id sid tid token lemma pos crl-13533 1 1 college college NOUN crl-13533 1 2 and and CCONJ crl-13533 1 3 research research NOUN crl-13533 1 4 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 1 5 frederick frederick PROPN crl-13533 1 6 duda duda PROPN crl-13533 1 7 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 1 8 's 's PART crl-13533 1 9 two two NUM crl-13533 1 10 - - PUNCT crl-13533 1 11 track track NOUN crl-13533 1 12 system system NOUN crl-13533 1 13 the the DET crl-13533 1 14 two two NUM crl-13533 1 15 - - PUNCT crl-13533 1 16 track track NOUN crl-13533 1 17 system system NOUN crl-13533 1 18 of of ADP crl-13533 1 19 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 1 20 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 1 21 and and CCONJ crl-13533 1 22 position position NOUN crl-13533 1 23 categories category NOUN crl-13533 1 24 at at ADP crl-13533 1 25 the the DET crl-13533 1 26 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 1 27 university university PROPN crl-13533 1 28 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 1 29 was be AUX crl-13533 1 30 implemented implement VERB crl-13533 1 31 in in ADP crl-13533 1 32 1973 1973 NUM crl-13533 1 33 - - SYM crl-13533 1 34 74 74 NUM crl-13533 1 35 , , PUNCT crl-13533 1 36 developing develop VERB crl-13533 1 37 . . PUNCT crl-13533 2 1 from from ADP crl-13533 2 2 an an DET crl-13533 2 3 earlier early ADJ crl-13533 2 4 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 2 5 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 2 6 recommendation recommendation NOUN crl-13533 2 7 . . PUNCT crl-13533 3 1 the the DET crl-13533 3 2 origins origin NOUN crl-13533 3 3 of of ADP crl-13533 3 4 the the DET crl-13533 3 5 system system NOUN crl-13533 3 6 are be AUX crl-13533 3 7 directly directly ADV crl-13533 3 8 related relate VERB crl-13533 3 9 to to ADP crl-13533 3 10 the the DET crl-13533 3 11 response response NOUN crl-13533 3 12 of of ADP crl-13533 3 13 the the DET crl-13533 3 14 librarians librarians PROPN crl-13533 3 15 to to ADP crl-13533 3 16 the the DET crl-13533 3 17 " " PUNCT crl-13533 3 18 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 3 19 crisis crisis NOUN crl-13533 3 20 of of ADP crl-13533 3 21 1968 1968 NUM crl-13533 3 22 " " PUNCT crl-13533 3 23 and and CCONJ crl-13533 3 24 to to ADP crl-13533 3 25 the the DET crl-13533 3 26 issue issue NOUN crl-13533 3 27 of of ADP crl-13533 3 28 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 3 29 status status NOUN crl-13533 3 30 . . PUNCT crl-13533 4 1 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 4 2 's 's PART crl-13533 4 3 statutory statutory ADJ crl-13533 4 4 recognition recognition NOUN crl-13533 4 5 of of ADP crl-13533 4 6 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 4 7 as as ADP crl-13533 4 8 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 4 9 officers officer NOUN crl-13533 4 10 of of ADP crl-13533 4 11 the the DET crl-13533 4 12 university university NOUN crl-13533 4 13 as as ADV crl-13533 4 14 early early ADV crl-13533 4 15 as as ADP crl-13533 4 16 1911 1911 NUM crl-13533 4 17 clearly clearly ADV crl-13533 4 18 • • NOUN crl-13533 4 19 influenced influence VERB crl-13533 4 20 both both CCONJ crl-13533 4 21 the the DET crl-13533 4 22 university university NOUN crl-13533 4 23 's 's PART crl-13533 4 24 responsiveness responsiveness NOUN crl-13533 4 25 to to ADP crl-13533 4 26 the the DET crl-13533 4 27 development development NOUN crl-13533 4 28 of of ADP crl-13533 4 29 the the DET crl-13533 4 30 system system NOUN crl-13533 4 31 and and CCONJ crl-13533 4 32 the the DET crl-13533 4 33 staffs staff NOUN crl-13533 4 34 concern concern NOUN crl-13533 4 35 for for ADP crl-13533 4 36 improving improve VERB crl-13533 4 37 the the DET crl-13533 4 38 status status NOUN crl-13533 4 39 of of ADP crl-13533 4 40 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 4 41 and and CCONJ crl-13533 4 42 developing develop VERB crl-13533 4 43 meaningful meaningful ADJ crl-13533 4 44 criteria criterion NOUN crl-13533 4 45 for for ADP crl-13533 4 46 the the DET crl-13533 4 47 recognition recognition NOUN crl-13533 4 48 of of ADP crl-13533 4 49 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 4 50 distinction distinction NOUN crl-13533 4 51 . . PUNCT crl-13533 5 1 the the DET crl-13533 5 2 general general ADJ crl-13533 5 3 outline outline NOUN crl-13533 5 4 of of ADP crl-13533 5 5 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 5 6 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 5 7 organization organization NOUN crl-13533 5 8 at at ADP crl-13533 5 9 the the DET crl-13533 5 10 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 5 11 university university PROPN crl-13533 5 12 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 5 13 includes include VERB crl-13533 5 14 two two NUM crl-13533 5 15 parallel parallel ADJ crl-13533 5 16 elements element NOUN crl-13533 5 17 , , PUNCT crl-13533 5 18 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 5 19 1 1 X crl-13533 5 20 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 5 21 a a DET crl-13533 5 22 system system NOUN crl-13533 5 23 of of ADP crl-13533 5 24 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 5 25 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 5 26 and and CCONJ crl-13533 5 27 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 5 28 2 2 X crl-13533 5 29 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 5 30 a a DET crl-13533 5 31 system system NOUN crl-13533 5 32 of of ADP crl-13533 5 33 position position NOUN crl-13533 5 34 categories category NOUN crl-13533 5 35 . . PUNCT crl-13533 6 1 with with ADP crl-13533 6 2 the the DET crl-13533 6 3 exception exception NOUN crl-13533 6 4 of of ADP crl-13533 6 5 a a DET crl-13533 6 6 few few ADJ crl-13533 6 7 senior senior ADJ crl-13533 6 8 officers officer NOUN crl-13533 6 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 6 10 each each DET crl-13533 6 11 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 6 12 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 6 13 holds hold VERB crl-13533 6 14 a a DET crl-13533 6 15 position position NOUN crl-13533 6 16 that that PRON crl-13533 6 17 is be AUX crl-13533 6 18 classified classify VERB crl-13533 6 19 into into ADP crl-13533 6 20 one one NUM crl-13533 6 21 of of ADP crl-13533 6 22 five five NUM crl-13533 6 23 categories category NOUN crl-13533 6 24 on on ADP crl-13533 6 25 the the DET crl-13533 6 26 basis basis NOUN crl-13533 6 27 of of ADP crl-13533 6 28 the the DET crl-13533 6 29 degree degree NOUN crl-13533 6 30 of of ADP crl-13533 6 31 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 6 32 or or CCONJ crl-13533 6 33 policymaking policymake VERB crl-13533 6 34 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 6 35 involved involve VERB crl-13533 6 36 . . PUNCT crl-13533 7 1 in in ADP crl-13533 7 2 addition addition NOUN crl-13533 7 3 to to ADP crl-13533 7 4 a a DET crl-13533 7 5 position position NOUN crl-13533 7 6 assignment assignment NOUN crl-13533 7 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 7 8 each each DET crl-13533 7 9 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 7 10 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 7 11 member member NOUN crl-13533 7 12 holds hold VERB crl-13533 7 13 a a DET crl-13533 7 14 title title NOUN crl-13533 7 15 denoting denote VERB crl-13533 7 16 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 7 17 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 7 18 , , PUNCT crl-13533 7 19 which which PRON crl-13533 7 20 is be AUX crl-13533 7 21 independent independent ADJ crl-13533 7 22 of of ADP crl-13533 7 23 the the DET crl-13533 7 24 position position NOUN crl-13533 7 25 and and CCONJ crl-13533 7 26 which which PRON crl-13533 7 27 reflects reflect VERB crl-13533 7 28 the the DET crl-13533 7 29 level level NOUN crl-13533 7 30 of of ADP crl-13533 7 31 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 7 32 achievement achievement NOUN crl-13533 7 33 of of ADP crl-13533 7 34 the the DET crl-13533 7 35 individual individual NOUN crl-13533 7 36 , , PUNCT crl-13533 7 37 largely largely ADV crl-13533 7 38 as as SCONJ crl-13533 7 39 seen see VERB crl-13533 7 40 by by ADP crl-13533 7 41 peers peer NOUN crl-13533 7 42 , , PUNCT crl-13533 7 43 that that ADV crl-13533 7 44 is is ADV crl-13533 7 45 , , PUNCT crl-13533 7 46 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 7 47 within within ADP crl-13533 7 48 the the DET crl-13533 7 49 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 7 50 system system NOUN crl-13533 7 51 and and CCONJ crl-13533 7 52 other other ADJ crl-13533 7 53 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 7 54 colleagues colleague NOUN crl-13533 7 55 . . PUNCT crl-13533 8 1 one one NUM crl-13533 8 2 element element NOUN crl-13533 8 3 of of ADP crl-13533 8 4 this this DET crl-13533 8 5 two two NUM crl-13533 8 6 - - PUNCT crl-13533 8 7 track track NOUN crl-13533 8 8 system system NOUN crl-13533 8 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 8 10 which which PRON crl-13533 8 11 was be AUX crl-13533 8 12 implemented implement VERB crl-13533 8 13 in in ADP crl-13533 8 14 1973 1973 NUM crl-13533 8 15 - - SYM crl-13533 8 16 74 74 NUM crl-13533 8 17 , , PUNCT crl-13533 8 18 was be AUX crl-13533 8 19 developed develop VERB crl-13533 8 20 in in ADP crl-13533 8 21 response response NOUN crl-13533 8 22 to to ADP crl-13533 8 23 the the DET crl-13533 8 24 " " PUNCT crl-13533 8 25 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 8 26 crisis crisis NOUN crl-13533 8 27 of of ADP crl-13533 8 28 1968 1968 NUM crl-13533 8 29 " " PUNCT crl-13533 8 30 and and CCONJ crl-13533 8 31 the the DET crl-13533 8 32 issue issue NOUN crl-13533 8 33 of of ADP crl-13533 8 34 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 8 35 status status NOUN crl-13533 8 36 for for ADP crl-13533 8 37 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 8 38 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 8 39 . . PUNCT crl-13533 9 1 prior prior ADV crl-13533 9 2 to to ADP crl-13533 9 3 the the DET crl-13533 9 4 development development NOUN crl-13533 9 5 and and CCONJ crl-13533 9 6 implementation implementation NOUN crl-13533 9 7 of of ADP crl-13533 9 8 these these DET crl-13533 9 9 systems system NOUN crl-13533 9 10 , , PUNCT crl-13533 9 11 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 9 12 had have VERB crl-13533 9 13 a a DET crl-13533 9 14 traditional traditional ADJ crl-13533 9 15 one one NUM crl-13533 9 16 - - PUNCT crl-13533 9 17 track track NOUN crl-13533 9 18 position position NOUN crl-13533 9 19 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 9 20 scheme scheme NOUN crl-13533 9 21 for for ADP crl-13533 9 22 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 9 23 . . PUNCT crl-13533 10 1 although although SCONJ crl-13533 10 2 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 10 3 was be AUX crl-13533 10 4 only only ADV crl-13533 10 5 one one NUM crl-13533 10 6 of of ADP crl-13533 10 7 a a DET crl-13533 10 8 number number NOUN crl-13533 10 9 of of ADP crl-13533 10 10 universities university NOUN crl-13533 10 11 that that PRON crl-13533 10 12 suffered suffer VERB crl-13533 10 13 violent violent ADJ crl-13533 10 14 student student NOUN crl-13533 10 15 disruptions disruption NOUN crl-13533 10 16 in in ADP crl-13533 10 17 the the DET crl-13533 10 18 late late ADJ crl-13533 10 19 1960s 1960 NOUN crl-13533 10 20 and and CCONJ crl-13533 10 21 frederick frederick PROPN crl-13533 10 22 duda duda PROPN crl-13533 10 23 is be AUX crl-13533 10 24 assistant assistant ADJ crl-13533 10 25 university university NOUN crl-13533 10 26 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 10 27 for for ADP crl-13533 10 28 personnel personnel NOUN crl-13533 10 29 , , PUNCT crl-13533 10 30 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 10 31 university university PROPN crl-13533 10 32 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 10 33 , , PUNCT crl-13533 10 34 new new PROPN crl-13533 10 35 york york PROPN crl-13533 10 36 city city PROPN crl-13533 10 37 . . PUNCT crl-13533 11 1 early early ADJ crl-13533 11 2 1970s 1970 NOUN crl-13533 11 3 , , PUNCT crl-13533 11 4 there there PRON crl-13533 11 5 were be VERB crl-13533 11 6 certain certain ADJ crl-13533 11 7 internal internal ADJ crl-13533 11 8 factors factor NOUN crl-13533 11 9 that that PRON crl-13533 11 10 contributed contribute VERB crl-13533 11 11 to to ADP crl-13533 11 12 the the DET crl-13533 11 13 intensity intensity NOUN crl-13533 11 14 of of ADP crl-13533 11 15 the the DET crl-13533 11 16 crisis crisis NOUN crl-13533 11 17 and and CCONJ crl-13533 11 18 culminated culminate VERB crl-13533 11 19 in in ADP crl-13533 11 20 the the DET crl-13533 11 21 still still ADV crl-13533 11 22 controversial controversial ADJ crl-13533 11 23 police police NOUN crl-13533 11 24 " " PUNCT crl-13533 11 25 bust bust NOUN crl-13533 11 26 " " PUNCT crl-13533 11 27 the the DET crl-13533 11 28 night night NOUN crl-13533 11 29 of of ADP crl-13533 11 30 april april PROPN crl-13533 11 31 29 29 NUM crl-13533 11 32 - - PUNCT crl-13533 11 33 -30 -30 NUM crl-13533 11 34 , , PUNCT crl-13533 11 35 1968 1968 NUM crl-13533 11 36 . . PUNCT crl-13533 12 1 as as SCONJ crl-13533 12 2 the the DET crl-13533 12 3 cox cox PROPN crl-13533 12 4 commission commission PROPN crl-13533 12 5 report report NOUN crl-13533 12 6 points point VERB crl-13533 12 7 out out ADP crl-13533 12 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 12 9 " " PUNCT crl-13533 12 10 the the DET crl-13533 12 11 administration administration NOUN crl-13533 12 12 of of ADP crl-13533 12 13 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 12 14 's 's PART crl-13533 12 15 affairs affair NOUN crl-13533 12 16 too too ADV crl-13533 12 17 often often ADV crl-13533 12 18 conveyed convey VERB crl-13533 12 19 an an DET crl-13533 12 20 attitude attitude NOUN crl-13533 12 21 of of ADP crl-13533 12 22 authoritarianism authoritarianism NOUN crl-13533 12 23 and and CCONJ crl-13533 12 24 invited invite VERB crl-13533 12 25 distrust distrust NOUN crl-13533 12 26 . . PUNCT crl-13533 13 1 " " PUNCT crl-13533 13 2 i i PRON crl-13533 13 3 f f X crl-13533 13 4 ~ ~ PUNCT crl-13533 13 5 ic­ ic­ NOUN crl-13533 13 6 tion tion NOUN crl-13533 13 7 between between ADP crl-13533 13 8 the the DET crl-13533 13 9 university university NOUN crl-13533 13 10 administration administration NOUN crl-13533 13 11 and and CCONJ crl-13533 13 12 the the DET crl-13533 13 13 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 13 14 , , PUNCT crl-13533 13 15 indifference indifference NOUN crl-13533 13 16 to to AUX crl-13533 13 17 student student NOUN crl-13533 13 18 opinion opinion NOUN crl-13533 13 19 and and CCONJ crl-13533 13 20 needs need NOUN crl-13533 13 21 , , PUNCT crl-13533 13 22 a a DET crl-13533 13 23 · · NUM crl-13533 13 24 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 13 25 structure structure NOUN crl-13533 13 26 which which PRON crl-13533 13 27 discouraged discourage VERB crl-13533 13 28 involvement involvement NOUN crl-13533 13 29 in in ADP crl-13533 13 30 decision decision NOUN crl-13533 13 31 making making NOUN crl-13533 13 32 , , PUNCT crl-13533 13 33 as as ADV crl-13533 13 34 well well ADV crl-13533 13 35 as as ADP crl-13533 13 36 the the DET crl-13533 13 37 lack lack NOUN crl-13533 13 38 of of ADP crl-13533 13 39 a a DET crl-13533 13 40 university university NOUN crl-13533 13 41 senate senate NOUN crl-13533 13 42 , , PUNCT crl-13533 13 43 were be AUX crl-13533 13 44 internal internal ADJ crl-13533 13 45 realities reality NOUN crl-13533 13 46 that that PRON crl-13533 13 47 , , PUNCT crl-13533 13 48 coupled couple VERB crl-13533 13 49 with with ADP crl-13533 13 50 the the DET crl-13533 13 51 social social ADJ crl-13533 13 52 unrest unrest NOUN crl-13533 13 53 of of ADP crl-13533 13 54 the the DET crl-13533 13 55 times time NOUN crl-13533 13 56 , , PUNCT crl-13533 13 57 made make VERB crl-13533 13 58 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 13 59 ripe ripe VERB crl-13533 13 60 for for ADP crl-13533 13 61 revolution revolution NOUN crl-13533 13 62 . . PUNCT crl-13533 14 1 following follow VERB crl-13533 14 2 the the DET crl-13533 14 3 crisis crisis NOUN crl-13533 14 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 14 5 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 14 6 embarked embark VERB crl-13533 14 7 upon upon SCONJ crl-13533 14 8 a a DET crl-13533 14 9 major major ADJ crl-13533 14 10 study study NOUN crl-13533 14 11 and and CCONJ crl-13533 14 12 restructuring restructuring NOUN crl-13533 14 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 14 14 a a DET crl-13533 14 15 process process NOUN crl-13533 14 16 that that PRON crl-13533 14 17 eventually eventually ADV crl-13533 14 18 led lead VERB crl-13533 14 19 to to ADP crl-13533 14 20 a a DET crl-13533 14 21 more more ADV crl-13533 14 22 responsive responsive ADJ crl-13533 14 23 system system NOUN crl-13533 14 24 of of ADP crl-13533 14 25 governance governance NOUN crl-13533 14 26 . . PUNCT crl-13533 15 1 librarians librarian VERB crl-13533 15 2 quite quite ADV crl-13533 15 3 early early ADV crl-13533 15 4 articulated articulate VERB crl-13533 15 5 their their PRON crl-13533 15 6 concern concern NOUN crl-13533 15 7 for for ADP crl-13533 15 8 an an DET crl-13533 15 9 active active ADJ crl-13533 15 10 role role NOUN crl-13533 15 11 in in ADP crl-13533 15 12 the the DET crl-13533 15 13 effort effort NOUN crl-13533 15 14 to to PART crl-13533 15 15 reorganize reorganize VERB crl-13533 15 16 the the DET crl-13533 15 17 university university NOUN crl-13533 15 18 . . PUNCT crl-13533 16 1 at at ADP crl-13533 16 2 a a DET crl-13533 16 3 general general ADJ crl-13533 16 4 meeting meeting NOUN crl-13533 16 5 of of ADP crl-13533 16 6 the the DET crl-13533 16 7 department department NOUN crl-13533 16 8 and and CCONJ crl-13533 16 9 division division NOUN crl-13533 16 10 heads head NOUN crl-13533 16 11 on on ADP crl-13533 16 12 may may PROPN crl-13533 16 13 7 7 NUM crl-13533 16 14 , , PUNCT crl-13533 16 15 1968 1968 NUM crl-13533 16 16 , , PUNCT crl-13533 16 17 richard richard PROPN crl-13533 16 18 h. h. PROPN crl-13533 16 19 logsdon logsdon PROPN crl-13533 16 20 , , PUNCT crl-13533 16 21 director director NOUN crl-13533 16 22 of of ADP crl-13533 16 23 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 16 24 from from ADP crl-13533 16 25 1953 1953 NUM crl-13533 16 26 to to ADP crl-13533 16 27 1969 1969 NUM crl-13533 16 28 , , PUNCT crl-13533 16 29 responded respond VERB crl-13533 16 30 to to ADP crl-13533 16 31 this this DET crl-13533 16 32 concern concern NOUN crl-13533 16 33 by by ADP crl-13533 16 34 establishing establish VERB crl-13533 16 35 the the DET crl-13533 16 36 study study NOUN crl-13533 16 37 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 16 38 , , PUNCT crl-13533 16 39 which which PRON crl-13533 16 40 was be AUX crl-13533 16 41 created create VERB crl-13533 16 42 to to PART crl-13533 16 43 make make VERB crl-13533 16 44 recommendations recommendation NOUN crl-13533 16 45 concerning concern VERB crl-13533 16 46 the the DET crl-13533 16 47 role role NOUN crl-13533 16 48 of of ADP crl-13533 16 49 the the DET crl-13533 16 50 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 16 51 in in ADP crl-13533 16 52 the the DET crl-13533 16 53 restructuring restructuring NOUN crl-13533 16 54 process process NOUN crl-13533 16 55 . . PUNCT crl-13533 17 1 initially initially ADV crl-13533 17 2 , , PUNCT crl-13533 17 3 the the DET crl-13533 17 4 study study NOUN crl-13533 17 5 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 17 6 concentrated concentrate VERB crl-13533 17 7 on on ADP crl-13533 17 8 university university NOUN crl-13533 17 9 - - PUNCT crl-13533 17 10 wide wide ADJ crl-13533 17 11 issues issue NOUN crl-13533 17 12 and and CCONJ crl-13533 17 13 suei suei VERB crl-13533 17 14 295 295 NUM crl-13533 17 15 296 296 NUM crl-13533 17 16 i i PROPN crl-13533 17 17 college college PROPN crl-13533 17 18 & & CCONJ crl-13533 17 19 research research PROPN crl-13533 17 20 libraries librarie VERB crl-13533 17 21 • • ADJ crl-13533 17 22 july july PROPN crl-13533 17 23 1980 1980 NUM crl-13533 17 24 cessfully cessfully ADV crl-13533 17 25 convinced convince VERB crl-13533 17 26 the the DET crl-13533 17 27 executive executive ADJ crl-13533 17 28 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 17 29 for for ADP crl-13533 17 30 the the DET crl-13533 17 31 restructuring restructuring NOUN crl-13533 17 32 of of ADP crl-13533 17 33 the the DET crl-13533 17 34 university university NOUN crl-13533 17 35 that that PRON crl-13533 17 36 librarians librarian VERB crl-13533 17 37 should should AUX crl-13533 17 38 have have VERB crl-13533 17 39 representation representation NOUN crl-13533 17 40 on on ADP crl-13533 17 41 the the DET crl-13533 17 42 first first ADJ crl-13533 17 43 university university NOUN crl-13533 17 44 senate senate PROPN crl-13533 17 45 , , PUNCT crl-13533 17 46 which which PRON crl-13533 17 47 was be AUX crl-13533 17 48 established establish VERB crl-13533 17 49 at at ADP crl-13533 17 50 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 17 51 in in ADP crl-13533 17 52 may may PROPN crl-13533 17 53 1969 1969 NUM crl-13533 17 54 . . PUNCT crl-13533 18 1 the the DET crl-13533 18 2 other other ADJ crl-13533 18 3 two two NUM crl-13533 18 4 areas area NOUN crl-13533 18 5 of of ADP crl-13533 18 6 primary primary ADJ crl-13533 18 7 concern concern NOUN crl-13533 18 8 were be AUX crl-13533 18 9 the the DET crl-13533 18 10 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 18 11 of of ADP crl-13533 18 12 the the DET crl-13533 18 13 relationships relationship NOUN crl-13533 18 14 of of ADP crl-13533 18 15 the the DET crl-13533 18 16 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 18 17 with with ADP crl-13533 18 18 students student NOUN crl-13533 18 19 and and CCONJ crl-13533 18 20 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 18 21 and and CCONJ crl-13533 18 22 the the DET crl-13533 18 23 status status NOUN crl-13533 18 24 of of ADP crl-13533 18 25 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 18 26 . . PUNCT crl-13533 19 1 in in ADP crl-13533 19 2 1969 1969 NUM crl-13533 19 3 - - SYM crl-13533 19 4 70 70 NUM crl-13533 19 5 , , PUNCT crl-13533 19 6 the the DET crl-13533 19 7 study study NOUN crl-13533 19 8 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 19 9 was be AUX crl-13533 19 10 reconstituted reconstitute VERB crl-13533 19 11 as as ADP crl-13533 19 12 the the DET crl-13533 19 13 representative representative ADJ crl-13533 19 14 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 19 15 of of ADP crl-13533 19 16 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 19 17 and and CCONJ crl-13533 19 18 completed complete VERB crl-13533 19 19 its its PRON crl-13533 19 20 work work NOUN crl-13533 19 21 on on ADP crl-13533 19 22 the the DET crl-13533 19 23 question question NOUN crl-13533 19 24 of of ADP crl-13533 19 25 the the DET crl-13533 19 26 role role NOUN crl-13533 19 27 and and CCONJ crl-13533 19 28 status status NOUN crl-13533 19 29 of of ADP crl-13533 19 30 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 19 31 within within ADP crl-13533 19 32 the the DET crl-13533 19 33 university university NOUN crl-13533 19 34 . . PUNCT crl-13533 20 1 the the DET crl-13533 20 2 representative representative PROPN crl-13533 20 3 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 20 4 of of ADP crl-13533 20 5 librarians librarians PROPN crl-13533 20 6 completed complete VERB crl-13533 20 7 this this DET crl-13533 20 8 inquiry inquiry NOUN crl-13533 20 9 when when SCONJ crl-13533 20 10 it it PRON crl-13533 20 11 submitted submit VERB crl-13533 20 12 two two NUM crl-13533 20 13 documents document NOUN crl-13533 20 14 to to ADP crl-13533 20 15 warren warren PROPN crl-13533 20 16 j. j. PROPN crl-13533 20 17 haas haas PROPN crl-13533 20 18 , , PUNCT crl-13533 20 19 who who PRON crl-13533 20 20 became become VERB crl-13533 20 21 university university NOUN crl-13533 20 22 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 20 23 in in ADP crl-13533 20 24 january january PROPN crl-13533 20 25 1970 1970 NUM crl-13533 20 26 : : PUNCT crl-13533 20 27 " " PUNCT crl-13533 20 28 a a DET crl-13533 20 29 recommended recommend VERB crl-13533 20 30 system system NOUN crl-13533 20 31 of of ADP crl-13533 20 32 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 20 33 levels level NOUN crl-13533 20 34 , , PUNCT crl-13533 20 35 " " PUNCT crl-13533 20 36 september september PROPN crl-13533 20 37 17 17 NUM crl-13533 20 38 , , PUNCT crl-13533 20 39 1970 1970 NUM crl-13533 20 40 , , PUNCT crl-13533 20 41 and and CCONJ crl-13533 20 42 " " PUNCT crl-13533 20 43 draft draft NOUN crl-13533 20 44 proposal proposal NOUN crl-13533 20 45 for for ADP crl-13533 20 46 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 20 47 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-13533 20 48 , , PUNCT crl-13533 20 49 " " PUNCT crl-13533 20 50 october october PROPN crl-13533 20 51 29 29 NUM crl-13533 20 52 , , PUNCT crl-13533 20 53 1971 1971 NUM crl-13533 20 54 . . PUNCT crl-13533 21 1 the the DET crl-13533 21 2 evolution evolution NOUN crl-13533 21 3 of of ADP crl-13533 21 4 these these DET crl-13533 21 5 recommendations recommendation NOUN crl-13533 21 6 for for ADP crl-13533 21 7 the the DET crl-13533 21 8 implementation implementation NOUN crl-13533 21 9 of of ADP crl-13533 21 10 a a DET crl-13533 21 11 one one NUM crl-13533 21 12 - - PUNCT crl-13533 21 13 track track NOUN crl-13533 21 14 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 21 15 system system NOUN crl-13533 21 16 of of ADP crl-13533 21 17 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 21 18 to to ADP crl-13533 21 19 the the DET crl-13533 21 20 current current ADJ crl-13533 21 21 twotrack twotrack NOUN crl-13533 21 22 system system NOUN crl-13533 21 23 occurred occur VERB crl-13533 21 24 over over ADP crl-13533 21 25 a a DET crl-13533 21 26 period period NOUN crl-13533 21 27 of of ADP crl-13533 21 28 several several ADJ crl-13533 21 29 years year NOUN crl-13533 21 30 and and CCONJ crl-13533 21 31 was be AUX crl-13533 21 32 influenced influence VERB crl-13533 21 33 by by ADP crl-13533 21 34 several several ADJ crl-13533 21 35 factors factor NOUN crl-13533 21 36 . . PUNCT crl-13533 22 1 before before ADP crl-13533 22 2 exploring explore VERB crl-13533 22 3 these these DET crl-13533 22 4 factors factor NOUN crl-13533 22 5 , , PUNCT crl-13533 22 6 however however ADV crl-13533 22 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 22 8 the the DET crl-13533 22 9 reasons reason NOUN crl-13533 22 10 why why SCONJ crl-13533 22 11 collective collective ADJ crl-13533 22 12 bargain bargain NOUN crl-13533 22 13 ' ' PUNCT crl-13533 22 14 ng ng PROPN crl-13533 22 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 22 16 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 22 17 status status NOUN crl-13533 22 18 were be AUX crl-13533 22 19 not not PART crl-13533 22 20 considered consider VERB crl-13533 22 21 viable viable ADJ crl-13533 22 22 ~ystems ~ystem NOUN crl-13533 22 23 of of ADP crl-13533 22 24 organization organization NOUN crl-13533 22 25 should should AUX crl-13533 22 26 be be AUX crl-13533 22 27 noted note VERB crl-13533 22 28 . . PUNCT crl-13533 23 1 collective collective ADJ crl-13533 23 2 bargaining bargaining NOUN crl-13533 23 3 and and CCONJ crl-13533 23 4 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 23 5 status status NOUN crl-13533 23 6 gwendolyn gwendolyn PROPN crl-13533 23 7 cruzat cruzat PROPN crl-13533 23 8 ' ' PUNCT crl-13533 23 9 s s NOUN crl-13533 23 10 observation observation NOUN crl-13533 23 11 on on ADP crl-13533 23 12 why why SCONJ crl-13533 23 13 some some DET crl-13533 23 14 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 23 15 in in ADP crl-13533 23 16 research research NOUN crl-13533 23 17 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 23 18 have have AUX crl-13533 23 19 rejected reject VERB crl-13533 23 20 both both DET crl-13533 23 21 collective collective ADJ crl-13533 23 22 bargaining bargaining NOUN crl-13533 23 23 and and CCONJ crl-13533 23 24 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 23 25 status status NOUN crl-13533 23 26 is be AUX crl-13533 23 27 applicable applicable ADJ crl-13533 23 28 to to ADP crl-13533 23 29 the the DET crl-13533 23 30 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 23 31 situation situation NOUN crl-13533 23 32 : : PUNCT crl-13533 23 33 the the DET crl-13533 23 34 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 23 35 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 23 36 in in ADP crl-13533 23 37 such such ADJ crl-13533 23 38 environments environment NOUN crl-13533 23 39 have have AUX crl-13533 23 40 been be AUX crl-13533 23 41 accorded accord VERB crl-13533 23 42 , , PUNCT crl-13533 23 43 in in ADP crl-13533 23 44 most most ADJ crl-13533 23 45 instances instance NOUN crl-13533 23 46 , , PUNCT crl-13533 23 47 status status NOUN crl-13533 23 48 as as ADP crl-13533 23 49 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 23 50 . . PUNCT crl-13533 24 1 that that ADV crl-13533 24 2 is is ADV crl-13533 24 3 , , PUNCT crl-13533 24 4 they they PRON crl-13533 24 5 play play VERB crl-13533 24 6 a a DET crl-13533 24 7 role role NOUN crl-13533 24 8 in in ADP crl-13533 24 9 the the DET crl-13533 24 10 governance governance NOUN crl-13533 24 11 of of ADP crl-13533 24 12 many many ADJ crl-13533 24 13 of of ADP crl-13533 24 14 these these DET crl-13533 24 15 institutions institution NOUN crl-13533 24 16 by by ADP crl-13533 24 17 having have VERB crl-13533 24 18 representation representation NOUN crl-13533 24 19 in in ADP crl-13533 24 20 the the DET crl-13533 24 21 institutions institution NOUN crl-13533 24 22 ' ' PART crl-13533 24 23 senates senate NOUN crl-13533 24 24 or or CCONJ crl-13533 24 25 other other ADJ crl-13533 24 26 policy policy NOUN crl-13533 24 27 making make VERB crl-13533 24 28 bodies body NOUN crl-13533 24 29 . . PUNCT crl-13533 25 1 they they PRON crl-13533 25 2 also also ADV crl-13533 25 3 serve serve VERB crl-13533 25 4 on on ADP crl-13533 25 5 the the DET crl-13533 25 6 standing standing NOUN crl-13533 25 7 and and CCONJ crl-13533 25 8 special special ADJ crl-13533 25 9 committees committee NOUN crl-13533 25 10 appointed appoint VERB crl-13533 25 11 by by ADP crl-13533 25 12 these these DET crl-13533 25 13 bodies body NOUN crl-13533 25 14 . . PUNCT crl-13533 26 1 there there PRON crl-13533 26 2 are be VERB crl-13533 26 3 also also ADV crl-13533 26 4 · · PUNCT crl-13533 26 5 institutions institution NOUN crl-13533 26 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 26 7 such such ADJ crl-13533 26 8 as as ADP crl-13533 26 9 harvard harvard PROPN crl-13533 26 10 university university PROPN crl-13533 26 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 26 12 where where SCONJ crl-13533 26 13 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 26 14 decided decide VERB crl-13533 26 15 to to PART crl-13533 26 16 work work VERB crl-13533 26 17 for for ADP crl-13533 26 18 a a DET crl-13533 26 19 kind kind NOUN crl-13533 26 20 of of ADP crl-13533 26 21 status status NOUN crl-13533 26 22 different different ADJ crl-13533 26 23 from from ADP crl-13533 26 24 that that PRON crl-13533 26 25 of of ADP crl-13533 26 26 the the DET crl-13533 26 27 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 26 28 . . PUNCT crl-13533 27 1 2 2 NUM crl-13533 