The truth of the Holy Scriptures a sermon preached at St. Martin's in the Fields, April 1, 1695 : being the fourth of the lecture for this present year, founded by the Honourable Robert Boyle, Esquire / by John Williams ... Williams, John, 1636?-1709. 1695 Approx. 43 KB of XML-encoded text transcribed from 19 1-bit group-IV TIFF page images. Text Creation Partnership, Ann Arbor, MI ; Oxford (UK) : 2009-03 (EEBO-TCP Phase 1). A66429 Wing W2736 ESTC R7718 12528759 ocm 12528759 62726 This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal . The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission. Early English books online. (EEBO-TCP ; phase 1, no. A66429) Transcribed from: (Early English Books Online ; image set 62726) Images scanned from microfilm: (Early English books, 1641-1700 ; 952:10) The truth of the Holy Scriptures a sermon preached at St. Martin's in the Fields, April 1, 1695 : being the fourth of the lecture for this present year, founded by the Honourable Robert Boyle, Esquire / by John Williams ... Williams, John, 1636?-1709. [4], 32 p. Printed for Ri. Chiswell, and Tho. Cockerill ..., London : 1695. Reproduction of original in Huntington Library. Errata: p. 32. Created by converting TCP files to TEI P5 using tcp2tei.xsl, TEI @ Oxford. Re-processed by University of Nebraska-Lincoln and Northwestern, with changes to facilitate morpho-syntactic tagging. Gap elements of known extent have been transformed into placeholder characters or elements to simplify the filling in of gaps by user contributors. EEBO-TCP is a partnership between the Universities of Michigan and Oxford and the publisher ProQuest to create accurately transcribed and encoded texts based on the image sets published by ProQuest via their Early English Books Online (EEBO) database (http://eebo.chadwyck.com). The general aim of EEBO-TCP is to encode one copy (usually the first edition) of every monographic English-language title published between 1473 and 1700 available in EEBO. EEBO-TCP aimed to produce large quantities of textual data within the usual project restraints of time and funding, and therefore chose to create diplomatic transcriptions (as opposed to critical editions) with light-touch, mainly structural encoding based on the Text Encoding Initiative (http://www.tei-c.org). The EEBO-TCP project was divided into two phases. The 25,363 texts created during Phase 1 of the project have been released into the public domain as of 1 January 2015. Anyone can now take and use these texts for their own purposes, but we respectfully request that due credit and attribution is given to their original source. Users should be aware of the process of creating the TCP texts, and therefore of any assumptions that can be made about the data. Text selection was based on the New Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (NCBEL). If an author (or for an anonymous work, the title) appears in NCBEL, then their works are eligible for inclusion. Selection was intended to range over a wide variety of subject areas, to reflect the true nature of the print record of the period. In general, first editions of a works in English were prioritized, although there are a number of works in other languages, notably Latin and Welsh, included and sometimes a second or later edition of a work was chosen if there was a compelling reason to do so. Image sets were sent to external keying companies for transcription and basic encoding. Quality assurance was then carried out by editorial teams in Oxford and Michigan. 5% (or 5 pages, whichever is the greater) of each text was proofread for accuracy and those which did not meet QA standards were returned to the keyers to be redone. After proofreading, the encoding was enhanced and/or corrected and characters marked as illegible were corrected where possible up to a limit of 100 instances per text. Any remaining illegibles were encoded as s. Understanding these processes should make clear that, while the overall quality of TCP data is very good, some errors will remain and some readable characters will be marked as illegible. Users should bear in mind that in all likelihood such instances will never have been looked at by a TCP editor. The texts were encoded and linked to page images in accordance with level 4 of the TEI in Libraries guidelines. Copies of the texts have been issued variously as SGML (TCP schema; ASCII text with mnemonic sdata character entities); displayable XML (TCP schema; characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or text strings within braces); or lossless XML (TEI P5, characters represented either as UTF-8 Unicode or TEI g elements). Keying and markup guidelines are available at the Text Creation Partnership web site . eng Revelation -- Sermons. Sermons, English -- 17th century. 2007-06 TCP Assigned for keying and markup 2007-07 Apex CoVantage Keyed and coded from ProQuest page images 2008-03 Elspeth Healey Sampled and proofread 2008-03 Elspeth Healey Text and markup reviewed and edited 2008-09 pfs Batch review (QC) and XML conversion D r WILLIAMS's FOURTH SERMON AT Mr. BOYLE'S Lecture , 1695. IMPRIMATUR , April 1. 1695. Guil. Lancaster . The Truth of the Holy Scriptures . A SERMON Preached at St. Martin's in the Fields , April 1. 