A discourse concerning the inventions of men in the worship of God by William Lord Bishop of Derry ... King, William, 1650-1729. 1694 Approx. 270 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 97 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2005-03 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A47436 Wing K528 ESTC R9667 11906607 ocm 11906607 50703 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A47436) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 50703) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 816:30) A discourse concerning the inventions of men in the worship of God by William Lord Bishop of Derry ... King, William, 1650-1729. [4], 188 p. Printed for the author, by Andrew Crook ..., Dublin : 1694. Reproduction of original in Cambridge University Library. Errata at end. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Church of England -- Liturgy. Public worship -- Early works to 1800. 2004-08 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2004-10 SPi Global Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2004-11 Emma (Leeson) Huber Sampled and proofread 2004-11 Emma (Leeson) Huber Text and markup reviewed and edited 2005-01 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion A DISCOURSE CONCERNING The Inventions of Men IN THE WORSHIP OF GOD. By WILLIAM Lord Bishop of DERRY . Printed for the instruction of his Diocess DVBLIN : Printed for the Author , by Andrew Crook , Printer to Their Most Sacred Majesties . MDCXCIV . The Contents of the several Chapters and Sections . Introduction . COntaining a brief Description of the Inward and Outward Worship of God ; and Rules for Examining the ordinary parts of Outward Publick Worship . Chap. I. Of Praises . Sect. 1. What the Holy Scriptures prescribe concerning them . page 6. Sect. 2. The manner of Praising God publickly , which is prescribed and practised by our Church . page 15 Sect. 3. The Dissenters manner of praising God in publick . page 18 Chap. II. Of Prayer . Sect. 1. What the Holy Scriptures prescribe concerning Prayer . page 25 Sect. 2. The Rules and Practice of our Church . p. 41 Sect. 3. The practice of those who differ from us . p. 43 Chap. III. Of Hearing . Sect. 1. What the Holy Scriptures prescribe concerning it . page 68 Sect. 2. The practice of our Church , in Reading and Preaching the Word . page 77 Sect. 3. The practice of the Dissenters . page 81 Chap. IV. Of Bodily Worship , and Kneeling at the Communion . Sect. 1. What the Holy Scriptures prescribe concerning it . page 104 Sect. 2. The practice of our Church in Bodily Worship . page 114 Sect. 3. The practice of the Dissenters . page 117 Chap. V. Of the Lords Supper . Sect. 1. What the Holy Scriptures prescribe concerning the frequency of Celebrating it . page 145 Sect. 2. The practice of our Church , as to frequent Communions . page 155 Sect. 3. The practice of the Dissenters . page 159 Conclusion , To the Conforming Clergy of the Diocess of Derry . page 164 To the Dissenting Ministers in the same Diocess . p. 170 To the Conforming Laity thereof . page 179 To the Dissenting Laity thereof . page 181 A DISCOURSE CONCERNING The Inventions of Men IN The VVorship of GOD , The Introduction . OUR Blessed Saviour has Taught us that there are some Ways of Worshiping God , which have so great a Mixture of Human Invention in them , that they are Vain and Unacceptable to Him , Mark VII . 7 . In vain , saith He , do they Worship Me , teaching for Doctrines the Commandments of Men. This obligeth every Man who has a Concern for his Soul , to examine carefully the Worship he offers to God , whether it be such as God has Instituted ; lest his Service should be Rejected with that Censure in the Prophet , Who has required this at your Hands ? But more especially it concerns the Pastors of the Church , who have the Direction of the Publick Worship of God , to be careful in Examining this Matter , that they may be able to satisfy their own Consciences , as well as the People 's Committed to their Charge , concerning the Purity of the Worship which they practice Themselves , and recommend to Others . II. It has pleased God in his Providence to make Me an Overseer over some part of his Flock in this Kingdom ; and I look upon it to be my Duty to use my Endeavours to Instruct Those that are committed to my Charge , in the Worship of God , according to the Rules He has prescribed ; and to warn such as I conceive to swerve from them , of their Mistakes . I hope it will be of Use and Satisfaction to those that joyn with Me in the Publick Worship of God , to find on Examination , That what they there practice , is agreeable to God's Institution : And as to those that think otherwise , I persuade my self that an Admonition in the Spirit of Meekness can give them no just Offence , but rather be of Use to them also , by obliging them to Examine and Revise their Ways , that they may correct their Judgments , if from what I offer , they shall see reason for it . III. In Order to help those concerned to make a true and impartial Judgment in these matters , I desire them to consider , 1 st , That it belongs only to God to give Rules how He will be Worshiped . This , I suppose , will be granted by all , since it seems to be a Truth , naturally implanted in the Minds of Men , and Universally acknowledged in all times . 2 dly , I take it for a Truth agreed to by the generality of Protestants , That the Holy Scriptures contain the Revelations of God's Will , concerning his Worship . 3 dly , From these two , we may reasonably infer , That it concerns us to keep as close as we can to those Directions which God has been pleas'd to afford us in his Word ; without adding to , omitting , or altering any thing that He has there laid down . For since God has vouchsafed us a certain Direction for his Worship in the Holy Scriptures , it is to be supposed that all ways of Worship are displeasing to Him , that are not expresly contained , or warranted by Examples of Holy Men mentioned therein . 4 thly , We must observe that the Worship of God is either Inward or Outward ; The Inward Worship of God consists in the inward Homage and Subjection of our Minds to Him. The Outward consists of such Acts and Duties as serve to express this inward Subjection of our Souls , or that promote , increase , or contribute towards it . Thus , for instance , Vocal Prayer is a part of Outward Worship , because it expresses the inward Dependance of our Souls on God : Thus reading the Word of God is a part of the same , because therein we acknowledge our Subjection to Him , and to his Laws , and use it as a means to promote and increase this Subjection : Thus Celebration of the Sacraments is a part of the same Worship , because in them we not only express our Dependance on God for his Grace , but likewise oblige and bind our selves to serve Him : And the same holds in all Outward Acts of Worship . 5 thly , We must remember , That 't is in these Outward Acts that we are more immediately concerned as Publick Worshipers ; for we cannot know the Inward Worship which Men pay to God in their Minds , but as it appears to us by these Outward Acts ; And generally when we speak of the Publick Worship of God , we mean this Outward ; and concerning it are the great Disputes and Differences among us ; all of us being agreed as to the inward , and of what sort that ought to be . IV. Having premised these few things , which I hope will be granted by all ; I shall proceed directly to my proposed Undertaking ; and shall with the greatest Fairness and Impartiallity I can , Examine and Compare the Worship of God , which is directed and warranted by Scripture , as well with that which is prescribed and practis'd by our Church , as with that which is practis'd by such as differ from us . V. Now if we consider the ordinary Service of God as prescribed and practic'd in Scripture , we shall find the main substantial parts of it to be these five : vizt . Praises . Prayers . Hearing . Bodily Worship . And , Celebration of the Holy Sacrament of the Body and Blood of Christ. The Method I shall take in Discoursing of each of these , shall be , First , To shew what the Holy Scriptures direct concerning them particularly . Secondly , I shall consider the Practice of our Church , with relation to those Directions and Examples . And , Thirdly , The Practice of Protestant-Dissenters . CHAP. I. Of Praises . Sect. 1. What the Holy Scriptures prescribe concerning them . I. FIrst then , as to the Praises of God. The Scriptures both of the Old and New Testaments require the use of the Psalms in offering up Praises to God. We find in the Old Testament ( 2 Chron. xxix . 30 . ) Hezekiah the King , and the Princes , commanded the Levites to sing praises to the Lord with the words of David , and of Asaph , and they sang with gladness . This Command of Hezekiah proceeded from God , and was approved by him : The same way of praising God continued in the Jewish Church till our Saviour's time : And after that , we have yet a more positive Command for the use of them by the Apostle . Ephes. v. 19 . Speaking to your selves in Psalms , and Hymns , and spiritual Songs . And Col. iii. 16 . Let the words of Christ dwell in you richly in all Wisdom , teaching and admonishing one another in Psalms , and Hymns , and spiritual Songs ; singing and making melody with grace in your hearts to the Lord. I think there is no room to doubt , but by the Psalms , &c. in these places , is meant the Book of Psalms , which the Holy Ghost has left for this purpose to the Church . II. Tho' the Scriptures recommend to us singing of Psalms , yet in some cases they allow us to say them ; I will not insist on those places of Scripture that seem to require us to do so ( such as Psal. cxviii . 2 . Let Israel now say that his mercy endureth for ever , let the House of Aaron now say , and let them that fear the Lord now say , &c. ) because these Expressions being Poetical , may be so interpreted as to mean singing , tho' there is no Necessity of restraining the general Command of Saying or Speaking the Praises of God to Singing only . We find in Scripture several Sacred Hymns , particularly of Hannah , the Blessed Virgin , Zacharias , and Simeon , and the Saints in Heaven , ( Rev. vii . 12 . & xi . 17 . ) which are said to have been Said by them respectively , and the circumstances in the Story do not make it probable that they were sung . From all which we may reasonably infer , That where People can sing , they are obliged to do it , in obedience to God's Command : But where through any defect of Nature or Art , they cannot Sing Decently , they may be dispensed with Saying . Only People ought not by this Indulgence to be encouraged to neglect singing altogether , or to think that God doth not require it of them , when by a little pains or industry they may attain to the Art of decently performing it in his Service . III. 'T is certain the Word of God recommendeth to us Psalms and Hymns in Prose , for our praising God. If we look into the Songs of the Blessed Virgin , of Zacharias , or Simeon , we shall find them all in Prose , and such are the Songs of the Blessed , which they are represented singing in the Revelations , particularly Chap. v. 9 . & Chap. xv . 3 . As to the Hebrew Psalms , 't is evident that they are Poetical , but the Poetry of them consists rather in the Style and manner of Expression , than in any certain Measures or Verses , which those that have searched most narrowly into them have yet been able to discover , so as to satisfy an indifferent Reader . But whatever Poetry there may be in them , we can not find by any of the antient Translations which were made use of by the Church in our Saviour , or his Apostles time , or in the Ages immediately following , that they or the first Christians did sing any thing in Verse ; but we are sure that they sung Hymns in Prose : So that we have no certain Scriptural Warrant for the Use of Verse or Meetre in the Praises of God. Perhaps some may fancy that Verse or Measure was not in use in those Countreys , and that therefore they sung their Songs in Prose ; but this is a Mistake ; Poetry and Verses were then in those places where the Psalms were translated , in great request ; and at the highest perfection , when the New Testament was penned ; and yet we have no Example therein of their Use in the Praises of God. And it is very manifest that this proceeded from Choice , not Necessity : For if the holy Ghost had thought Verse necessary for Divine Psalms , we may presume he would have inspired some of the holy Men in Scripture , when Extraordinary Gifts were so common , either to Translate the Psalms of the Old Testament into Verse , or else to Compose some of the other Hymns that are recorded in the New , after that way : But neither of these having been done , 't is at least a presumption that we may praise God as acceptably in Prose as in Verse . And there is one thing further to be considered , That the Prophets of the Heathen , who pretended to be inspired , generally wrote their Prophecies and their Hymns to their Gods , in Verse : We know not but this may be one Reason why the holy Ghost thought fit that such as were inspired by Him should decline that way of Recording their Prophecies or Praises . IV. As the Scriptures prescribe us the Use of Psalms in the praises of God , so they encourage us to offer those Praises by way of Responses , or Answering : For this we have the best Examples that can be desired , even the blessed Angels and glorified Saints : So Isa. vi . 3 . And one cried unto another , Holy , Holy , Holy is the Lord of Hosts . And the Church triumphant through the whole Revelation is ( I think ) constantly represented praising God after this manner . So Chap. vii . 9 . where The Multitude , that represent the People , cried out with a loud voice ( vers . 10. ) Salvation to our God , which sitteth upon the Throne , and to the Lamb. And then , The Angels and Elders , who represent the Clergy , perform their part , vers . 12. saying , Amen ; Blessing , and Glory , and Wisdom , and Thanksgiving , and Honour , and Power , and Might , be unto our God. They are represented the same way answering one another , Chap. xix . 1 . I heard a great voice of much People in Heaven , saying Alleluia ; this they repeat ( vers . 3. ) then the Twenty four Elders ( representing , as before , the Clergy ) answer ( vers . 4. ) Amen , Alleluia . Then ( vers . 5. ) a Voice came out of the Throne , saying , Praise our God. Upon which ( vers . 6. ) the People resume their part , and answer , Alleluia : for the Lord Omnipotent Reigns . I make no question but this is taken by Allusion from the manner of the Church's Praising God on Earth ; and there is nothing in it but what is agreeable to St. Paul's Command , of Teaching and Admonishing one another in Psalms , and Hymns , and Spiritual Songs ; which supposes every one to have share in them , either by turns , or by bearing a part . It is observable that the Psalms contain many excellent Instructions and Exhortations , as well as Praises and Prayers , and therefore St. Paul recommends them to Christians for their mutual Instruction and Admonition . It was common therefore for one to sing , and the rest to hearken for their Instruction and Edification , as appears 1 Cor. xiv . 31 . For ye may all prophesie one by one , that all may learn and be comforted : Prophesying here ( as we may find from the 26th verse of this Chapter ) includes Psalms , as well as Doctrines , Tongues , Revelations and Interpretations ; and the praising God one by one , or by turns , amounts to praising Him by way of Responses or Answering ; and tho' these Prophets were inspired , yet it is plain they acted in this according to the settled Order of the Church , Vers. 33. As in all the Churches of the Saints ; and these inspired Prophets thus praising God one by one , is an unquestionable Precedent that God approves this way in his Praises . This Way of praising God by Answering one another , is the most Antient we find in Scripture . For thus Miriam praised God , Exod. xv . 21 . And Miriam , answered them , Sing ye to the Lord , for He hath Triumphed gloriously , &c. And the last Song recorded in Scripture is of the same sort , Rev. xix . as is before mentioned . I reckon the songs with which the Women of Israel received Saul , 1 Sam. xviii . 7 . to be Religious , and there it is expresly said , That they answered one another : And Chap. xxi . 11 . Did they not sing one to another ? &c. But whether these songs were Religious or no , it is certain that the Frame and Composition of some Psalms are such , as plainly discover that they were designed to be sung in parts ; and as much is owned by the best Commentators : Such are the xxiv . and cxviii Psalms . It is to be observed that the Law of Moses neither prescribes Psalms in the praises of God , nor Singers , nor the way of Singing : These all therefore are parts of Natural Religion , and indeed antienter than the Law , as appears by Exod. xv . What therefore we find in the Old Testament concerning these , is either from the immediate Prescriptions and Revelations of God by his Prophets , or from the Dictates of Nature , and not any part of the Ceremonial Law. And 't is obvious that Natural Necessity will teach any considering Man this way of alternate singing or Answering in parts , for if the Songs be long , as some of the Psalms are , no one Mans Voice can hold out to the end . V. The Holy Scriptures recommend to us the use of Instruments in the praises of God ; the Psalmist frequently uses and recommends them , and the whole Book of Psalms is concluded with this advice , Psal. cl . 3 . Praise him with Timbrel , praise him with stringed Instruments and Organs , &c. Thus Religious persons were taught to praise God before the Law. Ex. xv . 20 . And Miriam the Prophetess the sister of Aaron , took a Timbrel in her hand , and all the Women went after with Timbrels , &c. And thus the Blessed in Heaven are represented praising God. Rev. v. 8 . and xiv . 2 . The Writers of the new Testament recommend to us the Psalms which were the Hymns of the Jewish Church , and command us to sing them , and 't is observable that the word we render Sing , Jam. v. 13 . originally implies singing with an Instrument . Now if they had not approved the Jewish way of singing them , which was with Instruments , they would not have used a word that imported it ; nay it is not to be doubted but they would have cautioned us against it ; but the use of Instruments ( as I have shewed before in the case of Miriam ) being no part of the Ceremonial Law , but antecedent to it , ought not to cease without some Command or Precept condemning it . VI. Lastly , The Scripture requires that we understand the praises we sing to God ; and this warrants our Translating them into the Vulgar Tongue : It is a Duty therefore incumbent on the Governours of the Church , to procure the Psalms to be Translated for the Use of the people under their Charge , and they may expect the Assistance of God's Spirit when they attempt it , in Obedience to his Command . But if through Human Frailty , any mistake , not contray to Faith , should creep in , this ought to be no Exception against the Use of the Translation , since there are such Mistakes both in the Syriac , Greek and Latin Translations , some of which are of great Antiquity , and were used by our Saviour himself , and his Apostles . These are the Directions the Scriptures give us for the performance of this first part of the Worship of God , which consists in praises , and the manner we find them offer'd to Him by his Saints . Sect. 2. The manner of Praising God Publickly , which is prescribed and practised by our Church . NOw as to the manner of offering Praises in our Church , it is to be considered , 1. That we are directed to praise , glorify and confess to God every day , in a certain number of Psalms of his own Appointment , out of the Old Testament ; and then in such Hymns as are recorded in the New : And to these there are added such other Hymns , Confessions of Faith and Thanksgivings , as will appear by and by to be agreeable to the general Directions of Scripture . But inasmuch as the Mystery of the holy Trinity is more explicitly revealed to us under the Gospel , than it was to those under the Law ; Therefore our Church has thought fit to require us with every Psalm and Hymn to intermix , Glory be to the Father , to the Son , and to the holy Ghost ; As it was in the beginning , is now , and ever shall be : To signify that we believe that the same God was worshiped by them as by us , the same God that is glorified in the Psalms , having been from the beginning Father , Son , and holy Ghost , as well as now : So that our ascribing this glory expresly to the Three Persons in whose Name we are Baptised , ought not to be taxed as any real Addition to the Psalms , it being only used as a necessary Expedient to turn the Jewish Psalms into Christian Hymns , and to fit them for the Use of the Church now , as they were before for the Use of the Synagogue ; which practice I presume can give cause of Exception to none but Socinians . 2. Our Church Orders these Psalms to be either Sung or Said , as the people are able to offer them ; not being willing to lay a greater restraint on them than the Scripture has done : In which ( as I have already shewed ) we have Examples for both these ways of praising God. 3. They are proposed to us in Prose , without any other alteration from the Original than what was necessary to make them intelligible in our Language . 4. The people are allowed to bear their part in them , and either to sing or say them by way of Answering : This is according to the Scripture Examples , but it is not imposed , except in very few Cases . 5. Our Church permitteth the Use of some grave Musical Instruments to regulate the Voices of those that sing , and to stir up their Affections , which are the Natural Effects of Musick , and seem more requisite in Northern Countreys , where generally peoples Voices are more harsh and untuneable than in other places ; but this is not imposed in any Congregation , nor doth any Rule of our Church require it , and therefore it is at the peoples Choice , whether they will use the help of these Instruments or no. 6. This then is the care our Church has taken , for the publick performance of the praises of God , and if we bring grace in our hearts , and an inward sense of the Majesty of God , and of his Mercies towards us , when we come to joyn in them , which is our part and duty to do , who can say that God's praises thus celebrated , are not according to his Commands , and acceptable to Him ? I think it sufficiently plain , that they are agreeable to the holy Scriptures , which ought to be our Rule for this , and all other parts of God's Worship . I think no more necessary therefore on this Head , but with all earnestness , to beseech you who are of our Communion to consider how great and important a part these praises are of the Worship of God , and to apply your selves with all diligence and holy zeal to the performance of it ; for we never come nearer the Imployment of the Blessed , then when our Hearts and Mouths are filled with the praises of our God. Sect. 3. The Dissenters manner of Praising God in Publick . ANd now as to you my Friends and Brethren , who dissent from this Worship of ours , give me leave with all calmness to examine how you perform this great work of Praising God ; and I desire you to compare your own practice in your publick Assemblies , with what you find in your Bibles concerning this Duty . I. Your Directory determines it to be the duty of Christians to praise God publickly , by singing of Psalms together in the Congregation , and that in singing Psalms the voice is to be tuneable and gravely ordered , and lastly , that it is convenient that the Minister , or some other fit person appointed by him and the other ruling Officers , do read the Psalm , line by line , before the singing thereof ; and your common practice is to sing two or three verses of a Psalm in Meetre , the Minister , or Clerk , first reading each line , and the people singing it after . II. Before I proceed to make any observations on these Rules and Practice , to prevent mistakes , I desire you to observe , 1. That I do not condemn the singing of Psalms in Meetre as unlawful . 2. That I take it for granted that the Apostles and Primitive Christians did praise God in Prose , and that Meetre and Rhyme are , for ought appears , purely of Human Invention . 3. We must consider that if we take the Psalms ( as We use them ) in Prose , there is not a more Exalted piece of Poetry in the World , nor any thing better fitted to raise in serious and well disposed people the most devout Affections . Whereas , if we take them as they are commonly used in Rhime , the Force , the Vigour , the Loftiness which are so Extraordinary in the Prose Translation , are almost intirely lost in the Verse , and tho' several have attempted to Translate them into English Verse , yet I cannot find that any one has done Justice to the Majesty of the Expressions , and hardly to the Sense of them . III. Having premised these things , I intreat you to consider impartially with me how far this your practice agrees with the Scripture Rule . 1. Then the Scriptures command us to praise God in Psalms , and undoubtedly the first Christians used whole Psalms at a time . Sometimes they joyned together in singing them , as our Saviour and his Disciples did , Matt. xxvi . 30 . Sometimes one only sung , and the rest attended for their Edification , as appears from 1 Cor. xiv . 26 . But the aforesaid method of singing the Meetre Psalms takes up so much time , that it is impossible to praise God in whole Psalms after that manner . But if we use the Psalms in Prose , according to the Order of our Church , the Experience of Good Men doth testify that we may easily pass through them in a month , with seriousness and attention , whether we sing or read them . And to well disposed minds no part of God's Service is more agreeable or edifying : whereas some years would not serve to that purpose , if we should use the new invented way of singing a few verses . And I question whether all of them were ever yet sung through in one Meeting place , perhaps not in all the Meetings of the Kingdom , and yet it must be confessed that every one of them was left to the Church by the Holy Ghost for that use , and is profitable , when thus used , for Doctrine , Reproof , Correction , Instruction and Comfort . Which plainly proves that the singing the Psalms in Meetre , is not the Scripture Way of Using them . 2. Let me mind you , that in the time of the late Usurpation , Dr. Manton , a Man of considerable Reputation among the Dissenters , observes in his Comment on the Epistle of St. James , Chap. v. vers . 13 , That several scrupled singing Psalms at all ; others objected against singing them in verse ; this he calleth a va●n cavil , yet proposeth , if the scruple continueth , that such may Sing the Reading Psalms , as hath been used in Cathedrals , and vouches St. Austin and Athanasius for it ; which is a plain confession from this considerable Person , that this way of singing is less lyable to exception , then yours . 3. I know it is alledged that we ought to have the Psalms in Verse for singing , as well as we ought to have them in Prose for Reading . But I have shewed already that Christ and his Disciples sung their Hymns in prose ; and I desire you to consider whether it be necessary to vary from these Precedents . We have a Command to Translate them ( which supposes into prose , because the Original is so ) but none to turn them into Meetre , which necessarily requires Paraphrasing , Changing the order of the Sentences , sometimes adding and leaving out words ; And on that account seems to give Human Wit too great a Liberty of treating the Word of God as Men please : At least , we must acknowledge that the Psalms so ordered partake of Human Frailty , and are hardly equal to the best meer Human Composures . When therefore we use such Psalms we ought to use them as Human Composures only , and not as God's Word : And thus they are used by our people in our Assemblies , not as any main substantial part of the Worship of God , but rather as a voluntary entertainment of Devotion , and a refreshment to the people between the parts of the Service ; much less are they allowed by us to justle out the Psalms and Hymns appointed by God. 4. As to the manner of singing the Psalms in Meetre , at present in use , both with you and us in some places , that is , the Minister or Clerks reading a line , and the people singing it after , it is a great interruption to the Musick , and to the understanding of the Psalm , by breaking the sense of it , and in that respect very inconvenient , and is likewise a late invention of our own , never used by any Foreign Church , either Popish or Reformed , for ought I can find , to this day ; and has been taken up to supply the negligence and laziness of people , who will not now , as formerly , be at pains to get Psalms by heart , or so much as procure Books , or learn to read them . 5. Notwithstanding your Directory requires the voice in singing Psalms to be tuneable and gravely ordered , yet you have not only refused the Use of Instruments , ( which are a natural means to help the Voice , and make it tuneable , and are used by most of the Reformed Churches in Europe , but have also determined it to be Unlawful . I would intreat you to consider , that though perhaps it may not be so proper to press the Use of Instruments in the service of God , in these parts , where so many , for want of being used to them , have entertained prejudices against them , and some are uncapable of being affected by them , yet the making them Unlawful , is against Nature and Scripture , and is on that account a dangerous Superstition , and Encroachment on Christian Liberty . 