A plea for the pardoning part of the soveraignty of the kings of England Philipps, Fabian, 1601-1690. 1682 Approx. 82 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 36 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2004-11 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A54690 Wing P2012 ESTC R9266 13539670 ocm 13539670 100066 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A54690) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 100066) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 472:3) A plea for the pardoning part of the soveraignty of the kings of England Philipps, Fabian, 1601-1690. [2], 68 p. Printed by H. H. for John Fish ..., London : 1682. Attributed to Fabian Philipps. Cf. BM. Reproduction of original in Huntington Library. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Great Britain -- Kings and rulers. 2004-07 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2004-07 Aptara Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2004-09 Judith Siefring Sampled and proofread 2004-09 Judith Siefring Text and markup reviewed and edited 2004-10 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion A PLEA FOR THE Pardoning Part OF THE SOVERAIGNTY OF THE KINGS OF ENGLAND . LONDON , Printed by H. H. for John Fish , near the Golden-Tun , in the Strand , 1682. A PLEA for the Pardoning Part of the Soveraignty of the Kings of England . IF Monarchy hath been by God himself , and the experience of above 5000 years and the longest Ages of the World approved ( as it hath ) to have been the best and most desirable form of Government . And the Kingdom of England , as it hath been , for more than 1000 years a well tempered Monarchy , and the Sword and Power thereof was given to our Kings only by God that ruleth the Hearts of them . The means thereunto which should be the Power of Punishment and Reward , can no way permit , that they should be without the Liberty and Prerogative of Pardoning , which was no Stranger in England long before the Conquest , in the Reign of King Athelstane , who did thereby free the Nation from four-footed Wolves by ordaining Pardons to such Out-laws as would help to free themselves and others from such villanous Neighbours , the Laws of Canutus also making it a great part of their business to injoyn a moderation in punishments ad divinam clementiam temperata to be observed in Magistracy and never to be wanting in the most Superior , none being so proper to acquit the offence as they that by our Laws are to take benefit by the Fines and Forfeitures arising thereby . Edward the Confessors Law would not have Rex regni sub cujus protectione & pace degunt universi , to be without it ; when amongst his Laws which the People of England held so sacred as they did hide them under his Shrine , and afterwards precibus & fletibus obtained of the Conqueror , that they should be observed , and procured the observation of them especially to be inserted in the Coronation-Oaths of our succeeding Kings , inviolably to be kept . And it is under the Title of misericordia Regis & Pardonatio , declared , That Si quispiam forisfactus ( which the Margin interpreteth rei Capitalis reus ) poposcerit Regiam misericordiam pro forisfacto suo , timidus mortis vel membrorum perdendorum , potest Rex ei lege suae dignitatis condonare si velit etiam mortem promeritam ; ipse tamen malefactor rectum faciat in quantumcunque poterit quibus forisfecit , & tradat fidejussores de pace & legalitate tenenda si vero fidejussores defecerint exulabitur a Patria . For the pardoning of Treason , Murder , breach of the Peace , &c. saith King Henry the First , in his Laws , so much esteemed by the Barons and Contenders for our Magna Charta , as they solemnly swore they would live and die in the defence thereof , do solely belong unto him , & super omnes homines in terra sua . In the fifth year of the Reign of King Edward the Second , Peirce Gaveston Earl of Cornewall , being banished by the King in Parliament , and all his Lands and Estate seized into the Kings hands , the King granted his Pardon , remitted the Seizures , and caused the Pardon and Discharges to be written and Sealed in His Presence . And howsoever he was shortly after upon his return into England , taken by the Earl of Warwick and beheaded without Process or Judgment at Law , yet he and his Complices thought themselves not to be in any safety , until they had by two Acts of Parliament in the seventh year of that Kings Reign obtained a Pardon , Ne quis occasionetur pro reditu & morte Petri de Gaveston , the power of pardoning , being always so annexed to the King and his Crown and Dignity . As the Acts of Parliament of 2 E. 3. ca. 2. 10 E. 3. ca. 15. 13 R. 2. ca. 1. and 16 R. 2. ca. 6. seeking by the Kings Leave and Licence in some things to qualifie it , are in that of 13 R. 2. ca. 1. content to allow the Power of Pardoning to belong to the Liberty of the King , and a Regality used heretofore by his Progenitors . Hubert de Burgh Earl of Kent Chief Justiciar of England , in the Reign of King Henry the third , laden with envy and as many deep Accusations as any Minister of State could lie under , in two several Charges in several Parliaments , then without an House of Commons , had the happiness , notwithstanding all the hate and extremities put upon him by an incensed Party , to receive two several Pardons of his and their King , and dye acquitted in the Estate which he had gained . In the fiftieth year of the Reign of King Edward the third , the Commons in Parliament petitioning the King , that no Officer of the Kings , or any man , high or low , that was impeached by them , should enjoy his Place or be of the Kings Council . The King only answered , he would do as he pleased . With which they were so well satisfied ; as the next year after , in Parliament , upon better consideration , they petitioned him , that Richard Lyons , John Pechie , and Alice Pierce , whom they had largely accused and believed guilty , might be pardoned . And that King was so unwilling to bereave himself of that one especial Flower in his Crown ; as in a Grant or Commission made in the same year to James Botiller Earl of Ormond of the Office of Chief Justiciar of Ireland giving him power under the Seal of that Kingdom to pardon all Trespasses Felonies , Murders , Treasons , &c. he did especially except and reserve to himself the power of pardoning Prelates , Earls and Barons . In the first year of the Reign of King Henry the fourth , the King in the Case of the Duke of Albemarle and others , declared in Parliament that Mercy and Grace belongeth to Him and his Royal Estate , and therefore reserved it to himself , and would that no man entitle himself thereunto . And many have been since granted by our succeeding Kings in Parliament , at the request of the Commons ( the People of England in Worldly and Civil Affairs as well ever since , as before , not knowing unto whom else to apply themselves for it . ) So as no fraud or indirect dealings being made use of in the obtaining of a Pardon , it ought not to be shaken or invalidated , whether it were before a Charge or Accusation in Parliament or after , or where there is no Charge or Indictment antecedent . The Pardon of the King to Richard Lyons at the request of the Commons in Parliament , as the Parliament Rolls do mention , although it was not inserted in the Pardon , was declared to be after a Charge against him by the Commons in Parliament , and in the perclose said to be per Dominum Regem . And a second of the same date and tenor , with a perclose said to have been per Dominum Regem & magnum Concilium . John Pechies pardon for whom that House of Commons in Parliament was said to intercede ; only mentioneth that it was precibus aliquorum Magnatum . 15 E. 3. The Archbishop of Canterbury before the King , Lords , and Commons humbling himself before the King Lords and Commons ; desired that where he was defamed through the Realm he might be larraigned before his Peers in open Parliamenti unto which the King answered , that He would attend the Common affairs , and afterward hear others . 5 H. 4. The King at the request of the Commons ; affirmeth the Archbishop of Canterbury , the Duke of York , the Earl of Northumberland , and other Lords , which were suspected to be of the confederacy of Henry Percy , to be his true Leige-men , and that they nor any of them should be impeached therefore , by the King or his Heirs in any time ensuing . 