Reflections upon the conduct of human life with reference to the study of learning and knowledge : in a letter to the excellent lady, the Lady Masham / by John Norris ... ; to which is annex'd a visitation sermon, by the same author. Norris, John, 1657-1711. 1690 Approx. 198 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 102 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2003-01 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A52433 Wing N1267 Wing N1270_PARTIAL ESTC R15880 12951607 ocm 12951607 95935 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A52433) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 95935) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 363:14) Reflections upon the conduct of human life with reference to the study of learning and knowledge : in a letter to the excellent lady, the Lady Masham / by John Norris ... ; to which is annex'd a visitation sermon, by the same author. Norris, John, 1657-1711. Masham, Damaris, Lady, 1658-1708. Norris, John, 1657-1711. Sermon preach'd in the Abby Church of Bath ... July 30, 1689. [7], 196, [3] p. Printed for S. Manship ..., London : 1690. "A sermon preach'd in the Abby Church of Bath" has special t.p., with imprint: London, 1690. Advertisement: [3] p. at end. Reproduction of original in Union Theological Seminary Library, New York. Marginal notes. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Church of England -- Sermons. Knowledge, Theory of (Religion) -- Early works to 1800. Sermons, English -- 17th century. 2002-06 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2002-08 SPi Global Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2002-09 John Latta Sampled and proofread 2002-09 John Latta Text and markup reviewed and edited 2002-10 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion Licens'd , November 1. 1689. REFLECTIONS UPON THE CONDUCT OF Human Life : With reference to the Study of Learning and Knowledge . In a Letter to the Excellent Lady , the Lady Masham . By Iohn Norris , M. A. Rector of Newton St. Loe , in Somersetshire , near Bath ; and late Fellow of All Souls College in Oxford . To which is annex'd , a Visitation SERMON , By the same Author . LONDON , Printed for S. Manship , at the Black Bull in Cornhil . M DC XC . MADAM , THE Affliction your Ladyship is under for the loss of your Sight is so great , and your Complaints upon that occasion so just , that I can neither blame you for the one , nor excuse my self from pittying you for the other . And indeed since you have been so unhappy as to be deprived of the use of your Eyes , I think I owe your Ladyship so much Compassion , that I cannot better employ mine , than in writing you such a Consolation , as the opportunity of my New Retirement , with the serious Reflections I have lately made in it , will suggest . And that I believe will be such , as is more peculiarly adapted to the Circumstance of your trouble , which tho occasion'd by a Common Accident , yet , I find , proceeds upon an Uncommon Principle . For tho 't is to be presumed that , notwithstanding your great Contempt of the World , it must be a considerable part of your Affliction to lose the Sight of some delectable Objects in it , since the Wisest of Men ( from whom your Ladyship cannot much dissent ) after a censure of vanity past upon all things under Heaven , is yet forc'd to confess that truly the Light is sweet , and a pleasant thing it is for the Eyes to behold the Sun ; yet I perceive the chief reason why your Ladyship is so concern'd for the loss of your Sight , is because you are thereby deprived of Conversation with your Books , and consequently retarded in your earnest pursuit after Learning and Knowledge . 'T is upon this hinge I know that the main weight of your Sorrow turns , and therefore you will not want a Specific proper for your Malady , if you should chance to be convinced that our Learning is generally misplaced , and that such an importunate pursuit after Learning and Knowledge is no way agreeable to the present Station and condition of Man. For certainly you will no longer lament the loss of your Eyes , for disabling you from doing that , which perhaps would not be adviseable for you to do , if you had them again . If therefore you once come to be convinc'd of this , one main ground of your discontent is removed ; and that you may , is the design of the following Reflections . The First Reflection . Wherein the general Conduct of Human Life is tax'd , for placing Learning and Knowledge , in such things as are little or nothing perfective of the understanding . I. BEING Naturally more than ordinarily disposed to Thoughtfulness , and from the circumstances of my present Solitude and Retirement further invited to it ; I began one day to fall into a deep Meditation upon the Conduct of my own , and of Humane Life . What Reflections I made upon my own , are too peculiarly Calculated for my proper Circumstances , to be of any General use , and therefore I shall not trouble you with them . But as for those past upon the conduct of Humane Life , I think they are of too general use , and withal of too Weighty Consequence , not to be Communicated . These therefore I shall think worth while to draw up into a little more orderly form than wherein they were first conceived , and present to your Ladyships Consideration . II. First then I consider that the Conduct of Human Life must be to the End of Human Life , which is the same with the End of Man , which is Happiness . This conduct therefore must be and and necessarily is , in Gross to Happiness . But now whereas there are two Faculties or Powers of Man , by the right ordering of which this Happiness is to be attain'd , Vnderstanding and Will , therefore more immediately and distinctly , this Conduct of Human Life is in order to the Government and exercise of these two Faculties , the due Regulation of which is the Immediate End , to which Human Life is to be Conducted . There is therefore a double conduct of Human Life , Intellectual and Moral . III. As to the Moral Conduct of Human Life , I do not intend at present to spend any Reflections upon it . Not because 't is Unexceptionable , but because 't is too Obnoxious , the general Impertinence and Irregularity of it being too open and exposed , to need any . And besides 't is a Butt , that has been Shot at so often , ever since Preaching and Writing has been in the World , that 't is now so thick-set with holes , that there is scarce room left to fasten a new Arrow in it . 2. The undue and irregular method of prosecuting what is really Perfective of it . 3. The too Importunate and over-earnest pursuit after Knowledge in General . These are the three Cardinal Irregularities , I have observ'd in the Intellectual Conduct of Human Life , and upon each of these I shall bestow a Reflection . VII . The business of this first Reflection shall be to Tax the General Conduct of Human Life , for placing Learning and Knowledge , in such things as are little or nothing Perfective of the understanding . This I confess to be a Charge of more than ordinary Severity and Boldness ; because it fastens an Imputation of Folly upon the Learned Order ( for with them only is my present Concern ) and not only so , but also in that very thing wherein they think their Wisdom and Intellectual accomplishment consists , and upon which they value themselves above the rest of Mankind . To question their Conduct in any thing else , would be but a trivial Charge , and such as they would not only readily Pardon , but Acknowledge ; it being a common thing with Learned Men not only to own , but studiously to affect Ignorance in things besides their Profession , as in Secular business , the common Affairs of Life , the Mysteries of Trades and the like . But to censure them as defective in that one thing they pretend to , to make that their Blind-side where they think they see clearest ; to maintain that they are not only not really wise and knowing , but that generally they don't so much as know what true Knowledge is , and that they generally place it in such things as contribute little or nothing to the Perfection of that , whereby they really excel the Brutes , and would be thought to excel the Common sort of Men ; this is so high , and so disobliging a charge , that I fear those who from the force of what shall be here urg'd , may be convinc'd of the Truth of it , will hardly forgive the Boldness of it . VIII . But as high a charge as it is , I question not but that it may be , and will be here made good . And that it may appear to be true , we will first of all by way of Address or Preparation , consider what antecedent grounds of probability there are , that men should generally place Learning and Knowledge in such things as are little or nothing perfective of the rational Part ; and then in the second place we will proceed directly to prove that they do so . IX . As to the first , your Ladyship cannot be so little acquainted either with hidden Springs , or outward Workings of humane Nature , as not to have observ'd that however strong and uuiversal is the desire of Knowledge , yet men are generally more in Love with the Fame and Reputation of it , than with the thing it self . There are indeed here and there a few humble retired Souls that are otherwise disposed , and like your Ladyship are so far from loving the Fame and Credit of knowledge before knowledge it self , that they don't love it at all , but are content to court Wisdom privately , and enjoy their own Light in the Dark . For it may be they consider that be their Attainments what they will , Fame is a thing of infinite uncertainty and contingency , that it depends more upon the Humours of men , or some more secret unaccountable Fate , than upon real excellency and merit , that some have the luck to be popular and cry'd up for nothing , when in the mean while others that are really and highly deserving can scarce keep their Heads above Contempt ; that the World is seldom just to true Merit , and that nothing is weigh'd in a falser Ballance than real excellency , whether Moral or Intellectual ; and that there is little reason to expect it should ever be otherwise as long as Envy and Ignorance hold the Scales . Then again it may be they consider with themselves , that suppose true worth were secure of Reputation , yet what a poor slender good is it ! For what is it to be talk'd of , or pointed at ? Should a Man be never so Popular the Antipodes will never hear of him , or if they do , what is he the better for what is said of him there ? And should his Fame , like the Sun , Travael round the whole Globe , besides that he is but Master of a Point when he has All , he can enjoy no more of it but just what he hears , which is inconsiderable . And yet as inconsiderable as it is , 't is like to be his whole Portion . For as for Posthumous Glory , it comes too late to be any thing valuable . He will either not be sensible of it , or despise it . For certainly it must needs be mightily beneath the improvements of a separate state to put any value upon the injudicious praises of poor Mortals here below . Or suppose that a Deceas'd Spirit could take any delight in reflecting upon the Fame he has left behind him , yet 't is to be considered that the Fashion of this world passes away , that those in whose praises he outlives himself , must also shortly dye , and that then his Fame will have a Funeral , as well as himself . These perhaps , or such like Considerations , may prevail with your Ladyship and a few more thinking Persons , to have but a very cold and indifferent regard for the Reputation of Learning and Knowledge : But as for the generality of mankind it must be own'd that they are fond of it to a strange degree , and are more concern'd to be accounted Wise and Learned , than really to be so . Otherwise I question whether our Libraries would be so full as they are . X. But now , tho the generality of men be so passionately and keenly set upon the fame of being Learned and Knowing , yet ( so little hath Nature design'd to gratify this ambitious humour ) there are but a very few that have either a Genius and inclination for Learning it self , or a capacity of attaining to it . Not an Inclination , because there is a great variety in the Speculative , as well as Moral inclinations of men , one being naturally disposed to this sort of study , and another to that , whereas true Knowledge whatever it be ( which shall be consider'd in its due place ) is of one determinate kind or nature in general , and consequently must require a certain peculiar frame and disposition of mind . Not a capacity , because the generality of men are known to have but indifferent Intellectuals , suited to the exigencies of common life , when as true knowledge ( what ever it be ) must be supposed to be a thing of uncommon difficulty , and the study of it a work fit only for sublimer wits , the more elevated and Awaken'd part of Mankind . XI . Now put these two things together , that almost all men would fain be thought Learned and Knowing , and that there is but here and there one that is Naturally made and fitted for true Knowledge , and then consider what is like to be the result of this Complication . Why , the Latter Few may succeed well in the search of what they were naturally qualified for , and having attain'd to a Competency of true Knowledge , such as is Perfective of the Understanding , they find themselves under no Temptation to place it in any thing else , or to bring into Credit any other sort of knowledge . Because having arrived so far , they are either wise enough to undervalue the Fame of being Learned , or else despair not of attaining it by their Proficiency in True Knowledge . Here therefore they take up their rest . XII . But now what shall we do with the others ? Are they to be perswaded that they are not of a Make for the Study and attainment of Learning ? You 'll find it tough work to convince them of that . But suppose it possible that they could be made sensible that they are not like to Commence very Learned and Knowing , yet all the World shall never be able to perswade them to lay aside that Natural itch of being so accounted . But you 'll say , tho this Inclination be too Natural and inbred to be quite laid aside , yet there 's hopes it may be Govern'd . No nor that neither . They must put in for the Prize , and 't is in vain to disswade them from it . But they must despair of ever winning it in a fair way , being supposed not able to reach the Tree of Knowledge . True. They have therefore but one way left , and that is , to turn the Tables , and cry up something or other for Learning which they are capable of . No matter whether it deserve that name , that is , whether it be really perfective of the Rational Part or no , 't is enough if they can reach it . For those that can't compass true Riches , and yet will have the Name and credit of it , are put upon the Necessity of Coyning and Counterfeiting . XIII . And truly this Supposition seems to me so very reasonable , that were experience altogether Silent in the Case , and were I utterly unacquainted with the State of Learning in the World , yet if I had a Draught given me of Human Nature , and were told how much the Ambition of being esteem'd as Learned and Knowing exceeds both the Desire and the Ability to be so , and were then ask'd what I thought would be the Intellectual Conduct of Human Life , I should without any further enquiry conclude that in all probability Men would generally place Learning and Knowledge in such things as signifie little or nothing to the Perfection of the understanding . XIV . But from grounds of Probability that they should do so , let us proceed to prove directly that they do so . Now in this Charge there is something supposed , and something asserted . The supposition is that there are some things , the knowledge of which is little or nothing Perfective of the understanding . The Assertion is , that Learning is generally placed in the knowledge of such things . The Proof of the Supposition will ingage my Pen upon the discussion of a very Gurious and weighty Question , wherein the Perfection of the understanding does consist , or what it is that is Perfective of the Understanding ? Which when we have duly fix'd and stated , we shall then have a certain Measure to go by in the Proof of the Assertion . XV. To the Question then I answer , that the Perfection of the Understanding , as that of the will , is either Formal or Objective . The Formal Perfection of the understanding , as that of the will , is no other than its Exercise or Operation , which is Thinking and Perception , as that of the other is Willing and Chusing . According to the vulgar Maxim , that the Perfection of every thing is its Operation , which must be understood only of the Formal Perfection . The Objective Perfection of the understanding is Truth , as that of the will is Good. The Result of these two Perfections joyn'd together , is what in the understanding we call Knowledge , and what in the will we call Vertue . XVI . Our concern is not at present with the Formal , but with the Objective Perfection of the understanding . This we have said in general to be Truth , as that of the will is Good. And thus far there is neither Difficulty , nor Controversie . All therefore that further remains to be here considerd , is , what Truth that is which is the Objective Perfection of the understanding , or , what Truth that is , in the Knowledge of which the Perfection of the understanding does consist , XVII . Now since there is so great a Proportion and Correspondence between the understanding and the will , and the Perfection of each , the first entrance we shall make upon the Resolution of this Question shall be to consider , what good that is which is the Objective Perfection of the will , or , what good that is in the desiring and embracing of which the Perfection of the will does consist . Which being determin'd , will afford at least a Fair Ground and Occasion , tho not an infallible Measure for the determination of the other . XVIII . Here then 't will be necessary to premise a Consideration of the Kinds of good . The most general distribution of which I conceive to be into these two , Necessary and Contingent good . By necessary good I understand that which cannot but be good , that which is always and immutably good . And this comprizes under it the good of the End which is desireable for it self , commonly called Pleasant good . And the good of the Means , which has an immutable connexion with it , and is desirable for the other , commonly call'd Profitable Good. By Contingent good I understand that which may , or may not be good , and is good , whenever it is so , only upon a Positive account , because enjoyn'd by the Will of a Competent Authority . This can never be the good of the End , or a self-desirable Good ; nor can it be such a good of the Means as has a Natural and immutable connexion with it ; but is always an Arbitrary and Mutable Means . XIX . This being briefly premised , I shall venture to assert that that good which is the Objective Perfection of the Will is Necessary Good. Either that which is Self-desirable , as God the Universal , or any other particular pleasant good . Or else that which has an immutable Connexion with it , as Moral good . As for Contingent good , that is no otherwise perfective of the Will , than in the force and vertue of the necessary good . For Obedience to a positive Law is no otherwise a Vertue , than as 't is included in some general natural Law , whereof 't is a contingent instance . Which is also the ground commonly assign'd by Casuists , why Human Laws oblige in Conscience . According to that of Aquinas , Lex Humana Obligat in Conscientia , quatenus participat legem aeternam & Naturalem . An Human Law obliges in Conscience as much as it partakes of the Eternal and Natural Law. That is , as far as it is founded , or relies upon the immutable will of God and the Dictate of Natural Reason . XX. This is too plain to need much Proof , though not so plain but that it may be demonstrated . If then a Reason be demanded why the objective Perfection of the Will is only necessary , not contingent good , 't will be sufficient to say , that that only is Perfective of the Will , which naturally , and of it self , makes it Happy , and wherein she can acquiesce with satisfaction and delight . But this is only necessary good , that which is essentially , intrinsically , and immutably good , either as the End , or as having a Natural Connexion with it , either of which involves Happiness . As for contingent good , that is supposed to be of it self indifferent as to Happiness , and tho by positive Ordination it may be made a condition of it , yet still it contributes to it only as an Arbitrary Means , which has no inward goodness in it self , and whose whole Moral Excellency is deriv'd from some general Law of Reason , whereof 't is an instance by accident , and in vertue whereof it obliges . Thus Moses's striking the Rock , had nothing morally good or perfective of the Will in it , but only as 't was an Instance of that General Law of obeying the Divine Will in all things . Nor did the Vertue of Moses consist , properly and strictly speaking , in striking the Rock , but in Obeying God by striking the Rock . XXI . By this it appears what good that is , in the desiring and embracing of which the Moral Perfection of the Will does properly and ultimately consist . That it is Necessary , not Contingent good . Whence we may take instruction how to state the Perfection of the understanding , which we shall do by following the same Common Measure . First then be it here also premised , that as in relation to the Will , all