id sid tid token lemma pos crl-16614 1 1 52 52 NUM crl-16614 1 2 format format NOUN crl-16614 1 3 aside aside ADV crl-16614 1 4 : : PUNCT crl-16614 1 5 applying apply VERB crl-16614 1 6 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 1 7 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 1 8 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 1 9 to to PART crl-16614 1 10 assess assess VERB crl-16614 1 11 the the DET crl-16614 1 12 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 1 13 nature nature NOUN crl-16614 1 14 of of ADP crl-16614 1 15 both both PRON crl-16614 1 16 oa oa ADJ crl-16614 1 17 and and CCONJ crl-16614 1 18 non non ADJ crl-16614 1 19 - - ADJ crl-16614 1 20 oa oa ADJ crl-16614 1 21 library library NOUN crl-16614 1 22 and and CCONJ crl-16614 1 23 information information NOUN crl-16614 1 24 science science NOUN crl-16614 1 25 journals journals PROPN crl-16614 1 26 joseph joseph PROPN crl-16614 1 27 d. d. PROPN crl-16614 1 28 olivarez olivarez PROPN crl-16614 1 29 , , PUNCT crl-16614 1 30 stephen stephen PROPN crl-16614 1 31 bales bales PROPN crl-16614 1 32 , , PUNCT crl-16614 1 33 laura laura PROPN crl-16614 1 34 sare sare PROPN crl-16614 1 35 , , PUNCT crl-16614 1 36 and and CCONJ crl-16614 1 37 wyoma wyoma PROPN crl-16614 1 38 vanduinkerken vanduinkerken PROPN crl-16614 1 39 * * PROPN crl-16614 1 40 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 1 41 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 1 42 ’s ’s PROPN crl-16614 1 43 blog blog NOUN crl-16614 1 44 listing listing NOUN crl-16614 1 45 of of ADP crl-16614 1 46 potential potential ADJ crl-16614 1 47 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 1 48 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 1 49 and and CCONJ crl-16614 1 50 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 1 51 , , PUNCT crl-16614 1 52 as as ADV crl-16614 1 53 well well ADV crl-16614 1 54 as as ADP crl-16614 1 55 his his PRON crl-16614 1 56 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 1 57 for for ADP crl-16614 1 58 determining determine VERB crl-16614 1 59 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 1 60 open open ADJ crl-16614 1 61 - - PUNCT crl-16614 1 62 access access NOUN crl-16614 1 63 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 1 64 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 1 65 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 1 66 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 1 67 are be AUX crl-16614 1 68 often often ADV crl-16614 1 69 looked look VERB crl-16614 1 70 at at ADP crl-16614 1 71 as as ADP crl-16614 1 72 tools tool NOUN crl-16614 1 73 to to PART crl-16614 1 74 help help VERB crl-16614 1 75 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 1 76 avoid avoid VERB crl-16614 1 77 publishing publish VERB crl-16614 1 78 in in ADP crl-16614 1 79 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 1 80 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 1 81 . . PUNCT crl-16614 2 1 while while SCONJ crl-16614 2 2 these these DET crl-16614 2 3 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 2 4 has have AUX crl-16614 2 5 brought bring VERB crl-16614 2 6 a a DET crl-16614 2 7 greater great ADJ crl-16614 2 8 awareness awareness NOUN crl-16614 2 9 of of ADP crl-16614 2 10 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 2 11 predatory predatory PROPN crl-16614 2 12 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 2 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 2 14 these these DET crl-16614 2 15 tools tool NOUN crl-16614 2 16 alone alone ADV crl-16614 2 17 should should AUX crl-16614 2 18 not not PART crl-16614 2 19 be be AUX crl-16614 2 20 used use VERB crl-16614 2 21 as as ADP crl-16614 2 22 the the DET crl-16614 2 23 only only ADJ crl-16614 2 24 source source NOUN crl-16614 2 25 in in ADP crl-16614 2 26 determining determine VERB crl-16614 2 27 the the DET crl-16614 2 28 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 2 29 of of ADP crl-16614 2 30 a a DET crl-16614 2 31 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 2 32 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 2 33 . . PUNCT crl-16614 3 1 employing employ VERB crl-16614 3 2 a a DET crl-16614 3 3 three three NUM crl-16614 3 4 - - PUNCT crl-16614 3 5 person person NOUN crl-16614 3 6 independent independent ADJ crl-16614 3 7 judgment judgment NOUN crl-16614 3 8 making make VERB crl-16614 3 9 panel panel NOUN crl-16614 3 10 , , PUNCT crl-16614 3 11 this this DET crl-16614 3 12 study study NOUN crl-16614 3 13 demonstrates demonstrate VERB crl-16614 3 14 the the DET crl-16614 3 15 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 3 16 nature nature NOUN crl-16614 3 17 of of ADP crl-16614 3 18 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 3 19 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 3 20 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 3 21 by by ADP crl-16614 3 22 applying apply VERB crl-16614 3 23 his his PRON crl-16614 3 24 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 3 25 to to ADP crl-16614 3 26 both both PRON crl-16614 3 27 oa oa VERB crl-16614 3 28 and and CCONJ crl-16614 3 29 non non ADJ crl-16614 3 30 - - ADJ crl-16614 3 31 oa oa ADJ crl-16614 3 32 library library NOUN crl-16614 3 33 and and CCONJ crl-16614 3 34 information information NOUN crl-16614 3 35 science science NOUN crl-16614 3 36 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 3 37 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 3 38 lis lis PROPN crl-16614 3 39 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 3 40 , , PUNCT crl-16614 3 41 to to PART crl-16614 3 42 demonstrate demonstrate VERB crl-16614 3 43 that that SCONJ crl-16614 3 44 traditional traditional ADJ crl-16614 3 45 peer peer NOUN crl-16614 3 46 - - PUNCT crl-16614 3 47 reviewed review VERB crl-16614 3 48 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 3 49 could could AUX crl-16614 3 50 be be AUX crl-16614 3 51 considered consider VERB crl-16614 3 52 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 3 53 . . PUNCT crl-16614 4 1 many many ADJ crl-16614 4 2 of of ADP crl-16614 4 3 these these DET crl-16614 4 4 lis lis ADJ crl-16614 4 5 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 4 6 are be AUX crl-16614 4 7 considered consider VERB crl-16614 4 8 as as ADP crl-16614 4 9 top top ADJ crl-16614 4 10 - - PUNCT crl-16614 4 11 tier tier NOUN crl-16614 4 12 publications publication NOUN crl-16614 4 13 in in ADP crl-16614 4 14 the the DET crl-16614 4 15 field field NOUN crl-16614 4 16 and and CCONJ crl-16614 4 17 used use VERB crl-16614 4 18 when when SCONJ crl-16614 4 19 evaluating evaluate VERB crl-16614 4 20 researcher researcher NOUN crl-16614 4 21 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 4 22 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 4 23 history history NOUN crl-16614 4 24 for for ADP crl-16614 4 25 promotion promotion NOUN crl-16614 4 26 and and CCONJ crl-16614 4 27 tenure tenure NOUN crl-16614 4 28 . . PUNCT crl-16614 5 1 introduction introduction NOUN crl-16614 5 2 while while SCONJ crl-16614 5 3 the the DET crl-16614 5 4 open open ADJ crl-16614 5 5 access access NOUN crl-16614 5 6 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 5 7 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 5 8 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 5 9 movement movement NOUN crl-16614 5 10 is be AUX crl-16614 5 11 growing grow VERB crl-16614 5 12 throughout throughout ADP crl-16614 5 13 academia academia NOUN crl-16614 5 14 and and CCONJ crl-16614 5 15 has have AUX crl-16614 5 16 gained gain VERB crl-16614 5 17 traction traction NOUN crl-16614 5 18 in in ADP crl-16614 5 19 some some DET crl-16614 5 20 disciplines discipline NOUN crl-16614 5 21 , , PUNCT crl-16614 5 22 there there PRON crl-16614 5 23 is be VERB crl-16614 5 24 still still ADV crl-16614 5 25 skepticism skepticism NOUN crl-16614 5 26 on on ADP crl-16614 5 27 the the DET crl-16614 5 28 part part NOUN crl-16614 5 29 of of ADP crl-16614 5 30 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 5 31 who who PRON crl-16614 5 32 question question VERB crl-16614 5 33 the the DET crl-16614 5 34 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 5 35 of of ADP crl-16614 5 36 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 5 37 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 5 38 and and CCONJ crl-16614 5 39 may may AUX crl-16614 5 40 associate associate VERB crl-16614 5 41 oa oa ADP crl-16614 5 42 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 5 43 with with ADP crl-16614 5 44 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 5 45 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 5 46 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 5 47 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 5 48 . . PUNCT crl-16614 6 1 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 6 2 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 6 3 defines define VERB crl-16614 6 4 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 6 5 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 6 6 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 6 7 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 6 8 as as ADP crl-16614 6 9 those those PRON crl-16614 6 10 that that PRON crl-16614 6 11 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 6 12 exploit exploit VERB crl-16614 6 13 the the DET crl-16614 6 14 gold gold NOUN crl-16614 6 15 open open ADJ crl-16614 6 16 - - PUNCT crl-16614 6 17 access access NOUN crl-16614 6 18 model model NOUN crl-16614 6 19 for for ADP crl-16614 6 20 their their PRON crl-16614 6 21 own own ADJ crl-16614 6 22 profit profit NOUN crl-16614 6 23 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 6 24 while while SCONJ crl-16614 6 25 not not PART crl-16614 6 26 engaging engage VERB crl-16614 6 27 in in ADP crl-16614 6 28 a a DET crl-16614 6 29 rigorous rigorous ADJ crl-16614 6 30 peer peer NOUN crl-16614 6 31 review review NOUN crl-16614 6 32 process.1 process.1 NOUN crl-16614 6 33 beall beall NOUN crl-16614 6 34 developed develop VERB crl-16614 6 35 a a DET crl-16614 6 36 tool tool NOUN crl-16614 6 37 on on ADP crl-16614 6 38 his his PRON crl-16614 6 39 blog blog NOUN crl-16614 6 40 to to PART crl-16614 6 41 help help VERB crl-16614 6 42 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 6 43 identify identify VERB crl-16614 6 44 potential potential ADJ crl-16614 6 45 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 6 46 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 6 47 and and CCONJ crl-16614 6 48 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 6 49 . . PUNCT crl-16614 7 1 this this DET crl-16614 7 2 tool tool NOUN crl-16614 7 3 is be AUX crl-16614 7 4 a a DET crl-16614 7 5 list list NOUN crl-16614 7 6 of of ADP crl-16614 7 7 potential potential ADJ crl-16614 7 8 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 7 9 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 7 10 and and CCONJ crl-16614 7 11 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 7 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 7 13 as as ADV crl-16614 7 14 well well ADV crl-16614 7 15 as as ADP crl-16614 7 16 the the DET crl-16614 7 17 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 7 18 for for ADP crl-16614 7 19 determining determine VERB crl-16614 7 20 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 7 21 open open ADJ crl-16614 7 22 - - PUNCT crl-16614 7 23 access access NOUN crl-16614 7 24 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 7 25 . . PUNCT crl-16614 8 1 joseph joseph PROPN crl-16614 8 2 d. d. PROPN crl-16614 8 3 olivarez olivarez PROPN crl-16614 8 4 is be AUX crl-16614 8 5 serials serial NOUN crl-16614 8 6 cataloging catalog VERB crl-16614 8 7 / / SYM crl-16614 8 8 metadata metadata PROPN crl-16614 8 9 librarian librarian PROPN crl-16614 8 10 , , PUNCT crl-16614 8 11 stephen stephen PROPN crl-16614 8 12 bales bales PROPN crl-16614 8 13 is be AUX crl-16614 8 14 humanities humanity NOUN crl-16614 8 15 and and CCONJ crl-16614 8 16 social social ADJ crl-16614 8 17 sciences sciences PROPN crl-16614 8 18 librarian librarian PROPN crl-16614 8 19 , , PUNCT crl-16614 8 20 laura laura PROPN crl-16614 8 21 sare sare PROPN crl-16614 8 22 is be AUX crl-16614 8 23 government government NOUN crl-16614 8 24 information information NOUN crl-16614 8 25 librarian librarian NOUN crl-16614 8 26 , , PUNCT crl-16614 8 27 and and CCONJ crl-16614 8 28 wyoma wyoma NOUN crl-16614 8 29 vanduinkerken vanduinkerken PROPN crl-16614 8 30 is be AUX crl-16614 8 31 director director NOUN crl-16614 8 32 of of ADP crl-16614 8 33 the the DET crl-16614 8 34 joint joint ADJ crl-16614 8 35 library library NOUN crl-16614 8 36 facility facility NOUN crl-16614 8 37 , , PUNCT crl-16614 8 38 all all PRON crl-16614 8 39 at at ADP crl-16614 8 40 texas texas PROPN crl-16614 8 41 a&m a&m PROPN crl-16614 8 42 university university PROPN crl-16614 8 43 libraries library NOUN crl-16614 8 44 ; ; PUNCT crl-16614 8 45 e e X crl-16614 8 46 - - NOUN crl-16614 8 47 mail mail NOUN crl-16614 8 48 : : PUNCT crl-16614 8 49 jolivare@library jolivare@library PROPN crl-16614 8 50 . . PUNCT crl-16614 9 1 tamu.edu tamu.edu X crl-16614 9 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 9 3 sbales@library.tamu.edu sbales@library.tamu.edu PROPN crl-16614 9 4 , , PUNCT crl-16614 9 5 lsare@library.tamu.edu lsare@library.tamu.edu PROPN crl-16614 9 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 9 7 wvanduin@library.tamu.edu wvanduin@library.tamu.edu NUM crl-16614 9 8 . . PUNCT crl-16614 10 1 © © NOUN crl-16614 10 2 2018 2018 NUM crl-16614 10 3 joseph joseph PROPN crl-16614 10 4 d. d. PROPN crl-16614 10 5 olivarez olivarez PROPN crl-16614 10 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 10 7 stephen stephen PROPN crl-16614 10 8 bales bales PROPN crl-16614 10 9 , , PUNCT crl-16614 10 10 laura laura PROPN crl-16614 10 11 sare sare PROPN crl-16614 10 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 10 13 and and CCONJ crl-16614 10 14 wyoma wyoma PROPN crl-16614 10 15 vanduinkerken vanduinkerken PROPN crl-16614 10 16 , , PUNCT crl-16614 10 17 attribution attribution NOUN crl-16614 10 18 - - PUNCT crl-16614 10 19 noncommercial noncommercial ADJ crl-16614 10 20 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 10 21 http:// http:// NOUN crl-16614 10 22 creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ NOUN crl-16614 10 23 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 10 24 cc cc VERB crl-16614 10 25 by by ADP crl-16614 10 26 - - PUNCT crl-16614 10 27 nc nc PROPN crl-16614 10 28 . . PUNCT crl-16614 10 29 doi:10.5860 doi:10.5860 PROPN crl-16614 10 30 / / SYM crl-16614 10 31 crl.79.1.52 crl.79.1.52 NOUN crl-16614 10 32 mailto:jolivare@library.tamu.edu mailto:jolivare@library.tamu.edu NOUN crl-16614 10 33 mailto:jolivare@library.tamu.edu mailto:jolivare@library.tamu.edu NOUN crl-16614 10 34 mailto:sbales@library.tamu.edu mailto:sbales@library.tamu.edu PROPN crl-16614 11 1 mailto:lsare@library.tamu.edu mailto:lsare@library.tamu.edu PROPN crl-16614 11 2 mailto:wvanduin@library.tamu.edu mailto:wvanduin@library.tamu.edu PROPN crl-16614 11 3 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ PROPN crl-16614 11 4 http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ PROPN crl-16614 11 5 https://doi.org/10.5860/crl.79.1.52 https://doi.org/10.5860/crl.79.1.52 PROPN crl-16614 11 6 format format NOUN crl-16614 11 7 aside aside ADV crl-16614 11 8 53 53 NUM crl-16614 11 9 the the DET crl-16614 11 10 authors author NOUN crl-16614 11 11 of of ADP crl-16614 11 12 this this DET crl-16614 11 13 interpretive interpretive ADJ crl-16614 11 14 analysis analysis NOUN crl-16614 11 15 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 11 16 hereafter hereafter ADV crl-16614 11 17 referred refer VERB crl-16614 11 18 to to ADP crl-16614 11 19 as as ADP crl-16614 11 20 the the DET crl-16614 11 21 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 11 22 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 11 23 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 11 24 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 11 25 believe believe VERB crl-16614 11 26 that that SCONJ crl-16614 11 27 users user NOUN crl-16614 11 28 need need VERB crl-16614 11 29 to to PART crl-16614 11 30 be be AUX crl-16614 11 31 cautioned caution VERB crl-16614 11 32 about about ADP crl-16614 11 33 the the DET crl-16614 11 34 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 11 35 nature nature NOUN crl-16614 11 36 of of ADP crl-16614 11 37 the the DET crl-16614 11 38 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 11 39 . . PUNCT crl-16614 12 1 they they PRON crl-16614 12 2 recommend recommend VERB crl-16614 12 3 discretion discretion NOUN crl-16614 12 4 because because SCONJ crl-16614 12 5 the the DET crl-16614 12 6 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 12 7 used use VERB crl-16614 12 8 are be AUX crl-16614 12 9 so so ADV crl-16614 12 10 general general ADJ crl-16614 12 11 that that SCONJ crl-16614 12 12 an an DET crl-16614 12 13 evaluator evaluator NOUN crl-16614 12 14 might might AUX crl-16614 12 15 label label VERB crl-16614 12 16 a a DET crl-16614 12 17 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 12 18 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 12 19 as as ADP crl-16614 12 20 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 12 21 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 12 22 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 12 23 when when SCONJ crl-16614 12 24 it it PRON crl-16614 12 25 is be AUX crl-16614 12 26 not not PART crl-16614 12 27 or or CCONJ crl-16614 12 28 may may AUX crl-16614 12 29 disregard disregard VERB crl-16614 12 30 the the DET crl-16614 12 31 article article NOUN crl-16614 12 32 as as ADP crl-16614 12 33 being be AUX crl-16614 12 34 without without ADP crl-16614 12 35 merit merit NOUN crl-16614 12 36 solely solely ADV crl-16614 12 37 because because SCONJ crl-16614 12 38 it it PRON crl-16614 12 39 is be AUX crl-16614 12 40 published publish VERB crl-16614 12 41 in in ADP crl-16614 12 42 a a DET crl-16614 12 43 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 12 44 found find VERB crl-16614 12 45 on on ADP crl-16614 12 46 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 12 47 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 12 48 list list NOUN crl-16614 12 49 . . PUNCT crl-16614 13 1 promotion promotion NOUN crl-16614 13 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 13 3 tenure tenure NOUN crl-16614 13 4 committees committee NOUN crl-16614 13 5 may may AUX crl-16614 13 6 even even ADV crl-16614 13 7 look look VERB crl-16614 13 8 to to ADP crl-16614 13 9 this this DET crl-16614 13 10 list list NOUN crl-16614 13 11 when when SCONJ crl-16614 13 12 reviewing review VERB crl-16614 13 13 tenure tenure NOUN crl-16614 13 14 candidate candidate NOUN crl-16614 13 15 publications publication NOUN crl-16614 13 16 , , PUNCT crl-16614 13 17 thereby thereby ADV crl-16614 13 18 influencing influence VERB crl-16614 13 19 future future ADJ crl-16614 13 20 research.2 research.2 PROPN crl-16614 13 21 although although SCONJ crl-16614 13 22 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 13 23 noted note VERB crl-16614 13 24 that that SCONJ crl-16614 13 25 such such ADJ crl-16614 13 26 committees committee NOUN crl-16614 13 27 need need VERB crl-16614 13 28 to to PART crl-16614 13 29 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 13 30 decide decide VERB crl-16614 13 31 for for ADP crl-16614 13 32 themselves themselves PRON crl-16614 13 33 how how SCONJ crl-16614 13 34 importantly importantly ADV crl-16614 13 35 or or CCONJ crl-16614 13 36 not not PART crl-16614 13 37 to to PART crl-16614 13 38 rate rate VERB crl-16614 13 39 articles article NOUN crl-16614 13 40 published publish VERB crl-16614 13 41 in in ADP crl-16614 13 42 these these DET crl-16614 13 43 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 13 44 in in ADP crl-16614 13 45 the the DET crl-16614 13 46 context context NOUN crl-16614 13 47 of of ADP crl-16614 13 48 their their PRON crl-16614 13 49 own own ADJ crl-16614 13 50 institutional institutional ADJ crl-16614 13 51 standards standard NOUN crl-16614 13 52 and/or and/or CCONJ crl-16614 13 53 geocultural geocultural ADJ crl-16614 13 54 locus,”3 locus,”3 PROPN crl-16614 13 55 there there PRON crl-16614 13 56 is be VERB crl-16614 13 57 the the DET crl-16614 13 58 potential potential NOUN crl-16614 13 59 to to AUX crl-16614 13 60 misconstrue misconstrue ADJ crl-16614 13 61 and and CCONJ crl-16614 13 62 misapply misapply VERB crl-16614 13 63 the the DET crl-16614 13 64 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 13 65 in in ADP crl-16614 13 66 terms term NOUN crl-16614 13 67 of of ADP crl-16614 13 68 its its PRON crl-16614 13 69 objectivity objectivity NOUN crl-16614 13 70 . . PUNCT crl-16614 14 1 indiscriminate indiscriminate ADJ crl-16614 14 2 application application NOUN crl-16614 14 3 could could AUX crl-16614 14 4 affect affect VERB crl-16614 14 5 promotion promotion NOUN crl-16614 14 6 and and CCONJ crl-16614 14 7 tenure tenure NOUN crl-16614 14 8 decisions decision NOUN crl-16614 14 9 , , PUNCT crl-16614 14 10 especially especially ADV crl-16614 14 11 those those DET crl-16614 14 12 decisions decision NOUN crl-16614 14 13 concerning concern VERB crl-16614 14 14 faculty faculty NOUN crl-16614 14 15 members member NOUN crl-16614 14 16 in in ADP crl-16614 14 17 emerging emerge VERB crl-16614 14 18 fields field NOUN crl-16614 14 19 of of ADP crl-16614 14 20 scholarship scholarship NOUN crl-16614 14 21 where where SCONJ crl-16614 14 22 needs need VERB crl-16614 14 23 for for ADP crl-16614 14 24 publishing publish VERB crl-16614 14 25 outlets outlet NOUN crl-16614 14 26 are be AUX crl-16614 14 27 met meet VERB crl-16614 14 28 with with ADP crl-16614 14 29 oa oa PROPN crl-16614 14 30 journals.4 journals.4 PROPN crl-16614 14 31 in in ADP crl-16614 14 32 this this DET crl-16614 14 33 study study NOUN crl-16614 14 34 , , PUNCT crl-16614 14 35 the the DET crl-16614 14 36 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 14 37 argue argue VERB crl-16614 14 38 that that SCONJ crl-16614 14 39 the the DET crl-16614 14 40 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 14 41 elements element NOUN crl-16614 14 42 of of ADP crl-16614 14 43 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 14 44 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 14 45 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 14 46 are be AUX crl-16614 14 47 so so ADV crl-16614 14 48 general general ADJ crl-16614 14 49 in in ADP crl-16614 14 50 design design NOUN crl-16614 14 51 that that SCONJ crl-16614 14 52 evaluators evaluator NOUN crl-16614 14 53 might might AUX crl-16614 14 54 broadly broadly ADV crl-16614 14 55 apply apply VERB crl-16614 14 56 them they PRON crl-16614 14 57 as as ADP crl-16614 14 58 measures measure NOUN crl-16614 14 59 of of ADP crl-16614 14 60 illegitimacy illegitimacy NOUN crl-16614 14 61 to to ADP crl-16614 14 62 any any DET crl-16614 14 63 refereed refereed NOUN crl-16614 14 64 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 14 65 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 14 66 , , PUNCT crl-16614 14 67 regardless regardless ADV crl-16614 14 68 of of ADP crl-16614 14 69 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 14 70 model model NOUN crl-16614 14 71 . . PUNCT crl-16614 15 1 by by ADP crl-16614 15 2 applying apply VERB crl-16614 15 3 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 15 4 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 15 5 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 15 6 to to ADP crl-16614 15 7 a a DET crl-16614 15 8 list list NOUN crl-16614 15 9 of of ADP crl-16614 15 10 both both PRON crl-16614 15 11 oa oa ADJ crl-16614 15 12 and and CCONJ crl-16614 15 13 non non ADJ crl-16614 15 14 - - ADJ crl-16614 15 15 oa oa ADJ crl-16614 15 16 well well ADV crl-16614 15 17 - - PUNCT crl-16614 15 18 regarded regard VERB crl-16614 15 19 refereed refereed NOUN crl-16614 15 20 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 15 21 lis lis ADJ crl-16614 15 22 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 15 23 , , PUNCT crl-16614 15 24 this this DET crl-16614 15 25 study study NOUN crl-16614 15 26 demonstrates demonstrate VERB crl-16614 15 27 the the DET crl-16614 15 28 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 15 29 nature nature NOUN crl-16614 15 30 of of ADP crl-16614 15 31 his his PRON crl-16614 15 32 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 15 33 . . PUNCT crl-16614 16 1 while while SCONJ crl-16614 16 2 the the DET crl-16614 16 3 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 16 4 may may AUX crl-16614 16 5 serve serve VERB crl-16614 16 6 as as ADP crl-16614 16 7 an an DET crl-16614 16 8 aid aid NOUN crl-16614 16 9 to to ADP crl-16614 16 10 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 16 11 ’ ’ PART crl-16614 16 12 selecting select VERB crl-16614 16 13 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 16 14 outlets outlet NOUN crl-16614 16 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 16 16 this this DET crl-16614 16 17 criteria criteria NOUN crl-16614 16 18 is be AUX crl-16614 16 19 presently presently ADV crl-16614 16 20 not not PART crl-16614 16 21 adequate adequate ADJ crl-16614 16 22 for for ADP crl-16614 16 23 making make VERB crl-16614 16 24 such such ADJ crl-16614 16 25 determinations determination NOUN crl-16614 16 26 because because SCONJ crl-16614 16 27 its its PRON crl-16614 16 28 elements element NOUN crl-16614 16 29 focus focus VERB crl-16614 16 30 more more ADV crl-16614 16 31 on on ADP crl-16614 16 32 the the DET crl-16614 16 33 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 16 34 and/or and/or CCONJ crl-16614 16 35 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 16 36 attributes attribute VERB crl-16614 16 37 rather rather ADV crl-16614 16 38 than than ADP crl-16614 16 39 the the DET crl-16614 16 40 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 16 41 of of ADP crl-16614 16 42 articles article NOUN crl-16614 16 43 published publish VERB crl-16614 16 44 by by ADP crl-16614 16 45 the the DET crl-16614 16 46 outlet outlet NOUN crl-16614 16 47 . . PUNCT crl-16614 17 1 literature literature NOUN crl-16614 17 2 review review VERB crl-16614 17 3 the the DET crl-16614 17 4 rising rise VERB crl-16614 17 5 cost cost NOUN crl-16614 17 6 of of ADP crl-16614 17 7 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 17 8 subscriptions subscription NOUN crl-16614 17 9 at at ADP crl-16614 17 10 the the DET crl-16614 17 11 end end NOUN crl-16614 17 12 of of ADP crl-16614 17 13 the the DET crl-16614 17 14 20th 20th ADJ crl-16614 17 15 century century NOUN crl-16614 17 16 created create VERB crl-16614 17 17 a a DET crl-16614 17 18 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 17 19 serials serial NOUN crl-16614 17 20 crisis crisis NOUN crl-16614 17 21 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 17 22 rendering render VERB crl-16614 17 23 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 17 24 unable unable ADJ crl-16614 17 25 to to PART crl-16614 17 26 afford afford VERB crl-16614 17 27 to to PART crl-16614 17 28 purchase purchase VERB crl-16614 17 29 all all PRON crl-16614 17 30 of of ADP crl-16614 17 31 the the DET crl-16614 17 32 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 17 33 literature literature NOUN crl-16614 17 34 needed need VERB crl-16614 17 35 to to PART crl-16614 17 36 support support VERB crl-16614 17 37 the the DET crl-16614 17 38 research research NOUN crl-16614 17 39 and and CCONJ crl-16614 17 40 educational educational ADJ crl-16614 17 41 missions mission NOUN crl-16614 17 42 of of ADP crl-16614 17 43 their their PRON crl-16614 17 44 institutions institution NOUN crl-16614 17 45 . . PUNCT crl-16614 18 1 however however ADV crl-16614 18 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 18 3 by by ADP crl-16614 18 4 the the DET crl-16614 18 5 1990s 1990s NUM crl-16614 18 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 18 7 the the DET crl-16614 18 8 world world NOUN crl-16614 18 9 wide wide ADJ crl-16614 18 10 web web NOUN crl-16614 18 11 became become VERB crl-16614 18 12 increasingly increasingly ADV crl-16614 18 13 available available ADJ crl-16614 18 14 to to ADP crl-16614 18 15 the the DET crl-16614 18 16 general general ADJ crl-16614 18 17 population population NOUN crl-16614 18 18 and and CCONJ crl-16614 18 19 enabled enable VERB crl-16614 18 20 the the DET crl-16614 18 21 proliferation proliferation NOUN crl-16614 18 22 of of ADP crl-16614 18 23 online online ADJ crl-16614 18 24 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 18 25 and and CCONJ crl-16614 18 26 , , PUNCT crl-16614 18 27 in in ADP crl-16614 18 28 turn turn NOUN crl-16614 18 29 , , PUNCT crl-16614 18 30 the the DET crl-16614 18 31 growth growth NOUN crl-16614 18 32 of of ADP crl-16614 18 33 the the DET crl-16614 18 34 oa oa PROPN crl-16614 18 35 movement movement NOUN crl-16614 18 36 . . PUNCT crl-16614 19 1 according accord VERB crl-16614 19 2 to to ADP crl-16614 19 3 suber suber NOUN crl-16614 19 4 , , PUNCT crl-16614 19 5 oa oa PROPN crl-16614 19 6 scholarship scholarship NOUN crl-16614 19 7 represents represent VERB crl-16614 19 8 an an DET crl-16614 19 9 attempt attempt NOUN crl-16614 19 10 to to PART crl-16614 19 11 circumvent circumvent