27 2 as as ADV crl-13533 27 3 early early ADV crl-13533 27 4 as as ADP crl-13533 27 5 1911 1911 NUM crl-13533 27 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 27 7 the the DET crl-13533 27 8 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 27 9 university university PROPN crl-13533 27 10 charters charter NOUN crl-13533 27 11 and and CCONJ crl-13533 27 12 statutes statute NOUN crl-13533 27 13 defined define VERB crl-13533 27 14 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 27 15 as as ADP crl-13533 27 16 a a DET crl-13533 27 17 distinct distinct ADJ crl-13533 27 18 group group NOUN crl-13533 27 19 allied ally VERB crl-13533 27 20 with with ADP crl-13533 27 21 the the DET crl-13533 27 22 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 27 23 in in ADP crl-13533 27 24 accomplishing accomplish VERB crl-13533 27 25 instructional instructional ADJ crl-13533 27 26 and and CCONJ crl-13533 27 27 research research NOUN crl-13533 27 28 objectives objective NOUN crl-13533 27 29 . . PUNCT crl-13533 28 1 the the DET crl-13533 28 2 1911 1911 NUM crl-13533 28 3 statutes statute NOUN crl-13533 28 4 not not PART crl-13533 28 5 only only ADV crl-13533 28 6 defined define VERB crl-13533 28 7 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 28 8 as as ADP crl-13533 28 9 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 28 10 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 28 11 but but CCONJ crl-13533 28 12 also also ADV crl-13533 28 13 equated equate VERB crl-13533 28 14 librarian librarian ADJ crl-13533 28 15 titles title NOUN crl-13533 28 16 to to ADP crl-13533 28 17 the the DET crl-13533 28 18 four four NUM crl-13533 28 19 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 28 20 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 28 21 . . PUNCT crl-13533 29 1 3 3 NUM crl-13533 29 2 the the DET crl-13533 29 3 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 29 4 of of ADP crl-13533 29 5 the the DET crl-13533 29 6 status status NOUN crl-13533 29 7 of of ADP crl-13533 29 8 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 29 9 at at ADP crl-13533 29 10 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 29 11 was be AUX crl-13533 29 12 clarified clarify VERB crl-13533 29 13 in in ADP crl-13533 29 14 subsequent subsequent ADJ crl-13533 29 15 revisions revision NOUN crl-13533 29 16 of of ADP crl-13533 29 17 the the DET crl-13533 29 18 statutes statute NOUN crl-13533 29 19 so so SCONJ crl-13533 29 20 that that SCONJ crl-13533 29 21 it it PRON crl-13533 29 22 was be AUX crl-13533 29 23 understood understand VERB crl-13533 29 24 that that SCONJ crl-13533 29 25 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 29 26 ranked rank VERB crl-13533 29 27 with with ADP crl-13533 29 28 officers officer NOUN crl-13533 29 29 of of ADP crl-13533 29 30 instruction instruction NOUN crl-13533 29 31 with with ADP crl-13533 29 32 respect respect NOUN crl-13533 29 33 to to ADP crl-13533 29 34 university university NOUN crl-13533 29 35 benefits benefit NOUN crl-13533 29 36 and and CCONJ crl-13533 29 37 privileges privilege NOUN crl-13533 29 38 . . PUNCT crl-13533 30 1 within within ADP crl-13533 30 2 this this DET crl-13533 30 3 framework framework NOUN crl-13533 30 4 the the DET crl-13533 30 5 university university NOUN crl-13533 30 6 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 30 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 30 8 with with ADP crl-13533 30 9 authorization authorization NOUN crl-13533 30 10 from from ADP crl-13533 30 11 the the DET crl-13533 30 12 executive executive ADJ crl-13533 30 13 vice vice NOUN crl-13533 30 14 - - NOUN crl-13533 30 15 president president NOUN crl-13533 30 16 for for ADP crl-13533 30 17 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 30 18 affairs affair NOUN crl-13533 30 19 and and CCONJ crl-13533 30 20 provost provost NOUN crl-13533 30 21 , , PUNCT crl-13533 30 22 has have VERB crl-13533 30 23 the the DET crl-13533 30 24 flexibility flexibility NOUN crl-13533 30 25 to to PART crl-13533 30 26 develop develop VERB crl-13533 30 27 a a DET crl-13533 30 28 system system NOUN crl-13533 30 29 of of ADP crl-13533 30 30 organization organization NOUN crl-13533 30 31 for for ADP crl-13533 30 32 the the DET crl-13533 30 33 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 30 34 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 30 35 that that PRON crl-13533 30 36 will will AUX crl-13533 30 37 both both PRON crl-13533 30 38 meet meet VERB crl-13533 30 39 library library NOUN crl-13533 30 40 service service NOUN crl-13533 30 41 objectives objective NOUN crl-13533 30 42 and and CCONJ crl-13533 30 43 provide provide VERB crl-13533 30 44 mechanisms mechanism NOUN crl-13533 30 45 for for ADP crl-13533 30 46 recognizing recognize VERB crl-13533 30 47 and and CCONJ crl-13533 30 48 rewarding rewarding ADJ crl-13533 30 49 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 30 50 on on ADP crl-13533 30 51 the the DET crl-13533 30 52 basis basis NOUN crl-13533 30 53 of of ADP crl-13533 30 54 their their PRON crl-13533 30 55 functional functional ADJ crl-13533 30 56 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 30 57 and and CCONJ crl-13533 30 58 individual individual ADJ crl-13533 30 59 contributions contribution NOUN crl-13533 30 60 . . PUNCT crl-13533 31 1 the the DET crl-13533 31 2 consensus consensus NOUN crl-13533 31 3 of of ADP crl-13533 31 4 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 31 5 at at ADP crl-13533 31 6 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 31 7 in in ADP crl-13533 31 8 the the DET crl-13533 31 9 late late ADJ crl-13533 31 10 1960s 1960 NOUN crl-13533 31 11 was be AUX crl-13533 31 12 that that PRON crl-13533 31 13 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 31 14 status status NOUN crl-13533 31 15 implied imply VERB crl-13533 31 16 adherence adherence NOUN crl-13533 31 17 to to ADP crl-13533 31 18 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 31 19 standards standard NOUN crl-13533 31 20 for for ADP crl-13533 31 21 appointment appointment NOUN crl-13533 31 22 , , PUNCT crl-13533 31 23 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 31 24 , , PUNCT crl-13533 31 25 and and CCONJ crl-13533 31 26 tenure tenure NOUN crl-13533 31 27 and and CCONJ crl-13533 31 28 that that SCONJ crl-13533 31 29 such such ADJ crl-13533 31 30 on on ADP crl-13533 31 31 adherence adherence NOUN crl-13533 31 32 would would AUX crl-13533 31 33 lead lead VERB crl-13533 31 34 to to ADP crl-13533 31 35 an an DET crl-13533 31 36 obfuscation obfuscation NOUN crl-13533 31 37 of of ADP crl-13533 31 38 their their PRON crl-13533 31 39 basic basic ADJ crl-13533 31 40 role role NOUN crl-13533 31 41 as as ADP crl-13533 31 42 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 31 43 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 31 44 . . PUNCT crl-13533 32 1 although although SCONJ crl-13533 32 2 they they PRON crl-13533 32 3 believed believe VERB crl-13533 32 4 that that SCONJ crl-13533 32 5 " " PUNCT crl-13533 32 6 there there PRON crl-13533 32 7 are be VERB crl-13533 32 8 several several ADJ crl-13533 32 9 levels level NOUN crl-13533 32 10 of of ADP crl-13533 32 11 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-13533 32 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 32 13 with with ADP crl-13533 32 14 a a DET crl-13533 32 15 range range NOUN crl-13533 32 16 comparable comparable ADJ crl-13533 32 17 to to ADP crl-13533 32 18 the the PRON crl-13533 32 19 . . PUNCT crl-13533 33 1 range range VERB crl-13533 33 2 among among ADP crl-13533 33 3 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 33 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 33 5 " " PUNCT crl-13533 33 6 4 4 NUM crl-13533 33 7 they they PRON crl-13533 33 8 also also ADV crl-13533 33 9 believed believe VERB crl-13533 33 10 that that SCONJ crl-13533 33 11 they they PRON crl-13533 33 12 should should AUX crl-13533 33 13 develop develop VERB crl-13533 33 14 their their PRON crl-13533 33 15 own own ADJ crl-13533 33 16 model model NOUN crl-13533 33 17 rather rather ADV crl-13533 33 18 than than ADP crl-13533 33 19 adopt adopt VERB crl-13533 33 20 one one NUM crl-13533 33 21 which which PRON crl-13533 33 22 neither neither CCONJ crl-13533 33 23 reflected reflect VERB crl-13533 33 24 their their PRON crl-13533 33 25 functional functional ADJ crl-13533 33 26 roles role NOUN crl-13533 33 27 nor nor CCONJ crl-13533 33 28 accommodated accommodate VERB crl-13533 33 29 their their PRON crl-13533 33 30 conception conception NOUN crl-13533 33 31 of of ADP crl-13533 33 32 distinction distinction NOUN crl-13533 33 33 . . PUNCT crl-13533 34 1 evolution evolution NOUN crl-13533 34 2 of of ADP crl-13533 34 3 the the DET crl-13533 34 4 two two NUM crl-13533 34 5 - - PUNCT crl-13533 34 6 track track NOUN crl-13533 34 7 syste syste NOUN crl-13533 34 8 ~ ~ PUNCT crl-13533 34 9 i i PRON crl-13533 34 10 the the DET crl-13533 34 11 system system NOUN crl-13533 34 12 of of ADP crl-13533 34 13 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 34 14 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 34 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 34 16 the the DET crl-13533 34 17 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 34 18 review review NOUN crl-13533 34 19 process process NOUN crl-13533 34 20 recommended recommend VERB crl-13533 34 21 by by ADP crl-13533 34 22 the the DET crl-13533 34 23 representative representative ADJ crl-13533 34 24 committe committe NOUN crl-13533 34 25 e e PROPN crl-13533 34 26 of of ADP crl-13533 34 27 librarians librarians PROPN crl-13533 34 28 in in ADP crl-13533 34 29 1970 1970 NUM crl-13533 34 30 and and CCONJ crl-13533 34 31 1971 1971 NUM crl-13533 34 32 was be AUX crl-13533 34 33 similar similar ADJ crl-13533 34 34 to to ADP crl-13533 34 35 systems system NOUN crl-13533 34 36 in in ADP crl-13533 34 37 existence existence NOUN crl-13533 34 38 or or CCONJ crl-13533 34 39 under under ADP crl-13533 34 40 development development NOUN crl-13533 34 41 at at ADP crl-13533 34 42 a a DET crl-13533 34 43 number number NOUN crl-13533 34 44 qf qf ADP crl-13533 34 45 institutions institution NOUN crl-13533 34 46 . . PUNCT crl-13533 35 1 the the DET crl-13533 35 2 evolution evolution NOUN crl-13533 35 3 from from ADP crl-13533 35 4 this this DET crl-13533 35 5 system system NOUN crl-13533 35 6 to to ADP crl-13533 35 7 the the DET crl-13533 35 8 current current ADJ crl-13533 35 9 two two NUM crl-13533 35 10 - - PUNCT crl-13533 35 11 track track NOUN crl-13533 35 12 system system NOUN crl-13533 35 13 occurred occur VERB crl-13533 35 14 over over ADP crl-13533 35 15 a a DET crl-13533 35 16 period period NOUN crl-13533 35 17 of of ADP crl-13533 35 18 almost almost ADV crl-13533 35 19 five five NUM crl-13533 35 20 years year NOUN crl-13533 35 21 . . PUNCT crl-13533 36 1 this this PRON crl-13533 36 2 seems seem VERB crl-13533 36 3 to to PART crl-13533 36 4 be be AUX crl-13533 36 5 a a DET crl-13533 36 6 relatively relatively ADV crl-13533 36 7 long long ADJ crl-13533 36 8 time time NOUN crl-13533 36 9 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 36 10 however however ADV crl-13533 36 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 36 12 a a DET crl-13533 36 13 number number NOUN crl-13533 36 14 of of ADP crl-13533 36 15 other other ADJ crl-13533 36 16 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 36 17 at at ADP crl-13533 36 18 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 36 19 during during ADP crl-13533 36 20 this this DET crl-13533 36 21 period period NOUN crl-13533 36 22 both both PRON crl-13533 36 23 affected affect VERB crl-13533 36 24 the the DET crl-13533 36 25 priority priority NOUN crl-13533 36 26 given give VERB crl-13533 36 27 to to ADP crl-13533 36 28 the the DET crl-13533 36 29 system system NOUN crl-13533 36 30 and and CCONJ crl-13533 36 31 influenced influence VERB crl-13533 36 32 its its PRON crl-13533 36 33 final final ADJ crl-13533 36 34 form form NOUN crl-13533 36 35 . . PUNCT crl-13533 37 1 during during ADP crl-13533 37 2 the the DET crl-13533 37 3 early early ADJ crl-13533 37 4 1970s 1970 NOUN crl-13533 37 5 higher high ADJ crl-13533 37 6 priorities priority NOUN crl-13533 37 7 had have VERB crl-13533 37 8 to to PART crl-13533 37 9 be be AUX crl-13533 37 10 given give VERB crl-13533 37 11 to to ADP crl-13533 37 12 the the DET crl-13533 37 13 development development NOUN crl-13533 37 14 and and CCONJ crl-13533 37 15 implementation implementation NOUN crl-13533 37 16 of of ADP crl-13533 37 17 a a DET crl-13533 37 18 new new ADJ crl-13533 37 19 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 37 20 scheme scheme NOUN crl-13533 37 21 for for ADP crl-13533 37 22 the the DET crl-13533 37 23 recently recently ADV crl-13533 37 24 unionized unionized ADJ crl-13533 37 25 supporting support VERB crl-13533 37 26 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 37 27 , , PUNCT crl-13533 37 28 as as ADV crl-13533 37 29 well well ADV crl-13533 37 30 as as ADP crl-13533 37 31 to to ADP crl-13533 37 32 training training NOUN crl-13533 37 33 supervisors supervisor NOUN crl-13533 37 34 in in ADP crl-13533 37 35 contract contract NOUN crl-13533 37 36 and and CCONJ crl-13533 37 37 grievance grievance PROPN crl-13533 37 38 administration administration NOUN crl-13533 37 39 . . PUNCT crl-13533 38 1 it it PRON crl-13533 38 2 was be AUX crl-13533 38 3 during during ADP crl-13533 38 4 this this DET crl-13533 38 5 period period NOUN crl-13533 38 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 38 7 also also ADV crl-13533 38 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 38 9 that that SCONJ crl-13533 38 10 the the DET crl-13533 38 11 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 38 12 developed develop VERB crl-13533 38 13 its its PRON crl-13533 38 14 goals goal NOUN crl-13533 38 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 38 16 procedures procedure NOUN crl-13533 38 17 for for ADP crl-13533 38 18 the the DET crl-13533 38 19 university university NOUN crl-13533 38 20 's 's PART crl-13533 38 21 first first ADJ crl-13533 38 22 affirmative affirmative ADJ crl-13533 38 23 action action NOUN crl-13533 38 24 plan plan NOUN crl-13533 38 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 38 26 which which PRON crl-13533 38 27 was be AUX crl-13533 38 28 accepted accept VERB crl-13533 38 29 by by ADP crl-13533 38 30 the the DET crl-13533 38 31 office office NOUN crl-13533 38 32 of of ADP crl-13533 38 33 civil civil ADJ crl-13533 38 34 rights right NOUN crl-13533 38 35 in in ADP crl-13533 38 36 december december PROPN crl-13533 38 37 1972 1972 NUM crl-13533 38 38 . . PUNCT crl-13533 39 1 another another DET crl-13533 39 2 key key ADJ crl-13533 39 3 activity activity NOUN crl-13533 39 4 at at ADP crl-13533 39 5 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 39 6 at at ADP crl-13533 39 7 the the DET crl-13533 39 8 time time NOUN crl-13533 39 9 was be AUX crl-13533 39 10 the the DET crl-13533 39 11 booz booz NOUN crl-13533 39 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 39 13 allen allen NOUN crl-13533 39 14 , , PUNCT crl-13533 39 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 39 16 hamilton hamilton PROPN crl-13533 39 17 management management NOUN crl-13533 39 18 study study NOUN crl-13533 39 19 , , PUNCT crl-13533 39 20 which which PRON crl-13533 39 21 was be AUX crl-13533 39 22 sponsored sponsor VERB crl-13533 39 23 by by ADP crl-13533 39 24 the the DET crl-13533 39 25 association association NOUN crl-13533 39 26 of of ADP crl-13533 39 27 research research NOUN crl-13533 39 28 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 39 29 in in ADP crl-13533 39 30 cooperation cooperation NOUN crl-13533 39 31 with with ADP crl-13533 39 32 the the DET crl-13533 39 33 american american PROPN crl-13533 39 34 council council PROPN crl-13533 39 35 on on ADP crl-13533 39 36 education education NOUN crl-13533 39 37 . . PUNCT crl-13533 40 1 this this DET crl-13533 40 2 study study NOUN crl-13533 40 3 , , PUNCT crl-13533 40 4 which which PRON crl-13533 40 5 was be AUX crl-13533 40 6 completed complete VERB crl-13533 40 7 in in ADP crl-13533 40 8 1972 1972 NUM crl-13533 40 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 40 10 was be AUX crl-13533 40 11 one one NUM crl-13533 40 12 of of ADP crl-13533 40 13 the the DET crl-13533 40 14 key key ADJ crl-13533 40 15 influences influence NOUN crl-13533 40 16 on on ADP crl-13533 40 17 the the DET crl-13533 40 18 development development NOUN crl-13533 40 19 of of ADP crl-13533 40 20 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 40 21 's 's PART crl-13533 40 22 two two NUM crl-13533 40 23 - - PUNCT crl-13533 40 24 track track NOUN crl-13533 40 25 system system NOUN crl-13533 40 26 . . PUNCT crl-13533 41 1 the the DET crl-13533 41 2 other other ADJ crl-13533 41 3 primary primary ADJ crl-13533 41 4 influence influence NOUN crl-13533 41 5 was be AUX crl-13533 41 6 -a -a PUNCT crl-13533 41 7 combination combination NOUN crl-13533 41 8 of of ADP crl-13533 41 9 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 41 10 input input NOUN crl-13533 41 11 and and CCONJ crl-13533 41 12 haas haas NOUN crl-13533 41 13 ' ' PART crl-13533 41 14 concepts concept NOUN crl-13533 41 15 of of ADP crl-13533 41 16 the the DET crl-13533 41 17 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 41 18 of of ADP crl-13533 41 19 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 41 20 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-13533 41 21 . . PUNCT crl-13533 42 1 in in ADP crl-13533 42 2 analyzing analyze VERB crl-13533 42 3 the the DET crl-13533 42 4 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 42 5 structure structure NOUN crl-13533 42 6 at at ADP crl-13533 42 7 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 42 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 42 9 the the DET crl-13533 42 10 management management NOUN crl-13533 42 11 study study NOUN crl-13533 42 12 made make VERB crl-13533 42 13 the the DET crl-13533 42 14 following following ADJ crl-13533 42 15 observation observation NOUN crl-13533 42 16 : : PUNCT crl-13533 42 17 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-13533 42 18 of of ADP crl-13533 42 19 present present ADJ crl-13533 42 20 staffing staffing NOUN crl-13533 42 21 patterns pattern NOUN crl-13533 42 22 at at ADP crl-13533 42 23 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 42 24 in in ADP crl-13533 42 25 terms term NOUN crl-13533 42 26 of of ADP crl-13533 42 27 principles principle NOUN crl-13533 42 28 developed develop VERB crl-13533 42 29 through through ADP crl-13533 42 30 experience experience NOUN crl-13533 42 31 in in ADP crl-13533 42 32 a a DET crl-13533 42 33 variety variety NOUN crl-13533 42 34 of of ADP crl-13533 42 35 institutions institution NOUN crl-13533 42 36 that that PRON crl-13533 42 37 can can AUX crl-13533 42 38 be be AUX crl-13533 42 39 applied apply VERB crl-13533 42 40 to to ADP crl-13533 42 41 research research NOUN crl-13533 42 42 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 42 43 indicates indicate VERB crl-13533 42 44 several several ADJ crl-13533 42 45 limitations limitation NOUN crl-13533 42 46 which which PRON crl-13533 42 47 should should AUX crl-13533 42 48 be be AUX crl-13533 42 49 overcome overcome VERB crl-13533 42 50 . . PUNCT crl-13533 43 1 of of ADP crl-13533 43 2 particular particular ADJ crl-13533 43 3 importance importance NOUN crl-13533 43 4 to to ADP crl-13533 43 5 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 43 6 's 's PART crl-13533 43 7 ability ability NOUN crl-13533 43 8 to to PART crl-13533 43 9 cope cope VERB crl-13533 43 10 effectively effectively ADV crl-13533 43 11 with with ADP crl-13533 43 12 future future ADJ crl-13533 43 13 requirements requirement NOUN crl-13533 43 14 is be AUX crl-13533 43 15 the the DET crl-13533 43 16 inadequacy inadequacy NOUN crl-13533 43 17 of of ADP crl-13533 43 18 present present ADJ crl-13533 43 19 staffing staffing NOUN crl-13533 43 20 patterns pattern NOUN crl-13533 43 21 in in ADP crl-13533 43 22 focusing focus VERB crl-13533 43 23 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 43 24 effort effort NOUN crl-13533 43 25 and and CCONJ crl-13533 43 26 in in ADP crl-13533 43 27 developing develop VERB crl-13533 43 28 specialized specialized ADJ crl-13533 43 29 capabilities capability NOUN crl-13533 43 30 and and CCONJ crl-13533 43 31 career career NOUN crl-13533 43 32 opportunities opportunity NOUN crl-13533 43 33 . . PUNCT crl-13533 44 1 because because SCONJ crl-13533 44 2 advancement advancement NOUN crl-13533 44 3 tends tend VERB crl-13533 44 4 to to PART crl-13533 44 5 follow follow VERB crl-13533 44 6 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 44 7 lines line NOUN crl-13533 44 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 44 9 librarians librarian VERB crl-13533 44 10 interested interested ADJ crl-13533 44 11 in in ADP crl-13533 44 12 careers career NOUN crl-13533 44 13 in in ADP crl-13533 44 14 a a DET crl-13533 44 15 subject subject ADJ crl-13533 44 16 area area NOUN crl-13533 44 17 or or CCONJ crl-13533 44 18 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 44 19 field field NOUN crl-13533 44 20 are be AUX crl-13533 44 21 limited limit VERB crl-13533 44 22 in in ADP crl-13533 44 23 their their PRON crl-13533 44 24 opportunities opportunity NOUN crl-13533 44 25 for for ADP crl-13533 44 26 career career NOUN crl-13533 44 27 progression progression NOUN crl-13533 44 28 . . PUNCT crl-13533 45 1 the the DET crl-13533 45 2 present present ADJ crl-13533 45 3 plan plan NOUN crl-13533 45 4 tends tend VERB crl-13533 45 5 to to PART crl-13533 45 6 force force VERB crl-13533 45 7 excellent excellent ADJ crl-13533 45 8 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 45 9 into into ADP crl-13533 45 10 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 45 11 positions position NOUN crl-13533 45 12 as as ADP crl-13533 45 13 the the DET crl-13533 45 14 only only ADJ crl-13533 45 15 channel channel NOUN crl-13533 45 16 for for ADP crl-13533 45 17 advancement advancement NOUN crl-13533 45 18 in in ADP crl-13533 45 19 the the DET crl-13533 45 20 system system NOUN crl-13533 45 21 . . PUNCT crl-13533 46 1 in in ADP crl-13533 46 2 addition addition NOUN crl-13533 46 3 , , PUNCT crl-13533 46 4 professionals professional NOUN crl-13533 46 5 with with ADP crl-13533 46 6 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 46 7 for for ADP crl-13533 46 8 particular particular ADJ crl-13533 46 9 small small ADJ crl-13533 46 10 operating operating NOUN crl-13533 46 11 units unit NOUN crl-13533 46 12 often often ADV crl-13533 46 13 perform perform VERB crl-13533 46 14 nonprofessional nonprofessional ADJ crl-13533 46 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 46 16 clerical clerical ADJ crl-13533 46 17 tasks task NOUN crl-13533 46 18 to to PART crl-13533 46 19 justify justify VERB crl-13533 46 20 their their PRON crl-13533 46 21 full full ADJ crl-13533 46 22 -time -time NOUN crl-13533 46 23 assignment assignment NOUN crl-13533 46 24 to to ADP crl-13533 46 25 the the DET crl-13533 46 26 position position NOUN crl-13533 46 27 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 46 28 this this PRON crl-13533 46 29 , , PUNCT crl-13533 46 30 of of ADP crl-13533 46 31 course course NOUN crl-13533 46 32 , , PUNCT crl-13533 46 33 diminishes diminish VERB crl-13533 46 34 user user NOUN crl-13533 46 35 access access NOUN crl-13533 46 36 to to ADP crl-13533 46 37 and and CCONJ crl-13533 46 38 utilization utilization NOUN crl-13533 46 39 of of ADP crl-13533 46 40 these these DET crl-13533 46 41 highly highly ADV crl-13533 46 42 skilled skilled ADJ crl-13533 46 43 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 46 44 . . PUNCT crl-13533 47 1 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 47 2 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 47 3 the the DET crl-13533 47 4 problem problem NOUN crl-13533 47 5 of of ADP crl-13533 47 6 career career NOUN crl-13533 47 7 progression progression NOUN crl-13533 47 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 47 9 which which PRON crl-13533 47 10 was be AUX crl-13533 47 11 a a DET crl-13533 47 12 concern concern NOUN crl-13533 47 13 of of ADP crl-13533 47 14 many many ADJ crl-13533 47 15 library library ADJ crl-13533 47 16 administrators administrator NOUN crl-13533 47 17 at at ADP crl-13533 47 18 the the DET crl-13533 47 19 time time NOUN crl-13533 47 20 , , PUNCT crl-13533 47 21 was be AUX crl-13533 47 22 noted note VERB crl-13533 47 23 by by ADP crl-13533 47 24 donald donald PROPN crl-13533 47 25 cameron cameron PROPN crl-13533 47 26 and and CCONJ crl-13533 47 27 peggy peggy ADJ crl-13533 47 28 heim heim NOUN crl-13533 47 29 in in ADP crl-13533 47 30 the the DET crl-13533 47 31 compensation compensation NOUN crl-13533 47 32 surveys survey NOUN crl-13533 47 33 they they PRON crl-13533 47 34 · · PUNCT crl-13533 47 35 conducted conduct VERB crl-13533 47 36 for for ADP crl-13533 47 37 the the DET crl-13533 47 38 council council NOUN crl-13533 47 39 on on ADP crl-13533 47 40 library library NOUN crl-13533 47 41 resources resource NOUN crl-13533 47 42 for for ADP crl-13533 47 43 1969 1969 NUM crl-13533 47 44 - - SYM crl-13533 47 45 70 70 NUM crl-13533 47 46 , , PUNCT crl-13533 47 47 1970 1970 NUM crl-13533 47 48 - - SYM crl-13533 47 49 71 71 NUM crl-13533 47 50 , , PUNCT crl-13533 47 51 and and CCONJ crl-13533 47 52 1972 1972 NUM crl-13533 47 53 - - SYM crl-13533 47 54 73 73 NUM crl-13533 47 55 . . PUNCT crl-13533 48 1 although although SCONJ crl-13533 48 2 caineron caineron NOUN crl-13533 48 3 and and CCONJ crl-13533 48 4 heim heim PROPN crl-13533 48 5 offered offer VERB crl-13533 48 6 no no DET crl-13533 48 7 one one NUM crl-13533 48 8 solution solution NOUN crl-13533 48 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 48 10 they they PRON crl-13533 48 11 suggested suggest VERB crl-13533 48 12 several several ADJ crl-13533 48 13 devices device NOUN crl-13533 48 14 which which PRON crl-13533 48 15 might might AUX crl-13533 48 16 resolve resolve VERB crl-13533 48 17 the the DET crl-13533 48 18 problem problem NOUN crl-13533 48 19 . . PUNCT crl-13533 49 1 two two NUM crl-13533 49 2 of of ADP crl-13533 49 3 these these PRON crl-13533 49 4 devi<;es devi<;e NOUN crl-13533 49 5 are be AUX crl-13533 49 6 relevant relevant ADJ crl-13533 49 7 to to ADP crl-13533 49 8 the the DET crl-13533 49 9 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 49 10 situation situation NOUN crl-13533 49 11 : : PUNCT crl-13533 49 12 still still ADV crl-13533 49 13 another another DET crl-13533 49 14 way way NOUN crl-13533 49 15 would would AUX crl-13533 49 16 be be AUX crl-13533 49 17 to to PART crl-13533 49 18 abandon abandon VERB crl-13533 49 19 the the DET crl-13533 49 20 decolumbia decolumbia PROPN crl-13533 49 21 i i PROPN crl-13533 49 22 297 297 NUM crl-13533 49 23 partmental partmental ADJ crl-13533 49 24 structure structure NOUN crl-13533 49 25 altogether altogether ADV crl-13533 49 26 . . PUNCT crl-13533 50 1 one one NUM crl-13533 50 2 variation variation NOUN crl-13533 50 3 would would AUX crl-13533 50 4 be be AUX crl-13533 50 5 to to PART crl-13533 50 6 classify classify VERB crl-13533 50 7 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 50 8 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 50 9 on on ADP crl-13533 50 10 some some DET crl-13533 50 11 kind kind NOUN crl-13533 50 12 of of ADP crl-13533 50 13 scale scale NOUN crl-13533 50 14 which which PRON crl-13533 50 15 would would AUX crl-13533 50 16 allow allow VERB crl-13533 50 17 for for ADP crl-13533 50 18 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 50 19 without without ADP crl-13533 50 20 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 50 21 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 50 22 and and CCONJ crl-13533 50 23 would would AUX crl-13533 50 24 reward reward VERB crl-13533 50 25 distinguished distinguished ADJ crl-13533 50 26 service service NOUN crl-13533 50 27 to to ADP crl-13533 50 28 students student NOUN crl-13533 50 29 and and CCONJ crl-13533 50 30 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 50 31 and and CCONJ crl-13533 50 32 to to ADP crl-13533 50 33 learning learn VERB crl-13533 50 34 at at ADP crl-13533 50 35 large large ADJ crl-13533 50 36 . . PUNCT crl-13533 51 1 a a DET crl-13533 51 2 second second ADJ crl-13533 51 3 variation variation NOUN crl-13533 51 4 would would AUX crl-13533 51 5 involve involve VERB crl-13533 51 6 a a DET crl-13533 51 7 reexamin·ation reexamin·ation NOUN crl-13533 51 8 of of ADP crl-13533 51 9 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 51 10 and and CCONJ crl-13533 51 11 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 51 12 requirements requirement NOUN crl-13533 51 13 for for ADP crl-13533 51 14 initial initial ADJ crl-13533 51 15 appointments appointment NOUN crl-13533 51 16 and and CCONJ crl-13533 51 17 for for ADP crl-13533 51 18 subsequent subsequent ADJ crl-13533 51 19 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 51 20 . . PUNCT crl-13533 52 1 in in ADP crl-13533 52 2 both both DET crl-13533 52 3 variations variation NOUN crl-13533 52 4 the the DET crl-13533 52 5 problem problem NOUN crl-13533 52 6 is be AUX crl-13533 52 7 the the DET crl-13533 52 8 establishment establishment NOUN crl-13533 52 9 of of ADP crl-13533 52 10 appropriate appropriate ADJ crl-13533 52 11 criteria criterion NOUN crl-13533 52 12 . . PUNCT crl-13533 53 1 6 6 NUM crl-13533 53 2 little little ADJ crl-13533 53 3 consideration consideration NOUN crl-13533 53 4 was be AUX crl-13533 53 5 given give VERB crl-13533 53 6 to to ADP crl-13533 53 7 abandoning abandon VERB crl-13533 53 8 an an DET crl-13533 53 9 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 53 10 or or CCONJ crl-13533 53 11 departmental departmental ADJ crl-13533 53 12 structure structure NOUN crl-13533 53 13 at at ADP crl-13533 53 14 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 53 15 because because SCONJ crl-13533 53 16 it it PRON crl-13533 53 17 was be AUX crl-13533 53 18 apparent apparent ADJ crl-13533 53 19 to to ADP crl-13533 53 20 the the DET crl-13533 53 21 library library PROPN crl-13533 53 22 administration administration NOUN crl-13533 53 23 and and CCONJ crl-13533 53 24 most most ADJ crl-13533 53 25 of of ADP crl-13533 53 26 the the DET crl-13533 53 27 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 53 28 that that PRON crl-13533 53 29 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 53 30 and and CCONJ crl-13533 53 31 supervisory supervisory ADJ crl-13533 53 32 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 53 33 were be AUX crl-13533 53 34 integral integral ADJ crl-13533 53 35 functions function NOUN crl-13533 53 36 of of ADP crl-13533 53 37 many many ADJ crl-13533 53 38 positions position NOUN crl-13533 53 39 . . PUNCT crl-13533 54 1 this this PRON crl-13533 54 2 was be AUX crl-13533 54 3 also also ADV crl-13533 54 4 observed observe VERB crl-13533 54 5 in in ADP crl-13533 54 6 the the DET crl-13533 54 7 management management NOUN crl-13533 54 8 study study NOUN crl-13533 54 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 54 10 which which PRON crl-13533 54 11 recommended recommend VERB crl-13533 54 12 the the DET crl-13533 54 13 development development NOUN crl-13533 54 14 of of ADP crl-13533 54 15 five five NUM crl-13533 54 16 classes class NOUN crl-13533 54 17 of of ADP crl-13533 54 18 librarian librarian