
8691	1626	11	court	court	NN
8691	1626	12	.	.	.
8691	1627	1	The	the	DT
8691	1627	2	latter	latter	JJ
8691	1627	3	reported	report	VBD
8691	1627	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1627	5	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	1627	6	from	from	IN
8691	1627	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1627	8	.	.	.
8691	1628	1	The	the	DT
8691	1628	2	new	new	JJ
8691	1628	3	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1628	4	have	have	VBP
8691	1628	5	abolished	abolish	VBN
8691	1628	6	demurrers	demurrer	NNS
8691	1628	7	in	in	IN
8691	1628	8	equity	equity	NN
8691	1628	9	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1628	10	in	in	IN
8691	1628	11	favor	favor	NN
8691	1628	12	of	of	IN
8691	1628	13	what	what	WP
8691	1628	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	1628	15	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	1628	16	the	the	DT
8691	1628	17	present	present	JJ
8691	1628	18	English	english	JJ
8691	1628	19	practice	practice	NN
8691	1628	20	.	.	.
8691	1629	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1629	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1629	3	:	:	:
8691	1629	4	See	see	VB
8691	1629	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1629	6	infra	infra	NN
8691	1629	7	,	,	,
8691	1629	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1629	9	page	page	NN
8691	1629	10	203	203	CD
8691	1629	11	.	.	.
8691	1629	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1630	1	In	in	IN
8691	1630	2	common	common	JJ
8691	1630	3	law	law	NN
8691	1630	4	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1630	5	in	in	IN
8691	1630	6	the	the	DT
8691	1630	7	District	District	NNP
8691	1630	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1630	9	,	,	,
8691	1630	10	the	the	DT
8691	1630	11	State	state	NN
8691	1630	12	remedies	remedy	VBZ
8691	1630	13	by	by	IN
8691	1630	14	way	way	NN
8691	1630	15	of	of	IN
8691	1630	16	attaching	attach	VBG
8691	1630	17	the	the	DT
8691	1630	18	property	property	NN
8691	1630	19	of	of	IN
8691	1630	20	a	a	DT
8691	1630	21	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	1630	22	to	to	TO
8691	1630	23	respond	respond	VB
8691	1630	24	to	to	IN
8691	1630	25	a	a	DT
8691	1630	26	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1630	27	,	,	,
8691	1630	28	or	or	CC
8691	1630	29	seizing	seize	VBG
8691	1630	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1630	31	on	on	IN
8691	1630	32	execution	execution	NN
8691	1630	33	,	,	,
8691	1630	34	or	or	CC
8691	1630	35	imposing	impose	VBG
8691	1630	36	a	a	DT
8691	1630	37	lien	lien	NN
8691	1630	38	upon	upon	IN
8691	1630	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1630	40	by	by	IN
8691	1630	41	a	a	DT
8691	1630	42	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1630	43	,	,	,
8691	1630	44	are	be	VBP
8691	1630	45	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1630	46	and	and	CC
8691	1630	47	enforced	enforce	VBN
8691	1630	48	.	.	.
8691	1631	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1631	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1631	3	:	:	:
8691	1631	4	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1631	5	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1631	6	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
8691	1632	1	Stat	Stat	NNP
8691	1632	2	.	.	.
8691	1632	3	,	,	,
8691	1632	4	§§	§§	NNP
8691	1632	5	915	915	CD
8691	1632	6	,	,	,
8691	1632	7	916	916	CD
8691	1632	8	,	,	,
8691	1632	9	967	967	CD
8691	1632	10	,	,	,
8691	1632	11	988	988	CD
8691	1632	12	.	.	.
8691	1632	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1633	1	The	the	DT
8691	1633	2	field	field	NN
8691	1633	3	of	of	IN
8691	1633	4	national	national	JJ
8691	1633	5	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	1633	6	being	be	VBG
8691	1633	7	narrow	narrow	JJ
8691	1633	8	,	,	,
8691	1633	9	the	the	DT
8691	1633	10	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	1633	11	against	against	IN
8691	1633	12	the	the	DT
8691	1633	13	nation	nation	NN
8691	1633	14	are	be	VBP
8691	1633	15	correspondingly	correspondingly	RB
8691	1633	16	few	few	JJ
8691	1633	17	.	.	.
8691	1634	1	Any	any	DT
8691	1634	2	acts	act	NNS
8691	1634	3	done	do	VBN
8691	1634	4	on	on	IN
8691	1634	5	lands	land	NNS
8691	1634	6	ceded	cede	VBN
8691	1634	7	by	by	IN
8691	1634	8	a	a	DT
8691	1634	9	State	State	NNP
8691	1634	10	,	,	,
8691	1634	11	which	which	WDT
8691	1634	12	would	would	MD
8691	1634	13	have	have	VB
8691	1634	14	been	be	VBN
8691	1634	15	crimes	crime	NNS
8691	1634	16	under	under	IN
8691	1634	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1634	18	law	law	NN
8691	1634	19	in	in	IN
8691	1634	20	1873	1873	CD
8691	1634	21	,	,	,
8691	1634	22	may	may	MD
8691	1634	23	be	be	VB
8691	1634	24	punished	punish	VBN
8691	1634	25	as	as	IN
8691	1634	26	such	such	JJ
8691	1634	27	in	in	IN
8691	1634	28	the	the	DT
8691	1634	29	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1634	30	courts	court	NNS
8691	1634	31	in	in	IN
8691	1634	32	the	the	DT
8691	1634	33	same	same	JJ
8691	1634	34	manner	manner	NN
8691	1634	35	which	which	WDT
8691	1634	36	that	that	DT
8691	1634	37	law	law	NN
8691	1634	38	provided	provide	VBD
8691	1634	39	.	.	.
8691	1635	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1635	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1635	3	:	:	:
8691	1635	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1635	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
8691	1635	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1635	7	.	.	NNP
8691	1635	8	,	,	,
8691	1635	9	§	§	NNP
8691	1635	10	5391	5391	CD
8691	1635	11	.	.	.
8691	1635	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1636	1	In	in	IN
8691	1636	2	the	the	DT
8691	1636	3	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1636	4	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1636	5	,	,	,
8691	1636	6	before	before	IN
8691	1636	7	1866	1866	CD
8691	1636	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1636	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1636	10	customary	customary	JJ
8691	1636	11	to	to	TO
8691	1636	12	defer	defer	VB
8691	1636	13	the	the	DT
8691	1636	14	trial	trial	NN
8691	1636	15	of	of	IN
8691	1636	16	important	important	JJ
8691	1636	17	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1636	18	until	until	IN
8691	1636	19	the	the	DT
8691	1636	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1636	21	of	of	IN
8691	1636	22	the	the	DT
8691	1636	23	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1636	24	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1636	25	assigned	assign	VBD
8691	1636	26	to	to	IN
8691	1636	27	the	the	DT
8691	1636	28	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1636	29	could	could	MD
8691	1636	30	be	be	VB
8691	1636	31	present	present	JJ
8691	1636	32	.	.	.
8691	1637	1	If	if	IN
8691	1637	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1637	3	differed	differ	VBD
8691	1637	4	on	on	IN
8691	1637	5	any	any	DT
8691	1637	6	material	material	JJ
8691	1637	7	point	point	NN
8691	1637	8	from	from	IN
8691	1637	9	the	the	DT
8691	1637	10	District	District	NNP
8691	1637	11	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	1637	12	,	,	,
8691	1637	13	this	this	DT
8691	1637	14	point	point	NN
8691	1637	15	could	could	MD
8691	1637	16	be	be	VB
8691	1637	17	certified	certify	VBN
8691	1637	18	up	up	RP
8691	1637	19	to	to	IN
8691	1637	20	the	the	DT
8691	1637	21	full	full	JJ
8691	1637	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1637	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1637	24	for	for	IN
8691	1637	25	argument	argument	NN
8691	1637	26	and	and	CC
8691	1637	27	decision	decision	NN
8691	1637	28	there	there	RB
8691	1637	29	.	.	.
8691	1638	1	During	during	IN
8691	1638	2	this	this	DT
8691	1638	3	period	period	NN
8691	1638	4	the	the	DT
8691	1638	5	published	publish	VBN
8691	1638	6	reports	report	NNS
8691	1638	7	of	of	IN
8691	1638	8	the	the	DT
8691	1638	9	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	1638	10	of	of	IN
8691	1638	11	the	the	DT
8691	1638	12	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1638	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1638	14	contain	contain	VBP
8691	1638	15	many	many	JJ
8691	1638	16	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	1638	17	of	of	IN
8691	1638	18	the	the	DT
8691	1638	19	highest	high	JJS
8691	1638	20	value	value	NN
8691	1638	21	.	.	.
8691	1639	1	Several	several	JJ
8691	1639	2	of	of	IN
8691	1639	3	the	the	DT
8691	1639	4	best	good	JJS
8691	1639	5	which	which	WDT
8691	1639	6	Story	Story	NNP
8691	1639	7	and	and	CC
8691	1639	8	Bushrod	Bushrod	NNP
8691	1639	9	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	1639	10	wrote	write	VBD
8691	1639	11	are	be	VBP
8691	1639	12	to	to	TO
8691	1639	13	be	be	VB
8691	1639	14	found	find	VBN
8691	1639	15	among	among	IN
8691	1639	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1639	17	.	.	.
8691	1640	1	The	the	DT
8691	1640	2	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1640	3	of	of	IN
8691	1640	4	1866	1866	CD
8691	1640	5	,	,	,
8691	1640	6	by	by	IN
8691	1640	7	which	which	WDT
8691	1640	8	a	a	DT
8691	1640	9	resident	resident	JJ
8691	1640	10	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1640	11	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	1640	12	was	be	VBD
8691	1640	13	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	1640	14	for	for	IN
8691	1640	15	each	each	DT
8691	1640	16	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1640	17	,	,	,
8691	1640	18	provided	provide	VBN
8691	1640	19	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
8691	1640	20	that	that	IN
8691	1640	21	each	each	DT
8691	1640	22	member	member	NN
8691	1640	23	of	of	IN
8691	1640	24	the	the	DT
8691	1640	25	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1640	26	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1640	27	should	should	MD
8691	1640	28	attend	attend	VB
8691	1640	29	at	at	RB
8691	1640	30	least	least	RBS
8691	1640	31	one	one	CD
8691	1640	32	term	term	NN
8691	1640	33	of	of	IN
8691	1640	34	the	the	DT
8691	1640	35	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1640	36	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1640	37	in	in	IN
8691	1640	38	each	each	DT
8691	1640	39	district	district	NN
8691	1640	40	as	as	RB
8691	1640	41	often	often	RB
8691	1640	42	as	as	IN
8691	1640	43	once	once	RB
8691	1640	44	in	in	IN
8691	1640	45	two	two	CD
8691	1640	46	years	year	NNS
8691	1640	47	.	.	.
8691	1641	1	The	the	DT
8691	1641	2	press	press	NN
8691	1641	3	of	of	IN
8691	1641	4	business	business	NN
8691	1641	5	at	at	IN
8691	1641	6	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	1641	7	,	,	,
8691	1641	8	however	however	RB
8691	1641	9	,	,	,
8691	1641	10	soon	soon	RB
8691	1641	11	became	become	VBD
8691	1641	12	such	such	JJ
8691	1641	13	as	as	IN
8691	1641	14	to	to	TO
8691	1641	15	make	make	VB
8691	1641	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1641	17	practically	practically	RB
8691	1641	18	impossible	impossible	JJ
8691	1641	19	for	for	IN
8691	1641	20	the	the	DT
8691	1641	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1641	22	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1641	23	Justices	Justices	NNPS
8691	1641	24	to	to	TO
8691	1641	25	do	do	VB
8691	1641	26	any	any	DT
8691	1641	27	substantial	substantial	JJ
8691	1641	28	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1641	29	work	work	NN
8691	1641	30	.	.	.
8691	1642	1	When	when	WRB
8691	1642	2	some	some	DT
8691	1642	3	case	case	NN
8691	1642	4	of	of	IN
8691	1642	5	national	national	JJ
8691	1642	6	importance	importance	NN
8691	1642	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1642	8	to	to	TO
8691	1642	9	be	be	VB
8691	1642	10	heard	hear	VBN
8691	1642	11	in	in	IN
8691	1642	12	any	any	DT
8691	1642	13	district	district	NN
8691	1642	14	,	,	,
8691	1642	15	the	the	DT
8691	1642	16	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1642	17	in	in	IN
8691	1642	18	whose	whose	WP$
8691	1642	19	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1642	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1642	21	was	be	VBD
8691	1642	22	included	include	VBN
8691	1642	23	would	would	MD
8691	1642	24	make	make	VB
8691	1642	25	a	a	DT
8691	1642	26	special	special	JJ
8691	1642	27	effort	effort	NN
8691	1642	28	to	to	TO
8691	1642	29	go	go	VB
8691	1642	30	down	down	RP
8691	1642	31	.	.	.
8691	1643	1	In	in	IN
8691	1643	2	this	this	DT
8691	1643	3	way	way	NN
8691	1643	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1643	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1643	6	Chase	Chase	NNP
8691	1643	7	heard	hear	VBD
8691	1643	8	and	and	CC
8691	1643	9	sustained	sustain	VBD
8691	1643	10	the	the	DT
8691	1643	11	plea	plea	NN
8691	1643	12	with	with	IN
8691	1643	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1643	14	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	1643	15	Davis	Davis	NNP
8691	1643	16	met	meet	VBD
8691	1643	17	the	the	DT
8691	1643	18	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	1643	19	against	against	IN
8691	1643	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1643	21	for	for	IN
8691	1643	22	treason	treason	NN
8691	1643	23	.	.	.
8691	1644	1	But	but	CC
8691	1644	2	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	1644	3	the	the	DT
8691	1644	4	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1644	5	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	1644	6	took	take	VBD
8691	1644	7	the	the	DT
8691	1644	8	place	place	NN
8691	1644	9	of	of	IN
8691	1644	10	the	the	DT
8691	1644	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1644	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1644	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1644	14	,	,	,
8691	1644	15	and	and	CC
8691	1644	16	the	the	DT
8691	1644	17	latter	latter	JJ
8691	1644	18	,	,	,
8691	1644	19	if	if	IN
8691	1644	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1644	21	appeared	appear	VBD
8691	1644	22	at	at	RB
8691	1644	23	all	all	RB
8691	1644	24	during	during	IN
8691	1644	25	the	the	DT
8691	1644	26	term	term	NN
8691	1644	27	,	,	,
8691	1644	28	remained	remain	VBD
8691	1644	29	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	1644	30	for	for	IN
8691	1644	31	a	a	DT
8691	1644	32	day	day	NN
8691	1644	33	.	.	.
8691	1645	1	The	the	DT
8691	1645	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1645	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1645	4	,	,	,
8691	1645	5	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1645	6	,	,	,
8691	1645	7	during	during	IN
8691	1645	8	over	over	IN
8691	1645	9	a	a	DT
8691	1645	10	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	1645	11	years	year	NNS
8691	1645	12	remained	remain	VBD
8691	1645	13	the	the	DT
8691	1645	14	only	only	JJ
8691	1645	15	court	court	NN
8691	1645	16	of	of	IN
8691	1645	17	the	the	DT
8691	1645	18	United	United	NNP
8691	1645	19	States	States	NNP
8691	1645	20	existing	exist	VBG
8691	1645	21	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	1645	22	for	for	IN
8691	1645	23	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	1645	24	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	1645	25	.	.	.
8691	1646	1	The	the	DT
8691	1646	2	work	work	NN
8691	1646	3	which	which	WDT
8691	1646	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1646	5	had	have	VBD
8691	1646	6	before	before	IN
8691	1646	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1646	8	at	at	IN
8691	1646	9	the	the	DT
8691	1646	10	last	last	JJ
8691	1646	11	term	term	NN
8691	1646	12	during	during	IN
8691	1646	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1646	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1646	15	occupied	occupy	VBD
8691	1646	16	this	this	DT
8691	1646	17	position	position	NN
8691	1646	18	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1646	19	October	October	NNP
8691	1646	20	Term	Term	NNP
8691	1646	21	,	,	,
8691	1646	22	1890	1890	CD
8691	1646	23	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1646	24	will	will	MD
8691	1646	25	show	show	VB
8691	1646	26	how	how	WRB
8691	1646	27	much	much	JJ
8691	1646	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1646	29	was	be	VBD
8691	1646	30	then	then	RB
8691	1646	31	overburdened	overburden	VBN
8691	1646	32	.	.	.
8691	1647	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1647	2	docket	docket	NN
8691	1647	3	contained	contain	VBD
8691	1647	4	1,177	1,177	CD
8691	1647	5	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	1647	6	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1647	7	forward	forward	RP
8691	1647	8	by	by	IN
8691	1647	9	continuance	continuance	NN
8691	1647	10	because	because	IN
8691	1647	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1647	12	could	could	MD
8691	1647	13	not	not	RB
8691	1647	14	be	be	VB
8691	1647	15	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	1647	16	of	of	IN
8691	1647	17	at	at	IN
8691	1647	18	the	the	DT
8691	1647	19	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	1647	20	term	term	NN
8691	1647	21	,	,	,
8691	1647	22	623	623	CD
8691	1647	23	new	new	JJ
8691	1647	24	cases	case	NNS
8691	1647	25	of	of	IN
8691	1647	26	the	the	DT
8691	1647	27	same	same	JJ
8691	1647	28	kind	kind	NN
8691	1647	29	,	,	,
8691	1647	30	and	and	CC
8691	1647	31	16	16	CD
8691	1647	32	cases	case	NNS
8691	1647	33	of	of	IN
8691	1647	34	original	original	JJ
8691	1647	35	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1647	36	,	,	,
8691	1647	37	making	make	VBG
8691	1647	38	a	a	DT
8691	1647	39	total	total	NN
8691	1647	40	of	of	IN
8691	1647	41	1,816	1,816	CD
8691	1647	42	actions	action	NNS
8691	1647	43	.	.	.
8691	1648	1	Of	of	IN
8691	1648	2	these	these	DT
8691	1648	3	,	,	,
8691	1648	4	although	although	IN
8691	1648	5	the	the	DT
8691	1648	6	term	term	NN
8691	1648	7	lasted	last	VBD
8691	1648	8	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	1648	9	eight	eight	CD
8691	1648	10	months	month	NNS
8691	1648	11	,	,	,
8691	1648	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1648	13	was	be	VBD
8691	1648	14	only	only	RB
8691	1648	15	able	able	JJ
8691	1648	16	to	to	TO
8691	1648	17	dispose	dispose	VB
8691	1648	18	of	of	IN
8691	1648	19	617	617	CD
8691	1648	20	,	,	,
8691	1648	21	thus	thus	RB
8691	1648	22	leaving	leave	VBG
8691	1648	23	1,199	1,199	CD
8691	1648	24	for	for	IN
8691	1648	25	continuance	continuance	NN
8691	1648	26	to	to	IN
8691	1648	27	the	the	DT
8691	1648	28	following	following	JJ
8691	1648	29	term	term	NN
8691	1648	30	.	.	.
8691	1649	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1649	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1649	3	:	:	:
8691	1649	4	140	140	CD
8691	1649	5	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1649	6	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1649	7	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1649	8	,	,	,
8691	1649	9	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
8691	1649	10	.	.	.
8691	1649	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1650	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1650	2	will	will	MD
8691	1650	3	be	be	VB
8691	1650	4	observed	observe	VBN
8691	1650	5	that	that	IN
8691	1650	6	the	the	DT
8691	1650	7	court	court	NN
8691	1650	8	was	be	VBD
8691	1650	9	no	no	RB
8691	1650	10	longer	long	RBR
8691	1650	11	able	able	JJ
8691	1650	12	to	to	TO
8691	1650	13	cope	cope	VB
8691	1650	14	with	with	IN
8691	1650	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1650	16	new	new	JJ
8691	1650	17	business	business	NN
8691	1650	18	,	,	,
8691	1650	19	not	not	RB
8691	1650	20	to	to	TO
8691	1650	21	mention	mention	VB
8691	1650	22	that	that	DT
8691	1650	23	left	leave	VBD
8691	1650	24	over	over	RP
8691	1650	25	from	from	IN
8691	1650	26	previous	previous	JJ
8691	1650	27	years	year	NNS
8691	1650	28	.	.	.
8691	1651	1	Appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	1651	2	now	now	RB
8691	1651	3	lie	lie	VBP
8691	1651	4	in	in	IN
8691	1651	5	most	most	JJS
8691	1651	6	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1651	7	cases	case	NNS
8691	1651	8	from	from	IN
8691	1651	9	the	the	DT
8691	1651	10	final	final	JJ
8691	1651	11	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1651	12	of	of	IN
8691	1651	13	the	the	DT
8691	1651	14	District	District	NNP
8691	1651	15	and	and	CC
8691	1651	16	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1651	17	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1651	18	,	,	,
8691	1651	19	and	and	CC
8691	1651	20	from	from	IN
8691	1651	21	convictions	conviction	NNS
8691	1651	22	for	for	IN
8691	1651	23	infamous	infamous	JJ
8691	1651	24	crimes	crime	NNS
8691	1651	25	,	,	,
8691	1651	26	not	not	RB
8691	1651	27	capital	capital	NN
8691	1651	28	,	,	,
8691	1651	29	to	to	IN
8691	1651	30	the	the	DT
8691	1651	31	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1651	32	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1651	33	of	of	IN
8691	1651	34	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1651	35	.	.	.
8691	1652	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1652	2	also	also	RB
8691	1652	3	extend	extend	VBP
8691	1652	4	to	to	IN
8691	1652	5	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1652	6	granting	grant	VBG
8691	1652	7	a	a	DT
8691	1652	8	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	1652	9	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	1652	10	.	.	.
8691	1653	1	There	there	EX
8691	1653	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1653	3	a	a	DT
8691	1653	4	court	court	NN
8691	1653	5	of	of	IN
8691	1653	6	this	this	DT
8691	1653	7	name	name	NN
8691	1653	8	for	for	IN
8691	1653	9	each	each	DT
8691	1653	10	of	of	IN
8691	1653	11	the	the	DT
8691	1653	12	nine	nine	CD
8691	1653	13	circuits	circuit	NNS
8691	1653	14	,	,	,
8691	1653	15	which	which	WDT
8691	1653	16	was	be	VBD
8691	1653	17	established	establish	VBN
8691	1653	18	in	in	IN
8691	1653	19	1891	1891	CD
8691	1653	20	for	for	IN
8691	1653	21	the	the	DT
8691	1653	22	further	further	JJ
8691	1653	23	relief	relief	NN
8691	1653	24	of	of	IN
8691	1653	25	the	the	DT
8691	1653	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1653	27	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1653	28	and	and	CC
8691	1653	29	the	the	DT
8691	1653	30	speedier	speedy	JJR
8691	1653	31	termination	termination	NN
8691	1653	32	of	of	IN
8691	1653	33	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	1653	34	.	.	.
8691	1654	1	This	this	DT
8691	1654	2	measure	measure	NN
8691	1654	3	originated	originate	VBD
8691	1654	4	in	in	IN
8691	1654	5	the	the	DT
8691	1654	6	American	American	NNP
8691	1654	7	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	1654	8	Association	Association	NNP
8691	1654	9	,	,	,
8691	1654	10	by	by	IN
8691	1654	11	which	which	WDT
8691	1654	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1654	13	was	be	VBD
8691	1654	14	pressed	press	VBN
8691	1654	15	upon	upon	IN
8691	1654	16	the	the	DT
8691	1654	17	attention	attention	NN
8691	1654	18	of	of	IN
8691	1654	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1654	20	.	.	.
8691	1655	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1655	2	had	have	VBD
8691	1655	3	become	become	VBN
8691	1655	4	an	an	DT
8691	1655	5	absolute	absolute	JJ
8691	1655	6	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	1655	7	to	to	TO
8691	1655	8	devise	devise	VB
8691	1655	9	some	some	DT
8691	1655	10	plan	plan	NN
8691	1655	11	of	of	IN
8691	1655	12	expediting	expedite	VBG
8691	1655	13	the	the	DT
8691	1655	14	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	1655	15	of	of	IN
8691	1655	16	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	1655	17	from	from	IN
8691	1655	18	the	the	DT
8691	1655	19	trial	trial	NN
8691	1655	20	courts	court	NNS
8691	1655	21	of	of	IN
8691	1655	22	the	the	DT
8691	1655	23	United	United	NNP
8691	1655	24	States	States	NNP
8691	1655	25	.	.	.
8691	1656	1	There	there	EX
8691	1656	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1656	3	more	more	JJR
8691	1656	4	than	than	IN
8691	1656	5	enough	enough	JJ
8691	1656	6	of	of	IN
8691	1656	7	such	such	JJ
8691	1656	8	business	business	NN
8691	1656	9	by	by	IN
8691	1656	10	the	the	DT
8691	1656	11	close	close	NN
8691	1656	12	of	of	IN
8691	1656	13	the	the	DT
8691	1656	14	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	1656	15	War	War	NNP
8691	1656	16	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1656	17	the	the	DT
8691	1656	18	events	event	NNS
8691	1656	19	attending	attend	VBG
8691	1656	20	which	which	WDT
8691	1656	21	brought	bring	VBD
8691	1656	22	up	up	RP
8691	1656	23	for	for	IN
8691	1656	24	decision	decision	NN
8691	1656	25	many	many	JJ
8691	1656	26	novel	novel	JJ
8691	1656	27	questions	question	NNS
8691	1656	28	of	of	IN
8691	1656	29	the	the	DT
8691	1656	30	highest	high	JJS
8691	1656	31	importance	importance	NN
8691	1656	32	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1656	33	to	to	TO
8691	1656	34	require	require	VB
8691	1656	35	the	the	DT
8691	1656	36	entire	entire	JJ
8691	1656	37	attention	attention	NN
8691	1656	38	of	of	IN
8691	1656	39	the	the	DT
8691	1656	40	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1656	41	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1656	42	.	.	.
8691	1657	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1657	2	soon	soon	RB
8691	1657	3	took	take	VBD
8691	1657	4	three	three	CD
8691	1657	5	years	year	NNS
8691	1657	6	after	after	IN
8691	1657	7	an	an	DT
8691	1657	8	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1657	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1657	10	docketed	docket	VBN
8691	1657	11	before	before	IN
8691	1657	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1657	13	could	could	MD
8691	1657	14	be	be	VB
8691	1657	15	reached	reach	VBN
8691	1657	16	for	for	IN
8691	1657	17	argument	argument	NN
8691	1657	18	.	.	.
8691	1658	1	This	this	DT
8691	1658	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1658	3	intolerable	intolerable	JJ
8691	1658	4	,	,	,
8691	1658	5	and	and	CC
8691	1658	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1658	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1658	8	obviously	obviously	RB
8691	1658	9	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1658	10	either	either	RB
8691	1658	11	to	to	TO
8691	1658	12	restrict	restrict	VB
8691	1658	13	the	the	DT
8691	1658	14	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	1658	15	of	of	IN
8691	1658	16	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1658	17	;	;	:
8691	1658	18	to	to	TO
8691	1658	19	constitute	constitute	VB
8691	1658	20	divisions	division	NNS
8691	1658	21	of	of	IN
8691	1658	22	the	the	DT
8691	1658	23	court	court	NN
8691	1658	24	,	,	,
8691	1658	25	one	one	CD
8691	1658	26	to	to	TO
8691	1658	27	hear	hear	VB
8691	1658	28	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	1658	29	of	of	IN
8691	1658	30	a	a	DT
8691	1658	31	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1658	32	class	class	NN
8691	1658	33	and	and	CC
8691	1658	34	another	another	DT
8691	1658	35	those	those	DT
8691	1658	36	of	of	IN
8691	1658	37	another	another	DT
8691	1658	38	class	class	NN
8691	1658	39	;	;	:
8691	1658	40	or	or	CC
8691	1658	41	to	to	TO
8691	1658	42	set	set	VB
8691	1658	43	up	up	RP
8691	1658	44	an	an	DT
8691	1658	45	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
8691	1658	46	court	court	NN
8691	1658	47	.	.	.
8691	1659	1	The	the	DT
8691	1659	2	last	last	JJ
8691	1659	3	method	method	NN
8691	1659	4	was	be	VBD
8691	1659	5	preferred	prefer	VBN
8691	1659	6	.	.	.
8691	1660	1	The	the	DT
8691	1660	2	practice	practice	NN
8691	1660	3	in	in	IN
8691	1660	4	the	the	DT
8691	1660	5	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1660	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1660	7	of	of	IN
8691	1660	8	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1660	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1660	10	governed	govern	VBN
8691	1660	11	by	by	IN
8691	1660	12	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1660	13	of	of	IN
8691	1660	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1660	15	own	own	JJ
8691	1660	16	making	making	NN
8691	1660	17	,	,	,
8691	1660	18	but	but	CC
8691	1660	19	in	in	IN
8691	1660	20	general	general	JJ
8691	1660	21	conforms	conform	VBZ
8691	1660	22	to	to	IN
8691	1660	23	that	that	DT
8691	1660	24	of	of	IN
8691	1660	25	the	the	DT
8691	1660	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1660	27	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1660	28	of	of	IN
8691	1660	29	the	the	DT
8691	1660	30	United	United	NNP
8691	1660	31	States	States	NNP
8691	1660	32	in	in	IN
8691	1660	33	appealed	appeal	VBD
8691	1660	34	cases	case	NNS
8691	1660	35	.	.	.
8691	1661	1	The	the	DT
8691	1661	2	commission	commission	NN
8691	1661	3	appointed	appoint	VBD
8691	1661	4	some	some	DT
8691	1661	5	years	year	NNS
8691	1661	6	since	since	IN
8691	1661	7	to	to	TO
8691	1661	8	prepare	prepare	VB
8691	1661	9	a	a	DT
8691	1661	10	revision	revision	NN
8691	1661	11	of	of	IN
8691	1661	12	the	the	DT
8691	1661	13	laws	law	NNS
8691	1661	14	of	of	IN
8691	1661	15	the	the	DT
8691	1661	16	United	United	NNP
8691	1661	17	States	States	NNP
8691	1661	18	have	have	VBP
8691	1661	19	reported	report	VBN
8691	1661	20	in	in	IN
8691	1661	21	favor	favor	NN
8691	1661	22	of	of	IN
8691	1661	23	abolishing	abolish	VBG
8691	1661	24	all	all	DT
8691	1661	25	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1661	26	of	of	IN
8691	1661	27	the	the	DT
8691	1661	28	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1661	29	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1661	30	over	over	IN
8691	1661	31	original	original	JJ
8691	1661	32	cases	case	NNS
8691	1661	33	and	and	CC
8691	1661	34	turning	turn	VBG
8691	1661	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1661	36	into	into	IN
8691	1661	37	an	an	DT
8691	1661	38	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	1661	39	court	court	NN
8691	1661	40	.	.	.
8691	1662	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1662	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1662	3	:	:	:
8691	1662	4	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	1662	5	Doc	Doc	NNP
8691	1662	6	.	.	.
8691	1663	1	68	68	CD
8691	1663	2	,	,	,
8691	1663	3	57th	57th	JJ
8691	1663	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1663	5	,	,	,
8691	1663	6	1st	1st	NN
8691	1663	7	Session	Session	NNP
8691	1663	8	.	.	.
8691	1663	9	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1664	1	Should	Should	MD
8691	1664	2	this	this	DT
8691	1664	3	recommendation	recommendation	NN
8691	1664	4	be	be	VB
8691	1664	5	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1664	6	,	,	,
8691	1664	7	the	the	DT
8691	1664	8	District	District	NNP
8691	1664	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1664	10	would	would	MD
8691	1664	11	acquire	acquire	VB
8691	1664	12	the	the	DT
8691	1664	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1664	14	now	now	RB
8691	1664	15	vested	vest	VBN
8691	1664	16	in	in	IN
8691	1664	17	the	the	DT
8691	1664	18	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1664	19	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1664	20	,	,	,
8691	1664	21	the	the	DT
8691	1664	22	District	District	NNP
8691	1664	23	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	1664	24	would	would	MD
8691	1664	25	sit	sit	VB
8691	1664	26	in	in	IN
8691	1664	27	the	the	DT
8691	1664	28	District	District	NNP
8691	1664	29	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1664	30	only	only	RB
8691	1664	31	,	,	,
8691	1664	32	and	and	CC
8691	1664	33	the	the	DT
8691	1664	34	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1664	35	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1664	36	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	1664	37	in	in	IN
8691	1664	38	the	the	DT
8691	1664	39	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1664	40	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1664	41	only	only	RB
8691	1664	42	,	,	,
8691	1664	43	while	while	IN
8691	1664	44	the	the	DT
8691	1664	45	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1664	46	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1664	47	of	of	IN
8691	1664	48	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1664	49	would	would	MD
8691	1664	50	come	come	VB
8691	1664	51	to	to	IN
8691	1664	52	an	an	DT
8691	1664	53	end	end	NN
8691	1664	54	.	.	.
8691	1665	1	The	the	DT
8691	1665	2	American	American	NNP
8691	1665	3	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	1665	4	Association	Association	NNP
8691	1665	5	voted	vote	VBD
8691	1665	6	in	in	IN
8691	1665	7	1903	1903	CD
8691	1665	8	that	that	IN
8691	1665	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1665	10	was	be	VBD
8691	1665	11	desirable	desirable	JJ
8691	1665	12	to	to	TO
8691	1665	13	establish	establish	VB
8691	1665	14	a	a	DT
8691	1665	15	new	new	JJ
8691	1665	16	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	1665	17	court	court	NN
8691	1665	18	to	to	TO
8691	1665	19	sit	sit	VB
8691	1665	20	at	at	IN
8691	1665	21	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	1665	22	and	and	CC
8691	1665	23	take	take	VB
8691	1665	24	cognizance	cognizance	NN
8691	1665	25	of	of	IN
8691	1665	26	patent	patent	NN
8691	1665	27	and	and	CC
8691	1665	28	copyright	copyright	NN
8691	1665	29	cases	case	NNS
8691	1665	30	.	.	.
8691	1666	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	1666	2	a	a	DT
8691	1666	3	measure	measure	NN
8691	1666	4	would	would	MD
8691	1666	5	tend	tend	VB
8691	1666	6	to	to	TO
8691	1666	7	relieve	relieve	VB
8691	1666	8	the	the	DT
8691	1666	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1666	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1666	11	of	of	IN
8691	1666	12	the	the	DT
8691	1666	13	United	United	NNP
8691	1666	14	States	States	NNP
8691	1666	15	of	of	IN
8691	1666	16	any	any	DT
8691	1666	17	undue	undue	JJ
8691	1666	18	pressure	pressure	NN
8691	1666	19	of	of	IN
8691	1666	20	business	business	NN
8691	1666	21	,	,	,
8691	1666	22	and	and	CC
8691	1666	23	promote	promote	VB
8691	1666	24	both	both	DT
8691	1666	25	uniformity	uniformity	NN
8691	1666	26	and	and	CC
8691	1666	27	promptitude	promptitude	NN
8691	1666	28	of	of	IN
8691	1666	29	decision	decision	NN
8691	1666	30	in	in	IN
8691	1666	31	a	a	DT
8691	1666	32	class	class	NN
8691	1666	33	of	of	IN
8691	1666	34	actions	action	NNS
8691	1666	35	in	in	IN
8691	1666	36	which	which	WDT
8691	1666	37	promptitude	promptitude	NN
8691	1666	38	and	and	CC
8691	1666	39	uniformity	uniformity	NN
8691	1666	40	are	be	VBP
8691	1666	41	of	of	IN
8691	1666	42	special	special	JJ
8691	1666	43	importance	importance	NN
8691	1666	44	.	.	.
8691	1667	1	As	as	IN
8691	1667	2	things	thing	NNS
8691	1667	3	stand	stand	VBP
8691	1667	4	now	now	RB
8691	1667	5	,	,	,
8691	1667	6	a	a	DT
8691	1667	7	patent	patent	NN
8691	1667	8	may	may	MD
8691	1667	9	be	be	VB
8691	1667	10	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	1667	11	invalid	invalid	JJ
8691	1667	12	in	in	IN
8691	1667	13	one	one	CD
8691	1667	14	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1667	15	and	and	CC
8691	1667	16	upheld	uphold	VBD
8691	1667	17	in	in	IN
8691	1667	18	another	another	DT
8691	1667	19	by	by	IN
8691	1667	20	courts	court	NNS
8691	1667	21	of	of	IN
8691	1667	22	equal	equal	JJ
8691	1667	23	authority	authority	NN
8691	1667	24	;	;	:
8691	1667	25	and	and	CC
8691	1667	26	while	while	IN
8691	1667	27	in	in	IN
8691	1667	28	such	such	JJ
8691	1667	29	event	event	NN
8691	1667	30	the	the	DT
8691	1667	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1667	32	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1667	33	would	would	MD
8691	1667	34	probably	probably	RB
8691	1667	35	,	,	,
8691	1667	36	on	on	IN
8691	1667	37	a	a	DT
8691	1667	38	special	special	JJ
8691	1667	39	application	application	NN
8691	1667	40	,	,	,
8691	1667	41	call	call	VB
8691	1667	42	both	both	PDT
8691	1667	43	these	these	DT
8691	1667	44	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1667	45	up	up	RP
8691	1667	46	before	before	IN
8691	1667	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1667	48	for	for	IN
8691	1667	49	review	review	NN
8691	1667	50	,	,	,
8691	1667	51	this	this	DT
8691	1667	52	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1667	53	can	can	MD
8691	1667	54	not	not	RB
8691	1667	55	be	be	VB
8691	1667	56	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	1667	57	as	as	IN
8691	1667	58	a	a	DT
8691	1667	59	matter	matter	NN
8691	1667	60	of	of	IN
8691	1667	61	absolute	absolute	JJ
8691	1667	62	right	right	NN
8691	1667	63	,	,	,
8691	1667	64	and	and	CC
8691	1667	65	is	be	VBZ
8691	1667	66	at	at	IN
8691	1667	67	best	good	JJS
8691	1667	68	a	a	DT
8691	1667	69	slow	slow	JJ
8691	1667	70	one	one	NN
8691	1667	71	.	.	.
8691	1668	1	The	the	DT
8691	1668	2	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1668	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1668	4	of	of	IN
8691	1668	5	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1668	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1668	7	held	hold	VBN
8691	1668	8	by	by	IN
8691	1668	9	three	three	CD
8691	1668	10	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1668	11	,	,	,
8691	1668	12	two	two	CD
8691	1668	13	constituting	constitute	VBG
8691	1668	14	a	a	DT
8691	1668	15	quorum	quorum	NN
8691	1668	16	.	.	.
8691	1669	1	Those	those	DT
8691	1669	2	generally	generally	RB
8691	1669	3	sitting	sit	VBG
8691	1669	4	are	be	VBP
8691	1669	5	the	the	DT
8691	1669	6	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1669	7	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	1669	8	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	1669	9	to	to	IN
8691	1669	10	the	the	DT
8691	1669	11	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1669	12	.	.	.
8691	1670	1	The	the	DT
8691	1670	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1670	3	of	of	IN
8691	1670	4	the	the	DT
8691	1670	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1670	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1670	7	assigned	assign	VBD
8691	1670	8	to	to	IN
8691	1670	9	the	the	DT
8691	1670	10	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1670	11	may	may	MD
8691	1670	12	also	also	RB
8691	1670	13	sit	sit	VB
8691	1670	14	,	,	,
8691	1670	15	and	and	CC
8691	1670	16	any	any	DT
8691	1670	17	of	of	IN
8691	1670	18	the	the	DT
8691	1670	19	District	District	NNP
8691	1670	20	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	1670	21	in	in	IN
8691	1670	22	the	the	DT
8691	1670	23	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1670	24	can	can	MD
8691	1670	25	be	be	VB
8691	1670	26	called	call	VBN
8691	1670	27	in	in	RP
8691	1670	28	.	.	.
8691	1671	1	Except	except	IN
8691	1671	2	in	in	IN
8691	1671	3	a	a	DT
8691	1671	4	very	very	RB
8691	1671	5	limited	limited	JJ
8691	1671	6	class	class	NN
8691	1671	7	of	of	IN
8691	1671	8	cases	case	NNS
8691	1671	9	,	,	,
8691	1671	10	the	the	DT
8691	1671	11	decision	decision	NN
8691	1671	12	of	of	IN
8691	1671	13	this	this	DT
8691	1671	14	court	court	NN
8691	1671	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	1671	16	final	final	JJ
8691	1671	17	,	,	,
8691	1671	18	unless	unless	IN
8691	1671	19	the	the	DT
8691	1671	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1671	21	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1671	22	,	,	,
8691	1671	23	on	on	IN
8691	1671	24	special	special	JJ
8691	1671	25	application	application	NN
8691	1671	26	,	,	,
8691	1671	27	should	should	MD
8691	1671	28	think	think	VB
8691	1671	29	the	the	DT
8691	1671	30	questions	question	NNS
8691	1671	31	involved	involve	VBN
8691	1671	32	to	to	TO
8691	1671	33	be	be	VB
8691	1671	34	of	of	IN
8691	1671	35	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	1671	36	importance	importance	NN
8691	1671	37	to	to	TO
8691	1671	38	require	require	VB
8691	1671	39	a	a	DT
8691	1671	40	review	review	NN
8691	1671	41	,	,	,
8691	1671	42	when	when	WRB
8691	1671	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1671	44	can	can	MD
8691	1671	45	order	order	VB
8691	1671	46	the	the	DT
8691	1671	47	record	record	NN
8691	1671	48	sent	send	VBN
8691	1671	49	up	up	RP
8691	1671	50	to	to	IN
8691	1671	51	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	1671	52	for	for	IN
8691	1671	53	that	that	DT
8691	1671	54	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1671	55	.	.	.
8691	1672	1	The	the	DT
8691	1672	2	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1672	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1672	4	of	of	IN
8691	1672	5	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1672	6	can	can	MD
8691	1672	7	also	also	RB
8691	1672	8	of	of	IN
8691	1672	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1672	10	own	own	JJ
8691	1672	11	motion	motion	NN
8691	1672	12	certify	certify	VB
8691	1672	13	up	up	RP
8691	1672	14	any	any	DT
8691	1672	15	questions	question	NNS
8691	1672	16	in	in	IN
8691	1672	17	a	a	DT
8691	1672	18	cause	cause	NN
8691	1672	19	to	to	IN
8691	1672	20	the	the	DT
8691	1672	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1672	22	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1672	23	for	for	IN
8691	1672	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1672	25	instructions	instruction	NNS
8691	1672	26	before	before	IN
8691	1672	27	making	make	VBG
8691	1672	28	a	a	DT
8691	1672	29	final	final	JJ
8691	1672	30	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	1672	31	of	of	IN
8691	1672	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1672	33	.	.	.
8691	1673	1	The	the	DT
8691	1673	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1673	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1673	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	1673	5	direct	direct	JJ
8691	1673	6	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	1673	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1673	8	over	over	IN
8691	1673	9	the	the	DT
8691	1673	10	District	District	NNP
8691	1673	11	and	and	CC
8691	1673	12	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1673	13	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1673	14	in	in	IN
8691	1673	15	cases	case	NNS
8691	1673	16	turning	turn	VBG
8691	1673	17	on	on	RP
8691	1673	18	the	the	DT
8691	1673	19	limits	limit	NNS
8691	1673	20	of	of	IN
8691	1673	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1673	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1673	23	,	,	,
8691	1673	24	in	in	IN
8691	1673	25	prize	prize	NN
8691	1673	26	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1673	27	,	,	,
8691	1673	28	in	in	IN
8691	1673	29	equity	equity	NN
8691	1673	30	suits	suit	NNS
8691	1673	31	by	by	IN
8691	1673	32	the	the	DT
8691	1673	33	United	United	NNP
8691	1673	34	States	States	NNP
8691	1673	35	under	under	IN
8691	1673	36	the	the	DT
8691	1673	37	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1673	38	regulating	regulate	VBG
8691	1673	39	inter	inter	JJ
8691	1673	40	-	-	JJ
8691	1673	41	State	state	JJ
8691	1673	42	commerce	commerce	NN
8691	1673	43	,	,	,
8691	1673	44	and	and	CC
8691	1673	45	in	in	IN
8691	1673	46	all	all	DT
8691	1673	47	cases	case	NNS
8691	1673	48	involving	involve	VBG
8691	1673	49	the	the	DT
8691	1673	50	construction	construction	NN
8691	1673	51	or	or	CC
8691	1673	52	application	application	NN
8691	1673	53	of	of	IN
8691	1673	54	the	the	DT
8691	1673	55	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1673	56	of	of	IN
8691	1673	57	the	the	DT
8691	1673	58	United	United	NNP
8691	1673	59	States	States	NNP
8691	1673	60	,	,	,
8691	1673	61	or	or	CC
8691	1673	62	of	of	IN
8691	1673	63	a	a	DT
8691	1673	64	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	1673	65	.	.	.
8691	1674	1	Appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	1674	2	also	also	RB
8691	1674	3	lie	lie	VBP
8691	1674	4	to	to	IN
8691	1674	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1674	6	from	from	IN
8691	1674	7	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1674	8	of	of	IN
8691	1674	9	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	1674	10	in	in	IN
8691	1674	11	the	the	DT
8691	1674	12	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1674	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1674	14	for	for	IN
8691	1674	15	capital	capital	NN
8691	1674	16	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	1674	17	.	.	.
8691	1675	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1675	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1675	3	:	:	:
8691	1675	4	29	29	CD
8691	1675	5	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1675	6	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1675	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNP
8691	1675	8	at	at	IN
8691	1675	9	Large	large	JJ
8691	1675	10	,	,	,
8691	1675	11	492	492	CD
8691	1675	12	;	;	:
8691	1675	13	32	32	CD
8691	1675	14	_	_	NNP
8691	1675	15	ib	ib	IN
8691	1675	16	_	_	NNP
8691	1675	17	.	.	.
8691	1676	1	823	823	CD
8691	1676	2	.	.	.
8691	1676	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1677	1	The	the	DT
8691	1677	2	consequence	consequence	NN
8691	1677	3	of	of	IN
8691	1677	4	the	the	DT
8691	1677	5	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1677	6	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1677	7	,	,	,
8691	1677	8	which	which	WDT
8691	1677	9	had	have	VBD
8691	1677	10	been	be	VBN
8691	1677	11	impaired	impair	VBN
8691	1677	12	by	by	IN
8691	1677	13	the	the	DT
8691	1677	14	practical	practical	JJ
8691	1677	15	withdrawal	withdrawal	NN
8691	1677	16	of	of	IN
8691	1677	17	the	the	DT
8691	1677	18	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1677	19	of	of	IN
8691	1677	20	the	the	DT
8691	1677	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1677	22	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1677	23	,	,	,
8691	1677	24	was	be	VBD
8691	1677	25	further	far	RBR
8691	1677	26	lessened	lessen	VBN
8691	1677	27	by	by	IN
8691	1677	28	the	the	DT
8691	1677	29	creation	creation	NN
8691	1677	30	of	of	IN
8691	1677	31	the	the	DT
8691	1677	32	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1677	33	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1677	34	of	of	IN
8691	1677	35	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1677	36	.	.	.
8691	1678	1	Before	before	IN
8691	1678	2	that	that	IN
8691	1678	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1678	4	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1678	5	in	in	IN
8691	1678	6	most	most	JJS
8691	1678	7	cases	case	NNS
8691	1678	8	were	be	VBD
8691	1678	9	final	final	JJ
8691	1678	10	.	.	.
8691	1679	1	In	in	IN
8691	1679	2	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1679	3	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1679	4	there	there	EX
8691	1679	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1679	6	no	no	DT
8691	1679	7	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1679	8	,	,	,
8691	1679	9	and	and	CC
8691	1679	10	in	in	IN
8691	1679	11	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	1679	12	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1679	13	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1679	14	none	none	NN
8691	1679	15	after	after	IN
8691	1679	16	1875	1875	CD
8691	1679	17	,	,	,
8691	1679	18	unless	unless	IN
8691	1679	19	the	the	DT
8691	1679	20	matter	matter	NN
8691	1679	21	in	in	IN
8691	1679	22	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	1679	23	exceeded	exceed	VBD
8691	1679	24	$	$	$
8691	1679	25	5,000	5,000	CD
8691	1679	26	in	in	IN
8691	1679	27	value	value	NN
8691	1679	28	.	.	.
8691	1680	1	This	this	DT
8691	1680	2	left	leave	VBD
8691	1680	3	the	the	DT
8691	1680	4	life	life	NN
8691	1680	5	,	,	,
8691	1680	6	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	1680	7	and	and	CC
8691	1680	8	property	property	NN
8691	1680	9	of	of	IN
8691	1680	10	the	the	DT
8691	1680	11	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	1680	12	top	top	NN
8691	1680	13	much	much	RB
8691	1680	14	in	in	IN
8691	1680	15	the	the	DT
8691	1680	16	hands	hand	NNS
8691	1680	17	of	of	IN
8691	1680	18	one	one	CD
8691	1680	19	man	man	NN
8691	1680	20	;	;	:
8691	1680	21	and	and	CC
8691	1680	22	the	the	DT
8691	1680	23	people	people	NNS
8691	1680	24	,	,	,
8691	1680	25	led	lead	VBN
8691	1680	26	by	by	IN
8691	1680	27	the	the	DT
8691	1680	28	bar	bar	NN
8691	1680	29	,	,	,
8691	1680	30	insisted	insist	VBD
8691	1680	31	on	on	IN
8691	1680	32	stripping	strip	VBG
8691	1680	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1680	34	of	of	IN
8691	1680	35	powers	power	NNS
8691	1680	36	so	so	RB
8691	1680	37	liable	liable	JJ
8691	1680	38	to	to	TO
8691	1680	39	abuse	abuse	VB
8691	1680	40	.	.	.
8691	1681	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1681	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1681	3	:	:	:
8691	1681	4	See	see	VB
8691	1681	5	an	an	DT
8691	1681	6	attack	attack	NN
8691	1681	7	on	on	IN
8691	1681	8	a	a	DT
8691	1681	9	similar	similar	JJ
8691	1681	10	state	state	NN
8691	1681	11	of	of	IN
8691	1681	12	things	thing	NNS
8691	1681	13	existing	exist	VBG
8691	1681	14	in	in	IN
8691	1681	15	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	1681	16	at	at	IN
8691	1681	17	one	one	CD
8691	1681	18	time	time	NN
8691	1681	19	in	in	IN
8691	1681	20	the	the	DT
8691	1681	21	District	District	NNP
8691	1681	22	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1681	23	,	,	,
8691	1681	24	by	by	IN
8691	1681	25	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	1681	26	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
8691	1681	27	in	in	IN
8691	1681	28	1826	1826	CD
8691	1681	29	.	.	.
8691	1682	1	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
8691	1682	2	,	,	,
8691	1682	3	"	"	``
8691	1682	4	Life	Life	NNP
8691	1682	5	of	of	IN
8691	1682	6	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	1682	7	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
8691	1682	8	,	,	,
8691	1682	9	"	"	``
8691	1682	10	302	302	CD
8691	1682	11	,	,	,
8691	1682	12	303	303	CD
8691	1682	13	.	.	.
8691	1682	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1683	1	No	no	DT
8691	1683	2	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	1683	3	can	can	MD
8691	1683	4	be	be	VB
8691	1683	5	sued	sue	VBN
8691	1683	6	in	in	IN
8691	1683	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1683	8	own	own	JJ
8691	1683	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	1683	10	without	without	IN
8691	1683	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1683	12	consent	consent	NN
8691	1683	13	.	.	.
8691	1684	1	The	the	DT
8691	1684	2	United	United	NNP
8691	1684	3	States	States	NNP
8691	1684	4	consent	consent	NN
8691	1684	5	to	to	TO
8691	1684	6	be	be	VB
8691	1684	7	sued	sue	VBN
8691	1684	8	on	on	IN
8691	1684	9	most	most	JJS
8691	1684	10	claims	claim	NNS
8691	1684	11	against	against	IN
8691	1684	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1684	13	of	of	IN
8691	1684	14	a	a	DT
8691	1684	15	contractual	contractual	JJ
8691	1684	16	nature	nature	NN
8691	1684	17	,	,	,
8691	1684	18	which	which	WDT
8691	1684	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1684	20	may	may	MD
8691	1684	21	dispute	dispute	VB
8691	1684	22	.	.	.
8691	1685	1	For	for	IN
8691	1685	2	this	this	DT
8691	1685	3	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1685	4	a	a	DT
8691	1685	5	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1685	6	of	of	IN
8691	1685	7	Claims	Claims	NNPS
8691	1685	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	1685	9	been	be	VBN
8691	1685	10	established	establish	VBN
8691	1685	11	at	at	IN
8691	1685	12	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	1685	13	,	,	,
8691	1685	14	consisting	consist	VBG
8691	1685	15	of	of	IN
8691	1685	16	a	a	DT
8691	1685	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1685	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1685	19	and	and	CC
8691	1685	20	four	four	CD
8691	1685	21	associates	associate	NNS
8691	1685	22	.	.	.
8691	1686	1	Originally	originally	RB
8691	1686	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1686	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1686	4	little	little	RB
8691	1686	5	more	more	JJR
8691	1686	6	than	than	IN
8691	1686	7	an	an	DT
8691	1686	8	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	1686	9	bureau	bureau	NN
8691	1686	10	;	;	:
8691	1686	11	but	but	CC
8691	1686	12	by	by	IN
8691	1686	13	successive	successive	JJ
8691	1686	14	amendments	amendment	NNS
8691	1686	15	of	of	IN
8691	1686	16	the	the	DT
8691	1686	17	law	law	NN
8691	1686	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1686	19	has	have	VBZ
8691	1686	20	come	come	VBN
8691	1686	21	to	to	TO
8691	1686	22	have	have	VB
8691	1686	23	fully	fully	RB
8691	1686	24	a	a	DT
8691	1686	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1686	26	character,[Footnote	character,[footnote	NN
8691	1686	27	:	:	:
8691	1686	28	United	United	NNP
8691	1686	29	States	States	NNP
8691	1686	30	_	_	NNP
8691	1686	31	v.	v.	IN
8691	1686	32	_	_	NNP
8691	1686	33	Klein	Klein	NNP
8691	1686	34	,	,	,
8691	1686	35	13	13	CD
8691	1686	36	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	1686	37	's	's	POS
8691	1686	38	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1686	39	,	,	,
8691	1686	40	128	128	CD
8691	1686	41	,	,	,
8691	1686	42	144	144	CD
8691	1686	43	;	;	:
8691	1686	44	24	24	CD
8691	1686	45	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1686	46	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1686	47	Statutes	Statutes	NNP
8691	1686	48	at	at	IN
8691	1686	49	Large	Large	NNP
8691	1686	50	,	,	,
8691	1686	51	505	505	CD
8691	1686	52	.	.	.
8691	1686	53	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1687	1	except	except	IN
8691	1687	2	in	in	IN
8691	1687	3	one	one	CD
8691	1687	4	particular	particular	JJ
8691	1687	5	.	.	.
8691	1688	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1688	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1688	3	a	a	DT
8691	1688	4	general	general	JJ
8691	1688	5	principle	principle	NN
8691	1688	6	that	that	IN
8691	1688	7	a	a	DT
8691	1688	8	court	court	NN
8691	1688	9	will	will	MD
8691	1688	10	make	make	VB
8691	1688	11	no	no	DT
8691	1688	12	decree	decree	NN
8691	1688	13	that	that	IN
8691	1688	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1688	15	can	can	MD
8691	1688	16	not	not	RB
8691	1688	17	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1688	18	.	.	.
8691	1689	1	The	the	DT
8691	1689	2	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1689	3	of	of	IN
8691	1689	4	Claims	Claims	NNPS
8691	1689	5	can	can	MD
8691	1689	6	not	not	RB
8691	1689	7	issue	issue	VB
8691	1689	8	an	an	DT
8691	1689	9	execution	execution	NN
8691	1689	10	to	to	TO
8691	1689	11	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1689	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1689	13	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1689	14	.	.	.
8691	1690	1	Money	money	NN
8691	1690	2	can	can	MD
8691	1690	3	be	be	VB
8691	1690	4	drawn	draw	VBN
8691	1690	5	from	from	IN
8691	1690	6	the	the	DT
8691	1690	7	treasury	treasury	NN
8691	1690	8	of	of	IN
8691	1690	9	the	the	DT
8691	1690	10	United	United	NNP
8691	1690	11	States	States	NNP
8691	1690	12	only	only	RB
8691	1690	13	to	to	TO
8691	1690	14	meet	meet	VB
8691	1690	15	appropriations	appropriation	NNS
8691	1690	16	made	make	VBN
8691	1690	17	by	by	IN
8691	1690	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1690	19	.	.	.
8691	1691	1	An	an	DT
8691	1691	2	appropriation	appropriation	NN
8691	1691	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1691	4	made	make	VBN
8691	1691	5	by	by	IN
8691	1691	6	each	each	DT
8691	1691	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1691	8	of	of	IN
8691	1691	9	a	a	DT
8691	1691	10	gross	gross	JJ
8691	1691	11	sum	sum	NN
8691	1691	12	to	to	TO
8691	1691	13	satisfy	satisfy	VB
8691	1691	14	any	any	DT
8691	1691	15	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1691	16	that	that	WDT
8691	1691	17	have	have	VBP
8691	1691	18	been	be	VBN
8691	1691	19	or	or	CC
8691	1691	20	may	may	MD
8691	1691	21	be	be	VB
8691	1691	22	rendered	render	VBN
8691	1691	23	by	by	IN
8691	1691	24	the	the	DT
8691	1691	25	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1691	26	of	of	IN
8691	1691	27	Claims	Claims	NNPS
8691	1691	28	;	;	:
8691	1691	29	but	but	CC
8691	1691	30	should	should	MD
8691	1691	31	this	this	DT
8691	1691	32	provision	provision	NN
8691	1691	33	be	be	VB
8691	1691	34	omitted	omit	VBN
8691	1691	35	in	in	IN
8691	1691	36	any	any	DT
8691	1691	37	appropriation	appropriation	NN
8691	1691	38	bill	bill	NN
8691	1691	39	the	the	DT
8691	1691	40	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1691	41	of	of	IN
8691	1691	42	the	the	DT
8691	1691	43	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1691	44	of	of	IN
8691	1691	45	Claims	Claims	NNPS
8691	1691	46	could	could	MD
8691	1691	47	not	not	RB
8691	1691	48	be	be	VB
8691	1691	49	collected	collect	VBN
8691	1691	50	.	.	.
8691	1692	1	Concurrent	concurrent	JJ
8691	1692	2	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1692	3	in	in	IN
8691	1692	4	these	these	DT
8691	1692	5	respects	respect	NNS
8691	1692	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1692	7	given	give	VBN
8691	1692	8	to	to	IN
8691	1692	9	the	the	DT
8691	1692	10	District	District	NNP
8691	1692	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1692	12	of	of	IN
8691	1692	13	claims	claim	NNS
8691	1692	14	not	not	RB
8691	1692	15	exceeding	exceed	VBG
8691	1692	16	$	$	$
8691	1692	17	1,000	1,000	CD
8691	1692	18	in	in	IN
8691	1692	19	amount	amount	NN
8691	1692	20	,	,	,
8691	1692	21	and	and	CC
8691	1692	22	to	to	IN
8691	1692	23	the	the	DT
8691	1692	24	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1692	25	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1692	26	of	of	IN
8691	1692	27	those	those	DT
8691	1692	28	exceeding	exceed	VBG
8691	1692	29	$	$	$
8691	1692	30	1,000	1,000	CD
8691	1692	31	and	and	CC
8691	1692	32	not	not	RB
8691	1692	33	exceeding	exceed	VBG
8691	1692	34	$	$	$
8691	1692	35	10,000	10,000	CD
8691	1692	36	.	.	.
8691	1693	1	Aliens	alien	NNS
8691	1693	2	can	can	MD
8691	1693	3	sue	sue	VB
8691	1693	4	in	in	IN
8691	1693	5	the	the	DT
8691	1693	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1693	7	of	of	IN
8691	1693	8	Claims	Claims	NNPS
8691	1693	9	when	when	WRB
8691	1693	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1693	11	own	own	JJ
8691	1693	12	country	country	NN
8691	1693	13	accords	accord	NNS
8691	1693	14	a	a	DT
8691	1693	15	similar	similar	JJ
8691	1693	16	privilege	privilege	NN
8691	1693	17	in	in	IN
8691	1693	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1693	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	1693	20	to	to	IN
8691	1693	21	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1693	22	of	of	IN
8691	1693	23	the	the	DT
8691	1693	24	United	United	NNP
8691	1693	25	States	States	NNP
8691	1693	26	.	.	.
8691	1694	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1694	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1694	3	:	:	:
8691	1694	4	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1694	5	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1694	6	Revised	Revised	NNP
8691	1694	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	1694	8	,	,	,
8691	1694	9	§	â§	NN
8691	1694	10	1068	1068	CD
8691	1694	11	.	.	.
8691	1694	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1695	1	This	this	DT
8691	1695	2	court	court	NN
8691	1695	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	1695	4	also	also	RB
8691	1695	5	a	a	DT
8691	1695	6	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
8691	1695	7	kind	kind	NN
8691	1695	8	of	of	IN
8691	1695	9	advisory	advisory	JJ
8691	1695	10	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1695	11	.	.	.
8691	1696	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1696	2	,	,	,
8691	1696	3	or	or	CC
8691	1696	4	any	any	DT
8691	1696	5	committee	committee	NN
8691	1696	6	of	of	IN
8691	1696	7	either	either	DT
8691	1696	8	house	house	NN
8691	1696	9	,	,	,
8691	1696	10	can	can	MD
8691	1696	11	refer	refer	VB
8691	1696	12	to	to	IN
8691	1696	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1696	14	any	any	DT
8691	1696	15	questions	question	NNS
8691	1696	16	of	of	IN
8691	1696	17	fact	fact	NN
8691	1696	18	which	which	WDT
8691	1696	19	may	may	MD
8691	1696	20	have	have	VB
8691	1696	21	come	come	VBN
8691	1696	22	before	before	IN
8691	1696	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1696	24	.	.	.
8691	1697	1	The	the	DT
8691	1697	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1697	3	must	must	MD
8691	1697	4	then	then	RB
8691	1697	5	ascertain	ascertain	VB
8691	1697	6	the	the	DT
8691	1697	7	facts	fact	NNS
8691	1697	8	and	and	CC
8691	1697	9	report	report	VB
8691	1697	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1697	11	back	back	RB
8691	1697	12	.	.	.
8691	1698	1	The	the	DT
8691	1698	2	head	head	NN
8691	1698	3	of	of	IN
8691	1698	4	any	any	DT
8691	1698	5	of	of	IN
8691	1698	6	the	the	DT
8691	1698	7	great	great	JJ
8691	1698	8	executive	executive	JJ
8691	1698	9	departments	department	NNS
8691	1698	10	may	may	MD
8691	1698	11	,	,	,
8691	1698	12	in	in	IN
8691	1698	13	like	like	NNP
8691	1698	14	manner	manner	NN
8691	1698	15	,	,	,
8691	1698	16	in	in	IN
8691	1698	17	dealing	deal	VBG
8691	1698	18	with	with	IN
8691	1698	19	any	any	DT
8691	1698	20	claim	claim	NN
8691	1698	21	against	against	IN
8691	1698	22	the	the	DT
8691	1698	23	government	government	NN
8691	1698	24	,	,	,
8691	1698	25	if	if	IN
8691	1698	26	the	the	DT
8691	1698	27	claimant	claimant	JJ
8691	1698	28	consents	consent	NNS
8691	1698	29	,	,	,
8691	1698	30	refer	refer	VBP
8691	1698	31	any	any	DT
8691	1698	32	uncontroverted	uncontroverted	JJ
8691	1698	33	questions	question	NNS
8691	1698	34	,	,	,
8691	1698	35	either	either	DT
8691	1698	36	of	of	IN
8691	1698	37	fact	fact	NN
8691	1698	38	or	or	CC
8691	1698	39	law	law	NN
8691	1698	40	,	,	,
8691	1698	41	to	to	IN
8691	1698	42	the	the	DT
8691	1698	43	court	court	NN
8691	1698	44	,	,	,
8691	1698	45	which	which	WDT
8691	1698	46	must	must	MD
8691	1698	47	then	then	RB
8691	1698	48	report	report	VB
8691	1698	49	back	back	RB
8691	1698	50	to	to	IN
8691	1698	51	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1698	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1698	53	findings	finding	NNS
8691	1698	54	and	and	CC
8691	1698	55	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1698	56	.	.	.
8691	1699	1	This	this	DT
8691	1699	2	does	do	VBZ
8691	1699	3	not	not	RB
8691	1699	4	take	take	VB
8691	1699	5	the	the	DT
8691	1699	6	form	form	NN
8691	1699	7	of	of	IN
8691	1699	8	a	a	DT
8691	1699	9	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1699	10	,	,	,
8691	1699	11	for	for	IN
8691	1699	12	there	there	EX
8691	1699	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	1699	14	no	no	DT
8691	1699	15	case	case	NN
8691	1699	16	and	and	CC
8691	1699	17	no	no	DT
8691	1699	18	parties	party	NNS
8691	1699	19	are	be	VBP
8691	1699	20	before	before	IN
8691	1699	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1699	22	.	.	.
8691	1700	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1700	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1700	3	a	a	DT
8691	1700	4	mere	mere	JJ
8691	1700	5	expression	expression	NN
8691	1700	6	of	of	IN
8691	1700	7	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1700	8	,	,	,
8691	1700	9	and	and	CC
8691	1700	10	stands	stand	VBZ
8691	1700	11	on	on	IN
8691	1700	12	much	much	RB
8691	1700	13	the	the	DT
8691	1700	14	footing	footing	NN
8691	1700	15	of	of	IN
8691	1700	16	the	the	DT
8691	1700	17	report	report	NN
8691	1700	18	of	of	IN
8691	1700	19	a	a	DT
8691	1700	20	committee	committee	NN
8691	1700	21	of	of	IN
8691	1700	22	inquiry	inquiry	NNP
8691	1700	23	to	to	IN
8691	1700	24	a	a	DT
8691	1700	25	superior	superior	JJ
8691	1700	26	authority	authority	NN
8691	1700	27	.	.	.
8691	1701	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1701	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1701	3	:	:	:
8691	1701	4	22	22	CD
8691	1701	5	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1701	6	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1701	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNP
8691	1701	8	at	at	IN
8691	1701	9	Large	large	JJ
8691	1701	10	,	,	,
8691	1701	11	485	485	CD
8691	1701	12	;	;	:
8691	1701	13	24	24	CD
8691	1701	14	_	_	NNP
8691	1701	15	i	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1701	16	d	d	NN
8691	1701	17	.	.	.
8691	1701	18	_	_	NNP
8691	1701	19	,	,	,
8691	1701	20	507	507	CD
8691	1701	21	.	.	.
8691	1701	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1702	1	A	a	DT
8691	1702	2	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	1702	3	court	court	NN
8691	1702	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1702	5	also	also	RB
8691	1702	6	in	in	IN
8691	1702	7	existence	existence	NN
8691	1702	8	called	call	VBN
8691	1702	9	the	the	DT
8691	1702	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1702	11	of	of	IN
8691	1702	12	Private	Private	NNP
8691	1702	13	Land	Land	NNP
8691	1702	14	Claims	Claims	NNPS
8691	1702	15	.	.	.
8691	1703	1	This	this	DT
8691	1703	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1703	3	composed	compose	VBN
8691	1703	4	of	of	IN
8691	1703	5	a	a	DT
8691	1703	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1703	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1703	8	and	and	CC
8691	1703	9	four	four	CD
8691	1703	10	associate	associate	NN
8691	1703	11	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1703	12	,	,	,
8691	1703	13	and	and	CC
8691	1703	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	1703	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1703	16	to	to	TO
8691	1703	17	hear	hear	VB
8691	1703	18	and	and	CC
8691	1703	19	determine	determine	VB
8691	1703	20	claims	claim	NNS
8691	1703	21	of	of	IN
8691	1703	22	title	title	NN
8691	1703	23	to	to	TO
8691	1703	24	land	land	VB
8691	1703	25	as	as	IN
8691	1703	26	against	against	IN
8691	1703	27	the	the	DT
8691	1703	28	United	United	NNP
8691	1703	29	States	States	NNP
8691	1703	30	,	,	,
8691	1703	31	founded	found	VBN
8691	1703	32	on	on	IN
8691	1703	33	Spanish	spanish	JJ
8691	1703	34	or	or	CC
8691	1703	35	Mexican	mexican	JJ
8691	1703	36	grants	grant	NNS
8691	1703	37	in	in	IN
8691	1703	38	New	New	NNP
8691	1703	39	Mexico	Mexico	NNP
8691	1703	40	,	,	,
8691	1703	41	Arizona	Arizona	NNP
8691	1703	42	,	,	,
8691	1703	43	Utah	Utah	NNP
8691	1703	44	,	,	,
8691	1703	45	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
8691	1703	46	,	,	,
8691	1703	47	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
8691	1703	48	or	or	CC
8691	1703	49	Wyoming	Wyoming	NNP
8691	1703	50	.	.	.
8691	1704	1	An	an	DT
8691	1704	2	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1704	3	from	from	IN
8691	1704	4	the	the	DT
8691	1704	5	final	final	JJ
8691	1704	6	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1704	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1704	8	given	give	VBN
8691	1704	9	to	to	IN
8691	1704	10	the	the	DT
8691	1704	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1704	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1704	13	of	of	IN
8691	1704	14	the	the	DT
8691	1704	15	United	United	NNP
8691	1704	16	States	States	NNP
8691	1704	17	.	.	.
8691	1705	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1705	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1705	3	:	:	:
8691	1705	4	26	26	CD
8691	1705	5	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1705	6	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1705	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNP
8691	1705	8	at	at	IN
8691	1705	9	Large	Large	NNP
8691	1705	10	,	,	,
8691	1705	11	854	854	CD
8691	1705	12	.	.	.
8691	1705	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1706	1	The	the	DT
8691	1706	2	District	District	NNP
8691	1706	3	of	of	IN
8691	1706	4	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
8691	1706	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	1706	6	a	a	DT
8691	1706	7	special	special	JJ
8691	1706	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1706	9	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	1706	10	.	.	.
8691	1707	1	There	there	EX
8691	1707	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1707	3	a	a	DT
8691	1707	4	court	court	NN
8691	1707	5	of	of	IN
8691	1707	6	general	general	JJ
8691	1707	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1707	8	known	know	VBN
8691	1707	9	as	as	IN
8691	1707	10	the	the	DT
8691	1707	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1707	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1707	13	of	of	IN
8691	1707	14	the	the	DT
8691	1707	15	District	District	NNP
8691	1707	16	of	of	IN
8691	1707	17	,	,	,
8691	1707	18	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
8691	1707	19	,	,	,
8691	1707	20	and	and	CC
8691	1707	21	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	1707	22	from	from	IN
8691	1707	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1707	24	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1707	25	lie	lie	VBP
8691	1707	26	to	to	IN
8691	1707	27	the	the	DT
8691	1707	28	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1707	29	of	of	IN
8691	1707	30	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	1707	31	of	of	IN
8691	1707	32	the	the	DT
8691	1707	33	District	District	NNP
8691	1707	34	of	of	IN
8691	1707	35	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
8691	1707	36	.	.	.
8691	1708	1	This	this	DT
8691	1708	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1708	3	composed	compose	VBN
8691	1708	4	of	of	IN
8691	1708	5	a	a	DT
8691	1708	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1708	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1708	8	and	and	CC
8691	1708	9	two	two	CD
8691	1708	10	associate	associate	JJ
8691	1708	11	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1708	12	,	,	,
8691	1708	13	and	and	CC
8691	1708	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1708	15	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1708	16	are	be	VBP
8691	1708	17	reviewable	reviewable	JJ
8691	1708	18	by	by	IN
8691	1708	19	the	the	DT
8691	1708	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1708	21	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1708	22	of	of	IN
8691	1708	23	the	the	DT
8691	1708	24	United	United	NNP
8691	1708	25	States	States	NNP
8691	1708	26	,	,	,
8691	1708	27	if	if	IN
8691	1708	28	$	$	$
8691	1708	29	5,000	5,000	CD
8691	1708	30	is	be	VBZ
8691	1708	31	involved	involve	VBN
8691	1708	32	,	,	,
8691	1708	33	or	or	CC
8691	1708	34	the	the	DT
8691	1708	35	validity	validity	NN
8691	1708	36	of	of	IN
8691	1708	37	an	an	DT
8691	1708	38	authority	authority	NN
8691	1708	39	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	1708	40	under	under	IN
8691	1708	41	the	the	DT
8691	1708	42	United	United	NNP
8691	1708	43	States	States	NNP
8691	1708	44	or	or	CC
8691	1708	45	a	a	DT
8691	1708	46	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	1708	47	or	or	CC
8691	1708	48	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1708	49	of	of	IN
8691	1708	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1708	51	is	be	VBZ
8691	1708	52	in	in	IN
8691	1708	53	question	question	NN
8691	1708	54	.	.	.
8691	1709	1	An	an	DT
8691	1709	2	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1709	3	also	also	RB
8691	1709	4	lies	lie	VBZ
8691	1709	5	to	to	IN
8691	1709	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1709	7	from	from	IN
8691	1709	8	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	1709	9	of	of	IN
8691	1709	10	the	the	DT
8691	1709	11	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
8691	1709	12	of	of	IN
8691	1709	13	Patents	Patents	NNPS
8691	1709	14	as	as	IN
8691	1709	15	to	to	IN
8691	1709	16	claims	claim	NNS
8691	1709	17	of	of	IN
8691	1709	18	a	a	DT
8691	1709	19	right	right	NN
8691	1709	20	to	to	IN
8691	1709	21	a	a	DT
8691	1709	22	patent	patent	NN
8691	1709	23	.	.	.
8691	1710	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1710	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1710	3	:	:	:
8691	1710	4	27	27	CD
8691	1710	5	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1710	6	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1710	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNP
8691	1710	8	at	at	IN
8691	1710	9	Large	Large	NNP
8691	1710	10	,	,	,
8691	1710	11	434	434	CD
8691	1710	12	.	.	.
8691	1710	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1711	1	When	when	WRB
8691	1711	2	new	new	JJ
8691	1711	3	territory	territory	NN
8691	1711	4	comes	come	VBZ
8691	1711	5	by	by	IN
8691	1711	6	conquest	conquest	NN
8691	1711	7	or	or	CC
8691	1711	8	cession	cession	NN
8691	1711	9	permanently	permanently	RB
8691	1711	10	under	under	IN
8691	1711	11	the	the	DT
8691	1711	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1711	13	of	of	IN
8691	1711	14	the	the	DT
8691	1711	15	United	United	NNP
8691	1711	16	States	States	NNP
8691	1711	17	,	,	,
8691	1711	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1711	19	belongs	belong	VBZ
8691	1711	20	to	to	IN
8691	1711	21	the	the	DT
8691	1711	22	President	President	NNP
8691	1711	23	,	,	,
8691	1711	24	in	in	IN
8691	1711	25	the	the	DT
8691	1711	26	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	1711	27	of	of	IN
8691	1711	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1711	29	executive	executive	JJ
8691	1711	30	power	power	NN
8691	1711	31	,	,	,
8691	1711	32	to	to	TO
8691	1711	33	see	see	VB
8691	1711	34	to	to	IN
8691	1711	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1711	36	proper	proper	JJ
8691	1711	37	government	government	NN
8691	1711	38	until	until	IN
8691	1711	39	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1711	40	makes	make	VBZ
8691	1711	41	other	other	JJ
8691	1711	42	provision	provision	NN
8691	1711	43	.	.	.
8691	1712	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1712	2	can	can	MD
8691	1712	3	institute	institute	VB
8691	1712	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	1712	5	there	there	RB
8691	1712	6	for	for	IN
8691	1712	7	that	that	DT
8691	1712	8	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1712	9	,	,	,
8691	1712	10	or	or	CC
8691	1712	11	if	if	IN
8691	1712	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1712	13	finds	find	VBZ
8691	1712	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	1712	15	created	create	VBN
8691	1712	16	by	by	IN
8691	1712	17	the	the	DT
8691	1712	18	former	former	JJ
8691	1712	19	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	1712	20	in	in	IN
8691	1712	21	existence	existence	NN
8691	1712	22	,	,	,
8691	1712	23	can	can	MD
8691	1712	24	expressly	expressly	RB
8691	1712	25	or	or	CC
8691	1712	26	impliedly	impliedly	RB
8691	1712	27	permit	permit	VB
8691	1712	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1712	29	to	to	TO
8691	1712	30	continue	continue	VB
8691	1712	31	in	in	IN
8691	1712	32	the	the	DT
8691	1712	33	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	1712	34	of	of	IN
8691	1712	35	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1712	36	functions	function	NNS
8691	1712	37	.	.	.
8691	1713	1	Each	each	DT
8691	1713	2	fully	fully	RB
8691	1713	3	organized	organize	VBN
8691	1713	4	Territory	territory	NN
8691	1713	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	1713	6	a	a	DT
8691	1713	7	set	set	NN
8691	1713	8	of	of	IN
8691	1713	9	local	local	JJ
8691	1713	10	courts	court	NNS
8691	1713	11	and	and	CC
8691	1713	12	one	one	CD
8691	1713	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1713	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1713	15	to	to	IN
8691	1713	16	which	which	WDT
8691	1713	17	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	1713	18	can	can	MD
8691	1713	19	be	be	VB
8691	1713	20	taken	take	VBN
8691	1713	21	and	and	CC
8691	1713	22	the	the	DT
8691	1713	23	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1713	24	of	of	IN
8691	1713	25	which	which	WDT
8691	1713	26	,	,	,
8691	1713	27	in	in	IN
8691	1713	28	cases	case	NNS
8691	1713	29	of	of	IN
8691	1713	30	large	large	JJ
8691	1713	31	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
8691	1713	32	magnitude	magnitude	NN
8691	1713	33	or	or	CC
8691	1713	34	great	great	JJ
8691	1713	35	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1713	36	importance	importance	NN
8691	1713	37	,	,	,
8691	1713	38	can	can	MD
8691	1713	39	be	be	VB
8691	1713	40	reviewed	review	VBN
8691	1713	41	by	by	IN
8691	1713	42	the	the	DT
8691	1713	43	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1713	44	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1713	45	of	of	IN
8691	1713	46	the	the	DT
8691	1713	47	United	United	NNP
8691	1713	48	States	States	NNP
8691	1713	49	.	.	.
8691	1714	1	These	these	DT
8691	1714	2	territorial	territorial	JJ
8691	1714	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1714	4	do	do	VBP
8691	1714	5	not	not	RB
8691	1714	6	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	1714	7	what	what	WP
8691	1714	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	1714	9	known	know	VBN
8691	1714	10	in	in	IN
8691	1714	11	the	the	DT
8691	1714	12	strict	strict	JJ
8691	1714	13	sense	sense	NN
8691	1714	14	and	and	CC
8691	1714	15	designated	designate	VBN
8691	1714	16	in	in	IN
8691	1714	17	the	the	DT
8691	1714	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1714	19	as	as	IN
8691	1714	20	"	"	``
8691	1714	21	the	the	DT
8691	1714	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1714	23	power	power	NN
8691	1714	24	of	of	IN
8691	1714	25	the	the	DT
8691	1714	26	United	United	NNP
8691	1714	27	States	States	NNP
8691	1714	28	.	.	.
8691	1714	29	"	"	''
8691	1715	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1715	2	are	be	VBP
8691	1715	3	created	create	VBN
8691	1715	4	to	to	TO
8691	1715	5	meet	meet	VB
8691	1715	6	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	1715	7	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	1715	8	,	,	,
8691	1715	9	and	and	CC
8691	1715	10	with	with	IN
8691	1715	11	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1715	12	whose	whose	WP$
8691	1715	13	commissions	commission	NNS
8691	1715	14	run	run	VBP
8691	1715	15	only	only	RB
8691	1715	16	for	for	IN
8691	1715	17	a	a	DT
8691	1715	18	few	few	JJ
8691	1715	19	years	year	NNS
8691	1715	20	.	.	.
8691	1716	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	1716	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1716	3	are	be	VBP
8691	1716	4	instruments	instrument	NNS
8691	1716	5	through	through	IN
8691	1716	6	which	which	WDT
8691	1716	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1716	8	exercises	exercise	VBZ
8691	1716	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1716	10	power	power	NN
8691	1716	11	of	of	IN
8691	1716	12	regulating	regulate	VBG
8691	1716	13	the	the	DT
8691	1716	14	territory	territory	NN
8691	1716	15	of	of	IN
8691	1716	16	the	the	DT
8691	1716	17	United	United	NNP
8691	1716	18	States	States	NNP
8691	1716	19	.	.	.
8691	1717	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1717	2	act	act	VBP
8691	1717	3	judicially	judicially	RB
8691	1717	4	.	.	.
8691	1718	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1718	2	have	have	VBP
8691	1718	3	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1718	4	power	power	NN
8691	1718	5	.	.	.
8691	1719	1	But	but	CC
8691	1719	2	the	the	DT
8691	1719	3	source	source	NN
8691	1719	4	of	of	IN
8691	1719	5	this	this	DT
8691	1719	6	power	power	NN
8691	1719	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1719	8	not	not	RB
8691	1719	9	the	the	DT
8691	1719	10	clause	clause	NN
8691	1719	11	in	in	IN
8691	1719	12	the	the	DT
8691	1719	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1719	14	under	under	IN
8691	1719	15	which	which	WDT
8691	1719	16	the	the	DT
8691	1719	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1719	18	power	power	NN
8691	1719	19	of	of	IN
8691	1719	20	the	the	DT
8691	1719	21	United	United	NNP
8691	1719	22	States	States	NNP
8691	1719	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	1719	24	defined	define	VBN
8691	1719	25	.	.	.
8691	1720	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1720	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1720	3	:	:	:
8691	1720	4	American	American	NNP
8691	1720	5	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	1720	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1720	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1720	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	1720	9	_	_	NNP
8691	1720	10	Canter	Canter	NNP
8691	1720	11	,	,	,
8691	1720	12	1	1	CD
8691	1720	13	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1720	14	'	'	POS
8691	1720	15	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1720	16	,	,	,
8691	1720	17	511	511	CD
8691	1720	18	.	.	.
8691	1720	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1721	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1721	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1721	3	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1721	4	not	not	RB
8691	1721	5	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1721	6	to	to	TO
8691	1721	7	confine	confine	VB
8691	1721	8	such	such	JJ
8691	1721	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	1721	10	strictly	strictly	RB
8691	1721	11	to	to	IN
8691	1721	12	the	the	DT
8691	1721	13	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	1721	14	of	of	IN
8691	1721	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1721	16	business	business	NN
8691	1721	17	.	.	.
8691	1722	1	In	in	IN
8691	1722	2	the	the	DT
8691	1722	3	organization	organization	NN
8691	1722	4	of	of	IN
8691	1722	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1722	6	earliest	early	JJS
8691	1722	7	Territories	territory	NNS
8691	1722	8	the	the	DT
8691	1722	9	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1722	10	were	be	VBD
8691	1722	11	given	give	VBN
8691	1722	12	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1722	13	functions	function	NNS
8691	1722	14	,	,	,
8691	1722	15	and	and	CC
8691	1722	16	while	while	IN
8691	1722	17	this	this	DT
8691	1722	18	was	be	VBD
8691	1722	19	originally	originally	RB
8691	1722	20	due	due	JJ
8691	1722	21	to	to	IN
8691	1722	22	the	the	DT
8691	1722	23	terms	term	NNS
8691	1722	24	of	of	IN
8691	1722	25	the	the	DT
8691	1722	26	Ordinance	Ordinance	NNP
8691	1722	27	of	of	IN
8691	1722	28	1787	1787	CD
8691	1722	29	,	,	,
8691	1722	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1722	31	was	be	VBD
8691	1722	32	confirmed	confirm	VBN
8691	1722	33	by	by	IN
8691	1722	34	various	various	JJ
8691	1722	35	Acts	act	NNS
8691	1722	36	of	of	IN
8691	1722	37	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1722	38	after	after	IN
8691	1722	39	the	the	DT
8691	1722	40	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	1722	41	of	of	IN
8691	1722	42	the	the	DT
8691	1722	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1722	44	of	of	IN
8691	1722	45	the	the	DT
8691	1722	46	United	United	NNP
8691	1722	47	States	States	NNP
8691	1722	48	.	.	.
8691	1723	1	The	the	DT
8691	1723	2	Philippines	Philippines	NNPS
8691	1723	3	are	be	VBP
8691	1723	4	governed	govern	VBN
8691	1723	5	under	under	IN
8691	1723	6	an	an	DT
8691	1723	7	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1723	8	of	of	IN
8691	1723	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1723	10	by	by	IN
8691	1723	11	a	a	DT
8691	1723	12	commission	commission	NN
8691	1723	13	acting	act	VBG
8691	1723	14	under	under	IN
8691	1723	15	the	the	DT
8691	1723	16	supervision	supervision	NN
8691	1723	17	of	of	IN
8691	1723	18	the	the	DT
8691	1723	19	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
8691	1723	20	of	of	IN
8691	1723	21	War	War	NNP
8691	1723	22	.	.	.
8691	1724	1	The	the	DT
8691	1724	2	organization	organization	NN
8691	1724	3	of	of	IN
8691	1724	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	1724	5	established	establish	VBN
8691	1724	6	by	by	IN
8691	1724	7	Spain	Spain	NNP
8691	1724	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	1724	9	been	be	VBN
8691	1724	10	in	in	IN
8691	1724	11	substance	substance	NN
8691	1724	12	preserved	preserve	VBN
8691	1724	13	.	.	.
8691	1725	1	The	the	DT
8691	1725	2	Spanish	spanish	JJ
8691	1725	3	law	law	NN
8691	1725	4	which	which	WDT
8691	1725	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1725	6	in	in	IN
8691	1725	7	force	force	NN
8691	1725	8	there	there	EX
8691	1725	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1725	10	expressed	express	VBN
8691	1725	11	in	in	IN
8691	1725	12	codes	code	NNS
8691	1725	13	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	1725	14	founded	found	VBN
8691	1725	15	on	on	IN
8691	1725	16	those	those	DT
8691	1725	17	framed	frame	VBN
8691	1725	18	for	for	IN
8691	1725	19	France	France	NNP
8691	1725	20	under	under	IN
8691	1725	21	Napoleon	Napoleon	NNP
8691	1725	22	I.	I.	NNP
8691	1726	1	In	in	IN
8691	1726	2	1901	1901	CD
8691	1726	3	,	,	,
8691	1726	4	the	the	DT
8691	1726	5	Spanish	spanish	JJ
8691	1726	6	code	code	NN
8691	1726	7	of	of	IN
8691	1726	8	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1726	9	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	1726	10	was	be	VBD
8691	1726	11	supplanted	supplant	VBN
8691	1726	12	by	by	IN
8691	1726	13	one	one	CD
8691	1726	14	prepared	prepare	VBN
8691	1726	15	by	by	IN
8691	1726	16	a	a	DT
8691	1726	17	member	member	NN
8691	1726	18	of	of	IN
8691	1726	19	the	the	DT
8691	1726	20	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
8691	1726	21	Commission	Commission	NNP
8691	1726	22	,	,	,
8691	1726	23	and	and	CC
8691	1726	24	which	which	WDT
8691	1726	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	1726	26	now	now	RB
8691	1726	27	familiarly	familiarly	RB
8691	1726	28	known	know	VBN
8691	1726	29	by	by	IN
8691	1726	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1726	31	name	name	NN
8691	1726	32	as	as	IN
8691	1726	33	the	the	DT
8691	1726	34	Ide	Ide	NNP
8691	1726	35	Code	Code	NNP
8691	1726	36	.	.	.
8691	1727	1	In	in	IN
8691	1727	2	substance	substance	NN
8691	1727	3	,	,	,
8691	1727	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1727	5	establishes	establish	VBZ
8691	1727	6	the	the	DT
8691	1727	7	mode	mode	NN
8691	1727	8	of	of	IN
8691	1727	9	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1727	10	in	in	IN
8691	1727	11	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1727	12	cases	case	NNS
8691	1727	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1727	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	1727	15	known	know	VBN
8691	1727	16	in	in	IN
8691	1727	17	the	the	DT
8691	1727	18	United	United	NNP
8691	1727	19	States	States	NNP
8691	1727	20	as	as	IN
8691	1727	21	code	code	NN
8691	1727	22	pleading	pleading	NN
8691	1727	23	.	.	.
8691	1728	1	Trial	trial	NN
8691	1728	2	by	by	IN
8691	1728	3	jury	jury	NN
8691	1728	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	1728	5	not	not	RB
8691	1728	6	been	be	VBN
8691	1728	7	introduced	introduce	VBN
8691	1728	8	into	into	IN
8691	1728	9	the	the	DT
8691	1728	10	Philippines	Philippines	NNP
8691	1728	11	either	either	CC
8691	1728	12	in	in	IN
8691	1728	13	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1728	14	or	or	CC
8691	1728	15	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1728	16	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1728	17	,	,	,
8691	1728	18	and	and	CC
8691	1728	19	need	nee	MD
8691	1728	20	not	not	RB
8691	1728	21	be	be	VB
8691	1728	22	.	.	.
8691	1729	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1729	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1729	3	:	:	:
8691	1729	4	Dorr	Dorr	NNP
8691	1729	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1729	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1729	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1729	8	United	United	NNP
8691	1729	9	States	States	NNP
8691	1729	10	,	,	,
8691	1729	11	195	195	CD
8691	1729	12	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1729	13	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1729	14	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1729	15	,	,	,
8691	1729	16	138	138	CD
8691	1729	17	.	.	.
8691	1729	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1730	1	In	in	IN
8691	1730	2	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1730	3	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1730	4	,	,	,
8691	1730	5	the	the	DT
8691	1730	6	Spanish	spanish	JJ
8691	1730	7	system	system	NN
8691	1730	8	was	be	VBD
8691	1730	9	originally	originally	RB
8691	1730	10	retained	retain	VBN
8691	1730	11	,	,	,
8691	1730	12	allowing	allow	VBG
8691	1730	13	either	either	DT
8691	1730	14	party	party	NN
8691	1730	15	,	,	,
8691	1730	16	the	the	DT
8691	1730	17	United	United	NNP
8691	1730	18	States	States	NNP
8691	1730	19	or	or	CC
8691	1730	20	the	the	DT
8691	1730	21	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	1730	22	,	,	,
8691	1730	23	to	to	TO
8691	1730	24	appeal	appeal	VB
8691	1730	25	from	from	IN
8691	1730	26	the	the	DT
8691	1730	27	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1730	28	of	of	IN
8691	1730	29	the	the	DT
8691	1730	30	court	court	NN
8691	1730	31	of	of	IN
8691	1730	32	first	first	JJ
8691	1730	33	instance	instance	NN
8691	1730	34	to	to	IN
8691	1730	35	the	the	DT
8691	1730	36	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1730	37	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1730	38	of	of	IN
8691	1730	39	the	the	DT
8691	1730	40	islands	island	NNS
8691	1730	41	and	and	CC
8691	1730	42	have	have	VBP
8691	1730	43	there	there	EX
8691	1730	44	a	a	DT
8691	1730	45	new	new	JJ
8691	1730	46	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	1730	47	both	both	DT
8691	1730	48	as	as	IN
8691	1730	49	to	to	IN
8691	1730	50	fact	fact	NN
8691	1730	51	and	and	CC
8691	1730	52	law	law	NN
8691	1730	53	.	.	.
8691	1731	1	This	this	DT
8691	1731	2	,	,	,
8691	1731	3	however	however	RB
8691	1731	4	,	,	,
8691	1731	5	so	so	RB
8691	1731	6	far	far	RB
8691	1731	7	as	as	IN
8691	1731	8	concerns	concern	NNS
8691	1731	9	an	an	DT
8691	1731	10	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1731	11	by	by	IN
8691	1731	12	the	the	DT
8691	1731	13	government	government	NN
8691	1731	14	,	,	,
8691	1731	15	was	be	VBD
8691	1731	16	held	hold	VBN
8691	1731	17	to	to	TO
8691	1731	18	be	be	VB
8691	1731	19	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	1731	20	to	to	IN
8691	1731	21	the	the	DT
8691	1731	22	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1731	23	of	of	IN
8691	1731	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1731	25	under	under	IN
8691	1731	26	which	which	WDT
8691	1731	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1731	28	was	be	VBD
8691	1731	29	constituted	constitute	VBN
8691	1731	30	.	.	.
8691	1732	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1732	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1732	3	:	:	:
8691	1732	4	Kepner	Kepner	NNP
8691	1732	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1732	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1732	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1732	8	United	United	NNP
8691	1732	9	States	States	NNP
8691	1732	10	,	,	,
8691	1732	11	195	195	CD
8691	1732	12	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1732	13	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1732	14	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1732	15	,	,	,
8691	1732	16	100	100	CD
8691	1732	17	.	.	.
8691	1732	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1733	1	The	the	DT
8691	1733	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1733	3	of	of	IN
8691	1733	4	the	the	DT
8691	1733	5	United	United	NNP
8691	1733	6	States	States	NNP
8691	1733	7	are	be	VBP
8691	1733	8	generally	generally	RB
8691	1733	9	provided	provide	VBN
8691	1733	10	with	with	IN
8691	1733	11	an	an	DT
8691	1733	12	officer	officer	NN
8691	1733	13	styled	style	VBD
8691	1733	14	a	a	DT
8691	1733	15	marshal	marshal	NN
8691	1733	16	.	.	.
8691	1734	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1734	2	executes	execute	VBZ
8691	1734	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1734	4	process	process	NN
8691	1734	5	,	,	,
8691	1734	6	attends	attend	VBZ
8691	1734	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1734	8	sessions	session	NNS
8691	1734	9	,	,	,
8691	1734	10	and	and	CC
8691	1734	11	exercises	exercise	NNS
8691	1734	12	in	in	IN
8691	1734	13	general	general	JJ
8691	1734	14	the	the	DT
8691	1734	15	functions	function	NNS
8691	1734	16	which	which	WDT
8691	1734	17	belong	belong	VBP
8691	1734	18	to	to	IN
8691	1734	19	a	a	DT
8691	1734	20	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	1734	21	as	as	IN
8691	1734	22	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	1734	23	State	State	NNP
8691	1734	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	1734	25	.	.	.
8691	1735	1	Each	each	DT
8691	1735	2	District	District	NNP
8691	1735	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1735	4	appoints	appoint	VBZ
8691	1735	5	a	a	DT
8691	1735	6	convenient	convenient	JJ
8691	1735	7	number	number	NN
8691	1735	8	of	of	IN
8691	1735	9	District	District	NNP
8691	1735	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1735	11	Commissioners	Commissioners	NNPS
8691	1735	12	,	,	,
8691	1735	13	who	who	WP
8691	1735	14	issue	issue	VBP
8691	1735	15	warrants	warrant	NNS
8691	1735	16	of	of	IN
8691	1735	17	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	1735	18	on	on	IN
8691	1735	19	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1735	20	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1735	21	,	,	,
8691	1735	22	take	take	VB
8691	1735	23	bail	bail	NN
8691	1735	24	,	,	,
8691	1735	25	inquire	inquire	VBP
8691	1735	26	whether	whether	IN
8691	1735	27	there	there	EX
8691	1735	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	1735	29	probable	probable	JJ
8691	1735	30	cause	cause	NN
8691	1735	31	to	to	TO
8691	1735	32	hold	hold	VB
8691	1735	33	the	the	DT
8691	1735	34	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	1735	35	to	to	TO
8691	1735	36	answer	answer	VB
8691	1735	37	to	to	IN
8691	1735	38	the	the	DT
8691	1735	39	charge	charge	NN
8691	1735	40	in	in	IN
8691	1735	41	court	court	NN
8691	1735	42	,	,	,
8691	1735	43	and	and	CC
8691	1735	44	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	1735	45	in	in	IN
8691	1735	46	such	such	JJ
8691	1735	47	respects	respect	NNS
8691	1735	48	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	1735	49	the	the	DT
8691	1735	50	functions	function	NNS
8691	1735	51	generally	generally	RB
8691	1735	52	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	1735	53	to	to	IN
8691	1735	54	justices	justice	NNS
8691	1735	55	of	of	IN
8691	1735	56	the	the	DT
8691	1735	57	peace	peace	NN
8691	1735	58	in	in	IN
8691	1735	59	the	the	DT
8691	1735	60	States	States	NNP
8691	1735	61	.	.	.
8691	1736	1	*	*	NFP
8691	1736	2	*	*	NFP
8691	1736	3	*	*	NFP
8691	1736	4	*	*	NFP
8691	1736	5	*	*	NFP
8691	1736	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	1736	7	X	x	NN
8691	1736	8	RELATIONS	relation	NNS
8691	1736	9	OF	of	IN
8691	1736	10	THE	the	DT
8691	1736	11	STATE	STATE	NNP
8691	1736	12	JUDICIARY	judiciary	NN
8691	1736	13	TO	to	IN
8691	1736	14	THE	the	DT
8691	1736	15	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
8691	1736	16	STATES	STATES	NNP
8691	1736	17	AND	and	CC
8691	1736	18	OF	of	IN
8691	1736	19	THE	the	DT
8691	1736	20	UNITED	UNITED	NNP
8691	1736	21	STATES	state	NNS
8691	1736	22	JUDICIARY	judiciary	NN
8691	1736	23	TO	to	IN
8691	1736	24	THE	the	DT
8691	1736	25	STATES	state	NNS
8691	1736	26	Every	every	DT
8691	1736	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1736	28	officer	officer	NN
8691	1736	29	of	of	IN
8691	1736	30	a	a	DT
8691	1736	31	State	State	NNP
8691	1736	32	is	be	VBZ
8691	1736	33	required	require	VBN
8691	1736	34	by	by	IN
8691	1736	35	the	the	DT
8691	1736	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1736	37	of	of	IN
8691	1736	38	the	the	DT
8691	1736	39	United	United	NNP
8691	1736	40	States	States	NNP
8691	1736	41	to	to	TO
8691	1736	42	bind	bind	VB
8691	1736	43	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1736	44	by	by	IN
8691	1736	45	oath	oath	NN
8691	1736	46	or	or	CC
8691	1736	47	affirmation	affirmation	NN
8691	1736	48	to	to	TO
8691	1736	49	support	support	VB
8691	1736	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1736	51	,	,	,
8691	1736	52	and	and	CC
8691	1736	53	this	this	DT
8691	1736	54	obligation	obligation	NN
8691	1736	55	compels	compel	VBZ
8691	1736	56	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1736	57	to	to	TO
8691	1736	58	respect	respect	VB
8691	1736	59	every	every	DT
8691	1736	60	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1736	61	of	of	IN
8691	1736	62	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1736	63	made	make	VBD
8691	1736	64	in	in	IN
8691	1736	65	pursuance	pursuance	NN
8691	1736	66	of	of	IN
8691	1736	67	the	the	DT
8691	1736	68	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1736	69	,	,	,
8691	1736	70	and	and	CC
8691	1736	71	every	every	DT
8691	1736	72	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	1736	73	made	make	VBN
8691	1736	74	under	under	IN
8691	1736	75	the	the	DT
8691	1736	76	authority	authority	NN
8691	1736	77	of	of	IN
8691	1736	78	the	the	DT
8691	1736	79	United	United	NNP
8691	1736	80	States	States	NNP
8691	1736	81	,	,	,
8691	1736	82	as	as	IN
8691	1736	83	,	,	,
8691	1736	84	in	in	IN
8691	1736	85	case	case	NN
8691	1736	86	of	of	IN
8691	1736	87	conflict	conflict	NN
8691	1736	88	,	,	,
8691	1736	89	superior	superior	JJ
8691	1736	90	to	to	IN
8691	1736	91	anything	anything	NN
8691	1736	92	in	in	IN
8691	1736	93	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1736	94	State	State	NNP
8691	1736	95	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1736	96	or	or	CC
8691	1736	97	laws	law	NNS
8691	1736	98	.	.	.
8691	1737	1	The	the	DT
8691	1737	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1737	3	of	of	IN
8691	1737	4	the	the	DT
8691	1737	5	national	national	JJ
8691	1737	6	government	government	NN
8691	1737	7	are	be	VBP
8691	1737	8	complementary	complementary	JJ
8691	1737	9	to	to	IN
8691	1737	10	those	those	DT
8691	1737	11	of	of	IN
8691	1737	12	the	the	DT
8691	1737	13	States	States	NNPS
8691	1737	14	.	.	.
8691	1738	1	Both	both	DT
8691	1738	2	belong	belong	VBP
8691	1738	3	to	to	IN
8691	1738	4	one	one	CD
8691	1738	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1738	6	system	system	NN
8691	1738	7	.	.	.
8691	1739	1	Rights	right	NNS
8691	1739	2	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1739	3	under	under	IN
8691	1739	4	the	the	DT
8691	1739	5	laws	law	NNS
8691	1739	6	of	of	IN
8691	1739	7	the	the	DT
8691	1739	8	United	United	NNP
8691	1739	9	States	States	NNP
8691	1739	10	may	may	MD
8691	1739	11	be	be	VB
8691	1739	12	enforced	enforce	VBN
8691	1739	13	by	by	IN
8691	1739	14	a	a	DT
8691	1739	15	State	State	NNP
8691	1739	16	court	court	NN
8691	1739	17	as	as	RB
8691	1739	18	well	well	RB
8691	1739	19	as	as	IN
8691	1739	20	by	by	IN
8691	1739	21	a	a	DT
8691	1739	22	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1739	23	court	court	NN
8691	1739	24	,	,	,
8691	1739	25	and	and	CC
8691	1739	26	rights	right	NNS
8691	1739	27	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1739	28	under	under	IN
8691	1739	29	a	a	DT
8691	1739	30	State	State	NNP
8691	1739	31	law	law	NN
8691	1739	32	by	by	IN
8691	1739	33	a	a	DT
8691	1739	34	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1739	35	as	as	RB
8691	1739	36	well	well	RB
8691	1739	37	as	as	IN
8691	1739	38	by	by	IN
8691	1739	39	the	the	DT
8691	1739	40	State	State	NNP
8691	1739	41	court	court	NN
8691	1739	42	,	,	,
8691	1739	43	unless	unless	IN
8691	1739	44	in	in	IN
8691	1739	45	cases	case	NNS
8691	1739	46	where	where	WRB
8691	1739	47	there	there	EX
8691	1739	48	is	be	VBZ
8691	1739	49	some	some	DT
8691	1739	50	special	special	JJ
8691	1739	51	restriction	restriction	NN
8691	1739	52	upon	upon	IN
8691	1739	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1739	54	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1739	55	.	.	.
8691	1740	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	1740	2	a	a	DT
8691	1740	3	restriction	restriction	NN
8691	1740	4	may	may	MD
8691	1740	5	be	be	VB
8691	1740	6	imposed	impose	VBN
8691	1740	7	by	by	IN
8691	1740	8	either	either	DT
8691	1740	9	government	government	NN
8691	1740	10	,	,	,
8691	1740	11	as	as	IN
8691	1740	12	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	1740	13	any	any	DT
8691	1740	14	right	right	NN
8691	1740	15	which	which	WDT
8691	1740	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1740	17	creates	create	VBZ
8691	1740	18	.	.	.
8691	1741	1	The	the	DT
8691	1741	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1741	3	power	power	NN
8691	1741	4	of	of	IN
8691	1741	5	the	the	DT
8691	1741	6	United	United	NNP
8691	1741	7	States	States	NNP
8691	1741	8	extends	extend	VBZ
8691	1741	9	only	only	RB
8691	1741	10	to	to	IN
8691	1741	11	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1741	12	classes	class	NNS
8691	1741	13	of	of	IN
8691	1741	14	cases	case	NNS
8691	1741	15	.	.	.
8691	1742	1	As	as	IN
8691	1742	2	to	to	IN
8691	1742	3	some	some	DT
8691	1742	4	of	of	IN
8691	1742	5	these	these	DT
8691	1742	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1742	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1742	8	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	1742	9	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
8691	1742	10	:	:	:
8691	1742	11	as	as	IN
8691	1742	12	to	to	IN
8691	1742	13	any	any	DT
8691	1742	14	of	of	IN
8691	1742	15	the	the	DT
8691	1742	16	rest	rest	NN
8691	1742	17	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1742	18	can	can	MD
8691	1742	19	make	make	VB
8691	1742	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1742	21	such	such	JJ
8691	1742	22	.	.	.
8691	1743	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1743	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1743	3	:	:	:
8691	1743	4	The	the	DT
8691	1743	5	Moses	Moses	NNP
8691	1743	6	Taylor	Taylor	NNP
8691	1743	7	,	,	,
8691	1743	8	4	4	CD
8691	1743	9	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	1743	10	's	's	POS
8691	1743	11	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1743	12	,	,	,
8691	1743	13	411	411	CD
8691	1743	14	,	,	,
8691	1743	15	429	429	CD
8691	1743	16	.	.	.
8691	1743	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1744	1	On	on	IN
8691	1744	2	the	the	DT
8691	1744	3	other	other	JJ
8691	1744	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	1744	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1744	6	may	may	MD
8691	1744	7	assume	assume	VB
8691	1744	8	to	to	TO
8691	1744	9	invest	invest	VB
8691	1744	10	a	a	DT
8691	1744	11	State	State	NNP
8691	1744	12	court	court	NN
8691	1744	13	with	with	IN
8691	1744	14	power	power	NN
8691	1744	15	to	to	TO
8691	1744	16	dispose	dispose	VB
8691	1744	17	of	of	IN
8691	1744	18	a	a	DT
8691	1744	19	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1744	20	matter	matter	NN
8691	1744	21	of	of	IN
8691	1744	22	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1744	23	right	right	NN
8691	1744	24	,	,	,
8691	1744	25	and	and	CC
8691	1744	26	the	the	DT
8691	1744	27	State	State	NNP
8691	1744	28	may	may	MD
8691	1744	29	decline	decline	VB
8691	1744	30	to	to	TO
8691	1744	31	permit	permit	VB
8691	1744	32	the	the	DT
8691	1744	33	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	1744	34	of	of	IN
8691	1744	35	such	such	PDT
8691	1744	36	a	a	DT
8691	1744	37	power	power	NN
8691	1744	38	.	.	.
8691	1745	1	The	the	DT
8691	1745	2	United	United	NNP
8691	1745	3	States	States	NNP
8691	1745	4	can	can	MD
8691	1745	5	not	not	RB
8691	1745	6	in	in	IN
8691	1745	7	that	that	DT
8691	1745	8	manner	manner	NN
8691	1745	9	compel	compel	VBP
8691	1745	10	the	the	DT
8691	1745	11	courts	court	NNS
8691	1745	12	of	of	IN
8691	1745	13	another	another	DT
8691	1745	14	government	government	NN
8691	1745	15	to	to	TO
8691	1745	16	do	do	VB
8691	1745	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1745	18	bidding	bidding	NN
8691	1745	19	.	.	.
8691	1746	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1746	2	would	would	MD
8691	1746	3	tend	tend	VB
8691	1746	4	to	to	TO
8691	1746	5	throw	throw	VB
8691	1746	6	on	on	RP
8691	1746	7	the	the	DT
8691	1746	8	States	States	NNP
8691	1746	9	a	a	DT
8691	1746	10	greater	great	JJR
8691	1746	11	burden	burden	NN
8691	1746	12	than	than	IN
8691	1746	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1746	14	might	may	MD
8691	1746	15	deem	deem	VB
8691	1746	16	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1746	17	or	or	CC
8691	1746	18	proper	proper	JJ
8691	1746	19	.	.	.
8691	1747	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1747	2	provide	provide	VBP
8691	1747	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1747	4	to	to	TO
8691	1747	5	meet	meet	VB
8691	1747	6	the	the	DT
8691	1747	7	wants	want	NNS
8691	1747	8	of	of	IN
8691	1747	9	those	those	DT
8691	1747	10	looking	look	VBG
8691	1747	11	to	to	IN
8691	1747	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1747	13	own	own	JJ
8691	1747	14	sovereignties	sovereignty	NNS
8691	1747	15	for	for	IN
8691	1747	16	justice	justice	NN
8691	1747	17	.	.	.
8691	1748	1	Thus	thus	RB
8691	1748	2	,	,	,
8691	1748	3	although	although	IN
8691	1748	4	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	1748	5	could	could	MD
8691	1748	6	seem	seem	VB
8691	1748	7	more	more	RBR
8691	1748	8	anomalous	anomalous	JJ
8691	1748	9	than	than	IN
8691	1748	10	for	for	IN
8691	1748	11	one	one	CD
8691	1748	12	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1748	13	to	to	TO
8691	1748	14	confer	confer	VB
8691	1748	15	citizenship	citizenship	NN
8691	1748	16	in	in	IN
8691	1748	17	another	another	DT
8691	1748	18	,	,	,
8691	1748	19	the	the	DT
8691	1748	20	laws	law	NNS
8691	1748	21	of	of	IN
8691	1748	22	the	the	DT
8691	1748	23	United	United	NNP
8691	1748	24	States	States	NNP
8691	1748	25	allow	allow	VBP
8691	1748	26	naturalization	naturalization	NN
8691	1748	27	to	to	TO
8691	1748	28	be	be	VB
8691	1748	29	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	1748	30	by	by	IN
8691	1748	31	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1748	32	in	in	IN
8691	1748	33	State	State	NNP
8691	1748	34	courts	court	NNS
8691	1748	35	.	.	.
8691	1749	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	1749	2	aliens	alien	NNS
8691	1749	3	who	who	WP
8691	1749	4	become	become	VBP
8691	1749	5	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1749	6	of	of	IN
8691	1749	7	the	the	DT
8691	1749	8	United	United	NNP
8691	1749	9	States	States	NNP
8691	1749	10	do	do	VBP
8691	1749	11	so	so	RB
8691	1749	12	in	in	IN
8691	1749	13	that	that	DT
8691	1749	14	way	way	NN
8691	1749	15	,	,	,
8691	1749	16	because	because	IN
8691	1749	17	the	the	DT
8691	1749	18	State	State	NNP
8691	1749	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	1749	20	are	be	VBP
8691	1749	21	more	more	RBR
8691	1749	22	easy	easy	JJ
8691	1749	23	of	of	IN
8691	1749	24	access	access	NN
8691	1749	25	.	.	.
8691	1750	1	But	but	CC
8691	1750	2	a	a	DT
8691	1750	3	State	state	NN
8691	1750	4	can	can	MD
8691	1750	5	at	at	IN
8691	1750	6	any	any	DT
8691	1750	7	time	time	NN
8691	1750	8	restrict	restrict	VB
8691	1750	9	or	or	CC
8691	1750	10	forbid	forbid	VB
8691	1750	11	the	the	DT
8691	1750	12	use	use	NN
8691	1750	13	of	of	IN
8691	1750	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1750	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	1750	16	for	for	IN
8691	1750	17	such	such	PDT
8691	1750	18	a	a	DT
8691	1750	19	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1750	20	.	.	.
8691	1751	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1751	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1751	3	:	:	:
8691	1751	4	Stephens	Stephens	NNP
8691	1751	5	,	,	,
8691	1751	6	petitioner	petitioner	NN
8691	1751	7	,	,	,
8691	1751	8	4	4	CD
8691	1751	9	Gray	Gray	NNP
8691	1751	10	's	's	POS
8691	1751	11	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1751	12	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	1751	13	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1752	1	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1752	2	,	,	,
8691	1752	3	559	559	CD
8691	1752	4	;	;	:
8691	1752	5	State	State	NNP
8691	1752	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1752	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	1752	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1752	9	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	1752	10	,	,	,
8691	1752	11	58	58	CD
8691	1752	12	N.	n.	NN
8691	1752	13	J.	j.	NN
8691	1753	1	Law	Law	NNP
8691	1753	2	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1753	3	,	,	,
8691	1753	4	97	97	CD
8691	1753	5	;	;	:
8691	1753	6	32	32	CD
8691	1753	7	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	1753	8	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	1753	9	,	,	,
8691	1753	10	743	743	CD
8691	1753	11	.	.	.
8691	1753	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1754	1	The	the	DT
8691	1754	2	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1754	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1754	4	can	can	MD
8691	1754	5	lend	lend	VB
8691	1754	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1754	7	aid	aid	NN
8691	1754	8	to	to	TO
8691	1754	9	carry	carry	VB
8691	1754	10	into	into	IN
8691	1754	11	effect	effect	NN
8691	1754	12	a	a	DT
8691	1754	13	right	right	NN
8691	1754	14	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1754	15	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	1754	16	from	from	IN
8691	1754	17	the	the	DT
8691	1754	18	statute	statute	NN
8691	1754	19	of	of	IN
8691	1754	20	a	a	DT
8691	1754	21	State	State	NNP
8691	1754	22	,	,	,
8691	1754	23	even	even	RB
8691	1754	24	if	if	IN
8691	1754	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1754	26	affect	affect	VBP
8691	1754	27	maritime	maritime	JJ
8691	1754	28	interests	interest	NNS
8691	1754	29	and	and	CC
8691	1754	30	must	must	MD
8691	1754	31	be	be	VB
8691	1754	32	enforced	enforce	VBN
8691	1754	33	,	,	,
8691	1754	34	if	if	IN
8691	1754	35	at	at	RB
8691	1754	36	all	all	RB
8691	1754	37	,	,	,
8691	1754	38	through	through	IN
8691	1754	39	an	an	DT
8691	1754	40	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	1754	41	court	court	NN
8691	1754	42	.	.	.
8691	1755	1	Admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	1755	2	suits	suit	NNS
8691	1755	3	,	,	,
8691	1755	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1755	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	1755	6	true	true	JJ
8691	1755	7	,	,	,
8691	1755	8	can	can	MD
8691	1755	9	only	only	RB
8691	1755	10	be	be	VB
8691	1755	11	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1755	12	in	in	IN
8691	1755	13	the	the	DT
8691	1755	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	1755	15	of	of	IN
8691	1755	16	the	the	DT
8691	1755	17	United	United	NNP
8691	1755	18	States	States	NNP
8691	1755	19	,	,	,
8691	1755	20	but	but	CC
8691	1755	21	that	that	DT
8691	1755	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	1755	23	the	the	DT
8691	1755	24	very	very	JJ
8691	1755	25	reason	reason	NN
8691	1755	26	why	why	WRB
8691	1755	27	,	,	,
8691	1755	28	if	if	IN
8691	1755	29	such	such	PDT
8691	1755	30	a	a	DT
8691	1755	31	suit	suit	NN
8691	1755	32	gives	give	VBZ
8691	1755	33	the	the	DT
8691	1755	34	only	only	JJ
8691	1755	35	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1755	36	,	,	,
8691	1755	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1755	38	of	of	IN
8691	1755	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1755	40	should	should	MD
8691	1755	41	be	be	VB
8691	1755	42	entertained	entertain	VBN
8691	1755	43	in	in	IN
8691	1755	44	the	the	DT
8691	1755	45	only	only	JJ
8691	1755	46	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1755	47	competent	competent	JJ
8691	1755	48	to	to	TO
8691	1755	49	give	give	VB
8691	1755	50	relief	relief	NN
8691	1755	51	.	.	.
8691	1756	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1756	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1756	3	:	:	:
8691	1756	4	The	the	DT
8691	1756	5	Lottawanna	Lottawanna	NNP
8691	1756	6	,	,	,
8691	1756	7	21	21	CD
8691	1756	8	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	1756	9	's	's	POS
8691	1756	10	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1756	11	,	,	,
8691	1756	12	558	558	CD
8691	1756	13	,	,	,
8691	1756	14	580	580	CD
8691	1756	15	.	.	.
8691	1756	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1757	1	There	there	EX
8691	1757	2	are	be	VBP
8691	1757	3	many	many	JJ
8691	1757	4	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1757	5	cases	case	NNS
8691	1757	6	which	which	WDT
8691	1757	7	can	can	MD
8691	1757	8	be	be	VB
8691	1757	9	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1757	10	,	,	,
8691	1757	11	at	at	IN
8691	1757	12	the	the	DT
8691	1757	13	option	option	NN
8691	1757	14	of	of	IN
8691	1757	15	the	the	DT
8691	1757	16	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1757	17	,	,	,
8691	1757	18	either	either	CC
8691	1757	19	in	in	IN
8691	1757	20	a	a	DT
8691	1757	21	court	court	NN
8691	1757	22	of	of	IN
8691	1757	23	the	the	DT
8691	1757	24	United	United	NNP
8691	1757	25	States	States	NNP
8691	1757	26	or	or	CC
8691	1757	27	in	in	IN
8691	1757	28	a	a	DT
8691	1757	29	State	State	NNP
8691	1757	30	court	court	NN
8691	1757	31	.	.	.
8691	1758	1	Some	some	DT
8691	1758	2	of	of	IN
8691	1758	3	these	these	DT
8691	1758	4	,	,	,
8691	1758	5	if	if	IN
8691	1758	6	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1758	7	in	in	RP
8691	1758	8	a	a	DT
8691	1758	9	State	State	NNP
8691	1758	10	court	court	NN
8691	1758	11	,	,	,
8691	1758	12	the	the	DT
8691	1758	13	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	1758	14	can	can	MD
8691	1758	15	,	,	,
8691	1758	16	at	at	IN
8691	1758	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1758	18	option	option	NN
8691	1758	19	,	,	,
8691	1758	20	allow	allow	VB
8691	1758	21	to	to	TO
8691	1758	22	remain	remain	VB
8691	1758	23	there	there	RB
8691	1758	24	or	or	CC
8691	1758	25	remove	remove	VB
8691	1758	26	for	for	IN
8691	1758	27	trial	trial	NN
8691	1758	28	into	into	IN
8691	1758	29	the	the	DT
8691	1758	30	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1758	31	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1758	32	of	of	IN
8691	1758	33	the	the	DT
8691	1758	34	United	United	NNP
8691	1758	35	States	States	NNP
8691	1758	36	.	.	.
8691	1759	1	Criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1759	2	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	1759	3	by	by	IN
8691	1759	4	a	a	DT
8691	1759	5	State	state	NN
8691	1759	6	may	may	MD
8691	1759	7	also	also	RB
8691	1759	8	be	be	VB
8691	1759	9	removed	remove	VBN
8691	1759	10	,	,	,
8691	1759	11	under	under	IN
8691	1759	12	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1759	13	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	1759	14	,	,	,
8691	1759	15	to	to	IN
8691	1759	16	the	the	DT
8691	1759	17	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1759	18	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1759	19	of	of	IN
8691	1759	20	the	the	DT
8691	1759	21	United	United	NNP
8691	1759	22	States	States	NNP
8691	1759	23	,	,	,
8691	1759	24	when	when	WRB
8691	1759	25	the	the	DT
8691	1759	26	defense	defense	NN
8691	1759	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	1759	28	one	one	NN
8691	1759	29	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1759	30	under	under	IN
8691	1759	31	the	the	DT
8691	1759	32	laws	law	NNS
8691	1759	33	of	of	IN
8691	1759	34	the	the	DT
8691	1759	35	United	United	NNP
8691	1759	36	States	States	NNP
8691	1759	37	.	.	.
8691	1760	1	In	in	IN
8691	1760	2	any	any	DT
8691	1760	3	cause	cause	NN
8691	1760	4	tried	try	VBN
8691	1760	5	in	in	IN
8691	1760	6	a	a	DT
8691	1760	7	State	State	NNP
8691	1760	8	court	court	NN
8691	1760	9	,	,	,
8691	1760	10	if	if	IN
8691	1760	11	the	the	DT
8691	1760	12	decision	decision	NN
8691	1760	13	turns	turn	VBZ
8691	1760	14	on	on	IN
8691	1760	15	a	a	DT
8691	1760	16	claim	claim	NN
8691	1760	17	of	of	IN
8691	1760	18	right	right	NN
8691	1760	19	,	,	,
8691	1760	20	set	set	VBN
8691	1760	21	up	up	RP
8691	1760	22	under	under	IN
8691	1760	23	the	the	DT
8691	1760	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1760	25	,	,	,
8691	1760	26	laws	law	NNS
8691	1760	27	or	or	CC
8691	1760	28	treaties	treaty	NNS
8691	1760	29	of	of	IN
8691	1760	30	the	the	DT
8691	1760	31	United	United	NNP
8691	1760	32	States	States	NNP
8691	1760	33	,	,	,
8691	1760	34	and	and	CC
8691	1760	35	is	be	VBZ
8691	1760	36	against	against	IN
8691	1760	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1760	38	validity	validity	NN
8691	1760	39	,	,	,
8691	1760	40	the	the	DT
8691	1760	41	losing	lose	VBG
8691	1760	42	party	party	NN
8691	1760	43	,	,	,
8691	1760	44	if	if	IN
8691	1760	45	unable	unable	JJ
8691	1760	46	to	to	TO
8691	1760	47	secure	secure	VB
8691	1760	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1760	49	reversal	reversal	NN
8691	1760	50	by	by	IN
8691	1760	51	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1760	52	to	to	IN
8691	1760	53	a	a	DT
8691	1760	54	higher	high	JJR
8691	1760	55	court	court	NN
8691	1760	56	of	of	IN
8691	1760	57	the	the	DT
8691	1760	58	State	State	NNP
8691	1760	59	,	,	,
8691	1760	60	can	can	MD
8691	1760	61	ask	ask	VB
8691	1760	62	such	such	JJ
8691	1760	63	relief	relief	NN
8691	1760	64	from	from	IN
8691	1760	65	the	the	DT
8691	1760	66	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1760	67	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1760	68	of	of	IN
8691	1760	69	the	the	DT
8691	1760	70	United	United	NNP
8691	1760	71	States	States	NNP
8691	1760	72	.	.	.
8691	1761	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1761	2	will	will	MD
8691	1761	3	be	be	VB
8691	1761	4	observed	observe	VBN
8691	1761	5	that	that	IN
8691	1761	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1761	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1761	8	the	the	DT
8691	1761	9	losing	lose	VBG
8691	1761	10	party	party	NN
8691	1761	11	only	only	RB
8691	1761	12	who	who	WP
8691	1761	13	has	have	VBZ
8691	1761	14	this	this	DT
8691	1761	15	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1761	16	.	.	.
8691	1762	1	If	if	IN
8691	1762	2	the	the	DT
8691	1762	3	State	State	NNP
8691	1762	4	court	court	NN
8691	1762	5	decides	decide	VBZ
8691	1762	6	,	,	,
8691	1762	7	however	however	RB
8691	1762	8	erroneously	erroneously	RB
8691	1762	9	,	,	,
8691	1762	10	that	that	IN
8691	1762	11	the	the	DT
8691	1762	12	claim	claim	NN
8691	1762	13	of	of	IN
8691	1762	14	a	a	DT
8691	1762	15	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1762	16	right	right	NN
8691	1762	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	1762	18	well	well	RB
8691	1762	19	grounded	ground	VBN
8691	1762	20	,	,	,
8691	1762	21	this	this	DT
8691	1762	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	1762	23	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	1762	24	as	as	IN
8691	1762	25	respects	respect	NNS
8691	1762	26	the	the	DT
8691	1762	27	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	1762	28	in	in	IN
8691	1762	29	that	that	DT
8691	1762	30	suit	suit	NN
8691	1762	31	.	.	.
8691	1763	1	If	if	IN
8691	1763	2	all	all	DT
8691	1763	3	State	State	NNP
8691	1763	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	1763	5	in	in	IN
8691	1763	6	which	which	WDT
8691	1763	7	the	the	DT
8691	1763	8	validity	validity	NN
8691	1763	9	of	of	IN
8691	1763	10	an	an	DT
8691	1763	11	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1763	12	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1763	13	of	of	IN
8691	1763	14	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1763	15	was	be	VBD
8691	1763	16	contested	contest	VBN
8691	1763	17	should	should	MD
8691	1763	18	uphold	uphold	VB
8691	1763	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1763	20	,	,	,
8691	1763	21	the	the	DT
8691	1763	22	courts	court	NNS
8691	1763	23	of	of	IN
8691	1763	24	the	the	DT
8691	1763	25	United	United	NNP
8691	1763	26	States	States	NNP
8691	1763	27	would	would	MD
8691	1763	28	be	be	VB
8691	1763	29	powerless	powerless	JJ
8691	1763	30	to	to	TO
8691	1763	31	right	right	VB
8691	1763	32	the	the	DT
8691	1763	33	wrong	wrong	NN
8691	1763	34	,	,	,
8691	1763	35	unless	unless	IN
8691	1763	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1763	37	were	be	VBD
8691	1763	38	called	call	VBN
8691	1763	39	upon	upon	IN
8691	1763	40	to	to	TO
8691	1763	41	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1763	42	the	the	DT
8691	1763	43	statute	statute	NN
8691	1763	44	in	in	IN
8691	1763	45	some	some	DT
8691	1763	46	suit	suit	NN
8691	1763	47	brought	bring	VBD
8691	1763	48	before	before	IN
8691	1763	49	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1763	50	for	for	IN
8691	1763	51	original	original	JJ
8691	1763	52	trial	trial	NN
8691	1763	53	.	.	.
8691	1764	1	The	the	DT
8691	1764	2	obvious	obvious	JJ
8691	1764	3	object	object	NN
8691	1764	4	of	of	IN
8691	1764	5	the	the	DT
8691	1764	6	limitation	limitation	NN
8691	1764	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1764	8	to	to	TO
8691	1764	9	preserve	preserve	VB
8691	1764	10	so	so	RB
8691	1764	11	far	far	RB
8691	1764	12	as	as	IN
8691	1764	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	1764	14	possible	possible	JJ
8691	1764	15	the	the	DT
8691	1764	16	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1764	17	of	of	IN
8691	1764	18	the	the	DT
8691	1764	19	States	States	NNPS
8691	1764	20	.	.	.
8691	1765	1	The	the	DT
8691	1765	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1765	3	of	of	IN
8691	1765	4	the	the	DT
8691	1765	5	nation	nation	NN
8691	1765	6	are	be	VBP
8691	1765	7	to	to	TO
8691	1765	8	set	set	VB
8691	1765	9	aside	aside	RB
8691	1765	10	acts	act	NNS
8691	1765	11	or	or	CC
8691	1765	12	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1765	13	flowing	flow	VBG
8691	1765	14	from	from	IN
8691	1765	15	that	that	DT
8691	1765	16	only	only	RB
8691	1765	17	in	in	IN
8691	1765	18	case	case	NN
8691	1765	19	of	of	IN
8691	1765	20	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	1765	21	and	and	CC
8691	1765	22	to	to	TO
8691	1765	23	preserve	preserve	VB
8691	1765	24	rights	right	NNS
8691	1765	25	flowing	flow	VBG
8691	1765	26	from	from	IN
8691	1765	27	the	the	DT
8691	1765	28	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1765	29	of	of	IN
8691	1765	30	the	the	DT
8691	1765	31	nation	nation	NN
8691	1765	32	.	.	.
8691	1766	1	For	for	IN
8691	1766	2	the	the	DT
8691	1766	3	same	same	JJ
8691	1766	4	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	1766	5	,	,	,
8691	1766	6	resort	resort	NN
8691	1766	7	can	can	MD
8691	1766	8	be	be	VB
8691	1766	9	had	have	VBN
8691	1766	10	to	to	IN
8691	1766	11	the	the	DT
8691	1766	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1766	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1766	14	of	of	IN
8691	1766	15	the	the	DT
8691	1766	16	United	United	NNP
8691	1766	17	States	States	NNP
8691	1766	18	only	only	RB
8691	1766	19	after	after	IN
8691	1766	20	every	every	DT
8691	1766	21	right	right	NN
8691	1766	22	of	of	IN
8691	1766	23	review	review	NN
8691	1766	24	given	give	VBN
8691	1766	25	by	by	IN
8691	1766	26	the	the	DT
8691	1766	27	laws	law	NNS
8691	1766	28	of	of	IN
8691	1766	29	the	the	DT
8691	1766	30	State	State	NNP
8691	1766	31	has	have	VBZ
8691	1766	32	been	be	VBN
8691	1766	33	exhausted	exhaust	VBN
8691	1766	34	.	.	.
8691	1767	1	Usually	usually	RB
8691	1767	2	this	this	DT
8691	1767	3	requires	require	VBZ
8691	1767	4	one	one	NN
8691	1767	5	who	who	WP
8691	1767	6	loses	lose	VBZ
8691	1767	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1767	8	cause	cause	NN
8691	1767	9	in	in	IN
8691	1767	10	a	a	DT
8691	1767	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	1767	12	court	court	NN
8691	1767	13	to	to	TO
8691	1767	14	take	take	VB
8691	1767	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1767	16	up	up	RP
8691	1767	17	to	to	IN
8691	1767	18	the	the	DT
8691	1767	19	State	State	NNP
8691	1767	20	court	court	NN
8691	1767	21	of	of	IN
8691	1767	22	last	last	JJ
8691	1767	23	resort	resort	NN
8691	1767	24	.	.	.
8691	1768	1	Where	where	WRB
8691	1768	2	,	,	,
8691	1768	3	however	however	RB
8691	1768	4	,	,	,
8691	1768	5	this	this	DT
8691	1768	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1768	7	not	not	RB
8691	1768	8	permitted	permit	VBN
8691	1768	9	by	by	IN
8691	1768	10	the	the	DT
8691	1768	11	State	State	NNP
8691	1768	12	law	law	NN
8691	1768	13	,	,	,
8691	1768	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1768	15	may	may	MD
8691	1768	16	ask	ask	VB
8691	1768	17	for	for	IN
8691	1768	18	a	a	DT
8691	1768	19	writ	writ	NN
8691	1768	20	of	of	IN
8691	1768	21	error	error	NN
8691	1768	22	from	from	IN
8691	1768	23	the	the	DT
8691	1768	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1768	25	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1768	26	of	of	IN
8691	1768	27	the	the	DT
8691	1768	28	United	United	NNP
8691	1768	29	States	States	NNP
8691	1768	30	to	to	IN
8691	1768	31	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	1768	32	court	court	NN
8691	1768	33	was	be	VBD
8691	1768	34	the	the	DT
8691	1768	35	highest	high	JJS
8691	1768	36	to	to	TO
8691	1768	37	which	which	WDT
8691	1768	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1768	39	was	be	VBD
8691	1768	40	able	able	JJ
8691	1768	41	to	to	TO
8691	1768	42	remove	remove	VB
8691	1768	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1768	44	;	;	:
8691	1768	45	and	and	CC
8691	1768	46	if	if	IN
8691	1768	47	,	,	,
8691	1768	48	by	by	IN
8691	1768	49	the	the	DT
8691	1768	50	State	State	NNP
8691	1768	51	law	law	NN
8691	1768	52	,	,	,
8691	1768	53	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1768	54	was	be	VBD
8691	1768	55	unable	unable	JJ
8691	1768	56	to	to	TO
8691	1768	57	appeal	appeal	VB
8691	1768	58	at	at	RB
8691	1768	59	all	all	RB
8691	1768	60	,	,	,
8691	1768	61	then	then	RB
8691	1768	62	the	the	DT
8691	1768	63	writ	writ	NNP
8691	1768	64	will	will	MD
8691	1768	65	go	go	VB
8691	1768	66	to	to	IN
8691	1768	67	the	the	DT
8691	1768	68	trial	trial	NN
8691	1768	69	court	court	NN
8691	1768	70	.	.	.
8691	1769	1	One	one	CD
8691	1769	2	of	of	IN
8691	1769	3	the	the	DT
8691	1769	4	greatest	great	JJS
8691	1769	5	of	of	IN
8691	1769	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1769	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1769	8	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1769	9	's	's	POS
8691	1769	10	great	great	JJ
8691	1769	11	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	1769	12	was	be	VBD
8691	1769	13	rendered	render	VBN
8691	1769	14	on	on	IN
8691	1769	15	a	a	DT
8691	1769	16	writ	writ	NN
8691	1769	17	of	of	IN
8691	1769	18	error	error	NN
8691	1769	19	to	to	IN
8691	1769	20	the	the	DT
8691	1769	21	quarterly	quarterly	JJ
8691	1769	22	session	session	NN
8691	1769	23	court	court	NN
8691	1769	24	for	for	IN
8691	1769	25	the	the	DT
8691	1769	26	borough	borough	NN
8691	1769	27	of	of	IN
8691	1769	28	Norfolk	Norfolk	NNP
8691	1769	29	in	in	IN
8691	1769	30	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	1769	31	,	,	,
8691	1769	32	held	hold	VBN
8691	1769	33	by	by	IN
8691	1769	34	the	the	DT
8691	1769	35	mayor	mayor	NN
8691	1769	36	,	,	,
8691	1769	37	recorder	recorder	NN
8691	1769	38	,	,	,
8691	1769	39	and	and	CC
8691	1769	40	aldermen	aldermen	NNP
8691	1769	41	of	of	IN
8691	1769	42	the	the	DT
8691	1769	43	borough	borough	NN
8691	1769	44	.	.	.
8691	1770	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1770	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1770	3	:	:	:
8691	1770	4	Cohens	Cohens	NNP
8691	1770	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1770	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1770	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1770	8	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	1770	9	,	,	,
8691	1770	10	6	6	CD
8691	1770	11	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	1770	12	's	's	POS
8691	1770	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1770	14	,	,	,
8691	1770	15	264	264	CD
8691	1770	16	.	.	.
8691	1770	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1771	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1771	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1771	3	the	the	DT
8691	1771	4	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1771	5	of	of	IN
8691	1771	6	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
8691	1771	7	that	that	IN
8691	1771	8	an	an	DT
8691	1771	9	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1771	10	might	may	MD
8691	1771	11	be	be	VB
8691	1771	12	given	give	VBN
8691	1771	13	from	from	IN
8691	1771	14	the	the	DT
8691	1771	15	State	State	NNP
8691	1771	16	courts	court	NNS
8691	1771	17	to	to	IN
8691	1771	18	the	the	DT
8691	1771	19	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	1771	20	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1771	21	courts	court	NNS
8691	1771	22	,	,	,
8691	1771	23	in	in	IN
8691	1771	24	case	case	NN
8691	1771	25	of	of	IN
8691	1771	26	a	a	DT
8691	1771	27	decision	decision	NN
8691	1771	28	turning	turn	VBG
8691	1771	29	on	on	RP
8691	1771	30	a	a	DT
8691	1771	31	right	right	NN
8691	1771	32	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	1771	33	under	under	IN
8691	1771	34	the	the	DT
8691	1771	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1771	36	or	or	CC
8691	1771	37	laws	law	NNS
8691	1771	38	of	of	IN
8691	1771	39	the	the	DT
8691	1771	40	United	United	NNP
8691	1771	41	States	States	NNP
8691	1771	42	.	.	.
8691	1772	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1772	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1772	3	:	:	:
8691	1772	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1772	5	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
8691	1772	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1772	7	,	,	,
8691	1772	8	No	no	UH
8691	1772	9	.	.	.
8691	1773	1	LXXXII	lxxxii	NN
8691	1773	2	.	.	.
8691	1773	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1774	1	This	this	DT
8691	1774	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1774	3	probably	probably	RB
8691	1774	4	true	true	JJ
8691	1774	5	,	,	,
8691	1774	6	but	but	CC
8691	1774	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1774	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	1774	9	wisely	wisely	RB
8691	1774	10	forborne	forbear	VBN
8691	1774	11	to	to	TO
8691	1774	12	make	make	VB
8691	1774	13	any	any	DT
8691	1774	14	such	such	JJ
8691	1774	15	provision	provision	NN
8691	1774	16	.	.	.
8691	1775	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1775	2	imposes	impose	VBZ
8691	1775	3	a	a	DT
8691	1775	4	strain	strain	NN
8691	1775	5	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
8691	1775	6	great	great	JJ
8691	1775	7	on	on	IN
8691	1775	8	the	the	DT
8691	1775	9	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1775	10	of	of	IN
8691	1775	11	a	a	DT
8691	1775	12	State	State	NNP
8691	1775	13	to	to	TO
8691	1775	14	subject	subject	VB
8691	1775	15	the	the	DT
8691	1775	16	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1775	17	of	of	IN
8691	1775	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1775	19	court	court	NN
8691	1775	20	of	of	IN
8691	1775	21	last	last	JJ
8691	1775	22	resort	resort	NN
8691	1775	23	to	to	IN
8691	1775	24	reversal	reversal	NN
8691	1775	25	by	by	IN
8691	1775	26	the	the	DT
8691	1775	27	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1775	28	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1775	29	of	of	IN
8691	1775	30	the	the	DT
8691	1775	31	nation	nation	NN
8691	1775	32	.	.	.
8691	1776	1	The	the	DT
8691	1776	2	power	power	NN
8691	1776	3	to	to	TO
8691	1776	4	declare	declare	VB
8691	1776	5	a	a	DT
8691	1776	6	statute	statute	NN
8691	1776	7	void	void	NN
8691	1776	8	because	because	IN
8691	1776	9	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
8691	1776	10	with	with	IN
8691	1776	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1776	12	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	1776	13	belongs	belong	VBZ
8691	1776	14	to	to	IN
8691	1776	15	every	every	DT
8691	1776	16	court	court	NN
8691	1776	17	in	in	IN
8691	1776	18	every	every	DT
8691	1776	19	case	case	NN
8691	1776	20	in	in	IN
8691	1776	21	which	which	WDT
8691	1776	22	such	such	PDT
8691	1776	23	a	a	DT
8691	1776	24	statute	statute	NN
8691	1776	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	1776	26	relied	rely	VBN
8691	1776	27	on	on	IN
8691	1776	28	either	either	CC
8691	1776	29	to	to	TO
8691	1776	30	support	support	VB
8691	1776	31	the	the	DT
8691	1776	32	action	action	NN
8691	1776	33	or	or	CC
8691	1776	34	in	in	IN
8691	1776	35	defense	defense	NN
8691	1776	36	.	.	.
8691	1777	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1777	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1777	3	:	:	:
8691	1777	4	See	see	VB
8691	1777	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	1777	6	.	.	.
8691	1778	1	VII	VII	NNP
8691	1778	2	.	.	.
8691	1778	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1779	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1779	2	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1779	3	belongs	belong	VBZ
8691	1779	4	,	,	,
8691	1779	5	as	as	IN
8691	1779	6	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	1779	7	a	a	DT
8691	1779	8	State	State	NNP
8691	1779	9	statute	statute	NN
8691	1779	10	which	which	WDT
8691	1779	11	may	may	MD
8691	1779	12	be	be	VB
8691	1779	13	attacked	attack	VBN
8691	1779	14	as	as	IN
8691	1779	15	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
8691	1779	16	with	with	IN
8691	1779	17	the	the	DT
8691	1779	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1779	19	of	of	IN
8691	1779	20	the	the	DT
8691	1779	21	United	United	NNP
8691	1779	22	States	States	NNP
8691	1779	23	,	,	,
8691	1779	24	to	to	IN
8691	1779	25	the	the	DT
8691	1779	26	trial	trial	NN
8691	1779	27	courts	court	NNS
8691	1779	28	of	of	IN
8691	1779	29	the	the	DT
8691	1779	30	United	United	NNP
8691	1779	31	States	States	NNP
8691	1779	32	as	as	RB
8691	1779	33	well	well	RB
8691	1779	34	as	as	IN
8691	1779	35	to	to	IN
8691	1779	36	the	the	DT
8691	1779	37	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1779	38	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1779	39	.	.	.
8691	1780	1	This	this	DT
8691	1780	2	makes	make	VBZ
8691	1780	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1780	4	possible	possible	JJ
8691	1780	5	for	for	IN
8691	1780	6	a	a	DT
8691	1780	7	District	District	NNP
8691	1780	8	or	or	CC
8691	1780	9	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1780	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1780	11	of	of	IN
8691	1780	12	the	the	DT
8691	1780	13	United	United	NNP
8691	1780	14	States	States	NNP
8691	1780	15	to	to	TO
8691	1780	16	adjudge	adjudge	VB
8691	1780	17	the	the	DT
8691	1780	18	statute	statute	NN
8691	1780	19	of	of	IN
8691	1780	20	a	a	DT
8691	1780	21	State	State	NNP
8691	1780	22	in	in	IN
8691	1780	23	which	which	WDT
8691	1780	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1780	25	sits	sit	VBZ
8691	1780	26	to	to	TO
8691	1780	27	be	be	VB
8691	1780	28	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1780	29	and	and	CC
8691	1780	30	void	void	JJ
8691	1780	31	,	,	,
8691	1780	32	although	although	IN
8691	1780	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1780	34	may	may	MD
8691	1780	35	have	have	VB
8691	1780	36	been	be	VBN
8691	1780	37	declared	declare	VBN
8691	1780	38	valid	valid	JJ
8691	1780	39	by	by	IN
8691	1780	40	a	a	DT
8691	1780	41	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1780	42	of	of	IN
8691	1780	43	the	the	DT
8691	1780	44	highest	high	JJS
8691	1780	45	court	court	NN
8691	1780	46	of	of	IN
8691	1780	47	the	the	DT
8691	1780	48	State	State	NNP
8691	1780	49	,	,	,
8691	1780	50	from	from	IN
8691	1780	51	which	which	WDT
8691	1780	52	no	no	DT
8691	1780	53	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1780	54	to	to	IN
8691	1780	55	the	the	DT
8691	1780	56	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1780	57	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1780	58	of	of	IN
8691	1780	59	the	the	DT
8691	1780	60	United	United	NNP
8691	1780	61	States	States	NNP
8691	1780	62	was	be	VBD
8691	1780	63	ever	ever	RB
8691	1780	64	taken	take	VBN
8691	1780	65	.	.	.
8691	1781	1	However	however	RB
8691	1781	2	derogatory	derogatory	JJ
8691	1781	3	to	to	IN
8691	1781	4	the	the	DT
8691	1781	5	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1781	6	of	of	IN
8691	1781	7	the	the	DT
8691	1781	8	States	state	NNS
8691	1781	9	the	the	DT
8691	1781	10	possession	possession	NN
8691	1781	11	of	of	IN
8691	1781	12	such	such	JJ
8691	1781	13	authority	authority	NN
8691	1781	14	may	may	MD
8691	1781	15	seem	seem	VB
8691	1781	16	and	and	CC
8691	1781	17	be	be	VB
8691	1781	18	,	,	,
8691	1781	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1781	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	1781	21	evidently	evidently	RB
8691	1781	22	a	a	DT
8691	1781	23	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1781	24	feature	feature	NN
8691	1781	25	of	of	IN
8691	1781	26	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1781	27	dual	dual	JJ
8691	1781	28	system	system	NN
8691	1781	29	of	of	IN
8691	1781	30	government	government	NN
8691	1781	31	.	.	.
8691	1782	1	In	in	IN
8691	1782	2	some	some	DT
8691	1782	3	way	way	NN
8691	1782	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1782	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1782	6	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
8691	1782	7	to	to	TO
8691	1782	8	provide	provide	VB
8691	1782	9	for	for	IN
8691	1782	10	maintaining	maintain	VBG
8691	1782	11	the	the	DT
8691	1782	12	full	full	JJ
8691	1782	13	powers	power	NNS
8691	1782	14	of	of	IN
8691	1782	15	the	the	DT
8691	1782	16	United	United	NNP
8691	1782	17	States	States	NNP
8691	1782	18	against	against	IN
8691	1782	19	encroachments	encroachment	NNS
8691	1782	20	by	by	IN
8691	1782	21	State	State	NNP
8691	1782	22	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	1782	23	,	,	,
8691	1782	24	and	and	CC
8691	1782	25	also	also	RB
8691	1782	26	for	for	IN
8691	1782	27	enforcing	enforce	VBG
8691	1782	28	all	all	PDT
8691	1782	29	the	the	DT
8691	1782	30	special	special	JJ
8691	1782	31	limitations	limitation	NNS
8691	1782	32	on	on	IN
8691	1782	33	the	the	DT
8691	1782	34	powers	power	NNS
8691	1782	35	of	of	IN
8691	1782	36	State	State	NNP
8691	1782	37	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	1782	38	which	which	WDT
8691	1782	39	the	the	DT
8691	1782	40	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1782	41	of	of	IN
8691	1782	42	the	the	DT
8691	1782	43	United	United	NNP
8691	1782	44	States	States	NNP
8691	1782	45	lays	lay	VBZ
8691	1782	46	down	down	RP
8691	1782	47	.	.	.
8691	1783	1	This	this	DT
8691	1783	2	could	could	MD
8691	1783	3	have	have	VB
8691	1783	4	been	be	VBN
8691	1783	5	done	do	VBN
8691	1783	6	effectually	effectually	RB
8691	1783	7	in	in	IN
8691	1783	8	but	but	CC
8691	1783	9	two	two	CD
8691	1783	10	ways	way	NNS
8691	1783	11	:	:	:
8691	1783	12	either	either	CC
8691	1783	13	by	by	IN
8691	1783	14	giving	give	VBG
8691	1783	15	to	to	IN
8691	1783	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1783	17	or	or	CC
8691	1783	18	to	to	IN
8691	1783	19	the	the	DT
8691	1783	20	President	President	NNP
8691	1783	21	a	a	DT
8691	1783	22	veto	veto	NN
8691	1783	23	upon	upon	IN
8691	1783	24	State	State	NNP
8691	1783	25	laws	law	NNS
8691	1783	26	;	;	,
8691	1783	27	or	or	CC
8691	1783	28	by	by	IN
8691	1783	29	leaving	leave	VBG
8691	1783	30	the	the	DT
8691	1783	31	right	right	NN
8691	1783	32	of	of	IN
8691	1783	33	control	control	NN
8691	1783	34	to	to	TO
8691	1783	35	lie	lie	VB
8691	1783	36	dormant	dormant	JJ
8691	1783	37	until	until	IN
8691	1783	38	a	a	DT
8691	1783	39	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	1783	40	for	for	IN
8691	1783	41	exercising	exercise	VBG
8691	1783	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1783	43	should	should	MD
8691	1783	44	arise	arise	VB
8691	1783	45	,	,	,
8691	1783	46	and	and	CC
8691	1783	47	then	then	RB
8691	1783	48	putting	put	VBG
8691	1783	49	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1783	50	in	in	IN
8691	1783	51	the	the	DT
8691	1783	52	hands	hand	NNS
8691	1783	53	of	of	IN
8691	1783	54	the	the	DT
8691	1783	55	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	1783	56	.	.	.
8691	1784	1	The	the	DT
8691	1784	2	latter	latter	JJ
8691	1784	3	method	method	NN
8691	1784	4	was	be	VBD
8691	1784	5	clearly	clearly	RB
8691	1784	6	open	open	JJ
8691	1784	7	to	to	IN
8691	1784	8	the	the	DT
8691	1784	9	least	least	JJS
8691	1784	10	objection	objection	NN
8691	1784	11	.	.	.
8691	1785	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1785	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1785	3	:	:	:
8691	1785	4	See	see	VB
8691	1785	5	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
8691	1785	6	's	's	POS
8691	1785	7	discussion	discussion	NN
8691	1785	8	on	on	IN
8691	1785	9	this	this	DT
8691	1785	10	point	point	NN
8691	1785	11	in	in	IN
8691	1785	12	the	the	DT
8691	1785	13	_	_	NNP
8691	1785	14	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
8691	1785	15	_	_	NNP
8691	1785	16	,	,	,
8691	1785	17	No	no	UH
8691	1785	18	.	.	.
8691	1786	1	LXXX	LXXX	NNP
8691	1786	2	.	.	.
8691	1786	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1787	1	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	1787	2	maintained	maintain	VBD
8691	1787	3	that	that	IN
8691	1787	4	there	there	EX
8691	1787	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1787	6	a	a	DT
8691	1787	7	third	third	JJ
8691	1787	8	,	,	,
8691	1787	9	and	and	CC
8691	1787	10	one	one	CD
8691	1787	11	which	which	WDT
8691	1787	12	the	the	DT
8691	1787	13	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1787	14	expressly	expressly	RB
8691	1787	15	provided	provide	VBN
8691	1787	16	.	.	.
8691	1788	1	This	this	DT
8691	1788	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1788	3	the	the	DT
8691	1788	4	calling	calling	NN
8691	1788	5	of	of	IN
8691	1788	6	a	a	DT
8691	1788	7	convention	convention	NN
8691	1788	8	of	of	IN
8691	1788	9	all	all	PDT
8691	1788	10	the	the	DT
8691	1788	11	States	States	NNPS
8691	1788	12	for	for	IN
8691	1788	13	proposing	propose	VBG
8691	1788	14	amendments	amendment	NNS
8691	1788	15	to	to	IN
8691	1788	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1788	17	.	.	.
8691	1789	1	If	if	IN
8691	1789	2	,	,	,
8691	1789	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1789	4	said	say	VBD
8691	1789	5	,	,	,
8691	1789	6	a	a	DT
8691	1789	7	State	state	NN
8691	1789	8	on	on	IN
8691	1789	9	the	the	DT
8691	1789	10	one	one	CD
8691	1789	11	hand	hand	NN
8691	1789	12	by	by	IN
8691	1789	13	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1789	14	highest	high	JJS
8691	1789	15	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	1789	16	asserts	assert	VBZ
8691	1789	17	a	a	DT
8691	1789	18	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1789	19	line	line	NN
8691	1789	20	of	of	IN
8691	1789	21	action	action	NN
8691	1789	22	to	to	TO
8691	1789	23	be	be	VB
8691	1789	24	within	within	IN
8691	1789	25	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1789	26	powers	power	NNS
8691	1789	27	,	,	,
8691	1789	28	and	and	CC
8691	1789	29	the	the	DT
8691	1789	30	United	United	NNP
8691	1789	31	States	States	NNP
8691	1789	32	by	by	IN
8691	1789	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1789	34	highest	high	JJS
8691	1789	35	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	1789	36	deny	deny	VBP
8691	1789	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1789	38	,	,	,
8691	1789	39	"	"	''
8691	1789	40	the	the	DT
8691	1789	41	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
8691	1789	42	arbiter	arbiter	NN
8691	1789	43	is	be	VBZ
8691	1789	44	the	the	DT
8691	1789	45	people	people	NNS
8691	1789	46	of	of	IN
8691	1789	47	the	the	DT
8691	1789	48	Union	Union	NNP
8691	1789	49	,	,	,
8691	1789	50	assembled	assemble	VBN
8691	1789	51	by	by	IN
8691	1789	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1789	53	deputies	deputy	NNS
8691	1789	54	in	in	IN
8691	1789	55	convention	convention	NN
8691	1789	56	,	,	,
8691	1789	57	at	at	IN
8691	1789	58	the	the	DT
8691	1789	59	call	call	NN
8691	1789	60	of	of	IN
8691	1789	61	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1789	62	,	,	,
8691	1789	63	or	or	CC
8691	1789	64	of	of	IN
8691	1789	65	two	two	CD
8691	1789	66	-	-	HYPH
8691	1789	67	thirds	third	NNS
8691	1789	68	of	of	IN
8691	1789	69	the	the	DT
8691	1789	70	States	States	NNPS
8691	1789	71	.	.	.
8691	1790	1	Let	let	VB
8691	1790	2	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1790	3	decide	decide	VB
8691	1790	4	to	to	TO
8691	1790	5	which	which	WDT
8691	1790	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1790	7	mean	mean	VBP
8691	1790	8	to	to	TO
8691	1790	9	give	give	VB
8691	1790	10	an	an	DT
8691	1790	11	authority	authority	NN
8691	1790	12	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	1790	13	by	by	IN
8691	1790	14	two	two	CD
8691	1790	15	of	of	IN
8691	1790	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1790	17	organs	organ	NNS
8691	1790	18	.	.	.
8691	1791	1	"	"	``
8691	1791	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1791	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1791	4	:	:	:
8691	1791	5	Letter	letter	NN
8691	1791	6	to	to	IN
8691	1791	7	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1791	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1791	9	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	1791	10	,	,	,
8691	1791	11	Tucker	Tucker	NNP
8691	1791	12	,	,	,
8691	1791	13	"	"	``
8691	1791	14	Life	life	NN
8691	1791	15	of	of	IN
8691	1791	16	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
8691	1791	17	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	1791	18	,	,	,
8691	1791	19	"	"	``
8691	1791	20	II	ii	CD
8691	1791	21	,	,	,
8691	1791	22	455	455	CD
8691	1791	23	.	.	.
8691	1791	24	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1792	1	There	there	EX
8691	1792	2	seems	seem	VBZ
8691	1792	3	a	a	DT
8691	1792	4	plain	plain	JJ
8691	1792	5	fallacy	fallacy	NN
8691	1792	6	in	in	IN
8691	1792	7	this	this	DT
8691	1792	8	proposition	proposition	NN
8691	1792	9	.	.	.
8691	1793	1	The	the	DT
8691	1793	2	question	question	NN
8691	1793	3	to	to	TO
8691	1793	4	be	be	VB
8691	1793	5	decided	decide	VBN
8691	1793	6	,	,	,
8691	1793	7	in	in	IN
8691	1793	8	case	case	NN
8691	1793	9	of	of	IN
8691	1793	10	a	a	DT
8691	1793	11	conflict	conflict	NN
8691	1793	12	of	of	IN
8691	1793	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1793	14	authority	authority	NN
8691	1793	15	,	,	,
8691	1793	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	1793	17	not	not	RB
8691	1793	18	which	which	WDT
8691	1793	19	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1793	20	ought	ought	MD
8691	1793	21	to	to	TO
8691	1793	22	be	be	VB
8691	1793	23	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1793	24	,	,	,
8691	1793	25	but	but	CC
8691	1793	26	which	which	WDT
8691	1793	27	was	be	VBD
8691	1793	28	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1793	29	when	when	WRB
8691	1793	30	the	the	DT
8691	1793	31	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1793	32	was	be	VBD
8691	1793	33	framed	frame	VBN
8691	1793	34	.	.	.
8691	1794	1	To	to	TO
8691	1794	2	amend	amend	VB
8691	1794	3	that	that	IN
8691	1794	4	instrument	instrument	NN
8691	1794	5	and	and	CC
8691	1794	6	make	make	VB
8691	1794	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1794	8	something	something	NN
8691	1794	9	else	else	RB
8691	1794	10	could	could	MD
8691	1794	11	not	not	RB
8691	1794	12	justly	justly	RB
8691	1794	13	be	be	VB
8691	1794	14	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	1794	15	to	to	TO
8691	1794	16	alter	alter	VB
8691	1794	17	the	the	DT
8691	1794	18	effect	effect	NN
8691	1794	19	of	of	IN
8691	1794	20	acts	act	NNS
8691	1794	21	previously	previously	RB
8691	1794	22	done	do	VBN
8691	1794	23	.	.	.
8691	1795	1	But	but	CC
8691	1795	2	one	one	CD
8691	1795	3	serious	serious	JJ
8691	1795	4	proposition	proposition	NN
8691	1795	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	1795	6	ever	ever	RB
8691	1795	7	been	be	VBN
8691	1795	8	made	make	VBN
8691	1795	9	to	to	TO
8691	1795	10	call	call	VB
8691	1795	11	a	a	DT
8691	1795	12	national	national	JJ
8691	1795	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	1795	14	convention	convention	NN
8691	1795	15	for	for	IN
8691	1795	16	any	any	DT
8691	1795	17	such	such	JJ
8691	1795	18	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1795	19	.	.	.
8691	1796	1	That	that	DT
8691	1796	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1796	3	by	by	IN
8691	1796	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	1796	5	in	in	IN
8691	1796	6	January	January	NNP
8691	1796	7	,	,	,
8691	1796	8	1861	1861	CD
8691	1796	9	,	,	,
8691	1796	10	when	when	WRB
8691	1796	11	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1796	12	war	war	NN
8691	1796	13	was	be	VBD
8691	1796	14	threatened	threaten	VBN
8691	1796	15	;	;	:
8691	1796	16	and	and	CC
8691	1796	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1796	18	was	be	VBD
8691	1796	19	not	not	RB
8691	1796	20	pressed	press	VBN
8691	1796	21	.	.	.
8691	1797	1	The	the	DT
8691	1797	2	very	very	JJ
8691	1797	3	delays	delay	NNS
8691	1797	4	which	which	WDT
8691	1797	5	would	would	MD
8691	1797	6	be	be	VB
8691	1797	7	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
8691	1797	8	in	in	IN
8691	1797	9	assembling	assemble	VBG
8691	1797	10	such	such	PDT
8691	1797	11	a	a	DT
8691	1797	12	body	body	NN
8691	1797	13	were	be	VBD
8691	1797	14	then	then	RB
8691	1797	15	a	a	DT
8691	1797	16	reason	reason	NN
8691	1797	17	for	for	IN
8691	1797	18	the	the	DT
8691	1797	19	call	call	NN
8691	1797	20	,	,	,
8691	1797	21	for	for	IN
8691	1797	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1797	23	would	would	MD
8691	1797	24	give	give	VB
8691	1797	25	time	time	NN
8691	1797	26	for	for	IN
8691	1797	27	the	the	DT
8691	1797	28	"	"	``
8691	1797	29	sober	sober	JJ
8691	1797	30	second	second	JJ
8691	1797	31	thought	thought	NN
8691	1797	32	.	.	.
8691	1797	33	"	"	''
8691	1798	1	The	the	DT
8691	1798	2	plan	plan	NN
8691	1798	3	,	,	,
8691	1798	4	however	however	RB
8691	1798	5	,	,	,
8691	1798	6	seemed	seem	VBD
8691	1798	7	and	and	CC
8691	1798	8	probably	probably	RB
8691	1798	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1798	10	impracticable	impracticable	JJ
8691	1798	11	.	.	.
8691	1799	1	The	the	DT
8691	1799	2	movement	movement	NN
8691	1799	3	toward	toward	IN
8691	1799	4	secession	secession	NN
8691	1799	5	had	have	VBD
8691	1799	6	gone	go	VBN
8691	1799	7	too	too	RB
8691	1799	8	far	far	RB
8691	1799	9	.	.	.
8691	1800	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1800	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1800	3	:	:	:
8691	1800	4	Debates	Debates	NNPS
8691	1800	5	and	and	CC
8691	1800	6	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNPS
8691	1800	7	of	of	IN
8691	1800	8	the	the	DT
8691	1800	9	National	National	NNP
8691	1800	10	Peace	Peace	NNP
8691	1800	11	Convention	Convention	NNP
8691	1800	12	,	,	,
8691	1800	13	45	45	CD
8691	1800	14	,	,	,
8691	1800	15	61	61	CD
8691	1800	16	,	,	,
8691	1800	17	67	67	CD
8691	1800	18	.	.	.
8691	1800	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1801	1	There	there	EX
8691	1801	2	were	be	VBD
8691	1801	3	many	many	JJ
8691	1801	4	,	,	,
8691	1801	5	at	at	IN
8691	1801	6	the	the	DT
8691	1801	7	time	time	NN
8691	1801	8	when	when	WRB
8691	1801	9	the	the	DT
8691	1801	10	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1801	11	of	of	IN
8691	1801	12	the	the	DT
8691	1801	13	United	United	NNP
8691	1801	14	States	States	NNP
8691	1801	15	was	be	VBD
8691	1801	16	before	before	IN
8691	1801	17	the	the	DT
8691	1801	18	people	people	NNS
8691	1801	19	for	for	IN
8691	1801	20	ratification	ratification	NN
8691	1801	21	,	,	,
8691	1801	22	who	who	WP
8691	1801	23	feared	fear	VBD
8691	1801	24	that	that	IN
8691	1801	25	the	the	DT
8691	1801	26	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1801	27	of	of	IN
8691	1801	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1801	29	courts	court	NNS
8691	1801	30	would	would	MD
8691	1801	31	be	be	VB
8691	1801	32	extended	extend	VBN
8691	1801	33	by	by	IN
8691	1801	34	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1801	35	construction	construction	NN
8691	1801	36	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	1801	37	the	the	DT
8691	1801	38	limits	limit	NNS
8691	1801	39	of	of	IN
8691	1801	40	the	the	DT
8691	1801	41	grant	grant	NN
8691	1801	42	.	.	.
8691	1802	1	New	New	NNP
8691	1802	2	York	York	NNP
8691	1802	3	in	in	IN
8691	1802	4	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1802	5	vote	vote	NN
8691	1802	6	of	of	IN
8691	1802	7	ratification	ratification	NN
8691	1802	8	incorporated	incorporate	VBD
8691	1802	9	a	a	DT
8691	1802	10	declaration	declaration	NN
8691	1802	11	that	that	IN
8691	1802	12	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1802	13	understood	understand	VBD
8691	1802	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1802	15	to	to	TO
8691	1802	16	be	be	VB
8691	1802	17	impossible	impossible	JJ
8691	1802	18	that	that	IN
8691	1802	19	the	the	DT
8691	1802	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1802	21	of	of	IN
8691	1802	22	any	any	DT
8691	1802	23	court	court	NN
8691	1802	24	of	of	IN
8691	1802	25	the	the	DT
8691	1802	26	United	United	NNP
8691	1802	27	States	States	NNP
8691	1802	28	could	could	MD
8691	1802	29	ever	ever	RB
8691	1802	30	be	be	VB
8691	1802	31	enlarged	enlarge	VBN
8691	1802	32	"	"	''
8691	1802	33	by	by	IN
8691	1802	34	any	any	DT
8691	1802	35	fiction	fiction	NN
8691	1802	36	.	.	.
8691	1802	37	"	"	''
8691	1803	1	In	in	IN
8691	1803	2	the	the	DT
8691	1803	3	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	1803	4	Convention	Convention	NNP
8691	1803	5	,	,	,
8691	1803	6	this	this	DT
8691	1803	7	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	1803	8	took	take	VBD
8691	1803	9	shape	shape	NN
8691	1803	10	in	in	IN
8691	1803	11	a	a	DT
8691	1803	12	proposed	propose	VBN
8691	1803	13	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	1803	14	to	to	IN
8691	1803	15	the	the	DT
8691	1803	16	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1803	17	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1803	18	by	by	IN
8691	1803	19	a	a	DT
8691	1803	20	committee	committee	NN
8691	1803	21	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	1803	22	for	for	IN
8691	1803	23	the	the	DT
8691	1803	24	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1803	25	,	,	,
8691	1803	26	but	but	CC
8691	1803	27	never	never	RB
8691	1803	28	reported	report	VBD
8691	1803	29	,	,	,
8691	1803	30	"	"	''
8691	1803	31	that	that	IN
8691	1803	32	the	the	DT
8691	1803	33	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	1803	34	courts	court	NNS
8691	1803	35	shall	shall	MD
8691	1803	36	not	not	RB
8691	1803	37	be	be	VB
8691	1803	38	entitled	entitle	VBN
8691	1803	39	to	to	IN
8691	1803	40	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1803	41	by	by	IN
8691	1803	42	fictions	fiction	NNS
8691	1803	43	or	or	CC
8691	1803	44	collusion	collusion	NN
8691	1803	45	.	.	.
8691	1804	1	"	"	``
8691	1804	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1804	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1804	4	:	:	:
8691	1804	5	Elliot	Elliot	NNP
8691	1804	6	's	's	POS
8691	1804	7	Debates	debate	NNS
8691	1804	8	,	,	,
8691	1804	9	550	550	CD
8691	1804	10	;	;	:
8691	1804	11	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
8691	1804	12	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	1804	13	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1804	14	Society	Society	NNP
8691	1804	15	,	,	,
8691	1804	16	XVII	XVII	NNP
8691	1804	17	,	,	,
8691	1804	18	504	504	CD
8691	1804	19	-	-	SYM
8691	1804	20	7	7	CD
8691	1804	21	.	.	.
8691	1804	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1805	1	Had	have	VBD
8691	1805	2	such	such	PDT
8691	1805	3	an	an	DT
8691	1805	4	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	1805	5	been	be	VBN
8691	1805	6	proposed	propose	VBN
8691	1805	7	and	and	CC
8691	1805	8	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1805	9	,	,	,
8691	1805	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1805	11	would	would	MD
8691	1805	12	have	have	VB
8691	1805	13	cut	cut	VBN
8691	1805	14	off	off	RP
8691	1805	15	a	a	DT
8691	1805	16	large	large	JJ
8691	1805	17	share	share	NN
8691	1805	18	of	of	IN
8691	1805	19	the	the	DT
8691	1805	20	most	most	RBS
8691	1805	21	important	important	JJ
8691	1805	22	cases	case	NNS
8691	1805	23	now	now	RB
8691	1805	24	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1805	25	before	before	RB
8691	1805	26	the	the	DT
8691	1805	27	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1805	28	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1805	29	.	.	.
8691	1806	1	In	in	IN
8691	1806	2	1787	1787	CD
8691	1806	3	,	,	,
8691	1806	4	there	there	EX
8691	1806	5	were	be	VBD
8691	1806	6	only	only	RB
8691	1806	7	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	1806	8	-	-	HYPH
8691	1806	9	seven	seven	CD
8691	1806	10	business	business	NN
8691	1806	11	corporations	corporation	NNS
8691	1806	12	in	in	IN
8691	1806	13	the	the	DT
8691	1806	14	United	United	NNP
8691	1806	15	States	States	NNP
8691	1806	16	.	.	.
8691	1807	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1807	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1807	3	:	:	:
8691	1807	4	Report	report	NN
8691	1807	5	of	of	IN
8691	1807	6	the	the	DT
8691	1807	7	American	American	NNP
8691	1807	8	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1807	9	Association	Association	NNP
8691	1807	10	for	for	IN
8691	1807	11	1902	1902	CD
8691	1807	12	,	,	,
8691	1807	13	267	267	CD
8691	1807	14	;	;	:
8691	1807	15	_	_	NNP
8691	1807	16	American	American	NNP
8691	1807	17	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1807	18	Review	Review	NNP
8691	1807	19	_	_	NNP
8691	1807	20	,	,	,
8691	1807	21	VIII	VIII	NNP
8691	1807	22	,	,	,
8691	1807	23	449	449	CD
8691	1807	24	.	.	.
8691	1807	25	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1808	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1808	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1808	3	not	not	RB
8691	1808	4	long	long	RB
8691	1808	5	before	before	IN
8691	1808	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1808	7	became	become	VBD
8691	1808	8	countless	countless	JJ
8691	1808	9	and	and	CC
8691	1808	10	the	the	DT
8691	1808	11	large	large	JJ
8691	1808	12	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	1808	13	of	of	IN
8691	1808	14	the	the	DT
8691	1808	15	country	country	NN
8691	1808	16	were	be	VBD
8691	1808	17	in	in	IN
8691	1808	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1808	19	hands	hand	NNS
8691	1808	20	.	.	.
8691	1809	1	Could	Could	MD
8691	1809	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1809	3	sue	sue	VB
8691	1809	4	and	and	CC
8691	1809	5	be	be	VB
8691	1809	6	sued	sue	VBN
8691	1809	7	in	in	IN
8691	1809	8	the	the	DT
8691	1809	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	1809	10	of	of	IN
8691	1809	11	the	the	DT
8691	1809	12	United	United	NNP
8691	1809	13	States	States	NNP
8691	1809	14	?	?	.
8691	1810	1	The	the	DT
8691	1810	2	decision	decision	NN
8691	1810	3	on	on	IN
8691	1810	4	this	this	DT
8691	1810	5	point	point	NN
8691	1810	6	was	be	VBD
8691	1810	7	that	that	IN
8691	1810	8	,	,	,
8691	1810	9	by	by	IN
8691	1810	10	force	force	NN
8691	1810	11	of	of	IN
8691	1810	12	a	a	DT
8691	1810	13	pure	pure	JJ
8691	1810	14	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1810	15	fiction	fiction	NN
8691	1810	16	,	,	,
8691	1810	17	invented	invent	VBN
8691	1810	18	for	for	IN
8691	1810	19	the	the	DT
8691	1810	20	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	1810	21	,	,	,
8691	1810	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1810	23	might	may	MD
8691	1810	24	be	be	VB
8691	1810	25	.	.	.
8691	1811	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1811	2	were	be	VBD
8691	1811	3	,	,	,
8691	1811	4	indeed	indeed	RB
8691	1811	5	,	,	,
8691	1811	6	not	not	RB
8691	1811	7	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1811	8	of	of	IN
8691	1811	9	any	any	DT
8691	1811	10	State;[Footnote	state;[footnote	NN
8691	1811	11	:	:	:
8691	1811	12	Paul	Paul	NNP
8691	1811	13	_	_	NNP
8691	1811	14	v.	v.	IN
8691	1811	15	_	_	NNP
8691	1811	16	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	1811	17	,	,	,
8691	1811	18	8	8	CD
8691	1811	19	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	1811	20	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1811	21	,	,	,
8691	1811	22	168	168	CD
8691	1811	23	.	.	.
8691	1811	24	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1812	1	but	but	CC
8691	1812	2	the	the	DT
8691	1812	3	persons	person	NNS
8691	1812	4	who	who	WP
8691	1812	5	composed	compose	VBD
8691	1812	6	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1812	7	probably	probably	RB
8691	1812	8	were	be	VBD
8691	1812	9	.	.	.
8691	1813	1	Therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1813	2	,	,	,
8691	1813	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1813	4	must	must	MD
8691	1813	5	be	be	VB
8691	1813	6	assumed	assume	VBN
8691	1813	7	that	that	IN
8691	1813	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1813	9	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	1813	10	were	be	VBD
8691	1813	11	,	,	,
8691	1813	12	and	and	CC
8691	1813	13	also	also	RB
8691	1813	14	that	that	IN
8691	1813	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1813	16	were	be	VBD
8691	1813	17	all	all	DT
8691	1813	18	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1813	19	of	of	IN
8691	1813	20	the	the	DT
8691	1813	21	same	same	JJ
8691	1813	22	State	State	NNP
8691	1813	23	and	and	CC
8691	1813	24	that	that	IN
8691	1813	25	the	the	DT
8691	1813	26	State	State	NNP
8691	1813	27	from	from	IN
8691	1813	28	which	which	WDT
8691	1813	29	incorporation	incorporation	NN
8691	1813	30	was	be	VBD
8691	1813	31	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	1813	32	.	.	.
8691	1814	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1814	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1814	3	:	:	:
8691	1814	4	Louisville	Louisville	NNP
8691	1814	5	,	,	,
8691	1814	6	Cincinnati	Cincinnati	NNP
8691	1814	7	and	and	CC
8691	1814	8	Charleston	Charleston	NNP
8691	1814	9	R.	R.	NNP
8691	1814	10	R.	R.	NNP
8691	1814	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1814	12	_	_	NNP
8691	1814	13	v.	v.	IN
8691	1814	14	_	_	NNP
8691	1814	15	Letson	Letson	NNP
8691	1814	16	,	,	,
8691	1814	17	2	2	CD
8691	1814	18	Howard	Howard	NNP
8691	1814	19	's	's	POS
8691	1814	20	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1814	21	,	,	,
8691	1814	22	497	497	CD
8691	1814	23	,	,	,
8691	1814	24	555	555	CD
8691	1814	25	;	;	:
8691	1814	26	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	1814	27	and	and	CC
8691	1814	28	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	1814	29	R.	R.	NNP
8691	1814	30	R.	R.	NNP
8691	1814	31	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1814	32	_	_	NNP
8691	1814	33	v.	v.	IN
8691	1814	34	_	_	NNP
8691	1814	35	Wheeler	Wheeler	NNP
8691	1814	36	,	,	,
8691	1814	37	I	I	NNP
8691	1814	38	Black	Black	NNP
8691	1814	39	's	's	POS
8691	1814	40	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1814	41	,	,	,
8691	1814	42	286	286	CD
8691	1814	43	.	.	.
8691	1814	44	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1815	1	Sir	Sir	NNP
8691	1815	2	Henry	Henry	NNP
8691	1815	3	Maine	Maine	NNP
8691	1815	4	maintained	maintain	VBD
8691	1815	5	that	that	IN
8691	1815	6	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1815	7	fictions	fiction	NNS
8691	1815	8	were	be	VBD
8691	1815	9	the	the	DT
8691	1815	10	rude	rude	JJ
8691	1815	11	device	device	NN
8691	1815	12	of	of	IN
8691	1815	13	early	early	JJ
8691	1815	14	stages	stage	NNS
8691	1815	15	in	in	IN
8691	1815	16	government	government	NN
8691	1815	17	,	,	,
8691	1815	18	and	and	CC
8691	1815	19	to	to	TO
8691	1815	20	add	add	VB
8691	1815	21	to	to	IN
8691	1815	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1815	23	disturbed	disturb	VBD
8691	1815	24	the	the	DT
8691	1815	25	symmetry	symmetry	NN
8691	1815	26	of	of	IN
8691	1815	27	a	a	DT
8691	1815	28	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1815	29	system	system	NN
8691	1815	30	and	and	CC
8691	1815	31	was	be	VBD
8691	1815	32	unworthy	unworthy	JJ
8691	1815	33	the	the	DT
8691	1815	34	approval	approval	NN
8691	1815	35	of	of	IN
8691	1815	36	modern	modern	JJ
8691	1815	37	courts	court	NNS
8691	1815	38	.	.	.
8691	1816	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1816	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1816	3	:	:	:
8691	1816	4	Ancient	Ancient	NNP
8691	1816	5	Law	Law	NNP
8691	1816	6	,	,	,
8691	1816	7	26	26	CD
8691	1816	8	.	.	.
8691	1816	9	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1817	1	But	but	CC
8691	1817	2	while	while	IN
8691	1817	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1817	4	are	be	VBP
8691	1817	5	among	among	IN
8691	1817	6	the	the	DT
8691	1817	7	things	thing	NNS
8691	1817	8	that	that	WDT
8691	1817	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1817	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	1817	11	hard	hard	JJ
8691	1817	12	to	to	TO
8691	1817	13	justify	justify	VB
8691	1817	14	on	on	IN
8691	1817	15	principle	principle	NN
8691	1817	16	,	,	,
8691	1817	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1817	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	1817	19	harder	hard	JJR
8691	1817	20	to	to	TO
8691	1817	21	dispense	dispense	VB
8691	1817	22	with	with	IN
8691	1817	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1817	24	in	in	IN
8691	1817	25	actual	actual	JJ
8691	1817	26	practice	practice	NN
8691	1817	27	,	,	,
8691	1817	28	as	as	IN
8691	1817	29	the	the	DT
8691	1817	30	instance	instance	NN
8691	1817	31	given	give	VBN
8691	1817	32	conspicuously	conspicuously	RB
8691	1817	33	illustrates	illustrate	NNS
8691	1817	34	.	.	.
8691	1818	1	Although	although	IN
8691	1818	2	the	the	DT
8691	1818	3	United	United	NNP
8691	1818	4	States	States	NNP
8691	1818	5	are	be	VBP
8691	1818	6	the	the	DT
8691	1818	7	only	only	JJ
8691	1818	8	depositary	depositary	NN
8691	1818	9	of	of	IN
8691	1818	10	the	the	DT
8691	1818	11	power	power	NN
8691	1818	12	of	of	IN
8691	1818	13	ordering	order	VBG
8691	1818	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1818	15	relations	relation	NNS
8691	1818	16	,	,	,
8691	1818	17	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1818	18	governments	government	NNS
8691	1818	19	are	be	VBP
8691	1818	20	often	often	RB
8691	1818	21	aggrieved	aggrieve	VBN
8691	1818	22	by	by	IN
8691	1818	23	acts	act	NNS
8691	1818	24	of	of	IN
8691	1818	25	the	the	DT
8691	1818	26	courts	court	NNS
8691	1818	27	of	of	IN
8691	1818	28	a	a	DT
8691	1818	29	State	state	NN
8691	1818	30	which	which	WDT
8691	1818	31	the	the	DT
8691	1818	32	United	United	NNP
8691	1818	33	States	States	NNP
8691	1818	34	have	have	VBP
8691	1818	35	but	but	CC
8691	1818	36	imperfect	imperfect	JJ
8691	1818	37	means	mean	NNS
8691	1818	38	of	of	IN
8691	1818	39	preventing	prevent	VBG
8691	1818	40	or	or	CC
8691	1818	41	rectifying	rectify	VBG
8691	1818	42	.	.	.
8691	1819	1	In	in	IN
8691	1819	2	1841	1841	CD
8691	1819	3	,	,	,
8691	1819	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1819	5	were	be	VBD
8691	1819	6	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1819	7	to	to	IN
8691	1819	8	the	the	DT
8691	1819	9	verge	verge	NN
8691	1819	10	of	of	IN
8691	1819	11	war	war	NN
8691	1819	12	with	with	IN
8691	1819	13	Great	Great	NNP
8691	1819	14	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	1819	15	by	by	IN
8691	1819	16	an	an	DT
8691	1819	17	incident	incident	NN
8691	1819	18	of	of	IN
8691	1819	19	this	this	DT
8691	1819	20	nature	nature	NN
8691	1819	21	.	.	.
8691	1820	1	An	an	DT
8691	1820	2	insurrection	insurrection	NN
8691	1820	3	broke	break	VBD
8691	1820	4	out	out	RP
8691	1820	5	in	in	IN
8691	1820	6	Canada	Canada	NNP
8691	1820	7	in	in	IN
8691	1820	8	1837	1837	CD
8691	1820	9	,	,	,
8691	1820	10	and	and	CC
8691	1820	11	a	a	DT
8691	1820	12	New	New	NNP
8691	1820	13	York	York	NNP
8691	1820	14	steamboat	steamboat	NN
8691	1820	15	was	be	VBD
8691	1820	16	chartered	charter	VBN
8691	1820	17	to	to	TO
8691	1820	18	bring	bring	VB
8691	1820	19	supplies	supply	NNS
8691	1820	20	across	across	IN
8691	1820	21	the	the	DT
8691	1820	22	Niagara	Niagara	NNP
8691	1820	23	River	River	NNP
8691	1820	24	to	to	IN
8691	1820	25	those	those	DT
8691	1820	26	engaged	engage	VBN
8691	1820	27	in	in	IN
8691	1820	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1820	29	.	.	.
8691	1821	1	One	one	CD
8691	1821	2	night	night	NN
8691	1821	3	when	when	WRB
8691	1821	4	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1821	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1821	6	moored	moor	VBN
8691	1821	7	on	on	IN
8691	1821	8	the	the	DT
8691	1821	9	New	New	NNP
8691	1821	10	York	York	NNP
8691	1821	11	side	side	NN
8691	1821	12	of	of	IN
8691	1821	13	the	the	DT
8691	1821	14	river	river	NN
8691	1821	15	a	a	DT
8691	1821	16	party	party	NN
8691	1821	17	of	of	IN
8691	1821	18	loyal	loyal	JJ
8691	1821	19	Canadians	Canadians	NNPS
8691	1821	20	seized	seize	VBD
8691	1821	21	and	and	CC
8691	1821	22	burned	burn	VBD
8691	1821	23	her	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1821	24	.	.	.
8691	1822	1	During	during	IN
8691	1822	2	the	the	DT
8691	1822	3	accompanying	accompany	VBG
8691	1822	4	affray	affray	NN
8691	1822	5	an	an	DT
8691	1822	6	American	American	NNP
8691	1822	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1822	8	killed	kill	VBN
8691	1822	9	.	.	.
8691	1823	1	A	a	DT
8691	1823	2	Canadian	canadian	JJ
8691	1823	3	named	name	VBN
8691	1823	4	McLeod	McLeod	NNP
8691	1823	5	,	,	,
8691	1823	6	who	who	WP
8691	1823	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1823	8	charged	charge	VBN
8691	1823	9	with	with	IN
8691	1823	10	having	have	VBG
8691	1823	11	fired	fire	VBN
8691	1823	12	the	the	DT
8691	1823	13	fatal	fatal	JJ
8691	1823	14	shot	shot	NN
8691	1823	15	,	,	,
8691	1823	16	was	be	VBD
8691	1823	17	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	1823	18	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	1823	19	in	in	IN
8691	1823	20	New	New	NNP
8691	1823	21	York	York	NNP
8691	1823	22	and	and	CC
8691	1823	23	indicted	indict	VBN
8691	1823	24	for	for	IN
8691	1823	25	murder	murder	NN
8691	1823	26	.	.	.
8691	1824	1	The	the	DT
8691	1824	2	British	british	JJ
8691	1824	3	government	government	NN
8691	1824	4	then	then	RB
8691	1824	5	informed	inform	VBD
8691	1824	6	ours	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1824	7	that	that	IN
8691	1824	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1824	9	had	have	VBD
8691	1824	10	ordered	order	VBN
8691	1824	11	the	the	DT
8691	1824	12	burning	burning	NN
8691	1824	13	of	of	IN
8691	1824	14	the	the	DT
8691	1824	15	steamer	steamer	NN
8691	1824	16	,	,	,
8691	1824	17	and	and	CC
8691	1824	18	thereupon	thereupon	RB
8691	1824	19	demanded	demand	VBD
8691	1824	20	McLeod	McLeod	NNP
8691	1824	21	's	's	POS
8691	1824	22	release	release	NN
8691	1824	23	.	.	.
8691	1825	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1825	2	Secretary	Secretary	NNP
8691	1825	3	of	of	IN
8691	1825	4	State	State	NNP
8691	1825	5	replied	reply	VBD
8691	1825	6	that	that	IN
8691	1825	7	the	the	DT
8691	1825	8	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	1825	9	was	be	VBD
8691	1825	10	in	in	IN
8691	1825	11	the	the	DT
8691	1825	12	hands	hand	NNS
8691	1825	13	of	of	IN
8691	1825	14	the	the	DT
8691	1825	15	State	State	NNP
8691	1825	16	of	of	IN
8691	1825	17	New	New	NNP
8691	1825	18	York	York	NNP
8691	1825	19	,	,	,
8691	1825	20	and	and	CC
8691	1825	21	the	the	DT
8691	1825	22	United	United	NNP
8691	1825	23	States	States	NNP
8691	1825	24	had	have	VBD
8691	1825	25	no	no	DT
8691	1825	26	control	control	NN
8691	1825	27	over	over	IN
8691	1825	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1825	29	.	.	.
8691	1826	1	Lord	Lord	NNP
8691	1826	2	Palmerston	Palmerston	NNP
8691	1826	3	made	make	VBD
8691	1826	4	the	the	DT
8691	1826	5	affair	affair	NN
8691	1826	6	the	the	DT
8691	1826	7	subject	subject	NN
8691	1826	8	of	of	IN
8691	1826	9	a	a	DT
8691	1826	10	dispatch	dispatch	NN
8691	1826	11	,	,	,
8691	1826	12	in	in	IN
8691	1826	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1826	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1826	15	stated	state	VBD
8691	1826	16	that	that	IN
8691	1826	17	McLeod	McLeod	NNP
8691	1826	18	's	's	POS
8691	1826	19	execution	execution	NN
8691	1826	20	would	would	MD
8691	1826	21	produce	produce	VB
8691	1826	22	"	"	``
8691	1826	23	a	a	DT
8691	1826	24	war	war	NN
8691	1826	25	of	of	IN
8691	1826	26	retaliation	retaliation	NN
8691	1826	27	and	and	CC
8691	1826	28	vengeance	vengeance	NN
8691	1826	29	.	.	.
8691	1826	30	"	"	''
8691	1827	1	The	the	DT
8691	1827	2	President	President	NNP
8691	1827	3	at	at	IN
8691	1827	4	once	once	RB
8691	1827	5	requested	request	VBD
8691	1827	6	the	the	DT
8691	1827	7	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1827	8	of	of	IN
8691	1827	9	New	New	NNP
8691	1827	10	York	York	NNP
8691	1827	11	to	to	TO
8691	1827	12	order	order	VB
8691	1827	13	a	a	DT
8691	1827	14	discontinuance	discontinuance	NN
8691	1827	15	of	of	IN
8691	1827	16	the	the	DT
8691	1827	17	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	1827	18	.	.	.
8691	1828	1	This	this	DT
8691	1828	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1828	3	declined	decline	VBN
8691	1828	4	,	,	,
8691	1828	5	but	but	CC
8691	1828	6	with	with	IN
8691	1828	7	a	a	DT
8691	1828	8	promise	promise	NN
8691	1828	9	to	to	TO
8691	1828	10	grant	grant	VB
8691	1828	11	a	a	DT
8691	1828	12	pardon	pardon	NN
8691	1828	13	in	in	IN
8691	1828	14	case	case	NN
8691	1828	15	of	of	IN
8691	1828	16	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	1828	17	.	.	.
8691	1829	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1829	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	1829	3	:	:	:
8691	1829	4	Lothrop	Lothrop	NNP
8691	1829	5	,	,	,
8691	1829	6	"	"	``
8691	1829	7	Life	Life	NNP
8691	1829	8	of	of	IN
8691	1829	9	William	William	NNP
8691	1829	10	H.	H.	NNP
8691	1829	11	Seward	Seward	NNP
8691	1829	12	,	,	,
8691	1829	13	"	"	''
8691	1829	14	35	35	CD
8691	1829	15	.	.	.
8691	1829	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1830	1	The	the	DT
8691	1830	2	State	State	NNP
8691	1830	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1830	4	refused	refuse	VBD
8691	1830	5	to	to	TO
8691	1830	6	discharge	discharge	VB
8691	1830	7	the	the	DT
8691	1830	8	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	1830	9	.	.	.
8691	1831	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1831	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1831	3	tried	try	VBN
8691	1831	4	on	on	IN
8691	1831	5	the	the	DT
8691	1831	6	original	original	JJ
8691	1831	7	charge	charge	NN
8691	1831	8	,	,	,
8691	1831	9	but	but	CC
8691	1831	10	acquitted	acquit	VBN
8691	1831	11	.	.	.
8691	1832	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1832	2	in	in	IN
8691	1832	3	1842	1842	CD
8691	1832	4	did	do	VBD
8691	1832	5	what	what	WP
8691	1832	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1832	7	could	could	MD
8691	1832	8	to	to	TO
8691	1832	9	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	1832	10	the	the	DT
8691	1832	11	recurrence	recurrence	NN
8691	1832	12	of	of	IN
8691	1832	13	such	such	PDT
8691	1832	14	a	a	DT
8691	1832	15	conflict	conflict	NN
8691	1832	16	of	of	IN
8691	1832	17	authority	authority	NN
8691	1832	18	by	by	IN
8691	1832	19	passing	pass	VBG
8691	1832	20	an	an	DT
8691	1832	21	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1832	22	giving	give	VBG
8691	1832	23	the	the	DT
8691	1832	24	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1832	25	and	and	CC
8691	1832	26	District	District	NNP
8691	1832	27	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1832	28	of	of	IN
8691	1832	29	the	the	DT
8691	1832	30	United	United	NNP
8691	1832	31	States	States	NNP
8691	1832	32	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1832	33	on	on	IN
8691	1832	34	_	_	NNP
8691	1832	35	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	1832	36	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	1832	37	_	_	NNP
8691	1832	38	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1832	39	in	in	IN
8691	1832	40	favor	favor	NN
8691	1832	41	of	of	IN
8691	1832	42	foreigners	foreigner	NNS
8691	1832	43	held	hold	VBN
8691	1832	44	by	by	IN
8691	1832	45	State	State	NNP
8691	1832	46	authority	authority	NN
8691	1832	47	,	,	,
8691	1832	48	who	who	WP
8691	1832	49	might	may	MD
8691	1832	50	claim	claim	VB
8691	1832	51	a	a	DT
8691	1832	52	right	right	NN
8691	1832	53	of	of	IN
8691	1832	54	release	release	NN
8691	1832	55	under	under	IN
8691	1832	56	the	the	DT
8691	1832	57	principles	principle	NNS
8691	1832	58	of	of	IN
8691	1832	59	international	international	JJ
8691	1832	60	law	law	NN
8691	1832	61	.	.	.
8691	1833	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1833	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1833	3	:	:	:
8691	1833	4	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1833	5	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1833	6	Revised	Revised	NNP
8691	1833	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	1833	8	,	,	,
8691	1833	9	§	§	NNP
8691	1833	10	762	762	CD
8691	1833	11	.	.	.
8691	1833	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1834	1	The	the	DT
8691	1834	2	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1834	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1834	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	1834	5	since	since	IN
8691	1834	6	1875	1875	CD
8691	1834	7	been	be	VBN
8691	1834	8	given	give	VBN
8691	1834	9	power	power	NN
8691	1834	10	to	to	TO
8691	1834	11	entertain	entertain	VB
8691	1834	12	original	original	JJ
8691	1834	13	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1834	14	of	of	IN
8691	1834	15	any	any	DT
8691	1834	16	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1834	17	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1834	18	under	under	IN
8691	1834	19	the	the	DT
8691	1834	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1834	21	,	,	,
8691	1834	22	laws	law	NNS
8691	1834	23	or	or	CC
8691	1834	24	treaties	treaty	NNS
8691	1834	25	of	of	IN
8691	1834	26	the	the	DT
8691	1834	27	United	United	NNP
8691	1834	28	States	States	NNP
8691	1834	29	,	,	,
8691	1834	30	regardless	regardless	RB
8691	1834	31	of	of	IN
8691	1834	32	the	the	DT
8691	1834	33	citizenship	citizenship	NN
8691	1834	34	of	of	IN
8691	1834	35	the	the	DT
8691	1834	36	parties	party	NNS
8691	1834	37	,	,	,
8691	1834	38	if	if	IN
8691	1834	39	a	a	DT
8691	1834	40	value	value	NN
8691	1834	41	of	of	IN
8691	1834	42	$	$	$
8691	1834	43	2,000	2,000	CD
8691	1834	44	is	be	VBZ
8691	1834	45	involved	involve	VBN
8691	1834	46	.	.	.
8691	1835	1	In	in	IN
8691	1835	2	all	all	DT
8691	1835	3	cases	case	NNS
8691	1835	4	,	,	,
8691	1835	5	also	also	RB
8691	1835	6	,	,	,
8691	1835	7	of	of	IN
8691	1835	8	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	1835	9	by	by	IN
8691	1835	10	State	State	NNP
8691	1835	11	authority	authority	NN
8691	1835	12	,	,	,
8691	1835	13	whether	whether	IN
8691	1835	14	under	under	IN
8691	1835	15	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	1835	16	before	before	IN
8691	1835	17	trial	trial	NN
8691	1835	18	or	or	CC
8691	1835	19	after	after	IN
8691	1835	20	a	a	DT
8691	1835	21	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	1835	22	of	of	IN
8691	1835	23	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	1835	24	,	,	,
8691	1835	25	in	in	IN
8691	1835	26	violation	violation	NN
8691	1835	27	of	of	IN
8691	1835	28	rights	right	NNS
8691	1835	29	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	1835	30	under	under	IN
8691	1835	31	the	the	DT
8691	1835	32	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1835	33	,	,	,
8691	1835	34	laws	law	NNS
8691	1835	35	or	or	CC
8691	1835	36	treaties	treaty	NNS
8691	1835	37	of	of	IN
8691	1835	38	the	the	DT
8691	1835	39	United	United	NNP
8691	1835	40	States	States	NNP
8691	1835	41	,	,	,
8691	1835	42	the	the	DT
8691	1835	43	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	1835	44	may	may	MD
8691	1835	45	now	now	RB
8691	1835	46	be	be	VB
8691	1835	47	summarily	summarily	RB
8691	1835	48	discharged	discharge	VBN
8691	1835	49	on	on	IN
8691	1835	50	a	a	DT
8691	1835	51	writ	writ	NN
8691	1835	52	of	of	IN
8691	1835	53	_	_	NNP
8691	1835	54	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	1835	55	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	1835	56	_	_	NNP
8691	1835	57	by	by	IN
8691	1835	58	a	a	DT
8691	1835	59	court	court	NN
8691	1835	60	or	or	CC
8691	1835	61	judge	judge	NN
8691	1835	62	of	of	IN
8691	1835	63	the	the	DT
8691	1835	64	United	United	NNP
8691	1835	65	States	States	NNP
8691	1835	66	.	.	.
8691	1836	1	Ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	1836	2	,	,	,
8691	1836	3	however	however	RB
8691	1836	4	,	,	,
8691	1836	5	as	as	IN
8691	1836	6	a	a	DT
8691	1836	7	matter	matter	NN
8691	1836	8	of	of	IN
8691	1836	9	comity	comity	NN
8691	1836	10	,	,	,
8691	1836	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1836	12	will	will	MD
8691	1836	13	be	be	VB
8691	1836	14	left	leave	VBN
8691	1836	15	to	to	TO
8691	1836	16	seek	seek	VB
8691	1836	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1836	18	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1836	19	in	in	IN
8691	1836	20	the	the	DT
8691	1836	21	State	State	NNP
8691	1836	22	courts	court	NNS
8691	1836	23	,	,	,
8691	1836	24	and	and	CC
8691	1836	25	if	if	IN
8691	1836	26	without	without	IN
8691	1836	27	success	success	NN
8691	1836	28	there	there	RB
8691	1836	29	,	,	,
8691	1836	30	on	on	IN
8691	1836	31	a	a	DT
8691	1836	32	writ	writ	NN
8691	1836	33	of	of	IN
8691	1836	34	error	error	NN
8691	1836	35	from	from	IN
8691	1836	36	the	the	DT
8691	1836	37	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1836	38	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1836	39	of	of	IN
8691	1836	40	the	the	DT
8691	1836	41	United	United	NNP
8691	1836	42	States	States	NNP
8691	1836	43	.	.	.
8691	1837	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1837	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1837	3	:	:	:
8691	1837	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1837	5	In	In	NNP
8691	1837	6	re	re	NN
8691	1837	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1837	8	Neagle	Neagle	NNP
8691	1837	9	,	,	,
8691	1837	10	135	135	CD
8691	1837	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1837	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1837	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1837	14	,	,	,
8691	1837	15	1	1	CD
8691	1837	16	;	;	:
8691	1837	17	_	_	NNP
8691	1837	18	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	1837	19	parte	parte	NN
8691	1837	20	_	_	NNP
8691	1837	21	Royall	Royall	NNP
8691	1837	22	,	,	,
8691	1837	23	117	117	CD
8691	1837	24	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1837	25	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1837	26	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1837	27	,	,	,
8691	1837	28	241	241	CD
8691	1837	29	.	.	.
8691	1837	30	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1838	1	The	the	DT
8691	1838	2	State	State	NNP
8691	1838	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1838	4	have	have	VBP
8691	1838	5	no	no	DT
8691	1838	6	power	power	NN
8691	1838	7	to	to	TO
8691	1838	8	release	release	VB
8691	1838	9	on	on	IN
8691	1838	10	_	_	NNP
8691	1838	11	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	1838	12	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	1838	13	_	_	NNP
8691	1838	14	one	one	NN
8691	1838	15	who	who	WP
8691	1838	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	1838	17	held	hold	VBN
8691	1838	18	under	under	IN
8691	1838	19	the	the	DT
8691	1838	20	authority	authority	NN
8691	1838	21	of	of	IN
8691	1838	22	the	the	DT
8691	1838	23	United	United	NNP
8691	1838	24	States	States	NNP
8691	1838	25	.	.	.
8691	1839	1	If	if	IN
8691	1839	2	that	that	DT
8691	1839	3	authority	authority	NN
8691	1839	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	1839	5	been	be	VBN
8691	1839	6	illegally	illegally	RB
8691	1839	7	exerted	exert	VBN
8691	1839	8	,	,	,
8691	1839	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1839	10	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1839	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	1839	12	in	in	IN
8691	1839	13	the	the	DT
8691	1839	14	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1839	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	1839	16	alone	alone	RB
8691	1839	17	.	.	.
8691	1840	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1840	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1840	3	:	:	:
8691	1840	4	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
8691	1840	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1840	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1840	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1840	8	Booth	Booth	NNP
8691	1840	9	,	,	,
8691	1840	10	21	21	CD
8691	1840	11	Howard	Howard	NNP
8691	1840	12	's	's	POS
8691	1840	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1840	14	,	,	,
8691	1840	15	506	506	CD
8691	1840	16	.	.	.
8691	1840	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1841	1	The	the	DT
8691	1841	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	1841	3	in	in	IN
8691	1841	4	which	which	WDT
8691	1841	5	a	a	DT
8691	1841	6	State	state	NN
8691	1841	7	can	can	MD
8691	1841	8	be	be	VB
8691	1841	9	sued	sue	VBN
8691	1841	10	in	in	IN
8691	1841	11	an	an	DT
8691	1841	12	original	original	JJ
8691	1841	13	suit	suit	NN
8691	1841	14	in	in	IN
8691	1841	15	the	the	DT
8691	1841	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1841	17	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1841	18	of	of	IN
8691	1841	19	the	the	DT
8691	1841	20	United	United	NNP
8691	1841	21	States	States	NNP
8691	1841	22	are	be	VBP
8691	1841	23	defined	define	VBN
8691	1841	24	in	in	IN
8691	1841	25	the	the	DT
8691	1841	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1841	27	and	and	CC
8691	1841	28	,	,	,
8691	1841	29	as	as	IN
8691	1841	30	limited	limit	VBN
8691	1841	31	by	by	IN
8691	1841	32	the	the	DT
8691	1841	33	eleventh	eleventh	NNP
8691	1841	34	amendment	amendment	NNP
8691	1841	35	to	to	IN
8691	1841	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1841	37	,	,	,
8691	1841	38	are	be	VBP
8691	1841	39	quite	quite	RB
8691	1841	40	few	few	JJ
8691	1841	41	.	.	.
8691	1842	1	Several	several	JJ
8691	1842	2	such	such	JJ
8691	1842	3	actions	action	NNS
8691	1842	4	have	have	VBP
8691	1842	5	been	be	VBN
8691	1842	6	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1842	7	.	.	.
8691	1843	1	In	in	IN
8691	1843	2	the	the	DT
8691	1843	3	earlier	early	JJR
8691	1843	4	ones	one	NNS
8691	1843	5	,	,	,
8691	1843	6	the	the	DT
8691	1843	7	State	State	NNP
8691	1843	8	declined	decline	VBD
8691	1843	9	to	to	TO
8691	1843	10	recognize	recognize	VB
8691	1843	11	the	the	DT
8691	1843	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1843	13	of	of	IN
8691	1843	14	the	the	DT
8691	1843	15	court	court	NN
8691	1843	16	and	and	CC
8691	1843	17	did	do	VBD
8691	1843	18	not	not	RB
8691	1843	19	enter	enter	VB
8691	1843	20	an	an	DT
8691	1843	21	appearance	appearance	NN
8691	1843	22	.	.	.
8691	1844	1	The	the	DT
8691	1844	2	court	court	NN
8691	1844	3	thereupon	thereupon	RB
8691	1844	4	decided	decide	VBD
8691	1844	5	to	to	TO
8691	1844	6	proceed	proceed	VB
8691	1844	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1844	8	ex	ex	NNP
8691	1844	9	parte	parte	NNP
8691	1844	10	_	_	NNP
8691	1844	11	on	on	IN
8691	1844	12	hearing	hear	VBG
8691	1844	13	the	the	DT
8691	1844	14	plaintiff;[Footnote	plaintiff;[footnote	NN
8691	1844	15	:	:	:
8691	1844	16	See	see	VB
8691	1844	17	New	New	NNP
8691	1844	18	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	1844	19	_	_	NNP
8691	1844	20	v.	v.	IN
8691	1844	21	_	_	NNP
8691	1844	22	New	New	NNP
8691	1844	23	York	York	NNP
8691	1844	24	,	,	,
8691	1844	25	5	5	CD
8691	1844	26	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1844	27	'	'	POS
8691	1844	28	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1844	29	,	,	,
8691	1844	30	283	283	CD
8691	1844	31	;	;	:
8691	1844	32	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1845	1	B.	B.	NNP
8691	1845	2	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
8691	1845	3	,	,	,
8691	1845	4	"	"	''
8691	1845	5	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1845	6	and	and	CC
8691	1845	7	State	State	NNP
8691	1845	8	Rights	Rights	NNPS
8691	1845	9	;	;	:
8691	1845	10	"	"	``
8691	1845	11	Report	Report	NNP
8691	1845	12	of	of	IN
8691	1845	13	American	American	NNP
8691	1845	14	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1845	15	Association	Association	NNP
8691	1845	16	for	for	IN
8691	1845	17	1901	1901	CD
8691	1845	18	,	,	,
8691	1845	19	II	II	NNP
8691	1845	20	,	,	,
8691	1845	21	83	83	CD
8691	1845	22	.	.	.
8691	1845	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1846	1	and	and	CC
8691	1846	2	in	in	IN
8691	1846	3	the	the	DT
8691	1846	4	later	later	JJ
8691	1846	5	cases	case	NNS
8691	1846	6	the	the	DT
8691	1846	7	States	state	NNS
8691	1846	8	have	have	VBP
8691	1846	9	appeared	appear	VBN
8691	1846	10	and	and	CC
8691	1846	11	made	make	VBD
8691	1846	12	defense	defense	NN
8691	1846	13	.	.	.
8691	1847	1	The	the	DT
8691	1847	2	court	court	NN
8691	1847	3	,	,	,
8691	1847	4	in	in	IN
8691	1847	5	one	one	CD
8691	1847	6	of	of	IN
8691	1847	7	these	these	DT
8691	1847	8	suits	suit	NNS
8691	1847	9	,	,	,
8691	1847	10	was	be	VBD
8691	1847	11	asked	ask	VBN
8691	1847	12	to	to	TO
8691	1847	13	issue	issue	VB
8691	1847	14	an	an	DT
8691	1847	15	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	1847	16	in	in	IN
8691	1847	17	favor	favor	NN
8691	1847	18	of	of	IN
8691	1847	19	the	the	DT
8691	1847	20	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
8691	1847	21	Indians	Indians	NNPS
8691	1847	22	against	against	IN
8691	1847	23	the	the	DT
8691	1847	24	State	State	NNP
8691	1847	25	of	of	IN
8691	1847	26	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1847	27	to	to	TO
8691	1847	28	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	1847	29	her	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1847	30	and	and	CC
8691	1847	31	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1847	32	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1847	33	,	,	,
8691	1847	34	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1847	35	and	and	CC
8691	1847	36	other	other	JJ
8691	1847	37	officers	officer	NNS
8691	1847	38	whatsoever	whatsoever	RB
8691	1847	39	from	from	IN
8691	1847	40	enforcing	enforce	VBG
8691	1847	41	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1847	42	of	of	IN
8691	1847	43	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1847	44	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1847	45	which	which	WDT
8691	1847	46	were	be	VBD
8691	1847	47	alleged	allege	VBN
8691	1847	48	to	to	TO
8691	1847	49	be	be	VB
8691	1847	50	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1847	51	.	.	.
8691	1848	1	The	the	DT
8691	1848	2	case	case	NN
8691	1848	3	went	go	VBD
8691	1848	4	off	off	RP
8691	1848	5	on	on	IN
8691	1848	6	another	another	DT
8691	1848	7	point	point	NN
8691	1848	8	,	,	,
8691	1848	9	but	but	CC
8691	1848	10	the	the	DT
8691	1848	11	majority	majority	NN
8691	1848	12	of	of	IN
8691	1848	13	the	the	DT
8691	1848	14	court	court	NN
8691	1848	15	intimated	intimate	VBD
8691	1848	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1848	17	to	to	TO
8691	1848	18	be	be	VB
8691	1848	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1848	20	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1848	21	that	that	IN
8691	1848	22	no	no	DT
8691	1848	23	such	such	JJ
8691	1848	24	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	1848	25	could	could	MD
8691	1848	26	properly	properly	RB
8691	1848	27	issue	issue	VB
8691	1848	28	against	against	IN
8691	1848	29	a	a	DT
8691	1848	30	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
8691	1848	31	State	state	NN
8691	1848	32	.	.	.
8691	1849	1	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	1849	2	thought	think	VBD
8691	1849	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1849	4	savored	savor	VBD
8691	1849	5	"	"	``
8691	1849	6	too	too	RB
8691	1849	7	much	much	JJ
8691	1849	8	of	of	IN
8691	1849	9	the	the	DT
8691	1849	10	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	1849	11	of	of	IN
8691	1849	12	political	political	JJ
8691	1849	13	power	power	NN
8691	1849	14	to	to	TO
8691	1849	15	be	be	VB
8691	1849	16	within	within	IN
8691	1849	17	the	the	DT
8691	1849	18	proper	proper	JJ
8691	1849	19	province	province	NN
8691	1849	20	of	of	IN
8691	1849	21	the	the	DT
8691	1849	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1849	23	department	department	NN
8691	1849	24	.	.	.
8691	1849	25	"	"	''
8691	1850	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1850	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1850	3	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	1850	4	said	say	VBD
8691	1850	5	that	that	IN
8691	1850	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1850	7	was	be	VBD
8691	1850	8	an	an	DT
8691	1850	9	attempt	attempt	NN
8691	1850	10	to	to	TO
8691	1850	11	compel	compel	VB
8691	1850	12	the	the	DT
8691	1850	13	President	President	NNP
8691	1850	14	of	of	IN
8691	1850	15	the	the	DT
8691	1850	16	United	United	NNP
8691	1850	17	States	States	NNP
8691	1850	18	,	,	,
8691	1850	19	and	and	CC
8691	1850	20	by	by	IN
8691	1850	21	indirection	indirection	NN
8691	1850	22	,	,	,
8691	1850	23	to	to	TO
8691	1850	24	do	do	VB
8691	1850	25	what	what	WP
8691	1850	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1850	27	had	have	VBD
8691	1850	28	declined	decline	VBN
8691	1850	29	to	to	TO
8691	1850	30	do	do	VB
8691	1850	31	on	on	IN
8691	1850	32	the	the	DT
8691	1850	33	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1850	34	's	's	POS
8691	1850	35	application	application	NN
8691	1850	36	to	to	IN
8691	1850	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1850	38	;	;	:
8691	1850	39	namely	namely	RB
8691	1850	40	,	,	,
8691	1850	41	"	"	''
8691	1850	42	to	to	TO
8691	1850	43	declare	declare	VB
8691	1850	44	war	war	NN
8691	1850	45	against	against	IN
8691	1850	46	a	a	DT
8691	1850	47	State	State	NNP
8691	1850	48	or	or	CC
8691	1850	49	to	to	TO
8691	1850	50	use	use	VB
8691	1850	51	the	the	DT
8691	1850	52	public	public	JJ
8691	1850	53	force	force	NN
8691	1850	54	to	to	TO
8691	1850	55	repel	repel	VB
8691	1850	56	the	the	DT
8691	1850	57	force	force	NN
8691	1850	58	and	and	CC
8691	1850	59	resist	resist	VB
8691	1850	60	the	the	DT
8691	1850	61	laws	law	NNS
8691	1850	62	of	of	IN
8691	1850	63	a	a	DT
8691	1850	64	State	state	NN
8691	1850	65	.	.	.
8691	1851	1	"	"	``
8691	1851	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1851	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1851	4	:	:	:
8691	1851	5	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
8691	1851	6	Nation	Nation	NNP
8691	1851	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1851	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	1851	9	_	_	NNP
8691	1851	10	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1851	11	,	,	,
8691	1851	12	5	5	CD
8691	1851	13	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1851	14	'	'	POS
8691	1851	15	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1851	16	,	,	,
8691	1851	17	1	1	CD
8691	1851	18	,	,	,
8691	1851	19	19	19	CD
8691	1851	20	,	,	,
8691	1851	21	29	29	CD
8691	1851	22	.	.	.
8691	1851	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1852	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1852	2	would	would	MD
8691	1852	3	be	be	VB
8691	1852	4	no	no	DT
8691	1852	5	easy	easy	JJ
8691	1852	6	thing	thing	NN
8691	1852	7	to	to	TO
8691	1852	8	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1852	9	a	a	DT
8691	1852	10	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1852	11	against	against	IN
8691	1852	12	a	a	DT
8691	1852	13	State	state	NN
8691	1852	14	should	should	MD
8691	1852	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1852	16	resist	resist	VB
8691	1852	17	.	.	.
8691	1853	1	Hence	hence	RB
8691	1853	2	the	the	DT
8691	1853	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1853	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1853	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	1853	6	been	be	VBN
8691	1853	7	justly	justly	RB
8691	1853	8	reluctant	reluctant	JJ
8691	1853	9	ever	ever	RB
8691	1853	10	to	to	TO
8691	1853	11	make	make	VB
8691	1853	12	any	any	DT
8691	1853	13	order	order	NN
8691	1853	14	which	which	WDT
8691	1853	15	would	would	MD
8691	1853	16	take	take	VB
8691	1853	17	money	money	NN
8691	1853	18	out	out	IN
8691	1853	19	of	of	IN
8691	1853	20	a	a	DT
8691	1853	21	State	State	NNP
8691	1853	22	treasury	treasury	NN
8691	1853	23	,	,	,
8691	1853	24	unless	unless	IN
8691	1853	25	in	in	IN
8691	1853	26	cases	case	NNS
8691	1853	27	where	where	WRB
8691	1853	28	the	the	DT
8691	1853	29	Treasurer	Treasurer	NNP
8691	1853	30	was	be	VBD
8691	1853	31	individually	individually	RB
8691	1853	32	sued	sue	VBN
8691	1853	33	,	,	,
8691	1853	34	and	and	CC
8691	1853	35	the	the	DT
8691	1853	36	money	money	NN
8691	1853	37	in	in	IN
8691	1853	38	dispute	dispute	NN
8691	1853	39	was	be	VBD
8691	1853	40	not	not	RB
8691	1853	41	mingled	mingle	VBN
8691	1853	42	with	with	IN
8691	1853	43	other	other	JJ
8691	1853	44	public	public	JJ
8691	1853	45	funds	fund	NNS
8691	1853	46	.	.	.
8691	1854	1	In	in	IN
8691	1854	2	1794	1794	CD
8691	1854	3	,	,	,
8691	1854	4	four	four	CD
8691	1854	5	years	year	NNS
8691	1854	6	before	before	IN
8691	1854	7	the	the	DT
8691	1854	8	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	1854	9	of	of	IN
8691	1854	10	the	the	DT
8691	1854	11	eleventh	eleventh	NNP
8691	1854	12	amendment	amendment	NNP
8691	1854	13	,	,	,
8691	1854	14	a	a	DT
8691	1854	15	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1854	16	against	against	IN
8691	1854	17	the	the	DT
8691	1854	18	State	State	NNP
8691	1854	19	of	of	IN
8691	1854	20	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1854	21	,	,	,
8691	1854	22	authorizing	authorize	VBG
8691	1854	23	an	an	DT
8691	1854	24	assessment	assessment	NN
8691	1854	25	of	of	IN
8691	1854	26	general	general	JJ
8691	1854	27	money	money	NN
8691	1854	28	damages	damage	NNS
8691	1854	29	against	against	IN
8691	1854	30	her	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1854	31	,	,	,
8691	1854	32	had	have	VBD
8691	1854	33	been	be	VBN
8691	1854	34	entered	enter	VBN
8691	1854	35	in	in	IN
8691	1854	36	the	the	DT
8691	1854	37	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1854	38	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1854	39	in	in	IN
8691	1854	40	favor	favor	NN
8691	1854	41	of	of	IN
8691	1854	42	one	one	CD
8691	1854	43	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
8691	1854	44	,	,	,
8691	1854	45	to	to	IN
8691	1854	46	whom	whom	WP
8691	1854	47	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1854	48	owed	owe	VBD
8691	1854	49	a	a	DT
8691	1854	50	debt	debt	NN
8691	1854	51	.	.	.
8691	1855	1	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1855	2	had	have	VBD
8691	1855	3	refused	refuse	VBN
8691	1855	4	to	to	TO
8691	1855	5	enter	enter	VB
8691	1855	6	an	an	DT
8691	1855	7	appearance	appearance	NN
8691	1855	8	in	in	IN
8691	1855	9	the	the	DT
8691	1855	10	suit	suit	NN
8691	1855	11	,	,	,
8691	1855	12	and	and	CC
8691	1855	13	in	in	IN
8691	1855	14	anticipation	anticipation	NN
8691	1855	15	of	of	IN
8691	1855	16	this	this	DT
8691	1855	17	result	result	NN
8691	1855	18	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1855	19	House	House	NNP
8691	1855	20	of	of	IN
8691	1855	21	Representatives	Representatives	NNPS
8691	1855	22	had	have	VBD
8691	1855	23	resolved	resolve	VBN
8691	1855	24	,	,	,
8691	1855	25	in	in	IN
8691	1855	26	1793	1793	CD
8691	1855	27	,	,	,
8691	1855	28	that	that	IN
8691	1855	29	if	if	IN
8691	1855	30	any	any	DT
8691	1855	31	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	1855	32	marshal	marshal	NN
8691	1855	33	should	should	MD
8691	1855	34	attempt	attempt	VB
8691	1855	35	to	to	TO
8691	1855	36	levy	levy	VB
8691	1855	37	an	an	DT
8691	1855	38	execution	execution	NN
8691	1855	39	on	on	IN
8691	1855	40	such	such	PDT
8691	1855	41	a	a	DT
8691	1855	42	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1855	43	against	against	IN
8691	1855	44	the	the	DT
8691	1855	45	State	State	NNP
8691	1855	46	,	,	,
8691	1855	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1855	48	should	should	MD
8691	1855	49	be	be	VB
8691	1855	50	a	a	DT
8691	1855	51	felony	felony	NN
8691	1855	52	,	,	,
8691	1855	53	and	and	CC
8691	1855	54	on	on	IN
8691	1855	55	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	1855	56	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1855	57	should	should	MD
8691	1855	58	be	be	VB
8691	1855	59	hanged	hang	VBN
8691	1855	60	.	.	.
8691	1856	1	The	the	DT
8691	1856	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	1856	3	had	have	VBD
8691	1856	4	not	not	RB
8691	1856	5	concurred	concur	VBN
8691	1856	6	in	in	IN
8691	1856	7	this	this	DT
8691	1856	8	measure	measure	NN
8691	1856	9	,	,	,
8691	1856	10	but	but	CC
8691	1856	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1856	12	reflected	reflect	VBD
8691	1856	13	pretty	pretty	RB
8691	1856	14	closely	closely	RB
8691	1856	15	the	the	DT
8691	1856	16	general	general	JJ
8691	1856	17	state	state	NN
8691	1856	18	of	of	IN
8691	1856	19	public	public	JJ
8691	1856	20	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	1856	21	in	in	IN
8691	1856	22	a	a	DT
8691	1856	23	State	state	NN
8691	1856	24	largely	largely	RB
8691	1856	25	indebted	indebted	JJ
8691	1856	26	for	for	IN
8691	1856	27	what	what	WP
8691	1856	28	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1856	29	people	people	NNS
8691	1856	30	thought	think	VBD
8691	1856	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1856	32	belonged	belong	VBD
8691	1856	33	to	to	IN
8691	1856	34	the	the	DT
8691	1856	35	United	United	NNP
8691	1856	36	States	States	NNP
8691	1856	37	to	to	TO
8691	1856	38	pay	pay	VB
8691	1856	39	.	.	.
8691	1857	1	The	the	DT
8691	1857	2	eleventh	eleventh	JJ
8691	1857	3	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	1857	4	was	be	VBD
8691	1857	5	proposed	propose	VBN
8691	1857	6	by	by	IN
8691	1857	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1857	8	during	during	IN
8691	1857	9	the	the	DT
8691	1857	10	term	term	NN
8691	1857	11	of	of	IN
8691	1857	12	court	court	NN
8691	1857	13	at	at	IN
8691	1857	14	which	which	WDT
8691	1857	15	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1857	16	was	be	VBD
8691	1857	17	entered	enter	VBN
8691	1857	18	,	,	,
8691	1857	19	but	but	CC
8691	1857	20	not	not	RB
8691	1857	21	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1857	22	until	until	IN
8691	1857	23	1798	1798	CD
8691	1857	24	.	.	.
8691	1858	1	Meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
8691	1858	2	,	,	,
8691	1858	3	the	the	DT
8691	1858	4	court	court	NN
8691	1858	5	had	have	VBD
8691	1858	6	thought	think	VBN
8691	1858	7	best	well	RBS
8691	1858	8	to	to	TO
8691	1858	9	defer	defer	VB
8691	1858	10	further	further	JJ
8691	1858	11	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1858	12	,	,	,
8691	1858	13	and	and	CC
8691	1858	14	none	none	NN
8691	1858	15	were	be	VBD
8691	1858	16	ever	ever	RB
8691	1858	17	taken	take	VBN
8691	1858	18	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	1858	19	.	.	.
8691	1859	1	The	the	DT
8691	1859	2	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1859	3	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1859	4	won	win	VBD
8691	1859	5	a	a	DT
8691	1859	6	barren	barren	JJ
8691	1859	7	victory	victory	NN
8691	1859	8	.	.	.
8691	1860	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1860	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1860	3	:	:	:
8691	1860	4	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1861	1	B.	B.	NNP
8691	1861	2	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
8691	1861	3	,	,	,
8691	1861	4	"	"	''
8691	1861	5	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1861	6	and	and	CC
8691	1861	7	State	State	NNP
8691	1861	8	Rights	Rights	NNPS
8691	1861	9	,	,	,
8691	1861	10	"	"	''
8691	1861	11	Report	Report	NNP
8691	1861	12	of	of	IN
8691	1861	13	American	American	NNP
8691	1861	14	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1861	15	Association	Association	NNP
8691	1861	16	for	for	IN
8691	1861	17	1901	1901	CD
8691	1861	18	,	,	,
8691	1861	19	II	II	NNP
8691	1861	20	,	,	,
8691	1861	21	25	25	CD
8691	1861	22	.	.	.
8691	1861	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1862	1	The	the	DT
8691	1862	2	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	1862	3	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1862	4	of	of	IN
8691	1862	5	the	the	DT
8691	1862	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1862	7	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1862	8	of	of	IN
8691	1862	9	the	the	DT
8691	1862	10	United	United	NNP
8691	1862	11	States	States	NNP
8691	1862	12	over	over	IN
8691	1862	13	States	States	NNP
8691	1862	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	1862	15	large	large	JJ
8691	1862	16	,	,	,
8691	1862	17	for	for	IN
8691	1862	18	the	the	DT
8691	1862	19	State	State	NNP
8691	1862	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	1862	21	the	the	DT
8691	1862	22	party	party	NN
8691	1862	23	in	in	IN
8691	1862	24	whose	whose	WP$
8691	1862	25	name	name	NN
8691	1862	26	all	all	DT
8691	1862	27	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	1862	28	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	1862	29	in	in	IN
8691	1862	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1862	31	courts	court	NNS
8691	1862	32	are	be	VBP
8691	1862	33	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1862	34	,	,	,
8691	1862	35	and	and	CC
8691	1862	36	in	in	IN
8691	1862	37	many	many	JJ
8691	1862	38	of	of	IN
8691	1862	39	these	these	DT
8691	1862	40	the	the	DT
8691	1862	41	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	1862	42	sets	set	VBZ
8691	1862	43	up	up	RP
8691	1862	44	some	some	DT
8691	1862	45	claim	claim	NN
8691	1862	46	under	under	IN
8691	1862	47	the	the	DT
8691	1862	48	laws	law	NNS
8691	1862	49	of	of	IN
8691	1862	50	the	the	DT
8691	1862	51	United	United	NNP
8691	1862	52	States	States	NNP
8691	1862	53	which	which	WDT
8691	1862	54	is	be	VBZ
8691	1862	55	overruled	overrule	VBN
8691	1862	56	.	.	.
8691	1863	1	Here	here	RB
8691	1863	2	again	again	RB
8691	1863	3	,	,	,
8691	1863	4	in	in	IN
8691	1863	5	case	case	NN
8691	1863	6	of	of	IN
8691	1863	7	resistance	resistance	NN
8691	1863	8	,	,	,
8691	1863	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1863	10	would	would	MD
8691	1863	11	be	be	VB
8691	1863	12	difficult	difficult	JJ
8691	1863	13	to	to	TO
8691	1863	14	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1863	15	a	a	DT
8691	1863	16	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1863	17	of	of	IN
8691	1863	18	reversal	reversal	NN
8691	1863	19	.	.	.
8691	1864	1	Shortly	shortly	RB
8691	1864	2	before	before	IN
8691	1864	3	the	the	DT
8691	1864	4	action	action	NN
8691	1864	5	of	of	IN
8691	1864	6	the	the	DT
8691	1864	7	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
8691	1864	8	Nation	Nation	NNP
8691	1864	9	for	for	IN
8691	1864	10	an	an	DT
8691	1864	11	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	1864	12	,	,	,
8691	1864	13	the	the	DT
8691	1864	14	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1864	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	1864	16	had	have	VBD
8691	1864	17	sentenced	sentence	VBN
8691	1864	18	Corn	Corn	NNP
8691	1864	19	Tassel	Tassel	NNP
8691	1864	20	,	,	,
8691	1864	21	one	one	CD
8691	1864	22	of	of	IN
8691	1864	23	the	the	DT
8691	1864	24	tribe	tribe	NN
8691	1864	25	,	,	,
8691	1864	26	to	to	IN
8691	1864	27	death	death	NN
8691	1864	28	for	for	IN
8691	1864	29	murdering	murder	VBG
8691	1864	30	another	another	DT
8691	1864	31	of	of	IN
8691	1864	32	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1864	33	.	.	.
8691	1865	1	Tassel	Tassel	NNP
8691	1865	2	had	have	VBD
8691	1865	3	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	1865	4	that	that	IN
8691	1865	5	by	by	IN
8691	1865	6	the	the	DT
8691	1865	7	laws	law	NNS
8691	1865	8	of	of	IN
8691	1865	9	the	the	DT
8691	1865	10	United	United	NNP
8691	1865	11	States	States	NNP
8691	1865	12	and	and	CC
8691	1865	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1865	14	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	1865	15	with	with	IN
8691	1865	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1865	17	nation	nation	NN
8691	1865	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1865	19	could	could	MD
8691	1865	20	only	only	RB
8691	1865	21	be	be	VB
8691	1865	22	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
8691	1865	23	before	before	IN
8691	1865	24	one	one	CD
8691	1865	25	of	of	IN
8691	1865	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1865	27	tribal	tribal	JJ
8691	1865	28	courts	court	NNS
8691	1865	29	.	.	.
8691	1866	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1866	2	obtained	obtain	VBD
8691	1866	3	a	a	DT
8691	1866	4	writ	writ	NN
8691	1866	5	of	of	IN
8691	1866	6	error	error	NN
8691	1866	7	from	from	IN
8691	1866	8	the	the	DT
8691	1866	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1866	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1866	11	to	to	TO
8691	1866	12	review	review	VB
8691	1866	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1866	14	case	case	NN
8691	1866	15	on	on	IN
8691	1866	16	this	this	DT
8691	1866	17	ground	ground	NN
8691	1866	18	.	.	.
8691	1867	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1867	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1867	3	served	serve	VBN
8691	1867	4	,	,	,
8691	1867	5	but	but	CC
8691	1867	6	before	before	IN
8691	1867	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1867	8	could	could	MD
8691	1867	9	be	be	VB
8691	1867	10	heard	hear	VBN
8691	1867	11	the	the	DT
8691	1867	12	day	day	NN
8691	1867	13	set	set	VBN
8691	1867	14	for	for	IN
8691	1867	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1867	16	execution	execution	NN
8691	1867	17	had	have	VBD
8691	1867	18	arrived	arrive	VBN
8691	1867	19	.	.	.
8691	1868	1	By	by	IN
8691	1868	2	the	the	DT
8691	1868	3	laws	law	NNS
8691	1868	4	of	of	IN
8691	1868	5	the	the	DT
8691	1868	6	United	United	NNP
8691	1868	7	States	States	NNP
8691	1868	8	the	the	DT
8691	1868	9	allowance	allowance	NN
8691	1868	10	of	of	IN
8691	1868	11	the	the	DT
8691	1868	12	writ	writ	NNP
8691	1868	13	of	of	IN
8691	1868	14	error	error	NN
8691	1868	15	superseded	supersede	VBD
8691	1868	16	the	the	DT
8691	1868	17	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	1868	18	until	until	IN
8691	1868	19	the	the	DT
8691	1868	20	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1868	21	should	should	MD
8691	1868	22	be	be	VB
8691	1868	23	decided	decide	VBN
8691	1868	24	.	.	.
8691	1869	1	The	the	DT
8691	1869	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1869	3	laid	lay	VBD
8691	1869	4	the	the	DT
8691	1869	5	matter	matter	NN
8691	1869	6	before	before	IN
8691	1869	7	the	the	DT
8691	1869	8	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1869	9	,	,	,
8691	1869	10	saying	say	VBG
8691	1869	11	that	that	IN
8691	1869	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1869	13	did	do	VBD
8691	1869	14	not	not	RB
8691	1869	15	propose	propose	VB
8691	1869	16	to	to	TO
8691	1869	17	regard	regard	VB
8691	1869	18	any	any	DT
8691	1869	19	orders	order	NNS
8691	1869	20	from	from	IN
8691	1869	21	the	the	DT
8691	1869	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1869	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1869	24	interfering	interfere	VBG
8691	1869	25	with	with	IN
8691	1869	26	those	those	DT
8691	1869	27	of	of	IN
8691	1869	28	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1869	29	courts	court	NNS
8691	1869	30	,	,	,
8691	1869	31	and	and	CC
8691	1869	32	should	should	MD
8691	1869	33	resist	resist	VB
8691	1869	34	any	any	DT
8691	1869	35	attempt	attempt	NN
8691	1869	36	to	to	TO
8691	1869	37	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1869	38	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1869	39	with	with	IN
8691	1869	40	all	all	PDT
8691	1869	41	the	the	DT
8691	1869	42	forces	force	NNS
8691	1869	43	at	at	IN
8691	1869	44	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1869	45	command	command	NN
8691	1869	46	.	.	.
8691	1870	1	The	the	DT
8691	1870	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	1870	3	approved	approve	VBD
8691	1870	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1870	5	position,[Footnote	position,[Footnote	NNS
8691	1870	6	:	:	:
8691	1870	7	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1871	1	B.	B.	NNP
8691	1871	2	Phillips	Phillips	NNP
8691	1871	3	,	,	,
8691	1871	4	"	"	''
8691	1871	5	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1871	6	and	and	CC
8691	1871	7	State	State	NNP
8691	1871	8	Rights	Rights	NNPS
8691	1871	9	,	,	,
8691	1871	10	"	"	''
8691	1871	11	Report	Report	NNP
8691	1871	12	of	of	IN
8691	1871	13	American	American	NNP
8691	1871	14	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	1871	15	Association	Association	NNP
8691	1871	16	for	for	IN
8691	1871	17	1901	1901	CD
8691	1871	18	,	,	,
8691	1871	19	II	II	NNP
8691	1871	20	,	,	,
8691	1871	21	77	77	CD
8691	1871	22	.	.	.
8691	1871	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1872	1	and	and	CC
8691	1872	2	Tassel	Tassel	NNP
8691	1872	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1872	4	hanged	hang	VBN
8691	1872	5	on	on	IN
8691	1872	6	the	the	DT
8691	1872	7	day	day	NN
8691	1872	8	originally	originally	RB
8691	1872	9	set	set	VBN
8691	1872	10	.	.	.
8691	1873	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1873	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1873	3	:	:	:
8691	1873	4	"	"	``
8691	1873	5	Memoirs	Memoirs	NNP
8691	1873	6	of	of	IN
8691	1873	7	William	William	NNP
8691	1873	8	Wirt	Wirt	NNP
8691	1873	9	,	,	,
8691	1873	10	"	"	``
8691	1873	11	II	II	NNP
8691	1873	12	,	,	,
8691	1873	13	291	291	CD
8691	1873	14	.	.	.
8691	1873	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1874	1	There	there	EX
8691	1874	2	had	have	VBD
8691	1874	3	been	be	VBN
8691	1874	4	no	no	DT
8691	1874	5	time	time	NN
8691	1874	6	to	to	TO
8691	1874	7	resort	resort	VB
8691	1874	8	again	again	RB
8691	1874	9	to	to	IN
8691	1874	10	the	the	DT
8691	1874	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1874	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1874	13	for	for	IN
8691	1874	14	relief	relief	NN
8691	1874	15	,	,	,
8691	1874	16	and	and	CC
8691	1874	17	as	as	RB
8691	1874	18	soon	soon	RB
8691	1874	19	as	as	IN
8691	1874	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1874	21	was	be	VBD
8691	1874	22	dead	dead	JJ
8691	1874	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1874	24	writ	writ	NN
8691	1874	25	of	of	IN
8691	1874	26	error	error	NN
8691	1874	27	fell	fall	VBD
8691	1874	28	with	with	IN
8691	1874	29	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1874	30	,	,	,
8691	1874	31	for	for	IN
8691	1874	32	such	such	PDT
8691	1874	33	a	a	DT
8691	1874	34	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1874	35	is	be	VBZ
8691	1874	36	legally	legally	RB
8691	1874	37	terminated	terminate	VBN
8691	1874	38	if	if	IN
8691	1874	39	the	the	DT
8691	1874	40	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1874	41	in	in	IN
8691	1874	42	error	error	NN
8691	1874	43	dies	die	VBZ
8691	1874	44	.	.	.
8691	1875	1	Two	two	CD
8691	1875	2	years	year	NNS
8691	1875	3	later	later	RB
8691	1875	4	,	,	,
8691	1875	5	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
8691	1876	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1876	2	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
8691	1876	3	,	,	,
8691	1876	4	a	a	DT
8691	1876	5	missionary	missionary	NN
8691	1876	6	who	who	WP
8691	1876	7	had	have	VBD
8691	1876	8	gone	go	VBN
8691	1876	9	to	to	TO
8691	1876	10	teach	teach	VB
8691	1876	11	the	the	DT
8691	1876	12	Christian	christian	JJ
8691	1876	13	religion	religion	NN
8691	1876	14	to	to	IN
8691	1876	15	the	the	DT
8691	1876	16	Cherokees	Cherokees	NNPS
8691	1876	17	,	,	,
8691	1876	18	was	be	VBD
8691	1876	19	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	1876	20	in	in	IN
8691	1876	21	the	the	DT
8691	1876	22	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	1876	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1876	24	of	of	IN
8691	1876	25	Gwinnet	Gwinnet	NNP
8691	1876	26	County	County	NNP
8691	1876	27	on	on	IN
8691	1876	28	an	an	DT
8691	1876	29	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	1876	30	for	for	IN
8691	1876	31	residing	reside	VBG
8691	1876	32	among	among	IN
8691	1876	33	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1876	34	without	without	IN
8691	1876	35	a	a	DT
8691	1876	36	license	license	NN
8691	1876	37	from	from	IN
8691	1876	38	the	the	DT
8691	1876	39	State	State	NNP
8691	1876	40	,	,	,
8691	1876	41	and	and	CC
8691	1876	42	sent	send	VBD
8691	1876	43	to	to	IN
8691	1876	44	the	the	DT
8691	1876	45	State	State	NNP
8691	1876	46	prison	prison	NN
8691	1876	47	.	.	.
8691	1877	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1877	2	appealed	appeal	VBD
8691	1877	3	to	to	IN
8691	1877	4	the	the	DT
8691	1877	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1877	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1877	7	of	of	IN
8691	1877	8	the	the	DT
8691	1877	9	United	United	NNP
8691	1877	10	States	States	NNP
8691	1877	11	,	,	,
8691	1877	12	which	which	WDT
8691	1877	13	decided	decide	VBD
8691	1877	14	that	that	IN
8691	1877	15	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1877	16	had	have	VBD
8691	1877	17	no	no	DT
8691	1877	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1877	19	over	over	IN
8691	1877	20	the	the	DT
8691	1877	21	Cherokee	Cherokee	NNP
8691	1877	22	reservation	reservation	NN
8691	1877	23	,	,	,
8691	1877	24	and	and	CC
8691	1877	25	could	could	MD
8691	1877	26	not	not	RB
8691	1877	27	require	require	VB
8691	1877	28	such	such	JJ
8691	1877	29	licenses	license	NNS
8691	1877	30	.	.	.
8691	1878	1	The	the	DT
8691	1878	2	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1878	3	against	against	IN
8691	1878	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1878	5	was	be	VBD
8691	1878	6	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1878	7	reversed	reverse	VBN
8691	1878	8	,	,	,
8691	1878	9	and	and	CC
8691	1878	10	an	an	DT
8691	1878	11	order	order	NN
8691	1878	12	made	make	VBD
8691	1878	13	"	"	''
8691	1878	14	that	that	IN
8691	1878	15	all	all	DT
8691	1878	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1878	17	on	on	IN
8691	1878	18	the	the	DT
8691	1878	19	said	say	VBN
8691	1878	20	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	1878	21	do	do	VBP
8691	1878	22	forever	forever	RB
8691	1878	23	surcease	surcease	VB
8691	1878	24	;	;	:
8691	1878	25	and	and	CC
8691	1878	26	that	that	IN
8691	1878	27	the	the	DT
8691	1878	28	said	say	VBD
8691	1878	29	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
8691	1878	30	A.	a.	NN
8691	1878	31	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
8691	1878	32	be	be	VB
8691	1878	33	and	and	CC
8691	1878	34	hereby	hereby	NNP
8691	1878	35	is	be	VBZ
8691	1878	36	henceforth	henceforth	RB
8691	1878	37	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
8691	1878	38	therefrom	therefrom	NN
8691	1878	39	,	,	,
8691	1878	40	and	and	CC
8691	1878	41	that	that	IN
8691	1878	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1878	43	go	go	VB
8691	1878	44	thereof	thereof	RB
8691	1878	45	quit	quit	VBD
8691	1878	46	without	without	IN
8691	1878	47	day	day	NN
8691	1878	48	,	,	,
8691	1878	49	and	and	CC
8691	1878	50	that	that	IN
8691	1878	51	a	a	DT
8691	1878	52	special	special	JJ
8691	1878	53	mandate	mandate	NN
8691	1878	54	do	do	VBP
8691	1878	55	go	go	VB
8691	1878	56	from	from	IN
8691	1878	57	this	this	DT
8691	1878	58	court	court	NN
8691	1878	59	to	to	IN
8691	1878	60	the	the	DT
8691	1878	61	said	say	VBN
8691	1878	62	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	1878	63	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1878	64	to	to	TO
8691	1878	65	carry	carry	VB
8691	1878	66	the	the	DT
8691	1878	67	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1878	68	into	into	IN
8691	1878	69	execution	execution	NN
8691	1878	70	.	.	.
8691	1879	1	"	"	``
8691	1879	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1879	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1879	4	:	:	:
8691	1879	5	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
8691	1879	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1879	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	1879	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1879	9	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1879	10	,	,	,
8691	1879	11	6	6	CD
8691	1879	12	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1879	13	'	'	POS
8691	1879	14	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1879	15	,	,	,
8691	1879	16	515	515	CD
8691	1879	17	,	,	,
8691	1879	18	596	596	CD
8691	1879	19	.	.	.
8691	1879	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1880	1	The	the	DT
8691	1880	2	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	1880	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1880	4	of	of	IN
8691	1880	5	Gwinnet	Gwinnet	NNP
8691	1880	6	County	County	NNP
8691	1880	7	paid	pay	VBD
8691	1880	8	no	no	DT
8691	1880	9	respect	respect	NN
8691	1880	10	to	to	IN
8691	1880	11	this	this	DT
8691	1880	12	mandate	mandate	NN
8691	1880	13	;	;	:
8691	1880	14	the	the	DT
8691	1880	15	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1880	16	of	of	IN
8691	1880	17	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1880	18	characterized	characterize	VBD
8691	1880	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1880	20	as	as	IN
8691	1880	21	an	an	DT
8691	1880	22	attempt	attempt	NN
8691	1880	23	at	at	IN
8691	1880	24	usurpation	usurpation	NN
8691	1880	25	which	which	WDT
8691	1880	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1880	27	should	should	MD
8691	1880	28	meet	meet	VB
8691	1880	29	in	in	IN
8691	1880	30	a	a	DT
8691	1880	31	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	1880	32	of	of	IN
8691	1880	33	determined	determine	VBN
8691	1880	34	resistance	resistance	NN
8691	1880	35	;	;	:
8691	1880	36	and	and	CC
8691	1880	37	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
8691	1880	38	remained	remain	VBD
8691	1880	39	in	in	IN
8691	1880	40	prison	prison	NN
8691	1880	41	until	until	IN
8691	1880	42	,	,	,
8691	1880	43	on	on	IN
8691	1880	44	expressing	express	VBG
8691	1880	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1880	46	willingness	willingness	NN
8691	1880	47	to	to	TO
8691	1880	48	abandon	abandon	VB
8691	1880	49	any	any	DT
8691	1880	50	further	further	JJ
8691	1880	51	efforts	effort	NNS
8691	1880	52	for	for	IN
8691	1880	53	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1880	54	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	1880	55	by	by	IN
8691	1880	56	authority	authority	NN
8691	1880	57	of	of	IN
8691	1880	58	the	the	DT
8691	1880	59	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1880	60	on	on	IN
8691	1880	61	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1880	62	writ	writ	NN
8691	1880	63	of	of	IN
8691	1880	64	error	error	NN
8691	1880	65	,	,	,
8691	1880	66	the	the	DT
8691	1880	67	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	1880	68	gave	give	VBD
8691	1880	69	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1880	70	a	a	DT
8691	1880	71	pardon	pardon	NN
8691	1880	72	on	on	IN
8691	1880	73	condition	condition	NN
8691	1880	74	of	of	IN
8691	1880	75	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1880	76	leaving	leave	VBG
8691	1880	77	the	the	DT
8691	1880	78	State	State	NNP
8691	1880	79	.	.	.
8691	1881	1	A	a	DT
8691	1881	2	year	year	NN
8691	1881	3	later	later	RB
8691	1881	4	,	,	,
8691	1881	5	James	James	NNP
8691	1881	6	Grady	Grady	NNP
8691	1881	7	,	,	,
8691	1881	8	who	who	WP
8691	1881	9	lay	lie	VBD
8691	1881	10	under	under	IN
8691	1881	11	a	a	DT
8691	1881	12	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	1881	13	of	of	IN
8691	1881	14	death	death	NN
8691	1881	15	under	under	IN
8691	1881	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1881	17	similar	similar	JJ
8691	1881	18	to	to	IN
8691	1881	19	those	those	DT
8691	1881	20	in	in	IN
8691	1881	21	Tassel	Tassel	NNP
8691	1881	22	's	's	POS
8691	1881	23	case	case	NN
8691	1881	24	,	,	,
8691	1881	25	like	like	IN
8691	1881	26	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1881	27	obtained	obtain	VBD
8691	1881	28	a	a	DT
8691	1881	29	writ	writ	NN
8691	1881	30	of	of	IN
8691	1881	31	error	error	NN
8691	1881	32	from	from	IN
8691	1881	33	the	the	DT
8691	1881	34	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1881	35	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1881	36	of	of	IN
8691	1881	37	the	the	DT
8691	1881	38	United	United	NNP
8691	1881	39	States	States	NNP
8691	1881	40	and	and	CC
8691	1881	41	had	have	VBD
8691	1881	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1881	43	served	serve	VBN
8691	1881	44	on	on	IN
8691	1881	45	the	the	DT
8691	1881	46	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1881	47	court	court	NN
8691	1881	48	,	,	,
8691	1881	49	only	only	RB
8691	1881	50	to	to	TO
8691	1881	51	find	find	VB
8691	1881	52	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1881	53	disregarded	disregard	VBN
8691	1881	54	.	.	.
8691	1882	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1882	2	execution	execution	NN
8691	1882	3	,	,	,
8691	1882	4	in	in	IN
8691	1882	5	spite	spite	NN
8691	1882	6	of	of	IN
8691	1882	7	the	the	DT
8691	1882	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1882	9	"	"	``
8691	1882	10	supersedeas	supersedea	NNS
8691	1882	11	"	"	''
8691	1882	12	_	_	NNP
8691	1882	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1882	14	goes	go	VBZ
8691	1882	15	by	by	IN
8691	1882	16	law	law	NN
8691	1882	17	with	with	IN
8691	1882	18	every	every	DT
8691	1882	19	such	such	JJ
8691	1882	20	suit	suit	NN
8691	1882	21	,	,	,
8691	1882	22	was	be	VBD
8691	1882	23	the	the	DT
8691	1882	24	last	last	JJ
8691	1882	25	of	of	IN
8691	1882	26	this	this	DT
8691	1882	27	series	series	NN
8691	1882	28	of	of	IN
8691	1882	29	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1882	30	outrages	outrage	NNS
8691	1882	31	.	.	.
8691	1883	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1883	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1883	3	:	:	:
8691	1883	4	"	"	``
8691	1883	5	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	1883	6	and	and	CC
8691	1883	7	State	State	NNP
8691	1883	8	Rights	Rights	NNPS
8691	1883	9	,	,	,
8691	1883	10	"	"	''
8691	1883	11	83	83	CD
8691	1883	12	.	.	.
8691	1883	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1884	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1884	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1884	3	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
8691	1884	4	for	for	IN
8691	1884	5	the	the	DT
8691	1884	6	sufferers	sufferer	NNS
8691	1884	7	in	in	IN
8691	1884	8	these	these	DT
8691	1884	9	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1884	10	that	that	WDT
8691	1884	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1884	12	took	take	VBD
8691	1884	13	place	place	NN
8691	1884	14	at	at	IN
8691	1884	15	a	a	DT
8691	1884	16	time	time	NN
8691	1884	17	when	when	WRB
8691	1884	18	the	the	DT
8691	1884	19	cry	cry	NN
8691	1884	20	of	of	IN
8691	1884	21	"	"	``
8691	1884	22	State	State	NNP
8691	1884	23	Rights	Rights	NNPS
8691	1884	24	"	"	''
8691	1884	25	was	be	VBD
8691	1884	26	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	1884	27	loud	loud	JJ
8691	1884	28	and	and	CC
8691	1884	29	general	general	JJ
8691	1884	30	in	in	IN
8691	1884	31	the	the	DT
8691	1884	32	South	South	NNP
8691	1884	33	.	.	.
8691	1885	1	South	South	NNP
8691	1885	2	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	1885	3	had	have	VBD
8691	1885	4	been	be	VBN
8691	1885	5	quieted	quiet	VBN
8691	1885	6	with	with	IN
8691	1885	7	difficulty	difficulty	NN
8691	1885	8	by	by	IN
8691	1885	9	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	1885	10	's	's	POS
8691	1885	11	action	action	NN
8691	1885	12	in	in	IN
8691	1885	13	regard	regard	NN
8691	1885	14	to	to	IN
8691	1885	15	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1885	16	nullification	nullification	NN
8691	1885	17	ordinance	ordinance	NN
8691	1885	18	,	,	,
8691	1885	19	and	and	CC
8691	1885	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1885	21	did	do	VBD
8691	1885	22	not	not	RB
8691	1885	23	wish	wish	VB
8691	1885	24	to	to	TO
8691	1885	25	go	go	VB
8691	1885	26	farther	farther	RB
8691	1885	27	than	than	IN
8691	1885	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1885	29	thought	think	VBD
8691	1885	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1885	31	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1885	32	in	in	IN
8691	1885	33	insisting	insist	VBG
8691	1885	34	on	on	IN
8691	1885	35	the	the	DT
8691	1885	36	supremacy	supremacy	NN
8691	1885	37	of	of	IN
8691	1885	38	the	the	DT
8691	1885	39	United	United	NNP
8691	1885	40	States	States	NNP
8691	1885	41	.	.	.
8691	1886	1	Since	since	IN
8691	1886	2	the	the	DT
8691	1886	3	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	1886	4	War	War	NNP
8691	1886	5	,	,	,
8691	1886	6	such	such	JJ
8691	1886	7	defiance	defiance	NN
8691	1886	8	by	by	IN
8691	1886	9	a	a	DT
8691	1886	10	State	state	NN
8691	1886	11	of	of	IN
8691	1886	12	the	the	DT
8691	1886	13	authority	authority	NN
8691	1886	14	of	of	IN
8691	1886	15	the	the	DT
8691	1886	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1886	17	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1886	18	of	of	IN
8691	1886	19	the	the	DT
8691	1886	20	United	United	NNP
8691	1886	21	States	States	NNP
8691	1886	22	has	have	VBZ
8691	1886	23	been	be	VBN
8691	1886	24	unknown	unknown	JJ
8691	1886	25	and	and	CC
8691	1886	26	would	would	MD
8691	1886	27	be	be	VB
8691	1886	28	almost	almost	RB
8691	1886	29	inconceivable	inconceivable	JJ
8691	1886	30	.	.	.
8691	1887	1	The	the	DT
8691	1887	2	absolute	absolute	JJ
8691	1887	3	right	right	NN
8691	1887	4	of	of	IN
8691	1887	5	the	the	DT
8691	1887	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1887	7	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1887	8	of	of	IN
8691	1887	9	the	the	DT
8691	1887	10	United	United	NNP
8691	1887	11	States	States	NNP
8691	1887	12	to	to	IN
8691	1887	13	pronounce	pronounce	NN
8691	1887	14	finally	finally	RB
8691	1887	15	,	,	,
8691	1887	16	so	so	RB
8691	1887	17	far	far	RB
8691	1887	18	as	as	IN
8691	1887	19	the	the	DT
8691	1887	20	States	state	NNS
8691	1887	21	are	be	VBP
8691	1887	22	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	1887	23	,	,	,
8691	1887	24	upon	upon	IN
8691	1887	25	every	every	DT
8691	1887	26	question	question	NN
8691	1887	27	brought	bring	VBN
8691	1887	28	before	before	IN
8691	1887	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1887	30	as	as	IN
8691	1887	31	to	to	IN
8691	1887	32	the	the	DT
8691	1887	33	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	1887	34	and	and	CC
8691	1887	35	effect	effect	NN
8691	1887	36	of	of	IN
8691	1887	37	the	the	DT
8691	1887	38	national	national	JJ
8691	1887	39	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1887	40	,	,	,
8691	1887	41	has	have	VBZ
8691	1887	42	come	come	VBN
8691	1887	43	to	to	TO
8691	1887	44	be	be	VB
8691	1887	45	universally	universally	RB
8691	1887	46	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
8691	1887	47	.	.	.
8691	1888	1	The	the	DT
8691	1888	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1888	3	of	of	IN
8691	1888	4	a	a	DT
8691	1888	5	State	State	NNP
8691	1888	6	have	have	VBP
8691	1888	7	the	the	DT
8691	1888	8	same	same	JJ
8691	1888	9	right	right	NN
8691	1888	10	,	,	,
8691	1888	11	except	except	IN
8691	1888	12	that	that	IN
8691	1888	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1888	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	1888	15	not	not	RB
8691	1888	16	final	final	JJ
8691	1888	17	.	.	.
8691	1889	1	This	this	DT
8691	1889	2	the	the	DT
8691	1889	3	original	original	JJ
8691	1889	4	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
8691	1889	5	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1889	6	of	of	IN
8691	1889	7	1789	1789	CD
8691	1889	8	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1889	9	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	1889	10	.	.	.
8691	1890	1	25	25	CD
8691	1890	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1890	3	fully	fully	RB
8691	1890	4	recognized	recognize	VBN
8691	1890	5	.	.	.
8691	1891	1	Something	something	NN
8691	1891	2	like	like	IN
8691	1891	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1891	4	may	may	MD
8691	1891	5	belong	belong	VB
8691	1891	6	to	to	IN
8691	1891	7	a	a	DT
8691	1891	8	Convention	Convention	NNP
8691	1891	9	of	of	IN
8691	1891	10	the	the	DT
8691	1891	11	whole	whole	JJ
8691	1891	12	people	people	NNS
8691	1891	13	of	of	IN
8691	1891	14	a	a	DT
8691	1891	15	State	State	NNP
8691	1891	16	,	,	,
8691	1891	17	called	call	VBD
8691	1891	18	to	to	TO
8691	1891	19	act	act	VB
8691	1891	20	upon	upon	IN
8691	1891	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1891	22	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	1891	23	concerns	concern	NNS
8691	1891	24	;	;	:
8691	1891	25	for	for	IN
8691	1891	26	that	that	DT
8691	1891	27	would	would	MD
8691	1891	28	represent	represent	VB
8691	1891	29	the	the	DT
8691	1891	30	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1891	31	of	of	IN
8691	1891	32	the	the	DT
8691	1891	33	State	State	NNP
8691	1891	34	as	as	IN
8691	1891	35	a	a	DT
8691	1891	36	whole	whole	NN
8691	1891	37	in	in	IN
8691	1891	38	the	the	DT
8691	1891	39	fullest	full	JJS
8691	1891	40	manner	manner	NN
8691	1891	41	.	.	.
8691	1892	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1892	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1892	3	from	from	IN
8691	1892	4	such	such	PDT
8691	1892	5	a	a	DT
8691	1892	6	convention	convention	NN
8691	1892	7	that	that	IN
8691	1892	8	the	the	DT
8691	1892	9	nullifying	nullify	VBG
8691	1892	10	ordinance	ordinance	NN
8691	1892	11	of	of	IN
8691	1892	12	1832	1832	CD
8691	1892	13	proceeded	proceed	VBD
8691	1892	14	,	,	,
8691	1892	15	but	but	CC
8691	1892	16	the	the	DT
8691	1892	17	vice	vice	NN
8691	1892	18	of	of	IN
8691	1892	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1892	20	action	action	NN
8691	1892	21	was	be	VBD
8691	1892	22	,	,	,
8691	1892	23	not	not	RB
8691	1892	24	so	so	RB
8691	1892	25	much	much	JJ
8691	1892	26	that	that	IN
8691	1892	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1892	28	pronounced	pronounce	VBD
8691	1892	29	the	the	DT
8691	1892	30	protective	protective	JJ
8691	1892	31	tariff	tariff	NN
8691	1892	32	Acts	act	NNS
8691	1892	33	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	1892	34	and	and	CC
8691	1892	35	void	void	JJ
8691	1892	36	,	,	,
8691	1892	37	but	but	CC
8691	1892	38	that	that	IN
8691	1892	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1892	40	assumed	assume	VBD
8691	1892	41	to	to	TO
8691	1892	42	deny	deny	VB
8691	1892	43	any	any	DT
8691	1892	44	right	right	NN
8691	1892	45	of	of	IN
8691	1892	46	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1892	47	in	in	IN
8691	1892	48	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	1892	49	growing	grow	VBG
8691	1892	50	out	out	IN
8691	1892	51	of	of	IN
8691	1892	52	these	these	DT
8691	1892	53	Acts	act	NNS
8691	1892	54	and	and	CC
8691	1892	55	the	the	DT
8691	1892	56	Ordinance	Ordinance	NNP
8691	1892	57	of	of	IN
8691	1892	58	Nullification	Nullification	NNP
8691	1892	59	,	,	,
8691	1892	60	from	from	IN
8691	1892	61	the	the	DT
8691	1892	62	courts	court	NNS
8691	1892	63	of	of	IN
8691	1892	64	South	South	NNP
8691	1892	65	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	1892	66	to	to	IN
8691	1892	67	the	the	DT
8691	1892	68	courts	court	NNS
8691	1892	69	of	of	IN
8691	1892	70	the	the	DT
8691	1892	71	United	United	NNP
8691	1892	72	States	States	NNP
8691	1892	73	.	.	.
8691	1893	1	This	this	DT
8691	1893	2	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	1893	3	of	of	IN
8691	1893	4	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	1893	5	in	in	IN
8691	1893	6	the	the	DT
8691	1893	7	regular	regular	JJ
8691	1893	8	course	course	NN
8691	1893	9	of	of	IN
8691	1893	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1893	11	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	1893	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	1893	13	the	the	DT
8691	1893	14	one	one	CD
8691	1893	15	thing	thing	NN
8691	1893	16	which	which	WDT
8691	1893	17	keeps	keep	VBZ
8691	1893	18	the	the	DT
8691	1893	19	United	United	NNP
8691	1893	20	States	States	NNP
8691	1893	21	in	in	IN
8691	1893	22	existence	existence	NN
8691	1893	23	.	.	.
8691	1894	1	The	the	DT
8691	1894	2	law	law	NN
8691	1894	3	governing	govern	VBG
8691	1894	4	the	the	DT
8691	1894	5	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	1894	6	transactions	transaction	NNS
8691	1894	7	of	of	IN
8691	1894	8	life	life	NN
8691	1894	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1894	10	that	that	DT
8691	1894	11	of	of	IN
8691	1894	12	the	the	DT
8691	1894	13	State	State	NNP
8691	1894	14	where	where	WRB
8691	1894	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1894	16	may	may	MD
8691	1894	17	have	have	VB
8691	1894	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1894	19	seat	seat	NN
8691	1894	20	.	.	.
8691	1895	1	This	this	DT
8691	1895	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1895	3	affirmed	affirm	VBN
8691	1895	4	in	in	IN
8691	1895	5	the	the	DT
8691	1895	6	original	original	JJ
8691	1895	7	Judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	1895	8	Act,[Footnote	act,[footnote	NN
8691	1895	9	:	:	:
8691	1895	10	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1895	11	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1895	12	Revised	Revised	NNP
8691	1895	13	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	1895	14	,	,	,
8691	1895	15	§	â§	NN
8691	1895	16	721	721	CD
8691	1895	17	.	.	.
8691	1896	1	As	as	IN
8691	1896	2	"	"	``
8691	1896	3	equity	equity	NN
8691	1896	4	follows	follow	VBZ
8691	1896	5	the	the	DT
8691	1896	6	law	law	NN
8691	1896	7	,	,	,
8691	1896	8	"	"	''
8691	1896	9	State	state	NN
8691	1896	10	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	1896	11	creating	create	VBG
8691	1896	12	new	new	JJ
8691	1896	13	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	1896	14	rights	right	NNS
8691	1896	15	or	or	CC
8691	1896	16	varying	vary	VBG
8691	1896	17	those	those	DT
8691	1896	18	formerly	formerly	RB
8691	1896	19	established	establish	VBN
8691	1896	20	also	also	RB
8691	1896	21	affects	affect	VBZ
8691	1896	22	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1896	23	in	in	IN
8691	1896	24	equity	equity	NN
8691	1896	25	in	in	IN
8691	1896	26	the	the	DT
8691	1896	27	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	1896	28	courts	court	NNS
8691	1896	29	.	.	.
8691	1897	1	Brine	Brine	NNP
8691	1897	2	_	_	NNP
8691	1897	3	v.	v.	IN
8691	1897	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1897	5	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	1897	6	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1897	7	,	,	,
8691	1897	8	96	96	CD
8691	1897	9	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1897	10	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1897	11	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1897	12	,	,	,
8691	1897	13	627	627	CD
8691	1897	14	;	;	:
8691	1897	15	but	but	CC
8691	1897	16	see	see	VB
8691	1897	17	James	James	NNP
8691	1897	18	_	_	NNP
8691	1897	19	v.	v.	IN
8691	1897	20	_	_	NNP
8691	1897	21	Gray	Gray	NNP
8691	1897	22	,	,	,
8691	1897	23	131	131	CD
8691	1897	24	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	1897	25	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	1897	26	,	,	,
8691	1897	27	401	401	CD
8691	1897	28	.	.	.
8691	1897	29	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1898	1	as	as	IN
8691	1898	2	a	a	DT
8691	1898	3	general	general	JJ
8691	1898	4	rule	rule	NN
8691	1898	5	for	for	IN
8691	1898	6	the	the	DT
8691	1898	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	1898	8	of	of	IN
8691	1898	9	the	the	DT
8691	1898	10	United	United	NNP
8691	1898	11	States	States	NNP
8691	1898	12	in	in	IN
8691	1898	13	trials	trial	NNS
8691	1898	14	at	at	IN
8691	1898	15	common	common	JJ
8691	1898	16	law	law	NN
8691	1898	17	.	.	.
8691	1899	1	By	by	IN
8691	1899	2	another	another	DT
8691	1899	3	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1899	4	of	of	IN
8691	1899	5	Congress,[Footnote	Congress,[Footnote	NNP
8691	1899	6	:	:	:
8691	1899	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1899	8	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
8691	1899	9	_	_	NNP
8691	1899	10	.	.	NNP
8691	1899	11	,	,	,
8691	1899	12	§	§	NNP
8691	1899	13	914	914	CD
8691	1899	14	.	.	.
8691	1899	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1900	1	the	the	DT
8691	1900	2	practice	practice	NN
8691	1900	3	,	,	,
8691	1900	4	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	1900	5	,	,	,
8691	1900	6	and	and	CC
8691	1900	7	form	form	NN
8691	1900	8	and	and	CC
8691	1900	9	mode	mode	NN
8691	1900	10	of	of	IN
8691	1900	11	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1900	12	in	in	IN
8691	1900	13	civil	civil	JJ
8691	1900	14	causes	cause	NNS
8691	1900	15	,	,	,
8691	1900	16	other	other	JJ
8691	1900	17	than	than	IN
8691	1900	18	those	those	DT
8691	1900	19	of	of	IN
8691	1900	20	equity	equity	NN
8691	1900	21	and	and	CC
8691	1900	22	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	1900	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1900	24	,	,	,
8691	1900	25	in	in	IN
8691	1900	26	the	the	DT
8691	1900	27	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1900	28	and	and	CC
8691	1900	29	District	District	NNP
8691	1900	30	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1900	31	are	be	VBP
8691	1900	32	to	to	TO
8691	1900	33	conform	conform	VB
8691	1900	34	as	as	RB
8691	1900	35	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	1900	36	as	as	IN
8691	1900	37	may	may	MD
8691	1900	38	be	be	VB
8691	1900	39	to	to	IN
8691	1900	40	that	that	DT
8691	1900	41	followed	follow	VBN
8691	1900	42	in	in	IN
8691	1900	43	the	the	DT
8691	1900	44	State	State	NNP
8691	1900	45	within	within	IN
8691	1900	46	which	which	WDT
8691	1900	47	these	these	DT
8691	1900	48	courts	court	NNS
8691	1900	49	may	may	MD
8691	1900	50	be	be	VB
8691	1900	51	held	hold	VBN
8691	1900	52	.	.	.
8691	1901	1	The	the	DT
8691	1901	2	State	State	NNP
8691	1901	3	laws	law	NNS
8691	1901	4	which	which	WDT
8691	1901	5	are	be	VBP
8691	1901	6	thus	thus	RB
8691	1901	7	made	make	VBN
8691	1901	8	a	a	DT
8691	1901	9	rule	rule	NN
8691	1901	10	for	for	IN
8691	1901	11	the	the	DT
8691	1901	12	United	United	NNP
8691	1901	13	States	States	NNP
8691	1901	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	1901	15	are	be	VBP
8691	1901	16	the	the	DT
8691	1901	17	law	law	NN
8691	1901	18	of	of	IN
8691	1901	19	the	the	DT
8691	1901	20	State	State	NNP
8691	1901	21	as	as	IN
8691	1901	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1901	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	1901	24	understood	understand	VBN
8691	1901	25	and	and	CC
8691	1901	26	applied	apply	VBN
8691	1901	27	in	in	IN
8691	1901	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1901	29	own	own	JJ
8691	1901	30	courts	court	NNS
8691	1901	31	.	.	.
8691	1902	1	Hence	hence	RB
8691	1902	2	the	the	DT
8691	1902	3	construction	construction	NN
8691	1902	4	of	of	IN
8691	1902	5	a	a	DT
8691	1902	6	State	State	NNP
8691	1902	7	statute	statute	NN
8691	1902	8	,	,	,
8691	1902	9	or	or	CC
8691	1902	10	the	the	DT
8691	1902	11	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
8691	1902	12	of	of	IN
8691	1902	13	the	the	DT
8691	1902	14	common	common	JJ
8691	1902	15	law	law	NN
8691	1902	16	in	in	IN
8691	1902	17	a	a	DT
8691	1902	18	particular	particular	JJ
8691	1902	19	State	state	NN
8691	1902	20	,	,	,
8691	1902	21	if	if	IN
8691	1902	22	definitely	definitely	RB
8691	1902	23	settled	settle	VBN
8691	1902	24	by	by	IN
8691	1902	25	the	the	DT
8691	1902	26	courts	court	NNS
8691	1902	27	of	of	IN
8691	1902	28	that	that	DT
8691	1902	29	State	State	NNP
8691	1902	30	,	,	,
8691	1902	31	must	must	MD
8691	1902	32	be	be	VB
8691	1902	33	followed	follow	VBN
8691	1902	34	in	in	IN
8691	1902	35	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	1902	36	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	1902	37	in	in	IN
8691	1902	38	the	the	DT
8691	1902	39	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1902	40	courts	court	NNS
8691	1902	41	.	.	.
8691	1903	1	Where	where	WRB
8691	1903	2	,	,	,
8691	1903	3	however	however	RB
8691	1903	4	,	,	,
8691	1903	5	a	a	DT
8691	1903	6	State	State	NNP
8691	1903	7	court	court	NN
8691	1903	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	1903	9	taken	take	VBN
8691	1903	10	a	a	DT
8691	1903	11	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1903	12	position	position	NN
8691	1903	13	as	as	IN
8691	1903	14	to	to	IN
8691	1903	15	what	what	WP
8691	1903	16	the	the	DT
8691	1903	17	law	law	NN
8691	1903	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	1903	19	,	,	,
8691	1903	20	and	and	CC
8691	1903	21	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	1903	22	changes	change	VBZ
8691	1903	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1903	24	position	position	NN
8691	1903	25	,	,	,
8691	1903	26	the	the	DT
8691	1903	27	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1903	28	courts	court	NNS
8691	1903	29	are	be	VBP
8691	1903	30	not	not	RB
8691	1903	31	compelled	compel	VBN
8691	1903	32	to	to	TO
8691	1903	33	change	change	VB
8691	1903	34	with	with	IN
8691	1903	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1903	36	,	,	,
8691	1903	37	if	if	IN
8691	1903	38	this	this	DT
8691	1903	39	would	would	MD
8691	1903	40	do	do	VB
8691	1903	41	injustice	injustice	NN
8691	1903	42	to	to	IN
8691	1903	43	one	one	CD
8691	1903	44	who	who	WP
8691	1903	45	has	have	VBZ
8691	1903	46	meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
8691	1903	47	acted	act	VBN
8691	1903	48	on	on	IN
8691	1903	49	the	the	DT
8691	1903	50	faith	faith	NN
8691	1903	51	of	of	IN
8691	1903	52	the	the	DT
8691	1903	53	original	original	JJ
8691	1903	54	ruling	ruling	NN
8691	1903	55	.	.	.
8691	1904	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1904	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1904	3	:	:	:
8691	1904	4	Burgess	Burgess	NNP
8691	1904	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1904	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1904	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1904	8	Seligman	Seligman	NNP
8691	1904	9	,	,	,
8691	1904	10	107	107	CD
8691	1904	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1904	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1904	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1904	14	,	,	,
8691	1904	15	20	20	CD
8691	1904	16	,	,	,
8691	1904	17	and	and	CC
8691	1904	18	see	see	VB
8691	1904	19	argument	argument	NN
8691	1904	20	of	of	IN
8691	1904	21	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
8691	1904	22	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	1904	23	in	in	IN
8691	1904	24	Groves	Groves	NNP
8691	1904	25	_	_	NNP
8691	1904	26	v.	v.	IN
8691	1904	27	_	_	NNP
8691	1904	28	Slaughter	Slaughter	NNP
8691	1904	29	,	,	,
8691	1904	30	15	15	CD
8691	1904	31	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1904	32	'	'	POS
8691	1904	33	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1904	34	,	,	,
8691	1904	35	449	449	CD
8691	1904	36	,	,	,
8691	1904	37	489	489	CD
8691	1904	38	.	.	.
8691	1904	39	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1905	1	Nor	nor	CC
8691	1905	2	are	be	VBP
8691	1905	3	the	the	DT
8691	1905	4	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1905	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	1905	6	,	,	,
8691	1905	7	in	in	IN
8691	1905	8	large	large	JJ
8691	1905	9	questions	question	NNS
8691	1905	10	of	of	IN
8691	1905	11	a	a	DT
8691	1905	12	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	1905	13	nature	nature	NN
8691	1905	14	,	,	,
8691	1905	15	bound	bind	VBN
8691	1905	16	always	always	RB
8691	1905	17	to	to	TO
8691	1905	18	accept	accept	VB
8691	1905	19	the	the	DT
8691	1905	20	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1905	21	of	of	IN
8691	1905	22	a	a	DT
8691	1905	23	State	State	NNP
8691	1905	24	court	court	NN
8691	1905	25	as	as	IN
8691	1905	26	to	to	IN
8691	1905	27	what	what	WP
8691	1905	28	the	the	DT
8691	1905	29	common	common	JJ
8691	1905	30	law	law	NN
8691	1905	31	of	of	IN
8691	1905	32	the	the	DT
8691	1905	33	State	State	NNP
8691	1905	34	may	may	MD
8691	1905	35	be	be	VB
8691	1905	36	.	.	.
8691	1906	1	The	the	DT
8691	1906	2	manner	manner	NN
8691	1906	3	in	in	IN
8691	1906	4	which	which	WDT
8691	1906	5	this	this	DT
8691	1906	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1906	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	1906	8	been	be	VBN
8691	1906	9	evolved	evolve	VBN
8691	1906	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	1906	11	an	an	DT
8691	1906	12	interesting	interesting	JJ
8691	1906	13	example	example	NN
8691	1906	14	of	of	IN
8691	1906	15	the	the	DT
8691	1906	16	manner	manner	NN
8691	1906	17	in	in	IN
8691	1906	18	which	which	WDT
8691	1906	19	law	law	NN
8691	1906	20	develops	develop	VBZ
8691	1906	21	by	by	IN
8691	1906	22	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	1906	23	,	,	,
8691	1906	24	and	and	CC
8691	1906	25	new	new	JJ
8691	1906	26	points	point	NNS
8691	1906	27	are	be	VBP
8691	1906	28	struck	strike	VBN
8691	1906	29	out	out	RP
8691	1906	30	in	in	IN
8691	1906	31	a	a	DT
8691	1906	32	single	single	JJ
8691	1906	33	case	case	NN
8691	1906	34	as	as	IN
8691	1906	35	the	the	DT
8691	1906	36	joint	joint	JJ
8691	1906	37	product	product	NN
8691	1906	38	of	of	IN
8691	1906	39	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	1906	40	and	and	CC
8691	1906	41	judge	judge	NN
8691	1906	42	.	.	.
8691	1907	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1907	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1907	3	:	:	:
8691	1907	4	See	See	NNP
8691	1907	5	Chaps	Chaps	NNP
8691	1907	6	,	,	,
8691	1907	7	XVII	XVII	NNP
8691	1907	8	,	,	,
8691	1907	9	XVIII	XVIII	NNP
8691	1907	10	.	.	.
8691	1907	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1908	1	A	a	DT
8691	1908	2	bill	bill	NN
8691	1908	3	of	of	IN
8691	1908	4	exchange	exchange	NN
8691	1908	5	drawn	draw	VBN
8691	1908	6	in	in	IN
8691	1908	7	Maine	Maine	NNP
8691	1908	8	on	on	IN
8691	1908	9	one	one	CD
8691	1908	10	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
8691	1908	11	,	,	,
8691	1908	12	a	a	DT
8691	1908	13	merchant	merchant	NN
8691	1908	14	in	in	IN
8691	1908	15	New	New	NNP
8691	1908	16	York	York	NNP
8691	1908	17	,	,	,
8691	1908	18	and	and	CC
8691	1908	19	bearing	bear	VBG
8691	1908	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1908	21	acceptance	acceptance	NN
8691	1908	22	,	,	,
8691	1908	23	was	be	VBD
8691	1908	24	indorsed	indorse	VBN
8691	1908	25	over	over	IN
8691	1908	26	to	to	IN
8691	1908	27	one	one	CD
8691	1908	28	Swift	Swift	NNP
8691	1908	29	,	,	,
8691	1908	30	who	who	WP
8691	1908	31	took	take	VBD
8691	1908	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1908	33	in	in	IN
8691	1908	34	good	good	JJ
8691	1908	35	faith	faith	NN
8691	1908	36	before	before	IN
8691	1908	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1908	38	fell	fall	VBD
8691	1908	39	due	due	JJ
8691	1908	40	,	,	,
8691	1908	41	in	in	IN
8691	1908	42	payment	payment	NN
8691	1908	43	of	of	IN
8691	1908	44	a	a	DT
8691	1908	45	pre	pre	JJ
8691	1908	46	-	-	JJ
8691	1908	47	existing	exist	VBG
8691	1908	48	debt	debt	NN
8691	1908	49	.	.	.
8691	1909	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1909	2	sued	sue	VBD
8691	1909	3	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
8691	1909	4	upon	upon	IN
8691	1909	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1909	6	in	in	IN
8691	1909	7	the	the	DT
8691	1909	8	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1909	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1909	10	of	of	IN
8691	1909	11	the	the	DT
8691	1909	12	United	United	NNP
8691	1909	13	States	States	NNP
8691	1909	14	in	in	IN
8691	1909	15	Maine	Maine	NNP
8691	1909	16	.	.	.
8691	1910	1	If	if	IN
8691	1910	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1910	3	rights	right	NNS
8691	1910	4	were	be	VBD
8691	1910	5	as	as	RB
8691	1910	6	good	good	JJ
8691	1910	7	as	as	IN
8691	1910	8	if	if	IN
8691	1910	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1910	10	had	have	VBD
8691	1910	11	paid	pay	VBN
8691	1910	12	value	value	NN
8691	1910	13	for	for	IN
8691	1910	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1910	15	at	at	IN
8691	1910	16	the	the	DT
8691	1910	17	time	time	NN
8691	1910	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1910	19	received	receive	VBD
8691	1910	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1910	21	,	,	,
8691	1910	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1910	23	was	be	VBD
8691	1910	24	entitled	entitle	VBN
8691	1910	25	to	to	TO
8691	1910	26	recover	recover	VB
8691	1910	27	.	.	.
8691	1911	1	If	if	IN
8691	1911	2	not	not	RB
8691	1911	3	,	,	,
8691	1911	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1911	5	action	action	NN
8691	1911	6	failed	fail	VBD
8691	1911	7	;	;	:
8691	1911	8	for	for	IN
8691	1911	9	the	the	DT
8691	1911	10	acceptance	acceptance	NN
8691	1911	11	had	have	VBD
8691	1911	12	been	be	VBN
8691	1911	13	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	1911	14	by	by	IN
8691	1911	15	fraud	fraud	NN
8691	1911	16	.	.	.
8691	1912	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1912	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1912	3	made	make	VBN
8691	1912	4	in	in	IN
8691	1912	5	New	New	NNP
8691	1912	6	York	York	NNP
8691	1912	7	.	.	.
8691	1913	1	The	the	DT
8691	1913	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1913	3	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	1913	4	of	of	IN
8691	1913	5	that	that	DT
8691	1913	6	State	State	NNP
8691	1913	7	,	,	,
8691	1913	8	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	1913	9	to	to	IN
8691	1913	10	the	the	DT
8691	1913	11	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	1913	12	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1913	13	as	as	IN
8691	1913	14	to	to	IN
8691	1913	15	what	what	WP
8691	1913	16	was	be	VBD
8691	1913	17	the	the	DT
8691	1913	18	general	general	JJ
8691	1913	19	common	common	JJ
8691	1913	20	law	law	NN
8691	1913	21	rule	rule	NN
8691	1913	22	,	,	,
8691	1913	23	seemed	seem	VBD
8691	1913	24	to	to	TO
8691	1913	25	favor	favor	VB
8691	1913	26	the	the	DT
8691	1913	27	view	view	NN
8691	1913	28	that	that	IN
8691	1913	29	a	a	DT
8691	1913	30	pre	pre	JJ
8691	1913	31	-	-	JJ
8691	1913	32	existing	exist	VBG
8691	1913	33	debt	debt	NN
8691	1913	34	did	do	VBD
8691	1913	35	not	not	RB
8691	1913	36	stand	stand	VB
8691	1913	37	on	on	RP
8691	1913	38	as	as	RB
8691	1913	39	good	good	JJ
8691	1913	40	a	a	DT
8691	1913	41	footing	footing	NN
8691	1913	42	as	as	IN
8691	1913	43	a	a	DT
8691	1913	44	present	present	JJ
8691	1913	45	payment	payment	NN
8691	1913	46	,	,	,
8691	1913	47	in	in	IN
8691	1913	48	support	support	NN
8691	1913	49	of	of	IN
8691	1913	50	a	a	DT
8691	1913	51	claim	claim	NN
8691	1913	52	upon	upon	IN
8691	1913	53	negotiable	negotiable	JJ
8691	1913	54	paper	paper	NN
8691	1913	55	.	.	.
8691	1914	1	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
8691	1914	2	Fessenden	Fessenden	NNP
8691	1914	3	of	of	IN
8691	1914	4	Portland	Portland	NNP
8691	1914	5	,	,	,
8691	1914	6	a	a	DT
8691	1914	7	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	1914	8	of	of	IN
8691	1914	9	great	great	JJ
8691	1914	10	ability	ability	NN
8691	1914	11	,	,	,
8691	1914	12	was	be	VBD
8691	1914	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1914	14	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	1914	15	.	.	.
8691	1915	1	The	the	DT
8691	1915	2	cause	cause	NN
8691	1915	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1915	4	submitted	submit	VBN
8691	1915	5	on	on	IN
8691	1915	6	briefs	brief	NNS
8691	1915	7	,	,	,
8691	1915	8	without	without	IN
8691	1915	9	oral	oral	JJ
8691	1915	10	argument	argument	NN
8691	1915	11	.	.	.
8691	1916	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1916	2	Fessenden	Fessenden	NNP
8691	1916	3	,	,	,
8691	1916	4	admitting	admit	VBG
8691	1916	5	that	that	IN
8691	1916	6	the	the	DT
8691	1916	7	law	law	NN
8691	1916	8	of	of	IN
8691	1916	9	the	the	DT
8691	1916	10	place	place	NN
8691	1916	11	where	where	WRB
8691	1916	12	acceptance	acceptance	NN
8691	1916	13	was	be	VBD
8691	1916	14	made	make	VBN
8691	1916	15	must	must	MD
8691	1916	16	govern	govern	VB
8691	1916	17	the	the	DT
8691	1916	18	obligations	obligation	NNS
8691	1916	19	of	of	IN
8691	1916	20	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
8691	1916	21	,	,	,
8691	1916	22	insisted	insist	VBD
8691	1916	23	that	that	IN
8691	1916	24	the	the	DT
8691	1916	25	New	New	NNP
8691	1916	26	York	York	NNP
8691	1916	27	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	1916	28	were	be	VBD
8691	1916	29	wrong	wrong	JJ
8691	1916	30	in	in	IN
8691	1916	31	principle	principle	NN
8691	1916	32	and	and	CC
8691	1916	33	ought	ought	MD
8691	1916	34	not	not	RB
8691	1916	35	to	to	TO
8691	1916	36	be	be	VB
8691	1916	37	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	1916	38	.	.	.
8691	1917	1	"	"	``
8691	1917	2	If	if	IN
8691	1917	3	,	,	,
8691	1917	4	"	"	''
8691	1917	5	said	say	VBD
8691	1917	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1917	7	brief	brief	NN
8691	1917	8	,	,	,
8691	1917	9	"	"	``
8691	1917	10	there	there	EX
8691	1917	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	1917	12	any	any	DT
8691	1917	13	question	question	NN
8691	1917	14	of	of	IN
8691	1917	15	law	law	NN
8691	1917	16	,	,	,
8691	1917	17	not	not	RB
8691	1917	18	local	local	JJ
8691	1917	19	,	,	,
8691	1917	20	but	but	CC
8691	1917	21	widely	widely	RB
8691	1917	22	general	general	JJ
8691	1917	23	in	in	IN
8691	1917	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1917	25	nature	nature	NN
8691	1917	26	and	and	CC
8691	1917	27	effects	effect	NNS
8691	1917	28	,	,	,
8691	1917	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1917	30	is	be	VBZ
8691	1917	31	the	the	DT
8691	1917	32	present	present	JJ
8691	1917	33	question	question	NN
8691	1917	34	.	.	.
8691	1918	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1918	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1918	3	one	one	CD
8691	1918	4	in	in	IN
8691	1918	5	which	which	WDT
8691	1918	6	foreigners	foreigner	NNS
8691	1918	7	,	,	,
8691	1918	8	the	the	DT
8691	1918	9	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	1918	10	of	of	IN
8691	1918	11	different	different	JJ
8691	1918	12	States	state	NNS
8691	1918	13	in	in	IN
8691	1918	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1918	15	contests	contest	NNS
8691	1918	16	with	with	IN
8691	1918	17	each	each	DT
8691	1918	18	other	other	JJ
8691	1918	19	,	,	,
8691	1918	20	nay	nay	NN
8691	1918	21	,	,	,
8691	1918	22	every	every	DT
8691	1918	23	nation	nation	NN
8691	1918	24	of	of	IN
8691	1918	25	the	the	DT
8691	1918	26	civilized	civilized	JJ
8691	1918	27	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	1918	28	world	world	NN
8691	1918	29	,	,	,
8691	1918	30	are	be	VBP
8691	1918	31	deeply	deeply	RB
8691	1918	32	interested	interested	JJ
8691	1918	33	.	.	.
8691	1919	1	By	by	IN
8691	1919	2	all	all	DT
8691	1919	3	without	without	IN
8691	1919	4	the	the	DT
8691	1919	5	United	United	NNP
8691	1919	6	States	States	NNP
8691	1919	7	this	this	DT
8691	1919	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1919	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1919	10	looked	look	VBN
8691	1919	11	to	to	IN
8691	1919	12	as	as	IN
8691	1919	13	the	the	DT
8691	1919	14	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	1919	15	of	of	IN
8691	1919	16	the	the	DT
8691	1919	17	whole	whole	JJ
8691	1919	18	nation	nation	NN
8691	1919	19	,	,	,
8691	1919	20	known	know	VBN
8691	1919	21	as	as	IN
8691	1919	22	the	the	DT
8691	1919	23	United	United	NNP
8691	1919	24	States	States	NNP
8691	1919	25	,	,	,
8691	1919	26	whose	whose	WP$
8691	1919	27	commerce	commerce	NN
8691	1919	28	and	and	CC
8691	1919	29	transactions	transaction	NNS
8691	1919	30	are	be	VBP
8691	1919	31	as	as	RB
8691	1919	32	widely	widely	RB
8691	1919	33	diffused	diffuse	VBN
8691	1919	34	as	as	IN
8691	1919	35	is	be	VBZ
8691	1919	36	the	the	DT
8691	1919	37	use	use	NN
8691	1919	38	of	of	IN
8691	1919	39	bills	bill	NNS
8691	1919	40	of	of	IN
8691	1919	41	exchange	exchange	NN
8691	1919	42	....	....	.
8691	1919	43	How	how	WRB
8691	1919	44	can	can	MD
8691	1919	45	this	this	DT
8691	1919	46	Court	court	NN
8691	1919	47	preserve	preserve	VB
8691	1919	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1919	49	control	control	NN
8691	1919	50	over	over	IN
8691	1919	51	the	the	DT
8691	1919	52	reason	reason	NN
8691	1919	53	and	and	CC
8691	1919	54	affections	affection	NNS
8691	1919	55	of	of	IN
8691	1919	56	the	the	DT
8691	1919	57	people	people	NNS
8691	1919	58	of	of	IN
8691	1919	59	the	the	DT
8691	1919	60	United	United	NNP
8691	1919	61	States	States	NNP
8691	1919	62	;	;	:
8691	1919	63	that	that	DT
8691	1919	64	control	control	NN
8691	1919	65	in	in	IN
8691	1919	66	which	which	WDT
8691	1919	67	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1919	68	usefulness	usefulness	NN
8691	1919	69	consists	consist	VBZ
8691	1919	70	,	,	,
8691	1919	71	and	and	CC
8691	1919	72	which	which	WDT
8691	1919	73	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1919	74	own	own	JJ
8691	1919	75	untrammeled	untrammeled	JJ
8691	1919	76	learning	learning	NN
8691	1919	77	and	and	CC
8691	1919	78	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1919	79	would	would	MD
8691	1919	80	enable	enable	VB
8691	1919	81	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1919	82	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	1919	83	to	to	TO
8691	1919	84	maintain	maintain	VB
8691	1919	85	;	;	:
8691	1919	86	if	if	IN
8691	1919	87	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1919	88	records	record	NNS
8691	1919	89	show	show	VBP
8691	1919	90	that	that	IN
8691	1919	91	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1919	92	has	have	VBZ
8691	1919	93	decided	decide	VBN
8691	1919	94	-	-	:
8691	1919	95	as	as	IN
8691	1919	96	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1919	97	may	may	MD
8691	1919	98	be	be	VB
8691	1919	99	compelled	compel	VBN
8691	1919	100	to	to	TO
8691	1919	101	decide	decide	VB
8691	1919	102	if	if	IN
8691	1919	103	the	the	DT
8691	1919	104	construction	construction	NN
8691	1919	105	referred	refer	VBD
8691	1919	106	to	to	IN
8691	1919	107	,	,	,
8691	1919	108	advocated	advocate	VBN
8691	1919	109	on	on	IN
8691	1919	110	the	the	DT
8691	1919	111	part	part	NN
8691	1919	112	of	of	IN
8691	1919	113	the	the	DT
8691	1919	114	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	1919	115	,	,	,
8691	1919	116	is	be	VBZ
8691	1919	117	established	establish	VBN
8691	1919	118	-	-	:
8691	1919	119	the	the	DT
8691	1919	120	same	same	JJ
8691	1919	121	identical	identical	JJ
8691	1919	122	question	question	NN
8691	1919	123	,	,	,
8691	1919	124	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1919	125	on	on	IN
8691	1919	126	a	a	DT
8691	1919	127	bill	bill	NN
8691	1919	128	of	of	IN
8691	1919	129	exchange	exchange	NN
8691	1919	130	,	,	,
8691	1919	131	first	first	RB
8691	1919	132	one	one	CD
8691	1919	133	way	way	NN
8691	1919	134	,	,	,
8691	1919	135	and	and	CC
8691	1919	136	then	then	RB
8691	1919	137	the	the	DT
8691	1919	138	other	other	JJ
8691	1919	139	,	,	,
8691	1919	140	with	with	IN
8691	1919	141	vacillating	vacillating	JJ
8691	1919	142	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
8691	1919	143	?	?	.
8691	1919	144	"	"	''
8691	1920	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1920	2	Dana	Dana	NNP
8691	1920	3	,	,	,
8691	1920	4	for	for	IN
8691	1920	5	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
8691	1920	6	,	,	,
8691	1920	7	maintained	maintain	VBD
8691	1920	8	the	the	DT
8691	1920	9	opposite	opposite	JJ
8691	1920	10	view	view	NN
8691	1920	11	with	with	IN
8691	1920	12	equal	equal	JJ
8691	1920	13	ability	ability	NN
8691	1920	14	.	.	.
8691	1921	1	"	"	``
8691	1921	2	In	in	IN
8691	1921	3	coming	come	VBG
8691	1921	4	together	together	RB
8691	1921	5	,	,	,
8691	1921	6	"	"	''
8691	1921	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1921	8	said	say	VBD
8691	1921	9	,	,	,
8691	1921	10	"	"	``
8691	1921	11	from	from	IN
8691	1921	12	the	the	DT
8691	1921	13	respective	respective	JJ
8691	1921	14	States	States	NNP
8691	1921	15	,	,	,
8691	1921	16	the	the	DT
8691	1921	17	framers	framer	NNS
8691	1921	18	of	of	IN
8691	1921	19	the	the	DT
8691	1921	20	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1921	21	,	,	,
8691	1921	22	and	and	CC
8691	1921	23	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1921	24	representatives	representative	NNS
8691	1921	25	in	in	IN
8691	1921	26	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1921	27	after	after	IN
8691	1921	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1921	29	,	,	,
8691	1921	30	must	must	MD
8691	1921	31	be	be	VB
8691	1921	32	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	1921	33	as	as	IN
8691	1921	34	having	have	VBG
8691	1921	35	had	have	VBN
8691	1921	36	in	in	IN
8691	1921	37	view	view	NN
8691	1921	38	the	the	DT
8691	1921	39	language	language	NN
8691	1921	40	,	,	,
8691	1921	41	laws	law	NNS
8691	1921	42	,	,	,
8691	1921	43	and	and	CC
8691	1921	44	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	1921	45	of	of	IN
8691	1921	46	the	the	DT
8691	1921	47	States	States	NNPS
8691	1921	48	which	which	WDT
8691	1921	49	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1921	50	represented	represent	VBD
8691	1921	51	.	.	.
8691	1921	52	"	"	''
8691	1922	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1922	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1922	3	Story	Story	NNP
8691	1922	4	gave	give	VBD
8691	1922	5	the	the	DT
8691	1922	6	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1922	7	of	of	IN
8691	1922	8	the	the	DT
8691	1922	9	court	court	NN
8691	1922	10	.	.	.
8691	1923	1	Referring	refer	VBG
8691	1923	2	to	to	IN
8691	1923	3	the	the	DT
8691	1923	4	provision	provision	NN
8691	1923	5	in	in	IN
8691	1923	6	the	the	DT
8691	1923	7	Judiciary	Judiciary	NNP
8691	1923	8	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1923	9	(	(	-LRB-
8691	1923	10	now	now	RB
8691	1923	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1923	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1923	13	Revised	Revised	NNP
8691	1923	14	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	1923	15	,	,	,
8691	1923	16	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	1923	17	.	.	.
8691	1924	1	721	721	LS
8691	1924	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	1924	3	above	above	IN
8691	1924	4	mentioned	mention	VBN
8691	1924	5	,	,	,
8691	1924	6	on	on	IN
8691	1924	7	the	the	DT
8691	1924	8	construction	construction	NN
8691	1924	9	of	of	IN
8691	1924	10	which	which	WDT
8691	1924	11	the	the	DT
8691	1924	12	case	case	NN
8691	1924	13	must	must	MD
8691	1924	14	turn	turn	VB
8691	1924	15	,	,	,
8691	1924	16	"	"	``
8691	1924	17	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1924	18	never	never	RB
8691	1924	19	,	,	,
8691	1924	20	"	"	''
8691	1924	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1924	22	remarked	remark	VBD
8691	1924	23	,	,	,
8691	1924	24	"	"	''
8691	1924	25	has	have	VBZ
8691	1924	26	been	be	VBN
8691	1924	27	supposed	suppose	VBN
8691	1924	28	by	by	IN
8691	1924	29	us	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1924	30	that	that	IN
8691	1924	31	the	the	DT
8691	1924	32	section	section	NN
8691	1924	33	did	do	VBD
8691	1924	34	apply	apply	VB
8691	1924	35	,	,	,
8691	1924	36	or	or	CC
8691	1924	37	was	be	VBD
8691	1924	38	designed	design	VBN
8691	1924	39	to	to	TO
8691	1924	40	apply	apply	VB
8691	1924	41	,	,	,
8691	1924	42	to	to	IN
8691	1924	43	questions	question	NNS
8691	1924	44	of	of	IN
8691	1924	45	a	a	DT
8691	1924	46	more	more	RBR
8691	1924	47	general	general	JJ
8691	1924	48	nature	nature	NN
8691	1924	49	,	,	,
8691	1924	50	not	not	RB
8691	1924	51	at	at	RB
8691	1924	52	all	all	RB
8691	1924	53	dependent	dependent	JJ
8691	1924	54	upon	upon	IN
8691	1924	55	local	local	JJ
8691	1924	56	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	1924	57	or	or	CC
8691	1924	58	local	local	JJ
8691	1924	59	usages	usage	NNS
8691	1924	60	of	of	IN
8691	1924	61	a	a	DT
8691	1924	62	fixed	fixed	JJ
8691	1924	63	and	and	CC
8691	1924	64	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	1924	65	operation	operation	NN
8691	1924	66	,	,	,
8691	1924	67	as	as	IN
8691	1924	68	,	,	,
8691	1924	69	for	for	IN
8691	1924	70	example	example	NN
8691	1924	71	,	,	,
8691	1924	72	to	to	IN
8691	1924	73	the	the	DT
8691	1924	74	construction	construction	NN
8691	1924	75	of	of	IN
8691	1924	76	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	1924	77	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	1924	78	or	or	CC
8691	1924	79	other	other	JJ
8691	1924	80	written	write	VBN
8691	1924	81	instruments	instrument	NNS
8691	1924	82	,	,	,
8691	1924	83	and	and	CC
8691	1924	84	especially	especially	RB
8691	1924	85	to	to	IN
8691	1924	86	questions	question	NNS
8691	1924	87	of	of	IN
8691	1924	88	general	general	JJ
8691	1924	89	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	1924	90	law	law	NN
8691	1924	91	,	,	,
8691	1924	92	where	where	WRB
8691	1924	93	the	the	DT
8691	1924	94	State	State	NNP
8691	1924	95	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	1924	96	are	be	VBP
8691	1924	97	called	call	VBN
8691	1924	98	upon	upon	IN
8691	1924	99	to	to	TO
8691	1924	100	perform	perform	VB
8691	1924	101	the	the	DT
8691	1924	102	like	like	JJ
8691	1924	103	functions	function	NNS
8691	1924	104	as	as	IN
8691	1924	105	ourselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1924	106	,	,	,
8691	1924	107	that	that	RB
8691	1924	108	is	is	RB
8691	1924	109	,	,	,
8691	1924	110	to	to	TO
8691	1924	111	ascertain	ascertain	VB
8691	1924	112	upon	upon	IN
8691	1924	113	general	general	JJ
8691	1924	114	reasoning	reasoning	NN
8691	1924	115	and	and	CC
8691	1924	116	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1924	117	analogies	analogy	NNS
8691	1924	118	,	,	,
8691	1924	119	what	what	WP
8691	1924	120	is	be	VBZ
8691	1924	121	the	the	DT
8691	1924	122	true	true	JJ
8691	1924	123	exposition	exposition	NN
8691	1924	124	of	of	IN
8691	1924	125	the	the	DT
8691	1924	126	contract	contract	NN
8691	1924	127	or	or	CC
8691	1924	128	instrument	instrument	NN
8691	1924	129	,	,	,
8691	1924	130	or	or	CC
8691	1924	131	what	what	WP
8691	1924	132	is	be	VBZ
8691	1924	133	the	the	DT
8691	1924	134	just	just	RB
8691	1924	135	rule	rule	NN
8691	1924	136	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	1924	137	by	by	IN
8691	1924	138	the	the	DT
8691	1924	139	principles	principle	NNS
8691	1924	140	of	of	IN
8691	1924	141	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	1924	142	law	law	NN
8691	1924	143	to	to	TO
8691	1924	144	govern	govern	VB
8691	1924	145	the	the	DT
8691	1924	146	case	case	NN
8691	1924	147	....	....	.
8691	1925	1	The	the	DT
8691	1925	2	law	law	NN
8691	1925	3	respecting	respect	VBG
8691	1925	4	negotiable	negotiable	JJ
8691	1925	5	instruments	instrument	NNS
8691	1925	6	may	may	MD
8691	1925	7	be	be	VB
8691	1925	8	truly	truly	RB
8691	1925	9	declared	declare	VBN
8691	1925	10	in	in	IN
8691	1925	11	the	the	DT
8691	1925	12	language	language	NN
8691	1925	13	of	of	IN
8691	1925	14	Cicero	Cicero	NNP
8691	1925	15	,	,	,
8691	1925	16	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1925	17	by	by	IN
8691	1925	18	Lord	Lord	NNP
8691	1925	19	Mansfield	Mansfield	NNP
8691	1925	20	in	in	IN
8691	1925	21	Luke	Luke	NNP
8691	1925	22	_	_	NNP
8691	1925	23	v.	v.	IN
8691	1925	24	_	_	NNP
8691	1925	25	Lyde	Lyde	NNP
8691	1925	26	,	,	,
8691	1925	27	2	2	CD
8691	1925	28	Burr	Burr	NNS
8691	1925	29	.	.	.
8691	1926	1	B.	B.	NNP
8691	1926	2	,	,	,
8691	1926	3	883	883	CD
8691	1926	4	,	,	,
8691	1926	5	887	887	CD
8691	1926	6	,	,	,
8691	1926	7	to	to	TO
8691	1926	8	be	be	VB
8691	1926	9	in	in	IN
8691	1926	10	a	a	DT
8691	1926	11	great	great	JJ
8691	1926	12	measure	measure	NN
8691	1926	13	,	,	,
8691	1926	14	not	not	RB
8691	1926	15	the	the	DT
8691	1926	16	law	law	NN
8691	1926	17	of	of	IN
8691	1926	18	a	a	DT
8691	1926	19	single	single	JJ
8691	1926	20	country	country	NN
8691	1926	21	only	only	RB
8691	1926	22	,	,	,
8691	1926	23	but	but	CC
8691	1926	24	of	of	IN
8691	1926	25	the	the	DT
8691	1926	26	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	1926	27	world	world	NN
8691	1926	28	.	.	.
8691	1927	1	_	_	NNP
8691	1927	2	Non	Non	NNP
8691	1927	3	erit	erit	JJ
8691	1927	4	alia	alia	NNS
8691	1927	5	lex	lex	NN
8691	1927	6	RomÃ	RomÃ	VBN
8691	1927	7	¦	¦	NNP
8691	1927	8	,	,	,
8691	1927	9	alia	alia	NNP
8691	1927	10	Athenis	Athenis	NNP
8691	1927	11	,	,	,
8691	1927	12	alia	alia	NNP
8691	1927	13	nunc	nunc	JJ
8691	1927	14	,	,	,
8691	1927	15	alia	alia	NNP
8691	1927	16	posthac	posthac	NNP
8691	1927	17	,	,	,
8691	1927	18	sed	sed	NNP
8691	1927	19	et	et	NNP
8691	1927	20	apud	apud	NNP
8691	1927	21	omnes	omnes	NNP
8691	1927	22	gentes	gentes	NNPS
8691	1927	23	,	,	,
8691	1927	24	et	et	NNP
8691	1927	25	omni	omni	NNP
8691	1927	26	tempore	tempore	VBD
8691	1927	27	,	,	,
8691	1927	28	una	una	NNP
8691	1927	29	eademque	eademque	NNP
8691	1927	30	lex	lex	NN
8691	1927	31	obtinebit	obtinebit	NN
8691	1927	32	.	.	.
8691	1928	1	"	"	``
8691	1928	2	_	_	NNP
8691	1928	3	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1928	4	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	1928	5	:	:	:
8691	1928	6	Swift	Swift	NNP
8691	1928	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1928	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	1928	9	_	_	NNP
8691	1928	10	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
8691	1928	11	,	,	,
8691	1928	12	16	16	CD
8691	1928	13	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1928	14	'	'	POS
8691	1928	15	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1928	16	,	,	,
8691	1928	17	1	1	CD
8691	1928	18	,	,	,
8691	1928	19	8	8	CD
8691	1928	20	,	,	,
8691	1928	21	9	9	CD
8691	1928	22	,	,	,
8691	1928	23	10	10	CD
8691	1928	24	,	,	,
8691	1928	25	11	11	CD
8691	1928	26	,	,	,
8691	1928	27	13	13	CD
8691	1928	28	,	,	,
8691	1928	29	18	18	CD
8691	1928	30	.	.	.
8691	1928	31	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1929	1	This	this	DT
8691	1929	2	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	1929	3	had	have	VBD
8691	1929	4	been	be	VBN
8691	1929	5	submitted	submit	VBN
8691	1929	6	to	to	IN
8691	1929	7	the	the	DT
8691	1929	8	court	court	NN
8691	1929	9	for	for	IN
8691	1929	10	the	the	DT
8691	1929	11	first	first	JJ
8691	1929	12	time	time	NN
8691	1929	13	during	during	IN
8691	1929	14	the	the	DT
8691	1929	15	evening	evening	NN
8691	1929	16	before	before	IN
8691	1929	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1929	18	was	be	VBD
8691	1929	19	delivered	deliver	VBN
8691	1929	20	.	.	.
8691	1930	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1930	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1930	3	:	:	:
8691	1930	4	_	_	NNP
8691	1930	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
8691	1930	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1930	7	.	.	NNP
8691	1930	8	,	,	,
8691	1930	9	23	23	CD
8691	1930	10	.	.	.
8691	1930	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1931	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1931	2	could	could	MD
8691	1931	3	not	not	RB
8691	1931	4	have	have	VB
8691	1931	5	received	receive	VBN
8691	1931	6	any	any	DT
8691	1931	7	very	very	RB
8691	1931	8	close	close	JJ
8691	1931	9	scrutiny	scrutiny	NN
8691	1931	10	.	.	.
8691	1932	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1932	2	relied	rely	VBD
8691	1932	3	on	on	IN
8691	1932	4	no	no	DT
8691	1932	5	authority	authority	NN
8691	1932	6	except	except	IN
8691	1932	7	that	that	DT
8691	1932	8	of	of	IN
8691	1932	9	Cicero	Cicero	NNP
8691	1932	10	,	,	,
8691	1932	11	for	for	IN
8691	1932	12	Lord	Lord	NNP
8691	1932	13	Mansfield	Mansfield	NNP
8691	1932	14	,	,	,
8691	1932	15	in	in	IN
8691	1932	16	the	the	DT
8691	1932	17	case	case	NN
8691	1932	18	of	of	IN
8691	1932	19	Luke	Luke	NNP
8691	1932	20	_	_	NNP
8691	1932	21	v.	v.	IN
8691	1932	22	_	_	NNP
8691	1932	23	Lyde	Lyde	NNP
8691	1932	24	,	,	,
8691	1932	25	was	be	VBD
8691	1932	26	speaking	speak	VBG
8691	1932	27	of	of	IN
8691	1932	28	the	the	DT
8691	1932	29	law	law	NN
8691	1932	30	of	of	IN
8691	1932	31	the	the	DT
8691	1932	32	sea	sea	NN
8691	1932	33	,	,	,
8691	1932	34	which	which	WDT
8691	1932	35	in	in	IN
8691	1932	36	the	the	DT
8691	1932	37	nature	nature	NN
8691	1932	38	of	of	IN
8691	1932	39	things	thing	NNS
8691	1932	40	no	no	DT
8691	1932	41	one	one	CD
8691	1932	42	nation	nation	NN
8691	1932	43	can	can	MD
8691	1932	44	prescribe	prescribe	VB
8691	1932	45	or	or	CC
8691	1932	46	change	change	VB
8691	1932	47	.	.	.
8691	1933	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1933	2	was	be	VBD
8691	1933	3	not	not	RB
8691	1933	4	easy	easy	JJ
8691	1933	5	to	to	TO
8691	1933	6	reconcile	reconcile	VB
8691	1933	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1933	8	with	with	IN
8691	1933	9	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	1933	10	cited	cite	VBN
8691	1933	11	by	by	IN
8691	1933	12	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1933	13	Dana	Dana	NNP
8691	1933	14	,	,	,
8691	1933	15	in	in	IN
8691	1933	16	one	one	CD
8691	1933	17	of	of	IN
8691	1933	18	which	which	WDT
8691	1933	19	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1933	20	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1933	21	Chase	Chase	NNP
8691	1933	22	of	of	IN
8691	1933	23	the	the	DT
8691	1933	24	same	same	JJ
8691	1933	25	court	court	NN
8691	1933	26	had	have	VBD
8691	1933	27	held	hold	VBN
8691	1933	28	on	on	IN
8691	1933	29	the	the	DT
8691	1933	30	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	1933	31	as	as	RB
8691	1933	32	early	early	RB
8691	1933	33	as	as	IN
8691	1933	34	1798	1798	CD
8691	1933	35	that	that	IN
8691	1933	36	the	the	DT
8691	1933	37	United	United	NNP
8691	1933	38	States	States	NNP
8691	1933	39	had	have	VBD
8691	1933	40	no	no	DT
8691	1933	41	common	common	JJ
8691	1933	42	law	law	NN
8691	1933	43	of	of	IN
8691	1933	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1933	45	own	own	JJ
8691	1933	46	,	,	,
8691	1933	47	and	and	CC
8691	1933	48	that	that	IN
8691	1933	49	the	the	DT
8691	1933	50	"	"	``
8691	1933	51	common	common	JJ
8691	1933	52	law	law	NN
8691	1933	53	,	,	,
8691	1933	54	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1933	55	,	,	,
8691	1933	56	of	of	IN
8691	1933	57	one	one	CD
8691	1933	58	State	State	NNP
8691	1933	59	is	be	VBZ
8691	1933	60	not	not	RB
8691	1933	61	the	the	DT
8691	1933	62	common	common	JJ
8691	1933	63	law	law	NN
8691	1933	64	of	of	IN
8691	1933	65	another	another	DT
8691	1933	66	;	;	:
8691	1933	67	but	but	CC
8691	1933	68	the	the	DT
8691	1933	69	common	common	JJ
8691	1933	70	law	law	NN
8691	1933	71	of	of	IN
8691	1933	72	England	England	NNP
8691	1933	73	is	be	VBZ
8691	1933	74	the	the	DT
8691	1933	75	law	law	NN
8691	1933	76	of	of	IN
8691	1933	77	each	each	DT
8691	1933	78	State	State	NNP
8691	1933	79	,	,	,
8691	1933	80	so	so	RB
8691	1933	81	far	far	RB
8691	1933	82	as	as	IN
8691	1933	83	each	each	DT
8691	1933	84	State	State	NNP
8691	1933	85	has	have	VBZ
8691	1933	86	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	1933	87	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1933	88	;	;	:
8691	1933	89	and	and	CC
8691	1933	90	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1933	91	results	result	VBZ
8691	1933	92	from	from	IN
8691	1933	93	that	that	DT
8691	1933	94	position	position	NN
8691	1933	95	,	,	,
8691	1933	96	connected	connect	VBN
8691	1933	97	with	with	IN
8691	1933	98	the	the	DT
8691	1933	99	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1933	100	act	act	NN
8691	1933	101	,	,	,
8691	1933	102	that	that	IN
8691	1933	103	the	the	DT
8691	1933	104	common	common	JJ
8691	1933	105	law	law	NN
8691	1933	106	will	will	MD
8691	1933	107	always	always	RB
8691	1933	108	apply	apply	VB
8691	1933	109	to	to	IN
8691	1933	110	suits	suit	NNS
8691	1933	111	between	between	IN
8691	1933	112	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	1933	113	and	and	CC
8691	1933	114	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	1933	115	,	,	,
8691	1933	116	whether	whether	IN
8691	1933	117	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1933	118	are	be	VBP
8691	1933	119	instituted	institute	VBN
8691	1933	120	in	in	IN
8691	1933	121	a	a	DT
8691	1933	122	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	1933	123	,	,	,
8691	1933	124	or	or	CC
8691	1933	125	State	State	NNP
8691	1933	126	,	,	,
8691	1933	127	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1933	128	.	.	.
8691	1934	1	"	"	``
8691	1934	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1934	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1934	4	:	:	:
8691	1934	5	United	United	NNP
8691	1934	6	States	States	NNP
8691	1934	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1934	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	1934	9	_	_	NNP
8691	1934	10	Worrall	Worrall	NNP
8691	1934	11	,	,	,
8691	1934	12	2	2	CD
8691	1934	13	Dallas	Dallas	NNP
8691	1934	14	'	'	POS
8691	1934	15	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1934	16	,	,	,
8691	1934	17	384	384	CD
8691	1934	18	,	,	,
8691	1934	19	394	394	CD
8691	1934	20	.	.	.
8691	1934	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1935	1	So	so	IN
8691	1935	2	the	the	DT
8691	1935	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1935	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1935	5	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1935	6	had	have	VBD
8691	1935	7	said	say	VBN
8691	1935	8	,	,	,
8691	1935	9	in	in	IN
8691	1935	10	1834	1834	CD
8691	1935	11	,	,	,
8691	1935	12	in	in	IN
8691	1935	13	a	a	DT
8691	1935	14	famous	famous	JJ
8691	1935	15	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1935	16	,	,	,
8691	1935	17	concurred	concur	VBN
8691	1935	18	in	in	RP
8691	1935	19	by	by	IN
8691	1935	20	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	1935	21	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	1935	22	Story	Story	NNP
8691	1935	23	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1935	24	,	,	,
8691	1935	25	that	that	IN
8691	1935	26	"	"	``
8691	1935	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1935	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	1935	29	clear	clear	JJ
8691	1935	30	,	,	,
8691	1935	31	there	there	EX
8691	1935	32	can	can	MD
8691	1935	33	be	be	VB
8691	1935	34	no	no	DT
8691	1935	35	common	common	JJ
8691	1935	36	law	law	NN
8691	1935	37	of	of	IN
8691	1935	38	the	the	DT
8691	1935	39	United	United	NNP
8691	1935	40	States	States	NNP
8691	1935	41	.	.	.
8691	1936	1	The	the	DT
8691	1936	2	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1936	3	government	government	NN
8691	1936	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1936	5	composed	compose	VBN
8691	1936	6	of	of	IN
8691	1936	7	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	1936	8	-	-	HYPH
8691	1936	9	four	four	CD
8691	1936	10	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
8691	1936	11	and	and	CC
8691	1936	12	independent	independent	JJ
8691	1936	13	States	state	NNS
8691	1936	14	;	;	:
8691	1936	15	each	each	DT
8691	1936	16	of	of	IN
8691	1936	17	which	which	WDT
8691	1936	18	may	may	MD
8691	1936	19	have	have	VB
8691	1936	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1936	21	local	local	JJ
8691	1936	22	usages	usage	NNS
8691	1936	23	,	,	,
8691	1936	24	customs	custom	NNS
8691	1936	25	and	and	CC
8691	1936	26	common	common	JJ
8691	1936	27	law	law	NN
8691	1936	28	.	.	.
8691	1937	1	There	there	EX
8691	1937	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1937	3	no	no	DT
8691	1937	4	principle	principle	NN
8691	1937	5	which	which	WDT
8691	1937	6	pervades	pervade	VBZ
8691	1937	7	the	the	DT
8691	1937	8	union	union	NN
8691	1937	9	and	and	CC
8691	1937	10	has	have	VBZ
8691	1937	11	the	the	DT
8691	1937	12	authority	authority	NN
8691	1937	13	of	of	IN
8691	1937	14	law	law	NN
8691	1937	15	that	that	WDT
8691	1937	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	1937	17	not	not	RB
8691	1937	18	embodied	embody	VBN
8691	1937	19	in	in	IN
8691	1937	20	the	the	DT
8691	1937	21	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	1937	22	or	or	CC
8691	1937	23	laws	law	NNS
8691	1937	24	of	of	IN
8691	1937	25	the	the	DT
8691	1937	26	union	union	NN
8691	1937	27	.	.	.
8691	1938	1	The	the	DT
8691	1938	2	common	common	JJ
8691	1938	3	law	law	NN
8691	1938	4	could	could	MD
8691	1938	5	be	be	VB
8691	1938	6	made	make	VBN
8691	1938	7	a	a	DT
8691	1938	8	part	part	NN
8691	1938	9	of	of	IN
8691	1938	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1938	11	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1938	12	system	system	NN
8691	1938	13	only	only	RB
8691	1938	14	by	by	IN
8691	1938	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	1938	16	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	1938	17	.	.	.
8691	1939	1	When	when	WRB
8691	1939	2	,	,	,
8691	1939	3	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1939	4	,	,	,
8691	1939	5	a	a	DT
8691	1939	6	common	common	JJ
8691	1939	7	law	law	NN
8691	1939	8	right	right	NN
8691	1939	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1939	10	asserted	assert	VBN
8691	1939	11	,	,	,
8691	1939	12	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1939	13	must	must	MD
8691	1939	14	look	look	VB
8691	1939	15	to	to	IN
8691	1939	16	the	the	DT
8691	1939	17	State	State	NNP
8691	1939	18	in	in	IN
8691	1939	19	which	which	WDT
8691	1939	20	the	the	DT
8691	1939	21	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	1939	22	originated	originate	VBD
8691	1939	23	.	.	.
8691	1940	1	"	"	``
8691	1940	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1940	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	1940	4	:	:	:
8691	1940	5	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	1940	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1940	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	1940	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1940	9	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1940	10	,	,	,
8691	1940	11	8	8	CD
8691	1940	12	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	1940	13	'	'	POS
8691	1940	14	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1940	15	,	,	,
8691	1940	16	658	658	CD
8691	1940	17	.	.	.
8691	1940	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1941	1	The	the	DT
8691	1941	2	State	State	NNP
8691	1941	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1941	4	have	have	VBP
8691	1941	5	looked	look	VBN
8691	1941	6	upon	upon	IN
8691	1941	7	the	the	DT
8691	1941	8	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	1941	9	announced	announce	VBN
8691	1941	10	in	in	IN
8691	1941	11	Swift	Swift	NNP
8691	1941	12	_	_	NNP
8691	1941	13	v.	v.	IN
8691	1941	14	_	_	NNP
8691	1941	15	Tyson	Tyson	NNP
8691	1941	16	with	with	IN
8691	1941	17	an	an	DT
8691	1941	18	unfriendly	unfriendly	JJ
8691	1941	19	eye	eye	NN
8691	1941	20	.	.	.
8691	1942	1	In	in	IN
8691	1942	2	some	some	DT
8691	1942	3	,	,	,
8691	1942	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1942	5	authority	authority	NN
8691	1942	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1942	7	denied	deny	VBN
8691	1942	8	.	.	.
8691	1943	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1943	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1943	3	:	:	:
8691	1943	4	See	see	VB
8691	1943	5	Porepaugh	Porepaugh	NNP
8691	1943	6	_	_	NNP
8691	1943	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	1943	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1943	9	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
8691	1943	10	,	,	,
8691	1943	11	Lackawanna	Lackawanna	NNP
8691	1943	12	and	and	CC
8691	1943	13	Western	Western	NNP
8691	1943	14	R.	R.	NNP
8691	1943	15	R.	R.	NNP
8691	1943	16	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1943	17	,	,	,
8691	1943	18	128	128	CD
8691	1943	19	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	1943	20	State	State	NNP
8691	1943	21	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1943	22	,	,	,
8691	1943	23	217	217	CD
8691	1943	24	;	;	:
8691	1943	25	18	18	CD
8691	1943	26	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	1943	27	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	1943	28	,	,	,
8691	1943	29	503	503	CD
8691	1943	30	.	.	.
8691	1943	31	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1944	1	In	in	IN
8691	1944	2	none	none	NN
8691	1944	3	will	will	MD
8691	1944	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1944	5	affect	affect	VB
8691	1944	6	the	the	DT
8691	1944	7	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	1944	8	of	of	IN
8691	1944	9	a	a	DT
8691	1944	10	cause	cause	NN
8691	1944	11	turning	turn	VBG
8691	1944	12	upon	upon	IN
8691	1944	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1944	14	own	own	JJ
8691	1944	15	law	law	NN
8691	1944	16	,	,	,
8691	1944	17	and	and	CC
8691	1944	18	not	not	RB
8691	1944	19	pending	pende	VBG
8691	1944	20	in	in	IN
8691	1944	21	the	the	DT
8691	1944	22	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1944	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	1944	24	.	.	.
8691	1945	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1945	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	1945	3	,	,	,
8691	1945	4	however	however	RB
8691	1945	5	,	,	,
8691	1945	6	been	be	VBN
8691	1945	7	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
8691	1945	8	reaffirmed	reaffirm	VBN
8691	1945	9	by	by	IN
8691	1945	10	the	the	DT
8691	1945	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1945	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1945	13	of	of	IN
8691	1945	14	the	the	DT
8691	1945	15	United	United	NNP
8691	1945	16	States	States	NNP
8691	1945	17	,	,	,
8691	1945	18	though	though	IN
8691	1945	19	the	the	DT
8691	1945	20	later	later	JJ
8691	1945	21	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	1945	22	appear	appear	VBP
8691	1945	23	to	to	TO
8691	1945	24	limit	limit	VB
8691	1945	25	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1945	26	effect	effect	NN
8691	1945	27	to	to	IN
8691	1945	28	questions	question	NNS
8691	1945	29	growing	grow	VBG
8691	1945	30	out	out	IN
8691	1945	31	of	of	IN
8691	1945	32	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	1945	33	transactions	transaction	NNS
8691	1945	34	not	not	RB
8691	1945	35	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	1945	36	confined	confine	VBN
8691	1945	37	to	to	IN
8691	1945	38	a	a	DT
8691	1945	39	single	single	JJ
8691	1945	40	State	state	NN
8691	1945	41	.	.	.
8691	1946	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1946	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1946	3	:	:	:
8691	1946	4	Western	Western	NNP
8691	1946	5	Union	Union	NNP
8691	1946	6	Telegraph	Telegraph	NNP
8691	1946	7	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1946	8	_	_	NNP
8691	1946	9	v.	v.	IN
8691	1946	10	_	_	NNP
8691	1946	11	Call	Call	NNP
8691	1946	12	Publishing	Publishing	NNP
8691	1946	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1946	14	,	,	,
8691	1946	15	181	181	CD
8691	1946	16	United	United	NNP
8691	1946	17	States	States	NNP
8691	1946	18	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1946	19	,	,	,
8691	1946	20	92	92	CD
8691	1946	21	.	.	.
8691	1947	1	See	see	VB
8691	1947	2	Article	article	NN
8691	1947	3	on	on	IN
8691	1947	4	the	the	DT
8691	1947	5	Common	Common	NNP
8691	1947	6	Law	Law	NNP
8691	1947	7	of	of	IN
8691	1947	8	the	the	DT
8691	1947	9	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	1947	10	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1947	11	,	,	,
8691	1947	12	by	by	IN
8691	1947	13	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	1947	14	C.	C.	NNP
8691	1947	15	Eliot	Eliot	NNP
8691	1947	16	,	,	,
8691	1947	17	_	_	NNP
8691	1947	18	American	American	NNP
8691	1947	19	Law	Law	NNP
8691	1947	20	Review	Review	NNP
8691	1947	21	_	_	NNP
8691	1947	22	,	,	,
8691	1947	23	XXXVI	XXXVI	NNP
8691	1947	24	,	,	,
8691	1947	25	498	498	CD
8691	1947	26	.	.	.
8691	1947	27	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1948	1	The	the	DT
8691	1948	2	right	right	NN
8691	1948	3	of	of	IN
8691	1948	4	recovery	recovery	NN
8691	1948	5	on	on	IN
8691	1948	6	a	a	DT
8691	1948	7	cause	cause	NN
8691	1948	8	of	of	IN
8691	1948	9	action	action	NN
8691	1948	10	of	of	IN
8691	1948	11	a	a	DT
8691	1948	12	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	1948	13	nature	nature	NN
8691	1948	14	will	will	MD
8691	1948	15	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1948	16	often	often	RB
8691	1948	17	depend	depend	VB
8691	1948	18	on	on	IN
8691	1948	19	the	the	DT
8691	1948	20	court	court	NN
8691	1948	21	which	which	WDT
8691	1948	22	the	the	DT
8691	1948	23	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1948	24	selects	select	NNS
8691	1948	25	.	.	.
8691	1949	1	If	if	IN
8691	1949	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1949	3	sues	sue	VBZ
8691	1949	4	in	in	IN
8691	1949	5	a	a	DT
8691	1949	6	State	State	NNP
8691	1949	7	court	court	NN
8691	1949	8	,	,	,
8691	1949	9	the	the	DT
8691	1949	10	common	common	JJ
8691	1949	11	law	law	NN
8691	1949	12	of	of	IN
8691	1949	13	the	the	DT
8691	1949	14	State	State	NNP
8691	1949	15	,	,	,
8691	1949	16	as	as	IN
8691	1949	17	the	the	DT
8691	1949	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1949	19	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	1949	20	of	of	IN
8691	1949	21	that	that	DT
8691	1949	22	State	State	NNP
8691	1949	23	declare	declare	VBP
8691	1949	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1949	25	to	to	TO
8691	1949	26	be	be	VB
8691	1949	27	,	,	,
8691	1949	28	will	will	MD
8691	1949	29	be	be	VB
8691	1949	30	applied	apply	VBN
8691	1949	31	;	;	:
8691	1949	32	if	if	IN
8691	1949	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1949	34	sues	sue	VBZ
8691	1949	35	in	in	IN
8691	1949	36	a	a	DT
8691	1949	37	court	court	NN
8691	1949	38	of	of	IN
8691	1949	39	the	the	DT
8691	1949	40	United	United	NNP
8691	1949	41	States	States	NNP
8691	1949	42	,	,	,
8691	1949	43	the	the	DT
8691	1949	44	common	common	JJ
8691	1949	45	law	law	NN
8691	1949	46	of	of	IN
8691	1949	47	the	the	DT
8691	1949	48	State	State	NNP
8691	1949	49	as	as	IN
8691	1949	50	the	the	DT
8691	1949	51	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	1949	52	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	1949	53	of	of	IN
8691	1949	54	the	the	DT
8691	1949	55	United	United	NNP
8691	1949	56	States	States	NNP
8691	1949	57	declare	declare	VBP
8691	1949	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1949	59	to	to	TO
8691	1949	60	be	be	VB
8691	1949	61	.	.	.
8691	1950	1	Each	each	DT
8691	1950	2	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	1950	3	will	will	MD
8691	1950	4	profess	profess	VB
8691	1950	5	to	to	TO
8691	1950	6	decide	decide	VB
8691	1950	7	by	by	IN
8691	1950	8	the	the	DT
8691	1950	9	same	same	JJ
8691	1950	10	rule	rule	NN
8691	1950	11	--	--	:
8691	1950	12	the	the	DT
8691	1950	13	law	law	NN
8691	1950	14	of	of	IN
8691	1950	15	the	the	DT
8691	1950	16	State	State	NNP
8691	1950	17	;	;	:
8691	1950	18	but	but	CC
8691	1950	19	the	the	DT
8691	1950	20	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1950	21	court	court	NN
8691	1950	22	will	will	MD
8691	1950	23	really	really	RB
8691	1950	24	apply	apply	VB
8691	1950	25	the	the	DT
8691	1950	26	common	common	JJ
8691	1950	27	law	law	NN
8691	1950	28	of	of	IN
8691	1950	29	England	England	NNP
8691	1950	30	,	,	,
8691	1950	31	as	as	IN
8691	1950	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1950	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	1950	34	generally	generally	RB
8691	1950	35	understood	understand	VBN
8691	1950	36	to	to	TO
8691	1950	37	be	be	VB
8691	1950	38	,	,	,
8691	1950	39	instead	instead	RB
8691	1950	40	of	of	IN
8691	1950	41	the	the	DT
8691	1950	42	common	common	JJ
8691	1950	43	law	law	NN
8691	1950	44	of	of	IN
8691	1950	45	that	that	DT
8691	1950	46	State	State	NNP
8691	1950	47	as	as	IN
8691	1950	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1950	49	is	be	VBZ
8691	1950	50	locally	locally	RB
8691	1950	51	understood	understand	VBN
8691	1950	52	to	to	TO
8691	1950	53	be	be	VB
8691	1950	54	.	.	.
8691	1951	1	The	the	DT
8691	1951	2	relations	relation	NNS
8691	1951	3	between	between	IN
8691	1951	4	the	the	DT
8691	1951	5	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1951	6	and	and	CC
8691	1951	7	State	State	NNP
8691	1951	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	1951	9	which	which	WDT
8691	1951	10	have	have	VBP
8691	1951	11	been	be	VBN
8691	1951	12	described	describe	VBN
8691	1951	13	obviously	obviously	RB
8691	1951	14	present	present	JJ
8691	1951	15	many	many	JJ
8691	1951	16	occasions	occasion	NNS
8691	1951	17	for	for	IN
8691	1951	18	conflicts	conflict	NNS
8691	1951	19	of	of	IN
8691	1951	20	authority	authority	NN
8691	1951	21	.	.	.
8691	1952	1	That	that	IN
8691	1952	2	such	such	JJ
8691	1952	3	conflicts	conflict	NNS
8691	1952	4	are	be	VBP
8691	1952	5	so	so	RB
8691	1952	6	infrequent	infrequent	JJ
8691	1952	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1952	8	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	1952	9	due	due	JJ
8691	1952	10	to	to	IN
8691	1952	11	a	a	DT
8691	1952	12	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	1952	13	of	of	IN
8691	1952	14	comity	comity	NN
8691	1952	15	,	,	,
8691	1952	16	which	which	WDT
8691	1952	17	the	the	DT
8691	1952	18	judges	judge	NNS
8691	1952	19	of	of	IN
8691	1952	20	each	each	DT
8691	1952	21	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1952	22	should	should	MD
8691	1952	23	and	and	CC
8691	1952	24	generally	generally	RB
8691	1952	25	do	do	VBP
8691	1952	26	show	show	VB
8691	1952	27	to	to	IN
8691	1952	28	those	those	DT
8691	1952	29	of	of	IN
8691	1952	30	the	the	DT
8691	1952	31	other	other	JJ
8691	1952	32	.	.	.
8691	1953	1	The	the	DT
8691	1953	2	federal	federal	JJ
8691	1953	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1953	4	are	be	VBP
8691	1953	5	also	also	RB
8691	1953	6	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
8691	1953	7	by	by	IN
8691	1953	8	Act	Act	NNP
8691	1953	9	of	of	IN
8691	1953	10	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1953	11	from	from	IN
8691	1953	12	issuing	issue	VBG
8691	1953	13	any	any	DT
8691	1953	14	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	1953	15	to	to	TO
8691	1953	16	stay	stay	VB
8691	1953	17	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1953	18	in	in	IN
8691	1953	19	a	a	DT
8691	1953	20	State	State	NNP
8691	1953	21	court	court	NN
8691	1953	22	,	,	,
8691	1953	23	except	except	IN
8691	1953	24	in	in	IN
8691	1953	25	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1953	26	cases	case	NNS
8691	1953	27	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1953	28	under	under	IN
8691	1953	29	the	the	DT
8691	1953	30	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	1953	31	laws	law	NNS
8691	1953	32	.	.	.
8691	1954	1	Independent	independent	JJ
8691	1954	2	of	of	IN
8691	1954	3	any	any	DT
8691	1954	4	statute	statute	NN
8691	1954	5	,	,	,
8691	1954	6	however	however	RB
8691	1954	7	,	,	,
8691	1954	8	the	the	DT
8691	1954	9	general	general	JJ
8691	1954	10	principles	principle	NNS
8691	1954	11	of	of	IN
8691	1954	12	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	1954	13	forbid	forbid	VBP
8691	1954	14	any	any	DT
8691	1954	15	direct	direct	JJ
8691	1954	16	attempt	attempt	NN
8691	1954	17	either	either	CC
8691	1954	18	by	by	IN
8691	1954	19	a	a	DT
8691	1954	20	court	court	NN
8691	1954	21	of	of	IN
8691	1954	22	the	the	DT
8691	1954	23	State	State	NNP
8691	1954	24	to	to	TO
8691	1954	25	control	control	VB
8691	1954	26	the	the	DT
8691	1954	27	action	action	NN
8691	1954	28	of	of	IN
8691	1954	29	a	a	DT
8691	1954	30	court	court	NN
8691	1954	31	of	of	IN
8691	1954	32	the	the	DT
8691	1954	33	United	United	NNP
8691	1954	34	States	States	NNP
8691	1954	35	or	or	CC
8691	1954	36	by	by	IN
8691	1954	37	a	a	DT
8691	1954	38	court	court	NN
8691	1954	39	of	of	IN
8691	1954	40	the	the	DT
8691	1954	41	United	United	NNP
8691	1954	42	States	States	NNP
8691	1954	43	to	to	TO
8691	1954	44	control	control	VB
8691	1954	45	the	the	DT
8691	1954	46	action	action	NN
8691	1954	47	of	of	IN
8691	1954	48	a	a	DT
8691	1954	49	State	State	NNP
8691	1954	50	court	court	NN
8691	1954	51	,	,	,
8691	1954	52	except	except	IN
8691	1954	53	to	to	IN
8691	1954	54	the	the	DT
8691	1954	55	limited	limited	JJ
8691	1954	56	extent	extent	NN
8691	1954	57	for	for	IN
8691	1954	58	which	which	WDT
8691	1954	59	provision	provision	NN
8691	1954	60	is	be	VBZ
8691	1954	61	made	make	VBN
8691	1954	62	in	in	IN
8691	1954	63	the	the	DT
8691	1954	64	national	national	JJ
8691	1954	65	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1954	66	.	.	.
8691	1955	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1955	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1955	3	:	:	:
8691	1955	4	Diggs	Diggs	NNP
8691	1955	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1955	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1955	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1955	8	Wolcott	Wolcott	NNP
8691	1955	9	,	,	,
8691	1955	10	4	4	CD
8691	1955	11	Cranch	Cranch	NNP
8691	1955	12	's	's	POS
8691	1955	13	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1955	14	,	,	,
8691	1955	15	179	179	CD
8691	1955	16	;	;	:
8691	1955	17	M'Kim	M'Kim	NNP
8691	1955	18	_	_	NNP
8691	1955	19	v.	v.	IN
8691	1955	20	_	_	NNP
8691	1955	21	Voorhies	Voorhies	NNPS
8691	1955	22	,	,	,
8691	1955	23	7	7	CD
8691	1955	24	Cranch	Cranch	NNP
8691	1955	25	's	's	POS
8691	1955	26	Reports	report	NNS
8691	1955	27	,	,	,
8691	1955	28	279	279	CD
8691	1955	29	.	.	.
8691	1955	30	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1956	1	Each	each	DT
8691	1956	2	court	court	NN
8691	1956	3	,	,	,
8691	1956	4	this	this	DT
8691	1956	5	exception	exception	NN
8691	1956	6	aside	aside	RB
8691	1956	7	,	,	,
8691	1956	8	exercises	exercise	VBZ
8691	1956	9	powers	power	NNS
8691	1956	10	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	1956	11	to	to	IN
8691	1956	12	an	an	DT
8691	1956	13	independent	independent	JJ
8691	1956	14	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	1956	15	,	,	,
8691	1956	16	and	and	CC
8691	1956	17	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	1956	18	subject	subject	JJ
8691	1956	19	to	to	IN
8691	1956	20	control	control	NN
8691	1956	21	by	by	IN
8691	1956	22	that	that	DT
8691	1956	23	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	1956	24	only	only	RB
8691	1956	25	.	.	.
