The censors censured, in a brief discourse to which is adjoyned the authors letter to an anti-episcopal minister concerning the government of the church : written in the year 1651, but not printed till now. Edmonds, Hugh. 1661 Approx. 23 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 9 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2007-10 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A37900 Wing E178A ESTC R36147 15612637 ocm 15612637 104118 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A37900) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 104118) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 1590:40) The censors censured, in a brief discourse to which is adjoyned the authors letter to an anti-episcopal minister concerning the government of the church : written in the year 1651, but not printed till now. Edmonds, Hugh. [6], 14 p. Printed for Phil. Stephens ..., London : 1661. "To the reader" signed: Hugh Edmonds. Reproduction of original in the Sion College Library, London. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Church of England -- Government. Church of England -- Apologetic works. Episcopacy. Presbyterianism -- Controversial literature. 2006-10 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2006-10 Aptara Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2006-11 Jonathan Blaney Sampled and proofread 2006-11 Jonathan Blaney Text and markup reviewed and edited 2007-02 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion THE CENSORS CENSVRED , IN A Brief Discourse : To which is adjoyned the AUTHORS LETTER TO AN Anti-Episcopal Minister Concerning The Government of the CHURCH . Written in the year 1651. but not printed till now . LONDON : Printed for Phil. Stephensat the Kings Armes over against Middle Temple Gate in Fleetstreet , 1661. To the READER , Courteous Reader , ALthough the many Books which have been already printed in defence of Episcopacy , may seem not only to forestal the credit , but to evacuate the use of future Impressions , about the same subject ; yet considering the messe of Confederate Brethren , who are sworn to oppose it , which ( being an Oglio of all Sects ) is of far greater dimension then the defendant party . I presumed it would not amount to the reckoning of a vanity to enter with my unkeen weapon into the same field : which ( though unworthy to be mustered with those forces of wit , that fight for victory ) may serve ( like the attendants of an Army ) to face the enemy . It is the fate of truth for its naked simplicity to be as little known , as trusted , with earthly inhabitants : whereas errour , clothed with glosing variety , finds not only acceptation , but maintenance in the hearts of most . What Gangrenes of Heresies , and fretting sores of schismatical opinions have infested the body of our National Church ? since Bishops ( the ministerial preservers thereof in soundnesse of Doctrine ) were first divorced from their office , as the History of former ages can yield no examples to parallel , so ( being by Satans subtilty heightned to an exquisite degree of wickednesse ) the possible corruption of succeeding times , will want invention to excel . Such was the sudden growth of greedy innovations in the black art of enmity , against their ancient guides , that experience hath proved them to be a true exception to the Philosophers saying , Nemo repente fit turpissimus . And if their master , who raised them to the pinacle of preferment , had not thrown them down headlong by a timely temptation , they would have all turned conceited Monarchs , and not lookt over , but for the Kingdomes of the earth . It will be as much shame hereafter to report , as it is now grief to remember the fiery generation of those meteors o● men , which ( rising by the fall of our great stars ) have vapoured from the Regions both of pulpit and presse , into the houses of the honourable , and musty Cottages of the basest people , deluding them into such a lamentable deviation from their right principles , that the greatest part of them ( like benighted Drunkards ) are not yet able to finde the way home . The consideration whereof doth offer us so much occasion , to pity the dangerous estate of their diseased souls , that I could wish no better successe to attend this work , then that , by detecting the malignant distemper of their faults , it may become a direction for their recovery . But knowing that habituated Crimes will not readily yield to a seperation from the subjects that possesse them , and that custome in sin , ( holding reason in bondage to the dominion of sense ) doth seldome nauseate the sinner to a detestation thereof . I am disposed to doubt , that the event will be unanswerable to the scope of my desire . However the chiefest Part of this Book being written in time of persecution , when Tyranny had stated the Tribes of all honest men in a fitter capacity of receiving wrongs then giving reasons , I shall not now disown the exposing thereof to publick view , though it happen to make a fermentation of humours in the cholerick stomacks of our English Pharisees . For being set forth with the same intention wherewith it was first penned , more to declare my willingnesse to approve , then ability of mind to defend the right of Episcopal Government . It may not be coujectured to be composed with confidence to confute those that deny , but out of love to confirm them who believe the same . To thee therefore , Gentle Reader , whosoever thou art of this number , do I principally dedicate this my labour , wherein if thou apprehend nothing deserving thy