ADJ crl-13533 54 19 positions position NOUN crl-13533 54 20 . . PUNCT crl-13533 55 1 7 7 NUM crl-13533 55 2 it it PRON crl-13533 55 3 is be AUX crl-13533 55 4 difficult difficult ADJ crl-13533 55 5 to to PART crl-13533 55 6 separate separate VERB crl-13533 55 7 haas haas NOUN crl-13533 55 8 ' ' PART crl-13533 55 9 contributions contribution NOUN crl-13533 55 10 to to ADP crl-13533 55 11 the the DET crl-13533 55 12 development development NOUN crl-13533 55 13 of of ADP crl-13533 55 14 the the DET crl-13533 55 15 two two NUM crl-13533 55 16 - - PUNCT crl-13533 55 17 track track NOUN crl-13533 55 18 system system NOUN crl-13533 55 19 from from ADP crl-13533 55 20 the the DET crl-13533 55 21 input input NOUN crl-13533 55 22 of of ADP crl-13533 55 23 various various ADJ crl-13533 55 24 members member NOUN crl-13533 55 25 of of ADP crl-13533 55 26 the the DET crl-13533 55 27 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 55 28 . . PUNCT crl-13533 56 1 although although SCONJ crl-13533 56 2 the the DET crl-13533 56 3 management management NOUN crl-13533 56 4 study study NOUN crl-13533 56 5 noted note VERB crl-13533 56 6 that that SCONJ crl-13533 56 7 working work VERB crl-13533 56 8 relationships relationship NOUN crl-13533 56 9 and and CCONJ crl-13533 56 10 communications communication NOUN crl-13533 56 11 at at ADP crl-13533 56 12 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 56 13 had have AUX crl-13533 56 14 " " PUNCT crl-13533 56 15 improved improve VERB crl-13533 56 16 through through ADP crl-13533 56 17 the the DET crl-13533 56 18 use use NOUN crl-13533 56 19 of of ADP crl-13533 56 20 committees committee NOUN crl-13533 56 21 , , PUNCT crl-13533 56 22 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 56 23 meetings meeting NOUN crl-13533 56 24 , , PUNCT crl-13533 56 25 and and CCONJ crl-13533 56 26 memoranda memorandum NOUN crl-13533 56 27 , , PUNCT crl-13533 56 28 " " PUNCT crl-13533 56 29 they they PRON crl-13533 56 30 were be AUX crl-13533 56 31 still still ADV crl-13533 56 32 considered consider VERB crl-13533 56 33 inadequate inadequate ADJ crl-13533 56 34 for for ADP crl-13533 56 35 various various ADJ crl-13533 56 36 reasons reason NOUN crl-13533 56 37 , , PUNCT crl-13533 56 38 including include VERB crl-13533 56 39 feelings feeling NOUN crl-13533 56 40 of of ADP crl-13533 56 41 distrust distrust NOUN crl-13533 56 42 among among ADP crl-13533 56 43 the the DET crl-13533 56 44 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 56 45 resulting result VERB crl-13533 56 46 from from ADP crl-13533 56 47 a a DET crl-13533 56 48 lack lack NOUN crl-13533 56 49 of of ADP crl-13533 56 50 involvement involvement NOUN crl-13533 56 51 in in ADP crl-13533 56 52 management management NOUN crl-13533 56 53 decisions decision NOUN crl-13533 56 54 . . PUNCT crl-13533 57 1 8 8 NUM crl-13533 57 2 l;lad l;lad NOUN crl-13533 57 3 there there PRON crl-13533 57 4 been be AUX crl-13533 57 5 no no DET crl-13533 57 6 management management NOUN crl-13533 57 7 study study NOUN crl-13533 57 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 57 9 it it PRON crl-13533 57 10 is be AUX crl-13533 57 11 apparent apparent ADJ crl-13533 57 12 to to ADP crl-13533 57 13 those those PRON crl-13533 57 14 who who PRON crl-13533 57 15 worked work VERB crl-13533 57 16 closely closely ADV crl-13533 57 17 with with ADP crl-13533 57 18 haas haas NOUN crl-13533 57 19 during during ADP crl-13533 57 20 the the DET crl-13533 57 21 eight eight NUM crl-13533 57 22 years year NOUN crl-13533 57 23 he he PRON crl-13533 57 24 was be AUX crl-13533 57 25 university university NOUN crl-13533 57 26 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 57 27 at at ADP crl-13533 57 28 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 57 29 that that SCONJ crl-13533 57 30 there there PRON crl-13533 57 31 would would AUX crl-13533 57 32 be be AUX crl-13533 57 33 more more ADJ crl-13533 57 34 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 57 35 involvement involvement NOUN crl-13533 57 36 in in ADP crl-13533 57 37 the the DET crl-13533 57 38 decision decision NOUN crl-13533 57 39 - - PUNCT crl-13533 57 40 making make VERB crl-13533 57 41 process process NOUN crl-13533 57 42 . . PUNCT crl-13533 58 1 characteristics characteristic NOUN crl-13533 58 2 of of ADP crl-13533 58 3 the the DET crl-13533 58 4 system system NOUN crl-13533 58 5 of of ADP crl-13533 58 6 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 58 7 ranks rank VERB crl-13533 58 8 the the DET crl-13533 58 9 system system NOUN crl-13533 58 10 of of ADP crl-13533 58 11 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 58 12 and and CCONJ crl-13533 58 13 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 58 14 review review NOUN crl-13533 58 15 at at ADP crl-13533 58 16 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 58 17 was be AUX crl-13533 58 18 established establish VERB crl-13533 58 19 to to PART crl-13533 58 20 benefit benefit VERB crl-13533 58 21 both both DET crl-13533 58 22 the the DET crl-13533 58 23 members member NOUN crl-13533 58 24 of of ADP crl-13533 58 25 the the DET crl-13533 58 26 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 58 27 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 58 28 and and CCONJ crl-13533 58 29 the the DET crl-13533 58 30 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 58 31 . . PUNCT crl-13533 59 1 for for ADP crl-13533 59 2 the the DET crl-13533 59 3 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 59 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 59 5 the the DET crl-13533 59 6 plan plan NOUN crl-13533 59 7 establishes establish VERB crl-13533 59 8 a a DET crl-13533 59 9 mechanism mechanism NOUN crl-13533 59 10 to to PART crl-13533 59 11 acknowledge acknowledge VERB crl-13533 59 12 · · PUNCT crl-13533 59 13 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 59 14 growth growth NOUN crl-13533 59 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 59 16 accomplishment accomplishment NOUN crl-13533 59 17 . . PUNCT crl-13533 60 1 the the DET crl-13533 60 2 system system NOUN crl-13533 60 3 of of ADP crl-13533 60 4 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 60 5 provides provide VERB crl-13533 60 6 for for ADP crl-13533 60 7 recognition recognition NOUN crl-13533 60 8 of of ADP crl-13533 60 9 individual individual ADJ crl-13533 60 10 merit merit NOUN crl-13533 60 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 60 12 quality quality NOUN crl-13533 60 13 of of ADP crl-13533 60 14 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 60 15 , , PUNCT crl-13533 60 16 and and CCONJ crl-13533 60 17 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 60 18 and and CCONJ crl-13533 60 19 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-13533 60 20 contributions contribution NOUN crl-13533 60 21 . . PUNCT crl-13533 61 1 further far ADV crl-13533 61 2 , , PUNCT crl-13533 61 3 it it PRON crl-13533 61 4 allows allow VERB crl-13533 61 5 each each DET crl-13533 61 6 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 61 7 to to PART crl-13533 61 8 receive receive VERB crl-13533 61 9 appropriate appropriate ADJ crl-13533 61 10 financial financial ADJ crl-13533 61 11 compensation compensation NOUN crl-13533 61 12 and and CCONJ crl-13533 61 13 significant significant ADJ crl-13533 61 14 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 61 15 advancement advancement NOUN crl-13533 61 16 without without ADP crl-13533 61 17 necessarily necessarily ADV crl-13533 61 18 assuming assume VERB crl-13533 61 19 management management NOUN crl-13533 61 20 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 61 21 . . PUNCT crl-13533 62 1 the the DET crl-13533 62 2 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-13533 62 3 and and CCONJ crl-13533 62 4 review review NOUN crl-13533 62 5 proce proce NOUN crl-13533 62 6 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 7 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 8 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 9 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 10 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 11 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 12 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 13 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 14 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 15 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 16 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 17 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 18 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 19 " " PUNCT crl-13533 62 20 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 21 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 22 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 23 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 24 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 25 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 26 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 27 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 28 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 29 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 62 30 _ _ PUNCT crl-13533 63 1 -~-~--------------- -~-~--------------- NUM crl-13533 63 2 , , PUNCT crl-13533 63 3 298 298 NUM crl-13533 63 4 i i PROPN crl-13533 63 5 college college PROPN crl-13533 63 6 & & CCONJ crl-13533 63 7 research research PROPN crl-13533 63 8 libraries librarie VERB crl-13533 63 9 • • ADJ crl-13533 63 10 july july PROPN crl-13533 63 11 1980 1980 NUM crl-13533 63 12 dures dure NOUN crl-13533 63 13 for for ADP crl-13533 63 14 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 63 15 in in ADP crl-13533 63 16 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 63 17 are be AUX crl-13533 63 18 intended intend VERB crl-13533 63 19 to to PART crl-13533 63 20 help help VERB crl-13533 63 21 assure assure VERB crl-13533 63 22 that that SCONJ crl-13533 63 23 each each DET crl-13533 63 24 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 63 25 will will AUX crl-13533 63 26 be be AUX crl-13533 63 27 appraised appraise VERB crl-13533 63 28 fairly fairly ADV crl-13533 63 29 on on ADP crl-13533 63 30 the the DET crl-13533 63 31 basis basis NOUN crl-13533 63 32 of of ADP crl-13533 63 33 stated stated ADJ crl-13533 63 34 criteria criterion NOUN crl-13533 63 35 . . PUNCT crl-13533 64 1 these these DET crl-13533 64 2 criteria criterion NOUN crl-13533 64 3 provide provide VERB crl-13533 64 4 guidelines guideline NOUN crl-13533 64 5 for for ADP crl-13533 64 6 uniform uniform ADJ crl-13533 64 7 assessment assessment NOUN crl-13533 64 8 throughout throughout ADP crl-13533 64 9 the the DET crl-13533 64 10 library library NOUN crl-13533 64 11 system system NOUN crl-13533 64 12 and and CCONJ crl-13533 64 13 facilitate facilitate NOUN crl-13533 64 14 recognition recognition NOUN crl-13533 64 15 of of ADP crl-13533 64 16 achievement achievement NOUN crl-13533 64 17 . . PUNCT crl-13533 65 1 the the DET crl-13533 65 2 system system NOUN crl-13533 65 3 is be AUX crl-13533 65 4 based base VERB crl-13533 65 5 on on ADP crl-13533 65 6 the the DET crl-13533 65 7 premises premise NOUN crl-13533 65 8 tbat tbat NOUN crl-13533 65 9 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-13533 65 10 is be AUX crl-13533 65 11 a a DET crl-13533 65 12 field field NOUN crl-13533 65 13 in in ADP crl-13533 65 14 which which PRON crl-13533 65 15 a a DET crl-13533 65 16 variety variety NOUN crl-13533 65 17 of of ADP crl-13533 65 18 skills skill NOUN crl-13533 65 19 and and CCONJ crl-13533 65 20 talents talent NOUN crl-13533 65 21 are be AUX crl-13533 65 22 valued value VERB crl-13533 65 23 and and CCONJ crl-13533 65 24 that that SCONJ crl-13533 65 25 the the DET crl-13533 65 26 " " PUNCT crl-13533 65 27 quality quality NOUN crl-13533 65 28 of of ADP crl-13533 65 29 library library NOUN crl-13533 65 30 operations operation NOUN crl-13533 65 31 is be AUX crl-13533 65 32 governed govern VERB crl-13533 65 33 by by ADP crl-13533 65 34 distinctive distinctive ADJ crl-13533 65 35 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 65 36 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 65 37 . . PUNCT crl-13533 66 1 the the DET crl-13533 66 2 system system NOUN crl-13533 66 3 of of ADP crl-13533 66 4 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 66 5 and and CCONJ crl-13533 66 6 the the DET crl-13533 66 7 related related ADJ crl-13533 66 8 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 66 9 review review NOUN crl-13533 66 10 process process NOUN crl-13533 66 11 encourage encourage VERB crl-13533 66 12 individual individual ADJ crl-13533 66 13 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 66 14 development development NOUN crl-13533 66 15 in in ADP crl-13533 66 16 the the DET crl-13533 66 17 context context NOUN crl-13533 66 18 of of ADP crl-13533 66 19 library library NOUN crl-13533 66 20 and and CCONJ crl-13533 66 21 university university NOUN crl-13533 66 22 objectives objective NOUN crl-13533 66 23 and and CCONJ crl-13533 66 24 thus thus ADV crl-13533 66 25 are be AUX crl-13533 66 26 aimed aim VERB crl-13533 66 27 at at ADP crl-13533 66 28 the the DET crl-13533 66 29 development development NOUN crl-13533 66 30 of of ADP crl-13533 66 31 an an DET crl-13533 66 32 effective effective ADJ crl-13533 66 33 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 66 34 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 66 35 of of ADP crl-13533 66 36 the the DET crl-13533 66 37 highest high ADJ crl-13533 66 38 quality quality NOUN crl-13533 66 39 " " PUNCT crl-13533 66 40 to to PART crl-13533 66 41 provide provide VERB crl-13533 66 42 excellent excellent ADJ crl-13533 66 43 library library NOUN crl-13533 66 44 service service NOUN crl-13533 66 45 to to ADP crl-13533 66 46 the the DET crl-13533 66 47 university university NOUN crl-13533 66 48 . . PUNCT crl-13533 67 1 with with ADP crl-13533 67 2 the the DET crl-13533 67 3 exception exception NOUN crl-13533 67 4 of of ADP crl-13533 67 5 the the DET crl-13533 67 6 university university NOUN crl-13533 67 7 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 67 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 67 9 each each DET crl-13533 67 10 member member NOUN crl-13533 67 11 of of ADP crl-13533 67 12 the the DET crl-13533 67 13 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 67 14 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 67 15 holds hold VERB crl-13533 67 16 one one NUM crl-13533 67 17 of of ADP crl-13533 67 18 four four NUM crl-13533 67 19 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 67 20 . . PUNCT crl-13533 68 1 initial initial ADJ crl-13533 68 2 determination determination NOUN crl-13533 68 3 of of ADP crl-13533 68 4 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 68 5 and and CCONJ crl-13533 68 6 subsequent subsequent ADJ crl-13533 68 7 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 68 8 are be AUX crl-13533 68 9 largely largely ADV crl-13533 68 10 governed govern VERB crl-13533 68 11 by by ADP crl-13533 68 12 a a DET crl-13533 68 13 review review NOUN crl-13533 68 14 process process NOUN crl-13533 68 15 conducted conduct VERB crl-13533 68 16 by by ADP crl-13533 68 17 the the DET crl-13533 68 18 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 68 19 review review NOUN crl-13533 68 20 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 68 21 . . PUNCT crl-13533 69 1 while while SCONJ crl-13533 69 2 the the DET crl-13533 69 3 recommendations recommendation NOUN crl-13533 69 4 of of ADP crl-13533 69 5 this this DET crl-13533 69 6 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 69 7 are be AUX crl-13533 69 8 advisory advisory ADJ crl-13533 69 9 to to ADP crl-13533 69 10 the the DET crl-13533 69 11 university university NOUN crl-13533 69 12 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 69 13 and and CCONJ crl-13533 69 14 ultimately ultimately ADV crl-13533 69 15 to to ADP crl-13533 69 16 the the DET crl-13533 69 17 university university NOUN crl-13533 69 18 administration administration NOUN crl-13533 69 19 , , PUNCT crl-13533 69 20 the the DET crl-13533 69 21 work work NOUN crl-13533 69 22 and and CCONJ crl-13533 69 23 judgment judgment NOUN crl-13533 69 24 of of ADP crl-13533 69 25 the the DET crl-13533 69 26 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 69 27 are be AUX crl-13533 69 28 fundamental fundamental ADJ crl-13533 69 29 to to ADP crl-13533 69 30 the the DET crl-13533 69 31 ranking ranking ADJ crl-13533 69 32 process process NOUN crl-13533 69 33 . . PUNCT crl-13533 70 1 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 70 2 procedures procedure NOUN crl-13533 70 3 have have AUX crl-13533 70 4 been be AUX crl-13533 70 5 carefully carefully ADV crl-13533 70 6 established establish VERB crl-13533 70 7 to to PART crl-13533 70 8 assure assure VERB crl-13533 70 9 comprehensive comprehensive ADJ crl-13533 70 10 and and CCONJ crl-13533 70 11 fair fair ADJ crl-13533 70 12 reviews review NOUN crl-13533 70 13 while while SCONJ crl-13533 70 14 maintaining maintain VERB crl-13533 70 15 confidentiality confidentiality NOUN crl-13533 70 16 . . PUNCT crl-13533 71 1 general general ADJ crl-13533 71 2 descriptions description NOUN crl-13533 71 3 of of ADP crl-13533 71 4 the the DET crl-13533 71 5 four four NUM crl-13533 71 6 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 71 7 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 71 8 follow follow VERB crl-13533 71 9 : : PUNCT crl-13533 71 10 l l X crl-13533 71 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 71 12 ibrarian ibrarian PROPN crl-13533 71 13 i i PRON crl-13533 71 14 . . PUNCT crl-13533 72 1 this this DET crl-13533 72 2 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 72 3 designates designate VERB crl-13533 72 4 the the DET crl-13533 72 5 beginning begin VERB crl-13533 72 6 level level NOUN crl-13533 72 7 of of ADP crl-13533 72 8 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-13533 72 9 . . PUNCT crl-13533 73 1 the the DET crl-13533 73 2 title title NOUN crl-13533 73 3 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 73 4 i i PRON crl-13533 73 5 is be AUX crl-13533 73 6 assigned assign VERB crl-13533 73 7 to to ADP crl-13533 73 8 individuals individual NOUN crl-13533 73 9 who who PRON crl-13533 73 10 have have AUX crl-13533 73 11 completed complete VERB crl-13533 73 12 the the DET crl-13533 73 13 required require VERB crl-13533 73 14 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 73 15 and/or and/or CCONJ crl-13533 73 16 other other ADJ crl-13533 73 17 graduate graduate NOUN crl-13533 73 18 training training NOUN crl-13533 73 19 , , PUNCT crl-13533 73 20 but but CCONJ crl-13533 73 21 have have VERB crl-13533 73 22 little little ADJ crl-13533 73 23 or or CCONJ crl-13533 73 24 no no PRON crl-13533 73 25 pertinent pertinent ADJ crl-13533 73 26 experience experience NOUN crl-13533 73 27 in in ADP crl-13533 73 28 research research NOUN crl-13533 73 29 or or CCONJ crl-13533 73 30 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 73 31 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-13533 73 32 . . PUNCT crl-13533 74 1 librarian librarian PROPN crl-13533 74 2 ii ii PROPN crl-13533 74 3 . . PUNCT crl-13533 75 1 this this PRON crl-13533 75 2 is be AUX crl-13533 75 3 the the DET crl-13533 75 4 initial initial ADJ crl-13533 75 5 career career NOUN crl-13533 75 6 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 75 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 75 8 and and CCONJ crl-13533 75 9 individuals individual NOUN crl-13533 75 10 promoted promote VERB crl-13533 75 11 to to ADP crl-13533 75 12 librarian librarian PROPN crl-13533 75 13 ii ii PROPN crl-13533 75 14 are be AUX crl-13533 75 15 those those PRON crl-13533 75 16 who who PRON crl-13533 75 17 have have AUX crl-13533 75 18 adequately adequately ADV crl-13533 75 19 displayed display VERB crl-13533 75 20 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 75 21 skills skill NOUN crl-13533 75 22 and and CCONJ crl-13533 75 23 perceptions perception NOUN crl-13533 75 24 as as ADV crl-13533 75 25 well well ADV crl-13533 75 26 as as ADP crl-13533 75 27 an an DET crl-13533 75 28 affinity affinity NOUN crl-13533 75 29 for for ADP crl-13533 75 30 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 75 31 and and CCONJ crl-13533 75 32 research research NOUN crl-13533 75 33 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-13533 75 34 . . PUNCT crl-13533 76 1 librarjan librarjan PROPN crl-13533 76 2 ill ill PROPN crl-13533 76 3 . . PUNCT crl-13533 77 1 this this PRON crl-13533 77 2 is be AUX crl-13533 77 3 the the DET crl-13533 77 4 principal principal ADJ crl-13533 77 5 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 77 6 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 77 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 77 8 which which PRON crl-13533 77 9 it it PRON crl-13533 77 10 is be AUX crl-13533 77 11 assumed assume VERB crl-13533 77 12 a a DET crl-13533 77 13 majority majority NOUN crl-13533 77 14 of of ADP crl-13533 77 15 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 77 16 members member NOUN crl-13533 77 17 will will AUX crl-13533 77 18 attain attain VERB crl-13533 77 19 . . PUNCT crl-13533 78 1 it it PRON crl-13533 78 2 generally generally ADV crl-13533 78 3 indicates indicate VERB crl-13533 78 4 that that SCONJ crl-13533 78 5 the the DET crl-13533 78 6 individual individual NOUN crl-13533 78 7 has have AUX crl-13533 78 8 mastered master VERB crl-13533 78 9 the the DET crl-13533 78 10 skills skill NOUN crl-13533 78 11 and and CCONJ crl-13533 78 12 techniques technique NOUN crl-13533 78 13 of of ADP crl-13533 78 14 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-13533 78 15 , , PUNCT crl-13533 78 16 has have AUX crl-13533 78 17 demonstrated demonstrate VERB crl-13533 78 18 a a DET crl-13533 78 19 high high ADJ crl-13533 78 20 level level NOUN crl-13533 78 21 of of ADP crl-13533 78 22 " " PUNCT crl-13533 78 23 prqfessional prqfessional ADJ crl-13533 78 24 perfonpance perfonpance NOUN crl-13533 78 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 78 26 and and CCONJ crl-13533 78 27 has have AUX crl-13533 78 28 made make VERB crl-13533 78 29 meaningful meaningful ADJ crl-13533 78 30 profession;tl profession;tl NUM crl-13533 78 31 contributions contribution NOUN crl-13533 78 32 . . PUNCT crl-13533 79 1 librarian librarian ADJ crl-13533 79 2 iv iv PROPN crl-13533 79 3 . . PUNCT crl-13533 80 1 this this DET crl-13533 80 2 highest high ADJ crl-13533 80 3 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 80 4 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 80 5 is be AUX crl-13533 80 6 reserved reserve VERB crl-13533 80 7 for for ADP crl-13533 80 8 individuals individual NOUN crl-13533 80 9 who who PRON crl-13533 80 10 have have AUX crl-13533 80 11 made make VERB crl-13533 80 12 distinctive distinctive ADJ crl-13533 80 13 contributions contribution NOUN crl-13533 80 14 over over ADP crl-13533 80 15 a a DET crl-13533 80 16 significant significant ADJ crl-13533 80 17 period period NOUN crl-13533 80 18 of of ADP crl-13533 80 19 time time NOUN crl-13533 80 20 to to ADP crl-13533 80 21 the the DET crl-13533 80 22 university university NOUN crl-13533 80 23 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 80 24 and and CCONJ crl-13533 80 25 to to ADP crl-13533 80 26 the the DET crl-13533 80 27 profession profession NOUN crl-13533 80 28 . . PUNCT crl-13533 81 1 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 81 2 to to ADP crl-13533 81 3 librarian librarian ADJ crl-13533 81 4 iv iv PROPN crl-13533 81 5 is be AUX crl-13533 81 6 exceptional exceptional ADJ crl-13533 81 7 rather rather ADV crl-13533 81 8 than than ADP crl-13533 81 9 usual usual ADJ crl-13533 81 10 . . PUNCT crl-13533 82 1 criteria criterion NOUN crl-13533 82 2 for for ADP crl-13533 82 3 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 82 4 the the DET crl-13533 82 5 general general ADJ crl-13533 82 6 criteria criterion NOUN crl-13533 82 7 for for ADP crl-13533 82 8 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 82 9 in in ADP crl-13533 82 10 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 82 11 are be AUX crl-13533 82 12 quality quality NOUN crl-13533 82 13 of of ADP crl-13533 82 14 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 82 15 in in ADP crl-13533 82 16 the the DET crl-13533 82 17 area area NOUN crl-13533 82 18 of of ADP crl-13533 82 19 the the DET crl-13533 82 20 candidate candidate NOUN crl-13533 82 21 's 's PART crl-13533 82 22 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 82 23 , , PUNCT crl-13533 82 24 as as ADV crl-13533 82 25 well well ADV crl-13533 82 26 as as ADP crl-13533 82 27 the the DET crl-13533 82 28 quality quality NOUN crl-13533 82 29 of of ADP crl-13533 82 30 service service NOUN crl-13533 82 31 on on ADP crl-13533 82 32 library library NOUN crl-13533 82 33 committees committee NOUN crl-13533 82 34 and and CCONJ crl-13533 82 35 task task NOUN crl-13533 82 36 forces force NOUN crl-13533 82 37 , , PUNCT crl-13533 82 38 library library PROPN crl-13533 82 39 instructional instructional ADJ crl-13533 82 40 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 82 41 , , PUNCT crl-13533 82 42 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 82 43 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 82 44 outside outside ADP crl-13533 82 45 the the DET crl-13533 82 46 library library NOUN crl-13533 82 47 , , PUNCT crl-13533 82 48 research research NOUN crl-13533 82 49 and and CCONJ crl-13533 82 50 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 82 51 achievement achievement NOUN crl-13533 82 52 , , PUNCT crl-13533 82 53 and and CCONJ crl-13533 82 54 participation participation NOUN crl-13533 82 55 in in ADP crl-13533 82 56 university university NOUN crl-13533 82 57 affairs affair NOUN crl-13533 82 58 . . PUNCT crl-13533 83 1 the the DET crl-13533 83 2 criteria criterion NOUN crl-13533 83 3 are be AUX crl-13533 83 4 not not PART crl-13533 83 5 of of ADP crl-13533 83 6 equal equal ADJ crl-13533 83 7 significance significance NOUN crl-13533 83 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 83 9 and and CCONJ crl-13533 83 10 the the DET crl-13533 83 11 degree degree NOUN crl-13533 83 12 of of ADP crl-13533 83 13 importance importance NOUN crl-13533 83 14 given give VERB crl-13533 83 15 to to ADP crl-13533 83 16 any any DET crl-13533 83 17 one one NUM crl-13533 83 18 of of ADP crl-13533 83 19 them they PRON crl-13533 83 20 may may AUX crl-13533 83 21 vary vary VERB crl-13533 83 22 from from ADP crl-13533 83 23 one one NUM crl-13533 83 24 candidate candidate NOUN crl-13533 83 25 to to ADP crl-13533 83 26 another another PRON crl-13533 83 27 . . PUNCT crl-13533 84 1 it it PRON crl-13533 84 2 is be AUX crl-13533 84 3 the the DET crl-13533 84 4 intent intent NOUN crl-13533 84 5 of of ADP crl-13533 84 6 the the DET crl-13533 84 7 system system NOUN crl-13533 84 8 to to PART crl-13533 84 9 foster foster VERB crl-13533 84 10 the the DET crl-13533 84 11 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 84 12 development development NOUN crl-13533 84 13 of of ADP crl-13533 84 14 the the DET crl-13533 84 15 individual individual NOUN crl-13533 84 16 through through ADP crl-13533 84 17 external external ADJ crl-13533 84 18 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 84 19 and and CCONJ crl-13533 84 20 the the DET crl-13533 84 21 pursuit pursuit NOUN crl-13533 84 22 of of ADP crl-13533 84 23 advanced advanced ADJ crl-13533 84 24 degrees degree NOUN crl-13533 84 25 in in ADP crl-13533 84 26 conjunction conjunction NOUN crl-13533 84 27 with with ADP crl-13533 84 28 , , PUNCT crl-13533 84 29 but but CCONJ crl-13533 84 30 not not PART crl-13533 84 31 at at ADP crl-13533 84 32 the the DET crl-13533 84 33 expense expense NOUN crl-13533 84 34 of of ADP crl-13533 84 35 , , PUNCT crl-13533 84 36 ftjlfillment ftjlfillment NOUN crl-13533 84 37 of of ADP crl-13533 84 38 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 84 39 to to ADP crl-13533 84 40 the the DET crl-13533 84 41 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 84 42 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 84 43 . . PUNCT crl-13533 85 1 although although SCONJ crl-13533 85 2 talents talent NOUN crl-13533 85 3 , , PUNCT crl-13533 85 4 inclinations inclination NOUN crl-13533 85 5 , , PUNCT crl-13533 85 6 and and CCONJ crl-13533 85 7 specialities speciality NOUN crl-13533 85 8 of of ADP crl-13533 85 9 individuals individual NOUN crl-13533 85 10 and and CCONJ crl-13533 85 11 demands demand NOUN crl-13533 85 12 of of ADP crl-13533 85 13 positions position NOUN crl-13533 85 14 may may AUX crl-13533 85 15 vary vary VERB crl-13533 85 16 , , PUNCT crl-13533 85 17 high high ADJ crl-13533 85 18 quality quality NOUN crl-13533 85 19 job job NOUN crl-13533 85 20 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 85 21 is be AUX crl-13533 85 22 one one NUM crl-13533 85 23 criterion criterion NOUN crl-13533 85 24 which which PRON crl-13533 85 25 must must AUX crl-13533 85 26 be be AUX crl-13533 85 27 met meet VERB crl-13533 85 28 for for ADP crl-13533 85 29 any any DET crl-13533 85 30 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 85 31 . . PUNCT crl-13533 86 1 advancement advancement NOUN crl-13533 86 2 in in ADP crl-13533 86 3 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 86 4 is be AUX crl-13533 86 5 not not PART crl-13533 86 6 automatic automatic ADJ crl-13533 86 7 upon upon SCONJ crl-13533 86 8 cumulation cumulation NOUN crl-13533 86 9 of of ADP crl-13533 86 10 years year NOUN crl-13533 86 11 of of ADP crl-13533 86 12 experience experience NOUN crl-13533 86 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 86 14 but but CCONJ crl-13533 86 15 is be AUX crl-13533 86 16 based base VERB crl-13533 86 17 on on ADP crl-13533 86 18 appraisal appraisal NOUN crl-13533 86 19 of of ADP crl-13533 86 20 the the DET crl-13533 86 21 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 86 22 of of ADP crl-13533 86 23 each each DET crl-13533 86 24 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 86 25 . . PUNCT crl-13533 87 1 in in ADP crl-13533 87 2 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 87 3 from from ADP crl-13533 87 4 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 87 5 i i PRON crl-13533 87 6 to to ADP crl-13533 87 7 ii ii PROPN crl-13533 87 8 and and CCONJ crl-13533 87 9 ii ii PROPN crl-13533 87 10 to to ADP crl-13533 87 11 iii iii NUM crl-13533 87 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 87 13 job job NOUN crl-13533 87 14 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 87 15 is be AUX crl-13533 87 16 typically typically ADV crl-13533 87 17 the the DET crl-13533 87 18 single single ADJ crl-13533 87 19 most most ADV crl-13533 87 20 important important ADJ crl-13533 87 21 factor factor NOUN crl-13533 87 22 . . PUNCT crl-13533 88 1 in in ADP crl-13533 88 2 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 88 3 from from ADP crl-13533 88 4 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 88 5 iii iii NUM crl-13533 88 6 to to ADP crl-13533 88 7 iv iv NUM crl-13533 88 8 othe othe DET crl-13533 88 9 r r NOUN crl-13533 88 10 factors factor NOUN crl-13533 88 11 in in ADP crl-13533 88 12 addition addition NOUN crl-13533 88 13 to to ADP crl-13533 88 14 job job NOUN crl-13533 88 15 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 88 16 are be AUX crl-13533 88 17 given give VERB crl-13533 88 18 increasing