VERB crl-16614 19 12 traditional traditional ADJ crl-16614 19 13 obstacles obstacle NOUN crl-16614 19 14 to to PART crl-16614 19 15 access.5 access.5 VERB crl-16614 19 16 this this DET crl-16614 19 17 practice practice NOUN crl-16614 19 18 of of ADP crl-16614 19 19 making make VERB crl-16614 19 20 content content NOUN crl-16614 19 21 freely freely ADV crl-16614 19 22 available available ADJ crl-16614 19 23 to to AUX crl-16614 19 24 access access NOUN crl-16614 19 25 online online ADV crl-16614 19 26 is be AUX crl-16614 19 27 significantly significantly ADV crl-16614 19 28 different different ADJ crl-16614 19 29 from from ADP crl-16614 19 30 the the DET crl-16614 19 31 traditional traditional ADJ crl-16614 19 32 for for ADP crl-16614 19 33 - - PUNCT crl-16614 19 34 profit profit NOUN crl-16614 19 35 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 19 36 model model NOUN crl-16614 19 37 that that SCONJ crl-16614 19 38 libraries library NOUN crl-16614 19 39 were be AUX crl-16614 19 40 required require VERB crl-16614 19 41 to to PART crl-16614 19 42 deal deal VERB crl-16614 19 43 with with ADP crl-16614 19 44 to to PART crl-16614 19 45 purchase purchase VERB crl-16614 19 46 access access NOUN crl-16614 19 47 to to ADP crl-16614 19 48 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 19 49 information information NOUN crl-16614 19 50 . . PUNCT crl-16614 20 1 some some DET crl-16614 20 2 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 20 3 have have AUX crl-16614 20 4 transformed transform VERB crl-16614 20 5 themselves themselves PRON crl-16614 20 6 from from ADP crl-16614 20 7 being be AUX crl-16614 20 8 content content NOUN crl-16614 20 9 providers provider NOUN crl-16614 20 10 to to ADP crl-16614 20 11 their their PRON crl-16614 20 12 readers reader NOUN crl-16614 20 13 to to ADP crl-16614 20 14 being be AUX crl-16614 20 15 service service NOUN crl-16614 20 16 providers provider NOUN crl-16614 20 17 to to ADP crl-16614 20 18 their their PRON crl-16614 20 19 authors author NOUN crl-16614 20 20 . . PUNCT crl-16614 21 1 these these DET crl-16614 21 2 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 21 3 charge charge VERB crl-16614 21 4 authors author NOUN crl-16614 21 5 a a DET crl-16614 21 6 fee fee NOUN crl-16614 21 7 to to PART crl-16614 21 8 publish publish VERB crl-16614 21 9 in in ADP crl-16614 21 10 their their PRON crl-16614 21 11 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 21 12 as as ADP crl-16614 21 13 a a DET crl-16614 21 14 way way NOUN crl-16614 21 15 of of ADP crl-16614 21 16 offsetting offset VERB crl-16614 21 17 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 21 18 costs.6 costs.6 NOUN crl-16614 21 19 charging charge VERB crl-16614 21 20 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 21 21 fees fee NOUN crl-16614 21 22 to to ADP crl-16614 21 23 authors author NOUN crl-16614 21 24 is be AUX crl-16614 21 25 not not PART crl-16614 21 26 a a DET crl-16614 21 27 new new ADJ crl-16614 21 28 concept concept NOUN crl-16614 21 29 . . PUNCT crl-16614 22 1 many many ADJ crl-16614 22 2 print print NOUN crl-16614 22 3 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 22 4 have have AUX crl-16614 22 5 been be AUX crl-16614 22 6 charging charge VERB crl-16614 22 7 authors author NOUN crl-16614 22 8 page page VERB crl-16614 22 9 charges charge NOUN crl-16614 22 10 to to PART crl-16614 22 11 offset offset VERB crl-16614 22 12 the the DET crl-16614 22 13 cost cost NOUN crl-16614 22 14 of of ADP crl-16614 22 15 publishing.7 publishing.7 PROPN crl-16614 22 16 shen shen PROPN crl-16614 22 17 and and CCONJ crl-16614 22 18 björk björk PROPN crl-16614 22 19 contended contend VERB crl-16614 22 20 that that SCONJ crl-16614 22 21 basic basic ADJ crl-16614 22 22 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 22 23 practices practice NOUN crl-16614 22 24 and and CCONJ crl-16614 22 25 elements element NOUN crl-16614 22 26 of of ADP crl-16614 22 27 article article NOUN crl-16614 22 28 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 22 29 , , PUNCT crl-16614 22 30 including include VERB crl-16614 22 31 peer peer NOUN crl-16614 22 32 review review NOUN crl-16614 22 33 , , PUNCT crl-16614 22 34 have have AUX crl-16614 22 35 not not PART crl-16614 22 36 changed change VERB crl-16614 22 37 appreciably.8 appreciably.8 PROPN crl-16614 22 38 because because SCONJ crl-16614 22 39 some some DET crl-16614 22 40 oa oa PROPN crl-16614 22 41 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 22 42 charge charge VERB crl-16614 22 43 a a DET crl-16614 22 44 fee fee NOUN crl-16614 22 45 , , PUNCT crl-16614 22 46 despite despite SCONJ crl-16614 22 47 having have VERB crl-16614 22 48 no no DET crl-16614 22 49 print print NOUN crl-16614 22 50 costs cost NOUN crl-16614 22 51 to to PART crl-16614 22 52 cover cover VERB crl-16614 22 53 , , PUNCT crl-16614 22 54 the the DET crl-16614 22 55 practice practice NOUN crl-16614 22 56 of of ADP crl-16614 22 57 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 22 58 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 22 59 charging charge VERB crl-16614 22 60 fees fee NOUN crl-16614 22 61 has have AUX crl-16614 22 62 opened open VERB crl-16614 22 63 up up ADP crl-16614 22 64 debate debate NOUN crl-16614 22 65 about about ADP crl-16614 22 66 questions question NOUN crl-16614 22 67 of of ADP crl-16614 22 68 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 22 69 , , PUNCT crl-16614 22 70 and and CCONJ crl-16614 22 71 whether whether SCONJ crl-16614 22 72 authors author NOUN crl-16614 22 73 are be AUX crl-16614 22 74 simply simply ADV crl-16614 22 75 paying pay VERB crl-16614 22 76 to to PART crl-16614 22 77 have have VERB crl-16614 22 78 their their PRON crl-16614 22 79 work work NOUN crl-16614 22 80 published publish VERB crl-16614 22 81 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 22 82 rather rather ADV crl-16614 22 83 than than ADP crl-16614 22 84 publishing publish VERB crl-16614 22 85 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 22 86 work work NOUN crl-16614 22 87 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 22 88 . . PUNCT crl-16614 23 1 for for ADP crl-16614 23 2 example example NOUN crl-16614 23 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 23 4 a a DET crl-16614 23 5 survey survey NOUN crl-16614 23 6 by by ADP crl-16614 23 7 swan swan NOUN crl-16614 23 8 and and CCONJ crl-16614 23 9 brown brown NOUN crl-16614 23 10 that that SCONJ crl-16614 23 11 compared compare VERB crl-16614 23 12 the the DET crl-16614 23 13 opinions opinion NOUN crl-16614 23 14 of of ADP crl-16614 23 15 authors author NOUN crl-16614 23 16 who who PRON crl-16614 23 17 had have AUX crl-16614 23 18 published publish VERB crl-16614 23 19 in in ADP crl-16614 23 20 oa oa ADP crl-16614 23 21 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 23 22 and and CCONJ crl-16614 23 23 those those PRON crl-16614 23 24 who who PRON crl-16614 23 25 had have AUX crl-16614 23 26 not not PART crl-16614 23 27 yet yet ADV crl-16614 23 28 published publish VERB crl-16614 23 29 in in ADP crl-16614 23 30 oa oa PRON crl-16614 23 31 showed show VERB crl-16614 23 32 that that SCONJ crl-16614 23 33 non non ADJ crl-16614 23 34 - - ADJ crl-16614 23 35 oa oa ADJ crl-16614 23 36 authors author NOUN crl-16614 23 37 perceived perceive VERB crl-16614 23 38 oa oa ADP crl-16614 23 39 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 23 40 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 23 41 to to PART crl-16614 23 42 be be AUX crl-16614 23 43 of of ADP crl-16614 23 44 lower low ADJ crl-16614 23 45 reputation reputation NOUN crl-16614 23 46 and and CCONJ crl-16614 23 47 prestige prestige NOUN crl-16614 23 48 . . PUNCT crl-16614 23 49 ”9 ”9 SPACE crl-16614 24 1 it it PRON crl-16614 24 2 can can AUX crl-16614 24 3 only only ADV crl-16614 24 4 be be AUX crl-16614 24 5 assumed assume VERB crl-16614 24 6 that that SCONJ crl-16614 24 7 oa oa PROPN crl-16614 24 8 authors author NOUN crl-16614 24 9 did do AUX crl-16614 24 10 not not PART crl-16614 24 11 perceive perceive VERB crl-16614 24 12 oa oa ADP crl-16614 24 13 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 24 14 the the DET crl-16614 24 15 same same ADJ crl-16614 24 16 way way NOUN crl-16614 24 17 . . PUNCT crl-16614 25 1 coonin coonin ADJ crl-16614 25 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 25 3 younce younce NOUN crl-16614 25 4 also also ADV crl-16614 25 5 found find VERB crl-16614 25 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 25 7 among among ADP crl-16614 25 8 social social ADJ crl-16614 25 9 sciences science NOUN crl-16614 25 10 and and CCONJ crl-16614 25 11 humanities humanity NOUN crl-16614 25 12 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 25 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 25 14 the the DET crl-16614 25 15 impression impression NOUN crl-16614 25 16 that that SCONJ crl-16614 25 17 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 25 18 [ [ X crl-16614 25 19 oa oa X crl-16614 25 20 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 25 21 may may AUX crl-16614 25 22 be be AUX crl-16614 25 23 a a DET crl-16614 25 24 less less ADV crl-16614 25 25 acceptable acceptable ADJ crl-16614 25 26 model model NOUN crl-16614 25 27 , , PUNCT crl-16614 25 28 whether whether SCONJ crl-16614 25 29 because because SCONJ crl-16614 25 30 research research NOUN crl-16614 25 31 is be AUX crl-16614 25 32 often often ADV crl-16614 25 33 undertaken undertake VERB crl-16614 25 34 without without ADP crl-16614 25 35 substantial substantial ADJ crl-16614 25 36 grant grant NOUN crl-16614 25 37 funding funding NOUN crl-16614 25 38 , , PUNCT crl-16614 25 39 or or CCONJ crl-16614 25 40 54 54 NUM crl-16614 25 41 college college NOUN crl-16614 25 42 & & CCONJ crl-16614 25 43 research research PROPN crl-16614 25 44 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 25 45 january january PROPN crl-16614 25 46 2018 2018 NUM crl-16614 25 47 because because SCONJ crl-16614 25 48 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 25 49 to to ADP crl-16614 25 50 some some PRON crl-16614 25 51 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 25 52 it it PRON crl-16614 25 53 may may AUX crl-16614 25 54 sound sound VERB crl-16614 25 55 a a DET crl-16614 25 56 bit bit NOUN crl-16614 25 57 too too ADV crl-16614 25 58 close close ADJ crl-16614 25 59 to to ADP crl-16614 25 60 ‘ ' PUNCT crl-16614 25 61 vanity vanity NOUN crl-16614 25 62 press press NOUN crl-16614 25 63 ’ ' PUNCT crl-16614 25 64 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 25 65 . . PUNCT crl-16614 26 1 ”10 ”10 PROPN crl-16614 26 2 john john PROPN crl-16614 26 3 bohannon bohannon PROPN crl-16614 26 4 highlighted highlight VERB crl-16614 26 5 his his PRON crl-16614 26 6 argument argument NOUN crl-16614 26 7 concerning concern VERB crl-16614 26 8 oa oa ADP crl-16614 26 9 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 26 10 in in ADP crl-16614 26 11 october october PROPN crl-16614 26 12 2013 2013 NUM crl-16614 26 13 when when SCONJ crl-16614 26 14 he he PRON crl-16614 26 15 performed perform VERB crl-16614 26 16 his his PRON crl-16614 26 17 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 26 18 sting sting NOUN crl-16614 26 19 operation operation NOUN crl-16614 26 20 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 26 21 on on ADP crl-16614 26 22 oa oa PROPN crl-16614 26 23 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 26 24 . . PUNCT crl-16614 27 1 bohannon bohannon PROPN crl-16614 27 2 composed compose VERB crl-16614 27 3 a a DET crl-16614 27 4 fraudulent fraudulent ADJ crl-16614 27 5 paper paper NOUN crl-16614 27 6 about about ADP crl-16614 27 7 a a DET crl-16614 27 8 lichen lichen ADJ crl-16614 27 9 molecule molecule NOUN crl-16614 27 10 that that PRON crl-16614 27 11 seemed seem VERB crl-16614 27 12 to to PART crl-16614 27 13 have have VERB crl-16614 27 14 cancer cancer NOUN crl-16614 27 15 - - PUNCT crl-16614 27 16 fighting fight VERB crl-16614 27 17 properties property NOUN crl-16614 27 18 and and CCONJ crl-16614 27 19 submitted submit VERB crl-16614 27 20 the the DET crl-16614 27 21 paper paper NOUN crl-16614 27 22 to to ADP crl-16614 27 23 304 304 NUM crl-16614 27 24 oa oa ADP crl-16614 27 25 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 27 26 . . PUNCT crl-16614 28 1 even even ADV crl-16614 28 2 though though SCONJ crl-16614 28 3 he he PRON crl-16614 28 4 wrote write VERB crl-16614 28 5 the the DET crl-16614 28 6 paper paper NOUN crl-16614 28 7 in in ADP crl-16614 28 8 a a DET crl-16614 28 9 way way NOUN crl-16614 28 10 that that PRON crl-16614 28 11 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 28 12 referees referee NOUN crl-16614 28 13 should should AUX crl-16614 28 14 have have AUX crl-16614 28 15 rejected reject VERB crl-16614 28 16 it it PRON crl-16614 28 17 immediately immediately ADV crl-16614 28 18 , , PUNCT crl-16614 28 19 157 157 NUM crl-16614 28 20 oa oa VERB crl-16614 28 21 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 28 22 accepted accept VERB crl-16614 28 23 the the DET crl-16614 28 24 paper.11 paper.11 NOUN crl-16614 28 25 davis davis PROPN crl-16614 28 26 pointed point VERB crl-16614 28 27 out out ADP crl-16614 28 28 that that SCONJ crl-16614 28 29 this this DET crl-16614 28 30 high high ADJ crl-16614 28 31 acceptance acceptance NOUN crl-16614 28 32 rate rate NOUN crl-16614 28 33 was be AUX crl-16614 28 34 not not PART crl-16614 28 35 surprising surprising ADJ crl-16614 28 36 , , PUNCT crl-16614 28 37 since since SCONJ crl-16614 28 38 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 28 39 nearly nearly ADV crl-16614 28 40 half half NOUN crl-16614 28 41 of of ADP crl-16614 28 42 the the DET crl-16614 28 43 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 28 44 were be AUX crl-16614 28 45 listed list VERB crl-16614 28 46 on on ADP crl-16614 28 47 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 28 48 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 28 49 list list NOUN crl-16614 28 50 of of ADP crl-16614 28 51 predator predator NOUN crl-16614 28 52 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 28 53 , , PUNCT crl-16614 28 54 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 28 55 further further ADJ crl-16614 28 56 lending lending NOUN crl-16614 28 57 validity validity NOUN crl-16614 28 58 to to PART crl-16614 28 59 beall beall NOUN crl-16614 28 60 ’s ’s NOUN crl-16614 28 61 list list NOUN crl-16614 28 62 as as ADP crl-16614 28 63 an an DET crl-16614 28 64 authoritative authoritative ADJ crl-16614 28 65 standard.12 standard.12 NOUN crl-16614 28 66 however however ADV crl-16614 28 67 , , PUNCT crl-16614 28 68 according accord VERB crl-16614 28 69 to to ADP crl-16614 28 70 bohannon bohannon NOUN crl-16614 28 71 , , PUNCT crl-16614 28 72 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 28 73 nearly nearly ADV crl-16614 28 74 half half NOUN crl-16614 28 75 of of ADP crl-16614 28 76 all all PRON crl-16614 28 77 of of ADP crl-16614 28 78 the the DET crl-16614 28 79 fee fee NOUN crl-16614 28 80 - - PUNCT crl-16614 28 81 charging charge VERB crl-16614 28 82 open open ADJ crl-16614 28 83 access access NOUN crl-16614 28 84 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 28 85 listed list VERB crl-16614 28 86 in in ADP crl-16614 28 87 the the DET crl-16614 28 88 doaj doaj NOUN crl-16614 28 89 [ [ X crl-16614 28 90 directory directory NOUN crl-16614 28 91 of of ADP crl-16614 28 92 open open ADJ crl-16614 28 93 access access NOUN crl-16614 28 94 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 28 95 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 28 96 failed fail VERB crl-16614 28 97 this this DET crl-16614 28 98 test test NOUN crl-16614 28 99 . . PUNCT crl-16614 29 1 ”13 ”13 NOUN crl-16614 29 2 because because SCONJ crl-16614 29 3 of of ADP crl-16614 29 4 this this PRON crl-16614 29 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 29 6 the the DET crl-16614 29 7 doaj doaj NOUN crl-16614 29 8 is be AUX crl-16614 29 9 performing perform VERB crl-16614 29 10 a a DET crl-16614 29 11 reevaluation reevaluation NOUN crl-16614 29 12 and and CCONJ crl-16614 29 13 cleanup cleanup NOUN crl-16614 29 14 of of ADP crl-16614 29 15 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 29 16 listed list VERB crl-16614 29 17 in in ADP crl-16614 29 18 their their PRON crl-16614 29 19 directory directory NOUN crl-16614 29 20 , , PUNCT crl-16614 29 21 having having AUX crl-16614 29 22 removed remove VERB crl-16614 29 23 3,300 3,300 NUM crl-16614 29 24 of of ADP crl-16614 29 25 approximately approximately ADV crl-16614 29 26 10,000 10,000 NUM crl-16614 29 27 titles.14 titles.14 DET crl-16614 29 28 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 29 29 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 29 30 argues argue VERB crl-16614 29 31 that that SCONJ crl-16614 29 32 there there PRON crl-16614 29 33 are be VERB crl-16614 29 34 some some DET crl-16614 29 35 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 29 36 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 29 37 not not PART crl-16614 29 38 all all PRON crl-16614 29 39 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 29 40 manipulating manipulate VERB crl-16614 29 41 this this DET crl-16614 29 42 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 29 43 author author NOUN crl-16614 29 44 - - PUNCT crl-16614 29 45 pay pay NOUN crl-16614 29 46 model model NOUN crl-16614 29 47 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 29 48 for for ADP crl-16614 29 49 their their PRON crl-16614 29 50 own own ADJ crl-16614 29 51 profit.15 profit.15 NOUN crl-16614 29 52 beall beall NOUN crl-16614 29 53 writes write VERB crl-16614 29 54 in in ADP crl-16614 29 55 his his PRON crl-16614 29 56 blog blog NOUN crl-16614 29 57 that that SCONJ crl-16614 29 58 these these DET crl-16614 29 59 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 29 60 fly fly VERB crl-16614 29 61 - - PUNCT crl-16614 29 62 bynight bynight ADJ crl-16614 29 63 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 29 64 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 29 65 operate operate VERB crl-16614 29 66 as as ADP crl-16614 29 67 vanity vanity NOUN crl-16614 29 68 presses press NOUN crl-16614 29 69 for for ADP crl-16614 29 70 the the DET crl-16614 29 71 sole sole ADJ crl-16614 29 72 purpose purpose NOUN crl-16614 29 73 of of ADP crl-16614 29 74 generating generate VERB crl-16614 29 75 income income NOUN crl-16614 29 76 and and CCONJ crl-16614 29 77 do do AUX crl-16614 29 78 not not PART crl-16614 29 79 follow follow VERB crl-16614 29 80 professional professional ADJ crl-16614 29 81 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 29 82 practices practice NOUN crl-16614 29 83 by by ADP crl-16614 29 84 disregarding disregard VERB crl-16614 29 85 peer peer NOUN crl-16614 29 86 review review NOUN crl-16614 29 87 and and CCONJ crl-16614 29 88 digital digital ADJ crl-16614 29 89 preservation preservation NOUN crl-16614 29 90 , , PUNCT crl-16614 29 91 and and CCONJ crl-16614 29 92 by by ADP crl-16614 29 93 spamming spamme VERB crl-16614 29 94 professional professional ADJ crl-16614 29 95 e e NOUN crl-16614 29 96 - - NOUN crl-16614 29 97 mail mail NOUN crl-16614 29 98 lists list NOUN crl-16614 29 99 to to PART crl-16614 29 100 solicit solicit VERB crl-16614 29 101 article article PROPN crl-16614 29 102 submissions.16 submissions.16 PROPN crl-16614 29 103 pickler pickler PROPN crl-16614 29 104 et et PROPN crl-16614 30 1 al al PROPN crl-16614 30 2 . . PROPN crl-16614 30 3 support support PROPN crl-16614 30 4 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 30 5 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 30 6 belief belief NOUN crl-16614 30 7 that that SCONJ crl-16614 30 8 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 30 9 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 30 10 engage engage VERB crl-16614 30 11 in in ADP crl-16614 30 12 deceptive deceptive ADJ crl-16614 30 13 practices practice NOUN crl-16614 30 14 , , PUNCT crl-16614 30 15 including include VERB crl-16614 30 16 making make VERB crl-16614 30 17 false false ADJ crl-16614 30 18 assertions assertion NOUN crl-16614 30 19 about about ADP crl-16614 30 20 the the DET crl-16614 30 21 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 30 22 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 30 23 status status NOUN crl-16614 30 24 within within ADP crl-16614 30 25 a a DET crl-16614 30 26 profession profession NOUN crl-16614 30 27 and and CCONJ crl-16614 30 28 providing provide VERB crl-16614 30 29 inadequate inadequate ADJ crl-16614 30 30 or or CCONJ crl-16614 30 31 bogus bogus ADJ crl-16614 30 32 information information NOUN crl-16614 30 33 concerning concern VERB crl-16614 30 34 the the DET crl-16614 30 35 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 30 36 or or CCONJ crl-16614 30 37 editorial editorial NOUN crl-16614 30 38 board.17 board.17 NOUN crl-16614 30 39 according accord VERB crl-16614 30 40 to to ADP crl-16614 30 41 beall beall NOUN crl-16614 30 42 , , PUNCT crl-16614 30 43 in in ADP crl-16614 30 44 2013 2013 NUM crl-16614 30 45 there there PRON crl-16614 30 46 were be VERB crl-16614 30 47 225 225 NUM crl-16614 30 48 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 30 49 and and CCONJ crl-16614 30 50 126 126 NUM crl-16614 30 51 stand stand VERB crl-16614 30 52 - - PUNCT crl-16614 30 53 alone alone ADJ crl-16614 30 54 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 30 55 he he PRON crl-16614 30 56 identified identify VERB crl-16614 30 57 as as ADP crl-16614 30 58 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 30 59 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 30 60 , , PUNCT crl-16614 30 61 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 30 62 while while SCONJ crl-16614 30 63 in in ADP crl-16614 30 64 2015 2015 NUM crl-16614 30 65 this this DET crl-16614 30 66 number number NOUN crl-16614 30 67 increased increase VERB crl-16614 30 68 to to ADP crl-16614 30 69 693 693 NUM crl-16614 30 70 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 30 71 and and CCONJ crl-16614 30 72 507 507 NUM crl-16614 30 73 stand stand VERB crl-16614 30 74 - - PUNCT crl-16614 30 75 alone alone ADV crl-16614 30 76 journals.18 journals.18 NOUN crl-16614 30 77 this this PRON crl-16614 30 78 indicated indicate VERB crl-16614 30 79 that that SCONJ crl-16614 30 80 the the DET crl-16614 30 81 number number NOUN crl-16614 30 82 of of ADP crl-16614 30 83 questionable questionable ADJ crl-16614 30 84 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 30 85 and and CCONJ crl-16614 30 86 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 30 87 is be AUX crl-16614 30 88 on on ADP crl-16614 30 89 the the DET crl-16614 30 90 rise rise NOUN crl-16614 30 91 , , PUNCT crl-16614 30 92 causing cause VERB crl-16614 30 93 much much ADJ crl-16614 30 94 negative negative ADJ crl-16614 30 95 publicity publicity NOUN crl-16614 30 96 for for ADP crl-16614 30 97 the the DET crl-16614 30 98 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 30 99 movement movement NOUN crl-16614 30 100 . . PUNCT crl-16614 31 1 in in ADP crl-16614 31 2 an an DET crl-16614 31 3 attempt attempt NOUN crl-16614 31 4 to to PART crl-16614 31 5 shed shed VERB crl-16614 31 6 light light NOUN crl-16614 31 7 and and CCONJ crl-16614 31 8 encourage encourage VERB crl-16614 31 9 discussion discussion NOUN crl-16614 31 10 about about ADP crl-16614 31 11 this this DET crl-16614 31 12 problem problem NOUN crl-16614 31 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 31 14 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 31 15 continues continue VERB crl-16614 31 16 to to PART crl-16614 31 17 develop develop VERB crl-16614 31 18 a a DET crl-16614 31 19 set set NOUN crl-16614 31 20 of of ADP crl-16614 31 21 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 31 22 for for ADP crl-16614 31 23 determining determine VERB crl-16614 31 24 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 31 25 open open ADJ crl-16614 31 26 - - PUNCT crl-16614 31 27 access access NOUN crl-16614 31 28 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 31 29 to to PART crl-16614 31 30 help help VERB crl-16614 31 31 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 31 32 determine determine VERB crl-16614 31 33 if if SCONJ crl-16614 31 34 a a DET crl-16614 31 35 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 31 36 is be AUX crl-16614 31 37 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 31 38 . . PUNCT crl-16614 32 1 he he PRON crl-16614 32 2 uses use VERB crl-16614 32 3 these these DET crl-16614 32 4 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 32 5 to to PART crl-16614 32 6 update update VERB crl-16614 32 7 continually continually ADV crl-16614 32 8 a a DET crl-16614 32 9 list list NOUN crl-16614 32 10 of of ADP crl-16614 32 11 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 32 12 that that PRON crl-16614 32 13 he he PRON crl-16614 32 14 believes believe VERB crl-16614 32 15 are be AUX crl-16614 32 16 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 32 17 potential potential ADJ crl-16614 32 18 , , PUNCT crl-16614 32 19 possible possible ADJ crl-16614 32 20 , , PUNCT crl-16614 32 21 or or CCONJ crl-16614 32 22 probable probable ADJ crl-16614 32 23 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 32 24 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 32 25 open open ADJ crl-16614 32 26 - - PUNCT crl-16614 32 27 access access NOUN crl-16614 32 28 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 32 29 . . PUNCT crl-16614 33 1 ”19 ”19 PUNCT crl-16614 34 1 in in ADP crl-16614 34 2 addition addition NOUN crl-16614 34 3 to to ADP crl-16614 34 4 having having AUX crl-16614 34 5 developed develop VERB crl-16614 34 6 the the DET crl-16614 34 7 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 34 8 , , PUNCT crl-16614 34 9 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 34 10 hosts host VERB crl-16614 34 11 a a DET crl-16614 34 12 website website NOUN crl-16614 34 13 on on ADP crl-16614 34 14 which which PRON crl-16614 34 15 he he PRON crl-16614 34 16 provides provide VERB crl-16614 34 17 a a DET crl-16614 34 18 list list NOUN crl-16614 34 19 of of ADP crl-16614 34 20 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 34 21 and and CCONJ crl-16614 34 22 stand stand VERB crl-16614 34 23 - - PUNCT crl-16614 34 24 alone alone ADJ crl-16614 34 25 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 34 26 that that PRON crl-16614 34 27 he he PRON crl-16614 34 28 considers consider VERB crl-16614 34 29 to to PART crl-16614 34 30 have have AUX crl-16614 34 31 failed fail VERB crl-16614 34 32 one one NUM crl-16614 34 33 or or CCONJ crl-16614 34 34 more more ADJ crl-16614 34 35 of of ADP crl-16614 34 36 these these DET crl-16614 34 37 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 34 38 . . PUNCT crl-16614 35 1 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 35 2 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 35 3 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 35 4 recognizes recognize VERB crl-16614 35 5 the the DET crl-16614 35 6 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 35 7 1 1 NUM crl-16614 35 8 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 35 9 code code NOUN crl-16614 35 10 of of ADP crl-16614 35 11 conduct conduct NOUN crl-16614 35 12 for for ADP crl-16614 35 13 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 35 14 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 35 15 and and CCONJ crl-16614 35 16 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 35 17 2 2 NUM crl-16614 35 18 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 35 19 principles principle NOUN crl-16614 35 20 of of ADP crl-16614 35 21 transparency transparency NOUN crl-16614 35 22 of of ADP crl-16614 35 23 best good ADJ crl-16614 35 24 practice practice NOUN crl-16614 35 25 in in ADP crl-16614 35 26 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 35 27 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 35 28 , , PUNCT crl-16614 35 29 both both PRON crl-16614 35 30 published publish VERB crl-16614 35 31 by by ADP crl-16614 35 32 the the DET crl-16614 35 33 committee committee NOUN crl-16614 35 34 on on ADP crl-16614 35 35 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 35 36 ethics ethic NOUN crl-16614 35 37 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 35 38 cope cope VERB crl-16614 35 39 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 35 40 , , PUNCT crl-16614 35 41 as as ADP crl-16614 35 42 foundational foundational PROPN crl-16614 35 43 documents.20 documents.20 PROPN crl-16614 35 44 cope cope PROPN crl-16614 35 45 , , PUNCT crl-16614 35 46 which which PRON crl-16614 35 47 adapted adapt VERB crl-16614 35 48 the the DET crl-16614 35 49 latter latter ADJ crl-16614 35 50 document document NOUN crl-16614 35 51 from from ADP crl-16614 35 52 one one NUM crl-16614 35 53 used use VERB crl-16614 35 54 by by ADP crl-16614 35 55 the the DET crl-16614 35 56 doaj doaj NOUN crl-16614 35 57 , , PUNCT crl-16614 35 58 uses use VERB crl-16614 35 59 it it PRON crl-16614 35 60 for for ADP crl-16614 35 61 the the DET crl-16614 35 62 purpose purpose NOUN crl-16614 35 63 of of ADP crl-16614 35 64 membership membership NOUN crl-16614 35 65 evaluation.21 evaluation.21 NOUN crl-16614 35 66 it it PRON crl-16614 35 67 is be AUX crl-16614 35 68 important important ADJ crl-16614 35 69 to to PART crl-16614 35 70 note note