6. The same Superstition and Encroachment it is , not only to forbear to praise God in singing or saying Psalms and Hymns by way of Responses or Answering ( of which I have given such Noble Precedents out of Scripture ) but even to determine it to be Unlawful . Lastly , I would entreat you to consider , That forasmuch as appears , you have altogether laid aside the Psalms in Prose , and the other Scripture Hymns , that are of God's immediate Appointment , and for the Use of which we have the Example of our Saviour and his Saints , insomuch that they are no where used by you in the Praises of God ; but in their stead you have substituted , as is before observed , a few Verses of a Psalm of Human Composure , without Scripture-Example or Precedent , and sing them in a way that has nothing of Antient Practise , much less Scripture , for it , but is purely and immediately an Invention of Men. IV. The Case then between our Church and you , in this point , I think impartially stands thus : Our Church praises God every day with five or six Psalms , besides other Hymns , of His Own Appointment , and in His own Words and Method , and yet is deserted and condemned by you in this very point , as Teaching for Doctrines the Commandments of Men ; whereas you , who only praise Him in a piece of a Psalm of a few Verses , and in a Method of your own finding out , perswade your selves that you keep the Ordinances of God pure and unmixed from Human Invention . This is a thing seriously to be considered by you ; for as it is easie to think what all unprejudiced Men will judge of it now , so we may conclude what God will judge it at the last day . If you in earnest lay these things to heart , and reflect on them , I perswade my self that they will at least prevail with you to be modest in your Censures of us your Brethren ; and prevent your Judging , much less Condemning us , or our manner of praising God , as Unacceptable to Him. CHAP. II. Of Prayer . Sect. 1. What the Holy Scriptures prescribe concerning it . I. LEt us now proceed to the Second main part of the Worship of God , in the Publick Meetings of Christians , which I observed was Prayer , or Supplication . And if we consider what Rules , Directions , and Examples the Scriptures afford us for the performance of this Duty , we shall find , That they direct us to offer up our Prayers in a set and prepared Form of Words . That we may more clearly judge of this matter , it will be fit to consider the several parts of Prayer distinctly by themselves ; such as Confession , Supplication , Intercession , &c. 1. Confession of our own Unworthiness , and of God's Mercy , to aggravate it , is commonly looked on as the first part of Prayer , and proper to introduce our Supplications . Now in searching the Scriptures we shall find express Command to use a set Form of Words in both these sorts of Confession . So Deuteron . xxvi . 3 . Thou shalt go unto the Priest that shall be in those days , and say unto him , I profess this day unto the Lord thy God , that I am come unto the Countrey which the Lord sware unto our fore-Fathers to give us . And then the Offerer was to make his Confession , ( vers . 5 ) And thou shalt speak and say before the Lord thy God , A Syrian ready to perish was my Father , &c. Here we have a Form of Confession of the person's Vnworthiness , and of God's Goodness and Mercy , together with a profession of Obedience and dependance on Him , prescribed by God Himself in set & prepared words . The same appears from Solomon's prescribing a Form of Confession for the penitent Israelites , 1 Kings viii . 47 . which words we find accordingly applied in Psal. cvi . 6 . and made part of a larger Form of Confession , to be used in their Captivity ( as Solomon designed them ) which appears from the 47th Verse of the same Psalm ( taken from the Form prescribed by David , 1 Chro. xvi . 35 ) And Daniel , in his Form of Confession in Captivity , ( Chap. ix . vers . 5. ) uses the same Form of Words : From whence it appears that they were not left Arbitrarily to Choice , or Discretion , tho' other Words might be joyned with them , when there was occasion to enlarge or vary the Form. Many of the Psalms are Forms of Confession , and were used and daily Repeated by the Jewish Church : Psal. li. was the Form of Confession David prepared and us'd , for his Murther and Adultery , and he not only used it himself , but directed it to the Master of his Choire , to be used in the Publick Service , as appears from the Title of it . Psal. lxxviii . is a general Confession for the whole people , setting forth at large the Mercies of God to them , and their Ingratitude , Disobedience and Rebellion ; and this not as a Pattern , but as a set and prepared Form , to be used in their publick Service : All which shew us that Addresses to God in such Forms , are of Divine Institution , and are a warrant to us that he approves that our Confession should be made to him in that manner . 2. The second part of Prayer is Supplication for good things ; and in this Case we have likewise the Commandment of God for a Form of Words , Deut. xxvi . 13 , 15. Then thou shalt say before the Lord thy God , Look down from thy holy Habitation , from Heaven , and bless thy people Israel , and the Land which thou hast given us , as thou swarest unto our Fathers , &c. So Hos. xiv . 2 . Take with you words , and turn to the Lord your God , and say unto Him , Take away all Iniquity , &c. Moses in the Wilderness used a set Form of Words to this purpose , and recommended it to be used by the Church of God for ever , as is manifest from Psal. xc . which has this Title , A Prayer of Moses the Man of God. When such a person , by the Inspiration of the holy Ghost , used , and left to be used by us in our Supplications , such a set and prepared Form of Words , we ought not to doubt but that manner of Address is acceptable to God. 3. The third part of Prayer is Intercession in the behalf of others : Now Blessing is an eminent sort of Intercession , and for the use of a set Form of Words in this , we have likewise the Command of God , Numb . vi . 23 . On this wise ye shall bless the Children of Israel , saying unto them , The Lord bless thee and keep thee , &c. Here we have not onely a Blessing , but an earnest Intercession with God for his people , and the Form and Words prescribed by Himself , which were not to be used by mean ignorant people , ( who are only now supposed by some to need the help of Forms ) but by Aaron and his Sons the Chief Priests : From which we may be assured , That God approves that manner of Address in our Blessings and Intercessions for one another , not onely from mean people , but from the greatest . 4. The fourth part of Prayer consisteth in Petitions for averting evil , commonly called Deprecation ; and for this purpose , we have several Forms prescribed by God , Joel i. 14 . Gather the Elders and all the Inhabitants of the Land into the House of the Lord your God , and say unto the Lord , Alas , for the day , the day of the Lord is at hand , &c. We have God's Commandment for another Form , Joel ii . 17 . Let the Priests , the Ministers of the Lord , weep between the Porch and the Altar , and let them say , Spare thy people , O Lord , and give not thine heritage to reproach , &c. From whence it clearly follows , that God approves the use of a Form in this part of Prayer , tho' commonly the most earnest and importunate , and such as seems least to admit of being bounded by a Form , so that we have the Approbation and Commandment of God for the use of a set Form of Words , in all the parts of Prayer . II. And accordingly we find Holy Men of God , tho' full of Wisdom and of his Spirit , using the same set Form of Prayer always on the same occasion . Thus the Scriptures inform us concerning Moses , Num. x. 35 . When the Ark set forward , Moses said , Rise up , Lord , and let thine Enemies be scattered , and let them that hate thee flee before thee . And when it rested , he said , Return , O Lord , unto the many Thousands of Israel . From whence it appears that God approves the use of one set constant Form of Words , in our Prayers , as long as the occasion of repeating them is the same ; for I presume none will suspect it was for want of Words , or of the Spirit of Prayer , that Moses confined himself to this Form. I shall add further , that the whole Book of Psalms is a Collection of Prayers of all sorts : And there are few of them but what are most Excellent Forms of Prayer , expressed in such pathetick , significant and moving words , that we have great reason to thank God for furnishing us with them , and which we can never hope to equal by any of our own invention , such are the 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 9 , 10 , 12 , &c. On this account they were used by the Jews as the constant Service and Liturgy performed in their Temple , as we may gather from what I formerly quoted , 2 Chron. xxix , 30. III. But perhaps some may think these Commands and Examples of set Forms of Prayer not to be a sufficient Warrant to Christians , because they are taken out of the Old Testament , before the Spirit was poured out in so plentiful a measure , as under the Gospel . I shall therefore proceed to examine the Commands and Examples of the New Testament , and here , 1. I think it is certain that our Saviour and his Apostles prayed by a Form , for they joyned in the Worship of the Temple and Synagogues , which consisted in Psalms , as I have already shewed , and in some certain Forms of Prayers added to them , and constantly used in their daily Service , as we learn from those that give an Account of the Jewish Worship at that * time . Now our Saviour and his Apostles being frequently present at their Service , both in the Temple and Synagogues , 't is manifest they approved the manner of Addressing themselves to God in a set Form of Words . 2. But our Saviour has put this matter out of all dispute with impartial Men , by prescribing a Form to his Disciples , when they desired him to teach them to pray as John taught his Disciples . For we find his way of Teaching them was not by directing them to wait for the impulses of the Spirit , and immediate Inspiration from God of what they were to offer up to him ; We do not find him saying , When ye pray , speak what shall then come into your minds , or what shall be given you in that hour , without taking thought about what they should say ; as He did in another case , that is , when they should be brought before Governours and Kings for his sake , Mat. x. 19 . But in addressing themselves to God , he prescribed them a Form of Words , and Commanded them to use it , Luke xi . 2 . And he said unto them When ye pray , say , Our Father which art in Heaven , &c. Here is an express Command of Christ to his Disciples to use these Words when they pray , Our Father , &c. A Command for the use of a Form , so plain , that it is impossible to express it in clearer terms . 'T is not to be doubted but Religious Persons among the Jews offer'd up constantly prayers to God. We see it in David , Psal. lv . 17 . and in Daniel , Chap. vi . 10 . And no doubt the Disciples of our Saviour were not wanting in this Duty , nor in skill to perform it , since we find that other devout Persons of their time had their hours of Prayer , as we see in Acts iii. 1 . Therefore what they desired of our Saviour , was not to teach them absolutely , or in general , to pray , but to teach them to pray as John also taught his Disciples ; that is , to give them a Form of Prayer proper to His Institution , as they saw the Disciples of Moses and John had proper to theirs : Upon which our Saviour gave them the Lord's-Prayer , as a summary of the main points of his Doctrine , and as a constant badge of their being his Disciples ; As if he should have said , When ever you offer up to God your usual Prayers , which Religious Custom has taught you , as Jews and Disciples of Moses , or of John , whether in Secret or Publick , add this always to your other prayers , for a continual Remembrance to you of those Duties , Priviledges and Qualifications which belong to you as My Disciples , and as a means of obtaining Grace from your Heavenly Father , to enable you to persevere in them . The Lords-Prayer is therefore a badge of Our Profession imposed by Christ himself , and to be used by Us , as we would be accounted His Disciples . Neither will saying the Substance of it in other Words of our own Invention , answer the intent of this Command : Since 1. We are sure the Substance of the Prayer is put by Christ in the most apposite and comprehensive Words that are possible , and therefore wholly to lay them aside for others , is plainly to decline the choice of Words that Christ has made for us , and substitute less apposite of our own , to express those Petitions in . 2. The more particularly any thing is Commanded in the Worship of God , we ought to be the more carefull to observe it , and may be the more confident , that God is pleased with our performance of it : since therefore we are particularly Commanded , when we pray , to say , Our Father , &c. whatever other prayers we offer to God , this ought not to be omitted . 3. In general we are Commanded to offer up our desires to God , and in particular to offer this Prayer . These Commands agree very well together , and therefore the one ought not to justle out the other : To lay aside the Prayer particularly commanded by Christ , for others of our own composing , in pusuance of the general Command , is too apparently to prefer our own Invention to God's Command . 4. When we take the liberty to word our own Prayers , we may forget some things , we may mix our own frailties and weakness in our Petitions ; and this too often appears both in the matter and wording of them : The way therefore to supply these defects , and to obtain pardon for our Infirmities , is to use our Lords perfect Prayer , not only as a Pattern for prayer , as some would have it , but likewise as a Form necessary to be used , to correct what may be amiss , or defective , in our own prayers . 5. They who lay aside the words of the Lord's Prayer , are in danger to lay aside some of the substance of it also ; particularly the substance of that Petition , Forgive us our Trespasses as we forgive them that trespass against us : For many who lay aside the Lord's Prayer , do neither in terms nor substance offer this Petition to God ; nay , are so far from making this the Condition of their pardon , as Christ has taught us , that they publickly dispute against the Form for this very reason : Tho' Christ , who fore-saw the Objection which our Corruptions would be apt to make , has Answered it , and bound it upon us indispensibly as our Duty , to ask Forgiveness on these and no other terms , Matth. vi . 15 . And indeed if such a Sentence had been prescribed by our Lord to be only repeated by Christians once or oftner every day , it would have seemed but what was necessary to mind them of that peculiar and indispensible Duty of their profession . We see the Wisdom of the Ancients thought fit to reduce their Doctrine or Instructions into Proverbs , or short Sentences to be got by heart , and kept continually in memory , as of great influence for guiding Mens Lives and Actions ; and such Sentences must be of much greater influence , when repeated in the presence of God , as these in our Lord's Prayer are required to be . Lastly , This Prayer being given us as a Badge of our Profession , a Summary of our Duty as Christians , and a Form of Sound Words , it is no more lawful to alter it , than to lay it aside ; and it would be the same presumption and hazard to substitute other words instead of Christs , in this Prayer , which we are oblig'd always to use when we pray , as to change the words of our Creed ; or as it would be in a Battel to change the Word given by a General , or any part of it , and to retain onely the signification of it . From all which 't is manifest that God has required Forms of Prayer to be used by us , both in the Old and New Testament . As to the difference we find in the Lord's Prayer as delivered by St. Matthew and St. Luke , 't is to be observed that our Saviour spake in the Syriac or vulgar Hebrew , and the Evangelists writ their Gospels in Greek : Now in the Syriack , one and the same word expresses both those different words which the Evangelists use in the same Petition , as Debts and Trespasses , &c. So that it is no real , but a seeming difference between them ; all the different Words being the same in the Original Language in which our Saviour spake . IV. As we have the Command of God , and the Example of his Saints , for offering up our Prayers to Him , in a set and prepared Form of Words , so we have the like Example for joyning Voices , upon occasion , in offering these Words . Generally it is sufficient that the People joyn in their hearts with the words of publick Prayers , yet the Scriptures warrant also , on some Occasions , their joyning their Voices . 1. Thus we find the people of Israel addressing themselves to God , Judges xxi . 2 . And the people came to the House of God , and abode there till even before God , and lift up their Voices , and wept sore , and said , O Lord God of Israel , why is this come to pass in Israel ? &c. 2. In Hymns and Psalms ( which are also Prayers in great part , as I noted before ) the people are generally allowed by all ( as being fully warranted by Scripture ) to joyn their Voices . So Moses and the Children of Israel sung unto the Lord , Exod. xv . 1 . 3. In the New Testament we have an Eminent Example of this practise , Acts iv . 24 . where the Apostles and their Disciples lift up their Voice to God with one accord , and said , Lord thou art God , &c. If this prayer was immediately inspired , as it seems it was , then the whole Assembly was inspired together , not only to think the same Thing , but likewise to utter the same Words ; and the Spirit of God by it has attested the fitness and decency of a whole Congregation's pronouncing the same prayer together . If it had not been convenient that this should be some times practised in our Christian Assemblies , God would not have given us this Example . If the people were always to joyn in their hearts only with our publick prayers , it would have been so here , for the Spirit of God wou'd not have led them to do an indecent thing , or a thing unfit for God's Worship . 4. St. Paul and Silas joyned also their Voices in their prayers , as we may see from Acts xvi . 25 . And at midnight Paul and Silas prayed , and sung praises unto God , and the prisoners heard them : I know it may be alledged , That they sung their prayers which they offered up to God on this Occasion , and on that account joyned their Voices ; I confess the Original favours this Inference ; but if it be allowed that the Apostles sung their prayers together , it must be allowed that they might likewise say them together : For we find the Blessed in Heaven offering not only their praises together , but their prayers also ; so Rev. vi . 10 . They cried with a loud voice , saying , How long , O Lord , Holy and True , dost thou not Judge and Avenge our Blood , &c. From all which it is manifest , that we are warranted by the Examples of God's people , both in the Old and New Testament , to joyn our Voices , as well as our Hearts , in some of our publick Supplications to God ; and that this practice is no New Invention of Men. V. If we consult the Scripture , we shall find that it is the Priest's part to make publick Intercession for the People , but yet so , that the People ought to bear a part by themselves , and answer in the Service , which we commonly call Responses . 1. They are commanded to do it , Psal. cvi . 48 . where after the Prayers and Praises of which the Psalm consists , are ended , it is added , Let all the people say , Amen , praise the Lord ; and accordingly we find 1 Chr. xvi . 36 . that the People said Amen , and praised the Lord. And this is more signally observable in that Solemn Service at the Dedication of Solomon's Temple , where we find first the Priests and Levites praising God , 2 Chron. v. 13 . And saying , For he is good , for his mercy endureth for ever , the usual Form of Praising so often repeated in the Psalms , particularly in the cxxxvi . which was probably used at that time . Then Solomon , who built the Temple , performed another part of the Service , Chap. vi . 3 . He blessed , First the People ; Secondly , He blessed and thanked God for his Mercy . And Lastly , offer'd that Divine Prayer of Dedication , which we find in that Chapter ; Then follow the burnt Offerings and Sacrifices , which were peculiarly the Priest's share of the Service , Chap. vii . And God gives his Approbation of their Praises , Prayers & Offerings , by sending down Fire from Heaven to consume their Sacrifices : And then last of all follows the people's part which they perform , Chap. vii . 3 . They bowed themselves with their faces to the ground upon the pavement , and worshipped and praised the Lord , saying , He is good , for his Mercy endureth for ever . This Service was Ordered by the Spirit of God , and plainly shews us that He approved of the people's having a share or part peculiar to themselves in his Worship . 2. If it be said that this was the way of Worshiping God under the Law , which is now Abolished and Unlawful , as well as the other Levitical Ceremonies : The Apostles have answer'd this , by continuing this practice in the Christian Church ; and by admitting the people to bear a part in the publick Service , and to answer to the prayers , have assured us that this is no Legal Abolished Ceremony . This is manifest from 1 Cor. xiv . 16 . Else when thou shalt bless with the Spirit , how shall he that occupieth the room of the unlearned say Amen at thy giving of thanks ? which shews that even the unlearned had a part assigned them in the Christian Assemblies . It may be added to this ( what I observed before , Chap. 1. Sect. 1. N. 4. ) of the Responses in praising God , and of the Worship described in the Revelations , where the Angels and Elders representing the Clergy , and the Multitude representing the people , bear each of them their distinct parts ; in allusion to what was done in the Christian Assemblies . And this is a clear proof , that the people bare a part , and answered to the blessings and prayers of him that Officiated , ever since the Christian Worship was Established . Sect. 2. The Rules and Practice of Our Church concerning Prayer . HAving thus seen the Directions and Examples which the Scriptures afford us for the publick performance of our prayers to God , let us now consider the Worship of our Church , and compare it with Them ; both as to the Words and Matter of Our Prayers . And to the comfort of us , who are of this Communion , it will clearly appear , 1. That there is not one thing we ask of God in them , which he has not particularly directed us to ask , or any thing for which we ought to pray , that is omited . This advantage we have towards the proof of this point , that our prayers are fixed and stated , and may be examined by all that have a mind to be satisfy'd in them . An Advantage we gain by putting them into a set and prepared Form of Words , according to the Commands of God , and the Examples of holy Men ; whereas 't is impossible for such as use only extempore prayer , thus to justify their Service , because their prayers are altogether uncertain , and depend on the present thoughts of the Speaker . 2. Our Church requires the people to join their voices with the Minister in some of the prayers , in which they are more particularly concerned , and which seem of the most general and greatest moment . Such are the general confessions of sin , and the Lord's Prayer . 3. Our Church has assigned for the people some short Answers or Responses to our prayers , whereby they may be stirred up to attention , and signify their concurrence with the Minister . Thus to every prayer and blessing they are obliged to answer Amen , as we find the people did in the Church of Corinth ; and to join Unanimously in some other short Ejaculations to implore God's Mercy , or beseech him to hear us . In all which I have already shewed we have the warrant of Scripture ; and it is plain to any one that will be at the pains to consider our Service , that we have taken the Rules thereof from Scripture , and have not invented a Service out of our own Heads ; and then ( as is too often the Custom of Innovators ) endeavoured to make the Scripture comply with it . The first Reformers of Our Church would never have retain'd and prepared Forms of Prayers , had they not found such in Scripture : they would never have required the people to join their voices in some prayers , and answer to others , if the Examples of Scripture had not led them to it . They professed , and their design was to make the Word of God their Rule ; and we see how exactly they conformed to it in these particulars . I wish I could say as much for all other ways of Worship among Protestants . Sect. 3. The Practice of those who differ from Vs. I. ANd here I must intreat you of my Diocess , who Dissent from Our Worship , seriously to consider with me , what it is which you have substituted in the place of these things which you have intirely laid aside , tho' so expresly directed and warranted by Scripture ; and examine whether your way have a solid Foundation in God's Word . I shall endeavour to represent it with all fairness and impartiality , and leave you to judge as God shall direct you , and as you will answer it at the last day . And here I find that some of your Writers are of Opinion , That the Spirit of prayer is given to all the Children of God in some measure , for enabling their Hearts to conceive , and their Tongues to express convenient desires to God ▪ and that therefore Forms of Prayer are of no necessary use , either in Publick or Private ; on the contrary , that they stint the Spirit , and hinder Men from stirring up or using the gift that God has given them . 2. Others of you go further , and affirm that all Forms of Prayer are unlawful to Christians , and that therefore it is a sin to join in a Worship where they are used , or to be present at it . 3. That the Minister is the mouth of the Congregation , and that he only is to speak publickly to God in the behalf of the people , and that they are not to join their Voices , but their Hearts only with him . Upon these principles you forsake our Worship , and many of you think it is a sin to be so much as present at our Religious Assemblies : It is of great importance therefore that you should understand what the Scriptures determine in this matter ; for if our Worship ( which you thus forsake ) be plainly enjoined by Scripture ( as I think I have made it sufficiently appear ; ) and these principles of Your Worship , and Your Practice pursuant to them , have no Foundation in Scripture ; I cannot see how You can answer your forsaking Our Assemblies , to God and your own Consciences . Let us then consider each of these Principles apart . II. And first , for that position of your Directory , That the Spirit of Prayer is given to all the Children of God in some measure , for enabling their Hearts to conceive , and their Tongues to express , convenient Desires to God ; I intreat you to consider what Promise or Foundation it has in Scripture . I profess to you seriously , That upon the strictest Enquiry I could make , I never could find any such Promise made to all the Children of God , in the Old or New Testaments ; neither did I ever meet any Dissenter that was able to shew any such , Exclusive of the Use of Forms . If then there be none such , as we may be well assured there is not , was it not too much presumption in the Compilers of your Directory , to obtrude this Doctrine on the World , or perswade people to depend on it , and neglect the help of Forms , which the Scripture prescribes , and recommends to us ? Nay , as there is no Promise for such extraordinary Assistance to all the Children of God to conceive prayer , so neither is there any Command in Scripture , requiring us to worship or pray to God in a conceiv'd extemporary or unpremeditated prayer ; or so much as an Example in a settled ordinary Congregation where it was practised . If then you can shew none of these in the holy Scriptures , neither Promise nor Command , 't is a plain case , that this Doctrine is a meer Invention of Men , and the Worship built on it a Vanity , in the sence of our Saviour , Mark vii . 7 . If my design were only to confute an Adversary , what I have already said were sufficient ; but this Spirit of Prayer is a point of such Consequence , that I hope it will be both grateful and instructive to the Readers of all sorts , to explain it to them , and set it in as clear a light as I can ; which I shall do under the following Heads . III. 1. First therefore I doubt not but it will be granted , That whoever prayeth to God with Faith , Sincerity , Fervency , Love , Humility , Conformity to God's will , Vnderstanding , and Decency of Expression , prays Acceptably to Him , and is endowed with the Spirit of Prayer ; and whoever prays without these , does want it . 2. I suppose no man of himself can attain these Graces that are requisite to make our prayers Acceptable , and that therefore we must have the Assistance of Gods Spirit to beget them in us . 3. I suppose that it is possible for a man to acquire , by natural means , an ability to express himself decently in prayer , tho' he cannot so acquire Faith , or any other inward Grace ; so that Decency of Expression is the lowest part of the Gift of Prayer , and not alwaies a part of it . 4. I say that one praying by a Form may have all these Qualifications , and therefore his prayer may be acceptable to God , and proceed from his Spirit . This may be proved to the Dissenters , 1. From the Assembly's Larger Catechism , which acknowledges it : For when the Question is put , How is the Lord's Prayer to be used ? The Answer is , The Lord's Prayer is not only for Direction , as a pattern according to which we are to make other prayers , but may be also used as a prayer , so that it be done with Vnderstanding , Faith , Reverence , and other Graces , necessary to the right performance of the Duty of prayer . 