9 H. 4. The Speaker of the House of Commons presented a Bill on the behalf of Thomas Brooke against VVilliam Widecombe , and required Judgement against him ; which Bill was received and the said William Widecombe was notwithstanding bound in a 1000 pound to hear his Judgment in Chancery . And the many restorations in blood and estate in 13 H. 4 and by King E. 4 and of many of our Kings may inform us how necessary and beneficial the pardons , and mercy of our Kings and Princes have been to their People and Posterities . The Commons accuse the Lord Stanley in sundry particulars , for being confederate with the Duke of York , and pray that he may be committed to prison : to which the King answered , he will be advised . William de la Poole Duke of Suffolke being in a Parliament in the 28 th year of the Reign of King Henry the 6 th deeply charged by the Commons and not demanding his Peerage but submitting himself to the Kings grace and mercy was only banished for five years . Whereupon the Viscount Beaumont ▪ in the behalf of the Bishops and the Lords required that the said Judgment without their assent might be no barr to their priviledge of Peerage , but no saving at all either requested or granted for , or by the Commons . And Pardons before Indictments or prosecution have not been rejected for that they did anticipate any troubles which might afterwards happen . For so was the Earl of Shrewsbury's in the Reign of Queen Elizabeth for fear of being troubled by his ill willers for a sudden raising of men without a warrant to suppress an insurrection of Rebels . Lionell Cranfeild Earl of Middlesex Lord Treasurer of England , being about the 18 th year of King James , accused by the Lords & Commons in Parliament , for great offences and misdemeanours fined by the King in Parliament to be displaced , pay 50000 l. and never more to sit in Parliament , was in the 2 d year of the Reign of King Charles the Martyr , upon his Submission to the King and payment of 20000 l. only , pardoned of all Crimes , Offences and Misdemeanors whatsoever any Sentence , Act , or Order of Parliament , or the said Sentence to the contrary notwithstanding . For whether the accusation be for Treason wherein the King is immediately and most especially concerned , or for lesser Offences where the people may have some concernment , but nothing near so much or equivalent to that of the Kings being the supreme Magistrate , the King may certainly pardon and in many pardons as of Outlaries , Felonies , &c. there have been conditions annexed . Ita quod stent recto si quis versus eos loqui voluerit . So the Lord Keeper Coventry's in the Reign of King Charles the Martyr to prevent any dangerous questions , touching the receiving of Fines and other Proceedings in Chancery , sued out his Pardon . The many Acts of oblivion , or general pardon ; granted by many of our Kings and Princes , to the great comfort and quiet of their Subjects , but great diminution of the Crown revenue did not make them guilty , that afterwards protected themselves thereby from unjust and malicious adversaries . And where there is not such a clause it is always implyed by Law in particular mens cases , and until the Sovereignty can be found by Law to be in the people , neither the King or his people ( who by their Oaths of Allegiance and Supremacy are to be subordinate unto him ) are to be deprived of his haute et basse Justice , and are not to be locked up or restrained by any Petition , Charge or Surmise which is not to be accompted infallible , or a truth , before it be proved to the King and his Council of Peers in Parliament , and our Kings that gave the Lords of Manors , Powers of Soke and Sake , Infangtheif , and Outfangtheif in their Court Barons , and sometimes as large as Fossarum & Furcarum , and the incident Power of Pardons and Remissions of Fine and Forfeitures which many do at this day without contradiction of their other Tenants enjoy , should not be bereaved of as much liberty in their primitive and supream Estates as they gave them in their derivatives . And though there have been revocations of Patents during pleasure , of Protections and Presentations , and Revocations of Revocations quibusdam certis de causis , yet never was there any Revocation of any Pardon 's granted where the King was not abused or deceived in the granting thereof . For in Letters Patents for other matters Reversals were not to be accounted legal , where they were not upon just causes proved upon Writs of Scire facias issuing out of the Chancery , and one of the Articles for the deposing of King Richard the 2 d. being that he revoked some of his Pardons . The recep's of Patents of Pardon , or other things were ordained so to signifie the time when they were first brought to the Chancellour , as to prevent controversies concerning priority or delays , made use of in the Sealing of them to the detriment of those that first obtained them . And the various forms in the drawing or passing of Pardons as long ago His testibus , afterwards per manum of the Chancellour or per Regem alone , per nostre Main , vel per manum Regis , or per Regem & Concilium , or authoritate Parliamenti , per Regem & Principem , per Breve de privat . sigillo , or per immediate Warrant being never able to hinder the energy and true meaning thereof . And need not certainly be pleaded in any subordinate Court of Justice without an occasion or to purchase then allowance who are not to controul such an Act of their Sovereign . Doctor Manwaring in the fourth or sixth Year of the Reign of King Charles the Martyr being grievously fined by both Houses of Parliament , and made incapable of any place or Imployment ; was afterwards pardoned and made Bishop of St. Asaph with a non obstante of any order or Act of Parliament , So they that would have Attainders pass by Bill or Act of Parliament to make that to be Treason which by the Law and antient and reasonable Customs of England , was never so before to be believed or adjudged , or to Accumulate Trespasses and Misdemeanors to make that a Treason which singly could never be so , either in truth , Law , right , reason or Justice . May be pleased to admit and take into their serious consideration , that Arguments a posse ad esse , or ab uno ad plures , are neither usual or allowable , and that such a way of proceeding will be as much against the Rules of Law , Honour , and Justice as of Equity and good Conscience . And may be likewise very prejudicial to the very ancient and honourable House of Peers in Parliament , for these and many more to be added Reasons , viz. For former Ages knew no Bills of Attainder , by Act of Parliament after an Acquittal or Judgment in the House of Peers , until that unhappy one in the latter end of the Reign of King Charles the Martyr , which for the unusalness thereof had a special Proviso inserted , That it should not hereafter be drawn into Examples or made use of a President . And proved to be so fatally mischievous to that blessed King himself , and His three Kingdoms of England ; Scotland and Ireland , as he bewailed in his excellent Soliloquies , and at his Death , his consenting to such an Act , and charged His Majesty that now is , never to make Himself or His People , to be partakers of any more such Mischief procuring State-Errors . The House of Commons if they will be Accusers , wherein they may be often mistaken , when they take it from others , and have no power to examine upon Oath , wild and envious Informations , and at the same time a part of the Parliament , subordinate to the King , will in such an Act of Attainder be both Judge and Party , which all the Laws in the World could never allow to be just . And such a course , if suffered , must needs be derogatory and prejudicial to the Rights and Priviledges , and Judicative Power of the Peers in Parliament , unparallelled , and unpresidented , when any Judgments given by them , shall by such a Bill of Attainder , like a Writ of Error , or as an Appeal from them to the House of Commons , be en●rvated or quite altered by an Act of Attainder framed by the House of Commons , whereby they which shall be freed or absolved by their Peers , or by that Honourable and more wise Assembly , shall by such a back or by-blow be condemned , or if only Fined by the House of Peers , may be made to forfeit their Lives , Estates and Posterities by the House of Commons ; or if condemned in the Upper House , be absolved in the Lower , who shall thereby grow to be so formidable as none of the Peerage , or Kings Privy-Council shall dare to displease them , and where the dernier Ressort , or Appeal , was before and ought ever to be to the King in His House of Peers , or without , will thus be lodged in the House of Commons , and of little avail will the Liberty of our Nobility be to be tryed by their own Peers , when it shall be contre caeur , and under the Control of the House of Commons . Or that the Commons disclaiming , as they ought , any power or Cognisance in the matters of War and Peace , should by a Bill of Attainder make themselves to be Judges and Parties against a Peer , both of the Kings Privy Council and Great Council in Parliament , touching Matters of that Nature . For if the Commons in Parliament had never after their own Impeachments of a Peer or Commoner , Petitioned the King to pardon the very Persons which they had Accused , as they did in the Cases of Lyons and John Pechie , in the 51 year of the Reign of King Edward the Third , whom they had fiercely accused in Parliament but the year before , the Objection that a Pardon ought not to be a Bar against an Impeachment might have had more force than it is like to have . Neither would it or did it discourage the exhibiting any for the future , no more than it did the many after Impeachments , which were made by the Commons in several Parliaments , and Kings Reigns , whereupon punishments severe enough ensued ; For if the very many Indictments and Informations at every Assizes and Quarter-Sessions in the Counties , and in the Court of Kings-Bench at Westminster , in the Term time , ever since the Usurpation and Reign of King Stephen , and the Pardon 's granted