increase VERB crl-13533 88 19 weight weight NOUN crl-13533 88 20 . . PUNCT crl-13533 89 1 the the DET crl-13533 89 2 specific specific ADJ crl-13533 89 3 criteria criterion NOUN crl-13533 89 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 89 5 which which PRON crl-13533 89 6 are be AUX crl-13533 89 7 summarized summarize VERB crl-13533 89 8 below below ADV crl-13533 89 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 89 10 are be AUX crl-13533 89 11 similar similar ADJ crl-13533 89 12 to to ADP crl-13533 89 13 those those PRON crl-13533 89 14 found find VERB crl-13533 89 15 at at ADP crl-13533 89 16 a a DET crl-13533 89 17 number number NOUN crl-13533 89 18 of of ADP crl-13533 89 19 institutions institution NOUN crl-13533 89 20 which which PRON crl-13533 89 21 have have VERB crl-13533 89 22 either either CCONJ crl-13533 89 23 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 89 24 status status NOUN crl-13533 89 25 or or CCONJ crl-13533 89 26 comparable comparable ADJ crl-13533 89 27 ranking ranking NOUN crl-13533 89 28 systems system NOUN crl-13533 89 29 . . PUNCT crl-13533 90 1 9 9 NUM crl-13533 90 2 job job NOUN crl-13533 90 3 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 90 4 . . PUNCT crl-13533 91 1 among among ADP crl-13533 91 2 the the DET crl-13533 91 3 factors factor NOUN crl-13533 91 4 considered consider VERB crl-13533 91 5 are be AUX crl-13533 91 6 : : PUNCT crl-13533 91 7 consistency consistency NOUN crl-13533 91 8 of of ADP crl-13533 91 9 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 91 10 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 11 ability ability NOUN crl-13533 91 12 to to PART crl-13533 91 13 innovate innovate VERB crl-13533 91 14 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 15 initiative initiative NOUN crl-13533 91 16 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 17 ability ability NOUN crl-13533 91 18 to to PART crl-13533 91 19 work work VERB crl-13533 91 20 effectively effectively ADV crl-13533 91 21 with with ADP crl-13533 91 22 others other NOUN crl-13533 91 23 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 24 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 91 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 26 ability ability NOUN crl-13533 91 27 to to PART crl-13533 91 28 organize organize VERB crl-13533 91 29 work work NOUN crl-13533 91 30 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 31 ability ability NOUN crl-13533 91 32 to to PART crl-13533 91 33 relate relate VERB crl-13533 91 34 job job NOUN crl-13533 91 35 functions function NOUN crl-13533 91 36 to to ADP crl-13533 91 37 the the DET crl-13533 91 38 more more ADV crl-13533 91 39 general general ADJ crl-13533 91 40 goals goal NOUN crl-13533 91 41 of of ADP crl-13533 91 42 the the DET crl-13533 91 43 library library NOUN crl-13533 91 44 and and CCONJ crl-13533 91 45 university university NOUN crl-13533 91 46 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 47 response response NOUN crl-13533 91 48 to to ADP crl-13533 91 49 criticism criticism NOUN crl-13533 91 50 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 51 dependability dependability NOUN crl-13533 91 52 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 53 accuracy accuracy NOUN crl-13533 91 54 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 55 oral oral ADJ crl-13533 91 56 and and CCONJ crl-13533 91 57 written write VERB crl-13533 91 58 skills skill NOUN crl-13533 91 59 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 60 judgment judgment NOUN crl-13533 91 61 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 62 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 91 63 attitude attitude NOUN crl-13533 91 64 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 65 adaptability adaptability NOUN crl-13533 91 66 , , PUNCT crl-13533 91 67 and and CCONJ crl-13533 91 68 leadership leadership NOUN crl-13533 91 69 . . PUNCT crl-13533 92 1 library library PROPN crl-13533 92 2 committe committe PROPN crl-13533 92 3 es es PROPN crl-13533 92 4 and and CCONJ crl-13533 92 5 instructipnal instructipnal ADJ crl-13533 92 6 assignments assignment NOUN crl-13533 92 7 . . PUNCT crl-13533 93 1 the the DET crl-13533 93 2 quality quality NOUN crl-13533 93 3 and and CCONJ crl-13533 93 4 extent extent NOUN crl-13533 93 5 of of ADP crl-13533 93 6 contributions contribution NOUN crl-13533 93 7 made make VERB crl-13533 93 8 to to ADP crl-13533 93 9 the the DET crl-13533 93 10 solution solution NOUN crl-13533 93 11 of of ADP crl-13533 93 12 library library NOUN crl-13533 93 13 problems problem NOUN crl-13533 93 14 through through ADP crl-13533 93 15 service service NOUN crl-13533 93 16 on on ADP crl-13533 93 17 internal internal ADJ crl-13533 93 18 committees committee NOUN crl-13533 93 19 , , PUNCT crl-13533 93 20 task task NOUN crl-13533 93 21 forces force NOUN crl-13533 93 22 , , PUNCT crl-13533 93 23 and and CCONJ crl-13533 93 24 the the DET crl-13533 93 25 instructional instructional ADJ crl-13533 93 26 program program NOUN crl-13533 93 27 are be AUX crl-13533 93 28 considered consider VERB crl-13533 93 29 , , PUNCT crl-13533 93 30 even even ADV crl-13533 93 31 though though SCONJ crl-13533 93 32 such such ADJ crl-13533 93 33 service service NOUN crl-13533 93 34 may may AUX crl-13533 93 35 be be AUX crl-13533 93 36 unrelated unrelated ADJ crl-13533 93 37 to to ADP crl-13533 93 38 the the DET crl-13533 93 39 individual individual NOUN crl-13533 93 40 's 's PART crl-13533 93 41 primary primary ADJ crl-13533 93 42 area area NOUN crl-13533 93 43 of of ADP crl-13533 93 44 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 93 45 . . PUNCT crl-13533 94 1 among among ADP crl-13533 94 2 the the DET crl-13533 94 3 factors factor NOUN crl-13533 94 4 considered consider VERB crl-13533 94 5 are be AUX crl-13533 94 6 : : PUNCT crl-13533 94 7 fulfillment fulfillment NOUN crl-13533 94 8 of of ADP crl-13533 94 9 basic basic ADJ crl-13533 94 10 obligations obligation NOUN crl-13533 94 11 of of ADP crl-13533 94 12 attendance attendance NOUN crl-13533 94 13 and and CCONJ crl-13533 94 14 participation participation NOUN crl-13533 94 15 , , PUNCT crl-13533 94 16 working work VERB crl-13533 94 17 relations relation NOUN crl-13533 94 18 with with ADP crl-13533 94 19 other other ADJ crl-13533 94 20 members member NOUN crl-13533 94 21 , , PUNCT crl-13533 94 22 membership membership NOUN crl-13533 94 23 / / SYM crl-13533 94 24 chairmanship chairmanship NOUN crl-13533 94 25 of of ADP crl-13533 94 26 subcommittees subcommittee NOUN crl-13533 94 27 , , PUNCT crl-13533 94 28 timely timely ADJ crl-13533 94 29 completion completion NOUN crl-13533 94 30 and and CCONJ crl-13533 94 31 quality quality NOUN crl-13533 94 32 of of ADP crl-13533 94 33 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 94 34 assignments assignment NOUN crl-13533 94 35 . . PUNCT crl-13533 95 1 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 95 2 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 95 3 , , PUNCT crl-13533 95 4 continuing continue VERB crl-13533 95 5 education education NOUN crl-13533 95 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 95 7 research research NOUN crl-13533 95 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 95 9 publications publication NOUN crl-13533 95 10 , , PUNCT crl-13533 95 11 and and CCONJ crl-13533 95 12 teaching teaching NOUN crl-13533 95 13 . . PUNCT crl-13533 96 1 meaningful meaningful ADJ crl-13533 96 2 participation participation NOUN crl-13533 96 3 in in ADP crl-13533 96 4 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 96 5 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 96 6 on on ADP crl-13533 96 7 local local ADJ crl-13533 96 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 96 9 state state NOUN crl-13533 96 10 , , PUNCT crl-13533 96 11 regional regional ADJ crl-13533 96 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 96 13 and and CCONJ crl-13533 96 14 national national ADJ crl-13533 96 15 levels level NOUN crl-13533 96 16 is be AUX crl-13533 96 17 considered consider VERB crl-13533 96 18 . . PUNCT crl-13533 97 1 examples example NOUN crl-13533 97 2 of of ADP crl-13533 97 3 such such ADJ crl-13533 97 4 participation participation NOUN crl-13533 97 5 include include VERB crl-13533 97 6 offices office NOUN crl-13533 97 7 held hold VERB crl-13533 97 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 97 9 awards award NOUN crl-13533 97 10 received receive VERB crl-13533 97 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 97 12 and and CCONJ crl-13533 97 13 leadership leadership NOUN crl-13533 97 14 of of ADP crl-13533 97 15 seminars seminar NOUN crl-13533 97 16 and and CCONJ crl-13533 97 17 workshops workshop NOUN crl-13533 97 18 . . PUNCT crl-13533 98 1 an an DET crl-13533 98 2 individual individual NOUN crl-13533 98 3 is be AUX crl-13533 98 4 expected expect VERB crl-13533 98 5 to to PART crl-13533 98 6 continue continue VERB crl-13533 98 7 study study NOUN crl-13533 98 8 and and CCONJ crl-13533 98 9 research research NOUN crl-13533 98 10 in in ADP crl-13533 98 11 fields field NOUN crl-13533 98 12 relevant relevant ADJ crl-13533 98 13 to to ADP crl-13533 98 14 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-13533 98 15 . . PUNCT crl-13533 99 1 involvement involvement NOUN crl-13533 99 2 in in ADP crl-13533 99 3 continuing continue VERB crl-13533 99 4 educa educa NOUN crl-13533 99 5 · · PUNCT crl-13533 99 6 tion tion NOUN crl-13533 99 7 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 99 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 99 9 such such ADJ crl-13533 99 10 as as ADP crl-13533 99 11 formal formal ADJ crl-13533 99 12 courses course NOUN crl-13533 99 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 99 14 seminars seminar NOUN crl-13533 99 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 99 16 workshops workshop NOUN crl-13533 99 17 , , PUNCT crl-13533 99 18 as as ADV crl-13533 99 19 well well ADV crl-13533 99 20 as as ADP crl-13533 99 21 advanced advanced ADJ crl-13533 99 22 degrees degree NOUN crl-13533 99 23 obtained obtain VERB crl-13533 99 24 or or CCONJ crl-13533 99 25 in in ADP crl-13533 99 26 progress progress NOUN crl-13533 99 27 will will AUX crl-13533 99 28 be be AUX crl-13533 99 29 considered consider VERB crl-13533 99 30 . . PUNCT crl-13533 100 1 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 100 2 contributions contribution NOUN crl-13533 100 3 such such ADJ crl-13533 100 4 as as ADP crl-13533 100 5 books book NOUN crl-13533 100 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 100 7 articles article NOUN crl-13533 100 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 100 9 book book NOUN crl-13533 100 10 reviews review NOUN crl-13533 100 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 100 12 editorships editorships PROPN crl-13533 100 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 100 14 bibliographies bibliography NOUN crl-13533 100 15 , , PUNCT crl-13533 100 16 handbooks handbook NOUN crl-13533 100 17 , , PUNCT crl-13533 100 18 teaching teach VERB crl-13533 100 19 appointments appointment NOUN crl-13533 100 20 , , PUNCT crl-13533 100 21 and and CCONJ crl-13533 100 22 lectures lecture NOUN crl-13533 100 23 are be AUX crl-13533 100 24 also also ADV crl-13533 100 25 considered consider VERB crl-13533 100 26 . . PUNCT crl-13533 101 1 university university NOUN crl-13533 101 2 service service NOUN crl-13533 101 3 . . PUNCT crl-13533 102 1 consideration consideration NOUN crl-13533 102 2 is be AUX crl-13533 102 3 given give VERB crl-13533 102 4 to to ADP crl-13533 102 5 relevant relevant ADJ crl-13533 102 6 university university NOUN crl-13533 102 7 service service NOUN crl-13533 102 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 102 9 such such ADJ crl-13533 102 10 as as ADP crl-13533 102 11 participation participation NOUN crl-13533 102 12 in in ADP crl-13533 102 13 the the DET crl-13533 102 14 work work NOUN crl-13533 102 15 of of ADP crl-13533 102 16 senate senate PROPN crl-13533 102 17 committees committee NOUN crl-13533 102 18 , , PUNCT crl-13533 102 19 departmental departmental ADJ crl-13533 102 20 and and CCONJ crl-13533 102 21 ad ad NOUN crl-13533 102 22 hoc hoc X crl-13533 102 23 committees committee NOUN crl-13533 102 24 , , PUNCT crl-13533 102 25 and and CCONJ crl-13533 102 26 other other ADJ crl-13533 102 27 university university NOUN crl-13533 102 28 organizations organization NOUN crl-13533 102 29 . . PUNCT crl-13533 103 1 two two NUM crl-13533 103 2 frequently frequently ADV crl-13533 103 3 asked ask VERB crl-13533 103 4 questions question NOUN crl-13533 103 5 addressed address VERB crl-13533 103 6 to to ADP crl-13533 103 7 the the DET crl-13533 103 8 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 103 9 review review NOUN crl-13533 103 10 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 103 11 by by ADP crl-13533 103 12 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 103 13 who who PRON crl-13533 103 14 were be AUX crl-13533 103 15 not not PART crl-13533 103 16 on on ADP crl-13533 103 17 the the DET crl-13533 103 18 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 103 19 when when SCONJ crl-13533 103 20 the the DET crl-13533 103 21 system system NOUN crl-13533 103 22 of of ADP crl-13533 103 23 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 103 24 was be AUX crl-13533 103 25 being be AUX crl-13533 103 26 developed develop VERB crl-13533 103 27 concern concern NOUN crl-13533 103 28 the the DET crl-13533 103 29 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 103 30 of of ADP crl-13533 103 31 the the DET crl-13533 103 32 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 103 33 review review NOUN crl-13533 103 34 pro pro ADJ crl-13533 103 35 · · PUNCT crl-13533 103 36 cess cess ADJ crl-13533 103 37 and and CCONJ crl-13533 103 38 the the DET crl-13533 103 39 element element NOUN crl-13533 103 40 of of ADP crl-13533 103 41 confidentiality confidentiality NOUN crl-13533 103 42 . . PUNCT crl-13533 104 1 both both PRON crl-13533 104 2 of of ADP crl-13533 104 3 these these DET crl-13533 104 4 elements element NOUN crl-13533 104 5 are be AUX crl-13533 104 6 critical critical ADJ crl-13533 104 7 to to ADP crl-13533 104 8 the the DET crl-13533 104 9 system system NOUN crl-13533 104 10 . . PUNCT crl-13533 105 1 the the DET crl-13533 105 2 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 105 3 of of ADP crl-13533 105 4 the the DET crl-13533 105 5 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 105 6 review review NOUN crl-13533 105 7 process process NOUN crl-13533 105 8 the the DET crl-13533 105 9 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 105 10 review review NOUN crl-13533 105 11 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 105 12 is be AUX crl-13533 105 13 analogous analogous ADJ crl-13533 105 14 to to ADP crl-13533 105 15 _ _ PRON crl-13533 105 16 ~nd ~nd PUNCT crl-13533 105 17 modeled model VERB crl-13533 105 18 on on ADP crl-13533 105 19 the the DET crl-13533 105 20 ad ad X crl-13533 105 21 hoc hoc X crl-13533 105 22 committees committee NOUN crl-13533 105 23 appointed appoint VERB crl-13533 105 24 at at ADP crl-13533 105 25 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 105 26 by by ADP crl-13533 105 27 the the DET crl-13533 105 28 provost provost NOUN crl-13533 105 29 to to PART crl-13533 105 30 advise advise VERB crl-13533 105 31 on on ADP crl-13533 105 32 the the DET crl-13533 105 33 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 105 34 tenure tenure NOUN crl-13533 105 35 recommendations recommendation NOUN crl-13533 105 36 to to PART crl-13533 105 37 be be AUX crl-13533 105 38 made make VERB crl-13533 105 39 to to ADP crl-13533 105 40 the the DET crl-13533 105 41 president president NOUN crl-13533 105 42 and and CCONJ crl-13533 105 43 trustees trustee NOUN crl-13533 105 44 . . PUNCT crl-13533 106 1 10 10 NUM crl-13533 106 2 under under ADP crl-13533 106 3 the the DET crl-13533 106 4 university university NOUN crl-13533 106 5 statutes statute NOUN crl-13533 106 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 106 7 only only ADV crl-13533 106 8 the the DET crl-13533 106 9 university university NOUN crl-13533 106 10 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 106 11 has have VERB crl-13533 106 12 the the DET crl-13533 106 13 authority authority NOUN crl-13533 106 14 to to PART crl-13533 106 15 recommend recommend VERB crl-13533 106 16 to to ADP crl-13533 106 17 the the DET crl-13533 106 18 president president NOUN crl-13533 106 19 and and CCONJ crl-13533 106 20 trustees trustee NOUN crl-13533 106 21 , , PUNCT crl-13533 106 22 through through ADP crl-13533 106 23 the the DET crl-13533 106 24 provost provost NOUN crl-13533 106 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 106 26 the the DET crl-13533 106 27 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 106 28 in in ADP crl-13533 106 29 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 106 30 of of ADP crl-13533 106 31 officers officer NOUN crl-13533 106 32 of of ADP crl-13533 106 33 the the DET crl-13533 106 34 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 106 35 . . PUNCT crl-13533 107 1 the the DET crl-13533 107 2 university university NOUN crl-13533 107 3 librarian librarian ADJ crl-13533 107 4 delegates delegate NOUN crl-13533 107 5 to to ADP crl-13533 107 6 the the DET crl-13533 107 7 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 107 8 review review NOUN crl-13533 107 9 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 107 10 the the DET crl-13533 107 11 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 107 12 for for ADP crl-13533 107 13 conducting conduct VERB crl-13533 107 14 a a DET crl-13533 107 15 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 107 16 review review NOUN crl-13533 107 17 and and CCONJ crl-13533 107 18 reporting report VERB crl-13533 107 19 to to ADP crl-13533 107 20 him he PRON crl-13533 107 21 or or CCONJ crl-13533 107 22 her she PRON crl-13533 107 23 the the DET crl-13533 107 24 results result NOUN crl-13533 107 25 of of ADP crl-13533 107 26 that that DET crl-13533 107 27 review review NOUN crl-13533 107 28 with with ADP crl-13533 107 29 a a DET crl-13533 107 30 recommendation recommendation NOUN crl-13533 107 31 for for ADP crl-13533 107 32 action action NOUN crl-13533 107 33 . . PUNCT crl-13533 108 1 the the DET crl-13533 108 2 term term NOUN crl-13533 108 3 " " PUNCT crl-13533 108 4 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 108 5 " " PUNCT crl-13533 108 6 denotes denote NOUN crl-13533 108 7 " " PUNCT crl-13533 108 8 one one NUM crl-13533 108 9 that that PRON crl-13533 108 10 is be AUX crl-13533 108 11 of of ADP crl-13533 108 12 the the DET crl-13533 108 13 same same ADJ crl-13533 108 14 or or CCONJ crl-13533 108 15 equal equal ADJ crl-13533 108 16 standing standing NOUN crl-13533 108 17 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 108 18 as as ADP crl-13533 108 19 in in ADP crl-13533 108 20 law law NOUN crl-13533 108 21 , , PUNCT crl-13533 108 22 rank rank PROPN crl-13533 108 23 , , PUNCT crl-13533 108 24 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 108 25 i i PROPN crl-13533 108 26 299 299 NUM crl-13533 108 27 quality quality NOUN crl-13533 108 28 , , PUNCT crl-13533 108 29 age age NOUN crl-13533 108 30 , , PUNCT crl-13533 108 31 ability ability NOUN crl-13533 108 32 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 108 33 with with ADP crl-13533 108 34 another another PRON crl-13533 108 35 " " PUNCT crl-13533 108 36 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 108 37 webster webster PROPN crl-13533 108 38 's 's PART crl-13533 108 39 third third ADJ crl-13533 108 40 new new ADJ crl-13533 108 41 international international ADJ crl-13533 108 42 dictionary dictionary PROPN crl-13533 108 43 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 108 44 . . PUNCT crl-13533 109 1 " " PUNCT crl-13533 109 2 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 109 3 review review NOUN crl-13533 109 4 " " PUNCT crl-13533 109 5 therefore therefore ADV crl-13533 109 6 implies imply VERB crl-13533 109 7 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 109 8 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-13533 109 9 by by ADP crl-13533 109 10 colleagues colleague NOUN crl-13533 109 11 from from ADP crl-13533 109 12 among among ADP crl-13533 109 13 one one PRON crl-13533 109 14 's 's PART crl-13533 109 15 own own ADJ crl-13533 109 16 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 109 17 . . PUNCT crl-13533 110 1 the the DET crl-13533 110 2 peers peer NOUN crl-13533 110 3 involved involve VERB crl-13533 110 4 in in ADP crl-13533 110 5 reviewing review VERB crl-13533 110 6 each each DET crl-13533 110 7 candidate candidate NOUN crl-13533 110 8 are be AUX crl-13533 110 9 not not PART crl-13533 110 10 just just ADV crl-13533 110 11 members member NOUN crl-13533 110 12 of of ADP crl-13533 110 13 the the DET crl-13533 110 14 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 110 15 review review NOUN crl-13533 110 16 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 110 17 but but CCONJ crl-13533 110 18 all all DET crl-13533 110 19 those those DET crl-13533 110 20 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 110 21 colleagues colleague NOUN crl-13533 110 22 , , PUNCT crl-13533 110 23 both both CCONJ crl-13533 110 24 within within ADP crl-13533 110 25 and and CCONJ crl-13533 110 26 outside outside ADP crl-13533 110 27 the the DET crl-13533 110 28 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 110 29 , , PUNCT crl-13533 110 30 who who PRON crl-13533 110 31 contribute contribute VERB crl-13533 110 32 their their PRON crl-13533 110 33 thoughtful thoughtful ADJ crl-13533 110 34 impressions impression NOUN crl-13533 110 35 to to ADP crl-13533 110 36 the the DET crl-13533 110 37 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 110 38 , , PUNCT crl-13533 110 39 which which PRON crl-13533 110 40 is be AUX crl-13533 110 41 responsible responsible ADJ crl-13533 110 42 for for ADP crl-13533 110 43 assembling assemble VERB crl-13533 110 44 and and CCONJ crl-13533 110 45 synthesizing synthesize VERB crl-13533 110 46 this this DET crl-13533 110 47 information information NOUN crl-13533 110 48 . . PUNCT crl-13533 111 1 since since SCONJ crl-13533 111 2 the the DET crl-13533 111 3 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 111 4 review review NOUN crl-13533 111 5 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 111 6 can can AUX crl-13533 111 7 only only ADV crl-13533 111 8 be be AUX crl-13533 111 9 advisory advisory ADJ crl-13533 111 10 to to ADP crl-13533 111 11 the the DET crl-13533 111 12 universfty universfty ADJ crl-13533 111 13 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 111 14 , , PUNCT crl-13533 111 15 the the DET crl-13533 111 16 " " PUNCT crl-13533 111 17 draft draft NOUN crl-13533 111 18 proposal proposal NOUN crl-13533 111 19 for for ADP crl-13533 111 20 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 111 21 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-13533 111 22 " " PUNCT crl-13533 111 23 developed develop VERB crl-13533 111 24 by by ADP crl-13533 111 25 the the DET crl-13533 111 26 representative representative ADJ crl-13533 111 27 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 111 28 of of ADP crl-13533 111 29 librarians librarians PROPN crl-13533 111 30 in in ADP crl-13533 111 31 1971 1971 NUM crl-13533 111 32 envisioned envision VERB crl-13533 111 33 from from ADP crl-13533 111 34 the the DET crl-13533 111 35 start start NOUN crl-13533 111 36 a a DET crl-13533 111 37 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 111 38 appointed appoint VERB crl-13533 111 39 by by ADP crl-13533 111 40 the the DET crl-13533 111 41 university university NOUN crl-13533 111 42 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 111 43 . . PUNCT crl-13533 112 1 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 112 2 members member NOUN crl-13533 112 3 must must AUX crl-13533 112 4 have have VERB crl-13533 112 5 a a DET crl-13533 112 6 broad broad ADJ crl-13533 112 7 view view NOUN crl-13533 112 8 of of ADP crl-13533 112 9 the the DET crl-13533 112 10 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 112 11 and and CCONJ crl-13533 112 12 the the DET crl-13533 112 13 profession profession NOUN crl-13533 112 14 and and CCONJ crl-13533 112 15 be be AUX crl-13533 112 16 in in ADP crl-13533 112 17 a a DET crl-13533 112 18 position position NOUN crl-13533 112 19 to to PART crl-13533 112 20 devote devote VERB crl-13533 112 21 a a DET crl-13533 112 22 substantial substantial ADJ crl-13533 112 23 amount amount NOUN crl-13533 112 24 of of ADP crl-13533 112 25 time time NOUN crl-13533 112 26 to to ADP crl-13533 112 27 the the DET crl-13533 112 28 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 112 29 's 's PART crl-13533 112 30 work work NOUN crl-13533 112 31 . . PUNCT crl-13533 113 1 when when SCONJ crl-13533 113 2 the the DET crl-13533 113 3 system system NOUN crl-13533 113 4 was be AUX crl-13533 113 5 · · PUNCT crl-13533 113 6 implemented implement VERB crl-13533 113 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 113 8 a a DET crl-13533 113 9 procedure procedure NOUN crl-13533 113 10 was be AUX crl-13533 113 11 establishecl establishecl PROPN crl-13533 113 12 by by ADP crl-13533 113 13 which which PRON crl-13533 113 14 the the DET crl-13533 113 15 representative representative ADJ crl-13533 113 16 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 113 17 of of ADP crl-13533 113 18 librarians librarians PROPN crl-13533 113 19 provides provide VERB crl-13533 113 20 the the DET crl-13533 113 21 university university NOUN crl-13533 113 22 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 113 23 with with ADP crl-13533 113 24 a a DET crl-13533 113 25 slate slate NOUN crl-13533 113 26 of of ADP crl-13533 113 27 nominees nominee NOUN crl-13533 113 28 for for ADP crl-13533 113 29 membership membership NOUN crl-13533 113 30 on on ADP crl-13533 113 31 the the DET crl-13533 113 32 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 113 33 review review NOUN crl-13533 113 34 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 113 35 when when SCONJ crl-13533 113 36 vacancies vacancy NOUN crl-13533 113 37 occur occur VERB crl-13533 113 38 . . PUNCT crl-13533 114 1 the the DET crl-13533 114 2 university university NOUN crl-13533 114 3 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 114 4 retains retain VERB crl-13533 114 5 the the DET crl-13533 114 6 authority authority NOUN crl-13533 114 7 to to PART crl-13533 114 8 supplement supplement VERB crl-13533 114 9 this this DET crl-13533 114 10 list list NOUN crl-13533 114 11 to to PART crl-13533 114 12 ensure ensure VERB crl-13533 114 13 a a DET crl-13533 114 14 balanced balanced ADJ crl-13533 114 15 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 114 16 familiar familiar ADJ crl-13533 114 17 with with ADP crl-13533 114 18 the the DET crl-13533 114 19 widest wide ADJ crl-13533 114 20 possible possible ADJ crl-13533 114 21 range range NOUN crl-13533 114 22 of of ADP crl-13533 114 23 library library NOUN crl-13533 114 24 and and CCONJ crl-13533 114 25 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 114 26 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 114 27 . . PUNCT crl-13533 115 1 confidential confidential ADJ crl-13533 115 2 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 115 3 of of ADP crl-13533 115 4 the the DET crl-13533 115 5 process process NOUN crl-13533 115 6 the the DET crl-13533 115 7 original original ADJ crl-13533 115 8 recommendation recommendation NOUN crl-13533 115 9 of of ADP crl-13533 115 10 the the DET crl-13533 115 11 representative representative ADJ crl-13533 115 12 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 115 13 of of ADP crl-13533 115 14 librarians librarians PROPN crl-13533 115 15 provided provide VERB crl-13533 115 16 : : PUNCT crl-13533 115 17 " " PUNCT crl-13533 115 18 all all DET crl-13533 115 19 relevant relevant ADJ crl-13533 115 20 documents document NOUN crl-13533 115 21 ... ... PUNCT crl-13533 115 22 will will AUX crl-13533 115 23 be be AUX crl-13533 115 24 kept keep VERB crl-13533 115 25 in in ADP crl-13533 115 26 strictest strictest ADJ crl-13533 115 27 confidence confidence NOUN crl-13533 115 28 . . PUNCT crl-13533 116 1 likewise likewise ADV crl-13533 116 2 , , PUNCT crl-13533 116 3 all all DET crl-13533 116 4 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 116 5 discussions discussion NOUN crl-13533 116 6 and and CCONJ crl-13533 116 7 results result NOUN crl-13533 116 8 will will AUX crl-13533 116 9 be be AUX crl-13533 116 10 confidential confidential ADJ crl-13533 116 11 . . PUNCT crl-13533 116 12 " " PUNCT crl-13533 117 1 the the DET crl-13533 117 2 models model NOUN crl-13533 117 3 from from ADP crl-13533 117 4 which which PRON crl-13533 117 5 this this DET crl-13533 117 6 ' ' PUNCT crl-13533 117 7 recommendation recommendation NOUN crl-13533 117 8 derives derive NOUN crl-13533 117 9 are be AUX crl-13533 117 10 those those PRON crl-13533 117 11 of of ADP crl-13533 117 12 the the DET crl-13533 117 13 tenure tenure NOUN crl-13533 117 14 review review NOUN crl-13533 117 15 procedure procedure NOUN crl-13533 117 16 for for ADP crl-13533 117 17 the the DET crl-13533 117 18 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 117 19 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 117 20 and and CCONJ crl-13533 117 21 of of ADP crl-13533 117 22 similar similar ADJ crl-13533 117 23 systems system NOUN crl-13533 117 24 at at ADP crl-13533 117 25 a a DET crl-13533 117 26 number number NOUN crl-13533 117 27 of of ADP crl-13533 117 28 other other ADJ crl-13533 117 29 large large ADJ crl-13533 117 30 research research NOUN crl-13533 117 31 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 117 32 . . PUNCT crl-13533 118 1 confidentiality confidentiality NOUN crl-13533 118 2 is be AUX crl-13533 118 3 an an DET crl-13533 118 4 integral integral ADJ crl-13533 118 5 aspect aspect NOUN crl-13533 118 6 of of ADP crl-13533 118 7 the the DET crl-13533 118 8 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 118 9 review review NOUN crl-13533 118 10 process process NOUN crl-13533 118 11 at at ADP crl-13533 118 12 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 118 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 118 14 as as SCONJ crl-13533 118 15 it it PRON crl-13533 118 16 is be AUX crl-13533 118 17 in in ADP crl-13533 118 18 most most ADJ crl-13533 118 19 colleges college NOUN crl-13533 118 20 and and CCONJ crl-13533 118 21 universities university NOUN crl-13533 118 22 , , PUNCT crl-13533 118 23 and and CCONJ crl-13533 118 24 is be AUX crl-13533 118 25 intended intend VERB crl-13533 118 26 to to PART crl-13533 118 27 protect protect VERB crl-13533 118 28 the the DET crl-13533 118 29 privacy privacy NOUN crl-13533 118 30 of of ADP crl-13533 118 31 candidates candidate NOUN crl-13533 118 32 , , PUNCT crl-13533 118 33 while while SCONJ crl-13533 118 34 encouraging encourage VERB crl-13533 118 35 a a DET crl-13533 118 36 rigorous rigorous ADJ crl-13533 118 37 and and CCONJ crl-13533 118 38 impartial impartial ADJ crl-13533 118 39 review review NOUN crl-13533 118 40 in in ADP crl-13533 118 41 recognizing recognize VERB crl-13533 118 42 and and CCONJ crl-13533 118 43 rewarding rewarding ADJ crl-13533 118 44 dis dis NOUN crl-13533 118 45 : : PUNCT crl-13533 118 46 . . PUNCT crl-13533 118 47 tinction tinction NOUN crl-13533 118 48 . . PUNCT crl-13533 119 1 at at ADP crl-13533 119 2 the the DET crl-13533 119 3 time time NOUN crl-13533 119 4 the the DET crl-13533 119 5 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 119 6 - - PUNCT crl-13533 119 7 review review NOUN crl-13533 119 8 process process NOUN crl-13533 119 9 was be AUX crl-13533 119 10 being be AUX crl-13533 119 11 developed develop VERB crl-13533 119 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 119 13 the the DET crl-13533 119 14 consensus consensus NOUN crl-13533 119 15 of of ADP crl-13533 119 16 the the DET crl-13533 119 17 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 119 18 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 119 19 was be AUX crl-13533 119 20 that that SCONJ crl-13533 119 21 it it PRON crl-13533 119 22 was be AUX crl-13533 119 23 essen.