8691	1957	1	The	the	DT
8691	1957	2	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	1957	3	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1957	4	of	of	IN
8691	1957	5	the	the	DT
8691	1957	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	1957	7	of	of	IN
8691	1957	8	the	the	DT
8691	1957	9	United	United	NNP
8691	1957	10	States	States	NNP
8691	1957	11	enables	enable	VBZ
8691	1957	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1957	13	to	to	TO
8691	1957	14	interfere	interfere	VB
8691	1957	15	in	in	IN
8691	1957	16	disputes	dispute	NNS
8691	1957	17	arising	arise	VBG
8691	1957	18	out	out	IN
8691	1957	19	of	of	IN
8691	1957	20	State	State	NNP
8691	1957	21	elections	election	NNS
8691	1957	22	in	in	IN
8691	1957	23	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1957	24	cases	case	NNS
8691	1957	25	in	in	IN
8691	1957	26	which	which	WDT
8691	1957	27	the	the	DT
8691	1957	28	claim	claim	NN
8691	1957	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	1957	30	set	set	VBN
8691	1957	31	up	up	RP
8691	1957	32	that	that	IN
8691	1957	33	rights	right	NNS
8691	1957	34	held	hold	VBN
8691	1957	35	under	under	IN
8691	1957	36	the	the	DT
8691	1957	37	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1957	38	or	or	CC
8691	1957	39	laws	law	NNS
8691	1957	40	of	of	IN
8691	1957	41	the	the	DT
8691	1957	42	United	United	NNP
8691	1957	43	States	States	NNP
8691	1957	44	have	have	VBP
8691	1957	45	been	be	VBN
8691	1957	46	violated	violate	VBN
8691	1957	47	.	.	.
8691	1958	1	Actions	action	NNS
8691	1958	2	for	for	IN
8691	1958	3	such	such	JJ
8691	1958	4	relief	relief	NN
8691	1958	5	are	be	VBP
8691	1958	6	rare	rare	JJ
8691	1958	7	,	,	,
8691	1958	8	and	and	CC
8691	1958	9	instances	instance	NNS
8691	1958	10	have	have	VBP
8691	1958	11	occurred	occur	VBN
8691	1958	12	in	in	IN
8691	1958	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1958	14	the	the	DT
8691	1958	15	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1958	16	has	have	VBZ
8691	1958	17	been	be	VBN
8691	1958	18	abused	abuse	VBN
8691	1958	19	for	for	IN
8691	1958	20	political	political	JJ
8691	1958	21	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	1958	22	.	.	.
8691	1959	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1959	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1959	3	:	:	:
8691	1959	4	See	see	VB
8691	1959	5	the	the	DT
8691	1959	6	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	1959	7	in	in	IN
8691	1959	8	the	the	DT
8691	1959	9	case	case	NN
8691	1959	10	of	of	IN
8691	1959	11	Kellogg	Kellogg	NNP
8691	1959	12	_	_	NNP
8691	1959	13	v.	v.	IN
8691	1959	14	_	_	NNP
8691	1959	15	Warmoth	Warmoth	NNP
8691	1959	16	in	in	IN
8691	1959	17	the	the	DT
8691	1959	18	United	United	NNP
8691	1959	19	States	States	NNP
8691	1959	20	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	1959	21	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1959	22	in	in	IN
8691	1959	23	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	1959	24	in	in	IN
8691	1959	25	1872	1872	CD
8691	1959	26	.	.	.
8691	1960	1	McPherson	McPherson	NNP
8691	1960	2	's	's	POS
8691	1960	3	"	"	``
8691	1960	4	History	History	NNP
8691	1960	5	of	of	IN
8691	1960	6	Reconstruction	reconstruction	NN
8691	1960	7	,	,	,
8691	1960	8	"	"	''
8691	1960	9	100	100	CD
8691	1960	10	-	-	HYPH
8691	1960	11	108	108	CD
8691	1960	12	.	.	.
8691	1960	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1961	1	The	the	DT
8691	1961	2	centralizing	centralize	VBG
8691	1961	3	and	and	CC
8691	1961	4	nationalizing	nationalize	VBG
8691	1961	5	tendencies	tendency	NNS
8691	1961	6	which	which	WDT
8691	1961	7	set	set	VBD
8691	1961	8	in	in	RP
8691	1961	9	early	early	RB
8691	1961	10	in	in	IN
8691	1961	11	the	the	DT
8691	1961	12	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	1961	13	century	century	NN
8691	1961	14	and	and	CC
8691	1961	15	were	be	VBD
8691	1961	16	so	so	RB
8691	1961	17	greatly	greatly	RB
8691	1961	18	strengthened	strengthen	VBN
8691	1961	19	by	by	IN
8691	1961	20	the	the	DT
8691	1961	21	course	course	NN
8691	1961	22	of	of	IN
8691	1961	23	events	event	NNS
8691	1961	24	during	during	IN
8691	1961	25	and	and	CC
8691	1961	26	following	follow	VBG
8691	1961	27	soon	soon	RB
8691	1961	28	after	after	IN
8691	1961	29	the	the	DT
8691	1961	30	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	1961	31	War	War	NNP
8691	1961	32	have	have	VBP
8691	1961	33	greatly	greatly	RB
8691	1961	34	weakened	weaken	VBN
8691	1961	35	the	the	DT
8691	1961	36	position	position	NN
8691	1961	37	and	and	CC
8691	1961	38	influence	influence	NN
8691	1961	39	of	of	IN
8691	1961	40	the	the	DT
8691	1961	41	State	State	NNP
8691	1961	42	courts	court	NNS
8691	1961	43	.	.	.
8691	1962	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1962	2	have	have	VBP
8691	1962	3	thus	thus	RB
8691	1962	4	rendered	render	VBN
8691	1962	5	the	the	DT
8691	1962	6	State	State	NNP
8691	1962	7	bench	bench	NN
8691	1962	8	less	less	RBR
8691	1962	9	attractive	attractive	JJ
8691	1962	10	.	.	.
8691	1963	1	In	in	IN
8691	1963	2	1791	1791	CD
8691	1963	3	,	,	,
8691	1963	4	John	John	NNP
8691	1963	5	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
8691	1963	6	,	,	,
8691	1963	7	an	an	DT
8691	1963	8	associate	associate	JJ
8691	1963	9	justice	justice	NN
8691	1963	10	of	of	IN
8691	1963	11	the	the	DT
8691	1963	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1963	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1963	14	of	of	IN
8691	1963	15	the	the	DT
8691	1963	16	United	United	NNP
8691	1963	17	States	States	NNP
8691	1963	18	,	,	,
8691	1963	19	resigned	resign	VBD
8691	1963	20	that	that	IN
8691	1963	21	office	office	NN
8691	1963	22	for	for	IN
8691	1963	23	the	the	DT
8691	1963	24	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1963	25	Justiceship	Justiceship	NNP
8691	1963	26	of	of	IN
8691	1963	27	South	South	NNP
8691	1963	28	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	1963	29	.	.	.
8691	1964	1	During	during	IN
8691	1964	2	the	the	DT
8691	1964	3	last	last	JJ
8691	1964	4	half	half	JJ
8691	1964	5	century	century	NN
8691	1964	6	,	,	,
8691	1964	7	several	several	JJ
8691	1964	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	1964	9	Justices	Justices	NNPS
8691	1964	10	of	of	IN
8691	1964	11	States	States	NNPS
8691	1964	12	have	have	VBP
8691	1964	13	resigned	resign	VBN
8691	1964	14	to	to	TO
8691	1964	15	become	become	VB
8691	1964	16	Associate	associate	JJ
8691	1964	17	Justices	Justices	NNPS
8691	1964	18	of	of	IN
8691	1964	19	the	the	DT
8691	1964	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1964	21	Court	Court	NNP
8691	1964	22	of	of	IN
8691	1964	23	the	the	DT
8691	1964	24	United	United	NNP
8691	1964	25	States	States	NNP
8691	1964	26	.	.	.
8691	1965	1	Associate	associate	JJ
8691	1965	2	Justices	Justices	NNPS
8691	1965	3	of	of	IN
8691	1965	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	1965	5	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	1965	6	in	in	IN
8691	1965	7	the	the	DT
8691	1965	8	smaller	small	JJR
8691	1965	9	States	state	NNS
8691	1965	10	have	have	VBP
8691	1965	11	also	also	RB
8691	1965	12	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	1965	13	resigned	resign	VBN
8691	1965	14	to	to	TO
8691	1965	15	accept	accept	VB
8691	1965	16	the	the	DT
8691	1965	17	position	position	NN
8691	1965	18	of	of	IN
8691	1965	19	District	District	NNP
8691	1965	20	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	1965	21	,	,	,
8691	1965	22	attracted	attract	VBN
8691	1965	23	by	by	IN
8691	1965	24	the	the	DT
8691	1965	25	life	life	NN
8691	1965	26	tenure	tenure	NN
8691	1965	27	,	,	,
8691	1965	28	larger	large	JJR
8691	1965	29	salary	salary	NN
8691	1965	30	,	,	,
8691	1965	31	and	and	CC
8691	1965	32	retiring	retire	VBG
8691	1965	33	pension	pension	NN
8691	1965	34	.	.	.
8691	1966	1	*	*	NFP
8691	1966	2	*	*	NFP
8691	1966	3	*	*	NFP
8691	1966	4	*	*	NFP
8691	1966	5	*	*	NFP
8691	1966	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	1966	7	XI	xi	NN
8691	1966	8	RELATIONS	relations	NN
8691	1966	9	BETWEEN	between	IN
8691	1966	10	THE	the	DT
8691	1966	11	COURTS	COURTS	NNP
8691	1966	12	OF	of	IN
8691	1966	13	DIFFERENT	DIFFERENT	NNP
8691	1966	14	STATES	state	NNS
8691	1966	15	Every	every	DT
8691	1966	16	State	State	NNP
8691	1966	17	has	have	VBZ
8691	1966	18	all	all	PDT
8691	1966	19	the	the	DT
8691	1966	20	rights	right	NNS
8691	1966	21	of	of	IN
8691	1966	22	an	an	DT
8691	1966	23	independent	independent	JJ
8691	1966	24	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	1966	25	,	,	,
8691	1966	26	except	except	IN
8691	1966	27	so	so	RB
8691	1966	28	far	far	RB
8691	1966	29	as	as	IN
8691	1966	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1966	31	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	1966	32	is	be	VBZ
8691	1966	33	limited	limit	VBN
8691	1966	34	by	by	IN
8691	1966	35	the	the	DT
8691	1966	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1966	37	of	of	IN
8691	1966	38	the	the	DT
8691	1966	39	United	United	NNP
8691	1966	40	States	States	NNP
8691	1966	41	.	.	.
8691	1967	1	As	as	IN
8691	1967	2	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	1967	3	each	each	DT
8691	1967	4	other	other	JJ
8691	1967	5	the	the	DT
8691	1967	6	States	state	NNS
8691	1967	7	are	be	VBP
8691	1967	8	for	for	IN
8691	1967	9	most	most	JJS
8691	1967	10	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	1967	11	in	in	IN
8691	1967	12	the	the	DT
8691	1967	13	position	position	NN
8691	1967	14	of	of	IN
8691	1967	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1967	16	governments	government	NNS
8691	1967	17	.	.	.
8691	1968	1	The	the	DT
8691	1968	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	1968	3	of	of	IN
8691	1968	4	one	one	CD
8691	1968	5	are	be	VBP
8691	1968	6	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	1968	7	by	by	IN
8691	1968	8	those	those	DT
8691	1968	9	of	of	IN
8691	1968	10	any	any	DT
8691	1968	11	other	other	JJ
8691	1968	12	as	as	IN
8691	1968	13	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1968	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	1968	15	,	,	,
8691	1968	16	except	except	IN
8691	1968	17	so	so	RB
8691	1968	18	far	far	RB
8691	1968	19	as	as	IN
8691	1968	20	the	the	DT
8691	1968	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1968	22	may	may	MD
8691	1968	23	have	have	VB
8691	1968	24	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
8691	1968	25	a	a	DT
8691	1968	26	different	different	JJ
8691	1968	27	rule	rule	NN
8691	1968	28	.	.	.
8691	1969	1	No	no	DT
8691	1969	2	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1969	3	process	process	NN
8691	1969	4	from	from	IN
8691	1969	5	a	a	DT
8691	1969	6	court	court	NN
8691	1969	7	can	can	MD
8691	1969	8	have	have	VB
8691	1969	9	any	any	DT
8691	1969	10	inherent	inherent	JJ
8691	1969	11	force	force	NN
8691	1969	12	outside	outside	IN
8691	1969	13	of	of	IN
8691	1969	14	the	the	DT
8691	1969	15	territorial	territorial	JJ
8691	1969	16	boundaries	boundary	NNS
8691	1969	17	of	of	IN
8691	1969	18	the	the	DT
8691	1969	19	government	government	NN
8691	1969	20	in	in	IN
8691	1969	21	which	which	WDT
8691	1969	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1969	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	1969	24	issued	issue	VBN
8691	1969	25	.	.	.
8691	1970	1	The	the	DT
8691	1970	2	law	law	NN
8691	1970	3	of	of	IN
8691	1970	4	that	that	DT
8691	1970	5	government	government	NN
8691	1970	6	may	may	MD
8691	1970	7	attach	attach	VB
8691	1970	8	certain	certain	JJ
8691	1970	9	consequences	consequence	NNS
8691	1970	10	to	to	IN
8691	1970	11	the	the	DT
8691	1970	12	fact	fact	NN
8691	1970	13	of	of	IN
8691	1970	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1970	15	service	service	NN
8691	1970	16	in	in	IN
8691	1970	17	a	a	DT
8691	1970	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1970	19	country	country	NN
8691	1970	20	,	,	,
8691	1970	21	but	but	CC
8691	1970	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1970	23	can	can	MD
8691	1970	24	do	do	VB
8691	1970	25	so	so	RB
8691	1970	26	only	only	RB
8691	1970	27	with	with	IN
8691	1970	28	reference	reference	NN
8691	1970	29	to	to	IN
8691	1970	30	the	the	DT
8691	1970	31	effect	effect	NN
8691	1970	32	of	of	IN
8691	1970	33	the	the	DT
8691	1970	34	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1970	35	on	on	IN
8691	1970	36	persons	person	NNS
8691	1970	37	or	or	CC
8691	1970	38	property	property	NN
8691	1970	39	subject	subject	NN
8691	1970	40	to	to	IN
8691	1970	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1970	42	own	own	JJ
8691	1970	43	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1970	44	.	.	.
8691	1971	1	Courts	court	NNS
8691	1971	2	,	,	,
8691	1971	3	as	as	IN
8691	1971	4	a	a	DT
8691	1971	5	general	general	JJ
8691	1971	6	rule	rule	NN
8691	1971	7	,	,	,
8691	1971	8	can	can	MD
8691	1971	9	act	act	VB
8691	1971	10	only	only	RB
8691	1971	11	when	when	WRB
8691	1971	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1971	13	have	have	VBP
8691	1971	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1971	15	over	over	IN
8691	1971	16	the	the	DT
8691	1971	17	person	person	NN
8691	1971	18	,	,	,
8691	1971	19	the	the	DT
8691	1971	20	subject	subject	NN
8691	1971	21	-	-	HYPH
8691	1971	22	matter	matter	NN
8691	1971	23	,	,	,
8691	1971	24	and	and	CC
8691	1971	25	the	the	DT
8691	1971	26	cause	cause	NN
8691	1971	27	.	.	.
8691	1972	1	In	in	IN
8691	1972	2	rare	rare	JJ
8691	1972	3	cases	case	NNS
8691	1972	4	,	,	,
8691	1972	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1972	6	over	over	IN
8691	1972	7	the	the	DT
8691	1972	8	subject	subject	NN
8691	1972	9	-	-	HYPH
8691	1972	10	matter	matter	NN
8691	1972	11	may	may	MD
8691	1972	12	be	be	VB
8691	1972	13	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	1972	14	as	as	IN
8691	1972	15	giving	give	VBG
8691	1972	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1972	17	over	over	IN
8691	1972	18	the	the	DT
8691	1972	19	person	person	NN
8691	1972	20	,	,	,
8691	1972	21	so	so	RB
8691	1972	22	far	far	RB
8691	1972	23	as	as	IN
8691	1972	24	may	may	MD
8691	1972	25	be	be	VB
8691	1972	26	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	1972	27	to	to	TO
8691	1972	28	uphold	uphold	VB
8691	1972	29	a	a	DT
8691	1972	30	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1972	31	settling	settle	VBG
8691	1972	32	the	the	DT
8691	1972	33	possession	possession	NN
8691	1972	34	or	or	CC
8691	1972	35	title	title	NN
8691	1972	36	to	to	IN
8691	1972	37	property	property	NN
8691	1972	38	.	.	.
8691	1973	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	1973	2	a	a	DT
8691	1973	3	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1973	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1973	5	,	,	,
8691	1973	6	either	either	CC
8691	1973	7	in	in	IN
8691	1973	8	form	form	NN
8691	1973	9	or	or	CC
8691	1973	10	substance	substance	NN
8691	1973	11	,	,	,
8691	1973	12	one	one	CD
8691	1973	13	not	not	RB
8691	1973	14	_	_	NNP
8691	1973	15	in	in	IN
8691	1973	16	personam	personam	NNP
8691	1973	17	_	_	NNP
8691	1973	18	but	but	CC
8691	1973	19	_	_	NNP
8691	1973	20	in	in	IN
8691	1973	21	rem	rem	NNP
8691	1973	22	_	_	NNP
8691	1973	23	.	.	.
8691	1974	1	The	the	DT
8691	1974	2	commonest	common	JJS
8691	1974	3	instance	instance	NN
8691	1974	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1974	5	a	a	DT
8691	1974	6	suit	suit	NN
8691	1974	7	in	in	IN
8691	1974	8	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	1974	9	to	to	TO
8691	1974	10	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1974	11	a	a	DT
8691	1974	12	maritime	maritime	NN
8691	1974	13	lien	lien	NN
8691	1974	14	,	,	,
8691	1974	15	such	such	JJ
8691	1974	16	as	as	IN
8691	1974	17	that	that	DT
8691	1974	18	given	give	VBN
8691	1974	19	by	by	IN
8691	1974	20	the	the	DT
8691	1974	21	universal	universal	JJ
8691	1974	22	law	law	NN
8691	1974	23	of	of	IN
8691	1974	24	the	the	DT
8691	1974	25	sea	sea	NN
8691	1974	26	for	for	IN
8691	1974	27	seamen	seamen	NNP
8691	1974	28	's	's	POS
8691	1974	29	wages	wage	NNS
8691	1974	30	.	.	.
8691	1975	1	Wherever	wherever	WRB
8691	1975	2	the	the	DT
8691	1975	3	vessel	vessel	NN
8691	1975	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	1975	5	found	find	VBN
8691	1975	6	,	,	,
8691	1975	7	this	this	DT
8691	1975	8	lien	lien	NN
8691	1975	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	1975	10	recognized	recognize	VBN
8691	1975	11	and	and	CC
8691	1975	12	will	will	MD
8691	1975	13	be	be	VB
8691	1975	14	enforced	enforce	VBN
8691	1975	15	by	by	IN
8691	1975	16	seizing	seize	VBG
8691	1975	17	and	and	CC
8691	1975	18	selling	sell	VBG
8691	1975	19	her	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1975	20	,	,	,
8691	1975	21	but	but	CC
8691	1975	22	only	only	RB
8691	1975	23	after	after	IN
8691	1975	24	some	some	DT
8691	1975	25	kind	kind	NN
8691	1975	26	of	of	IN
8691	1975	27	public	public	JJ
8691	1975	28	notice	notice	NN
8691	1975	29	has	have	VBZ
8691	1975	30	been	be	VBN
8691	1975	31	given	give	VBN
8691	1975	32	to	to	IN
8691	1975	33	all	all	DT
8691	1975	34	who	who	WP
8691	1975	35	have	have	VBP
8691	1975	36	any	any	DT
8691	1975	37	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
8691	1975	38	interest	interest	NN
8691	1975	39	in	in	IN
8691	1975	40	her	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1975	41	to	to	TO
8691	1975	42	appear	appear	VB
8691	1975	43	and	and	CC
8691	1975	44	be	be	VB
8691	1975	45	heard	hear	VBN
8691	1975	46	.	.	.
8691	1976	1	In	in	IN
8691	1976	2	such	such	PDT
8691	1976	3	a	a	DT
8691	1976	4	suit	suit	NN
8691	1976	5	,	,	,
8691	1976	6	personal	personal	JJ
8691	1976	7	notice	notice	NN
8691	1976	8	to	to	IN
8691	1976	9	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1976	10	owners	owner	NNS
8691	1976	11	,	,	,
8691	1976	12	served	serve	VBD
8691	1976	13	within	within	IN
8691	1976	14	the	the	DT
8691	1976	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1976	16	of	of	IN
8691	1976	17	the	the	DT
8691	1976	18	government	government	NN
8691	1976	19	to	to	IN
8691	1976	20	the	the	DT
8691	1976	21	courts	court	NNS
8691	1976	22	of	of	IN
8691	1976	23	which	which	WDT
8691	1976	24	the	the	DT
8691	1976	25	seamen	seaman	NNS
8691	1976	26	may	may	MD
8691	1976	27	resort	resort	VB
8691	1976	28	,	,	,
8691	1976	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	1976	30	not	not	RB
8691	1976	31	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
8691	1976	32	.	.	.
8691	1977	1	The	the	DT
8691	1977	2	presence	presence	NN
8691	1977	3	of	of	IN
8691	1977	4	the	the	DT
8691	1977	5	ship	ship	NN
8691	1977	6	within	within	IN
8691	1977	7	the	the	DT
8691	1977	8	power	power	NN
8691	1977	9	of	of	IN
8691	1977	10	the	the	DT
8691	1977	11	court	court	NN
8691	1977	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	1977	13	enough	enough	JJ
8691	1977	14	.	.	.
8691	1978	1	While	while	IN
8691	1978	2	State	state	NN
8691	1978	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	1978	4	have	have	VBP
8691	1978	5	no	no	DT
8691	1978	6	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	1978	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1978	8	,	,	,
8691	1978	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1978	10	can	can	MD
8691	1978	11	adjudicate	adjudicate	VB
8691	1978	12	upon	upon	IN
8691	1978	13	a	a	DT
8691	1978	14	claim	claim	NN
8691	1978	15	of	of	IN
8691	1978	16	title	title	NN
8691	1978	17	or	or	CC
8691	1978	18	right	right	NN
8691	1978	19	of	of	IN
8691	1978	20	possession	possession	NN
8691	1978	21	to	to	IN
8691	1978	22	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	1978	23	property	property	NN
8691	1978	24	within	within	IN
8691	1978	25	the	the	DT
8691	1978	26	territorial	territorial	JJ
8691	1978	27	limits	limit	NNS
8691	1978	28	of	of	IN
8691	1978	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1978	30	State	State	NNP
8691	1978	31	,	,	,
8691	1978	32	although	although	IN
8691	1978	33	the	the	DT
8691	1978	34	parties	party	NNS
8691	1978	35	adversely	adversely	RB
8691	1978	36	interested	interested	JJ
8691	1978	37	are	be	VBP
8691	1978	38	not	not	RB
8691	1978	39	and	and	CC
8691	1978	40	have	have	VBP
8691	1978	41	not	not	RB
8691	1978	42	been	be	VBN
8691	1978	43	personally	personally	RB
8691	1978	44	served	serve	VBN
8691	1978	45	with	with	IN
8691	1978	46	process	process	NN
8691	1978	47	there	there	RB
8691	1978	48	or	or	CC
8691	1978	49	anywhere	anywhere	RB
8691	1978	50	.	.	.
8691	1979	1	Here	here	RB
8691	1979	2	again	again	RB
8691	1979	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1979	4	power	power	NN
8691	1979	5	over	over	IN
8691	1979	6	the	the	DT
8691	1979	7	property	property	NN
8691	1979	8	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	1979	9	implies	imply	VBZ
8691	1979	10	such	such	JJ
8691	1979	11	power	power	NN
8691	1979	12	of	of	IN
8691	1979	13	control	control	NN
8691	1979	14	over	over	IN
8691	1979	15	those	those	DT
8691	1979	16	who	who	WP
8691	1979	17	might	may	MD
8691	1979	18	lay	lay	VB
8691	1979	19	claim	claim	NN
8691	1979	20	to	to	IN
8691	1979	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1979	22	as	as	IN
8691	1979	23	will	will	MD
8691	1979	24	suffice	suffice	VB
8691	1979	25	to	to	TO
8691	1979	26	settle	settle	VB
8691	1979	27	any	any	DT
8691	1979	28	dispute	dispute	NN
8691	1979	29	over	over	IN
8691	1979	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1979	31	ownership	ownership	NN
8691	1979	32	or	or	CC
8691	1979	33	possession	possession	NN
8691	1979	34	.	.	.
8691	1980	1	But	but	CC
8691	1980	2	in	in	IN
8691	1980	3	all	all	DT
8691	1980	4	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	1980	5	cases	case	NNS
8691	1980	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1980	7	are	be	VBP
8691	1980	8	not	not	RB
8691	1980	9	only	only	RB
8691	1980	10	powerless	powerless	JJ
8691	1980	11	to	to	TO
8691	1980	12	subject	subject	VB
8691	1980	13	any	any	DT
8691	1980	14	one	one	NN
8691	1980	15	to	to	TO
8691	1980	16	obedience	obedience	VB
8691	1980	17	to	to	IN
8691	1980	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1980	19	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	1980	20	who	who	WP
8691	1980	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	1980	22	not	not	RB
8691	1980	23	personally	personally	RB
8691	1980	24	within	within	IN
8691	1980	25	the	the	DT
8691	1980	26	State	State	NNP
8691	1980	27	in	in	IN
8691	1980	28	which	which	WDT
8691	1980	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1980	30	exist	exist	VBP
8691	1980	31	,	,	,
8691	1980	32	but	but	CC
8691	1980	33	powerless	powerless	JJ
8691	1980	34	so	so	RB
8691	1980	35	to	to	TO
8691	1980	36	subject	subject	VB
8691	1980	37	one	one	CD
8691	1980	38	who	who	WP
8691	1980	39	is	be	VBZ
8691	1980	40	personally	personally	RB
8691	1980	41	within	within	IN
8691	1980	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1980	43	,	,	,
8691	1980	44	but	but	CC
8691	1980	45	who	who	WP
8691	1980	46	did	do	VBD
8691	1980	47	not	not	RB
8691	1980	48	belong	belong	VB
8691	1980	49	there	there	RB
8691	1980	50	and	and	CC
8691	1980	51	was	be	VBD
8691	1980	52	not	not	RB
8691	1980	53	there	there	RB
8691	1980	54	served	serve	VBN
8691	1980	55	with	with	IN
8691	1980	56	process	process	NN
8691	1980	57	in	in	IN
8691	1980	58	the	the	DT
8691	1980	59	original	original	JJ
8691	1980	60	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1980	61	leading	lead	VBG
8691	1980	62	up	up	IN
8691	1980	63	to	to	IN
8691	1980	64	the	the	DT
8691	1980	65	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1980	66	,	,	,
8691	1980	67	unless	unless	IN
8691	1980	68	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1980	69	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
8691	1980	70	took	take	VBD
8691	1980	71	part	part	NN
8691	1980	72	in	in	IN
8691	1980	73	the	the	DT
8691	1980	74	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1980	75	.	.	.
8691	1981	1	In	in	IN
8691	1981	2	most	most	JJS
8691	1981	3	civilized	civilized	JJ
8691	1981	4	nations	nation	NNS
8691	1981	5	there	there	EX
8691	1981	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1981	7	a	a	DT
8691	1981	8	recognized	recognize	VBN
8691	1981	9	form	form	NN
8691	1981	10	of	of	IN
8691	1981	11	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	1981	12	by	by	IN
8691	1981	13	which	which	WDT
8691	1981	14	a	a	DT
8691	1981	15	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1981	16	of	of	IN
8691	1981	17	a	a	DT
8691	1981	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1981	19	court	court	NN
8691	1981	20	,	,	,
8691	1981	21	fairly	fairly	RB
8691	1981	22	rendered	render	VBN
8691	1981	23	after	after	IN
8691	1981	24	giving	give	VBG
8691	1981	25	a	a	DT
8691	1981	26	proper	proper	JJ
8691	1981	27	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	1981	28	to	to	IN
8691	1981	29	the	the	DT
8691	1981	30	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	1981	31	for	for	IN
8691	1981	32	a	a	DT
8691	1981	33	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	1981	34	,	,	,
8691	1981	35	can	can	MD
8691	1981	36	be	be	VB
8691	1981	37	enforced	enforce	VBN
8691	1981	38	by	by	IN
8691	1981	39	process	process	NN
8691	1981	40	from	from	IN
8691	1981	41	a	a	DT
8691	1981	42	domestic	domestic	JJ
8691	1981	43	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	1981	44	.	.	.
8691	1982	1	This	this	DT
8691	1982	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	1982	3	styled	style	VBN
8691	1982	4	making	make	VBG
8691	1982	5	the	the	DT
8691	1982	6	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1982	7	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1982	8	executory	executory	NN
8691	1982	9	.	.	.
8691	1983	1	The	the	DT
8691	1983	2	English	english	JJ
8691	1983	3	common	common	JJ
8691	1983	4	law	law	NN
8691	1983	5	did	do	VBD
8691	1983	6	not	not	RB
8691	1983	7	recognize	recognize	VB
8691	1983	8	such	such	PDT
8691	1983	9	a	a	DT
8691	1983	10	right	right	NN
8691	1983	11	,	,	,
8691	1983	12	and	and	CC
8691	1983	13	gave	give	VBD
8691	1983	14	no	no	DT
8691	1983	15	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1983	16	to	to	IN
8691	1983	17	one	one	CD
8691	1983	18	desiring	desire	VBG
8691	1983	19	to	to	TO
8691	1983	20	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1983	21	a	a	DT
8691	1983	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1983	23	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1983	24	,	,	,
8691	1983	25	except	except	IN
8691	1983	26	that	that	DT
8691	1983	27	of	of	IN
8691	1983	28	bringing	bring	VBG
8691	1983	29	a	a	DT
8691	1983	30	fresh	fresh	JJ
8691	1983	31	suit	suit	NN
8691	1983	32	.	.	.
8691	1984	1	In	in	IN
8691	1984	2	like	like	JJ
8691	1984	3	manner	manner	NN
8691	1984	4	,	,	,
8691	1984	5	whoever	whoever	WP
8691	1984	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	1984	7	recovered	recover	VBN
8691	1984	8	a	a	DT
8691	1984	9	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1984	10	against	against	IN
8691	1984	11	an	an	DT
8691	1984	12	inhabitant	inhabitant	NN
8691	1984	13	of	of	IN
8691	1984	14	any	any	DT
8691	1984	15	State	State	NNP
8691	1984	16	,	,	,
8691	1984	17	in	in	IN
8691	1984	18	a	a	DT
8691	1984	19	court	court	NN
8691	1984	20	held	hold	VBN
8691	1984	21	outside	outside	IN
8691	1984	22	of	of	IN
8691	1984	23	that	that	DT
8691	1984	24	State	state	NN
8691	1984	25	,	,	,
8691	1984	26	can	can	MD
8691	1984	27	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1984	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1984	29	against	against	IN
8691	1984	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1984	31	in	in	IN
8691	1984	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1984	33	own	own	JJ
8691	1984	34	State	state	NN
8691	1984	35	only	only	RB
8691	1984	36	by	by	IN
8691	1984	37	bringing	bring	VBG
8691	1984	38	a	a	DT
8691	1984	39	new	new	JJ
8691	1984	40	action	action	NN
8691	1984	41	.	.	.
8691	1985	1	This	this	DT
8691	1985	2	either	either	CC
8691	1985	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1985	4	,	,	,
8691	1985	5	or	or	CC
8691	1985	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	1985	7	in	in	IN
8691	1985	8	the	the	DT
8691	1985	9	nature	nature	NN
8691	1985	10	of	of	IN
8691	1985	11	,	,	,
8691	1985	12	the	the	DT
8691	1985	13	common	common	JJ
8691	1985	14	law	law	NN
8691	1985	15	action	action	NN
8691	1985	16	of	of	IN
8691	1985	17	"	"	``
8691	1985	18	debt	debt	NN
8691	1985	19	on	on	IN
8691	1985	20	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1985	21	"	"	''
8691	1985	22	;	;	:
8691	1985	23	and	and	CC
8691	1985	24	only	only	RB
8691	1985	25	two	two	CD
8691	1985	26	defenses	defense	NNS
8691	1985	27	are	be	VBP
8691	1985	28	available	available	JJ
8691	1985	29	.	.	.
8691	1986	1	These	these	DT
8691	1986	2	are	be	VBP
8691	1986	3	,	,	,
8691	1986	4	first	first	RB
8691	1986	5	,	,	,
8691	1986	6	that	that	IN
8691	1986	7	no	no	DT
8691	1986	8	such	such	JJ
8691	1986	9	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1986	10	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	1986	11	or	or	CC
8691	1986	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	1986	13	in	in	IN
8691	1986	14	force	force	NN
8691	1986	15	;	;	:
8691	1986	16	and	and	CC
8691	1986	17	,	,	,
8691	1986	18	second	second	RB
8691	1986	19	,	,	,
8691	1986	20	that	that	IN
8691	1986	21	if	if	IN
8691	1986	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1986	23	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	1986	24	,	,	,
8691	1986	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1986	26	was	be	VBD
8691	1986	27	rendered	render	VBN
8691	1986	28	by	by	IN
8691	1986	29	a	a	DT
8691	1986	30	court	court	NN
8691	1986	31	having	have	VBG
8691	1986	32	no	no	DT
8691	1986	33	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1986	34	over	over	IN
8691	1986	35	the	the	DT
8691	1986	36	subject	subject	JJ
8691	1986	37	-	-	HYPH
8691	1986	38	matter	matter	NN
8691	1986	39	or	or	CC
8691	1986	40	the	the	DT
8691	1986	41	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	1986	42	.	.	.
8691	1987	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1987	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1987	3	:	:	:
8691	1987	4	Pennoyer	Pennoyer	NNP
8691	1987	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1987	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1987	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1987	8	Neff	Neff	NNP
8691	1987	9	,	,	,
8691	1987	10	95	95	CD
8691	1987	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1987	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1987	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1987	14	,	,	,
8691	1987	15	714	714	CD
8691	1987	16	;	;	:
8691	1987	17	Grover	Grover	NNP
8691	1987	18	&	&	CC
8691	1987	19	Baker	Baker	NNP
8691	1987	20	Sewing	Sewing	NNP
8691	1987	21	Machine	Machine	NNP
8691	1987	22	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	1987	23	_	_	NNP
8691	1987	24	v.	v.	IN
8691	1987	25	_	_	NNP
8691	1987	26	Radcliffe	Radcliffe	NNP
8691	1987	27	,	,	,
8691	1987	28	137	137	CD
8691	1987	29	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1987	30	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1987	31	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	1987	32	,	,	,
8691	1987	33	287	287	CD
8691	1987	34	.	.	.
8691	1987	35	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1988	1	If	if	IN
8691	1988	2	there	there	EX
8691	1988	3	was	be	VBD
8691	1988	4	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	1988	5	,	,	,
8691	1988	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1988	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1988	8	of	of	IN
8691	1988	9	no	no	DT
8691	1988	10	consequence	consequence	NN
8691	1988	11	that	that	IN
8691	1988	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1988	13	was	be	VBD
8691	1988	14	erroneously	erroneously	RB
8691	1988	15	or	or	CC
8691	1988	16	unfairly	unfairly	RB
8691	1988	17	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	1988	18	.	.	.
8691	1989	1	The	the	DT
8691	1989	2	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	1989	3	for	for	IN
8691	1989	4	that	that	DT
8691	1989	5	must	must	MD
8691	1989	6	be	be	VB
8691	1989	7	sought	seek	VBN
8691	1989	8	in	in	IN
8691	1989	9	the	the	DT
8691	1989	10	State	State	NNP
8691	1989	11	where	where	WRB
8691	1989	12	the	the	DT
8691	1989	13	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1989	14	was	be	VBD
8691	1989	15	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	1989	16	.	.	.
8691	1990	1	Even	even	RB
8691	1990	2	fraud	fraud	NN
8691	1990	3	on	on	IN
8691	1990	4	the	the	DT
8691	1990	5	part	part	NN
8691	1990	6	of	of	IN
8691	1990	7	the	the	DT
8691	1990	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	1990	9	in	in	IN
8691	1990	10	procuring	procure	VBG
8691	1990	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1990	12	,	,	,
8691	1990	13	though	though	IN
8691	1990	14	a	a	DT
8691	1990	15	defense	defense	NN
8691	1990	16	against	against	IN
8691	1990	17	a	a	DT
8691	1990	18	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1990	19	of	of	IN
8691	1990	20	a	a	DT
8691	1990	21	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	1990	22	country	country	NN
8691	1990	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	1990	24	not	not	RB
8691	1990	25	one	one	CD
8691	1990	26	against	against	IN
8691	1990	27	a	a	DT
8691	1990	28	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	1990	29	of	of	IN
8691	1990	30	another	another	DT
8691	1990	31	State	state	NN
8691	1990	32	.	.	.
8691	1991	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1991	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1991	3	:	:	:
8691	1991	4	Christmas	Christmas	NNP
8691	1991	5	_	_	NNP
8691	1991	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	1991	7	_	_	NNP
8691	1991	8	Russell	Russell	NNP
8691	1991	9	,	,	,
8691	1991	10	5	5	CD
8691	1991	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	1991	12	's	's	POS
8691	1991	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	1991	14	,	,	,
8691	1991	15	290	290	CD
8691	1991	16	.	.	.
8691	1991	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1992	1	These	these	DT
8691	1992	2	rules	rule	NNS
8691	1992	3	are	be	VBP
8691	1992	4	established	establish	VBN
8691	1992	5	by	by	IN
8691	1992	6	Art	art	NN
8691	1992	7	.	.	.
8691	1993	1	IV	IV	NNP
8691	1993	2	,	,	,
8691	1993	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	1993	4	.	.	.
8691	1994	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1994	2	of	of	IN
8691	1994	3	the	the	DT
8691	1994	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	1994	5	of	of	IN
8691	1994	6	the	the	DT
8691	1994	7	United	United	NNP
8691	1994	8	States	States	NNP
8691	1994	9	and	and	CC
8691	1994	10	by	by	IN
8691	1994	11	Acts	Acts	NNPS
8691	1994	12	of	of	IN
8691	1994	13	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	1994	14	passed	pass	VBD
8691	1994	15	to	to	TO
8691	1994	16	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	1994	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1994	18	.	.	.
8691	1995	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	1995	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	1995	3	:	:	:
8691	1995	4	U.	U.	NNP
8691	1995	5	S.	S.	NNP
8691	1995	6	Revised	Revised	NNP
8691	1995	7	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	1995	8	,	,	,
8691	1995	9	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	1995	10	.	.	.
8691	1996	1	905	905	CD
8691	1996	2	.	.	.
8691	1996	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	1997	1	Commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	1997	2	intercourse	intercourse	NN
8691	1997	3	between	between	IN
8691	1997	4	the	the	DT
8691	1997	5	different	different	JJ
8691	1997	6	States	state	NNS
8691	1997	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	1997	8	so	so	RB
8691	1997	9	great	great	JJ
8691	1997	10	and	and	CC
8691	1997	11	so	so	RB
8691	1997	12	constant	constant	JJ
8691	1997	13	that	that	IN
8691	1997	14	questions	question	NNS
8691	1997	15	in	in	IN
8691	1997	16	the	the	DT
8691	1997	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	1997	18	of	of	IN
8691	1997	19	one	one	CD
8691	1997	20	often	often	RB
8691	1997	21	arise	arise	VBP
8691	1997	22	which	which	WDT
8691	1997	23	turn	turn	VBP
8691	1997	24	on	on	IN
8691	1997	25	the	the	DT
8691	1997	26	law	law	NN
8691	1997	27	of	of	IN
8691	1997	28	another	another	DT
8691	1997	29	.	.	.
8691	1998	1	Those	those	DT
8691	1998	2	who	who	WP
8691	1998	3	do	do	VBP
8691	1998	4	any	any	DT
8691	1998	5	act	act	NN
8691	1998	6	do	do	VB
8691	1998	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1998	8	with	with	IN
8691	1998	9	implied	imply	VBN
8691	1998	10	reference	reference	NN
8691	1998	11	to	to	IN
8691	1998	12	the	the	DT
8691	1998	13	law	law	NN
8691	1998	14	of	of	IN
8691	1998	15	the	the	DT
8691	1998	16	place	place	NN
8691	1998	17	where	where	WRB
8691	1998	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1998	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	1998	20	done	do	VBN
8691	1998	21	,	,	,
8691	1998	22	so	so	RB
8691	1998	23	far	far	RB
8691	1998	24	as	as	IN
8691	1998	25	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	1998	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	1998	27	legal	legal	JJ
8691	1998	28	consequences	consequence	NNS
8691	1998	29	.	.	.
8691	1999	1	If	if	IN
8691	1999	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1999	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	1999	4	a	a	DT
8691	1999	5	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
8691	1999	6	act	act	NN
8691	1999	7	there	there	RB
8691	1999	8	,	,	,
8691	1999	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	1999	10	will	will	MD
8691	1999	11	in	in	IN
8691	1999	12	most	most	JJS
8691	1999	13	instances	instance	NNS
8691	1999	14	be	be	VB
8691	1999	15	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	1999	16	a	a	DT
8691	1999	17	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
8691	1999	18	act	act	NN
8691	1999	19	everywhere	everywhere	RB
8691	1999	20	.	.	.
8691	2000	1	If	if	IN
8691	2000	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2000	3	leads	lead	VBZ
8691	2000	4	to	to	IN
8691	2000	5	a	a	DT
8691	2000	6	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2000	7	result	result	NN
8691	2000	8	as	as	IN
8691	2000	9	regards	regard	VBZ
8691	2000	10	property	property	NN
8691	2000	11	rights	right	NNS
8691	2000	12	there	there	RB
8691	2000	13	,	,	,
8691	2000	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2000	15	will	will	MD
8691	2000	16	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2000	17	give	give	VB
8691	2000	18	a	a	DT
8691	2000	19	right	right	NN
8691	2000	20	of	of	IN
8691	2000	21	action	action	NN
8691	2000	22	anywhere	anywhere	RB
8691	2000	23	,	,	,
8691	2000	24	to	to	TO
8691	2000	25	secure	secure	VB
8691	2000	26	the	the	DT
8691	2000	27	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	2000	28	of	of	IN
8691	2000	29	that	that	DT
8691	2000	30	result	result	NN
8691	2000	31	.	.	.
8691	2001	1	The	the	DT
8691	2001	2	law	law	NN
8691	2001	3	of	of	IN
8691	2001	4	each	each	DT
8691	2001	5	State	State	NNP
8691	2001	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2001	7	largely	largely	RB
8691	2001	8	an	an	DT
8691	2001	9	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	2001	10	common	common	JJ
8691	2001	11	law	law	NN
8691	2001	12	.	.	.
8691	2002	1	Even	even	RB
8691	2002	2	in	in	IN
8691	2002	3	those	those	DT
8691	2002	4	where	where	WRB
8691	2002	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2002	6	have	have	VBP
8691	2002	7	full	full	JJ
8691	2002	8	codes	code	NNS
8691	2002	9	defining	define	VBG
8691	2002	10	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2002	11	rights	right	NNS
8691	2002	12	,	,	,
8691	2002	13	these	these	DT
8691	2002	14	codes	code	NNS
8691	2002	15	are	be	VBP
8691	2002	16	expressed	express	VBN
8691	2002	17	in	in	IN
8691	2002	18	terms	term	NNS
8691	2002	19	for	for	IN
8691	2002	20	the	the	DT
8691	2002	21	definitions	definition	NNS
8691	2002	22	of	of	IN
8691	2002	23	many	many	JJ
8691	2002	24	of	of	IN
8691	2002	25	which	which	WDT
8691	2002	26	the	the	DT
8691	2002	27	common	common	JJ
8691	2002	28	law	law	NN
8691	2002	29	gives	give	VBZ
8691	2002	30	the	the	DT
8691	2002	31	rule	rule	NN
8691	2002	32	.	.	.
8691	2003	1	But	but	CC
8691	2003	2	this	this	DT
8691	2003	3	common	common	JJ
8691	2003	4	law	law	NN
8691	2003	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2003	6	not	not	RB
8691	2003	7	precisely	precisely	RB
8691	2003	8	the	the	DT
8691	2003	9	same	same	JJ
8691	2003	10	in	in	IN
8691	2003	11	any	any	DT
8691	2003	12	two	two	CD
8691	2003	13	States	state	NNS
8691	2003	14	.	.	.
8691	2004	1	In	in	IN
8691	2004	2	minor	minor	JJ
8691	2004	3	points	point	NNS
8691	2004	4	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	2004	5	,	,	,
8691	2004	6	and	and	CC
8691	2004	7	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	2004	8	in	in	IN
8691	2004	9	capital	capital	NN
8691	2004	10	ones	one	NNS
8691	2004	11	,	,	,
8691	2004	12	there	there	EX
8691	2004	13	will	will	MD
8691	2004	14	be	be	VB
8691	2004	15	a	a	DT
8691	2004	16	divergence	divergence	NN
8691	2004	17	.	.	.
8691	2005	1	In	in	IN
8691	2005	2	England	England	NNP
8691	2005	3	there	there	EX
8691	2005	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2005	5	one	one	CD
8691	2005	6	uniform	uniform	JJ
8691	2005	7	common	common	JJ
8691	2005	8	law	law	NN
8691	2005	9	.	.	.
8691	2006	1	Here	here	RB
8691	2006	2	,	,	,
8691	2006	3	divided	divide	VBN
8691	2006	4	as	as	IN
8691	2006	5	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2006	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2006	7	for	for	IN
8691	2006	8	most	most	JJS
8691	2006	9	business	business	NN
8691	2006	10	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	2006	11	into	into	IN
8691	2006	12	forty	forty	CD
8691	2006	13	-	-	HYPH
8691	2006	14	five	five	CD
8691	2006	15	different	different	JJ
8691	2006	16	sovereignties	sovereignty	NNS
8691	2006	17	,	,	,
8691	2006	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2006	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	2006	20	multiform	multiform	NN
8691	2006	21	.	.	.
8691	2007	1	If	if	IN
8691	2007	2	,	,	,
8691	2007	3	then	then	RB
8691	2007	4	,	,	,
8691	2007	5	the	the	DT
8691	2007	6	court	court	NN
8691	2007	7	of	of	IN
8691	2007	8	one	one	CD
8691	2007	9	State	State	NNP
8691	2007	10	in	in	IN
8691	2007	11	determining	determine	VBG
8691	2007	12	the	the	DT
8691	2007	13	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2007	14	effect	effect	NN
8691	2007	15	of	of	IN
8691	2007	16	a	a	DT
8691	2007	17	transaction	transaction	NN
8691	2007	18	having	have	VBG
8691	2007	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2007	20	seat	seat	NN
8691	2007	21	in	in	IN
8691	2007	22	another	another	DT
8691	2007	23	must	must	MD
8691	2007	24	be	be	VB
8691	2007	25	governed	govern	VBN
8691	2007	26	by	by	IN
8691	2007	27	the	the	DT
8691	2007	28	common	common	JJ
8691	2007	29	law	law	NN
8691	2007	30	of	of	IN
8691	2007	31	that	that	DT
8691	2007	32	State	State	NNP
8691	2007	33	,	,	,
8691	2007	34	where	where	WRB
8691	2007	35	is	be	VBZ
8691	2007	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2007	37	to	to	TO
8691	2007	38	be	be	VB
8691	2007	39	found	find	VBN
8691	2007	40	?	?	.
8691	2008	1	If	if	IN
8691	2008	2	there	there	EX
8691	2008	3	have	have	VBP
8691	2008	4	been	be	VBN
8691	2008	5	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2008	6	of	of	IN
8691	2008	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2008	8	highest	high	JJS
8691	2008	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	2008	10	in	in	IN
8691	2008	11	regard	regard	NN
8691	2008	12	to	to	IN
8691	2008	13	what	what	WP
8691	2008	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2008	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	2008	16	with	with	IN
8691	2008	17	reference	reference	NN
8691	2008	18	to	to	IN
8691	2008	19	the	the	DT
8691	2008	20	point	point	NN
8691	2008	21	in	in	IN
8691	2008	22	question	question	NN
8691	2008	23	,	,	,
8691	2008	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2008	25	will	will	MD
8691	2008	26	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2008	27	be	be	VB
8691	2008	28	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	2008	29	as	as	IN
8691	2008	30	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	2008	31	.	.	.
8691	2009	1	This	this	DT
8691	2009	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2009	3	not	not	RB
8691	2009	4	by	by	IN
8691	2009	5	virtue	virtue	NN
8691	2009	6	of	of	IN
8691	2009	7	the	the	DT
8691	2009	8	provision	provision	NN
8691	2009	9	in	in	IN
8691	2009	10	the	the	DT
8691	2009	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2009	12	of	of	IN
8691	2009	13	the	the	DT
8691	2009	14	United	United	NNP
8691	2009	15	States	States	NNP
8691	2009	16	that	that	IN
8691	2009	17	full	full	JJ
8691	2009	18	faith	faith	NN
8691	2009	19	and	and	CC
8691	2009	20	credit	credit	NN
8691	2009	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	2009	22	to	to	TO
8691	2009	23	be	be	VB
8691	2009	24	given	give	VBN
8691	2009	25	in	in	IN
8691	2009	26	each	each	DT
8691	2009	27	State	state	NN
8691	2009	28	to	to	IN
8691	2009	29	the	the	DT
8691	2009	30	public	public	JJ
8691	2009	31	records	record	NNS
8691	2009	32	and	and	CC
8691	2009	33	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2009	34	of	of	IN
8691	2009	35	the	the	DT
8691	2009	36	others	other	NNS
8691	2009	37	.	.	.
8691	2010	1	That	that	DT
8691	2010	2	refers	refer	VBZ
8691	2010	3	to	to	IN
8691	2010	4	the	the	DT
8691	2010	5	effect	effect	NN
8691	2010	6	of	of	IN
8691	2010	7	public	public	JJ
8691	2010	8	records	record	NNS
8691	2010	9	and	and	CC
8691	2010	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2010	11	upon	upon	IN
8691	2010	12	the	the	DT
8691	2010	13	rights	right	NNS
8691	2010	14	of	of	IN
8691	2010	15	those	those	DT
8691	2010	16	who	who	WP
8691	2010	17	are	be	VBP
8691	2010	18	or	or	CC
8691	2010	19	claim	claim	VBP
8691	2010	20	under	under	IN
8691	2010	21	parties	party	NNS
8691	2010	22	to	to	IN
8691	2010	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2010	24	.	.	.
8691	2011	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	2011	2	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2011	3	as	as	IN
8691	2011	4	those	those	DT
8691	2011	5	which	which	WDT
8691	2011	6	have	have	VBP
8691	2011	7	been	be	VBN
8691	2011	8	described	describe	VBN
8691	2011	9	are	be	VBP
8691	2011	10	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	2011	11	as	as	RB
8691	2011	12	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	2011	13	as	as	IN
8691	2011	14	to	to	IN
8691	2011	15	the	the	DT
8691	2011	16	rights	right	NNS
8691	2011	17	of	of	IN
8691	2011	18	those	those	DT
8691	2011	19	who	who	WP
8691	2011	20	were	be	VBD
8691	2011	21	not	not	RB
8691	2011	22	parties	party	NNS
8691	2011	23	to	to	IN
8691	2011	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2011	25	,	,	,
8691	2011	26	and	and	CC
8691	2011	27	simply	simply	RB
8691	2011	28	because	because	IN
8691	2011	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2011	30	are	be	VBP
8691	2011	31	considered	consider	VBN
8691	2011	32	the	the	DT
8691	2011	33	best	good	JJS
8691	2011	34	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2011	35	attainable	attainable	JJ
8691	2011	36	of	of	IN
8691	2011	37	a	a	DT
8691	2011	38	rule	rule	NN
8691	2011	39	of	of	IN
8691	2011	40	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	2011	41	law	law	NN
8691	2011	42	of	of	IN
8691	2011	43	general	general	JJ
8691	2011	44	application	application	NN
8691	2011	45	.	.	.
8691	2012	1	But	but	CC
8691	2012	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2012	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2012	4	not	not	RB
8691	2012	5	universally	universally	RB
8691	2012	6	so	so	RB
8691	2012	7	considered	considered	JJ
8691	2012	8	.	.	.
8691	2013	1	The	the	DT
8691	2013	2	rule	rule	NN
8691	2013	3	that	that	IN
8691	2013	4	transactions	transaction	NNS
8691	2013	5	are	be	VBP
8691	2013	6	governed	govern	VBN
8691	2013	7	by	by	IN
8691	2013	8	the	the	DT
8691	2013	9	law	law	NN
8691	2013	10	of	of	IN
8691	2013	11	the	the	DT
8691	2013	12	place	place	NN
8691	2013	13	where	where	WRB
8691	2013	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2013	15	have	have	VBP
8691	2013	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2013	17	seat	seat	NN
8691	2013	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	2013	19	one	one	CD
8691	2013	20	founded	found	VBN
8691	2013	21	on	on	IN
8691	2013	22	the	the	DT
8691	2013	23	presumed	presume	VBN
8691	2013	24	intent	intent	NN
8691	2013	25	of	of	IN
8691	2013	26	the	the	DT
8691	2013	27	parties	party	NNS
8691	2013	28	to	to	IN
8691	2013	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2013	30	.	.	.
8691	2014	1	But	but	CC
8691	2014	2	in	in	IN
8691	2014	3	fact	fact	NN
8691	2014	4	the	the	DT
8691	2014	5	parties	party	NNS
8691	2014	6	to	to	IN
8691	2014	7	a	a	DT
8691	2014	8	business	business	NN
8691	2014	9	transaction	transaction	NN
8691	2014	10	act	act	NN
8691	2014	11	on	on	IN
8691	2014	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2014	13	general	general	JJ
8691	2014	14	notions	notion	NNS
8691	2014	15	of	of	IN
8691	2014	16	what	what	WP
8691	2014	17	the	the	DT
8691	2014	18	law	law	NN
8691	2014	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	2014	20	or	or	CC
8691	2014	21	must	must	MD
8691	2014	22	be	be	VB
8691	2014	23	,	,	,
8691	2014	24	rather	rather	RB
8691	2014	25	than	than	IN
8691	2014	26	on	on	IN
8691	2014	27	any	any	DT
8691	2014	28	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2014	29	knowledge	knowledge	NN
8691	2014	30	of	of	IN
8691	2014	31	what	what	WP
8691	2014	32	courts	court	NNS
8691	2014	33	have	have	VBP
8691	2014	34	declared	declare	VBN
8691	2014	35	that	that	IN
8691	2014	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2014	37	is	be	VBZ
8691	2014	38	.	.	.
8691	2015	1	The	the	DT
8691	2015	2	rule	rule	NN
8691	2015	3	that	that	IN
8691	2015	4	one	one	CD
8691	2015	5	country	country	NN
8691	2015	6	will	will	MD
8691	2015	7	accept	accept	VB
8691	2015	8	the	the	DT
8691	2015	9	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2015	10	of	of	IN
8691	2015	11	the	the	DT
8691	2015	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2015	13	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	2015	14	of	of	IN
8691	2015	15	another	another	DT
8691	2015	16	as	as	IN
8691	2015	17	to	to	IN
8691	2015	18	what	what	WP
8691	2015	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2015	20	law	law	NN
8691	2015	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	2015	22	,	,	,
8691	2015	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	2015	24	one	one	CD
8691	2015	25	not	not	RB
8691	2015	26	to	to	TO
8691	2015	27	be	be	VB
8691	2015	28	pressed	press	VBN
8691	2015	29	so	so	RB
8691	2015	30	far	far	RB
8691	2015	31	as	as	IN
8691	2015	32	to	to	TO
8691	2015	33	sacrifice	sacrifice	VB
8691	2015	34	essential	essential	JJ
8691	2015	35	justice	justice	NN
8691	2015	36	.	.	.
8691	2016	1	In	in	IN
8691	2016	2	this	this	DT
8691	2016	3	point	point	NN
8691	2016	4	of	of	IN
8691	2016	5	view	view	NN
8691	2016	6	,	,	,
8691	2016	7	some	some	DT
8691	2016	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	2016	9	hold	hold	VBP
8691	2016	10	that	that	IN
8691	2016	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2016	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2016	13	permissible	permissible	JJ
8691	2016	14	to	to	TO
8691	2016	15	disregard	disregard	VB
8691	2016	16	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2016	17	of	of	IN
8691	2016	18	other	other	JJ
8691	2016	19	States	state	NNS
8691	2016	20	which	which	WDT
8691	2016	21	are	be	VBP
8691	2016	22	based	base	VBN
8691	2016	23	on	on	IN
8691	2016	24	a	a	DT
8691	2016	25	departure	departure	NN
8691	2016	26	from	from	IN
8691	2016	27	what	what	WP
8691	2016	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	2016	29	generally	generally	RB
8691	2016	30	considered	consider	VBN
8691	2016	31	a	a	DT
8691	2016	32	settled	settle	VBN
8691	2016	33	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	2016	34	of	of	IN
8691	2016	35	the	the	DT
8691	2016	36	common	common	JJ
8691	2016	37	law	law	NN
8691	2016	38	as	as	IN
8691	2016	39	to	to	IN
8691	2016	40	a	a	DT
8691	2016	41	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	2016	42	question	question	NN
8691	2016	43	.	.	.
8691	2017	1	This	this	DT
8691	2017	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2017	3	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	2017	4	the	the	DT
8691	2017	5	same	same	JJ
8691	2017	6	position	position	NN
8691	2017	7	taken	take	VBN
8691	2017	8	by	by	IN
8691	2017	9	the	the	DT
8691	2017	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2017	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2017	12	of	of	IN
8691	2017	13	the	the	DT
8691	2017	14	United	United	NNP
8691	2017	15	States	States	NNP
8691	2017	16	,	,	,
8691	2017	17	and	and	CC
8691	2017	18	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
8691	2017	19	described,[Footnote	described,[footnote	CD
8691	2017	20	:	:	:
8691	2017	21	See	see	VB
8691	2017	22	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	2017	23	.	.	.
8691	2018	1	X.	X.	NNP
8691	2018	2	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2019	1	concerning	concern	VBG
8691	2019	2	the	the	DT
8691	2019	3	right	right	NN
8691	2019	4	of	of	IN
8691	2019	5	a	a	DT
8691	2019	6	federal	federal	JJ
8691	2019	7	court	court	NN
8691	2019	8	to	to	TO
8691	2019	9	refuse	refuse	VB
8691	2019	10	to	to	TO
8691	2019	11	be	be	VB
8691	2019	12	bound	bind	VBN
8691	2019	13	by	by	IN
8691	2019	14	State	state	NN
8691	2019	15	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2019	16	as	as	IN
8691	2019	17	to	to	IN
8691	2019	18	the	the	DT
8691	2019	19	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	2019	20	law	law	NN
8691	2019	21	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	2019	22	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	2019	23	trade	trade	NN
8691	2019	24	or	or	CC
8691	2019	25	trade	trade	NN
8691	2019	26	between	between	IN
8691	2019	27	the	the	DT
8691	2019	28	States	States	NNP
8691	2019	29	.	.	.
8691	2020	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2020	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2020	3	:	:	:
8691	2020	4	Faulkner	Faulkner	NNP
8691	2020	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2020	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2020	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2020	8	Hart	Hart	NNP
8691	2020	9	,	,	,
8691	2020	10	82	82	CD
8691	2020	11	N.	n.	NN
8691	2020	12	Y.	y.	NN
8691	2021	1	Reports	report	NNS
8691	2021	2	,	,	,
8691	2021	3	413	413	CD
8691	2021	4	,	,	,
8691	2021	5	423	423	CD
8691	2021	6	.	.	.
8691	2021	7	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2022	1	Another	another	DT
8691	2022	2	rule	rule	NN
8691	2022	3	of	of	IN
8691	2022	4	practice	practice	NN
8691	2022	5	of	of	IN
8691	2022	6	great	great	JJ
8691	2022	7	importance	importance	NN
8691	2022	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2022	9	that	that	IN
8691	2022	10	in	in	IN
8691	2022	11	the	the	DT
8691	2022	12	absence	absence	NN
8691	2022	13	of	of	IN
8691	2022	14	proof	proof	NN
8691	2022	15	to	to	IN
8691	2022	16	the	the	DT
8691	2022	17	contrary	contrary	NN
8691	2022	18	the	the	DT
8691	2022	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	2022	20	will	will	MD
8691	2022	21	presume	presume	VB
8691	2022	22	,	,	,
8691	2022	23	in	in	IN
8691	2022	24	a	a	DT
8691	2022	25	State	state	NN
8691	2022	26	basing	base	VBG
8691	2022	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2022	28	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	2022	29	on	on	IN
8691	2022	30	the	the	DT
8691	2022	31	English	english	JJ
8691	2022	32	common	common	JJ
8691	2022	33	law	law	NN
8691	2022	34	,	,	,
8691	2022	35	that	that	IN
8691	2022	36	the	the	DT
8691	2022	37	unwritten	unwritten	JJ
8691	2022	38	law	law	NN
8691	2022	39	of	of	IN
8691	2022	40	any	any	DT
8691	2022	41	other	other	JJ
8691	2022	42	American	American	NNP
8691	2022	43	State	State	NNP
8691	2022	44	is	be	VBZ
8691	2022	45	the	the	DT
8691	2022	46	same	same	JJ
8691	2022	47	as	as	IN
8691	2022	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2022	49	own	own	JJ
8691	2022	50	.	.	.
8691	2023	1	As	as	IN
8691	2023	2	the	the	DT
8691	2023	3	reason	reason	NN
8691	2023	4	of	of	IN
8691	2023	5	this	this	DT
8691	2023	6	rule	rule	NN
8691	2023	7	fails	fail	VBZ
8691	2023	8	in	in	IN
8691	2023	9	the	the	DT
8691	2023	10	case	case	NN
8691	2023	11	of	of	IN
8691	2023	12	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	2023	13	,	,	,
8691	2023	14	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	2023	15	and	and	CC
8691	2023	16	Texas	Texas	NNP
8691	2023	17	,	,	,
8691	2023	18	which	which	WDT
8691	2023	19	were	be	VBD
8691	2023	20	subject	subject	JJ
8691	2023	21	to	to	IN
8691	2023	22	organized	organized	JJ
8691	2023	23	governments	government	NNS
8691	2023	24	not	not	RB
8691	2023	25	derived	derive	VBN
8691	2023	26	from	from	IN
8691	2023	27	Great	Great	NNP
8691	2023	28	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	2023	29	at	at	IN
8691	2023	30	the	the	DT
8691	2023	31	time	time	NN
8691	2023	32	when	when	WRB
8691	2023	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2023	34	were	be	VBD
8691	2023	35	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
8691	2023	36	into	into	IN
8691	2023	37	the	the	DT
8691	2023	38	United	United	NNP
8691	2023	39	States	States	NNP
8691	2023	40	,	,	,
8691	2023	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2023	42	is	be	VBZ
8691	2023	43	not	not	RB
8691	2023	44	applied	apply	VBN
8691	2023	45	to	to	IN
8691	2023	46	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2023	47	.	.	.
8691	2024	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2024	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2024	3	:	:	:
8691	2024	4	Norris	Norris	NNP
8691	2024	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2024	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2024	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2024	8	Harris	Harris	NNP
8691	2024	9	,	,	,
8691	2024	10	15	15	CD
8691	2024	11	California	California	NNP
8691	2024	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2024	13	,	,	,
8691	2024	14	253	253	CD
8691	2024	15	.	.	.
8691	2024	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2025	1	Decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2025	2	of	of	IN
8691	2025	3	a	a	DT
8691	2025	4	court	court	NN
8691	2025	5	constitute	constitute	VBP
8691	2025	6	a	a	DT
8691	2025	7	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	2025	8	of	of	IN
8691	2025	9	binding	bind	VBG
8691	2025	10	obligation	obligation	NN
8691	2025	11	only	only	RB
8691	2025	12	within	within	IN
8691	2025	13	the	the	DT
8691	2025	14	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2025	15	territorial	territorial	JJ
8691	2025	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2025	17	which	which	WDT
8691	2025	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	2025	19	subject	subject	JJ
8691	2025	20	to	to	IN
8691	2025	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2025	22	process	process	NN
8691	2025	23	.	.	.
8691	2026	1	In	in	IN
8691	2026	2	the	the	DT
8691	2026	3	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	2026	4	of	of	IN
8691	2026	5	one	one	CD
8691	2026	6	State	state	NN
8691	2026	7	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2026	8	rendered	render	VBN
8691	2026	9	in	in	IN
8691	2026	10	another	another	DT
8691	2026	11	on	on	IN
8691	2026	12	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2026	13	points	point	NNS
8691	2026	14	are	be	VBP
8691	2026	15	,	,	,
8691	2026	16	so	so	RB
8691	2026	17	far	far	RB
8691	2026	18	as	as	IN
8691	2026	19	respects	respect	NNS
8691	2026	20	transactions	transaction	NNS
8691	2026	21	not	not	RB
8691	2026	22	governed	govern	VBN
8691	2026	23	by	by	IN
8691	2026	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2026	25	local	local	JJ
8691	2026	26	law	law	NN
8691	2026	27	,	,	,
8691	2026	28	without	without	IN
8691	2026	29	any	any	DT
8691	2026	30	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
8691	2026	31	force	force	NN
8691	2026	32	.	.	.
8691	2027	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2027	2	may	may	MD
8691	2027	3	be	be	VB
8691	2027	4	read	read	VBN
8691	2027	5	,	,	,
8691	2027	6	just	just	RB
8691	2027	7	as	as	IN
8691	2027	8	the	the	DT
8691	2027	9	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	2027	10	of	of	IN
8691	2027	11	an	an	DT
8691	2027	12	author	author	NN
8691	2027	13	expressed	express	VBN
8691	2027	14	in	in	IN
8691	2027	15	a	a	DT
8691	2027	16	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2027	17	treatise	treatise	NN
8691	2027	18	,	,	,
8691	2027	19	or	or	CC
8691	2027	20	as	as	IN
8691	2027	21	the	the	DT
8691	2027	22	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2027	23	of	of	IN
8691	2027	24	an	an	DT
8691	2027	25	English	english	JJ
8691	2027	26	or	or	CC
8691	2027	27	German	german	JJ
8691	2027	28	court	court	NN
8691	2027	29	might	may	MD
8691	2027	30	be	be	VB
8691	2027	31	,	,	,
8691	2027	32	for	for	IN
8691	2027	33	what	what	WP
8691	2027	34	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2027	35	appear	appear	VBP
8691	2027	36	to	to	TO
8691	2027	37	be	be	VB
8691	2027	38	worth	worth	JJ
8691	2027	39	.	.	.
8691	2028	1	No	no	DT
8691	2028	2	formal	formal	JJ
8691	2028	3	proof	proof	NN
8691	2028	4	that	that	IN
8691	2028	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2028	6	were	be	VBD
8691	2028	7	really	really	RB
8691	2028	8	the	the	DT
8691	2028	9	deliverances	deliverance	NNS
8691	2028	10	of	of	IN
8691	2028	11	the	the	DT
8691	2028	12	court	court	NN
8691	2028	13	from	from	IN
8691	2028	14	which	which	WDT
8691	2028	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2028	16	purport	purport	VBP
8691	2028	17	to	to	TO
8691	2028	18	emanate	emanate	VB
8691	2028	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	2028	20	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2028	21	to	to	TO
8691	2028	22	support	support	VB
8691	2028	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2028	24	use	use	NN
8691	2028	25	for	for	IN
8691	2028	26	this	this	DT
8691	2028	27	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2028	28	.	.	.
8691	2029	1	The	the	DT
8691	2029	2	reported	report	VBN
8691	2029	3	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2029	4	of	of	IN
8691	2029	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	2029	6	of	of	IN
8691	2029	7	other	other	JJ
8691	2029	8	States	States	NNPS
8691	2029	9	,	,	,
8691	2029	10	whether	whether	IN
8691	2029	11	published	publish	VBN
8691	2029	12	officially	officially	RB
8691	2029	13	or	or	CC
8691	2029	14	unofficially	unofficially	RB
8691	2029	15	,	,	,
8691	2029	16	may	may	MD
8691	2029	17	be	be	VB
8691	2029	18	cited	cite	VBN
8691	2029	19	in	in	IN
8691	2029	20	argument	argument	NN
8691	2029	21	in	in	IN
8691	2029	22	any	any	DT
8691	2029	23	cause	cause	NN
8691	2029	24	,	,	,
8691	2029	25	to	to	TO
8691	2029	26	fortify	fortify	VB
8691	2029	27	the	the	DT
8691	2029	28	claims	claim	NNS
8691	2029	29	of	of	IN
8691	2029	30	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2029	31	as	as	IN
8691	2029	32	to	to	IN
8691	2029	33	the	the	DT
8691	2029	34	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2029	35	rules	rule	NNS
8691	2029	36	to	to	TO
8691	2029	37	be	be	VB
8691	2029	38	followed	follow	VBN
8691	2029	39	in	in	IN
8691	2029	40	reaching	reach	VBG
8691	2029	41	a	a	DT
8691	2029	42	decision	decision	NN
8691	2029	43	.	.	.
8691	2030	1	For	for	IN
8691	2030	2	this	this	DT
8691	2030	3	use	use	NN
8691	2030	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2030	5	are	be	VBP
8691	2030	6	introduced	introduce	VBN
8691	2030	7	simply	simply	RB
8691	2030	8	for	for	IN
8691	2030	9	the	the	DT
8691	2030	10	intrinsic	intrinsic	JJ
8691	2030	11	value	value	NN
8691	2030	12	of	of	IN
8691	2030	13	the	the	DT
8691	2030	14	reasoning	reasoning	NN
8691	2030	15	and	and	CC
8691	2030	16	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2030	17	.	.	.
8691	2031	1	If	if	IN
8691	2031	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2031	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2031	4	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	2031	5	that	that	IN
8691	2031	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2031	7	prove	prove	VBP
8691	2031	8	the	the	DT
8691	2031	9	law	law	NN
8691	2031	10	of	of	IN
8691	2031	11	the	the	DT
8691	2031	12	State	State	NNP
8691	2031	13	from	from	IN
8691	2031	14	which	which	WDT
8691	2031	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2031	16	come	come	VBP
8691	2031	17	to	to	TO
8691	2031	18	be	be	VB
8691	2031	19	of	of	IN
8691	2031	20	a	a	DT
8691	2031	21	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2031	22	nature	nature	NN
8691	2031	23	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2031	24	and	and	CC
8691	2031	25	that	that	DT
8691	2031	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	2031	27	a	a	DT
8691	2031	28	material	material	JJ
8691	2031	29	point	point	NN
8691	2031	30	in	in	IN
8691	2031	31	the	the	DT
8691	2031	32	case	case	NN
8691	2031	33	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2031	34	,	,	,
8691	2031	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2031	36	should	should	MD
8691	2031	37	be	be	VB
8691	2031	38	made	make	VBN
8691	2031	39	the	the	DT
8691	2031	40	subject	subject	NN
8691	2031	41	of	of	IN
8691	2031	42	proof	proof	NN
8691	2031	43	before	before	IN
8691	2031	44	argument	argument	NN
8691	2031	45	.	.	.
8691	2032	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2032	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2032	3	:	:	:
8691	2032	4	Hanley	Hanley	NNP
8691	2032	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2032	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2032	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2032	8	Donoghue	Donoghue	NNP
8691	2032	9	,	,	,
8691	2032	10	116	116	CD
8691	2032	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2032	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2032	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2032	14	,	,	,
8691	2032	15	1	1	CD
8691	2032	16	.	.	.
8691	2032	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2033	1	In	in	IN
8691	2033	2	many	many	JJ
8691	2033	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2033	4	this	this	DT
8691	2033	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2033	6	dispensed	dispense	VBN
8691	2033	7	with	with	IN
8691	2033	8	by	by	IN
8691	2033	9	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2033	10	allowing	allow	VBG
8691	2033	11	courts	court	NNS
8691	2033	12	to	to	TO
8691	2033	13	take	take	VB
8691	2033	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2033	15	notice	notice	NN
8691	2033	16	of	of	IN
8691	2033	17	all	all	DT
8691	2033	18	reported	report	VBN
8691	2033	19	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2033	20	in	in	IN
8691	2033	21	other	other	JJ
8691	2033	22	States	States	NNPS
8691	2033	23	;	;	:
8691	2033	24	that	that	RB
8691	2033	25	is	is	RB
8691	2033	26	,	,	,
8691	2033	27	in	in	IN
8691	2033	28	effect	effect	NN
8691	2033	29	,	,	,
8691	2033	30	to	to	TO
8691	2033	31	take	take	VB
8691	2033	32	any	any	DT
8691	2033	33	means	mean	NNS
8691	2033	34	which	which	WDT
8691	2033	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2033	36	think	think	VBP
8691	2033	37	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2033	38	to	to	TO
8691	2033	39	learn	learn	VB
8691	2033	40	what	what	WP
8691	2033	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2033	42	are	be	VBP
8691	2033	43	.	.	.
8691	2034	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2034	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2034	3	also	also	RB
8691	2034	4	the	the	DT
8691	2034	5	general	general	JJ
8691	2034	6	practice	practice	NN
8691	2034	7	of	of	IN
8691	2034	8	the	the	DT
8691	2034	9	bar	bar	NN
8691	2034	10	where	where	WRB
8691	2034	11	no	no	DT
8691	2034	12	such	such	JJ
8691	2034	13	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2034	14	exist	exist	VBP
8691	2034	15	to	to	TO
8691	2034	16	allow	allow	VB
8691	2034	17	the	the	DT
8691	2034	18	reports	report	NNS
8691	2034	19	of	of	IN
8691	2034	20	other	other	JJ
8691	2034	21	States	States	NNPS
8691	2034	22	to	to	TO
8691	2034	23	be	be	VB
8691	2034	24	read	read	VBN
8691	2034	25	for	for	IN
8691	2034	26	any	any	DT
8691	2034	27	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2034	28	without	without	IN
8691	2034	29	objection	objection	NN
8691	2034	30	.	.	.
8691	2035	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	2035	2	States	state	NNS
8691	2035	3	have	have	VBP
8691	2035	4	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2035	5	to	to	TO
8691	2035	6	facilitate	facilitate	VB
8691	2035	7	the	the	DT
8691	2035	8	proof	proof	NN
8691	2035	9	in	in	IN
8691	2035	10	court	court	NN
8691	2035	11	of	of	IN
8691	2035	12	the	the	DT
8691	2035	13	statute	statute	NN
8691	2035	14	laws	law	NNS
8691	2035	15	of	of	IN
8691	2035	16	other	other	JJ
8691	2035	17	States	States	NNPS
8691	2035	18	.	.	.
8691	2036	1	The	the	DT
8691	2036	2	mode	mode	NN
8691	2036	3	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
8691	2036	4	by	by	IN
8691	2036	5	Act	Act	NNP
8691	2036	6	of	of	IN
8691	2036	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	2036	8	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2036	9	Revised	Revised	NNP
8691	2036	10	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	2036	11	,	,	,
8691	2036	12	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	2036	13	.	.	.
8691	2037	1	905	905	CD
8691	2037	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2037	3	under	under	IN
8691	2037	4	the	the	DT
8691	2037	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	2037	6	provision	provision	NN
8691	2037	7	,	,	,
8691	2037	8	to	to	TO
8691	2037	9	which	which	WDT
8691	2037	10	reference	reference	NN
8691	2037	11	has	have	VBZ
8691	2037	12	been	be	VBN
8691	2037	13	made	make	VBN
8691	2037	14	,	,	,
8691	2037	15	involves	involve	VBZ
8691	2037	16	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2037	17	expense	expense	NN
8691	2037	18	for	for	IN
8691	2037	19	the	the	DT
8691	2037	20	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2037	21	certification	certification	NN
8691	2037	22	of	of	IN
8691	2037	23	copies	copy	NNS
8691	2037	24	.	.	.
8691	2038	1	Common	common	JJ
8691	2038	2	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	2038	3	of	of	IN
8691	2038	4	State	State	NNP
8691	2038	5	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	2038	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2038	7	that	that	IN
8691	2038	8	all	all	DT
8691	2038	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	2038	10	may	may	MD
8691	2038	11	take	take	VB
8691	2038	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2038	13	notice	notice	NN
8691	2038	14	of	of	IN
8691	2038	15	the	the	DT
8691	2038	16	laws	law	NNS
8691	2038	17	of	of	IN
8691	2038	18	other	other	JJ
8691	2038	19	States	States	NNPS
8691	2038	20	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2038	21	that	that	RB
8691	2038	22	is	is	RB
8691	2038	23	,	,	,
8691	2038	24	take	take	VB
8691	2038	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2038	26	into	into	IN
8691	2038	27	account	account	NN
8691	2038	28	without	without	IN
8691	2038	29	any	any	DT
8691	2038	30	formal	formal	JJ
8691	2038	31	proof	proof	NN
8691	2038	32	at	at	RB
8691	2038	33	all	all	RB
8691	2038	34	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2038	35	,	,	,
8691	2038	36	or	or	CC
8691	2038	37	that	that	IN
8691	2038	38	a	a	DT
8691	2038	39	copy	copy	NN
8691	2038	40	of	of	IN
8691	2038	41	the	the	DT
8691	2038	42	official	official	JJ
8691	2038	43	publications	publication	NNS
8691	2038	44	containing	contain	VBG
8691	2038	45	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2038	46	shall	shall	MD
8691	2038	47	be	be	VB
8691	2038	48	competent	competent	JJ
8691	2038	49	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2038	50	of	of	IN
8691	2038	51	what	what	WP
8691	2038	52	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2038	53	are	be	VBP
8691	2038	54	.	.	.
8691	2039	1	There	there	EX
8691	2039	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2039	3	a	a	DT
8691	2039	4	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2039	5	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	2039	6	of	of	IN
8691	2039	7	comity	comity	NN
8691	2039	8	to	to	IN
8691	2039	9	which	which	WDT
8691	2039	10	courts	court	NNS
8691	2039	11	often	often	RB
8691	2039	12	give	give	VBP
8691	2039	13	expression	expression	NN
8691	2039	14	in	in	IN
8691	2039	15	rendering	render	VBG
8691	2039	16	assistance	assistance	NN
8691	2039	17	to	to	IN
8691	2039	18	courts	court	NNS
8691	2039	19	of	of	IN
8691	2039	20	other	other	JJ
8691	2039	21	countries	country	NNS
8691	2039	22	.	.	.
8691	2040	1	This	this	DT
8691	2040	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2040	3	comity	comity	NN
8691	2040	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2040	5	been	be	VBN
8691	2040	6	defined	define	VBN
8691	2040	7	as	as	IN
8691	2040	8	"	"	``
8691	2040	9	the	the	DT
8691	2040	10	deference	deference	NN
8691	2040	11	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2040	12	paid	pay	VBN
8691	2040	13	by	by	IN
8691	2040	14	the	the	DT
8691	2040	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	2040	16	of	of	IN
8691	2040	17	one	one	CD
8691	2040	18	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2040	19	to	to	IN
8691	2040	20	the	the	DT
8691	2040	21	laws	law	NNS
8691	2040	22	or	or	CC
8691	2040	23	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2040	24	of	of	IN
8691	2040	25	another	another	DT
8691	2040	26	,	,	,
8691	2040	27	in	in	IN
8691	2040	28	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2040	29	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	2040	30	rights	right	NNS
8691	2040	31	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	2040	32	under	under	IN
8691	2040	33	such	such	JJ
8691	2040	34	laws	law	NNS
8691	2040	35	or	or	CC
8691	2040	36	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2040	37	.	.	.
8691	2041	1	"	"	``
8691	2041	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2041	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2041	4	:	:	:
8691	2041	5	"	"	``
8691	2041	6	Dict	dict	NN
8691	2041	7	.	.	.
8691	2042	1	of	of	IN
8691	2042	2	Philosophy	Philosophy	NNP
8691	2042	3	and	and	CC
8691	2042	4	Psychology	Psychology	NNP
8691	2042	5	,	,	,
8691	2042	6	"	"	''
8691	2042	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2042	8	Comity	Comity	NNP
8691	2042	9	_	_	NNP
8691	2042	10	.	.	.
8691	2042	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2043	1	As	as	IN
8691	2043	2	between	between	IN
8691	2043	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	2043	4	of	of	IN
8691	2043	5	the	the	DT
8691	2043	6	different	different	JJ
8691	2043	7	States	state	NNS
8691	2043	8	in	in	IN
8691	2043	9	the	the	DT
8691	2043	10	United	United	NNP
8691	2043	11	States	States	NNP
8691	2043	12	this	this	DT
8691	2043	13	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	2043	14	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	2043	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	2043	16	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	2043	17	strong	strong	JJ
8691	2043	18	.	.	.
8691	2044	1	In	in	IN
8691	2044	2	pursuance	pursuance	NN
8691	2044	3	of	of	IN
8691	2044	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2044	5	,	,	,
8691	2044	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2044	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2044	8	usual	usual	JJ
8691	2044	9	,	,	,
8691	2044	10	if	if	IN
8691	2044	11	there	there	EX
8691	2044	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	2044	13	been	be	VBN
8691	2044	14	a	a	DT
8691	2044	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2044	16	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	2044	17	in	in	IN
8691	2044	18	one	one	CD
8691	2044	19	State	State	NNP
8691	2044	20	of	of	IN
8691	2044	21	a	a	DT
8691	2044	22	representative	representative	NN
8691	2044	23	of	of	IN
8691	2044	24	the	the	DT
8691	2044	25	law	law	NN
8691	2044	26	to	to	TO
8691	2044	27	administer	administer	VB
8691	2044	28	an	an	DT
8691	2044	29	estate	estate	NN
8691	2044	30	of	of	IN
8691	2044	31	any	any	DT
8691	2044	32	kind	kind	NN
8691	2044	33	,	,	,
8691	2044	34	part	part	NN
8691	2044	35	of	of	IN
8691	2044	36	which	which	WDT
8691	2044	37	is	be	VBZ
8691	2044	38	in	in	IN
8691	2044	39	another	another	DT
8691	2044	40	State	State	NNP
8691	2044	41	,	,	,
8691	2044	42	for	for	IN
8691	2044	43	the	the	DT
8691	2044	44	courts	court	NNS
8691	2044	45	of	of	IN
8691	2044	46	the	the	DT
8691	2044	47	latter	latter	JJ
8691	2044	48	to	to	TO
8691	2044	49	give	give	VB
8691	2044	50	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2044	51	such	such	JJ
8691	2044	52	further	further	JJ
8691	2044	53	powers	power	NNS
8691	2044	54	or	or	CC
8691	2044	55	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	2044	56	as	as	IN
8691	2044	57	may	may	MD
8691	2044	58	be	be	VB
8691	2044	59	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2044	60	to	to	TO
8691	2044	61	put	put	VB
8691	2044	62	in	in	RP
8691	2044	63	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2044	64	possession	possession	NN
8691	2044	65	or	or	CC
8691	2044	66	control	control	NN
8691	2044	67	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	2044	68	is	be	VBZ
8691	2044	69	within	within	IN
8691	2044	70	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2044	71	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2044	72	.	.	.
8691	2045	1	An	an	DT
8691	2045	2	administrator	administrator	NN
8691	2045	3	of	of	IN
8691	2045	4	the	the	DT
8691	2045	5	estate	estate	NN
8691	2045	6	of	of	IN
8691	2045	7	a	a	DT
8691	2045	8	deceased	deceased	JJ
8691	2045	9	person	person	NN
8691	2045	10	would	would	MD
8691	2045	11	thus	thus	RB
8691	2045	12	be	be	VB
8691	2045	13	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	2045	14	,	,	,
8691	2045	15	almost	almost	RB
8691	2045	16	as	as	IN
8691	2045	17	a	a	DT
8691	2045	18	matter	matter	NN
8691	2045	19	of	of	IN
8691	2045	20	course	course	NN
8691	2045	21	,	,	,
8691	2045	22	administrator	administrator	NN
8691	2045	23	of	of	IN
8691	2045	24	such	such	JJ
8691	2045	25	estate	estate	NN
8691	2045	26	in	in	IN
8691	2045	27	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	2045	28	State	state	NN
8691	2045	29	property	property	NN
8691	2045	30	or	or	CC
8691	2045	31	rights	right	NNS
8691	2045	32	of	of	IN
8691	2045	33	action	action	NN
8691	2045	34	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	2045	35	to	to	IN
8691	2045	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2045	37	might	may	MD
8691	2045	38	be	be	VB
8691	2045	39	found	find	VBN
8691	2045	40	.	.	.
8691	2046	1	A	a	DT
8691	2046	2	receiver	receiver	NN
8691	2046	3	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	2046	4	by	by	IN
8691	2046	5	a	a	DT
8691	2046	6	court	court	NN
8691	2046	7	of	of	IN
8691	2046	8	equity	equity	NN
8691	2046	9	to	to	TO
8691	2046	10	take	take	VB
8691	2046	11	possession	possession	NN
8691	2046	12	of	of	IN
8691	2046	13	property	property	NN
8691	2046	14	would	would	MD
8691	2046	15	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2046	16	,	,	,
8691	2046	17	in	in	IN
8691	2046	18	like	like	JJ
8691	2046	19	manner	manner	NN
8691	2046	20	,	,	,
8691	2046	21	be	be	VB
8691	2046	22	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	2046	23	to	to	IN
8691	2046	24	the	the	DT
8691	2046	25	same	same	JJ
8691	2046	26	office	office	NN
8691	2046	27	wherever	wherever	WRB
8691	2046	28	any	any	DT
8691	2046	29	part	part	NN
8691	2046	30	of	of	IN
8691	2046	31	such	such	JJ
8691	2046	32	property	property	NN
8691	2046	33	might	may	MD
8691	2046	34	be	be	VB
8691	2046	35	situated	situate	VBN
8691	2046	36	;	;	:
8691	2046	37	and	and	CC
8691	2046	38	in	in	IN
8691	2046	39	some	some	DT
8691	2046	40	States	state	NNS
8691	2046	41	such	such	PDT
8691	2046	42	an	an	DT
8691	2046	43	officer	officer	NN
8691	2046	44	has	have	VBZ
8691	2046	45	been	be	VBN
8691	2046	46	permitted	permit	VBN
8691	2046	47	to	to	TO
8691	2046	48	sue	sue	VB
8691	2046	49	for	for	IN
8691	2046	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2046	51	under	under	IN
8691	2046	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2046	53	original	original	JJ
8691	2046	54	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	2046	55	.	.	.
8691	2047	1	The	the	DT
8691	2047	2	general	general	JJ
8691	2047	3	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	2047	4	,	,	,
8691	2047	5	however	however	RB
8691	2047	6	,	,	,
8691	2047	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2047	8	that	that	DT
8691	2047	9	a	a	DT
8691	2047	10	receiver	receiver	NN
8691	2047	11	in	in	IN
8691	2047	12	chancery	chancery	NN
8691	2047	13	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2047	14	that	that	RB
8691	2047	15	is	is	RB
8691	2047	16	,	,	,
8691	2047	17	a	a	DT
8691	2047	18	receiver	receiver	NN
8691	2047	19	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	2047	20	by	by	IN
8691	2047	21	a	a	DT
8691	2047	22	court	court	NN
8691	2047	23	of	of	IN
8691	2047	24	equity	equity	NN
8691	2047	25	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2047	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	2047	27	simply	simply	RB
8691	2047	28	an	an	DT
8691	2047	29	arm	arm	NN
8691	2047	30	of	of	IN
8691	2047	31	the	the	DT
8691	2047	32	court	court	NN
8691	2047	33	which	which	WDT
8691	2047	34	appoints	appoint	VBZ
8691	2047	35	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2047	36	,	,	,
8691	2047	37	and	and	CC
8691	2047	38	has	have	VBZ
8691	2047	39	no	no	DT
8691	2047	40	authority	authority	NN
8691	2047	41	to	to	TO
8691	2047	42	act	act	VB
8691	2047	43	outside	outside	IN
8691	2047	44	of	of	IN
8691	2047	45	the	the	DT
8691	2047	46	territorial	territorial	JJ
8691	2047	47	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2047	48	of	of	IN
8691	2047	49	that	that	DT
8691	2047	50	court	court	NN
8691	2047	51	.	.	.
8691	2048	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2048	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2048	3	:	:	:
8691	2048	4	Hale	Hale	NNP
8691	2048	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2048	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2048	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2048	8	Allinson	Allinson	NNP
8691	2048	9	,	,	,
8691	2048	10	188	188	CD
8691	2048	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2048	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2048	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2048	14	,	,	,
8691	2048	15	56	56	CD
8691	2048	16	.	.	.
8691	2048	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2049	1	A	a	DT
8691	2049	2	receiver	receiver	NN
8691	2049	3	of	of	IN
8691	2049	4	an	an	DT
8691	2049	5	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
8691	2049	6	corporation	corporation	NN
8691	2049	7	often	often	RB
8691	2049	8	finds	find	VBZ
8691	2049	9	that	that	IN
8691	2049	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2049	11	has	have	VBZ
8691	2049	12	shareholders	shareholder	NNS
8691	2049	13	living	live	VBG
8691	2049	14	in	in	IN
8691	2049	15	several	several	JJ
8691	2049	16	different	different	JJ
8691	2049	17	States	state	NNS
8691	2049	18	,	,	,
8691	2049	19	who	who	WP
8691	2049	20	have	have	VBP
8691	2049	21	not	not	RB
8691	2049	22	fully	fully	RB
8691	2049	23	paid	pay	VBN
8691	2049	24	in	in	IN
8691	2049	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2049	26	subscriptions	subscription	NNS
8691	2049	27	to	to	IN
8691	2049	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2049	29	capital	capital	NN
8691	2049	30	stock	stock	NN
8691	2049	31	.	.	.
8691	2050	1	In	in	IN
8691	2050	2	such	such	JJ
8691	2050	3	case	case	NN
8691	2050	4	,	,	,
8691	2050	5	if	if	IN
8691	2050	6	the	the	DT
8691	2050	7	statute	statute	NN
8691	2050	8	of	of	IN
8691	2050	9	the	the	DT
8691	2050	10	State	State	NNP
8691	2050	11	under	under	IN
8691	2050	12	the	the	DT
8691	2050	13	laws	law	NNS
8691	2050	14	of	of	IN
8691	2050	15	which	which	WDT
8691	2050	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2050	17	was	be	VBD
8691	2050	18	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
8691	2050	19	provided	provide	VBN
8691	2050	20	for	for	IN
8691	2050	21	the	the	DT
8691	2050	22	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	2050	23	of	of	IN
8691	2050	24	a	a	DT
8691	2050	25	receiver	receiver	NN
8691	2050	26	for	for	IN
8691	2050	27	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
8691	2050	28	corporations	corporation	NNS
8691	2050	29	of	of	IN
8691	2050	30	that	that	DT
8691	2050	31	character	character	NN
8691	2050	32	,	,	,
8691	2050	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2050	34	may	may	MD
8691	2050	35	be	be	VB
8691	2050	36	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	2050	37	in	in	IN
8691	2050	38	other	other	JJ
8691	2050	39	States	state	NNS
8691	2050	40	as	as	IN
8691	2050	41	one	one	CD
8691	2050	42	to	to	TO
8691	2050	43	whom	whom	WP
8691	2050	44	each	each	DT
8691	2050	45	shareholder	shareholder	NN
8691	2050	46	,	,	,
8691	2050	47	in	in	IN
8691	2050	48	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2050	49	effect	effect	NN
8691	2050	50	,	,	,
8691	2050	51	promised	promise	VBD
8691	2050	52	to	to	TO
8691	2050	53	pay	pay	VB
8691	2050	54	such	such	JJ
8691	2050	55	part	part	NN
8691	2050	56	of	of	IN
8691	2050	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2050	58	subscription	subscription	NN
8691	2050	59	as	as	IN
8691	2050	60	had	have	VBD
8691	2050	61	not	not	RB
8691	2050	62	been	be	VBN
8691	2050	63	previously	previously	RB
8691	2050	64	paid	pay	VBN
8691	2050	65	to	to	IN
8691	2050	66	the	the	DT
8691	2050	67	corporation	corporation	NN
8691	2050	68	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2050	69	.	.	.
8691	2051	1	On	on	IN
8691	2051	2	this	this	DT
8691	2051	3	theory	theory	NN
8691	2051	4	of	of	IN
8691	2051	5	liability	liability	NN
8691	2051	6	,	,	,
8691	2051	7	a	a	DT
8691	2051	8	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	2051	9	receiver	receiver	NN
8691	2051	10	has	have	VBZ
8691	2051	11	a	a	DT
8691	2051	12	right	right	NN
8691	2051	13	of	of	IN
8691	2051	14	action	action	NN
8691	2051	15	by	by	IN
8691	2051	16	virtue	virtue	NN
8691	2051	17	of	of	IN
8691	2051	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2051	19	official	official	JJ
8691	2051	20	position	position	NN
8691	2051	21	,	,	,
8691	2051	22	indeed	indeed	RB
8691	2051	23	,	,	,
8691	2051	24	but	but	CC
8691	2051	25	not	not	RB
8691	2051	26	because	because	IN
8691	2051	27	of	of	IN
8691	2051	28	authority	authority	NN
8691	2051	29	from	from	IN
8691	2051	30	a	a	DT
8691	2051	31	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	2051	32	court	court	NN
8691	2051	33	to	to	TO
8691	2051	34	use	use	VB
8691	2051	35	that	that	DT
8691	2051	36	position	position	NN
8691	2051	37	for	for	IN
8691	2051	38	such	such	PDT
8691	2051	39	a	a	DT
8691	2051	40	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2051	41	.	.	.
8691	2052	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2052	2	sues	sue	VBZ
8691	2052	3	as	as	IN
8691	2052	4	one	one	CD
8691	2052	5	to	to	TO
8691	2052	6	whom	whom	WP
8691	2052	7	the	the	DT
8691	2052	8	shareholder	shareholder	NN
8691	2052	9	promised	promise	VBD
8691	2052	10	to	to	TO
8691	2052	11	make	make	VB
8691	2052	12	a	a	DT
8691	2052	13	payment	payment	NN
8691	2052	14	,	,	,
8691	2052	15	and	and	CC
8691	2052	16	on	on	IN
8691	2052	17	a	a	DT
8691	2052	18	direct	direct	JJ
8691	2052	19	contract	contract	NN
8691	2052	20	between	between	IN
8691	2052	21	the	the	DT
8691	2052	22	two	two	CD
8691	2052	23	,	,	,
8691	2052	24	which	which	WDT
8691	2052	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	2052	26	implied	imply	VBN
8691	2052	27	by	by	IN
8691	2052	28	law	law	NN
8691	2052	29	.	.	.
8691	2053	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2053	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2053	3	:	:	:
8691	2053	4	Fish	Fish	NNP
8691	2053	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2053	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2053	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2053	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	2053	9	,	,	,
8691	2053	10	73	73	CD
8691	2053	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2053	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2053	13	,	,	,
8691	2053	14	377	377	CD
8691	2053	15	;	;	:
8691	2053	16	47	47	CD
8691	2053	17	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	2053	18	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2053	19	,	,	,
8691	2053	20	711	711	CD
8691	2053	21	;	;	:
8691	2053	22	84	84	CD
8691	2053	23	American	American	NNP
8691	2053	24	State	State	NNP
8691	2053	25	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2053	26	,	,	,
8691	2053	27	161	161	CD
8691	2053	28	.	.	.
8691	2053	29	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2054	1	The	the	DT
8691	2054	2	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	2054	3	or	or	CC
8691	2054	4	rule	rule	NN
8691	2054	5	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2054	6	for	for	IN
8691	2054	7	from	from	IN
8691	2054	8	being	be	VBG
8691	2054	9	a	a	DT
8691	2054	10	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	2054	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2054	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	2054	13	risen	rise	VBN
8691	2054	14	to	to	TO
8691	2054	15	be	be	VB
8691	2054	16	a	a	DT
8691	2054	17	rule	rule	NN
8691	2054	18	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2054	19	of	of	IN
8691	2054	20	comity	comity	NN
8691	2054	21	between	between	IN
8691	2054	22	States	States	NNP
8691	2054	23	both	both	DT
8691	2054	24	aids	aid	NNS
8691	2054	25	in	in	IN
8691	2054	26	the	the	DT
8691	2054	27	enforcement	enforcement	NN
8691	2054	28	in	in	IN
8691	2054	29	one	one	CD
8691	2054	30	of	of	IN
8691	2054	31	rights	right	NNS
8691	2054	32	acquired	acquire	VBN
8691	2054	33	under	under	IN
8691	2054	34	the	the	DT
8691	2054	35	other,[Footnote	other,[Footnote	NNP
8691	2054	36	:	:	:
8691	2054	37	Finney	Finney	NNP
8691	2054	38	_	_	NNP
8691	2054	39	v.	v.	IN
8691	2054	40	_	_	NNP
8691	2054	41	Guy	Guy	NNP
8691	2054	42	,	,	,
8691	2054	43	189	189	CD
8691	2054	44	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2054	45	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2054	46	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2054	47	,	,	,
8691	2054	48	335	335	CD
8691	2054	49	,	,	,
8691	2054	50	346	346	CD
8691	2054	51	.	.	.
8691	2054	52	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2055	1	and	and	CC
8691	2055	2	in	in	IN
8691	2055	3	the	the	DT
8691	2055	4	prevention	prevention	NN
8691	2055	5	by	by	IN
8691	2055	6	one	one	CD
8691	2055	7	of	of	IN
8691	2055	8	acts	act	NNS
8691	2055	9	which	which	WDT
8691	2055	10	would	would	MD
8691	2055	11	infringe	infringe	VB
8691	2055	12	on	on	IN
8691	2055	13	prohibitions	prohibition	NNS
8691	2055	14	created	create	VBN
8691	2055	15	by	by	IN
8691	2055	16	the	the	DT
8691	2055	17	other	other	JJ
8691	2055	18	.	.	.
8691	2056	1	Thus	thus	RB
8691	2056	2	,	,	,
8691	2056	3	if	if	IN
8691	2056	4	a	a	DT
8691	2056	5	corporation	corporation	NN
8691	2056	6	of	of	IN
8691	2056	7	one	one	CD
8691	2056	8	State	State	NNP
8691	2056	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	2056	10	been	be	VBN
8691	2056	11	organized	organize	VBN
8691	2056	12	to	to	TO
8691	2056	13	do	do	VB
8691	2056	14	business	business	NN
8691	2056	15	in	in	IN
8691	2056	16	another	another	DT
8691	2056	17	,	,	,
8691	2056	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2056	19	may	may	MD
8691	2056	20	be	be	VB
8691	2056	21	enjoined	enjoin	VBN
8691	2056	22	in	in	IN
8691	2056	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2056	24	home	home	NN
8691	2056	25	State	State	NNP
8691	2056	26	from	from	IN
8691	2056	27	amalgamating	amalgamate	VBG
8691	2056	28	with	with	IN
8691	2056	29	a	a	DT
8691	2056	30	corporation	corporation	NN
8691	2056	31	of	of	IN
8691	2056	32	the	the	DT
8691	2056	33	other	other	JJ
8691	2056	34	,	,	,
8691	2056	35	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	2056	36	to	to	IN
8691	2056	37	the	the	DT
8691	2056	38	public	public	JJ
8691	2056	39	policy	policy	NN
8691	2056	40	of	of	IN
8691	2056	41	the	the	DT
8691	2056	42	other	other	JJ
8691	2056	43	as	as	IN
8691	2056	44	declared	declare	VBN
8691	2056	45	by	by	IN
8691	2056	46	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2056	47	courts	court	NNS
8691	2056	48	.	.	.
8691	2057	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2057	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2057	3	:	:	:
8691	2057	4	Coler	Coler	NNP
8691	2057	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2057	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2057	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2057	8	Tacoma	Tacoma	NNP
8691	2057	9	Railway	Railway	NNP
8691	2057	10	and	and	CC
8691	2057	11	Power	Power	NNP
8691	2057	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	2057	13	,	,	,
8691	2057	14	70	70	CD
8691	2057	15	New	New	NNP
8691	2057	16	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	2057	17	Law	Law	NNP
8691	2057	18	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2057	19	;	;	:
8691	2057	20	54	54	CD
8691	2057	21	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	2057	22	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2057	23	,	,	,
8691	2057	24	413	413	CD
8691	2057	25	.	.	.
8691	2057	26	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2058	1	As	as	IN
8691	2058	2	no	no	DT
8691	2058	3	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2058	4	process	process	NN
8691	2058	5	can	can	MD
8691	2058	6	be	be	VB
8691	2058	7	effective	effective	JJ
8691	2058	8	outside	outside	IN
8691	2058	9	the	the	DT
8691	2058	10	limits	limit	NNS
8691	2058	11	of	of	IN
8691	2058	12	the	the	DT
8691	2058	13	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	2058	14	by	by	IN
8691	2058	15	authority	authority	NN
8691	2058	16	of	of	IN
8691	2058	17	which	which	WDT
8691	2058	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2058	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	2058	20	issued	issue	VBN
8691	2058	21	,	,	,
8691	2058	22	no	no	DT
8691	2058	23	court	court	NN
8691	2058	24	of	of	IN
8691	2058	25	a	a	DT
8691	2058	26	State	State	NNP
8691	2058	27	can	can	MD
8691	2058	28	summon	summon	VB
8691	2058	29	before	before	IN
8691	2058	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2058	31	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	2058	32	not	not	RB
8691	2058	33	found	find	VBN
8691	2058	34	within	within	IN
8691	2058	35	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2058	36	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2058	37	,	,	,
8691	2058	38	who	who	WP
8691	2058	39	live	live	VBP
8691	2058	40	in	in	IN
8691	2058	41	another	another	DT
8691	2058	42	State	state	NN
8691	2058	43	.	.	.
8691	2059	1	This	this	DT
8691	2059	2	,	,	,
8691	2059	3	in	in	IN
8691	2059	4	view	view	NN
8691	2059	5	of	of	IN
8691	2059	6	the	the	DT
8691	2059	7	free	free	JJ
8691	2059	8	intercourse	intercourse	NN
8691	2059	9	and	and	CC
8691	2059	10	trade	trade	NN
8691	2059	11	between	between	IN
8691	2059	12	all	all	DT
8691	2059	13	parts	part	NNS
8691	2059	14	of	of	IN
8691	2059	15	the	the	DT
8691	2059	16	United	United	NNP
8691	2059	17	States	States	NNP
8691	2059	18	,	,	,
8691	2059	19	would	would	MD
8691	2059	20	work	work	VB
8691	2059	21	intolerable	intolerable	JJ
8691	2059	22	hardship	hardship	NN
8691	2059	23	had	have	VBD
8691	2059	24	not	not	RB
8691	2059	25	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2059	26	been	be	VBN
8691	2059	27	passed	pass	VBN
8691	2059	28	by	by	IN
8691	2059	29	every	every	DT
8691	2059	30	State	state	NN
8691	2059	31	permitting	permit	VBG
8691	2059	32	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2059	33	to	to	TO
8691	2059	34	be	be	VB
8691	2059	35	taken	take	VBN
8691	2059	36	outside	outside	RB
8691	2059	37	of	of	IN
8691	2059	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2059	39	limits	limit	NNS
8691	2059	40	by	by	IN
8691	2059	41	written	write	VBN
8691	2059	42	deposition	deposition	NN
8691	2059	43	for	for	IN
8691	2059	44	use	use	NN
8691	2059	45	in	in	IN
8691	2059	46	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2059	47	cases	case	NNS
8691	2059	48	.	.	.
8691	2060	1	So	so	RB
8691	2060	2	far	far	RB
8691	2060	3	as	as	IN
8691	2060	4	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2060	5	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2060	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2060	7	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	2060	8	,	,	,
8691	2060	9	this	this	DT
8691	2060	10	mode	mode	NN
8691	2060	11	of	of	IN
8691	2060	12	relief	relief	NN
8691	2060	13	generally	generally	RB
8691	2060	14	can	can	MD
8691	2060	15	not	not	RB
8691	2060	16	be	be	VB
8691	2060	17	pursued	pursue	VBN
8691	2060	18	,	,	,
8691	2060	19	owing	owe	VBG
8691	2060	20	to	to	IN
8691	2060	21	the	the	DT
8691	2060	22	common	common	JJ
8691	2060	23	provision	provision	NN
8691	2060	24	in	in	IN
8691	2060	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2060	26	State	State	NNP
8691	2060	27	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	2060	28	that	that	IN
8691	2060	29	the	the	DT
8691	2060	30	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2060	31	must	must	MD
8691	2060	32	be	be	VB
8691	2060	33	confronted	confront	VBN
8691	2060	34	by	by	IN
8691	2060	35	the	the	DT
8691	2060	36	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	2060	37	against	against	IN
8691	2060	38	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2060	39	.	.	.
8691	2061	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	2061	2	of	of	IN
8691	2061	3	the	the	DT
8691	2061	4	Northeastern	Northeastern	NNP
8691	2061	5	States	States	NNPS
8691	2061	6	,	,	,
8691	2061	7	to	to	TO
8691	2061	8	meet	meet	VB
8691	2061	9	this	this	DT
8691	2061	10	difficulty	difficulty	NN
8691	2061	11	,	,	,
8691	2061	12	have	have	VBP
8691	2061	13	passed	pass	VBN
8691	2061	14	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2061	15	requiring	require	VBG
8691	2061	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2061	17	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	2061	18	when	when	WRB
8691	2061	19	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	2061	20	by	by	IN
8691	2061	21	a	a	DT
8691	2061	22	local	local	JJ
8691	2061	23	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2061	24	at	at	IN
8691	2061	25	the	the	DT
8691	2061	26	request	request	NN
8691	2061	27	of	of	IN
8691	2061	28	a	a	DT
8691	2061	29	court	court	NN
8691	2061	30	of	of	IN
8691	2061	31	another	another	DT
8691	2061	32	State	State	NNP
8691	2061	33	to	to	TO
8691	2061	34	appear	appear	VB
8691	2061	35	and	and	CC
8691	2061	36	testify	testify	VB
8691	2061	37	before	before	IN
8691	2061	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2061	39	in	in	IN
8691	2061	40	such	such	PDT
8691	2061	41	a	a	DT
8691	2061	42	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	2061	43	,	,	,
8691	2061	44	to	to	TO
8691	2061	45	do	do	VB
8691	2061	46	so	so	RB
8691	2061	47	upon	upon	IN
8691	2061	48	receiving	receive	VBG
8691	2061	49	payment	payment	NN
8691	2061	50	for	for	IN
8691	2061	51	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2061	52	time	time	NN
8691	2061	53	and	and	CC
8691	2061	54	expenses	expense	NNS
8691	2061	55	,	,	,
8691	2061	56	on	on	IN
8691	2061	57	pain	pain	NN
8691	2061	58	of	of	IN
8691	2061	59	a	a	DT
8691	2061	60	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2061	61	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
8691	2061	62	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
8691	2061	63	.	.	.
8691	2062	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2062	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2062	3	:	:	:
8691	2062	4	New	New	NNP
8691	2062	5	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	2062	6	inaugurated	inaugurate	VBD
8691	2062	7	this	this	DT
8691	2062	8	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	2062	9	more	more	JJR
8691	2062	10	than	than	IN
8691	2062	11	sixty	sixty	CD
8691	2062	12	years	year	NNS
8691	2062	13	ago	ago	RB
8691	2062	14	.	.	.
8691	2063	1	Public	Public	NNP
8691	2063	2	Stat	Stat	NNP
8691	2063	3	.	.	.
8691	2063	4	,	,	,
8691	2063	5	ed	ed	NNP
8691	2063	6	.	.	.
8691	2064	1	1842	1842	CD
8691	2064	2	,	,	,
8691	2064	3	382	382	CD
8691	2064	4	.	.	.
8691	2065	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	2065	2	of	of	IN
8691	2065	3	the	the	DT
8691	2065	4	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2065	5	apply	apply	VBP
8691	2065	6	only	only	RB
8691	2065	7	to	to	IN
8691	2065	8	adjoining	adjoining	JJ
8691	2065	9	or	or	CC
8691	2065	10	neighboring	neighboring	JJ
8691	2065	11	States	States	NNP
8691	2065	12	,	,	,
8691	2065	13	and	and	CC
8691	2065	14	some	some	DT
8691	2065	15	require	require	VBP
8691	2065	16	reciprocity	reciprocity	NN
8691	2065	17	on	on	IN
8691	2065	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2065	19	part	part	NN
8691	2065	20	.	.	.
8691	2065	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2066	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2066	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2066	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2066	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2066	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2066	6	Lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2066	7	of	of	IN
8691	2066	8	one	one	CD
8691	2066	9	State	state	NN
8691	2066	10	have	have	VBP
8691	2066	11	no	no	DT
8691	2066	12	right	right	NN
8691	2066	13	to	to	TO
8691	2066	14	practice	practice	VB
8691	2066	15	in	in	IN
8691	2066	16	any	any	DT
8691	2066	17	other	other	JJ
8691	2066	18	.	.	.
8691	2067	1	By	by	IN
8691	2067	2	courtesy	courtesy	NN
8691	2067	3	and	and	CC
8691	2067	4	on	on	IN
8691	2067	5	motion	motion	NN
8691	2067	6	of	of	IN
8691	2067	7	a	a	DT
8691	2067	8	member	member	NN
8691	2067	9	of	of	IN
8691	2067	10	the	the	DT
8691	2067	11	bar	bar	NN
8691	2067	12	,	,	,
8691	2067	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2067	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	2067	15	customary	customary	JJ
8691	2067	16	for	for	IN
8691	2067	17	the	the	DT
8691	2067	18	courts	court	NNS
8691	2067	19	of	of	IN
8691	2067	20	other	other	JJ
8691	2067	21	States	States	NNPS
8691	2067	22	to	to	TO
8691	2067	23	allow	allow	VB
8691	2067	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2067	25	to	to	TO
8691	2067	26	participate	participate	VB
8691	2067	27	in	in	IN
8691	2067	28	the	the	DT
8691	2067	29	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	2067	30	of	of	IN
8691	2067	31	any	any	DT
8691	2067	32	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2067	33	cause	cause	NN
8691	2067	34	.	.	.
8691	2068	1	In	in	IN
8691	2068	2	some	some	DT
8691	2068	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2068	4	,	,	,
8691	2068	5	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2068	6	who	who	WP
8691	2068	7	have	have	VBP
8691	2068	8	removed	remove	VBN
8691	2068	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2068	10	residence	residence	NN
8691	2068	11	into	into	IN
8691	2068	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2068	13	from	from	IN
8691	2068	14	another	another	DT
8691	2068	15	may	may	NNP
8691	2068	16	in	in	IN
8691	2068	17	the	the	DT
8691	2068	18	same	same	JJ
8691	2068	19	manner	manner	NN
8691	2068	20	be	be	VB
8691	2068	21	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	2068	22	to	to	IN
8691	2068	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2068	24	bar	bar	NN
8691	2068	25	;	;	:
8691	2068	26	in	in	IN
8691	2068	27	most	most	JJS
8691	2068	28	there	there	EX
8691	2068	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	2068	30	a	a	DT
8691	2068	31	standing	stand	VBG
8691	2068	32	rule	rule	NN
8691	2068	33	on	on	IN
8691	2068	34	the	the	DT
8691	2068	35	subject	subject	NN
8691	2068	36	which	which	WDT
8691	2068	37	requires	require	VBZ
8691	2068	38	proof	proof	NN
8691	2068	39	of	of	IN
8691	2068	40	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2068	41	having	have	VBG
8691	2068	42	practiced	practice	VBN
8691	2068	43	in	in	IN
8691	2068	44	the	the	DT
8691	2068	45	courts	court	NNS
8691	2068	46	of	of	IN
8691	2068	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2068	48	original	original	JJ
8691	2068	49	State	state	NN
8691	2068	50	for	for	IN
8691	2068	51	a	a	DT
8691	2068	52	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2068	53	number	number	NN
8691	2068	54	of	of	IN
8691	2068	55	years	year	NNS
8691	2068	56	,	,	,
8691	2068	57	and	and	CC
8691	2068	58	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	2068	59	provides	provide	VBZ
8691	2068	60	for	for	IN
8691	2068	61	an	an	DT
8691	2068	62	examination	examination	NN
8691	2068	63	into	into	IN
8691	2068	64	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2068	65	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2068	66	attainments	attainment	NNS
8691	2068	67	.	.	.
8691	2069	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2069	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2069	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2069	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2069	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2069	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	2069	7	XII	xii	NN
8691	2069	8	TRIAL	trial	NN
8691	2069	9	BY	by	IN
8691	2069	10	JURY	jury	NN
8691	2069	11	To	to	TO
8691	2069	12	have	have	VB
8691	2069	13	a	a	DT
8691	2069	14	trial	trial	NN
8691	2069	15	by	by	IN
8691	2069	16	jury	jury	NN
8691	2069	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	2069	18	,	,	,
8691	2069	19	as	as	IN
8691	2069	20	a	a	DT
8691	2069	21	general	general	JJ
8691	2069	22	rule	rule	NN
8691	2069	23	,	,	,
8691	2069	24	the	the	DT
8691	2069	25	right	right	NN
8691	2069	26	of	of	IN
8691	2069	27	every	every	DT
8691	2069	28	man	man	NN
8691	2069	29	who	who	WP
8691	2069	30	sues	sue	VBZ
8691	2069	31	or	or	CC
8691	2069	32	is	be	VBZ
8691	2069	33	sued	sue	VBN
8691	2069	34	in	in	IN
8691	2069	35	court	court	NN
8691	2069	36	on	on	IN
8691	2069	37	a	a	DT
8691	2069	38	cause	cause	NN
8691	2069	39	of	of	IN
8691	2069	40	action	action	NN
8691	2069	41	not	not	RB
8691	2069	42	of	of	IN
8691	2069	43	a	a	DT
8691	2069	44	kind	kind	NN
8691	2069	45	to	to	TO
8691	2069	46	be	be	VB
8691	2069	47	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	2069	48	of	of	IN
8691	2069	49	in	in	IN
8691	2069	50	a	a	DT
8691	2069	51	court	court	NN
8691	2069	52	of	of	IN
8691	2069	53	equity	equity	NN
8691	2069	54	or	or	CC
8691	2069	55	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	2069	56	.	.	.
8691	2070	1	The	the	DT
8691	2070	2	American	american	JJ
8691	2070	3	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	2070	4	did	do	VBD
8691	2070	5	not	not	RB
8691	2070	6	all	all	RB
8691	2070	7	adopt	adopt	VB
8691	2070	8	this	this	DT
8691	2070	9	mode	mode	NN
8691	2070	10	of	of	IN
8691	2070	11	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	2070	12	at	at	IN
8691	2070	13	first	first	RB
8691	2070	14	,	,	,
8691	2070	15	and	and	CC
8691	2070	16	few	few	JJ
8691	2070	17	of	of	IN
8691	2070	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2070	19	ever	ever	RB
8691	2070	20	practiced	practice	VBD
8691	2070	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2070	22	precisely	precisely	RB
8691	2070	23	on	on	IN
8691	2070	24	the	the	DT
8691	2070	25	English	English	NNP
8691	2070	26	plan	plan	NN
8691	2070	27	.	.	.
8691	2071	1	In	in	IN
8691	2071	2	the	the	DT
8691	2071	3	colony	colony	NN
8691	2071	4	of	of	IN
8691	2071	5	New	New	NNP
8691	2071	6	Haven	Haven	NNP
8691	2071	7	there	there	EX
8691	2071	8	were	be	VBD
8691	2071	9	no	no	DT
8691	2071	10	juries	jury	NNS
8691	2071	11	.	.	.
8691	2072	1	In	in	IN
8691	2072	2	all	all	PDT
8691	2072	3	the	the	DT
8691	2072	4	New	New	NNP
8691	2072	5	England	England	NNP
8691	2072	6	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	2072	7	,	,	,
8691	2072	8	later	later	RB
8691	2072	9	,	,	,
8691	2072	10	there	there	EX
8691	2072	11	were	be	VBD
8691	2072	12	juries	jury	NNS
8691	2072	13	,	,	,
8691	2072	14	but	but	CC
8691	2072	15	verdicts	verdict	NNS
8691	2072	16	in	in	IN
8691	2072	17	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2072	18	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2072	19	had	have	VBD
8691	2072	20	not	not	RB
8691	2072	21	the	the	DT
8691	2072	22	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	2072	23	force	force	NN
8691	2072	24	given	give	VBN
8691	2072	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2072	26	by	by	IN
8691	2072	27	the	the	DT
8691	2072	28	common	common	JJ
8691	2072	29	law	law	NN
8691	2072	30	.	.	.
8691	2073	1	The	the	DT
8691	2073	2	defeated	defeat	VBN
8691	2073	3	party	party	NN
8691	2073	4	had	have	VBD
8691	2073	5	what	what	WP
8691	2073	6	was	be	VBD
8691	2073	7	styled	style	VBN
8691	2073	8	the	the	DT
8691	2073	9	privilege	privilege	NN
8691	2073	10	of	of	IN
8691	2073	11	a	a	DT
8691	2073	12	review	review	NN
8691	2073	13	.	.	.
8691	2074	1	This	this	DT
8691	2074	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2074	3	a	a	DT
8691	2074	4	new	new	JJ
8691	2074	5	trial	trial	NN
8691	2074	6	before	before	IN
8691	2074	7	another	another	DT
8691	2074	8	jury	jury	NN
8691	2074	9	,	,	,
8691	2074	10	either	either	CC
8691	2074	11	in	in	IN
8691	2074	12	the	the	DT
8691	2074	13	same	same	JJ
8691	2074	14	court	court	NN
8691	2074	15	or	or	CC
8691	2074	16	a	a	DT
8691	2074	17	higher	high	JJR
8691	2074	18	one	one	NN
8691	2074	19	.	.	.
8691	2075	1	If	if	IN
8691	2075	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2075	3	lost	lose	VBD
8691	2075	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2075	5	case	case	NN
8691	2075	6	again	again	RB
8691	2075	7	,	,	,
8691	2075	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2075	9	was	be	VBD
8691	2075	10	the	the	DT
8691	2075	11	end	end	NN
8691	2075	12	of	of	IN
8691	2075	13	the	the	DT
8691	2075	14	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	2075	15	.	.	.
8691	2076	1	If	if	IN
8691	2076	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2076	3	gained	gain	VBD
8691	2076	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2076	5	on	on	IN
8691	2076	6	the	the	DT
8691	2076	7	second	second	JJ
8691	2076	8	trial	trial	NN
8691	2076	9	,	,	,
8691	2076	10	the	the	DT
8691	2076	11	other	other	JJ
8691	2076	12	party	party	NN
8691	2076	13	could	could	MD
8691	2076	14	demand	demand	VB
8691	2076	15	a	a	DT
8691	2076	16	third	third	JJ
8691	2076	17	,	,	,
8691	2076	18	and	and	CC
8691	2076	19	the	the	DT
8691	2076	20	event	event	NN
8691	2076	21	of	of	IN
8691	2076	22	that	that	DT
8691	2076	23	decided	decide	VBD
8691	2076	24	the	the	DT
8691	2076	25	cause	cause	NN
8691	2076	26	forever	forever	RB
8691	2076	27	.	.	.
8691	2077	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2077	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2077	3	:	:	:
8691	2077	4	Bissell	Bissell	NNP
8691	2077	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2077	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2077	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2077	8	Dickerson	Dickerson	NNP
8691	2077	9	,	,	,
8691	2077	10	64	64	CD
8691	2077	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2077	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2077	13	,	,	,
8691	2077	14	61	61	CD
8691	2077	15	,	,	,
8691	2077	16	65	65	CD
8691	2077	17	;	;	:
8691	2077	18	29	29	CD
8691	2077	19	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	2077	20	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2077	21	,	,	,
8691	2077	22	226	226	CD
8691	2077	23	.	.	.
8691	2077	24	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2078	1	In	in	IN
8691	2078	2	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2078	3	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2078	4	a	a	DT
8691	2078	5	similar	similar	JJ
8691	2078	6	right	right	NN
8691	2078	7	was	be	VBD
8691	2078	8	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2078	9	conceded	concede	VBN
8691	2078	10	to	to	IN
8691	2078	11	the	the	DT
8691	2078	12	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2078	13	in	in	IN
8691	2078	14	case	case	NN
8691	2078	15	of	of	IN
8691	2078	16	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	2078	17	.	.	.
8691	2079	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2079	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2079	3	:	:	:
8691	2079	4	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	2079	5	of	of	IN
8691	2079	6	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2079	7	,	,	,
8691	2079	8	ed	ed	NNP
8691	2079	9	.	.	.
8691	2080	1	1715	1715	CD
8691	2080	2	,	,	,
8691	2080	3	p.	p.	NN
8691	2081	1	131	131	CD
8691	2081	2	.	.	.
8691	2081	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2082	1	South	South	NNP
8691	2082	2	of	of	IN
8691	2082	3	New	New	NNP
8691	2082	4	England	England	NNP
8691	2082	5	there	there	EX
8691	2082	6	was	be	VBD
8691	2082	7	no	no	DT
8691	2082	8	such	such	JJ
8691	2082	9	radical	radical	JJ
8691	2082	10	departure	departure	NN
8691	2082	11	from	from	IN
8691	2082	12	the	the	DT
8691	2082	13	common	common	JJ
8691	2082	14	law	law	NN
8691	2082	15	,	,	,
8691	2082	16	but	but	CC
8691	2082	17	there	there	EX
8691	2082	18	were	be	VBD
8691	2082	19	before	before	IN
8691	2082	20	the	the	DT
8691	2082	21	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	2082	22	variations	variation	NNS
8691	2082	23	of	of	IN
8691	2082	24	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2082	25	importance	importance	NN
8691	2082	26	.	.	.
8691	2083	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2083	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2083	3	:	:	:
8691	2083	4	The	the	DT
8691	2083	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2083	6	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
8691	2083	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2083	8	,	,	,
8691	2083	9	No	no	UH
8691	2083	10	.	.	.
8691	2084	1	LXXXIII	LXXXIII	NNP
8691	2084	2	.	.	.
8691	2084	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2085	1	Instead	instead	RB
8691	2085	2	of	of	IN
8691	2085	3	sending	send	VBG
8691	2085	4	a	a	DT
8691	2085	5	case	case	NN
8691	2085	6	before	before	IN
8691	2085	7	an	an	DT
8691	2085	8	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	2085	9	jury	jury	NN
8691	2085	10	,	,	,
8691	2085	11	the	the	DT
8691	2085	12	court	court	NN
8691	2085	13	has	have	VBZ
8691	2085	14	power	power	NN
8691	2085	15	,	,	,
8691	2085	16	at	at	IN
8691	2085	17	the	the	DT
8691	2085	18	request	request	NN
8691	2085	19	of	of	IN
8691	2085	20	the	the	DT
8691	2085	21	parties	party	NNS
8691	2085	22	,	,	,
8691	2085	23	to	to	TO
8691	2085	24	direct	direct	VB
8691	2085	25	a	a	DT
8691	2085	26	special	special	JJ
8691	2085	27	jury	jury	NN
8691	2085	28	to	to	TO
8691	2085	29	be	be	VB
8691	2085	30	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	2085	31	to	to	TO
8691	2085	32	hear	hear	VB
8691	2085	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2085	34	.	.	.
8691	2086	1	This	this	DT
8691	2086	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2086	3	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	2086	4	asked	ask	VBN
8691	2086	5	or	or	CC
8691	2086	6	granted	grant	VBN
8691	2086	7	unless	unless	IN
8691	2086	8	the	the	DT
8691	2086	9	matter	matter	NN
8691	2086	10	in	in	IN
8691	2086	11	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	2086	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2086	13	of	of	IN
8691	2086	14	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
8691	2086	15	importance	importance	NN
8691	2086	16	and	and	CC
8691	2086	17	difficulty	difficulty	NN
8691	2086	18	.	.	.
8691	2087	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	2087	2	a	a	DT
8691	2087	3	jury	jury	NN
8691	2087	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2087	5	more	more	RBR
8691	2087	6	carefully	carefully	RB
8691	2087	7	selected	select	VBN
8691	2087	8	,	,	,
8691	2087	9	with	with	IN
8691	2087	10	the	the	DT
8691	2087	11	assistance	assistance	NN
8691	2087	12	of	of	IN
8691	2087	13	the	the	DT
8691	2087	14	parties	party	NNS
8691	2087	15	,	,	,
8691	2087	16	so	so	IN
8691	2087	17	as	as	IN
8691	2087	18	to	to	TO
8691	2087	19	make	make	VB
8691	2087	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2087	21	sure	sure	JJ
8691	2087	22	that	that	IN
8691	2087	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2087	24	will	will	MD
8691	2087	25	be	be	VB
8691	2087	26	composed	compose	VBN
8691	2087	27	of	of	IN
8691	2087	28	men	man	NNS
8691	2087	29	exceptionally	exceptionally	RB
8691	2087	30	competent	competent	JJ
8691	2087	31	to	to	TO
8691	2087	32	decide	decide	VB
8691	2087	33	a	a	DT
8691	2087	34	cause	cause	NN
8691	2087	35	and	and	CC
8691	2087	36	such	such	PDT
8691	2087	37	a	a	DT
8691	2087	38	cause	cause	NN
8691	2087	39	.	.	.
8691	2088	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2088	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2088	3	generally	generally	RB
8691	2088	4	paid	pay	VBN
8691	2088	5	a	a	DT
8691	2088	6	larger	large	JJR
8691	2088	7	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	2088	8	than	than	IN
8691	2088	9	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	2088	10	jurors	juror	NNS
8691	2088	11	receive	receive	VBP
8691	2088	12	,	,	,
8691	2088	13	the	the	DT
8691	2088	14	parties	party	NNS
8691	2088	15	furnishing	furnish	VBG
8691	2088	16	the	the	DT
8691	2088	17	additional	additional	JJ
8691	2088	18	sum	sum	NN
8691	2088	19	required	require	VBN
8691	2088	20	.	.	.
8691	2089	1	Prepayment	prepayment	NN
8691	2089	2	of	of	IN
8691	2089	3	these	these	DT
8691	2089	4	sums	sum	NNS
8691	2089	5	may	may	MD
8691	2089	6	be	be	VB
8691	2089	7	and	and	CC
8691	2089	8	often	often	RB
8691	2089	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	2089	10	made	make	VBN
8691	2089	11	a	a	DT
8691	2089	12	condition	condition	NN
8691	2089	13	of	of	IN
8691	2089	14	granting	grant	VBG
8691	2089	15	a	a	DT
8691	2089	16	trial	trial	NN
8691	2089	17	before	before	IN
8691	2089	18	such	such	PDT
8691	2089	19	a	a	DT
8691	2089	20	jury	jury	NN
8691	2089	21	.	.	.
8691	2090	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2090	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2090	3	:	:	:
8691	2090	4	Eckrich	Eckrich	NNP
8691	2090	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2090	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2090	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2090	8	St.	St.	NNP
8691	2090	9	Louis	Louis	NNP
8691	2090	10	Transit	Transit	NNP
8691	2090	11	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	2090	12	,	,	,
8691	2090	13	176	176	CD
8691	2090	14	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
8691	2090	15	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2090	16	,	,	,
8691	2090	17	621	621	CD
8691	2090	18	;	;	:
8691	2090	19	75	75	CD
8691	2090	20	Southwestern	southwestern	JJ
8691	2090	21	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	2090	22	,	,	,
8691	2090	23	755	755	CD
8691	2090	24	;	;	:
8691	2090	25	62	62	CD
8691	2090	26	Lawyers	Lawyers	NNPS
8691	2090	27	'	'	POS
8691	2090	28	Reports	report	NNS
8691	2090	29	Annotated	annotate	VBD
8691	2090	30	,	,	,
8691	2090	31	911	911	CD
8691	2090	32	.	.	.
8691	2090	33	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2091	1	The	the	DT
8691	2091	2	requirement	requirement	NN
8691	2091	3	of	of	IN
8691	2091	4	unanimity	unanimity	NN
8691	2091	5	on	on	IN
8691	2091	6	the	the	DT
8691	2091	7	part	part	NN
8691	2091	8	of	of	IN
8691	2091	9	the	the	DT
8691	2091	10	jury	jury	NN
8691	2091	11	in	in	IN
8691	2091	12	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2091	13	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2091	14	,	,	,
8691	2091	15	which	which	WDT
8691	2091	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2091	17	have	have	VBP
8691	2091	18	inherited	inherit	VBN
8691	2091	19	from	from	IN
8691	2091	20	England	England	NNP
8691	2091	21	,	,	,
8691	2091	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	2091	23	indefensible	indefensible	JJ
8691	2091	24	in	in	IN
8691	2091	25	principle	principle	NN
8691	2091	26	.	.	.
8691	2092	1	In	in	IN
8691	2092	2	practice	practice	NN
8691	2092	3	,	,	,
8691	2092	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2092	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	2092	6	saved	save	VBN
8691	2092	7	the	the	DT
8691	2092	8	institution	institution	NN
8691	2092	9	from	from	IN
8691	2092	10	destruction	destruction	NN
8691	2092	11	.	.	.
8691	2093	1	No	no	DT
8691	2093	2	one	one	PRP
8691	2093	3	would	would	MD
8691	2093	4	feel	feel	VB
8691	2093	5	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2093	6	safe	safe	JJ
8691	2093	7	if	if	IN
8691	2093	8	a	a	DT
8691	2093	9	majority	majority	NN
8691	2093	10	of	of	IN
8691	2093	11	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	2093	12	men	man	NNS
8691	2093	13	,	,	,
8691	2093	14	of	of	IN
8691	2093	15	no	no	DT
8691	2093	16	special	special	JJ
8691	2093	17	training	training	NN
8691	2093	18	in	in	IN
8691	2093	19	the	the	DT
8691	2093	20	study	study	NN
8691	2093	21	of	of	IN
8691	2093	22	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2093	23	rights	right	NNS
8691	2093	24	,	,	,
8691	2093	25	could	could	MD
8691	2093	26	strip	strip	VB
8691	2093	27	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2093	28	of	of	IN
8691	2093	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2093	30	property	property	NN
8691	2093	31	.	.	.
8691	2094	1	But	but	CC
8691	2094	2	among	among	IN
8691	2094	3	that	that	DT
8691	2094	4	number	number	NN
8691	2094	5	of	of	IN
8691	2094	6	persons	person	NNS
8691	2094	7	there	there	EX
8691	2094	8	can	can	MD
8691	2094	9	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	2094	10	fail	fail	VB
8691	2094	11	to	to	TO
8691	2094	12	be	be	VB
8691	2094	13	one	one	CD
8691	2094	14	or	or	CC
8691	2094	15	two	two	CD
8691	2094	16	of	of	IN
8691	2094	17	superior	superior	JJ
8691	2094	18	character	character	NN
8691	2094	19	and	and	CC
8691	2094	20	intelligence	intelligence	NN
8691	2094	21	.	.	.
8691	2095	1	These	these	DT
8691	2095	2	,	,	,
8691	2095	3	with	with	IN
8691	2095	4	the	the	DT
8691	2095	5	aid	aid	NN
8691	2095	6	of	of	IN
8691	2095	7	the	the	DT
8691	2095	8	judge	judge	NN
8691	2095	9	,	,	,
8691	2095	10	if	if	IN
8691	2095	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2095	12	be	be	VB
8691	2095	13	one	one	CD
8691	2095	14	who	who	WP
8691	2095	15	fulfills	fulfill	VBZ
8691	2095	16	properly	properly	RB
8691	2095	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2095	18	part	part	NN
8691	2095	19	of	of	IN
8691	2095	20	the	the	DT
8691	2095	21	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	2095	22	,	,	,
8691	2095	23	can	can	MD
8691	2095	24	generally	generally	RB
8691	2095	25	lead	lead	VB
8691	2095	26	the	the	DT
8691	2095	27	rest	rest	NN
8691	2095	28	to	to	IN
8691	2095	29	a	a	DT
8691	2095	30	just	just	JJ
8691	2095	31	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	2095	32	.	.	.
8691	2096	1	If	if	IN
8691	2096	2	the	the	DT
8691	2096	3	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2096	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2096	5	for	for	IN
8691	2096	6	the	the	DT
8691	2096	7	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2096	8	,	,	,
8691	2096	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2096	10	may	may	MD
8691	2096	11	have	have	VB
8691	2096	12	to	to	TO
8691	2096	13	yield	yield	VB
8691	2096	14	to	to	IN
8691	2096	15	some	some	DT
8691	2096	16	compromise	compromise	NN
8691	2096	17	as	as	IN
8691	2096	18	to	to	IN
8691	2096	19	the	the	DT
8691	2096	20	amount	amount	NN
8691	2096	21	of	of	IN
8691	2096	22	damages	damage	NNS
8691	2096	23	.	.	.
8691	2097	1	Not	not	RB
8691	2097	2	infrequently	infrequently	RB
8691	2097	3	this	this	DT
8691	2097	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2097	5	been	be	VBN
8691	2097	6	arrived	arrive	VBN
8691	2097	7	at	at	IN
8691	2097	8	by	by	IN
8691	2097	9	calling	call	VBG
8691	2097	10	for	for	IN
8691	2097	11	the	the	DT
8691	2097	12	separate	separate	JJ
8691	2097	13	estimates	estimate	NNS
8691	2097	14	of	of	IN
8691	2097	15	each	each	DT
8691	2097	16	juror	juror	NN
8691	2097	17	,	,	,
8691	2097	18	adding	add	VBG
8691	2097	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2097	20	together	together	RB
8691	2097	21	and	and	CC
8691	2097	22	dividing	divide	VBG
8691	2097	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2097	24	by	by	IN
8691	2097	25	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	2097	26	.	.	.
8691	2098	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2098	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2098	3	a	a	DT
8691	2098	4	rough	rough	JJ
8691	2098	5	way	way	NN
8691	2098	6	,	,	,
8691	2098	7	and	and	CC
8691	2098	8	not	not	RB
8691	2098	9	the	the	DT
8691	2098	10	fairest	fair	JJS
8691	2098	11	,	,	,
8691	2098	12	but	but	CC
8691	2098	13	the	the	DT
8691	2098	14	wiser	wise	JJR
8691	2098	15	heads	head	NNS
8691	2098	16	may	may	MD
8691	2098	17	consent	consent	VB
8691	2098	18	to	to	IN
8691	2098	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2098	20	to	to	TO
8691	2098	21	secure	secure	VB
8691	2098	22	the	the	DT
8691	2098	23	concurrence	concurrence	NN
8691	2098	24	of	of	IN
8691	2098	25	the	the	DT
8691	2098	26	weaker	weak	JJR
8691	2098	27	.	.	.
8691	2099	1	In	in	IN
8691	2099	2	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2099	3	cases	case	NNS
8691	2099	4	,	,	,
8691	2099	5	the	the	DT
8691	2099	6	importance	importance	NN
8691	2099	7	of	of	IN
8691	2099	8	a	a	DT
8691	2099	9	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2099	10	to	to	IN
8691	2099	11	the	the	DT
8691	2099	12	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2099	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	2099	14	so	so	RB
8691	2099	15	great	great	JJ
8691	2099	16	that	that	DT
8691	2099	17	unanimity	unanimity	NN
8691	2099	18	may	may	MD
8691	2099	19	well	well	RB
8691	2099	20	be	be	VB
8691	2099	21	required	require	VBN
8691	2099	22	.	.	.
8691	2100	1	While	while	IN
8691	2100	2	there	there	EX
8691	2100	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2100	4	a	a	DT
8691	2100	5	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2100	6	presumption	presumption	NN
8691	2100	7	that	that	IN
8691	2100	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2100	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	2100	10	innocent	innocent	JJ
8691	2100	11	until	until	IN
8691	2100	12	found	find	VBD
8691	2100	13	guilty	guilty	JJ
8691	2100	14	,	,	,
8691	2100	15	this	this	DT
8691	2100	16	in	in	IN
8691	2100	17	practice	practice	NN
8691	2100	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	2100	19	of	of	IN
8691	2100	20	little	little	JJ
8691	2100	21	avail	avail	NN
8691	2100	22	to	to	IN
8691	2100	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2100	24	with	with	IN
8691	2100	25	the	the	DT
8691	2100	26	jury	jury	NN
8691	2100	27	.	.	.
8691	2101	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2101	2	know	know	VBP
8691	2101	3	from	from	IN
8691	2101	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2101	5	every	every	DT
8691	2101	6	-	-	HYPH
8691	2101	7	day	day	NN
8691	2101	8	observation	observation	NN
8691	2101	9	of	of	IN
8691	2101	10	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	2101	11	that	that	IN
8691	2101	12	there	there	EX
8691	2101	13	are	be	VBP
8691	2101	14	few	few	JJ
8691	2101	15	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2101	16	which	which	WDT
8691	2101	17	reach	reach	VBP
8691	2101	18	the	the	DT
8691	2101	19	final	final	JJ
8691	2101	20	stage	stage	NN
8691	2101	21	of	of	IN
8691	2101	22	a	a	DT
8691	2101	23	trial	trial	NN
8691	2101	24	on	on	IN
8691	2101	25	the	the	DT
8691	2101	26	merits	merit	NNS
8691	2101	27	,	,	,
8691	2101	28	under	under	IN
8691	2101	29	which	which	WDT
8691	2101	30	there	there	EX
8691	2101	31	ought	ought	MD
8691	2101	32	not	not	RB
8691	2101	33	to	to	TO
8691	2101	34	be	be	VB
8691	2101	35	a	a	DT
8691	2101	36	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	2101	37	.	.	.
8691	2102	1	In	in	IN
8691	2102	2	several	several	JJ
8691	2102	3	States	States	NNP
8691	2102	4	verdicts	verdict	NNS
8691	2102	5	in	in	IN
8691	2102	6	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2102	7	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2102	8	by	by	IN
8691	2102	9	a	a	DT
8691	2102	10	three	three	CD
8691	2102	11	-	-	HYPH
8691	2102	12	fourths	fourth	NNS
8691	2102	13	vote	vote	NN
8691	2102	14	are	be	VBP
8691	2102	15	permitted	permit	VBN
8691	2102	16	.	.	.
8691	2103	1	This	this	DT
8691	2103	2	radical	radical	JJ
8691	2103	3	change	change	NN
8691	2103	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2103	5	not	not	RB
8691	2103	6	likely	likely	JJ
8691	2103	7	to	to	TO
8691	2103	8	become	become	VB
8691	2103	9	general	general	JJ
8691	2103	10	.	.	.
8691	2104	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2104	2	best	good	JJS
8691	2104	3	defense	defense	NN
8691	2104	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2104	5	that	that	IN
8691	2104	6	temptations	temptation	NNS
8691	2104	7	to	to	IN
8691	2104	8	corruption	corruption	NN
8691	2104	9	are	be	VBP
8691	2104	10	thus	thus	RB
8691	2104	11	removed	remove	VBN
8691	2104	12	.	.	.
8691	2105	1	So	so	RB
8691	2105	2	long	long	RB
8691	2105	3	as	as	IN
8691	2105	4	one	one	CD
8691	2105	5	juror	juror	NN
8691	2105	6	,	,	,
8691	2105	7	by	by	IN
8691	2105	8	refusing	refuse	VBG
8691	2105	9	to	to	TO
8691	2105	10	concur	concur	VB
8691	2105	11	with	with	IN
8691	2105	12	the	the	DT
8691	2105	13	rest	rest	NN
8691	2105	14	,	,	,
8691	2105	15	whether	whether	CC
8691	2105	16	with	with	IN
8691	2105	17	or	or	CC
8691	2105	18	without	without	IN
8691	2105	19	reason	reason	NN
8691	2105	20	,	,	,
8691	2105	21	can	can	MD
8691	2105	22	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	2105	23	a	a	DT
8691	2105	24	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2105	25	,	,	,
8691	2105	26	there	there	EX
8691	2105	27	will	will	MD
8691	2105	28	be	be	VB
8691	2105	29	defendants	defendant	NNS
8691	2105	30	seeking	seek	VBG
8691	2105	31	to	to	TO
8691	2105	32	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	2105	33	the	the	DT
8691	2105	34	recovery	recovery	NN
8691	2105	35	of	of	IN
8691	2105	36	what	what	WP
8691	2105	37	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2105	38	know	know	VBP
8691	2105	39	to	to	TO
8691	2105	40	be	be	VB
8691	2105	41	a	a	DT
8691	2105	42	just	just	JJ
8691	2105	43	demand	demand	NN
8691	2105	44	,	,	,
8691	2105	45	who	who	WP
8691	2105	46	will	will	MD
8691	2105	47	be	be	VB
8691	2105	48	ready	ready	JJ
8691	2105	49	to	to	TO
8691	2105	50	buy	buy	VB
8691	2105	51	a	a	DT
8691	2105	52	vote	vote	NN
8691	2105	53	.	.	.
8691	2106	1	In	in	IN
8691	2106	2	1899	1899	CD
8691	2106	3	,	,	,
8691	2106	4	seven	seven	CD
8691	2106	5	of	of	IN
8691	2106	6	the	the	DT
8691	2106	7	bailiffs	bailiff	NNS
8691	2106	8	in	in	IN
8691	2106	9	attendance	attendance	NN
8691	2106	10	on	on	IN
8691	2106	11	the	the	DT
8691	2106	12	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
8691	2106	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	2106	14	were	be	VBD
8691	2106	15	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2106	16	of	of	IN
8691	2106	17	lending	lend	VBG
8691	2106	18	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2106	19	to	to	IN
8691	2106	20	such	such	JJ
8691	2106	21	negotiations	negotiation	NNS
8691	2106	22	,	,	,
8691	2106	23	and	and	CC
8691	2106	24	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	2106	25	men	man	NNS
8691	2106	26	who	who	WP
8691	2106	27	had	have	VBD
8691	2106	28	been	be	VBN
8691	2106	29	jurors	juror	NNS
8691	2106	30	confessed	confess	VBN
8691	2106	31	that	that	IN
8691	2106	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2106	33	had	have	VBD
8691	2106	34	either	either	CC
8691	2106	35	taken	take	VBN
8691	2106	36	or	or	CC
8691	2106	37	been	be	VBN
8691	2106	38	offered	offer	VBN
8691	2106	39	bribes	bribe	NNS
8691	2106	40	.	.	.
8691	2107	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2107	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2107	3	:	:	:
8691	2107	4	Report	Report	NNP
8691	2107	5	of	of	IN
8691	2107	6	the	the	DT
8691	2107	7	New	New	NNP
8691	2107	8	York	York	NNP
8691	2107	9	State	State	NNP
8691	2107	10	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	2107	11	Association	Association	NNP
8691	2107	12	for	for	IN
8691	2107	13	1904	1904	CD
8691	2107	14	,	,	,
8691	2107	15	51	51	CD
8691	2107	16	.	.	.
8691	2107	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2108	1	The	the	DT
8691	2108	2	Anglo	anglo	JJ
8691	2108	3	-	-	HYPH
8691	2108	4	American	american	JJ
8691	2108	5	jury	jury	NN
8691	2108	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2108	7	unique	unique	JJ
8691	2108	8	because	because	IN
8691	2108	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2108	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2108	11	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	2108	12	unless	unless	IN
8691	2108	13	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
8691	2108	14	,	,	,
8691	2108	15	and	and	CC
8691	2108	16	because	because	IN
8691	2108	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2108	18	may	may	MD
8691	2108	19	render	render	VB
8691	2108	20	a	a	DT
8691	2108	21	general	general	JJ
8691	2108	22	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2108	23	,	,	,
8691	2108	24	stating	state	VBG
8691	2108	25	no	no	DT
8691	2108	26	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	2108	27	for	for	IN
8691	2108	28	the	the	DT
8691	2108	29	decision	decision	NN
8691	2108	30	,	,	,
8691	2108	31	on	on	IN
8691	2108	32	which	which	WDT
8691	2108	33	a	a	DT
8691	2108	34	general	general	JJ
8691	2108	35	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2108	36	,	,	,
8691	2108	37	save	save	VBP
8691	2108	38	in	in	IN
8691	2108	39	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
8691	2108	40	cases	case	NNS
8691	2108	41	,	,	,
8691	2108	42	is	be	VBZ
8691	2108	43	entered	enter	VBN
8691	2108	44	as	as	IN
8691	2108	45	of	of	IN
8691	2108	46	course	course	NN
8691	2108	47	.	.	.
8691	2109	1	In	in	IN
8691	2109	2	the	the	DT
8691	2109	3	early	early	JJ
8691	2109	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2109	5	history	history	NN
8691	2109	6	of	of	IN
8691	2109	7	the	the	DT
8691	2109	8	American	american	JJ
8691	2109	9	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	2109	10	juries	jury	NNS
8691	2109	11	were	be	VBD
8691	2109	12	less	less	JJR
8691	2109	13	under	under	IN
8691	2109	14	the	the	DT
8691	2109	15	control	control	NN
8691	2109	16	of	of	IN
8691	2109	17	the	the	DT
8691	2109	18	judge	judge	NN
8691	2109	19	than	than	IN
8691	2109	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2109	21	are	be	VBP
8691	2109	22	now	now	RB
8691	2109	23	.	.	.
8691	2110	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2110	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2110	3	:	:	:
8691	2110	4	See	see	VB
8691	2110	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	2110	6	.	.	.
8691	2111	1	XIV	XIV	NNP
8691	2111	2	.	.	.
8691	2111	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2112	1	In	in	IN
8691	2112	2	some	some	DT
8691	2112	3	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	2112	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2112	5	received	receive	VBD
8691	2112	6	no	no	DT
8691	2112	7	instructions	instruction	NNS
8691	2112	8	as	as	IN
8691	2112	9	to	to	IN
8691	2112	10	the	the	DT
8691	2112	11	law	law	NN
8691	2112	12	,	,	,
8691	2112	13	the	the	DT
8691	2112	14	chance	chance	NN
8691	2112	15	of	of	IN
8691	2112	16	an	an	DT
8691	2112	17	unjust	unjust	JJ
8691	2112	18	decision	decision	NN
8691	2112	19	being	be	VBG
8691	2112	20	guarded	guard	VBN
8691	2112	21	against	against	IN
8691	2112	22	in	in	IN
8691	2112	23	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2112	24	cases	case	NNS
8691	2112	25	,	,	,
8691	2112	26	as	as	RB
8691	2112	27	previously	previously	RB
8691	2112	28	stated	state	VBN
8691	2112	29	,	,	,
8691	2112	30	by	by	IN
8691	2112	31	an	an	DT
8691	2112	32	absolute	absolute	JJ
8691	2112	33	right	right	NN
8691	2112	34	in	in	IN
8691	2112	35	the	the	DT
8691	2112	36	losing	lose	VBG
8691	2112	37	party	party	NN
8691	2112	38	to	to	TO
8691	2112	39	claim	claim	VB
8691	2112	40	a	a	DT
8691	2112	41	new	new	JJ
8691	2112	42	trial	trial	NN
8691	2112	43	before	before	IN
8691	2112	44	another	another	DT
8691	2112	45	jury	jury	NN
8691	2112	46	.	.	.
8691	2113	1	The	the	DT
8691	2113	2	general	general	JJ
8691	2113	3	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	2113	4	of	of	IN
8691	2113	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2113	6	practice	practice	NN
8691	2113	7	in	in	IN
8691	2113	8	later	late	JJR
8691	2113	9	years	year	NNS
8691	2113	10	has	have	VBZ
8691	2113	11	been	be	VBN
8691	2113	12	to	to	TO
8691	2113	13	emphasize	emphasize	VB
8691	2113	14	the	the	DT
8691	2113	15	influence	influence	NN
8691	2113	16	of	of	IN
8691	2113	17	the	the	DT
8691	2113	18	judge	judge	NN
8691	2113	19	upon	upon	IN
8691	2113	20	verdicts	verdict	NNS
8691	2113	21	.	.	.
8691	2114	1	This	this	DT
8691	2114	2	often	often	RB
8691	2114	3	extends	extend	VBZ
8691	2114	4	to	to	IN
8691	2114	5	directing	direct	VBG
8691	2114	6	a	a	DT
8691	2114	7	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2114	8	,	,	,
8691	2114	9	peremptorily	peremptorily	RB
8691	2114	10	,	,	,
8691	2114	11	for	for	IN
8691	2114	12	one	one	CD
8691	2114	13	party	party	NN
8691	2114	14	or	or	CC
8691	2114	15	the	the	DT
8691	2114	16	other	other	JJ
8691	2114	17	,	,	,
8691	2114	18	when	when	WRB
8691	2114	19	the	the	DT
8691	2114	20	law	law	NN
8691	2114	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	2114	22	clear	clear	JJ
8691	2114	23	upon	upon	IN
8691	2114	24	the	the	DT
8691	2114	25	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2114	26	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	2114	27	or	or	CC
8691	2114	28	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	2114	29	.	.	.
8691	2115	1	Still	still	RB
8691	2115	2	more	more	RBR
8691	2115	3	often	often	RB
8691	2115	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2115	5	takes	take	VBZ
8691	2115	6	the	the	DT
8691	2115	7	shape	shape	NN
8691	2115	8	of	of	IN
8691	2115	9	a	a	DT
8691	2115	10	caution	caution	NN
8691	2115	11	as	as	IN
8691	2115	12	to	to	IN
8691	2115	13	the	the	DT
8691	2115	14	weight	weight	NN
8691	2115	15	that	that	WDT
8691	2115	16	can	can	MD
8691	2115	17	properly	properly	RB
8691	2115	18	be	be	VB
8691	2115	19	given	give	VBN
8691	2115	20	to	to	IN
8691	2115	21	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2115	22	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2115	23	,	,	,
8691	2115	24	or	or	CC
8691	2115	25	an	an	DT
8691	2115	26	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2115	27	as	as	IN
8691	2115	28	to	to	IN
8691	2115	29	what	what	WP
8691	2115	30	really	really	RB
8691	2115	31	are	be	VBP
8691	2115	32	the	the	DT
8691	2115	33	controlling	control	VBG
8691	2115	34	sources	source	NNS
8691	2115	35	of	of	IN
8691	2115	36	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2115	37	.	.	.
8691	2116	1	Without	without	IN
8691	2116	2	the	the	DT
8691	2116	3	guidance	guidance	NN
8691	2116	4	of	of	IN
8691	2116	5	an	an	DT
8691	2116	6	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
8691	2116	7	judge	judge	NN
8691	2116	8	,	,	,
8691	2116	9	a	a	DT
8691	2116	10	jury	jury	NN
8691	2116	11	would	would	MD
8691	2116	12	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	2116	13	come	come	VB
8691	2116	14	to	to	TO
8691	2116	15	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
8691	2116	16	and	and	CC
8691	2116	17	even	even	RB
8691	2116	18	unjust	unjust	JJ
8691	2116	19	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2116	20	.	.	.
8691	2117	1	That	that	IN
8691	2117	2	there	there	EX
8691	2117	3	should	should	MD
8691	2117	4	be	be	VB
8691	2117	5	such	such	JJ
8691	2117	6	guidance	guidance	NN
8691	2117	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2117	8	an	an	DT
8691	2117	9	essential	essential	JJ
8691	2117	10	part	part	NN
8691	2117	11	of	of	IN
8691	2117	12	the	the	DT
8691	2117	13	jury	jury	NN
8691	2117	14	system	system	NN
8691	2117	15	,	,	,
8691	2117	16	and	and	CC
8691	2117	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2117	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	2117	19	generally	generally	RB
8691	2117	20	given	give	VBN
8691	2117	21	most	most	RBS
8691	2117	22	effectually	effectually	RB
8691	2117	23	where	where	WRB
8691	2117	24	the	the	DT
8691	2117	25	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2117	26	are	be	VBP
8691	2117	27	the	the	DT
8691	2117	28	ablest	able	JJS
8691	2117	29	and	and	CC
8691	2117	30	the	the	DT
8691	2117	31	most	most	RBS
8691	2117	32	independent	independent	JJ
8691	2117	33	.	.	.
8691	2118	1	The	the	DT
8691	2118	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	2118	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	2118	4	at	at	IN
8691	2118	5	common	common	JJ
8691	2118	6	law	law	NN
8691	2118	7	and	and	CC
8691	2118	8	by	by	IN
8691	2118	9	practice	practice	NN
8691	2118	10	in	in	IN
8691	2118	11	most	most	JJS
8691	2118	12	American	american	JJ
8691	2118	13	States	States	NNP
8691	2118	14	a	a	DT
8691	2118	15	right	right	NN
8691	2118	16	in	in	IN
8691	2118	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2118	18	charge	charge	NN
8691	2118	19	to	to	TO
8691	2118	20	comment	comment	VB
8691	2118	21	on	on	IN
8691	2118	22	the	the	DT
8691	2118	23	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2118	24	and	and	CC
8691	2118	25	intimate	intimate	VB
8691	2118	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2118	27	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2118	28	as	as	IN
8691	2118	29	to	to	IN
8691	2118	30	the	the	DT
8691	2118	31	weight	weight	NN
8691	2118	32	which	which	WDT
8691	2118	33	should	should	MD
8691	2118	34	or	or	CC
8691	2118	35	should	should	MD
8691	2118	36	not	not	RB
8691	2118	37	be	be	VB
8691	2118	38	given	give	VBN
8691	2118	39	to	to	IN
8691	2118	40	any	any	DT
8691	2118	41	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2118	42	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2118	43	.	.	.
8691	2119	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2119	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2119	3	a	a	DT
8691	2119	4	right	right	NN
8691	2119	5	to	to	TO
8691	2119	6	be	be	VB
8691	2119	7	cautiously	cautiously	RB
8691	2119	8	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	2119	9	,	,	,
8691	2119	10	for	for	IN
8691	2119	11	juries	jury	NNS
8691	2119	12	are	be	VBP
8691	2119	13	greatly	greatly	RB
8691	2119	14	influenced	influence	VBN
8691	2119	15	in	in	IN
8691	2119	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2119	17	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2119	18	by	by	IN
8691	2119	19	remarks	remark	NNS
8691	2119	20	of	of	IN
8691	2119	21	that	that	DT
8691	2119	22	character	character	NN
8691	2119	23	.	.	.
8691	2120	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2120	2	feel	feel	VBP
8691	2120	3	that	that	IN
8691	2120	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2120	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2120	6	the	the	DT
8691	2120	7	head	head	NN
8691	2120	8	of	of	IN
8691	2120	9	the	the	DT
8691	2120	10	court	court	NN
8691	2120	11	,	,	,
8691	2120	12	and	and	CC
8691	2120	13	there	there	EX
8691	2120	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	2120	15	a	a	DT
8691	2120	16	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2120	17	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	2120	18	of	of	IN
8691	2120	19	loyalty	loyalty	NN
8691	2120	20	to	to	IN
8691	2120	21	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2120	22	as	as	RB
8691	2120	23	well	well	RB
8691	2120	24	as	as	IN
8691	2120	25	of	of	IN
8691	2120	26	respect	respect	NN
8691	2120	27	for	for	IN
8691	2120	28	any	any	DT
8691	2120	29	one	one	CD
8691	2120	30	occupying	occupy	VBG
8691	2120	31	the	the	DT
8691	2120	32	position	position	NN
8691	2120	33	in	in	IN
8691	2120	34	which	which	WDT
8691	2120	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2120	36	find	find	VBP
8691	2120	37	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2120	38	placed	place	VBN
8691	2120	39	by	by	IN
8691	2120	40	the	the	DT
8691	2120	41	authority	authority	NN
8691	2120	42	of	of	IN
8691	2120	43	the	the	DT
8691	2120	44	State	State	NNP
8691	2120	45	.	.	.
8691	2121	1	Sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2121	2	this	this	DT
8691	2121	3	power	power	NN
8691	2121	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2121	5	abused	abuse	VBN
8691	2121	6	.	.	.
8691	2122	1	The	the	DT
8691	2122	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	2122	3	desires	desire	VBZ
8691	2122	4	to	to	TO
8691	2122	5	indicate	indicate	VB
8691	2122	6	a	a	DT
8691	2122	7	decided	decided	JJ
8691	2122	8	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2122	9	.	.	.
8691	2123	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2123	2	fears	fear	VBZ
8691	2123	3	that	that	IN
8691	2123	4	if	if	IN
8691	2123	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2123	6	put	put	VBD
8691	2123	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2123	8	in	in	IN
8691	2123	9	plain	plain	JJ
8691	2123	10	words	word	NNS
8691	2123	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2123	12	might	may	MD
8691	2123	13	seem	seem	VB
8691	2123	14	so	so	RB
8691	2123	15	strong	strong	JJ
8691	2123	16	as	as	IN
8691	2123	17	to	to	TO
8691	2123	18	indicate	indicate	VB
8691	2123	19	partiality	partiality	NN
8691	2123	20	,	,	,
8691	2123	21	and	and	CC
8691	2123	22	furnish	furnish	JJ
8691	2123	23	ground	ground	NN
8691	2123	24	of	of	IN
8691	2123	25	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2123	26	.	.	.
8691	2124	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2124	2	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	2124	3	uses	use	VBZ
8691	2124	4	language	language	NN
8691	2124	5	,	,	,
8691	2124	6	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	2124	7	in	in	IN
8691	2124	8	reference	reference	NN
8691	2124	9	to	to	IN
8691	2124	10	the	the	DT
8691	2124	11	credibility	credibility	NN
8691	2124	12	of	of	IN
8691	2124	13	a	a	DT
8691	2124	14	witness	witness	NN
8691	2124	15	,	,	,
8691	2124	16	which	which	WDT
8691	2124	17	looks	look	VBZ
8691	2124	18	fair	fair	JJ
8691	2124	19	and	and	CC
8691	2124	20	even	even	RB
8691	2124	21	colorless	colorles	MD
8691	2124	22	on	on	IN
8691	2124	23	paper	paper	NN
8691	2124	24	,	,	,
8691	2124	25	but	but	CC
8691	2124	26	by	by	IN
8691	2124	27	the	the	DT
8691	2124	28	tone	tone	NN
8691	2124	29	or	or	CC
8691	2124	30	emphasis	emphasis	NN
8691	2124	31	in	in	IN
8691	2124	32	which	which	WDT
8691	2124	33	some	some	DT
8691	2124	34	vital	vital	JJ
8691	2124	35	word	word	NN
8691	2124	36	is	be	VBZ
8691	2124	37	uttered	uttered	JJ
8691	2124	38	,	,	,
8691	2124	39	or	or	CC
8691	2124	40	with	with	IN
8691	2124	41	the	the	DT
8691	2124	42	aid	aid	NN
8691	2124	43	of	of	IN
8691	2124	44	a	a	DT
8691	2124	45	shrug	shrug	NN
8691	2124	46	or	or	CC
8691	2124	47	glance	glance	NN
8691	2124	48	,	,	,
8691	2124	49	carries	carry	VBZ
8691	2124	50	to	to	IN
8691	2124	51	those	those	DT
8691	2124	52	whom	whom	WP
8691	2124	53	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2124	54	is	be	VBZ
8691	2124	55	addressing	address	VBG
8691	2124	56	an	an	DT
8691	2124	57	unmistakable	unmistakable	JJ
8691	2124	58	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	2124	59	that	that	IN
8691	2124	60	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2124	61	means	mean	VBZ
8691	2124	62	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2124	63	to	to	TO
8691	2124	64	be	be	VB
8691	2124	65	taken	take	VBN
8691	2124	66	in	in	IN
8691	2124	67	a	a	DT
8691	2124	68	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2124	69	sense	sense	NN
8691	2124	70	.	.	.
8691	2125	1	Any	any	DT
8691	2125	2	such	such	JJ
8691	2125	3	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2125	4	action	action	NN
8691	2125	5	,	,	,
8691	2125	6	however	however	RB
8691	2125	7	,	,	,
8691	2125	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2125	9	rare	rare	JJ
8691	2125	10	,	,	,
8691	2125	11	and	and	CC
8691	2125	12	would	would	MD
8691	2125	13	be	be	VB
8691	2125	14	looked	look	VBN
8691	2125	15	upon	upon	IN
8691	2125	16	with	with	IN
8691	2125	17	disapprobation	disapprobation	NN
8691	2125	18	by	by	IN
8691	2125	19	the	the	DT
8691	2125	20	bar	bar	NN
8691	2125	21	.	.	.
8691	2126	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2126	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2126	3	:	:	:
8691	2126	4	See	see	VB
8691	2126	5	Metropolitan	Metropolitan	NNP
8691	2126	6	Life	Life	NNP
8691	2126	7	Insurance	Insurance	NNP
8691	2126	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	2126	9	_	_	NNP
8691	2126	10	v.	v.	IN
8691	2126	11	_	_	NNP
8691	2126	12	Howle	Howle	NNP
8691	2126	13	,	,	,
8691	2126	14	68	68	CD
8691	2126	15	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	2126	16	State	State	NNP
8691	2126	17	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2126	18	,	,	,
8691	2126	19	614	614	CD
8691	2126	20	;	;	:
8691	2126	21	68	68	CD
8691	2126	22	Northeastern	northeastern	JJ
8691	2126	23	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	2126	24	,	,	,
8691	2126	25	4	4	CD
8691	2126	26	.	.	.
8691	2126	27	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2127	1	If	if	IN
8691	2127	2	the	the	DT
8691	2127	3	case	case	NN
8691	2127	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2127	5	one	one	CD
8691	2127	6	which	which	WDT
8691	2127	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	2127	8	been	be	VBN
8691	2127	9	pressed	press	VBN
8691	2127	10	by	by	IN
8691	2127	11	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2127	12	especially	especially	RB
8691	2127	13	upon	upon	IN
8691	2127	14	the	the	DT
8691	2127	15	sympathies	sympathy	NNS
8691	2127	16	of	of	IN
8691	2127	17	the	the	DT
8691	2127	18	jury	jury	NN
8691	2127	19	,	,	,
8691	2127	20	such	such	JJ
8691	2127	21	as	as	IN
8691	2127	22	a	a	DT
8691	2127	23	suit	suit	NN
8691	2127	24	arising	arise	VBG
8691	2127	25	out	out	IN
8691	2127	26	of	of	IN
8691	2127	27	a	a	DT
8691	2127	28	labor	labor	NN
8691	2127	29	strike	strike	NN
8691	2127	30	,	,	,
8691	2127	31	or	or	CC
8691	2127	32	by	by	IN
8691	2127	33	a	a	DT
8691	2127	34	widow	widow	NN
8691	2127	35	to	to	TO
8691	2127	36	recover	recover	VB
8691	2127	37	for	for	IN
8691	2127	38	an	an	DT
8691	2127	39	injury	injury	NN
8691	2127	40	resulting	result	VBG
8691	2127	41	in	in	IN
8691	2127	42	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2127	43	husband	husband	NN
8691	2127	44	's	's	POS
8691	2127	45	death	death	NN
8691	2127	46	,	,	,
8691	2127	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2127	48	is	be	VBZ
8691	2127	49	customary	customary	JJ
8691	2127	50	for	for	IN
8691	2127	51	the	the	DT
8691	2127	52	court	court	NN
8691	2127	53	to	to	TO
8691	2127	54	caution	caution	VB
8691	2127	55	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2127	56	in	in	IN
8691	2127	57	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2127	58	charge	charge	NN
8691	2127	59	that	that	IN
8691	2127	60	justice	justice	NN
8691	2127	61	and	and	CC
8691	2127	62	not	not	RB
8691	2127	63	sympathy	sympathy	NNP
8691	2127	64	is	be	VBZ
8691	2127	65	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2127	66	rule	rule	NN
8691	2127	67	of	of	IN
8691	2127	68	duty	duty	NN
8691	2127	69	.	.	.
8691	2128	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2128	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	2128	3	:	:	:
8691	2128	4	Bachert	Bachert	NNP
8691	2128	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2128	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2128	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2128	8	Lehigh	Lehigh	NNP
8691	2128	9	Coal	Coal	NNP
8691	2128	10	and	and	CC
8691	2128	11	Navigation	Navigation	NNP
8691	2128	12	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	2128	13	,	,	,
8691	2128	14	208	208	CD
8691	2128	15	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	2128	16	State	State	NNP
8691	2128	17	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2128	18	362	362	CD
8691	2128	19	;	;	:
8691	2128	20	57	57	CD
8691	2128	21	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	2128	22	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2128	23	,	,	,
8691	2128	24	765	765	CD
8691	2128	25	.	.	.
8691	2128	26	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2129	1	The	the	DT
8691	2129	2	American	american	JJ
8691	2129	3	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	2129	4	were	be	VBD
8691	2129	5	settled	settle	VBN
8691	2129	6	at	at	IN
8691	2129	7	a	a	DT
8691	2129	8	time	time	NN
8691	2129	9	when	when	WRB
8691	2129	10	the	the	DT
8691	2129	11	English	English	NNP
8691	2129	12	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2129	13	code	code	NN
8691	2129	14	was	be	VBD
8691	2129	15	extremely	extremely	RB
8691	2129	16	harsh	harsh	JJ
8691	2129	17	,	,	,
8691	2129	18	and	and	CC
8691	2129	19	the	the	DT
8691	2129	20	English	english	JJ
8691	2129	21	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2129	22	were	be	VBD
8691	2129	23	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	2129	24	to	to	TO
8691	2129	25	administer	administer	VB
8691	2129	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2129	27	in	in	IN
8691	2129	28	such	such	PDT
8691	2129	29	a	a	DT
8691	2129	30	way	way	NN
8691	2129	31	as	as	IN
8691	2129	32	to	to	TO
8691	2129	33	favor	favor	VB
8691	2129	34	the	the	DT
8691	2129	35	crown	crown	NN
8691	2129	36	.	.	.
8691	2130	1	If	if	IN
8691	2130	2	the	the	DT
8691	2130	3	government	government	NN
8691	2130	4	promoted	promote	VBD
8691	2130	5	a	a	DT
8691	2130	6	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	2130	7	,	,	,
8691	2130	8	there	there	EX
8691	2130	9	was	be	VBD
8691	2130	10	little	little	JJ
8691	2130	11	hope	hope	NN
8691	2130	12	for	for	IN
8691	2130	13	the	the	DT
8691	2130	14	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2130	15	,	,	,
8691	2130	16	except	except	IN
8691	2130	17	from	from	IN
8691	2130	18	the	the	DT
8691	2130	19	jury	jury	NN
8691	2130	20	.	.	.
8691	2131	1	The	the	DT
8691	2131	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	2131	3	held	hold	VBD
8691	2131	4	that	that	IN
8691	2131	5	on	on	IN
8691	2131	6	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2131	7	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2131	8	for	for	IN
8691	2131	9	publishing	publish	VBG
8691	2131	10	a	a	DT
8691	2131	11	libel	libel	NN
8691	2131	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2131	13	was	be	VBD
8691	2131	14	for	for	IN
8691	2131	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2131	16	to	to	TO
8691	2131	17	say	say	VB
8691	2131	18	whether	whether	IN
8691	2131	19	the	the	DT
8691	2131	20	paper	paper	NN
8691	2131	21	was	be	VBD
8691	2131	22	libellous	libellous	JJ
8691	2131	23	,	,	,
8691	2131	24	and	and	CC
8691	2131	25	for	for	IN
8691	2131	26	the	the	DT
8691	2131	27	jury	jury	NN
8691	2131	28	to	to	TO
8691	2131	29	decide	decide	VB
8691	2131	30	only	only	RB
8691	2131	31	as	as	IN
8691	2131	32	to	to	IN
8691	2131	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2131	34	publication	publication	NN
8691	2131	35	by	by	IN
8691	2131	36	the	the	DT
8691	2131	37	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2131	38	.	.	.
8691	2132	1	This	this	DT
8691	2132	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2132	3	the	the	DT
8691	2132	4	occasion	occasion	NN
8691	2132	5	of	of	IN
8691	2132	6	the	the	DT
8691	2132	7	Charles	Charles	NNP
8691	2132	8	James	James	NNP
8691	2132	9	Fox	Fox	NNP
8691	2132	10	Libel	Libel	NNP
8691	2132	11	Act	Act	NNP
8691	2132	12	of	of	IN
8691	2132	13	1792	1792	CD
8691	2132	14	,	,	,
8691	2132	15	and	and	CC
8691	2132	16	of	of	IN
8691	2132	17	many	many	JJ
8691	2132	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	2132	19	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	2132	20	to	to	IN
8691	2132	21	the	the	DT
8691	2132	22	same	same	JJ
8691	2132	23	effect	effect	NN
8691	2132	24	in	in	IN
8691	2132	25	this	this	DT
8691	2132	26	country	country	NN
8691	2132	27	,	,	,
8691	2132	28	under	under	IN
8691	2132	29	which	which	WDT
8691	2132	30	juries	jury	NNS
8691	2132	31	,	,	,
8691	2132	32	even	even	RB
8691	2132	33	in	in	IN
8691	2132	34	libel	libel	NN
8691	2132	35	cases	case	NNS
8691	2132	36	,	,	,
8691	2132	37	can	can	MD
8691	2132	38	render	render	VB
8691	2132	39	a	a	DT
8691	2132	40	general	general	JJ
8691	2132	41	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2132	42	of	of	IN
8691	2132	43	Not	not	RB
8691	2132	44	Guilty	guilty	JJ
8691	2132	45	.	.	.
8691	2133	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2133	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2133	3	under	under	IN
8691	2133	4	the	the	DT
8691	2133	5	influence	influence	NN
8691	2133	6	of	of	IN
8691	2133	7	these	these	DT
8691	2133	8	ideas	idea	NNS
8691	2133	9	,	,	,
8691	2133	10	and	and	CC
8691	2133	11	in	in	IN
8691	2133	12	view	view	NN
8691	2133	13	of	of	IN
8691	2133	14	the	the	DT
8691	2133	15	fact	fact	NN
8691	2133	16	that	that	IN
8691	2133	17	the	the	DT
8691	2133	18	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	2133	19	judge	judge	NN
8691	2133	20	often	often	RB
8691	2133	21	knew	know	VBD
8691	2133	22	no	no	DT
8691	2133	23	more	more	JJR
8691	2133	24	law	law	NN
8691	2133	25	than	than	IN
8691	2133	26	the	the	DT
8691	2133	27	jury	jury	NN
8691	2133	28	,	,	,
8691	2133	29	that	that	IN
8691	2133	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2133	31	became	become	VBD
8691	2133	32	common	common	JJ
8691	2133	33	in	in	IN
8691	2133	34	this	this	DT
8691	2133	35	country	country	NN
8691	2133	36	either	either	RB
8691	2133	37	to	to	TO
8691	2133	38	give	give	VB
8691	2133	39	a	a	DT
8691	2133	40	jury	jury	NN
8691	2133	41	in	in	IN
8691	2133	42	a	a	DT
8691	2133	43	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2133	44	cause	cause	NN
8691	2133	45	no	no	DT
8691	2133	46	instruction	instruction	NN
8691	2133	47	as	as	IN
8691	2133	48	to	to	IN
8691	2133	49	the	the	DT
8691	2133	50	law	law	NN
8691	2133	51	at	at	RB
8691	2133	52	all	all	RB
8691	2133	53	or	or	CC
8691	2133	54	to	to	TO
8691	2133	55	charge	charge	VB
8691	2133	56	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2133	57	that	that	IN
8691	2133	58	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2133	59	were	be	VBD
8691	2133	60	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2133	61	both	both	DT
8691	2133	62	of	of	IN
8691	2133	63	the	the	DT
8691	2133	64	law	law	NN
8691	2133	65	and	and	CC
8691	2133	66	fact	fact	NN
8691	2133	67	.	.	.
8691	2134	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2134	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2134	3	:	:	:
8691	2134	4	2	2	CD
8691	2134	5	Swift	Swift	NNP
8691	2134	6	's	's	POS
8691	2134	7	"	"	``
8691	2134	8	System	System	NNP
8691	2134	9	of	of	IN
8691	2134	10	the	the	DT
8691	2134	11	Laws	Laws	NNPS
8691	2134	12	of	of	IN
8691	2134	13	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2134	14	,	,	,
8691	2134	15	"	"	``
8691	2134	16	258	258	CD
8691	2134	17	,	,	,
8691	2134	18	401	401	CD
8691	2134	19	.	.	.
8691	2134	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2135	1	In	in	IN
8691	2135	2	some	some	DT
8691	2135	3	of	of	IN
8691	2135	4	the	the	DT
8691	2135	5	States	States	NNPS
8691	2135	6	,	,	,
8691	2135	7	a	a	DT
8691	2135	8	charge	charge	NN
8691	2135	9	to	to	IN
8691	2135	10	the	the	DT
8691	2135	11	effect	effect	NN
8691	2135	12	last	last	RB
8691	2135	13	stated	state	VBN
8691	2135	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	2135	15	now	now	RB
8691	2135	16	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2135	17	required	require	VBN
8691	2135	18	by	by	IN
8691	2135	19	statute	statute	NN
8691	2135	20	.	.	.
8691	2136	1	A	a	DT
8691	2136	2	jury	jury	NN
8691	2136	3	trial	trial	NN
8691	2136	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2136	5	a	a	DT
8691	2136	6	poor	poor	JJ
8691	2136	7	mode	mode	NN
8691	2136	8	of	of	IN
8691	2136	9	doing	do	VBG
8691	2136	10	justice	justice	NN
8691	2136	11	,	,	,
8691	2136	12	if	if	IN
8691	2136	13	there	there	EX
8691	2136	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	2136	15	a	a	DT
8691	2136	16	rule	rule	NN
8691	2136	17	of	of	IN
8691	2136	18	law	law	NN
8691	2136	19	which	which	WDT
8691	2136	20	,	,	,
8691	2136	21	as	as	IN
8691	2136	22	applied	apply	VBN
8691	2136	23	to	to	IN
8691	2136	24	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2136	25	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2136	26	,	,	,
8691	2136	27	should	should	MD
8691	2136	28	control	control	VB
8691	2136	29	the	the	DT
8691	2136	30	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2136	31	,	,	,
8691	2136	32	unless	unless	IN
8691	2136	33	that	that	DT
8691	2136	34	rule	rule	NN
8691	2136	35	of	of	IN
8691	2136	36	law	law	NN
8691	2136	37	be	be	VB
8691	2136	38	both	both	DT
8691	2136	39	stated	state	VBN
8691	2136	40	by	by	IN
8691	2136	41	the	the	DT
8691	2136	42	judge	judge	NN
8691	2136	43	,	,	,
8691	2136	44	and	and	CC
8691	2136	45	so	so	RB
8691	2136	46	stated	state	VBD
8691	2136	47	as	as	IN
8691	2136	48	to	to	TO
8691	2136	49	impress	impress	VB
8691	2136	50	upon	upon	IN
8691	2136	51	the	the	DT
8691	2136	52	jury	jury	NN
8691	2136	53	that	that	IN
8691	2136	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2136	55	is	be	VBZ
8691	2136	56	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2136	57	sworn	swear	VBN
8691	2136	58	duty	duty	NN
8691	2136	59	to	to	TO
8691	2136	60	apply	apply	VB
8691	2136	61	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2136	62	,	,	,
8691	2136	63	if	if	IN
8691	2136	64	the	the	DT
8691	2136	65	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2136	66	which	which	WDT
8691	2136	67	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2136	68	may	may	MD
8691	2136	69	find	find	VB
8691	2136	70	to	to	TO
8691	2136	71	exist	exist	VB
8691	2136	72	are	be	VBP
8691	2136	73	such	such	JJ
8691	2136	74	as	as	IN
8691	2136	75	to	to	TO
8691	2136	76	come	come	VB
8691	2136	77	under	under	IN
8691	2136	78	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2136	79	operation	operation	NN
8691	2136	80	.	.	.
8691	2137	1	That	that	IN
8691	2137	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2137	3	should	should	MD
8691	2137	4	be	be	VB
8691	2137	5	so	so	RB
8691	2137	6	instructed	instruct	VBN
8691	2137	7	,	,	,
8691	2137	8	even	even	RB
8691	2137	9	if	if	IN
8691	2137	10	declared	declare	VBN
8691	2137	11	by	by	IN
8691	2137	12	express	express	JJ
8691	2137	13	statute	statute	NN
8691	2137	14	to	to	TO
8691	2137	15	be	be	VB
8691	2137	16	the	the	DT
8691	2137	17	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2137	18	both	both	DT
8691	2137	19	of	of	IN
8691	2137	20	the	the	DT
8691	2137	21	law	law	NN
8691	2137	22	and	and	CC
8691	2137	23	the	the	DT
8691	2137	24	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2137	25	,	,	,
8691	2137	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	2137	27	the	the	DT
8691	2137	28	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	2137	29	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2137	30	of	of	IN
8691	2137	31	American	american	JJ
8691	2137	32	courts	court	NNS
8691	2137	33	and	and	CC
8691	2137	34	jurists	jurist	NNS
8691	2137	35	.	.	.
8691	2138	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2138	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2138	3	:	:	:
8691	2138	4	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
8691	2138	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2138	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2138	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2138	8	Anthes	Anthes	NNP
8691	2138	9	,	,	,
8691	2138	10	5	5	CD
8691	2138	11	Gray	Gray	NNP
8691	2138	12	's	's	POS
8691	2138	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2138	14	,	,	,
8691	2138	15	185	185	CD
8691	2138	16	;	;	:
8691	2138	17	Sparf	Sparf	NNP
8691	2138	18	_	_	NNP
8691	2138	19	v.	v.	IN
8691	2138	20	_	_	NNP
8691	2138	21	United	United	NNP
8691	2138	22	States	States	NNP
8691	2138	23	,	,	,
8691	2138	24	156	156	CD
8691	2138	25	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2138	26	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2138	27	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2138	28	,	,	,
8691	2138	29	51	51	CD
8691	2138	30	,	,	,
8691	2138	31	71	71	CD
8691	2138	32	.	.	.
8691	2138	33	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2139	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2139	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2139	3	of	of	IN
8691	2139	4	especial	especial	JJ
8691	2139	5	importance	importance	NN
8691	2139	6	that	that	IN
8691	2139	7	the	the	DT
8691	2139	8	duty	duty	NN
8691	2139	9	of	of	IN
8691	2139	10	juries	jury	NNS
8691	2139	11	to	to	TO
8691	2139	12	take	take	VB
8691	2139	13	the	the	DT
8691	2139	14	law	law	NN
8691	2139	15	from	from	IN
8691	2139	16	the	the	DT
8691	2139	17	court	court	NN
8691	2139	18	should	should	MD
8691	2139	19	be	be	VB
8691	2139	20	clearly	clearly	RB
8691	2139	21	stated	state	VBN
8691	2139	22	to	to	IN
8691	2139	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2139	24	in	in	IN
8691	2139	25	a	a	DT
8691	2139	26	country	country	NN
8691	2139	27	of	of	IN
8691	2139	28	written	write	VBN
8691	2139	29	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	2139	30	.	.	.
8691	2140	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	2140	2	crimes	crime	NNS
8691	2140	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2140	4	defined	define	VBN
8691	2140	5	by	by	IN
8691	2140	6	statute	statute	NN
8691	2140	7	.	.	.
8691	2141	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2141	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2141	3	easy	easy	JJ
8691	2141	4	for	for	IN
8691	2141	5	the	the	DT
8691	2141	6	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2141	7	's	's	POS
8691	2141	8	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2141	9	to	to	TO
8691	2141	10	claim	claim	VB
8691	2141	11	that	that	IN
8691	2141	12	the	the	DT
8691	2141	13	statute	statute	NN
8691	2141	14	on	on	IN
8691	2141	15	which	which	WDT
8691	2141	16	the	the	DT
8691	2141	17	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	2141	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	2141	19	based	base	VBN
8691	2141	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	2141	21	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	2141	22	.	.	.
8691	2142	1	If	if	IN
8691	2142	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2142	3	be	be	VBP
8691	2142	4	,	,	,
8691	2142	5	the	the	DT
8691	2142	6	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2142	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2142	8	entitled	entitle	VBN
8691	2142	9	to	to	IN
8691	2142	10	an	an	DT
8691	2142	11	acquittal	acquittal	NN
8691	2142	12	;	;	:
8691	2142	13	but	but	CC
8691	2142	14	if	if	IN
8691	2142	15	the	the	DT
8691	2142	16	jury	jury	NN
8691	2142	17	acquit	acquit	VBD
8691	2142	18	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2142	19	on	on	IN
8691	2142	20	that	that	DT
8691	2142	21	ground	ground	NN
8691	2142	22	,	,	,
8691	2142	23	and	and	CC
8691	2142	24	the	the	DT
8691	2142	25	ground	ground	NN
8691	2142	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	2142	27	false	false	JJ
8691	2142	28	,	,	,
8691	2142	29	injustice	injustice	NN
8691	2142	30	is	be	VBZ
8691	2142	31	done	do	VBN
8691	2142	32	.	.	.
8691	2143	1	Any	any	DT
8691	2143	2	such	such	JJ
8691	2143	3	claim	claim	NN
8691	2143	4	must	must	MD
8691	2143	5	be	be	VB
8691	2143	6	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	2143	7	of	of	IN
8691	2143	8	by	by	IN
8691	2143	9	the	the	DT
8691	2143	10	court	court	NN
8691	2143	11	,	,	,
8691	2143	12	in	in	IN
8691	2143	13	order	order	NN
8691	2143	14	to	to	TO
8691	2143	15	give	give	VB
8691	2143	16	the	the	DT
8691	2143	17	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2143	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2143	19	due	due	JJ
8691	2143	20	supremacy	supremacy	NN
8691	2143	21	.	.	.
8691	2144	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2144	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2144	3	:	:	:
8691	2144	4	State	State	NNP
8691	2144	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2144	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2144	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2144	8	Main	Main	NNP
8691	2144	9	,	,	,
8691	2144	10	69	69	CD
8691	2144	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2144	12	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2144	13	,	,	,
8691	2144	14	123	123	CD
8691	2144	15	,	,	,
8691	2144	16	132	132	CD
8691	2144	17	;	;	:
8691	2144	18	37	37	CD
8691	2144	19	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	2144	20	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2144	21	,	,	,
8691	2144	22	80	80	CD
8691	2144	23	;	;	:
8691	2144	24	61	61	CD
8691	2144	25	American	American	NNP
8691	2144	26	State	State	NNP
8691	2144	27	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2144	28	,	,	,
8691	2144	29	30	30	CD
8691	2144	30	.	.	.
8691	2144	31	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2145	1	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	2145	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2145	3	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
8691	2145	4	of	of	IN
8691	2145	5	the	the	DT
8691	2145	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2145	7	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2145	8	of	of	IN
8691	2145	9	the	the	DT
8691	2145	10	United	United	NNP
8691	2145	11	States	States	NNP
8691	2145	12	came	come	VBD
8691	2145	13	to	to	IN
8691	2145	14	the	the	DT
8691	2145	15	bench	bench	NN
8691	2145	16	,	,	,
8691	2145	17	in	in	IN
8691	2145	18	1829	1829	CD
8691	2145	19	,	,	,
8691	2145	20	strongly	strongly	RB
8691	2145	21	inclined	inclined	JJ
8691	2145	22	to	to	TO
8691	2145	23	minimize	minimize	VB
8691	2145	24	the	the	DT
8691	2145	25	power	power	NN
8691	2145	26	of	of	IN
8691	2145	27	the	the	DT
8691	2145	28	federal	federal	JJ
8691	2145	29	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	2145	30	.	.	.
8691	2146	1	In	in	IN
8691	2146	2	one	one	CD
8691	2146	3	of	of	IN
8691	2146	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2146	5	first	first	JJ
8691	2146	6	cases	case	NNS
8691	2146	7	on	on	IN
8691	2146	8	the	the	DT
8691	2146	9	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	2146	10	,	,	,
8691	2146	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2146	12	charged	charge	VBD
8691	2146	13	the	the	DT
8691	2146	14	jury	jury	NN
8691	2146	15	in	in	IN
8691	2146	16	a	a	DT
8691	2146	17	capital	capital	NN
8691	2146	18	case	case	NN
8691	2146	19	that	that	IN
8691	2146	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2146	21	were	be	VBD
8691	2146	22	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2146	23	of	of	IN
8691	2146	24	both	both	DT
8691	2146	25	law	law	NN
8691	2146	26	and	and	CC
8691	2146	27	fact	fact	NN
8691	2146	28	,	,	,
8691	2146	29	and	and	CC
8691	2146	30	if	if	IN
8691	2146	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2146	32	were	be	VBD
8691	2146	33	prepared	prepared	JJ
8691	2146	34	to	to	TO
8691	2146	35	say	say	VB
8691	2146	36	that	that	IN
8691	2146	37	the	the	DT
8691	2146	38	law	law	NN
8691	2146	39	was	be	VBD
8691	2146	40	different	different	JJ
8691	2146	41	from	from	IN
8691	2146	42	what	what	WP
8691	2146	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2146	44	had	have	VBD
8691	2146	45	stated	state	VBN
8691	2146	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2146	47	to	to	TO
8691	2146	48	be	be	VB
8691	2146	49	,	,	,
8691	2146	50	were	be	VBD
8691	2146	51	not	not	RB
8691	2146	52	bound	bind	VBN
8691	2146	53	by	by	IN
8691	2146	54	the	the	DT
8691	2146	55	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2146	56	of	of	IN
8691	2146	57	the	the	DT
8691	2146	58	court	court	NN
8691	2146	59	.	.	.
8691	2147	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2147	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2147	3	:	:	:
8691	2147	4	United	United	NNP
8691	2147	5	States	States	NNP
8691	2147	6	_	_	NNP
8691	2147	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	2147	8	_	_	NNP
8691	2147	9	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
8691	2147	10	,	,	,
8691	2147	11	1	1	CD
8691	2147	12	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
8691	2147	13	's	's	POS
8691	2147	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2147	15	,	,	,
8691	2147	16	109	109	CD
8691	2147	17	.	.	.
8691	2147	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2148	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2148	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2148	3	not	not	RB
8691	2148	4	long	long	RB
8691	2148	5	before	before	IN
8691	2148	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2148	7	found	find	VBD
8691	2148	8	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2148	9	compelled	compel	VBN
8691	2148	10	to	to	TO
8691	2148	11	retreat	retreat	VB
8691	2148	12	from	from	IN
8691	2148	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2148	14	position	position	NN
8691	2148	15	.	.	.
8691	2149	1	A	a	DT
8691	2149	2	man	man	NN
8691	2149	3	was	be	VBD
8691	2149	4	being	be	VBG
8691	2149	5	tried	try	VBN
8691	2149	6	before	before	IN
8691	2149	7	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2149	8	for	for	IN
8691	2149	9	forging	forge	VBG
8691	2149	10	notes	note	NNS
8691	2149	11	of	of	IN
8691	2149	12	the	the	DT
8691	2149	13	United	United	NNP
8691	2149	14	States	States	NNP
8691	2149	15	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	2149	16	,	,	,
8691	2149	17	and	and	CC
8691	2149	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2149	19	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2149	20	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	2149	21	an	an	DT
8691	2149	22	acquittal	acquittal	NN
8691	2149	23	because	because	IN
8691	2149	24	the	the	DT
8691	2149	25	law	law	NN
8691	2149	26	incorporating	incorporate	VBG
8691	2149	27	the	the	DT
8691	2149	28	bank	bank	NN
8691	2149	29	was	be	VBD
8691	2149	30	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	2149	31	,	,	,
8691	2149	32	reading	read	VBG
8691	2149	33	to	to	TO
8691	2149	34	prove	prove	VB
8691	2149	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2149	36	the	the	DT
8691	2149	37	veto	veto	NN
8691	2149	38	message	message	NN
8691	2149	39	of	of	IN
8691	2149	40	President	President	NNP
8691	2149	41	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	2149	42	,	,	,
8691	2149	43	with	with	IN
8691	2149	44	the	the	DT
8691	2149	45	accompanying	accompany	VBG
8691	2149	46	documents	document	NNS
8691	2149	47	.	.	.
8691	2150	1	To	to	IN
8691	2150	2	the	the	DT
8691	2150	3	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	2150	4	Democrats	Democrats	NNPS
8691	2150	5	on	on	IN
8691	2150	6	the	the	DT
8691	2150	7	panel	panel	NN
8691	2150	8	this	this	DT
8691	2150	9	was	be	VBD
8691	2150	10	quite	quite	PDT
8691	2150	11	an	an	DT
8691	2150	12	imposing	impose	VBG
8691	2150	13	argument	argument	NN
8691	2150	14	,	,	,
8691	2150	15	and	and	CC
8691	2150	16	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	2150	17	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2150	18	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
8691	2150	19	was	be	VBD
8691	2150	20	obliged	oblige	VBN
8691	2150	21	in	in	IN
8691	2150	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2150	23	charge	charge	NN
8691	2150	24	to	to	TO
8691	2150	25	sound	sound	VB
8691	2150	26	the	the	DT
8691	2150	27	warning	warning	NN
8691	2150	28	that	that	IN
8691	2150	29	for	for	IN
8691	2150	30	a	a	DT
8691	2150	31	jury	jury	NN
8691	2150	32	to	to	TO
8691	2150	33	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	2150	34	the	the	DT
8691	2150	35	power	power	NN
8691	2150	36	of	of	IN
8691	2150	37	treating	treat	VBG
8691	2150	38	an	an	DT
8691	2150	39	Act	Act	NNP
8691	2150	40	of	of	IN
8691	2150	41	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	2150	42	as	as	IN
8691	2150	43	invalid	invalid	JJ
8691	2150	44	was	be	VBD
8691	2150	45	virtually	virtually	RB
8691	2150	46	to	to	TO
8691	2150	47	give	give	VB
8691	2150	48	us	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2150	49	a	a	DT
8691	2150	50	country	country	NN
8691	2150	51	without	without	IN
8691	2150	52	a	a	DT
8691	2150	53	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2150	54	and	and	CC
8691	2150	55	without	without	IN
8691	2150	56	laws	law	NNS
8691	2150	57	.	.	.
8691	2151	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2151	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2151	3	:	:	:
8691	2151	4	United	United	NNP
8691	2151	5	States	States	NNP
8691	2151	6	_	_	NNP
8691	2151	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	2151	8	_	_	NNP
8691	2151	9	Sheve	Sheve	NNP
8691	2151	10	,	,	,
8691	2151	11	1	1	CD
8691	2151	12	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
8691	2151	13	's	's	POS
8691	2151	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2151	15	,	,	,
8691	2151	16	510	510	CD
8691	2151	17	,	,	,
8691	2151	18	513	513	CD
8691	2151	19	;	;	:
8691	2151	20	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	2151	21	Law	Law	NNP
8691	2151	22	Journal	Journal	NNP
8691	2151	23	for	for	IN
8691	2151	24	November	November	NNP
8691	2151	25	,	,	,
8691	2151	26	1846	1846	CD
8691	2151	27	,	,	,
8691	2151	28	p.	p.	NN
8691	2152	1	9	9	CD
8691	2152	2	.	.	.
8691	2152	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2153	1	In	in	IN
8691	2153	2	one	one	CD
8691	2153	3	of	of	IN
8691	2153	4	the	the	DT
8691	2153	5	Southern	Southern	NNP
8691	2153	6	States	States	NNPS
8691	2153	7	where	where	WRB
8691	2153	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2153	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	2153	10	a	a	DT
8691	2153	11	statutory	statutory	JJ
8691	2153	12	right	right	NN
8691	2153	13	to	to	TO
8691	2153	14	demand	demand	VB
8691	2153	15	instructions	instruction	NNS
8691	2153	16	that	that	WDT
8691	2153	17	the	the	DT
8691	2153	18	jury	jury	NN
8691	2153	19	are	be	VBP
8691	2153	20	the	the	DT
8691	2153	21	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2153	22	of	of	IN
8691	2153	23	the	the	DT
8691	2153	24	law	law	NN
8691	2153	25	,	,	,
8691	2153	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2153	27	was	be	VBD
8691	2153	28	the	the	DT
8691	2153	29	custom	custom	NN
8691	2153	30	of	of	IN
8691	2153	31	a	a	DT
8691	2153	32	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2153	33	trial	trial	NN
8691	2153	34	judge	judge	NN
8691	2153	35	of	of	IN
8691	2153	36	commanding	commanding	NN
8691	2153	37	presence	presence	NN
8691	2153	38	,	,	,
8691	2153	39	when	when	WRB
8691	2153	40	called	call	VBN
8691	2153	41	upon	upon	IN
8691	2153	42	to	to	TO
8691	2153	43	give	give	VB
8691	2153	44	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2153	45	,	,	,
8691	2153	46	to	to	TO
8691	2153	47	say	say	VB
8691	2153	48	to	to	IN
8691	2153	49	the	the	DT
8691	2153	50	jury	jury	NN
8691	2153	51	after	after	IN
8691	2153	52	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2153	53	had	have	VBD
8691	2153	54	done	do	VBN
8691	2153	55	so	so	RB
8691	2153	56	,	,	,
8691	2153	57	rising	rise	VBG
8691	2153	58	to	to	IN
8691	2153	59	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2153	60	full	full	JJ
8691	2153	61	height	height	NN
8691	2153	62	,	,	,
8691	2153	63	"	"	''
8691	2153	64	But	but	CC
8691	2153	65	,	,	,
8691	2153	66	gentlemen	gentleman	NNS
8691	2153	67	,	,	,
8691	2153	68	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2153	69	must	must	MD
8691	2153	70	recollect	recollect	VB
8691	2153	71	that	that	IN
8691	2153	72	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2153	73	have	have	VBP
8691	2153	74	told	tell	VBN
8691	2153	75	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2153	76	what	what	WP
8691	2153	77	the	the	DT
8691	2153	78	law	law	NN
8691	2153	79	that	that	WDT
8691	2153	80	governs	govern	VBZ
8691	2153	81	this	this	DT
8691	2153	82	case	case	NN
8691	2153	83	is	be	VBZ
8691	2153	84	,	,	,
8691	2153	85	and	and	CC
8691	2153	86	to	to	IN
8691	2153	87	this	this	DT
8691	2153	88	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2153	89	am	be	VBP
8691	2153	90	the	the	DT
8691	2153	91	only	only	JJ
8691	2153	92	witness	witness	NN
8691	2153	93	who	who	WP
8691	2153	94	has	have	VBZ
8691	2153	95	appeared	appear	VBN
8691	2153	96	or	or	CC
8691	2153	97	could	could	MD
8691	2153	98	appear	appear	VB
8691	2153	99	.	.	.
8691	2153	100	"	"	''
8691	2154	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2154	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2154	3	one	one	CD
8691	2154	4	of	of	IN
8691	2154	5	the	the	DT
8691	2154	6	acute	acute	JJ
8691	2154	7	observations	observation	NNS
8691	2154	8	of	of	IN
8691	2154	9	Alexander	Alexander	NNP
8691	2154	10	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
8691	2154	11	that	that	IN
8691	2154	12	under	under	IN
8691	2154	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2154	14	American	American	NNP
8691	2154	15	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	2154	16	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2154	17	are	be	VBP
8691	2154	18	less	less	JJR
8691	2154	19	to	to	TO
8691	2154	20	be	be	VB
8691	2154	21	relied	rely	VBN
8691	2154	22	on	on	RP
8691	2154	23	by	by	IN
8691	2154	24	one	one	CD
8691	2154	25	who	who	WP
8691	2154	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	2154	27	attacked	attack	VBN
8691	2154	28	by	by	IN
8691	2154	29	the	the	DT
8691	2154	30	government	government	NN
8691	2154	31	,	,	,
8691	2154	32	because	because	IN
8691	2154	33	those	those	DT
8691	2154	34	who	who	WP
8691	2154	35	direct	direct	VBP
8691	2154	36	the	the	DT
8691	2154	37	government	government	NN
8691	2154	38	are	be	VBP
8691	2154	39	the	the	DT
8691	2154	40	choice	choice	NN
8691	2154	41	of	of	IN
8691	2154	42	the	the	DT
8691	2154	43	people	people	NNS
8691	2154	44	,	,	,
8691	2154	45	and	and	CC
8691	2154	46	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	2154	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2154	48	do	do	VBP
8691	2154	49	is	be	VBZ
8691	2154	50	presumably	presumably	RB
8691	2154	51	popular	popular	JJ
8691	2154	52	.	.	.
8691	2155	1	The	the	DT
8691	2155	2	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	2155	3	,	,	,
8691	2155	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2155	5	said	say	VBD
8691	2155	6	,	,	,
8691	2155	7	was	be	VBD
8691	2155	8	less	less	RBR
8691	2155	9	independent	independent	JJ
8691	2155	10	here	here	RB
8691	2155	11	than	than	IN
8691	2155	12	in	in	IN
8691	2155	13	England	England	NNP
8691	2155	14	,	,	,
8691	2155	15	and	and	CC
8691	2155	16	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	2155	17	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2155	18	had	have	VBD
8691	2155	19	the	the	DT
8691	2155	20	more	more	JJR
8691	2155	21	reason	reason	NN
8691	2155	22	to	to	TO
8691	2155	23	cling	cling	VB
8691	2155	24	to	to	IN
8691	2155	25	the	the	DT
8691	2155	26	trial	trial	NN
8691	2155	27	by	by	IN
8691	2155	28	Jury	Jury	NNP
8691	2155	29	and	and	CC
8691	2155	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2155	31	power	power	NN
8691	2155	32	to	to	TO
8691	2155	33	render	render	VB
8691	2155	34	general	general	JJ
8691	2155	35	verdicts	verdict	NNS
8691	2155	36	as	as	IN
8691	2155	37	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2155	38	greatest	great	JJS
8691	2155	39	safety	safety	NN
8691	2155	40	.	.	.
8691	2156	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2156	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2156	3	:	:	:
8691	2156	4	People	People	NNS
8691	2156	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2156	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2156	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2156	8	Croswell	Croswell	NNP
8691	2156	9	,	,	,
8691	2156	10	3	3	CD
8691	2156	11	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	2156	12	's	's	POS
8691	2156	13	Cases	case	NNS
8691	2156	14	,	,	,
8691	2156	15	337	337	CD
8691	2156	16	,	,	,
8691	2156	17	353	353	CD
8691	2156	18	.	.	.
8691	2156	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2157	1	The	the	DT
8691	2157	2	States	state	NNS
8691	2157	3	which	which	WDT
8691	2157	4	guard	guard	VBP
8691	2157	5	these	these	DT
8691	2157	6	most	most	RBS
8691	2157	7	closely	closely	RB
8691	2157	8	are	be	VBP
8691	2157	9	those	those	DT
8691	2157	10	in	in	IN
8691	2157	11	which	which	WDT
8691	2157	12	there	there	EX
8691	2157	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	2157	14	the	the	DT
8691	2157	15	most	most	JJS
8691	2157	16	jealousy	jealousy	NN
8691	2157	17	of	of	IN
8691	2157	18	anything	anything	NN
8691	2157	19	like	like	IN
8691	2157	20	a	a	DT
8691	2157	21	standing	stand	VBG
8691	2157	22	order	order	NN
8691	2157	23	,	,	,
8691	2157	24	and	and	CC
8691	2157	25	the	the	DT
8691	2157	26	widest	wide	JJS
8691	2157	27	scope	scope	NN
8691	2157	28	of	of	IN
8691	2157	29	popular	popular	JJ
8691	2157	30	election	election	NN
8691	2157	31	.	.	.
8691	2158	1	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	2158	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2158	3	the	the	DT
8691	2158	4	State	State	NNP
8691	2158	5	,	,	,
8691	2158	6	among	among	IN
8691	2158	7	the	the	DT
8691	2158	8	old	old	JJ
8691	2158	9	thirteen	thirteen	CD
8691	2158	10	,	,	,
8691	2158	11	in	in	IN
8691	2158	12	which	which	WDT
8691	2158	13	these	these	DT
8691	2158	14	characteristics	characteristic	NNS
8691	2158	15	were	be	VBD
8691	2158	16	most	most	RBS
8691	2158	17	marked	marked	JJ
8691	2158	18	.	.	.
8691	2159	1	Her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2159	2	first	first	JJ
8691	2159	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2159	4	of	of	IN
8691	2159	5	1777	1777	CD
8691	2159	6	expressly	expressly	RB
8691	2159	7	threw	throw	VBD
8691	2159	8	the	the	DT
8691	2159	9	power	power	NN
8691	2159	10	of	of	IN
8691	2159	11	determining	determine	VBG
8691	2159	12	the	the	DT
8691	2159	13	law	law	NN
8691	2159	14	into	into	IN
8691	2159	15	the	the	DT
8691	2159	16	hands	hand	NNS
8691	2159	17	of	of	IN
8691	2159	18	the	the	DT
8691	2159	19	jury	jury	NN
8691	2159	20	in	in	IN
8691	2159	21	every	every	DT
8691	2159	22	case	case	NN
8691	2159	23	,	,	,
8691	2159	24	though	though	IN
8691	2159	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2159	26	were	be	VBD
8691	2159	27	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2159	28	to	to	TO
8691	2159	29	ask	ask	VB
8691	2159	30	the	the	DT
8691	2159	31	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2159	32	holding	hold	VBG
8691	2159	33	the	the	DT
8691	2159	34	court	court	NN
8691	2159	35	for	for	IN
8691	2159	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2159	37	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2159	38	,	,	,
8691	2159	39	in	in	IN
8691	2159	40	which	which	WDT
8691	2159	41	case	case	NN
8691	2159	42	each	each	DT
8691	2159	43	judge	judge	NN
8691	2159	44	gave	give	VBD
8691	2159	45	his	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2159	46	in	in	IN
8691	2159	47	rotation	rotation	NN
8691	2159	48	.	.	.
8691	2160	1	The	the	DT
8691	2160	2	party	party	NN
8691	2160	3	who	who	WP
8691	2160	4	lost	lose	VBD
8691	2160	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2160	6	case	case	NN
8691	2160	7	could	could	MD
8691	2160	8	demand	demand	VB
8691	2160	9	a	a	DT
8691	2160	10	new	new	JJ
8691	2160	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	2160	12	before	before	IN
8691	2160	13	a	a	DT
8691	2160	14	special	special	JJ
8691	2160	15	jury	jury	NN
8691	2160	16	.	.	.
8691	2161	1	The	the	DT
8691	2161	2	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	2161	3	jury	jury	NN
8691	2161	4	were	be	VBD
8691	2161	5	to	to	TO
8691	2161	6	be	be	VB
8691	2161	7	sworn	swear	VBN
8691	2161	8	to	to	TO
8691	2161	9	bring	bring	VB
8691	2161	10	in	in	RP
8691	2161	11	a	a	DT
8691	2161	12	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2161	13	according	accord	VBG
8691	2161	14	to	to	IN
8691	2161	15	law	law	NN
8691	2161	16	and	and	CC
8691	2161	17	the	the	DT
8691	2161	18	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2161	19	,	,	,
8691	2161	20	provided	provide	VBN
8691	2161	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2161	22	be	be	VB
8691	2161	23	not	not	RB
8691	2161	24	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
8691	2161	25	to	to	IN
8691	2161	26	the	the	DT
8691	2161	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2161	28	.	.	.
8691	2162	1	The	the	DT
8691	2162	2	special	special	JJ
8691	2162	3	jury	jury	NN
8691	2162	4	were	be	VBD
8691	2162	5	to	to	TO
8691	2162	6	be	be	VB
8691	2162	7	sworn	swear	VBN
8691	2162	8	to	to	TO
8691	2162	9	bring	bring	VB
8691	2162	10	one	one	NN
8691	2162	11	in	in	IN
8691	2162	12	according	accord	VBG
8691	2162	13	to	to	IN
8691	2162	14	law	law	NN
8691	2162	15	and	and	CC
8691	2162	16	the	the	DT
8691	2162	17	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2162	18	,	,	,
8691	2162	19	"	"	''
8691	2162	20	provided	provide	VBN
8691	2162	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2162	22	be	be	VB
8691	2162	23	not	not	RB
8691	2162	24	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
8691	2162	25	to	to	IN
8691	2162	26	justice	justice	NN
8691	2162	27	,	,	,
8691	2162	28	equity	equity	NN
8691	2162	29	,	,	,
8691	2162	30	and	and	CC
8691	2162	31	conscience	conscience	NN
8691	2162	32	,	,	,
8691	2162	33	and	and	CC
8691	2162	34	the	the	DT
8691	2162	35	rules	rule	NNS
8691	2162	36	and	and	CC
8691	2162	37	regulations	regulation	NNS
8691	2162	38	contained	contain	VBN
8691	2162	39	in	in	IN
8691	2162	40	this	this	DT
8691	2162	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2162	42	,	,	,
8691	2162	43	of	of	IN
8691	2162	44	which	which	WDT
8691	2162	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2162	46	shall	shall	MD
8691	2162	47	judge	judge	VB
8691	2162	48	.	.	.
8691	2162	49	"	"	''
8691	2163	1	Apparently	apparently	RB
8691	2163	2	the	the	DT
8691	2163	3	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	2163	4	of	of	IN
8691	2163	5	this	this	DT
8691	2163	6	was	be	VBD
8691	2163	7	that	that	IN
8691	2163	8	while	while	IN
8691	2163	9	the	the	DT
8691	2163	10	decision	decision	NN
8691	2163	11	of	of	IN
8691	2163	12	the	the	DT
8691	2163	13	first	first	JJ
8691	2163	14	jury	jury	NN
8691	2163	15	as	as	IN
8691	2163	16	to	to	IN
8691	2163	17	the	the	DT
8691	2163	18	law	law	NN
8691	2163	19	could	could	MD
8691	2163	20	be	be	VB
8691	2163	21	revised	revise	VBN
8691	2163	22	by	by	IN
8691	2163	23	a	a	DT
8691	2163	24	second	second	NN
8691	2163	25	,	,	,
8691	2163	26	that	that	DT
8691	2163	27	of	of	IN
8691	2163	28	the	the	DT
8691	2163	29	second	second	JJ
8691	2163	30	,	,	,
8691	2163	31	however	however	RB
8691	2163	32	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	2163	33	to	to	IN
8691	2163	34	the	the	DT
8691	2163	35	highest	high	JJS
8691	2163	36	law	law	NN
8691	2163	37	,	,	,
8691	2163	38	could	could	MD
8691	2163	39	not	not	RB
8691	2163	40	be	be	VB
8691	2163	41	.	.	.
8691	2164	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2164	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2164	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2164	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2164	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2164	6	Resort	Resort	NNP
8691	2164	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2164	8	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	2164	9	had	have	VBN
8691	2164	10	to	to	IN
8691	2164	11	the	the	DT
8691	2164	12	assistance	assistance	NN
8691	2164	13	of	of	IN
8691	2164	14	a	a	DT
8691	2164	15	jury	jury	NN
8691	2164	16	by	by	IN
8691	2164	17	a	a	DT
8691	2164	18	court	court	NN
8691	2164	19	of	of	IN
8691	2164	20	chancery	chancery	NN
8691	2164	21	for	for	IN
8691	2164	22	the	the	DT
8691	2164	23	better	well	JJR
8691	2164	24	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	2164	25	of	of	IN
8691	2164	26	some	some	DT
8691	2164	27	disputed	dispute	VBN
8691	2164	28	question	question	NN
8691	2164	29	of	of	IN
8691	2164	30	fact	fact	NN
8691	2164	31	on	on	IN
8691	2164	32	which	which	WDT
8691	2164	33	the	the	DT
8691	2164	34	equities	equity	NNS
8691	2164	35	of	of	IN
8691	2164	36	the	the	DT
8691	2164	37	parties	party	NNS
8691	2164	38	depend	depend	VBP
8691	2164	39	.	.	.
8691	2165	1	This	this	DT
8691	2165	2	can	can	MD
8691	2165	3	not	not	RB
8691	2165	4	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2165	5	except	except	IN
8691	2165	6	by	by	IN
8691	2165	7	force	force	NN
8691	2165	8	of	of	IN
8691	2165	9	some	some	DT
8691	2165	10	express	express	JJ
8691	2165	11	statute	statute	NN
8691	2165	12	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2165	13	be	be	VB
8691	2165	14	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	2165	15	as	as	IN
8691	2165	16	a	a	DT
8691	2165	17	matter	matter	NN
8691	2165	18	of	of	IN
8691	2165	19	right	right	JJ
8691	2165	20	.	.	.
8691	2166	1	The	the	DT
8691	2166	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	2166	3	sends	send	VBZ
8691	2166	4	the	the	DT
8691	2166	5	issue	issue	NN
8691	2166	6	to	to	IN
8691	2166	7	a	a	DT
8691	2166	8	jury	jury	NN
8691	2166	9	for	for	IN
8691	2166	10	trial	trial	NN
8691	2166	11	only	only	RB
8691	2166	12	if	if	IN
8691	2166	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2166	14	thinks	think	VBZ
8691	2166	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2166	16	would	would	MD
8691	2166	17	be	be	VB
8691	2166	18	helpful	helpful	JJ
8691	2166	19	to	to	IN
8691	2166	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2166	21	,	,	,
8691	2166	22	but	but	CC
8691	2166	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2166	24	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2166	25	has	have	VBZ
8691	2166	26	no	no	DT
8691	2166	27	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	2166	28	effect	effect	NN
8691	2166	29	.	.	.
8691	2167	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2167	2	can	can	MD
8691	2167	3	adopt	adopt	VB
8691	2167	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2167	5	or	or	CC
8691	2167	6	ignore	ignore	VB
8691	2167	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2167	8	,	,	,
8691	2167	9	at	at	IN
8691	2167	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2167	11	pleasure	pleasure	NN
8691	2167	12	.	.	.
8691	2168	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2168	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2168	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2168	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2168	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2168	6	The	the	DT
8691	2168	7	selection	selection	NN
8691	2168	8	of	of	IN
8691	2168	9	jurors	juror	NNS
8691	2168	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2168	11	a	a	DT
8691	2168	12	long	long	JJ
8691	2168	13	process	process	NN
8691	2168	14	.	.	.
8691	2169	1	The	the	DT
8691	2169	2	general	general	JJ
8691	2169	3	plan	plan	NN
8691	2169	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2169	5	to	to	TO
8691	2169	6	commit	commit	VB
8691	2169	7	to	to	IN
8691	2169	8	some	some	DT
8691	2169	9	local	local	JJ
8691	2169	10	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	2169	11	in	in	IN
8691	2169	12	each	each	DT
8691	2169	13	city	city	NN
8691	2169	14	,	,	,
8691	2169	15	town	town	NN
8691	2169	16	,	,	,
8691	2169	17	or	or	CC
8691	2169	18	county	county	NNP
8691	2169	19	the	the	DT
8691	2169	20	choice	choice	NN
8691	2169	21	of	of	IN
8691	2169	22	a	a	DT
8691	2169	23	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2169	24	number	number	NN
8691	2169	25	out	out	IN
8691	2169	26	of	of	IN
8691	2169	27	the	the	DT
8691	2169	28	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
8691	2169	29	whom	whom	WP
8691	2169	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2169	31	may	may	MD
8691	2169	32	think	think	VB
8691	2169	33	suitable	suitable	JJ
8691	2169	34	to	to	TO
8691	2169	35	serve	serve	VB
8691	2169	36	in	in	IN
8691	2169	37	that	that	DT
8691	2169	38	capacity	capacity	NN
8691	2169	39	;	;	:
8691	2169	40	then	then	RB
8691	2169	41	to	to	TO
8691	2169	42	have	have	VB
8691	2169	43	that	that	DT
8691	2169	44	list	list	NN
8691	2169	45	revised	revise	VBN
8691	2169	46	by	by	IN
8691	2169	47	some	some	DT
8691	2169	48	higher	high	JJR
8691	2169	49	officials	official	NNS
8691	2169	50	or	or	CC
8691	2169	51	persons	person	NNS
8691	2169	52	specially	specially	RB
8691	2169	53	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	2169	54	by	by	IN
8691	2169	55	the	the	DT
8691	2169	56	courts	court	NNS
8691	2169	57	for	for	IN
8691	2169	58	the	the	DT
8691	2169	59	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2169	60	,	,	,
8691	2169	61	who	who	WP
8691	2169	62	must	must	MD
8691	2169	63	strike	strike	VB
8691	2169	64	out	out	RP
8691	2169	65	a	a	DT
8691	2169	66	large	large	JJ
8691	2169	67	part	part	NN
8691	2169	68	of	of	IN
8691	2169	69	the	the	DT
8691	2169	70	names	name	NNS
8691	2169	71	;	;	:
8691	2169	72	and	and	CC
8691	2169	73	finally	finally	RB
8691	2169	74	to	to	TO
8691	2169	75	have	have	VB
8691	2169	76	those	those	DT
8691	2169	77	who	who	WP
8691	2169	78	are	be	VBP
8691	2169	79	to	to	TO
8691	2169	80	be	be	VB
8691	2169	81	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	2169	82	to	to	TO
8691	2169	83	attend	attend	VB
8691	2169	84	any	any	DT
8691	2169	85	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2169	86	term	term	NN
8691	2169	87	of	of	IN
8691	2169	88	court	court	NN
8691	2169	89	for	for	IN
8691	2169	90	jury	jury	NN
8691	2169	91	duty	duty	NN
8691	2169	92	chosen	choose	VBN
8691	2169	93	by	by	IN
8691	2169	94	drawing	draw	VBG
8691	2169	95	from	from	IN
8691	2169	96	the	the	DT
8691	2169	97	remaining	remain	VBG
8691	2169	98	names	name	NNS
8691	2169	99	by	by	IN
8691	2169	100	lot	lot	NN
8691	2169	101	.	.	.
8691	2170	1	In	in	IN
8691	2170	2	many	many	JJ
8691	2170	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2170	4	special	special	JJ
8691	2170	5	qualifications	qualification	NNS
8691	2170	6	as	as	IN
8691	2170	7	to	to	IN
8691	2170	8	age	age	NN
8691	2170	9	,	,	,
8691	2170	10	education	education	NN
8691	2170	11	,	,	,
8691	2170	12	and	and	CC
8691	2170	13	intelligence	intelligence	NN
8691	2170	14	are	be	VBP
8691	2170	15	required	require	VBN
8691	2170	16	.	.	.
8691	2171	1	Out	out	IN
8691	2171	2	of	of	IN
8691	2171	3	the	the	DT
8691	2171	4	jurors	juror	NNS
8691	2171	5	thus	thus	RB
8691	2171	6	summoned	summon	VBD
8691	2171	7	to	to	TO
8691	2171	8	attend	attend	VB
8691	2171	9	the	the	DT
8691	2171	10	court	court	NN
8691	2171	11	,	,	,
8691	2171	12	there	there	EX
8691	2171	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	2171	14	a	a	DT
8691	2171	15	further	further	JJ
8691	2171	16	choice	choice	NN
8691	2171	17	by	by	IN
8691	2171	18	lot	lot	NN
8691	2171	19	of	of	IN
8691	2171	20	those	those	DT
8691	2171	21	to	to	TO
8691	2171	22	try	try	VB
8691	2171	23	each	each	DT
8691	2171	24	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2171	25	case	case	NN
8691	2171	26	,	,	,
8691	2171	27	subject	subject	JJ
8691	2171	28	to	to	IN
8691	2171	29	objections	objection	NNS
8691	2171	30	made	make	VBN
8691	2171	31	by	by	IN
8691	2171	32	either	either	DT
8691	2171	33	party	party	NN
8691	2171	34	to	to	IN
8691	2171	35	any	any	DT
8691	2171	36	thus	thus	RB
8691	2171	37	drawn	draw	VBN
8691	2171	38	,	,	,
8691	2171	39	for	for	IN
8691	2171	40	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2171	41	cause	cause	NN
8691	2171	42	.	.	.
8691	2172	1	The	the	DT
8691	2172	2	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2172	3	of	of	IN
8691	2172	4	the	the	DT
8691	2172	5	United	United	NNP
8691	2172	6	States	States	NNP
8691	2172	7	provide	provide	VBP
8691	2172	8	that	that	IN
8691	2172	9	jurors	juror	NNS
8691	2172	10	in	in	IN
8691	2172	11	the	the	DT
8691	2172	12	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	2172	13	and	and	CC
8691	2172	14	District	District	NNP
8691	2172	15	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	2172	16	shall	shall	MD
8691	2172	17	be	be	VB
8691	2172	18	selected	select	VBN
8691	2172	19	in	in	IN
8691	2172	20	each	each	DT
8691	2172	21	State	state	NN
8691	2172	22	from	from	IN
8691	2172	23	those	those	DT
8691	2172	24	qualified	qualified	JJ
8691	2172	25	to	to	TO
8691	2172	26	serve	serve	VB
8691	2172	27	in	in	IN
8691	2172	28	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2172	29	highest	high	JJS
8691	2172	30	trial	trial	NN
8691	2172	31	courts	court	NNS
8691	2172	32	,	,	,
8691	2172	33	and	and	CC
8691	2172	34	in	in	IN
8691	2172	35	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	2172	36	the	the	DT
8691	2172	37	same	same	JJ
8691	2172	38	manner	manner	NN
8691	2172	39	.	.	.
8691	2173	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2173	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2173	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2173	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2173	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2173	6	The	the	DT
8691	2173	7	right	right	NN
8691	2173	8	to	to	IN
8691	2173	9	a	a	DT
8691	2173	10	jury	jury	NN
8691	2173	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	2173	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2173	13	in	in	IN
8691	2173	14	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2173	15	actions	action	NNS
8691	2173	16	often	often	RB
8691	2173	17	waived	waive	VBN
8691	2173	18	by	by	IN
8691	2173	19	both	both	DT
8691	2173	20	parties	party	NNS
8691	2173	21	,	,	,
8691	2173	22	in	in	IN
8691	2173	23	which	which	WDT
8691	2173	24	case	case	NN
8691	2173	25	the	the	DT
8691	2173	26	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2173	27	as	as	RB
8691	2173	28	well	well	RB
8691	2173	29	as	as	IN
8691	2173	30	the	the	DT
8691	2173	31	law	law	NN
8691	2173	32	are	be	VBP
8691	2173	33	determined	determine	VBN
8691	2173	34	by	by	IN
8691	2173	35	the	the	DT
8691	2173	36	judge	judge	NN
8691	2173	37	.	.	.
8691	2174	1	If	if	IN
8691	2174	2	not	not	RB
8691	2174	3	expressly	expressly	RB
8691	2174	4	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	2174	5	,	,	,
8691	2174	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2174	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2174	8	by	by	IN
8691	2174	9	the	the	DT
8691	2174	10	rules	rule	NNS
8691	2174	11	of	of	IN
8691	2174	12	practice	practice	NN
8691	2174	13	in	in	IN
8691	2174	14	some	some	DT
8691	2174	15	States	States	NNP
8691	2174	16	treated	treat	VBD
8691	2174	17	as	as	IN
8691	2174	18	waived	waive	VBN
8691	2174	19	.	.	.
8691	2175	1	The	the	DT
8691	2175	2	number	number	NN
8691	2175	3	of	of	IN
8691	2175	4	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2175	5	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2175	6	tried	try	VBD
8691	2175	7	to	to	IN
8691	2175	8	the	the	DT
8691	2175	9	jury	jury	NN
8691	2175	10	,	,	,
8691	2175	11	taking	take	VBG
8691	2175	12	the	the	DT
8691	2175	13	country	country	NN
8691	2175	14	as	as	IN
8691	2175	15	a	a	DT
8691	2175	16	whole	whole	NN
8691	2175	17	,	,	,
8691	2175	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	2175	19	declining	decline	VBG
8691	2175	20	.	.	.
8691	2176	1	The	the	DT
8691	2176	2	decline	decline	NN
8691	2176	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2176	4	generally	generally	RB
8691	2176	5	found	find	VBN
8691	2176	6	to	to	TO
8691	2176	7	be	be	VB
8691	2176	8	quite	quite	RB
8691	2176	9	accurately	accurately	RB
8691	2176	10	proportioned	proportion	VBN
8691	2176	11	to	to	IN
8691	2176	12	the	the	DT
8691	2176	13	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	2176	14	felt	feel	VBN
8691	2176	15	by	by	IN
8691	2176	16	the	the	DT
8691	2176	17	bar	bar	NN
8691	2176	18	in	in	IN
8691	2176	19	the	the	DT
8691	2176	20	ability	ability	NN
8691	2176	21	and	and	CC
8691	2176	22	independence	independence	NN
8691	2176	23	of	of	IN
8691	2176	24	the	the	DT
8691	2176	25	judge,[Footnote	judge,[footnote	CD
8691	2176	26	:	:	:
8691	2176	27	See	see	VB
8691	2176	28	Paper	Paper	NNP
8691	2176	29	by	by	IN
8691	2176	30	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2176	31	Henry	Henry	NNP
8691	2176	32	B.	B.	NNP
8691	2177	1	Brown	Brown	NNP
8691	2177	2	,	,	,
8691	2177	3	in	in	IN
8691	2177	4	the	the	DT
8691	2177	5	American	American	NNP
8691	2177	6	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	2177	7	Association	Association	NNP
8691	2177	8	Report	Report	NNP
8691	2177	9	for	for	IN
8691	2177	10	1889	1889	CD
8691	2177	11	,	,	,
8691	2177	12	p.	p.	NN
8691	2177	13	265	265	CD
8691	2177	14	,	,	,
8691	2177	15	on	on	IN
8691	2177	16	"	"	``
8691	2177	17	Judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2177	18	Independence	independence	NN
8691	2177	19	.	.	.
8691	2177	20	"	"	''
8691	2177	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2178	1	or	or	CC
8691	2178	2	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	2178	3	to	to	IN
8691	2178	4	that	that	DT
8691	2178	5	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	2178	6	in	in	IN
8691	2178	7	the	the	DT
8691	2178	8	case	case	NN
8691	2178	9	of	of	IN
8691	2178	10	a	a	DT
8691	2178	11	former	former	JJ
8691	2178	12	generation	generation	NN
8691	2178	13	.	.	.
8691	2179	1	Tradition	tradition	NN
8691	2179	2	and	and	CC
8691	2179	3	custom	custom	NN
8691	2179	4	have	have	VBP
8691	2179	5	a	a	DT
8691	2179	6	large	large	JJ
8691	2179	7	influence	influence	NN
8691	2179	8	on	on	IN
8691	2179	9	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	2179	10	pertains	pertain	VBZ
8691	2179	11	to	to	IN
8691	2179	12	the	the	DT
8691	2179	13	practice	practice	NN
8691	2179	14	of	of	IN
8691	2179	15	law	law	NN
8691	2179	16	.	.	.
8691	2180	1	In	in	IN
8691	2180	2	several	several	JJ
8691	2180	3	of	of	IN
8691	2180	4	the	the	DT
8691	2180	5	States	States	NNPS
8691	2180	6	a	a	DT
8691	2180	7	majority	majority	NN
8691	2180	8	of	of	IN
8691	2180	9	the	the	DT
8691	2180	10	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2180	11	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2180	12	which	which	WDT
8691	2180	13	might	may	MD
8691	2180	14	be	be	VB
8691	2180	15	tried	try	VBN
8691	2180	16	to	to	IN
8691	2180	17	the	the	DT
8691	2180	18	jury	jury	NN
8691	2180	19	are	be	VBP
8691	2180	20	not	not	RB
8691	2180	21	:	:	:
8691	2180	22	in	in	IN
8691	2180	23	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	2180	24	very	very	RB
8691	2180	25	few	few	JJ
8691	2180	26	are	be	VBP
8691	2180	27	.	.	.
8691	2181	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2181	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2181	3	:	:	:
8691	2181	4	See	see	VB
8691	2181	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	2181	6	.	.	.
8691	2182	1	XXIV	XXIV	NNP
8691	2182	2	.	.	.
8691	2182	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2183	1	The	the	DT
8691	2183	2	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	2183	3	in	in	IN
8691	2183	4	England	England	NNP
8691	2183	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2183	6	also	also	RB
8691	2183	7	toward	toward	IN
8691	2183	8	dispensing	dispense	VBG
8691	2183	9	with	with	IN
8691	2183	10	the	the	DT
8691	2183	11	jury	jury	NN
8691	2183	12	in	in	IN
8691	2183	13	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	2183	14	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2183	15	trials	trial	NNS
8691	2183	16	.	.	.
8691	2184	1	Over	over	IN
8691	2184	2	a	a	DT
8691	2184	3	million	million	CD
8691	2184	4	cases	case	NNS
8691	2184	5	are	be	VBP
8691	2184	6	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2184	7	every	every	DT
8691	2184	8	year	year	NN
8691	2184	9	in	in	IN
8691	2184	10	the	the	DT
8691	2184	11	English	English	NNP
8691	2184	12	county	county	NN
8691	2184	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	2184	14	,	,	,
8691	2184	15	and	and	CC
8691	2184	16	in	in	IN
8691	2184	17	not	not	RB
8691	2184	18	one	one	CD
8691	2184	19	in	in	IN
8691	2184	20	a	a	DT
8691	2184	21	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	2184	22	of	of	IN
8691	2184	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2184	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	2184	25	there	there	EX
8691	2184	26	a	a	DT
8691	2184	27	jury	jury	NN
8691	2184	28	trial	trial	NN
8691	2184	29	,	,	,
8691	2184	30	although	although	IN
8691	2184	31	if	if	IN
8691	2184	32	the	the	DT
8691	2184	33	matter	matter	NN
8691	2184	34	in	in	IN
8691	2184	35	demand	demand	NN
8691	2184	36	is	be	VBZ
8691	2184	37	over	over	IN
8691	2184	38	£5	â£5	NN
8691	2184	39	in	in	IN
8691	2184	40	value	value	NN
8691	2184	41	either	either	CC
8691	2184	42	party	party	NN
8691	2184	43	may	may	MD
8691	2184	44	claim	claim	VB
8691	2184	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2184	46	.	.	.
8691	2185	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2185	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2185	3	:	:	:
8691	2185	4	Maitland	Maitland	NNP
8691	2185	5	,	,	,
8691	2185	6	"	"	''
8691	2185	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2185	8	and	and	CC
8691	2185	9	Police	Police	NNPS
8691	2185	10	,	,	,
8691	2185	11	"	"	''
8691	2185	12	28	28	CD
8691	2185	13	,	,	,
8691	2185	14	29	29	CD
8691	2185	15	,	,	,
8691	2185	16	54	54	CD
8691	2185	17	.	.	.
8691	2186	1	For	for	IN
8691	2186	2	small	small	JJ
8691	2186	3	cases	case	NNS
8691	2186	4	the	the	DT
8691	2186	5	jury	jury	NN
8691	2186	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2186	7	one	one	CD
8691	2186	8	of	of	IN
8691	2186	9	five	five	CD
8691	2186	10	,	,	,
8691	2186	11	but	but	CC
8691	2186	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2186	13	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2186	14	must	must	MD
8691	2186	15	be	be	VB
8691	2186	16	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
8691	2186	17	.	.	.
8691	2186	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2187	1	Criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2187	2	trials	trial	NNS
8691	2187	3	,	,	,
8691	2187	4	except	except	IN
8691	2187	5	in	in	IN
8691	2187	6	case	case	NN
8691	2187	7	of	of	IN
8691	2187	8	trivial	trivial	JJ
8691	2187	9	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	2187	10	,	,	,
8691	2187	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2187	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2187	13	generally	generally	RB
8691	2187	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2187	15	to	to	TO
8691	2187	16	hold	hold	VB
8691	2187	17	before	before	IN
8691	2187	18	a	a	DT
8691	2187	19	jury	jury	NN
8691	2187	20	,	,	,
8691	2187	21	by	by	IN
8691	2187	22	express	express	JJ
8691	2187	23	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	2187	24	of	of	IN
8691	2187	25	the	the	DT
8691	2187	26	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2187	27	.	.	.
8691	2188	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2188	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2188	3	:	:	:
8691	2188	4	See	see	VB
8691	2188	5	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
8691	2188	6	,	,	,
8691	2188	7	"	"	``
8691	2188	8	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	2188	9	Limitations	limitation	NNS
8691	2188	10	,	,	,
8691	2188	11	"	"	''
8691	2188	12	389	389	CD
8691	2188	13	.	.	.
8691	2188	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2189	1	During	during	IN
8691	2189	2	the	the	DT
8691	2189	3	colonial	colonial	NN
8691	2189	4	era	era	NN
8691	2189	5	the	the	DT
8691	2189	6	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2189	7	was	be	VBD
8691	2189	8	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2189	9	in	in	IN
8691	2189	10	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	2189	11	to	to	TO
8691	2189	12	waive	waive	VB
8691	2189	13	a	a	DT
8691	2189	14	jury	jury	NN
8691	2189	15	,	,	,
8691	2189	16	even	even	RB
8691	2189	17	in	in	IN
8691	2189	18	capital	capital	NN
8691	2189	19	cases	case	NNS
8691	2189	20	.	.	.
8691	2190	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2190	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2190	3	:	:	:
8691	2190	4	Proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2190	5	of	of	IN
8691	2190	6	the	the	DT
8691	2190	7	Colonial	Colonial	NNP
8691	2190	8	Society	Society	NNP
8691	2190	9	of	of	IN
8691	2190	10	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	2190	11	,	,	,
8691	2190	12	VI	VI	NNP
8691	2190	13	,	,	,
8691	2190	14	95	95	CD
8691	2190	15	.	.	.
8691	2190	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2191	1	Statutory	statutory	JJ
8691	2191	2	permission	permission	NN
8691	2191	3	to	to	IN
8691	2191	4	the	the	DT
8691	2191	5	same	same	JJ
8691	2191	6	effect	effect	NN
8691	2191	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	2191	8	since	since	RB
8691	2191	9	been	be	VBN
8691	2191	10	given	give	VBN
8691	2191	11	in	in	IN
8691	2191	12	some	some	DT
8691	2191	13	States	state	NNS
8691	2191	14	where	where	WRB
8691	2191	15	there	there	EX
8691	2191	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	2191	17	no	no	DT
8691	2191	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	2191	19	provision	provision	NN
8691	2191	20	to	to	IN
8691	2191	21	the	the	DT
8691	2191	22	contrary	contrary	NN
8691	2191	23	.	.	.
8691	2192	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2192	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2192	3	:	:	:
8691	2192	4	State	State	NNP
8691	2192	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2192	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2192	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2192	8	Worden	Worden	NNP
8691	2192	9	,	,	,
8691	2192	10	46	46	CD
8691	2192	11	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2192	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2192	13	,	,	,
8691	2192	14	349	349	CD
8691	2192	15	.	.	.
8691	2192	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2193	1	In	in	IN
8691	2193	2	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2193	3	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2193	4	,	,	,
8691	2193	5	the	the	DT
8691	2193	6	right	right	NN
8691	2193	7	to	to	TO
8691	2193	8	demand	demand	VB
8691	2193	9	a	a	DT
8691	2193	10	jury	jury	NN
8691	2193	11	in	in	IN
8691	2193	12	petty	petty	JJ
8691	2193	13	cases	case	NNS
8691	2193	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	2193	15	been	be	VBN
8691	2193	16	restricted	restrict	VBN
8691	2193	17	in	in	IN
8691	2193	18	a	a	DT
8691	2193	19	number	number	NN
8691	2193	20	of	of	IN
8691	2193	21	States	States	NNP
8691	2193	22	.	.	.
8691	2194	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2194	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2194	3	:	:	:
8691	2194	4	In	in	IN
8691	2194	5	New	New	NNP
8691	2194	6	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	2194	7	,	,	,
8691	2194	8	for	for	IN
8691	2194	9	instance	instance	NN
8691	2194	10	,	,	,
8691	2194	11	a	a	DT
8691	2194	12	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	2194	13	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	2194	14	was	be	VBD
8691	2194	15	passed	pass	VBN
8691	2194	16	in	in	IN
8691	2194	17	1877	1877	CD
8691	2194	18	denying	deny	VBG
8691	2194	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2194	20	in	in	IN
8691	2194	21	cases	case	NNS
8691	2194	22	involving	involve	VBG
8691	2194	23	less	less	JJR
8691	2194	24	than	than	IN
8691	2194	25	$	$	$
8691	2194	26	100	100	CD
8691	2194	27	,	,	,
8691	2194	28	unless	unless	IN
8691	2194	29	title	title	NN
8691	2194	30	to	to	IN
8691	2194	31	land	land	NN
8691	2194	32	is	be	VBZ
8691	2194	33	involved	involve	VBN
8691	2194	34	.	.	.
8691	2194	35	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2195	1	At	at	IN
8691	2195	2	common	common	JJ
8691	2195	3	law	law	NN
8691	2195	4	the	the	DT
8691	2195	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2195	6	were	be	VBD
8691	2195	7	accustomed	accustom	VBN
8691	2195	8	and	and	CC
8691	2195	9	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2195	10	to	to	TO
8691	2195	11	put	put	VB
8691	2195	12	great	great	JJ
8691	2195	13	pressure	pressure	NN
8691	2195	14	upon	upon	IN
8691	2195	15	juries	jury	NNS
8691	2195	16	,	,	,
8691	2195	17	if	if	IN
8691	2195	18	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2195	19	,	,	,
8691	2195	20	to	to	TO
8691	2195	21	force	force	VB
8691	2195	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2195	23	to	to	TO
8691	2195	24	unite	unite	VB
8691	2195	25	in	in	IN
8691	2195	26	rendering	render	VBG
8691	2195	27	a	a	DT
8691	2195	28	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2195	29	.	.	.
8691	2196	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2196	2	could	could	MD
8691	2196	3	be	be	VB
8691	2196	4	kept	keep	VBN
8691	2196	5	together	together	RB
8691	2196	6	without	without	IN
8691	2196	7	food	food	NN
8691	2196	8	or	or	CC
8691	2196	9	beds	bed	NNS
8691	2196	10	all	all	DT
8691	2196	11	night	night	NN
8691	2196	12	,	,	,
8691	2196	13	and	and	CC
8691	2196	14	even	even	RB
8691	2196	15	carted	cart	VBD
8691	2196	16	about	about	IN
8691	2196	17	from	from	IN
8691	2196	18	one	one	CD
8691	2196	19	court	court	NN
8691	2196	20	town	town	NN
8691	2196	21	to	to	IN
8691	2196	22	another	another	DT
8691	2196	23	until	until	IN
8691	2196	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2196	25	were	be	VBD
8691	2196	26	ready	ready	JJ
8691	2196	27	to	to	TO
8691	2196	28	report	report	VB
8691	2196	29	an	an	DT
8691	2196	30	agreement	agreement	NN
8691	2196	31	.	.	.
8691	2197	1	Very	very	RB
8691	2197	2	little	little	JJ
8691	2197	3	of	of	IN
8691	2197	4	this	this	DT
8691	2197	5	practice	practice	NN
8691	2197	6	remains	remain	VBZ
8691	2197	7	in	in	IN
8691	2197	8	the	the	DT
8691	2197	9	United	United	NNP
8691	2197	10	States	States	NNP
8691	2197	11	.	.	.
8691	2198	1	In	in	IN
8691	2198	2	some	some	DT
8691	2198	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2198	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2198	5	are	be	VBP
8691	2198	6	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2198	7	to	to	TO
8691	2198	8	separate	separate	VB
8691	2198	9	and	and	CC
8691	2198	10	go	go	VB
8691	2198	11	to	to	IN
8691	2198	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2198	13	homes	home	NNS
8691	2198	14	at	at	IN
8691	2198	15	night	night	NN
8691	2198	16	during	during	IN
8691	2198	17	the	the	DT
8691	2198	18	trial	trial	NN
8691	2198	19	even	even	RB
8691	2198	20	of	of	IN
8691	2198	21	a	a	DT
8691	2198	22	capital	capital	NN
8691	2198	23	case	case	NN
8691	2198	24	,	,	,
8691	2198	25	and	and	CC
8691	2198	26	while	while	IN
8691	2198	27	deliberating	deliberate	VBG
8691	2198	28	over	over	IN
8691	2198	29	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2198	30	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2198	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2198	32	are	be	VBP
8691	2198	33	generally	generally	RB
8691	2198	34	supplied	supply	VBN
8691	2198	35	with	with	IN
8691	2198	36	food	food	NN
8691	2198	37	and	and	CC
8691	2198	38	other	other	JJ
8691	2198	39	comforts	comfort	NNS
8691	2198	40	.	.	.
8691	2199	1	The	the	DT
8691	2199	2	right	right	NN
8691	2199	3	of	of	IN
8691	2199	4	trial	trial	NN
8691	2199	5	by	by	IN
8691	2199	6	jury	jury	NN
8691	2199	7	was	be	VBD
8691	2199	8	limited	limit	VBN
8691	2199	9	at	at	IN
8691	2199	10	common	common	JJ
8691	2199	11	law	law	NN
8691	2199	12	to	to	IN
8691	2199	13	trials	trial	NNS
8691	2199	14	of	of	IN
8691	2199	15	what	what	WP
8691	2199	16	are	be	VBP
8691	2199	17	called	call	VBN
8691	2199	18	"	"	``
8691	2199	19	issues	issue	NNS
8691	2199	20	of	of	IN
8691	2199	21	fact	fact	NN
8691	2199	22	;	;	:
8691	2199	23	"	"	``
8691	2199	24	that	that	RB
8691	2199	25	is	is	RB
8691	2199	26	,	,	,
8691	2199	27	of	of	IN
8691	2199	28	the	the	DT
8691	2199	29	truth	truth	NN
8691	2199	30	of	of	IN
8691	2199	31	a	a	DT
8691	2199	32	statement	statement	NN
8691	2199	33	of	of	IN
8691	2199	34	material	material	JJ
8691	2199	35	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2199	36	made	make	VBN
8691	2199	37	by	by	IN
8691	2199	38	one	one	CD
8691	2199	39	party	party	NN
8691	2199	40	and	and	CC
8691	2199	41	denied	deny	VBN
8691	2199	42	by	by	IN
8691	2199	43	the	the	DT
8691	2199	44	other	other	JJ
8691	2199	45	.	.	.
8691	2200	1	If	if	IN
8691	2200	2	,	,	,
8691	2200	3	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	2200	4	,	,	,
8691	2200	5	in	in	IN
8691	2200	6	a	a	DT
8691	2200	7	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2200	8	cause	cause	NN
8691	2200	9	a	a	DT
8691	2200	10	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2200	11	has	have	VBZ
8691	2200	12	been	be	VBN
8691	2200	13	ordered	order	VBN
8691	2200	14	for	for	IN
8691	2200	15	the	the	DT
8691	2200	16	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2200	17	without	without	IN
8691	2200	18	a	a	DT
8691	2200	19	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2200	20	,	,	,
8691	2200	21	as	as	IN
8691	2200	22	where	where	WRB
8691	2200	23	the	the	DT
8691	2200	24	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2200	25	has	have	VBZ
8691	2200	26	failed	fail	VBN
8691	2200	27	to	to	TO
8691	2200	28	appear	appear	VB
8691	2200	29	and	and	CC
8691	2200	30	answer	answer	VB
8691	2200	31	,	,	,
8691	2200	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2200	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	2200	34	for	for	IN
8691	2200	35	the	the	DT
8691	2200	36	court	court	NN
8691	2200	37	to	to	TO
8691	2200	38	say	say	VB
8691	2200	39	for	for	IN
8691	2200	40	the	the	DT
8691	2200	41	recovery	recovery	NN
8691	2200	42	of	of	IN
8691	2200	43	what	what	WDT
8691	2200	44	amount	amount	NN
8691	2200	45	of	of	IN
8691	2200	46	damages	damage	NNS
8691	2200	47	the	the	DT
8691	2200	48	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2200	49	shall	shall	MD
8691	2200	50	be	be	VB
8691	2200	51	rendered	render	VBN
8691	2200	52	.	.	.
8691	2201	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2201	2	may	may	MD
8691	2201	3	inquire	inquire	VB
8691	2201	4	into	into	IN
8691	2201	5	this	this	DT
8691	2201	6	by	by	IN
8691	2201	7	the	the	DT
8691	2201	8	aid	aid	NN
8691	2201	9	of	of	IN
8691	2201	10	a	a	DT
8691	2201	11	jury	jury	NN
8691	2201	12	,	,	,
8691	2201	13	but	but	CC
8691	2201	14	such	such	PDT
8691	2201	15	a	a	DT
8691	2201	16	jury	jury	NN
8691	2201	17	need	nee	MD
8691	2201	18	not	not	RB
8691	2201	19	consist	consist	VB
8691	2201	20	of	of	IN
8691	2201	21	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	2201	22	.	.	.
8691	2202	1	The	the	DT
8691	2202	2	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	2202	3	may	may	MD
8691	2202	4	also	also	RB
8691	2202	5	be	be	VB
8691	2202	6	conducted	conduct	VBN
8691	2202	7	by	by	IN
8691	2202	8	the	the	DT
8691	2202	9	judge	judge	NN
8691	2202	10	alone	alone	RB
8691	2202	11	.	.	.
8691	2203	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2203	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2203	3	:	:	:
8691	2203	4	Dyson	Dyson	NNP
8691	2203	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2203	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2203	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2203	8	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	2203	9	Island	Island	NNP
8691	2203	10	Company	Company	NNP
8691	2203	11	,	,	,
8691	2203	12	25	25	CD
8691	2203	13	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	2203	14	Island	Island	NNP
8691	2203	15	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2203	16	;	;	:
8691	2203	17	57	57	CD
8691	2203	18	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	2203	19	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2203	20	,	,	,
8691	2203	21	771	771	CD
8691	2203	22	.	.	.
8691	2203	23	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2204	1	In	in	IN
8691	2204	2	most	most	JJS
8691	2204	3	of	of	IN
8691	2204	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2204	5	States	state	NNS
8691	2204	6	this	this	DT
8691	2204	7	common	common	JJ
8691	2204	8	law	law	NN
8691	2204	9	practice	practice	NN
8691	2204	10	has	have	VBZ
8691	2204	11	been	be	VBN
8691	2204	12	abandoned	abandon	VBN
8691	2204	13	,	,	,
8691	2204	14	and	and	CC
8691	2204	15	damages	damage	NNS
8691	2204	16	,	,	,
8691	2204	17	in	in	IN
8691	2204	18	cases	case	NNS
8691	2204	19	of	of	IN
8691	2204	20	the	the	DT
8691	2204	21	kind	kind	NN
8691	2204	22	above	above	RB
8691	2204	23	described	describe	VBN
8691	2204	24	,	,	,
8691	2204	25	would	would	MD
8691	2204	26	be	be	VB
8691	2204	27	assessed	assess	VBN
8691	2204	28	by	by	IN
8691	2204	29	a	a	DT
8691	2204	30	jury	jury	NN
8691	2204	31	of	of	IN
8691	2204	32	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	2204	33	.	.	.
8691	2205	1	This	this	DT
8691	2205	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2205	3	because	because	IN
8691	2205	4	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	2205	5	a	a	DT
8691	2205	6	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2205	7	who	who	WP
8691	2205	8	did	do	VBD
8691	2205	9	not	not	RB
8691	2205	10	dispute	dispute	VB
8691	2205	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2205	12	liability	liability	NN
8691	2205	13	for	for	IN
8691	2205	14	the	the	DT
8691	2205	15	act	act	NN
8691	2205	16	complained	complain	VBD
8691	2205	17	of	of	IN
8691	2205	18	and	and	CC
8691	2205	19	only	only	RB
8691	2205	20	wished	wish	VBD
8691	2205	21	to	to	TO
8691	2205	22	reduce	reduce	VB
8691	2205	23	the	the	DT
8691	2205	24	amount	amount	NN
8691	2205	25	of	of	IN
8691	2205	26	damages	damage	NNS
8691	2205	27	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	2205	28	in	in	IN
8691	2205	29	the	the	DT
8691	2205	30	writ	writ	NNP
8691	2205	31	might	might	NN
8691	2205	32	,	,	,
8691	2205	33	after	after	IN
8691	2205	34	declining	decline	VBG
8691	2205	35	to	to	TO
8691	2205	36	appear	appear	VB
8691	2205	37	and	and	CC
8691	2205	38	plead	plead	VB
8691	2205	39	,	,	,
8691	2205	40	come	come	VB
8691	2205	41	forward	forward	RB
8691	2205	42	with	with	IN
8691	2205	43	a	a	DT
8691	2205	44	motion	motion	NN
8691	2205	45	to	to	TO
8691	2205	46	be	be	VB
8691	2205	47	heard	hear	VBN
8691	2205	48	by	by	IN
8691	2205	49	the	the	DT
8691	2205	50	court	court	NN
8691	2205	51	on	on	IN
8691	2205	52	the	the	DT
8691	2205	53	question	question	NN
8691	2205	54	of	of	IN
8691	2205	55	damages	damage	NNS
8691	2205	56	.	.	.
8691	2206	1	A	a	DT
8691	2206	2	motion	motion	NN
8691	2206	3	of	of	IN
8691	2206	4	that	that	DT
8691	2206	5	kind	kind	NN
8691	2206	6	would	would	MD
8691	2206	7	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	2206	8	be	be	VB
8691	2206	9	granted	grant	VBN
8691	2206	10	,	,	,
8691	2206	11	and	and	CC
8691	2206	12	the	the	DT
8691	2206	13	effect	effect	NN
8691	2206	14	would	would	MD
8691	2206	15	be	be	VB
8691	2206	16	to	to	TO
8691	2206	17	transfer	transfer	VB
8691	2206	18	the	the	DT
8691	2206	19	decision	decision	NN
8691	2206	20	of	of	IN
8691	2206	21	the	the	DT
8691	2206	22	only	only	JJ
8691	2206	23	actual	actual	JJ
8691	2206	24	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	2206	25	between	between	IN
8691	2206	26	the	the	DT
8691	2206	27	parties	party	NNS
8691	2206	28	from	from	IN
8691	2206	29	a	a	DT
8691	2206	30	jury	jury	NN
8691	2206	31	to	to	IN
8691	2206	32	a	a	DT
8691	2206	33	judge	judge	NN
8691	2206	34	.	.	.
8691	2207	1	In	in	IN
8691	2207	2	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2207	3	the	the	DT
8691	2207	4	old	old	JJ
8691	2207	5	practice	practice	NN
8691	2207	6	was	be	VBD
8691	2207	7	maintained	maintain	VBN
8691	2207	8	until	until	IN
8691	2207	9	1907	1907	CD
8691	2207	10	,	,	,
8691	2207	11	and	and	CC
8691	2207	12	the	the	DT
8691	2207	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	2207	14	held	hold	VBD
8691	2207	15	that	that	DT
8691	2207	16	on	on	IN
8691	2207	17	the	the	DT
8691	2207	18	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	2207	19	as	as	IN
8691	2207	20	to	to	IN
8691	2207	21	the	the	DT
8691	2207	22	damages	damage	NNS
8691	2207	23	,	,	,
8691	2207	24	in	in	IN
8691	2207	25	actions	action	NNS
8691	2207	26	where	where	WRB
8691	2207	27	there	there	EX
8691	2207	28	had	have	VBD
8691	2207	29	been	be	VBN
8691	2207	30	no	no	DT
8691	2207	31	contract	contract	NN
8691	2207	32	between	between	IN
8691	2207	33	the	the	DT
8691	2207	34	parties	party	NNS
8691	2207	35	to	to	TO
8691	2207	36	fix	fix	VB
8691	2207	37	the	the	DT
8691	2207	38	rule	rule	NN
8691	2207	39	of	of	IN
8691	2207	40	assessment	assessment	NN
8691	2207	41	,	,	,
8691	2207	42	the	the	DT
8691	2207	43	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2207	44	might	may	MD
8691	2207	45	show	show	VB
8691	2207	46	,	,	,
8691	2207	47	if	if	IN
8691	2207	48	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2207	49	could	could	MD
8691	2207	50	,	,	,
8691	2207	51	that	that	IN
8691	2207	52	only	only	RB
8691	2207	53	nominal	nominal	JJ
8691	2207	54	damages	damage	NNS
8691	2207	55	should	should	MD
8691	2207	56	be	be	VB
8691	2207	57	given	give	VBN
8691	2207	58	,	,	,
8691	2207	59	because	because	IN
8691	2207	60	really	really	RB
8691	2207	61	the	the	DT
8691	2207	62	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2207	63	had	have	VBD
8691	2207	64	no	no	DT
8691	2207	65	cause	cause	NN
8691	2207	66	of	of	IN
8691	2207	67	action	action	NN
8691	2207	68	at	at	RB
8691	2207	69	all	all	RB
8691	2207	70	.	.	.
8691	2208	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2208	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2208	3	:	:	:
8691	2208	4	Lennon	Lennon	NNP
8691	2208	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2208	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2208	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2208	8	Rawitzer	Rawitzer	NNP
8691	2208	9	,	,	,
8691	2208	10	57	57	CD
8691	2208	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2208	12	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2208	13	,	,	,
8691	2208	14	583	583	CD
8691	2208	15	;	;	:
8691	2208	16	19	19	CD
8691	2208	17	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	2208	18	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2208	19	,	,	,
8691	2208	20	334	334	CD
8691	2208	21	.	.	.
8691	2208	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2209	1	The	the	DT
8691	2209	2	result	result	NN
8691	2209	3	was	be	VBD
8691	2209	4	that	that	IN
8691	2209	5	many	many	JJ
8691	2209	6	suits	suit	NNS
8691	2209	7	arising	arise	VBG
8691	2209	8	out	out	IN
8691	2209	9	of	of	IN
8691	2209	10	railway	railway	NN
8691	2209	11	accidents	accident	NNS
8691	2209	12	in	in	IN
8691	2209	13	that	that	DT
8691	2209	14	State	state	NN
8691	2209	15	were	be	VBD
8691	2209	16	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2209	17	against	against	IN
8691	2209	18	the	the	DT
8691	2209	19	company	company	NN
8691	2209	20	in	in	IN
8691	2209	21	fault	fault	NN
8691	2209	22	in	in	IN
8691	2209	23	other	other	JJ
8691	2209	24	States	States	NNPS
8691	2209	25	in	in	IN
8691	2209	26	which	which	WDT
8691	2209	27	process	process	NN
8691	2209	28	could	could	MD
8691	2209	29	be	be	VB
8691	2209	30	served	serve	VBN
8691	2209	31	to	to	TO
8691	2209	32	compel	compel	VB
8691	2209	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2209	34	appearance	appearance	NN
8691	2209	35	,	,	,
8691	2209	36	and	and	CC
8691	2209	37	where	where	WRB
8691	2209	38	a	a	DT
8691	2209	39	full	full	JJ
8691	2209	40	jury	jury	NN
8691	2209	41	trial	trial	NN
8691	2209	42	could	could	MD
8691	2209	43	be	be	VB
8691	2209	44	secured	secure	VBN
8691	2209	45	.	.	.
8691	2210	1	The	the	DT
8691	2210	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	2210	3	finally	finally	RB
8691	2210	4	interposed	interpose	VBD
8691	2210	5	and	and	CC
8691	2210	6	gave	give	VBD
8691	2210	7	the	the	DT
8691	2210	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2210	9	a	a	DT
8691	2210	10	right	right	NN
8691	2210	11	to	to	TO
8691	2210	12	claim	claim	VB
8691	2210	13	a	a	DT
8691	2210	14	trial	trial	NN
8691	2210	15	by	by	IN
8691	2210	16	jury	jury	NN
8691	2210	17	,	,	,
8691	2210	18	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
8691	2210	19	a	a	DT
8691	2210	20	default	default	NN
8691	2210	21	.	.	.
8691	2211	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2211	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2211	3	:	:	:
8691	2211	4	Public	public	JJ
8691	2211	5	Acts	Acts	NNPS
8691	2211	6	of	of	IN
8691	2211	7	1907	1907	CD
8691	2211	8	,	,	,
8691	2211	9	665	665	CD
8691	2211	10	.	.	.
8691	2211	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2212	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2212	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2212	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2212	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2212	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2212	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	2212	7	XIII	xiii	NN
8691	2212	8	FORMALITIES	formality	NNS
8691	2212	9	IN	in	IN
8691	2212	10	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	2212	11	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
8691	2212	12	The	the	DT
8691	2212	13	sessions	session	NNS
8691	2212	14	of	of	IN
8691	2212	15	a	a	DT
8691	2212	16	court	court	NN
8691	2212	17	of	of	IN
8691	2212	18	record	record	NN
8691	2212	19	of	of	IN
8691	2212	20	general	general	JJ
8691	2212	21	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2212	22	are	be	VBP
8691	2212	23	daily	daily	RB
8691	2212	24	opened	open	VBN
8691	2212	25	by	by	IN
8691	2212	26	a	a	DT
8691	2212	27	formal	formal	JJ
8691	2212	28	proclamation	proclamation	NN
8691	2212	29	made	make	VBN
8691	2212	30	,	,	,
8691	2212	31	at	at	IN
8691	2212	32	the	the	DT
8691	2212	33	command	command	NN
8691	2212	34	of	of	IN
8691	2212	35	the	the	DT
8691	2212	36	judge	judge	NN
8691	2212	37	,	,	,
8691	2212	38	by	by	IN
8691	2212	39	the	the	DT
8691	2212	40	crier	crier	NNP
8691	2212	41	or	or	CC
8691	2212	42	sheriff	sheriff	NNP
8691	2212	43	's	's	POS
8691	2212	44	officer	officer	NN
8691	2212	45	in	in	IN
8691	2212	46	attendance	attendance	NN
8691	2212	47	.	.	.
8691	2213	1	In	in	IN
8691	2213	2	many	many	JJ
8691	2213	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2213	4	the	the	DT
8691	2213	5	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	2213	6	English	english	JJ
8691	2213	7	style	style	NN
8691	2213	8	of	of	IN
8691	2213	9	expression	expression	NN
8691	2213	10	has	have	VBZ
8691	2213	11	been	be	VBN
8691	2213	12	preserved	preserve	VBN
8691	2213	13	,	,	,
8691	2213	14	which	which	WDT
8691	2213	15	dates	date	VBZ
8691	2213	16	back	back	RB
8691	2213	17	to	to	IN
8691	2213	18	the	the	DT
8691	2213	19	Norman	Norman	NNP
8691	2213	20	conquest	conquest	NN
8691	2213	21	,	,	,
8691	2213	22	and	and	CC
8691	2213	23	begins	begin	VBZ
8691	2213	24	with	with	IN
8691	2213	25	a	a	DT
8691	2213	26	cry	cry	NN
8691	2213	27	of	of	IN
8691	2213	28	"	"	``
8691	2213	29	_	_	NNP
8691	2213	30	Oyez	Oyez	NNP
8691	2213	31	,	,	,
8691	2213	32	Oyez	Oyez	NNP
8691	2213	33	,	,	,
8691	2213	34	Oyez	Oyez	NNP
8691	2213	35	_	_	NNP
8691	2213	36	.	.	.
8691	2213	37	"	"	''
8691	2214	1	These	these	DT
8691	2214	2	proclamations	proclamation	NNS
8691	2214	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2214	4	often	often	RB
8691	2214	5	closed	close	VBN
8691	2214	6	with	with	IN
8691	2214	7	such	such	JJ
8691	2214	8	words	word	NNS
8691	2214	9	as	as	IN
8691	2214	10	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2214	11	for	for	IN
8691	2214	12	instance	instance	NN
8691	2214	13	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2214	14	"	"	``
8691	2214	15	God	God	NNP
8691	2214	16	save	save	VBP
8691	2214	17	the	the	DT
8691	2214	18	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
8691	2214	19	of	of	IN
8691	2214	20	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	2214	21	Island	Island	NNP
8691	2214	22	and	and	CC
8691	2214	23	Providence	Providence	NNP
8691	2214	24	Plantations	Plantations	NNP
8691	2214	25	.	.	.
8691	2214	26	"	"	''
8691	2215	1	The	the	DT
8691	2215	2	adjournment	adjournment	NN
8691	2215	3	from	from	IN
8691	2215	4	day	day	NN
8691	2215	5	to	to	IN
8691	2215	6	day	day	NN
8691	2215	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2215	8	announced	announce	VBN
8691	2215	9	in	in	IN
8691	2215	10	a	a	DT
8691	2215	11	similar	similar	JJ
8691	2215	12	but	but	CC
8691	2215	13	less	less	RBR
8691	2215	14	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
8691	2215	15	manner	manner	NN
8691	2215	16	.	.	.
8691	2216	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	2216	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	2216	3	hold	hold	VBP
8691	2216	4	a	a	DT
8691	2216	5	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2216	6	number	number	NN
8691	2216	7	of	of	IN
8691	2216	8	stated	state	VBN
8691	2216	9	"	"	``
8691	2216	10	terms	term	NNS
8691	2216	11	"	"	''
8691	2216	12	annually	annually	RB
8691	2216	13	,	,	,
8691	2216	14	the	the	DT
8691	2216	15	first	first	JJ
8691	2216	16	day	day	NN
8691	2216	17	of	of	IN
8691	2216	18	which	which	WDT
8691	2216	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	2216	20	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	2216	21	by	by	IN
8691	2216	22	statute	statute	NN
8691	2216	23	,	,	,
8691	2216	24	and	and	CC
8691	2216	25	each	each	DT
8691	2216	26	of	of	IN
8691	2216	27	which	which	WDT
8691	2216	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	2216	29	adjourned	adjourn	VBN
8691	2216	30	whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	2216	31	the	the	DT
8691	2216	32	business	business	NN
8691	2216	33	that	that	WDT
8691	2216	34	may	may	MD
8691	2216	35	come	come	VB
8691	2216	36	before	before	IN
8691	2216	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2216	38	is	be	VBZ
8691	2216	39	finished	finish	VBN
8691	2216	40	,	,	,
8691	2216	41	lasting	last	VBG
8691	2216	42	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2216	43	but	but	CC
8691	2216	44	a	a	DT
8691	2216	45	few	few	JJ
8691	2216	46	days	day	NNS
8691	2216	47	and	and	CC
8691	2216	48	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2216	49	months	month	NNS
8691	2216	50	.	.	.
8691	2217	1	In	in	IN
8691	2217	2	a	a	DT
8691	2217	3	number	number	NN
8691	2217	4	of	of	IN
8691	2217	5	States	state	NNS
8691	2217	6	such	such	JJ
8691	2217	7	terms	term	NNS
8691	2217	8	are	be	VBP
8691	2217	9	opened	open	VBN
8691	2217	10	by	by	IN
8691	2217	11	prayer	prayer	NN
8691	2217	12	offered	offer	VBN
8691	2217	13	by	by	IN
8691	2217	14	a	a	DT
8691	2217	15	minister	minister	NN
8691	2217	16	of	of	IN
8691	2217	17	religion	religion	NN
8691	2217	18	,	,	,
8691	2217	19	invited	invite	VBN
8691	2217	20	in	in	IN
8691	2217	21	for	for	IN
8691	2217	22	the	the	DT
8691	2217	23	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2217	24	by	by	IN
8691	2217	25	the	the	DT
8691	2217	26	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	2217	27	or	or	CC
8691	2217	28	court	court	NN
8691	2217	29	attendant	attendant	NN
8691	2217	30	.	.	.
8691	2218	1	No	no	DT
8691	2218	2	regular	regular	JJ
8691	2218	3	chaplain	chaplain	NN
8691	2218	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2218	5	employed	employ	VBN
8691	2218	6	,	,	,
8691	2218	7	and	and	CC
8691	2218	8	one	one	CD
8691	2218	9	term	term	NN
8691	2218	10	may	may	MD
8691	2218	11	be	be	VB
8691	2218	12	opened	open	VBN
8691	2218	13	by	by	IN
8691	2218	14	a	a	DT
8691	2218	15	Presbyterian	presbyterian	JJ
8691	2218	16	minister	minister	NN
8691	2218	17	and	and	CC
8691	2218	18	the	the	DT
8691	2218	19	next	next	JJ
8691	2218	20	by	by	IN
8691	2218	21	a	a	DT
8691	2218	22	Roman	roman	JJ
8691	2218	23	Catholic	Catholic	NNP
8691	2218	24	priest	priest	NN
8691	2218	25	.	.	.
8691	2219	1	In	in	IN
8691	2219	2	some	some	DT
8691	2219	3	of	of	IN
8691	2219	4	the	the	DT
8691	2219	5	smaller	small	JJR
8691	2219	6	counties	county	NNS
8691	2219	7	in	in	IN
8691	2219	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	2219	9	the	the	DT
8691	2219	10	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	2219	11	or	or	CC
8691	2219	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2219	13	deputy	deputy	JJ
8691	2219	14	daily	daily	NN
8691	2219	15	escorts	escort	VBZ
8691	2219	16	the	the	DT
8691	2219	17	judge	judge	NN
8691	2219	18	to	to	IN
8691	2219	19	and	and	CC
8691	2219	20	from	from	IN
8691	2219	21	the	the	DT
8691	2219	22	court	court	NN
8691	2219	23	house	house	NN
8691	2219	24	,	,	,
8691	2219	25	in	in	IN
8691	2219	26	accordance	accordance	NN
8691	2219	27	with	with	IN
8691	2219	28	what	what	WP
8691	2219	29	has	have	VBZ
8691	2219	30	been	be	VBN
8691	2219	31	the	the	DT
8691	2219	32	usage	usage	NN
8691	2219	33	from	from	IN
8691	2219	34	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	2219	35	times	time	NNS
8691	2219	36	.	.	.
8691	2220	1	Formerly	formerly	RB
8691	2220	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2220	3	was	be	VBD
8691	2220	4	the	the	DT
8691	2220	5	practice	practice	NN
8691	2220	6	in	in	IN
8691	2220	7	New	New	NNP
8691	2220	8	England	England	NNP
8691	2220	9	to	to	TO
8691	2220	10	ring	ring	VB
8691	2220	11	the	the	DT
8691	2220	12	bell	bell	NN
8691	2220	13	of	of	IN
8691	2220	14	the	the	DT
8691	2220	15	principal	principal	JJ
8691	2220	16	church	church	NN
8691	2220	17	in	in	IN
8691	2220	18	the	the	DT
8691	2220	19	town	town	NN
8691	2220	20	daily	daily	RB
8691	2220	21	at	at	IN
8691	2220	22	the	the	DT
8691	2220	23	hour	hour	NN
8691	2220	24	when	when	WRB
8691	2220	25	court	court	NN
8691	2220	26	opened	open	VBD
8691	2220	27	.	.	.
8691	2221	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2221	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2221	3	:	:	:
8691	2221	4	This	this	DT
8691	2221	5	was	be	VBD
8691	2221	6	continued	continue	VBN
8691	2221	7	in	in	IN
8691	2221	8	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2221	9	until	until	IN
8691	2221	10	the	the	DT
8691	2221	11	last	last	JJ
8691	2221	12	quarter	quarter	NN
8691	2221	13	of	of	IN
8691	2221	14	the	the	DT
8691	2221	15	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	2221	16	century	century	NN
8691	2221	17	.	.	.
8691	2221	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2222	1	In	in	IN
8691	2222	2	many	many	JJ
8691	2222	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	2222	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2222	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2222	6	the	the	DT
8691	2222	7	custom	custom	NN
8691	2222	8	for	for	IN
8691	2222	9	all	all	DT
8691	2222	10	present	present	JJ
8691	2222	11	to	to	TO
8691	2222	12	rise	rise	VB
8691	2222	13	on	on	IN
8691	2222	14	a	a	DT
8691	2222	15	signal	signal	NN
8691	2222	16	from	from	IN
8691	2222	17	the	the	DT
8691	2222	18	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	2222	19	or	or	CC
8691	2222	20	marshal	marshal	NN
8691	2222	21	when	when	WRB
8691	2222	22	the	the	DT
8691	2222	23	judge	judge	NN
8691	2222	24	enters	enter	VBZ
8691	2222	25	the	the	DT
8691	2222	26	court	court	NN
8691	2222	27	room	room	NN
8691	2222	28	to	to	TO
8691	2222	29	take	take	VB
8691	2222	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2222	31	seat	seat	NN
8691	2222	32	on	on	IN
8691	2222	33	the	the	DT
8691	2222	34	bench	bench	NN
8691	2222	35	.	.	.
8691	2223	1	This	this	DT
8691	2223	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2223	3	the	the	DT
8691	2223	4	general	general	JJ
8691	2223	5	usage	usage	NN
8691	2223	6	in	in	IN
8691	2223	7	the	the	DT
8691	2223	8	federal	federal	JJ
8691	2223	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	2223	10	and	and	CC
8691	2223	11	in	in	IN
8691	2223	12	the	the	DT
8691	2223	13	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2223	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	2223	15	of	of	IN
8691	2223	16	States	States	NNP
8691	2223	17	.	.	.
8691	2224	1	In	in	IN
8691	2224	2	the	the	DT
8691	2224	3	latter	latter	JJ
8691	2224	4	a	a	DT
8691	2224	5	formal	formal	JJ
8691	2224	6	proclamation	proclamation	NN
8691	2224	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2224	8	often	often	RB
8691	2224	9	made	make	VBN
8691	2224	10	by	by	IN
8691	2224	11	the	the	DT
8691	2224	12	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	2224	13	to	to	TO
8691	2224	14	announce	announce	VB
8691	2224	15	the	the	DT
8691	2224	16	coming	coming	NN
8691	2224	17	of	of	IN
8691	2224	18	the	the	DT
8691	2224	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2224	20	procession	procession	NN
8691	2224	21	,	,	,
8691	2224	22	concluding	conclude	VBG
8691	2224	23	with	with	IN
8691	2224	24	a	a	DT
8691	2224	25	"	"	``
8691	2224	26	God	God	NNP
8691	2224	27	save	save	VB
8691	2224	28	the	the	DT
8691	2224	29	Commonwealth	Commonwealth	NNP
8691	2224	30	.	.	.
8691	2224	31	"	"	''
8691	2225	1	In	in	IN
8691	2225	2	some	some	DT
8691	2225	3	States	States	NNP
8691	2225	4	formal	formal	JJ
8691	2225	5	bows	bow	NNS
8691	2225	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2225	7	interchanged	interchange	VBN
8691	2225	8	between	between	IN
8691	2225	9	bench	bench	NN
8691	2225	10	and	and	CC
8691	2225	11	bar	bar	NN
8691	2225	12	as	as	IN
8691	2225	13	the	the	DT
8691	2225	14	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2225	15	take	take	VBP
8691	2225	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2225	17	places	place	NNS
8691	2225	18	,	,	,
8691	2225	19	after	after	IN
8691	2225	20	which	which	WDT
8691	2225	21	the	the	DT
8691	2225	22	court	court	NN
8691	2225	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	2225	24	opened	open	VBN
8691	2225	25	by	by	IN
8691	2225	26	the	the	DT
8691	2225	27	customary	customary	JJ
8691	2225	28	proclamation	proclamation	NN
8691	2225	29	and	and	CC
8691	2225	30	the	the	DT
8691	2225	31	bar	bar	NN
8691	2225	32	then	then	RB
8691	2225	33	requested	request	VBD
8691	2225	34	by	by	IN
8691	2225	35	the	the	DT
8691	2225	36	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2225	37	to	to	TO
8691	2225	38	resume	resume	VB
8691	2225	39	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2225	40	seats	seat	NNS
8691	2225	41	.	.	.
8691	2226	1	The	the	DT
8691	2226	2	rules	rule	NNS
8691	2226	3	of	of	IN
8691	2226	4	official	official	JJ
8691	2226	5	precedence	precedence	NN
8691	2226	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2226	7	strictly	strictly	RB
8691	2226	8	observed	observe	VBN
8691	2226	9	in	in	IN
8691	2226	10	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2226	11	courts	court	NNS
8691	2226	12	.	.	.
8691	2227	1	In	in	IN
8691	2227	2	entering	enter	VBG
8691	2227	3	the	the	DT
8691	2227	4	court	court	NN
8691	2227	5	room	room	NN
8691	2227	6	the	the	DT
8691	2227	7	chief	chief	JJ
8691	2227	8	justice	justice	NN
8691	2227	9	advances	advance	VBZ
8691	2227	10	first	first	RB
8691	2227	11	,	,	,
8691	2227	12	and	and	CC
8691	2227	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2227	14	associates	associate	NNS
8691	2227	15	follow	follow	VBP
8691	2227	16	in	in	IN
8691	2227	17	the	the	DT
8691	2227	18	order	order	NN
8691	2227	19	of	of	IN
8691	2227	20	the	the	DT
8691	2227	21	dates	date	NNS
8691	2227	22	of	of	IN
8691	2227	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2227	24	commissions	commission	NNS
8691	2227	25	,	,	,
8691	2227	26	the	the	DT
8691	2227	27	senior	senior	JJ
8691	2227	28	associate	associate	NN
8691	2227	29	justice	justice	NN
8691	2227	30	taking	take	VBG
8691	2227	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2227	32	seat	seat	NN
8691	2227	33	on	on	IN
8691	2227	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2227	35	right	right	NN
8691	2227	36	,	,	,
8691	2227	37	the	the	DT
8691	2227	38	second	second	JJ
8691	2227	39	in	in	IN
8691	2227	40	seniority	seniority	NN
8691	2227	41	on	on	IN
8691	2227	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2227	43	left	left	NN
8691	2227	44	,	,	,
8691	2227	45	the	the	DT
8691	2227	46	third	third	JJ
8691	2227	47	in	in	IN
8691	2227	48	seniority	seniority	NN
8691	2227	49	on	on	IN
8691	2227	50	the	the	DT
8691	2227	51	right	right	NN
8691	2227	52	of	of	IN
8691	2227	53	the	the	DT
8691	2227	54	senior	senior	JJ
8691	2227	55	associate	associate	NN
8691	2227	56	justice	justice	NN
8691	2227	57	,	,	,
8691	2227	58	and	and	CC
8691	2227	59	so	so	RB
8691	2227	60	on	on	RB
8691	2227	61	;	;	:
8691	2227	62	the	the	DT
8691	2227	63	junior	junior	NN
8691	2227	64	in	in	IN
8691	2227	65	commission	commission	NN
8691	2227	66	occupying	occupy	VBG
8691	2227	67	the	the	DT
8691	2227	68	end	end	NN
8691	2227	69	seat	seat	NN
8691	2227	70	on	on	IN
8691	2227	71	the	the	DT
8691	2227	72	left	left	NN
8691	2227	73	of	of	IN
8691	2227	74	the	the	DT
8691	2227	75	bench	bench	NN
8691	2227	76	.	.	.
8691	2228	1	The	the	DT
8691	2228	2	members	member	NNS
8691	2228	3	of	of	IN
8691	2228	4	the	the	DT
8691	2228	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2228	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2228	7	and	and	CC
8691	2228	8	of	of	IN
8691	2228	9	the	the	DT
8691	2228	10	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	2228	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2228	12	of	of	IN
8691	2228	13	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	2228	14	of	of	IN
8691	2228	15	the	the	DT
8691	2228	16	United	United	NNP
8691	2228	17	States	States	NNP
8691	2228	18	have	have	VBP
8691	2228	19	always	always	RB
8691	2228	20	worn	wear	VBN
8691	2228	21	black	black	JJ
8691	2228	22	silk	silk	NN
8691	2228	23	gowns	gown	NNS
8691	2228	24	.	.	.
8691	2229	1	The	the	DT
8691	2229	2	members	member	NNS
8691	2229	3	of	of	IN
8691	2229	4	the	the	DT
8691	2229	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2229	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2229	7	of	of	IN
8691	2229	8	South	South	NNP
8691	2229	9	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	2229	10	have	have	VBP
8691	2229	11	worn	wear	VBN
8691	2229	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2229	13	from	from	IN
8691	2229	14	a	a	DT
8691	2229	15	time	time	NN
8691	2229	16	antedating	antedate	VBG
8691	2229	17	the	the	DT
8691	2229	18	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	2229	19	.	.	.
8691	2230	1	The	the	DT
8691	2230	2	New	New	NNP
8691	2230	3	York	York	NNP
8691	2230	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2230	5	of	of	IN
8691	2230	6	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	2230	7	in	in	IN
8691	2230	8	1877	1877	CD
8691	2230	9	,	,	,
8691	2230	10	at	at	IN
8691	2230	11	the	the	DT
8691	2230	12	request	request	NN
8691	2230	13	of	of	IN
8691	2230	14	the	the	DT
8691	2230	15	bar	bar	NN
8691	2230	16	,	,	,
8691	2230	17	preferred	prefer	VBD
8691	2230	18	through	through	IN
8691	2230	19	David	David	NNP
8691	2230	20	Dudley	Dudley	NNP
8691	2230	21	Field	Field	NNP
8691	2230	22	,	,	,
8691	2230	23	adopted	adopt	VBD
8691	2230	24	the	the	DT
8691	2230	25	practice,[Footnote	practice,[Footnote	NNP
8691	2230	26	:	:	:
8691	2230	27	In	in	IN
8691	2230	28	1903	1903	CD
8691	2230	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2230	30	was	be	VBD
8691	2230	31	extended	extend	VBN
8691	2230	32	to	to	IN
8691	2230	33	_	_	NNP
8691	2230	34	nisi	nisi	NNP
8691	2230	35	prius	prius	NNP
8691	2230	36	_	_	NNP
8691	2230	37	courts	court	NNS
8691	2230	38	held	hold	VBN
8691	2230	39	by	by	IN
8691	2230	40	justices	justice	NNS
8691	2230	41	of	of	IN
8691	2230	42	the	the	DT
8691	2230	43	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2230	44	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2230	45	.	.	.
8691	2230	46	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2231	1	and	and	CC
8691	2231	2	the	the	DT
8691	2231	3	same	same	JJ
8691	2231	4	thing	thing	NN
8691	2231	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	2231	6	since	since	RB
8691	2231	7	been	be	VBN
8691	2231	8	done	do	VBN
8691	2231	9	by	by	IN
8691	2231	10	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2231	11	courts	court	NNS
8691	2231	12	in	in	IN
8691	2231	13	several	several	JJ
8691	2231	14	other	other	JJ
8691	2231	15	States	state	NNS
8691	2231	16	.	.	.
8691	2232	1	In	in	IN
8691	2232	2	one	one	CD
8691	2232	3	of	of	IN
8691	2232	4	these	these	DT
8691	2232	5	,	,	,
8691	2232	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	2232	7	,	,	,
8691	2232	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2232	9	had	have	VBD
8691	2232	10	been	be	VBN
8691	2232	11	worn	wear	VBN
8691	2232	12	in	in	IN
8691	2232	13	the	the	DT
8691	2232	14	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	2232	15	era	era	NN
8691	2232	16	.	.	.
8691	2233	1	About	about	RB
8691	2233	2	1760	1760	CD
8691	2233	3	,	,	,
8691	2233	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	2233	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2233	6	Hutchinson	Hutchinson	NNP
8691	2233	7	introduced	introduce	VBD
8691	2233	8	gowns	gown	NNS
8691	2233	9	and	and	CC
8691	2233	10	cassocks	cassock	NNS
8691	2233	11	there	there	RB
8691	2233	12	on	on	IN
8691	2233	13	the	the	DT
8691	2233	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2233	15	bench	bench	NN
8691	2233	16	,	,	,
8691	2233	17	and	and	CC
8691	2233	18	also	also	RB
8691	2233	19	gowns	gown	VBZ
8691	2233	20	,	,	,
8691	2233	21	bands	band	NNS
8691	2233	22	,	,	,
8691	2233	23	and	and	CC
8691	2233	24	tie	tie	NN
8691	2233	25	-	-	HYPH
8691	2233	26	wigs	wig	NNS
8691	2233	27	for	for	IN
8691	2233	28	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2233	29	who	who	WP
8691	2233	30	were	be	VBD
8691	2233	31	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	2233	32	as	as	IN
8691	2233	33	barristers	barrister	NNS
8691	2233	34	of	of	IN
8691	2233	35	the	the	DT
8691	2233	36	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	2233	37	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2233	38	.	.	.
8691	2234	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2234	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2234	3	:	:	:
8691	2234	4	"	"	``
8691	2234	5	Life	Life	NNP
8691	2234	6	and	and	CC
8691	2234	7	Works	Works	NNP
8691	2234	8	of	of	IN
8691	2234	9	John	John	NNP
8691	2234	10	Adams	Adams	NNP
8691	2234	11	,	,	,
8691	2234	12	"	"	``
8691	2234	13	II	II	NNP
8691	2234	14	,	,	,
8691	2234	15	133	133	CD
8691	2234	16	,	,	,
8691	2234	17	note	note	NN
8691	2234	18	,	,	,
8691	2234	19	197	197	CD
8691	2234	20	.	.	.
8691	2234	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2235	1	The	the	DT
8691	2235	2	latter	latter	JJ
8691	2235	3	soon	soon	RB
8691	2235	4	abandoned	abandon	VBD
8691	2235	5	these	these	DT
8691	2235	6	,	,	,
8691	2235	7	but	but	CC
8691	2235	8	gowns	gown	NNS
8691	2235	9	were	be	VBD
8691	2235	10	retained	retain	VBN
8691	2235	11	by	by	IN
8691	2235	12	the	the	DT
8691	2235	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2235	14	until	until	IN
8691	2235	15	1793	1793	CD
8691	2235	16	.	.	.
8691	2236	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2236	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2236	3	:	:	:
8691	2236	4	Publications	publication	NNS
8691	2236	5	of	of	IN
8691	2236	6	the	the	DT
8691	2236	7	Colonial	Colonial	NNP
8691	2236	8	Society	Society	NNP
8691	2236	9	of	of	IN
8691	2236	10	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	2236	11	,	,	,
8691	2236	12	V	V	NNP
8691	2236	13	,	,	,
8691	2236	14	22	22	CD
8691	2236	15	;	;	:
8691	2236	16	Amory	amory	NN
8691	2236	17	,	,	,
8691	2236	18	"	"	``
8691	2236	19	Life	life	NN
8691	2236	20	of	of	IN
8691	2236	21	James	James	NNP
8691	2236	22	Sullivan	Sullivan	NNP
8691	2236	23	,	,	,
8691	2236	24	"	"	``
8691	2236	25	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2236	26	,	,	,
8691	2236	27	261	261	CD
8691	2236	28	,	,	,
8691	2236	29	note	note	NN
8691	2236	30	.	.	.
8691	2236	31	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2237	1	In	in	IN
8691	2237	2	North	North	NNP
8691	2237	3	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	2237	4	gowns	gown	NNS
8691	2237	5	and	and	CC
8691	2237	6	bands	band	NNS
8691	2237	7	were	be	VBD
8691	2237	8	worn	wear	VBN
8691	2237	9	by	by	IN
8691	2237	10	the	the	DT
8691	2237	11	members	member	NNS
8691	2237	12	of	of	IN
8691	2237	13	the	the	DT
8691	2237	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2237	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2237	16	in	in	IN
8691	2237	17	1767	1767	CD
8691	2237	18	.	.	.
8691	2238	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2238	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2238	3	:	:	:
8691	2238	4	Proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2238	5	of	of	IN
8691	2238	6	the	the	DT
8691	2238	7	Colonial	Colonial	NNP
8691	2238	8	Society	Society	NNP
8691	2238	9	of	of	IN
8691	2238	10	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	2238	11	,	,	,
8691	2238	12	VI	VI	NNP
8691	2238	13	,	,	,
8691	2238	14	389	389	CD
8691	2238	15	.	.	.
8691	2238	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2239	1	In	in	IN
8691	2239	2	New	New	NNP
8691	2239	3	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	2239	4	,	,	,
8691	2239	5	the	the	DT
8691	2239	6	bar	bar	NN
8691	2239	7	were	be	VBD
8691	2239	8	at	at	IN
8691	2239	9	one	one	CD
8691	2239	10	time	time	NN
8691	2239	11	required	require	VBN
8691	2239	12	to	to	TO
8691	2239	13	assume	assume	VB
8691	2239	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2239	15	by	by	IN
8691	2239	16	a	a	DT
8691	2239	17	rule	rule	NN
8691	2239	18	of	of	IN
8691	2239	19	the	the	DT
8691	2239	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2239	21	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2239	22	,	,	,
8691	2239	23	but	but	CC
8691	2239	24	the	the	DT
8691	2239	25	rule	rule	NN
8691	2239	26	was	be	VBD
8691	2239	27	vacated	vacate	VBN
8691	2239	28	in	in	IN
8691	2239	29	1791	1791	CD
8691	2239	30	.	.	.
8691	2240	1	At	at	IN
8691	2240	2	the	the	DT
8691	2240	3	first	first	JJ
8691	2240	4	opening	opening	NN
8691	2240	5	of	of	IN
8691	2240	6	the	the	DT
8691	2240	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2240	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2240	9	of	of	IN
8691	2240	10	the	the	DT
8691	2240	11	United	United	NNP
8691	2240	12	States	States	NNP
8691	2240	13	,	,	,
8691	2240	14	in	in	IN
8691	2240	15	1790	1790	CD
8691	2240	16	,	,	,
8691	2240	17	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	2240	18	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2240	19	Jay	Jay	NNP
8691	2240	20	wore	wear	VBD
8691	2240	21	a	a	DT
8691	2240	22	gown	gown	NN
8691	2240	23	with	with	IN
8691	2240	24	salmon	salmon	NN
8691	2240	25	-	-	HYPH
8691	2240	26	colored	color	VBN
8691	2240	27	facings	facing	NNS
8691	2240	28	on	on	IN
8691	2240	29	the	the	DT
8691	2240	30	front	front	NN
8691	2240	31	and	and	CC
8691	2240	32	sleeves	sleeve	NNS
8691	2240	33	,	,	,
8691	2240	34	of	of	IN
8691	2240	35	the	the	DT
8691	2240	36	style	style	NN
8691	2240	37	then	then	RB
8691	2240	38	used	use	VBN
8691	2240	39	by	by	IN
8691	2240	40	Doctors	doctor	NNS
8691	2240	41	of	of	IN
8691	2240	42	Laws	Laws	NNPS
8691	2240	43	created	create	VBN
8691	2240	44	by	by	IN
8691	2240	45	the	the	DT
8691	2240	46	University	University	NNP
8691	2240	47	of	of	IN
8691	2240	48	Dublin	Dublin	NNP
8691	2240	49	,	,	,
8691	2240	50	from	from	IN
8691	2240	51	which	which	WDT
8691	2240	52	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2240	53	had	have	VBD
8691	2240	54	received	receive	VBN
8691	2240	55	that	that	DT
8691	2240	56	degree	degree	NN
8691	2240	57	.	.	.
8691	2241	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2241	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2241	3	:	:	:
8691	2241	4	134	134	CD
8691	2241	5	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2241	6	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2241	7	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2241	8	,	,	,
8691	2241	9	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
8691	2241	10	.	.	.
8691	2241	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2242	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2242	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	2242	3	not	not	RB
8691	2242	4	since	since	IN
8691	2242	5	,	,	,
8691	2242	6	in	in	IN
8691	2242	7	that	that	DT
8691	2242	8	or	or	CC
8691	2242	9	any	any	DT
8691	2242	10	other	other	JJ
8691	2242	11	American	american	JJ
8691	2242	12	court	court	NN
8691	2242	13	,	,	,
8691	2242	14	been	be	VBN
8691	2242	15	the	the	DT
8691	2242	16	practice	practice	NN
8691	2242	17	for	for	IN
8691	2242	18	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2242	19	to	to	TO
8691	2242	20	wear	wear	VB
8691	2242	21	academic	academic	JJ
8691	2242	22	hoods	hood	NNS
8691	2242	23	or	or	CC
8691	2242	24	other	other	JJ
8691	2242	25	decorations	decoration	NNS
8691	2242	26	on	on	IN
8691	2242	27	the	the	DT
8691	2242	28	bench	bench	NN
8691	2242	29	.	.	.
8691	2243	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2243	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2243	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2243	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2243	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2243	6	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
8691	2243	7	,	,	,
8691	2243	8	in	in	IN
8691	2243	9	addressing	address	VBG
8691	2243	10	the	the	DT
8691	2243	11	court	court	NN
8691	2243	12	,	,	,
8691	2243	13	rise	rise	VB
8691	2243	14	and	and	CC
8691	2243	15	begin	begin	VB
8691	2243	16	with	with	IN
8691	2243	17	"	"	``
8691	2243	18	May	May	MD
8691	2243	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2243	20	please	please	VB
8691	2243	21	the	the	DT
8691	2243	22	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2243	23	,	,	,
8691	2243	24	"	"	''
8691	2243	25	"	"	``
8691	2243	26	May	May	MD
8691	2243	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2243	28	please	please	VB
8691	2243	29	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2243	30	honor	honor	NN
8691	2243	31	,	,	,
8691	2243	32	"	"	''
8691	2243	33	or	or	CC
8691	2243	34	,	,	,
8691	2243	35	before	before	IN
8691	2243	36	a	a	DT
8691	2243	37	court	court	NN
8691	2243	38	in	in	IN
8691	2243	39	bane	bane	NN
8691	2243	40	,	,	,
8691	2243	41	"	"	``
8691	2243	42	May	May	MD
8691	2243	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2243	44	please	please	VB
8691	2243	45	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2243	46	honors	honor	NNS
8691	2243	47	.	.	.
8691	2243	48	"	"	''
8691	2244	1	The	the	DT
8691	2244	2	term	term	NN
8691	2244	3	"	"	``
8691	2244	4	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2244	5	"	"	''
8691	2244	6	would	would	MD
8691	2244	7	never	never	RB
8691	2244	8	be	be	VB
8691	2244	9	used	use	VBN
8691	2244	10	to	to	IN
8691	2244	11	a	a	DT
8691	2244	12	judge	judge	NN
8691	2244	13	on	on	IN
8691	2244	14	the	the	DT
8691	2244	15	bench	bench	NN
8691	2244	16	;	;	:
8691	2244	17	but	but	CC
8691	2244	18	that	that	DT
8691	2244	19	of	of	IN
8691	2244	20	"	"	``
8691	2244	21	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2244	22	Honor	honor	NN
8691	2244	23	"	"	''
8691	2244	24	would	would	MD
8691	2244	25	be	be	VB
8691	2244	26	employed	employ	VBN
8691	2244	27	.	.	.
8691	2245	1	Great	great	JJ
8691	2245	2	pains	pain	NNS
8691	2245	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2245	4	taken	take	VBN
8691	2245	5	by	by	IN
8691	2245	6	the	the	DT
8691	2245	7	officers	officer	NNS
8691	2245	8	in	in	IN
8691	2245	9	attendance	attendance	NN
8691	2245	10	to	to	TO
8691	2245	11	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	2245	12	anything	anything	NN
8691	2245	13	on	on	IN
8691	2245	14	the	the	DT
8691	2245	15	part	part	NN
8691	2245	16	of	of	IN
8691	2245	17	the	the	DT
8691	2245	18	audience	audience	NN
8691	2245	19	that	that	WDT
8691	2245	20	could	could	MD
8691	2245	21	in	in	IN
8691	2245	22	any	any	DT
8691	2245	23	way	way	NN
8691	2245	24	disturb	disturb	VB
8691	2245	25	the	the	DT
8691	2245	26	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2245	27	,	,	,
8691	2245	28	such	such	JJ
8691	2245	29	as	as	IN
8691	2245	30	loud	loud	JJ
8691	2245	31	conversation	conversation	NN
8691	2245	32	or	or	CC
8691	2245	33	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
8691	2245	34	moving	move	VBG
8691	2245	35	from	from	IN
8691	2245	36	place	place	NN
8691	2245	37	to	to	IN
8691	2245	38	place	place	NN
8691	2245	39	.	.	.
8691	2246	1	There	there	EX
8691	2246	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2246	3	a	a	DT
8691	2246	4	good	good	JJ
8691	2246	5	deal	deal	NN
8691	2246	6	of	of	IN
8691	2246	7	antique	antique	JJ
8691	2246	8	form	form	NN
8691	2246	9	in	in	IN
8691	2246	10	the	the	DT
8691	2246	11	manner	manner	NN
8691	2246	12	in	in	IN
8691	2246	13	which	which	WDT
8691	2246	14	,	,	,
8691	2246	15	under	under	IN
8691	2246	16	the	the	DT
8691	2246	17	direction	direction	NN
8691	2246	18	of	of	IN
8691	2246	19	the	the	DT
8691	2246	20	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	2246	21	,	,	,
8691	2246	22	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
8691	2246	23	are	be	VBP
8691	2246	24	arraigned	arraign	VBN
8691	2246	25	and	and	CC
8691	2246	26	juries	jury	NNS
8691	2246	27	are	be	VBP
8691	2246	28	made	make	VBN
8691	2246	29	up	up	RP
8691	2246	30	or	or	CC
8691	2246	31	"	"	``
8691	2246	32	impanelled	impanel	VBN
8691	2246	33	"	"	''
8691	2246	34	for	for	IN
8691	2246	35	the	the	DT
8691	2246	36	trial	trial	NN
8691	2246	37	of	of	IN
8691	2246	38	a	a	DT
8691	2246	39	cause	cause	NN
8691	2246	40	.	.	.
8691	2247	1	In	in	IN
8691	2247	2	charging	charge	VBG
8691	2247	3	a	a	DT
8691	2247	4	jury	jury	NN
8691	2247	5	,	,	,
8691	2247	6	the	the	DT
8691	2247	7	judge	judge	NN
8691	2247	8	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2247	9	rises	rise	VBZ
8691	2247	10	and	and	CC
8691	2247	11	the	the	DT
8691	2247	12	jury	jury	NN
8691	2247	13	do	do	VBP
8691	2247	14	the	the	DT
8691	2247	15	same	same	JJ
8691	2247	16	.	.	.
8691	2248	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2248	2	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2248	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2248	4	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	2248	5	on	on	IN
8691	2248	6	a	a	DT
8691	2248	7	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	2248	8	for	for	IN
8691	2248	9	crime	crime	NN
8691	2248	10	the	the	DT
8691	2248	11	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	2248	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2248	13	required	require	VBN
8691	2248	14	to	to	TO
8691	2248	15	rise	rise	VB
8691	2248	16	.	.	.
8691	2249	1	In	in	IN
8691	2249	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	2249	3	of	of	IN
8691	2249	4	capital	capital	NN
8691	2249	5	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	2249	6	,	,	,
8691	2249	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2249	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2249	9	asked	ask	VBN
8691	2249	10	by	by	IN
8691	2249	11	the	the	DT
8691	2249	12	judge	judge	NN
8691	2249	13	if	if	IN
8691	2249	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2249	15	has	have	VBZ
8691	2249	16	anything	anything	NN
8691	2249	17	to	to	TO
8691	2249	18	say	say	VB
8691	2249	19	why	why	WRB
8691	2249	20	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2249	21	of	of	IN
8691	2249	22	death	death	NN
8691	2249	23	should	should	MD
8691	2249	24	not	not	RB
8691	2249	25	be	be	VB
8691	2249	26	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	2249	27	against	against	IN
8691	2249	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2249	29	.	.	.
8691	2250	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2250	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2250	3	highly	highly	RB
8691	2250	4	improbable	improbable	JJ
8691	2250	5	at	at	IN
8691	2250	6	that	that	DT
8691	2250	7	stage	stage	NN
8691	2250	8	of	of	IN
8691	2250	9	the	the	DT
8691	2250	10	cause	cause	NN
8691	2250	11	that	that	IN
8691	2250	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2250	13	should	should	MD
8691	2250	14	have	have	VB
8691	2250	15	anything	anything	NN
8691	2250	16	to	to	TO
8691	2250	17	urge	urge	VB
8691	2250	18	which	which	WDT
8691	2250	19	has	have	VBZ
8691	2250	20	not	not	RB
8691	2250	21	been	be	VBN
8691	2250	22	already	already	RB
8691	2250	23	considered	consider	VBN
8691	2250	24	,	,	,
8691	2250	25	but	but	CC
8691	2250	26	the	the	DT
8691	2250	27	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	2250	28	English	english	JJ
8691	2250	29	practice	practice	NN
8691	2250	30	in	in	IN
8691	2250	31	this	this	DT
8691	2250	32	respect	respect	NN
8691	2250	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	2250	34	still	still	RB
8691	2250	35	followed	follow	VBN
8691	2250	36	,	,	,
8691	2250	37	for	for	IN
8691	2250	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2250	39	is	be	VBZ
8691	2250	40	not	not	RB
8691	2250	41	absolutely	absolutely	RB
8691	2250	42	impossible	impossible	JJ
8691	2250	43	that	that	IN
8691	2250	44	something	something	NN
8691	2250	45	may	may	MD
8691	2250	46	have	have	VB
8691	2250	47	occurred	occur	VBN
8691	2250	48	since	since	IN
8691	2250	49	the	the	DT
8691	2250	50	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2250	51	that	that	WDT
8691	2250	52	would	would	MD
8691	2250	53	affect	affect	VB
8691	2250	54	the	the	DT
8691	2250	55	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2250	56	.	.	.
8691	2251	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2251	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2251	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2251	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2251	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2251	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	2251	7	XIV	XIV	NNP
8691	2251	8	TRIAL	trial	NN
8691	2251	9	COURTS	court	NNS
8691	2251	10	FOR	for	IN
8691	2251	11	CIVIL	civil	NN
8691	2251	12	CAUSES	cause	NNS
8691	2251	13	The	the	DT
8691	2251	14	great	great	JJ
8691	2251	15	bulk	bulk	NN
8691	2251	16	of	of	IN
8691	2251	17	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	2251	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	2251	19	confined	confine	VBN
8691	2251	20	to	to	IN
8691	2251	21	the	the	DT
8691	2251	22	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2251	23	trial	trial	NN
8691	2251	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	2251	25	,	,	,
8691	2251	26	that	that	RB
8691	2251	27	is	is	RB
8691	2251	28	,	,	,
8691	2251	29	to	to	IN
8691	2251	30	courts	court	NNS
8691	2251	31	for	for	IN
8691	2251	32	the	the	DT
8691	2251	33	trial	trial	NN
8691	2251	34	of	of	IN
8691	2251	35	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	2251	36	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2251	37	between	between	IN
8691	2251	38	man	man	NN
8691	2251	39	and	and	CC
8691	2251	40	man	man	NN
8691	2251	41	.	.	.
8691	2252	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2252	2	also	also	RB
8691	2252	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	2252	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2252	5	seat	seat	NN
8691	2252	6	in	in	IN
8691	2252	7	the	the	DT
8691	2252	8	trial	trial	NN
8691	2252	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	2252	10	of	of	IN
8691	2252	11	the	the	DT
8691	2252	12	States	States	NNPS
8691	2252	13	,	,	,
8691	2252	14	for	for	IN
8691	2252	15	not	not	RB
8691	2252	16	only	only	RB
8691	2252	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	2252	18	the	the	DT
8691	2252	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2252	20	power	power	NN
8691	2252	21	of	of	IN
8691	2252	22	the	the	DT
8691	2252	23	United	United	NNP
8691	2252	24	States	States	NNP
8691	2252	25	confined	confine	VBN
8691	2252	26	by	by	IN
8691	2252	27	the	the	DT
8691	2252	28	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2252	29	within	within	IN
8691	2252	30	narrow	narrow	JJ
8691	2252	31	limits	limit	NNS
8691	2252	32	,	,	,
8691	2252	33	but	but	CC
8691	2252	34	these	these	DT
8691	2252	35	have	have	VBP
8691	2252	36	been	be	VBN
8691	2252	37	made	make	VBN
8691	2252	38	still	still	RB
8691	2252	39	narrower	narrow	JJR
8691	2252	40	by	by	IN
8691	2252	41	the	the	DT
8691	2252	42	action	action	NN
8691	2252	43	of	of	IN
8691	2252	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	2252	45	from	from	IN
8691	2252	46	time	time	NN
8691	2252	47	to	to	IN
8691	2252	48	time	time	NN
8691	2252	49	.	.	.
8691	2253	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	2253	2	lawsuits	lawsuit	NNS
8691	2253	3	never	never	RB
8691	2253	4	get	get	VBP
8691	2253	5	to	to	IN
8691	2253	6	trial	trial	NN
8691	2253	7	.	.	.
8691	2254	1	The	the	DT
8691	2254	2	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2254	3	generally	generally	RB
8691	2254	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2254	5	no	no	DT
8691	2254	6	defense	defense	NN
8691	2254	7	,	,	,
8691	2254	8	and	and	CC
8691	2254	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	2254	10	well	well	RB
8691	2254	11	aware	aware	JJ
8691	2254	12	of	of	IN
8691	2254	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2254	14	.	.	.
8691	2255	1	The	the	DT
8691	2255	2	suit	suit	NN
8691	2255	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2255	4	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2255	5	to	to	TO
8691	2255	6	obtain	obtain	VB
8691	2255	7	security	security	NN
8691	2255	8	or	or	CC
8691	2255	9	force	force	VB
8691	2255	10	a	a	DT
8691	2255	11	settlement	settlement	NN
8691	2255	12	.	.	.
8691	2256	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2256	2	employs	employ	VBZ
8691	2256	3	no	no	DT
8691	2256	4	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	2256	5	and	and	CC
8691	2256	6	lets	let	VBZ
8691	2256	7	things	thing	NNS
8691	2256	8	take	take	VB
8691	2256	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2256	10	course	course	NN
8691	2256	11	.	.	.
8691	2257	1	The	the	DT
8691	2257	2	result	result	NN
8691	2257	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2257	4	a	a	DT
8691	2257	5	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2257	6	against	against	IN
8691	2257	7	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2257	8	for	for	IN
8691	2257	9	default	default	NN
8691	2257	10	of	of	IN
8691	2257	11	appearance	appearance	NN
8691	2257	12	;	;	,
8691	2257	13	for	for	IN
8691	2257	14	if	if	IN
8691	2257	15	one	one	NN
8691	2257	16	who	who	WP
8691	2257	17	has	have	VBZ
8691	2257	18	been	be	VBN
8691	2257	19	duly	duly	RB
8691	2257	20	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	2257	21	to	to	IN
8691	2257	22	court	court	NN
8691	2257	23	to	to	TO
8691	2257	24	answer	answer	VB
8691	2257	25	to	to	IN
8691	2257	26	a	a	DT
8691	2257	27	demand	demand	NN
8691	2257	28	fails	fail	VBZ
8691	2257	29	to	to	TO
8691	2257	30	attend	attend	VB
8691	2257	31	and	and	CC
8691	2257	32	answer	answer	VB
8691	2257	33	,	,	,
8691	2257	34	the	the	DT
8691	2257	35	court	court	NN
8691	2257	36	assumes	assume	VBZ
8691	2257	37	that	that	IN
8691	2257	38	there	there	EX
8691	2257	39	is	be	VBZ
8691	2257	40	no	no	DT
8691	2257	41	answer	answer	NN
8691	2257	42	that	that	IN
8691	2257	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2257	44	could	could	MD
8691	2257	45	make	make	VB
8691	2257	46	,	,	,
8691	2257	47	and	and	CC
8691	2257	48	disposes	dispose	NNS
8691	2257	49	of	of	IN
8691	2257	50	the	the	DT
8691	2257	51	cause	cause	NN
8691	2257	52	on	on	IN
8691	2257	53	such	such	JJ
8691	2257	54	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2257	55	as	as	IN
8691	2257	56	the	the	DT
8691	2257	57	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2257	58	may	may	MD
8691	2257	59	produce	produce	VB
8691	2257	60	.	.	.
8691	2258	1	On	on	IN
8691	2258	2	the	the	DT
8691	2258	3	other	other	JJ
8691	2258	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	2258	5	,	,	,
8691	2258	6	the	the	DT
8691	2258	7	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2258	8	often	often	RB
8691	2258	9	does	do	VBZ
8691	2258	10	not	not	RB
8691	2258	11	care	care	VB
8691	2258	12	for	for	IN
8691	2258	13	a	a	DT
8691	2258	14	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2258	15	.	.	.
8691	2259	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2259	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	2259	3	become	become	VBN
8691	2259	4	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
8691	2259	5	that	that	IN
8691	2259	6	,	,	,
8691	2259	7	if	if	IN
8691	2259	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2259	9	got	get	VBD
8691	2259	10	one	one	CD
8691	2259	11	,	,	,
8691	2259	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2259	13	could	could	MD
8691	2259	14	not	not	RB
8691	2259	15	collect	collect	VB
8691	2259	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2259	17	,	,	,
8691	2259	18	or	or	CC
8691	2259	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2259	20	has	have	VBZ
8691	2259	21	availed	avail	VBN
8691	2259	22	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2259	23	of	of	IN
8691	2259	24	the	the	DT
8691	2259	25	suit	suit	NN
8691	2259	26	to	to	TO
8691	2259	27	secure	secure	VB
8691	2259	28	a	a	DT
8691	2259	29	compromise	compromise	NN
8691	2259	30	of	of	IN
8691	2259	31	the	the	DT
8691	2259	32	matter	matter	NN
8691	2259	33	in	in	IN
8691	2259	34	demand	demand	NN
8691	2259	35	on	on	IN
8691	2259	36	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
8691	2259	37	terms	term	NNS
8691	2259	38	.	.	.
8691	2260	1	In	in	IN
8691	2260	2	such	such	JJ
8691	2260	3	case	case	NN
8691	2260	4	,	,	,
8691	2260	5	or	or	CC
8691	2260	6	if	if	IN
8691	2260	7	,	,	,
8691	2260	8	after	after	IN
8691	2260	9	bringing	bring	VBG
8691	2260	10	an	an	DT
8691	2260	11	action	action	NN
8691	2260	12	,	,	,
8691	2260	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2260	14	becomes	become	VBZ
8691	2260	15	convinced	convinced	JJ
8691	2260	16	that	that	IN
8691	2260	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2260	18	can	can	MD
8691	2260	19	not	not	RB
8691	2260	20	maintain	maintain	VB
8691	2260	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2260	22	,	,	,
8691	2260	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2260	24	withdraws	withdraw	VBZ
8691	2260	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2260	26	,	,	,
8691	2260	27	or	or	CC
8691	2260	28	if	if	IN
8691	2260	29	the	the	DT
8691	2260	30	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2260	31	insists	insist	VBZ
8691	2260	32	,	,	,
8691	2260	33	suffers	suffer	VBZ
8691	2260	34	a	a	DT
8691	2260	35	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2260	36	to	to	TO
8691	2260	37	go	go	VB
8691	2260	38	against	against	IN
8691	2260	39	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2260	40	,	,	,
8691	2260	41	called	call	VBD
8691	2260	42	a	a	DT
8691	2260	43	nonsuit	nonsuit	NN
8691	2260	44	.	.	.
8691	2261	1	In	in	IN
8691	2261	2	some	some	DT
8691	2261	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2261	4	the	the	DT
8691	2261	5	writ	writ	NN
8691	2261	6	or	or	CC
8691	2261	7	process	process	NN
8691	2261	8	by	by	IN
8691	2261	9	which	which	WDT
8691	2261	10	the	the	DT
8691	2261	11	action	action	NN
8691	2261	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2261	13	begun	begin	VBN
8691	2261	14	must	must	MD
8691	2261	15	be	be	VB
8691	2261	16	accompanied	accompany	VBN
8691	2261	17	by	by	IN
8691	2261	18	a	a	DT
8691	2261	19	full	full	JJ
8691	2261	20	statement	statement	NN
8691	2261	21	of	of	IN
8691	2261	22	the	the	DT
8691	2261	23	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2261	24	nature	nature	NN
8691	2261	25	of	of	IN
8691	2261	26	the	the	DT
8691	2261	27	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2261	28	's	's	POS
8691	2261	29	claim	claim	NN
8691	2261	30	.	.	.
8691	2262	1	In	in	IN
8691	2262	2	others	other	NNS
8691	2262	3	this	this	DT
8691	2262	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2262	5	not	not	RB
8691	2262	6	required	require	VBN
8691	2262	7	,	,	,
8691	2262	8	and	and	CC
8691	2262	9	such	such	PDT
8691	2262	10	a	a	DT
8691	2262	11	statement	statement	NN
8691	2262	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2262	13	only	only	RB
8691	2262	14	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	2262	15	when	when	WRB
8691	2262	16	specially	specially	RB
8691	2262	17	ordered	order	VBN
8691	2262	18	by	by	IN
8691	2262	19	the	the	DT
8691	2262	20	court	court	NN
8691	2262	21	.	.	.
8691	2263	1	If	if	IN
8691	2263	2	the	the	DT
8691	2263	3	case	case	NN
8691	2263	4	goes	go	VBZ
8691	2263	5	to	to	IN
8691	2263	6	trial	trial	NN
8691	2263	7	on	on	IN
8691	2263	8	the	the	DT
8691	2263	9	merits	merit	NNS
8691	2263	10	,	,	,
8691	2263	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2263	12	will	will	MD
8691	2263	13	be	be	VB
8691	2263	14	on	on	IN
8691	2263	15	such	such	PDT
8691	2263	16	a	a	DT
8691	2263	17	statement	statement	NN
8691	2263	18	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	2263	19	by	by	IN
8691	2263	20	the	the	DT
8691	2263	21	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2263	22	,	,	,
8691	2263	23	and	and	CC
8691	2263	24	on	on	IN
8691	2263	25	some	some	DT
8691	2263	26	paper	paper	NN
8691	2263	27	filed	file	VBN
8691	2263	28	by	by	IN
8691	2263	29	the	the	DT
8691	2263	30	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2263	31	by	by	IN
8691	2263	32	way	way	NN
8691	2263	33	of	of	IN
8691	2263	34	answer	answer	NN
8691	2263	35	.	.	.
8691	2264	1	Occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	2264	2	these	these	DT
8691	2264	3	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	2264	4	,	,	,
8691	2264	5	as	as	IN
8691	2264	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2264	7	are	be	VBP
8691	2264	8	called	call	VBN
8691	2264	9	,	,	,
8691	2264	10	are	be	VBP
8691	2264	11	such	such	JJ
8691	2264	12	as	as	IN
8691	2264	13	to	to	TO
8691	2264	14	call	call	VB
8691	2264	15	out	out	RP
8691	2264	16	further	further	JJ
8691	2264	17	statements	statement	NNS
8691	2264	18	or	or	CC
8691	2264	19	claims	claim	NNS
8691	2264	20	by	by	IN
8691	2264	21	way	way	NN
8691	2264	22	of	of	IN
8691	2264	23	reply	reply	NN
8691	2264	24	and	and	CC
8691	2264	25	rejoinder	rejoinder	NN
8691	2264	26	.	.	.
8691	2265	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2265	2	form	form	NN
8691	2265	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2265	4	now	now	RB
8691	2265	5	generally	generally	RB
8691	2265	6	regulated	regulate	VBN
8691	2265	7	by	by	IN
8691	2265	8	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2265	9	,	,	,
8691	2265	10	and	and	CC
8691	2265	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2265	12	much	much	RB
8691	2265	13	the	the	DT
8691	2265	14	same	same	JJ
8691	2265	15	in	in	IN
8691	2265	16	most	most	JJS
8691	2265	17	of	of	IN
8691	2265	18	the	the	DT
8691	2265	19	States	States	NNP
8691	2265	20	,	,	,
8691	2265	21	being	be	VBG
8691	2265	22	based	base	VBN
8691	2265	23	upon	upon	IN
8691	2265	24	a	a	DT
8691	2265	25	system	system	NN
8691	2265	26	known	know	VBN
8691	2265	27	as	as	IN
8691	2265	28	"	"	``
8691	2265	29	Code	Code	NNP
8691	2265	30	Pleading	Pleading	NNP
8691	2265	31	,	,	,
8691	2265	32	"	"	''
8691	2265	33	which	which	WDT
8691	2265	34	originated	originate	VBD
8691	2265	35	in	in	IN
8691	2265	36	New	New	NNP
8691	2265	37	York	York	NNP
8691	2265	38	about	about	IN
8691	2265	39	the	the	DT
8691	2265	40	middle	middle	NN
8691	2265	41	of	of	IN
8691	2265	42	the	the	DT
8691	2265	43	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	2265	44	century	century	NN
8691	2265	45	.	.	.
8691	2266	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2266	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2266	3	simpler	simple	JJR
8691	2266	4	and	and	CC
8691	2266	5	less	less	RBR
8691	2266	6	technical	technical	JJ
8691	2266	7	than	than	IN
8691	2266	8	the	the	DT
8691	2266	9	system	system	NN
8691	2266	10	under	under	IN
8691	2266	11	the	the	DT
8691	2266	12	common	common	JJ
8691	2266	13	law	law	NN
8691	2266	14	which	which	WDT
8691	2266	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2266	16	replaced	replace	VBD
8691	2266	17	.	.	.
8691	2267	1	If	if	IN
8691	2267	2	the	the	DT
8691	2267	3	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2267	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2267	5	any	any	DT
8691	2267	6	objections	objection	NNS
8691	2267	7	to	to	IN
8691	2267	8	the	the	DT
8691	2267	9	maintenance	maintenance	NN
8691	2267	10	of	of	IN
8691	2267	11	the	the	DT
8691	2267	12	suit	suit	NN
8691	2267	13	,	,	,
8691	2267	14	on	on	IN
8691	2267	15	such	such	PDT
8691	2267	16	a	a	DT
8691	2267	17	ground	ground	NN
8691	2267	18	as	as	IN
8691	2267	19	that	that	IN
8691	2267	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2267	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	2267	22	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2267	23	in	in	RP
8691	2267	24	a	a	DT
8691	2267	25	wrong	wrong	JJ
8691	2267	26	court	court	NN
8691	2267	27	,	,	,
8691	2267	28	or	or	CC
8691	2267	29	a	a	DT
8691	2267	30	wrong	wrong	JJ
8691	2267	31	way	way	NN
8691	2267	32	,	,	,
8691	2267	33	these	these	DT
8691	2267	34	are	be	VBP
8691	2267	35	first	first	RB
8691	2267	36	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	2267	37	of	of	IN
8691	2267	38	.	.	.
8691	2268	1	Then	then	RB
8691	2268	2	,	,	,
8691	2268	3	if	if	IN
8691	2268	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2268	5	asserts	assert	VBZ
8691	2268	6	that	that	IN
8691	2268	7	the	the	DT
8691	2268	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2268	9	on	on	IN
8691	2268	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2268	11	own	own	JJ
8691	2268	12	showing	showing	NN
8691	2268	13	has	have	VBZ
8691	2268	14	no	no	DT
8691	2268	15	case	case	NN
8691	2268	16	,	,	,
8691	2268	17	or	or	CC
8691	2268	18	if	if	IN
8691	2268	19	the	the	DT
8691	2268	20	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2268	21	asserts	assert	VBZ
8691	2268	22	that	that	IN
8691	2268	23	the	the	DT
8691	2268	24	defense	defense	NN
8691	2268	25	set	set	VBD
8691	2268	26	up	up	RP
8691	2268	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	2268	28	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
8691	2268	29	on	on	IN
8691	2268	30	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2268	31	face	face	NN
8691	2268	32	,	,	,
8691	2268	33	this	this	DT
8691	2268	34	being	be	VBG
8691	2268	35	a	a	DT
8691	2268	36	question	question	NN
8691	2268	37	of	of	IN
8691	2268	38	law	law	NN
8691	2268	39	,	,	,
8691	2268	40	the	the	DT
8691	2268	41	judge	judge	NN
8691	2268	42	decides	decide	VBZ
8691	2268	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2268	44	without	without	IN
8691	2268	45	the	the	DT
8691	2268	46	aid	aid	NN
8691	2268	47	of	of	IN
8691	2268	48	a	a	DT
8691	2268	49	jury	jury	NN
8691	2268	50	.	.	.
8691	2269	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2269	2	,	,	,
8691	2269	3	however	however	RB
8691	2269	4	,	,	,
8691	2269	5	the	the	DT
8691	2269	6	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2269	7	are	be	VBP
8691	2269	8	in	in	IN
8691	2269	9	dispute	dispute	NN
8691	2269	10	,	,	,
8691	2269	11	a	a	DT
8691	2269	12	jury	jury	NN
8691	2269	13	must	must	MD
8691	2269	14	be	be	VB
8691	2269	15	called	call	VBN
8691	2269	16	in	in	RP
8691	2269	17	,	,	,
8691	2269	18	if	if	IN
8691	2269	19	either	either	DT
8691	2269	20	party	party	NN
8691	2269	21	claims	claim	VBZ
8691	2269	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2269	23	,	,	,
8691	2269	24	in	in	IN
8691	2269	25	an	an	DT
8691	2269	26	action	action	NN
8691	2269	27	not	not	RB
8691	2269	28	of	of	IN
8691	2269	29	an	an	DT
8691	2269	30	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	2269	31	nature	nature	NN
8691	2269	32	,	,	,
8691	2269	33	when	when	WRB
8691	2269	34	the	the	DT
8691	2269	35	matter	matter	NN
8691	2269	36	in	in	IN
8691	2269	37	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	2269	38	is	be	VBZ
8691	2269	39	one	one	CD
8691	2269	40	of	of	IN
8691	2269	41	any	any	DT
8691	2269	42	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2269	43	amount	amount	NN
8691	2269	44	.	.	.
8691	2270	1	In	in	IN
8691	2270	2	this	this	DT
8691	2270	3	country	country	NN
8691	2270	4	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2270	5	adhere	adhere	VBP
8691	2270	6	to	to	IN
8691	2270	7	the	the	DT
8691	2270	8	old	old	JJ
8691	2270	9	common	common	JJ
8691	2270	10	law	law	NN
8691	2270	11	mode	mode	NN
8691	2270	12	of	of	IN
8691	2270	13	taking	take	VBG
8691	2270	14	exceptions	exception	NNS
8691	2270	15	to	to	IN
8691	2270	16	the	the	DT
8691	2270	17	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2270	18	sufficiency	sufficiency	NN
8691	2270	19	of	of	IN
8691	2270	20	written	write	VBN
8691	2270	21	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	2270	22	.	.	.
8691	2271	1	This	this	DT
8691	2271	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2271	3	by	by	IN
8691	2271	4	filing	file	VBG
8691	2271	5	a	a	DT
8691	2271	6	paper	paper	NN
8691	2271	7	called	call	VBN
8691	2271	8	a	a	DT
8691	2271	9	"	"	``
8691	2271	10	demurrer	demurrer	NN
8691	2271	11	,	,	,
8691	2271	12	"	"	''
8691	2271	13	in	in	IN
8691	2271	14	which	which	WDT
8691	2271	15	the	the	DT
8691	2271	16	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2271	17	objections	objection	NNS
8691	2271	18	were	be	VBD
8691	2271	19	set	set	VBN
8691	2271	20	out	out	RP
8691	2271	21	,	,	,
8691	2271	22	unless	unless	IN
8691	2271	23	,	,	,
8691	2271	24	as	as	IN
8691	2271	25	was	be	VBD
8691	2271	26	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	2271	27	the	the	DT
8691	2271	28	case	case	NN
8691	2271	29	,	,	,
8691	2271	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2271	31	were	be	VBD
8691	2271	32	so	so	RB
8691	2271	33	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	2271	34	as	as	IN
8691	2271	35	to	to	TO
8691	2271	36	be	be	VB
8691	2271	37	apparent	apparent	JJ
8691	2271	38	at	at	IN
8691	2271	39	the	the	DT
8691	2271	40	first	first	JJ
8691	2271	41	glance	glance	NN
8691	2271	42	.	.	.
8691	2272	1	In	in	IN
8691	2272	2	many	many	JJ
8691	2272	3	States	States	NNPS
8691	2272	4	,	,	,
8691	2272	5	however	however	RB
8691	2272	6	,	,	,
8691	2272	7	the	the	DT
8691	2272	8	objections	objection	NNS
8691	2272	9	must	must	MD
8691	2272	10	always	always	RB
8691	2272	11	be	be	VB
8691	2272	12	particularized	particularize	VBN
8691	2272	13	.	.	.
8691	2273	1	In	in	IN
8691	2273	2	England	England	NNP
8691	2273	3	demurrers	demurrer	NNS
8691	2273	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2273	5	no	no	RB
8691	2273	6	longer	long	RBR
8691	2273	7	used	use	VBN
8691	2273	8	.	.	.
8691	2274	1	Her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2274	2	Judicature	Judicature	NNP
8691	2274	3	Act	Act	NNP
8691	2274	4	of	of	IN
8691	2274	5	1873	1873	CD
8691	2274	6	put	put	VBD
8691	2274	7	an	an	DT
8691	2274	8	end	end	NN
8691	2274	9	to	to	IN
8691	2274	10	the	the	DT
8691	2274	11	common	common	JJ
8691	2274	12	law	law	NN
8691	2274	13	system	system	NN
8691	2274	14	of	of	IN
8691	2274	15	pleading	pleading	NN
8691	2274	16	,	,	,
8691	2274	17	reconstituted	reconstitute	VBD
8691	2274	18	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2274	19	whole	whole	JJ
8691	2274	20	method	method	NN
8691	2274	21	of	of	IN
8691	2274	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2274	23	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	2274	24	,	,	,
8691	2274	25	and	and	CC
8691	2274	26	authorized	authorize	VBD
8691	2274	27	the	the	DT
8691	2274	28	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2274	29	to	to	TO
8691	2274	30	make	make	VB
8691	2274	31	rules	rule	NNS
8691	2274	32	and	and	CC
8691	2274	33	orders	order	NNS
8691	2274	34	from	from	IN
8691	2274	35	time	time	NN
8691	2274	36	to	to	IN
8691	2274	37	time	time	NN
8691	2274	38	to	to	TO
8691	2274	39	adopt	adopt	VB
8691	2274	40	the	the	DT
8691	2274	41	new	new	JJ
8691	2274	42	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	2274	43	to	to	TO
8691	2274	44	convenience	convenience	NN
8691	2274	45	in	in	IN
8691	2274	46	practice	practice	NN
8691	2274	47	.	.	.
8691	2275	1	One	one	CD
8691	2275	2	of	of	IN
8691	2275	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2275	4	orders	order	NNS
8691	2275	5	,	,	,
8691	2275	6	passed	pass	VBN
8691	2275	7	in	in	IN
8691	2275	8	1883	1883	CD
8691	2275	9	,	,	,
8691	2275	10	abolished	abolish	VBD
8691	2275	11	demurrers	demurrer	NNS
8691	2275	12	.	.	.
8691	2276	1	In	in	IN
8691	2276	2	place	place	NN
8691	2276	3	of	of	IN
8691	2276	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2276	5	,	,	,
8691	2276	6	the	the	DT
8691	2276	7	party	party	NN
8691	2276	8	desiring	desire	VBG
8691	2276	9	to	to	TO
8691	2276	10	have	have	VB
8691	2276	11	the	the	DT
8691	2276	12	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	2276	13	of	of	IN
8691	2276	14	points	point	NNS
8691	2276	15	of	of	IN
8691	2276	16	law	law	NN
8691	2276	17	arising	arise	VBG
8691	2276	18	on	on	IN
8691	2276	19	the	the	DT
8691	2276	20	face	face	NN
8691	2276	21	of	of	IN
8691	2276	22	the	the	DT
8691	2276	23	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	2276	24	may	may	MD
8691	2276	25	state	state	VB
8691	2276	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2276	27	point	point	NN
8691	2276	28	to	to	IN
8691	2276	29	the	the	DT
8691	2276	30	court	court	NN
8691	2276	31	and	and	CC
8691	2276	32	ask	ask	VB
8691	2276	33	to	to	TO
8691	2276	34	have	have	VB
8691	2276	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2276	36	set	set	VBN
8691	2276	37	down	down	RP
8691	2276	38	for	for	IN
8691	2276	39	separate	separate	JJ
8691	2276	40	argument	argument	NN
8691	2276	41	before	before	IN
8691	2276	42	proceeding	proceed	VBG
8691	2276	43	to	to	IN
8691	2276	44	a	a	DT
8691	2276	45	trial	trial	NN
8691	2276	46	of	of	IN
8691	2276	47	the	the	DT
8691	2276	48	cause	cause	NN
8691	2276	49	on	on	IN
8691	2276	50	the	the	DT
8691	2276	51	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2276	52	.	.	.
8691	2277	1	American	american	JJ
8691	2277	2	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2277	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2277	4	not	not	RB
8691	2277	5	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
8691	2277	6	with	with	IN
8691	2277	7	the	the	DT
8691	2277	8	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	2277	9	which	which	WDT
8691	2277	10	led	lead	VBD
8691	2277	11	to	to	IN
8691	2277	12	this	this	DT
8691	2277	13	change	change	NN
8691	2277	14	.	.	.
8691	2278	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2278	2	were	be	VBD
8691	2278	3	that	that	IN
8691	2278	4	the	the	DT
8691	2278	5	old	old	JJ
8691	2278	6	practice	practice	NN
8691	2278	7	made	make	VBD
8691	2278	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2278	9	a	a	DT
8691	2278	10	matter	matter	NN
8691	2278	11	of	of	IN
8691	2278	12	right	right	NN
8691	2278	13	to	to	TO
8691	2278	14	claim	claim	VB
8691	2278	15	a	a	DT
8691	2278	16	special	special	JJ
8691	2278	17	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	2278	18	on	on	IN
8691	2278	19	a	a	DT
8691	2278	20	law	law	NN
8691	2278	21	point	point	NN
8691	2278	22	,	,	,
8691	2278	23	while	while	IN
8691	2278	24	the	the	DT
8691	2278	25	new	new	JJ
8691	2278	26	order	order	NN
8691	2278	27	would	would	MD
8691	2278	28	leave	leave	VB
8691	2278	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2278	30	to	to	IN
8691	2278	31	the	the	DT
8691	2278	32	discretion	discretion	NN
8691	2278	33	of	of	IN
8691	2278	34	the	the	DT
8691	2278	35	judge	judge	NN
8691	2278	36	.	.	.
8691	2279	1	The	the	DT
8691	2279	2	English	english	JJ
8691	2279	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2279	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2279	5	few	few	JJ
8691	2279	6	and	and	CC
8691	2279	7	able	able	JJ
8691	2279	8	.	.	.
8691	2280	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	2280	2	a	a	DT
8691	2280	3	plan	plan	NN
8691	2280	4	may	may	MD
8691	2280	5	work	work	VB
8691	2280	6	satisfactorily	satisfactorily	RB
8691	2280	7	under	under	IN
8691	2280	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2280	9	administration	administration	NN
8691	2280	10	,	,	,
8691	2280	11	but	but	CC
8691	2280	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2280	13	might	may	MD
8691	2280	14	often	often	RB
8691	2280	15	lead	lead	VB
8691	2280	16	to	to	IN
8691	2280	17	useless	useless	JJ
8691	2280	18	delays	delay	NNS
8691	2280	19	and	and	CC
8691	2280	20	expense	expense	NN
8691	2280	21	if	if	IN
8691	2280	22	introduced	introduce	VBN
8691	2280	23	in	in	IN
8691	2280	24	a	a	DT
8691	2280	25	country	country	NN
8691	2280	26	where	where	WRB
8691	2280	27	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2280	28	are	be	VBP
8691	2280	29	so	so	RB
8691	2280	30	numerous	numerous	JJ
8691	2280	31	and	and	CC
8691	2280	32	of	of	IN
8691	2280	33	such	such	JJ
8691	2280	34	different	different	JJ
8691	2280	35	qualifications	qualification	NNS
8691	2280	36	as	as	IN
8691	2280	37	is	be	VBZ
8691	2280	38	the	the	DT
8691	2280	39	case	case	NN
8691	2280	40	in	in	IN
8691	2280	41	the	the	DT
8691	2280	42	United	United	NNP
8691	2280	43	States	States	NNP
8691	2280	44	.	.	.
8691	2281	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2281	2	trial	trial	NN
8691	2281	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	2281	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2281	5	now	now	RB
8691	2281	6	generally	generally	RB
8691	2281	7	held	hold	VBN
8691	2281	8	by	by	IN
8691	2281	9	a	a	DT
8691	2281	10	single	single	JJ
8691	2281	11	judge	judge	NN
8691	2281	12	.	.	.
8691	2282	1	Until	until	IN
8691	2282	2	the	the	DT
8691	2282	3	latter	latter	JJ
8691	2282	4	half	half	NN
8691	2282	5	of	of	IN
8691	2282	6	the	the	DT
8691	2282	7	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	2282	8	century	century	NN
8691	2282	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2282	10	was	be	VBD
8691	2282	11	not	not	RB
8691	2282	12	uncommon	uncommon	JJ
8691	2282	13	to	to	TO
8691	2282	14	have	have	VB
8691	2282	15	three	three	CD
8691	2282	16	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2282	17	sit	sit	VB
8691	2282	18	together	together	RB
8691	2282	19	in	in	IN
8691	2282	20	county	county	NN
8691	2282	21	or	or	CC
8691	2282	22	city	city	NN
8691	2282	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	2282	24	.	.	.
8691	2283	1	One	one	CD
8691	2283	2	of	of	IN
8691	2283	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2283	4	would	would	MD
8691	2283	5	be	be	VB
8691	2283	6	a	a	DT
8691	2283	7	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	2283	8	and	and	CC
8691	2283	9	the	the	DT
8691	2283	10	others	other	NNS
8691	2283	11	not	not	RB
8691	2283	12	.	.	.
8691	2284	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2284	2	See	see	VB
8691	2284	3	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	2284	4	.	.	.
8691	2285	1	VIII	VIII	NNP
8691	2285	2	.	.	.
8691	2285	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2286	1	In	in	IN
8691	2286	2	cities	city	NNS
8691	2286	3	the	the	DT
8691	2286	4	two	two	CD
8691	2286	5	side	side	NN
8691	2286	6	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2286	7	were	be	VBD
8691	2286	8	generally	generally	RB
8691	2286	9	aldermen	aldermen	JJ
8691	2286	10	.	.	.
8691	2287	1	A	a	DT
8691	2287	2	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	2287	3	thus	thus	RB
8691	2287	4	constituted	constitute	VBD
8691	2287	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2287	6	better	well	RBR
8691	2287	7	adapted	adapt	VBN
8691	2287	8	in	in	IN
8691	2287	9	some	some	DT
8691	2287	10	respects	respect	NNS
8691	2287	11	to	to	IN
8691	2287	12	trying	try	VBG
8691	2287	13	questions	question	NNS
8691	2287	14	of	of	IN
8691	2287	15	fact	fact	NN
8691	2287	16	than	than	IN
8691	2287	17	a	a	DT
8691	2287	18	single	single	JJ
8691	2287	19	judge	judge	NN
8691	2287	20	.	.	.
8691	2288	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2288	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2288	3	a	a	DT
8691	2288	4	jury	jury	NN
8691	2288	5	of	of	IN
8691	2288	6	three	three	CD
8691	2288	7	acting	acting	NN
8691	2288	8	by	by	IN
8691	2288	9	a	a	DT
8691	2288	10	majority	majority	NN
8691	2288	11	.	.	.