shall be exactly searched and numbred , the foot of the Accompt will plainly demonstrate , that the Pardons for Criminal Offences have not been above or so many as one in every hundred , or a much smaller and inconsiderable number , either in or before the first or later instance , before Tryal or after , and the Pardon 's granted by our Kings , so few and seldom , as it ought to be confest , that that Regal Power only proper for Kings , the Vicegerents of God Almighty , not of the People , hath been modestly and moderately used , and that the multitude of Indictments and Informations , and few Pardon 's now extant in every year , will be no good Witnesses of such a causelesly feared discouragement . And it will not be so easily proved , as it is fancied that there ever was by our Laws or reasonable Customs any Institution to preserve the Government by restraining the Prince , against whom and no other the Contempt and Injury is immediately committed from pardoning offences against Him , and in Him against the People to whose charge they are by God intrusted . Or that there was any such institution ( which would be worth the seeing if it could be found or heard of ) that it was the Chief , or that without it consequently the Government it self would be destroyed . To prove which groundless Institution the Author of those Reasons is necessitated ( without resorting as he supposeth to greater Antiquities ) to vouch to Warranty the Declaration of that excellent Prince , King Charles the First of Blessed Memory , made in that behalf ( when there was no Controversie or Question in agitation or debate touching the power of pardoning ) in his Answer to the nineteen Propositions of both Houses of Parliament , wherein stating the several parts of this well regulated Monarchy , he saith , the King , the House of Lords , and the House of Commons , have each particular Priviledges . Wherein amongst those which belong to the King , he reckons the power of pardoning , if the Framer of those Reasons might have been fair and candid , and added the Words immediately following , viz. And some more of the like kind are placed in the King. And this kind of excellently tempered Monarchy , having the power to preserve that Authority , without which it would be disabled to protect the Laws in their Force , and the Subjects in their Peace , Liberties , and Properties , ought to have drawn unto Him such a respect and reverence from the Nobility and Great Ones , as might hinder the Ills of Division and Faction ; and cause such a Fear and Respect from the People as may hinder Tumults and Violence . But the design being laid and devised to tack and piece together such parcels of His said late Majesties Answer , as might make most for the advantage of the Undertaker to take the Power of Pardoning from the Prince , and lodge it in the People , and do what they can to create a Soveraignty or Superiority in them , which cannot consist with his antient Monarchy , and the Laws and reasonable Customs of the Kingdom , the Records , Annals and Histories , Reason , Common Sense and understanding thereof , the long and very long approved usages of the Nation , and Oaths of Allegiance and Supremacy of those that would now not only deny but be above it . And would make the King , by some scattered or distorted parts of that Answer , mangled and torn from the whole context and purpose of it , to give away those undoubted Rights of his Crown , for which , and the preservation of the Liberties of His People , he died a Martyr ; the Author and his Party endeavouring all they can to translate the Assent of the Commons required in the levying of Money into that of the power of pardoning , and jumbling the Words and Sense of that Royal Answer , cements and puts together others of their own to fortifie and make out their unjust purposes , omitting every thing that might be understood against them , or give any disturbance thereunto . And with this resolution the Author proceedeth to do as well as he can , and saith : After the enumeration of which , and other His Prerogatives , His said Majesty adds thus ; Again ( as if it related to the matter of pardoning which it doth not at all , but only and properly to the levying of Money , wherein that Misinterpreter can afford to leave out His said Majesties Parenthesis ( which is the Sinews as well of Peace as War ) that the Prince may not make use of this high and perpetual Power to the hurt of those for whose good he hath it , and make use of the Name of Publick Necessity ( which clearly evidenceth that his late Majesty thereby only intended that part of his Answer to relate to the levying of Money ) for the gain of his private Favorites and Followers to the detriment of his People . Whither being come , our Man of Art or putter of his Matters together , finds some words which will not at all serve his turn inclosed in a Royal Parenthesis of his late Majesty , viz. ( An excellent Conserver of Liberty , but never intended for any share in Government , or the choosing of them that should govern ) but looked like a deep and dangerous Ditch which might Sowse him over head and ears , if not drown him and spoil all his inventions , and therefore well bethinks himself , retires a little , begins at An excellent Conserver of Liberty , makes that plural , adds , &c. which is not in the Original , fetches his seeze and leaps quite over all the rest of the Parenthesis , as being a Noli me tangere , dangerous words and of evil consequence , and having got over goeth on until he came to some just and considerable expostulations of his late Majesty , and then as if he had been in some Lincolnshire Fens and Marshes , is again enforced to leap until he come to , Therefore the Power legally placed in both Houses , is more than sufficient to prevent and restrain the Power of Tyranny . But not liking the subsequent words of his late Majesty , viz. And without the Power which is now asked from Vs , we shall not be able to discharge that Trust which is the end of Monarchy , since that would be a total subversion of the Fundamental Laws , and that excellent Constitution of this Kingdom , which hath made this Nation for many years both famous and happy to a great degree of envy , is glad to take his leave with an , &c. and meddle no more with such Edge-Tools , wherewith that Royal Answer was abundantly furnished . But looks back and betakes himself to an Argument framed out of some Melancholick or Feverish Fears and Jealousies , that until the Commons of England have right done unto them against that Plea of Pardon , they may justly apprehend that the whole Justice of the Kingdom in the Case of the five Lords , may be obstructed and defeated by Pardons of a like nature . As if the pardoning of one must of necessity amount to many , or all , in offences of a different nature committed at several times by several persons ( which is yet to be learned ) and the Justice of the Nation which hath been safe and flourished for many Ages , notwithstanding some necessary Pardons granted by our Princes , can be obstructed or defeated in a well constituted Government under our Kings and Laws ; so it may everlastingly be wondred upon what such jealousies should now be founded , or by what Law or Reason to be satisfied , if it shall thus be suffered to run wild or mad . For Canutus in his Laws ordained that there should be in all Punishments a moderata misericordia , and that there should be a misericordia in judicio exhibenda , which all our Laws , as well those in the Saxon and Danish times as since , have ever intended , and it was wont to be a parcel of good Divinity that Gods Mercy is over all his Works , who not seldom qualifies and abates the rigour of his Justice . When Trissilian Chief Justice , and Brambre Major of London , were by Judgment of the Parliament of the Eleventh of King Richard the second , Hanged and Executed , the Duke of Ireland banished , some others not so much punished , and many of their Complices pardoned , the people that did not know how soon they might want Pardons for themselves , did not afflict themselves or their Sovereign with Complaints and Murmurings that all were not Hanged and put to the extremities of Punishment ; nor was Richard Earl of Arundel , one of the fierce Appellants in that Matter , vexed at the pardoning of others , when he in a Revolution and Storm of State was within ten years after glad to make use of a Pardon for himself . King James pardoned Sir Walter Rawleigh , the Lord Cobham , Sir Griffin Markham with many others then guilty of Treason , and the Earl of Somerset and his Lady , for the Murder of Sir Thomas Overbury , without any commotion in the Brains of the rest of his Subjects , some of whom were much disturbed that he after caused Sir Walter Rawleigh to be executed for a second offence upon the Score of the former , not at all pardoned , but reprieved or only respited . And therefore whilest we cry out and wonder quantum mutantur tempora , may seek and never find what ever was or can be any necessary cause or consequence that the five Lords accused of High Treason , and a design of killing the King , will be sure to have a Pardon , if that the Pardon of the Earl of Danby , whose design must be understood by all men rather to preserve him , shall be allowed . Nor doth an Impeachment of the House of Commons virtually , or ever can from the first Constitution of it be proved or appear to be the voice of every particular Subject of the Kingdom ; for if we may believe Mr. William Pryn , one of their greatest Champions , and the Records of the Nation and Parliaments , the Commons in Parliament do not , or ever did Represent , or are Procurators for the Lords Spiritual and Temporal and their numerous Tenants and ancient Baronies , and those that hold or do now hold in Capite , nor for the many Tenants that should be of the Kings ancient Demesne and Revenues , nor for the Clergy , the multitude of Copyholders heretofore , as much as the fourth part of the Kingdom , neither the great number of Lease-holders , Cottagers , &c. that are not Freeholders , Citizens or Trades-men , nor can all the Members of the Body Politick be equally wounded in their Estates or concernments by the vain imaginations , causless fears , and jealousies and bugbears of other seditious or fanciful Mens own making . And to men that have not yet proceeded so far in the School of Revelation as to be sure of the Spirit of Prophesie , it may prove a matter of ill consequence that the universality of the People should have occasion ministred and continued to them to be apprehensive of utmost dangers from the Crown , from whence they of right expect Protection . And a Wonder next a Miracle , from whence the Premisses to such a trembling and timorous conclusion can be fetched , or how a People , whose valiant and wiser Forefathers were never heretofore scared with such panick fears , nor wont to be affrighted with such Phantasmes , should now suspect they can have no Protection from the Crown , when some of them do at the same time labour all they can to hinder it . Or how it should happen in the long Rebellious Parliament that after Mr. Chaloner a Linnen Draper of London , was hanged for Plotting a Surprize of the City of London and reducing it to the Kings obedience , honest Mr. Abbot the Scrivener should be pardoned without any such discontent and murmuring of the People , or that Oliver Cromwell should not be debarred of his Power of Pardoning in his Instrument of Government , and be allowed to Pardon the Lord Mordant for a supposed Treason against his usurped Authority ; and our King deriving his Authority , legally vested in Him and His Royal Ancestors , for more than one thousand years before , may not adventure to do it without the utter undoing and ruine of his Subjects in their Properties , Lives and Estates , by His pardoning of some Capital Offenders : Or why it should not be as lawful and convenient for the King to grant Pardons to some other Men , as to Doctor Oates or Mr. Bedlow . When no Histories Jewish , Pagan or Christian , can shew us a People Petitioning their Kings , that they would not Pardon , when all are not like to be Saints or Faultless , and it will ever be better to leave it to the Hearts of Kings , and God that directs them , than to believe Tyranny to be a Blessing , and Petition for it . And the most exact search that can be made , when it findeth the Commons petitioning in Parliament to the King or House of Peers , that they may be present at some Tryals there , upon their Impeachments , cannot meet with any one President where they ever desired , or were granted such a reasonless Request , pursued and set on by other Mens Designs to have one Mans Tryal had before another , and by strugling and wrestling for it , expose the King and Kingdom to an utter destruction . And therefore in those their fond importunities might do well to tarry until they can find some Reason why the Lords Spiritual may not Vote or Sit as Judges or Peers in Parliament , in the Case of the five-Lords , as well as of the Earl of Danby . Or any President that it is or hath been according to Parliamentary proceedings to have any such Vote or Request made by the Commons in Parliament . Who neither were or should be so omnipotent in the opinion of Hobart and Hutton and other the learned Judges of England , as to make a Punishment before a Law , or Laws with a Retrospect , which God himself did never allow , but should rather believe that Laws enacted contrary to the Laws of God and Morality , or that no Aids or Help are to be given to the King pro bono publico , or that there should be no Customs or Prescription , or that the King should be governed by His People , would be so far from gaining an Obedience to such Laws or Acts of Parliament as to render them , to be ipso facto null and of none effect . When the King hath been as careful to distribute Justice as his Mercy , without violence to his Laws and well-inform'd Conscience hath sometimes perswaded him to Pardon , to do Justice , or to cause it to be done in a legal and due manner , and is so appropriate to the Office and Power of a King , so annext , appendant and a part of it , as none but His Delegates are to intermeddle or put any limits thereunto , and if it should not be so solely inherent in Him would be either in abeyance or no where . For the House of Commons are neither a Judicature or sworn to do Justice , and if they were , would be both Judges and Parties , and the Lords Spiritual and Temporal are not as to particular proceedings sworn but meerly consultive ; So as Justice can vest in none but the King , who is by his Coronation-Oath only sworn to do it , if His Right of Inheritance and greater Concernments than any of His Subjects , did not abundantly ingage and prompt Him thereunto ; and is therefore so every way , and at all times obliged to do Justice and Protect the Lives , Estates , Peace and Liberty of His Subjects , as he is with all convenient speed and hast to Try or bring to Judgment , a Subject accused of Treason by the Houses of Lords and Commons , both or either of them in His Court of Kings-Bench before the Justices thereof , or by special Commission by a Lord High Steward in or without the time of Parliament . And the King may acquit ( which amounteth to a Remission or Pardon ) by a more Supreme Authority than any of His Judges ( some particular Cases wherein Appeals are , or may be brought , only excepted ) do ordinarily by an authority derived from no other , not to be debarred by probabilities , or possibilities , or by consequences , not always to be foreseen or avoided . For a Man pardoned for Man-slaughter , may be so unhappy as in the like manner afterwards to be the death of five or ten more ; 20000. Rebells pardoned at a time as in the Insurrections of Wat Tyler , Jack Cade , &c. may be guilty of the like Offence , twenty or forty years after : The Lord Mayor of London that hath an allowance of Tolls and Profits to take a care of the City and wholsomness of Food , might be , as they are , too much careless and undo them in their Health and well being . The Judges may as those in the Reign of King Edward the First , and Thorp in the Reign of King Edward the Third , be guilty of Misdemeanours , yet that is not to bereave us of that good which better Men may do us in their administration of Justice , our Kings have granted Priviledges , to certain Cities and Towns not to pay Subsidies , and granted Pardons as their Mercies and right reason inclined them , in the course of their several Reigns for many Ages last past , yet have not acquitted or left unpunished all the Offenders ever since , there being a greater likelyhood that they would not be so easie in pardoning , where they were to gain so much by Attainders , Fines and Forfeitures . And therefore panick & vain Fears , such as in constantem virum cadere non possunt , should not be permitted to affright our better to be imployed Imaginations , unless we had a mind to be as wise as a small and pleasant Courtier of King Henry the Eighths who would never endure to pass in a Boat under London-Bridge lest it should fall upon his Head , because it might once happen to do so . Our Magna Charta's and all our Laws which ordain no man to be condemned or punished without Tryal by his Peers , do allow it where it is by Confession , Outlawry , &c. and no Verdict . Did never think it fit that Publick Dangers , such as Treason should tarry , where Justice may as well be done otherwise without any precise Formalities to be used therein . For although it may be best done by the advice of the Kings greatest Council the Parliament , there is no Law or reasonable Custom of England either by Act of Parliament , or without , that restrains the King to do it only in the time of Parliament . When the Returns , Law-Days and Terms appointed and fixt , have ever given place to our Kings Commissions of Oyer and Terminer , Inquiries , &c. upon special and emergent occasions . And notwithstanding it will be always adviseable that Kings should be assisted by their greatest Council , when it may be had yet there is no Law or Act of Parliament extant , or any right reason or consideration to bind Him from making use of His ordinary Council in a Case of great and importunate necessity for the Tryal of Peers by their Peers , before a Lord High Steward , attended by the Kings learned Judges of the Law. For Cases of Treason , Felony and Trespass , being excepted out of Parliament , first and last granted and indulged Priviledges by our and their Kings and Princes , there