----------------------------------------------------------------300 essen.----------------------------------------------------------------300 PROPN crl-13533 119 24 i i PROPN crl-13533 119 25 college college PROPN crl-13533 119 26 & & CCONJ crl-13533 119 27 research research PROPN crl-13533 119 28 libraries librarie VERB crl-13533 119 29 • • ADJ crl-13533 119 30 july july PROPN crl-13533 119 31 1980 1980 NUM crl-13533 119 32 tial tial NOUN crl-13533 119 33 for for ADP crl-13533 119 34 the the DET crl-13533 119 35 documentation documentation NOUN crl-13533 119 36 assembled assemble VERB crl-13533 119 37 by by ADP crl-13533 119 38 the the DET crl-13533 119 39 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 119 40 to to PART crl-13533 119 41 be be AUX crl-13533 119 42 held hold VERB crl-13533 119 43 in in ADP crl-13533 119 44 confidence confidence NOUN crl-13533 119 45 . . PUNCT crl-13533 120 1 to to PART crl-13533 120 2 protect protect VERB crl-13533 120 3 the the DET crl-13533 120 4 candidate candidate NOUN crl-13533 120 5 , , PUNCT crl-13533 120 6 the the DET crl-13533 120 7 procedures procedure NOUN crl-13533 120 8 of of ADP crl-13533 120 9 the the DET crl-13533 120 10 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 120 11 review review NOUN crl-13533 120 12 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 120 13 re- re- PROPN crl-13533 120 14 . . PROPN crl-13533 120 15 quire quire NOUN crl-13533 120 16 that that SCONJ crl-13533 120 17 there there PRON crl-13533 120 18 be be VERB crl-13533 120 19 evidence evidence NOUN crl-13533 120 20 of of ADP crl-13533 120 21 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 120 22 contact contact NOUN crl-13533 120 23 between between ADP crl-13533 120 24 the the DET crl-13533 120 25 candidate candidate NOUN crl-13533 120 26 and and CCONJ crl-13533 120 27 anyone anyone PRON crl-13533 120 28 asked ask VERB crl-13533 120 29 to to PART crl-13533 120 30 write write VERB crl-13533 120 31 a a DET crl-13533 120 32 confidential confidential ADJ crl-13533 120 33 letter letter NOUN crl-13533 120 34 , , PUNCT crl-13533 120 35 and and CCONJ crl-13533 120 36 that that SCONJ crl-13533 120 37 the the DET crl-13533 120 38 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 120 39 , , PUNCT crl-13533 120 40 if if SCONJ crl-13533 120 41 it it PRON crl-13533 120 42 asks ask VERB crl-13533 120 43 any any PRON crl-13533 120 44 , , PUNCT crl-13533 120 45 must must AUX crl-13533 120 46 ask ask VERB crl-13533 120 47 more more ADJ crl-13533 120 48 than than ADP crl-13533 120 49 one one NUM crl-13533 120 50 co co NOUN crl-13533 120 51 - - NOUN crl-13533 120 52 worker worker NOUN crl-13533 120 53 or or CCONJ crl-13533 120 54 subordinate subordinate ADJ crl-13533 120 55 for for ADP crl-13533 120 56 letters letter NOUN crl-13533 120 57 . . PUNCT crl-13533 121 1 each each DET crl-13533 121 2 candidate candidate NOUN crl-13533 121 3 is be AUX crl-13533 121 4 invited invite VERB crl-13533 121 5 to to PART crl-13533 121 6 submit submit VERB crl-13533 121 7 names name NOUN crl-13533 121 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 121 9 and and CCONJ crl-13533 121 10 the the DET crl-13533 121 11 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 121 12 selects select VERB crl-13533 121 13 additional additional ADJ crl-13533 121 14 names name NOUN crl-13533 121 15 , , PUNCT crl-13533 121 16 with with ADP crl-13533 121 17 the the DET crl-13533 121 18 total total ADJ crl-13533 121 19 number number NOUN crl-13533 121 20 of of ADP crl-13533 121 21 letters letter NOUN crl-13533 121 22 solicited solicit VERB crl-13533 121 23 being be AUX crl-13533 121 24 related relate VERB crl-13533 121 25 to to ADP crl-13533 121 26 the the DET crl-13533 121 27 range range NOUN crl-13533 121 28 of of ADP crl-13533 121 29 the the DET crl-13533 121 30 candidate candidate NOUN crl-13533 121 31 's 's PART crl-13533 121 32 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 121 33 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 121 34 both both CCONJ crl-13533 121 35 within within ADP crl-13533 121 36 and and CCONJ crl-13533 121 37 outside outside ADP crl-13533 121 38 the the DET crl-13533 121 39 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 121 40 , , PUNCT crl-13533 121 41 and and CCONJ crl-13533 121 42 normally normally ADV crl-13533 121 43 increasing increase VERB crl-13533 121 44 for for ADP crl-13533 121 45 those those PRON crl-13533 121 46 being be AUX crl-13533 121 47 considered consider VERB crl-13533 121 48 for for ADP crl-13533 121 49 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 121 50 to to ADP crl-13533 121 51 the the DET crl-13533 121 52 higher high ADJ crl-13533 121 53 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 121 54 . . PUNCT crl-13533 122 1 these these DET crl-13533 122 2 procedures procedure NOUN crl-13533 122 3 were be AUX crl-13533 122 4 designed design VERB crl-13533 122 5 to to PART crl-13533 122 6 ensure ensure VERB crl-13533 122 7 that that SCONJ crl-13533 122 8 the the DET crl-13533 122 9 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 122 10 would would AUX crl-13533 122 11 not not PART crl-13533 122 12 receive receive VERB crl-13533 122 13 a a DET crl-13533 122 14 one one NUM crl-13533 122 15 - - PUNCT crl-13533 122 16 sided sided ADJ crl-13533 122 17 picture picture NOUN crl-13533 122 18 of of ADP crl-13533 122 19 the the DET crl-13533 122 20 job job NOUN crl-13533 122 21 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 122 22 and and CCONJ crl-13533 122 23 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 122 24 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 122 25 of of ADP crl-13533 122 26 a a DET crl-13533 122 27 candidate candidate NOUN crl-13533 122 28 , , PUNCT crl-13533 122 29 and and CCONJ crl-13533 122 30 that that SCONJ crl-13533 122 31 no no DET crl-13533 122 32 single single ADJ crl-13533 122 33 letter letter NOUN crl-13533 122 34 can can AUX crl-13533 122 35 determine determine VERB crl-13533 122 36 the the DET crl-13533 122 37 outcome outcome NOUN crl-13533 122 38 of of ADP crl-13533 122 39 an an DET crl-13533 122 40 individual individual NOUN crl-13533 122 41 's 's PART crl-13533 122 42 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 122 43 review review NOUN crl-13533 122 44 . . PUNCT crl-13533 123 1 the the DET crl-13533 123 2 documents document NOUN crl-13533 123 3 assembled assemble VERB crl-13533 123 4 for for ADP crl-13533 123 5 the the DET crl-13533 123 6 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 123 7 review review NOUN crl-13533 123 8 are be AUX crl-13533 123 9 accessible accessible ADJ crl-13533 123 10 only only ADV crl-13533 123 11 to to ADP crl-13533 123 12 the the DET crl-13533 123 13 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 123 14 review review NOUN crl-13533 123 15 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 123 16 , , PUNCT crl-13533 123 17 the the DET crl-13533 123 18 university university NOUN crl-13533 123 19 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 123 20 , , PUNCT crl-13533 123 21 and and CCONJ crl-13533 123 22 the the DET crl-13533 123 23 assistant assistant ADJ crl-13533 123 24 university university NOUN crl-13533 123 25 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 123 26 for for ADP crl-13533 123 27 personnel personnel NOUN crl-13533 123 28 . . PUNCT crl-13533 124 1 when when SCONJ crl-13533 124 2 the the DET crl-13533 124 3 review review NOUN crl-13533 124 4 is be AUX crl-13533 124 5 completed complete VERB crl-13533 124 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 124 7 the the DET crl-13533 124 8 documents document NOUN crl-13533 124 9 are be AUX crl-13533 124 10 placed place VERB crl-13533 124 11 in in ADP crl-13533 124 12 a a DET crl-13533 124 13 special special ADJ crl-13533 124 14 locked locked ADJ crl-13533 124 15 file file NOUN crl-13533 124 16 for for ADP crl-13533 124 17 a a DET crl-13533 124 18 three three NUM crl-13533 124 19 - - PUNCT crl-13533 124 20 year year NOUN crl-13533 124 21 period period NOUN crl-13533 124 22 and and CCONJ crl-13533 124 23 then then ADV crl-13533 124 24 are be AUX crl-13533 124 25 destroyed destroy VERB crl-13533 124 26 . . PUNCT crl-13533 125 1 the the DET crl-13533 125 2 only only ADJ crl-13533 125 3 records record NOUN crl-13533 125 4 from from ADP crl-13533 125 5 the the DET crl-13533 125 6 whole whole ADJ crl-13533 125 7 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 125 8 review review NOUN crl-13533 125 9 process process NOUN crl-13533 125 10 that that PRON crl-13533 125 11 are be AUX crl-13533 125 12 placed place VERB crl-13533 125 13 in in ADP crl-13533 125 14 an an DET crl-13533 125 15 individual individual NOUN crl-13533 125 16 's 's PART crl-13533 125 17 permanent permanent ADJ crl-13533 125 18 personnel personnel NOUN crl-13533 125 19 file file NOUN crl-13533 125 20 , , PUNCT crl-13533 125 21 and and CCONJ crl-13533 125 22 are be AUX crl-13533 125 23 therefore therefore ADV crl-13533 125 24 accessible accessible ADJ crl-13533 125 25 to to ADP crl-13533 125 26 an an DET crl-13533 125 27 individual individual NOUN crl-13533 125 28 's 's PART crl-13533 125 29 immediate immediate ADJ crl-13533 125 30 supervisor supervisor NOUN crl-13533 125 31 , , PUNCT crl-13533 125 32 are be AUX crl-13533 125 33 the the DET crl-13533 125 34 letter letter NOUN crl-13533 125 35 from from ADP crl-13533 125 36 the the DET crl-13533 125 37 university university NOUN crl-13533 125 38 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 125 39 communicating communicate VERB crl-13533 125 40 the the DET crl-13533 125 41 decision decision NOUN crl-13533 125 42 and and CCONJ crl-13533 125 43 the the DET crl-13533 125 44 summary summary NOUN crl-13533 125 45 statement statement NOUN crl-13533 125 46 explaining explain VERB crl-13533 125 47 the the DET crl-13533 125 48 reasons reason NOUN crl-13533 125 49 . . PUNCT crl-13533 126 1 although although SCONJ crl-13533 126 2 this this DET crl-13533 126 3 process process NOUN crl-13533 126 4 was be AUX crl-13533 126 5 modeled model VERB crl-13533 126 6 on on ADP crl-13533 126 7 the the DET crl-13533 126 8 procedures procedure NOUN crl-13533 126 9 for for ADP crl-13533 126 10 tenure tenure NOUN crl-13533 126 11 review review NOUN crl-13533 126 12 for for ADP crl-13533 126 13 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 126 14 at at ADP crl-13533 126 15 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 126 16 , , PUNCT crl-13533 126 17 there there PRON crl-13533 126 18 are be VERB crl-13533 126 19 differences difference NOUN crl-13533 126 20 . . PUNCT crl-13533 127 1 for for ADP crl-13533 127 2 example example NOUN crl-13533 127 3 , , PUNCT crl-13533 127 4 under under ADP crl-13533 127 5 the the DET crl-13533 127 6 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 127 7 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 127 8 tenure tenure NOUN crl-13533 127 9 review review NOUN crl-13533 127 10 system system NOUN crl-13533 127 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 127 12 the the DET crl-13533 127 13 candidate candidate NOUN crl-13533 127 14 does do AUX crl-13533 127 15 not not PART crl-13533 127 16 know know VERB crl-13533 127 17 who who PRON crl-13533 127 18 is be AUX crl-13533 127 19 appointed appoint VERB crl-13533 127 20 by by ADP crl-13533 127 21 the the DET crl-13533 127 22 provost provost NOUN crl-13533 127 23 to to PART crl-13533 127 24 serve serve VERB crl-13533 127 25 on on ADP crl-13533 127 26 his his PRON crl-13533 127 27 or or CCONJ crl-13533 127 28 her her PRON crl-13533 127 29 ad ad X crl-13533 127 30 hoc hoc X crl-13533 127 31 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 127 32 , , PUNCT crl-13533 127 33 what what PRON crl-13533 127 34 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-13533 127 35 the the DET crl-13533 127 36 dean dean NOUN crl-13533 127 37 or or CCONJ crl-13533 127 38 department department NOUN crl-13533 127 39 director director NOUN crl-13533 127 40 may may AUX crl-13533 127 41 have have AUX crl-13533 127 42 submitted submit VERB crl-13533 127 43 , , PUNCT crl-13533 127 44 or or CCONJ crl-13533 127 45 who who PRON crl-13533 127 46 is be AUX crl-13533 127 47 asked ask VERB crl-13533 127 48 to to PART crl-13533 127 49 be be AUX crl-13533 127 50 a a DET crl-13533 127 51 witness witness NOUN crl-13533 127 52 or or CCONJ crl-13533 127 53 to to PART crl-13533 127 54 write write VERB crl-13533 127 55 a a DET crl-13533 127 56 letter letter NOUN crl-13533 127 57 . . PUNCT crl-13533 128 1 the the DET crl-13533 128 2 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 128 3 review review NOUN crl-13533 128 4 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 128 5 in in ADP crl-13533 128 6 the the DET crl-13533 128 7 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 128 8 is be AUX crl-13533 128 9 a a DET crl-13533 128 10 standing stand VERB crl-13533 128 11 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 128 12 whose whose DET crl-13533 128 13 members member NOUN crl-13533 128 14 are be AUX crl-13533 128 15 known know VERB crl-13533 128 16 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 128 17 the the DET crl-13533 128 18 supervisory supervisory ADJ crl-13533 128 19 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 128 20 appraisal appraisal NOUN crl-13533 128 21 is be AUX crl-13533 128 22 given give VERB crl-13533 128 23 to to ADP crl-13533 128 24 the the DET crl-13533 128 25 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 128 26 who who PRON crl-13533 128 27 is be AUX crl-13533 128 28 encouraged encourage VERB crl-13533 128 29 to to PART crl-13533 128 30 respond respond VERB crl-13533 128 31 in in ADP crl-13533 128 32 writing writing NOUN crl-13533 128 33 . . PUNCT crl-13533 129 1 in in ADP crl-13533 129 2 addition addition NOUN crl-13533 129 3 , , PUNCT crl-13533 129 4 it it PRON crl-13533 129 5 has have AUX crl-13533 129 6 been be AUX crl-13533 129 7 understood understand VERB crl-13533 129 8 that that SCONJ crl-13533 129 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 129 10 while while SCONJ crl-13533 129 11 the the DET crl-13533 129 12 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 129 13 review review NOUN crl-13533 129 14 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 129 15 carefully carefully ADV crl-13533 129 16 protects protect VERB crl-13533 129 17 the the DET crl-13533 129 18 confidentiality confidentiality NOUN crl-13533 129 19 of of ADP crl-13533 129 20 all all DET crl-13533 129 21 letters letter NOUN crl-13533 129 22 submitted submit VERB crl-13533 129 23 as as ADP crl-13533 129 24 part part NOUN crl-13533 129 25 of of ADP crl-13533 129 26 the the DET crl-13533 129 27 review review NOUN crl-13533 129 28 process process NOUN crl-13533 129 29 , , PUNCT crl-13533 129 30 the the DET crl-13533 129 31 writers writer NOUN crl-13533 129 32 of of ADP crl-13533 129 33 the the DET crl-13533 129 34 letters letter NOUN crl-13533 129 35 are be AUX crl-13533 129 36 free free ADJ crl-13533 129 37 to to PART crl-13533 129 38 share share VERB crl-13533 129 39 them they PRON crl-13533 129 40 with with ADP crl-13533 129 41 the the DET crl-13533 129 42 candidate candidate NOUN crl-13533 129 43 should should AUX crl-13533 129 44 they they PRON crl-13533 129 45 wish wish VERB crl-13533 129 46 to to PART crl-13533 129 47 do do VERB crl-13533 129 48 so so ADV crl-13533 129 49 . . PUNCT crl-13533 130 1 implementation implementation NOUN crl-13533 130 2 of of ADP crl-13533 130 3 the the DET crl-13533 130 4 system system NOUN crl-13533 130 5 of of ADP crl-13533 130 6 ranks rank VERB crl-13533 130 7 the the DET crl-13533 130 8 staff staff PROPN crl-13533 130 9 development development PROPN crl-13533 130 10 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 130 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 130 12 which which PRON crl-13533 130 13 was be AUX crl-13533 130 14 established establish VERB crl-13533 130 15 as as ADP crl-13533 130 16 part part NOUN crl-13533 130 17 of of ADP crl-13533 130 18 the the DET crl-13533 130 19 general general ADJ crl-13533 130 20 reorganization reorganization NOUN crl-13533 130 21 of of ADP crl-13533 130 22 the the DET crl-13533 130 23 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 130 24 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 130 25 in in ADP crl-13533 130 26 july july PROPN crl-13533 130 27 1972 1972 NUM crl-13533 130 28 , , PUNCT crl-13533 130 29 was be AUX crl-13533 130 30 given give VERB crl-13533 130 31 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 130 32 for for ADP crl-13533 130 33 developing develop VERB crl-13533 130 34 proposals proposal NOUN crl-13533 130 35 for for ADP crl-13533 130 36 the the DET crl-13533 130 37 implementation implementation NOUN crl-13533 130 38 of of ADP crl-13533 130 39 the the DET crl-13533 130 40 system system NOUN crl-13533 130 41 of of ADP crl-13533 130 42 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 130 43 . . PUNCT crl-13533 131 1 the the DET crl-13533 131 2 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 131 3 conducted conduct VERB crl-13533 131 4 a a DET crl-13533 131 5 series series NOUN crl-13533 131 6 of of ADP crl-13533 131 7 meetings meeting NOUN crl-13533 131 8 with with ADP crl-13533 131 9 the the DET crl-13533 131 10 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 131 11 to to PART crl-13533 131 12 discuss discuss VERB crl-13533 131 13 materials material NOUN crl-13533 131 14 under under ADP crl-13533 131 15 development development NOUN crl-13533 131 16 which which PRON crl-13533 131 17 outlined outline VERB crl-13533 131 18 the the DET crl-13533 131 19 philosophy philosophy NOUN crl-13533 131 20 and and CCONJ crl-13533 131 21 procedures procedure NOUN crl-13533 131 22 for for ADP crl-13533 131 23 the the DET crl-13533 131 24 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 131 25 review review NOUN crl-13533 131 26 process process NOUN crl-13533 131 27 . . PUNCT crl-13533 132 1 several several ADJ crl-13533 132 2 modifications modification NOUN crl-13533 132 3 were be AUX crl-13533 132 4 made make VERB crl-13533 132 5 as as ADP crl-13533 132 6 a a DET crl-13533 132 7 result result NOUN crl-13533 132 8 of of ADP crl-13533 132 9 these these DET crl-13533 132 10 meetings meeting NOUN crl-13533 132 11 prior prior ADV crl-13533 132 12 to to ADP crl-13533 132 13 the the DET crl-13533 132 14 implementation implementation NOUN crl-13533 132 15 of of ADP crl-13533 132 16 the the DET crl-13533 132 17 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 132 18 review review NOUN crl-13533 132 19 process process NOUN crl-13533 132 20 , , PUNCT crl-13533 132 21 and and CCONJ crl-13533 132 22 changes change NOUN crl-13533 132 23 have have AUX crl-13533 132 24 continued continue VERB crl-13533 132 25 to to PART crl-13533 132 26 be be AUX crl-13533 132 27 made make VERB crl-13533 132 28 since since SCONJ crl-13533 132 29 the the DET crl-13533 132 30 system system NOUN crl-13533 132 31 of of ADP crl-13533 132 32 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 132 33 was be AUX crl-13533 132 34 fully fully ADV crl-13533 132 35 implemented implement VERB crl-13533 132 36 in in ADP crl-13533 132 37 1975 1975 NUM crl-13533 132 38 - - SYM crl-13533 132 39 76 76 NUM crl-13533 132 40 . . PUNCT crl-13533 133 1 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 133 2 the the DET crl-13533 133 3 staff staff PROPN crl-13533 133 4 development development PROPN crl-13533 133 5 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 133 6 was be AUX crl-13533 133 7 reconstituted reconstitute VERB crl-13533 133 8 as as ADP crl-13533 133 9 the the DET crl-13533 133 10 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 133 11 review review NOUN crl-13533 133 12 com com NOUN crl-13533 133 13 : : PUNCT crl-13533 133 14 mittee mittee NOUN crl-13533 133 15 in in ADP crl-13533 133 16 july july PROPN crl-13533 133 17 1975 1975 NUM crl-13533 133 18 and and CCONJ crl-13533 133 19 charged charge VERB crl-13533 133 20 with with ADP crl-13533 133 21 carrying carry VERB crl-13533 133 22 forward forward ADV crl-13533 133 23 the the DET crl-13533 133 24 system system NOUN crl-13533 133 25 of of ADP crl-13533 133 26 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 133 27 and and CCONJ crl-13533 133 28 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 133 29 review review NOUN crl-13533 133 30 . . PUNCT crl-13533 133 31 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 134 1 the the DET crl-13533 134 2 changes change NOUN crl-13533 134 3 made make VERB crl-13533 134 4 in in ADP crl-13533 134 5 the the DET crl-13533 134 6 system system NOUN crl-13533 134 7 of of ADP crl-13533 134 8 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 134 9 and and CCONJ crl-13533 134 10 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 134 11 review review NOUN crl-13533 134 12 included include VERB crl-13533 134 13 establishing establish VERB crl-13533 134 14 four four NUM crl-13533 134 15 rather rather ADV crl-13533 134 16 than than ADP crl-13533 134 17 five five NUM crl-13533 134 18 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 134 19 , , PUNCT crl-13533 134 20 a a DET crl-13533 134 21 modification modification NOUN crl-13533 134 22 which which PRON crl-13533 134 23 seemed seem VERB crl-13533 134 24 necessary necessary ADJ crl-13533 134 25 in in ADP crl-13533 134 26 order order NOUN crl-13533 134 27 to to PART crl-13533 134 28 emphasize emphasize VERB crl-13533 134 29 that that SCONJ crl-13533 134 30 the the DET crl-13533 134 31 highest high ADJ crl-13533 134 32 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 134 33 is be AUX crl-13533 134 34 " " PUNCT crl-13533 134 35 reserved reserve VERB crl-13533 134 36 for for ADP crl-13533 134 37 individuals individual NOUN crl-13533 134 38 who who PRON crl-13533 134 39 have have AUX crl-13533 134 40 made make VERB crl-13533 134 41 distinctive distinctive ADJ crl-13533 134 42 contributions contribution NOUN crl-13533 134 43 over over ADP crl-13533 134 44 a a DET crl-13533 134 45 significant significant ADJ crl-13533 134 46 period period NOUN crl-13533 134 47 of of ADP crl-13533 134 48 time time NOUN crl-13533 134 49 to to ADP crl-13533 134 50 the the DET crl-13533 134 51 university university NOUN crl-13533 134 52 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 134 53 and and CCONJ crl-13533 134 54 to to ADP crl-13533 134 55 the the DET crl-13533 134 56 profession profession NOUN crl-13533 134 57 . . PUNCT crl-13533 134 58 " " PUNCT crl-13533 135 1 11 11 NUM crl-13533 135 2 the the DET crl-13533 135 3 development development NOUN crl-13533 135 4 of of ADP crl-13533 135 5 summary summary NOUN crl-13533 135 6 statements statement NOUN crl-13533 135 7 to to PART crl-13533 135 8 provide provide VERB crl-13533 135 9 candidates candidate NOUN crl-13533 135 10 with with ADP crl-13533 135 11 the the DET crl-13533 135 12 reasons reason NOUN crl-13533 135 13 for for ADP crl-13533 135 14 promotional promotional ADJ crl-13533 135 15 decisions decision NOUN crl-13533 135 16 · · PUNCT crl-13533 135 17 and and CCONJ crl-13533 135 18 the the DET crl-13533 135 19 inclusion inclusion NOUN crl-13533 135 20 of of ADP crl-13533 135 21 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 135 22 supervisees supervisee NOUN crl-13533 135 23 among among ADP crl-13533 135 24 those those PRON crl-13533 135 25 who who PRON crl-13533 135 26 may may AUX crl-13533 135 27 be be AUX crl-13533 135 28 contacted contact VERB crl-13533 135 29 for for ADP crl-13533 135 30 additional additional ADJ crl-13533 135 31 documentation documentation NOUN crl-13533 135 32 were be AUX crl-13533 135 33 also also ADV crl-13533 135 34 instituted institute VERB crl-13533 135 35 as as ADP crl-13533 135 36 a a DET crl-13533 135 37 result result NOUN crl-13533 135 38 of of ADP crl-13533 135 39 suggestions suggestion NOUN crl-13533 135 40 from from ADP crl-13533 135 41 various various ADJ crl-13533 135 42 members member NOUN crl-13533 135 43 of of ADP crl-13533 135 44 the the DET crl-13533 135 45 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 135 46 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 135 47 . . PUNCT crl-13533 136 1 perhaps perhaps ADV crl-13533 136 2 the the DET crl-13533 136 3 most most ADV crl-13533 136 4 significant significant ADJ crl-13533 136 5 modification modification NOUN crl-13533 136 6 was be AUX crl-13533 136 7 the the DET crl-13533 136 8 decision decision NOUN crl-13533 136 9 not not PART crl-13533 136 10 to to PART crl-13533 136 11 exclude exclude VERB crl-13533 136 12 any any DET crl-13533 136 13 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 136 14 from from ADP crl-13533 136 15 consideration consideration NOUN crl-13533 136 16 for for ADP crl-13533 136 17 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 136 18 to to ADP crl-13533 136 19 the the DET crl-13533 136 20 highest high ADJ crl-13533 136 21 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 136 22 . . PUNCT crl-13533 137 1 there there PRON crl-13533 137 2 are be VERB crl-13533 137 3 a a DET crl-13533 137 4 number number NOUN crl-13533 137 5 of of ADP crl-13533 137 6 ranking rank VERB crl-13533 137 7 systems system NOUN crl-13533 137 8 that that PRON crl-13533 137 9 do do AUX crl-13533 137 10 have have VERB crl-13533 137 11 such such ADJ crl-13533 137 12 limitations limitation NOUN crl-13533 137 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 137 14 that that ADV crl-13533 137 15 is is ADV crl-13533 137 16 , , PUNCT crl-13533 137 17 individuals individual NOUN crl-13533 137 18 in in ADP crl-13533 137 19 certain certain ADJ crl-13533 137 20 positions position NOUN crl-13533 137 21 , , PUNCT crl-13533 137 22 such such ADJ crl-13533 137 23 as as ADP crl-13533 137 24 general general ADJ crl-13533 137 25 cataloging cataloging NOUN crl-13533 137 26 and and CCONJ crl-13533 137 27 reference reference NOUN crl-13533 137 28 , , PUNCT crl-13533 137 29 are be AUX crl-13533 137 30 normally normally ADV crl-13533 137 31 excluded exclude VERB crl-13533 137 32 from from ADP crl-13533 137 33 the the DET crl-13533 137 34 highest high ADJ crl-13533 137 35 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 137 36 . . PUNCT crl-13533 138 1 the the DET crl-13533 138 2 staff staff PROPN crl-13533 138 3 development development PROPN crl-13533 138 4 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 138 5 felt feel VERB crl-13533 138 6 that that SCONJ crl-13533 138 7 such such DET crl-13533 138 8 a a DET crl-13533 138 9 concept concept NOUN crl-13533 138 10 was be AUX crl-13533 138 11 inappropriate inappropriate ADJ crl-13533 138 12 at at ADP crl-13533 138 13 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 138 14 because because SCONJ crl-13533 138 15 it it PRON crl-13533 138 16 would would AUX crl-13533 138 17 impose impose VERB crl-13533 138 18 limitations limitation NOUN crl-13533 138 19 on on ADP crl-13533 138 20 a a DET crl-13533 138 21 large large ADJ crl-13533 138 22 number number NOUN crl-13533 138 23 of of ADP crl-13533 138 24 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 138 25 performing perform VERB crl-13533 138 26 key key ADJ crl-13533 138 27 bibliographic bibliographic ADJ crl-13533 138 28 and and CCONJ crl-13533 138 29 service service NOUN crl-13533 138 30 functions function NOUN crl-13533 138 31 . . PUNCT crl-13533 139 1 this this DET crl-13533 139 2 recommendation recommendation NOUN crl-13533 139 3 was be AUX crl-13533 139 4 accepted accept VERB crl-13533 139 5 by by ADP crl-13533 139 6 the the DET crl-13533 139 7 university university NOUN crl-13533 139 8 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 139 9 prior prior ADV crl-13533 139 10 to to ADP crl-13533 139 11 the the DET crl-13533 139 12 implementation implementation NOUN crl-13533 139 13 of of ADP crl-13533 139 14 the the DET crl-13533 139 15 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 139 16 review review NOUN crl-13533 139 17 process process NOUN crl-13533 139 18 . . PUNCT crl-13533 140 1 following follow VERB crl-13533 140 2 discussions discussion NOUN crl-13533 140 3 between between ADP crl-13533 140 4 the the DET crl-13533 140 5 staff staff PROPN crl-13533 140 6 development development PROPN crl-13533 140 7 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 140 8 · · PUNCT crl-13533 140 9 and and CCONJ crl-13533 140 10 the the DET crl-13533 140 11 university university NOUN crl-13533 140 12 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 140 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 140 14 it it PRON crl-13533 140 15 was be AUX crl-13533 140 16 agreed agree VERB crl-13533 140 17 that that SCONJ crl-13533 140 18 the the DET crl-13533 140 19 initial initial ADJ crl-13533 140 20 assignment assignment NOUN crl-13533 140 21 of of ADP crl-13533 140 22 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 140 23 would would AUX crl-13533 140 24 be be AUX crl-13533 140 25 handled handle VERB crl-13533 140 26 administratively administratively ADV crl-13533 140 27 by by ADP crl-13533 140 28 the the DET crl-13533 140 29 assistant assistant ADJ crl-13533 140 30 university university NOUN crl-13533 140 31 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 140 32 for for ADP crl-13533 140 33 personnel personnel NOUN crl-13533 140 34 . . PUNCT crl-13533 141 1 the the DET crl-13533 141 2 task task NOUN crl-13533 141 3 was be AUX crl-13533 141 4 to to PART crl-13533 141 5 rank rank VERB crl-13533 141 6 individual individual ADJ crl-13533 141 7 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 141 8 as as ADP crl-13533 141 9 librarian librarian PROPN crl-13533 141 10 i i PROPN crl-13533 141 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 141 12 librarian librarian PROPN crl-13533 141 13 ii ii PROPN crl-13533 141 14 / / SYM crl-13533 141 15 iii iii NUM crl-13533 141 16 , , PUNCT crl-13533 141 17 or or CCONJ crl-13533 141 18 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 141 19 iv iv VERB crl-13533 141 20 n. n. NOUN crl-13533 141 21 those those PRON crl-13533 141 22 ranked rank VERB crl-13533 141 23 as as ADP crl-13533 141 24 librarian librarian PROPN crl-13533 141 25 i i PRON crl-13533 141 26 generally generally ADV crl-13533 141 27 had have VERB crl-13533 141 28 less less ADJ crl-13533 141 29 than than ADP crl-13533 141 30 three three NUM crl-13533 141 31 years year NOUN crl-13533 141 32 of of ADP crl-13533 141 33 experience experience NOUN crl-13533 141 34 . . PUNCT crl-13533 142 1 the the DET crl-13533 142 2 distinctions distinction NOUN crl-13533 142 3 be be VERB crl-13533 142 4 : : PUNCT crl-13533 143 1 tween tween NOUN crl-13533 143 2 