1695. BEING THE Fourth of the LECTURE For this present YEAR , Founded by the Honourable ROBERT BOYLE , Esquire . By JOHN WILLIAMS , D. D. Chaplain in Ordinary to His Majesty . LONDON : Printed for Ri. Chiswell , and Tho. Cockerill , Sen r & Jun r : At the Rose and Crown in St. Paul's Church-Yard ; and at the Three Legs in the Poultrey . M DCXC V. HEB. I. 1 , 2. God who at sundry times , and in divers manners spake in time past unto the Fathers by the Prophets , hath in these last days spoken unto us by his Son , &c. IN these words , there is contained ( as I have before shewed ) 1. A description of Revelation , 't is God's speaking . 2. The Certainty of it , 't is by way of declaration , God who at sundry times , &c. 3. The Order observed in delivering this Revelation , it was at sundry times , &c. 4. The perfection and conclusion of all , 't is in these last days by his Son. Under the Second I have shewed , 1. That God has actually revealed his Will at sundry times , and in divers manners . 2. What are the Characters of true Revelation . 3. I am now in order to prove that the Scriptures of the Old and New Testament do contain the Matter of Divine Revelation , and have upon them the Characters belonging to it . For the better disposing of what I have to say under this Head of Discourse , I shall observe , 1. 'T is one thing to assert and prove the matter of Scripture to be true , and another to prove it to be of Divine Revelation . 2. 'T is one thing to prove the matter of Scripture to be of Divine Revelation , and another to prove these Books to be of Divine Inspiration . 3. 'T is one thing to assert that there were once such Books so inspired ; and another thing to prove this Set of Books , which now make up and compose the Canon of the Old and New Testament , to be those very Books . From hence arise Four Questions , viz. Quest . 1. How we can prove the Matter of Scripture to be true ? Q. 2. How we can prove the Matter of Scripture to be of Divine Revelation ? Books of mere Human Composition may contain nothing but Truth , without any Supernatural Assistance ; and therefore though we were never so well able to maintain and prove the Truth of the Matter , that is not sufficient , unless we can advance higher , and prove the Authority and Divinity of the Matter ? Q. 3. How we can prove those Books to be of Divine Inspiration ? The Epistle of Clemens Romanus was sometime read in the Church ( as the Apocrypha anciently was , and is now with us ) because of the Excellency and Profitableness of the Matter ; but yet it was not esteemed to be Canonical , and of immediate Inspiration from God ? Q ▪ 4. How we prove these Books , that are now extant and received by the Christian Church as Canonical , to be those Books which were once in time past wrote by Inspiration from God ? It will be of some use to us in the prosecution of this Argument , to consider the First Question , concerning the Truth of the Matter of Scripture , by it self , and apart from the Divine Authority of it . Now the Matter of Scripture is of various nature , such as Morality , Doctrinal Revelation , Institution , Prophecy and History : Of which the greatest part will be here set aside : For it is not necessary to prove the Truth of the Moral part of it , which is no other than the Dictate of Nature ; and therefore , though explain'd , confirmed , and illustrated in Scripture by many useful Rules , Principles and Observations , needs no proof . That of Doctrine and Institution , falls in with the Divine Authority , and so belongs to the Second Question . Prophecy , if yet to be accomplished , is not capable of other proof than Revelation ; and if already fulfilled , by the Event following and correspondent to the Prediction , it is the proof of it self . So that the Part now remaining to be proved more especially , is Scripture ▪ History ; which is a Relation of matter of Fact , of what has happened , been declared , or done , in the several Periods and Ages of the World for Four thousand Years together , and upwards . Under which Notion , I do not question but it may be made appear , That there is more to be said for the truth of Scripture-History , than for any thing of that kind in the whole World. I don't question again , but it may be made appear , that no Authors had greater advantages for Information in the Subjects they treat of ; nor were there ever any Writings that bore upon them more ample marks of Ability , Impartiality , and Care. So that if after all that is to be suspected , nothing of that kind is certain , and we call in question all matters of the like nature whatsoever . But this is further to be inquired into . Now of this kind , there are some things to be found only in Scripture , and no where else . In which case we have no other way to judge of the truth of it , than by the Credibility of the matter , the Self-agreement , its Concordance with time , place , and other circumstances of Action , together with the Credit and Reputation of the Pen-men of it . But there are other things which fall in with other Writings ; and then besides the former way of trial , we are to have recourse to such Books , to compare them , and determine concerning the truth by such a comparison . So that we have three sorts of Proof before us , or so many Characters by which we may judge concerning the Truth of what the Scripture relates : viz. 1. The Credibility of the Matter therein revealed . 2. Self consistence and Self agreement . 