8691	2289	1	But	but	CC
8691	2289	2	for	for	IN
8691	2289	3	the	the	DT
8691	2289	4	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	2289	5	of	of	IN
8691	2289	6	a	a	DT
8691	2289	7	jury	jury	NN
8691	2289	8	trial	trial	NN
8691	2289	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2289	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2289	11	unwieldy	unwieldy	JJ
8691	2289	12	,	,	,
8691	2289	13	slow	slow	RB
8691	2289	14	-	-	HYPH
8691	2289	15	moving	moving	JJ
8691	2289	16	and	and	CC
8691	2289	17	uncertain	uncertain	JJ
8691	2289	18	.	.	.
8691	2290	1	In	in	IN
8691	2290	2	most	most	JJS
8691	2290	3	cases	case	NNS
8691	2290	4	any	any	DT
8691	2290	5	question	question	NN
8691	2290	6	of	of	IN
8691	2290	7	law	law	NN
8691	2290	8	or	or	CC
8691	2290	9	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2290	10	practice	practice	NN
8691	2290	11	will	will	MD
8691	2290	12	be	be	VB
8691	2290	13	virtually	virtually	RB
8691	2290	14	decided	decide	VBN
8691	2290	15	by	by	IN
8691	2290	16	the	the	DT
8691	2290	17	presiding	preside	VBG
8691	2290	18	judge	judge	NN
8691	2290	19	,	,	,
8691	2290	20	but	but	CC
8691	2290	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2290	22	will	will	MD
8691	2290	23	usually	usually	RB
8691	2290	24	pause	pause	VB
8691	2290	25	to	to	TO
8691	2290	26	go	go	VB
8691	2290	27	through	through	IN
8691	2290	28	the	the	DT
8691	2290	29	form	form	NN
8691	2290	30	of	of	IN
8691	2290	31	consulting	consult	VBG
8691	2290	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2290	33	associates	associate	NNS
8691	2290	34	.	.	.
8691	2291	1	Occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	2291	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2291	3	will	will	MD
8691	2291	4	overrule	overrule	VB
8691	2291	5	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2291	6	,	,	,
8691	2291	7	and	and	CC
8691	2291	8	in	in	IN
8691	2291	9	such	such	JJ
8691	2291	10	case	case	NN
8691	2291	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2291	12	will	will	MD
8691	2291	13	be	be	VB
8691	2291	14	apt	apt	JJ
8691	2291	15	to	to	TO
8691	2291	16	be	be	VB
8691	2291	17	by	by	IN
8691	2291	18	a	a	DT
8691	2291	19	misunderstanding	misunderstanding	NN
8691	2291	20	or	or	CC
8691	2291	21	misapplication	misapplication	NN
8691	2291	22	of	of	IN
8691	2291	23	law	law	NN
8691	2291	24	.	.	.
8691	2292	1	The	the	DT
8691	2292	2	expense	expense	NN
8691	2292	3	of	of	IN
8691	2292	4	three	three	CD
8691	2292	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2292	6	,	,	,
8691	2292	7	however	however	RB
8691	2292	8	moderate	moderate	VB
8691	2292	9	the	the	DT
8691	2292	10	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	2292	11	,	,	,
8691	2292	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	2292	13	also	also	RB
8691	2292	14	weighed	weigh	VBN
8691	2292	15	in	in	IN
8691	2292	16	favor	favor	NN
8691	2292	17	of	of	IN
8691	2292	18	an	an	DT
8691	2292	19	abandonment	abandonment	NN
8691	2292	20	of	of	IN
8691	2292	21	the	the	DT
8691	2292	22	system	system	NN
8691	2292	23	.	.	.
8691	2293	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2293	2	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	2293	3	results	result	VBZ
8691	2293	4	in	in	IN
8691	2293	5	paying	pay	VBG
8691	2293	6	too	too	RB
8691	2293	7	little	little	JJ
8691	2293	8	to	to	IN
8691	2293	9	the	the	DT
8691	2293	10	chief	chief	JJ
8691	2293	11	judge	judge	NN
8691	2293	12	,	,	,
8691	2293	13	and	and	CC
8691	2293	14	too	too	RB
8691	2293	15	much	much	JJ
8691	2293	16	to	to	IN
8691	2293	17	the	the	DT
8691	2293	18	others	other	NNS
8691	2293	19	;	;	:
8691	2293	20	and	and	CC
8691	2293	21	always	always	RB
8691	2293	22	costs	cost	VBZ
8691	2293	23	more	more	JJR
8691	2293	24	than	than	IN
8691	2293	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2293	26	would	would	MD
8691	2293	27	to	to	TO
8691	2293	28	pay	pay	VB
8691	2293	29	one	one	CD
8691	2293	30	man	man	NN
8691	2293	31	a	a	DT
8691	2293	32	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	2293	33	salary	salary	NN
8691	2293	34	.	.	.
8691	2294	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2294	2	have	have	VBP
8691	2294	3	not	not	RB
8691	2294	4	the	the	DT
8691	2294	5	need	need	NN
8691	2294	6	of	of	IN
8691	2294	7	several	several	JJ
8691	2294	8	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2294	9	to	to	TO
8691	2294	10	hold	hold	VB
8691	2294	11	a	a	DT
8691	2294	12	trial	trial	NN
8691	2294	13	court	court	NN
8691	2294	14	,	,	,
8691	2294	15	which	which	WDT
8691	2294	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	2294	17	felt	feel	VBN
8691	2294	18	in	in	IN
8691	2294	19	many	many	JJ
8691	2294	20	countries	country	NNS
8691	2294	21	.	.	.
8691	2295	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2295	2	use	use	VBP
8691	2295	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2295	4	for	for	IN
8691	2295	5	a	a	DT
8691	2295	6	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2295	7	which	which	WDT
8691	2295	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2295	9	juries	jury	NNS
8691	2295	10	supply	supply	VBP
8691	2295	11	.	.	.
8691	2296	1	For	for	IN
8691	2296	2	similar	similar	JJ
8691	2296	3	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	2296	4	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	2296	5	have	have	VBP
8691	2296	6	not	not	RB
8691	2296	7	seen	see	VBN
8691	2296	8	any	any	DT
8691	2296	9	occasion	occasion	NN
8691	2296	10	for	for	IN
8691	2296	11	organizing	organize	VBG
8691	2296	12	special	special	JJ
8691	2296	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	2296	14	,	,	,
8691	2296	15	such	such	JJ
8691	2296	16	as	as	IN
8691	2296	17	are	be	VBP
8691	2296	18	the	the	DT
8691	2296	19	German	German	NNP
8691	2296	20	_	_	NNP
8691	2296	21	Gewerbegerichte	Gewerbegerichte	NNP
8691	2296	22	_	_	NNP
8691	2296	23	and	and	CC
8691	2296	24	_	_	NNP
8691	2296	25	Kaufmannsgerichte	Kaufmannsgerichte	NNP
8691	2296	26	,	,	,
8691	2296	27	_	_	NNP
8691	2296	28	to	to	TO
8691	2296	29	try	try	VB
8691	2296	30	special	special	JJ
8691	2296	31	classes	class	NNS
8691	2296	32	of	of	IN
8691	2296	33	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2296	34	.	.	.
8691	2297	1	A	a	DT
8691	2297	2	jury	jury	NN
8691	2297	3	of	of	IN
8691	2297	4	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	2297	5	will	will	MD
8691	2297	6	be	be	VB
8691	2297	7	apt	apt	JJ
8691	2297	8	to	to	TO
8691	2297	9	contain	contain	VB
8691	2297	10	some	some	DT
8691	2297	11	men	man	NNS
8691	2297	12	who	who	WP
8691	2297	13	will	will	MD
8691	2297	14	adequately	adequately	RB
8691	2297	15	represent	represent	VB
8691	2297	16	those	those	DT
8691	2297	17	interested	interested	JJ
8691	2297	18	in	in	IN
8691	2297	19	any	any	DT
8691	2297	20	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	2297	21	industrial	industrial	JJ
8691	2297	22	or	or	CC
8691	2297	23	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	2297	24	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	2297	25	.	.	.
8691	2298	1	Petty	petty	JJ
8691	2298	2	suits	suit	NNS
8691	2298	3	not	not	RB
8691	2298	4	of	of	IN
8691	2298	5	an	an	DT
8691	2298	6	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	2298	7	nature	nature	NN
8691	2298	8	must	must	MD
8691	2298	9	generally	generally	RB
8691	2298	10	be	be	VB
8691	2298	11	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2298	12	before	before	RB
8691	2298	13	a	a	DT
8691	2298	14	justice	justice	NN
8691	2298	15	of	of	IN
8691	2298	16	the	the	DT
8691	2298	17	peace	peace	NN
8691	2298	18	,	,	,
8691	2298	19	who	who	WP
8691	2298	20	disposes	dispose	VBZ
8691	2298	21	of	of	IN
8691	2298	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2298	23	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2298	24	,	,	,
8691	2298	25	both	both	CC
8691	2298	26	as	as	IN
8691	2298	27	to	to	IN
8691	2298	28	matters	matter	NNS
8691	2298	29	of	of	IN
8691	2298	30	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2298	31	and	and	CC
8691	2298	32	fact	fact	NN
8691	2298	33	,	,	,
8691	2298	34	but	but	CC
8691	2298	35	subject	subject	JJ
8691	2298	36	to	to	IN
8691	2298	37	an	an	DT
8691	2298	38	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2298	39	to	to	IN
8691	2298	40	a	a	DT
8691	2298	41	higher	high	JJR
8691	2298	42	court	court	NN
8691	2298	43	in	in	IN
8691	2298	44	which	which	WDT
8691	2298	45	a	a	DT
8691	2298	46	jury	jury	NN
8691	2298	47	trial	trial	NN
8691	2298	48	can	can	MD
8691	2298	49	be	be	VB
8691	2298	50	had	have	VBN
8691	2298	51	.	.	.
8691	2299	1	In	in	IN
8691	2299	2	some	some	DT
8691	2299	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2299	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2299	5	can	can	MD
8691	2299	6	summon	summon	VB
8691	2299	7	in	in	IN
8691	2299	8	a	a	DT
8691	2299	9	jury	jury	NN
8691	2299	10	of	of	IN
8691	2299	11	six	six	CD
8691	2299	12	and	and	CC
8691	2299	13	leave	leave	VB
8691	2299	14	the	the	DT
8691	2299	15	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2299	16	to	to	IN
8691	2299	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2299	18	determination	determination	NN
8691	2299	19	.	.	.
8691	2300	1	The	the	DT
8691	2300	2	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	2300	3	before	before	IN
8691	2300	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2300	5	are	be	VBP
8691	2300	6	usually	usually	RB
8691	2300	7	in	in	IN
8691	2300	8	the	the	DT
8691	2300	9	same	same	JJ
8691	2300	10	form	form	NN
8691	2300	11	as	as	IN
8691	2300	12	in	in	IN
8691	2300	13	the	the	DT
8691	2300	14	higher	high	JJR
8691	2300	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	2300	16	.	.	.
8691	2301	1	In	in	IN
8691	2301	2	jury	jury	NN
8691	2301	3	trials	trial	NNS
8691	2301	4	of	of	IN
8691	2301	5	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2301	6	causes	cause	VBZ
8691	2301	7	the	the	DT
8691	2301	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2301	9	function	function	NN
8691	2301	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2301	11	,	,	,
8691	2301	12	so	so	RB
8691	2301	13	far	far	RB
8691	2301	14	as	as	IN
8691	2301	15	possible	possible	JJ
8691	2301	16	,	,	,
8691	2301	17	divided	divide	VBN
8691	2301	18	into	into	IN
8691	2301	19	two	two	CD
8691	2301	20	distinct	distinct	JJ
8691	2301	21	parts	part	NNS
8691	2301	22	.	.	.
8691	2302	1	All	all	DT
8691	2302	2	questions	question	NNS
8691	2302	3	of	of	IN
8691	2302	4	pure	pure	JJ
8691	2302	5	law	law	NN
8691	2302	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2302	7	decided	decide	VBN
8691	2302	8	by	by	IN
8691	2302	9	the	the	DT
8691	2302	10	judge	judge	NN
8691	2302	11	alone	alone	RB
8691	2302	12	.	.	.
8691	2303	1	All	all	DT
8691	2303	2	questions	question	NNS
8691	2303	3	of	of	IN
8691	2303	4	pure	pure	JJ
8691	2303	5	fact	fact	NN
8691	2303	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2303	7	decided	decide	VBN
8691	2303	8	by	by	IN
8691	2303	9	the	the	DT
8691	2303	10	jury	jury	NN
8691	2303	11	alone	alone	RB
8691	2303	12	.	.	.
8691	2304	1	All	all	DT
8691	2304	2	questions	question	NNS
8691	2304	3	turning	turn	VBG
8691	2304	4	on	on	IN
8691	2304	5	the	the	DT
8691	2304	6	application	application	NN
8691	2304	7	of	of	IN
8691	2304	8	the	the	DT
8691	2304	9	law	law	NN
8691	2304	10	to	to	IN
8691	2304	11	the	the	DT
8691	2304	12	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2304	13	are	be	VBP
8691	2304	14	decided	decide	VBN
8691	2304	15	by	by	IN
8691	2304	16	the	the	DT
8691	2304	17	jury	jury	NN
8691	2304	18	under	under	IN
8691	2304	19	instructions	instruction	NNS
8691	2304	20	from	from	IN
8691	2304	21	the	the	DT
8691	2304	22	judge	judge	NN
8691	2304	23	as	as	IN
8691	2304	24	to	to	IN
8691	2304	25	what	what	WP
8691	2304	26	applications	application	NNS
8691	2304	27	of	of	IN
8691	2304	28	the	the	DT
8691	2304	29	law	law	NN
8691	2304	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2304	31	would	would	MD
8691	2304	32	be	be	VB
8691	2304	33	competent	competent	JJ
8691	2304	34	for	for	IN
8691	2304	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2304	36	to	to	TO
8691	2304	37	make	make	VB
8691	2304	38	under	under	IN
8691	2304	39	the	the	DT
8691	2304	40	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2304	41	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	2304	42	which	which	WDT
8691	2304	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2304	44	may	may	MD
8691	2304	45	find	find	VB
8691	2304	46	to	to	TO
8691	2304	47	have	have	VB
8691	2304	48	existed	exist	VBN
8691	2304	49	.	.	.
8691	2305	1	The	the	DT
8691	2305	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	2305	3	also	also	RB
8691	2305	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2305	5	a	a	DT
8691	2305	6	large	large	JJ
8691	2305	7	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
8691	2305	8	power	power	NN
8691	2305	9	in	in	IN
8691	2305	10	minor	minor	JJ
8691	2305	11	matters	matter	NNS
8691	2305	12	arising	arise	VBG
8691	2305	13	in	in	IN
8691	2305	14	the	the	DT
8691	2305	15	course	course	NN
8691	2305	16	of	of	IN
8691	2305	17	the	the	DT
8691	2305	18	suit	suit	NN
8691	2305	19	.	.	.
8691	2306	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2306	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2306	3	for	for	IN
8691	2306	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2306	5	to	to	TO
8691	2306	6	say	say	VB
8691	2306	7	when	when	WRB
8691	2306	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2306	9	shall	shall	MD
8691	2306	10	be	be	VB
8691	2306	11	tried	try	VBN
8691	2306	12	;	;	:
8691	2306	13	whether	whether	IN
8691	2306	14	the	the	DT
8691	2306	15	written	write	VBN
8691	2306	16	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	2306	17	are	be	VBP
8691	2306	18	in	in	IN
8691	2306	19	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2306	20	shape	shape	NN
8691	2306	21	,	,	,
8691	2306	22	and	and	CC
8691	2306	23	if	if	IN
8691	2306	24	not	not	RB
8691	2306	25	whether	whether	IN
8691	2306	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2306	27	may	may	MD
8691	2306	28	be	be	VB
8691	2306	29	amended	amend	VBN
8691	2306	30	;	;	:
8691	2306	31	and	and	CC
8691	2306	32	in	in	IN
8691	2306	33	what	what	WDT
8691	2306	34	order	order	NN
8691	2306	35	and	and	CC
8691	2306	36	within	within	IN
8691	2306	37	what	what	WP
8691	2306	38	limits	limit	VBZ
8691	2306	39	the	the	DT
8691	2306	40	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2306	41	may	may	MD
8691	2306	42	be	be	VB
8691	2306	43	introduced	introduce	VBN
8691	2306	44	.	.	.
8691	2307	1	No	no	DT
8691	2307	2	countries	country	NNS
8691	2307	3	in	in	IN
8691	2307	4	the	the	DT
8691	2307	5	world	world	NN
8691	2307	6	have	have	VBP
8691	2307	7	so	so	RB
8691	2307	8	artificial	artificial	JJ
8691	2307	9	a	a	DT
8691	2307	10	set	set	NN
8691	2307	11	of	of	IN
8691	2307	12	rules	rule	NNS
8691	2307	13	of	of	IN
8691	2307	14	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2307	15	as	as	IN
8691	2307	16	England	England	NNP
8691	2307	17	and	and	CC
8691	2307	18	the	the	DT
8691	2307	19	United	United	NNP
8691	2307	20	States	States	NNP
8691	2307	21	.	.	.
8691	2308	1	This	this	DT
8691	2308	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2308	3	because	because	IN
8691	2308	4	in	in	IN
8691	2308	5	no	no	DT
8691	2308	6	other	other	JJ
8691	2308	7	country	country	NN
8691	2308	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2308	9	the	the	DT
8691	2308	10	right	right	NN
8691	2308	11	to	to	IN
8691	2308	12	a	a	DT
8691	2308	13	jury	jury	NN
8691	2308	14	trial	trial	NN
8691	2308	15	so	so	RB
8691	2308	16	extensive	extensive	JJ
8691	2308	17	.	.	.
8691	2309	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	2309	2	of	of	IN
8691	2309	3	these	these	DT
8691	2309	4	rules	rule	NNS
8691	2309	5	date	date	VBP
8691	2309	6	back	back	RB
8691	2309	7	to	to	IN
8691	2309	8	the	the	DT
8691	2309	9	early	early	JJ
8691	2309	10	history	history	NN
8691	2309	11	of	of	IN
8691	2309	12	the	the	DT
8691	2309	13	English	english	JJ
8691	2309	14	common	common	JJ
8691	2309	15	law	law	NN
8691	2309	16	.	.	.
8691	2310	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2310	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2310	3	a	a	DT
8691	2310	4	time	time	NN
8691	2310	5	of	of	IN
8691	2310	6	general	general	JJ
8691	2310	7	illiteracy	illiteracy	NN
8691	2310	8	.	.	.
8691	2311	1	The	the	DT
8691	2311	2	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	2311	3	juror	juror	NN
8691	2311	4	could	could	MD
8691	2311	5	not	not	RB
8691	2311	6	read	read	VB
8691	2311	7	or	or	CC
8691	2311	8	write	write	VB
8691	2311	9	.	.	.
8691	2312	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2312	2	powers	power	NNS
8691	2312	3	of	of	IN
8691	2312	4	reasoning	reasoning	NN
8691	2312	5	and	and	CC
8691	2312	6	discrimination	discrimination	NN
8691	2312	7	had	have	VBD
8691	2312	8	had	have	VBN
8691	2312	9	little	little	JJ
8691	2312	10	or	or	CC
8691	2312	11	no	no	DT
8691	2312	12	cultivation	cultivation	NN
8691	2312	13	.	.	.
8691	2313	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2313	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2313	3	thought	think	VBN
8691	2313	4	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
8691	2313	5	to	to	TO
8691	2313	6	allow	allow	VB
8691	2313	7	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2313	8	to	to	TO
8691	2313	9	listen	listen	VB
8691	2313	10	to	to	IN
8691	2313	11	any	any	DT
8691	2313	12	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2313	13	that	that	WDT
8691	2313	14	was	be	VBD
8691	2313	15	not	not	RB
8691	2313	16	of	of	IN
8691	2313	17	the	the	DT
8691	2313	18	clearest	clear	JJS
8691	2313	19	and	and	CC
8691	2313	20	best	good	JJS
8691	2313	21	kind	kind	NN
8691	2313	22	.	.	.
8691	2314	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2314	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2314	3	thought	think	VBN
8691	2314	4	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2314	5	to	to	TO
8691	2314	6	bring	bring	VB
8691	2314	7	all	all	DT
8691	2314	8	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	2314	9	in	in	IN
8691	2314	10	person	person	NN
8691	2314	11	before	before	IN
8691	2314	12	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2314	13	and	and	CC
8691	2314	14	let	let	VB
8691	2314	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2314	16	hear	hear	VB
8691	2314	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2314	18	voice	voice	NN
8691	2314	19	and	and	CC
8691	2314	20	look	look	VB
8691	2314	21	into	into	IN
8691	2314	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2314	23	faces	face	NNS
8691	2314	24	in	in	IN
8691	2314	25	order	order	NN
8691	2314	26	to	to	TO
8691	2314	27	give	give	VB
8691	2314	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2314	29	the	the	DT
8691	2314	30	fullest	full	JJS
8691	2314	31	possible	possible	JJ
8691	2314	32	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	2314	33	to	to	TO
8691	2314	34	determine	determine	VB
8691	2314	35	whether	whether	IN
8691	2314	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2314	37	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2314	38	was	be	VBD
8691	2314	39	worthy	worthy	JJ
8691	2314	40	of	of	IN
8691	2314	41	credit	credit	NN
8691	2314	42	.	.	.
8691	2315	1	But	but	CC
8691	2315	2	while	while	IN
8691	2315	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2315	4	rules	rule	NNS
8691	2315	5	of	of	IN
8691	2315	6	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2315	7	were	be	VBD
8691	2315	8	devised	devise	VBN
8691	2315	9	for	for	IN
8691	2315	10	jury	jury	NN
8691	2315	11	trials	trial	NNS
8691	2315	12	,	,	,
8691	2315	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2315	14	are	be	VBP
8691	2315	15	applied	apply	VBN
8691	2315	16	with	with	IN
8691	2315	17	equal	equal	JJ
8691	2315	18	rigidity	rigidity	NN
8691	2315	19	in	in	IN
8691	2315	20	all	all	DT
8691	2315	21	trials	trial	NNS
8691	2315	22	.	.	.
8691	2316	1	A	a	DT
8691	2316	2	jury	jury	NN
8691	2316	3	may	may	MD
8691	2316	4	be	be	VB
8691	2316	5	waived	waive	VBN
8691	2316	6	;	;	:
8691	2316	7	a	a	DT
8691	2316	8	single	single	JJ
8691	2316	9	judge	judge	NN
8691	2316	10	may	may	MD
8691	2316	11	hear	hear	VB
8691	2316	12	the	the	DT
8691	2316	13	cause	cause	NN
8691	2316	14	;	;	:
8691	2316	15	and	and	CC
8691	2316	16	yet	yet	RB
8691	2316	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2316	18	must	must	MD
8691	2316	19	rule	rule	VB
8691	2316	20	out	out	IN
8691	2316	21	of	of	IN
8691	2316	22	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	2316	23	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	2316	24	would	would	MD
8691	2316	25	have	have	VB
8691	2316	26	been	be	VBN
8691	2316	27	inadmissible	inadmissible	JJ
8691	2316	28	if	if	IN
8691	2316	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2316	30	had	have	VBD
8691	2316	31	been	be	VBN
8691	2316	32	made	make	VBN
8691	2316	33	the	the	DT
8691	2316	34	subject	subject	NN
8691	2316	35	of	of	IN
8691	2316	36	a	a	DT
8691	2316	37	jury	jury	NN
8691	2316	38	trial	trial	NN
8691	2316	39	.	.	.
8691	2317	1	Much	much	RB
8691	2317	2	that	that	IN
8691	2317	3	in	in	IN
8691	2317	4	other	other	JJ
8691	2317	5	countries	country	NNS
8691	2317	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2317	7	helpful	helpful	JJ
8691	2317	8	in	in	IN
8691	2317	9	reaching	reach	VBG
8691	2317	10	a	a	DT
8691	2317	11	just	just	JJ
8691	2317	12	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	2317	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	2317	14	in	in	IN
8691	2317	15	this	this	DT
8691	2317	16	manner	manner	NN
8691	2317	17	shut	shut	VBD
8691	2317	18	out	out	RP
8691	2317	19	in	in	IN
8691	2317	20	American	american	JJ
8691	2317	21	courts	court	NNS
8691	2317	22	.	.	.
8691	2318	1	A	a	DT
8691	2318	2	man	man	NN
8691	2318	3	of	of	IN
8691	2318	4	the	the	DT
8691	2318	5	highest	high	JJS
8691	2318	6	character	character	NN
8691	2318	7	,	,	,
8691	2318	8	for	for	IN
8691	2318	9	instance	instance	NN
8691	2318	10	,	,	,
8691	2318	11	may	may	MD
8691	2318	12	say	say	VB
8691	2318	13	before	before	IN
8691	2318	14	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	2318	15	listeners	listener	NNS
8691	2318	16	that	that	WDT
8691	2318	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2318	18	saw	see	VBD
8691	2318	19	a	a	DT
8691	2318	20	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2318	21	person	person	NN
8691	2318	22	shoot	shoot	VB
8691	2318	23	and	and	CC
8691	2318	24	kill	kill	VB
8691	2318	25	another	another	DT
8691	2318	26	,	,	,
8691	2318	27	and	and	CC
8691	2318	28	state	state	NN
8691	2318	29	how	how	WRB
8691	2318	30	the	the	DT
8691	2318	31	whole	whole	JJ
8691	2318	32	thing	thing	NN
8691	2318	33	happened	happen	VBD
8691	2318	34	.	.	.
8691	2319	1	The	the	DT
8691	2319	2	person	person	NN
8691	2319	3	thus	thus	RB
8691	2319	4	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2319	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2319	6	sued	sue	VBN
8691	2319	7	for	for	IN
8691	2319	8	damages	damage	NNS
8691	2319	9	under	under	IN
8691	2319	10	a	a	DT
8691	2319	11	statute	statute	NN
8691	2319	12	permitting	permit	VBG
8691	2319	13	such	such	PDT
8691	2319	14	a	a	DT
8691	2319	15	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	2319	16	by	by	IN
8691	2319	17	the	the	DT
8691	2319	18	representatives	representative	NNS
8691	2319	19	of	of	IN
8691	2319	20	the	the	DT
8691	2319	21	man	man	NN
8691	2319	22	shot	shoot	VBD
8691	2319	23	.	.	.
8691	2320	1	Before	before	IN
8691	2320	2	the	the	DT
8691	2320	3	trial	trial	NN
8691	2320	4	the	the	DT
8691	2320	5	witness	witness	NN
8691	2320	6	of	of	IN
8691	2320	7	the	the	DT
8691	2320	8	act	act	NN
8691	2320	9	dies	die	VBZ
8691	2320	10	.	.	.
8691	2321	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2321	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2321	3	the	the	DT
8691	2321	4	sole	sole	JJ
8691	2321	5	witness	witness	NN
8691	2321	6	.	.	.
8691	2322	1	There	there	EX
8691	2322	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2322	3	no	no	DT
8691	2322	4	other	other	JJ
8691	2322	5	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2322	6	to	to	TO
8691	2322	7	be	be	VB
8691	2322	8	had	have	VBN
8691	2322	9	.	.	.
8691	2323	1	Under	under	IN
8691	2323	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2323	3	system	system	NN
8691	2323	4	of	of	IN
8691	2323	5	practice	practice	NN
8691	2323	6	,	,	,
8691	2323	7	those	those	DT
8691	2323	8	to	to	IN
8691	2323	9	whom	whom	WP
8691	2323	10	the	the	DT
8691	2323	11	statement	statement	NN
8691	2323	12	was	be	VBD
8691	2323	13	made	make	VBN
8691	2323	14	can	can	MD
8691	2323	15	not	not	RB
8691	2323	16	be	be	VB
8691	2323	17	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2323	18	to	to	TO
8691	2323	19	testify	testify	VB
8691	2323	20	to	to	IN
8691	2323	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2323	22	.	.	.
8691	2324	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	2324	2	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2324	3	would	would	MD
8691	2324	4	be	be	VB
8691	2324	5	"	"	``
8691	2324	6	hearsay	hearsay	NNP
8691	2324	7	.	.	.
8691	2324	8	"	"	''
8691	2325	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2325	2	would	would	MD
8691	2325	3	put	put	VB
8691	2325	4	before	before	IN
8691	2325	5	the	the	DT
8691	2325	6	jury	jury	NN
8691	2325	7	two	two	CD
8691	2325	8	questions	question	NNS
8691	2325	9	,	,	,
8691	2325	10	first	first	RB
8691	2325	11	whether	whether	IN
8691	2325	12	such	such	PDT
8691	2325	13	a	a	DT
8691	2325	14	statement	statement	NN
8691	2325	15	was	be	VBD
8691	2325	16	really	really	RB
8691	2325	17	made	make	VBN
8691	2325	18	,	,	,
8691	2325	19	and	and	CC
8691	2325	20	then	then	RB
8691	2325	21	whether	whether	IN
8691	2325	22	,	,	,
8691	2325	23	if	if	IN
8691	2325	24	made	make	VBN
8691	2325	25	,	,	,
8691	2325	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2325	27	was	be	VBD
8691	2325	28	true	true	JJ
8691	2325	29	.	.	.
8691	2326	1	The	the	DT
8691	2326	2	law	law	NN
8691	2326	3	of	of	IN
8691	2326	4	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2326	5	says	say	VBZ
8691	2326	6	that	that	IN
8691	2326	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2326	8	ought	ought	MD
8691	2326	9	not	not	RB
8691	2326	10	to	to	TO
8691	2326	11	be	be	VB
8691	2326	12	perplexed	perplex	VBN
8691	2326	13	by	by	IN
8691	2326	14	questions	question	NNS
8691	2326	15	upon	upon	IN
8691	2326	16	questions	question	NNS
8691	2326	17	.	.	.
8691	2327	1	The	the	DT
8691	2327	2	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	2327	3	of	of	IN
8691	2327	4	American	american	JJ
8691	2327	5	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	2327	6	of	of	IN
8691	2327	7	late	late	JJ
8691	2327	8	years	year	NNS
8691	2327	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	2327	10	been	be	VBN
8691	2327	11	strongly	strongly	RB
8691	2327	12	toward	toward	IN
8691	2327	13	removing	remove	VBG
8691	2327	14	some	some	DT
8691	2327	15	of	of	IN
8691	2327	16	these	these	DT
8691	2327	17	artificial	artificial	JJ
8691	2327	18	bars	bar	NNS
8691	2327	19	to	to	IN
8691	2327	20	getting	get	VBG
8691	2327	21	at	at	IN
8691	2327	22	the	the	DT
8691	2327	23	truth	truth	NN
8691	2327	24	.	.	.
8691	2328	1	The	the	DT
8691	2328	2	common	common	JJ
8691	2328	3	law	law	NN
8691	2328	4	thought	think	VBD
8691	2328	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2328	6	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
8691	2328	7	to	to	TO
8691	2328	8	allow	allow	VB
8691	2328	9	a	a	DT
8691	2328	10	jury	jury	NN
8691	2328	11	to	to	TO
8691	2328	12	hear	hear	VB
8691	2328	13	any	any	DT
8691	2328	14	witness	witness	NN
8691	2328	15	not	not	RB
8691	2328	16	under	under	IN
8691	2328	17	oath	oath	NN
8691	2328	18	,	,	,
8691	2328	19	nor	nor	CC
8691	2328	20	under	under	IN
8691	2328	21	such	such	PDT
8691	2328	22	an	an	DT
8691	2328	23	oath	oath	NN
8691	2328	24	as	as	IN
8691	2328	25	implied	imply	VBD
8691	2328	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2328	27	belief	belief	NN
8691	2328	28	in	in	IN
8691	2328	29	the	the	DT
8691	2328	30	existence	existence	NN
8691	2328	31	of	of	IN
8691	2328	32	a	a	DT
8691	2328	33	God	God	NNP
8691	2328	34	,	,	,
8691	2328	35	or	or	CC
8691	2328	36	any	any	DT
8691	2328	37	witness	witness	NN
8691	2328	38	having	have	VBG
8691	2328	39	a	a	DT
8691	2328	40	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
8691	2328	41	interest	interest	NN
8691	2328	42	,	,	,
8691	2328	43	in	in	IN
8691	2328	44	the	the	DT
8691	2328	45	event	event	NN
8691	2328	46	of	of	IN
8691	2328	47	the	the	DT
8691	2328	48	cause	cause	NN
8691	2328	49	.	.	.
8691	2329	1	An	an	DT
8691	2329	2	atheist	atheist	NN
8691	2329	3	or	or	CC
8691	2329	4	an	an	DT
8691	2329	5	agnostic	agnostic	JJ
8691	2329	6	could	could	MD
8691	2329	7	not	not	RB
8691	2329	8	testify	testify	VB
8691	2329	9	.	.	.
8691	2330	1	The	the	DT
8691	2330	2	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2330	3	and	and	CC
8691	2330	4	the	the	DT
8691	2330	5	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2330	6	could	could	MD
8691	2330	7	not	not	RB
8691	2330	8	.	.	.
8691	2331	1	These	these	DT
8691	2331	2	restrictions	restriction	NNS
8691	2331	3	have	have	VBP
8691	2331	4	been	be	VBN
8691	2331	5	almost	almost	RB
8691	2331	6	everywhere	everywhere	RB
8691	2331	7	repealed	repeal	VBN
8691	2331	8	.	.	.
8691	2332	1	The	the	DT
8691	2332	2	trial	trial	NN
8691	2332	3	judge	judge	NN
8691	2332	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2332	5	also	also	RB
8691	2332	6	,	,	,
8691	2332	7	and	and	CC
8691	2332	8	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	2332	9	,	,	,
8691	2332	10	a	a	DT
8691	2332	11	large	large	JJ
8691	2332	12	discretionary	discretionary	JJ
8691	2332	13	power	power	NN
8691	2332	14	in	in	IN
8691	2332	15	excluding	exclude	VBG
8691	2332	16	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2332	17	which	which	WDT
8691	2332	18	has	have	VBZ
8691	2332	19	only	only	RB
8691	2332	20	a	a	DT
8691	2332	21	remote	remote	JJ
8691	2332	22	bearing	bearing	NN
8691	2332	23	on	on	IN
8691	2332	24	the	the	DT
8691	2332	25	case	case	NN
8691	2332	26	,	,	,
8691	2332	27	and	and	CC
8691	2332	28	in	in	IN
8691	2332	29	limiting	limit	VBG
8691	2332	30	or	or	CC
8691	2332	31	extending	extend	VBG
8691	2332	32	the	the	DT
8691	2332	33	examination	examination	NN
8691	2332	34	of	of	IN
8691	2332	35	a	a	DT
8691	2332	36	witness	witness	NN
8691	2332	37	so	so	IN
8691	2332	38	as	as	IN
8691	2332	39	on	on	IN
8691	2332	40	the	the	DT
8691	2332	41	one	one	CD
8691	2332	42	hand	hand	NN
8691	2332	43	to	to	TO
8691	2332	44	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	2332	45	needless	needless	JJ
8691	2332	46	repetition	repetition	NN
8691	2332	47	,	,	,
8691	2332	48	and	and	CC
8691	2332	49	on	on	IN
8691	2332	50	the	the	DT
8691	2332	51	other	other	JJ
8691	2332	52	to	to	TO
8691	2332	53	get	get	VB
8691	2332	54	out	out	RP
8691	2332	55	the	the	DT
8691	2332	56	truth	truth	NN
8691	2332	57	and	and	CC
8691	2332	58	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	2332	59	but	but	IN
8691	2332	60	the	the	DT
8691	2332	61	truth	truth	NN
8691	2332	62	.	.	.
8691	2333	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2333	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	2333	3	similar	similar	JJ
8691	2333	4	authority	authority	NN
8691	2333	5	to	to	TO
8691	2333	6	restrain	restrain	VB
8691	2333	7	the	the	DT
8691	2333	8	arguments	argument	NNS
8691	2333	9	of	of	IN
8691	2333	10	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2333	11	within	within	IN
8691	2333	12	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	2333	13	limits	limit	NNS
8691	2333	14	.	.	.
8691	2334	1	A	a	DT
8691	2334	2	trial	trial	NN
8691	2334	3	judge	judge	NN
8691	2334	4	suddenly	suddenly	RB
8691	2334	5	called	call	VBD
8691	2334	6	upon	upon	IN
8691	2334	7	to	to	TO
8691	2334	8	make	make	VB
8691	2334	9	a	a	DT
8691	2334	10	ruling	ruling	NN
8691	2334	11	on	on	IN
8691	2334	12	some	some	DT
8691	2334	13	point	point	NN
8691	2334	14	of	of	IN
8691	2334	15	law	law	NN
8691	2334	16	in	in	IN
8691	2334	17	the	the	DT
8691	2334	18	progress	progress	NN
8691	2334	19	of	of	IN
8691	2334	20	a	a	DT
8691	2334	21	trial	trial	NN
8691	2334	22	may	may	MD
8691	2334	23	make	make	VB
8691	2334	24	a	a	DT
8691	2334	25	wrong	wrong	JJ
8691	2334	26	one	one	NN
8691	2334	27	.	.	.
8691	2335	1	If	if	IN
8691	2335	2	so	so	RB
8691	2335	3	,	,	,
8691	2335	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2335	5	may	may	MD
8691	2335	6	have	have	VB
8691	2335	7	an	an	DT
8691	2335	8	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	2335	9	to	to	TO
8691	2335	10	correct	correct	VB
8691	2335	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2335	12	at	at	IN
8691	2335	13	a	a	DT
8691	2335	14	later	later	JJ
8691	2335	15	stage	stage	NN
8691	2335	16	of	of	IN
8691	2335	17	the	the	DT
8691	2335	18	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	2335	19	.	.	.
8691	2336	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2336	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	2336	3	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	2336	4	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2336	5	which	which	WDT
8691	2336	6	should	should	MD
8691	2336	7	have	have	VB
8691	2336	8	been	be	VBN
8691	2336	9	excluded	exclude	VBN
8691	2336	10	.	.	.
8691	2337	1	In	in	IN
8691	2337	2	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2337	3	charge	charge	NN
8691	2337	4	to	to	IN
8691	2337	5	the	the	DT
8691	2337	6	jury	jury	NN
8691	2337	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2337	8	may	may	MD
8691	2337	9	instruct	instruct	VB
8691	2337	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2337	11	to	to	TO
8691	2337	12	disregard	disregard	VB
8691	2337	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2337	14	,	,	,
8691	2337	15	and	and	CC
8691	2337	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2337	17	error	error	NN
8691	2337	18	will	will	MD
8691	2337	19	thus	thus	RB
8691	2337	20	be	be	VB
8691	2337	21	cured	cure	VBN
8691	2337	22	.	.	.
8691	2338	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2338	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	2338	3	excluded	exclude	VBN
8691	2338	4	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2338	5	which	which	WDT
8691	2338	6	should	should	MD
8691	2338	7	have	have	VB
8691	2338	8	been	be	VBN
8691	2338	9	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	2338	10	.	.	.
8691	2339	1	Before	before	IN
8691	2339	2	the	the	DT
8691	2339	3	case	case	NN
8691	2339	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2339	5	closed	close	VBN
8691	2339	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2339	7	can	can	MD
8691	2339	8	change	change	VB
8691	2339	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2339	10	ruling	ruling	NN
8691	2339	11	and	and	CC
8691	2339	12	allow	allow	VB
8691	2339	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2339	14	to	to	TO
8691	2339	15	come	come	VB
8691	2339	16	in	in	RP
8691	2339	17	.	.	.
8691	2340	1	But	but	CC
8691	2340	2	so	so	RB
8691	2340	3	long	long	RB
8691	2340	4	as	as	IN
8691	2340	5	any	any	DT
8691	2340	6	ruling	ruling	NN
8691	2340	7	stands	stand	VBZ
8691	2340	8	unchanged	unchanged	JJ
8691	2340	9	,	,	,
8691	2340	10	whether	whether	IN
8691	2340	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2340	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2340	13	in	in	IN
8691	2340	14	accordance	accordance	NN
8691	2340	15	with	with	IN
8691	2340	16	law	law	NN
8691	2340	17	or	or	CC
8691	2340	18	not	not	RB
8691	2340	19	,	,	,
8691	2340	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2340	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	2340	22	the	the	DT
8691	2340	23	law	law	NN
8691	2340	24	of	of	IN
8691	2340	25	the	the	DT
8691	2340	26	case	case	NN
8691	2340	27	for	for	IN
8691	2340	28	the	the	DT
8691	2340	29	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	2340	30	of	of	IN
8691	2340	31	the	the	DT
8691	2340	32	trial	trial	NN
8691	2340	33	.	.	.
8691	2341	1	Counsel	Counsel	NNP
8691	2341	2	may	may	MD
8691	2341	3	endeavor	endeavor	VB
8691	2341	4	to	to	TO
8691	2341	5	procure	procure	VB
8691	2341	6	a	a	DT
8691	2341	7	reconsideration	reconsideration	NN
8691	2341	8	of	of	IN
8691	2341	9	the	the	DT
8691	2341	10	question	question	NN
8691	2341	11	,	,	,
8691	2341	12	but	but	CC
8691	2341	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2341	14	can	can	MD
8691	2341	15	not	not	RB
8691	2341	16	ask	ask	VB
8691	2341	17	the	the	DT
8691	2341	18	jury	jury	NN
8691	2341	19	to	to	TO
8691	2341	20	adopt	adopt	VB
8691	2341	21	a	a	DT
8691	2341	22	different	different	JJ
8691	2341	23	view	view	NN
8691	2341	24	from	from	IN
8691	2341	25	that	that	DT
8691	2341	26	taken	take	VBN
8691	2341	27	by	by	IN
8691	2341	28	the	the	DT
8691	2341	29	judge	judge	NN
8691	2341	30	.	.	.
8691	2342	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2342	2	only	only	JJ
8691	2342	3	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	2342	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2342	5	by	by	IN
8691	2342	6	a	a	DT
8691	2342	7	motion	motion	NN
8691	2342	8	for	for	IN
8691	2342	9	a	a	DT
8691	2342	10	new	new	JJ
8691	2342	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	2342	12	,	,	,
8691	2342	13	after	after	IN
8691	2342	14	the	the	DT
8691	2342	15	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2342	16	,	,	,
8691	2342	17	or	or	CC
8691	2342	18	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2342	19	in	in	IN
8691	2342	20	error	error	NN
8691	2342	21	before	before	IN
8691	2342	22	a	a	DT
8691	2342	23	higher	high	JJR
8691	2342	24	court	court	NN
8691	2342	25	.	.	.
8691	2343	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2343	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2343	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2343	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2343	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2343	6	Trial	trial	NN
8691	2343	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	2343	8	generally	generally	RB
8691	2343	9	sit	sit	VBP
8691	2343	10	during	during	IN
8691	2343	11	a	a	DT
8691	2343	12	greater	great	JJR
8691	2343	13	number	number	NN
8691	2343	14	of	of	IN
8691	2343	15	hours	hour	NNS
8691	2343	16	in	in	IN
8691	2343	17	the	the	DT
8691	2343	18	day	day	NN
8691	2343	19	than	than	IN
8691	2343	20	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2343	21	courts	court	NNS
8691	2343	22	.	.	.
8691	2344	1	This	this	DT
8691	2344	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2344	3	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	2344	4	true	true	JJ
8691	2344	5	when	when	WRB
8691	2344	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2344	7	are	be	VBP
8691	2344	8	held	hold	VBN
8691	2344	9	for	for	IN
8691	2344	10	short	short	JJ
8691	2344	11	terms	term	NNS
8691	2344	12	in	in	IN
8691	2344	13	a	a	DT
8691	2344	14	country	country	NN
8691	2344	15	shire	shire	NN
8691	2344	16	town	town	NN
8691	2344	17	.	.	.
8691	2345	1	In	in	IN
8691	2345	2	the	the	DT
8691	2345	3	larger	large	JJR
8691	2345	4	cities	city	NNS
8691	2345	5	where	where	WRB
8691	2345	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2345	7	sit	sit	VBP
8691	2345	8	during	during	IN
8691	2345	9	a	a	DT
8691	2345	10	large	large	JJ
8691	2345	11	part	part	NN
8691	2345	12	of	of	IN
8691	2345	13	the	the	DT
8691	2345	14	year	year	NN
8691	2345	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2345	16	generally	generally	RB
8691	2345	17	have	have	VBP
8691	2345	18	established	establish	VBN
8691	2345	19	hours	hour	NNS
8691	2345	20	from	from	IN
8691	2345	21	which	which	WDT
8691	2345	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2345	23	rarely	rarely	RB
8691	2345	24	depart	depart	VBP
8691	2345	25	,	,	,
8691	2345	26	such	such	JJ
8691	2345	27	as	as	IN
8691	2345	28	from	from	IN
8691	2345	29	ten	ten	CD
8691	2345	30	in	in	IN
8691	2345	31	the	the	DT
8691	2345	32	morning	morning	NN
8691	2345	33	to	to	IN
8691	2345	34	five	five	CD
8691	2345	35	in	in	IN
8691	2345	36	the	the	DT
8691	2345	37	afternoon	afternoon	NN
8691	2345	38	,	,	,
8691	2345	39	with	with	IN
8691	2345	40	a	a	DT
8691	2345	41	recess	recess	NN
8691	2345	42	of	of	IN
8691	2345	43	an	an	DT
8691	2345	44	hour	hour	NN
8691	2345	45	for	for	IN
8691	2345	46	lunch	lunch	NN
8691	2345	47	or	or	CC
8691	2345	48	dinner	dinner	NN
8691	2345	49	.	.	.
8691	2346	1	Formerly	formerly	RB
8691	2346	2	nine	nine	CD
8691	2346	3	o'clock	o'clock	NN
8691	2346	4	was	be	VBD
8691	2346	5	a	a	DT
8691	2346	6	more	more	RBR
8691	2346	7	common	common	JJ
8691	2346	8	hour	hour	NN
8691	2346	9	for	for	IN
8691	2346	10	opening	open	VBG
8691	2346	11	court	court	NN
8691	2346	12	.	.	.
8691	2347	1	In	in	IN
8691	2347	2	New	New	NNP
8691	2347	3	York	York	NNP
8691	2347	4	in	in	IN
8691	2347	5	1829	1829	CD
8691	2347	6	the	the	DT
8691	2347	7	sittings	sitting	NNS
8691	2347	8	were	be	VBD
8691	2347	9	from	from	IN
8691	2347	10	eight	eight	CD
8691	2347	11	to	to	TO
8691	2347	12	three	three	CD
8691	2347	13	,	,	,
8691	2347	14	when	when	WRB
8691	2347	15	there	there	EX
8691	2347	16	was	be	VBD
8691	2347	17	a	a	DT
8691	2347	18	recess	recess	NN
8691	2347	19	of	of	IN
8691	2347	20	two	two	CD
8691	2347	21	hours	hour	NNS
8691	2347	22	for	for	IN
8691	2347	23	dinner	dinner	NN
8691	2347	24	,	,	,
8691	2347	25	and	and	CC
8691	2347	26	then	then	RB
8691	2347	27	from	from	IN
8691	2347	28	five	five	CD
8691	2347	29	till	till	IN
8691	2347	30	some	some	DT
8691	2347	31	time	time	NN
8691	2347	32	in	in	IN
8691	2347	33	the	the	DT
8691	2347	34	evening	evening	NN
8691	2347	35	,	,	,
8691	2347	36	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	2347	37	as	as	RB
8691	2347	38	late	late	JJ
8691	2347	39	as	as	IN
8691	2347	40	ten	ten	CD
8691	2347	41	.	.	.
8691	2348	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2348	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2348	3	:	:	:
8691	2348	4	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
8691	2348	5	,	,	,
8691	2348	6	"	"	``
8691	2348	7	Memoirs	Memoirs	NNP
8691	2348	8	of	of	IN
8691	2348	9	William	William	NNP
8691	2348	10	Wirt	Wirt	NNP
8691	2348	11	,	,	,
8691	2348	12	"	"	``
8691	2348	13	II	ii	CD
8691	2348	14	,	,	,
8691	2348	15	231	231	CD
8691	2348	16	.	.	.
8691	2348	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2349	1	The	the	DT
8691	2349	2	modern	modern	JJ
8691	2349	3	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	2349	4	everywhere	everywhere	RB
8691	2349	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2349	6	toward	toward	IN
8691	2349	7	a	a	DT
8691	2349	8	shortening	shortening	NN
8691	2349	9	of	of	IN
8691	2349	10	the	the	DT
8691	2349	11	hours	hour	NNS
8691	2349	12	of	of	IN
8691	2349	13	daily	daily	JJ
8691	2349	14	session	session	NN
8691	2349	15	,	,	,
8691	2349	16	especially	especially	RB
8691	2349	17	when	when	WRB
8691	2349	18	an	an	DT
8691	2349	19	official	official	JJ
8691	2349	20	stenographer	stenographer	NN
8691	2349	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	2349	22	employed	employ	VBN
8691	2349	23	.	.	.
8691	2350	1	The	the	DT
8691	2350	2	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	2350	3	keeps	keep	VBZ
8691	2350	4	a	a	DT
8691	2350	5	docket	docket	NN
8691	2350	6	-	-	HYPH
8691	2350	7	book	book	NN
8691	2350	8	in	in	IN
8691	2350	9	which	which	WDT
8691	2350	10	each	each	DT
8691	2350	11	case	case	NN
8691	2350	12	returned	return	VBD
8691	2350	13	to	to	IN
8691	2350	14	court	court	NN
8691	2350	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	2350	16	entered	enter	VBN
8691	2350	17	and	and	CC
8691	2350	18	numbered	number	VBN
8691	2350	19	.	.	.
8691	2351	1	The	the	DT
8691	2351	2	entry	entry	NN
8691	2351	3	reads	read	VBZ
8691	2351	4	thus	thus	RB
8691	2351	5	:	:	:
8691	2351	6	John	John	NNP
8691	2351	7	Doe	Doe	NNP
8691	2351	8	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	2351	9	vs.	vs.	IN
8691	2351	10	Richard	Richard	NNP
8691	2351	11	Roe	Roe	NNP
8691	2351	12	Jones	Jones	NNP
8691	2351	13	.	.	.
8691	2352	1	Doe	Doe	NNP
8691	2352	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2352	3	here	here	RB
8691	2352	4	the	the	DT
8691	2352	5	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2352	6	and	and	CC
8691	2352	7	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	2352	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2352	9	the	the	DT
8691	2352	10	attorney	attorney	NN
8691	2352	11	who	who	WP
8691	2352	12	brought	bring	VBD
8691	2352	13	the	the	DT
8691	2352	14	suit	suit	NN
8691	2352	15	for	for	IN
8691	2352	16	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2352	17	.	.	.
8691	2353	1	Roe	Roe	NNP
8691	2353	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2353	3	the	the	DT
8691	2353	4	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2353	5	and	and	CC
8691	2353	6	Jones	Jones	NNP
8691	2353	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2353	8	the	the	DT
8691	2353	9	attorney	attorney	NN
8691	2353	10	who	who	WP
8691	2353	11	appears	appear	VBZ
8691	2353	12	in	in	IN
8691	2353	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2353	14	behalf	behalf	NN
8691	2353	15	.	.	.
8691	2354	1	If	if	IN
8691	2354	2	there	there	EX
8691	2354	3	be	be	VBP
8691	2354	4	more	more	JJR
8691	2354	5	than	than	IN
8691	2354	6	one	one	CD
8691	2354	7	party	party	NN
8691	2354	8	on	on	IN
8691	2354	9	either	either	DT
8691	2354	10	side	side	NN
8691	2354	11	the	the	DT
8691	2354	12	words	word	NNS
8691	2354	13	_	_	NNP
8691	2354	14	et	et	NNP
8691	2354	15	al	al	NNP
8691	2354	16	.	.	NNP
8691	2354	17	_	_	NNP
8691	2354	18	will	will	MD
8691	2354	19	be	be	VB
8691	2354	20	added	add	VBN
8691	2354	21	,	,	,
8691	2354	22	signifying	signify	VBG
8691	2354	23	as	as	IN
8691	2354	24	the	the	DT
8691	2354	25	case	case	NN
8691	2354	26	may	may	MD
8691	2354	27	be	be	VB
8691	2354	28	,	,	,
8691	2354	29	_	_	NNP
8691	2354	30	et	et	NNP
8691	2354	31	alius	alius	NN
8691	2354	32	,	,	,
8691	2354	33	et	et	NNP
8691	2354	34	alii	alii	NNP
8691	2354	35	_	_	NNP
8691	2354	36	or	or	CC
8691	2354	37	et	et	NNP
8691	2354	38	alium	alium	NN
8691	2354	39	,	,	,
8691	2354	40	_	_	NNP
8691	2354	41	or	or	CC
8691	2354	42	should	should	MD
8691	2354	43	there	there	EX
8691	2354	44	be	be	VB
8691	2354	45	three	three	CD
8691	2354	46	or	or	CC
8691	2354	47	more	more	JJR
8691	2354	48	defendants	defendant	NNS
8691	2354	49	,	,	,
8691	2354	50	_	_	NNP
8691	2354	51	et	et	NNP
8691	2354	52	als	als	NNP
8691	2354	53	_	_	NNP
8691	2354	54	,	,	,
8691	2354	55	signifying	signify	VBG
8691	2354	56	_	_	NNP
8691	2354	57	et	et	NNP
8691	2354	58	alios	alio	NNS
8691	2354	59	_	_	NNP
8691	2354	60	.	.	.
8691	2355	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2355	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2355	3	:	:	:
8691	2355	4	Another	another	DT
8691	2355	5	book	book	NN
8691	2355	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2355	7	kept	keep	VBN
8691	2355	8	for	for	IN
8691	2355	9	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2355	10	cases	case	NNS
8691	2355	11	,	,	,
8691	2355	12	which	which	WDT
8691	2355	13	are	be	VBP
8691	2355	14	docketed	docket	VBN
8691	2355	15	as	as	IN
8691	2355	16	"	"	``
8691	2355	17	The	the	DT
8691	2355	18	State	State	NNP
8691	2355	19	_	_	NNP
8691	2355	20	v.	v.	IN
8691	2355	21	_	_	NNP
8691	2355	22	John	John	NNP
8691	2355	23	Doe	Doe	NNP
8691	2355	24	,	,	,
8691	2355	25	"	"	``
8691	2355	26	in	in	IN
8691	2355	27	others	other	NNS
8691	2355	28	as	as	IN
8691	2355	29	"	"	``
8691	2355	30	The	the	DT
8691	2355	31	People	People	NNPS
8691	2355	32	_	_	NNP
8691	2355	33	v.	v.	IN
8691	2355	34	_	_	NNP
8691	2355	35	John	John	NNP
8691	2355	36	Doe	Doe	NNP
8691	2355	37	,	,	,
8691	2355	38	"	"	''
8691	2355	39	and	and	CC
8691	2355	40	in	in	IN
8691	2355	41	the	the	DT
8691	2355	42	federal	federal	JJ
8691	2355	43	courts	court	NNS
8691	2355	44	as	as	IN
8691	2355	45	"	"	``
8691	2355	46	The	the	DT
8691	2355	47	United	United	NNP
8691	2355	48	States	States	NNP
8691	2355	49	_	_	NNP
8691	2355	50	v.	v.	IN
8691	2355	51	_	_	NNP
8691	2355	52	John	John	NNP
8691	2355	53	Doe	Doe	NNP
8691	2355	54	.	.	.
8691	2355	55	"	"	''
8691	2355	56	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2356	1	From	from	IN
8691	2356	2	this	this	DT
8691	2356	3	docket	docket	NN
8691	2356	4	trial	trial	NN
8691	2356	5	lists	list	NNS
8691	2356	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2356	7	made	make	VBN
8691	2356	8	up	up	RP
8691	2356	9	for	for	IN
8691	2356	10	each	each	DT
8691	2356	11	term	term	NN
8691	2356	12	or	or	CC
8691	2356	13	session	session	NN
8691	2356	14	of	of	IN
8691	2356	15	court	court	NN
8691	2356	16	.	.	.
8691	2357	1	Assignments	assignment	NNS
8691	2357	2	for	for	IN
8691	2357	3	trial	trial	NN
8691	2357	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2357	5	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2357	6	made	make	VBN
8691	2357	7	by	by	IN
8691	2357	8	the	the	DT
8691	2357	9	court	court	NN
8691	2357	10	and	and	CC
8691	2357	11	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2357	12	arranged	arrange	VBN
8691	2357	13	by	by	IN
8691	2357	14	the	the	DT
8691	2357	15	bar	bar	NN
8691	2357	16	subject	subject	JJ
8691	2357	17	to	to	IN
8691	2357	18	the	the	DT
8691	2357	19	approval	approval	NN
8691	2357	20	of	of	IN
8691	2357	21	the	the	DT
8691	2357	22	court	court	NN
8691	2357	23	.	.	.
8691	2358	1	Several	several	JJ
8691	2358	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	2358	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2358	4	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2358	5	set	set	VBN
8691	2358	6	down	down	RP
8691	2358	7	for	for	IN
8691	2358	8	each	each	DT
8691	2358	9	day	day	NN
8691	2358	10	,	,	,
8691	2358	11	so	so	IN
8691	2358	12	that	that	IN
8691	2358	13	if	if	IN
8691	2358	14	one	one	PRP
8691	2358	15	falls	fall	VBZ
8691	2358	16	out	out	RP
8691	2358	17	another	another	DT
8691	2358	18	may	may	MD
8691	2358	19	be	be	VB
8691	2358	20	ready	ready	JJ
8691	2358	21	,	,	,
8691	2358	22	and	and	CC
8691	2358	23	in	in	IN
8691	2358	24	every	every	DT
8691	2358	25	case	case	NN
8691	2358	26	so	so	RB
8691	2358	27	assigned	assign	VBD
8691	2358	28	the	the	DT
8691	2358	29	parties	party	NNS
8691	2358	30	must	must	MD
8691	2358	31	be	be	VB
8691	2358	32	prepared	prepare	VBN
8691	2358	33	at	at	IN
8691	2358	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2358	35	peril	peril	NN
8691	2358	36	to	to	TO
8691	2358	37	appear	appear	VB
8691	2358	38	and	and	CC
8691	2358	39	proceed	proceed	VB
8691	2358	40	at	at	IN
8691	2358	41	any	any	DT
8691	2358	42	minute	minute	NN
8691	2358	43	when	when	WRB
8691	2358	44	called	call	VBN
8691	2358	45	upon	upon	IN
8691	2358	46	.	.	.
8691	2359	1	In	in	IN
8691	2359	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	2359	3	having	have	VBG
8691	2359	4	a	a	DT
8691	2359	5	large	large	JJ
8691	2359	6	docket	docket	NN
8691	2359	7	of	of	IN
8691	2359	8	cases	case	NNS
8691	2359	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2359	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2359	11	customary	customary	JJ
8691	2359	12	to	to	TO
8691	2359	13	set	set	VB
8691	2359	14	apart	apart	RB
8691	2359	15	one	one	CD
8691	2359	16	day	day	NN
8691	2359	17	in	in	IN
8691	2359	18	the	the	DT
8691	2359	19	week	week	NN
8691	2359	20	for	for	IN
8691	2359	21	the	the	DT
8691	2359	22	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	2359	23	of	of	IN
8691	2359	24	incidental	incidental	JJ
8691	2359	25	motions	motion	NNS
8691	2359	26	and	and	CC
8691	2359	27	for	for	IN
8691	2359	28	arguments	argument	NNS
8691	2359	29	on	on	IN
8691	2359	30	points	point	NNS
8691	2359	31	of	of	IN
8691	2359	32	law	law	NN
8691	2359	33	.	.	.
8691	2360	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2360	2	a	a	DT
8691	2360	3	case	case	NN
8691	2360	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2360	5	called	call	VBN
8691	2360	6	for	for	IN
8691	2360	7	trial	trial	NN
8691	2360	8	the	the	DT
8691	2360	9	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2360	10	's	's	POS
8691	2360	11	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2360	12	opens	open	VBZ
8691	2360	13	by	by	IN
8691	2360	14	stating	state	VBG
8691	2360	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2360	16	nature	nature	NN
8691	2360	17	and	and	CC
8691	2360	18	the	the	DT
8691	2360	19	main	main	JJ
8691	2360	20	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2360	21	as	as	IN
8691	2360	22	set	set	VBN
8691	2360	23	out	out	RP
8691	2360	24	in	in	IN
8691	2360	25	the	the	DT
8691	2360	26	declaration	declaration	NN
8691	2360	27	or	or	CC
8691	2360	28	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	2360	29	which	which	WDT
8691	2360	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2360	31	expects	expect	VBZ
8691	2360	32	to	to	TO
8691	2360	33	prove	prove	VB
8691	2360	34	.	.	.
8691	2361	1	Sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2361	2	the	the	DT
8691	2361	3	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	2361	4	on	on	IN
8691	2361	5	both	both	DT
8691	2361	6	sides	side	NNS
8691	2361	7	are	be	VBP
8691	2361	8	read	read	VBN
8691	2361	9	at	at	IN
8691	2361	10	length	length	NN
8691	2361	11	.	.	.
8691	2362	1	The	the	DT
8691	2362	2	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2362	3	's	's	POS
8691	2362	4	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	2362	5	are	be	VBP
8691	2362	6	then	then	RB
8691	2362	7	examined	examine	VBN
8691	2362	8	orally	orally	RB
8691	2362	9	,	,	,
8691	2362	10	after	after	IN
8691	2362	11	the	the	DT
8691	2362	12	examination	examination	NN
8691	2362	13	of	of	IN
8691	2362	14	each	each	DT
8691	2362	15	an	an	DT
8691	2362	16	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	2362	17	being	be	VBG
8691	2362	18	given	give	VBN
8691	2362	19	for	for	IN
8691	2362	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2362	21	cross	cross	NN
8691	2362	22	-	-	NN
8691	2362	23	examination	examination	NN
8691	2362	24	by	by	IN
8691	2362	25	the	the	DT
8691	2362	26	other	other	JJ
8691	2362	27	party	party	NN
8691	2362	28	.	.	.
8691	2363	1	The	the	DT
8691	2363	2	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2363	3	of	of	IN
8691	2363	4	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	2363	5	whose	whose	WP$
8691	2363	6	attendance	attendance	NN
8691	2363	7	can	can	MD
8691	2363	8	not	not	RB
8691	2363	9	be	be	VB
8691	2363	10	had	have	VBN
8691	2363	11	,	,	,
8691	2363	12	which	which	WDT
8691	2363	13	may	may	MD
8691	2363	14	include	include	VB
8691	2363	15	any	any	DT
8691	2363	16	living	living	NN
8691	2363	17	out	out	IN
8691	2363	18	of	of	IN
8691	2363	19	the	the	DT
8691	2363	20	State	State	NNP
8691	2363	21	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2363	22	or	or	CC
8691	2363	23	,	,	,
8691	2363	24	in	in	IN
8691	2363	25	the	the	DT
8691	2363	26	federal	federal	JJ
8691	2363	27	courts	court	NNS
8691	2363	28	,	,	,
8691	2363	29	over	over	IN
8691	2363	30	one	one	CD
8691	2363	31	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	2363	32	miles	mile	NNS
8691	2363	33	from	from	IN
8691	2363	34	the	the	DT
8691	2363	35	place	place	NN
8691	2363	36	of	of	IN
8691	2363	37	trial	trial	NN
8691	2363	38	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2363	39	,	,	,
8691	2363	40	or	or	CC
8691	2363	41	who	who	WP
8691	2363	42	are	be	VBP
8691	2363	43	infirm	infirm	NN
8691	2363	44	or	or	CC
8691	2363	45	sick	sick	JJ
8691	2363	46	,	,	,
8691	2363	47	may	may	MD
8691	2363	48	be	be	VB
8691	2363	49	secured	secure	VBN
8691	2363	50	by	by	IN
8691	2363	51	previously	previously	RB
8691	2363	52	taking	take	VBG
8691	2363	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2363	54	down	down	RP
8691	2363	55	out	out	IN
8691	2363	56	of	of	IN
8691	2363	57	court	court	NN
8691	2363	58	in	in	IN
8691	2363	59	the	the	DT
8691	2363	60	form	form	NN
8691	2363	61	of	of	IN
8691	2363	62	a	a	DT
8691	2363	63	written	write	VBN
8691	2363	64	deposition	deposition	NN
8691	2363	65	,	,	,
8691	2363	66	under	under	IN
8691	2363	67	oath	oath	NN
8691	2363	68	,	,	,
8691	2363	69	before	before	IN
8691	2363	70	a	a	DT
8691	2363	71	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2363	72	.	.	.
8691	2364	1	In	in	IN
8691	2364	2	such	such	JJ
8691	2364	3	case	case	NN
8691	2364	4	the	the	DT
8691	2364	5	adverse	adverse	JJ
8691	2364	6	party	party	NN
8691	2364	7	must	must	MD
8691	2364	8	have	have	VB
8691	2364	9	such	such	JJ
8691	2364	10	notice	notice	NN
8691	2364	11	as	as	IN
8691	2364	12	to	to	TO
8691	2364	13	enable	enable	VB
8691	2364	14	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2364	15	to	to	TO
8691	2364	16	be	be	VB
8691	2364	17	present	present	JJ
8691	2364	18	and	and	CC
8691	2364	19	cross	cross	VB
8691	2364	20	-	-	VB
8691	2364	21	examine	examine	VB
8691	2364	22	the	the	DT
8691	2364	23	deponent	deponent	NN
8691	2364	24	,	,	,
8691	2364	25	or	or	CC
8691	2364	26	to	to	TO
8691	2364	27	file	file	VB
8691	2364	28	written	write	VBN
8691	2364	29	cross	cross	NN
8691	2364	30	-	-	NNS
8691	2364	31	interrogatories	interrogatory	NNS
8691	2364	32	.	.	.
8691	2365	1	Depositions	deposition	NNS
8691	2365	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2365	3	received	receive	VBN
8691	2365	4	in	in	IN
8691	2365	5	the	the	DT
8691	2365	6	same	same	JJ
8691	2365	7	manner	manner	NN
8691	2365	8	and	and	CC
8691	2365	9	subject	subject	NN
8691	2365	10	to	to	IN
8691	2365	11	the	the	DT
8691	2365	12	same	same	JJ
8691	2365	13	objections	objection	NNS
8691	2365	14	as	as	IN
8691	2365	15	oral	oral	JJ
8691	2365	16	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2365	17	.	.	.
8691	2366	1	In	in	IN
8691	2366	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	2366	3	in	in	IN
8691	2366	4	equity	equity	NN
8691	2366	5	a	a	DT
8691	2366	6	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2366	7	part	part	NN
8691	2366	8	of	of	IN
8691	2366	9	the	the	DT
8691	2366	10	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2366	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2366	12	generally	generally	RB
8691	2366	13	presented	present	VBN
8691	2366	14	in	in	IN
8691	2366	15	written	write	VBN
8691	2366	16	form	form	NN
8691	2366	17	,	,	,
8691	2366	18	either	either	CC
8691	2366	19	by	by	IN
8691	2366	20	depositions	deposition	NNS
8691	2366	21	of	of	IN
8691	2366	22	the	the	DT
8691	2366	23	kind	kind	NN
8691	2366	24	described	describe	VBN
8691	2366	25	or	or	CC
8691	2366	26	certified	certify	VBN
8691	2366	27	by	by	IN
8691	2366	28	a	a	DT
8691	2366	29	special	special	JJ
8691	2366	30	officer	officer	NN
8691	2366	31	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	2366	32	by	by	IN
8691	2366	33	the	the	DT
8691	2366	34	court	court	NN
8691	2366	35	for	for	IN
8691	2366	36	the	the	DT
8691	2366	37	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2366	38	,	,	,
8691	2366	39	who	who	WP
8691	2366	40	may	may	MD
8691	2366	41	be	be	VB
8691	2366	42	called	call	VBN
8691	2366	43	an	an	DT
8691	2366	44	"	"	``
8691	2366	45	examiner	examiner	NN
8691	2366	46	.	.	.
8691	2366	47	"	"	''
8691	2367	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2367	2	the	the	DT
8691	2367	3	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2367	4	's	's	POS
8691	2367	5	case	case	NN
8691	2367	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	2367	7	been	be	VBN
8691	2367	8	thus	thus	RB
8691	2367	9	presented	present	VBN
8691	2367	10	,	,	,
8691	2367	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2367	12	attorney	attorney	NN
8691	2367	13	announces	announce	VBZ
8691	2367	14	that	that	IN
8691	2367	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2367	16	"	"	``
8691	2367	17	rests	rest	VBZ
8691	2367	18	.	.	.
8691	2367	19	"	"	''
8691	2368	1	The	the	DT
8691	2368	2	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2368	3	's	's	POS
8691	2368	4	attorney	attorney	NN
8691	2368	5	then	then	RB
8691	2368	6	states	state	VBZ
8691	2368	7	what	what	WP
8691	2368	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2368	9	proposes	propose	VBZ
8691	2368	10	to	to	TO
8691	2368	11	prove	prove	VB
8691	2368	12	,	,	,
8691	2368	13	and	and	CC
8691	2368	14	produces	produce	VBZ
8691	2368	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2368	16	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2368	17	,	,	,
8691	2368	18	at	at	IN
8691	2368	19	the	the	DT
8691	2368	20	close	close	NN
8691	2368	21	of	of	IN
8691	2368	22	which	which	WDT
8691	2368	23	the	the	DT
8691	2368	24	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2368	25	has	have	VBZ
8691	2368	26	the	the	DT
8691	2368	27	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	2368	28	to	to	TO
8691	2368	29	meet	meet	VB
8691	2368	30	any	any	DT
8691	2368	31	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2368	32	so	so	RB
8691	2368	33	produced	produce	VBD
8691	2368	34	as	as	IN
8691	2368	35	to	to	IN
8691	2368	36	points	point	NNS
8691	2368	37	not	not	RB
8691	2368	38	covered	cover	VBN
8691	2368	39	by	by	IN
8691	2368	40	the	the	DT
8691	2368	41	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2368	42	's	's	POS
8691	2368	43	case	case	NN
8691	2368	44	as	as	IN
8691	2368	45	presented	present	VBN
8691	2368	46	"	"	``
8691	2368	47	in	in	IN
8691	2368	48	chief	chief	NN
8691	2368	49	,	,	,
8691	2368	50	"	"	''
8691	2368	51	by	by	IN
8691	2368	52	rebutting	rebut	VBG
8691	2368	53	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2368	54	.	.	.
8691	2369	1	Should	Should	MD
8691	2369	2	there	there	EX
8691	2369	3	be	be	VB
8691	2369	4	any	any	DT
8691	2369	5	new	new	JJ
8691	2369	6	point	point	NN
8691	2369	7	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2369	8	out	out	RP
8691	2369	9	in	in	IN
8691	2369	10	the	the	DT
8691	2369	11	latter	latter	JJ
8691	2369	12	which	which	WDT
8691	2369	13	the	the	DT
8691	2369	14	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2369	15	had	have	VBD
8691	2369	16	not	not	RB
8691	2369	17	anticipated	anticipate	VBN
8691	2369	18	in	in	IN
8691	2369	19	presenting	present	VBG
8691	2369	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2369	21	case	case	NN
8691	2369	22	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2369	23	which	which	WDT
8691	2369	24	rarely	rarely	RB
8691	2369	25	happens	happen	VBZ
8691	2369	26	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2369	27	,	,	,
8691	2369	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2369	29	may	may	MD
8691	2369	30	now	now	RB
8691	2369	31	be	be	VB
8691	2369	32	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2369	33	to	to	TO
8691	2369	34	introduce	introduce	VB
8691	2369	35	further	further	JJ
8691	2369	36	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2369	37	as	as	IN
8691	2369	38	to	to	IN
8691	2369	39	that	that	DT
8691	2369	40	.	.	.
8691	2370	1	At	at	IN
8691	2370	2	the	the	DT
8691	2370	3	close	close	NN
8691	2370	4	of	of	IN
8691	2370	5	the	the	DT
8691	2370	6	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2370	7	the	the	DT
8691	2370	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2370	9	's	's	POS
8691	2370	10	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2370	11	argues	argue	VBZ
8691	2370	12	for	for	IN
8691	2370	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2370	14	client	client	NN
8691	2370	15	;	;	:
8691	2370	16	the	the	DT
8691	2370	17	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2370	18	's	's	POS
8691	2370	19	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2370	20	replies	reply	VBZ
8691	2370	21	;	;	:
8691	2370	22	and	and	CC
8691	2370	23	the	the	DT
8691	2370	24	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2370	25	's	's	POS
8691	2370	26	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2370	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	2370	28	then	then	RB
8691	2370	29	heard	hear	VBN
8691	2370	30	in	in	IN
8691	2370	31	answer	answer	NN
8691	2370	32	to	to	IN
8691	2370	33	anything	anything	NN
8691	2370	34	which	which	WDT
8691	2370	35	has	have	VBZ
8691	2370	36	been	be	VBN
8691	2370	37	said	say	VBN
8691	2370	38	in	in	IN
8691	2370	39	behalf	behalf	NN
8691	2370	40	of	of	IN
8691	2370	41	the	the	DT
8691	2370	42	other	other	JJ
8691	2370	43	side	side	NN
8691	2370	44	.	.	.
8691	2371	1	If	if	IN
8691	2371	2	the	the	DT
8691	2371	3	trial	trial	NN
8691	2371	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2371	5	been	be	VBN
8691	2371	6	had	have	VBN
8691	2371	7	before	before	IN
8691	2371	8	a	a	DT
8691	2371	9	judge	judge	NN
8691	2371	10	without	without	IN
8691	2371	11	a	a	DT
8691	2371	12	jury	jury	NN
8691	2371	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2371	14	then	then	RB
8691	2371	15	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2371	16	takes	take	VBZ
8691	2371	17	the	the	DT
8691	2371	18	written	write	VBN
8691	2371	19	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	2371	20	and	and	CC
8691	2371	21	makes	make	VBZ
8691	2371	22	up	up	RP
8691	2371	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2371	24	decision	decision	NN
8691	2371	25	at	at	IN
8691	2371	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2371	27	leisure	leisure	NN
8691	2371	28	;	;	:
8691	2371	29	but	but	CC
8691	2371	30	if	if	IN
8691	2371	31	the	the	DT
8691	2371	32	case	case	NN
8691	2371	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	2371	34	plain	plain	JJ
8691	2371	35	may	may	MD
8691	2371	36	give	give	VB
8691	2371	37	final	final	JJ
8691	2371	38	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2371	39	on	on	IN
8691	2371	40	the	the	DT
8691	2371	41	spot	spot	NN
8691	2371	42	.	.	.
8691	2372	1	If	if	IN
8691	2372	2	the	the	DT
8691	2372	3	trial	trial	NN
8691	2372	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2372	5	been	be	VBN
8691	2372	6	before	before	IN
8691	2372	7	a	a	DT
8691	2372	8	jury	jury	NN
8691	2372	9	the	the	DT
8691	2372	10	parties	party	NNS
8691	2372	11	argue	argue	VBP
8691	2372	12	as	as	IN
8691	2372	13	to	to	IN
8691	2372	14	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2372	15	in	in	IN
8691	2372	16	dispute	dispute	NN
8691	2372	17	to	to	IN
8691	2372	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2372	19	,	,	,
8691	2372	20	but	but	CC
8691	2372	21	as	as	IN
8691	2372	22	to	to	IN
8691	2372	23	the	the	DT
8691	2372	24	law	law	NN
8691	2372	25	upon	upon	IN
8691	2372	26	these	these	DT
8691	2372	27	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2372	28	to	to	IN
8691	2372	29	the	the	DT
8691	2372	30	court	court	NN
8691	2372	31	.	.	.
8691	2373	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2373	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2373	3	:	:	:
8691	2373	4	See	see	VB
8691	2373	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	2373	6	.	.	.
8691	2374	1	XII	XII	NNP
8691	2374	2	.	.	.
8691	2374	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2375	1	In	in	IN
8691	2375	2	some	some	DT
8691	2375	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2375	4	the	the	DT
8691	2375	5	arguments	argument	NNS
8691	2375	6	on	on	IN
8691	2375	7	the	the	DT
8691	2375	8	latter	latter	JJ
8691	2375	9	question	question	NN
8691	2375	10	are	be	VBP
8691	2375	11	made	make	VBN
8691	2375	12	before	before	IN
8691	2375	13	those	those	DT
8691	2375	14	on	on	IN
8691	2375	15	the	the	DT
8691	2375	16	former	former	JJ
8691	2375	17	,	,	,
8691	2375	18	and	and	CC
8691	2375	19	written	write	VBN
8691	2375	20	requests	request	NNS
8691	2375	21	or	or	CC
8691	2375	22	"	"	``
8691	2375	23	prayers	prayer	NNS
8691	2375	24	"	"	''
8691	2375	25	for	for	IN
8691	2375	26	instructions	instruction	NNS
8691	2375	27	to	to	IN
8691	2375	28	the	the	DT
8691	2375	29	jury	jury	NN
8691	2375	30	as	as	IN
8691	2375	31	to	to	IN
8691	2375	32	the	the	DT
8691	2375	33	law	law	NN
8691	2375	34	are	be	VBP
8691	2375	35	submitted	submit	VBN
8691	2375	36	to	to	IN
8691	2375	37	the	the	DT
8691	2375	38	court	court	NN
8691	2375	39	,	,	,
8691	2375	40	upon	upon	IN
8691	2375	41	which	which	WDT
8691	2375	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2375	43	passes	pass	VBZ
8691	2375	44	before	before	IN
8691	2375	45	the	the	DT
8691	2375	46	jury	jury	NN
8691	2375	47	are	be	VBP
8691	2375	48	addressed	address	VBN
8691	2375	49	.	.	.
8691	2376	1	In	in	IN
8691	2376	2	most	most	JJS
8691	2376	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2376	4	there	there	EX
8691	2376	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2376	6	no	no	DT
8691	2376	7	such	such	JJ
8691	2376	8	division	division	NN
8691	2376	9	of	of	IN
8691	2376	10	argument	argument	NN
8691	2376	11	;	;	:
8691	2376	12	judge	judge	NN
8691	2376	13	and	and	CC
8691	2376	14	jury	jury	NN
8691	2376	15	are	be	VBP
8691	2376	16	addressed	address	VBN
8691	2376	17	in	in	IN
8691	2376	18	turn	turn	NN
8691	2376	19	during	during	IN
8691	2376	20	the	the	DT
8691	2376	21	same	same	JJ
8691	2376	22	speech	speech	NN
8691	2376	23	,	,	,
8691	2376	24	and	and	CC
8691	2376	25	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2376	26	first	first	RB
8691	2376	27	know	know	VB
8691	2376	28	what	what	WP
8691	2376	29	view	view	NN
8691	2376	30	of	of	IN
8691	2376	31	the	the	DT
8691	2376	32	law	law	NN
8691	2376	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	2376	34	taken	take	VBN
8691	2376	35	by	by	IN
8691	2376	36	the	the	DT
8691	2376	37	court	court	NN
8691	2376	38	when	when	WRB
8691	2376	39	the	the	DT
8691	2376	40	judge	judge	NN
8691	2376	41	gives	give	VBZ
8691	2376	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2376	43	final	final	JJ
8691	2376	44	charge	charge	NN
8691	2376	45	.	.	.
8691	2377	1	In	in	IN
8691	2377	2	every	every	DT
8691	2377	3	jury	jury	NN
8691	2377	4	trial	trial	NN
8691	2377	5	,	,	,
8691	2377	6	after	after	IN
8691	2377	7	all	all	PDT
8691	2377	8	the	the	DT
8691	2377	9	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2377	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2377	11	in	in	IN
8691	2377	12	and	and	CC
8691	2377	13	the	the	DT
8691	2377	14	arguments	argument	NNS
8691	2377	15	concluded	conclude	VBD
8691	2377	16	,	,	,
8691	2377	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2377	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	2377	19	the	the	DT
8691	2377	20	duty	duty	NN
8691	2377	21	of	of	IN
8691	2377	22	the	the	DT
8691	2377	23	court	court	NN
8691	2377	24	to	to	TO
8691	2377	25	instruct	instruct	VB
8691	2377	26	the	the	DT
8691	2377	27	jury	jury	NN
8691	2377	28	as	as	IN
8691	2377	29	to	to	IN
8691	2377	30	what	what	WP
8691	2377	31	the	the	DT
8691	2377	32	precise	precise	JJ
8691	2377	33	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	2377	34	is	be	VBZ
8691	2377	35	and	and	CC
8691	2377	36	what	what	WDT
8691	2377	37	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	2377	38	of	of	IN
8691	2377	39	the	the	DT
8691	2377	40	cause	cause	NN
8691	2377	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2377	42	would	would	MD
8691	2377	43	be	be	VB
8691	2377	44	permissible	permissible	JJ
8691	2377	45	for	for	IN
8691	2377	46	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2377	47	to	to	TO
8691	2377	48	make	make	VB
8691	2377	49	.	.	.
8691	2378	1	If	if	IN
8691	2378	2	in	in	IN
8691	2378	3	view	view	NN
8691	2378	4	of	of	IN
8691	2378	5	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2378	6	which	which	WDT
8691	2378	7	are	be	VBP
8691	2378	8	undisputed	undisputed	JJ
8691	2378	9	by	by	IN
8691	2378	10	either	either	DT
8691	2378	11	party	party	NN
8691	2378	12	there	there	EX
8691	2378	13	can	can	MD
8691	2378	14	be	be	VB
8691	2378	15	in	in	IN
8691	2378	16	law	law	NN
8691	2378	17	but	but	CC
8691	2378	18	one	one	CD
8691	2378	19	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	2378	20	,	,	,
8691	2378	21	the	the	DT
8691	2378	22	judge	judge	NN
8691	2378	23	should	should	MD
8691	2378	24	direct	direct	VB
8691	2378	25	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2378	26	to	to	TO
8691	2378	27	render	render	VB
8691	2378	28	a	a	DT
8691	2378	29	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2378	30	accordingly	accordingly	RB
8691	2378	31	.	.	.
8691	2379	1	But	but	CC
8691	2379	2	if	if	IN
8691	2379	3	the	the	DT
8691	2379	4	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2379	5	might	may	MD
8691	2379	6	fairly	fairly	RB
8691	2379	7	be	be	VB
8691	2379	8	found	find	VBN
8691	2379	9	as	as	IN
8691	2379	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2379	11	are	be	VBP
8691	2379	12	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	2379	13	to	to	TO
8691	2379	14	be	be	VB
8691	2379	15	by	by	IN
8691	2379	16	either	either	DT
8691	2379	17	party	party	NN
8691	2379	18	,	,	,
8691	2379	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2379	20	instructs	instruct	VBZ
8691	2379	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2379	22	as	as	IN
8691	2379	23	to	to	IN
8691	2379	24	the	the	DT
8691	2379	25	law	law	NN
8691	2379	26	applicable	applicable	JJ
8691	2379	27	to	to	IN
8691	2379	28	the	the	DT
8691	2379	29	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2379	30	so	so	RB
8691	2379	31	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	2379	32	by	by	IN
8691	2379	33	each	each	DT
8691	2379	34	.	.	.
8691	2380	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2380	2	can	can	MD
8691	2380	3	,	,	,
8691	2380	4	at	at	IN
8691	2380	5	common	common	JJ
8691	2380	6	law	law	NN
8691	2380	7	and	and	CC
8691	2380	8	by	by	IN
8691	2380	9	the	the	DT
8691	2380	10	practice	practice	NN
8691	2380	11	in	in	IN
8691	2380	12	most	most	JJS
8691	2380	13	States	state	NNS
8691	2380	14	,	,	,
8691	2380	15	give	give	VB
8691	2380	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2380	17	own	own	JJ
8691	2380	18	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2380	19	as	as	IN
8691	2380	20	to	to	IN
8691	2380	21	the	the	DT
8691	2380	22	weight	weight	NN
8691	2380	23	of	of	IN
8691	2380	24	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2380	25	on	on	IN
8691	2380	26	any	any	DT
8691	2380	27	point	point	NN
8691	2380	28	in	in	IN
8691	2380	29	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	2380	30	.	.	.
8691	2381	1	The	the	DT
8691	2381	2	common	common	JJ
8691	2381	3	law	law	NN
8691	2381	4	requires	require	VBZ
8691	2381	5	unanimity	unanimity	NN
8691	2381	6	on	on	IN
8691	2381	7	the	the	DT
8691	2381	8	part	part	NN
8691	2381	9	of	of	IN
8691	2381	10	the	the	DT
8691	2381	11	jury	jury	NN
8691	2381	12	before	before	IN
8691	2381	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2381	14	can	can	MD
8691	2381	15	return	return	VB
8691	2381	16	a	a	DT
8691	2381	17	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2381	18	.	.	.
8691	2382	1	If	if	IN
8691	2382	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2382	3	can	can	MD
8691	2382	4	not	not	RB
8691	2382	5	be	be	VB
8691	2382	6	had	have	VBN
8691	2382	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2382	8	report	report	VB
8691	2382	9	a	a	DT
8691	2382	10	disagreement	disagreement	NN
8691	2382	11	,	,	,
8691	2382	12	and	and	CC
8691	2382	13	the	the	DT
8691	2382	14	case	case	NN
8691	2382	15	stands	stand	VBZ
8691	2382	16	over	over	RP
8691	2382	17	for	for	IN
8691	2382	18	another	another	DT
8691	2382	19	trial	trial	NN
8691	2382	20	.	.	.
8691	2383	1	If	if	IN
8691	2383	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2383	3	agree	agree	VBP
8691	2383	4	upon	upon	IN
8691	2383	5	a	a	DT
8691	2383	6	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2383	7	,	,	,
8691	2383	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2383	9	must	must	MD
8691	2383	10	,	,	,
8691	2383	11	to	to	TO
8691	2383	12	be	be	VB
8691	2383	13	effective	effective	JJ
8691	2383	14	,	,	,
8691	2383	15	be	be	VB
8691	2383	16	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	2383	17	by	by	IN
8691	2383	18	the	the	DT
8691	2383	19	court	court	NN
8691	2383	20	.	.	.
8691	2384	1	This	this	DT
8691	2384	2	acceptance	acceptance	NN
8691	2384	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2384	4	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2384	5	a	a	DT
8691	2384	6	matter	matter	NN
8691	2384	7	of	of	IN
8691	2384	8	course	course	NN
8691	2384	9	,	,	,
8691	2384	10	but	but	CC
8691	2384	11	if	if	IN
8691	2384	12	the	the	DT
8691	2384	13	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2384	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	2384	15	plainly	plainly	RB
8691	2384	16	contrary	contrary	JJ
8691	2384	17	to	to	IN
8691	2384	18	the	the	DT
8691	2384	19	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2384	20	or	or	CC
8691	2384	21	to	to	IN
8691	2384	22	the	the	DT
8691	2384	23	law	law	NN
8691	2384	24	as	as	IN
8691	2384	25	laid	lay	VBD
8691	2384	26	down	down	RP
8691	2384	27	in	in	IN
8691	2384	28	the	the	DT
8691	2384	29	charge	charge	NN
8691	2384	30	,	,	,
8691	2384	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2384	32	may	may	MD
8691	2384	33	be	be	VB
8691	2384	34	set	set	VBN
8691	2384	35	aside	aside	RB
8691	2384	36	and	and	CC
8691	2384	37	a	a	DT
8691	2384	38	new	new	JJ
8691	2384	39	trial	trial	NN
8691	2384	40	ordered	order	VBN
8691	2384	41	.	.	.
8691	2385	1	If	if	IN
8691	2385	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2385	3	gives	give	VBZ
8691	2385	4	damages	damage	NNS
8691	2385	5	which	which	WDT
8691	2385	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2385	7	plainly	plainly	RB
8691	2385	8	excessive	excessive	JJ
8691	2385	9	,	,	,
8691	2385	10	the	the	DT
8691	2385	11	judge	judge	NN
8691	2385	12	may	may	MD
8691	2385	13	set	set	VB
8691	2385	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2385	15	aside	aside	RB
8691	2385	16	,	,	,
8691	2385	17	unless	unless	IN
8691	2385	18	the	the	DT
8691	2385	19	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	2385	20	party	party	NN
8691	2385	21	enters	enter	VBZ
8691	2385	22	a	a	DT
8691	2385	23	_	_	NNP
8691	2385	24	remittitur	remittitur	NN
8691	2385	25	_	_	NNP
8691	2385	26	of	of	IN
8691	2385	27	a	a	DT
8691	2385	28	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2385	29	amount	amount	NN
8691	2385	30	,	,	,
8691	2385	31	that	that	RB
8691	2385	32	is	is	RB
8691	2385	33	,	,	,
8691	2385	34	formally	formally	RB
8691	2385	35	stipulates	stipulate	VBZ
8691	2385	36	on	on	IN
8691	2385	37	the	the	DT
8691	2385	38	record	record	NN
8691	2385	39	that	that	IN
8691	2385	40	the	the	DT
8691	2385	41	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2385	42	shall	shall	MD
8691	2385	43	stand	stand	VB
8691	2385	44	only	only	RB
8691	2385	45	for	for	IN
8691	2385	46	such	such	JJ
8691	2385	47	sum	sum	NN
8691	2385	48	as	as	IN
8691	2385	49	the	the	DT
8691	2385	50	judge	judge	NN
8691	2385	51	may	may	MD
8691	2385	52	have	have	VB
8691	2385	53	thus	thus	RB
8691	2385	54	indicated	indicate	VBN
8691	2385	55	to	to	TO
8691	2385	56	be	be	VB
8691	2385	57	what	what	WP
8691	2385	58	seems	seem	VBZ
8691	2385	59	to	to	IN
8691	2385	60	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2385	61	to	to	TO
8691	2385	62	be	be	VB
8691	2385	63	the	the	DT
8691	2385	64	utmost	utmost	JJ
8691	2385	65	limit	limit	NN
8691	2385	66	that	that	WDT
8691	2385	67	ought	ought	MD
8691	2385	68	to	to	TO
8691	2385	69	be	be	VB
8691	2385	70	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2385	71	.	.	.
8691	2386	1	In	in	IN
8691	2386	2	some	some	DT
8691	2386	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2386	4	,	,	,
8691	2386	5	if	if	IN
8691	2386	6	the	the	DT
8691	2386	7	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2386	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2386	9	unsatisfactory	unsatisfactory	JJ
8691	2386	10	to	to	IN
8691	2386	11	the	the	DT
8691	2386	12	judge	judge	NN
8691	2386	13	,	,	,
8691	2386	14	though	though	IN
8691	2386	15	not	not	RB
8691	2386	16	so	so	RB
8691	2386	17	manifestly	manifestly	RB
8691	2386	18	against	against	IN
8691	2386	19	the	the	DT
8691	2386	20	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2386	21	that	that	IN
8691	2386	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2386	23	would	would	MD
8691	2386	24	be	be	VB
8691	2386	25	justified	justify	VBN
8691	2386	26	in	in	IN
8691	2386	27	setting	set	VBG
8691	2386	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2386	29	aside	aside	RB
8691	2386	30	,	,	,
8691	2386	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2386	32	may	may	MD
8691	2386	33	return	return	VB
8691	2386	34	the	the	DT
8691	2386	35	jury	jury	NN
8691	2386	36	to	to	IN
8691	2386	37	a	a	DT
8691	2386	38	second	second	JJ
8691	2386	39	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	2386	40	of	of	IN
8691	2386	41	the	the	DT
8691	2386	42	cause	cause	NN
8691	2386	43	.	.	.
8691	2387	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2387	2	a	a	DT
8691	2387	3	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2387	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2387	5	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	2387	6	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2387	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2387	8	rendered	render	VBN
8691	2387	9	in	in	IN
8691	2387	10	accordance	accordance	NN
8691	2387	11	with	with	IN
8691	2387	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2387	13	.	.	.
8691	2388	1	To	to	IN
8691	2388	2	this	this	DT
8691	2388	3	rule	rule	NN
8691	2388	4	there	there	EX
8691	2388	5	are	be	VBP
8691	2388	6	,	,	,
8691	2388	7	however	however	RB
8691	2388	8	,	,	,
8691	2388	9	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2388	10	exceptions	exception	NNS
8691	2388	11	.	.	.
8691	2389	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2389	2	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2389	3	happens	happen	VBZ
8691	2389	4	that	that	IN
8691	2389	5	a	a	DT
8691	2389	6	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2389	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2389	8	returned	return	VBN
8691	2389	9	for	for	IN
8691	2389	10	a	a	DT
8691	2389	11	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2389	12	whose	whose	WP$
8691	2389	13	case	case	NN
8691	2389	14	as	as	IN
8691	2389	15	stated	state	VBN
8691	2389	16	in	in	IN
8691	2389	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2389	18	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	2389	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	2389	20	one	one	CD
8691	2389	21	which	which	WDT
8691	2389	22	in	in	IN
8691	2389	23	law	law	NN
8691	2389	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	2389	25	no	no	DT
8691	2389	26	case	case	NN
8691	2389	27	;	;	:
8691	2389	28	the	the	DT
8691	2389	29	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2389	30	having	have	VBG
8691	2389	31	failed	fail	VBN
8691	2389	32	to	to	TO
8691	2389	33	take	take	VB
8691	2389	34	this	this	DT
8691	2389	35	objection	objection	NN
8691	2389	36	and	and	CC
8691	2389	37	made	make	VBD
8691	2389	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2389	39	contest	contest	NN
8691	2389	40	only	only	RB
8691	2389	41	on	on	IN
8691	2389	42	the	the	DT
8691	2389	43	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2389	44	.	.	.
8691	2390	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2390	2	then	then	RB
8691	2390	3	can	can	MD
8691	2390	4	ask	ask	VB
8691	2390	5	the	the	DT
8691	2390	6	court	court	NN
8691	2390	7	not	not	RB
8691	2390	8	to	to	TO
8691	2390	9	render	render	VB
8691	2390	10	any	any	DT
8691	2390	11	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2390	12	upon	upon	IN
8691	2390	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2390	14	.	.	.
8691	2391	1	This	this	DT
8691	2391	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2391	3	technically	technically	RB
8691	2391	4	called	call	VBN
8691	2391	5	a	a	DT
8691	2391	6	motion	motion	NN
8691	2391	7	in	in	IN
8691	2391	8	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2391	9	of	of	IN
8691	2391	10	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2391	11	.	.	.
8691	2392	1	Again	again	RB
8691	2392	2	,	,	,
8691	2392	3	the	the	DT
8691	2392	4	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2392	5	may	may	MD
8691	2392	6	be	be	VB
8691	2392	7	rendered	render	VBN
8691	2392	8	,	,	,
8691	2392	9	by	by	IN
8691	2392	10	reason	reason	NN
8691	2392	11	of	of	IN
8691	2392	12	the	the	DT
8691	2392	13	state	state	NN
8691	2392	14	of	of	IN
8691	2392	15	the	the	DT
8691	2392	16	written	write	VBN
8691	2392	17	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	2392	18	,	,	,
8691	2392	19	on	on	IN
8691	2392	20	some	some	DT
8691	2392	21	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
8691	2392	22	point	point	NN
8691	2392	23	,	,	,
8691	2392	24	in	in	IN
8691	2392	25	favor	favor	NN
8691	2392	26	of	of	IN
8691	2392	27	one	one	CD
8691	2392	28	party	party	NN
8691	2392	29	,	,	,
8691	2392	30	when	when	WRB
8691	2392	31	there	there	EX
8691	2392	32	are	be	VBP
8691	2392	33	other	other	JJ
8691	2392	34	points	point	NNS
8691	2392	35	of	of	IN
8691	2392	36	controlling	control	VBG
8691	2392	37	importance	importance	NN
8691	2392	38	in	in	IN
8691	2392	39	favor	favor	NN
8691	2392	40	of	of	IN
8691	2392	41	the	the	DT
8691	2392	42	other	other	JJ
8691	2392	43	,	,	,
8691	2392	44	on	on	IN
8691	2392	45	which	which	WDT
8691	2392	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2392	47	has	have	VBZ
8691	2392	48	been	be	VBN
8691	2392	49	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	2392	50	that	that	IN
8691	2392	51	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2392	52	is	be	VBZ
8691	2392	53	in	in	IN
8691	2392	54	the	the	DT
8691	2392	55	right	right	NN
8691	2392	56	.	.	.
8691	2393	1	In	in	IN
8691	2393	2	such	such	JJ
8691	2393	3	case	case	NN
8691	2393	4	the	the	DT
8691	2393	5	party	party	NN
8691	2393	6	against	against	IN
8691	2393	7	whom	whom	WP
8691	2393	8	the	the	DT
8691	2393	9	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2393	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2393	11	rendered	render	VBN
8691	2393	12	may	may	MD
8691	2393	13	ask	ask	VB
8691	2393	14	for	for	IN
8691	2393	15	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2393	16	in	in	IN
8691	2393	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2393	18	own	own	JJ
8691	2393	19	favor	favor	NN
8691	2393	20	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
8691	2393	21	the	the	DT
8691	2393	22	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2393	23	.	.	.
8691	2394	1	Verdicts	verdict	NNS
8691	2394	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2394	3	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2394	4	given	give	VBN
8691	2394	5	directly	directly	RB
8691	2394	6	for	for	IN
8691	2394	7	the	the	DT
8691	2394	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2394	9	or	or	CC
8691	2394	10	the	the	DT
8691	2394	11	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2394	12	.	.	.
8691	2395	1	Printed	print	VBN
8691	2395	2	blanks	blank	NNS
8691	2395	3	for	for	IN
8691	2395	4	such	such	JJ
8691	2395	5	verdicts	verdict	NNS
8691	2395	6	,	,	,
8691	2395	7	one	one	CD
8691	2395	8	headed	head	VBD
8691	2395	9	"	"	``
8691	2395	10	plaintiff	plaintiff	NNP
8691	2395	11	's	's	POS
8691	2395	12	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2395	13	,	,	,
8691	2395	14	"	"	''
8691	2395	15	and	and	CC
8691	2395	16	the	the	DT
8691	2395	17	other	other	JJ
8691	2395	18	"	"	``
8691	2395	19	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2395	20	's	's	POS
8691	2395	21	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2395	22	,	,	,
8691	2395	23	"	"	``
8691	2395	24	are	be	VBP
8691	2395	25	often	often	RB
8691	2395	26	handed	hand	VBN
8691	2395	27	to	to	IN
8691	2395	28	the	the	DT
8691	2395	29	jury	jury	NN
8691	2395	30	when	when	WRB
8691	2395	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2395	32	retire	retire	VBP
8691	2395	33	,	,	,
8691	2395	34	to	to	TO
8691	2395	35	choose	choose	VB
8691	2395	36	from	from	IN
8691	2395	37	according	accord	VBG
8691	2395	38	as	as	IN
8691	2395	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2395	40	may	may	MD
8691	2395	41	find	find	VB
8691	2395	42	the	the	DT
8691	2395	43	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2395	44	.	.	.
8691	2396	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	2396	2	a	a	DT
8691	2396	3	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2396	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2396	5	called	call	VBN
8691	2396	6	a	a	DT
8691	2396	7	general	general	JJ
8691	2396	8	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2396	9	.	.	.
8691	2397	1	Occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	2397	2	one	one	CD
8691	2397	3	of	of	IN
8691	2397	4	a	a	DT
8691	2397	5	different	different	JJ
8691	2397	6	form	form	NN
8691	2397	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2397	8	returned	return	VBN
8691	2397	9	at	at	IN
8691	2397	10	the	the	DT
8691	2397	11	request	request	NN
8691	2397	12	of	of	IN
8691	2397	13	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2397	14	and	and	CC
8691	2397	15	by	by	IN
8691	2397	16	the	the	DT
8691	2397	17	permission	permission	NN
8691	2397	18	of	of	IN
8691	2397	19	the	the	DT
8691	2397	20	court	court	NN
8691	2397	21	.	.	.
8691	2398	1	This	this	DT
8691	2398	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2398	3	termed	term	VBN
8691	2398	4	a	a	DT
8691	2398	5	"	"	``
8691	2398	6	special	special	JJ
8691	2398	7	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2398	8	,	,	,
8691	2398	9	"	"	''
8691	2398	10	and	and	CC
8691	2398	11	sets	set	VBZ
8691	2398	12	forth	forth	RB
8691	2398	13	the	the	DT
8691	2398	14	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2398	15	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2398	16	as	as	IN
8691	2398	17	found	find	VBN
8691	2398	18	by	by	IN
8691	2398	19	the	the	DT
8691	2398	20	jury	jury	NN
8691	2398	21	in	in	IN
8691	2398	22	detail	detail	NN
8691	2398	23	,	,	,
8691	2398	24	without	without	IN
8691	2398	25	finding	find	VBG
8691	2398	26	the	the	DT
8691	2398	27	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
8691	2398	28	issue	issue	NN
8691	2398	29	for	for	IN
8691	2398	30	either	either	DT
8691	2398	31	party	party	NN
8691	2398	32	.	.	.
8691	2399	1	This	this	DT
8691	2399	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2399	3	only	only	RB
8691	2399	4	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2399	5	when	when	WRB
8691	2399	6	such	such	PDT
8691	2399	7	a	a	DT
8691	2399	8	finding	finding	NN
8691	2399	9	would	would	MD
8691	2399	10	have	have	VB
8691	2399	11	been	be	VBN
8691	2399	12	simply	simply	RB
8691	2399	13	a	a	DT
8691	2399	14	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2399	15	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	2399	16	from	from	IN
8691	2399	17	these	these	DT
8691	2399	18	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2399	19	.	.	.
8691	2400	1	A	a	DT
8691	2400	2	special	special	JJ
8691	2400	3	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2400	4	leaves	leave	VBZ
8691	2400	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2400	6	to	to	IN
8691	2400	7	the	the	DT
8691	2400	8	court	court	NN
8691	2400	9	to	to	TO
8691	2400	10	apply	apply	VB
8691	2400	11	the	the	DT
8691	2400	12	law	law	NN
8691	2400	13	and	and	CC
8691	2400	14	render	render	VB
8691	2400	15	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2400	16	as	as	IN
8691	2400	17	that	that	DT
8691	2400	18	requires	require	VBZ
8691	2400	19	.	.	.
8691	2401	1	In	in	IN
8691	2401	2	many	many	JJ
8691	2401	3	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2401	4	the	the	DT
8691	2401	5	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2401	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2401	7	all	all	DT
8691	2401	8	taken	take	VBN
8691	2401	9	out	out	IN
8691	2401	10	of	of	IN
8691	2401	11	court	court	NN
8691	2401	12	,	,	,
8691	2401	13	before	before	IN
8691	2401	14	some	some	DT
8691	2401	15	officer	officer	NN
8691	2401	16	or	or	CC
8691	2401	17	arm	arm	NN
8691	2401	18	of	of	IN
8691	2401	19	the	the	DT
8691	2401	20	court	court	NN
8691	2401	21	,	,	,
8691	2401	22	who	who	WP
8691	2401	23	only	only	RB
8691	2401	24	reports	report	VBZ
8691	2401	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2401	26	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2401	27	from	from	IN
8691	2401	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2401	29	as	as	IN
8691	2401	30	to	to	IN
8691	2401	31	the	the	DT
8691	2401	32	matters	matter	NNS
8691	2401	33	in	in	IN
8691	2401	34	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	2401	35	.	.	.
8691	2402	1	This	this	DT
8691	2402	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2402	3	a	a	DT
8691	2402	4	common	common	JJ
8691	2402	5	practice	practice	NN
8691	2402	6	in	in	IN
8691	2402	7	equity	equity	NN
8691	2402	8	,	,	,
8691	2402	9	the	the	DT
8691	2402	10	case	case	NN
8691	2402	11	being	be	VBG
8691	2402	12	sent	send	VBN
8691	2402	13	to	to	IN
8691	2402	14	a	a	DT
8691	2402	15	"	"	``
8691	2402	16	master	master	NN
8691	2402	17	in	in	IN
8691	2402	18	chancery	chancery	NN
8691	2402	19	"	"	''
8691	2402	20	for	for	IN
8691	2402	21	this	this	DT
8691	2402	22	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2402	23	.	.	.
8691	2403	1	In	in	IN
8691	2403	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	2403	3	of	of	IN
8691	2403	4	a	a	DT
8691	2403	5	common	common	JJ
8691	2403	6	law	law	NN
8691	2403	7	nature	nature	NN
8691	2403	8	the	the	DT
8691	2403	9	consent	consent	NN
8691	2403	10	of	of	IN
8691	2403	11	both	both	DT
8691	2403	12	parties	party	NNS
8691	2403	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	2403	14	generally	generally	RB
8691	2403	15	required	require	VBN
8691	2403	16	;	;	:
8691	2403	17	but	but	CC
8691	2403	18	with	with	IN
8691	2403	19	that	that	DT
8691	2403	20	any	any	DT
8691	2403	21	cause	cause	NN
8691	2403	22	may	may	MD
8691	2403	23	be	be	VB
8691	2403	24	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	2403	25	of	of	IN
8691	2403	26	before	before	IN
8691	2403	27	an	an	DT
8691	2403	28	arm	arm	NN
8691	2403	29	of	of	IN
8691	2403	30	the	the	DT
8691	2403	31	court	court	NN
8691	2403	32	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2403	33	termed	term	VBD
8691	2403	34	an	an	DT
8691	2403	35	"	"	``
8691	2403	36	auditor	auditor	NN
8691	2403	37	,	,	,
8691	2403	38	"	"	''
8691	2403	39	"	"	``
8691	2403	40	referee	referee	NN
8691	2403	41	"	"	''
8691	2403	42	or	or	CC
8691	2403	43	"	"	``
8691	2403	44	committee	committee	NN
8691	2403	45	.	.	.
8691	2403	46	"	"	''
8691	2404	1	The	the	DT
8691	2404	2	report	report	NN
8691	2404	3	of	of	IN
8691	2404	4	such	such	PDT
8691	2404	5	a	a	DT
8691	2404	6	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	2404	7	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2404	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2404	9	confined	confine	VBN
8691	2404	10	to	to	IN
8691	2404	11	the	the	DT
8691	2404	12	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2404	13	which	which	WDT
8691	2404	14	are	be	VBP
8691	2404	15	found	find	VBN
8691	2404	16	to	to	TO
8691	2404	17	have	have	VB
8691	2404	18	been	be	VBN
8691	2404	19	established	establish	VBN
8691	2404	20	.	.	.
8691	2405	1	In	in	IN
8691	2405	2	other	other	JJ
8691	2405	3	cases	case	NNS
8691	2405	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2405	5	may	may	MD
8691	2405	6	extend	extend	VB
8691	2405	7	to	to	IN
8691	2405	8	a	a	DT
8691	2405	9	provisional	provisional	JJ
8691	2405	10	decision	decision	NN
8691	2405	11	of	of	IN
8691	2405	12	questions	question	NNS
8691	2405	13	of	of	IN
8691	2405	14	law	law	NN
8691	2405	15	arising	arise	VBG
8691	2405	16	on	on	IN
8691	2405	17	those	those	DT
8691	2405	18	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2405	19	.	.	.
8691	2406	1	The	the	DT
8691	2406	2	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
8691	2406	3	decision	decision	NN
8691	2406	4	of	of	IN
8691	2406	5	any	any	DT
8691	2406	6	question	question	NN
8691	2406	7	of	of	IN
8691	2406	8	law	law	NN
8691	2406	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	2406	10	always	always	RB
8691	2406	11	for	for	IN
8691	2406	12	the	the	DT
8691	2406	13	court	court	NN
8691	2406	14	,	,	,
8691	2406	15	and	and	CC
8691	2406	16	if	if	IN
8691	2406	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2406	18	accepts	accept	VBZ
8691	2406	19	the	the	DT
8691	2406	20	report	report	NN
8691	2406	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2406	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	2406	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2406	24	duty	duty	NN
8691	2406	25	to	to	TO
8691	2406	26	draw	draw	VB
8691	2406	27	the	the	DT
8691	2406	28	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2406	29	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2406	30	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2406	31	from	from	IN
8691	2406	32	the	the	DT
8691	2406	33	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2406	34	established	establish	VBN
8691	2406	35	.	.	.
8691	2407	1	As	as	IN
8691	2407	2	to	to	IN
8691	2407	3	whether	whether	IN
8691	2407	4	the	the	DT
8691	2407	5	report	report	NN
8691	2407	6	shall	shall	MD
8691	2407	7	be	be	VB
8691	2407	8	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	2407	9	,	,	,
8691	2407	10	and	and	CC
8691	2407	11	as	as	IN
8691	2407	12	to	to	IN
8691	2407	13	the	the	DT
8691	2407	14	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2407	15	questions	question	NNS
8691	2407	16	arising	arise	VBG
8691	2407	17	upon	upon	IN
8691	2407	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2407	19	,	,	,
8691	2407	20	the	the	DT
8691	2407	21	parties	party	NNS
8691	2407	22	have	have	VBP
8691	2407	23	a	a	DT
8691	2407	24	right	right	NN
8691	2407	25	to	to	TO
8691	2407	26	be	be	VB
8691	2407	27	heard	hear	VBN
8691	2407	28	in	in	IN
8691	2407	29	court	court	NN
8691	2407	30	.	.	.
8691	2408	1	Improper	improper	JJ
8691	2408	2	or	or	CC
8691	2408	3	irregular	irregular	JJ
8691	2408	4	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	2408	5	on	on	IN
8691	2408	6	the	the	DT
8691	2408	7	part	part	NN
8691	2408	8	of	of	IN
8691	2408	9	the	the	DT
8691	2408	10	officer	officer	NN
8691	2408	11	making	make	VBG
8691	2408	12	the	the	DT
8691	2408	13	report	report	NN
8691	2408	14	may	may	MD
8691	2408	15	be	be	VB
8691	2408	16	shown	show	VBN
8691	2408	17	as	as	IN
8691	2408	18	a	a	DT
8691	2408	19	cause	cause	NN
8691	2408	20	for	for	IN
8691	2408	21	rejecting	reject	VBG
8691	2408	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2408	23	.	.	.
8691	2409	1	If	if	IN
8691	2409	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2409	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2409	4	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	2409	5	the	the	DT
8691	2409	6	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2409	7	found	find	VBN
8691	2409	8	generally	generally	RB
8691	2409	9	stand	stand	VBP
8691	2409	10	as	as	RB
8691	2409	11	conclusively	conclusively	RB
8691	2409	12	established	establish	VBN
8691	2409	13	.	.	.
8691	2410	1	Equity	equity	NN
8691	2410	2	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2410	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2410	4	generally	generally	RB
8691	2410	5	tried	try	VBN
8691	2410	6	before	before	IN
8691	2410	7	a	a	DT
8691	2410	8	single	single	JJ
8691	2410	9	judge	judge	NN
8691	2410	10	,	,	,
8691	2410	11	who	who	WP
8691	2410	12	decides	decide	VBZ
8691	2410	13	all	all	DT
8691	2410	14	questions	question	NNS
8691	2410	15	both	both	DT
8691	2410	16	of	of	IN
8691	2410	17	fact	fact	NN
8691	2410	18	and	and	CC
8691	2410	19	law	law	NN
8691	2410	20	,	,	,
8691	2410	21	proceeding	proceed	VBG
8691	2410	22	in	in	IN
8691	2410	23	the	the	DT
8691	2410	24	same	same	JJ
8691	2410	25	manner	manner	NN
8691	2410	26	as	as	IN
8691	2410	27	in	in	IN
8691	2410	28	a	a	DT
8691	2410	29	common	common	JJ
8691	2410	30	law	law	NN
8691	2410	31	cause	cause	VB
8691	2410	32	in	in	IN
8691	2410	33	which	which	WDT
8691	2410	34	a	a	DT
8691	2410	35	jury	jury	NN
8691	2410	36	has	have	VBZ
8691	2410	37	been	be	VBN
8691	2410	38	waived	waive	VBN
8691	2410	39	.	.	.
8691	2411	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2411	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2411	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2411	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2411	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2411	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	2411	7	XV	xv	NN
8691	2411	8	PROBATE	PROBATE	NNP
8691	2411	9	COURTS	court	VBD
8691	2411	10	The	the	DT
8691	2411	11	English	english	JJ
8691	2411	12	common	common	JJ
8691	2411	13	law	law	NN
8691	2411	14	regarded	regard	VBD
8691	2411	15	wills	will	NNS
8691	2411	16	of	of	IN
8691	2411	17	lands	land	NNS
8691	2411	18	as	as	IN
8691	2411	19	in	in	IN
8691	2411	20	the	the	DT
8691	2411	21	nature	nature	NN
8691	2411	22	of	of	IN
8691	2411	23	conveyances	conveyance	NNS
8691	2411	24	,	,	,
8691	2411	25	the	the	DT
8691	2411	26	due	due	JJ
8691	2411	27	execution	execution	NN
8691	2411	28	of	of	IN
8691	2411	29	which	which	WDT
8691	2411	30	,	,	,
8691	2411	31	if	if	IN
8691	2411	32	ever	ever	RB
8691	2411	33	called	call	VBN
8691	2411	34	in	in	IN
8691	2411	35	question	question	NN
8691	2411	36	in	in	IN
8691	2411	37	a	a	DT
8691	2411	38	lawsuit	lawsuit	NN
8691	2411	39	,	,	,
8691	2411	40	was	be	VBD
8691	2411	41	to	to	TO
8691	2411	42	be	be	VB
8691	2411	43	established	establish	VBN
8691	2411	44	then	then	RB
8691	2411	45	and	and	CC
8691	2411	46	there	there	RB
8691	2411	47	;	;	:
8691	2411	48	but	but	CC
8691	2411	49	if	if	IN
8691	2411	50	never	never	RB
8691	2411	51	so	so	RB
8691	2411	52	called	call	VBD
8691	2411	53	in	in	RP
8691	2411	54	question	question	NN
8691	2411	55	,	,	,
8691	2411	56	need	nee	MD
8691	2411	57	never	never	RB
8691	2411	58	be	be	VB
8691	2411	59	established	establish	VBN
8691	2411	60	at	at	RB
8691	2411	61	all	all	RB
8691	2411	62	by	by	IN
8691	2411	63	any	any	DT
8691	2411	64	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2411	65	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	2411	66	.	.	.
8691	2412	1	Wills	will	NNS
8691	2412	2	of	of	IN
8691	2412	3	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2412	4	property	property	NN
8691	2412	5	,	,	,
8691	2412	6	on	on	IN
8691	2412	7	the	the	DT
8691	2412	8	other	other	JJ
8691	2412	9	hand	hand	NN
8691	2412	10	,	,	,
8691	2412	11	were	be	VBD
8691	2412	12	to	to	TO
8691	2412	13	be	be	VB
8691	2412	14	proved	prove	VBN
8691	2412	15	as	as	RB
8691	2412	16	soon	soon	RB
8691	2412	17	as	as	IN
8691	2412	18	might	may	MD
8691	2412	19	be	be	VB
8691	2412	20	before	before	IN
8691	2412	21	an	an	DT
8691	2412	22	ecclesiastical	ecclesiastical	JJ
8691	2412	23	court	court	NN
8691	2412	24	,	,	,
8691	2412	25	and	and	CC
8691	2412	26	unless	unless	IN
8691	2412	27	so	so	RB
8691	2412	28	established	establish	VBN
8691	2412	29	were	be	VBD
8691	2412	30	ineffectual	ineffectual	JJ
8691	2412	31	.	.	.
8691	2413	1	This	this	DT
8691	2413	2	difference	difference	NN
8691	2413	3	in	in	IN
8691	2413	4	the	the	DT
8691	2413	5	treatment	treatment	NN
8691	2413	6	of	of	IN
8691	2413	7	the	the	DT
8691	2413	8	two	two	CD
8691	2413	9	kinds	kind	NNS
8691	2413	10	of	of	IN
8691	2413	11	wills	will	NNS
8691	2413	12	was	be	VBD
8691	2413	13	due	due	JJ
8691	2413	14	to	to	IN
8691	2413	15	the	the	DT
8691	2413	16	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2413	17	principle	principle	NN
8691	2413	18	that	that	WDT
8691	2413	19	so	so	RB
8691	2413	20	far	far	RB
8691	2413	21	as	as	IN
8691	2413	22	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2413	23	rights	right	NNS
8691	2413	24	and	and	CC
8691	2413	25	obligations	obligation	NNS
8691	2413	26	were	be	VBD
8691	2413	27	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	2413	28	the	the	DT
8691	2413	29	personality	personality	NN
8691	2413	30	of	of	IN
8691	2413	31	the	the	DT
8691	2413	32	dead	dead	JJ
8691	2413	33	was	be	VBD
8691	2413	34	,	,	,
8691	2413	35	after	after	IN
8691	2413	36	a	a	DT
8691	2413	37	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2413	38	fashion	fashion	NN
8691	2413	39	,	,	,
8691	2413	40	continued	continue	VBD
8691	2413	41	in	in	IN
8691	2413	42	existence	existence	NN
8691	2413	43	by	by	IN
8691	2413	44	attributing	attribute	VBG
8691	2413	45	personality	personality	NN
8691	2413	46	to	to	IN
8691	2413	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2413	48	estates	estate	NNS
8691	2413	49	.	.	.
8691	2414	1	These	these	DT
8691	2414	2	were	be	VBD
8691	2414	3	to	to	TO
8691	2414	4	be	be	VB
8691	2414	5	administered	administer	VBN
8691	2414	6	by	by	IN
8691	2414	7	some	some	DT
8691	2414	8	one	one	NN
8691	2414	9	as	as	IN
8691	2414	10	the	the	DT
8691	2414	11	"	"	``
8691	2414	12	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2414	13	representative	representative	NN
8691	2414	14	"	"	''
8691	2414	15	of	of	IN
8691	2414	16	the	the	DT
8691	2414	17	former	former	JJ
8691	2414	18	owner	owner	NN
8691	2414	19	.	.	.
8691	2415	1	This	this	DT
8691	2415	2	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2415	3	representative	representative	NN
8691	2415	4	discharged	discharge	VBD
8691	2415	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2415	6	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2415	7	obligations	obligation	NNS
8691	2415	8	so	so	RB
8691	2415	9	,	,	,
8691	2415	10	far	far	RB
8691	2415	11	as	as	IN
8691	2415	12	there	there	EX
8691	2415	13	might	may	MD
8691	2415	14	be	be	VB
8691	2415	15	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2415	16	estate	estate	NN
8691	2415	17	or	or	CC
8691	2415	18	rights	right	NNS
8691	2415	19	of	of	IN
8691	2415	20	property	property	NN
8691	2415	21	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	2415	22	for	for	IN
8691	2415	23	the	the	DT
8691	2415	24	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2415	25	.	.	.
8691	2416	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2416	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2416	3	styled	style	VBN
8691	2416	4	an	an	DT
8691	2416	5	executor	executor	NN
8691	2416	6	if	if	IN
8691	2416	7	designated	designate	VBN
8691	2416	8	by	by	IN
8691	2416	9	will	will	NN
8691	2416	10	;	;	:
8691	2416	11	an	an	DT
8691	2416	12	administrator	administrator	NN
8691	2416	13	if	if	IN
8691	2416	14	there	there	EX
8691	2416	15	were	be	VBD
8691	2416	16	no	no	DT
8691	2416	17	testamentary	testamentary	NN
8691	2416	18	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	2416	19	.	.	.
8691	2417	1	A	a	DT
8691	2417	2	man	man	NN
8691	2417	3	's	's	POS
8691	2417	4	lands	land	NNS
8691	2417	5	,	,	,
8691	2417	6	however	however	RB
8691	2417	7	,	,	,
8691	2417	8	went	go	VBD
8691	2417	9	upon	upon	IN
8691	2417	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2417	11	death	death	NN
8691	2417	12	straight	straight	RB
8691	2417	13	to	to	IN
8691	2417	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2417	15	heirs	heir	NNS
8691	2417	16	unless	unless	IN
8691	2417	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2417	18	had	have	VBD
8691	2417	19	by	by	IN
8691	2417	20	will	will	MD
8691	2417	21	conveyed	conveyed	VB
8691	2417	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2417	23	to	to	IN
8691	2417	24	some	some	DT
8691	2417	25	one	one	NN
8691	2417	26	else	else	RB
8691	2417	27	.	.	.
8691	2418	1	That	that	IN
8691	2418	2	when	when	WRB
8691	2418	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2418	4	died	die	VBD
8691	2418	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2418	6	were	be	VBD
8691	2418	7	part	part	NN
8691	2418	8	of	of	IN
8691	2418	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2418	10	estate	estate	NN
8691	2418	11	did	do	VBD
8691	2418	12	not	not	RB
8691	2418	13	charge	charge	VB
8691	2418	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2418	15	with	with	IN
8691	2418	16	the	the	DT
8691	2418	17	fulfillment	fulfillment	NN
8691	2418	18	of	of	IN
8691	2418	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2418	20	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2418	21	obligations	obligation	NNS
8691	2418	22	.	.	.
8691	2419	1	For	for	IN
8691	2419	2	the	the	DT
8691	2419	3	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	2419	4	of	of	IN
8691	2419	5	these	these	DT
8691	2419	6	the	the	DT
8691	2419	7	creditor	creditor	NN
8691	2419	8	must	must	MD
8691	2419	9	resort	resort	VB
8691	2419	10	to	to	IN
8691	2419	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2419	12	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2419	13	representative	representative	NN
8691	2419	14	.	.	.
8691	2420	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2420	2	heirs	heir	NNS
8691	2420	3	occupied	occupy	VBD
8691	2420	4	no	no	DT
8691	2420	5	such	such	JJ
8691	2420	6	position	position	NN
8691	2420	7	.	.	.
8691	2421	1	The	the	DT
8691	2421	2	administrator	administrator	NN
8691	2421	3	was	be	VBD
8691	2421	4	always	always	RB
8691	2421	5	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	2421	6	by	by	IN
8691	2421	7	an	an	DT
8691	2421	8	ecclesiastical	ecclesiastical	JJ
8691	2421	9	court	court	NN
8691	2421	10	and	and	CC
8691	2421	11	rendered	render	VBD
8691	2421	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2421	13	accounts	account	NNS
8691	2421	14	to	to	IN
8691	2421	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2421	16	.	.	.
8691	2422	1	Long	long	JJ
8691	2422	2	use	use	NN
8691	2422	3	and	and	CC
8691	2422	4	the	the	DT
8691	2422	5	existence	existence	NN
8691	2422	6	of	of	IN
8691	2422	7	a	a	DT
8691	2422	8	State	State	NNP
8691	2422	9	church	church	NN
8691	2422	10	with	with	IN
8691	2422	11	a	a	DT
8691	2422	12	regular	regular	JJ
8691	2422	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2422	14	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	2422	15	,	,	,
8691	2422	16	made	make	VBD
8691	2422	17	such	such	PDT
8691	2422	18	a	a	DT
8691	2422	19	system	system	NN
8691	2422	20	tolerable	tolerable	JJ
8691	2422	21	to	to	IN
8691	2422	22	the	the	DT
8691	2422	23	English	english	JJ
8691	2422	24	people	people	NNS
8691	2422	25	;	;	:
8691	2422	26	but	but	CC
8691	2422	27	the	the	DT
8691	2422	28	new	new	JJ
8691	2422	29	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	2422	30	under	under	IN
8691	2422	31	which	which	WDT
8691	2422	32	those	those	DT
8691	2422	33	of	of	IN
8691	2422	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2422	35	came	come	VBD
8691	2422	36	who	who	WP
8691	2422	37	planted	plant	VBD
8691	2422	38	the	the	DT
8691	2422	39	American	american	JJ
8691	2422	40	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	2422	41	made	make	VBD
8691	2422	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2422	43	both	both	CC
8691	2422	44	intolerable	intolerable	JJ
8691	2422	45	and	and	CC
8691	2422	46	impossible	impossible	JJ
8691	2422	47	here	here	RB
8691	2422	48	.	.	.
8691	2423	1	While	while	IN
8691	2423	2	most	most	JJS
8691	2423	3	of	of	IN
8691	2423	4	the	the	DT
8691	2423	5	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	2423	6	had	have	VBD
8691	2423	7	an	an	DT
8691	2423	8	established	establish	VBN
8691	2423	9	church	church	NN
8691	2423	10	,	,	,
8691	2423	11	none	none	NN
8691	2423	12	had	have	VBD
8691	2423	13	bishops	bishop	NNS
8691	2423	14	or	or	CC
8691	2423	15	bishops	bishop	NNS
8691	2423	16	'	'	POS
8691	2423	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	2423	18	.	.	.
8691	2424	1	The	the	DT
8691	2424	2	bishop	bishop	NN
8691	2424	3	of	of	IN
8691	2424	4	London	London	NNP
8691	2424	5	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	2424	6	a	a	DT
8691	2424	7	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2424	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2424	9	over	over	IN
8691	2424	10	all	all	DT
8691	2424	11	,	,	,
8691	2424	12	but	but	CC
8691	2424	13	in	in	IN
8691	2424	14	none	none	NN
8691	2424	15	was	be	VBD
8691	2424	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2424	17	recognized	recognize	VBN
8691	2424	18	as	as	IN
8691	2424	19	extending	extend	VBG
8691	2424	20	over	over	IN
8691	2424	21	the	the	DT
8691	2424	22	estates	estate	NNS
8691	2424	23	of	of	IN
8691	2424	24	the	the	DT
8691	2424	25	dead	dead	JJ
8691	2424	26	.	.	.
8691	2425	1	In	in	IN
8691	2425	2	the	the	DT
8691	2425	3	Crown	Crown	NNP
8691	2425	4	colonies	colonie	VBZ
8691	2425	5	the	the	DT
8691	2425	6	instructions	instruction	NNS
8691	2425	7	to	to	IN
8691	2425	8	the	the	DT
8691	2425	9	Governors	Governors	NNPS
8691	2425	10	generally	generally	RB
8691	2425	11	referred	refer	VBD
8691	2425	12	to	to	IN
8691	2425	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2425	14	as	as	IN
8691	2425	15	sanctioned	sanction	VBN
8691	2425	16	by	by	IN
8691	2425	17	the	the	DT
8691	2425	18	government	government	NN
8691	2425	19	but	but	CC
8691	2425	20	not	not	RB
8691	2425	21	as	as	RB
8691	2425	22	extending	extend	VBG
8691	2425	23	to	to	IN
8691	2425	24	the	the	DT
8691	2425	25	probate	probate	NN
8691	2425	26	of	of	IN
8691	2425	27	wills	will	NNS
8691	2425	28	.	.	.
8691	2426	1	Some	some	DT
8691	2426	2	of	of	IN
8691	2426	3	the	the	DT
8691	2426	4	Governors	Governors	NNPS
8691	2426	5	were	be	VBD
8691	2426	6	given	give	VBN
8691	2426	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2426	8	ex	ex	NNP
8691	2426	9	-	-	NN
8691	2426	10	officio	officio	NNP
8691	2426	11	_	_	NNP
8691	2426	12	full	full	JJ
8691	2426	13	probate	probate	JJ
8691	2426	14	powers	power	NNS
8691	2426	15	.	.	.
8691	2427	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2427	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2427	3	:	:	:
8691	2427	4	"	"	``
8691	2427	5	The	the	DT
8691	2427	6	American	American	NNP
8691	2427	7	Jurisdiction	Jurisdiction	NNP
8691	2427	8	of	of	IN
8691	2427	9	the	the	DT
8691	2427	10	Bishop	Bishop	NNP
8691	2427	11	of	of	IN
8691	2427	12	London	London	NNP
8691	2427	13	,	,	,
8691	2427	14	"	"	``
8691	2427	15	Transactions	transaction	NNS
8691	2427	16	of	of	IN
8691	2427	17	the	the	DT
8691	2427	18	American	american	JJ
8691	2427	19	Antiquarian	Antiquarian	NNP
8691	2427	20	Society	Society	NNP
8691	2427	21	,	,	,
8691	2427	22	Vol	Vol	NNP
8691	2427	23	.	.	.
8691	2428	1	XIII	XIII	NNP
8691	2428	2	,	,	,
8691	2428	3	188	188	CD
8691	2428	4	,	,	,
8691	2428	5	194	194	CD
8691	2428	6	,	,	,
8691	2428	7	197	197	CD
8691	2428	8	.	.	.
8691	2428	9	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2429	1	The	the	DT
8691	2429	2	same	same	JJ
8691	2429	3	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	2429	4	which	which	WDT
8691	2429	5	early	early	RB
8691	2429	6	led	lead	VBD
8691	2429	7	to	to	IN
8691	2429	8	the	the	DT
8691	2429	9	general	general	JJ
8691	2429	10	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	2429	11	of	of	IN
8691	2429	12	a	a	DT
8691	2429	13	recording	recording	NN
8691	2429	14	system	system	NN
8691	2429	15	for	for	IN
8691	2429	16	deeds	deed	NNS
8691	2429	17	of	of	IN
8691	2429	18	land	land	NN
8691	2429	19	in	in	IN
8691	2429	20	all	all	PDT
8691	2429	21	the	the	DT
8691	2429	22	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	2429	23	extended	extend	VBN
8691	2429	24	to	to	IN
8691	2429	25	wills	will	NNS
8691	2429	26	,	,	,
8691	2429	27	since	since	IN
8691	2429	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2429	29	also	also	RB
8691	2429	30	might	may	MD
8691	2429	31	convey	convey	VB
8691	2429	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2429	33	.	.	.
8691	2430	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	2430	2	records	record	NNS
8691	2430	3	,	,	,
8691	2430	4	to	to	TO
8691	2430	5	attain	attain	VB
8691	2430	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2430	7	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2430	8	,	,	,
8691	2430	9	had	have	VBD
8691	2430	10	to	to	TO
8691	2430	11	be	be	VB
8691	2430	12	public	public	JJ
8691	2430	13	in	in	IN
8691	2430	14	the	the	DT
8691	2430	15	fullest	full	JJS
8691	2430	16	sense	sense	NN
8691	2430	17	.	.	.
8691	2431	1	Nothing	nothing	NN
8691	2431	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2431	3	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2431	4	to	to	TO
8691	2431	5	go	go	VB
8691	2431	6	upon	upon	IN
8691	2431	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2431	8	which	which	WDT
8691	2431	9	had	have	VBD
8691	2431	10	not	not	RB
8691	2431	11	some	some	DT
8691	2431	12	kind	kind	NN
8691	2431	13	of	of	IN
8691	2431	14	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
8691	2431	15	sanction	sanction	NN
8691	2431	16	proceeding	proceed	VBG
8691	2431	17	from	from	IN
8691	2431	18	the	the	DT
8691	2431	19	State	State	NNP
8691	2431	20	.	.	.
8691	2432	1	Deeds	deed	NNS
8691	2432	2	were	be	VBD
8691	2432	3	first	first	JJ
8691	2432	4	to	to	TO
8691	2432	5	be	be	VB
8691	2432	6	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
8691	2432	7	before	before	IN
8691	2432	8	a	a	DT
8691	2432	9	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2432	10	.	.	.
8691	2433	1	As	as	IN
8691	2433	2	to	to	IN
8691	2433	3	wills	will	NNS
8691	2433	4	,	,	,
8691	2433	5	the	the	DT
8691	2433	6	practice	practice	NN
8691	2433	7	finally	finally	RB
8691	2433	8	came	come	VBD
8691	2433	9	to	to	TO
8691	2433	10	be	be	VB
8691	2433	11	to	to	TO
8691	2433	12	require	require	VB
8691	2433	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2433	14	to	to	TO
8691	2433	15	be	be	VB
8691	2433	16	established	establish	VBN
8691	2433	17	once	once	RB
8691	2433	18	for	for	IN
8691	2433	19	all	all	DT
8691	2433	20	as	as	IN
8691	2433	21	the	the	DT
8691	2433	22	act	act	NN
8691	2433	23	of	of	IN
8691	2433	24	the	the	DT
8691	2433	25	testator	testator	NN
8691	2433	26	by	by	IN
8691	2433	27	a	a	DT
8691	2433	28	court	court	NN
8691	2433	29	invested	invest	VBN
8691	2433	30	with	with	IN
8691	2433	31	special	special	JJ
8691	2433	32	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2433	33	for	for	IN
8691	2433	34	that	that	DT
8691	2433	35	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2433	36	,	,	,
8691	2433	37	and	and	CC
8691	2433	38	also	also	RB
8691	2433	39	over	over	IN
8691	2433	40	all	all	DT
8691	2433	41	estates	estate	NNS
8691	2433	42	of	of	IN
8691	2433	43	those	those	DT
8691	2433	44	who	who	WP
8691	2433	45	die	die	VBP
8691	2433	46	leaving	leave	VBG
8691	2433	47	no	no	DT
8691	2433	48	will	will	NN
8691	2433	49	.	.	.
8691	2434	1	This	this	DT
8691	2434	2	,	,	,
8691	2434	3	if	if	IN
8691	2434	4	organized	organize	VBN
8691	2434	5	for	for	IN
8691	2434	6	that	that	DT
8691	2434	7	special	special	JJ
8691	2434	8	function	function	NN
8691	2434	9	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	2434	10	,	,	,
8691	2434	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2434	12	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2434	13	styled	style	VBN
8691	2434	14	a	a	DT
8691	2434	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2434	16	of	of	IN
8691	2434	17	Probate	Probate	NNP
8691	2434	18	,	,	,
8691	2434	19	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	2434	20	a	a	DT
8691	2434	21	Surrogate	Surrogate	NNP
8691	2434	22	's	's	POS
8691	2434	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2434	24	or	or	CC
8691	2434	25	Orphans	Orphans	NNPS
8691	2434	26	'	'	POS
8691	2434	27	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2434	28	.	.	.
8691	2435	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2435	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2435	3	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2435	4	given	give	VBN
8691	2435	5	,	,	,
8691	2435	6	and	and	CC
8691	2435	7	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2435	8	not	not	RB
8691	2435	9	given	give	VBN
8691	2435	10	,	,	,
8691	2435	11	a	a	DT
8691	2435	12	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2435	13	authority	authority	NN
8691	2435	14	over	over	IN
8691	2435	15	the	the	DT
8691	2435	16	real	real	JJ
8691	2435	17	property	property	NN
8691	2435	18	within	within	IN
8691	2435	19	the	the	DT
8691	2435	20	State	State	NNP
8691	2435	21	while	while	IN
8691	2435	22	the	the	DT
8691	2435	23	estate	estate	NN
8691	2435	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	2435	25	in	in	IN
8691	2435	26	settlement	settlement	NN
8691	2435	27	.	.	.
8691	2436	1	All	all	DT
8691	2436	2	real	real	JJ
8691	2436	3	estate	estate	NN
8691	2436	4	left	leave	VBN
8691	2436	5	by	by	IN
8691	2436	6	a	a	DT
8691	2436	7	decedent	decedent	NN
8691	2436	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2436	9	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2436	10	made	make	VBN
8691	2436	11	,	,	,
8691	2436	12	by	by	IN
8691	2436	13	statute	statute	NN
8691	2436	14	,	,	,
8691	2436	15	liable	liable	JJ
8691	2436	16	for	for	IN
8691	2436	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2436	18	debts	debt	NNS
8691	2436	19	in	in	IN
8691	2436	20	case	case	NN
8691	2436	21	of	of	IN
8691	2436	22	a	a	DT
8691	2436	23	deficiency	deficiency	NN
8691	2436	24	of	of	IN
8691	2436	25	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2436	26	property	property	NN
8691	2436	27	,	,	,
8691	2436	28	except	except	IN
8691	2436	29	so	so	RB
8691	2436	30	far	far	RB
8691	2436	31	as	as	IN
8691	2436	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2436	33	may	may	MD
8691	2436	34	be	be	VB
8691	2436	35	charged	charge	VBN
8691	2436	36	with	with	IN
8691	2436	37	a	a	DT
8691	2436	38	right	right	NN
8691	2436	39	of	of	IN
8691	2436	40	dower	dower	NN
8691	2436	41	.	.	.
8691	2437	1	Even	even	RB
8691	2437	2	if	if	IN
8691	2437	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2437	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2437	5	gone	go	VBN
8691	2437	6	into	into	IN
8691	2437	7	the	the	DT
8691	2437	8	possession	possession	NN
8691	2437	9	of	of	IN
8691	2437	10	an	an	DT
8691	2437	11	heir	heir	NN
8691	2437	12	or	or	CC
8691	2437	13	devisee	devisee	NNP
8691	2437	14	,	,	,
8691	2437	15	the	the	DT
8691	2437	16	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2437	17	Probate	Probate	NNP
8691	2437	18	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2437	19	can	can	MD
8691	2437	20	order	order	VB
8691	2437	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2437	22	sale	sale	NN
8691	2437	23	for	for	IN
8691	2437	24	this	this	DT
8691	2437	25	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2437	26	,	,	,
8691	2437	27	if	if	IN
8691	2437	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2437	29	should	should	MD
8691	2437	30	appear	appear	VB
8691	2437	31	on	on	IN
8691	2437	32	the	the	DT
8691	2437	33	allowance	allowance	NN
8691	2437	34	of	of	IN
8691	2437	35	the	the	DT
8691	2437	36	administration	administration	NN
8691	2437	37	account	account	VBP
8691	2437	38	to	to	TO
8691	2437	39	be	be	VB
8691	2437	40	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2437	41	.	.	.
8691	2438	1	The	the	DT
8691	2438	2	formal	formal	JJ
8691	2438	3	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	2438	4	or	or	CC
8691	2438	5	"	"	``
8691	2438	6	probate	probate	NN
8691	2438	7	"	"	''
8691	2438	8	of	of	IN
8691	2438	9	a	a	DT
8691	2438	10	will	will	NN
8691	2438	11	does	do	VBZ
8691	2438	12	not	not	RB
8691	2438	13	affirm	affirm	VB
8691	2438	14	the	the	DT
8691	2438	15	validity	validity	NN
8691	2438	16	of	of	IN
8691	2438	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2438	18	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	2438	19	.	.	.
8691	2439	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2439	2	simply	simply	RB
8691	2439	3	adjudges	adjudge	VBZ
8691	2439	4	the	the	DT
8691	2439	5	instrument	instrument	NN
8691	2439	6	to	to	TO
8691	2439	7	be	be	VB
8691	2439	8	a	a	DT
8691	2439	9	will	will	MD
8691	2439	10	legally	legally	RB
8691	2439	11	executed	execute	VBN
8691	2439	12	by	by	IN
8691	2439	13	one	one	CD
8691	2439	14	competent	competent	NN
8691	2439	15	to	to	TO
8691	2439	16	make	make	VB
8691	2439	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2439	18	and	and	CC
8691	2439	19	who	who	WP
8691	2439	20	had	have	VBD
8691	2439	21	a	a	DT
8691	2439	22	home	home	NN
8691	2439	23	or	or	CC
8691	2439	24	property	property	NN
8691	2439	25	within	within	IN
8691	2439	26	the	the	DT
8691	2439	27	territorial	territorial	JJ
8691	2439	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2439	29	of	of	IN
8691	2439	30	the	the	DT
8691	2439	31	court	court	NN
8691	2439	32	.	.	.
8691	2440	1	Commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2440	2	,	,	,
8691	2440	3	if	if	IN
8691	2440	4	not	not	RB
8691	2440	5	universally	universally	RB
8691	2440	6	,	,	,
8691	2440	7	an	an	DT
8691	2440	8	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	2440	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	2440	10	given	give	VBN
8691	2440	11	,	,	,
8691	2440	12	either	either	CC
8691	2440	13	in	in	IN
8691	2440	14	the	the	DT
8691	2440	15	first	first	JJ
8691	2440	16	instance	instance	NN
8691	2440	17	or	or	CC
8691	2440	18	by	by	IN
8691	2440	19	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2440	20	to	to	IN
8691	2440	21	a	a	DT
8691	2440	22	higher	high	JJR
8691	2440	23	court	court	NN
8691	2440	24	,	,	,
8691	2440	25	to	to	TO
8691	2440	26	have	have	VB
8691	2440	27	these	these	DT
8691	2440	28	questions	question	NNS
8691	2440	29	tried	try	VBN
8691	2440	30	before	before	IN
8691	2440	31	a	a	DT
8691	2440	32	jury	jury	NN
8691	2440	33	.	.	.
8691	2441	1	The	the	DT
8691	2441	2	succession	succession	NN
8691	2441	3	of	of	IN
8691	2441	4	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2441	5	persons	person	NNS
8691	2441	6	to	to	IN
8691	2441	7	the	the	DT
8691	2441	8	property	property	NN
8691	2441	9	of	of	IN
8691	2441	10	the	the	DT
8691	2441	11	dead	dead	NN
8691	2441	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2441	13	not	not	RB
8691	2441	14	a	a	DT
8691	2441	15	matter	matter	NN
8691	2441	16	of	of	IN
8691	2441	17	natural	natural	JJ
8691	2441	18	right	right	NN
8691	2441	19	.	.	.
8691	2442	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2442	2	rests	rest	VBZ
8691	2442	3	upon	upon	IN
8691	2442	4	positive	positive	JJ
8691	2442	5	law	law	NN
8691	2442	6	and	and	CC
8691	2442	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2442	8	regulated	regulate	VBN
8691	2442	9	by	by	IN
8691	2442	10	the	the	DT
8691	2442	11	authority	authority	NN
8691	2442	12	of	of	IN
8691	2442	13	the	the	DT
8691	2442	14	government	government	NN
8691	2442	15	at	at	IN
8691	2442	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2442	17	pleasure	pleasure	NN
8691	2442	18	.	.	.
8691	2443	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2443	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2443	3	:	:	:
8691	2443	4	United	United	NNP
8691	2443	5	States	States	NNP
8691	2443	6	_	_	NNP
8691	2443	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	2443	8	_	_	NNP
8691	2443	9	Perkins	Perkins	NNP
8691	2443	10	,	,	,
8691	2443	11	163	163	CD
8691	2443	12	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2443	13	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2443	14	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2443	15	,	,	,
8691	2443	16	625	625	CD
8691	2443	17	.	.	.
8691	2443	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2444	1	Probate	probate	JJ
8691	2444	2	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	2444	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2444	4	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	2444	5	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	2444	6	determined	determine	VBN
8691	2444	7	by	by	IN
8691	2444	8	local	local	JJ
8691	2444	9	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	2444	10	and	and	CC
8691	2444	11	practice	practice	NN
8691	2444	12	.	.	.
8691	2445	1	In	in	IN
8691	2445	2	many	many	JJ
8691	2445	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2445	4	,	,	,
8691	2445	5	probate	probate	NN
8691	2445	6	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2445	7	belongs	belong	VBZ
8691	2445	8	to	to	IN
8691	2445	9	the	the	DT
8691	2445	10	county	county	NN
8691	2445	11	courts	court	NNS
8691	2445	12	.	.	.
8691	2446	1	In	in	IN
8691	2446	2	others	other	NNS
8691	2446	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2446	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2446	5	invested	invest	VBN
8691	2446	6	in	in	IN
8691	2446	7	local	local	JJ
8691	2446	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	2446	9	for	for	IN
8691	2446	10	lesser	less	JJR
8691	2446	11	subdivisions	subdivision	NNS
8691	2446	12	of	of	IN
8691	2446	13	territory	territory	NN
8691	2446	14	with	with	IN
8691	2446	15	the	the	DT
8691	2446	16	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2446	17	of	of	IN
8691	2446	18	cheapening	cheapen	VBG
8691	2446	19	the	the	DT
8691	2446	20	settlement	settlement	NN
8691	2446	21	of	of	IN
8691	2446	22	estates	estate	NNS
8691	2446	23	.	.	.
8691	2447	1	In	in	IN
8691	2447	2	a	a	DT
8691	2447	3	few	few	JJ
8691	2447	4	these	these	DT
8691	2447	5	local	local	JJ
8691	2447	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	2447	7	are	be	VBP
8691	2447	8	very	very	RB
8691	2447	9	numerous	numerous	JJ
8691	2447	10	,	,	,
8691	2447	11	all	all	PDT
8691	2447	12	the	the	DT
8691	2447	13	towns	town	NNS
8691	2447	14	of	of	IN
8691	2447	15	the	the	DT
8691	2447	16	State	State	NNP
8691	2447	17	being	be	VBG
8691	2447	18	distributed	distribute	VBN
8691	2447	19	into	into	IN
8691	2447	20	small	small	JJ
8691	2447	21	groups	group	NNS
8691	2447	22	and	and	CC
8691	2447	23	each	each	DT
8691	2447	24	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	2447	25	with	with	IN
8691	2447	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2447	27	Probate	Probate	NNP
8691	2447	28	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2447	29	,	,	,
8691	2447	30	the	the	DT
8691	2447	31	judge	judge	NN
8691	2447	32	of	of	IN
8691	2447	33	which	which	WDT
8691	2447	34	,	,	,
8691	2447	35	in	in	IN
8691	2447	36	many	many	JJ
8691	2447	37	instances	instance	NNS
8691	2447	38	,	,	,
8691	2447	39	has	have	VBZ
8691	2447	40	had	have	VBN
8691	2447	41	no	no	DT
8691	2447	42	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2447	43	training	training	NN
8691	2447	44	,	,	,
8691	2447	45	and	and	CC
8691	2447	46	receives	receive	VBZ
8691	2447	47	no	no	DT
8691	2447	48	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	2447	49	except	except	IN
8691	2447	50	stated	state	VBN
8691	2447	51	fees	fee	NNS
8691	2447	52	for	for	IN
8691	2447	53	such	such	JJ
8691	2447	54	business	business	NN
8691	2447	55	as	as	IN
8691	2447	56	may	may	MD
8691	2447	57	actually	actually	RB
8691	2447	58	come	come	VB
8691	2447	59	before	before	IN
8691	2447	60	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2447	61	.	.	.
8691	2448	1	An	an	DT
8691	2448	2	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2448	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2448	4	given	give	VBN
8691	2448	5	from	from	IN
8691	2448	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2448	7	orders	order	NNS
8691	2448	8	to	to	IN
8691	2448	9	a	a	DT
8691	2448	10	higher	high	JJR
8691	2448	11	court	court	NN
8691	2448	12	of	of	IN
8691	2448	13	general	general	JJ
8691	2448	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2448	15	.	.	.
8691	2449	1	In	in	IN
8691	2449	2	practice	practice	NN
8691	2449	3	such	such	PDT
8691	2449	4	a	a	DT
8691	2449	5	system	system	NN
8691	2449	6	works	work	VBZ
8691	2449	7	fairly	fairly	RB
8691	2449	8	well	well	RB
8691	2449	9	.	.	.
8691	2450	1	If	if	IN
8691	2450	2	there	there	EX
8691	2450	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2450	4	suitable	suitable	JJ
8691	2450	5	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2450	6	in	in	IN
8691	2450	7	the	the	DT
8691	2450	8	group	group	NN
8691	2450	9	of	of	IN
8691	2450	10	towns	town	NNS
8691	2450	11	forming	form	VBG
8691	2450	12	a	a	DT
8691	2450	13	probate	probate	NN
8691	2450	14	district	district	NN
8691	2450	15	,	,	,
8691	2450	16	one	one	CD
8691	2450	17	of	of	IN
8691	2450	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2450	19	who	who	WP
8691	2450	20	belongs	belong	VBZ
8691	2450	21	to	to	IN
8691	2450	22	the	the	DT
8691	2450	23	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	2450	24	party	party	NN
8691	2450	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	2450	26	generally	generally	RB
8691	2450	27	made	make	VBN
8691	2450	28	the	the	DT
8691	2450	29	judge	judge	NN
8691	2450	30	if	if	IN
8691	2450	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2450	32	will	will	MD
8691	2450	33	accept	accept	VB
8691	2450	34	the	the	DT
8691	2450	35	office	office	NN
8691	2450	36	,	,	,
8691	2450	37	and	and	CC
8691	2450	38	if	if	IN
8691	2450	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2450	40	fills	fill	VBZ
8691	2450	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2450	42	well	well	RB
8691	2450	43	is	be	VBZ
8691	2450	44	apt	apt	JJ
8691	2450	45	to	to	TO
8691	2450	46	be	be	VB
8691	2450	47	re	re	VBN
8691	2450	48	-	-	VBN
8691	2450	49	elected	elect	VBN
8691	2450	50	,	,	,
8691	2450	51	whichever	whichever	WDT
8691	2450	52	party	party	NN
8691	2450	53	may	may	MD
8691	2450	54	then	then	RB
8691	2450	55	be	be	VB
8691	2450	56	uppermost	uppermost	JJ
8691	2450	57	.	.	.
8691	2451	1	If	if	IN
8691	2451	2	a	a	DT
8691	2451	3	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	2451	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2451	5	not	not	RB
8691	2451	6	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	2451	7	and	and	CC
8691	2451	8	a	a	DT
8691	2451	9	case	case	NN
8691	2451	10	of	of	IN
8691	2451	11	any	any	DT
8691	2451	12	difficulty	difficulty	NN
8691	2451	13	presents	present	VBZ
8691	2451	14	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2451	15	,	,	,
8691	2451	16	the	the	DT
8691	2451	17	judge	judge	NN
8691	2451	18	will	will	MD
8691	2451	19	probably	probably	RB
8691	2451	20	consult	consult	VB
8691	2451	21	some	some	DT
8691	2451	22	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2451	23	in	in	IN
8691	2451	24	whom	whom	WP
8691	2451	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2451	26	feels	feel	VBZ
8691	2451	27	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	2451	28	,	,	,
8691	2451	29	and	and	CC
8691	2451	30	who	who	WP
8691	2451	31	will	will	MD
8691	2451	32	be	be	VB
8691	2451	33	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
8691	2451	34	flattered	flatter	VBN
8691	2451	35	by	by	IN
8691	2451	36	the	the	DT
8691	2451	37	request	request	NN
8691	2451	38	to	to	TO
8691	2451	39	advise	advise	VB
8691	2451	40	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2451	41	without	without	IN
8691	2451	42	making	make	VBG
8691	2451	43	any	any	DT
8691	2451	44	charge	charge	NN
8691	2451	45	for	for	IN
8691	2451	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2451	47	.	.	.
8691	2452	1	The	the	DT
8691	2452	2	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2452	3	seat	seat	NN
8691	2452	4	of	of	IN
8691	2452	5	administration	administration	NN
8691	2452	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2452	7	in	in	IN
8691	2452	8	the	the	DT
8691	2452	9	State	State	NNP
8691	2452	10	and	and	CC
8691	2452	11	the	the	DT
8691	2452	12	local	local	JJ
8691	2452	13	subdivision	subdivision	NN
8691	2452	14	of	of	IN
8691	2452	15	the	the	DT
8691	2452	16	State	State	NNP
8691	2452	17	where	where	WRB
8691	2452	18	the	the	DT
8691	2452	19	dead	dead	JJ
8691	2452	20	man	man	NN
8691	2452	21	belonged	belong	VBD
8691	2452	22	.	.	.
8691	2453	1	Proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2453	2	there	there	RB
8691	2453	3	affect	affect	VBP
8691	2453	4	all	all	PDT
8691	2453	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2453	6	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2453	7	property	property	NN
8691	2453	8	wherever	wherever	WRB
8691	2453	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2453	10	may	may	MD
8691	2453	11	be	be	VB
8691	2453	12	found	find	VBN
8691	2453	13	,	,	,
8691	2453	14	and	and	CC
8691	2453	15	generally	generally	RB
8691	2453	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2453	17	real	real	JJ
8691	2453	18	estate	estate	NN
8691	2453	19	situated	situate	VBN
8691	2453	20	anywhere	anywhere	RB
8691	2453	21	in	in	IN
8691	2453	22	the	the	DT
8691	2453	23	State	State	NNP
8691	2453	24	.	.	.
8691	2454	1	Real	real	JJ
8691	2454	2	estate	estate	NN
8691	2454	3	in	in	IN
8691	2454	4	another	another	DT
8691	2454	5	State	state	NN
8691	2454	6	can	can	MD
8691	2454	7	be	be	VB
8691	2454	8	affected	affect	VBN
8691	2454	9	by	by	IN
8691	2454	10	probate	probate	NN
8691	2454	11	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2454	12	only	only	RB
8691	2454	13	if	if	IN
8691	2454	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2454	15	take	take	VBP
8691	2454	16	place	place	NN
8691	2454	17	there	there	RB
8691	2454	18	,	,	,
8691	2454	19	by	by	IN
8691	2454	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2454	21	authority	authority	NN
8691	2454	22	.	.	.
8691	2455	1	For	for	IN
8691	2455	2	that	that	DT
8691	2455	3	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2455	4	"	"	``
8691	2455	5	ancillary	ancillary	JJ
8691	2455	6	"	"	''
8691	2455	7	administration	administration	NN
8691	2455	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2455	9	often	often	RB
8691	2455	10	taken	take	VBN
8691	2455	11	out	out	RP
8691	2455	12	,	,	,
8691	2455	13	that	that	RB
8691	2455	14	is	is	RB
8691	2455	15	,	,	,
8691	2455	16	one	one	CD
8691	2455	17	designed	design	VBN
8691	2455	18	to	to	TO
8691	2455	19	serve	serve	VB
8691	2455	20	the	the	DT
8691	2455	21	interests	interest	NNS
8691	2455	22	of	of	IN
8691	2455	23	the	the	DT
8691	2455	24	general	general	JJ
8691	2455	25	succession	succession	NN
8691	2455	26	as	as	IN
8691	2455	27	administered	administer	VBN
8691	2455	28	in	in	IN
8691	2455	29	the	the	DT
8691	2455	30	seat	seat	NN
8691	2455	31	of	of	IN
8691	2455	32	the	the	DT
8691	2455	33	principal	principal	JJ
8691	2455	34	administration	administration	NN
8691	2455	35	.	.	.
8691	2456	1	Since	since	IN
8691	2456	2	the	the	DT
8691	2456	3	right	right	NN
8691	2456	4	of	of	IN
8691	2456	5	a	a	DT
8691	2456	6	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2456	7	representative	representative	NN
8691	2456	8	to	to	TO
8691	2456	9	act	act	VB
8691	2456	10	for	for	IN
8691	2456	11	the	the	DT
8691	2456	12	estate	estate	NN
8691	2456	13	of	of	IN
8691	2456	14	the	the	DT
8691	2456	15	dead	dead	NN
8691	2456	16	comes	come	VBZ
8691	2456	17	from	from	IN
8691	2456	18	the	the	DT
8691	2456	19	positive	positive	JJ
8691	2456	20	law	law	NN
8691	2456	21	of	of	IN
8691	2456	22	the	the	DT
8691	2456	23	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2456	24	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	2456	25	having	have	VBG
8691	2456	26	the	the	DT
8691	2456	27	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2456	28	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2456	29	,	,	,
8691	2456	30	and	and	CC
8691	2456	31	since	since	IN
8691	2456	32	no	no	DT
8691	2456	33	law	law	NN
8691	2456	34	of	of	IN
8691	2456	35	a	a	DT
8691	2456	36	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2456	37	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	2456	38	can	can	MD
8691	2456	39	be	be	VB
8691	2456	40	enforced	enforce	VBN
8691	2456	41	,	,	,
8691	2456	42	by	by	IN
8691	2456	43	virtue	virtue	NN
8691	2456	44	of	of	IN
8691	2456	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2456	46	power	power	NN
8691	2456	47	or	or	CC
8691	2456	48	anything	anything	NN
8691	2456	49	dependent	dependent	JJ
8691	2456	50	on	on	IN
8691	2456	51	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2456	52	,	,	,
8691	2456	53	outside	outside	IN
8691	2456	54	of	of	IN
8691	2456	55	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2456	56	territorial	territorial	JJ
8691	2456	57	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2456	58	,	,	,
8691	2456	59	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2456	60	follows	follow	VBZ
8691	2456	61	that	that	IN
8691	2456	62	no	no	DT
8691	2456	63	executor	executor	NN
8691	2456	64	or	or	CC
8691	2456	65	administrator	administrator	NN
8691	2456	66	can	can	MD
8691	2456	67	of	of	IN
8691	2456	68	right	right	NN
8691	2456	69	maintain	maintain	VB
8691	2456	70	a	a	DT
8691	2456	71	suit	suit	NN
8691	2456	72	,	,	,
8691	2456	73	as	as	IN
8691	2456	74	such	such	JJ
8691	2456	75	,	,	,
8691	2456	76	out	out	IN
8691	2456	77	of	of	IN
8691	2456	78	the	the	DT
8691	2456	79	State	State	NNP
8691	2456	80	from	from	IN
8691	2456	81	the	the	DT
8691	2456	82	laws	law	NNS
8691	2456	83	of	of	IN
8691	2456	84	which	which	WDT
8691	2456	85	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2456	86	derives	derive	VBZ
8691	2456	87	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2456	88	authority	authority	NN
8691	2456	89	.	.	.
8691	2457	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2457	2	may	may	MD
8691	2457	3	take	take	VB
8691	2457	4	possession	possession	NN
8691	2457	5	of	of	IN
8691	2457	6	the	the	DT
8691	2457	7	goods	good	NNS
8691	2457	8	of	of	IN
8691	2457	9	the	the	DT
8691	2457	10	estate	estate	NN
8691	2457	11	found	find	VBN
8691	2457	12	in	in	IN
8691	2457	13	another	another	DT
8691	2457	14	State	state	NN
8691	2457	15	,	,	,
8691	2457	16	or	or	CC
8691	2457	17	collect	collect	VB
8691	2457	18	debts	debt	NNS
8691	2457	19	due	due	JJ
8691	2457	20	from	from	IN
8691	2457	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2457	22	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	2457	23	if	if	IN
8691	2457	24	no	no	DT
8691	2457	25	objection	objection	NN
8691	2457	26	be	be	VB
8691	2457	27	made	make	VBN
8691	2457	28	,	,	,
8691	2457	29	but	but	CC
8691	2457	30	if	if	IN
8691	2457	31	forced	force	VBN
8691	2457	32	to	to	TO
8691	2457	33	claim	claim	VB
8691	2457	34	the	the	DT
8691	2457	35	aid	aid	NN
8691	2457	36	of	of	IN
8691	2457	37	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2457	38	process	process	NN
8691	2457	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2457	40	must	must	MD
8691	2457	41	first	first	RB
8691	2457	42	prove	prove	VB
8691	2457	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2457	44	title	title	NN
8691	2457	45	there	there	RB
8691	2457	46	before	before	IN
8691	2457	47	the	the	DT
8691	2457	48	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
8691	2457	49	Probate	Probate	NNP
8691	2457	50	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2457	51	by	by	IN
8691	2457	52	taking	take	VBG
8691	2457	53	out	out	RP
8691	2457	54	ancillary	ancillary	JJ
8691	2457	55	administration	administration	NN
8691	2457	56	,	,	,
8691	2457	57	in	in	IN
8691	2457	58	which	which	WDT
8691	2457	59	case	case	NN
8691	2457	60	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2457	61	will	will	MD
8691	2457	62	probably	probably	RB
8691	2457	63	be	be	VB
8691	2457	64	compelled	compel	VBN
8691	2457	65	to	to	TO
8691	2457	66	give	give	VB
8691	2457	67	security	security	NN
8691	2457	68	for	for	IN
8691	2457	69	the	the	DT
8691	2457	70	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2457	71	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	2457	72	of	of	IN
8691	2457	73	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2457	74	duties	duty	NNS
8691	2457	75	under	under	IN
8691	2457	76	such	such	JJ
8691	2457	77	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	2457	78	.	.	.
8691	2458	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2458	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2458	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2458	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2458	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2458	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	2458	7	XVI	xvi	NN
8691	2458	8	BANKRUPTCY	BANKRUPTCY	NNS
8691	2458	9	AND	and	CC
8691	2458	10	INSOLVENCY	INSOLVENCY	VBN
8691	2458	11	COURTS	court	NNS
8691	2458	12	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2458	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	2458	14	within	within	IN
8691	2458	15	the	the	DT
8691	2458	16	power	power	NN
8691	2458	17	of	of	IN
8691	2458	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	2458	19	to	to	TO
8691	2458	20	assume	assume	VB
8691	2458	21	the	the	DT
8691	2458	22	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
8691	2458	23	regulation	regulation	NN
8691	2458	24	of	of	IN
8691	2458	25	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2458	26	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2458	27	throughout	throughout	IN
8691	2458	28	the	the	DT
8691	2458	29	United	United	NNP
8691	2458	30	States	States	NNP
8691	2458	31	.	.	.
8691	2459	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2459	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2459	3	:	:	:
8691	2459	4	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2459	5	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2459	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2459	7	,	,	,
8691	2459	8	Art	art	NN
8691	2459	9	.	.	.
8691	2460	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2460	2	,	,	,
8691	2460	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	2460	4	.	.	.
8691	2461	1	8	8	LS
8691	2461	2	.	.	.
8691	2461	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2462	1	There	there	EX
8691	2462	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2462	3	in	in	IN
8691	2462	4	this	this	DT
8691	2462	5	country	country	NN
8691	2462	6	no	no	DT
8691	2462	7	real	real	JJ
8691	2462	8	difference	difference	NN
8691	2462	9	in	in	IN
8691	2462	10	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	2462	11	between	between	IN
8691	2462	12	the	the	DT
8691	2462	13	terms	term	NNS
8691	2462	14	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2462	15	and	and	CC
8691	2462	16	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	2462	17	.	.	.
8691	2463	1	Each	each	DT
8691	2463	2	denotes	denote	VBZ
8691	2463	3	a	a	DT
8691	2463	4	_	_	NNP
8691	2463	5	status	status	NN
8691	2463	6	_	_	NNP
8691	2463	7	into	into	IN
8691	2463	8	which	which	WDT
8691	2463	9	one	one	NN
8691	2463	10	unable	unable	JJ
8691	2463	11	to	to	TO
8691	2463	12	pay	pay	VB
8691	2463	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2463	14	debts	debt	NNS
8691	2463	15	,	,	,
8691	2463	16	as	as	IN
8691	2463	17	and	and	CC
8691	2463	18	when	when	WRB
8691	2463	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2463	20	fall	fall	VBP
8691	2463	21	due	due	JJ
8691	2463	22	,	,	,
8691	2463	23	may	may	MD
8691	2463	24	put	put	VB
8691	2463	25	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2463	26	,	,	,
8691	2463	27	or	or	CC
8691	2463	28	be	be	VB
8691	2463	29	put	put	VBN
8691	2463	30	by	by	IN
8691	2463	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2463	32	creditors	creditor	NNS
8691	2463	33	.	.	.
8691	2464	1	The	the	DT
8691	2464	2	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	2464	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2464	4	not	not	RB
8691	2464	5	confined	confine	VBN
8691	2464	6	to	to	IN
8691	2464	7	any	any	DT
8691	2464	8	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2464	9	classes	class	NNS
8691	2464	10	of	of	IN
8691	2464	11	persons	person	NNS
8691	2464	12	,	,	,
8691	2464	13	and	and	CC
8691	2464	14	no	no	DT
8691	2464	15	more	more	JJR
8691	2464	16	fault	fault	NN
8691	2464	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	2464	18	implied	imply	VBN
8691	2464	19	on	on	IN
8691	2464	20	the	the	DT
8691	2464	21	part	part	NN
8691	2464	22	of	of	IN
8691	2464	23	one	one	CD
8691	2464	24	who	who	WP
8691	2464	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	2464	26	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
8691	2464	27	a	a	DT
8691	2464	28	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
8691	2464	29	than	than	IN
8691	2464	30	on	on	IN
8691	2464	31	the	the	DT
8691	2464	32	part	part	NN
8691	2464	33	of	of	IN
8691	2464	34	one	one	CD
8691	2464	35	who	who	WP
8691	2464	36	is	be	VBZ
8691	2464	37	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
8691	2464	38	an	an	DT
8691	2464	39	insolvent	insolvent	NN
8691	2464	40	.	.	.
8691	2465	1	During	during	IN
8691	2465	2	most	most	JJS
8691	2465	3	of	of	IN
8691	2465	4	the	the	DT
8691	2465	5	history	history	NN
8691	2465	6	of	of	IN
8691	2465	7	the	the	DT
8691	2465	8	United	United	NNP
8691	2465	9	States	States	NNP
8691	2465	10	there	there	EX
8691	2465	11	has	have	VBZ
8691	2465	12	been	be	VBN
8691	2465	13	no	no	DT
8691	2465	14	uniform	uniform	JJ
8691	2465	15	law	law	NN
8691	2465	16	on	on	IN
8691	2465	17	the	the	DT
8691	2465	18	subject	subject	NN
8691	2465	19	of	of	IN
8691	2465	20	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2465	21	for	for	IN
8691	2465	22	the	the	DT
8691	2465	23	whole	whole	JJ
8691	2465	24	country	country	NN
8691	2465	25	.	.	.
8691	2466	1	Three	three	CD
8691	2466	2	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
8691	2466	3	Acts	act	NNS
8691	2466	4	were	be	VBD
8691	2466	5	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	2466	6	by	by	IN
8691	2466	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	2466	8	from	from	IN
8691	2466	9	time	time	NN
8691	2466	10	to	to	IN
8691	2466	11	time	time	NN
8691	2466	12	during	during	IN
8691	2466	13	the	the	DT
8691	2466	14	first	first	JJ
8691	2466	15	century	century	NN
8691	2466	16	after	after	IN
8691	2466	17	the	the	DT
8691	2466	18	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	2466	19	of	of	IN
8691	2466	20	the	the	DT
8691	2466	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2466	22	.	.	.
8691	2467	1	Each	each	DT
8691	2467	2	followed	follow	VBD
8691	2467	3	some	some	DT
8691	2467	4	serious	serious	JJ
8691	2467	5	financial	financial	JJ
8691	2467	6	crisis	crisis	NN
8691	2467	7	,	,	,
8691	2467	8	and	and	CC
8691	2467	9	was	be	VBD
8691	2467	10	repealed	repeal	VBN
8691	2467	11	not	not	RB
8691	2467	12	long	long	RB
8691	2467	13	after	after	IN
8691	2467	14	the	the	DT
8691	2467	15	immediate	immediate	JJ
8691	2467	16	effects	effect	NNS
8691	2467	17	of	of	IN
8691	2467	18	the	the	DT
8691	2467	19	crisis	crisis	NN
8691	2467	20	had	have	VBD
8691	2467	21	passed	pass	VBN
8691	2467	22	away	away	RB
8691	2467	23	.	.	.
8691	2468	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2468	2	were	be	VBD
8691	2468	3	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	2468	4	as	as	IN
8691	2468	5	a	a	DT
8691	2468	6	kind	kind	NN
8691	2468	7	of	of	IN
8691	2468	8	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2468	9	Greek	greek	JJ
8691	2468	10	:	:	:
8691	2468	11	seisachtheia	seisachtheia	NN
8691	2468	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2468	13	to	to	TO
8691	2468	14	help	help	VB
8691	2468	15	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
8691	2468	16	debtors	debtor	NNS
8691	2468	17	to	to	TO
8691	2468	18	get	get	VB
8691	2468	19	on	on	IN
8691	2468	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2468	21	feet	foot	NNS
8691	2468	22	again	again	RB
8691	2468	23	.	.	.
8691	2469	1	A	a	DT
8691	2469	2	later	later	JJ
8691	2469	3	Act	Act	NNP
8691	2469	4	passed	pass	VBD
8691	2469	5	in	in	IN
8691	2469	6	1898	1898	CD
8691	2469	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2469	8	still	still	RB
8691	2469	9	in	in	IN
8691	2469	10	force,[Footnote	force,[Footnote	NNP
8691	2469	11	:	:	:
8691	2469	12	30	30	CD
8691	2469	13	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2469	14	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2469	15	Statutes	Statutes	NNP
8691	2469	16	at	at	IN
8691	2469	17	Large	large	JJ
8691	2469	18	,	,	,
8691	2469	19	544	544	CD
8691	2469	20	;	;	:
8691	2469	21	32	32	CD
8691	2469	22	_	_	NNP
8691	2469	23	i	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2469	24	d	d	NN
8691	2469	25	.	.	.
8691	2469	26	_	_	NNP
8691	2469	27	,	,	,
8691	2469	28	797	797	CD
8691	2469	29	.	.	.
8691	2469	30	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2470	1	and	and	CC
8691	2470	2	as	as	IN
8691	2470	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2470	4	contains	contain	VBZ
8691	2470	5	many	many	JJ
8691	2470	6	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	2470	7	which	which	WDT
8691	2470	8	have	have	VBP
8691	2470	9	been	be	VBN
8691	2470	10	found	find	VBN
8691	2470	11	useful	useful	JJ
8691	2470	12	by	by	IN
8691	2470	13	creditors	creditor	NNS
8691	2470	14	as	as	RB
8691	2470	15	well	well	RB
8691	2470	16	as	as	IN
8691	2470	17	by	by	IN
8691	2470	18	debtors	debtor	NNS
8691	2470	19	,	,	,
8691	2470	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2470	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	2470	22	not	not	RB
8691	2470	23	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
8691	2470	24	to	to	TO
8691	2470	25	remain	remain	VB
8691	2470	26	permanently	permanently	RB
8691	2470	27	upon	upon	IN
8691	2470	28	the	the	DT
8691	2470	29	statute	statute	NN
8691	2470	30	-	-	HYPH
8691	2470	31	books	book	NNS
8691	2470	32	.	.	.
8691	2471	1	The	the	DT
8691	2471	2	prosperity	prosperity	NN
8691	2471	3	of	of	IN
8691	2471	4	the	the	DT
8691	2471	5	United	United	NNP
8691	2471	6	States	States	NNP
8691	2471	7	rests	rest	VBZ
8691	2471	8	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	2471	9	on	on	IN
8691	2471	10	the	the	DT
8691	2471	11	absolute	absolute	JJ
8691	2471	12	free	free	JJ
8691	2471	13	trade	trade	NN
8691	2471	14	which	which	WDT
8691	2471	15	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	2471	16	between	between	IN
8691	2471	17	the	the	DT
8691	2471	18	several	several	JJ
8691	2471	19	States	state	NNS
8691	2471	20	.	.	.
8691	2472	1	That	that	IN
8691	2472	2	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	2472	3	results	result	VBZ
8691	2472	4	in	in	IN
8691	2472	5	innumerable	innumerable	JJ
8691	2472	6	credits	credit	NNS
8691	2472	7	extended	extend	VBN
8691	2472	8	by	by	IN
8691	2472	9	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	2472	10	of	of	IN
8691	2472	11	one	one	CD
8691	2472	12	State	state	NN
8691	2472	13	to	to	IN
8691	2472	14	those	those	DT
8691	2472	15	of	of	IN
8691	2472	16	others	other	NNS
8691	2472	17	,	,	,
8691	2472	18	and	and	CC
8691	2472	19	in	in	IN
8691	2472	20	immense	immense	JJ
8691	2472	21	property	property	NN
8691	2472	22	interests	interest	NNS
8691	2472	23	in	in	IN
8691	2472	24	each	each	DT
8691	2472	25	State	state	NN
8691	2472	26	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	2472	27	to	to	IN
8691	2472	28	non	non	JJ
8691	2472	29	-	-	NNS
8691	2472	30	residents	resident	NNS
8691	2472	31	.	.	.
8691	2473	1	In	in	IN
8691	2473	2	case	case	NN
8691	2473	3	of	of	IN
8691	2473	4	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	2473	5	full	full	JJ
8691	2473	6	justice	justice	NN
8691	2473	7	can	can	MD
8691	2473	8	not	not	RB
8691	2473	9	be	be	VB
8691	2473	10	worked	work	VBN
8691	2473	11	out	out	RP
8691	2473	12	except	except	IN
8691	2473	13	through	through	IN
8691	2473	14	the	the	DT
8691	2473	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	2473	16	powers	power	NNS
8691	2473	17	vested	vest	VBN
8691	2473	18	in	in	IN
8691	2473	19	the	the	DT
8691	2473	20	United	United	NNP
8691	2473	21	States	States	NNP
8691	2473	22	.	.	.
8691	2474	1	The	the	DT
8691	2474	2	Act	Act	NNP
8691	2474	3	of	of	IN
8691	2474	4	1898	1898	CD
8691	2474	5	allows	allow	VBZ
8691	2474	6	any	any	DT
8691	2474	7	one	one	CD
8691	2474	8	except	except	IN
8691	2474	9	a	a	DT
8691	2474	10	corporation	corporation	NN
8691	2474	11	to	to	TO
8691	2474	12	become	become	VB
8691	2474	13	a	a	DT
8691	2474	14	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
8691	2474	15	bankrupt	bankrupt	NN
8691	2474	16	.	.	.
8691	2475	1	Practically	practically	RB
8691	2475	2	any	any	DT
8691	2475	3	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
8691	2475	4	debtor	debtor	NN
8691	2475	5	can	can	MD
8691	2475	6	be	be	VB
8691	2475	7	thrown	throw	VBN
8691	2475	8	into	into	IN
8691	2475	9	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
8691	2475	10	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2475	11	,	,	,
8691	2475	12	except	except	IN
8691	2475	13	wage	wage	NN
8691	2475	14	earners	earner	NNS
8691	2475	15	,	,	,
8691	2475	16	farmers	farmer	NNS
8691	2475	17	,	,	,
8691	2475	18	incorporated	incorporate	VBN
8691	2475	19	banks	bank	NNS
8691	2475	20	,	,	,
8691	2475	21	or	or	CC
8691	2475	22	business	business	NN
8691	2475	23	corporations	corporation	NNS
8691	2475	24	owing	owe	VBG
8691	2475	25	less	less	JJR
8691	2475	26	than	than	IN
8691	2475	27	$	$	$
8691	2475	28	1,000	1,000	CD
8691	2475	29	.	.	.
8691	2476	1	This	this	DT
8691	2476	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2476	3	so	so	RB
8691	2476	4	even	even	RB
8691	2476	5	if	if	IN
8691	2476	6	a	a	DT
8691	2476	7	State	State	NNP
8691	2476	8	court	court	NN
8691	2476	9	of	of	IN
8691	2476	10	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	2476	11	has	have	VBZ
8691	2476	12	already	already	RB
8691	2476	13	taken	take	VBN
8691	2476	14	charge	charge	NN
8691	2476	15	of	of	IN
8691	2476	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2476	17	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	2476	18	;	;	:
8691	2476	19	and	and	CC
8691	2476	20	if	if	IN
8691	2476	21	that	that	DT
8691	2476	22	has	have	VBZ
8691	2476	23	occurred	occur	VBN
8691	2476	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2476	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	2476	26	of	of	IN
8691	2476	27	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2476	28	a	a	DT
8691	2476	29	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	2476	30	reason	reason	NN
8691	2476	31	for	for	IN
8691	2476	32	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2476	33	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2476	34	.	.	.
8691	2477	1	Petitions	petition	NNS
8691	2477	2	in	in	IN
8691	2477	3	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2477	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2477	5	preferred	prefer	VBN
8691	2477	6	to	to	IN
8691	2477	7	a	a	DT
8691	2477	8	District	District	NNP
8691	2477	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2477	10	of	of	IN
8691	2477	11	the	the	DT
8691	2477	12	United	United	NNP
8691	2477	13	States	States	NNP
8691	2477	14	.	.	.
8691	2478	1	Each	each	DT
8691	2478	2	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
8691	2478	3	estate	estate	NN
8691	2478	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2478	5	put	put	VBN
8691	2478	6	in	in	IN
8691	2478	7	charge	charge	NN
8691	2478	8	of	of	IN
8691	2478	9	one	one	CD
8691	2478	10	or	or	CC
8691	2478	11	more	more	JJR
8691	2478	12	trustees	trustee	NNS
8691	2478	13	.	.	.
8691	2479	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2479	2	can	can	MD
8691	2479	3	maintain	maintain	VB
8691	2479	4	actions	action	NNS
8691	2479	5	to	to	TO
8691	2479	6	recover	recover	VB
8691	2479	7	or	or	CC
8691	2479	8	protect	protect	VB
8691	2479	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2479	10	,	,	,
8691	2479	11	as	as	IN
8691	2479	12	a	a	DT
8691	2479	13	general	general	JJ
8691	2479	14	rule	rule	NN
8691	2479	15	,	,	,
8691	2479	16	in	in	IN
8691	2479	17	the	the	DT
8691	2479	18	courts	court	NNS
8691	2479	19	of	of	IN
8691	2479	20	any	any	DT
8691	2479	21	State	State	NNP
8691	2479	22	as	as	RB
8691	2479	23	well	well	RB
8691	2479	24	as	as	IN
8691	2479	25	in	in	IN
8691	2479	26	those	those	DT
8691	2479	27	of	of	IN
8691	2479	28	the	the	DT
8691	2479	29	United	United	NNP
8691	2479	30	States	States	NNP
8691	2479	31	.	.	.
8691	2480	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2480	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2480	3	:	:	:
8691	2480	4	See	see	VB
8691	2480	5	Bardes	Bardes	NNPS
8691	2480	6	_	_	NNP
8691	2480	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	2480	8	_	_	NNP
8691	2480	9	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	2480	10	,	,	,
8691	2480	11	178	178	CD
8691	2480	12	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2480	13	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2480	14	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2480	15	,	,	,
8691	2480	16	524	524	CD
8691	2480	17	.	.	.
8691	2480	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2481	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2481	2	title	title	NN
8691	2481	3	does	do	VBZ
8691	2481	4	not	not	RB
8691	2481	5	extend	extend	VB
8691	2481	6	to	to	IN
8691	2481	7	anything	anything	NN
8691	2481	8	which	which	WDT
8691	2481	9	by	by	IN
8691	2481	10	the	the	DT
8691	2481	11	laws	law	NNS
8691	2481	12	of	of	IN
8691	2481	13	the	the	DT
8691	2481	14	State	State	NNP
8691	2481	15	where	where	WRB
8691	2481	16	the	the	DT
8691	2481	17	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
8691	2481	18	belongs	belong	NNS
8691	2481	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	2481	20	exempt	exempt	JJ
8691	2481	21	from	from	IN
8691	2481	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2481	23	creditors	creditor	NNS
8691	2481	24	.	.	.
8691	2482	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	2482	2	exemptions	exemption	NNS
8691	2482	3	differ	differ	VBP
8691	2482	4	greatly	greatly	RB
8691	2482	5	in	in	IN
8691	2482	6	different	different	JJ
8691	2482	7	parts	part	NNS
8691	2482	8	of	of	IN
8691	2482	9	the	the	DT
8691	2482	10	country	country	NN
8691	2482	11	.	.	.
8691	2483	1	In	in	IN
8691	2483	2	some	some	DT
8691	2483	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2483	4	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2483	5	property	property	NN
8691	2483	6	of	of	IN
8691	2483	7	the	the	DT
8691	2483	8	value	value	NN
8691	2483	9	of	of	IN
8691	2483	10	$	$	$
8691	2483	11	5,000	5,000	CD
8691	2483	12	may	may	MD
8691	2483	13	be	be	VB
8691	2483	14	exempt	exempt	JJ
8691	2483	15	;	;	:
8691	2483	16	in	in	IN
8691	2483	17	others	other	NNS
8691	2483	18	the	the	DT
8691	2483	19	amount	amount	NN
8691	2483	20	which	which	WDT
8691	2483	21	the	the	DT
8691	2483	22	debtor	debtor	NN
8691	2483	23	can	can	MD
8691	2483	24	retain	retain	VB
8691	2483	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	2483	26	comparatively	comparatively	RB
8691	2483	27	trifling	trifle	VBG
8691	2483	28	.	.	.
8691	2484	1	There	there	EX
8691	2484	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2484	3	,	,	,
8691	2484	4	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	2484	5	,	,	,
8691	2484	6	no	no	DT
8691	2484	7	uniformity	uniformity	NN
8691	2484	8	in	in	IN
8691	2484	9	the	the	DT
8691	2484	10	result	result	NN
8691	2484	11	;	;	:
8691	2484	12	but	but	CC
8691	2484	13	there	there	EX
8691	2484	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	2484	15	,	,	,
8691	2484	16	nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
8691	2484	17	,	,	,
8691	2484	18	uniformity	uniformity	NN
8691	2484	19	in	in	IN
8691	2484	20	the	the	DT
8691	2484	21	rule	rule	NN
8691	2484	22	under	under	IN
8691	2484	23	which	which	WDT
8691	2484	24	the	the	DT
8691	2484	25	results	result	NNS
8691	2484	26	are	be	VBP
8691	2484	27	reached	reach	VBN
8691	2484	28	,	,	,
8691	2484	29	and	and	CC
8691	2484	30	this	this	DT
8691	2484	31	is	be	VBZ
8691	2484	32	enough	enough	JJ
8691	2484	33	to	to	TO
8691	2484	34	support	support	VB
8691	2484	35	the	the	DT
8691	2484	36	validity	validity	NN
8691	2484	37	of	of	IN
8691	2484	38	this	this	DT
8691	2484	39	provision	provision	NN
8691	2484	40	of	of	IN
8691	2484	41	the	the	DT
8691	2484	42	statute	statute	NN
8691	2484	43	.	.	.
8691	2485	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2485	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2485	3	:	:	:
8691	2485	4	Hanover	Hanover	NNP
8691	2485	5	National	National	NNP
8691	2485	6	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	2485	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2485	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	2485	9	_	_	NNP
8691	2485	10	Moyses	Moyses	NNP
8691	2485	11	,	,	,
8691	2485	12	186	186	CD
8691	2485	13	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2485	14	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2485	15	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2485	16	,	,	,
8691	2485	17	181	181	CD
8691	2485	18	.	.	.
8691	2485	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2486	1	The	the	DT
8691	2486	2	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
8691	2486	3	may	may	MD
8691	2486	4	propose	propose	VB
8691	2486	5	a	a	DT
8691	2486	6	composition	composition	NN
8691	2486	7	to	to	IN
8691	2486	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2486	9	creditors	creditor	NNS
8691	2486	10	,	,	,
8691	2486	11	and	and	CC
8691	2486	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2486	13	may	may	MD
8691	2486	14	be	be	VB
8691	2486	15	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	2486	16	by	by	IN
8691	2486	17	a	a	DT
8691	2486	18	majority	majority	NN
8691	2486	19	of	of	IN
8691	2486	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2486	21	in	in	IN
8691	2486	22	number	number	NN
8691	2486	23	if	if	IN
8691	2486	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2486	25	also	also	RB
8691	2486	26	hold	hold	VBP
8691	2486	27	the	the	DT
8691	2486	28	major	major	JJ
8691	2486	29	part	part	NN
8691	2486	30	of	of	IN
8691	2486	31	the	the	DT
8691	2486	32	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
8691	2486	33	.	.	.
8691	2487	1	If	if	IN
8691	2487	2	such	such	PDT
8691	2487	3	an	an	DT
8691	2487	4	acceptance	acceptance	NN
8691	2487	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2487	6	confirmed	confirm	VBN
8691	2487	7	by	by	IN
8691	2487	8	the	the	DT
8691	2487	9	court	court	NN
8691	2487	10	the	the	DT
8691	2487	11	entire	entire	JJ
8691	2487	12	indebtedness	indebtedness	NN
8691	2487	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	2487	14	discharged	discharge	VBN
8691	2487	15	when	when	WRB
8691	2487	16	the	the	DT
8691	2487	17	total	total	JJ
8691	2487	18	amount	amount	NN
8691	2487	19	to	to	TO
8691	2487	20	be	be	VB
8691	2487	21	paid	pay	VBN
8691	2487	22	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2487	23	including	include	VBG
8691	2487	24	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	2487	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	2487	26	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2487	27	to	to	TO
8691	2487	28	discharge	discharge	VB
8691	2487	29	all	all	DT
8691	2487	30	preferred	preferred	JJ
8691	2487	31	claims	claim	NNS
8691	2487	32	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2487	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	2487	34	deposited	deposit	VBN
8691	2487	35	in	in	IN
8691	2487	36	court	court	NN
8691	2487	37	.	.	.
8691	2488	1	A	a	DT
8691	2488	2	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	2488	3	may	may	MD
8691	2488	4	be	be	VB
8691	2488	5	granted	grant	VBN
8691	2488	6	to	to	IN
8691	2488	7	every	every	DT
8691	2488	8	honest	honest	JJ
8691	2488	9	bankrupt	bankrupt	NN
8691	2488	10	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2488	11	whether	whether	IN
8691	2488	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2488	13	estate	estate	NN
8691	2488	14	pays	pay	VBZ
8691	2488	15	anything	anything	NN
8691	2488	16	to	to	IN
8691	2488	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2488	18	creditors	creditor	NNS
8691	2488	19	or	or	CC
8691	2488	20	not	not	RB
8691	2488	21	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2488	22	,	,	,
8691	2488	23	which	which	WDT
8691	2488	24	clears	clear	VBZ
8691	2488	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2488	26	forever	forever	RB
8691	2488	27	of	of	IN
8691	2488	28	all	all	DT
8691	2488	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2488	30	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	2488	31	debts	debt	NNS
8691	2488	32	.	.	.
8691	2489	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2489	2	does	do	VBZ
8691	2489	3	not	not	RB
8691	2489	4	apply	apply	VB
8691	2489	5	to	to	IN
8691	2489	6	taxes	taxis	NNS
8691	2489	7	nor	nor	CC
8691	2489	8	to	to	IN
8691	2489	9	liabilities	liability	NNS
8691	2489	10	for	for	IN
8691	2489	11	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2489	12	wrongs	wrong	NNS
8691	2489	13	of	of	IN
8691	2489	14	an	an	DT
8691	2489	15	aggravated	aggravated	JJ
8691	2489	16	character	character	NN
8691	2489	17	;	;	:
8691	2489	18	nor	nor	CC
8691	2489	19	can	can	MD
8691	2489	20	two	two	CD
8691	2489	21	successive	successive	JJ
8691	2489	22	discharges	discharge	NNS
8691	2489	23	in	in	IN
8691	2489	24	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2489	25	be	be	VB
8691	2489	26	procured	procure	VBN
8691	2489	27	within	within	IN
8691	2489	28	six	six	CD
8691	2489	29	years	year	NNS
8691	2489	30	unless	unless	IN
8691	2489	31	the	the	DT
8691	2489	32	first	first	JJ
8691	2489	33	was	be	VBD
8691	2489	34	the	the	DT
8691	2489	35	result	result	NN
8691	2489	36	of	of	IN
8691	2489	37	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
8691	2489	38	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2489	39	.	.	.
8691	2490	1	Whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	2490	2	there	there	EX
8691	2490	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	2490	4	been	be	VBN
8691	2490	5	no	no	DT
8691	2490	6	national	national	JJ
8691	2490	7	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2490	8	law	law	NN
8691	2490	9	in	in	IN
8691	2490	10	existence	existence	NN
8691	2490	11	,	,	,
8691	2490	12	the	the	DT
8691	2490	13	States	state	NNS
8691	2490	14	have	have	VBP
8691	2490	15	been	be	VBN
8691	2490	16	held	hold	VBN
8691	2490	17	to	to	TO
8691	2490	18	be	be	VB
8691	2490	19	free	free	JJ
8691	2490	20	to	to	TO
8691	2490	21	pass	pass	VB
8691	2490	22	such	such	JJ
8691	2490	23	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
8691	2490	24	laws	law	NNS
8691	2490	25	as	as	IN
8691	2490	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2490	27	might	may	MD
8691	2490	28	think	think	VB
8691	2490	29	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2490	30	.	.	.
8691	2491	1	During	during	IN
8691	2491	2	the	the	DT
8691	2491	3	existence	existence	NN
8691	2491	4	of	of	IN
8691	2491	5	a	a	DT
8691	2491	6	national	national	JJ
8691	2491	7	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2491	8	law	law	NN
8691	2491	9	no	no	DT
8691	2491	10	State	state	NN
8691	2491	11	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
8691	2491	12	law	law	NN
8691	2491	13	can	can	MD
8691	2491	14	be	be	VB
8691	2491	15	of	of	IN
8691	2491	16	any	any	DT
8691	2491	17	force	force	NN
8691	2491	18	which	which	WDT
8691	2491	19	covers	cover	VBZ
8691	2491	20	the	the	DT
8691	2491	21	same	same	JJ
8691	2491	22	field	field	NN
8691	2491	23	.	.	.
8691	2492	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2492	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2492	3	:	:	:
8691	2492	4	Ogden	Ogden	NNP
8691	2492	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2492	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2492	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2492	8	Saunders	Saunders	NNPS
8691	2492	9	,	,	,
8691	2492	10	12	12	CD
8691	2492	11	Wheaton	Wheaton	NNP
8691	2492	12	's	's	POS
8691	2492	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2492	14	,	,	,
8691	2492	15	213	213	CD
8691	2492	16	;	;	:
8691	2492	17	Tua	Tua	NNP
8691	2492	18	_	_	NNP
8691	2492	19	v.	v.	IN
8691	2492	20	_	_	NNP
8691	2492	21	Carriere	Carriere	NNP
8691	2492	22	,	,	,
8691	2492	23	117	117	CD
8691	2492	24	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2492	25	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2492	26	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2492	27	,	,	,
8691	2492	28	201	201	CD
8691	2492	29	;	;	:
8691	2492	30	Ketcham	Ketcham	NNP
8691	2492	31	_	_	NNP
8691	2492	32	v.	v.	IN
8691	2492	33	_	_	NNP
8691	2492	34	McNamara	McNamara	NNP
8691	2492	35	,	,	,
8691	2492	36	72	72	CD
8691	2492	37	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2492	38	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2492	39	,	,	,
8691	2492	40	709	709	CD
8691	2492	41	,	,	,
8691	2492	42	711	711	CD
8691	2492	43	;	;	:
8691	2492	44	46	46	CD
8691	2492	45	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	2492	46	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2492	47	,	,	,
8691	2492	48	146	146	CD
8691	2492	49	.	.	.
8691	2492	50	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2493	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2493	2	operation	operation	NN
8691	2493	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2493	4	excluded	exclude	VBN
8691	2493	5	or	or	CC
8691	2493	6	suspended	suspend	VBN
8691	2493	7	as	as	IN
8691	2493	8	a	a	DT
8691	2493	9	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2493	10	effect	effect	NN
8691	2493	11	of	of	IN
8691	2493	12	the	the	DT
8691	2493	13	enactment	enactment	NN
8691	2493	14	of	of	IN
8691	2493	15	the	the	DT
8691	2493	16	Act	Act	NNP
8691	2493	17	of	of	IN
8691	2493	18	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	2493	19	,	,	,
8691	2493	20	although	although	IN
8691	2493	21	that	that	DT
8691	2493	22	contains	contain	VBZ
8691	2493	23	no	no	DT
8691	2493	24	express	express	JJ
8691	2493	25	provision	provision	NN
8691	2493	26	to	to	IN
8691	2493	27	that	that	DT
8691	2493	28	effect	effect	NN
8691	2493	29	.	.	.
8691	2494	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	2494	2	of	of	IN
8691	2494	3	the	the	DT
8691	2494	4	States	States	NNPS
8691	2494	5	have	have	VBP
8691	2494	6	on	on	IN
8691	2494	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2494	8	statute	statute	NN
8691	2494	9	-	-	HYPH
8691	2494	10	books	book	NNS
8691	2494	11	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	2494	12	for	for	IN
8691	2494	13	a	a	DT
8691	2494	14	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	2494	15	system	system	NN
8691	2494	16	of	of	IN
8691	2494	17	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	2494	18	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2494	19	.	.	.
8691	2495	1	In	in	IN
8691	2495	2	some	some	DT
8691	2495	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2495	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2495	5	as	as	RB
8691	2495	6	favorable	favorable	JJ
8691	2495	7	to	to	IN
8691	2495	8	the	the	DT
8691	2495	9	debtor	debtor	NN
8691	2495	10	as	as	IN
8691	2495	11	the	the	DT
8691	2495	12	United	United	NNP
8691	2495	13	States	States	NNP
8691	2495	14	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
8691	2495	15	law	law	NN
8691	2495	16	of	of	IN
8691	2495	17	1898	1898	CD
8691	2495	18	:	:	:
8691	2495	19	in	in	IN
8691	2495	20	more	more	JJR
8691	2495	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2495	22	are	be	VBP
8691	2495	23	less	less	RBR
8691	2495	24	favorable	favorable	JJ
8691	2495	25	.	.	.
8691	2496	1	Generally	generally	RB
8691	2496	2	such	such	JJ
8691	2496	3	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2496	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2496	5	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2496	6	before	before	RB
8691	2496	7	a	a	DT
8691	2496	8	court	court	NN
8691	2496	9	of	of	IN
8691	2496	10	special	special	JJ
8691	2496	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2496	12	,	,	,
8691	2496	13	constituted	constitute	VBD
8691	2496	14	both	both	DT
8691	2496	15	for	for	IN
8691	2496	16	this	this	DT
8691	2496	17	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2496	18	and	and	CC
8691	2496	19	for	for	IN
8691	2496	20	the	the	DT
8691	2496	21	settlement	settlement	NN
8691	2496	22	of	of	IN
8691	2496	23	the	the	DT
8691	2496	24	estates	estate	NNS
8691	2496	25	of	of	IN
8691	2496	26	deceased	deceased	JJ
8691	2496	27	persons	person	NNS
8691	2496	28	and	and	CC
8691	2496	29	of	of	IN
8691	2496	30	those	those	DT
8691	2496	31	who	who	WP
8691	2496	32	are	be	VBP
8691	2496	33	incapable	incapable	JJ
8691	2496	34	of	of	IN
8691	2496	35	managing	manage	VBG
8691	2496	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2496	37	own	own	JJ
8691	2496	38	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	2496	39	.	.	.
8691	2497	1	In	in	IN
8691	2497	2	the	the	DT
8691	2497	3	older	old	JJR
8691	2497	4	States	state	NNS
8691	2497	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2497	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2497	7	often	often	RB
8691	2497	8	made	make	VBN
8691	2497	9	a	a	DT
8691	2497	10	condition	condition	NN
8691	2497	11	of	of	IN
8691	2497	12	a	a	DT
8691	2497	13	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	2497	14	that	that	WDT
8691	2497	15	the	the	DT
8691	2497	16	creditors	creditor	NNS
8691	2497	17	shall	shall	MD
8691	2497	18	have	have	VB
8691	2497	19	received	receive	VBN
8691	2497	20	a	a	DT
8691	2497	21	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2497	22	percentage	percentage	NN
8691	2497	23	of	of	IN
8691	2497	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2497	25	claims	claim	NNS
8691	2497	26	.	.	.
8691	2498	1	The	the	DT
8691	2498	2	relief	relief	NN
8691	2498	3	which	which	WDT
8691	2498	4	the	the	DT
8691	2498	5	States	state	NNS
8691	2498	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2498	7	competent	competent	JJ
8691	2498	8	to	to	TO
8691	2498	9	give	give	VB
8691	2498	10	either	either	CC
8691	2498	11	to	to	TO
8691	2498	12	debtor	debtor	NN
8691	2498	13	or	or	CC
8691	2498	14	to	to	IN
8691	2498	15	creditor	creditor	NN
8691	2498	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	2498	17	very	very	RB
8691	2498	18	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
8691	2498	19	.	.	.
8691	2499	1	The	the	DT
8691	2499	2	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	2499	3	of	of	IN
8691	2499	4	the	the	DT
8691	2499	5	debtor	debtor	NN
8691	2499	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2499	7	of	of	IN
8691	2499	8	no	no	DT
8691	2499	9	avail	avail	NN
8691	2499	10	except	except	IN
8691	2499	11	as	as	IN
8691	2499	12	against	against	IN
8691	2499	13	those	those	DT
8691	2499	14	creditors	creditor	NNS
8691	2499	15	who	who	WP
8691	2499	16	were	be	VBD
8691	2499	17	subject	subject	JJ
8691	2499	18	to	to	IN
8691	2499	19	the	the	DT
8691	2499	20	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2499	21	of	of	IN
8691	2499	22	the	the	DT
8691	2499	23	court	court	NN
8691	2499	24	.	.	.
8691	2500	1	None	none	NN
8691	2500	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2500	3	so	so	RB
8691	2500	4	subject	subject	JJ
8691	2500	5	except	except	IN
8691	2500	6	those	those	DT
8691	2500	7	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	2500	8	in	in	IN
8691	2500	9	the	the	DT
8691	2500	10	State	State	NNP
8691	2500	11	,	,	,
8691	2500	12	or	or	CC
8691	2500	13	actually	actually	RB
8691	2500	14	taking	take	VBG
8691	2500	15	part	part	NN
8691	2500	16	in	in	IN
8691	2500	17	the	the	DT
8691	2500	18	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2500	19	.	.	.
8691	2501	1	Every	every	DT
8691	2501	2	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2501	3	or	or	CC
8691	2501	4	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	2501	5	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	2501	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2501	7	a	a	DT
8691	2501	8	great	great	JJ
8691	2501	9	lawsuit	lawsuit	NN
8691	2501	10	.	.	.
8691	2502	1	The	the	DT
8691	2502	2	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	2502	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2502	4	the	the	DT
8691	2502	5	final	final	JJ
8691	2502	6	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2502	7	in	in	IN
8691	2502	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2502	9	.	.	.
8691	2503	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2503	2	can	can	MD
8691	2503	3	bind	bind	VB
8691	2503	4	none	none	NN
8691	2503	5	who	who	WP
8691	2503	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2503	7	not	not	RB
8691	2503	8	parties	party	NNS
8691	2503	9	to	to	IN
8691	2503	10	the	the	DT
8691	2503	11	action	action	NN
8691	2503	12	.	.	.
8691	2504	1	Only	only	RB
8691	2504	2	those	those	DT
8691	2504	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2504	4	parties	party	NNS
8691	2504	5	who	who	WP
8691	2504	6	were	be	VBD
8691	2504	7	bound	bind	VBN
8691	2504	8	to	to	TO
8691	2504	9	appear	appear	VB
8691	2504	10	,	,	,
8691	2504	11	or	or	CC
8691	2504	12	who	who	WP
8691	2504	13	did	do	VBD
8691	2504	14	appear	appear	VB
8691	2504	15	.	.	.
8691	2505	1	No	no	DT
8691	2505	2	one	one	NN
8691	2505	3	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	2505	4	to	to	IN
8691	2505	5	any	any	DT
8691	2505	6	other	other	JJ
8691	2505	7	State	state	NN
8691	2505	8	or	or	CC
8691	2505	9	country	country	NN
8691	2505	10	can	can	MD
8691	2505	11	be	be	VB
8691	2505	12	bound	bind	VBN
8691	2505	13	to	to	TO
8691	2505	14	appear	appear	VB
8691	2505	15	,	,	,
8691	2505	16	unless	unless	IN
8691	2505	17	in	in	IN
8691	2505	18	the	the	DT
8691	2505	19	rare	rare	JJ
8691	2505	20	case	case	NN
8691	2505	21	of	of	IN
8691	2505	22	a	a	DT
8691	2505	23	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2505	24	service	service	NN
8691	2505	25	of	of	IN
8691	2505	26	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2505	27	process	process	NN
8691	2505	28	upon	upon	IN
8691	2505	29	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2505	30	,	,	,
8691	2505	31	made	make	VBN
8691	2505	32	while	while	IN
8691	2505	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2505	34	was	be	VBD
8691	2505	35	within	within	IN
8691	2505	36	the	the	DT
8691	2505	37	territorial	territorial	JJ
8691	2505	38	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2505	39	.	.	.
8691	2506	1	Any	any	DT
8691	2506	2	creditor	creditor	NN
8691	2506	3	,	,	,
8691	2506	4	wherever	wherever	WRB
8691	2506	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2506	6	may	may	MD
8691	2506	7	reside	reside	VB
8691	2506	8	,	,	,
8691	2506	9	who	who	WP
8691	2506	10	files	file	VBZ
8691	2506	11	a	a	DT
8691	2506	12	claim	claim	NN
8691	2506	13	against	against	IN
8691	2506	14	the	the	DT
8691	2506	15	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
8691	2506	16	estate	estate	NN
8691	2506	17	,	,	,
8691	2506	18	or	or	CC
8691	2506	19	receives	receive	VBZ
8691	2506	20	a	a	DT
8691	2506	21	dividend	dividend	NN
8691	2506	22	from	from	IN
8691	2506	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2506	24	,	,	,
8691	2506	25	makes	make	VBZ
8691	2506	26	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2506	27	a	a	DT
8691	2506	28	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
8691	2506	29	party	party	NN
8691	2506	30	.	.	.
8691	2507	1	But	but	CC
8691	2507	2	as	as	IN
8691	2507	3	against	against	IN
8691	2507	4	a	a	DT
8691	2507	5	non	non	JJ
8691	2507	6	-	-	JJ
8691	2507	7	resident	resident	JJ
8691	2507	8	who	who	WP
8691	2507	9	keeps	keep	VBZ
8691	2507	10	aloof	aloof	JJ
8691	2507	11	and	and	CC
8691	2507	12	takes	take	VBZ
8691	2507	13	no	no	DT
8691	2507	14	part	part	NN
8691	2507	15	in	in	IN
8691	2507	16	the	the	DT
8691	2507	17	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2507	18	the	the	DT
8691	2507	19	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	2507	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	2507	21	worthless	worthless	JJ
8691	2507	22	,	,	,
8691	2507	23	even	even	RB
8691	2507	24	in	in	IN
8691	2507	25	the	the	DT
8691	2507	26	courts	court	NNS
8691	2507	27	of	of	IN
8691	2507	28	the	the	DT
8691	2507	29	very	very	JJ
8691	2507	30	State	state	NN
8691	2507	31	by	by	IN
8691	2507	32	authority	authority	NN
8691	2507	33	of	of	IN
8691	2507	34	which	which	WDT
8691	2507	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2507	36	was	be	VBD
8691	2507	37	granted	grant	VBN
8691	2507	38	.	.	.
8691	2508	1	On	on	IN
8691	2508	2	the	the	DT
8691	2508	3	other	other	JJ
8691	2508	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	2508	5	,	,	,
8691	2508	6	the	the	DT
8691	2508	7	creditor	creditor	NN
8691	2508	8	gets	get	VBZ
8691	2508	9	less	less	JJR
8691	2508	10	aid	aid	NN
8691	2508	11	from	from	IN
8691	2508	12	the	the	DT
8691	2508	13	State	State	NNP
8691	2508	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	2508	15	than	than	IN
8691	2508	16	a	a	DT
8691	2508	17	trustee	trustee	NN
8691	2508	18	in	in	IN
8691	2508	19	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2508	20	.	.	.
8691	2509	1	The	the	DT
8691	2509	2	trustee	trustee	NN
8691	2509	3	in	in	IN
8691	2509	4	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2509	5	can	can	MD
8691	2509	6	sue	sue	VB
8691	2509	7	in	in	IN
8691	2509	8	any	any	DT
8691	2509	9	court	court	NN
8691	2509	10	in	in	IN
8691	2509	11	the	the	DT
8691	2509	12	country	country	NN
8691	2509	13	in	in	IN
8691	2509	14	which	which	WDT
8691	2509	15	the	the	DT
8691	2509	16	debtor	debtor	NN
8691	2509	17	could	could	MD
8691	2509	18	have	have	VB
8691	2509	19	sued	sue	VBN
8691	2509	20	for	for	IN
8691	2509	21	the	the	DT
8691	2509	22	same	same	JJ
8691	2509	23	cause	cause	NN
8691	2509	24	of	of	IN
8691	2509	25	action	action	NN
8691	2509	26	.	.	.
8691	2510	1	The	the	DT
8691	2510	2	trustee	trustee	NN
8691	2510	3	or	or	CC
8691	2510	4	assignee	assignee	NN
8691	2510	5	in	in	IN
8691	2510	6	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	2510	7	,	,	,
8691	2510	8	acting	act	VBG
8691	2510	9	under	under	IN
8691	2510	10	the	the	DT
8691	2510	11	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	2510	12	of	of	IN
8691	2510	13	a	a	DT
8691	2510	14	State	State	NNP
8691	2510	15	court	court	NN
8691	2510	16	,	,	,
8691	2510	17	can	can	MD
8691	2510	18	only	only	RB
8691	2510	19	sue	sue	VB
8691	2510	20	within	within	IN
8691	2510	21	that	that	DT
8691	2510	22	State	State	NNP
8691	2510	23	,	,	,
8691	2510	24	unless	unless	IN
8691	2510	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2510	26	title	title	NN
8691	2510	27	has	have	VBZ
8691	2510	28	been	be	VBN
8691	2510	29	fortified	fortify	VBN
8691	2510	30	by	by	IN
8691	2510	31	a	a	DT
8691	2510	32	conveyance	conveyance	NN
8691	2510	33	from	from	IN
8691	2510	34	the	the	DT
8691	2510	35	insolvent	insolvent	NN
8691	2510	36	which	which	WDT
8691	2510	37	would	would	MD
8691	2510	38	be	be	VB
8691	2510	39	good	good	JJ
8691	2510	40	at	at	IN
8691	2510	41	common	common	JJ
8691	2510	42	law	law	NN
8691	2510	43	.	.	.
8691	2511	1	So	so	RB
8691	2511	2	far	far	RB
8691	2511	3	as	as	IN
8691	2511	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2511	5	title	title	NN
8691	2511	6	rests	rest	VBZ
8691	2511	7	on	on	IN
8691	2511	8	a	a	DT
8691	2511	9	law	law	NN
8691	2511	10	,	,	,
8691	2511	11	by	by	IN
8691	2511	12	which	which	WDT
8691	2511	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2511	14	was	be	VBD
8691	2511	15	taken	take	VBN
8691	2511	16	away	away	RB
8691	2511	17	from	from	IN
8691	2511	18	the	the	DT
8691	2511	19	bankrupt	bankrupt	JJ
8691	2511	20	and	and	CC
8691	2511	21	vested	vest	VBN
8691	2511	22	in	in	IN
8691	2511	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2511	24	,	,	,
8691	2511	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2511	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	2511	27	ineffectual	ineffectual	JJ
8691	2511	28	wherever	wherever	WRB
8691	2511	29	that	that	IN
8691	2511	30	law	law	NN
8691	2511	31	is	be	VBZ
8691	2511	32	ineffectual	ineffectual	JJ
8691	2511	33	;	;	:
8691	2511	34	and	and	CC
8691	2511	35	the	the	DT
8691	2511	36	law	law	NN
8691	2511	37	of	of	IN
8691	2511	38	no	no	DT
8691	2511	39	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	2511	40	is	be	VBZ
8691	2511	41	effectual	effectual	JJ
8691	2511	42	of	of	IN
8691	2511	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2511	44	own	own	JJ
8691	2511	45	force	force	NN
8691	2511	46	outside	outside	IN
8691	2511	47	of	of	IN
8691	2511	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2511	49	territorial	territorial	JJ
8691	2511	50	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2511	51	.	.	.
8691	2512	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2512	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2512	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2512	4	:	:	:
8691	2512	5	Booth	Booth	NNP
8691	2512	6	_	_	NNP
8691	2512	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	2512	8	_	_	NNP
8691	2512	9	Clark	Clark	NNP
8691	2512	10	,	,	,
8691	2512	11	17	17	CD
8691	2512	12	Howard	Howard	NNP
8691	2512	13	's	's	POS
8691	2512	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2512	15	,	,	,
8691	2512	16	322	322	CD
8691	2512	17	,	,	,
8691	2512	18	337	337	CD
8691	2512	19	;	;	:
8691	2512	20	Hale	Hale	NNP
8691	2512	21	_	_	NNP
8691	2512	22	v.	v.	IN
8691	2512	23	_	_	NNP
8691	2512	24	Allinson	Allinson	NNP
8691	2512	25	,	,	,
8691	2512	26	188	188	CD
8691	2512	27	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2512	28	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2512	29	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2512	30	,	,	,
8691	2512	31	56	56	CD
8691	2512	32	.	.	.
8691	2513	1	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2513	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2513	3	If	if	IN
8691	2513	4	,	,	,
8691	2513	5	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	2513	6	,	,	,
8691	2513	7	as	as	IN
8691	2513	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2513	9	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2513	10	true	true	JJ
8691	2513	11	in	in	IN
8691	2513	12	estates	estate	NNS
8691	2513	13	of	of	IN
8691	2513	14	any	any	DT
8691	2513	15	magnitude	magnitude	NN
8691	2513	16	,	,	,
8691	2513	17	part	part	NN
8691	2513	18	of	of	IN
8691	2513	19	the	the	DT
8691	2513	20	assets	asset	NNS
8691	2513	21	can	can	MD
8691	2513	22	only	only	RB
8691	2513	23	be	be	VB
8691	2513	24	recovered	recover	VBN
8691	2513	25	by	by	IN
8691	2513	26	suit	suit	NN
8691	2513	27	in	in	IN
8691	2513	28	other	other	JJ
8691	2513	29	States	States	NNPS
8691	2513	30	,	,	,
8691	2513	31	there	there	EX
8691	2513	32	must	must	MD
8691	2513	33	be	be	VB
8691	2513	34	ancillary	ancillary	JJ
8691	2513	35	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	2513	36	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2513	37	there	there	RB
8691	2513	38	,	,	,
8691	2513	39	to	to	TO
8691	2513	40	clothe	clothe	VB
8691	2513	41	the	the	DT
8691	2513	42	principal	principal	JJ
8691	2513	43	assignee	assignee	NN
8691	2513	44	with	with	IN
8691	2513	45	the	the	DT
8691	2513	46	right	right	NN
8691	2513	47	of	of	IN
8691	2513	48	action	action	NN
8691	2513	49	.	.	.
8691	2514	1	Should	Should	MD
8691	2514	2	the	the	DT
8691	2514	3	insolvent	insolvent	NN
8691	2514	4	be	be	VB
8691	2514	5	the	the	DT
8691	2514	6	owner	owner	NN
8691	2514	7	of	of	IN
8691	2514	8	land	land	NN
8691	2514	9	in	in	IN
8691	2514	10	another	another	DT
8691	2514	11	State	State	NNP
8691	2514	12	,	,	,
8691	2514	13	the	the	DT
8691	2514	14	title	title	NN
8691	2514	15	to	to	IN
8691	2514	16	this	this	DT
8691	2514	17	can	can	MD
8691	2514	18	only	only	RB
8691	2514	19	be	be	VB
8691	2514	20	transferred	transfer	VBN
8691	2514	21	in	in	IN
8691	2514	22	accordance	accordance	NN
8691	2514	23	with	with	IN
8691	2514	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2514	25	law	law	NN
8691	2514	26	,	,	,
8691	2514	27	and	and	CC
8691	2514	28	a	a	DT
8691	2514	29	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	2514	30	assignment	assignment	NN
8691	2514	31	in	in	IN
8691	2514	32	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	2514	33	will	will	MD
8691	2514	34	be	be	VB
8691	2514	35	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	2514	36	ineffectual	ineffectual	JJ
8691	2514	37	.	.	.
8691	2515	1	Nor	nor	CC
8691	2515	2	will	will	MD
8691	2515	3	ancillary	ancillary	JJ
8691	2515	4	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2515	5	in	in	IN
8691	2515	6	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	2515	7	be	be	VB
8691	2515	8	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2515	9	to	to	TO
8691	2515	10	prejudice	prejudice	VB
8691	2515	11	the	the	DT
8691	2515	12	rights	right	NNS
8691	2515	13	of	of	IN
8691	2515	14	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	2515	15	of	of	IN
8691	2515	16	the	the	DT
8691	2515	17	State	State	NNP
8691	2515	18	in	in	IN
8691	2515	19	which	which	WDT
8691	2515	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2515	21	are	be	VBP
8691	2515	22	instituted	institute	VBN
8691	2515	23	to	to	IN
8691	2515	24	any	any	DT
8691	2515	25	security	security	NN
8691	2515	26	which	which	WDT
8691	2515	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2515	28	might	may	MD
8691	2515	29	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	2515	30	have	have	VB
8691	2515	31	for	for	IN
8691	2515	32	debts	debt	NNS
8691	2515	33	due	due	JJ
8691	2515	34	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2515	35	from	from	IN
8691	2515	36	the	the	DT
8691	2515	37	insolvent	insolvent	NN
8691	2515	38	.	.	.
8691	2516	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2516	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2516	3	:	:	:
8691	2516	4	Ward	Ward	NNP
8691	2516	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2516	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2516	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2516	8	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2517	1	Pipe	Pipe	NNP
8691	2517	2	Mfg	Mfg	NNP
8691	2517	3	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	2517	4	,	,	,
8691	2517	5	71	71	CD
8691	2517	6	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2517	7	,	,	,
8691	2517	8	345	345	CD
8691	2517	9	;	;	:
8691	2517	10	41	41	CD
8691	2517	11	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	2517	12	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2517	13	,	,	,
8691	2517	14	1057	1057	CD
8691	2517	15	;	;	:
8691	2517	16	42	42	CD
8691	2517	17	Lawyers	Lawyers	NNPS
8691	2517	18	'	'	POS
8691	2517	19	Reports	report	NNS
8691	2517	20	Annotated	annotate	VBD
8691	2517	21	,	,	,
8691	2517	22	706	706	CD
8691	2517	23	;	;	:
8691	2517	24	71	71	CD
8691	2517	25	Am	Am	NNP
8691	2517	26	.	.	.
8691	2518	1	State	State	NNP
8691	2518	2	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2518	3	,	,	,
8691	2518	4	207	207	CD
8691	2518	5	.	.	.
8691	2518	6	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2519	1	The	the	DT
8691	2519	2	right	right	NN
8691	2519	3	,	,	,
8691	2519	4	however	however	RB
8691	2519	5	,	,	,
8691	2519	6	of	of	IN
8691	2519	7	every	every	DT
8691	2519	8	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	2519	9	to	to	TO
8691	2519	10	postpone	postpone	VB
8691	2519	11	claims	claim	NNS
8691	2519	12	under	under	IN
8691	2519	13	a	a	DT
8691	2519	14	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	2519	15	bankruptcy	bankruptcy	NN
8691	2519	16	or	or	CC
8691	2519	17	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	2519	18	to	to	IN
8691	2519	19	the	the	DT
8691	2519	20	interests	interest	NNS
8691	2519	21	of	of	IN
8691	2519	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2519	23	own	own	JJ
8691	2519	24	people	people	NNS
8691	2519	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	2519	26	modified	modify	VBN
8691	2519	27	in	in	IN
8691	2519	28	the	the	DT
8691	2519	29	United	United	NNP
8691	2519	30	States	States	NNP
8691	2519	31	by	by	IN
8691	2519	32	the	the	DT
8691	2519	33	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	2519	34	provision	provision	NN
8691	2519	35	that	that	IN
8691	2519	36	the	the	DT
8691	2519	37	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	2519	38	of	of	IN
8691	2519	39	each	each	DT
8691	2519	40	State	state	NN
8691	2519	41	are	be	VBP
8691	2519	42	entitled	entitle	VBN
8691	2519	43	to	to	IN
8691	2519	44	all	all	DT
8691	2519	45	privileges	privilege	NNS
8691	2519	46	of	of	IN
8691	2519	47	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	2519	48	in	in	IN
8691	2519	49	the	the	DT
8691	2519	50	other	other	JJ
8691	2519	51	States	States	NNPS
8691	2519	52	.	.	.
8691	2520	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2520	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2520	3	:	:	:
8691	2520	4	Blake	Blake	NNP
8691	2520	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2520	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2520	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2520	8	McClung	McClung	NNP
8691	2520	9	,	,	,
8691	2520	10	172	172	CD
8691	2520	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2520	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2520	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2520	14	,	,	,
8691	2520	15	239	239	CD
8691	2520	16	.	.	.
8691	2520	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2521	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2521	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2521	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2521	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2521	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2521	6	CHAPTER	CHAPTER	NNP
8691	2521	7	XVII	XVII	NNP
8691	2521	8	CRIMINAL	CRIMINAL	NNP
8691	2521	9	PROCEDURE	PROCEDURE	NNP
8691	2521	10	The	the	DT
8691	2521	11	American	american	JJ
8691	2521	12	system	system	NN
8691	2521	13	of	of	IN
8691	2521	14	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2521	15	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	2521	16	rests	rest	NNS
8691	2521	17	on	on	IN
8691	2521	18	the	the	DT
8691	2521	19	principle	principle	NN
8691	2521	20	that	that	IN
8691	2521	21	the	the	DT
8691	2521	22	government	government	NN
8691	2521	23	should	should	MD
8691	2521	24	decide	decide	VB
8691	2521	25	on	on	IN
8691	2521	26	the	the	DT
8691	2521	27	propriety	propriety	NN
8691	2521	28	of	of	IN
8691	2521	29	beginning	begin	VBG
8691	2521	30	all	all	DT
8691	2521	31	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2521	32	,	,	,
8691	2521	33	and	and	CC
8691	2521	34	then	then	RB
8691	2521	35	should	should	MD
8691	2521	36	bring	bring	VB
8691	2521	37	and	and	CC
8691	2521	38	maintain	maintain	VB
8691	2521	39	,	,	,
8691	2521	40	at	at	IN
8691	2521	41	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2521	42	own	own	JJ
8691	2521	43	expense	expense	NN
8691	2521	44	,	,	,
8691	2521	45	such	such	JJ
8691	2521	46	as	as	IN
8691	2521	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2521	48	may	may	MD
8691	2521	49	deem	deem	VB
8691	2521	50	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2521	51	.	.	.
8691	2522	1	The	the	DT
8691	2522	2	first	first	JJ
8691	2522	3	step	step	NN
8691	2522	4	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2522	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2522	6	the	the	DT
8691	2522	7	filing	filing	NN
8691	2522	8	by	by	IN
8691	2522	9	an	an	DT
8691	2522	10	informing	inform	VBG
8691	2522	11	officer	officer	NN
8691	2522	12	of	of	IN
8691	2522	13	a	a	DT
8691	2522	14	written	write	VBN
8691	2522	15	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	2522	16	in	in	IN
8691	2522	17	the	the	DT
8691	2522	18	office	office	NN
8691	2522	19	of	of	IN
8691	2522	20	some	some	DT
8691	2522	21	court	court	NN
8691	2522	22	or	or	CC
8691	2522	23	with	with	IN
8691	2522	24	some	some	DT
8691	2522	25	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2522	26	,	,	,
8691	2522	27	upon	upon	IN
8691	2522	28	which	which	WDT
8691	2522	29	a	a	DT
8691	2522	30	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2522	31	of	of	IN
8691	2522	32	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2522	33	issues	issue	NNS
8691	2522	34	as	as	IN
8691	2522	35	of	of	IN
8691	2522	36	course	course	NN
8691	2522	37	.	.	.
8691	2523	1	In	in	IN
8691	2523	2	some	some	DT
8691	2523	3	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
8691	2523	4	original	original	JJ
8691	2523	5	informations	information	NNS
8691	2523	6	in	in	IN
8691	2523	7	a	a	DT
8691	2523	8	trial	trial	NN
8691	2523	9	court	court	NN
8691	2523	10	,	,	,
8691	2523	11	as	as	IN
8691	2523	12	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
8691	2523	13	from	from	IN
8691	2523	14	indictments	indictment	NNS
8691	2523	15	,	,	,
8691	2523	16	can	can	MD
8691	2523	17	only	only	RB
8691	2523	18	be	be	VB
8691	2523	19	filed	file	VBN
8691	2523	20	by	by	IN
8691	2523	21	leave	leave	NN
8691	2523	22	of	of	IN
8691	2523	23	court	court	NN
8691	2523	24	first	first	RB
8691	2523	25	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	2523	26	.	.	.
8691	2524	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	2524	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2524	3	the	the	DT
8691	2524	4	rule	rule	NN
8691	2524	5	in	in	IN
8691	2524	6	the	the	DT
8691	2524	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	2524	8	of	of	IN
8691	2524	9	the	the	DT
8691	2524	10	United	United	NNP
8691	2524	11	States	States	NNP
8691	2524	12	.	.	.
8691	2525	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2525	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2525	3	:	:	:
8691	2525	4	United	United	NNP
8691	2525	5	States	States	NNP
8691	2525	6	_	_	NNP
8691	2525	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	2525	8	_	_	NNP
8691	2525	9	Smith	Smith	NNP
8691	2525	10	,	,	,
8691	2525	11	40	40	CD
8691	2525	12	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	2525	13	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2525	14	,	,	,
8691	2525	15	755	755	CD
8691	2525	16	.	.	.
8691	2525	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2526	1	There	there	EX
8691	2526	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2526	3	no	no	DT
8691	2526	4	such	such	JJ
8691	2526	5	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
8691	2526	6	consultation	consultation	NN
8691	2526	7	with	with	IN
8691	2526	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2526	9	officers	officer	NNS
8691	2526	10	as	as	IN
8691	2526	11	characterizes	characterize	VBZ
8691	2526	12	European	european	JJ
8691	2526	13	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2526	14	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	2526	15	.	.	.
8691	2527	1	The	the	DT
8691	2527	2	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
8691	2527	3	officer	officer	NN
8691	2527	4	assumes	assume	VBZ
8691	2527	5	the	the	DT
8691	2527	6	entire	entire	JJ
8691	2527	7	responsibility	responsibility	NN
8691	2527	8	of	of	IN
8691	2527	9	initiating	initiate	VBG
8691	2527	10	the	the	DT
8691	2527	11	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	2527	12	and	and	CC
8691	2527	13	of	of	IN
8691	2527	14	giving	give	VBG
8691	2527	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2527	16	the	the	DT
8691	2527	17	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2527	18	form	form	NN
8691	2527	19	that	that	WDT
8691	2527	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2527	21	may	may	MD
8691	2527	22	assume	assume	VB
8691	2527	23	.	.	.
8691	2528	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2528	2	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2528	3	acts	act	VBZ
8691	2528	4	only	only	RB
8691	2528	5	on	on	IN
8691	2528	6	such	such	JJ
8691	2528	7	matters	matter	NNS
8691	2528	8	as	as	IN
8691	2528	9	are	be	VBP
8691	2528	10	officially	officially	RB
8691	2528	11	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2528	12	to	to	IN
8691	2528	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2528	14	attention	attention	NN
8691	2528	15	by	by	IN
8691	2528	16	constables	constable	NNS
8691	2528	17	or	or	CC
8691	2528	18	other	other	JJ
8691	2528	19	officers	officer	NNS
8691	2528	20	of	of	IN
8691	2528	21	police	police	NNS
8691	2528	22	.	.	.
8691	2529	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2529	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2529	3	rare	rare	JJ
8691	2529	4	that	that	IN
8691	2529	5	the	the	DT
8691	2529	6	party	party	NN
8691	2529	7	injured	injure	VBN
8691	2529	8	by	by	IN
8691	2529	9	an	an	DT
8691	2529	10	offense	offense	NN
8691	2529	11	complains	complain	VBZ
8691	2529	12	to	to	IN
8691	2529	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2529	14	personally	personally	RB
8691	2529	15	.	.	.
8691	2530	1	Hence	hence	RB
8691	2530	2	many	many	JJ
8691	2530	3	of	of	IN
8691	2530	4	the	the	DT
8691	2530	5	lesser	less	JJR
8691	2530	6	offences	offence	NNS
8691	2530	7	go	go	VBP
8691	2530	8	unpunished	unpunished	JJ
8691	2530	9	,	,	,
8691	2530	10	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	2530	11	in	in	IN
8691	2530	12	large	large	JJ
8691	2530	13	cities	city	NNS
8691	2530	14	,	,	,
8691	2530	15	because	because	IN
8691	2530	16	the	the	DT
8691	2530	17	police	police	NNS
8691	2530	18	fail	fail	VBP
8691	2530	19	to	to	TO
8691	2530	20	report	report	VB
8691	2530	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2530	22	,	,	,
8691	2530	23	on	on	IN
8691	2530	24	account	account	NN
8691	2530	25	of	of	IN
8691	2530	26	favoritism	favoritism	NN
8691	2530	27	or	or	CC
8691	2530	28	corruption	corruption	NN
8691	2530	29	.	.	.
8691	2531	1	The	the	DT
8691	2531	2	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2531	3	refers	refer	VBZ
8691	2531	4	to	to	IN
8691	2531	5	the	the	DT
8691	2531	6	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	2531	7	for	for	IN
8691	2531	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2531	9	support	support	NN
8691	2531	10	.	.	.
8691	2532	1	Between	between	IN
8691	2532	2	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2532	3	,	,	,
8691	2532	4	the	the	DT
8691	2532	5	offense	offense	NN
8691	2532	6	charged	charge	VBD
8691	2532	7	,	,	,
8691	2532	8	the	the	DT
8691	2532	9	person	person	NN
8691	2532	10	accused	accuse	VBD
8691	2532	11	,	,	,
8691	2532	12	and	and	CC
8691	2532	13	the	the	DT
8691	2532	14	thing	thing	NN
8691	2532	15	to	to	TO
8691	2532	16	be	be	VB
8691	2532	17	done	do	VBN
8691	2532	18	by	by	IN
8691	2532	19	the	the	DT
8691	2532	20	officer	officer	NN
8691	2532	21	who	who	WP
8691	2532	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	2532	23	to	to	TO
8691	2532	24	make	make	VB
8691	2532	25	service	service	NN
8691	2532	26	must	must	MD
8691	2532	27	be	be	VB
8691	2532	28	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	2532	29	stated	state	VBN
8691	2532	30	.	.	.
8691	2533	1	"	"	``
8691	2533	2	General	general	JJ
8691	2533	3	warrants	warrant	NNS
8691	2533	4	,	,	,
8691	2533	5	"	"	''
8691	2533	6	that	that	RB
8691	2533	7	is	is	RB
8691	2533	8	,	,	,
8691	2533	9	warrants	warrant	NNS
8691	2533	10	of	of	IN
8691	2533	11	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2533	12	or	or	CC
8691	2533	13	seizure	seizure	NN
8691	2533	14	,	,	,
8691	2533	15	not	not	RB
8691	2533	16	specifying	specify	VBG
8691	2533	17	the	the	DT
8691	2533	18	person	person	NN
8691	2533	19	who	who	WP
8691	2533	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	2533	21	to	to	TO
8691	2533	22	be	be	VB
8691	2533	23	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	2533	24	,	,	,
8691	2533	25	nor	nor	CC
8691	2533	26	the	the	DT
8691	2533	27	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2533	28	place	place	NN
8691	2533	29	where	where	WRB
8691	2533	30	the	the	DT
8691	2533	31	seizure	seizure	NN
8691	2533	32	is	be	VBZ
8691	2533	33	to	to	TO
8691	2533	34	be	be	VB
8691	2533	35	made	make	VBN
8691	2533	36	,	,	,
8691	2533	37	are	be	VBP
8691	2533	38	expressly	expressly	RB
8691	2533	39	forbidden	forbid	VBN
8691	2533	40	by	by	IN
8691	2533	41	the	the	DT
8691	2533	42	fourth	fourth	JJ
8691	2533	43	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	2533	44	of	of	IN
8691	2533	45	the	the	DT
8691	2533	46	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2533	47	of	of	IN
8691	2533	48	the	the	DT
8691	2533	49	United	United	NNP
8691	2533	50	States	States	NNP
8691	2533	51	as	as	IN
8691	2533	52	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	2533	53	federal	federal	JJ
8691	2533	54	courts	court	NNS
8691	2533	55	,	,	,
8691	2533	56	and	and	CC
8691	2533	57	as	as	IN
8691	2533	58	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	2533	59	those	those	DT
8691	2533	60	of	of	IN
8691	2533	61	the	the	DT
8691	2533	62	States	States	NNPS
8691	2533	63	,	,	,
8691	2533	64	are	be	VBP
8691	2533	65	generally	generally	RB
8691	2533	66	prohibited	prohibit	VBN
8691	2533	67	by	by	IN
8691	2533	68	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2533	69	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	2533	70	.	.	.
8691	2534	1	Any	any	DT
8691	2534	2	private	private	JJ
8691	2534	3	individual	individual	NN
8691	2534	4	may	may	MD
8691	2534	5	,	,	,
8691	2534	6	by	by	IN
8691	2534	7	night	night	NN
8691	2534	8	or	or	CC
8691	2534	9	day	day	NN
8691	2534	10	,	,	,
8691	2534	11	arrest	arrest	VB
8691	2534	12	without	without	IN
8691	2534	13	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2534	14	one	one	CD
8691	2534	15	whom	whom	WP
8691	2534	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2534	17	sees	see	VBZ
8691	2534	18	committing	commit	VBG
8691	2534	19	a	a	DT
8691	2534	20	felony	felony	NN
8691	2534	21	or	or	CC
8691	2534	22	a	a	DT
8691	2534	23	breach	breach	NN
8691	2534	24	of	of	IN
8691	2534	25	the	the	DT
8691	2534	26	peace	peace	NN
8691	2534	27	or	or	CC
8691	2534	28	running	run	VBG
8691	2534	29	off	off	RP
8691	2534	30	with	with	IN
8691	2534	31	goods	good	NNS
8691	2534	32	which	which	WDT
8691	2534	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2534	34	has	have	VBZ
8691	2534	35	stolen	steal	VBN
8691	2534	36	.	.	.
8691	2535	1	If	if	IN
8691	2535	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2535	3	knows	know	VBZ
8691	2535	4	that	that	IN
8691	2535	5	a	a	DT
8691	2535	6	felony	felony	NN
8691	2535	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	2535	8	been	be	VBN
8691	2535	9	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2535	10	and	and	CC
8691	2535	11	has	have	VBZ
8691	2535	12	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	2535	13	grounds	ground	NNS
8691	2535	14	for	for	IN
8691	2535	15	suspecting	suspect	VBG
8691	2535	16	that	that	IN
8691	2535	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2535	18	was	be	VBD
8691	2535	19	the	the	DT
8691	2535	20	act	act	NN
8691	2535	21	of	of	IN
8691	2535	22	a	a	DT
8691	2535	23	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2535	24	person	person	NN
8691	2535	25	,	,	,
8691	2535	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2535	27	may	may	MD
8691	2535	28	arrest	arrest	VB
8691	2535	29	the	the	DT
8691	2535	30	latter	latter	JJ
8691	2535	31	,	,	,
8691	2535	32	although	although	IN
8691	2535	33	without	without	IN
8691	2535	34	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2535	35	knowledge	knowledge	NN
8691	2535	36	of	of	IN
8691	2535	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2535	38	guilt	guilt	NN
8691	2535	39	.	.	.
8691	2536	1	A	a	DT
8691	2536	2	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	2536	3	,	,	,
8691	2536	4	constable	constable	JJ
8691	2536	5	,	,	,
8691	2536	6	or	or	CC
8691	2536	7	other	other	JJ
8691	2536	8	peace	peace	NN
8691	2536	9	officer	officer	NN
8691	2536	10	may	may	MD
8691	2536	11	arrest	arrest	VB
8691	2536	12	without	without	IN
8691	2536	13	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2536	14	any	any	DT
8691	2536	15	one	one	NN
8691	2536	16	whom	whom	WP
8691	2536	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2536	18	has	have	VBZ
8691	2536	19	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	2536	20	ground	ground	NN
8691	2536	21	for	for	IN
8691	2536	22	suspecting	suspecting	NN
8691	2536	23	to	to	TO
8691	2536	24	be	be	VB
8691	2536	25	guilty	guilty	JJ
8691	2536	26	of	of	IN
8691	2536	27	a	a	DT
8691	2536	28	felony	felony	NN
8691	2536	29	,	,	,
8691	2536	30	although	although	IN
8691	2536	31	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2536	32	may	may	MD
8691	2536	33	turn	turn	VB
8691	2536	34	out	out	RP
8691	2536	35	that	that	IN
8691	2536	36	no	no	DT
8691	2536	37	such	such	JJ
8691	2536	38	felony	felony	NN
8691	2536	39	was	be	VBD
8691	2536	40	ever	ever	RB
8691	2536	41	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2536	42	.	.	.
8691	2537	1	For	for	IN
8691	2537	2	any	any	DT
8691	2537	3	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	2537	4	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
8691	2537	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2537	6	could	could	MD
8691	2537	7	not	not	RB
8691	2537	8	,	,	,
8691	2537	9	at	at	IN
8691	2537	10	common	common	JJ
8691	2537	11	law	law	NN
8691	2537	12	,	,	,
8691	2537	13	arrest	arrest	VB
8691	2537	14	without	without	IN
8691	2537	15	a	a	DT
8691	2537	16	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2537	17	,	,	,
8691	2537	18	unless	unless	IN
8691	2537	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2537	20	personally	personally	RB
8691	2537	21	witnessed	witness	VBD
8691	2537	22	the	the	DT
8691	2537	23	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
8691	2537	24	act	act	NN
8691	2537	25	or	or	CC
8691	2537	26	was	be	VBD
8691	2537	27	near	near	IN
8691	2537	28	enough	enough	JJ
8691	2537	29	to	to	TO
8691	2537	30	hear	hear	VB
8691	2537	31	sounds	sound	NNS
8691	2537	32	indicating	indicate	VBG
8691	2537	33	what	what	WP
8691	2537	34	was	be	VBD
8691	2537	35	being	be	VBG
8691	2537	36	done	do	VBN
8691	2537	37	.	.	.
8691	2538	1	In	in	IN
8691	2538	2	practice	practice	NN
8691	2538	3	,	,	,
8691	2538	4	officers	officer	NNS
8691	2538	5	of	of	IN
8691	2538	6	local	local	JJ
8691	2538	7	police	police	NN
8691	2538	8	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2538	9	freely	freely	RB
8691	2538	10	on	on	IN
8691	2538	11	mere	mere	JJ
8691	2538	12	suspicion	suspicion	NN
8691	2538	13	and	and	CC
8691	2538	14	with	with	IN
8691	2538	15	no	no	DT
8691	2538	16	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2538	17	knowledge	knowledge	NN
8691	2538	18	either	either	CC
8691	2538	19	that	that	IN
8691	2538	20	any	any	DT
8691	2538	21	offense	offense	NN
8691	2538	22	has	have	VBZ
8691	2538	23	been	be	VBN
8691	2538	24	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2538	25	or	or	CC
8691	2538	26	that	that	IN
8691	2538	27	,	,	,
8691	2538	28	if	if	IN
8691	2538	29	any	any	DT
8691	2538	30	,	,	,
8691	2538	31	the	the	DT
8691	2538	32	person	person	NN
8691	2538	33	taken	take	VBN
8691	2538	34	in	in	IN
8691	2538	35	charge	charge	NN
8691	2538	36	was	be	VBD
8691	2538	37	connected	connect	VBN
8691	2538	38	with	with	IN
8691	2538	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2538	40	.	.	.
8691	2539	1	The	the	DT
8691	2539	2	only	only	JJ
8691	2539	3	risk	risk	NN
8691	2539	4	which	which	WDT
8691	2539	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2539	6	run	run	VBP
8691	2539	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2539	8	of	of	IN
8691	2539	9	an	an	DT
8691	2539	10	action	action	NN
8691	2539	11	for	for	IN
8691	2539	12	damages	damage	NNS
8691	2539	13	,	,	,
8691	2539	14	and	and	CC
8691	2539	15	that	that	DT
8691	2539	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	2539	17	slight	slight	JJ
8691	2539	18	.	.	.
8691	2540	1	If	if	IN
8691	2540	2	one	one	CD
8691	2540	3	were	be	VBD
8691	2540	4	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2540	5	and	and	CC
8691	2540	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2540	7	showed	show	VBD
8691	2540	8	that	that	IN
8691	2540	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2540	10	acted	act	VBD
8691	2540	11	in	in	IN
8691	2540	12	good	good	JJ
8691	2540	13	faith	faith	NN
8691	2540	14	and	and	CC
8691	2540	15	not	not	RB
8691	2540	16	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	2540	17	without	without	IN
8691	2540	18	cause	cause	NN
8691	2540	19	,	,	,
8691	2540	20	the	the	DT
8691	2540	21	amount	amount	NN
8691	2540	22	recovered	recover	VBN
8691	2540	23	would	would	MD
8691	2540	24	probably	probably	RB
8691	2540	25	be	be	VB
8691	2540	26	very	very	RB
8691	2540	27	small	small	JJ
8691	2540	28	,	,	,
8691	2540	29	and	and	CC
8691	2540	30	in	in	IN
8691	2540	31	any	any	DT
8691	2540	32	case	case	NN
8691	2540	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2540	34	would	would	MD
8691	2540	35	be	be	VB
8691	2540	36	difficult	difficult	JJ
8691	2540	37	to	to	TO
8691	2540	38	collect	collect	VB
8691	2540	39	a	a	DT
8691	2540	40	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2540	41	against	against	IN
8691	2540	42	one	one	CD
8691	2540	43	of	of	IN
8691	2540	44	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2540	45	,	,	,
8691	2540	46	as	as	IN
8691	2540	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2540	48	are	be	VBP
8691	2540	49	generally	generally	RB
8691	2540	50	men	man	NNS
8691	2540	51	of	of	IN
8691	2540	52	small	small	JJ
8691	2540	53	means	mean	NNS
8691	2540	54	.	.	.
8691	2541	1	In	in	IN
8691	2541	2	some	some	DT
8691	2541	3	of	of	IN
8691	2541	4	the	the	DT
8691	2541	5	original	original	JJ
8691	2541	6	States	state	NNS
8691	2541	7	a	a	DT
8691	2541	8	justice	justice	NN
8691	2541	9	of	of	IN
8691	2541	10	the	the	DT
8691	2541	11	peace	peace	NN
8691	2541	12	or	or	CC
8691	2541	13	higher	high	JJR
8691	2541	14	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2541	15	,	,	,
8691	2541	16	in	in	IN
8691	2541	17	whose	whose	WP$
8691	2541	18	actual	actual	JJ
8691	2541	19	presence	presence	NN
8691	2541	20	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2541	21	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
8691	2541	22	were	be	VBD
8691	2541	23	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2541	24	,	,	,
8691	2541	25	could	could	MD
8691	2541	26	deal	deal	VB
8691	2541	27	with	with	IN
8691	2541	28	the	the	DT
8691	2541	29	offender	offender	NN
8691	2541	30	summarily	summarily	RB
8691	2541	31	and	and	CC
8691	2541	32	sentence	sentence	VB
8691	2541	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2541	34	to	to	IN
8691	2541	35	a	a	DT
8691	2541	36	fine	fine	NN
8691	2541	37	without	without	IN
8691	2541	38	any	any	DT
8691	2541	39	written	write	VBN
8691	2541	40	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	2541	41	or	or	CC
8691	2541	42	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2541	43	.	.	.
8691	2542	1	This	this	DT
8691	2542	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2542	3	a	a	DT
8691	2542	4	survival	survival	NN
8691	2542	5	of	of	IN
8691	2542	6	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	2542	7	conceptions	conception	NNS
8691	2542	8	of	of	IN
8691	2542	9	the	the	DT
8691	2542	10	majesty	majesty	NNP
8691	2542	11	of	of	IN
8691	2542	12	official	official	JJ
8691	2542	13	station	station	NN
8691	2542	14	,	,	,
8691	2542	15	and	and	CC
8691	2542	16	the	the	DT
8691	2542	17	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2542	18	justifying	justify	VBG
8691	2542	19	the	the	DT
8691	2542	20	practice	practice	NN
8691	2542	21	soon	soon	RB
8691	2542	22	became	become	VBD
8691	2542	23	practically	practically	RB
8691	2542	24	obsolete	obsolete	JJ
8691	2542	25	.	.	.
8691	2543	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2543	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2543	3	one	one	CD
8691	2543	4	of	of	IN
8691	2543	5	the	the	DT
8691	2543	6	distinguishing	distinguish	VBG
8691	2543	7	features	feature	NNS
8691	2543	8	of	of	IN
8691	2543	9	the	the	DT
8691	2543	10	English	english	JJ
8691	2543	11	system	system	NN
8691	2543	12	of	of	IN
8691	2543	13	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2543	14	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	2543	15	that	that	WDT
8691	2543	16	any	any	DT
8691	2543	17	private	private	JJ
8691	2543	18	individual	individual	NN
8691	2543	19	can	can	MD
8691	2543	20	initiate	initiate	VB
8691	2543	21	a	a	DT
8691	2543	22	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2543	23	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	2543	24	,	,	,
8691	2543	25	and	and	CC
8691	2543	26	that	that	IN
8691	2543	27	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2543	28	are	be	VBP
8691	2543	29	generally	generally	RB
8691	2543	30	instituted	institute	VBN
8691	2543	31	in	in	IN
8691	2543	32	that	that	DT
8691	2543	33	manner	manner	NN
8691	2543	34	.	.	.
8691	2544	1	In	in	IN
8691	2544	2	doing	do	VBG
8691	2544	3	so	so	RB
8691	2544	4	,	,	,
8691	2544	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2544	6	exercises	exercise	VBZ
8691	2544	7	a	a	DT
8691	2544	8	right	right	NN
8691	2544	9	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	2544	10	to	to	IN
8691	2544	11	every	every	DT
8691	2544	12	member	member	NN
8691	2544	13	of	of	IN
8691	2544	14	the	the	DT
8691	2544	15	general	general	JJ
8691	2544	16	public	public	NN
8691	2544	17	,	,	,
8691	2544	18	and	and	CC
8691	2544	19	the	the	DT
8691	2544	20	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	2544	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	2544	22	,	,	,
8691	2544	23	in	in	IN
8691	2544	24	that	that	DT
8691	2544	25	point	point	NN
8691	2544	26	of	of	IN
8691	2544	27	view	view	NN
8691	2544	28	,	,	,
8691	2544	29	a	a	DT
8691	2544	30	public	public	JJ
8691	2544	31	one	one	NN
8691	2544	32	.	.	.
8691	2545	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2545	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2545	3	:	:	:
8691	2545	4	See	see	VB
8691	2545	5	Maitland	Maitland	NNP
8691	2545	6	,	,	,
8691	2545	7	"	"	''
8691	2545	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2545	9	and	and	CC
8691	2545	10	Police	Police	NNPS
8691	2545	11	,	,	,
8691	2545	12	"	"	''
8691	2545	13	141	141	CD
8691	2545	14	.	.	.
8691	2545	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2546	1	At	at	IN
8691	2546	2	common	common	JJ
8691	2546	3	law	law	NN
8691	2546	4	there	there	EX
8691	2546	5	were	be	VBD
8691	2546	6	but	but	CC
8691	2546	7	two	two	CD
8691	2546	8	guaranties	guaranty	NNS
8691	2546	9	against	against	IN
8691	2546	10	thus	thus	RB
8691	2546	11	bringing	bring	VBG
8691	2546	12	forward	forward	RB
8691	2546	13	frivolous	frivolous	JJ
8691	2546	14	or	or	CC
8691	2546	15	malicious	malicious	JJ
8691	2546	16	accusations	accusation	NNS
8691	2546	17	.	.	.
8691	2547	1	The	the	DT
8691	2547	2	complainant	complainant	NN
8691	2547	3	was	be	VBD
8691	2547	4	obliged	oblige	VBN
8691	2547	5	to	to	TO
8691	2547	6	verify	verify	VB
8691	2547	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2547	8	charge	charge	NN
8691	2547	9	by	by	IN
8691	2547	10	oath	oath	NN
8691	2547	11	,	,	,
8691	2547	12	and	and	CC
8691	2547	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2547	14	was	be	VBD
8691	2547	15	liable	liable	JJ
8691	2547	16	to	to	IN
8691	2547	17	a	a	DT
8691	2547	18	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2547	19	action	action	NN
8691	2547	20	if	if	IN
8691	2547	21	the	the	DT
8691	2547	22	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2547	23	was	be	VBD
8691	2547	24	acquitted	acquit	VBN
8691	2547	25	and	and	CC
8691	2547	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2547	27	appeared	appear	VBD
8691	2547	28	that	that	IN
8691	2547	29	there	there	EX
8691	2547	30	was	be	VBD
8691	2547	31	no	no	DT
8691	2547	32	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	2547	33	ground	ground	NN
8691	2547	34	for	for	IN
8691	2547	35	the	the	DT
8691	2547	36	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	2547	37	.	.	.
8691	2548	1	In	in	IN
8691	2548	2	some	some	DT
8691	2548	3	of	of	IN
8691	2548	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2548	5	States	state	NNS
8691	2548	6	,	,	,
8691	2548	7	also	also	RB
8691	2548	8	,	,	,
8691	2548	9	if	if	IN
8691	2548	10	any	any	DT
8691	2548	11	private	private	JJ
8691	2548	12	individual	individual	JJ
8691	2548	13	files	file	NNS
8691	2548	14	a	a	DT
8691	2548	15	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	2548	16	under	under	IN
8691	2548	17	oath	oath	NN
8691	2548	18	before	before	IN
8691	2548	19	a	a	DT
8691	2548	20	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2548	21	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2548	22	accusing	accuse	VBG
8691	2548	23	another	another	DT
8691	2548	24	of	of	IN
8691	2548	25	a	a	DT
8691	2548	26	properly	properly	RB
8691	2548	27	specified	specify	VBN
8691	2548	28	offense	offense	NN
8691	2548	29	,	,	,
8691	2548	30	a	a	DT
8691	2548	31	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2548	32	of	of	IN
8691	2548	33	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2548	34	may	may	MD
8691	2548	35	issue	issue	VB
8691	2548	36	.	.	.
8691	2549	1	In	in	IN
8691	2549	2	many	many	JJ
8691	2549	3	there	there	EX
8691	2549	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2549	5	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2549	6	authorizing	authorize	VBG
8691	2549	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2549	8	qui	qui	NNP
8691	2549	9	tam	tam	NNP
8691	2549	10	_	_	NNP
8691	2549	11	actions	action	NNS
8691	2549	12	to	to	TO
8691	2549	13	be	be	VB
8691	2549	14	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2549	15	by	by	IN
8691	2549	16	any	any	DT
8691	2549	17	one	one	CD
8691	2549	18	.	.	.
8691	2550	1	These	these	DT
8691	2550	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2550	3	actions	action	NNS
8691	2550	4	to	to	TO
8691	2550	5	recover	recover	VB
8691	2550	6	a	a	DT
8691	2550	7	statutory	statutory	JJ
8691	2550	8	penalty	penalty	NN
8691	2550	9	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
8691	2550	10	for	for	IN
8691	2550	11	some	some	DT
8691	2550	12	wrongful	wrongful	JJ
8691	2550	13	act	act	NN
8691	2550	14	in	in	IN
8691	2550	15	the	the	DT
8691	2550	16	nature	nature	NN
8691	2550	17	of	of	IN
8691	2550	18	a	a	DT
8691	2550	19	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
8691	2550	20	.	.	.
8691	2551	1	The	the	DT
8691	2551	2	term	term	NN
8691	2551	3	_	_	NNP
8691	2551	4	qui	qui	NNP
8691	2551	5	tam	tam	NNP
8691	2551	6	_	_	NNP
8691	2551	7	comes	come	VBZ
8691	2551	8	from	from	IN
8691	2551	9	the	the	DT
8691	2551	10	Latin	latin	JJ
8691	2551	11	terms	term	NNS
8691	2551	12	of	of	IN
8691	2551	13	the	the	DT
8691	2551	14	old	old	JJ
8691	2551	15	English	English	NNP
8691	2551	16	writ	writ	NN
8691	2551	17	used	use	VBN
8691	2551	18	for	for	IN
8691	2551	19	such	such	JJ
8691	2551	20	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2551	21	,	,	,
8691	2551	22	in	in	IN
8691	2551	23	which	which	WDT
8691	2551	24	the	the	DT
8691	2551	25	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2551	26	describes	describe	VBZ
8691	2551	27	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2551	28	as	as	IN
8691	2551	29	one	one	CD
8691	2551	30	_	_	NNP
8691	2551	31	qui	qui	NN
8691	2551	32	tam	tam	NNP
8691	2551	33	pro	pro	NNP
8691	2551	34	domino	domino	NNP
8691	2551	35	rege	rege	NN
8691	2551	36	quam	quam	NNP
8691	2551	37	pro	pro	FW
8691	2551	38	seipso	seipso	NN
8691	2551	39	in	in	IN
8691	2551	40	hoc	hoc	NNP
8691	2551	41	parte	parte	NNP
8691	2551	42	sequitur	sequitur	NNP
8691	2551	43	_	_	NNP
8691	2551	44	.	.	.
8691	2552	1	The	the	DT
8691	2552	2	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2552	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2552	4	styled	style	VBN
8691	2552	5	"	"	``
8691	2552	6	a	a	DT
8691	2552	7	common	common	JJ
8691	2552	8	informer	informer	NN
8691	2552	9	,	,	,
8691	2552	10	"	"	''
8691	2552	11	and	and	CC
8691	2552	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2552	13	action	action	NN
8691	2552	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	2552	15	for	for	IN
8691	2552	16	the	the	DT
8691	2552	17	joint	joint	JJ
8691	2552	18	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	2552	19	of	of	IN
8691	2552	20	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2552	21	and	and	CC
8691	2552	22	of	of	IN
8691	2552	23	the	the	DT
8691	2552	24	State	State	NNP
8691	2552	25	,	,	,
8691	2552	26	or	or	CC
8691	2552	27	of	of	IN
8691	2552	28	some	some	DT
8691	2552	29	other	other	JJ
8691	2552	30	public	public	JJ
8691	2552	31	corporation	corporation	NN
8691	2552	32	or	or	CC
8691	2552	33	officers	officer	NNS
8691	2552	34	designated	designate	VBN
8691	2552	35	by	by	IN
8691	2552	36	the	the	DT
8691	2552	37	statute	statute	NN
8691	2552	38	.	.	.
8691	2553	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2553	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2553	3	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2553	4	given	give	VBN
8691	2553	5	an	an	DT
8691	2553	6	option	option	NN
8691	2553	7	to	to	TO
8691	2553	8	sue	sue	VB
8691	2553	9	in	in	IN
8691	2553	10	the	the	DT
8691	2553	11	form	form	NN
8691	2553	12	of	of	IN
8691	2553	13	a	a	DT
8691	2553	14	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2553	15	action	action	NN
8691	2553	16	,	,	,
8691	2553	17	or	or	CC
8691	2553	18	by	by	IN
8691	2553	19	an	an	DT
8691	2553	20	information	information	NN
8691	2553	21	and	and	CC
8691	2553	22	the	the	DT
8691	2553	23	use	use	NN
8691	2553	24	of	of	IN
8691	2553	25	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2553	26	process	process	NN
8691	2553	27	.	.	.
8691	2554	1	In	in	IN
8691	2554	2	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2554	3	of	of	IN
8691	2554	4	the	the	DT
8691	2554	5	latter	latter	JJ
8691	2554	6	description	description	NN
8691	2554	7	a	a	DT
8691	2554	8	warrant	warrant	JJ
8691	2554	9	issues	issue	NNS
8691	2554	10	upon	upon	IN
8691	2554	11	which	which	WDT
8691	2554	12	the	the	DT
8691	2554	13	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2554	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	2554	15	liable	liable	JJ
8691	2554	16	to	to	TO
8691	2554	17	arrest	arrest	VB
8691	2554	18	.	.	.
8691	2555	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2555	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2555	3	:	:	:
8691	2555	4	Canfield	Canfield	NNP
8691	2555	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2555	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2555	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2555	8	Mitchell	Mitchell	NNP
8691	2555	9	,	,	,
8691	2555	10	43	43	CD
8691	2555	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2555	12	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2555	13	,	,	,
8691	2555	14	169	169	CD
8691	2555	15	.	.	.
8691	2555	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2556	1	The	the	DT
8691	2556	2	action	action	NN
8691	2556	3	may	may	MD
8691	2556	4	,	,	,
8691	2556	5	under	under	IN
8691	2556	6	some	some	DT
8691	2556	7	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2556	8	,	,	,
8691	2556	9	be	be	VB
8691	2556	10	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2556	11	in	in	IN
8691	2556	12	the	the	DT
8691	2556	13	name	name	NN
8691	2556	14	of	of	IN
8691	2556	15	the	the	DT
8691	2556	16	government	government	NN
8691	2556	17	,	,	,
8691	2556	18	though	though	IN
8691	2556	19	by	by	RB
8691	2556	20	and	and	CC
8691	2556	21	at	at	IN
8691	2556	22	the	the	DT
8691	2556	23	cost	cost	NN
8691	2556	24	of	of	IN
8691	2556	25	the	the	DT
8691	2556	26	informer	informer	NN
8691	2556	27	.	.	.
8691	2557	1	In	in	IN
8691	2557	2	such	such	JJ
8691	2557	3	case	case	NN
8691	2557	4	,	,	,
8691	2557	5	unless	unless	IN
8691	2557	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2557	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2557	8	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	2557	9	provided	provide	VBN
8691	2557	10	,	,	,
8691	2557	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2557	12	retains	retain	VBZ
8691	2557	13	the	the	DT
8691	2557	14	exclusive	exclusive	JJ
8691	2557	15	management	management	NN
8691	2557	16	of	of	IN
8691	2557	17	the	the	DT
8691	2557	18	cause	cause	NN
8691	2557	19	as	as	RB
8691	2557	20	fully	fully	RB
8691	2557	21	as	as	IN
8691	2557	22	if	if	IN
8691	2557	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2557	24	appeared	appear	VBD
8691	2557	25	as	as	IN
8691	2557	26	the	the	DT
8691	2557	27	sole	sole	JJ
8691	2557	28	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2557	29	on	on	IN
8691	2557	30	the	the	DT
8691	2557	31	face	face	NN
8691	2557	32	of	of	IN
8691	2557	33	the	the	DT
8691	2557	34	record	record	NN
8691	2557	35	.	.	.
8691	2558	1	If	if	IN
8691	2558	2	the	the	DT
8691	2558	3	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	2558	4	obtains	obtain	VBZ
8691	2558	5	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2558	6	,	,	,
8691	2558	7	and	and	CC
8691	2558	8	collects	collect	VBZ
8691	2558	9	the	the	DT
8691	2558	10	penalty	penalty	NN
8691	2558	11	,	,	,
8691	2558	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2558	13	must	must	MD
8691	2558	14	pay	pay	VB
8691	2558	15	half	half	NN
8691	2558	16	of	of	IN
8691	2558	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2558	18	over	over	RP
8691	2558	19	to	to	IN
8691	2558	20	the	the	DT
8691	2558	21	government	government	NN
8691	2558	22	.	.	.
8691	2559	1	If	if	IN
8691	2559	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2559	3	fails	fail	VBZ
8691	2559	4	,	,	,
8691	2559	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2559	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2559	7	personally	personally	RB
8691	2559	8	liable	liable	JJ
8691	2559	9	to	to	IN
8691	2559	10	the	the	DT
8691	2559	11	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2559	12	for	for	IN
8691	2559	13	the	the	DT
8691	2559	14	taxable	taxable	JJ
8691	2559	15	costs	cost	NNS
8691	2559	16	of	of	IN
8691	2559	17	the	the	DT
8691	2559	18	action	action	NN
8691	2559	19	.	.	.
8691	2560	1	Under	under	IN
8691	2560	2	such	such	PDT
8691	2560	3	a	a	DT
8691	2560	4	statute	statute	NN
8691	2560	5	,	,	,
8691	2560	6	a	a	DT
8691	2560	7	public	public	JJ
8691	2560	8	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
8691	2560	9	officer	officer	NN
8691	2560	10	can	can	MD
8691	2560	11	sue	sue	VB
8691	2560	12	for	for	IN
8691	2560	13	the	the	DT
8691	2560	14	entire	entire	JJ
8691	2560	15	penalty	penalty	NN
8691	2560	16	,	,	,
8691	2560	17	whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	2560	18	no	no	DT
8691	2560	19	action	action	NN
8691	2560	20	has	have	VBZ
8691	2560	21	been	be	VBN
8691	2560	22	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2560	23	by	by	IN
8691	2560	24	a	a	DT
8691	2560	25	private	private	JJ
8691	2560	26	individual	individual	NN
8691	2560	27	.	.	.
8691	2561	1	The	the	DT
8691	2561	2	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	2561	3	of	of	IN
8691	2561	4	modern	modern	JJ
8691	2561	5	American	american	JJ
8691	2561	6	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	2561	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2561	8	toward	toward	IN
8691	2561	9	placing	place	VBG
8691	2561	10	the	the	DT
8691	2561	11	collection	collection	NN
8691	2561	12	of	of	IN
8691	2561	13	penalties	penalty	NNS
8691	2561	14	for	for	IN
8691	2561	15	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
8691	2561	16	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	2561	17	in	in	IN
8691	2561	18	the	the	DT
8691	2561	19	hands	hand	NNS
8691	2561	20	of	of	IN
8691	2561	21	public	public	JJ
8691	2561	22	officers	officer	NNS
8691	2561	23	.	.	.
8691	2562	1	The	the	DT
8691	2562	2	_	_	NNP
8691	2562	3	qui	qui	NN
8691	2562	4	tam	tam	NNP
8691	2562	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2562	6	action	action	NN
8691	2562	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2562	8	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	2562	9	a	a	DT
8691	2562	10	cheap	cheap	JJ
8691	2562	11	mode	mode	NN
8691	2562	12	of	of	IN
8691	2562	13	enforcing	enforce	VBG
8691	2562	14	laws	law	NNS
8691	2562	15	,	,	,
8691	2562	16	and	and	CC
8691	2562	17	one	one	NN
8691	2562	18	likely	likely	JJ
8691	2562	19	to	to	TO
8691	2562	20	be	be	VB
8691	2562	21	pressed	press	VBN
8691	2562	22	to	to	IN
8691	2562	23	a	a	DT
8691	2562	24	prompt	prompt	JJ
8691	2562	25	issue	issue	NN
8691	2562	26	.	.	.
8691	2563	1	As	as	IN
8691	2563	2	observed	observe	VBN
8691	2563	3	by	by	IN
8691	2563	4	the	the	DT
8691	2563	5	late	late	JJ
8691	2563	6	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	2563	7	Deady	Deady	NNP
8691	2563	8	,	,	,
8691	2563	9	"	"	''
8691	2563	10	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2563	11	conducted	conduct	VBN
8691	2563	12	by	by	IN
8691	2563	13	such	such	JJ
8691	2563	14	means	mean	NNS
8691	2563	15	compare	compare	VBP
8691	2563	16	with	with	IN
8691	2563	17	the	the	DT
8691	2563	18	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	2563	19	methods	method	NNS
8691	2563	20	as	as	IN
8691	2563	21	the	the	DT
8691	2563	22	enterprising	enterprise	VBG
8691	2563	23	privateer	privateer	NN
8691	2563	24	does	do	VBZ
8691	2563	25	to	to	IN
8691	2563	26	the	the	DT
8691	2563	27	slow	slow	RB
8691	2563	28	-	-	HYPH
8691	2563	29	going	go	VBG
8691	2563	30	public	public	JJ
8691	2563	31	vessel	vessel	NN
8691	2563	32	.	.	.
8691	2564	1	"	"	``
8691	2564	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2564	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2564	4	:	:	:
8691	2564	5	United	United	NNP
8691	2564	6	States	States	NNP
8691	2564	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2564	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	2564	9	_	_	NNP
8691	2564	10	Griswold	Griswold	NNP
8691	2564	11	,	,	,
8691	2564	12	24	24	CD
8691	2564	13	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	2564	14	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2564	15	,	,	,
8691	2564	16	361	361	CD
8691	2564	17	;	;	:
8691	2564	18	30	30	CD
8691	2564	19	_	_	NNP
8691	2564	20	i	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2564	21	d	d	NNP
8691	2564	22	_	_	NNP
8691	2564	23	.	.	NNP
8691	2564	24	,	,	,
8691	2564	25	762	762	CD
8691	2564	26	.	.	.
8691	2564	27	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2565	1	But	but	CC
8691	2565	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2565	3	appeal	appeal	VBP
8691	2565	4	to	to	IN
8691	2565	5	sordid	sordid	NNP
8691	2565	6	motives	motive	NNS
8691	2565	7	and	and	CC
8691	2565	8	are	be	VBP
8691	2565	9	liable	liable	JJ
8691	2565	10	to	to	TO
8691	2565	11	abuse	abuse	VB
8691	2565	12	.	.	.
8691	2566	1	One	one	CD
8691	2566	2	who	who	WP
8691	2566	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2566	4	exposed	expose	VBN
8691	2566	5	to	to	IN
8691	2566	6	such	such	PDT
8691	2566	7	a	a	DT
8691	2566	8	suit	suit	NN
8691	2566	9	often	often	RB
8691	2566	10	gets	get	VBZ
8691	2566	11	a	a	DT
8691	2566	12	friend	friend	NN
8691	2566	13	to	to	TO
8691	2566	14	bring	bring	VB
8691	2566	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2566	16	,	,	,
8691	2566	17	in	in	IN
8691	2566	18	order	order	NN
8691	2566	19	to	to	TO
8691	2566	20	forestall	forestall	VB
8691	2566	21	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2566	22	by	by	IN
8691	2566	23	others	other	NNS
8691	2566	24	or	or	CC
8691	2566	25	by	by	IN
8691	2566	26	the	the	DT
8691	2566	27	State	State	NNP
8691	2566	28	,	,	,
8691	2566	29	and	and	CC
8691	2566	30	with	with	IN
8691	2566	31	a	a	DT
8691	2566	32	view	view	NN
8691	2566	33	to	to	IN
8691	2566	34	delaying	delay	VBG
8691	2566	35	or	or	CC
8691	2566	36	defeating	defeat	VBG
8691	2566	37	the	the	DT
8691	2566	38	collection	collection	NN
8691	2566	39	of	of	IN
8691	2566	40	the	the	DT
8691	2566	41	penalty	penalty	NN
8691	2566	42	.	.	.
8691	2567	1	These	these	DT
8691	2567	2	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	2567	3	induced	induce	VBD
8691	2567	4	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
8691	2567	5	to	to	TO
8691	2567	6	restrict	restrict	VB
8691	2567	7	the	the	DT
8691	2567	8	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	2567	9	in	in	IN
8691	2567	10	England	England	NNP
8691	2567	11	as	as	RB
8691	2567	12	early	early	RB
8691	2567	13	as	as	IN
8691	2567	14	the	the	DT
8691	2567	15	reign	reign	NN
8691	2567	16	of	of	IN
8691	2567	17	Henry	Henry	NNP
8691	2567	18	VII	VII	NNP
8691	2567	19	,	,	,
8691	2567	20	and	and	CC
8691	2567	21	have	have	VBP
8691	2567	22	proved	prove	VBN
8691	2567	23	of	of	IN
8691	2567	24	equal	equal	JJ
8691	2567	25	force	force	NN
8691	2567	26	in	in	IN
8691	2567	27	course	course	NN
8691	2567	28	of	of	IN
8691	2567	29	time	time	NN
8691	2567	30	in	in	IN
8691	2567	31	the	the	DT
8691	2567	32	United	United	NNP
8691	2567	33	States	States	NNP
8691	2567	34	.	.	.
8691	2568	1	Justices	justice	NNS
8691	2568	2	of	of	IN
8691	2568	3	the	the	DT
8691	2568	4	peace	peace	NN
8691	2568	5	and	and	CC
8691	2568	6	local	local	JJ
8691	2568	7	municipal	municipal	JJ
8691	2568	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	2568	9	of	of	IN
8691	2568	10	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2568	11	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2568	12	are	be	VBP
8691	2568	13	generally	generally	RB
8691	2568	14	given	give	VBN
8691	2568	15	power	power	NN
8691	2568	16	to	to	TO
8691	2568	17	deal	deal	VB
8691	2568	18	finally	finally	RB
8691	2568	19	with	with	IN
8691	2568	20	a	a	DT
8691	2568	21	few	few	JJ
8691	2568	22	petty	petty	JJ
8691	2568	23	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	2568	24	,	,	,
8691	2568	25	subject	subject	JJ
8691	2568	26	to	to	IN
8691	2568	27	a	a	DT
8691	2568	28	right	right	NN
8691	2568	29	of	of	IN
8691	2568	30	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2568	31	to	to	IN
8691	2568	32	a	a	DT
8691	2568	33	court	court	NN
8691	2568	34	where	where	WRB
8691	2568	35	a	a	DT
8691	2568	36	jury	jury	NN
8691	2568	37	trial	trial	NN
8691	2568	38	can	can	MD
8691	2568	39	be	be	VB
8691	2568	40	had	have	VBN
8691	2568	41	.	.	.
8691	2569	1	As	as	IN
8691	2569	2	to	to	IN
8691	2569	3	all	all	DT
8691	2569	4	others	other	NNS
8691	2569	5	,	,	,
8691	2569	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2569	7	function	function	NN
8691	2569	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2569	9	,	,	,
8691	2569	10	when	when	WRB
8691	2569	11	the	the	DT
8691	2569	12	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2569	13	of	of	IN
8691	2569	14	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2569	15	has	have	VBZ
8691	2569	16	been	be	VBN
8691	2569	17	executed	execute	VBN
8691	2569	18	,	,	,
8691	2569	19	to	to	TO
8691	2569	20	inquire	inquire	VB
8691	2569	21	whether	whether	IN
8691	2569	22	there	there	EX
8691	2569	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	2569	24	probable	probable	JJ
8691	2569	25	cause	cause	NN
8691	2569	26	for	for	IN
8691	2569	27	holding	hold	VBG
8691	2569	28	the	the	DT
8691	2569	29	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2569	30	to	to	TO
8691	2569	31	answer	answer	VB
8691	2569	32	to	to	IN
8691	2569	33	the	the	DT
8691	2569	34	charge	charge	NN
8691	2569	35	which	which	WDT
8691	2569	36	has	have	VBZ
8691	2569	37	been	be	VBN
8691	2569	38	made	make	VBN
8691	2569	39	against	against	IN
8691	2569	40	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2569	41	in	in	IN
8691	2569	42	a	a	DT
8691	2569	43	higher	high	JJR
8691	2569	44	court	court	NN
8691	2569	45	,	,	,
8691	2569	46	and	and	CC
8691	2569	47	if	if	IN
8691	2569	48	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2569	49	find	find	VBP
8691	2569	50	that	that	IN
8691	2569	51	such	such	JJ
8691	2569	52	cause	cause	NN
8691	2569	53	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	2569	54	,	,	,
8691	2569	55	to	to	TO
8691	2569	56	order	order	VB
8691	2569	57	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2569	58	to	to	TO
8691	2569	59	give	give	VB
8691	2569	60	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	2569	61	security	security	NN
8691	2569	62	that	that	WDT
8691	2569	63	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2569	64	will	will	MD
8691	2569	65	appear	appear	VB
8691	2569	66	before	before	IN
8691	2569	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2569	68	for	for	IN
8691	2569	69	trial	trial	NN
8691	2569	70	.	.	.
8691	2570	1	The	the	DT
8691	2570	2	question	question	NN
8691	2570	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2570	4	not	not	RB
8691	2570	5	whether	whether	IN
8691	2570	6	the	the	DT
8691	2570	7	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2570	8	satisfies	satisfy	VBZ
8691	2570	9	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2570	10	of	of	IN
8691	2570	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2570	12	guilt	guilt	NN
8691	2570	13	,	,	,
8691	2570	14	but	but	CC
8691	2570	15	simply	simply	RB
8691	2570	16	whether	whether	IN
8691	2570	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2570	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	2570	19	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	2570	20	,	,	,
8691	2570	21	in	in	IN
8691	2570	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2570	23	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2570	24	,	,	,
8691	2570	25	to	to	TO
8691	2570	26	make	make	VB
8691	2570	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2570	28	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2570	29	to	to	TO
8691	2570	30	send	send	VB
8691	2570	31	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2570	32	where	where	WRB
8691	2570	33	the	the	DT
8691	2570	34	charge	charge	NN
8691	2570	35	can	can	MD
8691	2570	36	be	be	VB
8691	2570	37	more	more	RBR
8691	2570	38	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
8691	2570	39	investigated	investigate	VBN
8691	2570	40	by	by	IN
8691	2570	41	those	those	DT
8691	2570	42	who	who	WP
8691	2570	43	have	have	VBP
8691	2570	44	the	the	DT
8691	2570	45	right	right	NN
8691	2570	46	to	to	TO
8691	2570	47	condemn	condemn	VB
8691	2570	48	or	or	CC
8691	2570	49	to	to	TO
8691	2570	50	acquit	acquit	VB
8691	2570	51	.	.	.
8691	2571	1	In	in	IN
8691	2571	2	making	make	VBG
8691	2571	3	this	this	DT
8691	2571	4	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	2571	5	,	,	,
8691	2571	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2571	7	hear	hear	VBP
8691	2571	8	both	both	DT
8691	2571	9	sides	side	NNS
8691	2571	10	,	,	,
8691	2571	11	if	if	IN
8691	2571	12	the	the	DT
8691	2571	13	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2571	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	2571	15	any	any	DT
8691	2571	16	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2571	17	to	to	TO
8691	2571	18	offer	offer	VB
8691	2571	19	.	.	.
8691	2572	1	In	in	IN
8691	2572	2	most	most	JJS
8691	2572	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2572	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2572	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2572	6	now	now	RB
8691	2572	7	a	a	DT
8691	2572	8	competent	competent	JJ
8691	2572	9	witness	witness	NN
8691	2572	10	in	in	IN
8691	2572	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2572	12	own	own	JJ
8691	2572	13	behalf	behalf	NN
8691	2572	14	,	,	,
8691	2572	15	provided	provide	VBN
8691	2572	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2572	17	desires	desire	VBZ
8691	2572	18	to	to	TO
8691	2572	19	testify	testify	VB
8691	2572	20	.	.	.
8691	2573	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2573	2	can	can	MD
8691	2573	3	not	not	RB
8691	2573	4	be	be	VB
8691	2573	5	interrogated	interrogate	VBN
8691	2573	6	in	in	IN
8691	2573	7	any	any	DT
8691	2573	8	court	court	NN
8691	2573	9	or	or	CC
8691	2573	10	before	before	IN
8691	2573	11	any	any	DT
8691	2573	12	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2573	13	without	without	IN
8691	2573	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2573	15	consent	consent	NN
8691	2573	16	.	.	.
8691	2574	1	This	this	DT
8691	2574	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2574	3	a	a	DT
8691	2574	4	weakness	weakness	NN
8691	2574	5	in	in	IN
8691	2574	6	the	the	DT
8691	2574	7	American	american	JJ
8691	2574	8	system	system	NN
8691	2574	9	of	of	IN
8691	2574	10	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2574	11	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	2574	12	.	.	.
8691	2575	1	Under	under	IN
8691	2575	2	the	the	DT
8691	2575	3	English	english	JJ
8691	2575	4	system	system	NN
8691	2575	5	of	of	IN
8691	2575	6	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2575	7	by	by	IN
8691	2575	8	private	private	JJ
8691	2575	9	persons	person	NNS
8691	2575	10	,	,	,
8691	2575	11	there	there	EX
8691	2575	12	are	be	VBP
8691	2575	13	greater	great	JJR
8691	2575	14	objections	objection	NNS
8691	2575	15	to	to	IN
8691	2575	16	subjecting	subject	VBG
8691	2575	17	an	an	DT
8691	2575	18	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2575	19	person	person	NN
8691	2575	20	to	to	IN
8691	2575	21	an	an	DT
8691	2575	22	examination	examination	NN
8691	2575	23	,	,	,
8691	2575	24	and	and	CC
8691	2575	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2575	26	can	can	MD
8691	2575	27	now	now	RB
8691	2575	28	only	only	RB
8691	2575	29	be	be	VB
8691	2575	30	had	have	VBN
8691	2575	31	by	by	IN
8691	2575	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2575	33	consent	consent	NN
8691	2575	34	.	.	.
8691	2576	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2576	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2576	3	:	:	:
8691	2576	4	Maitland	Maitland	NNP
8691	2576	5	,	,	,
8691	2576	6	"	"	''
8691	2576	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2576	8	and	and	CC
8691	2576	9	Police	Police	NNPS
8691	2576	10	,	,	,
8691	2576	11	"	"	''
8691	2576	12	129	129	CD
8691	2576	13	.	.	.
8691	2576	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2577	1	The	the	DT
8691	2577	2	certainty	certainty	NN
8691	2577	3	in	in	IN
8691	2577	4	England	England	NNP
8691	2577	5	also	also	RB
8691	2577	6	that	that	IN
8691	2577	7	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2577	8	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2577	9	may	may	MD
8691	2577	10	in	in	IN
8691	2577	11	any	any	DT
8691	2577	12	case	case	NN
8691	2577	13	be	be	VB
8691	2577	14	subjected	subject	VBN
8691	2577	15	to	to	IN
8691	2577	16	the	the	DT
8691	2577	17	power	power	NN
8691	2577	18	of	of	IN
8691	2577	19	a	a	DT
8691	2577	20	public	public	JJ
8691	2577	21	officer	officer	NN
8691	2577	22	by	by	IN
8691	2577	23	the	the	DT
8691	2577	24	interposition	interposition	NN
8691	2577	25	of	of	IN
8691	2577	26	the	the	DT
8691	2577	27	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
8691	2577	28	-	-	HYPH
8691	2577	29	General	General	NNP
8691	2577	30	or	or	CC
8691	2577	31	the	the	DT
8691	2577	32	Director	Director	NNP
8691	2577	33	of	of	IN
8691	2577	34	Public	Public	NNP
8691	2577	35	Prosecutions	Prosecutions	NNPS
8691	2577	36	makes	make	VBZ
8691	2577	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2577	38	more	more	RBR
8691	2577	39	important	important	JJ
8691	2577	40	to	to	TO
8691	2577	41	safeguard	safeguard	VB
8691	2577	42	a	a	DT
8691	2577	43	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2577	44	who	who	WP
8691	2577	45	may	may	MD
8691	2577	46	be	be	VB
8691	2577	47	arraigned	arraign	VBN
8691	2577	48	for	for	IN
8691	2577	49	a	a	DT
8691	2577	50	political	political	JJ
8691	2577	51	offense	offense	NN
8691	2577	52	,	,	,
8691	2577	53	and	and	CC
8691	2577	54	whose	whose	WP$
8691	2577	55	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	2577	56	may	may	MD
8691	2577	57	be	be	VB
8691	2577	58	inspired	inspire	VBN
8691	2577	59	by	by	IN
8691	2577	60	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	2577	61	of	of	IN
8691	2577	62	a	a	DT
8691	2577	63	partisan	partisan	JJ
8691	2577	64	nature	nature	NN
8691	2577	65	.	.	.
8691	2578	1	The	the	DT
8691	2578	2	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
8691	2578	3	upon	upon	IN
8691	2578	4	whom	whom	WP
8691	2578	5	the	the	DT
8691	2578	6	task	task	NN
8691	2578	7	of	of	IN
8691	2578	8	conducting	conduct	VBG
8691	2578	9	or	or	CC
8691	2578	10	superintending	superintend	VBG
8691	2578	11	the	the	DT
8691	2578	12	examination	examination	NN
8691	2578	13	would	would	MD
8691	2578	14	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	2578	15	fall	fall	VB
8691	2578	16	are	be	VBP
8691	2578	17	also	also	RB
8691	2578	18	largely	largely	RB
8691	2578	19	both	both	DT
8691	2578	20	representative	representative	NN
8691	2578	21	of	of	IN
8691	2578	22	class	class	NN
8691	2578	23	interests	interest	NNS
8691	2578	24	and	and	CC
8691	2578	25	unlearned	unlearn	VBN
8691	2578	26	in	in	IN
8691	2578	27	the	the	DT
8691	2578	28	law	law	NN
8691	2578	29	.	.	.
8691	2579	1	In	in	IN
8691	2579	2	the	the	DT
8691	2579	3	United	United	NNP
8691	2579	4	States	States	NNP
8691	2579	5	local	local	JJ
8691	2579	6	prosecutors	prosecutor	NNS
8691	2579	7	are	be	VBP
8691	2579	8	often	often	RB
8691	2579	9	of	of	IN
8691	2579	10	a	a	DT
8691	2579	11	different	different	JJ
8691	2579	12	party	party	NN
8691	2579	13	from	from	IN
8691	2579	14	that	that	DT
8691	2579	15	which	which	WDT
8691	2579	16	controls	control	VBZ
8691	2579	17	the	the	DT
8691	2579	18	State	state	NN
8691	2579	19	or	or	CC
8691	2579	20	the	the	DT
8691	2579	21	United	United	NNP
8691	2579	22	States	States	NNP
8691	2579	23	.	.	.
8691	2580	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2580	2	have	have	VBP
8691	2580	3	no	no	DT
8691	2580	4	close	close	JJ
8691	2580	5	connection	connection	NN
8691	2580	6	with	with	IN
8691	2580	7	those	those	DT
8691	2580	8	administering	administer	VBG
8691	2580	9	the	the	DT
8691	2580	10	general	general	JJ
8691	2580	11	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	2580	12	of	of	IN
8691	2580	13	the	the	DT
8691	2580	14	government	government	NN
8691	2580	15	.	.	.
8691	2581	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2581	2	hold	hold	VBP
8691	2581	3	office	office	NN
8691	2581	4	for	for	IN
8691	2581	5	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	2581	6	terms	term	NNS
8691	2581	7	,	,	,
8691	2581	8	not	not	RB
8691	2581	9	dependent	dependent	JJ
8691	2581	10	on	on	IN
8691	2581	11	any	any	DT
8691	2581	12	shifting	shifting	NN
8691	2581	13	of	of	IN
8691	2581	14	parliamentary	parliamentary	JJ
8691	2581	15	majorities	majority	NNS
8691	2581	16	or	or	CC
8691	2581	17	change	change	NN
8691	2581	18	of	of	IN
8691	2581	19	ministry	ministry	NN
8691	2581	20	.	.	.
8691	2582	1	Committing	commit	VBG
8691	2582	2	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
8691	2582	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2582	4	in	in	IN
8691	2582	5	a	a	DT
8691	2582	6	similar	similar	JJ
8691	2582	7	position	position	NN
8691	2582	8	.	.	.
8691	2583	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2583	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2583	3	also	also	RB
8691	2583	4	in	in	IN
8691	2583	5	many	many	JJ
8691	2583	6	cases	case	NNS
8691	2583	7	trained	train	VBD
8691	2583	8	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2583	9	.	.	.
8691	2584	1	If	if	IN
8691	2584	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2584	3	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	2584	4	could	could	MD
8691	2584	5	be	be	VB
8691	2584	6	so	so	RB
8691	2584	7	modified	modified	JJ
8691	2584	8	or	or	CC
8691	2584	9	so	so	RB
8691	2584	10	construed	construe	VBN
8691	2584	11	as	as	IN
8691	2584	12	to	to	TO
8691	2584	13	allow	allow	VB
8691	2584	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2584	15	to	to	TO
8691	2584	16	ask	ask	VB
8691	2584	17	the	the	DT
8691	2584	18	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2584	19	the	the	DT
8691	2584	20	questions	question	NNS
8691	2584	21	that	that	WDT
8691	2584	22	the	the	DT
8691	2584	23	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	2584	24	who	who	WP
8691	2584	25	makes	make	VBZ
8691	2584	26	the	the	DT
8691	2584	27	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2584	28	or	or	CC
8691	2584	29	the	the	DT
8691	2584	30	reporter	reporter	NN
8691	2584	31	who	who	WP
8691	2584	32	hurries	hurry	VBZ
8691	2584	33	after	after	IN
8691	2584	34	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2584	35	to	to	IN
8691	2584	36	the	the	DT
8691	2584	37	jail	jail	NN
8691	2584	38	is	be	VBZ
8691	2584	39	sure	sure	JJ
8691	2584	40	to	to	TO
8691	2584	41	ask	ask	VB
8691	2584	42	,	,	,
8691	2584	43	there	there	EX
8691	2584	44	are	be	VBP
8691	2584	45	many	many	JJ
8691	2584	46	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	2584	47	for	for	IN
8691	2584	48	believing	believe	VBG
8691	2584	49	that	that	IN
8691	2584	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2584	51	would	would	MD
8691	2584	52	oftener	oftener	RB
8691	2584	53	prove	prove	VB
8691	2584	54	a	a	DT
8691	2584	55	safeguard	safeguard	NN
8691	2584	56	to	to	IN
8691	2584	57	innocence	innocence	NN
8691	2584	58	than	than	IN
8691	2584	59	an	an	DT
8691	2584	60	occasion	occasion	NN
8691	2584	61	for	for	IN
8691	2584	62	extorted	extort	VBN
8691	2584	63	and	and	CC
8691	2584	64	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	2584	65	inconsiderate	inconsiderate	JJ
8691	2584	66	or	or	CC
8691	2584	67	misunderstood	misunderstood	JJ
8691	2584	68	admissions	admission	NNS
8691	2584	69	.	.	.
8691	2585	1	And	and	CC
8691	2585	2	be	be	VB
8691	2585	3	that	that	IN
8691	2585	4	as	as	IN
8691	2585	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2585	6	may	may	MD
8691	2585	7	,	,	,
8691	2585	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2585	9	would	would	MD
8691	2585	10	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	2585	11	lead	lead	VB
8691	2585	12	up	up	IN
8691	2585	13	to	to	IN
8691	2585	14	important	important	JJ
8691	2585	15	clues	clue	NNS
8691	2585	16	,	,	,
8691	2585	17	and	and	CC
8691	2585	18	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	2585	19	bring	bring	VB
8691	2585	20	out	out	RP
8691	2585	21	admissions	admission	NNS
8691	2585	22	that	that	WDT
8691	2585	23	were	be	VBD
8691	2585	24	both	both	DT
8691	2585	25	unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
8691	2585	26	true	true	JJ
8691	2585	27	and	and	CC
8691	2585	28	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2585	29	to	to	TO
8691	2585	30	establish	establish	VB
8691	2585	31	guilt	guilt	NN
8691	2585	32	.	.	.
8691	2586	1	The	the	DT
8691	2586	2	fifth	fifth	JJ
8691	2586	3	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	2586	4	to	to	IN
8691	2586	5	the	the	DT
8691	2586	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2586	7	of	of	IN
8691	2586	8	the	the	DT
8691	2586	9	United	United	NNP
8691	2586	10	States	States	NNP
8691	2586	11	,	,	,
8691	2586	12	and	and	CC
8691	2586	13	similar	similar	JJ
8691	2586	14	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	2586	15	in	in	IN
8691	2586	16	the	the	DT
8691	2586	17	various	various	JJ
8691	2586	18	State	State	NNP
8691	2586	19	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	2586	20	,	,	,
8691	2586	21	preclude	preclude	NN
8691	2586	22	,	,	,
8691	2586	23	so	so	RB
8691	2586	24	long	long	RB
8691	2586	25	as	as	IN
8691	2586	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2586	27	stand	stand	VBP
8691	2586	28	,	,	,
8691	2586	29	any	any	DT
8691	2586	30	radical	radical	JJ
8691	2586	31	reform	reform	NN
8691	2586	32	in	in	IN
8691	2586	33	this	this	DT
8691	2586	34	direction	direction	NN
8691	2586	35	.	.	.
8691	2587	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2587	2	speak	speak	VBP
8691	2587	3	for	for	IN
8691	2587	4	a	a	DT
8691	2587	5	policy	policy	NN
8691	2587	6	that	that	WDT
8691	2587	7	was	be	VBD
8691	2587	8	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2587	9	under	under	IN
8691	2587	10	the	the	DT
8691	2587	11	political	political	JJ
8691	2587	12	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	2587	13	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	2587	14	the	the	DT
8691	2587	15	American	American	NNP
8691	2587	16	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	2587	17	,	,	,
8691	2587	18	but	but	CC
8691	2587	19	which	which	WDT
8691	2587	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	2587	21	out	out	IN
8691	2587	22	of	of	IN
8691	2587	23	harmony	harmony	NN
8691	2587	24	with	with	IN
8691	2587	25	those	those	DT
8691	2587	26	now	now	RB
8691	2587	27	existing	exist	VBG
8691	2587	28	in	in	IN
8691	2587	29	the	the	DT
8691	2587	30	United	United	NNP
8691	2587	31	States	States	NNP
8691	2587	32	.	.	.
8691	2588	1	The	the	DT
8691	2588	2	interests	interest	NNS
8691	2588	3	of	of	IN
8691	2588	4	society	society	NN
8691	2588	5	are	be	VBP
8691	2588	6	greater	great	JJR
8691	2588	7	than	than	IN
8691	2588	8	those	those	DT
8691	2588	9	of	of	IN
8691	2588	10	any	any	DT
8691	2588	11	individual	individual	NN
8691	2588	12	,	,	,
8691	2588	13	and	and	CC
8691	2588	14	yet	yet	RB
8691	2588	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2588	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	2588	17	with	with	IN
8691	2588	18	us	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2588	19	the	the	DT
8691	2588	20	State	state	NN
8691	2588	21	that	that	WDT
8691	2588	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	2588	23	deprived	deprive	VBN
8691	2588	24	in	in	IN
8691	2588	25	public	public	JJ
8691	2588	26	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2588	27	of	of	IN
8691	2588	28	an	an	DT
8691	2588	29	equal	equal	JJ
8691	2588	30	chance	chance	NN
8691	2588	31	with	with	IN
8691	2588	32	the	the	DT
8691	2588	33	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2588	34	.	.	.
8691	2589	1	While	while	IN
8691	2589	2	burdened	burden	VBN
8691	2589	3	with	with	IN
8691	2589	4	the	the	DT
8691	2589	5	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	2589	6	of	of	IN
8691	2589	7	proving	prove	VBG
8691	2589	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2589	9	guilt	guilt	NN
8691	2589	10	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	2589	11	a	a	DT
8691	2589	12	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	2589	13	doubt	doubt	NN
8691	2589	14	,	,	,
8691	2589	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2589	16	can	can	MD
8691	2589	17	not	not	RB
8691	2589	18	,	,	,
8691	2589	19	according	accord	VBG
8691	2589	20	to	to	IN
8691	2589	21	the	the	DT
8691	2589	22	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	2589	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2589	24	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2589	25	in	in	IN
8691	2589	26	this	this	DT
8691	2589	27	country	country	NN
8691	2589	28	,	,	,
8691	2589	29	so	so	RB
8691	2589	30	much	much	RB
8691	2589	31	as	as	IN
8691	2589	32	ask	ask	VB
8691	2589	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2589	34	at	at	IN
8691	2589	35	any	any	DT
8691	2589	36	stage	stage	NN
8691	2589	37	of	of	IN
8691	2589	38	the	the	DT
8691	2589	39	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	2589	40	where	where	WRB
8691	2589	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2589	42	was	be	VBD
8691	2589	43	at	at	IN
8691	2589	44	the	the	DT
8691	2589	45	time	time	NN
8691	2589	46	when	when	WRB
8691	2589	47	the	the	DT
8691	2589	48	crime	crime	NN
8691	2589	49	charged	charge	VBN
8691	2589	50	was	be	VBD
8691	2589	51	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2589	52	.	.	.
8691	2590	1	The	the	DT
8691	2590	2	terms	term	NNS
8691	2590	3	of	of	IN
8691	2590	4	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2590	5	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	2590	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2590	7	not	not	RB
8691	2590	8	such	such	JJ
8691	2590	9	as	as	IN
8691	2590	10	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	2590	11	to	to	TO
8691	2590	12	demand	demand	VB
8691	2590	13	the	the	DT
8691	2590	14	construction	construction	NN
8691	2590	15	which	which	WDT
8691	2590	16	has	have	VBZ
8691	2590	17	been	be	VBN
8691	2590	18	generally	generally	RB
8691	2590	19	given	give	VBN
8691	2590	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2590	21	by	by	IN
8691	2590	22	the	the	DT
8691	2590	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	2590	24	.	.	.
8691	2591	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2591	2	have	have	VBP
8691	2591	3	been	be	VBN
8691	2591	4	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2591	5	interpreted	interpret	VBN
8691	2591	6	with	with	IN
8691	2591	7	a	a	DT
8691	2591	8	view	view	NN
8691	2591	9	to	to	IN
8691	2591	10	making	make	VBG
8691	2591	11	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2591	12	as	as	RB
8691	2591	13	helpful	helpful	JJ
8691	2591	14	as	as	IN
8691	2591	15	possible	possible	JJ
8691	2591	16	to	to	IN
8691	2591	17	the	the	DT
8691	2591	18	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2591	19	.	.	.
8691	2592	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2592	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2592	3	:	:	:
8691	2592	4	Boyd	Boyd	NNP
8691	2592	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2592	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2592	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2592	8	United	United	NNP
8691	2592	9	States	States	NNP
8691	2592	10	,	,	,
8691	2592	11	116	116	CD
8691	2592	12	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2592	13	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2592	14	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2592	15	,	,	,
8691	2592	16	616	616	CD
8691	2592	17	.	.	.
8691	2592	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2593	1	Provisions	provision	NNS
8691	2593	2	against	against	IN
8691	2593	3	compelling	compel	VBG
8691	2593	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2593	5	to	to	TO
8691	2593	6	testify	testify	VB
8691	2593	7	have	have	VBP
8691	2593	8	been	be	VBN
8691	2593	9	treated	treat	VBN
8691	2593	10	as	as	IN
8691	2593	11	if	if	IN
8691	2593	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2593	13	forbade	forbid	VBD
8691	2593	14	requesting	request	VBG
8691	2593	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2593	16	to	to	TO
8691	2593	17	testify	testify	VB
8691	2593	18	.	.	.
8691	2594	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2594	2	would	would	MD
8691	2594	3	seem	seem	VB
8691	2594	4	,	,	,
8691	2594	5	on	on	IN
8691	2594	6	principle	principle	NN
8691	2594	7	,	,	,
8691	2594	8	quite	quite	RB
8691	2594	9	compatible	compatible	JJ
8691	2594	10	with	with	IN
8691	2594	11	a	a	DT
8691	2594	12	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	2594	13	under	under	IN
8691	2594	14	which	which	WDT
8691	2594	15	the	the	DT
8691	2594	16	committing	commit	VBG
8691	2594	17	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
8691	2594	18	should	should	MD
8691	2594	19	in	in	IN
8691	2594	20	every	every	DT
8691	2594	21	case	case	NN
8691	2594	22	ask	ask	VB
8691	2594	23	the	the	DT
8691	2594	24	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2594	25	when	when	WRB
8691	2594	26	first	first	RB
8691	2594	27	brought	bring	VBD
8691	2594	28	before	before	IN
8691	2594	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2594	30	whether	whether	IN
8691	2594	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2594	32	desires	desire	VBZ
8691	2594	33	to	to	TO
8691	2594	34	make	make	VB
8691	2594	35	a	a	DT
8691	2594	36	statement	statement	NN
8691	2594	37	,	,	,
8691	2594	38	telling	tell	VBG
8691	2594	39	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2594	40	at	at	IN
8691	2594	41	the	the	DT
8691	2594	42	same	same	JJ
8691	2594	43	time	time	NN
8691	2594	44	that	that	WDT
8691	2594	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2594	46	can	can	MD
8691	2594	47	decline	decline	VB
8691	2594	48	if	if	IN
8691	2594	49	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2594	50	chooses	choose	VBZ
8691	2594	51	.	.	.
8691	2595	1	Should	Should	MD
8691	2595	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2595	3	then	then	RB
8691	2595	4	make	make	VB
8691	2595	5	one	one	CD
8691	2595	6	,	,	,
8691	2595	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2595	8	should	should	MD
8691	2595	9	be	be	VB
8691	2595	10	written	write	VBN
8691	2595	11	down	down	RP
8691	2595	12	at	at	IN
8691	2595	13	length	length	NN
8691	2595	14	in	in	IN
8691	2595	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2595	16	own	own	JJ
8691	2595	17	words	word	NNS
8691	2595	18	,	,	,
8691	2595	19	read	read	VB
8691	2595	20	over	over	RP
8691	2595	21	to	to	IN
8691	2595	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2595	23	for	for	IN
8691	2595	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2595	25	assent	assent	NN
8691	2595	26	or	or	CC
8691	2595	27	correction	correction	NN
8691	2595	28	,	,	,
8691	2595	29	and	and	CC
8691	2595	30	properly	properly	RB
8691	2595	31	attested	attest	VBN
8691	2595	32	.	.	.
8691	2596	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	2596	2	a	a	DT
8691	2596	3	guilty	guilty	JJ
8691	2596	4	man	man	NN
8691	2596	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2596	6	now	now	RB
8691	2596	7	acquitted	acquit	VBN
8691	2596	8	whose	whose	WP$
8691	2596	9	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	2596	10	could	could	MD
8691	2596	11	have	have	VB
8691	2596	12	been	be	VBN
8691	2596	13	secured	secure	VBN
8691	2596	14	on	on	IN
8691	2596	15	what	what	WP
8691	2596	16	such	such	PDT
8691	2596	17	a	a	DT
8691	2596	18	paper	paper	NN
8691	2596	19	would	would	MD
8691	2596	20	have	have	VB
8691	2596	21	disclosed	disclose	VBN
8691	2596	22	or	or	CC
8691	2596	23	have	have	VB
8691	2596	24	given	give	VBN
8691	2596	25	a	a	DT
8691	2596	26	clue	clue	NN
8691	2596	27	to	to	IN
8691	2596	28	ascertaining	ascertaining	NN
8691	2596	29	.	.	.
8691	2597	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	2597	2	an	an	DT
8691	2597	3	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	2597	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2597	5	long	long	RB
8691	2597	6	been	be	VBN
8691	2597	7	the	the	DT
8691	2597	8	English	english	JJ
8691	2597	9	practice	practice	NN
8691	2597	10	.	.	.
8691	2598	1	The	the	DT
8691	2598	2	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	2598	3	before	before	IN
8691	2598	4	the	the	DT
8691	2598	5	committing	commit	VBG
8691	2598	6	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2598	7	,	,	,
8691	2598	8	if	if	IN
8691	2598	9	any	any	DT
8691	2598	10	contest	contest	NN
8691	2598	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2598	12	made	make	VBN
8691	2598	13	,	,	,
8691	2598	14	generally	generally	RB
8691	2598	15	does	do	VBZ
8691	2598	16	not	not	RB
8691	2598	17	take	take	VB
8691	2598	18	place	place	NN
8691	2598	19	until	until	IN
8691	2598	20	some	some	DT
8691	2598	21	time	time	NN
8691	2598	22	after	after	IN
8691	2598	23	the	the	DT
8691	2598	24	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2598	25	.	.	.
8691	2599	1	Each	each	DT
8691	2599	2	party	party	NN
8691	2599	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2599	4	apt	apt	JJ
8691	2599	5	to	to	TO
8691	2599	6	wish	wish	VB
8691	2599	7	time	time	NN
8691	2599	8	to	to	TO
8691	2599	9	prepare	prepare	VB
8691	2599	10	for	for	IN
8691	2599	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2599	12	.	.	.
8691	2600	1	Meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
8691	2600	2	,	,	,
8691	2600	3	the	the	DT
8691	2600	4	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2600	5	can	can	MD
8691	2600	6	generally	generally	RB
8691	2600	7	claim	claim	VB
8691	2600	8	the	the	DT
8691	2600	9	privilege	privilege	NN
8691	2600	10	of	of	IN
8691	2600	11	release	release	NN
8691	2600	12	on	on	IN
8691	2600	13	bail	bail	NN
8691	2600	14	,	,	,
8691	2600	15	unless	unless	IN
8691	2600	16	the	the	DT
8691	2600	17	crime	crime	NN
8691	2600	18	be	be	VBP
8691	2600	19	capital	capital	NN
8691	2600	20	and	and	CC
8691	2600	21	the	the	DT
8691	2600	22	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	2600	23	strongly	strongly	RB
8691	2600	24	point	point	VBP
8691	2600	25	to	to	IN
8691	2600	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2600	27	guilt	guilt	NN
8691	2600	28	.	.	.
8691	2601	1	Here	here	RB
8691	2601	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2601	3	practice	practice	NN
8691	2601	4	differs	differ	VBZ
8691	2601	5	from	from	IN
8691	2601	6	that	that	DT
8691	2601	7	of	of	IN
8691	2601	8	an	an	DT
8691	2601	9	English	english	JJ
8691	2601	10	court	court	NN
8691	2601	11	of	of	IN
8691	2601	12	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	2601	13	.	.	.
8691	2602	1	While	while	IN
8691	2602	2	there	there	EX
8691	2602	3	bail	bail	NN
8691	2602	4	must	must	MD
8691	2602	5	be	be	VB
8691	2602	6	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2602	7	in	in	IN
8691	2602	8	case	case	NN
8691	2602	9	of	of	IN
8691	2602	10	misdemeanors	misdemeanor	NNS
8691	2602	11	and	and	CC
8691	2602	12	may	may	MD
8691	2602	13	be	be	VB
8691	2602	14	in	in	IN
8691	2602	15	case	case	NN
8691	2602	16	of	of	IN
8691	2602	17	felonies	felony	NNS
8691	2602	18	;	;	:
8691	2602	19	the	the	DT
8691	2602	20	amount	amount	NN
8691	2602	21	required	require	VBN
8691	2602	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	2602	23	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	2602	24	so	so	RB
8691	2602	25	large	large	JJ
8691	2602	26	as	as	IN
8691	2602	27	to	to	TO
8691	2602	28	be	be	VB
8691	2602	29	prohibitory	prohibitory	JJ
8691	2602	30	.	.	.
8691	2603	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2603	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2603	3	:	:	:
8691	2603	4	Maitland	Maitland	NNP
8691	2603	5	,	,	,
8691	2603	6	"	"	''
8691	2603	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2603	8	and	and	CC
8691	2603	9	Police	Police	NNPS
8691	2603	10	,	,	,
8691	2603	11	"	"	''
8691	2603	12	131	131	CD
8691	2603	13	.	.	.
8691	2603	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2604	1	The	the	DT
8691	2604	2	essence	essence	NN
8691	2604	3	of	of	IN
8691	2604	4	bail	bail	NN
8691	2604	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2604	6	that	that	IN
8691	2604	7	the	the	DT
8691	2604	8	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	2604	9	should	should	MD
8691	2604	10	enter	enter	VB
8691	2604	11	into	into	IN
8691	2604	12	an	an	DT
8691	2604	13	obligation	obligation	NN
8691	2604	14	,	,	,
8691	2604	15	together	together	RB
8691	2604	16	with	with	IN
8691	2604	17	one	one	CD
8691	2604	18	or	or	CC
8691	2604	19	more	more	JJR
8691	2604	20	others	other	NNS
8691	2604	21	of	of	IN
8691	2604	22	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
8691	2604	23	responsibility	responsibility	NN
8691	2604	24	as	as	IN
8691	2604	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2604	26	sureties	surety	NNS
8691	2604	27	,	,	,
8691	2604	28	to	to	TO
8691	2604	29	appear	appear	VB
8691	2604	30	whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	2604	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2604	32	may	may	MD
8691	2604	33	be	be	VB
8691	2604	34	called	call	VBN
8691	2604	35	for	for	IN
8691	2604	36	in	in	IN
8691	2604	37	the	the	DT
8691	2604	38	course	course	NN
8691	2604	39	of	of	IN
8691	2604	40	the	the	DT
8691	2604	41	pending	pende	VBG
8691	2604	42	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	2604	43	,	,	,
8691	2604	44	on	on	IN
8691	2604	45	pain	pain	NN
8691	2604	46	of	of	IN
8691	2604	47	forfeiting	forfeit	VBG
8691	2604	48	a	a	DT
8691	2604	49	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2604	50	sum	sum	NN
8691	2604	51	of	of	IN
8691	2604	52	money	money	NN
8691	2604	53	.	.	.
8691	2605	1	All	all	DT
8691	2605	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2605	3	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	2605	4	forbid	forbid	VBP
8691	2605	5	the	the	DT
8691	2605	6	taking	taking	NN
8691	2605	7	of	of	IN
8691	2605	8	excessive	excessive	JJ
8691	2605	9	bail	bail	NN
8691	2605	10	.	.	.
8691	2606	1	The	the	DT
8691	2606	2	sum	sum	NN
8691	2606	3	should	should	MD
8691	2606	4	be	be	VB
8691	2606	5	large	large	JJ
8691	2606	6	enough	enough	RB
8691	2606	7	to	to	TO
8691	2606	8	give	give	VB
8691	2606	9	a	a	DT
8691	2606	10	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	2606	11	assurance	assurance	NN
8691	2606	12	that	that	IN
8691	2606	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2606	14	will	will	MD
8691	2606	15	not	not	RB
8691	2606	16	allow	allow	VB
8691	2606	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2606	18	to	to	TO
8691	2606	19	be	be	VB
8691	2606	20	forfeited	forfeit	VBN
8691	2606	21	.	.	.
8691	2607	1	In	in	IN
8691	2607	2	fixing	fix	VBG
8691	2607	3	the	the	DT
8691	2607	4	amount	amount	NN
8691	2607	5	,	,	,
8691	2607	6	which	which	WDT
8691	2607	7	in	in	IN
8691	2607	8	each	each	DT
8691	2607	9	case	case	NN
8691	2607	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2607	11	left	leave	VBN
8691	2607	12	to	to	IN
8691	2607	13	the	the	DT
8691	2607	14	good	good	JJ
8691	2607	15	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2607	16	of	of	IN
8691	2607	17	the	the	DT
8691	2607	18	officer	officer	NN
8691	2607	19	before	before	IN
8691	2607	20	whom	whom	WP
8691	2607	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2607	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	2607	23	taken	take	VBN
8691	2607	24	,	,	,
8691	2607	25	special	special	JJ
8691	2607	26	regard	regard	NN
8691	2607	27	should	should	MD
8691	2607	28	be	be	VB
8691	2607	29	had	have	VBN
8691	2607	30	to	to	IN
8691	2607	31	the	the	DT
8691	2607	32	gravity	gravity	NN
8691	2607	33	of	of	IN
8691	2607	34	the	the	DT
8691	2607	35	offense	offense	NN
8691	2607	36	,	,	,
8691	2607	37	the	the	DT
8691	2607	38	nature	nature	NN
8691	2607	39	of	of	IN
8691	2607	40	the	the	DT
8691	2607	41	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	2607	42	in	in	IN
8691	2607	43	case	case	NN
8691	2607	44	of	of	IN
8691	2607	45	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	2607	46	,	,	,
8691	2607	47	and	and	CC
8691	2607	48	the	the	DT
8691	2607	49	means	mean	NNS
8691	2607	50	of	of	IN
8691	2607	51	the	the	DT
8691	2607	52	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2607	53	or	or	CC
8691	2607	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2607	55	friends	friend	NNS
8691	2607	56	.	.	.
8691	2608	1	If	if	IN
8691	2608	2	too	too	RB
8691	2608	3	large	large	JJ
8691	2608	4	an	an	DT
8691	2608	5	amount	amount	NN
8691	2608	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2608	7	demanded	demand	VBN
8691	2608	8	,	,	,
8691	2608	9	the	the	DT
8691	2608	10	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2608	11	can	can	MD
8691	2608	12	get	get	VB
8691	2608	13	relief	relief	NN
8691	2608	14	on	on	IN
8691	2608	15	a	a	DT
8691	2608	16	writ	writ	NN
8691	2608	17	of	of	IN
8691	2608	18	_	_	NNP
8691	2608	19	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	2608	20	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	2608	21	_	_	NNP
8691	2608	22	issued	issue	VBN
8691	2608	23	by	by	IN
8691	2608	24	some	some	DT
8691	2608	25	superior	superior	JJ
8691	2608	26	judge	judge	NN
8691	2608	27	.	.	.
8691	2609	1	This	this	DT
8691	2609	2	privilege	privilege	NN
8691	2609	3	of	of	IN
8691	2609	4	bail	bail	NN
8691	2609	5	in	in	IN
8691	2609	6	most	most	JJS
8691	2609	7	States	States	NNP
8691	2609	8	extends	extend	VBZ
8691	2609	9	to	to	IN
8691	2609	10	,	,	,
8691	2609	11	or	or	CC
8691	2609	12	at	at	IN
8691	2609	13	the	the	DT
8691	2609	14	discretion	discretion	NN
8691	2609	15	of	of	IN
8691	2609	16	the	the	DT
8691	2609	17	court	court	NN
8691	2609	18	may	may	MD
8691	2609	19	be	be	VB
8691	2609	20	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2609	21	at	at	IN
8691	2609	22	,	,	,
8691	2609	23	any	any	DT
8691	2609	24	stage	stage	NN
8691	2609	25	of	of	IN
8691	2609	26	a	a	DT
8691	2609	27	cause	cause	NN
8691	2609	28	,	,	,
8691	2609	29	not	not	RB
8691	2609	30	capital	capital	NN
8691	2609	31	,	,	,
8691	2609	32	even	even	RB
8691	2609	33	after	after	IN
8691	2609	34	a	a	DT
8691	2609	35	final	final	JJ
8691	2609	36	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2609	37	and	and	CC
8691	2609	38	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2609	39	,	,	,
8691	2609	40	provided	provide	VBD
8691	2609	41	an	an	DT
8691	2609	42	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2609	43	has	have	VBZ
8691	2609	44	been	be	VBN
8691	2609	45	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2609	46	with	with	IN
8691	2609	47	a	a	DT
8691	2609	48	stay	stay	NN
8691	2609	49	of	of	IN
8691	2609	50	execution	execution	NN
8691	2609	51	.	.	.
8691	2610	1	Bail	Bail	NNP
8691	2610	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2610	3	given	give	VBN
8691	2610	4	orally	orally	RB
8691	2610	5	or	or	CC
8691	2610	6	in	in	IN
8691	2610	7	writing	writing	NN
8691	2610	8	,	,	,
8691	2610	9	according	accord	VBG
8691	2610	10	to	to	IN
8691	2610	11	the	the	DT
8691	2610	12	practice	practice	NN
8691	2610	13	of	of	IN
8691	2610	14	the	the	DT
8691	2610	15	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2610	16	State	State	NNP
8691	2610	17	.	.	.
8691	2611	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2611	2	given	give	VBN
8691	2611	3	orally	orally	RB
8691	2611	4	,	,	,
8691	2611	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2611	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2611	7	termed	term	VBN
8691	2611	8	a	a	DT
8691	2611	9	recognizance	recognizance	NN
8691	2611	10	.	.	.
8691	2612	1	This	this	DT
8691	2612	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2612	3	entered	enter	VBN
8691	2612	4	into	into	IN
8691	2612	5	by	by	IN
8691	2612	6	the	the	DT
8691	2612	7	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2612	8	appearance	appearance	NN
8691	2612	9	of	of	IN
8691	2612	10	those	those	DT
8691	2612	11	who	who	WP
8691	2612	12	are	be	VBP
8691	2612	13	to	to	TO
8691	2612	14	assume	assume	VB
8691	2612	15	the	the	DT
8691	2612	16	obligation	obligation	NN
8691	2612	17	before	before	IN
8691	2612	18	a	a	DT
8691	2612	19	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2612	20	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2612	21	or	or	CC
8691	2612	22	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	2612	23	of	of	IN
8691	2612	24	court	court	NN
8691	2612	25	,	,	,
8691	2612	26	and	and	CC
8691	2612	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2612	28	due	due	JJ
8691	2612	29	acknowledgment	acknowledgment	NN
8691	2612	30	before	before	IN
8691	2612	31	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2612	32	that	that	IN
8691	2612	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2612	34	do	do	VBP
8691	2612	35	assume	assume	VB
8691	2612	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2612	37	.	.	.
8691	2613	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2613	2	makes	make	VBZ
8691	2613	3	a	a	DT
8691	2613	4	brief	brief	JJ
8691	2613	5	minute	minute	NN
8691	2613	6	of	of	IN
8691	2613	7	the	the	DT
8691	2613	8	fact	fact	NN
8691	2613	9	at	at	IN
8691	2613	10	the	the	DT
8691	2613	11	time	time	NN
8691	2613	12	,	,	,
8691	2613	13	from	from	IN
8691	2613	14	which	which	WDT
8691	2613	15	at	at	IN
8691	2613	16	any	any	DT
8691	2613	17	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	2613	18	time	time	NN
8691	2613	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2613	20	can	can	MD
8691	2613	21	make	make	VB
8691	2613	22	up	up	RP
8691	2613	23	a	a	DT
8691	2613	24	full	full	JJ
8691	2613	25	record	record	NN
8691	2613	26	in	in	IN
8691	2613	27	due	due	JJ
8691	2613	28	form	form	NN
8691	2613	29	.	.	.
8691	2614	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2614	2	bail	bail	NN
8691	2614	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2614	4	given	give	VBN
8691	2614	5	in	in	IN
8691	2614	6	writing	writing	NN
8691	2614	7	,	,	,
8691	2614	8	the	the	DT
8691	2614	9	obligation	obligation	NN
8691	2614	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2614	11	prepared	prepare	VBN
8691	2614	12	in	in	IN
8691	2614	13	behalf	behalf	NN
8691	2614	14	of	of	IN
8691	2614	15	the	the	DT
8691	2614	16	government	government	NN
8691	2614	17	and	and	CC
8691	2614	18	executed	execute	VBN
8691	2614	19	by	by	IN
8691	2614	20	the	the	DT
8691	2614	21	parties	party	NNS
8691	2614	22	to	to	IN
8691	2614	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2614	24	.	.	.
8691	2615	1	Whoever	whoever	WP
8691	2615	2	gives	give	VBZ
8691	2615	3	bail	bail	NN
8691	2615	4	as	as	IN
8691	2615	5	surety	surety	NN
8691	2615	6	for	for	IN
8691	2615	7	another	another	DT
8691	2615	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2615	9	by	by	IN
8691	2615	10	that	that	DT
8691	2615	11	very	very	JJ
8691	2615	12	fact	fact	NN
8691	2615	13	given	give	VBN
8691	2615	14	a	a	DT
8691	2615	15	kind	kind	NN
8691	2615	16	of	of	IN
8691	2615	17	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2615	18	control	control	NN
8691	2615	19	over	over	IN
8691	2615	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2615	21	.	.	.
8691	2616	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2616	2	can	can	MD
8691	2616	3	take	take	VB
8691	2616	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2616	5	into	into	IN
8691	2616	6	actual	actual	JJ
8691	2616	7	manual	manual	JJ
8691	2616	8	custody	custody	NN
8691	2616	9	without	without	IN
8691	2616	10	any	any	DT
8691	2616	11	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2616	12	,	,	,
8691	2616	13	and	and	CC
8691	2616	14	against	against	IN
8691	2616	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2616	16	will	will	NN
8691	2616	17	,	,	,
8691	2616	18	for	for	IN
8691	2616	19	the	the	DT
8691	2616	20	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2616	21	of	of	IN
8691	2616	22	returning	return	VBG
8691	2616	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2616	24	to	to	IN
8691	2616	25	court	court	NN
8691	2616	26	and	and	CC
8691	2616	27	surrendering	surrender	VBG
8691	2616	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2616	29	to	to	IN
8691	2616	30	the	the	DT
8691	2616	31	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	2616	32	.	.	.
8691	2617	1	This	this	DT
8691	2617	2	right	right	NN
8691	2617	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2617	4	a	a	DT
8691	2617	5	common	common	JJ
8691	2617	6	law	law	NN
8691	2617	7	right	right	RB
8691	2617	8	,	,	,
8691	2617	9	arising	arise	VBG
8691	2617	10	from	from	IN
8691	2617	11	the	the	DT
8691	2617	12	contract	contract	NN
8691	2617	13	of	of	IN
8691	2617	14	suretyship	suretyship	NN
8691	2617	15	,	,	,
8691	2617	16	and	and	CC
8691	2617	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	2617	18	not	not	RB
8691	2617	19	bounded	bound	VBN
8691	2617	20	by	by	IN
8691	2617	21	State	state	NN
8691	2617	22	lines	line	NNS
8691	2617	23	.	.	.
8691	2618	1	If	if	IN
8691	2618	2	the	the	DT
8691	2618	3	principal	principal	NN
8691	2618	4	absconds	abscond	VBZ
8691	2618	5	from	from	IN
8691	2618	6	the	the	DT
8691	2618	7	State	State	NNP
8691	2618	8	,	,	,
8691	2618	9	the	the	DT
8691	2618	10	surety	surety	NN
8691	2618	11	can	can	MD
8691	2618	12	have	have	VB
8691	2618	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2618	14	followed	follow	VBN
8691	2618	15	and	and	CC
8691	2618	16	brought	bring	VBD
8691	2618	17	back	back	RB
8691	2618	18	without	without	IN
8691	2618	19	any	any	DT
8691	2618	20	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2618	21	of	of	IN
8691	2618	22	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2618	23	.	.	.
8691	2619	1	The	the	DT
8691	2619	2	amount	amount	NN
8691	2619	3	of	of	IN
8691	2619	4	the	the	DT
8691	2619	5	bail	bail	NN
8691	2619	6	,	,	,
8691	2619	7	should	should	MD
8691	2619	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2619	9	be	be	VB
8691	2619	10	forfeited	forfeit	VBN
8691	2619	11	,	,	,
8691	2619	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2619	13	payable	payable	JJ
8691	2619	14	either	either	CC
8691	2619	15	to	to	IN
8691	2619	16	the	the	DT
8691	2619	17	government	government	NN
8691	2619	18	or	or	CC
8691	2619	19	to	to	IN
8691	2619	20	some	some	DT
8691	2619	21	other	other	JJ
8691	2619	22	representative	representative	NN
8691	2619	23	of	of	IN
8691	2619	24	the	the	DT
8691	2619	25	public	public	JJ
8691	2619	26	interests	interest	NNS
8691	2619	27	,	,	,
8691	2619	28	as	as	IN
8691	2619	29	may	may	MD
8691	2619	30	be	be	VB
8691	2619	31	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
8691	2619	32	by	by	IN
8691	2619	33	statute	statute	NN
8691	2619	34	.	.	.
8691	2620	1	If	if	IN
8691	2620	2	the	the	DT
8691	2620	3	sureties	surety	NNS
8691	2620	4	have	have	VBP
8691	2620	5	any	any	DT
8691	2620	6	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	2620	7	claim	claim	NN
8691	2620	8	to	to	IN
8691	2620	9	relief	relief	NN
8691	2620	10	by	by	IN
8691	2620	11	a	a	DT
8691	2620	12	reduction	reduction	NN
8691	2620	13	of	of	IN
8691	2620	14	the	the	DT
8691	2620	15	amount	amount	NN
8691	2620	16	,	,	,
8691	2620	17	there	there	EX
8691	2620	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	2620	19	often	often	RB
8691	2620	20	given	give	VBN
8691	2620	21	by	by	IN
8691	2620	22	statute	statute	NN
8691	2620	23	or	or	CC
8691	2620	24	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2620	25	practice	practice	NN
8691	2620	26	a	a	DT
8691	2620	27	right	right	NN
8691	2620	28	to	to	IN
8691	2620	29	the	the	DT
8691	2620	30	court	court	NN
8691	2620	31	in	in	IN
8691	2620	32	which	which	WDT
8691	2620	33	the	the	DT
8691	2620	34	obligation	obligation	NN
8691	2620	35	was	be	VBD
8691	2620	36	given	give	VBN
8691	2620	37	or	or	CC
8691	2620	38	before	before	IN
8691	2620	39	which	which	WDT
8691	2620	40	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2620	41	enforcement	enforcement	NN
8691	2620	42	is	be	VBZ
8691	2620	43	sought	seek	VBN
8691	2620	44	to	to	TO
8691	2620	45	grant	grant	VB
8691	2620	46	a	a	DT
8691	2620	47	reduction	reduction	NN
8691	2620	48	from	from	IN
8691	2620	49	the	the	DT
8691	2620	50	sum	sum	NN
8691	2620	51	which	which	WDT
8691	2620	52	would	would	MD
8691	2620	53	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	2620	54	be	be	VB
8691	2620	55	due	due	JJ
8691	2620	56	upon	upon	IN
8691	2620	57	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2620	58	.	.	.
8691	2621	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2621	2	a	a	DT
8691	2621	3	committing	commit	VBG
8691	2621	4	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2621	5	requires	require	VBZ
8691	2621	6	the	the	DT
8691	2621	7	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2621	8	to	to	TO
8691	2621	9	give	give	VB
8691	2621	10	bail	bail	NN
8691	2621	11	to	to	TO
8691	2621	12	appear	appear	VB
8691	2621	13	in	in	IN
8691	2621	14	a	a	DT
8691	2621	15	higher	high	JJR
8691	2621	16	court	court	NN
8691	2621	17	,	,	,
8691	2621	18	and	and	CC
8691	2621	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2621	20	does	do	VBZ
8691	2621	21	not	not	RB
8691	2621	22	give	give	VB
8691	2621	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2621	24	,	,	,
8691	2621	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2621	26	will	will	MD
8691	2621	27	be	be	VB
8691	2621	28	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2621	29	to	to	IN
8691	2621	30	jail	jail	NN
8691	2621	31	to	to	TO
8691	2621	32	await	await	VB
8691	2621	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2621	34	trial	trial	NN
8691	2621	35	there	there	RB
8691	2621	36	.	.	.
8691	2622	1	In	in	IN
8691	2622	2	this	this	DT
8691	2622	3	court	court	NN
8691	2622	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2622	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2622	6	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2622	7	tried	try	VBN
8691	2622	8	on	on	IN
8691	2622	9	the	the	DT
8691	2622	10	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	2622	11	upon	upon	IN
8691	2622	12	which	which	WDT
8691	2622	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2622	14	was	be	VBD
8691	2622	15	originally	originally	RB
8691	2622	16	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	2622	17	:	:	:
8691	2622	18	oftener	oftener	VB
8691	2622	19	a	a	DT
8691	2622	20	new	new	JJ
8691	2622	21	accusation	accusation	NN
8691	2622	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	2622	23	prepared	prepare	VBN
8691	2622	24	.	.	.
8691	2623	1	This	this	DT
8691	2623	2	may	may	MD
8691	2623	3	be	be	VB
8691	2623	4	either	either	CC
8691	2623	5	an	an	DT
8691	2623	6	information	information	NN
8691	2623	7	or	or	CC
8691	2623	8	an	an	DT
8691	2623	9	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2623	10	.	.	.
8691	2624	1	At	at	IN
8691	2624	2	common	common	JJ
8691	2624	3	law	law	NN
8691	2624	4	,	,	,
8691	2624	5	no	no	DT
8691	2624	6	one	one	PRP
8691	2624	7	could	could	MD
8691	2624	8	be	be	VB
8691	2624	9	tried	try	VBN
8691	2624	10	for	for	IN
8691	2624	11	a	a	DT
8691	2624	12	felony	felony	NN
8691	2624	13	unless	unless	IN
8691	2624	14	a	a	DT
8691	2624	15	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2624	16	jury	jury	NN
8691	2624	17	were	be	VBD
8691	2624	18	first	first	RB
8691	2624	19	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
8691	2624	20	that	that	IN
8691	2624	21	there	there	EX
8691	2624	22	was	be	VBD
8691	2624	23	good	good	JJ
8691	2624	24	ground	ground	NN
8691	2624	25	for	for	IN
8691	2624	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2624	27	.	.	.
8691	2625	1	The	the	DT
8691	2625	2	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2625	3	jury	jury	NN
8691	2625	4	consisted	consist	VBD
8691	2625	5	of	of	IN
8691	2625	6	not	not	RB
8691	2625	7	more	more	JJR
8691	2625	8	than	than	IN
8691	2625	9	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	2625	10	-	-	HYPH
8691	2625	11	four	four	CD
8691	2625	12	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
8691	2625	13	of	of	IN
8691	2625	14	the	the	DT
8691	2625	15	county	county	NN
8691	2625	16	,	,	,
8691	2625	17	and	and	CC
8691	2625	18	in	in	IN
8691	2625	19	practice	practice	NN
8691	2625	20	never	never	RB
8691	2625	21	of	of	IN
8691	2625	22	more	more	JJR
8691	2625	23	than	than	IN
8691	2625	24	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	2625	25	-	-	HYPH
8691	2625	26	three	three	CD
8691	2625	27	,	,	,
8691	2625	28	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	2625	29	for	for	IN
8691	2625	30	that	that	DT
8691	2625	31	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2625	32	to	to	TO
8691	2625	33	attend	attend	VB
8691	2625	34	at	at	IN
8691	2625	35	the	the	DT
8691	2625	36	opening	opening	NN
8691	2625	37	of	of	IN
8691	2625	38	a	a	DT
8691	2625	39	term	term	NN
8691	2625	40	of	of	IN
8691	2625	41	court	court	NN
8691	2625	42	.	.	.
8691	2626	1	To	to	TO
8691	2626	2	authorize	authorize	VB
8691	2626	3	a	a	DT
8691	2626	4	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	2626	5	the	the	DT
8691	2626	6	assent	assent	NN
8691	2626	7	of	of	IN
8691	2626	8	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	2626	9	of	of	IN
8691	2626	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2626	11	was	be	VBD
8691	2626	12	required	require	VBN
8691	2626	13	.	.	.
8691	2627	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2627	2	heard	hear	VBD
8691	2627	3	only	only	RB
8691	2627	4	the	the	DT
8691	2627	5	case	case	NN
8691	2627	6	for	for	IN
8691	2627	7	the	the	DT
8691	2627	8	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	2627	9	,	,	,
8691	2627	10	and	and	CC
8691	2627	11	heard	hear	VBD
8691	2627	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2627	13	in	in	IN
8691	2627	14	secret	secret	NN
8691	2627	15	,	,	,
8691	2627	16	after	after	IN
8691	2627	17	having	have	VBG
8691	2627	18	been	be	VBN
8691	2627	19	publicly	publicly	RB
8691	2627	20	charged	charge	VBN
8691	2627	21	by	by	IN
8691	2627	22	the	the	DT
8691	2627	23	court	court	NN
8691	2627	24	as	as	IN
8691	2627	25	to	to	IN
8691	2627	26	the	the	DT
8691	2627	27	nature	nature	NN
8691	2627	28	of	of	IN
8691	2627	29	the	the	DT
8691	2627	30	business	business	NN
8691	2627	31	which	which	WDT
8691	2627	32	would	would	MD
8691	2627	33	be	be	VB
8691	2627	34	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2627	35	before	before	IN
8691	2627	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2627	37	.	.	.
8691	2628	1	The	the	DT
8691	2628	2	court	court	NN
8691	2628	3	appointed	appoint	VBD
8691	2628	4	one	one	CD
8691	2628	5	of	of	IN
8691	2628	6	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2628	7	to	to	TO
8691	2628	8	act	act	VB
8691	2628	9	as	as	IN
8691	2628	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2628	11	foreman	foreman	NN
8691	2628	12	,	,	,
8691	2628	13	and	and	CC
8691	2628	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2628	15	reported	report	VBD
8691	2628	16	back	back	RP
8691	2628	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2628	18	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2628	19	in	in	IN
8691	2628	20	writing	writing	NN
8691	2628	21	,	,	,
8691	2628	22	and	and	CC
8691	2628	23	in	in	IN
8691	2628	24	one	one	CD
8691	2628	25	or	or	CC
8691	2628	26	the	the	DT
8691	2628	27	other	other	JJ
8691	2628	28	of	of	IN
8691	2628	29	two	two	CD
8691	2628	30	forms	form	NNS
8691	2628	31	--	--	:
8691	2628	32	by	by	IN
8691	2628	33	presentment	presentment	NN
8691	2628	34	or	or	CC
8691	2628	35	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2628	36	.	.	.
8691	2629	1	A	a	DT
8691	2629	2	presentment	presentment	NN
8691	2629	3	was	be	VBD
8691	2629	4	a	a	DT
8691	2629	5	presentation	presentation	NN
8691	2629	6	,	,	,
8691	2629	7	on	on	IN
8691	2629	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2629	9	own	own	JJ
8691	2629	10	motion	motion	NN
8691	2629	11	,	,	,
8691	2629	12	of	of	IN
8691	2629	13	an	an	DT
8691	2629	14	accusation	accusation	NN
8691	2629	15	against	against	IN
8691	2629	16	one	one	CD
8691	2629	17	or	or	CC
8691	2629	18	more	more	JJR
8691	2629	19	persons	person	NNS
8691	2629	20	.	.	.
8691	2630	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2630	2	were	be	VBD
8691	2630	3	the	the	DT
8691	2630	4	official	official	JJ
8691	2630	5	representatives	representative	NNS
8691	2630	6	of	of	IN
8691	2630	7	the	the	DT
8691	2630	8	public	public	NN
8691	2630	9	before	before	IN
8691	2630	10	the	the	DT
8691	2630	11	court	court	NN
8691	2630	12	,	,	,
8691	2630	13	and	and	CC
8691	2630	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2630	15	might	may	MD
8691	2630	16	well	well	RB
8691	2630	17	be	be	VB
8691	2630	18	that	that	IN
8691	2630	19	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	2630	20	had	have	VBD
8691	2630	21	occurred	occur	VBN
8691	2630	22	,	,	,
8691	2630	23	and	and	CC
8691	2630	24	become	become	VBP
8691	2630	25	matters	matter	NNS
8691	2630	26	of	of	IN
8691	2630	27	common	common	JJ
8691	2630	28	notoriety	notoriety	NN
8691	2630	29	,	,	,
8691	2630	30	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2630	31	for	for	IN
8691	2630	32	which	which	WDT
8691	2630	33	no	no	DT
8691	2630	34	one	one	NN
8691	2630	35	cared	care	VBD
8691	2630	36	or	or	CC
8691	2630	37	dared	dare	VBD
8691	2630	38	to	to	TO
8691	2630	39	bring	bring	VB
8691	2630	40	.	.	.
8691	2631	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	2631	2	a	a	DT
8691	2631	3	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	2631	4	was	be	VBD
8691	2631	5	comparatively	comparatively	RB
8691	2631	6	rare	rare	JJ
8691	2631	7	.	.	.
8691	2632	1	The	the	DT
8691	2632	2	common	common	JJ
8691	2632	3	course	course	NN
8691	2632	4	was	be	VBD
8691	2632	5	to	to	TO
8691	2632	6	pass	pass	VB
8691	2632	7	only	only	RB
8691	2632	8	on	on	IN
8691	2632	9	such	such	JJ
8691	2632	10	written	written	JJ
8691	2632	11	accusations	accusation	NNS
8691	2632	12	as	as	IN
8691	2632	13	others	other	NNS
8691	2632	14	might	may	MD
8691	2632	15	submit	submit	VB
8691	2632	16	to	to	IN
8691	2632	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2632	18	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	2632	19	.	.	.
8691	2633	1	These	these	DT
8691	2633	2	were	be	VBD
8691	2633	3	called	call	VBN
8691	2633	4	bills	bill	NNS
8691	2633	5	of	of	IN
8691	2633	6	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2633	7	.	.	.