2. Many of the Psalms are ( as I observed before ) Forms of Prayer , and the Dissenters make no scruple to turn these Forms of Prayers into Meetre , and then sing them Line by Line after the Minister . As for Example : The first Verse of the fifth Psalm , runs thus , in the Translation they use : Give ear unto my words , O Lord , My meditations weigh ; Hear my loud cry , my King , my God ; For I to theé will pray . This is as much a Form of Prayer , as any in the Litany , and by their using it as they do , they plainly practise praying by a Form ; And do further also allow that prayers , as well as praises , may be offered to God with singing , and that they may repeat their Forms of prayer after the Minister . With what reason then can it be said against us , That a Form of Prayer sung in Verse , and after the Minister's Reading it , is Commendable ; but the same said or sung in Prose , is Unlawful ? 5. Extemporary conceived prayers may want these spiritual qualifications of prayer , as I believe will not be denied by those that contend most for them , and they often are manifestly deficient ; being sometimes performed without Reverence or Decency of Expression , and by some even without Understanding ; and where these qualifications are found , others may be wanting . The Scriptures observe , That a man may make long prayers , and yet have a mind dispos'd to devour Widows Houses . He may want Faith , Humility , Fervency , and Affiance in God , and yet be able to pray without a Form : And therefore such prayers are not always Acceptable to God. 6. Therefore when God promises the Spirit of Grace and of Supplications to his people , Zach. xii . 10 . this Promise doth not extend to enable all men who are God's Children , to conceive with their Hearts , and express with their Mouths , convenient Desires , without a Form : for as I shewed before , every one to whom God gives a Heart and Disposition to pray , has the Spirit of Prayer , and he who from this principle offers up his desires to God in a Form , prays Acceptably ; and he that offers them without that principle , tho' he do it in unpremeditated and extemporary words , is rejected , and therefore the Spirit of prayer is the grace , the heart , the disposition and ability to pray , and whether it be with , or without a Form , such a Man's prayers are acceptable to God ; and 't is greatly superstitious to think or teach otherwise . If God give us a heart to pray , and by his providence hath provided us a Form to express our Desires in , or enables us to make one , 't is sufficient , and we ought to be thankful . 7. In confirmation of this Account of the Spirit of Prayer , we may further observe , 1. That no Worship is Acceptable to God , that is not offer'd to Him in Spirit and Truth , John iv . 24 . and therefore the Scripture recommends to us prayers in and by the Spirit ; but that praying with the Spirit , doth not signifie extemporary unpremeditated prayers , or exclude Forms , will appear from 1 Cor. xiv . 15 . I will pray with the Spirit , I will pray with the Vnderstanding , I will sing with the Spirit , I will sing with the Vnderstanding also : Here we find singing with the Spirit , as well as praying with it ; and whoever sings otherwise , doth not worship God as he ought ; but tho' we are obliged to sing with the Spirit , yet we must and ought to sing in the Congregation , with a set Form of Words , and therefore for the same reason , tho' we pray with the Spirit , we may pray by a set and prepared Form of Words : The most spiritual Songs consist of a set Form of imposed Words , and so may the most spiritual Prayers . Praying therefore with the Spirit in this place , is so far from meaning , or being an Argument for the Use of extemporary unpremeditated prayers , that it is rather an Argument against them : For either we are obliged by it to sing to God in extemporary Hymns , or we are not obliged to pray to Him in extemporary Prayers ; since it is Unreasonable to interpret singing with the Spirit , in one sense , and praying with the Spirit in a contrary . 2. And to confirm this further , we find the most spiritual Persons addressing themselves to God in Forms ; so did Moses , so did David , as I observed before ; and so did our Saviour himself on the Cross , when in his Agony he repeated the first Verse of Psal. xxii . in Syriack , and as some believe , the whole Psalm ; by which Act , He recommendeth to us Forms of Prayer in his Dying Breath , as the most proper means of expressing our condition to God , and as most suitable to the Divine Majesty ; and therefore praying — in the Spirit , Ephes. vi . 18 . Praying in the holy Ghost , Jude 20. and with the Spirit , 1 Cor. xiv . 15 . signifie praying with Grace in our Hearts , by the Assistance and Motion of the Holy Spirit : And a man may as well pray with Grace in his Heart , when he prays by a Form , as sing with Grace in his Heart , when he sings by a Form. 3. We have a Promise that God's Spirit will assist us with this Grace in our Hearts , but we have no Promise that He will help us to Words without the Use of Forms ; as will appear from Rom. viii . 26 . The Spirit also helpeth our Infirmities , for we know not what we should pray for as we ought , but the Spirit it self maketh Intercession for us with groanings that cannot be uttered ; those inward motions in the Heart , called here groanings , are that Grace in the Heart with which we ought to pray , and to which the Spirit of God doth , and indeed only can help us , and to pray with this Grace , is to pray in and with the Spirit , whether we use words or no ; and if we do use them , whether we reduce them into a Form first , or pour them forth as they present themselves to our Minds ; but we have no Promise that the Holy Ghost will always furnish us with fit words on all occasions , and therefore ought not to presume that He will. 4. T is certain that he did furnish some with such words , for we find both Prayers and Hymns dictated immediately by him , of which we have Examples in the Hymns of the Blessed Virgin and Zacharias , and in the Song or Prayer of Simeon , and in Acts iv . 24 . But then it is manifest that this was an extraordinary Gift of God , and a part of Prophecy , and we may not depend on the holy Ghost for this Gift , more then for any other Extraordinary Gift , till it be made appear that it was to continue alwaies in the Church , and to be communicated to All the Children of God. Praying , and singing the Praises of God , are Duties incumbent on all Christians ; but we are no more obliged to pray Extemporary Prayers , from any Example of inspired Men in Scripture , than to sing Extemporary Hymns from the like Examples ; to which yet none , I think , pretend . 5. 'T is very observable that even those who composed their Prayers and Hymns by immediate inspiration , did not generally offer them to God in the Congregation till they had first reduced them into a Form : Thus David first penned his Psalms , and then delivered them to be sung , 1. Chron. xvi . 7 . and 't is probable the Prophets , 1. Cor. xiv . 26 . did the same , for they are supposed , every one to have a Psalm , a Doctrine , a Tongue , a Revelation , &c. that is , to have them ready , and reduced into Form for the use of the Church when they came together . That this is the meaning of having a Psalm , &c. in this place , will appear very probable , not only from the words which naturally import this , and can hardly be otherwise interpreted , but likewise from the Apostles making a difference between what these Prophets had prepared , and what was revealed immediately at the time of their being together , vers . 30. If any thing be revealed to another that siteth by , let the first hold his peace . Which shews that these Psalms , &c. were to give place to such as were immediately inspired : So far were these inspired Men from countenancing an extemporary , unpremeditated way of serving God , except where there was an immediate Revelation for it , and so utterly void of Scripture-proof is this great principle of the Dissenters Worship , that the Spirit of prayer is given to every one of the Faithfull to enable them to conceive with the Heart and express with their Tongues their necessities to God without a Form of Prayer . 8. It lies therefore my Friends on your Teachers who are of this persuasion , to produce plain Scripture for your principles , or else to confess that you have laid aside Prayers by Forms commanded by God , and practised by holy Men in Scriptures , to make room for this way of Praying of Men's own invention . But further that place , Eccl. v. 1.2 . seems to me to afford a strong Argument against such Prayers , When thou goest to the House of God , — Be not rash with thy Mouth , and let not thy Heart be hasty to utter any thing before God : for God is in Heaven , and thou upon Earth : Therefore let thy words be few . It is hard to say what it is to be rash with our Mouths , or hasty to utter any thing before God , if it be not rashnesh to trust the expressing all our desires to such uncertain and unpremeditated words , as our invention suggests unto us , when we come before him , which ( as I have shewed ) the Scriptures give us no promise of being supplied to us by the Spirit on ordinary occasions . I appeal to you whether it would not be looked on as rashness for an ordinary person to speak to a Prince , or solemn Assembly , concerning a matter of great moment , in words unpremeditated and unformed , and we shall hardly find any so rash as to venture on it . King Solomon here seems to have recommended the same modesty to Men in their Addresses to God. 9. But in as much as God has not expressly forbidden all extemporary prayers , I would not be understood by this to condemn all such as unlawful . There may be some Men ( tho' not very many ) able to express themselves significantly and decently , extempore ; and there are some occasions that require it even in Publick ; and on these occasions , when a Man has not time allowed him to reduce his desires into form before he offers them , he may depend on the assistance of God's Spirit , as we may in all other cases of of necessity , or at least hope for pardon of course to our infirmities : But to depend on that Spirit , and neglect the means God has given us to provide our selves , looks so like tempting him , that we ought carefully to avoid it : And I find Prudent Modest Men are aware of this , and tho' they be very famous for extemporary prayers , yet they pray really as much by a Form as if they had the Common-Prayer before them . The secret is only this , they compose Forms of Prayer of several sorts , digest them well in their minds , and commit them to memory ; so that they can on occasion transpose the parts of them , change , add , or leave out , as they see reason ; and thus they are in effect provided with a Form , tho' the people cannot perceive it , and admire them for their readiness and fluency . It is easie for any Man of Moderate Parts to manage the matter thus , but the more ignorant and ordinary Preachers that know not , or are not capable of the method of it , fall into very indecent and vain repetitions , and are often at a loss when they strive to practise this way of Addressing to God. Another account may be given of these seeming Extemporary Prayers not much different from the former , namely , That good Men who make a Conscience of secret prayer to God , and have grown up in a constant Discharge of this Duty , do by degrees fall into a Form even with themselves ; for how much soever their prayers were Extempore at first , yet having continual Occasion of praying to God for the same things , they find in time that there is but one best way of expressing the same thing ; which necessarily leads to a form . However , the various ways they made use of before they settled on one , serve them as so many forms when they come in publick : And by changing of these , they seem to pray extempore . 10. Lastly , let me observe that the use of Extemporary conceived prayers , even in cases of necessity , is founded on a general Rule of Scripture only , which commands us to ask of God what we lack ; Of which Rule our own prudence makes the Application in such extemporary occasions , but when we set up this Human Application of this general Rule in opposition to that particular manner of asking , commanded by God , and practised by Holy Men , which is by set and premeditated Forms , in the ordinary Worship of God , and turn God's way out of his Worship , to make room for one of our own ; This is to displace a particular command of God on pretence of guiding our selves by a general one : In which we are not only more liable to mistakes , but we fail of paying due respect to God's Directions . For general Commands ought only to take place in such Cases where God has not laid down a particular Rule . And thus I have examined the First Principle of Dissenters ; That the Spirit of Prayer is given to all the Children of God , whereby they are enabled to conceive with the Heart , and express with the Mouth convenient desires to God. IV. I come now to speak to the Second , That all Forms of Prayer are Vnlawfull to Christians , and that it is a sin to join in a Worship where they are used , or so much as to be present at it . If there be any of you for whom I intend these Papers of this opinion , as I fear some of you are , and all of you do in your practice comply with those that maintain it , and therefore cannot acquit your selves from countenancing it ; I desire you to observe that if there were no harm in the opinion , or if it were a meer Speculation , we should not be much concerned at their mistake . But by what I have shewed of the Scripture Authority of Forms , it is plain that they who maintain this principle , do not only teach for Doctrines the Commandments of Men , but in effect set themselves up above Christ , and countermand what he has required . They not only add to the Gospel a new command , by Teaching that to be unlawful which Christ has no where condemned , but they Teach that to be unlawful which he has positively commanded . Whoever therefore do Teach Forms of Prayer to be unlawful , or countenance those that do Teach this Doctrine of Men , cannot acquit themselves from the imputation of resisting the Holy Ghost , by whose inspiration the word of God is penned . I can foresee only one thing that can be alledged in favour of those who maintain this opinion , and 't is , that to pray with , or without a Form ( excepting the Lords-Prayer ) is in it self indifferent , and that therefore the asserting the use of Forms is not a matter of such weight , as to justify our contending with our Brethren about it ; and that it seems uncharitable in us to insist on a thing which they are fully perswaded is unlawful , and we our selves count indifferent . 1. But in Answer to this , it is to be observed , First , That an opinion which necessarily divides him who believes it from the Communion of all the Established Churches in the World cannot be of so little moment as the objection would make it . And such is this opinion of the unlawfulness of Forms of Prayer ; since there neither is , nor has been any Established Church these 1500 years , but has maintained their Lawfulness , and used them in the Service of God , and therefore whoever believes them to be unlawful , in whatever Age he had lived , he must have separated from all the Established Churches of the World at that time ; and surely an opinion that necessarily produces such a Division must be of mighty consequence , whether true or false , & ought to be carefully examined , and if false , to be zealously opposed . But , 2. I suppose it will be granted , that eating Swines Flesh , or drinking Wine , are as indifferent as using a Form of Prayer , and of less concern to the Souls of Men , and that therefore to Teach these to be unlawful would be as innocent a mistake as to Teach the unlawfulness of Forms . For if we compare these two Doctrines together , and the mischiefs that each of them have , or may hereafter produce , It is hardly conceivable that the forbidding the use of some particular Meats should have so many ill effects as the forbidding Forms of prayer has had already . Yet it is observable how St. Paul judges of that Doctrine , 1 Tim. iv . 1 . In the latter times ( saith he ) some shall depart from the Faith , giving heed to seducing Spirits and Doctrines of Devils — Forbidding to Marry , and to abstain from Meats , which God hath Created to be received with Thanksgiving . You see here St. Paul counts it a departure from the Faith , and a Doctrine of Devils to forbid , as unlawful in it self , any sort of Meat which God has Created for the use of Man ; and if it be so Criminal to Teach any sort of Meat to be unclean when God has not forbidden it , then sure to Teach a Form of Prayer to be unlawful , when God has commanded it , must be a very ill Doctrine . And this consideration alone ought to make those who maintain it , or any such Doctrine whereby they are obliged to condemn their Brethren as practising unlawful things , to examine it carefully and impartially by the word of God , lest they be imposed on by Seducing Spirits . The great Design of the Devil is to bring us into an intire subjection to his will. But when he despairs of this , his next Attempt is to share with God in our Obedience , and impose new Commands of his Own upon us , as if they were God's , and so to procure himself to be obey'd . This he doth most successfully by giving them an appearance of Religion , and of more than ordinary strictness . Thus in St. Paul's time , under colour of Mortification , he forbad Meats and Marriage , as Vnlawful , which God had allowed ; speaking Lies in Hypocrisie , and under shew of Religion . And thus 't is to be feared he has prevailed on some under colour of greater spirituality , to abstain from Forms of Prayer , as Unlawful , which God has enjoyned . And here it is very remarkable , that where-ever the Devil gains this point with men , and brings them to believe a thing to be forbidden by God , which he has not forbidden , he soon brings a super-added Command of his Own , in Competition with some of God's , and prevails with them to prefer his Commands to God's ; and so plungeth them into direct Disobedience , which was his Design at first . Thus when he had prevailed with Men to abstain from Marriage , they soon fell not only to Commit Fornication , but even , in some cases , to Allow it , rather than Marriage , as the Papists do : And by perswading Men to abstain from Forms of Prayer , as Unlawful , he has deprived them in many places of all opportunity of Publick Worship , and made them choose rather not to serve God at all in Publick , than with a Form ; which is the case of many Thousands now in this Kingdom , who worship God publickly no where . But , 3. This Doctrine of the Unlawfulness of praying by Forms , is no such indifferent thing , that we may safely indulge Men in their own sense about it : Since it is very apt to puff them up , and make them take false measures in judging of their own Condition , and of the influence of God's Spirit upon them . We know that all good Men have the Spirit of God , and are guided and influenced by it in the whole tenor of their Lives ; we make no doubt but they are assisted by Him in their prayers , but no less in forgiving an Injury , or resisting a Temptation ; and his influence on a good Man's Mind is rather greater and more sensible in these and other Acts of Religion , than in Prayer . Love , Joy , Peace , Long-suffering , Gentleness , Goodness , Faith , Meekness , Temperance , are the Fruits of the Spirit , Gal. v. 22 . And it is principally by these we ought to conclude that we have that Spirit . But the Opinion of the Unlawfulness of Forms of Prayer , on a perswasion that the Spirit of God enables every Child of God to conceive with the Heart , and express with the Mouth suitable Desires , entitles every one to God's Spirit in some measure , that is able to express himself in apt and fluent Words , tho' without the other Graces of the Spirit , and exposes every one to despair that is not able to do this , as looking on himself to be destitute of the Spirit , tho' otherwise meek , humble , and charitable , and endowed with such Graces as are much wore certain signs of his presence . Nay , so far are many deluded by this Opinion , that they judge themselves or others Children of God , and in his Favour , according as they are more or less endowed with this Gift , without respect to other Qualifications . And I dare appeal to your selves , Whether some very Immoral Persons , guilty of gross and scandalous Crimes , have not been eminent for this Gift of Prayer ? And whether such persons are not apt to flatter themselves that they are the Children of God , and endowed with his Spirit , notwithstanding all their Wickedness ? And it is impossible either to convince these persons of their mistake , or to comfort poor ignorant people , dejected only for want of this Gift , whilst they are possessed with this Opinion of the Unlawfulness of Forms . Which in the 4th place ought not to be countenanced or indulged as an indifferent thing , because it has been a great hindrance to secret Devotion : Every Christian ought at least twice a day to address himself to God in secret prayer , but a great part of the World cannot do it without a Form ; Children and ignorant persons are at a loss for Words , and even other people are often not able to find them readily , especially when wearied , dull , or indisposed , as is sometimes the condition of the the best Christians ; this makes secret prayer , at least a constant regular course of it , uneasie to most that are absolutely against all Use of Forms , and it occasions too many to neglect it , which otherwise would not : And as for Children and ignorant people , amongst those of this Perswasion , I am well assured many of them never bow their Knees in secret to God ; and several of those that are grown up , are forced to speak aloud , or cannot pray at all , which is against the nature of secret Prayer ; and exposes not only the Persons that use it to the censure of Hypocrisy , but the Duty to Contempt . 'T is on this account that the pious Custom of Training up Young People to a constant course of Devotion , in their morning and evening secret Prayers , is too universally laid aside among you , as I have found by experience , and for the truth of the Observation I dare appeal to all of the Dissenters . On the contrary I am well assured that there cannot be a more effectual or easy method to revive and continue this regular and constant use of secret prayers , than to oblige every one to some certain Forms every Morning and Evening , which they may not omit , whatever other prayers they use : But this can never be done whilst the opinion of the unlawfulness of forms prevails ; and therefore all good people are obliged to oppose it , as they would retrieve the constant use of secret prayers ; which shews that this is no indifferent matter , as the objection would suggest , but of great weight and fit to be contended for . I will not mention some other Reasons that are of great moment , because they would but exasperate , and tend to make the Duty of Prayer , when performed extempore , ridiculous , which ill men might extend ( as it too often happens ) to expose Devotion in general ; such are the indecent Expressions which sometimes fall from persons that pray thus : I will only observe to you , that Extemporary Prayers of some Preachers have too often given occasion of Offence to serious persons even among your selves . 'T is certain , that to print some of them , as they have been spoken , as those that we make use of are printed , would not be for the Honour of the Holy Spirit , to whom they are ascribed , nor much recommend them to serious Men. But I esteem it an ill thing for Men to ridicule one anothers Devotion , whatever it is . V. There remains yet the Third Opinion of Dissenters which they advance against us in this matter of Prayer , to be Examined , That the Minister is the Mouth of the Congregation , and that the People have nothing to do but to joyn with him in their Hearts ; An Opinion far from any Authority of Scripture , which expresly requires us , Rom. xv . 6 . with one Mind , and one Mouth , to glorifie God ; We produce this , and many other places and Examples in Scripture , for the People's joyning their Voices , and bearing a part in their praises and prayers ; and we are assured there is no Scripture forbids it ; and therefore when you Condemn it , or teach it to be Unlawful , we must charge it upon You , as an instance of Your Teaching for Doctrines the Commandments of Men. Which is all I think needful to be said to this Head , after what I have shewed before in defence of our contrary practise from Scripture ; and , I think , sufficient to induce you seriously to consider it . And thus , I presume , I have faithfully examined the Rules and Examples the Scriptures afford us for the performance of that part of our publick Worship that consists in Prayers , and compared the Service of our Church , and the Dissenters way of Praying , with them , and made it appear that our performance of this Duty , both as to the Matter and Manner , is agreeable to the Commandments of God , and to the Examples of Holy Men recorded in Scripture : And that the Service the Dissenters have substituted in the room thereof , has in many particulars laid aside God's Commands , and deserted the Examples of Scripture , and is in the main part thereof an immediate Invention of Men. And I intreat you who are of this Persuasion , and adhere to these Principles of Worship which I have now mentioned , and shewed to be disagreeable to Scripture , to consider seriously whether you are not thereby literally guilty of that Sin with which our Saviour taxeth the Jews , Mark vii . 7 . of Teaching for Doctrines the Commandments of Men ; And also of that Superstition condemned by St. Paul , Col. ii . 21 . which saith , Touch not , taste not , handle not , ( that is , which teaches to forbear those things which God has made Lawful ) after the Doctrines and Commandments of Men : And I beseech God to inlighten your Minds to make a true Judgement in it , that you may deliver your Souls . CHAP. III. Of Hearing . Sect. 1. What the Holy Scriptures prescribe concerning it . I. ONE great design of Our Christian Assemblies is Hearing , and that which is to be heard is the Word of God. I shall proceed in examining this , in the same manner as I have done in the former Chapters ; And consider , First , What Directions the Scriptures afford us for the publick performance of this Duty . Secondly , Shall compare our own practice with them . And , Thirdly , That of the Dissenters . First then , God has positively Commanded us to read His Word in our publick Assemblies . So Deut. xxxi . 10 . In the feast of Tabernacles , when all Israel is come to appear before the Lord thy God , in the place where the Lord shall choose . Thou shalt read this Law before all Israel in their Hearing . Gather the people together , Men , Women and Children , and thy Stranger that is within thy gates , that they may hear , and that they may learn , and fear the Lord your God , and observe to do all the Words of this Law. And 't is observed ▪ Jos. viii . 35 . that there was not a word of all that Moses Commanded , which Joshua read not before all the Congregation . Neither was this confined to their Solemn Assemblies at Jerusalem ; It was likewise a constant part of their Sabbath Service in their Synagogues . As we may learn from Acts xiii . 14 . where it is observed , that Paul and Barnabas went into the Synagogue on the Sabbath day , and sate down ; and after the reading of the Law and the Prophets , the Rulers of the Synagogue sent unto them , &c. and St. Paul takes notice , vers . 27. that the Prophets were read every Sabbath day , meaning undoubtedly in their Assemblies . And St. James ( Acts xv . 21 . ) of Moses his being read in the Synagogues every Sabbath day . II. This reading the Law was the great , and most effectual means God provided for preserving the knowledge of himself amongst his people ; and where it was omitted , the people immediately sunk into Idolatry ; and the best Reformation began , and was carried on by Restoring this Ordinance . Thus 't is observed of Josiah , 2 Chron. xxxiv . 29 . that he gathered together all the Elders of Judah and Jerusalem — And all the Inhabitants of Jerusalem , and the Pri●sts and the Levites , and all the people great and small , and he read in their ears all the words of the book of the Covenant that was found in the House of the Lord. The like is observed of Ezra , Neh. viii . 3 . And he read therein before the street that was before the Water-gate , from Morning untill Mid-day , before the Men and the Women , and all that could understand . 'T is remarkable that after the Captivity , the Jews never fell into Idolatry : and the chief reason given by themselves was the strict Observation of this Ordinance of God , the Law being constantly read to them afterwards publickly in their Synagogues ; so powerfully doth God bless his own Ordinances to preserve those that use them from Error and Sin. III. From the practice of the Synagogue in reading the Law and the Prophets , the like Order was brought into the Christian Church ; and Reading was made a part of the Office of the Christian Elders , as it was before of the Jewish . And hence it is that Timothy is Commanded by St. Paul , 1 Tim. iv . 13 . To give attendance to Reading as well as to Exhortation and Doctrine . And the inspired Writings of the Apostles were read in the Christian Assemblies , as well as the Law and Prophets among the Jews , According to St. Paul's Command , Col. iv . 