3. It s concordance with other Books of good and sufficient Authority ; where such there are . And if this be made out , we have as much Evidence for the Truth of Scripture as is possible to have , in our circumstances ; and where the Matters related were transacted in place and time far remote from us . For all the Evidence we can have , is to be resolved into Testimony , and that Testimony into the Credibility of the Relators , or of the Matters related : And if we have as much Evidence of this kind as the nature of the thing will bear and admit , we have as much as is reasonable in it self , and sufficient to ground a certainty upon . For according as the nature of the thing is , and the ground upon which its Proof and Evidence depends , such is the Certainty : And as in things Mathematical , Demonstration is the Proof ; and in things Natural and Sensible , Sense is the Proof ; and in things Rational and Moral , Reason and Argument are the Proof ; so in Matters of Fact ( where we our selves are not present ) Testimony and Records are the Proof ; though for a further confirmation of it , there is the collateral proof of Moral Evidence , viz. the credibility of the Matter , and the Persons , into whose Testimony and Veracity the Matters are finally resolved . And beyond this we cannot go , in the Evidence for the truth of the Matters of Fact ; and consequently , if we have this Evidence , we have as great a certainty in things of this nature , as Demonstration is in things Mathematical , and Sense in things sensible ; I say , beyond this we cannot go , unless we advance to supernatural Evidence ; but that belongs not to this place . So that here we have no reason to doubt ; and where there is no reason to doubt , there is certainty . And if we can be certain of any thing we our selves have not seen , or been present at , we may be certain of what is recorded in the Scripture : Since there is no Evidence for any thing of that kind , which we have not for the Truth of Scripture ; and I may say we have that Evidence for it , which no Matters of Fact besides have . If then there be any certainty in such things , if any credit be to be given to them ; then there is here a sufficient Evidence to ground that Certainty and our Belief of it upon : And if there be no certainty in them , and no ground to believe them ; then there is no certainty in the world , and no credit to be given to whatever is , or has been allow'd by others in the world : Then there is no more credit to be given to the Commentaries of Caesar ( which he wrote himself ) nor to the Histories of the Four Empires , nay to those of our own Nation ; than there is to Achilles Tatius or Heliodorus , than to the Vainest Romances , the Fables of Poets , or the Legends of the most Superstitious and Credulous Ages of the world . And with all our Histories , though never so famed , and commonly received ; we are in no better a condition , than if Varro's fabulous and obscure Age had been continued , and all the Ages were now this day what it was before the Olympiads , wrapt up in Invention and Conjecture . But if there be any credit to be given to such Memorials , and that we read approved Histories with another sort of appetite and assurance , than we do Fables ; and that we read Lucan ( a Poetical Historian ) with another sort of relish than Ovid's Metamorphoses ; then the like Credit is to be given to the Scriptures as to any ; and so much the more , as the Evidence proper to its kind is beyond the Evidence we have for any other Writings whatsoever . And this I shall undertake and prosecute , by proving , 1. That the Scripture has sufficient Evidence of that kind to ground a certainty upon . 2. That it has all the Evidence that any Writings or Matters of this kind have , and more . In order to which it may well serve as an Introduction to what is to follow , briefly to reflect upon the Writers themselves and their Qualifications ; upon whose Credit and Authority there must be confessedly sometimes an absolute reliance . Since the Relators of matters of Fact profess not to Write out of their own Heads , but to receive what they Write from a constant and uninterrupted Tradition , or to Collect from the best Records and Memorials , or to set down what is of their own Knowledge and Observation : And therefore the Reputation of their Reports and Narratives doth very much depend upon their Skill and Judgment , that they be not abused by false Informations , and upon their Honesty and Integrity in not putting abuses upon the World. As for the ways of Information , there is nothing of that kind wanting in the Sacred Pen-men . For the First Writer , Moses , lived so near upon the Traditionary Age , and the things he Writes of are of such a nature , as may well be supposed to be deliver'd down without any difficulty from Progenitors to Posterity , had there been no other means of Conveyance ; and especially ( as has been before suggested , Sermon II. ) if we consider the few hands they were to pass through , when at the most Eight Persons only in succession continued the Line of above Two thousand five hundred years , from the Deluge to the time of Moses ; and that the Matters were snch as all those held themselves concerned to deliver them down as they had received them . Forasmuch as all the Prophecies they had receiv'd , which concerned the Good of Mankind , and of their Posterity , depended upon the careful and faithful preservation of these Memorials ; both as to Time and Pedigrees , as well as the Matters which the Series of Times and Descents were to be the great Supporters of . From hence it was afterwards that these Chronological Tables , and Genealogical Rolls were in all times exactly kept , and which upon occasion they might