8691	2634	1	If	if	IN
8691	2634	2	the	the	DT
8691	2634	3	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2634	4	jury	jury	NN
8691	2634	5	believed	believe	VBD
8691	2634	6	that	that	IN
8691	2634	7	there	there	EX
8691	2634	8	were	be	VBD
8691	2634	9	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	2634	10	grounds	ground	NNS
8691	2634	11	for	for	IN
8691	2634	12	upholding	uphold	VBG
8691	2634	13	any	any	DT
8691	2634	14	of	of	IN
8691	2634	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2634	16	,	,	,
8691	2634	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2634	18	foreman	foreman	NN
8691	2634	19	endorsed	endorse	VBD
8691	2634	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2634	21	as	as	IN
8691	2634	22	"	"	``
8691	2634	23	A	a	DT
8691	2634	24	true	true	JJ
8691	2634	25	bill	bill	NN
8691	2634	26	,	,	,
8691	2634	27	"	"	''
8691	2634	28	and	and	CC
8691	2634	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2634	30	then	then	RB
8691	2634	31	became	become	VBD
8691	2634	32	an	an	DT
8691	2634	33	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2634	34	.	.	.
8691	2635	1	If	if	IN
8691	2635	2	,	,	,
8691	2635	3	on	on	IN
8691	2635	4	the	the	DT
8691	2635	5	other	other	JJ
8691	2635	6	hand	hand	NN
8691	2635	7	,	,	,
8691	2635	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2635	9	rejected	reject	VBD
8691	2635	10	a	a	DT
8691	2635	11	bill	bill	NN
8691	2635	12	of	of	IN
8691	2635	13	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2635	14	as	as	IN
8691	2635	15	unfounded	unfounded	JJ
8691	2635	16	,	,	,
8691	2635	17	the	the	DT
8691	2635	18	foreman	foreman	NN
8691	2635	19	indorsed	indorse	VBD
8691	2635	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2635	21	as	as	IN
8691	2635	22	"	"	``
8691	2635	23	Not	not	RB
8691	2635	24	a	a	DT
8691	2635	25	true	true	JJ
8691	2635	26	bill	bill	NN
8691	2635	27	,	,	,
8691	2635	28	"	"	''
8691	2635	29	or	or	CC
8691	2635	30	with	with	IN
8691	2635	31	the	the	DT
8691	2635	32	Latin	latin	JJ
8691	2635	33	term	term	NN
8691	2635	34	"	"	``
8691	2635	35	_	_	NNP
8691	2635	36	Ignoramus	Ignoramus	NNP
8691	2635	37	_	_	NNP
8691	2635	38	,	,	,
8691	2635	39	"	"	''
8691	2635	40	and	and	CC
8691	2635	41	this	this	DT
8691	2635	42	was	be	VBD
8691	2635	43	the	the	DT
8691	2635	44	end	end	NN
8691	2635	45	of	of	IN
8691	2635	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2635	47	.	.	.
8691	2636	1	The	the	DT
8691	2636	2	organization	organization	NN
8691	2636	3	and	and	CC
8691	2636	4	functions	function	NNS
8691	2636	5	of	of	IN
8691	2636	6	the	the	DT
8691	2636	7	American	american	JJ
8691	2636	8	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2636	9	jury	jury	NN
8691	2636	10	are	be	VBP
8691	2636	11	similar	similar	JJ
8691	2636	12	,	,	,
8691	2636	13	except	except	IN
8691	2636	14	that	that	IN
8691	2636	15	here	here	RB
8691	2636	16	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2636	17	have	have	VBP
8691	2636	18	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
8691	2636	19	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	2636	20	to	to	TO
8691	2636	21	procure	procure	VB
8691	2636	22	the	the	DT
8691	2636	23	presence	presence	NN
8691	2636	24	of	of	IN
8691	2636	25	the	the	DT
8691	2636	26	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2636	27	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	2636	28	and	and	CC
8691	2636	29	direct	direct	VB
8691	2636	30	the	the	DT
8691	2636	31	course	course	NN
8691	2636	32	of	of	IN
8691	2636	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2636	34	examination	examination	NN
8691	2636	35	.	.	.
8691	2637	1	In	in	IN
8691	2637	2	the	the	DT
8691	2637	3	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	2637	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	2637	5	almost	almost	RB
8691	2637	6	all	all	DT
8691	2637	7	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2637	8	accusations	accusation	NNS
8691	2637	9	,	,	,
8691	2637	10	great	great	JJ
8691	2637	11	or	or	CC
8691	2637	12	small	small	JJ
8691	2637	13	,	,	,
8691	2637	14	are	be	VBP
8691	2637	15	,	,	,
8691	2637	16	and	and	CC
8691	2637	17	by	by	IN
8691	2637	18	the	the	DT
8691	2637	19	fifth	fifth	JJ
8691	2637	20	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	2637	21	to	to	IN
8691	2637	22	the	the	DT
8691	2637	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2637	24	of	of	IN
8691	2637	25	the	the	DT
8691	2637	26	United	United	NNP
8691	2637	27	States	States	NNP
8691	2637	28	all	all	DT
8691	2637	29	charges	charge	NNS
8691	2637	30	of	of	IN
8691	2637	31	infamous	infamous	JJ
8691	2637	32	crimes	crime	NNS
8691	2637	33	must	must	MD
8691	2637	34	be	be	VB
8691	2637	35	,	,	,
8691	2637	36	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
8691	2637	37	by	by	IN
8691	2637	38	presentment	presentment	NN
8691	2637	39	or	or	CC
8691	2637	40	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2637	41	.	.	.
8691	2638	1	In	in	IN
8691	2638	2	most	most	JJS
8691	2638	3	of	of	IN
8691	2638	4	the	the	DT
8691	2638	5	States	States	NNPS
8691	2638	6	the	the	DT
8691	2638	7	intervention	intervention	NN
8691	2638	8	of	of	IN
8691	2638	9	a	a	DT
8691	2638	10	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2638	11	jury	jury	NN
8691	2638	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2638	13	requisite	requisite	JJ
8691	2638	14	only	only	RB
8691	2638	15	in	in	IN
8691	2638	16	case	case	NN
8691	2638	17	of	of	IN
8691	2638	18	serious	serious	JJ
8691	2638	19	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	2638	20	;	;	:
8691	2638	21	in	in	IN
8691	2638	22	some	some	DT
8691	2638	23	only	only	RB
8691	2638	24	in	in	IN
8691	2638	25	capital	capital	NN
8691	2638	26	cases	case	NNS
8691	2638	27	.	.	.
8691	2639	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2639	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2639	3	obvious	obvious	JJ
8691	2639	4	that	that	IN
8691	2639	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2639	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2639	7	less	less	RBR
8691	2639	8	needed	need	VBN
8691	2639	9	here	here	RB
8691	2639	10	than	than	IN
8691	2639	11	in	in	IN
8691	2639	12	England	England	NNP
8691	2639	13	,	,	,
8691	2639	14	since	since	IN
8691	2639	15	here	here	RB
8691	2639	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2639	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	2639	18	not	not	RB
8691	2639	19	within	within	IN
8691	2639	20	the	the	DT
8691	2639	21	power	power	NN
8691	2639	22	of	of	IN
8691	2639	23	any	any	DT
8691	2639	24	private	private	JJ
8691	2639	25	individual	individual	NN
8691	2639	26	to	to	IN
8691	2639	27	institute	institute	VB
8691	2639	28	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2639	29	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2639	30	against	against	IN
8691	2639	31	another	another	DT
8691	2639	32	at	at	IN
8691	2639	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2639	34	own	own	JJ
8691	2639	35	will	will	NN
8691	2639	36	,	,	,
8691	2639	37	but	but	CC
8691	2639	38	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2639	39	are	be	VBP
8691	2639	40	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2639	41	by	by	IN
8691	2639	42	a	a	DT
8691	2639	43	public	public	JJ
8691	2639	44	officer	officer	NN
8691	2639	45	commissioned	commission	VBN
8691	2639	46	for	for	IN
8691	2639	47	that	that	DT
8691	2639	48	very	very	JJ
8691	2639	49	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2639	50	and	and	CC
8691	2639	51	acting	act	VBG
8691	2639	52	under	under	IN
8691	2639	53	the	the	DT
8691	2639	54	grave	grave	JJ
8691	2639	55	sense	sense	NN
8691	2639	56	of	of	IN
8691	2639	57	responsibility	responsibility	NN
8691	2639	58	which	which	WDT
8691	2639	59	such	such	JJ
8691	2639	60	authority	authority	NN
8691	2639	61	is	be	VBZ
8691	2639	62	quite	quite	RB
8691	2639	63	sure	sure	JJ
8691	2639	64	to	to	TO
8691	2639	65	carry	carry	VB
8691	2639	66	with	with	IN
8691	2639	67	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2639	68	.	.	.
8691	2640	1	The	the	DT
8691	2640	2	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2640	3	jury	jury	NN
8691	2640	4	,	,	,
8691	2640	5	however	however	RB
8691	2640	6	,	,	,
8691	2640	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	2640	8	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2640	9	plain	plain	JJ
8691	2640	10	uses	use	NNS
8691	2640	11	wherever	wherever	WRB
8691	2640	12	political	political	JJ
8691	2640	13	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	2640	14	leads	lead	NNS
8691	2640	15	to	to	IN
8691	2640	16	public	public	JJ
8691	2640	17	disorder	disorder	NN
8691	2640	18	.	.	.
8691	2641	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2641	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	2641	3	also	also	RB
8691	2641	4	,	,	,
8691	2641	5	since	since	IN
8691	2641	6	the	the	DT
8691	2641	7	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	2641	8	War	War	NNP
8691	2641	9	,	,	,
8691	2641	10	been	be	VBN
8691	2641	11	found	find	VBN
8691	2641	12	an	an	DT
8691	2641	13	effective	effective	JJ
8691	2641	14	restraint	restraint	NN
8691	2641	15	in	in	IN
8691	2641	16	some	some	DT
8691	2641	17	of	of	IN
8691	2641	18	the	the	DT
8691	2641	19	Southern	Southern	NNP
8691	2641	20	States	States	NNPS
8691	2641	21	,	,	,
8691	2641	22	whether	whether	IN
8691	2641	23	for	for	IN
8691	2641	24	good	good	JJ
8691	2641	25	or	or	CC
8691	2641	26	ill	ill	JJ
8691	2641	27	,	,	,
8691	2641	28	upon	upon	IN
8691	2641	29	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2641	30	for	for	IN
8691	2641	31	violations	violation	NNS
8691	2641	32	of	of	IN
8691	2641	33	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2641	34	laws	law	NNS
8691	2641	35	of	of	IN
8691	2641	36	the	the	DT
8691	2641	37	United	United	NNP
8691	2641	38	States	States	NNP
8691	2641	39	,	,	,
8691	2641	40	brought	bring	VBD
8691	2641	41	against	against	IN
8691	2641	42	members	member	NNS
8691	2641	43	of	of	IN
8691	2641	44	a	a	DT
8691	2641	45	community	community	NN
8691	2641	46	in	in	IN
8691	2641	47	which	which	WDT
8691	2641	48	those	those	DT
8691	2641	49	laws	law	NNS
8691	2641	50	were	be	VBD
8691	2641	51	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	2641	52	with	with	IN
8691	2641	53	general	general	JJ
8691	2641	54	disfavor	disfavor	NN
8691	2641	55	.	.	.
8691	2642	1	Prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2642	2	by	by	IN
8691	2642	3	information	information	NN
8691	2642	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2642	5	those	those	DT
8691	2642	6	not	not	RB
8691	2642	7	founded	found	VBN
8691	2642	8	on	on	IN
8691	2642	9	a	a	DT
8691	2642	10	presentment	presentment	NN
8691	2642	11	or	or	CC
8691	2642	12	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2642	13	.	.	.
8691	2643	1	The	the	DT
8691	2643	2	information	information	NN
8691	2643	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2643	4	a	a	DT
8691	2643	5	written	write	VBN
8691	2643	6	accusation	accusation	NN
8691	2643	7	filed	file	VBN
8691	2643	8	in	in	IN
8691	2643	9	court	court	NN
8691	2643	10	by	by	IN
8691	2643	11	the	the	DT
8691	2643	12	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
8691	2643	13	officer	officer	NN
8691	2643	14	.	.	.
8691	2644	1	In	in	IN
8691	2644	2	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2644	3	classes	class	NNS
8691	2644	4	of	of	IN
8691	2644	5	cases	case	NNS
8691	2644	6	,	,	,
8691	2644	7	the	the	DT
8691	2644	8	leave	leave	NN
8691	2644	9	of	of	IN
8691	2644	10	the	the	DT
8691	2644	11	court	court	NN
8691	2644	12	must	must	MD
8691	2644	13	be	be	VB
8691	2644	14	first	first	RB
8691	2644	15	asked	ask	VBN
8691	2644	16	in	in	IN
8691	2644	17	some	some	DT
8691	2644	18	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
8691	2644	19	.	.	.
8691	2645	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2645	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2645	3	not	not	RB
8691	2645	4	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2645	5	that	that	IN
8691	2645	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2645	7	be	be	VB
8691	2645	8	supported	support	VBN
8691	2645	9	by	by	IN
8691	2645	10	any	any	DT
8691	2645	11	previous	previous	JJ
8691	2645	12	statement	statement	NN
8691	2645	13	or	or	CC
8691	2645	14	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	2645	15	under	under	IN
8691	2645	16	oath	oath	NN
8691	2645	17	.	.	.
8691	2646	1	The	the	DT
8691	2646	2	officer	officer	NN
8691	2646	3	who	who	WP
8691	2646	4	prepares	prepare	VBZ
8691	2646	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2646	6	acts	act	VBZ
8691	2646	7	under	under	IN
8691	2646	8	an	an	DT
8691	2646	9	oath	oath	NN
8691	2646	10	of	of	IN
8691	2646	11	office	office	NN
8691	2646	12	,	,	,
8691	2646	13	and	and	CC
8691	2646	14	that	that	DT
8691	2646	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	2646	16	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	2646	17	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	2646	18	to	to	TO
8691	2646	19	give	give	VB
8691	2646	20	probability	probability	NN
8691	2646	21	to	to	IN
8691	2646	22	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	2646	23	charges	charge	NNS
8691	2646	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2646	25	may	may	MD
8691	2646	26	make	make	VB
8691	2646	27	.	.	.
8691	2647	1	If	if	IN
8691	2647	2	the	the	DT
8691	2647	3	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2647	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2647	5	already	already	RB
8691	2647	6	been	be	VBN
8691	2647	7	bound	bind	VBN
8691	2647	8	over	over	RP
8691	2647	9	by	by	IN
8691	2647	10	a	a	DT
8691	2647	11	committing	commit	VBG
8691	2647	12	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2647	13	,	,	,
8691	2647	14	such	such	PDT
8691	2647	15	an	an	DT
8691	2647	16	information	information	NN
8691	2647	17	may	may	MD
8691	2647	18	take	take	VB
8691	2647	19	the	the	DT
8691	2647	20	place	place	NN
8691	2647	21	of	of	IN
8691	2647	22	the	the	DT
8691	2647	23	original	original	JJ
8691	2647	24	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	2647	25	on	on	IN
8691	2647	26	which	which	WDT
8691	2647	27	the	the	DT
8691	2647	28	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2647	29	was	be	VBD
8691	2647	30	made	make	VBN
8691	2647	31	.	.	.
8691	2648	1	If	if	IN
8691	2648	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2648	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	2648	4	not	not	RB
8691	2648	5	yet	yet	RB
8691	2648	6	been	be	VBN
8691	2648	7	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	2648	8	,	,	,
8691	2648	9	or	or	CC
8691	2648	10	if	if	IN
8691	2648	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2648	12	was	be	VBD
8691	2648	13	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	2648	14	and	and	CC
8691	2648	15	discharged	discharge	VBN
8691	2648	16	by	by	IN
8691	2648	17	such	such	PDT
8691	2648	18	a	a	DT
8691	2648	19	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2648	20	,	,	,
8691	2648	21	the	the	DT
8691	2648	22	filing	filing	NN
8691	2648	23	of	of	IN
8691	2648	24	an	an	DT
8691	2648	25	information	information	NN
8691	2648	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	2648	27	accompanied	accompany	VBN
8691	2648	28	by	by	IN
8691	2648	29	a	a	DT
8691	2648	30	request	request	NN
8691	2648	31	for	for	IN
8691	2648	32	the	the	DT
8691	2648	33	issue	issue	NN
8691	2648	34	of	of	IN
8691	2648	35	a	a	DT
8691	2648	36	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2648	37	for	for	IN
8691	2648	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2648	39	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2648	40	from	from	IN
8691	2648	41	the	the	DT
8691	2648	42	court	court	NN
8691	2648	43	.	.	.
8691	2649	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	2649	2	a	a	DT
8691	2649	3	paper	paper	NN
8691	2649	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2649	5	called	call	VBN
8691	2649	6	a	a	DT
8691	2649	7	bench	bench	NN
8691	2649	8	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2649	9	,	,	,
8691	2649	10	and	and	CC
8691	2649	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2649	12	granted	grant	VBN
8691	2649	13	whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	2649	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2649	15	,	,	,
8691	2649	16	whether	whether	IN
8691	2649	17	upon	upon	IN
8691	2649	18	a	a	DT
8691	2649	19	presentment	presentment	NN
8691	2649	20	,	,	,
8691	2649	21	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2649	22	,	,	,
8691	2649	23	or	or	CC
8691	2649	24	information	information	NN
8691	2649	25	.	.	.
8691	2650	1	An	an	DT
8691	2650	2	information	information	NN
8691	2650	3	may	may	MD
8691	2650	4	be	be	VB
8691	2650	5	amended	amend	VBN
8691	2650	6	by	by	IN
8691	2650	7	leave	leave	NN
8691	2650	8	of	of	IN
8691	2650	9	the	the	DT
8691	2650	10	court	court	NN
8691	2650	11	at	at	IN
8691	2650	12	any	any	DT
8691	2650	13	time	time	NN
8691	2650	14	.	.	.
8691	2651	1	A	a	DT
8691	2651	2	presentment	presentment	NN
8691	2651	3	or	or	CC
8691	2651	4	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2651	5	can	can	MD
8691	2651	6	not	not	RB
8691	2651	7	be	be	VB
8691	2651	8	.	.	.
8691	2652	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2652	2	,	,	,
8691	2652	3	when	when	WRB
8691	2652	4	returned	return	VBD
8691	2652	5	to	to	IN
8691	2652	6	court	court	NN
8691	2652	7	,	,	,
8691	2652	8	are	be	VBP
8691	2652	9	the	the	DT
8691	2652	10	work	work	NN
8691	2652	11	of	of	IN
8691	2652	12	the	the	DT
8691	2652	13	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2652	14	jury	jury	NN
8691	2652	15	,	,	,
8691	2652	16	and	and	CC
8691	2652	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2652	18	end	end	VBP
8691	2652	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2652	20	work	work	NN
8691	2652	21	.	.	.
8691	2653	1	An	an	DT
8691	2653	2	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	2653	3	of	of	IN
8691	2653	4	a	a	DT
8691	2653	5	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2653	6	process	process	NN
8691	2653	7	can	can	MD
8691	2653	8	logically	logically	RB
8691	2653	9	be	be	VB
8691	2653	10	made	make	VBN
8691	2653	11	only	only	RB
8691	2653	12	by	by	IN
8691	2653	13	the	the	DT
8691	2653	14	hand	hand	NN
8691	2653	15	which	which	WDT
8691	2653	16	originally	originally	RB
8691	2653	17	prepared	prepare	VBD
8691	2653	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2653	19	.	.	.
8691	2654	1	This	this	DT
8691	2654	2	rule	rule	NN
8691	2654	3	leads	lead	VBZ
8691	2654	4	to	to	IN
8691	2654	5	the	the	DT
8691	2654	6	escape	escape	NN
8691	2654	7	of	of	IN
8691	2654	8	many	many	JJ
8691	2654	9	a	a	DT
8691	2654	10	criminal	criminal	NN
8691	2654	11	.	.	.
8691	2655	1	If	if	IN
8691	2655	2	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
8691	2655	3	by	by	IN
8691	2655	4	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2655	5	,	,	,
8691	2655	6	the	the	DT
8691	2655	7	case	case	NN
8691	2655	8	against	against	IN
8691	2655	9	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2655	10	must	must	MD
8691	2655	11	be	be	VB
8691	2655	12	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	2655	13	proved	prove	VBN
8691	2655	14	--	--	:
8691	2655	15	in	in	IN
8691	2655	16	whole	whole	JJ
8691	2655	17	or	or	CC
8691	2655	18	part	part	NN
8691	2655	19	--	--	:
8691	2655	20	as	as	IN
8691	2655	21	there	there	RB
8691	2655	22	stated	state	VBN
8691	2655	23	,	,	,
8691	2655	24	or	or	CC
8691	2655	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2655	26	goes	go	VBZ
8691	2655	27	free	free	JJ
8691	2655	28	.	.	.
8691	2656	1	Prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
8691	2656	2	officers	officer	NNS
8691	2656	3	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	2656	4	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	2656	5	prefer	prefer	VBP
8691	2656	6	to	to	TO
8691	2656	7	proceed	proceed	VB
8691	2656	8	upon	upon	IN
8691	2656	9	information	information	NN
8691	2656	10	whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	2656	11	the	the	DT
8691	2656	12	law	law	NN
8691	2656	13	permits	permit	VBZ
8691	2656	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2656	15	.	.	.
8691	2657	1	The	the	DT
8691	2657	2	intervention	intervention	NN
8691	2657	3	of	of	IN
8691	2657	4	a	a	DT
8691	2657	5	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2657	6	jury	jury	NN
8691	2657	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2657	8	also	also	RB
8691	2657	9	often	often	RB
8691	2657	10	the	the	DT
8691	2657	11	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2657	12	cause	cause	NN
8691	2657	13	of	of	IN
8691	2657	14	a	a	DT
8691	2657	15	delay	delay	NN
8691	2657	16	alike	alike	RB
8691	2657	17	prejudicial	prejudicial	NN
8691	2657	18	to	to	IN
8691	2657	19	the	the	DT
8691	2657	20	State	State	NNP
8691	2657	21	and	and	CC
8691	2657	22	to	to	IN
8691	2657	23	the	the	DT
8691	2657	24	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	2657	25	.	.	.
8691	2658	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2658	2	can	can	MD
8691	2658	3	only	only	RB
8691	2658	4	be	be	VB
8691	2658	5	called	call	VBN
8691	2658	6	in	in	RP
8691	2658	7	when	when	WRB
8691	2658	8	a	a	DT
8691	2658	9	court	court	NN
8691	2658	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2658	11	in	in	IN
8691	2658	12	session	session	NN
8691	2658	13	,	,	,
8691	2658	14	by	by	IN
8691	2658	15	which	which	WDT
8691	2658	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2658	17	can	can	MD
8691	2658	18	be	be	VB
8691	2658	19	instructed	instruct	VBN
8691	2658	20	as	as	IN
8691	2658	21	to	to	IN
8691	2658	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2658	23	duties	duty	NNS
8691	2658	24	and	and	CC
8691	2658	25	to	to	TO
8691	2658	26	which	which	WDT
8691	2658	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2658	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	2658	29	to	to	TO
8691	2658	30	report	report	VB
8691	2658	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2658	32	doings	doing	NNS
8691	2658	33	.	.	.
8691	2659	1	Months	month	NNS
8691	2659	2	often	often	RB
8691	2659	3	elapse	elapse	VBP
8691	2659	4	in	in	RP
8691	2659	5	every	every	DT
8691	2659	6	year	year	NN
8691	2659	7	when	when	WRB
8691	2659	8	no	no	DT
8691	2659	9	such	such	JJ
8691	2659	10	court	court	NN
8691	2659	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2659	12	in	in	IN
8691	2659	13	session	session	NN
8691	2659	14	.	.	.
8691	2660	1	For	for	IN
8691	2660	2	this	this	DT
8691	2660	3	reason	reason	NN
8691	2660	4	,	,	,
8691	2660	5	in	in	IN
8691	2660	6	case	case	NN
8691	2660	7	of	of	IN
8691	2660	8	a	a	DT
8691	2660	9	poor	poor	JJ
8691	2660	10	man	man	NN
8691	2660	11	under	under	IN
8691	2660	12	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2660	13	on	on	IN
8691	2660	14	a	a	DT
8691	2660	15	charge	charge	NN
8691	2660	16	of	of	IN
8691	2660	17	crime	crime	NN
8691	2660	18	,	,	,
8691	2660	19	who	who	WP
8691	2660	20	can	can	MD
8691	2660	21	not	not	RB
8691	2660	22	furnish	furnish	VB
8691	2660	23	bail	bail	NN
8691	2660	24	,	,	,
8691	2660	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2660	26	would	would	MD
8691	2660	27	often	often	RB
8691	2660	28	be	be	VB
8691	2660	29	much	much	RB
8691	2660	30	better	well	JJR
8691	2660	31	for	for	IN
8691	2660	32	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2660	33	were	be	VBD
8691	2660	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2660	35	liability	liability	NN
8691	2660	36	to	to	TO
8691	2660	37	be	be	VB
8691	2660	38	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2660	39	to	to	IN
8691	2660	40	trial	trial	NN
8691	2660	41	to	to	TO
8691	2660	42	be	be	VB
8691	2660	43	settled	settle	VBN
8691	2660	44	promptly	promptly	RB
8691	2660	45	by	by	IN
8691	2660	46	a	a	DT
8691	2660	47	single	single	JJ
8691	2660	48	examining	examine	VBG
8691	2660	49	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2660	50	.	.	.
8691	2661	1	At	at	IN
8691	2661	2	the	the	DT
8691	2661	3	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	2661	4	in	in	IN
8691	2661	5	that	that	DT
8691	2661	6	case	case	NN
8691	2661	7	also	also	RB
8691	2661	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2661	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	2661	10	a	a	DT
8691	2661	11	right	right	NN
8691	2661	12	to	to	TO
8691	2661	13	be	be	VB
8691	2661	14	present	present	JJ
8691	2661	15	and	and	CC
8691	2661	16	to	to	TO
8691	2661	17	be	be	VB
8691	2661	18	heard	hear	VBN
8691	2661	19	.	.	.
8691	2662	1	Before	before	IN
8691	2662	2	a	a	DT
8691	2662	3	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2662	4	jury	jury	NN
8691	2662	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2662	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	2662	7	no	no	DT
8691	2662	8	such	such	JJ
8691	2662	9	right	right	RB
8691	2662	10	.	.	.
8691	2663	1	In	in	IN
8691	2663	2	most	most	JJS
8691	2663	3	States	States	NNPS
8691	2663	4	,	,	,
8691	2663	5	the	the	DT
8691	2663	6	great	great	JJ
8691	2663	7	majority	majority	NN
8691	2663	8	of	of	IN
8691	2663	9	indictments	indictment	NNS
8691	2663	10	are	be	VBP
8691	2663	11	against	against	IN
8691	2663	12	those	those	DT
8691	2663	13	who	who	WP
8691	2663	14	have	have	VBP
8691	2663	15	already	already	RB
8691	2663	16	been	be	VBN
8691	2663	17	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2663	18	on	on	IN
8691	2663	19	a	a	DT
8691	2663	20	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2663	21	's	's	POS
8691	2663	22	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	2663	23	to	to	TO
8691	2663	24	answer	answer	VB
8691	2663	25	to	to	IN
8691	2663	26	the	the	DT
8691	2663	27	charge	charge	NN
8691	2663	28	,	,	,
8691	2663	29	should	should	MD
8691	2663	30	an	an	DT
8691	2663	31	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2663	32	be	be	VB
8691	2663	33	found	find	VBN
8691	2663	34	.	.	.
8691	2664	1	The	the	DT
8691	2664	2	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2664	3	thus	thus	RB
8691	2664	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2664	5	two	two	CD
8691	2664	6	chances	chance	NNS
8691	2664	7	of	of	IN
8691	2664	8	escape	escape	NN
8691	2664	9	before	before	IN
8691	2664	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2664	11	can	can	MD
8691	2664	12	be	be	VB
8691	2664	13	put	put	VBN
8691	2664	14	on	on	IN
8691	2664	15	trial	trial	NN
8691	2664	16	for	for	IN
8691	2664	17	the	the	DT
8691	2664	18	charge	charge	NN
8691	2664	19	against	against	IN
8691	2664	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2664	21	:	:	:
8691	2664	22	one	one	CD
8691	2664	23	by	by	IN
8691	2664	24	a	a	DT
8691	2664	25	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	2664	26	ordered	order	VBN
8691	2664	27	by	by	IN
8691	2664	28	the	the	DT
8691	2664	29	committing	commit	VBG
8691	2664	30	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2664	31	,	,	,
8691	2664	32	and	and	CC
8691	2664	33	one	one	CD
8691	2664	34	by	by	IN
8691	2664	35	the	the	DT
8691	2664	36	refusal	refusal	NN
8691	2664	37	of	of	IN
8691	2664	38	the	the	DT
8691	2664	39	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2664	40	jury	jury	NN
8691	2664	41	to	to	TO
8691	2664	42	return	return	VB
8691	2664	43	"	"	``
8691	2664	44	a	a	DT
8691	2664	45	true	true	JJ
8691	2664	46	bill	bill	NN
8691	2664	47	.	.	.
8691	2664	48	"	"	''
8691	2665	1	A	a	DT
8691	2665	2	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2665	3	jury	jury	NN
8691	2665	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2665	5	more	more	RBR
8691	2665	6	apt	apt	JJ
8691	2665	7	to	to	TO
8691	2665	8	throw	throw	VB
8691	2665	9	out	out	RP
8691	2665	10	a	a	DT
8691	2665	11	charge	charge	NN
8691	2665	12	as	as	IN
8691	2665	13	groundless	groundless	JJ
8691	2665	14	than	than	IN
8691	2665	15	a	a	DT
8691	2665	16	single	single	JJ
8691	2665	17	magistrate	magistrate	NN
8691	2665	18	.	.	.
8691	2666	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2666	2	feels	feel	VBZ
8691	2666	3	the	the	DT
8691	2666	4	full	full	JJ
8691	2666	5	weight	weight	NN
8691	2666	6	of	of	IN
8691	2666	7	undivided	undivided	JJ
8691	2666	8	responsibility	responsibility	NN
8691	2666	9	.	.	.
8691	2667	1	If	if	IN
8691	2667	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2667	3	err	err	VBD
8691	2667	4	by	by	IN
8691	2667	5	discharging	discharge	VBG
8691	2667	6	the	the	DT
8691	2667	7	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	2667	8	,	,	,
8691	2667	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2667	10	knows	know	VBZ
8691	2667	11	that	that	IN
8691	2667	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2667	13	may	may	MD
8691	2667	14	let	let	VB
8691	2667	15	a	a	DT
8691	2667	16	guilty	guilty	JJ
8691	2667	17	man	man	NN
8691	2667	18	go	go	VB
8691	2667	19	free	free	JJ
8691	2667	20	,	,	,
8691	2667	21	untried	untried	JJ
8691	2667	22	.	.	.
8691	2668	1	If	if	IN
8691	2668	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2668	3	err	err	VBD
8691	2668	4	by	by	IN
8691	2668	5	committing	commit	VBG
8691	2668	6	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2668	7	for	for	IN
8691	2668	8	trial	trial	NN
8691	2668	9	,	,	,
8691	2668	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2668	11	knows	know	VBZ
8691	2668	12	that	that	IN
8691	2668	13	,	,	,
8691	2668	14	if	if	IN
8691	2668	15	innocent	innocent	JJ
8691	2668	16	,	,	,
8691	2668	17	the	the	DT
8691	2668	18	jury	jury	NN
8691	2668	19	are	be	VBP
8691	2668	20	quite	quite	RB
8691	2668	21	sure	sure	JJ
8691	2668	22	to	to	TO
8691	2668	23	acquit	acquit	VB
8691	2668	24	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2668	25	.	.	.
8691	2669	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2669	2	acts	act	VBZ
8691	2669	3	also	also	RB
8691	2669	4	in	in	IN
8691	2669	5	public	public	NN
8691	2669	6	.	.	.
8691	2670	1	The	the	DT
8691	2670	2	whole	whole	JJ
8691	2670	3	community	community	NN
8691	2670	4	knows	know	VBZ
8691	2670	5	or	or	CC
8691	2670	6	may	may	MD
8691	2670	7	know	know	VB
8691	2670	8	the	the	DT
8691	2670	9	proofs	proof	NNS
8691	2670	10	before	before	IN
8691	2670	11	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2670	12	,	,	,
8691	2670	13	and	and	CC
8691	2670	14	will	will	MD
8691	2670	15	hold	hold	VB
8691	2670	16	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2670	17	to	to	TO
8691	2670	18	account	account	VB
8691	2670	19	accordingly	accordingly	RB
8691	2670	20	.	.	.
8691	2671	1	On	on	IN
8691	2671	2	the	the	DT
8691	2671	3	other	other	JJ
8691	2671	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	2671	5	,	,	,
8691	2671	6	in	in	IN
8691	2671	7	the	the	DT
8691	2671	8	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2671	9	jury	jury	NN
8691	2671	10	room	room	NN
8691	2671	11	all	all	DT
8691	2671	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2671	13	secret	secret	JJ
8691	2671	14	.	.	.
8691	2672	1	The	the	DT
8691	2672	2	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
8691	2672	3	attorney	attorney	NN
8691	2672	4	,	,	,
8691	2672	5	if	if	IN
8691	2672	6	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	2672	7	,	,	,
8691	2672	8	does	do	VBZ
8691	2672	9	not	not	RB
8691	2672	10	remain	remain	VB
8691	2672	11	while	while	IN
8691	2672	12	the	the	DT
8691	2672	13	jurors	juror	NNS
8691	2672	14	are	be	VBP
8691	2672	15	deliberating	deliberate	VBG
8691	2672	16	over	over	IN
8691	2672	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2672	18	decision	decision	NN
8691	2672	19	.	.	.
8691	2673	1	No	no	DT
8691	2673	2	one	one	NN
8691	2673	3	outside	outside	NN
8691	2673	4	knows	know	VBZ
8691	2673	5	who	who	WP
8691	2673	6	may	may	MD
8691	2673	7	vote	vote	VB
8691	2673	8	for	for	IN
8691	2673	9	and	and	CC
8691	2673	10	who	who	WP
8691	2673	11	against	against	IN
8691	2673	12	the	the	DT
8691	2673	13	return	return	NN
8691	2673	14	of	of	IN
8691	2673	15	an	an	DT
8691	2673	16	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2673	17	.	.	.
8691	2674	1	Every	every	DT
8691	2674	2	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	2674	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2674	4	thus	thus	RB
8691	2674	5	afforded	afford	VBN
8691	2674	6	for	for	IN
8691	2674	7	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2674	8	friendship	friendship	NN
8691	2674	9	for	for	IN
8691	2674	10	the	the	DT
8691	2674	11	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2674	12	or	or	CC
8691	2674	13	business	business	NN
8691	2674	14	connection	connection	NN
8691	2674	15	with	with	IN
8691	2674	16	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2674	17	to	to	TO
8691	2674	18	have	have	VB
8691	2674	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2674	20	influence	influence	NN
8691	2674	21	.	.	.
8691	2675	1	Judges	judge	NNS
8691	2675	2	know	know	VBP
8691	2675	3	this	this	DT
8691	2675	4	,	,	,
8691	2675	5	and	and	CC
8691	2675	6	in	in	IN
8691	2675	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2675	8	charge	charge	NN
8691	2675	9	often	often	RB
8691	2675	10	emphasize	emphasize	VBP
8691	2675	11	the	the	DT
8691	2675	12	importance	importance	NN
8691	2675	13	and	and	CC
8691	2675	14	gravity	gravity	NN
8691	2675	15	of	of	IN
8691	2675	16	the	the	DT
8691	2675	17	duty	duty	NN
8691	2675	18	to	to	TO
8691	2675	19	be	be	VB
8691	2675	20	performed	perform	VBN
8691	2675	21	.	.	.
8691	2676	1	In	in	IN
8691	2676	2	1903	1903	CD
8691	2676	3	,	,	,
8691	2676	4	the	the	DT
8691	2676	5	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
8691	2676	6	officer	officer	NN
8691	2676	7	in	in	IN
8691	2676	8	one	one	CD
8691	2676	9	of	of	IN
8691	2676	10	the	the	DT
8691	2676	11	small	small	JJ
8691	2676	12	counties	county	NNS
8691	2676	13	in	in	IN
8691	2676	14	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	2676	15	had	have	VBD
8691	2676	16	prepared	prepare	VBN
8691	2676	17	indictments	indictment	NNS
8691	2676	18	against	against	IN
8691	2676	19	several	several	JJ
8691	2676	20	men	man	NNS
8691	2676	21	of	of	IN
8691	2676	22	some	some	DT
8691	2676	23	local	local	JJ
8691	2676	24	prominence	prominence	NN
8691	2676	25	for	for	IN
8691	2676	26	arson	arson	NN
8691	2676	27	and	and	CC
8691	2676	28	bribery	bribery	NN
8691	2676	29	.	.	.
8691	2677	1	A	a	DT
8691	2677	2	special	special	JJ
8691	2677	3	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2677	4	jury	jury	NN
8691	2677	5	was	be	VBD
8691	2677	6	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	2677	7	to	to	TO
8691	2677	8	act	act	VB
8691	2677	9	upon	upon	IN
8691	2677	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2677	11	.	.	.
8691	2678	1	There	there	EX
8691	2678	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2678	3	reason	reason	NN
8691	2678	4	to	to	TO
8691	2678	5	expect	expect	VB
8691	2678	6	some	some	DT
8691	2678	7	reluctance	reluctance	NN
8691	2678	8	on	on	IN
8691	2678	9	the	the	DT
8691	2678	10	part	part	NN
8691	2678	11	of	of	IN
8691	2678	12	several	several	JJ
8691	2678	13	.	.	.
8691	2679	1	Of	of	IN
8691	2679	2	the	the	DT
8691	2679	3	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	2679	4	for	for	IN
8691	2679	5	the	the	DT
8691	2679	6	State	State	NNP
8691	2679	7	some	some	DT
8691	2679	8	were	be	VBD
8691	2679	9	no	no	RB
8691	2679	10	less	less	RBR
8691	2679	11	reluctant	reluctant	JJ
8691	2679	12	.	.	.
8691	2680	1	There	there	EX
8691	2680	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2680	3	great	great	JJ
8691	2680	4	public	public	JJ
8691	2680	5	excitement	excitement	NN
8691	2680	6	in	in	IN
8691	2680	7	the	the	DT
8691	2680	8	court	court	NN
8691	2680	9	town	town	NN
8691	2680	10	.	.	.
8691	2681	1	One	one	CD
8691	2681	2	witness	witness	NN
8691	2681	3	came	come	VBD
8691	2681	4	there	there	RB
8691	2681	5	over	over	IN
8691	2681	6	ninety	ninety	CD
8691	2681	7	miles	mile	NNS
8691	2681	8	by	by	IN
8691	2681	9	rail	rail	NN
8691	2681	10	hidden	hide	VBN
8691	2681	11	,	,	,
8691	2681	12	for	for	IN
8691	2681	13	fear	fear	NN
8691	2681	14	of	of	IN
8691	2681	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2681	16	life	life	NN
8691	2681	17	,	,	,
8691	2681	18	in	in	IN
8691	2681	19	a	a	DT
8691	2681	20	closed	closed	JJ
8691	2681	21	chest	chest	NN
8691	2681	22	in	in	IN
8691	2681	23	the	the	DT
8691	2681	24	car	car	NN
8691	2681	25	of	of	IN
8691	2681	26	an	an	DT
8691	2681	27	express	express	JJ
8691	2681	28	company	company	NN
8691	2681	29	.	.	.
8691	2682	1	The	the	DT
8691	2682	2	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2682	3	jury	jury	NN
8691	2682	4	were	be	VBD
8691	2682	5	told	tell	VBN
8691	2682	6	by	by	IN
8691	2682	7	the	the	DT
8691	2682	8	court	court	NN
8691	2682	9	that	that	IN
8691	2682	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2682	11	must	must	MD
8691	2682	12	make	make	VB
8691	2682	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2682	14	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	2682	15	a	a	DT
8691	2682	16	thorough	thorough	JJ
8691	2682	17	one	one	NN
8691	2682	18	and	and	CC
8691	2682	19	indict	indict	NN
8691	2682	20	without	without	IN
8691	2682	21	fear	fear	NN
8691	2682	22	or	or	CC
8691	2682	23	favor	favor	VBP
8691	2682	24	every	every	DT
8691	2682	25	person	person	NN
8691	2682	26	in	in	IN
8691	2682	27	the	the	DT
8691	2682	28	county	county	NN
8691	2682	29	who	who	WP
8691	2682	30	ought	ought	MD
8691	2682	31	to	to	TO
8691	2682	32	be	be	VB
8691	2682	33	indicted	indict	VBN
8691	2682	34	.	.	.
8691	2683	1	"	"	``
8691	2683	2	If	if	IN
8691	2683	3	,	,	,
8691	2683	4	"	"	''
8691	2683	5	the	the	DT
8691	2683	6	judge	judge	NN
8691	2683	7	added	add	VBD
8691	2683	8	,	,	,
8691	2683	9	"	"	``
8691	2683	10	the	the	DT
8691	2683	11	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2683	12	calls	call	VBZ
8691	2683	13	for	for	IN
8691	2683	14	indictments	indictment	NNS
8691	2683	15	and	and	CC
8691	2683	16	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2683	17	do	do	VBP
8691	2683	18	n't	not	RB
8691	2683	19	make	make	VB
8691	2683	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2683	21	,	,	,
8691	2683	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2683	23	will	will	MD
8691	2683	24	be	be	VB
8691	2683	25	made	make	VBN
8691	2683	26	anyway	anyway	RB
8691	2683	27	.	.	.
8691	2684	1	If	if	IN
8691	2684	2	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2684	3	do	do	VBP
8691	2684	4	not	not	RB
8691	2684	5	do	do	VB
8691	2684	6	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2684	7	full	full	JJ
8691	2684	8	duty	duty	NN
8691	2684	9	,	,	,
8691	2684	10	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2684	11	will	will	MD
8691	2684	12	do	do	VB
8691	2684	13	mine	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2684	14	by	by	IN
8691	2684	15	assembling	assemble	VBG
8691	2684	16	another	another	DT
8691	2684	17	grand	grand	JJ
8691	2684	18	jury	jury	NN
8691	2684	19	.	.	.
8691	2684	20	"	"	''
8691	2685	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2685	2	did	do	VBD
8691	2685	3	theirs	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2685	4	under	under	IN
8691	2685	5	these	these	DT
8691	2685	6	stirring	stir	VBG
8691	2685	7	injunctions	injunction	NNS
8691	2685	8	,	,	,
8691	2685	9	and	and	CC
8691	2685	10	the	the	DT
8691	2685	11	indictments	indictment	NNS
8691	2685	12	were	be	VBD
8691	2685	13	promptly	promptly	RB
8691	2685	14	found	find	VBN
8691	2685	15	.	.	.
8691	2686	1	After	after	IN
8691	2686	2	the	the	DT
8691	2686	3	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2686	4	or	or	CC
8691	2686	5	information	information	NN
8691	2686	6	comes	come	VBZ
8691	2686	7	the	the	DT
8691	2686	8	arraignment	arraignment	NN
8691	2686	9	.	.	.
8691	2687	1	This	this	DT
8691	2687	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2687	3	bringing	bring	VBG
8691	2687	4	the	the	DT
8691	2687	5	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2687	6	before	before	IN
8691	2687	7	the	the	DT
8691	2687	8	court	court	NN
8691	2687	9	and	and	CC
8691	2687	10	,	,	,
8691	2687	11	after	after	IN
8691	2687	12	the	the	DT
8691	2687	13	charge	charge	NN
8691	2687	14	made	make	VBN
8691	2687	15	against	against	IN
8691	2687	16	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2687	17	has	have	VBZ
8691	2687	18	been	be	VBN
8691	2687	19	read	read	VBN
8691	2687	20	,	,	,
8691	2687	21	directing	direct	VBG
8691	2687	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2687	23	to	to	TO
8691	2687	24	plead	plead	VB
8691	2687	25	to	to	IN
8691	2687	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2687	27	.	.	.
8691	2688	1	Before	before	IN
8691	2688	2	the	the	DT
8691	2688	3	plea	plea	NN
8691	2688	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2688	5	entered	enter	VBN
8691	2688	6	,	,	,
8691	2688	7	if	if	IN
8691	2688	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2688	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	2688	10	no	no	DT
8691	2688	11	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2688	12	,	,	,
8691	2688	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2688	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	2688	15	asked	ask	VBN
8691	2688	16	if	if	IN
8691	2688	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2688	18	desires	desire	VBZ
8691	2688	19	the	the	DT
8691	2688	20	aid	aid	NN
8691	2688	21	of	of	IN
8691	2688	22	one	one	CD
8691	2688	23	,	,	,
8691	2688	24	and	and	CC
8691	2688	25	if	if	IN
8691	2688	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2688	27	responds	respond	VBZ
8691	2688	28	that	that	IN
8691	2688	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2688	30	does	do	VBZ
8691	2688	31	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2688	32	or	or	CC
8691	2688	33	should	should	MD
8691	2688	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2688	35	not	not	RB
8691	2688	36	,	,	,
8691	2688	37	if	if	IN
8691	2688	38	the	the	DT
8691	2688	39	court	court	NN
8691	2688	40	thinks	think	VBZ
8691	2688	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2688	42	ought	ought	MD
8691	2688	43	to	to	TO
8691	2688	44	have	have	VB
8691	2688	45	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2688	46	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2688	47	,	,	,
8691	2688	48	some	some	DT
8691	2688	49	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	2688	50	will	will	MD
8691	2688	51	be	be	VB
8691	2688	52	assigned	assign	VBN
8691	2688	53	to	to	IN
8691	2688	54	that	that	DT
8691	2688	55	duty	duty	NN
8691	2688	56	.	.	.
8691	2689	1	Some	some	DT
8691	2689	2	of	of	IN
8691	2689	3	the	the	DT
8691	2689	4	younger	young	JJR
8691	2689	5	members	member	NNS
8691	2689	6	of	of	IN
8691	2689	7	the	the	DT
8691	2689	8	bar	bar	NN
8691	2689	9	who	who	WP
8691	2689	10	are	be	VBP
8691	2689	11	present	present	JJ
8691	2689	12	are	be	VBP
8691	2689	13	generally	generally	RB
8691	2689	14	desirous	desirous	JJ
8691	2689	15	of	of	IN
8691	2689	16	being	be	VBG
8691	2689	17	so	so	RB
8691	2689	18	assigned	assign	VBN
8691	2689	19	to	to	TO
8691	2689	20	defend	defend	VB
8691	2689	21	those	those	DT
8691	2689	22	who	who	WP
8691	2689	23	have	have	VBP
8691	2689	24	no	no	DT
8691	2689	25	means	means	NN
8691	2689	26	to	to	TO
8691	2689	27	employ	employ	VB
8691	2689	28	such	such	JJ
8691	2689	29	assistance	assistance	NN
8691	2689	30	.	.	.
8691	2690	1	The	the	DT
8691	2690	2	court	court	NN
8691	2690	3	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2690	4	makes	make	VBZ
8691	2690	5	the	the	DT
8691	2690	6	assignment	assignment	NN
8691	2690	7	from	from	IN
8691	2690	8	among	among	IN
8691	2690	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2690	10	number	number	NN
8691	2690	11	,	,	,
8691	2690	12	but	but	CC
8691	2690	13	in	in	IN
8691	2690	14	grave	grave	JJ
8691	2690	15	cases	case	NNS
8691	2690	16	often	often	RB
8691	2690	17	appoints	appoint	VBZ
8691	2690	18	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2690	19	of	of	IN
8691	2690	20	greater	great	JJR
8691	2690	21	experience	experience	NN
8691	2690	22	and	and	CC
8691	2690	23	reputation	reputation	NN
8691	2690	24	.	.	.
8691	2691	1	No	no	DT
8691	2691	2	one	one	NN
8691	2691	3	who	who	WP
8691	2691	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2691	5	so	so	RB
8691	2691	6	assigned	assigned	JJ
8691	2691	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2691	8	at	at	IN
8691	2691	9	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	2691	10	to	to	TO
8691	2691	11	decline	decline	VB
8691	2691	12	without	without	IN
8691	2691	13	showing	show	VBG
8691	2691	14	good	good	JJ
8691	2691	15	cause	cause	NN
8691	2691	16	for	for	IN
8691	2691	17	excuse	excuse	NN
8691	2691	18	.	.	.
8691	2692	1	A	a	DT
8691	2692	2	small	small	JJ
8691	2692	3	fee	fee	NN
8691	2692	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2692	5	often	often	RB
8691	2692	6	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2692	7	by	by	IN
8691	2692	8	statute	statute	NN
8691	2692	9	in	in	IN
8691	2692	10	such	such	JJ
8691	2692	11	cases	case	NNS
8691	2692	12	from	from	IN
8691	2692	13	the	the	DT
8691	2692	14	public	public	JJ
8691	2692	15	treasury	treasury	NN
8691	2692	16	.	.	.
8691	2693	1	Statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2693	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2693	3	also	also	RB
8691	2693	4	common	common	JJ
8691	2693	5	providing	provide	VBG
8691	2693	6	that	that	IN
8691	2693	7	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	2693	8	for	for	IN
8691	2693	9	the	the	DT
8691	2693	10	defense	defense	NN
8691	2693	11	may	may	MD
8691	2693	12	be	be	VB
8691	2693	13	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	2693	14	at	at	IN
8691	2693	15	the	the	DT
8691	2693	16	cost	cost	NN
8691	2693	17	of	of	IN
8691	2693	18	the	the	DT
8691	2693	19	government	government	NN
8691	2693	20	,	,	,
8691	2693	21	if	if	IN
8691	2693	22	the	the	DT
8691	2693	23	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2693	24	satisfies	satisfy	VBZ
8691	2693	25	the	the	DT
8691	2693	26	court	court	NN
8691	2693	27	that	that	WDT
8691	2693	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2693	29	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	2693	30	will	will	MD
8691	2693	31	be	be	VB
8691	2693	32	material	material	NN
8691	2693	33	,	,	,
8691	2693	34	and	and	CC
8691	2693	35	that	that	IN
8691	2693	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2693	37	is	be	VBZ
8691	2693	38	unable	unable	JJ
8691	2693	39	to	to	TO
8691	2693	40	meet	meet	VB
8691	2693	41	this	this	DT
8691	2693	42	expense	expense	NN
8691	2693	43	.	.	.
8691	2694	1	In	in	IN
8691	2694	2	the	the	DT
8691	2694	3	federal	federal	JJ
8691	2694	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	2694	5	,	,	,
8691	2694	6	in	in	IN
8691	2694	7	capital	capital	NN
8691	2694	8	cases	case	NNS
8691	2694	9	,	,	,
8691	2694	10	the	the	DT
8691	2694	11	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2694	12	must	must	MD
8691	2694	13	be	be	VB
8691	2694	14	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	2694	15	with	with	IN
8691	2694	16	a	a	DT
8691	2694	17	copy	copy	NN
8691	2694	18	of	of	IN
8691	2694	19	the	the	DT
8691	2694	20	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2694	21	and	and	CC
8691	2694	22	a	a	DT
8691	2694	23	list	list	NN
8691	2694	24	of	of	IN
8691	2694	25	the	the	DT
8691	2694	26	jurors	juror	NNS
8691	2694	27	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	2694	28	to	to	IN
8691	2694	29	court	court	NN
8691	2694	30	and	and	CC
8691	2694	31	of	of	IN
8691	2694	32	the	the	DT
8691	2694	33	government	government	NN
8691	2694	34	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	2694	35	,	,	,
8691	2694	36	at	at	RB
8691	2694	37	least	least	RBS
8691	2694	38	two	two	CD
8691	2694	39	days	day	NNS
8691	2694	40	before	before	IN
8691	2694	41	the	the	DT
8691	2694	42	trial	trial	NN
8691	2694	43	.	.	.
8691	2695	1	Whether	whether	IN
8691	2695	2	impanelling	impanel	VBG
8691	2695	3	the	the	DT
8691	2695	4	jury	jury	NN
8691	2695	5	for	for	IN
8691	2695	6	the	the	DT
8691	2695	7	trial	trial	NN
8691	2695	8	of	of	IN
8691	2695	9	a	a	DT
8691	2695	10	case	case	NN
8691	2695	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2695	12	a	a	DT
8691	2695	13	long	long	JJ
8691	2695	14	or	or	CC
8691	2695	15	short	short	JJ
8691	2695	16	process	process	NN
8691	2695	17	will	will	MD
8691	2695	18	depend	depend	VB
8691	2695	19	largely	largely	RB
8691	2695	20	on	on	IN
8691	2695	21	the	the	DT
8691	2695	22	intelligence	intelligence	NN
8691	2695	23	and	and	CC
8691	2695	24	firmness	firmness	NN
8691	2695	25	of	of	IN
8691	2695	26	the	the	DT
8691	2695	27	judge	judge	NN
8691	2695	28	who	who	WP
8691	2695	29	holds	hold	VBZ
8691	2695	30	the	the	DT
8691	2695	31	court	court	NN
8691	2695	32	.	.	.
8691	2696	1	Each	each	DT
8691	2696	2	side	side	NN
8691	2696	3	can	can	MD
8691	2696	4	challenge	challenge	VB
8691	2696	5	a	a	DT
8691	2696	6	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2696	7	number	number	NN
8691	2696	8	of	of	IN
8691	2696	9	the	the	DT
8691	2696	10	jurors	juror	NNS
8691	2696	11	in	in	IN
8691	2696	12	attendance	attendance	NN
8691	2696	13	without	without	IN
8691	2696	14	stating	state	VBG
8691	2696	15	any	any	DT
8691	2696	16	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	2696	17	for	for	IN
8691	2696	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2696	19	,	,	,
8691	2696	20	as	as	RB
8691	2696	21	well	well	RB
8691	2696	22	as	as	IN
8691	2696	23	any	any	DT
8691	2696	24	and	and	CC
8691	2696	25	every	every	DT
8691	2696	26	one	one	CD
8691	2696	27	of	of	IN
8691	2696	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2696	29	for	for	IN
8691	2696	30	cause	cause	NN
8691	2696	31	shown	show	VBN
8691	2696	32	.	.	.
8691	2697	1	If	if	IN
8691	2697	2	a	a	DT
8691	2697	3	juror	juror	NN
8691	2697	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2697	5	formed	form	VBN
8691	2697	6	an	an	DT
8691	2697	7	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2697	8	as	as	IN
8691	2697	9	to	to	IN
8691	2697	10	the	the	DT
8691	2697	11	guilt	guilt	NN
8691	2697	12	of	of	IN
8691	2697	13	the	the	DT
8691	2697	14	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2697	15	so	so	RB
8691	2697	16	definite	definite	JJ
8691	2697	17	as	as	IN
8691	2697	18	to	to	TO
8691	2697	19	amount	amount	VB
8691	2697	20	to	to	IN
8691	2697	21	a	a	DT
8691	2697	22	settled	settled	JJ
8691	2697	23	prejudice	prejudice	NN
8691	2697	24	against	against	IN
8691	2697	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2697	26	,	,	,
8691	2697	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2697	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	2697	29	incompetent	incompetent	JJ
8691	2697	30	.	.	.
8691	2698	1	In	in	IN
8691	2698	2	grave	grave	JJ
8691	2698	3	cases	case	NNS
8691	2698	4	the	the	DT
8691	2698	5	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	2698	6	's	's	POS
8691	2698	7	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2698	8	will	will	MD
8691	2698	9	often	often	RB
8691	2698	10	seek	seek	VB
8691	2698	11	to	to	TO
8691	2698	12	examine	examine	VB
8691	2698	13	every	every	DT
8691	2698	14	juror	juror	NN
8691	2698	15	whose	whose	WP$
8691	2698	16	name	name	NN
8691	2698	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	2698	18	drawn	draw	VBN
8691	2698	19	at	at	IN
8691	2698	20	great	great	JJ
8691	2698	21	length	length	NN
8691	2698	22	as	as	IN
8691	2698	23	to	to	IN
8691	2698	24	whether	whether	IN
8691	2698	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2698	26	has	have	VBZ
8691	2698	27	such	such	PDT
8691	2698	28	an	an	DT
8691	2698	29	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2698	30	.	.	.
8691	2699	1	A	a	DT
8691	2699	2	capable	capable	JJ
8691	2699	3	judge	judge	NN
8691	2699	4	will	will	MD
8691	2699	5	keep	keep	VB
8691	2699	6	such	such	PDT
8691	2699	7	an	an	DT
8691	2699	8	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	2699	9	within	within	IN
8691	2699	10	close	close	JJ
8691	2699	11	limits	limit	NNS
8691	2699	12	.	.	.
8691	2700	1	In	in	IN
8691	2700	2	1824	1824	CD
8691	2700	3	,	,	,
8691	2700	4	an	an	DT
8691	2700	5	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	2700	6	for	for	IN
8691	2700	7	murder	murder	NN
8691	2700	8	was	be	VBD
8691	2700	9	found	find	VBN
8691	2700	10	in	in	IN
8691	2700	11	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	2700	12	against	against	IN
8691	2700	13	a	a	DT
8691	2700	14	son	son	NN
8691	2700	15	of	of	IN
8691	2700	16	the	the	DT
8691	2700	17	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	2700	18	.	.	.
8691	2701	1	The	the	DT
8691	2701	2	case	case	NN
8691	2701	3	was	be	VBD
8691	2701	4	one	one	CD
8691	2701	5	which	which	WDT
8691	2701	6	excited	excite	VBD
8691	2701	7	great	great	JJ
8691	2701	8	public	public	JJ
8691	2701	9	interest	interest	NN
8691	2701	10	,	,	,
8691	2701	11	and	and	CC
8691	2701	12	was	be	VBD
8691	2701	13	talked	talk	VBN
8691	2701	14	over	over	RP
8691	2701	15	from	from	IN
8691	2701	16	one	one	CD
8691	2701	17	end	end	NN
8691	2701	18	of	of	IN
8691	2701	19	the	the	DT
8691	2701	20	State	State	NNP
8691	2701	21	to	to	IN
8691	2701	22	the	the	DT
8691	2701	23	other	other	JJ
8691	2701	24	.	.	.
8691	2702	1	The	the	DT
8691	2702	2	result	result	NN
8691	2702	3	was	be	VBD
8691	2702	4	that	that	IN
8691	2702	5	when	when	WRB
8691	2702	6	the	the	DT
8691	2702	7	trial	trial	NN
8691	2702	8	came	come	VBD
8691	2702	9	on	on	IN
8691	2702	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2702	11	was	be	VBD
8691	2702	12	found	find	VBN
8691	2702	13	impossible	impossible	JJ
8691	2702	14	,	,	,
8691	2702	15	term	term	NN
8691	2702	16	after	after	IN
8691	2702	17	term	term	NN
8691	2702	18	,	,	,
8691	2702	19	to	to	TO
8691	2702	20	make	make	VB
8691	2702	21	up	up	RP
8691	2702	22	a	a	DT
8691	2702	23	jury	jury	NN
8691	2702	24	of	of	IN
8691	2702	25	men	man	NNS
8691	2702	26	who	who	WP
8691	2702	27	,	,	,
8691	2702	28	from	from	IN
8691	2702	29	what	what	WP
8691	2702	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2702	31	had	have	VBD
8691	2702	32	heard	hear	VBN
8691	2702	33	or	or	CC
8691	2702	34	read	read	VB
8691	2702	35	,	,	,
8691	2702	36	had	have	VBD
8691	2702	37	not	not	RB
8691	2702	38	formed	form	VBN
8691	2702	39	what	what	WP
8691	2702	40	the	the	DT
8691	2702	41	defense	defense	NN
8691	2702	42	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	2702	43	and	and	CC
8691	2702	44	the	the	DT
8691	2702	45	court	court	NN
8691	2702	46	thought	think	VBD
8691	2702	47	to	to	TO
8691	2702	48	be	be	VB
8691	2702	49	a	a	DT
8691	2702	50	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
8691	2702	51	firm	firm	JJ
8691	2702	52	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2702	53	as	as	IN
8691	2702	54	to	to	IN
8691	2702	55	the	the	DT
8691	2702	56	guilt	guilt	NN
8691	2702	57	or	or	CC
8691	2702	58	innocence	innocence	NN
8691	2702	59	of	of	IN
8691	2702	60	the	the	DT
8691	2702	61	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2702	62	to	to	TO
8691	2702	63	justify	justify	VB
8691	2702	64	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2702	65	exclusion	exclusion	NN
8691	2702	66	.	.	.
8691	2703	1	The	the	DT
8691	2703	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	2703	3	was	be	VBD
8691	2703	4	finally	finally	RB
8691	2703	5	appealed	appeal	VBN
8691	2703	6	to	to	IN
8691	2703	7	for	for	IN
8691	2703	8	relief	relief	NN
8691	2703	9	and	and	CC
8691	2703	10	passed	pass	VBD
8691	2703	11	a	a	DT
8691	2703	12	statute	statute	NN
8691	2703	13	that	that	IN
8691	2703	14	an	an	DT
8691	2703	15	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2703	16	formed	form	VBN
8691	2703	17	from	from	IN
8691	2703	18	mere	mere	JJ
8691	2703	19	rumor	rumor	NN
8691	2703	20	should	should	MD
8691	2703	21	not	not	RB
8691	2703	22	be	be	VB
8691	2703	23	a	a	DT
8691	2703	24	ground	ground	NN
8691	2703	25	of	of	IN
8691	2703	26	challenge	challenge	NN
8691	2703	27	.	.	.
8691	2704	1	The	the	DT
8691	2704	2	case	case	NN
8691	2704	3	was	be	VBD
8691	2704	4	then	then	RB
8691	2704	5	,	,	,
8691	2704	6	in	in	IN
8691	2704	7	1827	1827	CD
8691	2704	8	,	,	,
8691	2704	9	taken	take	VBN
8691	2704	10	up	up	RP
8691	2704	11	for	for	IN
8691	2704	12	the	the	DT
8691	2704	13	ninth	ninth	JJ
8691	2704	14	time	time	NN
8691	2704	15	,	,	,
8691	2704	16	but	but	CC
8691	2704	17	with	with	IN
8691	2704	18	the	the	DT
8691	2704	19	same	same	JJ
8691	2704	20	result	result	NN
8691	2704	21	,	,	,
8691	2704	22	whereupon	whereupon	IN
8691	2704	23	the	the	DT
8691	2704	24	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2704	25	's	's	POS
8691	2704	26	father	father	NN
8691	2704	27	gave	give	VBD
8691	2704	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2704	29	a	a	DT
8691	2704	30	pardon	pardon	NN
8691	2704	31	,	,	,
8691	2704	32	on	on	IN
8691	2704	33	the	the	DT
8691	2704	34	ground	ground	NN
8691	2704	35	that	that	IN
8691	2704	36	"	"	``
8691	2704	37	the	the	DT
8691	2704	38	prospect	prospect	NN
8691	2704	39	of	of	IN
8691	2704	40	obtaining	obtain	VBG
8691	2704	41	a	a	DT
8691	2704	42	jury	jury	NN
8691	2704	43	is	be	VBZ
8691	2704	44	entirely	entirely	RB
8691	2704	45	hopeless	hopeless	JJ
8691	2704	46	,	,	,
8691	2704	47	"	"	''
8691	2704	48	and	and	CC
8691	2704	49	that	that	IN
8691	2704	50	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2704	51	had	have	VBD
8691	2704	52	"	"	``
8691	2704	53	no	no	DT
8691	2704	54	doubt	doubt	NN
8691	2704	55	of	of	IN
8691	2704	56	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2704	57	being	be	VBG
8691	2704	58	innocent	innocent	JJ
8691	2704	59	of	of	IN
8691	2704	60	the	the	DT
8691	2704	61	foul	foul	JJ
8691	2704	62	charges	charge	NNS
8691	2704	63	.	.	.
8691	2705	1	"	"	``
8691	2705	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2705	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2705	4	:	:	:
8691	2705	5	Niles	Niles	NNP
8691	2705	6	'	'	POS
8691	2705	7	Register	register	NN
8691	2705	8	,	,	,
8691	2705	9	XXXII	XXXII	NNP
8691	2705	10	,	,	,
8691	2705	11	357	357	CD
8691	2705	12	,	,	,
8691	2705	13	405	405	CD
8691	2705	14	;	;	,
8691	2705	15	XXXVIII	XXXVIII	NNP
8691	2705	16	,	,	,
8691	2705	17	336	336	CD
8691	2705	18	.	.	.
8691	2705	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2706	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2706	2	a	a	DT
8691	2706	3	capital	capital	NN
8691	2706	4	case	case	NN
8691	2706	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2706	6	coming	come	VBG
8691	2706	7	on	on	RP
8691	2706	8	,	,	,
8691	2706	9	great	great	JJ
8691	2706	10	pains	pain	NNS
8691	2706	11	will	will	MD
8691	2706	12	often	often	RB
8691	2706	13	be	be	VB
8691	2706	14	taken	take	VBN
8691	2706	15	by	by	IN
8691	2706	16	the	the	DT
8691	2706	17	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	2706	18	's	's	POS
8691	2706	19	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2706	20	to	to	TO
8691	2706	21	ascertain	ascertain	VB
8691	2706	22	the	the	DT
8691	2706	23	characteristics	characteristic	NNS
8691	2706	24	and	and	CC
8691	2706	25	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	2706	26	toward	toward	IN
8691	2706	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2706	28	client	client	NN
8691	2706	29	of	of	IN
8691	2706	30	each	each	DT
8691	2706	31	of	of	IN
8691	2706	32	the	the	DT
8691	2706	33	jurors	juror	NNS
8691	2706	34	who	who	WP
8691	2706	35	have	have	VBP
8691	2706	36	been	be	VBN
8691	2706	37	summoned	summon	VBN
8691	2706	38	to	to	IN
8691	2706	39	court	court	NN
8691	2706	40	.	.	.
8691	2707	1	This	this	DT
8691	2707	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	2707	3	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	2707	4	been	be	VBN
8691	2707	5	carried	carry	VBN
8691	2707	6	to	to	IN
8691	2707	7	the	the	DT
8691	2707	8	extent	extent	NN
8691	2707	9	of	of	IN
8691	2707	10	trickery	trickery	NN
8691	2707	11	,	,	,
8691	2707	12	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	2707	13	in	in	IN
8691	2707	14	some	some	DT
8691	2707	15	of	of	IN
8691	2707	16	the	the	DT
8691	2707	17	Southern	Southern	NNP
8691	2707	18	States	States	NNPS
8691	2707	19	.	.	.
8691	2708	1	Agents	agent	NNS
8691	2708	2	have	have	VBP
8691	2708	3	been	be	VBN
8691	2708	4	sent	send	VBN
8691	2708	5	over	over	IN
8691	2708	6	the	the	DT
8691	2708	7	county	county	NN
8691	2708	8	to	to	TO
8691	2708	9	see	see	VB
8691	2708	10	every	every	DT
8691	2708	11	man	man	NN
8691	2708	12	capable	capable	JJ
8691	2708	13	of	of	IN
8691	2708	14	jury	jury	NN
8691	2708	15	service	service	NN
8691	2708	16	.	.	.
8691	2709	1	There	there	EX
8691	2709	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2709	3	some	some	DT
8691	2709	4	ostensible	ostensible	JJ
8691	2709	5	reason	reason	NN
8691	2709	6	given	give	VBN
8691	2709	7	for	for	IN
8691	2709	8	the	the	DT
8691	2709	9	call	call	NN
8691	2709	10	.	.	.
8691	2710	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2710	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2710	3	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	2710	4	asked	ask	VBN
8691	2710	5	to	to	TO
8691	2710	6	buy	buy	VB
8691	2710	7	a	a	DT
8691	2710	8	photograph	photograph	NN
8691	2710	9	of	of	IN
8691	2710	10	the	the	DT
8691	2710	11	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2710	12	;	;	:
8691	2710	13	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	2710	14	to	to	TO
8691	2710	15	contribute	contribute	VB
8691	2710	16	to	to	IN
8691	2710	17	a	a	DT
8691	2710	18	fund	fund	NN
8691	2710	19	to	to	TO
8691	2710	20	provide	provide	VB
8691	2710	21	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2710	22	with	with	IN
8691	2710	23	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	2710	24	.	.	.
8691	2711	1	This	this	DT
8691	2711	2	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	2711	3	leads	lead	VBZ
8691	2711	4	to	to	IN
8691	2711	5	some	some	DT
8691	2711	6	expression	expression	NN
8691	2711	7	of	of	IN
8691	2711	8	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2711	9	in	in	IN
8691	2711	10	regards	regard	NNS
8691	2711	11	to	to	IN
8691	2711	12	the	the	DT
8691	2711	13	charge	charge	NN
8691	2711	14	made	make	VBN
8691	2711	15	against	against	IN
8691	2711	16	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2711	17	,	,	,
8691	2711	18	and	and	CC
8691	2711	19	if	if	IN
8691	2711	20	the	the	DT
8691	2711	21	man	man	NN
8691	2711	22	thus	thus	RB
8691	2711	23	"	"	``
8691	2711	24	interviewed	interview	VBN
8691	2711	25	"	"	''
8691	2711	26	should	should	MD
8691	2711	27	be	be	VB
8691	2711	28	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	2711	29	offered	offer	VBN
8691	2711	30	as	as	IN
8691	2711	31	a	a	DT
8691	2711	32	juror	juror	NN
8691	2711	33	,	,	,
8691	2711	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2711	35	is	be	VBZ
8691	2711	36	challenged	challenge	VBN
8691	2711	37	or	or	CC
8691	2711	38	not	not	RB
8691	2711	39	challenged	challenge	VBN
8691	2711	40	according	accord	VBG
8691	2711	41	to	to	IN
8691	2711	42	the	the	DT
8691	2711	43	information	information	NN
8691	2711	44	so	so	RB
8691	2711	45	obtained	obtain	VBD
8691	2711	46	.	.	.
8691	2712	1	In	in	IN
8691	2712	2	every	every	DT
8691	2712	3	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2712	4	case	case	NN
8691	2712	5	the	the	DT
8691	2712	6	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2712	7	's	's	POS
8691	2712	8	guilt	guilt	NN
8691	2712	9	must	must	MD
8691	2712	10	be	be	VB
8691	2712	11	proved	prove	VBN
8691	2712	12	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	2712	13	a	a	DT
8691	2712	14	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	2712	15	doubt	doubt	NN
8691	2712	16	.	.	.
8691	2713	1	A	a	DT
8691	2713	2	mere	mere	JJ
8691	2713	3	preponderance	preponderance	NN
8691	2713	4	of	of	IN
8691	2713	5	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2713	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2713	7	not	not	RB
8691	2713	8	enough	enough	JJ
8691	2713	9	.	.	.
8691	2714	1	In	in	IN
8691	2714	2	other	other	JJ
8691	2714	3	respects	respect	NNS
8691	2714	4	the	the	DT
8691	2714	5	rules	rule	NNS
8691	2714	6	of	of	IN
8691	2714	7	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2714	8	are	be	VBP
8691	2714	9	applicable	applicable	JJ
8691	2714	10	which	which	WDT
8691	2714	11	obtain	obtain	VBP
8691	2714	12	in	in	IN
8691	2714	13	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2714	14	cases	case	NNS
8691	2714	15	.	.	.
8691	2715	1	If	if	IN
8691	2715	2	a	a	DT
8691	2715	3	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2715	4	of	of	IN
8691	2715	5	Not	Not	NNP
8691	2715	6	Guilty	Guilty	NNP
8691	2715	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2715	8	returned	return	VBN
8691	2715	9	,	,	,
8691	2715	10	the	the	DT
8691	2715	11	court	court	NN
8691	2715	12	orders	order	VBZ
8691	2715	13	the	the	DT
8691	2715	14	discharge	discharge	NN
8691	2715	15	of	of	IN
8691	2715	16	the	the	DT
8691	2715	17	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	2715	18	,	,	,
8691	2715	19	as	as	IN
8691	2715	20	a	a	DT
8691	2715	21	matter	matter	NN
8691	2715	22	of	of	IN
8691	2715	23	course	course	NN
8691	2715	24	,	,	,
8691	2715	25	unless	unless	IN
8691	2715	26	provision	provision	NN
8691	2715	27	has	have	VBZ
8691	2715	28	been	be	VBN
8691	2715	29	made	make	VBN
8691	2715	30	by	by	IN
8691	2715	31	statute	statute	NN
8691	2715	32	for	for	IN
8691	2715	33	an	an	DT
8691	2715	34	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2715	35	by	by	IN
8691	2715	36	the	the	DT
8691	2715	37	State	State	NNP
8691	2715	38	for	for	IN
8691	2715	39	errors	error	NNS
8691	2715	40	of	of	IN
8691	2715	41	law	law	NN
8691	2715	42	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2715	43	on	on	IN
8691	2715	44	the	the	DT
8691	2715	45	trial	trial	NN
8691	2715	46	.	.	.
8691	2716	1	No	no	DT
8691	2716	2	such	such	JJ
8691	2716	3	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2716	4	can	can	MD
8691	2716	5	be	be	VB
8691	2716	6	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2716	7	for	for	IN
8691	2716	8	the	the	DT
8691	2716	9	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2716	10	of	of	IN
8691	2716	11	obtaining	obtain	VBG
8691	2716	12	a	a	DT
8691	2716	13	new	new	JJ
8691	2716	14	trial	trial	NN
8691	2716	15	on	on	IN
8691	2716	16	the	the	DT
8691	2716	17	ground	ground	NN
8691	2716	18	that	that	IN
8691	2716	19	the	the	DT
8691	2716	20	jury	jury	NN
8691	2716	21	came	come	VBD
8691	2716	22	to	to	IN
8691	2716	23	a	a	DT
8691	2716	24	wrong	wrong	JJ
8691	2716	25	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	2716	26	on	on	IN
8691	2716	27	the	the	DT
8691	2716	28	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2716	29	.	.	.
8691	2717	1	This	this	DT
8691	2717	2	would	would	MD
8691	2717	3	be	be	VB
8691	2717	4	to	to	TO
8691	2717	5	put	put	VB
8691	2717	6	the	the	DT
8691	2717	7	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2717	8	twice	twice	RB
8691	2717	9	in	in	IN
8691	2717	10	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
8691	2717	11	,	,	,
8691	2717	12	which	which	WDT
8691	2717	13	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2717	14	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	2717	15	generally	generally	RB
8691	2717	16	forbid	forbid	VBP
8691	2717	17	.	.	.
8691	2718	1	Even	even	RB
8691	2718	2	under	under	IN
8691	2718	3	the	the	DT
8691	2718	4	practice	practice	NN
8691	2718	5	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	2718	6	in	in	IN
8691	2718	7	the	the	DT
8691	2718	8	Philippine	Philippine	NNP
8691	2718	9	Islands	Islands	NNPS
8691	2718	10	,	,	,
8691	2718	11	where	where	WRB
8691	2718	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2718	13	have	have	VBP
8691	2718	14	no	no	DT
8691	2718	15	juries	jury	NNS
8691	2718	16	,	,	,
8691	2718	17	and	and	CC
8691	2718	18	an	an	DT
8691	2718	19	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2718	20	to	to	IN
8691	2718	21	a	a	DT
8691	2718	22	higher	high	JJR
8691	2718	23	court	court	NN
8691	2718	24	for	for	IN
8691	2718	25	a	a	DT
8691	2718	26	new	new	JJ
8691	2718	27	trial	trial	NN
8691	2718	28	on	on	IN
8691	2718	29	the	the	DT
8691	2718	30	merits	merit	NNS
8691	2718	31	has	have	VBZ
8691	2718	32	always	always	RB
8691	2718	33	been	be	VBN
8691	2718	34	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2718	35	to	to	IN
8691	2718	36	either	either	DT
8691	2718	37	party	party	NN
8691	2718	38	in	in	IN
8691	2718	39	a	a	DT
8691	2718	40	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2718	41	case	case	NN
8691	2718	42	,	,	,
8691	2718	43	as	as	IN
8691	2718	44	a	a	DT
8691	2718	45	matter	matter	NN
8691	2718	46	of	of	IN
8691	2718	47	right	right	NN
8691	2718	48	,	,	,
8691	2718	49	this	this	DT
8691	2718	50	rule	rule	NN
8691	2718	51	is	be	VBZ
8691	2718	52	held	hold	VBN
8691	2718	53	to	to	TO
8691	2718	54	apply	apply	VB
8691	2718	55	.	.	.
8691	2719	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2719	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2719	3	:	:	:
8691	2719	4	Kepner	Kepner	NNP
8691	2719	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2719	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2719	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2719	8	United	United	NNP
8691	2719	9	States	States	NNP
8691	2719	10	,	,	,
8691	2719	11	195	195	CD
8691	2719	12	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2719	13	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2719	14	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2719	15	,	,	,
8691	2719	16	100	100	CD
8691	2719	17	.	.	.
8691	2719	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2720	1	If	if	IN
8691	2720	2	the	the	DT
8691	2720	3	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2720	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2720	5	one	one	CD
8691	2720	6	of	of	IN
8691	2720	7	Guilty	Guilty	NNP
8691	2720	8	,	,	,
8691	2720	9	the	the	DT
8691	2720	10	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2720	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2720	12	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	2720	13	by	by	IN
8691	2720	14	the	the	DT
8691	2720	15	judge	judge	NN
8691	2720	16	.	.	.
8691	2721	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2721	2	generally	generally	RB
8691	2721	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	2721	4	a	a	DT
8691	2721	5	broad	broad	JJ
8691	2721	6	discretion	discretion	NN
8691	2721	7	as	as	IN
8691	2721	8	to	to	IN
8691	2721	9	the	the	DT
8691	2721	10	extent	extent	NN
8691	2721	11	and	and	CC
8691	2721	12	nature	nature	NN
8691	2721	13	of	of	IN
8691	2721	14	the	the	DT
8691	2721	15	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	2721	16	.	.	.
8691	2722	1	For	for	IN
8691	2722	2	many	many	JJ
8691	2722	3	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	2722	4	,	,	,
8691	2722	5	either	either	CC
8691	2722	6	fine	fine	JJ
8691	2722	7	or	or	CC
8691	2722	8	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	2722	9	or	or	CC
8691	2722	10	both	both	DT
8691	2722	11	may	may	MD
8691	2722	12	be	be	VB
8691	2722	13	imposed	impose	VBN
8691	2722	14	,	,	,
8691	2722	15	according	accord	VBG
8691	2722	16	to	to	IN
8691	2722	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2722	18	best	good	JJS
8691	2722	19	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2722	20	.	.	.
8691	2723	1	For	for	IN
8691	2723	2	most	most	JJS
8691	2723	3	,	,	,
8691	2723	4	when	when	WRB
8691	2723	5	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	2723	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2723	7	ordered	order	VBN
8691	2723	8	,	,	,
8691	2723	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2723	10	may	may	MD
8691	2723	11	be	be	VB
8691	2723	12	for	for	IN
8691	2723	13	a	a	DT
8691	2723	14	term	term	NN
8691	2723	15	such	such	JJ
8691	2723	16	as	as	IN
8691	2723	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2723	18	may	may	MD
8691	2723	19	prescribe	prescribe	VB
8691	2723	20	within	within	IN
8691	2723	21	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2723	22	limits	limit	NNS
8691	2723	23	,	,	,
8691	2723	24	as	as	IN
8691	2723	25	,	,	,
8691	2723	26	for	for	IN
8691	2723	27	instance	instance	NN
8691	2723	28	,	,	,
8691	2723	29	from	from	IN
8691	2723	30	one	one	CD
8691	2723	31	to	to	TO
8691	2723	32	five	five	CD
8691	2723	33	years	year	NNS
8691	2723	34	.	.	.
8691	2724	1	In	in	IN
8691	2724	2	a	a	DT
8691	2724	3	number	number	NN
8691	2724	4	of	of	IN
8691	2724	5	States	state	NNS
8691	2724	6	of	of	IN
8691	2724	7	late	late	JJ
8691	2724	8	years	year	NNS
8691	2724	9	the	the	DT
8691	2724	10	judge	judge	NN
8691	2724	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2724	12	permitted	permit	VBN
8691	2724	13	in	in	IN
8691	2724	14	such	such	PDT
8691	2724	15	a	a	DT
8691	2724	16	case	case	NN
8691	2724	17	to	to	IN
8691	2724	18	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2724	19	for	for	IN
8691	2724	20	not	not	RB
8691	2724	21	less	less	JJR
8691	2724	22	than	than	IN
8691	2724	23	one	one	CD
8691	2724	24	year	year	NN
8691	2724	25	,	,	,
8691	2724	26	and	and	CC
8691	2724	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2724	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	2724	29	left	leave	VBN
8691	2724	30	to	to	IN
8691	2724	31	some	some	DT
8691	2724	32	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	2724	33	board	board	NN
8691	2724	34	to	to	TO
8691	2724	35	determine	determine	VB
8691	2724	36	later	later	RB
8691	2724	37	how	how	WRB
8691	2724	38	much	much	RB
8691	2724	39	,	,	,
8691	2724	40	if	if	IN
8691	2724	41	any	any	DT
8691	2724	42	,	,	,
8691	2724	43	longer	long	RBR
8691	2724	44	the	the	DT
8691	2724	45	confinement	confinement	NN
8691	2724	46	shall	shall	MD
8691	2724	47	last	last	VB
8691	2724	48	,	,	,
8691	2724	49	in	in	IN
8691	2724	50	view	view	NN
8691	2724	51	of	of	IN
8691	2724	52	the	the	DT
8691	2724	53	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	2724	54	of	of	IN
8691	2724	55	the	the	DT
8691	2724	56	offense	offense	NN
8691	2724	57	,	,	,
8691	2724	58	the	the	DT
8691	2724	59	character	character	NN
8691	2724	60	of	of	IN
8691	2724	61	the	the	DT
8691	2724	62	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	2724	63	,	,	,
8691	2724	64	and	and	CC
8691	2724	65	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2724	66	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	2724	67	since	since	IN
8691	2724	68	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2724	69	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2724	70	.	.	.
8691	2725	1	A	a	DT
8691	2725	2	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2725	3	and	and	CC
8691	2725	4	increasing	increasing	JJ
8691	2725	5	group	group	NN
8691	2725	6	of	of	IN
8691	2725	7	penologists	penologist	NNS
8691	2725	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2725	9	pressing	press	VBG
8691	2725	10	upon	upon	IN
8691	2725	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2725	12	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	2725	13	the	the	DT
8691	2725	14	extension	extension	NN
8691	2725	15	of	of	IN
8691	2725	16	the	the	DT
8691	2725	17	principle	principle	NN
8691	2725	18	of	of	IN
8691	2725	19	the	the	DT
8691	2725	20	"	"	``
8691	2725	21	indeterminate	indeterminate	JJ
8691	2725	22	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2725	23	"	"	''
8691	2725	24	by	by	IN
8691	2725	25	removing	remove	VBG
8691	2725	26	the	the	DT
8691	2725	27	limit	limit	NN
8691	2725	28	of	of	IN
8691	2725	29	a	a	DT
8691	2725	30	_	_	NNP
8691	2725	31	minimum	minimum	JJ
8691	2725	32	_	_	NNP
8691	2725	33	term	term	NN
8691	2725	34	.	.	.
8691	2726	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2726	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2726	3	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
8691	2726	4	if	if	IN
8691	2726	5	such	such	PDT
8691	2726	6	a	a	DT
8691	2726	7	change	change	NN
8691	2726	8	would	would	MD
8691	2726	9	satisfy	satisfy	VB
8691	2726	10	the	the	DT
8691	2726	11	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	2726	12	requirement	requirement	NN
8691	2726	13	of	of	IN
8691	2726	14	a	a	DT
8691	2726	15	trial	trial	NN
8691	2726	16	by	by	IN
8691	2726	17	jury	jury	NN
8691	2726	18	.	.	.
8691	2727	1	That	that	IN
8691	2727	2	in	in	IN
8691	2727	3	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2727	4	nature	nature	NN
8691	2727	5	involves	involve	VBZ
8691	2727	6	a	a	DT
8691	2727	7	trial	trial	NN
8691	2727	8	before	before	IN
8691	2727	9	a	a	DT
8691	2727	10	judge	judge	NN
8691	2727	11	and	and	CC
8691	2727	12	a	a	DT
8691	2727	13	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2727	14	imposed	impose	VBN
8691	2727	15	by	by	IN
8691	2727	16	the	the	DT
8691	2727	17	court	court	NN
8691	2727	18	upon	upon	IN
8691	2727	19	the	the	DT
8691	2727	20	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2727	21	.	.	.
8691	2728	1	Can	Can	MD
8691	2728	2	that	that	WDT
8691	2728	3	be	be	VB
8691	2728	4	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	2728	5	a	a	DT
8691	2728	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2728	7	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2728	8	to	to	TO
8691	2728	9	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	2728	10	which	which	WDT
8691	2728	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2728	12	a	a	DT
8691	2728	13	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2728	14	to	to	TO
8691	2728	15	imprisonment	imprisonment	VB
8691	2728	16	during	during	IN
8691	2728	17	the	the	DT
8691	2728	18	pleasure	pleasure	NN
8691	2728	19	of	of	IN
8691	2728	20	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2728	21	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	2728	22	officials	official	NNS
8691	2728	23	?	?	.
8691	2729	1	Judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	2729	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2729	3	to	to	TO
8691	2729	4	ascertain	ascertain	VB
8691	2729	5	justice	justice	NN
8691	2729	6	.	.	.
8691	2730	1	To	to	TO
8691	2730	2	do	do	VB
8691	2730	3	this	this	DT
8691	2730	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2730	5	must	must	MD
8691	2730	6	be	be	VB
8691	2730	7	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2730	8	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2730	9	.	.	.
8691	2731	1	In	in	IN
8691	2731	2	a	a	DT
8691	2731	3	purely	purely	RB
8691	2731	4	indeterminate	indeterminate	JJ
8691	2731	5	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2731	6	there	there	EX
8691	2731	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2731	8	no	no	DT
8691	2731	9	certainty	certainty	NN
8691	2731	10	until	until	IN
8691	2731	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2731	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	2731	13	been	be	VBN
8691	2731	14	made	make	VBN
8691	2731	15	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2731	16	by	by	IN
8691	2731	17	the	the	DT
8691	2731	18	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	2731	19	action	action	NN
8691	2731	20	of	of	IN
8691	2731	21	the	the	DT
8691	2731	22	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	2731	23	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	2731	24	.	.	.
8691	2732	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2732	2	may	may	MD
8691	2732	3	turn	turn	VB
8691	2732	4	out	out	RP
8691	2732	5	to	to	TO
8691	2732	6	be	be	VB
8691	2732	7	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	2732	8	for	for	IN
8691	2732	9	life	life	NN
8691	2732	10	,	,	,
8691	2732	11	and	and	CC
8691	2732	12	the	the	DT
8691	2732	13	advocates	advocate	NNS
8691	2732	14	of	of	IN
8691	2732	15	this	this	DT
8691	2732	16	mode	mode	NN
8691	2732	17	of	of	IN
8691	2732	18	action	action	NN
8691	2732	19	frankly	frankly	RB
8691	2732	20	say	say	VBP
8691	2732	21	that	that	IN
8691	2732	22	such	such	JJ
8691	2732	23	ought	ought	MD
8691	2732	24	to	to	TO
8691	2732	25	be	be	VB
8691	2732	26	the	the	DT
8691	2732	27	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	2732	28	of	of	IN
8691	2732	29	all	all	DT
8691	2732	30	incorrigible	incorrigible	JJ
8691	2732	31	and	and	CC
8691	2732	32	habitual	habitual	JJ
8691	2732	33	criminals	criminal	NNS
8691	2732	34	.	.	.
8691	2733	1	If	if	IN
8691	2733	2	so	so	RB
8691	2733	3	,	,	,
8691	2733	4	ought	ought	MD
8691	2733	5	not	not	RB
8691	2733	6	the	the	DT
8691	2733	7	fate	fate	NN
8691	2733	8	to	to	TO
8691	2733	9	be	be	VB
8691	2733	10	meted	mete	VBN
8691	2733	11	out	out	RP
8691	2733	12	to	to	IN
8691	2733	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2733	14	by	by	IN
8691	2733	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2733	16	authority	authority	NN
8691	2733	17	?	?	.
8691	2734	1	Can	Can	MD
8691	2734	2	anything	anything	NN
8691	2734	3	less	less	JJR
8691	2734	4	than	than	IN
8691	2734	5	that	that	DT
8691	2734	6	be	be	VB
8691	2734	7	considered	consider	VBN
8691	2734	8	as	as	IN
8691	2734	9	due	due	JJ
8691	2734	10	process	process	NN
8691	2734	11	of	of	IN
8691	2734	12	law	law	NN
8691	2734	13	?	?	.
8691	2735	1	An	an	DT
8691	2735	2	experienced	experienced	JJ
8691	2735	3	and	and	CC
8691	2735	4	able	able	JJ
8691	2735	5	judge	judge	NN
8691	2735	6	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	2735	7	makes	make	VBZ
8691	2735	8	any	any	DT
8691	2735	9	serious	serious	JJ
8691	2735	10	error	error	NN
8691	2735	11	in	in	IN
8691	2735	12	grading	grade	VBG
8691	2735	13	the	the	DT
8691	2735	14	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	2735	15	of	of	IN
8691	2735	16	offenders	offender	NNS
8691	2735	17	who	who	WP
8691	2735	18	have	have	VBP
8691	2735	19	been	be	VBN
8691	2735	20	tried	try	VBN
8691	2735	21	before	before	IN
8691	2735	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2735	23	.	.	.
8691	2736	1	The	the	DT
8691	2736	2	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2736	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2736	4	not	not	RB
8691	2736	5	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	2736	6	until	until	IN
8691	2736	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2736	8	have	have	VBP
8691	2736	9	been	be	VBN
8691	2736	10	fully	fully	RB
8691	2736	11	heard	hear	VBN
8691	2736	12	as	as	IN
8691	2736	13	to	to	IN
8691	2736	14	all	all	DT
8691	2736	15	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	2736	16	of	of	IN
8691	2736	17	extenuation	extenuation	NN
8691	2736	18	,	,	,
8691	2736	19	nor	nor	CC
8691	2736	20	until	until	IN
8691	2736	21	the	the	DT
8691	2736	22	government	government	NN
8691	2736	23	has	have	VBZ
8691	2736	24	been	be	VBN
8691	2736	25	heard	hear	VBN
8691	2736	26	both	both	DT
8691	2736	27	as	as	IN
8691	2736	28	to	to	IN
8691	2736	29	these	these	DT
8691	2736	30	and	and	CC
8691	2736	31	as	as	IN
8691	2736	32	to	to	IN
8691	2736	33	any	any	DT
8691	2736	34	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	2736	35	of	of	IN
8691	2736	36	aggravation	aggravation	NN
8691	2736	37	.	.	.
8691	2737	1	The	the	DT
8691	2737	2	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2737	3	,	,	,
8691	2737	4	if	if	IN
8691	2737	5	the	the	DT
8691	2737	6	offense	offense	NN
8691	2737	7	be	be	VB
8691	2737	8	a	a	DT
8691	2737	9	grave	grave	JJ
8691	2737	10	one	one	NN
8691	2737	11	,	,	,
8691	2737	12	can	can	MD
8691	2737	13	not	not	RB
8691	2737	14	be	be	VB
8691	2737	15	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	2737	16	except	except	IN
8691	2737	17	in	in	IN
8691	2737	18	the	the	DT
8691	2737	19	presence	presence	NN
8691	2737	20	of	of	IN
8691	2737	21	the	the	DT
8691	2737	22	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	2737	23	man	man	NN
8691	2737	24	.	.	.
8691	2738	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2738	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	2738	3	an	an	DT
8691	2738	4	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	2738	5	for	for	IN
8691	2738	6	the	the	DT
8691	2738	7	last	last	JJ
8691	2738	8	word	word	NN
8691	2738	9	.	.	.
8691	2739	1	Judges	judge	NNS
8691	2739	2	who	who	WP
8691	2739	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2739	4	neither	neither	CC
8691	2739	5	able	able	JJ
8691	2739	6	nor	nor	CC
8691	2739	7	experienced	experience	VBN
8691	2739	8	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	2739	9	impose	impose	VBP
8691	2739	10	sentences	sentence	NNS
8691	2739	11	too	too	RB
8691	2739	12	light	light	JJ
8691	2739	13	or	or	CC
8691	2739	14	too	too	RB
8691	2739	15	severe	severe	JJ
8691	2739	16	.	.	.
8691	2740	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2740	2	have	have	VBP
8691	2740	3	too	too	RB
8691	2740	4	many	many	JJ
8691	2740	5	such	such	JJ
8691	2740	6	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2740	7	in	in	IN
8691	2740	8	the	the	DT
8691	2740	9	United	United	NNP
8691	2740	10	States	States	NNP
8691	2740	11	.	.	.
8691	2741	1	The	the	DT
8691	2741	2	real	real	JJ
8691	2741	3	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	2741	4	for	for	IN
8691	2741	5	the	the	DT
8691	2741	6	evil	evil	NN
8691	2741	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2741	8	to	to	TO
8691	2741	9	choose	choose	VB
8691	2741	10	better	well	JJR
8691	2741	11	ones	one	NNS
8691	2741	12	.	.	.
8691	2742	1	As	as	IN
8691	2742	2	between	between	IN
8691	2742	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2742	4	and	and	CC
8691	2742	5	boards	board	NNS
8691	2742	6	of	of	IN
8691	2742	7	prison	prison	NN
8691	2742	8	officers	officer	NNS
8691	2742	9	or	or	CC
8691	2742	10	of	of	IN
8691	2742	11	public	public	JJ
8691	2742	12	charities	charity	NNS
8691	2742	13	,	,	,
8691	2742	14	the	the	DT
8691	2742	15	judge	judge	NN
8691	2742	16	always	always	RB
8691	2742	17	has	have	VBZ
8691	2742	18	the	the	DT
8691	2742	19	great	great	JJ
8691	2742	20	advantage	advantage	NN
8691	2742	21	of	of	IN
8691	2742	22	having	have	VBG
8691	2742	23	tried	try	VBN
8691	2742	24	the	the	DT
8691	2742	25	case	case	NN
8691	2742	26	and	and	CC
8691	2742	27	heard	hear	VBD
8691	2742	28	the	the	DT
8691	2742	29	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	2742	30	.	.	.
8691	2743	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2743	2	ought	ought	MD
8691	2743	3	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	2743	4	to	to	TO
8691	2743	5	be	be	VB
8691	2743	6	best	well	RBS
8691	2743	7	able	able	JJ
8691	2743	8	to	to	TO
8691	2743	9	fix	fix	VB
8691	2743	10	the	the	DT
8691	2743	11	term	term	NN
8691	2743	12	of	of	IN
8691	2743	13	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	2743	14	.	.	.
8691	2744	1	The	the	DT
8691	2744	2	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	2744	3	to	to	TO
8691	2744	4	which	which	WDT
8691	2744	5	one	one	PRP
8691	2744	6	can	can	MD
8691	2744	7	be	be	VB
8691	2744	8	sentenced	sentence	VBN
8691	2744	9	on	on	IN
8691	2744	10	a	a	DT
8691	2744	11	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	2744	12	of	of	IN
8691	2744	13	crime	crime	NN
8691	2744	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	2744	15	now	now	RB
8691	2744	16	generally	generally	RB
8691	2744	17	limited	limited	JJ
8691	2744	18	to	to	IN
8691	2744	19	fine	fine	JJ
8691	2744	20	or	or	CC
8691	2744	21	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	2744	22	.	.	.
8691	2745	1	For	for	IN
8691	2745	2	graver	graver	JJ
8691	2745	3	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	2745	4	both	both	DT
8691	2745	5	may	may	MD
8691	2745	6	be	be	VB
8691	2745	7	inflicted	inflict	VBN
8691	2745	8	:	:	:
8691	2745	9	for	for	IN
8691	2745	10	murder	murder	NN
8691	2745	11	,	,	,
8691	2745	12	and	and	CC
8691	2745	13	in	in	IN
8691	2745	14	some	some	DT
8691	2745	15	States	States	NNP
8691	2745	16	for	for	IN
8691	2745	17	a	a	DT
8691	2745	18	very	very	RB
8691	2745	19	few	few	JJ
8691	2745	20	other	other	JJ
8691	2745	21	crimes	crime	NNS
8691	2745	22	the	the	DT
8691	2745	23	penalty	penalty	NN
8691	2745	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	2745	25	death	death	NN
8691	2745	26	.	.	.
8691	2746	1	The	the	DT
8691	2746	2	policy	policy	NN
8691	2746	3	of	of	IN
8691	2746	4	the	the	DT
8691	2746	5	older	old	JJR
8691	2746	6	States	States	NNP
8691	2746	7	long	long	RB
8691	2746	8	was	be	VBD
8691	2746	9	to	to	TO
8691	2746	10	require	require	VB
8691	2746	11	those	those	DT
8691	2746	12	whose	whose	WP$
8691	2746	13	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	2746	14	were	be	VBD
8691	2746	15	directed	direct	VBN
8691	2746	16	against	against	IN
8691	2746	17	property	property	NN
8691	2746	18	to	to	TO
8691	2746	19	make	make	VB
8691	2746	20	good	good	JJ
8691	2746	21	the	the	DT
8691	2746	22	loss	loss	NN
8691	2746	23	of	of	IN
8691	2746	24	the	the	DT
8691	2746	25	injured	injure	VBN
8691	2746	26	party	party	NN
8691	2746	27	.	.	.
8691	2747	1	Whipping	Whipping	NNP
8691	2747	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2747	3	also	also	RB
8691	2747	4	often	often	RB
8691	2747	5	added	add	VBN
8691	2747	6	,	,	,
8691	2747	7	and	and	CC
8691	2747	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2747	9	was	be	VBD
8691	2747	10	formerly	formerly	RB
8691	2747	11	a	a	DT
8691	2747	12	common	common	JJ
8691	2747	13	mode	mode	NN
8691	2747	14	of	of	IN
8691	2747	15	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	2747	16	throughout	throughout	IN
8691	2747	17	the	the	DT
8691	2747	18	country	country	NN
8691	2747	19	for	for	IN
8691	2747	20	all	all	DT
8691	2747	21	minor	minor	JJ
8691	2747	22	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	2747	23	.	.	.
8691	2748	1	Every	every	DT
8691	2748	2	colony	colony	NN
8691	2748	3	used	use	VBD
8691	2748	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2748	5	.	.	.
8691	2749	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2749	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2749	3	authorized	authorize	VBN
8691	2749	4	by	by	IN
8691	2749	5	the	the	DT
8691	2749	6	original	original	JJ
8691	2749	7	Act	Act	NNP
8691	2749	8	of	of	IN
8691	2749	9	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	2749	10	in	in	IN
8691	2749	11	1790	1790	CD
8691	2749	12	on	on	IN
8691	2749	13	the	the	DT
8691	2749	14	subject	subject	NN
8691	2749	15	of	of	IN
8691	2749	16	crimes	crime	NNS
8691	2749	17	,	,	,
8691	2749	18	and	and	CC
8691	2749	19	was	be	VBD
8691	2749	20	not	not	RB
8691	2749	21	abolished	abolish	VBN
8691	2749	22	for	for	IN
8691	2749	23	the	the	DT
8691	2749	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	2749	25	of	of	IN
8691	2749	26	the	the	DT
8691	2749	27	United	United	NNP
8691	2749	28	States	States	NNP
8691	2749	29	until	until	IN
8691	2749	30	1839	1839	CD
8691	2749	31	.	.	.
8691	2750	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2750	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2750	3	provided	provide	VBN
8691	2750	4	for	for	IN
8691	2750	5	in	in	IN
8691	2750	6	the	the	DT
8691	2750	7	early	early	JJ
8691	2750	8	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2750	9	of	of	IN
8691	2750	10	most	most	JJS
8691	2750	11	of	of	IN
8691	2750	12	the	the	DT
8691	2750	13	States	States	NNPS
8691	2750	14	,	,	,
8691	2750	15	and	and	CC
8691	2750	16	in	in	IN
8691	2750	17	some	some	DT
8691	2750	18	still	still	RB
8691	2750	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	2750	20	.	.	.
8691	2751	1	Until	until	IN
8691	2751	2	1830	1830	CD
8691	2751	3	,	,	,
8691	2751	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2751	5	was	be	VBD
8691	2751	6	the	the	DT
8691	2751	7	only	only	JJ
8691	2751	8	mode	mode	NN
8691	2751	9	of	of	IN
8691	2751	10	corporal	corporal	JJ
8691	2751	11	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	2751	12	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2751	13	in	in	IN
8691	2751	14	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2751	15	for	for	IN
8691	2751	16	the	the	DT
8691	2751	17	general	general	JJ
8691	2751	18	crime	crime	NN
8691	2751	19	of	of	IN
8691	2751	20	theft	theft	NN
8691	2751	21	.	.	.
8691	2752	1	For	for	IN
8691	2752	2	boys	boy	NNS
8691	2752	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2752	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2752	5	often	often	RB
8691	2752	6	the	the	DT
8691	2752	7	only	only	JJ
8691	2752	8	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	2752	9	that	that	WDT
8691	2752	10	can	can	MD
8691	2752	11	properly	properly	RB
8691	2752	12	be	be	VB
8691	2752	13	administered	administer	VBN
8691	2752	14	.	.	.
8691	2753	1	To	to	TO
8691	2753	2	fine	fine	VB
8691	2753	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2753	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2753	5	to	to	TO
8691	2753	6	punish	punish	VB
8691	2753	7	others	other	NNS
8691	2753	8	.	.	.
8691	2754	1	To	to	TO
8691	2754	2	imprison	imprison	VB
8691	2754	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2754	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2754	5	,	,	,
8691	2754	6	in	in	IN
8691	2754	7	nine	nine	CD
8691	2754	8	cases	case	NNS
8691	2754	9	out	out	IN
8691	2754	10	of	of	IN
8691	2754	11	ten	ten	CD
8691	2754	12	,	,	,
8691	2754	13	to	to	TO
8691	2754	14	degrade	degrade	VB
8691	2754	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2754	16	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	2754	17	recall	recall	NN
8691	2754	18	.	.	.
8691	2755	1	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	2755	2	,	,	,
8691	2755	3	in	in	IN
8691	2755	4	1898	1898	CD
8691	2755	5	,	,	,
8691	2755	6	reverted	revert	VBN
8691	2755	7	to	to	IN
8691	2755	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2755	9	as	as	IN
8691	2755	10	an	an	DT
8691	2755	11	alternative	alternative	NN
8691	2755	12	to	to	IN
8691	2755	13	fine	fine	JJ
8691	2755	14	or	or	CC
8691	2755	15	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	2755	16	in	in	IN
8691	2755	17	the	the	DT
8691	2755	18	case	case	NN
8691	2755	19	of	of	IN
8691	2755	20	boys	boy	NNS
8691	2755	21	under	under	IN
8691	2755	22	sixteen	sixteen	CD
8691	2755	23	,	,	,
8691	2755	24	provided	provide	VBD
8691	2755	25	the	the	DT
8691	2755	26	consent	consent	NN
8691	2755	27	of	of	IN
8691	2755	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2755	29	father	father	NN
8691	2755	30	or	or	CC
8691	2755	31	guardian	guardian	NN
8691	2755	32	be	be	VB
8691	2755	33	first	first	RB
8691	2755	34	given	give	VBN
8691	2755	35	.	.	.
8691	2756	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	2756	2	a	a	DT
8691	2756	3	statute	statute	NN
8691	2756	4	seems	seem	VBZ
8691	2756	5	absolutely	absolutely	RB
8691	2756	6	unobjectionable	unobjectionable	JJ
8691	2756	7	from	from	IN
8691	2756	8	any	any	DT
8691	2756	9	standpoint	standpoint	NN
8691	2756	10	.	.	.
8691	2757	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2757	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2757	3	often	often	RB
8691	2757	4	asserted	assert	VBN
8691	2757	5	that	that	IN
8691	2757	6	whipping	whipping	NN
8691	2757	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2757	8	a	a	DT
8691	2757	9	degrading	degrading	JJ
8691	2757	10	and	and	CC
8691	2757	11	inhuman	inhuman	JJ
8691	2757	12	invasion	invasion	NN
8691	2757	13	of	of	IN
8691	2757	14	the	the	DT
8691	2757	15	sanctity	sanctity	NN
8691	2757	16	of	of	IN
8691	2757	17	the	the	DT
8691	2757	18	person	person	NN
8691	2757	19	.	.	.
8691	2758	1	To	to	TO
8691	2758	2	shut	shut	VB
8691	2758	3	a	a	DT
8691	2758	4	man	man	NN
8691	2758	5	up	up	RP
8691	2758	6	in	in	IN
8691	2758	7	jail	jail	NN
8691	2758	8	against	against	IN
8691	2758	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2758	10	will	will	NN
8691	2758	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2758	12	a	a	DT
8691	2758	13	worse	bad	JJR
8691	2758	14	invasion	invasion	NN
8691	2758	15	.	.	.
8691	2759	1	But	but	CC
8691	2759	2	as	as	IN
8691	2759	3	against	against	IN
8691	2759	4	neither	neither	DT
8691	2759	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2759	6	the	the	DT
8691	2759	7	person	person	NN
8691	2759	8	of	of	IN
8691	2759	9	a	a	DT
8691	2759	10	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2759	11	convict	convict	NN
8691	2759	12	sacred	sacred	NN
8691	2759	13	.	.	.
8691	2760	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2760	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	2760	3	justly	justly	RB
8691	2760	4	forfeited	forfeit	VBN
8691	2760	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2760	6	right	right	NN
8691	2760	7	to	to	TO
8691	2760	8	be	be	VB
8691	2760	9	treated	treat	VBN
8691	2760	10	like	like	IN
8691	2760	11	a	a	DT
8691	2760	12	good	good	JJ
8691	2760	13	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	2760	14	.	.	.
8691	2761	1	Whether	whether	IN
8691	2761	2	whipping	whipping	NN
8691	2761	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2761	4	a	a	DT
8691	2761	5	degradation	degradation	NN
8691	2761	6	or	or	CC
8691	2761	7	not	not	RB
8691	2761	8	must	must	MD
8691	2761	9	depend	depend	VB
8691	2761	10	much	much	JJ
8691	2761	11	on	on	IN
8691	2761	12	the	the	DT
8691	2761	13	place	place	NN
8691	2761	14	of	of	IN
8691	2761	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2761	16	infliction	infliction	NN
8691	2761	17	.	.	.
8691	2762	1	The	the	DT
8691	2762	2	old	old	JJ
8691	2762	3	way	way	NN
8691	2762	4	in	in	IN
8691	2762	5	this	this	DT
8691	2762	6	country	country	NN
8691	2762	7	,	,	,
8691	2762	8	as	as	IN
8691	2762	9	in	in	IN
8691	2762	10	England	England	NNP
8691	2762	11	,	,	,
8691	2762	12	was	be	VBD
8691	2762	13	to	to	TO
8691	2762	14	inflict	inflict	VB
8691	2762	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2762	16	in	in	IN
8691	2762	17	public	public	NN
8691	2762	18	.	.	.
8691	2763	1	This	this	DT
8691	2763	2	puts	put	VBZ
8691	2763	3	the	the	DT
8691	2763	4	convict	convict	NN
8691	2763	5	to	to	IN
8691	2763	6	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
8691	2763	7	shame	shame	NN
8691	2763	8	.	.	.
8691	2764	1	Let	let	VB
8691	2764	2	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2764	3	be	be	VB
8691	2764	4	whipped	whip	VBN
8691	2764	5	in	in	IN
8691	2764	6	private	private	JJ
8691	2764	7	,	,	,
8691	2764	8	and	and	CC
8691	2764	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2764	10	only	only	JJ
8691	2764	11	real	real	JJ
8691	2764	12	degradation	degradation	NN
8691	2764	13	will	will	MD
8691	2764	14	be	be	VB
8691	2764	15	from	from	IN
8691	2764	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2764	17	crime	crime	NN
8691	2764	18	.	.	.
8691	2765	1	So	so	CC
8691	2765	2	inhumanity	inhumanity	NN
8691	2765	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2765	4	needless	needless	JJ
8691	2765	5	.	.	.
8691	2766	1	A	a	DT
8691	2766	2	moderate	moderate	JJ
8691	2766	3	whipping	whipping	NN
8691	2766	4	only	only	RB
8691	2766	5	should	should	MD
8691	2766	6	be	be	VB
8691	2766	7	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2766	8	.	.	.
8691	2767	1	That	that	DT
8691	2767	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2767	3	far	far	RB
8691	2767	4	more	more	RBR
8691	2767	5	humane	humane	JJ
8691	2767	6	to	to	IN
8691	2767	7	most	most	JJS
8691	2767	8	men	man	NNS
8691	2767	9	than	than	IN
8691	2767	10	a	a	DT
8691	2767	11	term	term	NN
8691	2767	12	of	of	IN
8691	2767	13	jail	jail	NN
8691	2767	14	;	;	:
8691	2767	15	that	that	RB
8691	2767	16	is	is	RB
8691	2767	17	,	,	,
8691	2767	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2767	19	detracts	detract	VBZ
8691	2767	20	less	less	RBR
8691	2767	21	from	from	IN
8691	2767	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2767	23	manhood	manhood	NN
8691	2767	24	than	than	IN
8691	2767	25	the	the	DT
8691	2767	26	long	long	JJ
8691	2767	27	slavery	slavery	NN
8691	2767	28	of	of	IN
8691	2767	29	confinement	confinement	NN
8691	2767	30	.	.	.
8691	2768	1	Of	of	IN
8691	2768	2	late	late	JJ
8691	2768	3	years	year	NNS
8691	2768	4	there	there	EX
8691	2768	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	2768	6	been	be	VBN
8691	2768	7	a	a	DT
8691	2768	8	decided	decided	JJ
8691	2768	9	movement	movement	NN
8691	2768	10	in	in	IN
8691	2768	11	the	the	DT
8691	2768	12	United	United	NNP
8691	2768	13	States	States	NNP
8691	2768	14	toward	toward	IN
8691	2768	15	a	a	DT
8691	2768	16	return	return	NN
8691	2768	17	to	to	IN
8691	2768	18	the	the	DT
8691	2768	19	penalty	penalty	NN
8691	2768	20	of	of	IN
8691	2768	21	whipping	whip	VBG
8691	2768	22	for	for	IN
8691	2768	23	atrocious	atrocious	JJ
8691	2768	24	cases	case	NNS
8691	2768	25	of	of	IN
8691	2768	26	assault	assault	NN
8691	2768	27	or	or	CC
8691	2768	28	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	2768	29	by	by	IN
8691	2768	30	boys	boy	NNS
8691	2768	31	.	.	.
8691	2769	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2769	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2769	3	:	:	:
8691	2769	4	See	see	VB
8691	2769	5	Paper	paper	NN
8691	2769	6	on	on	IN
8691	2769	7	"	"	``
8691	2769	8	Whipping	Whipping	NNP
8691	2769	9	and	and	CC
8691	2769	10	Castration	Castration	NNP
8691	2769	11	as	as	IN
8691	2769	12	Punishments	Punishments	NNP
8691	2769	13	for	for	IN
8691	2769	14	Crime	Crime	NNP
8691	2769	15	,	,	,
8691	2769	16	"	"	''
8691	2769	17	_	_	NNP
8691	2769	18	Yale	Yale	NNP
8691	2769	19	Law	Law	NNP
8691	2769	20	Journal	Journal	NNP
8691	2769	21	_	_	NNP
8691	2769	22	,	,	,
8691	2769	23	Vol	Vol	NNP
8691	2769	24	.	.	.
8691	2770	1	VIII	VIII	NNP
8691	2770	2	,	,	,
8691	2770	3	371	371	CD
8691	2770	4	,	,	,
8691	2770	5	and	and	CC
8691	2770	6	President	President	NNP
8691	2770	7	Roosevelt	Roosevelt	NNP
8691	2770	8	's	's	POS
8691	2770	9	Message	message	NN
8691	2770	10	to	to	IN
8691	2770	11	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	2770	12	in	in	IN
8691	2770	13	December	December	NNP
8691	2770	14	,	,	,
8691	2770	15	1904	1904	CD
8691	2770	16	.	.	.
8691	2770	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2771	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2771	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2771	3	probable	probable	JJ
8691	2771	4	that	that	IN
8691	2771	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2771	6	will	will	MD
8691	2771	7	find	find	VB
8691	2771	8	more	more	JJR
8691	2771	9	favor	favor	NN
8691	2771	10	hereafter	hereafter	RB
8691	2771	11	in	in	IN
8691	2771	12	the	the	DT
8691	2771	13	South	South	NNP
8691	2771	14	as	as	IN
8691	2771	15	a	a	DT
8691	2771	16	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	2771	17	for	for	IN
8691	2771	18	negroes	negro	NNS
8691	2771	19	.	.	.
8691	2772	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	2772	2	of	of	IN
8691	2772	3	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2772	4	criminals	criminal	NNS
8691	2772	5	are	be	VBP
8691	2772	6	of	of	IN
8691	2772	7	that	that	DT
8691	2772	8	race	race	NN
8691	2772	9	.	.	.
8691	2773	1	The	the	DT
8691	2773	2	jails	jail	NNS
8691	2773	3	have	have	VBP
8691	2773	4	no	no	DT
8691	2773	5	great	great	JJ
8691	2773	6	terrors	terror	NNS
8691	2773	7	for	for	IN
8691	2773	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2773	9	.	.	.
8691	2774	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2774	2	find	find	VBP
8691	2774	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2774	4	the	the	DT
8691	2774	5	only	only	JJ
8691	2774	6	ground	ground	NN
8691	2774	7	where	where	WRB
8691	2774	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2774	9	can	can	MD
8691	2774	10	mingle	mingle	VB
8691	2774	11	with	with	IN
8691	2774	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2774	13	white	white	JJ
8691	2774	14	fellow	fellow	NN
8691	2774	15	-	-	HYPH
8691	2774	16	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	2774	17	on	on	IN
8691	2774	18	terms	term	NNS
8691	2774	19	of	of	IN
8691	2774	20	social	social	JJ
8691	2774	21	equality	equality	NN
8691	2774	22	.	.	.
8691	2775	1	But	but	CC
8691	2775	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2775	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2775	4	sensitive	sensitive	JJ
8691	2775	5	to	to	IN
8691	2775	6	physical	physical	JJ
8691	2775	7	pain	pain	NN
8691	2775	8	.	.	.
8691	2776	1	A	a	DT
8691	2776	2	flogging	flogging	NN
8691	2776	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2776	4	dread	dread	VBP
8691	2776	5	just	just	RB
8691	2776	6	as	as	IN
8691	2776	7	a	a	DT
8691	2776	8	boy	boy	NN
8691	2776	9	dreads	dread	VBZ
8691	2776	10	a	a	DT
8691	2776	11	whipping	whipping	NN
8691	2776	12	from	from	IN
8691	2776	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2776	14	father	father	NN
8691	2776	15	,	,	,
8691	2776	16	because	because	IN
8691	2776	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2776	18	hurts	hurt	VBZ
8691	2776	19	.	.	.
8691	2777	1	The	the	DT
8691	2777	2	South	South	NNP
8691	2777	3	may	may	MD
8691	2777	4	have	have	VB
8691	2777	5	been	be	VBN
8691	2777	6	held	hold	VBN
8691	2777	7	back	back	RB
8691	2777	8	from	from	IN
8691	2777	9	applying	apply	VBG
8691	2777	10	this	this	DT
8691	2777	11	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	2777	12	in	in	IN
8691	2777	13	part	part	NN
8691	2777	14	from	from	IN
8691	2777	15	the	the	DT
8691	2777	16	apprehension	apprehension	NN
8691	2777	17	that	that	IN
8691	2777	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2777	19	might	may	MD
8691	2777	20	be	be	VB
8691	2777	21	considered	consider	VBN
8691	2777	22	as	as	IN
8691	2777	23	reinstating	reinstate	VBG
8691	2777	24	the	the	DT
8691	2777	25	methods	method	NNS
8691	2777	26	of	of	IN
8691	2777	27	slavery	slavery	NN
8691	2777	28	.	.	.
8691	2778	1	No	no	DT
8691	2778	2	such	such	JJ
8691	2778	3	criticism	criticism	NN
8691	2778	4	could	could	MD
8691	2778	5	fairly	fairly	RB
8691	2778	6	be	be	VB
8691	2778	7	made	make	VBN
8691	2778	8	.	.	.
8691	2779	1	Confinement	confinement	NN
8691	2779	2	in	in	IN
8691	2779	3	jail	jail	NN
8691	2779	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2779	5	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
8691	2779	6	servitude	servitude	NN
8691	2779	7	,	,	,
8691	2779	8	and	and	CC
8691	2779	9	involuntary	involuntary	JJ
8691	2779	10	servitude	servitude	NN
8691	2779	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2779	12	slavery	slavery	NN
8691	2779	13	.	.	.
8691	2780	1	Whipping	whipping	NN
8691	2780	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2780	3	a	a	DT
8691	2780	4	substitute	substitute	NN
8691	2780	5	for	for	IN
8691	2780	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2780	7	:	:	:
8691	2780	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2780	9	saves	save	VBZ
8691	2780	10	from	from	IN
8691	2780	11	slavery	slavery	NN
8691	2780	12	.	.	.
8691	2781	1	In	in	IN
8691	2781	2	several	several	JJ
8691	2781	3	of	of	IN
8691	2781	4	the	the	DT
8691	2781	5	Southern	Southern	NNP
8691	2781	6	States	States	NNP
8691	2781	7	,	,	,
8691	2781	8	instead	instead	RB
8691	2781	9	of	of	IN
8691	2781	10	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	2781	11	,	,	,
8691	2781	12	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	2781	13	offenders	offender	NNS
8691	2781	14	are	be	VBP
8691	2781	15	set	set	VBN
8691	2781	16	at	at	IN
8691	2781	17	work	work	NN
8691	2781	18	in	in	IN
8691	2781	19	the	the	DT
8691	2781	20	open	open	JJ
8691	2781	21	air	air	NN
8691	2781	22	,	,	,
8691	2781	23	either	either	CC
8691	2781	24	on	on	IN
8691	2781	25	convict	convict	NN
8691	2781	26	farms	farm	NNS
8691	2781	27	,	,	,
8691	2781	28	or	or	CC
8691	2781	29	in	in	IN
8691	2781	30	chain	chain	NN
8691	2781	31	gangs	gang	NNS
8691	2781	32	on	on	IN
8691	2781	33	the	the	DT
8691	2781	34	highway	highway	NN
8691	2781	35	,	,	,
8691	2781	36	or	or	CC
8691	2781	37	in	in	IN
8691	2781	38	the	the	DT
8691	2781	39	construction	construction	NN
8691	2781	40	of	of	IN
8691	2781	41	railroads	railroad	NNS
8691	2781	42	or	or	CC
8691	2781	43	similar	similar	JJ
8691	2781	44	works	work	NNS
8691	2781	45	.	.	.
8691	2782	1	This	this	DT
8691	2782	2	plan	plan	NN
8691	2782	3	prevails	prevail	VBZ
8691	2782	4	in	in	IN
8691	2782	5	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	2782	6	and	and	CC
8691	2782	7	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
8691	2782	8	to	to	IN
8691	2782	9	such	such	PDT
8691	2782	10	an	an	DT
8691	2782	11	extent	extent	NN
8691	2782	12	that	that	WDT
8691	2782	13	very	very	RB
8691	2782	14	few	few	JJ
8691	2782	15	are	be	VBP
8691	2782	16	confined	confine	VBN
8691	2782	17	in	in	IN
8691	2782	18	the	the	DT
8691	2782	19	penitentiary	penitentiary	NN
8691	2782	20	.	.	.
8691	2783	1	The	the	DT
8691	2783	2	convicts	convict	NNS
8691	2783	3	in	in	IN
8691	2783	4	these	these	DT
8691	2783	5	States	state	NNS
8691	2783	6	are	be	VBP
8691	2783	7	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	2783	8	negroes	negro	NNS
8691	2783	9	.	.	.
8691	2784	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2784	2	,	,	,
8691	2784	3	as	as	IN
8691	2784	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2784	5	been	be	VBN
8691	2784	6	at	at	IN
8691	2784	7	times	time	NNS
8691	2784	8	permitted	permit	VBN
8691	2784	9	,	,	,
8691	2784	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2784	11	have	have	VBP
8691	2784	12	been	be	VBN
8691	2784	13	turned	turn	VBN
8691	2784	14	over	over	RP
8691	2784	15	to	to	IN
8691	2784	16	private	private	JJ
8691	2784	17	employers	employer	NNS
8691	2784	18	to	to	TO
8691	2784	19	work	work	VB
8691	2784	20	in	in	IN
8691	2784	21	this	this	DT
8691	2784	22	manner	manner	NN
8691	2784	23	for	for	IN
8691	2784	24	wages	wage	NNS
8691	2784	25	paid	pay	VBN
8691	2784	26	to	to	IN
8691	2784	27	the	the	DT
8691	2784	28	State	State	NNP
8691	2784	29	,	,	,
8691	2784	30	many	many	JJ
8691	2784	31	of	of	IN
8691	2784	32	the	the	DT
8691	2784	33	abuses	abuse	NNS
8691	2784	34	of	of	IN
8691	2784	35	slavery	slavery	NN
8691	2784	36	have	have	VBP
8691	2784	37	reappeared	reappear	VBN
8691	2784	38	,	,	,
8691	2784	39	and	and	CC
8691	2784	40	public	public	JJ
8691	2784	41	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	2784	42	is	be	VBZ
8691	2784	43	becoming	become	VBG
8691	2784	44	decidedly	decidedly	RB
8691	2784	45	adverse	adverse	JJ
8691	2784	46	to	to	IN
8691	2784	47	the	the	DT
8691	2784	48	allowance	allowance	NN
8691	2784	49	of	of	IN
8691	2784	50	such	such	JJ
8691	2784	51	contracts	contract	NNS
8691	2784	52	for	for	IN
8691	2784	53	convict	convict	NN
8691	2784	54	labor	labor	NN
8691	2784	55	.	.	.
8691	2785	1	Similar	similar	JJ
8691	2785	2	objections	objection	NNS
8691	2785	3	do	do	VBP
8691	2785	4	not	not	RB
8691	2785	5	lie	lie	VB
8691	2785	6	in	in	IN
8691	2785	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2785	8	employment	employment	NN
8691	2785	9	on	on	IN
8691	2785	10	State	State	NNP
8691	2785	11	farms	farm	NNS
8691	2785	12	,	,	,
8691	2785	13	and	and	CC
8691	2785	14	in	in	IN
8691	2785	15	North	North	NNP
8691	2785	16	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	2785	17	and	and	CC
8691	2785	18	Texas	Texas	NNP
8691	2785	19	this	this	DT
8691	2785	20	has	have	VBZ
8691	2785	21	been	be	VBN
8691	2785	22	tried	try	VBN
8691	2785	23	with	with	IN
8691	2785	24	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2785	25	success	success	NN
8691	2785	26	.	.	.
8691	2786	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2786	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2786	3	:	:	:
8691	2786	4	See	see	VB
8691	2786	5	"	"	``
8691	2786	6	Bulletin	Bulletin	NNP
8691	2786	7	de	de	NNP
8691	2786	8	la	la	NNP
8691	2786	9	Commission	Commission	NNP
8691	2786	10	PÃ	PÃ	NNP
8691	2786	11	©	©	NNP
8691	2786	12	nÃ	nÃ	NNP
8691	2786	13	©	©	NNP
8691	2786	14	tentiaire	tentiaire	NN
8691	2786	15	Internationale	Internationale	NNP
8691	2786	16	,	,	,
8691	2786	17	"	"	``
8691	2786	18	5th	5th	JJ
8691	2786	19	series	series	NN
8691	2786	20	,	,	,
8691	2786	21	II	II	NNP
8691	2786	22	,	,	,
8691	2786	23	179	179	CD
8691	2786	24	.	.	.
8691	2786	25	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2787	1	Special	special	JJ
8691	2787	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	2787	3	have	have	VBP
8691	2787	4	been	be	VBN
8691	2787	5	organized	organize	VBN
8691	2787	6	,	,	,
8691	2787	7	or	or	CC
8691	2787	8	special	special	JJ
8691	2787	9	sessions	session	NNS
8691	2787	10	of	of	IN
8691	2787	11	existing	exist	VBG
8691	2787	12	courts	court	NNS
8691	2787	13	directed	direct	VBN
8691	2787	14	,	,	,
8691	2787	15	for	for	IN
8691	2787	16	the	the	DT
8691	2787	17	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	2787	18	of	of	IN
8691	2787	19	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2787	20	against	against	IN
8691	2787	21	children	child	NNS
8691	2787	22	in	in	IN
8691	2787	23	several	several	JJ
8691	2787	24	of	of	IN
8691	2787	25	the	the	DT
8691	2787	26	States	States	NNPS
8691	2787	27	and	and	CC
8691	2787	28	in	in	IN
8691	2787	29	the	the	DT
8691	2787	30	District	District	NNP
8691	2787	31	of	of	IN
8691	2787	32	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
8691	2787	33	during	during	IN
8691	2787	34	the	the	DT
8691	2787	35	past	past	JJ
8691	2787	36	few	few	JJ
8691	2787	37	years	year	NNS
8691	2787	38	.	.	.
8691	2788	1	The	the	DT
8691	2788	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	2788	3	holding	hold	VBG
8691	2788	4	such	such	PDT
8691	2788	5	a	a	DT
8691	2788	6	"	"	``
8691	2788	7	Juvenile	Juvenile	NNP
8691	2788	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2788	9	"	"	''
8691	2788	10	or	or	CC
8691	2788	11	"	"	``
8691	2788	12	Children	Children	NNPS
8691	2788	13	's	's	POS
8691	2788	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2788	15	"	"	''
8691	2788	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	2788	17	expected	expect	VBN
8691	2788	18	to	to	TO
8691	2788	19	deal	deal	VB
8691	2788	20	with	with	IN
8691	2788	21	those	those	DT
8691	2788	22	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2788	23	before	before	IN
8691	2788	24	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2788	25	rather	rather	RB
8691	2788	26	in	in	IN
8691	2788	27	a	a	DT
8691	2788	28	paternal	paternal	JJ
8691	2788	29	fashion	fashion	NN
8691	2788	30	.	.	.
8691	2789	1	An	an	DT
8691	2789	2	officer	officer	NN
8691	2789	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2789	4	generally	generally	RB
8691	2789	5	provided	provide	VBN
8691	2789	6	,	,	,
8691	2789	7	known	know	VBN
8691	2789	8	as	as	IN
8691	2789	9	a	a	DT
8691	2789	10	Probation	Probation	NNP
8691	2789	11	Officer	Officer	NNP
8691	2789	12	,	,	,
8691	2789	13	to	to	TO
8691	2789	14	whom	whom	WP
8691	2789	15	the	the	DT
8691	2789	16	custody	custody	NN
8691	2789	17	of	of	IN
8691	2789	18	the	the	DT
8691	2789	19	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2789	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	2789	21	largely	largely	RB
8691	2789	22	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2789	23	both	both	CC
8691	2789	24	before	before	IN
8691	2789	25	and	and	CC
8691	2789	26	after	after	IN
8691	2789	27	trial	trial	NN
8691	2789	28	.	.	.
8691	2790	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2790	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2790	3	to	to	TO
8691	2790	4	inquire	inquire	VB
8691	2790	5	into	into	IN
8691	2790	6	each	each	DT
8691	2790	7	case	case	NN
8691	2790	8	and	and	CC
8691	2790	9	represent	represent	VB
8691	2790	10	the	the	DT
8691	2790	11	defense	defense	NN
8691	2790	12	at	at	IN
8691	2790	13	the	the	DT
8691	2790	14	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	2790	15	.	.	.
8691	2791	1	In	in	IN
8691	2791	2	case	case	NN
8691	2791	3	of	of	IN
8691	2791	4	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	2791	5	,	,	,
8691	2791	6	the	the	DT
8691	2791	7	child	child	NN
8691	2791	8	can	can	MD
8691	2791	9	,	,	,
8691	2791	10	on	on	IN
8691	2791	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2791	12	advice	advice	NN
8691	2791	13	,	,	,
8691	2791	14	be	be	VB
8691	2791	15	released	release	VBN
8691	2791	16	on	on	IN
8691	2791	17	probation	probation	NN
8691	2791	18	,	,	,
8691	2791	19	or	or	CC
8691	2791	20	the	the	DT
8691	2791	21	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2791	22	can	can	MD
8691	2791	23	be	be	VB
8691	2791	24	suspended	suspend	VBN
8691	2791	25	.	.	.
8691	2792	1	For	for	IN
8691	2792	2	errors	error	NNS
8691	2792	3	of	of	IN
8691	2792	4	law	law	NN
8691	2792	5	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2792	6	by	by	IN
8691	2792	7	the	the	DT
8691	2792	8	judge	judge	NN
8691	2792	9	in	in	IN
8691	2792	10	the	the	DT
8691	2792	11	course	course	NN
8691	2792	12	of	of	IN
8691	2792	13	the	the	DT
8691	2792	14	trial	trial	NN
8691	2792	15	the	the	DT
8691	2792	16	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2792	17	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2792	18	has	have	VBZ
8691	2792	19	a	a	DT
8691	2792	20	right	right	NN
8691	2792	21	of	of	IN
8691	2792	22	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2792	23	.	.	.
8691	2793	1	Until	until	IN
8691	2793	2	1891	1891	CD
8691	2793	3	this	this	DT
8691	2793	4	was	be	VBD
8691	2793	5	not	not	RB
8691	2793	6	true	true	JJ
8691	2793	7	in	in	IN
8691	2793	8	the	the	DT
8691	2793	9	federal	federal	JJ
8691	2793	10	courts	court	NNS
8691	2793	11	,	,	,
8691	2793	12	and	and	CC
8691	2793	13	a	a	DT
8691	2793	14	man	man	NN
8691	2793	15	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	2793	16	and	and	CC
8691	2793	17	sentenced	sentence	VBN
8691	2793	18	there	there	RB
8691	2793	19	under	under	IN
8691	2793	20	an	an	DT
8691	2793	21	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
8691	2793	22	view	view	NN
8691	2793	23	of	of	IN
8691	2793	24	the	the	DT
8691	2793	25	law	law	NN
8691	2793	26	and	and	CC
8691	2793	27	in	in	IN
8691	2793	28	disregard	disregard	NN
8691	2793	29	of	of	IN
8691	2793	30	any	any	DT
8691	2793	31	of	of	IN
8691	2793	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2793	33	rights	right	NNS
8691	2793	34	had	have	VBD
8691	2793	35	no	no	DT
8691	2793	36	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	2793	37	,	,	,
8691	2793	38	even	even	RB
8691	2793	39	in	in	IN
8691	2793	40	a	a	DT
8691	2793	41	capital	capital	NN
8691	2793	42	case	case	NN
8691	2793	43	.	.	.
8691	2794	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2794	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2794	3	so	so	RB
8691	2794	4	in	in	IN
8691	2794	5	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
8691	2794	6	until	until	IN
8691	2794	7	1897	1897	CD
8691	2794	8	.	.	.
8691	2795	1	In	in	IN
8691	2795	2	some	some	DT
8691	2795	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2795	4	there	there	EX
8691	2795	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2795	6	a	a	DT
8691	2795	7	right	right	NN
8691	2795	8	of	of	IN
8691	2795	9	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2795	10	in	in	IN
8691	2795	11	favor	favor	NN
8691	2795	12	of	of	IN
8691	2795	13	the	the	DT
8691	2795	14	government	government	NN
8691	2795	15	as	as	RB
8691	2795	16	well	well	RB
8691	2795	17	as	as	IN
8691	2795	18	of	of	IN
8691	2795	19	the	the	DT
8691	2795	20	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2795	21	for	for	IN
8691	2795	22	errors	error	NNS
8691	2795	23	of	of	IN
8691	2795	24	law	law	NN
8691	2795	25	,	,	,
8691	2795	26	and	and	CC
8691	2795	27	this	this	DT
8691	2795	28	even	even	RB
8691	2795	29	after	after	IN
8691	2795	30	a	a	DT
8691	2795	31	jury	jury	NN
8691	2795	32	trial	trial	NN
8691	2795	33	ending	end	VBG
8691	2795	34	in	in	IN
8691	2795	35	a	a	DT
8691	2795	36	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2795	37	of	of	IN
8691	2795	38	acquittal	acquittal	NN
8691	2795	39	.	.	.
8691	2796	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2796	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2796	3	there	there	RB
8691	2796	4	held	hold	VBN
8691	2796	5	that	that	IN
8691	2796	6	the	the	DT
8691	2796	7	common	common	JJ
8691	2796	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	2796	9	provision	provision	NN
8691	2796	10	that	that	IN
8691	2796	11	no	no	DT
8691	2796	12	man	man	NN
8691	2796	13	shall	shall	MD
8691	2796	14	be	be	VB
8691	2796	15	put	put	VBN
8691	2796	16	twice	twice	RB
8691	2796	17	in	in	IN
8691	2796	18	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
8691	2796	19	of	of	IN
8691	2796	20	life	life	NN
8691	2796	21	or	or	CC
8691	2796	22	limb	limb	NN
8691	2796	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	2796	24	not	not	RB
8691	2796	25	contravened	contravene	VBN
8691	2796	26	by	by	IN
8691	2796	27	the	the	DT
8691	2796	28	allowance	allowance	NN
8691	2796	29	of	of	IN
8691	2796	30	such	such	PDT
8691	2796	31	a	a	DT
8691	2796	32	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	2796	33	.	.	.
8691	2797	1	The	the	DT
8691	2797	2	writ	writ	NN
8691	2797	3	of	of	IN
8691	2797	4	error	error	NN
8691	2797	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2797	6	a	a	DT
8691	2797	7	stage	stage	NN
8691	2797	8	in	in	IN
8691	2797	9	the	the	DT
8691	2797	10	original	original	JJ
8691	2797	11	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	2797	12	.	.	.
8691	2798	1	One	one	CD
8691	2798	2	acquitted	acquit	VBN
8691	2798	3	of	of	IN
8691	2798	4	crime	crime	NN
8691	2798	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2798	6	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	2798	7	not	not	RB
8691	2798	8	to	to	TO
8691	2798	9	be	be	VB
8691	2798	10	put	put	VBN
8691	2798	11	out	out	IN
8691	2798	12	of	of	IN
8691	2798	13	jeopardy	jeopardy	NN
8691	2798	14	unless	unless	IN
8691	2798	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2798	16	has	have	VBZ
8691	2798	17	been	be	VBN
8691	2798	18	acquitted	acquit	VBN
8691	2798	19	according	accord	VBG
8691	2798	20	to	to	IN
8691	2798	21	the	the	DT
8691	2798	22	forms	form	NNS
8691	2798	23	of	of	IN
8691	2798	24	law	law	NN
8691	2798	25	,	,	,
8691	2798	26	and	and	CC
8691	2798	27	after	after	IN
8691	2798	28	a	a	DT
8691	2798	29	trial	trial	NN
8691	2798	30	conducted	conduct	VBN
8691	2798	31	according	accord	VBG
8691	2798	32	to	to	IN
8691	2798	33	the	the	DT
8691	2798	34	rules	rule	NNS
8691	2798	35	of	of	IN
8691	2798	36	law	law	NN
8691	2798	37	.	.	.
8691	2799	1	What	what	WP
8691	2799	2	these	these	DT
8691	2799	3	rules	rule	NNS
8691	2799	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2799	5	,	,	,
8691	2799	6	in	in	IN
8691	2799	7	case	case	NN
8691	2799	8	of	of	IN
8691	2799	9	dispute	dispute	NN
8691	2799	10	between	between	IN
8691	2799	11	the	the	DT
8691	2799	12	government	government	NN
8691	2799	13	and	and	CC
8691	2799	14	the	the	DT
8691	2799	15	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	2799	16	,	,	,
8691	2799	17	must	must	MD
8691	2799	18	be	be	VB
8691	2799	19	determined	determine	VBN
8691	2799	20	by	by	IN
8691	2799	21	such	such	JJ
8691	2799	22	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2799	23	in	in	IN
8691	2799	24	the	the	DT
8691	2799	25	cause	cause	NN
8691	2799	26	as	as	IN
8691	2799	27	the	the	DT
8691	2799	28	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	2799	29	may	may	MD
8691	2799	30	deem	deem	VB
8691	2799	31	best	well	RBS
8691	2799	32	adapted	adapt	VBN
8691	2799	33	to	to	TO
8691	2799	34	ascertain	ascertain	VB
8691	2799	35	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2799	36	in	in	IN
8691	2799	37	an	an	DT
8691	2799	38	authoritative	authoritative	JJ
8691	2799	39	manner	manner	NN
8691	2799	40	.	.	.
8691	2800	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	2800	2	a	a	DT
8691	2800	3	mode	mode	NN
8691	2800	4	may	may	MD
8691	2800	5	properly	properly	RB
8691	2800	6	be	be	VB
8691	2800	7	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	2800	8	by	by	IN
8691	2800	9	allowing	allow	VBG
8691	2800	10	a	a	DT
8691	2800	11	resort	resort	NN
8691	2800	12	to	to	IN
8691	2800	13	a	a	DT
8691	2800	14	higher	high	JJR
8691	2800	15	court	court	NN
8691	2800	16	,	,	,
8691	2800	17	and	and	CC
8691	2800	18	a	a	DT
8691	2800	19	resort	resort	NN
8691	2800	20	in	in	IN
8691	2800	21	favor	favor	NN
8691	2800	22	of	of	IN
8691	2800	23	either	either	DT
8691	2800	24	party	party	NN
8691	2800	25	.	.	.
8691	2801	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2801	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2801	3	:	:	:
8691	2801	4	State	State	NNP
8691	2801	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2801	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2801	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2801	8	Lee	Lee	NNP
8691	2801	9	,	,	,
8691	2801	10	65	65	CD
8691	2801	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2801	12	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	2801	13	,	,	,
8691	2801	14	265	265	CD
8691	2801	15	;	;	:
8691	2801	16	30	30	CD
8691	2801	17	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	2801	18	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	2801	19	,	,	,
8691	2801	20	1110	1110	CD
8691	2801	21	;	;	:
8691	2801	22	48	48	CD
8691	2801	23	American	American	NNP
8691	2801	24	State	State	NNP
8691	2801	25	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2801	26	,	,	,
8691	2801	27	202	202	CD
8691	2801	28	;	;	:
8691	2801	29	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	2801	30	,	,	,
8691	2801	31	_	_	NNP
8691	2801	32	J	J	NNP
8691	2801	33	_	_	NNP
8691	2801	34	.	.	NNP
8691	2801	35	,	,	,
8691	2801	36	in	in	IN
8691	2801	37	People	People	NNP
8691	2801	38	_	_	NNP
8691	2801	39	v.	v.	IN
8691	2801	40	_	_	NNP
8691	2801	41	Olcott	Olcott	NNP
8691	2801	42	,	,	,
8691	2801	43	2	2	CD
8691	2801	44	Day	Day	NNP
8691	2801	45	's	's	POS
8691	2801	46	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2801	47	,	,	,
8691	2801	48	507	507	CD
8691	2801	49	,	,	,
8691	2801	50	note	note	NN
8691	2801	51	.	.	.
8691	2801	52	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2802	1	In	in	IN
8691	2802	2	other	other	JJ
8691	2802	3	States	States	NNPS
8691	2802	4	such	such	PDT
8691	2802	5	a	a	DT
8691	2802	6	review	review	NN
8691	2802	7	,	,	,
8691	2802	8	in	in	IN
8691	2802	9	favor	favor	NN
8691	2802	10	of	of	IN
8691	2802	11	the	the	DT
8691	2802	12	government	government	NN
8691	2802	13	,	,	,
8691	2802	14	of	of	IN
8691	2802	15	the	the	DT
8691	2802	16	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	2802	17	of	of	IN
8691	2802	18	the	the	DT
8691	2802	19	cause	cause	NN
8691	2802	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	2802	21	only	only	RB
8691	2802	22	supported	support	VBN
8691	2802	23	when	when	WRB
8691	2802	24	the	the	DT
8691	2802	25	exceptions	exception	NNS
8691	2802	26	taken	take	VBN
8691	2802	27	are	be	VBP
8691	2802	28	founded	found	VBN
8691	2802	29	on	on	IN
8691	2802	30	what	what	WP
8691	2802	31	may	may	MD
8691	2802	32	have	have	VB
8691	2802	33	preceded	precede	VBN
8691	2802	34	the	the	DT
8691	2802	35	trial	trial	NN
8691	2802	36	.	.	.
8691	2803	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2803	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2803	3	:	:	:
8691	2803	4	People	People	NNS
8691	2803	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2803	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2803	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2803	8	Webb	Webb	NNP
8691	2803	9	,	,	,
8691	2803	10	38	38	CD
8691	2803	11	California	California	NNP
8691	2803	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2803	13	,	,	,
8691	2803	14	467	467	CD
8691	2803	15	.	.	.
8691	2803	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2804	1	This	this	DT
8691	2804	2	distinction	distinction	NN
8691	2804	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2804	4	approved	approve	VBN
8691	2804	5	by	by	IN
8691	2804	6	the	the	DT
8691	2804	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2804	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2804	9	of	of	IN
8691	2804	10	the	the	DT
8691	2804	11	United	United	NNP
8691	2804	12	States	States	NNP
8691	2804	13	.	.	.
8691	2805	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2805	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2805	3	:	:	:
8691	2805	4	Kepner	Kepner	NNP
8691	2805	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2805	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	2805	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2805	8	United	United	NNP
8691	2805	9	States	States	NNP
8691	2805	10	,	,	,
8691	2805	11	195	195	CD
8691	2805	12	United	United	NNP
8691	2805	13	States	States	NNP
8691	2805	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2805	15	,	,	,
8691	2805	16	100	100	CD
8691	2805	17	,	,	,
8691	2805	18	130	130	CD
8691	2805	19	.	.	.
8691	2805	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2806	1	For	for	IN
8691	2806	2	errors	error	NNS
8691	2806	3	in	in	IN
8691	2806	4	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2806	5	of	of	IN
8691	2806	6	fact	fact	NN
8691	2806	7	the	the	DT
8691	2806	8	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2806	9	,	,	,
8691	2806	10	in	in	IN
8691	2806	11	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2806	12	cases	case	NNS
8691	2806	13	,	,	,
8691	2806	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	2806	15	a	a	DT
8691	2806	16	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	2806	17	on	on	IN
8691	2806	18	a	a	DT
8691	2806	19	petition	petition	NN
8691	2806	20	for	for	IN
8691	2806	21	a	a	DT
8691	2806	22	new	new	JJ
8691	2806	23	trial	trial	NN
8691	2806	24	,	,	,
8691	2806	25	but	but	CC
8691	2806	26	in	in	IN
8691	2806	27	no	no	DT
8691	2806	28	case	case	NN
8691	2806	29	can	can	MD
8691	2806	30	the	the	DT
8691	2806	31	State	State	NNP
8691	2806	32	ask	ask	VB
8691	2806	33	for	for	IN
8691	2806	34	one	one	CD
8691	2806	35	.	.	.
8691	2807	1	This	this	DT
8691	2807	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2807	3	true	true	JJ
8691	2807	4	even	even	RB
8691	2807	5	though	though	IN
8691	2807	6	the	the	DT
8691	2807	7	trial	trial	NN
8691	2807	8	was	be	VBD
8691	2807	9	not	not	RB
8691	2807	10	had	have	VBN
8691	2807	11	to	to	IN
8691	2807	12	a	a	DT
8691	2807	13	jury	jury	NN
8691	2807	14	.	.	.
8691	2808	1	There	there	EX
8691	2808	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2808	3	no	no	DT
8691	2808	4	doubt	doubt	NN
8691	2808	5	that	that	IN
8691	2808	6	new	new	JJ
8691	2808	7	trials	trial	NNS
8691	2808	8	are	be	VBP
8691	2808	9	too	too	RB
8691	2808	10	often	often	RB
8691	2808	11	granted	grant	VBN
8691	2808	12	in	in	IN
8691	2808	13	the	the	DT
8691	2808	14	United	United	NNP
8691	2808	15	States	States	NNP
8691	2808	16	in	in	IN
8691	2808	17	favor	favor	NN
8691	2808	18	of	of	IN
8691	2808	19	those	those	DT
8691	2808	20	who	who	WP
8691	2808	21	have	have	VBP
8691	2808	22	been	be	VBN
8691	2808	23	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	2808	24	of	of	IN
8691	2808	25	crime	crime	NN
8691	2808	26	.	.	.
8691	2809	1	Particularly	particularly	RB
8691	2809	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2809	3	this	this	DT
8691	2809	4	true	true	JJ
8691	2809	5	when	when	WRB
8691	2809	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2809	7	are	be	VBP
8691	2809	8	ordered	order	VBN
8691	2809	9	because	because	IN
8691	2809	10	of	of	IN
8691	2809	11	some	some	DT
8691	2809	12	irregularity	irregularity	NN
8691	2809	13	of	of	IN
8691	2809	14	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	2809	15	or	or	CC
8691	2809	16	slip	slip	NN
8691	2809	17	in	in	IN
8691	2809	18	the	the	DT
8691	2809	19	admission	admission	NN
8691	2809	20	or	or	CC
8691	2809	21	exclusion	exclusion	NN
8691	2809	22	of	of	IN
8691	2809	23	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2809	24	.	.	.
8691	2810	1	A	a	DT
8691	2810	2	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2810	3	,	,	,
8691	2810	4	whether	whether	IN
8691	2810	5	in	in	IN
8691	2810	6	a	a	DT
8691	2810	7	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2810	8	or	or	CC
8691	2810	9	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2810	10	case	case	NN
8691	2810	11	,	,	,
8691	2810	12	should	should	MD
8691	2810	13	stand	stand	VB
8691	2810	14	,	,	,
8691	2810	15	notwithstanding	notwithstanding	IN
8691	2810	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2810	17	was	be	VBD
8691	2810	18	preceded	precede	VBN
8691	2810	19	by	by	IN
8691	2810	20	erroneous	erroneous	JJ
8691	2810	21	rulings	ruling	NNS
8691	2810	22	or	or	CC
8691	2810	23	omissions	omission	NNS
8691	2810	24	of	of	IN
8691	2810	25	due	due	JJ
8691	2810	26	form	form	NN
8691	2810	27	,	,	,
8691	2810	28	unless	unless	IN
8691	2810	29	the	the	DT
8691	2810	30	court	court	NN
8691	2810	31	of	of	IN
8691	2810	32	review	review	NNP
8691	2810	33	can	can	MD
8691	2810	34	see	see	VB
8691	2810	35	that	that	IN
8691	2810	36	substantial	substantial	JJ
8691	2810	37	injustice	injustice	NN
8691	2810	38	may	may	MD
8691	2810	39	on	on	IN
8691	2810	40	that	that	DT
8691	2810	41	account	account	NN
8691	2810	42	have	have	VBP
8691	2810	43	been	be	VBN
8691	2810	44	done	do	VBN
8691	2810	45	.	.	.
8691	2811	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2811	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2811	3	:	:	:
8691	2811	4	See	see	VB
8691	2811	5	Paper	paper	NN
8691	2811	6	on	on	IN
8691	2811	7	"	"	``
8691	2811	8	New	New	NNP
8691	2811	9	Trials	Trials	NNPS
8691	2811	10	for	for	IN
8691	2811	11	Erroneous	erroneous	JJ
8691	2811	12	Rulings	Rulings	NNPS
8691	2811	13	upon	upon	IN
8691	2811	14	Evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2811	15	,	,	,
8691	2811	16	"	"	''
8691	2811	17	by	by	IN
8691	2811	18	Professor	Professor	NNP
8691	2811	19	J.	J.	NNP
8691	2811	20	H.	H.	NNP
8691	2811	21	Wigmore	Wigmore	NNP
8691	2811	22	,	,	,
8691	2811	23	in	in	IN
8691	2811	24	the	the	DT
8691	2811	25	_	_	NNP
8691	2811	26	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
8691	2811	27	Law	Law	NNP
8691	2811	28	Review	Review	NNP
8691	2811	29	_	_	NNP
8691	2811	30	for	for	IN
8691	2811	31	November	November	NNP
8691	2811	32	,	,	,
8691	2811	33	1903	1903	CD
8691	2811	34	.	.	.
8691	2811	35	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2812	1	To	to	TO
8691	2812	2	release	release	VB
8691	2812	3	a	a	DT
8691	2812	4	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	2812	5	criminal	criminal	NN
8691	2812	6	for	for	IN
8691	2812	7	error	error	NN
8691	2812	8	in	in	IN
8691	2812	9	mere	mere	JJ
8691	2812	10	technicalities	technicality	NNS
8691	2812	11	not	not	RB
8691	2812	12	really	really	RB
8691	2812	13	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	2812	14	the	the	DT
8691	2812	15	question	question	NN
8691	2812	16	of	of	IN
8691	2812	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2812	18	guilt	guilt	NN
8691	2812	19	tends	tend	VBZ
8691	2812	20	to	to	TO
8691	2812	21	make	make	VB
8691	2812	22	the	the	DT
8691	2812	23	people	people	NNS
8691	2812	24	lose	lose	VB
8691	2812	25	faith	faith	NN
8691	2812	26	in	in	IN
8691	2812	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2812	28	courts	court	NNS
8691	2812	29	and	and	CC
8691	2812	30	resort	resort	VB
8691	2812	31	to	to	IN
8691	2812	32	lynch	lynch	NNP
8691	2812	33	law	law	NNP
8691	2812	34	as	as	IN
8691	2812	35	a	a	DT
8691	2812	36	surer	sure	JJR
8691	2812	37	and	and	CC
8691	2812	38	swifter	swifter	JJ
8691	2812	39	mode	mode	NN
8691	2812	40	of	of	IN
8691	2812	41	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	2812	42	.	.	.
8691	2813	1	Appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	2813	2	in	in	IN
8691	2813	3	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2813	4	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2813	5	are	be	VBP
8691	2813	6	,	,	,
8691	2813	7	however	however	RB
8691	2813	8	,	,	,
8691	2813	9	much	much	JJ
8691	2813	10	rarer	rare	JJR
8691	2813	11	and	and	CC
8691	2813	12	also	also	RB
8691	2813	13	much	much	RB
8691	2813	14	less	less	RBR
8691	2813	15	often	often	RB
8691	2813	16	successful	successful	JJ
8691	2813	17	than	than	IN
8691	2813	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	2813	19	generally	generally	RB
8691	2813	20	supposed	suppose	VBN
8691	2813	21	.	.	.
8691	2814	1	About	about	RB
8691	2814	2	eleven	eleven	CD
8691	2814	3	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	2814	4	persons	person	NNS
8691	2814	5	were	be	VBD
8691	2814	6	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	2814	7	of	of	IN
8691	2814	8	felonies	felony	NNS
8691	2814	9	in	in	IN
8691	2814	10	the	the	DT
8691	2814	11	County	County	NNP
8691	2814	12	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	2814	13	of	of	IN
8691	2814	14	New	New	NNP
8691	2814	15	York	York	NNP
8691	2814	16	during	during	IN
8691	2814	17	the	the	DT
8691	2814	18	five	five	CD
8691	2814	19	years	year	NNS
8691	2814	20	from	from	IN
8691	2814	21	1898	1898	CD
8691	2814	22	to	to	IN
8691	2814	23	1902	1902	CD
8691	2814	24	,	,	,
8691	2814	25	inclusive	inclusive	JJ
8691	2814	26	of	of	IN
8691	2814	27	each	each	DT
8691	2814	28	,	,	,
8691	2814	29	and	and	CC
8691	2814	30	of	of	IN
8691	2814	31	these	these	DT
8691	2814	32	less	less	JJR
8691	2814	33	than	than	IN
8691	2814	34	nine	nine	CD
8691	2814	35	in	in	IN
8691	2814	36	a	a	DT
8691	2814	37	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	2814	38	pursued	pursue	VBD
8691	2814	39	an	an	DT
8691	2814	40	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2814	41	,	,	,
8691	2814	42	not	not	RB
8691	2814	43	a	a	DT
8691	2814	44	third	third	NN
8691	2814	45	of	of	IN
8691	2814	46	whom	whom	WP
8691	2814	47	secured	secure	VBD
8691	2814	48	a	a	DT
8691	2814	49	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2814	50	of	of	IN
8691	2814	51	reversal	reversal	NN
8691	2814	52	.	.	.
8691	2815	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2815	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2815	3	:	:	:
8691	2815	4	Nathan	Nathan	NNP
8691	2815	5	A.	A.	NNP
8691	2815	6	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
8691	2815	7	,	,	,
8691	2815	8	_	_	NNP
8691	2815	9	Harvard	Harvard	NNP
8691	2815	10	Law	Law	NNP
8691	2815	11	Review	Review	NNP
8691	2815	12	_	_	NNP
8691	2815	13	for	for	IN
8691	2815	14	March	March	NNP
8691	2815	15	,	,	,
8691	2815	16	1904	1904	CD
8691	2815	17	.	.	.
8691	2815	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2816	1	In	in	IN
8691	2816	2	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	2816	3	,	,	,
8691	2816	4	about	about	RB
8691	2816	5	a	a	DT
8691	2816	6	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	2816	7	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	2816	8	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2816	9	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	2816	10	are	be	VBP
8691	2816	11	annually	annually	RB
8691	2816	12	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2816	13	,	,	,
8691	2816	14	and	and	CC
8691	2816	15	the	the	DT
8691	2816	16	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	2816	17	to	to	IN
8691	2816	18	the	the	DT
8691	2816	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2816	20	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	2816	21	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2816	22	from	from	IN
8691	2816	23	sentences	sentence	NNS
8691	2816	24	of	of	IN
8691	2816	25	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	2816	26	rarely	rarely	RB
8691	2816	27	exceed	exceed	VBP
8691	2816	28	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	2816	29	to	to	TO
8691	2816	30	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	2816	31	-	-	HYPH
8691	2816	32	five	five	CD
8691	2816	33	in	in	IN
8691	2816	34	number	number	NN
8691	2816	35	,	,	,
8691	2816	36	and	and	CC
8691	2816	37	upon	upon	IN
8691	2816	38	these	these	DT
8691	2816	39	in	in	IN
8691	2816	40	each	each	DT
8691	2816	41	of	of	IN
8691	2816	42	the	the	DT
8691	2816	43	years	year	NNS
8691	2816	44	1902	1902	CD
8691	2816	45	and	and	CC
8691	2816	46	1903	1903	CD
8691	2816	47	only	only	RB
8691	2816	48	two	two	CD
8691	2816	49	new	new	JJ
8691	2816	50	trials	trial	NNS
8691	2816	51	were	be	VBD
8691	2816	52	granted	grant	VBN
8691	2816	53	.	.	.
8691	2817	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2817	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2817	3	:	:	:
8691	2817	4	_	_	NNP
8691	2817	5	Law	Law	NNP
8691	2817	6	Notes	Notes	NNPS
8691	2817	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2817	8	for	for	IN
8691	2817	9	December	December	NNP
8691	2817	10	,	,	,
8691	2817	11	1904	1904	CD
8691	2817	12	.	.	.
8691	2817	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2818	1	A	a	DT
8691	2818	2	comparison	comparison	NN
8691	2818	3	of	of	IN
8691	2818	4	the	the	DT
8691	2818	5	number	number	NN
8691	2818	6	of	of	IN
8691	2818	7	those	those	DT
8691	2818	8	put	put	VBN
8691	2818	9	to	to	IN
8691	2818	10	death	death	NN
8691	2818	11	in	in	IN
8691	2818	12	the	the	DT
8691	2818	13	United	United	NNP
8691	2818	14	States	States	NNP
8691	2818	15	for	for	IN
8691	2818	16	crime	crime	NN
8691	2818	17	by	by	IN
8691	2818	18	the	the	DT
8691	2818	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	2818	20	,	,	,
8691	2818	21	and	and	CC
8691	2818	22	on	on	IN
8691	2818	23	a	a	DT
8691	2818	24	charge	charge	NN
8691	2818	25	of	of	IN
8691	2818	26	crime	crime	NN
8691	2818	27	by	by	IN
8691	2818	28	a	a	DT
8691	2818	29	mob	mob	NN
8691	2818	30	,	,	,
8691	2818	31	for	for	IN
8691	2818	32	the	the	DT
8691	2818	33	past	past	JJ
8691	2818	34	three	three	CD
8691	2818	35	years	year	NNS
8691	2818	36	shows	show	VBZ
8691	2818	37	these	these	DT
8691	2818	38	results	result	NNS
8691	2818	39	:	:	:
8691	2818	40	Executed	execute	VBN
8691	2818	41	by	by	IN
8691	2818	42	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	2818	43	Sentence	Sentence	NNP
8691	2818	44	.	.	.
8691	2819	1	Lynched	lynch	VBN
8691	2819	2	.	.	.
8691	2820	1	Total	total	JJ
8691	2820	2	.	.	.
8691	2821	1	1901	1901	CD
8691	2821	2	118	118	CD
8691	2821	3	125	125	CD
8691	2821	4	243	243	CD
8691	2821	5	1902	1902	CD
8691	2821	6	144	144	CD
8691	2821	7	96	96	CD
8691	2821	8	240	240	CD
8691	2821	9	1903	1903	CD
8691	2821	10	123	123	CD
8691	2821	11	125	125	CD
8691	2821	12	248	248	CD
8691	2821	13	A	a	DT
8691	2821	14	large	large	JJ
8691	2821	15	majority	majority	NN
8691	2821	16	of	of	IN
8691	2821	17	those	those	DT
8691	2821	18	lynched	lynch	VBN
8691	2821	19	were	be	VBD
8691	2821	20	negroes	negro	NNS
8691	2821	21	,	,	,
8691	2821	22	and	and	CC
8691	2821	23	met	meet	VBD
8691	2821	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2821	25	fate	fate	NN
8691	2821	26	in	in	IN
8691	2821	27	the	the	DT
8691	2821	28	South	South	NNP
8691	2821	29	.	.	.
8691	2822	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2822	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2822	3	extremely	extremely	RB
8691	2822	4	difficult	difficult	JJ
8691	2822	5	to	to	TO
8691	2822	6	secure	secure	VB
8691	2822	7	a	a	DT
8691	2822	8	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	2822	9	of	of	IN
8691	2822	10	those	those	DT
8691	2822	11	who	who	WP
8691	2822	12	take	take	VBP
8691	2822	13	part	part	NN
8691	2822	14	in	in	IN
8691	2822	15	such	such	JJ
8691	2822	16	acts	act	NNS
8691	2822	17	of	of	IN
8691	2822	18	violence	violence	NN
8691	2822	19	.	.	.
8691	2823	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2823	2	commit	commit	VBP
8691	2823	3	the	the	DT
8691	2823	4	crime	crime	NN
8691	2823	5	of	of	IN
8691	2823	6	murder	murder	NN
8691	2823	7	,	,	,
8691	2823	8	and	and	CC
8691	2823	9	the	the	DT
8691	2823	10	penalty	penalty	NN
8691	2823	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2823	12	so	so	RB
8691	2823	13	heavy	heavy	JJ
8691	2823	14	that	that	IN
8691	2823	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2823	16	fellow	fellow	JJ
8691	2823	17	-	-	HYPH
8691	2823	18	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	2823	19	are	be	VBP
8691	2823	20	unwilling	unwilling	JJ
8691	2823	21	to	to	TO
8691	2823	22	subject	subject	VB
8691	2823	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2823	24	to	to	IN
8691	2823	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2823	26	.	.	.
8691	2824	1	The	the	DT
8691	2824	2	offenses	offense	NNS
8691	2824	3	with	with	IN
8691	2824	4	which	which	WDT
8691	2824	5	the	the	DT
8691	2824	6	men	man	NNS
8691	2824	7	whom	whom	WP
8691	2824	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2824	9	kill	kill	VBP
8691	2824	10	are	be	VBP
8691	2824	11	charged	charge	VBN
8691	2824	12	are	be	VBP
8691	2824	13	also	also	RB
8691	2824	14	generally	generally	RB
8691	2824	15	of	of	IN
8691	2824	16	a	a	DT
8691	2824	17	nature	nature	NN
8691	2824	18	which	which	WDT
8691	2824	19	make	make	VBP
8691	2824	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2824	21	peculiarly	peculiarly	JJ
8691	2824	22	offensive	offensive	NN
8691	2824	23	to	to	IN
8691	2824	24	the	the	DT
8691	2824	25	community	community	NN
8691	2824	26	.	.	.
8691	2825	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	2825	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2825	3	negroes	negro	NNS
8691	2825	4	charged	charge	VBN
8691	2825	5	with	with	IN
8691	2825	6	the	the	DT
8691	2825	7	rape	rape	NN
8691	2825	8	of	of	IN
8691	2825	9	a	a	DT
8691	2825	10	white	white	JJ
8691	2825	11	woman	woman	NN
8691	2825	12	,	,	,
8691	2825	13	to	to	TO
8691	2825	14	whom	whom	WP
8691	2825	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2825	16	would	would	MD
8691	2825	17	be	be	VB
8691	2825	18	intensely	intensely	RB
8691	2825	19	disagreeable	disagreeable	JJ
8691	2825	20	to	to	TO
8691	2825	21	testify	testify	VB
8691	2825	22	against	against	IN
8691	2825	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2825	24	.	.	.
8691	2826	1	Not	not	RB
8691	2826	2	a	a	DT
8691	2826	3	few	few	JJ
8691	2826	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2826	5	men	man	NNS
8691	2826	6	under	under	IN
8691	2826	7	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	2826	8	of	of	IN
8691	2826	9	death	death	NN
8691	2826	10	,	,	,
8691	2826	11	who	who	WP
8691	2826	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2826	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	2826	14	feared	fear	VBN
8691	2826	15	may	may	MD
8691	2826	16	escape	escape	VB
8691	2826	17	or	or	CC
8691	2826	18	delay	delay	VB
8691	2826	19	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	2826	20	by	by	IN
8691	2826	21	an	an	DT
8691	2826	22	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2826	23	.	.	.
8691	2827	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	2827	2	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	2827	3	can	can	MD
8691	2827	4	not	not	RB
8691	2827	5	excuse	excuse	VB
8691	2827	6	,	,	,
8691	2827	7	but	but	CC
8691	2827	8	present	present	VB
8691	2827	9	some	some	DT
8691	2827	10	slight	slight	JJ
8691	2827	11	palliation	palliation	NN
8691	2827	12	for	for	IN
8691	2827	13	those	those	DT
8691	2827	14	acts	act	NNS
8691	2827	15	of	of	IN
8691	2827	16	mob	mob	NN
8691	2827	17	violence	violence	NN
8691	2827	18	by	by	IN
8691	2827	19	which	which	WDT
8691	2827	20	the	the	DT
8691	2827	21	people	people	NNS
8691	2827	22	of	of	IN
8691	2827	23	the	the	DT
8691	2827	24	United	United	NNP
8691	2827	25	States	States	NNP
8691	2827	26	are	be	VBP
8691	2827	27	so	so	RB
8691	2827	28	often	often	RB
8691	2827	29	disgraced	disgrace	VBN
8691	2827	30	.	.	.
8691	2828	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2828	2	may	may	MD
8691	2828	3	be	be	VB
8691	2828	4	added	add	VBN
8691	2828	5	that	that	IN
8691	2828	6	out	out	IN
8691	2828	7	of	of	IN
8691	2828	8	the	the	DT
8691	2828	9	Southern	Southern	NNP
8691	2828	10	States	States	NNPS
8691	2828	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2828	12	are	be	VBP
8691	2828	13	quite	quite	RB
8691	2828	14	rare	rare	JJ
8691	2828	15	,	,	,
8691	2828	16	and	and	CC
8691	2828	17	in	in	IN
8691	2828	18	the	the	DT
8691	2828	19	Northeastern	Northeastern	NNP
8691	2828	20	States	States	NNPS
8691	2828	21	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	2828	22	unknown	unknown	JJ
8691	2828	23	.	.	.
8691	2829	1	Of	of	IN
8691	2829	2	the	the	DT
8691	2829	3	one	one	CD
8691	2829	4	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	2829	5	and	and	CC
8691	2829	6	four	four	CD
8691	2829	7	lynchings	lynching	NNS
8691	2829	8	in	in	IN
8691	2829	9	1903	1903	CD
8691	2829	10	,	,	,
8691	2829	11	only	only	RB
8691	2829	12	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	2829	13	occurred	occur	VBD
8691	2829	14	in	in	IN
8691	2829	15	the	the	DT
8691	2829	16	North	North	NNP
8691	2829	17	or	or	CC
8691	2829	18	West	West	NNP
8691	2829	19	.	.	.
8691	2830	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2830	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2830	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2830	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2830	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2830	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	2830	7	XVIII	xviii	VBP
8691	2830	8	THE	the	DT
8691	2830	9	EXERCISE	EXERCISE	NNP
8691	2830	10	OF	of	IN
8691	2830	11	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	2830	12	FUNCTIONS	FUNCTIONS	NNP
8691	2830	13	OUT	out	RB
8691	2830	14	OF	of	IN
8691	2830	15	COURT	court	NN
8691	2830	16	A	a	DT
8691	2830	17	public	public	JJ
8691	2830	18	officer	officer	NN
8691	2830	19	,	,	,
8691	2830	20	whose	whose	WP$
8691	2830	21	duties	duty	NNS
8691	2830	22	are	be	VBP
8691	2830	23	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	2830	24	other	other	JJ
8691	2830	25	than	than	IN
8691	2830	26	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2830	27	,	,	,
8691	2830	28	may	may	MD
8691	2830	29	be	be	VB
8691	2830	30	invested	invest	VBN
8691	2830	31	with	with	IN
8691	2830	32	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2830	33	power	power	NN
8691	2830	34	to	to	TO
8691	2830	35	be	be	VB
8691	2830	36	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	2830	37	only	only	RB
8691	2830	38	in	in	IN
8691	2830	39	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2830	40	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2830	41	which	which	WDT
8691	2830	42	may	may	MD
8691	2830	43	be	be	VB
8691	2830	44	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2830	45	before	before	IN
8691	2830	46	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2830	47	,	,	,
8691	2830	48	in	in	IN
8691	2830	49	disposing	dispose	VBG
8691	2830	50	of	of	IN
8691	2830	51	which	which	WDT
8691	2830	52	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2830	53	acts	act	VBZ
8691	2830	54	as	as	IN
8691	2830	55	a	a	DT
8691	2830	56	court	court	NN
8691	2830	57	.	.	.
8691	2831	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	2831	2	an	an	DT
8691	2831	3	one	one	NN
8691	2831	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	2831	5	a	a	DT
8691	2831	6	judge	judge	NN
8691	2831	7	only	only	RB
8691	2831	8	when	when	WRB
8691	2831	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2831	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2831	11	holding	hold	VBG
8691	2831	12	court	court	NN
8691	2831	13	.	.	.
8691	2832	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2832	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2832	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2832	4	adjourned	adjourn	VBN
8691	2832	5	,	,	,
8691	2832	6	no	no	DT
8691	2832	7	court	court	NN
8691	2832	8	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	2832	9	of	of	IN
8691	2832	10	which	which	WDT
8691	2832	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2832	12	could	could	MD
8691	2832	13	be	be	VB
8691	2832	14	a	a	DT
8691	2832	15	judge	judge	NN
8691	2832	16	.	.	.
8691	2833	1	Justices	justice	NNS
8691	2833	2	of	of	IN
8691	2833	3	the	the	DT
8691	2833	4	peace	peace	NN
8691	2833	5	and	and	CC
8691	2833	6	parish	parish	JJ
8691	2833	7	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2833	8	are	be	VBP
8691	2833	9	officers	officer	NNS
8691	2833	10	of	of	IN
8691	2833	11	this	this	DT
8691	2833	12	description	description	NN
8691	2833	13	.	.	.
8691	2834	1	But	but	CC
8691	2834	2	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2834	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2834	4	are	be	VBP
8691	2834	5	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	2834	6	to	to	TO
8691	2834	7	hold	hold	VB
8691	2834	8	some	some	DT
8691	2834	9	regular	regular	JJ
8691	2834	10	court	court	NN
8691	2834	11	,	,	,
8691	2834	12	with	with	IN
8691	2834	13	stated	stated	JJ
8691	2834	14	sessions	session	NNS
8691	2834	15	,	,	,
8691	2834	16	which	which	WDT
8691	2834	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	2834	18	always	always	RB
8691	2834	19	in	in	IN
8691	2834	20	existence	existence	NN
8691	2834	21	.	.	.
8691	2835	1	To	to	IN
8691	2835	2	such	such	PDT
8691	2835	3	a	a	DT
8691	2835	4	judge	judge	NN
8691	2835	5	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2835	6	powers	power	NNS
8691	2835	7	of	of	IN
8691	2835	8	a	a	DT
8691	2835	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2835	10	nature	nature	NN
8691	2835	11	are	be	VBP
8691	2835	12	usually	usually	RB
8691	2835	13	given	give	VBN
8691	2835	14	for	for	IN
8691	2835	15	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	2835	16	when	when	WRB
8691	2835	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2835	18	court	court	NN
8691	2835	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	2835	20	not	not	RB
8691	2835	21	in	in	IN
8691	2835	22	session	session	NN
8691	2835	23	.	.	.
8691	2836	1	The	the	DT
8691	2836	2	writ	writ	NN
8691	2836	3	of	of	IN
8691	2836	4	_	_	NNP
8691	2836	5	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	2836	6	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	2836	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2836	8	,	,	,
8691	2836	9	for	for	IN
8691	2836	10	instance	instance	NN
8691	2836	11	,	,	,
8691	2836	12	may	may	MD
8691	2836	13	be	be	VB
8691	2836	14	issued	issue	VBN
8691	2836	15	either	either	CC
8691	2836	16	by	by	IN
8691	2836	17	a	a	DT
8691	2836	18	court	court	NN
8691	2836	19	of	of	IN
8691	2836	20	record	record	NN
8691	2836	21	or	or	CC
8691	2836	22	by	by	IN
8691	2836	23	a	a	DT
8691	2836	24	judge	judge	NN
8691	2836	25	of	of	IN
8691	2836	26	such	such	PDT
8691	2836	27	a	a	DT
8691	2836	28	court	court	NN
8691	2836	29	,	,	,
8691	2836	30	if	if	IN
8691	2836	31	applied	apply	VBN
8691	2836	32	for	for	IN
8691	2836	33	when	when	WRB
8691	2836	34	the	the	DT
8691	2836	35	court	court	NN
8691	2836	36	is	be	VBZ
8691	2836	37	not	not	RB
8691	2836	38	in	in	IN
8691	2836	39	actual	actual	JJ
8691	2836	40	session	session	NN
8691	2836	41	.	.	.
8691	2837	1	In	in	IN
8691	2837	2	the	the	DT
8691	2837	3	latter	latter	JJ
8691	2837	4	case	case	NN
8691	2837	5	,	,	,
8691	2837	6	the	the	DT
8691	2837	7	return	return	NN
8691	2837	8	of	of	IN
8691	2837	9	the	the	DT
8691	2837	10	writ	writ	NNP
8691	2837	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2837	12	made	make	VBN
8691	2837	13	to	to	IN
8691	2837	14	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2837	15	,	,	,
8691	2837	16	the	the	DT
8691	2837	17	trial	trial	NN
8691	2837	18	had	have	VBD
8691	2837	19	before	before	IN
8691	2837	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2837	21	,	,	,
8691	2837	22	and	and	CC
8691	2837	23	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2837	24	rendered	render	VBN
8691	2837	25	out	out	IN
8691	2837	26	of	of	IN
8691	2837	27	court	court	NN
8691	2837	28	,	,	,
8691	2837	29	or	or	CC
8691	2837	30	,	,	,
8691	2837	31	as	as	IN
8691	2837	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2837	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	2837	34	styled	style	VBN
8691	2837	35	,	,	,
8691	2837	36	"	"	''
8691	2837	37	at	at	IN
8691	2837	38	chambers	chamber	NNS
8691	2837	39	.	.	.
8691	2837	40	"	"	''
8691	2838	1	While	while	IN
8691	2838	2	sitting	sit	VBG
8691	2838	3	for	for	IN
8691	2838	4	such	such	PDT
8691	2838	5	a	a	DT
8691	2838	6	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2838	7	,	,	,
8691	2838	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2838	9	may	may	MD
8691	2838	10	be	be	VB
8691	2838	11	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	2838	12	as	as	IN
8691	2838	13	exercising	exercise	VBG
8691	2838	14	functions	function	NNS
8691	2838	15	which	which	WDT
8691	2838	16	really	really	RB
8691	2838	17	belong	belong	VBP
8691	2838	18	to	to	IN
8691	2838	19	the	the	DT
8691	2838	20	court	court	NN
8691	2838	21	and	and	CC
8691	2838	22	acting	act	VBG
8691	2838	23	as	as	IN
8691	2838	24	a	a	DT
8691	2838	25	part	part	NN
8691	2838	26	of	of	IN
8691	2838	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2838	28	.	.	.
8691	2839	1	Statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2839	2	often	often	RB
8691	2839	3	,	,	,
8691	2839	4	in	in	IN
8691	2839	5	case	case	NN
8691	2839	6	of	of	IN
8691	2839	7	a	a	DT
8691	2839	8	court	court	NN
8691	2839	9	having	have	VBG
8691	2839	10	but	but	CC
8691	2839	11	a	a	DT
8691	2839	12	single	single	JJ
8691	2839	13	judge	judge	NN
8691	2839	14	,	,	,
8691	2839	15	give	give	VB
8691	2839	16	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2839	17	power	power	NN
8691	2839	18	to	to	TO
8691	2839	19	hold	hold	VB
8691	2839	20	special	special	JJ
8691	2839	21	courts	court	NNS
8691	2839	22	whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	2839	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2839	24	may	may	MD
8691	2839	25	think	think	VB
8691	2839	26	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2839	27	.	.	.
8691	2840	1	In	in	IN
8691	2840	2	such	such	PDT
8691	2840	3	a	a	DT
8691	2840	4	case	case	NN
8691	2840	5	no	no	DT
8691	2840	6	very	very	RB
8691	2840	7	definite	definite	JJ
8691	2840	8	line	line	NN
8691	2840	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	2840	10	drawn	draw	VBN
8691	2840	11	between	between	IN
8691	2840	12	what	what	WP
8691	2840	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2840	14	business	business	NN
8691	2840	15	the	the	DT
8691	2840	16	judge	judge	NN
8691	2840	17	does	do	VBZ
8691	2840	18	and	and	CC
8691	2840	19	what	what	WP
8691	2840	20	the	the	DT
8691	2840	21	court	court	NN
8691	2840	22	does	do	VBZ
8691	2840	23	.	.	.
8691	2841	1	While	while	IN
8691	2841	2	the	the	DT
8691	2841	3	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2841	4	and	and	CC
8691	2841	5	normal	normal	JJ
8691	2841	6	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	2841	7	of	of	IN
8691	2841	8	a	a	DT
8691	2841	9	court	court	NN
8691	2841	10	of	of	IN
8691	2841	11	record	record	NN
8691	2841	12	requires	require	VBZ
8691	2841	13	the	the	DT
8691	2841	14	attendance	attendance	NN
8691	2841	15	not	not	RB
8691	2841	16	only	only	RB
8691	2841	17	of	of	IN
8691	2841	18	a	a	DT
8691	2841	19	judge	judge	NN
8691	2841	20	,	,	,
8691	2841	21	but	but	CC
8691	2841	22	of	of	IN
8691	2841	23	a	a	DT
8691	2841	24	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	2841	25	and	and	CC
8691	2841	26	a	a	DT
8691	2841	27	crier	crier	NN
8691	2841	28	or	or	CC
8691	2841	29	sheriff	sheriff	NNP
8691	2841	30	's	's	POS
8691	2841	31	officer	officer	NN
8691	2841	32	,	,	,
8691	2841	33	the	the	DT
8691	2841	34	only	only	JJ
8691	2841	35	one	one	CD
8691	2841	36	whose	whose	WP$
8691	2841	37	presence	presence	NN
8691	2841	38	is	be	VBZ
8691	2841	39	indispensable	indispensable	JJ
8691	2841	40	is	be	VBZ
8691	2841	41	the	the	DT
8691	2841	42	judge	judge	NN
8691	2841	43	.	.	.
8691	2842	1	A	a	DT
8691	2842	2	District	District	NNP
8691	2842	3	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	2842	4	of	of	IN
8691	2842	5	the	the	DT
8691	2842	6	United	United	NNP
8691	2842	7	States	States	NNP
8691	2842	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	2842	9	this	this	DT
8691	2842	10	power	power	NN
8691	2842	11	of	of	IN
8691	2842	12	holding	hold	VBG
8691	2842	13	special	special	JJ
8691	2842	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	2842	15	,	,	,
8691	2842	16	and	and	CC
8691	2842	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	2842	18	a	a	DT
8691	2842	19	court	court	NN
8691	2842	20	wherever	wherever	WRB
8691	2842	21	and	and	CC
8691	2842	22	whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	2842	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2842	24	pleases	please	VBZ
8691	2842	25	to	to	TO
8691	2842	26	transact	transact	VB
8691	2842	27	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2842	28	business	business	NN
8691	2842	29	,	,	,
8691	2842	30	whether	whether	IN
8691	2842	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2842	32	describes	describe	VBZ
8691	2842	33	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2842	34	in	in	IN
8691	2842	35	such	such	JJ
8691	2842	36	papers	paper	NNS
8691	2842	37	or	or	CC
8691	2842	38	process	process	NN
8691	2842	39	as	as	IN
8691	2842	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2842	41	may	may	MD
8691	2842	42	issue	issue	VB
8691	2842	43	,	,	,
8691	2842	44	as	as	IN
8691	2842	45	court	court	NN
8691	2842	46	or	or	CC
8691	2842	47	judge	judge	NN
8691	2842	48	.	.	.
8691	2843	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2843	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2843	3	:	:	:
8691	2843	4	The	the	DT
8691	2843	5	U.	U.	NNP
8691	2843	6	S.	S.	NNP
8691	2843	7	_	_	NNP
8691	2843	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	2843	9	_	_	NNP
8691	2843	10	The	the	DT
8691	2843	11	Schooner	Schooner	NNP
8691	2843	12	"	"	``
8691	2843	13	Little	little	JJ
8691	2843	14	Charles	Charles	NNP
8691	2843	15	,	,	,
8691	2843	16	"	"	''
8691	2843	17	1	1	CD
8691	2843	18	Brockenbrough	Brockenbrough	NNP
8691	2843	19	's	's	POS
8691	2843	20	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2843	21	,	,	,
8691	2843	22	382	382	CD
8691	2843	23	.	.	.
8691	2843	24	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2844	1	The	the	DT
8691	2844	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2844	3	of	of	IN
8691	2844	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	2844	5	having	have	VBG
8691	2844	6	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	2844	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2844	8	act	act	NN
8691	2844	9	often	often	RB
8691	2844	10	out	out	IN
8691	2844	11	of	of	IN
8691	2844	12	court	court	NN
8691	2844	13	in	in	IN
8691	2844	14	the	the	DT
8691	2844	15	issue	issue	NN
8691	2844	16	of	of	IN
8691	2844	17	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	2844	18	injunctions	injunction	NNS
8691	2844	19	.	.	.
8691	2845	1	These	these	DT
8691	2845	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2845	3	writs	writ	NNS
8691	2845	4	directing	direct	VBG
8691	2845	5	some	some	DT
8691	2845	6	one	one	NN
8691	2845	7	to	to	TO
8691	2845	8	refrain	refrain	VB
8691	2845	9	from	from	IN
8691	2845	10	doing	do	VBG
8691	2845	11	a	a	DT
8691	2845	12	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2845	13	act	act	NN
8691	2845	14	.	.	.
8691	2846	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2846	2	generally	generally	RB
8691	2846	3	direct	direct	VBP
8691	2846	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2846	5	under	under	IN
8691	2846	6	pain	pain	NN
8691	2846	7	of	of	IN
8691	2846	8	a	a	DT
8691	2846	9	specified	specified	JJ
8691	2846	10	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
8691	2846	11	forfeiture	forfeiture	NN
8691	2846	12	;	;	:
8691	2846	13	but	but	CC
8691	2846	14	whether	whether	IN
8691	2846	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2846	16	do	do	VBP
8691	2846	17	so	so	RB
8691	2846	18	or	or	CC
8691	2846	19	not	not	RB
8691	2846	20	,	,	,
8691	2846	21	disobedience	disobedience	NN
8691	2846	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	2846	23	punishable	punishable	JJ
8691	2846	24	also	also	RB
8691	2846	25	by	by	IN
8691	2846	26	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2846	27	and	and	CC
8691	2846	28	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	2846	29	,	,	,
8691	2846	30	being	be	VBG
8691	2846	31	treated	treat	VBN
8691	2846	32	as	as	IN
8691	2846	33	a	a	DT
8691	2846	34	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	2846	35	of	of	IN
8691	2846	36	court	court	NN
8691	2846	37	.	.	.
8691	2847	1	The	the	DT
8691	2847	2	need	need	NN
8691	2847	3	of	of	IN
8691	2847	4	an	an	DT
8691	2847	5	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	2847	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2847	7	often	often	RB
8691	2847	8	immediate	immediate	JJ
8691	2847	9	.	.	.
8691	2848	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2848	2	would	would	MD
8691	2848	3	be	be	VB
8691	2848	4	worthless	worthless	JJ
8691	2848	5	unless	unless	IN
8691	2848	6	promptly	promptly	RB
8691	2848	7	granted	grant	VBN
8691	2848	8	.	.	.
8691	2849	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2849	2	,	,	,
8691	2849	3	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	2849	4	,	,	,
8691	2849	5	no	no	DT
8691	2849	6	court	court	NN
8691	2849	7	having	have	VBG
8691	2849	8	power	power	NN
8691	2849	9	to	to	TO
8691	2849	10	issue	issue	VB
8691	2849	11	one	one	CD
8691	2849	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2849	13	in	in	IN
8691	2849	14	actual	actual	JJ
8691	2849	15	session	session	NN
8691	2849	16	,	,	,
8691	2849	17	there	there	EX
8691	2849	18	would	would	MD
8691	2849	19	be	be	VB
8691	2849	20	a	a	DT
8691	2849	21	failure	failure	NN
8691	2849	22	of	of	IN
8691	2849	23	justice	justice	NN
8691	2849	24	if	if	IN
8691	2849	25	the	the	DT
8691	2849	26	judge	judge	NN
8691	2849	27	could	could	MD
8691	2849	28	not	not	RB
8691	2849	29	act	act	VB
8691	2849	30	to	to	IN
8691	2849	31	the	the	DT
8691	2849	32	extent	extent	NN
8691	2849	33	of	of	IN
8691	2849	34	granting	grant	VBG
8691	2849	35	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	2849	36	relief	relief	NN
8691	2849	37	.	.	.
8691	2850	1	Whether	whether	IN
8691	2850	2	the	the	DT
8691	2850	3	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	2850	4	should	should	MD
8691	2850	5	be	be	VB
8691	2850	6	made	make	VBN
8691	2850	7	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	2850	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2850	9	a	a	DT
8691	2850	10	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	2850	11	question	question	NN
8691	2850	12	,	,	,
8691	2850	13	to	to	TO
8691	2850	14	be	be	VB
8691	2850	15	determined	determine	VBN
8691	2850	16	after	after	IN
8691	2850	17	a	a	DT
8691	2850	18	full	full	JJ
8691	2850	19	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	2850	20	by	by	IN
8691	2850	21	the	the	DT
8691	2850	22	court	court	NN
8691	2850	23	.	.	.
8691	2851	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2851	2	may	may	MD
8691	2851	3	,	,	,
8691	2851	4	in	in	IN
8691	2851	5	urgent	urgent	JJ
8691	2851	6	cases	case	NNS
8691	2851	7	admitting	admit	VBG
8691	2851	8	of	of	IN
8691	2851	9	no	no	DT
8691	2851	10	delay	delay	NN
8691	2851	11	,	,	,
8691	2851	12	be	be	VB
8691	2851	13	issued	issue	VBN
8691	2851	14	_	_	NNP
8691	2851	15	ex	ex	NNP
8691	2851	16	parte	parte	NNP
8691	2851	17	_	_	NNP
8691	2851	18	,	,	,
8691	2851	19	but	but	CC
8691	2851	20	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2851	21	the	the	DT
8691	2851	22	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	2851	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	2851	24	notified	notify	VBN
8691	2851	25	and	and	CC
8691	2851	26	has	have	VBZ
8691	2851	27	an	an	DT
8691	2851	28	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	2851	29	for	for	IN
8691	2851	30	a	a	DT
8691	2851	31	summary	summary	NN
8691	2851	32	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	2851	33	,	,	,
8691	2851	34	either	either	CC
8691	2851	35	orally	orally	RB
8691	2851	36	or	or	CC
8691	2851	37	on	on	IN
8691	2851	38	affidavits	affidavit	NNS
8691	2851	39	,	,	,
8691	2851	40	before	before	IN
8691	2851	41	action	action	NN
8691	2851	42	is	be	VBZ
8691	2851	43	taken	take	VBN
8691	2851	44	.	.	.
8691	2852	1	A	a	DT
8691	2852	2	similar	similar	JJ
8691	2852	3	power	power	NN
8691	2852	4	often	often	RB
8691	2852	5	vested	vest	VBN
8691	2852	6	in	in	IN
8691	2852	7	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2852	8	at	at	IN
8691	2852	9	chambers	chamber	NNS
8691	2852	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2852	11	that	that	DT
8691	2852	12	of	of	IN
8691	2852	13	appointing	appoint	VBG
8691	2852	14	a	a	DT
8691	2852	15	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	2852	16	receiver	receiver	NN
8691	2852	17	;	;	:
8691	2852	18	that	that	RB
8691	2852	19	is	is	RB
8691	2852	20	,	,	,
8691	2852	21	of	of	IN
8691	2852	22	some	some	DT
8691	2852	23	one	one	NN
8691	2852	24	to	to	TO
8691	2852	25	take	take	VB
8691	2852	26	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	2852	27	charge	charge	NN
8691	2852	28	of	of	IN
8691	2852	29	property	property	NN
8691	2852	30	in	in	IN
8691	2852	31	behalf	behalf	NN
8691	2852	32	of	of	IN
8691	2852	33	and	and	CC
8691	2852	34	as	as	IN
8691	2852	35	agent	agent	NN
8691	2852	36	of	of	IN
8691	2852	37	the	the	DT
8691	2852	38	court	court	NN
8691	2852	39	,	,	,
8691	2852	40	when	when	WRB
8691	2852	41	this	this	DT
8691	2852	42	seems	seem	VBZ
8691	2852	43	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2852	44	in	in	IN
8691	2852	45	order	order	NN
8691	2852	46	to	to	TO
8691	2852	47	preserve	preserve	VB
8691	2852	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2852	49	.	.	.
8691	2853	1	If	if	IN
8691	2853	2	the	the	DT
8691	2853	3	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	2853	4	of	of	IN
8691	2853	5	a	a	DT
8691	2853	6	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	2853	7	partnership	partnership	NN
8691	2853	8	get	get	VB
8691	2853	9	into	into	IN
8691	2853	10	such	such	PDT
8691	2853	11	a	a	DT
8691	2853	12	condition	condition	NN
8691	2853	13	that	that	IN
8691	2853	14	the	the	DT
8691	2853	15	partners	partner	NNS
8691	2853	16	can	can	MD
8691	2853	17	not	not	RB
8691	2853	18	agree	agree	VB
8691	2853	19	on	on	IN
8691	2853	20	the	the	DT
8691	2853	21	mode	mode	NN
8691	2853	22	of	of	IN
8691	2853	23	conducting	conduct	VBG
8691	2853	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2853	25	,	,	,
8691	2853	26	such	such	PDT
8691	2853	27	an	an	DT
8691	2853	28	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	2853	29	can	can	MD
8691	2853	30	be	be	VB
8691	2853	31	made	make	VBN
8691	2853	32	to	to	TO
8691	2853	33	tide	tide	VB
8691	2853	34	matters	matter	NNS
8691	2853	35	along	along	RB
8691	2853	36	for	for	IN
8691	2853	37	the	the	DT
8691	2853	38	time	time	NN
8691	2853	39	being	be	VBG
8691	2853	40	.	.	.
8691	2854	1	So	so	RB
8691	2854	2	in	in	IN
8691	2854	3	case	case	NN
8691	2854	4	of	of	IN
8691	2854	5	an	an	DT
8691	2854	6	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
8691	2854	7	debtor	debtor	NN
8691	2854	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2854	9	estate	estate	NN
8691	2854	10	may	may	MD
8691	2854	11	,	,	,
8691	2854	12	under	under	IN
8691	2854	13	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2854	14	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	2854	15	,	,	,
8691	2854	16	be	be	VB
8691	2854	17	placed	place	VBN
8691	2854	18	in	in	IN
8691	2854	19	a	a	DT
8691	2854	20	receiver	receiver	NN
8691	2854	21	's	's	POS
8691	2854	22	hands	hand	NNS
8691	2854	23	by	by	IN
8691	2854	24	a	a	DT
8691	2854	25	summary	summary	NN
8691	2854	26	order	order	NN
8691	2854	27	,	,	,
8691	2854	28	issued	issue	VBN
8691	2854	29	out	out	IN
8691	2854	30	of	of	IN
8691	2854	31	court	court	NN
8691	2854	32	.	.	.
8691	2855	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2855	2	may	may	MD
8691	2855	3	be	be	VB
8691	2855	4	added	add	VBN
8691	2855	5	that	that	IN
8691	2855	6	by	by	IN
8691	2855	7	the	the	DT
8691	2855	8	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	2855	9	both	both	DT
8691	2855	10	of	of	IN
8691	2855	11	the	the	DT
8691	2855	12	United	United	NNP
8691	2855	13	States	States	NNP
8691	2855	14	and	and	CC
8691	2855	15	of	of	IN
8691	2855	16	all	all	PDT
8691	2855	17	the	the	DT
8691	2855	18	States	States	NNP
8691	2855	19	many	many	JJ
8691	2855	20	powers	power	NNS
8691	2855	21	of	of	IN
8691	2855	22	a	a	DT
8691	2855	23	_	_	NNP
8691	2855	24	quasi_-judicial	quasi_-judicial	NNP
8691	2855	25	character	character	NN
8691	2855	26	are	be	VBP
8691	2855	27	conferred	confer	VBN
8691	2855	28	on	on	IN
8691	2855	29	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2855	30	to	to	TO
8691	2855	31	be	be	VB
8691	2855	32	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	2855	33	out	out	IN
8691	2855	34	of	of	IN
8691	2855	35	court	court	NN
8691	2855	36	,	,	,
8691	2855	37	such	such	JJ
8691	2855	38	as	as	IN
8691	2855	39	those	those	DT
8691	2855	40	of	of	IN
8691	2855	41	ordering	order	VBG
8691	2855	42	the	the	DT
8691	2855	43	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2855	44	of	of	IN
8691	2855	45	one	one	CD
8691	2855	46	suspected	suspect	VBN
8691	2855	47	of	of	IN
8691	2855	48	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	2855	49	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	2855	50	,	,	,
8691	2855	51	examining	examine	VBG
8691	2855	52	into	into	IN
8691	2855	53	the	the	DT
8691	2855	54	charges	charge	NNS
8691	2855	55	against	against	IN
8691	2855	56	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2855	57	on	on	IN
8691	2855	58	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2855	59	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	2855	60	,	,	,
8691	2855	61	and	and	CC
8691	2855	62	admitting	admit	VBG
8691	2855	63	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2855	64	to	to	TO
8691	2855	65	bail	bail	VB
8691	2855	66	or	or	CC
8691	2855	67	sending	send	VBG
8691	2855	68	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2855	69	to	to	IN
8691	2855	70	jail	jail	NN
8691	2855	71	for	for	IN
8691	2855	72	want	want	NN
8691	2855	73	of	of	IN
8691	2855	74	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2855	75	.	.	.
8691	2856	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2856	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2856	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2856	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2856	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2856	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	2856	7	XIX	xix	NN
8691	2856	8	APPELLATE	appellate	JJ
8691	2856	9	COURTS	court	NNS
8691	2856	10	For	for	IN
8691	2856	11	each	each	DT
8691	2856	12	of	of	IN
8691	2856	13	the	the	DT
8691	2856	14	States	States	NNPS
8691	2856	15	and	and	CC
8691	2856	16	Territories	Territories	NNPS
8691	2856	17	as	as	RB
8691	2856	18	well	well	RB
8691	2856	19	as	as	IN
8691	2856	20	for	for	IN
8691	2856	21	the	the	DT
8691	2856	22	United	United	NNP
8691	2856	23	States	States	NNP
8691	2856	24	there	there	EX
8691	2856	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	2856	26	one	one	CD
8691	2856	27	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	2856	28	court	court	NNP
8691	2856	29	of	of	IN
8691	2856	30	appellate	appellate	NNP
8691	2856	31	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2856	32	.	.	.
8691	2857	1	The	the	DT
8691	2857	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2857	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2857	4	of	of	IN
8691	2857	5	the	the	DT
8691	2857	6	United	United	NNP
8691	2857	7	States	States	NNP
8691	2857	8	can	can	MD
8691	2857	9	entertain	entertain	VB
8691	2857	10	original	original	JJ
8691	2857	11	actions	action	NNS
8691	2857	12	of	of	IN
8691	2857	13	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2857	14	kinds	kind	NNS
8691	2857	15	.	.	.
8691	2858	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2858	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2858	3	:	:	:
8691	2858	4	See	see	VB
8691	2858	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	2858	6	.	.	.
8691	2859	1	IX	ix	NN
8691	2859	2	.	.	.
8691	2859	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2860	1	A	a	DT
8691	2860	2	few	few	JJ
8691	2860	3	also	also	RB
8691	2860	4	of	of	IN
8691	2860	5	the	the	DT
8691	2860	6	State	State	NNP
8691	2860	7	supreme	supreme	JJ
8691	2860	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	2860	9	of	of	IN
8691	2860	10	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2860	11	have	have	VBP
8691	2860	12	a	a	DT
8691	2860	13	limited	limited	JJ
8691	2860	14	original	original	JJ
8691	2860	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2860	16	.	.	.
8691	2861	1	This	this	DT
8691	2861	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2861	3	generally	generally	RB
8691	2861	4	confined	confine	VBN
8691	2861	5	to	to	IN
8691	2861	6	equity	equity	NN
8691	2861	7	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2861	8	,	,	,
8691	2861	9	election	election	NN
8691	2861	10	contests	contest	NNS
8691	2861	11	and	and	CC
8691	2861	12	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2861	13	actions	action	NNS
8691	2861	14	for	for	IN
8691	2861	15	extraordinary	extraordinary	JJ
8691	2861	16	relief	relief	NN
8691	2861	17	known	know	VBN
8691	2861	18	as	as	IN
8691	2861	19	prerogative	prerogative	JJ
8691	2861	20	writs	writ	NNS
8691	2861	21	,	,	,
8691	2861	22	such	such	JJ
8691	2861	23	as	as	IN
8691	2861	24	informations	information	NNS
8691	2861	25	in	in	IN
8691	2861	26	the	the	DT
8691	2861	27	nature	nature	NN
8691	2861	28	of	of	IN
8691	2861	29	_	_	NNP
8691	2861	30	quo	quo	NNP
8691	2861	31	warranto	warranto	NNP
8691	2861	32	_	_	NNP
8691	2861	33	and	and	CC
8691	2861	34	writs	writ	NNS
8691	2861	35	of	of	IN
8691	2861	36	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
8691	2861	37	.	.	.
8691	2862	1	The	the	DT
8691	2862	2	term	term	NN
8691	2862	3	"	"	``
8691	2862	4	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2862	5	"	"	''
8691	2862	6	in	in	IN
8691	2862	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2862	8	strictest	strictest	NN
8691	2862	9	signification	signification	NN
8691	2862	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	2862	11	confined	confine	VBN
8691	2862	12	to	to	IN
8691	2862	13	a	a	DT
8691	2862	14	removal	removal	NN
8691	2862	15	of	of	IN
8691	2862	16	a	a	DT
8691	2862	17	cause	cause	NN
8691	2862	18	after	after	IN
8691	2862	19	trial	trial	NN
8691	2862	20	to	to	IN
8691	2862	21	a	a	DT
8691	2862	22	higher	high	JJR
8691	2862	23	court	court	NN
8691	2862	24	for	for	IN
8691	2862	25	a	a	DT
8691	2862	26	new	new	JJ
8691	2862	27	trial	trial	NN
8691	2862	28	on	on	IN
8691	2862	29	the	the	DT
8691	2862	30	merits	merit	NNS
8691	2862	31	.	.	.
8691	2863	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2863	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2863	3	also	also	RB
8691	2863	4	and	and	CC
8691	2863	5	now	now	RB
8691	2863	6	more	more	RBR
8691	2863	7	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2863	8	used	use	VBN
8691	2863	9	to	to	TO
8691	2863	10	denote	denote	VB
8691	2863	11	such	such	PDT
8691	2863	12	a	a	DT
8691	2863	13	removal	removal	NN
8691	2863	14	for	for	IN
8691	2863	15	the	the	DT
8691	2863	16	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2863	17	only	only	RB
8691	2863	18	of	of	IN
8691	2863	19	inquiring	inquire	VBG
8691	2863	20	whether	whether	IN
8691	2863	21	any	any	DT
8691	2863	22	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2863	23	errors	error	NNS
8691	2863	24	were	be	VBD
8691	2863	25	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2863	26	on	on	IN
8691	2863	27	the	the	DT
8691	2863	28	trial	trial	NN
8691	2863	29	or	or	CC
8691	2863	30	are	be	VBP
8691	2863	31	to	to	TO
8691	2863	32	be	be	VB
8691	2863	33	found	find	VBN
8691	2863	34	in	in	IN
8691	2863	35	the	the	DT
8691	2863	36	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2863	37	.	.	.
8691	2864	1	In	in	IN
8691	2864	2	this	this	DT
8691	2864	3	sense	sense	NN
8691	2864	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2864	5	covers	cover	VBZ
8691	2864	6	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	2864	7	by	by	IN
8691	2864	8	a	a	DT
8691	2864	9	writ	writ	NN
8691	2864	10	of	of	IN
8691	2864	11	error	error	NN
8691	2864	12	,	,	,
8691	2864	13	and	and	CC
8691	2864	14	any	any	DT
8691	2864	15	other	other	JJ
8691	2864	16	mode	mode	NN
8691	2864	17	of	of	IN
8691	2864	18	reviewing	review	VBG
8691	2864	19	questions	question	NNS
8691	2864	20	of	of	IN
8691	2864	21	law	law	NN
8691	2864	22	.	.	.
8691	2865	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2865	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2865	3	:	:	:
8691	2865	4	See	see	VB
8691	2865	5	the	the	DT
8691	2865	6	_	_	NNP
8691	2865	7	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
8691	2865	8	_	_	NNP
8691	2865	9	,	,	,
8691	2865	10	No	no	UH
8691	2865	11	.	.	.
8691	2866	1	LXXXI	LXXXI	NNP
8691	2866	2	.	.	.
8691	2866	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2867	1	If	if	IN
8691	2867	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2867	3	does	do	VBZ
8691	2867	4	not	not	RB
8691	2867	5	appear	appear	VB
8691	2867	6	from	from	IN
8691	2867	7	the	the	DT
8691	2867	8	record	record	NN
8691	2867	9	of	of	IN
8691	2867	10	the	the	DT
8691	2867	11	lower	low	JJR
8691	2867	12	court	court	NN
8691	2867	13	that	that	IN
8691	2867	14	any	any	DT
8691	2867	15	of	of	IN
8691	2867	16	the	the	DT
8691	2867	17	errors	error	NNS
8691	2867	18	that	that	WDT
8691	2867	19	may	may	MD
8691	2867	20	be	be	VB
8691	2867	21	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	2867	22	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2867	23	or	or	CC
8691	2867	24	"	"	``
8691	2867	25	assigned	assign	VBN
8691	2867	26	,	,	,
8691	2867	27	"	"	''
8691	2867	28	as	as	IN
8691	2867	29	the	the	DT
8691	2867	30	phrase	phrase	NN
8691	2867	31	is	be	VBZ
8691	2867	32	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2867	33	exist	exist	VBP
8691	2867	34	,	,	,
8691	2867	35	the	the	DT
8691	2867	36	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2867	37	is	be	VBZ
8691	2867	38	affirmed	affirm	VBN
8691	2867	39	;	;	:
8691	2867	40	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	2867	41	the	the	DT
8691	2867	42	cause	cause	NN
8691	2867	43	is	be	VBZ
8691	2867	44	sent	send	VBN
8691	2867	45	back	back	RB
8691	2867	46	for	for	IN
8691	2867	47	a	a	DT
8691	2867	48	new	new	JJ
8691	2867	49	trial	trial	NN
8691	2867	50	or	or	CC
8691	2867	51	,	,	,
8691	2867	52	if	if	IN
8691	2867	53	the	the	DT
8691	2867	54	objections	objection	NNS
8691	2867	55	are	be	VBP
8691	2867	56	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	2867	57	and	and	CC
8691	2867	58	fatal	fatal	JJ
8691	2867	59	to	to	IN
8691	2867	60	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2867	61	maintenance	maintenance	NN
8691	2867	62	,	,	,
8691	2867	63	is	be	VBZ
8691	2867	64	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
8691	2867	65	.	.	.
8691	2868	1	Appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2868	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	2868	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2868	4	of	of	IN
8691	2868	5	many	many	JJ
8691	2868	6	kinds	kind	NNS
8691	2868	7	.	.	.
8691	2869	1	Some	some	DT
8691	2869	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2869	3	such	such	JJ
8691	2869	4	exclusively	exclusively	RB
8691	2869	5	;	;	:
8691	2869	6	some	some	DT
8691	2869	7	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	2869	8	.	.	.
8691	2870	1	In	in	IN
8691	2870	2	others	other	NNS
8691	2870	3	the	the	DT
8691	2870	4	functions	function	NNS
8691	2870	5	of	of	IN
8691	2870	6	entertaining	entertain	VBG
8691	2870	7	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	2870	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2870	9	a	a	DT
8691	2870	10	minor	minor	JJ
8691	2870	11	one	one	NN
8691	2870	12	,	,	,
8691	2870	13	most	most	JJS
8691	2870	14	of	of	IN
8691	2870	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2870	16	time	time	NN
8691	2870	17	being	be	VBG
8691	2870	18	occupied	occupy	VBN
8691	2870	19	in	in	IN
8691	2870	20	trying	try	VBG
8691	2870	21	original	original	JJ
8691	2870	22	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2870	23	.	.	.
8691	2871	1	An	an	DT
8691	2871	2	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2871	3	from	from	IN
8691	2871	4	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	2871	5	of	of	IN
8691	2871	6	a	a	DT
8691	2871	7	justice	justice	NN
8691	2871	8	of	of	IN
8691	2871	9	the	the	DT
8691	2871	10	peace	peace	NN
8691	2871	11	,	,	,
8691	2871	12	for	for	IN
8691	2871	13	instance	instance	NN
8691	2871	14	,	,	,
8691	2871	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	2871	16	generally	generally	RB
8691	2871	17	given	give	VBN
8691	2871	18	on	on	IN
8691	2871	19	the	the	DT
8691	2871	20	merits	merit	NNS
8691	2871	21	to	to	IN
8691	2871	22	county	county	NN
8691	2871	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	2871	24	,	,	,
8691	2871	25	but	but	CC
8691	2871	26	the	the	DT
8691	2871	27	greater	great	JJR
8691	2871	28	part	part	NN
8691	2871	29	of	of	IN
8691	2871	30	the	the	DT
8691	2871	31	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	2871	32	before	before	IN
8691	2871	33	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2871	34	comes	come	VBZ
8691	2871	35	there	there	RB
8691	2871	36	in	in	IN
8691	2871	37	the	the	DT
8691	2871	38	first	first	JJ
8691	2871	39	instance	instance	NN
8691	2871	40	.	.	.
8691	2872	1	So	so	RB
8691	2872	2	the	the	DT
8691	2872	3	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	2872	4	of	of	IN
8691	2872	5	county	county	NN
8691	2872	6	or	or	CC
8691	2872	7	other	other	JJ
8691	2872	8	minor	minor	JJ
8691	2872	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	2872	10	are	be	VBP
8691	2872	11	often	often	RB
8691	2872	12	reviewable	reviewable	JJ
8691	2872	13	on	on	IN
8691	2872	14	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2872	15	for	for	IN
8691	2872	16	errors	error	NNS
8691	2872	17	in	in	IN
8691	2872	18	law	law	NN
8691	2872	19	in	in	IN
8691	2872	20	some	some	DT
8691	2872	21	superior	superior	JJ
8691	2872	22	court	court	NN
8691	2872	23	which	which	WDT
8691	2872	24	,	,	,
8691	2872	25	like	like	IN
8691	2872	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2872	27	,	,	,
8691	2872	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	2872	29	principally	principally	RB
8691	2872	30	occupied	occupy	VBN
8691	2872	31	in	in	IN
8691	2872	32	the	the	DT
8691	2872	33	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	2872	34	of	of	IN
8691	2872	35	an	an	DT
8691	2872	36	original	original	JJ
8691	2872	37	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	2872	38	.	.	.
8691	2873	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2873	2	the	the	DT
8691	2873	3	American	american	JJ
8691	2873	4	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	2873	5	passed	pass	VBD
8691	2873	6	into	into	IN
8691	2873	7	States	States	NNP
8691	2873	8	,	,	,
8691	2873	9	as	as	IN
8691	2873	10	has	have	VBZ
8691	2873	11	been	be	VBN
8691	2873	12	seen	see	VBN
8691	2873	13	,	,	,
8691	2873	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2873	15	were	be	VBD
8691	2873	16	habituated	habituate	VBN
8691	2873	17	to	to	IN
8691	2873	18	the	the	DT
8691	2873	19	thought	thought	NN
8691	2873	20	of	of	IN
8691	2873	21	a	a	DT
8691	2873	22	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	2873	23	controlling	controlling	NNP
8691	2873	24	authority	authority	NN
8691	2873	25	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	2873	26	by	by	IN
8691	2873	27	one	one	CD
8691	2873	28	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	2873	29	of	of	IN
8691	2873	30	a	a	DT
8691	2873	31	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2873	32	character	character	NN
8691	2873	33	of	of	IN
8691	2873	34	last	last	JJ
8691	2873	35	resort	resort	NN
8691	2873	36	.	.	.
8691	2874	1	The	the	DT
8691	2874	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2874	3	committee	committee	NN
8691	2874	4	of	of	IN
8691	2874	5	the	the	DT
8691	2874	6	Privy	Privy	NNP
8691	2874	7	Council	Council	NNP
8691	2874	8	had	have	VBD
8691	2874	9	administered	administer	VBN
8691	2874	10	this	this	DT
8691	2874	11	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
8691	2874	12	power	power	NN
8691	2874	13	for	for	IN
8691	2874	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2874	15	,	,	,
8691	2874	16	and	and	CC
8691	2874	17	for	for	IN
8691	2874	18	a	a	DT
8691	2874	19	long	long	JJ
8691	2874	20	period	period	NN
8691	2874	21	of	of	IN
8691	2874	22	years	year	NNS
8691	2874	23	,	,	,
8691	2874	24	with	with	IN
8691	2874	25	general	general	JJ
8691	2874	26	acquiescence	acquiescence	NN
8691	2874	27	.	.	.
8691	2875	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2875	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2875	3	:	:	:
8691	2875	4	See	see	VB
8691	2875	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	2875	6	.	.	.
8691	2876	1	I.	I.	NNP
8691	2876	2	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2877	1	The	the	DT
8691	2877	2	uniformity	uniformity	NN
8691	2877	3	of	of	IN
8691	2877	4	result	result	NN
8691	2877	5	thus	thus	RB
8691	2877	6	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	2877	7	was	be	VBD
8691	2877	8	acknowledged	acknowledge	VBN
8691	2877	9	to	to	TO
8691	2877	10	be	be	VB
8691	2877	11	advantageous	advantageous	JJ
8691	2877	12	.	.	.
8691	2878	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2878	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2878	3	now	now	RB
8691	2878	4	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2878	5	to	to	TO
8691	2878	6	replace	replace	VB
8691	2878	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2878	8	by	by	IN
8691	2878	9	American	american	JJ
8691	2878	10	courts	court	NNS
8691	2878	11	of	of	IN
8691	2878	12	last	last	JJ
8691	2878	13	resort	resort	NN
8691	2878	14	,	,	,
8691	2878	15	and	and	CC
8691	2878	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2878	17	was	be	VBD
8691	2878	18	not	not	RB
8691	2878	19	difficult	difficult	JJ
8691	2878	20	in	in	IN
8691	2878	21	doing	do	VBG
8691	2878	22	so	so	RB
8691	2878	23	to	to	TO
8691	2878	24	improve	improve	VB
8691	2878	25	upon	upon	IN
8691	2878	26	the	the	DT
8691	2878	27	English	english	JJ
8691	2878	28	model	model	NN
8691	2878	29	.	.	.
8691	2879	1	The	the	DT
8691	2879	2	time	time	NN
8691	2879	3	had	have	VBD
8691	2879	4	come	come	VBN
8691	2879	5	for	for	IN
8691	2879	6	separating	separate	VBG
8691	2879	7	,	,	,
8691	2879	8	as	as	RB
8691	2879	9	far	far	RB
8691	2879	10	as	as	IN
8691	2879	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2879	12	could	could	MD
8691	2879	13	conveniently	conveniently	RB
8691	2879	14	be	be	VB
8691	2879	15	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
8691	2879	16	,	,	,
8691	2879	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2879	18	from	from	IN
8691	2879	19	political	political	JJ
8691	2879	20	power	power	NN
8691	2879	21	.	.	.
8691	2880	1	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	2880	2	was	be	VBD
8691	2880	3	the	the	DT
8691	2880	4	first	first	JJ
8691	2880	5	to	to	TO
8691	2880	6	act	act	VB
8691	2880	7	.	.	.
8691	2881	1	A	a	DT
8691	2881	2	few	few	JJ
8691	2881	3	days	day	NNS
8691	2881	4	before	before	IN
8691	2881	5	the	the	DT
8691	2881	6	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
8691	2881	7	of	of	IN
8691	2881	8	Independence	Independence	NNP
8691	2881	9	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2881	10	adopted	adopt	VBD
8691	2881	11	a	a	DT
8691	2881	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2881	13	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2881	14	under	under	IN
8691	2881	15	which	which	WDT
8691	2881	16	the	the	DT
8691	2881	17	government	government	NN
8691	2881	18	,	,	,
8691	2881	19	was	be	VBD
8691	2881	20	carried	carry	VBN
8691	2881	21	on	on	IN
8691	2881	22	until	until	IN
8691	2881	23	1830	1830	CD
8691	2881	24	,	,	,
8691	2881	25	though	though	IN
8691	2881	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2881	27	was	be	VBD
8691	2881	28	never	never	RB
8691	2881	29	formally	formally	RB
8691	2881	30	submitted	submit	VBN
8691	2881	31	to	to	IN
8691	2881	32	or	or	CC
8691	2881	33	ratified	ratify	VBN
8691	2881	34	by	by	IN
8691	2881	35	the	the	DT
8691	2881	36	people	people	NNS
8691	2881	37	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2881	38	providing	provide	VBG
8691	2881	39	for	for	IN
8691	2881	40	a	a	DT
8691	2881	41	separate	separate	JJ
8691	2881	42	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	2881	43	headed	head	VBN
8691	2881	44	by	by	IN
8691	2881	45	a	a	DT
8691	2881	46	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2881	47	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2881	48	of	of	IN
8691	2881	49	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	2881	50	whose	whose	WP$
8691	2881	51	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2881	52	should	should	MD
8691	2881	53	hold	hold	VB
8691	2881	54	office	office	NN
8691	2881	55	during	during	IN
8691	2881	56	good	good	JJ
8691	2881	57	behavior	behavior	NN
8691	2881	58	,	,	,
8691	2881	59	and	and	CC
8691	2881	60	be	be	VB
8691	2881	61	ineligible	ineligible	JJ
8691	2881	62	to	to	IN
8691	2881	63	the	the	DT
8691	2881	64	Privy	Privy	NNP
8691	2881	65	Council	Council	NNP
8691	2881	66	or	or	CC
8691	2881	67	General	General	NNP
8691	2881	68	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	2881	69	.	.	.
8691	2882	1	This	this	DT
8691	2882	2	divorce	divorce	NN
8691	2882	3	of	of	IN
8691	2882	4	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	2882	5	and	and	CC
8691	2882	6	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	2882	7	was	be	VBD
8691	2882	8	not	not	RB
8691	2882	9	the	the	DT
8691	2882	10	plan	plan	NN
8691	2882	11	universally	universally	RB
8691	2882	12	followed	follow	VBD
8691	2882	13	.	.	.
8691	2883	1	New	New	NNP
8691	2883	2	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	2883	3	,	,	,
8691	2883	4	in	in	IN
8691	2883	5	which	which	WDT
8691	2883	6	as	as	IN
8691	2883	7	a	a	DT
8691	2883	8	colony	colony	NN
8691	2883	9	the	the	DT
8691	2883	10	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	2883	11	and	and	CC
8691	2883	12	Council	Council	NNP
8691	2883	13	had	have	VBD
8691	2883	14	possessed	possess	VBN
8691	2883	15	an	an	DT
8691	2883	16	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2883	17	power	power	NN
8691	2883	18	like	like	IN
8691	2883	19	that	that	DT
8691	2883	20	vested	vest	VBN
8691	2883	21	in	in	IN
8691	2883	22	the	the	DT
8691	2883	23	English	English	NNP
8691	2883	24	House	House	NNP
8691	2883	25	of	of	IN
8691	2883	26	Lords	Lords	NNP
8691	2883	27	,	,	,
8691	2883	28	was	be	VBD
8691	2883	29	so	so	RB
8691	2883	30	well	well	RB
8691	2883	31	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
8691	2883	32	with	with	IN
8691	2883	33	this	this	DT
8691	2883	34	arrangement	arrangement	NN
8691	2883	35	as	as	IN
8691	2883	36	to	to	TO
8691	2883	37	continue	continue	VB
8691	2883	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2883	39	in	in	IN
8691	2883	40	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2883	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2883	42	of	of	IN
8691	2883	43	July	July	NNP
8691	2883	44	3	3	CD
8691	2883	45	,	,	,
8691	2883	46	1776	1776	CD
8691	2883	47	,	,	,
8691	2883	48	and	and	CC
8691	2883	49	up	up	IN
8691	2883	50	to	to	IN
8691	2883	51	the	the	DT
8691	2883	52	present	present	JJ
8691	2883	53	time	time	NN
8691	2883	54	puts	put	VBZ
8691	2883	55	upon	upon	IN
8691	2883	56	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2883	57	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2883	58	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2883	59	a	a	DT
8691	2883	60	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2883	61	number	number	NN
8691	2883	62	of	of	IN
8691	2883	63	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2883	64	who	who	WP
8691	2883	65	give	give	VBP
8691	2883	66	but	but	CC
8691	2883	67	a	a	DT
8691	2883	68	part	part	NN
8691	2883	69	of	of	IN
8691	2883	70	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2883	71	time	time	NN
8691	2883	72	to	to	IN
8691	2883	73	this	this	DT
8691	2883	74	work	work	NN
8691	2883	75	,	,	,
8691	2883	76	and	and	CC
8691	2883	77	are	be	VBP
8691	2883	78	not	not	RB
8691	2883	79	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	2883	80	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2883	81	though	though	IN
8691	2883	82	in	in	IN
8691	2883	83	practice	practice	NN
8691	2883	84	of	of	IN
8691	2883	85	late	late	JJ
8691	2883	86	years	year	NNS
8691	2883	87	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2883	88	generally	generally	RB
8691	2883	89	have	have	VBP
8691	2883	90	been	be	VBN
8691	2883	91	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2883	92	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2883	93	.	.	.
8691	2884	1	New	New	NNP
8691	2884	2	York	York	NNP
8691	2884	3	,	,	,
8691	2884	4	in	in	IN
8691	2884	5	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2884	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2884	7	of	of	IN
8691	2884	8	1777	1777	CD
8691	2884	9	,	,	,
8691	2884	10	pursued	pursue	VBD
8691	2884	11	a	a	DT
8691	2884	12	somewhat	somewhat	RB
8691	2884	13	similar	similar	JJ
8691	2884	14	plan	plan	NN
8691	2884	15	.	.	.
8691	2885	1	Her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2885	2	highest	high	JJS
8691	2885	3	court	court	NN
8691	2885	4	was	be	VBD
8691	2885	5	one	one	CD
8691	2885	6	"	"	``
8691	2885	7	for	for	IN
8691	2885	8	the	the	DT
8691	2885	9	trials	trial	NNS
8691	2885	10	of	of	IN
8691	2885	11	impeachments	impeachment	NNS
8691	2885	12	and	and	CC
8691	2885	13	the	the	DT
8691	2885	14	correction	correction	NN
8691	2885	15	of	of	IN
8691	2885	16	errors	error	NNS
8691	2885	17	.	.	.
8691	2885	18	"	"	''
8691	2886	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2886	2	members	member	NNS
8691	2886	3	were	be	VBD
8691	2886	4	the	the	DT
8691	2886	5	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	2886	6	with	with	IN
8691	2886	7	the	the	DT
8691	2886	8	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	2886	9	and	and	CC
8691	2886	10	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2886	11	of	of	IN
8691	2886	12	the	the	DT
8691	2886	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2886	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2886	15	.	.	.
8691	2887	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2887	2	a	a	DT
8691	2887	3	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2887	4	of	of	IN
8691	2887	5	that	that	DT
8691	2887	6	court	court	NN
8691	2887	7	was	be	VBD
8691	2887	8	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2887	9	up	up	RP
8691	2887	10	for	for	IN
8691	2887	11	review	review	NN
8691	2887	12	the	the	DT
8691	2887	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2887	14	were	be	VBD
8691	2887	15	to	to	TO
8691	2887	16	state	state	VB
8691	2887	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2887	18	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	2887	19	for	for	IN
8691	2887	20	giving	give	VBG
8691	2887	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2887	22	,	,	,
8691	2887	23	but	but	CC
8691	2887	24	had	have	VBD
8691	2887	25	no	no	DT
8691	2887	26	vote	vote	NN
8691	2887	27	.	.	.
8691	2888	1	This	this	DT
8691	2888	2	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	2888	3	was	be	VBD
8691	2888	4	adhered	adhere	VBN
8691	2888	5	to	to	IN
8691	2888	6	with	with	IN
8691	2888	7	little	little	JJ
8691	2888	8	modification	modification	NN
8691	2888	9	until	until	IN
8691	2888	10	1846	1846	CD
8691	2888	11	.	.	.
8691	2889	1	What	what	WP
8691	2889	2	made	make	VBD
8691	2889	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2889	4	tolerable	tolerable	JJ
8691	2889	5	was	be	VBD
8691	2889	6	that	that	IN
8691	2889	7	many	many	JJ
8691	2889	8	of	of	IN
8691	2889	9	those	those	DT
8691	2889	10	elected	elect	VBN
8691	2889	11	Senators	Senators	NNPS
8691	2889	12	were	be	VBD
8691	2889	13	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	2889	14	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2889	15	,	,	,
8691	2889	16	and	and	CC
8691	2889	17	that	that	DT
8691	2889	18	to	to	TO
8691	2889	19	be	be	VB
8691	2889	20	in	in	IN
8691	2889	21	the	the	DT
8691	2889	22	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	2889	23	soon	soon	RB
8691	2889	24	became	become	VBD
8691	2889	25	the	the	DT
8691	2889	26	ambition	ambition	NN
8691	2889	27	of	of	IN
8691	2889	28	a	a	DT
8691	2889	29	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	2889	30	with	with	IN
8691	2889	31	any	any	DT
8691	2889	32	desire	desire	NN
8691	2889	33	to	to	TO
8691	2889	34	know	know	VB
8691	2889	35	how	how	WRB
8691	2889	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2889	37	would	would	MD
8691	2889	38	feel	feel	VB
8691	2889	39	to	to	TO
8691	2889	40	be	be	VB
8691	2889	41	a	a	DT
8691	2889	42	judge	judge	NN
8691	2889	43	.	.	.
8691	2890	1	Able	able	JJ
8691	2890	2	and	and	CC
8691	2890	3	learned	learn	VBN
8691	2890	4	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	2890	5	were	be	VBD
8691	2890	6	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	2890	7	by	by	IN
8691	2890	8	such	such	JJ
8691	2890	9	men	man	NNS
8691	2890	10	in	in	IN
8691	2890	11	exercising	exercise	VBG
8691	2890	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2890	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2890	14	functions	function	NNS
8691	2890	15	,	,	,
8691	2890	16	and	and	CC
8691	2890	17	some	some	DT
8691	2890	18	of	of	IN
8691	2890	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2890	20	in	in	IN
8691	2890	21	the	the	DT
8691	2890	22	New	New	NNP
8691	2890	23	York	York	NNP
8691	2890	24	reports	report	NNS
8691	2890	25	are	be	VBP
8691	2890	26	still	still	RB
8691	2890	27	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	2890	28	the	the	DT
8691	2890	29	subject	subject	NN
8691	2890	30	of	of	IN
8691	2890	31	reference	reference	NN
8691	2890	32	as	as	IN
8691	2890	33	clear	clear	JJ
8691	2890	34	and	and	CC
8691	2890	35	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
8691	2890	36	statements	statement	NNS
8691	2890	37	of	of	IN
8691	2890	38	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2890	39	principles	principle	NNS
8691	2890	40	.	.	.
8691	2891	1	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2891	2	,	,	,
8691	2891	3	in	in	IN
8691	2891	4	1784	1784	CD
8691	2891	5	,	,	,
8691	2891	6	when	when	WRB
8691	2891	7	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2891	8	instituted	institute	VBD
8691	2891	9	for	for	IN
8691	2891	10	the	the	DT
8691	2891	11	first	first	JJ
8691	2891	12	time	time	NN
8691	2891	13	a	a	DT
8691	2891	14	court	court	NN
8691	2891	15	of	of	IN
8691	2891	16	last	last	JJ
8691	2891	17	resort	resort	NN
8691	2891	18	,	,	,
8691	2891	19	made	make	VBD
8691	2891	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2891	21	up	up	IN
8691	2891	22	of	of	IN
8691	2891	23	the	the	DT
8691	2891	24	Lieutenant	Lieutenant	NNP
8691	2891	25	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	2891	26	and	and	CC
8691	2891	27	the	the	DT
8691	2891	28	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	2891	29	Assistants	Assistants	NNPS
8691	2891	30	,	,	,
8691	2891	31	and	and	CC
8691	2891	32	soon	soon	RB
8691	2891	33	added	add	VBD
8691	2891	34	to	to	IN
8691	2891	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2891	36	the	the	DT
8691	2891	37	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	2891	38	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2891	39	.	.	.
8691	2892	1	A	a	DT
8691	2892	2	plan	plan	NN
8691	2892	3	of	of	IN
8691	2892	4	this	this	DT
8691	2892	5	kind	kind	NN
8691	2892	6	was	be	VBD
8691	2892	7	likely	likely	JJ
8691	2892	8	to	to	TO
8691	2892	9	work	work	VB
8691	2892	10	in	in	IN
8691	2892	11	that	that	DT
8691	2892	12	State	State	NNP
8691	2892	13	,	,	,
8691	2892	14	as	as	IN
8691	2892	15	in	in	IN
8691	2892	16	New	New	NNP
8691	2892	17	York	York	NNP
8691	2892	18	,	,	,
8691	2892	19	better	well	RBR
8691	2892	20	than	than	IN
8691	2892	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2892	22	looked	look	VBD
8691	2892	23	.	.	.
8691	2893	1	Lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2893	2	by	by	IN
8691	2893	3	this	this	DT
8691	2893	4	time	time	NN
8691	2893	5	had	have	VBD
8691	2893	6	come	come	VBN
8691	2893	7	to	to	TO
8691	2893	8	fill	fill	VB
8691	2893	9	most	most	JJS
8691	2893	10	of	of	IN
8691	2893	11	the	the	DT
8691	2893	12	higher	high	JJR
8691	2893	13	offices	office	NNS
8691	2893	14	of	of	IN
8691	2893	15	state	state	NN
8691	2893	16	.	.	.
8691	2894	1	Although	although	IN
8691	2894	2	the	the	DT
8691	2894	3	Assistants	Assistants	NNPS
8691	2894	4	were	be	VBD
8691	2894	5	elected	elect	VBN
8691	2894	6	annually	annually	RB
8691	2894	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2894	8	was	be	VBD
8691	2894	9	under	under	IN
8691	2894	10	a	a	DT
8691	2894	11	complicated	complicated	JJ
8691	2894	12	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	2894	13	of	of	IN
8691	2894	14	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	2894	15	,	,	,
8691	2894	16	which	which	WDT
8691	2894	17	,	,	,
8691	2894	18	unless	unless	IN
8691	2894	19	in	in	IN
8691	2894	20	case	case	NN
8691	2894	21	of	of	IN
8691	2894	22	a	a	DT
8691	2894	23	political	political	JJ
8691	2894	24	revolution	revolution	NN
8691	2894	25	,	,	,
8691	2894	26	ensured	ensure	VBD
8691	2894	27	re	re	NN
8691	2894	28	-	-	NN
8691	2894	29	election	election	NN
8691	2894	30	in	in	IN
8691	2894	31	every	every	DT
8691	2894	32	case	case	NN
8691	2894	33	.	.	.
8691	2895	1	A	a	DT
8691	2895	2	majority	majority	NN
8691	2895	3	of	of	IN
8691	2895	4	the	the	DT
8691	2895	5	Assistants	Assistants	NNPS
8691	2895	6	were	be	VBD
8691	2895	7	always	always	RB
8691	2895	8	members	member	NNS
8691	2895	9	of	of	IN
8691	2895	10	the	the	DT
8691	2895	11	bar	bar	NN
8691	2895	12	.	.	.
8691	2896	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2896	2	were	be	VBD
8691	2896	3	also	also	RB
8691	2896	4	Federalists	federalist	NNS
8691	2896	5	from	from	IN
8691	2896	6	the	the	DT
8691	2896	7	beginning	beginning	NN
8691	2896	8	of	of	IN
8691	2896	9	party	party	NN
8691	2896	10	divisions	division	NNS
8691	2896	11	in	in	IN
8691	2896	12	the	the	DT
8691	2896	13	country	country	NN
8691	2896	14	.	.	.
8691	2897	1	Naturally	naturally	RB
8691	2897	2	,	,	,
8691	2897	3	the	the	DT
8691	2897	4	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
8691	2897	5	found	find	VBD
8691	2897	6	such	such	PDT
8691	2897	7	a	a	DT
8691	2897	8	state	state	NN
8691	2897	9	of	of	IN
8691	2897	10	things	thing	NNS
8691	2897	11	intolerable	intolerable	JJ
8691	2897	12	.	.	.
8691	2898	1	All	all	PDT
8691	2898	2	the	the	DT
8691	2898	3	power	power	NN
8691	2898	4	of	of	IN
8691	2898	5	government	government	NN
8691	2898	6	in	in	IN
8691	2898	7	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	2898	8	,	,	,
8691	2898	9	said	say	VBD
8691	2898	10	one	one	CD
8691	2898	11	of	of	IN
8691	2898	12	those	those	DT
8691	2898	13	who	who	WP
8691	2898	14	were	be	VBD
8691	2898	15	celebrating	celebrate	VBG
8691	2898	16	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	2898	17	's	's	POS
8691	2898	18	second	second	JJ
8691	2898	19	election	election	NN
8691	2898	20	to	to	IN
8691	2898	21	the	the	DT
8691	2898	22	Presidency	Presidency	NNP
8691	2898	23	in	in	IN
8691	2898	24	1804	1804	CD
8691	2898	25	,	,	,
8691	2898	26	"	"	``
8691	2898	27	together	together	RB
8691	2898	28	with	with	IN
8691	2898	29	a	a	DT
8691	2898	30	complete	complete	JJ
8691	2898	31	control	control	NN
8691	2898	32	of	of	IN
8691	2898	33	elections	election	NNS
8691	2898	34	,	,	,
8691	2898	35	are	be	VBP
8691	2898	36	in	in	IN
8691	2898	37	the	the	DT
8691	2898	38	hands	hand	NNS
8691	2898	39	of	of	IN
8691	2898	40	seven	seven	CD
8691	2898	41	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2898	42	who	who	WP
8691	2898	43	have	have	VBP
8691	2898	44	gained	gain	VBN
8691	2898	45	a	a	DT
8691	2898	46	seat	seat	NN
8691	2898	47	at	at	IN
8691	2898	48	the	the	DT
8691	2898	49	council	council	NNP
8691	2898	50	board	board	NNP
8691	2898	51	.	.	.
8691	2899	1	These	these	DT
8691	2899	2	seven	seven	CD
8691	2899	3	men	man	NNS
8691	2899	4	virtually	virtually	RB
8691	2899	5	make	make	VBP
8691	2899	6	and	and	CC
8691	2899	7	repeal	repeal	VB
8691	2899	8	laws	law	NNS
8691	2899	9	as	as	IN
8691	2899	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2899	11	please	please	VBP
8691	2899	12	,	,	,
8691	2899	13	appoint	appoint	VB
8691	2899	14	all	all	PDT
8691	2899	15	the	the	DT
8691	2899	16	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	2899	17	,	,	,
8691	2899	18	plead	plead	VB
8691	2899	19	before	before	IN
8691	2899	20	those	those	DT
8691	2899	21	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	2899	22	,	,	,
8691	2899	23	and	and	CC
8691	2899	24	constitute	constitute	VB
8691	2899	25	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2899	26	a	a	DT
8691	2899	27	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2899	28	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2899	29	of	of	IN
8691	2899	30	Errors	Errors	NNPS
8691	2899	31	to	to	TO
8691	2899	32	decide	decide	VB
8691	2899	33	in	in	IN
8691	2899	34	the	the	DT
8691	2899	35	last	last	JJ
8691	2899	36	resort	resort	NN
8691	2899	37	on	on	IN
8691	2899	38	the	the	DT
8691	2899	39	laws	law	NNS
8691	2899	40	of	of	IN
8691	2899	41	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2899	42	own	own	JJ
8691	2899	43	making	making	NN
8691	2899	44	.	.	.
8691	2900	1	To	to	TO
8691	2900	2	crown	crown	VB
8691	2900	3	this	this	DT
8691	2900	4	absurdity	absurdity	NN
8691	2900	5	,	,	,
8691	2900	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2900	7	have	have	VBP
8691	2900	8	repealed	repeal	VBN
8691	2900	9	a	a	DT
8691	2900	10	law	law	NN
8691	2900	11	which	which	WDT
8691	2900	12	prohibited	prohibit	VBD
8691	2900	13	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2900	14	to	to	TO
8691	2900	15	plead	plead	VB
8691	2900	16	before	before	IN
8691	2900	17	the	the	DT
8691	2900	18	very	very	JJ
8691	2900	19	court	court	NN
8691	2900	20	of	of	IN
8691	2900	21	which	which	WDT
8691	2900	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2900	23	are	be	VBP
8691	2900	24	Judges	judge	NNS
8691	2900	25	.	.	.
8691	2900	26	"	"	''
8691	2901	1	Attacks	attack	NNS
8691	2901	2	like	like	IN
8691	2901	3	this	this	DT
8691	2901	4	were	be	VBD
8691	2901	5	too	too	RB
8691	2901	6	just	just	RB
8691	2901	7	to	to	TO
8691	2901	8	be	be	VB
8691	2901	9	resisted	resist	VBN
8691	2901	10	,	,	,
8691	2901	11	and	and	CC
8691	2901	12	two	two	CD
8691	2901	13	years	year	NNS
8691	2901	14	later	later	RB
8691	2901	15	the	the	DT
8691	2901	16	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	2901	17	,	,	,
8691	2901	18	Lieutenant	Lieutenant	NNP
8691	2901	19	-	-	HYPH
8691	2901	20	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	2901	21	and	and	CC
8691	2901	22	Assistants	Assistants	NNPS
8691	2901	23	were	be	VBD
8691	2901	24	replaced	replace	VBN
8691	2901	25	by	by	IN
8691	2901	26	the	the	DT
8691	2901	27	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	2901	28	of	of	IN
8691	2901	29	the	the	DT
8691	2901	30	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	2901	31	Court	Court	NNP
8691	2901	32	.	.	.
8691	2902	1	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	2902	2	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	2902	3	that	that	WDT
8691	2902	4	the	the	DT
8691	2902	5	right	right	NN
8691	2902	6	of	of	IN
8691	2902	7	trial	trial	NN
8691	2902	8	by	by	IN
8691	2902	9	jury	jury	NN
8691	2902	10	shall	shall	MD
8691	2902	11	be	be	VB
8691	2902	12	preserved	preserve	VBN
8691	2902	13	inviolate	inviolate	JJ
8691	2902	14	preclude	preclude	NN
8691	2902	15	,	,	,
8691	2902	16	as	as	IN
8691	2902	17	a	a	DT
8691	2902	18	general	general	JJ
8691	2902	19	rule	rule	NN
8691	2902	20	,	,	,
8691	2902	21	the	the	DT
8691	2902	22	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	2902	23	of	of	IN
8691	2902	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	2902	25	in	in	IN
8691	2902	26	which	which	WDT
8691	2902	27	the	the	DT
8691	2902	28	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2902	29	can	can	MD
8691	2902	30	make	make	VB
8691	2902	31	a	a	DT
8691	2902	32	final	final	JJ
8691	2902	33	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	2902	34	of	of	IN
8691	2902	35	petty	petty	JJ
8691	2902	36	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2902	37	which	which	WDT
8691	2902	38	turn	turn	VBP
8691	2902	39	on	on	RP
8691	2902	40	disputed	dispute	VBN
8691	2902	41	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2902	42	.	.	.
8691	2903	1	An	an	DT
8691	2903	2	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2903	3	from	from	IN
8691	2903	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2903	5	decision	decision	NN
8691	2903	6	must	must	MD
8691	2903	7	be	be	VB
8691	2903	8	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	2903	9	,	,	,
8691	2903	10	and	and	CC
8691	2903	11	a	a	DT
8691	2903	12	new	new	JJ
8691	2903	13	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	2903	14	given	give	VBN
8691	2903	15	on	on	IN
8691	2903	16	the	the	DT
8691	2903	17	merits	merit	NNS
8691	2903	18	in	in	IN
8691	2903	19	a	a	DT
8691	2903	20	court	court	NN
8691	2903	21	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	2903	22	with	with	IN
8691	2903	23	a	a	DT
8691	2903	24	jury	jury	NN
8691	2903	25	.	.	.
8691	2904	1	Under	under	IN
8691	2904	2	the	the	DT
8691	2904	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2904	4	of	of	IN
8691	2904	5	the	the	DT
8691	2904	6	United	United	NNP
8691	2904	7	States	States	NNP
8691	2904	8	a	a	DT
8691	2904	9	trial	trial	NN
8691	2904	10	by	by	IN
8691	2904	11	jury	jury	NN
8691	2904	12	can	can	MD
8691	2904	13	not	not	RB
8691	2904	14	be	be	VB
8691	2904	15	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	2904	16	in	in	IN
8691	2904	17	civil	civil	JJ
8691	2904	18	cases	case	NNS
8691	2904	19	at	at	IN
8691	2904	20	common	common	JJ
8691	2904	21	law	law	NN
8691	2904	22	involving	involve	VBG
8691	2904	23	a	a	DT
8691	2904	24	demand	demand	NN
8691	2904	25	of	of	IN
8691	2904	26	not	not	RB
8691	2904	27	over	over	IN
8691	2904	28	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	2904	29	dollars	dollar	NNS
8691	2904	30	,	,	,
8691	2904	31	and	and	CC
8691	2904	32	in	in	IN
8691	2904	33	most	most	JJS
8691	2904	34	of	of	IN
8691	2904	35	the	the	DT
8691	2904	36	older	old	JJR
8691	2904	37	States	state	NNS
8691	2904	38	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2904	39	can	can	MD
8691	2904	40	not	not	RB
8691	2904	41	be	be	VB
8691	2904	42	in	in	IN
8691	2904	43	cases	case	NNS
8691	2904	44	where	where	WRB
8691	2904	45	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2904	46	was	be	VBD
8691	2904	47	not	not	RB
8691	2904	48	a	a	DT
8691	2904	49	matter	matter	NN
8691	2904	50	of	of	IN
8691	2904	51	right	right	RB
8691	2904	52	prior	prior	RB
8691	2904	53	to	to	IN
8691	2904	54	the	the	DT
8691	2904	55	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	2904	56	of	of	IN
8691	2904	57	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2904	58	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	2904	59	.	.	.
8691	2905	1	The	the	DT
8691	2905	2	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2905	3	of	of	IN
8691	2905	4	a	a	DT
8691	2905	5	jury	jury	NN
8691	2905	6	can	can	MD
8691	2905	7	only	only	RB
8691	2905	8	be	be	VB
8691	2905	9	reviewed	review	VBN
8691	2905	10	on	on	IN
8691	2905	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2905	12	merits	merit	NNS
8691	2905	13	by	by	IN
8691	2905	14	a	a	DT
8691	2905	15	court	court	NN
8691	2905	16	of	of	IN
8691	2905	17	last	last	JJ
8691	2905	18	resort	resort	NN
8691	2905	19	where	where	WRB
8691	2905	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2905	21	was	be	VBD
8691	2905	22	clearly	clearly	RB
8691	2905	23	and	and	CC
8691	2905	24	palpably	palpably	RB
8691	2905	25	against	against	IN
8691	2905	26	the	the	DT
8691	2905	27	weight	weight	NN
8691	2905	28	of	of	IN
8691	2905	29	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2905	30	,	,	,
8691	2905	31	and	and	CC
8691	2905	32	in	in	IN
8691	2905	33	order	order	NN
8691	2905	34	to	to	TO
8691	2905	35	do	do	VB
8691	2905	36	this	this	DT
8691	2905	37	the	the	DT
8691	2905	38	whole	whole	JJ
8691	2905	39	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2905	40	given	give	VBN
8691	2905	41	in	in	IN
8691	2905	42	the	the	DT
8691	2905	43	trial	trial	NN
8691	2905	44	court	court	NN
8691	2905	45	must	must	MD
8691	2905	46	be	be	VB
8691	2905	47	certified	certify	VBN
8691	2905	48	up	up	RP
8691	2905	49	.	.	.
8691	2906	1	Where	where	WRB
8691	2906	2	a	a	DT
8691	2906	3	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2906	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2906	5	been	be	VBN
8691	2906	6	rendered	render	VBN
8691	2906	7	on	on	IN
8691	2906	8	a	a	DT
8691	2906	9	finding	finding	NN
8691	2906	10	of	of	IN
8691	2906	11	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2906	12	made	make	VBN
8691	2906	13	by	by	IN
8691	2906	14	a	a	DT
8691	2906	15	judge	judge	NN
8691	2906	16	in	in	IN
8691	2906	17	a	a	DT
8691	2906	18	cause	cause	NN
8691	2906	19	of	of	IN
8691	2906	20	an	an	DT
8691	2906	21	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	2906	22	nature	nature	NN
8691	2906	23	,	,	,
8691	2906	24	this	this	DT
8691	2906	25	finding	finding	NN
8691	2906	26	can	can	MD
8691	2906	27	,	,	,
8691	2906	28	in	in	IN
8691	2906	29	the	the	DT
8691	2906	30	courts	court	NNS
8691	2906	31	of	of	IN
8691	2906	32	the	the	DT
8691	2906	33	United	United	NNP
8691	2906	34	States	States	NNP
8691	2906	35	and	and	CC
8691	2906	36	in	in	IN
8691	2906	37	many	many	JJ
8691	2906	38	of	of	IN
8691	2906	39	the	the	DT
8691	2906	40	States	States	NNPS
8691	2906	41	,	,	,
8691	2906	42	be	be	VB
8691	2906	43	reversed	reverse	VBN
8691	2906	44	on	on	IN
8691	2906	45	any	any	DT
8691	2906	46	point	point	NN
8691	2906	47	on	on	IN
8691	2906	48	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2906	49	.	.	.
8691	2907	1	For	for	IN
8691	2907	2	this	this	DT
8691	2907	3	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	2907	4	also	also	RB
8691	2907	5	all	all	PDT
8691	2907	6	the	the	DT
8691	2907	7	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	2907	8	that	that	WDT
8691	2907	9	was	be	VBD
8691	2907	10	before	before	IN
8691	2907	11	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2907	12	,	,	,
8691	2907	13	or	or	CC
8691	2907	14	all	all	PDT
8691	2907	15	that	that	WDT
8691	2907	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	2907	17	pertinent	pertinent	JJ
8691	2907	18	to	to	IN
8691	2907	19	questions	question	NNS
8691	2907	20	involved	involve	VBN
8691	2907	21	,	,	,
8691	2907	22	must	must	MD
8691	2907	23	be	be	VB
8691	2907	24	reported	report	VBN
8691	2907	25	to	to	IN
8691	2907	26	the	the	DT
8691	2907	27	court	court	NN
8691	2907	28	above	above	RB
8691	2907	29	.	.	.
8691	2908	1	Except	except	IN
8691	2908	2	so	so	RB
8691	2908	3	far	far	RB
8691	2908	4	as	as	IN
8691	2908	5	the	the	DT
8691	2908	6	right	right	NN
8691	2908	7	of	of	IN
8691	2908	8	trial	trial	NN
8691	2908	9	by	by	IN
8691	2908	10	jury	jury	NN
8691	2908	11	may	may	MD
8691	2908	12	require	require	VB
8691	2908	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2908	14	,	,	,
8691	2908	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2908	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	2908	17	a	a	DT
8691	2908	18	matter	matter	NN
8691	2908	19	of	of	IN
8691	2908	20	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	2908	21	discretion	discretion	NN
8691	2908	22	whether	whether	IN
8691	2908	23	to	to	TO
8691	2908	24	give	give	VB
8691	2908	25	any	any	DT
8691	2908	26	remedy	remedy	NN
8691	2908	27	in	in	IN
8691	2908	28	a	a	DT
8691	2908	29	higher	high	JJR
8691	2908	30	court	court	NN
8691	2908	31	for	for	IN
8691	2908	32	the	the	DT
8691	2908	33	errors	error	NNS
8691	2908	34	of	of	IN
8691	2908	35	a	a	DT
8691	2908	36	lower	low	JJR
8691	2908	37	one	one	NN
8691	2908	38	.	.	.
8691	2909	1	In	in	IN
8691	2909	2	some	some	DT
8691	2909	3	States	state	NNS
8691	2909	4	an	an	DT
8691	2909	5	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2909	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2909	7	given	give	VBN
8691	2909	8	from	from	IN
8691	2909	9	a	a	DT
8691	2909	10	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2909	11	of	of	IN
8691	2909	12	an	an	DT
8691	2909	13	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	2909	14	court	court	NN
8691	2909	15	even	even	RB
8691	2909	16	though	though	IN
8691	2909	17	rendered	render	VBN
8691	2909	18	on	on	IN
8691	2909	19	the	the	DT
8691	2909	20	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	2909	21	of	of	IN
8691	2909	22	a	a	DT
8691	2909	23	jury	jury	NN
8691	2909	24	,	,	,
8691	2909	25	to	to	IN
8691	2909	26	a	a	DT
8691	2909	27	higher	high	JJR
8691	2909	28	one	one	CD
8691	2909	29	where	where	WRB
8691	2909	30	another	another	DT
8691	2909	31	trial	trial	NN
8691	2909	32	may	may	MD
8691	2909	33	be	be	VB
8691	2909	34	had	have	VBN
8691	2909	35	before	before	IN
8691	2909	36	a	a	DT
8691	2909	37	judge	judge	NN
8691	2909	38	of	of	IN
8691	2909	39	presumably	presumably	RB
8691	2909	40	greater	great	JJR
8691	2909	41	ability	ability	NN
8691	2909	42	.	.	.
8691	2910	1	In	in	IN
8691	2910	2	many	many	JJ
8691	2910	3	States	States	NNP
8691	2910	4	errors	error	NNS
8691	2910	5	in	in	IN
8691	2910	6	law	law	NN
8691	2910	7	of	of	IN
8691	2910	8	petty	petty	JJ
8691	2910	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	2910	10	may	may	MD
8691	2910	11	be	be	VB
8691	2910	12	reviewed	review	VBN
8691	2910	13	in	in	IN
8691	2910	14	higher	high	JJR
8691	2910	15	trial	trial	NN
8691	2910	16	courts	court	NNS
8691	2910	17	.	.	.
8691	2911	1	In	in	IN
8691	2911	2	a	a	DT
8691	2911	3	few	few	JJ
8691	2911	4	of	of	IN
8691	2911	5	the	the	DT
8691	2911	6	larger	large	JJR
8691	2911	7	ones	one	NNS
8691	2911	8	,	,	,
8691	2911	9	as	as	IN
8691	2911	10	in	in	IN
8691	2911	11	the	the	DT
8691	2911	12	United	United	NNP
8691	2911	13	States,[Footnote	States,[Footnote	NNP
8691	2911	14	:	:	:
8691	2911	15	See	see	VB
8691	2911	16	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	2911	17	.	.	.
8691	2912	1	IX	ix	NN
8691	2912	2	.	.	.
8691	2912	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2913	1	errors	error	NNS
8691	2913	2	in	in	IN
8691	2913	3	law	law	NN
8691	2913	4	of	of	IN
8691	2913	5	the	the	DT
8691	2913	6	higher	high	JJR
8691	2913	7	trial	trial	NN
8691	2913	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	2913	9	,	,	,
8691	2913	10	in	in	IN
8691	2913	11	a	a	DT
8691	2913	12	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2913	13	class	class	NN
8691	2913	14	of	of	IN
8691	2913	15	cases	case	NNS
8691	2913	16	,	,	,
8691	2913	17	are	be	VBP
8691	2913	18	finally	finally	RB
8691	2913	19	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	2913	20	of	of	IN
8691	2913	21	in	in	IN
8691	2913	22	an	an	DT
8691	2913	23	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
8691	2913	24	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2913	25	court	court	NN
8691	2913	26	,	,	,
8691	2913	27	constituted	constitute	VBD
8691	2913	28	to	to	TO
8691	2913	29	relieve	relieve	VB
8691	2913	30	the	the	DT
8691	2913	31	court	court	NN
8691	2913	32	of	of	IN
8691	2913	33	last	last	JJ
8691	2913	34	resort	resort	NN
8691	2913	35	from	from	IN
8691	2913	36	an	an	DT
8691	2913	37	overweight	overweight	NN
8691	2913	38	of	of	IN
8691	2913	39	business	business	NN
8691	2913	40	.	.	.
8691	2914	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2914	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2914	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2914	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2914	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2914	6	Ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2914	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2914	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	2914	9	the	the	DT
8691	2914	10	statutory	statutory	JJ
8691	2914	11	right	right	NN
8691	2914	12	of	of	IN
8691	2914	13	a	a	DT
8691	2914	14	defeated	defeat	VBN
8691	2914	15	litigant	litigant	NN
8691	2914	16	to	to	TO
8691	2914	17	take	take	VB
8691	2914	18	an	an	DT
8691	2914	19	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2914	20	,	,	,
8691	2914	21	provided	provide	VBN
8691	2914	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2914	23	can	can	MD
8691	2914	24	state	state	VB
8691	2914	25	any	any	DT
8691	2914	26	colorable	colorable	JJ
8691	2914	27	ground	ground	NN
8691	2914	28	of	of	IN
8691	2914	29	exception	exception	NN
8691	2914	30	.	.	.
8691	2915	1	In	in	IN
8691	2915	2	some	some	DT
8691	2915	3	jurisdictions	jurisdiction	NNS
8691	2915	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2915	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2915	6	required	require	VBN
8691	2915	7	to	to	TO
8691	2915	8	obtain	obtain	VB
8691	2915	9	the	the	DT
8691	2915	10	approval	approval	NN
8691	2915	11	of	of	IN
8691	2915	12	the	the	DT
8691	2915	13	trial	trial	NN
8691	2915	14	court	court	NN
8691	2915	15	or	or	CC
8691	2915	16	else	else	RB
8691	2915	17	of	of	IN
8691	2915	18	some	some	DT
8691	2915	19	member	member	NN
8691	2915	20	of	of	IN
8691	2915	21	the	the	DT
8691	2915	22	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2915	23	court	court	NN
8691	2915	24	.	.	.
8691	2916	1	There	there	EX
8691	2916	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2916	3	many	many	JJ
8691	2916	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2916	5	who	who	WP
8691	2916	6	think	think	VBP
8691	2916	7	that	that	IN
8691	2916	8	such	such	PDT
8691	2916	9	a	a	DT
8691	2916	10	practice	practice	NN
8691	2916	11	should	should	MD
8691	2916	12	be	be	VB
8691	2916	13	universally	universally	RB
8691	2916	14	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	2916	15	.	.	.
8691	2917	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2917	2	would	would	MD
8691	2917	3	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	2917	4	tend	tend	VB
8691	2917	5	to	to	TO
8691	2917	6	relieve	relieve	VB
8691	2917	7	the	the	DT
8691	2917	8	dockets	docket	NNS
8691	2917	9	of	of	IN
8691	2917	10	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2917	11	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	2917	12	,	,	,
8691	2917	13	and	and	CC
8691	2917	14	to	to	TO
8691	2917	15	bring	bring	VB
8691	2917	16	lawsuits	lawsuit	NNS
8691	2917	17	to	to	IN
8691	2917	18	a	a	DT
8691	2917	19	speedier	speedy	JJR
8691	2917	20	end	end	NN
8691	2917	21	.	.	.
8691	2918	1	If	if	IN
8691	2918	2	one	one	CD
8691	2918	3	were	be	VBD
8691	2918	4	sure	sure	JJ
8691	2918	5	that	that	IN
8691	2918	6	the	the	DT
8691	2918	7	judge	judge	NN
8691	2918	8	to	to	IN
8691	2918	9	whom	whom	WP
8691	2918	10	application	application	NN
8691	2918	11	was	be	VBD
8691	2918	12	made	make	VBN
8691	2918	13	for	for	IN
8691	2918	14	an	an	DT
8691	2918	15	approval	approval	NN
8691	2918	16	of	of	IN
8691	2918	17	the	the	DT
8691	2918	18	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2918	19	would	would	MD
8691	2918	20	always	always	RB
8691	2918	21	act	act	VB
8691	2918	22	intelligently	intelligently	RB
8691	2918	23	and	and	CC
8691	2918	24	impartially	impartially	RB
8691	2918	25	,	,	,
8691	2918	26	such	such	PDT
8691	2918	27	a	a	DT
8691	2918	28	precaution	precaution	NN
8691	2918	29	against	against	IN
8691	2918	30	useless	useless	JJ
8691	2918	31	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	2918	32	would	would	MD
8691	2918	33	be	be	VB
8691	2918	34	admirable	admirable	JJ
8691	2918	35	.	.	.
8691	2919	1	But	but	CC
8691	2919	2	the	the	DT
8691	2919	3	trial	trial	NN
8691	2919	4	judge	judge	NN
8691	2919	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2919	6	not	not	RB
8691	2919	7	in	in	IN
8691	2919	8	a	a	DT
8691	2919	9	position	position	NN
8691	2919	10	that	that	WDT
8691	2919	11	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	2919	12	leads	lead	VBZ
8691	2919	13	to	to	IN
8691	2919	14	an	an	DT
8691	2919	15	unprejudiced	unprejudiced	JJ
8691	2919	16	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2919	17	.	.	.
8691	2920	1	The	the	DT
8691	2920	2	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2920	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2920	4	asked	ask	VBN
8691	2920	5	on	on	IN
8691	2920	6	account	account	NN
8691	2920	7	of	of	IN
8691	2920	8	mistakes	mistake	NNS
8691	2920	9	of	of	IN
8691	2920	10	his	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2920	11	,	,	,
8691	2920	12	and	and	CC
8691	2920	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2920	14	will	will	MD
8691	2920	15	not	not	RB
8691	2920	16	be	be	VB
8691	2920	17	apt	apt	JJ
8691	2920	18	to	to	TO
8691	2920	19	think	think	VB
8691	2920	20	that	that	IN
8691	2920	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2920	22	has	have	VBZ
8691	2920	23	made	make	VBN
8691	2920	24	any	any	DT
8691	2920	25	.	.	.
8691	2921	1	The	the	DT
8691	2921	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	2921	3	of	of	IN
8691	2921	4	the	the	DT
8691	2921	5	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2921	6	court	court	NN
8691	2921	7	will	will	MD
8691	2921	8	be	be	VB
8691	2921	9	impartial	impartial	JJ
8691	2921	10	and	and	CC
8691	2921	11	unprejudiced	unprejudiced	JJ
8691	2921	12	,	,	,
8691	2921	13	but	but	CC
8691	2921	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2921	15	will	will	MD
8691	2921	16	have	have	VB
8691	2921	17	a	a	DT
8691	2921	18	very	very	RB
8691	2921	19	imperfect	imperfect	JJ
8691	2921	20	knowledge	knowledge	NN
8691	2921	21	of	of	IN
8691	2921	22	the	the	DT
8691	2921	23	case	case	NN
8691	2921	24	.	.	.
8691	2922	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2922	2	could	could	MD
8691	2922	3	only	only	RB
8691	2922	4	be	be	VB
8691	2922	5	asked	ask	VBN
8691	2922	6	to	to	TO
8691	2922	7	make	make	VB
8691	2922	8	a	a	DT
8691	2922	9	hasty	hasty	JJ
8691	2922	10	examination	examination	NN
8691	2922	11	of	of	IN
8691	2922	12	the	the	DT
8691	2922	13	points	point	NNS
8691	2922	14	involved	involve	VBN
8691	2922	15	,	,	,
8691	2922	16	and	and	CC
8691	2922	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2922	18	would	would	MD
8691	2922	19	be	be	VB
8691	2922	20	quite	quite	RB
8691	2922	21	possible	possible	JJ
8691	2922	22	for	for	IN
8691	2922	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2922	24	to	to	TO
8691	2922	25	reject	reject	VB
8691	2922	26	as	as	IN
8691	2922	27	frivolous	frivolous	JJ
8691	2922	28	grounds	ground	NNS
8691	2922	29	which	which	WDT
8691	2922	30	,	,	,
8691	2922	31	on	on	IN
8691	2922	32	a	a	DT
8691	2922	33	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
8691	2922	34	investigation	investigation	NN
8691	2922	35	after	after	IN
8691	2922	36	a	a	DT
8691	2922	37	full	full	JJ
8691	2922	38	argument	argument	NN
8691	2922	39	,	,	,
8691	2922	40	might	may	MD
8691	2922	41	have	have	VB
8691	2922	42	seemed	seem	VBN
8691	2922	43	to	to	IN
8691	2922	44	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2922	45	substantial	substantial	JJ
8691	2922	46	.	.	.
8691	2923	1	In	in	IN
8691	2923	2	view	view	NN
8691	2923	3	of	of	IN
8691	2923	4	these	these	DT
8691	2923	5	objections	objection	NNS
8691	2923	6	,	,	,
8691	2923	7	and	and	CC
8691	2923	8	of	of	IN
8691	2923	9	the	the	DT
8691	2923	10	unequal	unequal	JJ
8691	2923	11	attainments	attainment	NNS
8691	2923	12	and	and	CC
8691	2923	13	experience	experience	NN
8691	2923	14	of	of	IN
8691	2923	15	the	the	DT
8691	2923	16	different	different	JJ
8691	2923	17	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2923	18	of	of	IN
8691	2923	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2923	20	courts	court	NNS
8691	2923	21	,	,	,
8691	2923	22	the	the	DT
8691	2923	23	bar	bar	NN
8691	2923	24	are	be	VBP
8691	2923	25	generally	generally	RB
8691	2923	26	in	in	IN
8691	2923	27	favor	favor	NN
8691	2923	28	of	of	IN
8691	2923	29	making	make	VBG
8691	2923	30	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	2923	31	a	a	DT
8691	2923	32	matter	matter	NN
8691	2923	33	of	of	IN
8691	2923	34	right	right	JJ
8691	2923	35	;	;	:
8691	2923	36	and	and	CC
8691	2923	37	what	what	WP
8691	2923	38	the	the	DT
8691	2923	39	bar	bar	NN
8691	2923	40	favors	favor	VBZ
8691	2923	41	in	in	IN
8691	2923	42	such	such	PDT
8691	2923	43	a	a	DT
8691	2923	44	matter	matter	NN
8691	2923	45	the	the	DT
8691	2923	46	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	2923	47	usually	usually	RB
8691	2923	48	enacts	enact	VBZ
8691	2923	49	.	.	.
8691	2924	1	*	*	NFP
8691	2924	2	*	*	NFP
8691	2924	3	*	*	NFP
8691	2924	4	*	*	NFP
8691	2924	5	*	*	NFP
8691	2924	6	The	the	DT
8691	2924	7	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	2924	8	and	and	CC
8691	2924	9	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	2924	10	of	of	IN
8691	2924	11	all	all	DT
8691	2924	12	American	american	JJ
8691	2924	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	2924	14	of	of	IN
8691	2924	15	last	last	JJ
8691	2924	16	resort	resort	NN
8691	2924	17	are	be	VBP
8691	2924	18	officially	officially	RB
8691	2924	19	reported	report	VBN
8691	2924	20	for	for	IN
8691	2924	21	publication	publication	NN
8691	2924	22	.	.	.
8691	2925	1	At	at	IN
8691	2925	2	first	first	RB
8691	2925	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2925	4	were	be	VBD
8691	2925	5	not	not	RB
8691	2925	6	so	so	RB
8691	2925	7	reported	report	VBN
8691	2925	8	.	.	.
8691	2926	1	The	the	DT
8691	2926	2	earliest	early	JJS
8691	2926	3	volume	volume	NN
8691	2926	4	of	of	IN
8691	2926	5	American	american	JJ
8691	2926	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2926	7	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2926	8	(	(	-LRB-
8691	2926	9	Kirby	Kirby	NNP
8691	2926	10	's	's	POS
8691	2926	11	)	)	-RRB-
8691	2926	12	was	be	VBD
8691	2926	13	published	publish	VBN
8691	2926	14	in	in	IN
8691	2926	15	1789	1789	CD
8691	2926	16	as	as	IN
8691	2926	17	a	a	DT
8691	2926	18	private	private	JJ
8691	2926	19	venture	venture	NN
8691	2926	20	.	.	.
8691	2927	1	A	a	DT
8691	2927	2	few	few	JJ
8691	2927	3	years	year	NNS
8691	2927	4	later	later	RBR
8691	2927	5	the	the	DT
8691	2927	6	States	States	NNPS
8691	2927	7	began	begin	VBD
8691	2927	8	to	to	TO
8691	2927	9	provide	provide	VB
8691	2927	10	official	official	JJ
8691	2927	11	reporters	reporter	NNS
8691	2927	12	for	for	IN
8691	2927	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2927	14	highest	high	JJS
8691	2927	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	2927	16	and	and	CC
8691	2927	17	soon	soon	RB
8691	2927	18	assumed	assume	VBD
8691	2927	19	the	the	DT
8691	2927	20	expense	expense	NN
8691	2927	21	of	of	IN
8691	2927	22	publication	publication	NN
8691	2927	23	.	.	.
8691	2928	1	There	there	EX
8691	2928	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2928	3	now	now	RB
8691	2928	4	more	more	JJR
8691	2928	5	than	than	IN
8691	2928	6	fifty	fifty	CD
8691	2928	7	current	current	JJ
8691	2928	8	sets	set	NNS
8691	2928	9	of	of	IN
8691	2928	10	federal	federal	JJ
8691	2928	11	and	and	CC
8691	2928	12	State	State	NNP
8691	2928	13	reports	report	VBZ
8691	2928	14	,	,	,
8691	2928	15	the	the	DT
8691	2928	16	annual	annual	JJ
8691	2928	17	output	output	NN
8691	2928	18	being	be	VBG
8691	2928	19	about	about	RB
8691	2928	20	four	four	CD
8691	2928	21	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	2928	22	volumes	volume	NNS
8691	2928	23	,	,	,
8691	2928	24	containing	contain	VBG
8691	2928	25	25,000	25,000	CD
8691	2928	26	cases	case	NNS
8691	2928	27	.	.	.
8691	2929	1	The	the	DT
8691	2929	2	mere	mere	JJ
8691	2929	3	indexing	indexing	NN
8691	2929	4	and	and	CC
8691	2929	5	digesting	digesting	NN
8691	2929	6	of	of	IN
8691	2929	7	these	these	DT
8691	2929	8	reports	report	NNS
8691	2929	9	for	for	IN
8691	2929	10	the	the	DT
8691	2929	11	use	use	NN
8691	2929	12	of	of	IN
8691	2929	13	the	the	DT
8691	2929	14	bench	bench	NN
8691	2929	15	and	and	CC
8691	2929	16	bar	bar	NN
8691	2929	17	has	have	VBZ
8691	2929	18	become	become	VBN
8691	2929	19	a	a	DT
8691	2929	20	science	science	NN
8691	2929	21	.	.	.
8691	2930	1	While	while	IN
8691	2930	2	consulted	consult	VBN
8691	2930	3	by	by	IN
8691	2930	4	comparatively	comparatively	RB
8691	2930	5	few	few	JJ
8691	2930	6	who	who	WP
8691	2930	7	are	be	VBP
8691	2930	8	not	not	RB
8691	2930	9	connected	connect	VBN
8691	2930	10	with	with	IN
8691	2930	11	the	the	DT
8691	2930	12	legal	legal	JJ
8691	2930	13	profession	profession	NN
8691	2930	14	,	,	,
8691	2930	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2930	16	constitute	constitute	VBP
8691	2930	17	a	a	DT
8691	2930	18	set	set	NN
8691	2930	19	of	of	IN
8691	2930	20	public	public	JJ
8691	2930	21	records	record	NNS
8691	2930	22	of	of	IN
8691	2930	23	the	the	DT
8691	2930	24	highest	high	JJS
8691	2930	25	value	value	NN
8691	2930	26	to	to	IN
8691	2930	27	every	every	DT
8691	2930	28	student	student	NN
8691	2930	29	of	of	IN
8691	2930	30	history	history	NN
8691	2930	31	and	and	CC
8691	2930	32	sociology	sociology	NN
8691	2930	33	.	.	.
8691	2931	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2931	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	2931	3	:	:	:
8691	2931	4	See	see	VB
8691	2931	5	"	"	''
8691	2931	6	Two	two	CD
8691	2931	7	Centuries	Centuries	NNPS
8691	2931	8	'	'	POS
8691	2931	9	Growth	Growth	NNP
8691	2931	10	of	of	IN
8691	2931	11	American	American	NNP
8691	2931	12	Law	Law	NNP
8691	2931	13	,	,	,
8691	2931	14	"	"	''
8691	2931	15	6	6	CD
8691	2931	16	.	.	.
8691	2931	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2932	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2932	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2932	3	the	the	DT
8691	2932	4	custom	custom	NN
8691	2932	5	to	to	TO
8691	2932	6	prefix	prefix	VB
8691	2932	7	to	to	IN
8691	2932	8	the	the	DT
8691	2932	9	report	report	NN
8691	2932	10	of	of	IN
8691	2932	11	each	each	DT
8691	2932	12	case	case	NN
8691	2932	13	a	a	DT
8691	2932	14	head	head	NN
8691	2932	15	-	-	HYPH
8691	2932	16	note	note	NN
8691	2932	17	stating	state	VBG
8691	2932	18	briefly	briefly	RB
8691	2932	19	the	the	DT
8691	2932	20	points	point	NNS
8691	2932	21	decided	decide	VBD
8691	2932	22	.	.	.
8691	2933	1	Ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2933	2	this	this	DT
8691	2933	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2933	4	the	the	DT
8691	2933	5	work	work	NN
8691	2933	6	of	of	IN
8691	2933	7	the	the	DT
8691	2933	8	reporter	reporter	NN
8691	2933	9	.	.	.
8691	2934	1	In	in	IN
8691	2934	2	a	a	DT
8691	2934	3	few	few	JJ
8691	2934	4	States	state	NNS
8691	2934	5	the	the	DT
8691	2934	6	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2934	7	are	be	VBP
8691	2934	8	required	require	VBN
8691	2934	9	to	to	TO
8691	2934	10	prepare	prepare	VB
8691	2934	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2934	12	;	;	:
8691	2934	13	and	and	CC
8691	2934	14	to	to	TO
8691	2934	15	do	do	VB
8691	2934	16	so	so	RB
8691	2934	17	then	then	RB
8691	2934	18	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	2934	19	falls	fall	VBZ
8691	2934	20	to	to	IN
8691	2934	21	the	the	DT
8691	2934	22	lot	lot	NN
8691	2934	23	of	of	IN
8691	2934	24	that	that	DT
8691	2934	25	one	one	CD
8691	2934	26	of	of	IN
8691	2934	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2934	28	who	who	WP
8691	2934	29	wrote	write	VBD
8691	2934	30	the	the	DT
8691	2934	31	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2934	32	.	.	.
8691	2935	1	Occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	2935	2	the	the	DT
8691	2935	3	head	head	NN
8691	2935	4	-	-	HYPH
8691	2935	5	note	note	NN
8691	2935	6	contains	contain	VBZ
8691	2935	7	statements	statement	NNS
8691	2935	8	not	not	RB
8691	2935	9	supported	support	VBN
8691	2935	10	by	by	IN
8691	2935	11	the	the	DT
8691	2935	12	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2935	13	.	.	.
8691	2936	1	In	in	IN
8691	2936	2	such	such	JJ
8691	2936	3	case	case	NN
8691	2936	4	the	the	DT
8691	2936	5	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2936	6	controls	control	VBZ
8691	2936	7	unless	unless	IN
8691	2936	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2936	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	2936	10	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	2936	11	provided	provide	VBN
8691	2936	12	by	by	IN
8691	2936	13	statute	statute	NN
8691	2936	14	.	.	.
8691	2937	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2937	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	2937	3	not	not	RB
8691	2937	4	been	be	VBN
8691	2937	5	the	the	DT
8691	2937	6	usual	usual	JJ
8691	2937	7	custom	custom	NN
8691	2937	8	of	of	IN
8691	2937	9	English	english	JJ
8691	2937	10	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2937	11	of	of	IN
8691	2937	12	courts	court	NNS
8691	2937	13	of	of	IN
8691	2937	14	last	last	JJ
8691	2937	15	resort	resort	NN
8691	2937	16	to	to	TO
8691	2937	17	write	write	VB
8691	2937	18	out	out	RP
8691	2937	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2937	20	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	2937	21	.	.	.
8691	2938	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2938	2	have	have	VBP
8691	2938	3	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	2938	4	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	2938	5	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2938	6	orally	orally	RB
8691	2938	7	and	and	CC
8691	2938	8	left	leave	VBD
8691	2938	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2938	10	to	to	IN
8691	2938	11	the	the	DT
8691	2938	12	reporters	reporter	NNS
8691	2938	13	to	to	TO
8691	2938	14	put	put	VB
8691	2938	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2938	16	in	in	IN
8691	2938	17	shape	shape	NN
8691	2938	18	.	.	.
8691	2939	1	The	the	DT
8691	2939	2	consequence	consequence	NN
8691	2939	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	2939	4	been	be	VBN
8691	2939	5	that	that	IN
8691	2939	6	English	English	NNP
8691	2939	7	reports	report	NNS
8691	2939	8	have	have	VBP
8691	2939	9	a	a	DT
8691	2939	10	conversational	conversational	JJ
8691	2939	11	tone	tone	NN
8691	2939	12	,	,	,
8691	2939	13	and	and	CC
8691	2939	14	are	be	VBP
8691	2939	15	not	not	RB
8691	2939	16	free	free	JJ
8691	2939	17	from	from	IN
8691	2939	18	useless	useless	JJ
8691	2939	19	repetition	repetition	NN
8691	2939	20	.	.	.
8691	2940	1	This	this	DT
8691	2940	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	2940	3	been	be	VBN
8691	2940	4	not	not	RB
8691	2940	5	only	only	RB
8691	2940	6	a	a	DT
8691	2940	7	matter	matter	NN
8691	2940	8	of	of	IN
8691	2940	9	tradition	tradition	NN
8691	2940	10	but	but	CC
8691	2940	11	of	of	IN
8691	2940	12	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	2940	13	.	.	.
8691	2941	1	The	the	DT
8691	2941	2	English	english	JJ
8691	2941	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2941	4	have	have	VBP
8691	2941	5	always	always	RB
8691	2941	6	been	be	VBN
8691	2941	7	few	few	JJ
8691	2941	8	in	in	IN
8691	2941	9	number	number	NN
8691	2941	10	.	.	.
8691	2942	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2942	2	time	time	NN
8691	2942	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	2942	4	been	be	VBN
8691	2942	5	largely	largely	RB
8691	2942	6	occupied	occupy	VBN
8691	2942	7	in	in	IN
8691	2942	8	the	the	DT
8691	2942	9	trial	trial	NN
8691	2942	10	of	of	IN
8691	2942	11	cases	case	NNS
8691	2942	12	on	on	IN
8691	2942	13	the	the	DT
8691	2942	14	facts	fact	NNS
8691	2942	15	.	.	.
8691	2943	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2943	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2943	3	only	only	RB
8691	2943	4	in	in	IN
8691	2943	5	recent	recent	JJ
8691	2943	6	years	year	NNS
8691	2943	7	that	that	IN
8691	2943	8	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2943	9	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2943	10	have	have	VBP
8691	2943	11	been	be	VBN
8691	2943	12	set	set	VBN
8691	2943	13	apart	apart	RB
8691	2943	14	especially	especially	RB
8691	2943	15	for	for	IN
8691	2943	16	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2943	17	work	work	NN
8691	2943	18	.	.	.
8691	2944	1	American	american	JJ
8691	2944	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2944	3	,	,	,
8691	2944	4	on	on	IN
8691	2944	5	the	the	DT
8691	2944	6	other	other	JJ
8691	2944	7	hand	hand	NN
8691	2944	8	,	,	,
8691	2944	9	are	be	VBP
8691	2944	10	numerous	numerous	JJ
8691	2944	11	.	.	.
8691	2945	1	There	there	EX
8691	2945	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2945	3	the	the	DT
8691	2945	4	waste	waste	NN
8691	2945	5	of	of	IN
8691	2945	6	energy	energy	NN
8691	2945	7	in	in	IN
8691	2945	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2945	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2945	10	system	system	NN
8691	2945	11	which	which	WDT
8691	2945	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	2945	13	the	the	DT
8691	2945	14	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2945	15	concomitant	concomitant	NN
8691	2945	16	of	of	IN
8691	2945	17	the	the	DT
8691	2945	18	independent	independent	JJ
8691	2945	19	sphere	sphere	NN
8691	2945	20	belonging	belong	VBG
8691	2945	21	to	to	IN
8691	2945	22	each	each	DT
8691	2945	23	separate	separate	JJ
8691	2945	24	State	state	NN
8691	2945	25	.	.	.
8691	2946	1	Combination	combination	NN
8691	2946	2	of	of	IN
8691	2946	3	all	all	DT
8691	2946	4	of	of	IN
8691	2946	5	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2946	6	into	into	IN
8691	2946	7	one	one	CD
8691	2946	8	empire	empire	NN
8691	2946	9	would	would	MD
8691	2946	10	make	make	VB
8691	2946	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2946	12	easy	easy	JJ
8691	2946	13	to	to	TO
8691	2946	14	reduce	reduce	VB
8691	2946	15	the	the	DT
8691	2946	16	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	2946	17	to	to	IN
8691	2946	18	a	a	DT
8691	2946	19	tithe	tithe	NN
8691	2946	20	of	of	IN
8691	2946	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2946	22	present	present	JJ
8691	2946	23	numbers	number	NNS
8691	2946	24	.	.	.
8691	2947	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2947	2	salaries	salary	NNS
8691	2947	3	are	be	VBP
8691	2947	4	part	part	NN
8691	2947	5	of	of	IN
8691	2947	6	the	the	DT
8691	2947	7	price	price	NN
8691	2947	8	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2947	9	pay	pay	VBP
8691	2947	10	--	--	:
8691	2947	11	and	and	CC
8691	2947	12	can	can	MD
8691	2947	13	well	well	RB
8691	2947	14	afford	afford	VB
8691	2947	15	to	to	TO
8691	2947	16	pay	pay	VB
8691	2947	17	--	--	:
8691	2947	18	for	for	IN
8691	2947	19	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2947	20	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
8691	2947	21	system	system	NN
8691	2947	22	of	of	IN
8691	2947	23	political	political	JJ
8691	2947	24	government	government	NN
8691	2947	25	,	,	,
8691	2947	26	under	under	IN
8691	2947	27	which	which	WDT
8691	2947	28	every	every	DT
8691	2947	29	State	state	NN
8691	2947	30	is	be	VBZ
8691	2947	31	an	an	DT
8691	2947	32	_	_	NNP
8691	2947	33	imperium	imperium	NN
8691	2947	34	in	in	IN
8691	2947	35	imperio	imperio	NNP
8691	2947	36	_	_	NNP
8691	2947	37	.	.	.
8691	2948	1	The	the	DT
8691	2948	2	ever	ever	RB
8691	2948	3	-	-	HYPH
8691	2948	4	increasing	increase	VBG
8691	2948	5	number	number	NN
8691	2948	6	of	of	IN
8691	2948	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2948	8	States	state	NNS
8691	2948	9	,	,	,
8691	2948	10	each	each	DT
8691	2948	11	with	with	IN
8691	2948	12	a	a	DT
8691	2948	13	body	body	NN
8691	2948	14	of	of	IN
8691	2948	15	law	law	NN
8691	2948	16	not	not	RB
8691	2948	17	exactly	exactly	RB
8691	2948	18	like	like	IN
8691	2948	19	that	that	DT
8691	2948	20	of	of	IN
8691	2948	21	any	any	DT
8691	2948	22	other	other	JJ
8691	2948	23	,	,	,
8691	2948	24	and	and	CC
8691	2948	25	each	each	DT
8691	2948	26	with	with	IN
8691	2948	27	a	a	DT
8691	2948	28	written	write	VBN
8691	2948	29	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	2948	30	which	which	WDT
8691	2948	31	is	be	VBZ
8691	2948	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2948	33	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	2948	34	law	law	NNP
8691	2948	35	,	,	,
8691	2948	36	requires	require	VBZ
8691	2948	37	a	a	DT
8691	2948	38	court	court	NN
8691	2948	39	of	of	IN
8691	2948	40	last	last	JJ
8691	2948	41	resort	resort	NN
8691	2948	42	in	in	IN
8691	2948	43	each	each	DT
8691	2948	44	.	.	.
8691	2949	1	Experience	experience	NN
8691	2949	2	tends	tend	VBZ
8691	2949	3	to	to	TO
8691	2949	4	show	show	VB
8691	2949	5	that	that	IN
8691	2949	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2949	7	ought	ought	MD
8691	2949	8	not	not	RB
8691	2949	9	to	to	TO
8691	2949	10	be	be	VB
8691	2949	11	composed	compose	VBN
8691	2949	12	of	of	IN
8691	2949	13	less	less	JJR
8691	2949	14	than	than	IN
8691	2949	15	five	five	CD
8691	2949	16	.	.	.
8691	2950	1	There	there	EX
8691	2950	2	should	should	MD
8691	2950	3	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	2950	4	be	be	VB
8691	2950	5	an	an	DT
8691	2950	6	uneven	uneven	JJ
8691	2950	7	number	number	NN
8691	2950	8	to	to	TO
8691	2950	9	facilitate	facilitate	VB
8691	2950	10	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2950	11	by	by	IN
8691	2950	12	a	a	DT
8691	2950	13	majority	majority	NN
8691	2950	14	;	;	:
8691	2950	15	and	and	CC
8691	2950	16	unless	unless	IN
8691	2950	17	a	a	DT
8691	2950	18	minority	minority	NN
8691	2950	19	consists	consist	VBZ
8691	2950	20	of	of	IN
8691	2950	21	as	as	RB
8691	2950	22	many	many	JJ
8691	2950	23	as	as	IN
8691	2950	24	two	two	CD
8691	2950	25	,	,	,
8691	2950	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2950	27	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	2950	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	2950	29	apt	apt	JJ
8691	2950	30	to	to	TO
8691	2950	31	carry	carry	VB
8691	2950	32	little	little	JJ
8691	2950	33	weight	weight	NN
8691	2950	34	in	in	IN
8691	2950	35	public	public	JJ
8691	2950	36	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2950	37	.	.	.
8691	2951	1	In	in	IN
8691	2951	2	most	most	JJS
8691	2951	3	of	of	IN
8691	2951	4	the	the	DT
8691	2951	5	States	States	NNPS
8691	2951	6	the	the	DT
8691	2951	7	court	court	NN
8691	2951	8	of	of	IN
8691	2951	9	last	last	JJ
8691	2951	10	resort	resort	NN
8691	2951	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	2951	12	not	not	RB
8691	2951	13	overworked	overwork	VBN
8691	2951	14	.	.	.
8691	2952	1	In	in	IN
8691	2952	2	some	some	DT
8691	2952	3	the	the	DT
8691	2952	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2952	5	find	find	VBP
8691	2952	6	time	time	NN
8691	2952	7	to	to	TO
8691	2952	8	do	do	VB
8691	2952	9	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2952	10	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	2952	11	duty	duty	NN
8691	2952	12	in	in	IN
8691	2952	13	the	the	DT
8691	2952	14	trial	trial	NN
8691	2952	15	of	of	IN
8691	2952	16	original	original	JJ
8691	2952	17	causes	cause	NNS
8691	2952	18	.	.	.
8691	2953	1	This	this	DT
8691	2953	2	keeps	keep	VBZ
8691	2953	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2953	4	in	in	IN
8691	2953	5	touch	touch	NN
8691	2953	6	with	with	IN
8691	2953	7	the	the	DT
8691	2953	8	daily	daily	JJ
8691	2953	9	life	life	NN
8691	2953	10	of	of	IN
8691	2953	11	the	the	DT
8691	2953	12	community	community	NN
8691	2953	13	,	,	,
8691	2953	14	and	and	CC
8691	2953	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	2953	16	so	so	RB
8691	2953	17	far	far	RB
8691	2953	18	good	good	JJ
8691	2953	19	.	.	.
8691	2954	1	On	on	IN
8691	2954	2	the	the	DT
8691	2954	3	other	other	JJ
8691	2954	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	2954	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2954	6	disqualifies	disqualify	VBZ
8691	2954	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2954	8	from	from	IN
8691	2954	9	sitting	sit	VBG
8691	2954	10	on	on	IN
8691	2954	11	an	an	DT
8691	2954	12	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	2954	13	from	from	IN
8691	2954	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2954	15	own	own	JJ
8691	2954	16	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	2954	17	,	,	,
8691	2954	18	and	and	CC
8691	2954	19	so	so	RB
8691	2954	20	either	either	RB
8691	2954	21	reduces	reduce	VBZ
8691	2954	22	the	the	DT
8691	2954	23	number	number	NN
8691	2954	24	of	of	IN
8691	2954	25	the	the	DT
8691	2954	26	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2954	27	court	court	NN
8691	2954	28	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	2954	29	below	below	IN
8691	2954	30	that	that	DT
8691	2954	31	which	which	WDT
8691	2954	32	is	be	VBZ
8691	2954	33	normal	normal	JJ
8691	2954	34	and	and	CC
8691	2954	35	presumably	presumably	RB
8691	2954	36	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2954	37	,	,	,
8691	2954	38	or	or	CC
8691	2954	39	involves	involve	VBZ
8691	2954	40	calling	call	VBG
8691	2954	41	in	in	IN
8691	2954	42	some	some	DT
8691	2954	43	one	one	NN
8691	2954	44	to	to	TO
8691	2954	45	act	act	VB
8691	2954	46	temporarily	temporarily	RB
8691	2954	47	,	,	,
8691	2954	48	which	which	WDT
8691	2954	49	imperils	imperil	VBZ
8691	2954	50	the	the	DT
8691	2954	51	continuity	continuity	NN
8691	2954	52	of	of	IN
8691	2954	53	thought	thought	NN
8691	2954	54	and	and	CC
8691	2954	55	uniformity	uniformity	NN
8691	2954	56	of	of	IN
8691	2954	57	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	2954	58	which	which	WDT
8691	2954	59	should	should	MD
8691	2954	60	characterize	characterize	VB
8691	2954	61	every	every	DT
8691	2954	62	such	such	JJ
8691	2954	63	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	2954	64	.	.	.
8691	2955	1	There	there	EX
8691	2955	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2955	3	also	also	RB
8691	2955	4	a	a	DT
8691	2955	5	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2955	6	natural	natural	JJ
8691	2955	7	bias	bias	NN
8691	2955	8	,	,	,
8691	2955	9	insensible	insensible	JJ
8691	2955	10	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	2955	11	to	to	IN
8691	2955	12	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2955	13	,	,	,
8691	2955	14	which	which	WDT
8691	2955	15	tends	tend	VBZ
8691	2955	16	to	to	TO
8691	2955	17	make	make	VB
8691	2955	18	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2955	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	2955	20	stand	stand	VB
8691	2955	21	by	by	IN
8691	2955	22	one	one	CD
8691	2955	23	of	of	IN
8691	2955	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2955	25	members	member	NNS
8691	2955	26	whose	whose	WP$
8691	2955	27	rulings	ruling	NNS
8691	2955	28	while	while	IN
8691	2955	29	holding	hold	VBG
8691	2955	30	a	a	DT
8691	2955	31	trial	trial	NN
8691	2955	32	court	court	NN
8691	2955	33	are	be	VBP
8691	2955	34	brought	bring	VBN
8691	2955	35	in	in	RP
8691	2955	36	question	question	NN
8691	2955	37	.	.	.
8691	2956	1	For	for	IN
8691	2956	2	these	these	DT
8691	2956	3	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	2956	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2956	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	2956	6	now	now	RB
8691	2956	7	become	become	VBN
8691	2956	8	common	common	JJ
8691	2956	9	for	for	IN
8691	2956	10	the	the	DT
8691	2956	11	States	States	NNPS
8691	2956	12	to	to	TO
8691	2956	13	confine	confine	VB
8691	2956	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2956	15	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2956	16	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2956	17	exclusively	exclusively	RB
8691	2956	18	to	to	TO
8691	2956	19	appellate	appellate	VB
8691	2956	20	work	work	NN
8691	2956	21	.	.	.
8691	2957	1	The	the	DT
8691	2957	2	time	time	NN
8691	2957	3	,	,	,
8691	2957	4	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	2957	5	,	,	,
8691	2957	6	which	which	WDT
8691	2957	7	the	the	DT
8691	2957	8	English	english	JJ
8691	2957	9	judge	judge	NN
8691	2957	10	gives	give	VBZ
8691	2957	11	to	to	IN
8691	2957	12	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	2957	13	duty	duty	NN
8691	2957	14	the	the	DT
8691	2957	15	American	american	JJ
8691	2957	16	judge	judge	NN
8691	2957	17	can	can	MD
8691	2957	18	give	give	VB
8691	2957	19	to	to	IN
8691	2957	20	writing	write	VBG
8691	2957	21	out	out	RP
8691	2957	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2957	23	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	2957	24	with	with	IN
8691	2957	25	all	all	PDT
8691	2957	26	the	the	DT
8691	2957	27	art	art	NN
8691	2957	28	and	and	CC
8691	2957	29	care	care	NN
8691	2957	30	which	which	WDT
8691	2957	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2957	32	can	can	MD
8691	2957	33	command	command	VB
8691	2957	34	.	.	.
8691	2958	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2958	2	speaks	speak	VBZ
8691	2958	3	in	in	IN
8691	2958	4	most	most	JJS
8691	2958	5	instances	instance	NNS
8691	2958	6	to	to	IN
8691	2958	7	a	a	DT
8691	2958	8	small	small	JJ
8691	2958	9	audience	audience	NN
8691	2958	10	--	--	:
8691	2958	11	the	the	DT
8691	2958	12	bar	bar	NN
8691	2958	13	alone	alone	RB
8691	2958	14	.	.	.
8691	2959	1	But	but	CC
8691	2959	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2959	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2959	4	the	the	DT
8691	2959	5	bar	bar	NN
8691	2959	6	of	of	IN
8691	2959	7	this	this	DT
8691	2959	8	year	year	NN
8691	2959	9	and	and	CC
8691	2959	10	the	the	DT
8691	2959	11	next	next	JJ
8691	2959	12	year	year	NN
8691	2959	13	and	and	CC
8691	2959	14	the	the	DT
8691	2959	15	next	next	JJ
8691	2959	16	century	century	NN
8691	2959	17	.	.	.
8691	2960	1	Every	every	DT
8691	2960	2	volume	volume	NN
8691	2960	3	of	of	IN
8691	2960	4	reports	report	NNS
8691	2960	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	2960	6	part	part	NN
8691	2960	7	of	of	IN
8691	2960	8	the	the	DT
8691	2960	9	history	history	NN
8691	2960	10	of	of	IN
8691	2960	11	American	american	JJ
8691	2960	12	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	2960	13	and	and	CC
8691	2960	14	of	of	IN
8691	2960	15	American	american	JJ
8691	2960	16	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	2960	17	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2960	18	.	.	.
8691	2961	1	Occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	2961	2	some	some	DT
8691	2961	3	case	case	NN
8691	2961	4	arises	arise	VBZ
8691	2961	5	which	which	WDT
8691	2961	6	involves	involve	VBZ
8691	2961	7	large	large	JJ
8691	2961	8	political	political	JJ
8691	2961	9	questions	question	NNS
8691	2961	10	,	,	,
8691	2961	11	or	or	CC
8691	2961	12	one	one	CD
8691	2961	13	of	of	IN
8691	2961	14	especial	especial	JJ
8691	2961	15	local	local	JJ
8691	2961	16	interest	interest	NN
8691	2961	17	.	.	.
8691	2962	1	The	the	DT
8691	2962	2	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2962	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2962	4	then	then	RB
8691	2962	5	read	read	VBN
8691	2962	6	more	more	RBR
8691	2962	7	widely	widely	RB
8691	2962	8	.	.	.
8691	2963	1	The	the	DT
8691	2963	2	newspapers	newspaper	NNS
8691	2963	3	seize	seize	VBP
8691	2963	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2963	5	:	:	:
8691	2963	6	reviews	review	NNS
8691	2963	7	take	take	VB
8691	2963	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2963	9	up	up	RP
8691	2963	10	.	.	.
8691	2964	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2964	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2964	3	not	not	RB
8691	2964	4	always	always	RB
8691	2964	5	easy	easy	JJ
8691	2964	6	to	to	TO
8691	2964	7	anticipate	anticipate	VB
8691	2964	8	what	what	WDT
8691	2964	9	decision	decision	NN
8691	2964	10	will	will	MD
8691	2964	11	become	become	VB
8691	2964	12	a	a	DT
8691	2964	13	matter	matter	NN
8691	2964	14	of	of	IN
8691	2964	15	public	public	JJ
8691	2964	16	notoriety	notoriety	NN
8691	2964	17	;	;	:
8691	2964	18	what	what	WDT
8691	2964	19	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2964	20	will	will	MD
8691	2964	21	be	be	VB
8691	2964	22	quoted	quote	VBN
8691	2964	23	as	as	IN
8691	2964	24	an	an	DT
8691	2964	25	authority	authority	NN
8691	2964	26	in	in	IN
8691	2964	27	other	other	JJ
8691	2964	28	States	States	NNPS
8691	2964	29	;	;	:
8691	2964	30	and	and	CC
8691	2964	31	what	what	WP
8691	2964	32	drop	drop	NN
8691	2964	33	unnoticed	unnoticed	JJ
8691	2964	34	except	except	IN
8691	2964	35	by	by	IN
8691	2964	36	the	the	DT
8691	2964	37	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	2964	38	in	in	IN
8691	2964	39	the	the	DT
8691	2964	40	cause	cause	NN
8691	2964	41	.	.	.
8691	2965	1	A	a	DT
8691	2965	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	2965	3	,	,	,
8691	2965	4	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	2965	5	,	,	,
8691	2965	6	though	though	IN
8691	2965	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2965	8	have	have	VBP
8691	2965	9	no	no	DT
8691	2965	10	better	well	JJR
8691	2965	11	motive	motive	NN
8691	2965	12	than	than	IN
8691	2965	13	personal	personal	JJ
8691	2965	14	ambition	ambition	NN
8691	2965	15	,	,	,
8691	2965	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	2965	17	apt	apt	JJ
8691	2965	18	to	to	TO
8691	2965	19	do	do	VB
8691	2965	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2965	21	best	good	JJS
8691	2965	22	in	in	IN
8691	2965	23	every	every	DT
8691	2965	24	case	case	NN
8691	2965	25	to	to	TO
8691	2965	26	state	state	NN
8691	2965	27	the	the	DT
8691	2965	28	grounds	ground	NNS
8691	2965	29	of	of	IN
8691	2965	30	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2965	31	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2965	32	clearly	clearly	RB
8691	2965	33	and	and	CC
8691	2965	34	in	in	IN
8691	2965	35	order	order	NN
8691	2965	36	.	.	.
8691	2966	1	A	a	DT
8691	2966	2	certain	certain	JJ
8691	2966	3	style	style	NN
8691	2966	4	of	of	IN
8691	2966	5	American	american	JJ
8691	2966	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2966	7	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2966	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	2966	9	thus	thus	RB
8691	2966	10	grown	grow	VBN
8691	2966	11	up	up	RP
8691	2966	12	.	.	.
8691	2967	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2967	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2967	3	dogmatic	dogmatic	JJ
8691	2967	4	.	.	.
8691	2968	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2968	2	offers	offer	VBZ
8691	2968	3	no	no	DT
8691	2968	4	apologies	apology	NNS
8691	2968	5	.	.	.
8691	2969	1	There	there	EX
8691	2969	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2969	3	neither	neither	DT
8691	2969	4	time	time	NN
8691	2969	5	nor	nor	CC
8691	2969	6	need	need	VB
8691	2969	7	for	for	IN
8691	2969	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2969	9	.	.	.
8691	2970	1	The	the	DT
8691	2970	2	writer	writer	NN
8691	2970	3	speaks	speak	VBZ
8691	2970	4	"	"	``
8691	2970	5	as	as	IN
8691	2970	6	one	one	CD
8691	2970	7	having	have	VBG
8691	2970	8	authority	authority	NN
8691	2970	9	.	.	.
8691	2970	10	"	"	''
8691	2971	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2971	2	does	do	VBZ
8691	2971	3	not	not	RB
8691	2971	4	argue	argue	VB
8691	2971	5	out	out	RP
8691	2971	6	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2971	7	previously	previously	RB
8691	2971	8	settled	settle	VBN
8691	2971	9	by	by	IN
8691	2971	10	former	former	JJ
8691	2971	11	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	2971	12	,	,	,
8691	2971	13	but	but	CC
8691	2971	14	contents	content	VBZ
8691	2971	15	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2971	16	with	with	IN
8691	2971	17	a	a	DT
8691	2971	18	reference	reference	NN
8691	2971	19	to	to	IN
8691	2971	20	the	the	DT
8691	2971	21	case	case	NN
8691	2971	22	in	in	IN
8691	2971	23	the	the	DT
8691	2971	24	reports	report	NNS
8691	2971	25	in	in	IN
8691	2971	26	which	which	WDT
8691	2971	27	the	the	DT
8691	2971	28	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	2971	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	2971	30	to	to	TO
8691	2971	31	be	be	VB
8691	2971	32	found	find	VBN
8691	2971	33	.	.	.
8691	2972	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2972	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2972	3	as	as	RB
8691	2972	4	brief	brief	JJ
8691	2972	5	as	as	IN
8691	2972	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2972	7	dares	dare	VBZ
8691	2972	8	to	to	TO
8691	2972	9	be	be	VB
8691	2972	10	without	without	IN
8691	2972	11	risking	risk	VBG
8691	2972	12	obscurity	obscurity	NN
8691	2972	13	.	.	.
8691	2973	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2973	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2973	3	undoubtedly	undoubtedly	RB
8691	2973	4	true	true	JJ
8691	2973	5	that	that	IN
8691	2973	6	many	many	JJ
8691	2973	7	reported	report	VBN
8691	2973	8	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	2973	9	are	be	VBP
8691	2973	10	of	of	IN
8691	2973	11	a	a	DT
8691	2973	12	very	very	RB
8691	2973	13	different	different	JJ
8691	2973	14	type	type	NN
8691	2973	15	.	.	.
8691	2974	1	Some	some	DT
8691	2974	2	of	of	IN
8691	2974	3	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	2974	4	's	's	POS
8691	2974	5	assume	assume	VB
8691	2974	6	a	a	DT
8691	2974	7	tone	tone	NN
8691	2974	8	of	of	IN
8691	2974	9	apology	apology	NN
8691	2974	10	;	;	:
8691	2974	11	but	but	CC
8691	2974	12	in	in	IN
8691	2974	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2974	14	day	day	NN
8691	2974	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2974	16	was	be	VBD
8691	2974	17	needed	need	VBN
8691	2974	18	.	.	.
8691	2975	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2975	2	struck	strike	VBD
8691	2975	3	at	at	IN
8691	2975	4	cherished	cherish	VBN
8691	2975	5	rights	right	NNS
8691	2975	6	of	of	IN
8691	2975	7	States	States	NNP
8691	2975	8	,	,	,
8691	2975	9	upheld	uphold	VBN
8691	2975	10	by	by	IN
8691	2975	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2975	12	highest	high	JJS
8691	2975	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	2975	14	,	,	,
8691	2975	15	and	and	CC
8691	2975	16	struck	strike	VBD
8691	2975	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2975	18	down	down	RP
8691	2975	19	,	,	,
8691	2975	20	at	at	IN
8691	2975	21	a	a	DT
8691	2975	22	time	time	NN
8691	2975	23	when	when	WRB
8691	2975	24	the	the	DT
8691	2975	25	country	country	NN
8691	2975	26	was	be	VBD
8691	2975	27	unfamiliar	unfamiliar	JJ
8691	2975	28	with	with	IN
8691	2975	29	the	the	DT
8691	2975	30	conception	conception	NN
8691	2975	31	of	of	IN
8691	2975	32	the	the	DT
8691	2975	33	United	United	NNP
8691	2975	34	States	States	NNP
8691	2975	35	as	as	IN
8691	2975	36	a	a	DT
8691	2975	37	national	national	JJ
8691	2975	38	force	force	NN
8691	2975	39	.	.	.
8691	2976	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	2976	2	of	of	IN
8691	2976	3	those	those	DT
8691	2976	4	of	of	IN
8691	2976	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2976	6	of	of	IN
8691	2976	7	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	2976	8	ability	ability	NN
8691	2976	9	do	do	VBP
8691	2976	10	not	not	RB
8691	2976	11	rise	rise	VB
8691	2976	12	above	above	IN
8691	2976	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2976	14	source	source	NN
8691	2976	15	.	.	.
8691	2977	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2977	2	are	be	VBP
8691	2977	3	verbose	verbose	JJ
8691	2977	4	,	,	,
8691	2977	5	repetitious	repetitious	JJ
8691	2977	6	,	,	,
8691	2977	7	slovenly	slovenly	RB
8691	2977	8	,	,	,
8691	2977	9	inaccurate	inaccurate	JJ
8691	2977	10	in	in	IN
8691	2977	11	statement	statement	NN
8691	2977	12	,	,	,
8691	2977	13	loose	loose	JJ
8691	2977	14	in	in	IN
8691	2977	15	form	form	NN
8691	2977	16	;	;	:
8691	2977	17	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	2977	18	sinking	sink	VBG
8691	2977	19	into	into	IN
8691	2977	20	a	a	DT
8691	2977	21	humor	humor	NN
8691	2977	22	or	or	CC
8691	2977	23	sarcasm	sarcasm	VB
8691	2977	24	always	always	RB
8691	2977	25	out	out	IN
8691	2977	26	of	of	IN
8691	2977	27	place	place	NN
8691	2977	28	in	in	IN
8691	2977	29	the	the	DT
8691	2977	30	reports;[Footnote	reports;[footnote	NN
8691	2977	31	:	:	:
8691	2977	32	See	see	VB
8691	2977	33	,	,	,
8691	2977	34	for	for	IN
8691	2977	35	instance	instance	NN
8691	2977	36	,	,	,
8691	2977	37	Mincey	Mincey	NNP
8691	2977	38	_	_	NNP
8691	2977	39	v.	v.	IN
8691	2977	40	_	_	NNP
8691	2977	41	Bradburn	Bradburn	NNP
8691	2977	42	,	,	,
8691	2977	43	103	103	CD
8691	2977	44	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
8691	2977	45	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	2977	46	,	,	,
8691	2977	47	407	407	CD
8691	2977	48	;	;	:
8691	2977	49	Terry	Terry	NNP
8691	2977	50	_	_	NNP
8691	2977	51	v.	v.	IN
8691	2977	52	_	_	NNP
8691	2977	53	McDaniel	McDaniel	NNP
8691	2977	54	,	,	,
8691	2977	55	_	_	NNP
8691	2977	56	ibid	ibid	NNP
8691	2977	57	_	_	NNP
8691	2977	58	.	.	NNP
8691	2977	59	,	,	,
8691	2977	60	415	415	CD
8691	2977	61	;	;	:
8691	2977	62	Hall	Hall	NNP
8691	2977	63	-	-	HYPH
8691	2977	64	Moody	Moody	NNP
8691	2977	65	Institute	Institute	NNP
8691	2977	66	_	_	NNP
8691	2977	67	v.	v.	IN
8691	2977	68	_	_	NNP
8691	2977	69	Copass	Copass	NNP
8691	2977	70	,	,	,
8691	2977	71	108	108	CD
8691	2977	72	_	_	NNP
8691	2977	73	i	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2977	74	d	d	NNP
8691	2977	75	_	_	NNP
8691	2977	76	.	.	NNP
8691	2977	77	,	,	,
8691	2977	78	582	582	CD
8691	2977	79	.	.	.
8691	2977	80	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2978	1	possibly	possibly	RB
8691	2978	2	unfair	unfair	JJ
8691	2978	3	in	in	IN
8691	2978	4	describing	describe	VBG
8691	2978	5	the	the	DT
8691	2978	6	claims	claim	NNS
8691	2978	7	that	that	WDT
8691	2978	8	are	be	VBP
8691	2978	9	overruled	overrule	VBN
8691	2978	10	.	.	.
8691	2979	1	But	but	CC
8691	2979	2	,	,	,
8691	2979	3	as	as	IN
8691	2979	4	a	a	DT
8691	2979	5	whole	whole	NN
8691	2979	6	,	,	,
8691	2979	7	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	2979	8	need	need	VBP
8691	2979	9	not	not	RB
8691	2979	10	fear	fear	VB
8691	2979	11	to	to	TO
8691	2979	12	compare	compare	VB
8691	2979	13	the	the	DT
8691	2979	14	reports	report	NNS
8691	2979	15	of	of	IN
8691	2979	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2979	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	2979	18	with	with	IN
8691	2979	19	those	those	DT
8691	2979	20	of	of	IN
8691	2979	21	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	2979	22	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	2979	23	.	.	.
8691	2980	1	No	no	DT
8691	2980	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	2980	3	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	2980	4	,	,	,
8691	2980	5	viewed	view	VBN
8691	2980	6	from	from	IN
8691	2980	7	the	the	DT
8691	2980	8	point	point	NN
8691	2980	9	of	of	IN
8691	2980	10	style	style	NN
8691	2980	11	and	and	CC
8691	2980	12	argument	argument	NN
8691	2980	13	,	,	,
8691	2980	14	rank	rank	NN
8691	2980	15	higher	high	JJR
8691	2980	16	than	than	IN
8691	2980	17	some	some	DT
8691	2980	18	of	of	IN
8691	2980	19	those	those	DT
8691	2980	20	written	write	VBN
8691	2980	21	by	by	IN
8691	2980	22	American	american	JJ
8691	2980	23	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2980	24	.	.	.
8691	2981	1	Those	those	DT
8691	2981	2	of	of	IN
8691	2981	3	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2981	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	2981	5	are	be	VBP
8691	2981	6	generally	generally	RB
8691	2981	7	composed	compose	VBN
8691	2981	8	and	and	CC
8691	2981	9	delivered	deliver	VBN
8691	2981	10	by	by	IN
8691	2981	11	a	a	DT
8691	2981	12	single	single	JJ
8691	2981	13	one	one	CD
8691	2981	14	of	of	IN
8691	2981	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2981	16	members	member	NNS
8691	2981	17	,	,	,
8691	2981	18	but	but	CC
8691	2981	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2981	20	speaks	speak	VBZ
8691	2981	21	not	not	RB
8691	2981	22	only	only	RB
8691	2981	23	for	for	IN
8691	2981	24	the	the	DT
8691	2981	25	court	court	NN
8691	2981	26	but	but	CC
8691	2981	27	for	for	IN
8691	2981	28	every	every	DT
8691	2981	29	other	other	JJ
8691	2981	30	member	member	NN
8691	2981	31	of	of	IN
8691	2981	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2981	33	who	who	WP
8691	2981	34	does	do	VBZ
8691	2981	35	not	not	RB
8691	2981	36	expressly	expressly	RB
8691	2981	37	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	2981	38	.	.	.
8691	2982	1	Nevertheless	nevertheless	RB
8691	2982	2	,	,	,
8691	2982	3	as	as	IN
8691	2982	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2982	5	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2982	6	depend	depend	VBP
8691	2982	7	on	on	IN
8691	2982	8	one	one	CD
8691	2982	9	man	man	NN
8691	2982	10	for	for	IN
8691	2982	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2982	12	proper	proper	JJ
8691	2982	13	expression	expression	NN
8691	2982	14	,	,	,
8691	2982	15	the	the	DT
8691	2982	16	responsibility	responsibility	NN
8691	2982	17	for	for	IN
8691	2982	18	the	the	DT
8691	2982	19	particular	particular	JJ
8691	2982	20	manner	manner	NN
8691	2982	21	in	in	IN
8691	2982	22	which	which	WDT
8691	2982	23	the	the	DT
8691	2982	24	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2982	25	may	may	MD
8691	2982	26	set	set	VB
8691	2982	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2982	28	forth	forth	RB
8691	2982	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	2982	30	properly	properly	RB
8691	2982	31	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	2982	32	in	in	IN
8691	2982	33	a	a	DT
8691	2982	34	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
8691	2982	35	sense	sense	NN
8691	2982	36	to	to	TO
8691	2982	37	rest	rest	VB
8691	2982	38	upon	upon	IN
8691	2982	39	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2982	40	.	.	.
8691	2983	1	Nor	nor	CC
8691	2983	2	,	,	,
8691	2983	3	if	if	IN
8691	2983	4	the	the	DT
8691	2983	5	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2983	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	2983	7	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	2983	8	relied	rely	VBN
8691	2983	9	on	on	RP
8691	2983	10	as	as	IN
8691	2983	11	establishing	establish	VBG
8691	2983	12	a	a	DT
8691	2983	13	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	2983	14	,	,	,
8691	2983	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	2983	16	the	the	DT
8691	2983	17	court	court	NN
8691	2983	18	bound	bind	VBN
8691	2983	19	by	by	IN
8691	2983	20	anything	anything	NN
8691	2983	21	except	except	IN
8691	2983	22	the	the	DT
8691	2983	23	statement	statement	NN
8691	2983	24	of	of	IN
8691	2983	25	the	the	DT
8691	2983	26	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2983	27	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2983	28	to	to	TO
8691	2983	29	support	support	VB
8691	2983	30	the	the	DT
8691	2983	31	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	2983	32	.	.	.
8691	2984	1	If	if	IN
8691	2984	2	unsound	unsound	JJ
8691	2984	3	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	2984	4	for	for	IN
8691	2984	5	those	those	DT
8691	2984	6	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	2984	7	are	be	VBP
8691	2984	8	given	give	VBN
8691	2984	9	,	,	,
8691	2984	10	defective	defective	JJ
8691	2984	11	illustrations	illustration	NNS
8691	2984	12	used	use	VBN
8691	2984	13	,	,	,
8691	2984	14	or	or	CC
8691	2984	15	unguarded	unguarded	JJ
8691	2984	16	assertions	assertion	NNS
8691	2984	17	made	make	VBN
8691	2984	18	,	,	,
8691	2984	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2984	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	2984	21	chargeable	chargeable	JJ
8691	2984	22	with	with	IN
8691	2984	23	no	no	DT
8691	2984	24	inconsistency	inconsistency	NN
8691	2984	25	in	in	IN
8691	2984	26	subsequently	subsequently	RB
8691	2984	27	treating	treat	VBG
8691	2984	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2984	29	as	as	IN
8691	2984	30	merely	merely	RB
8691	2984	31	the	the	DT
8691	2984	32	individual	individual	JJ
8691	2984	33	expressions	expression	NNS
8691	2984	34	of	of	IN
8691	2984	35	the	the	DT
8691	2984	36	judge	judge	NN
8691	2984	37	who	who	WP
8691	2984	38	wrote	write	VBD
8691	2984	39	the	the	DT
8691	2984	40	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2984	41	.	.	.
8691	2985	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2985	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	2985	3	:	:	:
8691	2985	4	Exchange	Exchange	NNP
8691	2985	5	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	2985	6	of	of	IN
8691	2985	7	St.	St.	NNP
8691	2985	8	Louis	Louis	NNP
8691	2985	9	_	_	NNP
8691	2985	10	v.	v.	IN
8691	2985	11	_	_	NNP
8691	2985	12	Rice	Rice	NNP
8691	2985	13	,	,	,
8691	2985	14	107	107	CD
8691	2985	15	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	2986	1	Reports	report	NNS
8691	2986	2	,	,	,
8691	2986	3	37	37	CD
8691	2986	4	,	,	,
8691	2986	5	41	41	CD
8691	2986	6	.	.	.
8691	2987	1	This	this	DT
8691	2987	2	position	position	NN
8691	2987	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	2987	4	not	not	RB
8691	2987	5	,	,	,
8691	2987	6	universally	universally	RB
8691	2987	7	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	2987	8	.	.	.
8691	2988	1	See	see	VB
8691	2988	2	Merriman	Merriman	NNP
8691	2988	3	_	_	NNP
8691	2988	4	v.	v.	IN
8691	2988	5	_	_	NNP
8691	2988	6	Social	Social	NNP
8691	2988	7	Manufacturing	Manufacturing	NNP
8691	2988	8	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	2988	9	,	,	,
8691	2988	10	12	12	CD
8691	2988	11	R.	R.	NNP
8691	2988	12	I.	i.	NN
8691	2989	1	Reports	report	NNS
8691	2989	2	,	,	,
8691	2989	3	175	175	CD
8691	2989	4	,	,	,
8691	2989	5	184	184	CD
8691	2989	6	.	.	.
8691	2989	7	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2990	1	When	when	WRB
8691	2990	2	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	2990	3	became	become	VBD
8691	2990	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	2990	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2990	6	of	of	IN
8691	2990	7	the	the	DT
8691	2990	8	United	United	NNP
8691	2990	9	States	States	NNP
8691	2990	10	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2990	11	introduced	introduce	VBD
8691	2990	12	the	the	DT
8691	2990	13	practice	practice	NN
8691	2990	14	of	of	IN
8691	2990	15	writing	write	VBG
8691	2990	16	all	all	PDT
8691	2990	17	the	the	DT
8691	2990	18	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	2990	19	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2990	20	,	,	,
8691	2990	21	and	and	CC
8691	2990	22	with	with	IN
8691	2990	23	a	a	DT
8691	2990	24	few	few	JJ
8691	2990	25	exceptions	exception	NNS
8691	2990	26	maintained	maintain	VBD
8691	2990	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2990	28	for	for	IN
8691	2990	29	ten	ten	CD
8691	2990	30	years	year	NNS
8691	2990	31	,	,	,
8691	2990	32	and	and	CC
8691	2990	33	until	until	IN
8691	2990	34	,	,	,
8691	2990	35	by	by	IN
8691	2990	36	successive	successive	JJ
8691	2990	37	changes	change	NNS
8691	2990	38	in	in	IN
8691	2990	39	the	the	DT
8691	2990	40	court	court	NN
8691	2990	41	,	,	,
8691	2990	42	a	a	DT
8691	2990	43	majority	majority	NN
8691	2990	44	were	be	VBD
8691	2990	45	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
8691	2990	46	.	.	.
8691	2991	1	This	this	DT
8691	2991	2	,	,	,
8691	2991	3	as	as	IN
8691	2991	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	2991	5	been	be	VBN
8691	2991	6	well	well	RB
8691	2991	7	said	say	VBN
8691	2991	8	,	,	,
8691	2991	9	"	"	``
8691	2991	10	seemed	seem	VBD
8691	2991	11	all	all	DT
8691	2991	12	of	of	RB
8691	2991	13	a	a	DT
8691	2991	14	sudden	sudden	JJ
8691	2991	15	to	to	TO
8691	2991	16	give	give	VB
8691	2991	17	to	to	IN
8691	2991	18	the	the	DT
8691	2991	19	judicial	judicial	NNP
8691	2991	20	department	department	NN
8691	2991	21	a	a	DT
8691	2991	22	unity	unity	NN
8691	2991	23	like	like	IN
8691	2991	24	that	that	DT
8691	2991	25	of	of	IN
8691	2991	26	the	the	DT
8691	2991	27	executive	executive	NN
8691	2991	28	,	,	,
8691	2991	29	to	to	TO
8691	2991	30	concentrate	concentrate	VB
8691	2991	31	the	the	DT
8691	2991	32	whole	whole	JJ
8691	2991	33	force	force	NN
8691	2991	34	of	of	IN
8691	2991	35	that	that	DT
8691	2991	36	department	department	NN
8691	2991	37	in	in	IN
8691	2991	38	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2991	39	chief	chief	NN
8691	2991	40	,	,	,
8691	2991	41	and	and	CC
8691	2991	42	to	to	TO
8691	2991	43	reduce	reduce	VB
8691	2991	44	the	the	DT
8691	2991	45	side	side	NN
8691	2991	46	justices	justice	NNS
8691	2991	47	to	to	IN
8691	2991	48	a	a	DT
8691	2991	49	sort	sort	NN
8691	2991	50	of	of	IN
8691	2991	51	cabinet	cabinet	NN
8691	2991	52	advisers	adviser	NNS
8691	2991	53	.	.	.
8691	2992	1	"	"	``
8691	2992	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	2992	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	2992	4	:	:	:
8691	2992	5	Thayer	Thayer	NNP
8691	2992	6	,	,	,
8691	2992	7	"	"	''
8691	2992	8	John	John	NNP
8691	2992	9	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	2992	10	,	,	,
8691	2992	11	"	"	''
8691	2992	12	54	54	CD
8691	2992	13	.	.	.
8691	2992	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	2993	1	In	in	IN
8691	2993	2	some	some	DT
8691	2993	3	of	of	IN
8691	2993	4	the	the	DT
8691	2993	5	State	State	NNP
8691	2993	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	2993	7	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	2993	8	in	in	IN
8691	2993	9	early	early	JJ
8691	2993	10	days	day	NNS
8691	2993	11	,	,	,
8691	2993	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2993	13	was	be	VBD
8691	2993	14	the	the	DT
8691	2993	15	practice	practice	NN
8691	2993	16	for	for	IN
8691	2993	17	the	the	DT
8691	2993	18	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	2993	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2993	20	to	to	TO
8691	2993	21	deliver	deliver	VB
8691	2993	22	an	an	DT
8691	2993	23	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2993	24	in	in	IN
8691	2993	25	every	every	DT
8691	2993	26	case	case	NN
8691	2993	27	,	,	,
8691	2993	28	but	but	CC
8691	2993	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2993	30	associates	associate	NNS
8691	2993	31	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	2993	32	added	add	VBD
8691	2993	33	concurring	concur	VBG
8691	2993	34	or	or	CC
8691	2993	35	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	2993	36	ones	one	NNS
8691	2993	37	.	.	.
8691	2994	1	Of	of	IN
8691	2994	2	late	late	JJ
8691	2994	3	years	year	NNS
8691	2994	4	the	the	DT
8691	2994	5	business	business	NN
8691	2994	6	of	of	IN
8691	2994	7	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	2994	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	2994	9	in	in	IN
8691	2994	10	the	the	DT
8691	2994	11	United	United	NNP
8691	2994	12	States	States	NNP
8691	2994	13	and	and	CC
8691	2994	14	in	in	IN
8691	2994	15	most	most	JJS
8691	2994	16	of	of	IN
8691	2994	17	the	the	DT
8691	2994	18	States	States	NNPS
8691	2994	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	2994	20	so	so	RB
8691	2994	21	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	2994	22	that	that	IN
8691	2994	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2994	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	2994	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2994	26	to	to	TO
8691	2994	27	divide	divide	VB
8691	2994	28	the	the	DT
8691	2994	29	labor	labor	NN
8691	2994	30	,	,	,
8691	2994	31	and	and	CC
8691	2994	32	the	the	DT
8691	2994	33	cases	case	NNS
8691	2994	34	are	be	VBP
8691	2994	35	generally	generally	RB
8691	2994	36	distributed	distribute	VBN
8691	2994	37	equally	equally	RB
8691	2994	38	for	for	IN
8691	2994	39	the	the	DT
8691	2994	40	preparation	preparation	NN
8691	2994	41	of	of	IN
8691	2994	42	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	2994	43	.	.	.
8691	2995	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2995	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	2995	3	the	the	DT
8691	2995	4	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	2995	5	practice	practice	NN
8691	2995	6	to	to	TO
8691	2995	7	have	have	VB
8691	2995	8	the	the	DT
8691	2995	9	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2995	10	,	,	,
8691	2995	11	when	when	WRB
8691	2995	12	drafted	draft	VBN
8691	2995	13	by	by	IN
8691	2995	14	the	the	DT
8691	2995	15	judge	judge	NN
8691	2995	16	to	to	IN
8691	2995	17	whom	whom	WP
8691	2995	18	that	that	DT
8691	2995	19	duty	duty	NN
8691	2995	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	2995	21	assigned	assign	VBN
8691	2995	22	,	,	,
8691	2995	23	typewritten	typewritten	RB
8691	2995	24	or	or	CC
8691	2995	25	printed	print	VBN
8691	2995	26	,	,	,
8691	2995	27	and	and	CC
8691	2995	28	a	a	DT
8691	2995	29	copy	copy	NN
8691	2995	30	sent	send	VBN
8691	2995	31	to	to	IN
8691	2995	32	each	each	DT
8691	2995	33	of	of	IN
8691	2995	34	the	the	DT
8691	2995	35	other	other	JJ
8691	2995	36	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2995	37	for	for	IN
8691	2995	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2995	39	consideration	consideration	NN
8691	2995	40	separately	separately	RB
8691	2995	41	.	.	.
8691	2996	1	At	at	IN
8691	2996	2	a	a	DT
8691	2996	3	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	2996	4	conference	conference	NN
8691	2996	5	each	each	DT
8691	2996	6	judge	judge	NN
8691	2996	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	2996	8	called	call	VBN
8691	2996	9	upon	upon	IN
8691	2996	10	by	by	IN
8691	2996	11	the	the	DT
8691	2996	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	2996	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	2996	14	to	to	TO
8691	2996	15	state	state	NN
8691	2996	16	whether	whether	IN
8691	2996	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2996	18	concurs	concur	VBZ
8691	2996	19	in	in	IN
8691	2996	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2996	21	,	,	,
8691	2996	22	and	and	CC
8691	2996	23	if	if	IN
8691	2996	24	alterations	alteration	NNS
8691	2996	25	are	be	VBP
8691	2996	26	proposed	propose	VBN
8691	2996	27	there	there	EX
8691	2996	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	2996	29	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	2996	30	for	for	IN
8691	2996	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2996	32	discussion	discussion	NN
8691	2996	33	.	.	.
8691	2997	1	This	this	DT
8691	2997	2	practice	practice	NN
8691	2997	3	did	do	VBD
8691	2997	4	not	not	RB
8691	2997	5	become	become	VB
8691	2997	6	general	general	JJ
8691	2997	7	until	until	IN
8691	2997	8	the	the	DT
8691	2997	9	latter	latter	JJ
8691	2997	10	part	part	NN
8691	2997	11	of	of	IN
8691	2997	12	the	the	DT
8691	2997	13	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	2997	14	century	century	NN
8691	2997	15	,	,	,
8691	2997	16	when	when	WRB
8691	2997	17	the	the	DT
8691	2997	18	typewriter	typewriter	NN
8691	2997	19	had	have	VBD
8691	2997	20	come	come	VBN
8691	2997	21	into	into	IN
8691	2997	22	common	common	JJ
8691	2997	23	use	use	NN
8691	2997	24	.	.	.
8691	2998	1	Prior	prior	RB
8691	2998	2	to	to	IN
8691	2998	3	that	that	DT
8691	2998	4	time	time	NN
8691	2998	5	the	the	DT
8691	2998	6	draft	draft	NN
8691	2998	7	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	2998	8	was	be	VBD
8691	2998	9	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	2998	10	first	first	RB
8691	2998	11	made	make	VBN
8691	2998	12	known	known	JJ
8691	2998	13	by	by	IN
8691	2998	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2998	15	author	author	NN
8691	2998	16	to	to	IN
8691	2998	17	the	the	DT
8691	2998	18	other	other	JJ
8691	2998	19	judges	judge	NNS
8691	2998	20	either	either	RB
8691	2998	21	by	by	IN
8691	2998	22	reading	read	VBG
8691	2998	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2998	24	aloud	aloud	RB
8691	2998	25	at	at	IN
8691	2998	26	the	the	DT
8691	2998	27	final	final	JJ
8691	2998	28	consultation	consultation	NN
8691	2998	29	or	or	CC
8691	2998	30	by	by	IN
8691	2998	31	sending	send	VBG
8691	2998	32	one	one	CD
8691	2998	33	manuscript	manuscript	NN
8691	2998	34	copy	copy	VBP
8691	2998	35	around	around	RP
8691	2998	36	to	to	IN
8691	2998	37	each	each	DT
8691	2998	38	in	in	IN
8691	2998	39	succession	succession	NN
8691	2998	40	for	for	IN
8691	2998	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	2998	42	endorsement	endorsement	NN
8691	2998	43	of	of	IN
8691	2998	44	approval	approval	NN
8691	2998	45	or	or	CC
8691	2998	46	disapproval	disapproval	NN
8691	2998	47	.	.	.
8691	2999	1	In	in	IN
8691	2999	2	some	some	DT
8691	2999	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	2999	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2999	5	was	be	VBD
8691	2999	6	never	never	RB
8691	2999	7	thus	thus	RB
8691	2999	8	submitted	submit	VBN
8691	2999	9	at	at	RB
8691	2999	10	all	all	RB
8691	2999	11	,	,	,
8691	2999	12	and	and	CC
8691	2999	13	so	so	RB
8691	2999	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2999	15	were	be	VBD
8691	2999	16	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	2999	17	committed	commit	VBN
8691	2999	18	to	to	IN
8691	2999	19	positions	position	NNS
8691	2999	20	which	which	WDT
8691	2999	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2999	22	had	have	VBD
8691	2999	23	never	never	RB
8691	2999	24	intended	intend	VBN
8691	2999	25	to	to	TO
8691	2999	26	adopt	adopt	VB
8691	2999	27	and	and	CC
8691	2999	28	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	2999	29	found	find	VBD
8691	2999	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	2999	31	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	2999	32	to	to	TO
8691	2999	33	repudiate	repudiate	VB
8691	2999	34	.	.	.
8691	3000	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3000	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3000	3	:	:	:
8691	3000	4	See	see	VB
8691	3000	5	for	for	IN
8691	3000	6	an	an	DT
8691	3000	7	example	example	NN
8691	3000	8	of	of	IN
8691	3000	9	this	this	DT
8691	3000	10	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
8691	3000	11	_	_	NNP
8691	3000	12	v.	v.	IN
8691	3000	13	_	_	NNP
8691	3000	14	Heywood	Heywood	NNP
8691	3000	15	,	,	,
8691	3000	16	12	12	CD
8691	3000	17	R.	R.	NNP
8691	3000	18	I.	i.	NN
8691	3001	1	Reports	report	NNS
8691	3001	2	,	,	,
8691	3001	3	196	196	CD
8691	3001	4	,	,	,
8691	3001	5	198	198	CD
8691	3001	6	.	.	.
8691	3001	7	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3002	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3002	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	3002	3	of	of	IN
8691	3002	4	last	last	JJ
8691	3002	5	resort	resort	NN
8691	3002	6	generally	generally	RB
8691	3002	7	have	have	VBP
8691	3002	8	before	before	IN
8691	3002	9	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3002	10	a	a	DT
8691	3002	11	printed	print	VBN
8691	3002	12	statement	statement	NN
8691	3002	13	of	of	IN
8691	3002	14	the	the	DT
8691	3002	15	doings	doing	NNS
8691	3002	16	in	in	IN
8691	3002	17	the	the	DT
8691	3002	18	lower	low	JJR
8691	3002	19	court	court	NN
8691	3002	20	which	which	WDT
8691	3002	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3002	22	are	be	VBP
8691	3002	23	asked	ask	VBN
8691	3002	24	to	to	TO
8691	3002	25	review	review	VB
8691	3002	26	,	,	,
8691	3002	27	and	and	CC
8691	3002	28	a	a	DT
8691	3002	29	printed	print	VBN
8691	3002	30	argument	argument	NN
8691	3002	31	from	from	IN
8691	3002	32	each	each	DT
8691	3002	33	party	party	NN
8691	3002	34	to	to	IN
8691	3002	35	the	the	DT
8691	3002	36	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	3002	37	.	.	.
8691	3003	1	Oral	oral	JJ
8691	3003	2	arguments	argument	NNS
8691	3003	3	are	be	VBP
8691	3003	4	also	also	RB
8691	3003	5	usually	usually	RB
8691	3003	6	heard	hear	VBN
8691	3003	7	,	,	,
8691	3003	8	except	except	IN
8691	3003	9	in	in	IN
8691	3003	10	a	a	DT
8691	3003	11	few	few	JJ
8691	3003	12	States	States	NNP
8691	3003	13	where	where	WRB
8691	3003	14	the	the	DT
8691	3003	15	press	press	NN
8691	3003	16	of	of	IN
8691	3003	17	business	business	NN
8691	3003	18	renders	render	VBZ
8691	3003	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3003	20	practically	practically	RB
8691	3003	21	impossible	impossible	JJ
8691	3003	22	except	except	IN
8691	3003	23	in	in	IN
8691	3003	24	cases	case	NNS
8691	3003	25	of	of	IN
8691	3003	26	special	special	JJ
8691	3003	27	importance	importance	NN
8691	3003	28	.	.	.
8691	3004	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	3004	2	a	a	DT
8691	3004	3	press	press	NN
8691	3004	4	occurs	occur	VBZ
8691	3004	5	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	3004	6	in	in	IN
8691	3004	7	the	the	DT
8691	3004	8	largest	large	JJS
8691	3004	9	States	state	NNS
8691	3004	10	,	,	,
8691	3004	11	but	but	CC
8691	3004	12	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	3004	13	also	also	RB
8691	3004	14	in	in	IN
8691	3004	15	some	some	DT
8691	3004	16	whose	whose	WP$
8691	3004	17	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	3004	18	make	make	VBP
8691	3004	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3004	20	easy	easy	JJ
8691	3004	21	and	and	CC
8691	3004	22	over	over	RB
8691	3004	23	-	-	HYPH
8691	3004	24	cheap	cheap	JJ
8691	3004	25	for	for	IN
8691	3004	26	every	every	DT
8691	3004	27	defeated	defeat	VBN
8691	3004	28	litigant	litigant	NN
8691	3004	29	to	to	TO
8691	3004	30	carry	carry	VB
8691	3004	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3004	32	case	case	NN
8691	3004	33	up	up	IN
8691	3004	34	to	to	IN
8691	3004	35	the	the	DT
8691	3004	36	highest	high	JJS
8691	3004	37	court	court	NN
8691	3004	38	.	.	.
8691	3005	1	In	in	IN
8691	3005	2	the	the	DT
8691	3005	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3005	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3005	5	of	of	IN
8691	3005	6	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	3005	7	no	no	DT
8691	3005	8	costs	cost	NNS
8691	3005	9	exceeding	exceed	VBG
8691	3005	10	$	$	$
8691	3005	11	10	10	CD
8691	3005	12	can	can	MD
8691	3005	13	be	be	VB
8691	3005	14	taxed	tax	VBN
8691	3005	15	against	against	IN
8691	3005	16	the	the	DT
8691	3005	17	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
8691	3005	18	party	party	NN
8691	3005	19	;	;	:
8691	3005	20	and	and	CC
8691	3005	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3005	22	has	have	VBZ
8691	3005	23	had	have	VBN
8691	3005	24	eight	eight	CD
8691	3005	25	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3005	26	cases	case	NNS
8691	3005	27	in	in	IN
8691	3005	28	one	one	CD
8691	3005	29	year	year	NN
8691	3005	30	upon	upon	IN
8691	3005	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3005	32	docket	docket	NN
8691	3005	33	.	.	.
8691	3006	1	In	in	IN
8691	3006	2	most	most	JJS
8691	3006	3	States	state	NNS
8691	3006	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3006	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	3006	6	substantial	substantial	JJ
8691	3006	7	costs	cost	NNS
8691	3006	8	to	to	TO
8691	3006	9	pay	pay	VB
8691	3006	10	.	.	.