good is either Necessary or Contingent , so in relation to the Understanding , all Truth is either Necessary or Contingent . For besides the immediateness of the Opposition , which is Contradictory , I further consider , that that must be the Adaequate division of Truth which is of Being , Truth being a property of Being , and such a one , as tho formally and Abstractly different ( for the subject must never be included in the Precise Reason of the Property ) is yet Materially , and Concretely the same with it . But now Necessary and Contingent is the Adequate Division of Being , therefore also of Truth . XXII . By Necessary Truth I understand that which cannot but be True , that which is always and immutably True. Such is God among Simple Truths , who is immutably what he is , and all the Divine Ideas which ( as I have elsewhere abundantly explain'd it ) are the very Essence of God , as variously imitable or participable , thus or thus . Such also among Complex Truths are all Propositions of Eternal Truth , whether Absolute or Hypothetical , with all their regular Inferences and Conclusions , which ( as I have also elsewhere shewn ) are nothing else but the Divine Ideas themselves as they respect each other according to their several immutable Habitudes and Combinations . XXIII . By Contingent Truth I understand that which may or may not be True , that whose Truth depends not upon the Essence of God. ( That Ground and Pillar of all Necessary Truth ) but only upon his Meer Will and free Pleasure , either decreeing or permitting . Such among Simple Truths are all Created Beings , the whole Ectypal World , and all things in it , which tho made according to the Eternal and Immutable Patterns of the Divine Ideas or Archetypal World , yet in themselves are Temporary and Mutable . Such also among Complex Truths are all those Propositions the Terms of which have no Essential or Immutable Connexion with each other , but are so and so combined and related , meerly by the Decree or Permission of him , who is the Author of whatever is besides himself . XXIV . Under the First order of Truths are comprehended all those things which are the Matter of those Arts and Sciences which are built upon Stable and immoveable Foundations , which depend not upon the System of the Present World , but were antecedent to it , and might have been study'd before 't was made , and according to which the World it self was made , such as Theology , Metaphysics , Morality , Geometry , &c. together with all those unchangeable Rules and Measures of Reason and Consequence which are to be used about them all , which is the Subject of that Art or Science we call Logic. Under the second order are comprehended all Matters of Fact , all Temporary Events , all Natural or Artificial Effects , &c. Which are the Matter of all Arbitrary and Mutable Sciences ; as History , Chronology , Knowledge of Tongues , &c. Which began with this Mundan System , and stand or fall with it . XXV . Now as that good which is Primely and properly Perfective of the Will is Necessary good , so following the same Proportion I shall not doubt to assert , that that Truth which is Primely and Properly Perfective of the Understanding is also Necessary Truth . And as Contingent good is no otherwise Perfective of the Will , than in the Force and Vertue of the Necessary good ( as was above Explain'd ) so likewise Contingent Truth , is no otherwise Perfective of the understanding than in the Force and Vertue of Necessary Truth , that is , of the Divine Ideas wherein 't is contain'd . As for Example , when I Speculate some Particular Artificial Triangle which is a Contingent Simple Truth , it is no otherwise Perfective of my Understanding than as it is beheld in its Necessary and Immutable Nature , or ( which is all one ) in the Divine Idea . And thus again when I form a Proposition concerning this Triangle , by ascribing to it some Property or other , which is a Contingent Complex Truth , this again is no otherwise Perfective of my Understanding than as it belongs to , and is beheld in the Nature of a Triangle in Common , which is Necessary and Immutable , being no other than an Idea , or a Determinate Mode of the Divine Omniformity . So that at length the Perfection of the understanding is resolv'd into the Knowledge of Necessary Truth , which is its only Objective Perfection ; that which is Contingent being no way perfective of it , but only in vertue of the other . XXVI . I am ( Madam ) very sensible how strange and Paradoxical this way of Philosophizing will seem to those who are either unaddicted to Meditation in general , or not conversant in Theories of this kind , and therefore for their sakes , rather than for any inevidence of the Argument , I will give some Proof and Confirmation of it , which I will so order , that it shall be an Explanation at the same time . I will therefore first shew that 't is so , and secondly , how and why 't is so . That it is so I prove thus : First , I suppose that God was once when there was nothing besides God. Again , I suppose that as the Being of God did go before all other being in Order of time , so in Order of Nature it was antecedent even to the Will of Creating , putting , or permitting any thing . Again , I suppose that there was therefore then no other Truth but necessary Truth , that is , the Divine Ideas with their several Habitudes and Complications . I suppose again , that therefore God must be consider'd as knowing then only these necessary Truths . And yet I suppose again , that God was as perfect then as he is now ; and consequently , that the Divine Vnderstanding was as perfect then as now , the Nature of God requiring not only that he should be Absolutely Perfect , but that he should be so in himself . Whence I infer , that therefore the whole Perfection of the Divine Understanding is to be resolv'd into the sole knowledge of Necessary Truths , and that the knowledge of Contingent Truth gives no Perfection to it , any otherwise than as 't is beheld in that which is necessary , as was said before . XXVII . From this Process of Reasoning , I presume 't is sufficiently evident , that the Objective Perfection of the Divine Vnderstanding is only Necessary Truth , which I take in the first place to be a strong ground of presumption , that the Perfection of Human Vnderstanding does also consist in the same . But to make it further plain that it does so , I suppose again , that nothing were to exist but only God , and one Intelligent Being ; and that this Intelligent Being had the full and perfect fruition of God. Upon this supposition I enquire , whether this Intelligent Being would be perfectly Happy or no ? Without all question he would , as enjoying an All-sufficient Good. Well , if so , then he must be perfectly happy in his Vnderstanding . And yet 't is most certain , that he could then have the knowledge of very little more than Necessary Truth ; for all that he could possibly know besides , would be only that he himself did exist , and that he knew these Necessary Truths , and that he was happy in the knowledge of them , and the like . And lest the knowledge of such Contingencies should be thought any Accumulation to his Happiness , we will carry our Hypothesis a little further , by supposing that this Intelligent Being were not to attend to any of his own Perfections , or to any of those few Contingent Truths resulting from them , but were only to Contemplate God and the Divine Ideas ; and then I demand whether his understanding would be sufficiently perfected or no ? 'T is necessary to answer in the Affirmative , whence 't is also as necessary to conclude , that the only Objective Perfection of our understanding is Necessary Truth . XXVIII . This I think sufficient to prove that 't is so . I shall now briefly explain the Mode of it , by shewing how and why 't is so ; and I account for it after this manner . Necessary Truth is the same with the Divine Ideas ; and accordingly Plato , I remember , calls Science a Participation of Ideas , and the Divine Ideas are the very Essence of God , as 't is variously imitable according to its Omniformity : Necessary Truth therefore is no other than the Essence of God , the very Substance of the Divinity . More particularly , it is the same with the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the second Person in the Holy Triad , who is 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 as Philo speaks , the Archetypal Seal , and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Intellectual World , and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the Archetypal Paradigme , and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the Idea of Ideas . Whom also the Scripture represents as the Wisdom of his Father , and as the Light of the World , and who inlightens every Man that comes into it , not only Efficiently ( as 't is vulgarly understood ) but also Formally , he himself being the Truth , and the Light , in which we see all things . XXIX . These things ( Madam ) I only hint to you , referring you for further satisfaction to your deservedly admired Monsieur Malebranche in his de la Recherche de la Verité , and to a Treatise of mine call'd Reason and Religion ; where I have purposely treated of the Divine Ideas , and of our seeing all things in them : In which however whatever is deficient shall be supplied in another Latin Treatise of a larger compass , now under my hands , and which I shall communicate to the World e're long ( if God please to continue my Life and Health ) under the Title of Theoria Mundi Idealis , sive Metaphysica Platonica . XXX . However , lest I should be thought to proceed upon a precarious ground , I will here give you one short and evident Demonstration that Necessary Truth is the very Essence of God , and then advance . That God is the cause of whatever is besides himself , or that whatever is , is either God or the effect of God , is a clear and acknowledg'd principle . Upon which I thus argue : Necessary Truth is either God , or the Effect of God. But it is not the Effect of God , therefore it is no other than God himself . XXXI . That it is not the Effect of God , is evident from the many Absurdities that would follow upon that Supposition . For first , God would be then a Necessary Agent ; for if Necessary Truth be an Effect , 't is a Necessary Effect , and a Necessary Effect must have a Necessary Cause . Again , God would not only be a Necessary Agent , but also ( which is worse ) an Vnintelligent Agent . The consequence is unavoidable , for if Truth be the Effect of God , then antecedently to the effecting of it , there was no Truth , and consequently no Knowledge . Again , if Necessary Truth be the Effect of God , then the Perfection of the Divine Understanding must be supposed to depend upon something that is not God ; nay , upon something Created by God. 'T will follow again , that God has made something which he cannot destroy . And lastly , to add no more , if Necessary Truth be the Effect of God , then there will be something Necessary , Immutable , and Eternal , &c. besides God. The Consequences are all plain , and so are the Absurdities . The last of which appeared so great to the Excellent Monsieur Poiret , a stiff Opposer of your beloved Malebranche , and of the Ideal Philosophy , that he urges this as one Argument against the very being of Necessary Truth , because then there would be something Necessary besides God , not considering that this Necessary Truth is really one and the same with God himself . And this alone puts by the force of his Argument against the being of Necessary Truth , which however is sufficiently conclusive to the purpose we now aim at , that Necessary Truth is not the Effect of God. For if it were , then his Absurdity would come in , and there would be something Necessary besides God. Since then Necessary Truth is not the Effect of God , it remains by Vertue of the premised Disjunction , that it must be no other than the very Substance and Essence of the Deity . XXXII . I further consider , that the Essence of God is intimately and immediately united to the mind of Man ; this is plain from Scripture , which tells us that in God is our Life , our Motion , and our Being . And from Philosophy , which assures us , that what pervades all things , must needs be immediately united with every thing . And for this , you have the Authority of your excellent Malebranche , who therefore calls God the Place of Spirits , as Space is the Place of Bodies . XXXIII . Now upon these two Suppositions , that Necessary Truth is the same with God himself , and that the Essence of God is immediately united to the Mind of Man , 't is easie to Conceive how and why Necessary Truth should be the Objective Perfection of our Understanding ; since to make an Object Perfective of the Faculty , nothing else is requisite , than that it be its proper Good , and that it be intimately Present to it . And this will also sufficiently give us to understand that Contingent Truth cannot be the Objective Perfection of the Mind ; first , because that is a Created Being , whereas God alone is our proper Good. And secondly , because 't is without us , and cannot be immediately united to our minds , without which condition , were it never so Perfective otherwise , it could contribute nothing to the Perfection of our Understandings . XXXIV . And thus have I given a full Resolution to that Curious and Important Question which the Proof of my Supposition ingaged me upon , and which is to be the Measure of what follows in this Reflection . It is plain from hence , that there are some things the Knowledge whereof is little or nothing perfective of the understanding . For as I have shewn , 't is not Contingent but Necessary Truth , wherein the Perfection of the Understanding does consist . Whence it follows that True Learning ought to be placed in the Knowledge of Necessary Truth , in the Comprehension of those Arts and Sciences whose Foundations are not Arbitrary , but Stable and Immutable , and in understanding the Eternal and Unchangeable Laws and Measures of Reason and Consequence . He therefore is the truly Learned and Knowing Man , who has furnish'd his Mind with bright and clear Ideas , lodg'd them orderly and regularly in his Head , and settled the Relations and Consequences of one to another . He that is able to think clearly and distinctly ( for so much a Man knows , as he distinctly understands , and no more ) to judge truly and solidly , and to reason dependently and consequentially . In short , he that sees most of the Divine Ideas , is most familiarly conversant in the Intelligible World , and has the largest and the clearest view of the Field of Truth . This I hold to be Learning , and Intellectual Perfection , and besides what Arguments I have alledged in behalf of this Hypothesis ; it is further Confirmed by the Authority of Plato , when he makes the Happiness or Perfection of Man ( for 't is all one ) to consist in the Contemplation of Ideas . XXXV . But notwithstanding the unquestionable Certainty of the Premises , this is not that Measure which the generality of the World has thought fit to proceed by . Learning is generally placed in the Knowledge of Contingent , not of Necessary Truth . For your Ladyship very well Knows that the World does not esteem him a Learned Man whose Learning has Clear'd his understanding , who is arrived to clearness and Distinctness of Conception , and is a thorough Master of Notion and Discourse . No , 't will cost great Pains , great Labour of Mind , and anxiety of Thinking to arrive to this Pitch . Nor will all the Pains in the World do , unless a Man be Naturally made for it , unless he be of a Notional Complexion , and has had his Head cast in a Metaphysical Mould . Whereupon this Attainment is like to be the Lot of a very Few . This therefore must not be Learning , but something else must , that lies more within Common reach , tho of no real Moment to the Perfection of the understanding . Such ( as I have shewn ) are Contingent Truths , and yet Learning is generally placed in the Knowledge of these . XXXVI . For first , 't is reckon'd a notable point of Learning to understand variety of Languages . This alone gives a Man a Title to Learning without one Grain of Sense ; and on the other side , let a Man be an Angel for Notion and Discourse , yet unless he can express the same thoughts in variety of words , he may go for a Rational , but will by no means be esteem'd a Learned Man. And this brings to my mind a Passage which I met with not long since in London , where being in Company with an Ingenious French Man , I ask't him of what repute M. Malebranche was with the Learned in France ? He told me , that he was look'd upon as a great Master of Notion and Speculation , but as a Man of no great Learning . I ask'd him , why ? Because , said he , he understands but few Languages . How much that excellent Authors Talent may lie that way I am not concern'd . But whatever it be , the most Learned of them all must give me leave to say , that I would rather be Master of a Quarter of his Sense , than of all the Languages that may be form'd out of the Alphabet . But is it not a strange thing that so much Stress should be laid upon such a Triflle ? For what am I the better for being able to tell what 't is a Clock in several Languages ? What does this signifie to the Perfection of my understanding ? Words are purely in order to Thought and Sense , and therefore are of no further value than as they serve as helps either to Learn , or to Communicate the other . To affect them therefore for themselves , is to turn the Means into the End , than which nothing is more absurd . And yet this vain peice of Pedantry has prevail'd all the World over , and with some to that degree , that they have confounded Ideas with Words , and have made all Science to terminate in the latter . Thus the Philosophers of the Nominal way , and particularly Mr. Hobbs who makes Reason to be nothing else but Sequela Nominum , a well order'd Train of Words . Never certainly was there a grosser peice of Idolatry , nor a plainer Argument of the great degeneracy of Mankind . And tho all the Multipliers of Tongues are not Comprehended under this latter charge , yet it may concern them to consider , how great a Folly it must needs be , to place Learning in that , which is one of the greatest Curses upon Earth , and which shall utterly Cease in Heaven . XXXVII . Again , it passes for an extraordinary part of Learning to understand History , that is , in other words , to know what a company of silly Creatures , call'd Men , have been doing for almost this 6000 years . Now what is my understanding the Perfecter for knowing this ? I deny not but that there are some matters of Fact , as the more remarkable Turns of Ecclesiastical History , together with the greater revolutions of the Civil World , that may be of Moment to be known , not that the knowledge of them as such is Learning , or Perfective of the understanding , but because by discovering to us the Conduct of Divine Providence they supply us with occasions of adoring and glorifying the wisdom and goodness of God. I am not therefore against the knowing these things , but only I would not have men think themselves the Wiser or more Learned for such Knowledge . For 't is one thing to say that a thing deserves to be known , and another to say that 't is Learning or Wisdom to know it . For a thing may deserve to be known , not as perfecting the understanding , but meerly as touching upon our Interest . I grant therefore that it may be of Consequence to know some Historical passages , if we are any way concerned in them , and so it may to know the Clock has struck One , if I have appointed an Assignation at that time ; but sure the bare naked Theory of the Clock's having struck one , can add but little to the stock of my Intellectual Perfection . The most trivial matter of Fact in the World is worth knowing , if I have any concern depending upon it ; and the greatest without that is utterly insignificant . So that 't is not from the perfecting of our Vnderstanding , but from the Relation they have to our Interest , that these things deserve to be known . XXXVIII . This is sufficiently plain from the Measure we have premised , by which no Truth is perfective of the understanding but only Necessary Truth . But to address my self more Convincingly to the great Magnifiers of History , I shall only desire their answer to this one Question . Suppose such and such Matters of Fact , on the knowledge of which they Found their title to Learning , and perhaps , glory more in the knowing them , than the Actors themselves did in the doing them . Suppose , I say , such matters of Fact had never been done ; suppose Fabius had never Weather'd out Hannibal by Delays ; nor Cyrus took Babylon by draining the River into the Ditches , what loss or diminution would this have been to the Perfection of their Understandings ? They cannot say it would have been any . And why then should the knowing them now they are done , be reckon'd as an Intellectual Improvement ? And yet we find that 't is so , and that Men study these things not only for their use ( for that I allow ) but for their meer Theory , placing Learning in such History , which has nothing to commend it but only that it tells you such and such things were done . Of this impertinent sort is the greatest part of the Roman and Grecian History , which ( had not the World Voted it for Learning ) would no more concern a Man to know , than that a Bird has dropt a feather upon the Pyrenoean Mountains . XXXIX . Again , it goes for a Notable piece of Learning to understand Chronology , to be able to adjust the intervals and