can be no solid Reason or cogent Argument to perswade any man that the King cannot for the preservation of Himself and His People , in the absence or interval of Parliaments , punish and try Offenders in Cases of Treason , without which there can be no Justice , Protection or Government , if the Power of the King and Supreme Magistrate shall be tyed up by such , or the like as may happen , Obstructions . So until the Honourable House of Commons can produce some or any Law , Agreement , Pact , Concession , Liberty or Priviledge to Sit and Counsel the King , whether he will or no , as long as any of their Petitions remain unanswered ( which they never yet could or can ) ( those grand Impostures and Figments of the Modus tenendi Parliamenta and the supposed Mirror of Justice , being as they ought to be rejected ) when the Parliament Records will witness that many Petitions have , for want of time ( most of the ancient Parliaments not expending much of it ) been adjourned to be determined in other Courts , as in the Case of Staunton in 14 E. 3. and days have been limited to the Commons for the exhibiting of their Petitions ; the Petitions of the Corbers depended all the Reigns of King Edward the First and Second , until the eleventh year of Edward the Third , which was about sixty six years , and divers Petitions not dispatched , have in the Reign of King Richard the Second , been by the King referred to the Chancellor and sometimes with a direction to call to his assistance the Justices and the Kings Serjeants at Law , and the Commons themselves have at other times prayed to have their Petitions determined by the Councel of the King or by the Lord Chancellor . And there will be reason to believe that in Cases of urgent necessity for publick safety , the King is & ought to be at liberty to try & punish great and dangerous Offenders without His Great Council of Parliament . The Petitions in Parliament touching the pardoning of Richard Lyons , John Peachie , Alice Peirce , &c. and a long process of William Montacute Earl of Salisbury were renewed and repeated again in the Parliament of the first of Richard the Second , because the Parliament was ended before they could be answered . Anno 1. of King Richard the Second , John Lord of Gomenez formerly committed to the Tower for delivering up of the Town of Ardes in that Kings time , of which he took upon him the safe keeping in the time of King Edward the Third , and his excuse being disproved , the Lords gave Judgment that he should dye , but in regard he was a Gentleman and a Baronet and had otherwise well served , should be beheaded and Judgment respited until the King should be thereof fully informed , and was thereupon returned again to the Tower. King Henry the Second , did not tarry for the assembling a Parliament to try Henry de Essex , his Standard-bearer , whom he disherited for throwing it down and affrighting his Host or disheartning it . 16 E. 2. Henry de bello monte a Baron refusing to come to Parliament upon Summons was by the King , Lords and Council , and the Judges , and Barons of the Exchequer then assisting committed for his contempt to Prison . Anno 3 E. 3. the Bishop of Winchester was indicted in the Kings-Bench for departing from the Parliament at Salisbury . Neither did Henry the Eight forbear the beheading of His great Vicar-General Cromwell , upon none or a very small evidenced Treason , until a Parliament should be Assembled . The Duke of Somerset was Indicted of Treason and Felony , the second of December , Anno 3 & 4 Edwardi 6. sitting the Parliament , which began the fourth day of November , in the third year of His Reign , and ended the first day of February in the fourth , was acquitted by his Peers for Treason , but found guilty of Felony , for which neglecting to demand his Clergy he was put to Death . In the Reign of King Philip and Queen Mary , thirty nine of the House of Commons in Parliament ( whereof the famous Lawyer Edmond Plowden was one ) were Indicted in the Court of Kings-Bench , for being absent without License from the Parliament . Queen Elizabeth Charged and Tryed for Treason , and Executed Mary Queen of Scots her Feudatory , without the Advice of Parliament , and did the like with Robert Earl of Essex her special Favourite , for in such Cases of publick and general Dangers , the shortest delays have not seldom proved to be fatally mischievous . And howsoever it was in the Case of Stratford , Archbishop of Canterbury in the fifteenth year of the Reign of King Edward the Third , declared that the Peers de la terre ne doivent estre arestez ne mesnez en Jugement , Si non en Parlement & par leur Pairres , yet when there is no Parliament , though by the Common-Law their Persons may not then also be Arrested at a common persons Suit , they may by other ways be brought to Judgment in any other Court. And Charges put in by the Commons in the House of Peers , against any of the Peers have been dissolved with it . For Sir Edward Coke hath declared it to be according to the Law and reasonable Customs of England , followed by the modern practice , that the giving any Judgment in Parliament doth not make is a Session , and that such Bills as passed in either or both Houses , and had no Royal Assent unto them , must at the next Assembly begin again ; for every Session of Parliament is in Law ( where any Bill hath gained the Royal Assent , or any Record upon a Writ of Error brought in the House of Peers hath been certified ) is and hath been accompted to have been a Session . And although some of this later quarrelling Age have Espoused an Opinion , too much insisted upon , that an Impeachment brought by the House of Commons against any one makes the supposed Offence , until it be Tryed , unpardonable . A Reason whereof is undertaken to be given , because that in all Ages it hath been an undoubted Right of the Commons to Impeach before the Lords any Subject for Treason or any Crime whatsoever . And the Reason of that Reason is ( supposed to be ) because great Offences complained of in Parliament , are most effectually determined in Parliament . Wherein they that are of that Opinion may be intreated to take into their more serious consideration ; That there neither is , nor ever was , any House or Members of Commons in Parliament , before the Imprisonment of King H. 3. by a Rebellious part of his Subjects , in the Forty ninth year of his Reign , or any kind of fair or just evidence for it . Factious designing and fond conjectures being not amongst good Patriots , or the Sons of Wisdom ever accompted to be a sufficient , or any evidence . Nor was the House of Lords from its first and more ancient original , intituled under their King to a Judicative Power to their Kings , in common or ordinary Affairs , but in arduis , and not in all things of that nature , but in quibusdam , as the King should propose and desire their advice , concerning the Kingdom and Church , in matters of Treason or publick concernments , and did understand themselves , and that high and honourable Court , to be so much forbid by Law , ancient usage and custom to intermeddle with petty or small Crimes or Matters , as our Kings have ever since the sixth year of the Reign of King Edward the first , ordained some part of the Honourable House of Peers , to be Receivers and Tryers of Petitions of the Members of the House of Commons themselves and others , directed to the King , to admit what they found could have no remedy in the ordinary Courts of Justice , and reject such as were properly elsewhere to be determined , with an Indorsement of non est Petitio Parliamenti . Which may well be believed to have taken much of its reason and ground from a Law made by King Canutus who began his Reign about the year of our Lord , 1016. Nemo de injuriis alterius Regi queratur nisi quidem in Centuria Justitiam consequi & impetrare non poterit . For certainly , if it should be otherwise , the reason and foundation of that highest Court would not be as it hath been hitherto , always understood to be with a Cognisance only de quibusdam arduis , matters of a very high nature concerning the King and the Church . But it must have silenced all other Courts and Jurisdictions , and have been a continual Parliament , a Goal-delivery or an intermedler in Matters as low as Court Leets , or Baron and County Courts , and a Pye-Powder Court. And the words of any Crime whatsoever do not properly signifie great Offences , and that all great Offences do concern the Parliament , is without a Key to unlock the Secret not at all intelligible , when it was never instituted or made to be a Court for common or ordinary Criminals . For the House of Commons were never wont to take more upon them than to be Petitioners and Assenters unto such things as the King by the advice of His Lords Spiritual and Temporal should ordain , and obey , and endeavour to perform them . And an Impeachment of the House of Commons cannot be said to be in the Name , or on the behalf of all the People of England , for that they never did or can represent the one half of them , and if they will be pleased to examine the Writs and Commissions granted by our Kings for their Election , and the purpose of the Peoples Election of them to be their Representatives , Substitutes or Procurators , it will not extend