librarian librarian ADJ crl-13533 143 3 11/111 11/111 NUM crl-13533 143 4 and and CCONJ crl-13533 143 5 librarian librarian ADJ crl-13533 143 6 ivn ivn PROPN crl-13533 143 7 were be AUX crl-13533 143 8 based base VERB crl-13533 143 9 on on ADP crl-13533 143 10 a a DET crl-13533 143 11 combination combination NOUN crl-13533 143 12 of of ADP crl-13533 143 13 factors factor NOUN crl-13533 143 14 : : PUNCT crl-13533 143 15 experience experience NOUN crl-13533 143 16 , , PUNCT crl-13533 143 17 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 143 18 , , PUNCT crl-13533 143 19 and and CCONJ crl-13533 143 20 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 143 21 development development NOUN crl-13533 143 22 and and CCONJ crl-13533 143 23 accomplishments accomplishment NOUN crl-13533 143 24 . . PUNCT crl-13533 144 1 the the DET crl-13533 144 2 assistant assistant PROPN crl-13533 144 3 university university NOUN crl-13533 144 4 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 144 5 for for ADP crl-13533 144 6 personnel personnel NOUN crl-13533 144 7 held hold VERB crl-13533 144 8 meetings meeting NOUN crl-13533 144 9 with with ADP crl-13533 144 10 supervising supervise VERB crl-13533 144 11 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 144 12 in in ADP crl-13533 144 13 the the DET crl-13533 144 14 spring spring NOUN crl-13533 144 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 144 16 summer summer NOUN crl-13533 144 17 of of ADP crl-13533 144 18 1973 1973 NUM crl-13533 144 19 . . PUNCT crl-13533 145 1 after after ADP crl-13533 145 2 reviewing review VERB crl-13533 145 3 the the DET crl-13533 145 4 criteria criterion NOUN crl-13533 145 5 for for ADP crl-13533 145 6 the the DET crl-13533 145 7 various various ADJ crl-13533 145 8 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 145 9 and and CCONJ crl-13533 145 10 the the DET crl-13533 145 11 employment employment NOUN crl-13533 145 12 history history NOUN crl-13533 145 13 and and CCONJ crl-13533 145 14 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 145 15 of of ADP crl-13533 145 16 individual individual ADJ crl-13533 145 17 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 145 18 , , PUNCT crl-13533 145 19 supervising supervise VERB crl-13533 145 20 librarians librarians PROPN crl-13533 145 21 were be AUX crl-13533 145 22 asked ask VERB crl-13533 145 23 to to PART crl-13533 145 24 recommend recommend VERB crl-13533 145 25 a a DET crl-13533 145 26 " " PUNCT crl-13533 145 27 broad broad ADJ crl-13533 145 28 " " PUNCT crl-13533 145 29 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 145 30 . . PUNCT crl-13533 146 1 in in ADP crl-13533 146 2 most most ADJ crl-13533 146 3 cases case NOUN crl-13533 146 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 146 5 the the DET crl-13533 146 6 recommendations recommendation NOUN crl-13533 146 7 were be AUX crl-13533 146 8 accepted accept VERB crl-13533 146 9 . . PUNCT crl-13533 147 1 in in ADP crl-13533 147 2 several several ADJ crl-13533 147 3 instances instance NOUN crl-13533 147 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 147 5 the the DET crl-13533 147 6 university university NOUN crl-13533 147 7 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 147 8 made make VERB crl-13533 147 9 the the DET crl-13533 147 10 final final ADJ crl-13533 147 11 determination determination NOUN crl-13533 147 12 . . PUNCT crl-13533 148 1 in in ADP crl-13533 148 2 december december PROPN crl-13533 148 3 1973 1973 NUM crl-13533 148 4 the the DET crl-13533 148 5 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 148 6 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 148 7 were be AUX crl-13533 148 8 informed inform VERB crl-13533 148 9 of of ADP crl-13533 148 10 their their PRON crl-13533 148 11 broad broad ADJ crl-13533 148 12 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 148 13 . . PUNCT crl-13533 149 1 the the DET crl-13533 149 2 broad broad ADJ crl-13533 149 3 rankings ranking NOUN crl-13533 149 4 were be AUX crl-13533 149 5 subject subject ADJ crl-13533 149 6 to to ADP crl-13533 149 7 appeal appeal NOUN crl-13533 149 8 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 149 9 however however ADV crl-13533 149 10 , , PUNCT crl-13533 149 11 none none NOUN crl-13533 149 12 was be AUX crl-13533 149 13 made make VERB crl-13533 149 14 . . PUNCT crl-13533 150 1 one one NUM crl-13533 150 2 year year NOUN crl-13533 150 3 later later ADV crl-13533 150 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 150 5 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 150 6 were be AUX crl-13533 150 7 informed inform VERB crl-13533 150 8 of of ADP crl-13533 150 9 their their PRON crl-13533 150 10 specific specific ADJ crl-13533 150 11 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 150 12 . . PUNCT crl-13533 151 1 this this DET crl-13533 151 2 delay delay NOUN crl-13533 151 3 was be AUX crl-13533 151 4 due due ADJ crl-13533 151 5 in in ADP crl-13533 151 6 part part NOUN crl-13533 151 7 to to ADP crl-13533 151 8 the the DET crl-13533 151 9 following follow VERB crl-13533 151 10 problems problem NOUN crl-13533 151 11 : : PUNCT crl-13533 151 12 evaluating evaluate VERB crl-13533 151 13 long long ADJ crl-13533 151 14 - - PUNCT crl-13533 151 15 term term NOUN crl-13533 151 16 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 151 17 members member NOUN crl-13533 151 18 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 151 19 interpreting interpret VERB crl-13533 151 20 criteria criterion NOUN crl-13533 151 21 for for ADP crl-13533 151 22 the the DET crl-13533 151 23 various various ADJ crl-13533 151 24 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 151 25 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 151 26 and and CCONJ crl-13533 151 27 the the DET crl-13533 151 28 lack lack NOUN crl-13533 151 29 of of ADP crl-13533 151 30 organization organization NOUN crl-13533 151 31 of of ADP crl-13533 151 32 personnel personnel NOUN crl-13533 151 33 records record NOUN crl-13533 151 34 . . PUNCT crl-13533 152 1 the the DET crl-13533 152 2 staff staff PROPN crl-13533 152 3 development development PROPN crl-13533 152 4 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 152 5 was be AUX crl-13533 152 6 assigned assign VERB crl-13533 152 7 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 152 8 for for ADP crl-13533 152 9 hearing hear VERB crl-13533 152 10 appeals appeal NOUN crl-13533 152 11 on on ADP crl-13533 152 12 specific specific ADJ crl-13533 152 13 rankings ranking NOUN crl-13533 152 14 , , PUNCT crl-13533 152 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 152 16 one one NUM crl-13533 152 17 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 152 18 member member NOUN crl-13533 152 19 did do AUX crl-13533 152 20 submit submit VERB crl-13533 152 21 an an DET crl-13533 152 22 appeal appeal NOUN crl-13533 152 23 . . PUNCT crl-13533 153 1 after after ADP crl-13533 153 2 meeting meet VERB crl-13533 153 3 with with ADP crl-13533 153 4 the the DET crl-13533 153 5 individual individual NOUN crl-13533 153 6 and and CCONJ crl-13533 153 7 reviewing review VERB crl-13533 153 8 the the DET crl-13533 153 9 matter matter NOUN crl-13533 153 10 , , PUNCT crl-13533 153 11 the the DET crl-13533 153 12 staff staff PROPN crl-13533 153 13 development development PROPN crl-13533 153 14 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 153 15 upheld uphold VERB crl-13533 153 16 the the DET crl-13533 153 17 original original ADJ crl-13533 153 18 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 153 19 . . PUNCT crl-13533 154 1 assessment assessment NOUN crl-13533 154 2 of of ADP crl-13533 154 3 the the DET crl-13533 154 4 system system NOUN crl-13533 154 5 of of ADP crl-13533 154 6 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 154 7 there there PRON crl-13533 154 8 has have AUX crl-13533 154 9 been be AUX crl-13533 154 10 no no DET crl-13533 154 11 formal formal ADJ crl-13533 154 12 assessment assessment NOUN crl-13533 154 13 of of ADP crl-13533 154 14 the the DET crl-13533 154 15 system system NOUN crl-13533 154 16 of of ADP crl-13533 154 17 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 154 18 since since SCONJ crl-13533 154 19 the the DET crl-13533 154 20 first first ADJ crl-13533 154 21 group group NOUN crl-13533 154 22 of of ADP crl-13533 154 23 librarians librarians PROPN crl-13533 154 24 was be AUX crl-13533 154 25 scheduled schedule VERB crl-13533 154 26 for for ADP crl-13533 154 27 review review NOUN crl-13533 154 28 for for ADP crl-13533 154 29 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 154 30 in in ADP crl-13533 154 31 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 154 32 in in ADP crl-13533 154 33 1975 1975 NUM crl-13533 154 34 - - SYM crl-13533 154 35 76 76 NUM crl-13533 154 36 . . PUNCT crl-13533 155 1 during during ADP crl-13533 155 2 the the DET crl-13533 155 3 four four NUM crl-13533 155 4 years year NOUN crl-13533 155 5 that that SCONJ crl-13533 155 6 the the DET crl-13533 155 7 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 155 8 review review NOUN crl-13533 155 9 procolumbia procolumbia NOUN crl-13533 155 10 i i PROPN crl-13533 155 11 301 301 NUM crl-13533 155 12 cess cess NOUN crl-13533 155 13 has have AUX crl-13533 155 14 been be AUX crl-13533 155 15 in in ADP crl-13533 155 16 effect effect NOUN crl-13533 155 17 , , PUNCT crl-13533 155 18 a a DET crl-13533 155 19 total total NOUN crl-13533 155 20 of of ADP crl-13533 155 21 eightynine eightynine NOUN crl-13533 155 22 librarians librarians PROPN crl-13533 155 23 have have AUX crl-13533 155 24 been be AUX crl-13533 155 25 reviewed review VERB crl-13533 155 26 , , PUNCT crl-13533 155 27 and and CCONJ crl-13533 155 28 fifty fifty NUM crl-13533 155 29 - - PUNCT crl-13533 155 30 five five NUM crl-13533 155 31 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 155 32 62 62 NUM crl-13533 155 33 percent percent NOUN crl-13533 155 34 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 155 35 were be AUX crl-13533 155 36 promoted promote VERB crl-13533 155 37 . . PUNCT crl-13533 156 1 through through ADP crl-13533 156 2 feedback feedback NOUN crl-13533 156 3 that that SCONJ crl-13533 156 4 the the DET crl-13533 156 5 library library PROPN crl-13533 156 6 administration administration NOUN crl-13533 156 7 and and CCONJ crl-13533 156 8 the the DET crl-13533 156 9 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 156 10 review review NOUN crl-13533 156 11 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 156 12 have have AUX crl-13533 156 13 received receive VERB crl-13533 156 14 from from ADP crl-13533 156 15 individual individual ADJ crl-13533 156 16 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 156 17 members member NOUN crl-13533 156 18 and and CCONJ crl-13533 156 19 from from ADP crl-13533 156 20 the the DET crl-13533 156 21 representative representative ADJ crl-13533 156 22 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 156 23 of of ADP crl-13533 156 24 librarians librarians PROPN crl-13533 156 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 156 26 there there PRON crl-13533 156 27 is be VERB crl-13533 156 28 evidence evidence NOUN crl-13533 156 29 to to PART crl-13533 156 30 indicate indicate VERB crl-13533 156 31 that that SCONJ crl-13533 156 32 in in ADP crl-13533 156 33 general general ADJ crl-13533 156 34 the the DET crl-13533 156 35 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 156 36 considers consider VERB crl-13533 156 37 the the DET crl-13533 156 38 system system NOUN crl-13533 156 39 fair fair ADJ crl-13533 156 40 and and CCONJ crl-13533 156 41 the the DET crl-13533 156 42 review review NOUN crl-13533 156 43 process process NOUN crl-13533 156 44 a a DET crl-13533 156 45 relevant relevant ADJ crl-13533 156 46 assessment assessment NOUN crl-13533 156 47 of of ADP crl-13533 156 48 significant significant ADJ crl-13533 156 49 aspects aspect NOUN crl-13533 156 50 of of ADP crl-13533 156 51 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 156 52 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 156 53 . . PUNCT crl-13533 157 1 since since SCONJ crl-13533 157 2 there there PRON crl-13533 157 3 are be VERB crl-13533 157 4 mechanisms mechanism NOUN crl-13533 157 5 for for ADP crl-13533 157 6 modifying modify VERB crl-13533 157 7 the the DET crl-13533 157 8 system system NOUN crl-13533 157 9 of of ADP crl-13533 157 10 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 157 11 and and CCONJ crl-13533 157 12 since since SCONJ crl-13533 157 13 there there PRON crl-13533 157 14 are be VERB crl-13533 157 15 indications indication NOUN crl-13533 157 16 that that SCONJ crl-13533 157 17 the the DET crl-13533 157 18 original original ADJ crl-13533 157 19 objectives objective NOUN crl-13533 157 20 of of ADP crl-13533 157 21 recognizing recognize VERB crl-13533 157 22 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 157 23 accomplishments accomplishment NOUN crl-13533 157 24 within within ADP crl-13533 157 25 the the DET crl-13533 157 26 context context NOUN crl-13533 157 27 of of ADP crl-13533 157 28 library library NOUN crl-13533 157 29 program program NOUN crl-13533 157 30 and and CCONJ crl-13533 157 31 service service NOUN crl-13533 157 32 objectives objective NOUN crl-13533 157 33 are be AUX crl-13533 157 34 being be AUX crl-13533 157 35 met meet VERB crl-13533 157 36 , , PUNCT crl-13533 157 37 it it PRON crl-13533 157 38 is be AUX crl-13533 157 39 clear clear ADJ crl-13533 157 40 that that SCONJ crl-13533 157 41 the the DET crl-13533 157 42 system system NOUN crl-13533 157 43 of of ADP crl-13533 157 44 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 157 45 will will AUX crl-13533 157 46 remain remain VERB crl-13533 157 47 an an DET crl-13533 157 48 integral integral ADJ crl-13533 157 49 aspect aspect NOUN crl-13533 157 50 of of ADP crl-13533 157 51 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 157 52 's 's PART crl-13533 157 53 program program NOUN crl-13533 157 54 for for ADP crl-13533 157 55 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 157 56 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 157 57 . . PUNCT crl-13533 158 1 characteristics characteristic NOUN crl-13533 158 2 of of ADP crl-13533 158 3 the the DET crl-13533 158 4 system system NOUN crl-13533 158 5 of of ADP crl-13533 158 6 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 158 7 position position NOUN crl-13533 158 8 categories category NOUN crl-13533 158 9 the the DET crl-13533 158 10 position position NOUN crl-13533 158 11 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 158 12 scheme scheme NOUN crl-13533 158 13 that that PRON crl-13533 158 14 evolved evolve VERB crl-13533 158 15 as as ADP crl-13533 158 16 the the DET crl-13533 158 17 second second ADJ crl-13533 158 18 track track NOUN crl-13533 158 19 of of ADP crl-13533 158 20 the the DET crl-13533 158 21 system system NOUN crl-13533 158 22 of of ADP crl-13533 158 23 organization organization NOUN crl-13533 158 24 for for ADP crl-13533 158 25 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 158 26 at at ADP crl-13533 158 27 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 158 28 is be AUX crl-13533 158 29 relatively relatively ADV crl-13533 158 30 traditional traditional ADJ crl-13533 158 31 . . PUNCT crl-13533 159 1 as as SCONJ crl-13533 159 2 previously previously ADV crl-13533 159 3 indicated indicate VERB crl-13533 159 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 159 5 the the DET crl-13533 159 6 management management NOUN crl-13533 159 7 study study NOUN crl-13533 159 8 had have AUX crl-13533 159 9 recommended recommend VERB crl-13533 159 10 the the DET crl-13533 159 11 development development NOUN crl-13533 159 12 of of ADP crl-13533 159 13 five five NUM crl-13533 159 14 classes class NOUN crl-13533 159 15 of of ADP crl-13533 159 16 librarian librarian ADJ crl-13533 159 17 positions position NOUN crl-13533 159 18 . . PUNCT crl-13533 160 1 the the DET crl-13533 160 2 task task NOUN crl-13533 160 3 force force NOUN crl-13533 160 4 charged charge VERB crl-13533 160 5 with with ADP crl-13533 160 6 developing develop VERB crl-13533 160 7 and and CCONJ crl-13533 160 8 defining define VERB crl-13533 160 9 this this DET crl-13533 160 10 scheme scheme NOUN crl-13533 160 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 160 12 however however ADV crl-13533 160 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 160 14 was be AUX crl-13533 160 15 not not PART crl-13533 160 16 convinced convince VERB crl-13533 160 17 initially initially ADV crl-13533 160 18 that that SCONJ crl-13533 160 19 five five NUM crl-13533 160 20 classes class NOUN crl-13533 160 21 were be AUX crl-13533 160 22 sufficient sufficient ADJ crl-13533 160 23 to to PART crl-13533 160 24 accommodate accommodate VERB crl-13533 160 25 the the DET crl-13533 160 26 range range NOUN crl-13533 160 27 of of ADP crl-13533 160 28 activities activity NOUN crl-13533 160 29 and and CCONJ crl-13533 160 30 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 160 31 encompassed encompass VERB crl-13533 160 32 by by ADP crl-13533 160 33 some some DET crl-13533 160 34 130 130 NUM crl-13533 160 35 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 160 36 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 160 37 . . PUNCT crl-13533 161 1 the the DET crl-13533 161 2 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 161 3 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 161 4 task task NOUN crl-13533 161 5 force force NOUN crl-13533 161 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 161 7 which which PRON crl-13533 161 8 was be AUX crl-13533 161 9 appointed appoint VERB crl-13533 161 10 in in ADP crl-13533 161 11 march march PROPN crl-13533 161 12 1972 1972 NUM crl-13533 161 13 and and CCONJ crl-13533 161 14 charged charge VERB crl-13533 161 15 with with ADP crl-13533 161 16 recommending recommend VERB crl-13533 161 17 a a DET crl-13533 161 18 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 161 19 scheme scheme NOUN crl-13533 161 20 for for ADP crl-13533 161 21 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 161 22 positions position NOUN crl-13533 161 23 , , PUNCT crl-13533 161 24 was be AUX crl-13533 161 25 not not PART crl-13533 161 26 constrained constrain VERB crl-13533 161 27 to to PART crl-13533 161 28 fit fit VERB crl-13533 161 29 all all DET crl-13533 161 30 positions position NOUN crl-13533 161 31 into into ADP crl-13533 161 32 a a DET crl-13533 161 33 fivegrade fivegrade NOUN crl-13533 161 34 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 161 35 scheme scheme NOUN crl-13533 161 36 . . PUNCT crl-13533 162 1 the the DET crl-13533 162 2 maximum maximum ADJ crl-13533 162 3 number number NOUN crl-13533 162 4 of of ADP crl-13533 162 5 gradations gradation NOUN crl-13533 162 6 considered consider VERB crl-13533 162 7 by by ADP crl-13533 162 8 the the DET crl-13533 162 9 task task NOUN crl-13533 162 10 force force NOUN crl-13533 162 11 was be AUX crl-13533 162 12 eight eight NUM crl-13533 162 13 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 162 14 the the DET crl-13533 162 15 minimum minimum ADJ crl-13533 162 16 four four NUM crl-13533 162 17 . . PUNCT crl-13533 163 1 what what PRON crl-13533 163 2 did do AUX crl-13533 163 3 evolve evolve VERB crl-13533 163 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 163 5 however however ADV crl-13533 163 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 163 7 seemed seem VERB crl-13533 163 8 to to PART crl-13533 163 9 reflect reflect VERB crl-13533 163 10 the the DET crl-13533 163 11 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 163 12 of of ADP crl-13533 163 13 responsibilites responsibilite NOUN crl-13533 163 14 at at ADP crl-13533 163 15 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 163 16 . . PUNCT crl-13533 164 1 it it PRON crl-13533 164 2 involved involve VERB crl-13533 164 3 five five NUM crl-13533 164 4 position position NOUN crl-13533 164 5 categories category NOUN crl-13533 164 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 164 7 which which PRON crl-13533 164 8 were be AUX crl-13533 164 9 identified identify VERB crl-13533 164 10 through through ADP crl-13533 164 11 an an DET crl-13533 164 12 analysis analysis NOUN crl-13533 164 13 of of ADP crl-13533 164 14 various various ADJ crl-13533 164 15 factors factor NOUN crl-13533 164 16 that that PRON crl-13533 164 17 indicated indicate VERB crl-13533 164 18 an an DET crl-13533 164 19 ascending ascend VERB crl-13533 164 20 level level NOUN crl-13533 164 21 of of ADP crl-13533 164 22 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 164 23 governed govern VERB crl-13533 164 24 by by ADP crl-13533 164 25 the the DET crl-13533 164 26 extent extent NOUN crl-13533 164 27 of of ADP crl-13533 164 28 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 164 29 duties duty NOUN crl-13533 164 30 and/or and/or CCONJ crl-13533 164 31 policy policy NOUN crl-13533 164 32 - - PUNCT crl-13533 164 33 making make VERB crl-13533 164 34 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 164 35 . . PUNCT crl-13533 165 1 in in ADP crl-13533 165 2 other other ADJ crl-13533 165 3 words word NOUN crl-13533 165 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 165 5 the the DET crl-13533 165 6 task task NOUN crl-13533 165 7 force force NOUN crl-13533 165 8 believed believe VERB crl-13533 165 9 that that SCONJ crl-13533 165 10 one one NUM crl-13533 165 11 track track NOUN crl-13533 165 12 of of ADP crl-13533 165 13 the the DET crl-13533 165 14 system system NOUN crl-13533 165 15 or or CCONJ crl-13533 165 16 organization organization NOUN crl-13533 165 17 302 302 NUM crl-13533 165 18 i i PROPN crl-13533 165 19 college college PROPN crl-13533 165 20 & & CCONJ crl-13533 165 21 research research PROPN crl-13533 165 22 libraries librarie VERB crl-13533 165 23 • • ADJ crl-13533 165 24 july july PROPN crl-13533 165 25 1980 1980 NUM crl-13533 165 26 of of ADP crl-13533 165 27 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 165 28 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 165 29 at at ADP crl-13533 165 30 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 165 31 should should AUX crl-13533 165 32 include include VERB crl-13533 165 33 recognition recognition NOUN crl-13533 165 34 and and CCONJ crl-13533 165 35 compensation compensation NOUN crl-13533 165 36 for for ADP crl-13533 165 37 supervisory supervisory ADJ crl-13533 165 38 and and CCONJ crl-13533 165 39 managerial managerial ADJ crl-13533 165 40 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 165 41 . . PUNCT crl-13533 166 1 in in ADP crl-13533 166 2 developing develop VERB crl-13533 166 3 the the DET crl-13533 166 4 five five NUM crl-13533 166 5 position position NOUN crl-13533 166 6 categories category NOUN crl-13533 166 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 166 8 the the DET crl-13533 166 9 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 166 10 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 166 11 task task NOUN crl-13533 166 12 force force NOUN crl-13533 166 13 adopted adopt VERB crl-13533 166 14 a a DET crl-13533 166 15 " " PUNCT crl-13533 166 16 position position NOUN crl-13533 166 17 - - PUNCT crl-13533 166 18 grading grade VERB crl-13533 166 19 " " PUNCT crl-13533 166 20 system system NOUN crl-13533 166 21 to to PART crl-13533 166 22 determine determine VERB crl-13533 166 23 appropriate appropriate ADJ crl-13533 166 24 categories category NOUN crl-13533 166 25 . . PUNCT crl-13533 167 1 12 12 NUM crl-13533 167 2 the the DET crl-13533 167 3 process process NOUN crl-13533 167 4 involved involve VERB crl-13533 167 5 analyzing analyze VERB crl-13533 167 6 each each DET crl-13533 167 7 position position NOUN crl-13533 167 8 in in ADP crl-13533 167 9 relation relation NOUN crl-13533 167 10 to to ADP crl-13533 167 11 other other ADJ crl-13533 167 12 positions position NOUN crl-13533 167 13 and and CCONJ crl-13533 167 14 classifying classify VERB crl-13533 167 15 it it PRON crl-13533 167 16 in in ADP crl-13533 167 17 terms term NOUN crl-13533 167 18 of of ADP crl-13533 167 19 level level NOUN crl-13533 167 20 of of ADP crl-13533 167 21 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 167 22 . . PUNCT crl-13533 168 1 factors factor NOUN crl-13533 168 2 taken take VERB crl-13533 168 3 into into ADP crl-13533 168 4 consideration consideration NOUN crl-13533 168 5 were be AUX crl-13533 168 6 : : PUNCT crl-13533 168 7 complexity complexity NOUN crl-13533 168 8 of of ADP crl-13533 168 9 the the DET crl-13533 168 10 skills skill NOUN crl-13533 168 11 required require VERB crl-13533 168 12 for for ADP crl-13533 168 13 the the DET crl-13533 168 14 position position NOUN crl-13533 168 15 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 168 16 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 168 17 and and CCONJ crl-13533 168 18 extent extent NOUN crl-13533 168 19 of of ADP crl-13533 168 20 relationships relationship NOUN crl-13533 168 21 with with ADP crl-13533 168 22 students student NOUN crl-13533 168 23 , , PUNCT crl-13533 168 24 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 168 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 168 26 the the DET crl-13533 168 27 general general ADJ crl-13533 168 28 public public NOUN crl-13533 168 29 , , PUNCT crl-13533 168 30 and and CCONJ crl-13533 168 31 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 168 32 and and CCONJ crl-13533 168 33 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 168 34 components component NOUN crl-13533 168 35 of of ADP crl-13533 168 36 the the DET crl-13533 168 37 university university NOUN crl-13533 168 38 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 168 39 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-13533 168 40 for for ADP crl-13533 168 41 developing develop VERB crl-13533 168 42 and and CCONJ crl-13533 168 43 implementing implement VERB crl-13533 168 44 policies policy NOUN crl-13533 168 45 , , PUNCT crl-13533 168 46 programs program NOUN crl-13533 168 47 , , PUNCT crl-13533 168 48 and and CCONJ crl-13533 168 49 services service NOUN crl-13533 168 50 ; ; PUNCT crl-13533 168 51 and and CCONJ crl-13533 168 52 supervisory supervisory ADJ crl-13533 168 53 or or CCONJ crl-13533 168 54 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 168 55 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 168 56 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 168 57 including include VERB crl-13533 168 58 composition composition NOUN crl-13533 168 59 of of ADP crl-13533 168 60 stafl stafl PROPN crl-13533 168 61 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 168 62 . . PUNCT crl-13533 169 1 in in ADP crl-13533 169 2 essence essence NOUN crl-13533 169 3 , , PUNCT crl-13533 169 4 the the DET crl-13533 169 5 analysis analysis NOUN crl-13533 169 6 of of ADP crl-13533 169 7 these these DET crl-13533 169 8 factors factor NOUN crl-13533 169 9 indicated indicate VERB crl-13533 169 10 that that SCONJ crl-13533 169 11 there there PRON crl-13533 169 12 was be VERB crl-13533 169 13 an an DET crl-13533 169 14 ascending ascend VERB crl-13533 169 15 level level NOUN crl-13533 169 16 of of ADP crl-13533 169 17 position position NOUN crl-13533 169 18 categories category NOUN crl-13533 169 19 governed govern VERB crl-13533 169 20 by by ADP crl-13533 169 21 the the DET crl-13533 169 22 extent extent NOUN crl-13533 169 23 of of ADP crl-13533 169 24 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 169 25 duties duty NOUN crl-13533 169 26 and/or and/or CCONJ crl-13533 169 27 policymaking policymake VERB crl-13533 169 28 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 169 29 . . PUNCT crl-13533 170 1 the the DET crl-13533 170 2 system system NOUN crl-13533 170 3 of of ADP crl-13533 170 4 position position NOUN crl-13533 170 5 categories category NOUN crl-13533 170 6 views view VERB crl-13533 170 7 the the DET crl-13533 170 8 function function NOUN crl-13533 170 9 of of ADP crl-13533 170 10 a a DET crl-13533 170 11 position position NOUN crl-13533 170 12 as as ADP crl-13533 170 13 constant constant ADJ crl-13533 170 14 , , PUNCT crl-13533 170 15 although although SCONJ crl-13533 170 16 the the DET crl-13533 170 17 manner manner NOUN crl-13533 170 18 and and CCONJ crl-13533 170 19 the the DET crl-13533 170 20 effectiveness effectiveness NOUN crl-13533 170 21 with with ADP crl-13533 170 22 which which PRON crl-13533 170 23 the the DET crl-13533 170 24 function function NOUN crl-13533 170 25 is be AUX crl-13533 170 26 accomplished accomplished ADJ crl-13533 170 27 varies varie NOUN crl-13533 170 28 , , PUNCT crl-13533 170 29 depending depend VERB crl-13533 170 30 on on ADP crl-13533 170 31 a a DET crl-13533 170 32 number number NOUN crl-13533 170 33 of of ADP crl-13533 170 34 factors factor NOUN crl-13533 170 35 , , PUNCT crl-13533 170 36 including include VERB crl-13533 170 37 the the DET crl-13533 170 38 training training NOUN crl-13533 170 39 , , PUNCT crl-13533 170 40 background background NOUN crl-13533 170 41 , , PUNCT crl-13533 170 42 and and CCONJ crl-13533 170 43 experience experience NOUN crl-13533 170 44 of of ADP crl-13533 170 45 the the DET crl-13533 170 46 incumbent incumbent NOUN crl-13533 170 47 . . PUNCT crl-13533 171 1 because because SCONJ crl-13533 171 2 this this PRON crl-13533 171 3 is be AUX crl-13533 171 4 a a DET crl-13533 171 5 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 171 6 of of ADP crl-13533 171 7 positions position NOUN crl-13533 171 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 171 9 not not PART crl-13533 171 10 of of ADP crl-13533 171 11 people people NOUN crl-13533 171 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 171 13 the the DET crl-13533 171 14 concept concept NOUN crl-13533 171 15 of of ADP crl-13533 171 16 a a DET crl-13533 171 17 " " PUNCT crl-13533 171 18 beginning begin VERB crl-13533 171 19 " " PUNCT crl-13533 171 20 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 171 21 position position NOUN crl-13533 171 22 , , PUNCT crl-13533 171 23 that that ADV crl-13533 171 24 is is ADV crl-13533 171 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 171 26 one one NUM crl-13533 171 27 budgeted budget VERB crl-13533 171 28 at at ADP crl-13533 171 29 the the DET crl-13533 171 30 current current ADJ crl-13533 171 31 beginning begin VERB crl-13533 171 32 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 171 33 salary salary NOUN crl-13533 171 34 and and CCONJ crl-13533 171 35 usually usually ADV crl-13533 171 36 filled fill VERB crl-13533 171 37 by by ADP crl-13533 171 38 a a DET crl-13533 171 39 recent recent ADJ crl-13533 171 40 library library NOUN crl-13533 171 41 school school NOUN crl-13533 171 42 graduate graduate NOUN crl-13533 171 43 with with ADP crl-13533 171 44 little little ADJ crl-13533 171 45 or or CCONJ crl-13533 171 46 no no PRON crl-13533 171 47 previous previous ADJ crl-13533 171 48 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 171 49 experience experience NOUN crl-13533 171 50 , , PUNCT crl-13533 171 51 is be AUX crl-13533 171 52 not not PART crl-13533 171 53 reflected reflect VERB crl-13533 171 54 in in ADP crl-13533 171 55 · · PUNCT crl-13533 171 56 the the DET crl-13533 171 57 scheme scheme NOUN crl-13533 171 58 . . PUNCT crl-13533 172 1 theoretically theoretically ADV crl-13533 172 2 , , PUNCT crl-13533 172 3 a a DET crl-13533 172 4 " " PUNCT crl-13533 172 5 beginning begin VERB crl-13533 172 6 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 