id sid tid token lemma pos crl-14593 1 1 college college NOUN crl-14593 1 2 and and CCONJ crl-14593 1 3 research research NOUN crl-14593 1 4 libraries library NOUN crl-14593 1 5 setting set VERB crl-14593 1 6 and and CCONJ crl-14593 1 7 goes go VERB crl-14593 1 8 on on ADP crl-14593 1 9 to to PART crl-14593 1 10 discuss discuss VERB crl-14593 1 11 the the DET crl-14593 1 12 changes change NOUN crl-14593 1 13 in in ADP crl-14593 1 14 the the DET crl-14593 1 15 philosophy philosophy NOUN crl-14593 1 16 governing govern VERB crl-14593 1 17 development development NOUN crl-14593 1 18 and and CCONJ crl-14593 1 19 use use NOUN crl-14593 1 20 of of ADP crl-14593 1 21 the the DET crl-14593 1 22 collection collection NOUN crl-14593 1 23 under under ADP crl-14593 1 24 its its PRON crl-14593 1 25 early early ADJ crl-14593 1 26 li­ li­ NOUN crl-14593 1 27 brarians brarian NOUN crl-14593 1 28 , , PUNCT crl-14593 1 29 joseph joseph PROPN crl-14593 1 30 quincy quincy PROPN crl-14593 1 31 adams adams PROPN crl-14593 1 32 and and CCONJ crl-14593 1 33 louis louis PROPN crl-14593 1 34 b. b. PROPN crl-14593 1 35 wright wright PROPN crl-14593 1 36 . . PUNCT crl-14593 2 1 he he PRON crl-14593 2 2 reminds remind VERB crl-14593 2 3 us we PRON crl-14593 2 4 that that SCONJ crl-14593 2 5 " " PUNCT crl-14593 2 6 special­ special­ NOUN crl-14593 2 7 ized ize VERB crl-14593 2 8 research research NOUN crl-14593 2 9 libraries library NOUN crl-14593 2 10 exert exert VERB crl-14593 2 11 a a DET crl-14593 2 12 shaping shape VERB crl-14593 2 13 in­ in­ NOUN crl-14593 2 14 fluence fluence NOUN crl-14593 2 15 on on ADP crl-14593 2 16 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-14593 2 17 research research NOUN crl-14593 2 18 through through ADP crl-14593 2 19 pol­ pol­ NOUN crl-14593 2 20 icies icie NOUN crl-14593 2 21 that that PRON crl-14593 2 22 decide decide VERB crl-14593 2 23 not not PART crl-14593 2 24 only only ADV crl-14593 2 25 what what PRON crl-14593 2 26 is be AUX crl-14593 2 27 worth worth ADJ crl-14593 2 28 collecting collect VERB crl-14593 2 29 but but CCONJ crl-14593 2 30 also also ADV crl-14593 2 31 what what PRON crl-14593 2 32 constitutes constitute VERB crl-14593 2 33 a a DET crl-14593 2 34 com­ com­ NOUN crl-14593 2 35 plete plete NOUN crl-14593 2 36 and and CCONJ crl-14593 2 37 coherent coherent ADJ crl-14593 2 38 body body NOUN crl-14593 2 39 of of ADP crl-14593 2 40 materials material NOUN crl-14593 2 41 . . PUNCT crl-14593 2 42 " " PUNCT crl-14593 3 1 in in ADP crl-14593 3 2 the the DET crl-14593 3 3 end end NOUN crl-14593 3 4 , , PUNCT crl-14593 3 5 however however ADV crl-14593 3 6 , , PUNCT crl-14593 3 7 although although SCONJ crl-14593 3 8 " " PUNCT crl-14593 3 9 libraries library NOUN crl-14593 3 10 can can AUX crl-14593 3 11 lock lock VERB crl-14593 3 12 their their PRON crl-14593 3 13 doors1 doors1 NOUN crl-14593 3 14 or or CCONJ crl-14593 3 15 . . PUNCT crl-14593 3 16 . . PUNCT crl-14593 4 1 . . PUNCT crl-14593 5 1 restrict restrict VERB crl-14593 5 2 access access NOUN crl-14593 5 3 to to ADP crl-14593 5 4 their their PRON crl-14593 5 5 resources resource NOUN crl-14593 5 6 . . PUNCT crl-14593 5 7 . . PUNCT crl-14593 5 8 . . PUNCT crl-14593 6 1 libraries library NOUN crl-14593 6 2 as as ADP crl-14593 6 3 orga­ orga­ VERB crl-14593 6 4 nized nized ADJ crl-14593 6 5 collections collection NOUN crl-14593 6 6 of of ADP crl-14593 6 7 books book NOUN crl-14593 6 8 and and CCONJ crl-14593 6 9 other other ADJ crl-14593 6 10 arti­ arti­ ADP crl-14593 6 11 facts fact NOUN crl-14593 6 12 can can AUX crl-14593 6 13 not not PART crl-14593 6 14 directly directly ADV crl-14593 6 15 control control VERB crl-14593 6 16 what what PRON crl-14593 6 17 their their PRON crl-14593 6 18 cli­ cli­ PROPN crl-14593 6 19 ents ent NOUN crl-14593 6 20 will will AUX crl-14593 6 21 produce produce VERB crl-14593 6 22 . . PUNCT crl-14593 6 23 " " PUNCT crl-14593 7 1 while while SCONJ crl-14593 7 2 bristol bristol PROPN crl-14593 7 3 examines examine VERB crl-14593 7 4 the the DET crl-14593 7 5 philosophi­ philosophi­ PROPN crl-14593 7 6 cal cal NOUN crl-14593 7 7 background background NOUN crl-14593 7 8 and and CCONJ crl-14593 7 9 cultural cultural ADJ crl-14593 7 10 context context NOUN crl-14593 7 11 of of ADP crl-14593 7 12 pri­ pri­ PROPN crl-14593 7 13 vate vate NOUN crl-14593 7 14 collecting collect VERB crl-14593 7 15 in in ADP crl-14593 7 16 the the DET crl-14593 7 17 nineteenth nineteenth ADJ crl-14593 7 18 century century NOUN crl-14593 7 19 , , PUNCT crl-14593 7 20 james james PROPN crl-14593 7 21 gibson gibson PROPN crl-14593 7 22 provides provide VERB crl-14593 7 23 a a DET crl-14593 7 24 detailed detailed ADJ crl-14593 7 25 and and CCONJ crl-14593 7 26 readable readable ADJ crl-14593 7 27 account account NOUN crl-14593 7 28 of of ADP crl-14593 7 29 one one NUM crl-14593 7 30 shakespeare shakespeare ADJ crl-14593 7 31 col­ col­ NOUN crl-14593 7 32 lector lector NOUN crl-14593 7 33 , , PUNCT crl-14593 7 34 horace horace PROPN crl-14593 7 35 howard howard PROPN crl-14593 7 36 furness furness NOUN crl-14593 7 37 . . PUNCT crl-14593 8 1 the the DET crl-14593 8 2 son son NOUN crl-14593 8 3 of of ADP crl-14593 8 4 a a DET crl-14593 8 5 prominent prominent ADJ crl-14593 8 6 abolitionist abolitionist NOUN crl-14593 8 7 unitarian unitarian ADJ crl-14593 8 8 min­ min­ NOUN crl-14593 8 9 ister ister NOUN crl-14593 8 10 , , PUNCT crl-14593 8 11 and and CCONJ crl-14593 8 12 himself himself PRON crl-14593 8 13 a a DET crl-14593 8 14 student student NOUN crl-14593 8 15 of of ADP crl-14593 8 16 law law NOUN crl-14593 8 17 , , PUNCT crl-14593 8 18 fur­ fur­ PROPN crl-14593 8 19 ness ness ADV crl-14593 8 20 carne carne VERB crl-14593 8 21 from from ADP crl-14593 8 22 a a DET crl-14593 8 23 genteel genteel NOUN crl-14593 8 24 and and CCONJ crl-14593 8 25 cultured cultured ADJ crl-14593 8 26 , , PUNCT crl-14593 8 27 though though SCONJ crl-14593 8 28 not not PART crl-14593 8 29 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-14593 8 30 , , PUNCT crl-14593 8 31 background background NOUN crl-14593 8 32 . . PUNCT crl-14593 9 1 he he PRON crl-14593 9 2 was be AUX crl-14593 9 3 thus thus ADV crl-14593 9 4 typical typical ADJ crl-14593 9 5 of of ADP crl-14593 9 6 many many ADJ crl-14593 9 7 " " PUNCT crl-14593 9 8 gentleman gentleman NOUN crl-14593 9 9 scholars scholar NOUN