VERB crl-16614 35 71 , , PUNCT crl-16614 35 72 however however ADV crl-16614 35 73 , , PUNCT crl-16614 35 74 that that PRON crl-16614 35 75 cope cope VERB crl-16614 35 76 membership membership NOUN crl-16614 35 77 is be AUX crl-16614 35 78 open open ADJ crl-16614 35 79 to to ADP crl-16614 35 80 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 35 81 editors editor NOUN crl-16614 35 82 regardless regardless ADV crl-16614 35 83 of of ADP crl-16614 35 84 whether whether SCONJ crl-16614 35 85 or or CCONJ crl-16614 35 86 not not PART crl-16614 35 87 their their PRON crl-16614 35 88 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 35 89 is be AUX crl-16614 35 90 oa oa ADJ crl-16614 35 91 , , PUNCT crl-16614 35 92 and and CCONJ crl-16614 35 93 that that SCONJ crl-16614 35 94 these these DET crl-16614 35 95 two two NUM crl-16614 35 96 documents document NOUN crl-16614 35 97 are be AUX crl-16614 35 98 not not PART crl-16614 35 99 written write VERB crl-16614 35 100 specifically specifically ADV crl-16614 35 101 to to PART crl-16614 35 102 be be AUX crl-16614 35 103 applied apply VERB crl-16614 35 104 to to ADP crl-16614 35 105 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 35 106 publishers.22 publishers.22 NOUN crl-16614 35 107 beall beall NOUN crl-16614 35 108 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 35 109 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 35 110 for for ADP crl-16614 35 111 determining determine VERB crl-16614 35 112 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 35 113 open open ADJ crl-16614 35 114 - - PUNCT crl-16614 35 115 access access NOUN crl-16614 35 116 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 35 117 is be AUX crl-16614 35 118 currently currently ADV crl-16614 35 119 in in ADP crl-16614 35 120 its its PRON crl-16614 35 121 third third ADJ crl-16614 35 122 edition edition NOUN crl-16614 35 123 . . PUNCT crl-16614 36 1 it it PRON crl-16614 36 2 contains contain VERB crl-16614 36 3 27 27 NUM crl-16614 36 4 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 36 5 divided divide VERB crl-16614 36 6 into into ADP crl-16614 36 7 four four NUM crl-16614 36 8 categories category NOUN crl-16614 36 9 : : PUNCT crl-16614 36 10 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 36 11 and and CCONJ crl-16614 36 12 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 36 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 36 14 business business NOUN crl-16614 36 15 management management NOUN crl-16614 36 16 , , PUNCT crl-16614 36 17 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 36 18 , , PUNCT crl-16614 36 19 and and CCONJ crl-16614 36 20 other other ADJ crl-16614 36 21 . . PUNCT crl-16614 37 1 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 37 2 provides provide VERB crl-16614 37 3 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 37 4 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 37 5 under under ADP crl-16614 37 6 these these DET crl-16614 37 7 categories category NOUN crl-16614 37 8 but but CCONJ crl-16614 37 9 does do AUX crl-16614 37 10 not not PART crl-16614 37 11 include include VERB crl-16614 37 12 further further ADJ crl-16614 37 13 explanations explanation NOUN crl-16614 37 14 or or CCONJ crl-16614 37 15 definitions definition NOUN crl-16614 37 16 of of ADP crl-16614 37 17 the the DET crl-16614 37 18 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 37 19 themselves themselves PRON crl-16614 37 20 . . PUNCT crl-16614 38 1 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 38 2 also also ADV crl-16614 38 3 includes include VERB crl-16614 38 4 a a DET crl-16614 38 5 category category NOUN crl-16614 38 6 titled title VERB crl-16614 38 7 poor poor ADJ crl-16614 38 8 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 38 9 standards standard NOUN crl-16614 38 10 that that PRON crl-16614 38 11 consists consist VERB crl-16614 38 12 of of ADP crl-16614 38 13 26 26 NUM crl-16614 38 14 additional additional ADJ crl-16614 38 15 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 38 16 . . PUNCT crl-16614 39 1 however however ADV crl-16614 39 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 39 3 since since ADV crl-16614 39 4 , , PUNCT crl-16614 39 5 according accord VERB crl-16614 39 6 to to ADP crl-16614 39 7 beall beall NOUN crl-16614 39 8 , , PUNCT crl-16614 39 9 these these DET crl-16614 39 10 additional additional ADJ crl-16614 39 11 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 39 12 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 39 13 are be AUX crl-16614 39 14 considered consider VERB crl-16614 39 15 to to PART crl-16614 39 16 be be AUX crl-16614 39 17 reflective reflective ADJ crl-16614 39 18 of of ADP crl-16614 39 19 poor poor ADJ crl-16614 39 20 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 39 21 standards standard NOUN crl-16614 39 22 , , PUNCT crl-16614 39 23 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 39 24 but but CCONJ crl-16614 39 25 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 39 26 do do AUX crl-16614 39 27 not not PART crl-16614 39 28 equal equal VERB crl-16614 39 29 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 39 30 criteria,”23 criteria,”23 NOUN crl-16614 39 31 the the DET crl-16614 39 32 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 39 33 chose chose AUX crl-16614 39 34 not not PART crl-16614 39 35 consider consider VERB crl-16614 39 36 them they PRON crl-16614 39 37 in in ADP crl-16614 39 38 this this DET crl-16614 39 39 study study NOUN crl-16614 39 40 . . PUNCT crl-16614 40 1 a a DET crl-16614 40 2 number number NOUN crl-16614 40 3 of of ADP crl-16614 40 4 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 40 5 have have AUX crl-16614 40 6 criticized criticize VERB crl-16614 40 7 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 40 8 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 40 9 list list NOUN crl-16614 40 10 . . PUNCT crl-16614 41 1 shen shen PROPN crl-16614 41 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 41 3 björk björk NOUN crl-16614 41 4 , , PUNCT crl-16614 41 5 for for ADP crl-16614 41 6 example example NOUN crl-16614 41 7 , , PUNCT crl-16614 41 8 examined examine VERB crl-16614 41 9 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 41 10 ’s ’s NOUN crl-16614 41 11 list list NOUN crl-16614 41 12 by by ADP crl-16614 41 13 using use VERB crl-16614 41 14 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 41 15 a a DET crl-16614 41 16 multistage multistage NOUN crl-16614 41 17 stratified stratify VERB crl-16614 41 18 sampling sampling NOUN crl-16614 41 19 method method NOUN crl-16614 41 20 to to PART crl-16614 41 21 take take VERB crl-16614 41 22 a a DET crl-16614 41 23 look look NOUN crl-16614 41 24 into into ADP crl-16614 41 25 the the DET crl-16614 41 26 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 41 27 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 41 28 and and CCONJ crl-16614 41 29 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 41 30 on on ADP crl-16614 41 31 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 41 32 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 41 33 list list NOUN crl-16614 41 34 and and CCONJ crl-16614 41 35 generated generate VERB crl-16614 41 36 their their PRON crl-16614 41 37 format format NOUN crl-16614 41 38 aside aside ADV crl-16614 41 39 55 55 NUM crl-16614 41 40 development development NOUN crl-16614 41 41 trend trend NOUN crl-16614 41 42 over over ADP crl-16614 41 43 time time NOUN crl-16614 41 44 . . PUNCT crl-16614 42 1 ”24 ”24 VERB crl-16614 42 2 they they PRON crl-16614 42 3 found find VERB crl-16614 42 4 that that SCONJ crl-16614 42 5 the the DET crl-16614 42 6 problems problem NOUN crl-16614 42 7 caused cause VERB crl-16614 42 8 by by ADP crl-16614 42 9 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 42 10 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 42 11 are be AUX crl-16614 42 12 rather rather ADV crl-16614 42 13 limited limited ADJ crl-16614 42 14 and and CCONJ crl-16614 42 15 regional regional ADJ crl-16614 42 16 , , PUNCT crl-16614 42 17 seeing see VERB crl-16614 42 18 the the DET crl-16614 42 19 problem problem NOUN crl-16614 42 20 as as SCONJ crl-16614 42 21 created create VERB crl-16614 42 22 by by ADP crl-16614 42 23 institutions institution NOUN crl-16614 42 24 in in ADP crl-16614 42 25 developing develop VERB crl-16614 42 26 countries country NOUN crl-16614 42 27 trying try VERB crl-16614 42 28 to to PART crl-16614 42 29 compete compete VERB crl-16614 42 30 with with ADP crl-16614 42 31 the the DET crl-16614 42 32 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 42 33 excellence excellence NOUN crl-16614 42 34 viewpoint viewpoint NOUN crl-16614 42 35 focusing focus VERB crl-16614 42 36 on on ADP crl-16614 42 37 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 42 38 how how SCONJ crl-16614 42 39 often often ADV crl-16614 42 40 one one NUM crl-16614 42 41 publishes publish VERB crl-16614 42 42 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 42 43 rather rather ADV crl-16614 42 44 than than ADP crl-16614 42 45 on on ADP crl-16614 42 46 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 42 47 what what PRON crl-16614 42 48 is be AUX crl-16614 42 49 published publish VERB crl-16614 42 50 , , PUNCT crl-16614 42 51 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 42 52 creating create VERB crl-16614 42 53 a a DET crl-16614 42 54 market market NOUN crl-16614 42 55 for for ADP crl-16614 42 56 dubious dubious ADJ crl-16614 42 57 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 42 58 . . PUNCT crl-16614 43 1 other other ADJ crl-16614 43 2 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 43 3 like like ADP crl-16614 43 4 crawford crawford NOUN crl-16614 43 5 believe believe VERB crl-16614 43 6 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 43 7 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 43 8 lists list NOUN crl-16614 43 9 are be AUX crl-16614 43 10 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 43 11 resources.25 resources.25 NOUN crl-16614 43 12 berger berger PROPN crl-16614 43 13 and and CCONJ crl-16614 43 14 cirasella cirasella NOUN crl-16614 43 15 support support NOUN crl-16614 43 16 crawford crawford NOUN crl-16614 43 17 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 43 18 findings finding NOUN crl-16614 43 19 , , PUNCT crl-16614 43 20 stating state VERB crl-16614 43 21 , , PUNCT crl-16614 43 22 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 43 23 imperfect imperfect ADJ crl-16614 43 24 english english PROPN crl-16614 43 25 or or CCONJ crl-16614 43 26 a a DET crl-16614 43 27 predominantly predominantly ADV crl-16614 43 28 non non ADJ crl-16614 43 29 - - ADJ crl-16614 43 30 western western ADJ crl-16614 43 31 editorial editorial ADJ crl-16614 43 32 board board NOUN crl-16614 43 33 does do AUX crl-16614 43 34 not not PART crl-16614 43 35 make make VERB crl-16614 43 36 a a DET crl-16614 43 37 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 43 38 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 43 39 . . PUNCT crl-16614 44 1 ”26 ”26 ADJ crl-16614 44 2 despite despite SCONJ crl-16614 44 3 these these DET crl-16614 44 4 criticisms criticism NOUN crl-16614 44 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 44 6 the the DET crl-16614 44 7 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 44 8 beall beall AUX crl-16614 44 9 uses use VERB crl-16614 44 10 to to PART crl-16614 44 11 create create VERB crl-16614 44 12 his his PRON crl-16614 44 13 list list NOUN crl-16614 44 14 is be AUX crl-16614 44 15 a a DET crl-16614 44 16 good good ADJ crl-16614 44 17 foundation foundation NOUN crl-16614 44 18 for for ADP crl-16614 44 19 librarians librarian NOUN crl-16614 44 20 to to PART crl-16614 44 21 use use VERB crl-16614 44 22 when when SCONJ crl-16614 44 23 thinking think VERB crl-16614 44 24 about about ADP crl-16614 44 25 and and CCONJ crl-16614 44 26 identifying identify VERB crl-16614 44 27 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 44 28 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 44 29 and and CCONJ crl-16614 44 30 has have AUX crl-16614 44 31 been be AUX crl-16614 44 32 used use VERB crl-16614 44 33 by by ADP crl-16614 44 34 research research NOUN crl-16614 44 35 as as SCONJ crl-16614 44 36 the the DET crl-16614 44 37 foundation foundation NOUN crl-16614 44 38 of of ADP crl-16614 44 39 critical critical ADJ crl-16614 44 40 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-16614 44 41 of of ADP crl-16614 44 42 oa oa PROPN crl-16614 44 43 journals.27 journals.27 PROPN crl-16614 44 44 research research PROPN crl-16614 44 45 questions question NOUN crl-16614 44 46 the the DET crl-16614 44 47 purpose purpose NOUN crl-16614 44 48 of of ADP crl-16614 44 49 this this DET crl-16614 44 50 study study NOUN crl-16614 44 51 was be AUX crl-16614 44 52 to to PART crl-16614 44 53 assess assess VERB crl-16614 44 54 the the DET crl-16614 44 55 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN crl-16614 44 56 of of ADP crl-16614 44 57 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 44 58 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 44 59 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 44 60 for for ADP crl-16614 44 61 determining determine VERB crl-16614 44 62 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 44 63 open open ADJ crl-16614 44 64 - - PUNCT crl-16614 44 65 access access NOUN crl-16614 44 66 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 44 67 , , PUNCT crl-16614 44 68 the the DET crl-16614 44 69 same same ADJ crl-16614 44 70 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 44 71 by by ADP crl-16614 44 72 which which PRON crl-16614 44 73 he he PRON crl-16614 44 74 determines determine VERB crl-16614 44 75 his his PRON crl-16614 44 76 lists list NOUN crl-16614 44 77 . . PUNCT crl-16614 45 1 this this DET crl-16614 45 2 task task NOUN crl-16614 45 3 was be AUX crl-16614 45 4 accomplished accomplish VERB crl-16614 45 5 by by ADP crl-16614 45 6 applying apply VERB crl-16614 45 7 the the DET crl-16614 45 8 27 27 NUM crl-16614 45 9 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 45 10 to to ADP crl-16614 45 11 a a DET crl-16614 45 12 collection collection NOUN crl-16614 45 13 of of ADP crl-16614 45 14 lis lis ADJ crl-16614 45 15 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 45 16 , , PUNCT crl-16614 45 17 both both PRON crl-16614 45 18 oa oa ADJ crl-16614 45 19 and and CCONJ crl-16614 45 20 non non ADJ crl-16614 45 21 - - ADJ crl-16614 45 22 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 45 23 , , PUNCT crl-16614 45 24 which which PRON crl-16614 45 25 are be AUX crl-16614 45 26 generally generally ADV crl-16614 45 27 considered consider VERB crl-16614 45 28 to to PART crl-16614 45 29 be be AUX crl-16614 45 30 of of ADP crl-16614 45 31 high high ADJ crl-16614 45 32 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 45 33 because because SCONJ crl-16614 45 34 of of ADP crl-16614 45 35 their their PRON crl-16614 45 36 inclusion inclusion NOUN crl-16614 45 37 in in ADP crl-16614 45 38 a a DET crl-16614 45 39 recognized recognize VERB crl-16614 45 40 source source NOUN crl-16614 45 41 for for ADP crl-16614 45 42 identifying identify VERB crl-16614 45 43 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 45 44 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 45 45 rankings ranking NOUN crl-16614 45 46 . . PUNCT crl-16614 46 1 again again ADV crl-16614 46 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 46 3 the the DET crl-16614 46 4 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 46 5 did do AUX crl-16614 46 6 not not PART crl-16614 46 7 consider consider VERB crl-16614 46 8 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 46 9 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 46 10 category category NOUN crl-16614 46 11 area area NOUN crl-16614 46 12 of of ADP crl-16614 46 13 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 46 14 titled title VERB crl-16614 46 15 poor poor ADJ crl-16614 46 16 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 46 17 standards standard NOUN crl-16614 46 18 in in ADP crl-16614 46 19 this this DET crl-16614 46 20 study study NOUN crl-16614 46 21 . . PUNCT crl-16614 47 1 they they PRON crl-16614 47 2 were be AUX crl-16614 47 3 not not PART crl-16614 47 4 looking look VERB crl-16614 47 5 to to PART crl-16614 47 6 declare declare VERB crl-16614 47 7 any any PRON crl-16614 47 8 of of ADP crl-16614 47 9 these these DET crl-16614 47 10 lis lis ADJ crl-16614 47 11 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 47 12 as as ADP crl-16614 47 13 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 47 14 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 47 15 . . PUNCT crl-16614 47 16 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 48 1 on on ADP crl-16614 48 2 the the DET crl-16614 48 3 contrary contrary NOUN crl-16614 48 4 , , PUNCT crl-16614 48 5 they they PRON crl-16614 48 6 have have AUX crl-16614 48 7 published publish VERB crl-16614 48 8 in in ADP crl-16614 48 9 several several ADJ crl-16614 48 10 of of ADP crl-16614 48 11 the the DET crl-16614 48 12 lis lis ADJ crl-16614 48 13 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 48 14 from from ADP crl-16614 48 15 the the DET crl-16614 48 16 collection collection NOUN crl-16614 48 17 . . PUNCT crl-16614 49 1 instead instead ADV crl-16614 49 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 49 3 the the DET crl-16614 49 4 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 49 5 investigated investigate VERB crl-16614 49 6 whether whether SCONJ crl-16614 49 7 respected respected ADJ crl-16614 49 8 and and CCONJ crl-16614 49 9 long long ADV crl-16614 49 10 - - PUNCT crl-16614 49 11 established establish VERB crl-16614 49 12 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 49 13 would would AUX crl-16614 49 14 pass pass VERB crl-16614 49 15 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 49 16 ’s ’s NOUN crl-16614 49 17 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 49 18 as as SCONJ crl-16614 49 19 if if SCONJ crl-16614 49 20 they they PRON crl-16614 49 21 were be AUX crl-16614 49 22 newly newly ADV crl-16614 49 23 emerging emerge VERB crl-16614 49 24 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 49 25 without without ADP crl-16614 49 26 an an DET crl-16614 49 27 established established ADJ crl-16614 49 28 reputation reputation NOUN crl-16614 49 29 . . PUNCT crl-16614 50 1 the the DET crl-16614 50 2 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 50 3 asked ask VERB crl-16614 50 4 the the DET crl-16614 50 5 following follow VERB crl-16614 50 6 questions question NOUN crl-16614 50 7 during during ADP crl-16614 50 8 this this DET crl-16614 50 9 assessment assessment NOUN crl-16614 50 10 : : PUNCT crl-16614 50 11 1 1 X crl-16614 50 12 . . X crl-16614 50 13 how how SCONJ crl-16614 50 14 many many ADJ crl-16614 50 15 members member NOUN crl-16614 50 16 of of ADP crl-16614 50 17 the the DET crl-16614 50 18 population population NOUN crl-16614 50 19 fail fail VERB crl-16614 50 20 one one NUM crl-16614 50 21 or or CCONJ crl-16614 50 22 more more ADJ crl-16614 50 23 of of ADP crl-16614 50 24 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 50 25 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 50 26 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 50 27 ? ? PUNCT crl-16614 51 1 2 2 X crl-16614 51 2 . . X crl-16614 51 3 what what PRON crl-16614 51 4 are be AUX crl-16614 51 5 the the DET crl-16614 51 6 percentages percentage NOUN crl-16614 51 7 of of ADP crl-16614 51 8 failure failure NOUN crl-16614 51 9 for for ADP crl-16614 51 10 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 51 11 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 51 12 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 51 13 by by ADP crl-16614 51 14 area area NOUN crl-16614 51 15 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 51 16 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 51 17 and and CCONJ crl-16614 51 18 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 51 19 , , PUNCT crl-16614 51 20 business business NOUN crl-16614 51 21 management management NOUN crl-16614 51 22 , , PUNCT crl-16614 51 23 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 51 24 , , PUNCT crl-16614 51 25 and and CCONJ crl-16614 51 26 other other ADJ crl-16614 51 27 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 51 28 ? ? PUNCT crl-16614 52 1 3 3 X crl-16614 52 2 . . X crl-16614 52 3 what what PRON crl-16614 52 4 are be AUX crl-16614 52 5 the the DET crl-16614 52 6 average average ADJ crl-16614 52 7 ages age NOUN crl-16614 52 8 of of ADP crl-16614 52 9 the the DET crl-16614 52 10 failed fail VERB crl-16614 52 11 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 52 12 ? ? PUNCT crl-16614 53 1 4 4 X crl-16614 53 2 . . X crl-16614 53 3 what what DET crl-16614 53 4 type type NOUN crl-16614 53 5 of of ADP crl-16614 53 6 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 53 7 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 53 8 association association NOUN crl-16614 53 9 , , PUNCT crl-16614 53 10 commercial commercial ADJ crl-16614 53 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 53 12 or or CCONJ crl-16614 53 13 university university NOUN crl-16614 53 14 press press NOUN crl-16614 53 15 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 53 16 had have VERB crl-16614 53 17 the the DET crl-16614 53 18 largest large ADJ crl-16614 53 19 number number NOUN crl-16614 53 20 of of ADP crl-16614 53 21 failed fail VERB crl-16614 53 22 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 53 23 ? ? PUNCT crl-16614 54 1 5 5 X crl-16614 54 2 . . X crl-16614 54 3 to to ADP crl-16614 54 4 what what DET crl-16614 54 5 degree degree NOUN crl-16614 54 6 did do AUX crl-16614 54 7 the the DET crl-16614 54 8 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 54 9 agree agree VERB crl-16614 54 10 in in ADP crl-16614 54 11 terms term NOUN crl-16614 54 12 of of ADP crl-16614 54 13 their their PRON crl-16614 54 14 decision decision NOUN crl-16614 54 15 - - PUNCT crl-16614 54 16 making making NOUN crl-16614 54 17 when when SCONJ crl-16614 54 18 applying apply VERB crl-16614 54 19 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 54 20 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 54 21 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 54 22 ? ? PUNCT crl-16614 55 1 6 6 X crl-16614 55 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 55 3 what what PRON crl-16614 55 4 do do AUX crl-16614 55 5 the the DET crl-16614 55 6 previous previous ADJ crl-16614 55 7 questions question NOUN crl-16614 55 8 tell tell VERB crl-16614 55 9 us we PRON crl-16614 55 10 about about ADP crl-16614 55 11 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 55 12 ’s ’s NOUN crl-16614 55 13 list list NOUN crl-16614 55 14 as as ADP crl-16614 55 15 a a DET crl-16614 55 16 tool tool NOUN crl-16614 55 17 for for ADP crl-16614 55 18 evaluating evaluate VERB crl-16614 55 19 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 55 20 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 55 21 ? ? PUNCT crl-16614 56 1 methodology methodology NOUN crl-16614 56 2 to to PART crl-16614 56 3 analyze analyze VERB crl-16614 56 4 the the DET crl-16614 56 5 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN crl-16614 56 6 of of ADP crl-16614 56 7 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 56 8 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 56 9 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 56 10 , , PUNCT crl-16614 56 11 the the DET crl-16614 56 12 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 56 13 examined examine VERB crl-16614 56 14 a a DET crl-16614 56 15 collection collection NOUN crl-16614 56 16 of of ADP crl-16614 56 17 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 56 18 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 56 19 in in ADP crl-16614 56 20 the the DET crl-16614 56 21 field field NOUN crl-16614 56 22 of of ADP crl-16614 56 23 lis li NOUN crl-16614 56 24 to to PART crl-16614 56 25 determine determine VERB crl-16614 56 26 if if SCONJ crl-16614 56 27 evaluators evaluator NOUN crl-16614 56 28 of of ADP crl-16614 56 29 the the DET crl-16614 56 30 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 56 31 titles title NOUN crl-16614 56 32 could could AUX crl-16614 56 33 perceive perceive VERB crl-16614 56 34 them they PRON crl-16614 56 35 as as ADP crl-16614 56 36 having have VERB crl-16614 56 37 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 56 38 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 56 39 tendencies tendency NOUN crl-16614 56 40 when when SCONJ crl-16614 56 41 applying apply VERB crl-16614 56 42 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 56 43 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 56 44 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 56 45 . . PUNCT crl-16614 57 1 the the DET crl-16614 57 2 collection collection NOUN crl-16614 57 3 of of ADP crl-16614 57 4 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 57 5 tested test VERB crl-16614 57 6 against against ADP crl-16614 57 7 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 57 8 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 57 9 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 57 10 came come VERB crl-16614 57 11 from from ADP crl-16614 57 12 the the DET crl-16614 57 13 incites incites PROPN crl-16614 57 14 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 57 15 citations citation NOUN crl-16614 57 16 reports report NOUN crl-16614 57 17 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 57 18 jcr jcr NOUN crl-16614 57 19 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 57 20 section section NOUN crl-16614 57 21 in in ADP crl-16614 57 22 thomson thomson PROPN crl-16614 57 23 reuters reuters PROPN crl-16614 57 24 ’ ' PUNCT crl-16614 57 25 web web NOUN crl-16614 57 26 of of ADP crl-16614 57 27 science science NOUN crl-16614 57 28 database database NOUN crl-16614 57 29 . . PUNCT crl-16614 58 1 the the DET crl-16614 58 2 jcr jcr NOUN crl-16614 58 3 provided provide VERB crl-16614 58 4 a a DET crl-16614 58 5 category category NOUN crl-16614 58 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 58 7 information information NOUN crl-16614 58 8 science science PROPN crl-16614 58 9 & & CCONJ crl-16614 58 10 library library PROPN crl-16614 58 11 science science PROPN crl-16614 58 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 58 13 consisting consist VERB crl-16614 58 14 of of ADP crl-16614 58 15 87 87 NUM crl-16614 58 16 entries entry NOUN crl-16614 58 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 58 18 seven seven NUM crl-16614 58 19 of of ADP crl-16614 58 20 which which PRON crl-16614 58 21 were be AUX crl-16614 58 22 oa oa PROPN crl-16614 58 23 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 58 24 . . PUNCT crl-16614 59 1 at at ADP crl-16614 59 2 the the DET crl-16614 59 3 time time NOUN crl-16614 59 4 of of ADP crl-16614 59 5 retrieval retrieval NOUN crl-16614 59 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 59 7 these these DET crl-16614 59 8 87 87 NUM crl-16614 59 9 entries entry NOUN crl-16614 59 10 comprised comprise VERB crl-16614 59 11 the the DET crl-16614 59 12 entire entire ADJ crl-16614 59 13 population population NOUN crl-16614 59 14 of of ADP crl-16614 59 15 the the DET crl-16614 59 16 database database PROPN crl-16614 59 17 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 59 18 information information NOUN crl-16614 59 19 science science PROPN crl-16614 59 20 & & CCONJ crl-16614 59 21 library library PROPN crl-16614 59 22 science science PROPN crl-16614 59 23 topic topic NOUN crl-16614 59 24 category category NOUN crl-16614 59 25 . . PUNCT crl-16614 60 1 at at ADP crl-16614 60 2 the the DET crl-16614 60 3 time time NOUN crl-16614 60 4 of of ADP crl-16614 60 5 this this DET crl-16614 60 6 study study NOUN crl-16614 60 7 , , PUNCT crl-16614 60 8 the the DET crl-16614 60 9 most most ADV crl-16614 60 10 recent recent ADJ crl-16614 60 11 year year NOUN crl-16614 60 12 of of ADP crl-16614 60 13 jcr jcr PROPN crl-16614 60 14 listings listing NOUN crl-16614 60 15 compiled compile VERB crl-16614 60 16 was be AUX crl-16614 60 17 2014 2014 NUM crl-16614 60 18 . . PUNCT crl-16614 61 1 it it PRON crl-16614 61 2 was be AUX crl-16614 61 3 not not PART crl-16614 61 4 the the DET crl-16614 61 5 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 61 6 ’ ’ PART crl-16614 61 7 intention intention NOUN crl-16614 61 8 to to PART crl-16614 61 9 analyze analyze VERB crl-16614 61 10 the the DET crl-16614 61 11 jcr jcr PROPN crl-16614 61 12 collection collection NOUN crl-16614 61 13 to to PART crl-16614 61 14 make make VERB crl-16614 61 15 statistically statistically ADV crl-16614 61 16 generalizable generalizable ADJ crl-16614 61 17 claims claim NOUN crl-16614 61 18 concerning concern VERB crl-16614 61 19 the the DET crl-16614 61 20 applications application NOUN crl-16614 61 21 of of ADP crl-16614 61 22 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 61 23 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 61 24 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 61 25 to to ADP crl-16614 61 26 any any DET crl-16614 61 27 larger large ADJ crl-16614 61 28 population population NOUN crl-16614 61 29 of of ADP crl-16614 61 30 lis lis ADJ crl-16614 61 31 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 