16 . When this Epistle is read amongst you , cause that it also be read in the Church of the Laodiceans , and that ye likewise read the Epistle from Laodicea . And it was but reason , since the Gospel contained the Christian Law , that it should be read in the Christian Assemblies , as well as the Law of Moses was in the Synagogues . And that it was so read in the first Christian Assemblies , I might shew by many instances out of the Antient Fathers , if there were occasion . IV. This publick Reading the Law was of so great Reputation , that it is termed Preaching it ; as we may see from Acts xv . 21 . For Moses of old time hath in every City them that preach him , being read in the Synagogues every Sabbath day . The word Preaching has a peculiar sense in the New Testament , and signifies properly to Declare or Proclaim the Word of God , as a Herauld or Cryer proclaimes the Laws or Orders of a King. Hence only those that Proclaim'd the Gospel to such as had not heard it before , or read the Old Testament to the people , are said to Preach . Preaching is distinguished from Teaching and Exhortation ; and 't is observable , that in the whole New Testament , tho' reading the Scriptures is called Preaching , yet interpreting them , applying them , or exhorting the people from them in a Christian Auditory , is never called by that name . If it be objected that St. Paul is said to preach to the Disciples , Acts xx . 7 . when he only in probability made a Sermon , or Exhortation to Believers , as is usual now ; I answer , that the Original of this Word ( 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 ) is never translated preach in any other place of the New Testament , and should not have been here , but discours'd , disputed , spake , or reason'd ; so it is translated in Acts xvii . 2 , 17. xviii . 19 . xix . 8 , 9. Heb. xii . 5 , &c. for the Original Words which properly signifie preaching are 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 . From all which it is manifest that there are only two ways by which the Word of God is properly preached ; the first is , when it is declared to those that never heard of it before ; and the second is when the very words of the Scripture are read publickly to the peodle , as a Cryer doth a Proclamation , which he doth not word himself , but reads it in the words in which it is delivered to him . In short , The Scriptures are Sermons out of the Mouth of God , being dictated by his Holy Spirit ; for the Reading of which to the People for their Conviction and Instruction , there is a peculiar Command of God ; and where this Ordinance is duely observed , they are sure of the Word of Life ; and 't is impossible they should be ignorant of their Duty , for the Scriptures are sufficient to mak● them wise to Salvation ; and the hearing them with Humility and Attention , is a means sufficient to beget Faith in the Hearts of those that hear them ; for they are profitable for Doctrine , for Reproof , for Correction , for Instruction in Righteousness , that the Man of God may be perfect , thorowly furnished to all good Works , as we see 1 Tim. iii. 16 , 17. V. We find in Holy Scripture that the Publick Reading of the Word of God was with great Solemnity . 'T is observed Nehem. viii . 5 . When Ezra opened the Book , all the people stood up , and Ezra blessed the Lord , the great God ; and all the people answered , Amen , Amen , with lifting up their hands , and they bowed their heads , and worshiped the Lord with their faces to the ground ; and I find it generally agreed that both the Readers and Hearers stood up whilst the Law was read , tho' not when other things were read or taught ; hence it is observed Luke iv . 16 . that our Saviour stood up for to read ; and Vers. 20. after closing the Book , that he sat down to teach : Hence Rev. v. God is represented in allusion to the High-Priest , with a Book in his Right Hand , containing the Revelations of his Will ; and the Lamb , as his Minister , takes it out of his Hand to declare the Contents of it ; and Vers. 8. When he had taken the Book , the four Beasts and four and twenty Elders fell down before the Lamb — And they sung a New Song : The Angels joyn with them , Vers. 11. and the whole Creation , Verse . 13. From whence we see the Scriptures teach us to receive the Revelations of God's Will out of the Book of Life , with Adoration and Praises : And therefore we find that at the Reading the Law , Confessions , and Praises of God , were intermixed , and succeeded one another , Neh. ix . 3 . And they stood up in their place , and read in the Book of the Lord their God one fourth part of the Day , and another fourth part they Confessed and Worshiped the Lord their God. VI. We find that the Word of God is to be read in such a Language as the People understand . After the Captivity , the People being Born and Educated in a strange Land , their Language was changed , and they did not understand , at least Universally , the pure Hebrew in which the Law was first written ; therefore when Ezra read in the Law , a certain number of the Priests and Levites interpreted the Words of the Law , as Ezra read them to the People : Neh. viii . 7 . And they caused the people to understand the Law , and the people stood in their place ; so they read in the Book in the Law of God distinctly , and gave the sence , and caused them to understand the reading : And this Custom continueth among the Jews to this Day ; first the Hebrew Text is read , and then a Translation or Paraphrase , in a Language understood by the Hearers . And indeed there may be good reason for reading the Originals in Publick Assemblies , such a Custom being an effectual means to preserve the knowledge of them ; but they cannot be useful to the People without a Translation . Therefore St. Paul doth not absolutely forbid speaking in Unknown Tongues in the Church , but orders , 1 Cor. xiv . 27 . Let one interpret ; but if there be no Interpreter , let him keep silence in the Church . VII . We find that after reading the Word of God , there was sometimes an Enlargement or Comment on some part of it , and an Exhortation to the People : Thus when our Saviour had read a portion of Scripture , He applied it to the people in a Discourse to that purpose . But it doth not appear that this was constantly done , on the contrary it is rather probable that it was not . For had there been a constant Provision for such Enlargement , and Exposition of the Law , and Exhortation from it , there had been no occasion for the Rulers of the Synagogue , Acts xiii . 15 . to send to St. Paul and Barnabas , after the reading of the Law and Prophets , that Message we find there , Ye Men and Brethren , if ye have any Word of Exhortation for the People , say on . St. Paul supposes him who Teaches , and him whose Office it was to Exhort , distinct from him that Ruled , and him that Ministered , Rom. xii . And it doth not appear that every Church was furnished with all these Officers . The same St. Paul joyned Exhortation and Doctrine with Reading , in his Charge to Timothy , 1 Tim. iv . 13 . which shews that they went together , but whether indispensibly or no , doth not appear ; tho' it is manifest in the practise of most Churches in the Ages after the Apostles they were all generally exercis'd in the Publick Worship . VIII . Lastly , We find that they had a Summary of the Principal Doctrines of the Gospel , which they delivered to the people , and by which they ordered their own Discourses , and judged of what was delivered by others . Thus St. Paul to Timothy , 2 Tim. i. 13 . Hold fast the Form of sound Words which thou hast heard of me ; and Chap. ii . Vers. 2. And the things that thou hast heard of me among many Witnesses , the same commit thou to faithful Men , who shall be able to teach others : Perhaps this may be that proportion of Faith according to which the Prophets are exhorted to prophesy , Rom. xii . 6 . I think it is not doubted but this Form of sound Words contained the main Fundamentals of Christianity ; and St. Paul tells us what those were , Heb. vi . 1 , 2. Therefore leaving the Principles of the Doctrine of Christ , let us go on unto perfection ; not laying again the foundation of Repentance from dead Works , and Faith towards God , of the Doctrine of Baptisms , and of Laying on of Hands , and of the Resurrection of the Dead , and of Eternal Judgment . In all probability therefore the Form of sound Words delivered by St. Paul to Timothy , and by him to others , contained these six Heads or Principles of Christianity , which every Christian was obliged to hear and learn. Sect. 2. The Practice of Our Church in Reading and Preaching the word . THese are the Rules and Examples the Scriptures propose to us for our feeding the people with the Word of Life , and their Hearing it in Publick . Let us in the second place compare the Practise of Our Church with them , and surely no copy can come nearer the Original . 1. For first , Our Ministers are expresly oblig'd in their Ordination , diligently to read all the Canonical Scriptures of the Old and New Testament unto the people Assembled in the Church where they shall be appointed to serve . 2. Our Church has disposed the Holy Scriptures in a certain Order , and has appointed four or more Chapters to be read every day in the Publick Congregations , by which means all the most edifying parts of the Old Testament are Ordered to be read once a year , and the New Testament ( except the Revelations ) thrice in the same time ; And some select Chapters of the Revelations are appointed on extraordinary occasions . There are indeed some Chapters ( about one tenth ) of the Old Testament , left out of this Order : But then it is to be observed , that those which are left out , are either Genealogies , names of Persons and Places , Historical repetitions , or some obscure and mystical Prophecies in Ezekiel , which are not so proper for an ordinary Assembly ( for which reasons , some part of the Revelations is also left out ) yet these are not excluded , tho' not particularly Commanded . The general obligation on every Clergy-Man in his Ordination to read all the Canonical Scriptures of the Old and New Testament , still allows him to read these , and also obliges him to it when he shall perceive that it may be for the edification of the people . 3. Besides this Order for the whole Scriptures , on every Lords-day , and other solemn occasions , there are appointed certain select Portions out of the Epistles and Gospels to be read , which are adapted to the occasion ; and contain some great mystery of our Faith , or other weighty matter necessary to our Edification . 4. For the more solemnity of these readings ; Our Church joins with each of them Praises , Thanksgivings or Confessions , according to what we find practised in the Holy Scripture . 5. That the people may benefit , and be Edified by hearing the word of God , a plain Authentick and most excellent Translation is provided by publick Authority , in which the Scriptures are read to the People . This was the first care of our Church in the Reformation , and the generality of Dissenters are forced to be beholden to it for the word of Life , and draw all the knowledge that they have from the Fountains which our Bishops opened for them , by Translating the word of God , and putting it into a Language they understand . 6. 'T is ordered in our Church that the Ministers shall explain some part of the Holy Scriptures every Lords-day , and exhort their Congregations in a Sermon . 7. To inculcate the great Mysteries of our Faith the better , our Church has appointed certain solemn times , wherein once in the year they are obliged to explain , and inculcate every great Mystery of our Faith , and most material passages of the Gospel . Such are the Conception , Birth , Passion , Resurrection and Ascention of Our Saviour . Lastly , There is provided a Form of Sound Words in a short and plain Catechism ; in which are contained the first principles of the Oracles of God ; this is adapted , as it ought to be , to the capacity of Children , and is indeed sincere Milk , without School Notions , or hard words . And all the six principles which the Apostle mentions , Heb. vi . 1 , 2. are briefly explained in it , and yet largely enough to make those that attend to it wise to Salvation . The Teaching and Explaining these Fundamentals , is a part of our Publick Instruction , and injoined as a constant Duty on Ministers and People in our solemn Worship . The Minister in each Parish being required diligently upon Sundays and Holy-days — openly in the Church to instruct and examine so many Children of his Parish sent unto him , as he shall think convenient , in some part of the Catechism , and the people are obliged to come at the time appointed , and obediently to hear . And by our Twelfth Canon , for the better grounding of the people in the principles of Christian Religion , 't is ordained , That the heads of the Catechism being divided into so many parts as there are Sundays in the year , shall be explained to the people in every Parish Church . This is the care our Church has taken to Teach the People in their Publick Assemblies , and the method is so effectual , that 't is scarce conceivable how any one who duly conforms to these Orders should be ignorant of any thing that concerns his Soul. And by the blessing of God , the effect is such that we may affirm without Vanity or Partiality , that our Clergy , and Laity , especially where we can prevail with them to conform to the Rules of our Church , are generally much more knowing , modest , governable , devout and charitable , then perhaps may be found in any other Church , of which our late contests with the Papists , and behaviour under their Government , and since the present Revolution , are Evident proofs . Sect. 3. The Practice of the Dissenters in Hearing , and Reading the Word . I Come now to consider with you my Friends who dissent from us , how this great Duty of Teaching the people the Law of God is perform'd in your Assemblies , and to compare your practice in this point with the Scripture Rules and Examples . Which I shall do with the same Candour and Integrity that I have hitherto endeavoured to observe . I. And here I must needs say that your Teachers seem to have had very little Regard , either to Scripture Rules or Examples in framing this part of your Worship , having laid aside all those methods of instruction that the Scriptures recommend to us , except it be that of Exposition and Exhortation : Which among you is called Preaching , in so much , that tho' a Man frequent your Meetings all his Life , yet he has no security , or hardly possibility of learning from your publick Teachings all the great Mysteries of his Religion , or the necessary principles of his Faith. 1. For first , Your Preachers are intirely left to their choice what place of Scripture they will explain , or what Subject they will handle : And hence it happens that hardly any one Man in his life ever goes through the necessary Articles of Faith , or of practice , in his Publick Sermons , and for the truth of this I appeal to your selves . 2. You have no summary of Principles injoined to be either Read or Taught in your Publick Assemblies . A Catechism you have , but neither your Directory nor Practice make it any part of your Lords-day-Service ; And besides your Catechism is such , that it no ways answers the design of a Form of sound Words . I have already shewed that such a Form should contain only the first and necessary principles of the Oracles of God , in such Words and Methods as may make it easily apprehended and retained by the weak and unlearned , which make up the bulk of the people . But your Catechism is full of Hard Words , School Terms , and Abstruse Notions , no wise necessary to be known by the generality of Christians , or possible to be understood by Children , or unlearned Persons , for whose Edification principally a Catechism ought to be contrived . Besides all this , it is so long and intricate , even the Shorter that not one child in ten ever gets it by heart , nor one in five hundred retains it , as I have found by experience , and desire that you would judge of this matter as you find upon trial . Lastly , After all , it is imperfect of some of the principles of the Apostles Catechism , being quite left out of it , I mean laying on of hands ; Joined with Baptism , Heb. vi . 2 . a great defect sure in a Catechism to leave out a Fundamental of Christianity . II. But the most sad and deplorable defect of your performance of this Duty , is your casting out the reading of the Word of God , from most of your Publick Assemblies , directly contrary to God's Institution and Ordinance for the Instruction of his Church ; insomuch that in many of your Meetings , setting aside a verse or two for a Text , or Quotation at the discretion of the Teacher , the voice of God is never publickly heard amongst them . This is matter of fact , and undeniable ; And in all the Meetings in the North of Ireland in a whole year , perhaps there is not so much Scripture read , as in one day in our Church , by the strictest enquiry which I cou'd make . One would think this alone were sufficient to shew the people where the Worship of God is to be found in its Purity , and to prove our Assemblies to be the True Church of God , against all that come in competition with us ; whereof some hide the Word of God in a strange Language , and others banish it out of their Meetings . It being in our Congregations only , that the voice of God is heard speaking to his People , without cover or gloss . Sure it is a sad thing that a Man may go to most Meetings many years , and never hear one intire Chapter read in them . Now this omission is the more inexcusable in you , and must render you manifestly self-condemned . 1. First , Because you so vehemently press the necessity of Preaching , and quote the Holy Scriptures to prove it . In which , reading the Law ( as is shewed before ) is termed Preaching , Act , xv . 21 . but interpreting the Scriptures applying them , or exhorting the Congregation from them in a fixed Christian Auditory ( which you count Preaching ) is never called so in the whole New Testament . Therefore by laying aside the reading the Scriptures in your publick Assemblies , you have intirely cast aside Preaching , in the proper Scripture-sense of it . But , 2. This must render you self-condemned , because you pretend to honour the Holy Scriptures above other Christians : Your Mouths , Commendably and with just Reason , are continually full of the praises of the Holy Bible ; you own it , with the generality of the Reformed Churches , for the only sufficient Rule of Faith you appeal to it , and seem to found your selves on it : And yet your not allowing the Reading of it a constant place in your Religious Assemblies , makes it seem as if you had a very low Opinion of it in your hearts . If you really value it as you profess , why do you banish the Reading of it from your publick Worship , to make room for Discourses , Lectures , and Sermons of your own Teachers ? Remember of whom it is said , ( Mark vii . 6 . ) This People honoureth me with their Lips , but their Heart is far from me . While you thus justle the Word of God out of your Solemn Meetings , to make room for your own Sermons , I beseech you to consider whether this be not a laying aside the Commandments of God for Mens Inventions ; unless you will call your Sermons ( as some Quakers are said to do ) as much the Word of God as the Bible . III. I look on this as so Material a Point , and conceive the Honour of the Holy Scriptures and the Salvation of Christians to be so deeply concerned in it , that I think my self obliged to Examine the Pretences I have found to justifie it : Tho' I confess they seem to me so weak , that I am afraid I shall be almost suspected by indifferent persons not to do Justice in representing them : For it is unaccountable that any body should urge so slight Reasons for so considerable an Omission : And yet these are all I have ever met with , or heard from you . The first Reason I have heard urg'd , is , That the people are obliged to read the Scriptures at home , and being thus acquainted with them , the Reading of them is not necessary in their publick Meetings . But to this I Answer . 1. That we see from what has been said ; That the Reading of the Holy Scriptures is by God's Appointment a part of his solemn publick Worship ; therefore to leave it out in our Assemblies , on any pretence whatsoever , is to lay aside his Command , and so to corrupt and dismember his Worship . 2. The private performance of a Duty ought by no means to interfere with , or hinder the publick . We must pray to God , praise him , and instruct our Families in private ; and yet God forbid that our doing these privately , should banish the use of them from our Publick Assemblies ; or that any one should think himself excused from Attending on the Publick Performance of them , on account of his Private Diligence in them : And the same Rule holds for Reading the Holy Scriptures . 3. God tells the Children of Israel , Deut. vi . 6 . That these Words which I command thee this day , shall be in thine heart , and thou shalt teach them diligently to thy Children , and shalt talk of them when thou sittest in thine house , and when thou walkest by the way , and when thou liest down , and when thou risest up — and thou shalt write them on the posts of thy house . Here is as much private diligence in Reading and Teaching the Law , required of the Israelites , as any Christian can pretend to exercise ; and yet all this care to preserve the knowledge of the Law by private study and exercise , did not make the Reading it in their Synagogues unnecessary , or prevent God from requiring them to Use it as part of his publick Worship , Deut. xxxi . 11 . And therefore all your diligence in reading the Scriptures privately , or Your Teachers exhorting and requiring You to do it , ought not to warrant Their or Your dispensing with the Command of God , that appoints the Reading his Word as part of his publick Service . But , 4. When people are left to themselves in private , they may either do or not do a thing , as they please : And we are assured that there are many who come to Church , and hear the Word of God read there , that neither can , nor ever wou'd be at the pains to read it in private . It is therefore a great Temptation to the people to be negligent , and a great want of Care in a Church , to leave so material a thing as the Reading of the Word of God , to private diligence . We find by experience , that where no publick effectual care is taken to inform the generality of Men , the Knowledge of God's Word sensibly decays , and is in a fair way to be lost . The Papists read the Scriptures in a Language that the people do not understand , and we see into what gross ignorance they are fallen by this means . Those of Your Perswasion ( generally speaking ) do not read them at all in your Meetings , and the consequence of this is , That many of your common people are strangers to the very History of the Bible , and the First Principles of Christianity ; as I have found on Tryal , to my great trouble and astonishment . This pretence therefore of Peoples Reading the Holy Scriptures in private , will by no means justifie you , for breaking God's Command , in omitting the publick Reading them , as a part of God's Service , in the Congregations . The Second Pretence that I have met with for this Omission , is , That since the penning of the Scriptures , and settling of the Church by the Apostles , the case is much altered with Christians ; That Printing was not then known , and consequently Copies of the Bible were few , and hard to come by : Few could then read them if they had them , and therefore ( say some ) Reading the Scriptures in the Assemblies was then absolutely necessary , otherwise the generality must have been strangers to them : But now Copies of the Bible by means of Printing , are become common , and easie to be had , and most Families have some in them that can read ; And therefore the publick Reading them is not now necessary . 1. The plain Answer to this is , First , That the Reading the Scriptures publickly is an Institution of God : Therefore to lay it aside on the account of the Invention of Printing , is in effect to say , That Men have found out a better way to propagate the Knowledge of God's Word , than He instituted ; and plainly to lay aside his Command , for Mens own Inventions . 2. God has promised that there shall be always Religious Assemblies , and has commanded his Word to be read in them , which is a certain means to preserve the Knowledge thereof , as long as there is a Church ; but he has no where promised the constant commonness of Bibles , nor ability to people to read them at home . To omit therefore the Institution of God for Teaching his Word , and to rely on peoples procuring and reading Copies of the Bible privately , is to leave God's way , and presumptuously depend on that which has no Promise annexed to it . 3. How easie soever we may imagine the obtaining Copies of the Bible , and notwithstanding the number of those that can read , there are still many Families , even amongst Protestants , that can neither compass a Bible , or get any to read it , if they had one ; and therefore this Expedient is no waies sufficient to supply the Design of God's Institution , in commanding it to be read publickly . 4. Let us suppose Bibles to be as common as we can desire , and that every one can read them , yet who will secure us that they will do it ? People whilst the first Fervour of a Reformation is on them , may perhaps be diligent so long as the Scripture is a Novelty to them , or Zeal for a party inspirits them ; but when this wears off , as it generally does in a little time , we see by experience that their care of Reading and Meditating in the Scriptures decays with it ; and there are at this day too many of all Parties that neither read themselves , nor hear one Chapter read in a whole Year , except at Church . And therefore to omit the publick Reading them , on presumption that the people will do it themselves , since it is so easie for them to do it , is the ready way to introduce an Universal Ignorance of God's Word , and reduce us again to Popery ; the most effectual Bar against which , is the Bible in our own Language . 5. People may be obliged to come to the publick Congregations , and hear the Word of God read , though they have no inclination to it , and when they neglect they may be reproved or punished , but this is not practical when the Scriptures are required only to be read in private Families . Experience shews us that there is great difference between these two Methods in point of Efficacie . We see in England and Wales , where publick Reading was practised , the people generally embraced the Reformation , but in Ireland , where the same care was not taken , they rejected it . Had God's Way been taken , and the Scriptures as constantly read to the Native Irish , in a Language they understood , as it was in England or Wales , there is little doubt but the Reformation had succeeded as Universally here as it did there , but the want of this has kept them in ignorance to this day , which may convince us how ineffectual all our Contrivances are to enlighten Men , in respect of God's Institution . I am perswaded that if ever the Native Irish be brought to the Knowledge of God's Word , it must be by having it read to them publickly in a Language they understand , and not by thrusting Bibles privately into their hands ; of the ineffectualness of which , we have had an Experiment of 150 Years . 6. But lastly , Instead of all other Arguments , None of us are ignorant , that the Word of God cannot be presumed to have the same Efficacie when read privately , as it hath when read in the Assemblies of Christians , according to God's appointment : Since he has given us a peculiar promise to be present in such Assemblies . And there are no diligent Hearers of the Word Publickly read , but are able from their own experience to testify , that they often find it to have a different force and efficacy , when they hear it read , as a part of his Ordinance , in the Publick Assemblies , in which he has peculiarly promis'd his presence , than when they read it in private by themselves . The Third pretence I have found alledged for omitting the regular reading the Bible in your Meetings , is , That it takes up too much time , and is a hindrance to the more profitable Duty , of what you commonly call Preaching . 1. I intreat you to consider , That there is a time for every thing , and since God has appointed reading his Word a time and room in our Publick Assemblies , who are we , that we should presume to throw it out ? This surely is to set up our selves against God , and to think that we are able to Order things better for the Edification of his Church then he has done . Surely we ought rather to take care so to dispose our Sermons , that they may not interfere with any other Institution of God : But , that whatever time we allow them , there may remain sufficient for reading God's Holy Word ; Which I have proved is in Scripture Language Preaching ; And therefore to justle this out to make our own discourses longer , is plainly to prefer our way of Preaching to God's . If there were a necessity that one or the other must be omitted , Modesty ought to Teach us to omit our own Words rather then God's . 2. Suppose that upon some Extraordinary Occasion it may be Lawful to omit Reading God's Word in our Assemblies , that we may have the more time to manage a discourse for the Instruction of the People , yet it can never be justifiable to make this a common practise ; which is to put a manifest Contempt on the Word of God. A Fourth Pretence against reading the Scriptures publickly in a Regular Method , is , That they are hard to be understood , or applyed , and therefore only so much of them ought to be read at a time as the Minister may explain and apply to his Auditory . And that one Verse thus Applyed , is better than many Chapters read without such Application . 1. It is to be consider'd , First , That it is against the general opinion of the Reformed Churches , who universally teach that the Scriptures are plain , in all things necessary to Salvation . And therefore there is not that universal necessity of an explanation of every place of Scripture that is to be read , as is pretended . 