distances of Time , to know when such an Action was done , when such a Famous Man flourish'd , and who and who were contemporary , and the like . Now I deny not , but that while Men live in this World , they may be concern'd to have some acquaintance with these things , by reason of some interest or other that depends upon it . It may therefore , I say , for some purposes , be convenient to know that . For instance , there is a twofold Aera ( or date ) of the Victory at Actium , the one reckon'd from the Fight at the Promontory of Actium , according to the account of Dio and Xiphilinus ; the other from the taking of Alexandria , and the Death of Cleopatra , according to Ptolemy , Iosephus , Eusebius , and Censorinus . But however , concerning this may be , with respect to its usefulness , yet certainly as to any Intellectual Perfection that accrues by it , it must needs be a very unedifying Stuffage of Mind ; and yet 't is counted a great Accomplishment and Enrichment of it . XL. Another thing there is which passes for wonderful Learning , which I cannot well reduce either to Necessary or Contingent Truth , for indeed it does not belong to Truth at all , and that is our Sophistical way of Disputation . And indeed it may well be call'd so , for as 't is generally manag'd , 't is nothing but meer Quibbling and Jesting , not Arguing but Punning . For suppose the Question be , Whether he that has Faith shall be saved ? No says the Opponent , If the Damn'd have Faith , then not every one that has Faith shall be saved ; But the Damn'd have Faith. Therefore , &c Here 't is plain that the Word Faith , tho it has Something in Common in both Propositions , yet according to the intire Idea signifies one thing in one Proposition , and another in another . And why then is not the whole Proceedure to be rejected as Idle and Impertinent ? As for downright Fallacy and Equivocation where there is a Manifest Ambiguity ( as between Dog and Dog , one signifying a Celestial Sign , and the other a Terrestial Animal ) this is every where despised and laught at as unbecoming both the Acumen and the Gravity of a Disputant . And we think we have sufficiently discharged our hands of such an Argument , by Crying out that these are Four Terms in the Syllogism . But now I would fain know whether it be not the same to all real purposes in the foremention'd Instance , which is after the Common way of our Scholastic Disputation ? Is not Faith and Faith there , as much an Ambiguity as Dog and Dog here ? For my part I can perceive but this only Difference , that Dog and Dog have nothing in Common but the Name , whereas Faith and Faith have some Generical Part wherein they agree . But what does this Mend the Matter ? For tho there be some Generical Agreement , yet take 'em according to their whole Ideas , that is , take the Generical part with its Contracting Difference , and 't is plain that they signifie two different things , and consequently that there is really as great an Ambiguity here as there . And this we plainly Confess when we come to Distinguish . For what is a Distinction but a Pointing out of an Ambiguity ? What is it else but to say , that such a thing is True in this Sense , but not in that , True in that Sense wherein the Point of the Question is not concern'd , but not in that wherein it is . No ? why then , notwithstanding the Generical Agreement the Procedure is as fallacious and Impertinent as when the Question being about Star-Dog , the Opposition is about Land-Dog . And yet ( such is the inconsistency of Human Judgment ) the one is counted Trifling , and the other Serious Arguing . Whereas indeed no Arguing can be so , but where the Terms of the Question are first Defined ( as is done in Geometry ) and then always used according to the first Stated Sense . All Disputing any otherwise than so , must necessarily be nothing else but meer Punning , only much worse than what is in common use , because 't is Punning when a Man Pretends to be Serious . And yet this is made a considerable Part of our Academical Education and Learning . And to this I add this further Remark , that 't is reckon'd a notable Excellence to be able to Spin out an Argument to a great length , and he is counted the best Arguer that can thus Pun longest . Whereas indeed did a Man speak to the Purpose , Brevity would be his greatest Excellence . XLI . There are many other things which the unaccountable humour of the World has turn'd up for Learning , which Ignorance will never be the better for , and which Wisdom does not need . Thus 't is counted Learning to have tumbled over a multitude of Books , especially if great ones , and old ones , and obscure ones , but most of all , if Manuscripts ; the recovery of one of which is reckon'd so much added to the Commonwealth of Learning , as they call it . A Well-read Man signifies the very same as a Learned Man in most Mens Dictionaries , and by Well-read they dont mean one that has read well , that has clear'd and improv'd his understanding by his reading , but only one that has read a great deal , tho perhaps he has puzzled and confounded his Notions by doing so . Thus again it goes for Learning , to be acquainted with Mens Opinions , especially of the Ancients , to know what this or that Philosopher held , what this or that Author says , tho perhaps he says nothing but what is either Absurd , or Obviously True. Thus for instance , what can be more Absurd than that Fancy of Empedocles , that there are two Semi-circles compassing betwixt them the Earth , one whereof was composed of Fire , the other of Air , and that the former made the Day , and the latter Night ? And yet to know this is Learning . And what again is more obviously true , than that Grave Doctrine of Aristotle , that Privation must go before the introduction of the Form in all Generation ? And yet 't is Learning to know that he taught thus , tho it be a thing so plain , and so near the Surface , that a Child can't miss of it . To know the thing is nothing , because so plain and easie , but to know that Aristotle held it , that 's the Learning . Nay , to instance in a matter of greater difficulty , tho I know very well , and am able to demonstrate the grounds of the Atomical Philosophy , or the Motion of the Earth , or the Circulation of the Blood , yet I shall not be admitted into the Order of the Learned , unless I am able to tell that Moscus the Phoenician invented the first , and that Democritus and Leucippus afterwards improved it , and that the two latter owe their discovery to Copernicus and Harvey . So much more Learned an atchievement is it to know Opinions than things ; and accordingly , those are reckon'd the most Learned Authors , who have given the greatest Specimens of this kind of Knowledge . Thus is Picus Mirandula more admired for the Examination he has made of the Doctrine of the Pagans , than any of them were for what they deliver'd ; and Plutarch has got more Credit from the History he gives of their Opinions , in the 2d Tome of his Works , than from any of his Rational and Moral Discourses . And were he not accounted Learned for the Former , I question whether the Latter ( tho far more excellent than they are ) would ever have given him that Title . XLII . Now ( Madam ) what an hard and unreasonable imposition is this , that tho I am able to Think and Write never so much like an Angel my self , yet I must not be accounted a Man of Learning , unless I can tell what every whimsical Writer has said before me ! And how hard will this fall upon those , whose lot is to breathe in the last Ages of the World , who must be accountable for all the Whims and Extravagancies of so many Centuries ? And yet this is made so great a part of Learning , that the Learning of most Men lies in Books rather than in Things ; and among Authors , where one writes upon Things , there are twenty that writes upon Books . Nay , some have carried this odd humour on so far , that 't is thought Learning to know the very Titles of Books , and their several Editions , with the time and place , when and where they were Printed . And I have met with several my self , that have valued themselves not a little upon this Mechanical faculty , tho they knew no more of what was in them , than they do of what is written in the Rolls of Destiny . XLIII . From this placing of Learning in the Knowledge of Books , proceeds that ridiculous Vanity of Multiplying Quotations , which is also reckon'd another piece of Learning , tho they are used so unseasonably and impertinently , that there can be no other end in them , but only to shew that the Author has read such a Book . And yet 't is no such Convincing Evidence of that neither , it being neither New nor Difficult , for a Man that 's resolv'd upon it , to quote such Authors as he never Read nor Saw. And were it not too Odious , as well as Obvious a Truth , I could name to your Ladiship , some of those Author-Mongers , who yet pass for Men of shrewd Learning , and vast Reading . XLIV . These , and many other such things ( for 't were endless to reckon up all ) are by the Majority of the World Voted for Learning , and in these we spend our Education , our Study , and our Time , tho they are all of them Contingent Truths , that are not Perfective of the Understanding ( nothing being so but only Necessary Truths , or the Divine Ideas , the Eternal 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the Word and Wisdom of the Father ) and also most of them impertinent and unconcerning ones . So that in short , the Charge of this Reflection amounts to thus much , That Learning is generally placed in the Knowledge of such things , which neither the Intellectual Perfection , nor any other Interest of Man is concern'd to know . The End of the First Reflection . The Second Reflection . Wherein the General Conduct of Human Life is tax'd , for using undue and irregular Methods , in Prosecuting what is really Perfective of the Vnderstanding . I. IN the preceding Reflection , the Intellectual Conduct of Human Life was censured for the general Misplacing of Learning , for placing it in such things as are not Perfective of the understanding . In the Present Reflection supposing it to be Free from that Fault , we shall consider it as Chargeable with another , namely , with an undue and irregular Method of prosecuting what is really perfective of it . The First was an Errour about the End ; This Second is an Errour about the Means , which are the two hinges upon which all Prudence , and all Imprudence turns . II. That the Truth of this Charge may appear , we must here also propose a Measure , whereby we may proceed , as we did in the Former Reflection . And as there we took upon us to determine what that is which is Objectively perfective of the Vnderstanding , so we must here consider what is the Right Method of Prosecuting what is so . Which being stated will be a Measure to us in this , as the other was in the former Reflection . III. I design not here a just and Particular Treatise concerning The Method of Study or Inquiry after Truth , this Province being already Professedly undertaken , and Excellently adorn'd by two as great Masters of Thinking as ever were , or are like to be in the World , Cartesius and Malebranche , of both which your Ladyship is so much a Mistress , that a further undertaking of this kind would be as needless to your better information , as to the Argument it self , after the Management of it under such Excellent hands . However something I must say , it being impossible to shew that wrong Methods are used in this Grand Inquest , but by predefining which is the Right . This therefore I shall do , but briefly only , and in General . IV. Since therefore that Truth which is Perfective of the understanding is Necessary Truth , and since this Necessary Truth is the same with the Divine Ideas ( both which being already proved , are here supposed ) following the thred of the same Hypothesis , I find it Necessary to affirm , that the right and indeed only Method of Enquiry after that Truth which is perfective of the understanding is by Consulting the Ideal World , where only it is , or the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , who says of himself that he is not only the Truth , but also the way . V. Here I suppose two things , first that this Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Ideal World is intimately united with , and presential to the Mind . Secondly that we see and understand all things in him , That he is our Light and our Wisdom , the Light by which we See , and the Light which we See , that he is the very 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the inward word and Substantial Conception of our Minds , as he is of the Father , and that in this Sense he inlightens every Man that comes into the World. This I need not prove now , because I have done it professedly elsewhere , only I shall pass one necessary Remark upon the manner of our being inlighten'd by the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , who may be said to inlighten us in a double respect , either Fundamentally and Potentially by putting us into a Capacity of Illumination , by his intimate Union and Presence with us , or else Effectually and Actually , when we attend to his Divine Light , which is always present to us , tho we are not so to it . In the Former sense he inlightens every Man , in the latter only those who duly consult him and attend to him . VI. For I consider , that the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , is an Inlighteness in the same Proportion as he is a Redeemer . Now he redeems us either by putting us in a Salvable and Reconcilable State , which is a Redemption Vniversal Incondionate and Antecedent , or by actually reconciling and Saving us , which depends upon , and is consequent to certain conditions , and is conferr'd only upon those who are qualify'd accordingly . And as his Redemption is double , so is his Illumination . He inlightens either by putting us in a state or possibility of Illumination by being intimately present with us , and surrounding us with his Divine Ideal Light , which is a Benefit Common to all , or by actually informing our understandings when we apply our selves with due Attention to his all-diffused Light , which is ever present to us , and to the whole Creation , and Shineth even in the Darkness , tho the Darkness Comprehend it not . VII . And I was not a little glad to find the Grounds of this distinction in the writings of that Elevated Heathen , Hierocles , which I shall give you in the words of my own Translation . This bright Heathen Commenting upon that Mystical Prayer of Pythagoras , O Father Jupiter , either free all from their Manifold evils , Or else Discover to all what Daemon they use , Moves this Question , since they that know God and themselves are free from Mortal Passions ; why then are not all freed , since all are sufficiently assisted with the Opportunities of this knowledge ? To which he first gives this general Answer , Because the greatest part of Men embrace evil of their own accord , since they neither see nor hear Neighbouring good . Then a little after he is more particular in his Account . Since therefore ( says he ) that any thing may be shewn to any one , 't is necessary that the actions of two Persons concur ( for how can you shew what you have a mind should be shewn , to a Blind Man , although you offer it to him a thousand times , or how can you shew to one that sees , if you offer nothing to his Sight ) both these must be present , some good proposed by him that shews , and an Eye capable of seeing in him to whom it is to be shewn ; so that from a visible object , and a Faculty of seeing , may result a Manifestation . This being so , let us suppose that all would be freed from evil , if their Maker did shew to all the knowledge of his own Nature , and what Daemon they themselves use . But we find that all are not deliver'd from evil , it follows therefore that he does not make this discovery to all , but to those only who of their own accord endeavour to free themselves from evil , and voluntarily fix their Eye upon what is shewn by the intention of Contemplation . And again a little after , thus every Illumination of God by the Concurrence of our vision , becomes a Discovery . VIII . In all which Process , this refined Heathen supposes that God is ready on his part to inlighten all Men ; nay , that he does inlighten them all so far as to put them in the way , and within the Possibility of Illumination , which then becomes Actual and Effectual when they yield due Attention to the Divine Light. He does not indeed descend to so much Nicety and Particularity as to ascribe this Illumination to the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Ideal World , but only to God in general , nor does he determine whether God does inlighten us only Efficiently , by infusing Acts or Habits of knowledge ( as is more vulgarly held , than understood , and indeed is no way intelligible ) or Formally by being himself the very Formal Light of our Minds , and the immediate Object of our Knowledge . This I say he does not determine , nor do I cite him to this purpose , having sufficiently Explain'd and Establisht this Theory elsewhere , but only to shew his Concurrence with me in this Distinction of the double Illumination of God. IX . These Supposals being premised , First , that that Truth which is Perfective of the understanding is Necessary Truth ; then Secondly , that this Necessary Truth is the same with the Divine Ideas ; then Thirdly , that the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Ideal World , is intimately united with , and Praesential to the Mind ; then Fourthly , that we see and understand all things in him , and that 't is he that is our inlightner ; and that lastly , tho he inlightens all Fundamentally and Potentially , yet this Illumination is not reduced to Act , and made Effectual , but by the intervening of some Condition on our parts , which is duly to consult and apply our selves to him . From these Premises the same Conclusion which we touch't on before , necessarily and evidently follows , that the Right and only Method of Enquiry after that Truth which is Perfective of the understanding , is to consult the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Ideal World. For this is the Region of Truth , and here are hid all the Treasures of Wisdom and Knowledge . This is that great and Universal Oracle lodged in every Man's Breast , whereof the Antient Vrim and Thummim was an Expressive Type or Emblem . This is Reason , this is Conscience , this is Truth , this is that Light Within so Darkly talk'd of , by some who have by their aukward , untoward , and Vnprincipled way of representing it , discredited one of the Noblest Theorys in the World. But the thing in it self rightly understood is true , and if any shall yet call it Quakerism , or Euthusiasm , I shall only make this reply at present , that 't is such Quakerism as makes a good part of St. Iohn's Gospel , and of St. Austin's Works . But to return , this I say is that Divine Oracle which we all may , and must consult , if we would inrich our minds with Truth , that Truth which is Perfective of the understanding . And this is the true Method of being truly wise . And this is no other Method , than what is advised us by this Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the Substantial Wisdom of God. Blessed is the Man that heareth me , watching daily at my Gates , waiting at the Posts of my Doors . And again says the same Substantial Wisdom , Who so is Simple , let him turn in hither . And again , I am the Light of the World , he that follows me , or ( as the word more properly signifies ) he that consorts or keeps company with me , walketh not in Darkness . This therefore is via Intelligentiae , the way and Method of true Knowledge , to apply our selves to the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , to consult the Ideal World. X. Thus in general . If now it be further demanded how this is to be done , I answer that there are three ways of doing it , and I can think of no more . The First is by Attention . The Second is by Purity of Heart and Life . And the Third is by Prayer . Upon each of which I shall bestow some few Remarks , such as may rather give hints than full entertainment to your thoughts , because I Know your Ladyship loves to have something left to work out by your self in your own private Meditations . Which Consideration has made me all along use less Prolixity than the Quaintness and Weightiness of my Argument would otherwise justify . XI . The first Method assign'd is Attention , or Application of Mind to the Intelligible World , the World of Truth . This is the same with Thinking or Speculating , which if intelligibly accounted for , will be found to be nothing else but the Conversion of the Mind to the Ideal World , or Omniformity of the Divine Essence ; which as it is the First , so is it also the Directest and most Compendicus Method of Science . For this is to go directly to the Spring-head , to the Lucid Fountain of Good , 't is to take hold of Essential Truth nakedly as it is in it self ( as a very Contemplative Person expresses it ) 't is to fix the Eye of the Mind upon the Intellectual Sun , upon him who is Substantial Truth , and the Light of the World. Which must needs be the most ready way to be inlightned . For the more heedfully we attend to the Ideal World , the more we shall see and discover of it ; and not only so , but also more clearly distinguish what we do discover . For so a man that casts a short careless glance upon the Galaxy , sees only a Confused whiteness arising from the numerous mixture of little Splendors , but when the same Person fixes his Eye with steadiness and delay of Application , he begins to discern something more distinctly , a new Star ever and anon arises under his inspection , not discover'd before , and still the longer and harder he looks , the more he discerns , till at length he has discover'd as much as he can well atttend to at once , and has satiated his Faculty with the Brightness and Multitude of Light. The Application is as Obvious , as the Figure is Pertinent , and therefore I shall only remark this one thing more upon this part , that this was the Method of the first Inventors of Arts and Sciences , who made their way into the Coasts of Learning by meer dint of Thinking ; and further , that this is the very Method that has been used by the greatest Improvers of them ever since , such as Bacon , Boyle , Descartes , Galileus , Harvey , Mersennus , Digby , Malebranche , Poiret , and ( whom I name with particular Honour and Reverence ) our Excellent Friend Dr. More . All these must be allow'd , and I think are to be great Improvers of Learning , and that 't was by this Method they did it . And I dare Prophesie , that if ever any extraordinary Advancement be for the future made in the World , 't will be done by Thinking . XII . This as to Thinking in General . But now as to the Order of Thinking , if your Ladiship can be supposed to need any instruction about it , I cannot recommend you to a better Tutor than your Friend M. Malebranche , in his second part of his sixth Book of Inquiry after Truth , where he purposely describes the Method of Thinking , which you may remember he reduces to these few following Laws . XIII . The first Law is , that evidence be maintain'd in our Reasonings . From this Principle depends this general Law concerning the Matter of our Studies , that we ought not to Reason but only of those things whereof we have clear Ideas , and by Necessary Consequence , that we ought always to begin with the most simple and easie things , and also to dwell long upon them , before we advance to the inquisition of things more Complex and Difficult . XIV . Upon the same general Principle , depend the Laws concerning the manner whereby we are to proceed in the Solution of Questions . The first of which Laws is this , That the state of the Question to be solved is to be most distinctly Conceived . Besides , the Ideas of the Terms ought to be distinct that they may be Compared with one another , and that the Relations which are sought for may be Known . XV. But when the Relations of things to one another cannot be Known by immediately Comparing them , then the Second Law is , that we should employ our thoughts to find out one or more Middle Ideas , which we may use as a Common Measure to Know by their help the Relations that are between those things . And withal he advises that we should study to have those Ideas clear and distinct , proportionably to the Accuracy and Numerousness of those Relations which we endeavour to deprehend . XVI . But when the Questions are Difficult and require a long Examination , then the third Law is , that from the Matter in hand all those things should be removed whose examination is not necessary to the discovery of the sought for Truth . Because the Capacity of the Mind is not to be without reason divided , but all its force is to be imploy'd about those things from which it may perceive Light. And all those things which can be removed , and which being remov'd , the Question remains intire ; they are the things that do not belong to the Question . XVII . When the Question is included within a few Terms , then the Fourth Rule is , that the matter of our Meditation is to be divided by parts , and those parts to be handled singly according to their Natural Order , by beginning with the more Simple , that is , with those which include fewest Relations . And that we should not pass on to the more Complex , till the more Simple be distinctly known , and render'd Familiar . XVIII . When by Meditation these things become Familiar to us , then the Fifth Rule is , that the Ideas of all these are to be Contracted , and disposed in the Imagination , or to be Written down in Paper , that they may no longer fill the Capacity of the Mind . This Rule , tho always useful , yet he makes it necessary only in the most difficult Questions , which require a great Capacity of Mind . And he says withal , that the use of this and the following Rules , is not to be Accurately known but only in Algebra . XIX . When the Ideas of all things necessary to be consider'd , are clear , familiar , contract , and orderly digested in the Imagination , or exprest in Paper ; then the sixth Law is , That all things are to be Compared or Collated according to the Laws of Combination , alternately among one another , either by the sole Intuition of the Mind , or by the Motion of the Imagination , joyn'd with the Intuition of the Mind , or by the Calculation of the Pen joyn'd with the Attention of the Mind and of the Imagination . XX. If none of all those Relations which result from all those Collations , be that which is sought after , then again from all those Relations those are to be removed which are of no use to the Solution of the Question : And the others are to be made Familiar , to be Contracted , and to be orderly disposed in the Imagination , or express'd in Paper , and to be compared with each other , according to the Laws of Combination . And then we are to see whether the Compound Relation which is sought for be any one of all those Compound Relations which result from those new Comparisons . XXI . If none of those found Relatitions include the Solution of the Question , then again from all those Relations , the unserviceable are to be cast away , the other are to be made familiar , &c. And by proceeding in this manner , the Truth or Relation sought for , be it never so Complex , will at last be found , provided we are able sufficiently to extend the Capacity of our Mind , by Contracting Ideas , and that in all our Operations we always attend to the End and Scope which is to be arriv'd at . For in every step of this Intellectual Progress , we ought to have our eye perpetually fix'd upon the State of the Question . To all which he adds one Caution more , that we should beware lest we should sit down Contented with a false Light or Appearance , and so be deceived . And that therefore our Collations in order to the finding out the Truth we look after , be so often repeated , till we can no longer with hold our assent without being Secretly Chid and reprehended by a Certain Master Answering from within to our Questions , that is to our Labour , Application of Mind , and desire of Heart . By which Master within this admirable Theorist can mean nothing else but the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Ideal World , that Universal Oracle of Mankind , and of all the Intelligent Creation . This is a short view of those Laws which the Excellent M. Malebranche has given concerning the Method of Thinking . And I believe if an Angel had been ingaged in the undertaking , he could not have given Better . They are all Natural , Clear , Distinct , Easie , and depending ; Few enough not to burthen or Distract the Mind , and yet Many enough to inform it . And therefore I shall not be guilty of so much Presumption and Impertinence as to prescribe any other , thinking it sufficient to consider and Practice these . And so much for the first way of Consulting the Ideal World , which is by Thinking . XXIII . The second way is by Purity of Heart and Life . This I confess has a more immediate and special influence upon the Knowledge of Spiritual and Moral Truths , according to that of our Saviour , If any Man will do his will , he shall know of the Doctrine , &c. and that of his Prime Apostle , The Animal Man perceiveth not the things of God , &c. But its Efficacy is not confined here , but has a larger Sphere of activity , and serves to the discovery even of all Ideal or Necessary Truth . For as viciousness not only proceeds from Ignorance , but also causes it , by besotting and clouding the understanding , so Purity of Heart and Life not only proceeds from Light and Knowledge , but also produces it , and helps the Soul to see more Clearly and Distinctly . Hence the Pythagoric and Platonic 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , the Method of Purification and Purgation so much talk'd of by Perphyry , Iamblichus , Plotinus , and particularly by Hierocles in his Introduction to his Noble Comment , where he has these Words , As a Blear Eye cannot behold a very bright object till it be Purged , so a Soul not yet Clarify'd and refined by Vertue is not qualify'd to gaze upon the Beauty of Truth . And the same Method is no less recommended in Scripture . Wisdom will not enter into a Polluted Spirit , says the Wise Man. And says the Angel to Daniel , many shall be Purify'd and made white , and none of the wicked shall understand , but the wise shall understand . And says the Psalmist , I am wiser than the Aged because I keep thy Commandments . And to this purpose also is that of our Lord to be understood , He that follows me , that is , that lives after my Example , Walketh not in Darkness . The Purity of his Heart will be a Light to his understanding . XXIV . But to represent his more distinctly , there are two ways whereby Purity of Heart serves to the acquirement of Knowledge . By Natural Efficacy , and by the Divine grace and Benediction . And first it does it by Natural Efficacy , either by Clarifying the Medium , or by assisting the faculty . The former I conceive and represent after this Manner . I suppose in the first place that the Soul sees through a Medium ; Secondly , that this Medium is our Terrestrical Vehicle ; Thirdly , that the Grosness of this Medium hinders the Vision of the Soul. All which I ground upon those words of the Apostle , Now we see through a Glass , darkly . XXV . This Supposed , it follows that whatsoever Clarifys this Medium does also help the Vision of the Soul. And this Purity does , especially that more Eminent part of it which consists in Chastity and Temperance . For first it Composes the Passions , especially that of Lust , by that the Animal Spirits , and by that the Blood. For the Motion of the Passions Ferments the Spirits , and the Fermentation of the Spirits agitates the Blood , and by agitation raises all the feculent and drossy parts of it ; and makes it like a troubled Fountain , thick and muddy . And this I take to be one true reason why Men in any Passion can't reason so clearly as when they are in more quiet and silence of Spirit . But now by Purity of Heart all this disturbance is allay'd and composed , the Passions are becalm'd , the Spirits fix'd , the Fountain of the Blood clears up , and so all the inner part of that Glass the Apostle speaks of , becomes more bright and pellucid , more apt to transmit the Rays of the Ideal Light , and consequently we see more clearly through it . Tho it be still but Darkly in comparison of what we shall do hereafter . XXVI . But this is not all ; This Purity does also Clarifie the outward part of the Glass too . First by Consequence , because the finer the Spirits and Blood are , the finer will be the Threds of the outward Veil also . Then more directly , because Temperance does refine and Subtilize the Texture of the Body , diminishes from its Bulk and Grossness , and unloads the Soul of a good part of that Burthen which not only presses down her Aspirations , but also hinders her Sight : And besides , it refines the the inner part too , by bringing in fresh supplies of fine Spirits . This was that Temperance which made the Faces of Daniel , Hananiah , Mishael and Azariah look Clear and Fair , and which made them Wise too , gave a quick and delicate air to their Countenances , and let in the Light of the Ideal World upon their Souls . This was that Philosophical Temperance of the Pythagoreans , which ( to use the Words of Dr. More Commenting upon that place ) is the Mother of that Wisdom which makes the Face to shine , and nourishes the Luciform Vehicle of the Soul. XXVII . And as this Purity does Clarify the Medium , so does it also Assist the Faculty . And this it does by the same general way whereby it clarifies the Medium , that is , by composing the Passions . For the Passions not only trouble and thicken the Medium ( as was noted and explain'd before ) but al●o divide and disperse the Faculty . For the more things a man desires , the more things he will be engaged to think upon , and the more things he thinks upon at once , the more Languid and Confuse will his Conception be . But now this Purity by composing the Passions , contracts the Desires , and by contracting the Desires , it contracts also by consequence the Thoughts , and by this the Man is reduced to a greater Vnity , Simplicity , and Recollection of Mind , and having but few thoughts to divide him , he is the better inabled to think clearly and distinctly . XXVIII . And thus have I given a clear and distinct account how Purity of Heart serves to the acquirement of Knowledge by a Natural Efficacy . This it does also secondly by the Divine Grace and Benediction . Purity of Heart is that Heavenly Lure which invites not only the Holy Spirit , but also the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , to come and dwell in the Soul , and to inrich it with his Ideal Communications . This we may be assured of from his own mouth , He that loveth me , shall be lov'd of my Father , and I will love him , and manifest my self to him . And again , If a man love me , my Father will love him , and we will come unto him , and make our abode with him . The pure , chaste and good Soul shall not only be loved by the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , but be also of his Council and Privacy . For this is the Spouse of the Word Eternal , who first assumed innocent Nature , and then assumes innocent Persons , the first by a Natural , the second by a Mystic union . This is the Beloved Disciple who has the priviledge to lean upon the Bosom of his Lord , and to be admitted to his more secret Communications . And therefore says the Psalmist , The secret of the Lord is with them that fear him , and he will shew them his Covenant . And says our Lord himself , Blessed are the Pure in Heart , for they shall see God. And Concerning the Four Children that refused to defile themselves with the Portion of the Kings Meat , it is said , that God gave them Knowledge , and skill in all Learning and Wisdom ; and that Daniel had understanding in all Visions and Dreams . For they were not only Pure and Temperate but Religiously so , in obedience to the Law of their God , the God of Israel . Which the said God rewarded with Knowledge and skill in all Learning and Wisdom in them all , but in Daniel peculiarly , with a faculty of interpreting Aenigmatical Dreams and Visions ; as the Learned Dr. More observes in his excellent Comment upon that place . XXIX . The third and last way of consulting the Ideal World is by Prayer . This is a method which the Scripture also advises us to : If any of you lack wisdom , let him ask of God , that giveth to all men liberally , and upbraideth not , and it shall be given him . And this we know was the Method whereby the Wisest of men attain'd his unparallel'd Wisdom . For as Wisdom was his Choice , so the Method of his seeking and gaining , it was by Prayer . And 't is further observable that he address'd himself to the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Ideal World in particular , as you may see in that solemn Prayer of his recorded in the Book of Wisdom , give me Wisdom that sitteth by thy Throne , &c. Which I commend to your Ladyships perusal at leisure . XXX . And thus ( Madam ) have I Defined and by Scripture and Reason Proved , what is the Right Method of prosecuting that Truth which is Perfective of the understanding . This in general I have shewn to consist in Consulting the Ideal World ; The manner of doing which I have also shewn to be , First , by Thinking , the Order of which is also defined , Secondly , by Purity of Heart and Life , and lastly by Prayer . This I take to be via Intelligentiae , the Way and Method of Wisdom , whose House I think is Now Built , tho not upon Seven , yet upon Three Substantial Pillars , and I should be glad if any one would be so kind as to shew me the weakness of the Ground upon which they stand . XXXI . And now ( Madam ) I think I I need not use many words to shew that as Learning is generally placed in such things as are not Perfective of the understanding , so that what is so is generally prosecuted by undue Methods . For 't is but to compare the Methods in common use with that which we have premised and demonstrated , and you will immediately perceive the falseness and irregularity of them . For First , whereas the First and general Method of Wisdom and knowledge is by consulting the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 or Ideal World , the World of Light , that Light which inlightens every Man that comes into this World , the generality of Students don 't so much as Dream of this , nor make any such Application , but apply themselves altogether to the Ectypal World , to the World of Darkness and Obscurity . So verifying that complaint of God by the Prophet , My People have forsaken me the Fountain of Living Waters , and have digg'd to themselves broken Cisterns , that will hold no Water . XXXII . Then again , whereas another more Particular Method is by Attention and Thinking , this is generally so little regarded , that no sort of Men think so little for the most part as they that are ingaged in the Profess Study of Learning and Knowledge . This they don't reckon as any part of Study , nor as any Progress in the Stage of Learning , but only as a Graver way of being Idle . 'T is then only they Study when they are hanging their Heads over an Old Musty Folio , and are making huge Common-places , and stuffing their Memories with Grey Sentences , and Venerable sayings : And thus they spend their Time and their Ink , and having Scambl'd through a company of Books ( most of which perhaps were Written to as little purpose , as they are Read ) they think themselves Learned Men , and the World is too often of their Opinion , tho they have not made themselves Masters of any Sense or Notion , nor are able to demonstrate one single Truth upon solid Principles , and in a Consequential Process . XXXIII . And this is the Method not only of those who Misplace Learning , but also of the Most of those that place it aright . For even those that place it in Ideal Truths do not generally Think for it , but Read for it , Seek it not in their Souls , but in Books . And this methinks I can never sufficiently Wonder at . Indeed as for those that place Learning not in being able to frame Clear and Distinct Conceptions of ones Own , but in Knowing the Opinions of Others , 't is no wonder that they take this Method , for tho it be Not a means to the End they should propose , yet , t is a Means to the End which they do propose . But the wonder is how those that place Learning as they should , in the Clear Conception of Ideal Truths , should think to find this meerly by tumbling over Books . XXXIV . I deny not but that Reading is One way of Knowing ( otherwise I should not be at the Pains to write this to your Ladyship ) but then , t is only by Accident that it is so , as it gives hints and occasions for Thinking . And therefore Thinking is the only thing to be regarded even in Reading ( for Reading as such is Nothing ) and then we Read to most purpose , when we are thereby most enabled to Think . So that Thinking is the End of Reading , as Understanding is the End of Thinking . We Ought therefore to Read only in Order to Thinking . And yet this Method is generally so much inverted , that the Main Stress is laid upon Reading . Nothing but Read , Read , as long as Eyes and Spectacles will hold , not regarding whether the Head be Clear , so that it be full . XXXV . As to the particular Order in Thinking proposed by M. Malebranche , I refer your Ladyship to the same Excellent Author to shew you how much it is transgress'd . Which he does at large , and to Wonderful Satisfaction , shewing first that the School-Philosophers do not observe that General Law concerning the matter of study , which is the Cause of a great many Errors in their Physiology . Then shewing that the second part of the General Law is not observed by the Common Philosophers , and what extraordinary advances Cartesius made in Learning by the exact observation of it . Then he proceeds to explain the Principles of Aristotle's Philosophy , where he shews that he never observed the second Branch of the General Law , and reflects upon those Errors of his Philosophy occasioned by his not doing so . But for a fuller account in these things I refer you to the Author himself . XXXVI . Then again , whereas Purity of Heart and Life is another Method of arriving to the Light and Knowledge of Ideal Truth , your Ladyship cannot but know , and 't is a sad as well as a true observation , that this is not only neglected among that part of Mankind that sit down contentedly in Ignorance , and aspire to no greater stock of Knowledge than what they brought with them into the world , but also among the generality of those few that addict themselves to the Cultivation and Improvement of their minds . Nay these in proportion to their Number seem more guilty of this neglect than the other , and nothing so common as to see men of Curious and Inquisitive tempers and of famed Learning , who yet are very Corrupt in the Moral state of their minds , and live very ill lives . Whence