61 32 . . PUNCT crl-16614 62 1 the the DET crl-16614 62 2 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 62 3 selected select VERB crl-16614 62 4 the the DET crl-16614 62 5 jcr jcr NOUN crl-16614 62 6 list list NOUN crl-16614 62 7 because because SCONJ crl-16614 62 8 it it PRON crl-16614 62 9 provides provide VERB crl-16614 62 10 a a DET crl-16614 62 11 convenient convenient ADJ crl-16614 62 12 ranked rank VERB crl-16614 62 13 collection collection NOUN crl-16614 62 14 of of ADP crl-16614 62 15 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 62 16 that that PRON crl-16614 62 17 also also ADV crl-16614 62 18 represents represent VERB crl-16614 62 19 an an DET crl-16614 62 20 assumed assumed ADJ crl-16614 62 21 level level NOUN crl-16614 62 22 of of ADP crl-16614 62 23 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 62 24 in in ADP crl-16614 62 25 the the DET crl-16614 62 26 lis lis ADJ crl-16614 62 27 community community NOUN crl-16614 62 28 through through ADP crl-16614 62 29 its its PRON crl-16614 62 30 ranking ranking NOUN crl-16614 62 31 of of ADP crl-16614 62 32 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 62 33 having have VERB crl-16614 62 34 thomson thomson PROPN crl-16614 62 35 reuters reuters PROPN crl-16614 62 36 impact impact NOUN crl-16614 62 37 factors.28 factors.28 NOUN crl-16614 62 38 56 56 NUM crl-16614 62 39 college college PROPN crl-16614 62 40 & & CCONJ crl-16614 62 41 research research PROPN crl-16614 62 42 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 62 43 january january PROPN crl-16614 62 44 2018 2018 NUM crl-16614 62 45 the the DET crl-16614 62 46 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 62 47 implemented implement VERB crl-16614 62 48 an an DET crl-16614 62 49 interpretive interpretive ADJ crl-16614 62 50 approach approach NOUN crl-16614 62 51 consisting consist VERB crl-16614 62 52 of of ADP crl-16614 62 53 a a DET crl-16614 62 54 three three NUM crl-16614 62 55 - - PUNCT crl-16614 62 56 person person NOUN crl-16614 62 57 panel panel NOUN crl-16614 62 58 making make VERB crl-16614 62 59 independent independent ADJ crl-16614 62 60 judgments judgment NOUN crl-16614 62 61 to to PART crl-16614 62 62 determine determine VERB crl-16614 62 63 whether whether SCONJ crl-16614 62 64 a a DET crl-16614 62 65 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 62 66 from from ADP crl-16614 62 67 the the DET crl-16614 62 68 population population NOUN crl-16614 62 69 of of ADP crl-16614 62 70 jcr jcr PROPN crl-16614 62 71 lis lis PROPN crl-16614 62 72 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 62 73 qualifies qualify VERB crl-16614 62 74 to to PART crl-16614 62 75 be be AUX crl-16614 62 76 categorized categorize VERB crl-16614 62 77 as as ADP crl-16614 62 78 a a DET crl-16614 62 79 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 62 80 potential potential ADJ crl-16614 62 81 , , PUNCT crl-16614 62 82 possible possible ADJ crl-16614 62 83 , , PUNCT crl-16614 62 84 or or CCONJ crl-16614 62 85 probable probable ADJ crl-16614 62 86 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 62 87 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 62 88 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 62 89 according accord VERB crl-16614 62 90 to to ADP crl-16614 62 91 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 62 92 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 62 93 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 62 94 for for ADP crl-16614 62 95 determining determine VERB crl-16614 62 96 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 62 97 open open ADJ crl-16614 62 98 - - PUNCT crl-16614 62 99 access access NOUN crl-16614 62 100 publishers.29 publishers.29 NOUN crl-16614 62 101 other other ADJ crl-16614 62 102 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 62 103 have have AUX crl-16614 62 104 made make VERB crl-16614 62 105 use use NOUN crl-16614 62 106 of of ADP crl-16614 62 107 panels panel NOUN crl-16614 62 108 of of ADP crl-16614 62 109 expert expert NOUN crl-16614 62 110 judges judge NOUN crl-16614 62 111 in in ADP crl-16614 62 112 both both CCONJ crl-16614 62 113 quantitative quantitative ADJ crl-16614 62 114 and and CCONJ crl-16614 62 115 qualitative qualitative ADJ crl-16614 62 116 research research NOUN crl-16614 62 117 . . PUNCT crl-16614 63 1 saljo saljo NOUN crl-16614 63 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 63 3 for for ADP crl-16614 63 4 example example NOUN crl-16614 63 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 63 6 used use VERB crl-16614 63 7 both both CCONJ crl-16614 63 8 quantitative quantitative ADJ crl-16614 63 9 and and CCONJ crl-16614 63 10 qualitative qualitative ADJ crl-16614 63 11 judging judging NOUN crl-16614 63 12 techniques technique NOUN crl-16614 63 13 to to PART crl-16614 63 14 study study VERB crl-16614 63 15 learning learn VERB crl-16614 63 16 approach approach NOUN crl-16614 63 17 and and CCONJ crl-16614 63 18 outcomes.30 outcomes.30 PROPN crl-16614 63 19 douglas douglas PROPN crl-16614 63 20 , , PUNCT crl-16614 63 21 douglas douglas PROPN crl-16614 63 22 , , PUNCT crl-16614 63 23 mcclelland mcclelland NOUN crl-16614 63 24 , , PUNCT crl-16614 63 25 and and CCONJ crl-16614 63 26 davies davy NOUN crl-16614 63 27 used use VERB crl-16614 63 28 a a DET crl-16614 63 29 panel panel NOUN crl-16614 63 30 of of ADP crl-16614 63 31 three three NUM crl-16614 63 32 independent independent ADJ crl-16614 63 33 judges judge NOUN crl-16614 63 34 to to PART crl-16614 63 35 determine determine VERB crl-16614 63 36 levels level NOUN crl-16614 63 37 of of ADP crl-16614 63 38 student student NOUN crl-16614 63 39 satisfaction satisfaction NOUN crl-16614 63 40 and and CCONJ crl-16614 63 41 dissatisfaction dissatisfaction NOUN crl-16614 63 42 in in ADP crl-16614 63 43 u.k u.k PROPN crl-16614 63 44 . . PROPN crl-16614 63 45 higher high ADJ crl-16614 63 46 education education NOUN crl-16614 63 47 . . PUNCT crl-16614 64 1 use use NOUN crl-16614 64 2 of of ADP crl-16614 64 3 this this DET crl-16614 64 4 technique technique NOUN crl-16614 64 5 allowed allow VERB crl-16614 64 6 for for ADP crl-16614 64 7 making make VERB crl-16614 64 8 claims claim NOUN crl-16614 64 9 concerning concern VERB crl-16614 64 10 the the DET crl-16614 64 11 reliability reliability NOUN crl-16614 64 12 of of ADP crl-16614 64 13 the the DET crl-16614 64 14 judging judging NOUN crl-16614 64 15 process process NOUN crl-16614 64 16 and and CCONJ crl-16614 64 17 the the DET crl-16614 64 18 outcomes.31 outcomes.31 NOUN crl-16614 64 19 during during ADP crl-16614 64 20 the the DET crl-16614 64 21 course course NOUN crl-16614 64 22 of of ADP crl-16614 64 23 a a DET crl-16614 64 24 one one NUM crl-16614 64 25 - - PUNCT crl-16614 64 26 week week NOUN crl-16614 64 27 period period NOUN crl-16614 64 28 , , PUNCT crl-16614 64 29 the the DET crl-16614 64 30 panel panel NOUN crl-16614 64 31 rated rate VERB crl-16614 64 32 the the DET crl-16614 64 33 jcr jcr PROPN crl-16614 64 34 lis lis PROPN crl-16614 64 35 entries entry NOUN crl-16614 64 36 separately separately ADV crl-16614 64 37 . . PUNCT crl-16614 65 1 the the DET crl-16614 65 2 three three NUM crl-16614 65 3 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 65 4 are be AUX crl-16614 65 5 all all PRON crl-16614 65 6 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 65 7 librarians librarian NOUN crl-16614 65 8 possessing possess VERB crl-16614 65 9 ala ala NOUN crl-16614 65 10 - - PUNCT crl-16614 65 11 accredited accredit VERB crl-16614 65 12 master master NOUN crl-16614 65 13 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 65 14 degrees degree NOUN crl-16614 65 15 in in ADP crl-16614 65 16 lis lis PROPN crl-16614 65 17 and and CCONJ crl-16614 65 18 22 22 NUM crl-16614 65 19 years year NOUN crl-16614 65 20 ’ ’ PART crl-16614 65 21 total total ADJ crl-16614 65 22 combined combined ADJ crl-16614 65 23 experience experience NOUN crl-16614 65 24 as as ADP crl-16614 65 25 professional professional ADJ crl-16614 65 26 librarians librarian NOUN crl-16614 65 27 . . PUNCT crl-16614 66 1 they they PRON crl-16614 66 2 have have AUX crl-16614 66 3 authored author VERB crl-16614 66 4 a a DET crl-16614 66 5 combined combined ADJ crl-16614 66 6 total total NOUN crl-16614 66 7 of of ADP crl-16614 66 8 23 23 NUM crl-16614 66 9 refereed refereed NOUN crl-16614 66 10 publications publication NOUN crl-16614 66 11 in in ADP crl-16614 66 12 peer peer NOUN crl-16614 66 13 - - PUNCT crl-16614 66 14 reviewed review VERB crl-16614 66 15 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 66 16 — — PUNCT crl-16614 66 17 four four NUM crl-16614 66 18 of of ADP crl-16614 66 19 which which PRON crl-16614 66 20 are be AUX crl-16614 66 21 published publish VERB crl-16614 66 22 in in ADP crl-16614 66 23 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 66 24 listed list VERB crl-16614 66 25 in in ADP crl-16614 66 26 the the DET crl-16614 66 27 jcr jcr PROPN crl-16614 66 28 collection collection NOUN crl-16614 66 29 — — PUNCT crl-16614 66 30 and and CCONJ crl-16614 66 31 have have AUX crl-16614 66 32 themselves themselves PRON crl-16614 66 33 refereed refereed VERB crl-16614 66 34 16 16 NUM crl-16614 66 35 total total ADJ crl-16614 66 36 articles article NOUN crl-16614 66 37 for for ADP crl-16614 66 38 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 66 39 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 66 40 . . PUNCT crl-16614 67 1 the the DET crl-16614 67 2 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 67 3 were be AUX crl-16614 67 4 cognizant cognizant ADJ crl-16614 67 5 that that SCONJ crl-16614 67 6 their their PRON crl-16614 67 7 dual dual ADJ crl-16614 67 8 role role NOUN crl-16614 67 9 as as ADP crl-16614 67 10 both both DET crl-16614 67 11 authors author NOUN crl-16614 67 12 and and CCONJ crl-16614 67 13 judges judge NOUN crl-16614 67 14 increased increase VERB crl-16614 67 15 the the DET crl-16614 67 16 potential potential NOUN crl-16614 67 17 for for ADP crl-16614 67 18 bias bias NOUN crl-16614 67 19 in in ADP crl-16614 67 20 any any DET crl-16614 67 21 resulting result VERB crl-16614 67 22 analysis analysis NOUN crl-16614 67 23 . . PUNCT crl-16614 68 1 they they PRON crl-16614 68 2 recognized recognize VERB crl-16614 68 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 68 4 however however ADV crl-16614 68 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 68 6 that that DET crl-16614 68 7 bias bias NOUN crl-16614 68 8 is be AUX crl-16614 68 9 an an DET crl-16614 68 10 inherent inherent ADJ crl-16614 68 11 aspect aspect NOUN crl-16614 68 12 of of ADP crl-16614 68 13 interpretive interpretive ADJ crl-16614 68 14 research research NOUN crl-16614 68 15 and and CCONJ crl-16614 68 16 that that SCONJ crl-16614 68 17 conscious conscious ADJ crl-16614 68 18 reflection reflection NOUN crl-16614 68 19 throughout throughout ADP crl-16614 68 20 the the DET crl-16614 68 21 research research NOUN crl-16614 68 22 process process NOUN crl-16614 68 23 is be AUX crl-16614 68 24 a a DET crl-16614 68 25 method method NOUN crl-16614 68 26 for for ADP crl-16614 68 27 mitigating mitigate VERB crl-16614 68 28 such such ADJ crl-16614 68 29 bias bias NOUN crl-16614 68 30 . . PUNCT crl-16614 69 1 to to PART crl-16614 69 2 minimize minimize VERB crl-16614 69 3 bias bias NOUN crl-16614 69 4 , , PUNCT crl-16614 69 5 the the DET crl-16614 69 6 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 69 7 took take VERB crl-16614 69 8 part part NOUN crl-16614 69 9 in in ADP crl-16614 69 10 a a DET crl-16614 69 11 briefing briefing NOUN crl-16614 69 12 session session NOUN crl-16614 69 13 concerning concern VERB crl-16614 69 14 the the DET crl-16614 69 15 importance importance NOUN crl-16614 69 16 of of ADP crl-16614 69 17 reflexivity reflexivity NOUN crl-16614 69 18 prior prior ADV crl-16614 69 19 to to ADP crl-16614 69 20 beginning begin VERB crl-16614 69 21 the the DET crl-16614 69 22 analysis analysis NOUN crl-16614 69 23 . . PUNCT crl-16614 70 1 the the DET crl-16614 70 2 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 70 3 applied apply VERB crl-16614 70 4 the the DET crl-16614 70 5 27 27 NUM crl-16614 70 6 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 70 7 for for ADP crl-16614 70 8 determining determine VERB crl-16614 70 9 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 70 10 open open ADJ crl-16614 70 11 - - PUNCT crl-16614 70 12 access access NOUN crl-16614 70 13 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 70 14 to to ADP crl-16614 70 15 each each DET crl-16614 70 16 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 70 17 title title NOUN crl-16614 70 18 . . PUNCT crl-16614 71 1 they they PRON crl-16614 71 2 performed perform VERB crl-16614 71 3 this this DET crl-16614 71 4 task task NOUN crl-16614 71 5 independently independently ADV crl-16614 71 6 of of ADP crl-16614 71 7 each each DET crl-16614 71 8 other other ADJ crl-16614 71 9 , , PUNCT crl-16614 71 10 with with ADP crl-16614 71 11 no no DET crl-16614 71 12 additional additional ADJ crl-16614 71 13 instructions instruction NOUN crl-16614 71 14 for for ADP crl-16614 71 15 how how SCONJ crl-16614 71 16 to to PART crl-16614 71 17 apply apply VERB crl-16614 71 18 the the DET crl-16614 71 19 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 71 20 beyond beyond ADP crl-16614 71 21 those those PRON crl-16614 71 22 given give VERB crl-16614 71 23 in in ADP crl-16614 71 24 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 71 25 ’s ’s PROPN crl-16614 71 26 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 71 27 itself itself PRON crl-16614 71 28 . . PUNCT crl-16614 72 1 that that ADV crl-16614 72 2 is is ADV crl-16614 72 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 72 4 they they PRON crl-16614 72 5 were be AUX crl-16614 72 6 each each PRON crl-16614 72 7 required require VERB crl-16614 72 8 to to PART crl-16614 72 9 interpret interpret VERB crl-16614 72 10 and and CCONJ crl-16614 72 11 apply apply VERB crl-16614 72 12 the the DET crl-16614 72 13 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 72 14 themselves themselves PRON crl-16614 72 15 . . PUNCT crl-16614 73 1 none none NOUN crl-16614 73 2 of of ADP crl-16614 73 3 the the DET crl-16614 73 4 three three NUM crl-16614 73 5 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 73 6 had have AUX crl-16614 73 7 previously previously ADV crl-16614 73 8 served serve VERB crl-16614 73 9 as as ADP crl-16614 73 10 either either PRON crl-16614 73 11 editors editor NOUN crl-16614 73 12 or or CCONJ crl-16614 73 13 board board NOUN crl-16614 73 14 members member NOUN crl-16614 73 15 for for ADP crl-16614 73 16 any any PRON crl-16614 73 17 of of ADP crl-16614 73 18 the the DET crl-16614 73 19 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 73 20 under under ADP crl-16614 73 21 consideration consideration NOUN crl-16614 73 22 . . PUNCT crl-16614 74 1 there there PRON crl-16614 74 2 was be VERB crl-16614 74 3 no no DET crl-16614 74 4 time time NOUN crl-16614 74 5 limit limit NOUN crl-16614 74 6 for for ADP crl-16614 74 7 applying apply VERB crl-16614 74 8 the the DET crl-16614 74 9 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 74 10 to to ADP crl-16614 74 11 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 74 12 during during ADP crl-16614 74 13 the the DET crl-16614 74 14 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-16614 74 15 process process NOUN crl-16614 74 16 . . PUNCT crl-16614 75 1 there there PRON crl-16614 75 2 was be VERB crl-16614 75 3 no no DET crl-16614 75 4 discussion discussion NOUN crl-16614 75 5 allowed allow VERB crl-16614 75 6 concerning concern VERB crl-16614 75 7 possible possible ADJ crl-16614 75 8 interpretations interpretation NOUN crl-16614 75 9 of of ADP crl-16614 75 10 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 75 11 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 75 12 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 75 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 75 14 or or CCONJ crl-16614 75 15 as as ADP crl-16614 75 16 to to ADP crl-16614 75 17 whether whether SCONJ crl-16614 75 18 or or CCONJ crl-16614 75 19 not not PART crl-16614 75 20 a a DET crl-16614 75 21 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 75 22 or or CCONJ crl-16614 75 23 its its PRON crl-16614 75 24 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 75 25 met meet VERB crl-16614 75 26 any any PRON crl-16614 75 27 of of ADP crl-16614 75 28 the the DET crl-16614 75 29 27 27 NUM crl-16614 75 30 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 75 31 of of ADP crl-16614 75 32 the the DET crl-16614 75 33 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 75 34 . . PUNCT crl-16614 76 1 there there PRON crl-16614 76 2 was be VERB crl-16614 76 3 no no DET crl-16614 76 4 discussion discussion NOUN crl-16614 76 5 concerning concern VERB crl-16614 76 6 the the DET crl-16614 76 7 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 76 8 of of ADP crl-16614 76 9 any any PRON crl-16614 76 10 of of ADP crl-16614 76 11 the the DET crl-16614 76 12 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 76 13 being be AUX crl-16614 76 14 reviewed review VERB crl-16614 76 15 . . PUNCT crl-16614 77 1 the the DET crl-16614 77 2 only only ADJ crl-16614 77 3 discussion discussion NOUN crl-16614 77 4 allowed allow VERB crl-16614 77 5 among among ADP crl-16614 77 6 the the DET crl-16614 77 7 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 77 8 during during ADP crl-16614 77 9 this this DET crl-16614 77 10 period period NOUN crl-16614 77 11 of of ADP crl-16614 77 12 review review NOUN crl-16614 77 13 was be AUX crl-16614 77 14 only only ADV crl-16614 77 15 what what PRON crl-16614 77 16 was be AUX crl-16614 77 17 needed need VERB crl-16614 77 18 to to PART crl-16614 77 19 determine determine VERB crl-16614 77 20 and and CCONJ crl-16614 77 21 agree agree VERB crl-16614 77 22 upon upon SCONJ crl-16614 77 23 the the DET crl-16614 77 24 identity identity NOUN crl-16614 77 25 of of ADP crl-16614 77 26 a a DET crl-16614 77 27 particular particular ADJ crl-16614 77 28 listed list VERB crl-16614 77 29 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 77 30 if if SCONJ crl-16614 77 31 there there PRON crl-16614 77 32 was be VERB crl-16614 77 33 any any DET crl-16614 77 34 doubt doubt NOUN crl-16614 77 35 as as SCONJ crl-16614 77 36 to to ADP crl-16614 77 37 that that DET crl-16614 77 38 identity identity NOUN crl-16614 77 39 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 77 40 for for ADP crl-16614 77 41 example example NOUN crl-16614 77 42 , , PUNCT crl-16614 77 43 if if SCONJ crl-16614 77 44 more more ADJ crl-16614 77 45 than than ADP crl-16614 77 46 one one NUM crl-16614 77 47 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 77 48 exists exist VERB crl-16614 77 49 with with ADP crl-16614 77 50 the the DET crl-16614 77 51 same same ADJ crl-16614 77 52 title title NOUN crl-16614 77 53 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 77 54 . . PUNCT crl-16614 78 1 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 78 2 recorded record VERB crl-16614 78 3 a a DET crl-16614 78 4 yes yes INTJ crl-16614 78 5 or or CCONJ crl-16614 78 6 no no DET crl-16614 78 7 judgment judgment NOUN crl-16614 78 8 for for ADP crl-16614 78 9 each each PRON crl-16614 78 10 of of ADP crl-16614 78 11 the the DET crl-16614 78 12 27 27 NUM crl-16614 78 13 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 78 14 , , PUNCT crl-16614 78 15 with with ADP crl-16614 78 16 yes yes INTJ crl-16614 78 17 meaning mean VERB crl-16614 78 18 that that SCONJ crl-16614 78 19 their their PRON crl-16614 78 20 analysis analysis NOUN crl-16614 78 21 of of ADP crl-16614 78 22 the the DET crl-16614 78 23 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 78 24 indicated indicate VERB crl-16614 78 25 that that SCONJ crl-16614 78 26 it it PRON crl-16614 78 27 fit fit VERB crl-16614 78 28 the the DET crl-16614 78 29 description description NOUN crl-16614 78 30 of of ADP crl-16614 78 31 a a DET crl-16614 78 32 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 78 33 potential potential ADJ crl-16614 78 34 , , PUNCT crl-16614 78 35 possible possible ADJ crl-16614 78 36 , , PUNCT crl-16614 78 37 or or CCONJ crl-16614 78 38 probably probably ADV crl-16614 78 39 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 78 40 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 78 41 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 78 42 according accord VERB crl-16614 78 43 to to ADP crl-16614 78 44 the the DET crl-16614 78 45 particular particular ADJ crl-16614 78 46 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 78 47 , , PUNCT crl-16614 78 48 and and CCONJ crl-16614 78 49 no no DET crl-16614 78 50 meaning meaning NOUN crl-16614 78 51 that that SCONJ crl-16614 78 52 it it PRON crl-16614 78 53 did do AUX crl-16614 78 54 not not PART crl-16614 78 55 sufficiently sufficiently ADV crl-16614 78 56 meet meet VERB crl-16614 78 57 the the DET crl-16614 78 58 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 78 59 analyst analyst NOUN crl-16614 78 60 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 78 61 interpretation interpretation NOUN crl-16614 78 62 of of ADP crl-16614 78 63 the the DET crl-16614 78 64 particular particular ADJ crl-16614 78 65 criterion criterion NOUN crl-16614 78 66 . . PUNCT crl-16614 79 1 all all DET crl-16614 79 2 three three NUM crl-16614 79 3 of of ADP crl-16614 79 4 the the DET crl-16614 79 5 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 79 6 were be AUX crl-16614 79 7 unaware unaware ADJ crl-16614 79 8 of of ADP crl-16614 79 9 each each DET crl-16614 79 10 others other NOUN crl-16614 79 11 ’ ’ PART crl-16614 79 12 decisions decision NOUN crl-16614 79 13 throughout throughout ADP crl-16614 79 14 the the DET crl-16614 79 15 entire entire ADJ crl-16614 79 16 judging judging NOUN crl-16614 79 17 process process NOUN crl-16614 79 18 . . PUNCT crl-16614 80 1 following follow VERB crl-16614 80 2 completion completion NOUN crl-16614 80 3 of of ADP crl-16614 80 4 the the DET crl-16614 80 5 qualitative qualitative ADJ crl-16614 80 6 judgment judgment NOUN crl-16614 80 7 of of ADP crl-16614 80 8 the the DET crl-16614 80 9 87 87 NUM crl-16614 80 10 entries entry NOUN crl-16614 80 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 80 12 the the DET crl-16614 80 13 three three NUM crl-16614 80 14 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 80 15 ’ ’ PART crl-16614 80 16 decisions decision NOUN crl-16614 80 17 were be AUX crl-16614 80 18 tabulated tabulate VERB crl-16614 80 19 for for ADP crl-16614 80 20 each each DET crl-16614 80 21 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 80 22 . . PUNCT crl-16614 81 1 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 81 2 criterion criterion NOUN crl-16614 81 3 were be AUX crl-16614 81 4 assigned assign VERB crl-16614 81 5 an an DET crl-16614 81 6 overall overall ADJ crl-16614 81 7 yes yes INTJ crl-16614 81 8 designation designation NOUN crl-16614 81 9 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 81 10 meeting meet VERB crl-16614 81 11 the the DET crl-16614 81 12 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 81 13 for for ADP crl-16614 81 14 a a DET crl-16614 81 15 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 81 16 potential potential ADJ crl-16614 81 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 81 18 possible possible ADJ crl-16614 81 19 , , PUNCT crl-16614 81 20 or or CCONJ crl-16614 81 21 probable probable ADJ crl-16614 81 22 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 81 23 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 81 24 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 81 25 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 81 26 or or CCONJ crl-16614 81 27 a a DET crl-16614 81 28 no no DET crl-16614 81 29 designation designation NOUN crl-16614 81 30 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 81 31 failing fail VERB crl-16614 81 32 to to PART crl-16614 81 33 meet meet VERB crl-16614 81 34 the the DET crl-16614 81 35 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 81 36 for for ADP crl-16614 81 37 a a DET crl-16614 81 38 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 81 39 potential potential ADJ crl-16614 81 40 , , PUNCT crl-16614 81 41 possible possible ADJ crl-16614 81 42 , , PUNCT crl-16614 81 43 or or CCONJ crl-16614 81 44 probably probably ADV crl-16614 81 45 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 81 46 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 81 47 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 81 48 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 81 49 depending depend VERB crl-16614 81 50 on on ADP crl-16614 81 51 which which PRON crl-16614 81 52 of of ADP crl-16614 81 53 the the DET crl-16614 81 54 two two NUM crl-16614 81 55 possible possible ADJ crl-16614 81 56 outcomes outcome NOUN crl-16614 81 57 received receive VERB crl-16614 81 58 the the DET crl-16614 81 59 majority majority NOUN crl-16614 81 60 of of ADP crl-16614 81 61 votes vote NOUN crl-16614 81 62 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 81 63 that that ADV crl-16614 81 64 is is ADV crl-16614 81 65 , , PUNCT crl-16614 81 66 two two NUM crl-16614 81 67 or or CCONJ crl-16614 81 68 three three NUM crl-16614 81 69 votes vote NOUN crl-16614 81 70 out out ADP crl-16614 81 71 of of ADP crl-16614 81 72 three three NUM crl-16614 81 73 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 81 74 . . PUNCT crl-16614 82 1 the the DET crl-16614 82 2 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 82 3 recorded record VERB crl-16614 82 4 the the DET crl-16614 82 5 number number NOUN crl-16614 82 6 of of ADP crl-16614 82 7 yes yes INTJ crl-16614 82 8 versus versus ADP crl-16614 82 9 no no DET crl-16614 82 10 votes vote NOUN crl-16614 82 11 for for ADP crl-16614 82 12 each each DET crl-16614 82 13 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 82 14 for for ADP crl-16614 82 15 further further ADJ crl-16614 82 16 analysis analysis NOUN crl-16614 82 17 . . PUNCT crl-16614 83 1 format format NOUN crl-16614 83 2 aside aside ADV crl-16614 83 3 57 57 NUM crl-16614 83 4 results result NOUN crl-16614 83 5 of of ADP crl-16614 83 6 the the DET crl-16614 83 7 87 87 NUM crl-16614 83 8 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 83 9 titles title NOUN crl-16614 83 10 analyzed analyze VERB crl-16614 83 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 83 12 the the DET crl-16614 83 13 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 83 14 removed remove VERB crl-16614 83 15 six six NUM crl-16614 83 16 entries entry NOUN crl-16614 83 17 from from ADP crl-16614 83 18 the the DET crl-16614 83 19 study study NOUN crl-16614 83 20 due due ADP crl-16614 83 21 to to ADP crl-16614 83 22 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 83 23 title title NOUN crl-16614 83 24 duplication duplication NOUN crl-16614 83 25 , , PUNCT crl-16614 83 26 title title NOUN crl-16614 83 27 changes change NOUN crl-16614 83 28 , , PUNCT crl-16614 83 29 or or CCONJ crl-16614 83 30 the the DET crl-16614 83 31 determination determination NOUN crl-16614 83 32 that that PRON crl-16614 83 33 the the DET crl-16614 83 34 entry entry NOUN crl-16614 83 35 did do AUX crl-16614 83 36 not not PART crl-16614 83 37 actually actually ADV crl-16614 83 38 represent represent VERB crl-16614 83 39 a a DET crl-16614 83 40 peer peer NOUN crl-16614 83 41 - - PUNCT crl-16614 83 42 reviewed review VERB crl-16614 83 43 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 83 44 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 83 45 . . PUNCT crl-16614 84 1 the the DET crl-16614 84 2 remaining remain VERB crl-16614 84 3 81 81 NUM crl-16614 84 4 entries entry NOUN crl-16614 84 5 counted count VERB crl-16614 84 6 as as ADP crl-16614 84 7 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 84 8 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 84 9 titles title NOUN crl-16614 84 10 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 84 11 see see VERB crl-16614 84 12 appendix appendix PROPN crl-16614 84 13 for for ADP crl-16614 84 14 a a DET crl-16614 84 15 list list NOUN crl-16614 84 16 of of ADP crl-16614 84 17 the the DET crl-16614 84 18 81 81 NUM crl-16614 84 19 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 84 20 evaluated evaluate VERB crl-16614 84 21 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 84 22 . . PUNCT crl-16614 85 1 of of ADP crl-16614 85 2 these these DET crl-16614 85 3 81 81 NUM crl-16614 85 4 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 85 5 examined examine VERB crl-16614 85 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 85 7 45 45 NUM crl-16614 85 8 of of ADP crl-16614 85 9 the the DET crl-16614 85 10 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 85 11 failed fail VERB crl-16614 85 12 at at ADP crl-16614 85 13 least least ADJ crl-16614 85 14 one one NUM crl-16614 85 15 of of ADP crl-16614 85 16 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 85 17 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 85 18 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 85 19 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 85 20 again again ADV crl-16614 85 21 , , PUNCT crl-16614 85 22 this this DET crl-16614 85 23 determination determination NOUN crl-16614 85 24 of of ADP crl-16614 85 25 failure failure NOUN crl-16614 85 26 required require VERB