8691	3007	1	These	these	DT
8691	3007	2	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	3007	3	are	be	VBP
8691	3007	4	to	to	TO
8691	3007	5	meet	meet	VB
8691	3007	6	the	the	DT
8691	3007	7	expense	expense	NN
8691	3007	8	of	of	IN
8691	3007	9	printing	print	VBG
8691	3007	10	the	the	DT
8691	3007	11	record	record	NN
8691	3007	12	sent	send	VBN
8691	3007	13	up	up	RP
8691	3007	14	from	from	IN
8691	3007	15	the	the	DT
8691	3007	16	court	court	NN
8691	3007	17	below	below	RB
8691	3007	18	.	.	.
8691	3008	1	A	a	DT
8691	3008	2	single	single	JJ
8691	3008	3	case	case	NN
8691	3008	4	will	will	MD
8691	3008	5	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3008	6	fill	fill	VB
8691	3008	7	a	a	DT
8691	3008	8	volume	volume	NN
8691	3008	9	or	or	CC
8691	3008	10	even	even	RB
8691	3008	11	a	a	DT
8691	3008	12	set	set	NN
8691	3008	13	of	of	IN
8691	3008	14	volumes	volume	NNS
8691	3008	15	,	,	,
8691	3008	16	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	3008	17	in	in	IN
8691	3008	18	equity	equity	NN
8691	3008	19	causes	cause	NNS
8691	3008	20	in	in	IN
8691	3008	21	the	the	DT
8691	3008	22	federal	federal	JJ
8691	3008	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	3008	24	,	,	,
8691	3008	25	in	in	IN
8691	3008	26	which	which	WDT
8691	3008	27	all	all	PDT
8691	3008	28	the	the	DT
8691	3008	29	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	3008	30	is	be	VBZ
8691	3008	31	generally	generally	RB
8691	3008	32	written	write	VBN
8691	3008	33	out	out	RP
8691	3008	34	at	at	IN
8691	3008	35	length	length	NN
8691	3008	36	.	.	.
8691	3009	1	The	the	DT
8691	3009	2	appellant	appellant	NN
8691	3009	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	3009	4	to	to	TO
8691	3009	5	pay	pay	VB
8691	3009	6	for	for	IN
8691	3009	7	the	the	DT
8691	3009	8	printing	printing	NN
8691	3009	9	in	in	IN
8691	3009	10	the	the	DT
8691	3009	11	first	first	JJ
8691	3009	12	instance	instance	NN
8691	3009	13	,	,	,
8691	3009	14	but	but	CC
8691	3009	15	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	3009	16	,	,	,
8691	3009	17	if	if	IN
8691	3009	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3009	19	succeeds	succeed	VBZ
8691	3009	20	,	,	,
8691	3009	21	the	the	DT
8691	3009	22	other	other	JJ
8691	3009	23	party	party	NN
8691	3009	24	will	will	MD
8691	3009	25	be	be	VB
8691	3009	26	obliged	oblige	VBN
8691	3009	27	to	to	TO
8691	3009	28	reimburse	reimburse	VB
8691	3009	29	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3009	30	.	.	.
8691	3010	1	The	the	DT
8691	3010	2	cost	cost	NN
8691	3010	3	involved	involve	VBN
8691	3010	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3010	5	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	3010	6	several	several	JJ
8691	3010	7	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	3010	8	dollars	dollar	NNS
8691	3010	9	.	.	.
8691	3011	1	The	the	DT
8691	3011	2	party	party	NN
8691	3011	3	taking	take	VBG
8691	3011	4	the	the	DT
8691	3011	5	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	3011	6	must	must	MD
8691	3011	7	file	file	VB
8691	3011	8	a	a	DT
8691	3011	9	paper	paper	NN
8691	3011	10	stating	state	VBG
8691	3011	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3011	12	grounds	ground	NNS
8691	3011	13	for	for	IN
8691	3011	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3011	15	separately	separately	RB
8691	3011	16	,	,	,
8691	3011	17	distinctly	distinctly	RB
8691	3011	18	,	,	,
8691	3011	19	clearly	clearly	RB
8691	3011	20	and	and	CC
8691	3011	21	concisely	concisely	RB
8691	3011	22	.	.	.
8691	3012	1	There	there	EX
8691	3012	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3012	3	a	a	DT
8691	3012	4	temptation	temptation	NN
8691	3012	5	to	to	TO
8691	3012	6	include	include	VB
8691	3012	7	all	all	DT
8691	3012	8	that	that	WDT
8691	3012	9	can	can	MD
8691	3012	10	be	be	VB
8691	3012	11	thought	think	VBN
8691	3012	12	of	of	IN
8691	3012	13	,	,	,
8691	3012	14	good	good	JJ
8691	3012	15	,	,	,
8691	3012	16	bad	bad	JJ
8691	3012	17	and	and	CC
8691	3012	18	indifferent	indifferent	JJ
8691	3012	19	;	;	:
8691	3012	20	and	and	CC
8691	3012	21	whether	whether	IN
8691	3012	22	this	this	DT
8691	3012	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	3012	24	done	do	VBN
8691	3012	25	or	or	CC
8691	3012	26	not	not	RB
8691	3012	27	will	will	MD
8691	3012	28	depend	depend	VB
8691	3012	29	largely	largely	RB
8691	3012	30	on	on	IN
8691	3012	31	the	the	DT
8691	3012	32	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3012	33	which	which	WDT
8691	3012	34	the	the	DT
8691	3012	35	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3012	36	have	have	VBP
8691	3012	37	of	of	IN
8691	3012	38	the	the	DT
8691	3012	39	ability	ability	NN
8691	3012	40	of	of	IN
8691	3012	41	the	the	DT
8691	3012	42	court	court	NN
8691	3012	43	.	.	.
8691	3013	1	In	in	IN
8691	3013	2	the	the	DT
8691	3013	3	smaller	small	JJR
8691	3013	4	States	state	NNS
8691	3013	5	the	the	DT
8691	3013	6	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3013	7	have	have	VBP
8691	3013	8	time	time	NN
8691	3013	9	to	to	TO
8691	3013	10	enable	enable	VB
8691	3013	11	all	all	DT
8691	3013	12	to	to	TO
8691	3013	13	study	study	VB
8691	3013	14	each	each	DT
8691	3013	15	case	case	NN
8691	3013	16	with	with	IN
8691	3013	17	care	care	NN
8691	3013	18	.	.	.
8691	3014	1	In	in	IN
8691	3014	2	the	the	DT
8691	3014	3	largest	large	JJS
8691	3014	4	ones	one	NNS
8691	3014	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3014	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3014	7	not	not	RB
8691	3014	8	uncommon	uncommon	JJ
8691	3014	9	to	to	TO
8691	3014	10	assign	assign	VB
8691	3014	11	every	every	DT
8691	3014	12	case	case	NN
8691	3014	13	on	on	IN
8691	3014	14	the	the	DT
8691	3014	15	docket	docket	NN
8691	3014	16	,	,	,
8691	3014	17	in	in	IN
8691	3014	18	advance	advance	NN
8691	3014	19	of	of	IN
8691	3014	20	the	the	DT
8691	3014	21	argument	argument	NN
8691	3014	22	,	,	,
8691	3014	23	to	to	IN
8691	3014	24	a	a	DT
8691	3014	25	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3014	26	judge	judge	NN
8691	3014	27	.	.	.
8691	3015	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3015	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3015	3	expected	expect	VBN
8691	3015	4	to	to	TO
8691	3015	5	give	give	VB
8691	3015	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3015	7	special	special	JJ
8691	3015	8	attention	attention	NN
8691	3015	9	with	with	IN
8691	3015	10	a	a	DT
8691	3015	11	view	view	NN
8691	3015	12	to	to	IN
8691	3015	13	reporting	report	VBG
8691	3015	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3015	15	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	3015	16	upon	upon	IN
8691	3015	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3015	18	to	to	IN
8691	3015	19	the	the	DT
8691	3015	20	court	court	NN
8691	3015	21	,	,	,
8691	3015	22	and	and	CC
8691	3015	23	,	,	,
8691	3015	24	should	should	MD
8691	3015	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3015	26	be	be	VB
8691	3015	27	approved	approve	VBN
8691	3015	28	in	in	IN
8691	3015	29	consultation	consultation	NN
8691	3015	30	,	,	,
8691	3015	31	to	to	IN
8691	3015	32	writing	write	VBG
8691	3015	33	out	out	RP
8691	3015	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3015	35	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3015	36	subsequently	subsequently	RB
8691	3015	37	.	.	.
8691	3016	1	The	the	DT
8691	3016	2	assignment	assignment	NN
8691	3016	3	for	for	IN
8691	3016	4	a	a	DT
8691	3016	5	term	term	NN
8691	3016	6	of	of	IN
8691	3016	7	court	court	NN
8691	3016	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	3016	9	not	not	RB
8691	3016	10	infrequently	infrequently	RB
8691	3016	11	made	make	VBN
8691	3016	12	in	in	IN
8691	3016	13	the	the	DT
8691	3016	14	order	order	NN
8691	3016	15	in	in	IN
8691	3016	16	which	which	WDT
8691	3016	17	the	the	DT
8691	3016	18	docket	docket	NN
8691	3016	19	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3016	20	or	or	CC
8691	3016	21	printed	print	VBN
8691	3016	22	list	list	NN
8691	3016	23	of	of	IN
8691	3016	24	cases	case	NNS
8691	3016	25	to	to	TO
8691	3016	26	be	be	VB
8691	3016	27	heard	hear	VBN
8691	3016	28	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3016	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	3016	30	made	make	VBN
8691	3016	31	out	out	RP
8691	3016	32	,	,	,
8691	3016	33	the	the	DT
8691	3016	34	chief	chief	JJ
8691	3016	35	justice	justice	NN
8691	3016	36	taking	take	VBG
8691	3016	37	the	the	DT
8691	3016	38	first	first	JJ
8691	3016	39	case	case	NN
8691	3016	40	,	,	,
8691	3016	41	the	the	DT
8691	3016	42	senior	senior	JJ
8691	3016	43	associate	associate	NN
8691	3016	44	justice	justice	NN
8691	3016	45	the	the	DT
8691	3016	46	second	second	JJ
8691	3016	47	,	,	,
8691	3016	48	and	and	CC
8691	3016	49	so	so	RB
8691	3016	50	on	on	RB
8691	3016	51	.	.	.
8691	3017	1	At	at	IN
8691	3017	2	the	the	DT
8691	3017	3	next	next	JJ
8691	3017	4	term	term	NN
8691	3017	5	the	the	DT
8691	3017	6	same	same	JJ
8691	3017	7	practice	practice	NN
8691	3017	8	will	will	MD
8691	3017	9	be	be	VB
8691	3017	10	pursued	pursue	VBN
8691	3017	11	,	,	,
8691	3017	12	except	except	IN
8691	3017	13	that	that	IN
8691	3017	14	the	the	DT
8691	3017	15	justice	justice	NN
8691	3017	16	next	next	RB
8691	3017	17	in	in	IN
8691	3017	18	seniority	seniority	NN
8691	3017	19	to	to	IN
8691	3017	20	the	the	DT
8691	3017	21	one	one	NN
8691	3017	22	who	who	WP
8691	3017	23	had	have	VBD
8691	3017	24	the	the	DT
8691	3017	25	last	last	JJ
8691	3017	26	case	case	NN
8691	3017	27	under	under	IN
8691	3017	28	the	the	DT
8691	3017	29	previous	previous	JJ
8691	3017	30	assignments	assignment	NNS
8691	3017	31	will	will	MD
8691	3017	32	now	now	RB
8691	3017	33	take	take	VB
8691	3017	34	the	the	DT
8691	3017	35	first	first	JJ
8691	3017	36	case	case	NN
8691	3017	37	on	on	IN
8691	3017	38	the	the	DT
8691	3017	39	new	new	JJ
8691	3017	40	list	list	NN
8691	3017	41	,	,	,
8691	3017	42	and	and	CC
8691	3017	43	the	the	DT
8691	3017	44	next	next	JJ
8691	3017	45	junior	junior	NNP
8691	3017	46	justice	justice	NN
8691	3017	47	the	the	DT
8691	3017	48	second	second	JJ
8691	3017	49	.	.	.
8691	3018	1	Appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3018	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	3018	3	generally	generally	RB
8691	3018	4	sit	sit	VBP
8691	3018	5	not	not	RB
8691	3018	6	over	over	IN
8691	3018	7	four	four	CD
8691	3018	8	or	or	CC
8691	3018	9	five	five	CD
8691	3018	10	hours	hour	NNS
8691	3018	11	a	a	DT
8691	3018	12	day	day	NN
8691	3018	13	;	;	:
8691	3018	14	this	this	DT
8691	3018	15	time	time	NN
8691	3018	16	being	be	VBG
8691	3018	17	either	either	CC
8691	3018	18	preceded	precede	VBN
8691	3018	19	or	or	CC
8691	3018	20	followed	follow	VBN
8691	3018	21	by	by	IN
8691	3018	22	a	a	DT
8691	3018	23	consultation	consultation	NN
8691	3018	24	.	.	.
8691	3019	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3019	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3019	3	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	3019	4	in	in	IN
8691	3019	5	session	session	NN
8691	3019	6	more	more	JJR
8691	3019	7	than	than	IN
8691	3019	8	five	five	CD
8691	3019	9	days	day	NNS
8691	3019	10	in	in	IN
8691	3019	11	the	the	DT
8691	3019	12	week	week	NN
8691	3019	13	.	.	.
8691	3020	1	The	the	DT
8691	3020	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	3020	3	before	before	IN
8691	3020	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3020	5	are	be	VBP
8691	3020	6	not	not	RB
8691	3020	7	usually	usually	RB
8691	3020	8	assigned	assign	VBN
8691	3020	9	for	for	IN
8691	3020	10	argument	argument	NN
8691	3020	11	on	on	IN
8691	3020	12	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3020	13	days	day	NNS
8691	3020	14	.	.	.
8691	3021	1	A	a	DT
8691	3021	2	list	list	NN
8691	3021	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3021	4	made	make	VBN
8691	3021	5	up	up	RP
8691	3021	6	of	of	IN
8691	3021	7	all	all	DT
8691	3021	8	which	which	WDT
8691	3021	9	are	be	VBP
8691	3021	10	ready	ready	JJ
8691	3021	11	to	to	TO
8691	3021	12	be	be	VB
8691	3021	13	heard	hear	VBN
8691	3021	14	,	,	,
8691	3021	15	numbered	number	VBN
8691	3021	16	in	in	IN
8691	3021	17	order	order	NN
8691	3021	18	,	,	,
8691	3021	19	the	the	DT
8691	3021	20	oldest	old	JJS
8691	3021	21	first	first	JJ
8691	3021	22	.	.	.
8691	3022	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3022	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3022	3	then	then	RB
8691	3022	4	taken	take	VBN
8691	3022	5	up	up	RP
8691	3022	6	successively	successively	RB
8691	3022	7	as	as	IN
8691	3022	8	reached	reach	VBN
8691	3022	9	,	,	,
8691	3022	10	and	and	CC
8691	3022	11	the	the	DT
8691	3022	12	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	3022	13	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	3022	14	in	in	IN
8691	3022	15	each	each	DT
8691	3022	16	must	must	MD
8691	3022	17	be	be	VB
8691	3022	18	ready	ready	JJ
8691	3022	19	at	at	IN
8691	3022	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3022	21	peril	peril	NN
8691	3022	22	.	.	.
8691	3023	1	Often	often	RB
8691	3023	2	a	a	DT
8691	3023	3	limit	limit	NN
8691	3023	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3023	5	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	3023	6	by	by	IN
8691	3023	7	rule	rule	NN
8691	3023	8	as	as	IN
8691	3023	9	to	to	IN
8691	3023	10	the	the	DT
8691	3023	11	number	number	NN
8691	3023	12	of	of	IN
8691	3023	13	cases	case	NNS
8691	3023	14	that	that	WDT
8691	3023	15	can	can	MD
8691	3023	16	be	be	VB
8691	3023	17	called	call	VBN
8691	3023	18	for	for	IN
8691	3023	19	argument	argument	NN
8691	3023	20	in	in	IN
8691	3023	21	any	any	DT
8691	3023	22	one	one	CD
8691	3023	23	day	day	NN
8691	3023	24	.	.	.
8691	3024	1	In	in	IN
8691	3024	2	the	the	DT
8691	3024	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3024	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3024	5	of	of	IN
8691	3024	6	the	the	DT
8691	3024	7	United	United	NNP
8691	3024	8	States	States	NNP
8691	3024	9	this	this	DT
8691	3024	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	3024	11	the	the	DT
8691	3024	12	practice	practice	NN
8691	3024	13	,	,	,
8691	3024	14	and	and	CC
8691	3024	15	the	the	DT
8691	3024	16	number	number	NN
8691	3024	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	3024	18	ten	ten	CD
8691	3024	19	.	.	.
8691	3025	1	In	in	IN
8691	3025	2	some	some	DT
8691	3025	3	of	of	IN
8691	3025	4	the	the	DT
8691	3025	5	States	state	NNS
8691	3025	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3025	7	rises	rise	VBZ
8691	3025	8	as	as	RB
8691	3025	9	high	high	JJ
8691	3025	10	as	as	IN
8691	3025	11	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3025	12	.	.	.
8691	3026	1	At	at	IN
8691	3026	2	the	the	DT
8691	3026	3	first	first	JJ
8691	3026	4	consultation	consultation	NN
8691	3026	5	over	over	IN
8691	3026	6	a	a	DT
8691	3026	7	case	case	NN
8691	3026	8	which	which	WDT
8691	3026	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	3026	10	been	be	VBN
8691	3026	11	argued	argue	VBN
8691	3026	12	,	,	,
8691	3026	13	the	the	DT
8691	3026	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3026	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3026	16	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3026	17	unless	unless	IN
8691	3026	18	a	a	DT
8691	3026	19	special	special	JJ
8691	3026	20	assignment	assignment	NN
8691	3026	21	has	have	VBZ
8691	3026	22	been	be	VBN
8691	3026	23	previously	previously	RB
8691	3026	24	made	make	VBN
8691	3026	25	of	of	IN
8691	3026	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3026	27	to	to	IN
8691	3026	28	some	some	DT
8691	3026	29	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3026	30	member	member	NN
8691	3026	31	of	of	IN
8691	3026	32	the	the	DT
8691	3026	33	court	court	NN
8691	3026	34	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3026	35	asks	ask	VBZ
8691	3026	36	the	the	DT
8691	3026	37	junior	junior	JJ
8691	3026	38	justice	justice	NN
8691	3026	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3026	40	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3026	41	as	as	IN
8691	3026	42	to	to	IN
8691	3026	43	the	the	DT
8691	3026	44	proper	proper	JJ
8691	3026	45	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	3026	46	to	to	TO
8691	3026	47	be	be	VB
8691	3026	48	made	make	VBN
8691	3026	49	of	of	IN
8691	3026	50	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3026	51	,	,	,
8691	3026	52	and	and	CC
8691	3026	53	each	each	DT
8691	3026	54	justice	justice	NN
8691	3026	55	in	in	IN
8691	3026	56	turn	turn	NN
8691	3026	57	then	then	RB
8691	3026	58	gives	give	VBZ
8691	3026	59	his	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3026	60	,	,	,
8691	3026	61	in	in	IN
8691	3026	62	the	the	DT
8691	3026	63	reverse	reverse	JJ
8691	3026	64	order	order	NN
8691	3026	65	of	of	IN
8691	3026	66	seniority	seniority	NN
8691	3026	67	.	.	.
8691	3027	1	If	if	IN
8691	3027	2	there	there	EX
8691	3027	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3027	4	any	any	DT
8691	3027	5	serious	serious	JJ
8691	3027	6	disagreement	disagreement	NN
8691	3027	7	the	the	DT
8691	3027	8	matter	matter	NN
8691	3027	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	3027	10	generally	generally	RB
8691	3027	11	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	3027	12	to	to	TO
8691	3027	13	stand	stand	VB
8691	3027	14	over	over	RP
8691	3027	15	for	for	IN
8691	3027	16	further	further	JJ
8691	3027	17	discussion	discussion	NN
8691	3027	18	later	later	RB
8691	3027	19	.	.	.
8691	3028	1	At	at	IN
8691	3028	2	some	some	DT
8691	3028	3	convenient	convenient	JJ
8691	3028	4	time	time	NN
8691	3028	5	after	after	IN
8691	3028	6	the	the	DT
8691	3028	7	views	view	NNS
8691	3028	8	of	of	IN
8691	3028	9	the	the	DT
8691	3028	10	various	various	JJ
8691	3028	11	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3028	12	have	have	VBP
8691	3028	13	been	be	VBN
8691	3028	14	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
8691	3028	15	the	the	DT
8691	3028	16	cases	case	NNS
8691	3028	17	are	be	VBP
8691	3028	18	distributed	distribute	VBN
8691	3028	19	and	and	CC
8691	3028	20	,	,	,
8691	3028	21	as	as	IN
8691	3028	22	a	a	DT
8691	3028	23	rule	rule	NN
8691	3028	24	,	,	,
8691	3028	25	equally	equally	RB
8691	3028	26	for	for	IN
8691	3028	27	the	the	DT
8691	3028	28	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	3028	29	of	of	IN
8691	3028	30	preparing	prepare	VBG
8691	3028	31	the	the	DT
8691	3028	32	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3028	33	.	.	.
8691	3029	1	This	this	DT
8691	3029	2	distribution	distribution	NN
8691	3029	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3029	4	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3029	5	made	make	VBN
8691	3029	6	by	by	IN
8691	3029	7	the	the	DT
8691	3029	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3029	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3029	10	and	and	CC
8691	3029	11	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3029	12	by	by	IN
8691	3029	13	agreement	agreement	NN
8691	3029	14	,	,	,
8691	3029	15	or	or	CC
8691	3029	16	according	accord	VBG
8691	3029	17	to	to	IN
8691	3029	18	the	the	DT
8691	3029	19	arrangement	arrangement	NN
8691	3029	20	of	of	IN
8691	3029	21	the	the	DT
8691	3029	22	docket	docket	NN
8691	3029	23	.	.	.
8691	3030	1	Until	until	IN
8691	3030	2	the	the	DT
8691	3030	3	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3030	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	3030	5	been	be	VBN
8691	3030	6	finally	finally	RB
8691	3030	7	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	3030	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3030	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	3030	10	not	not	RB
8691	3030	11	usual	usual	JJ
8691	3030	12	to	to	TO
8691	3030	13	announce	announce	VB
8691	3030	14	the	the	DT
8691	3030	15	decision	decision	NN
8691	3030	16	.	.	.
8691	3031	1	Not	not	RB
8691	3031	2	infrequently	infrequently	RB
8691	3031	3	the	the	DT
8691	3031	4	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
8691	3031	5	decision	decision	NN
8691	3031	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3031	7	made	make	VBN
8691	3031	8	the	the	DT
8691	3031	9	other	other	JJ
8691	3031	10	way	way	NN
8691	3031	11	,	,	,
8691	3031	12	and	and	CC
8691	3031	13	a	a	DT
8691	3031	14	new	new	JJ
8691	3031	15	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3031	16	prepared	prepare	VBN
8691	3031	17	by	by	IN
8691	3031	18	the	the	DT
8691	3031	19	same	same	JJ
8691	3031	20	,	,	,
8691	3031	21	or	or	CC
8691	3031	22	,	,	,
8691	3031	23	if	if	IN
8691	3031	24	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3031	25	remains	remain	VBZ
8691	3031	26	unconvinced	unconvinced	JJ
8691	3031	27	that	that	IN
8691	3031	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3031	29	first	first	JJ
8691	3031	30	one	one	NN
8691	3031	31	was	be	VBD
8691	3031	32	wrong	wrong	JJ
8691	3031	33	,	,	,
8691	3031	34	by	by	IN
8691	3031	35	another	another	DT
8691	3031	36	judge	judge	NN
8691	3031	37	.	.	.
8691	3032	1	Still	still	RB
8691	3032	2	more	more	RBR
8691	3032	3	often	often	RB
8691	3032	4	the	the	DT
8691	3032	5	draft	draft	NN
8691	3032	6	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3032	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3032	8	altered	alter	VBN
8691	3032	9	in	in	IN
8691	3032	10	material	material	NN
8691	3032	11	points	point	NNS
8691	3032	12	to	to	TO
8691	3032	13	meet	meet	VB
8691	3032	14	criticisms	criticism	NNS
8691	3032	15	and	and	CC
8691	3032	16	avoid	avoid	VB
8691	3032	17	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	3032	18	.	.	.
8691	3033	1	Dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	3033	2	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3033	3	are	be	VBP
8691	3033	4	comparatively	comparatively	RB
8691	3033	5	rare	rare	JJ
8691	3033	6	,	,	,
8691	3033	7	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	3033	8	in	in	IN
8691	3033	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	3033	10	where	where	WRB
8691	3033	11	there	there	EX
8691	3033	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	3033	13	a	a	DT
8691	3033	14	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3033	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3033	16	with	with	IN
8691	3033	17	the	the	DT
8691	3033	18	qualities	quality	NNS
8691	3033	19	of	of	IN
8691	3033	20	a	a	DT
8691	3033	21	leader	leader	NN
8691	3033	22	;	;	:
8691	3033	23	that	that	RB
8691	3033	24	is	is	RB
8691	3033	25	,	,	,
8691	3033	26	with	with	IN
8691	3033	27	ability	ability	NN
8691	3033	28	,	,	,
8691	3033	29	learning	learning	NN
8691	3033	30	and	and	CC
8691	3033	31	tact	tact	NN
8691	3033	32	,	,	,
8691	3033	33	each	each	DT
8691	3033	34	in	in	IN
8691	3033	35	full	full	JJ
8691	3033	36	measure	measure	NN
8691	3033	37	.	.	.
8691	3034	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3034	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3034	3	:	:	:
8691	3034	4	Perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	3034	5	tact	tact	NN
8691	3034	6	counts	count	VBZ
8691	3034	7	the	the	DT
8691	3034	8	most	most	JJS
8691	3034	9	,	,	,
8691	3034	10	for	for	IN
8691	3034	11	the	the	DT
8691	3034	12	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3034	13	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3034	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	3034	15	the	the	DT
8691	3034	16	advantage	advantage	NN
8691	3034	17	of	of	IN
8691	3034	18	hearing	hear	VBG
8691	3034	19	the	the	DT
8691	3034	20	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3034	21	of	of	IN
8691	3034	22	all	all	DT
8691	3034	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3034	24	associates	associate	NNS
8691	3034	25	at	at	IN
8691	3034	26	all	all	DT
8691	3034	27	consultations	consultation	NNS
8691	3034	28	before	before	IN
8691	3034	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3034	30	gives	give	VBZ
8691	3034	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3034	32	own	own	JJ
8691	3034	33	.	.	.
8691	3035	1	Senator	Senator	NNP
8691	3035	2	Hoar	Hoar	NNP
8691	3035	3	makes	make	VBZ
8691	3035	4	a	a	DT
8691	3035	5	pungent	pungent	JJ
8691	3035	6	comment	comment	NN
8691	3035	7	on	on	IN
8691	3035	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3035	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3035	10	Shaw	Shaw	NNP
8691	3035	11	's	's	POS
8691	3035	12	want	want	NN
8691	3035	13	of	of	IN
8691	3035	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3035	15	,	,	,
8691	3035	16	in	in	IN
8691	3035	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3035	18	Autobiography	Autobiography	NNP
8691	3035	19	,	,	,
8691	3035	20	II	II	NNP
8691	3035	21	,	,	,
8691	3035	22	413	413	CD
8691	3035	23	.	.	.
8691	3035	24	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3036	1	Every	every	DT
8691	3036	2	instance	instance	NN
8691	3036	3	of	of	IN
8691	3036	4	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	3036	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	3036	6	a	a	DT
8691	3036	7	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3036	8	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	3036	9	to	to	TO
8691	3036	10	weaken	weaken	VB
8691	3036	11	the	the	DT
8691	3036	12	authority	authority	NN
8691	3036	13	of	of	IN
8691	3036	14	the	the	DT
8691	3036	15	decision	decision	NN
8691	3036	16	and	and	CC
8691	3036	17	even	even	RB
8691	3036	18	of	of	IN
8691	3036	19	the	the	DT
8691	3036	20	court	court	NN
8691	3036	21	.	.	.
8691	3037	1	Law	law	NN
8691	3037	2	should	should	MD
8691	3037	3	be	be	VB
8691	3037	4	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3037	5	,	,	,
8691	3037	6	and	and	CC
8691	3037	7	the	the	DT
8691	3037	8	community	community	NN
8691	3037	9	in	in	IN
8691	3037	10	which	which	WDT
8691	3037	11	those	those	DT
8691	3037	12	charged	charge	VBN
8691	3037	13	with	with	IN
8691	3037	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3037	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3037	16	administration	administration	NN
8691	3037	17	differ	differ	VBP
8691	3037	18	irreconcilably	irreconcilably	RB
8691	3037	19	as	as	IN
8691	3037	20	to	to	IN
8691	3037	21	what	what	WP
8691	3037	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3037	23	rules	rule	NNS
8691	3037	24	really	really	RB
8691	3037	25	are	be	VBP
8691	3037	26	,	,	,
8691	3037	27	as	as	IN
8691	3037	28	applied	apply	VBN
8691	3037	29	to	to	IN
8691	3037	30	the	the	DT
8691	3037	31	transaction	transaction	NN
8691	3037	32	of	of	IN
8691	3037	33	the	the	DT
8691	3037	34	daily	daily	JJ
8691	3037	35	business	business	NN
8691	3037	36	of	of	IN
8691	3037	37	life	life	NN
8691	3037	38	,	,	,
8691	3037	39	will	will	MD
8691	3037	40	have	have	VB
8691	3037	41	some	some	DT
8691	3037	42	cause	cause	NN
8691	3037	43	to	to	TO
8691	3037	44	think	think	VB
8691	3037	45	that	that	IN
8691	3037	46	either	either	CC
8691	3037	47	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3037	48	laws	law	NNS
8691	3037	49	or	or	CC
8691	3037	50	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3037	51	courts	court	NNS
8691	3037	52	are	be	VBP
8691	3037	53	defective	defective	JJ
8691	3037	54	and	and	CC
8691	3037	55	inadequate	inadequate	JJ
8691	3037	56	.	.	.
8691	3038	1	For	for	IN
8691	3038	2	these	these	DT
8691	3038	3	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	3038	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3038	5	of	of	IN
8691	3038	6	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3038	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	3038	8	often	often	RB
8691	3038	9	concur	concur	VBP
8691	3038	10	in	in	IN
8691	3038	11	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3038	12	,	,	,
8691	3038	13	of	of	IN
8691	3038	14	the	the	DT
8691	3038	15	soundness	soundness	NN
8691	3038	16	of	of	IN
8691	3038	17	which	which	WDT
8691	3038	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3038	19	are	be	VBP
8691	3038	20	only	only	RB
8691	3038	21	convinced	convinced	JJ
8691	3038	22	because	because	IN
8691	3038	23	of	of	IN
8691	3038	24	the	the	DT
8691	3038	25	respect	respect	NN
8691	3038	26	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3038	27	entertain	entertain	VBP
8691	3038	28	for	for	IN
8691	3038	29	the	the	DT
8691	3038	30	good	good	JJ
8691	3038	31	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3038	32	of	of	IN
8691	3038	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3038	34	associates	associate	NNS
8691	3038	35	.	.	.
8691	3039	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3039	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3039	3	willing	willing	JJ
8691	3039	4	to	to	TO
8691	3039	5	distrust	distrust	VB
8691	3039	6	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3039	7	rather	rather	RB
8691	3039	8	than	than	IN
8691	3039	9	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3039	10	.	.	.
8691	3040	1	Not	not	RB
8691	3040	2	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	3040	3	,	,	,
8691	3040	4	however	however	RB
8691	3040	5	,	,	,
8691	3040	6	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	3040	7	and	and	CC
8691	3040	8	the	the	DT
8691	3040	9	preparation	preparation	NN
8691	3040	10	of	of	IN
8691	3040	11	a	a	DT
8691	3040	12	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	3040	13	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3040	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	3040	15	in	in	IN
8691	3040	16	the	the	DT
8691	3040	17	course	course	NN
8691	3040	18	of	of	IN
8691	3040	19	time	time	NN
8691	3040	20	,	,	,
8691	3040	21	aided	aid	VBN
8691	3040	22	,	,	,
8691	3040	23	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	3040	24	,	,	,
8691	3040	25	by	by	IN
8691	3040	26	some	some	DT
8691	3040	27	change	change	NN
8691	3040	28	of	of	IN
8691	3040	29	membership	membership	NN
8691	3040	30	,	,	,
8691	3040	31	converted	convert	VBD
8691	3040	32	the	the	DT
8691	3040	33	court	court	NN
8691	3040	34	and	and	CC
8691	3040	35	led	lead	VBD
8691	3040	36	to	to	IN
8691	3040	37	overruling	overrule	VBG
8691	3040	38	a	a	DT
8691	3040	39	position	position	NN
8691	3040	40	incautiously	incautiously	RB
8691	3040	41	taken	take	VBN
8691	3040	42	which	which	WDT
8691	3040	43	was	be	VBD
8691	3040	44	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
8691	3040	45	with	with	IN
8691	3040	46	settled	settled	JJ
8691	3040	47	law	law	NN
8691	3040	48	.	.	.
8691	3041	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3041	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3041	3	:	:	:
8691	3041	4	A	a	DT
8691	3041	5	striking	striking	JJ
8691	3041	6	instance	instance	NN
8691	3041	7	of	of	IN
8691	3041	8	this	this	DT
8691	3041	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	3041	10	the	the	DT
8691	3041	11	case	case	NN
8691	3041	12	of	of	IN
8691	3041	13	Sanderson	Sanderson	NNP
8691	3041	14	_	_	NNP
8691	3041	15	v.	v.	IN
8691	3041	16	_	_	NNP
8691	3041	17	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3041	18	Coal	Coal	NNP
8691	3041	19	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	3041	20	,	,	,
8691	3041	21	86	86	CD
8691	3041	22	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3041	23	State	State	NNP
8691	3041	24	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3041	25	,	,	,
8691	3041	26	401	401	CD
8691	3041	27	;	;	SYM
8691	3041	28	94	94	CD
8691	3041	29	_	_	NNP
8691	3041	30	i	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3041	31	d	d	NNP
8691	3041	32	_	_	NNP
8691	3041	33	.	.	NNP
8691	3041	34	,	,	,
8691	3041	35	302	302	CD
8691	3041	36	;	;	:
8691	3041	37	102	102	CD
8691	3041	38	_	_	NNP
8691	3041	39	i	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3041	40	d	d	NNP
8691	3041	41	_	_	NNP
8691	3041	42	.	.	NNP
8691	3041	43	,	,	,
8691	3041	44	370	370	CD
8691	3041	45	;	;	SYM
8691	3041	46	113	113	CD
8691	3041	47	_	_	NNP
8691	3041	48	i	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3041	49	d	d	NNP
8691	3041	50	_	_	NNP
8691	3041	51	.	.	NNP
8691	3041	52	,	,	,
8691	3041	53	126	126	CD
8691	3041	54	;	;	SYM
8691	3041	55	6	6	CD
8691	3041	56	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	3041	57	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	3041	58	,	,	,
8691	3041	59	453	453	CD
8691	3041	60	.	.	.
8691	3041	61	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3042	1	More	More	JJR
8691	3042	2	than	than	IN
8691	3042	3	eighty	eighty	CD
8691	3042	4	out	out	IN
8691	3042	5	of	of	IN
8691	3042	6	every	every	DT
8691	3042	7	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3042	8	of	of	IN
8691	3042	9	the	the	DT
8691	3042	10	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3042	11	delivered	deliver	VBN
8691	3042	12	in	in	IN
8691	3042	13	the	the	DT
8691	3042	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	3042	15	of	of	IN
8691	3042	16	last	last	JJ
8691	3042	17	resort	resort	NN
8691	3042	18	of	of	IN
8691	3042	19	each	each	DT
8691	3042	20	State	State	NNP
8691	3042	21	of	of	IN
8691	3042	22	the	the	DT
8691	3042	23	United	United	NNP
8691	3042	24	States	States	NNP
8691	3042	25	,	,	,
8691	3042	26	excepting	except	VBG
8691	3042	27	one	one	CD
8691	3042	28	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3042	29	New	New	NNP
8691	3042	30	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	3042	31	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3042	32	,	,	,
8691	3042	33	and	and	CC
8691	3042	34	contained	contain	VBN
8691	3042	35	in	in	IN
8691	3042	36	the	the	DT
8691	3042	37	last	last	JJ
8691	3042	38	volume	volume	NN
8691	3042	39	of	of	IN
8691	3042	40	the	the	DT
8691	3042	41	reports	report	NNS
8691	3042	42	of	of	IN
8691	3042	43	each	each	DT
8691	3042	44	published	publish	VBN
8691	3042	45	prior	prior	RB
8691	3042	46	to	to	IN
8691	3042	47	June	June	NNP
8691	3042	48	,	,	,
8691	3042	49	1904	1904	CD
8691	3042	50	,	,	,
8691	3042	51	were	be	VBD
8691	3042	52	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
8691	3042	53	.	.	.
8691	3043	1	In	in	IN
8691	3043	2	New	New	NNP
8691	3043	3	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	3043	4	seventy	seventy	CD
8691	3043	5	-	-	HYPH
8691	3043	6	three	three	CD
8691	3043	7	out	out	IN
8691	3043	8	of	of	IN
8691	3043	9	every	every	DT
8691	3043	10	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3043	11	were	be	VBD
8691	3043	12	.	.	.
8691	3044	1	In	in	IN
8691	3044	2	two	two	CD
8691	3044	3	States	States	NNPS
8691	3044	4	,	,	,
8691	3044	5	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	3044	6	and	and	CC
8691	3044	7	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
8691	3044	8	,	,	,
8691	3044	9	there	there	EX
8691	3044	10	was	be	VBD
8691	3044	11	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	3044	12	in	in	IN
8691	3044	13	but	but	CC
8691	3044	14	two	two	CD
8691	3044	15	out	out	IN
8691	3044	16	of	of	IN
8691	3044	17	every	every	DT
8691	3044	18	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3044	19	cases	case	NNS
8691	3044	20	,	,	,
8691	3044	21	and	and	CC
8691	3044	22	in	in	IN
8691	3044	23	all	all	PDT
8691	3044	24	the	the	DT
8691	3044	25	States	States	NNPS
8691	3044	26	taken	take	VBN
8691	3044	27	together	together	RB
8691	3044	28	,	,	,
8691	3044	29	out	out	IN
8691	3044	30	of	of	IN
8691	3044	31	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	3044	32	5,000	5,000	CD
8691	3044	33	cases	case	NNS
8691	3044	34	decided	decide	VBD
8691	3044	35	a	a	DT
8691	3044	36	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	3044	37	is	be	VBZ
8691	3044	38	stated	state	VBN
8691	3044	39	in	in	IN
8691	3044	40	284	284	CD
8691	3044	41	only	only	RB
8691	3044	42	.	.	.
8691	3045	1	This	this	DT
8691	3045	2	made	make	VBD
8691	3045	3	the	the	DT
8691	3045	4	proportion	proportion	NN
8691	3045	5	of	of	IN
8691	3045	6	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
8691	3045	7	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	3045	8	of	of	IN
8691	3045	9	State	state	NN
8691	3045	10	courts	court	NNS
8691	3045	11	,	,	,
8691	3045	12	in	in	IN
8691	3045	13	the	the	DT
8691	3045	14	country	country	NN
8691	3045	15	at	at	IN
8691	3045	16	large	large	JJ
8691	3045	17	,	,	,
8691	3045	18	to	to	IN
8691	3045	19	those	those	DT
8691	3045	20	in	in	IN
8691	3045	21	which	which	WDT
8691	3045	22	there	there	EX
8691	3045	23	was	be	VBD
8691	3045	24	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	3045	25	nineteen	nineteen	CD
8691	3045	26	to	to	IN
8691	3045	27	one	one	CD
8691	3045	28	.	.	.
8691	3046	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3046	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3046	3	:	:	:
8691	3046	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3046	5	Law	Law	NNP
8691	3046	6	Notes	Notes	NNPS
8691	3046	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3046	8	for	for	IN
8691	3046	9	June	June	NNP
8691	3046	10	,	,	,
8691	3046	11	1904	1904	CD
8691	3046	12	,	,	,
8691	3046	13	p.	p.	NN
8691	3047	1	285	285	CD
8691	3047	2	.	.	.
8691	3047	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3048	1	A	a	DT
8691	3048	2	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	3048	3	judge	judge	NN
8691	3048	4	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3048	5	files	file	VBZ
8691	3048	6	an	an	DT
8691	3048	7	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3048	8	which	which	WDT
8691	3048	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	3048	10	then	then	RB
8691	3048	11	printed	print	VBN
8691	3048	12	in	in	IN
8691	3048	13	full	full	JJ
8691	3048	14	in	in	IN
8691	3048	15	the	the	DT
8691	3048	16	reports	report	NNS
8691	3048	17	.	.	.
8691	3049	1	More	more	RBR
8691	3049	2	often	often	RB
8691	3049	3	the	the	DT
8691	3049	4	fact	fact	NN
8691	3049	5	of	of	IN
8691	3049	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3049	7	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	3049	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	3049	9	simply	simply	RB
8691	3049	10	noted	note	VBN
8691	3049	11	.	.	.
8691	3050	1	In	in	IN
8691	3050	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	3050	3	involving	involve	VBG
8691	3050	4	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3050	5	questions	question	NNS
8691	3050	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3050	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3050	8	rare	rare	JJ
8691	3050	9	for	for	IN
8691	3050	10	a	a	DT
8691	3050	11	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	3050	12	judge	judge	NN
8691	3050	13	not	not	RB
8691	3050	14	to	to	TO
8691	3050	15	state	state	VB
8691	3050	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3050	17	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	3050	18	.	.	.
8691	3051	1	The	the	DT
8691	3051	2	importance	importance	NN
8691	3051	3	of	of	IN
8691	3051	4	the	the	DT
8691	3051	5	subject	subject	JJ
8691	3051	6	justifies	justifie	NNS
8691	3051	7	if	if	IN
8691	3051	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3051	9	does	do	VBZ
8691	3051	10	not	not	RB
8691	3051	11	demand	demand	VB
8691	3051	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3051	13	.	.	.
8691	3052	1	As	as	IN
8691	3052	2	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	3052	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3052	4	Story	Story	NNP
8691	3052	5	once	once	RB
8691	3052	6	observed	observe	VBD
8691	3052	7	,	,	,
8691	3052	8	"	"	``
8691	3052	9	Upon	upon	IN
8691	3052	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3052	11	questions	question	NNS
8691	3052	12	the	the	DT
8691	3052	13	public	public	NN
8691	3052	14	have	have	VBP
8691	3052	15	a	a	DT
8691	3052	16	right	right	NN
8691	3052	17	to	to	TO
8691	3052	18	know	know	VB
8691	3052	19	the	the	DT
8691	3052	20	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3052	21	of	of	IN
8691	3052	22	every	every	DT
8691	3052	23	judge	judge	NN
8691	3052	24	who	who	WP
8691	3052	25	dissents	dissent	VBZ
8691	3052	26	from	from	IN
8691	3052	27	the	the	DT
8691	3052	28	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3052	29	of	of	IN
8691	3052	30	the	the	DT
8691	3052	31	court	court	NN
8691	3052	32	,	,	,
8691	3052	33	and	and	CC
8691	3052	34	the	the	DT
8691	3052	35	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	3052	36	of	of	IN
8691	3052	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3052	38	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	3052	39	.	.	.
8691	3053	1	"	"	``
8691	3053	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3053	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3053	4	:	:	:
8691	3053	5	Briscoe	Briscoe	NNP
8691	3053	6	_	_	NNP
8691	3053	7	v.	v.	IN
8691	3053	8	_	_	NNP
8691	3053	9	Bank	Bank	NNP
8691	3053	10	of	of	IN
8691	3053	11	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	3053	12	,	,	,
8691	3053	13	11	11	CD
8691	3053	14	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	3053	15	'	'	POS
8691	3053	16	Reports	report	NNS
8691	3053	17	,	,	,
8691	3053	18	257	257	CD
8691	3053	19	,	,	,
8691	3053	20	349	349	CD
8691	3053	21	.	.	.
8691	3053	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3054	1	The	the	DT
8691	3054	2	official	official	JJ
8691	3054	3	reports	report	NNS
8691	3054	4	of	of	IN
8691	3054	5	the	the	DT
8691	3054	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	3054	7	have	have	VBP
8691	3054	8	some	some	DT
8691	3054	9	of	of	IN
8691	3054	10	the	the	DT
8691	3054	11	faults	fault	NNS
8691	3054	12	of	of	IN
8691	3054	13	officialism	officialism	NN
8691	3054	14	.	.	.
8691	3055	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3055	2	often	often	RB
8691	3055	3	do	do	VBP
8691	3055	4	not	not	RB
8691	3055	5	appear	appear	VB
8691	3055	6	until	until	IN
8691	3055	7	long	long	RB
8691	3055	8	after	after	IN
8691	3055	9	the	the	DT
8691	3055	10	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	3055	11	which	which	WDT
8691	3055	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3055	13	chronicle	chronicle	VBP
8691	3055	14	have	have	VBP
8691	3055	15	been	be	VBN
8691	3055	16	made	make	VBN
8691	3055	17	and	and	CC
8691	3055	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3055	19	general	general	JJ
8691	3055	20	make	make	VB
8691	3055	21	-	-	HYPH
8691	3055	22	up	up	NN
8691	3055	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	3055	24	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3055	25	unworkmanlike	unworkmanlike	JJ
8691	3055	26	and	and	CC
8691	3055	27	unscientific	unscientific	JJ
8691	3055	28	.	.	.
8691	3056	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3056	2	requires	require	VBZ
8691	3056	3	rare	rare	JJ
8691	3056	4	gifts	gift	NNS
8691	3056	5	to	to	TO
8691	3056	6	make	make	VB
8691	3056	7	a	a	DT
8691	3056	8	good	good	JJ
8691	3056	9	reporter	reporter	NN
8691	3056	10	of	of	IN
8691	3056	11	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3056	12	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3056	13	.	.	.
8691	3057	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3057	2	must	must	MD
8691	3057	3	have	have	VB
8691	3057	4	the	the	DT
8691	3057	5	art	art	NN
8691	3057	6	of	of	IN
8691	3057	7	clear	clear	JJ
8691	3057	8	and	and	CC
8691	3057	9	concise	concise	JJ
8691	3057	10	statement	statement	NN
8691	3057	11	;	;	:
8691	3057	12	the	the	DT
8691	3057	13	power	power	NN
8691	3057	14	to	to	TO
8691	3057	15	select	select	VB
8691	3057	16	what	what	WP
8691	3057	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	3057	18	material	material	NN
8691	3057	19	and	and	CC
8691	3057	20	drop	drop	VB
8691	3057	21	the	the	DT
8691	3057	22	rest	rest	NN
8691	3057	23	;	;	,
8691	3057	24	and	and	CC
8691	3057	25	the	the	DT
8691	3057	26	faculty	faculty	NN
8691	3057	27	of	of	IN
8691	3057	28	close	close	JJ
8691	3057	29	analysis	analysis	NN
8691	3057	30	of	of	IN
8691	3057	31	abstract	abstract	JJ
8691	3057	32	reasoning	reasoning	NN
8691	3057	33	.	.	.
8691	3058	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3058	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3058	3	:	:	:
8691	3058	4	Four	four	CD
8691	3058	5	of	of	IN
8691	3058	6	the	the	DT
8691	3058	7	reporters	reporter	NNS
8691	3058	8	of	of	IN
8691	3058	9	the	the	DT
8691	3058	10	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3058	11	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	3058	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3058	13	of	of	IN
8691	3058	14	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3058	15	have	have	VBP
8691	3058	16	been	be	VBN
8691	3058	17	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3058	18	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3058	19	of	of	IN
8691	3058	20	that	that	DT
8691	3058	21	court	court	NN
8691	3058	22	,	,	,
8691	3058	23	largely	largely	RB
8691	3058	24	in	in	IN
8691	3058	25	consequence	consequence	NN
8691	3058	26	of	of	IN
8691	3058	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3058	28	good	good	JJ
8691	3058	29	work	work	NN
8691	3058	30	in	in	IN
8691	3058	31	reporting	reporting	NN
8691	3058	32	.	.	.
8691	3059	1	A	a	DT
8691	3059	2	good	good	JJ
8691	3059	3	reporter	reporter	NN
8691	3059	4	always	always	RB
8691	3059	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	3059	6	the	the	DT
8691	3059	7	making	making	NN
8691	3059	8	of	of	IN
8691	3059	9	a	a	DT
8691	3059	10	good	good	JJ
8691	3059	11	judge	judge	NN
8691	3059	12	.	.	.
8691	3059	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3060	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	3060	2	of	of	IN
8691	3060	3	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3060	4	reporters	reporter	NNS
8691	3060	5	also	also	RB
8691	3060	6	are	be	VBP
8691	3060	7	practicing	practice	VBG
8691	3060	8	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3060	9	of	of	IN
8691	3060	10	no	no	DT
8691	3060	11	special	special	JJ
8691	3060	12	training	training	NN
8691	3060	13	for	for	IN
8691	3060	14	the	the	DT
8691	3060	15	work	work	NN
8691	3060	16	,	,	,
8691	3060	17	and	and	CC
8691	3060	18	who	who	WP
8691	3060	19	give	give	VBP
8691	3060	20	to	to	IN
8691	3060	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3060	22	but	but	CC
8691	3060	23	a	a	DT
8691	3060	24	portion	portion	NN
8691	3060	25	of	of	IN
8691	3060	26	the	the	DT
8691	3060	27	year	year	NN
8691	3060	28	.	.	.
8691	3061	1	The	the	DT
8691	3061	2	modern	modern	JJ
8691	3061	3	sense	sense	NN
8691	3061	4	of	of	IN
8691	3061	5	the	the	DT
8691	3061	6	value	value	NN
8691	3061	7	of	of	IN
8691	3061	8	time	time	NN
8691	3061	9	,	,	,
8691	3061	10	of	of	IN
8691	3061	11	scientific	scientific	JJ
8691	3061	12	treatment	treatment	NN
8691	3061	13	of	of	IN
8691	3061	14	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	3061	15	can	can	MD
8691	3061	16	be	be	VB
8691	3061	17	treated	treat	VBN
8691	3061	18	scientifically	scientifically	RB
8691	3061	19	,	,	,
8691	3061	20	and	and	CC
8691	3061	21	of	of	IN
8691	3061	22	uniformity	uniformity	NN
8691	3061	23	in	in	IN
8691	3061	24	scientific	scientific	JJ
8691	3061	25	methods	method	NNS
8691	3061	26	led	lead	VBN
8691	3061	27	toward	toward	IN
8691	3061	28	the	the	DT
8691	3061	29	close	close	NN
8691	3061	30	of	of	IN
8691	3061	31	the	the	DT
8691	3061	32	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	3061	33	century	century	NN
8691	3061	34	to	to	IN
8691	3061	35	competition	competition	NN
8691	3061	36	in	in	IN
8691	3061	37	reporting	reporting	NN
8691	3061	38	.	.	.
8691	3062	1	Private	private	JJ
8691	3062	2	publishing	publishing	NN
8691	3062	3	houses	house	NNS
8691	3062	4	undertook	undertake	VBD
8691	3062	5	the	the	DT
8691	3062	6	prompt	prompt	JJ
8691	3062	7	publication	publication	NN
8691	3062	8	,	,	,
8691	3062	9	in	in	IN
8691	3062	10	scientific	scientific	JJ
8691	3062	11	arrangement	arrangement	NN
8691	3062	12	upon	upon	IN
8691	3062	13	a	a	DT
8691	3062	14	uniform	uniform	JJ
8691	3062	15	plan	plan	NN
8691	3062	16	,	,	,
8691	3062	17	of	of	IN
8691	3062	18	the	the	DT
8691	3062	19	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3062	20	of	of	IN
8691	3062	21	the	the	DT
8691	3062	22	courts	court	NNS
8691	3062	23	.	.	.
8691	3063	1	This	this	DT
8691	3063	2	work	work	NN
8691	3063	3	began	begin	VBD
8691	3063	4	in	in	IN
8691	3063	5	1879	1879	CD
8691	3063	6	.	.	.
8691	3064	1	The	the	DT
8691	3064	2	result	result	NN
8691	3064	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	3064	4	been	be	VBN
8691	3064	5	that	that	IN
8691	3064	6	the	the	DT
8691	3064	7	series	series	NN
8691	3064	8	of	of	IN
8691	3064	9	official	official	JJ
8691	3064	10	reports	report	NNS
8691	3064	11	of	of	IN
8691	3064	12	the	the	DT
8691	3064	13	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	3064	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3064	15	of	of	IN
8691	3064	16	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	3064	17	of	of	IN
8691	3064	18	the	the	DT
8691	3064	19	United	United	NNP
8691	3064	20	States	States	NNP
8691	3064	21	has	have	VBZ
8691	3064	22	been	be	VBN
8691	3064	23	discontinued	discontinue	VBN
8691	3064	24	,	,	,
8691	3064	25	and	and	CC
8691	3064	26	that	that	IN
8691	3064	27	the	the	DT
8691	3064	28	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	3064	29	of	of	IN
8691	3064	30	all	all	DT
8691	3064	31	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3064	32	other	other	JJ
8691	3064	33	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3064	34	courts	court	NNS
8691	3064	35	are	be	VBP
8691	3064	36	now	now	RB
8691	3064	37	twice	twice	RB
8691	3064	38	reported	report	VBN
8691	3064	39	.	.	.
8691	3065	1	One	one	CD
8691	3065	2	publishing	publishing	NN
8691	3065	3	house	house	NN
8691	3065	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	3065	5	grouped	group	VBN
8691	3065	6	the	the	DT
8691	3065	7	States	States	NNPS
8691	3065	8	into	into	IN
8691	3065	9	clusters	cluster	NNS
8691	3065	10	,	,	,
8691	3065	11	issuing	issue	VBG
8691	3065	12	for	for	IN
8691	3065	13	each	each	DT
8691	3065	14	cluster	cluster	NN
8691	3065	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3065	16	own	own	JJ
8691	3065	17	series	series	NN
8691	3065	18	of	of	IN
8691	3065	19	reports	report	NNS
8691	3065	20	,	,	,
8691	3065	21	known	know	VBN
8691	3065	22	,	,	,
8691	3065	23	respectively	respectively	RB
8691	3065	24	,	,	,
8691	3065	25	as	as	IN
8691	3065	26	the	the	DT
8691	3065	27	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	3065	28	,	,	,
8691	3065	29	the	the	DT
8691	3065	30	Northeastern	Northeastern	NNP
8691	3065	31	,	,	,
8691	3065	32	the	the	DT
8691	3065	33	Northwestern	Northwestern	NNP
8691	3065	34	,	,	,
8691	3065	35	the	the	DT
8691	3065	36	Southeastern	Southeastern	NNP
8691	3065	37	,	,	,
8691	3065	38	the	the	DT
8691	3065	39	Southern	Southern	NNP
8691	3065	40	,	,	,
8691	3065	41	the	the	DT
8691	3065	42	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
8691	3065	43	and	and	CC
8691	3065	44	the	the	DT
8691	3065	45	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
8691	3065	46	Reporters	Reporters	NNPS
8691	3065	47	.	.	.
8691	3066	1	The	the	DT
8691	3066	2	States	States	NNP
8691	3066	3	forming	form	VBG
8691	3066	4	each	each	DT
8691	3066	5	group	group	NN
8691	3066	6	have	have	VBP
8691	3066	7	been	be	VBN
8691	3066	8	selected	select	VBN
8691	3066	9	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	3066	10	because	because	IN
8691	3066	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3066	12	were	be	VBD
8691	3066	13	neighbors	neighbor	NNS
8691	3066	14	geographically	geographically	RB
8691	3066	15	,	,	,
8691	3066	16	but	but	CC
8691	3066	17	partly	partly	RB
8691	3066	18	from	from	IN
8691	3066	19	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	3066	20	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	3066	21	.	.	.
8691	3067	1	Thus	thus	RB
8691	3067	2	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3067	3	,	,	,
8691	3067	4	which	which	WDT
8691	3067	5	would	would	MD
8691	3067	6	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	3067	7	be	be	VB
8691	3067	8	assigned	assign	VBN
8691	3067	9	to	to	IN
8691	3067	10	the	the	DT
8691	3067	11	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	3067	12	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	3067	13	,	,	,
8691	3067	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	3067	15	been	be	VBN
8691	3067	16	put	put	VBN
8691	3067	17	into	into	IN
8691	3067	18	the	the	DT
8691	3067	19	Northeastern	Northeastern	NNP
8691	3067	20	;	;	:
8691	3067	21	and	and	CC
8691	3067	22	such	such	JJ
8691	3067	23	inland	inland	NN
8691	3067	24	States	state	NNS
8691	3067	25	as	as	IN
8691	3067	26	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
8691	3067	27	and	and	CC
8691	3067	28	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
8691	3067	29	find	find	VBP
8691	3067	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3067	31	place	place	NN
8691	3067	32	in	in	IN
8691	3067	33	the	the	DT
8691	3067	34	Pacific	Pacific	NNP
8691	3067	35	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	3067	36	.	.	.
8691	3068	1	All	all	PDT
8691	3068	2	the	the	DT
8691	3068	3	reported	report	VBN
8691	3068	4	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	3068	5	of	of	IN
8691	3068	6	all	all	PDT
8691	3068	7	the	the	DT
8691	3068	8	States	States	NNPS
8691	3068	9	in	in	IN
8691	3068	10	each	each	DT
8691	3068	11	group	group	NN
8691	3068	12	are	be	VBP
8691	3068	13	printed	print	VBN
8691	3068	14	in	in	IN
8691	3068	15	pamphlet	pamphlet	NNP
8691	3068	16	form	form	NN
8691	3068	17	weekly	weekly	NNP
8691	3068	18	,	,	,
8691	3068	19	as	as	IN
8691	3068	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3068	21	may	may	MD
8691	3068	22	be	be	VB
8691	3068	23	handed	hand	VBN
8691	3068	24	down	down	RP
8691	3068	25	,	,	,
8691	3068	26	in	in	IN
8691	3068	27	chronological	chronological	JJ
8691	3068	28	order	order	NN
8691	3068	29	;	;	:
8691	3068	30	and	and	CC
8691	3068	31	every	every	DT
8691	3068	32	few	few	JJ
8691	3068	33	months	month	NNS
8691	3068	34	the	the	DT
8691	3068	35	whole	whole	NN
8691	3068	36	issued	issue	VBD
8691	3068	37	as	as	IN
8691	3068	38	a	a	DT
8691	3068	39	bound	bind	VBN
8691	3068	40	volume	volume	NN
8691	3068	41	.	.	.
8691	3069	1	In	in	IN
8691	3069	2	this	this	DT
8691	3069	3	way	way	NN
8691	3069	4	,	,	,
8691	3069	5	for	for	IN
8691	3069	6	a	a	DT
8691	3069	7	trifling	trifling	NN
8691	3069	8	sum	sum	NN
8691	3069	9	a	a	DT
8691	3069	10	copy	copy	NN
8691	3069	11	of	of	IN
8691	3069	12	any	any	DT
8691	3069	13	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3069	14	of	of	IN
8691	3069	15	any	any	DT
8691	3069	16	American	american	JJ
8691	3069	17	court	court	NN
8691	3069	18	of	of	IN
8691	3069	19	last	last	JJ
8691	3069	20	resort	resort	NN
8691	3069	21	can	can	MD
8691	3069	22	be	be	VB
8691	3069	23	had	have	VBN
8691	3069	24	in	in	IN
8691	3069	25	a	a	DT
8691	3069	26	few	few	JJ
8691	3069	27	days	day	NNS
8691	3069	28	or	or	CC
8691	3069	29	weeks	week	NNS
8691	3069	30	after	after	IN
8691	3069	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3069	32	announcement	announcement	NN
8691	3069	33	,	,	,
8691	3069	34	and	and	CC
8691	3069	35	a	a	DT
8691	3069	36	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	3069	37	's	's	POS
8691	3069	38	library	library	NN
8691	3069	39	can	can	MD
8691	3069	40	,	,	,
8691	3069	41	at	at	IN
8691	3069	42	slight	slight	JJ
8691	3069	43	expense	expense	NN
8691	3069	44	,	,	,
8691	3069	45	be	be	VB
8691	3069	46	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	3069	47	with	with	IN
8691	3069	48	the	the	DT
8691	3069	49	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	3069	50	not	not	RB
8691	3069	51	only	only	RB
8691	3069	52	of	of	IN
8691	3069	53	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3069	54	own	own	JJ
8691	3069	55	State	state	NN
8691	3069	56	but	but	CC
8691	3069	57	of	of	IN
8691	3069	58	several	several	JJ
8691	3069	59	others	other	NNS
8691	3069	60	having	have	VBG
8691	3069	61	not	not	RB
8691	3069	62	unlike	unlike	IN
8691	3069	63	laws	law	NNS
8691	3069	64	and	and	CC
8691	3069	65	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	3069	66	.	.	.
8691	3070	1	The	the	DT
8691	3070	2	multiplication	multiplication	NN
8691	3070	3	of	of	IN
8691	3070	4	American	american	JJ
8691	3070	5	reports	report	NNS
8691	3070	6	makes	make	VBZ
8691	3070	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3070	8	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	3070	9	of	of	IN
8691	3070	10	decreasing	decrease	VBG
8691	3070	11	value	value	NN
8691	3070	12	to	to	IN
8691	3070	13	the	the	DT
8691	3070	14	American	american	JJ
8691	3070	15	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	3070	16	.	.	.
8691	3071	1	English	english	JJ
8691	3071	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	3071	3	are	be	VBP
8691	3071	4	cited	cite	VBN
8691	3071	5	as	as	IN
8691	3071	6	authority	authority	NN
8691	3071	7	far	far	RB
8691	3071	8	less	less	RBR
8691	3071	9	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	3071	10	than	than	IN
8691	3071	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3071	12	were	be	VBD
8691	3071	13	before	before	IN
8691	3071	14	the	the	DT
8691	3071	15	middle	middle	NN
8691	3071	16	of	of	IN
8691	3071	17	the	the	DT
8691	3071	18	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	3071	19	century	century	NN
8691	3071	20	.	.	.
8691	3072	1	The	the	DT
8691	3072	2	omnipotence	omnipotence	NN
8691	3072	3	of	of	IN
8691	3072	4	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
8691	3072	5	and	and	CC
8691	3072	6	the	the	DT
8691	3072	7	free	free	JJ
8691	3072	8	hand	hand	NN
8691	3072	9	with	with	IN
8691	3072	10	which	which	WDT
8691	3072	11	that	that	WDT
8691	3072	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	3072	13	been	be	VBN
8691	3072	14	exerted	exert	VBN
8691	3072	15	to	to	TO
8691	3072	16	change	change	VB
8691	3072	17	the	the	DT
8691	3072	18	common	common	JJ
8691	3072	19	law	law	NN
8691	3072	20	have	have	VBP
8691	3072	21	tended	tend	VBN
8691	3072	22	to	to	TO
8691	3072	23	separate	separate	VB
8691	3072	24	English	English	NNP
8691	3072	25	from	from	IN
8691	3072	26	American	american	JJ
8691	3072	27	jurisprudence	jurisprudence	NN
8691	3072	28	.	.	.
8691	3073	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3073	2	written	write	VBN
8691	3073	3	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	3073	4	have	have	VBP
8691	3073	5	perpetuated	perpetuate	VBN
8691	3073	6	here	here	RB
8691	3073	7	ideas	idea	NNS
8691	3073	8	of	of	IN
8691	3073	9	government	government	NN
8691	3073	10	and	and	CC
8691	3073	11	property	property	NN
8691	3073	12	which	which	WDT
8691	3073	13	England	England	NNP
8691	3073	14	does	do	VBZ
8691	3073	15	not	not	RB
8691	3073	16	recognize	recognize	VB
8691	3073	17	.	.	.
8691	3074	1	Hence	hence	RB
8691	3074	2	American	american	JJ
8691	3074	3	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	3074	4	are	be	VBP
8691	3074	5	of	of	IN
8691	3074	6	more	more	JJR
8691	3074	7	use	use	NN
8691	3074	8	than	than	IN
8691	3074	9	English	English	NNP
8691	3074	10	.	.	.
8691	3075	1	But	but	CC
8691	3075	2	American	american	JJ
8691	3075	3	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	3075	4	are	be	VBP
8691	3075	5	becoming	become	VBG
8691	3075	6	so	so	RB
8691	3075	7	numerous	numerous	JJ
8691	3075	8	that	that	IN
8691	3075	9	the	the	DT
8691	3075	10	advocate	advocate	NN
8691	3075	11	who	who	WP
8691	3075	12	seeks	seek	VBZ
8691	3075	13	to	to	TO
8691	3075	14	avail	avail	VB
8691	3075	15	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3075	16	of	of	IN
8691	3075	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3075	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	3075	19	tempted	tempt	VBN
8691	3075	20	to	to	TO
8691	3075	21	cite	cite	VB
8691	3075	22	too	too	RB
8691	3075	23	many	many	JJ
8691	3075	24	and	and	CC
8691	3075	25	to	to	TO
8691	3075	26	examine	examine	VB
8691	3075	27	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3075	28	with	with	IN
8691	3075	29	too	too	RB
8691	3075	30	little	little	JJ
8691	3075	31	care	care	NN
8691	3075	32	.	.	.
8691	3076	1	In	in	IN
8691	3076	2	each	each	DT
8691	3076	3	State	state	NN
8691	3076	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3076	5	own	own	JJ
8691	3076	6	reports	report	NNS
8691	3076	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3076	8	the	the	DT
8691	3076	9	expression	expression	NN
8691	3076	10	of	of	IN
8691	3076	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3076	12	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
8691	3076	13	law	law	NN
8691	3076	14	.	.	.
8691	3077	1	With	with	IN
8691	3077	2	these	these	DT
8691	3077	3	every	every	DT
8691	3077	4	member	member	NN
8691	3077	5	of	of	IN
8691	3077	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3077	7	bar	bar	NN
8691	3077	8	must	must	MD
8691	3077	9	be	be	VB
8691	3077	10	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	3077	11	.	.	.
8691	3078	1	But	but	CC
8691	3078	2	the	the	DT
8691	3078	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	3078	4	before	before	IN
8691	3078	5	which	which	WDT
8691	3078	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3078	7	argues	argue	VBZ
8691	3078	8	listen	listen	VB
8691	3078	9	to	to	IN
8691	3078	10	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3078	11	with	with	IN
8691	3078	12	more	more	JJR
8691	3078	13	satisfaction	satisfaction	NN
8691	3078	14	and	and	CC
8691	3078	15	greater	great	JJR
8691	3078	16	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	3078	17	if	if	IN
8691	3078	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3078	19	deals	deal	VBZ
8691	3078	20	with	with	IN
8691	3078	21	the	the	DT
8691	3078	22	principles	principle	NNS
8691	3078	23	of	of	IN
8691	3078	24	law	law	NN
8691	3078	25	rather	rather	RB
8691	3078	26	than	than	IN
8691	3078	27	with	with	IN
8691	3078	28	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	3078	29	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	3078	30	which	which	WDT
8691	3078	31	may	may	MD
8691	3078	32	or	or	CC
8691	3078	33	may	may	MD
8691	3078	34	not	not	RB
8691	3078	35	correctly	correctly	RB
8691	3078	36	apply	apply	VB
8691	3078	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3078	38	.	.	.
8691	3079	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3079	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3079	3	:	:	:
8691	3079	4	See	see	VB
8691	3079	5	a	a	DT
8691	3079	6	valuable	valuable	JJ
8691	3079	7	statistical	statistical	JJ
8691	3079	8	article	article	NN
8691	3079	9	on	on	IN
8691	3079	10	"	"	``
8691	3079	11	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3079	12	and	and	CC
8691	3079	13	Citations	Citations	NNPS
8691	3079	14	"	"	''
8691	3079	15	in	in	IN
8691	3079	16	_	_	NNP
8691	3079	17	Law	Law	NNP
8691	3079	18	Notes	Notes	NNPS
8691	3079	19	_	_	NNP
8691	3079	20	for	for	IN
8691	3079	21	August	August	NNP
8691	3079	22	,	,	,
8691	3079	23	1904	1904	CD
8691	3079	24	.	.	.
8691	3079	25	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3080	1	Not	not	RB
8691	3080	2	every	every	DT
8691	3080	3	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3080	4	which	which	WDT
8691	3080	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3080	6	delivered	deliver	VBN
8691	3080	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3080	8	officially	officially	RB
8691	3080	9	reported	report	VBN
8691	3080	10	.	.	.
8691	3081	1	In	in	IN
8691	3081	2	most	most	JJS
8691	3081	3	States	state	NNS
8691	3081	4	the	the	DT
8691	3081	5	court	court	NN
8691	3081	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	3081	7	and	and	CC
8691	3081	8	exercises	exercise	VBZ
8691	3081	9	the	the	DT
8691	3081	10	power	power	NN
8691	3081	11	of	of	IN
8691	3081	12	directing	direct	VBG
8691	3081	13	that	that	DT
8691	3081	14	such	such	JJ
8691	3081	15	as	as	IN
8691	3081	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3081	17	may	may	MD
8691	3081	18	deem	deem	VB
8691	3081	19	of	of	IN
8691	3081	20	no	no	DT
8691	3081	21	substantial	substantial	JJ
8691	3081	22	value	value	NN
8691	3081	23	to	to	IN
8691	3081	24	the	the	DT
8691	3081	25	profession	profession	NN
8691	3081	26	at	at	IN
8691	3081	27	large	large	JJ
8691	3081	28	shall	shall	MD
8691	3081	29	not	not	RB
8691	3081	30	be	be	VB
8691	3081	31	.	.	.
8691	3082	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	3082	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3082	3	simply	simply	RB
8691	3082	4	applications	application	NNS
8691	3082	5	of	of	IN
8691	3082	6	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	3082	7	rules	rule	NNS
8691	3082	8	which	which	WDT
8691	3082	9	obviously	obviously	RB
8691	3082	10	control	control	VBP
8691	3082	11	.	.	.
8691	3083	1	Opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3083	2	of	of	IN
8691	3083	3	that	that	DT
8691	3083	4	kind	kind	JJ
8691	3083	5	interest	interest	NN
8691	3083	6	only	only	RB
8691	3083	7	the	the	DT
8691	3083	8	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3083	9	in	in	IN
8691	3083	10	the	the	DT
8691	3083	11	cause	cause	NN
8691	3083	12	.	.	.
8691	3084	1	In	in	IN
8691	3084	2	the	the	DT
8691	3084	3	unofficial	unofficial	JJ
8691	3084	4	reports	report	NNS
8691	3084	5	,	,	,
8691	3084	6	however	however	RB
8691	3084	7	,	,	,
8691	3084	8	such	such	JJ
8691	3084	9	cases	case	NNS
8691	3084	10	are	be	VBP
8691	3084	11	sure	sure	JJ
8691	3084	12	to	to	TO
8691	3084	13	appear	appear	VB
8691	3084	14	and	and	CC
8691	3084	15	the	the	DT
8691	3084	16	bar	bar	NN
8691	3084	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	3084	18	divided	divide	VBN
8691	3084	19	in	in	IN
8691	3084	20	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3084	21	as	as	IN
8691	3084	22	to	to	IN
8691	3084	23	whether	whether	IN
8691	3084	24	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3084	25	should	should	MD
8691	3084	26	not	not	RB
8691	3084	27	also	also	RB
8691	3084	28	be	be	VB
8691	3084	29	given	give	VBN
8691	3084	30	a	a	DT
8691	3084	31	place	place	NN
8691	3084	32	in	in	IN
8691	3084	33	the	the	DT
8691	3084	34	official	official	JJ
8691	3084	35	ones	one	NNS
8691	3084	36	.	.	.
8691	3085	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3085	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3085	3	not	not	RB
8691	3085	4	always	always	RB
8691	3085	5	easy	easy	JJ
8691	3085	6	for	for	IN
8691	3085	7	the	the	DT
8691	3085	8	court	court	NN
8691	3085	9	or	or	CC
8691	3085	10	the	the	DT
8691	3085	11	reporter	reporter	NN
8691	3085	12	to	to	TO
8691	3085	13	determine	determine	VB
8691	3085	14	what	what	WDT
8691	3085	15	decision	decision	NN
8691	3085	16	may	may	MD
8691	3085	17	thereafter	thereafter	RB
8691	3085	18	be	be	VB
8691	3085	19	relied	rely	VBN
8691	3085	20	on	on	IN
8691	3085	21	as	as	IN
8691	3085	22	a	a	DT
8691	3085	23	precedent	precedent	NN
8691	3085	24	.	.	.
8691	3086	1	Repeated	repeated	JJ
8691	3086	2	instances	instance	NNS
8691	3086	3	have	have	VBP
8691	3086	4	occurred	occur	VBN
8691	3086	5	in	in	IN
8691	3086	6	which	which	WDT
8691	3086	7	such	such	PDT
8691	3086	8	a	a	DT
8691	3086	9	use	use	NN
8691	3086	10	has	have	VBZ
8691	3086	11	in	in	IN
8691	3086	12	fact	fact	NN
8691	3086	13	been	be	VBN
8691	3086	14	made	make	VBN
8691	3086	15	and	and	CC
8691	3086	16	properly	properly	RB
8691	3086	17	made	make	VBN
8691	3086	18	of	of	IN
8691	3086	19	some	some	DT
8691	3086	20	not	not	RB
8691	3086	21	noted	note	VBN
8691	3086	22	in	in	IN
8691	3086	23	the	the	DT
8691	3086	24	regular	regular	JJ
8691	3086	25	reports	report	NNS
8691	3086	26	,	,	,
8691	3086	27	and	and	CC
8691	3086	28	not	not	RB
8691	3086	29	infrequently	infrequently	RB
8691	3086	30	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3086	31	have	have	VBP
8691	3086	32	subsequently	subsequently	RB
8691	3086	33	been	be	VBN
8691	3086	34	inserted	insert	VBN
8691	3086	35	in	in	IN
8691	3086	36	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3086	37	.	.	.
8691	3087	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3087	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3087	3	:	:	:
8691	3087	4	In	in	IN
8691	3087	5	the	the	DT
8691	3087	6	centennial	centennial	JJ
8691	3087	7	volume	volume	NN
8691	3087	8	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3087	9	Vol	Vol	NNP
8691	3087	10	.	.	.
8691	3088	1	CXXXI	CXXXI	NNP
8691	3088	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3088	3	of	of	IN
8691	3088	4	those	those	DT
8691	3088	5	of	of	IN
8691	3088	6	the	the	DT
8691	3088	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3088	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3088	9	of	of	IN
8691	3088	10	the	the	DT
8691	3088	11	United	United	NNP
8691	3088	12	States	States	NNP
8691	3088	13	,	,	,
8691	3088	14	one	one	CD
8691	3088	15	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3088	16	and	and	CC
8691	3088	17	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	3088	18	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3088	19	are	be	VBP
8691	3088	20	printed	print	VBN
8691	3088	21	,	,	,
8691	3088	22	the	the	DT
8691	3088	23	first	first	JJ
8691	3088	24	delivered	deliver	VBN
8691	3088	25	over	over	IN
8691	3088	26	fifty	fifty	CD
8691	3088	27	years	year	NNS
8691	3088	28	before	before	RB
8691	3088	29	,	,	,
8691	3088	30	which	which	WDT
8691	3088	31	previous	previous	JJ
8691	3088	32	reporters	reporter	NNS
8691	3088	33	had	have	VBD
8691	3088	34	thought	think	VBN
8691	3088	35	best	well	RBS
8691	3088	36	to	to	TO
8691	3088	37	omit	omit	VB
8691	3088	38	,	,	,
8691	3088	39	and	and	CC
8691	3088	40	two	two	CD
8691	3088	41	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3088	42	and	and	CC
8691	3088	43	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3088	44	-	-	HYPH
8691	3088	45	one	one	CD
8691	3088	46	more	more	JJR
8691	3088	47	such	such	JJ
8691	3088	48	are	be	VBP
8691	3088	49	published	publish	VBN
8691	3088	50	in	in	IN
8691	3088	51	Vol	Vol	NNP
8691	3088	52	.	.	.
8691	3089	1	CLIV	CLIV	NNP
8691	3089	2	.	.	.
8691	3090	1	Whoever	whoever	WP
8691	3090	2	runs	run	VBZ
8691	3090	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3090	4	over	over	RP
8691	3090	5	will	will	MD
8691	3090	6	be	be	VB
8691	3090	7	apt	apt	JJ
8691	3090	8	to	to	TO
8691	3090	9	think	think	VB
8691	3090	10	that	that	IN
8691	3090	11	the	the	DT
8691	3090	12	previous	previous	JJ
8691	3090	13	reporters	reporter	NNS
8691	3090	14	were	be	VBD
8691	3090	15	right	right	JJ
8691	3090	16	.	.	.
8691	3090	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3091	1	There	there	EX
8691	3091	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3091	3	also	also	RB
8691	3091	4	in	in	IN
8691	3091	5	case	case	NN
8691	3091	6	of	of	IN
8691	3091	7	an	an	DT
8691	3091	8	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3091	9	not	not	RB
8691	3091	10	to	to	TO
8691	3091	11	be	be	VB
8691	3091	12	officially	officially	RB
8691	3091	13	reported	report	VBN
8691	3091	14	a	a	DT
8691	3091	15	loss	loss	NN
8691	3091	16	of	of	IN
8691	3091	17	a	a	DT
8691	3091	18	valuable	valuable	JJ
8691	3091	19	safeguard	safeguard	NN
8691	3091	20	against	against	IN
8691	3091	21	unsound	unsound	JJ
8691	3091	22	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	3091	23	.	.	.
8691	3092	1	A	a	DT
8691	3092	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	3092	3	writes	write	VBZ
8691	3092	4	with	with	IN
8691	3092	5	more	more	JJR
8691	3092	6	care	care	NN
8691	3092	7	and	and	CC
8691	3092	8	examines	examine	VBZ
8691	3092	9	the	the	DT
8691	3092	10	points	point	NNS
8691	3092	11	of	of	IN
8691	3092	12	law	law	NN
8691	3092	13	which	which	WDT
8691	3092	14	may	may	MD
8691	3092	15	be	be	VB
8691	3092	16	presented	present	VBN
8691	3092	17	more	more	RBR
8691	3092	18	closely	closely	RB
8691	3092	19	if	if	IN
8691	3092	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3092	21	writes	write	VBZ
8691	3092	22	for	for	IN
8691	3092	23	the	the	DT
8691	3092	24	public	public	NN
8691	3092	25	and	and	CC
8691	3092	26	for	for	IN
8691	3092	27	posterity	posterity	NN
8691	3092	28	.	.	.
8691	3093	1	On	on	IN
8691	3093	2	the	the	DT
8691	3093	3	whole	whole	NN
8691	3093	4	the	the	DT
8691	3093	5	prevailing	prevailing	JJ
8691	3093	6	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	3093	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3093	8	that	that	IN
8691	3093	9	the	the	DT
8691	3093	10	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	3093	11	for	for	IN
8691	3093	12	repressing	repress	VBG
8691	3093	13	some	some	DT
8691	3093	14	are	be	VBP
8691	3093	15	stronger	strong	JJR
8691	3093	16	than	than	IN
8691	3093	17	those	those	DT
8691	3093	18	for	for	IN
8691	3093	19	publishing	publish	VBG
8691	3093	20	all	all	DT
8691	3093	21	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3093	22	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3093	23	.	.	.
8691	3094	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3094	2	will	will	MD
8691	3094	3	be	be	VB
8691	3094	4	few	few	JJ
8691	3094	5	only	only	RB
8691	3094	6	that	that	IN
8691	3094	7	,	,	,
8691	3094	8	under	under	IN
8691	3094	9	any	any	DT
8691	3094	10	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	3094	11	,	,	,
8691	3094	12	will	will	MD
8691	3094	13	be	be	VB
8691	3094	14	omitted	omit	VBN
8691	3094	15	.	.	.
8691	3095	1	The	the	DT
8691	3095	2	leading	lead	VBG
8691	3095	3	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3095	4	in	in	IN
8691	3095	5	every	every	DT
8691	3095	6	State	State	NNP
8691	3095	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3095	8	expected	expect	VBN
8691	3095	9	to	to	TO
8691	3095	10	run	run	VB
8691	3095	11	over	over	RP
8691	3095	12	,	,	,
8691	3095	13	if	if	IN
8691	3095	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3095	15	do	do	VBP
8691	3095	16	not	not	RB
8691	3095	17	read	read	VB
8691	3095	18	,	,	,
8691	3095	19	every	every	DT
8691	3095	20	case	case	NN
8691	3095	21	in	in	IN
8691	3095	22	every	every	DT
8691	3095	23	new	new	JJ
8691	3095	24	volume	volume	NN
8691	3095	25	of	of	IN
8691	3095	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3095	27	reports	report	NNS
8691	3095	28	.	.	.
8691	3096	1	Every	every	DT
8691	3096	2	case	case	NN
8691	3096	3	dropped	drop	VBD
8691	3096	4	lightens	lighten	VBZ
8691	3096	5	this	this	DT
8691	3096	6	task	task	NN
8691	3096	7	.	.	.
8691	3097	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3097	2	helps	help	VBZ
8691	3097	3	to	to	TO
8691	3097	4	keep	keep	VB
8691	3097	5	indexes	index	NNS
8691	3097	6	of	of	IN
8691	3097	7	reports	report	NNS
8691	3097	8	and	and	CC
8691	3097	9	digests	digest	NNS
8691	3097	10	of	of	IN
8691	3097	11	reports	report	NNS
8691	3097	12	and	and	CC
8691	3097	13	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3097	14	treatises	treatise	NNS
8691	3097	15	within	within	IN
8691	3097	16	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	3097	17	limits	limit	NNS
8691	3097	18	.	.	.
8691	3098	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3098	2	cuts	cut	VBZ
8691	3098	3	into	into	IN
8691	3098	4	an	an	DT
8691	3098	5	accumulating	accumulate	VBG
8691	3098	6	mass	mass	NN
8691	3098	7	of	of	IN
8691	3098	8	material	material	NN
8691	3098	9	,	,	,
8691	3098	10	most	most	JJS
8691	3098	11	of	of	IN
8691	3098	12	which	which	WDT
8691	3098	13	must	must	MD
8691	3098	14	,	,	,
8691	3098	15	in	in	IN
8691	3098	16	any	any	DT
8691	3098	17	event	event	NN
8691	3098	18	,	,	,
8691	3098	19	so	so	RB
8691	3098	20	far	far	RB
8691	3098	21	as	as	IN
8691	3098	22	points	point	NNS
8691	3098	23	of	of	IN
8691	3098	24	law	law	NN
8691	3098	25	are	be	VBP
8691	3098	26	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	3098	27	,	,	,
8691	3098	28	be	be	VB
8691	3098	29	a	a	DT
8691	3098	30	mere	mere	JJ
8691	3098	31	repetition	repetition	NN
8691	3098	32	of	of	IN
8691	3098	33	twice	twice	RB
8691	3098	34	-	-	HYPH
8691	3098	35	told	tell	VBN
8691	3098	36	tales	tale	NNS
8691	3098	37	,	,	,
8691	3098	38	that	that	RB
8691	3098	39	is	be	VBZ
8691	3098	40	becoming	become	VBG
8691	3098	41	so	so	RB
8691	3098	42	vast	vast	JJ
8691	3098	43	in	in	IN
8691	3098	44	the	the	DT
8691	3098	45	United	United	NNP
8691	3098	46	States	States	NNP
8691	3098	47	as	as	IN
8691	3098	48	to	to	IN
8691	3098	49	becloud	becloud	NNP
8691	3098	50	rather	rather	RB
8691	3098	51	than	than	IN
8691	3098	52	illuminate	illuminate	VB
8691	3098	53	whoever	whoever	WP
8691	3098	54	seeks	seek	VBZ
8691	3098	55	to	to	TO
8691	3098	56	know	know	VB
8691	3098	57	what	what	WP
8691	3098	58	American	american	JJ
8691	3098	59	law	law	NN
8691	3098	60	really	really	RB
8691	3098	61	is	be	VBZ
8691	3098	62	.	.	.
8691	3099	1	If	if	IN
8691	3099	2	reporters	reporter	NNS
8691	3099	3	will	will	MD
8691	3099	4	not	not	RB
8691	3099	5	select	select	VB
8691	3099	6	and	and	CC
8691	3099	7	discriminate	discriminate	VB
8691	3099	8	between	between	IN
8691	3099	9	adjudged	adjudged	JJ
8691	3099	10	cases	case	NNS
8691	3099	11	publishers	publisher	NNS
8691	3099	12	can	can	MD
8691	3099	13	and	and	CC
8691	3099	14	will	will	MD
8691	3099	15	.	.	.
8691	3100	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	3100	2	sets	set	NNS
8691	3100	3	have	have	VBP
8691	3100	4	been	be	VBN
8691	3100	5	prepared	prepare	VBN
8691	3100	6	and	and	CC
8691	3100	7	issued	issue	VBN
8691	3100	8	in	in	IN
8691	3100	9	recent	recent	JJ
8691	3100	10	years	year	NNS
8691	3100	11	of	of	IN
8691	3100	12	selected	select	VBN
8691	3100	13	cases	case	NNS
8691	3100	14	on	on	IN
8691	3100	15	all	all	DT
8691	3100	16	subjects	subject	NNS
8691	3100	17	taken	take	VBN
8691	3100	18	from	from	IN
8691	3100	19	the	the	DT
8691	3100	20	official	official	JJ
8691	3100	21	reports	report	NNS
8691	3100	22	of	of	IN
8691	3100	23	all	all	PDT
8691	3100	24	the	the	DT
8691	3100	25	States	States	NNPS
8691	3100	26	.	.	.
8691	3101	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3101	2	professed	professed	JJ
8691	3101	3	aim	aim	NN
8691	3101	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	3101	5	been	be	VBN
8691	3101	6	to	to	TO
8691	3101	7	include	include	VB
8691	3101	8	all	all	DT
8691	3101	9	worth	worth	JJ
8691	3101	10	preserving	preserving	NN
8691	3101	11	.	.	.
8691	3102	1	In	in	IN
8691	3102	2	fact	fact	NN
8691	3102	3	,	,	,
8691	3102	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3102	5	have	have	VBP
8691	3102	6	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	3102	7	been	be	VBN
8691	3102	8	guided	guide	VBN
8691	3102	9	to	to	IN
8691	3102	10	a	a	DT
8691	3102	11	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	3102	12	extent	extent	NN
8691	3102	13	by	by	IN
8691	3102	14	commercial	commercial	JJ
8691	3102	15	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	3102	16	.	.	.
8691	3103	1	To	to	IN
8691	3103	2	every	every	DT
8691	3103	3	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	3103	4	the	the	DT
8691	3103	5	leading	lead	VBG
8691	3103	6	cases	case	NNS
8691	3103	7	in	in	IN
8691	3103	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3103	9	own	own	JJ
8691	3103	10	State	state	NN
8691	3103	11	are	be	VBP
8691	3103	12	of	of	IN
8691	3103	13	the	the	DT
8691	3103	14	first	first	JJ
8691	3103	15	importance	importance	NN
8691	3103	16	.	.	.
8691	3104	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3104	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3104	3	not	not	RB
8691	3104	4	likely	likely	JJ
8691	3104	5	to	to	TO
8691	3104	6	buy	buy	VB
8691	3104	7	any	any	DT
8691	3104	8	compilation	compilation	NN
8691	3104	9	in	in	IN
8691	3104	10	which	which	WDT
8691	3104	11	a	a	DT
8691	3104	12	number	number	NN
8691	3104	13	of	of	IN
8691	3104	14	these	these	DT
8691	3104	15	do	do	VBP
8691	3104	16	not	not	RB
8691	3104	17	appear	appear	VB
8691	3104	18	,	,	,
8691	3104	19	even	even	RB
8691	3104	20	if	if	IN
8691	3104	21	intrinsically	intrinsically	RB
8691	3104	22	,	,	,
8691	3104	23	as	as	IN
8691	3104	24	statements	statement	NNS
8691	3104	25	of	of	IN
8691	3104	26	law	law	NN
8691	3104	27	,	,	,
8691	3104	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3104	29	may	may	MD
8691	3104	30	be	be	VB
8691	3104	31	of	of	IN
8691	3104	32	no	no	DT
8691	3104	33	great	great	JJ
8691	3104	34	value	value	NN
8691	3104	35	.	.	.
8691	3105	1	Hence	hence	RB
8691	3105	2	in	in	IN
8691	3105	3	the	the	DT
8691	3105	4	collections	collection	NNS
8691	3105	5	in	in	IN
8691	3105	6	question	question	NN
8691	3105	7	the	the	DT
8691	3105	8	rule	rule	NN
8691	3105	9	of	of	IN
8691	3105	10	selection	selection	NN
8691	3105	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	3105	12	often	often	RB
8691	3105	13	the	the	DT
8691	3105	14	rule	rule	NN
8691	3105	15	of	of	IN
8691	3105	16	three	three	CD
8691	3105	17	,	,	,
8691	3105	18	and	and	CC
8691	3105	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3105	20	are	be	VBP
8691	3105	21	apt	apt	JJ
8691	3105	22	to	to	TO
8691	3105	23	contain	contain	VB
8691	3105	24	a	a	DT
8691	3105	25	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3105	26	proportion	proportion	NN
8691	3105	27	of	of	IN
8691	3105	28	the	the	DT
8691	3105	29	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	3105	30	of	of	IN
8691	3105	31	every	every	DT
8691	3105	32	State	state	NN
8691	3105	33	.	.	.
8691	3106	1	The	the	DT
8691	3106	2	leading	lead	VBG
8691	3106	3	sets	set	NNS
8691	3106	4	are	be	VBP
8691	3106	5	the	the	DT
8691	3106	6	"	"	``
8691	3106	7	American	american	JJ
8691	3106	8	Decisions	Decisions	NNPS
8691	3106	9	,	,	,
8691	3106	10	"	"	''
8691	3106	11	running	run	VBG
8691	3106	12	from	from	IN
8691	3106	13	1760[Footnote	1760[footnote	CD
8691	3106	14	:	:	:
8691	3106	15	Long	long	RB
8691	3106	16	after	after	IN
8691	3106	17	the	the	DT
8691	3106	18	publication	publication	NN
8691	3106	19	of	of	IN
8691	3106	20	Kirby	Kirby	NNP
8691	3106	21	's	's	POS
8691	3106	22	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3106	23	in	in	IN
8691	3106	24	1784	1784	CD
8691	3106	25	,	,	,
8691	3106	26	some	some	DT
8691	3106	27	unofficial	unofficial	JJ
8691	3106	28	reports	report	NNS
8691	3106	29	were	be	VBD
8691	3106	30	published	publish	VBN
8691	3106	31	of	of	IN
8691	3106	32	cases	case	NNS
8691	3106	33	decided	decide	VBN
8691	3106	34	in	in	IN
8691	3106	35	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	3106	36	courts	court	NNS
8691	3106	37	prior	prior	RB
8691	3106	38	to	to	IN
8691	3106	39	any	any	DT
8691	3106	40	which	which	WDT
8691	3106	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3106	42	included	include	VBD
8691	3106	43	.	.	.
8691	3106	44	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3107	1	to	to	IN
8691	3107	2	1869	1869	CD
8691	3107	3	;	;	:
8691	3107	4	the	the	DT
8691	3107	5	"	"	``
8691	3107	6	American	American	NNP
8691	3107	7	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3107	8	,	,	,
8691	3107	9	"	"	''
8691	3107	10	from	from	IN
8691	3107	11	1869	1869	CD
8691	3107	12	to	to	IN
8691	3107	13	1886	1886	CD
8691	3107	14	;	;	:
8691	3107	15	the	the	DT
8691	3107	16	"	"	``
8691	3107	17	American	American	NNP
8691	3107	18	State	State	NNP
8691	3107	19	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3107	20	,	,	,
8691	3107	21	"	"	''
8691	3107	22	from	from	IN
8691	3107	23	1886	1886	CD
8691	3107	24	to	to	IN
8691	3107	25	the	the	DT
8691	3107	26	present	present	JJ
8691	3107	27	time	time	NN
8691	3107	28	,	,	,
8691	3107	29	which	which	WDT
8691	3107	30	three	three	CD
8691	3107	31	sets	set	NNS
8691	3107	32	include	include	VBP
8691	3107	33	over	over	IN
8691	3107	34	two	two	CD
8691	3107	35	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3107	36	and	and	CC
8691	3107	37	fifty	fifty	CD
8691	3107	38	volumes	volume	NNS
8691	3107	39	and	and	CC
8691	3107	40	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	3107	41	40,000	40,000	CD
8691	3107	42	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3107	43	;	;	:
8691	3107	44	and	and	CC
8691	3107	45	the	the	DT
8691	3107	46	"	"	``
8691	3107	47	Lawyers	Lawyers	NNPS
8691	3107	48	'	'	POS
8691	3107	49	Reports	report	NNS
8691	3107	50	Annotated	annotate	VBD
8691	3107	51	,	,	,
8691	3107	52	"	"	``
8691	3107	53	now	now	RB
8691	3107	54	extending	extend	VBG
8691	3107	55	over	over	IN
8691	3107	56	more	more	JJR
8691	3107	57	than	than	IN
8691	3107	58	sixty	sixty	CD
8691	3107	59	volumes	volume	NNS
8691	3107	60	,	,	,
8691	3107	61	the	the	DT
8691	3107	62	first	first	JJ
8691	3107	63	of	of	IN
8691	3107	64	which	which	WDT
8691	3107	65	was	be	VBD
8691	3107	66	published	publish	VBN
8691	3107	67	in	in	IN
8691	3107	68	1888	1888	CD
8691	3107	69	,	,	,
8691	3107	70	and	and	CC
8691	3107	71	contains	contain	VBZ
8691	3107	72	no	no	DT
8691	3107	73	cases	case	NNS
8691	3107	74	reported	report	VBN
8691	3107	75	prior	prior	RB
8691	3107	76	to	to	IN
8691	3107	77	the	the	DT
8691	3107	78	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	3107	79	year	year	NN
8691	3107	80	.	.	.
8691	3108	1	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
8691	3108	2	's	's	POS
8691	3108	3	rule	rule	NN
8691	3108	4	of	of	IN
8691	3108	5	social	social	JJ
8691	3108	6	evolution	evolution	NN
8691	3108	7	that	that	WDT
8691	3108	8	all	all	DT
8691	3108	9	progress	progress	NN
8691	3108	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	3108	11	from	from	IN
8691	3108	12	the	the	DT
8691	3108	13	homogeneous	homogeneous	JJ
8691	3108	14	to	to	IN
8691	3108	15	the	the	DT
8691	3108	16	heterogeneous	heterogeneous	JJ
8691	3108	17	tends	tend	NNS
8691	3108	18	steadily	steadily	RB
8691	3108	19	and	and	CC
8691	3108	20	inexorably	inexorably	RB
8691	3108	21	in	in	IN
8691	3108	22	the	the	DT
8691	3108	23	United	United	NNP
8691	3108	24	States	States	NNP
8691	3108	25	to	to	TO
8691	3108	26	lessen	lessen	VB
8691	3108	27	the	the	DT
8691	3108	28	value	value	NN
8691	3108	29	of	of	IN
8691	3108	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3108	31	reports	report	NNS
8691	3108	32	out	out	IN
8691	3108	33	of	of	IN
8691	3108	34	the	the	DT
8691	3108	35	State	State	NNP
8691	3108	36	in	in	IN
8691	3108	37	which	which	WDT
8691	3108	38	the	the	DT
8691	3108	39	cases	case	NNS
8691	3108	40	were	be	VBD
8691	3108	41	decided	decide	VBN
8691	3108	42	.	.	.
8691	3109	1	Each	each	DT
8691	3109	2	of	of	IN
8691	3109	3	forty	forty	CD
8691	3109	4	-	-	HYPH
8691	3109	5	five	five	CD
8691	3109	6	different	different	JJ
8691	3109	7	commonwealths	commonwealth	NNS
8691	3109	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	3109	9	building	build	VBG
8691	3109	10	upon	upon	IN
8691	3109	11	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3109	12	foundations	foundation	NNS
8691	3109	13	that	that	WDT
8691	3109	14	are	be	VBP
8691	3109	15	not	not	RB
8691	3109	16	dissimilar	dissimilar	JJ
8691	3109	17	,	,	,
8691	3109	18	but	but	CC
8691	3109	19	some	some	DT
8691	3109	20	of	of	IN
8691	3109	21	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3109	22	are	be	VBP
8691	3109	23	advancing	advance	VBG
8691	3109	24	far	far	RB
8691	3109	25	faster	fast	RBR
8691	3109	26	than	than	IN
8691	3109	27	others	other	NNS
8691	3109	28	,	,	,
8691	3109	29	and	and	CC
8691	3109	30	none	none	NN
8691	3109	31	proceed	proceed	VB
8691	3109	32	at	at	IN
8691	3109	33	exactly	exactly	RB
8691	3109	34	the	the	DT
8691	3109	35	same	same	JJ
8691	3109	36	rate	rate	NN
8691	3109	37	or	or	CC
8691	3109	38	on	on	IN
8691	3109	39	exactly	exactly	RB
8691	3109	40	the	the	DT
8691	3109	41	same	same	JJ
8691	3109	42	lines	line	NNS
8691	3109	43	.	.	.
8691	3110	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3110	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3110	3	building	build	VBG
8691	3110	4	by	by	IN
8691	3110	5	statute	statute	NN
8691	3110	6	,	,	,
8691	3110	7	by	by	IN
8691	3110	8	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3110	9	usage	usage	NN
8691	3110	10	and	and	CC
8691	3110	11	by	by	IN
8691	3110	12	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3110	13	decision	decision	NN
8691	3110	14	.	.	.
8691	3111	1	Heterogeneity	heterogeneity	NN
8691	3111	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3111	3	most	most	RBS
8691	3111	4	marked	mark	VBN
8691	3111	5	in	in	IN
8691	3111	6	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	3111	7	and	and	CC
8691	3111	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3111	9	tells	tell	VBZ
8691	3111	10	most	most	RBS
8691	3111	11	there	there	RB
8691	3111	12	.	.	.
8691	3112	1	Whoever	whoever	WP
8691	3112	2	looks	look	VBZ
8691	3112	3	over	over	IN
8691	3112	4	a	a	DT
8691	3112	5	volume	volume	NN
8691	3112	6	of	of	IN
8691	3112	7	reports	report	NNS
8691	3112	8	will	will	MD
8691	3112	9	find	find	VB
8691	3112	10	a	a	DT
8691	3112	11	large	large	JJ
8691	3112	12	proportion	proportion	NN
8691	3112	13	of	of	IN
8691	3112	14	the	the	DT
8691	3112	15	cases	case	NNS
8691	3112	16	turning	turn	VBG
8691	3112	17	upon	upon	IN
8691	3112	18	some	some	DT
8691	3112	19	local	local	JJ
8691	3112	20	statute	statute	NN
8691	3112	21	.	.	.
8691	3113	1	An	an	DT
8691	3113	2	important	important	JJ
8691	3113	3	index	index	NN
8691	3113	4	title	title	NN
8691	3113	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3113	6	that	that	DT
8691	3113	7	of	of	IN
8691	3113	8	"	"	``
8691	3113	9	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	3113	10	Cited	cite	VBN
8691	3113	11	and	and	CC
8691	3113	12	Expounded	expound	VBN
8691	3113	13	.	.	.
8691	3113	14	"	"	''
8691	3114	1	In	in	IN
8691	3114	2	Vol	Vol	NNP
8691	3114	3	.	.	.
8691	3115	1	138	138	CD
8691	3115	2	,	,	,
8691	3115	3	for	for	IN
8691	3115	4	instance	instance	NN
8691	3115	5	,	,	,
8691	3115	6	of	of	IN
8691	3115	7	the	the	DT
8691	3115	8	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3115	9	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3115	10	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3115	11	a	a	DT
8691	3115	12	volume	volume	NN
8691	3115	13	selected	select	VBN
8691	3115	14	at	at	IN
8691	3115	15	random	random	JJ
8691	3115	16	for	for	IN
8691	3115	17	this	this	DT
8691	3115	18	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	3115	19	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3115	20	,	,	,
8691	3115	21	223	223	CD
8691	3115	22	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	3115	23	or	or	CC
8691	3115	24	sections	section	NNS
8691	3115	25	of	of	IN
8691	3115	26	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	3115	27	are	be	VBP
8691	3115	28	noted	note	VBN
8691	3115	29	as	as	IN
8691	3115	30	having	have	VBG
8691	3115	31	been	be	VBN
8691	3115	32	made	make	VBN
8691	3115	33	the	the	DT
8691	3115	34	subject	subject	NN
8691	3115	35	of	of	IN
8691	3115	36	remark	remark	NN
8691	3115	37	in	in	IN
8691	3115	38	the	the	DT
8691	3115	39	170	170	CD
8691	3115	40	cases	case	NNS
8691	3115	41	which	which	WDT
8691	3115	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3115	43	contains	contain	VBZ
8691	3115	44	.	.	.
8691	3116	1	Almost	almost	RB
8691	3116	2	all	all	DT
8691	3116	3	are	be	VBP
8691	3116	4	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3116	5	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	3116	6	,	,	,
8691	3116	7	a	a	DT
8691	3116	8	very	very	RB
8691	3116	9	small	small	JJ
8691	3116	10	proportion	proportion	NN
8691	3116	11	of	of	IN
8691	3116	12	which	which	WDT
8691	3116	13	have	have	VBP
8691	3116	14	been	be	VBN
8691	3116	15	re	re	VBN
8691	3116	16	-	-	VBN
8691	3116	17	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	3116	18	elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
8691	3116	19	.	.	.
8691	3117	1	Appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3117	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	3117	3	thus	thus	RB
8691	3117	4	forced	force	VBD
8691	3117	5	at	at	IN
8691	3117	6	every	every	DT
8691	3117	7	turn	turn	NN
8691	3117	8	to	to	TO
8691	3117	9	study	study	VB
8691	3117	10	with	with	IN
8691	3117	11	care	care	NN
8691	3117	12	into	into	IN
8691	3117	13	the	the	DT
8691	3117	14	effect	effect	NN
8691	3117	15	of	of	IN
8691	3117	16	local	local	JJ
8691	3117	17	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	3117	18	,	,	,
8691	3117	19	much	much	JJ
8691	3117	20	of	of	IN
8691	3117	21	which	which	WDT
8691	3117	22	,	,	,
8691	3117	23	to	to	TO
8691	3117	24	get	get	VB
8691	3117	25	at	at	IN
8691	3117	26	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3117	27	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	3117	28	,	,	,
8691	3117	29	must	must	MD
8691	3117	30	be	be	VB
8691	3117	31	traced	trace	VBN
8691	3117	32	back	back	RB
8691	3117	33	historically	historically	RB
8691	3117	34	through	through	IN
8691	3117	35	various	various	JJ
8691	3117	36	changes	change	NNS
8691	3117	37	during	during	IN
8691	3117	38	a	a	DT
8691	3117	39	long	long	JJ
8691	3117	40	course	course	NN
8691	3117	41	of	of	IN
8691	3117	42	years	year	NNS
8691	3117	43	,	,	,
8691	3117	44	and	and	CC
8691	3117	45	in	in	IN
8691	3117	46	the	the	DT
8691	3117	47	older	old	JJR
8691	3117	48	States	States	NNP
8691	3117	49	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3117	50	for	for	IN
8691	3117	51	centuries	century	NNS
8691	3117	52	,	,	,
8691	3117	53	listen	listen	VB
8691	3117	54	unwillingly	unwillingly	RB
8691	3117	55	to	to	IN
8691	3117	56	citations	citation	NNS
8691	3117	57	from	from	IN
8691	3117	58	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	3117	59	of	of	IN
8691	3117	60	other	other	JJ
8691	3117	61	States	state	NNS
8691	3117	62	which	which	WDT
8691	3117	63	are	be	VBP
8691	3117	64	even	even	RB
8691	3117	65	remotely	remotely	RB
8691	3117	66	affected	affect	VBN
8691	3117	67	by	by	IN
8691	3117	68	the	the	DT
8691	3117	69	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	3117	70	that	that	WDT
8691	3117	71	may	may	MD
8691	3117	72	be	be	VB
8691	3117	73	there	there	RB
8691	3117	74	in	in	IN
8691	3117	75	force	force	NN
8691	3117	76	.	.	.
8691	3118	1	The	the	DT
8691	3118	2	newer	new	JJR
8691	3118	3	States	States	NNPS
8691	3118	4	and	and	CC
8691	3118	5	those	those	DT
8691	3118	6	with	with	IN
8691	3118	7	a	a	DT
8691	3118	8	small	small	JJ
8691	3118	9	population	population	NN
8691	3118	10	are	be	VBP
8691	3118	11	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	3118	12	the	the	DT
8691	3118	13	ones	one	NNS
8691	3118	14	that	that	WDT
8691	3118	15	rely	rely	VBP
8691	3118	16	most	most	RBS
8691	3118	17	on	on	IN
8691	3118	18	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	3118	19	authority	authority	NN
8691	3118	20	.	.	.
8691	3119	1	In	in	IN
8691	3119	2	the	the	DT
8691	3119	3	last	last	JJ
8691	3119	4	volume	volume	NN
8691	3119	5	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3119	6	Vol	Vol	NNP
8691	3119	7	.	.	.
8691	3120	1	26	26	CD
8691	3120	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3120	3	of	of	IN
8691	3120	4	the	the	DT
8691	3120	5	Nevada	Nevada	NNP
8691	3120	6	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3120	7	,	,	,
8691	3120	8	sixty	sixty	CD
8691	3120	9	-	-	HYPH
8691	3120	10	two	two	CD
8691	3120	11	per	per	NN
8691	3120	12	cent	cent	NN
8691	3120	13	,	,	,
8691	3120	14	of	of	IN
8691	3120	15	the	the	DT
8691	3120	16	cases	case	NNS
8691	3120	17	cited	cite	VBN
8691	3120	18	in	in	IN
8691	3120	19	the	the	DT
8691	3120	20	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3120	21	of	of	IN
8691	3120	22	the	the	DT
8691	3120	23	court	court	NN
8691	3120	24	are	be	VBP
8691	3120	25	of	of	IN
8691	3120	26	that	that	DT
8691	3120	27	kind	kind	NN
8691	3120	28	.	.	.
8691	3121	1	In	in	IN
8691	3121	2	the	the	DT
8691	3121	3	last	last	JJ
8691	3121	4	volume	volume	NN
8691	3121	5	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3121	6	Vol	Vol	NNP
8691	3121	7	.	.	.
8691	3122	1	178	178	LS
8691	3122	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3122	3	of	of	IN
8691	3122	4	the	the	DT
8691	3122	5	New	New	NNP
8691	3122	6	York	York	NNP
8691	3122	7	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3122	8	,	,	,
8691	3122	9	the	the	DT
8691	3122	10	percentage	percentage	NN
8691	3122	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	3122	12	but	but	CC
8691	3122	13	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	3122	14	,	,	,
8691	3122	15	and	and	CC
8691	3122	16	in	in	IN
8691	3122	17	the	the	DT
8691	3122	18	last	last	JJ
8691	3122	19	of	of	IN
8691	3122	20	the	the	DT
8691	3122	21	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3122	22	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3122	23	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3122	24	Vol	Vol	NNP
8691	3122	25	.	.	.
8691	3123	1	185	185	LS
8691	3123	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3123	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3123	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3123	5	only	only	RB
8691	3123	6	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3123	7	-	-	HYPH
8691	3123	8	five	five	CD
8691	3123	9	.	.	.
8691	3124	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3124	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3124	3	:	:	:
8691	3124	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3124	5	Law	Law	NNP
8691	3124	6	Notes	Notes	NNPS
8691	3124	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3124	8	for	for	IN
8691	3124	9	April	April	NNP
8691	3124	10	,	,	,
8691	3124	11	1905	1905	CD
8691	3124	12	,	,	,
8691	3124	13	8	8	CD
8691	3124	14	.	.	.
8691	3124	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3125	1	*	*	NFP
8691	3125	2	*	*	NFP
8691	3125	3	*	*	NFP
8691	3125	4	*	*	NFP
8691	3125	5	*	*	NFP
8691	3125	6	In	in	IN
8691	3125	7	the	the	DT
8691	3125	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3125	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3125	10	of	of	IN
8691	3125	11	the	the	DT
8691	3125	12	United	United	NNP
8691	3125	13	States	States	NNP
8691	3125	14	and	and	CC
8691	3125	15	in	in	IN
8691	3125	16	several	several	JJ
8691	3125	17	of	of	IN
8691	3125	18	the	the	DT
8691	3125	19	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3125	20	courts	court	NNS
8691	3125	21	of	of	IN
8691	3125	22	the	the	DT
8691	3125	23	larger	large	JJR
8691	3125	24	States	States	NNP
8691	3125	25	each	each	DT
8691	3125	26	judge	judge	NN
8691	3125	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	3125	28	provided	provide	VBN
8691	3125	29	with	with	IN
8691	3125	30	a	a	DT
8691	3125	31	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	3125	32	at	at	IN
8691	3125	33	public	public	JJ
8691	3125	34	expense	expense	NN
8691	3125	35	.	.	.
8691	3126	1	While	while	IN
8691	3126	2	this	this	DT
8691	3126	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3126	4	a	a	DT
8691	3126	5	means	means	NN
8691	3126	6	of	of	IN
8691	3126	7	relief	relief	NN
8691	3126	8	from	from	IN
8691	3126	9	much	much	JJ
8691	3126	10	which	which	WDT
8691	3126	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	3126	12	in	in	IN
8691	3126	13	the	the	DT
8691	3126	14	nature	nature	NN
8691	3126	15	of	of	IN
8691	3126	16	drudgery	drudgery	NN
8691	3126	17	,	,	,
8691	3126	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3126	19	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3126	20	leads	lead	VBZ
8691	3126	21	to	to	IN
8691	3126	22	a	a	DT
8691	3126	23	deterioration	deterioration	NN
8691	3126	24	in	in	IN
8691	3126	25	the	the	DT
8691	3126	26	quality	quality	NN
8691	3126	27	of	of	IN
8691	3126	28	the	the	DT
8691	3126	29	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3126	30	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3126	31	.	.	.
8691	3127	1	A	a	DT
8691	3127	2	dictated	dictated	JJ
8691	3127	3	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3127	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3127	5	apt	apt	JJ
8691	3127	6	to	to	TO
8691	3127	7	be	be	VB
8691	3127	8	unnecessarily	unnecessarily	RB
8691	3127	9	long	long	JJ
8691	3127	10	,	,	,
8691	3127	11	and	and	CC
8691	3127	12	when	when	WRB
8691	3127	13	a	a	DT
8691	3127	14	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	3127	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	3127	16	set	set	VBN
8691	3127	17	to	to	IN
8691	3127	18	looking	look	VBG
8691	3127	19	up	up	RP
8691	3127	20	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	3127	21	,	,	,
8691	3127	22	although	although	IN
8691	3127	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3127	24	can	can	MD
8691	3127	25	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	3127	26	be	be	VB
8691	3127	27	expected	expect	VBN
8691	3127	28	always	always	RB
8691	3127	29	to	to	TO
8691	3127	30	select	select	VB
8691	3127	31	the	the	DT
8691	3127	32	most	most	RBS
8691	3127	33	apposite	apposite	JJ
8691	3127	34	,	,	,
8691	3127	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3127	36	is	be	VBZ
8691	3127	37	easier	easy	JJR
8691	3127	38	to	to	TO
8691	3127	39	accept	accept	VB
8691	3127	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3127	41	work	work	NN
8691	3127	42	and	and	CC
8691	3127	43	use	use	VB
8691	3127	44	what	what	WP
8691	3127	45	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3127	46	has	have	VBZ
8691	3127	47	gathered	gather	VBN
8691	3127	48	than	than	IN
8691	3127	49	to	to	TO
8691	3127	50	institute	institute	VB
8691	3127	51	an	an	DT
8691	3127	52	independent	independent	JJ
8691	3127	53	search	search	NN
8691	3127	54	.	.	.
8691	3128	1	Some	some	DT
8691	3128	2	of	of	IN
8691	3128	3	the	the	DT
8691	3128	4	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3128	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	3128	6	which	which	WDT
8691	3128	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3128	8	most	most	RBS
8691	3128	9	fully	fully	RB
8691	3128	10	employed	employ	VBN
8691	3128	11	,	,	,
8691	3128	12	both	both	CC
8691	3128	13	State	State	NNP
8691	3128	14	and	and	CC
8691	3128	15	federal	federal	JJ
8691	3128	16	,	,	,
8691	3128	17	are	be	VBP
8691	3128	18	provided	provide	VBN
8691	3128	19	with	with	IN
8691	3128	20	special	special	JJ
8691	3128	21	libraries	library	NNS
8691	3128	22	of	of	IN
8691	3128	23	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	3128	24	extent	extent	NN
8691	3128	25	,	,	,
8691	3128	26	and	and	CC
8691	3128	27	each	each	DT
8691	3128	28	of	of	IN
8691	3128	29	the	the	DT
8691	3128	30	individual	individual	JJ
8691	3128	31	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3128	32	is	be	VBZ
8691	3128	33	also	also	RB
8691	3128	34	often	often	RB
8691	3128	35	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	3128	36	with	with	IN
8691	3128	37	an	an	DT
8691	3128	38	official	official	JJ
8691	3128	39	library	library	NN
8691	3128	40	,	,	,
8691	3128	41	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3128	42	containing	contain	VBG
8691	3128	43	several	several	JJ
8691	3128	44	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	3128	45	volumes	volume	NNS
8691	3128	46	,	,	,
8691	3128	47	for	for	IN
8691	3128	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3128	49	personal	personal	JJ
8691	3128	50	use	use	NN
8691	3128	51	,	,	,
8691	3128	52	to	to	TO
8691	3128	53	be	be	VB
8691	3128	54	handed	hand	VBN
8691	3128	55	over	over	RP
8691	3128	56	to	to	IN
8691	3128	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3128	58	successor	successor	NN
8691	3128	59	when	when	WRB
8691	3128	60	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3128	61	retires	retire	VBZ
8691	3128	62	from	from	IN
8691	3128	63	office	office	NN
8691	3128	64	.	.	.
8691	3129	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3129	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3129	3	:	:	:
8691	3129	4	In	in	IN
8691	3129	5	New	New	NNP
8691	3129	6	York	York	NNP
8691	3129	7	,	,	,
8691	3129	8	the	the	DT
8691	3129	9	private	private	JJ
8691	3129	10	library	library	NN
8691	3129	11	of	of	IN
8691	3129	12	the	the	DT
8691	3129	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3129	14	of	of	IN
8691	3129	15	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	3129	16	contains	contain	VBZ
8691	3129	17	over	over	IN
8691	3129	18	6,000	6,000	CD
8691	3129	19	volumes	volume	NNS
8691	3129	20	,	,	,
8691	3129	21	comprehending	comprehend	VBG
8691	3129	22	all	all	PDT
8691	3129	23	the	the	DT
8691	3129	24	reports	report	NNS
8691	3129	25	of	of	IN
8691	3129	26	all	all	PDT
8691	3129	27	the	the	DT
8691	3129	28	States	States	NNPS
8691	3129	29	,	,	,
8691	3129	30	and	and	CC
8691	3129	31	the	the	DT
8691	3129	32	personal	personal	JJ
8691	3129	33	libraries	library	NNS
8691	3129	34	provided	provide	VBN
8691	3129	35	for	for	IN
8691	3129	36	each	each	DT
8691	3129	37	judge	judge	NN
8691	3129	38	have	have	VBP
8691	3129	39	come	come	VBN
8691	3129	40	to	to	TO
8691	3129	41	comprise	comprise	VB
8691	3129	42	3,500	3,500	CD
8691	3129	43	volumes	volume	NNS
8691	3129	44	.	.	.
8691	3129	45	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3130	1	In	in	IN
8691	3130	2	some	some	DT
8691	3130	3	States	States	NNP
8691	3130	4	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	3130	5	have	have	VBP
8691	3130	6	the	the	DT
8691	3130	7	right	right	NN
8691	3130	8	to	to	TO
8691	3130	9	demand	demand	VB
8691	3130	10	to	to	TO
8691	3130	11	be	be	VB
8691	3130	12	heard	hear	VBN
8691	3130	13	before	before	IN
8691	3130	14	a	a	DT
8691	3130	15	full	full	JJ
8691	3130	16	court	court	NN
8691	3130	17	,	,	,
8691	3130	18	and	and	CC
8691	3130	19	those	those	DT
8691	3130	20	who	who	WP
8691	3130	21	have	have	VBP
8691	3130	22	taken	take	VBN
8691	3130	23	the	the	DT
8691	3130	24	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	3130	25	generally	generally	RB
8691	3130	26	exercise	exercise	VBP
8691	3130	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3130	28	.	.	.
8691	3131	1	As	as	IN
8691	3131	2	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	3131	3	go	go	VBP
8691	3131	4	by	by	IN
8691	3131	5	majorities	majority	NNS
8691	3131	6	,	,	,
8691	3131	7	the	the	DT
8691	3131	8	chance	chance	NN
8691	3131	9	of	of	IN
8691	3131	10	reversing	reverse	VBG
8691	3131	11	a	a	DT
8691	3131	12	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3131	13	before	before	RB
8691	3131	14	,	,	,
8691	3131	15	for	for	IN
8691	3131	16	instance	instance	NN
8691	3131	17	,	,	,
8691	3131	18	a	a	DT
8691	3131	19	court	court	NN
8691	3131	20	of	of	IN
8691	3131	21	five	five	CD
8691	3131	22	,	,	,
8691	3131	23	which	which	WDT
8691	3131	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	3131	25	a	a	DT
8691	3131	26	common	common	JJ
8691	3131	27	number	number	NN
8691	3131	28	,	,	,
8691	3131	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	3131	30	obviously	obviously	RB
8691	3131	31	greater	great	JJR
8691	3131	32	when	when	WRB
8691	3131	33	all	all	DT
8691	3131	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3131	35	members	member	NNS
8691	3131	36	sit	sit	VBP
8691	3131	37	than	than	IN
8691	3131	38	when	when	WRB
8691	3131	39	four	four	CD
8691	3131	40	do	do	NN
8691	3131	41	.	.	.
8691	3132	1	In	in	IN
8691	3132	2	either	either	DT
8691	3132	3	case	case	NN
8691	3132	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3132	5	must	must	MD
8691	3132	6	be	be	VB
8691	3132	7	the	the	DT
8691	3132	8	act	act	NN
8691	3132	9	of	of	IN
8691	3132	10	three	three	CD
8691	3132	11	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3132	12	,	,	,
8691	3132	13	and	and	CC
8691	3132	14	one	one	CD
8691	3132	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	3132	16	more	more	RBR
8691	3132	17	likely	likely	JJ
8691	3132	18	to	to	TO
8691	3132	19	convince	convince	VB
8691	3132	20	three	three	CD
8691	3132	21	out	out	IN
8691	3132	22	of	of	IN
8691	3132	23	five	five	CD
8691	3132	24	than	than	IN
8691	3132	25	three	three	CD
8691	3132	26	out	out	IN
8691	3132	27	of	of	IN
8691	3132	28	four	four	CD
8691	3132	29	.	.	.
8691	3133	1	In	in	IN
8691	3133	2	the	the	DT
8691	3133	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3133	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3133	5	of	of	IN
8691	3133	6	the	the	DT
8691	3133	7	United	United	NNP
8691	3133	8	States	States	NNP
8691	3133	9	there	there	EX
8691	3133	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	3133	11	no	no	DT
8691	3133	12	means	means	NN
8691	3133	13	of	of	IN
8691	3133	14	supplying	supply	VBG
8691	3133	15	the	the	DT
8691	3133	16	place	place	NN
8691	3133	17	of	of	IN
8691	3133	18	a	a	DT
8691	3133	19	judge	judge	NN
8691	3133	20	who	who	WP
8691	3133	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	3133	22	absent	absent	JJ
8691	3133	23	or	or	CC
8691	3133	24	disqualified	disqualify	VBN
8691	3133	25	.	.	.
8691	3134	1	The	the	DT
8691	3134	2	remaining	remain	VBG
8691	3134	3	members	member	NNS
8691	3134	4	,	,	,
8691	3134	5	provided	provide	VBN
8691	3134	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3134	7	constitute	constitute	VBP
8691	3134	8	a	a	DT
8691	3134	9	quorum	quorum	NN
8691	3134	10	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3134	11	that	that	RB
8691	3134	12	is	is	RB
8691	3134	13	,	,	,
8691	3134	14	a	a	DT
8691	3134	15	majority	majority	NN
8691	3134	16	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3134	17	,	,	,
8691	3134	18	proceed	proceed	VB
8691	3134	19	without	without	IN
8691	3134	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3134	21	.	.	.
8691	3135	1	In	in	IN
8691	3135	2	most	most	JJS
8691	3135	3	of	of	IN
8691	3135	4	the	the	DT
8691	3135	5	States	States	NNPS
8691	3135	6	there	there	EX
8691	3135	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3135	8	some	some	DT
8691	3135	9	provision	provision	NN
8691	3135	10	for	for	IN
8691	3135	11	filling	fill	VBG
8691	3135	12	the	the	DT
8691	3135	13	vacancy	vacancy	NN
8691	3135	14	in	in	IN
8691	3135	15	such	such	PDT
8691	3135	16	a	a	DT
8691	3135	17	contingency	contingency	NN
8691	3135	18	.	.	.
8691	3136	1	Sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3136	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3136	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3136	4	by	by	IN
8691	3136	5	calling	call	VBG
8691	3136	6	in	in	IN
8691	3136	7	a	a	DT
8691	3136	8	judge	judge	NN
8691	3136	9	of	of	IN
8691	3136	10	an	an	DT
8691	3136	11	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3136	12	court	court	NN
8691	3136	13	;	;	:
8691	3136	14	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3136	15	by	by	IN
8691	3136	16	application	application	NN
8691	3136	17	to	to	IN
8691	3136	18	the	the	DT
8691	3136	19	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3136	20	for	for	IN
8691	3136	21	the	the	DT
8691	3136	22	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	3136	23	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	3136	24	of	of	IN
8691	3136	25	some	some	DT
8691	3136	26	member	member	NN
8691	3136	27	of	of	IN
8691	3136	28	the	the	DT
8691	3136	29	bar	bar	NN
8691	3136	30	as	as	IN
8691	3136	31	a	a	DT
8691	3136	32	special	special	JJ
8691	3136	33	associate	associate	NN
8691	3136	34	justice	justice	NN
8691	3136	35	to	to	TO
8691	3136	36	sit	sit	VB
8691	3136	37	in	in	IN
8691	3136	38	a	a	DT
8691	3136	39	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3136	40	case	case	NN
8691	3136	41	.	.	.
8691	3137	1	In	in	IN
8691	3137	2	several	several	JJ
8691	3137	3	of	of	IN
8691	3137	4	the	the	DT
8691	3137	5	larger	large	JJR
8691	3137	6	States	state	NNS
8691	3137	7	all	all	PDT
8691	3137	8	the	the	DT
8691	3137	9	members	member	NNS
8691	3137	10	of	of	IN
8691	3137	11	the	the	DT
8691	3137	12	court	court	NN
8691	3137	13	of	of	IN
8691	3137	14	last	last	JJ
8691	3137	15	resort	resort	NN
8691	3137	16	do	do	VBP
8691	3137	17	not	not	RB
8691	3137	18	and	and	CC
8691	3137	19	need	nee	MD
8691	3137	20	not	not	RB
8691	3137	21	sit	sit	VB
8691	3137	22	in	in	IN
8691	3137	23	every	every	DT
8691	3137	24	case	case	NN
8691	3137	25	.	.	.
8691	3138	1	In	in	IN
8691	3138	2	some	some	DT
8691	3138	3	two	two	CD
8691	3138	4	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	3138	5	divisions	division	NNS
8691	3138	6	are	be	VBP
8691	3138	7	constituted	constitute	VBN
8691	3138	8	,	,	,
8691	3138	9	to	to	IN
8691	3138	10	each	each	DT
8691	3138	11	of	of	IN
8691	3138	12	which	which	WDT
8691	3138	13	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3138	14	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3138	15	are	be	VBP
8691	3138	16	assigned	assign	VBN
8691	3138	17	,	,	,
8691	3138	18	and	and	CC
8691	3138	19	both	both	DT
8691	3138	20	divisions	division	NNS
8691	3138	21	may	may	MD
8691	3138	22	be	be	VB
8691	3138	23	in	in	IN
8691	3138	24	session	session	NN
8691	3138	25	at	at	IN
8691	3138	26	the	the	DT
8691	3138	27	same	same	JJ
8691	3138	28	time	time	NN
8691	3138	29	.	.	.
8691	3139	1	In	in	IN
8691	3139	2	other	other	JJ
8691	3139	3	States	state	NNS
8691	3139	4	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3139	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3139	6	are	be	VBP
8691	3139	7	detached	detach	VBN
8691	3139	8	for	for	IN
8691	3139	9	a	a	DT
8691	3139	10	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3139	11	time	time	NN
8691	3139	12	,	,	,
8691	3139	13	during	during	IN
8691	3139	14	which	which	WDT
8691	3139	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3139	16	study	study	VBP
8691	3139	17	causes	cause	NNS
8691	3139	18	which	which	WDT
8691	3139	19	have	have	VBP
8691	3139	20	been	be	VBN
8691	3139	21	argued	argue	VBN
8691	3139	22	and	and	CC
8691	3139	23	prepare	prepare	VB
8691	3139	24	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3139	25	.	.	.
8691	3140	1	This	this	DT
8691	3140	2	done	do	VBN
8691	3140	3	,	,	,
8691	3140	4	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3140	5	resume	resume	VBP
8691	3140	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3140	7	seats	seat	NNS
8691	3140	8	,	,	,
8691	3140	9	and	and	CC
8691	3140	10	others	other	NNS
8691	3140	11	are	be	VBP
8691	3140	12	released	release	VBN
8691	3140	13	for	for	IN
8691	3140	14	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3140	15	duties	duty	NNS
8691	3140	16	.	.	.
8691	3141	1	In	in	IN
8691	3141	2	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	3141	3	,	,	,
8691	3141	4	for	for	IN
8691	3141	5	instance	instance	NN
8691	3141	6	,	,	,
8691	3141	7	the	the	DT
8691	3141	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3141	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3141	10	consists	consist	VBZ
8691	3141	11	of	of	IN
8691	3141	12	six	six	CD
8691	3141	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3141	14	and	and	CC
8691	3141	15	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	3141	16	sits	sit	VBZ
8691	3141	17	in	in	IN
8691	3141	18	two	two	CD
8691	3141	19	divisions	division	NNS
8691	3141	20	of	of	IN
8691	3141	21	three	three	CD
8691	3141	22	each	each	DT
8691	3141	23	,	,	,
8691	3141	24	having	have	VBG
8691	3141	25	equal	equal	JJ
8691	3141	26	authority	authority	NN
8691	3141	27	.	.	.
8691	3142	1	The	the	DT
8691	3142	2	whole	whole	JJ
8691	3142	3	court	court	NN
8691	3142	4	sits	sit	VBZ
8691	3142	5	to	to	TO
8691	3142	6	hear	hear	VB
8691	3142	7	any	any	DT
8691	3142	8	cause	cause	NN
8691	3142	9	involving	involve	VBG
8691	3142	10	a	a	DT
8691	3142	11	point	point	NN
8691	3142	12	of	of	IN
8691	3142	13	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3142	14	law	law	NN
8691	3142	15	.	.	.
8691	3143	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3143	2	also	also	RB
8691	3143	3	decides	decide	VBZ
8691	3143	4	those	those	DT
8691	3143	5	which	which	WDT
8691	3143	6	have	have	VBP
8691	3143	7	been	be	VBN
8691	3143	8	heard	hear	VBN
8691	3143	9	in	in	IN
8691	3143	10	one	one	CD
8691	3143	11	of	of	IN
8691	3143	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3143	13	divisions	division	NNS
8691	3143	14	and	and	CC
8691	3143	15	in	in	IN
8691	3143	16	which	which	WDT
8691	3143	17	the	the	DT
8691	3143	18	divisional	divisional	JJ
8691	3143	19	court	court	NN
8691	3143	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	3143	21	in	in	IN
8691	3143	22	favor	favor	NN
8691	3143	23	of	of	IN
8691	3143	24	reversing	reverse	VBG
8691	3143	25	the	the	DT
8691	3143	26	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3143	27	appealed	appeal	VBD
8691	3143	28	from	from	IN
8691	3143	29	.	.	.
8691	3144	1	An	an	DT
8691	3144	2	affirmance	affirmance	NN
8691	3144	3	by	by	IN
8691	3144	4	the	the	DT
8691	3144	5	divisional	divisional	JJ
8691	3144	6	court	court	NN
8691	3144	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3144	8	final	final	JJ
8691	3144	9	,	,	,
8691	3144	10	but	but	CC
8691	3144	11	if	if	IN
8691	3144	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3144	13	inclines	incline	VBZ
8691	3144	14	to	to	IN
8691	3144	15	a	a	DT
8691	3144	16	reversal	reversal	NN
8691	3144	17	the	the	DT
8691	3144	18	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3144	19	communicate	communicate	VBP
8691	3144	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3144	21	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3144	22	to	to	IN
8691	3144	23	the	the	DT
8691	3144	24	full	full	JJ
8691	3144	25	court	court	NN
8691	3144	26	,	,	,
8691	3144	27	which	which	WDT
8691	3144	28	also	also	RB
8691	3144	29	reads	read	VBZ
8691	3144	30	the	the	DT
8691	3144	31	printed	print	VBN
8691	3144	32	briefs	brief	NNS
8691	3144	33	submitted	submit	VBD
8691	3144	34	on	on	IN
8691	3144	35	the	the	DT
8691	3144	36	original	original	JJ
8691	3144	37	argument	argument	NN
8691	3144	38	,	,	,
8691	3144	39	and	and	CC
8691	3144	40	then	then	RB
8691	3144	41	without	without	IN
8691	3144	42	any	any	DT
8691	3144	43	further	further	JJ
8691	3144	44	oral	oral	JJ
8691	3144	45	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	3144	46	pronounces	pronounce	VBZ
8691	3144	47	final	final	JJ
8691	3144	48	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3144	49	.	.	.
8691	3145	1	Four	four	CD
8691	3145	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3145	3	,	,	,
8691	3145	4	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	3145	5	,	,	,
8691	3145	6	at	at	IN
8691	3145	7	least	least	JJS
8691	3145	8	,	,	,
8691	3145	9	must	must	MD
8691	3145	10	concur	concur	VB
8691	3145	11	to	to	TO
8691	3145	12	accomplish	accomplish	VB
8691	3145	13	a	a	DT
8691	3145	14	reversal	reversal	NN
8691	3145	15	.	.	.
8691	3146	1	Should	Should	MD
8691	3146	2	the	the	DT
8691	3146	3	full	full	JJ
8691	3146	4	court	court	NN
8691	3146	5	in	in	IN
8691	3146	6	any	any	DT
8691	3146	7	case	case	NN
8691	3146	8	be	be	VB
8691	3146	9	equally	equally	RB
8691	3146	10	divided	divide	VBN
8691	3146	11	,	,	,
8691	3146	12	the	the	DT
8691	3146	13	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3146	14	appealed	appeal	VBD
8691	3146	15	from	from	IN
8691	3146	16	stands	stand	NNS
8691	3146	17	.	.	.
8691	3147	1	Under	under	IN
8691	3147	2	the	the	DT
8691	3147	3	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3147	4	of	of	IN
8691	3147	5	California	California	NNP
8691	3147	6	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3147	7	Art	art	NN
8691	3147	8	.	.	.
8691	3148	1	VI	VI	NNP
8691	3148	2	,	,	,
8691	3148	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	3148	4	.	.	.
8691	3149	1	2	2	LS
8691	3149	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3149	3	the	the	DT
8691	3149	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3149	5	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3149	6	,	,	,
8691	3149	7	which	which	WDT
8691	3149	8	consists	consist	VBZ
8691	3149	9	of	of	IN
8691	3149	10	seven	seven	CD
8691	3149	11	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3149	12	,	,	,
8691	3149	13	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	3149	14	sits	sit	VBZ
8691	3149	15	in	in	IN
8691	3149	16	two	two	CD
8691	3149	17	departments	department	NNS
8691	3149	18	.	.	.
8691	3150	1	Three	three	CD
8691	3150	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3150	3	can	can	MD
8691	3150	4	render	render	VB
8691	3150	5	a	a	DT
8691	3150	6	decision	decision	NN
8691	3150	7	,	,	,
8691	3150	8	but	but	CC
8691	3150	9	the	the	DT
8691	3150	10	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3150	11	does	do	VBZ
8691	3150	12	not	not	RB
8691	3150	13	go	go	VB
8691	3150	14	into	into	IN
8691	3150	15	full	full	JJ
8691	3150	16	effect	effect	NN
8691	3150	17	for	for	IN
8691	3150	18	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	3150	19	days	day	NNS
8691	3150	20	unless	unless	IN
8691	3150	21	three	three	CD
8691	3150	22	,	,	,
8691	3150	23	including	include	VBG
8691	3150	24	the	the	DT
8691	3150	25	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3150	26	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3150	27	,	,	,
8691	3150	28	have	have	VBP
8691	3150	29	given	give	VBN
8691	3150	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3150	31	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3150	32	approval	approval	NN
8691	3150	33	.	.	.
8691	3151	1	The	the	DT
8691	3151	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3151	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3151	4	also	also	RB
8691	3151	5	,	,	,
8691	3151	6	with	with	IN
8691	3151	7	the	the	DT
8691	3151	8	concurrence	concurrence	NN
8691	3151	9	of	of	IN
8691	3151	10	two	two	CD
8691	3151	11	of	of	IN
8691	3151	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3151	13	associates	associate	NNS
8691	3151	14	,	,	,
8691	3151	15	or	or	CC
8691	3151	16	four	four	CD
8691	3151	17	of	of	IN
8691	3151	18	these	these	DT
8691	3151	19	without	without	IN
8691	3151	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3151	21	concurrence	concurrence	NN
8691	3151	22	,	,	,
8691	3151	23	can	can	MD
8691	3151	24	direct	direct	VB
8691	3151	25	that	that	IN
8691	3151	26	any	any	DT
8691	3151	27	cause	cause	NN
8691	3151	28	be	be	VB
8691	3151	29	heard	hear	VBN
8691	3151	30	before	before	IN
8691	3151	31	a	a	DT
8691	3151	32	full	full	JJ
8691	3151	33	court	court	NN
8691	3151	34	within	within	IN
8691	3151	35	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	3151	36	days	day	NNS
8691	3151	37	after	after	IN
8691	3151	38	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3151	39	by	by	IN
8691	3151	40	a	a	DT
8691	3151	41	department	department	NN
8691	3151	42	court	court	NN
8691	3151	43	.	.	.
8691	3152	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3152	2	can	can	MD
8691	3152	3	also	also	RB
8691	3152	4	order	order	VB
8691	3152	5	the	the	DT
8691	3152	6	removal	removal	NN
8691	3152	7	into	into	IN
8691	3152	8	the	the	DT
8691	3152	9	full	full	JJ
8691	3152	10	court	court	NN
8691	3152	11	of	of	IN
8691	3152	12	any	any	DT
8691	3152	13	cause	cause	NN
8691	3152	14	before	before	IN
8691	3152	15	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3152	16	.	.	.
8691	3153	1	In	in	IN
8691	3153	2	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
8691	3153	3	only	only	RB
8691	3153	4	five	five	CD
8691	3153	5	out	out	IN
8691	3153	6	of	of	IN
8691	3153	7	the	the	DT
8691	3153	8	eight	eight	CD
8691	3153	9	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3153	10	sit	sit	VBP
8691	3153	11	to	to	TO
8691	3153	12	hear	hear	VB
8691	3153	13	a	a	DT
8691	3153	14	case	case	NN
8691	3153	15	,	,	,
8691	3153	16	and	and	CC
8691	3153	17	if	if	IN
8691	3153	18	one	one	CD
8691	3153	19	of	of	IN
8691	3153	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3153	21	files	file	VBZ
8691	3153	22	an	an	DT
8691	3153	23	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3153	24	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	3153	25	from	from	IN
8691	3153	26	that	that	DT
8691	3153	27	of	of	IN
8691	3153	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3153	29	associates	associate	NNS
8691	3153	30	,	,	,
8691	3153	31	the	the	DT
8691	3153	32	losing	lose	VBG
8691	3153	33	party	party	NN
8691	3153	34	can	can	MD
8691	3153	35	demand	demand	VB
8691	3153	36	a	a	DT
8691	3153	37	rehearing	rehearing	NN
8691	3153	38	before	before	IN
8691	3153	39	the	the	DT
8691	3153	40	full	full	JJ
8691	3153	41	court	court	NN
8691	3153	42	.	.	.
8691	3154	1	Neither	neither	CC
8691	3154	2	the	the	DT
8691	3154	3	bar	bar	NN
8691	3154	4	nor	nor	CC
8691	3154	5	the	the	DT
8691	3154	6	bench	bench	NN
8691	3154	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3154	8	quite	quite	RB
8691	3154	9	satisfied	satisfied	JJ
8691	3154	10	with	with	IN
8691	3154	11	such	such	JJ
8691	3154	12	methods	method	NNS
8691	3154	13	of	of	IN
8691	3154	14	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3154	15	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	3154	16	.	.	.
8691	3155	1	The	the	DT
8691	3155	2	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	3155	3	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	3155	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3155	5	excellently	excellently	RB
8691	3155	6	adapted	adapt	VBN
8691	3155	7	for	for	IN
8691	3155	8	the	the	DT
8691	3155	9	dispatch	dispatch	NN
8691	3155	10	of	of	IN
8691	3155	11	business	business	NN
8691	3155	12	,	,	,
8691	3155	13	but	but	CC
8691	3155	14	may	may	MD
8691	3155	15	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	3155	16	an	an	DT
8691	3155	17	oral	oral	JJ
8691	3155	18	argument	argument	NN
8691	3155	19	before	before	IN
8691	3155	20	those	those	DT
8691	3155	21	who	who	WP
8691	3155	22	are	be	VBP
8691	3155	23	ultimately	ultimately	RB
8691	3155	24	to	to	TO
8691	3155	25	decide	decide	VB
8691	3155	26	the	the	DT
8691	3155	27	cause	cause	NN
8691	3155	28	.	.	.
8691	3156	1	That	that	DT
8691	3156	2	of	of	IN
8691	3156	3	California	California	NNP
8691	3156	4	often	often	RB
8691	3156	5	protracts	protract	VBZ
8691	3156	6	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	3156	7	.	.	.
8691	3157	1	Any	any	DT
8691	3157	2	such	such	JJ
8691	3157	3	plan	plan	NN
8691	3157	4	of	of	IN
8691	3157	5	division	division	NN
8691	3157	6	also	also	RB
8691	3157	7	must	must	MD
8691	3157	8	increase	increase	VB
8691	3157	9	the	the	DT
8691	3157	10	risk	risk	NN
8691	3157	11	of	of	IN
8691	3157	12	the	the	DT
8691	3157	13	court	court	NN
8691	3157	14	's	be	VBZ
8691	3157	15	taking	take	VBG
8691	3157	16	a	a	DT
8691	3157	17	position	position	NN
8691	3157	18	inconsistent	inconsistent	JJ
8691	3157	19	with	with	IN
8691	3157	20	one	one	CD
8691	3157	21	which	which	WDT
8691	3157	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3157	23	had	have	VBD
8691	3157	24	previously	previously	RB
8691	3157	25	assumed	assume	VBN
8691	3157	26	.	.	.
8691	3158	1	The	the	DT
8691	3158	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3158	3	in	in	IN
8691	3158	4	one	one	CD
8691	3158	5	division	division	NN
8691	3158	6	may	may	MD
8691	3158	7	come	come	VB
8691	3158	8	to	to	IN
8691	3158	9	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	3158	10	different	different	JJ
8691	3158	11	from	from	IN
8691	3158	12	those	those	DT
8691	3158	13	reached	reach	VBN
8691	3158	14	in	in	IN
8691	3158	15	the	the	DT
8691	3158	16	other	other	JJ
8691	3158	17	division	division	NN
8691	3158	18	;	;	:
8691	3158	19	or	or	CC
8691	3158	20	where	where	WRB
8691	3158	21	the	the	DT
8691	3158	22	court	court	NN
8691	3158	23	does	do	VBZ
8691	3158	24	not	not	RB
8691	3158	25	sit	sit	VB
8691	3158	26	in	in	IN
8691	3158	27	divisions	division	NNS
8691	3158	28	,	,	,
8691	3158	29	a	a	DT
8691	3158	30	point	point	NN
8691	3158	31	may	may	MD
8691	3158	32	be	be	VB
8691	3158	33	determined	determine	VBN
8691	3158	34	by	by	IN
8691	3158	35	a	a	DT
8691	3158	36	narrow	narrow	JJ
8691	3158	37	majority	majority	NN
8691	3158	38	in	in	IN
8691	3158	39	one	one	CD
8691	3158	40	case	case	NN
8691	3158	41	which	which	WDT
8691	3158	42	in	in	IN
8691	3158	43	a	a	DT
8691	3158	44	later	later	JJ
8691	3158	45	one	one	CD
8691	3158	46	,	,	,
8691	3158	47	through	through	IN
8691	3158	48	the	the	DT
8691	3158	49	substitution	substitution	NN
8691	3158	50	of	of	IN
8691	3158	51	one	one	CD
8691	3158	52	or	or	CC
8691	3158	53	two	two	CD
8691	3158	54	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3158	55	for	for	IN
8691	3158	56	those	those	DT
8691	3158	57	who	who	WP
8691	3158	58	heard	hear	VBD
8691	3158	59	the	the	DT
8691	3158	60	former	former	JJ
8691	3158	61	,	,	,
8691	3158	62	may	may	MD
8691	3158	63	be	be	VB
8691	3158	64	ruled	rule	VBN
8691	3158	65	the	the	DT
8691	3158	66	other	other	JJ
8691	3158	67	way	way	NN
8691	3158	68	.	.	.
8691	3159	1	The	the	DT
8691	3159	2	freedom	freedom	NN
8691	3159	3	of	of	IN
8691	3159	4	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	3159	5	which	which	WDT
8691	3159	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3159	7	generally	generally	RB
8691	3159	8	conceded	concede	VBN
8691	3159	9	to	to	IN
8691	3159	10	defeated	defeat	VBN
8691	3159	11	litigants	litigant	NNS
8691	3159	12	in	in	IN
8691	3159	13	this	this	DT
8691	3159	14	country	country	NN
8691	3159	15	has	have	VBZ
8691	3159	16	been	be	VBN
8691	3159	17	made	make	VBN
8691	3159	18	the	the	DT
8691	3159	19	subject	subject	NN
8691	3159	20	of	of	IN
8691	3159	21	severe	severe	JJ
8691	3159	22	criticism	criticism	NN
8691	3159	23	.	.	.
8691	3160	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3160	2	seems	seem	VBZ
8691	3160	3	,	,	,
8691	3160	4	however	however	RB
8691	3160	5	,	,	,
8691	3160	6	a	a	DT
8691	3160	7	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	3160	8	incident	incident	NN
8691	3160	9	of	of	IN
8691	3160	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3160	11	political	political	JJ
8691	3160	12	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	3160	13	.	.	.
8691	3161	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3161	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3161	3	built	build	VBN
8691	3161	4	upon	upon	IN
8691	3161	5	the	the	DT
8691	3161	6	foundation	foundation	NN
8691	3161	7	of	of	IN
8691	3161	8	a	a	DT
8691	3161	9	profound	profound	JJ
8691	3161	10	reverence	reverence	NN
8691	3161	11	for	for	IN
8691	3161	12	the	the	DT
8691	3161	13	rights	right	NNS
8691	3161	14	of	of	IN
8691	3161	15	the	the	DT
8691	3161	16	individual	individual	NN
8691	3161	17	and	and	CC
8691	3161	18	of	of	IN
8691	3161	19	the	the	DT
8691	3161	20	equality	equality	NN
8691	3161	21	of	of	IN
8691	3161	22	all	all	DT
8691	3161	23	before	before	IN
8691	3161	24	the	the	DT
8691	3161	25	law	law	NN
8691	3161	26	.	.	.
8691	3162	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3162	2	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	3162	3	guaranty	guaranty	NN
8691	3162	4	every	every	DT
8691	3162	5	man	man	NN
8691	3162	6	against	against	IN
8691	3162	7	deprivation	deprivation	NN
8691	3162	8	of	of	IN
8691	3162	9	life	life	NN
8691	3162	10	,	,	,
8691	3162	11	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	3162	12	or	or	CC
8691	3162	13	property	property	NN
8691	3162	14	without	without	IN
8691	3162	15	due	due	JJ
8691	3162	16	process	process	NN
8691	3162	17	of	of	IN
8691	3162	18	law	law	NN
8691	3162	19	.	.	.
8691	3163	1	If	if	IN
8691	3163	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3163	3	could	could	MD
8691	3163	4	count	count	VB
8691	3163	5	on	on	IN
8691	3163	6	having	have	VBG
8691	3163	7	as	as	IN
8691	3163	8	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3163	9	of	of	IN
8691	3163	10	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3163	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	3163	12	courts	court	NNS
8691	3163	13	none	none	NN
8691	3163	14	but	but	CC
8691	3163	15	men	man	NNS
8691	3163	16	of	of	IN
8691	3163	17	ability	ability	NN
8691	3163	18	,	,	,
8691	3163	19	learning	learning	NN
8691	3163	20	and	and	CC
8691	3163	21	independence	independence	NN
8691	3163	22	,	,	,
8691	3163	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3163	24	might	may	MD
8691	3163	25	be	be	VB
8691	3163	26	safe	safe	JJ
8691	3163	27	to	to	TO
8691	3163	28	leave	leave	VB
8691	3163	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3163	30	to	to	IN
8691	3163	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3163	32	to	to	TO
8691	3163	33	say	say	VB
8691	3163	34	what	what	WP
8691	3163	35	this	this	DT
8691	3163	36	due	due	JJ
8691	3163	37	process	process	NN
8691	3163	38	was	be	VBD
8691	3163	39	.	.	.
8691	3164	1	But	but	CC
8691	3164	2	the	the	DT
8691	3164	3	tenure	tenure	NN
8691	3164	4	of	of	IN
8691	3164	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3164	6	office	office	NN
8691	3164	7	in	in	IN
8691	3164	8	most	most	JJS
8691	3164	9	States	States	NNPS
8691	3164	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	3164	11	too	too	RB
8691	3164	12	brief	brief	JJ
8691	3164	13	,	,	,
8691	3164	14	the	the	DT
8691	3164	15	pay	pay	NN
8691	3164	16	too	too	RB
8691	3164	17	meagre	meagre	JJ
8691	3164	18	,	,	,
8691	3164	19	and	and	CC
8691	3164	20	the	the	DT
8691	3164	21	mode	mode	NN
8691	3164	22	of	of	IN
8691	3164	23	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	3164	24	too	too	RB
8691	3164	25	subject	subject	JJ
8691	3164	26	to	to	IN
8691	3164	27	political	political	JJ
8691	3164	28	influence	influence	NN
8691	3164	29	to	to	TO
8691	3164	30	give	give	VB
8691	3164	31	always	always	RB
8691	3164	32	that	that	DT
8691	3164	33	assurance	assurance	NN
8691	3164	34	that	that	WDT
8691	3164	35	could	could	MD
8691	3164	36	be	be	VB
8691	3164	37	wished	wish	VBN
8691	3164	38	either	either	RB
8691	3164	39	of	of	IN
8691	3164	40	the	the	DT
8691	3164	41	independence	independence	NN
8691	3164	42	of	of	IN
8691	3164	43	the	the	DT
8691	3164	44	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	3164	45	or	or	CC
8691	3164	46	of	of	IN
8691	3164	47	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3164	48	representing	represent	VBG
8691	3164	49	only	only	RB
8691	3164	50	what	what	WP
8691	3164	51	is	be	VBZ
8691	3164	52	best	good	JJS
8691	3164	53	in	in	IN
8691	3164	54	the	the	DT
8691	3164	55	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3164	56	profession	profession	NN
8691	3164	57	.	.	.
8691	3165	1	In	in	IN
8691	3165	2	England	England	NNP
8691	3165	3	,	,	,
8691	3165	4	until	until	IN
8691	3165	5	recently	recently	RB
8691	3165	6	,	,	,
8691	3165	7	there	there	EX
8691	3165	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3165	9	little	little	JJ
8691	3165	10	or	or	CC
8691	3165	11	no	no	UH
8691	3165	12	right	right	NN
8691	3165	13	of	of	IN
8691	3165	14	review	review	NN
8691	3165	15	in	in	IN
8691	3165	16	favor	favor	NN
8691	3165	17	of	of	IN
8691	3165	18	one	one	CD
8691	3165	19	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	3165	20	of	of	IN
8691	3165	21	crime	crime	NN
8691	3165	22	.	.	.
8691	3166	1	But	but	CC
8691	3166	2	the	the	DT
8691	3166	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3166	4	are	be	VBP
8691	3166	5	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3166	6	for	for	IN
8691	3166	7	life	life	NN
8691	3166	8	on	on	IN
8691	3166	9	ample	ample	JJ
8691	3166	10	salaries	salary	NNS
8691	3166	11	,	,	,
8691	3166	12	and	and	CC
8691	3166	13	tradition	tradition	NN
8691	3166	14	requires	require	VBZ
8691	3166	15	that	that	IN
8691	3166	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3166	17	be	be	VB
8691	3166	18	selected	select	VBN
8691	3166	19	only	only	RB
8691	3166	20	from	from	IN
8691	3166	21	among	among	IN
8691	3166	22	the	the	DT
8691	3166	23	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	3166	24	at	at	IN
8691	3166	25	the	the	DT
8691	3166	26	bar	bar	NN
8691	3166	27	.	.	.
8691	3167	1	Nor	nor	CC
8691	3167	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3167	3	the	the	DT
8691	3167	4	right	right	NN
8691	3167	5	of	of	IN
8691	3167	6	the	the	DT
8691	3167	7	individual	individual	NN
8691	3167	8	against	against	IN
8691	3167	9	the	the	DT
8691	3167	10	State	State	NNP
8691	3167	11	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	3167	12	so	so	RB
8691	3167	13	sacred	sacred	JJ
8691	3167	14	under	under	IN
8691	3167	15	English	English	NNP
8691	3167	16	as	as	IN
8691	3167	17	under	under	IN
8691	3167	18	American	american	JJ
8691	3167	19	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	3167	20	.	.	.
8691	3168	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3168	2	can	can	MD
8691	3168	3	not	not	RB
8691	3168	4	be	be	VB
8691	3168	5	in	in	IN
8691	3168	6	any	any	DT
8691	3168	7	country	country	NN
8691	3168	8	where	where	WRB
8691	3168	9	an	an	DT
8691	3168	10	hereditary	hereditary	JJ
8691	3168	11	aristocracy	aristocracy	NN
8691	3168	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	3168	13	from	from	IN
8691	3168	14	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	3168	15	times	time	NNS
8691	3168	16	had	have	VBD
8691	3168	17	a	a	DT
8691	3168	18	share	share	NN
8691	3168	19	in	in	IN
8691	3168	20	government	government	NN
8691	3168	21	.	.	.
8691	3169	1	As	as	IN
8691	3169	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	3169	3	been	be	VBN
8691	3169	4	seen	see	VBN
8691	3169	5	,	,	,
8691	3169	6	the	the	DT
8691	3169	7	English	english	JJ
8691	3169	8	practice	practice	NN
8691	3169	9	in	in	IN
8691	3169	10	this	this	DT
8691	3169	11	respect	respect	NN
8691	3169	12	for	for	IN
8691	3169	13	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	3169	14	a	a	DT
8691	3169	15	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3169	16	years	year	NNS
8691	3169	17	was	be	VBD
8691	3169	18	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	3169	19	in	in	IN
8691	3169	20	the	the	DT
8691	3169	21	courts	court	NNS
8691	3169	22	of	of	IN
8691	3169	23	the	the	DT
8691	3169	24	United	United	NNP
8691	3169	25	States	States	NNP
8691	3169	26	,	,	,
8691	3169	27	but	but	CC
8691	3169	28	public	public	JJ
8691	3169	29	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	3169	30	finally	finally	RB
8691	3169	31	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	3169	32	against	against	IN
8691	3169	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3169	34	.	.	.
8691	3170	1	Much	much	RB
8691	3170	2	less	less	JJR
8691	3170	3	could	could	MD
8691	3170	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3170	5	be	be	VB
8691	3170	6	safely	safely	RB
8691	3170	7	followed	follow	VBN
8691	3170	8	in	in	IN
8691	3170	9	the	the	DT
8691	3170	10	States	States	NNP
8691	3170	11	,	,	,
8691	3170	12	where	where	WRB
8691	3170	13	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3170	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	3170	15	are	be	VBP
8691	3170	16	often	often	RB
8691	3170	17	held	hold	VBN
8691	3170	18	by	by	IN
8691	3170	19	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3170	20	of	of	IN
8691	3170	21	little	little	JJ
8691	3170	22	ability	ability	NN
8691	3170	23	,	,	,
8691	3170	24	less	less	RBR
8691	3170	25	learning	learning	NN
8691	3170	26	,	,	,
8691	3170	27	and	and	CC
8691	3170	28	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3170	29	standing	standing	NN
8691	3170	30	at	at	IN
8691	3170	31	the	the	DT
8691	3170	32	bar	bar	NN
8691	3170	33	,	,	,
8691	3170	34	to	to	TO
8691	3170	35	which	which	WDT
8691	3170	36	,	,	,
8691	3170	37	after	after	IN
8691	3170	38	the	the	DT
8691	3170	39	expiration	expiration	NN
8691	3170	40	of	of	IN
8691	3170	41	a	a	DT
8691	3170	42	brief	brief	JJ
8691	3170	43	term	term	NN
8691	3170	44	,	,	,
8691	3170	45	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	3170	46	of	of	IN
8691	3170	47	but	but	CC
8691	3170	48	a	a	DT
8691	3170	49	year	year	NN
8691	3170	50	,	,	,
8691	3170	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3170	52	will	will	MD
8691	3170	53	return	return	VB
8691	3170	54	should	should	MD
8691	3170	55	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3170	56	fail	fail	VB
8691	3170	57	to	to	TO
8691	3170	58	secure	secure	VB
8691	3170	59	a	a	DT
8691	3170	60	party	party	NN
8691	3170	61	renomination	renomination	NN
8691	3170	62	.	.	.
8691	3171	1	The	the	DT
8691	3171	2	same	same	JJ
8691	3171	3	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	3171	4	,	,	,
8691	3171	5	if	if	IN
8691	3171	6	in	in	IN
8691	3171	7	less	less	JJR
8691	3171	8	degree	degree	NN
8691	3171	9	,	,	,
8691	3171	10	support	support	VBP
8691	3171	11	a	a	DT
8691	3171	12	liberal	liberal	JJ
8691	3171	13	right	right	NN
8691	3171	14	of	of	IN
8691	3171	15	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	3171	16	in	in	IN
8691	3171	17	cases	case	NNS
8691	3171	18	involving	involve	VBG
8691	3171	19	property	property	NN
8691	3171	20	only	only	RB
8691	3171	21	,	,	,
8691	3171	22	and	and	CC
8691	3171	23	oppose	oppose	VB
8691	3171	24	restrictions	restriction	NNS
8691	3171	25	based	base	VBN
8691	3171	26	only	only	RB
8691	3171	27	on	on	IN
8691	3171	28	the	the	DT
8691	3171	29	amount	amount	NN
8691	3171	30	in	in	IN
8691	3171	31	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	3171	32	.	.	.
8691	3172	1	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	3172	2	could	could	MD
8691	3172	3	never	never	RB
8691	3172	4	tolerate	tolerate	VB
8691	3172	5	keeping	keep	VBG
8691	3172	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3172	7	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3172	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	3172	9	for	for	IN
8691	3172	10	the	the	DT
8691	3172	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	3172	12	of	of	IN
8691	3172	13	large	large	JJ
8691	3172	14	causes	cause	NNS
8691	3172	15	only	only	RB
8691	3172	16	.	.	.
8691	3173	1	There	there	EX
8691	3173	2	must	must	MD
8691	3173	3	be	be	VB
8691	3173	4	no	no	DT
8691	3173	5	rich	rich	JJ
8691	3173	6	men	man	NNS
8691	3173	7	's	's	POS
8691	3173	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	3173	9	.	.	.
8691	3174	1	There	there	EX
8691	3174	2	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	3174	3	must	must	MD
8691	3174	4	be	be	VB
8691	3174	5	none	none	NN
8691	3174	6	to	to	TO
8691	3174	7	which	which	WDT
8691	3174	8	a	a	DT
8691	3174	9	claim	claim	NN
8691	3174	10	of	of	IN
8691	3174	11	right	right	NN
8691	3174	12	founded	found	VBN
8691	3174	13	on	on	IN
8691	3174	14	a	a	DT
8691	3174	15	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3174	16	provision	provision	NN
8691	3174	17	can	can	MD
8691	3174	18	not	not	RB
8691	3174	19	be	be	VB
8691	3174	20	carried	carry	VBN
8691	3174	21	up	up	RP
8691	3174	22	,	,	,
8691	3174	23	however	however	RB
8691	3174	24	trifling	trifle	VBG
8691	3174	25	in	in	IN
8691	3174	26	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
8691	3174	27	value	value	NN
8691	3174	28	may	may	MD
8691	3174	29	be	be	VB
8691	3174	30	the	the	DT
8691	3174	31	matter	matter	NN
8691	3174	32	in	in	IN
8691	3174	33	demand	demand	NN
8691	3174	34	.	.	.
8691	3175	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	3175	2	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	3175	3	fail	fail	VBP
8691	3175	4	.	.	.
8691	3176	1	There	there	EX
8691	3176	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3176	3	few	few	JJ
8691	3176	4	in	in	IN
8691	3176	5	which	which	WDT
8691	3176	6	the	the	DT
8691	3176	7	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	3176	8	who	who	WP
8691	3176	9	takes	take	VBZ
8691	3176	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3176	11	are	be	VBP
8691	3176	12	fully	fully	RB
8691	3176	13	confident	confident	JJ
8691	3176	14	of	of	IN
8691	3176	15	success	success	NN
8691	3176	16	.	.	.
8691	3177	1	Every	every	DT
8691	3177	2	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	3177	3	of	of	IN
8691	3177	4	large	large	JJ
8691	3177	5	experience	experience	NN
8691	3177	6	knows	know	VBZ
8691	3177	7	that	that	IN
8691	3177	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3177	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	3177	10	often	often	RB
8691	3177	11	won	win	VBN
8691	3177	12	when	when	WRB
8691	3177	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3177	14	expected	expect	VBD
8691	3177	15	to	to	TO
8691	3177	16	lose	lose	VB
8691	3177	17	,	,	,
8691	3177	18	and	and	CC
8691	3177	19	lost	lose	VBN
8691	3177	20	when	when	WRB
8691	3177	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3177	22	expected	expect	VBD
8691	3177	23	to	to	TO
8691	3177	24	prevail	prevail	VB
8691	3177	25	.	.	.
8691	3178	1	There	there	EX
8691	3178	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3178	3	not	not	RB
8691	3178	4	many	many	JJ
8691	3178	5	cases	case	NNS
8691	3178	6	involving	involve	VBG
8691	3178	7	large	large	JJ
8691	3178	8	pecuniary	pecuniary	JJ
8691	3178	9	interests	interest	NNS
8691	3178	10	or	or	CC
8691	3178	11	strong	strong	JJ
8691	3178	12	personal	personal	JJ
8691	3178	13	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	3178	14	that	that	WDT
8691	3178	15	are	be	VBP
8691	3178	16	not	not	RB
8691	3178	17	appealed	appeal	VBN
8691	3178	18	if	if	IN
8691	3178	19	there	there	EX
8691	3178	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	3178	21	any	any	DT
8691	3178	22	color	color	NN
8691	3178	23	for	for	IN
8691	3178	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3178	25	.	.	.
8691	3179	1	The	the	DT
8691	3179	2	proportion	proportion	NN
8691	3179	3	of	of	IN
8691	3179	4	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	3179	5	which	which	WDT
8691	3179	6	are	be	VBP
8691	3179	7	successful	successful	JJ
8691	3179	8	will	will	MD
8691	3179	9	generally	generally	RB
8691	3179	10	be	be	VB
8691	3179	11	not	not	RB
8691	3179	12	far	far	RB
8691	3179	13	from	from	IN
8691	3179	14	a	a	DT
8691	3179	15	third	third	NN
8691	3179	16	of	of	IN
8691	3179	17	the	the	DT
8691	3179	18	whole	whole	JJ
8691	3179	19	number	number	NN
8691	3179	20	taken	take	VBN
8691	3179	21	.	.	.
8691	3180	1	Of	of	RB
8691	3180	2	course	course	RB
8691	3180	3	,	,	,
8691	3180	4	however	however	RB
8691	3180	5	,	,	,
8691	3180	6	this	this	DT
8691	3180	7	must	must	MD
8691	3180	8	depend	depend	VB
8691	3180	9	largely	largely	RB
8691	3180	10	on	on	IN
8691	3180	11	the	the	DT
8691	3180	12	competency	competency	NN
8691	3180	13	of	of	IN
8691	3180	14	the	the	DT
8691	3180	15	trial	trial	NN
8691	3180	16	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3180	17	in	in	IN
8691	3180	18	the	the	DT
8691	3180	19	court	court	NN
8691	3180	20	where	where	WRB
8691	3180	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3180	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	3180	23	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	3180	24	that	that	IN
8691	3180	25	errors	error	NNS
8691	3180	26	have	have	VBP
8691	3180	27	occurred	occur	VBN
8691	3180	28	.	.	.
8691	3181	1	The	the	DT
8691	3181	2	abler	abler	NN
8691	3181	3	and	and	CC
8691	3181	4	more	more	RBR
8691	3181	5	experienced	experience	VBD
8691	3181	6	those	those	DT
8691	3181	7	who	who	WP
8691	3181	8	do	do	VBP
8691	3181	9	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	3181	10	duty	duty	NN
8691	3181	11	may	may	MD
8691	3181	12	be	be	VB
8691	3181	13	,	,	,
8691	3181	14	the	the	DT
8691	3181	15	oftener	oftener	NN
8691	3181	16	will	will	MD
8691	3181	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3181	18	doings	doing	NNS
8691	3181	19	be	be	VB
8691	3181	20	supported	support	VBN
8691	3181	21	in	in	IN
8691	3181	22	the	the	DT
8691	3181	23	court	court	NN
8691	3181	24	of	of	IN
8691	3181	25	last	last	JJ
8691	3181	26	resort	resort	NN
8691	3181	27	.	.	.
8691	3182	1	Short	short	JJ
8691	3182	2	terms	term	NNS
8691	3182	3	of	of	IN
8691	3182	4	office	office	NN
8691	3182	5	and	and	CC
8691	3182	6	consequent	consequent	NN
8691	3182	7	lack	lack	NN
8691	3182	8	of	of	IN
8691	3182	9	practical	practical	JJ
8691	3182	10	acquaintance	acquaintance	NN
8691	3182	11	with	with	IN
8691	3182	12	the	the	DT
8691	3182	13	business	business	NN
8691	3182	14	of	of	IN
8691	3182	15	a	a	DT
8691	3182	16	trial	trial	NN
8691	3182	17	judge	judge	NN
8691	3182	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	3182	19	the	the	DT
8691	3182	20	real	real	JJ
8691	3182	21	cause	cause	NN
8691	3182	22	why	why	WRB
8691	3182	23	so	so	RB
8691	3182	24	many	many	JJ
8691	3182	25	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	3182	26	are	be	VBP
8691	3182	27	taken	take	VBN
8691	3182	28	,	,	,
8691	3182	29	and	and	CC
8691	3182	30	are	be	VBP
8691	3182	31	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	3182	32	to	to	TO
8691	3182	33	be	be	VB
8691	3182	34	taken	take	VBN
8691	3182	35	in	in	IN
8691	3182	36	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3182	37	American	American	NNP
8691	3182	38	States	States	NNPS
8691	3182	39	.	.	.
8691	3183	1	As	as	IN
8691	3183	2	for	for	IN
8691	3183	3	the	the	DT
8691	3183	4	federal	federal	JJ
8691	3183	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	3183	6	of	of	IN
8691	3183	7	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	3183	8	,	,	,
8691	3183	9	there	there	EX
8691	3183	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	3183	11	another	another	DT
8691	3183	12	and	and	CC
8691	3183	13	unavoidable	unavoidable	JJ
8691	3183	14	occasion	occasion	NN
8691	3183	15	for	for	IN
8691	3183	16	large	large	JJ
8691	3183	17	dockets	docket	NNS
8691	3183	18	.	.	.
8691	3184	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3184	2	have	have	VBP
8691	3184	3	the	the	DT
8691	3184	4	last	last	JJ
8691	3184	5	word	word	NN
8691	3184	6	to	to	IN
8691	3184	7	pronounce	pronounce	NN
8691	3184	8	on	on	IN
8691	3184	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3184	10	questions	question	NNS
8691	3184	11	,	,	,
8691	3184	12	and	and	CC
8691	3184	13	there	there	EX
8691	3184	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	3184	15	probably	probably	RB
8691	3184	16	never	never	RB
8691	3184	17	been	be	VBN
8691	3184	18	a	a	DT
8691	3184	19	year	year	NN
8691	3184	20	since	since	IN
8691	3184	21	the	the	DT
8691	3184	22	United	United	NNP
8691	3184	23	States	States	NNP
8691	3184	24	came	come	VBD
8691	3184	25	into	into	IN
8691	3184	26	existence	existence	NN
8691	3184	27	when	when	WRB
8691	3184	28	the	the	DT
8691	3184	29	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
8691	3184	30	powers	power	NNS
8691	3184	31	of	of	IN
8691	3184	32	the	the	DT
8691	3184	33	general	general	JJ
8691	3184	34	government	government	NN
8691	3184	35	have	have	VBP
8691	3184	36	not	not	RB
8691	3184	37	been	be	VBN
8691	3184	38	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
8691	3184	39	infringed	infringe	VBN
8691	3184	40	upon	upon	IN
8691	3184	41	by	by	IN
8691	3184	42	State	State	NNP
8691	3184	43	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	3184	44	.	.	.
8691	3185	1	In	in	IN
8691	3185	2	the	the	DT
8691	3185	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3185	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3185	5	of	of	IN
8691	3185	6	the	the	DT
8691	3185	7	United	United	NNP
8691	3185	8	States	States	NNP
8691	3185	9	,	,	,
8691	3185	10	the	the	DT
8691	3185	11	reporter	reporter	NN
8691	3185	12	began	begin	VBD
8691	3185	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3185	14	second	second	JJ
8691	3185	15	century	century	NN
8691	3185	16	with	with	IN
8691	3185	17	a	a	DT
8691	3185	18	plan	plan	NN
8691	3185	19	of	of	IN
8691	3185	20	stating	state	VBG
8691	3185	21	the	the	DT
8691	3185	22	number	number	NN
8691	3185	23	of	of	IN
8691	3185	24	cases	case	NNS
8691	3185	25	affirmed	affirm	VBN
8691	3185	26	or	or	CC
8691	3185	27	reversed	reverse	VBN
8691	3185	28	at	at	IN
8691	3185	29	each	each	DT
8691	3185	30	term	term	NN
8691	3185	31	,	,	,
8691	3185	32	but	but	CC
8691	3185	33	dropped	drop	VBD
8691	3185	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3185	35	after	after	IN
8691	3185	36	two	two	CD
8691	3185	37	years	year	NNS
8691	3185	38	.	.	.
8691	3186	1	The	the	DT
8691	3186	2	record	record	NN
8691	3186	3	of	of	IN
8691	3186	4	these	these	DT
8691	3186	5	years	year	NNS
8691	3186	6	was	be	VBD
8691	3186	7	as	as	IN
8691	3186	8	follows	follow	VBZ
8691	3186	9	:	:	:
8691	3186	10	Affirmed	Affirmed	NNP
8691	3186	11	Reversed	Reversed	NNP
8691	3186	12	October	October	NNP
8691	3186	13	Term	Term	NNP
8691	3186	14	,	,	,
8691	3186	15	1890	1890	CD
8691	3186	16	248	248	CD
8691	3186	17	104	104	CD
8691	3186	18	October	October	NNP
8691	3186	19	Term	Term	NNP
8691	3186	20	,	,	,
8691	3186	21	1891	1891	CD
8691	3186	22	185	185	CD
8691	3186	23	103	103	CD
8691	3186	24	A	a	DT
8691	3186	25	tabulation	tabulation	NN
8691	3186	26	of	of	IN
8691	3186	27	the	the	DT
8691	3186	28	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	3186	29	reported	report	VBN
8691	3186	30	in	in	IN
8691	3186	31	the	the	DT
8691	3186	32	various	various	JJ
8691	3186	33	States	state	NNS
8691	3186	34	in	in	IN
8691	3186	35	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3186	36	last	last	JJ
8691	3186	37	volumes	volume	NNS
8691	3186	38	published	publish	VBN
8691	3186	39	prior	prior	RB
8691	3186	40	to	to	IN
8691	3186	41	June	June	NNP
8691	3186	42	,	,	,
8691	3186	43	1904	1904	CD
8691	3186	44	,	,	,
8691	3186	45	shows	show	VBZ
8691	3186	46	that	that	IN
8691	3186	47	on	on	IN
8691	3186	48	a	a	DT
8691	3186	49	general	general	JJ
8691	3186	50	average	average	NN
8691	3186	51	,	,	,
8691	3186	52	in	in	IN
8691	3186	53	sixty	sixty	CD
8691	3186	54	-	-	HYPH
8691	3186	55	three	three	CD
8691	3186	56	out	out	IN
8691	3186	57	of	of	IN
8691	3186	58	every	every	DT
8691	3186	59	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3186	60	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	3186	61	the	the	DT
8691	3186	62	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3186	63	of	of	IN
8691	3186	64	the	the	DT
8691	3186	65	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3186	66	court	court	NN
8691	3186	67	was	be	VBD
8691	3186	68	affirmed	affirm	VBN
8691	3186	69	.	.	.
8691	3187	1	In	in	IN
8691	3187	2	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3187	3	the	the	DT
8691	3187	4	percentage	percentage	NN
8691	3187	5	was	be	VBD
8691	3187	6	eighty	eighty	CD
8691	3187	7	-	-	HYPH
8691	3187	8	seven	seven	CD
8691	3187	9	per	per	IN
8691	3187	10	cent	cent	NN
8691	3187	11	.	.	.
8691	3188	1	In	in	IN
8691	3188	2	Texas	Texas	NNP
8691	3188	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3188	4	was	be	VBD
8691	3188	5	only	only	RB
8691	3188	6	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	3188	7	-	-	HYPH
8691	3188	8	four	four	CD
8691	3188	9	per	per	IN
8691	3188	10	cent	cent	NN
8691	3188	11	.	.	.
8691	3188	12	,	,	,
8691	3188	13	and	and	CC
8691	3188	14	in	in	IN
8691	3188	15	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
8691	3188	16	and	and	CC
8691	3188	17	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	3188	18	not	not	RB
8691	3188	19	much	much	RB
8691	3188	20	over	over	IN
8691	3188	21	forty	forty	CD
8691	3188	22	per	per	IN
8691	3188	23	cent	cent	NN
8691	3188	24	.	.	.
8691	3189	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3189	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3189	3	:	:	:
8691	3189	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3189	5	Law	Law	NNP
8691	3189	6	Notes	Notes	NNPS
8691	3189	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3189	8	for	for	IN
8691	3189	9	June	June	NNP
8691	3189	10	1904	1904	CD
8691	3189	11	,	,	,
8691	3189	12	p.	p.	NN
8691	3190	1	285	285	CD
8691	3190	2	.	.	.
8691	3190	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3191	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	3191	2	more	more	JJR
8691	3191	3	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	3191	4	are	be	VBP
8691	3191	5	taken	take	VBN
8691	3191	6	by	by	IN
8691	3191	7	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	3191	8	persons	person	NNS
8691	3191	9	in	in	IN
8691	3191	10	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3191	11	cases	case	NNS
8691	3191	12	at	at	IN
8691	3191	13	the	the	DT
8691	3191	14	South	South	NNP
8691	3191	15	than	than	IN
8691	3191	16	in	in	IN
8691	3191	17	the	the	DT
8691	3191	18	North	North	NNP
8691	3191	19	.	.	.
8691	3192	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	3192	2	more	more	JJR
8691	3192	3	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3192	4	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	3192	5	are	be	VBP
8691	3192	6	brought	bring	VBN
8691	3192	7	there	there	RB
8691	3192	8	,	,	,
8691	3192	9	in	in	IN
8691	3192	10	proportion	proportion	NN
8691	3192	11	to	to	IN
8691	3192	12	the	the	DT
8691	3192	13	population	population	NN
8691	3192	14	.	.	.
8691	3193	1	This	this	DT
8691	3193	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3193	3	due	due	JJ
8691	3193	4	largely	largely	RB
8691	3193	5	to	to	IN
8691	3193	6	the	the	DT
8691	3193	7	presence	presence	NN
8691	3193	8	of	of	IN
8691	3193	9	so	so	RB
8691	3193	10	large	large	JJ
8691	3193	11	a	a	DT
8691	3193	12	body	body	NN
8691	3193	13	of	of	IN
8691	3193	14	colored	colored	JJ
8691	3193	15	people	people	NNS
8691	3193	16	,	,	,
8691	3193	17	most	most	JJS
8691	3193	18	of	of	IN
8691	3193	19	whom	whom	WP
8691	3193	20	have	have	VBP
8691	3193	21	had	have	VBN
8691	3193	22	a	a	DT
8691	3193	23	very	very	RB
8691	3193	24	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3193	25	education	education	NN
8691	3193	26	and	and	CC
8691	3193	27	training	training	NN
8691	3193	28	.	.	.
8691	3194	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	3194	2	more	more	JJR
8691	3194	3	such	such	JJ
8691	3194	4	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	3194	5	are	be	VBP
8691	3194	6	successful	successful	JJ
8691	3194	7	also	also	RB
8691	3194	8	in	in	IN
8691	3194	9	the	the	DT
8691	3194	10	South	South	NNP
8691	3194	11	than	than	IN
8691	3194	12	in	in	IN
8691	3194	13	the	the	DT
8691	3194	14	North	North	NNP
8691	3194	15	.	.	.
8691	3195	1	In	in	IN
8691	3195	2	the	the	DT
8691	3195	3	reports	report	NNS
8691	3195	4	of	of	IN
8691	3195	5	the	the	DT
8691	3195	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	3195	7	of	of	IN
8691	3195	8	last	last	JJ
8691	3195	9	resort	resort	NN
8691	3195	10	of	of	IN
8691	3195	11	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
8691	3195	12	,	,	,
8691	3195	13	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	3195	14	,	,	,
8691	3195	15	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	3195	16	and	and	CC
8691	3195	17	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	3195	18	between	between	IN
8691	3195	19	December	December	NNP
8691	3195	20	20	20	CD
8691	3195	21	,	,	,
8691	3195	22	1902	1902	CD
8691	3195	23	,	,	,
8691	3195	24	and	and	CC
8691	3195	25	April	April	NNP
8691	3195	26	25	25	CD
8691	3195	27	,	,	,
8691	3195	28	1903,[Footnote	1903,[footnote	CD
8691	3195	29	:	:	:
8691	3195	30	As	as	IN
8691	3195	31	given	give	VBN
8691	3195	32	in	in	IN
8691	3195	33	Vol	Vol	NNP
8691	3195	34	.	.	.
8691	3196	1	XXXIII	XXXIII	NNP
8691	3196	2	of	of	IN
8691	3196	3	the	the	DT
8691	3196	4	Southern	Southern	NNP
8691	3196	5	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	3196	6	.	.	.
8691	3196	7	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3197	1	ninety	ninety	CD
8691	3197	2	-	-	HYPH
8691	3197	3	four	four	CD
8691	3197	4	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3197	5	cases	case	NNS
8691	3197	6	appear	appear	VBP
8691	3197	7	,	,	,
8691	3197	8	in	in	IN
8691	3197	9	forty	forty	CD
8691	3197	10	-	-	HYPH
8691	3197	11	six	six	CD
8691	3197	12	of	of	IN
8691	3197	13	which	which	WDT
8691	3197	14	the	the	DT
8691	3197	15	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3197	16	of	of	IN
8691	3197	17	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	3197	18	was	be	VBD
8691	3197	19	set	set	VBN
8691	3197	20	aside	aside	RB
8691	3197	21	.	.	.
8691	3198	1	In	in	IN
8691	3198	2	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3198	3	,	,	,
8691	3198	4	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
8691	3198	5	,	,	,
8691	3198	6	Maine	Maine	NNP
8691	3198	7	,	,	,
8691	3198	8	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	3198	9	,	,	,
8691	3198	10	New	New	NNP
8691	3198	11	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	3198	12	,	,	,
8691	3198	13	New	New	NNP
8691	3198	14	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	3198	15	,	,	,
8691	3198	16	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3198	17	,	,	,
8691	3198	18	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	3198	19	Island	Island	NNP
8691	3198	20	and	and	CC
8691	3198	21	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
8691	3198	22	between	between	IN
8691	3198	23	March	March	NNP
8691	3198	24	12	12	CD
8691	3198	25	and	and	CC
8691	3198	26	June	June	NNP
8691	3198	27	25	25	CD
8691	3198	28	,	,	,
8691	3198	29	1903,[Footnote	1903,[footnote	CD
8691	3198	30	:	:	:
8691	3198	31	As	as	IN
8691	3198	32	given	give	VBN
8691	3198	33	in	in	IN
8691	3198	34	Vol	Vol	NNP
8691	3198	35	.	.	.
8691	3199	1	LIV	LIV	NNP
8691	3199	2	of	of	IN
8691	3199	3	the	the	DT
8691	3199	4	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	3199	5	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	3199	6	.	.	.
8691	3199	7	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3200	1	the	the	DT
8691	3200	2	reports	report	NNS
8691	3200	3	show	show	VBP
8691	3200	4	only	only	RB
8691	3200	5	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3200	6	such	such	JJ
8691	3200	7	cases	case	NNS
8691	3200	8	,	,	,
8691	3200	9	of	of	IN
8691	3200	10	which	which	WDT
8691	3200	11	seven	seven	CD
8691	3200	12	were	be	VBD
8691	3200	13	set	set	VBN
8691	3200	14	aside	aside	RB
8691	3200	15	.	.	.
8691	3201	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3201	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3201	3	:	:	:
8691	3201	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3201	5	Law	Law	NNP
8691	3201	6	Notes	Notes	NNPS
8691	3201	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3201	8	for	for	IN
8691	3201	9	September	September	NNP
8691	3201	10	,	,	,
8691	3201	11	1903	1903	CD
8691	3201	12	,	,	,
8691	3201	13	105	105	CD
8691	3201	14	.	.	.
8691	3201	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3202	1	This	this	DT
8691	3202	2	would	would	MD
8691	3202	3	seem	seem	VB
8691	3202	4	to	to	TO
8691	3202	5	indicate	indicate	VB
8691	3202	6	either	either	CC
8691	3202	7	that	that	IN
8691	3202	8	the	the	DT
8691	3202	9	trial	trial	NN
8691	3202	10	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3202	11	of	of	IN
8691	3202	12	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3202	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	3202	14	in	in	IN
8691	3202	15	the	the	DT
8691	3202	16	Gulf	Gulf	NNP
8691	3202	17	States	States	NNPS
8691	3202	18	are	be	VBP
8691	3202	19	careless	careless	JJ
8691	3202	20	or	or	CC
8691	3202	21	that	that	IN
8691	3202	22	the	the	DT
8691	3202	23	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3202	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	3202	25	there	there	RB
8691	3202	26	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3202	27	under	under	IN
8691	3202	28	the	the	DT
8691	3202	29	pressure	pressure	NN
8691	3202	30	,	,	,
8691	3202	31	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	3202	32	,	,	,
8691	3202	33	of	of	IN
8691	3202	34	unwise	unwise	JJ
8691	3202	35	statutes)[Footnote	statutes)[Footnote	NNP
8691	3202	36	:	:	:
8691	3202	37	See	see	VB
8691	3202	38	Paper	paper	NN
8691	3202	39	on	on	IN
8691	3202	40	"	"	``
8691	3202	41	Judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3202	42	Independence	independence	NN
8691	3202	43	,	,	,
8691	3202	44	"	"	''
8691	3202	45	by	by	IN
8691	3202	46	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3202	47	Henry	Henry	NNP
8691	3202	48	B.	B.	NNP
8691	3203	1	Brown	Brown	NNP
8691	3203	2	in	in	IN
8691	3203	3	the	the	DT
8691	3203	4	Reports	report	NNS
8691	3203	5	of	of	IN
8691	3203	6	the	the	DT
8691	3203	7	Am	Am	NNP
8691	3203	8	.	.	.
8691	3204	1	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	3204	2	Association	Association	NNP
8691	3204	3	for	for	IN
8691	3204	4	1889	1889	CD
8691	3204	5	,	,	,
8691	3204	6	265	265	CD
8691	3204	7	.	.	.
8691	3204	8	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3205	1	are	be	VBP
8691	3205	2	inclined	inclined	JJ
8691	3205	3	to	to	TO
8691	3205	4	be	be	VB
8691	3205	5	too	too	RB
8691	3205	6	technical	technical	JJ
8691	3205	7	.	.	.
8691	3206	1	If	if	IN
8691	3206	2	either	either	CC
8691	3206	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3206	4	true	true	JJ
8691	3206	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3206	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3206	7	a	a	DT
8691	3206	8	just	just	RB
8691	3206	9	cause	cause	NN
8691	3206	10	for	for	IN
8691	3206	11	public	public	JJ
8691	3206	12	dissatisfaction	dissatisfaction	NN
8691	3206	13	with	with	IN
8691	3206	14	the	the	DT
8691	3206	15	administration	administration	NN
8691	3206	16	of	of	IN
8691	3206	17	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3206	18	justice	justice	NN
8691	3206	19	,	,	,
8691	3206	20	and	and	CC
8691	3206	21	some	some	DT
8691	3206	22	palliation	palliation	NN
8691	3206	23	for	for	IN
8691	3206	24	the	the	DT
8691	3206	25	frequent	frequent	JJ
8691	3206	26	resorts	resort	NNS
8691	3206	27	to	to	IN
8691	3206	28	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
8691	3206	29	law	law	NN
8691	3206	30	by	by	IN
8691	3206	31	the	the	DT
8691	3206	32	Southern	southern	JJ
8691	3206	33	people	people	NNS
8691	3206	34	.	.	.
8691	3207	1	The	the	DT
8691	3207	2	American	american	JJ
8691	3207	3	plan	plan	NN
8691	3207	4	of	of	IN
8691	3207	5	written	write	VBN
8691	3207	6	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3207	7	,	,	,
8691	3207	8	at	at	IN
8691	3207	9	least	least	JJS
8691	3207	10	in	in	IN
8691	3207	11	all	all	DT
8691	3207	12	cases	case	NNS
8691	3207	13	of	of	IN
8691	3207	14	novelty	novelty	NN
8691	3207	15	or	or	CC
8691	3207	16	general	general	JJ
8691	3207	17	interest	interest	NN
8691	3207	18	,	,	,
8691	3207	19	works	work	VBZ
8691	3207	20	better	well	RBR
8691	3207	21	in	in	IN
8691	3207	22	small	small	JJ
8691	3207	23	States	States	NNPS
8691	3207	24	than	than	IN
8691	3207	25	in	in	IN
8691	3207	26	large	large	JJ
8691	3207	27	ones	one	NNS
8691	3207	28	.	.	.
8691	3208	1	No	no	DT
8691	3208	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	3208	3	can	can	MD
8691	3208	4	find	find	VB
8691	3208	5	time	time	NN
8691	3208	6	to	to	TO
8691	3208	7	prepare	prepare	VB
8691	3208	8	more	more	JJR
8691	3208	9	than	than	IN
8691	3208	10	a	a	DT
8691	3208	11	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3208	12	and	and	CC
8691	3208	13	quite	quite	RB
8691	3208	14	moderate	moderate	JJ
8691	3208	15	number	number	NN
8691	3208	16	in	in	IN
8691	3208	17	a	a	DT
8691	3208	18	year	year	NN
8691	3208	19	,	,	,
8691	3208	20	if	if	IN
8691	3208	21	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3208	22	are	be	VBP
8691	3208	23	such	such	JJ
8691	3208	24	as	as	IN
8691	3208	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3208	26	should	should	MD
8691	3208	27	be	be	VB
8691	3208	28	.	.	.
8691	3209	1	The	the	DT
8691	3209	2	shorter	short	JJR
8691	3209	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3209	4	are	be	VBP
8691	3209	5	,	,	,
8691	3209	6	the	the	DT
8691	3209	7	more	more	JJR
8691	3209	8	time	time	NN
8691	3209	9	generally	generally	RB
8691	3209	10	has	have	VBZ
8691	3209	11	been	be	VBN
8691	3209	12	spent	spend	VBN
8691	3209	13	in	in	IN
8691	3209	14	condensing	condense	VBG
8691	3209	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3209	16	.	.	.
8691	3210	1	In	in	IN
8691	3210	2	a	a	DT
8691	3210	3	great	great	JJ
8691	3210	4	State	state	NN
8691	3210	5	there	there	EX
8691	3210	6	must	must	MD
8691	3210	7	,	,	,
8691	3210	8	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	3210	9	,	,	,
8691	3210	10	either	either	CC
8691	3210	11	be	be	VB
8691	3210	12	a	a	DT
8691	3210	13	larger	large	JJR
8691	3210	14	number	number	NN
8691	3210	15	of	of	IN
8691	3210	16	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3210	17	,	,	,
8691	3210	18	or	or	CC
8691	3210	19	every	every	DT
8691	3210	20	few	few	JJ
8691	3210	21	years	year	NNS
8691	3210	22	there	there	EX
8691	3210	23	must	must	MD
8691	3210	24	be	be	VB
8691	3210	25	a	a	DT
8691	3210	26	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	3210	27	addition	addition	NN
8691	3210	28	to	to	IN
8691	3210	29	the	the	DT
8691	3210	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3210	31	force	force	NN
8691	3210	32	to	to	TO
8691	3210	33	clear	clear	VB
8691	3210	34	off	off	RP
8691	3210	35	an	an	DT
8691	3210	36	accumulation	accumulation	NN
8691	3210	37	of	of	IN
8691	3210	38	cases	case	NNS
8691	3210	39	.	.	.
8691	3211	1	The	the	DT
8691	3211	2	latter	latter	JJ
8691	3211	3	expedient	expedient	NN
8691	3211	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3211	5	generally	generally	RB
8691	3211	6	preferred	prefer	VBN
8691	3211	7	.	.	.
8691	3212	1	Sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3212	2	a	a	DT
8691	3212	3	small	small	JJ
8691	3212	4	number	number	NN
8691	3212	5	of	of	IN
8691	3212	6	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3212	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3212	8	selected	select	VBN
8691	3212	9	to	to	TO
8691	3212	10	serve	serve	VB
8691	3212	11	as	as	IN
8691	3212	12	a	a	DT
8691	3212	13	special	special	JJ
8691	3212	14	commission	commission	NN
8691	3212	15	of	of	IN
8691	3212	16	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	3212	17	.	.	.
8691	3213	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3213	2	sit	sit	VBP
8691	3213	3	by	by	IN
8691	3213	4	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3213	5	,	,	,
8691	3213	6	but	but	CC
8691	3213	7	there	there	EX
8691	3213	8	may	may	MD
8691	3213	9	be	be	VB
8691	3213	10	a	a	DT
8691	3213	11	provision	provision	NN
8691	3213	12	for	for	IN
8691	3213	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3213	14	submitting	submit	VBG
8691	3213	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3213	16	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3213	17	to	to	TO
8691	3213	18	review	review	VB
8691	3213	19	by	by	IN
8691	3213	20	the	the	DT
8691	3213	21	regular	regular	JJ
8691	3213	22	court	court	NN
8691	3213	23	.	.	.
8691	3214	1	Some	some	DT
8691	3214	2	of	of	IN
8691	3214	3	the	the	DT
8691	3214	4	leading	lead	VBG
8691	3214	5	cases	case	NNS
8691	3214	6	in	in	IN
8691	3214	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3214	8	reports	report	NNS
8691	3214	9	have	have	VBP
8691	3214	10	been	be	VBN
8691	3214	11	decided	decide	VBN
8691	3214	12	by	by	IN
8691	3214	13	such	such	JJ
8691	3214	14	commissioners	commissioner	NNS
8691	3214	15	.	.	.
8691	3215	1	In	in	IN
8691	3215	2	California	California	NNP
8691	3215	3	,	,	,
8691	3215	4	where	where	WRB
8691	3215	5	such	such	PDT
8691	3215	6	a	a	DT
8691	3215	7	body	body	NN
8691	3215	8	now	now	RB
8691	3215	9	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	3215	10	,	,	,
8691	3215	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3215	12	members	member	NNS
8691	3215	13	are	be	VBP
8691	3215	14	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3215	15	by	by	IN
8691	3215	16	the	the	DT
8691	3215	17	court	court	NN
8691	3215	18	,	,	,
8691	3215	19	and	and	CC
8691	3215	20	removable	removable	VB
8691	3215	21	at	at	IN
8691	3215	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3215	23	pleasure	pleasure	NN
8691	3215	24	;	;	:
8691	3215	25	but	but	CC
8691	3215	26	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	3215	27	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3215	28	are	be	VBP
8691	3215	29	chosen	choose	VBN
8691	3215	30	by	by	IN
8691	3215	31	the	the	DT
8691	3215	32	executive	executive	JJ
8691	3215	33	or	or	CC
8691	3215	34	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	3215	35	departments	department	NNS
8691	3215	36	.	.	.
8691	3216	1	Sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3216	2	when	when	WRB
8691	3216	3	the	the	DT
8691	3216	4	cases	case	NNS
8691	3216	5	on	on	IN
8691	3216	6	the	the	DT
8691	3216	7	docket	docket	NN
8691	3216	8	of	of	IN
8691	3216	9	the	the	DT
8691	3216	10	court	court	NN
8691	3216	11	of	of	IN
8691	3216	12	last	last	JJ
8691	3216	13	resort	resort	NN
8691	3216	14	reach	reach	VBP
8691	3216	15	a	a	DT
8691	3216	16	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3216	17	number	number	NN
8691	3216	18	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3216	19	in	in	IN
8691	3216	20	New	New	NNP
8691	3216	21	York	York	NNP
8691	3216	22	this	this	DT
8691	3216	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	3216	24	put	put	VBN
8691	3216	25	at	at	IN
8691	3216	26	200	200	CD
8691	3216	27	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3216	28	the	the	DT
8691	3216	29	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3216	30	may	may	MD
8691	3216	31	call	call	VB
8691	3216	32	in	in	IN
8691	3216	33	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3216	34	of	of	IN
8691	3216	35	the	the	DT
8691	3216	36	next	next	JJ
8691	3216	37	court	court	NN
8691	3216	38	in	in	IN
8691	3216	39	rank	rank	NN
8691	3216	40	to	to	TO
8691	3216	41	sit	sit	VB
8691	3216	42	with	with	IN
8691	3216	43	the	the	DT
8691	3216	44	regular	regular	JJ
8691	3216	45	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3216	46	until	until	IN
8691	3216	47	the	the	DT
8691	3216	48	accumulation	accumulation	NN
8691	3216	49	is	be	VBZ
8691	3216	50	cleared	clear	VBN
8691	3216	51	off	off	RP
8691	3216	52	.	.	.
8691	3217	1	Fewer	few	JJR
8691	3217	2	causes	cause	NNS
8691	3217	3	can	can	MD
8691	3217	4	be	be	VB
8691	3217	5	heard	hear	VBN
8691	3217	6	and	and	CC
8691	3217	7	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	3217	8	of	of	IN
8691	3217	9	in	in	IN
8691	3217	10	American	american	JJ
8691	3217	11	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3217	12	courts	court	NNS
8691	3217	13	than	than	IN
8691	3217	14	in	in	IN
8691	3217	15	those	those	DT
8691	3217	16	of	of	IN
8691	3217	17	other	other	JJ
8691	3217	18	countries	country	NNS
8691	3217	19	by	by	IN
8691	3217	20	reason	reason	NN
8691	3217	21	of	of	IN
8691	3217	22	two	two	CD
8691	3217	23	things	thing	NNS
8691	3217	24	,	,	,
8691	3217	25	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3217	26	practice	practice	NN
8691	3217	27	of	of	IN
8691	3217	28	delivering	deliver	VBG
8691	3217	29	written	write	VBN
8691	3217	30	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3217	31	and	and	CC
8691	3217	32	the	the	DT
8691	3217	33	fulness	fulness	NN
8691	3217	34	of	of	IN
8691	3217	35	treatment	treatment	NN
8691	3217	36	thought	think	VBD
8691	3217	37	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	3217	38	in	in	IN
8691	3217	39	such	such	JJ
8691	3217	40	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3217	41	,	,	,
8691	3217	42	especially	especially	RB
8691	3217	43	when	when	WRB
8691	3217	44	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3217	45	deal	deal	VBP
8691	3217	46	with	with	IN
8691	3217	47	questions	question	NNS
8691	3217	48	of	of	IN
8691	3217	49	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3217	50	law	law	NN
8691	3217	51	.	.	.
8691	3218	1	In	in	IN
8691	3218	2	France	France	NNP
8691	3218	3	,	,	,
8691	3218	4	the	the	DT
8691	3218	5	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3218	6	of	of	IN
8691	3218	7	Cassation	Cassation	NNP
8691	3218	8	in	in	IN
8691	3218	9	1901	1901	CD
8691	3218	10	heard	hear	VBD
8691	3218	11	816	816	CD
8691	3218	12	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	3218	13	.	.	.
8691	3219	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3219	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3219	3	:	:	:
8691	3219	4	Of	of	IN
8691	3219	5	these	these	DT
8691	3219	6	,	,	,
8691	3219	7	219	219	CD
8691	3219	8	were	be	VBD
8691	3219	9	sustained	sustain	VBN
8691	3219	10	and	and	CC
8691	3219	11	597	597	CD
8691	3219	12	rejected	reject	VBN
8691	3219	13	.	.	.
8691	3219	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3220	1	Nothing	nothing	NN
8691	3220	2	approaching	approach	VBG
8691	3220	3	this	this	DT
8691	3220	4	number	number	NN
8691	3220	5	could	could	MD
8691	3220	6	be	be	VB
8691	3220	7	properly	properly	RB
8691	3220	8	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	3220	9	of	of	IN
8691	3220	10	on	on	IN
8691	3220	11	the	the	DT
8691	3220	12	merits	merit	NNS
8691	3220	13	in	in	IN
8691	3220	14	any	any	DT
8691	3220	15	American	American	NNP
8691	3220	16	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3220	17	of	of	IN
8691	3220	18	last	last	JJ
8691	3220	19	resort	resort	NN
8691	3220	20	.	.	.
8691	3221	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	3221	2	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	3221	3	,	,	,
8691	3221	4	however	however	RB
8691	3221	5	,	,	,
8691	3221	6	are	be	VBP
8691	3221	7	here	here	RB
8691	3221	8	,	,	,
8691	3221	9	as	as	RB
8691	3221	10	everywhere	everywhere	RB
8691	3221	11	,	,	,
8691	3221	12	abandoned	abandon	VBN
8691	3221	13	or	or	CC
8691	3221	14	dismissed	dismiss	VBN
8691	3221	15	for	for	IN
8691	3221	16	some	some	DT
8691	3221	17	failure	failure	NN
8691	3221	18	to	to	TO
8691	3221	19	comply	comply	VB
8691	3221	20	with	with	IN
8691	3221	21	the	the	DT
8691	3221	22	rules	rule	NNS
8691	3221	23	of	of	IN
8691	3221	24	practice	practice	NN
8691	3221	25	or	or	CC
8691	3221	26	because	because	IN
8691	3221	27	manifestly	manifestly	RB
8691	3221	28	frivolous	frivolous	JJ
8691	3221	29	,	,	,
8691	3221	30	and	and	CC
8691	3221	31	in	in	IN
8691	3221	32	these	these	DT
8691	3221	33	no	no	DT
8691	3221	34	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3221	35	are	be	VBP
8691	3221	36	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	3221	37	given	give	VBN
8691	3221	38	.	.	.
8691	3222	1	During	during	IN
8691	3222	2	the	the	DT
8691	3222	3	court	court	NN
8691	3222	4	year	year	NN
8691	3222	5	closing	close	VBG
8691	3222	6	with	with	IN
8691	3222	7	the	the	DT
8691	3222	8	Summer	Summer	NNP
8691	3222	9	of	of	IN
8691	3222	10	1903	1903	CD
8691	3222	11	,	,	,
8691	3222	12	the	the	DT
8691	3222	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3222	14	of	of	IN
8691	3222	15	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	3222	16	of	of	IN
8691	3222	17	New	New	NNP
8691	3222	18	York	York	NNP
8691	3222	19	filed	file	VBD
8691	3222	20	only	only	RB
8691	3222	21	221	221	CD
8691	3222	22	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3222	23	,	,	,
8691	3222	24	although	although	IN
8691	3222	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3222	26	disposed	dispose	VBD
8691	3222	27	,	,	,
8691	3222	28	in	in	IN
8691	3222	29	one	one	CD
8691	3222	30	way	way	NN
8691	3222	31	or	or	CC
8691	3222	32	another	another	DT
8691	3222	33	,	,	,
8691	3222	34	of	of	IN
8691	3222	35	640	640	CD
8691	3222	36	cases	case	NNS
8691	3222	37	;	;	:
8691	3222	38	and	and	CC
8691	3222	39	the	the	DT
8691	3222	40	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3222	41	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3222	42	of	of	IN
8691	3222	43	the	the	DT
8691	3222	44	United	United	NNP
8691	3222	45	States	States	NNP
8691	3222	46	filed	file	VBD
8691	3222	47	212	212	CD
8691	3222	48	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3222	49	and	and	CC
8691	3222	50	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	3222	51	of	of	IN
8691	3222	52	420	420	CD
8691	3222	53	cases	case	NNS
8691	3222	54	.	.	.
8691	3223	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3223	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3223	3	:	:	:
8691	3223	4	See	see	VB
8691	3223	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	3223	6	.	.	.
8691	3224	1	XXIV	XXIV	NNP
8691	3224	2	.	.	.
8691	3224	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3225	1	In	in	IN
8691	3225	2	the	the	DT
8691	3225	3	calendar	calendar	NN
8691	3225	4	year	year	NN
8691	3225	5	1904	1904	CD
8691	3225	6	,	,	,
8691	3225	7	the	the	DT
8691	3225	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3225	9	of	of	IN
8691	3225	10	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	3225	11	of	of	IN
8691	3225	12	New	New	NNP
8691	3225	13	York	York	NNP
8691	3225	14	filed	file	VBD
8691	3225	15	327	327	CD
8691	3225	16	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3225	17	,	,	,
8691	3225	18	and	and	CC
8691	3225	19	the	the	DT
8691	3225	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3225	21	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3225	22	of	of	IN
8691	3225	23	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
8691	3225	24	over	over	IN
8691	3225	25	500	500	CD
8691	3225	26	.	.	.
8691	3226	1	*	*	NFP
8691	3226	2	*	*	NFP
8691	3226	3	*	*	NFP
8691	3226	4	*	*	NFP
8691	3226	5	*	*	NFP
8691	3226	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	3226	7	XX	xx	IN
8691	3226	8	THE	the	DT
8691	3226	9	ENFORCEMENT	ENFORCEMENT	NNP
8691	3226	10	OF	of	IN
8691	3226	11	JUDGMENTS	judgment	NNS
8691	3226	12	AND	and	CC
8691	3226	13	PUNISHMENT	punishment	NN
8691	3226	14	OF	of	IN
8691	3226	15	CONTEMPTS	contempts	NN
8691	3226	16	OF	of	IN
8691	3226	17	COURT	COURT	NNP
8691	3226	18	No	no	DT
8691	3226	19	court	court	NN
8691	3226	20	can	can	MD
8691	3226	21	with	with	IN
8691	3226	22	propriety	propriety	NN
8691	3226	23	pass	pass	VB
8691	3226	24	a	a	DT
8691	3226	25	decree	decree	NN
8691	3226	26	which	which	WDT
8691	3226	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3226	28	can	can	MD
8691	3226	29	not	not	RB
8691	3226	30	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	3226	31	.	.	.
8691	3227	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3227	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3227	3	:	:	:
8691	3227	4	Clarke	Clarke	NNP
8691	3227	5	's	's	POS
8691	3227	6	Appeal	appeal	NN
8691	3227	7	from	from	IN
8691	3227	8	Probate	Probate	NNP
8691	3227	9	,	,	,
8691	3227	10	70	70	CD
8691	3227	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3227	12	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	3227	13	,	,	,
8691	3227	14	195	195	CD
8691	3227	15	,	,	,
8691	3227	16	209	209	CD
8691	3227	17	;	;	:
8691	3227	18	39	39	CD
8691	3227	19	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	3227	20	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	3227	21	,	,	,
8691	3227	22	155	155	CD
8691	3227	23	;	;	:
8691	3227	24	178	178	CD
8691	3227	25	U.	U.	NNP
8691	3227	26	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3227	27	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	3227	28	,	,	,
8691	3227	29	186	186	CD
8691	3227	30	.	.	.
8691	3227	31	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3228	1	After	after	IN
8691	3228	2	the	the	DT
8691	3228	3	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3228	4	comes	come	VBZ
8691	3228	5	the	the	DT
8691	3228	6	issue	issue	NN
8691	3228	7	of	of	IN
8691	3228	8	appropriate	appropriate	JJ
8691	3228	9	process	process	NN
8691	3228	10	to	to	TO
8691	3228	11	compel	compel	VB
8691	3228	12	obedience	obedience	NN
8691	3228	13	to	to	IN
8691	3228	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3228	15	,	,	,
8691	3228	16	unless	unless	IN
8691	3228	17	such	such	JJ
8691	3228	18	obedience	obedience	NN
8691	3228	19	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3228	20	as	as	IN
8691	3228	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	3228	22	generally	generally	RB
8691	3228	23	the	the	DT
8691	3228	24	case	case	NN
8691	3228	25	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3228	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	3228	27	voluntarily	voluntarily	RB
8691	3228	28	rendered	render	VBN
8691	3228	29	.	.	.
8691	3229	1	The	the	DT
8691	3229	2	whole	whole	JJ
8691	3229	3	power	power	NN
8691	3229	4	of	of	IN
8691	3229	5	government	government	NN
8691	3229	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3229	7	at	at	IN
8691	3229	8	the	the	DT
8691	3229	9	command	command	NN
8691	3229	10	of	of	IN
8691	3229	11	the	the	DT
8691	3229	12	court	court	NN
8691	3229	13	for	for	IN
8691	3229	14	this	this	DT
8691	3229	15	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	3229	16	.	.	.
8691	3230	1	A	a	DT
8691	3230	2	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	3230	3	with	with	IN
8691	3230	4	a	a	DT
8691	3230	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3230	6	process	process	NN
8691	3230	7	to	to	TO
8691	3230	8	serve	serve	VB
8691	3230	9	who	who	WP
8691	3230	10	meets	meet	VBZ
8691	3230	11	with	with	IN
8691	3230	12	resistance	resistance	NN
8691	3230	13	can	can	MD
8691	3230	14	summon	summon	VB
8691	3230	15	to	to	IN
8691	3230	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3230	17	aid	aid	NN
8691	3230	18	the	the	DT
8691	3230	19	_	_	NNP
8691	3230	20	posse	posse	NN
8691	3230	21	comitatus	comitatus	NN
8691	3230	22	_	_	NNP
8691	3230	23	.	.	.
8691	3231	1	By	by	IN
8691	3231	2	this	this	DT
8691	3231	3	term	term	NN
8691	3231	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3231	5	meant	mean	VBN
8691	3231	6	the	the	DT
8691	3231	7	whole	whole	JJ
8691	3231	8	power	power	NN
8691	3231	9	of	of	IN
8691	3231	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3231	11	county	county	NN
8691	3231	12	;	;	:
8691	3231	13	that	that	RB
8691	3231	14	is	is	RB
8691	3231	15	,	,	,
8691	3231	16	any	any	DT
8691	3231	17	or	or	CC
8691	3231	18	all	all	DT
8691	3231	19	of	of	IN
8691	3231	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3231	21	able	able	JJ
8691	3231	22	-	-	HYPH
8691	3231	23	bodied	bodied	JJ
8691	3231	24	inhabitants	inhabitant	NNS
8691	3231	25	on	on	IN
8691	3231	26	whom	whom	WP
8691	3231	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3231	28	may	may	MD
8691	3231	29	choose	choose	VB
8691	3231	30	to	to	TO
8691	3231	31	call	call	VB
8691	3231	32	.	.	.
8691	3232	1	Not	not	RB
8691	3232	2	to	to	TO
8691	3232	3	respond	respond	VB
8691	3232	4	to	to	IN
8691	3232	5	such	such	PDT
8691	3232	6	a	a	DT
8691	3232	7	call	call	NN
8691	3232	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	3232	9	a	a	DT
8691	3232	10	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3232	11	offense	offense	NN
8691	3232	12	.	.	.
8691	3233	1	The	the	DT
8691	3233	2	marshals	marshal	NNS
8691	3233	3	have	have	VBP
8691	3233	4	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3233	5	powers	power	NNS
8691	3233	6	in	in	IN
8691	3233	7	serving	serve	VBG
8691	3233	8	process	process	NN
8691	3233	9	from	from	IN
8691	3233	10	the	the	DT
8691	3233	11	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	3233	12	courts	court	NNS
8691	3233	13	.	.	.
8691	3234	1	The	the	DT
8691	3234	2	fact	fact	NN
8691	3234	3	that	that	IN
8691	3234	4	there	there	EX
8691	3234	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3234	6	this	this	DT
8691	3234	7	force	force	NN
8691	3234	8	behind	behind	IN
8691	3234	9	a	a	DT
8691	3234	10	writ	writ	NN
8691	3234	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	3234	12	so	so	RB
8691	3234	13	well	well	RB
8691	3234	14	understood	understand	VBN
8691	3234	15	by	by	IN
8691	3234	16	the	the	DT
8691	3234	17	community	community	NN
8691	3234	18	that	that	WDT
8691	3234	19	occasions	occasion	NNS
8691	3234	20	for	for	IN
8691	3234	21	resorting	resort	VBG
8691	3234	22	to	to	IN
8691	3234	23	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3234	24	use	use	NN
8691	3234	25	,	,	,
8691	3234	26	or	or	CC
8691	3234	27	indeed	indeed	RB
8691	3234	28	to	to	IN
8691	3234	29	the	the	DT
8691	3234	30	use	use	NN
8691	3234	31	of	of	IN
8691	3234	32	any	any	DT
8691	3234	33	actual	actual	JJ
8691	3234	34	force	force	NN
8691	3234	35	,	,	,
8691	3234	36	are	be	VBP
8691	3234	37	extremely	extremely	RB
8691	3234	38	rare	rare	JJ
8691	3234	39	.	.	.
8691	3235	1	If	if	IN
8691	3235	2	the	the	DT
8691	3235	3	process	process	NN
8691	3235	4	was	be	VBD
8691	3235	5	lawfully	lawfully	RB
8691	3235	6	issued	issue	VBN
8691	3235	7	,	,	,
8691	3235	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3235	9	would	would	MD
8691	3235	10	be	be	VB
8691	3235	11	useless	useless	JJ
8691	3235	12	to	to	TO
8691	3235	13	resist	resist	VB
8691	3235	14	.	.	.
8691	3236	1	If	if	IN
8691	3236	2	unlawfully	unlawfully	RB
8691	3236	3	,	,	,
8691	3236	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3236	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3236	6	easier	easy	JJR
8691	3236	7	and	and	CC
8691	3236	8	safer	safe	JJR
8691	3236	9	to	to	TO
8691	3236	10	seek	seek	VB
8691	3236	11	relief	relief	NN
8691	3236	12	by	by	IN
8691	3236	13	an	an	DT
8691	3236	14	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	3236	15	,	,	,
8691	3236	16	or	or	CC
8691	3236	17	in	in	IN
8691	3236	18	case	case	NN
8691	3236	19	of	of	IN
8691	3236	20	an	an	DT
8691	3236	21	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	3236	22	,	,	,
8691	3236	23	by	by	IN
8691	3236	24	a	a	DT
8691	3236	25	writ	writ	NN
8691	3236	26	of	of	IN
8691	3236	27	_	_	NNP
8691	3236	28	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	3236	29	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	3236	30	_	_	NNP
8691	3236	31	.	.	.
8691	3237	1	But	but	CC
8691	3237	2	there	there	EX
8691	3237	3	have	have	VBP
8691	3237	4	been	be	VBN
8691	3237	5	occasions	occasion	NNS
8691	3237	6	in	in	IN
8691	3237	7	the	the	DT
8691	3237	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3237	9	history	history	NN
8691	3237	10	of	of	IN
8691	3237	11	the	the	DT
8691	3237	12	United	United	NNP
8691	3237	13	States	States	NNP
8691	3237	14	when	when	WRB
8691	3237	15	,	,	,
8691	3237	16	under	under	IN
8691	3237	17	the	the	DT
8691	3237	18	influence	influence	NN
8691	3237	19	of	of	IN
8691	3237	20	a	a	DT
8691	3237	21	general	general	JJ
8691	3237	22	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3237	23	ferment	ferment	NN
8691	3237	24	,	,	,
8691	3237	25	the	the	DT
8691	3237	26	service	service	NN
8691	3237	27	of	of	IN
8691	3237	28	process	process	NN
8691	3237	29	from	from	IN
8691	3237	30	the	the	DT
8691	3237	31	courts	court	NNS
8691	3237	32	,	,	,
8691	3237	33	and	and	CC
8691	3237	34	even	even	RB
8691	3237	35	the	the	DT
8691	3237	36	holding	holding	NN
8691	3237	37	of	of	IN
8691	3237	38	courts	court	NNS
8691	3237	39	,	,	,
8691	3237	40	have	have	VBP
8691	3237	41	been	be	VBN
8691	3237	42	forcibly	forcibly	RB
8691	3237	43	prevented	prevent	VBN
8691	3237	44	.	.	.
8691	3238	1	Shay	Shay	NNP
8691	3238	2	's	's	POS
8691	3238	3	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
8691	3238	4	in	in	IN
8691	3238	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3238	6	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3238	7	in	in	IN
8691	3238	8	1786	1786	CD
8691	3238	9	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3238	10	was	be	VBD
8691	3238	11	the	the	DT
8691	3238	12	first	first	JJ
8691	3238	13	of	of	IN
8691	3238	14	these	these	DT
8691	3238	15	after	after	IN
8691	3238	16	the	the	DT
8691	3238	17	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	3238	18	.	.	.
8691	3239	1	Similar	similar	JJ
8691	3239	2	uprisings	uprising	NNS
8691	3239	3	of	of	IN
8691	3239	4	less	less	JJR
8691	3239	5	importance	importance	NN
8691	3239	6	took	take	VBD
8691	3239	7	place	place	NN
8691	3239	8	at	at	IN
8691	3239	9	about	about	IN
8691	3239	10	the	the	DT
8691	3239	11	same	same	JJ
8691	3239	12	time	time	NN
8691	3239	13	in	in	IN
8691	3239	14	New	New	NNP
8691	3239	15	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	3239	16	and	and	CC
8691	3239	17	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
8691	3239	18	.	.	.
8691	3240	1	A	a	DT
8691	3240	2	few	few	JJ
8691	3240	3	years	year	NNS
8691	3240	4	later	later	RB
8691	3240	5	,	,	,
8691	3240	6	the	the	DT
8691	3240	7	service	service	NN
8691	3240	8	of	of	IN
8691	3240	9	process	process	NN
8691	3240	10	from	from	IN
8691	3240	11	the	the	DT
8691	3240	12	New	New	NNP
8691	3240	13	York	York	NNP
8691	3240	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	3240	15	was	be	VBD
8691	3240	16	interrupted	interrupt	VBN
8691	3240	17	in	in	IN
8691	3240	18	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
8691	3240	19	County	County	NNP
8691	3240	20	.	.	.
8691	3241	1	There	there	EX
8691	3241	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3241	3	a	a	DT
8691	3241	4	strip	strip	NN
8691	3241	5	of	of	IN
8691	3241	6	territory	territory	NN
8691	3241	7	adjoining	adjoin	VBG
8691	3241	8	the	the	DT
8691	3241	9	Hudson	Hudson	NNP
8691	3241	10	River	River	NNP
8691	3241	11	,	,	,
8691	3241	12	title	title	NN
8691	3241	13	to	to	TO
8691	3241	14	which	which	WDT
8691	3241	15	was	be	VBD
8691	3241	16	claimed	claim	VBN
8691	3241	17	both	both	CC
8691	3241	18	by	by	IN
8691	3241	19	New	New	NNP
8691	3241	20	York	York	NNP
8691	3241	21	and	and	CC
8691	3241	22	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3241	23	.	.	.
8691	3242	1	Conflicting	conflict	VBG
8691	3242	2	claims	claim	NNS
8691	3242	3	,	,	,
8691	3242	4	awaking	awake	VBG
8691	3242	5	much	much	JJ
8691	3242	6	bitter	bitter	JJ
8691	3242	7	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	3242	8	,	,	,
8691	3242	9	arose	arise	VBD
8691	3242	10	under	under	IN
8691	3242	11	grants	grant	NNS
8691	3242	12	from	from	IN
8691	3242	13	each	each	DT
8691	3242	14	government	government	NN
8691	3242	15	.	.	.
8691	3243	1	In	in	IN
8691	3243	2	1791	1791	CD
8691	3243	3	,	,	,
8691	3243	4	the	the	DT
8691	3243	5	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	3243	6	of	of	IN
8691	3243	7	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
8691	3243	8	County	County	NNP
8691	3243	9	was	be	VBD
8691	3243	10	ordered	order	VBN
8691	3243	11	by	by	IN
8691	3243	12	the	the	DT
8691	3243	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	3243	14	,	,	,
8691	3243	15	in	in	IN
8691	3243	16	the	the	DT
8691	3243	17	course	course	NN
8691	3243	18	of	of	IN
8691	3243	19	a	a	DT
8691	3243	20	lawsuit	lawsuit	NN
8691	3243	21	,	,	,
8691	3243	22	to	to	TO
8691	3243	23	sell	sell	VB
8691	3243	24	a	a	DT
8691	3243	25	tract	tract	NN
8691	3243	26	of	of	IN
8691	3243	27	this	this	DT
8691	3243	28	land	land	NN
8691	3243	29	.	.	.
8691	3244	1	Seventeen	seventeen	CD
8691	3244	2	persons	person	NNS
8691	3244	3	disguised	disguise	VBN
8691	3244	4	as	as	IN
8691	3244	5	Indians	Indians	NNPS
8691	3244	6	appeared	appear	VBD
8691	3244	7	at	at	IN
8691	3244	8	the	the	DT
8691	3244	9	time	time	NN
8691	3244	10	of	of	IN
8691	3244	11	sale	sale	NN
8691	3244	12	to	to	TO
8691	3244	13	resist	resist	VB
8691	3244	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3244	15	,	,	,
8691	3244	16	and	and	CC
8691	3244	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3244	18	was	be	VBD
8691	3244	19	killed	kill	VBN
8691	3244	20	by	by	IN
8691	3244	21	a	a	DT
8691	3244	22	shot	shot	NN
8691	3244	23	from	from	IN
8691	3244	24	one	one	CD
8691	3244	25	of	of	IN
8691	3244	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3244	27	.	.	.
8691	3245	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3245	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3245	3	:	:	:
8691	3245	4	Report	Report	NNP
8691	3245	5	Am	Am	NNP
8691	3245	6	.	.	.
8691	3246	1	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	3246	2	Association	Association	NNP
8691	3246	3	for	for	IN
8691	3246	4	1896	1896	CD
8691	3246	5	,	,	,
8691	3246	6	I	I	NNP
8691	3246	7	,	,	,
8691	3246	8	152	152	CD
8691	3246	9	,	,	,
8691	3246	10	note	note	NN
8691	3246	11	.	.	.
8691	3246	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3247	1	Then	then	RB
8691	3247	2	came	come	VBD
8691	3247	3	the	the	DT
8691	3247	4	Whiskey	Whiskey	NNP
8691	3247	5	Rebellion	Rebellion	NNP
8691	3247	6	in	in	IN
8691	3247	7	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3247	8	.	.	.
8691	3248	1	The	the	DT
8691	3248	2	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	3248	3	of	of	IN
8691	3248	4	the	the	DT
8691	3248	5	United	United	NNP
8691	3248	6	States[Footnote	states[footnote	NN
8691	3248	7	:	:	:
8691	3248	8	United	United	NNP
8691	3248	9	States	States	NNP
8691	3248	10	Revised	Revised	NNP
8691	3248	11	Statues	Statues	NNPS
8691	3248	12	,	,	,
8691	3248	13	5299	5299	CD
8691	3248	14	.	.	.
8691	3248	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3249	1	provide	provide	VB
8691	3249	2	that	that	IN
8691	3249	3	if	if	IN
8691	3249	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3249	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	3249	6	meet	meet	VBP
8691	3249	7	with	with	IN
8691	3249	8	opposition	opposition	NN
8691	3249	9	of	of	IN
8691	3249	10	a	a	DT
8691	3249	11	serious	serious	JJ
8691	3249	12	nature	nature	NN
8691	3249	13	,	,	,
8691	3249	14	the	the	DT
8691	3249	15	President	President	NNP
8691	3249	16	may	may	MD
8691	3249	17	use	use	VB
8691	3249	18	the	the	DT
8691	3249	19	army	army	NN
8691	3249	20	or	or	CC
8691	3249	21	call	call	VB
8691	3249	22	out	out	RP
8691	3249	23	the	the	DT
8691	3249	24	militia	militia	NN
8691	3249	25	of	of	IN
8691	3249	26	one	one	CD
8691	3249	27	or	or	CC
8691	3249	28	more	more	JJR
8691	3249	29	States	States	NNP
8691	3249	30	to	to	TO
8691	3249	31	restore	restore	VB
8691	3249	32	order	order	NN
8691	3249	33	.	.	.
8691	3250	1	Opposition	opposition	NN
8691	3250	2	to	to	IN
8691	3250	3	the	the	DT
8691	3250	4	enforcement	enforcement	NN
8691	3250	5	of	of	IN
8691	3250	6	the	the	DT
8691	3250	7	revenue	revenue	NN
8691	3250	8	tax	tax	NN
8691	3250	9	on	on	IN
8691	3250	10	whiskey	whiskey	NN
8691	3250	11	in	in	IN
8691	3250	12	1794	1794	CD
8691	3250	13	called	call	VBD
8691	3250	14	for	for	IN
8691	3250	15	the	the	DT
8691	3250	16	first	first	JJ
8691	3250	17	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	3250	18	of	of	IN
8691	3250	19	this	this	DT
8691	3250	20	power	power	NN
8691	3250	21	.	.	.
8691	3251	1	Marshals	marshal	NNS
8691	3251	2	were	be	VBD
8691	3251	3	resisted	resist	VBN
8691	3251	4	in	in	IN
8691	3251	5	serving	serve	VBG
8691	3251	6	process	process	NN
8691	3251	7	,	,	,
8691	3251	8	and	and	CC
8691	3251	9	several	several	JJ
8691	3251	10	counties	county	NNS
8691	3251	11	were	be	VBD
8691	3251	12	in	in	IN
8691	3251	13	a	a	DT
8691	3251	14	state	state	NN
8691	3251	15	of	of	IN
8691	3251	16	insurrection	insurrection	NN
8691	3251	17	.	.	.
8691	3252	1	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	3252	2	sent	send	VBD
8691	3252	3	so	so	RB
8691	3252	4	large	large	JJ
8691	3252	5	a	a	DT
8691	3252	6	force	force	NN
8691	3252	7	of	of	IN
8691	3252	8	troops	troop	NNS
8691	3252	9	to	to	TO
8691	3252	10	suppress	suppress	VB
8691	3252	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3252	12	that	that	IN
8691	3252	13	the	the	DT
8691	3252	14	rioters	rioter	NNS
8691	3252	15	vanished	vanish	VBD
8691	3252	16	on	on	IN
8691	3252	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3252	18	approach	approach	NN
8691	3252	19	,	,	,
8691	3252	20	and	and	CC
8691	3252	21	there	there	EX
8691	3252	22	was	be	VBD
8691	3252	23	no	no	DT
8691	3252	24	further	further	JJ
8691	3252	25	obstruction	obstruction	NN
8691	3252	26	of	of	IN
8691	3252	27	the	the	DT
8691	3252	28	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	3252	29	course	course	NN
8691	3252	30	of	of	IN
8691	3252	31	justice	justice	NN
8691	3252	32	.	.	.
8691	3253	1	The	the	DT
8691	3253	2	total	total	JJ
8691	3253	3	expense	expense	NN
8691	3253	4	to	to	IN
8691	3253	5	the	the	DT
8691	3253	6	government	government	NN
8691	3253	7	in	in	IN
8691	3253	8	this	this	DT
8691	3253	9	affair	affair	NN
8691	3253	10	was	be	VBD
8691	3253	11	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	3253	12	$	$	$
8691	3253	13	1,000,000	1,000,000	CD
8691	3253	14	.	.	.
8691	3254	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3254	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3254	3	:	:	:
8691	3254	4	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
8691	3254	5	's	's	POS
8691	3254	6	"	"	``
8691	3254	7	State	State	NNP
8691	3254	8	Trials	Trials	NNPS
8691	3254	9	,	,	,
8691	3254	10	"	"	''
8691	3254	11	102	102	CD
8691	3254	12	.	.	.
8691	3254	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3255	1	In	in	IN
8691	3255	2	1799	1799	CD
8691	3255	3	,	,	,
8691	3255	4	somewhat	somewhat	RB
8691	3255	5	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3255	6	opposition	opposition	NN
8691	3255	7	arose	arise	VBD
8691	3255	8	in	in	IN
8691	3255	9	the	the	DT
8691	3255	10	same	same	JJ
8691	3255	11	State	State	NNP
8691	3255	12	against	against	IN
8691	3255	13	the	the	DT
8691	3255	14	enforcement	enforcement	NN
8691	3255	15	of	of	IN
8691	3255	16	the	the	DT
8691	3255	17	house	house	NN
8691	3255	18	taxes	taxis	NNS
8691	3255	19	laid	lay	VBN
8691	3255	20	by	by	IN
8691	3255	21	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3255	22	.	.	.
8691	3256	1	President	President	NNP
8691	3256	2	Adams	Adams	NNP
8691	3256	3	here	here	RB
8691	3256	4	also	also	RB
8691	3256	5	sent	send	VBD
8691	3256	6	a	a	DT
8691	3256	7	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	3256	8	force	force	NN
8691	3256	9	of	of	IN
8691	3256	10	militia	militia	NN
8691	3256	11	to	to	TO
8691	3256	12	suppress	suppress	VB
8691	3256	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3256	14	.	.	.
8691	3257	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3257	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3257	3	:	:	:
8691	3257	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3257	5	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
8691	3257	6	_	_	NNP
8691	3257	7	.	.	NNP
8691	3257	8	,	,	,
8691	3257	9	48	48	CD
8691	3257	10	,	,	,
8691	3257	11	459	459	CD
8691	3257	12	.	.	.
8691	3257	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3258	1	In	in	IN
8691	3258	2	1839	1839	CD
8691	3258	3	,	,	,
8691	3258	4	a	a	DT
8691	3258	5	general	general	JJ
8691	3258	6	combination	combination	NN
8691	3258	7	was	be	VBD
8691	3258	8	formed	form	VBN
8691	3258	9	among	among	IN
8691	3258	10	the	the	DT
8691	3258	11	tenant	tenant	NN
8691	3258	12	farmers	farmer	NNS
8691	3258	13	in	in	IN
8691	3258	14	New	New	NNP
8691	3258	15	York	York	NNP
8691	3258	16	holding	hold	VBG
8691	3258	17	long	long	JJ
8691	3258	18	or	or	CC
8691	3258	19	perpetual	perpetual	JJ
8691	3258	20	leases	lease	NNS
8691	3258	21	from	from	IN
8691	3258	22	manorial	manorial	JJ
8691	3258	23	proprietors	proprietor	NNS
8691	3258	24	to	to	TO
8691	3258	25	resist	resist	VB
8691	3258	26	the	the	DT
8691	3258	27	payment	payment	NN
8691	3258	28	of	of	IN
8691	3258	29	the	the	DT
8691	3258	30	stipulated	stipulate	VBN
8691	3258	31	rents	rent	NNS
8691	3258	32	.	.	.
8691	3259	1	In	in	IN
8691	3259	2	several	several	JJ
8691	3259	3	counties	county	NNS
8691	3259	4	the	the	DT
8691	3259	5	greater	great	JJR
8691	3259	6	part	part	NN
8691	3259	7	of	of	IN
8691	3259	8	the	the	DT
8691	3259	9	land	land	NN
8691	3259	10	was	be	VBD
8691	3259	11	occupied	occupy	VBN
8691	3259	12	under	under	IN
8691	3259	13	such	such	PDT
8691	3259	14	a	a	DT
8691	3259	15	tenure	tenure	NN
8691	3259	16	.	.	.
8691	3260	1	The	the	DT
8691	3260	2	design	design	NN
8691	3260	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3260	4	to	to	TO
8691	3260	5	compel	compel	VB
8691	3260	6	the	the	DT
8691	3260	7	landlords	landlord	NNS
8691	3260	8	to	to	TO
8691	3260	9	sell	sell	VB
8691	3260	10	to	to	IN
8691	3260	11	the	the	DT
8691	3260	12	existing	exist	VBG
8691	3260	13	tenants	tenant	NNS
8691	3260	14	at	at	IN
8691	3260	15	a	a	DT
8691	3260	16	price	price	NN
8691	3260	17	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	3260	18	by	by	IN
8691	3260	19	public	public	JJ
8691	3260	20	appraisal	appraisal	NN
8691	3260	21	,	,	,
8691	3260	22	or	or	CC
8691	3260	23	else	else	RB
8691	3260	24	that	that	WDT
8691	3260	25	the	the	DT
8691	3260	26	State	State	NNP
8691	3260	27	should	should	MD
8691	3260	28	take	take	VB
8691	3260	29	the	the	DT
8691	3260	30	lands	land	NNS
8691	3260	31	by	by	IN
8691	3260	32	eminent	eminent	JJ
8691	3260	33	domain	domain	NN
8691	3260	34	and	and	CC
8691	3260	35	dispose	dispose	VBP
8691	3260	36	of	of	IN
8691	3260	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3260	38	to	to	IN
8691	3260	39	the	the	DT
8691	3260	40	same	same	JJ
8691	3260	41	persons	person	NNS
8691	3260	42	on	on	IN
8691	3260	43	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	3260	44	terms	term	NNS
8691	3260	45	.	.	.
8691	3261	1	Sheriffs	sheriff	NNS
8691	3261	2	were	be	VBD
8691	3261	3	forcibly	forcibly	RB
8691	3261	4	prevented	prevent	VBN
8691	3261	5	from	from	IN
8691	3261	6	serving	serve	VBG
8691	3261	7	writs	writ	NNS
8691	3261	8	in	in	IN
8691	3261	9	dispossession	dispossession	NN
8691	3261	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3261	11	.	.	.
8691	3262	1	One	one	CD
8691	3262	2	who	who	WP
8691	3262	3	took	take	VBD
8691	3262	4	with	with	IN
8691	3262	5	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3262	6	a	a	DT
8691	3262	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3262	8	posse	posse	NN
8691	3262	9	comitatus	comitatus	NN
8691	3262	10	_	_	NNP
8691	3262	11	of	of	IN
8691	3262	12	five	five	CD
8691	3262	13	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3262	14	armed	armed	JJ
8691	3262	15	men	man	NNS
8691	3262	16	,	,	,
8691	3262	17	a	a	DT
8691	3262	18	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3262	19	of	of	IN
8691	3262	20	whom	whom	WP
8691	3262	21	were	be	VBD
8691	3262	22	mounted	mount	VBN
8691	3262	23	,	,	,
8691	3262	24	was	be	VBD
8691	3262	25	met	meet	VBN
8691	3262	26	and	and	CC
8691	3262	27	turned	turn	VBN
8691	3262	28	back	back	RB
8691	3262	29	by	by	IN
8691	3262	30	a	a	DT
8691	3262	31	larger	large	JJR
8691	3262	32	band	band	NN
8691	3262	33	,	,	,
8691	3262	34	who	who	WP
8691	3262	35	were	be	VBD
8691	3262	36	all	all	RB
8691	3262	37	mounted	mount	VBN
8691	3262	38	.	.	.
8691	3263	1	The	the	DT
8691	3263	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3263	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3263	4	finally	finally	RB
8691	3263	5	compelled	compel	VBN
8691	3263	6	to	to	TO
8691	3263	7	issue	issue	VB
8691	3263	8	a	a	DT
8691	3263	9	proclamation	proclamation	NN
8691	3263	10	against	against	IN
8691	3263	11	the	the	DT
8691	3263	12	"	"	``
8691	3263	13	up	up	NN
8691	3263	14	-	-	HYPH
8691	3263	15	renters	renter	NNS
8691	3263	16	,	,	,
8691	3263	17	"	"	''
8691	3263	18	as	as	IN
8691	3263	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3263	20	were	be	VBD
8691	3263	21	called	call	VBN
8691	3263	22	,	,	,
8691	3263	23	and	and	CC
8691	3263	24	to	to	TO
8691	3263	25	protect	protect	VB
8691	3263	26	the	the	DT
8691	3263	27	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	3263	28	by	by	IN
8691	3263	29	a	a	DT
8691	3263	30	large	large	JJ
8691	3263	31	body	body	NN
8691	3263	32	of	of	IN
8691	3263	33	militia	militia	NN
8691	3263	34	.	.	.
8691	3264	1	Put	put	VB
8691	3264	2	down	down	RP
8691	3264	3	in	in	IN
8691	3264	4	one	one	CD
8691	3264	5	county	county	NN
8691	3264	6	,	,	,
8691	3264	7	the	the	DT
8691	3264	8	movement	movement	NN
8691	3264	9	soon	soon	RB
8691	3264	10	reappeared	reappear	VBD
8691	3264	11	in	in	IN
8691	3264	12	others	other	NNS
8691	3264	13	.	.	.
8691	3265	1	Disguises	disguise	NNS
8691	3265	2	were	be	VBD
8691	3265	3	assumed	assume	VBN
8691	3265	4	,	,	,
8691	3265	5	the	the	DT
8691	3265	6	rioters	rioter	NNS
8691	3265	7	figuring	figure	VBG
8691	3265	8	under	under	IN
8691	3265	9	Indian	indian	JJ
8691	3265	10	names	name	NNS
8691	3265	11	and	and	CC
8691	3265	12	wearing	wear	VBG
8691	3265	13	more	more	RBR
8691	3265	14	or	or	CC
8691	3265	15	less	less	JJR
8691	3265	16	of	of	IN
8691	3265	17	the	the	DT
8691	3265	18	Indian	indian	JJ
8691	3265	19	garb	garb	NN
8691	3265	20	.	.	.
8691	3266	1	Three	three	CD
8691	3266	2	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3266	3	of	of	IN
8691	3266	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3266	5	,	,	,
8691	3266	6	with	with	IN
8691	3266	7	twice	twice	PDT
8691	3266	8	that	that	DT
8691	3266	9	number	number	NN
8691	3266	10	not	not	RB
8691	3266	11	in	in	IN
8691	3266	12	disguise	disguise	NN
8691	3266	13	,	,	,
8691	3266	14	prevented	prevent	VBD
8691	3266	15	a	a	DT
8691	3266	16	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	3266	17	from	from	IN
8691	3266	18	levying	levy	VBG
8691	3266	19	an	an	DT
8691	3266	20	execution	execution	NN
8691	3266	21	for	for	IN
8691	3266	22	rent	rent	NN
8691	3266	23	on	on	IN
8691	3266	24	tenants	tenant	NNS
8691	3266	25	upon	upon	IN
8691	3266	26	the	the	DT
8691	3266	27	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
8691	3266	28	manor	manor	NN
8691	3266	29	.	.	.
8691	3267	1	For	for	IN
8691	3267	2	six	six	CD
8691	3267	3	years	year	NNS
8691	3267	4	the	the	DT
8691	3267	5	contest	contest	NN
8691	3267	6	went	go	VBD
8691	3267	7	on	on	RP
8691	3267	8	in	in	IN
8691	3267	9	several	several	JJ
8691	3267	10	counties	county	NNS
8691	3267	11	.	.	.
8691	3268	1	Several	several	JJ
8691	3268	2	lives	life	NNS
8691	3268	3	were	be	VBD
8691	3268	4	lost	lose	VBN
8691	3268	5	on	on	IN
8691	3268	6	both	both	DT
8691	3268	7	sides	side	NNS
8691	3268	8	.	.	.
8691	3269	1	Sheriff	Sheriff	NNP
8691	3269	2	's	's	POS
8691	3269	3	officers	officer	NNS
8691	3269	4	were	be	VBD
8691	3269	5	tarred	tar	VBN
8691	3269	6	and	and	CC
8691	3269	7	feathered	feather	VBN
8691	3269	8	and	and	CC
8691	3269	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3269	10	writs	writ	NNS
8691	3269	11	destroyed	destroy	VBN
8691	3269	12	.	.	.
8691	3270	1	Of	of	IN
8691	3270	2	the	the	DT
8691	3270	3	rioters	rioter	NNS
8691	3270	4	many	many	JJ
8691	3270	5	were	be	VBD
8691	3270	6	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	3270	7	and	and	CC
8691	3270	8	prosecuted	prosecute	VBN
8691	3270	9	from	from	IN
8691	3270	10	time	time	NN
8691	3270	11	to	to	IN
8691	3270	12	time	time	NN
8691	3270	13	and	and	CC
8691	3270	14	some	some	DT
8691	3270	15	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	3270	16	.	.	.
8691	3271	1	Five	five	CD
8691	3271	2	were	be	VBD
8691	3271	3	sent	send	VBN
8691	3271	4	to	to	IN
8691	3271	5	the	the	DT
8691	3271	6	State	State	NNP
8691	3271	7	's	's	POS
8691	3271	8	prison	prison	NN
8691	3271	9	for	for	IN
8691	3271	10	life	life	NN
8691	3271	11	.	.	.
8691	3272	1	Two	two	CD
8691	3272	2	were	be	VBD
8691	3272	3	sentenced	sentence	VBN
8691	3272	4	to	to	TO
8691	3272	5	be	be	VB
8691	3272	6	hanged	hang	VBN
8691	3272	7	.	.	.
8691	3273	1	The	the	DT
8691	3273	2	State	State	NNP
8691	3273	3	used	use	VBD
8691	3273	4	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3273	5	militia	militia	NN
8691	3273	6	freely	freely	RB
8691	3273	7	to	to	TO
8691	3273	8	defend	defend	VB
8691	3273	9	the	the	DT
8691	3273	10	sheriffs	sheriff	NNS
8691	3273	11	,	,	,
8691	3273	12	at	at	IN
8691	3273	13	a	a	DT
8691	3273	14	cost	cost	NN
8691	3273	15	in	in	IN
8691	3273	16	one	one	CD
8691	3273	17	county	county	NN
8691	3273	18	of	of	IN
8691	3273	19	over	over	IN
8691	3273	20	$	$	$
8691	3273	21	60,000	60,000	CD
8691	3273	22	,	,	,
8691	3273	23	and	and	CC
8691	3273	24	in	in	IN
8691	3273	25	1845	1845	CD
8691	3273	26	a	a	DT
8691	3273	27	series	series	NN
8691	3273	28	of	of	IN
8691	3273	29	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	3273	30	and	and	CC
8691	3273	31	convictions	conviction	NNS
8691	3273	32	,	,	,
8691	3273	33	resulting	result	VBG
8691	3273	34	in	in	IN
8691	3273	35	over	over	IN
8691	3273	36	eighty	eighty	CD
8691	3273	37	sentences	sentence	NNS
8691	3273	38	at	at	IN
8691	3273	39	one	one	CD
8691	3273	40	term	term	NN
8691	3273	41	of	of	IN
8691	3273	42	court	court	NN
8691	3273	43	,	,	,
8691	3273	44	broke	break	VBD
8691	3273	45	the	the	DT
8691	3273	46	back	back	NN
8691	3273	47	of	of	IN
8691	3273	48	the	the	DT
8691	3273	49	insurrection	insurrection	NN
8691	3273	50	.	.	.
8691	3274	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3274	2	died	die	VBD
8691	3274	3	half	half	JJ
8691	3274	4	-	-	HYPH
8691	3274	5	victorious	victorious	JJ
8691	3274	6	,	,	,
8691	3274	7	however	however	RB
8691	3274	8	,	,	,
8691	3274	9	for	for	IN
8691	3274	10	an	an	DT
8691	3274	11	"	"	``
8691	3274	12	anti	anti	JJ
8691	3274	13	-	-	JJ
8691	3274	14	rent	rent	JJ
8691	3274	15	"	"	``
8691	3274	16	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3274	17	and	and	CC
8691	3274	18	Lieutenant	Lieutenant	NNP
8691	3274	19	-	-	HYPH
8691	3274	20	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3274	21	were	be	VBD
8691	3274	22	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3274	23	the	the	DT
8691	3274	24	next	next	JJ
8691	3274	25	year	year	NN
8691	3274	26	,	,	,
8691	3274	27	and	and	CC
8691	3274	28	several	several	JJ
8691	3274	29	statutory	statutory	JJ
8691	3274	30	changes	change	NNS
8691	3274	31	in	in	IN
8691	3274	32	the	the	DT
8691	3274	33	law	law	NN
8691	3274	34	of	of	IN
8691	3274	35	leases	lease	NNS
8691	3274	36	which	which	WDT
8691	3274	37	the	the	DT
8691	3274	38	malcontents	malcontent	NNS
8691	3274	39	had	have	VBD
8691	3274	40	desired	desire	VBN
8691	3274	41	were	be	VBD
8691	3274	42	soon	soon	RB
8691	3274	43	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	3274	44	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	3274	45	.	.	.
8691	3275	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3275	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3275	3	:	:	:
8691	3275	4	See	See	NNP
8691	3275	5	Paper	Paper	NNP
8691	3275	6	by	by	IN
8691	3275	7	David	David	NNP
8691	3275	8	Murray	Murray	NNP
8691	3275	9	on	on	IN
8691	3275	10	the	the	DT
8691	3275	11	"	"	``
8691	3275	12	Anti	anti	JJ
8691	3275	13	-	-	JJ
8691	3275	14	rent	rent	NNP
8691	3275	15	Episode	Episode	NNP
8691	3275	16	in	in	IN
8691	3275	17	New	New	NNP
8691	3275	18	York	York	NNP
8691	3275	19	,	,	,
8691	3275	20	"	"	``
8691	3275	21	Report	Report	NNP
8691	3275	22	of	of	IN
8691	3275	23	the	the	DT
8691	3275	24	American	American	NNP
8691	3275	25	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	3275	26	Association	Association	NNP
8691	3275	27	for	for	IN
8691	3275	28	1896	1896	CD
8691	3275	29	,	,	,
8691	3275	30	I	I	NNP
8691	3275	31	,	,	,
8691	3275	32	139	139	CD
8691	3275	33	.	.	.
8691	3275	34	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3276	1	During	during	IN
8691	3276	2	the	the	DT
8691	3276	3	period	period	NN
8691	3276	4	of	of	IN
8691	3276	5	reconstruction	reconstruction	NN
8691	3276	6	in	in	IN
8691	3276	7	the	the	DT
8691	3276	8	Southern	Southern	NNP
8691	3276	9	States	States	NNP
8691	3276	10	,	,	,
8691	3276	11	following	follow	VBG
8691	3276	12	the	the	DT
8691	3276	13	civil	civil	JJ
8691	3276	14	war	war	NN
8691	3276	15	,	,	,
8691	3276	16	the	the	DT
8691	3276	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	3276	18	were	be	VBD
8691	3276	19	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
8691	3276	20	broken	break	VBN
8691	3276	21	up	up	RP
8691	3276	22	by	by	IN
8691	3276	23	violence	violence	NN
8691	3276	24	and	and	CC
8691	3276	25	the	the	DT
8691	3276	26	service	service	NN
8691	3276	27	of	of	IN
8691	3276	28	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3276	29	process	process	NN
8691	3276	30	resisted	resist	VBD
8691	3276	31	,	,	,
8691	3276	32	in	in	IN
8691	3276	33	some	some	DT
8691	3276	34	instances	instance	NNS
8691	3276	35	by	by	IN
8691	3276	36	authority	authority	NN
8691	3276	37	of	of	IN
8691	3276	38	the	the	DT
8691	3276	39	military	military	JJ
8691	3276	40	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3276	41	.	.	.
8691	3277	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3277	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3277	3	:	:	:
8691	3277	4	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3277	5	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3277	6	Cox	Cox	NNP
8691	3277	7	,	,	,
8691	3277	8	"	"	``
8691	3277	9	Three	Three	NNP
8691	3277	10	Decades	Decades	NNPS
8691	3277	11	of	of	IN
8691	3277	12	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	3277	13	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
8691	3277	14	,	,	,
8691	3277	15	"	"	''
8691	3277	16	469	469	CD
8691	3277	17	,	,	,
8691	3277	18	472	472	CD
8691	3277	19	,	,	,
8691	3277	20	495	495	CD
8691	3277	21	,	,	,
8691	3277	22	496	496	CD
8691	3277	23	,	,	,
8691	3277	24	509	509	CD
8691	3277	25	,	,	,
8691	3277	26	544	544	CD
8691	3277	27	,	,	,
8691	3277	28	565	565	CD
8691	3277	29	.	.	.
8691	3277	30	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3278	1	The	the	DT
8691	3278	2	writ	writ	NNP
8691	3278	3	to	to	TO
8691	3278	4	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	3278	5	the	the	DT
8691	3278	6	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3278	7	of	of	IN
8691	3278	8	a	a	DT
8691	3278	9	court	court	NN
8691	3278	10	of	of	IN
8691	3278	11	law	law	NN
8691	3278	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	3278	13	called	call	VBN
8691	3278	14	an	an	DT
8691	3278	15	execution	execution	NN
8691	3278	16	.	.	.
8691	3279	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3279	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3279	3	directed	direct	VBN
8691	3279	4	to	to	IN
8691	3279	5	the	the	DT
8691	3279	6	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	3279	7	or	or	CC
8691	3279	8	other	other	JJ
8691	3279	9	proper	proper	JJ
8691	3279	10	executive	executive	JJ
8691	3279	11	officer	officer	NN
8691	3279	12	,	,	,
8691	3279	13	and	and	CC
8691	3279	14	requires	require	VBZ
8691	3279	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3279	16	to	to	TO
8691	3279	17	seize	seize	VB
8691	3279	18	and	and	CC
8691	3279	19	sell	sell	VB
8691	3279	20	the	the	DT
8691	3279	21	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	3279	22	's	's	POS
8691	3279	23	property	property	NN
8691	3279	24	or	or	CC
8691	3279	25	,	,	,
8691	3279	26	as	as	IN
8691	3279	27	the	the	DT
8691	3279	28	case	case	NN
8691	3279	29	may	may	MD
8691	3279	30	be	be	VB
8691	3279	31	,	,	,
8691	3279	32	to	to	TO
8691	3279	33	arrest	arrest	VB
8691	3279	34	and	and	CC
8691	3279	35	imprison	imprison	VB
8691	3279	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3279	37	,	,	,
8691	3279	38	to	to	TO
8691	3279	39	turn	turn	VB
8691	3279	40	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3279	41	out	out	IN
8691	3279	42	of	of	IN
8691	3279	43	possession	possession	NN
8691	3279	44	of	of	IN
8691	3279	45	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3279	46	lands	land	NNS
8691	3279	47	,	,	,
8691	3279	48	or	or	CC
8691	3279	49	to	to	TO
8691	3279	50	take	take	VB
8691	3279	51	some	some	DT
8691	3279	52	other	other	JJ
8691	3279	53	active	active	JJ
8691	3279	54	step	step	NN
8691	3279	55	against	against	IN
8691	3279	56	one	one	CD
8691	3279	57	who	who	WP
8691	3279	58	has	have	VBZ
8691	3279	59	been	be	VBN
8691	3279	60	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
8691	3279	61	in	in	IN
8691	3279	62	the	the	DT
8691	3279	63	wrong	wrong	NN
8691	3279	64	,	,	,
8691	3279	65	in	in	IN
8691	3279	66	order	order	NN
8691	3279	67	to	to	TO
8691	3279	68	right	right	VB
8691	3279	69	the	the	DT
8691	3279	70	wrong	wrong	NN
8691	3279	71	,	,	,
8691	3279	72	as	as	IN
8691	3279	73	the	the	DT
8691	3279	74	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3279	75	may	may	MD
8691	3279	76	command	command	VB
8691	3279	77	.	.	.
8691	3280	1	A	a	DT
8691	3280	2	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3280	3	for	for	IN
8691	3280	4	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	3280	5	relief	relief	NN
8691	3280	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3280	7	not	not	RB
8691	3280	8	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	3280	9	the	the	DT
8691	3280	10	subject	subject	NN
8691	3280	11	of	of	IN
8691	3280	12	an	an	DT
8691	3280	13	execution	execution	NN
8691	3280	14	.	.	.
8691	3281	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3281	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3281	3	:	:	:
8691	3281	4	See	see	VB
8691	3281	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	3281	6	.	.	.
8691	3282	1	VIII	VIII	NNP
8691	3282	2	.	.	.
8691	3282	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3283	1	A	a	DT
8691	3283	2	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3283	3	at	at	IN
8691	3283	4	law	law	NN
8691	3283	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3283	6	generally	generally	RB
8691	3283	7	to	to	IN
8691	3283	8	the	the	DT
8691	3283	9	effect	effect	NN
8691	3283	10	that	that	IN
8691	3283	11	one	one	CD
8691	3283	12	of	of	IN
8691	3283	13	the	the	DT
8691	3283	14	parties	party	NNS
8691	3283	15	shall	shall	MD
8691	3283	16	recover	recover	VB
8691	3283	17	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3283	18	money	money	NN
8691	3283	19	or	or	CC
8691	3283	20	goods	good	NNS
8691	3283	21	or	or	CC
8691	3283	22	land	land	NN
8691	3283	23	from	from	IN
8691	3283	24	the	the	DT
8691	3283	25	other	other	JJ
8691	3283	26	.	.	.
8691	3284	1	On	on	IN
8691	3284	2	the	the	DT
8691	3284	3	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	3284	4	party	party	NN
8691	3284	5	lies	lie	VBZ
8691	3284	6	the	the	DT
8691	3284	7	burden	burden	NN
8691	3284	8	of	of	IN
8691	3284	9	moving	move	VBG
8691	3284	10	to	to	TO
8691	3284	11	get	get	VB
8691	3284	12	possession	possession	NN
8691	3284	13	of	of	IN
8691	3284	14	what	what	WP
8691	3284	15	has	have	VBZ
8691	3284	16	thus	thus	RB
8691	3284	17	been	be	VBN
8691	3284	18	adjudged	adjudge	VBN
8691	3284	19	to	to	TO
8691	3284	20	be	be	VB
8691	3284	21	due	due	JJ
8691	3284	22	.	.	.
8691	3285	1	This	this	DT
8691	3285	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3285	3	does	do	VBZ
8691	3285	4	by	by	IN
8691	3285	5	taking	take	VBG
8691	3285	6	out	out	RP
8691	3285	7	an	an	DT
8691	3285	8	execution	execution	NN
8691	3285	9	.	.	.
8691	3286	1	A	a	DT
8691	3286	2	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3286	3	in	in	IN
8691	3286	4	equity	equity	NN
8691	3286	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3286	6	an	an	DT
8691	3286	7	order	order	NN
8691	3286	8	on	on	IN
8691	3286	9	the	the	DT
8691	3286	10	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	3286	11	to	to	TO
8691	3286	12	do	do	VB
8691	3286	13	or	or	CC
8691	3286	14	not	not	RB
8691	3286	15	to	to	TO
8691	3286	16	do	do	VB
8691	3286	17	some	some	DT
8691	3286	18	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3286	19	act	act	NN
8691	3286	20	.	.	.
8691	3287	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3287	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3287	3	now	now	RB
8691	3287	4	an	an	DT
8691	3287	5	affair	affair	NN
8691	3287	6	between	between	IN
8691	3287	7	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3287	8	and	and	CC
8691	3287	9	the	the	DT
8691	3287	10	court	court	NN
8691	3287	11	.	.	.
8691	3288	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3288	2	must	must	MD
8691	3288	3	obey	obey	VB
8691	3288	4	this	this	DT
8691	3288	5	mandate	mandate	NN
8691	3288	6	or	or	CC
8691	3288	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3288	8	will	will	MD
8691	3288	9	be	be	VB
8691	3288	10	treating	treat	VBG
8691	3288	11	the	the	DT
8691	3288	12	court	court	NN
8691	3288	13	with	with	IN
8691	3288	14	disrespect	disrespect	NN
8691	3288	15	.	.	.
8691	3289	1	To	to	TO
8691	3289	2	treat	treat	VB
8691	3289	3	a	a	DT
8691	3289	4	court	court	NN
8691	3289	5	with	with	IN
8691	3289	6	disrespect	disrespect	NN
8691	3289	7	,	,	,
8691	3289	8	or	or	CC
8691	3289	9	,	,	,
8691	3289	10	in	in	IN
8691	3289	11	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3289	12	parlance	parlance	NN
8691	3289	13	,	,	,
8691	3289	14	to	to	TO
8691	3289	15	be	be	VB
8691	3289	16	in	in	IN
8691	3289	17	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3289	18	of	of	IN
8691	3289	19	court	court	NN
8691	3289	20	,	,	,
8691	3289	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	3289	22	to	to	TO
8691	3289	23	incur	incur	VB
8691	3289	24	very	very	RB
8691	3289	25	serious	serious	JJ
8691	3289	26	responsibilities	responsibility	NNS
8691	3289	27	.	.	.
8691	3290	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3290	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3290	3	in	in	IN
8691	3290	4	the	the	DT
8691	3290	5	nature	nature	NN
8691	3290	6	of	of	IN
8691	3290	7	a	a	DT
8691	3290	8	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3290	9	wrong	wrong	NN
8691	3290	10	,	,	,
8691	3290	11	for	for	IN
8691	3290	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3290	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	3290	14	a	a	DT
8691	3290	15	direct	direct	JJ
8691	3290	16	opposition	opposition	NN
8691	3290	17	to	to	IN
8691	3290	18	the	the	DT
8691	3290	19	expressed	express	VBN
8691	3290	20	will	will	NN
8691	3290	21	of	of	IN
8691	3290	22	the	the	DT
8691	3290	23	State	State	NNP
8691	3290	24	.	.	.
8691	3291	1	Whoever	whoever	WP
8691	3291	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3291	3	guilty	guilty	JJ
8691	3291	4	of	of	IN
8691	3291	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3291	6	makes	make	VBZ
8691	3291	7	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3291	8	liable	liable	JJ
8691	3291	9	to	to	TO
8691	3291	10	arrest	arrest	VB
8691	3291	11	and	and	CC
8691	3291	12	to	to	TO
8691	3291	13	be	be	VB
8691	3291	14	subjected	subject	VBN
8691	3291	15	to	to	IN
8691	3291	16	fine	fine	JJ
8691	3291	17	or	or	CC
8691	3291	18	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	3291	19	.	.	.
8691	3292	1	If	if	IN
8691	3292	2	,	,	,
8691	3292	3	for	for	IN
8691	3292	4	instance	instance	NN
8691	3292	5	,	,	,
8691	3292	6	an	an	DT
8691	3292	7	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	3292	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	3292	9	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	3292	10	in	in	IN
8691	3292	11	a	a	DT
8691	3292	12	suit	suit	NN
8691	3292	13	for	for	IN
8691	3292	14	the	the	DT
8691	3292	15	infringement	infringement	NN
8691	3292	16	of	of	IN
8691	3292	17	a	a	DT
8691	3292	18	patent	patent	NN
8691	3292	19	right	right	NN
8691	3292	20	,	,	,
8691	3292	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3292	22	becomes	become	VBZ
8691	3292	23	at	at	IN
8691	3292	24	once	once	IN
8691	3292	25	the	the	DT
8691	3292	26	duty	duty	NN
8691	3292	27	of	of	IN
8691	3292	28	the	the	DT
8691	3292	29	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	3292	30	to	to	TO
8691	3292	31	desist	desist	VB
8691	3292	32	from	from	IN
8691	3292	33	making	make	VBG
8691	3292	34	or	or	CC
8691	3292	35	selling	sell	VBG
8691	3292	36	what	what	WP
8691	3292	37	the	the	DT
8691	3292	38	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	3292	39	has	have	VBZ
8691	3292	40	proved	prove	VBN
8691	3292	41	that	that	IN
8691	3292	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3292	43	only	only	RB
8691	3292	44	can	can	MD
8691	3292	45	lawfully	lawfully	RB
8691	3292	46	make	make	VB
8691	3292	47	and	and	CC
8691	3292	48	sell	sell	VB
8691	3292	49	.	.	.
8691	3293	1	If	if	IN
8691	3293	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3293	3	does	do	VBZ
8691	3293	4	not	not	RB
8691	3293	5	desist	desist	VB
8691	3293	6	,	,	,
8691	3293	7	the	the	DT
8691	3293	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	3293	9	can	can	MD
8691	3293	10	complain	complain	VB
8691	3293	11	to	to	IN
8691	3293	12	the	the	DT
8691	3293	13	court	court	NN
8691	3293	14	,	,	,
8691	3293	15	and	and	CC
8691	3293	16	if	if	IN
8691	3293	17	after	after	IN
8691	3293	18	a	a	DT
8691	3293	19	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
8691	3293	20	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	3293	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3293	22	appears	appear	VBZ
8691	3293	23	that	that	IN
8691	3293	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3293	25	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	3293	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	3293	27	well	well	RB
8691	3293	28	founded	found	VBN
8691	3293	29	,	,	,
8691	3293	30	can	can	MD
8691	3293	31	obtain	obtain	VB
8691	3293	32	a	a	DT
8691	3293	33	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	3293	34	of	of	IN
8691	3293	35	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	3293	36	,	,	,
8691	3293	37	styled	style	VBD
8691	3293	38	a	a	DT
8691	3293	39	"	"	``
8691	3293	40	process	process	NN
8691	3293	41	of	of	IN
8691	3293	42	attachment	attachment	NN
8691	3293	43	.	.	.
8691	3293	44	"	"	''
8691	3294	1	On	on	IN
8691	3294	2	this	this	DT
8691	3294	3	,	,	,
8691	3294	4	the	the	DT
8691	3294	5	proper	proper	JJ
8691	3294	6	officer	officer	NN
8691	3294	7	takes	take	VBZ
8691	3294	8	the	the	DT
8691	3294	9	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	3294	10	into	into	IN
8691	3294	11	custody	custody	NN
8691	3294	12	,	,	,
8691	3294	13	and	and	CC
8691	3294	14	brings	bring	VBZ
8691	3294	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3294	16	before	before	IN
8691	3294	17	the	the	DT
8691	3294	18	court	court	NN
8691	3294	19	to	to	TO
8691	3294	20	answer	answer	VB
8691	3294	21	for	for	IN
8691	3294	22	violating	violate	VBG
8691	3294	23	the	the	DT
8691	3294	24	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	3294	25	order	order	NN
8691	3294	26	.	.	.
8691	3295	1	If	if	IN
8691	3295	2	the	the	DT
8691	3295	3	case	case	NN
8691	3295	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3295	5	an	an	DT
8691	3295	6	aggravated	aggravated	JJ
8691	3295	7	one	one	CD
8691	3295	8	,	,	,
8691	3295	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3295	10	will	will	MD
8691	3295	11	be	be	VB
8691	3295	12	both	both	DT
8691	3295	13	fined	fine	VBN
8691	3295	14	and	and	CC
8691	3295	15	imprisoned	imprison	VBN
8691	3295	16	,	,	,
8691	3295	17	and	and	CC
8691	3295	18	the	the	DT
8691	3295	19	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	3295	20	will	will	MD
8691	3295	21	be	be	VB
8691	3295	22	in	in	IN
8691	3295	23	the	the	DT
8691	3295	24	common	common	JJ
8691	3295	25	jail	jail	NN
8691	3295	26	for	for	IN
8691	3295	27	such	such	JJ
8691	3295	28	time	time	NN
8691	3295	29	as	as	IN
8691	3295	30	the	the	DT
8691	3295	31	court	court	NN
8691	3295	32	may	may	MD
8691	3295	33	order	order	VB
8691	3295	34	.	.	.
8691	3296	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3296	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3296	3	the	the	DT
8691	3296	4	sting	sting	NN
8691	3296	5	in	in	IN
8691	3296	6	the	the	DT
8691	3296	7	tail	tail	NN
8691	3296	8	of	of	IN
8691	3296	9	an	an	DT
8691	3296	10	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	3296	11	that	that	WDT
8691	3296	12	makes	make	VBZ
8691	3296	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3296	14	especially	especially	RB
8691	3296	15	formidable	formidable	JJ
8691	3296	16	.	.	.
8691	3297	1	The	the	DT
8691	3297	2	debtor	debtor	NN
8691	3297	3	who	who	WP
8691	3297	4	fails	fail	VBZ
8691	3297	5	to	to	TO
8691	3297	6	pay	pay	VB
8691	3297	7	to	to	IN
8691	3297	8	the	the	DT
8691	3297	9	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	3297	10	,	,	,
8691	3297	11	when	when	WRB
8691	3297	12	demand	demand	NN
8691	3297	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	3297	14	made	make	VBN
8691	3297	15	upon	upon	IN
8691	3297	16	an	an	DT
8691	3297	17	execution	execution	NN
8691	3297	18	,	,	,
8691	3297	19	a	a	DT
8691	3297	20	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3297	21	for	for	IN
8691	3297	22	money	money	NN
8691	3297	23	damages	damage	NNS
8691	3297	24	commits	commit	VBZ
8691	3297	25	no	no	DT
8691	3297	26	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3297	27	of	of	IN
8691	3297	28	court	court	NN
8691	3297	29	.	.	.
8691	3298	1	The	the	DT
8691	3298	2	man	man	NN
8691	3298	3	who	who	WP
8691	3298	4	keeps	keep	VBZ
8691	3298	5	on	on	RP
8691	3298	6	doing	do	VBG
8691	3298	7	what	what	WP
8691	3298	8	a	a	DT
8691	3298	9	court	court	NN
8691	3298	10	of	of	IN
8691	3298	11	equity	equity	NN
8691	3298	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	3298	13	forbidden	forbid	VBN
8691	3298	14	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3298	15	to	to	TO
8691	3298	16	do	do	VB
8691	3298	17	does	do	VBZ
8691	3298	18	commit	commit	VB
8691	3298	19	one	one	CD
8691	3298	20	.	.	.
8691	3299	1	A	a	DT
8691	3299	2	conspicuous	conspicuous	JJ
8691	3299	3	instance	instance	NN
8691	3299	4	of	of	IN
8691	3299	5	the	the	DT
8691	3299	6	efficacy	efficacy	NN
8691	3299	7	of	of	IN
8691	3299	8	an	an	DT
8691	3299	9	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	3299	10	was	be	VBD
8691	3299	11	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	3299	12	by	by	IN
8691	3299	13	the	the	DT
8691	3299	14	great	great	JJ
8691	3299	15	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
8691	3299	16	railroad	railroad	NN
8691	3299	17	strike	strike	NN
8691	3299	18	and	and	CC
8691	3299	19	boycott	boycott	NNP
8691	3299	20	of	of	IN
8691	3299	21	1894	1894	CD
8691	3299	22	,	,	,
8691	3299	23	initiated	initiate	VBN
8691	3299	24	by	by	IN
8691	3299	25	the	the	DT
8691	3299	26	American	American	NNP
8691	3299	27	Railway	Railway	NNP
8691	3299	28	Union	Union	NNP
8691	3299	29	.	.	.
8691	3300	1	Mob	mob	NN
8691	3300	2	violence	violence	NN
8691	3300	3	followed	follow	VBD
8691	3300	4	.	.	.
8691	3301	1	More	More	JJR
8691	3301	2	than	than	IN
8691	3301	3	a	a	DT
8691	3301	4	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	3301	5	freight	freight	NN
8691	3301	6	cars	car	NNS
8691	3301	7	were	be	VBD
8691	3301	8	burned	burn	VBN
8691	3301	9	.	.	.
8691	3302	1	Trains	train	NNS
8691	3302	2	were	be	VBD
8691	3302	3	derailed	derail	VBN
8691	3302	4	,	,	,
8691	3302	5	passengers	passenger	NNS
8691	3302	6	fired	fire	VBD
8691	3302	7	at	at	IN
8691	3302	8	,	,	,
8691	3302	9	and	and	CC
8691	3302	10	lives	live	VBZ
8691	3302	11	lost	lose	VBN
8691	3302	12	.	.	.
8691	3303	1	The	the	DT
8691	3303	2	officers	officer	NNS
8691	3303	3	of	of	IN
8691	3303	4	the	the	DT
8691	3303	5	union	union	NN
8691	3303	6	,	,	,
8691	3303	7	after	after	IN
8691	3303	8	two	two	CD
8691	3303	9	or	or	CC
8691	3303	10	three	three	CD
8691	3303	11	weeks	week	NNS
8691	3303	12	,	,	,
8691	3303	13	wrote	write	VBD
8691	3303	14	to	to	IN
8691	3303	15	the	the	DT
8691	3303	16	managers	manager	NNS
8691	3303	17	of	of	IN
8691	3303	18	the	the	DT
8691	3303	19	railroads	railroad	NNS
8691	3303	20	principally	principally	RB
8691	3303	21	affected	affect	VBN
8691	3303	22	,	,	,
8691	3303	23	describing	describe	VBG
8691	3303	24	the	the	DT
8691	3303	25	strike	strike	NN
8691	3303	26	as	as	IN
8691	3303	27	threatening	threaten	VBG
8691	3303	28	"	"	``
8691	3303	29	not	not	RB
8691	3303	30	only	only	RB
8691	3303	31	every	every	DT
8691	3303	32	public	public	JJ
8691	3303	33	interest	interest	NN
8691	3303	34	,	,	,
8691	3303	35	but	but	CC
8691	3303	36	the	the	DT
8691	3303	37	peace	peace	NN
8691	3303	38	,	,	,
8691	3303	39	security	security	NN
8691	3303	40	and	and	CC
8691	3303	41	prosperity	prosperity	NN
8691	3303	42	of	of	IN
8691	3303	43	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3303	44	common	common	JJ
8691	3303	45	country	country	NN
8691	3303	46	.	.	.
8691	3304	1	"	"	``
8691	3304	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3304	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3304	4	:	:	:
8691	3304	5	United	United	NNP
8691	3304	6	States	States	NNP
8691	3304	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3304	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	3304	9	_	_	NNP
8691	3304	10	Debs	Debs	NNP
8691	3304	11	,	,	,
8691	3304	12	64	64	CD
8691	3304	13	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	3304	14	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	3304	15	,	,	,
8691	3304	16	724	724	CD
8691	3304	17	,	,	,
8691	3304	18	729	729	CD
8691	3304	19	.	.	.
8691	3304	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3305	1	A	a	DT
8691	3305	2	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	3305	3	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	3305	4	was	be	VBD
8691	3305	5	issued	issue	VBN
8691	3305	6	against	against	IN
8691	3305	7	these	these	DT
8691	3305	8	officers	officer	NNS
8691	3305	9	and	and	CC
8691	3305	10	others	other	NNS
8691	3305	11	by	by	IN
8691	3305	12	the	the	DT
8691	3305	13	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	3305	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3305	15	of	of	IN
8691	3305	16	the	the	DT
8691	3305	17	United	United	NNP
8691	3305	18	States	States	NNP
8691	3305	19	in	in	IN
8691	3305	20	an	an	DT
8691	3305	21	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	3305	22	action	action	NN
8691	3305	23	brought	bring	VBN
8691	3305	24	by	by	IN
8691	3305	25	the	the	DT
8691	3305	26	United	United	NNP
8691	3305	27	States	States	NNP
8691	3305	28	under	under	IN
8691	3305	29	the	the	DT
8691	3305	30	direction	direction	NN
8691	3305	31	of	of	IN
8691	3305	32	the	the	DT
8691	3305	33	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
8691	3305	34	-	-	HYPH
8691	3305	35	General	General	NNP
8691	3305	36	.	.	.
8691	3306	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3306	2	disobeyed	disobey	VBD
8691	3306	3	the	the	DT
8691	3306	4	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	3306	5	.	.	.
8691	3307	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3307	2	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	3307	3	for	for	IN
8691	3307	4	this	this	DT
8691	3307	5	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3307	6	of	of	IN
8691	3307	7	court	court	NN
8691	3307	8	promptly	promptly	RB
8691	3307	9	followed	follow	VBD
8691	3307	10	.	.	.
8691	3308	1	This	this	DT
8691	3308	2	stopped	stop	VBD
8691	3308	3	the	the	DT
8691	3308	4	flood	flood	NN
8691	3308	5	at	at	IN
8691	3308	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3308	7	source	source	NN
8691	3308	8	.	.	.
8691	3309	1	To	to	TO
8691	3309	2	quote	quote	VB
8691	3309	3	from	from	IN
8691	3309	4	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	3309	5	given	give	VBN
8691	3309	6	a	a	DT
8691	3309	7	few	few	JJ
8691	3309	8	weeks	week	NNS
8691	3309	9	later	later	RB
8691	3309	10	by	by	IN
8691	3309	11	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	3309	12	Debs	Debs	NNP
8691	3309	13	,	,	,
8691	3309	14	the	the	DT
8691	3309	15	President	President	NNP
8691	3309	16	of	of	IN
8691	3309	17	the	the	DT
8691	3309	18	Union	Union	NNP
8691	3309	19	,	,	,
8691	3309	20	"	"	''
8691	3309	21	As	as	RB
8691	3309	22	soon	soon	RB
8691	3309	23	as	as	IN
8691	3309	24	the	the	DT
8691	3309	25	employees	employee	NNS
8691	3309	26	found	find	VBD
8691	3309	27	that	that	IN
8691	3309	28	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3309	29	were	be	VBD
8691	3309	30	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	3309	31	and	and	CC
8691	3309	32	taken	take	VBN
8691	3309	33	from	from	IN
8691	3309	34	the	the	DT
8691	3309	35	scene	scene	NN
8691	3309	36	of	of	IN
8691	3309	37	action	action	NN
8691	3309	38	,	,	,
8691	3309	39	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3309	40	became	become	VBD
8691	3309	41	demoralized	demoralize	VBN
8691	3309	42	and	and	CC
8691	3309	43	that	that	DT
8691	3309	44	ended	end	VBD
8691	3309	45	the	the	DT
8691	3309	46	strike	strike	NN
8691	3309	47	....	....	.
8691	3310	1	The	the	DT
8691	3310	2	men	man	NNS
8691	3310	3	went	go	VBD
8691	3310	4	back	back	RB
8691	3310	5	to	to	IN
8691	3310	6	work	work	NN
8691	3310	7	and	and	CC
8691	3310	8	the	the	DT
8691	3310	9	ranks	rank	NNS
8691	3310	10	were	be	VBD
8691	3310	11	broken	break	VBN
8691	3310	12	and	and	CC
8691	3310	13	the	the	DT
8691	3310	14	strike	strike	NN
8691	3310	15	was	be	VBD
8691	3310	16	broken	break	VBN
8691	3310	17	up	up	RP
8691	3310	18	,	,	,
8691	3310	19	...	...	:
8691	3310	20	not	not	RB
8691	3310	21	by	by	IN
8691	3310	22	the	the	DT
8691	3310	23	army	army	NN
8691	3310	24	,	,	,
8691	3310	25	and	and	CC
8691	3310	26	not	not	RB
8691	3310	27	by	by	IN
8691	3310	28	any	any	DT
8691	3310	29	other	other	JJ
8691	3310	30	power	power	NN
8691	3310	31	,	,	,
8691	3310	32	but	but	CC
8691	3310	33	simply	simply	RB
8691	3310	34	and	and	CC
8691	3310	35	solely	solely	RB
8691	3310	36	by	by	IN
8691	3310	37	the	the	DT
8691	3310	38	action	action	NN
8691	3310	39	of	of	IN
8691	3310	40	the	the	DT
8691	3310	41	United	United	NNP
8691	3310	42	States	States	NNP
8691	3310	43	court	court	NN
8691	3310	44	in	in	IN
8691	3310	45	restraining	restrain	VBG
8691	3310	46	us	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3310	47	from	from	IN
8691	3310	48	discharging	discharge	VBG
8691	3310	49	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3310	50	duties	duty	NNS
8691	3310	51	as	as	IN
8691	3310	52	officers	officer	NNS
8691	3310	53	and	and	CC
8691	3310	54	representatives	representative	NNS
8691	3310	55	of	of	IN
8691	3310	56	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3310	57	employees	employee	NNS
8691	3310	58	.	.	.
8691	3311	1	"	"	``
8691	3311	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3311	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3311	4	:	:	:
8691	3311	5	United	United	NNP
8691	3311	6	States	States	NNP
8691	3311	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3311	8	v.	v.	IN
8691	3311	9	_	_	NNP
8691	3311	10	Debs	Debs	NNP
8691	3311	11	,	,	,
8691	3311	12	64	64	CD
8691	3311	13	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	3311	14	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	3311	15	,	,	,
8691	3311	16	724	724	CD
8691	3311	17	,	,	,
8691	3311	18	759	759	CD
8691	3311	19	.	.	.
8691	3311	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3312	1	The	the	DT
8691	3312	2	defendants	defendant	NNS
8691	3312	3	in	in	IN
8691	3312	4	the	the	DT
8691	3312	5	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3312	6	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3312	7	having	have	VBG
8691	3312	8	been	be	VBN
8691	3312	9	found	find	VBN
8691	3312	10	guilty	guilty	JJ
8691	3312	11	and	and	CC
8691	3312	12	sentenced	sentence	VBN
8691	3312	13	to	to	IN
8691	3312	14	jail	jail	NN
8691	3312	15	for	for	IN
8691	3312	16	terms	term	NNS
8691	3312	17	varying	vary	VBG
8691	3312	18	from	from	IN
8691	3312	19	three	three	CD
8691	3312	20	to	to	TO
8691	3312	21	six	six	CD
8691	3312	22	months	month	NNS
8691	3312	23	,	,	,
8691	3312	24	appealed	appeal	VBD
8691	3312	25	to	to	IN
8691	3312	26	the	the	DT
8691	3312	27	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3312	28	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3312	29	of	of	IN
8691	3312	30	the	the	DT
8691	3312	31	United	United	NNP
8691	3312	32	States	States	NNP
8691	3312	33	,	,	,
8691	3312	34	but	but	CC
8691	3312	35	without	without	IN
8691	3312	36	avail	avail	NN
8691	3312	37	.	.	.
8691	3313	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3313	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3313	3	:	:	:
8691	3313	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3313	5	In	In	NNP
8691	3313	6	re	re	NN
8691	3313	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3313	8	Debs	Debs	NNP
8691	3313	9	,	,	,
8691	3313	10	158	158	CD
8691	3313	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	3313	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3313	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	3313	14	,	,	,
8691	3313	15	564	564	CD
8691	3313	16	,	,	,
8691	3313	17	600	600	CD
8691	3313	18	.	.	.
8691	3313	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3314	1	Injunctions	injunction	NNS
8691	3314	2	not	not	RB
8691	3314	3	infrequently	infrequently	RB
8691	3314	4	are	be	VBP
8691	3314	5	granted	grant	VBN
8691	3314	6	as	as	IN
8691	3314	7	an	an	DT
8691	3314	8	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	3314	9	relief	relief	NN
8691	3314	10	against	against	IN
8691	3314	11	a	a	DT
8691	3314	12	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3314	13	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3314	14	.	.	.
8691	3315	1	_	_	NNP
8691	3315	2	Summum	Summum	NNP
8691	3315	3	jus	jus	NN
8691	3315	4	,	,	,
8691	3315	5	summa	summa	VBP
8691	3315	6	injuria	injuria	NNP
8691	3315	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3315	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	3315	9	an	an	DT
8691	3315	10	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	3315	11	maxim	maxim	NN
8691	3315	12	of	of	IN
8691	3315	13	the	the	DT
8691	3315	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	3315	15	.	.	.
8691	3316	1	The	the	DT
8691	3316	2	foundation	foundation	NN
8691	3316	3	of	of	IN
8691	3316	4	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	3316	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3316	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3316	7	that	that	IN
8691	3316	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	3316	9	of	of	IN
8691	3316	10	law	law	NN
8691	3316	11	can	can	MD
8691	3316	12	not	not	RB
8691	3316	13	always	always	RB
8691	3316	14	do	do	VB
8691	3316	15	justice	justice	NN
8691	3316	16	.	.	.
8691	3317	1	One	one	CD
8691	3317	2	may	may	MD
8691	3317	3	,	,	,
8691	3317	4	for	for	IN
8691	3317	5	instance	instance	NN
8691	3317	6	,	,	,
8691	3317	7	be	be	VB
8691	3317	8	invited	invite	VBN
8691	3317	9	to	to	TO
8691	3317	10	build	build	VB
8691	3317	11	a	a	DT
8691	3317	12	house	house	NN
8691	3317	13	on	on	IN
8691	3317	14	another	another	DT
8691	3317	15	's	's	POS
8691	3317	16	land	land	NN
8691	3317	17	,	,	,
8691	3317	18	and	and	CC
8691	3317	19	promised	promise	VBD
8691	3317	20	a	a	DT
8691	3317	21	deed	deed	NN
8691	3317	22	of	of	IN
8691	3317	23	the	the	DT
8691	3317	24	site	site	NN
8691	3317	25	.	.	.
8691	3318	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3318	2	builds	build	VBZ
8691	3318	3	the	the	DT
8691	3318	4	house	house	NN
8691	3318	5	and	and	CC
8691	3318	6	then	then	RB
8691	3318	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3318	8	refused	refuse	VBN
8691	3318	9	a	a	DT
8691	3318	10	deed	deed	NN
8691	3318	11	.	.	.
8691	3319	1	The	the	DT
8691	3319	2	invitation	invitation	NN
8691	3319	3	and	and	CC
8691	3319	4	promise	promise	NN
8691	3319	5	were	be	VBD
8691	3319	6	by	by	IN
8691	3319	7	word	word	NN
8691	3319	8	of	of	IN
8691	3319	9	mouth	mouth	NN
8691	3319	10	.	.	.
8691	3320	1	The	the	DT
8691	3320	2	rules	rule	NNS
8691	3320	3	of	of	IN
8691	3320	4	law	law	NN
8691	3320	5	make	make	VBP
8691	3320	6	such	such	PDT
8691	3320	7	a	a	DT
8691	3320	8	house	house	NN
8691	3320	9	the	the	DT
8691	3320	10	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3320	11	property	property	NN
8691	3320	12	of	of	IN
8691	3320	13	the	the	DT
8691	3320	14	landowner	landowner	NN
8691	3320	15	.	.	.
8691	3321	1	The	the	DT
8691	3321	2	rules	rule	NNS
8691	3321	3	of	of	IN
8691	3321	4	equity	equity	NN
8691	3321	5	make	make	VBP
8691	3321	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3321	7	the	the	DT
8691	3321	8	equitable	equitable	JJ
8691	3321	9	property	property	NN
8691	3321	10	of	of	IN
8691	3321	11	the	the	DT
8691	3321	12	man	man	NN
8691	3321	13	who	who	WP
8691	3321	14	built	build	VBD
8691	3321	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3321	16	on	on	IN
8691	3321	17	the	the	DT
8691	3321	18	faith	faith	NN
8691	3321	19	of	of	IN
8691	3321	20	the	the	DT
8691	3321	21	landowner	landowner	NN
8691	3321	22	's	's	POS
8691	3321	23	invitation	invitation	NN
8691	3321	24	and	and	CC
8691	3321	25	promise	promise	NN
8691	3321	26	.	.	.
8691	3322	1	If	if	IN
8691	3322	2	the	the	DT
8691	3322	3	latter	latter	JJ
8691	3322	4	sue	sue	NN
8691	3322	5	at	at	IN
8691	3322	6	law	law	NN
8691	3322	7	for	for	IN
8691	3322	8	the	the	DT
8691	3322	9	possession	possession	NN
8691	3322	10	of	of	IN
8691	3322	11	the	the	DT
8691	3322	12	house	house	NN
8691	3322	13	,	,	,
8691	3322	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3322	15	may	may	MD
8691	3322	16	get	get	VB
8691	3322	17	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3322	18	,	,	,
8691	3322	19	but	but	CC
8691	3322	20	equity	equity	NN
8691	3322	21	will	will	MD
8691	3322	22	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	3322	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3322	24	enforcing	enforce	VBG
8691	3322	25	the	the	DT
8691	3322	26	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3322	27	,	,	,
8691	3322	28	not	not	RB
8691	3322	29	because	because	IN
8691	3322	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3322	31	is	be	VBZ
8691	3322	32	not	not	RB
8691	3322	33	a	a	DT
8691	3322	34	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3322	35	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3322	36	,	,	,
8691	3322	37	but	but	CC
8691	3322	38	because	because	IN
8691	3322	39	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3322	40	is	be	VBZ
8691	3322	41	endeavoring	endeavor	VBG
8691	3322	42	to	to	TO
8691	3322	43	make	make	VB
8691	3322	44	an	an	DT
8691	3322	45	inequitable	inequitable	JJ
8691	3322	46	use	use	NN
8691	3322	47	of	of	IN
8691	3322	48	a	a	DT
8691	3322	49	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3322	50	right	right	NN
8691	3322	51	.	.	.
8691	3323	1	A	a	DT
8691	3323	2	court	court	NN
8691	3323	3	of	of	IN
8691	3323	4	equity	equity	NN
8691	3323	5	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3323	6	makes	make	VBZ
8691	3323	7	a	a	DT
8691	3323	8	decree	decree	NN
8691	3323	9	establishing	establish	VBG
8691	3323	10	a	a	DT
8691	3323	11	title	title	NN
8691	3323	12	.	.	.
8691	3324	1	To	to	TO
8691	3324	2	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	3324	3	such	such	PDT
8691	3324	4	a	a	DT
8691	3324	5	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3324	6	,	,	,
8691	3324	7	a	a	DT
8691	3324	8	writ	writ	NN
8691	3324	9	may	may	MD
8691	3324	10	be	be	VB
8691	3324	11	issued	issue	VBN
8691	3324	12	,	,	,
8691	3324	13	called	call	VBN
8691	3324	14	a	a	DT
8691	3324	15	writ	writ	NN
8691	3324	16	of	of	IN
8691	3324	17	assistance	assistance	NN
8691	3324	18	.	.	.
8691	3325	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3325	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3325	3	directed	direct	VBN
8691	3325	4	to	to	IN
8691	3325	5	the	the	DT
8691	3325	6	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	3325	7	and	and	CC
8691	3325	8	requires	require	VBZ
8691	3325	9	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3325	10	to	to	TO
8691	3325	11	do	do	VB
8691	3325	12	some	some	DT
8691	3325	13	specific	specific	JJ
8691	3325	14	act	act	NN
8691	3325	15	,	,	,
8691	3325	16	such	such	JJ
8691	3325	17	as	as	IN
8691	3325	18	putting	put	VBG
8691	3325	19	the	the	DT
8691	3325	20	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	3325	21	out	out	IN
8691	3325	22	of	of	IN
8691	3325	23	possession	possession	NN
8691	3325	24	of	of	IN
8691	3325	25	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3325	26	lands	land	NNS
8691	3325	27	and	and	CC
8691	3325	28	turning	turn	VBG
8691	3325	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3325	30	over	over	RP
8691	3325	31	to	to	IN
8691	3325	32	the	the	DT
8691	3325	33	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	3325	34	.	.	.
8691	3326	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3326	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3326	3	,	,	,
8691	3326	4	as	as	IN
8691	3326	5	appears	appear	VBZ
8691	3326	6	from	from	IN
8691	3326	7	instances	instance	NNS
8691	3326	8	which	which	WDT
8691	3326	9	have	have	VBP
8691	3326	10	been	be	VBN
8691	3326	11	given	give	VBN
8691	3326	12	,	,	,
8691	3326	13	possible	possible	JJ
8691	3326	14	that	that	IN
8691	3326	15	the	the	DT
8691	3326	16	execution	execution	NN
8691	3326	17	of	of	IN
8691	3326	18	process	process	NN
8691	3326	19	from	from	IN
8691	3326	20	the	the	DT
8691	3326	21	courts	court	NNS
8691	3326	22	may	may	MD
8691	3326	23	be	be	VB
8691	3326	24	defeated	defeat	VBN
8691	3326	25	by	by	IN
8691	3326	26	violence	violence	NN
8691	3326	27	which	which	WDT
8691	3326	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3326	29	can	can	MD
8691	3326	30	not	not	RB
8691	3326	31	overcome	overcome	VB
8691	3326	32	.	.	.
8691	3327	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3327	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3327	3	possible	possible	JJ
8691	3327	4	in	in	IN
8691	3327	5	fact	fact	NN
8691	3327	6	though	though	IN
8691	3327	7	impossible	impossible	JJ
8691	3327	8	in	in	IN
8691	3327	9	theory	theory	NN
8691	3327	10	.	.	.
8691	3328	1	As	as	IN
8691	3328	2	the	the	DT
8691	3328	3	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	3328	4	can	can	MD
8691	3328	5	employ	employ	VB
8691	3328	6	the	the	DT
8691	3328	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3328	8	posse	posse	NN
8691	3328	9	comitatus	comitatus	NN
8691	3328	10	_	_	NNP
8691	3328	11	,	,	,
8691	3328	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3328	13	ought	ought	MD
8691	3328	14	always	always	RB
8691	3328	15	to	to	TO
8691	3328	16	have	have	VB
8691	3328	17	an	an	DT
8691	3328	18	overwhelming	overwhelming	JJ
8691	3328	19	force	force	NN
8691	3328	20	at	at	IN
8691	3328	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3328	22	command	command	NN
8691	3328	23	.	.	.
8691	3329	1	But	but	CC
8691	3329	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3329	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3329	4	easier	easy	JJR
8691	3329	5	to	to	TO
8691	3329	6	"	"	``
8691	3329	7	call	call	VB
8691	3329	8	spirits	spirit	NNS
8691	3329	9	from	from	IN
8691	3329	10	the	the	DT
8691	3329	11	vasty	vasty	JJ
8691	3329	12	deep	deep	NN
8691	3329	13	"	"	''
8691	3329	14	than	than	IN
8691	3329	15	to	to	TO
8691	3329	16	make	make	VB
8691	3329	17	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3329	18	respond	respond	VB
8691	3329	19	.	.	.
8691	3330	1	Public	public	JJ
8691	3330	2	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	3330	3	may	may	MD
8691	3330	4	be	be	VB
8691	3330	5	so	so	RB
8691	3330	6	strong	strong	JJ
8691	3330	7	in	in	IN
8691	3330	8	opposition	opposition	NN
8691	3330	9	to	to	IN
8691	3330	10	the	the	DT
8691	3330	11	service	service	NN
8691	3330	12	of	of	IN
8691	3330	13	the	the	DT
8691	3330	14	process	process	NN
8691	3330	15	that	that	WDT
8691	3330	16	mob	mob	NN
8691	3330	17	violence	violence	NN
8691	3330	18	will	will	MD
8691	3330	19	be	be	VB
8691	3330	20	tolerated	tolerate	VBN
8691	3330	21	and	and	CC
8691	3330	22	even	even	RB
8691	3330	23	openly	openly	RB
8691	3330	24	supported	support	VBN
8691	3330	25	.	.	.
8691	3331	1	An	an	DT
8691	3331	2	armed	armed	JJ
8691	3331	3	mob	mob	NN
8691	3331	4	can	can	MD
8691	3331	5	only	only	RB
8691	3331	6	be	be	VB
8691	3331	7	effectually	effectually	RB
8691	3331	8	met	meet	VBN
8691	3331	9	by	by	IN
8691	3331	10	an	an	DT
8691	3331	11	armed	armed	JJ
8691	3331	12	force	force	NN
8691	3331	13	which	which	WDT
8691	3331	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	3331	15	not	not	RB
8691	3331	16	a	a	DT
8691	3331	17	mob	mob	NN
8691	3331	18	--	--	:
8691	3331	19	that	that	RB
8691	3331	20	is	is	RB
8691	3331	21	,	,	,
8691	3331	22	by	by	IN
8691	3331	23	disciplined	discipline	VBN
8691	3331	24	soldiers	soldier	NNS
8691	3331	25	.	.	.
8691	3332	1	The	the	DT
8691	3332	2	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	3332	3	,	,	,
8691	3332	4	if	if	IN
8691	3332	5	so	so	RB
8691	3332	6	opposed	opposed	JJ
8691	3332	7	,	,	,
8691	3332	8	may	may	MD
8691	3332	9	call	call	VB
8691	3332	10	upon	upon	IN
8691	3332	11	the	the	DT
8691	3332	12	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3332	13	of	of	IN
8691	3332	14	the	the	DT
8691	3332	15	State	State	NNP
8691	3332	16	for	for	IN
8691	3332	17	military	military	JJ
8691	3332	18	assistance	assistance	NN
8691	3332	19	.	.	.
8691	3333	1	How	how	WRB
8691	3333	2	efficient	efficient	JJ
8691	3333	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3333	4	will	will	MD
8691	3333	5	prove	prove	VB
8691	3333	6	will	will	MD
8691	3333	7	,	,	,
8691	3333	8	of	of	IN
8691	3333	9	course	course	NN
8691	3333	10	,	,	,
8691	3333	11	depend	depend	VBP
8691	3333	12	on	on	IN
8691	3333	13	the	the	DT
8691	3333	14	discipline	discipline	NN
8691	3333	15	of	of	IN
8691	3333	16	the	the	DT
8691	3333	17	militia	militia	NN
8691	3333	18	and	and	CC
8691	3333	19	the	the	DT
8691	3333	20	firmness	firmness	NN
8691	3333	21	of	of	IN
8691	3333	22	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3333	23	commanding	command	VBG
8691	3333	24	officers	officer	NNS
8691	3333	25	.	.	.
8691	3334	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3334	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3334	3	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	3334	4	that	that	IN
8691	3334	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3334	6	fails	fail	VBZ
8691	3334	7	to	to	TO
8691	3334	8	restore	restore	VB
8691	3334	9	order	order	NN
8691	3334	10	,	,	,
8691	3334	11	if	if	IN
8691	3334	12	the	the	DT
8691	3334	13	men	man	NNS
8691	3334	14	carry	carry	VBP
8691	3334	15	loaded	loaded	JJ
8691	3334	16	guns	gun	NNS
8691	3334	17	and	and	CC
8691	3334	18	are	be	VBP
8691	3334	19	directed	direct	VBN
8691	3334	20	to	to	IN
8691	3334	21	fire	fire	VB
8691	3334	22	at	at	IN
8691	3334	23	the	the	DT
8691	3334	24	first	first	JJ
8691	3334	25	outbreak	outbreak	NN
8691	3334	26	of	of	IN
8691	3334	27	forcible	forcible	JJ
8691	3334	28	resistance	resistance	NN
8691	3334	29	.	.	.
8691	3335	1	But	but	CC
8691	3335	2	the	the	DT
8691	3335	3	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3335	4	may	may	MD
8691	3335	5	refuse	refuse	VB
8691	3335	6	to	to	TO
8691	3335	7	comply	comply	VB
8691	3335	8	with	with	IN
8691	3335	9	the	the	DT
8691	3335	10	sheriff	sheriff	NN
8691	3335	11	's	's	POS
8691	3335	12	request	request	NN
8691	3335	13	.	.	.
8691	3336	1	In	in	IN
8691	3336	2	such	such	JJ
8691	3336	3	case	case	NN
8691	3336	4	,	,	,
8691	3336	5	the	the	DT
8691	3336	6	execution	execution	NN
8691	3336	7	of	of	IN
8691	3336	8	the	the	DT
8691	3336	9	process	process	NN
8691	3336	10	of	of	IN
8691	3336	11	the	the	DT
8691	3336	12	court	court	NN
8691	3336	13	fails	fail	VBZ
8691	3336	14	because	because	RB
8691	3336	15	of	of	IN
8691	3336	16	want	want	NN
8691	3336	17	,	,	,
8691	3336	18	not	not	RB
8691	3336	19	of	of	IN
8691	3336	20	power	power	NN
8691	3336	21	,	,	,
8691	3336	22	but	but	CC
8691	3336	23	of	of	IN
8691	3336	24	the	the	DT
8691	3336	25	will	will	NN
8691	3336	26	to	to	TO
8691	3336	27	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	3336	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3336	29	on	on	IN
8691	3336	30	the	the	DT
8691	3336	31	part	part	NN
8691	3336	32	of	of	IN
8691	3336	33	those	those	DT
8691	3336	34	on	on	IN
8691	3336	35	whom	whom	WP
8691	3336	36	that	that	IN
8691	3336	37	duty	duty	NN
8691	3336	38	rests	rest	NNS
8691	3336	39	.	.	.
8691	3337	1	In	in	IN
8691	3337	2	every	every	DT
8691	3337	3	government	government	NN
8691	3337	4	constituted	constitute	VBN
8691	3337	5	by	by	IN
8691	3337	6	a	a	DT
8691	3337	7	distribution	distribution	NN
8691	3337	8	of	of	IN
8691	3337	9	the	the	DT
8691	3337	10	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	3337	11	authority	authority	NNP
8691	3337	12	between	between	IN
8691	3337	13	different	different	JJ
8691	3337	14	departments	department	NNS
8691	3337	15	,	,	,
8691	3337	16	each	each	DT
8691	3337	17	of	of	IN
8691	3337	18	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3337	19	must	must	MD
8691	3337	20	do	do	VB
8691	3337	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3337	22	part	part	NN
8691	3337	23	loyally	loyally	RB
8691	3337	24	with	with	IN
8691	3337	25	respect	respect	NN
8691	3337	26	to	to	IN
8691	3337	27	the	the	DT
8691	3337	28	others	other	NNS
8691	3337	29	,	,	,
8691	3337	30	or	or	CC
8691	3337	31	the	the	DT
8691	3337	32	whole	whole	JJ
8691	3337	33	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	3337	34	,	,	,
8691	3337	35	for	for	IN
8691	3337	36	the	the	DT
8691	3337	37	time	time	NN
8691	3337	38	being	being	NN
8691	3337	39	,	,	,
8691	3337	40	breaks	break	VBZ
8691	3337	41	down	down	RP
8691	3337	42	.	.	.
8691	3338	1	In	in	IN
8691	3338	2	the	the	DT
8691	3338	3	United	United	NNP
8691	3338	4	States	States	NNP
8691	3338	5	this	this	DT
8691	3338	6	danger	danger	NN
8691	3338	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3338	8	doubly	doubly	RB
8691	3338	9	great	great	JJ
8691	3338	10	because	because	IN
8691	3338	11	of	of	IN
8691	3338	12	the	the	DT
8691	3338	13	interdependence	interdependence	NN
8691	3338	14	of	of	IN
8691	3338	15	the	the	DT
8691	3338	16	general	general	JJ
8691	3338	17	government	government	NN
8691	3338	18	and	and	CC
8691	3338	19	the	the	DT
8691	3338	20	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3338	21	States	States	NNP
8691	3338	22	.	.	.
8691	3339	1	Judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3339	2	process	process	NN
8691	3339	3	may	may	MD
8691	3339	4	issue	issue	VB
8691	3339	5	from	from	IN
8691	3339	6	a	a	DT
8691	3339	7	State	State	NNP
8691	3339	8	court	court	NN
8691	3339	9	against	against	IN
8691	3339	10	those	those	DT
8691	3339	11	who	who	WP
8691	3339	12	oppose	oppose	VBP
8691	3339	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3339	14	execution	execution	NN
8691	3339	15	under	under	IN
8691	3339	16	claim	claim	NN
8691	3339	17	of	of	IN
8691	3339	18	authority	authority	NN
8691	3339	19	from	from	IN
8691	3339	20	the	the	DT
8691	3339	21	United	United	NNP
8691	3339	22	States	States	NNP
8691	3339	23	;	;	:
8691	3339	24	or	or	CC
8691	3339	25	from	from	IN
8691	3339	26	a	a	DT
8691	3339	27	federal	federal	JJ
8691	3339	28	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3339	29	against	against	IN
8691	3339	30	those	those	DT
8691	3339	31	who	who	WP
8691	3339	32	oppose	oppose	VBP
8691	3339	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3339	34	execution	execution	NN
8691	3339	35	under	under	IN
8691	3339	36	claim	claim	NN
8691	3339	37	of	of	IN
8691	3339	38	authority	authority	NN
8691	3339	39	from	from	IN
8691	3339	40	a	a	DT
8691	3339	41	State	state	NN
8691	3339	42	.	.	.
8691	3340	1	Some	some	DT
8691	3340	2	instances	instance	NNS
8691	3340	3	of	of	IN
8691	3340	4	such	such	JJ
8691	3340	5	conflicts	conflict	NNS
8691	3340	6	of	of	IN
8691	3340	7	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3340	8	have	have	VBP
8691	3340	9	been	be	VBN
8691	3340	10	already	already	RB
8691	3340	11	mentioned	mention	VBN
8691	3340	12	.	.	.
8691	3341	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3341	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3341	3	:	:	:
8691	3341	4	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	3341	5	.	.	.
8691	3342	1	X.	X.	NNP
8691	3342	2	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3343	1	When	when	WRB
8691	3343	2	the	the	DT
8691	3343	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3343	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3343	5	of	of	IN
8691	3343	6	the	the	DT
8691	3343	7	United	United	NNP
8691	3343	8	States	States	NNP
8691	3343	9	reverses	reverse	VBZ
8691	3343	10	a	a	DT
8691	3343	11	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3343	12	of	of	IN
8691	3343	13	a	a	DT
8691	3343	14	State	State	NNP
8691	3343	15	court	court	NN
8691	3343	16	,	,	,
8691	3343	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3343	18	can	can	MD
8691	3343	19	either[Footnote	either[footnote	XX
8691	3343	20	:	:	:
8691	3343	21	U.	U.	NNP
8691	3343	22	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3343	23	Revised	Revised	NNP
8691	3343	24	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	3343	25	,	,	,
8691	3343	26	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	3343	27	.	.	.
8691	3344	1	709	709	CD
8691	3344	2	.	.	.
8691	3344	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3345	1	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3345	2	render	render	VBP
8691	3345	3	the	the	DT
8691	3345	4	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3345	5	which	which	WDT
8691	3345	6	the	the	DT
8691	3345	7	State	State	NNP
8691	3345	8	court	court	NN
8691	3345	9	ought	ought	MD
8691	3345	10	to	to	TO
8691	3345	11	have	have	VB
8691	3345	12	rendered	render	VBN
8691	3345	13	,	,	,
8691	3345	14	and	and	CC
8691	3345	15	issue	issue	VB
8691	3345	16	execution	execution	NN
8691	3345	17	,	,	,
8691	3345	18	or	or	CC
8691	3345	19	remand	remand	VB
8691	3345	20	the	the	DT
8691	3345	21	cause	cause	NN
8691	3345	22	to	to	IN
8691	3345	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3345	24	with	with	IN
8691	3345	25	directions	direction	NNS
8691	3345	26	that	that	IN
8691	3345	27	this	this	DT
8691	3345	28	be	be	VB
8691	3345	29	done	do	VBN
8691	3345	30	.	.	.
8691	3346	1	If	if	IN
8691	3346	2	the	the	DT
8691	3346	3	latter	latter	JJ
8691	3346	4	course	course	NN
8691	3346	5	be	be	VB
8691	3346	6	taken	take	VBN
8691	3346	7	,	,	,
8691	3346	8	the	the	DT
8691	3346	9	directions	direction	NNS
8691	3346	10	may	may	MD
8691	3346	11	be	be	VB
8691	3346	12	disobeyed	disobey	VBN
8691	3346	13	.	.	.
8691	3347	1	A	a	DT
8691	3347	2	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	3347	3	court	court	NN
8691	3347	4	was	be	VBD
8691	3347	5	guilty	guilty	JJ
8691	3347	6	of	of	IN
8691	3347	7	this	this	DT
8691	3347	8	contumacy	contumacy	NN
8691	3347	9	in	in	IN
8691	3347	10	the	the	DT
8691	3347	11	case	case	NN
8691	3347	12	of	of	IN
8691	3347	13	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
8691	3347	14	_	_	NNP
8691	3347	15	v.	v.	IN
8691	3347	16	_	_	NNP
8691	3347	17	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	3347	18	.	.	.
8691	3348	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3348	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3348	3	:	:	:
8691	3348	4	6	6	CD
8691	3348	5	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	3348	6	'	'	POS
8691	3348	7	Reports	report	NNS
8691	3348	8	,	,	,
8691	3348	9	515	515	CD
8691	3348	10	,	,	,
8691	3348	11	596	596	CD
8691	3348	12	.	.	.
8691	3348	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3349	1	If	if	IN
8691	3349	2	the	the	DT
8691	3349	3	former	former	JJ
8691	3349	4	course	course	NN
8691	3349	5	be	be	VB
8691	3349	6	taken	take	VBN
8691	3349	7	,	,	,
8691	3349	8	the	the	DT
8691	3349	9	service	service	NN
8691	3349	10	of	of	IN
8691	3349	11	the	the	DT
8691	3349	12	execution	execution	NN
8691	3349	13	may	may	MD
8691	3349	14	be	be	VB
8691	3349	15	resisted	resist	VBN
8691	3349	16	by	by	IN
8691	3349	17	the	the	DT
8691	3349	18	power	power	NN
8691	3349	19	of	of	IN
8691	3349	20	the	the	DT
8691	3349	21	State	State	NNP
8691	3349	22	.	.	.
8691	3350	1	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
8691	3350	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3350	3	illegally	illegally	RB
8691	3350	4	confined	confine	VBN
8691	3350	5	in	in	IN
8691	3350	6	the	the	DT
8691	3350	7	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	3350	8	penitentiary	penitentiary	NN
8691	3350	9	.	.	.
8691	3351	1	The	the	DT
8691	3351	2	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	3351	3	against	against	IN
8691	3351	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3351	5	had	have	VBD
8691	3351	6	been	be	VBN
8691	3351	7	set	set	VBN
8691	3351	8	aside	aside	RB
8691	3351	9	and	and	CC
8691	3351	10	the	the	DT
8691	3351	11	indictment	indictment	NN
8691	3351	12	adjudged	adjudge	VBD
8691	3351	13	to	to	TO
8691	3351	14	furnish	furnish	VB
8691	3351	15	no	no	DT
8691	3351	16	ground	ground	NN
8691	3351	17	of	of	IN
8691	3351	18	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	3351	19	.	.	.
8691	3352	1	But	but	CC
8691	3352	2	if	if	IN
8691	3352	3	the	the	DT
8691	3352	4	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3352	5	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3352	6	had	have	VBD
8691	3352	7	rendered	render	VBN
8691	3352	8	a	a	DT
8691	3352	9	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3352	10	dismissing	dismiss	VBG
8691	3352	11	the	the	DT
8691	3352	12	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	3352	13	,	,	,
8691	3352	14	and	and	CC
8691	3352	15	given	give	VBN
8691	3352	16	a	a	DT
8691	3352	17	writ	writ	NN
8691	3352	18	to	to	IN
8691	3352	19	the	the	DT
8691	3352	20	marshal	marshal	NN
8691	3352	21	directing	direct	VBG
8691	3352	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3352	23	to	to	TO
8691	3352	24	set	set	VB
8691	3352	25	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
8691	3352	26	at	at	IN
8691	3352	27	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	3352	28	,	,	,
8691	3352	29	the	the	DT
8691	3352	30	officer	officer	NN
8691	3352	31	would	would	MD
8691	3352	32	have	have	VB
8691	3352	33	found	find	VBN
8691	3352	34	the	the	DT
8691	3352	35	prison	prison	NN
8691	3352	36	doors	door	NNS
8691	3352	37	shut	shut	VBN
8691	3352	38	in	in	IN
8691	3352	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3352	40	face	face	NN
8691	3352	41	.	.	.
8691	3353	1	Every	every	DT
8691	3353	2	prison	prison	NN
8691	3353	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3353	4	a	a	DT
8691	3353	5	fortress	fortress	NN
8691	3353	6	,	,	,
8691	3353	7	so	so	RB
8691	3353	8	built	build	VBN
8691	3353	9	as	as	IN
8691	3353	10	to	to	TO
8691	3353	11	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	3353	12	rescue	rescue	NN
8691	3353	13	from	from	IN
8691	3353	14	without	without	IN
8691	3353	15	as	as	RB
8691	3353	16	well	well	RB
8691	3353	17	as	as	IN
8691	3353	18	escape	escape	NN
8691	3353	19	from	from	IN
8691	3353	20	within	within	IN
8691	3353	21	.	.	.
8691	3354	1	To	to	TO
8691	3354	2	lay	lay	VB
8691	3354	3	siege	siege	NN
8691	3354	4	to	to	IN
8691	3354	5	one	one	PRP
8691	3354	6	would	would	MD
8691	3354	7	be	be	VB
8691	3354	8	too	too	RB
8691	3354	9	great	great	JJ
8691	3354	10	an	an	DT
8691	3354	11	enterprise	enterprise	NN
8691	3354	12	for	for	IN
8691	3354	13	the	the	DT
8691	3354	14	marshal	marshal	NN
8691	3354	15	to	to	TO
8691	3354	16	undertake	undertake	VB
8691	3354	17	without	without	IN
8691	3354	18	military	military	JJ
8691	3354	19	assistance	assistance	NN
8691	3354	20	.	.	.
8691	3355	1	For	for	IN
8691	3355	2	this	this	DT
8691	3355	3	the	the	DT
8691	3355	4	President	President	NNP
8691	3355	5	could	could	MD
8691	3355	6	have	have	VB
8691	3355	7	been	be	VBN
8691	3355	8	called	call	VBN
8691	3355	9	upon	upon	IN
8691	3355	10	.	.	.
8691	3356	1	But	but	CC
8691	3356	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3356	3	might	may	MD
8691	3356	4	have	have	VB
8691	3356	5	refused	refuse	VBN
8691	3356	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3356	7	.	.	.
8691	3357	1	If	if	IN
8691	3357	2	so	so	RB
8691	3357	3	,	,	,
8691	3357	4	the	the	DT
8691	3357	5	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3357	6	of	of	IN
8691	3357	7	the	the	DT
8691	3357	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3357	9	department	department	NN
8691	3357	10	would	would	MD
8691	3357	11	have	have	VB
8691	3357	12	proved	prove	VBN
8691	3357	13	inoperative	inoperative	JJ
8691	3357	14	,	,	,
8691	3357	15	simply	simply	RB
8691	3357	16	because	because	IN
8691	3357	17	the	the	DT
8691	3357	18	officer	officer	NN
8691	3357	19	charged	charge	VBD
8691	3357	20	with	with	IN
8691	3357	21	the	the	DT
8691	3357	22	duty	duty	NN
8691	3357	23	of	of	IN
8691	3357	24	rendering	render	VBG
8691	3357	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3357	26	operative	operative	JJ
8691	3357	27	had	have	VBD
8691	3357	28	declined	decline	VBN
8691	3357	29	to	to	TO
8691	3357	30	fulfil	fulfil	VB
8691	3357	31	that	that	DT
8691	3357	32	duty	duty	NN
8691	3357	33	.	.	.
8691	3358	1	The	the	DT
8691	3358	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3358	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3358	4	,	,	,
8691	3358	5	in	in	IN
8691	3358	6	the	the	DT
8691	3358	7	Worcester	Worcester	NNP
8691	3358	8	case	case	NN
8691	3358	9	,	,	,
8691	3358	10	probably	probably	RB
8691	3358	11	had	have	VBD
8691	3358	12	reason	reason	NN
8691	3358	13	to	to	TO
8691	3358	14	believe	believe	VB
8691	3358	15	that	that	IN
8691	3358	16	if	if	IN
8691	3358	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3358	18	had	have	VBD
8691	3358	19	directed	direct	VBN
8691	3358	20	a	a	DT
8691	3358	21	call	call	NN
8691	3358	22	on	on	IN
8691	3358	23	President	President	NNP
8691	3358	24	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	3358	25	for	for	IN
8691	3358	26	a	a	DT
8691	3358	27	military	military	JJ
8691	3358	28	force	force	NN
8691	3358	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3358	30	would	would	MD
8691	3358	31	have	have	VB
8691	3358	32	been	be	VBN
8691	3358	33	refused	refuse	VBN
8691	3358	34	.	.	.
8691	3359	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3359	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3359	3	reported	report	VBN
8691	3359	4	that	that	IN
8691	3359	5	the	the	DT
8691	3359	6	President	President	NNP
8691	3359	7	,	,	,
8691	3359	8	in	in	IN
8691	3359	9	private	private	JJ
8691	3359	10	conversation	conversation	NN
8691	3359	11	,	,	,
8691	3359	12	intimated	intimate	VBN
8691	3359	13	as	as	RB
8691	3359	14	much	much	JJ
8691	3359	15	.	.	.
8691	3360	1	Possibly	possibly	RB
8691	3360	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3360	3	might	may	MD
8691	3360	4	have	have	VB
8691	3360	5	been	be	VBN
8691	3360	6	justified	justify	VBN
8691	3360	7	in	in	IN
8691	3360	8	the	the	DT
8691	3360	9	refusal	refusal	NN
8691	3360	10	.	.	.
8691	3361	1	South	South	NNP
8691	3361	2	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	3361	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3361	4	on	on	IN
8691	3361	5	the	the	DT
8691	3361	6	brink	brink	NN
8691	3361	7	of	of	IN
8691	3361	8	war	war	NN
8691	3361	9	with	with	IN
8691	3361	10	the	the	DT
8691	3361	11	United	United	NNP
8691	3361	12	States	States	NNP
8691	3361	13	.	.	.
8691	3362	1	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	3362	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3362	3	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3362	4	next	next	JJ
8691	3362	5	neighbor	neighbor	NN
8691	3362	6	,	,	,
8691	3362	7	and	and	CC
8691	3362	8	might	may	MD
8691	3362	9	have	have	VB
8691	3362	10	been	be	VBN
8691	3362	11	induced	induce	VBN
8691	3362	12	to	to	TO
8691	3362	13	make	make	VB
8691	3362	14	common	common	JJ
8691	3362	15	cause	cause	VB
8691	3362	16	with	with	IN
8691	3362	17	her	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3362	18	,	,	,
8691	3362	19	if	if	IN
8691	3362	20	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	3362	21	had	have	VBD
8691	3362	22	battered	batter	VBN
8691	3362	23	down	down	RP
8691	3362	24	the	the	DT
8691	3362	25	doors	door	NNS
8691	3362	26	of	of	IN
8691	3362	27	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3362	28	penitentiary	penitentiary	JJ
8691	3362	29	to	to	TO
8691	3362	30	release	release	VB
8691	3362	31	a	a	DT
8691	3362	32	man	man	NN
8691	3362	33	who	who	WP
8691	3362	34	,	,	,
8691	3362	35	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3362	36	courts	court	NNS
8691	3362	37	insisted	insist	VBD
8691	3362	38	,	,	,
8691	3362	39	had	have	VBD
8691	3362	40	been	be	VBN
8691	3362	41	properly	properly	RB
8691	3362	42	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	3362	43	of	of	IN
8691	3362	44	a	a	DT
8691	3362	45	serious	serious	JJ
8691	3362	46	crime	crime	NN
8691	3362	47	.	.	.
8691	3363	1	A	a	DT
8691	3363	2	court	court	NN
8691	3363	3	can	can	MD
8691	3363	4	do	do	VB
8691	3363	5	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	3363	6	short	short	JJ
8691	3363	7	of	of	IN
8691	3363	8	justice	justice	NN
8691	3363	9	.	.	.
8691	3364	1	The	the	DT
8691	3364	2	executive	executive	JJ
8691	3364	3	power	power	NN
8691	3364	4	,	,	,
8691	3364	5	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	3364	6	,	,	,
8691	3364	7	may	may	MD
8691	3364	8	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3364	9	rightly	rightly	RB
8691	3364	10	act	act	VB
8691	3364	11	or	or	CC
8691	3364	12	decline	decline	VBP
8691	3364	13	to	to	TO
8691	3364	14	act	act	VB
8691	3364	15	from	from	IN
8691	3364	16	motives	motive	NNS
8691	3364	17	of	of	IN
8691	3364	18	national	national	JJ
8691	3364	19	policy	policy	NN
8691	3364	20	.	.	.
8691	3365	1	In	in	IN
8691	3365	2	one	one	CD
8691	3365	3	instance	instance	NN
8691	3365	4	the	the	DT
8691	3365	5	armed	armed	JJ
8691	3365	6	forces	force	NNS
8691	3365	7	of	of	IN
8691	3365	8	a	a	DT
8691	3365	9	State	state	NN
8691	3365	10	were	be	VBD
8691	3365	11	actually	actually	RB
8691	3365	12	engaged	engage	VBN
8691	3365	13	,	,	,
8691	3365	14	under	under	IN
8691	3365	15	the	the	DT
8691	3365	16	authority	authority	NN
8691	3365	17	of	of	IN
8691	3365	18	the	the	DT
8691	3365	19	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3365	20	,	,	,
8691	3365	21	in	in	IN
8691	3365	22	forcibly	forcibly	RB
8691	3365	23	resisting	resist	VBG
8691	3365	24	the	the	DT
8691	3365	25	service	service	NN
8691	3365	26	of	of	IN
8691	3365	27	process	process	NN
8691	3365	28	from	from	IN
8691	3365	29	the	the	DT
8691	3365	30	federal	federal	JJ
8691	3365	31	courts	court	NNS
8691	3365	32	.	.	.
8691	3366	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3366	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3366	3	in	in	IN
8691	3366	4	1809	1809	CD
8691	3366	5	,	,	,
8691	3366	6	when	when	WRB
8691	3366	7	the	the	DT
8691	3366	8	marshal	marshal	NN
8691	3366	9	in	in	IN
8691	3366	10	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3366	11	was	be	VBD
8691	3366	12	opposed	oppose	VBN
8691	3366	13	by	by	IN
8691	3366	14	a	a	DT
8691	3366	15	large	large	JJ
8691	3366	16	body	body	NN
8691	3366	17	of	of	IN
8691	3366	18	the	the	DT
8691	3366	19	militia	militia	NN
8691	3366	20	called	call	VBN
8691	3366	21	out	out	RP
8691	3366	22	by	by	IN
8691	3366	23	order	order	NN
8691	3366	24	of	of	IN
8691	3366	25	the	the	DT
8691	3366	26	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3366	27	for	for	IN
8691	3366	28	the	the	DT
8691	3366	29	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	3366	30	.	.	.
8691	3367	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3367	2	commanding	commanding	JJ
8691	3367	3	officer	officer	NN
8691	3367	4	was	be	VBD
8691	3367	5	subsequently	subsequently	RB
8691	3367	6	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	3367	7	and	and	CC
8691	3367	8	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	3367	9	for	for	IN
8691	3367	10	the	the	DT
8691	3367	11	offense	offense	NN
8691	3367	12	in	in	IN
8691	3367	13	the	the	DT
8691	3367	14	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	3367	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3367	16	of	of	IN
8691	3367	17	the	the	DT
8691	3367	18	United	United	NNP
8691	3367	19	States	States	NNP
8691	3367	20	.	.	.
8691	3368	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3368	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3368	3	:	:	:
8691	3368	4	Wharton	Wharton	NNP
8691	3368	5	's	's	POS
8691	3368	6	State	State	NNP
8691	3368	7	Trials	Trials	NNPS
8691	3368	8	,	,	,
8691	3368	9	48	48	CD
8691	3368	10	;	;	:
8691	3368	11	McMaster	McMaster	NNP
8691	3368	12	,	,	,
8691	3368	13	"	"	``
8691	3368	14	History	history	NN
8691	3368	15	of	of	IN
8691	3368	16	the	the	DT
8691	3368	17	People	People	NNS
8691	3368	18	of	of	IN
8691	3368	19	the	the	DT
8691	3368	20	U.	U.	NNP
8691	3368	21	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3368	22	,	,	,
8691	3368	23	"	"	``
8691	3368	24	V	V	NNP
8691	3368	25	,	,	,
8691	3368	26	405	405	CD
8691	3368	27	;	;	:
8691	3368	28	Willoughby	Willoughby	NNP
8691	3368	29	,	,	,
8691	3368	30	"	"	''
8691	3368	31	The	the	DT
8691	3368	32	American	American	NNP
8691	3368	33	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
8691	3368	34	System	System	NNP
8691	3368	35	,	,	,
8691	3368	36	"	"	''
8691	3368	37	41	41	CD
8691	3368	38	,	,	,
8691	3368	39	43	43	CD
8691	3368	40	.	.	.
8691	3368	41	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3369	1	In	in	IN
8691	3369	2	1859	1859	CD
8691	3369	3	,	,	,
8691	3369	4	the	the	DT
8691	3369	5	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3369	6	of	of	IN
8691	3369	7	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	3369	8	refused	refuse	VBD
8691	3369	9	to	to	TO
8691	3369	10	honor	honor	VB
8691	3369	11	a	a	DT
8691	3369	12	requisition	requisition	NN
8691	3369	13	from	from	IN
8691	3369	14	the	the	DT
8691	3369	15	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3369	16	of	of	IN
8691	3369	17	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	3369	18	for	for	IN
8691	3369	19	the	the	DT
8691	3369	20	surrender	surrender	NN
8691	3369	21	of	of	IN
8691	3369	22	a	a	DT
8691	3369	23	fugitive	fugitive	NN
8691	3369	24	from	from	IN
8691	3369	25	justice	justice	NN
8691	3369	26	.	.	.
8691	3370	1	The	the	DT
8691	3370	2	act	act	NN
8691	3370	3	charged	charge	VBD
8691	3370	4	was	be	VBD
8691	3370	5	assisting	assist	VBG
8691	3370	6	a	a	DT
8691	3370	7	slave	slave	NN
8691	3370	8	to	to	TO
8691	3370	9	escape	escape	VB
8691	3370	10	.	.	.
8691	3371	1	This	this	DT
8691	3371	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3371	3	a	a	DT
8691	3371	4	crime	crime	NN
8691	3371	5	in	in	IN
8691	3371	6	the	the	DT
8691	3371	7	State	State	NNP
8691	3371	8	from	from	IN
8691	3371	9	which	which	WDT
8691	3371	10	the	the	DT
8691	3371	11	man	man	NN
8691	3371	12	had	have	VBD
8691	3371	13	fled	flee	VBN
8691	3371	14	,	,	,
8691	3371	15	but	but	CC
8691	3371	16	not	not	RB
8691	3371	17	in	in	IN
8691	3371	18	the	the	DT
8691	3371	19	State	State	NNP
8691	3371	20	where	where	WRB
8691	3371	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3371	22	had	have	VBD
8691	3371	23	found	find	VBN
8691	3371	24	refuge	refuge	NN
8691	3371	25	.	.	.
8691	3372	1	The	the	DT
8691	3372	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3372	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3372	4	of	of	IN
8691	3372	5	the	the	DT
8691	3372	6	United	United	NNP
8691	3372	7	States	States	NNP
8691	3372	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3372	9	asked	ask	VBN
8691	3372	10	by	by	IN
8691	3372	11	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	3372	12	to	to	TO
8691	3372	13	compel	compel	VB
8691	3372	14	the	the	DT
8691	3372	15	surrender	surrender	NN
8691	3372	16	.	.	.
8691	3373	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3373	2	held	hold	VBD
8691	3373	3	that	that	IN
8691	3373	4	the	the	DT
8691	3373	5	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3373	6	had	have	VBD
8691	3373	7	violated	violate	VBN
8691	3373	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3373	9	duty	duty	NN
8691	3373	10	,	,	,
8691	3373	11	but	but	CC
8691	3373	12	that	that	IN
8691	3373	13	the	the	DT
8691	3373	14	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3373	15	of	of	IN
8691	3373	16	the	the	DT
8691	3373	17	United	United	NNP
8691	3373	18	States	States	NNP
8691	3373	19	furnished	furnish	VBD
8691	3373	20	no	no	DT
8691	3373	21	means	means	NN
8691	3373	22	for	for	IN
8691	3373	23	enforcing	enforce	VBG
8691	3373	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3373	25	performance	performance	NN
8691	3373	26	by	by	IN
8691	3373	27	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3373	28	.	.	.
8691	3374	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3374	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3374	3	:	:	:
8691	3374	4	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	3374	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3374	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3374	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3374	8	Dennison	Dennison	NNP
8691	3374	9	,	,	,
8691	3374	10	24	24	CD
8691	3374	11	Howard	Howard	NNP
8691	3374	12	's	's	POS
8691	3374	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3374	14	,	,	,
8691	3374	15	66	66	CD
8691	3374	16	,	,	,
8691	3374	17	109	109	CD
8691	3374	18	.	.	.
8691	3374	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3375	1	Under	under	IN
8691	3375	2	the	the	DT
8691	3375	3	shelter	shelter	NN
8691	3375	4	of	of	IN
8691	3375	5	this	this	DT
8691	3375	6	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	3375	7	,	,	,
8691	3375	8	a	a	DT
8691	3375	9	man	man	NN
8691	3375	10	indicted	indict	VBN
8691	3375	11	for	for	IN
8691	3375	12	murder	murder	NN
8691	3375	13	in	in	IN
8691	3375	14	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	3375	15	has	have	VBZ
8691	3375	16	been	be	VBN
8691	3375	17	for	for	IN
8691	3375	18	several	several	JJ
8691	3375	19	recent	recent	JJ
8691	3375	20	years	year	NNS
8691	3375	21	residing	reside	VBG
8691	3375	22	in	in	IN
8691	3375	23	safety	safety	NN
8691	3375	24	in	in	IN
8691	3375	25	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
8691	3375	26	,	,	,
8691	3375	27	because	because	IN
8691	3375	28	the	the	DT
8691	3375	29	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3375	30	of	of	IN
8691	3375	31	that	that	DT
8691	3375	32	State	State	NNP
8691	3375	33	has	have	VBZ
8691	3375	34	refused	refuse	VBN
8691	3375	35	to	to	TO
8691	3375	36	comply	comply	VB
8691	3375	37	with	with	IN
8691	3375	38	repeated	repeat	VBN
8691	3375	39	requisitions	requisition	NNS
8691	3375	40	for	for	IN
8691	3375	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3375	42	surrender	surrender	NN
8691	3375	43	.	.	.
8691	3376	1	*	*	NFP
8691	3376	2	*	*	NFP
8691	3376	3	*	*	NFP
8691	3376	4	*	*	NFP
8691	3376	5	*	*	NFP
8691	3376	6	Every	every	DT
8691	3376	7	court	court	NN
8691	3376	8	of	of	IN
8691	3376	9	record	record	NN
8691	3376	10	while	while	IN
8691	3376	11	in	in	IN
8691	3376	12	session	session	NN
8691	3376	13	has	have	VBZ
8691	3376	14	inherent	inherent	JJ
8691	3376	15	power	power	NN
8691	3376	16	to	to	TO
8691	3376	17	compel	compel	VB
8691	3376	18	all	all	DT
8691	3376	19	who	who	WP
8691	3376	20	appear	appear	VBP
8691	3376	21	before	before	IN
8691	3376	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3376	23	to	to	TO
8691	3376	24	preserve	preserve	VB
8691	3376	25	order	order	NN
8691	3376	26	,	,	,
8691	3376	27	to	to	TO
8691	3376	28	obey	obey	VB
8691	3376	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3376	30	lawful	lawful	JJ
8691	3376	31	commands	command	NNS
8691	3376	32	issued	issue	VBN
8691	3376	33	in	in	IN
8691	3376	34	due	due	JJ
8691	3376	35	course	course	NN
8691	3376	36	of	of	IN
8691	3376	37	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3376	38	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	3376	39	,	,	,
8691	3376	40	and	and	CC
8691	3376	41	to	to	TO
8691	3376	42	refrain	refrain	VB
8691	3376	43	from	from	IN
8691	3376	44	any	any	DT
8691	3376	45	expressions	expression	NNS
8691	3376	46	of	of	IN
8691	3376	47	disrespect	disrespect	NN
8691	3376	48	to	to	IN
8691	3376	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3376	50	authority	authority	NN
8691	3376	51	,	,	,
8691	3376	52	under	under	IN
8691	3376	53	pain	pain	NN
8691	3376	54	of	of	IN
8691	3376	55	fine	fine	JJ
8691	3376	56	or	or	CC
8691	3376	57	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	3376	58	,	,	,
8691	3376	59	or	or	CC
8691	3376	60	both	both	DT
8691	3376	61	.	.	.
8691	3377	1	This	this	DT
8691	3377	2	power	power	NN
8691	3377	3	,	,	,
8691	3377	4	unless	unless	IN
8691	3377	5	withdrawn	withdraw	VBN
8691	3377	6	by	by	IN
8691	3377	7	statute	statute	NN
8691	3377	8	,	,	,
8691	3377	9	belongs	belong	VBZ
8691	3377	10	to	to	IN
8691	3377	11	any	any	DT
8691	3377	12	justice	justice	NN
8691	3377	13	of	of	IN
8691	3377	14	the	the	DT
8691	3377	15	peace	peace	NN
8691	3377	16	who	who	WP
8691	3377	17	has	have	VBZ
8691	3377	18	authority	authority	NN
8691	3377	19	to	to	TO
8691	3377	20	hold	hold	VB
8691	3377	21	a	a	DT
8691	3377	22	court	court	NN
8691	3377	23	of	of	IN
8691	3377	24	record	record	NN
8691	3377	25	,	,	,
8691	3377	26	while	while	IN
8691	3377	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3377	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	3377	29	holding	hold	VBG
8691	3377	30	one	one	CD
8691	3377	31	.	.	.
8691	3378	1	Commonly	commonly	RB
8691	3378	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3378	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3378	4	,	,	,
8691	3378	5	in	in	IN
8691	3378	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3378	7	case	case	NN
8691	3378	8	,	,	,
8691	3378	9	regulated	regulate	VBN
8691	3378	10	by	by	IN
8691	3378	11	statute	statute	NN
8691	3378	12	.	.	.
8691	3379	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3379	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3379	3	:	:	:
8691	3379	4	Church	Church	NNP
8691	3379	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3379	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3379	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3379	8	Pearne	Pearne	NNP
8691	3379	9	,	,	,
8691	3379	10	75	75	CD
8691	3379	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3379	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3379	13	,	,	,
8691	3379	14	350	350	CD
8691	3379	15	;	;	:
8691	3379	16	53	53	CD
8691	3379	17	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	3379	18	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	3379	19	,	,	,
8691	3379	20	955	955	CD
8691	3379	21	.	.	.
8691	3379	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3380	1	At	at	IN
8691	3380	2	common	common	JJ
8691	3380	3	law	law	NN
8691	3380	4	,	,	,
8691	3380	5	superior	superior	JJ
8691	3380	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	3380	7	of	of	IN
8691	3380	8	record	record	NN
8691	3380	9	also	also	RB
8691	3380	10	have	have	VBP
8691	3380	11	power	power	NN
8691	3380	12	during	during	IN
8691	3380	13	the	the	DT
8691	3380	14	progress	progress	NN
8691	3380	15	of	of	IN
8691	3380	16	a	a	DT
8691	3380	17	cause	cause	NN
8691	3380	18	to	to	IN
8691	3380	19	repress	repress	NN
8691	3380	20	or	or	CC
8691	3380	21	punish	punish	VB
8691	3380	22	any	any	DT
8691	3380	23	disrespectful	disrespectful	JJ
8691	3380	24	acts	act	NNS
8691	3380	25	or	or	CC
8691	3380	26	words	word	NNS
8691	3380	27	done	do	VBN
8691	3380	28	or	or	CC
8691	3380	29	uttered	uttered	JJ
8691	3380	30	,	,	,
8691	3380	31	not	not	RB
8691	3380	32	in	in	IN
8691	3380	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3380	34	presence	presence	NN
8691	3380	35	,	,	,
8691	3380	36	but	but	CC
8691	3380	37	so	so	RB
8691	3380	38	near	near	RB
8691	3380	39	to	to	IN
8691	3380	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3380	41	as	as	IN
8691	3380	42	to	to	TO
8691	3380	43	constitute	constitute	VB
8691	3380	44	a	a	DT
8691	3380	45	breach	breach	NN
8691	3380	46	of	of	IN
8691	3380	47	order	order	NN
8691	3380	48	or	or	CC
8691	3380	49	tend	tend	VBP
8691	3380	50	directly	directly	RB
8691	3380	51	to	to	TO
8691	3380	52	lessen	lessen	VB
8691	3380	53	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3380	54	efficiency	efficiency	NN
8691	3380	55	.	.	.