to accuse Criminals , for that appertained to the King himself and His Laws , care of Justice and the Publick ; the Common People had their Inferiour Courts and Grand Juries , Assises and Goal-Deliveries to dispatch such Affairs without immediately troubling Him or His Parliament , and the tenour and purpose of their Commissions and Elections to Parliament , is no more than ad faciendum & consentiendum iis to obey and perform such things as the King , by the advice of His Lords Spiritual and Temporal , should in Parliament ordain . For although where the Wife or Children of a Man murdered shall bring an Appeal , the King is debarred from giving a Pardon , because by our Saxon Laws derived from the Laws of God , they are not to be disturbed in that satisfaction which they ought to have by the loss or death of the Man murdered . Yet the publick Justice will not be satisfied without the party offending be Arraigned and brought to Judgment for it , if the party that hath right to Appeal should surcease or be bought off , so as an Appeal may be brought after or before the King hath Indicted , and an auter foitz acquit in the one case will not prejudice in the other , and where the Matter of Fact comes to be afterwards fully proved , and the Appeal of a Wife or Children of a Bastard called filius populi , quia nullius filius , where only the King is Heir , cannot vacate or supersede an Indictment of the Kings . Neither is an Appeal upon a Crime or in criminal Matters , in the first instance to be at all pursued in Parliament , by the Statute made in the First year of the Reign of King H. 4. the words whereof are , Item for many great inconveniencies and mischiefs that often have happened by many Appeals made within the Realm of England ( to the great afflictions and calamities of the Nation , as it afterwards happened by the Lancastrian Plots and Designs in that mischievous Appeal in Anno 11 of King Richard the Second ) before this time ; It is ordained and stablished from henceforth , That all the Appeals to be made of things done out of the Realm , shall be tryed and determined before the Constable and Marshal of England for the time being ; And moreover it is accorded and assented , That no Appeals be from henceforth made , or in any wise pursued in Parliament in any time to come . And therefore that allegation that the House of Peers cannot reject the Impeachment of the Commons , because that Suit or Complaint of the Commons can be determined no where else , will want a better foundation ( an Impeachment of the House of Commons , in the Name of all the People being no other than an Appeal to the King in Parliament . ) And the Suit of such as might be Appellants in another place ( being there expresly prohibited ) cannot be supposed to be the concern or interest of all the People deserving or requiring satisfaction , or especially provided for by Law to have satisfaction , unless it could by any probability or soundness of Judgment be concluded that all the People of England , besides Wives , Children or near Kindred and Relations ( the necessity of publick Justice and deterring Examples ) are or should be concerned in such a never to be fancied Appeal of the People . And it will be very hard to prove that one or a few are all the People of England , or if they could be so imagined , are to be more concerned than the King , who is sworn to do Justice , unless they would claim and prove a Sovereignty and to be sworn to do Justice , which though they had once by a villanous Rebellion attacked , until Oliver Cromwel their Man of Sin , cheated them of it ; for God would never allow them any such power or priviledge , or any Title to the Jesuits Doctrine , which some of our Protestant Dissenters , their modern Proselites , have learned of them , that the King although he be singulis major , is minor universis . And it is no denial of Justice in the House of Peers to deny the receiving of an Impeachment from the House of Commons , when they cannot understand any just cause or reason to receive it , and the Records , Rolls , Petitions and Orders of Parliament will inform those that will be at the pains to be rightly and truly directed by them , that Petitions in Parliament have been adjourned , modified or denied ; and that in the Common or Inferior Courts of Justice , Writs and Process may sometimes be denied , superseded or altered according to the Rules of Justice , or the circumstances thereof . And our Records can witness , that Plaintiffs have petitioned Courts of Justice recedere a brevi & impetrare aliud . And it cannot be said that the King doth denegare Justitiam , when he would bind them unto their ancient , legal , well experimented forms of seeking it in the pursuing their Rights and Remedies , and hinders them in nothing but seeking to hurt others and destroy themselves . For Justice no otherwise denied should not be termed Arbitrary , until there can be some solid reason , proof or evidence for it . When it is rather to be believed , that if the Factious Vulgar Rabble might have their Wills , they would never be content or leave their fooling until they may obtain an unbounded liberty of tumbling and tossing the Government into as many several Forms and Methods , as there be days in the year , and no smaller variety of Religions . And they must be little conversant with our Records , that have not understood that the Commons have many times received just denials to their Petitions , and that some have not seldom wanted the foundations of Reason or Justice . That many of their Petitions have adopted the Concerns and Interests of others , that were either Strangers unto them , or the Designs of some of the grand Nobility who thought them as necessary to their purposes as Wind , Tide , and Sails are to the speeding of a Ship into the Port or Landing-places of their Designs . For upon their exhibiting in a Parliament in the 28 year of the Reign of King Henry the Sixth , abundance of Articles of High Treason , and Misdemeanours , against William de la Poole , Duke of Suffolk ; one whereof was that he had sold the Realm of England to the French King , who was preparing to invade it . When they did require the King and House of Lords that the Duke ( whom not long before they had recommended to the King to be rewarded for special services ) might be committed Prisoner to the Tower of London , the Lords and Justices upon consultation , thought it not reasonable unless some special Matter was objected against him . Whereupon the said Duke not putting himself upon his Peerage , but with protestation of his innocency , only submitting himself to the Kings mercy , who acquitting him from the Treason and many of the Misdemeanours ▪ and for some or them by the advice of the Lords , only banished him for five years . And that thereupon when the Viscount Beaumont in the behalf of the Lords Spiritual and Temporal required that it might be Inrolled that the Judgment was by the Kings own Rule , & not by their Assent , and that neither they nor their Heirs should by this Example be barred of their Peerage . No Protestation appears to have been made by any of the Lords Spiritual or Temporal for or on the behalf of the Commons . Or by the Commons for themselves . So as a different manner of doing Justice can neither truly or rationally be said to be an absolute denial of Justice , and was never believed to be so by the Predecessors of the House of Commons in Parliament in our former Kings Reigns , when some hundreds of their Petitions in Parliament have been answered by , There is a Law already provided , or let the old Law stand , or the King will provide a convenable or fitting remedy . And is not likely if it were , as it is not to be , any Arbitrary Power , or any temptation or inducement thereunto , to produce any Rule or incouragement to the exercise of an Arbitrary Power in the Inferiour Courts , when there is none so weak in his Intellect , but may understand that different Courts have several Boundaries , Methods and Forms of Proceedings , and that the Kings extraordinary great Court and Councel in His House of Peers although very just and unarbitrary in their procedures , is so always ready to succour the Complaints of People , as it never willingly makes it self to be the cause of it . And cannot misrepresent the House of Peers to the King and his People , in the Case of Mr. Fitz-Harris , or any others , when that honourable Assembly takes so much care as it doth to repress Arbitrary Power , and doth all it can to protect the whole Nation from it , and many of the House of Commons Impeachments have been disallowed by the King and his House of Peers in Parliament without any ground or cause of fear of Arbitrary Power , which can no where be so mischievously placed , as in the giddy multitude whose Impeachments would be worse than the Ostracisme at Athens , and so often overturn and tire all the wise men and good men in the Nation as there would be none but such as deserve not to be so stiled , to manage the Affairs of the Government , subordinate to their King and Sovereign . To all which may be added , if the former Presidents cited to assert the Kings Power of Pardoning aswell after an Impeachment made by the Commons in Parliament , as before and after an Impeachment received by the