crl-14593 9 10 '' '' PUNCT crl-14593 9 11 of of ADP crl-14593 9 12 the the DET crl-14593 9 13 period period NOUN crl-14593 9 14 , , PUNCT crl-14593 9 15 though though SCONJ crl-14593 9 16 what what PRON crl-14593 9 17 be­ be­ NOUN crl-14593 9 18 gan gin VERB crl-14593 9 19 for for ADP crl-14593 9 20 him he PRON crl-14593 9 21 as as ADP crl-14593 9 22 a a DET crl-14593 9 23 kind kind NOUN crl-14593 9 24 of of ADP crl-14593 9 25 hobby hobby NOUN crl-14593 9 26 grew grow VERB crl-14593 9 27 into into ADP crl-14593 9 28 a a DET crl-14593 9 29 lifelong lifelong ADJ crl-14593 9 30 obsession obsession NOUN crl-14593 9 31 that that PRON crl-14593 9 32 would would AUX crl-14593 9 33 have have AUX crl-14593 9 34 been be AUX crl-14593 9 35 the the DET crl-14593 9 36 death death NOUN crl-14593 9 37 of of ADP crl-14593 9 38 many many ADJ crl-14593 9 39 university university NOUN crl-14593 9 40 men man NOUN crl-14593 9 41 . . PUNCT crl-14593 10 1 his his PRON crl-14593 10 2 ini­ ini­ ADJ crl-14593 10 3 tial tial NOUN crl-14593 10 4 dabbling dabbling NOUN crl-14593 10 5 with with ADP crl-14593 10 6 the the DET crl-14593 10 7 bard bard NOUN crl-14593 10 8 at at ADP crl-14593 10 9 meetings meeting NOUN crl-14593 10 10 of of ADP crl-14593 10 11 the the DET crl-14593 10 12 shakespeare shakespeare ADJ crl-14593 10 13 society society NOUN crl-14593 10 14 of of ADP crl-14593 10 15 philadelphia philadelphia PROPN crl-14593 10 16 ( ( PUNCT crl-14593 10 17 all all DET crl-14593 10 18 males male NOUN crl-14593 10 19 , , PUNCT crl-14593 10 20 mainly mainly ADV crl-14593 10 21 of of ADP crl-14593 10 22 the the DET crl-14593 10 23 legal legal ADJ crl-14593 10 24 persuasion persuasion NOUN crl-14593 10 25 ) ) PUNCT crl-14593 10 26 led lead VERB crl-14593 10 27 to to ADP crl-14593 10 28 his his PRON crl-14593 10 29 first first ADJ crl-14593 10 30 venture venture NOUN crl-14593 10 31 at at ADP crl-14593 10 32 editing edit VERB crl-14593 10 33 a a DET crl-14593 10 34 shake­ shake­ ADV crl-14593 10 35 spearian spearian ADJ crl-14593 10 36 text text NOUN crl-14593 10 37 ( ( PUNCT crl-14593 10 38 romeo romeo VERB crl-14593 10 39 an1 an1 PROPN crl-14593 10 40 juliet juliet PROPN crl-14593 10 41 , , PUNCT crl-14593 10 42 1871 1871 NUM crl-14593 10 43 ) ) PUNCT crl-14593 10 44 and and CCONJ crl-14593 10 45 eventually eventually ADV crl-14593 10 46 to to ADP crl-14593 10 47 his his PRON crl-14593 10 48 establishment establishment NOUN crl-14593 10 49 of of ADP crl-14593 10 50 the the DET crl-14593 10 51 first first ADJ crl-14593 10 52 fifteen fifteen NUM crl-14593 10 53 volumes volume NOUN crl-14593 10 54 of of ADP crl-14593 10 55 the the DET crl-14593 10 56 monumental monumental ADJ crl-14593 10 57 vario­ vario­ NOUN crl-14593 10 58 rum rum NOUN crl-14593 10 59 shakespeare shakespeare NOUN crl-14593 10 60 . . PUNCT crl-14593 11 1 in in ADP crl-14593 11 2 a a DET crl-14593 11 3 period period NOUN crl-14593 11 4 in in ADP crl-14593 11 5 which which PRON crl-14593 11 6 henry henry NOUN crl-14593 11 7 clay clay NOUN crl-14593 11 8 folger folger NOUN crl-14593 11 9 was be AUX crl-14593 11 10 just just ADV crl-14593 11 11 beginning begin VERB crl-14593 11 12 his his PRON crl-14593 11 13 collection collection NOUN crl-14593 11 14 , , PUNCT crl-14593 11 15 no no DET crl-14593 11 16 american american ADJ crl-14593 11 17 library library PROPN crl-14593 11 18 had have VERB crl-14593 11 19 the the DET crl-14593 11 20 resources resource NOUN crl-14593 11 21 to to ADP crl-14593 11 22 sup­ sup­ PROPN crl-14593 11 23 port port VERB crl-14593 11 24 such such DET crl-14593 11 25 a a DET crl-14593 11 26 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-14593 11 27 undertaking undertaking NOUN crl-14593 11 28 as as ADP crl-14593 11 29 the the DET crl-14593 11 30 variorum variorum PROPN crl-14593 11 31 . . PUNCT crl-14593 12 1 furness furness NOUN crl-14593 12 2 accordingly accordingly ADV crl-14593 12 3 set set VERB crl-14593 12 4 out out ADP crl-14593 12 5 to to PART crl-14593 12 6 form form VERB crl-14593 12 7 his his PRON crl-14593 12 8 own own ADJ crl-14593 12 9 collection collection NOUN crl-14593 12 10 . . PUNCT crl-14593 13 1 his his PRON crl-14593 13 2 first first ADJ crl-14593 13 3 attempt attempt NOUN crl-14593 13 4 , , PUNCT crl-14593 13 5 a a DET crl-14593 13 6 bid bid NOUN crl-14593 13 7 to to PART crl-14593 13 8 purchase purchase VERB crl-14593 13 9 '' '' PUNCT crl-14593 13 10 the the DET crl-14593 13 11 shakespearian shakespearian ADJ crl-14593 13 12 por­ por­ PROPN crl-14593 13 13 tion tion NOUN crl-14593 13 14 of of ADP crl-14593 13 15 the the DET crl-14593 13 16 library library NOUN crl-14593 13 17 of of ADP crl-14593 13 18 thomas thomas PROPN crl-14593 13 19 pennant pennant PROPN crl-14593 13 20 bar­ bar­ PROPN crl-14593 13 21 ton ton PROPN crl-14593 13 22 , , PUNCT crl-14593 13 23 '' '' PUNCT crl-14593 13 24 failed fail VERB crl-14593 13 25 when when SCONJ crl-14593 13 26 a a DET crl-14593 13 27 decision decision NOUN crl-14593 13 28 was be AUX crl-14593 13 29 reached reach VERB crl-14593 13 30 not not PART crl-14593 13 31 to to PART crl-14593 13 32 split split VERB crl-14593 13 33 the the DET crl-14593 13 34 collection collection NOUN crl-14593 13 35 but but CCONJ crl-14593 13 36 to to PART crl-14593 13 37 sell sell VERB crl-14593 13 38 the the DET crl-14593 13 39 whole whole NOUN crl-14593 13 40 to to ADP crl-14593 13 41 the the DET crl-14593 13 42 boston boston PROPN crl-14593 13 43 public public PROPN crl-14593 13 44 library library PROPN crl-14593 13 45 . . PUNCT crl-14593 14 1 fur­ fur­ PROPN crl-14593 14 2 ness ness ADV crl-14593 14 3 received receive VERB crl-14593 14 4 help help NOUN crl-14593 14 5 in in ADP crl-14593 14 6 his his PRON crl-14593 14 7 endeavor endeavor NOUN crl-14593 14 8 , , PUNCT crl-14593 14 9 how­ how­ NOUN crl-14593 14 10 ever ever ADV crl-14593 14 11 , , PUNCT crl-14593 14 12 from from ADP crl-14593 14 13 the the DET crl-14593 14 14 british british ADJ crl-14593 14 15 shakespeare shakespeare PROPN crl-14593 14 16 scholar scholar NOUN crl-14593 14 17 and and CCONJ crl-14593 14 18 bibliographer bibliographer NOUN crl-14593 14 19 , , PUNCT crl-14593 14 20 j. j. PROPN crl-14593 14 21 0 0 PROPN crl-14593 14 22 . . PUNCT crl-14593 15 1 halliwell halliwell NOUN crl-14593 15 2 - - PUNCT crl-14593 15 3 phil­ phil­ NOUN crl-14593 15 4 lipps lipp NOUN crl-14593 15 5 , , PUNCT crl-14593 15 6 who who PRON crl-14593 15 7 not not PART crl-14593 15 8 only only ADV crl-14593 15 9 provided provide VERB crl-14593 15 10 furness furness ADJ crl-14593 15 11 recent recent ADJ crl-14593 15 12 publications publication NOUN crl-14593 15 13 571 571 NUM crl-14593 15 14 with with ADP crl-14593 15 15 materials material NOUN crl-14593 15 16 from from ADP crl-14593 15 17 his his PRON crl-14593 15 18 own own ADJ crl-14593 15 19 collection collection NOUN crl-14593 15 20 , , PUNCT crl-14593 15 21 but but CCONJ crl-14593 15 22 also also ADV crl-14593 15 23 recommended recommend VERB crl-14593 15 24 the the DET crl-14593 15 25 london london PROPN crl-14593 15 26 book­ book­ PROPN crl-14593 15 27 dealer dealer NOUN crl-14593 15 28 , , PUNCT crl-14593 15 29 alfred alfred PROPN crl-14593 15 30 russell russell PROPN crl-14593 15 31 smith smith PROPN crl-14593 15 32 . . PUNCT crl-14593 16 1 through through ADP crl-14593 16 2 smith smith PROPN crl-14593 16 3 , , PUNCT crl-14593 16 4 furness furness NOUN crl-14593 16 5 purchased purchase VERB crl-14593 16 6 many many ADJ crl-14593 16 7 of of ADP crl-14593 16 8 his his PRON crl-14593 16 9 treasures treasure NOUN crl-14593 16 10 , , PUNCT crl-14593 16 11 including include VERB crl-14593 16 12 the the DET crl-14593 16 13 first first ADJ crl-14593 16 14 , , PUNCT crl-14593 16 15 third third ADJ crl-14593 16 16 , , PUNCT crl-14593 16 17 and and CCONJ crl-14593 16 18 fourth fourth ADJ crl-14593 16 19 folios folio NOUN crl-14593 16 20 from from ADP crl-14593 16 21 the the DET crl-14593 16 22 corser corser PROPN crl-14593 16 23 library library PROPN crl-14593 16 24 sale sale NOUN crl-14593 16 25 in in ADP crl-14593 16 26 1871 1871 NUM crl-14593 16 27 ; ; PUNCT crl-14593 16 28 he he PRON crl-14593 16 29 also also ADV crl-14593 16 30 obtained obtain VERB crl-14593 16 31 the the DET crl-14593 16 32 1611 1611 NUM crl-14593 16 33 hamlet hamlet NOUN crl-14593 16 34 and and CCONJ crl-14593 16 35 three three NUM crl-14593 16 36 pavier pavi ADJ crl-14593 16 37 quartos quarto VERB crl-14593 16 38 , , PUNCT crl-14593 16 39 " " PUNCT crl-14593 16 40 which which PRON crl-14593 16 41 had have AUX crl-14593 16 42 be­ be­ PROPN crl-14593 16 43 longed long VERB crl-14593 16 44 to to ADP crl-14593 16 45 the the DET crl-14593 16 46 shakespearian shakespearian PROPN crl-14593 16 47 editor editor PROPN crl-14593 16 48 edward edward PROPN crl-14593 16 49 capell capell PROPN crl-14593 16 50 . . PUNCT crl-14593 16 51 " " PUNCT crl-14593 17 1 by by ADP crl-14593 17 2 the the DET crl-14593 17 3 mid-1870s mid-1870 NOUN crl-14593 17 4 he he PRON crl-14593 17 5 had have VERB crl-14593 17 6 over over ADP crl-14593 17 7 2,000 2,000 NUM crl-14593 17 8 volumes volume NOUN crl-14593 17 9 , , PUNCT crl-14593 17 10 and and CCONJ crl-14593 17 11 " " PUNCT crl-14593 17 12 his his PRON crl-14593 17 13 collection collection NOUN crl-14593 17 14 of of ADP crl-14593 17 15 german german ADJ crl-14593 17 16 and and CCONJ crl-14593 17 17 french french ADJ crl-14593 17 18 editions edition NOUN crl-14593 17 19 of of ADP crl-14593 17 20 shake­ shake­ ADJ crl-14593 17 21 speare speare NOUN crl-14593 17 22 . . PUNCT crl-14593 17 23 . . PUNCT crl-14593 17 24 . . PUNCT crl-14593 18 1 { { PUNCT crl-14593 18 2 was be AUX crl-14593 18 3 ] ] X crl-14593 18 4 judged judge VERB crl-14593 18 5 to to PART crl-14593 18 6 be be AUX crl-14593 18 7 the the DET crl-14593 18 8 most most ADV crl-14593 18 9 complete complete ADJ crl-14593 18 10 in in ADP crl-14593 18 11 the the DET crl-14593 18 12 united united PROPN crl-14593 18 13 states states PROPN crl-14593 18 14 . . PUNCT crl-14593 18 15 " " PUNCT crl-14593 19 1 along along ADP crl-14593 19 2 with with ADP crl-14593 19 3 the the DET crl-14593 19 4 history history NOUN crl-14593 19 5 of of ADP crl-14593 19 6 these these DET crl-14593 19 7 nineteenth nineteenth ADJ crl-14593 19 8 - - PUNCT crl-14593 19 9 century century NOUN crl-14593 19 10 shakespearian shakespearian ADJ crl-14593 19 11 collec­ collec­ PROPN crl-14593 19 12 tions tion NOUN crl-14593 19 13 and and CCONJ crl-14593 19 14 of of ADP crl-14593 19 15 the the DET crl-14593 19 16 social social ADJ crl-14593 19 17 relationships relationship NOUN crl-14593 19 18 among among ADP crl-14593 19 19 scholars scholar NOUN crl-14593 19 20 and and CCONJ crl-14593 19 21 bibliophiles bibliophile NOUN crl-14593 19 22 in in ADP crl-14593 19 23 this this DET crl-14593 19 24 period period NOUN crl-14593 19 25 , , PUNCT crl-14593 19 26 librarians librarians PROPN crl-14593 19 27 will will AUX crl-14593 19 28 find find VERB crl-14593 19 29 much much ADJ crl-14593 19 30 to to PART crl-14593 19 31 profit profit VERB crl-14593 19 32 from from ADP crl-14593 19 33 in in ADP crl-14593 19 34 bristol bristol PROPN crl-14593 19 35 's 's PART crl-14593 19 36 description description NOUN crl-14593 19 37 of of ADP crl-14593 19 38 the the DET crl-14593 19 39 chang­ chang­ PROPN crl-14593 19 40 ing ing ADJ crl-14593 19 41 cultural cultural ADJ crl-14593 19 42 climate climate NOUN crl-14593 19 43 that that PRON crl-14593 19 44 has have AUX crl-14593 19 45 given give VERB crl-14593 19 46 rise rise NOUN crl-14593 19 47 to to ADP crl-14593 19 48 the the DET crl-14593 19 49 various various ADJ crl-14593 19 50 movements movement NOUN crl-14593 19 51 in in ADP crl-14593 19 52 shakespeare shakespeare ADJ crl-14593 19 53 criticism criticism NOUN crl-14593 19 54 down down ADP crl-14593 19 55 to to ADP crl-14593 19 56 our our PRON crl-14593 19 57 day.-georgianna day.