have recourse to ; and that there were Annals in future Ages that were looked upon as Sacred Repositories : And from whence the Holy Writers drew their Materials , and to which they do Refer , as may be observed in the Books of Kings and Chronicles . But if we add hereunto , That a great part of what is the Subject of Holy Writ , was what the Writers themselves had the Personal Knowledge of , bore a part in , and what happened in their own Times ; it gives the greater Authority to what they have Written . And this was the case of Moses as to the Four last of his Books ; of Joshua , of Samuel , of the Prophets , and of the Evangelical Writers . So that if we will grant any thing to be allowed to Tradition , to Records of Ages , to Reports of Eye and Ear-Witnesses , there is the highest Credit to be given to the Divine Authors , in what they have Collected and made Report of . And what has been done with so much Faithfulness , Impartiality , and Judgment ( as their Composers testify ) that even that what tends to the disparagement of their Nation and Ancestors , their Families and Persons , is not concealed , when it might tend to the Glory of God , the Reasons of the Divine Proceedings towards them , or the giving any Life to the Matters they Relate . A practice rarely to be observed in other Authors ; and when it is , doth give Credit to what they Report . But the chief thing is the Credibility of the Matter ( which I shall now proceed to ) 1. The Credibility of the Matter , which is a standing Character that we are to judge of the Truth of a Relation by . But then we must judge aright concerning the Credibility of it . For that at first sight may seem to be Incredible , which upon farther consideration and examination may prove to be Credible : As St. Paul saith to Agrippa , Acts ●6 . 8. Why should it be thought a thing incredible with you that God should raise the dead ? It might seem a thing Incredible at the first proposal , as it did to the Athenians Acts 17. 32. but the Apostle states the Case right , 1 Cor. 15. 35. in Answer to that Question , Some man will say , How are the dead raised up , and with what body do they come ? thou fool , that which thou sowest is not quickned except it die . And that which thou sowest , thou sowest not that body that shall be , but God giveth it a body , &c. Where he first of all confirms it by a like Instance in Nature , and then resolves it into the Power of God. 'T is for want of these Two Considerations , that is , of the Understanding of Nature , the Order , Power , and Operation of second Causes ; and of the Power of God , the Supreme Cause , that we often mistake about the Credibility of things ; and judge that to be Impossible and Incredible , which in it self , and often in the Event proves to be Possible and Credible . And thus it frequently fares in matters of Fact , of the Credibility or Incredibility of which , we are as liable to mistake , as about the Possibility or impossibility of Effects in Nature ; when we judge of other Nations and Ages by our own , and of what we do not know , by what we do ; and sometimes are so vain as to reason against others Experience and Observation . Thus it was with the Ancients , that thought the Torrid-Zone Uninhabitable ; and with others , that accounted the Opinion of Antipodes Fabulous and Impossible . Hence it is that the Errors of former Writers are so often Corrected by Modern Observations . But this we may confidently affirm of the Holy Scripture , that after it has stood the Test of above Three thousand Years in whole or in part ( for so long is it since the time of Moses ) and that nothing has been left unattempted by its Adversaries to overthrow its Authority , it has yet maintained it , so as to be the most Exact , Faithful , and Impartial Relation the World ever had . For the better Judging of whose Veracity , and Confirming its Credibility , we may observe ; 1. That a great part of it carries with it its own Evidence , and has the common Consent of Mankind to attest it . Such I account the History of the Creation of the World , the Formation of Man , and the Degeneracy of Human Nature , to be . The first of these was universally acknowledged ; nor was the Creation of the World ever Questioned or Disputed , till above a Thousand Years after the time of Moses ( as Aristotle , who was of that Opinion , acknowledges , de Coelo , lib. 1. cap. 10 ▪ ) . And the last was the Observation of all Ages . 2. There is a Relation of such things in Scripture , as have in them the face and appearance of Truth ; and of which no certain or tolerable account can be given by any other Monuments of History that are , or ever were extant in the World. Such are the Age of the World ; the Dispersion of Nations ; the Variety of Languages ; the Distribution of Time , &c. Now if the Account given of these things in Scripture be True , we are capable of Solving the greatest Difficulties as to these Matters . And that they are True , there is good Reason to conclude . As for Instance , let us consider the Instances before given , viz. ( 1. ) The Origine of the World as it is in Genesis . I acknowlege there may be nothing in the Composition of it , or in the Course of Nature , to determine this Point more in favour of Moses , than of the Egyptians , Chaldeans , or Chinese . But to lay aside all other Arguments from the Novelty of Arts and Sciences , and the reputed Inventors of them ; it is certain that in the Account given by Moses there is an