crl-16614 85 27 at at ADP crl-16614 85 28 least least ADJ crl-16614 85 29 two two NUM crl-16614 85 30 of of ADP crl-16614 85 31 three three NUM crl-16614 85 32 yes yes NOUN crl-16614 85 33 votes vote NOUN crl-16614 85 34 on on ADP crl-16614 85 35 the the DET crl-16614 85 36 part part NOUN crl-16614 85 37 of of ADP crl-16614 85 38 the the DET crl-16614 85 39 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 85 40 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 85 41 . . PUNCT crl-16614 86 1 a a DET crl-16614 86 2 closer close ADJ crl-16614 86 3 look look NOUN crl-16614 86 4 at at ADP crl-16614 86 5 these these DET crl-16614 86 6 45 45 NUM crl-16614 86 7 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 86 8 in in ADP crl-16614 86 9 table table NOUN crl-16614 86 10 1 1 NUM crl-16614 86 11 shows show VERB crl-16614 86 12 that that SCONJ crl-16614 86 13 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 86 14 can can AUX crl-16614 86 15 and and CCONJ crl-16614 86 16 have have AUX crl-16614 86 17 failed fail VERB crl-16614 86 18 more more ADJ crl-16614 86 19 than than ADP crl-16614 86 20 one one NUM crl-16614 86 21 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 86 22 in in ADP crl-16614 86 23 the the DET crl-16614 86 24 study study NOUN crl-16614 86 25 , , PUNCT crl-16614 86 26 with with ADP crl-16614 86 27 18 18 NUM crl-16614 86 28 of of ADP crl-16614 86 29 the the DET crl-16614 86 30 45 45 NUM crl-16614 86 31 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 86 32 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 86 33 45 45 NUM crl-16614 86 34 % % NOUN crl-16614 86 35 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 86 36 failing fail VERB crl-16614 86 37 more more ADJ crl-16614 86 38 than than ADP crl-16614 86 39 one one NUM crl-16614 86 40 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 86 41 . . PUNCT crl-16614 87 1 looking look VERB crl-16614 87 2 closer close ADV crl-16614 87 3 at at ADP crl-16614 87 4 the the DET crl-16614 87 5 types type NOUN crl-16614 87 6 of of ADP crl-16614 87 7 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 87 8 : : PUNCT crl-16614 87 9 association association NOUN crl-16614 87 10 , , PUNCT crl-16614 87 11 commercial commercial ADJ crl-16614 87 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 87 13 or or CCONJ crl-16614 87 14 university university NOUN crl-16614 87 15 press press NOUN crl-16614 87 16 , , PUNCT crl-16614 87 17 we we PRON crl-16614 87 18 see see VERB crl-16614 87 19 that that SCONJ crl-16614 87 20 all all DET crl-16614 87 21 types type NOUN crl-16614 87 22 of of ADP crl-16614 87 23 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 87 24 failed fail VERB crl-16614 87 25 at at ADP crl-16614 87 26 least least ADV crl-16614 87 27 one one NUM crl-16614 87 28 criterion criterion NOUN crl-16614 87 29 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 87 30 see see VERB crl-16614 87 31 table table NOUN crl-16614 87 32 2 2 NUM crl-16614 87 33 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 87 34 . . PUNCT crl-16614 88 1 in in ADP crl-16614 88 2 cases case NOUN crl-16614 88 3 where where SCONJ crl-16614 88 4 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 88 5 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 88 6 were be AUX crl-16614 88 7 affiliated affiliate VERB crl-16614 88 8 with with ADP crl-16614 88 9 an an DET crl-16614 88 10 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 88 11 institution institution NOUN crl-16614 88 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 88 13 the the DET crl-16614 88 14 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 88 15 classified classify VERB crl-16614 88 16 those those PRON crl-16614 88 17 as as ADP crl-16614 88 18 university university NOUN crl-16614 88 19 presses press NOUN crl-16614 88 20 . . PUNCT crl-16614 89 1 commercial commercial ADJ crl-16614 89 2 presses press NOUN crl-16614 89 3 published publish VERB crl-16614 89 4 the the DET crl-16614 89 5 majority majority NOUN crl-16614 89 6 of of ADP crl-16614 89 7 failed fail VERB crl-16614 89 8 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 89 9 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 89 10 52 52 NUM crl-16614 89 11 % % NOUN crl-16614 89 12 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 89 13 . . PUNCT crl-16614 90 1 it it PRON crl-16614 90 2 should should AUX crl-16614 90 3 be be AUX crl-16614 90 4 noted note VERB crl-16614 90 5 that that SCONJ crl-16614 90 6 the the DET crl-16614 90 7 17 17 NUM crl-16614 90 8 instances instance NOUN crl-16614 90 9 of of ADP crl-16614 90 10 failed fail VERB crl-16614 90 11 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 90 12 does do AUX crl-16614 90 13 not not PART crl-16614 90 14 represent represent VERB crl-16614 90 15 17 17 NUM crl-16614 90 16 different different ADJ crl-16614 90 17 commercial commercial ADJ crl-16614 90 18 presses press NOUN crl-16614 90 19 , , PUNCT crl-16614 90 20 but but CCONJ crl-16614 90 21 that that SCONJ crl-16614 90 22 certain certain ADJ crl-16614 90 23 presses press NOUN crl-16614 90 24 had have VERB crl-16614 90 25 multiple multiple ADJ crl-16614 90 26 failed fail VERB crl-16614 90 27 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 90 28 titles title NOUN crl-16614 90 29 . . PUNCT crl-16614 91 1 table table NOUN crl-16614 91 2 3 3 NUM crl-16614 91 3 shows show VERB crl-16614 91 4 the the DET crl-16614 91 5 number number NOUN crl-16614 91 6 of of ADP crl-16614 91 7 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 91 8 failed fail VERB crl-16614 91 9 by by ADP crl-16614 91 10 age age NOUN crl-16614 91 11 of of ADP crl-16614 91 12 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 91 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 91 14 demonstrating demonstrate VERB crl-16614 91 15 that that SCONJ crl-16614 91 16 all all PRON crl-16614 91 17 of of ADP crl-16614 91 18 the the DET crl-16614 91 19 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 91 20 that that PRON crl-16614 91 21 failed fail VERB crl-16614 91 22 a a DET crl-16614 91 23 criterion criterion NOUN crl-16614 91 24 are be AUX crl-16614 91 25 at at ADP crl-16614 91 26 least least ADV crl-16614 91 27 10 10 NUM crl-16614 91 28 years year NOUN crl-16614 91 29 old old ADJ crl-16614 91 30 . . PUNCT crl-16614 92 1 the the DET crl-16614 92 2 median median ADJ crl-16614 92 3 age age NOUN crl-16614 92 4 of of ADP crl-16614 92 5 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 92 6 in in ADP crl-16614 92 7 the the DET crl-16614 92 8 isi isi ADJ crl-16614 92 9 example example NOUN crl-16614 92 10 is be AUX crl-16614 92 11 32 32 NUM crl-16614 92 12 years year NOUN crl-16614 92 13 . . PUNCT crl-16614 93 1 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 93 2 divides divide VERB crl-16614 93 3 his his PRON crl-16614 93 4 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 93 5 into into ADP crl-16614 93 6 four four NUM crl-16614 93 7 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 93 8 areas area NOUN crl-16614 93 9 . . PUNCT crl-16614 94 1 table table NOUN crl-16614 94 2 4 4 NUM crl-16614 94 3 highlights highlight NOUN crl-16614 94 4 the the DET crl-16614 94 5 percentage percentage NOUN crl-16614 94 6 of of ADP crl-16614 94 7 total total ADJ crl-16614 94 8 failed fail VERB crl-16614 94 9 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 94 10 in in ADP crl-16614 94 11 each each DET crl-16614 94 12 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 94 13 area area NOUN crl-16614 94 14 . . PUNCT crl-16614 95 1 the the DET crl-16614 95 2 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 95 3 area area NOUN crl-16614 95 4 for for ADP crl-16614 95 5 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 95 6 and and CCONJ crl-16614 95 7 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 95 8 , , PUNCT crl-16614 95 9 which which PRON crl-16614 95 10 has have VERB crl-16614 95 11 nine nine NUM crl-16614 95 12 specific specific ADJ crl-16614 95 13 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 95 14 , , PUNCT crl-16614 95 15 had have VERB crl-16614 95 16 the the DET crl-16614 95 17 largest large ADJ crl-16614 95 18 failure failure NOUN crl-16614 95 19 percentage percentage NOUN crl-16614 95 20 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 95 21 77.78 77.78 NUM crl-16614 95 22 % % NOUN crl-16614 95 23 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 95 24 . . PUNCT crl-16614 96 1 the the DET crl-16614 96 2 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 96 3 area area NOUN crl-16614 96 4 for for ADP crl-16614 96 5 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 96 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 96 7 which which PRON crl-16614 96 8 encompasses encompass VERB crl-16614 96 9 seven seven NUM crl-16614 96 10 specific specific ADJ crl-16614 96 11 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 96 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 96 13 was be AUX crl-16614 96 14 not not PART crl-16614 96 15 the the DET crl-16614 96 16 cause cause NOUN crl-16614 96 17 for for ADP crl-16614 96 18 any any DET crl-16614 96 19 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 96 20 failure failure NOUN crl-16614 96 21 . . PUNCT crl-16614 97 1 table table NOUN crl-16614 97 2 5 5 NUM crl-16614 97 3 illustrates illustrate VERB crl-16614 97 4 the the DET crl-16614 97 5 number number NOUN crl-16614 97 6 of of ADP crl-16614 97 7 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 97 8 that that PRON crl-16614 97 9 could could AUX crl-16614 97 10 be be AUX crl-16614 97 11 perceived perceive VERB crl-16614 97 12 as as ADP crl-16614 97 13 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 97 14 by by ADP crl-16614 97 15 the the DET crl-16614 97 16 top top ADJ crl-16614 97 17 five five NUM crl-16614 97 18 failing fail VERB crl-16614 97 19 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 97 20 . . PUNCT crl-16614 98 1 the the DET crl-16614 98 2 most most ADV crl-16614 98 3 failed fail VERB crl-16614 98 4 criterion criterion NOUN crl-16614 98 5 was be AUX crl-16614 98 6 under under ADP crl-16614 98 7 the the DET crl-16614 98 8 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 98 9 area area NOUN crl-16614 98 10 business business NOUN crl-16614 98 11 management management NOUN crl-16614 98 12 : : PUNCT crl-16614 98 13 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 98 14 has have VERB crl-16614 98 15 no no DET crl-16614 98 16 policies policy NOUN crl-16614 98 17 or or CCONJ crl-16614 98 18 practices practice NOUN crl-16614 98 19 for for ADP crl-16614 98 20 digital digital ADJ crl-16614 98 21 preservation preservation NOUN crl-16614 98 22 , , PUNCT crl-16614 98 23 meaning mean VERB crl-16614 98 24 that that SCONJ crl-16614 98 25 if if SCONJ crl-16614 98 26 the the DET crl-16614 98 27 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 98 28 ceases cease VERB crl-16614 98 29 operations operation NOUN crl-16614 98 30 , , PUNCT crl-16614 98 31 all all PRON crl-16614 98 32 of of ADP crl-16614 98 33 the the DET crl-16614 98 34 content content NOUN crl-16614 98 35 disappears disappear VERB crl-16614 98 36 from from ADP crl-16614 98 37 the the DET crl-16614 98 38 internet internet NOUN crl-16614 98 39 . . PUNCT crl-16614 98 40 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 99 1 twenty twenty NUM crl-16614 99 2 - - PUNCT crl-16614 99 3 two two NUM crl-16614 99 4 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 99 5 failed fail VERB crl-16614 99 6 this this DET crl-16614 99 7 criterion criterion NOUN crl-16614 99 8 . . PUNCT crl-16614 100 1 three three NUM crl-16614 100 2 out out ADP crl-16614 100 3 of of ADP crl-16614 100 4 five five NUM crl-16614 100 5 of of ADP crl-16614 100 6 the the DET crl-16614 100 7 top top ADJ crl-16614 100 8 five five NUM crl-16614 100 9 most most ADV crl-16614 100 10 failed fail VERB crl-16614 100 11 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 100 12 fell fall VERB crl-16614 100 13 into into ADP crl-16614 100 14 the the DET crl-16614 100 15 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 100 16 and and CCONJ crl-16614 100 17 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 100 18 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 100 19 area area NOUN crl-16614 100 20 . . PUNCT crl-16614 101 1 table table NOUN crl-16614 101 2 1 1 NUM crl-16614 101 3 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 101 4 that that PRON crl-16614 101 5 failed fail VERB crl-16614 101 6 one one NUM crl-16614 101 7 or or CCONJ crl-16614 101 8 more more ADJ crl-16614 101 9 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 101 10 number number NOUN crl-16614 101 11 of of ADP crl-16614 101 12 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 101 13 number number NOUN crl-16614 101 14 of of ADP crl-16614 101 15 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 101 16 failed fail VERB crl-16614 101 17 27 27 NUM crl-16614 101 18 1 1 NUM crl-16614 101 19 10 10 NUM crl-16614 101 20 2 2 NUM crl-16614 101 21 4 4 NUM crl-16614 101 22 3–6 3–6 NUM crl-16614 101 23 4 4 NUM crl-16614 101 24 7–9 7–9 NUM crl-16614 101 25 table table NOUN crl-16614 101 26 2 2 NUM crl-16614 101 27 types type NOUN crl-16614 101 28 of of ADP crl-16614 101 29 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 101 30 that that PRON crl-16614 101 31 failed fail VERB crl-16614 101 32 one one NUM crl-16614 101 33 or or CCONJ crl-16614 101 34 more more ADJ crl-16614 101 35 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 101 36 type type NOUN crl-16614 101 37 of of ADP crl-16614 101 38 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 101 39 number number NOUN crl-16614 101 40 of of ADP crl-16614 101 41 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 101 42 that that PRON crl-16614 101 43 failed fail VERB crl-16614 101 44 association association NOUN crl-16614 101 45 press press PROPN crl-16614 101 46 8 8 NUM crl-16614 101 47 commercial commercial ADJ crl-16614 101 48 press press NOUN crl-16614 101 49 17 17 NUM crl-16614 101 50 university university NOUN crl-16614 101 51 press press NOUN crl-16614 101 52 8 8 NUM crl-16614 101 53 table table NOUN crl-16614 101 54 3 3 NUM crl-16614 101 55 age age NOUN crl-16614 101 56 and and CCONJ crl-16614 101 57 number number NOUN crl-16614 101 58 of of ADP crl-16614 101 59 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 101 60 that that PRON crl-16614 101 61 failed fail VERB crl-16614 101 62 one one NUM crl-16614 101 63 or or CCONJ crl-16614 101 64 more more ADJ crl-16614 101 65 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 101 66 age age NOUN crl-16614 101 67 of of ADP crl-16614 101 68 the the DET crl-16614 101 69 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 101 70 number number NOUN crl-16614 101 71 of of ADP crl-16614 101 72 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 101 73 total total ADJ crl-16614 101 74 number number NOUN crl-16614 101 75 of of ADP crl-16614 101 76 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 101 77 failed fail VERB crl-16614 101 78 50–150 50–150 PROPN crl-16614 101 79 years year NOUN crl-16614 101 80 old old ADJ crl-16614 101 81 9 9 NUM crl-16614 101 82 28 28 NUM crl-16614 101 83 30–49 30–49 NUM crl-16614 101 84 years year NOUN crl-16614 101 85 old old ADJ crl-16614 101 86 18 18 NUM crl-16614 101 87 21 21 NUM crl-16614 101 88 10–29 10–29 NUM crl-16614 101 89 years year NOUN crl-16614 101 90 old old ADJ crl-16614 101 91 18 18 NUM crl-16614 101 92 49 49 NUM crl-16614 101 93 0–9 0–9 NUM crl-16614 101 94 years year NOUN crl-16614 101 95 old old ADJ crl-16614 101 96 0 0 NUM crl-16614 101 97 0 0 NUM crl-16614 101 98 58 58 NUM crl-16614 101 99 college college PROPN crl-16614 101 100 & & CCONJ crl-16614 101 101 research research PROPN crl-16614 101 102 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 101 103 january january PROPN crl-16614 101 104 2018 2018 NUM crl-16614 101 105 interanalyst interanalyst NOUN crl-16614 101 106 agreement agreement NOUN crl-16614 101 107 statistics statistic VERB crl-16614 101 108 the the DET crl-16614 101 109 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 101 110 calculated calculate VERB crl-16614 101 111 interanalyst interanalyst NOUN crl-16614 101 112 agreement agreement NOUN crl-16614 101 113 statistics statistic NOUN crl-16614 101 114 for for ADP crl-16614 101 115 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 101 116 criterion criterion NOUN crl-16614 101 117 as as ADV crl-16614 101 118 well well ADV crl-16614 101 119 as as ADP crl-16614 101 120 the the DET crl-16614 101 121 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 101 122 areas area NOUN crl-16614 101 123 . . PUNCT crl-16614 102 1 they they PRON crl-16614 102 2 excluded exclude VERB crl-16614 102 3 two two NUM crl-16614 102 4 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 102 5 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 102 6 from from ADP crl-16614 102 7 the the DET crl-16614 102 8 ranking ranking NOUN crl-16614 102 9 because because SCONJ crl-16614 102 10 they they PRON crl-16614 102 11 had have VERB crl-16614 102 12 too too ADV crl-16614 102 13 many many ADJ crl-16614 102 14 missing missing ADJ crl-16614 102 15 cells cell NOUN crl-16614 102 16 to to PART crl-16614 102 17 get get VERB crl-16614 102 18 an an DET crl-16614 102 19 accurate accurate ADJ crl-16614 102 20 agreement agreement NOUN crl-16614 102 21 percentage percentage NOUN crl-16614 102 22 rating rating NOUN crl-16614 102 23 . . PUNCT crl-16614 103 1 these these DET crl-16614 103 2 excluded exclude VERB crl-16614 103 3 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 103 4 were be AUX crl-16614 103 5 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 103 6 the the DET crl-16614 103 7 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 103 8 falsely falsely ADV crl-16614 103 9 claims claim VERB crl-16614 103 10 to to PART crl-16614 103 11 have have VERB crl-16614 103 12 its its PRON crl-16614 103 13 content content NOUN crl-16614 103 14 indexed index VERB crl-16614 103 15 in in ADP crl-16614 103 16 legitimate legitimate ADJ crl-16614 103 17 abstracting abstracting NOUN crl-16614 103 18 and and CCONJ crl-16614 103 19 indexing indexing NOUN crl-16614 103 20 services service NOUN crl-16614 103 21 or or CCONJ crl-16614 103 22 claims claim NOUN crl-16614 103 23 that that SCONJ crl-16614 103 24 its its PRON crl-16614 103 25 content content NOUN crl-16614 103 26 is be AUX crl-16614 103 27 indexed index VERB crl-16614 103 28 in in ADP crl-16614 103 29 resources resource NOUN crl-16614 103 30 that that PRON crl-16614 103 31 are be AUX crl-16614 103 32 not not PART crl-16614 103 33 abstracting abstract VERB crl-16614 103 34 and and CCONJ crl-16614 103 35 indexing indexing NOUN crl-16614 103 36 services service NOUN crl-16614 103 37 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 103 38 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 103 39 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 103 40 area area NOUN crl-16614 103 41 : : PUNCT crl-16614 103 42 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 103 43 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 103 44 and and CCONJ crl-16614 103 45 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 103 46 publish publish VERB crl-16614 103 47 papers paper NOUN crl-16614 103 48 that that PRON crl-16614 103 49 are be AUX crl-16614 103 50 not not PART crl-16614 103 51 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 103 52 at at ADV crl-16614 103 53 all all ADV crl-16614 103 54 , , PUNCT crl-16614 103 55 e.g. e.g. ADV crl-16614 103 56 essays essay NOUN crl-16614 103 57 by by ADP crl-16614 103 58 laypeople laypeople NOUN crl-16614 103 59 , , PUNCT crl-16614 103 60 polemical polemical ADJ crl-16614 103 61 editorials editorial NOUN crl-16614 103 62 , , PUNCT crl-16614 103 63 or or CCONJ crl-16614 103 64 obvious obvious ADJ crl-16614 103 65 pseudo pseudo NOUN crl-16614 103 66 - - NOUN crl-16614 103 67 science science NOUN crl-16614 103 68 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 103 69 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 103 70 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 103 71 area area NOUN crl-16614 103 72 : : PUNCT crl-16614 103 73 other other ADJ crl-16614 103 74 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 103 75 . . PUNCT crl-16614 104 1 all all DET crl-16614 104 2 three three NUM crl-16614 104 3 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 104 4 agreed agree VERB crl-16614 104 5 either either CCONJ crl-16614 104 6 yes yes INTJ crl-16614 104 7 or or CCONJ crl-16614 104 8 no no DET crl-16614 104 9 87.5 87.5 NUM crl-16614 104 10 percent percent NOUN crl-16614 104 11 of of ADP crl-16614 104 12 the the DET crl-16614 104 13 time time NOUN crl-16614 104 14 . . PUNCT crl-16614 105 1 according accord VERB crl-16614 105 2 to to ADP crl-16614 105 3 table table NOUN crl-16614 105 4 6 6 NUM crl-16614 105 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 105 6 the the DET crl-16614 105 7 most most ADV crl-16614 105 8 disagreement disagreement NOUN crl-16614 105 9 occurred occur VERB crl-16614 105 10 in in ADP crl-16614 105 11 the the DET crl-16614 105 12 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 105 13 area area NOUN crl-16614 105 14 of of ADP crl-16614 105 15 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 105 16 and and CCONJ crl-16614 105 17 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 105 18 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 105 19 76 76 NUM crl-16614 105 20 % % NOUN crl-16614 105 21 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 105 22 . . PUNCT crl-16614 106 1 the the DET crl-16614 106 2 highest high ADJ crl-16614 106 3 area area NOUN crl-16614 106 4 of of ADP crl-16614 106 5 agreement agreement NOUN crl-16614 106 6 was be AUX crl-16614 106 7 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 106 8 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 106 9 98 98 NUM crl-16614 106 10 % % NOUN crl-16614 106 11 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 106 12 . . PUNCT crl-16614 107 1 table table NOUN crl-16614 107 2 6 6 NUM crl-16614 107 3 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 107 4 ranked rank VERB crl-16614 107 5 from from ADP crl-16614 107 6 least least ADJ crl-16614 107 7 referee referee NOUN crl-16614 107 8 agreement agreement NOUN crl-16614 107 9 to to ADP crl-16614 107 10 most most ADJ crl-16614 107 11 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 107 12 area area NOUN crl-16614 107 13 % % NOUN crl-16614 107 14 of of ADP crl-16614 107 15 agreement agreement NOUN crl-16614 107 16 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 107 17 and and CCONJ crl-16614 107 18 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 107 19 76 76 NUM crl-16614 107 20 % % NOUN crl-16614 107 21 business business NOUN crl-16614 107 22 management management NOUN crl-16614 107 23 86 86 NUM crl-16614 107 24 % % NOUN crl-16614 107 25 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 107 26 98 98 NUM crl-16614 107 27 % % NOUN crl-16614 107 28 other other ADJ crl-16614 107 29 90 90 NUM crl-16614 107 30 % % NOUN crl-16614 107 31 table table NOUN crl-16614 107 32 5 5 NUM crl-16614 107 33 number number NOUN crl-16614 107 34 of of ADP crl-16614 107 35 failing fail VERB crl-16614 107 36 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 107 37 in in ADP crl-16614 107 38 the the DET crl-16614 107 39 top top ADJ crl-16614 107 40 five five NUM crl-16614 107 41 failed fail VERB crl-16614 107 42 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 107 43 failed fail VERB crl-16614 107 44 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 107 45 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 107 46 area area NOUN crl-16614 107 47 number number NOUN crl-16614 107 48 of of ADP crl-16614 107 49 failing fail VERB crl-16614 107 50 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 107 51 has have VERB crl-16614 107 52 no no DET crl-16614 107 53 policies policy NOUN crl-16614 107 54 or or CCONJ crl-16614 107 55 practices practice NOUN crl-16614 107 56 for for ADP crl-16614 107 57 digital digital ADJ crl-16614 107 58 preservation preservation NOUN crl-16614 107 59 , , PUNCT crl-16614 107 60 meaning mean VERB crl-16614 107 61 that that SCONJ crl-16614 107 62 if if SCONJ crl-16614 107 63 the the DET crl-16614 107 64 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 107 65 ceases cease VERB crl-16614 107 66 operations operation NOUN crl-16614 107 67 , , PUNCT crl-16614 107 68 all all PRON crl-16614 107 69 of of ADP crl-16614 107 70 the the DET crl-16614 107 71 content content NOUN crl-16614 107 72 disappears disappear VERB crl-16614 107 73 from from ADP crl-16614 107 74 the the DET crl-16614 107 75 internet internet NOUN crl-16614 107 76 . . PUNCT crl-16614 108 1 business business NOUN crl-16614 108 2 management management NOUN crl-16614 108 3 22 22 NUM crl-16614 108 4 no no DET crl-16614 108 5 single single ADJ crl-16614 108 6 individual individual NOUN crl-16614 108 7 is be AUX crl-16614 108 8 identified identify VERB crl-16614 108 9 as as ADP crl-16614 108 10 any any DET crl-16614 108 11 specific specific ADJ crl-16614 108 12 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 108 13 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 108 14 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 108 15 . . PUNCT crl-16614 109 1 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 109 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 109 3 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 109 4 17 17 NUM crl-16614 109 5 no no DET crl-16614 109 6 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 109 7 information information NOUN crl-16614 109 8 is be AUX crl-16614 109 9 provided provide VERB crl-16614 109 10 regarding regard VERB crl-16614 109 11 the the DET crl-16614 109 12 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 109 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 109 14 editorial editorial ADJ crl-16614 109 15 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 109 16 , , PUNCT crl-16614 109 17 and/or and/or CCONJ crl-16614 109 18 review review VERB crl-16614 109 19 board board NOUN crl-16614 109 20 members member NOUN crl-16614 109 21 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 109 22 such such ADJ crl-16614 109 23 as as ADP crl-16614 109 24 institutional institutional ADJ crl-16614 109 25 affiliation affiliation NOUN crl-16614 109 26 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 109 27 . . PUNCT crl-16614 110 1 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 110 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 110 3 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 110 4 13 13 NUM crl-16614 110 5 there there PRON crl-16614 110 6 is be VERB crl-16614 110 7 little little ADJ crl-16614 110 8 or or CCONJ crl-16614 110 9 no no PRON crl-16614 110 10 geographical geographical ADJ crl-16614 110 11 diversity diversity NOUN crl-16614 110 12 among among ADP crl-16614 110 13 the the DET crl-16614 110 14 editorial editorial ADJ crl-16614 110 15 board board NOUN crl-16614 110 16 members member NOUN crl-16614 110 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 110 18 especially especially ADV crl-16614 110 19 for for ADP crl-16614 110 20 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 110 21 that that PRON crl-16614 110 22 claim claim VERB crl-16614 110 23 to to PART crl-16614 110 24 be be AUX crl-16614 110 25 international international ADJ crl-16614 110 26 in in ADP crl-16614 110 27 scope scope NOUN crl-16614 110 28 or or CCONJ crl-16614 110 29 coverage coverage NOUN crl-16614 110 30 . . PUNCT crl-16614 111 1 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 111 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 111 3 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 111 4 12 12 NUM crl-16614 111 5 have have VERB crl-16614 111 6 a a DET crl-16614 111 7 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 111 8 contact contact VERB crl-16614 111 9 us we PRON crl-16614 111 10 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 111 11 page page NOUN crl-16614 111 12 that that PRON crl-16614 111 13 only only ADV crl-16614 111 14 includes include VERB crl-16614 111 15 a a DET crl-16614 111 16 web web NOUN crl-16614 111 17 form form NOUN crl-16614 111 18 or or CCONJ crl-16614 111 19 an an DET crl-16614 111 20 e e NOUN crl-16614 111 21 - - NOUN crl-16614 111 22 mail mail NOUN crl-16614 111 23 address address NOUN crl-16614 111 24 , , PUNCT crl-16614 111 25 and and CCONJ crl-16614 111 26 the the DET crl-16614 111 27 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 111 28 hides hide VERB crl-16614 111 29 or or CCONJ crl-16614 111 30 does do AUX crl-16614 111 31 not not PART crl-16614 111 32 reveal reveal VERB crl-16614 111 33 its its PRON crl-16614 111 34 location location NOUN crl-16614 111 35 . . PUNCT crl-16614 112 1 other other ADJ crl-16614 112 2 11 11 NUM crl-16614 112 3 table table NOUN crl-16614 112 4 4 4 NUM crl-16614 112 5 percentage percentage NOUN crl-16614 112 6 of of ADP crl-16614 112 7 total total ADJ crl-16614 112 8 failed fail VERB crl-16614 112 9 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 112 10 by by ADP crl-16614 112 11 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 112 12 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 112 13 area area NOUN crl-16614 112 14 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 