-georgianna PROPN crl-14593 19 58 ziegler ziegler NOUN crl-14593 19 59 , , PUNCT crl-14593 19 60 university university PROPN crl-14593 19 61 of of ADP crl-14593 19 62 pennsylvania pennsylvania PROPN crl-14593 19 63 , , PUNCT crl-14593 19 64 philadel­ philadel­ NOUN crl-14593 19 65 phia phia PROPN crl-14593 19 66 , , PUNCT crl-14593 19 67 · · NUM crl-14593 19 68 pennsylvania pennsylvania PROPN crl-14593 19 69 . . PUNCT crl-14593 20 1 kimball kimball PROPN crl-14593 20 2 , , PUNCT crl-14593 20 3 roger roger PROPN crl-14593 20 4 . . PUNCT crl-14593 21 1 tenured tenure VERB crl-14593 21 2 radicals radical NOUN crl-14593 21 3 : : PUNCT crl-14593 21 4 how how SCONJ crl-14593 21 5 politics politic NOUN crl-14593 21 6 has have AUX crl-14593 21 7 corrupted corrupt VERB crl-14593 21 8 our our PRON crl-14593 21 9 higher high ADJ crl-14593 21 10 educa­ educa­ ADJ crl-14593 21 11 tion tion NOUN crl-14593 21 12 . . PUNCT crl-14593 22 1 new new PROPN crl-14593 22 2 york york PROPN crl-14593 22 3 : : PUNCT crl-14593 22 4 harper harper PROPN crl-14593 22 5 & & CCONJ crl-14593 22 6 row row NOUN crl-14593 22 7 , , PUNCT crl-14593 22 8 1990 1990 NUM crl-14593 22 9 . . PUNCT crl-14593 23 1 204p 204p NOUN crl-14593 23 2 . . PUNCT crl-14593 24 1 $ $ SYM crl-14593 24 2 18.95 18.95 NUM crl-14593 24 3 ( ( PUNCT crl-14593 24 4 isbn isbn NOUN crl-14593 24 5 0 0 NUM crl-14593 24 6 - - SYM crl-14593 24 7 06 06 NUM crl-14593 24 8 - - PUNCT crl-14593 24 9 016190 016190 NUM crl-14593 24 10 ) ) PUNCT crl-14593 24 11 . . PUNCT crl-14593 25 1 lc lc NOUN crl-14593 25 2 89­ 89­ NUM crl-14593 25 3 45049 45049 NUM crl-14593 25 4 . . PUNCT crl-14593 26 1 american american PROPN crl-14593 26 2 educational educational ADJ crl-14593 26 3 institutions institution NOUN crl-14593 26 4 have have AUX crl-14593 26 5 come come VERB crl-14593 26 6 under under ADP crl-14593 26 7 much much ADJ crl-14593 26 8 scrutiny scrutiny NOUN crl-14593 26 9 in in ADP crl-14593 26 10 recent recent ADJ crl-14593 26 11 years year NOUN crl-14593 26 12 , , PUNCT crl-14593 26 13 often often ADV crl-14593 26 14 in in ADP crl-14593 26 15 the the DET crl-14593 26 16 form form NOUN crl-14593 26 17 of of ADP crl-14593 26 18 trenchant trenchant NOUN crl-14593 26 19 criti­ criti­ NOUN crl-14593 26 20 cism cism NOUN crl-14593 26 21 of of ADP crl-14593 26 22 aims aim NOUN crl-14593 26 23 and and CCONJ crl-14593 26 24 objectives objective NOUN crl-14593 26 25 , , PUNCT crl-14593 26 26 as as ADV crl-14593 26 27 well well ADV crl-14593 26 28 as as ADP crl-14593 26 29 of of ADP crl-14593 26 30 methods method NOUN crl-14593 26 31 . . PUNCT crl-14593 27 1 while while SCONJ crl-14593 27 2 much much ADJ crl-14593 27 3 attention attention NOUN crl-14593 27 4 has have AUX crl-14593 27 5 been be AUX crl-14593 27 6 focused focus VERB crl-14593 27 7 on on ADP crl-14593 27 8 elementary elementary ADJ crl-14593 27 9 and and CCONJ crl-14593 27 10 secondary secondary ADJ crl-14593 27 11 ed­ ed­ PROPN crl-14593 27 12 ucation ucation NOUN crl-14593 27 13 , , PUNCT crl-14593 27 14 higher high ADJ crl-14593 27 15 education education NOUN crl-14593 27 16 has have AUX crl-14593 27 17 certainly certainly ADV crl-14593 27 18 not not PART crl-14593 27 19 been be AUX crl-14593 27 20 spared spare VERB crl-14593 27 21 . . PUNCT crl-14593 28 1 allan allan PROPN crl-14593 28 2 bloom bloom PROPN crl-14593 28 3 's 's PART crl-14593 28 4 the the DET crl-14593 28 5 · · PUNCT crl-14593 28 6 clos­ clos­ NOUN crl-14593 28 7 ing ing NOUN crl-14593 28 8 of of ADP crl-14593 28 9 the the DET crl-14593 28 10 american american ADJ crl-14593 28 11 mind mind NOUN crl-14593 28 12 set set VERB crl-14593 28 13 the the DET crl-14593 28 14 tone tone NOUN crl-14593 28 15 for for ADP crl-14593 28 16 an an DET crl-14593 28 17 ongoing ongoing ADJ crl-14593 28 18 controversy controversy NOUN crl-14593 28 19 , , PUNCT crl-14593 28 20 of of ADP crl-14593 28 21 which which PRON crl-14593 28 22 academic academic ADJ crl-14593 28 23 librarians librarian NOUN crl-14593 28 24 need need VERB crl-14593 28 25 to to PART crl-14593 28 26 be be AUX crl-14593 28 27 aware aware ADJ crl-14593 28 28 . . PUNCT crl-14593 29 1 roger roger PROPN crl-14593 29 2 kimball kimball PROPN crl-14593 29 3 , , PUNCT crl-14593 29 4 managing manage VERB crl-14593 29 5 editor editor NOUN crl-14593 29 6 of of ADP crl-14593 29 7 the the DET crl-14593 29 8 new new ADJ crl-14593 29 9 criterion criterion NOUN crl-14593 29 10 , , PUNCT crl-14593 29 11 attempts attempt VERB crl-14593 29 12 here here ADV crl-14593 29 13 to to PART crl-14593 29 14 ride ride VERB crl-14593 29 15 this this DET crl-14593 29 16 re­ re­ NOUN crl-14593 29 17 cent cent NOUN crl-14593 29 18 wave wave NOUN crl-14593 29 19 of of ADP crl-14593 29 20 criticism criticism NOUN crl-14593 29 21 . . PUNCT crl-14593 30 1 kimball kimball PROPN crl-14593 30 2 is be AUX crl-14593 30 3 espe­ espe­ ADJ crl-14593 30 4 cially cially ADV crl-14593 30 5 critical critical ADJ crl-14593 30 6 of of ADP crl-14593 30 7 '' '' PUNCT crl-14593 30 8 recent recent ADJ crl-14593 30 9 developments development NOUN crl-14593 30 10 in in ADP crl-14593 30 11 the the DET crl-14593 30 12 academic academic ADJ crl-14593 30 13 study study NOUN crl-14593 30 14 of of ADP crl-14593 30 15 the the DET crl-14593 30 16 humanities humanity NOUN crl-14593 30 17 , , PUNCT crl-14593 30 18 " " PUNCT crl-14593 30 19 especially especially ADV crl-14593 30 20 deconstruction deconstruction NOUN crl-14593 30 21 , , PUNCT crl-14593 30 22 feminist feminist PROPN crl-14593 30 23 stud­ stud­ PROPN crl-14593 30 24 ies ies PROPN crl-14593 30 25 , , PUNCT crl-14593 30 26 and and CCONJ crl-14593 30 27 other other ADJ crl-14593 30 28 movements movement NOUN crl-14593 30 29 to to PART crl-14593 30 30 undermine undermine VERB crl-14593 30 31 the the DET crl-14593 30 32 traditional traditional ADJ crl-14593 30 33 canon canon NOUN crl-14593 30 34 of of ADP crl-14593 30 35 liberal liberal ADJ crl-14593 30 36 studies study NOUN crl-14593 30 37 . . PUNCT crl-14593 31 1 he he PRON crl-14593 31 2 regales regale VERB crl-14593 31 3 us we PRON crl-14593 31 4 with with ADP crl-14593 31 5 illustrations illustration NOUN crl-14593 31 6 of of ADP crl-14593 31 7 the the DET crl-14593 31 8 obscu­ obscu­ ADJ crl-14593 31 9 rity rity NOUN crl-14593 31 10 or or CCONJ crl-14593 31 11 just just ADV crl-14593 31 12 plain plain ADJ crl-14593 31 13 silliness silliness NOUN crl-14593 31 14 of of ADP crl-14593 31 15 many many ADJ crl-14593 31 16 of of ADP crl-14593 31 17 the the DET crl-14593 31 18 latest late ADJ crl-14593 31 19 modes mode NOUN crl-14593 31 20 of of ADP crl-14593 31 21 criticism criticism NOUN crl-14593 31 22 , , PUNCT crl-14593 31 23 especially especially ADV crl-14593 31 24 liter­ liter­ PROPN crl-14593 31 25 ary ary ADJ crl-14593 31 26 criticism criticism NOUN crl-14593 31 27 , , PUNCT crl-14593 31 28 but but CCONJ crl-14593 31 29 his his PRON crl-14593 31 30 indictment indictment NOUN crl-14593 31 31 goes go VERB crl-14593 31 32 572 572 NUM crl-14593 31 33 college college PROPN crl-14593 31 34 & & CCONJ crl-14593 31 35 research research PROPN crl-14593 31 36 libraries library NOUN crl-14593 31 37 november november PROPN crl-14593 31 38 1990 1990 