Exact Order , the Narration begins and is carried on with a strict Coherence ; and let us trace it back from the Flood to Adam ; or from Abraham ( suppose ) to the Flood , there is a very regular Relation of Persons and things . But besides the Incredibility of the other , of the Thousands of the Egyptians , the Hundred thousands of the Chaldeans , and the Millions of the Chineses ; it all ends at last in Fable , in Apotheoses , or imaginary Gods and Heroes , and Self-Contradictions ( as has been shewn by many Learned Writers on this Argument ) . ( 2. ) As to the Dispersion of Nations , and the Consequents of it , the Pedigree of Moses is justified in the Names of Places agreeing with those of the Persons ; as has been abundantly proved by Bochart in his Geographia Sacra . And which would appear to the Eye of every Reader , if a Table was made of the Tenth Chapter of Genesis , and compared with the Ancient Geography ; and should have been here inserted , were there a place for it . ( 3. ) As to the Distribution of Time , there is an orderly Progression , both with respect to the Genealogies of Families , and the several Periods from the Creation to the Flood , from thence to the Law at Sinai , from thence to the Rearing of Solomon's Temple , from thence to the Captivity , and from that to our Saviour's Death . Time and Place are good Characters of the Truth of any matter of Fact , as well as good Marks and Directors ; and carry in them a great appearance of Truth where they are to be found . And then none can be presumed to be more certain than the Scripture , where the Relation these had to the Messiah , and each Person had to his Tribe , and each Tribe to its Place and Scituation , made them to be scrupulously exact and Critical . 3. There are other things that are highly Credible , and have nothing difficult to be admitted ; and if admitted , are a wonderful Instance of the Divine Providence ; as in the Punishment of profligate and incorrigible Wickedness , in the Two Notorious Examples of the Deluge and Sodom ; 2 Pet. 2. 5 , 6 : So in the Preservation of Pious Persons , such as Noah , Abraham , Lot , Joseph , David , &c. But above all is this evident in God's erecting , establishing , guiding and preserving his Church , when in Egypt , in Canaan , though perpetually surrounded with watchful and malicious Adversaries ; and recovering so much of it out of Captivity as was sufficient in a continued Succession to answer the end of accomplishing all the Scripture-Prophecies in the Person of the Messiah , that was to descend from the Lineage of Abraham , the Tribe of Judah , and the Family of David . So that as the Ancient Genealogies , together with the Chronology of Scripture , were carefully recorded , to demonstrate to succeeding Generations that the World had a beginning , and a late beginning in comparison : So the later Genealogies from Abraham were very exactly preserved , that so it might appear to all the World , that what had been foretold above 1800 years before , was in its order and time punctually fulfilled : Which if the Genealogies had been lost or confounded , could not have been observed ; and so we had been wanting in a considerable Evidence of the Descent of our Saviour , and consequently of his being the Messiah . Indeed the whole Scripture History is little else than the History of Divine Providence ; where there is an admirable concatenation of Relations of various kinds , but all subservient to the same End ; and were there an Extract made of it , and all the Events rehearsed , and Operations therein described , brought into one entire Body , it would be the best Commentary on that Divine Subject in the whole World , and infinitely beyond any Human Composure . 4. There are ▪ other things that are difficult , either as to the Relations themselves , or the manner and circumstances of them ; but what should no more prejudice us against the truth and certainty of the things related , and much less of the whole , than the Difficulties of Divine Providence should warrant us to deny it ; and for want of not understanding some of its Operations , or Events , we should take encouragement to deny what we do understand . 'T is an excellent Saying of St. Austin , De Doctrina , l. 4. c. 6. ( speaking of the Divine Writers ) Where I do understand them , there is nothing seems to me more wisely or more eloquently expressed : But where I do not understand them , there to me appears less of their Eloquence ; but yet I do not doubt it to be such , as it is where I understand it . We ought rather to suspend our Censure , with the modesty of this Father , and for the sake of what we do understand , think the more favourably of what we do not . And therefore , as when we have uncontroulable Reason to believe a Providence , the difficulties about it are no sufficient reason to call the Doctrine of Divine Providence into question : So when we have so great reason to believe the Scripture's Relation of things to be true , the Difficulties about it ought not to derogate from its Veracity ; nor give us the confidence any more to question the Truth of Scripture , than the Certainty of Providence . For by this way of proceeding , not only the Truth of Scripture , but of all other Books whatsoever will be overthrown ; nay the plainest and most obvious appearances in Nature . And yet of this kind are many of the Objections that are brought into the Field , and are made to serve in the Cause of Impiety : Such as these , That we don't know into whose hands those Books have fallen , nor in what Copies such various Readings have been found ; or whether there are not more of that kind in other hands . Theol. Polit. c. 7. The issue of all which is , That if this will invalidate the Truth of Scripture , it will also invalidate that of all Writings whatsoever ; and so is no more to be regarded , than an Argument against Motion , which is rather to be contemned than answered . 