112 15 number number NOUN crl-16614 112 16 of of ADP crl-16614 112 17 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 112 18 in in ADP crl-16614 112 19 area area NOUN crl-16614 112 20 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 112 21 % % NOUN crl-16614 112 22 of of ADP crl-16614 112 23 total total ADJ crl-16614 112 24 failed fail VERB crl-16614 112 25 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 112 26 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 112 27 and and CCONJ crl-16614 112 28 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 112 29 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 112 30 9 9 NUM crl-16614 112 31 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 112 32 77.78 77.78 NUM crl-16614 112 33 % % NOUN crl-16614 112 34 business business NOUN crl-16614 112 35 management management NOUN crl-16614 112 36 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 112 37 6 6 NUM crl-16614 112 38 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 112 39 33.34 33.34 NUM crl-16614 112 40 % % NOUN crl-16614 112 41 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 112 42 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 112 43 7 7 NUM crl-16614 112 44 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 112 45 0 0 NUM crl-16614 112 46 % % NOUN crl-16614 112 47 other other ADJ crl-16614 112 48 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 112 49 6 6 NUM crl-16614 112 50 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 112 51 16.67 16.67 NUM crl-16614 112 52 % % NOUN crl-16614 112 53 format format NOUN crl-16614 112 54 aside aside ADV crl-16614 112 55 59 59 NUM crl-16614 112 56 table table NOUN crl-16614 112 57 7 7 NUM crl-16614 112 58 lists list NOUN crl-16614 112 59 the the DET crl-16614 112 60 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 112 61 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 112 62 in in ADP crl-16614 112 63 order order NOUN crl-16614 112 64 of of ADP crl-16614 112 65 percentage percentage NOUN crl-16614 112 66 of of ADP crl-16614 112 67 agreement agreement NOUN crl-16614 112 68 . . PUNCT crl-16614 113 1 the the DET crl-16614 113 2 highest high ADJ crl-16614 113 3 percentage percentage NOUN crl-16614 113 4 of of ADP crl-16614 113 5 disagreement disagreement NOUN crl-16614 113 6 occurred occur VERB crl-16614 113 7 for for ADP crl-16614 113 8 the the DET crl-16614 113 9 criterion criterion NOUN crl-16614 113 10 , , PUNCT crl-16614 113 11 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 113 12 the the DET crl-16614 113 13 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 113 14 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 113 15 owner owner NOUN crl-16614 113 16 is be AUX crl-16614 113 17 identified identify VERB crl-16614 113 18 as as ADP crl-16614 113 19 the the DET crl-16614 113 20 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 113 21 of of ADP crl-16614 113 22 each each DET crl-16614 113 23 and and CCONJ crl-16614 113 24 every every PRON crl-16614 113 25 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 113 26 published publish VERB crl-16614 113 27 by by ADP crl-16614 113 28 the the DET crl-16614 113 29 organization organization NOUN crl-16614 113 30 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 113 31 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 113 32 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 113 33 area area NOUN crl-16614 113 34 : : PUNCT crl-16614 113 35 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 113 36 and and CCONJ crl-16614 113 37 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 113 38 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 113 39 . . PUNCT crl-16614 114 1 table table NOUN crl-16614 114 2 7 7 NUM crl-16614 114 3 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 114 4 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 114 5 in in ADP crl-16614 114 6 order order NOUN crl-16614 114 7 of of ADP crl-16614 114 8 percentage percentage NOUN crl-16614 114 9 of of ADP crl-16614 114 10 agreement agreement NOUN crl-16614 114 11 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 114 12 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 114 13 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 114 14 area area NOUN crl-16614 114 15 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 114 16 agree agree VERB crl-16614 114 17 % % INTJ crl-16614 114 18 the the DET crl-16614 114 19 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 114 20 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 114 21 owner owner NOUN crl-16614 114 22 is be AUX crl-16614 114 23 identified identify VERB crl-16614 114 24 as as ADP crl-16614 114 25 the the DET crl-16614 114 26 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 114 27 of of ADP crl-16614 114 28 each each DET crl-16614 114 29 and and CCONJ crl-16614 114 30 every every PRON crl-16614 114 31 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 114 32 published publish VERB crl-16614 114 33 by by ADP crl-16614 114 34 the the DET crl-16614 114 35 organization organization NOUN crl-16614 114 36 . . PUNCT crl-16614 115 1 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 115 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 115 3 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 115 4 0 0 NUM crl-16614 115 5 have have VERB crl-16614 115 6 a a DET crl-16614 115 7 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 115 8 contact contact VERB crl-16614 115 9 us we PRON crl-16614 115 10 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 115 11 page page NOUN crl-16614 115 12 that that PRON crl-16614 115 13 only only ADV crl-16614 115 14 includes include VERB crl-16614 115 15 a a DET crl-16614 115 16 web web NOUN crl-16614 115 17 form form NOUN crl-16614 115 18 or or CCONJ crl-16614 115 19 an an DET crl-16614 115 20 e e NOUN crl-16614 115 21 - - NOUN crl-16614 115 22 mail mail NOUN crl-16614 115 23 address address NOUN crl-16614 115 24 , , PUNCT crl-16614 115 25 and and CCONJ crl-16614 115 26 the the DET crl-16614 115 27 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 115 28 hides hide VERB crl-16614 115 29 or or CCONJ crl-16614 115 30 does do AUX crl-16614 115 31 not not PART crl-16614 115 32 reveal reveal VERB crl-16614 115 33 its its PRON crl-16614 115 34 location location NOUN crl-16614 115 35 . . PUNCT crl-16614 116 1 other other ADJ crl-16614 116 2 57 57 NUM crl-16614 116 3 has have VERB crl-16614 116 4 no no DET crl-16614 116 5 policies policy NOUN crl-16614 116 6 or or CCONJ crl-16614 116 7 practices practice NOUN crl-16614 116 8 for for ADP crl-16614 116 9 digital digital ADJ crl-16614 116 10 preservation preservation NOUN crl-16614 116 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 116 12 meaning mean VERB crl-16614 116 13 that that SCONJ crl-16614 116 14 if if SCONJ crl-16614 116 15 the the DET crl-16614 116 16 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 116 17 ceases cease VERB crl-16614 116 18 operations operation NOUN crl-16614 116 19 , , PUNCT crl-16614 116 20 all all PRON crl-16614 116 21 of of ADP crl-16614 116 22 the the DET crl-16614 116 23 content content NOUN crl-16614 116 24 disappears disappear VERB crl-16614 116 25 from from ADP crl-16614 116 26 the the DET crl-16614 116 27 internet internet NOUN crl-16614 116 28 . . PUNCT crl-16614 117 1 business business NOUN crl-16614 117 2 management management NOUN crl-16614 117 3 60 60 NUM crl-16614 117 4 there there PRON crl-16614 117 5 is be VERB crl-16614 117 6 little little ADJ crl-16614 117 7 or or CCONJ crl-16614 117 8 no no PRON crl-16614 117 9 geographical geographical ADJ crl-16614 117 10 diversity diversity NOUN crl-16614 117 11 among among ADP crl-16614 117 12 the the DET crl-16614 117 13 editorial editorial ADJ crl-16614 117 14 board board NOUN crl-16614 117 15 members member NOUN crl-16614 117 16 , , PUNCT crl-16614 117 17 especially especially ADV crl-16614 117 18 for for ADP crl-16614 117 19 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 117 20 that that PRON crl-16614 117 21 claim claim VERB crl-16614 117 22 to to PART crl-16614 117 23 be be AUX crl-16614 117 24 international international ADJ crl-16614 117 25 in in ADP crl-16614 117 26 scope scope NOUN crl-16614 117 27 or or CCONJ crl-16614 117 28 coverage coverage NOUN crl-16614 117 29 . . PUNCT crl-16614 118 1 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 118 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 118 3 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 118 4 76 76 NUM crl-16614 118 5 no no DET crl-16614 118 6 single single ADJ crl-16614 118 7 individual individual NOUN crl-16614 118 8 is be AUX crl-16614 118 9 identified identify VERB crl-16614 118 10 as as ADP crl-16614 118 11 any any DET crl-16614 118 12 specific specific ADJ crl-16614 118 13 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 118 14 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 118 15 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 118 16 ; ; PUNCT crl-16614 118 17 no no DET crl-16614 118 18 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 118 19 information information NOUN crl-16614 118 20 is be AUX crl-16614 118 21 provided provide VERB crl-16614 118 22 regarding regard VERB crl-16614 118 23 the the DET crl-16614 118 24 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 118 25 , , PUNCT crl-16614 118 26 editorial editorial ADJ crl-16614 118 27 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 118 28 , , PUNCT crl-16614 118 29 and/or and/or CCONJ crl-16614 118 30 review review VERB crl-16614 118 31 board board NOUN crl-16614 118 32 members member NOUN crl-16614 118 33 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 118 34 such such ADJ crl-16614 118 35 as as ADP crl-16614 118 36 institutional institutional ADJ crl-16614 118 37 affiliation affiliation NOUN crl-16614 118 38 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 118 39 . . PUNCT crl-16614 119 1 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 119 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 119 3 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 119 4 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 119 5 and and CCONJ crl-16614 119 6 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 119 7 81 81 NUM crl-16614 119 8 provides provide VERB crl-16614 119 9 insufficient insufficient ADJ crl-16614 119 10 information information NOUN crl-16614 119 11 or or CCONJ crl-16614 119 12 hides hide VERB crl-16614 119 13 information information NOUN crl-16614 119 14 about about ADP crl-16614 119 15 author author NOUN crl-16614 119 16 fees fee NOUN crl-16614 119 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 119 18 offering offer VERB crl-16614 119 19 to to PART crl-16614 119 20 publish publish VERB crl-16614 119 21 an an DET crl-16614 119 22 author author NOUN crl-16614 119 23 ’s ’s NOUN crl-16614 119 24 paper paper NOUN crl-16614 119 25 and and CCONJ crl-16614 119 26 later later ADV crl-16614 119 27 sending send VERB crl-16614 119 28 an an DET crl-16614 119 29 unanticipated unanticipated ADJ crl-16614 119 30 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 119 31 surprise surprise NOUN crl-16614 119 32 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 119 33 invoice invoice NOUN crl-16614 119 34 . . PUNCT crl-16614 120 1 business business NOUN crl-16614 120 2 management management NOUN crl-16614 120 3 84 84 NUM crl-16614 120 4 the the DET crl-16614 120 5 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 120 6 does do AUX crl-16614 120 7 not not PART crl-16614 120 8 identify identify VERB crl-16614 120 9 a a DET crl-16614 120 10 formal formal ADJ crl-16614 120 11 editorial editorial NOUN crl-16614 120 12 / / SYM crl-16614 120 13 review review NOUN crl-16614 120 14 board board NOUN crl-16614 120 15 . . PUNCT crl-16614 121 1 demonstrates demonstrate VERB crl-16614 121 2 a a DET crl-16614 121 3 lack lack NOUN crl-16614 121 4 of of ADP crl-16614 121 5 transparency transparency NOUN crl-16614 121 6 in in ADP crl-16614 121 7 publishing publish VERB crl-16614 121 8 operations operation NOUN crl-16614 121 9 . . PUNCT crl-16614 122 1 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 122 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 122 3 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 122 4 business business NOUN crl-16614 122 5 management management NOUN crl-16614 122 6 86 86 NUM crl-16614 122 7 evidence evidence NOUN crl-16614 122 8 exists exist VERB crl-16614 122 9 showing show VERB crl-16614 122 10 that that SCONJ crl-16614 122 11 the the DET crl-16614 122 12 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 122 13 and/or and/or CCONJ crl-16614 122 14 review review VERB crl-16614 122 15 board board NOUN crl-16614 122 16 members member NOUN crl-16614 122 17 do do AUX crl-16614 122 18 not not PART crl-16614 122 19 possess possess VERB crl-16614 122 20 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 122 21 expertise expertise NOUN crl-16614 122 22 to to PART crl-16614 122 23 reasonably reasonably ADV crl-16614 122 24 qualify qualify VERB crl-16614 122 25 them they PRON crl-16614 122 26 to to PART crl-16614 122 27 be be AUX crl-16614 122 28 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 122 29 gatekeepers gatekeeper NOUN crl-16614 122 30 in in ADP crl-16614 122 31 the the DET crl-16614 122 32 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 122 33 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 122 34 field field NOUN crl-16614 122 35 . . PUNCT crl-16614 123 1 the the DET crl-16614 123 2 editorial editorial ADJ crl-16614 123 3 board board NOUN crl-16614 123 4 engages engage VERB crl-16614 123 5 in in ADP crl-16614 123 6 gender gender NOUN crl-16614 123 7 bias bias NOUN crl-16614 123 8 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 123 9 i.e. i.e. X crl-16614 123 10 , , PUNCT crl-16614 123 11 exclusion exclusion NOUN crl-16614 123 12 of of ADP crl-16614 123 13 any any DET crl-16614 123 14 female female ADJ crl-16614 123 15 members member NOUN crl-16614 123 16 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 123 17 . . PUNCT crl-16614 124 1 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 124 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 124 3 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 124 4 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 124 5 and and CCONJ crl-16614 124 6 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 124 7 88 88 NUM crl-16614 124 8 the the DET crl-16614 124 9 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 124 10 have have VERB crl-16614 124 11 an an DET crl-16614 124 12 insufficient insufficient ADJ crl-16614 124 13 number number NOUN crl-16614 124 14 of of ADP crl-16614 124 15 board board NOUN crl-16614 124 16 members,(e.g members,(e.g NOUN crl-16614 124 17 . . PROPN crl-16614 124 18 , , PUNCT crl-16614 124 19 2 2 NUM crl-16614 124 20 or or CCONJ crl-16614 124 21 3 3 NUM crl-16614 124 22 members),have members),have VERB crl-16614 124 23 concocted concoct VERB crl-16614 124 24 editorial editorial ADJ crl-16614 124 25 boards board NOUN crl-16614 124 26 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 124 27 made make VERB crl-16614 124 28 up up ADP crl-16614 124 29 names name NOUN crl-16614 124 30 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 124 31 , , PUNCT crl-16614 124 32 name name NOUN crl-16614 124 33 scholars scholar NOUN crl-16614 124 34 on on ADP crl-16614 124 35 their their PRON crl-16614 124 36 editorial editorial ADJ crl-16614 124 37 board board NOUN crl-16614 124 38 without without ADP crl-16614 124 39 their their PRON crl-16614 124 40 knowledge knowledge NOUN crl-16614 124 41 or or CCONJ crl-16614 124 42 permission permission NOUN crl-16614 124 43 or or CCONJ crl-16614 124 44 have have VERB crl-16614 124 45 board board NOUN crl-16614 124 46 members member NOUN crl-16614 124 47 who who PRON crl-16614 124 48 are be AUX crl-16614 124 49 prominent prominent ADJ crl-16614 124 50 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 124 51 but but CCONJ crl-16614 124 52 exempt exempt VERB crl-16614 124 53 them they PRON crl-16614 124 54 from from ADP crl-16614 124 55 any any DET crl-16614 124 56 contributions contribution NOUN crl-16614 124 57 to to ADP crl-16614 124 58 the the DET crl-16614 124 59 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 124 60 except except SCONJ crl-16614 124 61 the the DET crl-16614 124 62 use use NOUN crl-16614 124 63 of of ADP crl-16614 124 64 their their PRON crl-16614 124 65 names name NOUN crl-16614 124 66 and/ and/ PROPN crl-16614 124 67 or or CCONJ crl-16614 124 68 photographs photograph NOUN crl-16614 124 69 . . PUNCT crl-16614 125 1 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 125 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 125 3 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 125 4 87 87 NUM crl-16614 125 5 does do AUX crl-16614 125 6 not not PART crl-16614 125 7 allow allow VERB crl-16614 125 8 search search NOUN crl-16614 125 9 engines engine NOUN crl-16614 125 10 to to PART crl-16614 125 11 crawl crawl VERB crl-16614 125 12 the the DET crl-16614 125 13 published publish VERB crl-16614 125 14 content content NOUN crl-16614 125 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 125 16 preventing prevent VERB crl-16614 125 17 the the DET crl-16614 125 18 content content NOUN crl-16614 125 19 from from ADP crl-16614 125 20 being be AUX crl-16614 125 21 indexed index VERB crl-16614 125 22 in in ADP crl-16614 125 23 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 125 24 indexes index NOUN crl-16614 125 25 . . PUNCT crl-16614 126 1 business business NOUN crl-16614 126 2 management management NOUN crl-16614 126 3 92 92 NUM crl-16614 126 4 60 60 NUM crl-16614 126 5 college college NOUN crl-16614 126 6 & & CCONJ crl-16614 126 7 research research PROPN crl-16614 126 8 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 126 9 january january PROPN crl-16614 126 10 2018 2018 NUM crl-16614 126 11 table table NOUN crl-16614 126 12 7 7 NUM crl-16614 126 13 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 126 14 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 126 15 in in ADP crl-16614 126 16 order order NOUN crl-16614 126 17 of of ADP crl-16614 126 18 percentage percentage NOUN crl-16614 126 19 of of ADP crl-16614 126 20 agreement agreement NOUN crl-16614 126 21 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 126 22 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 126 23 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 126 24 area area NOUN crl-16614 126 25 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 126 26 agree agree VERB crl-16614 126 27 % % NOUN crl-16614 126 28 two two NUM crl-16614 126 29 or or CCONJ crl-16614 126 30 more more ADJ crl-16614 126 31 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 126 32 have have VERB crl-16614 126 33 duplicate duplicate ADJ crl-16614 126 34 editorial editorial ADJ crl-16614 126 35 boards board NOUN crl-16614 126 36 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 126 37 i.e. i.e. X crl-16614 126 38 , , PUNCT crl-16614 126 39 same same ADJ crl-16614 126 40 editorial editorial ADJ crl-16614 126 41 board board NOUN crl-16614 126 42 for for ADP crl-16614 126 43 more more ADJ crl-16614 126 44 than than ADP crl-16614 126 45 one one NUM crl-16614 126 46 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 126 47 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 126 48 . . PUNCT crl-16614 127 1 provides provide VERB crl-16614 127 2 insufficient insufficient ADJ crl-16614 127 3 information information NOUN crl-16614 127 4 or or CCONJ crl-16614 127 5 hides hide VERB crl-16614 127 6 information information NOUN crl-16614 127 7 about about ADP crl-16614 127 8 author author NOUN crl-16614 127 9 fees fee NOUN crl-16614 127 10 , , PUNCT crl-16614 127 11 offering offer VERB crl-16614 127 12 to to PART crl-16614 127 13 publish publish VERB crl-16614 127 14 an an DET crl-16614 127 15 author author NOUN crl-16614 127 16 ’s ’s NOUN crl-16614 127 17 paper paper NOUN crl-16614 127 18 and and CCONJ crl-16614 127 19 later later ADV crl-16614 127 20 sending send VERB crl-16614 127 21 an an DET crl-16614 127 22 unanticipated unanticipated ADJ crl-16614 127 23 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 127 24 surprise surprise NOUN crl-16614 127 25 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 127 26 invoice invoice NOUN crl-16614 127 27 . . PUNCT crl-16614 128 1 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 128 2 and and CCONJ crl-16614 128 3 staff staff NOUN crl-16614 128 4 business business NOUN crl-16614 128 5 management management NOUN crl-16614 128 6 94 94 NUM crl-16614 128 7 the the DET crl-16614 128 8 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 128 9 asks ask VERB crl-16614 128 10 the the DET crl-16614 128 11 corresponding correspond VERB crl-16614 128 12 author author NOUN crl-16614 128 13 for for ADP crl-16614 128 14 suggested suggested ADJ crl-16614 128 15 reviewers reviewer NOUN crl-16614 128 16 and and CCONJ crl-16614 128 17 the the DET crl-16614 128 18 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 128 19 subsequently subsequently ADV crl-16614 128 20 uses use VERB crl-16614 128 21 the the DET crl-16614 128 22 suggested suggest VERB crl-16614 128 23 reviewers reviewer NOUN crl-16614 128 24 without without ADP crl-16614 128 25 sufficiently sufficiently ADV crl-16614 128 26 vetting vet VERB crl-16614 128 27 their their PRON crl-16614 128 28 qualifications qualification NOUN crl-16614 128 29 or or CCONJ crl-16614 128 30 authenticity authenticity NOUN crl-16614 128 31 . . PUNCT crl-16614 129 1 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 129 2 this this DET crl-16614 129 3 protocol protocol NOUN crl-16614 129 4 also also ADV crl-16614 129 5 may may AUX crl-16614 129 6 allow allow VERB crl-16614 129 7 authors author NOUN crl-16614 129 8 to to PART crl-16614 129 9 create create VERB crl-16614 129 10 faux faux ADJ crl-16614 129 11 online online ADJ crl-16614 129 12 identities identity NOUN crl-16614 129 13 to to PART crl-16614 129 14 review review VERB crl-16614 129 15 their their PRON crl-16614 129 16 own own ADJ crl-16614 129 17 papers paper NOUN crl-16614 129 18 . . PUNCT crl-16614 129 19 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 130 1 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 130 2 95 95 NUM crl-16614 131 1 the the DET crl-16614 131 2 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 131 3 dedicates dedicate VERB crl-16614 131 4 insufficient insufficient ADJ crl-16614 131 5 resources resource NOUN crl-16614 131 6 to to ADP crl-16614 131 7 preventing prevent VERB crl-16614 131 8 and and CCONJ crl-16614 131 9 eliminating eliminate VERB crl-16614 131 10 author author NOUN crl-16614 131 11 misconduct misconduct NOUN crl-16614 131 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 131 13 to to ADP crl-16614 131 14 the the DET crl-16614 131 15 extent extent NOUN crl-16614 131 16 that that SCONJ crl-16614 131 17 the the DET crl-16614 131 18 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 131 19 or or CCONJ crl-16614 131 20 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 131 21 suffer suffer VERB crl-16614 131 22 from from ADP crl-16614 131 23 repeated repeat VERB crl-16614 131 24 cases case NOUN crl-16614 131 25 of of ADP crl-16614 131 26 plagiarism plagiarism NOUN crl-16614 131 27 , , PUNCT crl-16614 131 28 self self NOUN crl-16614 131 29 - - PUNCT crl-16614 131 30 plagiarism plagiarism NOUN crl-16614 131 31 , , PUNCT crl-16614 131 32 image image NOUN crl-16614 131 33 manipulation manipulation NOUN crl-16614 131 34 , , PUNCT crl-16614 131 35 and and CCONJ crl-16614 131 36 the the DET crl-16614 131 37 like like ADJ crl-16614 131 38 . . PUNCT crl-16614 132 1 use use VERB crl-16614 132 2 boastful boastful ADJ crl-16614 132 3 language language NOUN crl-16614 132 4 claiming claim VERB crl-16614 132 5 to to PART crl-16614 132 6 be be AUX crl-16614 132 7 a a DET crl-16614 132 8 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 132 9 leading lead VERB crl-16614 132 10 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 132 11 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 132 12 even even ADV crl-16614 132 13 though though SCONJ crl-16614 132 14 the the DET crl-16614 132 15 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 132 16 may may AUX crl-16614 132 17 only only ADV crl-16614 132 18 be be AUX crl-16614 132 19 a a DET crl-16614 132 20 startup startup NOUN crl-16614 132 21 or or CCONJ crl-16614 132 22 a a DET crl-16614 132 23 novice novice NOUN crl-16614 132 24 organization organization NOUN crl-16614 132 25 . . PUNCT crl-16614 133 1 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 133 2 other other ADJ crl-16614 133 3 97 97 NUM crl-16614 133 4 begins begin VERB crl-16614 133 5 operations operation NOUN crl-16614 133 6 with with ADP crl-16614 133 7 a a DET crl-16614 133 8 large large ADJ crl-16614 133 9 fleet fleet NOUN crl-16614 133 10 of of ADP crl-16614 133 11 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 133 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 133 13 often often ADV crl-16614 133 14 using use VERB crl-16614 133 15 a a DET crl-16614 133 16 common common ADJ crl-16614 133 17 template template NOUN crl-16614 133 18 to to PART crl-16614 133 19 quickly quickly ADV crl-16614 133 20 create create VERB crl-16614 133 21 each each DET crl-16614 133 22 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 133 23 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 133 24 homepage homepage NOUN crl-16614 133 25 . . PUNCT crl-16614 134 1 the the DET crl-16614 134 2 name name NOUN crl-16614 134 3 of of ADP crl-16614 134 4 a a DET crl-16614 134 5 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 134 6 is be AUX crl-16614 134 7 incongruent incongruent ADJ crl-16614 134 8 with with ADP crl-16614 134 9 the the DET crl-16614 134 10 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 134 11 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 134 12 mission mission NOUN crl-16614 134 13 the the DET crl-16614 134 14 name name NOUN crl-16614 134 15 of of ADP crl-16614 134 16 a a DET crl-16614 134 17 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 134 18 does do AUX crl-16614 134 19 not not PART crl-16614 134 20 adequately adequately ADV crl-16614 134 21 reflect reflect VERB crl-16614 134 22 its its PRON crl-16614 134 23 origin origin NOUN crl-16614 134 24 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 134 25 such such ADJ crl-16614 134 26 as as ADP crl-16614 134 27 a a DET crl-16614 134 28 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 134 29 with with ADP crl-16614 134 30 the the DET crl-16614 134 31 word word NOUN crl-16614 134 32 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 134 33 canadian canadian ADJ crl-16614 134 34 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 134 35 or or CCONJ crl-16614 134 36 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 134 37 swiss swiss ADJ crl-16614 134 38 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 134 39 in in ADP crl-16614 134 40 its its PRON crl-16614 134 41 name name NOUN crl-16614 134 42 when when SCONJ crl-16614 134 43 neither neither CCONJ crl-16614 134 44 the the DET crl-16614 134 45 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 134 46 , , PUNCT crl-16614 134 47 editor editor NOUN crl-16614 134 48 , , PUNCT crl-16614 134 49 nor nor CCONJ crl-16614 134 50 any any DET crl-16614 134 51 purported purport VERB crl-16614 134 52 institutional institutional ADJ crl-16614 134 53 affiliate affiliate NOUN crl-16614 134 54 relates relate VERB crl-16614 134 55 whatsoever whatsoever ADV crl-16614 134 56 to to ADP crl-16614 134 57 canada canada PROPN crl-16614 134 58 or or CCONJ crl-16614 134 59 switzerland switzerland PROPN crl-16614 134 60 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 134 61 . . PUNCT crl-16614 135 1 in in ADP crl-16614 135 2 its its PRON crl-16614 135 3 spam spam NOUN crl-16614 135 4 e e NOUN crl-16614 135 5 - - NOUN crl-16614 135 6 mail mail NOUN crl-16614 135 7 or or CCONJ crl-16614 135 8 on on ADP crl-16614 135 9 its its PRON crl-16614 135 10 website website NOUN crl-16614 135 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 135 12 the the DET crl-16614 135 13 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 135 14 falsely falsely ADV crl-16614 135 15 claims claim VERB crl-16614 135 16 one one NUM crl-16614 135 17 or or CCONJ crl-16614 135 18 more more ADJ crl-16614 135 19 of of ADP crl-16614 135 20 its its PRON crl-16614 135 21 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 135 22 have have VERB crl-16614 135 23 actual actual ADJ crl-16614 135 24 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 135 25 thomson thomson NOUN crl-16614 135 26 - - PUNCT crl-16614 135 27 reuters reuters NOUN crl-16614 135 28 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 135 29 impact impact NOUN crl-16614 135 30 factors factor NOUN crl-16614 135 31 , , PUNCT crl-16614 135 32 or or CCONJ crl-16614 135 33 advertises advertise VERB crl-16614 135 34 impact impact NOUN crl-16614 135 35 factors factor NOUN crl-16614 135 36 assigned assign VERB crl-16614 135 37 by by ADP crl-16614 135 38 fake fake ADJ crl-16614 135 39 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 135 40 impact impact NOUN crl-16614 135 41 factor factor NOUN crl-16614 135 42 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 