2. The Holy Scriptures , when heard with Humility and Attention , apply themselves better then any Man can do it . The Words of them are the Words of God , and they have a plainness , force and spirit in them , which no Humane Eloquence can improve , and therefore it is a great affront to them to say that they have little efficacy except a Minister apply them . 3. Suppose one verse well applied to be better than many Chapters ( for which there is no colour ) yet this would not justifie the omission of reading them publickly ; for no Application can be so well made of them whilst people are not thoroughly acquainted with them . It ought therefore to be our first care to read them to the People often and solemnly , that they may be acquainted with the whole Body of them , and then one word of Application may do more good then many Sermons to People not so prepared with the general knowledge of them . The literal knowledge of the will of God must always go before the saving , and is the best Introduction to it . Now the reading the Law in the ears of the people is the means appointed by God to teach them that literal knowledge ; and therefore while your Teachers have laid aside this means of God's Appointment , they have in a great measure debarred people of the Spiritual and Saving knowledge of his Will. 4. Fourthly , Reading a verse or two , and trusting to the Ministers Application , without the peoples being acquainted with the whole body of the Scriptures , does put Christians too much in the power of their Teachers , and makes them liable to be seduced by them . This is the very Artifice whereby the Romish Priests keep their people in ignorance ; and your Teachers using the same Method ( while it is manifest that so great a part of their people either do not , or cannot , read them at home ) seems too like a design on their Hearers , and tempts the World to suspect that they are affraid of the naked simplicity of the Scriptures , since they dare not trust their people with Hearing them Publickly read , except they add their own glosses to them . The Fifth Pretence that I have met with for laying aside the publick reading the Word of God , is , That the dead Letter ( as some call it ) is a dull formal thing , without Spirit or Life , where it is not applied to the Souls of Men , by the Spirit of God speaking in his Ministers , and that without such Assistance the Scriptures have little Efficacy on the Heart . I hope there are few of any Communion will own this pretence , since it is so horrid a Reflection , and affront on the Word of God. I will however in answer to it offer these following Considerations . 1. That the Holy Scriptures give a Character of themselves very different from this . They represent the Word of God as the Sword of the Spirit , as quick and powerfull , as able to make a Man wise to Salvation , as giving wisdom to the simple , as Converting the Soul , with many other Expressions to denote the Efficacie thereof on the hearts of Men ; and therefore to reflect on the Word , as dull and formal , as a meer dead Letter that cannot engage the attention of the Hearers , or reach their Hearts , is too near Blasphemy . 2. We are certain that God speaks to us immediately by his Holy Spirit in his Word : And where the Spirit of God is , there is Power . But when Men speak their own Words , or pretend to apply the Words or Passages of Scripture , tho' they seem to do it with the greatest Zeal and Learning , yet they may be mistaken , nay , they may decieve us : And therefore wholly to lay aside the immediate dictates of the Holy Ghost recorded in the Scriptures for any pretended Explication or Application , made by Men , is manifestly to exchange God's undoubted Words and Command for what may be a meer Humane Invention . 3. 'T is to be considered , that the people have always been apt to grow weary of the Service of God in the way of his own appointment , and complain of it , as dull and tedious , so Mal. i. 13 . Ye said also what a weariness is it , and ye snuffed at it . And the reason is because the way of God's appointing is always more Spiritual , in respect of that which is of Man 's own Invention , and therefore it cannot be so easy or agreable to the Carnal minds of Men. 4. It ought therefore to be considered by you , when people complain of being dull , and unaffected by meer Hearing the Word of God read , whether this do not truly proceed from a Carnal and Wicked Heart estranged from the Spirit of God , and whether the reason that Sermons please and affect more then a Chapter out of the Bible be not the novelty and outward Ornaments of them , rather than the Spiritualness of the discourse . We are sure St. Paul supposeth such as are not affected with the Words of God , to be meer Natural , or Carnal Men , 1 Cor. ii . 13 . where having taken Notice of speaking , Not in Words which Man's Wisdom Teacheth , but which the Holy Ghost Teacheth , he adds , but the Natural Man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God : For they are foolishness to him , neither can he know them , for they are spiritually discerned . From whence it clearly follows , that the reason why Men do not understand or receive the things of God delivered to them in the Words of Scripture , dictated by the Holy Ghost , is , because they are meer Natural Men , and want the Spirit of God. Whoever therefore is more affected , or delights more in a Sermon then in a Chapter of the Bible , has reason to look into his Heart , and examine himself whether he have the Spirit of God. Those mentioned in Scripture that had that Spirit delighted in the Law of God : It was the joy of their Hearts ; they preferred it to all things , they meditate in it Day and Night : And were so far from turning it out of their Publick Assemblies , that the Hearing it read was a great part of their Worship . Whoever therefore lays aside this practise , have reason to suspect that they want that Temper and Spirit with which those Holy Men were inspired ; and notwithstanding all their pretences to a more then ordinary Spiritualness and Reformation , are little advanced above the Natural Men that neither receive or relish the things of God , at least not as they ought . I find it alledged as a Sixth pretence for not Reading the Word of God in your Meetings , That a Child may read them , and perform this Duty ; and then what need it take up the Ministers time . To which there needs no other answer then that the Service of God is not less his , or the less to be valued because it is easy . On the contrary 't is the more sinfull to neglect it , the more easy it is . Ministers are not set apart for difficult things only , which others cannot perform ; but they are to execute the Office that God has imposed on them , whether it be easy or difficult . As for Example . God has Commanded his Ministers to Baptise , In the Name of the Father , &c. Now to pour on Water in this Form is no such difficult thing , but a Child , or any else might perform it ; Neither is there any greater difficulty in the Sacrament of the Lord's-Supper , as to the Essentials of it . Yet I suppose it will be granted by all , that it belongs only to the Minister's Office to perform these , and that they must not delegate them , or any part of them to others , or omit them because they are easy ; And that they have a quite different Sacredness , Efficacy and Force , when performed by a Person Ordained and Authorized to this purpose , then when performed by another ; and the same Rule holds in offering up our Prayers , and in Reading the Scriptures : A Man may read them at home , a Child may read them in Church , but they have not the same assurance of Efficacy , and a blessing , as when they come from the Mouth of a Person set a-part by God's Ordinance for this purpose . I make no doubt but the Experience ( as I have said ) of most Christians , from what they have felt in their own Hearts in Hearing the Word of God publickly read , will attest the Truth of this . Now if you , my Friends , know and own this , as I hope the generality of you do , you must see the unreasonableness of this pretence . If any of you do not know it , you must give me leave to say that I fear it is from ignorance , and not considering the Scriptures . And 't is your Teachers Duty to inform you better . Reading the Scripture being allowed by their Directory to be a part of God's Publick Worship . We have this Rule there in express words , That it is requisite , that all the Canonical Books be read over in order , that the people may be better acquainted with the whole Body of Scriptures . Now if you can shew but one Meeting in the last Age , in which this has been duly performed , we will not accuse you so generally of violating God's Command in this point ; but if there be not one such Meeting , you ought to consider how you will excuse your selves before God. And I think it necessary here to observe to you how insignificant general Rules are without descending to a particular Determination of Circumstances . Here we have in your Dir●ctory a general Rule ( such as it is ) for Reading the Scripture , but for want of being particular , as the Calender in our Common-Prayer-Book is , I question if it yet was ever once observed , or indeed that it is Practical to observe it . And it is so almost in every other general Rule , and therefore to leave the Service of God to be Ordered by such general Rules only , is in effect to Teach people to neglect it . V. These are all the Reasons that I can possibly think of , or have heard urged for Your practice in this point . I will not say but others may be pretended , but I must profess that I do not remember to have met with them ; if I had , I would have given them a due consideration : I am perswaded that they cannot be of greater force than those I have examined . And that they can never excuse You in this matter , from manifest breach of God's Command , in preferring Mens Inventions to his Institutions . After all , I must profess to You , That I look on all these to be only Pretences ; and that the true Reason of Mens Negligence in this Duty , is given us , 2 Tim. iv . 3 . For the time will come , ( saith the Apostle ) when they will not endure sound Doctrine ; but after their own Lusts shall they heap up to themselves Teachers , having itching Ears . An itching Ear here , can signifie nothing so properly , as an Ear that loves Novelty and Variety : Because therefore our Church gives the people little that is New , in her Prayers , or Reading the Scriptures , but retains a Form of sound Words in the one , and the plain Word of God in the other ; Hence it is that some people cannot endure our Service , but heap up to themselves Teachers , that instead of the Praises , Prayers and Sermons of God's immediate Appointment , will gratifie them every Meeting with a New Prayer , without troubling them with such Prayers or Sermons as they think old , which are incomparably better , only the itching Ears of the People , as the Apostle fore-told , are pleased with the Novelty and Variety of the one , and disgust the Repetition of the other , as the Israelites did that of Angels Food , Psa. lxxviii . 25 Num. xxi . 5 . & xi . 6 It is the Duty of all Ministers , and the business of the truly Conscientious to check and curb this Humour in the People ; and notwithstanding all Discouragements , the Ministers of Our Church , instead of complying with them , have constantly reproved them for their Negligence and Levity , where they found them guilty . But as Aaron , to please the Israelites , made the Golden Calf , so some Ministers ( tho' contrary to their own Principles ) have changed God's Institution to please their people ; and lest out the constant and regular Reading of God's Word , because their people grew weary of it . But let all Men judge who behave themselves most like the Ministers of Christ ; We , who keep to the Reading God's Word , according to His own Institution , whether the people will hear or forbear , or They that comply with them , and lay aside God's Command to oblige and gain them . CHAP. IV. Of Bodily Worship . Sect. 1. What the Holy Scriptures prescribe concerning it . I. THe Fourth part of the Publick Worship of God , or Design of Religious Assemblies , is Visible or Bodily Adoration ; such amongst us are Vncovering the Head , Bowing , Kneeling , and other Outward Signs of Reverence and Submission ; by which we openly acknowledge the Mercy , the Justice , and Power of God , and express the inward sense we have of these Attributes . In treating of this Head , I will keep my self to the same Method , as in the former , and consider , First , The Rules and Examples that the Scriptures afford us for the performance of this Duty . Secondly , Compare the Practise of Our Church with them . Thirdly , Examine the Dissenters Practise , and the Reasons they alledge for it . 1. As to the first of these we find a Positive Command of God for Bodily Worship in Publick , Psal. xcv . 6 . O come let us Worship and bow down , let us kneel before the Lord our Maker . The second Verse of this Psalm plainly shews us that this is meant of Publick Worship : Let us come before his presence with Thanksgiving . And that this bowing or kneeling is to be interpreted , literally , not figuratively , appears from the same Verses , where Singing , Thanksgiving and Psalms , are all litterally to be understood ; and there is no more reason for understanding bowing and kneeling in a figurative sence , than the other . II. The same Bodily Worship is required by the Second Commandment , which forbids us to bow down to a graven Image , by which words we are commanded to bow down to God ; for it is confessed by all , and laid down as a Rule by the Assembly's larger Catechism , That the Negative Commandments include in them the contrary Positive ; that is to say , When a Commandment forbids us any thing , it requires us to perform the Duty contrary to what is forbidden . As for Example : When the first Commandment forbids us to have any other Gods before the Lord , it requires us to own and worship Him for our only God ; and after the same manner all other Commands are to be interpreted . By which Rule , when the Second Commandment , Exod. xx . 5 . forbids us in these words , Thou shalt not bow down to them , nor serve them , it requires us to practice the contrary Duties in our Addresses to God. To bow down to Him and serve Him , that is , to worship Him both with the worship of our Bodies and Minds : Therefore as he that either bows or kneels , or uses any posture of Reverence to a graven Image , breaks the second Commandment ; so doth he who on occasion of Publick Worship either refuses or neglects to use some such posture to God. It being a Contempt of God , and contrary to His Commands , to pray to Him , for instance , without some posture of Adoration to Him , when we can do it , as well as it is a sin to kneel to an Image , without praying to it , which the Papists pretend to do ; the one is Idolatry , and the other Sacriledge : For the Reason why we are not to bow down to an Idol , is , Because 't is an Act of Worship due to God. And whether we give what is due to Him to an Image , or refuse to pay it to Himself , we are equally Robbers of God , we deny him his Honour , and are guilty of Sacriledge . I wish all concerned may seriously consider , and amend their practise in this particular . III. But the practise of Holy Men , and of the Church of God in Scripture , are the best Interpreters of God's Commands ; and from them we may learn what he requires or approves in his Worship . Now through the whole Old Testament , we shall never find any one sitting at his Devotions : But on all occasions of Worship , especially in Publick Assemblies , the people of God stood , kneeled , bowed , or prostrated themselves . 'T is said indeed , 2 Sam. vii . 8 . That King David then went and sat before the Lord : But here the Original Word is capable of another signification , and may as well be translated , that he remained , stayed , or abode before the Lord ; and accordingly it is thus translated in other places of Scripture , particularly Gen. xxii . 5 . & xxiv . 55 . & xxix . 19 . 1 Kings xii . 2 . This place therefore is no Exception against that practise which is so evident through the whole Old Testament , that Holy Men worshiped God with their Bodies as well as with their Minds . IV. We shall find the same practised by our Saviour and his Apostles in the New T. Our Saviour undoubtedly is the Best Example we can propose to our selves for the worship of God , and we ought to imitate what he did and approved . Now if we consider the worship he offered to his Father , we shall find him addressing himself to him with bowing the Body , with Kneeling and Prostration , as well as with strong Cries and Tears ; so Mat. xxvi . 39 . And he went a little further , and fell on his Face , and prayed , O my Father , &c. and Luk. xxii . 41 . He kneeled down and prayed . And as he paid this Bodily Worship to God , so he accepted the same from Men when he was on Earth : Thus the Wise Men worshiped him in his Cradle , Mat. ii . 11 . When they saw the young Child and his Mother Mary , they fell down , &c. Thus they that desired to be Cured by him , addressed themselves to him , Mark v. 22 . VVhen he saw him , he fell at his Feet , and besought , &c. And after the same manner those who were Cured by him returned him Thanks , Luke xvii . 16 . Thus his beloved Mary came into his presence , John xi . 32 . And Matth. xxviii . 9 . They held him by the Feet and worshiped him . Our Saviour looked on this Bodily Worship to be so indispensibly his due , that he accepted of it from the very Devils , and they durst not forbear to pay it to him , Mark iii. 11 . And unclean spirits , when they saw him , fell down before him , and cried , Thou art the Son of God. And thus the very Heathen , as well as his Disciples , approached him , even whilst he was in his state of Humiliation . And that we may not be tempted to think , that our Saviour admitted this Bodily Worship to be paid him only whilst he was Bodily present , we may observe St. Stephen presents his Prayer with the same posture , Acts , vii . 60 . He kneeled down and cryed with a loud voice , Lord lay not this sin to their charge . V. The Scriptures represent to us the First Christians thus glorifying God with their Bodies , ( as St. Paul expresly commands us 1 Cor. vi . 20 ) in the Publick Assemblies , as we may learn from 1 Cor. xiv . 23 . where the Apostle speaking of a Heathen coming into the Assembly of Christians , and being convinced , addeth , and so falling down on his face he will Worship God. If it had not been the custom for Christians to do thus , it would never have been expected from a Heathen , or reckoned an Argument of his Conviction . If the Church Triumphant in Heaven may be allowed a fit Pattern to us of what is decent in the Worship of God , we find them paying this Bodily Worship to God , Rev. vii . 11 . And all the Angels stood about the Throne , and about the Elders , and about the Beasts , and fell on their faces before the Throne , and Worshiped God , so Chap. iv . 10 . and Chap. xix . 4 . And the same we find practised by the Church on Earth , Acts xxi 5. where St. Paul , and the Church of Tyre kneeled down on the Shore and prayed . After the same manner he took his leave of the Elders of Ephesus , Act. xx . 36 . He kneeled down and prayed with them all . So constantly are Bodily Worship and Prayer joined together , that bowing the knee , sometimes signifies , Prayer , Eph. iii. 14 . For this cause I bow my knees unto the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ. VI. The Scriptures represent this Bodily Worship as the most proper external Act of Adoration : If we look into the Scriptures we shall not find Praying , Praising , Reading the Scriptures , or Administring the Sacraments , termed Worship ; they are indeed Duties which we are obliged to perform to the Honour of God , but not immediate direct Acts of Worship , properly so called : For Worship is properly the subjection of our minds to God ; and that is a proper Act of External Worship , which directly signifies this subjection or submission of our minds ; But Prayer signifies our desires of good things from God , and only indirectly our subjection to him ; Praises immediately signify the sense we have of God's Excellencies , and only by consequence our submission ; Reading the Scriptures is a means of Instruction , and tends to bring us to submit to God , but does not directly express it ; And the Sacraments primarily signifie God's grace to us rather then our submission to Him. All these may in a large sense , upon very good grounds , be look'd upon as parts of Worship , because they do imply such submission ; but bending or bowing the Body is that which is properly in Scripture called Worship , as signifying immediately and naturally the bending and submission of our Souls , and nothing else . In the Old Testament the words rendered Worship ▪ signifie properly and originally to bow down or prostrate the Body . This is the proper signification of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 and of 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 the latter of which in the Second Commandment is render'd to bow down , and very often when the Original has they bowed down themselves , the Translators render it they Worshiped . So Psal. xcv . 5 . and Jer. i. 16 . And Worshiped the work of their own hands . In the Original 't is They bowed themselves down to the work , &c. Gen. xxiv . 52 . He worshiped the Lord bowing himself to the Earth . The Original has no more but He bowed himself to the Earth to the Lord , so Psal. xcv . 5 . And the same holds generally through the whole Old Testament , from whence it follows that in the opinion of our Translators , to bow ones self to the Earth , is that proper Act which they call Worship . And hence the whole Worship of God is signified by bowing before him , Micah vi . 6 . Wherewith shall I come before the Lord , and bow my self before the High God ? that is , How shall I worship him acceptably ? As to the New Testament , the Word generally there rendered Worship , properly signifies a Bodily Action 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 is Originally to pay Homage by a kiss , as we now kiss the King's Hand , which usually was done kneeling ; And hence Kneeling and Worshiping signify the same thing in the New Testament , and the one is put for the other . Thus Matt. viii . 2 . There came a Leper and worshiped him . The same is said ( Mark i. 40 . ) to come beseeching him and kneeling to him . Of the Canaanitish Woman it is said ( Matt. xv . 25 . ) That She came and worshiped him . And Mark says ( Chap. vii . 25 . ) She came and fell at his feet . Luke says of the Man among the Tombs , that he fell down before him ( Chap. viii . 28 . ) Mark , that He worshiped him , ( Chap. v. 6 . ) Of Jairus , Mark and Luke say , that He fell down at his feet . Mathew , that He worshiped him . Luke viii . 40 . Mark v. 22 . Math. ix . 18 . So promiscuously do the Evangelists use the words kneeling , or falling down , and worshiping , to signify the same thing . Whence we may learn that when any is said to Worship Christ visibly , by it is meant they kneeled to him . And when we are Commanded to Worship God in the Congregation , the meaning is , that we are required to express the submission of our minds by bowing our selves , or kneeling unto him . Hence the very Soldiers , that in derision bowed their knees to Christ , are said to Worship him , Mark xv . 19 . And St. John , Rev. xxii . 8 . when he would Worship the Angel , fell before his feet , to which the Angel replied , See thou do it not — Worship God : From which Text it clearly follows , that falling down is an Act of Worship , and that we are Commanded by the Mouth of an Angel to pay it to God. VII . We find in Scripture some Act of this Bodily Worship accompanying every Religious Performance . Thus Prayers are generally offered with kneeling , and that so constantly ( as is observed before ) that to bow the knee , in Scripture-Language , is to pray . Thus Praises , Thanksgivings , and Confessions of Faith , are offered standing , 1 King. viii . 14 . And the King turned his face about , and blessed all the Congregation of Israel ( and all the Congregation of Israel stood ) and he said , Blessed be the Lord , &c. the same posture is observed , Ver. 55. 2 Chron. xx . 19 . And the Levites — stood up to praise the Lord God of Israel with a loud voice , 2 Chron. xxix . 26 . Neh. x. 40 . And this was not a voluntary act , but imposed on the people , as appears from Neh. ix . 5 . Then the Levites — said , Stand up and bless the Lord your God , &c. In conformity to which , the Saints and Angels in Heaven are represented to us thus praising God , Rev. vii . 9 . They stood before the Throne , and before the Lamb — and cried with a loud Voice , saying , Salvation , &c. At Reading the holy Scriptures , both Reader and People used the same posture , as appears from Neh. viii . 4 , 5. And Ezra the Scribe stood on a Pulpit of Wood — And Ezra opened the Book , and all the People stood up . And Chap. ix . 3 . And they stood up in their place , and read in the Book : Which our Saviour likewise observed , Luke iv . 16 . Lastly , They offered their Sacrifices with Bodily Adoration , 2 Chron. xxix . 27 . And when the Burnt Offerings began , the Song of the Lord began also — And all the Congregation worshiped , and the Singers sang , and the Trumpets sounded ; and all this continued until the Burnt Offering was finished . The word , as was observed , here rendred Worshiped , signifies literally they bowed themselves down , and the meaning is , They continued prostrate , or kneeling , whilst the Burnt Offering was offered . Thus in every Religious Performance , the Scripture has taken particular notice and Recorded to us , with what Acts of Bodily Worship it was offered up unto God. Sect. 2. The Practice of Our Church in Bodily Worship . LEt us in next place compare our own Practise with this Representation , and see how we perform this part of Visible Worship in our Church . I. First then , when we come into the Publick Assemblies , we believe our selves to come into Christs presence ; because he has promised Mat. xviii . 21 . Where two or three are gathered together in My Name , there am I in the midst of them : And therefore in Obedience to the Commands of God in Scripture , 'T is our Custom to lift up our hearts to Him in Prayer , and bow our Bodies before Him : This bowing our Bodies when we come into the Assembly of Christians met together in Christs Name , and for his Service ; which tho' it be not enjoyned by any Constitution of our Church , is generally practis'd by good people , as very decent in it self , and edifying to others . Our bowing our Bodies therefore at our coming into a Christian Assembly for Worship , is only to pay that Bodily Worship to God that He requires from us when we come into his peculiar presence , which presence He has promised in such Assemblies . Some indeed are so weak as to term our thus worshiping God , a bowing to the Altar : whereas our Church expresly declaring against any Adoration to be paid to the Consecrated Bread and Wine , does much deelare against doing it to the Altar . II. Vncovering the Head is a Mark of Respect among us ; and therefore we continue Uncovered whilst the Assembly lasts ; that is , whilst we are in Christs presence . The custom of the Eastern Church was to Vncover their Feet in the presence of God ; so Moses and Joshua were commanded to do ; ( to which Solomon alludes , Eccles. v. 1 . ) This was easily practised with them , because they wore nothing on their Feet but loose Shoes and Sandals , which were readily slipt off ; And this continued till our Saviour's time , as appears by their washing their Feet when they came into Houses , Luke vii . 44 . Vncovering the Head is the same common mark of respect with us now , as uncovering the Feet was with them in their time ; and this uncovering the Feet being neither practicable with us , nor any note of respect among us , but rather the contrary , Our Church has requir'd us instead of it , to uncover our Heads , Can. vii . For the justification of this practise , give me leave to digress so far as to explain one passage in the New Testament , which seems to require that a Man should have his Head uncovered in the presence of God , not as a note of respect , but of Priviledge , 1 Cor. xi . 7 . For a Man indeed ought not to cover his Head , forasmuch as he is the Image and Glory of God ; but the Woman is the Glory of the Man. Which passage does not primarily relate to the covering the Head , but the Face , by a Vail , according to the Custom of the Eastern Countries : and this covering the face , was a note of respect , as the contrary was a note of Priviledge : So we find that when Rebecca was to appear before her Husband ( Gen. xxiv . 65 . ) She took a Vail and covered her self . So ( Exod. iii. 6 . ) Moses hid his face , for he was afraid to look upon God ; and Elijah wrapped his face in his Mantle when he went out to meet God , 1 Kings xix . 13 . On the same Account the Seraphins cover their faces with their Wings , Is. vi . 2 . 'T is therefore a peculiar Priviledge and favour to be allowed to appear before God uncover'd , and it is reckon'd as such , 2 Cor. iii. 18 . but we all with open face beholding as in a glass the glory of the Lord , &c. Those that were out of favour might not appear bare-faced before their Prince , but with their Heads covered , as Haman was when the King signified his displeasure against him . Ester vii . 