NUM crl-14593 31 39 deeper deep ADJ crl-14593 31 40 . . PUNCT crl-14593 32 1 these these DET crl-14593 32 2 recent recent ADJ crl-14593 32 3 fancies fancy NOUN crl-14593 32 4 are be AUX crl-14593 32 5 , , PUNCT crl-14593 32 6 in in ADP crl-14593 32 7 his his PRON crl-14593 32 8 words word NOUN crl-14593 32 9 , , PUNCT crl-14593 32 10 " " PUNCT crl-14593 32 11 ideologically ideologically ADV crl-14593 32 12 motivated motivated ADJ crl-14593 32 13 assaults assault NOUN crl-14593 32 14 on on ADP crl-14593 32 15 the the DET crl-14593 32 16 intellectual intellectual ADJ crl-14593 32 17 and and CCONJ crl-14593 32 18 moral moral ADJ crl-14593 32 19 substance substance NOUN crl-14593 32 20 of of ADP crl-14593 32 21 our our PRON crl-14593 32 22 culture culture NOUN crl-14593 32 23 . . PUNCT crl-14593 32 24 " " PUNCT crl-14593 33 1 kimball kimball PROPN crl-14593 33 2 's 's PART crl-14593 33 3 thesis thesis NOUN crl-14593 33 4 is be AUX crl-14593 33 5 that that SCONJ crl-14593 33 6 the the DET crl-14593 33 7 student student NOUN crl-14593 33 8 rebels rebel NOUN crl-14593 33 9 of of ADP crl-14593 33 10 the the DET crl-14593 33 11 1960s 1960 NOUN crl-14593 33 12 have have AUX crl-14593 33 13 taken take VERB crl-14593 33 14 over over ADP crl-14593 33 15 our our PRON crl-14593 33 16 system system NOUN crl-14593 33 17 of of ADP crl-14593 33 18 higher high ADJ crl-14593 33 19 education education NOUN crl-14593 33 20 ( ( PUNCT crl-14593 33 21 or or CCONJ crl-14593 33 22 at at ADP crl-14593 33 23 least least ADJ crl-14593 33 24 " " PUNCT crl-14593 33 25 our our PRON crl-14593 33 26 best good ADJ crl-14593 33 27 colleges college NOUN crl-14593 33 28 and and CCONJ crl-14593 33 29 universities university NOUN crl-14593 33 30 " " PUNCT crl-14593 33 31 ) ) PUNCT crl-14593 33 32 , , PUNCT crl-14593 33 33 and and CCONJ crl-14593 33 34 they they PRON crl-14593 33 35 are be AUX crl-14593 33 36 now now ADV crl-14593 33 37 subverting subvert VERB crl-14593 33 38 it it PRON crl-14593 33 39 from from ADP crl-14593 33 40 within within ADV crl-14593 33 41 , , PUNCT crl-14593 33 42 as as ADP crl-14593 33 43 professors professor NOUN crl-14593 33 44 . . PUNCT crl-14593 34 1 attacks attack NOUN crl-14593 34 2 on on ADP crl-14593 34 3 the the DET crl-14593 34 4 canon canon NOUN crl-14593 34 5 , , PUNCT crl-14593 34 6 deconstruction deconstruction NOUN crl-14593 34 7 , , PUNCT crl-14593 34 8 semiology semiology NOUN crl-14593 34 9 , , PUNCT crl-14593 34 10 and and CCONJ crl-14593 34 11 poststructuralism poststructuralism NOUN crl-14593 34 12 are be AUX crl-14593 34 13 all all PRON crl-14593 34 14 parts part NOUN crl-14593 34 15 of of ADP crl-14593 34 16 a a DET crl-14593 34 17 politi­ politi­ ADJ crl-14593 34 18 cal cal NOUN crl-14593 34 19 assault assault NOUN crl-14593 34 20 on on ADP crl-14593 34 21 the the DET crl-14593 34 22 humanities humanity NOUN crl-14593 34 23 in in ADP crl-14593 34 24 toto toto NOUN crl-14593 34 25 . . PUNCT crl-14593 35 1 even even ADV crl-14593 35 2 the the DET crl-14593 35 3 recent recent ADJ crl-14593 35 4 supreme supreme PROPN crl-14593 35 5 court court NOUN crl-14593 35 6 decision decision NOUN crl-14593 35 7 forc­ forc­ ADP crl-14593 35 8 ing e VERB crl-14593 35 9 the the DET crl-14593 35 10 university university PROPN crl-14593 35 11 of of ADP crl-14593 35 12 pennsylvania pennsylvania PROPN crl-14593 35 13 to to PART crl-14593 35 14 open open VERB crl-14593 35 15 its its PRON crl-14593 35 16 employment employment NOUN crl-14593 35 17 files file NOUN crl-14593 35 18 to to ADP crl-14593 35 19 federal federal ADJ crl-14593 35 20 courts court NOUN crl-14593 35 21 in in ADP crl-14593 35 22 tenure tenure NOUN crl-14593 35 23 cases case NOUN crl-14593 35 24 is be AUX crl-14593 35 25 part part NOUN crl-14593 35 26 of of ADP crl-14593 35 27 the the DET crl-14593 35 28 move­ move­ ADJ crl-14593 35 29 ment ment NOUN crl-14593 35 30 . . PUNCT crl-14593 36 1 the the DET crl-14593 36 2 reader reader NOUN crl-14593 36 3 can can AUX crl-14593 36 4 see see VERB crl-14593 36 5 where where SCONJ crl-14593 36 6 mr mr PROPN crl-14593 36 7 . . PROPN crl-14593 36 8 kim­ kim­ PROPN crl-14593 36 9 ball ball PROPN crl-14593 36 10 stands stand VERB crl-14593 36 11 on on ADP crl-14593 36 12 the the DET crl-14593 36 13 political political ADJ crl-14593 36 14 spectrum spectrum NOUN crl-14593 36 15 when when SCONJ crl-14593 36 16 he he PRON crl-14593 36 17 considers consider VERB crl-14593 36 18 even even ADV crl-14593 36 19 the the DET crl-14593 36 20 supreme supreme PROPN crl-14593 36 21 court court PROPN crl-14593 36 22 '' '' PUNCT crl-14593 36 23 tenured tenure VERB crl-14593 36 24 radicals radical NOUN crl-14593 36 25 . . PUNCT crl-14593 36 26 '' '' PUNCT crl-14593 37 1 much much ADJ crl-14593 37 2 of of ADP crl-14593 37 3 the the DET crl-14593 37 4 book book NOUN crl-14593 37 5 consists consist VERB crl-14593 37 6 of of ADP crl-14593 37 7 what what PRON crl-14593 37 8 kim­ kim­ PROPN crl-14593 37 9 ball ball NOUN crl-14593 37 10 calls call VERB crl-14593 37 11 " " PUNCT crl-14593 37 12 reports report NOUN crl-14593 37 13 from from ADP crl-14593 37 14 the the DET crl-14593 37 15 front front NOUN crl-14593 37 16 , , PUNCT crl-14593 37 17 " " PUNCT crl-14593 37 18 or or CCONJ crl-14593 37 19 ac­ ac­ PROPN crl-14593 37 20 counts count NOUN crl-14593 37 21 of of ADP crl-14593 37 22 symposia symposia PROPN crl-14593 37 23 or or CCONJ crl-14593 37 24 conferences conference NOUN crl-14593 37 25 where where SCONJ crl-14593 37 26 the the DET crl-14593 37 27 radicals radical NOUN crl-14593 37 28 whom whom PRON crl-14593 37 29 kimball kimball NOUN crl-14593 37 30 considers consider VERB crl-14593 37 31 the the DET crl-14593 37 32 stars star NOUN crl-14593 37 33 of of ADP crl-14593 37 34 contemporary contemporary ADJ crl-14593 37 35 academia academia NOUN crl-14593 37 36 have have AUX crl-14593 37 37 met meet VERB crl-14593 37 38 to to PART crl-14593 37 39 discuss discuss VERB crl-14593 37 40 the the DET crl-14593 37 41 current current ADJ crl-14593 37 42 " " PUNCT crl-14593 37 43 crisis crisis NOUN crl-14593 37 44 " " PUNCT crl-14593 37 45 in in ADP crl-14593 37 46 the the DET crl-14593 37 47 hu­ hu­ PROPN crl-14593 37 48 manities manitie NOUN crl-14593 37 49 . . PUNCT crl-14593 38 1 he he PRON crl-14593 38 2 dwells dwell VERB crl-14593 38 3 especially especially ADV crl-14593 38 4 on on