condemnation , but the truth of my affection to the welfare of the Church , it will be applause enough to satisfie the expectation of Thy well-wishing friend , HUGH EDMONDS . THE CENSORS CENSURED . AS in natural , so in bodies Politique , there are no distempers more smartly afflicting , than those which invade the most noble parts , and amongst the many causes , which work a solution of unity , in a civill constitution of government , the corrupt humours of a brain-sick clergy are the most intrinsecal . The Truth whereof , though we have by the sad experiences of our own past miseries been better taught to bewail , than dispute ; yet being farther instructed by the present discovery of their propagated mischiefs ( notwithstanding the bountiful rayes of mercy diffused amongst them from our Englands Sun ) we cannot but account it a pitifull folly to commiserate them , who think it a virtue to be cruel to themselves ; for they , whom neither the sense of their own sin , nor apprehension of the Kings pardon can reform , must needs be not onely the charity , which submitteth to the worst of Governours , and it may be justly feared , that no true concordance will inhabit the centre , whilest such Heteroclites are left to lurk in the circumference of the Church , who will rather professe themselves St. Peters animals by standing out in their own conceit , than St. Pauls souls in stooping to the authority of their lawful superiours , neither can they be well thought fit Trustees for the securitie of the Gospels treasure , who having once shipwrackt their Allegiance to the King , are still bankrupt of faith and honesty . Those are the old stocks , whereupon Satan hath graffed the variety of Sects , which hath been the shame , and is yet the grief of Englands Church , whose first non conformity to Canonical orders , hath been the very originals , whereunto the many copies of obstinate Fanaticks , that are now extant , have their true reference , who following the tracts of St. Judes murmurers , in admiration of some mens persons for advantage sake , do dissociate themselves from the community of Saints , not only in opinion , but practise , than which nothing can be more destructive to the concord and peaceable unanimity of spiritual Congregations ; for as in physical Compositu●s , a violent disunion of Integrable parts breeds a more dangerous shisme in the body , than a humerous distemper ; so in Ecclesiastical corporations , an actual seperation from the Catholick fellowship of beleevers in Gods service is a greater pandor to confusion , than the scandal of a speculative distraction . It is time therefore for our Seminary Presbyters , who have been the Protoplastiques of a Rebellious generation , both in Church and State , to make a confession of their past faults , as well as their present faith to the King. They are now sufficiently read in the book of their own consciences to know , nemo periculosius peccat , quam qui peccata defendit , to Apologize for sin is more damnable , than to act it , and not to retract inexcusable errours , doth as much unqualifie a delinquent for mercy , as the perpetration thereof can adapt him to justice . Repentance , though it may be too soon ended , can never bee too late begun ; he , that lives like St. Lukes judge on the bench , neither fearing God , nor regarding man , may have the grace to die like the Jewes theef on the Crosse , with profession of both ; for that power which expresly denyeth forgivenesse to one sin onely , doth implicitely conceede a possibility of pardon to all others . On this consideration it would be worth their paines to translate their Petition for Presbytery into a Suit for Indempnity , and publickly to acknowledge his Majesties Declaration which is the proof of his grace , to be an argument of their guilt , who ( like cunning fencers , that aim at the legs , when they intend to veny the pate ) under a reformative pretence of destroying those revenous beasts , which worry the people , begg'd leave of their master to hunt the kingdome , which being granted , they took liber●y of themselves to make him their chief game : for it is well known from Dan to Beersheba , that the credit of their false doctrine was the very leaven wherewith the people were first moulded into a sowre lump of armed malice against their Sovereigne . And I may truly say , it was the unlucky Boutefen , which not only yielded smoak to smother all Treaties into a nullity of successe , but that gave light also to clear the way for more active instruments then themselves to take off the Head of our eternally renowned Saint Charles , together with the Government from his soulders ; for although they entred not the Stage with those miscreants that personated Pilate in the fifth Act ; yet because they appeared with others who playd the parts of Annas and Caiphas , in the first Scene of the Tragedy , we may justly christen them the Grandfathers in law of that bloudy fact , which being unmatchable in humane stories , may be in some sort compared to the crafty complement of the cruel wolfe in the fable , who told the sheep , Da mihi potum , & ego mihi dabo cibum , meaning to eat him up for his courtesie . A fact , which as former ages have not been so learnedly wicked to invent , so I hope the future will be more honestly wise than to imitate ; A fact , which may schoole our Kings of England into a use of the Italians prayer , to be delivered from their friends whom they trust , as well as from their enemies whom they fear , and inform the people with the Spaniards soul , rather to sheath their swords in one anothers bowels upon private quarrels , than to draw them against their Sovereign in open war. But , if the Recognition of such an execrable murder be not caution enough for subjects to restrain them from Rebellion , let the memorable example of the Amalekites punishment be their exhortation to obedience , 2 Sam. 1. 