some have taken occasion to represent Learning , as an Enemy to Religion , and have cry'd up Ignorance as the Mother of Devotion . And tho the Conclusion of these men be notoriously weak and absurd , yet it must be confest that the Ground upon which they build it , is too true . Men famed for Learning , are oftentimes as infamous for Living , and many that study hard to furnish their Heads , are yet very negligent in purifying their Hearts , not considering that there is a Moral , as well as a Natural Communication between one and the other , and that they are concern'd to be pure in Heart and Life not only upon the Common Account , in order to a happy state hereafter , but also in pursuance of their own particular way and end here . XXXVII . Then again Lastly , whereas another Method of Wisdom is Prayer , I do not find that the generality of Students do at all apply themselves to this Method . Pray indeed ( 't is to be hoped ) they do for other things , which they think lye more out of their reach , but as for Learning and Knowledge , they think they can compass this well enough by their own proper Industry , and the help of good Books , without being beholden to the assistance of Heaven . And this , tho they do place Learning in the knowledge of Necessary Truth . Which procedure of theirs I cannot resolve into any other principle , ( I mean as to those that act by any ) but the meer want of knowing or considering that this Necessary Truth is really the same with God himself . For did they attentively consider that God is Truth , and that so much as they possess of Truth , so much they have of God , 't is not to be imagined they should be so indifferent in using Prayer , or any of the other preceding Methods of Consulting God for his own Light. The End of the Second Reflection . The Third Reflection . Wherein the General Conduct of Human Life is tax'd with a too importunate , and over-earnest Pursuit after Knowledge in General . I. HAving pass'd over the two first Stages of the Intellectual Conduct of Human Life , that of the End , and that of the Means ; and reflected upon the Irregularities of each , by shewing how both are generally mistaken and misplaced ; I am now arrived to the Third and Last , which consists not in the choice of the Object , or of the Method to it ( that belonging to the two former ) but in the Degree of Affection wherewith they are prosecuted . Which part of our Intellectual Conduct , as it is equally Capable of being faulty , so I shall here make it my business to shew that it is actually as faulty and irregular , if not more than either of the two former . And the fault that I tax it with , is , A too importunate and over-earnest Pursuit after Knowledge in General . II. The Charge of this Reflection is of a larger compass and extent than either of the two Preceding , those being directed against such as either misplace the Object , or else mistake the Method of Learning and Knowledge ; but this takes in both together , and others also not concerned in either of the former . For not only those that err in the placing of Learning , or in the method to it , but also those who are Right in both , come under the Censure of the Present Reflection , they all agree in this , in being too importunate and vehement in the Pursuit of Knowledge . III. Now in the making out the Truth of this Charge , We must here also according to the Method observ'd in the two former Reflections , first lay down a common measure of Proceeding , by stating the due Bounds of our Present Affection to , and search after Knowledge , Or , how far it becomes man to imploy himself in the Prosecution of Learning and Knowledge ? the due stating of which Question will be a certain direction to us in the Determination of this , whether our general Inquest after Knowledge be Immoderate or no. Now for the Determination of the first it will be necessary to draw up the true State or Hypothesis of man according to the Posture wherein he now stands . Which I shall do distinctly in these following Considerations . IV. First I consider , that the utmost Pitch of Knowledge man by his utmost endeavours can arrive to in this world is very inconsiderable . God indeed has given us Reason enough to distinguish us from the Brute part of the Creation , and we may improve it so far as to distinguish our selves from One another , and so one man may deserve to be call'd Learned and Knowing in comparison of another that is either Naturally more ignorant , or more unimproved ; but absolutely speaking , the most that any or all of us either know or can know here is of little or no Consideration . What we know of God is but little , for as the Apostle says , we see through a Glass , darkly ; what we know of our selves perhaps is Less , and what we know of the world about us is not much . We have seen but a few of Gods works , as the wise man observes , and we understand yet fewer . There are almost an infinite number of things which we never so much as thought of , and of most things we conceive very darkly and uncertainly , and there is not one thing from the greatest to the least , which we do or can understand thoroughly . Those that apply their whole study to any one thing , can never come to the End of that one thing , for not only every Science but every particular of it has its unmeasurable depths and recesses ; and 't is confess'd by a great inquirer into the Nature of Antimony ( as 't is related by the Honourable Mr. Boyle ) that 't is impossible for one man to understand throughly that one single Mineral only . And if a man I cannot understand All of so little , how little must he understand of All ! Suppose further , that all the Knowledge of the Learned were put together , 't would weigh but Light , for what one Art or Science is there that is brought to any tolerable Perfection ? And if the Common Stock be so little , how small a Pittance is it that must fall to every particular Man's share ! And where is that Man who after all his Poring and Studying , is able to answer all the Questions , I will not say which God put to Iob , but which may be askt him by the next Idiot he meets ? V. 'T were an endless undertaking to represent at large the little that we know , or are capable of knowing . Nor do I design to turn a second Agrippa , and entertain your Ladyship with a long Harangue about the Vanity of Humane Sciences , only give me leave to touch upon two notorious instances of our Ignorance , and in that very Science which is pretended to be at the very Vertical Point of Improvement . 'T is Concerning the the Maximum and the Minimum Naturale , the Greatest and the Least thing in Nature . As to the first , the Question is whether the Extension of the Universe be Finite or Infinite ? If you say 't is Positively Infinite , besides the difficulty of conceiving how any thing can be so extended , 't will follow that God himself cannot add the least further Dimension to it . If you say 't is Finite , suppose your self in the utmost extremities of it , and try whether it be possible for you to dis-imagin further Extension . Then as to the Second , the Question is whether every , even the Least assignable Part of matter be infinitely Divisible or no ? If you say yes , then 't will unavoidably follow that the least Atom will have as many Parts as the whole World. If you say no , then you must say that Matter may be Divided so long till at last you come to a Part that does not contain more other Parts , if so , then I enquire has this uncontaining Part Figure , or has it not ? If not , then 't is infinite , Figure being only the Termination of Quantity . But if it has , then it has more other Parts above , below and of each side , and consequently may again be divided , contrary to what you suppos'd . So that you see here are Desperate Difficulties on both sides , say what you will you are equally baffled , and yet 't is most certain that one only can be true , they being two opposite parts of a Contradiction , but which is so , is beyond the Capacity of Humane understanding to determine . VI. The like Difficulties we meet with when we inquire concerning Time , whether it be Infinitely divisible , or only into Moments ? And so again in the Business of Motion , whether there be any such thing as the Extream Degree of Swiftness and Slowness , or no ? Neither of which can be defined without manifest Absurdity . But 't is superfluous , as well as endless , to display the particulars of our Ignorance , tho indeed when all Accompts are cast up , that will be found to be our best Knowledge . This only in General , our Life is so short , our Progress in Learning so slow , and Learning in it self so long and tedious , and what we do or can know so very little , that the Patrons of Scepticism had much more reason to conclude from the Disability of our Facculties and the slightness of our Attainments , than from the uncertainty and Instability of Truth , that there is no Knowledge . VII . Secondly , I consider , that as we can here know but Little , so even that very little which we do , serves more to our Trouble and Disquiet , than to our Pleasure and Satisfaction . And here comes in that experimental Reflection of the Wise Man , In much Wisdom is much Grief , and he that increases Knowledge , increases Sorrow . This Proposition is not true , Absolutely consider'd , Knowledge being the Perfection of Human Nature , the Image of God , and the Principal Ingredient of our Future Happiness ; but only with relation to the present State and Posture of Man. And in this respect it is abundantly true . First , because the more we know , the more we shall discover of our Ignorance , ( that being the chiefest thing we learn by our study ) which we shall find to be of an infinitely larger Sphere than our Knowledge , and consequently shall be more troubled for what we do not know , than pleas'd with what we do . Secondly , because the Prospect of what yet further remains to be known will inflame our Thirst after it . For Wisdom says of her self , They that Eat of me shall yet be Hungry , and they that Drink of me shall yet be Thirsty . Which tho it be a great Commendation of Wisdom , and an Argument of her Inexhaustible excellence , yet 't is withal a great instrument of Punishment to those who can attain to so little of it , as cannot satisfie that thirst which it has inflamed . Thirdly , because the more a Man improves his thinking faculty , the more apt he will be to be disgusted and offended with the follies of Society ; as the most delicate Touch is the soonest put to pain . There being a thousand impertinencies that will strike very disagreeably upon a discerning mind which won't so much as affect a grosser understanding . VIII . But the Principal Ground of this Assertion , and which , did not the quickness of your Ladyship's Apprenhension oblige me to Brevity , I could be Voluminous upon , is this . 'T is most certain that Man is now placed in the Midst of Vanities and unsatisfying Objects , and and that his True good is not within his reach , and consequently whatever Pleasure he takes in those things that are , is purely owing to his Ignorance of their Vanity . Well , if so , then Vae Sapienti , woe be to the Wise Man. This is not a Place to be Wise in . There is nothing here Solid enough to endure the Test of Wisdom . The Wise Man cannot find a Paradice here , tho the Fool can . The more he knows the more he discovers the Vanity of all pretended Enjoyments , and the more he does this , the more he streightens and retrenches his Delights , and the more he does this , the more he retires and withdraws himself from all Worldly Diversions , and this sets him the more a Thinking and Musing , and this again presents to his mind a fresh and more lively Conviction of the Worlds Vanity , and this makes him again retrench his Delights , and so on in this returning Circle , till at length he finds nothing but his bare Wisdom to delight in . And a little more Thinking makes him see the Vanity of that too . And now all 's gone . To dispatch this part in one word , this is the Fruit of being Wise , to be able to taste nothing that 's Present , nor to flatter ones self with the Prospect of what is to come , which is a state of horrible Privation and Sterility . This is the thorough Wise Mans Lot , and every advance in Wisdom is a step towards this Condition So true is it , that he who increases Wisdom , increases Sorrow , while in the mean time the Fool Laughs , and is Merry . IX . Thirdly , I Consider , that if our Knowledge could yield us more Satisfaction than it occasions Trouble , yet our Life is so short , and so incumber'd , that we can make but little of the enjoyment , so little , that 't is not answerable to the meer Labour we undergo in acquiring it . All the Morning of our days is spent in the Preliminaries of Learning , in Learning Words and Terms of Art , wherein there is nothing but toil and drudgery , and before we can taste any of the Fruits of the Tree of Knowledge , before we can relish what is Intellectual and Rational in it , our Sun is got into the Meridian , and then it presently begins to decline and our Learning with it ; our Light , our Strength , and our Time make haste to consume , nothing increases now but the Shadows , that is our Ignorance and Darkness of mind , and while we consider and look about us , the Sun Sets , and all is concluded in the Darkness and Shadow of Death . But oftentimes the Sun is intercepted by a Cloud long before it Setts , and we live backward again , grow weak and Childish , Silly and forgetful , and unlearn faster than we learnt ; or if it chance to shine bright to the last , then we improve too much , and grow too wise for our selves , and reject the greatest part of what we learnt before , as idle and insignificant . So that we are under a Necessity of unlearning in a short time most of what we have so dearly learnt , either through forgetfulness , or improvement of Iudgment . Fourthly , I Consider , that there is no Necessity of our being so wonderfully Learned and Knowing here . 'T is neither Necessary as injoin'd by God , nor as a Means to any considerable End. We can be Good , and we can be Happy without it . And as to the Interest of Communities and Public Societies , 't is Civil Prudence and Honesty , and not Learning which makes them Happy . And lest any advantage in our after State should be alledged for its Necessity , this makes it more unnecessary than any Consideration besides . For tho we are never so unlearned now , provided we know enough to do our Duty , and live well , we shall in a short time arrive to such a degree of Knowledge as is requisite to our Supream Perfection , to which our Present Learning cannot add , and from which our Present Ignorance will not Diminish . I do not say this will be immediately upon our discharge from the Body , there being some reasonable Controversie about that , ( which would be too great a Digression at present to pursue ) tho 't is most certain that even then there must needs be great inlargements of Understanding ; However 't is most unquestionable that this our Intellectual Accomplishment can be no further off than our enjoyment of the Beatific Vision . We shall then commence instantaneously Wise and Learned , and be fully possess'd of the Tree of Knowledge , as well as of the Tree of Life . For then that Glass through which we now see Darkly shall be laid aside , and there shall be no other but the Speculum Deitatis , the Glass of the Divinty , which is no other than the Ideal World , which shall be now more intimately united to us , and more clearly display'd before us . And tho even now there shall be Degrees of Knowledge according to the various Participiation of the Ideal Light , yet the variety of this Dispensation shall not proceed by the degree of our Knowledge in this Life , but by some other Measure . For , XI . Fifthly , I Consider , that tho there is no necessity of our being so very Learned and Knowing , yet there is an Absolute Necessity of our being Good and Vertuous . This is Necessary both ways , as Commanded by God , and as a Means to our Final Perfection . And besides 't is necessary Now , there being no other opportunity for it . If we don't know here , we may know hereafter , and shall infalliably do so if we are but Good here ; but if we be not good here , we shall neither be Good , Happy , nor Knowing hereafter . The Main opportunity for Knowledge is after this Life , but the only opportunity for being good is Now. And if we take care to improve this , we are sufficiently secure of the other , and of whatever else appertains to the Perfection of our Natures . But if this be neglected all is lost . This therefore is indispensably necessary , and 't is the only thing that is so , and 't is necessary Now , necessary not only to our Happiness in General , but also to that of our Intellectual Part in Particular . For , XII . Sixthly , And lastly I Consider , that thus stands the Case between God and Man. First , Man is supposed to be made in a State of Innocence and Perfection , in perfect Favour and Communion with God , his true Good , and in a Capacity so to Continue . From this excellent state he is supposed to Fall , and by his Fall so to disable himself that he cannot by his own strength Repent and Live well , and so to provoke God , that tho he could and did Repent , yet he would not be Pardon'd and Accepted , without Satisfaction made to Divine Justice . This satisfaction Man is supposed not able to make , nor any other Creature for him . Whereupon God in great Mercy and Pitty is supposed to ordain a Mediator , his own Son , God and Man , between himself and his Laps'd Creature , who by the Sacrifice of himself should Effect two things , answerable to the double Necessity of Man , first make Repentance available , which otherwise would not have been so ; and secondly Merit Grace for him that he might be able to Repent . And this is what we are to understand by the Restoration or Redemption of Man , which thus far is Vniversal and Inconditionate . XIII . But still notwithstanding all that this Mediator has done for him , Man is supposed only so far restored , as to be put in a Pardonable and Reconcilable State ( for as for our being actually and immediately reconciled by the Death of Christ , that 's a silly , fond , Antinomian conceit , and no way consistent with the Great Mystery of Godliness ) I say Man is yet only in a Capacity or Possibility of Pardon and Reconciliation , which is then , and then only reduced to act , when he actually performs the Conditions of Reconciliation , when he Believes , Repents and leads a good Life , with which he may , and without which he shall not be Pardon'd and Saved , notwithstanding that Christ has Dy'd for him . The design of whose Death was not to make a good Life unnecessary , but only to render it Efficacious and Available , not to procure a Priviledge of being saved without it ( as some fancy ) but that we might be Saved with it . If this Qualification be wanting , we shall be so far from being any thing advantaged from the Redemption purchas'd by our Mediator , that we shall be Accountable for it , to the great aggravation both of our Guilt and Misery . It therefore highly concerns Man to improve with all diligence this short and only opportunity of Making his Great Fortune , to adorn his mind with all Moral and Religious Perfections , and his Life with all good actions , since with this he may be Happy in all his capacities , and without it he shall not only fall into a state of unutterable Misery , but be also accountable for the Possibility he had of escaping it , for neglecting so great Salvation , so great an Opportunity of being saved . XIV . These things being Premised concerning the present Hypothesis or state of Man , First , that he can there know but very little , Secondly , that even that little Knowledge which he can attain to serves more to his Trouble than Satisfaction , and so is not only Vanity , but also Vexation of Spirit . Thirdly , that supposing it as Pleasant as may be , yet such is the shortness and incumbrance of his Life , that the enjoyment of it is not answerable to the Labour of acquiring it . Fourthly , that there is no Necessity of such a deal of Learning and Knowledge , either as to this World , or to the next , and that e're long he shall have his fill of Knowledge in the Beatifick Vision of the Ideal World , one glance whereof shall instruct him more , than an Eternal poring upon all the Books in this , and undistinguish the greatest Doctor from the most ignorant Peasant . Fifthly , that there is an Absolute Necessity of his being Good and Vertuous , this being the condition not only of his Happiness in general , but also of the accomplishment of his Vnderstanding in particular . And that Now is the only opportunity for it . Sixthly , and lastly , that the Attainment of Happiness and Intellectual Perfection upon this Condition was the Purchase of his Saviours Death , who has also Merited Grace for his assistance in the Performance of it . Which if he neglect , he shall not only miss of Happiness , but be also answerable for so Great and so Dear an opportunity of gaining it ; From these Premises 't will I think follow with no less than Mathematical Evidence . XV. First , that Learning and Knowledge is not the thing for which God design'd Man in this Station , nor consequently the End or Reason of his bestowing upon him those intellectual and Rational Powers which he has . For had this been the End and Design of God he would have made it more Possible for him , and withal more his Interest and Concern , to attain it . Secondly , 't will follow that the End for which God intended Man here , and the Reason why he