Lords in Parliament , or made both by the Lords and Commons in Parliament , and after an Impeachment received by the Lords in Parliament , or made both by the Lords and Commons in Parliament be not sufficient that of Hugh le Despenser , Son of Hugh le Despenser , the younger , a Lord of a great Estate , which is thus entred in the Parliament Roll of the fifth year of the Reign of King Edward the Third , ought surely to satisfie , that the Laws and reasonable Customs of England will warrant it . Anno 5 E. 3. Sir Eubule le Strange and eleven other Mainprisers , being to bring forth the Body of Hugh the Son of Hugh le Despenser the younger , saith the Record , A respondre au prochein Parlement & de ester an droit & affaire ce & de liu en conseil soit ordine & mesuerent le Corps le dit Hugh devant nostre Seigneur le Roi Countes Barons & autres Grantz en mesme le Parlement & monstrent les L'res Patents du Roi de Pardon al dit Hugh forisfacturam vite & membrorum sectam pacis homicidia roborias Felonias & omnes transgressiones , &c. Dated 20 Martii anno primo Regni sui Et priant a n're Seigneur le Roi quil le vousist delivrer de las Mainprise & faire audit Hugh sa grace & n're Seigneur le Roi eiant regard a ses dites L'res & voilant uttroier a la Priere le dit Mons'r Eble & autres Mainpernors avant dit & auxint de les Prelatz qui prierent molt especialment pur lui si ad comande de sa grace sa delivrance . Et voet que ses Menpernors avant ditz & chescun d' eux soient dischargez de leur Mainprise & auxint & le dit Hugh soit quit & delivrers de Prisone & de garde yssint & si ho'me trove cause devers lui autre & nest uncore trove quil estoise au droit . And the English Translator , or Abridger of the Parliament Records , hath observed that the old usage was , that when any person being in the Kings displeasure , was thereof acquitted by Tryal or Pardon , yet notwithstanding he was to put in twelve of his Peers to be his Sureties for his good Behaviour at the Kings pleasure . And may be accompanied by the Case of Richard Earl of Arundel in the 22 year of the Reign of King Richard the Second , being Appealed by the Lords Appellant , and they requiring the King , that such persons Appealed , that were under Arrest , might come to their Tryal , it was commanded to Ralph , Lord Nevil , Constable of the Tower of London to bring forth the said Richard Earl of Arundel , then in his custody , whom the said Constable brought into the Parliament , at which time the Lords Appellants came also in their proper Persons . To the which Earl the Duke of Lancaster ( who was then hatching the Treason which afterwards in Storms of State and Blood came to effect against the King ) by the Kings Commandment and Assent of the Lords declared the whole circumstances ; after the reading and declaring whereof the Earl of Arundel , who in Anno 11 of that Kings Reign , had been one of the Appellants , together with Henry Earl of Derby son of the said Duke of Lancaster , and afterwards the usurping King Henry the Fourth against Robert de Vere , Duke of Ireland and Earl of Oxford , and some other Ministers of State , under King Richard the Second , alledged that he had one Pardon granted in the Eleventh year of the Reign of King Richard the Second , and another Pardon granted but six years before that present time . And prays that they might be allowed . To which the Duke answered , that for as much as they were unlawfully made , the present Parliament had revoked them . And the said Earl therefore was willed to say further for himself at his peril ; whereupon Sir Walter Clopton , Chief Justice , by the Kings Commandment declared to the said Earl , that if he said no other thing , the Law would adjudge him guilty of all the Actions against him . The which Earl notwithstanding would say no other thing , but required allowance of his Pardons . And thereupon the Lords Appellant in their proper Persons , desired that Judgment might be given against the said Earl as Convict of the Treason aforesaid . Whereupon the Duke of Lancaster , by the Assent of the King , Bishops and Lords , adjudged the said Earl to be Convict of all the Articles aforesaid , and thereby a Traytor to the King and Realm , and that he should be hanged , drawn and quartered , and forfeit all his Lands in Fee or Fee-tail , as he had the nineteenth day of September , in the tenth year of the Kings Reign , together with all his Goods and Chattels . But for that the said Earl was come of noble Blood and House , the King pardoned the hanging , drawing and quartering , and granted that he should be beheaded ; which was done accordingly . But Anno 1 Hen. 4. the Commons do pray the reversal of that Judgment given against him , and restoration of Thomas the Son and Heir of the said Richard Earl of Arundel . Unto which the King answered , he hath shewed favour to Thomas now Earl , and to others , as doth appear . The Commons do notwithstanding pray , that the Records touching the Inheritance of the said Richard Earl of Arundel , late imbezelled , may be searched for and restored . Unto which was answered , the King willeth . And their noble Predecessors in that Honourable House of Peers , the Lords Spiritual and Temporal in Parliament long before that , videlicet , in the fifth year of the Reign of King Edward the Third , made no scruple or meet point or question in Law , whether the power of pardoning was valid and solely in the King after an Impeachment of the Lords in Parliament , when in the Case of Edmond Mortimer , the Son of Roger Mortimer Earl of March a Peer of great Nobility and Estate , the Prelats , Counts , Barons , & autres gentz du Parlement , did in full Parliament , as the Record it self will evidence , Petition the King to restore the said Edmond Mortimer to his Blood and Estate which were to remain unto him after the death of his said Father , to whom it was answered by the King in these words ; Et sur ce nostre Seigneur le Roi chargea les ditz Prelats , Countes ▪ & Barons en leur foies & ligeance queux ils lui devoient & de puis ce que le Piere nostre Seigneur le Roi que ore est estoit murdre per le dit Counte de la Marche & person procurement a ce quil avoit mesmes comdevant sa mort que eux eant regarda le Roi en tiel cas lui consilassent ce quil devoit faire de reson audit Esmon filz le dit Counte les queux Prelats , Countes , Barons & autres _____ avys & trete entre eux respondirent a nostre Seigneur _____ le Roi de Common assent que en regard a si horrible fait comme de murdre _____ de terre & lour Seigneur lige quen faist unques me avoient devant en leur temps ne nes devant venir en le eyde de dieu quils ne scavoient uncore Juger ne conseiller ceque serroit affaire en tiel cas . Et sur ce prierent a nostre Seigneur le Roi quils poierent ent aver avisement tanque au prochein Parlement la quelle priere le Roi ottroia & sur ce prierent outre que nostre Seigneur le Roi feist au dit Esmon sa bone grace a quoi il respond quil lui voloit faire mes cella grace vendroit de lui mesmes . Sir Thomas de Berkeley ( who Sir William Dugdale in his Book of the Baronage of England , found and believes to have been a Baron ) being called to account by the King , for the murder of his Father King Edward the Second , to whose custody at his Castle of Barkeley , he was committed , not claiming his Peerage , but pleading that he was at the same time sick almost to death at Bradely , some miles distant , and had committed the custody and care of the King unto Thomas de Gourney & William de Ocle ad eum salvo custodiendi , and was not guilty of the murder of the King or any ways assenting thereunto Et de illo posuit se super Patriam , had a Jury of twelve Knights sworn and impannelled in Parliament who acquitted him thereof , but finding that he had committed the custody of the King to the aforesaid Thomas de Gournay & William de Ocle , and that the King extitit murderatus , a further day was given to the said Sir Thomas de Berkeley de audiendo Judicio suo in prox . Parliamento , and he was in the interim committed to the custody of Ralph de Nevil Steward of the Kings Houshold . At which next Parliament Prierent les Prelatz ▪ Countes & Barons a nostre Seigneur le Roi on the behalf of the said Sir Thomas de Berkeley , that he would free him of his Bayl or Mainprize , whereupon the King charging the said Prelats , Counts and Barons to give him their advice therein : Le quel priere fust ottroia & puis granta nostre Seigneur le Roi de rechef a leur requeste que le dit Mons'r Thomas & ses Mainpernors fusseient delivres & discharges de lure mainprise & si estoit Jour donne a dit Thomas de estre en prochein Parlement , which proved to be a clear Dismission , for no more afterwards appeareth of that matter . Neither after a fierce Impeachment in the said Parliament of 21 R. 2. against Thomas Arundel Archbishop of Canterbury and Chancellor of England , of High Treason , upon which he was by that injuried Prince condemned and banished , when as the Record saith , Les dits Countz prierent , au Roi ordenir tiel Jugement vers le dit Ercevesque come le cas demande & le Roi sur ceo Recorda en le dit Parlement que le dit Ercevesque avoit este devant lui en presence de certeines Seigneurs & confessor que en la use de la dite Commission il sey mesprise & lui mist en la grace du Roi surquoi , the Judgment was given against the said Archbishop , that he should be banished and forfeit all his Lands , Goods and Estate , when in the first year of the Reign of the usurping King H. 4. that Archbishop not tarrying long in Exile , the minds of the Commons became so setled on the prevailing side , there was so small or no opposition made by them against him , as the Duke of York and Earl of Northumberland , and others of the Blood of the said Archbishop of Canterbury did in Parliament pray the King that the said Archbishop might have his recovery against Roger Walden , for sundry Wasts and Spoils done by him in the Lands of the said Archbishoprick , which the King granted , and thanked them for their motion . The Bishop of Exeter Chancellor of England at the assembling of the Parliament , taking his Text out of the Prophecy of Ezekiel , Rexerit unus omnibus , alledging the power that ought to be in Soveraign Kings and Princes whereby to govern , and the Obedience in Subjects to obey , and that all alienations of his Kingly Priviledges and Prerogatives were reassumable and to be Repealed by his Coronation-Oath , Pour quoi le Roi ad fut assembler le Estatz de Parlement a cest faire pour estre enformer si ascun droitz de sa Corone soient sustretz ou amemuser a fin que par leur bon advis & discretion tiel remedie puisse estre mis que le Roi puisse esteer en sa libertie ou poir Comme ses Progenitors ont este devant lui & duissent de droit non obstante ascun ordinance au contraire & ainsi le Roi as Tener , Et les governera , whereupon the Commons made their Protestation , and prayed the King that it might be Inrolled , that it was not their intente ou volunte to Impeach or Accuse any Person in that Parliament sans congie du Roi , And thereupon the Chancellor by the Kings command , likewise declared , That Nostre Seigneur le Roi considerant coment plusieurs hautes offenses & mesfaits on t estre faitz par le People de son Roialme en contre leur ligeance & l' Estat nostre Seigneur le Roi & la loie de la terre devant ces heures dont son People estiet en grant perill & danger de leie & leur corps & biens & voullant sur ce de sa royalle benignite monstre & faire grace a son dit People a fyn quilz ayent le greindre corage & volonte de bien faire & de leure mieux porter devots le Roi en temps avenir si voet & grante de faire & ease & quiete & salvation de son dit People une generalle Pardon a ces liges forspries certaines pointz limitez par le samant la suite al partie forspris cyn quont persones queux plaira au Roi nomer & tour ceux qui serront Empecher en ce present Parlement & dit austre que le dit Roi voet que plein droit & Justice soyent faitz a Chascun de ses liges qui en violent complandre en cest Parlement & ad ordiner & assigner Receivers & Triers des Petitions en cest Parlement . And did in pursuance thereof in full Parliament excuse , the Duke of York , the Bishop of Worcester , Sir Richard le Scroop then living , William late Archbishop of Canterbury , Alexander late Archbishop of York , Thomas late Bishop of Exeter , and Michael late Abbot of Walton then being dead , of the Execution and intent of the Commission made in the Tenth year of his Reign , as being assured of their Loyalty , and therefore by Parliament restored them to their good Name . And it is more than a little probable that the Prelates , Counts and Barons in that Honourable House of Peers in Parliament , did well understand that the King was a fit , and the only person to Petition unto for that Pardon , Discharge or Dismission amounting to a Pardon , and did not think it to be either legal or rational to Petition the People and their Fellow Subjects , upon a supposed incredible and invisible Soveraignty , no man knows when or how radicated and inherent in them . The Decree of the great Ahashuerus that Reigned from India to Ethiopia , over one hundred twenty seven Provinces , whose Laws were holden to be irrevocable , was reversed for the preservation of the Jewish Nation upon the Petition of Queen Esther , and his holding out his Golden Scepter unto her . The unquiet People of Athens now come enough under a Mahometan Slavery , would not again wish for Draco's bloody repealed Laws , without the mercy of a Prince to moderate them according to the Rules of a prudent and discerning mercy . Which made the Goodness and Wisdom of Solomon , so extraordinarily eminent in his determination in the Case betwixt the two Mothers claiming one Child . Neither can a People ever be , or so much as think themselves to be in any condition of happiness when their Laws shall be inflexible and hard hearted , and there shall be no Superior Power to allay the rigidness or severity of them . No Cities of Refuge or Asylums to fly unto , upon occasion of Misfortunes , which God himself ordained for his Chosen People of Israel . And therefore when Juries may erre or play the Knaves , be Corrupt , Malicious or Perjured , and Judges mistaken , our Judges have in their doubtings stayed the Execution until they could attend the King for his determination . Whereupon his Pardons did not seldom ensue , or a long Lease for Life was granted to the penitent Offender , it being not amiss said by our old Bracton , That Tutius est reddere rationem misericordiae quam Judicii , the Saxons in doubtful Cases appealed to God for discovery , by Kemp or Camp , Fight , Fire or Water Ordeal , which being now abolished and out of use , requires a greater necessity of the right use of pardoning ; for Sir Edward Coke saith , Lex Angliae est Lex misericordiae , like the Laws of Scripture wherein Mercy is not opposite unto Justice but a part of it , as 1 John 19. Psalm 71. 2. Jer. 18. 7 , 8 , 9 , 10. Ezek. 33. 13 , 14. and it hath not been ill said , that Justitia semper mitiorem sequitur partem , for it is known that a Judge since his Majesties happy Restoration , who were he now living , would wish he had made a greater pause than he did in a Case near Brodway-Hills , in the County of Worcester or Glocester , where a Mother and a Son were , upon a seeming full evidence , Hanged for the Murther of a Father , who afterwards when it was too late , appeared to be living . And Posterity by the remembrance of Matters and Transactions in Times past , may bewail the Fate of some Ministers of State , who have been ruined by being exposed to the Fury of the People , ( who did not know how or for what they accuse them ) and left to the never to be found Piety or Wisdom of a Giddy , Incensed and Inconsiderate accusing Multitude , and Hurrying on the reasonless or little Wit of one another . And consider how necessary it had been for the pious good Duke of Somerset , in the Reign of King Edward the Sixth to have had his Pardon , when at his Tryal neither his Judges , nor the prevalency of the faction that would have rather his Room than his Company , nor himself could remember to put him in mind to demand the benefit of his Clergy . Or how far it would have gone towards the prevention of that ever to be wailed National Blood-shedding miseries and devastions , which followed the Murthers of the Earl of Strafford , and Archbishop Laud , if their Innocencies had but demanded and made use of his late Majesties Pardon . Or what reason can be found why a Pardon after an Impeachment of a particular Person by an House of Commons in Parliament , or an House of Peers joyning or consenting therewith , should not be as valid and effectual in Law , Reason and good Conscience . As the very many General Pardons and Acts of Oblivion , which have been granted by our Kings and Princes to their People for Extortions of Sheriffs Bayliffs , &c. together with many other Misdemeanours , Grievances and Offences , often complained of in many of our Parliaments , as the Records thereof will witness , whereby they have acquitted and given away as much of their own just Rights and Regal Revenues to their Subjects , than the Aids and Subsidies , which they have Contributed towards his Preservation , and in His their own , when they have not had a King or Prince but hath been , as more especially this our present Sovereign , Piger ad poenas ad praemia velox . FINIS . Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A54690-e90 Ll. Canuti . Ll. Edwardi Confessor ▪ p. 19. Ll. H. 1. Rot. Claus. 5 E. 2. indorso , m. 15. Mat. Paris . Rot. part . 50 E. 3. Rot. part . 51 E. 3. Rot. Claus. 51 E. 3. Rot. part . 1 H. 4. Rot. part . 15 E. 3. Rot. part . 5 H. 4. Rot. part . 9. H. 4. Rot. part . 38 H. 6. Rot. part . 28 H. 6. Exact Collection of Remonstrances , Declarations and Messages betwixt his late Majesty and the Parliament , Printed by Order of the Commons in Parliament , 24. March , 1642. Ll. Canusi . Rot parl . 21 R. 2. Pryns 4 part of his Register of Parliament Writs . Prins Animad . upon Cokes 4 Instit. Rot. parl . Cokes 4 part of the Institutes . Cokes 4 part of the Institutes Tit. Parliament . Rot. parl . 7 E. 1. Ll. Canuti , 16. Ll. Inae , 6 1 H. 4. ca. 14. Rot. parl . 28 H. 6. n. 16 , 17. Rot. parl . 5 E. 3. n. 8. 22 R. 2. In the Abridgment of the Parliament Records in English said to be done by Sir Robert Cotton . Rot. parl . 1 H. 4. n. 109. 111. Rot. parl . 5 E. 3. n. 16. Rot. parl . 4 E. 3. n. 16. Rot. parl . 5 E ▪ 3. Rot. parl . 21 R. 2. Esthe● ca. 1 , 3 , 5 , 8. 1 Reg. 3. Bracton . Cokes Instit. 2. 315.