'T is but reasonable then that we should give the same quarter to the Scripture , that we allow to other Writings . And therefore all Objections levell'd against the Scriptures , which will equally be managed against any others , ought not to be allowed , unless we will give credit to nothing but what we our selves hear and see : And then to carry on the Cause , We must recede again , since there are thousands of Cases happen , where even our own Senses may be subject to Error and Mistake . II. Another Character for the proof or discovery of the truth of History , is Self-consistence and Agreement . This is a necessary Character , and absolutely requisite to all true History ; for nothing more shews the weakness and injudiciousness of a Writer , than that he comprehends not his own Design ; and 't is a sign he doth not comprehend it , that contradicts himself , and makes one part to disagree with another . I grant that this alone is not an infallible Character of Truth , that it is self-consistent ; for where the Plat is wholly fictitious and imaginary , there may be an exact agreement throughout the whole : The Model may be so regularly squared , and laid out , that there may be a becoming Symetry ; and Place , and Time , and all Circumstances made to concur , to set it off with the greater advantage . But though this may be , where Truth is not ; yet that cannot be true , which is without it , Truth being always consistent with it self . But there is this above all others observable in Scripture , That it is a System of several Books , wrote by several Persons , in several Ages , on several Subjects ; and yet however different in Style and Phrase , Method and Order , are like the several Features in the Face , that besides the sweetness in each alone , there is what we call Beauty , that arises from the mixture of all . Thus it is in the Sacred History , which has a great variety in it of matter , dispersed up and down sometimes to quicken the Appetite , and excite the Diligence of the Reader , where each has its Order and Use : But when considered in one complex Body , and compared and shewn together , there is such a wonderful Agreement between the Old Testament and the New , the Types and Anti-Types , the Predictions and the Events , &c. that it makes a very beauteous , lively , and admirable Appearance , without any such inconsistencies as may make it liable to have its Veracity questioned , if duly consider'd , and seriously examined . I say , if duly consider'd , and seriously examin'd ; for else it must be acknowledged , that there are some appearances of this kind . 1. But I account not those to be Inconsistencies , which in other Authors may justly be esteemed Errors of the Transcribers ; and for which no Author suffers in his Reputation . As for instance , When the Famous Historian Herodotus in one place saith , That Homer lived about Four hundred Years before his Time ; and in another place , That it was about Six hundred . This escape doth not lessen his Reputation among Judicious Persons ; but for all that , he preserves the Character of Pater Historiarum ▪ and is esteemed as no injudicious or careless Writer . And so if a greater number in Scripture is taken for a less , or a less for a greater , when there are sufficient Directions therein for the Correction of it ; 't is not reasonable to charge this as an inconsistency , and to urge it as a reason for the overthrowing the Credit and Veracity of it . If it be said , How doth it appear that they are the Faults of the Transcriber ? A. I Answer , 'T is apparently so sometimes , as may be observed in the various Readings ; which could not be , were there not such mistakes in the Transcriber : And where it doth not appear so to be , we ought in reason so to judge , where there are all the appearances of Faithfulness , Diligence , and Observation in the Writers themselves . As for instance , What can be more exactly Penn'd than the Book of Joshua , in which there is a punctual account of the Scituation and bounds of each Tribe , as it was set out and describ'd by Joshua himself , the Chief Arbiter and Director of all ; and if there should be found in his Book any Literal Errors , one Name put for another , or a different Reading of the same Names , we cannot in reason judge it to be an oversight of so Sufficient , and so Careful a Writer , but that it might proceed from some one that Transcribed it after the 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 〈◊〉 , or Original Copy , in some successive Generations , and which in reason 't is impossible wholly to prevent . 