8 . Now for the understanding of the before cited place , we must consider that Man being the Image and Glory of God , is allowed to take this Confidence before God , which is denied to Women : For since God was pleased to make Man his Image and Glory , it is not fit that this his glory should be covered before him : but on the other hand , it is fit that Man's glory , which is Woman , should be covered before God. This I conceive is the full meaning of this place , and has no relation to the manner of uncovering the of Head in use with us now ; which is only a mark of civil respect , and that peculiar to Men , and not to Women . But however being an honour paid to Men , there is no reason why it should not be paid to God : On the contrary it seems to be required by the Apostles general Injunction , Let all things be done decently . And it is one of the Articles of our Church , That the Church has power to order Rites and Ceremonies ; that is , to determine what particular things come under the Apostles general word of Decency . 3. We stand up at our Praisings , Thanksgivings , and Confessions of Faith , in Conformity to the Examples of Holy Scripture . 4. At our Confessions of Sin , and at our Prayers , we present our selves before God on our knees , by order of our Church , according to the Example of our Saviour , and the Church of God. III. We Celebrate the Holy Sacrament of the Body and Blood of Christ in a Worshiping posture . I know that many except against this . It would engage me in a longer discourse to examine it fully ; perhaps God may hereafter give me an Opportunity to discuss it at large , at present I shall only hint at the Scripture-Grounds we have for it , by the following deduction . 1. The Altar was of Old the Lord's Table , from whence his Attendants were fed , Mal. i. 7 . Ye offer polluted Bread upon mine Altar , and ye say , Wherein have we polluted thee ? In that ye say , The Table of the Lord is contemptible . 2. On this account the Israelites came to the Altar , and worshiped before it , as being God's Table , on which the Sacrifice was presented , as his Meat , of which they were permitted to partake : So 2 Chron. vi . 12 . And he stood before the Altar of the Lord — vers . 13. And kneeled down on his knees . And 1 Kings viii . 54 . He arose from before the Altar , from kneeling on his knees . Nor can it be said ; That this kneeling of Solomon was only because he offered up a Prayer at that time , and that therefore he was in a praying posture ; for undoubtedly it was the Duty of all that were present at any Sacrifice , to offer up prayers to God with the Sacrifice : And accordingly we find it commanded 2 Kings xviii·22 . Ye shall worship before this Altar in Jerusalem ; literally , Ye shall bow down your selves . 3. The Communion-Table is called the Lord's-Table , 1 Cor. x. 21 . 4. The Israelites partaking of the Altar is proposed as an Example for our partaking of the Lord's Table , 1 Cor. x. 16 . The Cup of Blessing which we bless , is it not the Communion of the Blood of Christ ? The Bread which we break , is it not the Communion of the Body of Christ — vers . 18. Behold Israel after the Flesh : Are not they which eat of the Sacrifices partakers of the Altar ? 5. In allusion to this Religious Eating with Bodily Worship , it is Prophecied of our Saviour , Psal. xxii . 29 . All they that be fat upon Earth ( that is , the favoured and happy Servants of God here ; called in vers . 26. The meek ) shall eat and Worship . Since then the Scripture sets forth to us a Relious Eating at the Lords-Table with Worship , and the Holy Communion is such an Eating at his Table , it follows that the Scripture Warrants our Worshiping when we Eat . 2. We are Commanded in Scripture to receive the Holy Eucharist In remembrance of Christ's death , and by it we shew his death till he come . The same Scriptures Command us to Worship our Saviour : For he is the Lord , and Worship thou him . Psal. xlv . 11 . If ever then we are to Worship our Saviour , it is certainly when we come to him in the nearest approaches that we are capable of in this World , and with the highest sense of Gratitude that our Souls can admit of ; to remember and adore him for the greatest Act of love that could be extended towards us , even laying down his Life for us , and partake of the benefits thereof by feeding on him . If it be not our duty to Worship him with our Bodies , as well as our Minds , on this occasion , it is hard to say when we are obliged to do it . This consideration prevail'd with the Protestant Church of Poland , to oblige all their Members to receive kneeling or standing , in Opposition to the Socinians , who refused to pay any Worship to our Saviour ; and therefore Celebrated his Supper sitting . The Words of their General Synod are these . ( Corpus Confession . p. 236. ) Quod attinet ad Caeremonias , &c. As to the Ceremonies of the Lord's-Supper , the Decree some time ago discust in the Synod of Sandomir , and the Conclusion made and repeated in the General Synod of Cracow and Petrokow , is also approved in this Session of the Synod of Vladislaw , vizt . That sitting at the Lord's-Table shall not be used in any of the Churches of Poland or Lithuania , &c. of our Communion : For this Ceremony ( tho' indifferent as others are ) is not used by the Christian and Reformed Churches ; and is proper to the Infidel Arrians only , who place themselves in an equal Throne with the Lord. Since then sitting has crept into some of our Churches , chiefly by the occasion and countenance of those who have miserably fallen from us , and denied the Lord that bought us , We intreat and exhort all those Congregations , and our Brethren in the Lord , that they would change sitting into the Ceremonies used by us Protestants in all the Reformed Churches of Europe , even that the Lord's Supper may be administred to the Communicants standing or kneeling ( with a protestation against Bread-Worship used by the Papists ) both which Rites ( as they have been hitherto used in some Churches ) we leave free , and approve ; without blaming or giving offence to those who use either . This Synod was held June 19 th : 1583. The Synod of Petrokow above mentioned ( held June 1.2.3 . 1578. pa. 234. ) expresses it self in these words . Because those Traiterous Fugitives from us to Arianism , who change all things in the Church , pretending to imitate Christ without discretion , were the first Authors amongst us of sitting at the Lord's Table , contrary to the Rites used in all the Reformed Churches through Europe . Therefore we reject this Ceremony , as proper to them who treat as well Christ as his Sacraments irreverently , as indecent and irreligious , and very offensive to well meaning people . It ought to be observed , that this Church reckons Sitting a Ceremony ; and a Ceremony of an ill signification and Original ; and not used by any Protestant Church in their time . IV. But I find most people acknowledge the reasonableness of this , and grant if it were left to us how we wou'd Receive , that we ought to do it with Adoration , but , say they , Obedience is better then Sacrifice ; we are commanded to do what Christ did , and he Instituted , and his Disciples received it , in a Table posture , and therefore so ought we . Notwithstanding the Scriptures , Reason , and Decency seem to recommend another posture to us . Now to this Argument , which is the only one I find brought from Scripture , and which seems to prevail with most . I answer , 1. That we are not required , nor is it convenient to imitate all that Christ did . Neither the time , nor the number of Receivers , nor the posture being obligatory to us , as appears from St. Paul , 1 Cor xi 23. who having occasion to mention what he received of the Lord concerning this Sacrament , mentions only our Saviour's taking Bread , giving thanks , and breaking it , and then saying , Take eat , this is my Body , &c. without the circumstances of the number of Receivers , his posture , or being at supper . Nay , that we may not think that this had any relation to a common supper , or the circumstances of it , he observes that Supper was done when he took the Cup. Our Saviour's posture therefore , whatever it was , is no wise obligatory to us , it not being any part of what St. Paul professes to have received from Christ concerning this Sacrament . 2. I have already proved that Religious Eating was accompanied with Bodily Worship , and therefore if it were granted that we were obliged to receive this Sacrament in a Table posture from the example of our Saviour , yet it would not follow that we should not receive it kneeling . 'T is certain our Saviour did not sit , but lie at Table when he did eat his usual Meals . Suppose then he had obliged us to his posture of Eating , we ought to lie as he did , but none assert the necessity of our doing so , or practise this way . Since then all Parties change it , sure we do better that change it into the Religious way of Eating , recommended to us in the Scriptures , with Adoration , then others that change our Saviour's way into sitting , the common way of our Eating . 3. We have this further to say for our practise , That our Saviour was not at a common supper when he Instituted this Sacrament , but at the Passover , which was a Sacramental Eating , and had a peculiar posture prescribed for it , Ex. xii . 11 . and tho' some think ( but without warrant from Scripture ) that the Jews did not observe this , yet it is owned they observed another , which differed from the common posture of Eating , and was reckoned Religious : However 't is spoken that our Saviour performed this Eating with several Religious Ceremonies that were not in the first Institution . Such is that we find , Luke xxii . 17 . And He took the Cup , and gave thanks , and said , Take this and divide it among your selves . This Cup is different from the Sacramental Cup , which is Instituted vers . 20. and therefore if we would imitate Christ , we ought to Eat the Lord's - Supper in a way peculiar to it self , and different from our common Meals . 4 But fourthly , The full Answer to the Argument is , That it goes on a false Supposition that our Saviour instituted this Sacrament in the common posture of Eating ; which no wise appears in Scripture , neither can it be inferred from any thing said or intimated by the Evangelists , or St. Paul , but rather the contrary . It is true , whilst the Disciples were Eating , he took Bread , but after that he gave thanks and blessed it , and then he brake it , and gave it to them ; and it is not to be supposed that the Disciples continued Eating , whilst our Saviour was giving thanks and blessing ; that is , praying . Our Saviour therefore , or his Disciples , were not Eating , but giving thanks and praying , whilst this Sacrament was instituted ; and therefore it was proper to be done ( and in probability was done by our Saviour ) in a thanksgiving and praying posture ; neither was there any necessity to take notice of this change of posture , since the change of the Action , from Eating to Thanksgiving and Blessing , sufficiently signifies and infers it . There is no Notice taken of our Saviour's rising at all from the Table , by any of the three Evangelists that deliver to us the Institution of the Sacrament ; and yet it is plain from John xiii . 4 . that he did rise from that Supper , and washed his Disciples Feet , and sat down again , Vers. 12. and so he might rise to bless and distribute the holy Sacrament : And therefore we have no assurance from Scripture that our Saviour instituted this Sacrament in a common Table-posture , rather the contrary seems probable . So that He has left us at liberty to follow the general Rules of Decency and Reason , and what the Scriptures represent to us as fit , and practised in the like cases . Lastly , We find the Apostle severely reproving the Corinthians , for their Irreverence in Receiving this Sacrament , and threatning them with Damnation , for not discerning the Lords Body ; that is , for receiving it as their common Food , without distinguishing between them by a Reverend and Religious Receiving it : And sure it is but a due distinction between It and our common Food , to Approach the Lord's Table with as much Reverence as the Jews did their Altar , at which they never sat down . Upon the whole , I think we do nothing in this , or any other sacred Action , as to Bodily Worship , but what is warranted and grounded on the Holy Scriptures , and particularly as to what we do at the Holy Sacrament of the Lord's Supper : It is as unjust to suspect or accuse us of worshiping the Lord's Table , or the Elements of Bread and Wine , because we receive them kneeling ; as it were to accuse the Jews of worshiping their Altar or Sacrifices , because they worshiped before them , as God commanded them to do , 2 Kings xviii . 22 . I beseech God to give us true Submission and Humility of Heart ; for the Outward Expressions of these Inward Dispositions of Mind which our Church has appointed by Bodily Worship , are certainly such as God has approved , and holy Men have practised in Scripture . Sect. 3. The Practice of the Dissenters in Bodily Worship . I. AND now , I come to you , my Friends , who Dissent from Us , to consider how You perform This Part of God's Worship , and to compare Your Principles and Practice with what I have represented from the Holy Scriptures . And first as to Your Principles : I need not tell you , That you do not allow Bodily Adoration to be any part of God's Worship , which you cannot but discern to be Plainly contrary to the Holy Scriptures , that make it the most proper peculiar Act thereof , as I have shewed before , Chap. IV. Sect. 1. N o. 1.2.3 . In your Confession of Faith , Chap. 21. Prayer , Reading , Scriptures , &c. singing Psalms , Administration of the Sacraments , are reckon'd up as parts of Religious Worship , but not a word concerning the worship of the Body . Your Directory doth not only leave it out , but excludes it , by requiring all to enter the Assembly , and to take their Seats and Places without Adoration or bowing themselves towards one Place or other , that is , without bowing themselves at all ; A Rule directly opposite to Natural Reason , as well as to the Commands of God , and to the Examples of his Saints : And 't is unconceivable how it should be laid down by a Society of Men that professed to believe Christ peculiarly present in their Assemblies ; which yet the Authors of your Directory profess to do in that very place where they forbid all Adoration : Let us then , I pray you , compare their Rule with Gods Word ; You have the Bible in your hands , and you look upon it to be your Priviledge to use it : The Scriptures say , O come , let us worship , let us bow down , let us kneel before the Lord our Maker . Your Directory says , Let us enter the Assembly without Adoration or bowing : Where notwithstanding it allows that we in a special manner appear in God's presence . Surely you cannot but see this is not only to lay aside , but to contradict the Rules of Scripture . II. Your Practice is conformable to your Principles : For , 1. At your Thanksgivings or Praises , you neither bow nor stand up . 2. Whereas We , and the Churches of God in all Ages , have used to stand up at the solemn Confessions of Faith , you have cast out of your Religious Assemblies not only this Act of Worship , but the Confessions of Faith themselves ; so material a part of the service of God , as appears from Rom. x. 9 , 10. If thou shalt confess with thy Mouth the Lord Jesus , and shalt believe in thine Heart that God hath raised Him from the Dead , thou shalt be saved : For with the Heart Man believes unto Righteousness , and with the Mouth Confession is made unto salvation . To profess solemnly that we expect no Happiness but from the good pleasure of God , and that we freely acquiesce in his Provisions for us , is no small Evidence of the submission of our Minds to God ; and upon that account may be reckoned an Instance of External Worship , and accordingly many of the Psalms contain such Confessions . 3. You sit generally at your Publick Prayers . 4. At the holy Sacrament you sit , not only whilst you Receive , but likewise at the Thanksgiving and Blessing before ; and your Directory imposes this posture on Communicants , tho' contrary to Holy Scripture , in respect of that part that concerns the Prayer and Thanksgiving ; and without any Command , or so much as Example from Scripture , in respect of the sitting at the time of Receiving . 5. Too many of your perswasion condemn us , who conform to God's Word in these particulars , as guilty of Superstition ; and endeavour to render our Conformity ridiculous ; not being content to lay aside the Commands of God themselves , but endeavouring likewise to condemn and scoff at the Observation of them in Vs. In short , I entreat you to consider , That you have not any one Visible Act of Adoration amongst you in your Assemblies , except we reckon in this Number , That your Men Vncover their Heads at Prayer ; and yet even this is not required by your Directory . III. And now let me a while Examine calmly with you , the Pretences I have met with for laying aside this part of God's Worship ; for it is not probable that any would banish Adoration out of their Assemblies , and alledge no Reason for their doing so . 1. First therefore , I find that place of Scripture produced to this purpose , John iv . 24 . God is a Spirit , and they that worship Him must worship Him in Spirit and in Truth . Some think that all Bodily Worship is here forbidden , and that only the Worship of the Spirit or Mind is required of us under the Gospel : Upon this , some have declared against all Churches , or separate places for Worship ; Others are against all Bodily VVorship ; Others against all Sacraments , ; Others against all Vocal Prayers , Praises , and Thanksgivings ; And even in the Apostle's time , some were against all Visible Assemblies . And indeed , if we understand this place as some do , that all Bodily Worship is excluded by it , and that it is sufficient to Worship God in our Spirits or Minds only , I do not see but all these are in the right ; and those who pretend to be above Ordinances , and worship God no-where , are most conformable to this Rule ; and next to them , the silent Meetings of the Quakers , without Sacraments , without Vocal Prayers or Praises , are the most spiritual service . For if other Dissenters think Bodily Worship , such as Bowing , Kneeling , &c. Unlawful or Unnecessary , because they are Acts of the Body , and unfit on that account to be offered to God , who is a Spirit , why may not the Quakers omit the Sacraments , and the Words of the Mouth , which are Outward Things as well as the other ? Nay , why should not outward Teaching or Preaching cease ? Since the Spirit is a sufficient Teacher , and has promised us , Heb. viii . 10 . I will put my Laws into their Minds , and write them in their Hearts — Vers. 11. And they shall not teach every Man his Neighbour , and every Man his Brother , &c. The Principle and Reasoning is the same in all these , and will justifie the Silent Meetings of the Quakers , nay the Extravagance of Those that pretend to be above all Ordinances , as well as the Irreverence of other Dissenters . But we ought to interpret Scripture so as one place may not contradict another ; and since the Holy Scriptures shew us , that God requires our Vocal Prayers and Praises , our Visible Sacraments and Adoration , we ought not to interpret worshiping in the Spirit so as to exclude these , but rather conclude that they may be offered up to God in such a manner as to become proper for spiritual VVorship , or God would never have required them . When therefore our Saviour represents the Worship He taught the World , as a Worship in Spirit and Truth , his meaning doubtless is not to exempt us from worshiping his Father with our Bodies , whereof He Himself has given us an Example ; but to teach us , That the Outward Acts of Worship that we pay to God , are only Acceptable to Him , when they proceed from , and are accompanied with a hearty submission of our Souls ; and that every Act is more or less Acceptable , as it has more or less of our Hearts and Affections in it : But that Circumstances of place , and the like , give us no Advantage , and are of no value towards making our Worship Acceptable . This meaning of the words directly answers our Saviour's design , which was to shew the Samaritan Woman that the time was coming that the Worship offered to God under the Gospel would be nothing more acceptable for being offered at Jerusalem , or Mount-Gerezim , or any other place ; But the Heart being right , all places were alike . Which was directly contrary to the Jewish Law , that allowed no Sacrifice or Oblation to be acceptable to God , that was not offered at the Temple , and consequently their Worship derived its acceptance from the place , and not from the Heart alone of him that offered it . We affirm therefore , as our Saviour has here taught us , that it is only from the Heart , or Spirit , that our Worship becomes acceptable to God , and that the time or place where it is offered contributes nothing to our acceptance : But that in whatever place , at whatever time , in whatsoever posture we offer up our Spirits and Hearts to God , we are accepted by him . But then we say likewise , a Man who neglects the Assemblies of Christians , cannot have a good Heart towards God , because he breaks his Command ; that such as do not take care to provide a convenient and decent place , and set it apart for Christians to meet , and to perform God's Worship in , cannot have a value for it ; that such as neglect the Holy Sacraments , want Faith in His promises , as well as Obedience to His Commands ; and that those who neglect to Worship him with their Body , and to pay outward Reverence and Adoration when they come into his presence , must want inward submission of their minds , because they do not approach as he requires . If a Man truly Worship God in his Spirit , it will oblige him , if able , to perform these outward Acts ; and if he be not able , God doth not require them . It is in this , as in Faith , Jam. ii . 18 . A Man may say , Thou hast Faith , and I have Works : Shew me thy Faith without thy Works , and I will shew thee my Faith by my Works . After the same manner a Man may say , Thou Worshipest God inwardly in Heart and Spirit , and I Worship him outwardly , and in the face of the Church with my Body . Shew me thy inward Worship without bowing , kneeling , or other Bodily act of Worship , and I will shew thee my inward Worship , and dread of God's Majesty by the worship of my Body . From all which it is manifest , that our Obligation to worship God in Spirit and Truth , doth no more exclude Bodily Worship , then Faith does exclude Works . 2. The second pretence I have heard for banishing of Bodily Adoration is much like the first . It is alledged , That God has no value for it , and that if our Hearts are humble and right with God , no matter whether we signify it by outward acts of Adoration or no. But to this I answer , 1. That God himself is the best Judge of what befits His Majesty , and 't is a sure sign that He valueth a thing when he requires it ; since therefore he has Commanded us to render him this Bodily Worship ; for us to alledge , That He doth not value it , is too like setting up our own Wisdom above His. 2. The Words of our Prayers , or Praises , and all the Fruits of our Lips , are outward things , as well as the gestures of our Bodies , and God values them as little as our prostrating our Bodies before him , when the Heart goes not along with them , as appears from Is. i. where he shews his Abhorrence , not only of Sacrifices , Feasts and spreading forth hands , but likewise of Prayers , vers . 4. And Mark vii . 6 . This People honoureth me with their Lips , but their Heart is far from me , howbeit in vain do they Worship me , &c. Yet to throw Vocal Prayers and Praises out of the service of God , were absolutely to destroy His Visible Worship ; and after the same manner to throw out all Outward signs of Reverence , such as kneeling , &c. is a fair step to it . For the same God that has sworn , That every Tongue shall confess unto him , has likewise sworn , That every knee shall bow unto him , Rom. xiv . 11 . Both therefore are alike required in the Worship of God , and both alike insignificant when separated from the sincere concurrence of our Hearts . When the Meditations of our Hearts go along with the words of our Mouths , they are acceptable to God ; and when the submission of our Souls goes along with the Worship of our Bodies , it is grateful to him , and valuable in his sight , as all other acts of Obedience are . 3. Tho' Bodily Worship in it self were a small thing , yet the omission of it may be a great and Crying sin , and a great Contempt of Almighty God. Thus eating the forbidden Fruit was in it self a very inconsiderable Outward Action , and yet being forbidden , is was the Ruine of all Mankind . Thus the washing a Man with Water , In the Name of the Father , Son , and Holy Ghost , is in it self no great matter , yet the willful omission of it is acknowledged by most to be damnable . Thus kneeling , or standing at our Prayers , is but a Circumstance , yet since God has required it , and Holy Men recommended it by their Example , to omit it willfully may be a great sin , and render our best meant Prayers ineffectual . Much more must it be sinful to condemn , or mock at those who practise it according to God's Institution . 4. As small a value as you think God has for Outward performances , yet it is plain , that you lay great weight upon the doing , or not doing of them . In cases of necessity we think they may be lawfully omitted ; but you are Taught that in no cases they may be lawfully practised . You are Taught rather to stay at Home , and not to Worship God at all Publickly , than to conform in their Outward Gestures , or Circumstances . You are advised rather to abstain all your lives from the Lord's - Supper than recive it Kneeling . Now if you think God does hate them so much , upon supposition that he has not required them , and accounts them a polluting of his Ordinance . How must it displease him to omit them , if it appears that He has Commanded them , as I think I have made sufficiently plain . 5. I intreat you , my Friends , to consider , That whatever Bodily Worship be in it self , yet to throw it out of Our Publick Assemblies is of fatall consequence , since it doth in a great measure defeat the design of them . The great design of Publick Worship is , First , To signify , and Testify to the World the Sense and Belief we have of the Being , Power and Providence of God , To declare his Name to our Brethren , and in the midst of the Church to sing Praise unto him , Heb. ii . 12 . And Secondly to be a means to beget , stir up , and preserve this sense and belief in one another . Heb. x. 25 . To both these ends , Bodily and External Worship do very much contribute ; and 't is hardly possible to attain either of them without it . For we cannot see into one anothers Hearts , and therefore we must signify our sense and belief of God in the Publick Assemblies , either by Words or Actions , and if possible , by such as are peculiarly appointed by God to this purpose . But in your Meetings there is no Obligation on any one to signify his Concurrence with the Congregation in any Ordinary act of Worship , either by Word or Gesture , and therefore this end of Publick Assemblies is utterly defeated by you . Your Directory does not require , or allow the People so much as to signify their assent by adding an Amen to the Prayers or Thanksgivings there offered : But on the contrary , you ridicule those that practise it pursuant to the Directions and Examples in Scripture . And as to Gestures , such as kneeling , standing , or bowing the body , &c. you condemn them all as Relicts of Idolatry , or Superstition . There remains therefore in your Assemblies nothing whereby the people may testify their Belief , or assent to what they hear , which was one design of the Meeting . Thus by turning all Bodily Worship out of your Assemblies , you have made void this great end of them , and left no visible distinction whereby any one may signify whether he assents to the Worship that is offered , or dissents from it . The whole Assembly being to one another meer Spectators and Hearers , not Joint-Worshipers . As to the other end of Publick Worship , which is to keep alive , and stir up our affections ; you cannot but own that the omission of this outward Worship is a great hindrance to it . For it must needs be a great check to Devotion to see a Man come into the presence of God in a Christian Assembly , with less Reverence , or shew of respect , then into the presence of an Ordinary Superior ; and behave himself less civilly there , then he would do in a Court of Justice . And let people pretend what they will , That can never be suitable Worship to God , which would be rudeness to a Judge . And therefore the Quakers act much more reasonably , who refuse to take off their Hats , or pay Bodily Worship to Men , then other Dissenters , who pay it to Men , and refuse it to God. For to do so must Naturally tend to extinguish the aw and sense we ought to have of His Majesty , and the Belief of his peculiar presence in our Assemblies , and it is much to be feared that this proceeds too often from the want of such aw . 6. To conclude , There is a Language of Gestures rather more significant and moving than that of the Tongue ; and he must have a peculiar make of Mind , that is not more awakened and affected by seeing a whole Congregation on their Knees , with their Hands and Eyes lift up to Heaven ; than to see them sitting or leaning , whilst their Petitions are offering up to God. Words therefore and Gestures being only different parts of the Language whereby we express and communicate our Thoughts and Affections to one another , and Both being Recommended to us by Nature , and Commanded by Scripture , to be used in the Worship of God , he who lays aside Gestures , does sin against the Commandment of God , as well as he that lays aside Words . I heartily wish You , and all Dissenters , wou'd consider this ; which if you did , I assure my self you wou'd perceive this to be a matter of some moment , and neither condemn our Bodily Adorations , nor continue your own ( what I must call ) Irreverence . 