172 7 " " PUNCT crl-13533 172 8 could could AUX crl-13533 172 9 be be AUX crl-13533 172 10 appointed appoint VERB crl-13533 172 11 to to ADP crl-13533 172 12 a a DET crl-13533 172 13 position position NOUN crl-13533 172 14 in in ADP crl-13533 172 15 any any DET crl-13533 172 16 category category NOUN crl-13533 172 17 . . PUNCT crl-13533 173 1 realistically realistically ADV crl-13533 173 2 , , PUNCT crl-13533 173 3 however however ADV crl-13533 173 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 173 5 such such ADJ crl-13533 173 6 appointments appointment NOUN crl-13533 173 7 would would AUX crl-13533 173 8 be be AUX crl-13533 173 9 unlikely unlikely ADJ crl-13533 173 10 for for ADP crl-13533 173 11 positions position NOUN crl-13533 173 12 requiring require VERB crl-13533 173 13 substantial substantial ADJ crl-13533 173 14 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 173 15 , , PUNCT crl-13533 173 16 technical technical ADJ crl-13533 173 17 , , PUNCT crl-13533 173 18 or or CCONJ crl-13533 173 19 program program NOUN crl-13533 173 20 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 173 21 . . PUNCT crl-13533 174 1 implementation implementation NOUN crl-13533 174 2 of of ADP crl-13533 174 3 position position NOUN crl-13533 174 4 categories category NOUN crl-13533 174 5 the the DET crl-13533 174 6 task task NOUN crl-13533 174 7 force force NOUN crl-13533 174 8 appointed appoint VERB crl-13533 174 9 to to PART crl-13533 174 10 develop develop VERB crl-13533 174 11 the the DET crl-13533 174 12 system system NOUN crl-13533 174 13 of of ADP crl-13533 174 14 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 174 15 position position NOUN crl-13533 174 16 categories category NOUN crl-13533 174 17 b'egan b'egan VERB crl-13533 174 18 its its PRON crl-13533 174 19 work work NOUN crl-13533 174 20 in in ADP crl-13533 174 21 march march PROPN crl-13533 174 22 1972 1972 NUM crl-13533 174 23 . . PUNCT crl-13533 175 1 in in ADP crl-13533 175 2 december december PROPN crl-13533 175 3 1973 1973 NUM crl-13533 175 4 letters letter NOUN crl-13533 175 5 were be AUX crl-13533 175 6 sent send VERB crl-13533 175 7 to to ADP crl-13533 175 8 all all DET crl-13533 175 9 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 175 10 informing inform VERB crl-13533 175 11 them they PRON crl-13533 175 12 of of ADP crl-13533 175 13 the the DET crl-13533 175 14 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 175 15 of of ADP crl-13533 175 16 their their PRON crl-13533 175 17 positions position NOUN crl-13533 175 18 . . PUNCT crl-13533 176 1 to to PART crl-13533 176 2 provide provide VERB crl-13533 176 3 input input NOUN crl-13533 176 4 from from ADP crl-13533 176 5 the the DET crl-13533 176 6 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 176 7 and and CCONJ crl-13533 176 8 to to PART crl-13533 176 9 verify verify VERB crl-13533 176 10 the the DET crl-13533 176 11 validity validity NOUN crl-13533 176 12 of of ADP crl-13533 176 13 the the DET crl-13533 176 14 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 176 15 , , PUNCT crl-13533 176 16 a a DET crl-13533 176 17 review review NOUN crl-13533 176 18 or or CCONJ crl-13533 176 19 appeal appeal NOUN crl-13533 176 20 process process NOUN crl-13533 176 21 was be AUX crl-13533 176 22 instituted institute VERB crl-13533 176 23 at at ADP crl-13533 176 24 the the DET crl-13533 176 25 time time NOUN crl-13533 176 26 of of ADP crl-13533 176 27 the the DET crl-13533 176 28 announcements announcement NOUN crl-13533 176 29 . . PUNCT crl-13533 177 1 the the DET crl-13533 177 2 appeal appeal NOUN crl-13533 177 3 process process NOUN crl-13533 177 4 provided provide VERB crl-13533 177 5 each each DET crl-13533 177 6 member member NOUN crl-13533 177 7 of of ADP crl-13533 177 8 the the DET crl-13533 177 9 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 177 10 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 177 11 with with ADP crl-13533 177 12 the the DET crl-13533 177 13 opportunity opportunity NOUN crl-13533 177 14 to to PART crl-13533 177 15 meet meet VERB crl-13533 177 16 with with ADP crl-13533 177 17 the the DET crl-13533 177 18 task task NOUN crl-13533 177 19 force force NOUN crl-13533 177 20 to to PART crl-13533 177 21 discuss discuss VERB crl-13533 177 22 the the DET crl-13533 177 23 system system NOUN crl-13533 177 24 in in ADP crl-13533 177 25 general general ADJ crl-13533 177 26 and and CCONJ crl-13533 177 27 to to PART crl-13533 177 28 indicate indicate VERB crl-13533 177 29 the the DET crl-13533 177 30 reasons reason NOUN crl-13533 177 31 they they PRON crl-13533 177 32 felt feel VERB crl-13533 177 33 that that SCONJ crl-13533 177 34 their their PRON crl-13533 177 35 own own ADJ crl-13533 177 36 or or CCONJ crl-13533 177 37 other other ADJ crl-13533 177 38 positions position NOUN crl-13533 177 39 had have AUX crl-13533 177 40 not not PART crl-13533 177 41 been be AUX crl-13533 177 42 properly properly ADV crl-13533 177 43 classified classify VERB crl-13533 177 44 . . PUNCT crl-13533 178 1 at at ADP crl-13533 178 2 the the DET crl-13533 178 3 time time NOUN crl-13533 178 4 of of ADP crl-13533 178 5 the the DET crl-13533 178 6 appeals appeal NOUN crl-13533 178 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 178 8 there there PRON crl-13533 178 9 were be VERB crl-13533 178 10 135 135 NUM crl-13533 178 11 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 178 12 in in ADP crl-13533 178 13 positions position NOUN crl-13533 178 14 covered cover VERB crl-13533 178 15 by by ADP crl-13533 178 16 the the DET crl-13533 178 17 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 178 18 scheme scheme NOUN crl-13533 178 19 . . PUNCT crl-13533 179 1 twenty twenty NUM crl-13533 179 2 - - PUNCT crl-13533 179 3 seven seven NUM crl-13533 179 4 or or CCONJ crl-13533 179 5 20 20 NUM crl-13533 179 6 percent percent NOUN crl-13533 179 7 of of ADP crl-13533 179 8 them they PRON crl-13533 179 9 appealed appeal VERB crl-13533 179 10 their their PRON crl-13533 179 11 position position NOUN crl-13533 179 12 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 179 13 . . PUNCT crl-13533 180 1 this this PRON crl-13533 180 2 was be AUX crl-13533 180 3 considered consider VERB crl-13533 180 4 high high ADJ crl-13533 180 5 in in ADP crl-13533 180 6 relation relation NOUN crl-13533 180 7 to to ADP crl-13533 180 8 the the DET crl-13533 180 9 number number NOUN crl-13533 180 10 of of ADP crl-13533 180 11 grievances grievance NOUN crl-13533 180 12 submitted submit VERB crl-13533 180 13 following follow VERB crl-13533 180 14 the the DET crl-13533 180 15 release release NOUN crl-13533 180 16 of of ADP crl-13533 180 17 the the DET crl-13533 180 18 union union NOUN crl-13533 180 19 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 180 20 for for ADP crl-13533 180 21 supporting support VERB crl-13533 180 22 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 180 23 in in ADP crl-13533 180 24 the the DET crl-13533 180 25 spring spring NOUN crl-13533 180 26 of of ADP crl-13533 180 27 1970 1970 NUM crl-13533 180 28 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 180 29 thirty thirty NUM crl-13533 180 30 - - PUNCT crl-13533 180 31 two two NUM crl-13533 180 32 grievances grievance NOUN crl-13533 180 33 or or CCONJ crl-13533 180 34 about about ADV crl-13533 180 35 10 10 NUM crl-13533 180 36 percent percent NOUN crl-13533 180 37 of of ADP crl-13533 180 38 the the DET crl-13533 180 39 stafl stafl PROPN crl-13533 180 40 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 180 41 . . PUNCT crl-13533 181 1 of of ADP crl-13533 181 2 the the DET crl-13533 181 3 twenty twenty NUM crl-13533 181 4 - - PUNCT crl-13533 181 5 seven seven NUM crl-13533 181 6 appeals appeal NOUN crl-13533 181 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 181 8 twenty twenty NUM crl-13533 181 9 - - PUNCT crl-13533 181 10 five five NUM crl-13533 181 11 were be AUX crl-13533 181 12 from from ADP crl-13533 181 13 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 181 14 whose whose DET crl-13533 181 15 positions position NOUN crl-13533 181 16 had have AUX crl-13533 181 17 been be AUX crl-13533 181 18 classified classify VERB crl-13533 181 19 in in ADP crl-13533 181 20 category category NOUN crl-13533 181 21 i. i. PROPN crl-13533 181 22 the the DET crl-13533 181 23 other other ADJ crl-13533 181 24 two two NUM crl-13533 181 25 were be AUX crl-13533 181 26 submftted submftte VERB crl-13533 181 27 by by ADP crl-13533 181 28 individuals individual NOUN crl-13533 181 29 whose whose DET crl-13533 181 30 positions position NOUN crl-13533 181 31 were be AUX crl-13533 181 32 in in ADP crl-13533 181 33 category category NOUN crl-13533 181 34 ii ii PROPN crl-13533 181 35 . . PUNCT crl-13533 182 1 the the DET crl-13533 182 2 task task PROPN crl-13533 182 3 force force NOUN crl-13533 182 4 had have VERB crl-13533 182 5 a a DET crl-13533 182 6 general general ADJ crl-13533 182 7 understanding understanding NOUN crl-13533 182 8 of of ADP crl-13533 182 9 the the DET crl-13533 182 10 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 182 11 of of ADP crl-13533 182 12 and and CCONJ crl-13533 182 13 reasons reason NOUN crl-13533 182 14 for for ADP crl-13533 182 15 the the DET crl-13533 182 16 appeals appeal NOUN crl-13533 182 17 prior prior ADV crl-13533 182 18 to to ADP crl-13533 182 19 meeting meeting NOUN crl-13533 182 20 with with ADP crl-13533 182 21 individual individual ADJ crl-13533 182 22 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 182 23 since since SCONJ crl-13533 182 24 the the DET crl-13533 182 25 appeals appeal NOUN crl-13533 182 26 had have VERB crl-13533 182 27 to to PART crl-13533 182 28 be be AUX crl-13533 182 29 stated state VERB crl-13533 182 30 in in ADP crl-13533 182 31 writing writing NOUN crl-13533 182 32 . . PUNCT crl-13533 183 1 it it PRON crl-13533 183 2 was be AUX crl-13533 183 3 apparent apparent ADJ crl-13533 183 4 that that SCONJ crl-13533 183 5 some some DET crl-13533 183 6 individuals individual NOUN crl-13533 183 7 were be AUX crl-13533 183 8 unclear unclear ADJ crl-13533 183 9 on on ADP crl-13533 183 10 the the DET crl-13533 183 11 distinctions distinction NOUN crl-13533 183 12 between between ADP crl-13533 183 13 the the DET crl-13533 183 14 system system NOUN crl-13533 183 15 of of ADP crl-13533 183 16 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 183 17 and and CCONJ crl-13533 183 18 the the DET crl-13533 183 19 system system NOUN crl-13533 183 20 of of ADP crl-13533 183 21 position position NOUN crl-13533 183 22 categories category NOUN crl-13533 183 23 . . PUNCT crl-13533 184 1 although although SCONJ crl-13533 184 2 the the DET crl-13533 184 3 document document NOUN crl-13533 184 4 describing describe VERB crl-13533 184 5 the the DET crl-13533 184 6 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 184 7 scheme scheme NOUN crl-13533 184 8 pointed point VERB crl-13533 184 9 out out ADP crl-13533 184 10 that that SCONJ crl-13533 184 11 it it PRON crl-13533 184 12 emphasized emphasize VERB crl-13533 184 13 " " PUNCT crl-13533 184 14 an an DET crl-13533 184 15 ascending ascend VERB crl-13533 184 16 level level NOUN crl-13533 184 17 ... ... PUNCT crl-13533 184 18 governed govern VERB crl-13533 184 19 by by ADP crl-13533 184 20 the the DET crl-13533 184 21 extent extent NOUN crl-13533 184 22 of of ADP crl-13533 184 23 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 184 24 duties duty NOUN crl-13533 184 25 and/or and/or CCONJ crl-13533 184 26 policy policy NOUN crl-13533 184 27 - - PUNCT crl-13533 184 28 making make VERB crl-13533 184 29 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 184 30 , , PUNCT crl-13533 184 31 " " PUNCT crl-13533 184 32 individuals individual NOUN crl-13533 184 33 either either CCONJ crl-13533 184 34 would would AUX crl-13533 184 35 not not PART crl-13533 184 36 accept accept VERB crl-13533 184 37 or or CCONJ crl-13533 184 38 did do AUX crl-13533 184 39 not not PART crl-13533 184 40 understand understand VERB crl-13533 184 41 the the DET crl-13533 184 42 rationale rationale NOUN crl-13533 184 43 · · PUNCT crl-13533 184 44 for for ADP crl-13533 184 45 this this DET crl-13533 184 46 emphasis emphasis NOUN crl-13533 184 47 . . PUNCT crl-13533 185 1 when when SCONJ crl-13533 185 2 the the DET crl-13533 185 3 task task NOUN crl-13533 185 4 force force NOUN crl-13533 185 5 met meet VERB crl-13533 185 6 with with ADP crl-13533 185 7 individual individual ADJ crl-13533 185 8 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 185 9 members member NOUN crl-13533 185 10 , , PUNCT crl-13533 185 11 therefore therefore ADV crl-13533 185 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 185 13 its its PRON crl-13533 185 14 introductory introductory ADJ crl-13533 185 15 remarks remark NOUN crl-13533 185 16 centered center VERB crl-13533 185 17 on on ADP crl-13533 185 18 the the DET crl-13533 185 19 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 185 20 of of ADP crl-13533 185 21 position position NOUN crl-13533 185 22 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 185 23 schemes scheme NOUN crl-13533 185 24 and and CCONJ crl-13533 185 25 the the DET crl-13533 185 26 primary primary ADJ crl-13533 185 27 characteristics characteristic NOUN crl-13533 185 28 of of ADP crl-13533 185 29 the the DET crl-13533 185 30 system system NOUN crl-13533 185 31 of of ADP crl-13533 185 32 position position NOUN crl-13533 185 33 categories category NOUN crl-13533 185 34 . . PUNCT crl-13533 186 1 stress stress NOUN crl-13533 186 2 was be AUX crl-13533 186 3 also also ADV crl-13533 186 4 given give VERB crl-13533 186 5 to to ADP crl-13533 186 6 the the DET crl-13533 186 7 differences difference NOUN crl-13533 186 8 between between ADP crl-13533 186 9 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 186 10 and and CCONJ crl-13533 186 11 position position NOUN crl-13533 186 12 . . PUNCT crl-13533 187 1 the the DET crl-13533 187 2 appeals appeal NOUN crl-13533 187 3 were be AUX crl-13533 187 4 scheduled schedule VERB crl-13533 187 5 and and CCONJ crl-13533 187 6 took take VERB crl-13533 187 7 place place NOUN crl-13533 187 8 in in ADP crl-13533 187 9 march march PROPN crl-13533 187 10 1974 1974 NUM crl-13533 187 11 . . PUNCT crl-13533 188 1 in in ADP crl-13533 188 2 most most ADJ crl-13533 188 3 instances instance NOUN crl-13533 188 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 188 5 the the DET crl-13533 188 6 task task NOUN crl-13533 188 7 force force NOUN crl-13533 188 8 thought think VERB crl-13533 188 9 that that SCONJ crl-13533 188 10 the the DET crl-13533 188 11 discussions discussion NOUN crl-13533 188 12 were be AUX crl-13533 188 13 mutually mutually ADV crl-13533 188 14 informative informative ADJ crl-13533 188 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 188 16 productive productive ADJ crl-13533 188 17 . . PUNCT crl-13533 189 1 the the DET crl-13533 189 2 task task PROPN crl-13533 189 3 force force NOUN crl-13533 189 4 quickly quickly ADV crl-13533 189 5 concluded conclude VERB crl-13533 189 6 that that SCONJ crl-13533 189 7 the the DET crl-13533 189 8 description description NOUN crl-13533 189 9 of of ADP crl-13533 189 10 the the DET crl-13533 189 11 functional functional ADJ crl-13533 189 12 characteristics characteristic NOUN crl-13533 189 13 of of ADP crl-13533 189 14 the the DET crl-13533 189 15 different different ADJ crl-13533 189 16 position position NOUN crl-13533 189 17 categories category NOUN crl-13533 189 18 could could AUX crl-13533 189 19 be be AUX crl-13533 189 20 improved improve VERB crl-13533 189 21 . . PUNCT crl-13533 190 1 these these DET crl-13533 190 2 revisions revision NOUN crl-13533 190 3 included include VERB crl-13533 190 4 the the DET crl-13533 190 5 phrase phrase NOUN crl-13533 190 6 " " PUNCT crl-13533 190 7 this this PRON crl-13533 190 8 is be AUX crl-13533 190 9 a a DET crl-13533 190 10 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 190 11 of of ADP crl-13533 190 12 positions position NOUN crl-13533 190 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 190 14 not not PART crl-13533 190 15 of of ADP crl-13533 190 16 people people NOUN crl-13533 190 17 , , PUNCT crl-13533 190 18 " " PUNCT crl-13533 190 19 which which PRON crl-13533 190 20 was be AUX crl-13533 190 21 necessary necessary ADJ crl-13533 190 22 to to PART crl-13533 190 23 underline underline VERB crl-13533 190 24 the the DET crl-13533 190 25 distinctions distinction NOUN crl-13533 190 26 between between ADP crl-13533 190 27 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 190 28 and and CCONJ crl-13533 190 29 position position NOUN crl-13533 190 30 category category NOUN crl-13533 190 31 . . PUNCT crl-13533 191 1 the the DET crl-13533 191 2 majority majority NOUN crl-13533 191 3 of of ADP crl-13533 191 4 the the DET crl-13533 191 5 appeals appeal NOUN crl-13533 191 6 were be AUX crl-13533 191 7 made make VERB crl-13533 191 8 by by ADP crl-13533 191 9 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 191 10 in in ADP crl-13533 191 11 cataloging catalog VERB crl-13533 191 12 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 191 13 seven seven NUM crl-13533 191 14 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 191 15 , , PUNCT crl-13533 191 16 bibliographer bibliographer NOUN crl-13533 191 17 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 191 18 four four NUM crl-13533 191 19 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 191 20 , , PUNCT crl-13533 191 21 and and CCONJ crl-13533 191 22 reference reference NOUN crl-13533 191 23 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 191 24 nine nine NUM crl-13533 191 25 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 191 26 positions position NOUN crl-13533 191 27 . . PUNCT crl-13533 192 1 the the DET crl-13533 192 2 characteristic characteristic ADJ crl-13533 192 3 comments comment NOUN crl-13533 192 4 made make VERB crl-13533 192 5 are be AUX crl-13533 192 6 summarized summarize VERB crl-13533 192 7 below below ADV crl-13533 192 8 : : PUNCT crl-13533 192 9 catalogers cataloger NOUN crl-13533 192 10 . . PUNCT crl-13533 193 1 they they PRON crl-13533 193 2 generally generally ADV crl-13533 193 3 considered consider VERB crl-13533 193 4 the the DET crl-13533 193 5 cataloging catalog VERB crl-13533 193 6 function function NOUN crl-13533 193 7 to to PART crl-13533 193 8 be be AUX crl-13533 193 9 on on ADP crl-13533 193 10 the the DET crl-13533 193 11 same same ADJ crl-13533 193 12 level level NOUN crl-13533 193 13 as as ADP crl-13533 193 14 the the DET crl-13533 193 15 bibliographer bibliographer NOUN crl-13533 193 16 and and CCONJ crl-13533 193 17 reference reference NOUN crl-13533 193 18 functions function NOUN crl-13533 193 19 . . PUNCT crl-13533 194 1 several several ADJ crl-13533 194 2 felt feel VERB crl-13533 194 3 that that SCONJ crl-13533 194 4 category category NOUN crl-13533 194 5 i i PRON crl-13533 194 6 had have AUX crl-13533 194 7 been be AUX crl-13533 194 8 watered water VERB crl-13533 194 9 down down ADP crl-13533 195 1 b b X crl-13533 195 2 y y PROPN crl-13533 195 3 the the DET crl-13533 195 4 inclusion inclusion NOUN crl-13533 195 5 of of ADP crl-13533 195 6 positions position NOUN crl-13533 195 7 which which PRON crl-13533 195 8 were be AUX crl-13533 195 9 not not PART crl-13533 195 10 " " PUNCT crl-13533 195 11 fully fully ADV crl-13533 195 12 realized realize VERB crl-13533 195 13 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 195 14 positions position NOUN crl-13533 195 15 . . PUNCT crl-13533 195 16 " " PUNCT crl-13533 196 1 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 196 2 the the DET crl-13533 196 3 task task NOUN crl-13533 196 4 force force NOUN crl-13533 196 5 explained explain VERB crl-13533 196 6 that that SCONJ crl-13533 196 7 most most ADJ crl-13533 196 8 of of ADP crl-13533 196 9 these these DET crl-13533 196 10 positions position NOUN crl-13533 196 11 had have AUX crl-13533 196 12 been be AUX crl-13533 196 13 or or CCONJ crl-13533 196 14 were be AUX crl-13533 196 15 in in ADP crl-13533 196 16 the the DET crl-13533 196 17 process process NOUN crl-13533 196 18 of of ADP crl-13533 196 19 being be AUX crl-13533 196 20 phased phase VERB crl-13533 196 21 out out ADP crl-13533 196 22 . . PUNCT crl-13533 196 23 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 197 1 bibliographers bibliographer VERB crl-13533 197 2 . . PUNCT crl-13533 198 1 they they PRON crl-13533 198 2 considered consider VERB crl-13533 198 3 their their PRON crl-13533 198 4 functions function NOUN crl-13533 198 5 to to PART crl-13533 198 6 be be AUX crl-13533 198 7 on on ADP crl-13533 198 8 a a DET crl-13533 198 9 higher high ADJ crl-13533 198 10 level level NOUN crl-13533 198 11 than than ADP crl-13533 198 12 those those PRON crl-13533 198 13 of of ADP crl-13533 198 14 catalogers cataloger NOUN crl-13533 198 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 198 16 reference reference NOUN crl-13533 198 17 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 198 18 because because SCONJ crl-13533 198 19 of of ADP crl-13533 198 20 the the DET crl-13533 198 21 impact impact NOUN crl-13533 198 22 of of ADP crl-13533 198 23 their their PRON crl-13533 198 24 decisions decision NOUN crl-13533 198 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 198 26 their their PRON crl-13533 198 27 language language NOUN crl-13533 198 28 and and CCONJ crl-13533 198 29 subject subject ADJ crl-13533 198 30 qualifications qualification NOUN crl-13533 198 31 , , PUNCT crl-13533 198 32 and and CCONJ crl-13533 198 33 their their PRON crl-13533 198 34 fiscal fiscal ADJ crl-13533 198 35 accountability accountability NOUN crl-13533 198 36 . . PUNCT crl-13533 199 1 reference reference NOUN crl-13533 199 2 librarians librarians PROPN crl-13533 199 3 . . PUNCT crl-13533 200 1 they they PRON crl-13533 200 2 did do AUX crl-13533 200 3 not not PART crl-13533 200 4 want want VERB crl-13533 200 5 to to PART crl-13533 200 6 compare compare VERB crl-13533 200 7 their their PRON crl-13533 200 8 functions function NOUN crl-13533 200 9 to to ADP crl-13533 200 10 those those PRON crl-13533 200 11 of of ADP crl-13533 200 12 bibliographers bibliographer NOUN crl-13533 200 13 and and CCONJ crl-13533 200 14 catalogers cataloger NOUN crl-13533 200 15 because because SCONJ crl-13533 200 16 they they PRON crl-13533 200 17 felt feel VERB crl-13533 200 18 that that SCONJ crl-13533 200 19 they they PRON crl-13533 200 20 did do AUX crl-13533 200 21 not not PART crl-13533 200 22 have have VERB crl-13533 200 23 sufli<;ient sufli<;ient ADJ crl-13533 200 24 information information NOUN crl-13533 200 25 about about ADP crl-13533 200 26 these these DET crl-13533 200 27 positions position NOUN crl-13533 200 28 . . PUNCT crl-13533 201 1 they they PRON crl-13533 201 2 indicated indicate VERB crl-13533 201 3 concern concern NOUN crl-13533 201 4 over over ADP crl-13533 201 5 the the DET crl-13533 201 6 number number NOUN crl-13533 201 7 of of ADP crl-13533 201 8 reader reader NOUN crl-13533 201 9 service service NOUN crl-13533 201 10 positions position NOUN crl-13533 201 11 in in ADP crl-13533 201 12 category category NOUN crl-13533 201 13 i i PRON crl-13533 201 14 and and CCONJ crl-13533 201 15 the the DET crl-13533 201 16 emphasis emphasis NOUN crl-13533 201 17 on on ADP crl-13533 201 18 administrative administrative ADJ crl-13533 201 19 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 201 20 in in ADP crl-13533 201 21 general general ADJ crl-13533 201 22 . . PUNCT crl-13533 202 1 in in ADP crl-13533 202 2 considering consider VERB crl-13533 202 3 the the DET crl-13533 202 4 appeals appeal NOUN crl-13533 202 5 , , PUNCT crl-13533 202 6 the the DET crl-13533 202 7 task task NOUN crl-13533 202 8 force force NOUN crl-13533 202 9 also also ADV crl-13533 202 10 reviewed review VERB crl-13533 202 11 twenty twenty NUM crl-13533 202 12 other other ADJ crl-13533 202 13 positions position NOUN crl-13533 202 14 either either CCONJ crl-13533 202 15 because because SCONJ crl-13533 202 16 they they PRON crl-13533 202 17 were be AUX crl-13533 202 18 comparable comparable ADJ crl-13533 202 19 to to ADP crl-13533 202 20 those those PRON crl-13533 202 21 that that PRON crl-13533 202 22 had have AUX crl-13533 202 23 been be AUX crl-13533 202 24 appealed appeal VERB crl-13533 202 25 or or CCONJ crl-13533 202 26 because because SCONJ crl-13533 202 27 they they PRON crl-13533 202 28 had have AUX crl-13533 202 29 been be AUX crl-13533 202 30 questioned question VERB crl-13533 202 31 by by ADP crl-13533 202 32 one one NUM crl-13533 202 33 or or CCONJ crl-13533 202 34 more more ADJ crl-13533 202 35 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 202 36 during during ADP crl-13533 202 37 the the DET crl-13533 202 38 hearings hearing NOUN crl-13533 202 39 . . PUNCT crl-13533 203 1 forty forty NUM crl-13533 203 2 - - PUNCT crl-13533 203 3 seven seven NUM crl-13533 203 4 positions position NOUN crl-13533 203 5 , , PUNCT crl-13533 203 6 therefore therefore ADV crl-13533 203 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 203 8 were be AUX crl-13533 203 9 reconsidered reconsider VERB crl-13533 203 10 before before SCONJ crl-13533 203 11 the the DET crl-13533 203 12 task task NOUN crl-13533 203 13 force force NOUN crl-13533 203 14 submitted submit VERB crl-13533 203 15 its its PRON crl-13533 203 16 recommendation recommendation NOUN crl-13533 203 17 to to ADP crl-13533 203 18 the the DET crl-13533 203 19 university university NOUN crl-13533 203 20 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 203 21 . . PUNCT crl-13533 204 1 since since SCONJ crl-13533 204 2 the the DET crl-13533 204 3 task task NOUN crl-13533 204 4 force force NOUN crl-13533 204 5 could could AUX crl-13533 204 6 not not PART crl-13533 204 7 reach reach VERB crl-13533 204 8 a a DET crl-13533 204 9 consensus consensus NOUN crl-13533 204 10 on on ADP crl-13533 204 11 certain certain ADJ crl-13533 204 12 positions position NOUN crl-13533 204 13 ~ ~ PUNCT crl-13533 204 14 the the DET crl-13533 204 15 university university NOUN crl-13533 204 16 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 204 17 asked ask VERB crl-13533 204 18 the the DET crl-13533 204 19 directors director NOUN crl-13533 204 20 of of ADP crl-13533 204 21 resources resource NOUN crl-13533 204 22 , , PUNCT crl-13533 204 23 services service NOUN crl-13533 204 24 , , PUNCT crl-13533 204 25 and and CCONJ crl-13533 204 26 support support VERB crl-13533 204 27 to to PART crl-13533 204 28 serve serve VERB crl-13533 204 29 as as ADP crl-13533 204 30 an an DET crl-13533 204 31 ad ad NOUN crl-13533 204 32 hoc hoc X crl-13533 204 33 subcommittee subcommittee NOUN crl-13533 204 34 to to PART crl-13533 204 35 provide provide VERB crl-13533 204 36 the the DET crl-13533 204 37 task task NOUN crl-13533 204 38 force force NOUN crl-13533 204 39 with with ADP crl-13533 204 40 additional additional ADJ crl-13533 204 41 guidance guidance NOUN crl-13533 204 42 . . PUNCT crl-13533 205 1 as as ADP crl-13533 205 2 a a DET crl-13533 205 3 result result NOUN crl-13533 205 4 of of ADP crl-13533 205 5 the the DET crl-13533 205 6 appeals appeal NOUN crl-13533 205 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 205 8 the the DET crl-13533 205 9 input input NOUN crl-13533 205 10 from from ADP crl-13533 205 11 the the DET crl-13533 205 12 subcommittee subcommittee NOUN crl-13533 205 13 and and CCONJ crl-13533 205 14 from from ADP crl-13533 205 15 the the DET crl-13533 205 16 university university NOUN crl-13533 205 17 librarian librarian NOUN crl-13533 205 18 , , PUNCT crl-13533 205 19 four four NUM crl-13533 205 20 positions position NOUN crl-13533 205 21 were be AUX crl-13533 205 22 upgraded upgrade VERB crl-13533 205 23 and and CCONJ crl-13533 205 24 two two NUM crl-13533 205 25 downgraded downgrade VERB crl-13533 205 26 . . PUNCT crl-13533 206 1 the the DET crl-13533 206 2 appellants appellant NOUN crl-13533 206 3 received receive VERB crl-13533 206 4 written write VERB crl-13533 206 5 responses response NOUN crl-13533 206 6 on on ADP crl-13533 206 7 august august PROPN crl-13533 206 8 1 1 NUM crl-13533 206 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 206 10 1974 1974 NUM crl-13533 206 11 . . PUNCT crl-13533 207 1 thus thus ADV crl-13533 207 2 , , PUNCT crl-13533 207 3 the the DET crl-13533 207 4 implementation implementation NOUN crl-13533 207 5 of of ADP crl-13533 207 6 the the DET crl-13533 207 7 system system NOUN crl-13533 207 8 of of ADP crl-13533 207 9 position position NOUN crl-13533 207 10 categories category NOUN crl-13533 207 11 was be AUX crl-13533 207 12 completed complete VERB crl-13533 207 13 two two NUM crl-13533 207 14 years year NOUN crl-13533 207 15 and and CCONJ crl-13533 207 16 four four NUM crl-13533 207 17 months month NOUN crl-13533 207 18 after after SCONJ crl-13533 207 19 the the DET crl-13533 207 20 task task NOUN crl-13533 207 21 force force NOUN crl-13533 207 22 had have AUX crl-13533 207 23 been be AUX crl-13533 207 24 appointed appoint VERB crl-13533 207 25 . . PUNCT crl-13533 208 1 assessment assessment NOUN crl-13533 208 2 of of ADP crl-13533 208 3 the the DET crl-13533 208 4 system system NOUN crl-13533 208 5 of of ADP crl-13533 208 6 position position NOUN crl-13533 208 7 categories category NOUN crl-13533 208 8 there there PRON crl-13533 208 9 has have AUX crl-13533 208 10 been be AUX crl-13533 208 11 no no DET crl-13533 208 12 formal formal ADJ crl-13533 208 13 assessment assessment NOUN crl-13533 208 14 of of ADP crl-13533 208 15 the the DET crl-13533 208 16 system system NOUN crl-13533 208 17 of of ADP crl-13533 208 18 position position NOUN crl-13533 208 19 categories category NOUN crl-13533 208 20 during during ADP crl-13533 208 21 the the DET crl-13533 208 22 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 208 23 i i PRON crl-13533 208 24 303 303 NUM crl-13533 208 25 past past ADP crl-13533 208 26 five five NUM crl-13533 208 27 years year NOUN crl-13533 208 28 . . PUNCT crl-13533 209 1 mechanisms mechanism NOUN crl-13533 209 2 do do AUX crl-13533 209 3 exist exist VERB crl-13533 209 4 for for ADP crl-13533 209 5 reviewing review VERB crl-13533 209 6 positions position NOUN crl-13533 209 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 209 8 and and CCONJ crl-13533 209 9 changes change NOUN crl-13533 209 10 are be AUX crl-13533 209 11 made make VERB crl-13533 209 12 when when SCONJ crl-13533 209 13 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 209 14 change change VERB crl-13533 209 15 significantly significantly ADV crl-13533 209 16 . . PUNCT crl-13533 210 1 we we PRON crl-13533 210 2 expect expect VERB crl-13533 210 3 that that SCONJ crl-13533 210 4 in in ADP crl-13533 210 5 the the DET crl-13533 210 6 next next ADJ crl-13533 210 7 year year NOUN crl-13533 210 8 we we PRON crl-13533 210 9 shall shall AUX crl-13533 210 10 be be AUX crl-13533 210 11 able able ADJ crl-13533 210 12 to to PART crl-13533 210 13 conduct conduct VERB crl-13533 210 14 a a DET crl-13533 210 15 major major ADJ crl-13533 210 16 review review NOUN crl-13533 210 17 of of ADP crl-13533 210 18 the the DET crl-13533 210 19 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 210 20 to to PART crl-13533 210 21 determine determine VERB crl-13533 210 22 if if SCONJ crl-13533 210 23 it it PRON crl-13533 210 24 continues continue VERB crl-13533 210 25 adequately adequately ADV crl-13533 210 26 to to PART crl-13533 210 27 reflect reflect VERB crl-13533 210 28 the the DET crl-13533 210 29 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 210 30 of