8691	3381	1	These	these	DT
8691	3381	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3381	3	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	3381	4	powers	power	NNS
8691	3381	5	inherent	inherent	JJ
8691	3381	6	in	in	IN
8691	3381	7	such	such	PDT
8691	3381	8	a	a	DT
8691	3381	9	court	court	NN
8691	3381	10	,	,	,
8691	3381	11	because	because	IN
8691	3381	12	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	3381	13	to	to	TO
8691	3381	14	support	support	VB
8691	3381	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3381	16	proper	proper	JJ
8691	3381	17	dignity	dignity	NN
8691	3381	18	and	and	CC
8691	3381	19	independence	independence	NN
8691	3381	20	.	.	.
8691	3382	1	Statutes	statute	NNS
8691	3382	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3382	3	common	common	JJ
8691	3382	4	to	to	TO
8691	3382	5	define	define	VB
8691	3382	6	or	or	CC
8691	3382	7	restrict	restrict	VB
8691	3382	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3382	9	,	,	,
8691	3382	10	but	but	CC
8691	3382	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3382	12	can	can	MD
8691	3382	13	not	not	RB
8691	3382	14	take	take	VB
8691	3382	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3382	16	away	away	RB
8691	3382	17	altogether	altogether	RB
8691	3382	18	.	.	.
8691	3383	1	To	to	TO
8691	3383	2	do	do	VB
8691	3383	3	so	so	RB
8691	3383	4	would	would	MD
8691	3383	5	be	be	VB
8691	3383	6	to	to	TO
8691	3383	7	take	take	VB
8691	3383	8	away	away	RB
8691	3383	9	an	an	DT
8691	3383	10	essential	essential	JJ
8691	3383	11	incident	incident	NN
8691	3383	12	of	of	IN
8691	3383	13	the	the	DT
8691	3383	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3383	15	power	power	NN
8691	3383	16	.	.	.
8691	3384	1	Nor	nor	CC
8691	3384	2	can	can	MD
8691	3384	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3384	4	so	so	RB
8691	3384	5	far	far	RB
8691	3384	6	reduce	reduce	VB
8691	3384	7	the	the	DT
8691	3384	8	penalty	penalty	NN
8691	3384	9	that	that	WDT
8691	3384	10	may	may	MD
8691	3384	11	be	be	VB
8691	3384	12	inflicted	inflict	VBN
8691	3384	13	as	as	IN
8691	3384	14	to	to	TO
8691	3384	15	deprive	deprive	VB
8691	3384	16	the	the	DT
8691	3384	17	court	court	NN
8691	3384	18	of	of	IN
8691	3384	19	a	a	DT
8691	3384	20	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	3384	21	measure	measure	NN
8691	3384	22	of	of	IN
8691	3384	23	the	the	DT
8691	3384	24	right	right	NN
8691	3384	25	of	of	IN
8691	3384	26	self	self	NN
8691	3384	27	-	-	HYPH
8691	3384	28	protection	protection	NN
8691	3384	29	.	.	.
8691	3385	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3385	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3385	3	:	:	:
8691	3385	4	Batchelder	Batchelder	NNP
8691	3385	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3385	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3385	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3385	8	Moore	Moore	NNP
8691	3385	9	,	,	,
8691	3385	10	42	42	CD
8691	3385	11	California	California	NNP
8691	3385	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3385	13	,	,	,
8691	3385	14	412	412	CD
8691	3385	15	.	.	.
8691	3385	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3386	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3386	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3386	3	,	,	,
8691	3386	4	to	to	TO
8691	3386	5	say	say	VB
8691	3386	6	the	the	DT
8691	3386	7	least	least	JJS
8691	3386	8	,	,	,
8691	3386	9	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
8691	3386	10	if	if	IN
8691	3386	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3386	12	can	can	MD
8691	3386	13	even	even	RB
8691	3386	14	restrict	restrict	VB
8691	3386	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3386	16	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	3386	17	by	by	IN
8691	3386	18	any	any	DT
8691	3386	19	court	court	NN
8691	3386	20	created	create	VBN
8691	3386	21	by	by	IN
8691	3386	22	the	the	DT
8691	3386	23	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3386	24	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3386	25	.	.	.
8691	3387	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3387	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3387	3	:	:	:
8691	3387	4	State	State	NNP
8691	3387	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3387	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3387	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3387	8	Morrill	Morrill	NNP
8691	3387	9	,	,	,
8691	3387	10	16	16	CD
8691	3387	11	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
8691	3387	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3387	13	,	,	,
8691	3387	14	384	384	CD
8691	3387	15	;	;	:
8691	3387	16	State	State	NNP
8691	3387	17	_	_	NNP
8691	3387	18	v.	v.	IN
8691	3387	19	_	_	NNP
8691	3387	20	Shepherd	Shepherd	NNP
8691	3387	21	,	,	,
8691	3387	22	177	177	CD
8691	3387	23	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
8691	3387	24	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3387	25	,	,	,
8691	3387	26	205	205	CD
8691	3387	27	;	;	:
8691	3387	28	76	76	CD
8691	3387	29	Southwestern	Southwestern	NNP
8691	3387	30	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	3387	31	,	,	,
8691	3387	32	79	79	CD
8691	3387	33	;	;	:
8691	3387	34	_	_	NNP
8691	3387	35	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	3387	36	parte	parte	NN
8691	3387	37	_	_	NNP
8691	3387	38	Robinson	Robinson	NNP
8691	3387	39	,	,	,
8691	3387	40	19	19	CD
8691	3387	41	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	3387	42	's	's	POS
8691	3387	43	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3387	44	,	,	,
8691	3387	45	505	505	CD
8691	3387	46	,	,	,
8691	3387	47	510	510	CD
8691	3387	48	.	.	.
8691	3387	49	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3388	1	The	the	DT
8691	3388	2	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	3388	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3388	4	not	not	RB
8691	3388	5	entitled	entitle	VBN
8691	3388	6	as	as	IN
8691	3388	7	of	of	IN
8691	3388	8	right	right	NN
8691	3388	9	to	to	IN
8691	3388	10	a	a	DT
8691	3388	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	3388	12	by	by	IN
8691	3388	13	jury	jury	NN
8691	3388	14	.	.	.
8691	3389	1	The	the	DT
8691	3389	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	3389	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3389	4	the	the	DT
8691	3389	5	best	good	JJS
8691	3389	6	guardian	guardian	NN
8691	3389	7	of	of	IN
8691	3389	8	the	the	DT
8691	3389	9	dignity	dignity	NN
8691	3389	10	of	of	IN
8691	3389	11	the	the	DT
8691	3389	12	court	court	NN
8691	3389	13	.	.	.
8691	3390	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3390	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3390	3	:	:	:
8691	3390	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3390	5	In	In	NNP
8691	3390	6	re	re	NN
8691	3390	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3390	8	Debs	Debs	NNP
8691	3390	9	,	,	,
8691	3390	10	158	158	CD
8691	3390	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	3390	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3390	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	3390	14	,	,	,
8691	3390	15	564	564	CD
8691	3390	16	,	,	,
8691	3390	17	595	595	CD
8691	3390	18	.	.	.
8691	3390	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3391	1	The	the	DT
8691	3391	2	rule	rule	NN
8691	3391	3	of	of	IN
8691	3391	4	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3391	5	law	law	NN
8691	3391	6	that	that	WDT
8691	3391	7	to	to	TO
8691	3391	8	convict	convict	VB
8691	3391	9	a	a	DT
8691	3391	10	man	man	NN
8691	3391	11	of	of	IN
8691	3391	12	crime	crime	NN
8691	3391	13	requires	require	VBZ
8691	3391	14	proof	proof	NN
8691	3391	15	of	of	IN
8691	3391	16	guilt	guilt	NN
8691	3391	17	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	3391	18	a	a	DT
8691	3391	19	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	3391	20	doubt	doubt	NN
8691	3391	21	applies	apply	VBZ
8691	3391	22	to	to	IN
8691	3391	23	all	all	DT
8691	3391	24	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3391	25	of	of	IN
8691	3391	26	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3391	27	.	.	.
8691	3392	1	The	the	DT
8691	3392	2	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	3392	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3392	4	also	also	RB
8691	3392	5	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	3392	6	to	to	TO
8691	3392	7	go	go	VB
8691	3392	8	free	free	JJ
8691	3392	9	on	on	IN
8691	3392	10	giving	give	VBG
8691	3392	11	bail	bail	NN
8691	3392	12	until	until	IN
8691	3392	13	final	final	JJ
8691	3392	14	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	3392	15	,	,	,
8691	3392	16	if	if	IN
8691	3392	17	that	that	DT
8691	3392	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	3392	19	to	to	TO
8691	3392	20	be	be	VB
8691	3392	21	preceded	precede	VBN
8691	3392	22	by	by	IN
8691	3392	23	any	any	DT
8691	3392	24	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
8691	3392	25	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	3392	26	involving	involve	VBG
8691	3392	27	adjournments	adjournment	NNS
8691	3392	28	from	from	IN
8691	3392	29	day	day	NN
8691	3392	30	to	to	IN
8691	3392	31	day	day	NN
8691	3392	32	.	.	.
8691	3393	1	No	no	DT
8691	3393	2	such	such	JJ
8691	3393	3	inquiry	inquiry	NN
8691	3393	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3393	5	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	3393	6	when	when	WRB
8691	3393	7	the	the	DT
8691	3393	8	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3393	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	3393	10	plain	plain	JJ
8691	3393	11	and	and	CC
8691	3393	12	was	be	VBD
8691	3393	13	committed	commit	VBN
8691	3393	14	in	in	IN
8691	3393	15	the	the	DT
8691	3393	16	presence	presence	NN
8691	3393	17	of	of	IN
8691	3393	18	the	the	DT
8691	3393	19	court	court	NN
8691	3393	20	.	.	.
8691	3394	1	In	in	IN
8691	3394	2	the	the	DT
8691	3394	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	3394	4	of	of	IN
8691	3394	5	the	the	DT
8691	3394	6	United	United	NNP
8691	3394	7	States	States	NNP
8691	3394	8	and	and	CC
8691	3394	9	in	in	IN
8691	3394	10	most	most	JJS
8691	3394	11	of	of	IN
8691	3394	12	the	the	DT
8691	3394	13	States	States	NNPS
8691	3394	14	no	no	DT
8691	3394	15	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	3394	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	3394	17	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	3394	18	for	for	IN
8691	3394	19	errors	error	NNS
8691	3394	20	in	in	IN
8691	3394	21	law	law	NN
8691	3394	22	from	from	IN
8691	3394	23	a	a	DT
8691	3394	24	summary	summary	NN
8691	3394	25	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	3394	26	of	of	IN
8691	3394	27	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	3394	28	for	for	IN
8691	3394	29	a	a	DT
8691	3394	30	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3394	31	of	of	IN
8691	3394	32	court	court	NN
8691	3394	33	.	.	.
8691	3395	1	Appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	3395	2	lie	lie	VBP
8691	3395	3	only	only	RB
8691	3395	4	from	from	IN
8691	3395	5	final	final	JJ
8691	3395	6	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	3395	7	in	in	IN
8691	3395	8	a	a	DT
8691	3395	9	cause	cause	NN
8691	3395	10	,	,	,
8691	3395	11	and	and	CC
8691	3395	12	such	such	PDT
8691	3395	13	a	a	DT
8691	3395	14	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	3395	15	for	for	IN
8691	3395	16	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3395	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	3395	18	not	not	RB
8691	3395	19	so	so	RB
8691	3395	20	regarded	regarded	JJ
8691	3395	21	.	.	.
8691	3396	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3396	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3396	3	:	:	:
8691	3396	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3396	5	ex	ex	NNP
8691	3396	6	parte	parte	NNP
8691	3396	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3396	8	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
8691	3396	9	,	,	,
8691	3396	10	7	7	CD
8691	3396	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	3396	12	's	's	POS
8691	3396	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3396	14	,	,	,
8691	3396	15	364	364	CD
8691	3396	16	,	,	,
8691	3396	17	376	376	CD
8691	3396	18	.	.	.
8691	3396	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3397	1	If	if	IN
8691	3397	2	the	the	DT
8691	3397	3	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3397	4	be	be	VBP
8691	3397	5	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3397	6	as	as	IN
8691	3397	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3397	8	may	may	MD
8691	3397	9	be	be	VB
8691	3397	10	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3397	11	made	make	VBN
8691	3397	12	the	the	DT
8691	3397	13	subject	subject	NN
8691	3397	14	of	of	IN
8691	3397	15	a	a	DT
8691	3397	16	formal	formal	JJ
8691	3397	17	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3397	18	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	3397	19	and	and	CC
8691	3397	20	a	a	DT
8691	3397	21	jury	jury	NN
8691	3397	22	trial	trial	NN
8691	3397	23	,	,	,
8691	3397	24	an	an	DT
8691	3397	25	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	3397	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	3397	27	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	3397	28	.	.	.
8691	3398	1	A	a	DT
8691	3398	2	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	3398	3	inflicted	inflict	VBN
8691	3398	4	for	for	IN
8691	3398	5	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3398	6	,	,	,
8691	3398	7	even	even	RB
8691	3398	8	though	though	IN
8691	3398	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3398	10	goes	go	VBZ
8691	3398	11	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	3398	12	the	the	DT
8691	3398	13	rightful	rightful	JJ
8691	3398	14	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3398	15	of	of	IN
8691	3398	16	the	the	DT
8691	3398	17	court	court	NN
8691	3398	18	in	in	IN
8691	3398	19	such	such	PDT
8691	3398	20	a	a	DT
8691	3398	21	matter	matter	NN
8691	3398	22	,	,	,
8691	3398	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	3398	24	a	a	DT
8691	3398	25	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3398	26	act	act	NN
8691	3398	27	,	,	,
8691	3398	28	and	and	CC
8691	3398	29	does	do	VBZ
8691	3398	30	not	not	RB
8691	3398	31	expose	expose	VB
8691	3398	32	the	the	DT
8691	3398	33	judge	judge	NN
8691	3398	34	passing	pass	VBG
8691	3398	35	the	the	DT
8691	3398	36	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	3398	37	to	to	IN
8691	3398	38	an	an	DT
8691	3398	39	action	action	NN
8691	3398	40	for	for	IN
8691	3398	41	damages	damage	NNS
8691	3398	42	.	.	.
8691	3399	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3399	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3399	3	:	:	:
8691	3399	4	Bradley	Bradley	NNP
8691	3399	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3399	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3399	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3399	8	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
8691	3399	9	,	,	,
8691	3399	10	13	13	CD
8691	3399	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	3399	12	's	's	POS
8691	3399	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3399	14	,	,	,
8691	3399	15	335	335	CD
8691	3399	16	.	.	.
8691	3399	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3400	1	*	*	NFP
8691	3400	2	*	*	NFP
8691	3400	3	*	*	NFP
8691	3400	4	*	*	NFP
8691	3400	5	*	*	NFP
8691	3400	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	3400	7	XXI	XXI	NNP
8691	3400	8	JUDICIAL	JUDICIAL	NNP
8691	3400	9	PROCEEDINGS	proceeding	NNS
8691	3400	10	IN	in	IN
8691	3400	11	TERRITORY	TERRITORY	NNP
8691	3400	12	SUBJECT	SUBJECT	.
8691	3400	13	TO	to	IN
8691	3400	14	MARTIAL	MARTIAL	NNP
8691	3400	15	LAW	LAW	NNP
8691	3400	16	Martial	martial	JJ
8691	3400	17	law	law	NN
8691	3400	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	3400	19	the	the	DT
8691	3400	20	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	3400	21	of	of	IN
8691	3400	22	military	military	JJ
8691	3400	23	power	power	NN
8691	3400	24	.	.	.
8691	3401	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3401	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3401	3	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3401	4	rule	rule	NN
8691	3401	5	at	at	IN
8691	3401	6	the	the	DT
8691	3401	7	will	will	NN
8691	3401	8	of	of	IN
8691	3401	9	the	the	DT
8691	3401	10	commanding	command	VBG
8691	3401	11	military	military	JJ
8691	3401	12	officer	officer	NN
8691	3401	13	.	.	.
8691	3402	1	In	in	IN
8691	3402	2	time	time	NN
8691	3402	3	of	of	IN
8691	3402	4	war	war	NN
8691	3402	5	and	and	CC
8691	3402	6	at	at	IN
8691	3402	7	the	the	DT
8691	3402	8	seat	seat	NN
8691	3402	9	of	of	IN
8691	3402	10	war	war	NN
8691	3402	11	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3402	12	rule	rule	NN
8691	3402	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	3402	14	a	a	DT
8691	3402	15	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	3402	16	,	,	,
8691	3402	17	and	and	CC
8691	3402	18	under	under	IN
8691	3402	19	such	such	JJ
8691	3402	20	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	3402	21	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3402	22	law	law	NN
8691	3402	23	may	may	MD
8691	3402	24	rightfully	rightfully	RB
8691	3402	25	be	be	VB
8691	3402	26	enforced	enforce	VBN
8691	3402	27	by	by	IN
8691	3402	28	any	any	DT
8691	3402	29	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	3402	30	as	as	IN
8691	3402	31	an	an	DT
8691	3402	32	incident	incident	NN
8691	3402	33	of	of	IN
8691	3402	34	the	the	DT
8691	3402	35	war	war	NN
8691	3402	36	,	,	,
8691	3402	37	whether	whether	IN
8691	3402	38	that	that	DT
8691	3402	39	is	be	VBZ
8691	3402	40	being	be	VBG
8691	3402	41	waged	wage	VBN
8691	3402	42	with	with	IN
8691	3402	43	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	3402	44	or	or	CC
8691	3402	45	domestic	domestic	JJ
8691	3402	46	enemies	enemy	NNS
8691	3402	47	.	.	.
8691	3403	1	The	the	DT
8691	3403	2	case	case	NN
8691	3403	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3403	4	different	different	JJ
8691	3403	5	when	when	WRB
8691	3403	6	,	,	,
8691	3403	7	though	though	IN
8691	3403	8	war	war	NN
8691	3403	9	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	3403	10	,	,	,
8691	3403	11	an	an	DT
8691	3403	12	attempt	attempt	NN
8691	3403	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	3403	14	made	make	VBN
8691	3403	15	to	to	TO
8691	3403	16	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	3403	17	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3403	18	law	law	NN
8691	3403	19	at	at	IN
8691	3403	20	a	a	DT
8691	3403	21	place	place	NN
8691	3403	22	which	which	WDT
8691	3403	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	3403	24	not	not	RB
8691	3403	25	the	the	DT
8691	3403	26	seat	seat	NN
8691	3403	27	of	of	IN
8691	3403	28	war	war	NN
8691	3403	29	,	,	,
8691	3403	30	nor	nor	CC
8691	3403	31	so	so	RB
8691	3403	32	near	near	IN
8691	3403	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3403	34	as	as	IN
8691	3403	35	to	to	TO
8691	3403	36	make	make	VB
8691	3403	37	military	military	JJ
8691	3403	38	rule	rule	NN
8691	3403	39	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	3403	40	for	for	IN
8691	3403	41	military	military	JJ
8691	3403	42	success	success	NN
8691	3403	43	.	.	.
8691	3404	1	Constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3404	2	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	3404	3	may	may	MD
8691	3404	4	also	also	RB
8691	3404	5	affect	affect	VB
8691	3404	6	the	the	DT
8691	3404	7	question	question	NN
8691	3404	8	.	.	.
8691	3405	1	Those	those	DT
8691	3405	2	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	3405	3	the	the	DT
8691	3405	4	United	United	NNP
8691	3405	5	States	States	NNP
8691	3405	6	contain	contain	VBP
8691	3405	7	limitations	limitation	NNS
8691	3405	8	stricter	strict	JJR
8691	3405	9	than	than	IN
8691	3405	10	those	those	DT
8691	3405	11	found	find	VBN
8691	3405	12	in	in	IN
8691	3405	13	some	some	DT
8691	3405	14	of	of	IN
8691	3405	15	the	the	DT
8691	3405	16	State	State	NNP
8691	3405	17	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	3405	18	.	.	.
8691	3406	1	Ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	3406	2	no	no	DT
8691	3406	3	military	military	JJ
8691	3406	4	officer	officer	NN
8691	3406	5	can	can	MD
8691	3406	6	rightfully	rightfully	RB
8691	3406	7	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	3406	8	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3406	9	law	law	NN
8691	3406	10	in	in	IN
8691	3406	11	a	a	DT
8691	3406	12	place	place	NN
8691	3406	13	where	where	WRB
8691	3406	14	the	the	DT
8691	3406	15	regular	regular	JJ
8691	3406	16	courts	court	NNS
8691	3406	17	of	of	IN
8691	3406	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3406	19	sovereign	sovereign	JJ
8691	3406	20	are	be	VBP
8691	3406	21	open	open	JJ
8691	3406	22	and	and	CC
8691	3406	23	in	in	IN
8691	3406	24	the	the	DT
8691	3406	25	proper	proper	JJ
8691	3406	26	and	and	CC
8691	3406	27	unobstructed	unobstructed	JJ
8691	3406	28	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	3406	29	of	of	IN
8691	3406	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3406	31	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3406	32	.	.	.
8691	3407	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3407	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3407	3	:	:	:
8691	3407	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3407	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	3407	6	parte	parte	NN
8691	3407	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3407	8	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
8691	3407	9	,	,	,
8691	3407	10	4	4	CD
8691	3407	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	3407	12	's	's	POS
8691	3407	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3407	14	,	,	,
8691	3407	15	2	2	CD
8691	3407	16	,	,	,
8691	3407	17	127	127	CD
8691	3407	18	.	.	.
8691	3407	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3408	1	The	the	DT
8691	3408	2	first	first	JJ
8691	3408	3	serious	serious	JJ
8691	3408	4	contest	contest	NN
8691	3408	5	between	between	IN
8691	3408	6	the	the	DT
8691	3408	7	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	3408	8	and	and	CC
8691	3408	9	the	the	DT
8691	3408	10	military	military	JJ
8691	3408	11	power	power	NN
8691	3408	12	in	in	IN
8691	3408	13	this	this	DT
8691	3408	14	country	country	NN
8691	3408	15	as	as	IN
8691	3408	16	to	to	IN
8691	3408	17	the	the	DT
8691	3408	18	questions	question	NNS
8691	3408	19	thus	thus	RB
8691	3408	20	involved	involve	VBN
8691	3408	21	took	take	VBD
8691	3408	22	place	place	NN
8691	3408	23	during	during	IN
8691	3408	24	the	the	DT
8691	3408	25	war	war	NN
8691	3408	26	of	of	IN
8691	3408	27	1812	1812	CD
8691	3408	28	.	.	.
8691	3409	1	General	General	NNP
8691	3409	2	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	3409	3	,	,	,
8691	3409	4	in	in	IN
8691	3409	5	1814	1814	CD
8691	3409	6	,	,	,
8691	3409	7	was	be	VBD
8691	3409	8	at	at	IN
8691	3409	9	New	New	NNP
8691	3409	10	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
8691	3409	11	in	in	IN
8691	3409	12	command	command	NN
8691	3409	13	of	of	IN
8691	3409	14	the	the	DT
8691	3409	15	military	military	JJ
8691	3409	16	Department	Department	NNP
8691	3409	17	of	of	IN
8691	3409	18	the	the	DT
8691	3409	19	South	South	NNP
8691	3409	20	.	.	.
8691	3410	1	The	the	DT
8691	3410	2	city	city	NN
8691	3410	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3410	4	threatened	threaten	VBN
8691	3410	5	with	with	IN
8691	3410	6	invasion	invasion	NN
8691	3410	7	.	.	.
8691	3411	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3411	2	declared	declare	VBD
8691	3411	3	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3411	4	law	law	NN
8691	3411	5	,	,	,
8691	3411	6	and	and	CC
8691	3411	7	not	not	RB
8691	3411	8	long	long	RB
8691	3411	9	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	3411	10	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	3411	11	a	a	DT
8691	3411	12	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	3411	13	Louaillier	Louaillier	NNP
8691	3411	14	,	,	,
8691	3411	15	a	a	DT
8691	3411	16	member	member	NN
8691	3411	17	of	of	IN
8691	3411	18	the	the	DT
8691	3411	19	State	State	NNP
8691	3411	20	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3411	21	,	,	,
8691	3411	22	for	for	IN
8691	3411	23	writing	write	VBG
8691	3411	24	a	a	DT
8691	3411	25	newspaper	newspaper	NN
8691	3411	26	article	article	NN
8691	3411	27	in	in	IN
8691	3411	28	which	which	WDT
8691	3411	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3411	30	objected	object	VBD
8691	3411	31	to	to	IN
8691	3411	32	the	the	DT
8691	3411	33	continuance	continuance	NN
8691	3411	34	of	of	IN
8691	3411	35	this	this	DT
8691	3411	36	kind	kind	NN
8691	3411	37	of	of	IN
8691	3411	38	military	military	JJ
8691	3411	39	government	government	NN
8691	3411	40	.	.	.
8691	3412	1	Louaillier	Louaillier	NNP
8691	3412	2	obtained	obtain	VBD
8691	3412	3	a	a	DT
8691	3412	4	writ	writ	NN
8691	3412	5	of	of	IN
8691	3412	6	_	_	NNP
8691	3412	7	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	3412	8	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	3412	9	_	_	NNP
8691	3412	10	from	from	IN
8691	3412	11	the	the	DT
8691	3412	12	District	District	NNP
8691	3412	13	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3412	14	of	of	IN
8691	3412	15	the	the	DT
8691	3412	16	United	United	NNP
8691	3412	17	States	States	NNP
8691	3412	18	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3412	19	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3412	20	Hall	Hall	NNP
8691	3412	21	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3412	22	,	,	,
8691	3412	23	directed	direct	VBN
8691	3412	24	to	to	IN
8691	3412	25	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	3412	26	.	.	.
8691	3413	1	The	the	DT
8691	3413	2	General	General	NNP
8691	3413	3	,	,	,
8691	3413	4	instead	instead	RB
8691	3413	5	of	of	IN
8691	3413	6	obeying	obey	VBG
8691	3413	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3413	8	,	,	,
8691	3413	9	forthwith	forthwith	NNP
8691	3413	10	took	take	VBD
8691	3413	11	possession	possession	NN
8691	3413	12	of	of	IN
8691	3413	13	the	the	DT
8691	3413	14	original	original	JJ
8691	3413	15	writ	writ	NNP
8691	3413	16	,	,	,
8691	3413	17	arrested	arrest	VBD
8691	3413	18	the	the	DT
8691	3413	19	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3413	20	,	,	,
8691	3413	21	and	and	CC
8691	3413	22	deported	deport	VBD
8691	3413	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3413	24	from	from	IN
8691	3413	25	the	the	DT
8691	3413	26	city	city	NN
8691	3413	27	.	.	.
8691	3414	1	Two	two	CD
8691	3414	2	days	day	NNS
8691	3414	3	later	later	RBR
8691	3414	4	despatches	despatch	NNS
8691	3414	5	were	be	VBD
8691	3414	6	received	receive	VBN
8691	3414	7	from	from	IN
8691	3414	8	the	the	DT
8691	3414	9	War	War	NNP
8691	3414	10	Department	Department	NNP
8691	3414	11	officially	officially	RB
8691	3414	12	announcing	announce	VBG
8691	3414	13	the	the	DT
8691	3414	14	conclusion	conclusion	NN
8691	3414	15	of	of	IN
8691	3414	16	a	a	DT
8691	3414	17	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	3414	18	of	of	IN
8691	3414	19	peace	peace	NN
8691	3414	20	.	.	.
8691	3415	1	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3415	2	Hall	Hall	NNP
8691	3415	3	now	now	RB
8691	3415	4	returned	return	VBD
8691	3415	5	,	,	,
8691	3415	6	and	and	CC
8691	3415	7	a	a	DT
8691	3415	8	rule	rule	NN
8691	3415	9	to	to	TO
8691	3415	10	show	show	VB
8691	3415	11	cause	cause	NN
8691	3415	12	why	why	WRB
8691	3415	13	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	3415	14	should	should	MD
8691	3415	15	not	not	RB
8691	3415	16	be	be	VB
8691	3415	17	attached	attach	VBN
8691	3415	18	for	for	IN
8691	3415	19	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3415	20	of	of	IN
8691	3415	21	court	court	NN
8691	3415	22	was	be	VBD
8691	3415	23	issued	issue	VBN
8691	3415	24	.	.	.
8691	3416	1	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	3416	2	appeared	appear	VBD
8691	3416	3	and	and	CC
8691	3416	4	filed	file	VBD
8691	3416	5	a	a	DT
8691	3416	6	long	long	JJ
8691	3416	7	answer	answer	NN
8691	3416	8	,	,	,
8691	3416	9	first	first	RB
8691	3416	10	stating	state	VBG
8691	3416	11	various	various	JJ
8691	3416	12	objections	objection	NNS
8691	3416	13	to	to	IN
8691	3416	14	the	the	DT
8691	3416	15	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3416	16	,	,	,
8691	3416	17	and	and	CC
8691	3416	18	then	then	RB
8691	3416	19	setting	set	VBG
8691	3416	20	up	up	RP
8691	3416	21	the	the	DT
8691	3416	22	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	3416	23	calling	call	VBG
8691	3416	24	for	for	IN
8691	3416	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3416	26	proclamation	proclamation	NN
8691	3416	27	of	of	IN
8691	3416	28	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3416	29	law	law	NN
8691	3416	30	.	.	.
8691	3417	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3417	2	had	have	VBD
8691	3417	3	been	be	VBN
8691	3417	4	told	tell	VBN
8691	3417	5	,	,	,
8691	3417	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3417	7	said	say	VBD
8691	3417	8	,	,	,
8691	3417	9	that	that	IN
8691	3417	10	the	the	DT
8691	3417	11	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3417	12	was	be	VBD
8691	3417	13	"	"	``
8691	3417	14	politically	politically	RB
8691	3417	15	rotten	rotten	JJ
8691	3417	16	.	.	.
8691	3417	17	"	"	''
8691	3418	1	The	the	DT
8691	3418	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3418	3	had	have	VBD
8691	3418	4	warned	warn	VBN
8691	3418	5	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3418	6	that	that	IN
8691	3418	7	the	the	DT
8691	3418	8	State	state	NN
8691	3418	9	was	be	VBD
8691	3418	10	"	"	``
8691	3418	11	filled	fill	VBN
8691	3418	12	with	with	IN
8691	3418	13	spies	spy	NNS
8691	3418	14	and	and	CC
8691	3418	15	traitors	traitor	NNS
8691	3418	16	,	,	,
8691	3418	17	"	"	''
8691	3418	18	and	and	CC
8691	3418	19	advised	advise	VBD
8691	3418	20	,	,	,
8691	3418	21	in	in	IN
8691	3418	22	the	the	DT
8691	3418	23	presence	presence	NN
8691	3418	24	of	of	IN
8691	3418	25	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3418	26	Hall	Hall	NNP
8691	3418	27	,	,	,
8691	3418	28	and	and	CC
8691	3418	29	with	with	IN
8691	3418	30	no	no	DT
8691	3418	31	dissent	dissent	NN
8691	3418	32	from	from	IN
8691	3418	33	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3418	34	,	,	,
8691	3418	35	that	that	DT
8691	3418	36	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3418	37	law	law	NN
8691	3418	38	be	be	VB
8691	3418	39	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
8691	3418	40	.	.	.
8691	3419	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3419	2	seemed	seem	VBD
8691	3419	3	a	a	DT
8691	3419	4	time	time	NN
8691	3419	5	when	when	WRB
8691	3419	6	"	"	``
8691	3419	7	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3419	8	forms	form	NNS
8691	3419	9	must	must	MD
8691	3419	10	be	be	VB
8691	3419	11	suspended	suspend	VBN
8691	3419	12	for	for	IN
8691	3419	13	the	the	DT
8691	3419	14	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	3419	15	preservation	preservation	NN
8691	3419	16	of	of	IN
8691	3419	17	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3419	18	rights	right	NNS
8691	3419	19	.	.	.
8691	3419	20	"	"	''
8691	3420	1	The	the	DT
8691	3420	2	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
8691	3420	3	paper	paper	NN
8691	3420	4	,	,	,
8691	3420	5	which	which	WDT
8691	3420	6	was	be	VBD
8691	3420	7	evidently	evidently	RB
8691	3420	8	written	write	VBN
8691	3420	9	by	by	IN
8691	3420	10	a	a	DT
8691	3420	11	skilful	skilful	JJ
8691	3420	12	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	3420	13	,	,	,
8691	3420	14	closed	close	VBD
8691	3420	15	thus	thus	RB
8691	3420	16	:	:	:
8691	3420	17	"	"	``
8691	3420	18	The	the	DT
8691	3420	19	powers	power	NNS
8691	3420	20	which	which	WDT
8691	3420	21	the	the	DT
8691	3420	22	exigency	exigency	NN
8691	3420	23	of	of	IN
8691	3420	24	the	the	DT
8691	3420	25	times	time	NNS
8691	3420	26	forced	force	VBD
8691	3420	27	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3420	28	to	to	TO
8691	3420	29	assume	assume	VB
8691	3420	30	have	have	VBP
8691	3420	31	been	be	VBN
8691	3420	32	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	3420	33	exclusively	exclusively	RB
8691	3420	34	for	for	IN
8691	3420	35	the	the	DT
8691	3420	36	public	public	JJ
8691	3420	37	good	good	NN
8691	3420	38	;	;	:
8691	3420	39	and	and	CC
8691	3420	40	,	,	,
8691	3420	41	by	by	IN
8691	3420	42	the	the	DT
8691	3420	43	blessing	blessing	NN
8691	3420	44	of	of	IN
8691	3420	45	God	God	NNP
8691	3420	46	,	,	,
8691	3420	47	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3420	48	have	have	VBP
8691	3420	49	been	be	VBN
8691	3420	50	attended	attend	VBN
8691	3420	51	with	with	IN
8691	3420	52	unparalleled	unparalleled	JJ
8691	3420	53	success	success	NN
8691	3420	54	.	.	.
8691	3421	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3421	2	have	have	VBP
8691	3421	3	saved	save	VBN
8691	3421	4	the	the	DT
8691	3421	5	country	country	NN
8691	3421	6	;	;	:
8691	3421	7	and	and	CC
8691	3421	8	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	3421	9	may	may	MD
8691	3421	10	be	be	VB
8691	3421	11	the	the	DT
8691	3421	12	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3421	13	of	of	IN
8691	3421	14	that	that	DT
8691	3421	15	country	country	NN
8691	3421	16	,	,	,
8691	3421	17	or	or	CC
8691	3421	18	the	the	DT
8691	3421	19	decrees	decree	NNS
8691	3421	20	of	of	IN
8691	3421	21	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3421	22	courts	court	NNS
8691	3421	23	in	in	IN
8691	3421	24	relation	relation	NN
8691	3421	25	to	to	IN
8691	3421	26	the	the	DT
8691	3421	27	means	mean	NNS
8691	3421	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3421	29	has	have	VBZ
8691	3421	30	used	use	VBN
8691	3421	31	,	,	,
8691	3421	32	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3421	33	can	can	MD
8691	3421	34	never	never	RB
8691	3421	35	regret	regret	VB
8691	3421	36	that	that	IN
8691	3421	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3421	38	employed	employ	VBD
8691	3421	39	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3421	40	.	.	.
8691	3422	1	"	"	``
8691	3422	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3422	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	3422	4	:	:	:
8691	3422	5	Reid	Reid	NNP
8691	3422	6	and	and	CC
8691	3422	7	Baton	Baton	NNP
8691	3422	8	's	's	POS
8691	3422	9	"	"	``
8691	3422	10	Life	Life	NNP
8691	3422	11	of	of	IN
8691	3422	12	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
8691	3422	13	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	3422	14	,	,	,
8691	3422	15	"	"	``
8691	3422	16	408	408	CD
8691	3422	17	,	,	,
8691	3422	18	423	423	CD
8691	3422	19	.	.	.
8691	3422	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3423	1	The	the	DT
8691	3423	2	court	court	NN
8691	3423	3	,	,	,
8691	3423	4	not	not	RB
8691	3423	5	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	3423	6	impressed	impressed	JJ
8691	3423	7	with	with	IN
8691	3423	8	these	these	DT
8691	3423	9	arguments	argument	NNS
8691	3423	10	,	,	,
8691	3423	11	ordered	order	VBD
8691	3423	12	the	the	DT
8691	3423	13	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3423	14	to	to	TO
8691	3423	15	go	go	VB
8691	3423	16	forward	forward	RB
8691	3423	17	and	and	CC
8691	3423	18	required	require	VBD
8691	3423	19	the	the	DT
8691	3423	20	General	General	NNP
8691	3423	21	to	to	TO
8691	3423	22	answer	answer	VB
8691	3423	23	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3423	24	interrogatories	interrogatory	NNS
8691	3423	25	respecting	respect	VBG
8691	3423	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3423	27	course	course	NN
8691	3423	28	of	of	IN
8691	3423	29	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	3423	30	,	,	,
8691	3423	31	by	by	IN
8691	3423	32	a	a	DT
8691	3423	33	day	day	NN
8691	3423	34	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3423	35	.	.	.
8691	3424	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3424	2	appeared	appear	VBD
8691	3424	3	on	on	IN
8691	3424	4	that	that	DT
8691	3424	5	day	day	NN
8691	3424	6	and	and	CC
8691	3424	7	declined	decline	VBD
8691	3424	8	to	to	TO
8691	3424	9	answer	answer	VB
8691	3424	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3424	11	,	,	,
8691	3424	12	with	with	IN
8691	3424	13	this	this	DT
8691	3424	14	concluding	concluding	NN
8691	3424	15	shot	shoot	VBD
8691	3424	16	:	:	:
8691	3424	17	"	"	``
8691	3424	18	Your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3424	19	honour	honour	NN
8691	3424	20	will	will	MD
8691	3424	21	not	not	RB
8691	3424	22	understand	understand	VB
8691	3424	23	me	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3424	24	as	as	IN
8691	3424	25	intending	intend	VBG
8691	3424	26	any	any	DT
8691	3424	27	disrespect	disrespect	NN
8691	3424	28	to	to	IN
8691	3424	29	the	the	DT
8691	3424	30	court	court	NN
8691	3424	31	;	;	:
8691	3424	32	but	but	CC
8691	3424	33	as	as	IN
8691	3424	34	no	no	DT
8691	3424	35	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	3424	36	has	have	VBZ
8691	3424	37	been	be	VBN
8691	3424	38	afforded	afford	VBN
8691	3424	39	me	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3424	40	of	of	IN
8691	3424	41	explaining	explain	VBG
8691	3424	42	the	the	DT
8691	3424	43	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	3424	44	and	and	CC
8691	3424	45	motives	motive	NNS
8691	3424	46	by	by	IN
8691	3424	47	which	which	WDT
8691	3424	48	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3424	49	was	be	VBD
8691	3424	50	influenced	influence	VBN
8691	3424	51	,	,	,
8691	3424	52	so	so	CC
8691	3424	53	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3424	54	is	be	VBZ
8691	3424	55	expected	expect	VBN
8691	3424	56	that	that	DT
8691	3424	57	censure	censure	NN
8691	3424	58	will	will	MD
8691	3424	59	constitute	constitute	VB
8691	3424	60	no	no	DT
8691	3424	61	part	part	NN
8691	3424	62	of	of	IN
8691	3424	63	that	that	DT
8691	3424	64	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	3424	65	,	,	,
8691	3424	66	which	which	WDT
8691	3424	67	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3424	68	imagine	imagine	VBP
8691	3424	69	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3424	70	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3424	71	duty	duty	NN
8691	3424	72	to	to	IN
8691	3424	73	pronounce	pronounce	NN
8691	3424	74	.	.	.
8691	3425	1	"	"	``
8691	3425	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3425	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3425	4	:	:	:
8691	3425	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3425	6	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
8691	3425	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3425	8	.	.	NNP
8691	3425	9	,	,	,
8691	3425	10	387	387	CD
8691	3425	11	.	.	.
8691	3425	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3426	1	The	the	DT
8691	3426	2	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	3426	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3426	4	a	a	DT
8691	3426	5	fine	fine	NN
8691	3426	6	of	of	IN
8691	3426	7	$	$	$
8691	3426	8	1,000	1,000	CD
8691	3426	9	,	,	,
8691	3426	10	which	which	WDT
8691	3426	11	was	be	VBD
8691	3426	12	at	at	IN
8691	3426	13	once	once	RB
8691	3426	14	paid	pay	VBN
8691	3426	15	.	.	.
8691	3427	1	The	the	DT
8691	3427	2	sympathy	sympathy	NN
8691	3427	3	of	of	IN
8691	3427	4	the	the	DT
8691	3427	5	country	country	NN
8691	3427	6	was	be	VBD
8691	3427	7	with	with	IN
8691	3427	8	"	"	``
8691	3427	9	the	the	DT
8691	3427	10	hero	hero	NN
8691	3427	11	of	of	IN
8691	3427	12	New	New	NNP
8691	3427	13	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
8691	3427	14	"	"	''
8691	3427	15	in	in	IN
8691	3427	16	this	this	DT
8691	3427	17	affair	affair	NN
8691	3427	18	,	,	,
8691	3427	19	whose	whose	WP$
8691	3427	20	gallant	gallant	JJ
8691	3427	21	defense	defense	NN
8691	3427	22	of	of	IN
8691	3427	23	that	that	DT
8691	3427	24	city	city	NN
8691	3427	25	had	have	VBD
8691	3427	26	cast	cast	VBN
8691	3427	27	a	a	DT
8691	3427	28	gleam	gleam	NN
8691	3427	29	of	of	IN
8691	3427	30	glory	glory	NN
8691	3427	31	upon	upon	IN
8691	3427	32	the	the	DT
8691	3427	33	close	close	NN
8691	3427	34	of	of	IN
8691	3427	35	a	a	DT
8691	3427	36	long	long	JJ
8691	3427	37	and	and	CC
8691	3427	38	apparently	apparently	RB
8691	3427	39	fruitless	fruitless	JJ
8691	3427	40	war	war	NN
8691	3427	41	.	.	.
8691	3428	1	Some	some	DT
8691	3428	2	of	of	IN
8691	3428	3	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3428	4	people	people	NNS
8691	3428	5	subscribed	subscribe	VBD
8691	3428	6	the	the	DT
8691	3428	7	money	money	NN
8691	3428	8	to	to	TO
8691	3428	9	reimburse	reimburse	VB
8691	3428	10	to	to	IN
8691	3428	11	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3428	12	the	the	DT
8691	3428	13	amount	amount	NN
8691	3428	14	of	of	IN
8691	3428	15	the	the	DT
8691	3428	16	penalty	penalty	NN
8691	3428	17	,	,	,
8691	3428	18	but	but	CC
8691	3428	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3428	20	declined	decline	VBD
8691	3428	21	to	to	TO
8691	3428	22	accept	accept	VB
8691	3428	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3428	24	.	.	.
8691	3429	1	Nearly	nearly	RB
8691	3429	2	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	3429	3	years	year	NNS
8691	3429	4	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	3429	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3429	6	made	make	VBD
8691	3429	7	an	an	DT
8691	3429	8	appropriation	appropriation	NN
8691	3429	9	for	for	IN
8691	3429	10	the	the	DT
8691	3429	11	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	3429	12	,	,	,
8691	3429	13	and	and	CC
8691	3429	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3429	15	received	receive	VBD
8691	3429	16	the	the	DT
8691	3429	17	full	full	JJ
8691	3429	18	amount	amount	NN
8691	3429	19	with	with	IN
8691	3429	20	interest	interest	NN
8691	3429	21	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3429	22	in	in	IN
8691	3429	23	all	all	DT
8691	3429	24	$	$	$
8691	3429	25	2,700	2,700	CD
8691	3429	26	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3429	27	from	from	IN
8691	3429	28	the	the	DT
8691	3429	29	treasury	treasury	NNP
8691	3429	30	,	,	,
8691	3429	31	as	as	IN
8691	3429	32	a	a	DT
8691	3429	33	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	3429	34	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	3429	35	for	for	IN
8691	3429	36	a	a	DT
8691	3429	37	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3429	38	wrong	wrong	NN
8691	3429	39	.	.	.
8691	3430	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3430	2	would	would	MD
8691	3430	3	seem	seem	VB
8691	3430	4	,	,	,
8691	3430	5	however	however	RB
8691	3430	6	,	,	,
8691	3430	7	that	that	IN
8691	3430	8	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3430	9	Hall	Hall	NNP
8691	3430	10	acted	act	VBD
8691	3430	11	within	within	IN
8691	3430	12	the	the	DT
8691	3430	13	limits	limit	NNS
8691	3430	14	of	of	IN
8691	3430	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3430	16	authority	authority	NN
8691	3430	17	.	.	.
8691	3431	1	When	when	WRB
8691	3431	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3431	3	signed	sign	VBD
8691	3431	4	the	the	DT
8691	3431	5	writ	writ	NNP
8691	3431	6	of	of	IN
8691	3431	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3431	8	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	3431	9	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	3431	10	_	_	NNP
8691	3431	11	the	the	DT
8691	3431	12	State	State	NNP
8691	3431	13	was	be	VBD
8691	3431	14	at	at	IN
8691	3431	15	peace	peace	NN
8691	3431	16	,	,	,
8691	3431	17	and	and	CC
8691	3431	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3431	19	was	be	VBD
8691	3431	20	generally	generally	RB
8691	3431	21	known	know	VBN
8691	3431	22	,	,	,
8691	3431	23	though	though	IN
8691	3431	24	not	not	RB
8691	3431	25	officially	officially	RB
8691	3431	26	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
8691	3431	27	,	,	,
8691	3431	28	that	that	IN
8691	3431	29	a	a	DT
8691	3431	30	formal	formal	JJ
8691	3431	31	treaty	treaty	NN
8691	3431	32	of	of	IN
8691	3431	33	peace	peace	NN
8691	3431	34	had	have	VBD
8691	3431	35	been	be	VBN
8691	3431	36	signed	sign	VBN
8691	3431	37	between	between	IN
8691	3431	38	the	the	DT
8691	3431	39	United	United	NNP
8691	3431	40	States	States	NNP
8691	3431	41	and	and	CC
8691	3431	42	Great	Great	NNP
8691	3431	43	Britain	Britain	NNP
8691	3431	44	.	.	.
8691	3432	1	The	the	DT
8691	3432	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	3432	3	were	be	VBD
8691	3432	4	open	open	JJ
8691	3432	5	;	;	:
8691	3432	6	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3432	7	court	court	NN
8691	3432	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3432	9	open	open	JJ
8691	3432	10	;	;	:
8691	3432	11	and	and	CC
8691	3432	12	the	the	DT
8691	3432	13	General	General	NNP
8691	3432	14	should	should	MD
8691	3432	15	have	have	VB
8691	3432	16	respected	respect	VBN
8691	3432	17	the	the	DT
8691	3432	18	process	process	NN
8691	3432	19	which	which	WDT
8691	3432	20	issued	issue	VBD
8691	3432	21	from	from	IN
8691	3432	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3432	23	.	.	.
8691	3433	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3433	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3433	3	:	:	:
8691	3433	4	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	3433	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3433	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3433	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3433	8	Duncan	Duncan	NNP
8691	3433	9	,	,	,
8691	3433	10	3	3	CD
8691	3433	11	Martin	Martin	NNP
8691	3433	12	's	's	POS
8691	3433	13	La.	Louisiana	NNP
8691	3434	1	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	3434	2	,	,	,
8691	3434	3	O.	O.	NNP
8691	3434	4	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3434	5	,	,	,
8691	3434	6	530	530	CD
8691	3434	7	.	.	.
8691	3435	1	See	see	VB
8691	3435	2	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3435	3	of	of	IN
8691	3435	4	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	3435	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3435	6	Miller	Miller	NNP
8691	3435	7	in	in	IN
8691	3435	8	Dow	Dow	NNP
8691	3435	9	_	_	NNP
8691	3435	10	v.	v.	IN
8691	3435	11	_	_	NNP
8691	3435	12	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	3435	13	,	,	,
8691	3435	14	100	100	CD
8691	3435	15	U.	U.	NNP
8691	3435	16	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3435	17	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	3435	18	,	,	,
8691	3435	19	158	158	CD
8691	3435	20	,	,	,
8691	3435	21	193	193	CD
8691	3435	22	;	;	:
8691	3435	23	_	_	NNP
8691	3435	24	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	3435	25	parte	parte	NN
8691	3435	26	_	_	NNP
8691	3435	27	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
8691	3435	28	,	,	,
8691	3435	29	4	4	CD
8691	3435	30	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	3435	31	's	's	POS
8691	3435	32	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3435	33	,	,	,
8691	3435	34	2	2	CD
8691	3435	35	,	,	,
8691	3435	36	127	127	CD
8691	3435	37	.	.	.
8691	3435	38	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3436	1	During	during	IN
8691	3436	2	the	the	DT
8691	3436	3	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	3436	4	War	War	NNP
8691	3436	5	,	,	,
8691	3436	6	President	President	NNP
8691	3436	7	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
8691	3436	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3436	9	responsible	responsible	JJ
8691	3436	10	for	for	IN
8691	3436	11	many	many	JJ
8691	3436	12	arrests	arrest	NNS
8691	3436	13	by	by	IN
8691	3436	14	military	military	JJ
8691	3436	15	officers	officer	NNS
8691	3436	16	of	of	IN
8691	3436	17	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	3436	18	of	of	IN
8691	3436	19	States	States	NNPS
8691	3436	20	remote	remote	JJ
8691	3436	21	from	from	IN
8691	3436	22	the	the	DT
8691	3436	23	seat	seat	NN
8691	3436	24	of	of	IN
8691	3436	25	actual	actual	JJ
8691	3436	26	hostilities	hostility	NNS
8691	3436	27	,	,	,
8691	3436	28	and	and	CC
8691	3436	29	in	in	IN
8691	3436	30	which	which	WDT
8691	3436	31	the	the	DT
8691	3436	32	courts	court	NNS
8691	3436	33	were	be	VBD
8691	3436	34	open	open	JJ
8691	3436	35	.	.	.
8691	3437	1	At	at	IN
8691	3437	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3437	3	first	first	JJ
8691	3437	4	outbreak	outbreak	NN
8691	3437	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3437	6	entirely	entirely	RB
8691	3437	7	suspended	suspend	VBD
8691	3437	8	the	the	DT
8691	3437	9	privilege	privilege	NN
8691	3437	10	of	of	IN
8691	3437	11	the	the	DT
8691	3437	12	writ	writ	NNP
8691	3437	13	of	of	IN
8691	3437	14	_	_	NNP
8691	3437	15	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	3437	16	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	3437	17	_	_	NNP
8691	3437	18	,	,	,
8691	3437	19	and	and	CC
8691	3437	20	one	one	CD
8691	3437	21	issued	issue	VBN
8691	3437	22	by	by	IN
8691	3437	23	the	the	DT
8691	3437	24	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3437	25	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3437	26	of	of	IN
8691	3437	27	the	the	DT
8691	3437	28	United	United	NNP
8691	3437	29	States	States	NNP
8691	3437	30	was	be	VBD
8691	3437	31	disobeyed	disobey	VBN
8691	3437	32	.	.	.
8691	3438	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3438	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3438	3	:	:	:
8691	3438	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3438	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	3438	6	parte	parte	NN
8691	3438	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3438	8	Merryman	Merryman	NNP
8691	3438	9	,	,	,
8691	3438	10	Taney	Taney	NNP
8691	3438	11	's	's	POS
8691	3438	12	Decisions	Decisions	NNPS
8691	3438	13	,	,	,
8691	3438	14	246	246	CD
8691	3438	15	.	.	.
8691	3438	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3439	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3439	2	in	in	IN
8691	3439	3	1863	1863	CD
8691	3439	4	enacted	enact	VBD
8691	3439	5	that	that	IN
8691	3439	6	any	any	DT
8691	3439	7	order	order	NN
8691	3439	8	of	of	IN
8691	3439	9	the	the	DT
8691	3439	10	President	President	NNP
8691	3439	11	,	,	,
8691	3439	12	or	or	CC
8691	3439	13	under	under	IN
8691	3439	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3439	15	authority	authority	NN
8691	3439	16	,	,	,
8691	3439	17	in	in	IN
8691	3439	18	the	the	DT
8691	3439	19	course	course	NN
8691	3439	20	of	of	IN
8691	3439	21	the	the	DT
8691	3439	22	war	war	NN
8691	3439	23	,	,	,
8691	3439	24	should	should	MD
8691	3439	25	be	be	VB
8691	3439	26	a	a	DT
8691	3439	27	defense	defense	NN
8691	3439	28	to	to	IN
8691	3439	29	any	any	DT
8691	3439	30	action	action	NN
8691	3439	31	in	in	IN
8691	3439	32	any	any	DT
8691	3439	33	court	court	NN
8691	3439	34	for	for	IN
8691	3439	35	what	what	WP
8691	3439	36	was	be	VBD
8691	3439	37	done	do	VBN
8691	3439	38	by	by	IN
8691	3439	39	virtue	virtue	NN
8691	3439	40	of	of	IN
8691	3439	41	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3439	42	.	.	.
8691	3440	1	The	the	DT
8691	3440	2	State	State	NNP
8691	3440	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	3440	4	disregarded	disregard	VBD
8691	3440	5	the	the	DT
8691	3440	6	statute	statute	NN
8691	3440	7	.	.	.
8691	3441	1	If	if	IN
8691	3441	2	,	,	,
8691	3441	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3441	4	said	say	VBD
8691	3441	5	,	,	,
8691	3441	6	either	either	CC
8691	3441	7	the	the	DT
8691	3441	8	common	common	JJ
8691	3441	9	law	law	NN
8691	3441	10	or	or	CC
8691	3441	11	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3441	12	law	law	NN
8691	3441	13	justified	justify	VBD
8691	3441	14	the	the	DT
8691	3441	15	order	order	NN
8691	3441	16	,	,	,
8691	3441	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3441	18	justified	justify	VBD
8691	3441	19	the	the	DT
8691	3441	20	act	act	NN
8691	3441	21	;	;	:
8691	3441	22	if	if	IN
8691	3441	23	neither	neither	DT
8691	3441	24	did	do	VBD
8691	3441	25	,	,	,
8691	3441	26	the	the	DT
8691	3441	27	fiat	fiat	NN
8691	3441	28	of	of	IN
8691	3441	29	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3441	30	can	can	MD
8691	3441	31	not	not	RB
8691	3441	32	make	make	VB
8691	3441	33	the	the	DT
8691	3441	34	act	act	NN
8691	3441	35	a	a	DT
8691	3441	36	lawful	lawful	JJ
8691	3441	37	one	one	NN
8691	3441	38	.	.	.
8691	3442	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3442	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3442	3	:	:	:
8691	3442	4	Griffin	Griffin	NNP
8691	3442	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3442	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3442	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3442	8	Wilcox	Wilcox	NNP
8691	3442	9	,	,	,
8691	3442	10	21	21	CD
8691	3442	11	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
8691	3442	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3442	13	,	,	,
8691	3442	14	370	370	CD
8691	3442	15	.	.	.
8691	3442	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3443	1	The	the	DT
8691	3443	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3443	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3443	4	of	of	IN
8691	3443	5	the	the	DT
8691	3443	6	United	United	NNP
8691	3443	7	States	States	NNP
8691	3443	8	had	have	VBD
8691	3443	9	this	this	DT
8691	3443	10	question	question	NN
8691	3443	11	before	before	IN
8691	3443	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3443	13	,	,	,
8691	3443	14	but	but	CC
8691	3443	15	did	do	VBD
8691	3443	16	not	not	RB
8691	3443	17	find	find	VB
8691	3443	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3443	19	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	3443	20	to	to	TO
8691	3443	21	decide	decide	VB
8691	3443	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3443	23	.	.	.
8691	3444	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3444	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3444	3	:	:	:
8691	3444	4	Bean	Bean	NNP
8691	3444	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3444	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3444	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3444	8	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
8691	3444	9	,	,	,
8691	3444	10	18	18	CD
8691	3444	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	3444	12	's	's	POS
8691	3444	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3444	14	,	,	,
8691	3444	15	510	510	CD
8691	3444	16	;	;	:
8691	3444	17	Beckwith	Beckwith	NNP
8691	3444	18	_	_	NNP
8691	3444	19	v.	v.	IN
8691	3444	20	_	_	NNP
8691	3444	21	Bean	Bean	NNP
8691	3444	22	,	,	,
8691	3444	23	98	98	CD
8691	3444	24	U.	U.	NNP
8691	3444	25	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3444	26	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	3444	27	,	,	,
8691	3444	28	266	266	CD
8691	3444	29	.	.	.
8691	3445	1	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3445	2	See	see	VB
8691	3445	3	the	the	DT
8691	3445	4	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	3445	5	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3445	6	of	of	IN
8691	3445	7	two	two	CD
8691	3445	8	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3445	9	in	in	IN
8691	3445	10	the	the	DT
8691	3445	11	last	last	JJ
8691	3445	12	report	report	NN
8691	3445	13	,	,	,
8691	3445	14	p.	p.	NN
8691	3446	1	292	292	CD
8691	3446	2	.	.	.
8691	3446	3	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3446	4	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3447	1	Had	have	VBD
8691	3447	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3447	3	done	do	VBN
8691	3447	4	so	so	RB
8691	3447	5	,	,	,
8691	3447	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3447	7	would	would	MD
8691	3447	8	probably	probably	RB
8691	3447	9	have	have	VB
8691	3447	10	been	be	VBN
8691	3447	11	answered	answer	VBN
8691	3447	12	in	in	IN
8691	3447	13	the	the	DT
8691	3447	14	same	same	JJ
8691	3447	15	way	way	NN
8691	3447	16	.	.	.
8691	3448	1	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
8691	3448	2	inserted	insert	VBD
8691	3448	3	in	in	IN
8691	3448	4	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3448	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3448	6	of	of	IN
8691	3448	7	1865	1865	CD
8691	3448	8	a	a	DT
8691	3448	9	provision	provision	NN
8691	3448	10	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3448	11	to	to	IN
8691	3448	12	the	the	DT
8691	3448	13	Act	Act	NNP
8691	3448	14	of	of	IN
8691	3448	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3448	16	.	.	.
8691	3449	1	This	this	DT
8691	3449	2	,	,	,
8691	3449	3	of	of	IN
8691	3449	4	course	course	NN
8691	3449	5	,	,	,
8691	3449	6	so	so	RB
8691	3449	7	far	far	RB
8691	3449	8	as	as	IN
8691	3449	9	that	that	DT
8691	3449	10	State	State	NNP
8691	3449	11	could	could	MD
8691	3449	12	do	do	VB
8691	3449	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3449	14	,	,	,
8691	3449	15	abrogated	abrogate	VBD
8691	3449	16	any	any	DT
8691	3449	17	rule	rule	NN
8691	3449	18	of	of	IN
8691	3449	19	law	law	NN
8691	3449	20	to	to	IN
8691	3449	21	the	the	DT
8691	3449	22	contrary	contrary	NN
8691	3449	23	,	,	,
8691	3449	24	and	and	CC
8691	3449	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3449	26	was	be	VBD
8691	3449	27	held	hold	VBN
8691	3449	28	not	not	RB
8691	3449	29	to	to	TO
8691	3449	30	contravene	contravene	VB
8691	3449	31	any	any	DT
8691	3449	32	provision	provision	NN
8691	3449	33	of	of	IN
8691	3449	34	the	the	DT
8691	3449	35	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	3449	36	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3449	37	.	.	.
8691	3450	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3450	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3450	3	:	:	:
8691	3450	4	Drehman	Drehman	NNP
8691	3450	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3450	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3450	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3450	8	Stifle	Stifle	NNP
8691	3450	9	,	,	,
8691	3450	10	8	8	CD
8691	3450	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	3450	12	's	's	POS
8691	3450	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3450	14	,	,	,
8691	3450	15	595	595	CD
8691	3450	16	.	.	.
8691	3450	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3451	1	The	the	DT
8691	3451	2	transaction	transaction	NN
8691	3451	3	in	in	IN
8691	3451	4	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	3451	5	,	,	,
8691	3451	6	however	however	RB
8691	3451	7	,	,	,
8691	3451	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3451	9	before	before	IN
8691	3451	10	the	the	DT
8691	3451	11	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	3451	12	of	of	IN
8691	3451	13	the	the	DT
8691	3451	14	fourteenth	fourteenth	NNP
8691	3451	15	amendment	amendment	NN
8691	3451	16	,	,	,
8691	3451	17	and	and	CC
8691	3451	18	had	have	VBD
8691	3451	19	the	the	DT
8691	3451	20	prohibition	prohibition	NN
8691	3451	21	in	in	IN
8691	3451	22	that	that	DT
8691	3451	23	been	be	VBN
8691	3451	24	then	then	RB
8691	3451	25	in	in	IN
8691	3451	26	existence	existence	NN
8691	3451	27	,	,	,
8691	3451	28	a	a	DT
8691	3451	29	different	different	JJ
8691	3451	30	result	result	NN
8691	3451	31	would	would	MD
8691	3451	32	probably	probably	RB
8691	3451	33	have	have	VB
8691	3451	34	been	be	VBN
8691	3451	35	reached	reach	VBN
8691	3451	36	.	.	.
8691	3452	1	The	the	DT
8691	3452	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3452	3	of	of	IN
8691	3452	4	North	North	NNP
8691	3452	5	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	3452	6	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3452	7	William	William	NNP
8691	3452	8	W.	W.	NNP
8691	3452	9	Holden	Holden	NNP
8691	3452	10	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3452	11	in	in	IN
8691	3452	12	1870	1870	CD
8691	3452	13	declared	declare	VBD
8691	3452	14	two	two	CD
8691	3452	15	counties	county	NNS
8691	3452	16	in	in	IN
8691	3452	17	a	a	DT
8691	3452	18	state	state	NN
8691	3452	19	of	of	IN
8691	3452	20	insurrection	insurrection	NN
8691	3452	21	.	.	.
8691	3453	1	The	the	DT
8691	3453	2	militia	militia	NN
8691	3453	3	were	be	VBD
8691	3453	4	called	call	VBN
8691	3453	5	out	out	RP
8691	3453	6	and	and	CC
8691	3453	7	a	a	DT
8691	3453	8	number	number	NN
8691	3453	9	of	of	IN
8691	3453	10	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	3453	11	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	3453	12	.	.	.
8691	3454	1	Writs	writ	NNS
8691	3454	2	of	of	IN
8691	3454	3	_	_	NNP
8691	3454	4	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	3454	5	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	3454	6	_	_	NNP
8691	3454	7	in	in	IN
8691	3454	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3454	9	favor	favor	NN
8691	3454	10	were	be	VBD
8691	3454	11	issued	issue	VBN
8691	3454	12	by	by	IN
8691	3454	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3454	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3454	15	Pearson	Pearson	NNP
8691	3454	16	of	of	IN
8691	3454	17	the	the	DT
8691	3454	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3454	19	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3454	20	of	of	IN
8691	3454	21	the	the	DT
8691	3454	22	State	State	NNP
8691	3454	23	against	against	IN
8691	3454	24	the	the	DT
8691	3454	25	military	military	JJ
8691	3454	26	officers	officer	NNS
8691	3454	27	.	.	.
8691	3455	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3455	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3455	3	:	:	:
8691	3455	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3455	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	3455	6	parte	parte	NN
8691	3455	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3455	8	Moore	Moore	NNP
8691	3455	9	,	,	,
8691	3455	10	64	64	CD
8691	3455	11	North	North	NNP
8691	3455	12	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	3455	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3455	14	,	,	,
8691	3455	15	802	802	CD
8691	3455	16	;	;	:
8691	3455	17	65	65	CD
8691	3455	18	North	North	NNP
8691	3455	19	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	3455	20	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3455	21	,	,	,
8691	3455	22	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
8691	3455	23	,	,	,
8691	3455	24	349	349	CD
8691	3455	25	.	.	.
8691	3455	26	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3456	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3456	2	at	at	IN
8691	3456	3	first	first	RB
8691	3456	4	refused	refuse	VBN
8691	3456	5	,	,	,
8691	3456	6	by	by	IN
8691	3456	7	the	the	DT
8691	3456	8	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3456	9	's	's	POS
8691	3456	10	authority	authority	NN
8691	3456	11	,	,	,
8691	3456	12	to	to	TO
8691	3456	13	obey	obey	VB
8691	3456	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3456	15	.	.	.
8691	3457	1	Similar	similar	JJ
8691	3457	2	writs	writ	NNS
8691	3457	3	were	be	VBD
8691	3457	4	then	then	RB
8691	3457	5	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	3457	6	from	from	IN
8691	3457	7	the	the	DT
8691	3457	8	District	District	NNP
8691	3457	9	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3457	10	of	of	IN
8691	3457	11	the	the	DT
8691	3457	12	United	United	NNP
8691	3457	13	States	States	NNP
8691	3457	14	,	,	,
8691	3457	15	upon	upon	IN
8691	3457	16	which	which	WDT
8691	3457	17	the	the	DT
8691	3457	18	petitioners	petitioner	NNS
8691	3457	19	were	be	VBD
8691	3457	20	,	,	,
8691	3457	21	by	by	IN
8691	3457	22	the	the	DT
8691	3457	23	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3457	24	's	's	POS
8691	3457	25	orders	order	NNS
8691	3457	26	,	,	,
8691	3457	27	produced	produce	VBN
8691	3457	28	before	before	IN
8691	3457	29	the	the	DT
8691	3457	30	State	State	NNP
8691	3457	31	judge	judge	NN
8691	3457	32	.	.	.
8691	3458	1	The	the	DT
8691	3458	2	result	result	NN
8691	3458	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3458	4	the	the	DT
8691	3458	5	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	3458	6	of	of	IN
8691	3458	7	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3458	8	Holden	Holden	NNP
8691	3458	9	and	and	CC
8691	3458	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3458	11	removal	removal	NN
8691	3458	12	from	from	IN
8691	3458	13	office	office	NN
8691	3458	14	.	.	.
8691	3459	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3459	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3459	3	:	:	:
8691	3459	4	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3459	5	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3459	6	Cox	Cox	NNP
8691	3459	7	,	,	,
8691	3459	8	"	"	``
8691	3459	9	Three	Three	NNP
8691	3459	10	Decades	Decades	NNPS
8691	3459	11	of	of	IN
8691	3459	12	Federal	Federal	NNP
8691	3459	13	Legislation	Legislation	NNP
8691	3459	14	,	,	,
8691	3459	15	"	"	''
8691	3459	16	458	458	CD
8691	3459	17	.	.	.
8691	3459	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3460	1	While	while	IN
8691	3460	2	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3460	3	law	law	NN
8691	3460	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3460	5	the	the	DT
8691	3460	6	will	will	NN
8691	3460	7	of	of	IN
8691	3460	8	the	the	DT
8691	3460	9	commanding	command	VBG
8691	3460	10	officer	officer	NN
8691	3460	11	,	,	,
8691	3460	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3460	13	may	may	MD
8691	3460	14	be	be	VB
8691	3460	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3460	16	will	will	NN
8691	3460	17	to	to	TO
8691	3460	18	have	have	VB
8691	3460	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3460	20	applied	apply	VBN
8691	3460	21	,	,	,
8691	3460	22	so	so	RB
8691	3460	23	far	far	RB
8691	3460	24	as	as	IN
8691	3460	25	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	3460	26	matters	matter	NNS
8691	3460	27	of	of	IN
8691	3460	28	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	3460	29	are	be	VBP
8691	3460	30	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	3460	31	,	,	,
8691	3460	32	by	by	IN
8691	3460	33	courts	court	NNS
8691	3460	34	.	.	.
8691	3461	1	For	for	IN
8691	3461	2	that	that	DT
8691	3461	3	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	3461	4	,	,	,
8691	3461	5	when	when	WRB
8691	3461	6	in	in	IN
8691	3461	7	occupation	occupation	NN
8691	3461	8	of	of	IN
8691	3461	9	enemy	enemy	NN
8691	3461	10	's	's	POS
8691	3461	11	territory	territory	NN
8691	3461	12	,	,	,
8691	3461	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3461	14	may	may	MD
8691	3461	15	allow	allow	VB
8691	3461	16	the	the	DT
8691	3461	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	3461	18	previously	previously	RB
8691	3461	19	existing	exist	VBG
8691	3461	20	under	under	IN
8691	3461	21	the	the	DT
8691	3461	22	government	government	NN
8691	3461	23	of	of	IN
8691	3461	24	the	the	DT
8691	3461	25	enemy	enemy	NN
8691	3461	26	to	to	TO
8691	3461	27	continue	continue	VB
8691	3461	28	in	in	IN
8691	3461	29	the	the	DT
8691	3461	30	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	3461	31	of	of	IN
8691	3461	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3461	33	functions	function	NNS
8691	3461	34	as	as	IN
8691	3461	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3461	36	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	3461	37	representatives	representative	NNS
8691	3461	38	;	;	:
8691	3461	39	or	or	CC
8691	3461	40	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3461	41	can	can	MD
8691	3461	42	institute	institute	VB
8691	3461	43	new	new	JJ
8691	3461	44	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	3461	45	of	of	IN
8691	3461	46	local	local	JJ
8691	3461	47	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3461	48	having	have	VBG
8691	3461	49	the	the	DT
8691	3461	50	name	name	NN
8691	3461	51	and	and	CC
8691	3461	52	form	form	NN
8691	3461	53	of	of	IN
8691	3461	54	civil	civil	JJ
8691	3461	55	courts	court	NNS
8691	3461	56	,	,	,
8691	3461	57	and	and	CC
8691	3461	58	proceeding	proceed	VBG
8691	3461	59	according	accord	VBG
8691	3461	60	to	to	IN
8691	3461	61	the	the	DT
8691	3461	62	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	3461	63	rules	rule	NNS
8691	3461	64	of	of	IN
8691	3461	65	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	3461	66	justice	justice	NN
8691	3461	67	.	.	.
8691	3462	1	All	all	DT
8691	3462	2	such	such	JJ
8691	3462	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	3462	4	act	act	VBP
8691	3462	5	really	really	RB
8691	3462	6	as	as	IN
8691	3462	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3462	8	agents	agent	NNS
8691	3462	9	and	and	CC
8691	3462	10	subject	subject	JJ
8691	3462	11	to	to	IN
8691	3462	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3462	13	control	control	NN
8691	3462	14	,	,	,
8691	3462	15	but	but	CC
8691	3462	16	in	in	IN
8691	3462	17	practice	practice	NN
8691	3462	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3462	19	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	3462	20	interferes	interfere	VBZ
8691	3462	21	with	with	IN
8691	3462	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3462	23	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	3462	24	.	.	.
8691	3463	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3463	2	can	can	MD
8691	3463	3	not	not	RB
8691	3463	4	,	,	,
8691	3463	5	however	however	RB
8691	3463	6	,	,	,
8691	3463	7	in	in	IN
8691	3463	8	establishing	establish	VBG
8691	3463	9	such	such	PDT
8691	3463	10	a	a	DT
8691	3463	11	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	3463	12	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	3463	13	,	,	,
8691	3463	14	give	give	VB
8691	3463	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3463	16	the	the	DT
8691	3463	17	powers	power	NNS
8691	3463	18	of	of	IN
8691	3463	19	an	an	DT
8691	3463	20	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	3463	21	court	court	NN
8691	3463	22	over	over	IN
8691	3463	23	prize	prize	NN
8691	3463	24	cases	case	NNS
8691	3463	25	.	.	.
8691	3464	1	The	the	DT
8691	3464	2	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3464	3	_	_	NNP
8691	3464	4	in	in	IN
8691	3464	5	rem	rem	NNP
8691	3464	6	_	_	NNP
8691	3464	7	of	of	IN
8691	3464	8	an	an	DT
8691	3464	9	admiralty	admiralty	JJ
8691	3464	10	court	court	NN
8691	3464	11	,	,	,
8691	3464	12	condemning	condemn	VBG
8691	3464	13	a	a	DT
8691	3464	14	captured	capture	VBN
8691	3464	15	ship	ship	NN
8691	3464	16	as	as	IN
8691	3464	17	a	a	DT
8691	3464	18	lawful	lawful	JJ
8691	3464	19	prize	prize	NN
8691	3464	20	of	of	IN
8691	3464	21	war	war	NN
8691	3464	22	,	,	,
8691	3464	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	3464	24	treated	treat	VBN
8691	3464	25	as	as	IN
8691	3464	26	conclusive	conclusive	JJ
8691	3464	27	all	all	RB
8691	3464	28	over	over	IN
8691	3464	29	the	the	DT
8691	3464	30	world	world	NN
8691	3464	31	;	;	:
8691	3464	32	but	but	CC
8691	3464	33	this	this	DT
8691	3464	34	is	be	VBZ
8691	3464	35	because	because	IN
8691	3464	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3464	37	is	be	VBZ
8691	3464	38	a	a	DT
8691	3464	39	decree	decree	NN
8691	3464	40	of	of	IN
8691	3464	41	a	a	DT
8691	3464	42	competent	competent	JJ
8691	3464	43	court	court	NN
8691	3464	44	,	,	,
8691	3464	45	properly	properly	RB
8691	3464	46	established	establish	VBN
8691	3464	47	to	to	TO
8691	3464	48	administer	administer	VB
8691	3464	49	a	a	DT
8691	3464	50	branch	branch	NN
8691	3464	51	of	of	IN
8691	3464	52	maritime	maritime	JJ
8691	3464	53	law	law	NN
8691	3464	54	which	which	WDT
8691	3464	55	,	,	,
8691	3464	56	in	in	IN
8691	3464	57	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3464	58	main	main	JJ
8691	3464	59	principles	principle	NNS
8691	3464	60	,	,	,
8691	3464	61	is	be	VBZ
8691	3464	62	part	part	NN
8691	3464	63	of	of	IN
8691	3464	64	the	the	DT
8691	3464	65	law	law	NN
8691	3464	66	of	of	IN
8691	3464	67	nations	nation	NNS
8691	3464	68	and	and	CC
8691	3464	69	common	common	JJ
8691	3464	70	to	to	IN
8691	3464	71	the	the	DT
8691	3464	72	world	world	NN
8691	3464	73	.	.	.
8691	3465	1	No	no	DT
8691	3465	2	mere	mere	JJ
8691	3465	3	military	military	JJ
8691	3465	4	court	court	NN
8691	3465	5	on	on	IN
8691	3465	6	enemy	enemy	NN
8691	3465	7	's	's	POS
8691	3465	8	territory	territory	NN
8691	3465	9	occupies	occupie	NNS
8691	3465	10	that	that	DT
8691	3465	11	position	position	NN
8691	3465	12	.	.	.
8691	3466	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3466	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3466	3	:	:	:
8691	3466	4	Jecker	Jecker	NNP
8691	3466	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3466	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3466	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3466	8	Montgomery	Montgomery	NNP
8691	3466	9	,	,	,
8691	3466	10	13	13	CD
8691	3466	11	Howard	Howard	NNP
8691	3466	12	's	's	POS
8691	3466	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3466	14	,	,	,
8691	3466	15	498	498	CD
8691	3466	16	,	,	,
8691	3466	17	515	515	CD
8691	3466	18	.	.	.
8691	3466	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3467	1	This	this	DT
8691	3467	2	right	right	NN
8691	3467	3	of	of	IN
8691	3467	4	the	the	DT
8691	3467	5	military	military	JJ
8691	3467	6	commander	commander	NN
8691	3467	7	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	3467	8	equally	equally	RB
8691	3467	9	on	on	IN
8691	3467	10	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	3467	11	territory	territory	NN
8691	3467	12	in	in	IN
8691	3467	13	military	military	JJ
8691	3467	14	occupation	occupation	NN
8691	3467	15	and	and	CC
8691	3467	16	on	on	IN
8691	3467	17	domestic	domestic	JJ
8691	3467	18	territory	territory	NN
8691	3467	19	,	,	,
8691	3467	20	when	when	WRB
8691	3467	21	the	the	DT
8691	3467	22	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	3467	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	3467	24	of	of	IN
8691	3467	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3467	26	country	country	NN
8691	3467	27	are	be	VBP
8691	3467	28	not	not	RB
8691	3467	29	open	open	JJ
8691	3467	30	.	.	.
8691	3468	1	During	during	IN
8691	3468	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3468	3	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	3468	4	War	War	NNP
8691	3468	5	,	,	,
8691	3468	6	in	in	IN
8691	3468	7	1864	1864	CD
8691	3468	8	,	,	,
8691	3468	9	President	President	NNP
8691	3468	10	Lincoln	Lincoln	NNP
8691	3468	11	,	,	,
8691	3468	12	as	as	IN
8691	3468	13	commander	commander	NN
8691	3468	14	in	in	IN
8691	3468	15	chief	chief	NN
8691	3468	16	of	of	IN
8691	3468	17	the	the	DT
8691	3468	18	army	army	NNP
8691	3468	19	and	and	CC
8691	3468	20	navy	navy	NNP
8691	3468	21	,	,	,
8691	3468	22	set	set	VBD
8691	3468	23	up	up	RP
8691	3468	24	a	a	DT
8691	3468	25	"	"	``
8691	3468	26	Provisional	Provisional	NNP
8691	3468	27	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3468	28	for	for	IN
8691	3468	29	the	the	DT
8691	3468	30	State	State	NNP
8691	3468	31	of	of	IN
8691	3468	32	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	3468	33	,	,	,
8691	3468	34	"	"	''
8691	3468	35	after	after	IN
8691	3468	36	the	the	DT
8691	3468	37	Southern	southern	JJ
8691	3468	38	portion	portion	NN
8691	3468	39	of	of	IN
8691	3468	40	that	that	DT
8691	3468	41	State	State	NNP
8691	3468	42	had	have	VBD
8691	3468	43	been	be	VBN
8691	3468	44	occupied	occupy	VBN
8691	3468	45	by	by	IN
8691	3468	46	the	the	DT
8691	3468	47	national	national	JJ
8691	3468	48	forces	force	NNS
8691	3468	49	and	and	CC
8691	3468	50	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3468	51	law	law	NN
8691	3468	52	declared	declare	VBD
8691	3468	53	.	.	.
8691	3469	1	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3469	2	Charles	Charles	NNP
8691	3469	3	A.	A.	NNP
8691	3469	4	Peabody	Peabody	NNP
8691	3469	5	of	of	IN
8691	3469	6	New	New	NNP
8691	3469	7	York	York	NNP
8691	3469	8	,	,	,
8691	3469	9	who	who	WP
8691	3469	10	had	have	VBD
8691	3469	11	been	be	VBN
8691	3469	12	a	a	DT
8691	3469	13	justice	justice	NN
8691	3469	14	of	of	IN
8691	3469	15	the	the	DT
8691	3469	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3469	17	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3469	18	of	of	IN
8691	3469	19	that	that	DT
8691	3469	20	State	State	NNP
8691	3469	21	,	,	,
8691	3469	22	was	be	VBD
8691	3469	23	commissioned	commission	VBN
8691	3469	24	to	to	TO
8691	3469	25	hold	hold	VB
8691	3469	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3469	27	and	and	CC
8691	3469	28	to	to	TO
8691	3469	29	dispose	dispose	VB
8691	3469	30	of	of	IN
8691	3469	31	both	both	CC
8691	3469	32	civil	civil	JJ
8691	3469	33	and	and	CC
8691	3469	34	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3469	35	causes	cause	NNS
8691	3469	36	.	.	.
8691	3470	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3470	2	docket	docket	NN
8691	3470	3	became	become	VBD
8691	3470	4	at	at	IN
8691	3470	5	once	once	RB
8691	3470	6	a	a	DT
8691	3470	7	full	full	JJ
8691	3470	8	one	one	CD
8691	3470	9	,	,	,
8691	3470	10	and	and	CC
8691	3470	11	important	important	JJ
8691	3470	12	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	3470	13	was	be	VBD
8691	3470	14	transacted	transact	VBN
8691	3470	15	there	there	RB
8691	3470	16	with	with	IN
8691	3470	17	general	general	JJ
8691	3470	18	acceptance	acceptance	NN
8691	3470	19	until	until	IN
8691	3470	20	the	the	DT
8691	3470	21	close	close	NN
8691	3470	22	of	of	IN
8691	3470	23	the	the	DT
8691	3470	24	war	war	NN
8691	3470	25	.	.	.
8691	3471	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3471	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3471	3	:	:	:
8691	3471	4	The	the	DT
8691	3471	5	Grapeshot	Grapeshot	NNP
8691	3471	6	,	,	,
8691	3471	7	9	9	CD
8691	3471	8	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	3471	9	's	's	POS
8691	3471	10	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3471	11	,	,	,
8691	3471	12	129	129	CD
8691	3471	13	;	;	:
8691	3471	14	Report	Report	NNP
8691	3471	15	of	of	IN
8691	3471	16	Am	Am	NNP
8691	3471	17	.	.	.
8691	3472	1	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	3472	2	Association	Association	NNP
8691	3472	3	for	for	IN
8691	3472	4	1892	1892	CD
8691	3472	5	,	,	,
8691	3472	6	199	199	CD
8691	3472	7	.	.	.
8691	3472	8	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3473	1	In	in	IN
8691	3473	2	the	the	DT
8691	3473	3	original	original	JJ
8691	3473	4	proclamation	proclamation	NN
8691	3473	5	of	of	IN
8691	3473	6	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3473	7	law	law	NN
8691	3473	8	in	in	IN
8691	3473	9	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	3473	10	the	the	DT
8691	3473	11	commanding	command	VBG
8691	3473	12	officer	officer	NN
8691	3473	13	announced	announce	VBD
8691	3473	14	that	that	IN
8691	3473	15	civil	civil	JJ
8691	3473	16	causes	cause	NNS
8691	3473	17	between	between	IN
8691	3473	18	parties	party	NNS
8691	3473	19	would	would	MD
8691	3473	20	be	be	VB
8691	3473	21	referred	refer	VBN
8691	3473	22	to	to	IN
8691	3473	23	the	the	DT
8691	3473	24	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	3473	25	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	3473	26	.	.	.
8691	3474	1	One	one	CD
8691	3474	2	of	of	IN
8691	3474	3	the	the	DT
8691	3474	4	State	State	NNP
8691	3474	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	3474	6	,	,	,
8691	3474	7	known	know	VBN
8691	3474	8	as	as	IN
8691	3474	9	a	a	DT
8691	3474	10	District	District	NNP
8691	3474	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3474	12	of	of	IN
8691	3474	13	the	the	DT
8691	3474	14	City	City	NNP
8691	3474	15	and	and	CC
8691	3474	16	Parish	Parish	NNP
8691	3474	17	of	of	IN
8691	3474	18	New	New	NNP
8691	3474	19	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
8691	3474	20	,	,	,
8691	3474	21	the	the	DT
8691	3474	22	judge	judge	NN
8691	3474	23	of	of	IN
8691	3474	24	which	which	WDT
8691	3474	25	took	take	VBD
8691	3474	26	the	the	DT
8691	3474	27	oath	oath	NN
8691	3474	28	of	of	IN
8691	3474	29	allegiance	allegiance	NN
8691	3474	30	to	to	IN
8691	3474	31	the	the	DT
8691	3474	32	United	United	NNP
8691	3474	33	States	States	NNP
8691	3474	34	,	,	,
8691	3474	35	continued	continue	VBD
8691	3474	36	to	to	TO
8691	3474	37	sit	sit	VB
8691	3474	38	and	and	CC
8691	3474	39	dispose	dispose	VB
8691	3474	40	of	of	IN
8691	3474	41	business	business	NN
8691	3474	42	in	in	IN
8691	3474	43	the	the	DT
8691	3474	44	usual	usual	JJ
8691	3474	45	course	course	NN
8691	3474	46	.	.	.
8691	3475	1	A	a	DT
8691	3475	2	few	few	JJ
8691	3475	3	months	month	NNS
8691	3475	4	later	later	RB
8691	3475	5	a	a	DT
8691	3475	6	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	3475	7	of	of	IN
8691	3475	8	New	New	NNP
8691	3475	9	York	York	NNP
8691	3475	10	sued	sue	VBD
8691	3475	11	a	a	DT
8691	3475	12	military	military	JJ
8691	3475	13	officer	officer	NN
8691	3475	14	before	before	IN
8691	3475	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3475	16	for	for	IN
8691	3475	17	ravaging	ravage	VBG
8691	3475	18	a	a	DT
8691	3475	19	plantation	plantation	NN
8691	3475	20	which	which	WDT
8691	3475	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3475	22	owned	own	VBD
8691	3475	23	in	in	IN
8691	3475	24	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	3475	25	,	,	,
8691	3475	26	and	and	CC
8691	3475	27	recovered	recover	VBN
8691	3475	28	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3475	29	.	.	.
8691	3476	1	A	a	DT
8691	3476	2	suit	suit	NN
8691	3476	3	upon	upon	IN
8691	3476	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3476	5	was	be	VBD
8691	3476	6	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	3476	7	brought	bring	VBN
8691	3476	8	in	in	IN
8691	3476	9	Maine	Maine	NNP
8691	3476	10	,	,	,
8691	3476	11	where	where	WRB
8691	3476	12	the	the	DT
8691	3476	13	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	3476	14	resided	reside	VBD
8691	3476	15	.	.	.
8691	3477	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3477	2	pleaded	plead	VBD
8691	3477	3	that	that	IN
8691	3477	4	the	the	DT
8691	3477	5	property	property	NN
8691	3477	6	of	of	IN
8691	3477	7	the	the	DT
8691	3477	8	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	3477	9	had	have	VBD
8691	3477	10	been	be	VBN
8691	3477	11	taken	take	VBN
8691	3477	12	to	to	TO
8691	3477	13	furnish	furnish	VB
8691	3477	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3477	15	troops	troop	NNS
8691	3477	16	with	with	IN
8691	3477	17	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	3477	18	supplies	supply	NNS
8691	3477	19	.	.	.
8691	3478	1	The	the	DT
8691	3478	2	case	case	NN
8691	3478	3	ultimately	ultimately	RB
8691	3478	4	came	come	VBD
8691	3478	5	before	before	IN
8691	3478	6	the	the	DT
8691	3478	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3478	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3478	9	of	of	IN
8691	3478	10	the	the	DT
8691	3478	11	United	United	NNP
8691	3478	12	States	States	NNP
8691	3478	13	.	.	.
8691	3479	1	Here	here	RB
8691	3479	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3479	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3479	4	thrown	throw	VBN
8691	3479	5	out	out	RP
8691	3479	6	,	,	,
8691	3479	7	the	the	DT
8691	3479	8	court	court	NN
8691	3479	9	saying	say	VBG
8691	3479	10	that	that	IN
8691	3479	11	the	the	DT
8691	3479	12	District	District	NNP
8691	3479	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3479	14	of	of	IN
8691	3479	15	New	New	NNP
8691	3479	16	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
8691	3479	17	had	have	VBD
8691	3479	18	no	no	DT
8691	3479	19	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3479	20	to	to	TO
8691	3479	21	call	call	VB
8691	3479	22	military	military	JJ
8691	3479	23	officers	officer	NNS
8691	3479	24	to	to	TO
8691	3479	25	account	account	VB
8691	3479	26	for	for	IN
8691	3479	27	acts	act	NNS
8691	3479	28	done	do	VBN
8691	3479	29	under	under	IN
8691	3479	30	claim	claim	NN
8691	3479	31	of	of	IN
8691	3479	32	military	military	JJ
8691	3479	33	right	right	NN
8691	3479	34	.	.	.
8691	3480	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3480	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3480	3	:	:	:
8691	3480	4	Dow	Dow	NNP
8691	3480	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3480	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3480	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3480	8	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	3480	9	,	,	,
8691	3480	10	100	100	CD
8691	3480	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	3480	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3480	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	3480	14	,	,	,
8691	3480	15	158	158	CD
8691	3480	16	.	.	.
8691	3480	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3481	1	So	so	RB
8691	3481	2	far	far	RB
8691	3481	3	,	,	,
8691	3481	4	however	however	RB
8691	3481	5	,	,	,
8691	3481	6	as	as	IN
8691	3481	7	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	3481	8	between	between	IN
8691	3481	9	private	private	JJ
8691	3481	10	parties	party	NNS
8691	3481	11	unconnected	unconnecte	VBN
8691	3481	12	with	with	IN
8691	3481	13	military	military	JJ
8691	3481	14	operations	operation	NNS
8691	3481	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	3481	16	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	3481	17	,	,	,
8691	3481	18	a	a	DT
8691	3481	19	court	court	NN
8691	3481	20	of	of	IN
8691	3481	21	this	this	DT
8691	3481	22	character	character	NN
8691	3481	23	,	,	,
8691	3481	24	established	establish	VBN
8691	3481	25	by	by	IN
8691	3481	26	law	law	NN
8691	3481	27	,	,	,
8691	3481	28	and	and	CC
8691	3481	29	suffered	suffer	VBN
8691	3481	30	by	by	IN
8691	3481	31	the	the	DT
8691	3481	32	military	military	JJ
8691	3481	33	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	3481	34	to	to	TO
8691	3481	35	continue	continue	VB
8691	3481	36	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3481	37	sessions	session	NNS
8691	3481	38	,	,	,
8691	3481	39	has	have	VBZ
8691	3481	40	competent	competent	JJ
8691	3481	41	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3481	42	,	,	,
8691	3481	43	and	and	CC
8691	3481	44	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3481	45	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	3481	46	will	will	MD
8691	3481	47	be	be	VB
8691	3481	48	enforced	enforce	VBN
8691	3481	49	in	in	IN
8691	3481	50	other	other	JJ
8691	3481	51	States	state	NNS
8691	3481	52	.	.	.
8691	3482	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3482	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3482	3	:	:	:
8691	3482	4	Pepin	Pepin	NNP
8691	3482	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3482	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3482	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3482	8	Lachenmeyer	Lachenmeyer	NNP
8691	3482	9	,	,	,
8691	3482	10	45	45	CD
8691	3482	11	New	New	NNP
8691	3482	12	York	York	NNP
8691	3482	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3482	14	,	,	,
8691	3482	15	27	27	CD
8691	3482	16	.	.	.
8691	3482	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3483	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3483	2	have	have	VBP
8691	3483	3	no	no	DT
8691	3483	4	power	power	NN
8691	3483	5	to	to	TO
8691	3483	6	entertain	entertain	VB
8691	3483	7	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3483	8	charges	charge	NNS
8691	3483	9	against	against	IN
8691	3483	10	those	those	DT
8691	3483	11	in	in	IN
8691	3483	12	the	the	DT
8691	3483	13	military	military	JJ
8691	3483	14	service	service	NN
8691	3483	15	,	,	,
8691	3483	16	who	who	WP
8691	3483	17	would	would	MD
8691	3483	18	be	be	VB
8691	3483	19	punishable	punishable	JJ
8691	3483	20	by	by	IN
8691	3483	21	court	court	NN
8691	3483	22	martial	martial	NN
8691	3483	23	.	.	.
8691	3484	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3484	2	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	3484	3	:	:	:
8691	3484	4	Coleman	Coleman	NNP
8691	3484	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3484	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3484	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3484	8	Tennessee	Tennessee	NNP
8691	3484	9	,	,	,
8691	3484	10	97	97	CD
8691	3484	11	U.	U.	NNP
8691	3484	12	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3484	13	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	3484	14	,	,	,
8691	3484	15	509	509	CD
8691	3484	16	,	,	,
8691	3484	17	519	519	CD
8691	3484	18	.	.	.
8691	3484	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3485	1	In	in	IN
8691	3485	2	1864	1864	CD
8691	3485	3	,	,	,
8691	3485	4	during	during	IN
8691	3485	5	the	the	DT
8691	3485	6	war	war	NN
8691	3485	7	,	,	,
8691	3485	8	but	but	CC
8691	3485	9	in	in	IN
8691	3485	10	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
8691	3485	11	,	,	,
8691	3485	12	a	a	DT
8691	3485	13	State	state	NN
8691	3485	14	distant	distant	JJ
8691	3485	15	from	from	IN
8691	3485	16	the	the	DT
8691	3485	17	seat	seat	NN
8691	3485	18	of	of	IN
8691	3485	19	hostilities	hostility	NNS
8691	3485	20	,	,	,
8691	3485	21	the	the	DT
8691	3485	22	military	military	JJ
8691	3485	23	commandant	commandant	NN
8691	3485	24	of	of	IN
8691	3485	25	the	the	DT
8691	3485	26	district	district	NN
8691	3485	27	ordered	order	VBD
8691	3485	28	the	the	DT
8691	3485	29	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	3485	30	of	of	IN
8691	3485	31	a	a	DT
8691	3485	32	private	private	JJ
8691	3485	33	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	3485	34	and	and	CC
8691	3485	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3485	36	trial	trial	NN
8691	3485	37	before	before	IN
8691	3485	38	a	a	DT
8691	3485	39	military	military	JJ
8691	3485	40	commission	commission	NN
8691	3485	41	on	on	IN
8691	3485	42	charges	charge	NNS
8691	3485	43	of	of	IN
8691	3485	44	conspiracy	conspiracy	NN
8691	3485	45	against	against	IN
8691	3485	46	the	the	DT
8691	3485	47	United	United	NNP
8691	3485	48	States	States	NNP
8691	3485	49	,	,	,
8691	3485	50	as	as	IN
8691	3485	51	a	a	DT
8691	3485	52	member	member	NN
8691	3485	53	of	of	IN
8691	3485	54	a	a	DT
8691	3485	55	secret	secret	JJ
8691	3485	56	organization	organization	NN
8691	3485	57	known	know	VBN
8691	3485	58	as	as	IN
8691	3485	59	the	the	DT
8691	3485	60	Order	order	NN
8691	3485	61	of	of	IN
8691	3485	62	American	American	NNP
8691	3485	63	Knights	Knights	NNPS
8691	3485	64	or	or	CC
8691	3485	65	Sons	Sons	NNPS
8691	3485	66	of	of	IN
8691	3485	67	Liberty	Liberty	NNP
8691	3485	68	.	.	.
8691	3486	1	The	the	DT
8691	3486	2	trial	trial	NN
8691	3486	3	resulted	result	VBD
8691	3486	4	in	in	IN
8691	3486	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3486	6	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	3486	7	,	,	,
8691	3486	8	and	and	CC
8691	3486	9	a	a	DT
8691	3486	10	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	3486	11	to	to	IN
8691	3486	12	death	death	NN
8691	3486	13	,	,	,
8691	3486	14	which	which	WDT
8691	3486	15	was	be	VBD
8691	3486	16	approved	approve	VBN
8691	3486	17	by	by	IN
8691	3486	18	the	the	DT
8691	3486	19	President	President	NNP
8691	3486	20	of	of	IN
8691	3486	21	the	the	DT
8691	3486	22	United	United	NNP
8691	3486	23	States	States	NNP
8691	3486	24	.	.	.
8691	3487	1	Before	before	IN
8691	3487	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3487	3	could	could	MD
8691	3487	4	be	be	VB
8691	3487	5	executed	execute	VBN
8691	3487	6	,	,	,
8691	3487	7	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3487	8	applied	apply	VBD
8691	3487	9	to	to	IN
8691	3487	10	the	the	DT
8691	3487	11	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	3487	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3487	13	of	of	IN
8691	3487	14	the	the	DT
8691	3487	15	United	United	NNP
8691	3487	16	States	States	NNP
8691	3487	17	for	for	IN
8691	3487	18	the	the	DT
8691	3487	19	District	District	NNP
8691	3487	20	of	of	IN
8691	3487	21	Indiana	Indiana	NNP
8691	3487	22	for	for	IN
8691	3487	23	a	a	DT
8691	3487	24	writ	writ	NN
8691	3487	25	of	of	IN
8691	3487	26	_	_	NNP
8691	3487	27	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	3487	28	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	3487	29	_	_	NNP
8691	3487	30	.	.	.
8691	3488	1	The	the	DT
8691	3488	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3488	3	of	of	IN
8691	3488	4	that	that	DT
8691	3488	5	court	court	NN
8691	3488	6	were	be	VBD
8691	3488	7	divided	divide	VBN
8691	3488	8	in	in	IN
8691	3488	9	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3488	10	in	in	IN
8691	3488	11	regard	regard	NN
8691	3488	12	to	to	IN
8691	3488	13	the	the	DT
8691	3488	14	case	case	NN
8691	3488	15	,	,	,
8691	3488	16	but	but	CC
8691	3488	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3488	18	was	be	VBD
8691	3488	19	decided	decide	VBN
8691	3488	20	in	in	IN
8691	3488	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3488	22	favor	favor	NN
8691	3488	23	when	when	WRB
8691	3488	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3488	25	came	come	VBD
8691	3488	26	before	before	IN
8691	3488	27	the	the	DT
8691	3488	28	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3488	29	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3488	30	of	of	IN
8691	3488	31	the	the	DT
8691	3488	32	United	United	NNP
8691	3488	33	States	States	NNP
8691	3488	34	.	.	.
8691	3489	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3489	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3489	3	:	:	:
8691	3489	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3489	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	3489	6	parte	parte	NN
8691	3489	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3489	8	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
8691	3489	9	,	,	,
8691	3489	10	4	4	CD
8691	3489	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	3489	12	's	's	POS
8691	3489	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3489	14	,	,	,
8691	3489	15	2	2	CD
8691	3489	16	,	,	,
8691	3489	17	121	121	CD
8691	3489	18	,	,	,
8691	3489	19	127	127	CD
8691	3489	20	.	.	.
8691	3489	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3490	1	The	the	DT
8691	3490	2	decision	decision	NN
8691	3490	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3490	4	unanimous	unanimous	JJ
8691	3490	5	,	,	,
8691	3490	6	but	but	CC
8691	3490	7	in	in	IN
8691	3490	8	stating	state	VBG
8691	3490	9	the	the	DT
8691	3490	10	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	3490	11	for	for	IN
8691	3490	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3490	13	the	the	DT
8691	3490	14	court	court	NN
8691	3490	15	was	be	VBD
8691	3490	16	divided	divide	VBN
8691	3490	17	in	in	IN
8691	3490	18	a	a	DT
8691	3490	19	manner	manner	NN
8691	3490	20	which	which	WDT
8691	3490	21	has	have	VBZ
8691	3490	22	not	not	RB
8691	3490	23	been	be	VBN
8691	3490	24	uncommon	uncommon	JJ
8691	3490	25	since	since	IN
8691	3490	26	the	the	DT
8691	3490	27	death	death	NN
8691	3490	28	of	of	IN
8691	3490	29	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3490	30	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3490	31	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	3490	32	when	when	WRB
8691	3490	33	any	any	DT
8691	3490	34	great	great	JJ
8691	3490	35	question	question	NN
8691	3490	36	of	of	IN
8691	3490	37	a	a	DT
8691	3490	38	political	political	JJ
8691	3490	39	nature	nature	NN
8691	3490	40	has	have	VBZ
8691	3490	41	been	be	VBN
8691	3490	42	involved	involve	VBN
8691	3490	43	.	.	.
8691	3491	1	Five	five	CD
8691	3491	2	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3491	3	held	hold	VBD
8691	3491	4	that	that	IN
8691	3491	5	the	the	DT
8691	3491	6	trial	trial	NN
8691	3491	7	of	of	IN
8691	3491	8	a	a	DT
8691	3491	9	civilian	civilian	NN
8691	3491	10	by	by	IN
8691	3491	11	a	a	DT
8691	3491	12	military	military	JJ
8691	3491	13	commission	commission	NN
8691	3491	14	can	can	MD
8691	3491	15	never	never	RB
8691	3491	16	be	be	VB
8691	3491	17	vindicated	vindicate	VBN
8691	3491	18	in	in	IN
8691	3491	19	a	a	DT
8691	3491	20	peaceful	peaceful	JJ
8691	3491	21	State	State	NNP
8691	3491	22	where	where	WRB
8691	3491	23	the	the	DT
8691	3491	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	3491	25	are	be	VBP
8691	3491	26	open	open	JJ
8691	3491	27	and	and	CC
8691	3491	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3491	29	process	process	NN
8691	3491	30	unobstructed	unobstructe	VBN
8691	3491	31	.	.	.
8691	3492	1	Four	four	CD
8691	3492	2	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3492	3	dissented	dissent	VBD
8691	3492	4	,	,	,
8691	3492	5	and	and	CC
8691	3492	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3492	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3492	8	Chase	Chase	NNP
8691	3492	9	thus	thus	RB
8691	3492	10	summarized	summarize	VBD
8691	3492	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3492	12	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	3492	13	:	:	:
8691	3492	14	There	there	EX
8691	3492	15	are	be	VBP
8691	3492	16	under	under	IN
8691	3492	17	the	the	DT
8691	3492	18	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3492	19	three	three	CD
8691	3492	20	kinds	kind	NNS
8691	3492	21	of	of	IN
8691	3492	22	military	military	JJ
8691	3492	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3492	24	:	:	:
8691	3492	25	one	one	CD
8691	3492	26	to	to	TO
8691	3492	27	be	be	VB
8691	3492	28	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	3492	29	both	both	DT
8691	3492	30	in	in	IN
8691	3492	31	peace	peace	NN
8691	3492	32	and	and	CC
8691	3492	33	war	war	NN
8691	3492	34	;	;	,
8691	3492	35	another	another	DT
8691	3492	36	to	to	TO
8691	3492	37	be	be	VB
8691	3492	38	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	3492	39	in	in	IN
8691	3492	40	time	time	NN
8691	3492	41	of	of	IN
8691	3492	42	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	3492	43	war	war	NN
8691	3492	44	without	without	IN
8691	3492	45	the	the	DT
8691	3492	46	boundaries	boundary	NNS
8691	3492	47	of	of	IN
8691	3492	48	the	the	DT
8691	3492	49	United	United	NNP
8691	3492	50	States	States	NNP
8691	3492	51	,	,	,
8691	3492	52	or	or	CC
8691	3492	53	in	in	IN
8691	3492	54	time	time	NN
8691	3492	55	of	of	IN
8691	3492	56	rebellion	rebellion	NN
8691	3492	57	and	and	CC
8691	3492	58	civil	civil	JJ
8691	3492	59	war	war	NN
8691	3492	60	within	within	IN
8691	3492	61	States	States	NNP
8691	3492	62	or	or	CC
8691	3492	63	districts	district	NNS
8691	3492	64	occupied	occupy	VBN
8691	3492	65	by	by	IN
8691	3492	66	rebels	rebel	NNS
8691	3492	67	treated	treat	VBN
8691	3492	68	as	as	IN
8691	3492	69	belligerents	belligerent	NNS
8691	3492	70	;	;	:
8691	3492	71	and	and	CC
8691	3492	72	a	a	DT
8691	3492	73	third	third	NN
8691	3492	74	to	to	TO
8691	3492	75	be	be	VB
8691	3492	76	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	3492	77	in	in	IN
8691	3492	78	time	time	NN
8691	3492	79	of	of	IN
8691	3492	80	invasion	invasion	NN
8691	3492	81	or	or	CC
8691	3492	82	insurrection	insurrection	NN
8691	3492	83	within	within	IN
8691	3492	84	the	the	DT
8691	3492	85	limits	limit	NNS
8691	3492	86	of	of	IN
8691	3492	87	the	the	DT
8691	3492	88	United	United	NNP
8691	3492	89	States	States	NNP
8691	3492	90	,	,	,
8691	3492	91	or	or	CC
8691	3492	92	during	during	IN
8691	3492	93	rebellion	rebellion	NN
8691	3492	94	within	within	IN
8691	3492	95	the	the	DT
8691	3492	96	limits	limit	NNS
8691	3492	97	of	of	IN
8691	3492	98	States	state	NNS
8691	3492	99	maintaining	maintain	VBG
8691	3492	100	adhesion	adhesion	NN
8691	3492	101	to	to	IN
8691	3492	102	the	the	DT
8691	3492	103	National	National	NNP
8691	3492	104	Government	Government	NNP
8691	3492	105	,	,	,
8691	3492	106	when	when	WRB
8691	3492	107	the	the	DT
8691	3492	108	public	public	JJ
8691	3492	109	danger	danger	NN
8691	3492	110	requires	require	VBZ
8691	3492	111	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3492	112	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	3492	113	.	.	.
8691	3493	1	The	the	DT
8691	3493	2	first	first	JJ
8691	3493	3	of	of	IN
8691	3493	4	these	these	DT
8691	3493	5	may	may	MD
8691	3493	6	be	be	VB
8691	3493	7	called	call	VBN
8691	3493	8	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3493	9	under	under	IN
8691	3493	10	military	military	JJ
8691	3493	11	law	law	NN
8691	3493	12	,	,	,
8691	3493	13	and	and	CC
8691	3493	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	3493	15	found	find	VBN
8691	3493	16	in	in	IN
8691	3493	17	acts	act	NNS
8691	3493	18	of	of	IN
8691	3493	19	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3493	20	prescribing	prescribing	NN
8691	3493	21	rules	rule	NNS
8691	3493	22	and	and	CC
8691	3493	23	articles	article	NNS
8691	3493	24	of	of	IN
8691	3493	25	war	war	NN
8691	3493	26	,	,	,
8691	3493	27	or	or	CC
8691	3493	28	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	3493	29	providing	provide	VBG
8691	3493	30	for	for	IN
8691	3493	31	the	the	DT
8691	3493	32	government	government	NN
8691	3493	33	of	of	IN
8691	3493	34	the	the	DT
8691	3493	35	national	national	JJ
8691	3493	36	forces	force	NNS
8691	3493	37	;	;	:
8691	3493	38	the	the	DT
8691	3493	39	second	second	JJ
8691	3493	40	may	may	MD
8691	3493	41	be	be	VB
8691	3493	42	distinguished	distinguish	VBN
8691	3493	43	as	as	IN
8691	3493	44	military	military	JJ
8691	3493	45	government	government	NN
8691	3493	46	,	,	,
8691	3493	47	superseding	supersede	VBG
8691	3493	48	,	,	,
8691	3493	49	as	as	RB
8691	3493	50	far	far	RB
8691	3493	51	as	as	IN
8691	3493	52	may	may	MD
8691	3493	53	be	be	VB
8691	3493	54	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	3493	55	expedient	expedient	NN
8691	3493	56	,	,	,
8691	3493	57	the	the	DT
8691	3493	58	local	local	JJ
8691	3493	59	law	law	NN
8691	3493	60	,	,	,
8691	3493	61	and	and	CC
8691	3493	62	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	3493	63	by	by	IN
8691	3493	64	the	the	DT
8691	3493	65	military	military	JJ
8691	3493	66	commander	commander	NN
8691	3493	67	under	under	IN
8691	3493	68	the	the	DT
8691	3493	69	direction	direction	NN
8691	3493	70	of	of	IN
8691	3493	71	the	the	DT
8691	3493	72	President	President	NNP
8691	3493	73	,	,	,
8691	3493	74	with	with	IN
8691	3493	75	the	the	DT
8691	3493	76	express	express	JJ
8691	3493	77	or	or	CC
8691	3493	78	implied	imply	VBN
8691	3493	79	sanction	sanction	NN
8691	3493	80	of	of	IN
8691	3493	81	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3493	82	,	,	,
8691	3493	83	while	while	IN
8691	3493	84	the	the	DT
8691	3493	85	third	third	JJ
8691	3493	86	may	may	MD
8691	3493	87	be	be	VB
8691	3493	88	denominated	denominate	VBN
8691	3493	89	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3493	90	law	law	NN
8691	3493	91	proper	proper	JJ
8691	3493	92	,	,	,
8691	3493	93	and	and	CC
8691	3493	94	is	be	VBZ
8691	3493	95	called	call	VBN
8691	3493	96	into	into	IN
8691	3493	97	action	action	NN
8691	3493	98	by	by	IN
8691	3493	99	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3493	100	,	,	,
8691	3493	101	or	or	CC
8691	3493	102	temporarily	temporarily	RB
8691	3493	103	,	,	,
8691	3493	104	when	when	WRB
8691	3493	105	the	the	DT
8691	3493	106	action	action	NN
8691	3493	107	of	of	IN
8691	3493	108	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3493	109	can	can	MD
8691	3493	110	not	not	RB
8691	3493	111	be	be	VB
8691	3493	112	invited	invite	VBN
8691	3493	113	,	,	,
8691	3493	114	and	and	CC
8691	3493	115	in	in	IN
8691	3493	116	the	the	DT
8691	3493	117	case	case	NN
8691	3493	118	of	of	IN
8691	3493	119	justifying	justify	VBG
8691	3493	120	or	or	CC
8691	3493	121	excusing	excuse	VBG
8691	3493	122	peril	peril	NN
8691	3493	123	,	,	,
8691	3493	124	by	by	IN
8691	3493	125	the	the	DT
8691	3493	126	President	President	NNP
8691	3493	127	,	,	,
8691	3493	128	in	in	IN
8691	3493	129	times	time	NNS
8691	3493	130	of	of	IN
8691	3493	131	insurrection	insurrection	NN
8691	3493	132	or	or	CC
8691	3493	133	invasion	invasion	NN
8691	3493	134	,	,	,
8691	3493	135	or	or	CC
8691	3493	136	of	of	IN
8691	3493	137	civil	civil	JJ
8691	3493	138	or	or	CC
8691	3493	139	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	3493	140	war	war	NN
8691	3493	141	within	within	IN
8691	3493	142	districts	district	NNS
8691	3493	143	or	or	CC
8691	3493	144	localities	locality	NNS
8691	3493	145	where	where	WRB
8691	3493	146	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	3493	147	law	law	NN
8691	3493	148	no	no	RB
8691	3493	149	longer	long	RBR
8691	3493	150	adequately	adequately	RB
8691	3493	151	secures	secure	VBZ
8691	3493	152	public	public	JJ
8691	3493	153	safety	safety	NN
8691	3493	154	and	and	CC
8691	3493	155	private	private	JJ
8691	3493	156	rights	right	NNS
8691	3493	157	.	.	.
8691	3494	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3494	2	think	think	VBP
8691	3494	3	that	that	IN
8691	3494	4	the	the	DT
8691	3494	5	power	power	NN
8691	3494	6	of	of	IN
8691	3494	7	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3494	8	in	in	IN
8691	3494	9	such	such	JJ
8691	3494	10	times	time	NNS
8691	3494	11	and	and	CC
8691	3494	12	in	in	IN
8691	3494	13	such	such	JJ
8691	3494	14	localities	locality	NNS
8691	3494	15	to	to	TO
8691	3494	16	authorize	authorize	VB
8691	3494	17	trials	trial	NNS
8691	3494	18	for	for	IN
8691	3494	19	crimes	crime	NNS
8691	3494	20	against	against	IN
8691	3494	21	the	the	DT
8691	3494	22	security	security	NN
8691	3494	23	and	and	CC
8691	3494	24	safety	safety	NN
8691	3494	25	of	of	IN
8691	3494	26	the	the	DT
8691	3494	27	national	national	JJ
8691	3494	28	forces	force	NNS
8691	3494	29	may	may	MD
8691	3494	30	be	be	VB
8691	3494	31	derived	derive	VBN
8691	3494	32	from	from	IN
8691	3494	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3494	34	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3494	35	authority	authority	NN
8691	3494	36	to	to	TO
8691	3494	37	raise	raise	VB
8691	3494	38	and	and	CC
8691	3494	39	support	support	VB
8691	3494	40	armies	army	NNS
8691	3494	41	and	and	CC
8691	3494	42	to	to	TO
8691	3494	43	declare	declare	VB
8691	3494	44	war	war	NN
8691	3494	45	,	,	,
8691	3494	46	if	if	IN
8691	3494	47	not	not	RB
8691	3494	48	from	from	IN
8691	3494	49	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3494	50	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3494	51	authority	authority	NN
8691	3494	52	to	to	TO
8691	3494	53	provide	provide	VB
8691	3494	54	for	for	IN
8691	3494	55	governing	govern	VBG
8691	3494	56	the	the	DT
8691	3494	57	national	national	JJ
8691	3494	58	forces	force	NNS
8691	3494	59	.	.	.
8691	3495	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3495	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3495	3	:	:	:
8691	3495	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3495	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	3495	6	parte	parte	NN
8691	3495	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3495	8	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
8691	3495	9	,	,	,
8691	3495	10	4	4	CD
8691	3495	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	3495	12	's	's	POS
8691	3495	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3495	14	,	,	,
8691	3495	15	141	141	CD
8691	3495	16	.	.	.
8691	3495	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3496	1	The	the	DT
8691	3496	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3496	3	of	of	IN
8691	3496	4	the	the	DT
8691	3496	5	United	United	NNP
8691	3496	6	States	States	NNP
8691	3496	7	contains	contain	VBZ
8691	3496	8	some	some	DT
8691	3496	9	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	3496	10	restricting	restrict	VBG
8691	3496	11	the	the	DT
8691	3496	12	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3496	13	of	of	IN
8691	3496	14	military	military	JJ
8691	3496	15	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	3496	16	and	and	CC
8691	3496	17	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	3496	18	over	over	IN
8691	3496	19	controversies	controversy	NNS
8691	3496	20	,	,	,
8691	3496	21	which	which	WDT
8691	3496	22	are	be	VBP
8691	3496	23	not	not	RB
8691	3496	24	found	find	VBN
8691	3496	25	in	in	IN
8691	3496	26	the	the	DT
8691	3496	27	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	3496	28	of	of	IN
8691	3496	29	the	the	DT
8691	3496	30	States	States	NNP
8691	3496	31	.	.	.
8691	3497	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3497	2	may	may	MD
8691	3497	3	well	well	RB
8691	3497	4	be	be	VB
8691	3497	5	that	that	DT
8691	3497	6	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3497	7	law	law	NN
8691	3497	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	3497	9	for	for	IN
8691	3497	10	the	the	DT
8691	3497	11	United	United	NNP
8691	3497	12	States	States	NNP
8691	3497	13	a	a	DT
8691	3497	14	narrower	narrow	JJR
8691	3497	15	meaning	meaning	NN
8691	3497	16	than	than	IN
8691	3497	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3497	18	may	may	MD
8691	3497	19	possess	possess	VB
8691	3497	20	in	in	IN
8691	3497	21	a	a	DT
8691	3497	22	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3497	23	State	state	NN
8691	3497	24	.	.	.
8691	3498	1	The	the	DT
8691	3498	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3498	3	of	of	IN
8691	3498	4	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	3498	5	Island	Island	NNP
8691	3498	6	in	in	IN
8691	3498	7	1842	1842	CD
8691	3498	8	,	,	,
8691	3498	9	during	during	IN
8691	3498	10	"	"	``
8691	3498	11	Dorr	Dorr	NNP
8691	3498	12	's	's	POS
8691	3498	13	Rebellion	rebellion	NN
8691	3498	14	,	,	,
8691	3498	15	"	"	''
8691	3498	16	by	by	IN
8691	3498	17	a	a	DT
8691	3498	18	Public	Public	NNP
8691	3498	19	Act	Act	NNP
8691	3498	20	put	put	VBD
8691	3498	21	that	that	IN
8691	3498	22	State	State	NNP
8691	3498	23	under	under	IN
8691	3498	24	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3498	25	law	law	NN
8691	3498	26	until	until	IN
8691	3498	27	further	further	JJ
8691	3498	28	order	order	NN
8691	3498	29	,	,	,
8691	3498	30	or	or	CC
8691	3498	31	until	until	IN
8691	3498	32	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3498	33	termination	termination	NN
8691	3498	34	should	should	MD
8691	3498	35	be	be	VB
8691	3498	36	proclaimed	proclaim	VBN
8691	3498	37	by	by	IN
8691	3498	38	the	the	DT
8691	3498	39	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3498	40	.	.	.
8691	3499	1	A	a	DT
8691	3499	2	squad	squad	NN
8691	3499	3	of	of	IN
8691	3499	4	militia	militia	NN
8691	3499	5	broke	break	VBD
8691	3499	6	into	into	IN
8691	3499	7	the	the	DT
8691	3499	8	house	house	NN
8691	3499	9	of	of	IN
8691	3499	10	a	a	DT
8691	3499	11	private	private	JJ
8691	3499	12	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	3499	13	to	to	TO
8691	3499	14	arrest	arrest	VB
8691	3499	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3499	16	as	as	IN
8691	3499	17	an	an	DT
8691	3499	18	abettor	abettor	NN
8691	3499	19	of	of	IN
8691	3499	20	Dorr	Dorr	NNP
8691	3499	21	,	,	,
8691	3499	22	and	and	CC
8691	3499	23	were	be	VBD
8691	3499	24	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	3499	25	sued	sue	VBN
8691	3499	26	in	in	IN
8691	3499	27	trespass	trespass	NN
8691	3499	28	before	before	IN
8691	3499	29	the	the	DT
8691	3499	30	civil	civil	JJ
8691	3499	31	courts	court	NNS
8691	3499	32	.	.	.
8691	3500	1	The	the	DT
8691	3500	2	cause	cause	NN
8691	3500	3	finally	finally	RB
8691	3500	4	came	come	VBD
8691	3500	5	before	before	IN
8691	3500	6	the	the	DT
8691	3500	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3500	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3500	9	of	of	IN
8691	3500	10	the	the	DT
8691	3500	11	United	United	NNP
8691	3500	12	States	States	NNP
8691	3500	13	,	,	,
8691	3500	14	where	where	WRB
8691	3500	15	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3500	16	one	one	CD
8691	3500	17	justice	justice	NN
8691	3500	18	only	only	RB
8691	3500	19	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	3500	20	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3500	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3500	22	was	be	VBD
8691	3500	23	held	hold	VBN
8691	3500	24	that	that	IN
8691	3500	25	the	the	DT
8691	3500	26	Act	Act	NNP
8691	3500	27	could	could	MD
8691	3500	28	not	not	RB
8691	3500	29	be	be	VB
8691	3500	30	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	3500	31	an	an	DT
8691	3500	32	unjustifiable	unjustifiable	JJ
8691	3500	33	exercise	exercise	NN
8691	3500	34	of	of	IN
8691	3500	35	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	3500	36	power	power	NN
8691	3500	37	under	under	IN
8691	3500	38	any	any	DT
8691	3500	39	provision	provision	NN
8691	3500	40	of	of	IN
8691	3500	41	the	the	DT
8691	3500	42	federal	federal	JJ
8691	3500	43	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3500	44	.	.	.
8691	3501	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3501	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3501	3	:	:	:
8691	3501	4	Luther	Luther	NNP
8691	3501	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3501	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3501	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3501	8	Borden	Borden	NNP
8691	3501	9	,	,	,
8691	3501	10	7	7	CD
8691	3501	11	Howard	Howard	NNP
8691	3501	12	's	's	POS
8691	3501	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3501	14	,	,	,
8691	3501	15	1	1	CD
8691	3501	16	,	,	,
8691	3501	17	45	45	CD
8691	3501	18	.	.	.
8691	3501	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3502	1	Whether	whether	IN
8691	3502	2	the	the	DT
8691	3502	3	courts	court	NNS
8691	3502	4	of	of	IN
8691	3502	5	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	3502	6	Island	Island	NNP
8691	3502	7	could	could	MD
8691	3502	8	have	have	VB
8691	3502	9	taken	take	VBN
8691	3502	10	a	a	DT
8691	3502	11	different	different	JJ
8691	3502	12	view	view	NN
8691	3502	13	,	,	,
8691	3502	14	under	under	IN
8691	3502	15	the	the	DT
8691	3502	16	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	3502	17	laws	law	NNS
8691	3502	18	of	of	IN
8691	3502	19	the	the	DT
8691	3502	20	State	State	NNP
8691	3502	21	,	,	,
8691	3502	22	was	be	VBD
8691	3502	23	not	not	RB
8691	3502	24	decided	decide	VBN
8691	3502	25	.	.	.
8691	3503	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3503	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3503	3	:	:	:
8691	3503	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3503	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	3503	6	parte	parte	NN
8691	3503	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3503	8	Milligan	Milligan	NNP
8691	3503	9	,	,	,
8691	3503	10	4	4	CD
8691	3503	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	3503	12	's	's	POS
8691	3503	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3503	14	,	,	,
8691	3503	15	2	2	CD
8691	3503	16	,	,	,
8691	3503	17	129	129	CD
8691	3503	18	.	.	.
8691	3503	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3504	1	On	on	IN
8691	3504	2	the	the	DT
8691	3504	3	other	other	JJ
8691	3504	4	hand	hand	NN
8691	3504	5	,	,	,
8691	3504	6	there	there	EX
8691	3504	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3504	8	States	state	NNS
8691	3504	9	in	in	IN
8691	3504	10	which	which	WDT
8691	3504	11	the	the	DT
8691	3504	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3504	13	explicitly	explicitly	RB
8691	3504	14	provides	provide	VBZ
8691	3504	15	that	that	IN
8691	3504	16	"	"	``
8691	3504	17	the	the	DT
8691	3504	18	military	military	JJ
8691	3504	19	power	power	NN
8691	3504	20	shall	shall	MD
8691	3504	21	always	always	RB
8691	3504	22	be	be	VB
8691	3504	23	held	hold	VBN
8691	3504	24	in	in	IN
8691	3504	25	an	an	DT
8691	3504	26	exact	exact	JJ
8691	3504	27	subordination	subordination	NN
8691	3504	28	to	to	IN
8691	3504	29	the	the	DT
8691	3504	30	civil	civil	JJ
8691	3504	31	authority	authority	NN
8691	3504	32	and	and	CC
8691	3504	33	be	be	VB
8691	3504	34	governed	govern	VBN
8691	3504	35	by	by	IN
8691	3504	36	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3504	37	.	.	.
8691	3505	1	"	"	``
8691	3505	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3505	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3505	4	:	:	:
8691	3505	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3505	6	of	of	IN
8691	3505	7	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3505	8	,	,	,
8691	3505	9	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
8691	3505	10	of	of	IN
8691	3505	11	Rights	Rights	NNPS
8691	3505	12	,	,	,
8691	3505	13	Art	art	NN
8691	3505	14	.	.	.
8691	3506	1	17	17	CD
8691	3506	2	.	.	.
8691	3507	1	_	_	NNP
8691	3507	2	Cf	Cf	NNP
8691	3507	3	.	.	.
8691	3507	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3507	5	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3507	6	of	of	IN
8691	3507	7	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
8691	3507	8	,	,	,
8691	3507	9	Art	Art	NNP
8691	3507	10	.	.	.
8691	3508	1	2	2	LS
8691	3508	2	,	,	,
8691	3508	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	3508	4	,	,	,
8691	3508	5	22	22	CD
8691	3508	6	.	.	.
8691	3508	7	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3509	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3509	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3509	3	a	a	DT
8691	3509	4	serious	serious	JJ
8691	3509	5	question	question	NN
8691	3509	6	whether	whether	IN
8691	3509	7	,	,	,
8691	3509	8	under	under	IN
8691	3509	9	such	such	JJ
8691	3509	10	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	3509	11	,	,	,
8691	3509	12	a	a	DT
8691	3509	13	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	3509	14	or	or	CC
8691	3509	15	executive	executive	JJ
8691	3509	16	declaration	declaration	NN
8691	3509	17	of	of	IN
8691	3509	18	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3509	19	law	law	NN
8691	3509	20	in	in	IN
8691	3509	21	time	time	NN
8691	3509	22	of	of	IN
8691	3509	23	peace	peace	NN
8691	3509	24	,	,	,
8691	3509	25	in	in	IN
8691	3509	26	order	order	NN
8691	3509	27	the	the	DT
8691	3509	28	better	well	JJR
8691	3509	29	to	to	TO
8691	3509	30	cope	cope	VB
8691	3509	31	with	with	IN
8691	3509	32	some	some	DT
8691	3509	33	local	local	JJ
8691	3509	34	disturbance	disturbance	NN
8691	3509	35	,	,	,
8691	3509	36	is	be	VBZ
8691	3509	37	to	to	TO
8691	3509	38	be	be	VB
8691	3509	39	regarded	regard	VBN
8691	3509	40	as	as	IN
8691	3509	41	an	an	DT
8691	3509	42	expression	expression	NN
8691	3509	43	of	of	IN
8691	3509	44	the	the	DT
8691	3509	45	will	will	NN
8691	3509	46	of	of	IN
8691	3509	47	the	the	DT
8691	3509	48	civil	civil	JJ
8691	3509	49	authority	authority	NN
8691	3509	50	,	,	,
8691	3509	51	by	by	IN
8691	3509	52	virtue	virtue	NN
8691	3509	53	of	of	IN
8691	3509	54	which	which	WDT
8691	3509	55	the	the	DT
8691	3509	56	civil	civil	JJ
8691	3509	57	courts	court	NNS
8691	3509	58	lose	lose	VBP
8691	3509	59	the	the	DT
8691	3509	60	power	power	NN
8691	3509	61	of	of	IN
8691	3509	62	discharging	discharge	VBG
8691	3509	63	on	on	IN
8691	3509	64	_	_	NNP
8691	3509	65	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	3509	66	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	3509	67	_	_	NNP
8691	3509	68	one	one	CD
8691	3509	69	restrained	restrain	VBD
8691	3509	70	of	of	IN
8691	3509	71	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3509	72	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	3509	73	by	by	IN
8691	3509	74	military	military	NN
8691	3509	75	command	command	NN
8691	3509	76	.	.	.
8691	3510	1	That	that	IN
8691	3510	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3510	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3510	4	such	such	PDT
8691	3510	5	an	an	DT
8691	3510	6	expression	expression	NN
8691	3510	7	was	be	VBD
8691	3510	8	held	hold	VBN
8691	3510	9	in	in	IN
8691	3510	10	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
8691	3510	11	in	in	IN
8691	3510	12	1904	1904	CD
8691	3510	13	,	,	,
8691	3510	14	but	but	CC
8691	3510	15	by	by	IN
8691	3510	16	a	a	DT
8691	3510	17	court	court	NN
8691	3510	18	composed	compose	VBN
8691	3510	19	of	of	IN
8691	3510	20	only	only	RB
8691	3510	21	three	three	CD
8691	3510	22	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3510	23	,	,	,
8691	3510	24	of	of	IN
8691	3510	25	whom	whom	WP
8691	3510	26	one	one	CD
8691	3510	27	,	,	,
8691	3510	28	in	in	IN
8691	3510	29	a	a	DT
8691	3510	30	dissenting	dissent	VBG
8691	3510	31	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3510	32	,	,	,
8691	3510	33	observed	observe	VBD
8691	3510	34	that	that	IN
8691	3510	35	the	the	DT
8691	3510	36	decision	decision	NN
8691	3510	37	of	of	IN
8691	3510	38	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3510	39	associates	associate	NNS
8691	3510	40	"	"	''
8691	3510	41	is	be	VBZ
8691	3510	42	so	so	RB
8691	3510	43	repugnant	repugnant	JJ
8691	3510	44	to	to	IN
8691	3510	45	my	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3510	46	notions	notion	NNS
8691	3510	47	of	of	IN
8691	3510	48	civil	civil	JJ
8691	3510	49	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	3510	50	,	,	,
8691	3510	51	so	so	RB
8691	3510	52	antagonistic	antagonistic	JJ
8691	3510	53	to	to	IN
8691	3510	54	my	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3510	55	ideas	idea	NNS
8691	3510	56	of	of	IN
8691	3510	57	a	a	DT
8691	3510	58	republican	republican	JJ
8691	3510	59	form	form	NN
8691	3510	60	of	of	IN
8691	3510	61	government	government	NN
8691	3510	62	,	,	,
8691	3510	63	and	and	CC
8691	3510	64	so	so	RB
8691	3510	65	shocking	shocking	JJ
8691	3510	66	to	to	IN
8691	3510	67	my	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3510	68	sense	sense	NN
8691	3510	69	of	of	IN
8691	3510	70	propriety	propriety	NN
8691	3510	71	and	and	CC
8691	3510	72	justice	justice	NN
8691	3510	73	that	that	WDT
8691	3510	74	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3510	75	can	can	MD
8691	3510	76	not	not	RB
8691	3510	77	properly	properly	RB
8691	3510	78	characterize	characterize	VB
8691	3510	79	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3510	80	.	.	.
8691	3510	81	"	"	''
8691	3511	1	A	a	DT
8691	3511	2	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3511	3	question	question	NN
8691	3511	4	arose	arise	VBD
8691	3511	5	,	,	,
8691	3511	6	but	but	CC
8691	3511	7	was	be	VBD
8691	3511	8	not	not	RB
8691	3511	9	judicially	judicially	RB
8691	3511	10	determined	determine	VBN
8691	3511	11	,	,	,
8691	3511	12	in	in	IN
8691	3511	13	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
8691	3511	14	in	in	IN
8691	3511	15	1874	1874	CD
8691	3511	16	.	.	.
8691	3512	1	There	there	EX
8691	3512	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3512	3	a	a	DT
8691	3512	4	contest	contest	NN
8691	3512	5	over	over	IN
8691	3512	6	the	the	DT
8691	3512	7	election	election	NN
8691	3512	8	of	of	IN
8691	3512	9	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3512	10	.	.	.
8691	3513	1	The	the	DT
8691	3513	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3513	3	provided	provide	VBD
8691	3513	4	that	that	IN
8691	3513	5	such	such	JJ
8691	3513	6	contests	contest	NNS
8691	3513	7	should	should	MD
8691	3513	8	be	be	VB
8691	3513	9	decided	decide	VBN
8691	3513	10	by	by	IN
8691	3513	11	the	the	DT
8691	3513	12	joint	joint	JJ
8691	3513	13	vote	vote	NN
8691	3513	14	of	of	IN
8691	3513	15	both	both	DT
8691	3513	16	houses	house	NNS
8691	3513	17	of	of	IN
8691	3513	18	the	the	DT
8691	3513	19	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3513	20	.	.	.
8691	3514	1	Baxter	baxter	NN
8691	3514	2	,	,	,
8691	3514	3	the	the	DT
8691	3514	4	candidate	candidate	NN
8691	3514	5	who	who	WP
8691	3514	6	was	be	VBD
8691	3514	7	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3514	8	on	on	IN
8691	3514	9	the	the	DT
8691	3514	10	face	face	NN
8691	3514	11	of	of	IN
8691	3514	12	the	the	DT
8691	3514	13	returns	return	NNS
8691	3514	14	,	,	,
8691	3514	15	was	be	VBD
8691	3514	16	declared	declare	VBN
8691	3514	17	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3514	18	by	by	IN
8691	3514	19	the	the	DT
8691	3514	20	President	President	NNP
8691	3514	21	of	of	IN
8691	3514	22	the	the	DT
8691	3514	23	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	3514	24	and	and	CC
8691	3514	25	took	take	VBD
8691	3514	26	the	the	DT
8691	3514	27	oath	oath	NN
8691	3514	28	of	of	IN
8691	3514	29	office	office	NN
8691	3514	30	.	.	.
8691	3515	1	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
8691	3515	2	,	,	,
8691	3515	3	the	the	DT
8691	3515	4	other	other	JJ
8691	3515	5	candidate	candidate	NN
8691	3515	6	,	,	,
8691	3515	7	presented	present	VBD
8691	3515	8	a	a	DT
8691	3515	9	petition	petition	NN
8691	3515	10	for	for	IN
8691	3515	11	a	a	DT
8691	3515	12	contest	contest	NN
8691	3515	13	to	to	IN
8691	3515	14	the	the	DT
8691	3515	15	lower	low	JJR
8691	3515	16	house	house	NN
8691	3515	17	,	,	,
8691	3515	18	which	which	WDT
8691	3515	19	refused	refuse	VBD
8691	3515	20	to	to	TO
8691	3515	21	grant	grant	VB
8691	3515	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3515	23	.	.	.
8691	3516	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3516	2	then	then	RB
8691	3516	3	applied	apply	VBD
8691	3516	4	to	to	IN
8691	3516	5	the	the	DT
8691	3516	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3516	7	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3516	8	on	on	IN
8691	3516	9	_	_	NNP
8691	3516	10	quo	quo	NNP
8691	3516	11	warranto	warranto	NNP
8691	3516	12	_	_	NNP
8691	3516	13	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3516	14	,	,	,
8691	3516	15	which	which	WDT
8691	3516	16	threw	throw	VBD
8691	3516	17	out	out	RP
8691	3516	18	the	the	DT
8691	3516	19	case	case	NN
8691	3516	20	for	for	IN
8691	3516	21	want	want	NN
8691	3516	22	of	of	IN
8691	3516	23	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3516	24	.	.	.
8691	3517	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3517	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3517	3	:	:	:
8691	3517	4	State	State	NNP
8691	3517	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3517	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3517	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3517	8	Baxter	Baxter	NNP
8691	3517	9	,	,	,
8691	3517	10	28	28	CD
8691	3517	11	Arkansas	Arkansas	NNP
8691	3517	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3517	13	,	,	,
8691	3517	14	129	129	CD
8691	3517	15	.	.	.
8691	3517	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3518	1	A	a	DT
8691	3518	2	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3518	3	suit	suit	NN
8691	3518	4	was	be	VBD
8691	3518	5	then	then	RB
8691	3518	6	brought	bring	VBN
8691	3518	7	in	in	RP
8691	3518	8	a	a	DT
8691	3518	9	_	_	NNP
8691	3518	10	nisi	nisi	NNP
8691	3518	11	prius	prius	NNP
8691	3518	12	_	_	NNP
8691	3518	13	court	court	NN
8691	3518	14	,	,	,
8691	3518	15	on	on	IN
8691	3518	16	which	which	WDT
8691	3518	17	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3518	18	was	be	VBD
8691	3518	19	rendered	render	VBN
8691	3518	20	in	in	IN
8691	3518	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3518	22	favor,[Footnote	favor,[footnote	NN
8691	3518	23	:	:	:
8691	3518	24	This	this	DT
8691	3518	25	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3518	26	was	be	VBD
8691	3518	27	reversed	reverse	VBN
8691	3518	28	on	on	IN
8691	3518	29	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	3518	30	.	.	.
8691	3519	1	Baxter	Baxter	NNP
8691	3519	2	_	_	NNP
8691	3519	3	v.	v.	IN
8691	3519	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3519	5	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
8691	3519	6	,	,	,
8691	3519	7	29	29	CD
8691	3519	8	_	_	NNP
8691	3519	9	i	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3519	10	d	d	NNP
8691	3519	11	_	_	NNP
8691	3519	12	.	.	NNP
8691	3519	13	,	,	,
8691	3519	14	173	173	CD
8691	3519	15	.	.	.
8691	3519	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3520	1	and	and	CC
8691	3520	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3520	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3520	4	put	put	VBN
8691	3520	5	in	in	IN
8691	3520	6	possession	possession	NN
8691	3520	7	of	of	IN
8691	3520	8	the	the	DT
8691	3520	9	executive	executive	JJ
8691	3520	10	chambers	chamber	NNS
8691	3520	11	by	by	IN
8691	3520	12	an	an	DT
8691	3520	13	armed	armed	JJ
8691	3520	14	force	force	NN
8691	3520	15	which	which	WDT
8691	3520	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3520	17	assembled	assemble	VBD
8691	3520	18	.	.	.
8691	3521	1	Baxter	baxter	NN
8691	3521	2	then	then	RB
8691	3521	3	declared	declare	VBD
8691	3521	4	martial	martial	JJ
8691	3521	5	law	law	NN
8691	3521	6	in	in	IN
8691	3521	7	the	the	DT
8691	3521	8	county	county	NN
8691	3521	9	in	in	IN
8691	3521	10	which	which	WDT
8691	3521	11	the	the	DT
8691	3521	12	capital	capital	NN
8691	3521	13	was	be	VBD
8691	3521	14	situated	situate	VBN
8691	3521	15	,	,	,
8691	3521	16	and	and	CC
8691	3521	17	arrested	arrest	VBN
8691	3521	18	two	two	CD
8691	3521	19	of	of	IN
8691	3521	20	the	the	DT
8691	3521	21	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3521	22	of	of	IN
8691	3521	23	the	the	DT
8691	3521	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3521	25	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3521	26	on	on	IN
8691	3521	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3521	28	way	way	NN
8691	3521	29	to	to	TO
8691	3521	30	attend	attend	VB
8691	3521	31	a	a	DT
8691	3521	32	special	special	JJ
8691	3521	33	session	session	NN
8691	3521	34	called	call	VBN
8691	3521	35	to	to	TO
8691	3521	36	take	take	VB
8691	3521	37	action	action	NN
8691	3521	38	in	in	IN
8691	3521	39	_	_	NNP
8691	3521	40	mandamus	mandamus	NNP
8691	3521	41	_	_	NNP
8691	3521	42	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3521	43	brought	bring	VBN
8691	3521	44	in	in	RP
8691	3521	45	behalf	behalf	NN
8691	3521	46	of	of	IN
8691	3521	47	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
8691	3521	48	.	.	.
8691	3522	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3522	2	were	be	VBD
8691	3522	3	rescued	rescue	VBN
8691	3522	4	after	after	IN
8691	3522	5	a	a	DT
8691	3522	6	day	day	NN
8691	3522	7	or	or	CC
8691	3522	8	two	two	CD
8691	3522	9	by	by	IN
8691	3522	10	United	United	NNP
8691	3522	11	States	States	NNP
8691	3522	12	troops	troop	NNS
8691	3522	13	and	and	CC
8691	3522	14	proceeded	proceed	VBD
8691	3522	15	to	to	TO
8691	3522	16	join	join	VB
8691	3522	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3522	18	associates	associate	NNS
8691	3522	19	.	.	.
8691	3523	1	The	the	DT
8691	3523	2	court	court	NN
8691	3523	3	then	then	RB
8691	3523	4	gave	give	VBD
8691	3523	5	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3523	6	for	for	IN
8691	3523	7	Brooks	Brooks	NNP
8691	3523	8	in	in	IN
8691	3523	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3523	10	third	third	JJ
8691	3523	11	suit	suit	NN
8691	3523	12	,	,	,
8691	3523	13	directing	direct	VBG
8691	3523	14	the	the	DT
8691	3523	15	State	State	NNP
8691	3523	16	Treasurer	Treasurer	NNP
8691	3523	17	to	to	TO
8691	3523	18	pay	pay	VB
8691	3523	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3523	20	warrants	warrant	NNS
8691	3523	21	.	.	.
8691	3524	1	At	at	IN
8691	3524	2	this	this	DT
8691	3524	3	point	point	NN
8691	3524	4	the	the	DT
8691	3524	5	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3524	6	applied	apply	VBD
8691	3524	7	to	to	IN
8691	3524	8	the	the	DT
8691	3524	9	President	President	NNP
8691	3524	10	of	of	IN
8691	3524	11	the	the	DT
8691	3524	12	United	United	NNP
8691	3524	13	States	States	NNP
8691	3524	14	for	for	IN
8691	3524	15	protection	protection	NN
8691	3524	16	against	against	IN
8691	3524	17	domestic	domestic	JJ
8691	3524	18	violence	violence	NN
8691	3524	19	,	,	,
8691	3524	20	under	under	IN
8691	3524	21	Art	art	NN
8691	3524	22	.	.	.
8691	3525	1	IV	IV	NNP
8691	3525	2	of	of	IN
8691	3525	3	the	the	DT
8691	3525	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3525	5	of	of	IN
8691	3525	6	the	the	DT
8691	3525	7	United	United	NNP
8691	3525	8	States	States	NNP
8691	3525	9	,	,	,
8691	3525	10	and	and	CC
8691	3525	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3525	12	compliance	compliance	NN
8691	3525	13	by	by	IN
8691	3525	14	a	a	DT
8691	3525	15	proclamation	proclamation	NN
8691	3525	16	officially	officially	RB
8691	3525	17	recognizing	recognize	VBG
8691	3525	18	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3525	19	Baxter	Baxter	NNP
8691	3525	20	and	and	CC
8691	3525	21	ordering	order	VBG
8691	3525	22	the	the	DT
8691	3525	23	Federal	federal	JJ
8691	3525	24	troops	troop	NNS
8691	3525	25	to	to	TO
8691	3525	26	support	support	VB
8691	3525	27	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3525	28	closed	close	VBD
8691	3525	29	the	the	DT
8691	3525	30	history	history	NN
8691	3525	31	of	of	IN
8691	3525	32	this	this	DT
8691	3525	33	disgraceful	disgraceful	JJ
8691	3525	34	incident	incident	NN
8691	3525	35	.	.	.
8691	3526	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3526	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3526	3	:	:	:
8691	3526	4	McPherson	McPherson	NNP
8691	3526	5	,	,	,
8691	3526	6	"	"	``
8691	3526	7	Hand	hand	NN
8691	3526	8	-	-	HYPH
8691	3526	9	book	book	NN
8691	3526	10	of	of	IN
8691	3526	11	Politics	Politics	NNPS
8691	3526	12	for	for	IN
8691	3526	13	1874	1874	CD
8691	3526	14	,	,	,
8691	3526	15	"	"	``
8691	3526	16	87	87	CD
8691	3526	17	-	-	HYPH
8691	3526	18	100	100	CD
8691	3526	19	.	.	.
8691	3526	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3527	1	*	*	NFP
8691	3527	2	*	*	NFP
8691	3527	3	*	*	NFP
8691	3527	4	*	*	NFP
8691	3527	5	*	*	NFP
8691	3527	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	3527	7	XXII	XXII	NNP
8691	3527	8	APPOINTMENT	APPOINTMENT	NNP
8691	3527	9	,	,	,
8691	3527	10	TENURE	tenure	NN
8691	3527	11	OF	of	IN
8691	3527	12	OFFICE	office	NN
8691	3527	13	AND	and	CC
8691	3527	14	COMPENSATION	compensation	NN
8691	3527	15	OF	of	IN
8691	3527	16	JUDGES	JUDGES	NNP
8691	3527	17	The	the	DT
8691	3527	18	oldest	old	JJS
8691	3527	19	which	which	WDT
8691	3527	20	survives	survive	VBZ
8691	3527	21	of	of	IN
8691	3527	22	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3527	23	American	American	NNP
8691	3527	24	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3527	25	,	,	,
8691	3527	26	that	that	IN
8691	3527	27	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	3527	28	by	by	IN
8691	3527	29	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3527	30	in	in	IN
8691	3527	31	1780	1780	CD
8691	3527	32	,	,	,
8691	3527	33	requires	require	VBZ
8691	3527	34	the	the	DT
8691	3527	35	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	3527	36	of	of	IN
8691	3527	37	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3527	38	to	to	TO
8691	3527	39	be	be	VB
8691	3527	40	made	make	VBN
8691	3527	41	by	by	IN
8691	3527	42	the	the	DT
8691	3527	43	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3527	44	of	of	IN
8691	3527	45	the	the	DT
8691	3527	46	State	State	NNP
8691	3527	47	,	,	,
8691	3527	48	with	with	IN
8691	3527	49	the	the	DT
8691	3527	50	advice	advice	NN
8691	3527	51	of	of	IN
8691	3527	52	the	the	DT
8691	3527	53	Council	Council	NNP
8691	3527	54	,	,	,
8691	3527	55	and	and	CC
8691	3527	56	for	for	IN
8691	3527	57	good	good	JJ
8691	3527	58	behavior	behavior	NN
8691	3527	59	.	.	.
8691	3528	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3528	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3528	3	:	:	:
8691	3528	4	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3528	5	of	of	IN
8691	3528	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3528	7	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3528	8	1780	1780	CD
8691	3528	9	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3528	10	,	,	,
8691	3528	11	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	3528	12	.	.	.
8691	3529	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3529	2	,	,	,
8691	3529	3	Art	art	NN
8691	3529	4	.	.	.
8691	3530	1	9	9	LS
8691	3530	2	;	;	:
8691	3530	3	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	3530	4	,	,	,
8691	3530	5	III	III	NNP
8691	3530	6	,	,	,
8691	3530	7	Art	art	NN
8691	3530	8	.	.	.
8691	3531	1	1	1	LS
8691	3531	2	.	.	.
8691	3531	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3532	1	This	this	DT
8691	3532	2	plan	plan	NN
8691	3532	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3532	4	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	3532	5	followed	follow	VBN
8691	3532	6	in	in	IN
8691	3532	7	framing	frame	VBG
8691	3532	8	the	the	DT
8691	3532	9	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3532	10	of	of	IN
8691	3532	11	the	the	DT
8691	3532	12	United	United	NNP
8691	3532	13	States	States	NNP
8691	3532	14	.	.	.
8691	3533	1	That	that	DT
8691	3533	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3533	3	planned	plan	VBN
8691	3533	4	for	for	IN
8691	3533	5	a	a	DT
8691	3533	6	small	small	JJ
8691	3533	7	number	number	NN
8691	3533	8	of	of	IN
8691	3533	9	States	States	NNP
8691	3533	10	,	,	,
8691	3533	11	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	3533	12	only	only	RB
8691	3533	13	nine	nine	CD
8691	3533	14	,	,	,
8691	3533	15	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	3533	16	at	at	IN
8691	3533	17	first	first	RB
8691	3533	18	not	not	RB
8691	3533	19	over	over	IN
8691	3533	20	thirteen	thirteen	CD
8691	3533	21	.	.	.
8691	3534	1	The	the	DT
8691	3534	2	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	3534	3	,	,	,
8691	3534	4	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	3534	5	,	,	,
8691	3534	6	would	would	MD
8691	3534	7	be	be	VB
8691	3534	8	a	a	DT
8691	3534	9	body	body	NN
8691	3534	10	small	small	JJ
8691	3534	11	enough	enough	RB
8691	3534	12	to	to	TO
8691	3534	13	serve	serve	VB
8691	3534	14	as	as	IN
8691	3534	15	an	an	DT
8691	3534	16	executive	executive	JJ
8691	3534	17	council	council	NN
8691	3534	18	.	.	.
8691	3535	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3535	2	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	3535	3	enlargement	enlargement	NN
8691	3535	4	by	by	IN
8691	3535	5	the	the	DT
8691	3535	6	admission	admission	NN
8691	3535	7	of	of	IN
8691	3535	8	new	new	JJ
8691	3535	9	States	States	NNP
8691	3535	10	has	have	VBZ
8691	3535	11	long	long	RB
8691	3535	12	made	make	VBN
8691	3535	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3535	14	but	but	CC
8691	3535	15	ill	ill	RB
8691	3535	16	-	-	HYPH
8691	3535	17	suited	suited	JJ
8691	3535	18	for	for	IN
8691	3535	19	this	this	DT
8691	3535	20	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	3535	21	,	,	,
8691	3535	22	and	and	CC
8691	3535	23	has	have	VBZ
8691	3535	24	thrown	throw	VBN
8691	3535	25	the	the	DT
8691	3535	26	power	power	NN
8691	3535	27	of	of	IN
8691	3535	28	confirming	confirm	VBG
8691	3535	29	or	or	CC
8691	3535	30	rejecting	reject	VBG
8691	3535	31	an	an	DT
8691	3535	32	executive	executive	JJ
8691	3535	33	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3535	34	for	for	IN
8691	3535	35	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3535	36	office	office	NN
8691	3535	37	largely	largely	RB
8691	3535	38	under	under	IN
8691	3535	39	the	the	DT
8691	3535	40	control	control	NN
8691	3535	41	of	of	IN
8691	3535	42	the	the	DT
8691	3535	43	Senators	Senators	NNPS
8691	3535	44	from	from	IN
8691	3535	45	the	the	DT
8691	3535	46	State	state	NN
8691	3535	47	to	to	TO
8691	3535	48	which	which	WDT
8691	3535	49	the	the	DT
8691	3535	50	person	person	NN
8691	3535	51	named	name	VBN
8691	3535	52	belongs	belongs	NNP
8691	3535	53	,	,	,
8691	3535	54	although	although	IN
8691	3535	55	this	this	DT
8691	3535	56	control	control	NN
8691	3535	57	is	be	VBZ
8691	3535	58	much	much	RB
8691	3535	59	weakened	weaken	VBN
8691	3535	60	if	if	IN
8691	3535	61	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3535	62	do	do	VBP
8691	3535	63	not	not	RB
8691	3535	64	belong	belong	VB
8691	3535	65	to	to	IN
8691	3535	66	the	the	DT
8691	3535	67	party	party	NN
8691	3535	68	of	of	IN
8691	3535	69	the	the	DT
8691	3535	70	administration	administration	NN
8691	3535	71	.	.	.
8691	3536	1	The	the	DT
8691	3536	2	principle	principle	NN
8691	3536	3	that	that	IN
8691	3536	4	the	the	DT
8691	3536	5	greater	great	JJR
8691	3536	6	the	the	DT
8691	3536	7	concentration	concentration	NN
8691	3536	8	of	of	IN
8691	3536	9	the	the	DT
8691	3536	10	appointing	appoint	VBG
8691	3536	11	power	power	NN
8691	3536	12	,	,	,
8691	3536	13	the	the	DT
8691	3536	14	greater	great	JJR
8691	3536	15	will	will	MD
8691	3536	16	be	be	VB
8691	3536	17	the	the	DT
8691	3536	18	sense	sense	NN
8691	3536	19	of	of	IN
8691	3536	20	individual	individual	JJ
8691	3536	21	responsibility	responsibility	NN
8691	3536	22	for	for	IN
8691	3536	23	every	every	DT
8691	3536	24	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	3536	25	made	make	VBN
8691	3536	26	,	,	,
8691	3536	27	makes	make	VBZ
8691	3536	28	this	this	DT
8691	3536	29	result	result	NN
8691	3536	30	of	of	IN
8691	3536	31	a	a	DT
8691	3536	32	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	3536	33	of	of	IN
8691	3536	34	ninety	ninety	CD
8691	3536	35	members	member	NNS
8691	3536	36	not	not	RB
8691	3536	37	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	3536	38	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
8691	3536	39	.	.	.
8691	3537	1	The	the	DT
8691	3537	2	President	President	NNP
8691	3537	3	now	now	RB
8691	3537	4	consults	consult	VBZ
8691	3537	5	a	a	DT
8691	3537	6	council	council	NN
8691	3537	7	of	of	IN
8691	3537	8	two	two	CD
8691	3537	9	.	.	.
8691	3538	1	Thirteen	Thirteen	NNP
8691	3538	2	States	States	NNPS
8691	3538	3	in	in	IN
8691	3538	4	all	all	DT
8691	3538	5	originally	originally	RB
8691	3538	6	gave	give	VBD
8691	3538	7	to	to	IN
8691	3538	8	the	the	DT
8691	3538	9	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3538	10	the	the	DT
8691	3538	11	power	power	NN
8691	3538	12	either	either	CC
8691	3538	13	of	of	IN
8691	3538	14	appointing	appointing	NN
8691	3538	15	or	or	CC
8691	3538	16	of	of	IN
8691	3538	17	nominating	nominate	VBG
8691	3538	18	the	the	DT
8691	3538	19	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3538	20	of	of	IN
8691	3538	21	the	the	DT
8691	3538	22	higher	high	JJR
8691	3538	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	3538	24	;	;	:
8691	3538	25	fourteen	fourteen	CD
8691	3538	26	gave	give	VBD
8691	3538	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3538	28	election	election	NN
8691	3538	29	to	to	IN
8691	3538	30	the	the	DT
8691	3538	31	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3538	32	;	;	:
8691	3538	33	the	the	DT
8691	3538	34	rest	rest	NN
8691	3538	35	preferred	prefer	VBD
8691	3538	36	an	an	DT
8691	3538	37	election	election	NN
8691	3538	38	by	by	IN
8691	3538	39	the	the	DT
8691	3538	40	people	people	NNS
8691	3538	41	.	.	.
8691	3539	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3539	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3539	3	:	:	:
8691	3539	4	'	'	''
8691	3539	5	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
8691	3539	6	,	,	,
8691	3539	7	"	"	''
8691	3539	8	Modern	modern	JJ
8691	3539	9	Political	Political	NNP
8691	3539	10	Institutions	Institutions	NNPS
8691	3539	11	,	,	,
8691	3539	12	"	"	''
8691	3539	13	58	58	CD
8691	3539	14	,	,	,
8691	3539	15	59	59	CD
8691	3539	16	.	.	.
8691	3539	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3540	1	If	if	IN
8691	3540	2	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3540	3	compare	compare	VBP
8691	3540	4	the	the	DT
8691	3540	5	original	original	JJ
8691	3540	6	practice	practice	NN
8691	3540	7	in	in	IN
8691	3540	8	each	each	DT
8691	3540	9	State	State	NNP
8691	3540	10	with	with	IN
8691	3540	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3540	12	present	present	JJ
8691	3540	13	practice	practice	NN
8691	3540	14	,	,	,
8691	3540	15	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3540	16	find	find	VBP
8691	3540	17	that	that	IN
8691	3540	18	there	there	EX
8691	3540	19	are	be	VBP
8691	3540	20	now	now	RB
8691	3540	21	fewer	few	JJR
8691	3540	22	in	in	IN
8691	3540	23	which	which	WDT
8691	3540	24	the	the	DT
8691	3540	25	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3540	26	appoints	appoint	NNS
8691	3540	27	or	or	CC
8691	3540	28	nominates	nominate	NNS
8691	3540	29	;	;	:
8691	3540	30	fewer	few	JJR
8691	3540	31	in	in	IN
8691	3540	32	which	which	WDT
8691	3540	33	the	the	DT
8691	3540	34	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3540	35	elects	elect	VBZ
8691	3540	36	;	;	:
8691	3540	37	more	more	JJR
8691	3540	38	in	in	IN
8691	3540	39	which	which	WDT
8691	3540	40	the	the	DT
8691	3540	41	people	people	NNS
8691	3540	42	do	do	VBP
8691	3540	43	.	.	.
8691	3541	1	Legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	3541	2	elections	election	NNS
8691	3541	3	have	have	VBP
8691	3541	4	been	be	VBN
8691	3541	5	found	find	VBN
8691	3541	6	to	to	TO
8691	3541	7	imply	imply	VB
8691	3541	8	a	a	DT
8691	3541	9	system	system	NN
8691	3541	10	of	of	IN
8691	3541	11	caucus	caucus	JJ
8691	3541	12	nominations	nomination	NNS
8691	3541	13	,	,	,
8691	3541	14	and	and	CC
8691	3541	15	have	have	VBP
8691	3541	16	often	often	RB
8691	3541	17	led	lead	VBN
8691	3541	18	to	to	IN
8691	3541	19	a	a	DT
8691	3541	20	parcelling	parcelling	NN
8691	3541	21	out	out	IN
8691	3541	22	of	of	IN
8691	3541	23	places	place	NNS
8691	3541	24	among	among	IN
8691	3541	25	the	the	DT
8691	3541	26	different	different	JJ
8691	3541	27	counties	county	NNS
8691	3541	28	in	in	IN
8691	3541	29	which	which	WDT
8691	3541	30	geographical	geographical	JJ
8691	3541	31	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	3541	32	told	tell	VBD
8691	3541	33	for	for	IN
8691	3541	34	more	more	JJR
8691	3541	35	than	than	IN
8691	3541	36	did	do	VBD
8691	3541	37	fitness	fitness	NN
8691	3541	38	for	for	IN
8691	3541	39	office	office	NN
8691	3541	40	.	.	.
8691	3542	1	In	in	IN
8691	3542	2	one	one	CD
8691	3542	3	State[Footnote	state[footnote	NN
8691	3542	4	:	:	:
8691	3542	5	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3542	6	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3542	7	,	,	,
8691	3542	8	Twenty	Twenty	NNP
8691	3542	9	-	-	HYPH
8691	3542	10	sixth	sixth	NNP
8691	3542	11	Amendment	Amendment	NNP
8691	3542	12	.	.	.
8691	3542	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3543	1	since	since	IN
8691	3543	2	1880	1880	CD
8691	3543	3	,	,	,
8691	3543	4	the	the	DT
8691	3543	5	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3543	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	3543	7	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3543	8	on	on	IN
8691	3543	9	the	the	DT
8691	3543	10	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3543	11	's	's	POS
8691	3543	12	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3543	13	.	.	.
8691	3544	1	In	in	IN
8691	3544	2	practice	practice	NN
8691	3544	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3544	4	have	have	VBP
8691	3544	5	never	never	RB
8691	3544	6	failed	fail	VBN
8691	3544	7	to	to	TO
8691	3544	8	act	act	VB
8691	3544	9	favorably	favorably	RB
8691	3544	10	upon	upon	IN
8691	3544	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3544	12	.	.	.
8691	3545	1	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	3545	2	,	,	,
8691	3545	3	which	which	WDT
8691	3545	4	,	,	,
8691	3545	5	in	in	IN
8691	3545	6	1832	1832	CD
8691	3545	7	,	,	,
8691	3545	8	became	become	VBD
8691	3545	9	a	a	DT
8691	3545	10	leader	leader	NN
8691	3545	11	in	in	IN
8691	3545	12	the	the	DT
8691	3545	13	movement	movement	NN
8691	3545	14	toward	toward	IN
8691	3545	15	the	the	DT
8691	3545	16	choice	choice	NN
8691	3545	17	of	of	IN
8691	3545	18	the	the	DT
8691	3545	19	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3545	20	by	by	IN
8691	3545	21	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3545	22	election	election	NN
8691	3545	23	,	,	,
8691	3545	24	in	in	IN
8691	3545	25	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3545	26	latest	late	JJS
8691	3545	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3545	28	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3545	29	of	of	IN
8691	3545	30	1890	1890	CD
8691	3545	31	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3545	32	follows	follow	VBZ
8691	3545	33	the	the	DT
8691	3545	34	plan	plan	NN
8691	3545	35	of	of	IN
8691	3545	36	the	the	DT
8691	3545	37	United	United	NNP
8691	3545	38	States	States	NNP
8691	3545	39	,	,	,
8691	3545	40	the	the	DT
8691	3545	41	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3545	42	nominating	nominating	NN
8691	3545	43	and	and	CC
8691	3545	44	the	the	DT
8691	3545	45	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	3545	46	confirming	confirm	VBG
8691	3545	47	.	.	.
8691	3546	1	The	the	DT
8691	3546	2	action	action	NN
8691	3546	3	of	of	IN
8691	3546	4	the	the	DT
8691	3546	5	confirming	confirm	VBG
8691	3546	6	or	or	CC
8691	3546	7	electing	elect	VBG
8691	3546	8	body	body	NN
8691	3546	9	when	when	WRB
8691	3546	10	unfavorable	unfavorable	JJ
8691	3546	11	in	in	IN
8691	3546	12	any	any	DT
8691	3546	13	State	State	NNP
8691	3546	14	has	have	VBZ
8691	3546	15	generally	generally	RB
8691	3546	16	been	be	VBN
8691	3546	17	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
8691	3546	18	.	.	.
8691	3547	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3547	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3547	3	apt	apt	JJ
8691	3547	4	to	to	TO
8691	3547	5	be	be	VB
8691	3547	6	affected	affect	VBN
8691	3547	7	by	by	IN
8691	3547	8	local	local	JJ
8691	3547	9	or	or	CC
8691	3547	10	personal	personal	JJ
8691	3547	11	political	political	JJ
8691	3547	12	influence	influence	NN
8691	3547	13	to	to	TO
8691	3547	14	which	which	WDT
8691	3547	15	the	the	DT
8691	3547	16	chief	chief	JJ
8691	3547	17	executive	executive	NN
8691	3547	18	would	would	MD
8691	3547	19	be	be	VB
8691	3547	20	insensible	insensible	JJ
8691	3547	21	.	.	.
8691	3548	1	A	a	DT
8691	3548	2	large	large	JJ
8691	3548	3	number	number	NN
8691	3548	4	of	of	IN
8691	3548	5	able	able	JJ
8691	3548	6	men	man	NNS
8691	3548	7	have	have	VBP
8691	3548	8	thus	thus	RB
8691	3548	9	,	,	,
8691	3548	10	from	from	IN
8691	3548	11	time	time	NN
8691	3548	12	to	to	IN
8691	3548	13	time	time	NN
8691	3548	14	,	,	,
8691	3548	15	been	be	VBN
8691	3548	16	deprived	deprive	VBN
8691	3548	17	of	of	IN
8691	3548	18	a	a	DT
8691	3548	19	seat	seat	NN
8691	3548	20	on	on	IN
8691	3548	21	the	the	DT
8691	3548	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3548	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3548	24	of	of	IN
8691	3548	25	the	the	DT
8691	3548	26	United	United	NNP
8691	3548	27	States	States	NNP
8691	3548	28	who	who	WP
8691	3548	29	would	would	MD
8691	3548	30	have	have	VB
8691	3548	31	added	add	VBN
8691	3548	32	to	to	IN
8691	3548	33	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3548	34	luster	luster	NN
8691	3548	35	.	.	.
8691	3549	1	In	in	IN
8691	3549	2	1867	1867	CD
8691	3549	3	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3549	4	lost	lose	VBD
8691	3549	5	a	a	DT
8691	3549	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3549	7	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3549	8	of	of	IN
8691	3549	9	the	the	DT
8691	3549	10	first	first	JJ
8691	3549	11	rank	rank	NN
8691	3549	12	in	in	IN
8691	3549	13	this	this	DT
8691	3549	14	way	way	NN
8691	3549	15	by	by	IN
8691	3549	16	the	the	DT
8691	3549	17	defeat	defeat	NN
8691	3549	18	of	of	IN
8691	3549	19	Benjamin	Benjamin	NNP
8691	3549	20	F.	F.	NNP
8691	3549	21	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
8691	3549	22	.	.	.
8691	3550	1	The	the	DT
8691	3550	2	council	council	NN
8691	3550	3	refused	refuse	VBD
8691	3550	4	,	,	,
8691	3550	5	by	by	IN
8691	3550	6	a	a	DT
8691	3550	7	majority	majority	NN
8691	3550	8	of	of	IN
8691	3550	9	one	one	CD
8691	3550	10	,	,	,
8691	3550	11	to	to	TO
8691	3550	12	confirm	confirm	VB
8691	3550	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3550	14	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3550	15	because	because	IN
8691	3550	16	,	,	,
8691	3550	17	though	though	IN
8691	3550	18	of	of	IN
8691	3550	19	the	the	DT
8691	3550	20	same	same	JJ
8691	3550	21	party	party	NN
8691	3550	22	with	with	IN
8691	3550	23	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3550	24	,	,	,
8691	3550	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3550	26	was	be	VBD
8691	3550	27	of	of	IN
8691	3550	28	a	a	DT
8691	3550	29	different	different	JJ
8691	3550	30	wing	wing	NN
8691	3550	31	.	.	.
8691	3551	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3551	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3551	3	:	:	:
8691	3551	4	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
8691	3551	5	Mass.	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3552	1	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	3552	2	Society	Society	NNP
8691	3552	3	,	,	,
8691	3552	4	2d	2d	NNP
8691	3552	5	Series	Series	NNP
8691	3552	6	,	,	,
8691	3552	7	XIV	XIV	NNP
8691	3552	8	,	,	,
8691	3552	9	301	301	CD
8691	3552	10	.	.	.
8691	3552	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3553	1	In	in	IN
8691	3553	2	most	most	JJS
8691	3553	3	of	of	IN
8691	3553	4	the	the	DT
8691	3553	5	States	States	NNPS
8691	3553	6	the	the	DT
8691	3553	7	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3553	8	are	be	VBP
8691	3553	9	now	now	RB
8691	3553	10	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3553	11	by	by	IN
8691	3553	12	the	the	DT
8691	3553	13	people	people	NNS
8691	3553	14	.	.	.
8691	3554	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3554	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3554	3	:	:	:
8691	3554	4	In	in	IN
8691	3554	5	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	3554	6	-	-	HYPH
8691	3554	7	three	three	CD
8691	3554	8	.	.	.
8691	3555	1	In	in	IN
8691	3555	2	one	one	CD
8691	3555	3	other	other	JJ
8691	3555	4	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3555	5	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	3555	6	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3555	7	the	the	DT
8691	3555	8	people	people	NNS
8691	3555	9	elect	elect	VBP
8691	3555	10	the	the	DT
8691	3555	11	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3555	12	of	of	IN
8691	3555	13	the	the	DT
8691	3555	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3555	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3555	16	,	,	,
8691	3555	17	and	and	CC
8691	3555	18	the	the	DT
8691	3555	19	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3555	20	,	,	,
8691	3555	21	with	with	IN
8691	3555	22	the	the	DT
8691	3555	23	advice	advice	NN
8691	3555	24	and	and	CC
8691	3555	25	consent	consent	NN
8691	3555	26	of	of	IN
8691	3555	27	the	the	DT
8691	3555	28	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	3555	29	,	,	,
8691	3555	30	appoints	appoint	VBZ
8691	3555	31	those	those	DT
8691	3555	32	of	of	IN
8691	3555	33	the	the	DT
8691	3555	34	superior	superior	JJ
8691	3555	35	courts	court	NNS
8691	3555	36	.	.	.
8691	3556	1	The	the	DT
8691	3556	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3556	3	nominates	nominate	VBZ
8691	3556	4	in	in	IN
8691	3556	5	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
8691	3556	6	,	,	,
8691	3556	7	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	3556	8	and	and	CC
8691	3556	9	New	New	NNP
8691	3556	10	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	3556	11	,	,	,
8691	3556	12	and	and	CC
8691	3556	13	in	in	IN
8691	3556	14	the	the	DT
8691	3556	15	four	four	CD
8691	3556	16	largest	large	JJS
8691	3556	17	New	New	NNP
8691	3556	18	England	England	NNP
8691	3556	19	States	States	NNP
8691	3556	20	.	.	.
8691	3557	1	In	in	IN
8691	3557	2	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	3557	3	Island	Island	NNP
8691	3557	4	and	and	CC
8691	3557	5	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
8691	3557	6	,	,	,
8691	3557	7	South	South	NNP
8691	3557	8	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	3557	9	and	and	CC
8691	3557	10	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	3557	11	,	,	,
8691	3557	12	the	the	DT
8691	3557	13	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3557	14	elects	elect	VBZ
8691	3557	15	.	.	.
8691	3557	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3558	1	This	this	DT
8691	3558	2	makes	make	VBZ
8691	3558	3	the	the	DT
8691	3558	4	choice	choice	NN
8691	3558	5	more	more	JJR
8691	3558	6	a	a	DT
8691	3558	7	political	political	JJ
8691	3558	8	affair	affair	NN
8691	3558	9	.	.	.
8691	3559	1	The	the	DT
8691	3559	2	nominations	nomination	NNS
8691	3559	3	are	be	VBP
8691	3559	4	made	make	VBN
8691	3559	5	by	by	IN
8691	3559	6	party	party	NN
8691	3559	7	conventions	convention	NNS
8691	3559	8	,	,	,
8691	3559	9	and	and	CC
8691	3559	10	generally	generally	RB
8691	3559	11	in	in	IN
8691	3559	12	connection	connection	NN
8691	3559	13	with	with	IN
8691	3559	14	others	other	NNS
8691	3559	15	of	of	IN
8691	3559	16	a	a	DT
8691	3559	17	purely	purely	RB
8691	3559	18	political	political	JJ
8691	3559	19	character	character	NN
8691	3559	20	.	.	.
8691	3560	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3560	2	also	also	RB
8691	3560	3	,	,	,
8691	3560	4	in	in	IN
8691	3560	5	case	case	NN
8691	3560	6	of	of	IN
8691	3560	7	a	a	DT
8691	3560	8	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3560	9	for	for	IN
8691	3560	10	re	re	NN
8691	3560	11	-	-	NN
8691	3560	12	election	election	NN
8691	3560	13	,	,	,
8691	3560	14	places	place	VBZ
8691	3560	15	a	a	DT
8691	3560	16	judge	judge	NN
8691	3560	17	on	on	IN
8691	3560	18	the	the	DT
8691	3560	19	bench	bench	NN
8691	3560	20	in	in	IN
8691	3560	21	the	the	DT
8691	3560	22	disagreeable	disagreeable	JJ
8691	3560	23	position	position	NN
8691	3560	24	of	of	IN
8691	3560	25	being	be	VBG
8691	3560	26	a	a	DT
8691	3560	27	candidate	candidate	NN
8691	3560	28	for	for	IN
8691	3560	29	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3560	30	favor	favor	NN
8691	3560	31	at	at	IN
8691	3560	32	the	the	DT
8691	3560	33	polls	poll	NNS
8691	3560	34	and	and	CC
8691	3560	35	an	an	DT
8691	3560	36	object	object	NN
8691	3560	37	of	of	IN
8691	3560	38	public	public	JJ
8691	3560	39	criticism	criticism	NN
8691	3560	40	by	by	IN
8691	3560	41	the	the	DT
8691	3560	42	political	political	JJ
8691	3560	43	press	press	NN
8691	3560	44	.	.	.
8691	3561	1	In	in	IN
8691	3561	2	1902	1902	CD
8691	3561	3	a	a	DT
8691	3561	4	justice	justice	NN
8691	3561	5	of	of	IN
8691	3561	6	the	the	DT
8691	3561	7	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3561	8	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3561	9	of	of	IN
8691	3561	10	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
8691	3561	11	was	be	VBD
8691	3561	12	nominated	nominate	VBN
8691	3561	13	for	for	IN
8691	3561	14	re	re	NN
8691	3561	15	-	-	NN
8691	3561	16	election	election	NN
8691	3561	17	.	.	.
8691	3562	1	There	there	EX
8691	3562	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3562	3	an	an	DT
8691	3562	4	opposing	oppose	VBG
8691	3562	5	candidate	candidate	NN
8691	3562	6	,	,	,
8691	3562	7	some	some	DT
8691	3562	8	of	of	IN
8691	3562	9	whose	whose	WP$
8691	3562	10	friends	friend	NNS
8691	3562	11	published	publish	VBD
8691	3562	12	a	a	DT
8691	3562	13	statement	statement	NN
8691	3562	14	that	that	IN
8691	3562	15	in	in	IN
8691	3562	16	the	the	DT
8691	3562	17	nine	nine	CD
8691	3562	18	years	year	NNS
8691	3562	19	during	during	IN
8691	3562	20	which	which	WDT
8691	3562	21	the	the	DT
8691	3562	22	justice	justice	NN
8691	3562	23	had	have	VBD
8691	3562	24	already	already	RB
8691	3562	25	served	serve	VBN
8691	3562	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3562	27	had	have	VBD
8691	3562	28	written	write	VBN
8691	3562	29	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3562	30	in	in	IN
8691	3562	31	68	68	CD
8691	3562	32	railroad	railroad	NN
8691	3562	33	and	and	CC
8691	3562	34	street	street	NN
8691	3562	35	railway	railway	NN
8691	3562	36	cases	case	NNS
8691	3562	37	of	of	IN
8691	3562	38	which	which	WDT
8691	3562	39	51	51	CD
8691	3562	40	were	be	VBD
8691	3562	41	in	in	IN
8691	3562	42	favor	favor	NN
8691	3562	43	of	of	IN
8691	3562	44	the	the	DT
8691	3562	45	companies	company	NNS
8691	3562	46	.	.	.
8691	3563	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3563	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3563	3	re	re	VBN
8691	3563	4	-	-	VBN
8691	3563	5	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3563	6	,	,	,
8691	3563	7	but	but	CC
8691	3563	8	some	some	DT
8691	3563	9	time	time	NN
8691	3563	10	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	3563	11	this	this	DT
8691	3563	12	fact	fact	NN
8691	3563	13	was	be	VBD
8691	3563	14	reprinted	reprint	VBN
8691	3563	15	in	in	IN
8691	3563	16	a	a	DT
8691	3563	17	local	local	JJ
8691	3563	18	periodical	periodical	NN
8691	3563	19	accompanied	accompany	VBN
8691	3563	20	by	by	IN
8691	3563	21	the	the	DT
8691	3563	22	remark	remark	NN
8691	3563	23	that	that	IN
8691	3563	24	"	"	``
8691	3563	25	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3563	26	must	must	MD
8691	3563	27	conclude	conclude	VB
8691	3563	28	that	that	IN
8691	3563	29	either	either	CC
8691	3563	30	the	the	DT
8691	3563	31	railroad	railroad	NN
8691	3563	32	and	and	CC
8691	3563	33	railway	railway	NN
8691	3563	34	companies--4	companies--4	-LRB-
8691	3563	35	to	to	IN
8691	3563	36	1	1	CD
8691	3563	37	-	-	HYPH
8691	3563	38	-had	-had	VBD
8691	3563	39	exceptionally	exceptionally	RB
8691	3563	40	good	good	JJ
8691	3563	41	cases	case	NNS
8691	3563	42	from	from	IN
8691	3563	43	the	the	DT
8691	3563	44	standpoint	standpoint	NN
8691	3563	45	of	of	IN
8691	3563	46	law	law	NN
8691	3563	47	and	and	CC
8691	3563	48	justice	justice	NN
8691	3563	49	or	or	CC
8691	3563	50	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3563	51	Honor	Honor	NNP
8691	3563	52	's	's	POS
8691	3563	53	mind	mind	NN
8691	3563	54	was	be	VBD
8691	3563	55	somewhat	somewhat	RB
8691	3563	56	warped	warped	JJ
8691	3563	57	in	in	IN
8691	3563	58	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3563	59	favor	favor	NN
8691	3563	60	....	....	.
8691	3563	61	You	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3563	62	ca	can	MD
8691	3563	63	n't	not	RB
8691	3563	64	expurge	expurge	VB
8691	3563	65	mental	mental	JJ
8691	3563	66	prejudice	prejudice	NN
8691	3563	67	from	from	IN
8691	3563	68	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3563	69	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3563	70	any	any	DT
8691	3563	71	more	more	RBR
8691	3563	72	than	than	IN
8691	3563	73	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3563	74	can	can	MD
8691	3563	75	from	from	IN
8691	3563	76	the	the	DT
8691	3563	77	reasonings	reasoning	NNS
8691	3563	78	of	of	IN
8691	3563	79	theologians	theologian	NNS
8691	3563	80	and	and	CC
8691	3563	81	atheists	atheist	NNS
8691	3563	82	....	....	.
8691	3563	83	To	to	TO
8691	3563	84	imagine	imagine	VB
8691	3563	85	a	a	DT
8691	3563	86	justice	justice	NN
8691	3563	87	deciding	decide	VBG
8691	3563	88	a	a	DT
8691	3563	89	case	case	NN
8691	3563	90	against	against	IN
8691	3563	91	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3563	92	personal	personal	JJ
8691	3563	93	interests	interest	NNS
8691	3563	94	is	be	VBZ
8691	3563	95	too	too	RB
8691	3563	96	great	great	JJ
8691	3563	97	a	a	DT
8691	3563	98	stretch	stretch	NN
8691	3563	99	of	of	IN
8691	3563	100	imagination	imagination	NN
8691	3563	101	for	for	IN
8691	3563	102	us	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3563	103	to	to	TO
8691	3563	104	appreciate	appreciate	VB
8691	3563	105	.	.	.
8691	3563	106	"	"	''
8691	3564	1	A	a	DT
8691	3564	2	less	less	RBR
8691	3564	3	brutal	brutal	JJ
8691	3564	4	but	but	CC
8691	3564	5	more	more	RBR
8691	3564	6	dangerous	dangerous	JJ
8691	3564	7	attack	attack	NN
8691	3564	8	,	,	,
8691	3564	9	made	make	VBN
8691	3564	10	in	in	IN
8691	3564	11	1903	1903	CD
8691	3564	12	by	by	IN
8691	3564	13	a	a	DT
8691	3564	14	religious	religious	JJ
8691	3564	15	newspaper	newspaper	NN
8691	3564	16	,	,	,
8691	3564	17	illustrates	illustrate	VBZ
8691	3564	18	the	the	DT
8691	3564	19	same	same	JJ
8691	3564	20	evil	evil	NN
8691	3564	21	.	.	.
8691	3565	1	The	the	DT
8691	3565	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3565	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3565	4	of	of	IN
8691	3565	5	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
8691	3565	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	3565	7	decided	decide	VBN
8691	3565	8	that	that	IN
8691	3565	9	under	under	IN
8691	3565	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3565	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3565	12	the	the	DT
8691	3565	13	Bible	Bible	NNP
8691	3565	14	can	can	MD
8691	3565	15	not	not	RB
8691	3565	16	be	be	VB
8691	3565	17	used	use	VBN
8691	3565	18	in	in	IN
8691	3565	19	the	the	DT
8691	3565	20	public	public	JJ
8691	3565	21	schools	school	NNS
8691	3565	22	.	.	.
8691	3566	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3566	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3566	3	,	,	,
8691	3566	4	of	of	IN
8691	3566	5	course	course	NN
8691	3566	6	,	,	,
8691	3566	7	a	a	DT
8691	3566	8	pure	pure	JJ
8691	3566	9	question	question	NN
8691	3566	10	of	of	IN
8691	3566	11	the	the	DT
8691	3566	12	construction	construction	NN
8691	3566	13	of	of	IN
8691	3566	14	a	a	DT
8691	3566	15	law	law	NN
8691	3566	16	,	,	,
8691	3566	17	for	for	IN
8691	3566	18	the	the	DT
8691	3566	19	policy	policy	NN
8691	3566	20	of	of	IN
8691	3566	21	which	which	WDT
8691	3566	22	the	the	DT
8691	3566	23	court	court	NN
8691	3566	24	had	have	VBD
8691	3566	25	no	no	DT
8691	3566	26	responsibility	responsibility	NN
8691	3566	27	.	.	.
8691	3567	1	The	the	DT
8691	3567	2	newspaper	newspaper	NN
8691	3567	3	in	in	IN
8691	3567	4	question[Footnote	question[footnote	RB
8691	3567	5	:	:	:
8691	3567	6	The	the	DT
8691	3567	7	Boston	Boston	NNP
8691	3567	8	_	_	NNP
8691	3567	9	Congregationalist	Congregationalist	NNP
8691	3567	10	_	_	NNP
8691	3567	11	of	of	IN
8691	3567	12	Oct.	October	NNP
8691	3567	13	3	3	CD
8691	3567	14	,	,	,
8691	3567	15	1903	1903	CD
8691	3567	16	.	.	.
8691	3567	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3568	1	which	which	WDT
8691	3568	2	,	,	,
8691	3568	3	though	though	IN
8691	3568	4	published	publish	VBN
8691	3568	5	in	in	IN
8691	3568	6	the	the	DT
8691	3568	7	East	East	NNP
8691	3568	8	,	,	,
8691	3568	9	had	have	VBD
8691	3568	10	some	some	DT
8691	3568	11	circulation	circulation	NN
8691	3568	12	in	in	IN
8691	3568	13	that	that	DT
8691	3568	14	State	State	NNP
8691	3568	15	,	,	,
8691	3568	16	printed	print	VBD
8691	3568	17	this	this	DT
8691	3568	18	paragraph	paragraph	NN
8691	3568	19	:	:	:
8691	3568	20	"	"	``
8691	3568	21	The	the	DT
8691	3568	22	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3568	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3568	24	judge	judge	NN
8691	3568	25	of	of	IN
8691	3568	26	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
8691	3568	27	who	who	WP
8691	3568	28	wrote	write	VBD
8691	3568	29	the	the	DT
8691	3568	30	decision	decision	NN
8691	3568	31	that	that	IN
8691	3568	32	the	the	DT
8691	3568	33	State	State	NNP
8691	3568	34	constitution	constitution	NN
8691	3568	35	prohibits	prohibit	VBZ
8691	3568	36	the	the	DT
8691	3568	37	use	use	NN
8691	3568	38	of	of	IN
8691	3568	39	the	the	DT
8691	3568	40	Bible	Bible	NNP
8691	3568	41	in	in	IN
8691	3568	42	the	the	DT
8691	3568	43	public	public	JJ
8691	3568	44	schools	school	NNS
8691	3568	45	is	be	VBZ
8691	3568	46	standing	stand	VBG
8691	3568	47	for	for	IN
8691	3568	48	re	re	NN
8691	3568	49	-	-	NN
8691	3568	50	election	election	NN
8691	3568	51	,	,	,
8691	3568	52	and	and	CC
8691	3568	53	the	the	DT
8691	3568	54	fact	fact	NN
8691	3568	55	that	that	IN
8691	3568	56	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3568	57	made	make	VBD
8691	3568	58	such	such	PDT
8691	3568	59	a	a	DT
8691	3568	60	decision	decision	NN
8691	3568	61	is	be	VBZ
8691	3568	62	not	not	RB
8691	3568	63	forgotten	forget	VBN
8691	3568	64	by	by	IN
8691	3568	65	the	the	DT
8691	3568	66	Christian	christian	JJ
8691	3568	67	voters	voter	NNS
8691	3568	68	.	.	.
8691	3568	69	"	"	''
8691	3569	1	In	in	IN
8691	3569	2	States	state	NNS
8691	3569	3	the	the	DT
8691	3569	4	control	control	NN
8691	3569	5	of	of	IN
8691	3569	6	which	which	WDT
8691	3569	7	by	by	IN
8691	3569	8	one	one	CD
8691	3569	9	of	of	IN
8691	3569	10	the	the	DT
8691	3569	11	great	great	JJ
8691	3569	12	political	political	JJ
8691	3569	13	parties	party	NNS
8691	3569	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	3569	15	assured	assure	VBN
8691	3569	16	,	,	,
8691	3569	17	the	the	DT
8691	3569	18	real	real	JJ
8691	3569	19	contest	contest	NN
8691	3569	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	3569	21	for	for	IN
8691	3569	22	the	the	DT
8691	3569	23	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3569	24	,	,	,
8691	3569	25	and	and	CC
8691	3569	26	here	here	RB
8691	3569	27	there	there	EX
8691	3569	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	3569	29	even	even	RB
8691	3569	30	more	more	JJR
8691	3569	31	license	license	NN
8691	3569	32	for	for	IN
8691	3569	33	unfavorable	unfavorable	JJ
8691	3569	34	comment	comment	NN
8691	3569	35	on	on	IN
8691	3569	36	the	the	DT
8691	3569	37	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3569	38	record	record	NN
8691	3569	39	of	of	IN
8691	3569	40	one	one	NN
8691	3569	41	who	who	WP
8691	3569	42	seeks	seek	VBZ
8691	3569	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3569	44	.	.	.
8691	3570	1	In	in	IN
8691	3570	2	a	a	DT
8691	3570	3	Southern	Southern	NNP
8691	3570	4	State	State	NNP
8691	3570	5	there	there	EX
8691	3570	6	was	be	VBD
8691	3570	7	such	such	PDT
8691	3570	8	a	a	DT
8691	3570	9	struggle	struggle	NN
8691	3570	10	in	in	IN
8691	3570	11	1903	1903	CD
8691	3570	12	for	for	IN
8691	3570	13	the	the	DT
8691	3570	14	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3570	15	of	of	IN
8691	3570	16	the	the	DT
8691	3570	17	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	3570	18	party	party	NN
8691	3570	19	for	for	IN
8691	3570	20	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3570	21	.	.	.
8691	3571	1	The	the	DT
8691	3571	2	person	person	NN
8691	3571	3	who	who	WP
8691	3571	4	then	then	RB
8691	3571	5	held	hold	VBD
8691	3571	6	that	that	DT
8691	3571	7	place	place	NN
8691	3571	8	desired	desire	VBD
8691	3571	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3571	10	.	.	.
8691	3572	1	So	so	RB
8691	3572	2	did	do	VBD
8691	3572	3	one	one	CD
8691	3572	4	of	of	IN
8691	3572	5	the	the	DT
8691	3572	6	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3572	7	of	of	IN
8691	3572	8	the	the	DT
8691	3572	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3572	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3572	11	.	.	.
8691	3573	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3573	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3573	3	said	say	VBN
8691	3573	4	that	that	IN
8691	3573	5	the	the	DT
8691	3573	6	friends	friend	NNS
8691	3573	7	of	of	IN
8691	3573	8	the	the	DT
8691	3573	9	former	former	JJ
8691	3573	10	circulated	circulate	VBD
8691	3573	11	a	a	DT
8691	3573	12	cartoon	cartoon	NN
8691	3573	13	representing	represent	VBG
8691	3573	14	the	the	DT
8691	3573	15	five	five	CD
8691	3573	16	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3573	17	together	together	RB
8691	3573	18	as	as	IN
8691	3573	19	five	five	CD
8691	3573	20	jackasses	jackass	NNS
8691	3573	21	,	,	,
8691	3573	22	and	and	CC
8691	3573	23	another	another	DT
8691	3573	24	in	in	IN
8691	3573	25	which	which	WDT
8691	3573	26	the	the	DT
8691	3573	27	justice	justice	NN
8691	3573	28	whom	whom	WP
8691	3573	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3573	30	were	be	VBD
8691	3573	31	trying	try	VBG
8691	3573	32	to	to	TO
8691	3573	33	run	run	VB
8691	3573	34	off	off	IN
8691	3573	35	the	the	DT
8691	3573	36	field	field	NN
8691	3573	37	was	be	VBD
8691	3573	38	caricatured	caricature	VBN
8691	3573	39	in	in	IN
8691	3573	40	the	the	DT
8691	3573	41	act	act	NN
8691	3573	42	of	of	IN
8691	3573	43	setting	set	VBG
8691	3573	44	aside	aside	RP
8691	3573	45	a	a	DT
8691	3573	46	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	3573	47	in	in	IN
8691	3573	48	favor	favor	NN
8691	3573	49	of	of	IN
8691	3573	50	a	a	DT
8691	3573	51	child	child	NN
8691	3573	52	injured	injure	VBN
8691	3573	53	by	by	IN
8691	3573	54	a	a	DT
8691	3573	55	railway	railway	NN
8691	3573	56	accident	accident	NN
8691	3573	57	.	.	.
8691	3574	1	The	the	DT
8691	3574	2	two	two	CD
8691	3574	3	candidates	candidate	NNS
8691	3574	4	subsequently	subsequently	RB
8691	3574	5	met	meet	VBD
8691	3574	6	upon	upon	IN
8691	3574	7	the	the	DT
8691	3574	8	platform	platform	NN
8691	3574	9	for	for	IN
8691	3574	10	a	a	DT
8691	3574	11	joint	joint	JJ
8691	3574	12	discussion	discussion	NN
8691	3574	13	of	of	IN
8691	3574	14	the	the	DT
8691	3574	15	issues	issue	NNS
8691	3574	16	before	before	IN
8691	3574	17	the	the	DT
8691	3574	18	people	people	NNS
8691	3574	19	.	.	.
8691	3575	1	The	the	DT
8691	3575	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3575	3	sharply	sharply	RB
8691	3575	4	criticised	criticise	VBD
8691	3575	5	the	the	DT
8691	3575	6	character	character	NN
8691	3575	7	of	of	IN
8691	3575	8	the	the	DT
8691	3575	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3575	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3575	11	.	.	.
8691	3576	1	The	the	DT
8691	3576	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	3576	3	caught	catch	VBD
8691	3576	4	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3576	5	by	by	IN
8691	3576	6	the	the	DT
8691	3576	7	collar	collar	NN
8691	3576	8	and	and	CC
8691	3576	9	was	be	VBD
8691	3576	10	about	about	JJ
8691	3576	11	to	to	TO
8691	3576	12	strike	strike	VB
8691	3576	13	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3576	14	when	when	WRB
8691	3576	15	friends	friend	NNS
8691	3576	16	intervened	intervene	VBD
8691	3576	17	,	,	,
8691	3576	18	and	and	CC
8691	3576	19	an	an	DT
8691	3576	20	explanation	explanation	NN
8691	3576	21	of	of	IN
8691	3576	22	the	the	DT
8691	3576	23	remarks	remark	NNS
8691	3576	24	was	be	VBD
8691	3576	25	made	make	VBN
8691	3576	26	which	which	WDT
8691	3576	27	was	be	VBD
8691	3576	28	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	3576	29	as	as	IN
8691	3576	30	satisfactory	satisfactory	JJ
8691	3576	31	.	.	.
8691	3577	1	In	in	IN
8691	3577	2	the	the	DT
8691	3577	3	heat	heat	NN
8691	3577	4	of	of	IN
8691	3577	5	a	a	DT
8691	3577	6	political	political	JJ
8691	3577	7	campaign	campaign	NN
8691	3577	8	men	man	NNS
8691	3577	9	do	do	VBP
8691	3577	10	not	not	RB
8691	3577	11	always	always	RB
8691	3577	12	stop	stop	VB
8691	3577	13	to	to	TO
8691	3577	14	measure	measure	VB
8691	3577	15	words	word	NNS
8691	3577	16	or	or	CC
8691	3577	17	weigh	weigh	VB
8691	3577	18	questions	question	NNS
8691	3577	19	of	of	IN
8691	3577	20	propriety	propriety	NN
8691	3577	21	.	.	.
8691	3578	1	The	the	DT
8691	3578	2	personal	personal	JJ
8691	3578	3	character	character	NN
8691	3578	4	and	and	CC
8691	3578	5	public	public	JJ
8691	3578	6	acts	act	NNS
8691	3578	7	of	of	IN
8691	3578	8	an	an	DT
8691	3578	9	opponent	opponent	NN
8691	3578	10	are	be	VBP
8691	3578	11	a	a	DT
8691	3578	12	legitimate	legitimate	JJ
8691	3578	13	subject	subject	NN
8691	3578	14	of	of	IN
8691	3578	15	description	description	NN
8691	3578	16	and	and	CC
8691	3578	17	comment	comment	NN
8691	3578	18	.	.	.
8691	3579	1	Sharp	sharp	JJ
8691	3579	2	attacks	attack	NNS
8691	3579	3	must	must	MD
8691	3579	4	be	be	VB
8691	3579	5	expected	expect	VBN
8691	3579	6	as	as	IN
8691	3579	7	a	a	DT
8691	3579	8	natural	natural	JJ
8691	3579	9	incident	incident	NN
8691	3579	10	of	of	IN
8691	3579	11	such	such	PDT
8691	3579	12	a	a	DT
8691	3579	13	contest	contest	NN
8691	3579	14	,	,	,
8691	3579	15	and	and	CC
8691	3579	16	by	by	IN
8691	3579	17	candidates	candidate	NNS
8691	3579	18	for	for	IN
8691	3579	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3579	20	office	office	NN
8691	3579	21	as	as	RB
8691	3579	22	well	well	RB
8691	3579	23	as	as	IN
8691	3579	24	others	other	NNS
8691	3579	25	.	.	.
8691	3580	1	The	the	DT
8691	3580	2	public	public	JJ
8691	3580	3	record	record	NN
8691	3580	4	of	of	IN
8691	3580	5	all	all	DT
8691	3580	6	for	for	IN
8691	3580	7	whom	whom	WP
8691	3580	8	votes	vote	NNS
8691	3580	9	are	be	VBP
8691	3580	10	asked	ask	VBN
8691	3580	11	at	at	IN
8691	3580	12	a	a	DT
8691	3580	13	public	public	JJ
8691	3580	14	election	election	NN
8691	3580	15	must	must	MD
8691	3580	16	be	be	VB
8691	3580	17	the	the	DT
8691	3580	18	subject	subject	NN
8691	3580	19	of	of	IN
8691	3580	20	open	open	JJ
8691	3580	21	criticism	criticism	NN
8691	3580	22	,	,	,
8691	3580	23	or	or	CC
8691	3580	24	there	there	EX
8691	3580	25	would	would	MD
8691	3580	26	be	be	VB
8691	3580	27	danger	danger	NN
8691	3580	28	that	that	IN
8691	3580	29	unworthy	unworthy	JJ
8691	3580	30	men	man	NNS
8691	3580	31	would	would	MD
8691	3580	32	succeed	succeed	VB
8691	3580	33	.	.	.
8691	3581	1	To	to	TO
8691	3581	2	treat	treat	VB
8691	3581	3	such	such	JJ
8691	3581	4	observations	observation	NNS
8691	3581	5	as	as	IN
8691	3581	6	have	have	VBP
8691	3581	7	been	be	VBN
8691	3581	8	quoted	quote	VBN
8691	3581	9	upon	upon	IN
8691	3581	10	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3581	11	previously	previously	RB
8691	3581	12	written	write	VBN
8691	3581	13	by	by	IN
8691	3581	14	a	a	DT
8691	3581	15	candidate	candidate	NN
8691	3581	16	for	for	IN
8691	3581	17	re	re	NN
8691	3581	18	-	-	NN
8691	3581	19	election	election	NN
8691	3581	20	,	,	,
8691	3581	21	however	however	RB
8691	3581	22	unseemly	unseemly	JJ
8691	3581	23	or	or	CC
8691	3581	24	unjust	unjust	JJ
8691	3581	25	,	,	,
8691	3581	26	as	as	IN
8691	3581	27	a	a	DT
8691	3581	28	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	3581	29	of	of	IN
8691	3581	30	court	court	NN
8691	3581	31	would	would	MD
8691	3581	32	be	be	VB
8691	3581	33	indirectly	indirectly	RB
8691	3581	34	to	to	TO
8691	3581	35	impair	impair	VB
8691	3581	36	the	the	DT
8691	3581	37	right	right	NN
8691	3581	38	of	of	IN
8691	3581	39	free	free	JJ
8691	3581	40	suffrage	suffrage	NN
8691	3581	41	.	.	.
8691	3582	1	If	if	IN
8691	3582	2	assertions	assertion	NNS
8691	3582	3	published	publish	VBD
8691	3582	4	as	as	IN
8691	3582	5	to	to	IN
8691	3582	6	acts	act	NNS
8691	3582	7	done	do	VBN
8691	3582	8	or	or	CC
8691	3582	9	words	word	NNS
8691	3582	10	said	say	VBD
8691	3582	11	are	be	VBP
8691	3582	12	false	false	JJ
8691	3582	13	,	,	,
8691	3582	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3582	15	does	do	VBZ
8691	3582	16	not	not	RB
8691	3582	17	follow	follow	VB
8691	3582	18	that	that	IN
8691	3582	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3582	20	are	be	VBP
8691	3582	21	libellous	libellous	JJ
8691	3582	22	.	.	.
8691	3583	1	An	an	DT
8691	3583	2	honest	honest	JJ
8691	3583	3	mistake	mistake	NN
8691	3583	4	may	may	MD
8691	3583	5	be	be	VB
8691	3583	6	a	a	DT
8691	3583	7	defense	defense	NN
8691	3583	8	for	for	IN
8691	3583	9	such	such	PDT
8691	3583	10	a	a	DT
8691	3583	11	misstatement	misstatement	NN
8691	3583	12	.	.	.
8691	3584	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3584	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3584	3	:	:	:
8691	3584	4	Briggs	Briggs	NNP
8691	3584	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3584	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3584	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3584	8	Garrett	Garrett	NNP
8691	3584	9	,	,	,
8691	3584	10	111	111	CD
8691	3584	11	Penn	Penn	NNP
8691	3584	12	.	.	.
8691	3585	1	State	State	NNP
8691	3585	2	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3585	3	,	,	,
8691	3585	4	404	404	CD
8691	3585	5	;	;	SYM
8691	3585	6	2	2	CD
8691	3585	7	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	3585	8	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	3585	9	,	,	,
8691	3585	10	513	513	CD
8691	3585	11	.	.	.
8691	3585	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3586	1	Judges	judge	NNS
8691	3586	2	of	of	IN
8691	3586	3	trial	trial	NN
8691	3586	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	3586	5	,	,	,
8691	3586	6	when	when	WRB
8691	3586	7	candidates	candidate	NNS
8691	3586	8	for	for	IN
8691	3586	9	re	re	NN
8691	3586	10	-	-	NN
8691	3586	11	election	election	NN
8691	3586	12	,	,	,
8691	3586	13	may	may	MD
8691	3586	14	expect	expect	VB
8691	3586	15	the	the	DT
8691	3586	16	publication	publication	NN
8691	3586	17	of	of	IN
8691	3586	18	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3586	19	attacks	attack	NNS
8691	3586	20	on	on	IN
8691	3586	21	rulings	ruling	NNS
8691	3586	22	which	which	WDT
8691	3586	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3586	24	have	have	VBP
8691	3586	25	made	make	VBN
8691	3586	26	.	.	.
8691	3587	1	The	the	DT
8691	3587	2	following	follow	VBG
8691	3587	3	dispatches	dispatch	NNS
8691	3587	4	,	,	,
8691	3587	5	which	which	WDT
8691	3587	6	appeared	appear	VBD
8691	3587	7	in	in	IN
8691	3587	8	the	the	DT
8691	3587	9	same	same	JJ
8691	3587	10	issue	issue	NN
8691	3587	11	of	of	IN
8691	3587	12	a	a	DT
8691	3587	13	local	local	JJ
8691	3587	14	newspaper	newspaper	NN
8691	3587	15	in	in	IN
8691	3587	16	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3587	17	in	in	IN
8691	3587	18	1903	1903	CD
8691	3587	19	,	,	,
8691	3587	20	when	when	WRB
8691	3587	21	a	a	DT
8691	3587	22	county	county	NN
8691	3587	23	election	election	NN
8691	3587	24	was	be	VBD
8691	3587	25	soon	soon	RB
8691	3587	26	to	to	TO
8691	3587	27	occur	occur	VB
8691	3587	28	,	,	,
8691	3587	29	will	will	MD
8691	3587	30	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
8691	3587	31	illustrate	illustrate	VB
8691	3587	32	this	this	DT
8691	3587	33	:	:	:
8691	3587	34	HOT	hot	JJ
8691	3587	35	JUDICIAL	judicial	NN
8691	3587	36	FIGHT	fight	VBP
8691	3587	37	PROMISED	PROMISED	NNS
8691	3587	38	FOR	for	IN
8691	3587	39	MERCER	MERCER	NNP
8691	3587	40	.	.	.
8691	3588	1	COUNTY	COUNTY	NNP
8691	3588	2	WILL	WILL	MD
8691	3588	3	BE	be	VB
8691	3588	4	SCENE	scene	NN
8691	3588	5	OF	of	IN
8691	3588	6	AN	an	DT
8691	3588	7	INTERESTING	interesting	JJ
8691	3588	8	STRUGGLE	struggle	NN
8691	3588	9	FOR	for	IN
8691	3588	10	SEATS	seat	NNS
8691	3588	11	IN	in	IN
8691	3588	12	THE	the	DT
8691	3588	13	LEGISLATURE	LEGISLATURE	NNP
8691	3588	14	.	.	.
8691	3589	1	Sharon	Sharon	NNP
8691	3589	2	,	,	,
8691	3589	3	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3589	4	,	,	,
8691	3589	5	Dec.	December	NNP
8691	3590	1	25.--From	25.--from	CD
8691	3590	2	present	present	JJ
8691	3590	3	indications	indication	NNS
8691	3590	4	the	the	DT
8691	3590	5	coming	come	VBG
8691	3590	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3590	7	fight	fight	NN
8691	3590	8	in	in	IN
8691	3590	9	Mercer	Mercer	NNP
8691	3590	10	County	County	NNP
8691	3590	11	will	will	MD
8691	3590	12	be	be	VB
8691	3590	13	a	a	DT
8691	3590	14	bitter	bitter	JJ
8691	3590	15	one	one	NN
8691	3590	16	.	.	.
8691	3591	1	Public	public	JJ
8691	3591	2	interest	interest	NN
8691	3591	3	centers	center	NNS
8691	3591	4	in	in	IN
8691	3591	5	the	the	DT
8691	3591	6	efforts	effort	NNS
8691	3591	7	of	of	IN
8691	3591	8	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3591	9	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3591	10	H.	H.	NNP
8691	3591	11	Miller	Miller	NNP
8691	3591	12	and	and	CC
8691	3591	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3591	14	friends	friend	NNS
8691	3591	15	to	to	TO
8691	3591	16	secure	secure	VB
8691	3591	17	a	a	DT
8691	3591	18	re	re	NN
8691	3591	19	-	-	NN
8691	3591	20	election	election	NN
8691	3591	21	,	,	,
8691	3591	22	and	and	CC
8691	3591	23	the	the	DT
8691	3591	24	attempts	attempt	NNS
8691	3591	25	of	of	IN
8691	3591	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3591	27	opponents	opponent	NNS
8691	3591	28	to	to	TO
8691	3591	29	place	place	VB
8691	3591	30	A.	a.	NN
8691	3591	31	W.	W.	NNP
8691	3591	32	Williams	Williams	NNP
8691	3591	33	of	of	IN
8691	3591	34	Sharon	Sharon	NNP
8691	3591	35	on	on	IN
8691	3591	36	the	the	DT
8691	3591	37	bench	bench	NN
8691	3591	38	instead	instead	RB
8691	3591	39	.	.	.
8691	3592	1	While	while	IN
8691	3592	2	the	the	DT
8691	3592	3	sole	sole	JJ
8691	3592	4	topic	topic	NN
8691	3592	5	politically	politically	RB
8691	3592	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3592	7	on	on	IN
8691	3592	8	the	the	DT
8691	3592	9	judgeship	judgeship	NN
8691	3592	10	,	,	,
8691	3592	11	the	the	DT
8691	3592	12	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3592	13	or	or	CC
8691	3592	14	more	more	JJR
8691	3592	15	candidates	candidate	NNS
8691	3592	16	for	for	IN
8691	3592	17	Assembly	Assembly	NNP
8691	3592	18	are	be	VBP
8691	3592	19	not	not	RB
8691	3592	20	losing	lose	VBG
8691	3592	21	the	the	DT
8691	3592	22	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	3592	23	of	of	IN
8691	3592	24	fixing	fix	VBG
8691	3592	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3592	26	fences	fence	NNS
8691	3592	27	.	.	.
8691	3593	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3593	2	,	,	,
8691	3593	3	too	too	RB
8691	3593	4	,	,	,
8691	3593	5	have	have	VBP
8691	3593	6	assumed	assume	VBN
8691	3593	7	a	a	DT
8691	3593	8	reticence	reticence	NN
8691	3593	9	in	in	IN
8691	3593	10	regard	regard	NN
8691	3593	11	to	to	IN
8691	3593	12	the	the	DT
8691	3593	13	matter	matter	NN
8691	3593	14	of	of	IN
8691	3593	15	the	the	DT
8691	3593	16	judgeship	judgeship	NN
8691	3593	17	.	.	.
8691	3594	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3594	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3594	3	expected	expect	VBN
8691	3594	4	that	that	IN
8691	3594	5	on	on	IN
8691	3594	6	the	the	DT
8691	3594	7	last	last	JJ
8691	3594	8	lap	lap	NN
8691	3594	9	of	of	IN
8691	3594	10	the	the	DT
8691	3594	11	race	race	NN
8691	3594	12	Williams	Williams	NNP
8691	3594	13	and	and	CC
8691	3594	14	Miller	Miller	NNP
8691	3594	15	will	will	MD
8691	3594	16	be	be	VB
8691	3594	17	the	the	DT
8691	3594	18	only	only	JJ
8691	3594	19	two	two	CD
8691	3594	20	men	man	NNS
8691	3594	21	remaining	remain	VBG
8691	3594	22	.	.	.
8691	3595	1	There	there	EX
8691	3595	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3595	3	three	three	CD
8691	3595	4	other	other	JJ
8691	3595	5	candidates	candidate	NNS
8691	3595	6	for	for	IN
8691	3595	7	the	the	DT
8691	3595	8	Republican	republican	JJ
8691	3595	9	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3595	10	who	who	WP
8691	3595	11	have	have	VBP
8691	3595	12	thus	thus	RB
8691	3595	13	far	far	RB
8691	3595	14	announced	announce	VBN
8691	3595	15	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3595	16	.	.	.
8691	3596	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3596	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3596	3	:	:	:
8691	3596	4	W.	W.	NNP
8691	3596	5	J.	J.	NNP
8691	3596	6	Whieldon	Whieldon	NNP
8691	3596	7	of	of	IN
8691	3596	8	Mercer	Mercer	NNP
8691	3596	9	;	;	:
8691	3596	10	W.	W.	NNP
8691	3596	11	W.	W.	NNP
8691	3596	12	Moore	Moore	NNP
8691	3596	13	of	of	IN
8691	3596	14	Mercer	Mercer	NNP
8691	3596	15	,	,	,
8691	3596	16	and	and	CC
8691	3596	17	L.	L.	NNP
8691	3596	18	L.	L.	NNP
8691	3596	19	Kuder	Kuder	NNP
8691	3596	20	,	,	,
8691	3596	21	burgess	burgess	NN
8691	3596	22	of	of	IN
8691	3596	23	Greenville	Greenville	NNP
8691	3596	24	.	.	.
8691	3597	1	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3597	2	Miller	Miller	NNP
8691	3597	3	and	and	CC
8691	3597	4	A.	A.	NNP
8691	3597	5	W.	W.	NNP
8691	3597	6	Williams	Williams	NNP
8691	3597	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3597	8	the	the	DT
8691	3597	9	closest	close	JJS
8691	3597	10	of	of	IN
8691	3597	11	friends	friend	NNS
8691	3597	12	.	.	.
8691	3598	1	JUDGE	JUDGE	NNP
8691	3598	2	MILLER	MILLER	NNP
8691	3598	3	ASKS	asks	VBP
8691	3598	4	FOR	for	IN
8691	3598	5	MODERATION	MODERATION	NNP
8691	3598	6	.	.	.
8691	3599	1	BARS	bar	NNS
8691	3599	2	PURE	pure	VBP
8691	3599	3	FOOD	food	NN
8691	3599	4	PROSECUTIONS	prosecutions	NN
8691	3599	5	BY	by	RB
8691	3599	6	REFUSING	refuse	VBG
8691	3599	7	TO	to	IN
8691	3599	8	SENTENCE	sentence	VB
8691	3599	9	THOSE	those	DT
8691	3599	10	CONVICTED	convict	VBN
8691	3599	11	.	.	.
8691	3600	1	Harrisburg	Harrisburg	NNP
8691	3600	2	,	,	,
8691	3600	3	Pa.	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3600	4	,	,	,
8691	3600	5	Dec.	December	NNP
8691	3601	1	25.--State	25.--state	CD
8691	3601	2	Dairy	Dairy	NNP
8691	3601	3	and	and	CC
8691	3601	4	Food	Food	NNP
8691	3601	5	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
8691	3601	6	Warren	Warren	NNP
8691	3601	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	3601	8	been	be	VBN
8691	3601	9	confronted	confront	VBN
8691	3601	10	with	with	IN
8691	3601	11	a	a	DT
8691	3601	12	new	new	JJ
8691	3601	13	proposition	proposition	NN
8691	3601	14	in	in	IN
8691	3601	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3601	16	crusade	crusade	NN
8691	3601	17	in	in	IN
8691	3601	18	Western	Western	NNP
8691	3601	19	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3601	20	against	against	IN
8691	3601	21	violators	violator	NNS
8691	3601	22	of	of	IN
8691	3601	23	the	the	DT
8691	3601	24	pure	pure	JJ
8691	3601	25	food	food	NN
8691	3601	26	laws	law	NNS
8691	3601	27	.	.	.
8691	3602	1	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3602	2	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3602	3	H.	H.	NNP
8691	3602	4	Miller	Miller	NNP
8691	3602	5	of	of	IN
8691	3602	6	Mercer	Mercer	NNP
8691	3602	7	County	County	NNP
8691	3602	8	,	,	,
8691	3602	9	before	before	IN
8691	3602	10	whom	whom	WP
8691	3602	11	several	several	JJ
8691	3602	12	oleomargarine	oleomargarine	NN
8691	3602	13	dealers	dealer	NNS
8691	3602	14	were	be	VBD
8691	3602	15	recently	recently	RB
8691	3602	16	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	3602	17	for	for	IN
8691	3602	18	the	the	DT
8691	3602	19	illegal	illegal	JJ
8691	3602	20	sale	sale	NN
8691	3602	21	of	of	IN
8691	3602	22	"	"	``
8691	3602	23	oleo	oleo	NNS
8691	3602	24	,	,	,
8691	3602	25	"	"	''
8691	3602	26	has	have	VBZ
8691	3602	27	refused	refuse	VBN
8691	3602	28	to	to	TO
8691	3602	29	sentence	sentence	VB
8691	3602	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3602	31	on	on	IN
8691	3602	32	the	the	DT
8691	3602	33	ground	ground	NN
8691	3602	34	that	that	IN
8691	3602	35	the	the	DT
8691	3602	36	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	3602	37	of	of	IN
8691	3602	38	the	the	DT
8691	3602	39	State	State	NNP
8691	3602	40	Pure	Pure	NNP
8691	3602	41	Food	Food	NNP
8691	3602	42	Bureau	Bureau	NNP
8691	3602	43	is	be	VBZ
8691	3602	44	persecution	persecution	NN
8691	3602	45	and	and	CC
8691	3602	46	lacking	lack	VBG
8691	3602	47	in	in	IN
8691	3602	48	equity	equity	NN
8691	3602	49	.	.	.
8691	3603	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3603	2	takes	take	VBZ
8691	3603	3	the	the	DT
8691	3603	4	position	position	NN
8691	3603	5	that	that	IN
8691	3603	6	grocers	grocer	NNS
8691	3603	7	and	and	CC
8691	3603	8	saloon	saloon	NN
8691	3603	9	keepers	keeper	NNS
8691	3603	10	,	,	,
8691	3603	11	not	not	RB
8691	3603	12	being	be	VBG
8691	3603	13	expert	expert	JJ
8691	3603	14	chemists	chemist	NNS
8691	3603	15	,	,	,
8691	3603	16	should	should	MD
8691	3603	17	at	at	IN
8691	3603	18	least	least	JJS
8691	3603	19	be	be	VB
8691	3603	20	warned	warn	VBN
8691	3603	21	previous	previous	JJ
8691	3603	22	to	to	TO
8691	3603	23	arrest	arrest	VB
8691	3603	24	,	,	,
8691	3603	25	and	and	CC
8691	3603	26	be	be	VB
8691	3603	27	given	give	VBN
8691	3603	28	a	a	DT
8691	3603	29	chance	chance	NN
8691	3603	30	to	to	TO
8691	3603	31	determine	determine	VB
8691	3603	32	whether	whether	IN
8691	3603	33	the	the	DT
8691	3603	34	foods	food	NNS
8691	3603	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3603	36	are	be	VBP
8691	3603	37	handling	handle	VBG
8691	3603	38	are	be	VBP
8691	3603	39	pure	pure	JJ
8691	3603	40	or	or	CC
8691	3603	41	adulterated	adulterated	JJ
8691	3603	42	.	.	.
8691	3604	1	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3604	2	Miller	Miller	NNP
8691	3604	3	's	's	POS
8691	3604	4	position	position	NN
8691	3604	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3604	6	a	a	DT
8691	3604	7	serious	serious	JJ
8691	3604	8	impediment	impediment	NN
8691	3604	9	in	in	IN
8691	3604	10	the	the	DT
8691	3604	11	way	way	NN
8691	3604	12	of	of	IN
8691	3604	13	the	the	DT
8691	3604	14	enforcement	enforcement	NN
8691	3604	15	of	of	IN
8691	3604	16	the	the	DT
8691	3604	17	law	law	NN
8691	3604	18	,	,	,
8691	3604	19	and	and	CC
8691	3604	20	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
8691	3604	21	Warren	Warren	NNP
8691	3604	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	3604	23	preparing	prepare	VBG
8691	3604	24	to	to	TO
8691	3604	25	take	take	VB
8691	3604	26	action	action	NN
8691	3604	27	that	that	WDT
8691	3604	28	may	may	MD
8691	3604	29	compel	compel	VB
8691	3604	30	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3604	31	to	to	TO
8691	3604	32	punish	punish	VB
8691	3604	33	offenders	offender	NNS
8691	3604	34	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	3604	35	before	before	IN
8691	3604	36	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3604	37	.	.	.
8691	3605	1	Not	not	RB
8691	3605	2	infrequently	infrequently	RB
8691	3605	3	in	in	IN
8691	3605	4	the	the	DT
8691	3605	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3605	6	history	history	NN
8691	3605	7	of	of	IN
8691	3605	8	the	the	DT
8691	3605	9	United	United	NNP
8691	3605	10	States	States	NNP
8691	3605	11	there	there	EX
8691	3605	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	3605	13	been	be	VBN
8691	3605	14	presented	present	VBN
8691	3605	15	to	to	IN
8691	3605	16	a	a	DT
8691	3605	17	judge	judge	NN
8691	3605	18	the	the	DT
8691	3605	19	choice	choice	NN
8691	3605	20	between	between	IN
8691	3605	21	rendering	render	VBG
8691	3605	22	a	a	DT
8691	3605	23	decision	decision	NN
8691	3605	24	according	accord	VBG
8691	3605	25	to	to	IN
8691	3605	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3605	27	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3605	28	of	of	IN
8691	3605	29	the	the	DT
8691	3605	30	law	law	NN
8691	3605	31	and	and	CC
8691	3605	32	the	the	DT
8691	3605	33	facts	fact	NNS
8691	3605	34	and	and	CC
8691	3605	35	losing	lose	VBG
8691	3605	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3605	37	seat	seat	NN
8691	3605	38	,	,	,
8691	3605	39	and	and	CC
8691	3605	40	rendering	render	VBG
8691	3605	41	one	one	NN
8691	3605	42	according	accord	VBG
8691	3605	43	to	to	IN
8691	3605	44	public	public	JJ
8691	3605	45	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3605	46	,	,	,
8691	3605	47	or	or	CC
8691	3605	48	the	the	DT
8691	3605	49	public	public	JJ
8691	3605	50	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3605	51	of	of	IN
8691	3605	52	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3605	53	party	party	NN
8691	3605	54	friends	friend	NNS
8691	3605	55	,	,	,
8691	3605	56	and	and	CC
8691	3605	57	keeping	keep	VBG
8691	3605	58	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3605	59	.	.	.
8691	3606	1	A	a	DT
8691	3606	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	3606	3	of	of	IN
8691	3606	4	the	the	DT
8691	3606	5	High	High	NNP
8691	3606	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3606	7	of	of	IN
8691	3606	8	Errors	Errors	NNPS
8691	3606	9	and	and	CC
8691	3606	10	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	3606	11	in	in	IN
8691	3606	12	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	3606	13	was	be	VBD
8691	3606	14	one	one	CD
8691	3606	15	of	of	IN
8691	3606	16	the	the	DT
8691	3606	17	earlier	early	JJR
8691	3606	18	martyrs	martyr	NNS
8691	3606	19	in	in	IN
8691	3606	20	the	the	DT
8691	3606	21	cause	cause	NN
8691	3606	22	of	of	IN
8691	3606	23	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3606	24	independence	independence	NN
8691	3606	25	.	.	.
8691	3607	1	The	the	DT
8691	3607	2	State	State	NNP
8691	3607	3	had	have	VBD
8691	3607	4	incurred	incur	VBN
8691	3607	5	a	a	DT
8691	3607	6	heavy	heavy	JJ
8691	3607	7	bonded	bond	VBN
8691	3607	8	debt	debt	NN
8691	3607	9	,	,	,
8691	3607	10	which	which	WDT
8691	3607	11	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3607	12	found	find	VBD
8691	3607	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3607	14	inconvenient	inconvenient	JJ
8691	3607	15	to	to	TO
8691	3607	16	pay	pay	VB
8691	3607	17	.	.	.
8691	3608	1	The	the	DT
8691	3608	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3608	3	,	,	,
8691	3608	4	who	who	WP
8691	3608	5	had	have	VBD
8691	3608	6	approved	approve	VBN
8691	3608	7	the	the	DT
8691	3608	8	bills	bill	NNS
8691	3608	9	under	under	IN
8691	3608	10	which	which	WDT
8691	3608	11	over	over	IN
8691	3608	12	$	$	$
8691	3608	13	15,000,000	15,000,000	CD
8691	3608	14	of	of	IN
8691	3608	15	the	the	DT
8691	3608	16	bonds	bond	NNS
8691	3608	17	had	have	VBD
8691	3608	18	been	be	VBN
8691	3608	19	issued	issue	VBN
8691	3608	20	,	,	,
8691	3608	21	concluded	conclude	VBN
8691	3608	22	in	in	IN
8691	3608	23	1841	1841	CD
8691	3608	24	,	,	,
8691	3608	25	after	after	IN
8691	3608	26	the	the	DT
8691	3608	27	issue	issue	NN
8691	3608	28	,	,	,
8691	3608	29	that	that	IN
8691	3608	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3608	31	was	be	VBD
8691	3608	32	forbidden	forbid	VBN
8691	3608	33	by	by	IN
8691	3608	34	the	the	DT
8691	3608	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3608	36	of	of	IN
8691	3608	37	the	the	DT
8691	3608	38	State	State	NNP
8691	3608	39	,	,	,
8691	3608	40	and	and	CC
8691	3608	41	issued	issue	VBD
8691	3608	42	a	a	DT
8691	3608	43	proclamation	proclamation	NN
8691	3608	44	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	3608	45	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3608	46	void	void	JJ
8691	3608	47	.	.	.
8691	3609	1	In	in	IN
8691	3609	2	a	a	DT
8691	3609	3	suit	suit	NN
8691	3609	4	in	in	IN
8691	3609	5	chancery	chancery	NN
8691	3609	6	this	this	DT
8691	3609	7	question	question	NN
8691	3609	8	came	come	VBD
8691	3609	9	up	up	RP
8691	3609	10	for	for	IN
8691	3609	11	decision	decision	NN
8691	3609	12	in	in	IN
8691	3609	13	1852	1852	CD
8691	3609	14	.	.	.
8691	3610	1	Meanwhile	meanwhile	RB
8691	3610	2	the	the	DT
8691	3610	3	policy	policy	NN
8691	3610	4	of	of	IN
8691	3610	5	"	"	``
8691	3610	6	Repudiation	Repudiation	NNP
8691	3610	7	"	"	''
8691	3610	8	had	have	VBD
8691	3610	9	been	be	VBN
8691	3610	10	made	make	VBN
8691	3610	11	a	a	DT
8691	3610	12	political	political	JJ
8691	3610	13	issue	issue	NN
8691	3610	14	and	and	CC
8691	3610	15	the	the	DT
8691	3610	16	people	people	NNS
8691	3610	17	had	have	VBD
8691	3610	18	given	give	VBN
8691	3610	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3610	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3610	21	approval	approval	NN
8691	3610	22	by	by	IN
8691	3610	23	electing	elect	VBG
8691	3610	24	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3610	25	advocates	advocate	NNS
8691	3610	26	year	year	NN
8691	3610	27	after	after	IN
8691	3610	28	year	year	NN
8691	3610	29	to	to	IN
8691	3610	30	the	the	DT
8691	3610	31	highest	high	JJS
8691	3610	32	offices	office	NNS
8691	3610	33	.	.	.
8691	3611	1	The	the	DT
8691	3611	2	chancellor	chancellor	NN
8691	3611	3	upheld	uphold	VBD
8691	3611	4	the	the	DT
8691	3611	5	validity	validity	NN
8691	3611	6	of	of	IN
8691	3611	7	the	the	DT
8691	3611	8	bonds	bond	NNS
8691	3611	9	,	,	,
8691	3611	10	and	and	CC
8691	3611	11	on	on	IN
8691	3611	12	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	3611	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3611	14	decision	decision	NN
8691	3611	15	was	be	VBD
8691	3611	16	unanimously	unanimously	RB
8691	3611	17	affirmed	affirm	VBN
8691	3611	18	.	.	.
8691	3612	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3612	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3612	3	:	:	:
8691	3612	4	State	State	NNP
8691	3612	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3612	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3612	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3612	8	Johnson	Johnson	NNP
8691	3612	9	,	,	,
8691	3612	10	25	25	CD
8691	3612	11	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	3612	12	Reports	Reports	NNP
8691	3612	13	,	,	,
8691	3612	14	625	625	CD
8691	3612	15	;	;	:
8691	3612	16	Memoir	Memoir	NNP
8691	3612	17	of	of	IN
8691	3612	18	Sergeant	Sergeant	NNP
8691	3612	19	S.	S.	NNP
8691	3612	20	Prentiss	Prentiss	NNP
8691	3612	21	,	,	,
8691	3612	22	II	II	NNP
8691	3612	23	,	,	,
8691	3612	24	268	268	CD
8691	3612	25	.	.	.
8691	3612	26	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3613	1	A	a	DT
8691	3613	2	few	few	JJ
8691	3613	3	months	month	NNS
8691	3613	4	later	later	RB
8691	3613	5	the	the	DT
8691	3613	6	term	term	NN
8691	3613	7	of	of	IN
8691	3613	8	office	office	NN
8691	3613	9	of	of	IN
8691	3613	10	one	one	CD
8691	3613	11	of	of	IN
8691	3613	12	the	the	DT
8691	3613	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3613	14	who	who	WP
8691	3613	15	had	have	VBD
8691	3613	16	concurred	concur	VBN
8691	3613	17	in	in	IN
8691	3613	18	this	this	DT
8691	3613	19	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3613	20	expired	expire	VBD
8691	3613	21	,	,	,
8691	3613	22	and	and	CC
8691	3613	23	the	the	DT
8691	3613	24	people	people	NNS
8691	3613	25	put	put	VBD
8691	3613	26	a	a	DT
8691	3613	27	successor	successor	NN
8691	3613	28	in	in	IN
8691	3613	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3613	30	place	place	NN
8691	3613	31	who	who	WP
8691	3613	32	held	hold	VBD
8691	3613	33	doctrines	doctrine	NNS
8691	3613	34	better	better	RB
8691	3613	35	suited	suit	VBN
8691	3613	36	to	to	IN
8691	3613	37	the	the	DT
8691	3613	38	public	public	JJ
8691	3613	39	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	3613	40	of	of	IN
8691	3613	41	the	the	DT
8691	3613	42	hour	hour	NN
8691	3613	43	.	.	.
8691	3614	1	In	in	IN
8691	3614	2	the	the	DT
8691	3614	3	days	day	NNS
8691	3614	4	preceding	precede	VBG
8691	3614	5	the	the	DT
8691	3614	6	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	3614	7	War	War	NNP
8691	3614	8	,	,	,
8691	3614	9	the	the	DT
8691	3614	10	validity	validity	NN
8691	3614	11	of	of	IN
8691	3614	12	the	the	DT
8691	3614	13	laws	law	NNS
8691	3614	14	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	3614	15	by	by	IN
8691	3614	16	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3614	17	to	to	TO
8691	3614	18	secure	secure	VB
8691	3614	19	the	the	DT
8691	3614	20	recapture	recapture	NN
8691	3614	21	of	of	IN
8691	3614	22	slaves	slave	NNS
8691	3614	23	who	who	WP
8691	3614	24	had	have	VBD
8691	3614	25	fled	flee	VBN
8691	3614	26	to	to	IN
8691	3614	27	the	the	DT
8691	3614	28	free	free	JJ
8691	3614	29	States	States	NNP
8691	3614	30	was	be	VBD
8691	3614	31	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	3614	32	attacked	attack	VBN
8691	3614	33	in	in	IN
8691	3614	34	the	the	DT
8691	3614	35	press	press	NN
8691	3614	36	and	and	CC
8691	3614	37	on	on	IN
8691	3614	38	the	the	DT
8691	3614	39	platform	platform	NN
8691	3614	40	.	.	.
8691	3615	1	The	the	DT
8691	3615	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3615	3	expressly	expressly	RB
8691	3615	4	provided	provide	VBN
8691	3615	5	for	for	IN
8691	3615	6	such	such	JJ
8691	3615	7	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3615	8	,	,	,
8691	3615	9	and	and	CC
8691	3615	10	the	the	DT
8691	3615	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3615	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3615	13	of	of	IN
8691	3615	14	the	the	DT
8691	3615	15	United	United	NNP
8691	3615	16	States	States	NNP
8691	3615	17	in	in	IN
8691	3615	18	1842	1842	CD
8691	3615	19	had	have	VBD
8691	3615	20	pronounced	pronounce	VBN
8691	3615	21	the	the	DT
8691	3615	22	"	"	``
8691	3615	23	Fugitive	Fugitive	NNP
8691	3615	24	Slave	Slave	NNP
8691	3615	25	law	law	NN
8691	3615	26	"	"	''
8691	3615	27	of	of	IN
8691	3615	28	1793	1793	CD
8691	3615	29	to	to	TO
8691	3615	30	be	be	VB
8691	3615	31	valid	valid	JJ
8691	3615	32	in	in	IN
8691	3615	33	all	all	DT
8691	3615	34	respects	respect	NNS
8691	3615	35	.	.	.
8691	3616	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3616	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3616	3	:	:	:
8691	3616	4	Prigg	Prigg	NNP
8691	3616	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3616	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3616	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3616	8	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3616	9	,	,	,
8691	3616	10	16	16	CD
8691	3616	11	Peters	Peters	NNP
8691	3616	12	'	'	POS
8691	3616	13	Reports	report	NNS
8691	3616	14	,	,	,
8691	3616	15	539	539	CD
8691	3616	16	.	.	.
8691	3616	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3617	1	The	the	DT
8691	3617	2	principle	principle	NN
8691	3617	3	of	of	IN
8691	3617	4	this	this	DT
8691	3617	5	decision	decision	NN
8691	3617	6	plainly	plainly	RB
8691	3617	7	covered	cover	VBD
8691	3617	8	the	the	DT
8691	3617	9	later	later	JJ
8691	3617	10	Act	Act	NNP
8691	3617	11	of	of	IN
8691	3617	12	1850	1850	CD
8691	3617	13	,	,	,
8691	3617	14	but	but	CC
8691	3617	15	as	as	IN
8691	3617	16	public	public	JJ
8691	3617	17	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	3617	18	in	in	IN
8691	3617	19	the	the	DT
8691	3617	20	North	North	NNP
8691	3617	21	became	become	VBD
8691	3617	22	more	more	RBR
8691	3617	23	and	and	CC
8691	3617	24	more	more	RBR
8691	3617	25	uncompromising	uncompromising	JJ
8691	3617	26	in	in	IN
8691	3617	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3617	28	hostility	hostility	NN
8691	3617	29	to	to	IN
8691	3617	30	the	the	DT
8691	3617	31	existence	existence	NN
8691	3617	32	of	of	IN
8691	3617	33	slavery	slavery	NN
8691	3617	34	under	under	IN
8691	3617	35	the	the	DT
8691	3617	36	flag	flag	NN
8691	3617	37	of	of	IN
8691	3617	38	the	the	DT
8691	3617	39	United	United	NNP
8691	3617	40	States	States	NNP
8691	3617	41	,	,	,
8691	3617	42	the	the	DT
8691	3617	43	State	State	NNP
8691	3617	44	courts	court	NNS
8691	3617	45	were	be	VBD
8691	3617	46	not	not	RB
8691	3617	47	always	always	RB
8691	3617	48	strong	strong	JJ
8691	3617	49	enough	enough	RB
8691	3617	50	to	to	TO
8691	3617	51	withstand	withstand	VB
8691	3617	52	the	the	DT
8691	3617	53	pressure	pressure	NN
8691	3617	54	to	to	TO
8691	3617	55	disregard	disregard	VB
8691	3617	56	precedents	precedent	NNS
8691	3617	57	and	and	CC
8691	3617	58	let	let	VB
8691	3617	59	the	the	DT
8691	3617	60	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3617	61	give	give	VB
8691	3617	62	place	place	NN
8691	3617	63	to	to	IN
8691	3617	64	what	what	WP
8691	3617	65	the	the	DT
8691	3617	66	phrase	phrase	NN
8691	3617	67	of	of	IN
8691	3617	68	the	the	DT
8691	3617	69	time	time	NN
8691	3617	70	called	call	VBN
8691	3617	71	a	a	DT
8691	3617	72	"	"	``
8691	3617	73	higher	high	JJR
8691	3617	74	law	law	NN
8691	3617	75	.	.	.
8691	3617	76	"	"	''
8691	3618	1	In	in	IN
8691	3618	2	1859	1859	CD
8691	3618	3	,	,	,
8691	3618	4	a	a	DT
8691	3618	5	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	3618	6	of	of	IN
8691	3618	7	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	3618	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3618	9	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	3618	10	in	in	IN
8691	3618	11	the	the	DT
8691	3618	12	District	District	NNP
8691	3618	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3618	14	of	of	IN
8691	3618	15	the	the	DT
8691	3618	16	United	United	NNP
8691	3618	17	States	States	NNP
8691	3618	18	and	and	CC
8691	3618	19	sentenced	sentence	VBN
8691	3618	20	to	to	IN
8691	3618	21	jail	jail	NN
8691	3618	22	for	for	IN
8691	3618	23	rescuing	rescue	VBG
8691	3618	24	a	a	DT
8691	3618	25	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
8691	3618	26	slave	slave	NN
8691	3618	27	who	who	WP
8691	3618	28	had	have	VBD
8691	3618	29	been	be	VBN
8691	3618	30	recaptured	recapture	VBN
8691	3618	31	in	in	IN
8691	3618	32	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	3618	33	by	by	IN
8691	3618	34	an	an	DT
8691	3618	35	agent	agent	NN
8691	3618	36	of	of	IN
8691	3618	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3618	38	master	master	NN
8691	3618	39	,	,	,
8691	3618	40	to	to	IN
8691	3618	41	whom	whom	WP
8691	3618	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3618	43	had	have	VBD
8691	3618	44	been	be	VBN
8691	3618	45	committed	commit	VBN
8691	3618	46	in	in	IN
8691	3618	47	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3618	48	under	under	IN
8691	3618	49	the	the	DT
8691	3618	50	Act	Act	NNP
8691	3618	51	of	of	IN
8691	3618	52	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3618	53	.	.	.
8691	3619	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3619	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3619	3	imprisoned	imprison	VBN
8691	3619	4	in	in	IN
8691	3619	5	an	an	DT
8691	3619	6	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	3619	7	jail	jail	NN
8691	3619	8	,	,	,
8691	3619	9	the	the	DT
8691	3619	10	United	United	NNP
8691	3619	11	States	States	NNP
8691	3619	12	then	then	RB
8691	3619	13	having	have	VBG
8691	3619	14	none	none	NN
8691	3619	15	of	of	IN
8691	3619	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3619	17	own	own	JJ
8691	3619	18	,	,	,
8691	3619	19	but	but	CC
8691	3619	20	placing	place	VBG
8691	3619	21	all	all	PDT
8691	3619	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3619	23	convicts	convict	NNS
8691	3619	24	in	in	IN
8691	3619	25	State	state	NN
8691	3619	26	jails	jail	NNS
8691	3619	27	or	or	CC
8691	3619	28	prisons	prison	NNS
8691	3619	29	under	under	IN
8691	3619	30	a	a	DT
8691	3619	31	contract	contract	NN
8691	3619	32	with	with	IN
8691	3619	33	the	the	DT
8691	3619	34	State	State	NNP
8691	3619	35	to	to	TO
8691	3619	36	keep	keep	VB
8691	3619	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3619	38	for	for	IN
8691	3619	39	a	a	DT
8691	3619	40	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3619	41	price	price	NN
8691	3619	42	.	.	.
8691	3620	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3620	2	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	3620	3	applied	apply	VBD
8691	3620	4	to	to	IN
8691	3620	5	the	the	DT
8691	3620	6	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3620	7	of	of	IN
8691	3620	8	the	the	DT
8691	3620	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3620	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3620	11	at	at	IN
8691	3620	12	chambers	chamber	NNS
8691	3620	13	for	for	IN
8691	3620	14	a	a	DT
8691	3620	15	writ	writ	NN
8691	3620	16	of	of	IN
8691	3620	17	_	_	NNP
8691	3620	18	habeas	habeas	NNP
8691	3620	19	corpus	corpus	NNP
8691	3620	20	_	_	NNP
8691	3620	21	against	against	IN
8691	3620	22	the	the	DT
8691	3620	23	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	3620	24	jailer	jailer	NN
8691	3620	25	.	.	.
8691	3621	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3621	2	produced	produce	VBD
8691	3621	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3621	4	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	3621	5	and	and	CC
8691	3621	6	submitted	submit	VBD
8691	3621	7	a	a	DT
8691	3621	8	copy	copy	NN
8691	3621	9	of	of	IN
8691	3621	10	the	the	DT
8691	3621	11	warrant	warrant	NN
8691	3621	12	of	of	IN
8691	3621	13	commitment	commitment	NN
8691	3621	14	from	from	IN
8691	3621	15	the	the	DT
8691	3621	16	District	District	NNP
8691	3621	17	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3621	18	.	.	.
8691	3622	1	The	the	DT
8691	3622	2	public	public	NN
8691	3622	3	were	be	VBD
8691	3622	4	extremely	extremely	RB
8691	3622	5	interested	interested	JJ
8691	3622	6	in	in	IN
8691	3622	7	the	the	DT
8691	3622	8	outcome	outcome	NN
8691	3622	9	of	of	IN
8691	3622	10	the	the	DT
8691	3622	11	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3622	12	.	.	.
8691	3623	1	The	the	DT
8691	3623	2	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
8691	3623	3	-	-	HYPH
8691	3623	4	General	General	NNP
8691	3623	5	of	of	IN
8691	3623	6	the	the	DT
8691	3623	7	State	State	NNP
8691	3623	8	assisted	assist	VBN
8691	3623	9	in	in	IN
8691	3623	10	presenting	present	VBG
8691	3623	11	the	the	DT
8691	3623	12	petitioner	petitioner	NN
8691	3623	13	's	's	POS
8691	3623	14	case	case	NN
8691	3623	15	.	.	.
8691	3624	1	The	the	DT
8691	3624	2	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3624	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3624	4	one	one	CD
8691	3624	5	of	of	IN
8691	3624	6	the	the	DT
8691	3624	7	multitude	multitude	NNP
8691	3624	8	present	present	NN
8691	3624	9	in	in	IN
8691	3624	10	the	the	DT
8691	3624	11	crowded	crowded	JJ
8691	3624	12	court	court	NN
8691	3624	13	room	room	NN
8691	3624	14	.	.	.
8691	3625	1	The	the	DT
8691	3625	2	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
8691	3625	3	-	-	HYPH
8691	3625	4	General	General	NNP
8691	3625	5	declared	declare	VBD
8691	3625	6	that	that	IN
8691	3625	7	the	the	DT
8691	3625	8	position	position	NN
8691	3625	9	that	that	WDT
8691	3625	10	the	the	DT
8691	3625	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3625	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3625	13	of	of	IN
8691	3625	14	the	the	DT
8691	3625	15	United	United	NNP
8691	3625	16	States	States	NNP
8691	3625	17	had	have	VBD
8691	3625	18	the	the	DT
8691	3625	19	power	power	NN
8691	3625	20	to	to	TO
8691	3625	21	decide	decide	VB
8691	3625	22	conclusively	conclusively	RB
8691	3625	23	as	as	IN
8691	3625	24	to	to	IN
8691	3625	25	the	the	DT
8691	3625	26	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	3625	27	of	of	IN
8691	3625	28	the	the	DT
8691	3625	29	laws	law	NNS
8691	3625	30	of	of	IN
8691	3625	31	the	the	DT
8691	3625	32	United	United	NNP
8691	3625	33	States	States	NNP
8691	3625	34	and	and	CC
8691	3625	35	so	so	RB
8691	3625	36	tie	tie	VB
8691	3625	37	the	the	DT
8691	3625	38	hands	hand	NNS
8691	3625	39	of	of	IN
8691	3625	40	the	the	DT
8691	3625	41	State	State	NNP
8691	3625	42	authority	authority	NN
8691	3625	43	was	be	VBD
8691	3625	44	untenable	untenable	JJ
8691	3625	45	and	and	CC
8691	3625	46	monstrous	monstrous	JJ
8691	3625	47	.	.	.
8691	3626	1	"	"	``
8691	3626	2	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	3626	3	,	,	,
8691	3626	4	"	"	''
8691	3626	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3626	6	said	say	VBD
8691	3626	7	,	,	,
8691	3626	8	"	"	``
8691	3626	9	hung	hang	VBD
8691	3626	10	Graves	Graves	NNP
8691	3626	11	and	and	CC
8691	3626	12	Tassel	Tassel	NNP
8691	3626	13	over	over	IN
8691	3626	14	the	the	DT
8691	3626	15	writ	writ	NN
8691	3626	16	of	of	IN
8691	3626	17	error	error	NN
8691	3626	18	of	of	IN
8691	3626	19	this	this	DT
8691	3626	20	same	same	JJ
8691	3626	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3626	22	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3626	23	.	.	.
8691	3627	1	God	God	NNP
8691	3627	2	bless	bless	VBP
8691	3627	3	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	3627	4	for	for	IN
8691	3627	5	that	that	DT
8691	3627	6	valiant	valiant	JJ
8691	3627	7	and	and	CC
8691	3627	8	beneficent	beneficent	JJ
8691	3627	9	example	example	NN
8691	3627	10	.	.	.
8691	3628	1	"	"	``
8691	3628	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3628	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3628	4	:	:	:
8691	3628	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3628	6	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	3628	7	parte	parte	NN
8691	3628	8	_	_	NNP
8691	3628	9	Bushnell	Bushnell	NNP
8691	3628	10	,	,	,
8691	3628	11	9	9	CD
8691	3628	12	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	3628	13	State	State	NNP
8691	3628	14	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3628	15	,	,	,
8691	3628	16	150	150	CD
8691	3628	17	.	.	.
8691	3628	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3629	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3629	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3629	3	,	,	,
8691	3629	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3629	5	continued	continue	VBD
8691	3629	6	,	,	,
8691	3629	7	"	"	''
8691	3629	8	a	a	DT
8691	3629	9	sectional	sectional	JJ
8691	3629	10	court	court	NN
8691	3629	11	composed	compose	VBN
8691	3629	12	of	of	IN
8691	3629	13	sectional	sectional	JJ
8691	3629	14	men	man	NNS
8691	3629	15	,	,	,
8691	3629	16	judging	judge	VBG
8691	3629	17	sectional	sectional	JJ
8691	3629	18	questions	question	NNS
8691	3629	19	upon	upon	IN
8691	3629	20	sectional	sectional	JJ
8691	3629	21	influences	influence	NNS
8691	3629	22	.	.	.
8691	3630	1	"	"	``
8691	3630	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3630	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3630	4	:	:	:
8691	3630	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3630	6	Ibid	Ibid	NNP
8691	3630	7	.	.	.
8691	3630	8	_	_	NNP
8691	3630	9	,	,	,
8691	3630	10	161	161	CD
8691	3630	11	.	.	.
8691	3630	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3631	1	Of	of	IN
8691	3631	2	the	the	DT
8691	3631	3	five	five	CD
8691	3631	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3631	5	,	,	,
8691	3631	6	three	three	CD
8691	3631	7	held	hold	VBD
8691	3631	8	that	that	IN
8691	3631	9	the	the	DT
8691	3631	10	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	3631	11	of	of	IN
8691	3631	12	the	the	DT
8691	3631	13	Fugitive	Fugitive	NNP
8691	3631	14	Slave	Slave	NNP
8691	3631	15	law	law	NN
8691	3631	16	was	be	VBD
8691	3631	17	settled	settle	VBN
8691	3631	18	conclusively	conclusively	RB
8691	3631	19	by	by	IN
8691	3631	20	repeated	repeat	VBN
8691	3631	21	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	3631	22	of	of	IN
8691	3631	23	the	the	DT
8691	3631	24	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3631	25	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3631	26	of	of	IN
8691	3631	27	the	the	DT
8691	3631	28	United	United	NNP
8691	3631	29	States	States	NNP
8691	3631	30	,	,	,
8691	3631	31	and	and	CC
8691	3631	32	that	that	IN
8691	3631	33	the	the	DT
8691	3631	34	State	State	NNP
8691	3631	35	courts	court	NNS
8691	3631	36	could	could	MD
8691	3631	37	not	not	RB
8691	3631	38	release	release	VB
8691	3631	39	the	the	DT
8691	3631	40	prisoner	prisoner	NN
8691	3631	41	.	.	.
8691	3632	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3632	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3632	3	Swan	Swan	NNP
8691	3632	4	gave	give	VBD
8691	3632	5	the	the	DT
8691	3632	6	leading	lead	VBG
8691	3632	7	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3632	8	.	.	.
8691	3633	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3633	2	positions	position	NNS
8691	3633	3	were	be	VBD
8691	3633	4	thoroughly	thoroughly	RB
8691	3633	5	distasteful	distasteful	JJ
8691	3633	6	to	to	IN
8691	3633	7	the	the	DT
8691	3633	8	people	people	NNS
8691	3633	9	of	of	IN
8691	3633	10	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	3633	11	.	.	.
8691	3634	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3634	2	knew	know	VBD
8691	3634	3	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3634	4	would	would	MD
8691	3634	5	be	be	VB
8691	3634	6	.	.	.
8691	3635	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3635	2	term	term	NN
8691	3635	3	,	,	,
8691	3635	4	which	which	WDT
8691	3635	5	was	be	VBD
8691	3635	6	one	one	CD
8691	3635	7	of	of	IN
8691	3635	8	five	five	CD
8691	3635	9	years	year	NNS
8691	3635	10	,	,	,
8691	3635	11	expired	expire	VBD
8691	3635	12	in	in	IN
8691	3635	13	the	the	DT
8691	3635	14	following	following	JJ
8691	3635	15	February	February	NNP
8691	3635	16	,	,	,
8691	3635	17	and	and	CC
8691	3635	18	the	the	DT
8691	3635	19	vacancy	vacancy	NN
8691	3635	20	was	be	VBD
8691	3635	21	to	to	TO
8691	3635	22	be	be	VB
8691	3635	23	filled	fill	VBN
8691	3635	24	at	at	IN
8691	3635	25	the	the	DT
8691	3635	26	State	State	NNP
8691	3635	27	election	election	NN
8691	3635	28	in	in	IN
8691	3635	29	October	October	NNP
8691	3635	30	.	.	.
8691	3636	1	On	on	IN
8691	3636	2	the	the	DT
8691	3636	3	day	day	NN
8691	3636	4	before	before	IN
8691	3636	5	the	the	DT
8691	3636	6	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	3636	7	was	be	VBD
8691	3636	8	announced	announce	VBN
8691	3636	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3636	10	told	tell	VBD
8691	3636	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3636	12	wife	wife	NN
8691	3636	13	that	that	IN
8691	3636	14	this	this	DT
8691	3636	15	would	would	MD
8691	3636	16	be	be	VB
8691	3636	17	fatal	fatal	JJ
8691	3636	18	to	to	IN
8691	3636	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3636	20	re	re	NN
8691	3636	21	-	-	NN
8691	3636	22	election	election	NN
8691	3636	23	.	.	.
8691	3637	1	"	"	``
8691	3637	2	If	if	IN
8691	3637	3	the	the	DT
8691	3637	4	law	law	NN
8691	3637	5	makes	make	VBZ
8691	3637	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3637	7	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3637	8	duty	duty	NN
8691	3637	9	to	to	TO
8691	3637	10	give	give	VB
8691	3637	11	such	such	PDT
8691	3637	12	an	an	DT
8691	3637	13	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3637	14	,	,	,
8691	3637	15	"	"	''
8691	3637	16	said	say	VBD
8691	3637	17	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3637	18	,	,	,
8691	3637	19	"	"	``
8691	3637	20	do	do	VB
8691	3637	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3637	22	,	,	,
8691	3637	23	whatever	whatever	WDT
8691	3637	24	happens	happen	VBZ
8691	3637	25	.	.	.
8691	3637	26	"	"	''
8691	3638	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3638	2	gave	give	VBD
8691	3638	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3638	4	,	,	,
8691	3638	5	and	and	CC
8691	3638	6	what	what	WP
8691	3638	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3638	8	anticipated	anticipate	VBD
8691	3638	9	occurred	occur	VBD
8691	3638	10	.	.	.
8691	3639	1	The	the	DT
8691	3639	2	convention	convention	NN
8691	3639	3	of	of	IN
8691	3639	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3639	5	party	party	NN
8691	3639	6	declined	decline	VBD
8691	3639	7	to	to	TO
8691	3639	8	renominate	renominate	VB
8691	3639	9	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3639	10	.	.	.
8691	3640	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3640	2	resigned	resign	VBD
8691	3640	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3640	4	office	office	NN
8691	3640	5	immediately	immediately	RB
8691	3640	6	after	after	IN
8691	3640	7	the	the	DT
8691	3640	8	election	election	NN
8691	3640	9	and	and	CC
8691	3640	10	retired	retire	VBN
8691	3640	11	to	to	IN
8691	3640	12	private	private	JJ
8691	3640	13	life	life	NN
8691	3640	14	at	at	IN
8691	3640	15	an	an	DT
8691	3640	16	age	age	NN
8691	3640	17	and	and	CC
8691	3640	18	under	under	IN
8691	3640	19	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	3640	20	which	which	WDT
8691	3640	21	made	make	VBD
8691	3640	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3640	23	impracticable	impracticable	JJ
8691	3640	24	for	for	IN
8691	3640	25	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3640	26	to	to	TO
8691	3640	27	re	re	VB
8691	3640	28	-	-	VB
8691	3640	29	enter	enter	VB
8691	3640	30	the	the	DT
8691	3640	31	bar	bar	NN
8691	3640	32	with	with	IN
8691	3640	33	success	success	NN
8691	3640	34	,	,	,
8691	3640	35	but	but	CC
8691	3640	36	with	with	IN
8691	3640	37	the	the	DT
8691	3640	38	consolation	consolation	NN
8691	3640	39	of	of	IN
8691	3640	40	knowing	know	VBG
8691	3640	41	that	that	IN
8691	3640	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3640	43	had	have	VBD
8691	3640	44	acted	act	VBN
8691	3640	45	right	right	RB
8691	3640	46	.	.	.
8691	3641	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3641	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3641	3	Day	Day	NNP
8691	3641	4	of	of	IN
8691	3641	5	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
8691	3641	6	,	,	,
8691	3641	7	one	one	CD
8691	3641	8	of	of	IN
8691	3641	9	the	the	DT
8691	3641	10	ablest	able	JJS
8691	3641	11	men	man	NNS
8691	3641	12	who	who	WP
8691	3641	13	ever	ever	RB
8691	3641	14	sat	sit	VBD
8691	3641	15	on	on	IN
8691	3641	16	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3641	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3641	18	bench	bench	NN
8691	3641	19	,	,	,
8691	3641	20	in	in	IN
8691	3641	21	the	the	DT
8691	3641	22	same	same	JJ
8691	3641	23	way	way	NN
8691	3641	24	lost	lose	VBD
8691	3641	25	a	a	DT
8691	3641	26	re	re	NN
8691	3641	27	-	-	NN
8691	3641	28	election	election	NN
8691	3641	29	by	by	IN
8691	3641	30	writing	write	VBG
8691	3641	31	an	an	DT
8691	3641	32	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3641	33	of	of	IN
8691	3641	34	the	the	DT
8691	3641	35	court	court	NN
8691	3641	36	,	,	,
8691	3641	37	which	which	WDT
8691	3641	38	announced	announce	VBD
8691	3641	39	a	a	DT
8691	3641	40	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	3641	41	that	that	WDT
8691	3641	42	was	be	VBD
8691	3641	43	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3641	44	but	but	CC
8691	3641	45	unpopular	unpopular	JJ
8691	3641	46	.	.	.
8691	3642	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3642	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3642	3	:	:	:
8691	3642	4	Koehler	Koehler	NNP
8691	3642	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3642	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3642	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3642	8	Hill	Hill	NNP
8691	3642	9	,	,	,
8691	3642	10	60	60	CD
8691	3642	11	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
8691	3642	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3642	13	,	,	,
8691	3642	14	543	543	CD
8691	3642	15	,	,	,
8691	3642	16	603	603	CD
8691	3642	17	.	.	.
8691	3642	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3643	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3643	2	term	term	NN
8691	3643	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3643	4	soon	soon	RB
8691	3643	5	to	to	TO
8691	3643	6	expire	expire	VB
8691	3643	7	.	.	.
8691	3644	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3644	2	,	,	,
8691	3644	3	too	too	RB
8691	3644	4	,	,	,
8691	3644	5	knew	know	VBD
8691	3644	6	that	that	IN
8691	3644	7	this	this	DT
8691	3644	8	decision	decision	NN
8691	3644	9	would	would	MD
8691	3644	10	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	3644	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3644	12	renomination	renomination	NN
8691	3644	13	,	,	,
8691	3644	14	and	and	CC
8691	3644	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3644	16	did	do	VBD
8691	3644	17	.	.	.
8691	3645	1	In	in	IN
8691	3645	2	1885	1885	CD
8691	3645	3	,	,	,
8691	3645	4	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3645	5	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3645	6	Cooley	Cooley	NNP
8691	3645	7	of	of	IN
8691	3645	8	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
8691	3645	9	,	,	,
8691	3645	10	one	one	CD
8691	3645	11	of	of	IN
8691	3645	12	the	the	DT
8691	3645	13	great	great	JJ
8691	3645	14	jurists	jurist	NNS
8691	3645	15	and	and	CC
8691	3645	16	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3645	17	of	of	IN
8691	3645	18	the	the	DT
8691	3645	19	country	country	NN
8691	3645	20	,	,	,
8691	3645	21	failed	fail	VBD
8691	3645	22	to	to	TO
8691	3645	23	secure	secure	VB
8691	3645	24	a	a	DT
8691	3645	25	re	re	NN
8691	3645	26	-	-	NN
8691	3645	27	election	election	NN
8691	3645	28	to	to	IN
8691	3645	29	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3645	30	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3645	31	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3645	32	,	,	,
8691	3645	33	which	which	WDT
8691	3645	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3645	35	had	have	VBD
8691	3645	36	adorned	adorn	VBN
8691	3645	37	for	for	IN
8691	3645	38	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3645	39	-	-	HYPH
8691	3645	40	one	one	CD
8691	3645	41	years	year	NNS
8691	3645	42	,	,	,
8691	3645	43	largely	largely	RB
8691	3645	44	on	on	IN
8691	3645	45	account	account	NN
8691	3645	46	of	of	IN
8691	3645	47	an	an	DT
8691	3645	48	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3645	49	which	which	WDT
8691	3645	50	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3645	51	had	have	VBD
8691	3645	52	written	write	VBN
8691	3645	53	supporting	support	VBG
8691	3645	54	a	a	DT
8691	3645	55	large	large	JJ
8691	3645	56	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	3645	57	against	against	IN
8691	3645	58	a	a	DT
8691	3645	59	Detroit	Detroit	NNP
8691	3645	60	newspaper	newspaper	NN
8691	3645	61	for	for	IN
8691	3645	62	libel	libel	NN
8691	3645	63	.	.	.
8691	3646	1	The	the	DT
8691	3646	2	newspaper	newspaper	NN
8691	3646	3	,	,	,
8691	3646	4	upon	upon	IN
8691	3646	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3646	6	renomination	renomination	NN
8691	3646	7	,	,	,
8691	3646	8	described	describe	VBD
8691	3646	9	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3646	10	as	as	IN
8691	3646	11	a	a	DT
8691	3646	12	railroad	railroad	NN
8691	3646	13	judge	judge	NN
8691	3646	14	,	,	,
8691	3646	15	and	and	CC
8691	3646	16	kept	keep	VBD
8691	3646	17	up	up	RP
8691	3646	18	a	a	DT
8691	3646	19	running	run	VBG
8691	3646	20	fire	fire	NN
8691	3646	21	through	through	IN
8691	3646	22	the	the	DT
8691	3646	23	campaign	campaign	NN
8691	3646	24	,	,	,
8691	3646	25	which	which	WDT
8691	3646	26	contributed	contribute	VBD
8691	3646	27	materially	materially	RB
8691	3646	28	to	to	IN
8691	3646	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3646	30	defeat	defeat	NN
8691	3646	31	.	.	.
8691	3647	1	Political	political	JJ
8691	3647	2	contests	contest	NNS
8691	3647	3	cost	cost	VBP
8691	3647	4	money	money	NN
8691	3647	5	,	,	,
8691	3647	6	and	and	CC
8691	3647	7	if	if	IN
8691	3647	8	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3647	9	appear	appear	VBP
8691	3647	10	as	as	IN
8691	3647	11	candidates	candidate	NNS
8691	3647	12	for	for	IN
8691	3647	13	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3647	14	suffrage	suffrage	NN
8691	3647	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3647	16	are	be	VBP
8691	3647	17	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	3647	18	expected	expect	VBN
8691	3647	19	to	to	TO
8691	3647	20	contribute	contribute	VB
8691	3647	21	to	to	IN
8691	3647	22	the	the	DT
8691	3647	23	expense	expense	NN
8691	3647	24	.	.	.
8691	3648	1	The	the	DT
8691	3648	2	other	other	JJ
8691	3648	3	candidates	candidate	NNS
8691	3648	4	on	on	IN
8691	3648	5	the	the	DT
8691	3648	6	same	same	JJ
8691	3648	7	ticket	ticket	NN
8691	3648	8	do	do	VB
8691	3648	9	this	this	DT
8691	3648	10	,	,	,
8691	3648	11	and	and	CC
8691	3648	12	if	if	IN
8691	3648	13	those	those	DT
8691	3648	14	nominated	nominate	VBN
8691	3648	15	for	for	IN
8691	3648	16	the	the	DT
8691	3648	17	bench	bench	NN
8691	3648	18	did	do	VBD
8691	3648	19	not	not	RB
8691	3648	20	,	,	,
8691	3648	21	somebody	somebody	NN
8691	3648	22	would	would	MD
8691	3648	23	have	have	VB
8691	3648	24	to	to	TO
8691	3648	25	do	do	VB
8691	3648	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3648	27	for	for	IN
8691	3648	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3648	29	,	,	,
8691	3648	30	thus	thus	RB
8691	3648	31	bringing	bring	VBG
8691	3648	32	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3648	33	under	under	IN
8691	3648	34	obligations	obligation	NNS
8691	3648	35	that	that	WDT
8691	3648	36	might	may	MD
8691	3648	37	have	have	VB
8691	3648	38	an	an	DT
8691	3648	39	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
8691	3648	40	appearance	appearance	NN
8691	3648	41	,	,	,
8691	3648	42	if	if	IN
8691	3648	43	not	not	RB
8691	3648	44	an	an	DT
8691	3648	45	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
8691	3648	46	effect	effect	NN
8691	3648	47	.	.	.
8691	3649	1	In	in	IN
8691	3649	2	New	New	NNP
8691	3649	3	York	York	NNP
8691	3649	4	,	,	,
8691	3649	5	where	where	WRB
8691	3649	6	some	some	DT
8691	3649	7	of	of	IN
8691	3649	8	the	the	DT
8691	3649	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3649	10	salaries	salary	NNS
8691	3649	11	are	be	VBP
8691	3649	12	higher	high	JJR
8691	3649	13	than	than	IN
8691	3649	14	anywhere	anywhere	RB
8691	3649	15	else	else	RB
8691	3649	16	in	in	IN
8691	3649	17	the	the	DT
8691	3649	18	country	country	NN
8691	3649	19	,	,	,
8691	3649	20	and	and	CC
8691	3649	21	the	the	DT
8691	3649	22	terms	term	NNS
8691	3649	23	for	for	IN
8691	3649	24	the	the	DT
8691	3649	25	highest	high	JJS
8691	3649	26	places	place	NNS
8691	3649	27	are	be	VBP
8691	3649	28	long	long	JJ
8691	3649	29	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3649	30	fourteen	fourteen	CD
8691	3649	31	years	year	NNS
8691	3649	32	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3649	33	,	,	,
8691	3649	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3649	35	has	have	VBZ
8691	3649	36	been	be	VBN
8691	3649	37	customary	customary	JJ
8691	3649	38	for	for	IN
8691	3649	39	those	those	DT
8691	3649	40	placed	place	VBN
8691	3649	41	in	in	IN
8691	3649	42	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3649	43	to	to	TO
8691	3649	44	contribute	contribute	VB
8691	3649	45	a	a	DT
8691	3649	46	large	large	JJ
8691	3649	47	sum	sum	NN
8691	3649	48	to	to	IN
8691	3649	49	the	the	DT
8691	3649	50	campaign	campaign	NN
8691	3649	51	expenses	expense	NNS
8691	3649	52	of	of	IN
8691	3649	53	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3649	54	party	party	NN
8691	3649	55	.	.	.
8691	3650	1	This	this	DT
8691	3650	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3650	3	tacitly	tacitly	RB
8691	3650	4	understood	understand	VBN
8691	3650	5	to	to	TO
8691	3650	6	be	be	VB
8691	3650	7	a	a	DT
8691	3650	8	condition	condition	NN
8691	3650	9	of	of	IN
8691	3650	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3650	11	accepting	accept	VBG
8691	3650	12	the	the	DT
8691	3650	13	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3650	14	,	,	,
8691	3650	15	and	and	CC
8691	3650	16	the	the	DT
8691	3650	17	amount	amount	NN
8691	3650	18	to	to	TO
8691	3650	19	be	be	VB
8691	3650	20	paid	pay	VBN
8691	3650	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	3650	22	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	3650	23	by	by	IN
8691	3650	24	party	party	NN
8691	3650	25	practice	practice	NN
8691	3650	26	.	.	.
8691	3651	1	For	for	IN
8691	3651	2	an	an	DT
8691	3651	3	original	original	JJ
8691	3651	4	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3651	5	by	by	IN
8691	3651	6	the	the	DT
8691	3651	7	party	party	NN
8691	3651	8	in	in	IN
8691	3651	9	power	power	NN
8691	3651	10	,	,	,
8691	3651	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3651	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	3651	13	said	say	VBN
8691	3651	14	to	to	TO
8691	3651	15	be	be	VB
8691	3651	16	about	about	RB
8691	3651	17	equal	equal	JJ
8691	3651	18	to	to	IN
8691	3651	19	a	a	DT
8691	3651	20	year	year	NN
8691	3651	21	's	's	POS
8691	3651	22	salary	salary	NN
8691	3651	23	;	;	:
8691	3651	24	for	for	IN
8691	3651	25	a	a	DT
8691	3651	26	renomination	renomination	NN
8691	3651	27	half	half	NN
8691	3651	28	that	that	WDT
8691	3651	29	sum	sum	NN
8691	3651	30	may	may	MD
8691	3651	31	suffice	suffice	VB
8691	3651	32	.	.	.
8691	3652	1	But	but	CC
8691	3652	2	a	a	DT
8691	3652	3	judge	judge	NN
8691	3652	4	holding	hold	VBG
8691	3652	5	office	office	NN
8691	3652	6	by	by	IN
8691	3652	7	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3652	8	election	election	NN
8691	3652	9	must	must	MD
8691	3652	10	in	in	IN
8691	3652	11	any	any	DT
8691	3652	12	case	case	NN
8691	3652	13	owe	owe	VB
8691	3652	14	something	something	NN
8691	3652	15	to	to	IN
8691	3652	16	somebody	somebody	NN
8691	3652	17	for	for	IN
8691	3652	18	supporting	support	VBG
8691	3652	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3652	20	candidacy	candidacy	NN
8691	3652	21	.	.	.
8691	3653	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3653	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3653	3	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	3653	4	under	under	IN
8691	3653	5	a	a	DT
8691	3653	6	natural	natural	JJ
8691	3653	7	inclination	inclination	NN
8691	3653	8	to	to	TO
8691	3653	9	use	use	VB
8691	3653	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3653	11	power	power	NN
8691	3653	12	,	,	,
8691	3653	13	so	so	RB
8691	3653	14	far	far	RB
8691	3653	15	as	as	IN
8691	3653	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3653	17	properly	properly	RB
8691	3653	18	can	can	MD
8691	3653	19	,	,	,
8691	3653	20	in	in	IN
8691	3653	21	such	such	PDT
8691	3653	22	a	a	DT
8691	3653	23	way	way	NN
8691	3653	24	as	as	IN
8691	3653	25	to	to	TO
8691	3653	26	show	show	VB
8691	3653	27	that	that	IN
8691	3653	28	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3653	29	has	have	VBZ
8691	3653	30	not	not	RB
8691	3653	31	forgotten	forget	VBN
8691	3653	32	what	what	WP
8691	3653	33	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3653	34	friends	friend	NNS
8691	3653	35	have	have	VBP
8691	3653	36	done	do	VBN
8691	3653	37	for	for	IN
8691	3653	38	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3653	39	.	.	.
8691	3654	1	There	there	EX
8691	3654	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3654	3	always	always	RB
8691	3654	4	a	a	DT
8691	3654	5	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3654	6	amount	amount	NN
8691	3654	7	of	of	IN
8691	3654	8	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3654	9	patronage	patronage	NN
8691	3654	10	to	to	TO
8691	3654	11	be	be	VB
8691	3654	12	bestowed	bestow	VBN
8691	3654	13	.	.	.
8691	3655	1	There	there	EX
8691	3655	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3655	3	clerks	clerk	NNS
8691	3655	4	and	and	CC
8691	3655	5	messengers	messenger	NNS
8691	3655	6	,	,	,
8691	3655	7	trustees	trustee	NNS
8691	3655	8	and	and	CC
8691	3655	9	receivers	receiver	NNS
8691	3655	10	,	,	,
8691	3655	11	referees	referee	NNS
8691	3655	12	and	and	CC
8691	3655	13	committees	committee	NNS
8691	3655	14	,	,	,
8691	3655	15	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	3655	16	public	public	JJ
8691	3655	17	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
8691	3655	18	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	3655	19	and	and	CC
8691	3655	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3655	21	assistants	assistant	NNS
8691	3655	22	,	,	,
8691	3655	23	to	to	TO
8691	3655	24	appoint	appoint	VB
8691	3655	25	.	.	.
8691	3656	1	Other	other	JJ
8691	3656	2	things	thing	NNS
8691	3656	3	being	be	VBG
8691	3656	4	equal	equal	JJ
8691	3656	5	,	,	,
8691	3656	6	no	no	DT
8691	3656	7	one	one	PRP
8691	3656	8	would	would	MD
8691	3656	9	blame	blame	VB
8691	3656	10	a	a	DT
8691	3656	11	judge	judge	NN
8691	3656	12	for	for	IN
8691	3656	13	naming	name	VBG
8691	3656	14	a	a	DT
8691	3656	15	political	political	JJ
8691	3656	16	friend	friend	NN
8691	3656	17	for	for	IN
8691	3656	18	such	such	PDT
8691	3656	19	a	a	DT
8691	3656	20	position	position	NN
8691	3656	21	.	.	.
8691	3657	1	But	but	CC
8691	3657	2	as	as	IN
8691	3657	3	to	to	IN
8691	3657	4	whether	whether	IN
8691	3657	5	other	other	JJ
8691	3657	6	things	thing	NNS
8691	3657	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3657	8	equal	equal	JJ
8691	3657	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3657	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	3657	11	to	to	TO
8691	3657	12	decide	decide	VB
8691	3657	13	.	.	.
8691	3658	1	To	to	IN
8691	3658	2	the	the	DT
8691	3658	3	most	most	RBS
8691	3658	4	upright	upright	JJ
8691	3658	5	and	and	CC
8691	3658	6	fearless	fearless	JJ
8691	3658	7	man	man	NN
8691	3658	8	the	the	DT
8691	3658	9	danger	danger	NN
8691	3658	10	of	of	IN
8691	3658	11	this	this	DT
8691	3658	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	3658	13	great	great	JJ
8691	3658	14	;	;	:
8691	3658	15	to	to	IN
8691	3658	16	a	a	DT
8691	3658	17	weak	weak	JJ
8691	3658	18	or	or	CC
8691	3658	19	bad	bad	JJ
8691	3658	20	man	man	NN
8691	3658	21	the	the	DT
8691	3658	22	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	3658	23	of	of	IN
8691	3658	24	personal	personal	JJ
8691	3658	25	obligation	obligation	NN
8691	3658	26	will	will	MD
8691	3658	27	be	be	VB
8691	3658	28	controlling	control	VBG
8691	3658	29	.	.	.
8691	3659	1	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3659	2	Barnard	Barnard	NNP
8691	3659	3	of	of	IN
8691	3659	4	the	the	DT
8691	3659	5	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3659	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3659	7	of	of	IN
8691	3659	8	New	New	NNP
8691	3659	9	York	York	NNP
8691	3659	10	once	once	RB
8691	3659	11	observed	observe	VBD
8691	3659	12	on	on	IN
8691	3659	13	the	the	DT
8691	3659	14	bench	bench	NN
8691	3659	15	that	that	WDT
8691	3659	16	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3659	17	had	have	VBD
8691	3659	18	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	3659	19	patronage	patronage	NN
8691	3659	20	to	to	TO
8691	3659	21	be	be	VB
8691	3659	22	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	3659	23	of	of	IN
8691	3659	24	at	at	IN
8691	3659	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3659	26	discretion	discretion	NN
8691	3659	27	,	,	,
8691	3659	28	and	and	CC
8691	3659	29	that	that	IN
8691	3659	30	for	for	IN
8691	3659	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3659	32	part	part	NN
8691	3659	33	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3659	34	had	have	VBD
8691	3659	35	always	always	RB
8691	3659	36	succeeded	succeed	VBN
8691	3659	37	in	in	IN
8691	3659	38	life	life	NN
8691	3659	39	by	by	IN
8691	3659	40	helping	help	VBG
8691	3659	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3659	42	friends	friend	NNS
8691	3659	43	and	and	CC
8691	3659	44	not	not	RB
8691	3659	45	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3659	46	enemies	enemy	NNS
8691	3659	47	.	.	.
8691	3660	1	For	for	IN
8691	3660	2	this	this	DT
8691	3660	3	practice	practice	NN
8691	3660	4	,	,	,
8691	3660	5	among	among	IN
8691	3660	6	other	other	JJ
8691	3660	7	things	thing	NNS
8691	3660	8	,	,	,
8691	3660	9	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3660	10	was	be	VBD
8691	3660	11	impeached	impeach	VBN
8691	3660	12	and	and	CC
8691	3660	13	removed	remove	VBN
8691	3660	14	from	from	IN
8691	3660	15	office	office	NN
8691	3660	16	;	;	:
8691	3660	17	but	but	CC
8691	3660	18	how	how	WRB
8691	3660	19	many	many	JJ
8691	3660	20	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3660	21	are	be	VBP
8691	3660	22	there	there	EX
8691	3660	23	who	who	WP
8691	3660	24	yield	yield	VBP
8691	3660	25	to	to	IN
8691	3660	26	this	this	DT
8691	3660	27	temptation	temptation	NN
8691	3660	28	without	without	IN
8691	3660	29	avowing	avow	VBG
8691	3660	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3660	31	?	?	.
8691	3661	1	A	a	DT
8691	3661	2	French	french	JJ
8691	3661	3	critic	critic	NN
8691	3661	4	of	of	IN
8691	3661	5	the	the	DT
8691	3661	6	elective	elective	JJ
8691	3661	7	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	3661	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	3661	9	thus	thus	RB
8691	3661	10	referred	refer	VBN
8691	3661	11	to	to	IN
8691	3661	12	these	these	DT
8691	3661	13	remarks	remark	NNS
8691	3661	14	of	of	IN
8691	3661	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3661	16	Barnard	Barnard	NNP
8691	3661	17	:	:	:
8691	3661	18	Le	Le	NNP
8691	3661	19	Juge	Juge	NNP
8691	3661	20	Barnard	Barnard	NNP
8691	3661	21	,	,	,
8691	3661	22	qui	qui	NNP
8691	3661	23	formulait	formulait	VB
8691	3661	24	en	en	IN
8691	3661	25	plein	plein	NNP
8691	3661	26	tribunal	tribunal	NNP
8691	3661	27	cette	cette	NN
8691	3661	28	dÃ	dÃ	NNP
8691	3661	29	©	©	NNP
8691	3661	30	claration	claration	NN
8691	3661	31	de	de	FW
8691	3661	32	principes	principe	NNS
8691	3661	33	,	,	,
8691	3661	34	fut	fut	NNP
8691	3661	35	dÃ	dÃ	NNP
8691	3661	36	©	©	NNP
8691	3661	37	crÃ	crÃ	NNP
8691	3661	38	©	©	NNP
8691	3661	39	tÃ	tÃ	NNP
8691	3661	40	©	©	NNP
8691	3661	41	d'accusation	d'accusation	NN
8691	3661	42	et	et	NNP
8691	3661	43	condamnÃ	condamnÃ	NNP
8691	3661	44	©	©	UH
8691	3661	45	,	,	,
8691	3661	46	non	non	NNP
8691	3661	47	sans	sans	NNP
8691	3661	48	justes	justes	NNP
8691	3661	49	motifs	motifs	NNP
8691	3661	50	.	.	.
8691	3662	1	Mais	Mais	NNP
8691	3662	2	son	son	NN
8691	3662	3	crime	crime	NN
8691	3662	4	impardonable	impardonable	NN
8691	3662	5	Ã	Ã	NNP
8691	3662	6	©	©	NNP
8691	3662	7	tait	tait	NNP
8691	3662	8	de	de	IN
8691	3662	9	proclamer	proclamer	NNP
8691	3662	10	trop	trop	NNP
8691	3662	11	franchement	franchement	NNP
8691	3662	12	les	les	NNP
8691	3662	13	doctrines	doctrines	NNP
8691	3662	14	de	de	NNP
8691	3662	15	la	la	NNP
8691	3662	16	magistrature	magistrature	NNP
8691	3662	17	Ã	Ã	NNP
8691	3662	18	©	©	NNP
8691	3662	19	lective	lective	NN
8691	3662	20	:	:	:
8691	3662	21	il	il	NNP
8691	3662	22	trahissait	trahissait	NNP
8691	3662	23	le	le	NNP
8691	3662	24	secret	secret	NNP
8691	3662	25	professionnel	professionnel	NNP
8691	3662	26	.	.	.
8691	3663	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3663	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3663	3	:	:	:
8691	3663	4	Duc	Duc	NNP
8691	3663	5	De	De	NNP
8691	3663	6	Noailles	Noailles	NNP
8691	3663	7	,	,	,
8691	3663	8	_	_	NNP
8691	3663	9	Cent	Cent	NNP
8691	3663	10	Ans	Ans	NNP
8691	3663	11	de	de	NNP
8691	3663	12	RÃ	RÃ	NNP
8691	3663	13	©	©	NNP
8691	3663	14	publique	publique	NN
8691	3663	15	aux	aux	NN
8691	3663	16	Etats	Etats	NNP
8691	3663	17	-	-	HYPH
8691	3663	18	Unis	Unis	NNP
8691	3663	19	_	_	NNP
8691	3663	20	,	,	,
8691	3663	21	II	II	NNP
8691	3663	22	,	,	,
8691	3663	23	232	232	CD
8691	3663	24	.	.	.
8691	3663	25	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3664	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	3664	2	of	of	IN
8691	3664	3	the	the	DT
8691	3664	4	old	old	JJ
8691	3664	5	thirteen	thirteen	CD
8691	3664	6	States	state	NNS
8691	3664	7	in	in	IN
8691	3664	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3664	9	first	first	JJ
8691	3664	10	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	3664	11	provided	provide	VBN
8691	3664	12	that	that	IN
8691	3664	13	the	the	DT
8691	3664	14	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3664	15	of	of	IN
8691	3664	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3664	17	highest	high	JJS
8691	3664	18	courts	court	NNS
8691	3664	19	should	should	MD
8691	3664	20	hold	hold	VB
8691	3664	21	office	office	NN
8691	3664	22	during	during	IN
8691	3664	23	good	good	JJ
8691	3664	24	behavior	behavior	NN
8691	3664	25	,	,	,
8691	3664	26	or	or	CC
8691	3664	27	until	until	IN
8691	3664	28	seventy	seventy	CD
8691	3664	29	years	year	NNS
8691	3664	30	of	of	IN
8691	3664	31	age	age	NN
8691	3664	32	.	.	.
8691	3665	1	New	New	NNP
8691	3665	2	York	York	NNP
8691	3665	3	at	at	IN
8691	3665	4	first	first	RB
8691	3665	5	put	put	VBD
8691	3665	6	the	the	DT
8691	3665	7	age	age	NN
8691	3665	8	of	of	IN
8691	3665	9	superannuation	superannuation	NN
8691	3665	10	at	at	IN
8691	3665	11	sixty	sixty	CD
8691	3665	12	,	,	,
8691	3665	13	but	but	CC
8691	3665	14	after	after	IN
8691	3665	15	losing	lose	VBG
8691	3665	16	by	by	IN
8691	3665	17	this	this	DT
8691	3665	18	the	the	DT
8691	3665	19	services	service	NNS
8691	3665	20	of	of	IN
8691	3665	21	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	3665	22	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	3665	23	for	for	IN
8691	3665	24	some	some	DT
8691	3665	25	of	of	IN
8691	3665	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3665	27	best	good	JJS
8691	3665	28	and	and	CC
8691	3665	29	most	most	RBS
8691	3665	30	fruitful	fruitful	JJ
8691	3665	31	years	year	NNS
8691	3665	32	,	,	,
8691	3665	33	postponed	postpone	VBD
8691	3665	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3665	35	to	to	IN
8691	3665	36	seventy	seventy	CD
8691	3665	37	.	.	.
8691	3666	1	Georgia	Georgia	NNP
8691	3666	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3666	3	the	the	DT
8691	3666	4	first	first	JJ
8691	3666	5	to	to	TO
8691	3666	6	set	set	VB
8691	3666	7	the	the	DT
8691	3666	8	fashion	fashion	NN
8691	3666	9	of	of	IN
8691	3666	10	short	short	JJ
8691	3666	11	terms	term	NNS
8691	3666	12	.	.	.
8691	3667	1	Her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3667	2	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3667	3	of	of	IN
8691	3667	4	1798	1798	CD
8691	3667	5	provided	provide	VBD
8691	3667	6	that	that	IN
8691	3667	7	the	the	DT
8691	3667	8	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3667	9	of	of	IN
8691	3667	10	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3667	11	highest	high	JJS
8691	3667	12	court	court	NN
8691	3667	13	should	should	MD
8691	3667	14	be	be	VB
8691	3667	15	"	"	``
8691	3667	16	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3667	17	"	"	''
8691	3667	18	for	for	IN
8691	3667	19	three	three	CD
8691	3667	20	years	year	NNS
8691	3667	21	,	,	,
8691	3667	22	but	but	CC
8691	3667	23	that	that	IN
8691	3667	24	those	those	DT
8691	3667	25	of	of	IN
8691	3667	26	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3667	27	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3667	28	courts	court	NNS
8691	3667	29	should	should	MD
8691	3667	30	be	be	VB
8691	3667	31	"	"	``
8691	3667	32	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3667	33	"	"	''
8691	3667	34	by	by	IN
8691	3667	35	the	the	DT
8691	3667	36	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3667	37	and	and	CC
8691	3667	38	hold	hold	VB
8691	3667	39	during	during	IN
8691	3667	40	good	good	JJ
8691	3667	41	behavior	behavior	NN
8691	3667	42	.	.	.
8691	3668	1	The	the	DT
8691	3668	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3668	3	construed	construe	VBD
8691	3668	4	this	this	DT
8691	3668	5	as	as	IN
8691	3668	6	allowing	allow	VBG
8691	3668	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3668	8	to	to	TO
8691	3668	9	frame	frame	VB
8691	3668	10	such	such	PDT
8691	3668	11	a	a	DT
8691	3668	12	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	3668	13	of	of	IN
8691	3668	14	election	election	NN
8691	3668	15	as	as	IN
8691	3668	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3668	17	thought	think	VBD
8691	3668	18	best	well	RBS
8691	3668	19	,	,	,
8691	3668	20	and	and	CC
8691	3668	21	that	that	IN
8691	3668	22	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	3668	23	was	be	VBD
8691	3668	24	for	for	IN
8691	3668	25	the	the	DT
8691	3668	26	House	House	NNP
8691	3668	27	to	to	TO
8691	3668	28	nominate	nominate	VB
8691	3668	29	three	three	CD
8691	3668	30	,	,	,
8691	3668	31	from	from	IN
8691	3668	32	whom	whom	WP
8691	3668	33	the	the	DT
8691	3668	34	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	3668	35	elected	elect	VBD
8691	3668	36	one	one	CD
8691	3668	37	.	.	.
8691	3669	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3669	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3669	3	:	:	:
8691	3669	4	Schouler	Schouler	NNP
8691	3669	5	,	,	,
8691	3669	6	"	"	``
8691	3669	7	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
8691	3669	8	Studies	Studies	NNPS
8691	3669	9	,	,	,
8691	3669	10	"	"	''
8691	3669	11	65	65	CD
8691	3669	12	.	.	.
8691	3669	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3670	1	In	in	IN
8691	3670	2	all	all	DT
8691	3670	3	but	but	CC
8691	3670	4	three	three	CD
8691	3670	5	States	States	NNPS
8691	3670	6	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3670	7	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3670	8	,	,	,
8691	3670	9	New	New	NNP
8691	3670	10	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	3670	11	and	and	CC
8691	3670	12	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	3670	13	Island	Island	NNP
8691	3670	14	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3670	15	at	at	IN
8691	3670	16	the	the	DT
8691	3670	17	present	present	JJ
8691	3670	18	time	time	NN
8691	3670	19	all	all	DT
8691	3670	20	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3670	21	hold	hold	VBP
8691	3670	22	for	for	IN
8691	3670	23	a	a	DT
8691	3670	24	term	term	NN
8691	3670	25	of	of	IN
8691	3670	26	years	year	NNS
8691	3670	27	,	,	,
8691	3670	28	and	and	CC
8691	3670	29	as	as	IN
8691	3670	30	a	a	DT
8691	3670	31	general	general	JJ
8691	3670	32	rule	rule	NN
8691	3670	33	those	those	DT
8691	3670	34	of	of	IN
8691	3670	35	the	the	DT
8691	3670	36	higher	high	JJR
8691	3670	37	courts	court	NNS
8691	3670	38	have	have	VBP
8691	3670	39	longer	long	JJR
8691	3670	40	terms	term	NNS
8691	3670	41	than	than	IN
8691	3670	42	those	those	DT
8691	3670	43	of	of	IN
8691	3670	44	the	the	DT
8691	3670	45	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3670	46	ones	one	NNS
8691	3670	47	.	.	.
8691	3671	1	The	the	DT
8691	3671	2	change	change	NN
8691	3671	3	from	from	IN
8691	3671	4	life	life	NN
8691	3671	5	tenure	tenure	NN
8691	3671	6	to	to	IN
8691	3671	7	that	that	DT
8691	3671	8	for	for	IN
8691	3671	9	a	a	DT
8691	3671	10	term	term	NN
8691	3671	11	of	of	IN
8691	3671	12	years	year	NNS
8691	3671	13	was	be	VBD
8691	3671	14	partly	partly	RB
8691	3671	15	due	due	JJ
8691	3671	16	to	to	IN
8691	3671	17	several	several	JJ
8691	3671	18	instances	instance	NNS
8691	3671	19	which	which	WDT
8691	3671	20	occurred	occur	VBD
8691	3671	21	early	early	RB
8691	3671	22	in	in	IN
8691	3671	23	the	the	DT
8691	3671	24	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	3671	25	century	century	NN
8691	3671	26	,	,	,
8691	3671	27	in	in	IN
8691	3671	28	which	which	WDT
8691	3671	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3671	30	was	be	VBD
8691	3671	31	evident	evident	JJ
8691	3671	32	that	that	IN
8691	3671	33	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3671	34	had	have	VBD
8691	3671	35	outlived	outlive	VBN
8691	3671	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3671	37	usefulness	usefulness	NN
8691	3671	38	.	.	.
8691	3672	1	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3672	2	Pickering	Pickering	NNP
8691	3672	3	of	of	IN
8691	3672	4	the	the	DT
8691	3672	5	District	District	NNP
8691	3672	6	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3672	7	of	of	IN
8691	3672	8	New	New	NNP
8691	3672	9	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	3672	10	lost	lose	VBD
8691	3672	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3672	12	reason	reason	NN
8691	3672	13	,	,	,
8691	3672	14	and	and	CC
8691	3672	15	to	to	TO
8691	3672	16	get	get	VB
8691	3672	17	rid	rid	VBN
8691	3672	18	of	of	IN
8691	3672	19	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3672	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3672	21	became	become	VBD
8691	3672	22	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	3672	23	to	to	TO
8691	3672	24	go	go	VB
8691	3672	25	through	through	IN
8691	3672	26	the	the	DT
8691	3672	27	form	form	NN
8691	3672	28	of	of	IN
8691	3672	29	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	3672	30	.	.	.
8691	3673	1	In	in	IN
8691	3673	2	1803	1803	CD
8691	3673	3	,	,	,
8691	3673	4	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3673	5	Bradbury	Bradbury	NNP
8691	3673	6	of	of	IN
8691	3673	7	the	the	DT
8691	3673	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3673	9	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	3673	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3673	11	of	of	IN
8691	3673	12	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3673	13	,	,	,
8691	3673	14	who	who	WP
8691	3673	15	had	have	VBD
8691	3673	16	been	be	VBN
8691	3673	17	incapacitated	incapacitate	VBN
8691	3673	18	by	by	IN
8691	3673	19	paralysis	paralysis	NN
8691	3673	20	,	,	,
8691	3673	21	was	be	VBD
8691	3673	22	displaced	displace	VBN
8691	3673	23	in	in	IN
8691	3673	24	the	the	DT
8691	3673	25	same	same	JJ
8691	3673	26	way	way	NN
8691	3673	27	,	,	,
8691	3673	28	though	though	IN
8691	3673	29	only	only	RB
8691	3673	30	a	a	DT
8691	3673	31	few	few	JJ
8691	3673	32	months	month	NNS
8691	3673	33	before	before	IN
8691	3673	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3673	35	death	death	NN
8691	3673	36	.	.	.
8691	3674	1	In	in	IN
8691	3674	2	1822	1822	CD
8691	3674	3	,	,	,
8691	3674	4	an	an	DT
8691	3674	5	old	old	JJ
8691	3674	6	man	man	NN
8691	3674	7	who	who	WP
8691	3674	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3674	9	the	the	DT
8691	3674	10	chief	chief	JJ
8691	3674	11	judge	judge	NN
8691	3674	12	of	of	IN
8691	3674	13	one	one	CD
8691	3674	14	of	of	IN
8691	3674	15	the	the	DT
8691	3674	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3674	17	districts	district	NNS
8691	3674	18	of	of	IN
8691	3674	19	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	3674	20	was	be	VBD
8691	3674	21	presented	present	VBN
8691	3674	22	by	by	IN
8691	3674	23	the	the	DT
8691	3674	24	grand	grand	JJ
8691	3674	25	jury	jury	NN
8691	3674	26	as	as	IN
8691	3674	27	a	a	DT
8691	3674	28	"	"	``
8691	3674	29	serious	serious	JJ
8691	3674	30	grievance	grievance	NN
8691	3674	31	,	,	,
8691	3674	32	"	"	''
8691	3674	33	on	on	IN
8691	3674	34	account	account	NN
8691	3674	35	of	of	IN
8691	3674	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3674	37	habitual	habitual	JJ
8691	3674	38	absence	absence	NN
8691	3674	39	from	from	IN
8691	3674	40	court	court	NN
8691	3674	41	.	.	.
8691	3675	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3675	2	physician	physician	NN
8691	3675	3	certified	certify	VBD
8691	3675	4	that	that	IN
8691	3675	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3675	6	life	life	NN
8691	3675	7	would	would	MD
8691	3675	8	be	be	VB
8691	3675	9	hazarded	hazard	VBN
8691	3675	10	if	if	IN
8691	3675	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3675	12	undertook	undertake	VBD
8691	3675	13	to	to	TO
8691	3675	14	attend	attend	VB
8691	3675	15	,	,	,
8691	3675	16	but	but	CC
8691	3675	17	the	the	DT
8691	3675	18	natural	natural	JJ
8691	3675	19	answer	answer	NN
8691	3675	20	was	be	VBD
8691	3675	21	that	that	IN
8691	3675	22	then	then	RB
8691	3675	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3675	24	should	should	MD
8691	3675	25	resign	resign	VB
8691	3675	26	.	.	.
8691	3676	1	At	at	IN
8691	3676	2	present	present	NN
8691	3676	3	,	,	,
8691	3676	4	for	for	IN
8691	3676	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3676	6	of	of	IN
8691	3676	7	the	the	DT
8691	3676	8	State	State	NNP
8691	3676	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	3676	10	of	of	IN
8691	3676	11	last	last	JJ
8691	3676	12	resort	resort	NN
8691	3676	13	,	,	,
8691	3676	14	the	the	DT
8691	3676	15	term	term	NN
8691	3676	16	in	in	IN
8691	3676	17	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3676	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	3676	19	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3676	20	-	-	HYPH
8691	3676	21	one	one	CD
8691	3676	22	years	year	NNS
8691	3676	23	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3676	24	but	but	CC
8691	3676	25	with	with	IN
8691	3676	26	a	a	DT
8691	3676	27	prohibition	prohibition	NN
8691	3676	28	of	of	IN
8691	3676	29	re	re	NN
8691	3676	30	-	-	NN
8691	3676	31	election	election	NN
8691	3676	32	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3676	33	;	;	:
8691	3676	34	in	in	IN
8691	3676	35	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	3676	36	,	,	,
8691	3676	37	fifteen	fifteen	CD
8691	3676	38	;	;	:
8691	3676	39	in	in	IN
8691	3676	40	New	New	NNP
8691	3676	41	York	York	NNP
8691	3676	42	,	,	,
8691	3676	43	fourteen	fourteen	CD
8691	3676	44	;	;	:
8691	3676	45	in	in	IN
8691	3676	46	California	California	NNP
8691	3676	47	,	,	,
8691	3676	48	Delaware	Delaware	NNP
8691	3676	49	,	,	,
8691	3676	50	Louisiana	Louisiana	NNP
8691	3676	51	,	,	,
8691	3676	52	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	3676	53	,	,	,
8691	3676	54	and	and	CC
8691	3676	55	West	West	NNP
8691	3676	56	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	3676	57	,	,	,
8691	3676	58	twelve	twelve	CD
8691	3676	59	;	;	:
8691	3676	60	in	in	IN
8691	3676	61	Michigan	Michigan	NNP
8691	3676	62	,	,	,
8691	3676	63	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
8691	3676	64	,	,	,
8691	3676	65	and	and	CC
8691	3676	66	Wisconsin	Wisconsin	NNP
8691	3676	67	,	,	,
8691	3676	68	ten	ten	CD
8691	3676	69	;	;	:
8691	3676	70	in	in	IN
8691	3676	71	Colorado	Colorado	NNP
8691	3676	72	,	,	,
8691	3676	73	Illinois	Illinois	NNP
8691	3676	74	,	,	,
8691	3676	75	and	and	CC
8691	3676	76	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	3676	77	,	,	,
8691	3676	78	nine	nine	CD
8691	3676	79	.	.	.
8691	3677	1	The	the	DT
8691	3677	2	general	general	JJ
8691	3677	3	average	average	NN
8691	3677	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3677	5	eight	eight	CD
8691	3677	6	,	,	,
8691	3677	7	although	although	IN
8691	3677	8	that	that	DT
8691	3677	9	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3677	10	number	number	NN
8691	3677	11	obtains	obtain	NNS
8691	3677	12	in	in	IN
8691	3677	13	but	but	CC
8691	3677	14	seven	seven	CD
8691	3677	15	States	state	NNS
8691	3677	16	.	.	.
8691	3678	1	In	in	IN
8691	3678	2	eighteen	eighteen	CD
8691	3678	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3678	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3678	5	six	six	CD
8691	3678	6	.	.	.
8691	3679	1	The	the	DT
8691	3679	2	shortest	short	JJS
8691	3679	3	term	term	NN
8691	3679	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3679	5	two	two	CD
8691	3679	6	,	,	,
8691	3679	7	and	and	CC
8691	3679	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	3679	9	found	find	VBN
8691	3679	10	in	in	IN
8691	3679	11	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
8691	3679	12	.	.	.
8691	3680	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3680	2	may	may	MD
8691	3680	3	be	be	VB
8691	3680	4	noted	note	VBN
8691	3680	5	that	that	IN
8691	3680	6	the	the	DT
8691	3680	7	original	original	JJ
8691	3680	8	rule	rule	NN
8691	3680	9	in	in	IN
8691	3680	10	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
8691	3680	11	was	be	VBD
8691	3680	12	to	to	TO
8691	3680	13	elect	elect	VB
8691	3680	14	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3680	15	annually	annually	RB
8691	3680	16	.	.	.
8691	3681	1	As	as	IN
8691	3681	2	compared	compare	VBN
8691	3681	3	with	with	IN
8691	3681	4	the	the	DT
8691	3681	5	terms	term	NNS
8691	3681	6	of	of	IN
8691	3681	7	office	office	NN
8691	3681	8	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
8691	3681	9	at	at	IN
8691	3681	10	the	the	DT
8691	3681	11	middle	middle	NN
8691	3681	12	of	of	IN
8691	3681	13	the	the	DT
8691	3681	14	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	3681	15	century	century	NN
8691	3681	16	,	,	,
8691	3681	17	those	those	DT
8691	3681	18	at	at	IN
8691	3681	19	the	the	DT
8691	3681	20	opening	opening	NN
8691	3681	21	of	of	IN
8691	3681	22	the	the	DT
8691	3681	23	twentieth	twentieth	NNS
8691	3681	24	are	be	VBP
8691	3681	25	on	on	IN
8691	3681	26	the	the	DT
8691	3681	27	average	average	NN
8691	3681	28	decidedly	decidedly	RB
8691	3681	29	longer	long	RBR
8691	3681	30	.	.	.
8691	3682	1	*	*	NFP
8691	3682	2	*	*	NFP
8691	3682	3	*	*	NFP
8691	3682	4	*	*	NFP
8691	3682	5	*	*	NFP
8691	3682	6	The	the	DT
8691	3682	7	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	3682	8	of	of	IN
8691	3682	9	most	most	JJS
8691	3682	10	American	american	JJ
8691	3682	11	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3682	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	3682	13	a	a	DT
8691	3682	14	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	3682	15	salary	salary	NN
8691	3682	16	.	.	.
8691	3683	1	In	in	IN
8691	3683	2	some	some	DT
8691	3683	3	States	state	NNS
8691	3683	4	,	,	,
8691	3683	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	3683	6	of	of	IN
8691	3683	7	probate	probate	NN
8691	3683	8	and	and	CC
8691	3683	9	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	3683	10	,	,	,
8691	3683	11	and	and	CC
8691	3683	12	in	in	IN
8691	3683	13	all	all	DT
8691	3683	14	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3683	15	of	of	IN
8691	3683	16	the	the	DT
8691	3683	17	peace	peace	NN
8691	3683	18	when	when	WRB
8691	3683	19	holding	hold	VBG
8691	3683	20	court	court	NN
8691	3683	21	,	,	,
8691	3683	22	are	be	VBP
8691	3683	23	paid	pay	VBN
8691	3683	24	by	by	IN
8691	3683	25	such	such	JJ
8691	3683	26	fees	fee	NNS
8691	3683	27	as	as	IN
8691	3683	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3683	29	may	may	MD
8691	3683	30	receive	receive	VB
8691	3683	31	,	,	,
8691	3683	32	at	at	IN
8691	3683	33	statutory	statutory	JJ
8691	3683	34	rates	rate	NNS
8691	3683	35	,	,	,
8691	3683	36	for	for	IN
8691	3683	37	business	business	NN
8691	3683	38	done	do	VBN
8691	3683	39	.	.	.
8691	3684	1	As	as	IN
8691	3684	2	in	in	IN
8691	3684	3	the	the	DT
8691	3684	4	case	case	NN
8691	3684	5	of	of	IN
8691	3684	6	sheriffs	sheriff	NNS
8691	3684	7	and	and	CC
8691	3684	8	clerks	clerk	NNS
8691	3684	9	,	,	,
8691	3684	10	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3684	11	under	under	IN
8691	3684	12	such	such	PDT
8691	3684	13	a	a	DT
8691	3684	14	system	system	NN
8691	3684	15	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3684	16	receive	receive	VBP
8691	3684	17	a	a	DT
8691	3684	18	much	much	RB
8691	3684	19	larger	large	JJR
8691	3684	20	official	official	JJ
8691	3684	21	income	income	NN
8691	3684	22	than	than	IN
8691	3684	23	any	any	DT
8691	3684	24	one	one	NN
8691	3684	25	would	would	MD
8691	3684	26	venture	venture	VB
8691	3684	27	to	to	TO
8691	3684	28	propose	propose	VB
8691	3684	29	to	to	TO
8691	3684	30	give	give	VB
8691	3684	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3684	32	were	be	VBD
8691	3684	33	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3684	34	to	to	TO
8691	3684	35	be	be	VB
8691	3684	36	paid	pay	VBN
8691	3684	37	for	for	IN
8691	3684	38	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3684	39	services	service	NNS
8691	3684	40	from	from	IN
8691	3684	41	the	the	DT
8691	3684	42	public	public	JJ
8691	3684	43	treasury	treasury	NN
8691	3684	44	.	.	.
8691	3685	1	A	a	DT
8691	3685	2	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	3685	3	of	of	IN
8691	3685	4	court	court	NN
8691	3685	5	often	often	RB
8691	3685	6	receives	receive	VBZ
8691	3685	7	more	more	JJR
8691	3685	8	than	than	IN
8691	3685	9	the	the	DT
8691	3685	10	judge	judge	NN
8691	3685	11	,	,	,
8691	3685	12	and	and	CC
8691	3685	13	some	some	DT
8691	3685	14	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3685	15	of	of	IN
8691	3685	16	probate	probate	NN
8691	3685	17	and	and	CC
8691	3685	18	insolvency	insolvency	NN
8691	3685	19	more	more	JJR
8691	3685	20	than	than	IN
8691	3685	21	the	the	DT
8691	3685	22	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3685	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3685	24	of	of	IN
8691	3685	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3685	26	State	State	NNP
8691	3685	27	.	.	.
8691	3686	1	In	in	IN
8691	3686	2	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	3686	3	times	time	NNS
8691	3686	4	,	,	,
8691	3686	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3686	6	were	be	VBD
8691	3686	7	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3686	8	paid	pay	VBN
8691	3686	9	in	in	IN
8691	3686	10	part	part	NN
8691	3686	11	by	by	IN
8691	3686	12	fees	fee	NNS
8691	3686	13	,	,	,
8691	3686	14	in	in	IN
8691	3686	15	part	part	NN
8691	3686	16	by	by	IN
8691	3686	17	occasional	occasional	JJ
8691	3686	18	grants	grant	NNS
8691	3686	19	by	by	IN
8691	3686	20	the	the	DT
8691	3686	21	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3686	22	,	,	,
8691	3686	23	and	and	CC
8691	3686	24	in	in	IN
8691	3686	25	part	part	NN
8691	3686	26	by	by	IN
8691	3686	27	a	a	DT
8691	3686	28	regular	regular	JJ
8691	3686	29	stipend	stipend	NN
8691	3686	30	.	.	.
8691	3687	1	This	this	DT
8691	3687	2	practice	practice	NN
8691	3687	3	of	of	IN
8691	3687	4	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	3687	5	grants	grant	NNS
8691	3687	6	from	from	IN
8691	3687	7	time	time	NN
8691	3687	8	to	to	IN
8691	3687	9	time	time	NN
8691	3687	10	in	in	IN
8691	3687	11	addition	addition	NN
8691	3687	12	to	to	IN
8691	3687	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3687	14	salaries	salary	NNS
8691	3687	15	was	be	VBD
8691	3687	16	continued	continue	VBN
8691	3687	17	in	in	IN
8691	3687	18	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3687	19	in	in	IN
8691	3687	20	favor	favor	NN
8691	3687	21	of	of	IN
8691	3687	22	the	the	DT
8691	3687	23	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3687	24	of	of	IN
8691	3687	25	the	the	DT
8691	3687	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3687	27	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	3687	28	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3687	29	for	for	IN
8691	3687	30	a	a	DT
8691	3687	31	quarter	quarter	NN
8691	3687	32	of	of	IN
8691	3687	33	a	a	DT
8691	3687	34	century	century	NN
8691	3687	35	,	,	,
8691	3687	36	in	in	IN
8691	3687	37	the	the	DT
8691	3687	38	face	face	NN
8691	3687	39	of	of	IN
8691	3687	40	a	a	DT
8691	3687	41	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3687	42	which	which	WDT
8691	3687	43	provided	provide	VBD
8691	3687	44	that	that	IN
8691	3687	45	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3687	46	"	"	``
8691	3687	47	should	should	MD
8691	3687	48	have	have	VB
8691	3687	49	honourable	honourable	JJ
8691	3687	50	salaries	salary	NNS
8691	3687	51	ascertained	ascertain	VBN
8691	3687	52	and	and	CC
8691	3687	53	established	establish	VBN
8691	3687	54	by	by	IN
8691	3687	55	standing	stand	VBG
8691	3687	56	laws	law	NNS
8691	3687	57	.	.	.
8691	3688	1	"	"	``
8691	3688	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3688	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3688	4	:	:	:
8691	3688	5	Memoir	Memoir	NNP
8691	3688	6	of	of	IN
8691	3688	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3688	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3688	9	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
8691	3688	10	,	,	,
8691	3688	11	228	228	CD
8691	3688	12	.	.	.
8691	3688	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3689	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3689	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3689	3	evidently	evidently	RB
8691	3689	4	indefensible	indefensible	JJ
8691	3689	5	in	in	IN
8691	3689	6	principle	principle	NN
8691	3689	7	,	,	,
8691	3689	8	and	and	CC
8691	3689	9	to	to	TO
8691	3689	10	remove	remove	VB
8691	3689	11	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3689	12	,	,	,
8691	3689	13	as	as	RB
8691	3689	14	far	far	RB
8691	3689	15	as	as	IN
8691	3689	16	possible	possible	JJ
8691	3689	17	,	,	,
8691	3689	18	from	from	IN
8691	3689	19	temptation	temptation	NN
8691	3689	20	either	either	CC
8691	3689	21	to	to	TO
8691	3689	22	court	court	VB
8691	3689	23	the	the	DT
8691	3689	24	favor	favor	NN
8691	3689	25	or	or	CC
8691	3689	26	dread	dread	VBP
8691	3689	27	the	the	DT
8691	3689	28	displeasure	displeasure	NN
8691	3689	29	of	of	IN
8691	3689	30	the	the	DT
8691	3689	31	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3689	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3689	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	3689	34	now	now	RB
8691	3689	35	generally	generally	RB
8691	3689	36	provided	provide	VBN
8691	3689	37	in	in	IN
8691	3689	38	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3689	39	American	American	NNP
8691	3689	40	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	3689	41	that	that	IN
8691	3689	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3689	43	salaries	salary	NNS
8691	3689	44	shall	shall	MD
8691	3689	45	be	be	VB
8691	3689	46	neither	neither	CC
8691	3689	47	increased	increase	VBN
8691	3689	48	nor	nor	CC
8691	3689	49	decreased	decrease	VBD
8691	3689	50	during	during	IN
8691	3689	51	the	the	DT
8691	3689	52	term	term	NN
8691	3689	53	for	for	IN
8691	3689	54	which	which	WDT
8691	3689	55	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3689	56	may	may	MD
8691	3689	57	have	have	VB
8691	3689	58	been	be	VBN
8691	3689	59	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3689	60	by	by	IN
8691	3689	61	any	any	DT
8691	3689	62	subsequent	subsequent	JJ
8691	3689	63	change	change	NN
8691	3689	64	of	of	IN
8691	3689	65	the	the	DT
8691	3689	66	law	law	NN
8691	3689	67	.	.	.
8691	3690	1	In	in	IN
8691	3690	2	a	a	DT
8691	3690	3	few	few	JJ
8691	3690	4	States	state	NNS
8691	3690	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3690	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3690	7	thought	think	VBN
8691	3690	8	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	3690	9	to	to	TO
8691	3690	10	guard	guard	VB
8691	3690	11	against	against	IN
8691	3690	12	the	the	DT
8691	3690	13	consequences	consequence	NNS
8691	3690	14	of	of	IN
8691	3690	15	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	3690	16	disfavor	disfavor	NN
8691	3690	17	,	,	,
8691	3690	18	and	and	CC
8691	3690	19	the	the	DT
8691	3690	20	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	3690	21	forbid	forbid	VBP
8691	3690	22	only	only	RB
8691	3690	23	such	such	PDT
8691	3690	24	a	a	DT
8691	3690	25	decrease	decrease	NN
8691	3690	26	of	of	IN
8691	3690	27	salary	salary	NN
8691	3690	28	.	.	.
8691	3691	1	The	the	DT
8691	3691	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3691	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3691	4	of	of	IN
8691	3691	5	the	the	DT
8691	3691	6	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3691	7	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3691	8	of	of	IN
8691	3691	9	the	the	DT
8691	3691	10	United	United	NNP
8691	3691	11	States	States	NNP
8691	3691	12	receives	receive	VBZ
8691	3691	13	$	$	$
8691	3691	14	13,000	13,000	CD
8691	3691	15	a	a	DT
8691	3691	16	year	year	NN
8691	3691	17	and	and	CC
8691	3691	18	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3691	19	associates	associate	NNS
8691	3691	20	$	$	$
8691	3691	21	12,500	12,500	CD
8691	3691	22	.	.	.
8691	3692	1	Circuit	circuit	NN
8691	3692	2	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	3692	3	have	have	VBP
8691	3692	4	$	$	$
8691	3692	5	7,000	7,000	CD
8691	3692	6	,	,	,
8691	3692	7	and	and	CC
8691	3692	8	District	District	NNP
8691	3692	9	Judges	Judges	NNP
8691	3692	10	$	$	$
8691	3692	11	6,000	6,000	CD
8691	3692	12	.	.	.
8691	3693	1	In	in	IN
8691	3693	2	the	the	DT
8691	3693	3	States	States	NNP
8691	3693	4	,	,	,
8691	3693	5	the	the	DT
8691	3693	6	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3693	7	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3693	8	of	of	IN
8691	3693	9	the	the	DT
8691	3693	10	New	New	NNP
8691	3693	11	York	York	NNP
8691	3693	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3693	13	of	of	IN
8691	3693	14	Appeals	Appeals	NNP
8691	3693	15	receives	receive	VBZ
8691	3693	16	$	$	$
8691	3693	17	10,500	10,500	CD
8691	3693	18	and	and	CC
8691	3693	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3693	20	associates	associate	NNS
8691	3693	21	$	$	$
8691	3693	22	10,000	10,000	CD
8691	3693	23	.	.	.
8691	3694	1	The	the	DT
8691	3694	2	same	same	JJ
8691	3694	3	salaries	salary	NNS
8691	3694	4	are	be	VBP
8691	3694	5	given	give	VBN
8691	3694	6	in	in	IN
8691	3694	7	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3694	8	.	.	.
8691	3695	1	In	in	IN
8691	3695	2	New	New	NNP
8691	3695	3	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	3695	4	,	,	,
8691	3695	5	the	the	DT
8691	3695	6	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	3695	7	and	and	CC
8691	3695	8	the	the	DT
8691	3695	9	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3695	10	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3695	11	each	each	DT
8691	3695	12	receive	receive	VBP
8691	3695	13	$	$	$
8691	3695	14	10,000	10,000	CD
8691	3695	15	and	and	CC
8691	3695	16	the	the	DT
8691	3695	17	associate	associate	JJ
8691	3695	18	judges	judge	VBZ
8691	3695	19	$	$	$
8691	3695	20	9,000	9,000	CD
8691	3695	21	.	.	.
8691	3696	1	In	in	IN
8691	3696	2	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3696	3	,	,	,
8691	3696	4	the	the	DT
8691	3696	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3696	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3696	7	receives	receive	VBZ
8691	3696	8	$	$	$
8691	3696	9	8,500	8,500	CD
8691	3696	10	and	and	CC
8691	3696	11	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3696	12	associates	associate	NNS
8691	3696	13	$	$	$
8691	3696	14	8,000	8,000	CD
8691	3696	15	.	.	.
8691	3697	1	In	in	IN
8691	3697	2	the	the	DT
8691	3697	3	other	other	JJ
8691	3697	4	States	state	NNS
8691	3697	5	less	less	RBR
8691	3697	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3697	7	paid	pay	VBN
8691	3697	8	,	,	,
8691	3697	9	the	the	DT
8691	3697	10	average	average	NN
8691	3697	11	for	for	IN
8691	3697	12	associate	associate	JJ
8691	3697	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3697	14	in	in	IN
8691	3697	15	the	the	DT
8691	3697	16	highest	high	JJS
8691	3697	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	3697	18	being	be	VBG
8691	3697	19	about	about	IN
8691	3697	20	$	$	$
8691	3697	21	4,350	4,350	CD
8691	3697	22	.	.	.
8691	3698	1	Only	only	RB
8691	3698	2	nine	nine	CD
8691	3698	3	States	state	NNS
8691	3698	4	pay	pay	VBP
8691	3698	5	over	over	IN
8691	3698	6	$	$	$
8691	3698	7	5,000	5,000	CD
8691	3698	8	.	.	.
8691	3699	1	The	the	DT
8691	3699	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3699	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3699	4	in	in	IN
8691	3699	5	many	many	JJ
8691	3699	6	receives	receive	NNS
8691	3699	7	$	$	$
8691	3699	8	500	500	CD
8691	3699	9	more	more	JJR
8691	3699	10	.	.	.
8691	3700	1	These	these	DT
8691	3700	2	salaries	salary	NNS
8691	3700	3	are	be	VBP
8691	3700	4	,	,	,
8691	3700	5	however	however	RB
8691	3700	6	,	,	,
8691	3700	7	generally	generally	RB
8691	3700	8	supplemented	supplement	VBN
8691	3700	9	by	by	IN
8691	3700	10	a	a	DT
8691	3700	11	liberal	liberal	JJ
8691	3700	12	allowance	allowance	NN
8691	3700	13	for	for	IN
8691	3700	14	expenses	expense	NNS
8691	3700	15	,	,	,
8691	3700	16	and	and	CC
8691	3700	17	in	in	IN
8691	3700	18	some	some	DT
8691	3700	19	States	state	NNS
8691	3700	20	each	each	DT
8691	3700	21	judge	judge	NN
8691	3700	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	3700	23	provided	provide	VBN
8691	3700	24	with	with	IN
8691	3700	25	a	a	DT
8691	3700	26	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	3700	27	.	.	.
8691	3701	1	In	in	IN
8691	3701	2	New	New	NNP
8691	3701	3	York	York	NNP
8691	3701	4	,	,	,
8691	3701	5	this	this	DT
8691	3701	6	addition	addition	NN
8691	3701	7	amounts	amount	VBZ
8691	3701	8	to	to	IN
8691	3701	9	$	$	$
8691	3701	10	3,700	3,700	CD
8691	3701	11	;	;	:
8691	3701	12	in	in	IN
8691	3701	13	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3701	14	,	,	,
8691	3701	15	to	to	IN
8691	3701	16	$	$	$
8691	3701	17	1,500	1,500	CD
8691	3701	18	;	;	:
8691	3701	19	in	in	IN
8691	3701	20	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
8691	3701	21	,	,	,
8691	3701	22	to	to	IN
8691	3701	23	$	$	$
8691	3701	24	300	300	CD
8691	3701	25	.	.	.
8691	3702	1	The	the	DT
8691	3702	2	salaries	salary	NNS
8691	3702	3	for	for	IN
8691	3702	4	the	the	DT
8691	3702	5	highest	high	JJS
8691	3702	6	trial	trial	NN
8691	3702	7	court	court	NN
8691	3702	8	generally	generally	RB
8691	3702	9	closely	closely	RB
8691	3702	10	approximate	approximate	VBP
8691	3702	11	those	those	DT
8691	3702	12	paid	pay	VBN
8691	3702	13	to	to	IN
8691	3702	14	the	the	DT
8691	3702	15	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3702	16	of	of	IN
8691	3702	17	the	the	DT
8691	3702	18	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3702	19	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3702	20	,	,	,
8691	3702	21	and	and	CC
8691	3702	22	in	in	IN
8691	3702	23	case	case	NN
8691	3702	24	of	of	IN
8691	3702	25	trial	trial	NN
8691	3702	26	courts	court	NNS
8691	3702	27	held	hold	VBN
8691	3702	28	in	in	IN
8691	3702	29	large	large	JJ
8691	3702	30	cities	city	NNS
8691	3702	31	are	be	VBP
8691	3702	32	often	often	RB
8691	3702	33	greater	great	JJR
8691	3702	34	.	.	.
8691	3703	1	Those	those	DT
8691	3703	2	for	for	IN
8691	3703	3	the	the	DT
8691	3703	4	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3703	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	3703	6	are	be	VBP
8691	3703	7	much	much	RB
8691	3703	8	lower	low	JJR
8691	3703	9	.	.	.
8691	3704	1	The	the	DT
8691	3704	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3704	3	of	of	IN
8691	3704	4	the	the	DT
8691	3704	5	principal	principal	NN
8691	3704	6	_	_	NNP
8691	3704	7	nisi	nisi	NNP
8691	3704	8	prius	prius	NNP
8691	3704	9	_	_	NNP
8691	3704	10	court	court	NN
8691	3704	11	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3704	12	which	which	WDT
8691	3704	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	3704	14	misnamed	misname	VBN
8691	3704	15	the	the	DT
8691	3704	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3704	17	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3704	18	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3704	19	in	in	IN
8691	3704	20	New	New	NNP
8691	3704	21	York	York	NNP
8691	3704	22	City	City	NNP
8691	3704	23	are	be	VBP
8691	3704	24	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	3704	25	by	by	IN
8691	3704	26	law	law	NN
8691	3704	27	to	to	TO
8691	3704	28	accept	accept	VB
8691	3704	29	additional	additional	JJ
8691	3704	30	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	3704	31	from	from	IN
8691	3704	32	the	the	DT
8691	3704	33	county	county	NN
8691	3704	34	,	,	,
8691	3704	35	and	and	CC
8691	3704	36	receive	receive	VB
8691	3704	37	from	from	IN
8691	3704	38	that	that	DT
8691	3704	39	source	source	NN
8691	3704	40	more	more	JJR
8691	3704	41	than	than	IN
8691	3704	42	from	from	IN
8691	3704	43	the	the	DT
8691	3704	44	State	State	NNP
8691	3704	45	,	,	,
8691	3704	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3704	47	total	total	JJ
8691	3704	48	official	official	JJ
8691	3704	49	income	income	NN
8691	3704	50	being	be	VBG
8691	3704	51	$	$	$
8691	3704	52	17,500	17,500	CD
8691	3704	53	.	.	.
8691	3705	1	The	the	DT
8691	3705	2	trial	trial	NN
8691	3705	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3705	4	in	in	IN
8691	3705	5	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
8691	3705	6	also	also	RB
8691	3705	7	receive	receive	VBP
8691	3705	8	$	$	$
8691	3705	9	10,000	10,000	CD
8691	3705	10	,	,	,
8691	3705	11	although	although	IN
8691	3705	12	the	the	DT
8691	3705	13	highest	high	JJS
8691	3705	14	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3705	15	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3705	16	in	in	IN
8691	3705	17	the	the	DT
8691	3705	18	State	State	NNP
8691	3705	19	have	have	VBP
8691	3705	20	a	a	DT
8691	3705	21	salary	salary	NN
8691	3705	22	of	of	IN
8691	3705	23	only	only	RB
8691	3705	24	$	$	$
8691	3705	25	7,000	7,000	CD
8691	3705	26	.	.	.
8691	3706	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3706	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3706	3	not	not	RB
8691	3706	4	surprising	surprising	JJ
8691	3706	5	that	that	IN
8691	3706	6	American	american	JJ
8691	3706	7	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3706	8	salaries	salary	NNS
8691	3706	9	are	be	VBP
8691	3706	10	no	no	RB
8691	3706	11	greater	great	JJR
8691	3706	12	,	,	,
8691	3706	13	but	but	CC
8691	3706	14	rather	rather	RB
8691	3706	15	that	that	IN
8691	3706	16	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3706	17	are	be	VBP
8691	3706	18	so	so	RB
8691	3706	19	large	large	JJ
8691	3706	20	.	.	.
8691	3707	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3707	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3707	3	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	3707	4	by	by	IN
8691	3707	5	a	a	DT
8691	3707	6	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3707	7	,	,	,
8691	3707	8	the	the	DT
8691	3707	9	majority	majority	NN
8691	3707	10	of	of	IN
8691	3707	11	the	the	DT
8691	3707	12	members	member	NNS
8691	3707	13	of	of	IN
8691	3707	14	which	which	WDT
8691	3707	15	are	be	VBP
8691	3707	16	men	man	NNS
8691	3707	17	of	of	IN
8691	3707	18	very	very	RB
8691	3707	19	moderate	moderate	JJ
8691	3707	20	income	income	NN
8691	3707	21	,	,	,
8691	3707	22	and	and	CC
8691	3707	23	when	when	WRB
8691	3707	24	originally	originally	RB
8691	3707	25	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	3707	26	in	in	IN
8691	3707	27	the	the	DT
8691	3707	28	older	old	JJR
8691	3707	29	States	States	NNP
8691	3707	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3707	31	was	be	VBD
8691	3707	32	often	often	RB
8691	3707	33	by	by	IN
8691	3707	34	men	man	NNS
8691	3707	35	not	not	RB
8691	3707	36	altogether	altogether	RB
8691	3707	37	friendly	friendly	JJ
8691	3707	38	to	to	IN
8691	3707	39	the	the	DT
8691	3707	40	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	3707	41	.	.	.
8691	3708	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3708	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3708	3	a	a	DT
8691	3708	4	saying	saying	NN
8691	3708	5	of	of	IN
8691	3708	6	Aaron	Aaron	NNP
8691	3708	7	Burr	Burr	NNP
8691	3708	8	,	,	,
8691	3708	9	which	which	WDT
8691	3708	10	was	be	VBD
8691	3708	11	not	not	RB
8691	3708	12	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	3708	13	untrue	untrue	JJ
8691	3708	14	in	in	IN
8691	3708	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3708	16	day	day	NN
8691	3708	17	,	,	,
8691	3708	18	that	that	IN
8691	3708	19	"	"	``
8691	3708	20	every	every	DT
8691	3708	21	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3708	22	in	in	IN
8691	3708	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3708	24	treatment	treatment	NN
8691	3708	25	of	of	IN
8691	3708	26	the	the	DT
8691	3708	27	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	3708	28	is	be	VBZ
8691	3708	29	a	a	DT
8691	3708	30	damned	damn	VBN
8691	3708	31	Jacobin	Jacobin	NNP
8691	3708	32	club	club	NN
8691	3708	33	.	.	.
8691	3709	1	"	"	``
8691	3709	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3709	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3709	4	:	:	:
8691	3709	5	"	"	``
8691	3709	6	Memoir	Memoir	NNP
8691	3709	7	of	of	IN
8691	3709	8	Jeremiah	Jeremiah	NNP
8691	3709	9	Mason	Mason	NNP
8691	3709	10	,	,	,
8691	3709	11	"	"	``
8691	3709	12	186	186	CD
8691	3709	13	.	.	.
8691	3709	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3710	1	Only	only	RB
8691	3710	2	the	the	DT
8691	3710	3	influence	influence	NN
8691	3710	4	of	of	IN
8691	3710	5	the	the	DT
8691	3710	6	bar	bar	NN
8691	3710	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	3710	8	carried	carry	VBN
8691	3710	9	through	through	IN
8691	3710	10	the	the	DT
8691	3710	11	successive	successive	JJ
8691	3710	12	increases	increase	NNS
8691	3710	13	which	which	WDT
8691	3710	14	have	have	VBP
8691	3710	15	been	be	VBN
8691	3710	16	everywhere	everywhere	RB
8691	3710	17	made	make	VBN
8691	3710	18	.	.	.
8691	3711	1	The	the	DT
8691	3711	2	first	first	JJ
8691	3711	3	pension	pension	NN
8691	3711	4	to	to	IN
8691	3711	5	a	a	DT
8691	3711	6	retired	retired	JJ
8691	3711	7	judge	judge	NN
8691	3711	8	ever	ever	RB
8691	3711	9	granted	grant	VBN
8691	3711	10	in	in	IN
8691	3711	11	the	the	DT
8691	3711	12	United	United	NNP
8691	3711	13	States	States	NNP
8691	3711	14	was	be	VBD
8691	3711	15	one	one	CD
8691	3711	16	of	of	IN
8691	3711	17	$	$	$
8691	3711	18	300	300	CD
8691	3711	19	voted	vote	VBD
8691	3711	20	in	in	IN
8691	3711	21	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	3711	22	in	in	IN
8691	3711	23	1803	1803	CD
8691	3711	24	.	.	.
8691	3712	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3712	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3712	3	offered	offer	VBN
8691	3712	4	to	to	IN
8691	3712	5	one	one	CD
8691	3712	6	of	of	IN
8691	3712	7	the	the	DT
8691	3712	8	members	member	NNS
8691	3712	9	of	of	IN
8691	3712	10	the	the	DT
8691	3712	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3712	12	of	of	IN
8691	3712	13	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	3712	14	to	to	TO
8691	3712	15	induce	induce	VB
8691	3712	16	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3712	17	to	to	TO
8691	3712	18	resign	resign	VB
8691	3712	19	,	,	,
8691	3712	20	but	but	CC
8691	3712	21	the	the	DT
8691	3712	22	year	year	NN
8691	3712	23	after	after	IN
8691	3712	24	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3712	25	resignation	resignation	NN
8691	3712	26	the	the	DT
8691	3712	27	statute	statute	NN
8691	3712	28	was	be	VBD
8691	3712	29	repealed	repeal	VBN
8691	3712	30	on	on	IN
8691	3712	31	the	the	DT
8691	3712	32	ground	ground	NN
8691	3712	33	that	that	IN
8691	3712	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3712	35	was	be	VBD
8691	3712	36	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	3712	37	.	.	.
8691	3713	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3713	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3713	3	:	:	:
8691	3713	4	Sumner	Sumner	NNP
8691	3713	5	,	,	,
8691	3713	6	"	"	''
8691	3713	7	Life	Life	NNP
8691	3713	8	of	of	IN
8691	3713	9	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
8691	3713	10	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	3713	11	,	,	,
8691	3713	12	"	"	``
8691	3713	13	120	120	CD
8691	3713	14	.	.	.
8691	3713	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3714	1	Since	since	IN
8691	3714	2	1869	1869	CD
8691	3714	3	,	,	,
8691	3714	4	the	the	DT
8691	3714	5	United	United	NNP
8691	3714	6	States	States	NNP
8691	3714	7	have	have	VBP
8691	3714	8	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	3714	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3714	10	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3714	11	who	who	WP
8691	3714	12	have	have	VBP
8691	3714	13	reached	reach	VBN
8691	3714	14	the	the	DT
8691	3714	15	age	age	NN
8691	3714	16	of	of	IN
8691	3714	17	seventy	seventy	CD
8691	3714	18	,	,	,
8691	3714	19	after	after	IN
8691	3714	20	not	not	RB
8691	3714	21	less	less	JJR
8691	3714	22	than	than	IN
8691	3714	23	ten	ten	CD
8691	3714	24	years	year	NNS
8691	3714	25	'	'	POS
8691	3714	26	service	service	NN
8691	3714	27	,	,	,
8691	3714	28	to	to	TO
8691	3714	29	retire	retire	VB
8691	3714	30	,	,	,
8691	3714	31	at	at	IN
8691	3714	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3714	33	option	option	NN
8691	3714	34	,	,	,
8691	3714	35	receiving	receive	VBG
8691	3714	36	the	the	DT
8691	3714	37	full	full	JJ
8691	3714	38	official	official	JJ
8691	3714	39	salary	salary	NN
8691	3714	40	during	during	IN
8691	3714	41	the	the	DT
8691	3714	42	remainder	remainder	NN
8691	3714	43	of	of	IN
8691	3714	44	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3714	45	lives	life	NNS
8691	3714	46	.	.	.
8691	3715	1	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	3715	2	Island	Island	NNP
8691	3715	3	gives	give	VBZ
8691	3715	4	hers	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3715	5	the	the	DT
8691	3715	6	same	same	JJ
8691	3715	7	privilege	privilege	NN
8691	3715	8	after	after	IN
8691	3715	9	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3715	10	-	-	HYPH
8691	3715	11	five	five	CD
8691	3715	12	years	year	NNS
8691	3715	13	'	'	POS
8691	3715	14	service	service	NN
8691	3715	15	,	,	,
8691	3715	16	and	and	CC
8691	3715	17	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3715	18	and	and	CC
8691	3715	19	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	3715	20	have	have	VBP
8691	3715	21	somewhat	somewhat	RB
8691	3715	22	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3715	23	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	3715	24	,	,	,
8691	3715	25	except	except	IN
8691	3715	26	that	that	IN
8691	3715	27	the	the	DT
8691	3715	28	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3715	29	on	on	IN
8691	3715	30	retirement	retirement	NN
8691	3715	31	receive	receive	NN
8691	3715	32	but	but	CC
8691	3715	33	part	part	NN
8691	3715	34	of	of	IN
8691	3715	35	what	what	WP
8691	3715	36	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3715	37	formerly	formerly	RB
8691	3715	38	did	do	VBD
8691	3715	39	.	.	.
8691	3716	1	The	the	DT
8691	3716	2	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3716	3	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3716	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3716	5	in	in	IN
8691	3716	6	the	the	DT
8691	3716	7	habit	habit	NN
8691	3716	8	of	of	IN
8691	3716	9	appointing	appoint	VBG
8691	3716	10	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3716	11	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3716	12	,	,	,
8691	3716	13	both	both	DT
8691	3716	14	of	of	IN
8691	3716	15	the	the	DT
8691	3716	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3716	17	and	and	CC
8691	3716	18	Superior	Superior	NNP
8691	3716	19	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3716	20	,	,	,
8691	3716	21	when	when	WRB
8691	3716	22	retired	retire	VBN
8691	3716	23	at	at	IN
8691	3716	24	the	the	DT
8691	3716	25	age	age	NN
8691	3716	26	of	of	IN
8691	3716	27	seventy	seventy	CD
8691	3716	28	,	,	,
8691	3716	29	State	state	NN
8691	3716	30	referees	referee	NNS
8691	3716	31	for	for	IN
8691	3716	32	life	life	NN
8691	3716	33	,	,	,
8691	3716	34	with	with	IN
8691	3716	35	an	an	DT
8691	3716	36	allowance	allowance	NN
8691	3716	37	of	of	IN
8691	3716	38	$	$	$
8691	3716	39	2,500	2,500	CD
8691	3716	40	for	for	IN
8691	3716	41	salary	salary	NN
8691	3716	42	and	and	CC
8691	3716	43	expenses	expense	NNS
8691	3716	44	,	,	,
8691	3716	45	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3716	46	duties	duty	NNS
8691	3716	47	being	be	VBG
8691	3716	48	to	to	TO
8691	3716	49	try	try	VB
8691	3716	50	such	such	JJ
8691	3716	51	questions	question	NNS
8691	3716	52	of	of	IN
8691	3716	53	fact	fact	NN
8691	3716	54	as	as	IN
8691	3716	55	the	the	DT
8691	3716	56	courts	court	NNS
8691	3716	57	may	may	MD
8691	3716	58	refer	refer	VB
8691	3716	59	to	to	IN
8691	3716	60	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3716	61	and	and	CC
8691	3716	62	to	to	TO
8691	3716	63	report	report	VB
8691	3716	64	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3716	65	conclusions	conclusion	NNS
8691	3716	66	.	.	.
8691	3717	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3717	2	State	State	NNP
8691	3717	3	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	3717	4	now	now	RB
8691	3717	5	generally	generally	RB
8691	3717	6	provide	provide	VBP
8691	3717	7	that	that	IN
8691	3717	8	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3717	9	shall	shall	MD
8691	3717	10	hold	hold	VB
8691	3717	11	no	no	DT
8691	3717	12	other	other	JJ
8691	3717	13	public	public	JJ
8691	3717	14	office	office	NN
8691	3717	15	.	.	.
8691	3718	1	Some	some	DT
8691	3718	2	also	also	RB
8691	3718	3	provide	provide	VBP
8691	3718	4	that	that	IN
8691	3718	5	all	all	DT
8691	3718	6	votes	vote	NNS
8691	3718	7	for	for	IN
8691	3718	8	any	any	DT
8691	3718	9	of	of	IN
8691	3718	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3718	11	for	for	IN
8691	3718	12	any	any	DT
8691	3718	13	other	other	JJ
8691	3718	14	than	than	IN
8691	3718	15	a	a	DT
8691	3718	16	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3718	17	office	office	NN
8691	3718	18	shall	shall	MD
8691	3718	19	be	be	VB
8691	3718	20	void	void	JJ
8691	3718	21	.	.	.
8691	3719	1	*	*	NFP
8691	3719	2	*	*	NFP
8691	3719	3	*	*	NFP
8691	3719	4	*	*	NFP
8691	3719	5	*	*	NFP
8691	3719	6	Occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	3719	7	a	a	DT
8691	3719	8	judge	judge	NN
8691	3719	9	,	,	,
8691	3719	10	in	in	IN
8691	3719	11	order	order	NN
8691	3719	12	to	to	TO
8691	3719	13	eke	eke	VB
8691	3719	14	out	out	RP
8691	3719	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3719	16	official	official	JJ
8691	3719	17	income	income	NN
8691	3719	18	,	,	,
8691	3719	19	accepts	accept	VBZ
8691	3719	20	a	a	DT
8691	3719	21	salaried	salaried	JJ
8691	3719	22	position	position	NN
8691	3719	23	,	,	,
8691	3719	24	calling	call	VBG
8691	3719	25	for	for	IN
8691	3719	26	but	but	CC
8691	3719	27	little	little	JJ
8691	3719	28	of	of	IN
8691	3719	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3719	30	time	time	NN
8691	3719	31	,	,	,
8691	3719	32	in	in	IN
8691	3719	33	a	a	DT
8691	3719	34	matter	matter	NN
8691	3719	35	of	of	IN
8691	3719	36	private	private	JJ
8691	3719	37	business	business	NN
8691	3719	38	employment	employment	NN
8691	3719	39	.	.	.
8691	3720	1	This	this	DT
8691	3720	2	,	,	,
8691	3720	3	however	however	RB
8691	3720	4	,	,	,
8691	3720	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3720	6	rarely	rarely	RB
8691	3720	7	done	do	VBN
8691	3720	8	and	and	CC
8691	3720	9	there	there	EX
8691	3720	10	are	be	VBP
8691	3720	11	obvious	obvious	JJ
8691	3720	12	objections	objection	NNS
8691	3720	13	to	to	IN
8691	3720	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3720	15	when	when	WRB
8691	3720	16	the	the	DT
8691	3720	17	employer	employer	NN
8691	3720	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	3720	19	one	one	NN
8691	3720	20	likely	likely	JJ
8691	3720	21	to	to	TO
8691	3720	22	have	have	VB
8691	3720	23	business	business	NN
8691	3720	24	before	before	IN
8691	3720	25	the	the	DT
8691	3720	26	court	court	NN
8691	3720	27	.	.	.