made him a Rational Creature , was that he might Live vertuously and well , so serve him here , that he might be rewarded with Happiness and perfect Knowledge hereafter ; Having furnish'd him with Intellectual abilities sufficient for this , tho not for the other . Thirdly and lastly , 't will follow that the Principal care and concern of Man both because of his own interest , and out of compliance with the Designs of God , ought to be to Live a good and regular Life , to accomplish the Moral part of his Nature , to subdue his Passions , to rectifie his Love , to study Purity of Heart and Life , in one word , to perfect Holiness in the fear of God , and ( which is what we have been hitherto inquiring after ) that he ought to busy himself in the Study of Learning and Knowledge no further , than as 't is conducive to the Interest of Religion and Vertue . XVI . This therefore is the Measure to be observ'd in our prosecution of Learning and Knowledge . We are to Study only that we may be good , and consequently ought to prosecute such Knowledge only as has an aptness to make us so , that which the Apostle calls the Truth , which is after Godliness . For that 's the only business we have to do in this World. Whatever Knowledge we prosecute besides this , or further than 't is conducive to this end , tho it be absolutely consider'd , never so excellent and Perfective of our Rational part , yet with respect to the present Posture and Station of Man , 't is a Culpable Curiosity , and an unaccountable Vanity , and only a more Solemn and laborious way of being Idle and Impertinent . XVII . And this will be found ( if well examin'd ) to be nothing different from the censure of the Wise Preacher . And I gave my heart to to know Wisdom , says he , and I perceiv'd that this also is vanity and vexation of Sptrit . Not that he now first applied himself to the study of Wisdom . No , he had been inspired with that before , and and by the help of it had discover'd the vanity of all other things . But that Wisdom which saw through all other things , did not as yet perceive the Vanity of it self . He therefore now gave his Heart to Know Wisdom , that is , to reflect upon it , and Consider whether this might be excepted from his general censure , and struck out of the Scroll of vanities . And upon deep reflection he found that it could not , and that even this also was as much a vanity as any of the rest . Now this Proposition of Solomon's cannot be understood Absolutely ( Knowledge being an undoubted Perfection of Human Nature ) but only with respect to the present posture of Man in this World. Neither can it be understood of all kind of Knowledge even in this Life , some kind of Knowledge being necessary to qualifie him for Happiness in the next . It must therefore Necessarily be understood of all that Knowledge which contributes not to that great End. So that from these two Necessary Limitations the sense of Solomon's Proposition ( if it have any ) must be this ; that to Man in this present juncture all Knowledge that does not Contribute to the interest of his After-state , is downright Vanity and Vexation of Spirit . XVIII . For , to what purpose should we Study so much , considering that after all we are able to Know so little , considering that even that little is enough to trouble and disquiet us , considering that our Life is as much too short for the enjoying what Knowledge we have , as for compassing what we would have , and withal considering that there lies no manner of Obligation or Necessity upon us to do thus . But ( which is what I would most of all inculcate ) to what purpose imaginable should we be so busy , and vehement in the pursuit of Learning , of any Learning , but what is of use to the Moral Conduct of our Life , considering these two things , First , that 't is but to stay a little while and we shall have all that Knowledge Gratis , from the Communications of the Ideal World , which we so unsuccessfully drudge for here , to the neglect of more important and concerning exercises . And Secondly , considering that there is such an absolute necessity of being Good , and of Living well , and that this short uncertain Life is the only time for it , which if neglected , this great work must lie undone for ever ? Upon the former consideration this Studious , Bookish humour is like laying out a great Sum of Money to purchase an Estate which after one weak , dropping Life will of Course fall into hand . And I am sure he would be reckon'd Fool or Mad that should do so . And upon the latter , 't is as if a Man that was Riding Post upon Business of Life and Death , should as he passes through a Wood , stand still to listen to the Singing of a Nightingale , and so forget the main and only business of his Journey . XIX . 'T is most certain that the two Cases here supposed , are as great instances of Folly and Impertinence as can well be conceiv'd , and yet ( however it comes to pass that we are not sensible of it ) 't is certain that they are very applicable to the Intellectual Conduct of Human Life as 't is generally managed . And tho we are all ready enough to call such men Fools as shall do as in the two mention'd instances is supposed , yet 't is most certain that we do the very same or worse , that we are too much concern'd in the Application of the Parable , and that of most of us it may be truly said , Thou art the Man. XX. For I demand , what difference is there between him that now labours and toils for Learning and Knowledge , which in a little time he shall be easily and fully possest of , and him that dearly buys an estate which would otherwise come to him after a short interval ? what difference is there , but only this , that he that buys the estate , tho he might have spared his Money , yet however he gets what he laid out his Money for ; his expence indeed was needless , but not in vain . Whereas he that drudges in the pursuit of Knowledge , not only toils for that which in a short time he shall have with ease , and in abundance , but which after all he can't compass in any considerable measure , and so undergoes a vain as well as unnecessary Labour . And is therefore the greater Fool. XXI . Again I demand , what difference is there between him who when he is imploy'd upon business of Life and Death shall alight from his Horse , and stand Idling to hear a Nightingale Singing in the Wood , and him who having an Eternity of Happiness to secure by the right ordering of his Life and Manners , and having only this Point of time to do it in , shall yet turn Vertuoso , and set up for Learning and Curiosity . 'T is true indeed the Nightingale Sings well , and 't were worth while to stand still and hear him , were I disingaged from more concerning affairs , but not certainly when I am upon Life and Death . And so Learning and Knowledge are excellent things , and such as would deserve my Study , and my Time , had I any to spare , and were more at leisure , but not certainly when I have so great an interest as that of my final state dependi●g upon the good use of it . My Business now , is not to be Learned , but to be good . XXII . For is my Life so long , am I so over-stock'd with Time , or is my depending interest so little , or is it so easily Secured , that I can find leisure for unnecessary Curiosities ? Is this Conduct agreeable to the present station and Posture of Man , whose entrance into this World , and whose whole stay in it , is purely in order to another state ? Or would any one imagin this to be the condition of Man by such a Conduct ! Shall a Prisoner who has but a few days allow'd him to make a Preparation for his Trial , spend that little opportunity in Cutting and Carving , and such like Mechanical Contrivances ? Or would any one imagin such a Man to be in such a Condition , near a doubtful Trial of Life and Death , whom coming into a Prison he finds so imploy'd ? And yet is there any thing more Absurd and Impertinent in this , than in the present Supposition , than to have a Man who has so great a Concern upon his Hands as the Preparing for Eternity , all busy and taken up with Quadrants , and Telescopes , Furnaces , Syphons and Air-Pumps ? XXIII . When we would expose any Signal Impertinence , we commonly illustrate it by the Example of Archimedes , who was busy in making Mathematical Figures on the Sands of Syracuse while the City was taking by Marcellus , and so though there were Particular Orders given for his safety , lost his Life by his unseasonable Study . Now I confess there was impertinence and absurdity enough in this instance to consign it over to Posterity . But had Archimedes been a Christian , or otherwise assured of the great concerns of another World , I should have said , that the Main of his Impertinence did not lie here , in being Mathematically imploy'd when the Enemy was taking the City , but in laying out his Thoughts and Time upon such an insignificant unconcerning Study , while he had no less a concern upon him than the securing his Eternal Interest . Which must be done now or never . Nothing certainly is an Impertinence , if this be not , to hunt after Learning and Knowledge in such a juncture as this . XXIV . Sure I am , and your Ladyship too very well knows , that many other Proceedings in the Conduct of Life are condemn'd of Vanity and Impertinence upon the very same grounds , tho not half so inconsistent with the Character of Man , nor so disagreeable to his present Posture in this World , For is not the World full of invectives , and have not the Pens of Moral Writers been all along imploy'd against those that apply themselves to Secular acquirements , spend their short and uncertain Lives , which ought to be imploy'd in the Pursuit of an infinitely higher Interest , in gaping up and down after Honours and Preferments , in long and frequent attendances at Court , in raising Families , getting Estates and the like ? These things I say and such like are condemn'd and censured not only upon the stock of their particular Viciousness , as Crimes of Ambition or Covetousness respectively , but for what they have in Common , as they are mispendings of Time , and unconcerning Excentrical imployments . XXV . But now I would fain know , whether any of these Misconducts of Life be more expensive of our Time , more remote and alien from the main business of it , more unrelating to our Grand Concern , and consequently more Impertinent , than to be busily imploy'd in the Niceties and Curiosities of Learning : And whether a Man that loiters away Six Weeks in Court-Attendances for a place of Honour , be not every whit as accountably imploy'd with respect to the End of Man in the other World , and his Business in this , as he that shall spend so much time in the Solution of a Mathematical Question , as M. Descrates I remember confesses of himself in one of his Epistles . And why then the Prosecution of Learning should be the only thing excepted from the Vanities and Impertinencies of Life I have not head enough to understand . XXVI . And yet so it is . All other Excentrical unconcerning Occupations are cried down meerly for being so , as not according with the present Character and State of Man. This alone is not contented with the reputation of Innocence , but stands for positive merit and excellence , for Praise and Commendation . To say a Man is a Lover of Knowledge , and a diligent inquirer after Truth , is almost as great an Encomium as you can give him , and the time spent in the Study , tho in the search of unedifying Truth , is reckon'd almost as laudably bestow'd as that in the Chapel , and ( so inconsistent with its self is Human Judgment ) 't is Learning only that is allow'd not only to divide , but to devour the greatest part of our short Life , and is the only thing that with Credit and Public allowance stands in Competition with Religion and the study of Vertue . Nay , by the most is preferr'd before it , who would rather be counted Learned , than Pious . XXVII . But is not this a strenge and unreasonable Competition ? It must indeed be confess'd that the Perfection of Man is double , of the Intellectual as well as of the Moral Part , and that Knowledge is a very Divine Excellence . But certainly Rectitude of Will is a greater Ornament and Perfection than Brightness of Vnderstanding , and to be Good is more Divine than to be Wise and Knowing , that being the Principal , perhaps only difference between an Angel and a Devil . And tho Solomon's Choice be universally applauded , yet I think that of Mary is to be preferr'd before it , and ( to use the Expression of the Excellent Monsieur Poiret ) that 't is better like an Infant without much reasoning to Love much , than like the Devil to Reason much without Love. XXVIII . But suppose Knowledge were a much Diviner excellence than 't is , suppose it were more Perfective of , and Ornamental to Human Nature than the Habit and Practice of Vertue , yet still this Competition would be utterly against Reason . For 't is to be consider'd ( as I have already suggested ) that the Former we can't have now in any Measure , and shall have it hereafter without Measure , but the latter we may have now ( for we may Love much tho we can't know much ) and cannot have it hereafter . Now the Question is , whether we ought to be more Solicitious for that Intellectual Perfection which we can't have here , and shall have hereafter , or for that Moral Perfection which we may have here , and cannot hereafter ? And I think we need not consult an Oracle , or conjure up a Spirit to be resolv'd of this Question . XXIX . And this one Solitary Consideration ( much more in Conjunction with the other parts of the Human Character ) I take to be sufficient to justifie the Truth of what measure we have prescribed to our Intellectual Conduct , that we ought to prosecute Learning and Knowledge no further than as 't is conducive to the great Ends of Piety and Vertue . And consequently that when ever we study to any other Purpose , or in any other Degree than this , we are unaccountably impertinently , I may add Sinfully imploy'd . For this is the whole of Man , to fear God and keep his Commandments , the whole of Man in this Station , and consequently this ought to be the only Scope of all his Studys and Endeavours . XXX . And accordingly 't is observable that the Scripture whenever it makes mention of Wisdom with any mark of Commendation , it always means by it either the very Practice of Religion and Vertue , or such Knowledge at least , that has a near and strong influence upon it ; thereby implying that that is the only Wisdom which becomes the study of Man. Remarkable above the rest to this purpose is the 28th Chapter of Iob , where having run through several instances of Natural Knowledge , at length says he , But where shall Wisdom be found ? And where is the place of understanding ? As much as to say that in none of the other things mention'd did consist the Wisdom of Man. Then it follows , Man knoweth not the Price thereof , neither is it found in the Land of the Living , The Depth saith , it is not in me , and the Sea saith it is not in me . Not in the Depths of Learning , nor in the Recesses of Speculation , seeing it is hid from the Eyes of all Living , and kept close from the Fowls of the Air , from Men of high and Towring Notions , and sublime Theories . Destruction and Death say , we have heard the Fame thereof with our Ears . As much as to say , that after this Life , and then only , unless perhaps about the hour of Death , Men begin to have a true sense and Lively Savoury Relish of this Wisdom . But in the mean time , God understandeth the way thereof , and he knoweth the place thereof . And unto Man he said , behold the Fear of the Lord that is Wisdom , and to depart from Evil , that is understanding . To Man he said . Had it been to another Creature , suppose an Angel , in a state of Security and Confirmation , he would perhaps have recommended for Wisdom the Study of Nature , and the Curiosities of Philosophy , but having to do with Man , a Probationary and unfixt Creature , that shall be either Happy or Miserable according as he demeans himself in this short time of Trial , the only Wisdom he advises to such a Creature in such a Station , is to look well to his Moral Conduct , to study Religion and good Life . XXXI . And now ( Madam ) since we are upon Scripture-Authority ( for indeed so little has this matter been consider'd , that I have scarce any other to follow ) will your Ladyship give me leave in further Confirmation of the Measure propos'd , to commend to your Consideration two great Scripture-Examples , both of Men Eminently Wise , and of a Learned Education . The Men I instance in are Moses and St. Paul. The latter of which professedly declares that he determin'd to know nothing , but Iesus Christ and him Crucify'd , that is , nothing but what concerns either the Faith or the Practice of Christianity . And the former complaining of the gross Ignorance of the People committed to his charge , and desiring they would become wiser , breaks out into this Passionate Wish , O that they were Wise , that they understood this , that they would consider their latter End. XXXII . Moses had been bred a Scholar , as well as a Courtier , and was well instructed in all the Secrets of the Aegyptian Philosophy , which was then the best in the World. Besides , he was himself a wise Man , a Man that besides the advantages of Pharaoh's Court , had the Divine 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 himself for his Tutor , and convers'd personally with his maker , and therefore must needs be supposed to know what was true Wisdom . But now this he does not make to consist either in the Accomplishments of Courtly Education , or in the deep Mysteries of Philosophy , but in the consideration of our latter End. He wishes that his People were Wise , and to this End he does not wish that they were as Well-bred as he , or as Learned as he , but only that they understood this , this one thing , that they would consider their latter End. Which he makes the Summary and Abstract of all Wisdom . Much like that of Plato , when he defines Philosophy to be , The Theory of Death . XXXIII . And here , if your Ladyship will dispence with a short digression , a digression from the immediate Thred of my Discourse , tho not from the general Design of it , I would upon this occasion briefly represent to you what an excellent part of Wisdom it is for man seriously to consider his latter end . To make this distinctly appear , I shall proceed upon these two grounds : First , That the Consideration of Death is the most proper exercise that a wise man can be employ'd about . And Secondly , that this is the most compendious way of making him wise that is not so . XXXIV . And First , it is the most proper exercise that a wise man can employ himself about . For Wisdom consists in a due estimation of things ; and then things are duly estimated , when they are measured and rated , first as they are absolutely in themselves ; and secondly , as they stand in Relation to us . If they are great and extraordinary then they deserve to be consider'd for their own sakes ; and if they nearly relate to us , then they deserve to be consider'd for ours . And upon both these accounts , Death and its consequences are highly deserving a wise mans Thoughts and Reflections . XXXV . For first , they are great and extraordinary Transactions , barely as in themselves consider'd , and as such would deservedly ingage the most attentive consideration , even of a stander by , of any other indifferent Being , suppose an Angel , that can be no otherwise concerned in it , than as t is a great Event , a Noble Scene of Providence , a matter of Wonder and Curiosity . I say upon this single Account Death with its consequences is as fit a subject for the Contemplation of a Wise man as auy in Nature . XXXVI . Or if there be within the Sphere of Nature things of a greater and more Bulky appearance , yet certainly there is nothing wherein man is so nearly concern'd , so highly interessed as in Death . Since upon the manner of this depends his Eternal Happiness or Ruin. There is therefore nothing that so much deserves to be consider'd by him . Whether therefore we regard the Absolute greatness of the thing , or its Relative greatness with respect to us , as we are interessed and concerned in it , but especially if we weigh both , the consideration of Death is as proper an Exercise as a Wise man can be imploy'd about . XXXVII . And as 't is so fit an imployment for him that is wise already , so secondly is it the most compendious way of making him wise , truly wise , that is not so . For all wisdom is in Order to Happiness , and to be truly wise , is to be Wise unto Salvation . Whatever Knowledge contributes not to this , is quite beside the Mark , and is as the Apostle calls it , Science falsly so called . The Knowledge itself is vain , and the Study of it is impertinent . XXXVIII . Now the only way to Happiness is a good life , and consequently all wisdom being in Order to Happiness , that 's the only wisdom that serves to the promoting of good life , according to that of Iob before cited , And to man he said , behold the fear of the Lord that is wisdom , and to depart from evil is understanding . That therefore is the most compendious way of making a man wise , that soonest makes him good , and reduces his mind to a moral Regularity . And nothing does this so soon and so well as the serious and habitual consideration of Death . And therefore says the wise man , Remember Death and Corruption , and keep the Commandments . The shortest Compendium of Holy living that ever was given . As if he had said , Many are the Precepts and Admonitions left us by wise and