3. But thirdly , Some alledge , for their omiting this part of God's Worship , That they do not condemn Bodily Adoration in his service ; but that to stand up and kneel in the Congregation is so troublesome to them , that they judge they are better omitted . To which I Answer , That I verily believe that these persons do give the true Reason of this Practice ; For , as it has been shewed before , 't was of old the Reason of people's Neglecting God's Service , and Matter of their Complaint against it , That it was a weariness , Mal. i. 13 . But sure 't is no less a sin to lay aside the Commandments of God for our Ease , than to change them for the Traditions of Men. 'T is an Effect of our Natural Corruption , to desire to serve God with that which costs us nothing , and without trouble ; and most are willing to save their Pains , as well as their Money , in his Service . But this is a certain sign that they have little Heart and Affection to It ; if they had , it would not seem a trouble to them to shew it by all the Outward Demonstrations that the Scriptures recommend to us . A devout Heart bows the Body , bends the Knees , and lifts up the Hands in Prayer , without any trouble . And they have reason to suspect their own Hearts , that find these demonstrations of Reverence to their Creator and Redeemer , Uneasie to them . This very Pretence ought to shew you , That it is the Negligence and Dead-heartedness of People towards God's Service , that has banished these Bodily Adorations out of it . We think it no Disadvantage to our Church , that we are forc'd to acknowledge , That your way of VVorship is much Easier than ours , to such as are present at it ; it being much less trouble to a Man that has no value for Religion , to come into an Assembly , and there sit down , and lap his Cloak about him , without being obliged to any VVord or Gesture that may disturb his sleep , or VVorldly Thoughts , than to be under an Obligation every moment to signify his Attention by some Word or Gesture , under the Penalty of being remarked by the whole Congregation , for his Negligence and Irreverence ; which is the case in our Assemblies ; and 't is to be feared , is the Reason that some leave us , and go where they may be at ease and negligent more securely . 4. I confess , in the fourth place , There are some that excuse themselves more handsomly , for not kneeling at their Prayers , &c. Say they , VVe want Conveniency , we have no room to kneel . To these we Answer , That where such a thing is omitted out of Necessity , not Negligence , or Contempt , we believe God will not impute it to them , neither do we accuse them for it . But then we cannot but observe that this is not the general Reason of omitting this part of God's VVorship among you : For , First , It is not your Custom to kneel in your Publick Worship , tho' you have Conveniency , as is manifest from the Practice in all your Meetings ; in which , I could never learn that any one kneeled ; on the contrary , you condemn Us who do . 2. When you want Conveniency for Kneeling , you might Stand at your Prayers , which is a Scripture-posture , as well as Kneeling ; you might bow your Bodies when you come into God's presence ; you might continue Vncovered whilst in it : But you omit all these , as well as Kneeling ; and thereby plainly shew that your Neglect in this point , is an Effect of Choice , not Necessity . 3. If Kneeling at Publick Prayers be a Duty , we are obliged to provide conveniency for it , for it is certainly a sin to suffer any part of God's Service to be omitted for want of care . It is as easy to provide conveniency for kneeling as for sitting in Publick Assemblies : And if we Consider , how carefull most people are to provide Seats for their ease , and how negligent to make any provision for kneeling ; 'T is but too manifest a sign ( whatever is pretended ) that they are much more zealous for their ease , then for the Service of God. But what conveniency is it that Men desire ? It is easy for them to have as much conveniency as St. Paul and his Congregation had when they kneeled on the Shore , Act. xx . If they had the Devotion of St. Paul , they would not fail to imitate his Example : Be ye followers , saith he , of me , as I am of Christ. St. Paul followed the Example of Christ in this particular ; and surely we ought to follow his , except we think our selves grown wiser then He was , or prefer our ease to our Duty . But the Truth of the matter , as it seems to me , is , That your Neglecting to kneel at the most solemn of all Christian Ordinances , the Lord's Supper , does harden you against Reverence in the other parts of Divine Worship : And it is no wonder it shou'd do so ; for if Reverence be not thought necessary in that Duty , it may well seem unnecessary in any other . CHAP. V. Of the Lord's-Supper . Sect. 1. What the Holy Scriptures prescribe concerning the frequency of Celebrating it . I. THe Fifth Main and Substantial part of the ordinary Worship of God in the Assemblies of Christians , is the Celebration of the Lord's-Supper . It is not to be expected that I should treat concerning the preparation requisite in the Receivers , or any of those other circumstances , which are generally agreed on as necessary in this matter ; and concerning which so many excellent Treatises are extant . I shall confine my self to one Point , and that is the Frequency of it , as a Publick act of Worship , and examine , First , what the Institution and Practice of the Church of God in Scripture Teach us , as to this particular . Secondly , Compare our Practice therewith . And Thirdly , The Practice of those who differ from us . As to the Frequency of Celebrating the Lord's-Supper , I find many People of opinion , that the Scriptures have determined nothing in it , & that therefore it is intirely left to the discretion of the Ministers , how often they will Celebrate it , and to the People's how often they will receive it : And that on this Account every one is left to judge for himself , when he will be a partaker of it , as he thinks it most for his Comfort and Edification ; which makes the Celebration and Receiving it so Arbitrary a thing , that many never receive it at all . And the Universal neglect of it is become one of the Crying sins of these Kingdoms , and a great Objection against the Reformation . But if we Consider the Institution of this Sacrament , it will help us to pass a right judgment , as to the Obligation of the frequency that lies on us . I shall endeavour to make this plain in the following particulars . 1. Our Saviour when he had blessed , broken , and delivered the Bread to his Disciples , Commanded them to Take Eat , and do This , that they saw Him do , in Rememberance of him ; and when He had Blessed the Cup , and given it to them , he Commanded them to Drink all of it , and as often as they drink it , to do it in Remembrance of him . 1 Cor. xi . 26 . Now I conceive the most Natural Interpretation of these words of our Saviour , Do this in Remembrance of Me , and This do Ye as often as often as you drink it , in Remembrance of Me , to be , as if he had said . We have now Celebrated together the Jewish Passover in Remembrance of our Fore-fathers deliverance out of Egypt . But I am about to purchase for you by my Death a much more glorious deliverance from the slavery of Sin , and the power of Hell. And I order you for the future to do this ( which you see done by me ) in Remembrance of Me , as what you have hitherto done , has been in Remembrance of your Deliverance out of Egypt . From this Institution it appears , 1. That the Lord's-Supper is substituted in the place of the Passover , which was Commanded by the Law to be Celebrated once in the Year ; and that in a place appointed by God , where all Israel were to assemble for it . 2. That Our Saviour has confin'd us to no Place , or prefixt time for the Celebration of his Supper that succeeds it ; which makes it much more easy for us to observe it , and renders us much more inexcusable if we neglect it . 3. Since Our Saviour has taken off the Confinement to Time and Place , that made the Passover such a Burthen . It follows that they who Celebrate it seldomer then the Jews did their Passover , must needs have less regard to the memory of Christ's Death , and the deliverance wrought by it , then the Jews had to their Deliverance out of Egypt . There being no other imaginable reason that can tempt them to neglect purifying themselves for this solemnity of Worship , and frequenting it , but the deadness of their Hearts towards Christ , and the want of Sense , Gratitude and Love towards their Master . 4. Christ's positive Command to Do this in Remembrance of Him , &c. must oblige us in some Times , and in some Circumstances ; And there can be no better way of determining when we are obliged to do it , then by observing when God in his goodness gives us Opportunity , for either we are then obliged to do it , or else we may choose whether we will ever do it or no ; there being no better means of determining the frequency , then this of God's giving us the opportunity . And the same Rule holding in all other general , positive Commands , such as in those that oblige us to Charity , we may be sure it holds likewise in this . Therefore whoever slights , or neglects any Opportunity of Receiving , which God affords him , does sin as certainly as he who being enabled by God to perform an Act of Charity , and invited by a fit Object , neglects to Relieve him , or shuts up his Bowels of Compassion against him ; concerning whom the Scripture assures us , That the Love of God dwells not in him : And the Argument is rather stronger against him who neglects this holy Sacrament ; for how can it be supposed that a Man has a true love for his Saviour , or a due sense of his sufferings who refuses , or neglects to remember the greatest of all benefits , in the easyest manner , tho' Commanded to do it by his Redeemer , and invited by a a fair opportunity of God's own offering . 5. It is manifest that if it be not our own Faults , we may have an Opportunity every Lord's Day , when we meet together ; And therefore that Church is guilty of laying aside this Command , whose Order of Worship doth not require and provide for this Practice . Christ's Command seems to lead us directly to it : For , Do this in remembrance of Me , implies that Christ was to leave them ; that they were to meet together after he was gone ; and that he required them to remember him at their Meetings whilst he was absent . The very Design of our Publick Meetings on the Lord's - Day , and not on the Jewish Sabbath , is to remember , and keep up in our Minds a sense of what Christ did and suffered for us , till He come again ; and this we are obliged to do , not in such a manner as our own Invention suggests , but by such means as Christ himself has prescribed to us ; that is , by celebrating this Holy Sacrament . It seems then probable from the very Institution of this Sacrament , that our Saviour designed it should be a part of God's Service , in all the solemn Assemblies of Christians , as the Passover was in the Yearly Assemblies of the Jews . To know therefore how often Christ requires us to celebrate this Feast , we have no more to do , but to enquire how often Christ requires us to Meet together ; that is , at least every Lord's Day . II. And the same is farther manifest , in the second place , from the Examples of the Apostles , and of the Churches of God in the New Testament . They cannot be supposed but to have understood what Christ meant by these words , Do this in Remembrance of Me ; and if it appears that they did make this Feast a constant part of their Ordinary Worship , we may safely conclude , That Christ meant it should be so . And here 't is observable , That we do not find any solemn stated Meeting of Christians for Worship in the whole New Testament , without it . At first the Disciples had their Meetings every Day , and then they likewise daily received this Sacrament , Acts ii . 46 . And they continued daily with one Accord in the Temple , and in breaking Bread from House to House : And St. Paul supposes that their Meeting together was on purpose , and with express Design to Celebrate this Feast , 1 Cor. x. 20 . When ye come together therefore into one place , this is not to eat the Lord's Supper ; which intimates , That one main Design of their coming together , was and ought to have been , to eat the Lord's Supper ; tho' by their misbehaviour they so corrupted the Ordinance , that it could not be called His Supper . If one should now reprove Christians , whom they observe to mis-behave themselves in Church , in these words : When you come together into one place , this is not to hear the Word of God Preached to you ; for one is Talking , and another is Sleeping : Wou'd not every Body conclude , That in the Opinion of the Reprover , the Hearing the Word of God Preached , ought to be one End of their coming together ? And then surely the Apostles saying that when you come together into one place , this is not to eat the Lord's Supper , &c. gives us ground to conclude , that in his Opinion , Eating the Lords Supper ought to be one constant End of our coming together . Which is further manifest from the Advice he gives them , Vers. 33. Wherefore , my Brethren , when ye come together to eat , tarry one for another . One End therefore of their coming together , was , as Children come together in a Family at Meal-time ; that is , to be fed at their Father's Table : For what the Apostle called in the former Verse , coming together into one place ; in this Verse he calls , coming together to eat ; intimating , that a main end of their coming together into one place , was to eat . 3. When the Meeting of Christians came to be fixed to the First Day of the Week , or the Lord's Day , the Breaking of Bread was likewise brought to the same Day : So Acts xx . 7 . And upon the first Day of the Week , when the Disciples came together to break Bread , Paul preached unto them . From which words we may conclude two things ; First , That the First Day of the Week was the Disciples time of Publick Worship . Secondly , That the Breaking of Bread , or celebrating the holy Eucharist , was a part of that Worship . The Scripture is as plain for the one as the other . There have been some Disputes raised about Changing the Day of Worship from the Last to the First Day of the Week , and this place is usually produced to justifie the Change ; And sure the same place is as clear for the Celebration of the Lord's Supper on that Day , as for the Observation of the Day it self , instead of the Sabbath . And therefore whoever wilfully passes the Lord's-Day without it , doth not observe it as the Scriptures , from the Practice of the Disciples , direct us to do . 4. I have endeavoured all along to confine my self to the plain words of Scripture , and to use such Arguments only , as the meanest persons might be able to judge of from their Bibles : Yet in a Controverted place of Scripture , concerning the meaning of a Command of Christ relating to some positive Duty , I take the constant practice of the Church from the Apostles downward , to be a good means of determining the sense of it ; And as there is not any Example of a stated Assembly for Worship in the New Testament without the Lord's - Supper , so I think there is not any Example of that Nature in all Antiquity . For the truth of which I appeal to those that are skill'd in it . The nearer we come to the Apostles , we shall still find the Lord's - Supper the more punctually observed , as a constant part of the Ordinary service of the Church : And 't is remarkable , that when first some who had been present at the Prayers and Preaching of the Church began to go away from the Publick Assemblies without Receiving ( which was a corruption that came in about 300 years after Christ ) it was looked on as so great an Innovation and breach of the Scripture Rule , that the Church decreed whosoever was guilty of it should be Excommunicated . So , particularly the Ninth of those commonly called the Canons of the Apostles , and the second Canon of the Council of Antioch . Thus the Practice of the Church continued for many Ages . And tho' the generality of Men could not be persuaded constantly to partake of the Lord's - Supper , after the Discipline of the Church was dissolved , and the piety of Men began to cool , yet still it was Celebrated on the Lord's - day , according to the first setled Practice of the Church . 5. And indeed the corrupt practice of the solitary Masses of the Papists is a further evidence of its being counted Originally a part of the ordinary Worship of God. I think it is confessed by all , even by the Papists themselves , that those Masses had their Original from the universal corruption and negligence of Christians ; For whilst the People had either Piety or Zeal , they communicated with the Bishop , or Ministers , in every Assembly , at least a competent number of them : But when Piety and Devotion were in a manner lost in the corrupt Ages of the Church , it came to pass , that tho' the Minister Consecrated the Elements every Lord's-day , according to the Example of the Holy Scriptures , and Antiquity , yet he could prevail with few or none to receive with him , but was often forced to receive alone . This was a great corruption and a falling from the Scripture precedent ; but the Roman Church instead of Reforming the abuse , by obliging the people to receive as formerly , corrupted her principles , as well as practice , and decreed it lawful and sufficient for the Priest to receive alone . Yet this abuse shews us what should be , and what has been the practice ; and that the Church has constantly reckoned the Lord's-Supper , as an Ordinary part of Publick Worship in Christian Assemblies on solemn days ; and sure then to lay it aside can be termed no less then an Invention of our own , Since we can neither in Scripture , or in the Church of God for 1400 years together , ( which is a sufficient commentary on the Scripture Text ) produce one Example of a stated solemn Christian Assembly without it . Sect. 2. The Practice of Our Church as to frequent Communions . I. HAving thus consider'd the Rules and Examples that the Scriptures afford us in this point , let us in the second place compare the Rules and Practices of Our Church with this pattern . I will not pretend that they come fully up to it , this being the most defective part of the Reformation ; But I doubt not on view it will appear that Our Church comes nearer the Scripture precedent then perhaps any other . 'T was the design of the Reformation to throw out the corruptions of the Church of Rome , and to bring things back to what was practised in the Apostles time , and in the purer Ages of th● Church . And as to the present point before us , Our Reformers found two corruptions crept in by time : The first was , That the Priest received the Lord's-Supper alone , without the people , which destroyed the Nature of this Holy Sacrament , as a Communion ; The second was , That the people thought they had sufficiently observed the Lord's-day if they saw Mass , without understanding it , or receiving . Our Church therefore to Reform the first of these , Ordains , That there shall be no Communion , except 4 ( or 3 at the least ) Communicate with the Priest. So where 3 are willing to Receive , the Ministers may proceed to the Holy Communion every Lord's-day . For our Saviour has promised that Where two or three are met together he will be in the midst of them . Three therefore make a Congregation , and have a Title to the Ordinances of Christ ; and there is no reason that the Obstinacy or Negligence of others should hinder such as are willing from Worshiping God , according to his Institution ; and therefore Our Church has taken care to provide for them , by Ordering that some part of the Communion-Service be read every Lord's-day ; both with design to put all people in ? mind of their Duty , and to accommodate such as can be prevail'd on herein to live up to the Rules of Scripture , and the practice of the Primitive Church . 2. 'T is Ordered , That in Cathedral and Collegiate Churches and Colledges , where there are many Priests and Deacons , they shall all receive the Communion every Sunday at the least . 3. That every Parishioner shall Communicate at least three times in the year , whereof Easter to be one ; and surely such as cannot fit themselves so often , must , in their own Opinion , be out of a state of Grace , and deserve to be Excommunicated by the Church . 4. Lastly , As to our Practice , we have prevailed so far , that Universally the Lord's Supper is Celebrated Thrice every year ; and where either our Perswasions , Arguments , or Entreaties can prevail with our People , we have Monthly Communions ; and in Cities and large Towns , by the changing the Monthly Days in several Churches , people that are devoutly disposed , have Opportunities of Receiving Weekly : And we have reason to bless God that our Church wants not some , and I hope I may say many such . 5. Upon the whole , it must be confessed , That to hold Solemn Assemblies of Christians ▪ without Communicating , is a corruption of Popery , and came in by dissolution of Manners , and slackning of the Discipline of the Church ; and tho' we have not been able to Root-out and Reform this Popish Practice intirely , yet we have done our Endeavour ; and , by God's Blessing , may say we have made some progress in it ; insomuch that if we take that for Ordinary which has a constant fixed time for its Observation ▪ the Holy Sacrament is an Ordinary part of our publick Service of God. And I verily perswade my self , That by God's Assistance we should have brought our people before now to the Scripture-Order of constant Weekly Communicating , had not the Ill Example and Obstinacy of those that separate from our Church , Encouraged them in their Negligence , and weakened our Discipline : For our Church orders Non-Communicants to be presented and punished ; and our Ministers do not generally flatter the people in their sin , or dissemble their Duty in this point ; but frequently and earnestly , by Sermons , Admonitions , and Treatises purposely published to this intent , press them to it ; and therefore we are blameless before God and Man. Nor is it our Fault that the practice of our people is not Reformed , according to the Pattern of the Apostolick Church , and the Rules of our Own : So that we cannot be accused of laying aside the Commandments of God , or of teaching any Doctrine of our own Invention , in this particular ; tho' we are yet too far short of the Primitive Practice and Institution . Sect. 3. The Practice of the Dissenters about Frequency of Communicating . I. I Come now ( according to my former Method ) to You , my Friends , who Dissent from us , and intreat You to Examine , with Me , your Principles and Practice , by these Scripture-Rules and Examples : And here first I must observe to you , That you have no fixt or set Times for the Administration of this Sacrament ; on the contrary , your Directory orders , That the times how often this is to be Celebrated may be considered and determined by the Ministers and other Church-Governours of each Congregation , as they shall find most convenient for the Comfort and Edification of the People committed to their charge : By which Rule , the Lord's Supper is Excluded from being any ordinary constant part of God's Service , it being referred to the Discretion of the Ministers and Elders of each Congregation to determine , as in other occasional things , how often the people shall have the comfort of it . It had been as reasonable to refer it to their Discretion how often the people shou'd have the comfort of Hearing the Scriptures read , of joyning in the Praises of God , or in Prayers to Him ; which yet they determine they are obliged to every Lord's Day . Had they made the same Rule for the holy Communion , they had indeed conformed to the Scripture-Precedent , and might have pretended to some Reformation : But to leave the celebration of this Feast altogether Discretionary , I have shewed to be directly against what we find practised in Scripture . II. Whereas it is a corruption of Popery to suffer the people to be present at the publick Assemblies for Worship and celebration of the Lords Supper , without being obliged to Receive ; your Teachers , instead of endeavouring to reform this Abuse and Innovation , have fallen into another practice as unprecedented in Scripture , the Excluding this Sacrament intirely from your Ordinary solemn Meetings . And truly in this point you seem more inexcusable than the Papists themselves ; for the Papists order the Elements to be consecrated every Lords Day , and distributed to those that desire it : But your Teachers neither offer it to the people , nor invite them to it ; nay , so far are they from it , that they do not so much as afford an Opportunity to those that desire to be constant Receivers : Which is plainly to multiply the Abuses introduced by Popery , instead of Reforming them . III. They rarely press their people to Communicate ; they have few Sermons or Discourses to that purpose ; and many of them condemn our Zeal , for endeavouring to restore the constant Communion precedented in Scripture . I must further make you sensible that your Practice is yet worse than your Principles . Your Directory owns that the Communion , or Supper of the Lord is frequently to be celebrated , &c. But it fares with this , as with all other indefinite Rules : they signifie only that people may do what they please in the case . No body can certainly tell what frequently , many , often , or convenient , signifie ; and therefore where only these words are used in a Rule , it is little better than to have no Rule at all ; as appears in this very case : For when people were relaxed from the particular and certain Rules of our Church , by the first breaking off of those of your Perswasion from us , the Lord's Supper was laid aside wholly for several years by some Congregations ; and at last too many came to look on it as a matter of no constant necessity . I appeal to You , whether it is not yet reckoned a great thing among many of you , if once in a year or two a Communion be celebrated in one of your Meetings ; Nay , among some of you it is often omitted for several years together , and in some places for ten or more : I fear I may say , Your people generally have too little sence of the Obligation of Receiving it at all ; and your Ministers indulge them so far in this corruption , that a Man may live comfortably amongst you , and with the Reputation of a Professor , to Thirty or Fourty Years of Age , and never Receive at all ; And by the best Enquiry I cou'd make , I cou'd not compute that One in Ten that goe to your Meetings ever Receive through the whole course of their Lives , notwithstanding Christ's positive Command to do it in remembrance of Him. So unhappily are Men over-seen in laying aside the Commands of God , for their own Inventions . I should be glad to find that I were mistaken in this Computation : In the mean time you must give me leave to tell you plainly , That this practice of Rare or No Communion , is so peculiarly your own , that I think you are altogether singular in it ; and are so far from having any Precedent for it in Scripture , that I doubt whether any Precedent can be found for you , even amongst the most degenerated or Barbarous People that ever called themselves Christians . And therefore , if you have either any true regard for Scripture , or Reverence for the Constant and Vniversal Practice of the Church of God. You ought to reflect upon your practice herein ; and consider how You can answer it to God , or your Consciences . I will not Examine the Reasons , commonly given for your Omissions in this weighty Affair , since it is manifest no Reason of Man's Invention ought to be admitted for direct disobedience to Christ's Command ; If You are Christians in earnest , you ought , as often as you have Opportunity , to remember the great Love of Our Lord and Master , as he has Commanded ; And your Ministers ought to take care to afford you frequently such Opportunities . If you or they neglect this , I do not see how you can with Reason insist so much on the Purity and Observation of Christ's Institution . CONCLUSION . I Have gone through the Five Principal Parts of the Publick Worship of God ; and ( I hope ) in all of them have made good what I first undertook , and shewed that there needs no more to justify the Publick Service of our Church , than to compare it with the Rules and Examples of Scripture . I have only a few words to add by way of Conclusion , First to my Brethren of the Clergy , and then to the Laity who are under my Charge . To the Conforming CLERGY of DERRY . 1. AND first as to you , My Brethren . , that are of Our Communion , and owning My Authority , let Me , as a Brother and a Fellow-Labourer , exhort you to be thankful to God , that has Entrusted you with such an Excellent Ministry and Service , which being built on so sure a Foundation as the Word of God , can never be shaken , or put you to any great Difficulty to defend it , since you need no more than the plain words of your Bibles , without gloss , or Commentators , to assert and justify it . 2. Let me recommend to you Reverence , Devotion and Diligence , in the Use of this Service . I have already observed that there is a Language of Gestures rather more significant and affecting than that of Words . It becomes us therefore not only to Love and Use our Service , but likewise to recommend it to the people , by a distinct and affectionate manner of pronouncing and reading it , and by a devout and grave behaviour at it . This can never be pressed too much on you , or on others by you ; since 't is absolutely necessary to give Life and Efficacy to it ; as the contrary will expose the best and most sacred thing to contempt ; and bring a greater disparagement on our Service , then all Our Adversaries endeavours can ever do . Tho' Our Service be appointed by God , and Warranted by Scripture , yet even God's Appointments are Abominations to him , when separated from the heart , and are only acceptable to him , as they contribute to Inward Devotion . Let me therefore intreat you to labour so to perform the Service of Our Church , that it may attain the End for which God has design'd His Worship . 