ADP crl-14593 38 5 the the DET crl-14593 38 6 de­ de­ ADJ crl-14593 38 7 constructionists constructionist NOUN crl-14593 38 8 and and CCONJ crl-14593 38 9 their their PRON crl-14593 38 10 deliberate deliberate ADJ crl-14593 38 11 ob­ ob­ NOUN crl-14593 38 12 scurity scurity NOUN crl-14593 38 13 , , PUNCT crl-14593 38 14 although although SCONJ crl-14593 38 15 it it PRON crl-14593 38 16 is be AUX crl-14593 38 17 difficult difficult ADJ crl-14593 38 18 to to PART crl-14593 38 19 see see VERB crl-14593 38 20 how how SCONJ crl-14593 38 21 the the DET crl-14593 38 22 irrelevant irrelevant ADJ crl-14593 38 23 vagaries vagary NOUN crl-14593 38 24 he he PRON crl-14593 38 25 describes describe VERB crl-14593 38 26 carry carry VERB crl-14593 38 27 any any DET crl-14593 38 28 consistent consistent ADJ crl-14593 38 29 political political ADJ crl-14593 38 30 message message NOUN crl-14593 38 31 . . PUNCT crl-14593 39 1 kimball kimball PROPN crl-14593 39 2 's 's PART crl-14593 39 3 fundamental fundamental ADJ crl-14593 39 4 disagreement disagreement NOUN crl-14593 39 5 with with ADP crl-14593 39 6 the the DET crl-14593 39 7 varied varied ADJ crl-14593 39 8 assortment assortment NOUN crl-14593 39 9 of of ADP crl-14593 39 10 educators educator NOUN crl-14593 39 11 he he PRON crl-14593 39 12 criticizes criticize VERB crl-14593 39 13 is be AUX crl-14593 39 14 about about ADP crl-14593 39 15 the the DET crl-14593 39 16 very very ADJ crl-14593 39 17 nature nature NOUN crl-14593 39 18 of of ADP crl-14593 39 19 the the DET crl-14593 39 20 humanities humanity NOUN crl-14593 39 21 . . PUNCT crl-14593 40 1 he he PRON crl-14593 40 2 consistently consistently ADV crl-14593 40 3 urges urge VERB crl-14593 40 4 that that SCONJ crl-14593 40 5 the the DET crl-14593 40 6 humanities humanity NOUN crl-14593 40 7 curriculum curriculum NOUN crl-14593 40 8 must must AUX crl-14593 40 9 include include VERB crl-14593 40 10 " " PUNCT crl-14593 40 11 the the DET crl-14593 40 12 best good ADJ crl-14593 40 13 that that PRON crl-14593 40 14 has have AUX crl-14593 40 15 been be AUX crl-14593 40 16 thought think VERB crl-14593 40 17 and and CCONJ crl-14593 40 18 read read VERB crl-14593 40 19 . . PUNCT crl-14593 40 20 '' '' PUNCT crl-14593 41 1 the the DET crl-14593 41 2 tenured tenure VERB crl-14593 41 3 radicals radical NOUN crl-14593 41 4 , , PUNCT crl-14593 41 5 he he PRON crl-14593 41 6 says say VERB crl-14593 41 7 , , PUNCT crl-14593 41 8 are be AUX crl-14593 41 9 opposed oppose VERB crl-14593 41 10 to to ADP crl-14593 41 11 this this DET crl-14593 41 12 notion notion NOUN crl-14593 41 13 . . PUNCT crl-14593 42 1 but but CCONJ crl-14593 42 2 he he PRON crl-14593 42 3 misses miss VERB crl-14593 42 4 their their PRON crl-14593 42 5 point point NOUN crl-14593 42 6 that that SCONJ crl-14593 42 7 the the DET crl-14593 42 8 issue issue NOUN crl-14593 42 9 is be AUX crl-14593 42 10 really really ADV crl-14593 42 11 , , PUNCT crl-14593 42 12 " " PUNCT crl-14593 42 13 what what PRON crl-14593 42 14 is be AUX crl-14593 42 15 the the DET crl-14593 42 16 best good ADJ crl-14593 42 17 ? ? PUNCT crl-14593 43 1 who who PRON crl-14593 43 2 decides decide VERB crl-14593 43 3 ? ? PUNCT crl-14593 43 4 " " PUNCT crl-14593 43 5 for for ADP crl-14593 43 6 kimball kimball NOUN crl-14593 43 7 it it PRON crl-14593 43 8 is be AUX crl-14593 43 9 the the DET crl-14593 43 10 traditional traditional ADJ crl-14593 43 11 canon canon NOUN crl-14593 43 12 of of ADP crl-14593 43 13 western western ADJ crl-14593 43 14 civilization civilization NOUN crl-14593 43 15 , , PUNCT crl-14593 43 16 which which PRON crl-14593 43 17 he he PRON crl-14593 43 18 admits admit VERB crl-14593 43 19 i i PRON crl-14593 43 20 ' ' AUX crl-14593 43 21 can can AUX crl-14593 43 22 be be AUX crl-14593 43 23 seen see VERB crl-14593 43 24 to to PART crl-14593 43 25 be be AUX crl-14593 43 26 exclusive exclusive ADJ crl-14593 43 27 or or CCONJ crl-14593 43 28 elit­ elit­ NOUN crl-14593 43 29 ist ist NOUN crl-14593 43 30 . . PUNCT crl-14593 44 1 but but CCONJ crl-14593 44 2 in in ADP crl-14593 44 3 another another DET crl-14593 44 4 sense sense NOUN crl-14593 44 5 , , PUNCT crl-14593 44 6 it it PRON crl-14593 44 7 is be AUX crl-14593 44 8 deeply deeply ADV crl-14593 44 9 dem­ dem­ NOUN crl-14593 44 10 ocratic ocratic ADJ crl-14593 44 11 for for SCONJ crl-14593 44 12 it it PRON crl-14593 44 13 locates locate VERB crl-14593 44 14 authority authority NOUN crl-14593 44 15 not not PART crl-14593 44 16 in in ADP crl-14593 44 17 any any DET crl-14593 44 18 class class NOUN crl-14593 44 19 or or CCONJ crl-14593 44 20 race race NOUN crl-14593 44 21 or or CCONJ crl-14593 44 22 sex sex NOUN crl-14593 44 23 , , PUNCT crl-14593 44 24 but but CCONJ crl-14593 44 25 in in ADP crl-14593 44 26 a a DET crl-14593 44 27 tradition tradition NOUN crl-14593 45 1 be­ be­ PROPN crl-14593 45 2 fore fore NOUN crl-14593 45 3 which which PRON crl-14593 45 4 all all PRON crl-14593 45 5 are be AUX crl-14593 45 6 equal equal ADJ crl-14593 45 7 . . PUNCT crl-14593 45 8 " " PUNCT crl-14593 46 1 he he PRON crl-14593 46 2 seems seem VERB crl-14593 46 3 to to PART crl-14593 46 4 think think VERB crl-14593 46 5 this this DET crl-14593 46 6 canon canon NOUN crl-14593 46 7 dropped drop VERB crl-14593 46 8 from from ADP crl-14593 46 9 the the DET crl-14593 46 10 heav­ heav­ PROPN crl-14593 46 11 ens ens PROPN crl-14593 46 12 , , PUNCT crl-14593 46 13 or or CCONJ crl-14593 46 14 sprang sprang AUX crl-14593 46 15 fully fully ADV crl-14593 46 16 clothed clothe VERB crl-14593 46 17 from from ADP crl-14593 46 18 some some DET crl-14593 46 19 universal universal ADJ crl-14593 46 20 mind mind NOUN crl-14593 46 21 . . PUNCT crl-14593 47 1 the the DET crl-14593 47 2 recent recent ADJ crl-14593 47 3 revelations revelation NOUN crl-14593 47 4 about about ADP crl-14593 47 5 paul paul PROPN crl-14593 47 6 de de PROPN crl-14593 47 7 man man PROPN crl-14593 47 8 's 's PART crl-14593 47 9 wartime wartime ADJ crl-14593 47 10 journalism journalism NOUN crl-14593 47 11 provide provide VERB crl-14593 47 12 kim­ kim­ PROPN crl-14593 47 13 ball ball NOUN crl-14593 47 14 with with ADP crl-14593 47 15 irrefutable irrefutable ADJ crl-14593 47 16 proof proof NOUN crl-14593 47 17 that that SCONJ crl-14593 47 18 deconstruc­ deconstruc­ ADP crl-14593 47 19 tion tion NOUN crl-14593 47 20 is be AUX crl-14593 47 21 perverted