135 43 services service NOUN crl-16614 135 44 , , PUNCT crl-16614 135 45 or or CCONJ crl-16614 135 46 it it PRON crl-16614 135 47 uses use VERB crl-16614 135 48 some some DET crl-16614 135 49 made make VERB crl-16614 135 50 - - PUNCT crl-16614 135 51 up up ADP crl-16614 135 52 measure measure NOUN crl-16614 135 53 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 135 54 such such ADJ crl-16614 135 55 as as ADP crl-16614 135 56 view view NOUN crl-16614 135 57 factor factor NOUN crl-16614 135 58 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 135 59 , , PUNCT crl-16614 135 60 feigning feign VERB crl-16614 135 61 / / SYM crl-16614 135 62 claiming claim VERB crl-16614 135 63 an an DET crl-16614 135 64 exaggerated exaggerated ADJ crl-16614 135 65 international international ADJ crl-16614 135 66 standing standing NOUN crl-16614 135 67 . . PUNCT crl-16614 136 1 republish republish ADJ crl-16614 136 2 papers paper NOUN crl-16614 136 3 already already ADV crl-16614 136 4 published publish VERB crl-16614 136 5 in in ADP crl-16614 136 6 other other ADJ crl-16614 136 7 venues venue NOUN crl-16614 136 8 / / SYM crl-16614 136 9 outlets outlet NOUN crl-16614 136 10 without without ADP crl-16614 136 11 providing provide VERB crl-16614 136 12 appropriate appropriate ADJ crl-16614 136 13 credits credit NOUN crl-16614 136 14 operate operate VERB crl-16614 136 15 in in ADP crl-16614 136 16 a a DET crl-16614 136 17 western western ADJ crl-16614 136 18 country country NOUN crl-16614 136 19 chiefly chiefly ADV crl-16614 136 20 for for ADP crl-16614 136 21 the the DET crl-16614 136 22 purpose purpose NOUN crl-16614 136 23 of of ADP crl-16614 136 24 functioning function VERB crl-16614 136 25 as as ADP crl-16614 136 26 a a DET crl-16614 136 27 vanity vanity NOUN crl-16614 136 28 press press NOUN crl-16614 136 29 for for ADP crl-16614 136 30 scholars scholar NOUN crl-16614 136 31 in in ADP crl-16614 136 32 a a DET crl-16614 136 33 developing develop VERB crl-16614 136 34 country country NOUN crl-16614 136 35 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 136 36 such such ADJ crl-16614 136 37 as as ADP crl-16614 136 38 using use VERB crl-16614 136 39 a a DET crl-16614 136 40 mail mail NOUN crl-16614 136 41 - - PUNCT crl-16614 136 42 drop drop NOUN crl-16614 136 43 address address NOUN crl-16614 136 44 or or CCONJ crl-16614 136 45 p.o p.o PROPN crl-16614 136 46 . . PROPN crl-16614 136 47 box box PROPN crl-16614 136 48 address address NOUN crl-16614 136 49 in in ADP crl-16614 136 50 the the DET crl-16614 136 51 united united PROPN crl-16614 136 52 states states PROPN crl-16614 136 53 , , PUNCT crl-16614 136 54 while while SCONJ crl-16614 136 55 actually actually ADV crl-16614 136 56 operating operate VERB crl-16614 136 57 from from ADP crl-16614 136 58 a a DET crl-16614 136 59 developing develop VERB crl-16614 136 60 country country NOUN crl-16614 136 61 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 136 62 . . PUNCT crl-16614 137 1 provide provide VERB crl-16614 137 2 minimal minimal ADJ crl-16614 137 3 or or CCONJ crl-16614 137 4 no no DET crl-16614 137 5 copyediting copyediting NOUN crl-16614 137 6 or or CCONJ crl-16614 137 7 proofreading proofreading NOUN crl-16614 137 8 of of ADP crl-16614 137 9 submissions submission NOUN crl-16614 137 10 . . PUNCT crl-16614 138 1 business business NOUN crl-16614 138 2 management management NOUN crl-16614 138 3 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 138 4 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 138 5 integrity integrity NOUN crl-16614 138 6 other other ADJ crl-16614 138 7 other other ADJ crl-16614 138 8 other other ADJ crl-16614 138 9 99 99 NUM crl-16614 138 10 format format NOUN crl-16614 138 11 aside aside ADV crl-16614 138 12 61 61 NUM crl-16614 138 13 discussion discussion NOUN crl-16614 138 14 what what PRON crl-16614 138 15 do do AUX crl-16614 138 16 the the DET crl-16614 138 17 data datum NOUN crl-16614 138 18 tell tell VERB crl-16614 138 19 us we PRON crl-16614 138 20 about about ADP crl-16614 138 21 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 138 22 ’s ’s NOUN crl-16614 138 23 list list NOUN crl-16614 138 24 as as ADP crl-16614 138 25 a a DET crl-16614 138 26 tool tool NOUN crl-16614 138 27 for for ADP crl-16614 138 28 evaluating evaluate VERB crl-16614 138 29 both both PRON crl-16614 138 30 oa oa ADJ crl-16614 138 31 and and CCONJ crl-16614 138 32 traditional traditional ADJ crl-16614 138 33 model model ADJ crl-16614 138 34 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 138 35 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 138 36 ? ? PUNCT crl-16614 139 1 first first ADV crl-16614 139 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 139 3 might might AUX crl-16614 139 4 evaluators evaluator NOUN crl-16614 139 5 consider consider VERB crl-16614 139 6 these these DET crl-16614 139 7 established establish VERB crl-16614 139 8 , , PUNCT crl-16614 139 9 well well ADV crl-16614 139 10 - - PUNCT crl-16614 139 11 regarded regard VERB crl-16614 139 12 lis lis ADJ crl-16614 139 13 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 139 14 as as ADP crl-16614 139 15 possible possible ADJ crl-16614 139 16 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 139 17 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 139 18 ? ? PUNCT crl-16614 140 1 according accord VERB crl-16614 140 2 to to ADP crl-16614 140 3 the the DET crl-16614 140 4 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 140 5 ’ ’ PART crl-16614 140 6 application application NOUN crl-16614 140 7 of of ADP crl-16614 140 8 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 140 9 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 140 10 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 140 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 140 12 yes yes INTJ crl-16614 140 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 140 14 even even ADV crl-16614 140 15 traditional traditional ADJ crl-16614 140 16 model model NOUN crl-16614 140 17 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 140 18 might might AUX crl-16614 140 19 classify classify VERB crl-16614 140 20 as as ADP crl-16614 140 21 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 140 22 . . PUNCT crl-16614 141 1 again again ADV crl-16614 141 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 141 3 the the DET crl-16614 141 4 panel panel NOUN crl-16614 141 5 was be AUX crl-16614 141 6 not not PART crl-16614 141 7 applying apply VERB crl-16614 141 8 the the DET crl-16614 141 9 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 141 10 to to PART crl-16614 141 11 identify identify VERB crl-16614 141 12 lis lis ADJ crl-16614 141 13 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 141 14 from from ADP crl-16614 141 15 the the DET crl-16614 141 16 jcr jcr PROPN crl-16614 141 17 collection collection PROPN crl-16614 141 18 as as ADP crl-16614 141 19 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 141 20 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 141 21 and and CCONJ crl-16614 141 22 to to PART crl-16614 141 23 avoid avoid VERB crl-16614 141 24 any any DET crl-16614 141 25 misreading misreading NOUN crl-16614 141 26 of of ADP crl-16614 141 27 method method NOUN crl-16614 141 28 , , PUNCT crl-16614 141 29 this this DET crl-16614 141 30 research research NOUN crl-16614 141 31 report report NOUN crl-16614 141 32 does do AUX crl-16614 141 33 not not PART crl-16614 141 34 directly directly ADV crl-16614 141 35 identify identify VERB crl-16614 141 36 by by ADP crl-16614 141 37 name name NOUN crl-16614 141 38 individual individual ADJ crl-16614 141 39 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 141 40 with with ADP crl-16614 141 41 how how SCONJ crl-16614 141 42 they they PRON crl-16614 141 43 fared fare VERB crl-16614 141 44 against against ADP crl-16614 141 45 any any PRON crl-16614 141 46 of of ADP crl-16614 141 47 the the DET crl-16614 141 48 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 141 49 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 141 50 . . PUNCT crl-16614 142 1 the the DET crl-16614 142 2 primary primary ADJ crl-16614 142 3 motivation motivation NOUN crl-16614 142 4 of of ADP crl-16614 142 5 the the DET crl-16614 142 6 exercise exercise NOUN crl-16614 142 7 was be AUX crl-16614 142 8 to to PART crl-16614 142 9 determine determine VERB crl-16614 142 10 the the DET crl-16614 142 11 validity validity NOUN crl-16614 142 12 of of ADP crl-16614 142 13 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 142 14 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 142 15 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 142 16 and and CCONJ crl-16614 142 17 whether whether SCONJ crl-16614 142 18 these these DET crl-16614 142 19 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 142 20 , , PUNCT crl-16614 142 21 which which PRON crl-16614 142 22 are be AUX crl-16614 142 23 arguably arguably ADV crl-16614 142 24 considered consider VERB crl-16614 142 25 high high ADJ crl-16614 142 26 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 142 27 and and CCONJ crl-16614 142 28 high high ADJ crl-16614 142 29 impact impact NOUN crl-16614 142 30 , , PUNCT crl-16614 142 31 would would AUX crl-16614 142 32 fail fail VERB crl-16614 142 33 some some DET crl-16614 142 34 elements element NOUN crl-16614 142 35 of of ADP crl-16614 142 36 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 142 37 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 142 38 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 142 39 . . PUNCT crl-16614 143 1 consequently consequently ADV crl-16614 143 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 143 3 the the DET crl-16614 143 4 present present ADJ crl-16614 143 5 authors author NOUN crl-16614 143 6 question question VERB crl-16614 143 7 if if SCONJ crl-16614 143 8 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 143 9 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 143 10 list list NOUN crl-16614 143 11 suggests suggest VERB crl-16614 143 12 a a DET crl-16614 143 13 possible possible ADJ crl-16614 143 14 bias bias NOUN crl-16614 143 15 against against ADP crl-16614 143 16 oa oa ADP crl-16614 143 17 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 143 18 and and CCONJ crl-16614 143 19 favors favor VERB crl-16614 143 20 traditional traditional ADJ crl-16614 143 21 model model NOUN crl-16614 143 22 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 143 23 in in ADP crl-16614 143 24 a a DET crl-16614 143 25 way way NOUN crl-16614 143 26 that that PRON crl-16614 143 27 is be AUX crl-16614 143 28 not not PART crl-16614 143 29 defensible defensible ADJ crl-16614 143 30 , , PUNCT crl-16614 143 31 which which PRON crl-16614 143 32 previous previous ADJ crl-16614 143 33 research research NOUN crl-16614 143 34 has have AUX crl-16614 143 35 also also ADV crl-16614 143 36 addressed.32 addressed.32 X crl-16614 143 37 as as ADP crl-16614 143 38 a a DET crl-16614 143 39 result result NOUN crl-16614 143 40 , , PUNCT crl-16614 143 41 the the DET crl-16614 143 42 authors author NOUN crl-16614 143 43 find find VERB crl-16614 143 44 it it PRON crl-16614 143 45 necessary necessary ADJ crl-16614 143 46 to to PART crl-16614 143 47 consider consider VERB crl-16614 143 48 why why SCONJ crl-16614 143 49 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 143 50 ’s ’ NOUN crl-16614 143 51 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 143 52 aims aim VERB crl-16614 143 53 predominantly predominantly ADV crl-16614 143 54 at at ADP crl-16614 143 55 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 143 56 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 143 57 when when SCONJ crl-16614 143 58 established establish VERB crl-16614 143 59 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 143 60 based base VERB crl-16614 143 61 on on ADP crl-16614 143 62 traditional traditional ADJ crl-16614 143 63 models model NOUN crl-16614 143 64 can can AUX crl-16614 143 65 fail fail VERB crl-16614 143 66 at at ADP crl-16614 143 67 a a DET crl-16614 143 68 high high ADJ crl-16614 143 69 rate rate NOUN crl-16614 143 70 . . PUNCT crl-16614 144 1 future future ADJ crl-16614 144 2 research research NOUN crl-16614 144 3 might might AUX crl-16614 144 4 analyze analyze VERB crl-16614 144 5 a a DET crl-16614 144 6 list list NOUN crl-16614 144 7 of of ADP crl-16614 144 8 oa oa PROPN crl-16614 144 9 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 144 10 generally generally ADV crl-16614 144 11 considered consider VERB crl-16614 144 12 to to PART crl-16614 144 13 be be AUX crl-16614 144 14 of of ADP crl-16614 144 15 high high ADJ crl-16614 144 16 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 144 17 to to PART crl-16614 144 18 compare compare VERB crl-16614 144 19 traditional traditional ADJ crl-16614 144 20 and and CCONJ crl-16614 144 21 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 144 22 models model NOUN crl-16614 144 23 according accord VERB crl-16614 144 24 to to ADP crl-16614 144 25 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 144 26 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 144 27 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 144 28 . . PUNCT crl-16614 145 1 second second ADV crl-16614 145 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 145 3 although although SCONJ crl-16614 145 4 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 145 5 acknowledges acknowledge VERB crl-16614 145 6 the the DET crl-16614 145 7 subjectivity subjectivity NOUN crl-16614 145 8 of of ADP crl-16614 145 9 his his PRON crl-16614 145 10 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 145 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 145 12 going go VERB crl-16614 145 13 as as ADV crl-16614 145 14 far far ADV crl-16614 145 15 as as SCONJ crl-16614 145 16 to to PART crl-16614 145 17 state state NOUN crl-16614 145 18 that that SCONJ crl-16614 145 19 his his PRON crl-16614 145 20 lists list NOUN crl-16614 145 21 consist consist VERB crl-16614 145 22 solely solely ADV crl-16614 145 23 of of ADP crl-16614 145 24 his his PRON crl-16614 145 25 opinion,33 opinion,33 NOUN crl-16614 145 26 this this DET crl-16614 145 27 study study NOUN crl-16614 145 28 affirms affirm VERB crl-16614 145 29 this this DET crl-16614 145 30 subjectiveness subjectiveness NOUN crl-16614 145 31 and and CCONJ crl-16614 145 32 raises raise VERB crl-16614 145 33 questions question NOUN crl-16614 145 34 concerning concern VERB crl-16614 145 35 their their PRON crl-16614 145 36 application application NOUN crl-16614 145 37 to to ADP crl-16614 145 38 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 145 39 and and CCONJ crl-16614 145 40 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 145 41 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-16614 145 42 . . PUNCT crl-16614 146 1 due due ADP crl-16614 146 2 to to ADP crl-16614 146 3 the the DET crl-16614 146 4 rate rate NOUN crl-16614 146 5 of of ADP crl-16614 146 6 disagreement disagreement NOUN crl-16614 146 7 , , PUNCT crl-16614 146 8 the the DET crl-16614 146 9 use use NOUN crl-16614 146 10 of of ADP crl-16614 146 11 a a DET crl-16614 146 12 three three NUM crl-16614 146 13 - - PUNCT crl-16614 146 14 person person NOUN crl-16614 146 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 146 16 independently independently ADV crl-16614 146 17 working work VERB crl-16614 146 18 panel panel NOUN crl-16614 146 19 of of ADP crl-16614 146 20 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 146 21 highlights highlight VERB crl-16614 146 22 the the DET crl-16614 146 23 subjectiveness subjectiveness NOUN crl-16614 146 24 of of ADP crl-16614 146 25 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 146 26 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 146 27 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 146 28 . . PUNCT crl-16614 147 1 this this PRON crl-16614 147 2 calls call VERB crl-16614 147 3 into into ADP crl-16614 147 4 question question NOUN crl-16614 147 5 its its PRON crl-16614 147 6 indiscriminate indiscriminate ADJ crl-16614 147 7 use use NOUN crl-16614 147 8 by by ADP crl-16614 147 9 librarians librarian NOUN crl-16614 147 10 who who PRON crl-16614 147 11 provide provide VERB crl-16614 147 12 the the DET crl-16614 147 13 list list NOUN crl-16614 147 14 to to ADP crl-16614 147 15 students student NOUN crl-16614 147 16 and and CCONJ crl-16614 147 17 faculty faculty NOUN crl-16614 147 18 as as ADP crl-16614 147 19 a a DET crl-16614 147 20 resource resource NOUN crl-16614 147 21 without without ADP crl-16614 147 22 explaining explain VERB crl-16614 147 23 the the DET crl-16614 147 24 limitations limitation NOUN crl-16614 147 25 of of ADP crl-16614 147 26 the the DET crl-16614 147 27 list list NOUN crl-16614 147 28 and and CCONJ crl-16614 147 29 of of ADP crl-16614 147 30 the the DET crl-16614 147 31 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 147 32 . . PUNCT crl-16614 148 1 this this PRON crl-16614 148 2 is be AUX crl-16614 148 3 especially especially ADV crl-16614 148 4 important important ADJ crl-16614 148 5 regarding regard VERB crl-16614 148 6 promotion promotion NOUN crl-16614 148 7 and and CCONJ crl-16614 148 8 tenure tenure NOUN crl-16614 148 9 committees committee NOUN crl-16614 148 10 across across ADP crl-16614 148 11 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 148 12 institutions institution NOUN crl-16614 148 13 who who PRON crl-16614 148 14 may may AUX crl-16614 148 15 use use VERB crl-16614 148 16 beall beall NOUN crl-16614 148 17 ’s ’s NOUN crl-16614 148 18 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 148 19 as as ADP crl-16614 148 20 a a DET crl-16614 148 21 way way NOUN crl-16614 148 22 to to PART crl-16614 148 23 disqualify disqualify VERB crl-16614 148 24 articles article NOUN crl-16614 148 25 published publish VERB crl-16614 148 26 in in ADP crl-16614 148 27 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 148 28 that that SCONJ crl-16614 148 29 the the DET crl-16614 148 30 committee committee NOUN crl-16614 148 31 determined determine VERB crl-16614 148 32 fail fail VERB crl-16614 148 33 some some DET crl-16614 148 34 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 148 35 but but CCONJ crl-16614 148 36 are be AUX crl-16614 148 37 not not PART crl-16614 148 38 truly truly ADV crl-16614 148 39 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 148 40 . . PUNCT crl-16614 149 1 evaluators evaluator NOUN crl-16614 149 2 should should AUX crl-16614 149 3 consider consider VERB crl-16614 149 4 a a DET crl-16614 149 5 variety variety NOUN crl-16614 149 6 of of ADP crl-16614 149 7 resources resource NOUN crl-16614 149 8 when when SCONJ crl-16614 149 9 determining determine VERB crl-16614 149 10 the the DET crl-16614 149 11 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 149 12 of of ADP crl-16614 149 13 a a DET crl-16614 149 14 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 149 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 149 16 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 149 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 149 18 or or CCONJ crl-16614 149 19 article article NOUN crl-16614 149 20 . . PUNCT crl-16614 150 1 such such ADJ crl-16614 150 2 tools tool NOUN crl-16614 150 3 might might AUX crl-16614 150 4 include include VERB crl-16614 150 5 jcr jcr NOUN crl-16614 150 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 150 7 the the DET crl-16614 150 8 doaj doaj NOUN crl-16614 150 9 , , PUNCT crl-16614 150 10 the the DET crl-16614 150 11 open open ADJ crl-16614 150 12 access access NOUN crl-16614 150 13 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 150 14 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 150 15 association association NOUN crl-16614 150 16 , , PUNCT crl-16614 150 17 cabell cabell PROPN crl-16614 150 18 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 150 19 directory directory NOUN crl-16614 150 20 of of ADP crl-16614 150 21 publishing publish VERB crl-16614 150 22 opportunities opportunity NOUN crl-16614 150 23 , , PUNCT crl-16614 150 24 and and CCONJ crl-16614 150 25 subject subject ADJ crl-16614 150 26 specialist specialist NOUN crl-16614 150 27 knowledge knowledge NOUN crl-16614 150 28 . . PUNCT crl-16614 151 1 the the DET crl-16614 151 2 present present ADJ crl-16614 151 3 authors author NOUN crl-16614 151 4 recognize recognize VERB crl-16614 151 5 that that SCONJ crl-16614 151 6 there there PRON crl-16614 151 7 are be VERB crl-16614 151 8 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 151 9 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 151 10 in in ADP crl-16614 151 11 the the DET crl-16614 151 12 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 151 13 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 151 14 model model NOUN crl-16614 151 15 . . PUNCT crl-16614 152 1 however however ADV crl-16614 152 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 152 3 it it PRON crl-16614 152 4 would would AUX crl-16614 152 5 be be AUX crl-16614 152 6 prudent prudent ADJ crl-16614 152 7 to to PART crl-16614 152 8 caution caution VERB crl-16614 152 9 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 152 10 to to PART crl-16614 152 11 understand understand VERB crl-16614 152 12 that that SCONJ crl-16614 152 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 152 14 as as SCONJ crl-16614 152 15 noted note VERB crl-16614 152 16 by by ADP crl-16614 152 17 berger berger PROPN crl-16614 152 18 and and CCONJ crl-16614 152 19 cirasella cirasella NOUN crl-16614 152 20 , , PUNCT crl-16614 152 21 there there PRON crl-16614 152 22 are be VERB crl-16614 152 23 also also ADV crl-16614 152 24 low low ADJ crl-16614 152 25 - - PUNCT crl-16614 152 26 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 152 27 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 152 28 found find VERB crl-16614 152 29 in in ADP crl-16614 152 30 the the DET crl-16614 152 31 traditional traditional ADJ crl-16614 152 32 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 152 33 model.34 model.34 NOUN crl-16614 152 34 therefore therefore ADV crl-16614 152 35 , , PUNCT crl-16614 152 36 the the DET crl-16614 152 37 present present ADJ crl-16614 152 38 authors author NOUN crl-16614 152 39 recommend recommend VERB crl-16614 152 40 that that SCONJ crl-16614 152 41 librarians librarians PROPN crl-16614 152 42 remain remain VERB crl-16614 152 43 cognizant cognizant ADJ crl-16614 152 44 of of ADP crl-16614 152 45 these these DET crl-16614 152 46 liabilities liability NOUN crl-16614 152 47 , , PUNCT crl-16614 152 48 but but CCONJ crl-16614 152 49 they they PRON crl-16614 152 50 agree agree VERB crl-16614 152 51 with with ADP crl-16614 152 52 the the DET crl-16614 152 53 conclusion conclusion NOUN crl-16614 152 54 of of ADP crl-16614 152 55 smith smith PROPN crl-16614 152 56 that that PRON crl-16614 152 57 librarians librarian VERB crl-16614 152 58 should should AUX crl-16614 152 59 stress stress VERB crl-16614 152 60 to to ADP crl-16614 152 61 users user NOUN crl-16614 152 62 that that PRON crl-16614 152 63 oa oa VERB crl-16614 152 64 and and CCONJ crl-16614 152 65 traditional traditional ADJ crl-16614 152 66 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 152 67 deserve deserve VERB crl-16614 152 68 equal equal ADJ crl-16614 152 69 consideration consideration NOUN crl-16614 152 70 when when SCONJ crl-16614 152 71 making make VERB crl-16614 152 72 decisions decision NOUN crl-16614 152 73 concerning concern VERB crl-16614 152 74 quality.35 quality.35 PROPN crl-16614 152 75 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 153 1 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 153 2 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 153 3 serves serve VERB crl-16614 153 4 an an DET crl-16614 153 5 important important ADJ crl-16614 153 6 purpose purpose NOUN crl-16614 153 7 as as ADP crl-16614 153 8 a a DET crl-16614 153 9 tool tool NOUN crl-16614 153 10 for for ADP crl-16614 153 11 information information NOUN crl-16614 153 12 literacy literacy NOUN crl-16614 153 13 and and CCONJ crl-16614 153 14 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-16614 153 15 . . PUNCT crl-16614 154 1 however however ADV crl-16614 154 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 154 3 since since SCONJ crl-16614 154 4 beall beall NOUN crl-16614 154 5 ties tie NOUN crl-16614 154 6 it it PRON crl-16614 154 7 directly directly ADV crl-16614 154 8 to to ADP crl-16614 154 9 his his PRON crl-16614 154 10 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 154 11 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 154 12 and and CCONJ crl-16614 154 13 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 154 14 lists list NOUN crl-16614 154 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 154 16 the the DET crl-16614 154 17 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 154 18 becomes become VERB crl-16614 154 19 counterproductive counterproductive ADJ crl-16614 154 20 to to ADP crl-16614 154 21 the the DET crl-16614 154 22 two two NUM crl-16614 154 23 objectives objective NOUN crl-16614 154 24 of of ADP crl-16614 154 25 information information NOUN crl-16614 154 26 literacy literacy NOUN crl-16614 154 27 and and CCONJ crl-16614 154 28 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-16614 154 29 . . PUNCT crl-16614 155 1 because because SCONJ crl-16614 155 2 evaluators evaluator NOUN crl-16614 155 3 often often ADV crl-16614 155 4 interpret interpret VERB crl-16614 155 5 the the DET crl-16614 155 6 lists list NOUN crl-16614 155 7 as as ADP crl-16614 155 8 determinative determinative NOUN crl-16614 155 9 of of ADP crl-16614 155 10 a a DET crl-16614 155 11 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 155 12 or or CCONJ crl-16614 155 13 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 155 14 ’s ’s NOUN crl-16614 155 15 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 155 16 status status NOUN crl-16614 155 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 155 18 this this PRON crl-16614 155 19 impedes impede VERB crl-16614 155 20 the the DET crl-16614 155 21 application application NOUN crl-16614 155 22 of of ADP crl-16614 155 23 the the DET crl-16614 155 24 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 155 25 because because SCONJ crl-16614 155 26 it it PRON crl-16614 155 27 represents represent VERB crl-16614 155 28 the the DET crl-16614 155 29 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 155 30 employment employment NOUN crl-16614 155 31 of of ADP crl-16614 155 32 the the DET crl-16614 155 33 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 155 34 by by ADP crl-16614 155 35 beall beall NOUN crl-16614 155 36 himself himself PRON crl-16614 155 37 . . PUNCT crl-16614 156 1 the the DET crl-16614 156 2 indiscriminate indiscriminate ADJ crl-16614 156 3 use use NOUN crl-16614 156 4 of of ADP crl-16614 156 5 the the DET crl-16614 156 6 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 156 7 and and CCONJ crl-16614 156 8 the the DET crl-16614 156 9 lists list NOUN crl-16614 156 10 derived derive VERB crl-16614 156 11 from from ADP crl-16614 156 12 it it PRON crl-16614 156 13 effectively effectively ADV crl-16614 156 14 obscures obscure VERB crl-16614 156 15 this this DET crl-16614 156 16 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 156 17 nature nature NOUN crl-16614 156 18 and and CCONJ crl-16614 156 19 alienates alienate VERB crl-16614 156 20 the the DET crl-16614 156 21 reader reader NOUN crl-16614 156 22 from from ADP crl-16614 156 23 the the DET crl-16614 156 24 process process NOUN crl-16614 156 25 . . PUNCT crl-16614 157 1 additionally additionally ADV crl-16614 157 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 157 3 the the DET crl-16614 157 4 title title NOUN crl-16614 157 5 of of ADP crl-16614 157 6 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 157 7 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 157 8 benchmarking benchmarke VERB crl-16614 157 9 tool tool NOUN crl-16614 157 10 , , PUNCT crl-16614 157 11 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 157 12 for for ADP crl-16614 157 13 determining determine VERB crl-16614 157 14 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 157 15 open open ADJ crl-16614 157 16 - - PUNCT crl-16614 157 17 access access NOUN crl-16614 157 18 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 157 19 , , PUNCT crl-16614 157 20 is be AUX crl-16614 157 21 misleading mislead VERB crl-16614 157 22 to to ADP crl-16614 157 23 the the DET crl-16614 157 24 reader reader NOUN crl-16614 157 25 . . PUNCT crl-16614 158 1 the the DET crl-16614 158 2 title title NOUN crl-16614 158 3 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 158 4 orientation orientation NOUN crl-16614 158 5 toward toward ADP crl-16614 158 6 only only ADV crl-16614 158 7 oa oa ADP crl-16614 158 8 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 158 9 potentially potentially ADV crl-16614 158 10 biases bias VERB crl-16614 158 11 readers reader NOUN crl-16614 158 12 against against ADP crl-16614 158 13 oa oa NOUN crl-16614 158 14 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 158 15 and and CCONJ crl-16614 158 16 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 158 17 . . PUNCT crl-16614 159 1 in in ADP crl-16614 159 2 addition addition NOUN crl-16614 159 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 159 4 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 