3. Since the Service of Our Church is such as God has required in his Word , let nothing discourage us in the use of it : Let us Remember that we perform it in Obedience to God ; And tho' some hate , some revile , and some despise it , yet that the Author of it is able to vindicate it . This is no New Thing , 'T is the Entertainment the World has generally given God's Service , and his Truths : And therefore neither Obstinacy , Perverseness , or Negligence of the People , whom you are to persuade , ought to discourage you . Be Diligent , be Constant , be Resolute , and be assured that God will always give you success so far as is necessary to support his Truth . All means are therefore to be attempted ; and when one faileth another is to be applied ; And the more averse people seem to the way of Worship prescribed by God , and the more eager they are for any Corruption , the more Industry is to be used to bring them off from it ; And when all other means fail , earnest Prayers and Intercessions with God still remain : We are never to dispair whilst we have God's Truth on our side , tho' whole Provinces should fall off from the Church , As all they in Asia did from St. Paul , 2. Tim. i. 15 . Tho' few or none should believe our Report , as it happened to Our Saviour himself ; Yet God will have a Reward for the Faithful Endeavours of his Ministers ; And therefore me must not desist , tho' people seem obstinate , but in season and out of season , by Exhortation and writing , by all means of Importunity and Industry , we must press them to their Duty , and endeavour to bring them back to the purity of God's Worship as he has Instituted it . 4. Let me put you in mind , That the Motives you have to do your Duty are the most Noble and Generous that can be ; And you have this Advantage , that you cannot be supposed to be zealous in your Office out of any private Interest , or prospect of particular profit . Your Maintenance and Preferments are ascertained to you by Law , and do not depend on the Voluntary Contribution of the People . And as you are under no Temptation to please them , by complying with their vices or humours , so neither can you be suspected to be diligent and industrious in your Office out of any such mean Considerations . Since therefore what pains you take may well be supposed to proceed only from sense of Duty , and the love of God , let me entreat you to labour in it . It is certain , That neither Popularity , Faction , nor Worldly Interest can influence you to this , so as they may some , that have no other way to attain to Honour , or Support , but by making or gaining a Party . But God forbid that true Piety and Zeal for Souls should work less effectually upon you , then those carnal and servile motives do on others . Let me therefore earnestly encourage and intreat you to do it more and more , and that you will endeavour to become all things to all Men , and decline none of those Arts which are allowable , when applied , to gain the people to Truth and Holiness ; But very wicked , when employed to divide and seduce them . 5. Let me put you in mind , That you are Ministers of the Gospel , and not of a Party ; And therefore it concerns you to mind the common interest of Holiness and Religion , more then those differences that are often of little concern in themselves , and are insisted on only as the occasions and badges of those people , who being resolved to seperate themselves , are obliged to take up little differences for a distinction . The less you meddle with these disputes , it is commonly the better ; And indeed it is not prudent to mention them , till Mens minds be fitted and prepared by a true sense of the great Duties of Religion : And then the best way perhaps will be to shew of what little weight they are , to cause or justify divisions or quarrels amongst Christians . I am well aware that it may be objected to us , that whilst we press the great Duties of the first and second Table . and spend our pains and diligence in defending our common Christianity against Papists , Socinians , Deists and Atheists , those that are our Adversaries in these lesser points , have made their advantage of Our being employed against the common Enemy , to undermine us with the people ; nay , that some of them have even joined with those Enemies to pull down Our Constitution . But yet I persuade my self that we are in less hazard from them , whilst we do our Duty and apply our selves to the great and common Obligations of Our Holy Religion , then if we should leave this exposed to the Assaults of Our Common Enemies , to guard our selves from the attempts of such back Friends . We must therefore have an eye to them ; But the other , the great and common Truths , and Duties of the Gospel , must be our main business . I might add many more Remarks proper to my present subject , but I know your own Prudence and Observation are sufficient to suggest them to you ; I shall only add my Prayers for you , that God will encrease your Wisdom and Zeal , and effectually turn them to his own Glory . To the Dissenting Ministers of Derry . BUt as to You , My Brethren , That disown my Communion and Authority , I have reason to fear that what I shall offer to you may receive some prejudices from my Station and Character , with which you seem offended ; Yet reason is reason from whom soever it proceeds ; and I only desire that you would weigh seriously what I have here offered , in defence of the Service of Our Church ; and if the Arguments do not convince You , yet let me pray You to reflect thus far on the matter , as to remember that all Mens minds are not of the same make ; and that it becomes You , and all good Men , at least to treat Our Service with respect ; Since we believe , and think we have proved , That it is clearly founded on the Word of God. It will not excuse scurrilous , or unseemly Reflections on it , to say that we are mistaken : For all Men are fallible , and You may as well be mistaken , as you suppose We are ; And therefore lest You should be in the wrong , it will be the safest way to be modest in censuring . No Man ought to take it ill that another proposes Reasons against his Opinion ; but to scoff at , or revile any practice , or opinion that another believes to be founded on the Word of God , is not only ill manners , but is of dangerous consequence ; being apt to breed Bitterness and Animosities between the Parties ; And if it should happen in a Case where the Practice , or Opinion is really Warranted by the Word of God , it would be Blasphemy and Impiety . And therefore in all matters of Religion we ought to avoid this manner of treatment ; and whatever Book uses it , we need trouble our selves no further with it , for it certainly is written only to serve a Party , and not Truth . There is another thing that in Justice I think I may request of You , which is , That in Your Worship and Practice , You will not make the difference between us seem greater then really it is . To abstain from a thing confessed to be lawful in the Service of God , meerly because observed by us , is surely very far from a Spirit of Meekness and Moderation : And therefore I may hope that you will not Indulge Your People in such affected distances , that can serve to no other purpose but to make Parties irreconcilable ; and must proceed from a greater bitterness of Spirit then a good Man can be guilty of towards any Christian. And that You may understand my mind the better in this matter , I will give You a few instances that I hope will be inoffensive ; and in which we may justly expect Your Complyance . 1. The first is in the use of the Lord's - Prayer , which is owned in Your larger Catechism , to be Not only for Direction , as a Pattern according to which we are to make other Prayers , but may be also used as a Prayer . And in your Directory 't is recommended to be used in the Prayers of the Church . Yet I am informed that You , my Brethren , of this Diocess , who separate from Our Communion , do universally neglect it , and thereby confirm Your Hearers in an Opinion too common amongst them , that all Forms of Prayer are unlawful . And that for no other reason , that I can learn , but to keep up a difference from us in practice , where we really agree in point of Doctrine : 2. Your sitting at Publick Prayers , may be a second Instance , in which we may reasonably expect some Reformation . 'T is a very irreverent thing in it self , against the Command and Examples of Scripture , as I think I have sufficiently shewed , and against the Opinion of your best Casuists , particularly of Dr. Ames , de Conscientia , Lib. 4· Cap. 18. Sessio per se non est gestus Orandi , quia nullam exprimit reverentiam neque in Scripturis approbatur . That is , Sitting is not of it self a posture of prayer , because it expresses no Reverence . neither is it approved in Scripture . Yet I understand that this is the general posture in which your people Offer their publick prayers ; and either because it is for their Ease , or because you are unwilling to seem to lay any stress on Outward Performances , or lastly , lest you shou'd be like us , you indulge them in it ; and some of them are so ignorant that they reckon it a piece of Superstition in us to kneel at our prayers ; and are averse to our Service , amongst other Reasons , because this is required at it . Which Notions , I suppose , you your selves do not approve ; and therefore we may justly expect that you shou'd endeavour to inform your people better , and bring them to a Compliance with the Rules of Decency in their Religious Performances . 3. My third Instance shall be in the Matter of the Holy Sacrament of the Lord's - Supper . I suppose no serious considering persons amongst you can deny but the celebrating it so seldom as it is done in your Meetings , and the people's backwardness in Receiving it , are very great faults ; and therefore we may reasonably expect that you should press home to your people the Danger of their Neglect , and represent to them truly the sin of it , so as not to suffer any to assume the Name of a Professor or a Religious Person , that doth not in some measure come up to the Scripture-precedent in this particular ; and withal , so order the celebration thereof , that every one may have sufficient Opportunities to Receive , as the first Christians did ; which in your present way of managing , is impossible : From whence you may be sure , yours is not the Scripture-way , and therefore needs Reformation . 4. Let me put you in mind , That it is ordered by your Directory ( as I have already observed ) that ordinarily one Chapter of each Testament be read at every Meeting , and sometimes more . I think you cannot dispense with this Rule , without being liable to just Censure , from all that have a true value for the Word of God : And yet I am informed that there is not one of your Meetings in this Diocess , where it is observed ; to the great detriment of our common Christianity , and offence of your Brethren . I know the people are fonder of Sermons and Lectures of Human Composure , than of the pure Word of God in its Naked Simplicity ; but you know this to be a carnal and sinful Humour in them ; And God forbid any that claims to be a Minister of the Gospel shou'd indulge them in it : And therefore as you wou'd maintain a due Reverence in the people for the Word of God , I think we may expect your Conformity to us in this particular . 5. I suppose you very well know that the most learned and sober Nonconformists do own that Occasional Communion with our Church is lawful , and that people had better come to our Worship ( at least where he that officiates is of Ability and Sobriety ) than sit at home on the Lord's Day , or frequent no Assemblies at all ; And you cannot be ignorant that many thousands in these parts neglect all Publick Worship , and many suffer their Children to die Unbaptized , for want of Ministers of their own Communion ; And therefore in this case , it is a point of Justice due to the Souls of these poor people , and to our common Christianity , to let them know that it is their Duty to joyn with us both in Worship and Sacraments , as far as your Brethren in England have Allowed it on such Occasions . 6. You are sensible that amongst those Protestants that dissent from our Church , some are Congregational , and others Presbyterians ; You of this Diocess where I am concerned , profess to be of this latter sort , and agree with us in owning that by Christ's Appointment , the particular Churches in convenient Districts , ought , according to Scripture-Precedents , to Associate under one Government ; and these again to Unite themselves into greater Combinations of Provincial and National Churches . The Difference between You and Vs is concerning these particular Districts ; Namely , Whether the Government of them ought to be in a Presbytery , with a Bishop as President and Governor , by Christ's Appointment ; or in a Colledge of Presbyters absolutely Equal . So then , we both own National and Provincial Churches , as well as single Worshiping Congregations ; but the Congregational Dissenters deny that Christ Instituted any other Church , besides a single Congregation ; and affirm that all other Churches , such as Classical , Provincial , or National , are Human Inventions ; and that every single Congregation is Independent , and may indeed keep a fair correspondence with its Neighbour Congregations , but is not under any common Government with them . These last are the avowed Principles of Mr. Baxter , Dr. Owen , Mr. Lob , Mr. Humphrys , Mr. Boyse , Mr. Alsop , Mr. Clerkson , and generally of all the late defenders of the Dissenters cause in England and Ireland that I have met with . Now it is manifest that these Principles of theirs , are much more different from your Principles , then ours are ; And the difference is much greater , and more material . For it is possible on your Principles and ours to preserve Unity , and to keep up some value for Excommunication , and other censures of the Church ; since he who is censured in one Church cannot be received into another , neither with you , nor us : Whereas in the Congregational way , he that is Excommunicated in one Congregation , may remove to another , or set up one for himself if he pleases ; at the worst , if he shou'd , it wou'd be counted but an Irregularity . These Principles are destructive to the Peace and Unity of the Church , as well as to our common Cause ; and our Learned Men have carefully Answered all the principal Writers of that sort ; so that no Books of that kind have remained Unanswered , but such only as were meer Repetitions of what had been said and answered before . I do not remember any of you have of late undertaken the Defence of this important Truth ; tho' the Assembly of Divines in their Humble Advice — concerning Church-Government ( which I suppose you approve ) do prove it from the Holy Scriptures , in their Title of Classical Assemblies . Now we think , in Justice to your Own Cause , as well as to Us , you ought to warn your people against those Books that maintain Principles contrary to us both ; at least not to bear them in hand , that those Books written against Vs , make for You ; for this will appear a great piece of Insincerity , as well as Ingratitude ; and will tempt the World to believe that you are willing to encourage Principles destructive to your own Cause , ( as the Principles of those Books manifestly are in this very Point ) so they do but serve a Turn , and strengthen your Party amongst the ignorant People . 6. Lastly , I think we may justly expect from you a ready concurrence with us to beat down such Vices and Immoralities as are confessed on all hands to be against our common Christianity ; such as Adultery , Fornication , Blasphemy , Profanation of the Lord's Day , &c. And since the Bishop's Courts are Legally Impowered to punish these , and many are guilty of them who yet will not appear or submit to acknowledge their sins , and upon that Account are Excommunicated : The least that can be expected from you in these Cases , is , Not to encourage such Sinners in their Obstinacy , or to admit them to Communion amongst You , whilst they lie under such Censures ; which might be a means to Reform , in some measure , these Crying Vices . These are but a few of those things that might be instanc'd ; in which we may concur in our Practice , as well as we do in our Opinions ; and if we did , I perswade my self , that tho they did not bring us to one Religious Communion , yet they might much contribute to our living easily with one another , and take off that Uncharitableness which our Religious Dissentions are apt to cause amongst us : However , it wou'd be a great Satisfaction to Me , and I shou'd reckon it some kind of Success in my Office , if I cou'd prevail with any sort of people , that profess to meet in the Name of Christ , to come nearer to his Institutions in their Worship ; tho' I should not be able to perswade them to the Communion whereof I am a Member . To the Conforming LAITY of the Diocess of DERRY . AS to You , my Friends and Brethren of the Laity , who profess your selves Members of the Established Church ; It hath pleased God to place Me amongst you , and to give Me an Inspection over you ; and 't is chiefly on your Account that I have written and published this Treatise , that it may be a Pledge and Testimony to you of my concern for you , and make my care to reach as far as may be amongst you . I hope my Labours this way may be Useful to you , to settle the Minds of the Doubtful , and to awaken you all to Diligence and Zeal in the performance of the Service of God. The great Principles of your Religion , as you are Members of the Established Church , are Uncontroverted on all hands ; and I have here endeavoured to shew that your particular Way of Worship is warranted by the Holy Scriptures . You have reason to bless God , that He has afforded you so many conveniencies of frequenting it : In which He has been pleased to give you so manifest Advantage above your Dissenting Neighbours , that notwithstanding their Numerousness , you have Five places for Worship , for One that they have . This will render you inexcusable , if you neglect attendance at them , or spend any Lord's Day ( as is too common in this Country ) in a meer Rest from Labour , without any Publick Worship . I must likewise put you in mind , that our Service is not only fitted for the Publick , but is likewise proper for private Families ; And therefore I would advise you to make use of the words with which Our Church has furnished you , in your Houses , as well as in the Church . At least to use such select Hymns and Collects as seem most adapted to that purpose . And at more solemn times I conceive our Litany is as full and proper a Service as any Master of a Family can desire to offer to God. I must therefore most earnestly & passionately exhort you , by the Name of Our Lord Jesus Christ , for his Church's sake , and your own , that you will add Diligence and Zeal to this your reasonable Service , and prepare your hearts to seek the Lord your God in his Holy Worship . And particularly that you wou'd endeavour to convince the World , that it is not Faction , or a Party you contend for , but the Fruits of Righteousness ; And thereupon strive rather to out-live those that differ from You , then to out-argue them . Let the innocency of your Lives , and your Christian Moderation convince them of the unreasonableness of their separation from You. I beseech the God and Father of Our Lord Jesus Christ to multiply his Grace and Peace upon You ; and to influence You by his Holy Spirit , that You may be perfect in every good Work ; and particularly in that of Worshiping him in purity and Holiness . To the Dissenting-LAITY of the Diocess of DERRY . AS to You , My Friends , that dissent from Our Communion , it remains only , that I beseech You in the Spirit of Meekness , ( as one that is appointed by the Providence of God , and the care of a Christian Magistracy , to watch over Your Souls ) That You will seriously consider , and lay to heart what I have here tender'd to You. I cannot prevail with you to come and receive Instruction from my Mouth ; And therefore I have taken this way to inform You. I will only add a few Observations , which I recommend to You , and shall leave the success intirely to God. 1. Therefore You may observe that in this Treatise I have not led You into long Reasonings , or the intricacies of Human Learning ; but I have referred You to your Bibles , and You need go no further then to them to be satisfied whether the things I have said be as I have represented them or not . Those of Berea are reckoned a Noble People ( Acts xvii . 11 ) because they searched the Scriptures , and I pray most heartily to God to give You a part in that Nobleness of mind , that You may search and find the Truth . 2. I wou'd desire You to observe that it ever has been , and in all probability ever will be the humour of the World , to be more fond of Their Own Inventions then of what God Commands . If we look thro' the whole Scriptures we shall find , that the Prophets sent by God , the Doctrines revealed by him , and the Worship he Commanded , have had but ill Entertainment amongst the people . There never appeared half so much Zeal or inclination in the generality of Men , for the true God and his Worship , as for the false Gods , and their Prophets . And there is an obvious natural reason for it , since what Man invents must needs have a near agreement to the Carnal and Corrupt inclinations of our depraved Nature , then what God prescribes : which is the very reason that induces Men to change the Institutions of God , and substitute their own Inventions instead of them . A thing that wou'd never come into any Man's mind , if he did not find more ease or gratification to his humour in them , then in observing God's Commandments . If it were proper to refer you to the History of the Church , you would find that most of all the Corruptions in the Worship of God were introduced by the fondness and violent inclinations of the people for them : And that the Church Governours did long oppose them , and were brought with difficulty at last to comply with them . Thus the Worship of Images , Prayers for the Dead , Purgatory , the intercession of Saints , half Communion , being present at Church Assemblies without receiving the Lord's - Supper , and Worshiping the Host , were all vulgar practices at first , against the Opinion of the Governours of the Church , who generally Opposed and Condemned them ; but being Human Inventions , the People were so violent for them , that there was no withstanding them , so that if the Governours they had would not comply , the people did set up those that wou'd . Now let me entreat you to reflect a little , and consider with all seriousness whether there may not be something like this in your own Case , especially in the matter of Extemporary Prayers . It is plain you have brought them into practice against the opinion and constitution of the Church Governours , and of the First Reformers , who all did settle Lyturgies in the Churches which they Reformed : This Knox did in Scotland , whose Lyturgy we have ready to produce , to the Conviction of those who pretend to be his Successors , and yet condemn Forms of Prayer as Unlawful . This Luther did for Germany , and Calvin for Geneva , and for the French Church , whose Liturgyes are still used by them . Yet I find this weighs not much with you , tho' you seem to me to have little to oppose to it , besides a strange fondness and passion you have entertained for the contrary ; and let me tell you that it is no hard matter to give a reason why the generality of the people are better pleased with such Extemporary Prayers , than with Forms : For can any one wonder that a prayer which people never heard before , and is adapted to the Fancies and Humours of a Party , with all the Advantages which Novelty gives , shou'd gratifie carnal and itching Ears , more than the fixt and settled prayers of a Church , or that Form dictated by Christ himself ? To joyn in these with Devotion , requires us duly to prepare our Hearts , to strain and lift up our minds with much seriousness and attention , or we cannot be affected by them , whereas there is a pleasure , and a kind of sensual delight , in the novelty of the other Prayers ; and the tone with which they are sometimes delivered , makes the Hearers imaginarily Devout ; tho' they come to them without taking pains to strain their minds to true Devotion . But you ought to remember that Images and Relicks and Mediatory Saints had the very same effect on people long ago ; which made them so fond of them , that they brought them into their Worship , in spite of the Bishops and Pastors of the Church ; as you have now brought in Extemporary Prayers : But 't is rare to find the generality of Men fond of what is truly Spiritual ; And therefore people's fondness of your peculiar way of Worship is so far from being an Argument for it , as I find some of you use it , that on the contrary it is a shrewd presumption that it is not from God : Especially since ill people are fond of it , as well as good ; As is manifest from many undeniable Instances ; which could not be so if it were Truly , and of it self , Spiritual . 3. I would desire you to consider that nothing can generally induce our Clergy to decline these Extemporary Prayers , but their Conscience and Conviction that they are not convenient in the Publick Service of God : 'T is manifest that Extemporary Prayers would be much more easy to most of us , and less burthensome then the Service we use ; you may think otherwise , but assure your selves that you are mistaken ; And I dare appeal to those that have tryed both , whether is most easy : There are such both amongst You and Vs who have made the Experiment ; And I dare referr it to them to declare on their Consciences , which of the two Services they look on to be the greater burthen to him that performs them . Whatever You may think , if we would Indulge our selves , it were no hard matter for the meanest of Vs to pass an Extemporary Prayer on our Auditory , or to turn the Heads of our Sermons into one . Lastly , I have one thing which I would more especially request of You , that You would believe that I sincerely and heartily desire and study the good of your Souls ; and that I have in this Treatise endeavoured to promote it , and by God's Assistance ever shall in all my Undertakings . And if You had the same Apprehensions with Me , You would not wonder at my concrn in this matter ; for how is it possible that any man that has a zeal for the purity of God's Worship , should not have his Spirit moved within him to see a well-meaning people so strangely misled , as to content themselves to meet together , perhaps for some Years , with a design to Worship God , and yet hardly ever see or hear any thing of God's immmediate Apointment in their Meetings . Now to my thoughts this is manifestly the case of many of You ; since a Man may frequent some Meetings amongst You for some Years , and never hear a Prayer , a Psalm , or Chapter which has been immediately dictated by God ; and never be called on to bow his knee to God , or see either Minister or People address themselves to him in that humble posture . Lastly , never see any body offer to Administer , or desire to receive the food of Life in the Lord's-Supper . These are Melancholy Reflections to me who believe that God has required these in his Worship ; And therefore I hope you will take it in good part that I endeavour to restore them to You. I have only to add my most earnest Prayers to God for You. And to beseech him who is the God of Mercy and Purchaser of his Church , by a price Inestimable , to vouchsafe his blessing to these my Endeavours for your Souls Instruction ; That You may reap the benefit , and I the comfort of them in the great day of our Lord Jesus Christ ; who only is the true Teacher of Souls , by his Spirit ; and is able to Seal the Instructions of his Ministers to Your Hearts , to open the Eyes of Your Understandings ; and to guide You into all Truth . FINIS . Errata . PAge 5 l. 20. for words read word . pa. 13 l. 10 , r. the timbrel . p. 14 l. 16 r contrary : p. 24 l. 22 for judge it , r. judge of it . p. 33 ult . r. pursuance . p. 39 ult . Levitical . p. 41 l. 15 r. omitted , p. 45 l. 11 instead of Exclusive of the use of Forms , r promise to furnish us with words in Prayer , without the use of Sett and Premeditated Forms . p , 54 l. 6 r. rashness . p. 72 l. 15 and 16 r. people . p. 73 l. 3 r. throughly . p. 83 l. 16 instead of the first of put in a semi-colon . p. 97 l. 7 r. deceive . p. 98 l. 25 r. Meditated , p. 101 l. 11 r. Calendar . p 112 l. 1 after the same r. Person . p. 114 l. 16 r. in the next . p. 115. l. 4 de . which Ibid. p , 16 for much deelare r. much more declare . p. 118 l. 17 after for ic , r. And that . p. 120 l. 1. after and r. to . p. 127 l. 1 after Scriptures a colon . Ib. 3 after Supper a comma . p. 131 l. 7 de . are . 137 l. 16 de . their . Ib. l. 18 r. receive . p. 149 de . a. p. 164 l , 14. for owning r. own . 169 l. 3. after table a comma . Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A47436-e3420 * Much to this purpose might be urged out of the Rabbins ; but the Author thinks it fit to confine himself to Scripture . See Durel and Knoxes Book of Disc. Notes for div A47436-e16390 The Author's Intention is not to assert that the Scriptures require Kneeling at the Lord's-Supper , but to shew that it is not contrary to the Institution of Christ , or Practise of the Apostles , who compare our receiving it with the Jews partaking of their Altar , to which they approached with Adoration .