good men , for the moral Conduct of life , but would you have a short and infallible Directory of living well ? why , remember Death and Corruption ; Do but remember this , and forget all other Rules if you will , and your Duty if you can . XXXIX . And what is here remarked by one wise man is consented to by all . Hence those common Practises among the Antients of placing Sepulchres in their Gardens , and of using that celebrated Motto , Memento Mori . Hence also that Modern as well as Antient Custom of putting Emblems of Mortality in Churches , and other Public places , by all which t is implied that the Consideration of Death , is the greatest security of a good life . As indeed it must be upon this general ground , because it does that at a Blow , which other considerations do by Parts , and gives an entire defeat to the three great Enemies of our Salvation at once . It sets us above the Temptations of the World the Flesh , and the Devib . For how can the World captivate him , who considers he is but a stranger in it , and that he must shortly leave it ! How can the Flesh insnare him who has his Sepulchre always in his Eye , and reflects upon the cold lodging he shall have there ! And how can the Devil prevail upon him , who remembers always he must dye , and then enter upon an unchangeable State of Happiness or Misery , according as he has either resisted or yeilded to his Temptations ! Of so vast consequence is the constant Thinking upon Death above all other things that fall within the compass even of useful and Practical Meditation , and so great Reason had Moses for placing the Wisdom of Man in the Consideration of his latter End. XL. But to return ( if being still in pursuit of my general design , I may well be said to be out of the way ) I now perswade my self that from the Character I have drawn of Man and his present Circumstances , together with those Reflections built upon it , and interwoven with it , and lastly from Divine Authority , the measure we have given is so well Establish'd , that if your Ladyship be not yet , you ought to be convinc'd that however Naturally desirous we may be of Knowledge , yet that this Appetite is to be govern'd as well as those that are Sensual ; that we ought to indulge it only so far as may tend to the Moralizing our Souls , and the conducting our Lives , and the fitting us for that Happiness which God has promised not to the Learned , but to the Good. And that if it be gratify'd to any other purpose , or in any other Measure than this , our Curiosity is impertinent , our study immoderate , and the Tree of Knowledge still a forbidden Plant. XLI . And now ( Madam ) having fix'd and Stated the Measure of our present Affection to , and Inquiry after Learning and Knowledge , which I think is Establish'd upon irrefutable Principles , I may leave it to your Ladyship to consider how much 't is observ'd in the general Conduct of our Studies . T is plain that 't is not observ'd at all . For these two things are too Notorious to need any more for their Proof than only to look abroad into the World. First , that very little of that which is generally made the subject of Study has any manner of Tendency to Living well here , or Happily hereafter . And Secondly , that these very studies which have no Religious or Moral influence upon Life , do yet devour the greatest part of it . The Best and Most of our Time is devoted to Dry-Learning , this we make the Course of our Study , the rest is only by the by , and 't is well if what is Devotional , Practical or Divinely-relishing , can find us at leisure upon a Broken piece of a Sunday or Holiday . But the Main Current of our Life runs in Studies of another Nature , that don't so much as glance one kind Aspect upon good living , 't is well if some of them dont hinder it . I am sure St. Austin thought so , and makes it part of his Penitentials . And yet to these our youth is dedicated , in these we imploy our riper years ; nor do we see the vanity and impertinence of it in old Age. And then when we dye , this very thing makes one great part of our Funeral Elegy , that we were so diligent and indefatigable in our studies , and so inquisitive in the search of Knowledge , perhaps that we procured an early interment by it , when according to the Principles before laid down , we were as impertinently imploy'd all the while , as if we had been so long picking Straws in Bedlam . I say as impertinently , tho perhaps not so innocently . The Sum of all comes to this : The measure of prosecuting Learning and Knowledge is their usefullness to good Life . Consequently all Prosecution of it beyond or beside this End is impertinent and immoderate . This has been fully proved by evident Principles . But now of this sort is the general prosecution of Learning and Knowledge , as is plain by appealing to the general Conduct of Study . The Conclusion therefore unovoidably follows . That the Intellectual Conduct of Human Life is justly chargeable with an immoderate and impertinent pursuit of Knowledge . Which was the Proposition to be made out , and I am sorry to see it so well proved . The End of the Third Reflection . The Conclusion . ANd now ( Madam ) having finish'd my Threefold Reflection upon the Intellectual Conduct of Human Life , I have a double Application to make , one to your Ladyship , and another to my self . That to your Ladyship is this , that you would consider to what a narrow compass , by vertue of the preceding Discourses , these three things are reduced , which before use to take up so large a room , viz. Learning it self , the Method of Learning , and the Desire and Prosecution of Learning . The first of which is comprized within the Limits of Necessary Truth , the second within those of Thinking , Purity and Prayer ; the third within its usefulness to the furtherance of good life . These indeed are great retrenchments , but I think such as are just and necessary to the Regulation of our Intellectual Conduct , which I am glad to find so compendious and disincumber'd , that being a Mark of no small Probability to confirm me in the Truth of it , as the Rightest Line is also always the Shortest . And since both Learning it self , its Method , and limits of Prosecution are all so reduced , I would further commend to your Ladyships consideration , whether from this great Abridgment you can forbear deducing these two Corollaries , first , that this Bookish Humour which every where so prevails , is one of the Spiritual Dyscrasys , or Moral Diseases of Mankind , one of the most Malignant Reliques of Original depravation . It carrying in it the very Stamp and Signature of Adam's Transgression , which owed its birth to Curiosity , and inordinate desire of Knowledge . Secondly , that those who have Eyes , may in a great Measure spare them , and that those who have not , should not , upon the account of Learning , much lament the want of them which is what particularly concerns your Ladyship's case , and is now address'd to your Private Considerarion . Now as to my own particular Concern , the Result of what I have written is this . I am so inwardly and throughly convinc'd of the certainty of those Principles , I have here lay'd down , that I think I am not only under a particular Obligation , but almost under a Necessity of conducting my studies according to the Measures proposed . The last of which has left such a strong influence , such a deep impression upon me , that I think I shall now follow the Advice of the Heathen ( M. Antonius as I remember ) 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , rid my self of the Thirst after Books , and study nothing but what serves to the advancement of Piety and good life . I have now spent about Thirteen years in the most celebrated University in the World , and , according to the ordinary Measures , perhaps not amiss , having accomplish'd my self in a competent degree both with such Learning as the Academical Standard requires , and with whatever else my own Private Genius inclined me to . But truly I cannot say that I have order'd my studies in that Theatre of Learning , so much to my own Satisfaction , as to my Reputation with others . To be free with you , I must declare , that when I reflect upon my past Intellectual Conduct , I am as little satisfy'd with it as I am with that of my Morals , and that I think I have nigh as much to answer for the Former , as I have for the Latter , being very Conscious that the greatest part of it has been imploy'd in Vnconcerning Curiosities , , such as derive no moral influence upon the Soul that contemplates them . But I have now ( if I sufficiently understand my self ) a very different Taste and Apprehension of things , and intend to spend my uncertain remainder of time in studying only such things as make for the Moral improvement of my mind , and the Regulation of my Life , not being able to give an account upon any rational and consistent Principles , why I should study any thing else . More particularly I think I shall cheifly apply my self to the Reading of such Books as are rather Perswasive , than Instructive , such as are Sapid , Pathetic and Divinely-relishing , such as Warm , Kindle and inlarge the Interiour , and awaken the Divine Sense of the Soul , as considering with my self that I have now , after so much Reading and Speculation , more need of Heat than of Light. Tho if I were for more Light still , I think this would prove the best Method of Illumination , and that when all 's done , the Love of God is the best Light of the Soul. For I consider with the Excellent Cardinal Bona , that a Man may have Knowledge without Love. But he that Loves , altho he wants Sciences humanely acquired , yet he will know more than Human Wisdom can teach him , because he has that Master within who teaches Man Knowledge . Purity of Heart and Life being one of the Methods of Consulting the Ideal World , as was shewn in the Second Part. And now ( Madam ) I cannot well presage how your Ladyship will relish this Renunciation of all studies Meerly Curious , from one whom you apprehended ( perhaps upon too just grounds ) to have been so naturally disposed to them , and so deeply ingaged in them . Perhaps you 'll say I am already Countrify'd since I left the Vniversity . How far that Metamorphosis may seize upon me , I can't yet tell , if Solitude and Retirement be enough to bring it , I am I confess in great Danger , being now got into a little Corner of the World , where I must be more Company to my self than I have been ever yet . But the best on 't is , I have not been so great a stranger to my own Company all along , as to fear any great alteration by it now . Nor do I think the Management of the Present undertaking a sign of any such change . Whether I should have had the same Thoughts in the Vniversity or no , I can't say , I rather believe they are owing to my Country-Retirement ( as I hinted in the Beginning ) but however that be , sure I am they were entertain'd upon the deepest and severest Consideration , and I believe are so well grounded , that the more your Ladyship considers , the more you will be convinc'd both of the Truth of what I have Discours'd , and of the Reasonableness of what I design ; which is to devote my self wholly to the accomplishment of my Moral part , and of my Intellectual , only so far as is Subservient to the other . And now ( Madam ) having bid farewel to all unconcerning Studies , all the dry and unsavoury parts of Learning , 't is high time to take my leave of your Ladyship too ; which I do with this Hope , that one great ground of your Trouble for the Misfortune of your Eyes is by the foregoing Considerations removed : And with this Assurance , that if these Discourses be too Weak to bring you over to my present Opinion , they will however prove Strong enough to work you into a Better , which is to believe , that I still continue in all Reality , Your Ladyships Most Faithful Friend and Servant , Iohn Norris . Newton St. Loe , Sept. 2. 1689. A SERMON Preach'd in the ABBY CHURCH OF BATH , Before the Right Reverend Father in GOD , THOMAS , Lord Bishop of BATH and WELLS : At his VISITATION held there Iuly 30. 1689. By Iohn Norris , M. A. Rector of Newton St. Loe , near Bath , and late Fellow of All-Souls College in Oxford . London , Printed in the Year 1690. John 21. v. 15. So when they had Dined , Iesus saith to Simon Peter , Simon Son of Ionas , Lovest thou me more than these ? He saith unto him , yea Lord ; Thou knowest that I Love thee . He saith unto him , Feed my Lambs . THE Words consist of Three considerable parts . First , of a Question put by our Lord to St. Peter . Secondly , of St. Peter's Answer . Thirdly , of a Command by way of inference from it . The Question was whether St. Peter Loved him beyond the rest of his Disciples then present . This Demand of our Lord was not so high as were St. Peter's former Professions and Pretensions . This warm and Zealous Apostle had always profess'd a more than ordinary Adhesion to his Lord and Master , and pretended to as great a Supremacy of Love , as his Successours do of Knowledge and Iurisdiction . He seem'd to be among the Apostles what the Seraphim are among the Angels , to out-shine and out-burn not this or that vulgar Disciple only , but the whole Apostolical Order in Zeal , Courage , and Flames of Divine Love. For no less can that Eminent Profession of his import , Tho all Men should be offended because of thee , yet will I never be offended . But not having made good his high Pretensions , our Lord now puts the Question to him in terms more moderate than those wherein he had before voluntarily boasted of his own Fidelity ; and whereas he had before made shew of a Superlative Love beyond All the Disciples , our Lord only asks him this Modest Question , Lovest thou me more than these ? The good Apostle having now partly from the late experiment of his own frailty , and partly from the manner of our Lords Question , learnt more Humility and Modesty , returns such an Answer as was short not only of his former Professions , but even of the Question too . He does not reply , Lord thou knowest that I love thee more than these . No , he dares not venture any more so much as to determine any thing concerning the Measure of his Love , but is contented barely to aver the Truth , and Sincerity of it . And for this he fears not to appeal at last to the Divine Omniscience , Lord thou knowest all things , thou knowest that I love thee . Our Lord takes the Answer , and does not at all question the Truth and Sincerity of it , only he gives him a Test whereby it might be tried and justified , both before God , himself and the World , by subjoining this Illative Command , feed my Lambs , as it is in the Text , or as in the two following verses , feed my sheep . This whole intercourse between our Lord and St. Peter , may I conceive , as to the full stress and scope of it , fitly be reduced to this short Hypothetical sceme of speech , If thou lovest me , feed my sheep . Like that of our Saviour , upon another occasion to his Disciples in common , If ye love me keep my Commandments . This under a shorter view takes in the full force of the words , and I shall accordingly discourse upon them , as if they had stood in this Posture . Hence then I shall take occasion to consider these three things , as naturally arising from the words , and as no less pertinent to our present Concern . First the great Love of our Lord Christ to his Church , which he here calls his Lambs , and his Sheep , which he here commands St. Peter as he loved him to feed , and which lastly he would not absolutely and finally commit to his Charge , till after three distinct Inquiries whether he truly loved him . Secondly , I shall consider the Command here given , and shew the great obligation that lies upon all spiritual Pastors and Guides of Souls to feed this flock of Christ which is so dearly beloved by him . Thirdly , I shall consider the Connexion and Dependence that is between the Practice of this command and the Love of Christ. If thou Lovst me feed my sheep . Lastly , I shall close all with an earnest exhortation to the Conscientious Practice of the Duty enjoyned . The first thing I shall consider is the great Love of Christ to his Church . And certainly if there be any Secret in Religion fit for Angels to Contemplate , and too high for them to comprehend ; if there be any Love that has Breadth and Length , and Depth , and Heighth , if there be any Love that passes Knowledge , if there be any love that is stronger than Death , and dearer than Life , if there be any , lastly , that is truly wonderful , and that passes love not only of Women , but of the whole Creation , 't is this Love of our Lord to his Church . We have no line long enough to fathom so vast a Depth , nor can Mortality furnish us with Ideas to conceive , or with words to utter so deep a Mystery . If there be any words that can reach it , they must be such as St. Paul heard in his Rapture , strange words , 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 words that cannot be pronounced by an Human Tongue , and that would be meer Barbarism to a Mortal capacity . But however , that we may take some Measure of that which really has none , and be able to frame some Notion of this Love of Christ , which as the Apostle tells us passes knowledge , we will exhibit a Prospect of it in a Double Light ; First , in those verbal Representations which the Scripture gives of it , and Secondly , in those real and actual Proofs whereby Christ himself has exprest this his most excellent , and otherwise Incredible Love. As to the First , the Scripture we know is full of great things , and those set forth with as great and magnificent Expressions . The Rhetoric and Stile of Scripture runs incomparably high , beyond that of any other writings in whatever it treats of . But there are three things more especially , in the description of which the Holy Spirit seems to Labour , and be at a Stand for Expression . And these are the Glories of Heaven , the Miseries of Hell , and the Love of Christ to his Church . These the Scripture represents under all the variety of Symbols , Figures and Images that can be supplied either from the Intellectual or Material World ; that so what is wanting in each single Representation , might be made up from the Multitude and Combination of them , that if one should miss , another might strike us , to make if possible some impression of so strange and so concerning Truths upon the minds of Men. But the last of these , as 't is most wonderful and Mysterious ( it being a greater wonder that God should Love Man , than that either there should be so much Happiness in the Enjoyment of God , or so much misery in the Loss of him ) so is it more frequently inculcated , and more strongly represented . So frequently inculcated is it , that were it not for the Mystery of the thing , and that there is no Tautology in Love , the Scripture would seem Chargeable with vain Repetitions . Every Page almost in Holy writ breathes forth this Mystery of Divine Love , and besides that , there is one whole Book particularly imploy'd in the representation of it , by all the Flowers and Delicacies of the most exalted Poetry ; it may be said of the whole Sacred Volumn that 't is but one continued Expression of Love from Christ to his Church , one Larger Canticles . And as 't is thus frequently inculcated , so is it no less strongly represented . 