13 , 14. who ( though a stranger to Sauls kingdome , and by them requested to conclude his pain with the inference of death ) was by Davids command for touching the Lords anointed , instantly condemned to loose his life . If Kings lives then are so precious in Gods account , that they may not be touched in the heat of proclaimd hostility , what a cursed sin must that be , which justifieth those who take them away in cold bloud ? By these animadversions I hope the whole host of spirituall officers , who have fought against the Regiment of the Church , will be victoriously fens'd into a unanimous Iudgement , that it is far better for them to have the Apostles doctrine in their hearts , then the Scots discipline in their hands , to be content with that estate wherein they have been , then to covet that wherein they ought not to be , to submit to the King in causes Ecclesiastical , rather then by calling his power in question , to abuse their own authority in the Gospel , to give Caesar his , will be no substraction from their due , had not our Saviour paid for himself and Peter , it might be doubted , whether the Clerks of this age ( like the old Egyptian Priests ) would not plead their estates untributary , as well as their offices unsubj●ct to the King. With what tenure of spiritual power they are invested Jure divino , none but those Laicks whom the Popes Mandate hath screen'd from the Sun-shine of Gods word , can be ignorant . The officious Acts of Jehoiada to Jehoash , and Nathan to David , are not only presidents to warrant the right , but boundaries to limit the extent of their claim ; they must instruct Kings as the one , and may reprove them as the other did , which was not executed by an excommunicative scourge to make David do pennance for his offence , but with the monition of a meek spirit , to give him a penitent sense thereof ; for as the act of reproof argued the King to be Gods subject : so the mode of reproving maintain'd him to be the Proph●ts Sovereign . And thus I believe Azariah withstood Vzziah by no other force , save that of the tongue , whose aim was to strike at the fact , not the person of the King , to induce him into a consciousnesse of his fault , not to require his submission to punishment , which , because immediately inflicted of God ▪ supposeth him priviledg'd not to receive it from man : so that rebus sic stantibus , our ministerial Guides have little reason , and lesse grace to pride themselves in their Ghostly authority of reb●●ing Kings , such verbal Reprehensions being no more then religious servants ( not adventuring beyond the sphear of their calling ) may lawfully practise towards their ungodly masters ; for as it is the Resolve of Divines , that in case of neccessity Quil●bet Christianus est sacerdos , so it is not only the liberty , but the duty of every one in Gods case boldly to reprove an offending brother , as I think my self bound to tell the associated brethren , that they have highly wronged the Majesty of God & the King , both by their orall and manual prolusions to introduce a new fangled government in the Church , & that it will be more safe for them to observe the duty of looking into their own , then the false commission of overseeing their superiours actions , the performance whereof might happily make that saying ex culpa sacerdotum ruina populi , to be as well known to themselves , as felt by others , and convert the hypocrisie , which some do , into the sincerity of obedience , which all should professe ; for though none of them be puritanized into Donatisme , but can protest it their necessary obligation to reverence the Kings person , yet most are so far sublimated from the drosse of superstition , that they cannot without defiling their consciences vaile to the train of his ceremonious Titles , they can easily concoct supream Governours , dryly swallowed , but with the sawce of Ecclesiastical causes it quite nauseates their stomacks , and the name of head is more offensive to their palates , then perfumes are to the nostrils of those that are grieved with an Histerical passion ; a monstrous straw for such mighty men to stumble at , which may be put in the same ballance with that of their schismatical Predecessours in the conference at Hampton Court , who were scandalized with the word absolution in the Liturgy , but well content with the Term Remission of sins . What difference there is betwixt supream Governour and Head in a notional acception , is more fit for Grammatical Criticks , then politick Christians to inquire , as they are complicated in one subject , and determined to a constant onenesse both of action and end , they must by the rules of honesty as well as Art , be construed Synonymous , and in a promiscuous manner adjudged to contract their literal variety into an identity of sense . Indeed we cannot deny but the Title of supream Head was first given to King Henry the Eight by the Pope , who being by his own institution in the world ( as the soul is in the body by Gods Creation ) Totus in toto , and not onely singulis , but universis major , cannot be supposed to part with a piece of himself but for his own ends ; yet we conceive it no trespasse against any Canon , either of Scripture or reason , to convert that to a good use , which was first bestowed