of ADP crl-13533 210 31 the the DET crl-13533 210 32 various various ADJ crl-13533 210 33 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 210 34 in in ADP crl-13533 210 35 the the DET crl-13533 210 36 library library NOUN crl-13533 210 37 system system NOUN crl-13533 210 38 . . PUNCT crl-13533 211 1 conclusion conclusion VERB crl-13533 211 2 the the DET crl-13533 211 3 two two NUM crl-13533 211 4 - - PUNCT crl-13533 211 5 track track NOUN crl-13533 211 6 system system NOUN crl-13533 211 7 described describe VERB crl-13533 211 8 in in ADP crl-13533 211 9 this this DET crl-13533 211 10 paper paper NOUN crl-13533 211 11 evolved evolve VERB crl-13533 211 12 during during ADP crl-13533 211 13 a a DET crl-13533 211 14 period period NOUN crl-13533 211 15 of of ADP crl-13533 211 16 major major ADJ crl-13533 211 17 change change NOUN crl-13533 211 18 in in ADP crl-13533 211 19 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 211 20 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-13533 211 21 and and CCONJ crl-13533 211 22 considerable considerable ADJ crl-13533 211 23 conflict conflict NOUN crl-13533 211 24 at at ADP crl-13533 211 25 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 211 26 university university PROPN crl-13533 211 27 . . PUNCT crl-13533 212 1 a a DET crl-13533 212 2 key key ADJ crl-13533 212 3 element element NOUN crl-13533 212 4 in in ADP crl-13533 212 5 the the DET crl-13533 212 6 development development NOUN crl-13533 212 7 of of ADP crl-13533 212 8 the the DET crl-13533 212 9 system system NOUN crl-13533 212 10 of of ADP crl-13533 212 11 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 212 12 and and CCONJ crl-13533 212 13 position position NOUN crl-13533 212 14 categories category NOUN crl-13533 212 15 was be AUX crl-13533 212 16 the the DET crl-13533 212 17 concern concern NOUN crl-13533 212 18 of of ADP crl-13533 212 19 significant significant ADJ crl-13533 212 20 numbers number NOUN crl-13533 212 21 of of ADP crl-13533 212 22 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 212 23 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 212 24 at at ADP crl-13533 212 25 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 212 26 for for ADP crl-13533 212 27 a a DET crl-13533 212 28 system system NOUN crl-13533 212 29 of of ADP crl-13533 212 30 organization organization NOUN crl-13533 212 31 that that PRON crl-13533 212 32 would would AUX crl-13533 212 33 both both PRON crl-13533 212 34 acknowledge acknowledge VERB crl-13533 212 35 the the DET crl-13533 212 36 nature nature NOUN crl-13533 212 37 of of ADP crl-13533 212 38 their their PRON crl-13533 212 39 duties duty NOUN crl-13533 212 40 and and CCONJ crl-13533 212 41 responsibilities responsibility NOUN crl-13533 212 42 and and CCONJ crl-13533 212 43 their their PRON crl-13533 212 44 individual individual ADJ crl-13533 212 45 contributions contribution NOUN crl-13533 212 46 in in ADP crl-13533 212 47 providing provide VERB crl-13533 212 48 a a DET crl-13533 212 49 truly truly ADV crl-13533 212 50 high high ADJ crl-13533 212 51 level level NOUN crl-13533 212 52 of of ADP crl-13533 212 53 library library NOUN crl-13533 212 54 service service NOUN crl-13533 212 55 . . PUNCT crl-13533 213 1 the the DET crl-13533 213 2 most most ADV crl-13533 213 3 significant significant ADJ crl-13533 213 4 aspect aspect NOUN crl-13533 213 5 of of ADP crl-13533 213 6 the the DET crl-13533 213 7 two two NUM crl-13533 213 8 elements element NOUN crl-13533 213 9 of of ADP crl-13533 213 10 the the DET crl-13533 213 11 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 213 12 organization organization NOUN crl-13533 213 13 is be AUX crl-13533 213 14 the the DET crl-13533 213 15 system system NOUN crl-13533 213 16 of of ADP crl-13533 213 17 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 213 18 and and CCONJ crl-13533 213 19 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 213 20 review review NOUN crl-13533 213 21 , , PUNCT crl-13533 213 22 which which PRON crl-13533 213 23 encourages encourage VERB crl-13533 213 24 higher high ADJ crl-13533 213 25 standards standard NOUN crl-13533 213 26 of of ADP crl-13533 213 27 performance performance NOUN crl-13533 213 28 and and CCONJ crl-13533 213 29 provides provide VERB crl-13533 213 30 a a DET crl-13533 213 31 means mean NOUN crl-13533 213 32 for for ADP crl-13533 213 33 acknowledging acknowledging NOUN crl-13533 213 34 and and CCONJ crl-13533 213 35 rewarding reward VERB crl-13533 213 36 such such ADJ crl-13533 213 37 contributions contribution NOUN crl-13533 213 38 . . PUNCT crl-13533 214 1 the the DET crl-13533 214 2 success success NOUN crl-13533 214 3 of of ADP crl-13533 214 4 the the DET crl-13533 214 5 system system NOUN crl-13533 214 6 of of ADP crl-13533 214 7 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 214 8 depends depend VERB crl-13533 214 9 to to ADP crl-13533 214 10 a a DET crl-13533 214 11 large large ADJ crl-13533 214 12 degree degree NOUN crl-13533 214 13 on on ADP crl-13533 214 14 the the DET crl-13533 214 15 perceptions perception NOUN crl-13533 214 16 and and CCONJ crl-13533 214 17 standards standard NOUN crl-13533 214 18 of of ADP crl-13533 214 19 the the DET crl-13533 214 20 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 214 21 review review NOUN crl-13533 214 22 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 214 23 . . PUNCT crl-13533 215 1 fortunately fortunately ADV crl-13533 215 2 , , PUNCT crl-13533 215 3 the the DET crl-13533 215 4 various various ADJ crl-13533 215 5 members member NOUN crl-13533 215 6 of of ADP crl-13533 215 7 the the DET crl-13533 215 8 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 215 9 development development NOUN crl-13533 215 10 and and CCONJ crl-13533 215 11 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 215 12 review review NOUN crl-13533 215 13 committees committee NOUN crl-13533 215 14 have have AUX crl-13533 215 15 demonstrated demonstrate VERB crl-13533 215 16 their their PRON crl-13533 215 17 commitment commitment NOUN crl-13533 215 18 to to ADP crl-13533 215 19 the the DET crl-13533 215 20 objectives objective NOUN crl-13533 215 21 of of ADP crl-13533 215 22 the the DET crl-13533 215 23 system system NOUN crl-13533 215 24 of of ADP crl-13533 215 25 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 215 26 in in ADP crl-13533 215 27 their their PRON crl-13533 215 28 administration administration NOUN crl-13533 215 29 of of ADP crl-13533 215 30 the the DET crl-13533 215 31 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 215 32 review review NOUN crl-13533 215 33 process process NOUN crl-13533 215 34 . . PUNCT crl-13533 216 1 the the DET crl-13533 216 2 chairs chair NOUN crl-13533 216 3 of of ADP crl-13533 216 4 these these DET crl-13533 216 5 committees committee NOUN crl-13533 216 6 deserve deserve VERB crl-13533 216 7 particular particular ADJ crl-13533 216 8 appreciation appreciation NOUN crl-13533 216 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 216 10 not not PART crl-13533 216 11 only only ADV crl-13533 216 12 for for ADP crl-13533 216 13 their their PRON crl-13533 216 14 contributions contribution NOUN crl-13533 216 15 to to ADP crl-13533 216 16 the the DET crl-13533 216 17 ranking rank VERB crl-13533 216 18 system system NOUN crl-13533 216 19 , , PUNCT crl-13533 216 20 but but CCONJ crl-13533 216 21 also also ADV crl-13533 216 22 for for ADP crl-13533 216 23 the the DET crl-13533 216 24 text text NOUN crl-13533 216 25 of of ADP crl-13533 216 26 significant significant ADJ crl-13533 216 27 parts part NOUN crl-13533 216 28 of of ADP crl-13533 216 29 this this DET crl-13533 216 30 article article NOUN crl-13533 216 31 : : PUNCT crl-13533 216 32 joyce joyce PROPN crl-13533 216 33 d. d. PROPN crl-13533 216 34 veenstra veenstra PROPN crl-13533 216 35 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 216 36 1972 1972 NUM crl-13533 216 37 - - SYM crl-13533 216 38 75 75 NUM crl-13533 216 39 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 216 40 , , PUNCT crl-13533 216 41 ruth ruth PROPN crl-13533 216 42 b. b. PROPN crl-13533 216 43 gibbs gibbs PROPN crl-13533 216 44 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 216 45 1975 1975 NUM crl-13533 216 46 - - SYM crl-13533 216 47 76 76 NUM crl-13533 216 48 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 216 49 , , PUNCT crl-13533 216 50 carol carol PROPN crl-13533 216 51 a. a. NOUN crl-13533 216 52 mandel mandel PROPN crl-13533 216 53 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 216 54 197~ 197~ NUM crl-13533 216 55 77 77 NUM crl-13533 216 56 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 216 57 , , PUNCT crl-13533 216 58 ann ann PROPN crl-13533 216 59 l. l. PROPN crl-13533 216 60 wood wood PROPN crl-13533 216 61 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 216 62 1977 1977 NUM crl-13533 216 63 - - SYM crl-13533 216 64 78 78 NUM crl-13533 216 65 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 216 66 , , PUNCT crl-13533 216 67 pamela pamela PROPN crl-13533 216 68 w. w. PROPN crl-13533 216 69 darling darling PROPN crl-13533 216 70 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 216 71 1978 1978 NUM crl-13533 216 72 - - SYM crl-13533 216 73 79 79 NUM crl-13533 216 74 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 216 75 , , PUNCT crl-13533 216 76 and and CCONJ crl-13533 216 77 ellen ellen ADJ crl-13533 216 78 nagle nagle NOUN crl-13533 216 79 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 216 80 197980 197980 NUM crl-13533 216 81 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 216 82 . . PUNCT crl-13533 217 1 references reference NOUN crl-13533 217 2 l. l. ADP crl-13533 217 3 the the DET crl-13533 217 4 cox cox PROPN crl-13533 217 5 commission commission PROPN crl-13533 217 6 report report NOUN crl-13533 217 7 : : PUNCT crl-13533 217 8 crisis crisis NOUN crl-13533 217 9 at at ADP crl-13533 217 10 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 217 11 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 217 12 new new PROPN crl-13533 217 13 york york PROPN crl-13533 217 14 : : PUNCT crl-13533 217 15 vintage vintage NOUN crl-13533 217 16 books book NOUN crl-13533 217 17 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 18 1968 1968 NUM crl-13533 217 19 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 217 20 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 21 p.l93 p.l93 PROPN crl-13533 217 22 . . PROPN crl-13533 217 23 2 2 NUM crl-13533 217 24 . . PROPN crl-13533 217 25 gwendolyn gwendolyn PROPN crl-13533 217 26 cruzat cruzat PROPN crl-13533 217 27 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 28 " " PUNCT crl-13533 217 29 issues issue NOUN crl-13533 217 30 and and CCONJ crl-13533 217 31 strategies strategy NOUN crl-13533 217 32 for for ADP crl-13533 217 33 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 217 34 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 217 35 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 36 " " PUNCT crl-13533 217 37 in in ADP crl-13533 217 38 collective collective ADJ crl-13533 217 39 bargain304 bargain304 PROPN crl-13533 217 40 i i PROPN crl-13533 217 41 college college PROPN crl-13533 217 42 & & CCONJ crl-13533 217 43 research research PROPN crl-13533 217 44 libraries librarie VERB crl-13533 217 45 • • ADJ crl-13533 217 46 july july PROPN crl-13533 217 47 1980 1980 NUM crl-13533 217 48 ing ing NOUN crl-13533 217 49 in in ADP crl-13533 217 50 higher high ADJ crl-13533 217 51 education education NOUN crl-13533 217 52 : : PUNCT crl-13533 217 53 its its PRON crl-13533 217 54 implications implication NOUN crl-13533 217 55 for for ADP crl-13533 217 56 governance governance NOUN crl-13533 217 57 and and CCONJ crl-13533 217 58 faculty faculty NOUN crl-13533 217 59 status status NOUN crl-13533 217 60 for for ADP crl-13533 217 61 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 217 62 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 63 proceedings proceeding NOUN crl-13533 217 64 of of ADP crl-13533 217 65 a a DET crl-13533 217 66 preconference preconference PROPN crl-13533 217 67 institute institute NOUN crl-13533 217 68 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 69 sponsored sponsor VERB crl-13533 217 70 by by ADP crl-13533 217 71 the the DET crl-13533 217 72 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 217 73 status status NOUN crl-13533 217 74 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 217 75 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 76 association association NOUN crl-13533 217 77 of of ADP crl-13533 217 78 college college NOUN crl-13533 217 79 and and CCONJ crl-13533 217 80 research research NOUN crl-13533 217 81 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 217 82 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 83 american american PROPN crl-13533 217 84 library library PROPN crl-13533 217 85 association association PROPN crl-13533 217 86 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 87 san san PROPN crl-13533 217 88 francisco francisco PROPN crl-13533 217 89 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 90 june june PROPN crl-13533 217 91 27 27 NUM crl-13533 217 92 and and CCONJ crl-13533 217 93 28 28 NUM crl-13533 217 94 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 95 1975 1975 NUM crl-13533 217 96 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 217 97 chicago chicago PROPN crl-13533 217 98 : : PUNCT crl-13533 217 99 american american PROPN crl-13533 217 100 library library PROPN crl-13533 217 101 assn assn PROPN crl-13533 217 102 . . PUNCT crl-13533 217 103 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 104 1976 1976 NUM crl-13533 217 105 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 217 106 , , PUNCT crl-13533 217 107 p.104 p.104 PROPN crl-13533 217 108 . . PUNCT crl-13533 218 1 3 3 X crl-13533 218 2 . . PUNCT crl-13533 219 1 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 219 2 university university PROPN crl-13533 219 3 , , PUNCT crl-13533 219 4 charters charter NOUN crl-13533 219 5 and and CCONJ crl-13533 219 6 statutes statute NOUN crl-13533 219 7 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 219 8 new new PROPN crl-13533 219 9 york york PROPN crl-13533 219 10 : : PUNCT crl-13533 219 11 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 219 12 univ univ PROPN crl-13533 219 13 . . PROPN crl-13533 219 14 , , PUNCT crl-13533 219 15 1911 1911 NUM crl-13533 219 16 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 219 17 , , PUNCT crl-13533 219 18 p p NOUN crl-13533 219 19 .22 .22 NUM crl-13533 219 20 . . PUNCT crl-13533 220 1 4 4 X crl-13533 220 2 . . PROPN crl-13533 220 3 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 220 4 university university PROPN crl-13533 220 5 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 220 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 220 7 study study NOUN crl-13533 220 8 . . PUNCT crl-13533 221 1 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 221 2 , , PUNCT crl-13533 221 3 " " PUNCT crl-13533 221 4 statement statement NOUN crl-13533 221 5 of of ADP crl-13533 221 6 principles principle NOUN crl-13533 221 7 , , PUNCT crl-13533 221 8 " " PUNCT crl-13533 221 9 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 221 10 university university PROPN crl-13533 221 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 221 12 oct oct PROPN crl-13533 221 13 . . PROPN crl-13533 221 14 31 31 NUM crl-13533 221 15 , , PUNCT crl-13533 221 16 1968 1968 NUM crl-13533 221 17 . . PUNCT crl-13533 222 1 members member NOUN crl-13533 222 2 of of ADP crl-13533 222 3 the the DET crl-13533 222 4 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 222 5 at at ADP crl-13533 222 6 the the DET crl-13533 222 7 time time NOUN crl-13533 222 8 were be AUX crl-13533 222 9 donald donald PROPN crl-13533 222 10 c. c. PROPN crl-13533 222 11 anthony anthony PROPN crl-13533 222 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 222 13 c c PROPN crl-13533 222 14 . . PUNCT crl-13533 223 1 donald donald PROPN crl-13533 223 2 cook cook PROPN crl-13533 223 3 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 223 4 chair chair NOUN crl-13533 223 5 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 223 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 223 7 frederick frederick PROPN crl-13533 223 8 duda duda PROPN crl-13533 223 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 223 10 paul paul PROPN crl-13533 223 11 j. j. PROPN crl-13533 223 12 fasana fasana PROPN crl-13533 223 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 223 14 cecile cecile ADJ crl-13533 223 15 e e NOUN crl-13533 223 16 . . PUNCT crl-13533 224 1 kramer kramer PROPN crl-13533 224 2 , , PUNCT crl-13533 224 3 carol carol PROPN crl-13533 224 4 l. l. PROPN crl-13533 224 5 learmont learmont PROPN crl-13533 224 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 224 7 adolf adolf PROPN crl-13533 224 8 k. k. PROPN crl-13533 224 9 placzek placzek PROPN crl-13533 224 10 , , PUNCT crl-13533 224 11 edwin edwin PROPN crl-13533 224 12 schuck schuck VERB crl-13533 224 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 224 14 and and CCONJ crl-13533 224 15 darrow darrow VERB crl-13533 224 16 wood wood NOUN crl-13533 224 17 . . PUNCT crl-13533 225 1 5 5 X crl-13533 225 2 . . X crl-13533 225 3 organization organization NOUN crl-13533 225 4 and and CCONJ crl-13533 225 5 staffing staffing NOUN crl-13533 225 6 of of ADP crl-13533 225 7 the the DET crl-13533 225 8 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 225 9 of of ADP crl-13533 225 10 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 225 11 uni uni PROPN crl-13533 225 12 v v ADP crl-13533 225 13 ersity ersity NOUN crl-13533 225 14 : : PUNCT crl-13533 225 15 a a DET crl-13533 225 16 case case NOUN crl-13533 225 17 study study NOUN crl-13533 225 18 . . PUNCT crl-13533 226 1 prepared prepare VERB crl-13533 226 2 by by ADP crl-13533 226 3 booz booz NOUN crl-13533 226 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 226 5 allen allen PROPN crl-13533 226 6 & & CCONJ crl-13533 226 7 hamilton hamilton PROPN crl-13533 226 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 226 9 inc inc PROPN crl-13533 226 10 . . PROPN crl-13533 226 11 sponsored sponsor VERB crl-13533 226 12 by by ADP crl-13533 226 13 the the DET crl-13533 226 14 association association NOUN crl-13533 226 15 of of ADP crl-13533 226 16 research research NOUN crl-13533 226 17 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 226 18 in in ADP crl-13533 226 19 cooperation cooperation NOUN crl-13533 226 20 with with ADP crl-13533 226 21 the the DET crl-13533 226 22 american american PROPN crl-13533 226 23 council council PROPN crl-13533 226 24 of of ADP crl-13533 226 25 education education NOUN crl-13533 226 26 under under ADP crl-13533 226 27 a a DET crl-13533 226 28 grant grant NOUN crl-13533 226 29 from from ADP crl-13533 226 30 the the DET crl-13533 226 31 council council NOUN crl-13533 226 32 on on ADP crl-13533 226 33 library library NOUN crl-13533 226 34 resources resource NOUN crl-13533 226 35 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 226 36 westport westport PROPN crl-13533 226 37 , , PUNCT crl-13533 226 38 conn conn PROPN crl-13533 226 39 . . PUNCT crl-13533 226 40 : : PUNCT crl-13533 227 1 redgrave redgrave PROPN crl-13533 227 2 information information PROPN crl-13533 227 3 resources resources PROPN crl-13533 227 4 corp corp PROPN crl-13533 227 5 . . PROPN crl-13533 227 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 227 7 1973 1973 NUM crl-13533 227 8 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 227 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 227 10 p p NOUN crl-13533 227 11 .85 .85 NUM crl-13533 227 12 . . PUNCT crl-13533 228 1 6 6 NUM crl-13533 228 2 . . X crl-13533 228 3 donald donald PROPN crl-13533 228 4 f f PROPN crl-13533 228 5 . . PUNCT crl-13533 229 1 cam cam VERB crl-13533 229 2 e e PROPN crl-13533 229 3 ron ron PROPN crl-13533 229 4 and and CCONJ crl-13533 229 5 pegg pegg VERB crl-13533 229 6 y y PROPN crl-13533 229 7 heim heim PROPN crl-13533 229 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 229 9 librarians librarian VERB crl-13533 229 10 in in ADP crl-13533 229 11 higher high ADJ crl-13533 229 12 education education NOUN crl-13533 229 13 : : PUNCT crl-13533 229 14 their their PRON crl-13533 229 15 compensation compensation NOUN crl-13533 229 16 structures structure NOUN crl-13533 229 17 for for ADP crl-13533 229 18 the the DET crl-13533 229 19 academic academic ADJ crl-13533 229 20 year year NOUN crl-13533 229 21 1972 1972 NUM crl-13533 229 22 - - SYM crl-13533 229 23 73 73 NUM crl-13533 229 24 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 229 25 washington washington PROPN crl-13533 229 26 , , PUNCT crl-13533 229 27 d.c d.c PROPN crl-13533 229 28 . . PROPN crl-13533 229 29 : : PUNCT crl-13533 230 1 council council NOUN crl-13533 230 2 on on ADP crl-13533 230 3 library library NOUN crl-13533 230 4 resources resource NOUN crl-13533 230 5 , , PUNCT crl-13533 230 6 1974 1974 NUM crl-13533 230 7 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 230 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 230 9 p.13 p.13 PUNCT crl-13533 230 10 - - SYM crl-13533 230 11 14 14 NUM crl-13533 230 12 . . NUM crl-13533 231 1 7 7 NUM crl-13533 231 2 . . X crl-13533 231 3 organization organization NOUN crl-13533 231 4 and and CCONJ crl-13533 231 5 staffing staffing NOUN crl-13533 231 6 of of ADP crl-13533 231 7 the the DET crl-13533 231 8 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 231 9 of of ADP crl-13533 231 10 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 231 11 university university PROPN crl-13533 231 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 231 13 p.91 p.91 PROPN crl-13533 231 14 . . PROPN crl-13533 232 1 8 8 X crl-13533 232 2 . . X crl-13533 232 3 ibid ibid PROPN crl-13533 232 4 . . PUNCT crl-13533 232 5 , , PUNCT crl-13533 232 6 p.14~. p.14~. PROPN crl-13533 232 7 9 9 NUM crl-13533 232 8 . . PROPN crl-13533 232 9 duke duke PROPN crl-13533 232 10 university university PROPN crl-13533 232 11 library library PROPN crl-13533 232 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 232 13 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 232 14 on on ADP crl-13533 232 15 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 232 16 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 232 17 structure structure NOUN crl-13533 232 18 , , PUNCT crl-13533 232 19 " " PUNCT crl-13533 232 20 ranking rank VERB crl-13533 232 21 structure structure NOUN crl-13533 232 22 for for ADP crl-13533 232 23 duke duke PROPN crl-13533 232 24 university university PROPN crl-13533 232 25 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 232 26 , , PUNCT crl-13533 232 27 " " PUNCT crl-13533 232 28 duke duke PROPN crl-13533 232 29 u u PROPN crl-13533 232 30 niversity niversity NOUN crl-13533 232 31 library library PROPN crl-13533 232 32 , , PUNCT crl-13533 232 33 may may AUX crl-13533 232 34 20 20 NUM crl-13533 232 35 , , PUNCT crl-13533 232 36 1974 1974 NUM crl-13533 232 37 , , PUNCT crl-13533 232 38 revised revise VERB crl-13533 232 39 oct oct PROPN crl-13533 232 40 . . PUNCT crl-13533 233 1 13 13 NUM crl-13533 233 2 , , PUNCT crl-13533 233 3 1977 1977 NUM crl-13533 233 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 233 5 p.4 p.4 PROPN crl-13533 233 6 . . PUNCT crl-13533 234 1 in in ADP crl-13533 234 2 developin'g developin'g PROPN crl-13533 234 3 its its PRON crl-13533 234 4 criteria criterion NOUN crl-13533 234 5 for for ADP crl-13533 234 6 promotion promotion NOUN crl-13533 234 7 in in ADP crl-13533 234 8 rank rank NOUN crl-13533 234 9 , , PUNCT crl-13533 234 10 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 234 11 drew draw VERB crl-13533 234 12 heavily heavily ADV crl-13533 234 13 from from ADP crl-13533 234 14 the the DET crl-13533 234 15 duke duke NOUN crl-13533 234 16 document document NOUN crl-13533 234 17 . . PUNCT crl-13533 235 1 10 10 NUM crl-13533 235 2 . . PROPN crl-13533 235 3 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 235 4 university university PROPN crl-13533 235 5 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 235 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 235 7 " " PUNCT crl-13533 235 8 the the DET crl-13533 235 9 system system NOUN crl-13533 235 10 of of ADP crl-13533 235 11 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 235 12 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 235 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 235 14 " " PUNCT crl-13533 235 15 in in ADP crl-13533 235 16 " " PUNCT crl-13533 235 17 handbook handbook NOUN crl-13533 235 18 for for ADP crl-13533 235 19 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 235 20 , , PUNCT crl-13533 235 21 " " PUNCT crl-13533 235 22 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 235 23 university university PROPN crl-13533 235 24 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 235 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 235 26 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 235 27 review review NOUN crl-13533 235 28 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 235 29 , , PUNCT crl-13533 235 30 june june PROPN crl-13533 235 31 1979 1979 NUM crl-13533 235 32 . . PUNCT crl-13533 236 1 this this DET crl-13533 236 2 section section NOUN crl-13533 236 3 , , PUNCT crl-13533 236 4 which which PRON crl-13533 236 5 describes describe VERB crl-13533 236 6 the the DET crl-13533 236 7 peer peer NOUN crl-13533 236 8 review review NOUN crl-13533 236 9 process process NOUN crl-13533 236 10 and and CCONJ crl-13533 236 11 the the DET crl-13533 236 12 element element NOUN crl-13533 236 13 of of ADP crl-13533 236 14 confidentiality confidentiality NOUN crl-13533 236 15 , , PUNCT crl-13533 236 16 was be AUX crl-13533 236 17 written write VERB crl-13533 236 18 primarily primarily ADV crl-13533 236 19 by by ADP crl-13533 236 20 pamela pamela PROPN crl-13533 236 21 w. w. PROPN crl-13533 236 22 darling darling PROPN crl-13533 236 23 , , PUNCT crl-13533 236 24 chair chair NOUN crl-13533 236 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 236 26 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 236 27 review review NOUN crl-13533 236 28 committee committee NOUN crl-13533 236 29 , , PUNCT crl-13533 236 30 197879 197879 NUM crl-13533 236 31 . . PUNCT crl-13533 237 1 she she PRON crl-13533 237 2 was be AUX crl-13533 237 3 assisted assist VERB crl-13533 237 4 by by ADP crl-13533 237 5 mary mary PROPN crl-13533 237 6 lou lou PROPN crl-13533 237 7 lucy lucy PROPN crl-13533 237 8 , , PUNCT crl-13533 237 9 ellen ellen PROPN crl-13533 237 10 nagle nagle PROPN crl-13533 237 11 , , PUNCT crl-13533 237 12 thomas thomas PROPN crl-13533 237 13 t. t. PROPN crl-13533 237 14 watkins watkins PROPN crl-13533 237 15 , , PUNCT crl-13533 237 16 and and CCONJ crl-13533 237 17 elizabeth elizabeth PROPN crl-13533 237 18 a. a. PROPN crl-13533 237 19 widenmann widenmann PROPN crl-13533 237 20 . . PUNCT crl-13533 238 1 11 11 NUM crl-13533 238 2 . . PROPN crl-13533 238 3 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 238 4 university university PROPN crl-13533 238 5 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 238 6 , , PUNCT crl-13533 238 7 " " PUNCT crl-13533 238 8 the the DET crl-13533 238 9 system system NOUN crl-13533 238 10 of of ADP crl-13533 238 11 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 238 12 ranks rank NOUN crl-13533 238 13 , , PUNCT crl-13533 238 14 " " PUNCT crl-13533 238 15 in in ADP crl-13533 238 16 " " PUNCT crl-13533 238 17 handbook handbook NOUN crl-13533 238 18 for for ADP crl-13533 238 19 librarians librarian NOUN crl-13533 238 20 , , PUNCT crl-13533 238 21 " " PUNCT crl-13533 238 22 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 238 23 university university PROPN crl-13533 238 24 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 238 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 238 26 staff staff NOUN crl-13533 238 27 development development PROPN crl-13533 238 28 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 238 29 , , PUNCT crl-13533 238 30 nov nov PROPN crl-13533 238 31 . . PUNCT crl-13533 239 1 1973 1973 NUM crl-13533 239 2 . . PUNCT crl-13533 240 1 members member NOUN crl-13533 240 2 of of ADP crl-13533 240 3 the the DET crl-13533 240 4 staff staff PROPN crl-13533 240 5 development development PROPN crl-13533 240 6 committee committee PROPN crl-13533 240 7 in in ADP crl-13533 240 8 1973 1973 NUM crl-13533 240 9 - - SYM crl-13533 240 10 74 74 NUM crl-13533 240 11 were be AUX crl-13533 240 12 ann ann PROPN crl-13533 240 13 borsuk borsuk PROPN crl-13533 240 14 , , PUNCT crl-13533 240 15 james james PROPN crl-13533 240 16 e. e. PROPN crl-13533 240 17 fall fall PROPN crl-13533 240 18 , , PUNCT crl-13533 240 19 ruth ruth PROPN crl-13533 240 20 b. b. PROPN crl-13533 240 21 gibbs gibbs PROPN crl-13533 240 22 , , PUNCT crl-13533 240 23 judith judith PROPN crl-13533 240 24 herschman herschman PROPN crl-13533 240 25 , , PUNCT crl-13533 240 26 and and CCONJ crl-13533 240 27 joyce joyce PROPN crl-13533 240 28 d. d. PROPN crl-13533 240 29 veenstra veenstra PROPN crl-13533 240 30 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 240 31 chair chair NOUN crl-13533 240 32 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 240 33 . . PUNCT crl-13533 241 1 12 12 NUM crl-13533 241 2 . . PUNCT crl-13533 242 1 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 242 2 university university PROPN crl-13533 242 3 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 242 4 , , PUNCT crl-13533 242 5 " " PUNCT crl-13533 242 6 the the DET crl-13533 242 7 system system NOUN crl-13533 242 8 of of ADP crl-13533 242 9 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 242 10 position position NOUN crl-13533 242 11 categories category NOUN crl-13533 242 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 242 13 " " PUNCT crl-13533 242 14 columbia columbia PROPN crl-13533 242 15 university university PROPN crl-13533 242 16 libraries library NOUN crl-13533 242 17 , , PUNCT crl-13533 242 18 professional professional ADJ crl-13533 242 19 classification classification NOUN crl-13533 242 20 task task NOUN crl-13533 242 21 force force NOUN crl-13533 242 22 , , PUNCT crl-13533 242 23 dec dec PROPN crl-13533 242 24 . . PROPN crl-13533 242 25 1973 1973 NUM crl-13533 242 26 . . PUNCT crl-13533 243 1 members member NOUN crl-13533 243 2 of of ADP crl-13533 243 3 the the DET crl-13533 243 4 task task NOUN crl-13533 243 5 force force NOUN crl-13533 243 6 at at ADP crl-13533 243 7 the the DET crl-13533 243 8 time time NOUN crl-13533 243 9 were be AUX crl-13533 243 10 laura laura PROPN crl-13533 243 11 cummings cumming NOUN crl-13533 243 12 , , PUNCT crl-13533 243 13 frederick frederick PROPN crl-13533 243 14 duda duda PROPN crl-13533 243 15 ( ( PUNCT crl-13533 243 16 chair chair NOUN crl-13533 243 17 ) ) PUNCT crl-13533 243 18 , , PUNCT crl-13533 243 19 rita rita PROPN crl-13533 243 20 g. g. PROPN crl-13533 243 21 keckeissen keckeissen PROPN crl-13533 243 22 , , PUNCT crl-13533 243 23 cecile cecile ADJ crl-13533 243 24 e. e. PROPN crl-13533 243 25 kramer kramer PROPN crl-13533 243 26 , , PUNCT crl-13533 243 27 helen helen PROPN crl-13533 243 28 m. m. PROPN crl-13533 243 29 selesky selesky PROPN crl-13533 243 30 , , PUNCT crl-13533 243 31 and and CCONJ crl-13533 243 32 thomas thomas PROPN crl-13533 243 33 t. t. PROPN crl-13533 243 34 watkins watkins PROPN crl-13533 243 35 . . PUNCT