pervert VERB crl-14593 47 22 doctrine doctrine NOUN crl-14593 47 23 . . PUNCT crl-14593 48 1 de de X crl-14593 48 2 man man NOUN crl-14593 48 3 is be AUX crl-14593 48 4 criti­ criti­ AUX crl-14593 48 5 cized cize VERB crl-14593 48 6 as as ADP crl-14593 48 7 anti anti ADJ crl-14593 48 8 - - ADJ crl-14593 48 9 semitic semitic ADJ crl-14593 48 10 for for ADP crl-14593 48 11 having having AUX crl-14593 48 12 written write VERB crl-14593 48 13 that that SCONJ crl-14593 48 14 western western ADJ crl-14593 48 15 literature literature NOUN crl-14593 48 16 would would AUX crl-14593 48 17 not not PART crl-14593 48 18 suffer suffer VERB crl-14593 48 19 if if SCONJ crl-14593 48 20 we we PRON crl-14593 48 21 removed remove VERB crl-14593 48 22 the the DET crl-14593 48 23 contributions contribution NOUN crl-14593 48 24 of of ADP crl-14593 48 25 its its PRON crl-14593 48 26 jew­ jew­ NOUN crl-14593 48 27 ish ish X crl-14593 48 28 writers writer NOUN crl-14593 48 29 . . PUNCT crl-14593 49 1 yet yet ADV crl-14593 49 2 , , PUNCT crl-14593 49 3 how how SCONJ crl-14593 49 4 many many ADJ crl-14593 49 5 jewish jewish ADJ crl-14593 49 6 writers writer NOUN crl-14593 49 7 would would AUX crl-14593 49 8 we we PRON crl-14593 49 9 find find VERB crl-14593 49 10 in in ADP crl-14593 49 11 kimball kimball PROPN crl-14593 49 12 's 's PART crl-14593 49 13 traditional traditional ADJ crl-14593 49 14 canon canon NOUN crl-14593 49 15 ? ? PUNCT crl-14593 50 1 precious precious ADJ crl-14593 50 2 few few ADJ crl-14593 50 3 , , PUNCT crl-14593 50 4 once once SCONJ crl-14593 50 5 we we PRON crl-14593 50 6 move move VERB crl-14593 50 7 be­ be­ PROPN crl-14593 50 8 yond yond VERB crl-14593 50 9 the the DET crl-14593 50 10 bible bible NOUN crl-14593 50 11 . . PUNCT crl-14593 51 1 so so ADV crl-14593 51 2 the the DET crl-14593 51 3 young young ADJ crl-14593 51 4 de de X crl-14593 51 5 man man NOUN crl-14593 51 6 and and CCONJ crl-14593 51 7 kimball kimball NOUN crl-14593 51 8 are be AUX crl-14593 51 9 essentially essentially ADV crl-14593 51 10 in in ADP crl-14593 51 11 agreement agreement NOUN crl-14593 51 12 about about ADP crl-14593 51 13 " " PUNCT crl-14593 51 14 the the DET crl-14593 51 15 best good ADJ crl-14593 51 16 that that PRON crl-14593 51 17 has have AUX crl-14593 51 18 been be AUX crl-14593 51 19 thought think VERB crl-14593 51 20 and and CCONJ crl-14593 51 21 read read VERB crl-14593 51 22 . . PUNCT crl-14593 51 23 '' '' PUNCT crl-14593 52 1 it it PRON crl-14593 52 2 does do AUX crl-14593 52 3 not not PART crl-14593 52 4 include include VERB crl-14593 52 5 jews jews PROPN crl-14593 52 6 , , PUNCT crl-14593 52 7 or or CCONJ crl-14593 52 8 blacks black NOUN crl-14593 52 9 , , PUNCT crl-14593 52 10 or or CCONJ crl-14593 52 11 asians asian NOUN crl-14593 52 12 , , PUNCT crl-14593 52 13 or or CCONJ crl-14593 52 14 many many ADJ crl-14593 52 15 women woman NOUN crl-14593 52 16 of of ADP crl-14593 52 17 any any DET crl-14593 52 18 race race NOUN crl-14593 52 19 . . PUNCT crl-14593 53 1 while while SCONJ crl-14593 53 2 kimball kimball PROPN crl-14593 53 3 makes make VERB crl-14593 53 4 some some DET crl-14593 53 5 valid valid ADJ crl-14593 53 6 criti­ criti­ NOUN crl-14593 53 7 cism cism NOUN crl-14593 53 8 of of ADP crl-14593 53 9 the the DET crl-14593 53 10 current current ADJ crl-14593 53 11 trends trend NOUN crl-14593 53 12 in in ADP crl-14593 53 13 critical critical ADJ crl-14593 53 14 the­ the­ NOUN crl-14593 53 15 ory ory PROPN crl-14593 53 16 , , PUNCT crl-14593 53 17 these these DET crl-14593 53 18 points point NOUN crl-14593 53 19 would would AUX crl-14593 53 20 be be AUX crl-14593 53 21 better well ADV crl-14593 53 22 made make VERB crl-14593 53 23 elsewhere elsewhere ADV crl-14593 53 24 . . PUNCT crl-14593 54 1 the the DET crl-14593 54 2 book book NOUN crl-14593 54 3 often often ADV crl-14593 54 4 strays stray VERB crl-14593 54 5 too too ADV crl-14593 54 6 far far ADV crl-14593 54 7 from from ADP crl-14593 54 8 its its PRON crl-14593 54 9 main main ADJ crl-14593 54 10 thesis thesis NOUN crl-14593 54 11 , , PUNCT crl-14593 54 12 giving give VERB crl-14593 54 13 the the DET crl-14593 54 14 impres­ impres­ ADJ crl-14593 54 15 sion sion NOUN crl-14593 54 16 that that SCONJ crl-14593 54 17 the the DET crl-14593 54 18 thesis thesis NOUN crl-14593 54 19 itself itself PRON crl-14593 54 20 was be AUX crl-14593 54 21 an an DET crl-14593 54 22 after­ after­ NOUN crl-14593 54 23 thought thought NOUN crl-14593 54 24 , , PUNCT crl-14593 54 25 inserted insert VERB crl-14593 54 26 to to PART crl-14593 54 27 set set VERB crl-14593 54 28 the the DET crl-14593 54 29 book book NOUN crl-14593 54 30 apart apart ADV crl-14593 54 31 from from ADP crl-14593 54 32 others other NOUN crl-14593 54 33 of of ADP crl-14593 54 34 its its PRON crl-14593 54 35 genre genre NOUN crl-14593 54 36 . . PUNCT crl-14593 55 1 the the DET crl-14593 55 2 thesis thesis NOUN crl-14593 55 3 is be AUX crl-14593 55 4 no­ no­ NOUN crl-14593 55 5 where where SCONJ crl-14593 55 6 proven prove VERB crl-14593 55 7 and and CCONJ crl-14593 55 8 amounts amount VERB crl-14593 55 9 to to ADP crl-14593 55 10 nothing nothing PRON crl-14593 55 11 more more ADJ crl-14593 55 12 than than ADP crl-14593 55 13 an an DET crl-14593 55 14 oversimplification oversimplification NOUN crl-14593 55 15 of of ADP crl-14593 55 16 a a DET crl-14593 55 17 com­ com­ PROPN crl-14593 55 18 plex plex NOUN crl-14593 55 19 problem problem NOUN crl-14593 55 20 . . PUNCT crl-14593 56 1 the the DET crl-14593 56 2 recent recent ADJ crl-14593 56 3 elimination elimination NOUN crl-14593 56 4 of of ADP crl-14593 56 5 the the DET crl-14593 56 6 western western ADJ crl-14593 56 7 civilization civilization NOUN crl-14593 56 8 requirement requirement NOUN crl-14593 56 9 at at ADP crl-14593 56 10 stanford stanford PROPN crl-14593 56 11 is be AUX crl-14593 56 12 offered offer VERB crl-14593 56 13 as as ADP crl-14593 56 14 proof proof NOUN crl-14593 56 15 of of ADP crl-14593 56 16 the the DET crl-14593 56 17 politici­ politici­ ADJ crl-14593 56 18 zation zation NOUN crl-14593 56 19 of of ADP crl-14593 56 20 the the DET crl-14593 56 21 curriculum curriculum NOUN crl-14593 56 22 . . PUNCT crl-14593 57 1 yet yet ADV crl-14593 57 2 , , PUNCT crl-14593 57 3 we we PRON crl-14593 57 4 are be AUX crl-14593 57 5 soon soon ADV crl-14593 57 6 told tell VERB crl-14593 57 7 that that