to an ill purpose , but for Presbyters to take that away for the better esteem of their own authority , which was given by the Pope , to disgrace the Kings jurisdiction in the Church , is no lesse unreasonable to devise , then irreligious to practise . That great Bulwark of objection , ( Christ is the sole Head of the Church , ergo no other can have the Title ) which hath been presumed too strong for an army of Schoolmen to beat down , must necessarily yield upon terms to our side . For although as the Church is internally considered in respect of the kingdome of Grace , and our Saviour Christ as Lord thereof , by right of Redemption , ruling the hearts of the faithful by his spirit , there is no subjection allowable , nor headship to be attributed but to him only ; yet as he is King by right of Creation , loving an Imperial Sovereignty over all his creatures , and the Church in a militant condition , which ( by reason of an inseperable commixture of good and bad , and common relation of the inward and outward man ) doth necessarily require an external policy to maintain a uniformity and order in the worship of God , so he hath ordained his Vicegerent on earth to whom both Clergy and Laity must be subject . And in this qualification of sense Kings may be truly stiled supream Heads in causes Ecclesiastical , within their Dominions ; Thus Samuel called Saul the Head of the Tribes of Israel , 1 Sam. 15. 17. which in eodem signo rationis doth imply all persons , as well Ecclesiastical as civil in that Commonwealth , to be his subordinate members . And that the Priests were subject in their very Offices to the supreame power of their magistrates , 2 Chron. 8. Solomons Acts in ordering their courses , and appointing the Levites to their charges , ( who in manifestation of their duty are said not to depart from the commandement of the King ) do sufficiently evidence , whose authority likewise to punish sins of the first table , that refer to Religion as well as those of the second , which belong to humane society . Gods own prescript Laws to Moses , Deut. 13. Deut. 17. Levit. 17. are the authentique seals to confirm , whereunto we may annex that fact of our Saviour Christ himself , chastising the Jewish Pedlers , by vertue of his divine Royalty , for profanation of the Temple , as an exemplary proof beyond all exception . Having pickt out the pith of their Divinity in the former objection , there resteth one hard Argument more a break , wherein lies the marrow of their Logick , if the power , say they , in Ecclesiastical matters be proper to the supream magistrate as a Magistrate , then it should belong to all magistrates , and consequently to the heathen : the definition of a magistrate being one in Christian and Heathen Princes ; but this would be both sinful and ridiculous to assert , ergo that cannot lawfully be maintained . Truly this is a witty sophisme , which deserves the Reply of an ingenious Respondent in the Philosophers School , salse profecto , sed falso quidem . I presume the same learning which qualified them to oppose others , may enable them to answer themselves in this point ; for if their consequence be good , Baals Priests had as much right to the service of the Temple , as the Levitical Clergy-men , neither can our Protestant ministers have a better Title to the dispensation of Christs ordinances , then the officers of the Romish Church do now claim . Therefore if they will honestly defend their own as we do the Kings authority in the Church , they must acknowledge their argument to be contrary to the principles of art , as their opinion is to the precepts of Religion ; for when a Restrictive Term is adjoyned to an equivocal subject ( as magistrate is ) To argue from an indefinite to a universall , is an illegal consequence , the reason is , because what is attributed by such a note of limitation , is not an absolute but a comparate propriety , which doth convenire subjecto mediante alio , as the power of the King in c●uses Eccl●siastical is not proper to him , simply secundum naturam , but Relatively as he is a true Christian Magistrate ; according to which univocation , if their Argument had been formed , the consequence would be logically true . But as we do appropriate this power onely to Kings truly Christian , So I must acquaint them that the Heathen subjects had such a Reverend respect to the authority of the supream magistrate in matters of their idolatrous Religion , that Aristotle , Polit. l. 3. could say 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 . The King is Lord and Ruler of things that pertain to the Gods. To conclude , I wish those men , who ( like the first matter have an indifferency to all forms , and are so unfixedly disposed ●n Religion , ●hat they can be content with the Sichemites , to ●e circumcised for their advantage , would ( not for wra●h but for conscience sake ) give a seasonable Testimony of their obedience by a willing conformity to the Kings power in Ecclesiastical causes , that the Church may be no longer grieved with the rapine of forreign wolves , or 〈◊〉 of 〈…〉 , but that sound doctrine may flourish within her gates , and true discipline be established in her borders , to which end the Lord send us a speedy Restauration of our ancient Government by the hands of Zerubbabel and Joshua , the King and the Bishop , that as we are baptized in one faith , so we may be subject to one Rule , & as we are of one body , we may be all of one mind , to worship God both in the purity and beauty of holinesse , and to preserve the unity of the spirit in the bond of peace . Amen . FINIS .