'T is not here necessary for me to enter upon a debate , how far the Providence of God doth herein concern it self in preserving the Text free from all Corruptions : I am now Treating upon this Argument humanly speaking , and of the Truth of it separately from its Divine Authority . And admitting there are such petty Errors that creep in by such imperceptible ways , though we cannot tell when or how they came in , and have been disseminated into all Copies , for ought we know , that are Extant ; yet I don't know any reason why they should be charged upon the Original and the Compiler of it ; nor how the main Cause is herein concerned . It is a respect due and given to all Authors of any Repute for their Care and Fidelity , that Write consistently as to the main , to pass the most favourable Construction upon any such little Errors ; which if theirs , were not voluntary ; or rather , not to make them theirs , without an apparent necessity for it . And surely we should not then press the case with the utmost severity , and make that , which is in it self , and in all Books besides , a Venial Error , to be no less than a Mortal one in the Scripture , and to stab its Veracity to the heart , and spoil its Credit for ever for the future . If it be said there is more reason for this in the case of Scripture than in any other Book ; because That alone pretends to Divine Authority . I Answer , That for the present is not the matter under Consideration ; we are now upon the Point of its Truth , and content our selves to enter upon this Debate , as if it had no pretence to Divine Authority and Inspiration . And so we claim the same Favour and Right on its behalf , as we do for any other Author's Credit and Repute , of great Antiquity ; and general Reception . And therefore there ought no such Arguments or Objections to be urg'd for the Invalidity of its Authority , which it is not decent or reasonable to offer against other Writings ; and we may reasonably claim the same allowance for that which all Mankind do give , or in reason ought to give , in things of this nature . 2. I don't account these to be Inconsistencies or Contradictions , which do not affect the main body or part of the History ; but that are like a Parenthesis in a Sentence , that whether inserted or omitted , the sence is perfect and compleat . And therefore when the History of Jacob blessing his Sons is the Subject under Consideration ; whether it was as Gen. 47. 31. He bowed himself upon the bed's-head , or as Heb. 11. 21. He worshipped — upon the top of his staff ; is not material . And so it may be in many cases besides ; But what real prejudice will redound to the Reader by the mistake of any thing of this kind , or what prejudice is there to the Relation , when a thing of no moment is omitted or inserted , exchanged or altered ? I say not this as if I despaired of having an account given of these matters ( for that I am sensible is to be done , as in the Case before-recited ) but to shew how unreasonable it is to condemn Scripture for that which we will let others go away with , free from all Blame and Censure ; and they shall be good and laudable Writers , and their Histories admitted to be true and exact , though they have many Errors of this kind ; and in the mean while the other shall be sifted to the very bottom , and every Molehill be a Mountain ; and upon every little supposed defect , it shall be said , It has been weighed in the balance of Reason and Examination , and has been found too light . Thus partial are these sort of persons , while they malevolently lay the Right hand upon the youngest , and their Left upon the eldest . If indeed the inconsistency were like a Disease in the Vitals , that affects the Heart or the Brain , it is to be accounted Mortal ; if it did affect the main Body of the Relation , and had originally proceeded from the Author , it would have been a just Allegation , and his Truth and Fidelity , his Knowledge , and his Care might with good reason be called in question . But that we deny ; and appeal to all the various Readings and Observations on Scripture as our Compurgators in this point . And consequently the Scripture will so far remain as a true Relator of matters of Fact , and may compare with , and be deservedly set above all other Writings whatsoever ; in which no one Man , whose hand pass'd through the whole Work , can compare with that to which so many Hands in various Circumstances , at several times did so exactly concur and agree , as if they had been wrote by one Hand and at one Time , and were but one intire Argument running through the whole . III. Another Character is the Agreement of Scripture with other Authors ; when such there are . I may well say , when such there are . Since it is evident that there are no Writers can pretend to the like Antiquity with Moses ; and then we must wholy rely on his Authority for what he relates . But however , though the most ancient among the Heathens are much later than him , and so wanted those Advantages for Information which he had ; yet they ( so far as they agree with him ) give a Confirmation and Credibility to what he relates , since they deliver it as the Sense of the Ages before , and of those in which they themselves lived . It is not here so much to our purpose to enquire from whence they derived the knowledge of the things they relate , whether from the Jews , or from the general Tradition ( which was best to be known from the Eastern Parts of the World ) as it is to observe their concurrence in them with the Sacred Writers . It is indeed probable that the Ancient Writers of the Heathens were ( if at all ) less beholding to the Jews for their Information , and the Later more ; as may be observed from the great difference between the one and the other , the later being much plainer in many things than the former : For the higher we ascend from the time of the Olympiads , the more intricate , obscure , and fabulous they are . So that generally speaking , it is with them as Plutarch saith of Geographers , That rather than leave any vacant places in their Maps , fill them up with inaccessible Mountains , Frozen Seas , or Monsters . So when such Historians would compleat their Narratives ; rather than be deficient in it , they insert wonderful and tragical Stories ; and like Nations that can give no account of their Pedigree and Original , derive themselves from the gods , or from the Earth , and become Aborigines . But however , though this be too truly the state of the World for about 3000 Years from the Creation ; yet there is a mixture of fine Gold with the greater dross ; and from whence we may extract so much as may serve to confirm what the Scripture advances for Truth , and we for the sake of it receive as such ; as might be shewn . This is a Tract has been often beaten by Ancients and Moderns , by Aristobulus and Josephus among the Jews ; by several of the Fathers , such as Justin Martyr , Tertullian , Eusebius , &c. and by many in these Days . And it were easy to form a History out of them ; especially if we change but the Names , and instead of Saturn , read Adam ; and instead of Pandora , Eve ; instead of the Garden of Jupiter , Eden ; instead of Ogyges or Deucalion , Noah , &c. for we should find more of the Truth under the disguise of the Fable than at the first appears ; and that the former gave occasion frequently to the later . But over and above this , we have a great part of the Ancient History of Scripture confirm'd by the express Testimony of some of their gravest and strictest Writers , as the Collection that has been made in that way by several of the Learned , shews . To go no further than that of Moses , who is placed by some of them in the first rank of the chiefest Lawgivers , and whose Wonders in Egypt , and at the Red-Sea , are not obscurely referr'd to by them . 4. When there is a Disagreement between the Scripture and other Authors , there is sufficient reason to prefer the former before the later , and to rectify these by that . As for the first 3000 Years it is acknowledged , That there was elsewhere little else than Fable and Conjecture , Confusion and uncertain Tradition , as has been before observed : And who is there that is not able to see the difference between an Adam and a Saturn , a Noah and Bacchus , a Moses and Mercury ; between the Building of the Babylonish Tower , and the War of the Giants with the gods ; that is , between the true History and the Fable ? Who can observe the various Accounts amongst the Pagan Writers , their inconsistencies one with another , their apparent ignorance of what they write about , especially when it concerns other Nations or Ages , than those in which themselves liv'd ; but must needs surrender up the Cause , and own that the one has much the advantage of the other in point of Credibility ? So that setting aside the Divine Authority of Scripture , yet it has upon it all the Characters of Truth , which any Book or Books in the World can pretend : And if there be any thing necessary more than what those have , to establish its certainty and Credibility , that is not wanting . In conclusion , After all the attempt made to weaken its Authority , it is with no better success than that of Celsus or Hierocles , who endeavoured to set up an Aristeas or an Appollonius , in Competition with our Blessed Saviour ; and opposed their pitiful Shifts and Impostures , to his approved and incontestable Miracles . But there is somewhat farther to be respected . Hitherto we have consider'd the Scripture as able and sufficient to support it self without any supernatural Aid ; and by the sole evidence of Humane Testimony , and such Characters as belong to other Writings in common with that : But there is a further point in reserve , and which I had chiefly in my Eye , and that is an Authority superior to all others , and peculiar to Scripture , That I mean of Divine Revelation ▪ and what for the matter of it was inspired from above . And this , the due Consideration of it as an excellent History will open a way to ; when we find not only all the Principles , Precepts , and Means , that are necessary to a virtuous Life therein taught and prescribed ; but also admirable Examples of it in Fact , that nothing might be wanting to animate and incourage us to the like practice . See it in the Noah's , the Abraham's , the Joseph's , the Job's , the Moses's , the David's , and all the Patriarchs of old . See it in the Holy Apostles , the Martyrs and Confessors ; but above all in the Example of Examples , our Blessed Saviour . Here is a History , that fills the Mind with the best Ideas and Images of things , that represents the Instances of our Duty with all the advantage to our Thoughts , that recommends it self to our Attention by the importance and profitableness of the Argument , as well as the force of its Authority . Upon this therefore let us dwell , and make it the delightful Subject of our most serious Hours , which will abundantly reward all our Pains , and is sufficient to furnish us throughly unto all good Works . FINIS . ERRATA . PAge 11. l. 19. for Composers r. Composures , ibid. l. 23. after Glory of God , add to the manifestation of , p. 16. l ▪ 19. for them r. the Jews , p. 18. l. 3. after events add therein ▪ Notes, typically marginal, from the original text Notes for div A66429-e280 Euterpe . c. 53. Vita Hom. Bochart , Huetius , Dr. Stillingfleet , &c.