8691	3721	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	3721	2	of	of	IN
8691	3721	3	the	the	DT
8691	3721	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3721	5	of	of	IN
8691	3721	6	the	the	DT
8691	3721	7	higher	high	JJR
8691	3721	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	3721	9	,	,	,
8691	3721	10	including	include	VBG
8691	3721	11	several	several	JJ
8691	3721	12	of	of	IN
8691	3721	13	the	the	DT
8691	3721	14	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3721	15	of	of	IN
8691	3721	16	the	the	DT
8691	3721	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3721	18	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3721	19	of	of	IN
8691	3721	20	the	the	DT
8691	3721	21	United	United	NNP
8691	3721	22	States	States	NNP
8691	3721	23	,	,	,
8691	3721	24	are	be	VBP
8691	3721	25	professors	professor	NNS
8691	3721	26	or	or	CC
8691	3721	27	lecturers	lecturer	NNS
8691	3721	28	in	in	IN
8691	3721	29	law	law	NN
8691	3721	30	schools	school	NNS
8691	3721	31	.	.	.
8691	3722	1	The	the	DT
8691	3722	2	best	good	JJS
8691	3722	3	mode	mode	NN
8691	3722	4	of	of	IN
8691	3722	5	appointing	appoint	VBG
8691	3722	6	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3722	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3722	8	that	that	DT
8691	3722	9	which	which	WDT
8691	3722	10	secures	secure	VBZ
8691	3722	11	the	the	DT
8691	3722	12	best	good	JJS
8691	3722	13	men	man	NNS
8691	3722	14	.	.	.
8691	3723	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	3723	2	men	man	NNS
8691	3723	3	are	be	VBP
8691	3723	4	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
8691	3723	5	to	to	TO
8691	3723	6	accept	accept	VB
8691	3723	7	a	a	DT
8691	3723	8	place	place	NN
8691	3723	9	on	on	IN
8691	3723	10	the	the	DT
8691	3723	11	bench	bench	NN
8691	3723	12	of	of	IN
8691	3723	13	one	one	CD
8691	3723	14	of	of	IN
8691	3723	15	the	the	DT
8691	3723	16	higher	high	JJR
8691	3723	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	3723	18	,	,	,
8691	3723	19	unless	unless	IN
8691	3723	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3723	21	carries	carry	VBZ
8691	3723	22	with	with	IN
8691	3723	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3723	24	some	some	DT
8691	3723	25	prospect	prospect	NN
8691	3723	26	of	of	IN
8691	3723	27	permanence	permanence	NN
8691	3723	28	.	.	.
8691	3724	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3724	2	does	do	VBZ
8691	3724	3	,	,	,
8691	3724	4	if	if	IN
8691	3724	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3724	6	comes	come	VBZ
8691	3724	7	to	to	IN
8691	3724	8	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3724	9	by	by	IN
8691	3724	10	way	way	NN
8691	3724	11	of	of	IN
8691	3724	12	promotion	promotion	NN
8691	3724	13	after	after	IN
8691	3724	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3724	15	have	have	VBP
8691	3724	16	served	serve	VBN
8691	3724	17	acceptably	acceptably	RB
8691	3724	18	for	for	IN
8691	3724	19	a	a	DT
8691	3724	20	length	length	NN
8691	3724	21	of	of	IN
8691	3724	22	time	time	NN
8691	3724	23	in	in	IN
8691	3724	24	an	an	DT
8691	3724	25	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3724	26	court	court	NN
8691	3724	27	.	.	.
8691	3725	1	But	but	CC
8691	3725	2	most	most	JJS
8691	3725	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3725	4	must	must	MD
8691	3725	5	be	be	VB
8691	3725	6	taken	take	VBN
8691	3725	7	from	from	IN
8691	3725	8	the	the	DT
8691	3725	9	bar	bar	NN
8691	3725	10	and	and	CC
8691	3725	11	,	,	,
8691	3725	12	save	save	VB
8691	3725	13	in	in	IN
8691	3725	14	very	very	RB
8691	3725	15	unusual	unusual	JJ
8691	3725	16	cases	case	NNS
8691	3725	17	,	,	,
8691	3725	18	will	will	MD
8691	3725	19	be	be	VB
8691	3725	20	in	in	IN
8691	3725	21	large	large	JJ
8691	3725	22	and	and	CC
8691	3725	23	active	active	JJ
8691	3725	24	practice	practice	NN
8691	3725	25	.	.	.
8691	3726	1	This	this	DT
8691	3726	2	must	must	MD
8691	3726	3	be	be	VB
8691	3726	4	totally	totally	RB
8691	3726	5	abandoned	abandon	VBN
8691	3726	6	if	if	IN
8691	3726	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3726	8	take	take	VBP
8691	3726	9	one	one	CD
8691	3726	10	of	of	IN
8691	3726	11	the	the	DT
8691	3726	12	higher	high	JJR
8691	3726	13	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3726	14	positions	position	NNS
8691	3726	15	;	;	:
8691	3726	16	and	and	CC
8691	3726	17	if	if	IN
8691	3726	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3726	19	take	take	VBP
8691	3726	20	the	the	DT
8691	3726	21	lowest	low	JJS
8691	3726	22	,	,	,
8691	3726	23	must	must	MD
8691	3726	24	be	be	VB
8691	3726	25	made	make	VBN
8691	3726	26	secondary	secondary	JJ
8691	3726	27	to	to	IN
8691	3726	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3726	29	.	.	.
8691	3727	1	A	a	DT
8691	3727	2	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	3727	3	's	's	POS
8691	3727	4	practice	practice	NN
8691	3727	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3727	6	more	more	RBR
8691	3727	7	easily	easily	RB
8691	3727	8	lost	lose	VBN
8691	3727	9	than	than	IN
8691	3727	10	gathered	gather	VBN
8691	3727	11	.	.	.
8691	3728	1	If	if	IN
8691	3728	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3728	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3728	4	a	a	DT
8691	3728	5	solid	solid	JJ
8691	3728	6	one	one	NN
8691	3728	7	,	,	,
8691	3728	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3728	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	3728	10	of	of	IN
8691	3728	11	slow	slow	JJ
8691	3728	12	growth	growth	NN
8691	3728	13	.	.	.
8691	3729	1	For	for	IN
8691	3729	2	one	one	CD
8691	3729	3	who	who	WP
8691	3729	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	3729	5	turned	turn	VBN
8691	3729	6	from	from	IN
8691	3729	7	the	the	DT
8691	3729	8	bar	bar	NN
8691	3729	9	to	to	IN
8691	3729	10	the	the	DT
8691	3729	11	bench	bench	NN
8691	3729	12	to	to	TO
8691	3729	13	expect	expect	VB
8691	3729	14	on	on	IN
8691	3729	15	retirement	retirement	NN
8691	3729	16	from	from	IN
8691	3729	17	office	office	NN
8691	3729	18	to	to	TO
8691	3729	19	resume	resume	VB
8691	3729	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3729	21	old	old	JJ
8691	3729	22	practice	practice	NN
8691	3729	23	would	would	MD
8691	3729	24	be	be	VB
8691	3729	25	to	to	TO
8691	3729	26	expect	expect	VB
8691	3729	27	the	the	DT
8691	3729	28	impossible	impossible	JJ
8691	3729	29	.	.	.
8691	3730	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3730	2	may	may	MD
8691	3730	3	have	have	VB
8691	3730	4	achieved	achieve	VBN
8691	3730	5	a	a	DT
8691	3730	6	position	position	NN
8691	3730	7	by	by	IN
8691	3730	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3730	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3730	10	work	work	NN
8691	3730	11	which	which	WDT
8691	3730	12	will	will	MD
8691	3730	13	enable	enable	VB
8691	3730	14	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3730	15	to	to	TO
8691	3730	16	take	take	VB
8691	3730	17	a	a	DT
8691	3730	18	better	well	JJR
8691	3730	19	position	position	NN
8691	3730	20	at	at	IN
8691	3730	21	the	the	DT
8691	3730	22	bar	bar	NN
8691	3730	23	;	;	:
8691	3730	24	but	but	CC
8691	3730	25	in	in	IN
8691	3730	26	that	that	DT
8691	3730	27	case	case	NN
8691	3730	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3730	29	clients	client	NNS
8691	3730	30	will	will	MD
8691	3730	31	be	be	VB
8691	3730	32	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	3730	33	new	new	JJ
8691	3730	34	ones	one	NNS
8691	3730	35	.	.	.
8691	3731	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3731	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3731	3	more	more	RBR
8691	3731	4	likely	likely	JJ
8691	3731	5	,	,	,
8691	3731	6	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	3731	7	if	if	IN
8691	3731	8	no	no	RB
8691	3731	9	longer	long	RBR
8691	3731	10	young	young	JJ
8691	3731	11	,	,	,
8691	3731	12	to	to	TO
8691	3731	13	sink	sink	VB
8691	3731	14	into	into	IN
8691	3731	15	a	a	DT
8691	3731	16	meagre	meagre	JJ
8691	3731	17	office	office	NN
8691	3731	18	practice	practice	NN
8691	3731	19	and	and	CC
8691	3731	20	feel	feel	VBP
8691	3731	21	the	the	DT
8691	3731	22	pinch	pinch	NN
8691	3731	23	of	of	IN
8691	3731	24	narrow	narrow	JJ
8691	3731	25	means	mean	NNS
8691	3731	26	,	,	,
8691	3731	27	always	always	RB
8691	3731	28	doubly	doubly	RB
8691	3731	29	sharp	sharp	JJ
8691	3731	30	to	to	IN
8691	3731	31	one	one	CD
8691	3731	32	who	who	WP
8691	3731	33	by	by	IN
8691	3731	34	force	force	NN
8691	3731	35	of	of	IN
8691	3731	36	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	3731	37	has	have	VBZ
8691	3731	38	a	a	DT
8691	3731	39	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3731	40	social	social	JJ
8691	3731	41	standing	standing	NN
8691	3731	42	to	to	TO
8691	3731	43	maintain	maintain	VB
8691	3731	44	.	.	.
8691	3732	1	The	the	DT
8691	3732	2	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	3732	3	at	at	IN
8691	3732	4	the	the	DT
8691	3732	5	bar	bar	NN
8691	3732	6	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	3732	7	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	3732	8	consent	consent	VBP
8691	3732	9	to	to	TO
8691	3732	10	go	go	VB
8691	3732	11	upon	upon	IN
8691	3732	12	the	the	DT
8691	3732	13	bench	bench	NN
8691	3732	14	unless	unless	IN
8691	3732	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3732	16	have	have	VBP
8691	3732	17	property	property	NN
8691	3732	18	enough	enough	RB
8691	3732	19	to	to	TO
8691	3732	20	ensure	ensure	VB
8691	3732	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3732	22	comfortable	comfortable	JJ
8691	3732	23	support	support	NN
8691	3732	24	after	after	IN
8691	3732	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3732	26	leave	leave	VBP
8691	3732	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3732	28	,	,	,
8691	3732	29	without	without	IN
8691	3732	30	returning	return	VBG
8691	3732	31	to	to	IN
8691	3732	32	the	the	DT
8691	3732	33	labors	labor	NNS
8691	3732	34	of	of	IN
8691	3732	35	the	the	DT
8691	3732	36	bar	bar	NN
8691	3732	37	.	.	.
8691	3733	1	This	this	DT
8691	3733	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3733	3	one	one	CD
8691	3733	4	of	of	IN
8691	3733	5	those	those	DT
8691	3733	6	evils	evil	NNS
8691	3733	7	which	which	WDT
8691	3733	8	carry	carry	VBP
8691	3733	9	in	in	RP
8691	3733	10	some	some	DT
8691	3733	11	sort	sort	NN
8691	3733	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3733	13	own	own	JJ
8691	3733	14	antidote	antidote	NN
8691	3733	15	.	.	.
8691	3734	1	The	the	DT
8691	3734	2	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3734	3	,	,	,
8691	3734	4	as	as	IN
8691	3734	5	a	a	DT
8691	3734	6	body	body	NN
8691	3734	7	,	,	,
8691	3734	8	are	be	VBP
8691	3734	9	always	always	RB
8691	3734	10	anxious	anxious	JJ
8691	3734	11	for	for	IN
8691	3734	12	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3734	13	own	own	JJ
8691	3734	14	sake	sake	NN
8691	3734	15	to	to	TO
8691	3734	16	have	have	VB
8691	3734	17	an	an	DT
8691	3734	18	able	able	JJ
8691	3734	19	and	and	CC
8691	3734	20	independent	independent	JJ
8691	3734	21	bench	bench	NN
8691	3734	22	.	.	.
8691	3735	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3735	2	do	do	VBP
8691	3735	3	not	not	RB
8691	3735	4	wish	wish	VB
8691	3735	5	to	to	TO
8691	3735	6	trust	trust	VB
8691	3735	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3735	8	causes	cause	NNS
8691	3735	9	,	,	,
8691	3735	10	when	when	WRB
8691	3735	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3735	12	come	come	VBP
8691	3735	13	before	before	IN
8691	3735	14	a	a	DT
8691	3735	15	court	court	NN
8691	3735	16	of	of	IN
8691	3735	17	last	last	JJ
8691	3735	18	resort	resort	NN
8691	3735	19	for	for	IN
8691	3735	20	final	final	JJ
8691	3735	21	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	3735	22	,	,	,
8691	3735	23	to	to	IN
8691	3735	24	men	man	NNS
8691	3735	25	of	of	IN
8691	3735	26	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3735	27	capacity	capacity	NN
8691	3735	28	and	and	CC
8691	3735	29	standing	standing	NN
8691	3735	30	.	.	.
8691	3736	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3736	2	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	3736	3	can	can	MD
8691	3736	4	generally	generally	RB
8691	3736	5	be	be	VB
8691	3736	6	relied	rely	VBN
8691	3736	7	on	on	RP
8691	3736	8	to	to	TO
8691	3736	9	urge	urge	VB
8691	3736	10	on	on	IN
8691	3736	11	the	the	DT
8691	3736	12	nominating	nominating	NN
8691	3736	13	or	or	CC
8691	3736	14	appointing	appoint	VBG
8691	3736	15	power	power	NN
8691	3736	16	the	the	DT
8691	3736	17	selection	selection	NN
8691	3736	18	of	of	IN
8691	3736	19	competent	competent	JJ
8691	3736	20	men	man	NNS
8691	3736	21	.	.	.
8691	3737	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3737	2	influence	influence	NN
8691	3737	3	in	in	IN
8691	3737	4	this	this	DT
8691	3737	5	respect	respect	NN
8691	3737	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3737	7	little	little	RB
8691	3737	8	short	short	JJ
8691	3737	9	of	of	IN
8691	3737	10	controlling	control	VBG
8691	3737	11	.	.	.
8691	3738	1	If	if	IN
8691	3738	2	competent	competent	JJ
8691	3738	3	men	man	NNS
8691	3738	4	will	will	MD
8691	3738	5	not	not	RB
8691	3738	6	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	3738	7	go	go	VB
8691	3738	8	on	on	IN
8691	3738	9	the	the	DT
8691	3738	10	bench	bench	NN
8691	3738	11	of	of	IN
8691	3738	12	an	an	DT
8691	3738	13	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	3738	14	court	court	NN
8691	3738	15	,	,	,
8691	3738	16	unless	unless	IN
8691	3738	17	by	by	IN
8691	3738	18	way	way	NN
8691	3738	19	of	of	IN
8691	3738	20	promotion	promotion	NN
8691	3738	21	,	,	,
8691	3738	22	until	until	IN
8691	3738	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3738	24	have	have	VBP
8691	3738	25	accumulated	accumulate	VBN
8691	3738	26	a	a	DT
8691	3738	27	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	3738	28	fortune	fortune	NN
8691	3738	29	to	to	TO
8691	3738	30	make	make	VB
8691	3738	31	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3738	32	comfortable	comfortable	JJ
8691	3738	33	in	in	IN
8691	3738	34	old	old	JJ
8691	3738	35	age	age	NN
8691	3738	36	,	,	,
8691	3738	37	then	then	RB
8691	3738	38	as	as	IN
8691	3738	39	competent	competent	JJ
8691	3738	40	men	man	NNS
8691	3738	41	will	will	MD
8691	3738	42	usually	usually	RB
8691	3738	43	,	,	,
8691	3738	44	in	in	IN
8691	3738	45	one	one	CD
8691	3738	46	way	way	NN
8691	3738	47	or	or	CC
8691	3738	48	another	another	DT
8691	3738	49	,	,	,
8691	3738	50	be	be	VB
8691	3738	51	selected	select	VBN
8691	3738	52	,	,	,
8691	3738	53	and	and	CC
8691	3738	54	as	as	IN
8691	3738	55	few	few	JJ
8691	3738	56	of	of	IN
8691	3738	57	these	these	DT
8691	3738	58	are	be	VBP
8691	3738	59	men	man	NNS
8691	3738	60	who	who	WP
8691	3738	61	from	from	IN
8691	3738	62	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3738	63	youth	youth	NN
8691	3738	64	have	have	VBP
8691	3738	65	been	be	VBN
8691	3738	66	occupying	occupy	VBG
8691	3738	67	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3738	68	positions	position	NNS
8691	3738	69	,	,	,
8691	3738	70	the	the	DT
8691	3738	71	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3738	72	will	will	MD
8691	3738	73	usually	usually	RB
8691	3738	74	be	be	VB
8691	3738	75	possessed	possess	VBN
8691	3738	76	of	of	IN
8691	3738	77	some	some	DT
8691	3738	78	independent	independent	JJ
8691	3738	79	means	mean	NNS
8691	3738	80	.	.	.
8691	3739	1	A	a	DT
8691	3739	2	property	property	NN
8691	3739	3	qualification	qualification	NN
8691	3739	4	almost	almost	RB
8691	3739	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3739	6	thus	thus	RB
8691	3739	7	imposed	impose	VBN
8691	3739	8	by	by	IN
8691	3739	9	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	3739	10	on	on	IN
8691	3739	11	those	those	DT
8691	3739	12	forming	form	VBG
8691	3739	13	the	the	DT
8691	3739	14	American	american	JJ
8691	3739	15	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	3739	16	in	in	IN
8691	3739	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3739	18	highest	high	JJS
8691	3739	19	places	place	NNS
8691	3739	20	.	.	.
8691	3740	1	The	the	DT
8691	3740	2	same	same	JJ
8691	3740	3	thing	thing	NN
8691	3740	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3740	5	true	true	JJ
8691	3740	6	of	of	IN
8691	3740	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3740	8	higher	high	JJR
8691	3740	9	diplomatic	diplomatic	JJ
8691	3740	10	positions	position	NNS
8691	3740	11	.	.	.
8691	3741	1	As	as	IN
8691	3741	2	Goethe	Goethe	NNP
8691	3741	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	3741	4	said	say	VBN
8691	3741	5	,	,	,
8691	3741	6	there	there	EX
8691	3741	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3741	8	a	a	DT
8691	3741	9	dignity	dignity	NN
8691	3741	10	in	in	IN
8691	3741	11	gold	gold	NN
8691	3741	12	.	.	.
8691	3742	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3742	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3742	3	a	a	DT
8691	3742	4	poor	poor	JJ
8691	3742	5	kind	kind	NN
8691	3742	6	of	of	IN
8691	3742	7	dignity	dignity	NN
8691	3742	8	when	when	WRB
8691	3742	9	unsupported	unsupporte	VBN
8691	3742	10	by	by	IN
8691	3742	11	merit	merit	NN
8691	3742	12	,	,	,
8691	3742	13	but	but	CC
8691	3742	14	if	if	IN
8691	3742	15	to	to	IN
8691	3742	16	gold	gold	NN
8691	3742	17	merit	merit	NN
8691	3742	18	be	be	VB
8691	3742	19	joined	join	VBN
8691	3742	20	,	,	,
8691	3742	21	each	each	DT
8691	3742	22	lends	lend	VBZ
8691	3742	23	to	to	IN
8691	3742	24	the	the	DT
8691	3742	25	other	other	JJ
8691	3742	26	solidity	solidity	NN
8691	3742	27	and	and	CC
8691	3742	28	power	power	NN
8691	3742	29	.	.	.
8691	3743	1	Among	among	IN
8691	3743	2	the	the	DT
8691	3743	3	men	man	NNS
8691	3743	4	of	of	IN
8691	3743	5	the	the	DT
8691	3743	6	first	first	JJ
8691	3743	7	eminence	eminence	NN
8691	3743	8	at	at	IN
8691	3743	9	the	the	DT
8691	3743	10	bar	bar	NN
8691	3743	11	whom	whom	WP
8691	3743	12	the	the	DT
8691	3743	13	meagerness	meagerness	NN
8691	3743	14	of	of	IN
8691	3743	15	the	the	DT
8691	3743	16	salary	salary	NN
8691	3743	17	has	have	VBZ
8691	3743	18	kept	keep	VBN
8691	3743	19	off	off	RP
8691	3743	20	the	the	DT
8691	3743	21	bench	bench	NN
8691	3743	22	may	may	MD
8691	3743	23	be	be	VB
8691	3743	24	mentioned	mention	VBN
8691	3743	25	Jeremiah	Jeremiah	NNP
8691	3743	26	Mason	Mason	NNP
8691	3743	27	,	,	,
8691	3743	28	who	who	WP
8691	3743	29	declined	decline	VBD
8691	3743	30	the	the	DT
8691	3743	31	position	position	NN
8691	3743	32	of	of	IN
8691	3743	33	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3743	34	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3743	35	of	of	IN
8691	3743	36	New	New	NNP
8691	3743	37	Hampshire	Hampshire	NNP
8691	3743	38	on	on	IN
8691	3743	39	this	this	DT
8691	3743	40	account	account	NN
8691	3743	41	,	,	,
8691	3743	42	and	and	CC
8691	3743	43	William	William	NNP
8691	3743	44	Wirt	Wirt	NNP
8691	3743	45	.	.	.
8691	3744	1	Wirt	wirt	VB
8691	3744	2	in	in	IN
8691	3744	3	1802	1802	CD
8691	3744	4	was	be	VBD
8691	3744	5	made	make	VBN
8691	3744	6	one	one	CD
8691	3744	7	of	of	IN
8691	3744	8	the	the	DT
8691	3744	9	Chancellors	Chancellors	NNPS
8691	3744	10	of	of	IN
8691	3744	11	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	3744	12	at	at	IN
8691	3744	13	the	the	DT
8691	3744	14	age	age	NN
8691	3744	15	of	of	IN
8691	3744	16	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3744	17	-	-	HYPH
8691	3744	18	nine	nine	CD
8691	3744	19	.	.	.
8691	3745	1	The	the	DT
8691	3745	2	salary	salary	NN
8691	3745	3	and	and	CC
8691	3745	4	fees	fee	NNS
8691	3745	5	amounted	amount	VBD
8691	3745	6	to	to	IN
8691	3745	7	about	about	RB
8691	3745	8	five	five	CD
8691	3745	9	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3745	10	pounds	pound	NNS
8691	3745	11	a	a	DT
8691	3745	12	year	year	NN
8691	3745	13	.	.	.
8691	3746	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3746	2	married	marry	VBD
8691	3746	3	on	on	IN
8691	3746	4	the	the	DT
8691	3746	5	strength	strength	NN
8691	3746	6	of	of	IN
8691	3746	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3746	8	,	,	,
8691	3746	9	but	but	CC
8691	3746	10	in	in	IN
8691	3746	11	a	a	DT
8691	3746	12	few	few	JJ
8691	3746	13	months	month	NNS
8691	3746	14	found	find	VBD
8691	3746	15	that	that	IN
8691	3746	16	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3746	17	income	income	NN
8691	3746	18	was	be	VBD
8691	3746	19	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
8691	3746	20	to	to	TO
8691	3746	21	maintain	maintain	VB
8691	3746	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3746	23	family	family	NN
8691	3746	24	,	,	,
8691	3746	25	and	and	CC
8691	3746	26	resigned	resign	VBD
8691	3746	27	.	.	.
8691	3747	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3747	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3747	3	:	:	:
8691	3747	4	"	"	``
8691	3747	5	Memoirs	Memoirs	NNP
8691	3747	6	of	of	IN
8691	3747	7	William	William	NNP
8691	3747	8	Wirt	Wirt	NNP
8691	3747	9	,	,	,
8691	3747	10	"	"	``
8691	3747	11	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3747	12	,	,	,
8691	3747	13	91	91	CD
8691	3747	14	,	,	,
8691	3747	15	99	99	CD
8691	3747	16	.	.	.
8691	3747	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3748	1	Dignity	dignity	NN
8691	3748	2	and	and	CC
8691	3748	3	power	power	NN
8691	3748	4	,	,	,
8691	3748	5	however	however	RB
8691	3748	6	,	,	,
8691	3748	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3748	8	strong	strong	JJ
8691	3748	9	attractions	attraction	NNS
8691	3748	10	.	.	.
8691	3749	1	Theophilus	Theophilus	NNP
8691	3749	2	Parsons	Parsons	NNPS
8691	3749	3	in	in	IN
8691	3749	4	1806	1806	CD
8691	3749	5	left	leave	VBD
8691	3749	6	a	a	DT
8691	3749	7	practice	practice	NN
8691	3749	8	worth	worth	JJ
8691	3749	9	$	$	$
8691	3749	10	10,000	10,000	CD
8691	3749	11	a	a	DT
8691	3749	12	year	year	NN
8691	3749	13	--	--	:
8691	3749	14	the	the	DT
8691	3749	15	largest	large	JJS
8691	3749	16	in	in	IN
8691	3749	17	New	New	NNP
8691	3749	18	England	England	NNP
8691	3749	19	in	in	IN
8691	3749	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3749	21	day	day	NN
8691	3749	22	--	--	:
8691	3749	23	to	to	TO
8691	3749	24	take	take	VB
8691	3749	25	the	the	DT
8691	3749	26	place	place	NN
8691	3749	27	of	of	IN
8691	3749	28	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3749	29	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3749	30	of	of	IN
8691	3749	31	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3749	32	on	on	IN
8691	3749	33	a	a	DT
8691	3749	34	salary	salary	NN
8691	3749	35	of	of	IN
8691	3749	36	$	$	$
8691	3749	37	2,500	2,500	CD
8691	3749	38	.	.	.
8691	3750	1	After	after	IN
8691	3750	2	three	three	CD
8691	3750	3	years	year	NNS
8691	3750	4	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3750	5	sent	send	VBD
8691	3750	6	in	in	IN
8691	3750	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3750	8	resignation	resignation	NN
8691	3750	9	,	,	,
8691	3750	10	saying	say	VBG
8691	3750	11	that	that	IN
8691	3750	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3750	13	found	find	VBD
8691	3750	14	that	that	IN
8691	3750	15	this	this	DT
8691	3750	16	sum	sum	NN
8691	3750	17	was	be	VBD
8691	3750	18	insufficient	insufficient	JJ
8691	3750	19	for	for	IN
8691	3750	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3750	21	support	support	NN
8691	3750	22	,	,	,
8691	3750	23	even	even	RB
8691	3750	24	with	with	IN
8691	3750	25	the	the	DT
8691	3750	26	addition	addition	NN
8691	3750	27	of	of	IN
8691	3750	28	the	the	DT
8691	3750	29	income	income	NN
8691	3750	30	from	from	IN
8691	3750	31	such	such	JJ
8691	3750	32	property	property	NN
8691	3750	33	as	as	IN
8691	3750	34	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3750	35	possessed	possess	VBD
8691	3750	36	.	.	.
8691	3751	1	The	the	DT
8691	3751	2	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3751	3	thereupon	thereupon	RB
8691	3751	4	raised	raise	VBD
8691	3751	5	the	the	DT
8691	3751	6	salary	salary	NN
8691	3751	7	to	to	IN
8691	3751	8	$	$	$
8691	3751	9	3,500	3,500	CD
8691	3751	10	,	,	,
8691	3751	11	and	and	CC
8691	3751	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3751	13	remained	remain	VBD
8691	3751	14	on	on	IN
8691	3751	15	the	the	DT
8691	3751	16	bench	bench	NN
8691	3751	17	through	through	IN
8691	3751	18	a	a	DT
8691	3751	19	long	long	JJ
8691	3751	20	life	life	NN
8691	3751	21	.	.	.
8691	3752	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3752	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3752	3	:	:	:
8691	3752	4	"	"	``
8691	3752	5	Memoir	Memoir	NNP
8691	3752	6	of	of	IN
8691	3752	7	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3752	8	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3752	9	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
8691	3752	10	,	,	,
8691	3752	11	"	"	``
8691	3752	12	194	194	CD
8691	3752	13	,	,	,
8691	3752	14	228	228	CD
8691	3752	15	,	,	,
8691	3752	16	230	230	CD
8691	3752	17	.	.	.
8691	3752	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3753	1	In	in	IN
8691	3753	2	1891	1891	CD
8691	3753	3	,	,	,
8691	3753	4	Richard	Richard	NNP
8691	3753	5	W.	W.	NNP
8691	3753	6	Greene	Greene	NNP
8691	3753	7	of	of	IN
8691	3753	8	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	3753	9	Island	Island	NNP
8691	3753	10	,	,	,
8691	3753	11	who	who	WP
8691	3753	12	then	then	RB
8691	3753	13	had	have	VBD
8691	3753	14	a	a	DT
8691	3753	15	practice	practice	NN
8691	3753	16	of	of	IN
8691	3753	17	$	$	$
8691	3753	18	8,000	8,000	CD
8691	3753	19	a	a	DT
8691	3753	20	year	year	NN
8691	3753	21	,	,	,
8691	3753	22	gave	give	VBD
8691	3753	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3753	24	up	up	RP
8691	3753	25	for	for	IN
8691	3753	26	the	the	DT
8691	3753	27	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3753	28	Justiceship	Justiceship	NNP
8691	3753	29	of	of	IN
8691	3753	30	the	the	DT
8691	3753	31	State	State	NNP
8691	3753	32	,	,	,
8691	3753	33	though	though	IN
8691	3753	34	the	the	DT
8691	3753	35	salary	salary	NN
8691	3753	36	was	be	VBD
8691	3753	37	then	then	RB
8691	3753	38	but	but	CC
8691	3753	39	$	$	$
8691	3753	40	750	750	CD
8691	3753	41	,	,	,
8691	3753	42	supplemented	supplement	VBN
8691	3753	43	by	by	IN
8691	3753	44	some	some	DT
8691	3753	45	trifling	trifling	NN
8691	3753	46	fees	fee	NNS
8691	3753	47	.	.	.
8691	3754	1	In	in	IN
8691	3754	2	a	a	DT
8691	3754	3	few	few	JJ
8691	3754	4	years	year	NNS
8691	3754	5	,	,	,
8691	3754	6	however	however	RB
8691	3754	7	,	,	,
8691	3754	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3754	9	resigned	resign	VBD
8691	3754	10	the	the	DT
8691	3754	11	office	office	NN
8691	3754	12	on	on	IN
8691	3754	13	account	account	NN
8691	3754	14	of	of	IN
8691	3754	15	the	the	DT
8691	3754	16	inadequacy	inadequacy	NN
8691	3754	17	of	of	IN
8691	3754	18	the	the	DT
8691	3754	19	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	3754	20	.	.	.
8691	3755	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3755	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3755	3	:	:	:
8691	3755	4	Payne	Payne	NNP
8691	3755	5	,	,	,
8691	3755	6	"	"	``
8691	3755	7	Reminiscences	reminiscence	NNS
8691	3755	8	of	of	IN
8691	3755	9	the	the	DT
8691	3755	10	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	3755	11	Island	Island	NNP
8691	3755	12	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	3755	13	,	,	,
8691	3755	14	"	"	''
8691	3755	15	75	75	CD
8691	3755	16	.	.	.
8691	3755	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3756	1	The	the	DT
8691	3756	2	qualities	quality	NNS
8691	3756	3	of	of	IN
8691	3756	4	a	a	DT
8691	3756	5	judge	judge	NN
8691	3756	6	are	be	VBP
8691	3756	7	by	by	IN
8691	3756	8	no	no	DT
8691	3756	9	means	means	NN
8691	3756	10	the	the	DT
8691	3756	11	qualities	quality	NNS
8691	3756	12	of	of	IN
8691	3756	13	a	a	DT
8691	3756	14	politician	politician	NN
8691	3756	15	.	.	.
8691	3757	1	The	the	DT
8691	3757	2	faculty	faculty	NN
8691	3757	3	of	of	IN
8691	3757	4	looking	look	VBG
8691	3757	5	at	at	IN
8691	3757	6	both	both	DT
8691	3757	7	sides	side	NNS
8691	3757	8	of	of	IN
8691	3757	9	a	a	DT
8691	3757	10	question	question	NN
8691	3757	11	and	and	CC
8691	3757	12	the	the	DT
8691	3757	13	power	power	NN
8691	3757	14	of	of	IN
8691	3757	15	forming	form	VBG
8691	3757	16	deliberate	deliberate	JJ
8691	3757	17	and	and	CC
8691	3757	18	well	well	RB
8691	3757	19	-	-	HYPH
8691	3757	20	considered	consider	VBN
8691	3757	21	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	3757	22	do	do	VBP
8691	3757	23	not	not	RB
8691	3757	24	tell	tell	VB
8691	3757	25	for	for	IN
8691	3757	26	much	much	JJ
8691	3757	27	in	in	IN
8691	3757	28	a	a	DT
8691	3757	29	campaign	campaign	NN
8691	3757	30	speech	speech	NN
8691	3757	31	.	.	.
8691	3758	1	The	the	DT
8691	3758	2	politician	politician	NN
8691	3758	3	's	's	POS
8691	3758	4	title	title	NN
8691	3758	5	to	to	TO
8691	3758	6	support	support	VB
8691	3758	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3758	8	standing	stand	VBG
8691	3758	9	by	by	IN
8691	3758	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3758	11	friends	friend	NNS
8691	3758	12	.	.	.
8691	3759	1	The	the	DT
8691	3759	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	3759	3	's	's	POS
8691	3759	4	duty	duty	NN
8691	3759	5	may	may	MD
8691	3759	6	be	be	VB
8691	3759	7	to	to	TO
8691	3759	8	decide	decide	VB
8691	3759	9	a	a	DT
8691	3759	10	cause	cause	NN
8691	3759	11	against	against	IN
8691	3759	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3759	13	friends	friend	NNS
8691	3759	14	.	.	.
8691	3760	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	3760	2	a	a	DT
8691	3760	3	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	3760	4	of	of	IN
8691	3760	5	eminence	eminence	NN
8691	3760	6	might	may	MD
8691	3760	7	accept	accept	VB
8691	3760	8	a	a	DT
8691	3760	9	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3760	10	from	from	IN
8691	3760	11	a	a	DT
8691	3760	12	President	President	NNP
8691	3760	13	or	or	CC
8691	3760	14	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3760	15	involving	involve	VBG
8691	3760	16	no	no	DT
8691	3760	17	participation	participation	NN
8691	3760	18	in	in	IN
8691	3760	19	a	a	DT
8691	3760	20	political	political	JJ
8691	3760	21	election	election	NN
8691	3760	22	contest	contest	NN
8691	3760	23	who	who	WP
8691	3760	24	would	would	MD
8691	3760	25	refuse	refuse	VB
8691	3760	26	one	one	CD
8691	3760	27	from	from	IN
8691	3760	28	a	a	DT
8691	3760	29	party	party	NN
8691	3760	30	convention	convention	NN
8691	3760	31	.	.	.
8691	3761	1	The	the	DT
8691	3761	2	general	general	JJ
8691	3761	3	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	3761	4	of	of	IN
8691	3761	5	thinking	think	VBG
8691	3761	6	men	man	NNS
8691	3761	7	in	in	IN
8691	3761	8	the	the	DT
8691	3761	9	United	United	NNP
8691	3761	10	States	States	NNP
8691	3761	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	3761	12	that	that	IN
8691	3761	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3761	14	should	should	MD
8691	3761	15	never	never	RB
8691	3761	16	be	be	VB
8691	3761	17	chosen	choose	VBN
8691	3761	18	by	by	IN
8691	3761	19	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3761	20	vote	vote	NN
8691	3761	21	.	.	.
8691	3762	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3762	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3762	3	,	,	,
8691	3762	4	however	however	RB
8691	3762	5	,	,	,
8691	3762	6	an	an	DT
8691	3762	7	unpopular	unpopular	JJ
8691	3762	8	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	3762	9	.	.	.
8691	3763	1	The	the	DT
8691	3763	2	people	people	NNS
8691	3763	3	in	in	IN
8691	3763	4	general	general	JJ
8691	3763	5	do	do	VBP
8691	3763	6	not	not	RB
8691	3763	7	appreciate	appreciate	VB
8691	3763	8	the	the	DT
8691	3763	9	difference	difference	NN
8691	3763	10	between	between	IN
8691	3763	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3763	12	fitness	fitness	NN
8691	3763	13	to	to	TO
8691	3763	14	select	select	VB
8691	3763	15	political	political	JJ
8691	3763	16	rulers	ruler	NNS
8691	3763	17	and	and	CC
8691	3763	18	to	to	TO
8691	3763	19	select	select	VB
8691	3763	20	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3763	21	rulers	ruler	NNS
8691	3763	22	--	--	:
8691	3763	23	to	to	TO
8691	3763	24	choose	choose	VB
8691	3763	25	out	out	RP
8691	3763	26	good	good	JJ
8691	3763	27	men	man	NNS
8691	3763	28	and	and	CC
8691	3763	29	to	to	TO
8691	3763	30	choose	choose	VB
8691	3763	31	out	out	RP
8691	3763	32	good	good	JJ
8691	3763	33	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3763	34	.	.	.
8691	3764	1	And	and	CC
8691	3764	2	the	the	DT
8691	3764	3	people	people	NNS
8691	3764	4	make	make	VBP
8691	3764	5	and	and	CC
8691	3764	6	ought	ought	MD
8691	3764	7	to	to	TO
8691	3764	8	make	make	VB
8691	3764	9	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3764	10	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	3764	11	.	.	.
8691	3765	1	Rufus	Rufus	NNP
8691	3765	2	Choate	Choate	NNP
8691	3765	3	once	once	RB
8691	3765	4	said	say	VBD
8691	3765	5	that	that	IN
8691	3765	6	the	the	DT
8691	3765	7	question	question	NN
8691	3765	8	at	at	IN
8691	3765	9	bottom	bottom	NN
8691	3765	10	was	be	VBD
8691	3765	11	,	,	,
8691	3765	12	Are	be	VBP
8691	3765	13	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3765	14	afraid	afraid	JJ
8691	3765	15	to	to	TO
8691	3765	16	trust	trust	VB
8691	3765	17	the	the	DT
8691	3765	18	people	people	NNS
8691	3765	19	?	?	.
8691	3766	1	If	if	IN
8691	3766	2	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3766	3	answer	answer	VBP
8691	3766	4	Yes	yes	UH
8691	3766	5	,	,	,
8691	3766	6	then	then	RB
8691	3766	7	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3766	8	cry	cry	VBP
8691	3766	9	out	out	RP
8691	3766	10	that	that	IN
8691	3766	11	"	"	``
8691	3766	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3766	13	blasphemeth	blasphemeth	NNP
8691	3766	14	.	.	.
8691	3766	15	"	"	''
8691	3767	1	If	if	IN
8691	3767	2	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3767	3	answer	answer	VBP
8691	3767	4	No	no	UH
8691	3767	5	,	,	,
8691	3767	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3767	7	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	3767	8	reply	reply	VBP
8691	3767	9	,	,	,
8691	3767	10	Then	then	RB
8691	3767	11	let	let	VB
8691	3767	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3767	13	elect	elect	VB
8691	3767	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3767	15	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3767	16	.	.	.
8691	3768	1	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	3768	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3768	3	the	the	DT
8691	3768	4	first	first	JJ
8691	3768	5	to	to	TO
8691	3768	6	suggest	suggest	VB
8691	3768	7	an	an	DT
8691	3768	8	elective	elective	JJ
8691	3768	9	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	3768	10	,	,	,
8691	3768	11	basing	base	VBG
8691	3768	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3768	13	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3768	14	on	on	IN
8691	3768	15	a	a	DT
8691	3768	16	misconception	misconception	NN
8691	3768	17	of	of	IN
8691	3768	18	the	the	DT
8691	3768	19	usage	usage	NN
8691	3768	20	in	in	IN
8691	3768	21	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3768	22	.	.	.
8691	3769	1	There	there	RB
8691	3769	2	,	,	,
8691	3769	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3769	4	wrote	write	VBD
8691	3769	5	,	,	,
8691	3769	6	the	the	DT
8691	3769	7	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3769	8	had	have	VBD
8691	3769	9	been	be	VBN
8691	3769	10	chosen	choose	VBN
8691	3769	11	by	by	IN
8691	3769	12	the	the	DT
8691	3769	13	people	people	NNS
8691	3769	14	every	every	DT
8691	3769	15	six	six	CD
8691	3769	16	months	month	NNS
8691	3769	17	for	for	IN
8691	3769	18	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	3769	19	two	two	CD
8691	3769	20	centuries	century	NNS
8691	3769	21	,	,	,
8691	3769	22	yet	yet	RB
8691	3769	23	with	with	IN
8691	3769	24	few	few	JJ
8691	3769	25	changes	change	NNS
8691	3769	26	on	on	IN
8691	3769	27	the	the	DT
8691	3769	28	bench	bench	NN
8691	3769	29	,	,	,
8691	3769	30	"	"	''
8691	3769	31	so	so	RB
8691	3769	32	powerful	powerful	JJ
8691	3769	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	3769	34	the	the	DT
8691	3769	35	curb	curb	NN
8691	3769	36	of	of	IN
8691	3769	37	incessant	incessant	JJ
8691	3769	38	responsibility	responsibility	NN
8691	3769	39	.	.	.
8691	3770	1	"	"	``
8691	3770	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3770	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3770	4	:	:	:
8691	3770	5	Works	Works	NNP
8691	3770	6	,	,	,
8691	3770	7	VII	VII	NNP
8691	3770	8	,	,	,
8691	3770	9	9	9	CD
8691	3770	10	,	,	,
8691	3770	11	12	12	CD
8691	3770	12	,	,	,
8691	3770	13	13	13	CD
8691	3770	14	,	,	,
8691	3770	15	35	35	CD
8691	3770	16	;	;	:
8691	3770	17	letter	letter	NN
8691	3770	18	of	of	IN
8691	3770	19	July	July	NNP
8691	3770	20	12	12	CD
8691	3770	21	,	,	,
8691	3770	22	1816	1816	CD
8691	3770	23	,	,	,
8691	3770	24	regarding	regard	VBG
8691	3770	25	a	a	DT
8691	3770	26	new	new	JJ
8691	3770	27	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3770	28	for	for	IN
8691	3770	29	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	3770	30	.	.	.
8691	3770	31	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3771	1	In	in	IN
8691	3771	2	fact	fact	NN
8691	3771	3	,	,	,
8691	3771	4	the	the	DT
8691	3771	5	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3771	6	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3771	7	were	be	VBD
8691	3771	8	chosen	choose	VBN
8691	3771	9	annually	annually	RB
8691	3771	10	,	,	,
8691	3771	11	and	and	CC
8691	3771	12	those	those	DT
8691	3771	13	not	not	RB
8691	3771	14	holding	hold	VBG
8691	3771	15	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3771	16	powers	power	NNS
8691	3771	17	as	as	IN
8691	3771	18	an	an	DT
8691	3771	19	incident	incident	NN
8691	3771	20	of	of	IN
8691	3771	21	political	political	JJ
8691	3771	22	ones	one	NNS
8691	3771	23	were	be	VBD
8691	3771	24	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3771	25	by	by	IN
8691	3771	26	the	the	DT
8691	3771	27	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3771	28	.	.	.
8691	3772	1	The	the	DT
8691	3772	2	experiment	experiment	NN
8691	3772	3	of	of	IN
8691	3772	4	resorting	resort	VBG
8691	3772	5	to	to	IN
8691	3772	6	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3772	7	election	election	NN
8691	3772	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3772	9	first	first	RB
8691	3772	10	fully	fully	RB
8691	3772	11	tried	try	VBN
8691	3772	12	in	in	IN
8691	3772	13	Mississippi	Mississippi	NNP
8691	3772	14	in	in	IN
8691	3772	15	1832	1832	CD
8691	3772	16	,	,	,
8691	3772	17	under	under	IN
8691	3772	18	the	the	DT
8691	3772	19	influence	influence	NN
8691	3772	20	of	of	IN
8691	3772	21	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3772	22	Henry	Henry	NNP
8691	3772	23	T.	T.	NNP
8691	3772	24	Foote	Foote	NNP
8691	3772	25	,	,	,
8691	3772	26	but	but	CC
8691	3772	27	in	in	IN
8691	3772	28	later	late	JJR
8691	3772	29	life	life	NN
8691	3772	30	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3772	31	expressed	express	VBD
8691	3772	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3772	33	regret	regret	NN
8691	3772	34	at	at	IN
8691	3772	35	the	the	DT
8691	3772	36	course	course	NN
8691	3772	37	which	which	WDT
8691	3772	38	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3772	39	had	have	VBD
8691	3772	40	taken	take	VBN
8691	3772	41	,	,	,
8691	3772	42	and	and	CC
8691	3772	43	the	the	DT
8691	3772	44	belief	belief	NN
8691	3772	45	that	that	IN
8691	3772	46	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3772	47	had	have	VBD
8691	3772	48	weakened	weaken	VBN
8691	3772	49	the	the	DT
8691	3772	50	character	character	NN
8691	3772	51	of	of	IN
8691	3772	52	the	the	DT
8691	3772	53	bench	bench	NN
8691	3772	54	.	.	.
8691	3773	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3773	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3773	3	:	:	:
8691	3773	4	"	"	``
8691	3773	5	Casket	Casket	NNP
8691	3773	6	of	of	IN
8691	3773	7	Reminiscenses	Reminiscenses	NNPS
8691	3773	8	,	,	,
8691	3773	9	"	"	''
8691	3773	10	348	348	CD
8691	3773	11	.	.	.
8691	3773	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3774	1	The	the	DT
8691	3774	2	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	3774	3	of	of	IN
8691	3774	4	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3774	5	election	election	NN
8691	3774	6	may	may	MD
8691	3774	7	be	be	VB
8691	3774	8	pursued	pursue	VBN
8691	3774	9	with	with	IN
8691	3774	10	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	3774	11	success	success	NN
8691	3774	12	if	if	IN
8691	3774	13	the	the	DT
8691	3774	14	bar	bar	NN
8691	3774	15	use	use	VBP
8691	3774	16	all	all	PDT
8691	3774	17	the	the	DT
8691	3774	18	influence	influence	NN
8691	3774	19	at	at	IN
8691	3774	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3774	21	command	command	NN
8691	3774	22	to	to	TO
8691	3774	23	secure	secure	VB
8691	3774	24	both	both	DT
8691	3774	25	good	good	JJ
8691	3774	26	nominations	nomination	NNS
8691	3774	27	originally	originally	RB
8691	3774	28	and	and	CC
8691	3774	29	the	the	DT
8691	3774	30	re	re	NN
8691	3774	31	-	-	NN
8691	3774	32	election	election	NN
8691	3774	33	of	of	IN
8691	3774	34	all	all	DT
8691	3774	35	who	who	WP
8691	3774	36	have	have	VBP
8691	3774	37	served	serve	VBN
8691	3774	38	well	well	RB
8691	3774	39	.	.	.
8691	3775	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3775	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3775	3	:	:	:
8691	3775	4	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3775	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3775	6	not	not	RB
8691	3775	7	uncommon	uncommon	JJ
8691	3775	8	for	for	IN
8691	3775	9	local	local	JJ
8691	3775	10	bar	bar	NN
8691	3775	11	associations	association	NNS
8691	3775	12	after	after	IN
8691	3775	13	the	the	DT
8691	3775	14	party	party	NN
8691	3775	15	nominations	nomination	NNS
8691	3775	16	for	for	IN
8691	3775	17	the	the	DT
8691	3775	18	bench	bench	NN
8691	3775	19	have	have	VBP
8691	3775	20	been	be	VBN
8691	3775	21	made	make	VBN
8691	3775	22	to	to	TO
8691	3775	23	refer	refer	VB
8691	3775	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3775	25	to	to	IN
8691	3775	26	a	a	DT
8691	3775	27	committee	committee	NN
8691	3775	28	,	,	,
8691	3775	29	on	on	IN
8691	3775	30	the	the	DT
8691	3775	31	report	report	NN
8691	3775	32	of	of	IN
8691	3775	33	which	which	WDT
8691	3775	34	those	those	DT
8691	3775	35	deemed	deem	VBD
8691	3775	36	the	the	DT
8691	3775	37	best	good	JJS
8691	3775	38	are	be	VBP
8691	3775	39	commended	commend	VBN
8691	3775	40	for	for	IN
8691	3775	41	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3775	42	approval	approval	NN
8691	3775	43	.	.	.
8691	3776	1	In	in	IN
8691	3776	2	two	two	CD
8691	3776	3	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3776	4	districts	district	NNS
8691	3776	5	in	in	IN
8691	3776	6	Iowa	Iowa	NNP
8691	3776	7	,	,	,
8691	3776	8	the	the	DT
8691	3776	9	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3776	10	nominate	nominate	VBP
8691	3776	11	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3776	12	for	for	IN
8691	3776	13	the	the	DT
8691	3776	14	district	district	NN
8691	3776	15	in	in	IN
8691	3776	16	a	a	DT
8691	3776	17	convention	convention	NN
8691	3776	18	of	of	IN
8691	3776	19	delegates	delegate	NNS
8691	3776	20	from	from	IN
8691	3776	21	the	the	DT
8691	3776	22	bar	bar	NN
8691	3776	23	,	,	,
8691	3776	24	and	and	CC
8691	3776	25	then	then	RB
8691	3776	26	see	see	VB
8691	3776	27	to	to	IN
8691	3776	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3776	29	that	that	IN
8691	3776	30	the	the	DT
8691	3776	31	nominations	nomination	NNS
8691	3776	32	are	be	VBP
8691	3776	33	ratified	ratify	VBN
8691	3776	34	by	by	IN
8691	3776	35	the	the	DT
8691	3776	36	party	party	NN
8691	3776	37	conventions	convention	NNS
8691	3776	38	.	.	.
8691	3777	1	Simon	Simon	NNP
8691	3777	2	Fleischmann	Fleischmann	NNP
8691	3777	3	,	,	,
8691	3777	4	"	"	``
8691	3777	5	The	the	DT
8691	3777	6	Influence	Influence	NNP
8691	3777	7	of	of	IN
8691	3777	8	the	the	DT
8691	3777	9	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	3777	10	in	in	IN
8691	3777	11	the	the	DT
8691	3777	12	Selection	Selection	NNP
8691	3777	13	of	of	IN
8691	3777	14	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	3777	15	,	,	,
8691	3777	16	"	"	``
8691	3777	17	Report	report	NN
8691	3777	18	of	of	IN
8691	3777	19	28th	28th	JJ
8691	3777	20	annual	annual	JJ
8691	3777	21	meeting	meeting	NN
8691	3777	22	of	of	IN
8691	3777	23	the	the	DT
8691	3777	24	New	New	NNP
8691	3777	25	York	York	NNP
8691	3777	26	State	State	NNP
8691	3777	27	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	3777	28	Association	Association	NNP
8691	3777	29	(	(	-LRB-
8691	3777	30	1905	1905	CD
8691	3777	31	)	)	-RRB-
8691	3777	32	.	.	.
8691	3777	33	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3778	1	A	a	DT
8691	3778	2	conspicuous	conspicuous	JJ
8691	3778	3	instance	instance	NN
8691	3778	4	of	of	IN
8691	3778	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3778	6	success	success	NN
8691	3778	7	under	under	IN
8691	3778	8	such	such	JJ
8691	3778	9	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	3778	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	3778	11	shown	show	VBN
8691	3778	12	by	by	IN
8691	3778	13	the	the	DT
8691	3778	14	repeated	repeated	JJ
8691	3778	15	re	re	NN
8691	3778	16	-	-	NN
8691	3778	17	election	election	NN
8691	3778	18	of	of	IN
8691	3778	19	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3778	20	Joseph	Joseph	NNP
8691	3778	21	E.	E.	NNP
8691	3778	22	Gary	Gary	NNP
8691	3778	23	of	of	IN
8691	3778	24	the	the	DT
8691	3778	25	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	3778	26	court	court	NN
8691	3778	27	of	of	IN
8691	3778	28	the	the	DT
8691	3778	29	city	city	NN
8691	3778	30	of	of	IN
8691	3778	31	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
8691	3778	32	.	.	.
8691	3779	1	Originally	originally	RB
8691	3779	2	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3779	3	in	in	IN
8691	3779	4	1863	1863	CD
8691	3779	5	,	,	,
8691	3779	6	when	when	WRB
8691	3779	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3779	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3779	9	called	call	VBN
8691	3779	10	the	the	DT
8691	3779	11	Recorder	Recorder	NNP
8691	3779	12	's	's	POS
8691	3779	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3779	14	,	,	,
8691	3779	15	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3779	16	has	have	VBZ
8691	3779	17	been	be	VBN
8691	3779	18	re	re	VBN
8691	3779	19	-	-	VBN
8691	3779	20	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3779	21	for	for	IN
8691	3779	22	successive	successive	JJ
8691	3779	23	terms	term	NNS
8691	3779	24	of	of	IN
8691	3779	25	six	six	CD
8691	3779	26	years	year	NNS
8691	3779	27	without	without	IN
8691	3779	28	a	a	DT
8691	3779	29	break	break	NN
8691	3779	30	,	,	,
8691	3779	31	and	and	CC
8691	3779	32	in	in	IN
8691	3779	33	1903	1903	CD
8691	3779	34	,	,	,
8691	3779	35	when	when	WRB
8691	3779	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3779	37	was	be	VBD
8691	3779	38	82	82	CD
8691	3779	39	years	year	NNS
8691	3779	40	old	old	JJ
8691	3779	41	and	and	CC
8691	3779	42	still	still	RB
8691	3779	43	in	in	IN
8691	3779	44	active	active	JJ
8691	3779	45	service	service	NN
8691	3779	46	on	on	IN
8691	3779	47	the	the	DT
8691	3779	48	bench	bench	NN
8691	3779	49	,	,	,
8691	3779	50	received	receive	VBD
8691	3779	51	well	well	RB
8691	3779	52	-	-	HYPH
8691	3779	53	merited	merit	VBN
8691	3779	54	addresses	address	NNS
8691	3779	55	of	of	IN
8691	3779	56	congratulation	congratulation	NN
8691	3779	57	from	from	IN
8691	3779	58	the	the	DT
8691	3779	59	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
8691	3779	60	Law	Law	NNP
8691	3779	61	Institute	Institute	NNP
8691	3779	62	and	and	CC
8691	3779	63	the	the	DT
8691	3779	64	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
8691	3779	65	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	3779	66	Association	Association	NNP
8691	3779	67	.	.	.
8691	3780	1	Judges	judge	NNS
8691	3780	2	of	of	IN
8691	3780	3	Probate	Probate	NNP
8691	3780	4	,	,	,
8691	3780	5	whose	whose	WP$
8691	3780	6	functions	function	NNS
8691	3780	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3780	8	largely	largely	RB
8691	3780	9	of	of	IN
8691	3780	10	a	a	DT
8691	3780	11	business	business	NN
8691	3780	12	character	character	NN
8691	3780	13	,	,	,
8691	3780	14	and	and	CC
8691	3780	15	who	who	WP
8691	3780	16	are	be	VBP
8691	3780	17	brought	bring	VBN
8691	3780	18	into	into	IN
8691	3780	19	close	close	JJ
8691	3780	20	contact	contact	NN
8691	3780	21	with	with	IN
8691	3780	22	the	the	DT
8691	3780	23	people	people	NNS
8691	3780	24	at	at	IN
8691	3780	25	first	first	JJ
8691	3780	26	hand	hand	NN
8691	3780	27	,	,	,
8691	3780	28	are	be	VBP
8691	3780	29	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	3780	30	re	re	VBN
8691	3780	31	-	-	VBN
8691	3780	32	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3780	33	for	for	IN
8691	3780	34	a	a	DT
8691	3780	35	long	long	JJ
8691	3780	36	period	period	NN
8691	3780	37	of	of	IN
8691	3780	38	years	year	NNS
8691	3780	39	with	with	IN
8691	3780	40	little	little	JJ
8691	3780	41	regard	regard	NN
8691	3780	42	to	to	IN
8691	3780	43	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3780	44	party	party	NN
8691	3780	45	affiliations	affiliation	NNS
8691	3780	46	.	.	.
8691	3781	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3781	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3781	3	:	:	:
8691	3781	4	In	in	IN
8691	3781	5	the	the	DT
8691	3781	6	Probate	Probate	NNP
8691	3781	7	District	District	NNP
8691	3781	8	of	of	IN
8691	3781	9	Hartford	Hartford	NNP
8691	3781	10	in	in	IN
8691	3781	11	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3781	12	there	there	EX
8691	3781	13	have	have	VBP
8691	3781	14	been	be	VBN
8691	3781	15	but	but	CC
8691	3781	16	two	two	CD
8691	3781	17	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3781	18	during	during	IN
8691	3781	19	the	the	DT
8691	3781	20	last	last	JJ
8691	3781	21	forty	forty	CD
8691	3781	22	years	year	NNS
8691	3781	23	,	,	,
8691	3781	24	though	though	IN
8691	3781	25	the	the	DT
8691	3781	26	elections	election	NNS
8691	3781	27	have	have	VBP
8691	3781	28	been	be	VBN
8691	3781	29	annual	annual	JJ
8691	3781	30	or	or	CC
8691	3781	31	biennial	biennial	JJ
8691	3781	32	.	.	.
8691	3781	33	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3782	1	In	in	IN
8691	3782	2	case	case	NN
8691	3782	3	of	of	IN
8691	3782	4	those	those	DT
8691	3782	5	having	have	VBG
8691	3782	6	long	long	JJ
8691	3782	7	terms	term	NNS
8691	3782	8	of	of	IN
8691	3782	9	office	office	NN
8691	3782	10	,	,	,
8691	3782	11	a	a	DT
8691	3782	12	re	re	NN
8691	3782	13	-	-	NN
8691	3782	14	election	election	NN
8691	3782	15	comes	come	VBZ
8691	3782	16	more	more	RBR
8691	3782	17	easily	easily	RB
8691	3782	18	and	and	CC
8691	3782	19	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	3782	20	.	.	.
8691	3783	1	A	a	DT
8691	3783	2	man	man	NN
8691	3783	3	who	who	WP
8691	3783	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	3783	5	been	be	VBN
8691	3783	6	ten	ten	CD
8691	3783	7	or	or	CC
8691	3783	8	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3783	9	years	year	NNS
8691	3783	10	upon	upon	IN
8691	3783	11	the	the	DT
8691	3783	12	bench	bench	NN
8691	3783	13	has	have	VBZ
8691	3783	14	become	become	VBN
8691	3783	15	set	set	VBN
8691	3783	16	apart	apart	RB
8691	3783	17	from	from	IN
8691	3783	18	the	the	DT
8691	3783	19	community	community	NN
8691	3783	20	.	.	.
8691	3784	1	The	the	DT
8691	3784	2	people	people	NNS
8691	3784	3	have	have	VBP
8691	3784	4	ceased	cease	VBN
8691	3784	5	to	to	TO
8691	3784	6	think	think	VB
8691	3784	7	of	of	IN
8691	3784	8	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3784	9	as	as	IN
8691	3784	10	one	one	CD
8691	3784	11	of	of	IN
8691	3784	12	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3784	13	,	,	,
8691	3784	14	so	so	RB
8691	3784	15	far	far	RB
8691	3784	16	as	as	IN
8691	3784	17	the	the	DT
8691	3784	18	active	active	JJ
8691	3784	19	political	political	JJ
8691	3784	20	and	and	CC
8691	3784	21	business	business	NN
8691	3784	22	life	life	NN
8691	3784	23	of	of	IN
8691	3784	24	the	the	DT
8691	3784	25	day	day	NN
8691	3784	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	3784	27	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	3784	28	.	.	.
8691	3785	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3785	2	position	position	NN
8691	3785	3	and	and	CC
8691	3785	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3785	5	work	work	NN
8691	3785	6	,	,	,
8691	3785	7	if	if	IN
8691	3785	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3785	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	3785	10	been	be	VBN
8691	3785	11	good	good	JJ
8691	3785	12	,	,	,
8691	3785	13	have	have	VBP
8691	3785	14	given	give	VBN
8691	3785	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3785	16	a	a	DT
8691	3785	17	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3785	18	elevation	elevation	NN
8691	3785	19	of	of	IN
8691	3785	20	station	station	NN
8691	3785	21	.	.	.
8691	3786	1	Men	man	NNS
8691	3786	2	have	have	VBP
8691	3786	3	learned	learn	VBN
8691	3786	4	to	to	TO
8691	3786	5	trust	trust	VB
8691	3786	6	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3786	7	,	,	,
8691	3786	8	and	and	CC
8691	3786	9	to	to	TO
8691	3786	10	feel	feel	VB
8691	3786	11	that	that	IN
8691	3786	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3786	13	presence	presence	NN
8691	3786	14	on	on	IN
8691	3786	15	the	the	DT
8691	3786	16	court	court	NN
8691	3786	17	helps	help	VBZ
8691	3786	18	to	to	TO
8691	3786	19	make	make	VB
8691	3786	20	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	3786	21	and	and	CC
8691	3786	22	property	property	NN
8691	3786	23	more	more	RBR
8691	3786	24	secure	secure	JJ
8691	3786	25	.	.	.
8691	3787	1	If	if	IN
8691	3787	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3787	3	receives	receive	VBZ
8691	3787	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3787	5	party	party	NN
8691	3787	6	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3787	7	,	,	,
8691	3787	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3787	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	3787	10	apt	apt	JJ
8691	3787	11	to	to	TO
8691	3787	12	secure	secure	VB
8691	3787	13	a	a	DT
8691	3787	14	majority	majority	NN
8691	3787	15	of	of	IN
8691	3787	16	votes	vote	NNS
8691	3787	17	,	,	,
8691	3787	18	whether	whether	IN
8691	3787	19	the	the	DT
8691	3787	20	others	other	NNS
8691	3787	21	on	on	IN
8691	3787	22	the	the	DT
8691	3787	23	ticket	ticket	NN
8691	3787	24	are	be	VBP
8691	3787	25	or	or	CC
8691	3787	26	are	be	VBP
8691	3787	27	not	not	RB
8691	3787	28	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3787	29	.	.	.
8691	3788	1	The	the	DT
8691	3788	2	opposing	oppose	VBG
8691	3788	3	party	party	NN
8691	3788	4	often	often	RB
8691	3788	5	nominates	nominate	VBZ
8691	3788	6	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3788	7	also	also	RB
8691	3788	8	,	,	,
8691	3788	9	and	and	CC
8691	3788	10	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3788	11	,	,	,
8691	3788	12	if	if	IN
8691	3788	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3788	14	own	own	JJ
8691	3788	15	gives	give	VBZ
8691	3788	16	the	the	DT
8691	3788	17	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3788	18	to	to	IN
8691	3788	19	another	another	DT
8691	3788	20	,	,	,
8691	3788	21	nominates	nominate	VBZ
8691	3788	22	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3788	23	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3788	24	,	,	,
8691	3788	25	and	and	CC
8691	3788	26	with	with	IN
8691	3788	27	success	success	NN
8691	3788	28	.	.	.
8691	3789	1	In	in	IN
8691	3789	2	New	New	NNP
8691	3789	3	York	York	NNP
8691	3789	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3789	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	3789	6	been	be	VBN
8691	3789	7	generally	generally	RB
8691	3789	8	the	the	DT
8691	3789	9	case	case	NN
8691	3789	10	that	that	WDT
8691	3789	11	a	a	DT
8691	3789	12	good	good	JJ
8691	3789	13	judge	judge	NN
8691	3789	14	of	of	IN
8691	3789	15	the	the	DT
8691	3789	16	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3789	17	of	of	IN
8691	3789	18	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	3789	19	or	or	CC
8691	3789	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3789	21	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3789	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	3789	23	re	re	VBN
8691	3789	24	-	-	VBN
8691	3789	25	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3789	26	until	until	IN
8691	3789	27	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3789	28	reaches	reach	VBZ
8691	3789	29	the	the	DT
8691	3789	30	age	age	NN
8691	3789	31	limit	limit	NN
8691	3789	32	set	set	VBN
8691	3789	33	by	by	IN
8691	3789	34	the	the	DT
8691	3789	35	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3789	36	.	.	.
8691	3790	1	To	to	TO
8691	3790	2	accomplish	accomplish	VB
8691	3790	3	this	this	DT
8691	3790	4	,	,	,
8691	3790	5	however	however	RB
8691	3790	6	,	,	,
8691	3790	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3790	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	3790	9	been	be	VBN
8691	3790	10	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	3790	11	for	for	IN
8691	3790	12	the	the	DT
8691	3790	13	bar	bar	NN
8691	3790	14	to	to	TO
8691	3790	15	use	use	VB
8691	3790	16	constant	constant	JJ
8691	3790	17	efforts	effort	NNS
8691	3790	18	to	to	TO
8691	3790	19	bring	bring	VB
8691	3790	20	the	the	DT
8691	3790	21	nominating	nominating	NN
8691	3790	22	conventions	convention	NNS
8691	3790	23	of	of	IN
8691	3790	24	both	both	DT
8691	3790	25	parties	party	NNS
8691	3790	26	to	to	IN
8691	3790	27	the	the	DT
8691	3790	28	support	support	NN
8691	3790	29	of	of	IN
8691	3790	30	the	the	DT
8691	3790	31	same	same	JJ
8691	3790	32	man	man	NN
8691	3790	33	or	or	CC
8691	3790	34	men	man	NNS
8691	3790	35	,	,	,
8691	3790	36	and	and	CC
8691	3790	37	personal	personal	JJ
8691	3790	38	ambition	ambition	NN
8691	3790	39	and	and	CC
8691	3790	40	party	party	NN
8691	3790	41	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	3790	42	have	have	VBP
8691	3790	43	on	on	IN
8691	3790	44	a	a	DT
8691	3790	45	number	number	NN
8691	3790	46	of	of	IN
8691	3790	47	occasions	occasion	NNS
8691	3790	48	set	set	VBN
8691	3790	49	up	up	RP
8691	3790	50	an	an	DT
8691	3790	51	effectual	effectual	JJ
8691	3790	52	bar	bar	NN
8691	3790	53	.	.	.
8691	3791	1	Before	before	IN
8691	3791	2	a	a	DT
8691	3791	3	recent	recent	JJ
8691	3791	4	election	election	NN
8691	3791	5	of	of	IN
8691	3791	6	two	two	CD
8691	3791	7	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3791	8	in	in	IN
8691	3791	9	that	that	DT
8691	3791	10	State	State	NNP
8691	3791	11	,	,	,
8691	3791	12	in	in	IN
8691	3791	13	preparation	preparation	NN
8691	3791	14	for	for	IN
8691	3791	15	which	which	WDT
8691	3791	16	a	a	DT
8691	3791	17	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	3791	18	had	have	VBD
8691	3791	19	been	be	VBN
8691	3791	20	suggested	suggest	VBN
8691	3791	21	by	by	IN
8691	3791	22	which	which	WDT
8691	3791	23	one	one	CD
8691	3791	24	of	of	IN
8691	3791	25	the	the	DT
8691	3791	26	outgoing	outgoing	JJ
8691	3791	27	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3791	28	of	of	IN
8691	3791	29	each	each	DT
8691	3791	30	party	party	NN
8691	3791	31	should	should	MD
8691	3791	32	be	be	VB
8691	3791	33	re	re	VBN
8691	3791	34	-	-	VBN
8691	3791	35	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3791	36	,	,	,
8691	3791	37	a	a	DT
8691	3791	38	third	third	JJ
8691	3791	39	candidate	candidate	NN
8691	3791	40	for	for	IN
8691	3791	41	the	the	DT
8691	3791	42	succession	succession	NN
8691	3791	43	,	,	,
8691	3791	44	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3791	45	a	a	DT
8691	3791	46	prominent	prominent	JJ
8691	3791	47	member	member	NN
8691	3791	48	of	of	IN
8691	3791	49	the	the	DT
8691	3791	50	bar	bar	NN
8691	3791	51	and	and	CC
8691	3791	52	an	an	DT
8691	3791	53	officer	officer	NN
8691	3791	54	of	of	IN
8691	3791	55	the	the	DT
8691	3791	56	State	State	NNP
8691	3791	57	,	,	,
8691	3791	58	published	publish	VBD
8691	3791	59	a	a	DT
8691	3791	60	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
8691	3791	61	statement	statement	NN
8691	3791	62	of	of	IN
8691	3791	63	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3791	64	claims	claim	NNS
8691	3791	65	,	,	,
8691	3791	66	which	which	WDT
8691	3791	67	concluded	conclude	VBD
8691	3791	68	thus	thus	RB
8691	3791	69	:	:	:
8691	3791	70	"	"	``
8691	3791	71	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3791	72	am	be	VBP
8691	3791	73	a	a	DT
8691	3791	74	candidate	candidate	NN
8691	3791	75	for	for	IN
8691	3791	76	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3791	77	to	to	IN
8691	3791	78	the	the	DT
8691	3791	79	office	office	NN
8691	3791	80	of	of	IN
8691	3791	81	Associate	Associate	NNP
8691	3791	82	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3791	83	of	of	IN
8691	3791	84	the	the	DT
8691	3791	85	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3791	86	of	of	IN
8691	3791	87	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	3791	88	at	at	IN
8691	3791	89	the	the	DT
8691	3791	90	coming	come	VBG
8691	3791	91	Democratic	Democratic	NNP
8691	3791	92	State	State	NNP
8691	3791	93	Convention	Convention	NNP
8691	3791	94	.	.	.
8691	3792	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3792	2	appeal	appeal	VBP
8691	3792	3	to	to	IN
8691	3792	4	my	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3792	5	fellow	fellow	NN
8691	3792	6	-	-	HYPH
8691	3792	7	citizens	citizen	NNS
8691	3792	8	for	for	IN
8691	3792	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3792	10	support	support	NN
8691	3792	11	.	.	.
8691	3793	1	While	while	IN
8691	3793	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3793	3	do	do	VBP
8691	3793	4	not	not	RB
8691	3793	5	believe	believe	VB
8691	3793	6	that	that	DT
8691	3793	7	support	support	NN
8691	3793	8	for	for	IN
8691	3793	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3793	10	candidacy	candidacy	NN
8691	3793	11	should	should	MD
8691	3793	12	be	be	VB
8691	3793	13	unduly	unduly	RB
8691	3793	14	importuned	importuned	JJ
8691	3793	15	,	,	,
8691	3793	16	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3793	17	feel	feel	VBP
8691	3793	18	that	that	IN
8691	3793	19	the	the	DT
8691	3793	20	present	present	JJ
8691	3793	21	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	3793	22	justify	justify	VBP
8691	3793	23	me	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3793	24	in	in	IN
8691	3793	25	making	make	VBG
8691	3793	26	this	this	DT
8691	3793	27	announcement	announcement	NN
8691	3793	28	.	.	.
8691	3794	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3794	2	have	have	VBP
8691	3794	3	always	always	RB
8691	3794	4	stood	stand	VBN
8691	3794	5	by	by	IN
8691	3794	6	my	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3794	7	party	party	NN
8691	3794	8	in	in	IN
8691	3794	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3794	10	dark	dark	JJ
8691	3794	11	days	day	NNS
8691	3794	12	,	,	,
8691	3794	13	when	when	WRB
8691	3794	14	others	other	NNS
8691	3794	15	voted	vote	VBD
8691	3794	16	the	the	DT
8691	3794	17	Republican	republican	JJ
8691	3794	18	ticket	ticket	NN
8691	3794	19	in	in	IN
8691	3794	20	the	the	DT
8691	3794	21	interest	interest	NN
8691	3794	22	of	of	IN
8691	3794	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3794	24	business	business	NN
8691	3794	25	.	.	.
8691	3795	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3795	2	have	have	VBP
8691	3795	3	assisted	assist	VBN
8691	3795	4	in	in	IN
8691	3795	5	endeavors	endeavor	NNS
8691	3795	6	to	to	TO
8691	3795	7	so	so	RB
8691	3795	8	shape	shape	VB
8691	3795	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3795	10	policies	policy	NNS
8691	3795	11	as	as	IN
8691	3795	12	to	to	TO
8691	3795	13	make	make	VB
8691	3795	14	success	success	NN
8691	3795	15	possible	possible	JJ
8691	3795	16	.	.	.
8691	3796	1	Now	now	RB
8691	3796	2	that	that	IN
8691	3796	3	this	this	DT
8691	3796	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	3796	5	been	be	VBN
8691	3796	6	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
8691	3796	7	,	,	,
8691	3796	8	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3796	9	do	do	VBP
8691	3796	10	not	not	RB
8691	3796	11	think	think	VB
8691	3796	12	that	that	IN
8691	3796	13	my	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3796	14	fellow	fellow	NN
8691	3796	15	-	-	HYPH
8691	3796	16	Democrats	Democrats	NNPS
8691	3796	17	will	will	MD
8691	3796	18	thrust	thrust	VB
8691	3796	19	me	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3796	20	aside	aside	RB
8691	3796	21	to	to	TO
8691	3796	22	make	make	VB
8691	3796	23	way	way	NN
8691	3796	24	for	for	IN
8691	3796	25	those	those	DT
8691	3796	26	who	who	WP
8691	3796	27	neither	neither	CC
8691	3796	28	affiliate	affiliate	VBP
8691	3796	29	with	with	IN
8691	3796	30	the	the	DT
8691	3796	31	party	party	NN
8691	3796	32	nor	nor	CC
8691	3796	33	vote	vote	VB
8691	3796	34	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3796	35	ticket	ticket	NN
8691	3796	36	.	.	.
8691	3796	37	"	"	''
8691	3797	1	As	as	IN
8691	3797	2	a	a	DT
8691	3797	3	general	general	JJ
8691	3797	4	rule	rule	NN
8691	3797	5	,	,	,
8691	3797	6	in	in	IN
8691	3797	7	the	the	DT
8691	3797	8	country	country	NN
8691	3797	9	at	at	IN
8691	3797	10	large	large	JJ
8691	3797	11	political	political	JJ
8691	3797	12	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	3797	13	are	be	VBP
8691	3797	14	decisive	decisive	JJ
8691	3797	15	,	,	,
8691	3797	16	both	both	CC
8691	3797	17	in	in	IN
8691	3797	18	cases	case	NNS
8691	3797	19	of	of	IN
8691	3797	20	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3797	21	election	election	NN
8691	3797	22	and	and	CC
8691	3797	23	of	of	IN
8691	3797	24	executive	executive	JJ
8691	3797	25	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3797	26	,	,	,
8691	3797	27	but	but	CC
8691	3797	28	as	as	IN
8691	3797	29	to	to	IN
8691	3797	30	the	the	DT
8691	3797	31	latter	latter	JJ
8691	3797	32	exceptions	exception	NNS
8691	3797	33	are	be	VBP
8691	3797	34	more	more	RBR
8691	3797	35	frequent	frequent	JJ
8691	3797	36	.	.	.
8691	3798	1	One	one	CD
8691	3798	2	instance	instance	NN
8691	3798	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	3798	4	occurred	occur	VBN
8691	3798	5	in	in	IN
8691	3798	6	which	which	WDT
8691	3798	7	a	a	DT
8691	3798	8	President	President	NNP
8691	3798	9	of	of	IN
8691	3798	10	the	the	DT
8691	3798	11	United	United	NNP
8691	3798	12	States	States	NNP
8691	3798	13	nominated	nominate	VBD
8691	3798	14	to	to	IN
8691	3798	15	the	the	DT
8691	3798	16	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3798	17	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3798	18	a	a	DT
8691	3798	19	member	member	NN
8691	3798	20	of	of	IN
8691	3798	21	the	the	DT
8691	3798	22	party	party	NN
8691	3798	23	in	in	IN
8691	3798	24	opposition	opposition	NN
8691	3798	25	to	to	IN
8691	3798	26	the	the	DT
8691	3798	27	administration,[Footnote	administration,[Footnote	NNPS
8691	3798	28	:	:	:
8691	3798	29	Howell	Howell	NNP
8691	3798	30	E.	E.	NNP
8691	3798	31	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	3798	32	,	,	,
8691	3798	33	a	a	DT
8691	3798	34	Democrat	Democrat	NNP
8691	3798	35	,	,	,
8691	3798	36	was	be	VBD
8691	3798	37	thus	thus	RB
8691	3798	38	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3798	39	by	by	IN
8691	3798	40	President	President	NNP
8691	3798	41	Harrison	Harrison	NNP
8691	3798	42	,	,	,
8691	3798	43	a	a	DT
8691	3798	44	Republican	Republican	NNP
8691	3798	45	,	,	,
8691	3798	46	in	in	IN
8691	3798	47	1893	1893	CD
8691	3798	48	.	.	.
8691	3799	1	President	President	NNP
8691	3799	2	Taft	Taft	NNP
8691	3799	3	,	,	,
8691	3799	4	a	a	DT
8691	3799	5	Republican	Republican	NNP
8691	3799	6	,	,	,
8691	3799	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	3799	8	since	since	IN
8691	3799	9	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3799	10	two	two	CD
8691	3799	11	Democrats	Democrats	NNPS
8691	3799	12	,	,	,
8691	3799	13	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3799	14	Lurton	Lurton	NNP
8691	3799	15	and	and	CC
8691	3799	16	Lamar	Lamar	NNP
8691	3799	17	,	,	,
8691	3799	18	and	and	CC
8691	3799	19	made	make	VBD
8691	3799	20	a	a	DT
8691	3799	21	third	third	JJ
8691	3799	22	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3799	23	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3799	24	.	.	.
8691	3799	25	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3800	1	and	and	CC
8691	3800	2	the	the	DT
8691	3800	3	same	same	JJ
8691	3800	4	President	President	NNP
8691	3800	5	,	,	,
8691	3800	6	upon	upon	IN
8691	3800	7	the	the	DT
8691	3800	8	creation	creation	NN
8691	3800	9	of	of	IN
8691	3800	10	the	the	DT
8691	3800	11	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	3800	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3800	13	of	of	IN
8691	3800	14	Appeals	Appeals	NNPS
8691	3800	15	,	,	,
8691	3800	16	when	when	WRB
8691	3800	17	there	there	EX
8691	3800	18	were	be	VBD
8691	3800	19	a	a	DT
8691	3800	20	number	number	NN
8691	3800	21	of	of	IN
8691	3800	22	new	new	JJ
8691	3800	23	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3800	24	to	to	TO
8691	3800	25	be	be	VB
8691	3800	26	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3800	27	,	,	,
8691	3800	28	gave	give	VBD
8691	3800	29	several	several	JJ
8691	3800	30	of	of	IN
8691	3800	31	the	the	DT
8691	3800	32	places	place	NNS
8691	3800	33	to	to	IN
8691	3800	34	those	those	DT
8691	3800	35	not	not	RB
8691	3800	36	of	of	IN
8691	3800	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3800	38	political	political	JJ
8691	3800	39	faith	faith	NN
8691	3800	40	.	.	.
8691	3801	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3801	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3801	3	,	,	,
8691	3801	4	however	however	RB
8691	3801	5	,	,	,
8691	3801	6	to	to	TO
8691	3801	7	be	be	VB
8691	3801	8	expected	expect	VBN
8691	3801	9	that	that	IN
8691	3801	10	the	the	DT
8691	3801	11	Presidents	president	NNS
8691	3801	12	of	of	IN
8691	3801	13	the	the	DT
8691	3801	14	United	United	NNP
8691	3801	15	States	States	NNP
8691	3801	16	,	,	,
8691	3801	17	as	as	IN
8691	3801	18	a	a	DT
8691	3801	19	general	general	JJ
8691	3801	20	rule	rule	NN
8691	3801	21	,	,	,
8691	3801	22	will	will	MD
8691	3801	23	place	place	VB
8691	3801	24	upon	upon	IN
8691	3801	25	the	the	DT
8691	3801	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3801	27	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3801	28	none	none	NN
8691	3801	29	whose	whose	WP$
8691	3801	30	political	political	JJ
8691	3801	31	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3801	32	are	be	VBP
8691	3801	33	not	not	RB
8691	3801	34	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3801	35	to	to	IN
8691	3801	36	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3801	37	own	own	JJ
8691	3801	38	.	.	.
8691	3802	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3802	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3802	3	a	a	DT
8691	3802	4	court	court	NN
8691	3802	5	wielding	wield	VBG
8691	3802	6	too	too	RB
8691	3802	7	great	great	JJ
8691	3802	8	a	a	DT
8691	3802	9	political	political	JJ
8691	3802	10	power	power	NN
8691	3802	11	to	to	TO
8691	3802	12	allow	allow	VB
8691	3802	13	this	this	DT
8691	3802	14	ground	ground	NN
8691	3802	15	of	of	IN
8691	3802	16	qualification	qualification	NN
8691	3802	17	to	to	TO
8691	3802	18	be	be	VB
8691	3802	19	lightly	lightly	RB
8691	3802	20	passed	pass	VBN
8691	3802	21	over	over	RP
8691	3802	22	.	.	.
8691	3803	1	Precisely	precisely	RB
8691	3803	2	because	because	IN
8691	3803	3	of	of	IN
8691	3803	4	this	this	DT
8691	3803	5	,	,	,
8691	3803	6	the	the	DT
8691	3803	7	political	political	JJ
8691	3803	8	antecedents	antecedent	NNS
8691	3803	9	of	of	IN
8691	3803	10	the	the	DT
8691	3803	11	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3803	12	of	of	IN
8691	3803	13	the	the	DT
8691	3803	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3803	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3803	16	are	be	VBP
8691	3803	17	more	more	RBR
8691	3803	18	apt	apt	JJ
8691	3803	19	to	to	TO
8691	3803	20	be	be	VB
8691	3803	21	discoverable	discoverable	JJ
8691	3803	22	in	in	IN
8691	3803	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3803	24	opinions	opinion	NNS
8691	3803	25	than	than	IN
8691	3803	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	3803	27	the	the	DT
8691	3803	28	case	case	NN
8691	3803	29	in	in	IN
8691	3803	30	State	State	NNP
8691	3803	31	courts	court	NNS
8691	3803	32	.	.	.
8691	3804	1	Professor	Professor	NNP
8691	3804	2	William	William	NNP
8691	3804	3	G.	G.	NNP
8691	3804	4	Sumner	Sumner	NNP
8691	3804	5	,	,	,
8691	3804	6	in	in	IN
8691	3804	7	referring	refer	VBG
8691	3804	8	to	to	IN
8691	3804	9	the	the	DT
8691	3804	10	change	change	NN
8691	3804	11	of	of	IN
8691	3804	12	character	character	NN
8691	3804	13	of	of	IN
8691	3804	14	the	the	DT
8691	3804	15	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3804	16	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3804	17	by	by	IN
8691	3804	18	reason	reason	NN
8691	3804	19	of	of	IN
8691	3804	20	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	3804	21	's	's	POS
8691	3804	22	appointments	appointment	NNS
8691	3804	23	to	to	IN
8691	3804	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3804	25	,	,	,
8691	3804	26	remarks	remark	VBZ
8691	3804	27	with	with	IN
8691	3804	28	some	some	DT
8691	3804	29	truth	truth	NN
8691	3804	30	that	that	IN
8691	3804	31	"	"	``
8691	3804	32	the	the	DT
8691	3804	33	effect	effect	NN
8691	3804	34	of	of	IN
8691	3804	35	political	political	JJ
8691	3804	36	appointments	appointment	NNS
8691	3804	37	to	to	IN
8691	3804	38	the	the	DT
8691	3804	39	bench	bench	NN
8691	3804	40	is	be	VBZ
8691	3804	41	always	always	RB
8691	3804	42	traceable	traceable	JJ
8691	3804	43	after	after	IN
8691	3804	44	two	two	CD
8691	3804	45	or	or	CC
8691	3804	46	three	three	CD
8691	3804	47	years	year	NNS
8691	3804	48	in	in	IN
8691	3804	49	the	the	DT
8691	3804	50	reports	report	NNS
8691	3804	51	,	,	,
8691	3804	52	which	which	WDT
8691	3804	53	come	come	VBP
8691	3804	54	to	to	TO
8691	3804	55	read	read	VB
8691	3804	56	like	like	IN
8691	3804	57	a	a	DT
8691	3804	58	collection	collection	NN
8691	3804	59	of	of	IN
8691	3804	60	old	old	JJ
8691	3804	61	stump	stump	NN
8691	3804	62	speeches	speech	NNS
8691	3804	63	.	.	.
8691	3805	1	"	"	``
8691	3805	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3805	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3805	4	:	:	:
8691	3805	5	"	"	``
8691	3805	6	Life	Life	NNP
8691	3805	7	of	of	IN
8691	3805	8	Andrew	Andrew	NNP
8691	3805	9	Jackson	Jackson	NNP
8691	3805	10	,	,	,
8691	3805	11	"	"	``
8691	3805	12	363	363	CD
8691	3805	13	.	.	.
8691	3805	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3806	1	In	in	IN
8691	3806	2	States	States	NNP
8691	3806	3	where	where	WRB
8691	3806	4	the	the	DT
8691	3806	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3806	6	are	be	VBP
8691	3806	7	only	only	RB
8691	3806	8	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3806	9	for	for	IN
8691	3806	10	a	a	DT
8691	3806	11	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3806	12	term	term	NN
8691	3806	13	of	of	IN
8691	3806	14	years	year	NNS
8691	3806	15	,	,	,
8691	3806	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3806	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	3806	18	not	not	RB
8691	3806	19	unusual	unusual	JJ
8691	3806	20	for	for	IN
8691	3806	21	the	the	DT
8691	3806	22	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3806	23	,	,	,
8691	3806	24	if	if	IN
8691	3806	25	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3806	26	has	have	VBZ
8691	3806	27	the	the	DT
8691	3806	28	power	power	NN
8691	3806	29	of	of	IN
8691	3806	30	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3806	31	,	,	,
8691	3806	32	to	to	TO
8691	3806	33	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	3806	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3806	35	in	in	IN
8691	3806	36	favor	favor	NN
8691	3806	37	of	of	IN
8691	3806	38	outgoing	outgoing	JJ
8691	3806	39	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3806	40	who	who	WP
8691	3806	41	are	be	VBP
8691	3806	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3806	43	political	political	JJ
8691	3806	44	opponents	opponent	NNS
8691	3806	45	.	.	.
8691	3807	1	So	so	RB
8691	3807	2	,	,	,
8691	3807	3	also	also	RB
8691	3807	4	,	,	,
8691	3807	5	if	if	IN
8691	3807	6	there	there	EX
8691	3807	7	happen	happen	VB
8691	3807	8	to	to	TO
8691	3807	9	be	be	VB
8691	3807	10	several	several	JJ
8691	3807	11	original	original	JJ
8691	3807	12	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
8691	3807	13	to	to	TO
8691	3807	14	fill	fill	VB
8691	3807	15	,	,	,
8691	3807	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3807	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	3807	18	the	the	DT
8691	3807	19	traditional	traditional	JJ
8691	3807	20	method	method	NN
8691	3807	21	in	in	IN
8691	3807	22	a	a	DT
8691	3807	23	few	few	JJ
8691	3807	24	States	state	NNS
8691	3807	25	to	to	TO
8691	3807	26	give	give	VB
8691	3807	27	one	one	CD
8691	3807	28	of	of	IN
8691	3807	29	the	the	DT
8691	3807	30	places	place	NNS
8691	3807	31	to	to	IN
8691	3807	32	a	a	DT
8691	3807	33	member	member	NN
8691	3807	34	of	of	IN
8691	3807	35	the	the	DT
8691	3807	36	opposition	opposition	NN
8691	3807	37	party	party	NN
8691	3807	38	.	.	.
8691	3808	1	If	if	IN
8691	3808	2	the	the	DT
8691	3808	3	election	election	NN
8691	3808	4	belongs	belong	VBZ
8691	3808	5	to	to	IN
8691	3808	6	the	the	DT
8691	3808	7	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3808	8	,	,	,
8691	3808	9	a	a	DT
8691	3808	10	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3808	11	practice	practice	NN
8691	3808	12	prevails	prevail	NNS
8691	3808	13	in	in	IN
8691	3808	14	some	some	DT
8691	3808	15	of	of	IN
8691	3808	16	the	the	DT
8691	3808	17	older	old	JJR
8691	3808	18	States	States	NNP
8691	3808	19	.	.	.
8691	3809	1	In	in	IN
8691	3809	2	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3809	3	but	but	CC
8691	3809	4	six	six	CD
8691	3809	5	instances	instance	NNS
8691	3809	6	of	of	IN
8691	3809	7	refusing	refuse	VBG
8691	3809	8	a	a	DT
8691	3809	9	re	re	NN
8691	3809	10	-	-	NN
8691	3809	11	election	election	NN
8691	3809	12	to	to	IN
8691	3809	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3809	14	of	of	IN
8691	3809	15	the	the	DT
8691	3809	16	higher	high	JJR
8691	3809	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	3809	18	for	for	IN
8691	3809	19	mere	mere	JJ
8691	3809	20	party	party	NN
8691	3809	21	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	3809	22	have	have	VBP
8691	3809	23	occurred	occur	VBN
8691	3809	24	for	for	IN
8691	3809	25	more	more	JJR
8691	3809	26	than	than	IN
8691	3809	27	a	a	DT
8691	3809	28	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3809	29	years	year	NNS
8691	3809	30	.	.	.
8691	3810	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3810	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3810	3	:	:	:
8691	3810	4	Judges	Judges	NNP
8691	3810	5	Baldwin	Baldwin	NNP
8691	3810	6	,	,	,
8691	3810	7	Goddard	Goddard	NNP
8691	3810	8	,	,	,
8691	3810	9	Gould	Gould	NNP
8691	3810	10	and	and	CC
8691	3810	11	Trumbull	Trumbull	NNP
8691	3810	12	were	be	VBD
8691	3810	13	dropped	drop	VBN
8691	3810	14	in	in	IN
8691	3810	15	1818	1818	CD
8691	3810	16	and	and	CC
8691	3810	17	1819	1819	CD
8691	3810	18	as	as	IN
8691	3810	19	an	an	DT
8691	3810	20	incident	incident	NN
8691	3810	21	of	of	IN
8691	3810	22	the	the	DT
8691	3810	23	political	political	JJ
8691	3810	24	revolution	revolution	NN
8691	3810	25	which	which	WDT
8691	3810	26	destroyed	destroy	VBD
8691	3810	27	the	the	DT
8691	3810	28	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
8691	3810	29	party	party	NN
8691	3810	30	in	in	IN
8691	3810	31	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3810	32	and	and	CC
8691	3810	33	brought	bring	VBD
8691	3810	34	about	about	RP
8691	3810	35	the	the	DT
8691	3810	36	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	3810	37	of	of	IN
8691	3810	38	a	a	DT
8691	3810	39	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3810	40	,	,	,
8691	3810	41	under	under	IN
8691	3810	42	which	which	WDT
8691	3810	43	the	the	DT
8691	3810	44	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3810	45	were	be	VBD
8691	3810	46	to	to	TO
8691	3810	47	hold	hold	VB
8691	3810	48	for	for	IN
8691	3810	49	life	life	NN
8691	3810	50	,	,	,
8691	3810	51	to	to	TO
8691	3810	52	replace	replace	VB
8691	3810	53	the	the	DT
8691	3810	54	royal	royal	JJ
8691	3810	55	charter	charter	NN
8691	3810	56	.	.	.
8691	3811	1	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	3811	2	Seymour	Seymour	NNP
8691	3811	3	and	and	CC
8691	3811	4	Waldo	Waldo	NNP
8691	3811	5	were	be	VBD
8691	3811	6	dropped	drop	VBN
8691	3811	7	in	in	IN
8691	3811	8	1863	1863	CD
8691	3811	9	during	during	IN
8691	3811	10	the	the	DT
8691	3811	11	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	3811	12	War	War	NNP
8691	3811	13	,	,	,
8691	3811	14	because	because	IN
8691	3811	15	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3811	16	were	be	VBD
8691	3811	17	classed	class	VBN
8691	3811	18	with	with	IN
8691	3811	19	the	the	DT
8691	3811	20	"	"	``
8691	3811	21	Peace	Peace	NNP
8691	3811	22	Democrats	Democrats	NNPS
8691	3811	23	.	.	.
8691	3811	24	"	"	''
8691	3812	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3812	2	successors	successor	NNS
8691	3812	3	,	,	,
8691	3812	4	however	however	RB
8691	3812	5	,	,	,
8691	3812	6	were	be	VBD
8691	3812	7	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3812	8	from	from	IN
8691	3812	9	the	the	DT
8691	3812	10	"	"	``
8691	3812	11	War	war	JJ
8691	3812	12	Democrats	Democrats	NNPS
8691	3812	13	,	,	,
8691	3812	14	"	"	''
8691	3812	15	though	though	IN
8691	3812	16	the	the	DT
8691	3812	17	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3812	18	was	be	VBD
8691	3812	19	Republican	Republican	NNP
8691	3812	20	.	.	.
8691	3812	21	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3813	1	In	in	IN
8691	3813	2	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
8691	3813	3	,	,	,
8691	3813	4	where	where	WRB
8691	3813	5	elections	election	NNS
8691	3813	6	to	to	IN
8691	3813	7	the	the	DT
8691	3813	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3813	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3813	10	were	be	VBD
8691	3813	11	annual	annual	JJ
8691	3813	12	,	,	,
8691	3813	13	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3813	14	Redfield	Redfield	NNP
8691	3813	15	was	be	VBD
8691	3813	16	placed	place	VBN
8691	3813	17	on	on	IN
8691	3813	18	the	the	DT
8691	3813	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3813	20	bench	bench	NN
8691	3813	21	and	and	CC
8691	3813	22	then	then	RB
8691	3813	23	re	re	VB
8691	3813	24	-	-	JJ
8691	3813	25	elected	elect	VBN
8691	3813	26	year	year	NN
8691	3813	27	after	after	IN
8691	3813	28	year	year	NN
8691	3813	29	for	for	IN
8691	3813	30	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3813	31	-	-	HYPH
8691	3813	32	three	three	CD
8691	3813	33	successive	successive	JJ
8691	3813	34	years	year	NNS
8691	3813	35	by	by	IN
8691	3813	36	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	3813	37	controlled	control	VBN
8691	3813	38	by	by	IN
8691	3813	39	the	the	DT
8691	3813	40	party	party	NN
8691	3813	41	politically	politically	RB
8691	3813	42	opposed	opposed	JJ
8691	3813	43	to	to	IN
8691	3813	44	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3813	45	.	.	.
8691	3814	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3814	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3814	3	:	:	:
8691	3814	4	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	3814	5	J.	J.	NNP
8691	3814	6	Phelps	Phelps	NNP
8691	3814	7	,	,	,
8691	3814	8	"	"	``
8691	3814	9	Orations	Orations	NNPS
8691	3814	10	and	and	CC
8691	3814	11	Essays	Essays	NNPS
8691	3814	12	,	,	,
8691	3814	13	"	"	''
8691	3814	14	220	220	CD
8691	3814	15	.	.	.
8691	3814	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3815	1	In	in	IN
8691	3815	2	a	a	DT
8691	3815	3	few	few	JJ
8691	3815	4	States	state	NNS
8691	3815	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3815	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3815	7	not	not	RB
8691	3815	8	customary	customary	JJ
8691	3815	9	for	for	IN
8691	3815	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3815	11	party	party	NN
8691	3815	12	to	to	TO
8691	3815	13	renominate	renominate	VB
8691	3815	14	a	a	DT
8691	3815	15	judge	judge	NN
8691	3815	16	more	more	RBR
8691	3815	17	than	than	IN
8691	3815	18	once	once	RB
8691	3815	19	.	.	.
8691	3816	1	Two	two	CD
8691	3816	2	terms	term	NNS
8691	3816	3	are	be	VBP
8691	3816	4	considered	consider	VBN
8691	3816	5	enough	enough	RB
8691	3816	6	for	for	IN
8691	3816	7	one	one	CD
8691	3816	8	man	man	NN
8691	3816	9	,	,	,
8691	3816	10	and	and	CC
8691	3816	11	when	when	WRB
8691	3816	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3816	13	has	have	VBZ
8691	3816	14	served	serve	VBN
8691	3816	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3816	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3816	17	should	should	MD
8691	3816	18	make	make	VB
8691	3816	19	room	room	NN
8691	3816	20	for	for	IN
8691	3816	21	some	some	DT
8691	3816	22	one	one	NN
8691	3816	23	else	else	RB
8691	3816	24	.	.	.
8691	3817	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	3817	2	a	a	DT
8691	3817	3	judge	judge	NN
8691	3817	4	has	have	VBZ
8691	3817	5	thus	thus	RB
8691	3817	6	been	be	VBN
8691	3817	7	taken	take	VBN
8691	3817	8	from	from	IN
8691	3817	9	the	the	DT
8691	3817	10	bench	bench	NN
8691	3817	11	at	at	IN
8691	3817	12	a	a	DT
8691	3817	13	time	time	NN
8691	3817	14	when	when	WRB
8691	3817	15	,	,	,
8691	3817	16	with	with	IN
8691	3817	17	the	the	DT
8691	3817	18	aid	aid	NN
8691	3817	19	of	of	IN
8691	3817	20	experience	experience	NN
8691	3817	21	,	,	,
8691	3817	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3817	23	was	be	VBD
8691	3817	24	doing	do	VBG
8691	3817	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3817	26	best	good	JJS
8691	3817	27	work	work	NN
8691	3817	28	.	.	.
8691	3818	1	Appointments	appointment	NNS
8691	3818	2	to	to	TO
8691	3818	3	appellate	appellate	VB
8691	3818	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	3818	5	are	be	VBP
8691	3818	6	generally	generally	RB
8691	3818	7	provided	provide	VBN
8691	3818	8	for	for	IN
8691	3818	9	by	by	IN
8691	3818	10	a	a	DT
8691	3818	11	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	3818	12	calculated	calculate	VBN
8691	3818	13	to	to	TO
8691	3818	14	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	3818	15	any	any	DT
8691	3818	16	sudden	sudden	JJ
8691	3818	17	and	and	CC
8691	3818	18	general	general	JJ
8691	3818	19	changes	change	NNS
8691	3818	20	of	of	IN
8691	3818	21	membership	membership	NN
8691	3818	22	.	.	.
8691	3819	1	Not	not	RB
8691	3819	2	more	more	JJR
8691	3819	3	than	than	IN
8691	3819	4	one	one	CD
8691	3819	5	or	or	CC
8691	3819	6	two	two	CD
8691	3819	7	receive	receive	VBP
8691	3819	8	an	an	DT
8691	3819	9	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	3819	10	in	in	IN
8691	3819	11	any	any	DT
8691	3819	12	one	one	CD
8691	3819	13	year	year	NN
8691	3819	14	,	,	,
8691	3819	15	so	so	IN
8691	3819	16	that	that	IN
8691	3819	17	the	the	DT
8691	3819	18	terms	term	NNS
8691	3819	19	of	of	IN
8691	3819	20	not	not	RB
8691	3819	21	more	more	JJR
8691	3819	22	than	than	IN
8691	3819	23	one	one	CD
8691	3819	24	or	or	CC
8691	3819	25	two	two	CD
8691	3819	26	can	can	MD
8691	3819	27	expire	expire	VB
8691	3819	28	at	at	IN
8691	3819	29	the	the	DT
8691	3819	30	same	same	JJ
8691	3819	31	time	time	NN
8691	3819	32	.	.	.
8691	3820	1	Where	where	WRB
8691	3820	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3820	3	hold	hold	VBP
8691	3820	4	for	for	IN
8691	3820	5	life	life	NN
8691	3820	6	or	or	CC
8691	3820	7	--	--	:
8691	3820	8	as	as	IN
8691	3820	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	3820	10	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	3820	11	the	the	DT
8691	3820	12	case	case	NN
8691	3820	13	--	--	:
8691	3820	14	if	if	IN
8691	3820	15	there	there	EX
8691	3820	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	3820	17	a	a	DT
8691	3820	18	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3820	19	provision	provision	NN
8691	3820	20	that	that	IN
8691	3820	21	no	no	DT
8691	3820	22	judge	judge	NN
8691	3820	23	shall	shall	MD
8691	3820	24	hold	hold	VB
8691	3820	25	office	office	NN
8691	3820	26	after	after	IN
8691	3820	27	reaching	reach	VBG
8691	3820	28	the	the	DT
8691	3820	29	age	age	NN
8691	3820	30	of	of	IN
8691	3820	31	seventy	seventy	CD
8691	3820	32	,	,	,
8691	3820	33	the	the	DT
8691	3820	34	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
8691	3820	35	will	will	MD
8691	3820	36	,	,	,
8691	3820	37	of	of	IN
8691	3820	38	course	course	NN
8691	3820	39	,	,	,
8691	3820	40	occur	occur	VB
8691	3820	41	and	and	CC
8691	3820	42	be	be	VB
8691	3820	43	filled	fill	VBN
8691	3820	44	at	at	IN
8691	3820	45	irregular	irregular	JJ
8691	3820	46	intervals	interval	NNS
8691	3820	47	.	.	.
8691	3821	1	All	all	PDT
8691	3821	2	this	this	DT
8691	3821	3	,	,	,
8691	3821	4	in	in	IN
8691	3821	5	connection	connection	NN
8691	3821	6	with	with	IN
8691	3821	7	the	the	DT
8691	3821	8	natural	natural	JJ
8691	3821	9	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	3821	10	to	to	TO
8691	3821	11	reappoint	reappoint	VB
8691	3821	12	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3821	13	who	who	WP
8691	3821	14	have	have	VBP
8691	3821	15	earned	earn	VBN
8691	3821	16	the	the	DT
8691	3821	17	public	public	JJ
8691	3821	18	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	3821	19	,	,	,
8691	3821	20	secures	secure	NNS
8691	3821	21	to	to	IN
8691	3821	22	the	the	DT
8691	3821	23	court	court	NN
8691	3821	24	a	a	DT
8691	3821	25	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3821	26	continuity	continuity	NN
8691	3821	27	of	of	IN
8691	3821	28	existence	existence	NN
8691	3821	29	and	and	CC
8691	3821	30	consistency	consistency	NN
8691	3821	31	of	of	IN
8691	3821	32	view	view	NN
8691	3821	33	.	.	.
8691	3822	1	In	in	IN
8691	3822	2	every	every	DT
8691	3822	3	court	court	NN
8691	3822	4	of	of	IN
8691	3822	5	last	last	JJ
8691	3822	6	resort	resort	NN
8691	3822	7	in	in	IN
8691	3822	8	the	the	DT
8691	3822	9	older	old	JJR
8691	3822	10	States	States	NNP
8691	3822	11	there	there	EX
8691	3822	12	will	will	MD
8691	3822	13	be	be	VB
8691	3822	14	apt	apt	JJ
8691	3822	15	to	to	TO
8691	3822	16	be	be	VB
8691	3822	17	found	find	VBN
8691	3822	18	some	some	DT
8691	3822	19	who	who	WP
8691	3822	20	have	have	VBP
8691	3822	21	served	serve	VBN
8691	3822	22	ten	ten	CD
8691	3822	23	or	or	CC
8691	3822	24	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	3822	25	years	year	NNS
8691	3822	26	and	and	CC
8691	3822	27	were	be	VBD
8691	3822	28	at	at	IN
8691	3822	29	first	first	RB
8691	3822	30	associated	associate	VBN
8691	3822	31	with	with	IN
8691	3822	32	those	those	DT
8691	3822	33	who	who	WP
8691	3822	34	had	have	VBD
8691	3822	35	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3822	36	then	then	RB
8691	3822	37	served	serve	VBN
8691	3822	38	as	as	RB
8691	3822	39	long	long	RB
8691	3822	40	.	.	.
8691	3823	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3823	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3823	3	not	not	RB
8691	3823	4	easy	easy	JJ
8691	3823	5	to	to	TO
8691	3823	6	"	"	``
8691	3823	7	pack	pack	VB
8691	3823	8	"	"	''
8691	3823	9	a	a	DT
8691	3823	10	court	court	NN
8691	3823	11	thus	thus	RB
8691	3823	12	constituted	constitute	VBD
8691	3823	13	.	.	.
8691	3824	1	If	if	IN
8691	3824	2	,	,	,
8691	3824	3	however	however	RB
8691	3824	4	,	,	,
8691	3824	5	some	some	DT
8691	3824	6	question	question	NN
8691	3824	7	of	of	IN
8691	3824	8	supreme	supreme	JJ
8691	3824	9	political	political	JJ
8691	3824	10	importance	importance	NN
8691	3824	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	3824	12	looming	loom	VBG
8691	3824	13	up	up	RP
8691	3824	14	,	,	,
8691	3824	15	likely	likely	RB
8691	3824	16	soon	soon	RB
8691	3824	17	to	to	TO
8691	3824	18	become	become	VB
8691	3824	19	the	the	DT
8691	3824	20	subject	subject	NN
8691	3824	21	of	of	IN
8691	3824	22	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	3824	23	,	,	,
8691	3824	24	the	the	DT
8691	3824	25	nominating	nominating	NN
8691	3824	26	or	or	CC
8691	3824	27	appointing	appoint	VBG
8691	3824	28	power	power	NN
8691	3824	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	3824	30	not	not	RB
8691	3824	31	likely	likely	JJ
8691	3824	32	to	to	TO
8691	3824	33	be	be	VB
8691	3824	34	insensible	insensible	JJ
8691	3824	35	of	of	IN
8691	3824	36	the	the	DT
8691	3824	37	party	party	NN
8691	3824	38	advantages	advantage	NNS
8691	3824	39	that	that	WDT
8691	3824	40	may	may	MD
8691	3824	41	result	result	VB
8691	3824	42	from	from	IN
8691	3824	43	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3824	44	decision	decision	NN
8691	3824	45	in	in	IN
8691	3824	46	a	a	DT
8691	3824	47	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3824	48	way	way	NN
8691	3824	49	by	by	IN
8691	3824	50	the	the	DT
8691	3824	51	highest	high	JJS
8691	3824	52	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3824	53	authority	authority	NN
8691	3824	54	,	,	,
8691	3824	55	nor	nor	CC
8691	3824	56	of	of	IN
8691	3824	57	the	the	DT
8691	3824	58	importance	importance	NN
8691	3824	59	of	of	IN
8691	3824	60	the	the	DT
8691	3824	61	vote	vote	NN
8691	3824	62	to	to	TO
8691	3824	63	be	be	VB
8691	3824	64	cast	cast	VBN
8691	3824	65	by	by	IN
8691	3824	66	each	each	DT
8691	3824	67	who	who	WP
8691	3824	68	may	may	MD
8691	3824	69	share	share	VB
8691	3824	70	in	in	IN
8691	3824	71	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3824	72	administration	administration	NN
8691	3824	73	.	.	.
8691	3825	1	During	during	IN
8691	3825	2	the	the	DT
8691	3825	3	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	3825	4	War	War	NNP
8691	3825	5	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3825	6	passed	pass	VBD
8691	3825	7	a	a	DT
8691	3825	8	conscription	conscription	NN
8691	3825	9	law	law	NN
8691	3825	10	.	.	.
8691	3826	1	The	the	DT
8691	3826	2	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3826	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3826	4	of	of	IN
8691	3826	5	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3826	6	pronounced	pronounce	VBD
8691	3826	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3826	8	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	3826	9	,	,	,
8691	3826	10	and	and	CC
8691	3826	11	advised	advise	VBD
8691	3826	12	the	the	DT
8691	3826	13	issue	issue	NN
8691	3826	14	of	of	IN
8691	3826	15	a	a	DT
8691	3826	16	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	3826	17	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	3826	18	to	to	TO
8691	3826	19	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	3826	20	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3826	21	enforcement	enforcement	NN
8691	3826	22	by	by	IN
8691	3826	23	the	the	DT
8691	3826	24	officials	official	NNS
8691	3826	25	charged	charge	VBN
8691	3826	26	with	with	IN
8691	3826	27	that	that	DT
8691	3826	28	function	function	NN
8691	3826	29	.	.	.
8691	3827	1	The	the	DT
8691	3827	2	term	term	NN
8691	3827	3	of	of	IN
8691	3827	4	the	the	DT
8691	3827	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3827	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3827	7	was	be	VBD
8691	3827	8	about	about	JJ
8691	3827	9	to	to	TO
8691	3827	10	expire	expire	VB
8691	3827	11	.	.	.
8691	3828	1	The	the	DT
8691	3828	2	decision	decision	NN
8691	3828	3	had	have	VBD
8691	3828	4	been	be	VBN
8691	3828	5	made	make	VBN
8691	3828	6	by	by	IN
8691	3828	7	three	three	CD
8691	3828	8	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3828	9	,	,	,
8691	3828	10	of	of	IN
8691	3828	11	whom	whom	WP
8691	3828	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3828	13	was	be	VBD
8691	3828	14	one	one	CD
8691	3828	15	,	,	,
8691	3828	16	against	against	IN
8691	3828	17	two	two	CD
8691	3828	18	who	who	WP
8691	3828	19	dissented	dissent	VBD
8691	3828	20	.	.	.
8691	3829	1	The	the	DT
8691	3829	2	political	political	JJ
8691	3829	3	party	party	NN
8691	3829	4	to	to	TO
8691	3829	5	which	which	WDT
8691	3829	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3829	7	belonged	belong	VBD
8691	3829	8	renominated	renominate	VBD
8691	3829	9	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3829	10	,	,	,
8691	3829	11	but	but	CC
8691	3829	12	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3829	13	was	be	VBD
8691	3829	14	defeated	defeat	VBN
8691	3829	15	at	at	IN
8691	3829	16	the	the	DT
8691	3829	17	polls	poll	NNS
8691	3829	18	.	.	.
8691	3830	1	A	a	DT
8691	3830	2	motion	motion	NN
8691	3830	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3830	4	soon	soon	RB
8691	3830	5	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	3830	6	made	make	VBN
8691	3830	7	to	to	TO
8691	3830	8	dissolve	dissolve	VB
8691	3830	9	the	the	DT
8691	3830	10	injunction	injunction	NN
8691	3830	11	.	.	.
8691	3831	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3831	2	successor	successor	NN
8691	3831	3	joined	join	VBD
8691	3831	4	with	with	IN
8691	3831	5	the	the	DT
8691	3831	6	former	former	JJ
8691	3831	7	minority	minority	NN
8691	3831	8	in	in	IN
8691	3831	9	advising	advise	VBG
8691	3831	10	that	that	IN
8691	3831	11	the	the	DT
8691	3831	12	motion	motion	NN
8691	3831	13	be	be	VB
8691	3831	14	granted	grant	VBN
8691	3831	15	,	,	,
8691	3831	16	and	and	CC
8691	3831	17	on	on	IN
8691	3831	18	the	the	DT
8691	3831	19	ground	ground	NN
8691	3831	20	that	that	IN
8691	3831	21	the	the	DT
8691	3831	22	Act	Act	NNP
8691	3831	23	of	of	IN
8691	3831	24	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3831	25	was	be	VBD
8691	3831	26	not	not	RB
8691	3831	27	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	3831	28	.	.	.
8691	3832	1	The	the	DT
8691	3832	2	two	two	CD
8691	3832	3	remaining	remain	VBG
8691	3832	4	members	member	NNS
8691	3832	5	of	of	IN
8691	3832	6	the	the	DT
8691	3832	7	court	court	NN
8691	3832	8	adhered	adhere	VBD
8691	3832	9	to	to	IN
8691	3832	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3832	11	former	former	JJ
8691	3832	12	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3832	13	.	.	.
8691	3833	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3833	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3833	3	:	:	:
8691	3833	4	Kneedler	Kneedler	NNP
8691	3833	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3833	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	3833	7	_	_	NNP
8691	3833	8	Lane	Lane	NNP
8691	3833	9	,	,	,
8691	3833	10	45	45	CD
8691	3833	11	Penn	Penn	NNP
8691	3833	12	.	.	.
8691	3834	1	State	State	NNP
8691	3834	2	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3834	3	,	,	,
8691	3834	4	238	238	CD
8691	3834	5	.	.	.
8691	3835	1	See	see	VB
8691	3835	2	this	this	DT
8691	3835	3	case	case	NN
8691	3835	4	reviewed	review	VBN
8691	3835	5	in	in	IN
8691	3835	6	Pomeroy	Pomeroy	NNP
8691	3835	7	,	,	,
8691	3835	8	"	"	``
8691	3835	9	Introduction	introduction	NN
8691	3835	10	to	to	IN
8691	3835	11	the	the	DT
8691	3835	12	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
8691	3835	13	Law	Law	NNP
8691	3835	14	of	of	IN
8691	3835	15	the	the	DT
8691	3835	16	United	United	NNP
8691	3835	17	States	States	NNP
8691	3835	18	,	,	,
8691	3835	19	"	"	''
8691	3835	20	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	3835	21	.	.	.
8691	3836	1	479	479	CD
8691	3836	2	.	.	.
8691	3836	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3837	1	In	in	IN
8691	3837	2	some	some	DT
8691	3837	3	States	state	NNS
8691	3837	4	the	the	DT
8691	3837	5	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3837	6	of	of	IN
8691	3837	7	the	the	DT
8691	3837	8	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3837	9	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3837	10	select	select	VBP
8691	3837	11	one	one	CD
8691	3837	12	of	of	IN
8691	3837	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3837	14	number	number	NN
8691	3837	15	annually	annually	RB
8691	3837	16	to	to	TO
8691	3837	17	be	be	VB
8691	3837	18	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3837	19	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3837	20	for	for	IN
8691	3837	21	the	the	DT
8691	3837	22	year	year	NN
8691	3837	23	ensuing	ensue	VBG
8691	3837	24	.	.	.
8691	3838	1	In	in	IN
8691	3838	2	several	several	JJ
8691	3838	3	,	,	,
8691	3838	4	whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	3838	5	there	there	EX
8691	3838	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3838	7	a	a	DT
8691	3838	8	vacancy	vacancy	NN
8691	3838	9	,	,	,
8691	3838	10	the	the	DT
8691	3838	11	office	office	NN
8691	3838	12	falls	fall	VBZ
8691	3838	13	,	,	,
8691	3838	14	as	as	IN
8691	3838	15	of	of	IN
8691	3838	16	course	course	NN
8691	3838	17	,	,	,
8691	3838	18	to	to	IN
8691	3838	19	the	the	DT
8691	3838	20	justice	justice	NN
8691	3838	21	who	who	WP
8691	3838	22	has	have	VBZ
8691	3838	23	the	the	DT
8691	3838	24	shortest	short	JJS
8691	3838	25	time	time	NN
8691	3838	26	to	to	TO
8691	3838	27	serve	serve	VB
8691	3838	28	.	.	.
8691	3839	1	This	this	DT
8691	3839	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3839	3	a	a	DT
8691	3839	4	ready	ready	JJ
8691	3839	5	way	way	NN
8691	3839	6	to	to	TO
8691	3839	7	pass	pass	VB
8691	3839	8	a	a	DT
8691	3839	9	title	title	NN
8691	3839	10	about	about	IN
8691	3839	11	and	and	CC
8691	3839	12	attach	attach	VB
8691	3839	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3839	14	to	to	IN
8691	3839	15	as	as	RB
8691	3839	16	many	many	JJ
8691	3839	17	men	man	NNS
8691	3839	18	as	as	IN
8691	3839	19	possible	possible	JJ
8691	3839	20	in	in	IN
8691	3839	21	quick	quick	JJ
8691	3839	22	succession	succession	NN
8691	3839	23	.	.	.
8691	3840	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3840	2	ostensible	ostensible	JJ
8691	3840	3	defense	defense	NN
8691	3840	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3840	5	that	that	IN
8691	3840	6	there	there	EX
8691	3840	7	can	can	MD
8691	3840	8	be	be	VB
8691	3840	9	no	no	DT
8691	3840	10	unfair	unfair	JJ
8691	3840	11	discrimination	discrimination	NN
8691	3840	12	and	and	CC
8691	3840	13	favoritism	favoritism	NN
8691	3840	14	in	in	IN
8691	3840	15	such	such	PDT
8691	3840	16	an	an	DT
8691	3840	17	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	3840	18	,	,	,
8691	3840	19	and	and	CC
8691	3840	20	that	that	IN
8691	3840	21	as	as	IN
8691	3840	22	the	the	DT
8691	3840	23	judge	judge	NN
8691	3840	24	whose	whose	WP$
8691	3840	25	term	term	NN
8691	3840	26	has	have	VBZ
8691	3840	27	most	most	RBS
8691	3840	28	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	3840	29	elapsed	elapse	VBN
8691	3840	30	will	will	MD
8691	3840	31	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	3840	32	be	be	VB
8691	3840	33	the	the	DT
8691	3840	34	one	one	CD
8691	3840	35	who	who	WP
8691	3840	36	has	have	VBZ
8691	3840	37	served	serve	VBN
8691	3840	38	the	the	DT
8691	3840	39	longest	long	JJS
8691	3840	40	,	,	,
8691	3840	41	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3840	42	will	will	MD
8691	3840	43	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	3840	44	have	have	VB
8691	3840	45	the	the	DT
8691	3840	46	advantages	advantage	NNS
8691	3840	47	of	of	IN
8691	3840	48	experience	experience	NN
8691	3840	49	.	.	.
8691	3841	1	These	these	DT
8691	3841	2	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	3841	3	deserve	deserve	VBP
8691	3841	4	little	little	JJ
8691	3841	5	weight	weight	NN
8691	3841	6	in	in	IN
8691	3841	7	view	view	NN
8691	3841	8	of	of	IN
8691	3841	9	the	the	DT
8691	3841	10	sacrifices	sacrifice	NNS
8691	3841	11	that	that	WDT
8691	3841	12	such	such	PDT
8691	3841	13	a	a	DT
8691	3841	14	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	3841	15	entails	entail	VBZ
8691	3841	16	.	.	.
8691	3842	1	Unfair	unfair	JJ
8691	3842	2	discrimination	discrimination	NN
8691	3842	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3842	4	indeed	indeed	RB
8691	3842	5	prevented	prevent	VBN
8691	3842	6	,	,	,
8691	3842	7	but	but	CC
8691	3842	8	so	so	RB
8691	3842	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	3842	10	a	a	DT
8691	3842	11	just	just	JJ
8691	3842	12	and	and	CC
8691	3842	13	proper	proper	JJ
8691	3842	14	discrimination	discrimination	NN
8691	3842	15	.	.	.
8691	3843	1	The	the	DT
8691	3843	2	plan	plan	NN
8691	3843	3	of	of	IN
8691	3843	4	promoting	promote	VBG
8691	3843	5	the	the	DT
8691	3843	6	senior	senior	JJ
8691	3843	7	associate	associate	JJ
8691	3843	8	justice	justice	NN
8691	3843	9	when	when	WRB
8691	3843	10	a	a	DT
8691	3843	11	vacancy	vacancy	NN
8691	3843	12	occurs	occur	VBZ
8691	3843	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	3843	14	liable	liable	JJ
8691	3843	15	to	to	IN
8691	3843	16	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3843	17	objections	objection	NNS
8691	3843	18	,	,	,
8691	3843	19	though	though	IN
8691	3843	20	in	in	IN
8691	3843	21	less	less	JJR
8691	3843	22	degree	degree	NN
8691	3843	23	.	.	.
8691	3844	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3844	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3844	3	at	at	IN
8691	3844	4	least	least	JJS
8691	3844	5	not	not	RB
8691	3844	6	unlikely	unlikely	JJ
8691	3844	7	to	to	TO
8691	3844	8	serve	serve	VB
8691	3844	9	for	for	IN
8691	3844	10	a	a	DT
8691	3844	11	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	3844	12	time	time	NN
8691	3844	13	.	.	.
8691	3845	1	To	to	TO
8691	3845	2	be	be	VB
8691	3845	3	a	a	DT
8691	3845	4	good	good	JJ
8691	3845	5	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3845	6	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3845	7	requires	require	VBZ
8691	3845	8	special	special	JJ
8691	3845	9	gifts	gift	NNS
8691	3845	10	.	.	.
8691	3846	1	Whoever	whoever	WP
8691	3846	2	holds	hold	VBZ
8691	3846	3	that	that	DT
8691	3846	4	office	office	NN
8691	3846	5	should	should	MD
8691	3846	6	have	have	VB
8691	3846	7	not	not	RB
8691	3846	8	only	only	RB
8691	3846	9	learning	learning	NN
8691	3846	10	and	and	CC
8691	3846	11	ability	ability	NN
8691	3846	12	,	,	,
8691	3846	13	but	but	CC
8691	3846	14	patience	patience	NN
8691	3846	15	and	and	CC
8691	3846	16	courtesy	courtesy	NN
8691	3846	17	in	in	IN
8691	3846	18	a	a	DT
8691	3846	19	high	high	JJ
8691	3846	20	degree	degree	NN
8691	3846	21	.	.	.
8691	3847	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3847	2	must	must	MD
8691	3847	3	be	be	VB
8691	3847	4	methodical	methodical	JJ
8691	3847	5	in	in	IN
8691	3847	6	the	the	DT
8691	3847	7	transaction	transaction	NN
8691	3847	8	of	of	IN
8691	3847	9	business	business	NN
8691	3847	10	,	,	,
8691	3847	11	if	if	IN
8691	3847	12	the	the	DT
8691	3847	13	docket	docket	NN
8691	3847	14	of	of	IN
8691	3847	15	the	the	DT
8691	3847	16	court	court	NN
8691	3847	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	3847	18	a	a	DT
8691	3847	19	large	large	JJ
8691	3847	20	one	one	NN
8691	3847	21	.	.	.
8691	3848	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3848	2	should	should	MD
8691	3848	3	have	have	VB
8691	3848	4	the	the	DT
8691	3848	5	art	art	NN
8691	3848	6	of	of	IN
8691	3848	7	presiding	preside	VBG
8691	3848	8	over	over	IN
8691	3848	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3848	10	public	public	JJ
8691	3848	11	sessions	session	NNS
8691	3848	12	and	and	CC
8691	3848	13	disposing	disposing	NN
8691	3848	14	of	of	IN
8691	3848	15	the	the	DT
8691	3848	16	minor	minor	JJ
8691	3848	17	motions	motion	NNS
8691	3848	18	which	which	WDT
8691	3848	19	may	may	MD
8691	3848	20	be	be	VB
8691	3848	21	made	make	VBN
8691	3848	22	from	from	IN
8691	3848	23	the	the	DT
8691	3848	24	bar	bar	NN
8691	3848	25	with	with	IN
8691	3848	26	dignity	dignity	NN
8691	3848	27	and	and	CC
8691	3848	28	tact	tact	NN
8691	3848	29	.	.	.
8691	3849	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3849	2	should	should	MD
8691	3849	3	be	be	VB
8691	3849	4	a	a	DT
8691	3849	5	man	man	NN
8691	3849	6	who	who	WP
8691	3849	7	commonly	commonly	RB
8691	3849	8	carries	carry	VBZ
8691	3849	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3849	10	associates	associate	NNS
8691	3849	11	with	with	IN
8691	3849	12	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3849	13	at	at	IN
8691	3849	14	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3849	15	private	private	JJ
8691	3849	16	consultations	consultation	NNS
8691	3849	17	in	in	IN
8691	3849	18	support	support	NN
8691	3849	19	of	of	IN
8691	3849	20	any	any	DT
8691	3849	21	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	3849	22	which	which	WDT
8691	3849	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3849	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	3849	25	firmly	firmly	RB
8691	3849	26	convinced	convinced	JJ
8691	3849	27	to	to	TO
8691	3849	28	be	be	VB
8691	3849	29	the	the	DT
8691	3849	30	law	law	NN
8691	3849	31	applicable	applicable	JJ
8691	3849	32	to	to	IN
8691	3849	33	the	the	DT
8691	3849	34	case	case	NN
8691	3849	35	in	in	IN
8691	3849	36	hand	hand	NN
8691	3849	37	.	.	.
8691	3850	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3850	2	should	should	MD
8691	3850	3	have	have	VB
8691	3850	4	the	the	DT
8691	3850	5	faculty	faculty	NN
8691	3850	6	of	of	IN
8691	3850	7	conciliation	conciliation	NN
8691	3850	8	.	.	.
8691	3851	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3851	2	should	should	MD
8691	3851	3	know	know	VB
8691	3851	4	when	when	WRB
8691	3851	5	to	to	TO
8691	3851	6	yield	yield	VB
8691	3851	7	as	as	RB
8691	3851	8	well	well	RB
8691	3851	9	as	as	IN
8691	3851	10	to	to	TO
8691	3851	11	insist	insist	VB
8691	3851	12	,	,	,
8691	3851	13	in	in	IN
8691	3851	14	order	order	NN
8691	3851	15	to	to	TO
8691	3851	16	secure	secure	VB
8691	3851	17	the	the	DT
8691	3851	18	best	good	JJS
8691	3851	19	results	result	NNS
8691	3851	20	for	for	IN
8691	3851	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3851	22	court	court	NN
8691	3851	23	and	and	CC
8691	3851	24	for	for	IN
8691	3851	25	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3851	26	State	State	NNP
8691	3851	27	.	.	.
8691	3852	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3852	2	should	should	MD
8691	3852	3	be	be	VB
8691	3852	4	able	able	JJ
8691	3852	5	to	to	TO
8691	3852	6	write	write	VB
8691	3852	7	a	a	DT
8691	3852	8	clear	clear	JJ
8691	3852	9	and	and	CC
8691	3852	10	forcible	forcible	JJ
8691	3852	11	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3852	12	.	.	.
8691	3853	1	The	the	DT
8691	3853	2	best	good	JJS
8691	3853	3	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	3853	4	in	in	IN
8691	3853	5	the	the	DT
8691	3853	6	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	3853	7	who	who	WP
8691	3853	8	may	may	MD
8691	3853	9	be	be	VB
8691	3853	10	supposed	suppose	VBN
8691	3853	11	to	to	TO
8691	3853	12	have	have	VB
8691	3853	13	these	these	DT
8691	3853	14	qualities	quality	NNS
8691	3853	15	and	and	CC
8691	3853	16	will	will	MD
8691	3853	17	accept	accept	VB
8691	3853	18	the	the	DT
8691	3853	19	position	position	NN
8691	3853	20	ought	ought	MD
8691	3853	21	to	to	TO
8691	3853	22	be	be	VB
8691	3853	23	at	at	IN
8691	3853	24	the	the	DT
8691	3853	25	head	head	NN
8691	3853	26	of	of	IN
8691	3853	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3853	28	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	3853	29	.	.	.
8691	3854	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	3854	2	have	have	VBP
8691	3854	3	been	be	VBN
8691	3854	4	tempted	tempt	VBN
8691	3854	5	from	from	IN
8691	3854	6	the	the	DT
8691	3854	7	bar	bar	NN
8691	3854	8	by	by	IN
8691	3854	9	an	an	DT
8691	3854	10	offer	offer	NN
8691	3854	11	of	of	IN
8691	3854	12	that	that	DT
8691	3854	13	place	place	NN
8691	3854	14	who	who	WP
8691	3854	15	would	would	MD
8691	3854	16	have	have	VB
8691	3854	17	refused	refuse	VBN
8691	3854	18	the	the	DT
8691	3854	19	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	3854	20	of	of	IN
8691	3854	21	associate	associate	JJ
8691	3854	22	justice	justice	NN
8691	3854	23	.	.	.
8691	3855	1	John	John	NNP
8691	3855	2	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	3855	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3855	4	one	one	CD
8691	3855	5	of	of	IN
8691	3855	6	these	these	DT
8691	3855	7	.	.	.
8691	3856	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3856	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3856	3	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
8691	3856	4	of	of	IN
8691	3856	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3856	6	was	be	VBD
8691	3856	7	another	another	DT
8691	3856	8	.	.	.
8691	3857	1	In	in	IN
8691	3857	2	the	the	DT
8691	3857	3	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3857	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3857	5	of	of	IN
8691	3857	6	the	the	DT
8691	3857	7	United	United	NNP
8691	3857	8	States	States	NNP
8691	3857	9	no	no	DT
8691	3857	10	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3857	11	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3857	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	3857	13	ever	ever	RB
8691	3857	14	been	be	VBN
8691	3857	15	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3857	16	from	from	IN
8691	3857	17	among	among	IN
8691	3857	18	the	the	DT
8691	3857	19	associate	associate	JJ
8691	3857	20	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3857	21	,	,	,
8691	3857	22	although	although	IN
8691	3857	23	a	a	DT
8691	3857	24	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3857	25	was	be	VBD
8691	3857	26	offered	offer	VBN
8691	3857	27	to	to	IN
8691	3857	28	and	and	CC
8691	3857	29	declined	decline	VBD
8691	3857	30	by	by	IN
8691	3857	31	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	3857	32	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3857	33	Cushing	Cushing	NNP
8691	3857	34	in	in	IN
8691	3857	35	1796	1796	CD
8691	3857	36	.	.	.
8691	3858	1	In	in	IN
8691	3858	2	the	the	DT
8691	3858	3	State	State	NNP
8691	3858	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	3858	5	the	the	DT
8691	3858	6	general	general	JJ
8691	3858	7	practice	practice	NN
8691	3858	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	3858	9	to	to	IN
8691	3858	10	the	the	DT
8691	3858	11	contrary	contrary	NN
8691	3858	12	,	,	,
8691	3858	13	and	and	CC
8691	3858	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3858	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	3858	16	common	common	JJ
8691	3858	17	to	to	TO
8691	3858	18	fill	fill	VB
8691	3858	19	a	a	DT
8691	3858	20	vacancy	vacancy	NN
8691	3858	21	by	by	IN
8691	3858	22	appointing	appoint	VBG
8691	3858	23	one	one	CD
8691	3858	24	of	of	IN
8691	3858	25	the	the	DT
8691	3858	26	associate	associate	JJ
8691	3858	27	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3858	28	.	.	.
8691	3859	1	Popular	popular	JJ
8691	3859	2	election	election	NN
8691	3859	3	and	and	CC
8691	3859	4	life	life	NN
8691	3859	5	tenure	tenure	NN
8691	3859	6	can	can	MD
8691	3859	7	not	not	RB
8691	3859	8	well	well	RB
8691	3859	9	go	go	VB
8691	3859	10	together	together	RB
8691	3859	11	.	.	.
8691	3860	1	The	the	DT
8691	3860	2	chance	chance	NN
8691	3860	3	of	of	IN
8691	3860	4	an	an	DT
8691	3860	5	irremediable	irremediable	JJ
8691	3860	6	mistake	mistake	NN
8691	3860	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3860	8	too	too	RB
8691	3860	9	great	great	JJ
8691	3860	10	.	.	.
8691	3861	1	Judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3861	2	nominations	nomination	NNS
8691	3861	3	are	be	VBP
8691	3861	4	often	often	RB
8691	3861	5	the	the	DT
8691	3861	6	mere	mere	JJ
8691	3861	7	incident	incident	NN
8691	3861	8	of	of	IN
8691	3861	9	the	the	DT
8691	3861	10	prevalence	prevalence	NN
8691	3861	11	in	in	IN
8691	3861	12	a	a	DT
8691	3861	13	party	party	NN
8691	3861	14	convention	convention	NN
8691	3861	15	of	of	IN
8691	3861	16	one	one	CD
8691	3861	17	faction	faction	NN
8691	3861	18	of	of	IN
8691	3861	19	the	the	DT
8691	3861	20	delegates	delegate	NNS
8691	3861	21	,	,	,
8691	3861	22	whose	whose	WP$
8691	3861	23	main	main	JJ
8691	3861	24	object	object	NN
8691	3861	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	3861	26	to	to	TO
8691	3861	27	control	control	VB
8691	3861	28	the	the	DT
8691	3861	29	nominations	nomination	NNS
8691	3861	30	for	for	IN
8691	3861	31	other	other	JJ
8691	3861	32	positions	position	NNS
8691	3861	33	.	.	.
8691	3862	1	American	american	JJ
8691	3862	2	experience	experience	NN
8691	3862	3	seems	seem	VBZ
8691	3862	4	to	to	TO
8691	3862	5	indicate	indicate	VB
8691	3862	6	life	life	NN
8691	3862	7	tenure	tenure	NN
8691	3862	8	and	and	CC
8691	3862	9	executive	executive	JJ
8691	3862	10	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3862	11	,	,	,
8691	3862	12	with	with	IN
8691	3862	13	some	some	DT
8691	3862	14	suitable	suitable	JJ
8691	3862	15	provision	provision	NN
8691	3862	16	for	for	IN
8691	3862	17	securing	secure	VBG
8691	3862	18	retirement	retirement	NN
8691	3862	19	at	at	IN
8691	3862	20	a	a	DT
8691	3862	21	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3862	22	age	age	NN
8691	3862	23	,	,	,
8691	3862	24	as	as	RB
8691	3862	25	likely	likely	JJ
8691	3862	26	to	to	TO
8691	3862	27	secure	secure	VB
8691	3862	28	the	the	DT
8691	3862	29	best	good	JJS
8691	3862	30	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3862	31	of	of	IN
8691	3862	32	the	the	DT
8691	3862	33	higher	high	JJR
8691	3862	34	courts	court	NNS
8691	3862	35	.	.	.
8691	3863	1	This	this	DT
8691	3863	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	3863	3	worked	work	VBN
8691	3863	4	well	well	RB
8691	3863	5	for	for	IN
8691	3863	6	the	the	DT
8691	3863	7	United	United	NNP
8691	3863	8	States	States	NNP
8691	3863	9	,	,	,
8691	3863	10	and	and	CC
8691	3863	11	no	no	DT
8691	3863	12	State	state	NN
8691	3863	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	3863	14	have	have	VBP
8691	3863	15	stood	stand	VBD
8691	3863	16	higher	high	JJR
8691	3863	17	in	in	IN
8691	3863	18	the	the	DT
8691	3863	19	general	general	JJ
8691	3863	20	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3863	21	of	of	IN
8691	3863	22	the	the	DT
8691	3863	23	bar	bar	NN
8691	3863	24	than	than	IN
8691	3863	25	those	those	DT
8691	3863	26	thus	thus	RB
8691	3863	27	organized	organize	VBN
8691	3863	28	.	.	.
8691	3864	1	For	for	IN
8691	3864	2	the	the	DT
8691	3864	3	lower	low	JJR
8691	3864	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	3864	5	there	there	EX
8691	3864	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	3864	7	less	less	JJR
8691	3864	8	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	3864	9	and	and	CC
8691	3864	10	less	less	JJR
8691	3864	11	chance	chance	NN
8691	3864	12	for	for	IN
8691	3864	13	getting	get	VBG
8691	3864	14	men	man	NNS
8691	3864	15	of	of	IN
8691	3864	16	the	the	DT
8691	3864	17	first	first	JJ
8691	3864	18	rank	rank	NN
8691	3864	19	in	in	IN
8691	3864	20	attainments	attainment	NNS
8691	3864	21	and	and	CC
8691	3864	22	character	character	NN
8691	3864	23	.	.	.
8691	3865	1	Shorter	short	JJR
8691	3865	2	terms	term	NNS
8691	3865	3	of	of	IN
8691	3865	4	office	office	NN
8691	3865	5	can	can	MD
8691	3865	6	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	3865	7	reasonably	reasonably	RB
8691	3865	8	be	be	VB
8691	3865	9	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
8691	3865	10	,	,	,
8691	3865	11	and	and	CC
8691	3865	12	the	the	DT
8691	3865	13	objections	objection	NNS
8691	3865	14	to	to	IN
8691	3865	15	popular	popular	JJ
8691	3865	16	election	election	NN
8691	3865	17	are	be	VBP
8691	3865	18	correspondingly	correspondingly	RB
8691	3865	19	less	less	JJR
8691	3865	20	.	.	.
8691	3866	1	Even	even	RB
8691	3866	2	as	as	IN
8691	3866	3	to	to	IN
8691	3866	4	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3866	5	,	,	,
8691	3866	6	however	however	RB
8691	3866	7	,	,	,
8691	3866	8	the	the	DT
8691	3866	9	plan	plan	NN
8691	3866	10	of	of	IN
8691	3866	11	executive	executive	JJ
8691	3866	12	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3866	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	3866	14	safer	safe	JJR
8691	3866	15	than	than	IN
8691	3866	16	that	that	DT
8691	3866	17	of	of	IN
8691	3866	18	party	party	NN
8691	3866	19	nomination	nomination	NN
8691	3866	20	.	.	.
8691	3867	1	A	a	DT
8691	3867	2	man	man	NN
8691	3867	3	acts	act	VBZ
8691	3867	4	carefully	carefully	RB
8691	3867	5	when	when	WRB
8691	3867	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3867	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3867	8	the	the	DT
8691	3867	9	only	only	JJ
8691	3867	10	one	one	CD
8691	3867	11	whom	whom	WP
8691	3867	12	the	the	DT
8691	3867	13	public	public	NN
8691	3867	14	can	can	MD
8691	3867	15	hold	hold	VB
8691	3867	16	responsible	responsible	JJ
8691	3867	17	for	for	IN
8691	3867	18	what	what	WP
8691	3867	19	is	be	VBZ
8691	3867	20	done	do	VBN
8691	3867	21	.	.	.
8691	3868	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3868	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3868	3	customary	customary	JJ
8691	3868	4	to	to	TO
8691	3868	5	provide	provide	VB
8691	3868	6	that	that	IN
8691	3868	7	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
8691	3868	8	in	in	IN
8691	3868	9	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3868	10	offices	office	NNS
8691	3868	11	can	can	MD
8691	3868	12	be	be	VB
8691	3868	13	temporarily	temporarily	RB
8691	3868	14	filled	fill	VBN
8691	3868	15	by	by	IN
8691	3868	16	the	the	DT
8691	3868	17	Executive	Executive	NNP
8691	3868	18	until	until	IN
8691	3868	19	there	there	EX
8691	3868	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	3868	21	an	an	DT
8691	3868	22	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	3868	23	for	for	IN
8691	3868	24	a	a	DT
8691	3868	25	new	new	JJ
8691	3868	26	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	3868	27	or	or	CC
8691	3868	28	election	election	NN
8691	3868	29	by	by	IN
8691	3868	30	the	the	DT
8691	3868	31	proper	proper	JJ
8691	3868	32	authority	authority	NN
8691	3868	33	.	.	.
8691	3869	1	The	the	DT
8691	3869	2	place	place	NN
8691	3869	3	of	of	IN
8691	3869	4	a	a	DT
8691	3869	5	judge	judge	NN
8691	3869	6	who	who	WP
8691	3869	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3869	8	absent	absent	JJ
8691	3869	9	or	or	CC
8691	3869	10	disqualified	disqualify	VBN
8691	3869	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	3869	12	in	in	IN
8691	3869	13	some	some	DT
8691	3869	14	States	state	NNS
8691	3869	15	,	,	,
8691	3869	16	by	by	IN
8691	3869	17	authority	authority	NN
8691	3869	18	of	of	IN
8691	3869	19	a	a	DT
8691	3869	20	statute	statute	NN
8691	3869	21	or	or	CC
8691	3869	22	agreement	agreement	NN
8691	3869	23	of	of	IN
8691	3869	24	the	the	DT
8691	3869	25	parties	party	NNS
8691	3869	26	,	,	,
8691	3869	27	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	3869	28	taken	take	VBN
8691	3869	29	by	by	IN
8691	3869	30	a	a	DT
8691	3869	31	member	member	NN
8691	3869	32	of	of	IN
8691	3869	33	the	the	DT
8691	3869	34	bar	bar	NN
8691	3869	35	called	call	VBN
8691	3869	36	in	in	RP
8691	3869	37	to	to	TO
8691	3869	38	try	try	VB
8691	3869	39	a	a	DT
8691	3869	40	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3869	41	cause	cause	NN
8691	3869	42	or	or	CC
8691	3869	43	hold	hold	VB
8691	3869	44	a	a	DT
8691	3869	45	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3869	46	term	term	NN
8691	3869	47	of	of	IN
8691	3869	48	court	court	NN
8691	3869	49	.	.	.
8691	3870	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3870	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3870	3	:	:	:
8691	3870	4	See	see	VB
8691	3870	5	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
8691	3870	6	Code	Code	NNP
8691	3870	7	of	of	IN
8691	3870	8	1896	1896	CD
8691	3870	9	,	,	,
8691	3870	10	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	3870	11	.	.	.
8691	3871	1	3838	3838	CD
8691	3871	2	;	;	:
8691	3871	3	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	3871	4	's	's	POS
8691	3871	5	note	note	NN
8691	3871	6	to	to	IN
8691	3871	7	Kellogg	Kellogg	NNP
8691	3871	8	_	_	NNP
8691	3871	9	v.	v.	IN
8691	3871	10	_	_	NNP
8691	3871	11	Brown	Brown	NNP
8691	3871	12	,	,	,
8691	3871	13	32	32	CD
8691	3871	14	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3871	15	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3871	16	,	,	,
8691	3871	17	112	112	CD
8691	3871	18	.	.	.
8691	3871	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3872	1	So	so	RB
8691	3872	2	the	the	DT
8691	3872	3	English	english	JJ
8691	3872	4	assize	assize	NN
8691	3872	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3872	6	are	be	VBP
8691	3872	7	constituted	constitute	VBN
8691	3872	8	by	by	IN
8691	3872	9	special	special	JJ
8691	3872	10	commissions	commission	NNS
8691	3872	11	for	for	IN
8691	3872	12	each	each	DT
8691	3872	13	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	3872	14	,	,	,
8691	3872	15	which	which	WDT
8691	3872	16	include	include	VBP
8691	3872	17	also	also	RB
8691	3872	18	the	the	DT
8691	3872	19	barristers	barrister	NNS
8691	3872	20	on	on	IN
8691	3872	21	the	the	DT
8691	3872	22	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	3872	23	who	who	WP
8691	3872	24	are	be	VBP
8691	3872	25	sergeants	sergeant	NNS
8691	3872	26	at	at	IN
8691	3872	27	law	law	NN
8691	3872	28	,	,	,
8691	3872	29	king	king	NNP
8691	3872	30	's	's	POS
8691	3872	31	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	3872	32	,	,	,
8691	3872	33	or	or	CC
8691	3872	34	holders	holder	NNS
8691	3872	35	of	of	IN
8691	3872	36	patents	patent	NNS
8691	3872	37	of	of	IN
8691	3872	38	precedence	precedence	NN
8691	3872	39	.	.	.
8691	3873	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3873	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3873	3	hard	hard	JJ
8691	3873	4	to	to	TO
8691	3873	5	dislodge	dislodge	VB
8691	3873	6	a	a	DT
8691	3873	7	judge	judge	NN
8691	3873	8	for	for	IN
8691	3873	9	misconduct	misconduct	NN
8691	3873	10	or	or	CC
8691	3873	11	inefficiency	inefficiency	NN
8691	3873	12	.	.	.
8691	3874	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3874	2	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	3874	3	give	give	VBP
8691	3874	4	remedies	remedy	NNS
8691	3874	5	by	by	IN
8691	3874	6	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	3874	7	or	or	CC
8691	3874	8	by	by	IN
8691	3874	9	removal	removal	NN
8691	3874	10	by	by	IN
8691	3874	11	the	the	DT
8691	3874	12	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3874	13	on	on	IN
8691	3874	14	address	address	NN
8691	3874	15	of	of	IN
8691	3874	16	the	the	DT
8691	3874	17	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3874	18	,	,	,
8691	3874	19	but	but	CC
8691	3874	20	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
8691	3874	21	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3874	22	are	be	VBP
8691	3874	23	generally	generally	RB
8691	3874	24	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	3874	25	to	to	TO
8691	3874	26	obtain	obtain	VB
8691	3874	27	the	the	DT
8691	3874	28	benefit	benefit	NN
8691	3874	29	of	of	IN
8691	3874	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3874	31	,	,	,
8691	3874	32	and	and	CC
8691	3874	33	the	the	DT
8691	3874	34	decision	decision	NN
8691	3874	35	is	be	VBZ
8691	3874	36	often	often	RB
8691	3874	37	in	in	IN
8691	3874	38	favor	favor	NN
8691	3874	39	of	of	IN
8691	3874	40	the	the	DT
8691	3874	41	judge	judge	NN
8691	3874	42	.	.	.
8691	3875	1	Party	party	NN
8691	3875	2	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	3875	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	3875	4	apt	apt	JJ
8691	3875	5	to	to	TO
8691	3875	6	have	have	VB
8691	3875	7	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3875	8	influence	influence	NN
8691	3875	9	in	in	IN
8691	3875	10	such	such	JJ
8691	3875	11	matters	matter	NNS
8691	3875	12	.	.	.
8691	3876	1	Whether	whether	IN
8691	3876	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3876	3	does	do	VBZ
8691	3876	4	or	or	CC
8691	3876	5	does	do	VBZ
8691	3876	6	not	not	RB
8691	3876	7	,	,	,
8691	3876	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3876	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	3876	10	an	an	DT
8691	3876	11	unpleasant	unpleasant	JJ
8691	3876	12	task	task	NN
8691	3876	13	to	to	TO
8691	3876	14	assume	assume	VB
8691	3876	15	the	the	DT
8691	3876	16	initiative	initiative	NN
8691	3876	17	.	.	.
8691	3877	1	Those	those	DT
8691	3877	2	who	who	WP
8691	3877	3	best	good	JJS
8691	3877	4	know	know	VBP
8691	3877	5	the	the	DT
8691	3877	6	facts	fact	NNS
8691	3877	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3877	8	the	the	DT
8691	3877	9	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3877	10	,	,	,
8691	3877	11	and	and	CC
8691	3877	12	if	if	IN
8691	3877	13	some	some	DT
8691	3877	14	of	of	IN
8691	3877	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3877	16	are	be	VBP
8691	3877	17	the	the	DT
8691	3877	18	ones	one	NNS
8691	3877	19	to	to	TO
8691	3877	20	move	move	VB
8691	3877	21	,	,	,
8691	3877	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3877	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	3877	24	at	at	IN
8691	3877	25	the	the	DT
8691	3877	26	risk	risk	NN
8691	3877	27	,	,	,
8691	3877	28	should	should	MD
8691	3877	29	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3877	30	fail	fail	VB
8691	3877	31	,	,	,
8691	3877	32	of	of	IN
8691	3877	33	having	have	VBG
8691	3877	34	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	3877	35	to	to	TO
8691	3877	36	conduct	conduct	VB
8691	3877	37	causes	cause	NNS
8691	3877	38	in	in	IN
8691	3877	39	a	a	DT
8691	3877	40	court	court	NN
8691	3877	41	presided	preside	VBD
8691	3877	42	over	over	RP
8691	3877	43	by	by	IN
8691	3877	44	one	one	CD
8691	3877	45	who	who	WP
8691	3877	46	is	be	VBZ
8691	3877	47	not	not	RB
8691	3877	48	likely	likely	JJ
8691	3877	49	to	to	TO
8691	3877	50	regard	regard	VB
8691	3877	51	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3877	52	with	with	IN
8691	3877	53	a	a	DT
8691	3877	54	friendly	friendly	JJ
8691	3877	55	eye	eye	NN
8691	3877	56	.	.	.
8691	3878	1	The	the	DT
8691	3878	2	number	number	NN
8691	3878	3	of	of	IN
8691	3878	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3878	5	impeachments	impeachment	NNS
8691	3878	6	in	in	IN
8691	3878	7	the	the	DT
8691	3878	8	history	history	NN
8691	3878	9	of	of	IN
8691	3878	10	the	the	DT
8691	3878	11	country	country	NN
8691	3878	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	3878	13	been	be	VBN
8691	3878	14	comparatively	comparatively	RB
8691	3878	15	small	small	JJ
8691	3878	16	,	,	,
8691	3878	17	and	and	CC
8691	3878	18	few	few	JJ
8691	3878	19	of	of	IN
8691	3878	20	these	these	DT
8691	3878	21	have	have	VBP
8691	3878	22	resulted	result	VBN
8691	3878	23	in	in	IN
8691	3878	24	convictions	conviction	NNS
8691	3878	25	.	.	.
8691	3879	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3879	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3879	3	:	:	:
8691	3879	4	See	see	VB
8691	3879	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	3879	6	.	.	.
8691	3880	1	III	iii	CD
8691	3880	2	.	.	.
8691	3880	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3881	1	Of	of	IN
8691	3881	2	the	the	DT
8691	3881	3	cases	case	NNS
8691	3881	4	which	which	WDT
8691	3881	5	were	be	VBD
8691	3881	6	successful	successful	JJ
8691	3881	7	,	,	,
8691	3881	8	the	the	DT
8691	3881	9	most	most	RBS
8691	3881	10	noteworthy	noteworthy	JJ
8691	3881	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	3881	12	that	that	DT
8691	3881	13	of	of	IN
8691	3881	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3881	15	George	George	NNP
8691	3881	16	G.	G.	NNP
8691	3881	17	Barnard	Barnard	NNP
8691	3881	18	of	of	IN
8691	3881	19	the	the	DT
8691	3881	20	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3881	21	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3881	22	of	of	IN
8691	3881	23	New	New	NNP
8691	3881	24	York	York	NNP
8691	3881	25	,	,	,
8691	3881	26	who	who	WP
8691	3881	27	was	be	VBD
8691	3881	28	convicted	convict	VBN
8691	3881	29	of	of	IN
8691	3881	30	having	have	VBG
8691	3881	31	abused	abuse	VBN
8691	3881	32	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3881	33	right	right	NN
8691	3881	34	to	to	TO
8691	3881	35	issue	issue	VB
8691	3881	36	_	_	NNP
8691	3881	37	ex	ex	NNP
8691	3881	38	parte	parte	NNP
8691	3881	39	_	_	NNP
8691	3881	40	orders	order	NNS
8691	3881	41	and	and	CC
8691	3881	42	of	of	IN
8691	3881	43	other	other	JJ
8691	3881	44	measures	measure	NNS
8691	3881	45	of	of	IN
8691	3881	46	improper	improper	JJ
8691	3881	47	favoritism	favoritism	NN
8691	3881	48	.	.	.
8691	3882	1	The	the	DT
8691	3882	2	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	3882	3	Association	Association	NNP
8691	3882	4	of	of	IN
8691	3882	5	the	the	DT
8691	3882	6	City	City	NNP
8691	3882	7	of	of	IN
8691	3882	8	New	New	NNP
8691	3882	9	York	York	NNP
8691	3882	10	brought	bring	VBD
8691	3882	11	the	the	DT
8691	3882	12	charges	charge	NNS
8691	3882	13	,	,	,
8691	3882	14	and	and	CC
8691	3882	15	were	be	VBD
8691	3882	16	influential	influential	JJ
8691	3882	17	in	in	IN
8691	3882	18	carrying	carry	VBG
8691	3882	19	the	the	DT
8691	3882	20	whole	whole	JJ
8691	3882	21	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	3882	22	through	through	RP
8691	3882	23	to	to	IN
8691	3882	24	a	a	DT
8691	3882	25	favorable	favorable	JJ
8691	3882	26	result	result	NN
8691	3882	27	.	.	.
8691	3883	1	In	in	IN
8691	3883	2	another	another	DT
8691	3883	3	instance	instance	NN
8691	3883	4	,	,	,
8691	3883	5	occurring	occur	VBG
8691	3883	6	in	in	IN
8691	3883	7	1854	1854	CD
8691	3883	8	in	in	IN
8691	3883	9	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3883	10	,	,	,
8691	3883	11	the	the	DT
8691	3883	12	right	right	NN
8691	3883	13	of	of	IN
8691	3883	14	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	3883	15	was	be	VBD
8691	3883	16	stretched	stretch	VBN
8691	3883	17	to	to	IN
8691	3883	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3883	19	limit	limit	NN
8691	3883	20	by	by	IN
8691	3883	21	removing	remove	VBG
8691	3883	22	a	a	DT
8691	3883	23	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3883	24	of	of	IN
8691	3883	25	Probate	Probate	NNP
8691	3883	26	,	,	,
8691	3883	27	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	3883	28	G.	G.	NNP
8691	3883	29	Loring	Loring	NNP
8691	3883	30	,	,	,
8691	3883	31	the	the	DT
8691	3883	32	only	only	JJ
8691	3883	33	real	real	JJ
8691	3883	34	ground	ground	NN
8691	3883	35	being	be	VBG
8691	3883	36	that	that	IN
8691	3883	37	as	as	IN
8691	3883	38	a	a	DT
8691	3883	39	United	United	NNP
8691	3883	40	States	States	NNP
8691	3883	41	Commissioner	Commissioner	NNP
8691	3883	42	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3883	43	had	have	VBD
8691	3883	44	ordered	order	VBN
8691	3883	45	the	the	DT
8691	3883	46	return	return	NN
8691	3883	47	of	of	IN
8691	3883	48	a	a	DT
8691	3883	49	fugitive	fugitive	JJ
8691	3883	50	slave	slave	NN
8691	3883	51	under	under	IN
8691	3883	52	the	the	DT
8691	3883	53	laws	law	NNS
8691	3883	54	of	of	IN
8691	3883	55	the	the	DT
8691	3883	56	United	United	NNP
8691	3883	57	States	States	NNP
8691	3883	58	--	--	:
8691	3883	59	laws	law	NNS
8691	3883	60	the	the	DT
8691	3883	61	constitutionality	constitutionality	NN
8691	3883	62	of	of	IN
8691	3883	63	which	which	WDT
8691	3883	64	the	the	DT
8691	3883	65	highest	high	JJS
8691	3883	66	court	court	NN
8691	3883	67	of	of	IN
8691	3883	68	the	the	DT
8691	3883	69	State	State	NNP
8691	3883	70	had	have	VBD
8691	3883	71	recently	recently	RB
8691	3883	72	declared	declare	VBN
8691	3883	73	to	to	TO
8691	3883	74	be	be	VB
8691	3883	75	fully	fully	RB
8691	3883	76	settled	settle	VBN
8691	3883	77	.	.	.
8691	3884	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3884	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3884	3	:	:	:
8691	3884	4	Sims	Sims	NNP
8691	3884	5	'	'	POS
8691	3884	6	Case	Case	NNP
8691	3884	7	,	,	,
8691	3884	8	7	7	CD
8691	3884	9	Cushing	Cushing	NNP
8691	3884	10	's	's	POS
8691	3884	11	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3884	12	,	,	,
8691	3884	13	285	285	CD
8691	3884	14	.	.	.
8691	3884	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3885	1	Judges	judge	NNS
8691	3885	2	of	of	IN
8691	3885	3	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3885	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	3885	5	are	be	VBP
8691	3885	6	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3885	7	removable	removable	JJ
8691	3885	8	by	by	IN
8691	3885	9	the	the	DT
8691	3885	10	higher	high	JJR
8691	3885	11	ones	one	NNS
8691	3885	12	for	for	IN
8691	3885	13	cause	cause	NN
8691	3885	14	,	,	,
8691	3885	15	on	on	IN
8691	3885	16	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	3885	17	of	of	IN
8691	3885	18	a	a	DT
8691	3885	19	public	public	JJ
8691	3885	20	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
8691	3885	21	.	.	.
8691	3886	1	In	in	IN
8691	3886	2	such	such	JJ
8691	3886	3	case	case	NN
8691	3886	4	,	,	,
8691	3886	5	the	the	DT
8691	3886	6	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	3886	7	being	be	VBG
8691	3886	8	strictly	strictly	RB
8691	3886	9	a	a	DT
8691	3886	10	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3886	11	one	one	NN
8691	3886	12	,	,	,
8691	3886	13	there	there	EX
8691	3886	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	3886	15	more	more	JJR
8691	3886	16	assurance	assurance	NN
8691	3886	17	of	of	IN
8691	3886	18	success	success	NN
8691	3886	19	if	if	IN
8691	3886	20	the	the	DT
8691	3886	21	charges	charge	NNS
8691	3886	22	are	be	VBP
8691	3886	23	well	well	RB
8691	3886	24	founded	found	VBN
8691	3886	25	.	.	.
8691	3887	1	Here	here	RB
8691	3887	2	also	also	RB
8691	3887	3	,	,	,
8691	3887	4	however	however	RB
8691	3887	5	,	,	,
8691	3887	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3887	7	will	will	MD
8691	3887	8	be	be	VB
8691	3887	9	known	know	VBN
8691	3887	10	from	from	IN
8691	3887	11	whom	whom	WP
8691	3887	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3887	13	come	come	VBP
8691	3887	14	,	,	,
8691	3887	15	and	and	CC
8691	3887	16	the	the	DT
8691	3887	17	hearings	hearing	NNS
8691	3887	18	are	be	VBP
8691	3887	19	likely	likely	JJ
8691	3887	20	to	to	TO
8691	3887	21	be	be	VB
8691	3887	22	so	so	RB
8691	3887	23	protracted	protracted	JJ
8691	3887	24	and	and	CC
8691	3887	25	expensive	expensive	JJ
8691	3887	26	to	to	IN
8691	3887	27	the	the	DT
8691	3887	28	State	state	NN
8691	3887	29	that	that	WDT
8691	3887	30	only	only	RB
8691	3887	31	a	a	DT
8691	3887	32	flagrant	flagrant	JJ
8691	3887	33	case	case	NN
8691	3887	34	will	will	MD
8691	3887	35	usually	usually	RB
8691	3887	36	be	be	VB
8691	3887	37	taken	take	VBN
8691	3887	38	up	up	RP
8691	3887	39	.	.	.
8691	3888	1	The	the	DT
8691	3888	2	hearings	hearing	NNS
8691	3888	3	on	on	IN
8691	3888	4	such	such	PDT
8691	3888	5	a	a	DT
8691	3888	6	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	3888	7	,	,	,
8691	3888	8	brought	bring	VBN
8691	3888	9	in	in	IN
8691	3888	10	New	New	NNP
8691	3888	11	York	York	NNP
8691	3888	12	in	in	IN
8691	3888	13	1903	1903	CD
8691	3888	14	,	,	,
8691	3888	15	extended	extend	VBN
8691	3888	16	over	over	IN
8691	3888	17	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	3888	18	-	-	HYPH
8691	3888	19	six	six	CD
8691	3888	20	days	day	NNS
8691	3888	21	;	;	:
8691	3888	22	the	the	DT
8691	3888	23	stenographic	stenographic	JJ
8691	3888	24	minutes	minute	NNS
8691	3888	25	of	of	IN
8691	3888	26	the	the	DT
8691	3888	27	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	3888	28	covered	cover	VBN
8691	3888	29	over	over	IN
8691	3888	30	3,300	3,300	CD
8691	3888	31	pages	page	NNS
8691	3888	32	;	;	:
8691	3888	33	there	there	EX
8691	3888	34	were	be	VBD
8691	3888	35	over	over	IN
8691	3888	36	four	four	CD
8691	3888	37	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3888	38	exhibits	exhibit	NNS
8691	3888	39	introduced	introduce	VBN
8691	3888	40	;	;	:
8691	3888	41	and	and	CC
8691	3888	42	the	the	DT
8691	3888	43	items	item	NNS
8691	3888	44	of	of	IN
8691	3888	45	cost	cost	NN
8691	3888	46	presented	present	VBN
8691	3888	47	for	for	IN
8691	3888	48	taxation	taxation	NN
8691	3888	49	amounted	amount	VBD
8691	3888	50	to	to	IN
8691	3888	51	over	over	IN
8691	3888	52	$	$	$
8691	3888	53	20,000	20,000	CD
8691	3888	54	.	.	.
8691	3889	1	Removals	removal	NNS
8691	3889	2	by	by	IN
8691	3889	3	the	the	DT
8691	3889	4	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	3889	5	on	on	IN
8691	3889	6	the	the	DT
8691	3889	7	address	address	NN
8691	3889	8	of	of	IN
8691	3889	9	the	the	DT
8691	3889	10	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3889	11	have	have	VBP
8691	3889	12	been	be	VBN
8691	3889	13	more	more	RBR
8691	3889	14	frequent	frequent	JJ
8691	3889	15	,	,	,
8691	3889	16	and	and	CC
8691	3889	17	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	3889	18	have	have	VBP
8691	3889	19	been	be	VBN
8691	3889	20	dictated	dictate	VBN
8691	3889	21	largely	largely	RB
8691	3889	22	by	by	IN
8691	3889	23	party	party	NN
8691	3889	24	managers	manager	NNS
8691	3889	25	who	who	WP
8691	3889	26	desired	desire	VBD
8691	3889	27	to	to	TO
8691	3889	28	make	make	VB
8691	3889	29	places	place	NNS
8691	3889	30	for	for	IN
8691	3889	31	those	those	DT
8691	3889	32	of	of	IN
8691	3889	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3889	34	own	own	JJ
8691	3889	35	political	political	JJ
8691	3889	36	faith	faith	NN
8691	3889	37	.	.	.
8691	3890	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3890	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3890	3	:	:	:
8691	3890	4	Schouler	Schouler	NNP
8691	3890	5	,	,	,
8691	3890	6	"	"	``
8691	3890	7	Constitutional	Constitutional	NNP
8691	3890	8	Studies	Studies	NNPS
8691	3890	9	,	,	,
8691	3890	10	"	"	''
8691	3890	11	288	288	CD
8691	3890	12	,	,	,
8691	3890	13	note	note	NN
8691	3890	14	.	.	.
8691	3890	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3891	1	In	in	IN
8691	3891	2	one	one	CD
8691	3891	3	instance	instance	NN
8691	3891	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3891	5	was	be	VBD
8691	3891	6	attempted	attempt	VBN
8691	3891	7	,	,	,
8691	3891	8	but	but	CC
8691	3891	9	unsuccessfully	unsuccessfully	RB
8691	3891	10	,	,	,
8691	3891	11	in	in	IN
8691	3891	12	Kentucky	Kentucky	NNP
8691	3891	13	as	as	IN
8691	3891	14	a	a	DT
8691	3891	15	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	3891	16	for	for	IN
8691	3891	17	giving	give	VBG
8691	3891	18	a	a	DT
8691	3891	19	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3891	20	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3891	21	that	that	IN
8691	3891	22	a	a	DT
8691	3891	23	stay	stay	NN
8691	3891	24	-	-	HYPH
8691	3891	25	law	law	NN
8691	3891	26	recently	recently	RB
8691	3891	27	passed	pass	VBN
8691	3891	28	by	by	IN
8691	3891	29	the	the	DT
8691	3891	30	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3891	31	was	be	VBD
8691	3891	32	unconstitutional	unconstitutional	JJ
8691	3891	33	.	.	.
8691	3892	1	A	a	DT
8691	3892	2	two	two	CD
8691	3892	3	-	-	HYPH
8691	3892	4	thirds	third	NNS
8691	3892	5	vote	vote	NN
8691	3892	6	of	of	IN
8691	3892	7	each	each	DT
8691	3892	8	house	house	NN
8691	3892	9	was	be	VBD
8691	3892	10	required	require	VBN
8691	3892	11	,	,	,
8691	3892	12	and	and	CC
8691	3892	13	as	as	IN
8691	3892	14	in	in	IN
8691	3892	15	the	the	DT
8691	3892	16	lower	low	JJR
8691	3892	17	house	house	NN
8691	3892	18	,	,	,
8691	3892	19	though	though	IN
8691	3892	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3892	21	voted	vote	VBD
8691	3892	22	for	for	IN
8691	3892	23	an	an	DT
8691	3892	24	address	address	NN
8691	3892	25	by	by	IN
8691	3892	26	a	a	DT
8691	3892	27	large	large	JJ
8691	3892	28	majority	majority	NN
8691	3892	29	,	,	,
8691	3892	30	this	this	DT
8691	3892	31	could	could	MD
8691	3892	32	not	not	RB
8691	3892	33	be	be	VB
8691	3892	34	obtained	obtain	VBN
8691	3892	35	,	,	,
8691	3892	36	the	the	DT
8691	3892	37	proceeding	proceeding	NN
8691	3892	38	was	be	VBD
8691	3892	39	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	3892	40	to	to	TO
8691	3892	41	drop	drop	VB
8691	3892	42	.	.	.
8691	3893	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3893	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3893	3	:	:	:
8691	3893	4	Niles	Niles	NNP
8691	3893	5	'	'	POS
8691	3893	6	Register	register	NN
8691	3893	7	,	,	,
8691	3893	8	XXII	XXII	NNP
8691	3893	9	,	,	,
8691	3893	10	266	266	CD
8691	3893	11	.	.	.
8691	3894	1	See	see	VB
8691	3894	2	_	_	NNP
8691	3894	3	ante	ante	NN
8691	3894	4	_	_	NNP
8691	3894	5	p.	p.	NN
8691	3895	1	114	114	CD
8691	3895	2	.	.	.
8691	3895	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3896	1	In	in	IN
8691	3896	2	all	all	DT
8691	3896	3	there	there	EX
8691	3896	4	have	have	VBP
8691	3896	5	been	be	VBN
8691	3896	6	in	in	IN
8691	3896	7	the	the	DT
8691	3896	8	whole	whole	JJ
8691	3896	9	country	country	NN
8691	3896	10	since	since	IN
8691	3896	11	1776	1776	CD
8691	3896	12	not	not	RB
8691	3896	13	over	over	IN
8691	3896	14	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	3896	15	removals	removal	NNS
8691	3896	16	,	,	,
8691	3896	17	whether	whether	IN
8691	3896	18	on	on	IN
8691	3896	19	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	3896	20	and	and	CC
8691	3896	21	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	3896	22	or	or	CC
8691	3896	23	on	on	IN
8691	3896	24	address	address	NN
8691	3896	25	of	of	IN
8691	3896	26	the	the	DT
8691	3896	27	two	two	CD
8691	3896	28	houses	house	NNS
8691	3896	29	,	,	,
8691	3896	30	of	of	IN
8691	3896	31	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3896	32	of	of	IN
8691	3896	33	a	a	DT
8691	3896	34	higher	high	JJR
8691	3896	35	grade	grade	NN
8691	3896	36	than	than	IN
8691	3896	37	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3896	38	of	of	IN
8691	3896	39	the	the	DT
8691	3896	40	peace	peace	NN
8691	3896	41	.	.	.
8691	3897	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3897	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3897	3	:	:	:
8691	3897	4	See	see	VB
8691	3897	5	Foster	Foster	NNP
8691	3897	6	,	,	,
8691	3897	7	"	"	''
8691	3897	8	Commentaries	commentary	NNS
8691	3897	9	on	on	IN
8691	3897	10	the	the	DT
8691	3897	11	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	3897	12	of	of	IN
8691	3897	13	the	the	DT
8691	3897	14	United	United	NNP
8691	3897	15	States	States	NNP
8691	3897	16	,	,	,
8691	3897	17	"	"	``
8691	3897	18	Appendix	Appendix	NNP
8691	3897	19	,	,	,
8691	3897	20	633	633	CD
8691	3897	21	.	.	.
8691	3897	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3898	1	Wholesale	wholesale	JJ
8691	3898	2	removals	removal	NNS
8691	3898	3	have	have	VBP
8691	3898	4	also	also	RB
8691	3898	5	,	,	,
8691	3898	6	in	in	IN
8691	3898	7	rare	rare	JJ
8691	3898	8	instances	instance	NNS
8691	3898	9	,	,	,
8691	3898	10	been	be	VBN
8691	3898	11	effected	effect	VBN
8691	3898	12	for	for	IN
8691	3898	13	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3898	14	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	3898	15	by	by	IN
8691	3898	16	abolishing	abolish	VBG
8691	3898	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	3898	18	,	,	,
8691	3898	19	the	the	DT
8691	3898	20	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3898	21	of	of	IN
8691	3898	22	which	which	WDT
8691	3898	23	held	hold	VBN
8691	3898	24	during	during	IN
8691	3898	25	good	good	JJ
8691	3898	26	behavior	behavior	NN
8691	3898	27	.	.	.
8691	3899	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3899	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3899	3	:	:	:
8691	3899	4	See	see	VB
8691	3899	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	3899	6	.	.	.
8691	3900	1	VII	VII	NNP
8691	3900	2	.	.	.
8691	3900	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3901	1	Maryland	Maryland	NNP
8691	3901	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3901	3	the	the	DT
8691	3901	4	first	first	JJ
8691	3901	5	to	to	TO
8691	3901	6	do	do	VB
8691	3901	7	this	this	DT
8691	3901	8	,	,	,
8691	3901	9	abolishing	abolish	VBG
8691	3901	10	a	a	DT
8691	3901	11	court	court	NN
8691	3901	12	and	and	CC
8691	3901	13	re	re	NN
8691	3901	14	-	-	VBG
8691	3901	15	establishing	establish	VBG
8691	3901	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3901	17	at	at	IN
8691	3901	18	the	the	DT
8691	3901	19	same	same	JJ
8691	3901	20	session	session	NN
8691	3901	21	,	,	,
8691	3901	22	almost	almost	RB
8691	3901	23	in	in	IN
8691	3901	24	the	the	DT
8691	3901	25	words	word	NNS
8691	3901	26	of	of	IN
8691	3901	27	the	the	DT
8691	3901	28	former	former	JJ
8691	3901	29	law	law	NN
8691	3901	30	.	.	.
8691	3902	1	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3902	2	followed	follow	VBD
8691	3902	3	in	in	IN
8691	3902	4	1802	1802	CD
8691	3902	5	by	by	IN
8691	3902	6	repealing	repeal	VBG
8691	3902	7	the	the	DT
8691	3902	8	statute	statute	NN
8691	3902	9	of	of	IN
8691	3902	10	the	the	DT
8691	3902	11	year	year	NN
8691	3902	12	before	before	IN
8691	3902	13	by	by	IN
8691	3902	14	which	which	WDT
8691	3902	15	a	a	DT
8691	3902	16	new	new	JJ
8691	3902	17	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	3902	18	of	of	IN
8691	3902	19	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	3902	20	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	3902	21	was	be	VBD
8691	3902	22	arranged	arrange	VBN
8691	3902	23	and	and	CC
8691	3902	24	under	under	IN
8691	3902	25	which	which	WDT
8691	3902	26	sixteen	sixteen	CD
8691	3902	27	Federalists	federalist	NNS
8691	3902	28	had	have	VBD
8691	3902	29	been	be	VBN
8691	3902	30	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3902	31	to	to	IN
8691	3902	32	the	the	DT
8691	3902	33	bench	bench	NN
8691	3902	34	.	.	.
8691	3903	1	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3903	2	did	do	VBD
8691	3903	3	the	the	DT
8691	3903	4	same	same	JJ
8691	3903	5	thing	thing	NN
8691	3903	6	in	in	IN
8691	3903	7	1811	1811	CD
8691	3903	8	with	with	IN
8691	3903	9	respect	respect	NN
8691	3903	10	to	to	IN
8691	3903	11	her	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3903	12	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	3903	13	of	of	IN
8691	3903	14	Common	Common	NNP
8691	3903	15	Pleas	Pleas	NNPS
8691	3903	16	.	.	.
8691	3904	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3904	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3904	3	:	:	:
8691	3904	4	See	see	VB
8691	3904	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	3904	6	.	.	.
8691	3905	1	VIII	VIII	NNP
8691	3905	2	.	.	.
8691	3905	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3906	1	The	the	DT
8691	3906	2	occurrence	occurrence	NN
8691	3906	3	of	of	IN
8691	3906	4	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
8691	3906	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	3906	6	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3906	7	been	be	VBN
8691	3906	8	prevented	prevent	VBN
8691	3906	9	in	in	IN
8691	3906	10	a	a	DT
8691	3906	11	similar	similar	JJ
8691	3906	12	manner	manner	NN
8691	3906	13	when	when	WRB
8691	3906	14	the	the	DT
8691	3906	15	nominating	nominating	NN
8691	3906	16	or	or	CC
8691	3906	17	appointing	appoint	VBG
8691	3906	18	authority	authority	NN
8691	3906	19	was	be	VBD
8691	3906	20	politically	politically	RB
8691	3906	21	opposed	opposed	JJ
8691	3906	22	to	to	IN
8691	3906	23	the	the	DT
8691	3906	24	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3906	25	.	.	.
8691	3907	1	The	the	DT
8691	3907	2	existence	existence	NN
8691	3907	3	of	of	IN
8691	3907	4	a	a	DT
8691	3907	5	supreme	supreme	NNP
8691	3907	6	court	court	NNP
8691	3907	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3907	8	required	require	VBN
8691	3907	9	by	by	IN
8691	3907	10	all	all	DT
8691	3907	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3907	12	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	3907	13	,	,	,
8691	3907	14	but	but	CC
8691	3907	15	the	the	DT
8691	3907	16	number	number	NN
8691	3907	17	of	of	IN
8691	3907	18	the	the	DT
8691	3907	19	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3907	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	3907	21	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	3907	22	left	leave	VBN
8691	3907	23	to	to	TO
8691	3907	24	be	be	VB
8691	3907	25	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	3907	26	from	from	IN
8691	3907	27	time	time	NN
8691	3907	28	to	to	IN
8691	3907	29	time	time	NN
8691	3907	30	by	by	IN
8691	3907	31	statute	statute	NN
8691	3907	32	.	.	.
8691	3908	1	The	the	DT
8691	3908	2	Federalists	Federalists	NNPS
8691	3908	3	,	,	,
8691	3908	4	when	when	WRB
8691	3908	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3908	6	were	be	VBD
8691	3908	7	about	about	JJ
8691	3908	8	to	to	TO
8691	3908	9	go	go	VB
8691	3908	10	out	out	IN
8691	3908	11	of	of	IN
8691	3908	12	power	power	NN
8691	3908	13	,	,	,
8691	3908	14	provided	provide	VBN
8691	3908	15	that	that	IN
8691	3908	16	the	the	DT
8691	3908	17	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3908	18	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3908	19	of	of	IN
8691	3908	20	the	the	DT
8691	3908	21	United	United	NNP
8691	3908	22	States	States	NNP
8691	3908	23	should	should	MD
8691	3908	24	on	on	IN
8691	3908	25	the	the	DT
8691	3908	26	next	next	JJ
8691	3908	27	vacancy	vacancy	NN
8691	3908	28	be	be	VB
8691	3908	29	reduced	reduce	VBN
8691	3908	30	from	from	IN
8691	3908	31	six	six	CD
8691	3908	32	to	to	TO
8691	3908	33	five	five	CD
8691	3908	34	,	,	,
8691	3908	35	thus	thus	RB
8691	3908	36	seeking	seek	VBG
8691	3908	37	to	to	TO
8691	3908	38	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	3908	39	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	3908	40	from	from	IN
8691	3908	41	filling	fill	VBG
8691	3908	42	such	such	JJ
8691	3908	43	vacancy	vacancy	NN
8691	3908	44	.	.	.
8691	3909	1	By	by	IN
8691	3909	2	1863	1863	CD
8691	3909	3	the	the	DT
8691	3909	4	number	number	NN
8691	3909	5	had	have	VBD
8691	3909	6	been	be	VBN
8691	3909	7	raised	raise	VBN
8691	3909	8	to	to	IN
8691	3909	9	ten	ten	CD
8691	3909	10	,	,	,
8691	3909	11	but	but	CC
8691	3909	12	three	three	CD
8691	3909	13	years	year	NNS
8691	3909	14	later	later	RB
8691	3909	15	,	,	,
8691	3909	16	when	when	WRB
8691	3909	17	a	a	DT
8691	3909	18	Democratic	democratic	JJ
8691	3909	19	President	President	NNP
8691	3909	20	was	be	VBD
8691	3909	21	contending	contend	VBG
8691	3909	22	with	with	IN
8691	3909	23	a	a	DT
8691	3909	24	Republican	Republican	NNP
8691	3909	25	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3909	26	,	,	,
8691	3909	27	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3909	28	was	be	VBD
8691	3909	29	enacted	enact	VBN
8691	3909	30	that	that	IN
8691	3909	31	as	as	IN
8691	3909	32	vacancies	vacancy	NNS
8691	3909	33	might	may	MD
8691	3909	34	occur	occur	VB
8691	3909	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3909	36	should	should	MD
8691	3909	37	be	be	VB
8691	3909	38	reduced	reduce	VBN
8691	3909	39	to	to	IN
8691	3909	40	seven	seven	CD
8691	3909	41	.	.	.
8691	3910	1	In	in	IN
8691	3910	2	1869	1869	CD
8691	3910	3	,	,	,
8691	3910	4	when	when	WRB
8691	3910	5	a	a	DT
8691	3910	6	Republican	republican	JJ
8691	3910	7	President	President	NNP
8691	3910	8	had	have	VBD
8691	3910	9	come	come	VBN
8691	3910	10	in	in	RP
8691	3910	11	,	,	,
8691	3910	12	the	the	DT
8691	3910	13	number	number	NN
8691	3910	14	was	be	VBD
8691	3910	15	restored	restore	VBN
8691	3910	16	to	to	IN
8691	3910	17	nine	nine	CD
8691	3910	18	,	,	,
8691	3910	19	and	and	CC
8691	3910	20	the	the	DT
8691	3910	21	new	new	JJ
8691	3910	22	justice	justice	NN
8691	3910	23	for	for	IN
8691	3910	24	whom	whom	WP
8691	3910	25	a	a	DT
8691	3910	26	place	place	NN
8691	3910	27	was	be	VBD
8691	3910	28	thus	thus	RB
8691	3910	29	made	make	VBN
8691	3910	30	shortly	shortly	RB
8691	3910	31	joined	join	VBN
8691	3910	32	in	in	IN
8691	3910	33	reversing	reverse	VBG
8691	3910	34	a	a	DT
8691	3910	35	decision	decision	NN
8691	3910	36	made	make	VBN
8691	3910	37	by	by	IN
8691	3910	38	the	the	DT
8691	3910	39	court	court	NN
8691	3910	40	not	not	RB
8691	3910	41	long	long	RB
8691	3910	42	before	before	RB
8691	3910	43	and	and	CC
8691	3910	44	quite	quite	RB
8691	3910	45	unsatisfactory	unsatisfactory	JJ
8691	3910	46	to	to	IN
8691	3910	47	the	the	DT
8691	3910	48	majority	majority	NN
8691	3910	49	in	in	IN
8691	3910	50	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3910	51	on	on	IN
8691	3910	52	an	an	DT
8691	3910	53	important	important	JJ
8691	3910	54	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3910	55	point	point	NN
8691	3910	56	.	.	.
8691	3911	1	Similar	similar	JJ
8691	3911	2	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	3911	3	,	,	,
8691	3911	4	for	for	IN
8691	3911	5	like	like	JJ
8691	3911	6	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	3911	7	,	,	,
8691	3911	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	3911	9	been	be	VBN
8691	3911	10	had	have	VBN
8691	3911	11	in	in	IN
8691	3911	12	many	many	JJ
8691	3911	13	of	of	IN
8691	3911	14	the	the	DT
8691	3911	15	States	States	NNPS
8691	3911	16	.	.	.
8691	3912	1	*	*	NFP
8691	3912	2	*	*	NFP
8691	3912	3	*	*	NFP
8691	3912	4	*	*	NFP
8691	3912	5	*	*	NFP
8691	3912	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	3912	7	XXIII	xxiii	NN
8691	3912	8	THE	the	DT
8691	3912	9	CHARACTER	CHARACTER	NNP
8691	3912	10	OF	of	IN
8691	3912	11	THE	the	DT
8691	3912	12	BAR	BAR	NNP
8691	3912	13	AND	and	CC
8691	3912	14	ITS	its	PRP$
8691	3912	15	RELATIONS	relations	NN
8691	3912	16	TO	to	IN
8691	3912	17	THE	the	DT
8691	3912	18	BENCH	BENCH	NNP
8691	3912	19	Every	every	DT
8691	3912	20	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	3912	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	3912	22	an	an	DT
8691	3912	23	officer	officer	NN
8691	3912	24	of	of	IN
8691	3912	25	the	the	DT
8691	3912	26	court	court	NN
8691	3912	27	as	as	RB
8691	3912	28	fully	fully	RB
8691	3912	29	as	as	IN
8691	3912	30	is	be	VBZ
8691	3912	31	the	the	DT
8691	3912	32	judge	judge	NN
8691	3912	33	or	or	CC
8691	3912	34	the	the	DT
8691	3912	35	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	3912	36	.	.	.
8691	3913	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3913	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	3913	3	,	,	,
8691	3913	4	indeed	indeed	RB
8691	3913	5	,	,	,
8691	3913	6	a	a	DT
8691	3913	7	longer	long	JJR
8691	3913	8	term	term	NN
8691	3913	9	of	of	IN
8691	3913	10	office	office	NN
8691	3913	11	than	than	IN
8691	3913	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	3913	13	generally	generally	RB
8691	3913	14	accorded	accord	VBN
8691	3913	15	to	to	IN
8691	3913	16	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3913	17	,	,	,
8691	3913	18	for	for	IN
8691	3913	19	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3913	20	holds	hold	VBZ
8691	3913	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3913	22	position	position	NN
8691	3913	23	for	for	IN
8691	3913	24	life	life	NN
8691	3913	25	,	,	,
8691	3913	26	or	or	CC
8691	3913	27	during	during	IN
8691	3913	28	good	good	JJ
8691	3913	29	behavior	behavior	NN
8691	3913	30	.	.	.
8691	3914	1	Courts	court	NNS
8691	3914	2	could	could	MD
8691	3914	3	not	not	RB
8691	3914	4	exist	exist	VB
8691	3914	5	under	under	IN
8691	3914	6	the	the	DT
8691	3914	7	American	american	JJ
8691	3914	8	system	system	NN
8691	3914	9	without	without	IN
8691	3914	10	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3914	11	to	to	TO
8691	3914	12	stand	stand	VB
8691	3914	13	between	between	IN
8691	3914	14	litigants	litigant	NNS
8691	3914	15	and	and	CC
8691	3914	16	the	the	DT
8691	3914	17	judge	judge	NN
8691	3914	18	or	or	CC
8691	3914	19	jury	jury	NN
8691	3914	20	.	.	.
8691	3915	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3915	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	3915	3	a	a	DT
8691	3915	4	system	system	NN
8691	3915	5	that	that	WDT
8691	3915	6	requires	require	VBZ
8691	3915	7	written	write	VBN
8691	3915	8	pleadings	pleading	NNS
8691	3915	9	,	,	,
8691	3915	10	originally	originally	RB
8691	3915	11	very	very	RB
8691	3915	12	artificial	artificial	JJ
8691	3915	13	in	in	IN
8691	3915	14	form	form	NN
8691	3915	15	and	and	CC
8691	3915	16	still	still	RB
8691	3915	17	somewhat	somewhat	RB
8691	3915	18	so	so	RB
8691	3915	19	.	.	.
8691	3916	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3916	2	imposes	impose	VBZ
8691	3916	3	many	many	JJ
8691	3916	4	limitations	limitation	NNS
8691	3916	5	on	on	IN
8691	3916	6	the	the	DT
8691	3916	7	introduction	introduction	NN
8691	3916	8	of	of	IN
8691	3916	9	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	3916	10	,	,	,
8691	3916	11	which	which	WDT
8691	3916	12	often	often	RB
8691	3916	13	seem	seem	VBP
8691	3916	14	to	to	TO
8691	3916	15	shut	shut	VB
8691	3916	16	out	out	RP
8691	3916	17	what	what	WP
8691	3916	18	ought	ought	MD
8691	3916	19	to	to	TO
8691	3916	20	be	be	VB
8691	3916	21	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	3916	22	,	,	,
8691	3916	23	and	and	CC
8691	3916	24	rest	rest	VB
8691	3916	25	on	on	IN
8691	3916	26	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	3916	27	not	not	RB
8691	3916	28	apparent	apparent	JJ
8691	3916	29	to	to	IN
8691	3916	30	any	any	DT
8691	3916	31	who	who	WP
8691	3916	32	have	have	VBP
8691	3916	33	not	not	RB
8691	3916	34	been	be	VBN
8691	3916	35	specially	specially	RB
8691	3916	36	instructed	instruct	VBN
8691	3916	37	in	in	IN
8691	3916	38	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3916	39	history	history	NN
8691	3916	40	.	.	.
8691	3917	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3917	2	divides	divide	VBZ
8691	3917	3	the	the	DT
8691	3917	4	decision	decision	NN
8691	3917	5	of	of	IN
8691	3917	6	a	a	DT
8691	3917	7	cause	cause	NN
8691	3917	8	between	between	IN
8691	3917	9	judge	judge	NN
8691	3917	10	and	and	CC
8691	3917	11	jury	jury	NN
8691	3917	12	in	in	IN
8691	3917	13	a	a	DT
8691	3917	14	manner	manner	NN
8691	3917	15	only	only	RB
8691	3917	16	to	to	TO
8691	3917	17	be	be	VB
8691	3917	18	understood	understand	VBN
8691	3917	19	after	after	IN
8691	3917	20	a	a	DT
8691	3917	21	long	long	JJ
8691	3917	22	and	and	CC
8691	3917	23	close	close	JJ
8691	3917	24	study	study	NN
8691	3917	25	.	.	.
8691	3918	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3918	2	gives	give	VBZ
8691	3918	3	a	a	DT
8691	3918	4	defeated	defeat	VBN
8691	3918	5	party	party	NN
8691	3918	6	a	a	DT
8691	3918	7	right	right	NN
8691	3918	8	of	of	IN
8691	3918	9	review	review	NN
8691	3918	10	dependent	dependent	JJ
8691	3918	11	on	on	IN
8691	3918	12	a	a	DT
8691	3918	13	number	number	NN
8691	3918	14	of	of	IN
8691	3918	15	technical	technical	JJ
8691	3918	16	rules	rule	NNS
8691	3918	17	,	,	,
8691	3918	18	and	and	CC
8691	3918	19	to	to	TO
8691	3918	20	be	be	VB
8691	3918	21	availed	avail	VBN
8691	3918	22	of	of	IN
8691	3918	23	only	only	RB
8691	3918	24	by	by	IN
8691	3918	25	those	those	DT
8691	3918	26	who	who	WP
8691	3918	27	are	be	VBP
8691	3918	28	skilled	skilled	JJ
8691	3918	29	in	in	IN
8691	3918	30	the	the	DT
8691	3918	31	preparation	preparation	NN
8691	3918	32	of	of	IN
8691	3918	33	law	law	NN
8691	3918	34	papers	paper	NNS
8691	3918	35	of	of	IN
8691	3918	36	a	a	DT
8691	3918	37	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
8691	3918	38	kind	kind	NN
8691	3918	39	.	.	.
8691	3919	1	A	a	DT
8691	3919	2	class	class	NN
8691	3919	3	of	of	IN
8691	3919	4	men	man	NNS
8691	3919	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	3919	6	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	3919	7	been	be	VBN
8691	3919	8	set	set	VBN
8691	3919	9	apart	apart	RB
8691	3919	10	to	to	TO
8691	3919	11	keep	keep	VB
8691	3919	12	the	the	DT
8691	3919	13	people	people	NNS
8691	3919	14	from	from	IN
8691	3919	15	direct	direct	JJ
8691	3919	16	approach	approach	NN
8691	3919	17	to	to	IN
8691	3919	18	the	the	DT
8691	3919	19	bench	bench	NN
8691	3919	20	,	,	,
8691	3919	21	except	except	IN
8691	3919	22	when	when	WRB
8691	3919	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3919	24	may	may	MD
8691	3919	25	desire	desire	VB
8691	3919	26	to	to	TO
8691	3919	27	argue	argue	VB
8691	3919	28	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3919	29	own	own	JJ
8691	3919	30	cases	case	NNS
8691	3919	31	,	,	,
8691	3919	32	which	which	WDT
8691	3919	33	rarely	rarely	RB
8691	3919	34	occurs	occur	VBZ
8691	3919	35	.	.	.
8691	3920	1	In	in	IN
8691	3920	2	England	England	NNP
8691	3920	3	there	there	EX
8691	3920	4	are	be	VBP
8691	3920	5	two	two	CD
8691	3920	6	such	such	JJ
8691	3920	7	barriers	barrier	NNS
8691	3920	8	,	,	,
8691	3920	9	the	the	DT
8691	3920	10	class	class	NN
8691	3920	11	of	of	IN
8691	3920	12	barristers	barrister	NNS
8691	3920	13	and	and	CC
8691	3920	14	the	the	DT
8691	3920	15	class	class	NN
8691	3920	16	of	of	IN
8691	3920	17	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	3920	18	.	.	.
8691	3921	1	The	the	DT
8691	3921	2	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	3921	3	keep	keep	VBP
8691	3921	4	the	the	DT
8691	3921	5	people	people	NNS
8691	3921	6	from	from	IN
8691	3921	7	access	access	NN
8691	3921	8	to	to	IN
8691	3921	9	the	the	DT
8691	3921	10	barristers	barrister	NNS
8691	3921	11	;	;	:
8691	3921	12	the	the	DT
8691	3921	13	barristers	barrister	NNS
8691	3921	14	keep	keep	VBP
8691	3921	15	the	the	DT
8691	3921	16	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	3921	17	from	from	IN
8691	3921	18	access	access	NN
8691	3921	19	to	to	IN
8691	3921	20	the	the	DT
8691	3921	21	court	court	NN
8691	3921	22	.	.	.
8691	3922	1	The	the	DT
8691	3922	2	attorney	attorney	NN
8691	3922	3	prepares	prepare	VBZ
8691	3922	4	the	the	DT
8691	3922	5	case	case	NN
8691	3922	6	,	,	,
8691	3922	7	represents	represent	VBZ
8691	3922	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3922	9	client	client	NN
8691	3922	10	in	in	IN
8691	3922	11	the	the	DT
8691	3922	12	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3922	13	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
8691	3922	14	to	to	IN
8691	3922	15	the	the	DT
8691	3922	16	trial	trial	NN
8691	3922	17	,	,	,
8691	3922	18	and	and	CC
8691	3922	19	assists	assist	VBZ
8691	3922	20	the	the	DT
8691	3922	21	barrister	barrister	NN
8691	3922	22	whom	whom	WP
8691	3922	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3922	24	may	may	MD
8691	3922	25	retain	retain	VB
8691	3922	26	at	at	IN
8691	3922	27	the	the	DT
8691	3922	28	trial	trial	NN
8691	3922	29	,	,	,
8691	3922	30	but	but	CC
8691	3922	31	can	can	MD
8691	3922	32	not	not	RB
8691	3922	33	examine	examine	VB
8691	3922	34	a	a	DT
8691	3922	35	witness	witness	NN
8691	3922	36	or	or	CC
8691	3922	37	argue	argue	VB
8691	3922	38	the	the	DT
8691	3922	39	cause	cause	NN
8691	3922	40	.	.	.
8691	3923	1	In	in	IN
8691	3923	2	America	America	NNP
8691	3923	3	we	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3923	4	do	do	VBP
8691	3923	5	not	not	RB
8691	3923	6	thus	thus	RB
8691	3923	7	divide	divide	VB
8691	3923	8	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3923	9	into	into	IN
8691	3923	10	two	two	CD
8691	3923	11	classes	class	NNS
8691	3923	12	.	.	.
8691	3924	1	There	there	EX
8691	3924	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3924	3	many	many	JJ
8691	3924	4	of	of	IN
8691	3924	5	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3924	6	who	who	WP
8691	3924	7	never	never	RB
8691	3924	8	in	in	IN
8691	3924	9	fact	fact	NN
8691	3924	10	address	address	NN
8691	3924	11	the	the	DT
8691	3924	12	court	court	NN
8691	3924	13	,	,	,
8691	3924	14	but	but	CC
8691	3924	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3924	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	3924	17	not	not	RB
8691	3924	18	because	because	IN
8691	3924	19	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3924	20	have	have	VBP
8691	3924	21	not	not	RB
8691	3924	22	a	a	DT
8691	3924	23	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3924	24	right	right	NN
8691	3924	25	to	to	TO
8691	3924	26	do	do	VB
8691	3924	27	so	so	RB
8691	3924	28	.	.	.
8691	3925	1	Every	every	DT
8691	3925	2	member	member	NN
8691	3925	3	of	of	IN
8691	3925	4	the	the	DT
8691	3925	5	bar	bar	NN
8691	3925	6	of	of	IN
8691	3925	7	any	any	DT
8691	3925	8	court	court	NN
8691	3925	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	3925	10	all	all	PDT
8691	3925	11	the	the	DT
8691	3925	12	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3925	13	rights	right	NNS
8691	3925	14	of	of	IN
8691	3925	15	any	any	DT
8691	3925	16	other	other	JJ
8691	3925	17	member	member	NN
8691	3925	18	of	of	IN
8691	3925	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3925	20	.	.	.
8691	3926	1	The	the	DT
8691	3926	2	qualifications	qualification	NNS
8691	3926	3	for	for	IN
8691	3926	4	admission	admission	NN
8691	3926	5	to	to	IN
8691	3926	6	the	the	DT
8691	3926	7	bar	bar	NN
8691	3926	8	are	be	VBP
8691	3926	9	generally	generally	RB
8691	3926	10	left	leave	VBN
8691	3926	11	to	to	TO
8691	3926	12	be	be	VB
8691	3926	13	regulated	regulate	VBN
8691	3926	14	by	by	IN
8691	3926	15	the	the	DT
8691	3926	16	courts	court	NNS
8691	3926	17	.	.	.
8691	3927	1	In	in	IN
8691	3927	2	a	a	DT
8691	3927	3	few	few	JJ
8691	3927	4	States	state	NNS
8691	3927	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3927	6	are	be	VBP
8691	3927	7	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	3927	8	by	by	IN
8691	3927	9	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	3927	10	or	or	CC
8691	3927	11	statutory	statutory	JJ
8691	3927	12	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	3927	13	.	.	.
8691	3928	1	In	in	IN
8691	3928	2	all	all	DT
8691	3928	3	,	,	,
8691	3928	4	when	when	WRB
8691	3928	5	the	the	DT
8691	3928	6	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	3928	7	do	do	VBP
8691	3928	8	not	not	RB
8691	3928	9	regulate	regulate	VB
8691	3928	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3928	11	,	,	,
8691	3928	12	the	the	DT
8691	3928	13	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3928	14	can	can	MD
8691	3928	15	.	.	.
8691	3929	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3929	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	3929	3	indeed	indeed	RB
8691	3929	4	been	be	VBN
8691	3929	5	asserted	assert	VBN
8691	3929	6	that	that	IN
8691	3929	7	the	the	DT
8691	3929	8	admission	admission	NN
8691	3929	9	of	of	IN
8691	3929	10	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	3929	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	3929	12	in	in	IN
8691	3929	13	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3929	14	nature	nature	NN
8691	3929	15	a	a	DT
8691	3929	16	matter	matter	NN
8691	3929	17	for	for	IN
8691	3929	18	the	the	DT
8691	3929	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	3929	20	only	only	RB
8691	3929	21	.	.	.
8691	3930	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3930	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3930	3	:	:	:
8691	3930	4	See	see	VB
8691	3930	5	_	_	NNP
8691	3930	6	American	American	NNP
8691	3930	7	Law	Law	NNP
8691	3930	8	School	School	NNP
8691	3930	9	Review	Review	NNP
8691	3930	10	_	_	NNP
8691	3930	11	,	,	,
8691	3930	12	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3930	13	,	,	,
8691	3930	14	211	211	CD
8691	3930	15	.	.	.
8691	3930	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3931	1	English	english	JJ
8691	3931	2	history	history	NN
8691	3931	3	does	do	VBZ
8691	3931	4	not	not	RB
8691	3931	5	support	support	VB
8691	3931	6	this	this	DT
8691	3931	7	contention	contention	NN
8691	3931	8	.	.	.
8691	3932	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3932	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3932	3	:	:	:
8691	3932	4	Pollock	Pollock	NNP
8691	3932	5	&	&	CC
8691	3932	6	Maitland	Maitland	NNP
8691	3932	7	,	,	,
8691	3932	8	"	"	''
8691	3932	9	History	history	NN
8691	3932	10	of	of	IN
8691	3932	11	English	English	NNP
8691	3932	12	Law	Law	NNP
8691	3932	13	,	,	,
8691	3932	14	"	"	``
8691	3932	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3932	16	,	,	,
8691	3932	17	211	211	CD
8691	3932	18	-	-	SYM
8691	3932	19	217	217	CD
8691	3932	20	;	;	:
8691	3932	21	II	II	NNP
8691	3932	22	,	,	,
8691	3932	23	226	226	CD
8691	3932	24	.	.	.
8691	3933	1	O'Brien	O'Brien	NNP
8691	3933	2	's	's	POS
8691	3933	3	Petition	Petition	NNP
8691	3933	4	,	,	,
8691	3933	5	79	79	CD
8691	3933	6	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3933	7	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	3933	8	,	,	,
8691	3933	9	46	46	CD
8691	3933	10	;	;	:
8691	3933	11	63	63	CD
8691	3933	12	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	3933	13	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	3933	14	,	,	,
8691	3933	15	777	777	CD
8691	3933	16	.	.	.
8691	3933	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3934	1	The	the	DT
8691	3934	2	Inns	Inns	NNPS
8691	3934	3	of	of	IN
8691	3934	4	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3934	5	,	,	,
8691	3934	6	which	which	WDT
8691	3934	7	are	be	VBP
8691	3934	8	mere	mere	JJ
8691	3934	9	voluntary	voluntary	JJ
8691	3934	10	associations	association	NNS
8691	3934	11	of	of	IN
8691	3934	12	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3934	13	,	,	,
8691	3934	14	have	have	VBP
8691	3934	15	from	from	IN
8691	3934	16	time	time	NN
8691	3934	17	immemorial	immemorial	NNP
8691	3934	18	exercised	exercise	VBD
8691	3934	19	the	the	DT
8691	3934	20	function	function	NN
8691	3934	21	of	of	IN
8691	3934	22	calling	call	VBG
8691	3934	23	to	to	IN
8691	3934	24	the	the	DT
8691	3934	25	bar	bar	NN
8691	3934	26	,	,	,
8691	3934	27	so	so	RB
8691	3934	28	far	far	RB
8691	3934	29	as	as	IN
8691	3934	30	barristers	barrister	NNS
8691	3934	31	are	be	VBP
8691	3934	32	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	3934	33	,	,	,
8691	3934	34	and	and	CC
8691	3934	35	the	the	DT
8691	3934	36	admission	admission	NN
8691	3934	37	of	of	IN
8691	3934	38	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	3934	39	has	have	VBZ
8691	3934	40	always	always	RB
8691	3934	41	been	be	VBN
8691	3934	42	regulated	regulate	VBN
8691	3934	43	by	by	IN
8691	3934	44	Acts	Acts	NNPS
8691	3934	45	of	of	IN
8691	3934	46	Parliament	Parliament	NNP
8691	3934	47	.	.	.
8691	3935	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3935	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3935	3	:	:	:
8691	3935	4	See	see	VB
8691	3935	5	In	in	IN
8691	3935	6	the	the	DT
8691	3935	7	Matter	Matter	NNP
8691	3935	8	of	of	IN
8691	3935	9	Cooper	Cooper	NNP
8691	3935	10	,	,	,
8691	3935	11	22	22	CD
8691	3935	12	N.	n.	NN
8691	3935	13	Y.	y.	NN
8691	3936	1	Reports	report	NNS
8691	3936	2	,	,	,
8691	3936	3	67	67	CD
8691	3936	4	,	,	,
8691	3936	5	90	90	CD
8691	3936	6	.	.	.
8691	3936	7	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3937	1	By	by	IN
8691	3937	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3937	3	American	american	JJ
8691	3937	4	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	3937	5	the	the	DT
8691	3937	6	same	same	JJ
8691	3937	7	course	course	NN
8691	3937	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	3937	9	been	be	VBN
8691	3937	10	generally	generally	RB
8691	3937	11	pursued	pursue	VBN
8691	3937	12	.	.	.
8691	3938	1	The	the	DT
8691	3938	2	duty	duty	NN
8691	3938	3	of	of	IN
8691	3938	4	ascertaining	ascertaining	NN
8691	3938	5	whether	whether	IN
8691	3938	6	candidates	candidate	NNS
8691	3938	7	for	for	IN
8691	3938	8	admission	admission	NN
8691	3938	9	have	have	VBP
8691	3938	10	the	the	DT
8691	3938	11	prescribed	prescribe	VBN
8691	3938	12	qualifications	qualification	NNS
8691	3938	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	3938	14	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	3938	15	performed	perform	VBN
8691	3938	16	by	by	IN
8691	3938	17	the	the	DT
8691	3938	18	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3938	19	in	in	IN
8691	3938	20	person	person	NN
8691	3938	21	;	;	:
8691	3938	22	more	more	RBR
8691	3938	23	often	often	RB
8691	3938	24	by	by	IN
8691	3938	25	a	a	DT
8691	3938	26	committee	committee	NN
8691	3938	27	of	of	IN
8691	3938	28	the	the	DT
8691	3938	29	bar	bar	NN
8691	3938	30	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	3938	31	by	by	IN
8691	3938	32	the	the	DT
8691	3938	33	court	court	NN
8691	3938	34	for	for	IN
8691	3938	35	that	that	DT
8691	3938	36	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	3938	37	;	;	:
8691	3938	38	in	in	IN
8691	3938	39	some	some	DT
8691	3938	40	States	States	NNP
8691	3938	41	by	by	IN
8691	3938	42	a	a	DT
8691	3938	43	standing	stand	VBG
8691	3938	44	board	board	NN
8691	3938	45	of	of	IN
8691	3938	46	State	State	NNP
8691	3938	47	examiners	examiner	NNS
8691	3938	48	,	,	,
8691	3938	49	receiving	receive	VBG
8691	3938	50	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	3938	51	for	for	IN
8691	3938	52	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3938	53	services	service	NNS
8691	3938	54	.	.	.
8691	3939	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3939	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3939	3	:	:	:
8691	3939	4	This	this	DT
8691	3939	5	comes	come	VBZ
8691	3939	6	from	from	IN
8691	3939	7	fees	fee	NNS
8691	3939	8	paid	pay	VBN
8691	3939	9	by	by	IN
8691	3939	10	those	those	DT
8691	3939	11	examined	examine	VBN
8691	3939	12	.	.	.
8691	3939	13	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3940	1	The	the	DT
8691	3940	2	latter	latter	JJ
8691	3940	3	method	method	NN
8691	3940	4	was	be	VBD
8691	3940	5	introduced	introduce	VBN
8691	3940	6	in	in	IN
8691	3940	7	the	the	DT
8691	3940	8	latter	latter	JJ
8691	3940	9	part	part	NN
8691	3940	10	of	of	IN
8691	3940	11	the	the	DT
8691	3940	12	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	3940	13	century	century	NN
8691	3940	14	and	and	CC
8691	3940	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	3940	16	steadily	steadily	RB
8691	3940	17	gaining	gain	VBG
8691	3940	18	in	in	IN
8691	3940	19	favor	favor	NN
8691	3940	20	.	.	.
8691	3941	1	A	a	DT
8691	3941	2	committee	committee	NN
8691	3941	3	of	of	IN
8691	3941	4	a	a	DT
8691	3941	5	local	local	JJ
8691	3941	6	bar	bar	NN
8691	3941	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	3941	8	unavoidably	unavoidably	RB
8691	3941	9	subject	subject	JJ
8691	3941	10	to	to	IN
8691	3941	11	some	some	DT
8691	3941	12	local	local	JJ
8691	3941	13	influences	influence	NNS
8691	3941	14	or	or	CC
8691	3941	15	prepossessions	prepossession	NNS
8691	3941	16	.	.	.
8691	3942	1	A	a	DT
8691	3942	2	State	State	NNP
8691	3942	3	board	board	NN
8691	3942	4	can	can	MD
8691	3942	5	act	act	VB
8691	3942	6	with	with	IN
8691	3942	7	greater	great	JJR
8691	3942	8	independence	independence	NN
8691	3942	9	and	and	CC
8691	3942	10	maintain	maintain	VB
8691	3942	11	with	with	IN
8691	3942	12	more	more	JJR
8691	3942	13	ease	ease	NN
8691	3942	14	a	a	DT
8691	3942	15	high	high	JJ
8691	3942	16	standard	standard	NN
8691	3942	17	of	of	IN
8691	3942	18	admission	admission	NN
8691	3942	19	.	.	.
8691	3943	1	In	in	IN
8691	3943	2	early	early	JJ
8691	3943	3	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	3943	4	days	day	NNS
8691	3943	5	the	the	DT
8691	3943	6	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	3943	7	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	3943	8	set	set	VBD
8691	3943	9	a	a	DT
8691	3943	10	limit	limit	NN
8691	3943	11	to	to	IN
8691	3943	12	the	the	DT
8691	3943	13	number	number	NN
8691	3943	14	of	of	IN
8691	3943	15	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	3943	16	who	who	WP
8691	3943	17	could	could	MD
8691	3943	18	be	be	VB
8691	3943	19	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	3943	20	to	to	TO
8691	3943	21	practice	practice	VB
8691	3943	22	before	before	IN
8691	3943	23	the	the	DT
8691	3943	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	3943	25	.	.	.
8691	3944	1	In	in	IN
8691	3944	2	some	some	DT
8691	3944	3	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	3944	4	the	the	DT
8691	3944	5	number	number	NN
8691	3944	6	at	at	IN
8691	3944	7	the	the	DT
8691	3944	8	bar	bar	NN
8691	3944	9	of	of	IN
8691	3944	10	a	a	DT
8691	3944	11	particular	particular	JJ
8691	3944	12	court	court	NN
8691	3944	13	was	be	VBD
8691	3944	14	fixed	fix	VBN
8691	3944	15	;	;	:
8691	3944	16	in	in	IN
8691	3944	17	others	other	NNS
8691	3944	18	the	the	DT
8691	3944	19	number	number	NN
8691	3944	20	of	of	IN
8691	3944	21	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3944	22	in	in	IN
8691	3944	23	each	each	DT
8691	3944	24	county	county	NN
8691	3944	25	.	.	.
8691	3945	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3945	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3945	3	:	:	:
8691	3945	4	Acts	Acts	NNPS
8691	3945	5	and	and	CC
8691	3945	6	Laws	Laws	NNPS
8691	3945	7	of	of	IN
8691	3945	8	the	the	DT
8691	3945	9	Colony	Colony	NNP
8691	3945	10	of	of	IN
8691	3945	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3945	12	,	,	,
8691	3945	13	May	May	NNP
8691	3945	14	session	session	NN
8691	3945	15	,	,	,
8691	3945	16	1730	1730	CD
8691	3945	17	,	,	,
8691	3945	18	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	3945	19	.	.	.
8691	3946	1	LIV	LIV	NNP
8691	3946	2	.	.	.
8691	3947	1	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
8691	3947	2	,	,	,
8691	3947	3	"	"	``
8691	3947	4	Life	Life	NNP
8691	3947	5	of	of	IN
8691	3947	6	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	3947	7	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
8691	3947	8	,	,	,
8691	3947	9	"	"	``
8691	3947	10	48	48	CD
8691	3947	11	.	.	.
8691	3947	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3948	1	No	no	DT
8691	3948	2	such	such	JJ
8691	3948	3	limitation	limitation	NN
8691	3948	4	now	now	RB
8691	3948	5	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	3948	6	in	in	IN
8691	3948	7	any	any	DT
8691	3948	8	State	State	NNP
8691	3948	9	,	,	,
8691	3948	10	and	and	CC
8691	3948	11	the	the	DT
8691	3948	12	matter	matter	NN
8691	3948	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	3948	14	left	leave	VBN
8691	3948	15	to	to	TO
8691	3948	16	be	be	VB
8691	3948	17	regulated	regulate	VBN
8691	3948	18	by	by	IN
8691	3948	19	the	the	DT
8691	3948	20	law	law	NN
8691	3948	21	of	of	IN
8691	3948	22	supply	supply	NN
8691	3948	23	and	and	CC
8691	3948	24	demand	demand	NN
8691	3948	25	.	.	.
8691	3949	1	This	this	DT
8691	3949	2	by	by	IN
8691	3949	3	the	the	DT
8691	3949	4	census	census	NN
8691	3949	5	of	of	IN
8691	3949	6	1900	1900	CD
8691	3949	7	required	require	VBD
8691	3949	8	over	over	IN
8691	3949	9	114,000	114,000	CD
8691	3949	10	.	.	.
8691	3950	1	The	the	DT
8691	3950	2	freer	free	JJR
8691	3950	3	a	a	DT
8691	3950	4	country	country	NN
8691	3950	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	3950	6	,	,	,
8691	3950	7	and	and	CC
8691	3950	8	the	the	DT
8691	3950	9	quicker	quick	JJR
8691	3950	10	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3950	11	step	step	NN
8691	3950	12	in	in	IN
8691	3950	13	the	the	DT
8691	3950	14	march	march	NN
8691	3950	15	of	of	IN
8691	3950	16	civilization	civilization	NN
8691	3950	17	,	,	,
8691	3950	18	the	the	DT
8691	3950	19	more	more	JJR
8691	3950	20	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3950	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3950	22	will	will	MD
8691	3950	23	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	3950	24	have	have	VB
8691	3950	25	.	.	.
8691	3951	1	The	the	DT
8691	3951	2	growth	growth	NN
8691	3951	3	and	and	CC
8691	3951	4	importance	importance	NN
8691	3951	5	of	of	IN
8691	3951	6	the	the	DT
8691	3951	7	bar	bar	NN
8691	3951	8	are	be	VBP
8691	3951	9	stunted	stunted	JJ
8691	3951	10	wherever	wherever	WRB
8691	3951	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3951	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	3951	13	overshadowed	overshadow	VBN
8691	3951	14	by	by	IN
8691	3951	15	an	an	DT
8691	3951	16	hereditary	hereditary	JJ
8691	3951	17	aristocracy	aristocracy	NN
8691	3951	18	.	.	.
8691	3952	1	A	a	DT
8691	3952	2	land	land	NN
8691	3952	3	of	of	IN
8691	3952	4	absolutism	absolutism	NN
8691	3952	5	and	and	CC
8691	3952	6	stagnation	stagnation	NN
8691	3952	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	3952	8	no	no	DT
8691	3952	9	use	use	NN
8691	3952	10	for	for	IN
8691	3952	11	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3952	12	.	.	.
8691	3953	1	The	the	DT
8691	3953	2	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	3953	3	of	of	IN
8691	3953	4	China	China	NNP
8691	3953	5	would	would	MD
8691	3953	6	not	not	RB
8691	3953	7	be	be	VB
8691	3953	8	safe	safe	JJ
8691	3953	9	if	if	IN
8691	3953	10	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3953	11	had	have	VBD
8691	3953	12	a	a	DT
8691	3953	13	bar	bar	NN
8691	3953	14	.	.	.
8691	3954	1	Lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3954	2	are	be	VBP
8691	3954	3	a	a	DT
8691	3954	4	conservative	conservative	JJ
8691	3954	5	force	force	NN
8691	3954	6	in	in	IN
8691	3954	7	a	a	DT
8691	3954	8	free	free	JJ
8691	3954	9	country	country	NN
8691	3954	10	;	;	:
8691	3954	11	an	an	DT
8691	3954	12	upheaving	upheaving	NN
8691	3954	13	force	force	NN
8691	3954	14	under	under	IN
8691	3954	15	a	a	DT
8691	3954	16	despotic	despotic	JJ
8691	3954	17	government	government	NN
8691	3954	18	.	.	.
8691	3955	1	In	in	IN
8691	3955	2	Russia	Russia	NNP
8691	3955	3	one	one	CD
8691	3955	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	3955	5	found	find	VBN
8691	3955	6	enough	enough	RB
8691	3955	7	to	to	TO
8691	3955	8	serve	serve	VB
8691	3955	9	over	over	IN
8691	3955	10	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	3955	11	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	3955	12	;	;	:
8691	3955	13	in	in	IN
8691	3955	14	the	the	DT
8691	3955	15	United	United	NNP
8691	3955	16	States	States	NNP
8691	3955	17	there	there	EX
8691	3955	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	3955	19	about	about	RB
8691	3955	20	one	one	CD
8691	3955	21	to	to	IN
8691	3955	22	every	every	DT
8691	3955	23	six	six	CD
8691	3955	24	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3955	25	and	and	CC
8691	3955	26	sixty	sixty	CD
8691	3955	27	of	of	IN
8691	3955	28	the	the	DT
8691	3955	29	population,[Footnote	population,[Footnote	NNP
8691	3955	30	:	:	:
8691	3955	31	In	in	IN
8691	3955	32	1870	1870	CD
8691	3955	33	,	,	,
8691	3955	34	there	there	EX
8691	3955	35	was	be	VBD
8691	3955	36	one	one	CD
8691	3955	37	to	to	IN
8691	3955	38	every	every	DT
8691	3955	39	946	946	CD
8691	3955	40	;	;	:
8691	3955	41	in	in	IN
8691	3955	42	1880	1880	CD
8691	3955	43	,	,	,
8691	3955	44	one	one	CD
8691	3955	45	to	to	IN
8691	3955	46	every	every	DT
8691	3955	47	782	782	CD
8691	3955	48	.	.	.
8691	3955	49	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3956	1	and	and	CC
8691	3956	2	in	in	IN
8691	3956	3	England	England	NNP
8691	3956	4	one	one	CD
8691	3956	5	to	to	IN
8691	3956	6	every	every	DT
8691	3956	7	eleven	eleven	CD
8691	3956	8	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	3956	9	.	.	.
8691	3957	1	The	the	DT
8691	3957	2	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	3957	3	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3957	4	of	of	IN
8691	3957	5	the	the	DT
8691	3957	6	seventeenth	seventeenth	JJ
8691	3957	7	and	and	CC
8691	3957	8	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
8691	3957	9	centuries	century	NNS
8691	3957	10	occupied	occupy	VBD
8691	3957	11	an	an	DT
8691	3957	12	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3957	13	place	place	NN
8691	3957	14	in	in	IN
8691	3957	15	the	the	DT
8691	3957	16	community	community	NN
8691	3957	17	as	as	IN
8691	3957	18	compared	compare	VBN
8691	3957	19	with	with	IN
8691	3957	20	that	that	DT
8691	3957	21	now	now	RB
8691	3957	22	held	hold	VBN
8691	3957	23	by	by	IN
8691	3957	24	the	the	DT
8691	3957	25	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3957	26	profession	profession	NN
8691	3957	27	.	.	.
8691	3958	1	There	there	EX
8691	3958	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3958	3	comparatively	comparatively	RB
8691	3958	4	little	little	JJ
8691	3958	5	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	3958	6	to	to	TO
8691	3958	7	rise	rise	VB
8691	3958	8	to	to	TO
8691	3958	9	eminence	eminence	VB
8691	3958	10	.	.	.
8691	3959	1	The	the	DT
8691	3959	2	positions	position	NNS
8691	3959	3	on	on	IN
8691	3959	4	the	the	DT
8691	3959	5	bench	bench	NN
8691	3959	6	,	,	,
8691	3959	7	as	as	IN
8691	3959	8	has	have	VBZ
8691	3959	9	been	be	VBN
8691	3959	10	seen	see	VBN
8691	3959	11	,	,	,
8691	3959	12	were	be	VBD
8691	3959	13	largely	largely	RB
8691	3959	14	held	hold	VBN
8691	3959	15	by	by	IN
8691	3959	16	those	those	DT
8691	3959	17	not	not	RB
8691	3959	18	trained	train	VBN
8691	3959	19	as	as	IN
8691	3959	20	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3959	21	.	.	.
8691	3960	1	Before	before	IN
8691	3960	2	such	such	JJ
8691	3960	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	3960	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3960	5	was	be	VBD
8691	3960	6	a	a	DT
8691	3960	7	waste	waste	NN
8691	3960	8	of	of	IN
8691	3960	9	words	word	NNS
8691	3960	10	to	to	TO
8691	3960	11	make	make	VB
8691	3960	12	elaborate	elaborate	JJ
8691	3960	13	arguments	argument	NNS
8691	3960	14	on	on	IN
8691	3960	15	points	point	NNS
8691	3960	16	of	of	IN
8691	3960	17	law	law	NN
8691	3960	18	.	.	.
8691	3961	1	Among	among	IN
8691	3961	2	the	the	DT
8691	3961	3	first	first	JJ
8691	3961	4	settlers	settler	NNS
8691	3961	5	were	be	VBD
8691	3961	6	a	a	DT
8691	3961	7	few	few	JJ
8691	3961	8	who	who	WP
8691	3961	9	had	have	VBD
8691	3961	10	been	be	VBN
8691	3961	11	educated	educate	VBN
8691	3961	12	for	for	IN
8691	3961	13	the	the	DT
8691	3961	14	English	English	NNP
8691	3961	15	bar	bar	NN
8691	3961	16	.	.	.
8691	3962	1	One	one	CD
8691	3962	2	of	of	IN
8691	3962	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3962	4	,	,	,
8691	3962	5	in	in	IN
8691	3962	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3962	7	,	,	,
8691	3962	8	Rev.	Rev.	NNP
8691	3963	1	Nathaniel	Nathaniel	NNP
8691	3963	2	Ward	Ward	NNP
8691	3963	3	,	,	,
8691	3963	4	drafted	draft	VBD
8691	3963	5	the	the	DT
8691	3963	6	_	_	NNP
8691	3963	7	Magna	Magna	NNPS
8691	3963	8	Charta	Charta	NNP
8691	3963	9	_	_	NNP
8691	3963	10	or	or	CC
8691	3963	11	"	"	``
8691	3963	12	Body	Body	NNP
8691	3963	13	of	of	IN
8691	3963	14	Liberties	Liberties	NNPS
8691	3963	15	"	"	''
8691	3963	16	of	of	IN
8691	3963	17	that	that	DT
8691	3963	18	colony	colony	NN
8691	3963	19	,	,	,
8691	3963	20	adopted	adopt	VBN
8691	3963	21	in	in	IN
8691	3963	22	1641	1641	CD
8691	3963	23	.	.	.
8691	3964	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3964	2	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	3964	3	of	of	IN
8691	3964	4	the	the	DT
8691	3964	5	need	need	NN
8691	3964	6	of	of	IN
8691	3964	7	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3964	8	may	may	MD
8691	3964	9	be	be	VB
8691	3964	10	inferred	infer	VBN
8691	3964	11	from	from	IN
8691	3964	12	the	the	DT
8691	3964	13	fact	fact	NN
8691	3964	14	that	that	IN
8691	3964	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3964	16	provided	provide	VBD
8691	3964	17	expressly	expressly	RB
8691	3964	18	that	that	IN
8691	3964	19	those	those	DT
8691	3964	20	who	who	WP
8691	3964	21	pleaded	plead	VBD
8691	3964	22	causes	cause	NNS
8691	3964	23	for	for	IN
8691	3964	24	others	other	NNS
8691	3964	25	should	should	MD
8691	3964	26	receive	receive	VB
8691	3964	27	no	no	DT
8691	3964	28	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	3964	29	for	for	IN
8691	3964	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3964	31	.	.	.
8691	3965	1	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	3965	2	adopted	adopt	VBD
8691	3965	3	the	the	DT
8691	3965	4	same	same	JJ
8691	3965	5	policy	policy	NN
8691	3965	6	from	from	IN
8691	3965	7	1645	1645	CD
8691	3965	8	to	to	IN
8691	3965	9	1662	1662	CD
8691	3965	10	.	.	.
8691	3966	1	Later	later	RB
8691	3966	2	,	,	,
8691	3966	3	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	3966	4	practicing	practice	VBG
8691	3966	5	in	in	IN
8691	3966	6	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3966	7	were	be	VBD
8691	3966	8	excluded	exclude	VBN
8691	3966	9	from	from	IN
8691	3966	10	the	the	DT
8691	3966	11	General	General	NNP
8691	3966	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3966	13	.	.	.
8691	3967	1	As	as	IN
8691	3967	2	that	that	DT
8691	3967	3	had	have	VBD
8691	3967	4	large	large	JJ
8691	3967	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	3967	6	powers	power	NNS
8691	3967	7	,	,	,
8691	3967	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3967	9	was	be	VBD
8691	3967	10	thought	think	VBN
8691	3967	11	fitting	fitting	JJ
8691	3967	12	to	to	TO
8691	3967	13	give	give	VB
8691	3967	14	no	no	DT
8691	3967	15	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	3967	16	to	to	IN
8691	3967	17	any	any	DT
8691	3967	18	to	to	TO
8691	3967	19	sit	sit	VB
8691	3967	20	there	there	RB
8691	3967	21	to	to	IN
8691	3967	22	-	-	HYPH
8691	3967	23	day	day	NN
8691	3967	24	to	to	TO
8691	3967	25	judge	judge	VB
8691	3967	26	and	and	CC
8691	3967	27	to	to	TO
8691	3967	28	appear	appear	VB
8691	3967	29	to	to	IN
8691	3967	30	-	-	HYPH
8691	3967	31	morrow	morrow	NNP
8691	3967	32	before	before	IN
8691	3967	33	an	an	DT
8691	3967	34	inferior	inferior	JJ
8691	3967	35	court	court	NN
8691	3967	36	to	to	TO
8691	3967	37	argue	argue	VB
8691	3967	38	as	as	IN
8691	3967	39	an	an	DT
8691	3967	40	advocate	advocate	NN
8691	3967	41	.	.	.
8691	3968	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3968	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3968	3	:	:	:
8691	3968	4	Hutchinson	Hutchinson	NNP
8691	3968	5	,	,	,
8691	3968	6	"	"	``
8691	3968	7	History	history	NN
8691	3968	8	of	of	IN
8691	3968	9	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3968	10	,	,	,
8691	3968	11	"	"	''
8691	3968	12	III	III	NNP
8691	3968	13	,	,	,
8691	3968	14	104	104	CD
8691	3968	15	.	.	.
8691	3968	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3969	1	As	as	IN
8691	3969	2	time	time	NN
8691	3969	3	went	go	VBD
8691	3969	4	on	on	RP
8691	3969	5	,	,	,
8691	3969	6	an	an	DT
8691	3969	7	American	American	NNP
8691	3969	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3969	9	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	3969	10	sent	send	VBN
8691	3969	11	to	to	IN
8691	3969	12	London	London	NNP
8691	3969	13	to	to	TO
8691	3969	14	read	read	VB
8691	3969	15	law	law	NN
8691	3969	16	.	.	.
8691	3970	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3970	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3970	3	apt	apt	JJ
8691	3970	4	to	to	TO
8691	3970	5	be	be	VB
8691	3970	6	a	a	DT
8691	3970	7	young	young	JJ
8691	3970	8	man	man	NN
8691	3970	9	of	of	IN
8691	3970	10	fortune	fortune	NNP
8691	3970	11	,	,	,
8691	3970	12	who	who	WP
8691	3970	13	entered	enter	VBD
8691	3970	14	the	the	DT
8691	3970	15	Temple	Temple	NNP
8691	3970	16	or	or	CC
8691	3970	17	the	the	DT
8691	3970	18	Inns	Inns	NNPS
8691	3970	19	of	of	IN
8691	3970	20	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3970	21	more	more	RBR
8691	3970	22	as	as	IN
8691	3970	23	a	a	DT
8691	3970	24	means	means	NN
8691	3970	25	of	of	IN
8691	3970	26	gaining	gain	VBG
8691	3970	27	pleasant	pleasant	JJ
8691	3970	28	acquaintances	acquaintance	NNS
8691	3970	29	than	than	IN
8691	3970	30	for	for	IN
8691	3970	31	any	any	DT
8691	3970	32	serious	serious	JJ
8691	3970	33	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	3970	34	of	of	IN
8691	3970	35	education	education	NN
8691	3970	36	.	.	.
8691	3971	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	3971	2	of	of	IN
8691	3971	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3971	4	came	come	VBD
8691	3971	5	from	from	IN
8691	3971	6	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3971	7	and	and	CC
8691	3971	8	the	the	DT
8691	3971	9	Southern	southern	JJ
8691	3971	10	colonies	colony	NNS
8691	3971	11	.	.	.
8691	3972	1	Two	two	CD
8691	3972	2	Presidents	president	NNS
8691	3972	3	of	of	IN
8691	3972	4	the	the	DT
8691	3972	5	Continental	Continental	NNP
8691	3972	6	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	3972	7	,	,	,
8691	3972	8	Randolph	Randolph	NNP
8691	3972	9	and	and	CC
8691	3972	10	McKean	McKean	NNP
8691	3972	11	,	,	,
8691	3972	12	four	four	CD
8691	3972	13	signers	signer	NNS
8691	3972	14	of	of	IN
8691	3972	15	the	the	DT
8691	3972	16	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
8691	3972	17	of	of	IN
8691	3972	18	Independence	Independence	NNP
8691	3972	19	,	,	,
8691	3972	20	Heyward	Heyward	NNP
8691	3972	21	,	,	,
8691	3972	22	Lynch	Lynch	NNP
8691	3972	23	,	,	,
8691	3972	24	Middleton	Middleton	NNP
8691	3972	25	,	,	,
8691	3972	26	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	3972	27	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
8691	3972	28	,	,	,
8691	3972	29	and	and	CC
8691	3972	30	John	John	NNP
8691	3972	31	Rutledge	Rutledge	NNP
8691	3972	32	,	,	,
8691	3972	33	one	one	CD
8691	3972	34	of	of	IN
8691	3972	35	the	the	DT
8691	3972	36	first	first	JJ
8691	3972	37	associate	associate	JJ
8691	3972	38	justices	justice	NNS
8691	3972	39	of	of	IN
8691	3972	40	the	the	DT
8691	3972	41	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	3972	42	Court	Court	NNP
8691	3972	43	of	of	IN
8691	3972	44	the	the	DT
8691	3972	45	United	United	NNP
8691	3972	46	States	States	NNP
8691	3972	47	,	,	,
8691	3972	48	were	be	VBD
8691	3972	49	of	of	IN
8691	3972	50	the	the	DT
8691	3972	51	number	number	NN
8691	3972	52	.	.	.
8691	3973	1	Not	not	RB
8691	3973	2	infrequently	infrequently	RB
8691	3973	3	there	there	EX
8691	3973	4	were	be	VBD
8691	3973	5	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3973	6	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3973	7	in	in	IN
8691	3973	8	London	London	NNP
8691	3973	9	which	which	WDT
8691	3973	10	concerned	concern	VBD
8691	3973	11	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	3973	12	interests	interest	NNS
8691	3973	13	.	.	.
8691	3974	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3974	2	charters	charter	NNS
8691	3974	3	were	be	VBD
8691	3974	4	attacked	attack	VBN
8691	3974	5	or	or	CC
8691	3974	6	colony	colony	NN
8691	3974	7	laws	law	NNS
8691	3974	8	and	and	CC
8691	3974	9	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	3974	10	put	put	VBN
8691	3974	11	in	in	IN
8691	3974	12	question	question	NN
8691	3974	13	before	before	IN
8691	3974	14	the	the	DT
8691	3974	15	Lords	Lords	NNPS
8691	3974	16	of	of	IN
8691	3974	17	Trade	Trade	NNP
8691	3974	18	and	and	CC
8691	3974	19	Plantations	Plantations	NNP
8691	3974	20	.	.	.
8691	3975	1	In	in	IN
8691	3975	2	such	such	JJ
8691	3975	3	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	3975	4	,	,	,
8691	3975	5	if	if	IN
8691	3975	6	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	3975	7	were	be	VBD
8691	3975	8	needed	need	VBN
8691	3975	9	,	,	,
8691	3975	10	English	english	JJ
8691	3975	11	barristers	barrister	NNS
8691	3975	12	were	be	VBD
8691	3975	13	generally	generally	RB
8691	3975	14	employed	employ	VBN
8691	3975	15	.	.	.
8691	3976	1	An	an	DT
8691	3976	2	American	american	JJ
8691	3976	3	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	3976	4	now	now	RB
8691	3976	5	and	and	CC
8691	3976	6	then	then	RB
8691	3976	7	went	go	VBD
8691	3976	8	over	over	RP
8691	3976	9	to	to	TO
8691	3976	10	consult	consult	VB
8691	3976	11	with	with	IN
8691	3976	12	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3976	13	and	and	CC
8691	3976	14	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	3976	15	to	to	TO
8691	3976	16	join	join	VB
8691	3976	17	in	in	IN
8691	3976	18	the	the	DT
8691	3976	19	argument	argument	NN
8691	3976	20	,	,	,
8691	3976	21	but	but	CC
8691	3976	22	the	the	DT
8691	3976	23	leading	leading	JJ
8691	3976	24	part	part	NN
8691	3976	25	was	be	VBD
8691	3976	26	theirs	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3976	27	.	.	.
8691	3977	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3977	2	was	be	VBD
8691	3977	3	not	not	RB
8691	3977	4	until	until	IN
8691	3977	5	the	the	DT
8691	3977	6	quickening	quicken	VBG
8691	3977	7	and	and	CC
8691	3977	8	deepening	deepening	NN
8691	3977	9	of	of	IN
8691	3977	10	American	american	JJ
8691	3977	11	life	life	NN
8691	3977	12	which	which	WDT
8691	3977	13	preceded	precede	VBD
8691	3977	14	and	and	CC
8691	3977	15	portended	portend	VBD
8691	3977	16	the	the	DT
8691	3977	17	Revolution	Revolution	NNP
8691	3977	18	that	that	IN
8691	3977	19	anything	anything	NN
8691	3977	20	like	like	IN
8691	3977	21	a	a	DT
8691	3977	22	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	3977	23	bar	bar	NN
8691	3977	24	,	,	,
8691	3977	25	led	lead	VBN
8691	3977	26	by	by	IN
8691	3977	27	a	a	DT
8691	3977	28	man	man	NN
8691	3977	29	of	of	IN
8691	3977	30	learning	learning	NN
8691	3977	31	and	and	CC
8691	3977	32	position	position	NN
8691	3977	33	,	,	,
8691	3977	34	really	really	RB
8691	3977	35	came	come	VBD
8691	3977	36	into	into	IN
8691	3977	37	existence	existence	NN
8691	3977	38	.	.	.
8691	3978	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3978	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3978	3	:	:	:
8691	3978	4	"	"	``
8691	3978	5	Two	two	CD
8691	3978	6	Centuries	Centuries	NNPS
8691	3978	7	'	'	POS
8691	3978	8	Growth	Growth	NNP
8691	3978	9	of	of	IN
8691	3978	10	American	American	NNP
8691	3978	11	Law	Law	NNP
8691	3978	12	,	,	,
8691	3978	13	"	"	''
8691	3978	14	16	16	CD
8691	3978	15	.	.	.
8691	3978	16	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3979	1	From	from	IN
8691	3979	2	the	the	DT
8691	3979	3	middle	middle	NN
8691	3979	4	of	of	IN
8691	3979	5	the	the	DT
8691	3979	6	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
8691	3979	7	century	century	NN
8691	3979	8	to	to	IN
8691	3979	9	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3979	10	close	close	NN
8691	3979	11	there	there	EX
8691	3979	12	was	be	VBD
8691	3979	13	a	a	DT
8691	3979	14	steady	steady	JJ
8691	3979	15	and	and	CC
8691	3979	16	rapid	rapid	JJ
8691	3979	17	progress	progress	NN
8691	3979	18	in	in	IN
8691	3979	19	this	this	DT
8691	3979	20	direction	direction	NN
8691	3979	21	.	.	.
8691	3980	1	Legal	legal	JJ
8691	3980	2	education	education	NN
8691	3980	3	was	be	VBD
8691	3980	4	taken	take	VBN
8691	3980	5	seriously	seriously	RB
8691	3980	6	.	.	.
8691	3981	1	In	in	IN
8691	3981	2	the	the	DT
8691	3981	3	case	case	NN
8691	3981	4	of	of	IN
8691	3981	5	many	many	JJ
8691	3981	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3981	7	began	begin	VBD
8691	3981	8	with	with	IN
8691	3981	9	the	the	DT
8691	3981	10	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	3981	11	notions	notion	NNS
8691	3981	12	of	of	IN
8691	3981	13	justice	justice	NN
8691	3981	14	and	and	CC
8691	3981	15	right	right	NN
8691	3981	16	.	.	.
8691	3982	1	The	the	DT
8691	3982	2	Greek	greek	JJ
8691	3982	3	and	and	CC
8691	3982	4	Latin	latin	JJ
8691	3982	5	classics	classic	NNS
8691	3982	6	on	on	IN
8691	3982	7	those	those	DT
8691	3982	8	heads	head	NNS
8691	3982	9	were	be	VBD
8691	3982	10	read	read	VBN
8691	3982	11	.	.	.
8691	3983	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3983	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3983	3	:	:	:
8691	3983	4	"	"	``
8691	3983	5	Life	Life	NNP
8691	3983	6	of	of	IN
8691	3983	7	Peter	Peter	NNP
8691	3983	8	Van	Van	NNP
8691	3983	9	Schaick	Schaick	NNP
8691	3983	10	,	,	,
8691	3983	11	"	"	''
8691	3983	12	9	9	CD
8691	3983	13	.	.	.
8691	3983	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3984	1	The	the	DT
8691	3984	2	private	private	JJ
8691	3984	3	law	law	NN
8691	3984	4	of	of	IN
8691	3984	5	the	the	DT
8691	3984	6	Romans	Romans	NNPS
8691	3984	7	was	be	VBD
8691	3984	8	studied	study	VBN
8691	3984	9	to	to	IN
8691	3984	10	a	a	DT
8691	3984	11	greater	great	JJR
8691	3984	12	extent	extent	NN
8691	3984	13	relatively	relatively	RB
8691	3984	14	than	than	IN
8691	3984	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3984	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	3984	17	now	now	RB
8691	3984	18	.	.	.
8691	3985	1	The	the	DT
8691	3985	2	first	first	JJ
8691	3985	3	chair	chair	NN
8691	3985	4	of	of	IN
8691	3985	5	law	law	NN
8691	3985	6	in	in	IN
8691	3985	7	the	the	DT
8691	3985	8	United	United	NNP
8691	3985	9	States	States	NNP
8691	3985	10	was	be	VBD
8691	3985	11	established	establish	VBN
8691	3985	12	at	at	IN
8691	3985	13	William	William	NNP
8691	3985	14	and	and	CC
8691	3985	15	Mary	Mary	NNP
8691	3985	16	College	College	NNP
8691	3985	17	in	in	IN
8691	3985	18	1779	1779	CD
8691	3985	19	,	,	,
8691	3985	20	and	and	CC
8691	3985	21	there	there	RB
8691	3985	22	,	,	,
8691	3985	23	under	under	IN
8691	3985	24	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	3985	25	Wythe	Wythe	NNP
8691	3985	26	,	,	,
8691	3985	27	John	John	NNP
8691	3985	28	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	3985	29	was	be	VBD
8691	3985	30	a	a	DT
8691	3985	31	student	student	NN
8691	3985	32	.	.	.
8691	3986	1	President	President	NNP
8691	3986	2	Stiles	Stiles	NNP
8691	3986	3	of	of	IN
8691	3986	4	Yale	Yale	NNP
8691	3986	5	,	,	,
8691	3986	6	in	in	IN
8691	3986	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3986	8	"	"	``
8691	3986	9	Literary	Literary	NNP
8691	3986	10	Diary	Diary	NNP
8691	3986	11	,	,	,
8691	3986	12	"	"	''
8691	3986	13	so	so	RB
8691	3986	14	full	full	JJ
8691	3986	15	of	of	IN
8691	3986	16	that	that	DT
8691	3986	17	kind	kind	NN
8691	3986	18	of	of	IN
8691	3986	19	historical	historical	JJ
8691	3986	20	incident	incident	NN
8691	3986	21	which	which	WDT
8691	3986	22	after	after	IN
8691	3986	23	a	a	DT
8691	3986	24	few	few	JJ
8691	3986	25	years	year	NNS
8691	3986	26	have	have	VBP
8691	3986	27	passed	pass	VBN
8691	3986	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3986	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	3986	30	most	most	RBS
8691	3986	31	difficult	difficult	JJ
8691	3986	32	to	to	TO
8691	3986	33	trace	trace	VB
8691	3986	34	,	,	,
8691	3986	35	enumerates	enumerate	VBZ
8691	3986	36	the	the	DT
8691	3986	37	books	book	NNS
8691	3986	38	read	read	VBN
8691	3986	39	by	by	IN
8691	3986	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3986	41	son	son	NN
8691	3986	42	,	,	,
8691	3986	43	Ezra	Ezra	NNP
8691	3986	44	Stiles	Stiles	NNP
8691	3986	45	,	,	,
8691	3986	46	Jr.	Jr.	NNP
8691	3986	47	,	,	,
8691	3986	48	between	between	IN
8691	3986	49	1778	1778	CD
8691	3986	50	and	and	CC
8691	3986	51	1781	1781	CD
8691	3986	52	,	,	,
8691	3986	53	in	in	IN
8691	3986	54	preparation	preparation	NN
8691	3986	55	for	for	IN
8691	3986	56	the	the	DT
8691	3986	57	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	3986	58	bar	bar	NN
8691	3986	59	,	,	,
8691	3986	60	under	under	IN
8691	3986	61	the	the	DT
8691	3986	62	advice	advice	NN
8691	3986	63	and	and	CC
8691	3986	64	in	in	IN
8691	3986	65	the	the	DT
8691	3986	66	offices	office	NNS
8691	3986	67	of	of	IN
8691	3986	68	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	3986	69	Parker	Parker	NNP
8691	3986	70	of	of	IN
8691	3986	71	Portsmouth	Portsmouth	NNP
8691	3986	72	and	and	CC
8691	3986	73	Charles	Charles	NNP
8691	3986	74	Chauncey	Chauncey	NNP
8691	3986	75	of	of	IN
8691	3986	76	New	New	NNP
8691	3986	77	Haven	Haven	NNP
8691	3986	78	.	.	.
8691	3987	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3987	2	comprehended	comprehend	VBD
8691	3987	3	,	,	,
8691	3987	4	besides	besides	IN
8691	3987	5	much	much	JJ
8691	3987	6	in	in	IN
8691	3987	7	English	English	NNP
8691	3987	8	and	and	CC
8691	3987	9	Scotch	Scotch	NNP
8691	3987	10	law	law	NN
8691	3987	11	,	,	,
8691	3987	12	Burlamaqui	Burlamaqui	NNP
8691	3987	13	's	's	POS
8691	3987	14	_	_	NNP
8691	3987	15	Principes	Principes	NNP
8691	3987	16	de	de	NNP
8691	3987	17	Droit	Droit	NNP
8691	3987	18	Naturel	Naturel	NNP
8691	3987	19	_	_	NNP
8691	3987	20	,	,	,
8691	3987	21	Montesquieu	Montesquieu	NNP
8691	3987	22	,	,	,
8691	3987	23	_	_	NNP
8691	3987	24	de	de	IN
8691	3987	25	l'Esprit	l'Esprit	NNP
8691	3987	26	des	des	FW
8691	3987	27	Lois	Lois	NNP
8691	3987	28	_	_	NNP
8691	3987	29	,	,	,
8691	3987	30	the	the	DT
8691	3987	31	Institutes	Institutes	NNPS
8691	3987	32	of	of	IN
8691	3987	33	Justinian	Justinian	NNP
8691	3987	34	,	,	,
8691	3987	35	certain	certain	JJ
8691	3987	36	titles	title	NNS
8691	3987	37	of	of	IN
8691	3987	38	the	the	DT
8691	3987	39	Pandects	Pandects	NNPS
8691	3987	40	,	,	,
8691	3987	41	and	and	CC
8691	3987	42	Puffendorf	Puffendorf	NNP
8691	3987	43	_	_	NNP
8691	3987	44	de	de	NNP
8691	3987	45	Officio	Officio	NNP
8691	3987	46	Hominis	Hominis	NNP
8691	3987	47	et	et	FW
8691	3987	48	Civis	Civis	NNP
8691	3987	49	juxta	juxta	NN
8691	3987	50	Legem	Legem	NNP
8691	3987	51	Naturalem	Naturalem	NNP
8691	3987	52	_	_	NNP
8691	3987	53	.	.	.
8691	3988	1	James	James	NNP
8691	3988	2	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	3988	3	at	at	IN
8691	3988	4	about	about	IN
8691	3988	5	the	the	DT
8691	3988	6	same	same	JJ
8691	3988	7	time	time	NN
8691	3988	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3988	9	reading	read	VBG
8691	3988	10	Grotius	Grotius	NNP
8691	3988	11	and	and	CC
8691	3988	12	Puffendorf	Puffendorf	NNP
8691	3988	13	in	in	IN
8691	3988	14	the	the	DT
8691	3988	15	office	office	NN
8691	3988	16	of	of	IN
8691	3988	17	the	the	DT
8691	3988	18	Attorney	Attorney	NNP
8691	3988	19	-	-	HYPH
8691	3988	20	General	General	NNP
8691	3988	21	of	of	IN
8691	3988	22	New	New	NNP
8691	3988	23	York	York	NNP
8691	3988	24	,	,	,
8691	3988	25	and	and	CC
8691	3988	26	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	3988	27	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
8691	3988	28	,	,	,
8691	3988	29	under	under	IN
8691	3988	30	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	3988	31	Lansing	Lansing	NNP
8691	3988	32	,	,	,
8691	3988	33	explored	explore	VBD
8691	3988	34	all	all	DT
8691	3988	35	parts	part	NNS
8691	3988	36	of	of	IN
8691	3988	37	the	the	DT
8691	3988	38	_	_	NNP
8691	3988	39	Corpus	Corpus	NNP
8691	3988	40	Juris	Juris	NNP
8691	3988	41	Civilis	Civilis	NNP
8691	3988	42	_	_	NNP
8691	3988	43	.	.	.
8691	3989	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3989	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3989	3	:	:	:
8691	3989	4	Hunt	Hunt	NNP
8691	3989	5	,	,	,
8691	3989	6	"	"	''
8691	3989	7	Life	Life	NNP
8691	3989	8	of	of	IN
8691	3989	9	Edward	Edward	NNP
8691	3989	10	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
8691	3989	11	,	,	,
8691	3989	12	"	"	``
8691	3989	13	41	41	CD
8691	3989	14	.	.	.
8691	3989	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3990	1	John	John	NNP
8691	3990	2	Quincy	Quincy	NNP
8691	3990	3	Adams	Adams	NNP
8691	3990	4	a	a	DT
8691	3990	5	few	few	JJ
8691	3990	6	years	year	NNS
8691	3990	7	later	later	RB
8691	3990	8	,	,	,
8691	3990	9	under	under	IN
8691	3990	10	the	the	DT
8691	3990	11	instruction	instruction	NN
8691	3990	12	of	of	IN
8691	3990	13	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	3990	14	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3990	15	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
8691	3990	16	of	of	IN
8691	3990	17	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	3990	18	,	,	,
8691	3990	19	took	take	VBD
8691	3990	20	up	up	RP
8691	3990	21	Vattel	Vattel	NNP
8691	3990	22	and	and	CC
8691	3990	23	the	the	DT
8691	3990	24	Institutes	Institutes	NNPS
8691	3990	25	of	of	IN
8691	3990	26	Justinian	Justinian	NNP
8691	3990	27	.	.	.
8691	3991	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3991	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3991	3	:	:	:
8691	3991	4	Report	report	NN
8691	3991	5	of	of	IN
8691	3991	6	the	the	DT
8691	3991	7	American	American	NNP
8691	3991	8	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	3991	9	Association	Association	NNP
8691	3991	10	for	for	IN
8691	3991	11	1903	1903	CD
8691	3991	12	,	,	,
8691	3991	13	675	675	CD
8691	3991	14	,	,	,
8691	3991	15	note	note	NN
8691	3991	16	.	.	.
8691	3991	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3992	1	The	the	DT
8691	3992	2	latter	latter	JJ
8691	3992	3	,	,	,
8691	3992	4	as	as	RB
8691	3992	5	well	well	RB
8691	3992	6	as	as	IN
8691	3992	7	Van	Van	NNP
8691	3992	8	Muyden	Muyden	NNP
8691	3992	9	's	's	POS
8691	3992	10	_	_	NNP
8691	3992	11	Compendiosa	Compendiosa	NNP
8691	3992	12	Tractatio	Tractatio	NNP
8691	3992	13	_	_	NNP
8691	3992	14	of	of	IN
8691	3992	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3992	16	,	,	,
8691	3992	17	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3992	18	father	father	NN
8691	3992	19	had	have	VBD
8691	3992	20	studied	study	VBN
8691	3992	21	in	in	IN
8691	3992	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	3992	23	preparation	preparation	NN
8691	3992	24	for	for	IN
8691	3992	25	the	the	DT
8691	3992	26	bar	bar	NN
8691	3992	27	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	3992	28	years	year	NNS
8691	3992	29	before	before	RB
8691	3992	30	.	.	.
8691	3993	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3993	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3993	3	:	:	:
8691	3993	4	"	"	``
8691	3993	5	Life	Life	NNP
8691	3993	6	and	and	CC
8691	3993	7	Works	Works	NNP
8691	3993	8	of	of	IN
8691	3993	9	John	John	NNP
8691	3993	10	Adams	Adams	NNP
8691	3993	11	,	,	,
8691	3993	12	"	"	``
8691	3993	13	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	3993	14	,	,	,
8691	3993	15	46	46	CD
8691	3993	16	.	.	.
8691	3993	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	3994	1	The	the	DT
8691	3994	2	lectures	lecture	NNS
8691	3994	3	of	of	IN
8691	3994	4	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	3994	5	Wythe	Wythe	NNP
8691	3994	6	at	at	IN
8691	3994	7	William	William	NNP
8691	3994	8	and	and	CC
8691	3994	9	Mary	Mary	NNP
8691	3994	10	,	,	,
8691	3994	11	like	like	IN
8691	3994	12	those	those	DT
8691	3994	13	of	of	IN
8691	3994	14	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	3994	15	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	3994	16	Wilson	Wilson	NNP
8691	3994	17	in	in	IN
8691	3994	18	1790	1790	CD
8691	3994	19	at	at	IN
8691	3994	20	the	the	DT
8691	3994	21	University	University	NNP
8691	3994	22	of	of	IN
8691	3994	23	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	3994	24	and	and	CC
8691	3994	25	of	of	IN
8691	3994	26	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	3994	27	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	3994	28	in	in	IN
8691	3994	29	1794	1794	CD
8691	3994	30	at	at	IN
8691	3994	31	Columbia	Columbia	NNP
8691	3994	32	,	,	,
8691	3994	33	were	be	VBD
8691	3994	34	designed	design	VBN
8691	3994	35	,	,	,
8691	3994	36	as	as	IN
8691	3994	37	were	be	VBD
8691	3994	38	Blackstone	Blackstone	NNP
8691	3994	39	's	's	POS
8691	3994	40	at	at	IN
8691	3994	41	Oxford	Oxford	NNP
8691	3994	42	,	,	,
8691	3994	43	to	to	TO
8691	3994	44	give	give	VB
8691	3994	45	such	such	JJ
8691	3994	46	information	information	NN
8691	3994	47	as	as	IN
8691	3994	48	to	to	IN
8691	3994	49	the	the	DT
8691	3994	50	nature	nature	NN
8691	3994	51	and	and	CC
8691	3994	52	principles	principle	NNS
8691	3994	53	of	of	IN
8691	3994	54	law	law	NN
8691	3994	55	as	as	IN
8691	3994	56	might	may	MD
8691	3994	57	be	be	VB
8691	3994	58	of	of	IN
8691	3994	59	service	service	NN
8691	3994	60	to	to	IN
8691	3994	61	any	any	DT
8691	3994	62	one	one	CD
8691	3994	63	desirous	desirous	JJ
8691	3994	64	of	of	IN
8691	3994	65	acquiring	acquire	VBG
8691	3994	66	a	a	DT
8691	3994	67	liberal	liberal	JJ
8691	3994	68	education	education	NN
8691	3994	69	.	.	.
8691	3995	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	3995	2	instruction	instruction	NN
8691	3995	3	could	could	MD
8691	3995	4	not	not	RB
8691	3995	5	be	be	VB
8691	3995	6	considered	consider	VBN
8691	3995	7	as	as	IN
8691	3995	8	anything	anything	NN
8691	3995	9	approaching	approach	VBG
8691	3995	10	a	a	DT
8691	3995	11	proper	proper	JJ
8691	3995	12	preparation	preparation	NN
8691	3995	13	for	for	IN
8691	3995	14	entering	enter	VBG
8691	3995	15	on	on	IN
8691	3995	16	the	the	DT
8691	3995	17	practice	practice	NN
8691	3995	18	of	of	IN
8691	3995	19	the	the	DT
8691	3995	20	legal	legal	JJ
8691	3995	21	profession	profession	NN
8691	3995	22	.	.	.
8691	3996	1	The	the	DT
8691	3996	2	United	United	NNP
8691	3996	3	States	States	NNP
8691	3996	4	preceded	precede	VBD
8691	3996	5	England	England	NNP
8691	3996	6	in	in	IN
8691	3996	7	the	the	DT
8691	3996	8	endeavor	endeavor	NN
8691	3996	9	to	to	TO
8691	3996	10	provide	provide	VB
8691	3996	11	such	such	PDT
8691	3996	12	a	a	DT
8691	3996	13	preparation	preparation	NN
8691	3996	14	by	by	IN
8691	3996	15	a	a	DT
8691	3996	16	systematic	systematic	JJ
8691	3996	17	course	course	NN
8691	3996	18	of	of	IN
8691	3996	19	study	study	NN
8691	3996	20	pursued	pursue	VBN
8691	3996	21	under	under	IN
8691	3996	22	competent	competent	JJ
8691	3996	23	teachers	teacher	NNS
8691	3996	24	at	at	IN
8691	3996	25	a	a	DT
8691	3996	26	seat	seat	NN
8691	3996	27	of	of	IN
8691	3996	28	learning	learn	VBG
8691	3996	29	established	establish	VBN
8691	3996	30	for	for	IN
8691	3996	31	that	that	DT
8691	3996	32	sole	sole	JJ
8691	3996	33	purpose	purpose	NN
8691	3996	34	.	.	.
8691	3997	1	The	the	DT
8691	3997	2	need	need	NN
8691	3997	3	of	of	IN
8691	3997	4	something	something	NN
8691	3997	5	of	of	IN
8691	3997	6	the	the	DT
8691	3997	7	kind	kind	NN
8691	3997	8	was	be	VBD
8691	3997	9	felt	feel	VBN
8691	3997	10	to	to	TO
8691	3997	11	be	be	VB
8691	3997	12	pressing	press	VBG
8691	3997	13	after	after	IN
8691	3997	14	the	the	DT
8691	3997	15	independence	independence	NN
8691	3997	16	of	of	IN
8691	3997	17	the	the	DT
8691	3997	18	United	United	NNP
8691	3997	19	States	States	NNP
8691	3997	20	had	have	VBD
8691	3997	21	been	be	VBN
8691	3997	22	fully	fully	RB
8691	3997	23	established	establish	VBN
8691	3997	24	.	.	.
8691	3998	1	An	an	DT
8691	3998	2	unusual	unusual	JJ
8691	3998	3	number	number	NN
8691	3998	4	of	of	IN
8691	3998	5	young	young	JJ
8691	3998	6	men	man	NNS
8691	3998	7	of	of	IN
8691	3998	8	promise	promise	NN
8691	3998	9	were	be	VBD
8691	3998	10	turning	turn	VBG
8691	3998	11	from	from	IN
8691	3998	12	the	the	DT
8691	3998	13	army	army	NN
8691	3998	14	to	to	IN
8691	3998	15	the	the	DT
8691	3998	16	bar	bar	NN
8691	3998	17	.	.	.
8691	3999	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	3999	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	3999	3	:	:	:
8691	3999	4	"	"	``
8691	3999	5	Memoirs	Memoirs	NNPS
8691	3999	6	of	of	IN
8691	3999	7	James	James	NNP
8691	3999	8	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	3999	9	,	,	,
8691	3999	10	"	"	''
8691	3999	11	31	31	CD
8691	3999	12	.	.	.
8691	4000	1	In	in	IN
8691	4000	2	1788	1788	CD
8691	4000	3	,	,	,
8691	4000	4	the	the	DT
8691	4000	5	number	number	NN
8691	4000	6	of	of	IN
8691	4000	7	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	4000	8	in	in	IN
8691	4000	9	the	the	DT
8691	4000	10	State	State	NNP
8691	4000	11	of	of	IN
8691	4000	12	New	New	NNP
8691	4000	13	York	York	NNP
8691	4000	14	had	have	VBD
8691	4000	15	risen	rise	VBN
8691	4000	16	to	to	IN
8691	4000	17	120	120	CD
8691	4000	18	.	.	.
8691	4001	1	Morse	Morse	NNP
8691	4001	2	's	's	POS
8691	4001	3	"	"	``
8691	4001	4	American	American	NNP
8691	4001	5	Geography	Geography	NNP
8691	4001	6	,	,	,
8691	4001	7	"	"	''
8691	4001	8	ed	ed	NN
8691	4001	9	.	.	.
8691	4002	1	1796	1796	CD
8691	4002	2	,	,	,
8691	4002	3	506	506	CD
8691	4002	4	.	.	.
8691	4003	1	Thirty	thirty	CD
8691	4003	2	years	year	NNS
8691	4003	3	later	later	RB
8691	4003	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4003	5	was	be	VBD
8691	4003	6	1,200	1,200	CD
8691	4003	7	.	.	.
8691	4004	1	Miles	Miles	NNP
8691	4004	2	'	'	POS
8691	4004	3	"	"	``
8691	4004	4	Register	Register	NNP
8691	4004	5	,	,	,
8691	4004	6	"	"	''
8691	4004	7	XIV	xiv	NN
8691	4004	8	,	,	,
8691	4004	9	311	311	CD
8691	4004	10	.	.	.
8691	4004	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4005	1	Those	those	DT
8691	4005	2	already	already	RB
8691	4005	3	members	member	NNS
8691	4005	4	of	of	IN
8691	4005	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4005	6	had	have	VBD
8691	4005	7	educated	educate	VBN
8691	4005	8	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4005	9	as	as	IN
8691	4005	10	best	best	RB
8691	4005	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4005	12	could	could	MD
8691	4005	13	,	,	,
8691	4005	14	with	with	IN
8691	4005	15	slight	slight	JJ
8691	4005	16	assistance	assistance	NN
8691	4005	17	from	from	IN
8691	4005	18	the	the	DT
8691	4005	19	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4005	20	in	in	IN
8691	4005	21	whose	whose	WP$
8691	4005	22	offices	office	NNS
8691	4005	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4005	24	had	have	VBD
8691	4005	25	studied	study	VBN
8691	4005	26	.	.	.
8691	4006	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4006	2	in	in	IN
8691	4006	3	turn	turn	NN
8691	4006	4	were	be	VBD
8691	4006	5	indisposed	indisposed	JJ
8691	4006	6	to	to	TO
8691	4006	7	do	do	VB
8691	4006	8	more	more	JJR
8691	4006	9	for	for	IN
8691	4006	10	such	such	JJ
8691	4006	11	as	as	IN
8691	4006	12	might	may	MD
8691	4006	13	desire	desire	VB
8691	4006	14	to	to	TO
8691	4006	15	read	read	VB
8691	4006	16	law	law	NN
8691	4006	17	in	in	IN
8691	4006	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4006	19	offices	office	NNS
8691	4006	20	.	.	.
8691	4007	1	Few	few	JJ
8691	4007	2	of	of	IN
8691	4007	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4007	4	were	be	VBD
8691	4007	5	competent	competent	JJ
8691	4007	6	to	to	TO
8691	4007	7	do	do	VB
8691	4007	8	much	much	RB
8691	4007	9	.	.	.
8691	4008	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4008	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4008	3	:	:	:
8691	4008	4	See	see	VB
8691	4008	5	"	"	''
8691	4008	6	Life	Life	NNP
8691	4008	7	of	of	IN
8691	4008	8	Peter	Peter	NNP
8691	4008	9	Van	Van	NNP
8691	4008	10	Schaick	Schaick	NNP
8691	4008	11	,	,	,
8691	4008	12	"	"	``
8691	4008	13	9	9	CD
8691	4008	14	,	,	,
8691	4008	15	13	13	CD
8691	4008	16	.	.	.
8691	4008	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4009	1	There	there	EX
8691	4009	2	was	be	VBD
8691	4009	3	a	a	DT
8691	4009	4	demand	demand	NN
8691	4009	5	for	for	IN
8691	4009	6	a	a	DT
8691	4009	7	professed	professed	JJ
8691	4009	8	school	school	NN
8691	4009	9	of	of	IN
8691	4009	10	law	law	NN
8691	4009	11	,	,	,
8691	4009	12	and	and	CC
8691	4009	13	in	in	IN
8691	4009	14	1784	1784	CD
8691	4009	15	the	the	DT
8691	4009	16	first	first	JJ
8691	4009	17	in	in	IN
8691	4009	18	any	any	DT
8691	4009	19	English	English	NNP
8691	4009	20	-	-	HYPH
8691	4009	21	speaking	speak	VBG
8691	4009	22	country	country	NN
8691	4009	23	was	be	VBD
8691	4009	24	opened	open	VBN
8691	4009	25	at	at	IN
8691	4009	26	Litchfield	Litchfield	NNP
8691	4009	27	,	,	,
8691	4009	28	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	4009	29	.	.	.
8691	4010	1	There	there	EX
8691	4010	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4010	3	now	now	RB
8691	4010	4	104	104	CD
8691	4010	5	of	of	IN
8691	4010	6	them,[Footnote	them,[Footnote	NNP
8691	4010	7	:	:	:
8691	4010	8	Report	report	NN
8691	4010	9	of	of	IN
8691	4010	10	the	the	DT
8691	4010	11	American	American	NNP
8691	4010	12	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	4010	13	Association	Association	NNP
8691	4010	14	for	for	IN
8691	4010	15	1903	1903	CD
8691	4010	16	,	,	,
8691	4010	17	p.	p.	NN
8691	4011	1	398	398	CD
8691	4011	2	.	.	.
8691	4011	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4012	1	with	with	IN
8691	4012	2	a	a	DT
8691	4012	3	total	total	JJ
8691	4012	4	attendance	attendance	NN
8691	4012	5	of	of	IN
8691	4012	6	over	over	IN
8691	4012	7	fourteen	fourteen	CD
8691	4012	8	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	4012	9	students	student	NNS
8691	4012	10	.	.	.
8691	4013	1	The	the	DT
8691	4013	2	course	course	NN
8691	4013	3	of	of	IN
8691	4013	4	study	study	NN
8691	4013	5	in	in	IN
8691	4013	6	a	a	DT
8691	4013	7	few	few	JJ
8691	4013	8	may	may	MD
8691	4013	9	be	be	VB
8691	4013	10	completed	complete	VBN
8691	4013	11	in	in	IN
8691	4013	12	one	one	CD
8691	4013	13	year	year	NN
8691	4013	14	;	;	:
8691	4013	15	in	in	IN
8691	4013	16	most	most	JJS
8691	4013	17	two	two	CD
8691	4013	18	are	be	VBP
8691	4013	19	required	require	VBN
8691	4013	20	;	;	:
8691	4013	21	in	in	IN
8691	4013	22	the	the	DT
8691	4013	23	rest	rest	NN
8691	4013	24	three	three	CD
8691	4013	25	,	,	,
8691	4013	26	with	with	IN
8691	4013	27	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	4013	28	an	an	DT
8691	4013	29	offer	offer	NN
8691	4013	30	of	of	IN
8691	4013	31	a	a	DT
8691	4013	32	fourth	fourth	JJ
8691	4013	33	for	for	IN
8691	4013	34	advanced	advanced	JJ
8691	4013	35	instruction	instruction	NN
8691	4013	36	leading	lead	VBG
8691	4013	37	to	to	IN
8691	4013	38	the	the	DT
8691	4013	39	degree	degree	NN
8691	4013	40	of	of	IN
8691	4013	41	master	master	NN
8691	4013	42	or	or	CC
8691	4013	43	doctor	doctor	NN
8691	4013	44	of	of	IN
8691	4013	45	laws	law	NNS
8691	4013	46	.	.	.
8691	4014	1	The	the	DT
8691	4014	2	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	4014	3	degree	degree	NN
8691	4014	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	4014	5	that	that	DT
8691	4014	6	of	of	IN
8691	4014	7	bachelor	bachelor	NN
8691	4014	8	of	of	IN
8691	4014	9	laws	law	NNS
8691	4014	10	(	(	-LRB-
8691	4014	11	LL.B.	LL.B.	NNP
8691	4014	12	)	)	-RRB-
8691	4014	13	.	.	.
8691	4015	1	The	the	DT
8691	4015	2	American	American	NNP
8691	4015	3	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	4015	4	Association	Association	NNP
8691	4015	5	has	have	VBZ
8691	4015	6	had	have	VBN
8691	4015	7	an	an	DT
8691	4015	8	important	important	JJ
8691	4015	9	influence	influence	NN
8691	4015	10	from	from	IN
8691	4015	11	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4015	12	first	first	JJ
8691	4015	13	organization	organization	NN
8691	4015	14	,	,	,
8691	4015	15	in	in	IN
8691	4015	16	1877	1877	CD
8691	4015	17	,	,	,
8691	4015	18	in	in	IN
8691	4015	19	prolonging	prolong	VBG
8691	4015	20	the	the	DT
8691	4015	21	period	period	NN
8691	4015	22	and	and	CC
8691	4015	23	raising	raise	VBG
8691	4015	24	the	the	DT
8691	4015	25	standards	standard	NNS
8691	4015	26	of	of	IN
8691	4015	27	legal	legal	JJ
8691	4015	28	education	education	NN
8691	4015	29	.	.	.
8691	4016	1	In	in	IN
8691	4016	2	affiliation	affiliation	NN
8691	4016	3	with	with	IN
8691	4016	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4016	5	there	there	EX
8691	4016	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	4016	7	an	an	DT
8691	4016	8	"	"	``
8691	4016	9	Association	Association	NNP
8691	4016	10	of	of	IN
8691	4016	11	American	American	NNP
8691	4016	12	Law	Law	NNP
8691	4016	13	Schools	Schools	NNP
8691	4016	14	,	,	,
8691	4016	15	"	"	''
8691	4016	16	representing	represent	VBG
8691	4016	17	a	a	DT
8691	4016	18	large	large	JJ
8691	4016	19	majority	majority	NN
8691	4016	20	of	of	IN
8691	4016	21	the	the	DT
8691	4016	22	teachers	teacher	NNS
8691	4016	23	and	and	CC
8691	4016	24	students	student	NNS
8691	4016	25	engaged	engage	VBD
8691	4016	26	in	in	IN
8691	4016	27	law	law	NN
8691	4016	28	school	school	NN
8691	4016	29	work	work	NN
8691	4016	30	.	.	.
8691	4017	1	This	this	DT
8691	4017	2	admits	admit	VBZ
8691	4017	3	no	no	DT
8691	4017	4	institution	institution	NN
8691	4017	5	into	into	IN
8691	4017	6	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4017	7	ranks	rank	NNS
8691	4017	8	at	at	IN
8691	4017	9	which	which	WDT
8691	4017	10	students	student	NNS
8691	4017	11	are	be	VBP
8691	4017	12	received	receive	VBN
8691	4017	13	without	without	IN
8691	4017	14	a	a	DT
8691	4017	15	preliminary	preliminary	JJ
8691	4017	16	education	education	NN
8691	4017	17	at	at	IN
8691	4017	18	least	least	JJS
8691	4017	19	equal	equal	JJ
8691	4017	20	to	to	IN
8691	4017	21	that	that	DT
8691	4017	22	given	give	VBN
8691	4017	23	by	by	IN
8691	4017	24	the	the	DT
8691	4017	25	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	4017	26	high	high	JJ
8691	4017	27	school	school	NN
8691	4017	28	.	.	.
8691	4018	1	A	a	DT
8691	4018	2	few	few	JJ
8691	4018	3	of	of	IN
8691	4018	4	the	the	DT
8691	4018	5	schools	school	NNS
8691	4018	6	so	so	RB
8691	4018	7	associated	associated	JJ
8691	4018	8	receive	receive	VBP
8691	4018	9	no	no	DT
8691	4018	10	student	student	NN
8691	4018	11	,	,	,
8691	4018	12	save	save	VB
8691	4018	13	in	in	IN
8691	4018	14	exceptional	exceptional	JJ
8691	4018	15	cases	case	NNS
8691	4018	16	,	,	,
8691	4018	17	unless	unless	IN
8691	4018	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4018	19	already	already	RB
8691	4018	20	holds	hold	VBZ
8691	4018	21	a	a	DT
8691	4018	22	degree	degree	NN
8691	4018	23	in	in	IN
8691	4018	24	arts	art	NNS
8691	4018	25	,	,	,
8691	4018	26	science	science	NN
8691	4018	27	,	,	,
8691	4018	28	philosophy	philosophy	NN
8691	4018	29	,	,	,
8691	4018	30	or	or	CC
8691	4018	31	letters	letter	NNS
8691	4018	32	from	from	IN
8691	4018	33	some	some	DT
8691	4018	34	collegiate	collegiate	JJ
8691	4018	35	institution	institution	NN
8691	4018	36	.	.	.
8691	4019	1	In	in	IN
8691	4019	2	several	several	JJ
8691	4019	3	of	of	IN
8691	4019	4	the	the	DT
8691	4019	5	States	States	NNPS
8691	4019	6	having	have	VBG
8691	4019	7	boards	board	NNS
8691	4019	8	of	of	IN
8691	4019	9	State	state	NN
8691	4019	10	examiners	examiner	NNS
8691	4019	11	no	no	DT
8691	4019	12	one	one	NN
8691	4019	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	4019	14	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	4019	15	to	to	IN
8691	4019	16	the	the	DT
8691	4019	17	final	final	JJ
8691	4019	18	examination	examination	NN
8691	4019	19	before	before	IN
8691	4019	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4019	21	who	who	WP
8691	4019	22	did	do	VBD
8691	4019	23	not	not	RB
8691	4019	24	prior	prior	RB
8691	4019	25	to	to	IN
8691	4019	26	the	the	DT
8691	4019	27	beginning	beginning	NN
8691	4019	28	of	of	IN
8691	4019	29	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4019	30	education	education	NN
8691	4019	31	receive	receive	VBP
8691	4019	32	one	one	CD
8691	4019	33	of	of	IN
8691	4019	34	the	the	DT
8691	4019	35	degrees	degree	NNS
8691	4019	36	above	above	IN
8691	4019	37	indicated	indicate	VBD
8691	4019	38	or	or	CC
8691	4019	39	else	else	RB
8691	4019	40	pass	pass	VB
8691	4019	41	a	a	DT
8691	4019	42	special	special	JJ
8691	4019	43	examination	examination	NN
8691	4019	44	before	before	IN
8691	4019	45	the	the	DT
8691	4019	46	same	same	JJ
8691	4019	47	board	board	NN
8691	4019	48	on	on	IN
8691	4019	49	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4019	50	prescribed	prescribed	JJ
8691	4019	51	studies	study	NNS
8691	4019	52	,	,	,
8691	4019	53	corresponding	correspond	VBG
8691	4019	54	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	4019	55	with	with	IN
8691	4019	56	those	those	DT
8691	4019	57	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	4019	58	pursued	pursue	VBN
8691	4019	59	in	in	IN
8691	4019	60	a	a	DT
8691	4019	61	high	high	JJ
8691	4019	62	school	school	NN
8691	4019	63	.	.	.
8691	4020	1	Some	some	DT
8691	4020	2	proof	proof	NN
8691	4020	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	4020	4	everywhere	everywhere	RB
8691	4020	5	required	require	VBN
8691	4020	6	that	that	IN
8691	4020	7	an	an	DT
8691	4020	8	applicant	applicant	NN
8691	4020	9	for	for	IN
8691	4020	10	admission	admission	NN
8691	4020	11	to	to	IN
8691	4020	12	the	the	DT
8691	4020	13	bar	bar	NN
8691	4020	14	possesses	possess	VBZ
8691	4020	15	a	a	DT
8691	4020	16	good	good	JJ
8691	4020	17	moral	moral	JJ
8691	4020	18	character	character	NN
8691	4020	19	.	.	.
8691	4021	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4021	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4021	3	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	4021	4	largely	largely	RB
8691	4021	5	a	a	DT
8691	4021	6	matter	matter	NN
8691	4021	7	of	of	IN
8691	4021	8	form	form	NN
8691	4021	9	.	.	.
8691	4022	1	Certificates	certificate	NNS
8691	4022	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4022	3	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	4022	4	required	require	VBN
8691	4022	5	from	from	IN
8691	4022	6	those	those	DT
8691	4022	7	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	4022	8	with	with	IN
8691	4022	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4022	10	previous	previous	JJ
8691	4022	11	life	life	NN
8691	4022	12	,	,	,
8691	4022	13	and	and	CC
8691	4022	14	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	4022	15	the	the	DT
8691	4022	16	mere	mere	JJ
8691	4022	17	motion	motion	NN
8691	4022	18	for	for	IN
8691	4022	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4022	20	admission	admission	NN
8691	4022	21	by	by	IN
8691	4022	22	a	a	DT
8691	4022	23	member	member	NN
8691	4022	24	of	of	IN
8691	4022	25	the	the	DT
8691	4022	26	bar	bar	NN
8691	4022	27	representing	represent	VBG
8691	4022	28	the	the	DT
8691	4022	29	examining	examine	VBG
8691	4022	30	committee	committee	NN
8691	4022	31	is	be	VBZ
8691	4022	32	accepted	accept	VBN
8691	4022	33	as	as	IN
8691	4022	34	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
8691	4022	35	implying	imply	VBG
8691	4022	36	that	that	IN
8691	4022	37	no	no	DT
8691	4022	38	unworthy	unworthy	JJ
8691	4022	39	person	person	NN
8691	4022	40	would	would	MD
8691	4022	41	be	be	VB
8691	4022	42	thus	thus	RB
8691	4022	43	presented	present	VBN
8691	4022	44	.	.	.
8691	4023	1	In	in	IN
8691	4023	2	a	a	DT
8691	4023	3	few	few	JJ
8691	4023	4	States	state	NNS
8691	4023	5	a	a	DT
8691	4023	6	distinction	distinction	NN
8691	4023	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4023	8	made	make	VBN
8691	4023	9	between	between	IN
8691	4023	10	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	4023	11	with	with	IN
8691	4023	12	reference	reference	NN
8691	4023	13	to	to	IN
8691	4023	14	the	the	DT
8691	4023	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	4023	16	in	in	IN
8691	4023	17	which	which	WDT
8691	4023	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4023	19	may	may	MD
8691	4023	20	practice	practice	VB
8691	4023	21	.	.	.
8691	4024	1	When	when	WRB
8691	4024	2	first	first	RB
8691	4024	3	admitted	admit	VBD
8691	4024	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4024	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	4024	6	to	to	IN
8691	4024	7	the	the	DT
8691	4024	8	bar	bar	NN
8691	4024	9	of	of	IN
8691	4024	10	the	the	DT
8691	4024	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	4024	12	courts	court	NNS
8691	4024	13	.	.	.
8691	4025	1	Later	later	RB
8691	4025	2	,	,	,
8691	4025	3	after	after	IN
8691	4025	4	a	a	DT
8691	4025	5	few	few	JJ
8691	4025	6	years	year	NNS
8691	4025	7	of	of	IN
8691	4025	8	experience	experience	NN
8691	4025	9	,	,	,
8691	4025	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4025	11	can	can	MD
8691	4025	12	be	be	VB
8691	4025	13	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	4025	14	on	on	IN
8691	4025	15	further	further	JJ
8691	4025	16	examination	examination	NN
8691	4025	17	to	to	TO
8691	4025	18	practice	practice	VB
8691	4025	19	also	also	RB
8691	4025	20	in	in	IN
8691	4025	21	the	the	DT
8691	4025	22	highest	high	JJS
8691	4025	23	courts	court	NNS
8691	4025	24	of	of	IN
8691	4025	25	the	the	DT
8691	4025	26	State	State	NNP
8691	4025	27	.	.	.
8691	4026	1	This	this	DT
8691	4026	2	distinction	distinction	NN
8691	4026	3	reaches	reach	VBZ
8691	4026	4	back	back	RB
8691	4026	5	,	,	,
8691	4026	6	in	in	IN
8691	4026	7	New	New	NNP
8691	4026	8	Jersey	Jersey	NNP
8691	4026	9	,	,	,
8691	4026	10	to	to	IN
8691	4026	11	the	the	DT
8691	4026	12	colonial	colonial	JJ
8691	4026	13	era	era	NN
8691	4026	14	.	.	.
8691	4027	1	Attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	4027	2	were	be	VBD
8691	4027	3	there	there	EX
8691	4027	4	a	a	DT
8691	4027	5	different	different	JJ
8691	4027	6	class	class	NN
8691	4027	7	from	from	IN
8691	4027	8	"	"	``
8691	4027	9	counsellors	counsellor	NNS
8691	4027	10	,	,	,
8691	4027	11	"	"	''
8691	4027	12	and	and	CC
8691	4027	13	,	,	,
8691	4027	14	following	follow	VBG
8691	4027	15	the	the	DT
8691	4027	16	English	English	NNP
8691	4027	17	practice	practice	NN
8691	4027	18	,	,	,
8691	4027	19	the	the	DT
8691	4027	20	style	style	NN
8691	4027	21	of	of	IN
8691	4027	22	"	"	``
8691	4027	23	sergeant	sergeant	NN
8691	4027	24	"	"	''
8691	4027	25	was	be	VBD
8691	4027	26	also	also	RB
8691	4027	27	formerly	formerly	RB
8691	4027	28	bestowed	bestow	VBN
8691	4027	29	on	on	IN
8691	4027	30	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	4027	31	at	at	IN
8691	4027	32	the	the	DT
8691	4027	33	bar	bar	NN
8691	4027	34	.	.	.
8691	4028	1	The	the	DT
8691	4028	2	last	last	JJ
8691	4028	3	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4028	4	bearing	bear	VBG
8691	4028	5	the	the	DT
8691	4028	6	title	title	NN
8691	4028	7	survived	survive	VBD
8691	4028	8	until	until	IN
8691	4028	9	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	4028	10	the	the	DT
8691	4028	11	middle	middle	NN
8691	4028	12	of	of	IN
8691	4028	13	the	the	DT
8691	4028	14	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	4028	15	century	century	NN
8691	4028	16	.	.	.
8691	4029	1	In	in	IN
8691	4029	2	this	this	DT
8691	4029	3	State	State	NNP
8691	4029	4	the	the	DT
8691	4029	5	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	4029	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	4029	7	always	always	RB
8691	4029	8	issued	issue	VBN
8691	4029	9	the	the	DT
8691	4029	10	licenses	license	NNS
8691	4029	11	or	or	CC
8691	4029	12	commissions	commission	NNS
8691	4029	13	to	to	IN
8691	4029	14	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	4029	15	and	and	CC
8691	4029	16	solicitors	solicitor	NNS
8691	4029	17	in	in	IN
8691	4029	18	chancery	chancery	NN
8691	4029	19	,	,	,
8691	4029	20	but	but	CC
8691	4029	21	for	for	IN
8691	4029	22	more	more	JJR
8691	4029	23	than	than	IN
8691	4029	24	a	a	DT
8691	4029	25	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	4029	26	and	and	CC
8691	4029	27	fifty	fifty	CD
8691	4029	28	years	year	NNS
8691	4029	29	only	only	RB
8691	4029	30	on	on	IN
8691	4029	31	the	the	DT
8691	4029	32	recommendation	recommendation	NN
8691	4029	33	of	of	IN
8691	4029	34	the	the	DT
8691	4029	35	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4029	36	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4029	37	.	.	.
8691	4030	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4030	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4030	3	:	:	:
8691	4030	4	_	_	NNP
8691	4030	5	In	In	NNP
8691	4030	6	re	re	NN
8691	4030	7	_	_	NNP
8691	4030	8	Branch	Branch	NNP
8691	4030	9	,	,	,
8691	4030	10	70	70	CD
8691	4030	11	N.	n.	NN
8691	4030	12	J.	J.	NNP
8691	4031	1	Law	Law	NNP
8691	4031	2	Reports	report	VBZ
8691	4031	3	;	;	:
8691	4031	4	57	57	CD
8691	4031	5	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	4031	6	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	4031	7	,	,	,
8691	4031	8	431	431	CD
8691	4031	9	.	.	.
8691	4031	10	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4032	1	The	the	DT
8691	4032	2	admission	admission	NN
8691	4032	3	of	of	IN
8691	4032	4	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	4032	5	in	in	IN
8691	4032	6	the	the	DT
8691	4032	7	several	several	JJ
8691	4032	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	4032	9	of	of	IN
8691	4032	10	the	the	DT
8691	4032	11	United	United	NNP
8691	4032	12	States	States	NNP
8691	4032	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	4032	14	determined	determine	VBN
8691	4032	15	by	by	IN
8691	4032	16	rules	rule	NNS
8691	4032	17	which	which	WDT
8691	4032	18	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4032	19	respectively	respectively	RB
8691	4032	20	establish	establish	VBP
8691	4032	21	from	from	IN
8691	4032	22	time	time	NN
8691	4032	23	to	to	IN
8691	4032	24	time	time	NN
8691	4032	25	.	.	.
8691	4033	1	These	these	DT
8691	4033	2	rules	rule	NNS
8691	4033	3	make	make	VBP
8691	4033	4	the	the	DT
8691	4033	5	only	only	JJ
8691	4033	6	qualification	qualification	NN
8691	4033	7	membership	membership	NN
8691	4033	8	in	in	IN
8691	4033	9	regular	regular	JJ
8691	4033	10	standing	standing	NN
8691	4033	11	for	for	IN
8691	4033	12	a	a	DT
8691	4033	13	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4033	14	period	period	NN
8691	4033	15	of	of	IN
8691	4033	16	time	time	NN
8691	4033	17	in	in	IN
8691	4033	18	the	the	DT
8691	4033	19	bar	bar	NN
8691	4033	20	of	of	IN
8691	4033	21	a	a	DT
8691	4033	22	State	State	NNP
8691	4033	23	and	and	CC
8691	4033	24	good	good	JJ
8691	4033	25	moral	moral	JJ
8691	4033	26	character	character	NN
8691	4033	27	.	.	.
8691	4034	1	There	there	EX
8691	4034	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4034	3	no	no	DT
8691	4034	4	doubt	doubt	NN
8691	4034	5	that	that	IN
8691	4034	6	the	the	DT
8691	4034	7	United	United	NNP
8691	4034	8	States	States	NNP
8691	4034	9	have	have	VBP
8691	4034	10	been	be	VBN
8691	4034	11	in	in	IN
8691	4034	12	advance	advance	NN
8691	4034	13	of	of	IN
8691	4034	14	England	England	NNP
8691	4034	15	both	both	DT
8691	4034	16	in	in	IN
8691	4034	17	providing	provide	VBG
8691	4034	18	means	mean	NNS
8691	4034	19	of	of	IN
8691	4034	20	legal	legal	JJ
8691	4034	21	education	education	NN
8691	4034	22	and	and	CC
8691	4034	23	in	in	IN
8691	4034	24	requiring	require	VBG
8691	4034	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4034	26	use	use	NN
8691	4034	27	.	.	.
8691	4035	1	The	the	DT
8691	4035	2	length	length	NN
8691	4035	3	of	of	IN
8691	4035	4	the	the	DT
8691	4035	5	course	course	NN
8691	4035	6	of	of	IN
8691	4035	7	study	study	NN
8691	4035	8	now	now	RB
8691	4035	9	established	establish	VBN
8691	4035	10	at	at	IN
8691	4035	11	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4035	12	older	old	JJR
8691	4035	13	Law	Law	NNP
8691	4035	14	Schools	Schools	NNPS
8691	4035	15	--	--	:
8691	4035	16	three	three	CD
8691	4035	17	years	year	NNS
8691	4035	18	--	--	:
8691	4035	19	seems	seem	VBZ
8691	4035	20	all	all	DT
8691	4035	21	that	that	WDT
8691	4035	22	can	can	MD
8691	4035	23	reasonably	reasonably	RB
8691	4035	24	be	be	VB
8691	4035	25	exacted	exact	VBN
8691	4035	26	,	,	,
8691	4035	27	if	if	IN
8691	4035	28	a	a	DT
8691	4035	29	proper	proper	JJ
8691	4035	30	foundation	foundation	NN
8691	4035	31	of	of	IN
8691	4035	32	general	general	JJ
8691	4035	33	discipline	discipline	NN
8691	4035	34	and	and	CC
8691	4035	35	knowledge	knowledge	NN
8691	4035	36	has	have	VBZ
8691	4035	37	been	be	VBN
8691	4035	38	previously	previously	RB
8691	4035	39	laid	lay	VBN
8691	4035	40	.	.	.
8691	4036	1	The	the	DT
8691	4036	2	first	first	JJ
8691	4036	3	provision	provision	NN
8691	4036	4	for	for	IN
8691	4036	5	one	one	CD
8691	4036	6	or	or	CC
8691	4036	7	more	more	JJR
8691	4036	8	years	year	NNS
8691	4036	9	of	of	IN
8691	4036	10	graduate	graduate	JJ
8691	4036	11	study	study	NN
8691	4036	12	for	for	IN
8691	4036	13	those	those	DT
8691	4036	14	who	who	WP
8691	4036	15	may	may	MD
8691	4036	16	desire	desire	VB
8691	4036	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4036	18	was	be	VBD
8691	4036	19	made	make	VBN
8691	4036	20	at	at	IN
8691	4036	21	Yale	Yale	NNP
8691	4036	22	University	University	NNP
8691	4036	23	in	in	IN
8691	4036	24	1876	1876	CD
8691	4036	25	,	,	,
8691	4036	26	and	and	CC
8691	4036	27	a	a	DT
8691	4036	28	similar	similar	JJ
8691	4036	29	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	4036	30	has	have	VBZ
8691	4036	31	since	since	IN
8691	4036	32	been	be	VBN
8691	4036	33	offered	offer	VBN
8691	4036	34	at	at	IN
8691	4036	35	several	several	JJ
8691	4036	36	others	other	NNS
8691	4036	37	;	;	:
8691	4036	38	but	but	CC
8691	4036	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4036	40	has	have	VBZ
8691	4036	41	been	be	VBN
8691	4036	42	availed	avail	VBN
8691	4036	43	of	of	IN
8691	4036	44	by	by	IN
8691	4036	45	few	few	JJ
8691	4036	46	,	,	,
8691	4036	47	and	and	CC
8691	4036	48	of	of	IN
8691	4036	49	these	these	DT
8691	4036	50	a	a	DT
8691	4036	51	considerable	considerable	JJ
8691	4036	52	part	part	NN
8691	4036	53	had	have	VBD
8691	4036	54	in	in	IN
8691	4036	55	view	view	NN
8691	4036	56	the	the	DT
8691	4036	57	teaching	teaching	NN
8691	4036	58	of	of	IN
8691	4036	59	law	law	NN
8691	4036	60	as	as	IN
8691	4036	61	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4036	62	ultimate	ultimate	JJ
8691	4036	63	vocation	vocation	NN
8691	4036	64	rather	rather	RB
8691	4036	65	than	than	IN
8691	4036	66	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4036	67	practice	practice	NN
8691	4036	68	.	.	.
8691	4037	1	Unquestionably	unquestionably	RB
8691	4037	2	the	the	DT
8691	4037	3	American	american	JJ
8691	4037	4	bar	bar	NN
8691	4037	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	4037	6	now	now	RB
8691	4037	7	,	,	,
8691	4037	8	as	as	IN
8691	4037	9	a	a	DT
8691	4037	10	whole	whole	NN
8691	4037	11	,	,	,
8691	4037	12	a	a	DT
8691	4037	13	far	far	RB
8691	4037	14	better	well	RBR
8691	4037	15	trained	train	VBN
8691	4037	16	class	class	NN
8691	4037	17	of	of	IN
8691	4037	18	men	man	NNS
8691	4037	19	than	than	IN
8691	4037	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4037	21	was	be	VBD
8691	4037	22	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	4037	23	or	or	CC
8691	4037	24	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	4037	25	years	year	NNS
8691	4037	26	ago	ago	RB
8691	4037	27	,	,	,
8691	4037	28	and	and	CC
8691	4037	29	the	the	DT
8691	4037	30	efficiency	efficiency	NN
8691	4037	31	of	of	IN
8691	4037	32	the	the	DT
8691	4037	33	courts	court	NNS
8691	4037	34	has	have	VBZ
8691	4037	35	been	be	VBN
8691	4037	36	correspondingly	correspondingly	RB
8691	4037	37	increased	increase	VBN
8691	4037	38	.	.	.
8691	4038	1	*	*	NFP
8691	4038	2	*	*	NFP
8691	4038	3	*	*	NFP
8691	4038	4	*	*	NFP
8691	4038	5	*	*	NFP
8691	4038	6	Members	member	NNS
8691	4038	7	of	of	IN
8691	4038	8	the	the	DT
8691	4038	9	bar	bar	NN
8691	4038	10	are	be	VBP
8691	4038	11	always	always	RB
8691	4038	12	subject	subject	JJ
8691	4038	13	to	to	IN
8691	4038	14	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	4038	15	by	by	IN
8691	4038	16	the	the	DT
8691	4038	17	court	court	NN
8691	4038	18	for	for	IN
8691	4038	19	official	official	JJ
8691	4038	20	misconduct	misconduct	NN
8691	4038	21	.	.	.
8691	4039	1	This	this	DT
8691	4039	2	may	may	MD
8691	4039	3	be	be	VB
8691	4039	4	by	by	IN
8691	4039	5	censure	censure	NN
8691	4039	6	,	,	,
8691	4039	7	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	4039	8	suspension	suspension	NN
8691	4039	9	from	from	IN
8691	4039	10	practice	practice	NN
8691	4039	11	,	,	,
8691	4039	12	or	or	CC
8691	4039	13	disbarment	disbarment	NN
8691	4039	14	.	.	.
8691	4040	1	If	if	IN
8691	4040	2	guilty	guilty	JJ
8691	4040	3	of	of	IN
8691	4040	4	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	4040	5	of	of	IN
8691	4040	6	court	court	NN
8691	4040	7	,	,	,
8691	4040	8	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4040	9	can	can	MD
8691	4040	10	also	also	RB
8691	4040	11	be	be	VB
8691	4040	12	sentenced	sentence	VBN
8691	4040	13	to	to	IN
8691	4040	14	fine	fine	JJ
8691	4040	15	or	or	CC
8691	4040	16	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	4040	17	.	.	.
8691	4041	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4041	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4041	3	:	:	:
8691	4041	4	See	see	VB
8691	4041	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	4041	6	.	.	.
8691	4042	1	XX	XX	NNP
8691	4042	2	.	.	.
8691	4042	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4043	1	As	as	IN
8691	4043	2	suspension	suspension	NN
8691	4043	3	or	or	CC
8691	4043	4	disbarment	disbarment	NN
8691	4043	5	means	mean	VBZ
8691	4043	6	a	a	DT
8691	4043	7	loss	loss	NN
8691	4043	8	,	,	,
8691	4043	9	temporary	temporary	JJ
8691	4043	10	or	or	CC
8691	4043	11	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	4043	12	,	,	,
8691	4043	13	of	of	IN
8691	4043	14	a	a	DT
8691	4043	15	livelihood	livelihood	NN
8691	4043	16	,	,	,
8691	4043	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4043	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	4043	19	only	only	RB
8691	4043	20	ordered	order	VBN
8691	4043	21	in	in	IN
8691	4043	22	aggravated	aggravated	JJ
8691	4043	23	cases	case	NNS
8691	4043	24	and	and	CC
8691	4043	25	after	after	IN
8691	4043	26	an	an	DT
8691	4043	27	opportunity	opportunity	NN
8691	4043	28	for	for	IN
8691	4043	29	a	a	DT
8691	4043	30	formal	formal	JJ
8691	4043	31	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	4043	32	.	.	.
8691	4044	1	Disbarment	disbarment	NN
8691	4044	2	can	can	MD
8691	4044	3	not	not	RB
8691	4044	4	be	be	VB
8691	4044	5	decreed	decree	VBN
8691	4044	6	by	by	IN
8691	4044	7	the	the	DT
8691	4044	8	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	4044	9	department	department	NN
8691	4044	10	.	.	.
8691	4045	1	That	that	DT
8691	4045	2	would	would	MD
8691	4045	3	be	be	VB
8691	4045	4	virtually	virtually	RB
8691	4045	5	an	an	DT
8691	4045	6	act	act	NN
8691	4045	7	of	of	IN
8691	4045	8	attainder	attainder	NN
8691	4045	9	.	.	.
8691	4046	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4046	2	must	must	MD
8691	4046	3	come	come	VB
8691	4046	4	from	from	IN
8691	4046	5	a	a	DT
8691	4046	6	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4046	7	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	4046	8	.	.	.
8691	4047	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4047	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4047	3	:	:	:
8691	4047	4	_	_	NNP
8691	4047	5	Ex	Ex	NNP
8691	4047	6	parte	parte	NN
8691	4047	7	_	_	NNP
8691	4047	8	Garland	Garland	NNP
8691	4047	9	,	,	,
8691	4047	10	4	4	CD
8691	4047	11	Wallace	Wallace	NNP
8691	4047	12	's	's	POS
8691	4047	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	4047	14	,	,	,
8691	4047	15	333	333	CD
8691	4047	16	,	,	,
8691	4047	17	378	378	CD
8691	4047	18	.	.	.
8691	4047	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4048	1	In	in	IN
8691	4048	2	some	some	DT
8691	4048	3	States	state	NNS
8691	4048	4	the	the	DT
8691	4048	5	principal	principal	JJ
8691	4048	6	trial	trial	NN
8691	4048	7	court	court	NN
8691	4048	8	,	,	,
8691	4048	9	which	which	WDT
8691	4048	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	4048	11	the	the	DT
8691	4048	12	one	one	NN
8691	4048	13	by	by	IN
8691	4048	14	order	order	NN
8691	4048	15	of	of	IN
8691	4048	16	which	which	WDT
8691	4048	17	attorneys	attorney	NNS
8691	4048	18	generally	generally	RB
8691	4048	19	are	be	VBP
8691	4048	20	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	4048	21	to	to	IN
8691	4048	22	the	the	DT
8691	4048	23	bar	bar	NN
8691	4048	24	,	,	,
8691	4048	25	appoints	appoint	VBZ
8691	4048	26	a	a	DT
8691	4048	27	standing	stand	VBG
8691	4048	28	committee	committee	NN
8691	4048	29	on	on	IN
8691	4048	30	grievances	grievance	NNS
8691	4048	31	.	.	.
8691	4049	1	In	in	IN
8691	4049	2	others	other	NNS
8691	4049	3	such	such	JJ
8691	4049	4	committees	committee	NNS
8691	4049	5	are	be	VBP
8691	4049	6	created	create	VBN
8691	4049	7	by	by	IN
8691	4049	8	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	4049	9	Associations	Associations	NNPS
8691	4049	10	,	,	,
8691	4049	11	of	of	IN
8691	4049	12	which	which	WDT
8691	4049	13	almost	almost	RB
8691	4049	14	every	every	DT
8691	4049	15	State	state	NN
8691	4049	16	has	have	VBZ
8691	4049	17	one	one	CD
8691	4049	18	for	for	IN
8691	4049	19	the	the	DT
8691	4049	20	whole	whole	JJ
8691	4049	21	State	state	NN
8691	4049	22	,	,	,
8691	4049	23	while	while	IN
8691	4049	24	several	several	JJ
8691	4049	25	have	have	VBP
8691	4049	26	also	also	RB
8691	4049	27	one	one	CD
8691	4049	28	or	or	CC
8691	4049	29	more	more	JJR
8691	4049	30	local	local	JJ
8691	4049	31	associations	association	NNS
8691	4049	32	.	.	.
8691	4050	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4050	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4050	3	the	the	DT
8691	4050	4	duty	duty	NN
8691	4050	5	of	of	IN
8691	4050	6	such	such	PDT
8691	4050	7	a	a	DT
8691	4050	8	committee	committee	NN
8691	4050	9	to	to	TO
8691	4050	10	inquire	inquire	VB
8691	4050	11	into	into	IN
8691	4050	12	any	any	DT
8691	4050	13	instances	instance	NNS
8691	4050	14	of	of	IN
8691	4050	15	professional	professional	JJ
8691	4050	16	misconduct	misconduct	NN
8691	4050	17	that	that	WDT
8691	4050	18	may	may	MD
8691	4050	19	be	be	VB
8691	4050	20	brought	bring	VBN
8691	4050	21	to	to	IN
8691	4050	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4050	23	notice	notice	NN
8691	4050	24	and	and	CC
8691	4050	25	either	either	CC
8691	4050	26	institute	institute	NNP
8691	4050	27	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	4050	28	for	for	IN
8691	4050	29	a	a	DT
8691	4050	30	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	4050	31	before	before	IN
8691	4050	32	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4050	33	or	or	CC
8691	4050	34	bring	bring	VB
8691	4050	35	the	the	DT
8691	4050	36	matter	matter	NN
8691	4050	37	to	to	IN
8691	4050	38	the	the	DT
8691	4050	39	attention	attention	NN
8691	4050	40	of	of	IN
8691	4050	41	the	the	DT
8691	4050	42	court	court	NN
8691	4050	43	,	,	,
8691	4050	44	so	so	IN
8691	4050	45	that	that	IN
8691	4050	46	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4050	47	may	may	MD
8691	4050	48	be	be	VB
8691	4050	49	instituted	institute	VBN
8691	4050	50	there	there	RB
8691	4050	51	by	by	IN
8691	4050	52	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4050	53	order	order	NN
8691	4050	54	and	and	CC
8691	4050	55	conducted	conduct	VBN
8691	4050	56	by	by	IN
8691	4050	57	the	the	DT
8691	4050	58	public	public	JJ
8691	4050	59	prosecutor	prosecutor	NN
8691	4050	60	.	.	.
8691	4051	1	In	in	IN
8691	4051	2	the	the	DT
8691	4051	3	larger	large	JJR
8691	4051	4	States	state	NNS
8691	4051	5	,	,	,
8691	4051	6	several	several	JJ
8691	4051	7	inquiries	inquiry	NNS
8691	4051	8	of	of	IN
8691	4051	9	this	this	DT
8691	4051	10	nature	nature	NN
8691	4051	11	are	be	VBP
8691	4051	12	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	4051	13	set	set	VBN
8691	4051	14	on	on	IN
8691	4051	15	foot	foot	NN
8691	4051	16	every	every	DT
8691	4051	17	year	year	NN
8691	4051	18	,	,	,
8691	4051	19	which	which	WDT
8691	4051	20	result	result	VBP
8691	4051	21	in	in	IN
8691	4051	22	suspension	suspension	NN
8691	4051	23	or	or	CC
8691	4051	24	disbarment	disbarment	NN
8691	4051	25	.	.	.
8691	4052	1	In	in	IN
8691	4052	2	the	the	DT
8691	4052	3	smaller	small	JJR
8691	4052	4	States	state	NNS
8691	4052	5	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4052	6	are	be	VBP
8691	4052	7	rare	rare	JJ
8691	4052	8	,	,	,
8691	4052	9	both	both	DT
8691	4052	10	because	because	IN
8691	4052	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4052	12	have	have	VBP
8691	4052	13	smaller	small	JJR
8691	4052	14	bars	bar	NNS
8691	4052	15	and	and	CC
8691	4052	16	because	because	IN
8691	4052	17	the	the	DT
8691	4052	18	smaller	small	JJR
8691	4052	19	a	a	DT
8691	4052	20	bar	bar	NN
8691	4052	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	4052	22	the	the	DT
8691	4052	23	more	more	RBR
8691	4052	24	difficult	difficult	JJ
8691	4052	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	4052	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4052	27	for	for	IN
8691	4052	28	any	any	DT
8691	4052	29	one	one	CD
8691	4052	30	of	of	IN
8691	4052	31	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4052	32	number	number	NN
8691	4052	33	to	to	TO
8691	4052	34	hide	hide	VB
8691	4052	35	any	any	DT
8691	4052	36	misdoing	misdoing	NN
8691	4052	37	from	from	IN
8691	4052	38	the	the	DT
8691	4052	39	rest	rest	NN
8691	4052	40	.	.	.
8691	4053	1	The	the	DT
8691	4053	2	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	4053	3	Associations	Associations	NNPS
8691	4053	4	,	,	,
8691	4053	5	which	which	WDT
8691	4053	6	first	first	RB
8691	4053	7	began	begin	VBD
8691	4053	8	to	to	TO
8691	4053	9	start	start	VB
8691	4053	10	up	up	RP
8691	4053	11	soon	soon	RB
8691	4053	12	after	after	IN
8691	4053	13	the	the	DT
8691	4053	14	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	4053	15	War	War	NNP
8691	4053	16	,	,	,
8691	4053	17	have	have	VBP
8691	4053	18	been	be	VBN
8691	4053	19	of	of	IN
8691	4053	20	great	great	JJ
8691	4053	21	service	service	NN
8691	4053	22	in	in	IN
8691	4053	23	upholding	uphold	VBG
8691	4053	24	the	the	DT
8691	4053	25	honor	honor	NN
8691	4053	26	of	of	IN
8691	4053	27	the	the	DT
8691	4053	28	profession	profession	NN
8691	4053	29	.	.	.
8691	4054	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4054	2	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	4054	3	generally	generally	RB
8691	4054	4	name	name	VBP
8691	4054	5	this	this	DT
8691	4054	6	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	4054	7	as	as	IN
8691	4054	8	among	among	IN
8691	4054	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4054	10	professed	profess	VBN
8691	4054	11	objects	object	NNS
8691	4054	12	.	.	.
8691	4055	1	One	one	CD
8691	4055	2	State[Footnote	state[footnote	NN
8691	4055	3	:	:	:
8691	4055	4	Alabama	Alabama	NNP
8691	4055	5	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4055	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	4055	7	recently	recently	RB
8691	4055	8	under	under	IN
8691	4055	9	such	such	JJ
8691	4055	10	influences	influence	NNS
8691	4055	11	,	,	,
8691	4055	12	passed	pass	VBD
8691	4055	13	a	a	DT
8691	4055	14	statute	statute	NN
8691	4055	15	making	make	VBG
8691	4055	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4055	17	a	a	DT
8691	4055	18	misdemeanor	misdemeanor	NN
8691	4055	19	for	for	IN
8691	4055	20	an	an	DT
8691	4055	21	attorney	attorney	NN
8691	4055	22	to	to	TO
8691	4055	23	send	send	VB
8691	4055	24	out	out	RP
8691	4055	25	"	"	``
8691	4055	26	runners	runner	NNS
8691	4055	27	"	"	''
8691	4055	28	to	to	TO
8691	4055	29	solicit	solicit	VB
8691	4055	30	practice	practice	NN
8691	4055	31	,	,	,
8691	4055	32	and	and	CC
8691	4055	33	requiring	require	VBG
8691	4055	34	the	the	DT
8691	4055	35	public	public	JJ
8691	4055	36	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
8691	4055	37	officer	officer	NN
8691	4055	38	to	to	IN
8691	4055	39	institute	institute	VB
8691	4055	40	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	4055	41	for	for	IN
8691	4055	42	any	any	DT
8691	4055	43	violation	violation	NN
8691	4055	44	of	of	IN
8691	4055	45	the	the	DT
8691	4055	46	law	law	NN
8691	4055	47	,	,	,
8691	4055	48	upon	upon	IN
8691	4055	49	the	the	DT
8691	4055	50	complaint	complaint	NN
8691	4055	51	of	of	IN
8691	4055	52	the	the	DT
8691	4055	53	council	council	NN
8691	4055	54	of	of	IN
8691	4055	55	the	the	DT
8691	4055	56	State	State	NNP
8691	4055	57	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	4055	58	Association	Association	NNP
8691	4055	59	.	.	.
8691	4056	1	The	the	DT
8691	4056	2	steadily	steadily	JJ
8691	4056	3	and	and	CC
8691	4056	4	rapidly	rapidly	RB
8691	4056	5	increasing	increase	VBG
8691	4056	6	proportion	proportion	NN
8691	4056	7	of	of	IN
8691	4056	8	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4056	9	to	to	IN
8691	4056	10	the	the	DT
8691	4056	11	population	population	NN
8691	4056	12	in	in	IN
8691	4056	13	the	the	DT
8691	4056	14	United	United	NNP
8691	4056	15	States	States	NNP
8691	4056	16	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	4056	17	tends	tend	VBZ
8691	4056	18	to	to	IN
8691	4056	19	a	a	DT
8691	4056	20	lowering	lowering	NN
8691	4056	21	of	of	IN
8691	4056	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4056	23	average	average	JJ
8691	4056	24	professional	professional	JJ
8691	4056	25	income	income	NN
8691	4056	26	,	,	,
8691	4056	27	and	and	CC
8691	4056	28	this	this	DT
8691	4056	29	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	4056	30	is	be	VBZ
8691	4056	31	not	not	RB
8691	4056	32	fully	fully	RB
8691	4056	33	overcome	overcome	VBN
8691	4056	34	by	by	IN
8691	4056	35	the	the	DT
8691	4056	36	increase	increase	NN
8691	4056	37	of	of	IN
8691	4056	38	the	the	DT
8691	4056	39	wealth	wealth	NN
8691	4056	40	and	and	CC
8691	4056	41	business	business	NN
8691	4056	42	of	of	IN
8691	4056	43	the	the	DT
8691	4056	44	country	country	NN
8691	4056	45	.	.	.
8691	4057	1	The	the	DT
8691	4057	2	principle	principle	NN
8691	4057	3	of	of	IN
8691	4057	4	the	the	DT
8691	4057	5	concentration	concentration	NN
8691	4057	6	of	of	IN
8691	4057	7	industry	industry	NN
8691	4057	8	also	also	RB
8691	4057	9	works	work	VBZ
8691	4057	10	against	against	IN
8691	4057	11	the	the	DT
8691	4057	12	great	great	JJ
8691	4057	13	majority	majority	NN
8691	4057	14	of	of	IN
8691	4057	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4057	16	.	.	.
8691	4058	1	Searching	search	VBG
8691	4058	2	titles	title	NNS
8691	4058	3	to	to	IN
8691	4058	4	real	real	JJ
8691	4058	5	estate	estate	NN
8691	4058	6	,	,	,
8691	4058	7	for	for	IN
8691	4058	8	instance	instance	NN
8691	4058	9	,	,	,
8691	4058	10	was	be	VBD
8691	4058	11	until	until	IN
8691	4058	12	the	the	DT
8691	4058	13	last	last	JJ
8691	4058	14	half	half	NN
8691	4058	15	of	of	IN
8691	4058	16	the	the	DT
8691	4058	17	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	4058	18	century	century	NN
8691	4058	19	part	part	NN
8691	4058	20	of	of	IN
8691	4058	21	the	the	DT
8691	4058	22	business	business	NN
8691	4058	23	of	of	IN
8691	4058	24	every	every	DT
8691	4058	25	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4058	26	.	.	.
8691	4059	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4059	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4059	3	now	now	RB
8691	4059	4	in	in	IN
8691	4059	5	the	the	DT
8691	4059	6	larger	large	JJR
8691	4059	7	cities	city	NNS
8691	4059	8	monopolized	monopolize	VBN
8691	4059	9	by	by	IN
8691	4059	10	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4059	11	firms	firm	NNS
8691	4059	12	or	or	CC
8691	4059	13	corporations	corporation	NNS
8691	4059	14	,	,	,
8691	4059	15	who	who	WP
8691	4059	16	own	own	VBP
8691	4059	17	copies	copy	NNS
8691	4059	18	or	or	CC
8691	4059	19	abstracts	abstract	NNS
8691	4059	20	of	of	IN
8691	4059	21	the	the	DT
8691	4059	22	public	public	JJ
8691	4059	23	records	record	NNS
8691	4059	24	,	,	,
8691	4059	25	laboriously	laboriously	RB
8691	4059	26	prepared	prepared	JJ
8691	4059	27	,	,	,
8691	4059	28	which	which	WDT
8691	4059	29	give	give	VBP
8691	4059	30	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4059	31	special	special	JJ
8691	4059	32	facilities	facility	NNS
8691	4059	33	for	for	IN
8691	4059	34	doing	do	VBG
8691	4059	35	the	the	DT
8691	4059	36	work	work	NN
8691	4059	37	rapidly	rapidly	RB
8691	4059	38	and	and	CC
8691	4059	39	well	well	RB
8691	4059	40	.	.	.
8691	4060	1	So	so	RB
8691	4060	2	collecting	collect	VBG
8691	4060	3	uncontested	uncontested	JJ
8691	4060	4	debts	debt	NNS
8691	4060	5	was	be	VBD
8691	4060	6	formerly	formerly	RB
8691	4060	7	the	the	DT
8691	4060	8	staple	staple	NN
8691	4060	9	of	of	IN
8691	4060	10	many	many	JJ
8691	4060	11	a	a	DT
8691	4060	12	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4060	13	's	's	POS
8691	4060	14	practice	practice	NN
8691	4060	15	.	.	.
8691	4061	1	The	the	DT
8691	4061	2	general	general	JJ
8691	4061	3	abolition	abolition	NN
8691	4061	4	of	of	IN
8691	4061	5	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	4061	6	for	for	IN
8691	4061	7	debt	debt	NN
8691	4061	8	about	about	IN
8691	4061	9	the	the	DT
8691	4061	10	middle	middle	NN
8691	4061	11	of	of	IN
8691	4061	12	the	the	DT
8691	4061	13	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	4061	14	century	century	NN
8691	4061	15	rendered	render	VBD
8691	4061	16	the	the	DT
8691	4061	17	process	process	NN
8691	4061	18	much	much	RB
8691	4061	19	more	more	RBR
8691	4061	20	difficult	difficult	JJ
8691	4061	21	and	and	CC
8691	4061	22	the	the	DT
8691	4061	23	fees	fee	NNS
8691	4061	24	less	less	RBR
8691	4061	25	,	,	,
8691	4061	26	and	and	CC
8691	4061	27	of	of	IN
8691	4061	28	late	late	JJ
8691	4061	29	years	year	NNS
8691	4061	30	great	great	JJ
8691	4061	31	collection	collection	NN
8691	4061	32	agencies	agency	NNS
8691	4061	33	,	,	,
8691	4061	34	generally	generally	RB
8691	4061	35	corporations	corporation	NNS
8691	4061	36	,	,	,
8691	4061	37	have	have	VBP
8691	4061	38	sprung	spring	VBN
8691	4061	39	up	up	RP
8691	4061	40	,	,	,
8691	4061	41	with	with	IN
8691	4061	42	an	an	DT
8691	4061	43	extensive	extensive	JJ
8691	4061	44	system	system	NN
8691	4061	45	of	of	IN
8691	4061	46	correspondents	correspondent	NNS
8691	4061	47	among	among	IN
8691	4061	48	members	member	NNS
8691	4061	49	of	of	IN
8691	4061	50	the	the	DT
8691	4061	51	bar	bar	NN
8691	4061	52	,	,	,
8691	4061	53	by	by	IN
8691	4061	54	whom	whom	WP
8691	4061	55	most	most	JJS
8691	4061	56	suits	suit	NNS
8691	4061	57	of	of	IN
8691	4061	58	such	such	PDT
8691	4061	59	a	a	DT
8691	4061	60	nature	nature	NN
8691	4061	61	are	be	VBP
8691	4061	62	now	now	RB
8691	4061	63	brought	bring	VBN
8691	4061	64	under	under	IN
8691	4061	65	an	an	DT
8691	4061	66	agreement	agreement	NN
8691	4061	67	to	to	TO
8691	4061	68	divide	divide	VB
8691	4061	69	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4061	70	fees	fee	NNS
8691	4061	71	with	with	IN
8691	4061	72	the	the	DT
8691	4061	73	central	central	JJ
8691	4061	74	bureau	bureau	NN
8691	4061	75	.	.	.
8691	4062	1	Until	until	IN
8691	4062	2	the	the	DT
8691	4062	3	last	last	JJ
8691	4062	4	half	half	NN
8691	4062	5	of	of	IN
8691	4062	6	the	the	DT
8691	4062	7	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	4062	8	century	century	NN
8691	4062	9	there	there	EX
8691	4062	10	were	be	VBD
8691	4062	11	probably	probably	RB
8691	4062	12	no	no	DT
8691	4062	13	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4062	14	in	in	IN
8691	4062	15	this	this	DT
8691	4062	16	country	country	NN
8691	4062	17	whose	whose	WP$
8691	4062	18	average	average	JJ
8691	4062	19	net	net	JJ
8691	4062	20	income	income	NN
8691	4062	21	from	from	IN
8691	4062	22	year	year	NN
8691	4062	23	to	to	IN
8691	4062	24	year	year	NN
8691	4062	25	was	be	VBD
8691	4062	26	equal	equal	JJ
8691	4062	27	to	to	IN
8691	4062	28	that	that	DT
8691	4062	29	of	of	IN
8691	4062	30	the	the	DT
8691	4062	31	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	4062	32	of	of	IN
8691	4062	33	the	the	DT
8691	4062	34	English	English	NNP
8691	4062	35	bar	bar	NN
8691	4062	36	.	.	.
8691	4063	1	In	in	IN
8691	4063	2	1806	1806	CD
8691	4063	3	there	there	EX
8691	4063	4	was	be	VBD
8691	4063	5	but	but	CC
8691	4063	6	one	one	CD
8691	4063	7	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4063	8	in	in	IN
8691	4063	9	New	New	NNP
8691	4063	10	England	England	NNP
8691	4063	11	with	with	IN
8691	4063	12	an	an	DT
8691	4063	13	annual	annual	JJ
8691	4063	14	professional	professional	JJ
8691	4063	15	income	income	NN
8691	4063	16	of	of	IN
8691	4063	17	$	$	$
8691	4063	18	10,000	10,000	CD
8691	4063	19	:	:	:
8691	4063	20	until	until	IN
8691	4063	21	about	about	RB
8691	4063	22	1860	1860	CD
8691	4063	23	there	there	EX
8691	4063	24	was	be	VBD
8691	4063	25	none	none	NN
8691	4063	26	in	in	IN
8691	4063	27	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	4063	28	,	,	,
8691	4063	29	and	and	CC
8691	4063	30	probably	probably	RB
8691	4063	31	not	not	RB
8691	4063	32	over	over	IN
8691	4063	33	a	a	DT
8691	4063	34	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	4063	35	in	in	IN
8691	4063	36	the	the	DT
8691	4063	37	entire	entire	JJ
8691	4063	38	country	country	NN
8691	4063	39	.	.	.
8691	4064	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4064	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4064	3	:	:	:
8691	4064	4	Parton	Parton	NNP
8691	4064	5	,	,	,
8691	4064	6	"	"	``
8691	4064	7	Life	life	NN
8691	4064	8	of	of	IN
8691	4064	9	Aaron	Aaron	NNP
8691	4064	10	Burr	Burr	NNP
8691	4064	11	.	.	.
8691	4064	12	"	"	''
8691	4065	1	153	153	LS
8691	4065	2	;	;	:
8691	4065	3	Great	Great	NNP
8691	4065	4	American	American	NNP
8691	4065	5	Lawyers	Lawyers	NNPS
8691	4065	6	,	,	,
8691	4065	7	III	III	NNP
8691	4065	8	,	,	,
8691	4065	9	55	55	CD
8691	4065	10	.	.	.
8691	4065	11	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4066	1	In	in	IN
8691	4066	2	1827	1827	CD
8691	4066	3	,	,	,
8691	4066	4	William	William	NNP
8691	4066	5	Wirt	Wirt	NNP
8691	4066	6	was	be	VBD
8691	4066	7	informed	inform	VBN
8691	4066	8	by	by	IN
8691	4066	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	4066	10	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
8691	4066	11	of	of	IN
8691	4066	12	the	the	DT
8691	4066	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4066	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4066	15	of	of	IN
8691	4066	16	the	the	DT
8691	4066	17	United	United	NNP
8691	4066	18	States	States	NNP
8691	4066	19	that	that	IN
8691	4066	20	"	"	``
8691	4066	21	six	six	CD
8691	4066	22	,	,	,
8691	4066	23	eight	eight	CD
8691	4066	24	,	,	,
8691	4066	25	and	and	CC
8691	4066	26	ten	ten	CD
8691	4066	27	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	4066	28	dollars	dollar	NNS
8691	4066	29	is	be	VBZ
8691	4066	30	considered	consider	VBN
8691	4066	31	great	great	JJ
8691	4066	32	practice	practice	NN
8691	4066	33	in	in	IN
8691	4066	34	New	New	NNP
8691	4066	35	York	York	NNP
8691	4066	36	and	and	CC
8691	4066	37	ten	ten	CD
8691	4066	38	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	4066	39	dollars	dollar	NNS
8691	4066	40	the	the	DT
8691	4066	41	_	_	NNP
8691	4066	42	maximum	maximum	NN
8691	4066	43	_	_	NNP
8691	4066	44	.	.	.
8691	4067	1	"	"	``
8691	4067	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4067	3	Footnote	Footnote	NNP
8691	4067	4	:	:	:
8691	4067	5	Kennedy	Kennedy	NNP
8691	4067	6	,	,	,
8691	4067	7	"	"	``
8691	4067	8	Memoirs	Memoirs	NNP
8691	4067	9	of	of	IN
8691	4067	10	William	William	NNP
8691	4067	11	Wirt	Wirt	NNP
8691	4067	12	,	,	,
8691	4067	13	"	"	``
8691	4067	14	II	II	NNP
8691	4067	15	,	,	,
8691	4067	16	209	209	CD
8691	4067	17	.	.	.
8691	4067	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4068	1	Thirty	thirty	CD
8691	4068	2	years	year	NNS
8691	4068	3	later	later	RB
8691	4068	4	the	the	DT
8691	4068	5	same	same	JJ
8691	4068	6	was	be	VBD
8691	4068	7	true	true	JJ
8691	4068	8	,	,	,
8691	4068	9	except	except	IN
8691	4068	10	that	that	IN
8691	4068	11	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	4068	12	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	4068	13	dollars	dollar	NNS
8691	4068	14	had	have	VBD
8691	4068	15	then	then	RB
8691	4068	16	become	become	VBN
8691	4068	17	the	the	DT
8691	4068	18	highest	high	JJS
8691	4068	19	annual	annual	JJ
8691	4068	20	average	average	NN
8691	4068	21	,	,	,
8691	4068	22	and	and	CC
8691	4068	23	that	that	DT
8691	4068	24	but	but	CC
8691	4068	25	of	of	IN
8691	4068	26	a	a	DT
8691	4068	27	very	very	RB
8691	4068	28	few	few	JJ
8691	4068	29	.	.	.
8691	4069	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4069	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4069	3	:	:	:
8691	4069	4	Parton	Parton	NNP
8691	4069	5	,	,	,
8691	4069	6	"	"	``
8691	4069	7	Life	life	NN
8691	4069	8	of	of	IN
8691	4069	9	Aaron	Aaron	NNP
8691	4069	10	Burr	Burr	NNP
8691	4069	11	,	,	,
8691	4069	12	"	"	''
8691	4069	13	153	153	CD
8691	4069	14	.	.	.
8691	4069	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4070	1	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
8691	4070	2	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	4070	3	earned	earn	VBD
8691	4070	4	from	from	IN
8691	4070	5	$	$	$
8691	4070	6	12,000	12,000	CD
8691	4070	7	to	to	TO
8691	4070	8	$	$	$
8691	4070	9	20,000	20,000	CD
8691	4070	10	when	when	WRB
8691	4070	11	at	at	IN
8691	4070	12	the	the	DT
8691	4070	13	height	height	NN
8691	4070	14	of	of	IN
8691	4070	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4070	16	career	career	NN
8691	4070	17	.	.	.
8691	4071	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4071	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4071	3	:	:	:
8691	4071	4	Harvey	harvey	NN
8691	4071	5	,	,	,
8691	4071	6	"	"	``
8691	4071	7	Reminiscences	Reminiscences	NNP
8691	4071	8	of	of	IN
8691	4071	9	Daniel	Daniel	NNP
8691	4071	10	Webster	Webster	NNP
8691	4071	11	,	,	,
8691	4071	12	"	"	''
8691	4071	13	84	84	CD
8691	4071	14	.	.	.
8691	4071	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4072	1	The	the	DT
8691	4072	2	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	4072	3	War	War	NNP
8691	4072	4	was	be	VBD
8691	4072	5	the	the	DT
8691	4072	6	occasion	occasion	NN
8691	4072	7	of	of	IN
8691	4072	8	many	many	JJ
8691	4072	9	important	important	JJ
8691	4072	10	business	business	NN
8691	4072	11	enterprises	enterprise	NNS
8691	4072	12	,	,	,
8691	4072	13	and	and	CC
8691	4072	14	gave	give	VBD
8691	4072	15	rise	rise	NN
8691	4072	16	to	to	IN
8691	4072	17	much	much	JJ
8691	4072	18	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	4072	19	.	.	.
8691	4073	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4073	2	brought	bring	VBD
8691	4073	3	also	also	RB
8691	4073	4	a	a	DT
8691	4073	5	great	great	JJ
8691	4073	6	increase	increase	NN
8691	4073	7	of	of	IN
8691	4073	8	wealth	wealth	NN
8691	4073	9	to	to	IN
8691	4073	10	the	the	DT
8691	4073	11	North	North	NNP
8691	4073	12	and	and	CC
8691	4073	13	West	West	NNP
8691	4073	14	,	,	,
8691	4073	15	and	and	CC
8691	4073	16	new	new	JJ
8691	4073	17	and	and	CC
8691	4073	18	greater	great	JJR
8691	4073	19	investments	investment	NNS
8691	4073	20	of	of	IN
8691	4073	21	Northern	northern	JJ
8691	4073	22	capital	capital	NN
8691	4073	23	in	in	IN
8691	4073	24	the	the	DT
8691	4073	25	South	South	NNP
8691	4073	26	.	.	.
8691	4074	1	From	from	IN
8691	4074	2	that	that	DT
8691	4074	3	time	time	NN
8691	4074	4	the	the	DT
8691	4074	5	business	business	NN
8691	4074	6	of	of	IN
8691	4074	7	the	the	DT
8691	4074	8	leading	lead	VBG
8691	4074	9	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4074	10	in	in	IN
8691	4074	11	every	every	DT
8691	4074	12	State	State	NNP
8691	4074	13	became	become	VBD
8691	4074	14	more	more	RBR
8691	4074	15	remunerative	remunerative	JJ
8691	4074	16	.	.	.
8691	4075	1	Incomes	income	NNS
8691	4075	2	of	of	IN
8691	4075	3	$	$	$
8691	4075	4	20,000	20,000	CD
8691	4075	5	and	and	CC
8691	4075	6	$	$	$
8691	4075	7	25,000	25,000	CD
8691	4075	8	were	be	VBD
8691	4075	9	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	4075	10	earned	earn	VBN
8691	4075	11	in	in	IN
8691	4075	12	the	the	DT
8691	4075	13	smaller	small	JJR
8691	4075	14	States	States	NNP
8691	4075	15	,	,	,
8691	4075	16	and	and	CC
8691	4075	17	of	of	IN
8691	4075	18	four	four	CD
8691	4075	19	or	or	CC
8691	4075	20	five	five	CD
8691	4075	21	times	time	NNS
8691	4075	22	as	as	RB
8691	4075	23	much	much	RB
8691	4075	24	in	in	IN
8691	4075	25	the	the	DT
8691	4075	26	larger	large	JJR
8691	4075	27	ones	one	NNS
8691	4075	28	.	.	.
8691	4076	1	The	the	DT
8691	4076	2	American	american	JJ
8691	4076	3	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4076	4	of	of	IN
8691	4076	5	the	the	DT
8691	4076	6	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
8691	4076	7	century	century	NN
8691	4076	8	was	be	VBD
8691	4076	9	apt	apt	JJ
8691	4076	10	to	to	TO
8691	4076	11	have	have	VB
8691	4076	12	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4076	13	office	office	NN
8691	4076	14	in	in	IN
8691	4076	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4076	16	house	house	NN
8691	4076	17	.	.	.
8691	4077	1	During	during	IN
8691	4077	2	the	the	DT
8691	4077	3	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	4077	4	century	century	NN
8691	4077	5	this	this	DT
8691	4077	6	became	become	VBD
8691	4077	7	less	less	RBR
8691	4077	8	and	and	CC
8691	4077	9	less	less	RBR
8691	4077	10	common	common	JJ
8691	4077	11	and	and	CC
8691	4077	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	4077	13	now	now	RB
8691	4077	14	comparatively	comparatively	RB
8691	4077	15	rare	rare	JJ
8691	4077	16	.	.	.
8691	4078	1	In	in	IN
8691	4078	2	cities	city	NNS
8691	4078	3	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4078	4	streets	street	NNS
8691	4078	5	,	,	,
8691	4078	6	generally	generally	RB
8691	4078	7	near	near	IN
8691	4078	8	the	the	DT
8691	4078	9	court	court	NN
8691	4078	10	-	-	HYPH
8691	4078	11	house	house	NN
8691	4078	12	,	,	,
8691	4078	13	are	be	VBP
8691	4078	14	crowded	crowd	VBN
8691	4078	15	with	with	IN
8691	4078	16	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4078	17	'	'	POS
8691	4078	18	offices	office	NNS
8691	4078	19	.	.	.
8691	4079	1	These	these	DT
8691	4079	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4079	3	generally	generally	RB
8691	4079	4	over	over	IN
8691	4079	5	business	business	NN
8691	4079	6	stores	store	NNS
8691	4079	7	,	,	,
8691	4079	8	but	but	CC
8691	4079	9	in	in	IN
8691	4079	10	some	some	DT
8691	4079	11	places	place	NNS
8691	4079	12	residential	residential	JJ
8691	4079	13	streets	street	NNS
8691	4079	14	have	have	VBP
8691	4079	15	been	be	VBN
8691	4079	16	converted	convert	VBN
8691	4079	17	to	to	IN
8691	4079	18	this	this	DT
8691	4079	19	use	use	NN
8691	4079	20	,	,	,
8691	4079	21	and	and	CC
8691	4079	22	what	what	WP
8691	4079	23	was	be	VBD
8691	4079	24	formerly	formerly	RB
8691	4079	25	a	a	DT
8691	4079	26	handsome	handsome	JJ
8691	4079	27	mansion	mansion	NN
8691	4079	28	will	will	MD
8691	4079	29	have	have	VB
8691	4079	30	the	the	DT
8691	4079	31	chambers	chamber	NNS
8691	4079	32	of	of	IN
8691	4079	33	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	4079	34	on	on	IN
8691	4079	35	every	every	DT
8691	4079	36	floor	floor	NN
8691	4079	37	.	.	.
8691	4080	1	In	in	IN
8691	4080	2	many	many	JJ
8691	4080	3	of	of	IN
8691	4080	4	the	the	DT
8691	4080	5	counties	county	NNS
8691	4080	6	in	in	IN
8691	4080	7	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	4080	8	chambers	chamber	NNS
8691	4080	9	for	for	IN
8691	4080	10	the	the	DT
8691	4080	11	accommodation	accommodation	NN
8691	4080	12	of	of	IN
8691	4080	13	the	the	DT
8691	4080	14	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4080	15	are	be	VBP
8691	4080	16	built	build	VBN
8691	4080	17	in	in	IN
8691	4080	18	the	the	DT
8691	4080	19	rear	rear	NN
8691	4080	20	of	of	IN
8691	4080	21	the	the	DT
8691	4080	22	court	court	NN
8691	4080	23	-	-	HYPH
8691	4080	24	house	house	NN
8691	4080	25	on	on	IN
8691	4080	26	public	public	JJ
8691	4080	27	ground	ground	NN
8691	4080	28	.	.	.
8691	4081	1	A	a	DT
8691	4081	2	small	small	JJ
8691	4081	3	rent	rent	NN
8691	4081	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	4081	5	paid	pay	VBN
8691	4081	6	by	by	IN
8691	4081	7	the	the	DT
8691	4081	8	occupants	occupant	NNS
8691	4081	9	to	to	IN
8691	4081	10	the	the	DT
8691	4081	11	county	county	NN
8691	4081	12	.	.	.
8691	4082	1	When	when	WRB
8691	4082	2	court	court	NN
8691	4082	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	4082	4	about	about	JJ
8691	4082	5	to	to	TO
8691	4082	6	open	open	VB
8691	4082	7	each	each	DT
8691	4082	8	day	day	NN
8691	4082	9	the	the	DT
8691	4082	10	crier	crier	NN
8691	4082	11	calls	call	VBZ
8691	4082	12	out	out	RP
8691	4082	13	from	from	IN
8691	4082	14	one	one	CD
8691	4082	15	of	of	IN
8691	4082	16	the	the	DT
8691	4082	17	court	court	NN
8691	4082	18	-	-	HYPH
8691	4082	19	house	house	NN
8691	4082	20	windows	window	VBZ
8691	4082	21	the	the	DT
8691	4082	22	name	name	NN
8691	4082	23	of	of	IN
8691	4082	24	each	each	DT
8691	4082	25	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4082	26	to	to	TO
8691	4082	27	notify	notify	VB
8691	4082	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4082	29	of	of	IN
8691	4082	30	the	the	DT
8691	4082	31	fact	fact	NN
8691	4082	32	.	.	.
8691	4083	1	The	the	DT
8691	4083	2	relations	relation	NNS
8691	4083	3	of	of	IN
8691	4083	4	the	the	DT
8691	4083	5	bar	bar	NN
8691	4083	6	to	to	IN
8691	4083	7	the	the	DT
8691	4083	8	bench	bench	NN
8691	4083	9	assume	assume	VBP
8691	4083	10	a	a	DT
8691	4083	11	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
8691	4083	12	character	character	NN
8691	4083	13	under	under	IN
8691	4083	14	the	the	DT
8691	4083	15	conditions	condition	NNS
8691	4083	16	of	of	IN
8691	4083	17	American	american	JJ
8691	4083	18	society	society	NN
8691	4083	19	.	.	.