'T is represented by that which is the most proper Effect , and the last End and Accomplishment of all Love , by Vnion . For there are three most admirable Unions proposed to our Faith in the Christian Religion . The Unity of Essence in the Trinity , the Unity of Person in Jesus Christ , and the Union that is between Christ and his Church . The First of these is an Example and Prefiguration as it were to the Second , and the Second to the Third . For we cannot better represent the Union of Christ with his Church , than by the Hypostatic Vnion , or the Union of the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 with Human Nature . For First , as in this Mystery the Plurality of Nature is consistent with the Unity of Person , so does Love effect the same Miracle in the Union between Christ and his Church . For here also we meet with a new Theanthropy , a strange Composition of God and Man , two vastly different Substances , which without Confusion of either Natures or Properties , make up one and the same Body . For if Christ be Head of the Church , he is also one Body with it . And so St. Austin , Totus Christus secundam Ecclesiam & Caput & Corpus est . Again , as in the Mystery of the Hypostatic union there is a Communication of Idioms or Properties whereby what primarily and abstractly belongs to one , may secondarily and concretely be attributed to the other , as that God is man , and man is God , so has Love introduced the like Communication between Christ and his Church , which may be said to be happy and glorified in Christ , as he is said to suffer in his Church . Again , as in the Mystery of the Hypostatic union the Word uniting it self to Human Nature adorn'd and exalted it , not only by the Priviledge of so sacred a Confederacy , but also with many distinct Graces and Excellencies , whereby it was necessarily tho not forcibly determin'd to love the Divinity , and highly fitted to be loved by it , so is it also in this Union between Christ and his Church . He has not only innobled her by so sacred an Alliance , but is ever conferring upon her his Gifts and Graces , and will never cease to do so , till at length he present her to himself a Glorious Church , without spot or blemish , and make her in some measure worthy of so great a Love , and so intimate an Vnion . For 't is observable , that in Scripture Jesus Christ is set out as the Author and Dispencer of all Grace , to him is ascribed the Work of the Second as well as of the First Creation , from his fulness we all receive , and the Apostle says expresly , that to every one of us is given grace according to the Measure of the gift of Christ. But not to pursue this Metaphysical Parallel any further , let us return to consider this Union , as 't is represented in Holy Scripture . Now there are but two sorts of Union in the World , Natural and Moral . And the Holy Spirit has made Choice of the Closest of each , whereby to Figure out to us the Union between Christ and his Church . The closest of Natural Unions is that between the Head and the Body ; and the closest of all Moral Unions is that between the Husband and the Wife . And both these are by the Holy Spirit applied to this Mystery . Thus is Christ oftentimes call'd the Head of the Church , and the Church the Body of Christ. Thus again is he stiled the Bridegroom , and the Church honour'd with the Name of his Spouse . And because this Latter Figure carries in it more of sensible endearment , therefore is it of more frequent use , and withal of more Antient Date . For besides that Adam first open'd this Mystery , and by his Miraculous Marriage typified to us that of Christ with his Church , which came out of the Wounded Side of our Lord , as Eve was taken out of Adam's , the Prophets have also given our Lord the title of Bridegroom in the Old Testament . The 45th Psalm is a plain Spiritual Epithalamium , and so is the whole Book of Canticles , and the Holy Baptist , in whom both Types and Prophesie expire , calls him expresly by the Name of Bridegroom . Strange Miracle of Humility and Love ! That ever God should come down to seek a Spouse upon Earth ! was it not enough , O Blessed Jesu , that thou wast one with the Father and Holy Spirit , in the Eternal Trinity ? was it not enough that thou hadst made thy self one with our Mortal Flesh by assuming our Nature , but that thou must yet heap Mystery upon Mystery , and as if thou wert not yet near enough allied to us , must also make thy self one with thy Church ? But such is thy Love to man as not to be contented with one single union with him ? And so great thy Condescention as if thou need'st a Partner , to compleat thy Happiness , and as if it were no more good for the second , than 't was for the first Adam to be alone . These are the two Principal Figures under which the Scripture Pictures out to us the Love of Christ to his Church , and his union with it . Not that they rise up to the heighth of the Mystery , but because they come the nearest of any to it . For indeed they fall vastly short , and give but a faint shadowy resemblance of what they are intended to represent . And therefore as we have hitherto represented the dearness between Christ and his Church , by that between the Head and the Members , and the Husband and Wife , so we may , and with better reason invert the Order , and propose the Former as an Example and Measure for both the Latter . And 't is observable that St. Paul does so ; For says he , Husbands love your Wives , even as Christ loved the Church . And again , No Man ever yet hated his own Flesh , but Nourishes and Cherishes it even as the Lord the Church . Where you see the Love of Christ to his Church is not , as before , set out by that of Married Persons , and that of a Man to his own Flesh , but these are set out and illustrated by the other . So great and transcending all Love , yea even all Knowledge , is this Love of Christ to his Church . But 't will appear yet greater , if we take a Prospect of it in the Second Light , namely in those Real and Actual Proofs whereby Christ himself has exprest this his most excellent and otherwise incredible Love. And certainly they are such as never were , will , or can be given by any other Lover . For ( to make the Prospect as short as maybe ) was it not an amazing instance of Love for the great and ever Blessed God , who could neither be advantaged by our Happiness , nor damaged by our Misery , to come down and assume our Nature in its meanest Circumstances , to live a needy and contemptible Life , and dye a painful aud execrable Death , and all this to reconcile a Rebel , to restore an Apostate ? Indeed the work of Man's Redemption , if we deeply consider the whole Method and Contrivance of it , is such an Heroic instance of Love , and so much exceeding that of his Creation , that 't is well Man was Created and Redeem'd by the same good being , since otherwise his obligations to his Redeemer being so much greater than those to his Creator , he would be very much divided and distracted in his returns of Love and Gratitude . But let us reflect a little upon the Life , before we further consider the Death of our Redeemer . It was one constant Argument , one continued Miracle of Love. He lived as one purely Devoted to the good of Mankind . All his Thoughts , all his Words , all his Actions were Love , His whole business was to Glorify his Father , and ( which was his greatest Glory ) to express his Love to Man , which tho at all times exceeding wonderful , yet toward the Evening of his Life it thicken'd and grew stronger , like Motion within the Neighbourhood of the Center , and as then he Prayed , so he Loved yet more earnestly . For 't was then that he wept over Condemn'd Ierusalem , and bedew'd with Tears the Grave of Lazarus . 'T was then that with desire he desired to Eat the Passover with his Disciples , instituted a perpetual Monument of Love , his Holy Supper , and left another of Humility by condescending to wash their Feet . 'T was then that he comforted his Disciples with the variety of the Heavenly Mansions , with a Declaration that he himself was the way , the Truth and the Life , with an assurance that their Prayers in his Name should be effectual , with a Promise of the Holy Spirit , and with a Legacy of his own Peace , to compensate for the Tribulation they should meet with in the World. 'T was then , lastly , that he recommended the state of his Apostles , together with his own Glorification , in one and the same Solemn Prayer to his Father , that he would preserve them in Unity and Truth , and at length Glorify them with the whole Body of true Believers with himself in Heaven . And all this at a time when one would have thought his own concern should have been his only Meditation , and Fear his only Passion , for now was he within view of his amazing sufferings , and the shade was just ready to point at the dreadful hour , and yet even now his Love was truly stronger than Death , and the Care of his Disciples prevailed over the Horrors of his approaching Agony . Which he further shewed by giving up himself to a cruel and shameful Death , for the Life and Salvation of the World. A Death ( to say no more of it ) of such strange Sorrow and Anguish , that the very Prospect of it put him into a Sweat of Blood , and the induring it made him complain of being deserted of his Father . And then that his Redemption might prove effectual , after his Resurrection he gives Commission to his Disciples to go and publish it with its conditions throughout the world , and orders them all , as he does here St. Peter , to feed his Sheep . And lest the the Benefit of his Death should be again frustrated for want of Power to perform the conditions , presently after his Ascension he sent down the Spirit of consolation upon his Apostles , and does continually confer Grace upon , and make Intercession for his Church . So tenderly affected was he toward this his Spouse , that even the felicities of Heaven could not make him forget her , as he further shew'd by complaining in behalf of his Church , when from the midst of his Glory he said , Saul , Saul , why persecutest thou me ? Which words shew him as much concern'd for the wounds given to his Mystical , as for those he felt in his Natural Body . And now since the Love of our Lord to his Church is so exceeding great , it certainly concerns all Christians , especially those whom he has intrusted with the Care of his Church to be alike minded . Which leads me in the Second place to consider the command here given , and to shew the great Obligation that lies upon all spiritual Pastors , to feed this flock of Christ which is so nearly beloved by him . Feed my sheep , says our Lord to St. Peter , and in him to all the Pastors of the Christian Church , who are equally concerned both in the Command and in the Duty . And that they are so is , already sufficiently concluded from what has been discoursed concerning the great Love of Christ to his Church . To make you therefore more sensible of this Duty I need only propose to your Meditation , how affectionately our Lord loves his Church , and how dear her Interests are to him , that out of this his abundant Love , he has set apart a distinct Order of men on this very purpose , to promote and further her in the way of Salvation , that he has intrusted the care of her in their hands , and has made them his Vicegerents and Trustees ; that 't is a Charge worthy their greatest care , for which there needs no other Argument than that 't is committed to them , by him who knows the worth . of Souls ; that he strictly commands them , as they have any Love or Regard for him , to feed his Sheep ; that 't was the very last Command that he gave them , when he was just leaving the world , and upon the very confines of Glorification , and that lastly as this is the greatest Trust that was ever by God reposed in Men , so there will be the severest account taken of it at the last day , at the Great Visitation of the Bishop of Souls . This is enough , if duely weighed , to shew the Obligation of this command , and to conclude this part , were it not necessary to add something concerning the manner of discharging it . Feed my Sheep is the Command given by Christ to the Pastors of his Church , and we have seen the obligation of it : But how are they to Feed them ? I answer , First by Prayer for their respective charges both in Public and in Private . This is the First thing belonging to the Pastoral Office , and accordingly with this St. Paul begins his Admonition to his Son Timothy . I exhort therefore that first of all , Supplications , Prayers , Intercessions and giving Thanks be made for all Men. Secondly by Preaching , with Private Instruction and Admonition as occasion shall serve and require . And here their first care should be to Preach nothing but what is True. Secondly , to confine their Discourses to Vseful Truths , such as tend to the promotion of good Life , that which the Apostle calls the Truth which is after Godliness . Thirdly , to deliver only Plain Truths . For there are many Truths which are highly useful and have a very Practical aspect when they are once understood , which are not so easie and obvious to be so . These therefore ought as much to be waved as those which are not useful , because tho useful , simply speaking , yet respectively they are not . And upon these two latter accounts we should not trouble our Unlearned Auditories , either with Thorny Questions and Knotty Controversies which in themselves have no Practical use , or with more refined Theories and School Niceties , which to them are as useless and unpractical as the other . To Feed them with the Former would be to give them Stones instead of Bread ; And to Feed them with the Latter would be like placing a Man in the Region of pure Ether ; why , he can't breath in it , and will starve by reason of the over-fineness of his Diet. Nor is it enough that the Truths we Preach be Vseful and Plain , unless in the Fourth place they be deliver'd in a Plain and Intelligible Manner . For what signifies it that the things are in themselves Plain , if we make them obscure in our expressing them ; we are all ready enough to laugh at the Poor Frier for going about to Preach the Gospel to Beasts and Trees , and are not they alike ridiculous that order Discourses so as not to be understood by those that hear them ? Don't these also Preach to Beasts and Trees ? We ought therefore to consult the Capacity of our Hearers , and consider to whom , as well as what we speak . And to this Plainness of Expression we would do well to join some degrees of Warmth and Concernedness . And this I rather recommend because there are some that affect a Cold , Dead , careless and heartless way of Delivery . But certainly this has as little Decorum in it as it has of Devotion . For since the things we speak are supposed not only to be Truths , but Concerning and Important Truths , what can be more absurd than to see a Man deliver a Sermon as drily and indifferently , as one would Read a Mathematical Lecture ? 'T is said of Iohn the Baptist , that he was a Burning , as well as a Shining Light. And truly we have need of such in this Cold Frozen Age. Plain Sermons , Preach'd with Warmth and Affection do more than the Best , Coldly deliver'd . You know the Story in Eusebius of the Heathen Philosopher coming into the Council of Nice , who was baffled into Christianity by the meer Warmth and Heartiness wherewith the good Old Man address'd him . He could have resisted his Arguments , but not the Spirit and Zeal wherewith he spake . And this is all I shall think proper to remark to you upon the Preaching part . The next way whereby the Pastors of the Church are to Feed the Sheep of Christ , is by duely Administring to them the Holy Sacrament , which is their true Spiritual Food , the Manna that must sustain them in this Wilderness . This is the most proper way of Feeding them , for the Body of Christ is Meat indeed , and his Blood is Drink indeed . There remains yet one way more of Feeding the Flock of Christ , without which the rest will signifie but little , and that is by a good Example . Among the other Properties of a good Shepherd , our Saviour reckons this as one , that he goes before his Sheep , and leads them by his Steps , as well as with his Voice . There ought to be a Connexion between Hear and Do , but much more between Preach and Do. And he that is not careful of this , as he cannot expect to do much good to others , so he will certainly Condemn himself . To be short ( for I hope I need not inlarge , speaking to Wise Men ) a good Preacher who is an ill Liver is such a Monster as cannot be Match'd in all Affrica . And for his State hereafter , I may leave it to be consider'd how great a Condemnation awaits him , whom not only the Book of God , and of Conscience , but even his own Sermons shall Judge at the last Day . These are the several ways of discharging this Precept , Feed my Sheep ; to which however I think it necessary to add one thing more , and that is that we Feed them our selves , and not by Proxy , or Deputation . For out Lord does not say to St. Peter , do thou get some body to Feed my Sheep , but do thou Feed them thy self . For however St. Peter's Shadow might do Cures upon the Body , it must be his Person that must do good upon the Souls of his Charge . To speak out plainly what I intend , Non-residency is one of the greatest scandals of the Reform'd , yea of the Christian Religion , contrary to all Reason and Justice , as well as Primitive Practice . And whoever are guilty of it , plainly shew that they are Lovers of Ease , Honour or Profit more than Lovers of Christ. For certainly he that Loves Christ as he ought will not think himself too good to Feed his Sheep . Which leads me in the Third and Last place to consider the Connexion and Dependance that is between the Practice of this Command and the Love of Christ. Now this I briefly make out upon a double ground . The First Ground is , because the Love of Christ will naturally ingage us to Love whatever he Loves , and consequently since his Church is so exceeding dear to him , 't will ingage us to Love his Church , and if to Love it , then consequently to be diligent in Feeding it , that being the most proper instance of shewing our Love to it . The Second Ground is , because the Person of Jesus Christ consisting of a Double Nature , God and Man , the Love of him must include the Love of his Humanity ; as well as of his Divinity . If therefore we Love Christ , we Love the Human Nature as well as the Divine , and if so , then we Love Man as Man , consequently all Men , and if we Love all Men , we shall desire and endeavour their Salvation , and accordingly take care to Feed them with the Bread of Life . Upon these two Grounds it plainly appears that there is a strong Connexion between the Loving of Christ , and the Feeding of his Sheep , and that such Pastors as do not well discharge the Latter , have no right of pretending to the Former . This is the Test whereby both St. Peter's and every Spiritual Pastor's affection to our Lord must be tried , If you Love me , Feed my Sheep . Let me therefore exhort you all , as you Love our Lord Jesus Christ , and as you desire to be Loved and approv'd of by him , to a sincere and Conscientious Discharge of your Pastoral Duty , to take heed unto your selves and to all the Flock over which the Holy Ghost has made you Overseers , to Feed the Church of God , which he has purchased with his own Blood. Let me beseech you to consider what you are , and what you should be . What you are by your Character and Profession , and what you should be in the Exercise of it , and therefore to take heed to your selves , to your Doctrine , and above all to your Publick Life and Conversation . For certainly it cannot be an Ordinary Measure of Religion that will serve our turn , who are concern'd not only to be Good , but Exemplary , and must Live well for others as well as for our selves , what therefore is Perfection in others , will be but strict Duty in us . The Devotion of our Ordinary days , ought to exceed that of their Festivals , and we should Live in as much Warmth of Religion as they Dye . 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 In all things shewing thy self a Pattern of good Works , That 's our Rule , we ought to be Patterns and Examples of a Holy and refined Conversation . Let your Lamps therefore be always trimm'd , and your Lights always Burning , and that with such Brightness , as to shame those that will not be allured by the Glory of the Flame . And that you may the better do all this , let me desire you all frequently and seriously to Meditate upon the Excellent Example of the great and good Shepherd Christ Jesus , whose Life was wholly imploy'd , and at last laid down for the good of his Sheep . I pray you ( My Reverend Brethren ) consider this and all that has been said , that so when this great Shepherd shall return to visit his Flock , you may all give up the same Account to him , that he did to his Father , Those that thou gavest me I have kept , and none of them is lost . Amen . FINIS . Books Printed for Sam. Manship , at the Black-Bull , in Cornhil . ODes . Satyrs , and Epistles of Horace , done into English ; the second Edition . Lives of the most Famous English Poets , or the honour of Parnassus , in a brief Essay of the Works and Writings of above two hundred of them , from the time of K. William the Conqueror , to the Reign of the late K. Iames the second , in Octav. Reason and Religion , or the Grounds and Measures of Devotion , Considered from the Nature of God and the Nature of Man , in several Contemplations , with Exercises of Devotion , applied to every Contemplation ; by Iohn Norris , M. A. and Fellow of All-Souls-College in Oxford . Octavo , price 2 s. The Theory and Regulation of Love , a Moral Essay in two Parts , to which is added Letters Philosophical and Moral , between the Author and Doctor More , by I. Noris , M. A. and Fellow of All-Souls-College in Oxford . 2 s. A Cap of Gray-Hairs , for a Green Head , or the Fathers Counsel to his Son an Apprentice in London : Containing wholesome Instructions for the Managements of a Man's whole Life : The Fourth Edition in Twelves . 1 s. The Injured Lovers , or the Ambitious Father a Tragedy ; Acted by their Majesties Servants , at the Theatre Royal : by W. Mountfort . A Comedy . The Comical Revenge , or Love in a Tub ; as it is now Acted at their Majesties Theatre : by Sir Geo. Ethenege . The Gallant Hermaphrodite , an Amorous Novel , Translated from the French , of the Sieur de Chouigny . price 1 s. The Marrow of Divinity , or the Chief Grounds of Protestant Religion , briefly Explained in a Form of Catechising ; by way of Question and Answer , by William Ames , D. D. price 3. d. FINIS . Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A52433-e280 Eccles. 11.7 . Notes for div A52433-e530 Exod. 17.6 . Vid. Reason and Religion . Pag. 82. Vid. the same Treatise . Pag. 203. 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 . p. 3. Cogitationes Rationales de Deo p. 296. De la Recherche de la verite p. 208. 1 Cor. 13.8 . Notes for div A52433-e7740 Vide , Reason and Religion . Joh. 1.5 . P. 144. P. 146. P. 148 , Reason and Religion . Colos. 2.3 . Prov. 8.34 . C. 9.4 . Joh. 8.12 . Tauler Sermon , 3. Pasch. P. 412. Joh. 7.17 . 1 Cor. ● . 14 . 1 Wisd. 4. Dan. 12.10 . Psal. 119. Joh. 8.12 . 1 Cor. 13.12 . Dan. 1.15 Joh. 14.2 . V. 23. Psal. 25.13 . Dan. 1.17 . Pag. 5. Jam. 1.5 . 1 King. 3.9 . Notes for div A52433-e12910 Eccl. 43. Nat. Hist. p. 13. Job . 38. Eccles. 1.18 . Colos. 3.10 . Cogitat . Ration . de Deo. p. 62● . Eccles. 12.13 . V. 12. V. 13. V. 14. V. 21. V. 22. V. 23. V. 28. 1 Cor. 2. Deut. 32.29 . Confess . Lib. c. 1.16 . Notes for div A52433-e19770 Via compendii ad Deum . p. 172. Notes for div A52433-e21120 Mat. 26.33 . Ephes. 3.19 . Ephes. 5.27 . Ephes. 4.7 . Ephes. 5.25 . Ver. 29. Luke . 22.44 . Jo. 17. 1 Tim. 2.1 . 1 Titus . John 5.35 . John 10.4 Act. 20.28 . Tit. 2.7 . John 17.12 .