SCONJ crl-14593 57 8 this this DET crl-14593 57 9 requirement requirement NOUN crl-14593 57 10 had have AUX crl-14593 57 11 been be AUX crl-14593 57 12 estab­ estab­ NOUN crl-14593 57 13 lished lishe VERB crl-14593 57 14 only only ADV crl-14593 57 15 in in ADP crl-14593 57 16 1980 1980 NUM crl-14593 57 17 . . PUNCT crl-14593 58 1 hallowed hallowed ADJ crl-14593 58 2 tradition tradition NOUN crl-14593 58 3 ! ! PUNCT crl-14593 59 1 kimball kimball NOUN crl-14593 59 2 gets get VERB crl-14593 59 3 closer close ADJ crl-14593 59 4 to to ADP crl-14593 59 5 the the DET crl-14593 59 6 real real ADJ crl-14593 59 7 problems problem NOUN crl-14593 59 8 when when SCONJ crl-14593 59 9 he he PRON crl-14593 59 10 quotes quote VERB crl-14593 59 11 hannah hannah PROPN crl-14593 59 12 arendt arendt PROPN crl-14593 59 13 on on ADP crl-14593 59 14 the the DET crl-14593 59 15 crisis crisis NOUN crl-14593 59 16 of of ADP crl-14593 59 17 authority authority NOUN crl-14593 59 18 in in ADP crl-14593 59 19 modern modern ADJ crl-14593 59 20 education education NOUN crl-14593 59 21 , , PUNCT crl-14593 59 22 and and CCONJ crl-14593 59 23 he he PRON crl-14593 59 24 himself himself PRON crl-14593 59 25 makes make VERB crl-14593 59 26 the the DET crl-14593 59 27 observation observation NOUN crl-14593 59 28 that that SCONJ crl-14593 59 29 she she PRON crl-14593 59 30 was be AUX crl-14593 59 31 writing write VERB crl-14593 59 32 in in ADP crl-14593 59 33 1958 1958 NUM crl-14593 59 34 ! ! PUNCT crl-14593 60 1 the the DET crl-14593 60 2 problems problem NOUN crl-14593 60 3 of of ADP crl-14593 60 4 higher high ADJ crl-14593 60 5 education education NOUN crl-14593 60 6 , , PUNCT crl-14593 60 7 then then ADV crl-14593 60 8 , , PUNCT crl-14593 60 9 have have VERB crl-14593 60 10 deeper deep ADJ crl-14593 60 11 and and CCONJ crl-14593 60 12 more more ADV crl-14593 60 13 complex complex ADJ crl-14593 60 14 roots root NOUN crl-14593 60 15 than than SCONJ crl-14593 60 16 kimball kimball PROPN crl-14593 60 17 would would AUX crl-14593 60 18 have have VERB crl-14593 60 19 us we PRON crl-14593 60 20 believe believe VERB crl-14593 60 21 . . PUNCT crl-14593 61 1 and and CCONJ crl-14593 61 2 the the DET crl-14593 61 3 origins origin NOUN crl-14593 61 4 and and CCONJ crl-14593 61 5 nature nature NOUN crl-14593 61 6 of of ADP crl-14593 61 7 the the DET crl-14593 61 8 humanities humanity NOUN crl-14593 61 9 cur­ cur­ ADJ crl-14593 61 10 riculum riculum PROPN crl-14593 61 11 are be AUX crl-14593 61 12 not not PART crl-14593 61 13 so so ADV crl-14593 61 14 apolitical apolitical ADJ crl-14593 61 15 . . PUNCT crl-14593 62 1 for for ADP crl-14593 62 2 a a DET crl-14593 62 3 better well ADJ crl-14593 62 4 treatment treatment NOUN crl-14593 62 5 of of ADP crl-14593 62 6 this this DET crl-14593 62 7 topic topic NOUN crl-14593 62 8 , , PUNCT crl-14593 62 9 see see VERB crl-14593 62 10 anthony anthony PROPN crl-14593 62 11 graf­ graf­ PROPN crl-14593 62 12 ton ton PROPN crl-14593 62 13 and and CCONJ crl-14593 62 14 lisa lisa PROPN crl-14593 62 15 jardine jardine PROPN crl-14593 62 16 , , PUNCT crl-14593 62 17 from from ADP crl-14593 62 18 humanism humanism NOUN crl-14593 62 19 to to ADP crl-14593 62 20 the the DET crl-14593 62 21 humanities humanity NOUN crl-14593 62 22 . . PUNCT crl-14593 63 1 kimball kimball PROPN crl-14593 63 2 exaggerates exaggerate VERB crl-14593 63 3 when when SCONJ crl-14593 63 4 he he PRON crl-14593 63 5 portrays portray VERB crl-14593 63 6 current current ADJ crl-14593 63 7 intellectual intellectual ADJ crl-14593 63 8 fads fad NOUN crl-14593 63 9 as as ADP crl-14593 63 10 dan­ dan­ ADJ crl-14593 63 11 gerous gerous ADJ crl-14593 63 12 political political ADJ crl-14593 63 13 dogma dogma NOUN crl-14593 63 14 , , PUNCT crl-14593 63 15 and and CCONJ crl-14593 63 16 their their PRON crl-14593 63 17 provoca­ provoca­ NOUN crl-14593 63 18 tive tive NOUN crl-14593 63 19 adherents adherent NOUN crl-14593 63 20 as as ADP crl-14593 63 21 the the DET crl-14593 63 22 ' ' PUNCT crl-14593 63 23 i i PRON crl-14593 63 24 establishment establishment NOUN crl-14593 63 25 '' '' PUNCT crl-14593 63 26 of of ADP crl-14593 63 27 american american ADJ crl-14593 63 28 higher high ADJ crl-14593 63 29 education education NOUN crl-14593 63 30 . . PUNCT crl-14593 64 1 while while SCONJ crl-14593 64 2 the the DET crl-14593 64 3 western western ADJ crl-14593 64 4 civilization civilization NOUN crl-14593 64 5 canon canon NOUN crl-14593 64 6 is be AUX crl-14593 64 7 being be AUX crl-14593 64 8 ques­ ques­ NOUN crl-14593 64 9 tioned tione VERB crl-14593 64 10 , , PUNCT crl-14593 64 11 it it PRON crl-14593 64 12 is be AUX crl-14593 64 13 still still ADV crl-14593 64 14 taught teach VERB crl-14593 64 15 almost almost ADV crl-14593 64 16 every­ every­ PRON crl-14593 64 17 where where SCONJ crl-14593 64 18 . . PUNCT crl-14593 65 1 does do AUX crl-14593 65 2 anyone anyone PRON crl-14593 65 3 read read VERB crl-14593 65 4 milton milton NOUN crl-14593 65 5 other other ADJ crl-14593 65 6 than than ADP crl-14593 65 7 on on ADP crl-14593 65 8 a a DET crl-14593 65 9 college college NOUN crl-14593 65 10 campus campus NOUN crl-14593 65 11 ? ? PUNCT crl-14593 66 1 kimball kimball PROPN crl-14593 66 2 writes write VERB crl-14593 66 3 well well ADV crl-14593 66 4 ( ( PUNCT crl-14593 66 5 unlike unlike ADP crl-14593 66 6 his his PRON crl-14593 66 7 academic academic ADJ crl-14593 66 8 targets target NOUN crl-14593 66 9 ) ) PUNCT crl-14593 66 10 , , PUNCT crl-14593 66 11 and and CCONJ crl-14593 66 12 is be AUX crl-14593 66 13 very very ADV crl-14593 66 14 entertaining entertaining ADJ crl-14593 66 15 , , PUNCT crl-14593 66 16 but but CCONJ crl-14593 66 17 his his PRON crl-14593 66 18 book book NOUN crl-14593 66 19 will will AUX crl-14593 66 20 not not PART crl-14593 66 21 stand stand VERB crl-14593 66 22 as as ADP crl-14593 66 23 a a DET crl-14593 66 24 major major ADJ crl-14593 66 25 contribution contribution NOUN crl-14593 66 26 to to ADP crl-14593 66 27 the the DET crl-14593 66 28 cur­ cur­ ADJ crl-14593 66 29 rent rent NOUN crl-14593 66 30 debate.-william debate.-william PUNCT crl-14593 66 31 s. s. PROPN crl-14593 66 32 monroe monroe PROPN crl-14593 66 33 , , PUNCT crl-14593 66 34 new new PROPN crl-14593 66 35 york york PROPN crl-14593 66 36 university university PROPN crl-14593 66 37 libraries library NOUN crl-14593 66 38 . . PUNCT