8691	4084	1	The	the	DT
8691	4084	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4084	3	stand	stand	VBP
8691	4084	4	closer	close	JJR
8691	4084	5	to	to	IN
8691	4084	6	the	the	DT
8691	4084	7	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4084	8	in	in	IN
8691	4084	9	this	this	DT
8691	4084	10	country	country	NN
8691	4084	11	than	than	IN
8691	4084	12	in	in	IN
8691	4084	13	any	any	DT
8691	4084	14	other	other	JJ
8691	4084	15	.	.	.
8691	4085	1	All	all	DT
8691	4085	2	of	of	IN
8691	4085	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4085	4	,	,	,
8691	4085	5	unlike	unlike	IN
8691	4085	6	those	those	DT
8691	4085	7	of	of	IN
8691	4085	8	continental	continental	JJ
8691	4085	9	Europe	Europe	NNP
8691	4085	10	,	,	,
8691	4085	11	have	have	VBP
8691	4085	12	been	be	VBN
8691	4085	13	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4085	14	practicing	practice	VBG
8691	4085	15	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4085	16	.	.	.
8691	4086	1	The	the	DT
8691	4086	2	majority	majority	NN
8691	4086	3	,	,	,
8691	4086	4	unlike	unlike	IN
8691	4086	5	those	those	DT
8691	4086	6	of	of	IN
8691	4086	7	England	England	NNP
8691	4086	8	,	,	,
8691	4086	9	are	be	VBP
8691	4086	10	young	young	JJ
8691	4086	11	men	man	NNS
8691	4086	12	,	,	,
8691	4086	13	sitting	sit	VBG
8691	4086	14	in	in	IN
8691	4086	15	minor	minor	JJ
8691	4086	16	courts	court	NNS
8691	4086	17	,	,	,
8691	4086	18	who	who	WP
8691	4086	19	have	have	VBP
8691	4086	20	generally	generally	RB
8691	4086	21	left	leave	VBN
8691	4086	22	the	the	DT
8691	4086	23	bar	bar	NN
8691	4086	24	for	for	IN
8691	4086	25	but	but	CC
8691	4086	26	a	a	DT
8691	4086	27	brief	brief	JJ
8691	4086	28	period	period	NN
8691	4086	29	,	,	,
8691	4086	30	expecting	expecting	NN
8691	4086	31	,	,	,
8691	4086	32	if	if	IN
8691	4086	33	not	not	RB
8691	4086	34	desiring	desire	VBG
8691	4086	35	,	,	,
8691	4086	36	soon	soon	RB
8691	4086	37	to	to	TO
8691	4086	38	return	return	VB
8691	4086	39	to	to	IN
8691	4086	40	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4086	41	.	.	.
8691	4087	1	Not	not	RB
8691	4087	2	a	a	DT
8691	4087	3	few	few	JJ
8691	4087	4	hold	hold	NN
8691	4087	5	court	court	NN
8691	4087	6	but	but	CC
8691	4087	7	one	one	CD
8691	4087	8	or	or	CC
8691	4087	9	two	two	CD
8691	4087	10	days	day	NNS
8691	4087	11	in	in	IN
8691	4087	12	the	the	DT
8691	4087	13	week	week	NN
8691	4087	14	or	or	CC
8691	4087	15	one	one	CD
8691	4087	16	or	or	CC
8691	4087	17	two	two	CD
8691	4087	18	hours	hour	NNS
8691	4087	19	in	in	IN
8691	4087	20	the	the	DT
8691	4087	21	day	day	NN
8691	4087	22	,	,	,
8691	4087	23	and	and	CC
8691	4087	24	for	for	IN
8691	4087	25	the	the	DT
8691	4087	26	rest	rest	NN
8691	4087	27	of	of	IN
8691	4087	28	the	the	DT
8691	4087	29	time	time	NN
8691	4087	30	are	be	VBP
8691	4087	31	actively	actively	RB
8691	4087	32	engaged	engage	VBN
8691	4087	33	in	in	IN
8691	4087	34	professional	professional	JJ
8691	4087	35	practice	practice	NN
8691	4087	36	before	before	IN
8691	4087	37	other	other	JJ
8691	4087	38	courts	court	NNS
8691	4087	39	.	.	.
8691	4088	1	Those	those	DT
8691	4088	2	of	of	IN
8691	4088	3	the	the	DT
8691	4088	4	latter	latter	JJ
8691	4088	5	description	description	NN
8691	4088	6	always	always	RB
8691	4088	7	occupy	occupy	VBP
8691	4088	8	a	a	DT
8691	4088	9	somewhat	somewhat	RB
8691	4088	10	unfortunate	unfortunate	JJ
8691	4088	11	position	position	NN
8691	4088	12	.	.	.
8691	4089	1	The	the	DT
8691	4089	2	State	State	NNP
8691	4089	3	does	do	VBZ
8691	4089	4	not	not	RB
8691	4089	5	expect	expect	VB
8691	4089	6	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4089	7	to	to	TO
8691	4089	8	devote	devote	VB
8691	4089	9	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4089	10	entirely	entirely	RB
8691	4089	11	to	to	IN
8691	4089	12	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4089	13	service	service	NN
8691	4089	14	.	.	.
8691	4090	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4090	2	does	do	VBZ
8691	4090	3	not	not	RB
8691	4090	4	provide	provide	VB
8691	4090	5	for	for	IN
8691	4090	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4090	7	compensation	compensation	NN
8691	4090	8	on	on	IN
8691	4090	9	that	that	DT
8691	4090	10	basis	basis	NN
8691	4090	11	.	.	.
8691	4091	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4091	2	expects	expect	VBZ
8691	4091	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4091	4	to	to	TO
8691	4091	5	continue	continue	VB
8691	4091	6	the	the	DT
8691	4091	7	general	general	JJ
8691	4091	8	practice	practice	NN
8691	4091	9	of	of	IN
8691	4091	10	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4091	11	profession	profession	NN
8691	4091	12	,	,	,
8691	4091	13	except	except	IN
8691	4091	14	so	so	RB
8691	4091	15	far	far	RB
8691	4091	16	as	as	IN
8691	4091	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4091	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4091	19	duties	duty	NNS
8691	4091	20	may	may	MD
8691	4091	21	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	4091	22	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	4091	23	.	.	.
8691	4092	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4092	2	certainly	certainly	RB
8691	4092	3	can	can	MD
8691	4092	4	not	not	RB
8691	4092	5	practice	practice	VB
8691	4092	6	in	in	IN
8691	4092	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4092	8	own	own	JJ
8691	4092	9	court	court	NN
8691	4092	10	with	with	IN
8691	4092	11	propriety	propriety	NN
8691	4092	12	.	.	.
8691	4093	1	Statutes	statute	NNS
8691	4093	2	to	to	TO
8691	4093	3	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	4093	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4093	5	are	be	VBP
8691	4093	6	not	not	RB
8691	4093	7	uncommon	uncommon	JJ
8691	4093	8	.	.	.
8691	4094	1	For	for	IN
8691	4094	2	the	the	DT
8691	4094	3	same	same	JJ
8691	4094	4	man	man	NN
8691	4094	5	to	to	TO
8691	4094	6	charge	charge	VB
8691	4094	7	the	the	DT
8691	4094	8	jury	jury	NN
8691	4094	9	one	one	CD
8691	4094	10	day	day	NN
8691	4094	11	as	as	IN
8691	4094	12	judge	judge	NN
8691	4094	13	and	and	CC
8691	4094	14	address	address	VB
8691	4094	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4094	16	the	the	DT
8691	4094	17	next	next	JJ
8691	4094	18	in	in	IN
8691	4094	19	argument	argument	NN
8691	4094	20	as	as	IN
8691	4094	21	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	4094	22	must	must	MD
8691	4094	23	tend	tend	VB
8691	4094	24	to	to	TO
8691	4094	25	confuse	confuse	VB
8691	4094	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4094	27	notions	notion	NNS
8691	4094	28	as	as	IN
8691	4094	29	to	to	IN
8691	4094	30	the	the	DT
8691	4094	31	weight	weight	NN
8691	4094	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4094	33	should	should	MD
8691	4094	34	give	give	VB
8691	4094	35	to	to	IN
8691	4094	36	what	what	WP
8691	4094	37	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4094	38	says	say	VBZ
8691	4094	39	,	,	,
8691	4094	40	and	and	CC
8691	4094	41	to	to	TO
8691	4094	42	lend	lend	VB
8691	4094	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4094	44	often	often	RB
8691	4094	45	a	a	DT
8691	4094	46	weight	weight	NN
8691	4094	47	which	which	WDT
8691	4094	48	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4094	49	may	may	MD
8691	4094	50	not	not	RB
8691	4094	51	deserve	deserve	VB
8691	4094	52	.	.	.
8691	4095	1	So	so	RB
8691	4095	2	,	,	,
8691	4095	3	too	too	RB
8691	4095	4	,	,	,
8691	4095	5	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4095	6	relations	relation	NNS
8691	4095	7	to	to	IN
8691	4095	8	the	the	DT
8691	4095	9	clerk	clerk	NN
8691	4095	10	and	and	CC
8691	4095	11	other	other	JJ
8691	4095	12	court	court	NN
8691	4095	13	officers	officer	NNS
8691	4095	14	are	be	VBP
8691	4095	15	such	such	JJ
8691	4095	16	officially	officially	RB
8691	4095	17	as	as	IN
8691	4095	18	to	to	TO
8691	4095	19	give	give	VB
8691	4095	20	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4095	21	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
8691	4095	22	for	for	IN
8691	4095	23	influencing	influence	VBG
8691	4095	24	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4095	25	when	when	WRB
8691	4095	26	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4095	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	4095	28	engaged	engage	VBN
8691	4095	29	at	at	IN
8691	4095	30	the	the	DT
8691	4095	31	bar	bar	NN
8691	4095	32	,	,	,
8691	4095	33	not	not	RB
8691	4095	34	shared	share	VBN
8691	4095	35	by	by	IN
8691	4095	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4095	37	brother	brother	NN
8691	4095	38	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4095	39	.	.	.
8691	4096	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4096	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4096	3	:	:	:
8691	4096	4	French	French	NNP
8691	4096	5	_	_	NNP
8691	4096	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	4096	7	_	_	NNP
8691	4096	8	Waterbury	Waterbury	NNP
8691	4096	9	,	,	,
8691	4096	10	72	72	CD
8691	4096	11	Conn.	Connecticut	NNP
8691	4096	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	4096	13	,	,	,
8691	4096	14	435	435	CD
8691	4096	15	;	;	:
8691	4096	16	44	44	CD
8691	4096	17	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	4096	18	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	4096	19	,	,	,
8691	4096	20	740	740	CD
8691	4096	21	.	.	.
8691	4096	22	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4097	1	There	there	EX
8691	4097	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4097	3	,	,	,
8691	4097	4	however	however	RB
8691	4097	5	,	,	,
8691	4097	6	in	in	IN
8691	4097	7	every	every	DT
8691	4097	8	State	state	NN
8691	4097	9	quite	quite	PDT
8691	4097	10	a	a	DT
8691	4097	11	number	number	NN
8691	4097	12	of	of	IN
8691	4097	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4097	14	of	of	IN
8691	4097	15	higher	high	JJR
8691	4097	16	courts	court	NNS
8691	4097	17	who	who	WP
8691	4097	18	receive	receive	VBP
8691	4097	19	a	a	DT
8691	4097	20	salary	salary	NN
8691	4097	21	deemed	deem	VBN
8691	4097	22	sufficient	sufficient	JJ
8691	4097	23	for	for	IN
8691	4097	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4097	25	support	support	NN
8691	4097	26	and	and	CC
8691	4097	27	who	who	WP
8691	4097	28	are	be	VBP
8691	4097	29	expected	expect	VBN
8691	4097	30	to	to	TO
8691	4097	31	devote	devote	VB
8691	4097	32	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4097	33	entire	entire	JJ
8691	4097	34	time	time	NN
8691	4097	35	to	to	IN
8691	4097	36	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4097	37	duties	duty	NNS
8691	4097	38	.	.	.
8691	4098	1	As	as	IN
8691	4098	2	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	4098	3	those	those	DT
8691	4098	4	of	of	IN
8691	4098	5	the	the	DT
8691	4098	6	United	United	NNP
8691	4098	7	States	States	NNP
8691	4098	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	4098	9	there	there	EX
8691	4098	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	4098	11	a	a	DT
8691	4098	12	statute	statute	NN
8691	4098	13	(	(	-LRB-
8691	4098	14	U.	U.	NNP
8691	4098	15	S.	S.	NNP
8691	4098	16	Revised	Revised	NNP
8691	4098	17	Statutes	Statutes	NNPS
8691	4098	18	,	,	,
8691	4098	19	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	4098	20	.	.	.
8691	4099	1	713	713	LS
8691	4099	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	4099	3	making	make	VBG
8691	4099	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4099	5	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	4099	6	for	for	IN
8691	4099	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4099	8	to	to	TO
8691	4099	9	practice	practice	VB
8691	4099	10	law	law	NN
8691	4099	11	.	.	.
8691	4100	1	Similar	similar	JJ
8691	4100	2	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	4100	3	exists	exist	VBZ
8691	4100	4	in	in	IN
8691	4100	5	some	some	DT
8691	4100	6	of	of	IN
8691	4100	7	the	the	DT
8691	4100	8	States	States	NNPS
8691	4100	9	with	with	IN
8691	4100	10	regard	regard	NN
8691	4100	11	to	to	IN
8691	4100	12	the	the	DT
8691	4100	13	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4100	14	of	of	IN
8691	4100	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4100	16	higher	high	JJR
8691	4100	17	courts	court	NNS
8691	4100	18	,	,	,
8691	4100	19	but	but	CC
8691	4100	20	without	without	IN
8691	4100	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4100	22	a	a	DT
8691	4100	23	sense	sense	NN
8691	4100	24	of	of	IN
8691	4100	25	propriety	propriety	NN
8691	4100	26	dictates	dictate	VBZ
8691	4100	27	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4100	28	abstaining	abstaining	NN
8691	4100	29	from	from	IN
8691	4100	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4100	31	,	,	,
8691	4100	32	and	and	CC
8691	4100	33	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4100	34	has	have	VBZ
8691	4100	35	even	even	RB
8691	4100	36	been	be	VBN
8691	4100	37	held	hold	VBN
8691	4100	38	that	that	IN
8691	4100	39	the	the	DT
8691	4100	40	right	right	NN
8691	4100	41	of	of	IN
8691	4100	42	any	any	DT
8691	4100	43	judge	judge	NN
8691	4100	44	of	of	IN
8691	4100	45	a	a	DT
8691	4100	46	superior	superior	JJ
8691	4100	47	trial	trial	NN
8691	4100	48	court	court	NN
8691	4100	49	of	of	IN
8691	4100	50	general	general	JJ
8691	4100	51	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	4100	52	over	over	IN
8691	4100	53	important	important	JJ
8691	4100	54	causes	cause	NNS
8691	4100	55	to	to	TO
8691	4100	56	act	act	VB
8691	4100	57	as	as	IN
8691	4100	58	an	an	DT
8691	4100	59	attorney	attorney	NN
8691	4100	60	or	or	CC
8691	4100	61	counsellor	counsellor	NN
8691	4100	62	,	,	,
8691	4100	63	except	except	IN
8691	4100	64	in	in	IN
8691	4100	65	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4100	66	own	own	JJ
8691	4100	67	cause	cause	NN
8691	4100	68	,	,	,
8691	4100	69	is	be	VBZ
8691	4100	70	suspended	suspend	VBN
8691	4100	71	by	by	IN
8691	4100	72	implication	implication	NN
8691	4100	73	of	of	IN
8691	4100	74	law	law	NN
8691	4100	75	so	so	RB
8691	4100	76	long	long	RB
8691	4100	77	as	as	IN
8691	4100	78	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4100	79	retains	retain	VBZ
8691	4100	80	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4100	81	seat	seat	NN
8691	4100	82	on	on	IN
8691	4100	83	the	the	DT
8691	4100	84	bench	bench	NN
8691	4100	85	.	.	.
8691	4101	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4101	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4101	3	:	:	:
8691	4101	4	Perry	Perry	NNP
8691	4101	5	_	_	NNP
8691	4101	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	4101	7	_	_	NNP
8691	4101	8	Bush	Bush	NNP
8691	4101	9	,	,	,
8691	4101	10	45	45	CD
8691	4101	11	Florida	Florida	NNP
8691	4101	12	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	4101	13	;	;	:
8691	4101	14	35	35	CD
8691	4101	15	Southern	southern	JJ
8691	4101	16	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	4101	17	,	,	,
8691	4101	18	225	225	CD
8691	4101	19	.	.	.
8691	4101	20	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4102	1	The	the	DT
8691	4102	2	demeanor	demeanor	NN
8691	4102	3	of	of	IN
8691	4102	4	the	the	DT
8691	4102	5	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4102	6	to	to	IN
8691	4102	7	the	the	DT
8691	4102	8	bar	bar	NN
8691	4102	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	4102	10	inevitably	inevitably	RB
8691	4102	11	affected	affect	VBN
8691	4102	12	to	to	IN
8691	4102	13	some	some	DT
8691	4102	14	extent	extent	NN
8691	4102	15	by	by	IN
8691	4102	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4102	17	tenure	tenure	NN
8691	4102	18	of	of	IN
8691	4102	19	office	office	NN
8691	4102	20	.	.	.
8691	4103	1	If	if	IN
8691	4103	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4103	3	hold	hold	VBP
8691	4103	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4103	5	places	place	NNS
8691	4103	6	for	for	IN
8691	4103	7	life	life	NN
8691	4103	8	,	,	,
8691	4103	9	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4103	10	naturally	naturally	RB
8691	4103	11	are	be	VBP
8691	4103	12	less	less	RBR
8691	4103	13	sedulous	sedulous	JJ
8691	4103	14	to	to	TO
8691	4103	15	avoid	avoid	VB
8691	4103	16	giving	give	VBG
8691	4103	17	offense	offense	NN
8691	4103	18	and	and	CC
8691	4103	19	less	less	RBR
8691	4103	20	ready	ready	JJ
8691	4103	21	to	to	TO
8691	4103	22	tolerate	tolerate	VB
8691	4103	23	a	a	DT
8691	4103	24	poor	poor	JJ
8691	4103	25	or	or	CC
8691	4103	26	tedious	tedious	JJ
8691	4103	27	argument	argument	NN
8691	4103	28	.	.	.
8691	4104	1	A	a	DT
8691	4104	2	greater	great	JJR
8691	4104	3	distance	distance	NN
8691	4104	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	4104	5	maintained	maintain	VBN
8691	4104	6	for	for	IN
8691	4104	7	this	this	DT
8691	4104	8	cause	cause	NN
8691	4104	9	between	between	IN
8691	4104	10	bench	bench	NN
8691	4104	11	and	and	CC
8691	4104	12	bar	bar	NN
8691	4104	13	in	in	IN
8691	4104	14	the	the	DT
8691	4104	15	federal	federal	JJ
8691	4104	16	courts	court	NNS
8691	4104	17	than	than	IN
8691	4104	18	is	be	VBZ
8691	4104	19	usual	usual	JJ
8691	4104	20	in	in	IN
8691	4104	21	most	most	JJS
8691	4104	22	of	of	IN
8691	4104	23	the	the	DT
8691	4104	24	State	State	NNP
8691	4104	25	courts	court	NNS
8691	4104	26	.	.	.
8691	4105	1	No	no	DT
8691	4105	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	4105	3	,	,	,
8691	4105	4	however	however	RB
8691	4105	5	,	,	,
8691	4105	6	desires	desire	NNS
8691	4105	7	to	to	TO
8691	4105	8	have	have	VB
8691	4105	9	the	the	DT
8691	4105	10	reputation	reputation	NN
8691	4105	11	of	of	IN
8691	4105	12	being	be	VBG
8691	4105	13	overbearing	overbearing	JJ
8691	4105	14	,	,	,
8691	4105	15	rough	rough	JJ
8691	4105	16	or	or	CC
8691	4105	17	impatient	impatient	JJ
8691	4105	18	,	,	,
8691	4105	19	and	and	CC
8691	4105	20	few	few	JJ
8691	4105	21	are	be	VBP
8691	4105	22	.	.	.
8691	4106	1	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	4106	2	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	4106	3	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
8691	4106	4	of	of	IN
8691	4106	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	4106	6	at	at	IN
8691	4106	7	one	one	CD
8691	4106	8	time	time	NN
8691	4106	9	fell	fall	VBD
8691	4106	10	into	into	IN
8691	4106	11	an	an	DT
8691	4106	12	inveterate	inveterate	JJ
8691	4106	13	habit	habit	NN
8691	4106	14	on	on	IN
8691	4106	15	the	the	DT
8691	4106	16	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	4106	17	of	of	IN
8691	4106	18	checking	check	VBG
8691	4106	19	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	4106	20	in	in	IN
8691	4106	21	argument	argument	NN
8691	4106	22	rather	rather	RB
8691	4106	23	curtly	curtly	RB
8691	4106	24	when	when	WRB
8691	4106	25	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4106	26	seemed	seem	VBD
8691	4106	27	to	to	IN
8691	4106	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4106	29	to	to	TO
8691	4106	30	wander	wander	VB
8691	4106	31	from	from	IN
8691	4106	32	the	the	DT
8691	4106	33	vital	vital	JJ
8691	4106	34	point	point	NN
8691	4106	35	.	.	.
8691	4107	1	The	the	DT
8691	4107	2	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	4107	3	of	of	IN
8691	4107	4	the	the	DT
8691	4107	5	bar	bar	NN
8691	4107	6	of	of	IN
8691	4107	7	Boston	Boston	NNP
8691	4107	8	finally	finally	RB
8691	4107	9	determined	determine	VBD
8691	4107	10	to	to	TO
8691	4107	11	stop	stop	VB
8691	4107	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4107	13	,	,	,
8691	4107	14	and	and	CC
8691	4107	15	arranged	arrange	VBD
8691	4107	16	at	at	IN
8691	4107	17	the	the	DT
8691	4107	18	next	next	JJ
8691	4107	19	term	term	NN
8691	4107	20	at	at	IN
8691	4107	21	which	which	WDT
8691	4107	22	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4107	23	was	be	VBD
8691	4107	24	to	to	TO
8691	4107	25	preside	preside	VB
8691	4107	26	that	that	IN
8691	4107	27	whoever	whoever	WP
8691	4107	28	of	of	IN
8691	4107	29	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4107	30	was	be	VBD
8691	4107	31	thus	thus	RB
8691	4107	32	treated	treat	VBN
8691	4107	33	should	should	MD
8691	4107	34	leave	leave	VB
8691	4107	35	the	the	DT
8691	4107	36	court	court	NN
8691	4107	37	room	room	NN
8691	4107	38	.	.	.
8691	4108	1	The	the	DT
8691	4108	2	first	first	JJ
8691	4108	3	to	to	TO
8691	4108	4	address	address	VB
8691	4108	5	the	the	DT
8691	4108	6	court	court	NN
8691	4108	7	was	be	VBD
8691	4108	8	checked	check	VBN
8691	4108	9	in	in	IN
8691	4108	10	the	the	DT
8691	4108	11	usual	usual	JJ
8691	4108	12	manner	manner	NN
8691	4108	13	,	,	,
8691	4108	14	and	and	CC
8691	4108	15	observing	observe	VBG
8691	4108	16	that	that	IN
8691	4108	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4108	18	regretted	regret	VBD
8691	4108	19	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4108	20	argument	argument	NN
8691	4108	21	seemed	seem	VBD
8691	4108	22	not	not	RB
8691	4108	23	worthy	worthy	JJ
8691	4108	24	of	of	IN
8691	4108	25	the	the	DT
8691	4108	26	court	court	NN
8691	4108	27	's	's	POS
8691	4108	28	attention	attention	NN
8691	4108	29	,	,	,
8691	4108	30	took	take	VBD
8691	4108	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4108	32	papers	paper	NNS
8691	4108	33	and	and	CC
8691	4108	34	went	go	VBD
8691	4108	35	out	out	RP
8691	4108	36	.	.	.
8691	4109	1	The	the	DT
8691	4109	2	next	next	JJ
8691	4109	3	met	meet	VBD
8691	4109	4	the	the	DT
8691	4109	5	same	same	JJ
8691	4109	6	kind	kind	NN
8691	4109	7	of	of	IN
8691	4109	8	interruption	interruption	NN
8691	4109	9	in	in	IN
8691	4109	10	the	the	DT
8691	4109	11	same	same	JJ
8691	4109	12	way	way	NN
8691	4109	13	,	,	,
8691	4109	14	and	and	CC
8691	4109	15	so	so	RB
8691	4109	16	on	on	RB
8691	4109	17	until	until	IN
8691	4109	18	the	the	DT
8691	4109	19	court	court	NN
8691	4109	20	room	room	NN
8691	4109	21	was	be	VBD
8691	4109	22	cleared	clear	VBN
8691	4109	23	.	.	.
8691	4110	1	The	the	DT
8691	4110	2	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	4110	3	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	4110	4	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	4110	5	sought	seek	VBD
8691	4110	6	an	an	DT
8691	4110	7	explanation	explanation	NN
8691	4110	8	,	,	,
8691	4110	9	received	receive	VBD
8691	4110	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4110	11	in	in	IN
8691	4110	12	good	good	JJ
8691	4110	13	part	part	NN
8691	4110	14	,	,	,
8691	4110	15	and	and	CC
8691	4110	16	was	be	VBD
8691	4110	17	forever	forever	RB
8691	4110	18	cured	cure	VBN
8691	4110	19	of	of	IN
8691	4110	20	what	what	WP
8691	4110	21	had	have	VBD
8691	4110	22	been	be	VBN
8691	4110	23	a	a	DT
8691	4110	24	serious	serious	JJ
8691	4110	25	impediment	impediment	NN
8691	4110	26	to	to	IN
8691	4110	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4110	28	usefulness	usefulness	NN
8691	4110	29	on	on	IN
8691	4110	30	the	the	DT
8691	4110	31	bench	bench	NN
8691	4110	32	.	.	.
8691	4111	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4111	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4111	3	:	:	:
8691	4111	4	See	see	VB
8691	4111	5	George	George	NNP
8691	4111	6	F.	F.	NNP
8691	4111	7	Hoar	Hoar	NNP
8691	4111	8	,	,	,
8691	4111	9	Autobiography	Autobiography	NNP
8691	4111	10	,	,	,
8691	4111	11	II	II	NNP
8691	4111	12	,	,	,
8691	4111	13	397	397	CD
8691	4111	14	.	.	.
8691	4111	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4112	1	Occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	4112	2	a	a	DT
8691	4112	3	trial	trial	NN
8691	4112	4	judge	judge	NN
8691	4112	5	will	will	MD
8691	4112	6	have	have	VB
8691	4112	7	a	a	DT
8691	4112	8	similar	similar	JJ
8691	4112	9	lesson	lesson	NN
8691	4112	10	taught	teach	VBD
8691	4112	11	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4112	12	by	by	IN
8691	4112	13	finding	find	VBG
8691	4112	14	no	no	DT
8691	4112	15	business	business	NN
8691	4112	16	to	to	TO
8691	4112	17	be	be	VB
8691	4112	18	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	4112	19	of	of	IN
8691	4112	20	when	when	WRB
8691	4112	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4112	22	opens	open	VBZ
8691	4112	23	court	court	NN
8691	4112	24	,	,	,
8691	4112	25	and	and	CC
8691	4112	26	learning	learn	VBG
8691	4112	27	later	later	RB
8691	4112	28	that	that	IN
8691	4112	29	the	the	DT
8691	4112	30	bar	bar	NN
8691	4112	31	agreed	agree	VBD
8691	4112	32	to	to	IN
8691	4112	33	the	the	DT
8691	4112	34	continuance	continuance	NN
8691	4112	35	of	of	IN
8691	4112	36	all	all	DT
8691	4112	37	pending	pende	VBG
8691	4112	38	cases	case	NNS
8691	4112	39	,	,	,
8691	4112	40	because	because	IN
8691	4112	41	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4112	42	did	do	VBD
8691	4112	43	not	not	RB
8691	4112	44	care	care	VB
8691	4112	45	to	to	TO
8691	4112	46	trust	trust	VB
8691	4112	47	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4112	48	with	with	IN
8691	4112	49	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4112	50	,	,	,
8691	4112	51	or	or	CC
8691	4112	52	were	be	VBD
8691	4112	53	disinclined	disinclined	JJ
8691	4112	54	to	to	TO
8691	4112	55	submit	submit	VB
8691	4112	56	to	to	IN
8691	4112	57	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4112	58	manner	manner	NN
8691	4112	59	of	of	IN
8691	4112	60	conducting	conduct	VBG
8691	4112	61	a	a	DT
8691	4112	62	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	4112	63	.	.	.
8691	4113	1	Judges	judge	NNS
8691	4113	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4113	3	universally	universally	RB
8691	4113	4	desirous	desirous	JJ
8691	4113	5	of	of	IN
8691	4113	6	securing	secure	VBG
8691	4113	7	the	the	DT
8691	4113	8	good	good	JJ
8691	4113	9	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	4113	10	of	of	IN
8691	4113	11	the	the	DT
8691	4113	12	bar	bar	NN
8691	4113	13	as	as	IN
8691	4113	14	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	4113	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4113	16	knowledge	knowledge	NN
8691	4113	17	of	of	IN
8691	4113	18	law	law	NN
8691	4113	19	and	and	CC
8691	4113	20	powers	power	NNS
8691	4113	21	of	of	IN
8691	4113	22	discrimination	discrimination	NN
8691	4113	23	and	and	CC
8691	4113	24	analysis	analysis	NN
8691	4113	25	.	.	.
8691	4114	1	The	the	DT
8691	4114	2	bar	bar	NN
8691	4114	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	4114	4	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4114	5	little	little	JJ
8691	4114	6	world	world	NN
8691	4114	7	.	.	.
8691	4115	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4115	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4115	3	a	a	DT
8691	4115	4	critical	critical	JJ
8691	4115	5	world	world	NN
8691	4115	6	,	,	,
8691	4115	7	for	for	IN
8691	4115	8	in	in	IN
8691	4115	9	every	every	DT
8691	4115	10	case	case	NN
8691	4115	11	that	that	WDT
8691	4115	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	4115	13	tried	try	VBN
8691	4115	14	there	there	EX
8691	4115	15	will	will	MD
8691	4115	16	be	be	VB
8691	4115	17	one	one	CD
8691	4115	18	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4115	19	who	who	WP
8691	4115	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	4115	21	dissatisfied	dissatisfied	JJ
8691	4115	22	with	with	IN
8691	4115	23	the	the	DT
8691	4115	24	result	result	NN
8691	4115	25	,	,	,
8691	4115	26	and	and	CC
8691	4115	27	likely	likely	JJ
8691	4115	28	to	to	TO
8691	4115	29	think	think	VB
8691	4115	30	the	the	DT
8691	4115	31	judge	judge	NN
8691	4115	32	wrong	wrong	RB
8691	4115	33	rather	rather	RB
8691	4115	34	than	than	IN
8691	4115	35	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4115	36	,	,	,
8691	4115	37	if	if	IN
8691	4115	38	every	every	DT
8691	4115	39	proposition	proposition	NN
8691	4115	40	of	of	IN
8691	4115	41	law	law	NN
8691	4115	42	which	which	WDT
8691	4115	43	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4115	44	has	have	VBZ
8691	4115	45	asserted	assert	VBN
8691	4115	46	has	have	VBZ
8691	4115	47	not	not	RB
8691	4115	48	been	be	VBN
8691	4115	49	conceded	concede	VBN
8691	4115	50	.	.	.
8691	4116	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4116	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4116	3	much	much	RB
8691	4116	4	more	more	RBR
8691	4116	5	common	common	JJ
8691	4116	6	for	for	IN
8691	4116	7	American	american	JJ
8691	4116	8	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4116	9	to	to	TO
8691	4116	10	be	be	VB
8691	4116	11	too	too	RB
8691	4116	12	tolerant	tolerant	JJ
8691	4116	13	of	of	IN
8691	4116	14	a	a	DT
8691	4116	15	waste	waste	NN
8691	4116	16	of	of	IN
8691	4116	17	time	time	NN
8691	4116	18	by	by	IN
8691	4116	19	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	4116	20	than	than	IN
8691	4116	21	to	to	TO
8691	4116	22	be	be	VB
8691	4116	23	too	too	RB
8691	4116	24	impatient	impatient	JJ
8691	4116	25	at	at	IN
8691	4116	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4116	27	.	.	.
8691	4117	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4117	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4117	3	:	:	:
8691	4117	4	See	see	VB
8691	4117	5	a	a	DT
8691	4117	6	striking	striking	JJ
8691	4117	7	instance	instance	NN
8691	4117	8	of	of	IN
8691	4117	9	this	this	DT
8691	4117	10	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	4117	11	given	give	VBN
8691	4117	12	in	in	IN
8691	4117	13	Cleveland	Cleveland	NNP
8691	4117	14	,	,	,
8691	4117	15	Painesville	Painesville	NNP
8691	4117	16	&	&	CC
8691	4117	17	Eastern	Eastern	NNP
8691	4117	18	R.	R.	NNP
8691	4117	19	R.	R.	NNP
8691	4117	20	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	4117	21	_	_	NNP
8691	4117	22	v.	v.	IN
8691	4117	23	_	_	NNP
8691	4117	24	Pritschau	Pritschau	NNP
8691	4117	25	,	,	,
8691	4117	26	69	69	CD
8691	4117	27	Ohio	Ohio	NNP
8691	4117	28	State	State	NNP
8691	4117	29	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	4117	30	,	,	,
8691	4117	31	438	438	CD
8691	4117	32	;	;	:
8691	4117	33	69	69	CD
8691	4117	34	Eastern	eastern	JJ
8691	4117	35	Reporter	reporter	NN
8691	4117	36	,	,	,
8691	4117	37	663	663	CD
8691	4117	38	.	.	.
8691	4117	39	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4118	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4118	2	dislike	dislike	VBP
8691	4118	3	even	even	RB
8691	4118	4	to	to	TO
8691	4118	5	seem	seem	VB
8691	4118	6	harsh	harsh	JJ
8691	4118	7	.	.	.
8691	4119	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	4119	2	of	of	IN
8691	4119	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4119	4	also	also	RB
8691	4119	5	hold	hold	VBP
8691	4119	6	office	office	NN
8691	4119	7	only	only	RB
8691	4119	8	for	for	IN
8691	4119	9	a	a	DT
8691	4119	10	term	term	NN
8691	4119	11	of	of	IN
8691	4119	12	years	year	NNS
8691	4119	13	and	and	CC
8691	4119	14	do	do	VBP
8691	4119	15	not	not	RB
8691	4119	16	forget	forget	VB
8691	4119	17	that	that	IN
8691	4119	18	undue	undue	JJ
8691	4119	19	severity	severity	NN
8691	4119	20	may	may	MD
8691	4119	21	jeopardize	jeopardize	VB
8691	4119	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4119	23	re	re	NN
8691	4119	24	-	-	NN
8691	4119	25	election	election	NN
8691	4119	26	.	.	.
8691	4120	1	This	this	DT
8691	4120	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4120	3	one	one	CD
8691	4120	4	reason	reason	NN
8691	4120	5	for	for	IN
8691	4120	6	the	the	DT
8691	4120	7	fact	fact	NN
8691	4120	8	that	that	IN
8691	4120	9	at	at	IN
8691	4120	10	all	all	DT
8691	4120	11	points	point	NNS
8691	4120	12	the	the	DT
8691	4120	13	bar	bar	NN
8691	4120	14	are	be	VBP
8691	4120	15	subject	subject	JJ
8691	4120	16	to	to	IN
8691	4120	17	fewer	few	JJR
8691	4120	18	restrictions	restriction	NNS
8691	4120	19	upon	upon	IN
8691	4120	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4120	21	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	4120	22	in	in	IN
8691	4120	23	the	the	DT
8691	4120	24	trial	trial	NN
8691	4120	25	of	of	IN
8691	4120	26	causes	cause	NNS
8691	4120	27	in	in	IN
8691	4120	28	American	american	JJ
8691	4120	29	courts	court	NNS
8691	4120	30	than	than	IN
8691	4120	31	in	in	IN
8691	4120	32	those	those	DT
8691	4120	33	of	of	IN
8691	4120	34	most	most	JJS
8691	4120	35	other	other	JJ
8691	4120	36	countries	country	NNS
8691	4120	37	.	.	.
8691	4121	1	Another	another	DT
8691	4121	2	,	,	,
8691	4121	3	and	and	CC
8691	4121	4	a	a	DT
8691	4121	5	more	more	RBR
8691	4121	6	fundamental	fundamental	JJ
8691	4121	7	one	one	NN
8691	4121	8	,	,	,
8691	4121	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	4121	10	that	that	IN
8691	4121	11	the	the	DT
8691	4121	12	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4121	13	and	and	CC
8691	4121	14	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4121	15	stand	stand	VBP
8691	4121	16	more	more	RBR
8691	4121	17	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	4121	18	on	on	IN
8691	4121	19	the	the	DT
8691	4121	20	same	same	JJ
8691	4121	21	level	level	NN
8691	4121	22	both	both	DT
8691	4121	23	in	in	IN
8691	4121	24	public	public	JJ
8691	4121	25	regard	regard	NN
8691	4121	26	and	and	CC
8691	4121	27	official	official	JJ
8691	4121	28	position	position	NN
8691	4121	29	.	.	.
8691	4122	1	The	the	DT
8691	4122	2	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4122	3	holds	hold	VBZ
8691	4122	4	a	a	DT
8691	4122	5	more	more	RBR
8691	4122	6	permanent	permanent	JJ
8691	4122	7	office	office	NN
8691	4122	8	in	in	IN
8691	4122	9	the	the	DT
8691	4122	10	court	court	NN
8691	4122	11	than	than	IN
8691	4122	12	the	the	DT
8691	4122	13	judge	judge	NN
8691	4122	14	.	.	.
8691	4123	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4123	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4123	3	quite	quite	RB
8691	4123	4	likely	likely	JJ
8691	4123	5	to	to	TO
8691	4123	6	be	be	VB
8691	4123	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4123	8	superior	superior	JJ
8691	4123	9	in	in	IN
8691	4123	10	learning	learning	NN
8691	4123	11	and	and	CC
8691	4123	12	ability	ability	NN
8691	4123	13	.	.	.
8691	4124	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4124	2	belongs	belong	VBZ
8691	4124	3	to	to	IN
8691	4124	4	a	a	DT
8691	4124	5	class	class	NN
8691	4124	6	that	that	WDT
8691	4124	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4124	8	influential	influential	JJ
8691	4124	9	in	in	IN
8691	4124	10	the	the	DT
8691	4124	11	community	community	NN
8691	4124	12	,	,	,
8691	4124	13	and	and	CC
8691	4124	14	whose	whose	WP$
8691	4124	15	members	member	NNS
8691	4124	16	usually	usually	RB
8691	4124	17	share	share	VBP
8691	4124	18	quite	quite	RB
8691	4124	19	actively	actively	RB
8691	4124	20	in	in	IN
8691	4124	21	the	the	DT
8691	4124	22	direction	direction	NN
8691	4124	23	of	of	IN
8691	4124	24	party	party	NN
8691	4124	25	politics	politic	NNS
8691	4124	26	.	.	.
8691	4125	1	The	the	DT
8691	4125	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	4125	3	in	in	IN
8691	4125	4	most	most	JJS
8691	4125	5	instances	instance	NNS
8691	4125	6	holds	hold	VBZ
8691	4125	7	but	but	CC
8691	4125	8	a	a	DT
8691	4125	9	brief	brief	JJ
8691	4125	10	authority	authority	NN
8691	4125	11	.	.	.
8691	4126	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4126	2	does	do	VBZ
8691	4126	3	not	not	RB
8691	4126	4	wish	wish	VB
8691	4126	5	to	to	TO
8691	4126	6	parade	parade	VB
8691	4126	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4126	8	in	in	IN
8691	4126	9	such	such	PDT
8691	4126	10	a	a	DT
8691	4126	11	manner	manner	NN
8691	4126	12	as	as	IN
8691	4126	13	might	may	MD
8691	4126	14	seem	seem	VB
8691	4126	15	offensive	offensive	JJ
8691	4126	16	.	.	.
8691	4127	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4127	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4127	3	in	in	IN
8691	4127	4	danger	danger	NN
8691	4127	5	of	of	IN
8691	4127	6	seeming	seem	VBG
8691	4127	7	to	to	TO
8691	4127	8	parade	parade	VB
8691	4127	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4127	10	if	if	IN
8691	4127	11	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4127	12	goes	go	VBZ
8691	4127	13	beyond	beyond	IN
8691	4127	14	what	what	WP
8691	4127	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	4127	16	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	4127	17	in	in	IN
8691	4127	18	regulating	regulate	VBG
8691	4127	19	the	the	DT
8691	4127	20	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	4127	21	of	of	IN
8691	4127	22	the	the	DT
8691	4127	23	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4127	24	who	who	WP
8691	4127	25	may	may	MD
8691	4127	26	appear	appear	VB
8691	4127	27	before	before	IN
8691	4127	28	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4127	29	.	.	.
8691	4128	1	The	the	DT
8691	4128	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	4128	3	who	who	WP
8691	4128	4	keeps	keep	VBZ
8691	4128	5	a	a	DT
8691	4128	6	rigid	rigid	JJ
8691	4128	7	watch	watch	NN
8691	4128	8	on	on	IN
8691	4128	9	the	the	DT
8691	4128	10	examination	examination	NN
8691	4128	11	of	of	IN
8691	4128	12	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	4128	13	to	to	TO
8691	4128	14	exclude	exclude	VB
8691	4128	15	all	all	DT
8691	4128	16	improper	improper	JJ
8691	4128	17	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	4128	18	,	,	,
8691	4128	19	whether	whether	IN
8691	4128	20	objection	objection	NN
8691	4128	21	be	be	VB
8691	4128	22	made	make	VBN
8691	4128	23	to	to	IN
8691	4128	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4128	25	or	or	CC
8691	4128	26	not	not	RB
8691	4128	27	,	,	,
8691	4128	28	declines	decline	VBZ
8691	4128	29	to	to	TO
8691	4128	30	hear	hear	VB
8691	4128	31	argument	argument	NN
8691	4128	32	on	on	IN
8691	4128	33	matters	matter	NNS
8691	4128	34	that	that	WDT
8691	4128	35	may	may	MD
8691	4128	36	appear	appear	VB
8691	4128	37	to	to	IN
8691	4128	38	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4128	39	too	too	RB
8691	4128	40	clear	clear	JJ
8691	4128	41	to	to	TO
8691	4128	42	justify	justify	VB
8691	4128	43	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4128	44	,	,	,
8691	4128	45	and	and	CC
8691	4128	46	is	be	VBZ
8691	4128	47	impatient	impatient	JJ
8691	4128	48	when	when	WRB
8691	4128	49	argument	argument	NN
8691	4128	50	on	on	IN
8691	4128	51	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
8691	4128	52	points	point	NNS
8691	4128	53	is	be	VBZ
8691	4128	54	continued	continue	VBN
8691	4128	55	longer	long	RBR
8691	4128	56	than	than	IN
8691	4128	57	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4128	58	thinks	think	VBZ
8691	4128	59	worth	worth	JJ
8691	4128	60	while	while	IN
8691	4128	61	,	,	,
8691	4128	62	may	may	MD
8691	4128	63	be	be	VB
8691	4128	64	respected	respect	VBN
8691	4128	65	,	,	,
8691	4128	66	but	but	CC
8691	4128	67	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4128	68	will	will	MD
8691	4128	69	never	never	RB
8691	4128	70	be	be	VB
8691	4128	71	popular	popular	JJ
8691	4128	72	.	.	.
8691	4129	1	Trials	trial	NNS
8691	4129	2	for	for	IN
8691	4129	3	these	these	DT
8691	4129	4	reasons	reason	NNS
8691	4129	5	are	be	VBP
8691	4129	6	longer	long	JJR
8691	4129	7	in	in	IN
8691	4129	8	the	the	DT
8691	4129	9	United	United	NNP
8691	4129	10	States	States	NNP
8691	4129	11	than	than	IN
8691	4129	12	in	in	IN
8691	4129	13	England	England	NNP
8691	4129	14	.	.	.
8691	4130	1	Fewer	few	JJR
8691	4130	2	summary	summary	NN
8691	4130	3	rulings	ruling	NNS
8691	4130	4	are	be	VBP
8691	4130	5	made	make	VBN
8691	4130	6	.	.	.
8691	4131	1	More	more	RBR
8691	4131	2	questionable	questionable	JJ
8691	4131	3	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	4131	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	4131	5	admitted	admit	VBN
8691	4131	6	.	.	.
8691	4132	1	More	More	JJR
8691	4132	2	time	time	NN
8691	4132	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	4132	4	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	4132	5	to	to	TO
8691	4132	6	counsel	counsel	VB
8691	4132	7	in	in	IN
8691	4132	8	the	the	DT
8691	4132	9	argument	argument	NN
8691	4132	10	of	of	IN
8691	4132	11	the	the	DT
8691	4132	12	cause	cause	NN
8691	4132	13	,	,	,
8691	4132	14	and	and	CC
8691	4132	15	more	more	JJR
8691	4132	16	freedom	freedom	NN
8691	4132	17	in	in	IN
8691	4132	18	arguing	argue	VBG
8691	4132	19	points	point	NNS
8691	4132	20	that	that	WDT
8691	4132	21	may	may	MD
8691	4132	22	seem	seem	VB
8691	4132	23	immaterial	immaterial	JJ
8691	4132	24	to	to	IN
8691	4132	25	the	the	DT
8691	4132	26	court	court	NN
8691	4132	27	.	.	.
8691	4133	1	The	the	DT
8691	4133	2	broad	broad	JJ
8691	4133	3	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	4133	4	of	of	IN
8691	4133	5	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	4133	6	generally	generally	RB
8691	4133	7	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	4133	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	4133	9	another	another	DT
8691	4133	10	reason	reason	NN
8691	4133	11	for	for	IN
8691	4133	12	hesitation	hesitation	NN
8691	4133	13	on	on	IN
8691	4133	14	the	the	DT
8691	4133	15	part	part	NN
8691	4133	16	of	of	IN
8691	4133	17	trial	trial	NN
8691	4133	18	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4133	19	to	to	TO
8691	4133	20	interfere	interfere	VB
8691	4133	21	more	more	JJR
8691	4133	22	than	than	IN
8691	4133	23	seems	seem	VBZ
8691	4133	24	absolutely	absolutely	RB
8691	4133	25	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	4133	26	with	with	IN
8691	4133	27	the	the	DT
8691	4133	28	management	management	NN
8691	4133	29	of	of	IN
8691	4133	30	a	a	DT
8691	4133	31	cause	cause	NN
8691	4133	32	by	by	IN
8691	4133	33	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	4133	34	.	.	.
8691	4134	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4134	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4134	3	not	not	RB
8691	4134	4	merely	merely	RB
8691	4134	5	the	the	DT
8691	4134	6	legal	legal	JJ
8691	4134	7	right	right	NN
8691	4134	8	of	of	IN
8691	4134	9	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	4134	10	but	but	CC
8691	4134	11	the	the	DT
8691	4134	12	practice	practice	NN
8691	4134	13	under	under	IN
8691	4134	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4134	15	which	which	WDT
8691	4134	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	4134	17	a	a	DT
8691	4134	18	peculiar	peculiar	JJ
8691	4134	19	feature	feature	NN
8691	4134	20	of	of	IN
8691	4134	21	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4134	22	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4134	23	system	system	NN
8691	4134	24	.	.	.
8691	4135	1	A	a	DT
8691	4135	2	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	4135	3	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4135	4	often	often	RB
8691	4135	5	hesitates	hesitate	VBZ
8691	4135	6	to	to	TO
8691	4135	7	cross	cross	VB
8691	4135	8	swords	sword	NNS
8691	4135	9	with	with	IN
8691	4135	10	the	the	DT
8691	4135	11	judge	judge	NN
8691	4135	12	.	.	.
8691	4136	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4136	2	distrusts	distrust	VBZ
8691	4136	3	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4136	4	own	own	JJ
8691	4136	5	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	4136	6	if	if	IN
8691	4136	7	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4136	8	differs	differ	VBZ
8691	4136	9	from	from	IN
8691	4136	10	that	that	DT
8691	4136	11	of	of	IN
8691	4136	12	the	the	DT
8691	4136	13	court	court	NN
8691	4136	14	.	.	.
8691	4137	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4137	2	defers	defer	VBZ
8691	4137	3	to	to	IN
8691	4137	4	the	the	DT
8691	4137	5	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	4137	6	of	of	IN
8691	4137	7	the	the	DT
8691	4137	8	bench	bench	NN
8691	4137	9	,	,	,
8691	4137	10	not	not	RB
8691	4137	11	only	only	RB
8691	4137	12	as	as	IN
8691	4137	13	stating	state	VBG
8691	4137	14	the	the	DT
8691	4137	15	law	law	NN
8691	4137	16	of	of	IN
8691	4137	17	the	the	DT
8691	4137	18	case	case	NN
8691	4137	19	,	,	,
8691	4137	20	but	but	CC
8691	4137	21	as	as	IN
8691	4137	22	probably	probably	RB
8691	4137	23	stating	state	VBG
8691	4137	24	the	the	DT
8691	4137	25	law	law	NN
8691	4137	26	of	of	IN
8691	4137	27	the	the	DT
8691	4137	28	land	land	NN
8691	4137	29	.	.	.
8691	4138	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4138	2	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	4138	3	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	4138	4	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	4138	5	on	on	IN
8691	4138	6	minor	minor	JJ
8691	4138	7	points	point	NNS
8691	4138	8	of	of	IN
8691	4138	9	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	4138	10	,	,	,
8691	4138	11	even	even	RB
8691	4138	12	if	if	IN
8691	4138	13	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4138	14	could	could	MD
8691	4138	15	.	.	.
8691	4139	1	In	in	IN
8691	4139	2	the	the	DT
8691	4139	3	United	United	NNP
8691	4139	4	States	States	NNP
8691	4139	5	probably	probably	RB
8691	4139	6	one	one	CD
8691	4139	7	case	case	NN
8691	4139	8	in	in	IN
8691	4139	9	ten	ten	CD
8691	4139	10	of	of	IN
8691	4139	11	all	all	DT
8691	4139	12	that	that	WDT
8691	4139	13	go	go	VBP
8691	4139	14	to	to	IN
8691	4139	15	trial	trial	NN
8691	4139	16	is	be	VBZ
8691	4139	17	carried	carry	VBN
8691	4139	18	up	up	RP
8691	4139	19	for	for	IN
8691	4139	20	review	review	NN
8691	4139	21	on	on	IN
8691	4139	22	points	point	NNS
8691	4139	23	of	of	IN
8691	4139	24	law	law	NN
8691	4139	25	;	;	:
8691	4139	26	many	many	JJ
8691	4139	27	of	of	IN
8691	4139	28	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4139	29	mere	mere	JJ
8691	4139	30	matters	matter	NNS
8691	4139	31	of	of	IN
8691	4139	32	practice	practice	NN
8691	4139	33	not	not	RB
8691	4139	34	affecting	affect	VBG
8691	4139	35	the	the	DT
8691	4139	36	merits	merit	NNS
8691	4139	37	of	of	IN
8691	4139	38	the	the	DT
8691	4139	39	cause	cause	NN
8691	4139	40	.	.	.
8691	4140	1	The	the	DT
8691	4140	2	American	american	JJ
8691	4140	3	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4140	4	can	can	MD
8691	4140	5	also	also	RB
8691	4140	6	safely	safely	RB
8691	4140	7	speak	speak	VB
8691	4140	8	with	with	IN
8691	4140	9	freedom	freedom	NN
8691	4140	10	of	of	IN
8691	4140	11	the	the	DT
8691	4140	12	conduct	conduct	NN
8691	4140	13	of	of	IN
8691	4140	14	the	the	DT
8691	4140	15	government	government	NN
8691	4140	16	or	or	CC
8691	4140	17	of	of	IN
8691	4140	18	high	high	JJ
8691	4140	19	officials	official	NNS
8691	4140	20	should	should	MD
8691	4140	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4140	22	come	come	VB
8691	4140	23	in	in	IN
8691	4140	24	question	question	NN
8691	4140	25	.	.	.
8691	4141	1	Those	those	DT
8691	4141	2	in	in	IN
8691	4141	3	any	any	DT
8691	4141	4	court	court	NN
8691	4141	5	,	,	,
8691	4141	6	high	high	JJ
8691	4141	7	or	or	CC
8691	4141	8	low	low	JJ
8691	4141	9	,	,	,
8691	4141	10	who	who	WP
8691	4141	11	hope	hope	VBP
8691	4141	12	for	for	IN
8691	4141	13	a	a	DT
8691	4141	14	reappointment	reappointment	NN
8691	4141	15	know	know	VBP
8691	4141	16	that	that	IN
8691	4141	17	the	the	DT
8691	4141	18	best	good	JJS
8691	4141	19	way	way	NN
8691	4141	20	to	to	TO
8691	4141	21	obtain	obtain	VB
8691	4141	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4141	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	4141	24	to	to	TO
8691	4141	25	secure	secure	VB
8691	4141	26	the	the	DT
8691	4141	27	good	good	JJ
8691	4141	28	will	will	NN
8691	4141	29	of	of	IN
8691	4141	30	the	the	DT
8691	4141	31	bar	bar	NN
8691	4141	32	.	.	.
8691	4142	1	The	the	DT
8691	4142	2	reputation	reputation	NN
8691	4142	3	of	of	IN
8691	4142	4	a	a	DT
8691	4142	5	judge	judge	NN
8691	4142	6	depends	depend	VBZ
8691	4142	7	on	on	IN
8691	4142	8	the	the	DT
8691	4142	9	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	4142	10	which	which	WDT
8691	4142	11	the	the	DT
8691	4142	12	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4142	13	have	have	VBP
8691	4142	14	of	of	IN
8691	4142	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4142	16	.	.	.
8691	4143	1	The	the	DT
8691	4143	2	general	general	JJ
8691	4143	3	public	public	NN
8691	4143	4	may	may	MD
8691	4143	5	be	be	VB
8691	4143	6	deceived	deceive	VBN
8691	4143	7	as	as	IN
8691	4143	8	to	to	IN
8691	4143	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4143	10	character	character	NN
8691	4143	11	,	,	,
8691	4143	12	ability	ability	NN
8691	4143	13	and	and	CC
8691	4143	14	attainments	attainment	NNS
8691	4143	15	;	;	:
8691	4143	16	the	the	DT
8691	4143	17	bar	bar	NN
8691	4143	18	can	can	MD
8691	4143	19	not	not	RB
8691	4143	20	be	be	VB
8691	4143	21	.	.	.
8691	4144	1	In	in	IN
8691	4144	2	the	the	DT
8691	4144	3	public	public	JJ
8691	4144	4	sessions	session	NNS
8691	4144	5	of	of	IN
8691	4144	6	court	court	NN
8691	4144	7	there	there	EX
8691	4144	8	are	be	VBP
8691	4144	9	few	few	JJ
8691	4144	10	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4144	11	who	who	WP
8691	4144	12	are	be	VBP
8691	4144	13	not	not	RB
8691	4144	14	impressed	impressed	JJ
8691	4144	15	with	with	IN
8691	4144	16	the	the	DT
8691	4144	17	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	4144	18	of	of	IN
8691	4144	19	maintaining	maintain	VBG
8691	4144	20	the	the	DT
8691	4144	21	dignity	dignity	NN
8691	4144	22	of	of	IN
8691	4144	23	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4144	24	position	position	NN
8691	4144	25	as	as	IN
8691	4144	26	representing	represent	VBG
8691	4144	27	the	the	DT
8691	4144	28	power	power	NN
8691	4144	29	of	of	IN
8691	4144	30	the	the	DT
8691	4144	31	State	State	NNP
8691	4144	32	.	.	.
8691	4145	1	The	the	DT
8691	4145	2	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4145	3	recognize	recognize	VBP
8691	4145	4	this	this	DT
8691	4145	5	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	4145	6	as	as	RB
8691	4145	7	just	just	RB
8691	4145	8	.	.	.
8691	4146	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4146	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4146	3	common	common	JJ
8691	4146	4	for	for	IN
8691	4146	5	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4146	6	to	to	TO
8691	4146	7	rise	rise	VB
8691	4146	8	as	as	IN
8691	4146	9	a	a	DT
8691	4146	10	body	body	NN
8691	4146	11	when	when	WRB
8691	4146	12	the	the	DT
8691	4146	13	judge	judge	NN
8691	4146	14	enters	enter	VBZ
8691	4146	15	the	the	DT
8691	4146	16	bench	bench	NN
8691	4146	17	.	.	.
8691	4147	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4147	2	find	find	VBP
8691	4147	3	no	no	DT
8691	4147	4	difficulty	difficulty	NN
8691	4147	5	in	in	IN
8691	4147	6	using	use	VBG
8691	4147	7	the	the	DT
8691	4147	8	conventional	conventional	JJ
8691	4147	9	style	style	NN
8691	4147	10	of	of	IN
8691	4147	11	address	address	NN
8691	4147	12	of	of	IN
8691	4147	13	"	"	``
8691	4147	14	May	May	MD
8691	4147	15	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4147	16	please	please	VB
8691	4147	17	the	the	DT
8691	4147	18	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4147	19	,	,	,
8691	4147	20	"	"	''
8691	4147	21	or	or	CC
8691	4147	22	"	"	``
8691	4147	23	May	May	MD
8691	4147	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4147	25	please	please	VB
8691	4147	26	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4147	27	Honor	honor	NN
8691	4147	28	.	.	.
8691	4147	29	"	"	''
8691	4148	1	When	when	WRB
8691	4148	2	a	a	DT
8691	4148	3	ruling	ruling	NN
8691	4148	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	4148	5	made	make	VBN
8691	4148	6	in	in	IN
8691	4148	7	the	the	DT
8691	4148	8	course	course	NN
8691	4148	9	of	of	IN
8691	4148	10	a	a	DT
8691	4148	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	4148	12	the	the	DT
8691	4148	13	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4148	14	,	,	,
8691	4148	15	whose	whose	WP$
8691	4148	16	client	client	NN
8691	4148	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	4148	18	adversely	adversely	RB
8691	4148	19	affected	affect	VBN
8691	4148	20	by	by	IN
8691	4148	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4148	22	,	,	,
8691	4148	23	accepts	accept	VBZ
8691	4148	24	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4148	25	without	without	IN
8691	4148	26	further	further	JJ
8691	4148	27	discussion	discussion	NN
8691	4148	28	,	,	,
8691	4148	29	simply	simply	RB
8691	4148	30	reserving	reserve	VBG
8691	4148	31	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4148	32	exception	exception	NN
8691	4148	33	,	,	,
8691	4148	34	if	if	IN
8691	4148	35	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4148	36	have	have	VBP
8691	4148	37	one	one	CD
8691	4148	38	,	,	,
8691	4148	39	for	for	IN
8691	4148	40	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	4148	41	of	of	IN
8691	4148	42	review	review	NN
8691	4148	43	in	in	IN
8691	4148	44	a	a	DT
8691	4148	45	higher	high	JJR
8691	4148	46	court	court	NN
8691	4148	47	.	.	.
8691	4149	1	If	if	IN
8691	4149	2	,	,	,
8691	4149	3	in	in	IN
8691	4149	4	addressing	address	VBG
8691	4149	5	the	the	DT
8691	4149	6	jury	jury	NN
8691	4149	7	,	,	,
8691	4149	8	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	4149	9	exceed	exceed	VBP
8691	4149	10	the	the	DT
8691	4149	11	bounds	bound	NNS
8691	4149	12	of	of	IN
8691	4149	13	professional	professional	JJ
8691	4149	14	license	license	NN
8691	4149	15	in	in	IN
8691	4149	16	commenting	comment	VBG
8691	4149	17	on	on	IN
8691	4149	18	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	4149	19	or	or	CC
8691	4149	20	alluding	allude	VBG
8691	4149	21	to	to	IN
8691	4149	22	the	the	DT
8691	4149	23	character	character	NN
8691	4149	24	of	of	IN
8691	4149	25	the	the	DT
8691	4149	26	parties	party	NNS
8691	4149	27	,	,	,
8691	4149	28	the	the	DT
8691	4149	29	court	court	NN
8691	4149	30	will	will	MD
8691	4149	31	check	check	VB
8691	4149	32	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4149	33	without	without	IN
8691	4149	34	hesitation	hesitation	NN
8691	4149	35	.	.	.
8691	4150	1	Less	Less	JJR
8691	4150	2	outward	outward	JJ
8691	4150	3	respect	respect	NN
8691	4150	4	was	be	VBD
8691	4150	5	shown	show	VBN
8691	4150	6	toward	toward	IN
8691	4150	7	the	the	DT
8691	4150	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	4150	9	by	by	IN
8691	4150	10	the	the	DT
8691	4150	11	bar	bar	NN
8691	4150	12	in	in	IN
8691	4150	13	former	former	JJ
8691	4150	14	times	time	NNS
8691	4150	15	than	than	IN
8691	4150	16	now	now	RB
8691	4150	17	,	,	,
8691	4150	18	and	and	CC
8691	4150	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4150	20	often	often	RB
8691	4150	21	received	receive	VBD
8691	4150	22	less	less	RBR
8691	4150	23	courtesy	courtesy	NN
8691	4150	24	of	of	IN
8691	4150	25	treatment	treatment	NN
8691	4150	26	from	from	IN
8691	4150	27	the	the	DT
8691	4150	28	bench	bench	NN
8691	4150	29	.	.	.
8691	4151	1	An	an	DT
8691	4151	2	incident	incident	NN
8691	4151	3	occurring	occur	VBG
8691	4151	4	in	in	IN
8691	4151	5	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	4151	6	about	about	IN
8691	4151	7	the	the	DT
8691	4151	8	beginning	beginning	NN
8691	4151	9	of	of	IN
8691	4151	10	the	the	DT
8691	4151	11	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	4151	12	century	century	NN
8691	4151	13	may	may	MD
8691	4151	14	serve	serve	VB
8691	4151	15	as	as	IN
8691	4151	16	an	an	DT
8691	4151	17	illustration	illustration	NN
8691	4151	18	.	.	.
8691	4152	1	Robert	Robert	NNP
8691	4152	2	Treat	Treat	NNP
8691	4152	3	Paine	Paine	NNP
8691	4152	4	,	,	,
8691	4152	5	a	a	DT
8691	4152	6	signer	signer	NN
8691	4152	7	of	of	IN
8691	4152	8	the	the	DT
8691	4152	9	Declaration	Declaration	NNP
8691	4152	10	of	of	IN
8691	4152	11	Independence	Independence	NNP
8691	4152	12	,	,	,
8691	4152	13	resigned	resign	VBD
8691	4152	14	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4152	15	seat	seat	NN
8691	4152	16	on	on	IN
8691	4152	17	the	the	DT
8691	4152	18	bench	bench	NN
8691	4152	19	of	of	IN
8691	4152	20	the	the	DT
8691	4152	21	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4152	22	Judicial	Judicial	NNP
8691	4152	23	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4152	24	in	in	IN
8691	4152	25	1804	1804	CD
8691	4152	26	,	,	,
8691	4152	27	at	at	IN
8691	4152	28	the	the	DT
8691	4152	29	age	age	NN
8691	4152	30	of	of	IN
8691	4152	31	seventy	seventy	CD
8691	4152	32	,	,	,
8691	4152	33	largely	largely	RB
8691	4152	34	on	on	IN
8691	4152	35	account	account	NN
8691	4152	36	of	of	IN
8691	4152	37	deafness	deafness	NN
8691	4152	38	.	.	.
8691	4153	1	Naturally	naturally	RB
8691	4153	2	somewhat	somewhat	RB
8691	4153	3	imperious	imperious	JJ
8691	4153	4	in	in	IN
8691	4153	5	temperament	temperament	NN
8691	4153	6	,	,	,
8691	4153	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4153	8	bearing	bearing	NN
8691	4153	9	toward	toward	IN
8691	4153	10	the	the	DT
8691	4153	11	bar	bar	NN
8691	4153	12	had	have	VBD
8691	4153	13	seemed	seem	VBN
8691	4153	14	harsher	harsh	JJR
8691	4153	15	from	from	IN
8691	4153	16	this	this	DT
8691	4153	17	infirmity	infirmity	NN
8691	4153	18	.	.	.
8691	4154	1	Fisher	Fisher	NNP
8691	4154	2	Ames	Ames	NNP
8691	4154	3	used	use	VBN
8691	4154	4	to	to	TO
8691	4154	5	refer	refer	VB
8691	4154	6	to	to	IN
8691	4154	7	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4154	8	as	as	IN
8691	4154	9	_	_	NNP
8691	4154	10	Ursa	Ursa	NNP
8691	4154	11	Major	Major	NNP
8691	4154	12	_	_	NNP
8691	4154	13	,	,	,
8691	4154	14	and	and	CC
8691	4154	15	once	once	RB
8691	4154	16	told	tell	VBD
8691	4154	17	a	a	DT
8691	4154	18	friend	friend	NN
8691	4154	19	that	that	IN
8691	4154	20	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4154	21	should	should	MD
8691	4154	22	not	not	RB
8691	4154	23	go	go	VB
8691	4154	24	into	into	IN
8691	4154	25	court	court	NN
8691	4154	26	again	again	RB
8691	4154	27	,	,	,
8691	4154	28	when	when	WRB
8691	4154	29	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	4154	30	Paine	Paine	NNP
8691	4154	31	held	hold	VBD
8691	4154	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4154	33	,	,	,
8691	4154	34	without	without	IN
8691	4154	35	a	a	DT
8691	4154	36	club	club	NN
8691	4154	37	in	in	IN
8691	4154	38	one	one	CD
8691	4154	39	hand	hand	NN
8691	4154	40	and	and	CC
8691	4154	41	a	a	DT
8691	4154	42	speaking	speak	VBG
8691	4154	43	trumpet	trumpet	NN
8691	4154	44	in	in	IN
8691	4154	45	the	the	DT
8691	4154	46	other	other	JJ
8691	4154	47	.	.	.
8691	4155	1	Theophilus	Theophilus	NNP
8691	4155	2	Parsons	Parsons	NNPS
8691	4155	3	,	,	,
8691	4155	4	not	not	RB
8691	4155	5	long	long	RB
8691	4155	6	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	4155	7	made	make	VBD
8691	4155	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	4155	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	4155	10	of	of	IN
8691	4155	11	the	the	DT
8691	4155	12	State	State	NNP
8691	4155	13	,	,	,
8691	4155	14	was	be	VBD
8691	4155	15	arguing	argue	VBG
8691	4155	16	before	before	IN
8691	4155	17	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4155	18	one	one	CD
8691	4155	19	day	day	NN
8691	4155	20	when	when	WRB
8691	4155	21	the	the	DT
8691	4155	22	judge	judge	NN
8691	4155	23	,	,	,
8691	4155	24	under	under	IN
8691	4155	25	the	the	DT
8691	4155	26	misconception	misconception	NN
8691	4155	27	into	into	IN
8691	4155	28	which	which	WDT
8691	4155	29	a	a	DT
8691	4155	30	deaf	deaf	JJ
8691	4155	31	old	old	JJ
8691	4155	32	person	person	NN
8691	4155	33	so	so	RB
8691	4155	34	easily	easily	RB
8691	4155	35	falls	fall	VBZ
8691	4155	36	,	,	,
8691	4155	37	that	that	IN
8691	4155	38	the	the	DT
8691	4155	39	younger	young	JJR
8691	4155	40	generation	generation	NN
8691	4155	41	all	all	DT
8691	4155	42	speak	speak	VBP
8691	4155	43	hurriedly	hurriedly	RB
8691	4155	44	and	and	CC
8691	4155	45	indistinctly	indistinctly	RB
8691	4155	46	,	,	,
8691	4155	47	cried	cry	VBD
8691	4155	48	out	out	RP
8691	4155	49	,	,	,
8691	4155	50	"	"	''
8691	4155	51	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	4155	52	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
8691	4155	53	,	,	,
8691	4155	54	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4155	55	tell	tell	VBP
8691	4155	56	you	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4155	57	once	once	RB
8691	4155	58	for	for	IN
8691	4155	59	all	all	DT
8691	4155	60	,	,	,
8691	4155	61	take	take	VB
8691	4155	62	that	that	DT
8691	4155	63	glove	glove	NN
8691	4155	64	off	off	IN
8691	4155	65	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4155	66	tongue	tongue	NN
8691	4155	67	.	.	.
8691	4155	68	"	"	''
8691	4156	1	"	"	``
8691	4156	2	Certainly	certainly	RB
8691	4156	3	,	,	,
8691	4156	4	Sir	Sir	NNP
8691	4156	5	,	,	,
8691	4156	6	"	"	''
8691	4156	7	was	be	VBD
8691	4156	8	the	the	DT
8691	4156	9	quick	quick	JJ
8691	4156	10	retort	retort	NN
8691	4156	11	,	,	,
8691	4156	12	"	"	''
8691	4156	13	and	and	CC
8691	4156	14	may	may	MD
8691	4156	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4156	16	beg	beg	VB
8691	4156	17	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4156	18	honor	honor	NN
8691	4156	19	to	to	TO
8691	4156	20	take	take	VB
8691	4156	21	the	the	DT
8691	4156	22	wool	wool	NN
8691	4156	23	out	out	IN
8691	4156	24	of	of	IN
8691	4156	25	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4156	26	ears	ear	NNS
8691	4156	27	?	?	.
8691	4157	1	"	"	``
8691	4157	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4157	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4157	4	:	:	:
8691	4157	5	"	"	``
8691	4157	6	Memoir	Memoir	NNP
8691	4157	7	of	of	IN
8691	4157	8	Theophilus	Theophilus	NNP
8691	4157	9	Parsons	Parsons	NNPS
8691	4157	10	,	,	,
8691	4157	11	"	"	''
8691	4157	12	214	214	CD
8691	4157	13	.	.	.
8691	4157	14	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4158	1	Some	some	DT
8691	4158	2	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	4158	3	years	year	NNS
8691	4158	4	later	later	RB
8691	4158	5	Roger	Roger	NNP
8691	4158	6	Minott	Minott	NNP
8691	4158	7	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
8691	4158	8	,	,	,
8691	4158	9	the	the	DT
8691	4158	10	leader	leader	NN
8691	4158	11	of	of	IN
8691	4158	12	the	the	DT
8691	4158	13	Connecticut	Connecticut	NNP
8691	4158	14	bar	bar	NN
8691	4158	15	,	,	,
8691	4158	16	in	in	IN
8691	4158	17	trying	try	VBG
8691	4158	18	a	a	DT
8691	4158	19	cause	cause	NN
8691	4158	20	before	before	IN
8691	4158	21	an	an	DT
8691	4158	22	empty	empty	JJ
8691	4158	23	-	-	HYPH
8691	4158	24	headed	headed	JJ
8691	4158	25	judge	judge	NN
8691	4158	26	who	who	WP
8691	4158	27	had	have	VBD
8691	4158	28	been	be	VBN
8691	4158	29	put	put	VBN
8691	4158	30	on	on	IN
8691	4158	31	the	the	DT
8691	4158	32	bench	bench	NN
8691	4158	33	for	for	IN
8691	4158	34	no	no	DT
8691	4158	35	other	other	JJ
8691	4158	36	apparent	apparent	JJ
8691	4158	37	reason	reason	NN
8691	4158	38	than	than	IN
8691	4158	39	that	that	IN
8691	4158	40	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4158	41	father	father	NN
8691	4158	42	was	be	VBD
8691	4158	43	a	a	DT
8691	4158	44	man	man	NN
8691	4158	45	of	of	IN
8691	4158	46	distinction	distinction	NN
8691	4158	47	,	,	,
8691	4158	48	quoted	quote	VBD
8691	4158	49	several	several	JJ
8691	4158	50	English	english	JJ
8691	4158	51	authorities	authority	NNS
8691	4158	52	and	and	CC
8691	4158	53	was	be	VBD
8691	4158	54	about	about	JJ
8691	4158	55	to	to	TO
8691	4158	56	read	read	VB
8691	4158	57	from	from	IN
8691	4158	58	another	another	DT
8691	4158	59	when	when	WRB
8691	4158	60	the	the	DT
8691	4158	61	judge	judge	NN
8691	4158	62	remarked	remark	VBD
8691	4158	63	that	that	IN
8691	4158	64	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4158	65	need	nee	MD
8691	4158	66	not	not	RB
8691	4158	67	take	take	VB
8691	4158	68	the	the	DT
8691	4158	69	trouble	trouble	NN
8691	4158	70	to	to	TO
8691	4158	71	read	read	VB
8691	4158	72	anything	anything	NN
8691	4158	73	more	more	JJR
8691	4158	74	of	of	IN
8691	4158	75	that	that	DT
8691	4158	76	sort	sort	NN
8691	4158	77	to	to	IN
8691	4158	78	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4158	79	.	.	.
8691	4159	1	"	"	``
8691	4159	2	Then	then	RB
8691	4159	3	,	,	,
8691	4159	4	"	"	''
8691	4159	5	said	say	VBD
8691	4159	6	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	4159	7	Sherman	Sherman	NNP
8691	4159	8	,	,	,
8691	4159	9	"	"	``
8691	4159	10	with	with	IN
8691	4159	11	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4159	12	Honor	Honor	NNP
8691	4159	13	's	's	POS
8691	4159	14	permission	permission	NN
8691	4159	15	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4159	16	will	will	MD
8691	4159	17	read	read	VB
8691	4159	18	from	from	IN
8691	4159	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4159	20	to	to	IN
8691	4159	21	the	the	DT
8691	4159	22	jury	jury	NN
8691	4159	23	,	,	,
8691	4159	24	and	and	CC
8691	4159	25	let	let	VB
8691	4159	26	me	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4159	27	say	say	VB
8691	4159	28	that	that	IN
8691	4159	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4159	30	is	be	VBZ
8691	4159	31	an	an	DT
8691	4159	32	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	4159	33	of	of	IN
8691	4159	34	Lord	Lord	NNP
8691	4159	35	Ellenborough	Ellenborough	NNP
8691	4159	36	,	,	,
8691	4159	37	a	a	DT
8691	4159	38	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	4159	39	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	4159	40	of	of	IN
8691	4159	41	England	England	NNP
8691	4159	42	who	who	WP
8691	4159	43	rose	rise	VBD
8691	4159	44	to	to	IN
8691	4159	45	the	the	DT
8691	4159	46	bench	bench	NN
8691	4159	47	by	by	IN
8691	4159	48	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4159	49	own	own	JJ
8691	4159	50	merits	merit	NNS
8691	4159	51	,	,	,
8691	4159	52	and	and	CC
8691	4159	53	shone	shine	VBN
8691	4159	54	by	by	IN
8691	4159	55	no	no	DT
8691	4159	56	reflected	reflected	JJ
8691	4159	57	light	light	NN
8691	4159	58	.	.	.
8691	4159	59	"	"	''
8691	4160	1	One	one	CD
8691	4160	2	of	of	IN
8691	4160	3	the	the	DT
8691	4160	4	anecdotes	anecdote	NNS
8691	4160	5	of	of	IN
8691	4160	6	the	the	DT
8691	4160	7	Boston	Boston	NNP
8691	4160	8	bar	bar	NN
8691	4160	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	4160	10	that	that	IN
8691	4160	11	while	while	IN
8691	4160	12	Samuel	Samuel	NNP
8691	4160	13	Dexter	Dexter	NNP
8691	4160	14	,	,	,
8691	4160	15	one	one	CD
8691	4160	16	of	of	IN
8691	4160	17	the	the	DT
8691	4160	18	great	great	JJ
8691	4160	19	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4160	20	of	of	IN
8691	4160	21	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4160	22	day	day	NN
8691	4160	23	,	,	,
8691	4160	24	was	be	VBD
8691	4160	25	arguing	argue	VBG
8691	4160	26	a	a	DT
8691	4160	27	cause	cause	NN
8691	4160	28	in	in	IN
8691	4160	29	the	the	DT
8691	4160	30	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	4160	31	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4160	32	of	of	IN
8691	4160	33	the	the	DT
8691	4160	34	United	United	NNP
8691	4160	35	States	States	NNP
8691	4160	36	before	before	IN
8691	4160	37	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	4160	38	Story	Story	NNP
8691	4160	39	,	,	,
8691	4160	40	soon	soon	RB
8691	4160	41	after	after	IN
8691	4160	42	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4160	43	accession	accession	NN
8691	4160	44	to	to	IN
8691	4160	45	the	the	DT
8691	4160	46	bench	bench	NN
8691	4160	47	,	,	,
8691	4160	48	the	the	DT
8691	4160	49	court	court	NN
8691	4160	50	suddenly	suddenly	RB
8691	4160	51	interposed	interpose	VBD
8691	4160	52	,	,	,
8691	4160	53	as	as	IN
8691	4160	54	a	a	DT
8691	4160	55	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4160	56	principle	principle	NN
8691	4160	57	was	be	VBD
8691	4160	58	asserted	assert	VBN
8691	4160	59	,	,	,
8691	4160	60	with	with	IN
8691	4160	61	"	"	``
8691	4160	62	That	that	DT
8691	4160	63	proposition	proposition	NN
8691	4160	64	is	be	VBZ
8691	4160	65	not	not	RB
8691	4160	66	law	law	NN
8691	4160	67	,	,	,
8691	4160	68	Sir	Sir	NNP
8691	4160	69	,	,	,
8691	4160	70	"	"	''
8691	4160	71	to	to	TO
8691	4160	72	which	which	WDT
8691	4160	73	Mr.	Mr.	NNP
8691	4160	74	Dexter	Dexter	NNP
8691	4160	75	retorted	retort	VBD
8691	4160	76	,	,	,
8691	4160	77	"	"	``
8691	4160	78	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4160	79	is	be	VBZ
8691	4160	80	the	the	DT
8691	4160	81	law	law	NN
8691	4160	82	,	,	,
8691	4160	83	if	if	IN
8691	4160	84	your	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4160	85	Honor	honor	NN
8691	4160	86	please	please	UH
8691	4160	87	,	,	,
8691	4160	88	and	and	CC
8691	4160	89	will	will	MD
8691	4160	90	finally	finally	RB
8691	4160	91	be	be	VB
8691	4160	92	declared	declare	VBN
8691	4160	93	to	to	TO
8691	4160	94	be	be	VB
8691	4160	95	the	the	DT
8691	4160	96	law	law	NN
8691	4160	97	by	by	IN
8691	4160	98	this	this	DT
8691	4160	99	court	court	NN
8691	4160	100	,	,	,
8691	4160	101	"	"	``
8691	4160	102	as	as	RB
8691	4160	103	indeed	indeed	RB
8691	4160	104	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4160	105	was	be	VBD
8691	4160	106	later	later	RB
8691	4160	107	by	by	IN
8691	4160	108	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	4160	109	Story	Story	NNP
8691	4160	110	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4160	111	.	.	.
8691	4161	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4161	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4161	3	:	:	:
8691	4161	4	Payne	Payne	NNP
8691	4161	5	,	,	,
8691	4161	6	"	"	``
8691	4161	7	Reminiscences	reminiscence	NNS
8691	4161	8	of	of	IN
8691	4161	9	the	the	DT
8691	4161	10	Rhode	Rhode	NNP
8691	4161	11	Island	Island	NNP
8691	4161	12	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	4161	13	,	,	,
8691	4161	14	"	"	``
8691	4161	15	241	241	CD
8691	4161	16	.	.	.
8691	4161	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4162	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	4162	2	a	a	DT
8691	4162	3	passage	passage	NN
8691	4162	4	at	at	IN
8691	4162	5	arms	arm	NNS
8691	4162	6	between	between	IN
8691	4162	7	court	court	NN
8691	4162	8	and	and	CC
8691	4162	9	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	4162	10	as	as	IN
8691	4162	11	took	take	VBD
8691	4162	12	place	place	NN
8691	4162	13	in	in	IN
8691	4162	14	either	either	DT
8691	4162	15	of	of	IN
8691	4162	16	these	these	DT
8691	4162	17	instances	instance	NNS
8691	4162	18	could	could	MD
8691	4162	19	now	now	RB
8691	4162	20	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	4162	21	occur	occur	VB
8691	4162	22	.	.	.
8691	4163	1	Out	out	IN
8691	4163	2	of	of	IN
8691	4163	3	court	court	NN
8691	4163	4	there	there	EX
8691	4163	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	4163	6	no	no	RB
8691	4163	7	longer	long	RBR
8691	4163	8	this	this	DT
8691	4163	9	distance	distance	NN
8691	4163	10	between	between	IN
8691	4163	11	judge	judge	NN
8691	4163	12	and	and	CC
8691	4163	13	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4163	14	.	.	.
8691	4164	1	While	while	IN
8691	4164	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4164	3	will	will	MD
8691	4164	4	not	not	RB
8691	4164	5	talk	talk	VB
8691	4164	6	over	over	IN
8691	4164	7	an	an	DT
8691	4164	8	unfinished	unfinished	JJ
8691	4164	9	case	case	NN
8691	4164	10	,	,	,
8691	4164	11	one	one	NN
8691	4164	12	that	that	WDT
8691	4164	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	4164	14	finally	finally	RB
8691	4164	15	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	4164	16	of	of	IN
8691	4164	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	4164	18	often	often	RB
8691	4164	19	the	the	DT
8691	4164	20	subject	subject	NN
8691	4164	21	of	of	IN
8691	4164	22	free	free	JJ
8691	4164	23	comment	comment	NN
8691	4164	24	by	by	IN
8691	4164	25	each	each	DT
8691	4164	26	.	.	.
8691	4165	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4165	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4165	3	now	now	RB
8691	4165	4	entirely	entirely	RB
8691	4165	5	upon	upon	IN
8691	4165	6	the	the	DT
8691	4165	7	same	same	JJ
8691	4165	8	level	level	NN
8691	4165	9	in	in	IN
8691	4165	10	the	the	DT
8691	4165	11	community	community	NN
8691	4165	12	.	.	.
8691	4166	1	Officialism	officialism	NN
8691	4166	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4166	3	put	put	VBN
8691	4166	4	off	off	RP
8691	4166	5	when	when	WRB
8691	4166	6	the	the	DT
8691	4166	7	court	court	NN
8691	4166	8	room	room	NN
8691	4166	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	4166	10	closed	close	VBN
8691	4166	11	.	.	.
8691	4167	1	Socially	socially	RB
8691	4167	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4167	3	meet	meet	VBP
8691	4167	4	in	in	IN
8691	4167	5	the	the	DT
8691	4167	6	same	same	JJ
8691	4167	7	circles	circle	NNS
8691	4167	8	and	and	CC
8691	4167	9	on	on	IN
8691	4167	10	the	the	DT
8691	4167	11	same	same	JJ
8691	4167	12	footing	footing	NN
8691	4167	13	.	.	.
8691	4168	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4168	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4168	3	considered	consider	VBN
8691	4168	4	not	not	RB
8691	4168	5	improper	improper	JJ
8691	4168	6	for	for	IN
8691	4168	7	a	a	DT
8691	4168	8	judge	judge	NN
8691	4168	9	to	to	TO
8691	4168	10	accept	accept	VB
8691	4168	11	the	the	DT
8691	4168	12	hospitality	hospitality	NN
8691	4168	13	of	of	IN
8691	4168	14	a	a	DT
8691	4168	15	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4168	16	concerned	concern	VBN
8691	4168	17	in	in	IN
8691	4168	18	a	a	DT
8691	4168	19	case	case	NN
8691	4168	20	before	before	IN
8691	4168	21	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4168	22	,	,	,
8691	4168	23	and	and	CC
8691	4168	24	even	even	RB
8691	4168	25	a	a	DT
8691	4168	26	case	case	NN
8691	4168	27	on	on	IN
8691	4168	28	trial	trial	NN
8691	4168	29	.	.	.
8691	4169	1	The	the	DT
8691	4169	2	American	american	JJ
8691	4169	3	rule	rule	NN
8691	4169	4	in	in	IN
8691	4169	5	this	this	DT
8691	4169	6	respect	respect	NN
8691	4169	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4169	8	much	much	RB
8691	4169	9	less	less	RBR
8691	4169	10	strict	strict	JJ
8691	4169	11	than	than	IN
8691	4169	12	the	the	DT
8691	4169	13	English	English	NNP
8691	4169	14	.	.	.
8691	4170	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4170	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4170	3	:	:	:
8691	4170	4	See	see	VB
8691	4170	5	"	"	''
8691	4170	6	Memoir	Memoir	NNP
8691	4170	7	of	of	IN
8691	4170	8	Chief	Chief	NNP
8691	4170	9	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	4170	10	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
8691	4170	11	,	,	,
8691	4170	12	"	"	''
8691	4170	13	208	208	CD
8691	4170	14	-	-	SYM
8691	4170	15	211	211	CD
8691	4170	16	.	.	.
8691	4170	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4171	1	*	*	NFP
8691	4171	2	*	*	NFP
8691	4171	3	*	*	NFP
8691	4171	4	*	*	NFP
8691	4171	5	*	*	NFP
8691	4171	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	4171	7	XXIV	xxiv	NN
8691	4171	8	THE	the	DT
8691	4171	9	LAW	law	NN
8691	4171	10	'S	be	VBZ
8691	4171	11	DELAYS	delay	NNS
8691	4171	12	The	the	DT
8691	4171	13	right	right	NN
8691	4171	14	to	to	TO
8691	4171	15	be	be	VB
8691	4171	16	heard	hear	VBN
8691	4171	17	before	before	IN
8691	4171	18	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	4171	19	,	,	,
8691	4171	20	the	the	DT
8691	4171	21	right	right	NN
8691	4171	22	to	to	TO
8691	4171	23	have	have	VB
8691	4171	24	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	4171	25	rendered	render	VBN
8691	4171	26	only	only	RB
8691	4171	27	on	on	IN
8691	4171	28	due	due	JJ
8691	4171	29	process	process	NN
8691	4171	30	of	of	IN
8691	4171	31	law	law	NN
8691	4171	32	,	,	,
8691	4171	33	and	and	CC
8691	4171	34	the	the	DT
8691	4171	35	right	right	NN
8691	4171	36	in	in	IN
8691	4171	37	most	most	JJS
8691	4171	38	cases	case	NNS
8691	4171	39	to	to	IN
8691	4171	40	a	a	DT
8691	4171	41	jury	jury	NN
8691	4171	42	trial	trial	NN
8691	4171	43	,	,	,
8691	4171	44	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	4171	45	make	make	VB
8691	4171	46	the	the	DT
8691	4171	47	course	course	NN
8691	4171	48	of	of	IN
8691	4171	49	justice	justice	NN
8691	4171	50	slower	slow	JJR
8691	4171	51	in	in	IN
8691	4171	52	this	this	DT
8691	4171	53	country	country	NN
8691	4171	54	than	than	IN
8691	4171	55	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4171	56	need	nee	MD
8691	4171	57	be	be	VB
8691	4171	58	in	in	IN
8691	4171	59	one	one	CD
8691	4171	60	where	where	WRB
8691	4171	61	there	there	EX
8691	4171	62	are	be	VBP
8691	4171	63	no	no	DT
8691	4171	64	such	such	JJ
8691	4171	65	guaranties	guaranty	NNS
8691	4171	66	in	in	IN
8691	4171	67	favor	favor	NN
8691	4171	68	of	of	IN
8691	4171	69	those	those	DT
8691	4171	70	against	against	IN
8691	4171	71	whom	whom	WP
8691	4171	72	the	the	DT
8691	4171	73	aid	aid	NN
8691	4171	74	of	of	IN
8691	4171	75	a	a	DT
8691	4171	76	court	court	NN
8691	4171	77	is	be	VBZ
8691	4171	78	invoked	invoke	VBN
8691	4171	79	.	.	.
8691	4172	1	The	the	DT
8691	4172	2	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	4172	3	,	,	,
8691	4172	4	too	too	RB
8691	4172	5	,	,	,
8691	4172	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	4172	7	corresponding	correspond	VBG
8691	4172	8	rights	right	NNS
8691	4172	9	.	.	.
8691	4173	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4173	2	was	be	VBD
8691	4173	3	found	find	VBN
8691	4173	4	not	not	RB
8691	4173	5	so	so	RB
8691	4173	6	easy	easy	JJ
8691	4173	7	by	by	IN
8691	4173	8	Frederick	Frederick	NNP
8691	4173	9	the	the	DT
8691	4173	10	Great	Great	NNP
8691	4173	11	to	to	TO
8691	4173	12	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	4173	13	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4173	14	famous	famous	JJ
8691	4173	15	decree	decree	NN
8691	4173	16	that	that	WDT
8691	4173	17	every	every	DT
8691	4173	18	lawsuit	lawsuit	NN
8691	4173	19	in	in	IN
8691	4173	20	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4173	21	dominions	dominion	NNS
8691	4173	22	must	must	MD
8691	4173	23	be	be	VB
8691	4173	24	finished	finish	VBN
8691	4173	25	in	in	IN
8691	4173	26	a	a	DT
8691	4173	27	year	year	NN
8691	4173	28	.	.	.
8691	4174	1	In	in	IN
8691	4174	2	a	a	DT
8691	4174	3	freer	free	JJR
8691	4174	4	land	land	NN
8691	4174	5	no	no	DT
8691	4174	6	such	such	JJ
8691	4174	7	result	result	NN
8691	4174	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	4174	9	possible	possible	JJ
8691	4174	10	.	.	.
8691	4175	1	The	the	DT
8691	4175	2	power	power	NN
8691	4175	3	of	of	IN
8691	4175	4	the	the	DT
8691	4175	5	judge	judge	NN
8691	4175	6	to	to	TO
8691	4175	7	expedite	expedite	VB
8691	4175	8	trials	trial	NNS
8691	4175	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	4175	10	also	also	RB
8691	4175	11	much	much	RB
8691	4175	12	less	less	JJR
8691	4175	13	in	in	IN
8691	4175	14	the	the	DT
8691	4175	15	United	United	NNP
8691	4175	16	States	States	NNP
8691	4175	17	than	than	IN
8691	4175	18	in	in	IN
8691	4175	19	most	most	JJS
8691	4175	20	countries	country	NNS
8691	4175	21	.	.	.
8691	4176	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4176	2	must	must	MD
8691	4176	3	be	be	VB
8691	4176	4	had	have	VBN
8691	4176	5	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	4176	6	on	on	IN
8691	4176	7	oral	oral	JJ
8691	4176	8	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	4176	9	.	.	.
8691	4177	1	The	the	DT
8691	4177	2	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	4177	3	must	must	MD
8691	4177	4	be	be	VB
8691	4177	5	so	so	RB
8691	4177	6	given	give	VBN
8691	4177	7	that	that	IN
8691	4177	8	thirteen	thirteen	CD
8691	4177	9	different	different	JJ
8691	4177	10	men	man	NNS
8691	4177	11	may	may	MD
8691	4177	12	each	each	DT
8691	4177	13	understand	understand	VB
8691	4177	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4177	15	.	.	.
8691	4178	1	What	what	WP
8691	4178	2	the	the	DT
8691	4178	3	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	4178	4	may	may	MD
8691	4178	5	be	be	VB
8691	4178	6	allowed	allow	VBN
8691	4178	7	to	to	TO
8691	4178	8	tell	tell	VB
8691	4178	9	,	,	,
8691	4178	10	and	and	CC
8691	4178	11	what	what	WP
8691	4178	12	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4178	13	can	can	MD
8691	4178	14	not	not	RB
8691	4178	15	be	be	VB
8691	4178	16	,	,	,
8691	4178	17	depends	depend	VBZ
8691	4178	18	on	on	IN
8691	4178	19	the	the	DT
8691	4178	20	application	application	NN
8691	4178	21	of	of	IN
8691	4178	22	numerous	numerous	JJ
8691	4178	23	and	and	CC
8691	4178	24	artificial	artificial	JJ
8691	4178	25	rules	rule	NNS
8691	4178	26	of	of	IN
8691	4178	27	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	4178	28	.	.	.
8691	4179	1	If	if	IN
8691	4179	2	there	there	EX
8691	4179	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	4179	4	a	a	DT
8691	4179	5	question	question	NN
8691	4179	6	as	as	IN
8691	4179	7	to	to	IN
8691	4179	8	whether	whether	IN
8691	4179	9	this	this	DT
8691	4179	10	rule	rule	NN
8691	4179	11	or	or	CC
8691	4179	12	that	that	DT
8691	4179	13	applies	apply	VBZ
8691	4179	14	,	,	,
8691	4179	15	the	the	DT
8691	4179	16	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4179	17	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	4179	18	invite	invite	VBP
8691	4179	19	and	and	CC
8691	4179	20	generally	generally	RB
8691	4179	21	allow	allow	VB
8691	4179	22	a	a	DT
8691	4179	23	discussion	discussion	NN
8691	4179	24	by	by	IN
8691	4179	25	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	4179	26	.	.	.
8691	4180	1	Appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	4180	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4180	3	liberally	liberally	RB
8691	4180	4	conceded	concede	VBN
8691	4180	5	.	.	.
8691	4181	1	If	if	IN
8691	4181	2	exceptions	exception	NNS
8691	4181	3	to	to	IN
8691	4181	4	any	any	DT
8691	4181	5	ruling	ruling	NN
8691	4181	6	of	of	IN
8691	4181	7	the	the	DT
8691	4181	8	court	court	NN
8691	4181	9	are	be	VBP
8691	4181	10	to	to	TO
8691	4181	11	be	be	VB
8691	4181	12	made	make	VBN
8691	4181	13	the	the	DT
8691	4181	14	basis	basis	NN
8691	4181	15	of	of	IN
8691	4181	16	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	4181	17	in	in	IN
8691	4181	18	error	error	NN
8691	4181	19	,	,	,
8691	4181	20	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4181	21	must	must	MD
8691	4181	22	be	be	VB
8691	4181	23	carefully	carefully	RB
8691	4181	24	noted	note	VBN
8691	4181	25	at	at	IN
8691	4181	26	the	the	DT
8691	4181	27	time	time	NN
8691	4181	28	,	,	,
8691	4181	29	and	and	CC
8691	4181	30	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	4181	31	made	make	VBD
8691	4181	32	the	the	DT
8691	4181	33	subject	subject	NN
8691	4181	34	of	of	IN
8691	4181	35	a	a	DT
8691	4181	36	lengthy	lengthy	JJ
8691	4181	37	set	set	NN
8691	4181	38	of	of	IN
8691	4181	39	papers	paper	NNS
8691	4181	40	.	.	.
8691	4182	1	Many	many	JJ
8691	4182	2	trial	trial	NN
8691	4182	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4182	4	are	be	VBP
8691	4182	5	young	young	JJ
8691	4182	6	men	man	NNS
8691	4182	7	of	of	IN
8691	4182	8	little	little	JJ
8691	4182	9	experience	experience	NN
8691	4182	10	either	either	CC
8691	4182	11	on	on	IN
8691	4182	12	the	the	DT
8691	4182	13	bench	bench	NN
8691	4182	14	or	or	CC
8691	4182	15	at	at	IN
8691	4182	16	the	the	DT
8691	4182	17	bar	bar	NN
8691	4182	18	.	.	.
8691	4183	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4183	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4183	3	learning	learn	VBG
8691	4183	4	the	the	DT
8691	4183	5	law	law	NN
8691	4183	6	by	by	IN
8691	4183	7	administering	administer	VBG
8691	4183	8	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4183	9	.	.	.
8691	4184	1	Such	such	JJ
8691	4184	2	men	man	NNS
8691	4184	3	can	can	MD
8691	4184	4	not	not	RB
8691	4184	5	decide	decide	VB
8691	4184	6	controverted	controverted	JJ
8691	4184	7	points	point	NNS
8691	4184	8	in	in	IN
8691	4184	9	a	a	DT
8691	4184	10	moment	moment	NN
8691	4184	11	,	,	,
8691	4184	12	and	and	CC
8691	4184	13	shut	shut	VBD
8691	4184	14	off	off	RP
8691	4184	15	all	all	DT
8691	4184	16	unnecessary	unnecessary	JJ
8691	4184	17	discussion	discussion	NN
8691	4184	18	in	in	IN
8691	4184	19	the	the	DT
8691	4184	20	manner	manner	NN
8691	4184	21	that	that	WDT
8691	4184	22	might	may	MD
8691	4184	23	be	be	VB
8691	4184	24	expected	expect	VBN
8691	4184	25	and	and	CC
8691	4184	26	tolerated	tolerate	VBN
8691	4184	27	from	from	IN
8691	4184	28	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4184	29	of	of	IN
8691	4184	30	the	the	DT
8691	4184	31	first	first	JJ
8691	4184	32	rank	rank	NN
8691	4184	33	.	.	.
8691	4185	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4185	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4185	3	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	4185	4	probable	probable	JJ
8691	4185	5	that	that	IN
8691	4185	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4185	7	will	will	MD
8691	4185	8	always	always	RB
8691	4185	9	come	come	VB
8691	4185	10	to	to	IN
8691	4185	11	the	the	DT
8691	4185	12	right	right	JJ
8691	4185	13	decision	decision	NN
8691	4185	14	at	at	IN
8691	4185	15	last	last	JJ
8691	4185	16	.	.	.
8691	4186	1	Hence	hence	RB
8691	4186	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4186	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	4186	4	that	that	DT
8691	4186	5	so	so	RB
8691	4186	6	great	great	JJ
8691	4186	7	a	a	DT
8691	4186	8	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	4186	9	of	of	IN
8691	4186	10	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	4186	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	4186	12	granted	grant	VBN
8691	4186	13	in	in	IN
8691	4186	14	every	every	DT
8691	4186	15	American	American	NNP
8691	4186	16	State	State	NNP
8691	4186	17	.	.	.
8691	4187	1	Appeal	appeal	NN
8691	4187	2	means	mean	VBZ
8691	4187	3	delay	delay	NN
8691	4187	4	.	.	.
8691	4188	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4188	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4188	3	:	:	:
8691	4188	4	See	see	VB
8691	4188	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	4188	6	.	.	.
8691	4189	1	XIX	XIX	NNP
8691	4189	2	.	.	.
8691	4189	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4190	1	A	a	DT
8691	4190	2	man	man	NN
8691	4190	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	4190	4	fortunate	fortunate	JJ
8691	4190	5	whose	whose	WP$
8691	4190	6	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	4190	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4190	8	heard	hear	VBN
8691	4190	9	within	within	IN
8691	4190	10	three	three	CD
8691	4190	11	months	month	NNS
8691	4190	12	and	and	CC
8691	4190	13	decided	decide	VBD
8691	4190	14	within	within	IN
8691	4190	15	six	six	CD
8691	4190	16	.	.	.
8691	4191	1	Oftener	oftener	RB
8691	4191	2	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4191	3	must	must	MD
8691	4191	4	expect	expect	VB
8691	4191	5	to	to	TO
8691	4191	6	wait	wait	VB
8691	4191	7	a	a	DT
8691	4191	8	year	year	NN
8691	4191	9	or	or	CC
8691	4191	10	two	two	CD
8691	4191	11	.	.	.
8691	4192	1	During	during	IN
8691	4192	2	a	a	DT
8691	4192	3	long	long	JJ
8691	4192	4	course	course	NN
8691	4192	5	of	of	IN
8691	4192	6	years	year	NNS
8691	4192	7	an	an	DT
8691	4192	8	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	4192	9	to	to	IN
8691	4192	10	the	the	DT
8691	4192	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4192	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4192	13	of	of	IN
8691	4192	14	the	the	DT
8691	4192	15	United	United	NNP
8691	4192	16	States	States	NNP
8691	4192	17	could	could	MD
8691	4192	18	not	not	RB
8691	4192	19	be	be	VB
8691	4192	20	reached	reach	VBN
8691	4192	21	for	for	IN
8691	4192	22	argument	argument	NN
8691	4192	23	in	in	IN
8691	4192	24	regular	regular	JJ
8691	4192	25	order	order	NN
8691	4192	26	in	in	IN
8691	4192	27	less	less	JJR
8691	4192	28	than	than	IN
8691	4192	29	three	three	CD
8691	4192	30	years	year	NNS
8691	4192	31	after	after	IN
8691	4192	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4192	33	was	be	VBD
8691	4192	34	taken	take	VBN
8691	4192	35	.	.	.
8691	4193	1	In	in	IN
8691	4193	2	Nebraska	Nebraska	NNP
8691	4193	3	,	,	,
8691	4193	4	for	for	IN
8691	4193	5	some	some	DT
8691	4193	6	time	time	NN
8691	4193	7	prior	prior	RB
8691	4193	8	to	to	IN
8691	4193	9	1901	1901	CD
8691	4193	10	the	the	DT
8691	4193	11	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4193	12	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4193	13	was	be	VBD
8691	4193	14	so	so	RB
8691	4193	15	overwhelmed	overwhelmed	JJ
8691	4193	16	with	with	IN
8691	4193	17	business	business	NN
8691	4193	18	that	that	IN
8691	4193	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4193	20	could	could	MD
8691	4193	21	not	not	RB
8691	4193	22	hear	hear	VB
8691	4193	23	a	a	DT
8691	4193	24	cause	cause	NN
8691	4193	25	until	until	IN
8691	4193	26	five	five	CD
8691	4193	27	years	year	NNS
8691	4193	28	after	after	IN
8691	4193	29	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4193	30	was	be	VBD
8691	4193	31	docketed	docket	VBN
8691	4193	32	.	.	.
8691	4194	1	In	in	IN
8691	4194	2	1882	1882	CD
8691	4194	3	a	a	DT
8691	4194	4	brakeman	brakeman	NN
8691	4194	5	was	be	VBD
8691	4194	6	injured	injure	VBN
8691	4194	7	on	on	IN
8691	4194	8	a	a	DT
8691	4194	9	New	New	NNP
8691	4194	10	York	York	NNP
8691	4194	11	railroad	railroad	NN
8691	4194	12	.	.	.
8691	4195	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4195	2	brought	bring	VBD
8691	4195	3	suit	suit	NN
8691	4195	4	against	against	IN
8691	4195	5	the	the	DT
8691	4195	6	company	company	NN
8691	4195	7	,	,	,
8691	4195	8	and	and	CC
8691	4195	9	in	in	IN
8691	4195	10	1884	1884	CD
8691	4195	11	recovered	recover	VBD
8691	4195	12	$	$	$
8691	4195	13	4,000	4,000	CD
8691	4195	14	damages	damage	NNS
8691	4195	15	.	.	.
8691	4196	1	The	the	DT
8691	4196	2	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	4196	3	in	in	IN
8691	4196	4	1886	1886	CD
8691	4196	5	was	be	VBD
8691	4196	6	reversed	reverse	VBN
8691	4196	7	on	on	IN
8691	4196	8	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	4196	9	.	.	.
8691	4197	1	On	on	IN
8691	4197	2	a	a	DT
8691	4197	3	new	new	JJ
8691	4197	4	trial	trial	NN
8691	4197	5	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4197	6	got	get	VBD
8691	4197	7	a	a	DT
8691	4197	8	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	4197	9	for	for	IN
8691	4197	10	$	$	$
8691	4197	11	4,900	4,900	CD
8691	4197	12	.	.	.
8691	4198	1	This	this	DT
8691	4198	2	was	be	VBD
8691	4198	3	appealed	appeal	VBN
8691	4198	4	to	to	IN
8691	4198	5	two	two	CD
8691	4198	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	4198	7	successively	successively	RB
8691	4198	8	.	.	.
8691	4199	1	The	the	DT
8691	4199	2	first	first	JJ
8691	4199	3	affirmed	affirm	VBN
8691	4199	4	and	and	CC
8691	4199	5	the	the	DT
8691	4199	6	second	second	NN
8691	4199	7	reversed	reverse	VBD
8691	4199	8	the	the	DT
8691	4199	9	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	4199	10	.	.	.
8691	4200	1	In	in	IN
8691	4200	2	1889	1889	CD
8691	4200	3	,	,	,
8691	4200	4	there	there	EX
8691	4200	5	was	be	VBD
8691	4200	6	a	a	DT
8691	4200	7	third	third	JJ
8691	4200	8	trial	trial	NN
8691	4200	9	,	,	,
8691	4200	10	at	at	IN
8691	4200	11	which	which	WDT
8691	4200	12	the	the	DT
8691	4200	13	company	company	NN
8691	4200	14	won	win	VBD
8691	4200	15	.	.	.
8691	4201	1	Two	two	CD
8691	4201	2	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	4201	3	by	by	IN
8691	4201	4	the	the	DT
8691	4201	5	brakeman	brakeman	NN
8691	4201	6	followed	follow	VBD
8691	4201	7	.	.	.
8691	4202	1	On	on	IN
8691	4202	2	the	the	DT
8691	4202	3	first	first	JJ
8691	4202	4	the	the	DT
8691	4202	5	intermediate	intermediate	JJ
8691	4202	6	appellate	appellate	JJ
8691	4202	7	court	court	NN
8691	4202	8	,	,	,
8691	4202	9	in	in	IN
8691	4202	10	1894	1894	CD
8691	4202	11	,	,	,
8691	4202	12	decided	decide	VBD
8691	4202	13	against	against	IN
8691	4202	14	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4202	15	.	.	.
8691	4203	1	On	on	IN
8691	4203	2	the	the	DT
8691	4203	3	second	second	JJ
8691	4203	4	,	,	,
8691	4203	5	in	in	IN
8691	4203	6	1897	1897	CD
8691	4203	7	,	,	,
8691	4203	8	the	the	DT
8691	4203	9	court	court	NN
8691	4203	10	of	of	IN
8691	4203	11	last	last	JJ
8691	4203	12	resort	resort	NN
8691	4203	13	decided	decide	VBD
8691	4203	14	for	for	IN
8691	4203	15	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4203	16	.	.	.
8691	4204	1	For	for	IN
8691	4204	2	the	the	DT
8691	4204	3	fourth	fourth	JJ
8691	4204	4	time	time	NN
8691	4204	5	the	the	DT
8691	4204	6	case	case	NN
8691	4204	7	came	come	VBD
8691	4204	8	on	on	RP
8691	4204	9	in	in	IN
8691	4204	10	the	the	DT
8691	4204	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	4204	12	court	court	NN
8691	4204	13	,	,	,
8691	4204	14	and	and	CC
8691	4204	15	a	a	DT
8691	4204	16	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	4204	17	for	for	IN
8691	4204	18	$	$	$
8691	4204	19	4,500	4,500	CD
8691	4204	20	was	be	VBD
8691	4204	21	recovered	recover	VBN
8691	4204	22	.	.	.
8691	4205	1	The	the	DT
8691	4205	2	company	company	NN
8691	4205	3	appealed	appeal	VBD
8691	4205	4	and	and	CC
8691	4205	5	with	with	IN
8691	4205	6	success	success	NN
8691	4205	7	.	.	.
8691	4206	1	A	a	DT
8691	4206	2	fifth	fifth	JJ
8691	4206	3	trial	trial	NN
8691	4206	4	gave	give	VBD
8691	4206	5	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4206	6	a	a	DT
8691	4206	7	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	4206	8	for	for	IN
8691	4206	9	$	$	$
8691	4206	10	4,900	4,900	CD
8691	4206	11	.	.	.
8691	4207	1	This	this	DT
8691	4207	2	,	,	,
8691	4207	3	too	too	RB
8691	4207	4	,	,	,
8691	4207	5	was	be	VBD
8691	4207	6	set	set	VBN
8691	4207	7	aside	aside	RB
8691	4207	8	on	on	IN
8691	4207	9	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	4207	10	.	.	.
8691	4208	1	A	a	DT
8691	4208	2	sixth	sixth	JJ
8691	4208	3	trial	trial	NN
8691	4208	4	followed	follow	VBD
8691	4208	5	with	with	IN
8691	4208	6	exactly	exactly	RB
8691	4208	7	the	the	DT
8691	4208	8	same	same	JJ
8691	4208	9	results	result	NNS
8691	4208	10	.	.	.
8691	4209	1	In	in	IN
8691	4209	2	1902	1902	CD
8691	4209	3	,	,	,
8691	4209	4	the	the	DT
8691	4209	5	seventh	seventh	JJ
8691	4209	6	and	and	CC
8691	4209	7	final	final	JJ
8691	4209	8	trial	trial	NN
8691	4209	9	took	take	VBD
8691	4209	10	place	place	NN
8691	4209	11	.	.	.
8691	4210	1	The	the	DT
8691	4210	2	verdict	verdict	NN
8691	4210	3	this	this	DT
8691	4210	4	time	time	NN
8691	4210	5	was	be	VBD
8691	4210	6	for	for	IN
8691	4210	7	$	$	$
8691	4210	8	4,500	4,500	CD
8691	4210	9	.	.	.
8691	4211	1	The	the	DT
8691	4211	2	company	company	NN
8691	4211	3	appealed	appeal	VBD
8691	4211	4	again	again	RB
8691	4211	5	,	,	,
8691	4211	6	but	but	CC
8691	4211	7	was	be	VBD
8691	4211	8	defeated	defeat	VBN
8691	4211	9	.	.	.
8691	4212	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4212	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4212	3	:	:	:
8691	4212	4	Case	Case	NNP
8691	4212	5	and	and	CC
8691	4212	6	Comment	Comment	NNP
8691	4212	7	,	,	,
8691	4212	8	X	X	NNP
8691	4212	9	,	,	,
8691	4212	10	50	50	CD
8691	4212	11	.	.	.
8691	4212	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4213	1	A	a	DT
8691	4213	2	lawsuit	lawsuit	NN
8691	4213	3	that	that	WDT
8691	4213	4	embraces	embrace	VBZ
8691	4213	5	seven	seven	CD
8691	4213	6	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	4213	7	and	and	CC
8691	4213	8	lasts	last	VBZ
8691	4213	9	for	for	IN
8691	4213	10	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	4213	11	years	year	NNS
8691	4213	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	4213	13	,	,	,
8691	4213	14	of	of	IN
8691	4213	15	course	course	NN
8691	4213	16	,	,	,
8691	4213	17	a	a	DT
8691	4213	18	rarity	rarity	NN
8691	4213	19	,	,	,
8691	4213	20	but	but	CC
8691	4213	21	the	the	DT
8691	4213	22	system	system	NN
8691	4213	23	of	of	IN
8691	4213	24	administrative	administrative	JJ
8691	4213	25	justice	justice	NN
8691	4213	26	under	under	IN
8691	4213	27	which	which	WDT
8691	4213	28	such	such	JJ
8691	4213	29	things	thing	NNS
8691	4213	30	are	be	VBP
8691	4213	31	possible	possible	JJ
8691	4213	32	is	be	VBZ
8691	4213	33	faulty	faulty	JJ
8691	4213	34	somewhere	somewhere	RB
8691	4213	35	.	.	.
8691	4214	1	The	the	DT
8691	4214	2	right	right	NN
8691	4214	3	of	of	IN
8691	4214	4	trial	trial	NN
8691	4214	5	by	by	IN
8691	4214	6	jury	jury	NN
8691	4214	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4214	8	one	one	CD
8691	4214	9	cause	cause	NN
8691	4214	10	of	of	IN
8691	4214	11	such	such	JJ
8691	4214	12	delays	delay	NNS
8691	4214	13	.	.	.
8691	4215	1	The	the	DT
8691	4215	2	broad	broad	JJ
8691	4215	3	right	right	NN
8691	4215	4	of	of	IN
8691	4215	5	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	4215	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	4215	7	another	another	DT
8691	4215	8	.	.	.
8691	4216	1	The	the	DT
8691	4216	2	want	want	NN
8691	4216	3	of	of	IN
8691	4216	4	skill	skill	NN
8691	4216	5	and	and	CC
8691	4216	6	experience	experience	NN
8691	4216	7	on	on	IN
8691	4216	8	the	the	DT
8691	4216	9	part	part	NN
8691	4216	10	of	of	IN
8691	4216	11	trial	trial	NN
8691	4216	12	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4216	13	and	and	CC
8691	4216	14	trial	trial	NN
8691	4216	15	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4216	16	may	may	MD
8691	4216	17	be	be	VB
8691	4216	18	a	a	DT
8691	4216	19	third	third	NN
8691	4216	20	.	.	.
8691	4217	1	The	the	DT
8691	4217	2	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	4217	3	-	-	HYPH
8691	4217	4	three	three	CD
8691	4217	5	English	english	JJ
8691	4217	6	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4217	7	of	of	IN
8691	4217	8	the	the	DT
8691	4217	9	High	High	NNP
8691	4217	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4217	11	of	of	IN
8691	4217	12	Justice	Justice	NNP
8691	4217	13	(	(	-LRB-
8691	4217	14	with	with	IN
8691	4217	15	the	the	DT
8691	4217	16	aid	aid	NN
8691	4217	17	of	of	IN
8691	4217	18	masters	master	NNS
8691	4217	19	in	in	IN
8691	4217	20	chancery	chancery	NN
8691	4217	21	and	and	CC
8691	4217	22	referees	referee	NNS
8691	4217	23	)	)	-RRB-
8691	4217	24	actually	actually	RB
8691	4217	25	try	try	VBP
8691	4217	26	and	and	CC
8691	4217	27	determine	determine	VBP
8691	4217	28	about	about	RB
8691	4217	29	fifty	fifty	CD
8691	4217	30	-	-	HYPH
8691	4217	31	six	six	CD
8691	4217	32	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	4217	33	cases	case	NNS
8691	4217	34	a	a	DT
8691	4217	35	year	year	NN
8691	4217	36	.	.	.
8691	4218	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4218	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4218	3	:	:	:
8691	4218	4	This	this	DT
8691	4218	5	was	be	VBD
8691	4218	6	the	the	DT
8691	4218	7	average	average	JJ
8691	4218	8	number	number	NN
8691	4218	9	for	for	IN
8691	4218	10	each	each	DT
8691	4218	11	of	of	IN
8691	4218	12	the	the	DT
8691	4218	13	years	year	NNS
8691	4218	14	1900	1900	CD
8691	4218	15	and	and	CC
8691	4218	16	1901	1901	CD
8691	4218	17	.	.	.
8691	4218	18	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4219	1	Each	each	DT
8691	4219	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	4219	3	,	,	,
8691	4219	4	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	4219	5	,	,	,
8691	4219	6	on	on	IN
8691	4219	7	the	the	DT
8691	4219	8	average	average	NN
8691	4219	9	,	,	,
8691	4219	10	dispatches	dispatch	NNS
8691	4219	11	over	over	IN
8691	4219	12	two	two	CD
8691	4219	13	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	4219	14	and	and	CC
8691	4219	15	forty	forty	CD
8691	4219	16	.	.	.
8691	4220	1	No	no	DT
8691	4220	2	American	american	JJ
8691	4220	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4220	4	under	under	IN
8691	4220	5	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4220	6	American	american	JJ
8691	4220	7	system	system	NN
8691	4220	8	of	of	IN
8691	4220	9	practice	practice	NN
8691	4220	10	could	could	MD
8691	4220	11	do	do	VB
8691	4220	12	as	as	RB
8691	4220	13	much	much	JJ
8691	4220	14	and	and	CC
8691	4220	15	do	do	VB
8691	4220	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4220	17	well	well	RB
8691	4220	18	.	.	.
8691	4221	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4221	2	tolerate	tolerate	VBP
8691	4221	3	a	a	DT
8691	4221	4	succession	succession	NN
8691	4221	5	of	of	IN
8691	4221	6	motions	motion	NNS
8691	4221	7	and	and	CC
8691	4221	8	objections	objection	NNS
8691	4221	9	and	and	CC
8691	4221	10	arguments	argument	NNS
8691	4221	11	from	from	IN
8691	4221	12	the	the	DT
8691	4221	13	bar	bar	NN
8691	4221	14	which	which	WDT
8691	4221	15	English	English	NNP
8691	4221	16	courts	court	NNS
8691	4221	17	would	would	MD
8691	4221	18	not	not	RB
8691	4221	19	.	.	.
8691	4222	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4222	2	often	often	RB
8691	4222	3	take	take	VBP
8691	4222	4	more	more	JJR
8691	4222	5	time	time	NN
8691	4222	6	in	in	IN
8691	4222	7	impanelling	impanel	VBG
8691	4222	8	a	a	DT
8691	4222	9	jury	jury	NN
8691	4222	10	than	than	IN
8691	4222	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4222	12	would	would	MD
8691	4222	13	in	in	IN
8691	4222	14	trying	try	VBG
8691	4222	15	the	the	DT
8691	4222	16	case	case	NN
8691	4222	17	.	.	.
8691	4223	1	The	the	DT
8691	4223	2	American	american	JJ
8691	4223	3	bar	bar	NN
8691	4223	4	,	,	,
8691	4223	5	unlike	unlike	IN
8691	4223	6	the	the	DT
8691	4223	7	English	English	NNP
8691	4223	8	,	,	,
8691	4223	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	4223	10	not	not	RB
8691	4223	11	so	so	RB
8691	4223	12	constituted	constituted	JJ
8691	4223	13	that	that	IN
8691	4223	14	a	a	DT
8691	4223	15	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4223	16	number	number	NN
8691	4223	17	of	of	IN
8691	4223	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4223	19	members	member	NNS
8691	4223	20	are	be	VBP
8691	4223	21	professedly	professedly	RB
8691	4223	22	devoted	devoted	JJ
8691	4223	23	in	in	IN
8691	4223	24	a	a	DT
8691	4223	25	special	special	JJ
8691	4223	26	way	way	NN
8691	4223	27	to	to	IN
8691	4223	28	the	the	DT
8691	4223	29	trial	trial	NN
8691	4223	30	of	of	IN
8691	4223	31	cases	case	NNS
8691	4223	32	.	.	.
8691	4224	1	The	the	DT
8691	4224	2	English	English	NNP
8691	4224	3	barrister	barrister	NN
8691	4224	4	in	in	IN
8691	4224	5	active	active	JJ
8691	4224	6	practice	practice	NN
8691	4224	7	may	may	MD
8691	4224	8	almost	almost	RB
8691	4224	9	be	be	VB
8691	4224	10	said	say	VBN
8691	4224	11	to	to	TO
8691	4224	12	do	do	VB
8691	4224	13	nothing	nothing	NN
8691	4224	14	else	else	RB
8691	4224	15	.	.	.
8691	4225	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4225	2	standing	standing	NN
8691	4225	3	and	and	CC
8691	4225	4	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4225	5	income	income	NN
8691	4225	6	depend	depend	VBP
8691	4225	7	on	on	IN
8691	4225	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4225	9	ability	ability	NN
8691	4225	10	to	to	TO
8691	4225	11	try	try	VB
8691	4225	12	case	case	NN
8691	4225	13	after	after	IN
8691	4225	14	case	case	NN
8691	4225	15	in	in	IN
8691	4225	16	rapid	rapid	JJ
8691	4225	17	succession	succession	NN
8691	4225	18	.	.	.
8691	4226	1	Others	other	NNS
8691	4226	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4226	3	responsible	responsible	JJ
8691	4226	4	for	for	IN
8691	4226	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4226	6	slow	slow	JJ
8691	4226	7	and	and	CC
8691	4226	8	careful	careful	JJ
8691	4226	9	preparation	preparation	NN
8691	4226	10	.	.	.
8691	4227	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4227	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4227	3	responsible	responsible	JJ
8691	4227	4	for	for	IN
8691	4227	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4227	6	quick	quick	JJ
8691	4227	7	and	and	CC
8691	4227	8	effective	effective	JJ
8691	4227	9	dispatch	dispatch	NN
8691	4227	10	when	when	WRB
8691	4227	11	the	the	DT
8691	4227	12	preparation	preparation	NN
8691	4227	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	4227	14	ended	end	VBN
8691	4227	15	.	.	.
8691	4228	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4228	2	becomes	become	VBZ
8691	4228	3	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	4228	4	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	4228	5	with	with	IN
8691	4228	6	the	the	DT
8691	4228	7	_	_	NNP
8691	4228	8	technique	technique	NN
8691	4228	9	_	_	NNP
8691	4228	10	of	of	IN
8691	4228	11	a	a	DT
8691	4228	12	trial	trial	NN
8691	4228	13	at	at	IN
8691	4228	14	every	every	DT
8691	4228	15	point	point	NN
8691	4228	16	.	.	.
8691	4229	1	In	in	IN
8691	4229	2	examining	examine	VBG
8691	4229	3	a	a	DT
8691	4229	4	witness	witness	NN
8691	4229	5	,	,	,
8691	4229	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4229	7	strikes	strike	VBZ
8691	4229	8	directly	directly	RB
8691	4229	9	at	at	IN
8691	4229	10	what	what	WP
8691	4229	11	is	be	VBZ
8691	4229	12	material	material	NN
8691	4229	13	,	,	,
8691	4229	14	and	and	CC
8691	4229	15	would	would	MD
8691	4229	16	be	be	VB
8691	4229	17	ashamed	ashamed	JJ
8691	4229	18	to	to	TO
8691	4229	19	appear	appear	VB
8691	4229	20	ignorant	ignorant	JJ
8691	4229	21	of	of	IN
8691	4229	22	what	what	WP
8691	4229	23	that	that	DT
8691	4229	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	4229	25	.	.	.
8691	4230	1	In	in	IN
8691	4230	2	argument	argument	NN
8691	4230	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4230	4	stops	stop	VBZ
8691	4230	5	when	when	WRB
8691	4230	6	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4230	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4230	8	through	through	RB
8691	4230	9	.	.	.
8691	4231	1	The	the	DT
8691	4231	2	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	4231	3	American	american	JJ
8691	4231	4	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4231	5	who	who	WP
8691	4231	6	tries	try	VBZ
8691	4231	7	a	a	DT
8691	4231	8	case	case	NN
8691	4231	9	to	to	IN
8691	4231	10	-	-	HYPH
8691	4231	11	day	day	NN
8691	4231	12	,	,	,
8691	4231	13	draws	draw	VBZ
8691	4231	14	papers	paper	NNS
8691	4231	15	constituting	constitute	VBG
8691	4231	16	a	a	DT
8691	4231	17	partnership	partnership	NN
8691	4231	18	or	or	CC
8691	4231	19	a	a	DT
8691	4231	20	corporation	corporation	NN
8691	4231	21	the	the	DT
8691	4231	22	next	next	JJ
8691	4231	23	,	,	,
8691	4231	24	and	and	CC
8691	4231	25	prepares	prepare	VBZ
8691	4231	26	an	an	DT
8691	4231	27	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	4231	28	on	on	IN
8691	4231	29	the	the	DT
8691	4231	30	construction	construction	NN
8691	4231	31	of	of	IN
8691	4231	32	a	a	DT
8691	4231	33	will	will	NN
8691	4231	34	the	the	DT
8691	4231	35	day	day	NN
8691	4231	36	after	after	RB
8691	4231	37	,	,	,
8691	4231	38	has	have	VBZ
8691	4231	39	not	not	RB
8691	4231	40	that	that	DT
8691	4231	41	concentration	concentration	NN
8691	4231	42	of	of	IN
8691	4231	43	knowledge	knowledge	NN
8691	4231	44	which	which	WDT
8691	4231	45	comes	come	VBZ
8691	4231	46	from	from	IN
8691	4231	47	concentration	concentration	NN
8691	4231	48	of	of	IN
8691	4231	49	occupation	occupation	NN
8691	4231	50	.	.	.
8691	4232	1	The	the	DT
8691	4232	2	art	art	NN
8691	4232	3	of	of	IN
8691	4232	4	making	make	VBG
8691	4232	5	a	a	DT
8691	4232	6	clear	clear	JJ
8691	4232	7	and	and	CC
8691	4232	8	definite	definite	JJ
8691	4232	9	statement	statement	NN
8691	4232	10	of	of	IN
8691	4232	11	the	the	DT
8691	4232	12	points	point	NNS
8691	4232	13	in	in	IN
8691	4232	14	controversy	controversy	NN
8691	4232	15	on	on	IN
8691	4232	16	paper	paper	NN
8691	4232	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	4232	18	also	also	RB
8691	4232	19	one	one	CD
8691	4232	20	not	not	RB
8691	4232	21	sufficiently	sufficiently	RB
8691	4232	22	cultivated	cultivate	VBN
8691	4232	23	by	by	IN
8691	4232	24	the	the	DT
8691	4232	25	American	american	JJ
8691	4232	26	bar	bar	NN
8691	4232	27	.	.	.
8691	4233	1	Without	without	IN
8691	4233	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4233	3	the	the	DT
8691	4233	4	system	system	NN
8691	4233	5	of	of	IN
8691	4233	6	"	"	``
8691	4233	7	code	code	NN
8691	4233	8	pleading	pleading	NN
8691	4233	9	,	,	,
8691	4233	10	"	"	''
8691	4233	11	which	which	WDT
8691	4233	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	4233	13	in	in	IN
8691	4233	14	most	most	JJS
8691	4233	15	States	States	NNPS
8691	4233	16	supplanted	supplant	VBD
8691	4233	17	the	the	DT
8691	4233	18	rigid	rigid	JJ
8691	4233	19	and	and	CC
8691	4233	20	often	often	RB
8691	4233	21	meaningless	meaningless	JJ
8691	4233	22	forms	form	NNS
8691	4233	23	of	of	IN
8691	4233	24	the	the	DT
8691	4233	25	common	common	JJ
8691	4233	26	law	law	NN
8691	4233	27	,	,	,
8691	4233	28	leads	lead	VBZ
8691	4233	29	to	to	IN
8691	4233	30	confusion	confusion	NN
8691	4233	31	and	and	CC
8691	4233	32	obscurity	obscurity	NN
8691	4233	33	.	.	.
8691	4234	1	The	the	DT
8691	4234	2	claims	claim	NNS
8691	4234	3	of	of	IN
8691	4234	4	each	each	DT
8691	4234	5	party	party	NN
8691	4234	6	ought	ought	MD
8691	4234	7	to	to	TO
8691	4234	8	be	be	VB
8691	4234	9	,	,	,
8691	4234	10	but	but	CC
8691	4234	11	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	4234	12	are	be	VBP
8691	4234	13	,	,	,
8691	4234	14	so	so	RB
8691	4234	15	presented	present	VBD
8691	4234	16	that	that	IN
8691	4234	17	matters	matter	NNS
8691	4234	18	of	of	IN
8691	4234	19	law	law	NN
8691	4234	20	are	be	VBP
8691	4234	21	,	,	,
8691	4234	22	so	so	RB
8691	4234	23	far	far	RB
8691	4234	24	as	as	IN
8691	4234	25	possible	possible	JJ
8691	4234	26	,	,	,
8691	4234	27	kept	keep	VBD
8691	4234	28	distinct	distinct	JJ
8691	4234	29	from	from	IN
8691	4234	30	matters	matter	NNS
8691	4234	31	of	of	IN
8691	4234	32	fact	fact	NN
8691	4234	33	,	,	,
8691	4234	34	and	and	CC
8691	4234	35	what	what	WP
8691	4234	36	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4234	37	means	mean	VBZ
8691	4234	38	to	to	TO
8691	4234	39	prove	prove	VB
8691	4234	40	is	be	VBZ
8691	4234	41	set	set	VBN
8691	4234	42	forth	forth	RP
8691	4234	43	,	,	,
8691	4234	44	but	but	CC
8691	4234	45	not	not	RB
8691	4234	46	the	the	DT
8691	4234	47	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	4234	48	by	by	IN
8691	4234	49	which	which	WDT
8691	4234	50	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4234	51	hopes	hope	VBZ
8691	4234	52	to	to	TO
8691	4234	53	establish	establish	VB
8691	4234	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4234	55	.	.	.
8691	4235	1	This	this	DT
8691	4235	2	looseness	looseness	NN
8691	4235	3	of	of	IN
8691	4235	4	pleading	plead	VBG
8691	4235	5	leads	lead	NNS
8691	4235	6	to	to	IN
8691	4235	7	endless	endless	JJ
8691	4235	8	motions	motion	NNS
8691	4235	9	to	to	TO
8691	4235	10	expunge	expunge	VB
8691	4235	11	this	this	DT
8691	4235	12	and	and	CC
8691	4235	13	correct	correct	JJ
8691	4235	14	that	that	DT
8691	4235	15	,	,	,
8691	4235	16	and	and	CC
8691	4235	17	time	time	NN
8691	4235	18	of	of	IN
8691	4235	19	the	the	DT
8691	4235	20	court	court	NN
8691	4235	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	4235	22	taken	take	VBN
8691	4235	23	up	up	RP
8691	4235	24	by	by	IN
8691	4235	25	the	the	DT
8691	4235	26	preliminaries	preliminary	NNS
8691	4235	27	of	of	IN
8691	4235	28	trials	trial	NNS
8691	4235	29	which	which	WDT
8691	4235	30	,	,	,
8691	4235	31	if	if	IN
8691	4235	32	the	the	DT
8691	4235	33	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4235	34	used	use	VBD
8691	4235	35	more	more	JJR
8691	4235	36	care	care	NN
8691	4235	37	or	or	CC
8691	4235	38	had	have	VBD
8691	4235	39	more	more	JJR
8691	4235	40	skill	skill	NN
8691	4235	41	,	,	,
8691	4235	42	would	would	MD
8691	4235	43	be	be	VB
8691	4235	44	devoted	devoted	JJ
8691	4235	45	to	to	IN
8691	4235	46	the	the	DT
8691	4235	47	trials	trial	NNS
8691	4235	48	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4235	49	.	.	.
8691	4236	1	Still	still	RB
8691	4236	2	worse	bad	JJR
8691	4236	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	4236	4	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4236	5	when	when	WRB
8691	4236	6	such	such	JJ
8691	4236	7	motions	motion	NNS
8691	4236	8	are	be	VBP
8691	4236	9	postponed	postpone	VBN
8691	4236	10	until	until	IN
8691	4236	11	the	the	DT
8691	4236	12	case	case	NN
8691	4236	13	comes	come	VBZ
8691	4236	14	on	on	RP
8691	4236	15	for	for	IN
8691	4236	16	final	final	JJ
8691	4236	17	hearing	hearing	NN
8691	4236	18	,	,	,
8691	4236	19	and	and	CC
8691	4236	20	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	4236	21	and	and	CC
8691	4236	22	juries	jury	NNS
8691	4236	23	are	be	VBP
8691	4236	24	compelled	compel	VBN
8691	4236	25	to	to	TO
8691	4236	26	wait	wait	VB
8691	4236	27	during	during	IN
8691	4236	28	tedious	tedious	JJ
8691	4236	29	arguments	argument	NNS
8691	4236	30	over	over	IN
8691	4236	31	questions	question	NNS
8691	4236	32	of	of	IN
8691	4236	33	mere	mere	JJ
8691	4236	34	form	form	NN
8691	4236	35	.	.	.
8691	4237	1	In	in	IN
8691	4237	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4237	3	great	great	JJ
8691	4237	4	centers	center	NNS
8691	4237	5	of	of	IN
8691	4237	6	population	population	NN
8691	4237	7	business	business	NN
8691	4237	8	under	under	IN
8691	4237	9	these	these	DT
8691	4237	10	circumstances	circumstance	NNS
8691	4237	11	almost	almost	RB
8691	4237	12	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	4237	13	accumulates	accumulate	VBZ
8691	4237	14	too	too	RB
8691	4237	15	fast	fast	RB
8691	4237	16	for	for	IN
8691	4237	17	the	the	DT
8691	4237	18	courts	court	NNS
8691	4237	19	to	to	TO
8691	4237	20	handle	handle	VB
8691	4237	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4237	22	.	.	.
8691	4238	1	In	in	IN
8691	4238	2	bringing	bring	VBG
8691	4238	3	on	on	RP
8691	4238	4	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	4238	5	trials	trial	NNS
8691	4238	6	there	there	EX
8691	4238	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4238	8	little	little	JJ
8691	4238	9	delay	delay	NN
8691	4238	10	,	,	,
8691	4238	11	unless	unless	IN
8691	4238	12	at	at	IN
8691	4238	13	the	the	DT
8691	4238	14	request	request	NN
8691	4238	15	of	of	IN
8691	4238	16	the	the	DT
8691	4238	17	accused	accuse	VBN
8691	4238	18	,	,	,
8691	4238	19	and	and	CC
8691	4238	20	for	for	IN
8691	4238	21	what	what	WP
8691	4238	22	seems	seem	VBZ
8691	4238	23	good	good	JJ
8691	4238	24	reason	reason	NN
8691	4238	25	.	.	.
8691	4239	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4239	2	Constitutions	Constitutions	NNPS
8691	4239	3	generally	generally	RB
8691	4239	4	provide	provide	VBP
8691	4239	5	that	that	IN
8691	4239	6	whoever	whoever	WP
8691	4239	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4239	8	to	to	TO
8691	4239	9	be	be	VB
8691	4239	10	tried	try	VBN
8691	4239	11	on	on	IN
8691	4239	12	a	a	DT
8691	4239	13	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	4239	14	charge	charge	NN
8691	4239	15	shall	shall	MD
8691	4239	16	be	be	VB
8691	4239	17	tried	try	VBN
8691	4239	18	promptly	promptly	RB
8691	4239	19	,	,	,
8691	4239	20	and	and	CC
8691	4239	21	the	the	DT
8691	4239	22	practice	practice	NN
8691	4239	23	of	of	IN
8691	4239	24	the	the	DT
8691	4239	25	courts	court	NNS
8691	4239	26	conforms	conform	VBZ
8691	4239	27	to	to	IN
8691	4239	28	this	this	DT
8691	4239	29	rule	rule	NN
8691	4239	30	.	.	.
8691	4240	1	The	the	DT
8691	4240	2	broad	broad	JJ
8691	4240	3	right	right	NN
8691	4240	4	of	of	IN
8691	4240	5	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	4240	6	,	,	,
8691	4240	7	however	however	RB
8691	4240	8	,	,	,
8691	4240	9	for	for	IN
8691	4240	10	errors	error	NNS
8691	4240	11	of	of	IN
8691	4240	12	law	law	NN
8691	4240	13	on	on	IN
8691	4240	14	the	the	DT
8691	4240	15	part	part	NN
8691	4240	16	of	of	IN
8691	4240	17	the	the	DT
8691	4240	18	court	court	NN
8691	4240	19	may	may	MD
8691	4240	20	serve	serve	VB
8691	4240	21	to	to	TO
8691	4240	22	postpone	postpone	VB
8691	4240	23	the	the	DT
8691	4240	24	execution	execution	NN
8691	4240	25	of	of	IN
8691	4240	26	a	a	DT
8691	4240	27	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	4240	28	,	,	,
8691	4240	29	and	and	CC
8691	4240	30	too	too	RB
8691	4240	31	many	many	JJ
8691	4240	32	new	new	JJ
8691	4240	33	trials	trial	NNS
8691	4240	34	are	be	VBP
8691	4240	35	granted	grant	VBN
8691	4240	36	by	by	IN
8691	4240	37	the	the	DT
8691	4240	38	courts	court	NNS
8691	4240	39	for	for	IN
8691	4240	40	steps	step	NNS
8691	4240	41	in	in	IN
8691	4240	42	procedure	procedure	NN
8691	4240	43	in	in	IN
8691	4240	44	matters	matter	NNS
8691	4240	45	of	of	IN
8691	4240	46	a	a	DT
8691	4240	47	purely	purely	RB
8691	4240	48	technical	technical	JJ
8691	4240	49	character	character	NN
8691	4240	50	.	.	.
8691	4241	1	Delays	delay	NNS
8691	4241	2	from	from	IN
8691	4241	3	this	this	DT
8691	4241	4	cause	cause	NN
8691	4241	5	are	be	VBP
8691	4241	6	,	,	,
8691	4241	7	however	however	RB
8691	4241	8	,	,	,
8691	4241	9	comparatively	comparatively	RB
8691	4241	10	infrequent	infrequent	NN
8691	4241	11	.	.	.
8691	4242	1	Most	Most	JJS
8691	4242	2	convicts	convict	NNS
8691	4242	3	are	be	VBP
8691	4242	4	too	too	RB
8691	4242	5	poor	poor	JJ
8691	4242	6	to	to	TO
8691	4242	7	take	take	VB
8691	4242	8	advantage	advantage	NN
8691	4242	9	of	of	IN
8691	4242	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4242	11	.	.	.
8691	4243	1	Most	most	RBS
8691	4243	2	also	also	RB
8691	4243	3	know	know	VBP
8691	4243	4	that	that	IN
8691	4243	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4243	6	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	4243	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4243	8	just	just	RB
8691	4243	9	,	,	,
8691	4243	10	and	and	CC
8691	4243	11	are	be	VBP
8691	4243	12	anxious	anxious	JJ
8691	4243	13	only	only	RB
8691	4243	14	to	to	TO
8691	4243	15	have	have	VB
8691	4243	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4243	17	executed	execute	VBN
8691	4243	18	and	and	CC
8691	4243	19	through	through	RB
8691	4243	20	with	with	IN
8691	4243	21	as	as	RB
8691	4243	22	soon	soon	RB
8691	4243	23	as	as	IN
8691	4243	24	possible	possible	JJ
8691	4243	25	.	.	.
8691	4244	1	In	in	IN
8691	4244	2	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	4244	3	one	one	CD
8691	4244	4	case	case	NN
8691	4244	5	in	in	IN
8691	4244	6	a	a	DT
8691	4244	7	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	4244	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	4244	9	an	an	DT
8691	4244	10	appeal	appeal	NN
8691	4244	11	taken	take	VBN
8691	4244	12	or	or	CC
8691	4244	13	,	,	,
8691	4244	14	if	if	IN
8691	4244	15	taken	take	VBN
8691	4244	16	,	,	,
8691	4244	17	pursued	pursue	VBN
8691	4244	18	to	to	IN
8691	4244	19	the	the	DT
8691	4244	20	end	end	NN
8691	4244	21	.	.	.
8691	4245	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4245	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4245	3	:	:	:
8691	4245	4	See	see	VB
8691	4245	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	4245	6	.	.	.
8691	4246	1	XVII	XVII	NNP
8691	4246	2	.	.	.
8691	4246	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4247	1	In	in	IN
8691	4247	2	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4247	3	largest	large	JJS
8691	4247	4	cities	city	NNS
8691	4247	5	the	the	DT
8691	4247	6	disposition	disposition	NN
8691	4247	7	of	of	IN
8691	4247	8	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	4247	9	business	business	NN
8691	4247	10	occupies	occupy	VBZ
8691	4247	11	the	the	DT
8691	4247	12	time	time	NN
8691	4247	13	of	of	IN
8691	4247	14	several	several	JJ
8691	4247	15	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4247	16	,	,	,
8691	4247	17	and	and	CC
8691	4247	18	the	the	DT
8691	4247	19	prosecuting	prosecute	VBG
8691	4247	20	officer	officer	NN
8691	4247	21	has	have	VBZ
8691	4247	22	a	a	DT
8691	4247	23	staff	staff	NN
8691	4247	24	of	of	IN
8691	4247	25	professional	professional	JJ
8691	4247	26	assistants	assistant	NNS
8691	4247	27	.	.	.
8691	4248	1	In	in	IN
8691	4248	2	cases	case	NNS
8691	4248	3	of	of	IN
8691	4248	4	such	such	JJ
8691	4248	5	importance	importance	NN
8691	4248	6	as	as	IN
8691	4248	7	to	to	TO
8691	4248	8	call	call	VB
8691	4248	9	for	for	IN
8691	4248	10	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4248	11	personal	personal	JJ
8691	4248	12	management	management	NN
8691	4248	13	a	a	DT
8691	4248	14	postponement	postponement	NN
8691	4248	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	4248	16	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	4248	17	inevitable	inevitable	JJ
8691	4248	18	.	.	.
8691	4249	1	In	in	IN
8691	4249	2	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
8691	4249	3	,	,	,
8691	4249	4	in	in	IN
8691	4249	5	December	December	NNP
8691	4249	6	,	,	,
8691	4249	7	1903	1903	CD
8691	4249	8	,	,	,
8691	4249	9	over	over	IN
8691	4249	10	a	a	DT
8691	4249	11	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	4249	12	cases	case	NNS
8691	4249	13	were	be	VBD
8691	4249	14	awaiting	await	VBG
8691	4249	15	trial	trial	NN
8691	4249	16	in	in	IN
8691	4249	17	the	the	DT
8691	4249	18	Criminal	Criminal	NNP
8691	4249	19	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4249	20	.	.	.
8691	4250	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4250	2	tends	tend	VBZ
8691	4250	3	to	to	TO
8691	4250	4	expedition	expedition	VB
8691	4250	5	in	in	IN
8691	4250	6	the	the	DT
8691	4250	7	trial	trial	NN
8691	4250	8	of	of	IN
8691	4250	9	any	any	DT
8691	4250	10	cause	cause	NN
8691	4250	11	if	if	IN
8691	4250	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4250	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	4250	14	heard	hear	VBN
8691	4250	15	before	before	IN
8691	4250	16	a	a	DT
8691	4250	17	judge	judge	NN
8691	4250	18	especially	especially	RB
8691	4250	19	familiar	familiar	JJ
8691	4250	20	with	with	IN
8691	4250	21	the	the	DT
8691	4250	22	class	class	NN
8691	4250	23	of	of	IN
8691	4250	24	questions	question	NNS
8691	4250	25	which	which	WDT
8691	4250	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4250	27	involves	involve	VBZ
8691	4250	28	.	.	.
8691	4251	1	Criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	4251	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	4251	3	,	,	,
8691	4251	4	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	4251	5	in	in	IN
8691	4251	6	cities	city	NNS
8691	4251	7	,	,	,
8691	4251	8	are	be	VBP
8691	4251	9	largely	largely	RB
8691	4251	10	held	hold	VBN
8691	4251	11	by	by	IN
8691	4251	12	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4251	13	whose	whose	WP$
8691	4251	14	work	work	NN
8691	4251	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	4251	16	either	either	CC
8691	4251	17	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	4251	18	or	or	CC
8691	4251	19	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	4251	20	confined	confine	VBN
8691	4251	21	to	to	IN
8691	4251	22	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4251	23	.	.	.
8691	4252	1	This	this	DT
8691	4252	2	helps	help	VBZ
8691	4252	3	greatly	greatly	RB
8691	4252	4	to	to	TO
8691	4252	5	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	4252	6	delays	delay	NNS
8691	4252	7	in	in	IN
8691	4252	8	such	such	JJ
8691	4252	9	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	4252	10	.	.	.
8691	4253	1	For	for	IN
8691	4253	2	a	a	DT
8691	4253	3	similar	similar	JJ
8691	4253	4	cause	cause	NN
8691	4253	5	admiralty	admiralty	NN
8691	4253	6	business	business	NN
8691	4253	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4253	8	dispatched	dispatch	VBN
8691	4253	9	with	with	IN
8691	4253	10	great	great	JJ
8691	4253	11	rapidity	rapidity	NN
8691	4253	12	by	by	IN
8691	4253	13	the	the	DT
8691	4253	14	District	District	NNP
8691	4253	15	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	4253	16	at	at	IN
8691	4253	17	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4253	18	principal	principal	JJ
8691	4253	19	ports	port	NNS
8691	4253	20	,	,	,
8691	4253	21	and	and	CC
8691	4253	22	patent	patent	NN
8691	4253	23	causes	cause	NNS
8691	4253	24	by	by	IN
8691	4253	25	the	the	DT
8691	4253	26	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	4253	27	Courts	Courts	NNPS
8691	4253	28	.	.	.
8691	4254	1	In	in	IN
8691	4254	2	the	the	DT
8691	4254	3	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	4254	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	4254	5	of	of	IN
8691	4254	6	New	New	NNP
8691	4254	7	York	York	NNP
8691	4254	8	City	City	NNP
8691	4254	9	in	in	IN
8691	4254	10	1903	1903	CD
8691	4254	11	,	,	,
8691	4254	12	there	there	EX
8691	4254	13	were	be	VBD
8691	4254	14	about	about	RB
8691	4254	15	3,000	3,000	CD
8691	4254	16	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	4254	17	on	on	IN
8691	4254	18	which	which	WDT
8691	4254	19	indictments	indictment	NNS
8691	4254	20	were	be	VBD
8691	4254	21	found	find	VBN
8691	4254	22	,	,	,
8691	4254	23	and	and	CC
8691	4254	24	the	the	DT
8691	4254	25	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	4254	26	committed	commit	VBD
8691	4254	27	for	for	IN
8691	4254	28	want	want	NN
8691	4254	29	of	of	IN
8691	4254	30	bail	bail	NN
8691	4254	31	.	.	.
8691	4255	1	In	in	IN
8691	4255	2	most	most	JJS
8691	4255	3	of	of	IN
8691	4255	4	these	these	DT
8691	4255	5	cases	case	NNS
8691	4255	6	there	there	EX
8691	4255	7	was	be	VBD
8691	4255	8	a	a	DT
8691	4255	9	plea	plea	NN
8691	4255	10	of	of	IN
8691	4255	11	guilty	guilty	JJ
8691	4255	12	,	,	,
8691	4255	13	but	but	CC
8691	4255	14	counting	count	VBG
8691	4255	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4255	16	with	with	IN
8691	4255	17	the	the	DT
8691	4255	18	others	other	NNS
8691	4255	19	,	,	,
8691	4255	20	the	the	DT
8691	4255	21	average	average	JJ
8691	4255	22	time	time	NN
8691	4255	23	as	as	IN
8691	4255	24	to	to	IN
8691	4255	25	all	all	DT
8691	4255	26	which	which	WDT
8691	4255	27	elapsed	elapse	VBD
8691	4255	28	between	between	IN
8691	4255	29	the	the	DT
8691	4255	30	original	original	JJ
8691	4255	31	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	4255	32	and	and	CC
8691	4255	33	the	the	DT
8691	4255	34	final	final	JJ
8691	4255	35	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	4255	36	was	be	VBD
8691	4255	37	only	only	RB
8691	4255	38	eight	eight	CD
8691	4255	39	days	day	NNS
8691	4255	40	.	.	.
8691	4256	1	During	during	IN
8691	4256	2	the	the	DT
8691	4256	3	same	same	JJ
8691	4256	4	time	time	NN
8691	4256	5	those	those	DT
8691	4256	6	who	who	WP
8691	4256	7	gave	give	VBD
8691	4256	8	bail	bail	NN
8691	4256	9	were	be	VBD
8691	4256	10	generally	generally	RB
8691	4256	11	tried	try	VBN
8691	4256	12	within	within	IN
8691	4256	13	three	three	CD
8691	4256	14	months	month	NNS
8691	4256	15	from	from	IN
8691	4256	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4256	17	arrest	arrest	NN
8691	4256	18	.	.	.
8691	4257	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4257	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4257	3	:	:	:
8691	4257	4	Nathan	Nathan	NNP
8691	4257	5	A.	A.	NNP
8691	4257	6	Smyth	Smyth	NNP
8691	4257	7	in	in	IN
8691	4257	8	the	the	DT
8691	4257	9	Harvard	Harvard	NNP
8691	4257	10	Law	Law	NNP
8691	4257	11	Review	Review	NNP
8691	4257	12	for	for	IN
8691	4257	13	March	March	NNP
8691	4257	14	,	,	,
8691	4257	15	1904	1904	CD
8691	4257	16	.	.	.
8691	4257	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4258	1	An	an	DT
8691	4258	2	insufficiency	insufficiency	NN
8691	4258	3	of	of	IN
8691	4258	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4258	5	was	be	VBD
8691	4258	6	formerly	formerly	RB
8691	4258	7	one	one	CD
8691	4258	8	great	great	JJ
8691	4258	9	cause	cause	NN
8691	4258	10	of	of	IN
8691	4258	11	delay	delay	NN
8691	4258	12	,	,	,
8691	4258	13	but	but	CC
8691	4258	14	the	the	DT
8691	4258	15	modern	modern	JJ
8691	4258	16	tendency	tendency	NN
8691	4258	17	has	have	VBZ
8691	4258	18	been	be	VBN
8691	4258	19	to	to	TO
8691	4258	20	have	have	VB
8691	4258	21	too	too	RB
8691	4258	22	many	many	JJ
8691	4258	23	,	,	,
8691	4258	24	rather	rather	RB
8691	4258	25	than	than	IN
8691	4258	26	too	too	RB
8691	4258	27	few	few	JJ
8691	4258	28	.	.	.
8691	4259	1	In	in	IN
8691	4259	2	the	the	DT
8691	4259	3	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4259	4	of	of	IN
8691	4259	5	Chancery	Chancery	NNP
8691	4259	6	in	in	IN
8691	4259	7	Virginia	Virginia	NNP
8691	4259	8	(	(	-LRB-
8691	4259	9	which	which	WDT
8691	4259	10	was	be	VBD
8691	4259	11	held	hold	VBN
8691	4259	12	by	by	IN
8691	4259	13	a	a	DT
8691	4259	14	single	single	JJ
8691	4259	15	Chancellor	Chancellor	NNP
8691	4259	16	,	,	,
8691	4259	17	then	then	RB
8691	4259	18	a	a	DT
8691	4259	19	man	man	NN
8691	4259	20	seventy	seventy	CD
8691	4259	21	-	-	HYPH
8691	4259	22	six	six	CD
8691	4259	23	years	year	NNS
8691	4259	24	old	old	JJ
8691	4259	25	)	)	-RRB-
8691	4259	26	there	there	EX
8691	4259	27	were	be	VBD
8691	4259	28	in	in	IN
8691	4259	29	1802	1802	CD
8691	4259	30	,	,	,
8691	4259	31	2,627	2,627	CD
8691	4259	32	causes	cause	NNS
8691	4259	33	pending	pende	VBG
8691	4259	34	at	at	IN
8691	4259	35	one	one	CD
8691	4259	36	term	term	NN
8691	4259	37	.	.	.
8691	4260	1	In	in	IN
8691	4260	2	the	the	DT
8691	4260	3	city	city	NN
8691	4260	4	of	of	IN
8691	4260	5	New	New	NNP
8691	4260	6	York	York	NNP
8691	4260	7	a	a	DT
8691	4260	8	jury	jury	NN
8691	4260	9	trial	trial	NN
8691	4260	10	in	in	IN
8691	4260	11	civil	civil	JJ
8691	4260	12	causes	cause	NNS
8691	4260	13	can	can	MD
8691	4260	14	not	not	RB
8691	4260	15	ordinarily	ordinarily	RB
8691	4260	16	be	be	VB
8691	4260	17	reached	reach	VBN
8691	4260	18	until	until	IN
8691	4260	19	two	two	CD
8691	4260	20	years	year	NNS
8691	4260	21	after	after	IN
8691	4260	22	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4260	23	are	be	VBP
8691	4260	24	brought	bring	VBN
8691	4260	25	.	.	.
8691	4261	1	In	in	IN
8691	4261	2	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4261	3	principal	principal	JJ
8691	4261	4	trial	trial	NN
8691	4261	5	court	court	NN
8691	4261	6	between	between	IN
8691	4261	7	four	four	CD
8691	4261	8	and	and	CC
8691	4261	9	five	five	CD
8691	4261	10	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	4261	11	cases	case	NNS
8691	4261	12	are	be	VBP
8691	4261	13	annually	annually	RB
8691	4261	14	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	4261	15	of	of	IN
8691	4261	16	,	,	,
8691	4261	17	and	and	CC
8691	4261	18	in	in	IN
8691	4261	19	1903	1903	CD
8691	4261	20	,	,	,
8691	4261	21	there	there	EX
8691	4261	22	were	be	VBD
8691	4261	23	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	4261	24	ten	ten	CD
8691	4261	25	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	4261	26	on	on	IN
8691	4261	27	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4261	28	docket	docket	NN
8691	4261	29	.	.	.
8691	4262	1	When	when	WRB
8691	4262	2	the	the	DT
8691	4262	3	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	4262	4	courts	court	NNS
8691	4262	5	in	in	IN
8691	4262	6	the	the	DT
8691	4262	7	borough	borough	NN
8691	4262	8	of	of	IN
8691	4262	9	Manhattan	Manhattan	NNP
8691	4262	10	--	--	:
8691	4262	11	the	the	DT
8691	4262	12	greatest	great	JJS
8691	4262	13	division	division	NN
8691	4262	14	of	of	IN
8691	4262	15	the	the	DT
8691	4262	16	city	city	NN
8691	4262	17	--	--	:
8691	4262	18	were	be	VBD
8691	4262	19	opened	open	VBN
8691	4262	20	in	in	IN
8691	4262	21	October	October	NNP
8691	4262	22	of	of	IN
8691	4262	23	that	that	DT
8691	4262	24	year	year	NN
8691	4262	25	,	,	,
8691	4262	26	there	there	EX
8691	4262	27	were	be	VBD
8691	4262	28	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	4262	29	five	five	CD
8691	4262	30	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	4262	31	different	different	JJ
8691	4262	32	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	4262	33	to	to	TO
8691	4262	34	be	be	VB
8691	4262	35	disposed	dispose	VBN
8691	4262	36	of	of	IN
8691	4262	37	,	,	,
8691	4262	38	and	and	CC
8691	4262	39	a	a	DT
8691	4262	40	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	4262	41	and	and	CC
8691	4262	42	sixty	sixty	CD
8691	4262	43	-	-	HYPH
8691	4262	44	seven	seven	CD
8691	4262	45	prisoners	prisoner	NNS
8691	4262	46	awaiting	await	VBG
8691	4262	47	trial	trial	NN
8691	4262	48	who	who	WP
8691	4262	49	had	have	VBD
8691	4262	50	been	be	VBN
8691	4262	51	unable	unable	JJ
8691	4262	52	to	to	TO
8691	4262	53	procure	procure	VB
8691	4262	54	bail	bail	NN
8691	4262	55	.	.	.
8691	4263	1	In	in	IN
8691	4263	2	the	the	DT
8691	4263	3	county	county	NN
8691	4263	4	containing	contain	VBG
8691	4263	5	the	the	DT
8691	4263	6	city	city	NN
8691	4263	7	of	of	IN
8691	4263	8	Chicago	Chicago	NNP
8691	4263	9	(	(	-LRB-
8691	4263	10	and	and	CC
8691	4263	11	which	which	WDT
8691	4263	12	contains	contain	VBZ
8691	4263	13	little	little	JJ
8691	4263	14	else	else	RB
8691	4263	15	)	)	-RRB-
8691	4263	16	,	,	,
8691	4263	17	there	there	EX
8691	4263	18	were	be	VBD
8691	4263	19	in	in	IN
8691	4263	20	1903	1903	CD
8691	4263	21	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	4263	22	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	4263	23	civil	civil	JJ
8691	4263	24	cases	case	NNS
8691	4263	25	on	on	IN
8691	4263	26	the	the	DT
8691	4263	27	dockets	docket	NNS
8691	4263	28	of	of	IN
8691	4263	29	the	the	DT
8691	4263	30	courts	court	NNS
8691	4263	31	.	.	.
8691	4264	1	This	this	DT
8691	4264	2	mass	mass	NN
8691	4264	3	of	of	IN
8691	4264	4	business	business	NN
8691	4264	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4264	6	would	would	MD
8691	4264	7	require	require	VB
8691	4264	8	more	more	JJR
8691	4264	9	than	than	IN
8691	4264	10	two	two	CD
8691	4264	11	years	year	NNS
8691	4264	12	and	and	CC
8691	4264	13	a	a	DT
8691	4264	14	half	half	NN
8691	4264	15	to	to	TO
8691	4264	16	dispose	dispose	VB
8691	4264	17	of	of	IN
8691	4264	18	with	with	IN
8691	4264	19	the	the	DT
8691	4264	20	number	number	NN
8691	4264	21	of	of	IN
8691	4264	22	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4264	23	then	then	RB
8691	4264	24	provided	provide	VBN
8691	4264	25	,	,	,
8691	4264	26	were	be	VBD
8691	4264	27	no	no	DT
8691	4264	28	new	new	JJ
8691	4264	29	suits	suit	NNS
8691	4264	30	instituted	institute	VBN
8691	4264	31	to	to	TO
8691	4264	32	divide	divide	VB
8691	4264	33	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4264	34	attention	attention	NN
8691	4264	35	.	.	.
8691	4265	1	A	a	DT
8691	4265	2	very	very	RB
8691	4265	3	large	large	JJ
8691	4265	4	part	part	NN
8691	4265	5	of	of	IN
8691	4265	6	the	the	DT
8691	4265	7	cases	case	NNS
8691	4265	8	tried	try	VBD
8691	4265	9	to	to	IN
8691	4265	10	the	the	DT
8691	4265	11	jury	jury	NN
8691	4265	12	are	be	VBP
8691	4265	13	claims	claim	NNS
8691	4265	14	for	for	IN
8691	4265	15	damages	damage	NNS
8691	4265	16	for	for	IN
8691	4265	17	accidental	accidental	JJ
8691	4265	18	injuries	injury	NNS
8691	4265	19	received	receive	VBN
8691	4265	20	by	by	IN
8691	4265	21	employees	employee	NNS
8691	4265	22	in	in	IN
8691	4265	23	the	the	DT
8691	4265	24	course	course	NN
8691	4265	25	of	of	IN
8691	4265	26	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4265	27	service	service	NN
8691	4265	28	.	.	.
8691	4266	1	In	in	IN
8691	4266	2	the	the	DT
8691	4266	3	county	county	NN
8691	4266	4	in	in	IN
8691	4266	5	Missouri	Missouri	NNP
8691	4266	6	including	include	VBG
8691	4266	7	Kansas	Kansas	NNP
8691	4266	8	City	City	NNP
8691	4266	9	there	there	EX
8691	4266	10	were	be	VBD
8691	4266	11	,	,	,
8691	4266	12	in	in	IN
8691	4266	13	December	December	NNP
8691	4266	14	,	,	,
8691	4266	15	1903	1903	CD
8691	4266	16	,	,	,
8691	4266	17	over	over	IN
8691	4266	18	fifty	fifty	CD
8691	4266	19	-	-	HYPH
8691	4266	20	one	one	CD
8691	4266	21	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	4266	22	civil	civil	JJ
8691	4266	23	causes	cause	NNS
8691	4266	24	on	on	IN
8691	4266	25	the	the	DT
8691	4266	26	dockets	docket	NNS
8691	4266	27	of	of	IN
8691	4266	28	the	the	DT
8691	4266	29	various	various	JJ
8691	4266	30	courts	court	NNS
8691	4266	31	.	.	.
8691	4267	1	The	the	DT
8691	4267	2	population	population	NN
8691	4267	3	of	of	IN
8691	4267	4	the	the	DT
8691	4267	5	county	county	NN
8691	4267	6	was	be	VBD
8691	4267	7	less	less	JJR
8691	4267	8	than	than	IN
8691	4267	9	two	two	CD
8691	4267	10	hundred	hundred	CD
8691	4267	11	thousand	thousand	CD
8691	4267	12	.	.	.
8691	4268	1	About	about	RB
8691	4268	2	three	three	CD
8691	4268	3	-	-	HYPH
8691	4268	4	fourths	fourth	NNS
8691	4268	5	of	of	IN
8691	4268	6	the	the	DT
8691	4268	7	cases	case	NNS
8691	4268	8	were	be	VBD
8691	4268	9	against	against	IN
8691	4268	10	corporations	corporation	NNS
8691	4268	11	for	for	IN
8691	4268	12	injuries	injury	NNS
8691	4268	13	received	receive	VBN
8691	4268	14	by	by	IN
8691	4268	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4268	16	employees	employee	NNS
8691	4268	17	.	.	.
8691	4269	1	The	the	DT
8691	4269	2	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	4269	3	in	in	IN
8691	4269	4	such	such	PDT
8691	4269	5	an	an	DT
8691	4269	6	action	action	NN
8691	4269	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4269	8	generally	generally	RB
8691	4269	9	in	in	IN
8691	4269	10	no	no	DT
8691	4269	11	hurry	hurry	NN
8691	4269	12	to	to	TO
8691	4269	13	bring	bring	VB
8691	4269	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4269	15	to	to	IN
8691	4269	16	trial	trial	NN
8691	4269	17	.	.	.
8691	4270	1	The	the	DT
8691	4270	2	plaintiff	plaintiff	NN
8691	4270	3	often	often	RB
8691	4270	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	4270	5	not	not	RB
8691	4270	6	.	.	.
8691	4271	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4271	2	may	may	MD
8691	4271	3	have	have	VB
8691	4271	4	a	a	DT
8691	4271	5	weak	weak	JJ
8691	4271	6	case	case	NN
8691	4271	7	,	,	,
8691	4271	8	brought	bring	VBN
8691	4271	9	in	in	RP
8691	4271	10	the	the	DT
8691	4271	11	hope	hope	NN
8691	4271	12	of	of	IN
8691	4271	13	forcing	force	VBG
8691	4271	14	a	a	DT
8691	4271	15	settlement	settlement	NN
8691	4271	16	.	.	.
8691	4272	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4272	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	4272	3	probably	probably	RB
8691	4272	4	no	no	DT
8691	4272	5	money	money	NN
8691	4272	6	to	to	TO
8691	4272	7	pay	pay	VB
8691	4272	8	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4272	9	lawyer	lawyer	NN
8691	4272	10	for	for	IN
8691	4272	11	trying	try	VBG
8691	4272	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4272	13	,	,	,
8691	4272	14	and	and	CC
8691	4272	15	finds	find	VBZ
8691	4272	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4272	17	hard	hard	JJ
8691	4272	18	to	to	TO
8691	4272	19	get	get	VB
8691	4272	20	together	together	RB
8691	4272	21	what	what	WP
8691	4272	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	4272	23	necessary	necessary	JJ
8691	4272	24	to	to	TO
8691	4272	25	summon	summon	VB
8691	4272	26	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4272	27	witnesses	witness	NNS
8691	4272	28	and	and	CC
8691	4272	29	provide	provide	VB
8691	4272	30	expert	expert	NN
8691	4272	31	testimony	testimony	NN
8691	4272	32	as	as	IN
8691	4272	33	to	to	IN
8691	4272	34	the	the	DT
8691	4272	35	nature	nature	NN
8691	4272	36	of	of	IN
8691	4272	37	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4272	38	injuries	injury	NNS
8691	4272	39	.	.	.
8691	4273	1	Whenever	whenever	WRB
8691	4273	2	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4273	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	4273	4	tried	try	VBN
8691	4273	5	,	,	,
8691	4273	6	however	however	RB
8691	4273	7	,	,	,
8691	4273	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4273	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	4273	10	sure	sure	JJ
8691	4273	11	to	to	TO
8691	4273	12	want	want	VB
8691	4273	13	a	a	DT
8691	4273	14	jury	jury	NN
8691	4273	15	,	,	,
8691	4273	16	for	for	IN
8691	4273	17	if	if	IN
8691	4273	18	the	the	DT
8691	4273	19	case	case	NN
8691	4273	20	is	be	VBZ
8691	4273	21	a	a	DT
8691	4273	22	good	good	JJ
8691	4273	23	one	one	CD
8691	4273	24	a	a	DT
8691	4273	25	jury	jury	NN
8691	4273	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	4273	27	apt	apt	JJ
8691	4273	28	to	to	TO
8691	4273	29	give	give	VB
8691	4273	30	larger	large	JJR
8691	4273	31	damages	damage	NNS
8691	4273	32	than	than	IN
8691	4273	33	a	a	DT
8691	4273	34	judge	judge	NN
8691	4273	35	,	,	,
8691	4273	36	and	and	CC
8691	4273	37	if	if	IN
8691	4273	38	a	a	DT
8691	4273	39	bad	bad	JJ
8691	4273	40	one	one	CD
8691	4273	41	a	a	DT
8691	4273	42	jury	jury	NN
8691	4273	43	is	be	VBZ
8691	4273	44	less	less	RBR
8691	4273	45	likely	likely	JJ
8691	4273	46	to	to	TO
8691	4273	47	appreciate	appreciate	VB
8691	4273	48	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4273	49	weakness	weakness	NN
8691	4273	50	.	.	.
8691	4274	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4274	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4274	3	:	:	:
8691	4274	4	McCloskey	McCloskey	NNP
8691	4274	5	_	_	NNP
8691	4274	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	4274	7	_	_	NNP
8691	4274	8	Bell	Bell	NNP
8691	4274	9	's	's	POS
8691	4274	10	Gap	Gap	NNP
8691	4274	11	R.	R.	NNP
8691	4274	12	R.	R.	NNP
8691	4274	13	Co.	Co.	NNP
8691	4274	14	,	,	,
8691	4274	15	156	156	CD
8691	4274	16	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	4274	17	State	State	NNP
8691	4274	18	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	4274	19	,	,	,
8691	4274	20	254	254	CD
8691	4274	21	;	;	:
8691	4274	22	27	27	CD
8691	4274	23	Atlantic	Atlantic	NNP
8691	4274	24	Reporter	Reporter	NNP
8691	4274	25	,	,	,
8691	4274	26	246	246	CD
8691	4274	27	.	.	.
8691	4274	28	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4275	1	A	a	DT
8691	4275	2	jury	jury	NN
8691	4275	3	trial	trial	NN
8691	4275	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	4275	5	much	much	RB
8691	4275	6	slower	slow	JJR
8691	4275	7	than	than	IN
8691	4275	8	a	a	DT
8691	4275	9	trial	trial	NN
8691	4275	10	before	before	IN
8691	4275	11	a	a	DT
8691	4275	12	judge	judge	NN
8691	4275	13	,	,	,
8691	4275	14	although	although	IN
8691	4275	15	the	the	DT
8691	4275	16	decision	decision	NN
8691	4275	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	4275	18	apt	apt	JJ
8691	4275	19	to	to	TO
8691	4275	20	come	come	VB
8691	4275	21	more	more	RBR
8691	4275	22	quickly	quickly	RB
8691	4275	23	.	.	.
8691	4276	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4276	2	also	also	RB
8691	4276	3	facilitates	facilitate	VBZ
8691	4276	4	appeals	appeal	NNS
8691	4276	5	by	by	IN
8691	4276	6	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	4276	7	presenting	present	VBG
8691	4276	8	more	more	JJR
8691	4276	9	occasions	occasion	NNS
8691	4276	10	for	for	IN
8691	4276	11	error	error	NN
8691	4276	12	.	.	.
8691	4277	1	A	a	DT
8691	4277	2	judge	judge	NN
8691	4277	3	in	in	IN
8691	4277	4	trying	try	VBG
8691	4277	5	a	a	DT
8691	4277	6	cause	cause	NN
8691	4277	7	,	,	,
8691	4277	8	if	if	IN
8691	4277	9	evidence	evidence	NN
8691	4277	10	of	of	IN
8691	4277	11	doubtful	doubtful	JJ
8691	4277	12	competency	competency	NN
8691	4277	13	is	be	VBZ
8691	4277	14	offered	offer	VBN
8691	4277	15	,	,	,
8691	4277	16	can	can	MD
8691	4277	17	admit	admit	VB
8691	4277	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4277	19	provisionally	provisionally	RB
8691	4277	20	and	and	CC
8691	4277	21	exclude	exclude	VB
8691	4277	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4277	23	afterwards	afterwards	RB
8691	4277	24	if	if	IN
8691	4277	25	,	,	,
8691	4277	26	on	on	IN
8691	4277	27	deliberation	deliberation	NN
8691	4277	28	,	,	,
8691	4277	29	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4277	30	thinks	think	VBZ
8691	4277	31	that	that	IN
8691	4277	32	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4277	33	should	should	MD
8691	4277	34	not	not	RB
8691	4277	35	be	be	VB
8691	4277	36	considered	consider	VBN
8691	4277	37	.	.	.
8691	4278	1	With	with	IN
8691	4278	2	a	a	DT
8691	4278	3	jury	jury	NN
8691	4278	4	this	this	DT
8691	4278	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	4278	6	impossible	impossible	JJ
8691	4278	7	.	.	.
8691	4279	1	There	there	EX
8691	4279	2	must	must	MD
8691	4279	3	be	be	VB
8691	4279	4	an	an	DT
8691	4279	5	immediate	immediate	JJ
8691	4279	6	ruling	rule	VBG
8691	4279	7	one	one	CD
8691	4279	8	way	way	NN
8691	4279	9	or	or	CC
8691	4279	10	the	the	DT
8691	4279	11	other	other	JJ
8691	4279	12	.	.	.
8691	4280	1	In	in	IN
8691	4280	2	the	the	DT
8691	4280	3	charge	charge	NN
8691	4280	4	to	to	IN
8691	4280	5	a	a	DT
8691	4280	6	jury	jury	NN
8691	4280	7	,	,	,
8691	4280	8	also	also	RB
8691	4280	9	,	,	,
8691	4280	10	opportunities	opportunity	NNS
8691	4280	11	are	be	VBP
8691	4280	12	offered	offer	VBN
8691	4280	13	for	for	IN
8691	4280	14	exceptions	exception	NNS
8691	4280	15	which	which	WDT
8691	4280	16	do	do	VBP
8691	4280	17	not	not	RB
8691	4280	18	exist	exist	VB
8691	4280	19	if	if	IN
8691	4280	20	the	the	DT
8691	4280	21	cause	cause	NN
8691	4280	22	is	be	VBZ
8691	4280	23	to	to	TO
8691	4280	24	be	be	VB
8691	4280	25	decided	decide	VBN
8691	4280	26	by	by	IN
8691	4280	27	the	the	DT
8691	4280	28	judge	judge	NN
8691	4280	29	alone	alone	RB
8691	4280	30	.	.	.
8691	4281	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4281	2	does	do	VBZ
8691	4281	3	not	not	RB
8691	4281	4	have	have	VB
8691	4281	5	to	to	TO
8691	4281	6	instruct	instruct	VB
8691	4281	7	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4281	8	in	in	IN
8691	4281	9	public	public	NN
8691	4281	10	.	.	.
8691	4282	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4282	2	can	can	MD
8691	4282	3	study	study	VB
8691	4282	4	the	the	DT
8691	4282	5	case	case	NN
8691	4282	6	in	in	IN
8691	4282	7	private	private	JJ
8691	4282	8	at	at	IN
8691	4282	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4282	10	leisure	leisure	NN
8691	4282	11	.	.	.
8691	4283	1	A	a	DT
8691	4283	2	cause	cause	NN
8691	4283	3	of	of	IN
8691	4283	4	delay	delay	NN
8691	4283	5	formerly	formerly	RB
8691	4283	6	existed	exist	VBD
8691	4283	7	in	in	IN
8691	4283	8	several	several	JJ
8691	4283	9	States	state	NNS
8691	4283	10	which	which	WDT
8691	4283	11	arose	arise	VBD
8691	4283	12	from	from	IN
8691	4283	13	the	the	DT
8691	4283	14	method	method	NN
8691	4283	15	of	of	IN
8691	4283	16	computing	compute	VBG
8691	4283	17	the	the	DT
8691	4283	18	costs	cost	NNS
8691	4283	19	taxable	taxable	JJ
8691	4283	20	against	against	IN
8691	4283	21	the	the	DT
8691	4283	22	losing	lose	VBG
8691	4283	23	party	party	NN
8691	4283	24	.	.	.
8691	4284	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4284	2	included	include	VBD
8691	4284	3	,	,	,
8691	4284	4	by	by	IN
8691	4284	5	statute	statute	NN
8691	4284	6	,	,	,
8691	4284	7	a	a	DT
8691	4284	8	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4284	9	sum	sum	NN
8691	4284	10	,	,	,
8691	4284	11	say	say	VBP
8691	4284	12	twenty	twenty	CD
8691	4284	13	-	-	HYPH
8691	4284	14	five	five	CD
8691	4284	15	or	or	CC
8691	4284	16	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	4284	17	-	-	HYPH
8691	4284	18	three	three	CD
8691	4284	19	cents	cent	NNS
8691	4284	20	a	a	DT
8691	4284	21	day	day	NN
8691	4284	22	for	for	IN
8691	4284	23	each	each	DT
8691	4284	24	day	day	NN
8691	4284	25	's	's	POS
8691	4284	26	attendance	attendance	NN
8691	4284	27	at	at	IN
8691	4284	28	court	court	NN
8691	4284	29	by	by	IN
8691	4284	30	the	the	DT
8691	4284	31	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	4284	32	party	party	NN
8691	4284	33	.	.	.
8691	4285	1	This	this	DT
8691	4285	2	was	be	VBD
8691	4285	3	construed	construe	VBN
8691	4285	4	to	to	TO
8691	4285	5	mean	mean	VB
8691	4285	6	each	each	DT
8691	4285	7	day	day	NN
8691	4285	8	during	during	IN
8691	4285	9	which	which	WDT
8691	4285	10	the	the	DT
8691	4285	11	action	action	NN
8691	4285	12	lay	lie	VBD
8691	4285	13	in	in	IN
8691	4285	14	court	court	NN
8691	4285	15	,	,	,
8691	4285	16	since	since	IN
8691	4285	17	upon	upon	IN
8691	4285	18	any	any	DT
8691	4285	19	of	of	IN
8691	4285	20	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4285	21	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4285	22	might	may	MD
8691	4285	23	by	by	IN
8691	4285	24	possibility	possibility	NN
8691	4285	25	be	be	VB
8691	4285	26	called	call	VBN
8691	4285	27	up	up	RP
8691	4285	28	,	,	,
8691	4285	29	and	and	CC
8691	4285	30	the	the	DT
8691	4285	31	client	client	NN
8691	4285	32	was	be	VBD
8691	4285	33	always	always	RB
8691	4285	34	represented	represent	VBN
8691	4285	35	by	by	IN
8691	4285	36	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4285	37	attorney	attorney	NN
8691	4285	38	of	of	IN
8691	4285	39	record	record	NN
8691	4285	40	,	,	,
8691	4285	41	a	a	DT
8691	4285	42	notice	notice	NN
8691	4285	43	to	to	IN
8691	4285	44	whom	whom	WP
8691	4285	45	was	be	VBD
8691	4285	46	a	a	DT
8691	4285	47	notice	notice	NN
8691	4285	48	to	to	IN
8691	4285	49	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4285	50	.	.	.
8691	4286	1	Christian	christian	JJ
8691	4286	2	Roselius	Roselius	NNP
8691	4286	3	,	,	,
8691	4286	4	one	one	CD
8691	4286	5	of	of	IN
8691	4286	6	the	the	DT
8691	4286	7	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	4286	8	of	of	IN
8691	4286	9	the	the	DT
8691	4286	10	New	New	NNP
8691	4286	11	Orleans	Orleans	NNP
8691	4286	12	bar	bar	NN
8691	4286	13	in	in	IN
8691	4286	14	the	the	DT
8691	4286	15	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	4286	16	century	century	NN
8691	4286	17	,	,	,
8691	4286	18	once	once	RB
8691	4286	19	said	say	VBD
8691	4286	20	that	that	IN
8691	4286	21	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4286	22	had	have	VBD
8691	4286	23	spent	spend	VBN
8691	4286	24	a	a	DT
8691	4286	25	fourth	fourth	JJ
8691	4286	26	of	of	IN
8691	4286	27	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4286	28	life	life	NN
8691	4286	29	in	in	IN
8691	4286	30	the	the	DT
8691	4286	31	court	court	NN
8691	4286	32	house	house	NN
8691	4286	33	waiting	wait	VBG
8691	4286	34	for	for	IN
8691	4286	35	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4286	36	cases	case	NNS
8691	4286	37	to	to	TO
8691	4286	38	be	be	VB
8691	4286	39	called	call	VBN
8691	4286	40	.	.	.
8691	4287	1	The	the	DT
8691	4287	2	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4287	3	,	,	,
8691	4287	4	as	as	IN
8691	4287	5	the	the	DT
8691	4287	6	duty	duty	NN
8691	4287	7	of	of	IN
8691	4287	8	attendance	attendance	NN
8691	4287	9	fell	fall	VBD
8691	4287	10	on	on	IN
8691	4287	11	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4287	12	,	,	,
8691	4287	13	generally	generally	RB
8691	4287	14	considered	consider	VBN
8691	4287	15	this	this	DT
8691	4287	16	allowance	allowance	NN
8691	4287	17	as	as	IN
8691	4287	18	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4287	19	perquisite	perquisite	NN
8691	4287	20	.	.	.
8691	4288	1	An	an	DT
8691	4288	2	attorney	attorney	NN
8691	4288	3	with	with	IN
8691	4288	4	a	a	DT
8691	4288	5	large	large	JJ
8691	4288	6	docket	docket	NN
8691	4288	7	received	receive	VBN
8691	4288	8	,	,	,
8691	4288	9	therefore	therefore	RB
8691	4288	10	,	,	,
8691	4288	11	a	a	DT
8691	4288	12	number	number	NN
8691	4288	13	of	of	IN
8691	4288	14	dollars	dollar	NNS
8691	4288	15	for	for	IN
8691	4288	16	every	every	DT
8691	4288	17	day	day	NN
8691	4288	18	the	the	DT
8691	4288	19	court	court	NN
8691	4288	20	sat	sit	VBD
8691	4288	21	,	,	,
8691	4288	22	and	and	CC
8691	4288	23	the	the	DT
8691	4288	24	longer	long	JJR
8691	4288	25	the	the	DT
8691	4288	26	term	term	NN
8691	4288	27	lasted	last	VBD
8691	4288	28	or	or	CC
8691	4288	29	the	the	DT
8691	4288	30	more	more	JJR
8691	4288	31	terms	term	NNS
8691	4288	32	to	to	TO
8691	4288	33	which	which	WDT
8691	4288	34	a	a	DT
8691	4288	35	cause	cause	NN
8691	4288	36	was	be	VBD
8691	4288	37	carried	carry	VBN
8691	4288	38	over	over	RP
8691	4288	39	,	,	,
8691	4288	40	the	the	DT
8691	4288	41	larger	large	JJR
8691	4288	42	was	be	VBD
8691	4288	43	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4288	44	gain	gain	NN
8691	4288	45	if	if	IN
8691	4288	46	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4288	47	client	client	NN
8691	4288	48	ultimately	ultimately	RB
8691	4288	49	obtained	obtain	VBD
8691	4288	50	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	4288	51	,	,	,
8691	4288	52	and	and	CC
8691	4288	53	the	the	DT
8691	4288	54	defendant	defendant	NN
8691	4288	55	was	be	VBD
8691	4288	56	of	of	IN
8691	4288	57	financial	financial	JJ
8691	4288	58	responsibility	responsibility	NN
8691	4288	59	.	.	.
8691	4289	1	This	this	DT
8691	4289	2	system	system	NN
8691	4289	3	was	be	VBD
8691	4289	4	not	not	RB
8691	4289	5	universally	universally	RB
8691	4289	6	discontinued	discontinue	VBN
8691	4289	7	until	until	IN
8691	4289	8	the	the	DT
8691	4289	9	last	last	JJ
8691	4289	10	quarter	quarter	NN
8691	4289	11	of	of	IN
8691	4289	12	the	the	DT
8691	4289	13	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	4289	14	century	century	NN
8691	4289	15	.	.	.
8691	4290	1	A	a	DT
8691	4290	2	few	few	JJ
8691	4290	3	States	state	NNS
8691	4290	4	,	,	,
8691	4290	5	by	by	IN
8691	4290	6	statute	statute	NN
8691	4290	7	or	or	CC
8691	4290	8	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	4290	9	provision	provision	NN
8691	4290	10	,	,	,
8691	4290	11	set	set	VBD
8691	4290	12	a	a	DT
8691	4290	13	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4290	14	time	time	NN
8691	4290	15	within	within	IN
8691	4290	16	which	which	WDT
8691	4290	17	a	a	DT
8691	4290	18	decision	decision	NN
8691	4290	19	must	must	MD
8691	4290	20	be	be	VB
8691	4290	21	rendered	render	VBN
8691	4290	22	after	after	IN
8691	4290	23	the	the	DT
8691	4290	24	trial	trial	NN
8691	4290	25	.	.	.
8691	4291	1	California	California	NNP
8691	4291	2	gives	give	VBZ
8691	4291	3	ninety	ninety	JJ
8691	4291	4	days	day	NNS
8691	4291	5	;	;	:
8691	4291	6	Idaho	Idaho	NNP
8691	4291	7	(	(	-LRB-
8691	4291	8	Const	Const	NNP
8691	4291	9	.	.	.
8691	4291	10	,	,	,
8691	4291	11	Art	art	NN
8691	4291	12	.	.	.
8691	4292	1	V.	V.	NNP
8691	4292	2	,	,	,
8691	4292	3	Sec	Sec	NNP
8691	4292	4	.	.	.
8691	4293	1	17	17	CD
8691	4293	2	)	)	-RRB-
8691	4293	3	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	4293	4	.	.	.
8691	4294	1	A	a	DT
8691	4294	2	sanction	sanction	NN
8691	4294	3	for	for	IN
8691	4294	4	the	the	DT
8691	4294	5	law	law	NN
8691	4294	6	sometimes	sometimes	RB
8691	4294	7	provided	provide	VBD
8691	4294	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	4294	9	that	that	IN
8691	4294	10	the	the	DT
8691	4294	11	judge	judge	NN
8691	4294	12	can	can	MD
8691	4294	13	not	not	RB
8691	4294	14	draw	draw	VB
8691	4294	15	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4294	16	salary	salary	NN
8691	4294	17	until	until	IN
8691	4294	18	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4294	19	has	have	VBZ
8691	4294	20	made	make	VBN
8691	4294	21	oath	oath	NN
8691	4294	22	that	that	IN
8691	4294	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4294	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	4294	25	in	in	IN
8691	4294	26	no	no	DT
8691	4294	27	default	default	NN
8691	4294	28	.	.	.
8691	4295	1	*	*	NFP
8691	4295	2	*	*	NFP
8691	4295	3	*	*	NFP
8691	4295	4	*	*	NFP
8691	4295	5	*	*	NFP
8691	4295	6	CHAPTER	chapter	NN
8691	4295	7	XXV	XXV	NNP
8691	4295	8	THE	the	DT
8691	4295	9	ATTITUDE	attitude	NN
8691	4295	10	OF	of	IN
8691	4295	11	THE	the	DT
8691	4295	12	PEOPLE	PEOPLE	NNS
8691	4295	13	TOWARD	toward	NN
8691	4295	14	THE	the	DT
8691	4295	15	JUDICIARY	JUDICIARY	NNP
8691	4295	16	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	4295	17	are	be	VBP
8691	4295	18	proud	proud	JJ
8691	4295	19	of	of	IN
8691	4295	20	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4295	21	country	country	NN
8691	4295	22	and	and	CC
8691	4295	23	of	of	IN
8691	4295	24	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4295	25	State	state	NN
8691	4295	26	.	.	.
8691	4296	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4296	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4296	3	proud	proud	JJ
8691	4296	4	of	of	IN
8691	4296	5	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4296	6	scheme	scheme	NN
8691	4296	7	of	of	IN
8691	4296	8	government	government	NN
8691	4296	9	,	,	,
8691	4296	10	by	by	IN
8691	4296	11	which	which	WDT
8691	4296	12	an	an	DT
8691	4296	13	imperial	imperial	JJ
8691	4296	14	world	world	NN
8691	4296	15	-	-	HYPH
8691	4296	16	power	power	NN
8691	4296	17	has	have	VBZ
8691	4296	18	been	be	VBN
8691	4296	19	created	create	VBN
8691	4296	20	for	for	IN
8691	4296	21	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4296	22	national	national	JJ
8691	4296	23	and	and	CC
8691	4296	24	international	international	JJ
8691	4296	25	purposes	purpose	NNS
8691	4296	26	,	,	,
8691	4296	27	resting	rest	VBG
8691	4296	28	on	on	IN
8691	4296	29	a	a	DT
8691	4296	30	collection	collection	NN
8691	4296	31	of	of	IN
8691	4296	32	States	States	NNP
8691	4296	33	,	,	,
8691	4296	34	each	each	DT
8691	4296	35	of	of	IN
8691	4296	36	which	which	WDT
8691	4296	37	is	be	VBZ
8691	4296	38	an	an	DT
8691	4296	39	independent	independent	JJ
8691	4296	40	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	4296	41	,	,	,
8691	4296	42	absolutely	absolutely	RB
8691	4296	43	as	as	IN
8691	4296	44	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	4296	45	the	the	DT
8691	4296	46	others	other	NNS
8691	4296	47	,	,	,
8691	4296	48	and	and	CC
8691	4296	49	for	for	IN
8691	4296	50	the	the	DT
8691	4296	51	most	most	JJS
8691	4296	52	part	part	NN
8691	4296	53	as	as	IN
8691	4296	54	respects	respect	VBZ
8691	4296	55	the	the	DT
8691	4296	56	United	United	NNP
8691	4296	57	States	States	NNP
8691	4296	58	.	.	.
8691	4297	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4297	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4297	3	in	in	IN
8691	4297	4	the	the	DT
8691	4297	5	mass	mass	NN
8691	4297	6	an	an	DT
8691	4297	7	educated	educated	JJ
8691	4297	8	and	and	CC
8691	4297	9	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
8691	4297	10	people	people	NNS
8691	4297	11	.	.	.
8691	4298	1	The	the	DT
8691	4298	2	public	public	JJ
8691	4298	3	schools	school	NNS
8691	4298	4	have	have	VBP
8691	4298	5	thus	thus	RB
8691	4298	6	far	far	RB
8691	4298	7	been	be	VBN
8691	4298	8	found	find	VBN
8691	4298	9	adequate	adequate	JJ
8691	4298	10	to	to	IN
8691	4298	11	Americanizing	americanize	VBG
8691	4298	12	the	the	DT
8691	4298	13	children	child	NNS
8691	4298	14	of	of	IN
8691	4298	15	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	4298	16	immigrants	immigrant	NNS
8691	4298	17	.	.	.
8691	4299	1	The	the	DT
8691	4299	2	colored	colored	JJ
8691	4299	3	population	population	NN
8691	4299	4	of	of	IN
8691	4299	5	the	the	DT
8691	4299	6	South	South	NNP
8691	4299	7	stands	stand	VBZ
8691	4299	8	largely	largely	RB
8691	4299	9	by	by	IN
8691	4299	10	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4299	11	,	,	,
8691	4299	12	and	and	CC
8691	4299	13	constitutes	constitute	VBZ
8691	4299	14	no	no	DT
8691	4299	15	active	active	JJ
8691	4299	16	and	and	CC
8691	4299	17	self	self	NN
8691	4299	18	-	-	HYPH
8691	4299	19	moving	move	VBG
8691	4299	20	force	force	NN
8691	4299	21	in	in	IN
8691	4299	22	matters	matter	NNS
8691	4299	23	of	of	IN
8691	4299	24	political	political	JJ
8691	4299	25	concern	concern	NN
8691	4299	26	.	.	.
8691	4300	1	An	an	DT
8691	4300	2	educated	educated	JJ
8691	4300	3	and	and	CC
8691	4300	4	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
8691	4300	5	people	people	NNS
8691	4300	6	living	live	VBG
8691	4300	7	under	under	IN
8691	4300	8	a	a	DT
8691	4300	9	government	government	NN
8691	4300	10	of	of	IN
8691	4300	11	written	write	VBN
8691	4300	12	law	law	NN
8691	4300	13	of	of	IN
8691	4300	14	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4300	15	own	own	JJ
8691	4300	16	making	making	NN
8691	4300	17	can	can	MD
8691	4300	18	not	not	RB
8691	4300	19	but	but	CC
8691	4300	20	know	know	VB
8691	4300	21	how	how	WRB
8691	4300	22	vital	vital	JJ
8691	4300	23	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4300	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	4300	25	that	that	IN
8691	4300	26	this	this	DT
8691	4300	27	law	law	NN
8691	4300	28	should	should	MD
8691	4300	29	be	be	VB
8691	4300	30	fully	fully	RB
8691	4300	31	guarded	guard	VBN
8691	4300	32	and	and	CC
8691	4300	33	fairly	fairly	RB
8691	4300	34	administered	administer	VBN
8691	4300	35	.	.	.
8691	4301	1	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	4301	2	have	have	VBP
8691	4301	3	become	become	VBN
8691	4301	4	distrustful	distrustful	JJ
8691	4301	5	of	of	IN
8691	4301	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4301	7	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	4301	8	.	.	.
8691	4302	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4302	2	believe	believe	VBP
8691	4302	3	that	that	IN
8691	4302	4	much	much	JJ
8691	4302	5	of	of	IN
8691	4302	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4302	7	work	work	NN
8691	4302	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	4302	9	ill	ill	RB
8691	4302	10	-	-	HYPH
8691	4302	11	considered	consider	VBN
8691	4302	12	,	,	,
8691	4302	13	and	and	CC
8691	4302	14	that	that	IN
8691	4302	15	some	some	DT
8691	4302	16	of	of	IN
8691	4302	17	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4302	18	has	have	VBZ
8691	4302	19	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4302	20	source	source	NN
8691	4302	21	in	in	IN
8691	4302	22	corruption	corruption	NN
8691	4302	23	.	.	.
8691	4303	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4303	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4303	3	far	far	RB
8691	4303	4	removed	remove	VBN
8691	4303	5	from	from	IN
8691	4303	6	the	the	DT
8691	4303	7	chief	chief	JJ
8691	4303	8	executive	executive	JJ
8691	4303	9	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
8691	4303	10	,	,	,
8691	4303	11	and	and	CC
8691	4303	12	from	from	IN
8691	4303	13	the	the	DT
8691	4303	14	sphere	sphere	NN
8691	4303	15	in	in	IN
8691	4303	16	which	which	WDT
8691	4303	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4303	18	move	move	VBP
8691	4303	19	.	.	.
8691	4304	1	The	the	DT
8691	4304	2	President	President	NNP
8691	4304	3	comes	come	VBZ
8691	4304	4	nearer	near	RBR
8691	4304	5	to	to	IN
8691	4304	6	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4304	7	than	than	IN
8691	4304	8	the	the	DT
8691	4304	9	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	4304	10	of	of	IN
8691	4304	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4304	12	State	state	NN
8691	4304	13	because	because	IN
8691	4304	14	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4304	15	stands	stand	VBZ
8691	4304	16	for	for	IN
8691	4304	17	more	more	JJR
8691	4304	18	,	,	,
8691	4304	19	and	and	CC
8691	4304	20	personifies	personify	VBZ
8691	4304	21	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4304	22	country	country	NN
8691	4304	23	,	,	,
8691	4304	24	but	but	CC
8691	4304	25	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4304	26	is	be	VBZ
8691	4304	27	not	not	RB
8691	4304	28	from	from	IN
8691	4304	29	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4304	30	that	that	IN
8691	4304	31	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4304	32	look	look	VBP
8691	4304	33	for	for	IN
8691	4304	34	peace	peace	NN
8691	4304	35	and	and	CC
8691	4304	36	safety	safety	NN
8691	4304	37	in	in	IN
8691	4304	38	the	the	DT
8691	4304	39	ordinary	ordinary	JJ
8691	4304	40	affairs	affair	NNS
8691	4304	41	of	of	IN
8691	4304	42	life	life	NN
8691	4304	43	and	and	CC
8691	4304	44	home	home	NN
8691	4304	45	.	.	.
8691	4305	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4305	2	look	look	VBP
8691	4305	3	for	for	IN
8691	4305	4	these	these	DT
8691	4305	5	to	to	IN
8691	4305	6	the	the	DT
8691	4305	7	courts	court	NNS
8691	4305	8	,	,	,
8691	4305	9	and	and	CC
8691	4305	10	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4305	11	know	know	VBP
8691	4305	12	that	that	IN
8691	4305	13	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4305	14	will	will	MD
8691	4305	15	seldom	seldom	RB
8691	4305	16	look	look	VB
8691	4305	17	in	in	IN
8691	4305	18	vain	vain	JJ
8691	4305	19	.	.	.
8691	4306	1	Only	only	RB
8691	4306	2	an	an	DT
8691	4306	3	educated	educated	JJ
8691	4306	4	and	and	CC
8691	4306	5	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
8691	4306	6	people	people	NNS
8691	4306	7	can	can	MD
8691	4306	8	live	live	VB
8691	4306	9	under	under	IN
8691	4306	10	a	a	DT
8691	4306	11	written	write	VBN
8691	4306	12	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	4306	13	.	.	.
8691	4307	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4307	2	requires	require	VBZ
8691	4307	3	of	of	IN
8691	4307	4	those	those	DT
8691	4307	5	whom	whom	WP
8691	4307	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4307	7	governs	govern	VBZ
8691	4307	8	a	a	DT
8691	4307	9	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4307	10	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	4307	11	of	of	IN
8691	4307	12	conservatism	conservatism	NN
8691	4307	13	,	,	,
8691	4307	14	a	a	DT
8691	4307	15	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4307	16	sentiment	sentiment	NN
8691	4307	17	of	of	IN
8691	4307	18	reverence	reverence	NN
8691	4307	19	for	for	IN
8691	4307	20	ancient	ancient	JJ
8691	4307	21	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	4307	22	.	.	.
8691	4308	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4308	2	Constitutions	constitution	NNS
8691	4308	3	are	be	VBP
8691	4308	4	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	4308	5	the	the	DT
8691	4308	6	work	work	NN
8691	4308	7	of	of	IN
8691	4308	8	former	former	JJ
8691	4308	9	generations	generation	NNS
8691	4308	10	.	.	.
8691	4309	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4309	2	may	may	MD
8691	4309	3	amend	amend	VB
8691	4309	4	or	or	CC
8691	4309	5	recast	recast	VB
8691	4309	6	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4309	7	,	,	,
8691	4309	8	but	but	CC
8691	4309	9	the	the	DT
8691	4309	10	substantial	substantial	JJ
8691	4309	11	framework	framework	NN
8691	4309	12	will	will	MD
8691	4309	13	remain	remain	VB
8691	4309	14	the	the	DT
8691	4309	15	same	same	JJ
8691	4309	16	.	.	.
8691	4310	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4310	2	Declarations	declaration	NNS
8691	4310	3	of	of	IN
8691	4310	4	Rights	Rights	NNPS
8691	4310	5	speak	speak	VBP
8691	4310	6	the	the	DT
8691	4310	7	language	language	NN
8691	4310	8	and	and	CC
8691	4310	9	the	the	DT
8691	4310	10	lessons	lesson	NNS
8691	4310	11	of	of	IN
8691	4310	12	the	the	DT
8691	4310	13	eighteenth	eighteenth	JJ
8691	4310	14	century	century	NN
8691	4310	15	.	.	.
8691	4311	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4311	2	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	4311	3	are	be	VBP
8691	4311	4	almost	almost	RB
8691	4311	5	wholly	wholly	RB
8691	4311	6	aimed	aim	VBN
8691	4311	7	at	at	IN
8691	4311	8	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4311	9	executives	executive	NNS
8691	4311	10	and	and	CC
8691	4311	11	legislators	legislator	NNS
8691	4311	12	.	.	.
8691	4312	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4312	2	give	give	VBP
8691	4312	3	guarantees	guarantee	NNS
8691	4312	4	which	which	WDT
8691	4312	5	the	the	DT
8691	4312	6	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	4312	7	only	only	RB
8691	4312	8	can	can	MD
8691	4312	9	enforce	enforce	VB
8691	4312	10	.	.	.
8691	4313	1	No	no	DT
8691	4313	2	people	people	NNS
8691	4313	3	can	can	MD
8691	4313	4	steadily	steadily	RB
8691	4313	5	prosper	prosper	VB
8691	4313	6	unless	unless	IN
8691	4313	7	a	a	DT
8691	4313	8	just	just	RB
8691	4313	9	mean	mean	NN
8691	4313	10	be	be	VB
8691	4313	11	preserved	preserve	VBN
8691	4313	12	between	between	IN
8691	4313	13	reform	reform	NN
8691	4313	14	and	and	CC
8691	4313	15	conservatism	conservatism	NN
8691	4313	16	in	in	IN
8691	4313	17	the	the	DT
8691	4313	18	administration	administration	NN
8691	4313	19	of	of	IN
8691	4313	20	the	the	DT
8691	4313	21	government	government	NN
8691	4313	22	.	.	.
8691	4314	1	The	the	DT
8691	4314	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	4314	3	stand	stand	VBP
8691	4314	4	for	for	IN
8691	4314	5	conservatism	conservatism	NN
8691	4314	6	,	,	,
8691	4314	7	but	but	CC
8691	4314	8	by	by	IN
8691	4314	9	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4314	10	recognition	recognition	NN
8691	4314	11	of	of	IN
8691	4314	12	custom	custom	NN
8691	4314	13	as	as	IN
8691	4314	14	law	law	NN
8691	4314	15	,	,	,
8691	4314	16	and	and	CC
8691	4314	17	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4314	18	free	free	JJ
8691	4314	19	use	use	NN
8691	4314	20	of	of	IN
8691	4314	21	logic	logic	NN
8691	4314	22	and	and	CC
8691	4314	23	analogy	analogy	NN
8691	4314	24	to	to	TO
8691	4314	25	develop	develop	VB
8691	4314	26	law	law	NN
8691	4314	27	,	,	,
8691	4314	28	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4314	29	also	also	RB
8691	4314	30	keep	keep	VBP
8691	4314	31	a	a	DT
8691	4314	32	door	door	NN
8691	4314	33	open	open	JJ
8691	4314	34	for	for	IN
8691	4314	35	the	the	DT
8691	4314	36	entrance	entrance	NN
8691	4314	37	of	of	IN
8691	4314	38	reform	reform	NN
8691	4314	39	.	.	.
8691	4315	1	The	the	DT
8691	4315	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	4315	3	also	also	RB
8691	4315	4	come	come	VBP
8691	4315	5	very	very	RB
8691	4315	6	close	close	RB
8691	4315	7	to	to	IN
8691	4315	8	the	the	DT
8691	4315	9	people	people	NNS
8691	4315	10	.	.	.
8691	4316	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4316	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4316	3	to	to	TO
8691	4316	4	be	be	VB
8691	4316	5	found	find	VBN
8691	4316	6	in	in	IN
8691	4316	7	every	every	DT
8691	4316	8	county	county	NN
8691	4316	9	and	and	CC
8691	4316	10	almost	almost	RB
8691	4316	11	every	every	DT
8691	4316	12	township	township	NN
8691	4316	13	.	.	.
8691	4317	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4317	2	settle	settle	VBP
8691	4317	3	the	the	DT
8691	4317	4	estates	estate	NNS
8691	4317	5	of	of	IN
8691	4317	6	the	the	DT
8691	4317	7	dead	dead	JJ
8691	4317	8	.	.	.
8691	4318	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4318	2	protect	protect	VBP
8691	4318	3	the	the	DT
8691	4318	4	living	living	NN
8691	4318	5	.	.	.
8691	4319	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4319	2	act	act	VBP
8691	4319	3	largely	largely	RB
8691	4319	4	through	through	IN
8691	4319	5	juries	jury	NNS
8691	4319	6	made	make	VBN
8691	4319	7	up	up	RP
8691	4319	8	of	of	IN
8691	4319	9	the	the	DT
8691	4319	10	people	people	NNS
8691	4319	11	and	and	CC
8691	4319	12	returning	return	VBG
8691	4319	13	to	to	IN
8691	4319	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4319	15	after	after	IN
8691	4319	16	a	a	DT
8691	4319	17	brief	brief	JJ
8691	4319	18	term	term	NN
8691	4319	19	of	of	IN
8691	4319	20	public	public	JJ
8691	4319	21	service	service	NN
8691	4319	22	.	.	.
8691	4320	1	All	all	PDT
8691	4320	2	these	these	DT
8691	4320	3	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	4320	4	put	put	VBD
8691	4320	5	Americans	Americans	NNPS
8691	4320	6	in	in	IN
8691	4320	7	a	a	DT
8691	4320	8	friendly	friendly	JJ
8691	4320	9	attitude	attitude	NN
8691	4320	10	toward	toward	IN
8691	4320	11	the	the	DT
8691	4320	12	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	4320	13	.	.	.
8691	4321	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4321	2	makes	make	VBZ
8691	4321	3	less	less	JJR
8691	4321	4	show	show	NN
8691	4321	5	of	of	IN
8691	4321	6	authority	authority	NN
8691	4321	7	than	than	IN
8691	4321	8	the	the	DT
8691	4321	9	policeman	policeman	NN
8691	4321	10	or	or	CC
8691	4321	11	the	the	DT
8691	4321	12	militiaman	militiaman	NN
8691	4321	13	.	.	.
8691	4322	1	But	but	CC
8691	4322	2	the	the	DT
8691	4322	3	people	people	NNS
8691	4322	4	feel	feel	VBP
8691	4322	5	that	that	IN
8691	4322	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4322	7	has	have	VBZ
8691	4322	8	authority	authority	NN
8691	4322	9	and	and	CC
8691	4322	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	4322	11	ready	ready	JJ
8691	4322	12	to	to	TO
8691	4322	13	exercise	exercise	VB
8691	4322	14	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4322	15	always	always	RB
8691	4322	16	to	to	TO
8691	4322	17	secure	secure	VB
8691	4322	18	that	that	IN
8691	4322	19	right	right	RB
8691	4322	20	be	be	VB
8691	4322	21	done	do	VBN
8691	4322	22	.	.	.
8691	4323	1	When	when	WRB
8691	4323	2	a	a	DT
8691	4323	3	plain	plain	JJ
8691	4323	4	man	man	NN
8691	4323	5	who	who	WP
8691	4323	6	thinks	think	VBZ
8691	4323	7	that	that	IN
8691	4323	8	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4323	9	has	have	VBZ
8691	4323	10	been	be	VBN
8691	4323	11	wronged	wrong	VBN
8691	4323	12	by	by	IN
8691	4323	13	another	another	DT
8691	4323	14	declares	declare	NNS
8691	4323	15	that	that	IN
8691	4323	16	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4323	17	"	"	``
8691	4323	18	will	will	MD
8691	4323	19	have	have	VB
8691	4323	20	the	the	DT
8691	4323	21	law	law	NN
8691	4323	22	on	on	IN
8691	4323	23	him	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4323	24	,	,	,
8691	4323	25	"	"	''
8691	4323	26	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4323	27	expresses	express	VBZ
8691	4323	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4323	29	conviction	conviction	NN
8691	4323	30	that	that	IN
8691	4323	31	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4323	32	can	can	MD
8691	4323	33	get	get	VB
8691	4323	34	justice	justice	NN
8691	4323	35	from	from	IN
8691	4323	36	the	the	DT
8691	4323	37	courts	court	NNS
8691	4323	38	.	.	.
8691	4324	1	The	the	DT
8691	4324	2	creation	creation	NN
8691	4324	3	of	of	IN
8691	4324	4	the	the	DT
8691	4324	5	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	4324	6	of	of	IN
8691	4324	7	the	the	DT
8691	4324	8	United	United	NNP
8691	4324	9	States	States	NNP
8691	4324	10	was	be	VBD
8691	4324	11	welcomed	welcome	VBN
8691	4324	12	at	at	IN
8691	4324	13	the	the	DT
8691	4324	14	outset	outset	NN
8691	4324	15	by	by	IN
8691	4324	16	all	all	DT
8691	4324	17	.	.	.
8691	4325	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4325	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4325	3	:	:	:
8691	4325	4	See	see	VB
8691	4325	5	"	"	''
8691	4325	6	Life	Life	NNP
8691	4325	7	of	of	IN
8691	4325	8	Peter	Peter	NNP
8691	4325	9	Van	Van	NNP
8691	4325	10	Schaick	Schaick	NNP
8691	4325	11	,	,	,
8691	4325	12	"	"	''
8691	4325	13	435	435	CD
8691	4325	14	.	.	.
8691	4325	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4326	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4326	2	was	be	VBD
8691	4326	3	not	not	RB
8691	4326	4	until	until	IN
8691	4326	5	party	party	NN
8691	4326	6	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	4326	7	had	have	VBD
8691	4326	8	become	become	VBN
8691	4326	9	intense	intense	JJ
8691	4326	10	that	that	IN
8691	4326	11	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
8691	4326	12	found	find	VBD
8691	4326	13	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4326	14	difficult	difficult	JJ
8691	4326	15	to	to	TO
8691	4326	16	look	look	VB
8691	4326	17	with	with	IN
8691	4326	18	approval	approval	NN
8691	4326	19	on	on	IN
8691	4326	20	a	a	DT
8691	4326	21	force	force	NN
8691	4326	22	evidently	evidently	RB
8691	4326	23	becoming	become	VBG
8691	4326	24	stronger	strong	JJR
8691	4326	25	every	every	DT
8691	4326	26	day	day	NN
8691	4326	27	,	,	,
8691	4326	28	and	and	CC
8691	4326	29	that	that	IN
8691	4326	30	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	4326	31	could	could	MD
8691	4326	32	describe	describe	VB
8691	4326	33	the	the	DT
8691	4326	34	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4326	35	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4326	36	as	as	IN
8691	4326	37	the	the	DT
8691	4326	38	sappers	sapper	NNS
8691	4326	39	and	and	CC
8691	4326	40	miners	miner	NNS
8691	4326	41	who	who	WP
8691	4326	42	were	be	VBD
8691	4326	43	gradually	gradually	RB
8691	4326	44	undermining	undermine	VBG
8691	4326	45	the	the	DT
8691	4326	46	foundations	foundation	NNS
8691	4326	47	of	of	IN
8691	4326	48	American	american	JJ
8691	4326	49	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	4326	50	.	.	.
8691	4327	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4327	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4327	3	:	:	:
8691	4327	4	Letter	letter	NN
8691	4327	5	to	to	IN
8691	4327	6	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
8691	4327	7	Ritchie	Ritchie	NNP
8691	4327	8	of	of	IN
8691	4327	9	Dec.	December	NNP
8691	4327	10	25	25	CD
8691	4327	11	,	,	,
8691	4327	12	1870	1870	CD
8691	4327	13	.	.	.
8691	4328	1	"	"	``
8691	4328	2	Works	work	NNS
8691	4328	3	of	of	IN
8691	4328	4	Thomas	Thomas	NNP
8691	4328	5	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	4328	6	,	,	,
8691	4328	7	"	"	''
8691	4328	8	VII	VII	NNP
8691	4328	9	,	,	,
8691	4328	10	192	192	CD
8691	4328	11	.	.	.
8691	4328	12	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4329	1	Of	of	IN
8691	4329	2	the	the	DT
8691	4329	3	political	political	JJ
8691	4329	4	questions	question	NNS
8691	4329	5	which	which	WDT
8691	4329	6	engaged	engage	VBD
8691	4329	7	attention	attention	NN
8691	4329	8	over	over	IN
8691	4329	9	the	the	DT
8691	4329	10	whole	whole	JJ
8691	4329	11	country	country	NN
8691	4329	12	from	from	IN
8691	4329	13	time	time	NN
8691	4329	14	to	to	IN
8691	4329	15	time	time	NN
8691	4329	16	from	from	IN
8691	4329	17	the	the	DT
8691	4329	18	adoption	adoption	NN
8691	4329	19	of	of	IN
8691	4329	20	the	the	DT
8691	4329	21	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	4329	22	to	to	IN
8691	4329	23	the	the	DT
8691	4329	24	close	close	NN
8691	4329	25	of	of	IN
8691	4329	26	the	the	DT
8691	4329	27	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	4329	28	War	War	NNP
8691	4329	29	,	,	,
8691	4329	30	almost	almost	RB
8691	4329	31	all	all	DT
8691	4329	32	bore	bear	VBD
8691	4329	33	some	some	DT
8691	4329	34	relation	relation	NN
8691	4329	35	to	to	IN
8691	4329	36	the	the	DT
8691	4329	37	institution	institution	NN
8691	4329	38	of	of	IN
8691	4329	39	slavery	slavery	NN
8691	4329	40	and	and	CC
8691	4329	41	derived	derive	VBD
8691	4329	42	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4329	43	real	real	JJ
8691	4329	44	vitality	vitality	NN
8691	4329	45	from	from	IN
8691	4329	46	that	that	DT
8691	4329	47	connection	connection	NN
8691	4329	48	.	.	.
8691	4330	1	Slavery	Slavery	NNP
8691	4330	2	depended	depend	VBD
8691	4330	3	on	on	IN
8691	4330	4	State	State	NNP
8691	4330	5	laws	law	NNS
8691	4330	6	.	.	.
8691	4331	1	Unless	unless	IN
8691	4331	2	the	the	DT
8691	4331	3	authority	authority	NN
8691	4331	4	of	of	IN
8691	4331	5	each	each	DT
8691	4331	6	State	State	NNP
8691	4331	7	to	to	TO
8691	4331	8	allow	allow	VB
8691	4331	9	and	and	CC
8691	4331	10	regulate	regulate	VB
8691	4331	11	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4331	12	were	be	VBD
8691	4331	13	preserved	preserve	VBN
8691	4331	14	,	,	,
8691	4331	15	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4331	16	countenance	countenance	NN
8691	4331	17	would	would	MD
8691	4331	18	be	be	VB
8691	4331	19	endangered	endanger	VBN
8691	4331	20	.	.	.
8691	4332	1	This	this	DT
8691	4332	2	was	be	VBD
8691	4332	3	largely	largely	RB
8691	4332	4	the	the	DT
8691	4332	5	source	source	NN
8691	4332	6	of	of	IN
8691	4332	7	the	the	DT
8691	4332	8	"	"	``
8691	4332	9	State	State	NNP
8691	4332	10	Rights	Rights	NNPS
8691	4332	11	"	"	''
8691	4332	12	cry	cry	VBP
8691	4332	13	.	.	.
8691	4333	1	Almost	almost	RB
8691	4333	2	all	all	PDT
8691	4333	3	the	the	DT
8691	4333	4	powers	power	NNS
8691	4333	5	which	which	WDT
8691	4333	6	the	the	DT
8691	4333	7	United	United	NNP
8691	4333	8	States	States	NNP
8691	4333	9	possessed	possess	VBD
8691	4333	10	the	the	DT
8691	4333	11	States	States	NNPS
8691	4333	12	had	have	VBD
8691	4333	13	lost	lose	VBN
8691	4333	14	.	.	.
8691	4334	1	For	for	IN
8691	4334	2	thirteen	thirteen	CD
8691	4334	3	years	year	NNS
8691	4334	4	each	each	DT
8691	4334	5	had	have	VBD
8691	4334	6	been	be	VBN
8691	4334	7	in	in	IN
8691	4334	8	the	the	DT
8691	4334	9	position	position	NN
8691	4334	10	of	of	IN
8691	4334	11	a	a	DT
8691	4334	12	full	full	JJ
8691	4334	13	sovereign	sovereign	NN
8691	4334	14	.	.	.
8691	4335	1	Its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4335	2	courts	court	NNS
8691	4335	3	had	have	VBD
8691	4335	4	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	4335	5	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	4335	6	over	over	IN
8691	4335	7	all	all	DT
8691	4335	8	kinds	kind	NNS
8691	4335	9	of	of	IN
8691	4335	10	actions	action	NNS
8691	4335	11	.	.	.
8691	4336	1	Now	now	RB
8691	4336	2	a	a	DT
8691	4336	3	new	new	JJ
8691	4336	4	set	set	NN
8691	4336	5	of	of	IN
8691	4336	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	4336	7	had	have	VBD
8691	4336	8	risen	rise	VBN
8691	4336	9	up	up	RP
8691	4336	10	having	have	VBG
8691	4336	11	over	over	IN
8691	4336	12	many	many	JJ
8691	4336	13	actions	action	NNS
8691	4336	14	an	an	DT
8691	4336	15	equal	equal	JJ
8691	4336	16	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	4336	17	,	,	,
8691	4336	18	over	over	IN
8691	4336	19	some	some	DT
8691	4336	20	a	a	DT
8691	4336	21	superior	superior	JJ
8691	4336	22	one	one	NN
8691	4336	23	.	.	.
8691	4337	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4337	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4337	3	:	:	:
8691	4337	4	See	see	VB
8691	4337	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	4337	6	.	.	.
8691	4338	1	X.	X.	NNP
8691	4338	2	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4339	1	The	the	DT
8691	4339	2	case	case	NN
8691	4339	3	of	of	IN
8691	4339	4	Chisholm	Chisholm	NNP
8691	4339	5	_	_	NNP
8691	4339	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	4339	7	_	_	NNP
8691	4339	8	Georgia,[Footnote	Georgia,[Footnote	NNP
8691	4339	9	:	:	:
8691	4339	10	2	2	CD
8691	4339	11	Dallas	Dallas	NNP
8691	4339	12	'	'	POS
8691	4339	13	Reports	report	NNS
8691	4339	14	,	,	,
8691	4339	15	419	419	CD
8691	4339	16	.	.	.
8691	4339	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4340	1	in	in	IN
8691	4340	2	1793	1793	CD
8691	4340	3	,	,	,
8691	4340	4	and	and	CC
8691	4340	5	the	the	DT
8691	4340	6	institution	institution	NN
8691	4340	7	of	of	IN
8691	4340	8	similar	similar	JJ
8691	4340	9	suits	suit	NNS
8691	4340	10	against	against	IN
8691	4340	11	other	other	JJ
8691	4340	12	States	States	NNPS
8691	4340	13	of	of	IN
8691	4340	14	the	the	DT
8691	4340	15	South	South	NNP
8691	4340	16	showed	show	VBD
8691	4340	17	that	that	IN
8691	4340	18	the	the	DT
8691	4340	19	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4340	20	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4340	21	of	of	IN
8691	4340	22	the	the	DT
8691	4340	23	United	United	NNP
8691	4340	24	States	States	NNP
8691	4340	25	claimed	claim	VBD
8691	4340	26	authority	authority	NN
8691	4340	27	to	to	TO
8691	4340	28	render	render	VB
8691	4340	29	a	a	DT
8691	4340	30	money	money	NN
8691	4340	31	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	4340	32	against	against	IN
8691	4340	33	a	a	DT
8691	4340	34	State	State	NNP
8691	4340	35	,	,	,
8691	4340	36	which	which	WDT
8691	4340	37	meant	mean	VBD
8691	4340	38	that	that	IN
8691	4340	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4340	40	could	could	MD
8691	4340	41	then	then	RB
8691	4340	42	issue	issue	VB
8691	4340	43	an	an	DT
8691	4340	44	execution	execution	NN
8691	4340	45	to	to	TO
8691	4340	46	collect	collect	VB
8691	4340	47	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4340	48	by	by	IN
8691	4340	49	levying	levy	VBG
8691	4340	50	on	on	IN
8691	4340	51	the	the	DT
8691	4340	52	property	property	NN
8691	4340	53	of	of	IN
8691	4340	54	the	the	DT
8691	4340	55	State	State	NNP
8691	4340	56	.	.	.
8691	4341	1	In	in	IN
8691	4341	2	1798	1798	CD
8691	4341	3	,	,	,
8691	4341	4	the	the	DT
8691	4341	5	Alien	Alien	NNP
8691	4341	6	and	and	CC
8691	4341	7	Sedition	Sedition	NNP
8691	4341	8	Laws	Laws	NNPS
8691	4341	9	were	be	VBD
8691	4341	10	passed	pass	VBN
8691	4341	11	,	,	,
8691	4341	12	and	and	CC
8691	4341	13	a	a	DT
8691	4341	14	crime	crime	NN
8691	4341	15	previously	previously	RB
8691	4341	16	cognizable	cognizable	JJ
8691	4341	17	exclusively	exclusively	RB
8691	4341	18	in	in	IN
8691	4341	19	the	the	DT
8691	4341	20	State	State	NNP
8691	4341	21	courts	court	NNS
8691	4341	22	was	be	VBD
8691	4341	23	made	make	VBN
8691	4341	24	a	a	DT
8691	4341	25	subject	subject	NN
8691	4341	26	of	of	IN
8691	4341	27	prosecution	prosecution	NN
8691	4341	28	in	in	IN
8691	4341	29	those	those	DT
8691	4341	30	of	of	IN
8691	4341	31	the	the	DT
8691	4341	32	United	United	NNP
8691	4341	33	States	States	NNP
8691	4341	34	if	if	IN
8691	4341	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4341	36	affected	affect	VBD
8691	4341	37	an	an	DT
8691	4341	38	officer	officer	NN
8691	4341	39	of	of	IN
8691	4341	40	the	the	DT
8691	4341	41	United	United	NNP
8691	4341	42	States	States	NNP
8691	4341	43	.	.	.
8691	4342	1	A	a	DT
8691	4342	2	member	member	NN
8691	4342	3	of	of	IN
8691	4342	4	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	4342	5	,	,	,
8691	4342	6	Matthew	Matthew	NNP
8691	4342	7	Lyon	Lyon	NNP
8691	4342	8	,	,	,
8691	4342	9	of	of	IN
8691	4342	10	Vermont	Vermont	NNP
8691	4342	11	,	,	,
8691	4342	12	who	who	WP
8691	4342	13	was	be	VBD
8691	4342	14	sentenced	sentence	VBN
8691	4342	15	in	in	IN
8691	4342	16	the	the	DT
8691	4342	17	Fall	fall	NN
8691	4342	18	of	of	IN
8691	4342	19	that	that	DT
8691	4342	20	year	year	NN
8691	4342	21	to	to	IN
8691	4342	22	a	a	DT
8691	4342	23	fine	fine	NN
8691	4342	24	of	of	IN
8691	4342	25	$	$	$
8691	4342	26	1,000	1,000	CD
8691	4342	27	and	and	CC
8691	4342	28	four	four	CD
8691	4342	29	months	month	NNS
8691	4342	30	in	in	IN
8691	4342	31	jail	jail	NN
8691	4342	32	for	for	IN
8691	4342	33	writing	writing	NN
8691	4342	34	of	of	IN
8691	4342	35	the	the	DT
8691	4342	36	President	President	NNP
8691	4342	37	and	and	CC
8691	4342	38	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	4342	39	,	,	,
8691	4342	40	that	that	IN
8691	4342	41	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4342	42	message	message	NN
8691	4342	43	to	to	IN
8691	4342	44	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	4342	45	in	in	IN
8691	4342	46	1797	1797	CD
8691	4342	47	was	be	VBD
8691	4342	48	a	a	DT
8691	4342	49	bullying	bullying	NN
8691	4342	50	speech	speech	NN
8691	4342	51	,	,	,
8691	4342	52	which	which	WDT
8691	4342	53	the	the	DT
8691	4342	54	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	4342	55	in	in	IN
8691	4342	56	a	a	DT
8691	4342	57	stupid	stupid	JJ
8691	4342	58	answer	answer	NN
8691	4342	59	had	have	VBD
8691	4342	60	echoed	echo	VBN
8691	4342	61	with	with	IN
8691	4342	62	more	more	JJR
8691	4342	63	servility	servility	NN
8691	4342	64	than	than	IN
8691	4342	65	ever	ever	RB
8691	4342	66	Geo	Geo	NNP
8691	4342	67	.	.	.
8691	4343	1	III	iii	CD
8691	4343	2	.	.	.
8691	4344	1	experienced	experience	VBN
8691	4344	2	from	from	IN
8691	4344	3	either	either	DT
8691	4344	4	house	house	NN
8691	4344	5	of	of	IN
8691	4344	6	parliament	parliament	NN
8691	4344	7	,	,	,
8691	4344	8	served	serve	VBD
8691	4344	9	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4344	10	time	time	NN
8691	4344	11	and	and	CC
8691	4344	12	paid	pay	VBD
8691	4344	13	the	the	DT
8691	4344	14	fine	fine	NN
8691	4344	15	,	,	,
8691	4344	16	but	but	CC
8691	4344	17	for	for	IN
8691	4344	18	the	the	DT
8691	4344	19	amount	amount	NN
8691	4344	20	of	of	IN
8691	4344	21	the	the	DT
8691	4344	22	latter	latter	JJ
8691	4344	23	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4344	24	was	be	VBD
8691	4344	25	reimbursed	reimburse	VBN
8691	4344	26	by	by	IN
8691	4344	27	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	4344	28	in	in	IN
8691	4344	29	1840	1840	CD
8691	4344	30	.	.	.
8691	4345	1	The	the	DT
8691	4345	2	case	case	NN
8691	4345	3	of	of	IN
8691	4345	4	Jonathan	Jonathan	NNP
8691	4345	5	Robbins[Footnote	Robbins[Footnote	VBZ
8691	4345	6	:	:	:
8691	4345	7	See	see	VB
8691	4345	8	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	4345	9	.	.	.
8691	4346	1	III	iii	CD
8691	4346	2	.	.	.
8691	4346	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4347	1	in	in	IN
8691	4347	2	South	South	NNP
8691	4347	3	Carolina	Carolina	NNP
8691	4347	4	in	in	IN
8691	4347	5	1799	1799	CD
8691	4347	6	,	,	,
8691	4347	7	showed	show	VBD
8691	4347	8	that	that	IN
8691	4347	9	the	the	DT
8691	4347	10	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	4347	11	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4347	12	at	at	IN
8691	4347	13	the	the	DT
8691	4347	14	request	request	NN
8691	4347	15	of	of	IN
8691	4347	16	the	the	DT
8691	4347	17	President	President	NNP
8691	4347	18	could	could	MD
8691	4347	19	surrender	surrender	VB
8691	4347	20	an	an	DT
8691	4347	21	American	american	JJ
8691	4347	22	citizen	citizen	NN
8691	4347	23	to	to	IN
8691	4347	24	a	a	DT
8691	4347	25	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	4347	26	government	government	NN
8691	4347	27	to	to	TO
8691	4347	28	be	be	VB
8691	4347	29	carried	carry	VBN
8691	4347	30	off	off	RP
8691	4347	31	and	and	CC
8691	4347	32	tried	try	VBN
8691	4347	33	for	for	IN
8691	4347	34	murder	murder	NN
8691	4347	35	.	.	.
8691	4348	1	This	this	DT
8691	4348	2	and	and	CC
8691	4348	3	the	the	DT
8691	4348	4	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	4348	5	of	of	IN
8691	4348	6	Lyon	Lyon	NNP
8691	4348	7	became	become	VBD
8691	4348	8	immediately	immediately	RB
8691	4348	9	the	the	DT
8691	4348	10	subject	subject	NN
8691	4348	11	of	of	IN
8691	4348	12	hot	hot	JJ
8691	4348	13	discussion	discussion	NN
8691	4348	14	in	in	IN
8691	4348	15	Congress	Congress	NNP
8691	4348	16	,	,	,
8691	4348	17	and	and	CC
8691	4348	18	both	both	DT
8691	4348	19	contributed	contribute	VBD
8691	4348	20	to	to	IN
8691	4348	21	the	the	DT
8691	4348	22	political	political	JJ
8691	4348	23	revolution	revolution	NN
8691	4348	24	which	which	WDT
8691	4348	25	put	put	VBD
8691	4348	26	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	4348	27	in	in	IN
8691	4348	28	the	the	DT
8691	4348	29	seat	seat	NN
8691	4348	30	of	of	IN
8691	4348	31	Adams	Adams	NNP
8691	4348	32	in	in	IN
8691	4348	33	1801	1801	CD
8691	4348	34	.	.	.
8691	4349	1	The	the	DT
8691	4349	2	creation	creation	NN
8691	4349	3	by	by	IN
8691	4349	4	the	the	DT
8691	4349	5	outgoing	outgoing	JJ
8691	4349	6	party	party	NN
8691	4349	7	of	of	IN
8691	4349	8	places	place	NNS
8691	4349	9	for	for	IN
8691	4349	10	eighteen	eighteen	CD
8691	4349	11	new	new	NNP
8691	4349	12	Circuit	Circuit	NNP
8691	4349	13	Judges	Judges	NNPS
8691	4349	14	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	4349	15	by	by	IN
8691	4349	16	Adams	Adams	NNP
8691	4349	17	in	in	IN
8691	4349	18	the	the	DT
8691	4349	19	last	last	JJ
8691	4349	20	month	month	NN
8691	4349	21	of	of	IN
8691	4349	22	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4349	23	administration	administration	NN
8691	4349	24	strengthened	strengthen	VBD
8691	4349	25	the	the	DT
8691	4349	26	popular	popular	JJ
8691	4349	27	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	4349	28	that	that	IN
8691	4349	29	the	the	DT
8691	4349	30	courts	court	NNS
8691	4349	31	of	of	IN
8691	4349	32	the	the	DT
8691	4349	33	United	United	NNP
8691	4349	34	States	States	NNP
8691	4349	35	were	be	VBD
8691	4349	36	too	too	RB
8691	4349	37	powerful	powerful	JJ
8691	4349	38	.	.	.
8691	4350	1	That	that	DT
8691	4350	2	Act	Act	NNP
8691	4350	3	was	be	VBD
8691	4350	4	at	at	IN
8691	4350	5	once	once	RB
8691	4350	6	repealed,[Footnote	repealed,[footnote	NN
8691	4350	7	:	:	:
8691	4350	8	See	see	VB
8691	4350	9	Chaps	Chaps	NNP
8691	4350	10	.	.	.
8691	4351	1	IX	ix	NN
8691	4351	2	,	,	,
8691	4351	3	XXII	XXII	NNP
8691	4351	4	.	.	.
8691	4351	5	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4352	1	and	and	CC
8691	4352	2	also	also	RB
8691	4352	3	the	the	DT
8691	4352	4	provision	provision	NN
8691	4352	5	for	for	IN
8691	4352	6	the	the	DT
8691	4352	7	next	next	JJ
8691	4352	8	regular	regular	JJ
8691	4352	9	term	term	NN
8691	4352	10	of	of	IN
8691	4352	11	the	the	DT
8691	4352	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4352	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4352	14	.	.	.
8691	4353	1	The	the	DT
8691	4353	2	latter	latter	JJ
8691	4353	3	measure	measure	NN
8691	4353	4	was	be	VBD
8691	4353	5	taken	take	VBN
8691	4353	6	to	to	TO
8691	4353	7	prevent	prevent	VB
8691	4353	8	any	any	DT
8691	4353	9	legal	legal	JJ
8691	4353	10	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	4353	11	in	in	IN
8691	4353	12	the	the	DT
8691	4353	13	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4353	14	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4353	15	to	to	TO
8691	4353	16	secure	secure	VB
8691	4353	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4353	18	intervention	intervention	NN
8691	4353	19	in	in	IN
8691	4353	20	behalf	behalf	NN
8691	4353	21	of	of	IN
8691	4353	22	the	the	DT
8691	4353	23	displaced	displace	VBN
8691	4353	24	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4353	25	.	.	.
8691	4354	1	The	the	DT
8691	4354	2	new	new	JJ
8691	4354	3	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	4354	4	system	system	NN
8691	4354	5	had	have	VBD
8691	4354	6	been	be	VBN
8691	4354	7	swept	sweep	VBN
8691	4354	8	away	away	RB
8691	4354	9	,	,	,
8691	4354	10	but	but	CC
8691	4354	11	the	the	DT
8691	4354	12	full	full	JJ
8691	4354	13	bench	bench	NN
8691	4354	14	at	at	IN
8691	4354	15	Washington	Washington	NNP
8691	4354	16	,	,	,
8691	4354	17	headed	head	VBN
8691	4354	18	by	by	IN
8691	4354	19	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	4354	20	,	,	,
8691	4354	21	remained	remain	VBD
8691	4354	22	.	.	.
8691	4355	1	The	the	DT
8691	4355	2	unsuccessful	unsuccessful	JJ
8691	4355	3	impeachment	impeachment	NN
8691	4355	4	of	of	IN
8691	4355	5	one	one	CD
8691	4355	6	of	of	IN
8691	4355	7	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4355	8	followed	follow	VBD
8691	4355	9	in	in	IN
8691	4355	10	1804	1804	CD
8691	4355	11	.	.	.
8691	4356	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4356	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4356	3	:	:	:
8691	4356	4	See	see	VB
8691	4356	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	4356	6	.	.	.
8691	4357	1	III	iii	CD
8691	4357	2	.	.	.
8691	4357	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4358	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4358	2	acquittal	acquittal	NN
8691	4358	3	the	the	DT
8691	4358	4	next	next	JJ
8691	4358	5	year	year	NN
8691	4358	6	,	,	,
8691	4358	7	and	and	CC
8691	4358	8	that	that	DT
8691	4358	9	of	of	IN
8691	4358	10	a	a	DT
8691	4358	11	majority	majority	NN
8691	4358	12	of	of	IN
8691	4358	13	the	the	DT
8691	4358	14	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4358	15	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4358	16	of	of	IN
8691	4358	17	Pennsylvania,[Footnote	Pennsylvania,[Footnote	NNP
8691	4358	18	:	:	:
8691	4358	19	McMaster	McMaster	NNP
8691	4358	20	,	,	,
8691	4358	21	"	"	``
8691	4358	22	History	history	NN
8691	4358	23	of	of	IN
8691	4358	24	the	the	DT
8691	4358	25	United	United	NNP
8691	4358	26	States	States	NNP
8691	4358	27	,	,	,
8691	4358	28	"	"	''
8691	4358	29	III	iii	CD
8691	4358	30	,	,	,
8691	4358	31	159	159	CD
8691	4358	32	.	.	.
8691	4358	33	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4359	1	who	who	WP
8691	4359	2	were	be	VBD
8691	4359	3	impeached	impeach	VBN
8691	4359	4	there	there	RB
8691	4359	5	at	at	IN
8691	4359	6	the	the	DT
8691	4359	7	same	same	JJ
8691	4359	8	time	time	NN
8691	4359	9	for	for	IN
8691	4359	10	punishing	punish	VBG
8691	4359	11	a	a	DT
8691	4359	12	libel	libel	NN
8691	4359	13	on	on	IN
8691	4359	14	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4359	15	proceedings	proceeding	NNS
8691	4359	16	before	before	IN
8691	4359	17	that	that	DT
8691	4359	18	court	court	NN
8691	4359	19	by	by	IN
8691	4359	20	a	a	DT
8691	4359	21	sentence	sentence	NN
8691	4359	22	of	of	IN
8691	4359	23	imprisonment	imprisonment	NN
8691	4359	24	,	,	,
8691	4359	25	satisfied	satisfy	VBD
8691	4359	26	all	all	DT
8691	4359	27	that	that	WDT
8691	4359	28	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4359	29	was	be	VBD
8691	4359	30	practically	practically	RB
8691	4359	31	impossible	impossible	JJ
8691	4359	32	to	to	TO
8691	4359	33	secure	secure	VB
8691	4359	34	the	the	DT
8691	4359	35	removal	removal	NN
8691	4359	36	of	of	IN
8691	4359	37	a	a	DT
8691	4359	38	judge	judge	NN
8691	4359	39	except	except	IN
8691	4359	40	for	for	IN
8691	4359	41	the	the	DT
8691	4359	42	gravest	grave	JJS
8691	4359	43	cause	cause	NN
8691	4359	44	.	.	.
8691	4360	1	Judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4360	2	independence	independence	NN
8691	4360	3	had	have	VBD
8691	4360	4	been	be	VBN
8691	4360	5	secured	secure	VBN
8691	4360	6	by	by	IN
8691	4360	7	the	the	DT
8691	4360	8	very	very	JJ
8691	4360	9	struggle	struggle	NN
8691	4360	10	to	to	TO
8691	4360	11	defeat	defeat	VB
8691	4360	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4360	13	.	.	.
8691	4361	1	What	what	WP
8691	4361	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	4361	3	won	win	VBN
8691	4361	4	in	in	IN
8691	4361	5	any	any	DT
8691	4361	6	contest	contest	NN
8691	4361	7	finds	find	VBZ
8691	4361	8	favor	favor	NN
8691	4361	9	with	with	IN
8691	4361	10	the	the	DT
8691	4361	11	multitude	multitude	NN
8691	4361	12	.	.	.
8691	4362	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4362	2	admire	admire	VBP
8691	4362	3	a	a	DT
8691	4362	4	victor	victor	NN
8691	4362	5	.	.	.
8691	4363	1	From	from	IN
8691	4363	2	this	this	DT
8691	4363	3	time	time	NN
8691	4363	4	on	on	IN
8691	4363	5	the	the	DT
8691	4363	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	4363	7	both	both	DT
8691	4363	8	of	of	IN
8691	4363	9	the	the	DT
8691	4363	10	United	United	NNP
8691	4363	11	States	States	NNP
8691	4363	12	and	and	CC
8691	4363	13	the	the	DT
8691	4363	14	States	States	NNPS
8691	4363	15	grew	grow	VBD
8691	4363	16	in	in	IN
8691	4363	17	public	public	JJ
8691	4363	18	esteem	esteem	NN
8691	4363	19	.	.	.
8691	4364	1	When	when	WRB
8691	4364	2	those	those	DT
8691	4364	3	of	of	IN
8691	4364	4	the	the	DT
8691	4364	5	former	former	JJ
8691	4364	6	seemed	seem	VBD
8691	4364	7	to	to	TO
8691	4364	8	trench	trench	VB
8691	4364	9	on	on	IN
8691	4364	10	the	the	DT
8691	4364	11	fields	field	NNS
8691	4364	12	of	of	IN
8691	4364	13	State	State	NNP
8691	4364	14	sovereignty	sovereignty	NN
8691	4364	15	,	,	,
8691	4364	16	particularly	particularly	RB
8691	4364	17	in	in	IN
8691	4364	18	the	the	DT
8691	4364	19	South	South	NNP
8691	4364	20	,	,	,
8691	4364	21	the	the	DT
8691	4364	22	inroad	inroad	NN
8691	4364	23	was	be	VBD
8691	4364	24	resented	resent	VBN
8691	4364	25	.	.	.
8691	4365	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4365	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4365	3	:	:	:
8691	4365	4	See	see	VB
8691	4365	5	letters	letter	NNS
8691	4365	6	of	of	IN
8691	4365	7	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	4365	8	alluding	allude	VBG
8691	4365	9	to	to	IN
8691	4365	10	this	this	DT
8691	4365	11	,	,	,
8691	4365	12	in	in	IN
8691	4365	13	"	"	``
8691	4365	14	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNP
8691	4365	15	of	of	IN
8691	4365	16	the	the	DT
8691	4365	17	Massachusetts	Massachusetts	NNP
8691	4365	18	Historical	Historical	NNP
8691	4365	19	Society	Society	NNP
8691	4365	20	,	,	,
8691	4365	21	"	"	''
8691	4365	22	2d	2d	NNP
8691	4365	23	Series	Series	NNP
8691	4365	24	,	,	,
8691	4365	25	XIV	XIV	NNP
8691	4365	26	,	,	,
8691	4365	27	325	325	CD
8691	4365	28	,	,	,
8691	4365	29	327	327	CD
8691	4365	30	,	,	,
8691	4365	31	329	329	CD
8691	4365	32	,	,	,
8691	4365	33	330	330	CD
8691	4365	34	.	.	.
8691	4365	35	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4366	1	In	in	IN
8691	4366	2	one	one	CD
8691	4366	3	Southern	Southern	NNP
8691	4366	4	State	State	NNP
8691	4366	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4366	6	was	be	VBD
8691	4366	7	even	even	RB
8691	4366	8	opposed	oppose	VBN
8691	4366	9	by	by	IN
8691	4366	10	force	force	NN
8691	4366	11	.	.	.
8691	4367	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4367	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4367	3	:	:	:
8691	4367	4	See	see	VB
8691	4367	5	Chap	Chap	NNP
8691	4367	6	.	.	.
8691	4368	1	X.	X.	NNP
8691	4368	2	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4369	1	As	as	RB
8691	4369	2	late	late	RB
8691	4369	3	as	as	IN
8691	4369	4	1854	1854	CD
8691	4369	5	the	the	DT
8691	4369	6	supremacy	supremacy	NN
8691	4369	7	of	of	IN
8691	4369	8	the	the	DT
8691	4369	9	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4369	10	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4369	11	of	of	IN
8691	4369	12	the	the	DT
8691	4369	13	United	United	NNP
8691	4369	14	States	States	NNP
8691	4369	15	in	in	IN
8691	4369	16	expounding	expound	VBG
8691	4369	17	the	the	DT
8691	4369	18	federal	federal	JJ
8691	4369	19	Constitution	Constitution	NNP
8691	4369	20	was	be	VBD
8691	4369	21	contested	contest	VBN
8691	4369	22	by	by	IN
8691	4369	23	the	the	DT
8691	4369	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	4369	25	of	of	IN
8691	4369	26	a	a	DT
8691	4369	27	Northern	Northern	NNP
8691	4369	28	State	State	NNP
8691	4369	29	;	;	:
8691	4369	30	there	there	EX
8691	4369	31	also	also	RB
8691	4369	32	in	in	IN
8691	4369	33	a	a	DT
8691	4369	34	case	case	NN
8691	4369	35	growing	grow	VBG
8691	4369	36	out	out	IN
8691	4369	37	of	of	IN
8691	4369	38	the	the	DT
8691	4369	39	system	system	NN
8691	4369	40	of	of	IN
8691	4369	41	slavery	slavery	NN
8691	4369	42	.	.	.
8691	4370	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4370	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4370	3	:	:	:
8691	4370	4	Ableman	Ableman	NNP
8691	4370	5	_	_	NNP
8691	4370	6	v.	v.	IN
8691	4370	7	_	_	NNP
8691	4370	8	Booth	Booth	NNP
8691	4370	9	,	,	,
8691	4370	10	21	21	CD
8691	4370	11	Howard	Howard	NNP
8691	4370	12	's	's	POS
8691	4370	13	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	4370	14	,	,	,
8691	4370	15	506	506	CD
8691	4370	16	.	.	.
8691	4370	17	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4371	1	Another	another	DT
8691	4371	2	decision	decision	NN
8691	4371	3	by	by	IN
8691	4371	4	the	the	DT
8691	4371	5	same	same	JJ
8691	4371	6	tribunal	tribunal	NN
8691	4371	7	of	of	IN
8691	4371	8	a	a	DT
8691	4371	9	similar	similar	JJ
8691	4371	10	nature	nature	NN
8691	4371	11	--	--	:
8691	4371	12	that	that	IN
8691	4371	13	in	in	IN
8691	4371	14	the	the	DT
8691	4371	15	Dred	Dred	NNP
8691	4371	16	Scott	Scott	NNP
8691	4371	17	case[Footnote	case[Footnote	''
8691	4371	18	:	:	:
8691	4371	19	Dred	Dred	NNP
8691	4371	20	Scott	Scott	NNP
8691	4371	21	_	_	NNP
8691	4371	22	v.	v.	IN
8691	4371	23	_	_	NNP
8691	4371	24	Sandford	Sandford	NNP
8691	4371	25	,	,	,
8691	4371	26	19	19	CD
8691	4371	27	Howard	Howard	NNP
8691	4371	28	's	's	POS
8691	4371	29	Reports	Reports	NNPS
8691	4371	30	,	,	,
8691	4371	31	393	393	CD
8691	4371	32	.	.	.
8691	4371	33	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4372	1	--greatly	--greatly	RB
8691	4372	2	strengthened	strengthen	VBD
8691	4372	3	the	the	DT
8691	4372	4	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	4372	5	of	of	IN
8691	4372	6	the	the	DT
8691	4372	7	Southern	southern	JJ
8691	4372	8	people	people	NNS
8691	4372	9	in	in	IN
8691	4372	10	the	the	DT
8691	4372	11	federal	federal	JJ
8691	4372	12	courts	court	NNS
8691	4372	13	,	,	,
8691	4372	14	and	and	CC
8691	4372	15	weakened	weaken	VBD
8691	4372	16	that	that	DT
8691	4372	17	of	of	IN
8691	4372	18	the	the	DT
8691	4372	19	North	North	NNP
8691	4372	20	.	.	.
8691	4373	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4373	2	did	do	VBD
8691	4373	3	much	much	JJ
8691	4373	4	to	to	TO
8691	4373	5	bring	bring	VB
8691	4373	6	on	on	RP
8691	4373	7	the	the	DT
8691	4373	8	Civil	Civil	NNP
8691	4373	9	War	War	NNP
8691	4373	10	,	,	,
8691	4373	11	but	but	CC
8691	4373	12	the	the	DT
8691	4373	13	result	result	NN
8691	4373	14	of	of	IN
8691	4373	15	that	that	DT
8691	4373	16	struggle	struggle	NN
8691	4373	17	was	be	VBD
8691	4373	18	to	to	TO
8691	4373	19	confirm	confirm	VB
8691	4373	20	the	the	DT
8691	4373	21	authority	authority	NN
8691	4373	22	not	not	RB
8691	4373	23	only	only	RB
8691	4373	24	of	of	IN
8691	4373	25	the	the	DT
8691	4373	26	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4373	27	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4373	28	but	but	CC
8691	4373	29	of	of	IN
8691	4373	30	the	the	DT
8691	4373	31	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4373	32	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4373	33	as	as	IN
8691	4373	34	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4373	35	was	be	VBD
8691	4373	36	under	under	IN
8691	4373	37	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	4373	38	and	and	CC
8691	4373	39	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4373	40	original	original	JJ
8691	4373	41	associates	associate	NNS
8691	4373	42	.	.	.
8691	4374	1	In	in	IN
8691	4374	2	1901	1901	CD
8691	4374	3	,	,	,
8691	4374	4	the	the	DT
8691	4374	5	centenary	centenary	NN
8691	4374	6	of	of	IN
8691	4374	7	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4374	8	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	4374	9	was	be	VBD
8691	4374	10	celebrated	celebrate	VBN
8691	4374	11	all	all	RB
8691	4374	12	over	over	IN
8691	4374	13	the	the	DT
8691	4374	14	country	country	NN
8691	4374	15	,	,	,
8691	4374	16	North	North	NNP
8691	4374	17	and	and	CC
8691	4374	18	South	South	NNP
8691	4374	19	.	.	.
8691	4375	1	Such	such	PDT
8691	4375	2	a	a	DT
8691	4375	3	tribute	tribute	NN
8691	4375	4	was	be	VBD
8691	4375	5	never	never	RB
8691	4375	6	paid	pay	VBN
8691	4375	7	before	before	RB
8691	4375	8	in	in	IN
8691	4375	9	any	any	DT
8691	4375	10	country	country	NN
8691	4375	11	to	to	IN
8691	4375	12	the	the	DT
8691	4375	13	memory	memory	NN
8691	4375	14	of	of	IN
8691	4375	15	a	a	DT
8691	4375	16	judge	judge	NN
8691	4375	17	.	.	.
8691	4376	1	His	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4376	2	services	service	NNS
8691	4376	3	were	be	VBD
8691	4376	4	commemorated	commemorate	VBN
8691	4376	5	for	for	IN
8691	4376	6	the	the	DT
8691	4376	7	very	very	JJ
8691	4376	8	reason	reason	NN
8691	4376	9	that	that	WDT
8691	4376	10	led	lead	VBD
8691	4376	11	Jefferson	Jefferson	NNP
8691	4376	12	to	to	TO
8691	4376	13	depreciate	depreciate	VB
8691	4376	14	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4376	15	--	--	:
8691	4376	16	because	because	IN
8691	4376	17	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4376	18	led	lead	VBD
8691	4376	19	to	to	IN
8691	4376	20	the	the	DT
8691	4376	21	establishment	establishment	NN
8691	4376	22	of	of	IN
8691	4376	23	a	a	DT
8691	4376	24	strong	strong	JJ
8691	4376	25	national	national	JJ
8691	4376	26	government	government	NN
8691	4376	27	with	with	IN
8691	4376	28	a	a	DT
8691	4376	29	controlling	control	VBG
8691	4376	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4376	31	authority	authority	NN
8691	4376	32	adequate	adequate	JJ
8691	4376	33	to	to	TO
8691	4376	34	protect	protect	VB
8691	4376	35	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4376	36	within	within	IN
8691	4376	37	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4376	38	sphere	sphere	NN
8691	4376	39	from	from	IN
8691	4376	40	interference	interference	NN
8691	4376	41	or	or	CC
8691	4376	42	obstruction	obstruction	NN
8691	4376	43	in	in	IN
8691	4376	44	any	any	DT
8691	4376	45	way	way	NN
8691	4376	46	by	by	IN
8691	4376	47	any	any	DT
8691	4376	48	State	State	NNP
8691	4376	49	.	.	.
8691	4377	1	Confidence	confidence	NN
8691	4377	2	in	in	IN
8691	4377	3	the	the	DT
8691	4377	4	State	State	NNP
8691	4377	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	4377	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	4377	7	also	also	RB
8691	4377	8	been	be	VBN
8691	4377	9	strengthened	strengthen	VBN
8691	4377	10	during	during	IN
8691	4377	11	the	the	DT
8691	4377	12	last	last	JJ
8691	4377	13	century	century	NN
8691	4377	14	.	.	.
8691	4378	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4378	2	was	be	VBD
8691	4378	3	greatly	greatly	RB
8691	4378	4	shaken	shake	VBN
8691	4378	5	at	at	IN
8691	4378	6	the	the	DT
8691	4378	7	time	time	NN
8691	4378	8	of	of	IN
8691	4378	9	the	the	DT
8691	4378	10	fall	fall	NN
8691	4378	11	of	of	IN
8691	4378	12	the	the	DT
8691	4378	13	Federalists	Federalists	NNPS
8691	4378	14	.	.	.
8691	4379	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4379	2	had	have	VBD
8691	4379	3	lost	lose	VBN
8691	4379	4	the	the	DT
8691	4379	5	executive	executive	JJ
8691	4379	6	and	and	CC
8691	4379	7	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	4379	8	power	power	NN
8691	4379	9	,	,	,
8691	4379	10	but	but	CC
8691	4379	11	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4379	12	retained	retain	VBD
8691	4379	13	the	the	DT
8691	4379	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4379	15	,	,	,
8691	4379	16	and	and	CC
8691	4379	17	the	the	DT
8691	4379	18	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
8691	4379	19	found	find	VBD
8691	4379	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4379	21	hard	hard	JJ
8691	4379	22	to	to	TO
8691	4379	23	tolerate	tolerate	VB
8691	4379	24	courts	court	NNS
8691	4379	25	that	that	WDT
8691	4379	26	represented	represent	VBD
8691	4379	27	the	the	DT
8691	4379	28	political	political	JJ
8691	4379	29	ideas	idea	NNS
8691	4379	30	of	of	IN
8691	4379	31	a	a	DT
8691	4379	32	former	former	JJ
8691	4379	33	generation	generation	NN
8691	4379	34	.	.	.
8691	4380	1	This	this	DT
8691	4380	2	continued	continue	VBD
8691	4380	3	long	long	RB
8691	4380	4	after	after	IN
8691	4380	5	the	the	DT
8691	4380	6	extinction	extinction	NN
8691	4380	7	of	of	IN
8691	4380	8	the	the	DT
8691	4380	9	Federalist	Federalist	NNP
8691	4380	10	party	party	NN
8691	4380	11	,	,	,
8691	4380	12	and	and	CC
8691	4380	13	often	often	RB
8691	4380	14	extended	extend	VBD
8691	4380	15	to	to	IN
8691	4380	16	distrust	distrust	NN
8691	4380	17	of	of	IN
8691	4380	18	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4380	19	elected	elect	VBN
8691	4380	20	by	by	IN
8691	4380	21	the	the	DT
8691	4380	22	Republicans	Republicans	NNPS
8691	4380	23	who	who	WP
8691	4380	24	were	be	VBD
8691	4380	25	thought	think	VBN
8691	4380	26	to	to	TO
8691	4380	27	have	have	VB
8691	4380	28	become	become	VBN
8691	4380	29	affected	affect	VBN
8691	4380	30	by	by	IN
8691	4380	31	the	the	DT
8691	4380	32	influence	influence	NN
8691	4380	33	of	of	IN
8691	4380	34	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4380	35	senior	senior	JJ
8691	4380	36	associates	associate	NNS
8691	4380	37	.	.	.
8691	4381	1	In	in	IN
8691	4381	2	the	the	DT
8691	4381	3	New	New	NNP
8691	4381	4	York	York	NNP
8691	4381	5	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	4381	6	convention	convention	NN
8691	4381	7	of	of	IN
8691	4381	8	1821	1821	CD
8691	4381	9	,	,	,
8691	4381	10	Peter	Peter	NNP
8691	4381	11	R.	R.	NNP
8691	4381	12	Livingston	Livingston	NNP
8691	4381	13	appealed	appeal	VBD
8691	4381	14	to	to	IN
8691	4381	15	the	the	DT
8691	4381	16	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4381	17	present	present	JJ
8691	4381	18	to	to	TO
8691	4381	19	say	say	VB
8691	4381	20	"	"	``
8691	4381	21	whether	whether	IN
8691	4381	22	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4381	23	has	have	VBZ
8691	4381	24	not	not	RB
8691	4381	25	been	be	VBN
8691	4381	26	the	the	DT
8691	4381	27	case	case	NN
8691	4381	28	that	that	IN
8691	4381	29	when	when	WRB
8691	4381	30	a	a	DT
8691	4381	31	man	man	NN
8691	4381	32	in	in	IN
8691	4381	33	the	the	DT
8691	4381	34	country	country	NN
8691	4381	35	of	of	IN
8691	4381	36	any	any	DT
8691	4381	37	political	political	JJ
8691	4381	38	standing	standing	NN
8691	4381	39	has	have	VBZ
8691	4381	40	had	have	VBN
8691	4381	41	a	a	DT
8691	4381	42	suit	suit	NN
8691	4381	43	depending	depend	VBG
8691	4381	44	at	at	IN
8691	4381	45	a	a	DT
8691	4381	46	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	4381	47	court	court	NN
8691	4381	48	,	,	,
8691	4381	49	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4381	50	has	have	VBZ
8691	4381	51	not	not	RB
8691	4381	52	consulted	consult	VBN
8691	4381	53	with	with	IN
8691	4381	54	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4381	55	counsel	counsel	NN
8691	4381	56	to	to	TO
8691	4381	57	know	know	VB
8691	4381	58	what	what	WP
8691	4381	59	judge	judge	NN
8691	4381	60	was	be	VBD
8691	4381	61	to	to	TO
8691	4381	62	preside	preside	VB
8691	4381	63	at	at	IN
8691	4381	64	the	the	DT
8691	4381	65	circuit	circuit	NN
8691	4381	66	;	;	:
8691	4381	67	and	and	CC
8691	4381	68	whether	whether	IN
8691	4381	69	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4381	70	has	have	VBZ
8691	4381	71	not	not	RB
8691	4381	72	been	be	VBN
8691	4381	73	frequently	frequently	RB
8691	4381	74	told	tell	VBN
8691	4381	75	that	that	IN
8691	4381	76	a	a	DT
8691	4381	77	political	political	JJ
8691	4381	78	judge	judge	NN
8691	4381	79	was	be	VBD
8691	4381	80	to	to	TO
8691	4381	81	preside	preside	VB
8691	4381	82	and	and	CC
8691	4381	83	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4381	84	would	would	MD
8691	4381	85	not	not	RB
8691	4381	86	do	do	VB
8691	4381	87	to	to	TO
8691	4381	88	let	let	VB
8691	4381	89	the	the	DT
8691	4381	90	cause	cause	NN
8691	4381	91	come	come	VB
8691	4381	92	on	on	RP
8691	4381	93	.	.	.
8691	4382	1	"	"	``
8691	4382	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4382	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4382	4	:	:	:
8691	4382	5	Reports	report	NNS
8691	4382	6	of	of	IN
8691	4382	7	the	the	DT
8691	4382	8	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNPS
8691	4382	9	and	and	CC
8691	4382	10	Debates	Debates	NNPS
8691	4382	11	of	of	IN
8691	4382	12	the	the	DT
8691	4382	13	Convention	Convention	NNP
8691	4382	14	of	of	IN
8691	4382	15	1821	1821	CD
8691	4382	16	,	,	,
8691	4382	17	618	618	CD
8691	4382	18	.	.	.
8691	4382	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4383	1	Who	who	WP
8691	4383	2	,	,	,
8691	4383	3	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4383	4	asked	ask	VBD
8691	4383	5	,	,	,
8691	4383	6	were	be	VBD
8691	4383	7	the	the	DT
8691	4383	8	present	present	JJ
8691	4383	9	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4383	10	of	of	IN
8691	4383	11	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4383	12	Supreme	Supreme	NNP
8691	4383	13	Court	Court	NNP
8691	4383	14	?	?	.
8691	4384	1	"	"	``
8691	4384	2	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	4384	3	Spencer	Spencer	NNP
8691	4384	4	came	come	VBD
8691	4384	5	into	into	IN
8691	4384	6	office	office	NN
8691	4384	7	under	under	IN
8691	4384	8	a	a	DT
8691	4384	9	republican	republican	JJ
8691	4384	10	administration	administration	NN
8691	4384	11	;	;	:
8691	4384	12	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	4384	13	Van	Van	NNP
8691	4384	14	Ness	Ness	NNP
8691	4384	15	was	be	VBD
8691	4384	16	appointed	appoint	VBN
8691	4384	17	by	by	IN
8691	4384	18	a	a	DT
8691	4384	19	mongrel	mongrel	NNP
8691	4384	20	council	council	NN
8691	4384	21	;	;	:
8691	4384	22	and	and	CC
8691	4384	23	the	the	DT
8691	4384	24	elevation	elevation	NN
8691	4384	25	to	to	IN
8691	4384	26	the	the	DT
8691	4384	27	bench	bench	NN
8691	4384	28	of	of	IN
8691	4384	29	Judge	Judge	NNP
8691	4384	30	Platt	Platt	NNP
8691	4384	31	was	be	VBD
8691	4384	32	occasioned	occasion	VBN
8691	4384	33	by	by	IN
8691	4384	34	the	the	DT
8691	4384	35	defection	defection	NN
8691	4384	36	from	from	IN
8691	4384	37	the	the	DT
8691	4384	38	Republican	republican	JJ
8691	4384	39	ranks	rank	NNS
8691	4384	40	of	of	IN
8691	4384	41	a	a	DT
8691	4384	42	man	man	NN
8691	4384	43	elected	elect	VBN
8691	4384	44	to	to	IN
8691	4384	45	the	the	DT
8691	4384	46	Senate	Senate	NNP
8691	4384	47	from	from	IN
8691	4384	48	the	the	DT
8691	4384	49	county	county	NN
8691	4384	50	of	of	IN
8691	4384	51	Dutchess	Dutchess	NNP
8691	4384	52	,	,	,
8691	4384	53	who	who	WP
8691	4384	54	acted	act	VBD
8691	4384	55	the	the	DT
8691	4384	56	part	part	NN
8691	4384	57	of	of	IN
8691	4384	58	a	a	DT
8691	4384	59	political	political	JJ
8691	4384	60	Judas	Judas	NNP
8691	4384	61	,	,	,
8691	4384	62	and	and	CC
8691	4384	63	sold	sell	VBD
8691	4384	64	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4384	65	party	party	NN
8691	4384	66	.	.	.
8691	4385	1	We	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4385	2	have	have	VBP
8691	4385	3	been	be	VBN
8691	4385	4	bought	buy	VBN
8691	4385	5	and	and	CC
8691	4385	6	sold	sell	VBN
8691	4385	7	--	--	:
8691	4385	8	there	there	EX
8691	4385	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	4385	10	not	not	RB
8691	4385	11	one	one	CD
8691	4385	12	of	of	IN
8691	4385	13	these	these	DT
8691	4385	14	men	man	NNS
8691	4385	15	who	who	WP
8691	4385	16	would	would	MD
8691	4385	17	have	have	VB
8691	4385	18	been	be	VBN
8691	4385	19	on	on	IN
8691	4385	20	the	the	DT
8691	4385	21	bench	bench	NN
8691	4385	22	if	if	IN
8691	4385	23	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4385	24	administration	administration	NN
8691	4385	25	had	have	VBD
8691	4385	26	been	be	VBN
8691	4385	27	truly	truly	RB
8691	4385	28	republican	republican	JJ
8691	4385	29	....	....	.
8691	4386	1	There	there	EX
8691	4386	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4386	3	not	not	RB
8691	4386	4	a	a	DT
8691	4386	5	man	man	NN
8691	4386	6	in	in	IN
8691	4386	7	this	this	DT
8691	4386	8	Convention	Convention	NNP
8691	4386	9	who	who	WP
8691	4386	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	4386	11	a	a	DT
8691	4386	12	republican	republican	NN
8691	4386	13	of	of	IN
8691	4386	14	any	any	DT
8691	4386	15	standing	standing	NN
8691	4386	16	or	or	CC
8691	4386	17	character	character	NN
8691	4386	18	who	who	WP
8691	4386	19	would	would	MD
8691	4386	20	like	like	VB
8691	4386	21	to	to	TO
8691	4386	22	have	have	VB
8691	4386	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4386	24	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	4386	25	or	or	CC
8691	4386	26	property	property	NN
8691	4386	27	placed	place	VBN
8691	4386	28	in	in	IN
8691	4386	29	the	the	DT
8691	4386	30	hands	hand	NNS
8691	4386	31	of	of	IN
8691	4386	32	a	a	DT
8691	4386	33	political	political	JJ
8691	4386	34	judge	judge	NN
8691	4386	35	of	of	IN
8691	4386	36	a	a	DT
8691	4386	37	different	different	JJ
8691	4386	38	party	party	NN
8691	4386	39	.	.	.
8691	4387	1	"	"	``
8691	4387	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4387	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4387	4	:	:	:
8691	4387	5	Reports	report	NNS
8691	4387	6	of	of	IN
8691	4387	7	the	the	DT
8691	4387	8	Proceedings	Proceedings	NNPS
8691	4387	9	and	and	CC
8691	4387	10	Debates	Debates	NNPS
8691	4387	11	of	of	IN
8691	4387	12	the	the	DT
8691	4387	13	Convention	Convention	NNP
8691	4387	14	of	of	IN
8691	4387	15	1821	1821	CD
8691	4387	16	,	,	,
8691	4387	17	620	620	CD
8691	4387	18	.	.	.
8691	4387	19	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4388	1	The	the	DT
8691	4388	2	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	4388	3	may	may	MD
8691	4388	4	also	also	RB
8691	4388	5	have	have	VB
8691	4388	6	suffered	suffer	VBN
8691	4388	7	somewhat	somewhat	RB
8691	4388	8	in	in	IN
8691	4388	9	the	the	DT
8691	4388	10	esteem	esteem	NN
8691	4388	11	of	of	IN
8691	4388	12	dispassionate	dispassionate	JJ
8691	4388	13	observers	observer	NNS
8691	4388	14	on	on	IN
8691	4388	15	account	account	NN
8691	4388	16	of	of	IN
8691	4388	17	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4388	18	attitude	attitude	NN
8691	4388	19	in	in	IN
8691	4388	20	many	many	JJ
8691	4388	21	of	of	IN
8691	4388	22	the	the	DT
8691	4388	23	States	States	NNPS
8691	4388	24	toward	toward	IN
8691	4388	25	the	the	DT
8691	4388	26	financial	financial	JJ
8691	4388	27	enterprises	enterprise	NNS
8691	4388	28	in	in	IN
8691	4388	29	corporate	corporate	JJ
8691	4388	30	form	form	NN
8691	4388	31	,	,	,
8691	4388	32	in	in	IN
8691	4388	33	which	which	WDT
8691	4388	34	so	so	RB
8691	4388	35	much	much	JJ
8691	4388	36	money	money	NN
8691	4388	37	was	be	VBD
8691	4388	38	made	make	VBN
8691	4388	39	and	and	CC
8691	4388	40	lost	lose	VBN
8691	4388	41	in	in	IN
8691	4388	42	the	the	DT
8691	4388	43	first	first	JJ
8691	4388	44	third	third	NN
8691	4388	45	of	of	IN
8691	4388	46	the	the	DT
8691	4388	47	nineteenth	nineteenth	JJ
8691	4388	48	century	century	NN
8691	4388	49	.	.	.
8691	4389	1	In	in	IN
8691	4389	2	commenting	comment	VBG
8691	4389	3	on	on	IN
8691	4389	4	a	a	DT
8691	4389	5	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4389	6	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	4389	7	in	in	IN
8691	4389	8	a	a	DT
8691	4389	9	Southern	southern	JJ
8691	4389	10	bank	bank	NN
8691	4389	11	case	case	NN
8691	4389	12	,	,	,
8691	4389	13	the	the	DT
8691	4389	14	author	author	NN
8691	4389	15	of	of	IN
8691	4389	16	one	one	CD
8691	4389	17	of	of	IN
8691	4389	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4389	19	leading	lead	VBG
8691	4389	20	American	american	JJ
8691	4389	21	legal	legal	JJ
8691	4389	22	treatises	treatise	NNS
8691	4389	23	,	,	,
8691	4389	24	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4389	25	once	once	RB
8691	4389	26	a	a	DT
8691	4389	27	judge	judge	NN
8691	4389	28	,	,	,
8691	4389	29	has	have	VBZ
8691	4389	30	referred	refer	VBN
8691	4389	31	to	to	IN
8691	4389	32	this	this	DT
8691	4389	33	period	period	NN
8691	4389	34	in	in	IN
8691	4389	35	these	these	DT
8691	4389	36	plain	plain	JJ
8691	4389	37	words	word	NNS
8691	4389	38	:	:	:
8691	4389	39	Decisions	decision	NNS
8691	4389	40	of	of	IN
8691	4389	41	this	this	DT
8691	4389	42	kind	kind	NN
8691	4389	43	,	,	,
8691	4389	44	which	which	WDT
8691	4389	45	were	be	VBD
8691	4389	46	not	not	RB
8691	4389	47	infrequent	infrequent	JJ
8691	4389	48	in	in	IN
8691	4389	49	the	the	DT
8691	4389	50	era	era	NN
8691	4389	51	of	of	IN
8691	4389	52	State	State	NNP
8691	4389	53	banks	bank	NNS
8691	4389	54	of	of	IN
8691	4389	55	issue	issue	NN
8691	4389	56	,	,	,
8691	4389	57	can	can	MD
8691	4389	58	only	only	RB
8691	4389	59	be	be	VB
8691	4389	60	"	"	``
8691	4389	61	reconciled	reconcile	VBN
8691	4389	62	"	"	''
8691	4389	63	with	with	IN
8691	4389	64	modern	modern	JJ
8691	4389	65	holdings	holding	NNS
8691	4389	66	in	in	IN
8691	4389	67	view	view	NN
8691	4389	68	of	of	IN
8691	4389	69	the	the	DT
8691	4389	70	well	well	RB
8691	4389	71	-	-	HYPH
8691	4389	72	known	know	VBN
8691	4389	73	fact	fact	NN
8691	4389	74	that	that	IN
8691	4389	75	nearly	nearly	RB
8691	4389	76	all	all	PDT
8691	4389	77	the	the	DT
8691	4389	78	politicians	politician	NNS
8691	4389	79	were	be	VBD
8691	4389	80	creditors	creditor	NNS
8691	4389	81	of	of	IN
8691	4389	82	those	those	DT
8691	4389	83	political	political	JJ
8691	4389	84	banks	bank	NNS
8691	4389	85	,	,	,
8691	4389	86	by	by	IN
8691	4389	87	notes	note	NNS
8691	4389	88	often	often	RB
8691	4389	89	renewed	renew	VBD
8691	4389	90	,	,	,
8691	4389	91	at	at	IN
8691	4389	92	the	the	DT
8691	4389	93	time	time	NN
8691	4389	94	when	when	WRB
8691	4389	95	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4389	96	finally	finally	RB
8691	4389	97	suspended	suspend	VBD
8691	4389	98	,	,	,
8691	4389	99	and	and	CC
8691	4389	100	that	that	IN
8691	4389	101	all	all	PDT
8691	4389	102	the	the	DT
8691	4389	103	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4389	104	were	be	VBD
8691	4389	105	politicians	politician	NNS
8691	4389	106	.	.	.
8691	4390	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4390	2	can	can	MD
8691	4390	3	hardly	hardly	RB
8691	4390	4	be	be	VB
8691	4390	5	doubted	doubt	VBN
8691	4390	6	that	that	IN
8691	4390	7	in	in	IN
8691	4390	8	many	many	JJ
8691	4390	9	of	of	IN
8691	4390	10	those	those	DT
8691	4390	11	semi	semi	JJ
8691	4390	12	-	-	JJ
8691	4390	13	barbarous	barbarous	JJ
8691	4390	14	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	4390	15	the	the	DT
8691	4390	16	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4390	17	were	be	VBD
8691	4390	18	either	either	CC
8691	4390	19	rendering	render	VBG
8691	4390	20	decisions	decision	NNS
8691	4390	21	to	to	TO
8691	4390	22	exonerate	exonerate	VB
8691	4390	23	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4390	24	from	from	IN
8691	4390	25	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4390	26	liabilities	liability	NNS
8691	4390	27	to	to	IN
8691	4390	28	the	the	DT
8691	4390	29	insolvent	insolvent	JJ
8691	4390	30	banks	bank	NNS
8691	4390	31	or	or	CC
8691	4390	32	to	to	TO
8691	4390	33	exonerate	exonerate	VB
8691	4390	34	powerful	powerful	JJ
8691	4390	35	and	and	CC
8691	4390	36	influential	influential	JJ
8691	4390	37	politicians	politician	NNS
8691	4390	38	upon	upon	IN
8691	4390	39	whom	whom	WP
8691	4390	40	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4390	41	depended	depend	VBD
8691	4390	42	for	for	IN
8691	4390	43	the	the	DT
8691	4390	44	tenure	tenure	NN
8691	4390	45	of	of	IN
8691	4390	46	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4390	47	offices	office	NNS
8691	4390	48	.	.	.
8691	4391	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4391	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4391	3	:	:	:
8691	4391	4	Thompson	Thompson	NNP
8691	4391	5	on	on	IN
8691	4391	6	"	"	``
8691	4391	7	Private	Private	NNP
8691	4391	8	Corporations	corporation	NNS
8691	4391	9	,	,	,
8691	4391	10	"	"	''
8691	4391	11	V	v	NN
8691	4391	12	,	,	,
8691	4391	13	p.	p.	NN
8691	4392	1	5306	5306	CD
8691	4392	2	.	.	.
8691	4392	3	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4393	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4393	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4393	3	quite	quite	RB
8691	4393	4	probable	probable	JJ
8691	4393	5	that	that	IN
8691	4393	6	an	an	DT
8691	4393	7	insensible	insensible	JJ
8691	4393	8	bias	bias	NN
8691	4393	9	in	in	IN
8691	4393	10	favor	favor	NN
8691	4393	11	of	of	IN
8691	4393	12	friends	friend	NNS
8691	4393	13	and	and	CC
8691	4393	14	neighbors	neighbor	NNS
8691	4393	15	may	may	MD
8691	4393	16	have	have	VB
8691	4393	17	had	have	VBN
8691	4393	18	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4393	19	share	share	NN
8691	4393	20	in	in	IN
8691	4393	21	producing	produce	VBG
8691	4393	22	the	the	DT
8691	4393	23	judgments	judgment	NNS
8691	4393	24	to	to	TO
8691	4393	25	which	which	WDT
8691	4393	26	reference	reference	NN
8691	4393	27	was	be	VBD
8691	4393	28	thus	thus	RB
8691	4393	29	made	make	VBN
8691	4393	30	,	,	,
8691	4393	31	but	but	CC
8691	4393	32	quite	quite	RB
8691	4393	33	improbable	improbable	JJ
8691	4393	34	that	that	IN
8691	4393	35	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4393	36	were	be	VBD
8691	4393	37	the	the	DT
8691	4393	38	fruit	fruit	NN
8691	4393	39	of	of	IN
8691	4393	40	baser	baser	NNP
8691	4393	41	motives	motive	NNS
8691	4393	42	.	.	.
8691	4394	1	Independently	independently	RB
8691	4394	2	of	of	IN
8691	4394	3	other	other	JJ
8691	4394	4	considerations	consideration	NNS
8691	4394	5	,	,	,
8691	4394	6	every	every	DT
8691	4394	7	judge	judge	NN
8691	4394	8	is	be	VBZ
8691	4394	9	watched	watch	VBN
8691	4394	10	by	by	IN
8691	4394	11	sharp	sharp	JJ
8691	4394	12	eyes	eye	NNS
8691	4394	13	in	in	IN
8691	4394	14	every	every	DT
8691	4394	15	step	step	NN
8691	4394	16	which	which	WDT
8691	4394	17	he	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4394	18	may	may	MD
8691	4394	19	take	take	VB
8691	4394	20	in	in	RP
8691	4394	21	the	the	DT
8691	4394	22	progress	progress	NN
8691	4394	23	of	of	IN
8691	4394	24	a	a	DT
8691	4394	25	cause	cause	NN
8691	4394	26	.	.	.
8691	4395	1	He	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4395	2	acts	act	VBZ
8691	4395	3	in	in	IN
8691	4395	4	view	view	NN
8691	4395	5	of	of	IN
8691	4395	6	the	the	DT
8691	4395	7	bar	bar	NN
8691	4395	8	at	at	IN
8691	4395	9	large	large	JJ
8691	4395	10	,	,	,
8691	4395	11	and	and	CC
8691	4395	12	of	of	IN
8691	4395	13	two	two	CD
8691	4395	14	of	of	IN
8691	4395	15	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4395	16	number	number	NN
8691	4395	17	in	in	IN
8691	4395	18	particular	particular	JJ
8691	4395	19	,	,	,
8691	4395	20	one	one	CD
8691	4395	21	of	of	IN
8691	4395	22	whom	whom	WP
8691	4395	23	probably	probably	RB
8691	4395	24	will	will	MD
8691	4395	25	be	be	VB
8691	4395	26	disappointed	disappoint	VBN
8691	4395	27	by	by	IN
8691	4395	28	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4395	29	decision	decision	NN
8691	4395	30	,	,	,
8691	4395	31	and	and	CC
8691	4395	32	solicitous	solicitous	JJ
8691	4395	33	to	to	IN
8691	4395	34	ascertain	ascertain	NN
8691	4395	35	and	and	CC
8691	4395	36	employ	employ	VB
8691	4395	37	every	every	DT
8691	4395	38	reasonable	reasonable	JJ
8691	4395	39	ground	ground	NN
8691	4395	40	for	for	IN
8691	4395	41	overturning	overturn	VBG
8691	4395	42	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4395	43	.	.	.
8691	4396	1	The	the	DT
8691	4396	2	Bar	Bar	NNP
8691	4396	3	Association	Association	NNP
8691	4396	4	of	of	IN
8691	4396	5	the	the	DT
8691	4396	6	country	country	NN
8691	4396	7	have	have	VBP
8691	4396	8	exercised	exercise	VBN
8691	4396	9	a	a	DT
8691	4396	10	large	large	JJ
8691	4396	11	influence	influence	NN
8691	4396	12	during	during	IN
8691	4396	13	the	the	DT
8691	4396	14	past	past	JJ
8691	4396	15	thirty	thirty	CD
8691	4396	16	years	year	NNS
8691	4396	17	in	in	IN
8691	4396	18	maintaining	maintain	VBG
8691	4396	19	public	public	JJ
8691	4396	20	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	4396	21	in	in	IN
8691	4396	22	the	the	DT
8691	4396	23	purity	purity	NN
8691	4396	24	of	of	IN
8691	4396	25	the	the	DT
8691	4396	26	bench	bench	NN
8691	4396	27	.	.	.
8691	4397	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4397	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4397	3	extremely	extremely	RB
8691	4397	4	rare	rare	JJ
8691	4397	5	that	that	IN
8691	4397	6	suspicion	suspicion	NN
8691	4397	7	of	of	IN
8691	4397	8	corruption	corruption	NN
8691	4397	9	attaches	attach	VBZ
8691	4397	10	to	to	IN
8691	4397	11	a	a	DT
8691	4397	12	judge	judge	NN
8691	4397	13	;	;	,
8691	4397	14	and	and	CC
8691	4397	15	rarer	rare	JJR
8691	4397	16	still	still	RB
8691	4397	17	that	that	IN
8691	4397	18	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4397	19	attaches	attach	VBZ
8691	4397	20	justly	justly	RB
8691	4397	21	.	.	.
8691	4398	1	Jurors	juror	NNS
8691	4398	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4398	3	occasionally	occasionally	RB
8691	4398	4	found	find	VBN
8691	4398	5	who	who	WP
8691	4398	6	are	be	VBP
8691	4398	7	guilty	guilty	JJ
8691	4398	8	of	of	IN
8691	4398	9	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4398	10	,	,	,
8691	4398	11	and	and	CC
8691	4398	12	more	more	RBR
8691	4398	13	who	who	WP
8691	4398	14	,	,	,
8691	4398	15	without	without	IN
8691	4398	16	being	be	VBG
8691	4398	17	chargeable	chargeable	JJ
8691	4398	18	with	with	IN
8691	4398	19	so	so	RB
8691	4398	20	black	black	JJ
8691	4398	21	a	a	DT
8691	4398	22	crime	crime	NN
8691	4398	23	,	,	,
8691	4398	24	are	be	VBP
8691	4398	25	more	more	RBR
8691	4398	26	interested	interested	JJ
8691	4398	27	in	in	IN
8691	4398	28	serving	serve	VBG
8691	4398	29	a	a	DT
8691	4398	30	friend	friend	NN
8691	4398	31	than	than	IN
8691	4398	32	in	in	IN
8691	4398	33	doing	do	VBG
8691	4398	34	justice	justice	NN
8691	4398	35	.	.	.
8691	4399	1	As	as	IN
8691	4399	2	a	a	DT
8691	4399	3	whole	whole	NN
8691	4399	4	,	,	,
8691	4399	5	however	however	RB
8691	4399	6	,	,	,
8691	4399	7	American	american	JJ
8691	4399	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	4399	9	are	be	VBP
8691	4399	10	clean	clean	JJ
8691	4399	11	-	-	HYPH
8691	4399	12	handed	handed	JJ
8691	4399	13	throughout	throughout	RP
8691	4399	14	,	,	,
8691	4399	15	and	and	CC
8691	4399	16	the	the	DT
8691	4399	17	people	people	NNS
8691	4399	18	know	know	VBP
8691	4399	19	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4399	20	.	.	.
8691	4400	1	The	the	DT
8691	4400	2	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	4400	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	4400	4	been	be	VBN
8691	4400	5	popularized	popularize	VBN
8691	4400	6	in	in	IN
8691	4400	7	most	most	JJS
8691	4400	8	States	state	NNS
8691	4400	9	by	by	IN
8691	4400	10	constitutional	constitutional	JJ
8691	4400	11	provisions	provision	NNS
8691	4400	12	replacing	replace	VBG
8691	4400	13	tenure	tenure	NN
8691	4400	14	during	during	IN
8691	4400	15	good	good	JJ
8691	4400	16	behavior	behavior	NN
8691	4400	17	by	by	IN
8691	4400	18	stated	stated	JJ
8691	4400	19	terms	term	NNS
8691	4400	20	of	of	IN
8691	4400	21	years	year	NNS
8691	4400	22	,	,	,
8691	4400	23	and	and	CC
8691	4400	24	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	4400	25	by	by	IN
8691	4400	26	the	the	DT
8691	4400	27	Governor	Governor	NNP
8691	4400	28	or	or	CC
8691	4400	29	legislature	legislature	NN
8691	4400	30	by	by	IN
8691	4400	31	election	election	NN
8691	4400	32	by	by	IN
8691	4400	33	the	the	DT
8691	4400	34	people	people	NNS
8691	4400	35	.	.	.
8691	4401	1	The	the	DT
8691	4401	2	powers	power	NNS
8691	4401	3	of	of	IN
8691	4401	4	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4401	5	have	have	VBP
8691	4401	6	been	be	VBN
8691	4401	7	on	on	IN
8691	4401	8	the	the	DT
8691	4401	9	whole	whole	NN
8691	4401	10	increased	increase	VBD
8691	4401	11	.	.	.
8691	4402	1	The	the	DT
8691	4402	2	only	only	JJ
8691	4402	3	matter	matter	NN
8691	4402	4	in	in	IN
8691	4402	5	which	which	WDT
8691	4402	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4402	7	have	have	VBP
8691	4402	8	been	be	VBN
8691	4402	9	substantially	substantially	RB
8691	4402	10	cut	cut	VBN
8691	4402	11	down	down	RP
8691	4402	12	is	be	VBZ
8691	4402	13	that	that	DT
8691	4402	14	of	of	IN
8691	4402	15	punishment	punishment	NN
8691	4402	16	for	for	IN
8691	4402	17	contempt	contempt	NN
8691	4402	18	.	.	.
8691	4403	1	Serious	serious	JJ
8691	4403	2	attempts	attempt	NNS
8691	4403	3	have	have	VBP
8691	4403	4	been	be	VBN
8691	4403	5	made	make	VBN
8691	4403	6	to	to	TO
8691	4403	7	abridge	abridge	VB
8691	4403	8	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4403	9	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	4403	10	over	over	IN
8691	4403	11	injunctions	injunction	NNS
8691	4403	12	,	,	,
8691	4403	13	but	but	CC
8691	4403	14	without	without	IN
8691	4403	15	success	success	NN
8691	4403	16	.	.	.
8691	4404	1	These	these	DT
8691	4404	2	attacks	attack	NNS
8691	4404	3	have	have	VBP
8691	4404	4	come	come	VBN
8691	4404	5	from	from	IN
8691	4404	6	those	those	DT
8691	4404	7	representing	represent	VBG
8691	4404	8	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4404	9	labor	labor	NN
8691	4404	10	unions	union	NNS
8691	4404	11	.	.	.
8691	4405	1	The	the	DT
8691	4405	2	more	more	RBR
8691	4405	3	thorough	thorough	JJ
8691	4405	4	organization	organization	NN
8691	4405	5	of	of	IN
8691	4405	6	working	working	NN
8691	4405	7	-	-	HYPH
8691	4405	8	men	man	NNS
8691	4405	9	in	in	IN
8691	4405	10	all	all	DT
8691	4405	11	trades	trade	NNS
8691	4405	12	and	and	CC
8691	4405	13	callings	calling	NNS
8691	4405	14	during	during	IN
8691	4405	15	the	the	DT
8691	4405	16	last	last	JJ
8691	4405	17	half	half	JJ
8691	4405	18	century	century	NN
8691	4405	19	,	,	,
8691	4405	20	and	and	CC
8691	4405	21	the	the	DT
8691	4405	22	development	development	NN
8691	4405	23	of	of	IN
8691	4405	24	collectivism	collectivism	NNP
8691	4405	25	as	as	IN
8691	4405	26	a	a	DT
8691	4405	27	working	work	VBG
8691	4405	28	theory	theory	NN
8691	4405	29	,	,	,
8691	4405	30	have	have	VBP
8691	4405	31	produced	produce	VBN
8691	4405	32	a	a	DT
8691	4405	33	class	class	NN
8691	4405	34	of	of	IN
8691	4405	35	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	4405	36	among	among	IN
8691	4405	37	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4405	38	who	who	WP
8691	4405	39	regard	regard	VBP
8691	4405	40	the	the	DT
8691	4405	41	courts	court	NNS
8691	4405	42	as	as	IN
8691	4405	43	manned	man	VBN
8691	4405	44	by	by	IN
8691	4405	45	representatives	representative	NNS
8691	4405	46	of	of	IN
8691	4405	47	capital	capital	NN
8691	4405	48	and	and	CC
8691	4405	49	controlled	control	VBN
8691	4405	50	in	in	IN
8691	4405	51	the	the	DT
8691	4405	52	interests	interest	NNS
8691	4405	53	of	of	IN
8691	4405	54	capital	capital	NN
8691	4405	55	.	.	.
8691	4406	1	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4406	2	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4406	3	:	:	:
8691	4406	4	The	the	DT
8691	4406	5	number	number	NN
8691	4406	6	of	of	IN
8691	4406	7	the	the	DT
8691	4406	8	_	_	NNP
8691	4406	9	Pennsylvania	Pennsylvania	NNP
8691	4406	10	Grange	Grange	NNP
8691	4406	11	News	News	NNP
8691	4406	12	_	_	NNP
8691	4406	13	for	for	IN
8691	4406	14	Sept.	September	NNP
8691	4406	15	,	,	,
8691	4406	16	1904	1904	CD
8691	4406	17	,	,	,
8691	4406	18	states	state	VBZ
8691	4406	19	this	this	DT
8691	4406	20	view	view	NN
8691	4406	21	at	at	IN
8691	4406	22	length	length	NN
8691	4406	23	.	.	.
8691	4406	24	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4407	1	As	as	IN
8691	4407	2	a	a	DT
8691	4407	3	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4407	4	office	office	NN
8691	4407	5	can	can	MD
8691	4407	6	only	only	RB
8691	4407	7	be	be	VB
8691	4407	8	properly	properly	RB
8691	4407	9	filled	fill	VBN
8691	4407	10	by	by	IN
8691	4407	11	one	one	CD
8691	4407	12	who	who	WP
8691	4407	13	has	have	VBZ
8691	4407	14	had	have	VBN
8691	4407	15	a	a	DT
8691	4407	16	legal	legal	JJ
8691	4407	17	education	education	NN
8691	4407	18	and	and	CC
8691	4407	19	as	as	IN
8691	4407	20	,	,	,
8691	4407	21	aside	aside	RB
8691	4407	22	from	from	IN
8691	4407	23	a	a	DT
8691	4407	24	few	few	JJ
8691	4407	25	petty	petty	JJ
8691	4407	26	magistrates	magistrate	NNS
8691	4407	27	and	and	CC
8691	4407	28	local	local	JJ
8691	4407	29	tribunals	tribunal	NNS
8691	4407	30	,	,	,
8691	4407	31	practically	practically	RB
8691	4407	32	all	all	PDT
8691	4407	33	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4407	34	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4407	35	are	be	VBP
8691	4407	36	trained	train	VBN
8691	4407	37	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4407	38	,	,	,
8691	4407	39	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4407	40	necessarily	necessarily	RB
8691	4407	41	follows	follow	VBZ
8691	4407	42	that	that	IN
8691	4407	43	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4407	44	can	can	MD
8691	4407	45	not	not	RB
8691	4407	46	belong	belong	VB
8691	4407	47	to	to	IN
8691	4407	48	the	the	DT
8691	4407	49	class	class	NN
8691	4407	50	of	of	IN
8691	4407	51	working	working	NN
8691	4407	52	-	-	HYPH
8691	4407	53	men	man	NNS
8691	4407	54	in	in	IN
8691	4407	55	the	the	DT
8691	4407	56	general	general	JJ
8691	4407	57	acceptation	acceptation	NN
8691	4407	58	of	of	IN
8691	4407	59	that	that	DT
8691	4407	60	term	term	NN
8691	4407	61	.	.	.
8691	4408	1	Their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4408	2	education	education	NN
8691	4408	3	has	have	VBZ
8691	4408	4	cost	cost	NN
8691	4408	5	money	money	NN
8691	4408	6	and	and	CC
8691	4408	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4408	8	generally	generally	RB
8691	4408	9	the	the	DT
8691	4408	10	fruit	fruit	NN
8691	4408	11	of	of	IN
8691	4408	12	capital	capital	NN
8691	4408	13	.	.	.
8691	4409	1	The	the	DT
8691	4409	2	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4409	3	of	of	IN
8691	4409	4	the	the	DT
8691	4409	5	higher	high	JJR
8691	4409	6	courts	court	NNS
8691	4409	7	are	be	VBP
8691	4409	8	usually	usually	RB
8691	4409	9	men	man	NNS
8691	4409	10	of	of	IN
8691	4409	11	some	some	DT
8691	4409	12	means	mean	NNS
8691	4409	13	.	.	.
8691	4410	1	If	if	IN
8691	4410	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4410	3	were	be	VBD
8691	4410	4	not	not	RB
8691	4410	5	,	,	,
8691	4410	6	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4410	7	could	could	MD
8691	4410	8	not	not	RB
8691	4410	9	have	have	VB
8691	4410	10	afforded	afford	VBN
8691	4410	11	to	to	TO
8691	4410	12	accept	accept	VB
8691	4410	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4410	14	places	place	NNS
8691	4410	15	.	.	.
8691	4411	1	But	but	CC
8691	4411	2	the	the	DT
8691	4411	3	people	people	NNS
8691	4411	4	at	at	IN
8691	4411	5	large	large	JJ
8691	4411	6	do	do	VBP
8691	4411	7	not	not	RB
8691	4411	8	believe	believe	VB
8691	4411	9	that	that	IN
8691	4411	10	only	only	RB
8691	4411	11	the	the	DT
8691	4411	12	poor	poor	JJ
8691	4411	13	man	man	NN
8691	4411	14	can	can	MD
8691	4411	15	be	be	VB
8691	4411	16	relied	rely	VBN
8691	4411	17	on	on	RP
8691	4411	18	to	to	TO
8691	4411	19	deal	deal	VB
8691	4411	20	justly	justly	RB
8691	4411	21	on	on	IN
8691	4411	22	the	the	DT
8691	4411	23	bench	bench	NN
8691	4411	24	.	.	.
8691	4412	1	The	the	DT
8691	4412	2	mass	mass	NN
8691	4412	3	of	of	IN
8691	4412	4	working	working	NN
8691	4412	5	-	-	HYPH
8691	4412	6	men	man	NNS
8691	4412	7	do	do	VBP
8691	4412	8	not	not	RB
8691	4412	9	believe	believe	VB
8691	4412	10	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4412	11	.	.	.
8691	4413	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4413	2	do	do	VBP
8691	4413	3	believe	believe	VB
8691	4413	4	that	that	IN
8691	4413	5	courts	court	NNS
8691	4413	6	have	have	VBP
8691	4413	7	too	too	RB
8691	4413	8	much	much	JJ
8691	4413	9	power	power	NN
8691	4413	10	over	over	IN
8691	4413	11	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4413	12	in	in	IN
8691	4413	13	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4413	14	associated	associate	VBN
8691	4413	15	relations	relation	NNS
8691	4413	16	.	.	.
8691	4414	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4414	2	are	be	VBP
8691	4414	3	in	in	IN
8691	4414	4	favor	favor	NN
8691	4414	5	of	of	IN
8691	4414	6	cutting	cut	VBG
8691	4414	7	off	off	RP
8691	4414	8	the	the	DT
8691	4414	9	right	right	NN
8691	4414	10	of	of	IN
8691	4414	11	issuing	issue	VBG
8691	4414	12	injunctions	injunction	NNS
8691	4414	13	to	to	TO
8691	4414	14	suppress	suppress	VB
8691	4414	15	boycotts	boycotts	NNP
8691	4414	16	or	or	CC
8691	4414	17	"	"	``
8691	4414	18	picketing	picket	VBG
8691	4414	19	"	"	''
8691	4414	20	in	in	IN
8691	4414	21	case	case	NN
8691	4414	22	of	of	IN
8691	4414	23	strikes	strike	NNS
8691	4414	24	.	.	.
8691	4415	1	But	but	CC
8691	4415	2	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4415	3	know	know	VBP
8691	4415	4	that	that	IN
8691	4415	5	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4415	6	is	be	VBZ
8691	4415	7	from	from	IN
8691	4415	8	the	the	DT
8691	4415	9	legislatures	legislature	NNS
8691	4415	10	and	and	CC
8691	4415	11	not	not	RB
8691	4415	12	from	from	IN
8691	4415	13	the	the	DT
8691	4415	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	4415	15	that	that	WDT
8691	4415	16	this	this	DT
8691	4415	17	must	must	MD
8691	4415	18	be	be	VB
8691	4415	19	sought	seek	VBN
8691	4415	20	.	.	.
8691	4416	1	The	the	DT
8691	4416	2	federal	federal	JJ
8691	4416	3	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4416	4	stand	stand	VBP
8691	4416	5	higher	high	JJR
8691	4416	6	in	in	IN
8691	4416	7	public	public	JJ
8691	4416	8	estimation	estimation	NN
8691	4416	9	than	than	IN
8691	4416	10	the	the	DT
8691	4416	11	State	State	NNP
8691	4416	12	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4416	13	of	of	IN
8691	4416	14	corresponding	correspond	VBG
8691	4416	15	rank	rank	NN
8691	4416	16	.	.	.
8691	4417	1	This	this	DT
8691	4417	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4417	3	partly	partly	RB
8691	4417	4	on	on	IN
8691	4417	5	account	account	NN
8691	4417	6	of	of	IN
8691	4417	7	the	the	DT
8691	4417	8	paramount	paramount	NNP
8691	4417	9	authority	authority	NNP
8691	4417	10	of	of	IN
8691	4417	11	the	the	DT
8691	4417	12	government	government	NN
8691	4417	13	which	which	WDT
8691	4417	14	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4417	15	represent	represent	VBP
8691	4417	16	.	.	.
8691	4418	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4418	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4418	3	partly	partly	RB
8691	4418	4	also	also	RB
8691	4418	5	because	because	IN
8691	4418	6	there	there	EX
8691	4418	7	are	be	VBP
8691	4418	8	none	none	NN
8691	4418	9	of	of	IN
8691	4418	10	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4418	11	who	who	WP
8691	4418	12	occupy	occupy	VBP
8691	4418	13	the	the	DT
8691	4418	14	lower	low	JJR
8691	4418	15	grades	grade	NNS
8691	4418	16	of	of	IN
8691	4418	17	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4418	18	station	station	NN
8691	4418	19	with	with	IN
8691	4418	20	a	a	DT
8691	4418	21	petty	petty	JJ
8691	4418	22	jurisdiction	jurisdiction	NN
8691	4418	23	over	over	IN
8691	4418	24	petty	petty	JJ
8691	4418	25	controversies	controversy	NNS
8691	4418	26	.	.	.
8691	4419	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4419	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4419	3	more	more	JJR
8691	4419	4	because	because	IN
8691	4419	5	of	of	IN
8691	4419	6	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4419	7	permanence	permanence	NN
8691	4419	8	of	of	IN
8691	4419	9	tenure	tenure	NN
8691	4419	10	.	.	.
8691	4420	1	This	this	DT
8691	4420	2	removes	remove	VBZ
8691	4420	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4420	4	from	from	IN
8691	4420	5	that	that	DT
8691	4420	6	field	field	NN
8691	4420	7	of	of	IN
8691	4420	8	criticism	criticism	NN
8691	4420	9	which	which	WDT
8691	4420	10	surrounds	surround	VBZ
8691	4420	11	every	every	DT
8691	4420	12	public	public	JJ
8691	4420	13	officer	officer	NN
8691	4420	14	who	who	WP
8691	4420	15	holds	hold	VBZ
8691	4420	16	for	for	IN
8691	4420	17	a	a	DT
8691	4420	18	term	term	NN
8691	4420	19	limited	limit	VBN
8691	4420	20	in	in	IN
8691	4420	21	duration	duration	NN
8691	4420	22	,	,	,
8691	4420	23	and	and	CC
8691	4420	24	is	be	VBZ
8691	4420	25	always	always	RB
8691	4420	26	in	in	IN
8691	4420	27	the	the	DT
8691	4420	28	position	position	NN
8691	4420	29	of	of	IN
8691	4420	30	a	a	DT
8691	4420	31	candidate	candidate	NN
8691	4420	32	for	for	IN
8691	4420	33	re	re	NN
8691	4420	34	-	-	NN
8691	4420	35	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	4420	36	.	.	.
8691	4421	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4421	2	methods	method	NNS
8691	4421	3	of	of	IN
8691	4421	4	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4421	5	appointment	appointment	NN
8691	4421	6	are	be	VBP
8691	4421	7	not	not	RB
8691	4421	8	such	such	JJ
8691	4421	9	as	as	IN
8691	4421	10	always	always	RB
8691	4421	11	to	to	TO
8691	4421	12	exclude	exclude	VB
8691	4421	13	political	political	JJ
8691	4421	14	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	4421	15	from	from	IN
8691	4421	16	the	the	DT
8691	4421	17	bench	bench	NN
8691	4421	18	either	either	DT
8691	4421	19	of	of	IN
8691	4421	20	the	the	DT
8691	4421	21	States	States	NNPS
8691	4421	22	or	or	CC
8691	4421	23	of	of	IN
8691	4421	24	the	the	DT
8691	4421	25	United	United	NNP
8691	4421	26	States	States	NNP
8691	4421	27	,	,	,
8691	4421	28	but	but	CC
8691	4421	29	the	the	DT
8691	4421	30	people	people	NNS
8691	4421	31	know	know	VBP
8691	4421	32	that	that	IN
8691	4421	33	there	there	EX
8691	4421	34	is	be	VBZ
8691	4421	35	less	less	JJR
8691	4421	36	of	of	IN
8691	4421	37	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4421	38	there	there	RB
8691	4421	39	than	than	IN
8691	4421	40	in	in	IN
8691	4421	41	any	any	DT
8691	4421	42	other	other	JJ
8691	4421	43	department	department	NN
8691	4421	44	of	of	IN
8691	4421	45	governmental	governmental	JJ
8691	4421	46	action	action	NN
8691	4421	47	.	.	.
8691	4422	1	President	President	NNP
8691	4422	2	Hadley	Hadley	NNP
8691	4422	3	of	of	IN
8691	4422	4	Yale	Yale	NNP
8691	4422	5	University	University	NNP
8691	4422	6	has	have	VBZ
8691	4422	7	thus	thus	RB
8691	4422	8	expressed	express	VBN
8691	4422	9	what	what	WP
8691	4422	10	is	be	VBZ
8691	4422	11	the	the	DT
8691	4422	12	general	general	JJ
8691	4422	13	view	view	NN
8691	4422	14	of	of	IN
8691	4422	15	the	the	DT
8691	4422	16	work	work	NN
8691	4422	17	of	of	IN
8691	4422	18	the	the	DT
8691	4422	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	4422	20	held	hold	VBN
8691	4422	21	by	by	IN
8691	4422	22	thoughtful	thoughtful	JJ
8691	4422	23	men	man	NNS
8691	4422	24	in	in	IN
8691	4422	25	the	the	DT
8691	4422	26	United	United	NNP
8691	4422	27	States	States	NNP
8691	4422	28	;	;	:
8691	4422	29	and	and	CC
8691	4422	30	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4422	31	is	be	VBZ
8691	4422	32	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4422	33	who	who	WP
8691	4422	34	in	in	IN
8691	4422	35	the	the	DT
8691	4422	36	long	long	JJ
8691	4422	37	run	run	NN
8691	4422	38	form	form	NN
8691	4422	39	and	and	CC
8691	4422	40	lead	lead	VB
8691	4422	41	public	public	JJ
8691	4422	42	opinion	opinion	NN
8691	4422	43	.	.	.
8691	4423	1	"	"	``
8691	4423	2	On	on	IN
8691	4423	3	the	the	DT
8691	4423	4	whole	whole	JJ
8691	4423	5	,	,	,
8691	4423	6	federal	federal	JJ
8691	4423	7	and	and	CC
8691	4423	8	State	state	NN
8691	4423	9	courts	court	NNS
8691	4423	10	alike	alike	RB
8691	4423	11	have	have	VBP
8691	4423	12	been	be	VBN
8691	4423	13	not	not	RB
8691	4423	14	only	only	RB
8691	4423	15	a	a	DT
8691	4423	16	protection	protection	NN
8691	4423	17	,	,	,
8691	4423	18	but	but	CC
8691	4423	19	the	the	DT
8691	4423	20	one	one	NN
8691	4423	21	really	really	RB
8691	4423	22	efficient	efficient	JJ
8691	4423	23	protection	protection	NN
8691	4423	24	of	of	IN
8691	4423	25	minority	minority	NN
8691	4423	26	interests	interest	NNS
8691	4423	27	against	against	IN
8691	4423	28	oppression	oppression	NN
8691	4423	29	by	by	IN
8691	4423	30	the	the	DT
8691	4423	31	majority	majority	NN
8691	4423	32	....	....	.
8691	4424	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4424	2	has	have	VBZ
8691	4424	3	more	more	JJR
8691	4424	4	than	than	IN
8691	4424	5	once	once	RB
8691	4424	6	happened	happen	VBN
8691	4424	7	that	that	IN
8691	4424	8	an	an	DT
8691	4424	9	impatient	impatient	JJ
8691	4424	10	majority	majority	NN
8691	4424	11	has	have	VBZ
8691	4424	12	denounced	denounce	VBN
8691	4424	13	these	these	DT
8691	4424	14	courts	court	NNS
8691	4424	15	as	as	IN
8691	4424	16	instruments	instrument	NNS
8691	4424	17	of	of	IN
8691	4424	18	partisanship	partisanship	NN
8691	4424	19	.	.	.
8691	4425	1	The	the	DT
8691	4425	2	anti	anti	JJ
8691	4425	3	-	-	JJ
8691	4425	4	slavery	slavery	JJ
8691	4425	5	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	4425	6	,	,	,
8691	4425	7	the	the	DT
8691	4425	8	soft	soft	JJ
8691	4425	9	money	money	NN
8691	4425	10	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	4425	11	,	,	,
8691	4425	12	and	and	CC
8691	4425	13	the	the	DT
8691	4425	14	labor	labor	NN
8691	4425	15	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	4425	16	have	have	VBP
8691	4425	17	in	in	IN
8691	4425	18	turn	turn	NN
8691	4425	19	taken	take	VBN
8691	4425	20	exception	exception	NN
8691	4425	21	to	to	IN
8691	4425	22	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4425	23	utterances	utterance	NNS
8691	4425	24	,	,	,
8691	4425	25	and	and	CC
8691	4425	26	even	even	RB
8691	4425	27	ventured	venture	VBD
8691	4425	28	to	to	TO
8691	4425	29	impugn	impugn	VB
8691	4425	30	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4425	31	motives	motive	NNS
8691	4425	32	.	.	.
8691	4426	1	But	but	CC
8691	4426	2	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4426	3	think	think	VBP
8691	4426	4	that	that	IN
8691	4426	5	most	most	JJS
8691	4426	6	intelligent	intelligent	JJ
8691	4426	7	men	man	NNS
8691	4426	8	who	who	WP
8691	4426	9	know	know	VBP
8691	4426	10	the	the	DT
8691	4426	11	history	history	NN
8691	4426	12	of	of	IN
8691	4426	13	the	the	DT
8691	4426	14	country	country	NN
8691	4426	15	will	will	MD
8691	4426	16	say	say	VB
8691	4426	17	that	that	IN
8691	4426	18	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4426	19	courts	court	NNS
8691	4426	20	have	have	VBP
8691	4426	21	been	be	VBN
8691	4426	22	the	the	DT
8691	4426	23	real	real	JJ
8691	4426	24	bulwarks	bulwark	NNS
8691	4426	25	of	of	IN
8691	4426	26	American	american	JJ
8691	4426	27	liberty	liberty	NN
8691	4426	28	;	;	:
8691	4426	29	and	and	CC
8691	4426	30	that	that	IN
8691	4426	31	while	while	IN
8691	4426	32	Hamilton	Hamilton	NNP
8691	4426	33	and	and	CC
8691	4426	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4426	35	associates	associate	NNS
8691	4426	36	would	would	MD
8691	4426	37	be	be	VB
8691	4426	38	somewhat	somewhat	RB
8691	4426	39	disappointed	disappointed	JJ
8691	4426	40	in	in	IN
8691	4426	41	the	the	DT
8691	4426	42	working	working	NN
8691	4426	43	of	of	IN
8691	4426	44	the	the	DT
8691	4426	45	machinery	machinery	NN
8691	4426	46	of	of	IN
8691	4426	47	legislation	legislation	NN
8691	4426	48	and	and	CC
8691	4426	49	administration	administration	NN
8691	4426	50	if	if	IN
8691	4426	51	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4426	52	could	could	MD
8691	4426	53	see	see	VB
8691	4426	54	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4426	55	in	in	IN
8691	4426	56	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4426	57	present	present	JJ
8691	4426	58	shape	shape	NN
8691	4426	59	,	,	,
8691	4426	60	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4426	61	would	would	MD
8691	4426	62	be	be	VB
8691	4426	63	filled	fill	VBN
8691	4426	64	with	with	IN
8691	4426	65	admiration	admiration	NN
8691	4426	66	at	at	IN
8691	4426	67	the	the	DT
8691	4426	68	work	work	NN
8691	4426	69	which	which	WDT
8691	4426	70	has	have	VBZ
8691	4426	71	been	be	VBN
8691	4426	72	accomplished	accomplish	VBN
8691	4426	73	by	by	IN
8691	4426	74	the	the	DT
8691	4426	75	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	4426	76	.	.	.
8691	4427	1	I	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4427	2	believe	believe	VBP
8691	4427	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4427	4	to	to	TO
8691	4427	5	be	be	VB
8691	4427	6	the	the	DT
8691	4427	7	judgment	judgment	NN
8691	4427	8	of	of	IN
8691	4427	9	sober	sober	JJ
8691	4427	10	-	-	HYPH
8691	4427	11	minded	minded	JJ
8691	4427	12	men	man	NNS
8691	4427	13	that	that	IN
8691	4427	14	the	the	DT
8691	4427	15	courts	court	NNS
8691	4427	16	have	have	VBP
8691	4427	17	furnished	furnish	VBN
8691	4427	18	the	the	DT
8691	4427	19	agency	agency	NN
8691	4427	20	which	which	WDT
8691	4427	21	has	have	VBZ
8691	4427	22	guarded	guard	VBN
8691	4427	23	us	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4427	24	against	against	IN
8691	4427	25	excesses	excess	NNS
8691	4427	26	,	,	,
8691	4427	27	and	and	CC
8691	4427	28	have	have	VBP
8691	4427	29	saved	save	VBN
8691	4427	30	the	the	DT
8691	4427	31	American	american	JJ
8691	4427	32	republic	republic	NN
8691	4427	33	from	from	IN
8691	4427	34	the	the	DT
8691	4427	35	necessity	necessity	NN
8691	4427	36	of	of	IN
8691	4427	37	repeating	repeat	VBG
8691	4427	38	the	the	DT
8691	4427	39	successive	successive	JJ
8691	4427	40	revolutionary	revolutionary	JJ
8691	4427	41	experiences	experience	NNS
8691	4427	42	which	which	WDT
8691	4427	43	France	France	NNP
8691	4427	44	underwent	undergo	VBD
8691	4427	45	before	before	IN
8691	4427	46	she	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4427	47	could	could	MD
8691	4427	48	attain	attain	VB
8691	4427	49	to	to	IN
8691	4427	50	a	a	DT
8691	4427	51	stable	stable	JJ
8691	4427	52	democracy	democracy	NN
8691	4427	53	.	.	.
8691	4428	1	"	"	``
8691	4428	2	[	[	-LRB-
8691	4428	3	Footnote	footnote	NN
8691	4428	4	:	:	:
8691	4428	5	"	"	``
8691	4428	6	Freedom	Freedom	NNP
8691	4428	7	and	and	CC
8691	4428	8	Responsibility	Responsibility	NNP
8691	4428	9	,	,	,
8691	4428	10	"	"	''
8691	4428	11	23	23	CD
8691	4428	12	,	,	,
8691	4428	13	24	24	CD
8691	4428	14	.	.	.
8691	4428	15	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4429	1	This	this	DT
8691	4429	2	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	4429	3	in	in	IN
8691	4429	4	and	and	CC
8691	4429	5	respect	respect	NN
8691	4429	6	for	for	IN
8691	4429	7	the	the	DT
8691	4429	8	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	4429	9	as	as	IN
8691	4429	10	a	a	DT
8691	4429	11	whole	whole	NN
8691	4429	12	has	have	VBZ
8691	4429	13	increased	increase	VBN
8691	4429	14	with	with	IN
8691	4429	15	the	the	DT
8691	4429	16	general	general	JJ
8691	4429	17	advance	advance	NN
8691	4429	18	of	of	IN
8691	4429	19	the	the	DT
8691	4429	20	country	country	NN
8691	4429	21	in	in	IN
8691	4429	22	population	population	NN
8691	4429	23	and	and	CC
8691	4429	24	wealth	wealth	NN
8691	4429	25	.	.	.
8691	4430	1	There	there	EX
8691	4430	2	have	have	VBP
8691	4430	3	been	be	VBN
8691	4430	4	larger	large	JJR
8691	4430	5	questions	question	NNS
8691	4430	6	with	with	IN
8691	4430	7	which	which	WDT
8691	4430	8	to	to	TO
8691	4430	9	deal	deal	VB
8691	4430	10	,	,	,
8691	4430	11	and	and	CC
8691	4430	12	the	the	DT
8691	4430	13	courts	court	NNS
8691	4430	14	have	have	VBP
8691	4430	15	been	be	VBN
8691	4430	16	found	find	VBN
8691	4430	17	adequate	adequate	JJ
8691	4430	18	to	to	IN
8691	4430	19	the	the	DT
8691	4430	20	task	task	NN
8691	4430	21	.	.	.
8691	4431	1	But	but	CC
8691	4431	2	at	at	IN
8691	4431	3	the	the	DT
8691	4431	4	same	same	JJ
8691	4431	5	time	time	NN
8691	4431	6	the	the	DT
8691	4431	7	personal	personal	JJ
8691	4431	8	consequence	consequence	NN
8691	4431	9	and	and	CC
8691	4431	10	reputation	reputation	NN
8691	4431	11	of	of	IN
8691	4431	12	every	every	DT
8691	4431	13	individual	individual	JJ
8691	4431	14	American	american	JJ
8691	4431	15	judge	judge	NN
8691	4431	16	has	have	VBZ
8691	4431	17	been	be	VBN
8691	4431	18	steadily	steadily	RB
8691	4431	19	decreasing	decrease	VBG
8691	4431	20	.	.	.
8691	4432	1	As	as	IN
8691	4432	2	States	state	NNS
8691	4432	3	multiply	multiply	VBP
8691	4432	4	and	and	CC
8691	4432	5	the	the	DT
8691	4432	6	range	range	NN
8691	4432	7	of	of	IN
8691	4432	8	litigation	litigation	NN
8691	4432	9	widens	widen	NNS
8691	4432	10	,	,	,
8691	4432	11	the	the	DT
8691	4432	12	work	work	NN
8691	4432	13	of	of	IN
8691	4432	14	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4432	15	exposition	exposition	NN
8691	4432	16	of	of	IN
8691	4432	17	legal	legal	JJ
8691	4432	18	principles	principle	NNS
8691	4432	19	comes	come	VBZ
8691	4432	20	to	to	TO
8691	4432	21	be	be	VB
8691	4432	22	shared	share	VBN
8691	4432	23	by	by	IN
8691	4432	24	so	so	RB
8691	4432	25	many	many	JJ
8691	4432	26	hands	hand	NNS
8691	4432	27	that	that	IN
8691	4432	28	what	what	WP
8691	4432	29	any	any	DT
8691	4432	30	one	one	CD
8691	4432	31	man	man	NN
8691	4432	32	does	do	VBZ
8691	4432	33	is	be	VBZ
8691	4432	34	of	of	IN
8691	4432	35	comparatively	comparatively	RB
8691	4432	36	small	small	JJ
8691	4432	37	account	account	NN
8691	4432	38	.	.	.
8691	4433	1	There	there	EX
8691	4433	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4433	3	no	no	DT
8691	4433	4	room	room	NN
8691	4433	5	for	for	IN
8691	4433	6	star	star	NN
8691	4433	7	players	player	NNS
8691	4433	8	upon	upon	IN
8691	4433	9	the	the	DT
8691	4433	10	stage	stage	NN
8691	4433	11	.	.	.
8691	4434	1	Broad	broad	JJ
8691	4434	2	as	as	IN
8691	4434	3	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4434	4	is	be	VBZ
8691	4434	5	,	,	,
8691	4434	6	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4434	7	is	be	VBZ
8691	4434	8	too	too	RB
8691	4434	9	crowded	crowded	JJ
8691	4434	10	for	for	IN
8691	4434	11	one	one	CD
8691	4434	12	to	to	TO
8691	4434	13	make	make	VB
8691	4434	14	a	a	DT
8691	4434	15	conspicuous	conspicuous	JJ
8691	4434	16	place	place	NN
8691	4434	17	for	for	IN
8691	4434	18	himself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4434	19	and	and	CC
8691	4434	20	stand	stand	VB
8691	4434	21	as	as	IN
8691	4434	22	Marshall	Marshall	NNP
8691	4434	23	or	or	CC
8691	4434	24	Story	Story	NNP
8691	4434	25	,	,	,
8691	4434	26	Kent	Kent	NNP
8691	4434	27	or	or	CC
8691	4434	28	Parsons	Parsons	NNP
8691	4434	29	,	,	,
8691	4434	30	did	do	VBD
8691	4434	31	,	,	,
8691	4434	32	apart	apart	RB
8691	4434	33	from	from	IN
8691	4434	34	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4434	35	fellows	fellow	NNS
8691	4434	36	.	.	.
8691	4435	1	Popular	popular	JJ
8691	4435	2	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	4435	3	is	be	VBZ
8691	4435	4	now	now	RB
8691	4435	5	not	not	RB
8691	4435	6	placed	place	VBN
8691	4435	7	in	in	IN
8691	4435	8	courts	court	NNS
8691	4435	9	because	because	IN
8691	4435	10	this	this	DT
8691	4435	11	or	or	CC
8691	4435	12	that	that	DT
8691	4435	13	man	man	NN
8691	4435	14	is	be	VBZ
8691	4435	15	the	the	DT
8691	4435	16	ruling	rule	VBG
8691	4435	17	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	4435	18	in	in	IN
8691	4435	19	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4435	20	.	.	.
8691	4436	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4436	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4436	3	impersonal	impersonal	JJ
8691	4436	4	and	and	CC
8691	4436	5	attaches	attach	VBZ
8691	4436	6	itself	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4436	7	to	to	IN
8691	4436	8	the	the	DT
8691	4436	9	institution	institution	NN
8691	4436	10	of	of	IN
8691	4436	11	the	the	DT
8691	4436	12	judiciary	judiciary	NN
8691	4436	13	as	as	IN
8691	4436	14	,	,	,
8691	4436	15	all	all	DT
8691	4436	16	things	thing	NNS
8691	4436	17	considered	consider	VBN
8691	4436	18	,	,	,
8691	4436	19	the	the	DT
8691	4436	20	best	good	JJS
8691	4436	21	guaranty	guaranty	NN
8691	4436	22	of	of	IN
8691	4436	23	good	good	JJ
8691	4436	24	government	government	NN
8691	4436	25	in	in	IN
8691	4436	26	the	the	DT
8691	4436	27	United	United	NNP
8691	4436	28	States	States	NNP
8691	4436	29	.	.	.
8691	4437	1	This	this	DT
8691	4437	2	spirit	spirit	NN
8691	4437	3	of	of	IN
8691	4437	4	confidence	confidence	NN
8691	4437	5	is	be	VBZ
8691	4437	6	,	,	,
8691	4437	7	of	of	IN
8691	4437	8	course	course	NN
8691	4437	9	,	,	,
8691	4437	10	not	not	RB
8691	4437	11	universal	universal	JJ
8691	4437	12	and	and	CC
8691	4437	13	unqualified	unqualified	JJ
8691	4437	14	.	.	.
8691	4438	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4438	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4438	3	often	often	RB
8691	4438	4	not	not	RB
8691	4438	5	found	find	VBN
8691	4438	6	in	in	IN
8691	4438	7	bodies	body	NNS
8691	4438	8	of	of	IN
8691	4438	9	working	work	VBG
8691	4438	10	men	man	NNS
8691	4438	11	,	,	,
8691	4438	12	associated	associate	VBN
8691	4438	13	as	as	IN
8691	4438	14	Labor	Labor	NNP
8691	4438	15	Unions	Unions	NNP
8691	4438	16	.	.	.
8691	4439	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4439	2	have	have	VBP
8691	4439	3	repeatedly	repeatedly	RB
8691	4439	4	found	find	VBN
8691	4439	5	a	a	DT
8691	4439	6	court	court	NN
8691	4439	7	enforcing	enforce	VBG
8691	4439	8	public	public	JJ
8691	4439	9	order	order	NN
8691	4439	10	in	in	IN
8691	4439	11	a	a	DT
8691	4439	12	way	way	NN
8691	4439	13	that	that	WDT
8691	4439	14	interfered	interfere	VBD
8691	4439	15	with	with	IN
8691	4439	16	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4439	17	manner	manner	NN
8691	4439	18	of	of	IN
8691	4439	19	conducting	conduct	VBG
8691	4439	20	a	a	DT
8691	4439	21	strike	strike	NN
8691	4439	22	.	.	.
8691	4440	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4440	2	have	have	VBP
8691	4440	3	been	be	VBN
8691	4440	4	met	meet	VBN
8691	4440	5	by	by	IN
8691	4440	6	injunctions	injunction	NNS
8691	4440	7	,	,	,
8691	4440	8	and	and	CC
8691	4440	9	more	more	RBR
8691	4440	10	often	often	RB
8691	4440	11	by	by	IN
8691	4440	12	criminal	criminal	JJ
8691	4440	13	prosecutions	prosecution	NNS
8691	4440	14	.	.	.
8691	4441	1	The	the	DT
8691	4441	2	membership	membership	NN
8691	4441	3	of	of	IN
8691	4441	4	a	a	DT
8691	4441	5	Labor	Labor	NNP
8691	4441	6	Union	Union	NNP
8691	4441	7	,	,	,
8691	4441	8	in	in	IN
8691	4441	9	many	many	JJ
8691	4441	10	parts	part	NNS
8691	4441	11	of	of	IN
8691	4441	12	the	the	DT
8691	4441	13	country	country	NN
8691	4441	14	,	,	,
8691	4441	15	is	be	VBZ
8691	4441	16	apt	apt	JJ
8691	4441	17	to	to	TO
8691	4441	18	be	be	VB
8691	4441	19	largely	largely	RB
8691	4441	20	of	of	IN
8691	4441	21	foreign	foreign	JJ
8691	4441	22	birth	birth	NN
8691	4441	23	.	.	.
8691	4442	1	The	the	DT
8691	4442	2	leaders	leader	NNS
8691	4442	3	not	not	RB
8691	4442	4	infrequently	infrequently	RB
8691	4442	5	know	know	VBP
8691	4442	6	little	little	JJ
8691	4442	7	of	of	IN
8691	4442	8	the	the	DT
8691	4442	9	English	english	JJ
8691	4442	10	language	language	NN
8691	4442	11	and	and	CC
8691	4442	12	less	less	JJR
8691	4442	13	of	of	IN
8691	4442	14	American	american	JJ
8691	4442	15	institutions	institution	NNS
8691	4442	16	.	.	.
8691	4443	1	They	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4443	2	have	have	VBP
8691	4443	3	been	be	VBN
8691	4443	4	led	lead	VBN
8691	4443	5	,	,	,
8691	4443	6	in	in	IN
8691	4443	7	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4443	8	native	native	JJ
8691	4443	9	land	land	NN
8691	4443	10	,	,	,
8691	4443	11	to	to	TO
8691	4443	12	regard	regard	VB
8691	4443	13	the	the	DT
8691	4443	14	law	law	NN
8691	4443	15	and	and	CC
8691	4443	16	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4443	17	officers	officer	NNS
8691	4443	18	as	as	IN
8691	4443	19	their	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4443	20	enemies	enemy	NNS
8691	4443	21	,	,	,
8691	4443	22	and	and	CC
8691	4443	23	they	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4443	24	look	look	VBP
8691	4443	25	at	at	IN
8691	4443	26	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4443	27	in	in	IN
8691	4443	28	the	the	DT
8691	4443	29	same	same	JJ
8691	4443	30	way	way	NN
8691	4443	31	here	here	RB
8691	4443	32	.	.	.
8691	4444	1	It	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4444	2	is	be	VBZ
8691	4444	3	believed	believe	VBN
8691	4444	4	,	,	,
8691	4444	5	however	however	RB
8691	4444	6	,	,	,
8691	4444	7	that	that	IN
8691	4444	8	a	a	DT
8691	4444	9	large	large	JJ
8691	4444	10	majority	majority	NN
8691	4444	11	of	of	IN
8691	4444	12	the	the	DT
8691	4444	13	Unions	Unions	NNPS
8691	4444	14	regard	regard	VBP
8691	4444	15	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4444	16	with	with	IN
8691	4444	17	respect	respect	NN
8691	4444	18	,	,	,
8691	4444	19	and	and	CC
8691	4444	20	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4444	21	is	be	VBZ
8691	4444	22	certain	certain	JJ
8691	4444	23	that	that	IN
8691	4444	24	such	such	JJ
8691	4444	25	is	be	VBZ
8691	4444	26	the	the	DT
8691	4444	27	prevailing	prevail	VBG
8691	4444	28	feeling	feeling	NN
8691	4444	29	of	of	IN
8691	4444	30	non	non	JJ
8691	4444	31	-	-	JJ
8691	4444	32	union	union	JJ
8691	4444	33	men	man	NNS
8691	4444	34	.	.	.
8691	4445	1	But	but	CC
8691	4445	2	that	that	IN
8691	4445	3	the	the	DT
8691	4445	4	public	public	JJ
8691	4445	5	trust	trust	NN
8691	4445	6	in	in	IN
8691	4445	7	our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4445	8	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4445	9	is	be	VBZ
8691	4445	10	less	less	JJR
8691	4445	11	than	than	IN
8691	4445	12	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4445	13	was	be	VBD
8691	4445	14	when	when	WRB
8691	4445	15	the	the	DT
8691	4445	16	first	first	JJ
8691	4445	17	edition	edition	NN
8691	4445	18	of	of	IN
8691	4445	19	this	this	DT
8691	4445	20	work	work	NN
8691	4445	21	was	be	VBD
8691	4445	22	published,[Footnote	published,[footnote	CD
8691	4445	23	:	:	:
8691	4445	24	See	see	VB
8691	4445	25	_	_	NNP
8691	4445	26	supra	supra	NNP
8691	4445	27	_	_	NNP
8691	4445	28	,	,	,
8691	4445	29	page	page	NN
8691	4445	30	340	340	CD
8691	4445	31	.	.	.
8691	4445	32	]	]	-RRB-
8691	4446	1	is	be	VBZ
8691	4446	2	indicated	indicate	VBN
8691	4446	3	by	by	IN
8691	4446	4	the	the	DT
8691	4446	5	favor	favor	NN
8691	4446	6	with	with	IN
8691	4446	7	which	which	WDT
8691	4446	8	,	,	,
8691	4446	9	in	in	IN
8691	4446	10	many	many	JJ
8691	4446	11	quarters	quarter	NNS
8691	4446	12	,	,	,
8691	4446	13	the	the	DT
8691	4446	14	doctrine	doctrine	NN
8691	4446	15	of	of	IN
8691	4446	16	the	the	DT
8691	4446	17	"	"	``
8691	4446	18	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4446	19	recall	recall	NN
8691	4446	20	"	"	''
8691	4446	21	has	have	VBZ
8691	4446	22	been	be	VBN
8691	4446	23	received	receive	VBN
8691	4446	24	.	.	.
8691	4447	1	The	the	DT
8691	4447	2	dangers	danger	NNS
8691	4447	3	incident	incident	VBP
8691	4447	4	to	to	IN
8691	4447	5	its	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4447	6	practice	practice	NN
8691	4447	7	are	be	VBP
8691	4447	8	obvious	obvious	JJ
8691	4447	9	,	,	,
8691	4447	10	and	and	CC
8691	4447	11	seem	seem	VB
8691	4447	12	far	far	RB
8691	4447	13	to	to	TO
8691	4447	14	outweigh	outweigh	VB
8691	4447	15	any	any	DT
8691	4447	16	attending	attend	VBG
8691	4447	17	advantages	advantage	NNS
8691	4447	18	.	.	.
8691	4448	1	In	in	IN
8691	4448	2	the	the	DT
8691	4448	3	United	United	NNP
8691	4448	4	States	States	NNP
8691	4448	5	,	,	,
8691	4448	6	of	of	IN
8691	4448	7	all	all	DT
8691	4448	8	lands	land	NNS
8691	4448	9	on	on	IN
8691	4448	10	the	the	DT
8691	4448	11	face	face	NN
8691	4448	12	of	of	IN
8691	4448	13	the	the	DT
8691	4448	14	earth	earth	NN
8691	4448	15	,	,	,
8691	4448	16	it	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4448	17	is	be	VBZ
8691	4448	18	important	important	JJ
8691	4448	19	that	that	IN
8691	4448	20	the	the	DT
8691	4448	21	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4448	22	should	should	MD
8691	4448	23	act	act	VB
8691	4448	24	with	with	IN
8691	4448	25	resolution	resolution	NN
8691	4448	26	and	and	CC
8691	4448	27	without	without	IN
8691	4448	28	thought	thought	NN
8691	4448	29	of	of	IN
8691	4448	30	the	the	DT
8691	4448	31	consequences	consequence	NNS
8691	4448	32	personal	personal	JJ
8691	4448	33	to	to	IN
8691	4448	34	themselves	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4448	35	.	.	.
8691	4449	1	Elsewhere	elsewhere	RB
8691	4449	2	in	in	IN
8691	4449	3	form	form	NN
8691	4449	4	,	,	,
8691	4449	5	but	but	CC
8691	4449	6	here	here	RB
8691	4449	7	only	only	RB
8691	4449	8	in	in	IN
8691	4449	9	fact	fact	NN
8691	4449	10	,	,	,
8691	4449	11	are	be	VBP
8691	4449	12	judges	judge	NNS
8691	4449	13	armed	arm	VBN
8691	4449	14	with	with	IN
8691	4449	15	the	the	DT
8691	4449	16	power	power	NN
8691	4449	17	of	of	IN
8691	4449	18	declaring	declare	VBG
8691	4449	19	legislative	legislative	JJ
8691	4449	20	action	action	NN
8691	4449	21	void	void	NN
8691	4449	22	which	which	WDT
8691	4449	23	is	be	VBZ
8691	4449	24	in	in	IN
8691	4449	25	conflict	conflict	NN
8691	4449	26	with	with	IN
8691	4449	27	a	a	DT
8691	4449	28	higher	high	JJR
8691	4449	29	form	form	NN
8691	4449	30	of	of	IN
8691	4449	31	law	law	NN
8691	4449	32	,	,	,
8691	4449	33	that	that	WDT
8691	4449	34	proceeded	proceed	VBD
8691	4449	35	directly	directly	RB
8691	4449	36	from	from	IN
8691	4449	37	the	the	DT
8691	4449	38	people	people	NNS
8691	4449	39	,	,	,
8691	4449	40	and	and	CC
8691	4449	41	mainly	mainly	RB
8691	4449	42	from	from	IN
8691	4449	43	the	the	DT
8691	4449	44	people	people	NNS
8691	4449	45	of	of	IN
8691	4449	46	a	a	DT
8691	4449	47	former	former	JJ
8691	4449	48	generation	generation	NN
8691	4449	49	.	.	.
8691	4450	1	To	to	TO
8691	4450	2	expose	expose	VB
8691	4450	3	one	one	CD
8691	4450	4	who	who	WP
8691	4450	5	exercises	exercise	VBZ
8691	4450	6	this	this	DT
8691	4450	7	power	power	NN
8691	4450	8	to	to	IN
8691	4450	9	immediate	immediate	JJ
8691	4450	10	displacement	displacement	NN
8691	4450	11	,	,	,
8691	4450	12	by	by	IN
8691	4450	13	a	a	DT
8691	4450	14	popular	popular	JJ
8691	4450	15	vote	vote	NN
8691	4450	16	--	--	:
8691	4450	17	largely	largely	RB
8691	4450	18	,	,	,
8691	4450	19	perhaps	perhaps	RB
8691	4450	20	,	,	,
8691	4450	21	composed	compose	VBN
8691	4450	22	of	of	IN
8691	4450	23	his	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4450	24	political	political	JJ
8691	4450	25	opponents	opponent	NNS
8691	4450	26	--	--	:
8691	4450	27	is	be	VBZ
8691	4450	28	to	to	TO
8691	4450	29	invite	invite	VB
8691	4450	30	the	the	DT
8691	4450	31	enactment	enactment	NN
8691	4450	32	of	of	IN
8691	4450	33	questionable	questionable	JJ
8691	4450	34	statutes	statute	NNS
8691	4450	35	,	,	,
8691	4450	36	and	and	CC
8691	4450	37	still	still	RB
8691	4450	38	worse	bad	JJR
8691	4450	39	--	--	:
8691	4450	40	to	to	TO
8691	4450	41	weaken	weaken	VB
8691	4450	42	the	the	DT
8691	4450	43	attractions	attraction	NNS
8691	4450	44	of	of	IN
8691	4450	45	the	the	DT
8691	4450	46	bench	bench	NN
8691	4450	47	for	for	IN
8691	4450	48	able	able	JJ
8691	4450	49	and	and	CC
8691	4450	50	honest	honest	JJ
8691	4450	51	men	man	NNS
8691	4450	52	.	.	.
8691	4451	1	Our	-PRON-	PRP$
8691	4451	2	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4451	3	terms	term	NNS
8691	4451	4	,	,	,
8691	4451	5	in	in	IN
8691	4451	6	most	most	JJS
8691	4451	7	of	of	IN
8691	4451	8	the	the	DT
8691	4451	9	States	States	NNPS
8691	4451	10	,	,	,
8691	4451	11	are	be	VBP
8691	4451	12	already	already	RB
8691	4451	13	too	too	RB
8691	4451	14	brief	brief	JJ
8691	4451	15	for	for	IN
8691	4451	16	the	the	DT
8691	4451	17	public	public	JJ
8691	4451	18	good	good	NN
8691	4451	19	.	.	.
8691	4452	1	To	to	TO
8691	4452	2	make	make	VB
8691	4452	3	them	-PRON-	PRP
8691	4452	4	determinable	determinable	VB
8691	4452	5	at	at	IN
8691	4452	6	the	the	DT
8691	4452	7	will	will	NN
8691	4452	8	of	of	IN
8691	4452	9	the	the	DT
8691	4452	10	electoral	electoral	JJ
8691	4452	11	constituency	constituency	NN
8691	4452	12	tends	tend	VBZ
8691	4452	13	powerfully	powerfully	RB
8691	4452	14	to	to	TO
8691	4452	15	keep	keep	VB
8691	4452	16	good	good	JJ
8691	4452	17	lawyers	lawyer	NNS
8691	4452	18	at	at	IN
8691	4452	19	the	the	DT
8691	4452	20	bar	bar	NN
8691	4452	21	,	,	,
8691	4452	22	who	who	WP
8691	4452	23	might	may	MD
8691	4452	24	otherwise	otherwise	RB
8691	4452	25	have	have	VB
8691	4452	26	done	do	VBN
8691	4452	27	honor	honor	NN
8691	4452	28	to	to	IN
8691	4452	29	a	a	DT
8691	4452	30	judicial	judicial	JJ
8691	4452	31	station	station	NN
8691	4452	32	.	.	.