159 5 ’s ’s DET crl-16614 159 6 use use NOUN crl-16614 159 7 of of ADP crl-16614 159 8 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 159 9 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 159 10 for for ADP crl-16614 159 11 determining determine VERB crl-16614 159 12 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 159 13 in in ADP crl-16614 159 14 the the DET crl-16614 159 15 title title NOUN crl-16614 159 16 of of ADP crl-16614 159 17 his his PRON crl-16614 159 18 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-16614 159 19 tool tool NOUN crl-16614 159 20 further far ADV crl-16614 159 21 muddies muddy VERB crl-16614 159 22 the the DET crl-16614 159 23 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 159 24 nature nature NOUN crl-16614 159 25 62 62 NUM crl-16614 159 26 college college PROPN crl-16614 159 27 & & CCONJ crl-16614 159 28 research research PROPN crl-16614 159 29 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 159 30 january january PROPN crl-16614 159 31 2018 2018 NUM crl-16614 159 32 of of ADP crl-16614 159 33 the the DET crl-16614 159 34 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 159 35 . . PUNCT crl-16614 160 1 according accord VERB crl-16614 160 2 to to ADP crl-16614 160 3 the the DET crl-16614 160 4 oxford oxford PROPN crl-16614 160 5 english english PROPN crl-16614 160 6 dictionary dictionary PROPN crl-16614 160 7 , , PUNCT crl-16614 160 8 to to PART crl-16614 160 9 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 160 10 determine determine VERB crl-16614 160 11 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 160 12 something something PRON crl-16614 160 13 means mean VERB crl-16614 160 14 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 160 15 to to PART crl-16614 160 16 end end VERB crl-16614 160 17 in in ADP crl-16614 160 18 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 160 19 a a DET crl-16614 160 20 termination termination NOUN crl-16614 160 21 , , PUNCT crl-16614 160 22 conclusion conclusion NOUN crl-16614 160 23 , , PUNCT crl-16614 160 24 or or CCONJ crl-16614 160 25 result result VERB crl-16614 160 26 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 160 27 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 160 28 as as ADV crl-16614 160 29 well well ADV crl-16614 160 30 as as ADP crl-16614 160 31 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 160 32 to to PART crl-16614 160 33 bring bring VERB crl-16614 160 34 to to ADP crl-16614 160 35 an an DET crl-16614 160 36 end end NOUN crl-16614 160 37 a a DET crl-16614 160 38 dispute dispute NOUN crl-16614 160 39 , , PUNCT crl-16614 160 40 controversy controversy NOUN crl-16614 160 41 , , PUNCT crl-16614 160 42 or or CCONJ crl-16614 160 43 doubtful doubtful ADJ crl-16614 160 44 matter matter NOUN crl-16614 160 45 ; ; PUNCT crl-16614 160 46 to to PART crl-16614 160 47 conclude conclude VERB crl-16614 160 48 , , PUNCT crl-16614 160 49 settle settle VERB crl-16614 160 50 , , PUNCT crl-16614 160 51 decide decide VERB crl-16614 160 52 , , PUNCT crl-16614 160 53 fix fix NOUN crl-16614 160 54 . . PUNCT crl-16614 161 1 ”36 ”36 VERB crl-16614 161 2 the the DET crl-16614 161 3 present present ADJ crl-16614 161 4 authors author NOUN crl-16614 161 5 argue argue VERB crl-16614 161 6 that that SCONJ crl-16614 161 7 , , PUNCT crl-16614 161 8 while while SCONJ crl-16614 161 9 the the DET crl-16614 161 10 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 161 11 may may AUX crl-16614 161 12 serve serve VERB crl-16614 161 13 as as ADP crl-16614 161 14 an an DET crl-16614 161 15 aid aid NOUN crl-16614 161 16 to to ADP crl-16614 161 17 this this DET crl-16614 161 18 end end NOUN crl-16614 161 19 , , PUNCT crl-16614 161 20 it it PRON crl-16614 161 21 is be AUX crl-16614 161 22 presently presently ADV crl-16614 161 23 not not PART crl-16614 161 24 adequate adequate ADJ crl-16614 161 25 for for ADP crl-16614 161 26 making make VERB crl-16614 161 27 such such ADJ crl-16614 161 28 determinations determination NOUN crl-16614 161 29 and and CCONJ crl-16614 161 30 they they PRON crl-16614 161 31 question question VERB crl-16614 161 32 the the DET crl-16614 161 33 limited limited ADJ crl-16614 161 34 scope scope NOUN crl-16614 161 35 of of ADP crl-16614 161 36 the the DET crl-16614 161 37 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 161 38 . . PUNCT crl-16614 162 1 information information NOUN crl-16614 162 2 literacy literacy NOUN crl-16614 162 3 and and CCONJ crl-16614 162 4 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-16614 162 5 goes go VERB crl-16614 162 6 beyond beyond ADP crl-16614 162 7 the the DET crl-16614 162 8 structure structure NOUN crl-16614 162 9 of of ADP crl-16614 162 10 the the DET crl-16614 162 11 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 162 12 and and CCONJ crl-16614 162 13 its its PRON crl-16614 162 14 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 162 15 practices practice NOUN crl-16614 162 16 to to PART crl-16614 162 17 include include VERB crl-16614 162 18 the the DET crl-16614 162 19 assessment assessment NOUN crl-16614 162 20 of of ADP crl-16614 162 21 the the DET crl-16614 162 22 actual actual ADJ crl-16614 162 23 information information NOUN crl-16614 162 24 content content NOUN crl-16614 162 25 . . PUNCT crl-16614 163 1 this this PRON crl-16614 163 2 is be AUX crl-16614 163 3 extremely extremely ADV crl-16614 163 4 important important ADJ crl-16614 163 5 for for ADP crl-16614 163 6 the the DET crl-16614 163 7 work work NOUN crl-16614 163 8 of of ADP crl-16614 163 9 promotion promotion NOUN crl-16614 163 10 and and CCONJ crl-16614 163 11 tenure tenure NOUN crl-16614 163 12 committees committee NOUN crl-16614 163 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 163 14 as as SCONJ crl-16614 163 15 they they PRON crl-16614 163 16 need need VERB crl-16614 163 17 to to PART crl-16614 163 18 assess assess VERB crl-16614 163 19 the the DET crl-16614 163 20 actual actual ADJ crl-16614 163 21 information information NOUN crl-16614 163 22 content content NOUN crl-16614 163 23 rather rather ADV crl-16614 163 24 than than ADP crl-16614 163 25 simply simply ADV crl-16614 163 26 relying rely VERB crl-16614 163 27 on on ADP crl-16614 163 28 a a DET crl-16614 163 29 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 163 30 criterion criterion NOUN crl-16614 163 31 such such ADJ crl-16614 163 32 as as ADP crl-16614 163 33 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 163 34 there there PRON crl-16614 163 35 is be VERB crl-16614 163 36 little little ADJ crl-16614 163 37 or or CCONJ crl-16614 163 38 no no PRON crl-16614 163 39 geographical geographical ADJ crl-16614 163 40 diversity diversity NOUN crl-16614 163 41 among among ADP crl-16614 163 42 the the DET crl-16614 163 43 editorial editorial ADJ crl-16614 163 44 board board NOUN crl-16614 163 45 members member NOUN crl-16614 163 46 , , PUNCT crl-16614 163 47 especially especially ADV crl-16614 163 48 for for ADP crl-16614 163 49 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 163 50 that that PRON crl-16614 163 51 claim claim VERB crl-16614 163 52 to to PART crl-16614 163 53 be be AUX crl-16614 163 54 international international ADJ crl-16614 163 55 in in ADP crl-16614 163 56 scope scope NOUN crl-16614 163 57 or or CCONJ crl-16614 163 58 coverage coverage NOUN crl-16614 163 59 . . PUNCT crl-16614 163 60 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 164 1 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 164 2 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 164 3 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 164 4 does do AUX crl-16614 164 5 not not PART crl-16614 164 6 adequately adequately ADV crl-16614 164 7 account account VERB crl-16614 164 8 for for ADP crl-16614 164 9 the the DET crl-16614 164 10 subject subject ADJ crl-16614 164 11 knowledge knowledge NOUN crl-16614 164 12 and and CCONJ crl-16614 164 13 subject subject NOUN crl-16614 164 14 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-16614 164 15 expertise expertise NOUN crl-16614 164 16 necessary necessary ADJ crl-16614 164 17 for for ADP crl-16614 164 18 determining determine VERB crl-16614 164 19 the the DET crl-16614 164 20 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 164 21 of of ADP crl-16614 164 22 the the DET crl-16614 164 23 published publish VERB crl-16614 164 24 content content NOUN crl-16614 164 25 ; ; PUNCT crl-16614 164 26 instead instead ADV crl-16614 164 27 , , PUNCT crl-16614 164 28 it it PRON crl-16614 164 29 focuses focus VERB crl-16614 164 30 on on ADP crl-16614 164 31 traditional traditional ADJ crl-16614 164 32 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 164 33 standards standard NOUN crl-16614 164 34 as as SCONJ crl-16614 164 35 interpreted interpret VERB crl-16614 164 36 through through ADP crl-16614 164 37 the the DET crl-16614 164 38 lens lens NOUN crl-16614 164 39 of of ADP crl-16614 164 40 a a DET crl-16614 164 41 librarian librarian ADJ crl-16614 164 42 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 164 43 specifically specifically ADV crl-16614 164 44 the the DET crl-16614 164 45 lens lens NOUN crl-16614 164 46 of of ADP crl-16614 164 47 beall beall NOUN crl-16614 164 48 and and CCONJ crl-16614 164 49 all all PRON crl-16614 164 50 of of ADP crl-16614 164 51 his his PRON crl-16614 164 52 possible possible ADJ crl-16614 164 53 biases bias NOUN crl-16614 164 54 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 164 55 . . PUNCT crl-16614 165 1 therefore therefore ADV crl-16614 165 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 165 3 while while SCONJ crl-16614 165 4 the the DET crl-16614 165 5 authors author NOUN crl-16614 165 6 of of ADP crl-16614 165 7 this this DET crl-16614 165 8 study study NOUN crl-16614 165 9 are be AUX crl-16614 165 10 not not PART crl-16614 165 11 devaluating devaluate VERB crl-16614 165 12 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 165 13 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 165 14 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 165 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 165 16 they they PRON crl-16614 165 17 advocate advocate VERB crl-16614 165 18 the the DET crl-16614 165 19 development development NOUN crl-16614 165 20 of of ADP crl-16614 165 21 additional additional ADJ crl-16614 165 22 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 165 23 that that PRON crl-16614 165 24 focus focus VERB crl-16614 165 25 on on ADP crl-16614 165 26 subject subject ADJ crl-16614 165 27 content content NOUN crl-16614 165 28 , , PUNCT crl-16614 165 29 particularly particularly ADV crl-16614 165 30 if if SCONJ crl-16614 165 31 evaluators evaluator NOUN crl-16614 165 32 might might AUX crl-16614 165 33 use use VERB crl-16614 165 34 such such DET crl-16614 165 35 a a DET crl-16614 165 36 list list NOUN crl-16614 165 37 of of ADP crl-16614 165 38 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 165 39 as as ADP crl-16614 165 40 a a DET crl-16614 165 41 means mean NOUN crl-16614 165 42 for for ADP crl-16614 165 43 making make VERB crl-16614 165 44 decisions decision NOUN crl-16614 165 45 regarding regard VERB crl-16614 165 46 promotion promotion NOUN crl-16614 165 47 and and CCONJ crl-16614 165 48 tenure tenure NOUN crl-16614 165 49 across across ADP crl-16614 165 50 university university NOUN crl-16614 165 51 departments department NOUN crl-16614 165 52 . . PUNCT crl-16614 166 1 conclusion conclusion VERB crl-16614 166 2 this this DET crl-16614 166 3 study study NOUN crl-16614 166 4 demonstrates demonstrate VERB crl-16614 166 5 the the DET crl-16614 166 6 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 166 7 nature nature NOUN crl-16614 166 8 of of ADP crl-16614 166 9 the the DET crl-16614 166 10 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 166 11 by by ADP crl-16614 166 12 which which PRON crl-16614 166 13 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 166 14 constructs construct VERB crl-16614 166 15 his his PRON crl-16614 166 16 lists list NOUN crl-16614 166 17 . . PUNCT crl-16614 167 1 furthermore furthermore ADV crl-16614 167 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 167 3 it it PRON crl-16614 167 4 highlights highlight VERB crl-16614 167 5 the the DET crl-16614 167 6 finding finding NOUN crl-16614 167 7 that that SCONJ crl-16614 167 8 well well ADV crl-16614 167 9 - - PUNCT crl-16614 167 10 regarded regard VERB crl-16614 167 11 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 167 12 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 167 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 167 14 whether whether SCONJ crl-16614 167 15 oa oa PRON crl-16614 167 16 or or CCONJ crl-16614 167 17 not not PART crl-16614 167 18 , , PUNCT crl-16614 167 19 can can AUX crl-16614 167 20 be be AUX crl-16614 167 21 considered consider VERB crl-16614 167 22 as as ADP crl-16614 167 23 possible possible ADJ crl-16614 167 24 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 167 25 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 167 26 , , PUNCT crl-16614 167 27 even even ADV crl-16614 167 28 when when SCONJ crl-16614 167 29 lis lis ADJ crl-16614 167 30 professionals professional NOUN crl-16614 167 31 apply apply VERB crl-16614 167 32 the the DET crl-16614 167 33 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 167 34 . . PUNCT crl-16614 168 1 the the DET crl-16614 168 2 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 168 3 recommend recommend VERB crl-16614 168 4 placing place VERB crl-16614 168 5 emphasis emphasis NOUN crl-16614 168 6 upon upon SCONJ crl-16614 168 7 training training NOUN crl-16614 168 8 evaluators evaluator NOUN crl-16614 168 9 to to PART crl-16614 168 10 apply apply VERB crl-16614 168 11 the the DET crl-16614 168 12 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 168 13 itself itself PRON crl-16614 168 14 , , PUNCT crl-16614 168 15 as as SCONJ crl-16614 168 16 opposed oppose VERB crl-16614 168 17 to to ADP crl-16614 168 18 relying rely VERB crl-16614 168 19 on on ADP crl-16614 168 20 a a DET crl-16614 168 21 list list NOUN crl-16614 168 22 of of ADP crl-16614 168 23 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 168 24 derived derive VERB crl-16614 168 25 from from ADP crl-16614 168 26 the the DET crl-16614 168 27 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 168 28 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 168 29 application application NOUN crl-16614 168 30 developed develop VERB crl-16614 168 31 under under ADP crl-16614 168 32 one one NUM crl-16614 168 33 person person NOUN crl-16614 168 34 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 168 35 opinion opinion NOUN crl-16614 168 36 . . PUNCT crl-16614 169 1 the the DET crl-16614 169 2 problem problem NOUN crl-16614 169 3 with with ADP crl-16614 169 4 relying rely VERB crl-16614 169 5 on on ADP crl-16614 169 6 any any DET crl-16614 169 7 list list NOUN crl-16614 169 8 is be AUX crl-16614 169 9 that that SCONJ crl-16614 169 10 when when SCONJ crl-16614 169 11 an an DET crl-16614 169 12 information information NOUN crl-16614 169 13 specialist specialist NOUN crl-16614 169 14 presents present VERB crl-16614 169 15 a a DET crl-16614 169 16 list list NOUN crl-16614 169 17 to to ADP crl-16614 169 18 a a DET crl-16614 169 19 reader reader NOUN crl-16614 169 20 , , PUNCT crl-16614 169 21 the the DET crl-16614 169 22 reader reader NOUN crl-16614 169 23 might might AUX crl-16614 169 24 view view VERB crl-16614 169 25 this this DET crl-16614 169 26 list list NOUN crl-16614 169 27 uncritically uncritically ADV crl-16614 169 28 , , PUNCT crl-16614 169 29 assuming assume VERB crl-16614 169 30 it it PRON crl-16614 169 31 to to PART crl-16614 169 32 be be AUX crl-16614 169 33 100 100 NUM crl-16614 169 34 percent percent NOUN crl-16614 169 35 correct correct ADJ crl-16614 169 36 . . PUNCT crl-16614 170 1 the the DET crl-16614 170 2 reader reader NOUN crl-16614 170 3 may may AUX crl-16614 170 4 rely rely VERB crl-16614 170 5 solely solely ADV crl-16614 170 6 on on ADP crl-16614 170 7 the the DET crl-16614 170 8 list list NOUN crl-16614 170 9 , , PUNCT crl-16614 170 10 even even ADV crl-16614 170 11 with with ADP crl-16614 170 12 the the DET crl-16614 170 13 author author NOUN crl-16614 170 14 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 170 15 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 170 16 warnings warning NOUN crl-16614 170 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 170 18 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 170 19 and and CCONJ crl-16614 170 20 not not PART crl-16614 170 21 consider consider VERB crl-16614 170 22 the the DET crl-16614 170 23 information information NOUN crl-16614 170 24 content content NOUN crl-16614 170 25 presented present VERB crl-16614 170 26 within within ADP crl-16614 170 27 the the DET crl-16614 170 28 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 170 29 itself itself PRON crl-16614 170 30 . . PUNCT crl-16614 171 1 however however ADV crl-16614 171 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 171 3 as as SCONJ crl-16614 171 4 this this DET crl-16614 171 5 study study NOUN crl-16614 171 6 has have AUX crl-16614 171 7 demonstrated demonstrate VERB crl-16614 171 8 , , PUNCT crl-16614 171 9 even even ADV crl-16614 171 10 librarians librarian NOUN crl-16614 171 11 disagree disagree VERB crl-16614 171 12 about about ADP crl-16614 171 13 the the DET crl-16614 171 14 interpretation interpretation NOUN crl-16614 171 15 and and CCONJ crl-16614 171 16 application application NOUN crl-16614 171 17 of of ADP crl-16614 171 18 the the DET crl-16614 171 19 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 171 20 , , PUNCT crl-16614 171 21 and and CCONJ crl-16614 171 22 this this DET crl-16614 171 23 study study NOUN crl-16614 171 24 ’s ’s NUM crl-16614 171 25 three three NUM crl-16614 171 26 analysts analyst NOUN crl-16614 171 27 did do AUX crl-16614 171 28 not not PART crl-16614 171 29 even even ADV crl-16614 171 30 consider consider VERB crl-16614 171 31 the the DET crl-16614 171 32 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 171 33 of of ADP crl-16614 171 34 the the DET crl-16614 171 35 content content NOUN crl-16614 171 36 found find VERB crl-16614 171 37 within within ADP crl-16614 171 38 the the DET crl-16614 171 39 pages page NOUN crl-16614 171 40 of of ADP crl-16614 171 41 the the DET crl-16614 171 42 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 171 43 . . PUNCT crl-16614 172 1 after after ADV crl-16614 172 2 all all ADV crl-16614 172 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 172 4 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 172 5 communication communication NOUN crl-16614 172 6 is be AUX crl-16614 172 7 ultimately ultimately ADV crl-16614 172 8 driven drive VERB crl-16614 172 9 by by ADP crl-16614 172 10 the the DET crl-16614 172 11 information information NOUN crl-16614 172 12 within within ADP crl-16614 172 13 the the DET crl-16614 172 14 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 172 15 . . PUNCT crl-16614 173 1 the the DET crl-16614 173 2 researchers researcher NOUN crl-16614 173 3 put put VERB crl-16614 173 4 forth forth ADV crl-16614 173 5 that that SCONJ crl-16614 173 6 only only ADV crl-16614 173 7 experts expert NOUN crl-16614 173 8 in in ADP crl-16614 173 9 a a DET crl-16614 173 10 specific specific ADJ crl-16614 173 11 field field NOUN crl-16614 173 12 of of ADP crl-16614 173 13 study study NOUN crl-16614 173 14 can can AUX crl-16614 173 15 truly truly ADV crl-16614 173 16 identify identify VERB crl-16614 173 17 fraudulent fraudulent ADJ crl-16614 173 18 information information NOUN crl-16614 173 19 in in ADP crl-16614 173 20 their their PRON crl-16614 173 21 field field NOUN crl-16614 173 22 of of ADP crl-16614 173 23 expertise expertise NOUN crl-16614 173 24 , , PUNCT crl-16614 173 25 whether whether SCONJ crl-16614 173 26 or or CCONJ crl-16614 173 27 not not PART crl-16614 173 28 that that DET crl-16614 173 29 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 173 30 finds find VERB crl-16614 173 31 itself itself PRON crl-16614 173 32 on on ADP crl-16614 173 33 any any DET crl-16614 173 34 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 173 35 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 173 36 list list NOUN crl-16614 173 37 . . PUNCT crl-16614 174 1 however however ADV crl-16614 174 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 174 3 if if SCONJ crl-16614 174 4 a a DET crl-16614 174 5 list list NOUN crl-16614 174 6 of of ADP crl-16614 174 7 potential potential ADJ crl-16614 174 8 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 174 9 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 174 10 and and CCONJ crl-16614 174 11 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 174 12 is be AUX crl-16614 174 13 given give VERB crl-16614 174 14 , , PUNCT crl-16614 174 15 an an DET crl-16614 174 16 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-16614 174 17 process process NOUN crl-16614 174 18 needs need VERB crl-16614 174 19 to to PART crl-16614 174 20 be be AUX crl-16614 174 21 developed develop VERB crl-16614 174 22 that that PRON crl-16614 174 23 is be AUX crl-16614 174 24 transparent transparent ADJ crl-16614 174 25 to to ADP crl-16614 174 26 the the DET crl-16614 174 27 reader reader NOUN crl-16614 174 28 so so SCONJ crl-16614 174 29 that that SCONJ crl-16614 174 30 the the DET crl-16614 174 31 reader reader NOUN crl-16614 174 32 will will AUX crl-16614 174 33 know know VERB crl-16614 174 34 and and CCONJ crl-16614 174 35 understand understand VERB crl-16614 174 36 why why SCONJ crl-16614 174 37 certain certain ADJ crl-16614 174 38 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 174 39 did do AUX crl-16614 174 40 not not PART crl-16614 174 41 pass pass VERB crl-16614 174 42 muster muster NOUN crl-16614 174 43 and and CCONJ crl-16614 174 44 , , PUNCT crl-16614 174 45 therefore therefore ADV crl-16614 174 46 , , PUNCT crl-16614 174 47 why why SCONJ crl-16614 174 48 the the DET crl-16614 174 49 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 174 50 failed fail VERB crl-16614 174 51 the the DET crl-16614 174 52 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-16614 174 53 . . PUNCT crl-16614 175 1 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 175 2 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 175 3 lists list NOUN crl-16614 175 4 are be AUX crl-16614 175 5 deficient deficient ADJ crl-16614 175 6 in in ADP crl-16614 175 7 this this DET crl-16614 175 8 area area NOUN crl-16614 175 9 , , PUNCT crl-16614 175 10 as as SCONJ crl-16614 175 11 he he PRON crl-16614 175 12 provides provide VERB crl-16614 175 13 only only ADV crl-16614 175 14 names name NOUN crl-16614 175 15 and and CCONJ crl-16614 175 16 links link NOUN crl-16614 175 17 to to ADP crl-16614 175 18 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 175 19 publisher publisher NOUN crl-16614 175 20 websites website NOUN crl-16614 175 21 that that PRON crl-16614 175 22 have have AUX crl-16614 175 23 failed fail VERB crl-16614 175 24 . . PUNCT crl-16614 176 1 identifying identify VERB crl-16614 176 2 the the DET crl-16614 176 3 reasons reason NOUN crl-16614 176 4 a a DET crl-16614 176 5 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 176 6 failed fail VERB crl-16614 176 7 would would AUX crl-16614 176 8 shine shine VERB crl-16614 176 9 light light NOUN crl-16614 176 10 on on ADP crl-16614 176 11 the the DET crl-16614 176 12 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 176 13 and and CCONJ crl-16614 176 14 would would AUX crl-16614 176 15 help help VERB crl-16614 176 16 the the DET crl-16614 176 17 reader reader NOUN crl-16614 176 18 to to PART crl-16614 176 19 reconsider reconsider VERB crl-16614 176 20 if if SCONJ crl-16614 176 21 the the DET crl-16614 176 22 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 176 23 is be AUX crl-16614 176 24 truly truly ADV crl-16614 176 25 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 176 26 , , PUNCT crl-16614 176 27 possibly possibly ADV crl-16614 176 28 causing cause VERB crl-16614 176 29 them they PRON crl-16614 176 30 to to PART crl-16614 176 31 further far ADV crl-16614 176 32 consider consider VERB crl-16614 176 33 the the DET crl-16614 176 34 information information NOUN crl-16614 176 35 within within ADP crl-16614 176 36 the the DET crl-16614 176 37 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 176 38 . . PUNCT crl-16614 177 1 this this DET crl-16614 177 2 study study NOUN crl-16614 177 3 shows show VERB crl-16614 177 4 the the DET crl-16614 177 5 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 177 6 nature nature NOUN crl-16614 177 7 of of ADP crl-16614 177 8 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 177 9 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 177 10 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 177 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 177 12 as as ADV crl-16614 177 13 well well ADV crl-16614 177 14 as as ADP crl-16614 177 15 the the DET crl-16614 177 16 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 177 17 nature nature NOUN crl-16614 177 18 of of ADP crl-16614 177 19 the the DET crl-16614 177 20 lists list NOUN crl-16614 177 21 created create VERB crl-16614 177 22 from from ADP crl-16614 177 23 the the DET crl-16614 177 24 application application NOUN crl-16614 177 25 of of ADP crl-16614 177 26 the the DET crl-16614 177 27 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 177 28 . . PUNCT crl-16614 178 1 such such ADJ crl-16614 178 2 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 178 3 provide provide VERB crl-16614 178 4 a a DET crl-16614 178 5 starting starting NOUN crl-16614 178 6 point point NOUN crl-16614 178 7 for for ADP crl-16614 178 8 a a DET crl-16614 178 9 discussion discussion NOUN crl-16614 178 10 on on ADP crl-16614 178 11 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 178 12 aspects aspect NOUN crl-16614 178 13 of of ADP crl-16614 178 14 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 178 15 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 178 16 . . PUNCT crl-16614 179 1 nevertheless nevertheless ADV crl-16614 179 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 179 3 as as ADP crl-16614 179 4 librarians librarian NOUN crl-16614 179 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 179 6 our our PRON crl-16614 179 7 duty duty NOUN crl-16614 179 8 is be AUX crl-16614 179 9 to to PART crl-16614 179 10 refrain refrain VERB crl-16614 179 11 from from ADP crl-16614 179 12 offering offer VERB crl-16614 179 13 up up ADP crl-16614 179 14 these these DET crl-16614 179 15 lists list NOUN crl-16614 179 16 as as ADP crl-16614 179 17 the the DET crl-16614 179 18 final final ADJ crl-16614 179 19 word word NOUN crl-16614 179 20 on on ADP crl-16614 179 21 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 179 22 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 179 23 . . PUNCT crl-16614 180 1 rather rather ADV crl-16614 180 2 , , PUNCT crl-16614 180 3 it it PRON crl-16614 180 4 is be AUX crl-16614 180 5 our our PRON crl-16614 180 6 responsibility responsibility NOUN crl-16614 180 7 to to ADP crl-16614 180 8 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 180 9 1 1 X crl-16614 180 10 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 180 11 use use VERB crl-16614 180 12 such such ADJ crl-16614 180 13 lists list NOUN crl-16614 180 14 and and CCONJ crl-16614 180 15 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 180 16 as as SCONJ crl-16614 180 17 format format NOUN crl-16614 180 18 aside aside ADV crl-16614 180 19 63 63 NUM crl-16614 180 20 tools tool NOUN crl-16614 180 21 for for ADP crl-16614 180 22 teaching teach VERB crl-16614 180 23 faculty faculty NOUN crl-16614 180 24 to to PART crl-16614 180 25 be be AUX crl-16614 180 26 proactive proactive ADJ crl-16614 180 27 about about ADP crl-16614 180 28 evaluating evaluate VERB crl-16614 180 29 what what PRON crl-16614 180 30 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 180 31 to to PART crl-16614 180 32 publish publish VERB crl-16614 180 33 in in ADV crl-16614 180 34 and and CCONJ crl-16614 180 35 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 180 36 2 2 NUM crl-16614 180 37 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 180 38 to to PART crl-16614 180 39 ensure ensure VERB crl-16614 180 40 that that SCONJ crl-16614 180 41 newer new ADJ crl-16614 180 42 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 180 43 , , PUNCT crl-16614 180 44 which which PRON crl-16614 180 45 are be AUX crl-16614 180 46 often often ADV crl-16614 180 47 oa oa ADP crl-16614 180 48 , , PUNCT crl-16614 180 49 are be AUX crl-16614 180 50 not not PART crl-16614 180 51 disqualified disqualify VERB crl-16614 180 52 unfairly unfairly ADV crl-16614 180 53 from from ADP crl-16614 180 54 consideration consideration NOUN crl-16614 180 55 as as ADP crl-16614 180 56 part part NOUN crl-16614 180 57 of of ADP crl-16614 180 58 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 180 59 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 180 60 output output NOUN crl-16614 180 61 . . PUNCT crl-16614 181 1 this this DET crl-16614 181 2 latter latter ADJ crl-16614 181 3 point point NOUN crl-16614 181 4 is be AUX crl-16614 181 5 especially especially ADV crl-16614 181 6 important important ADJ crl-16614 181 7 if if SCONJ crl-16614 181 8 promotion promotion NOUN crl-16614 181 9 and and CCONJ crl-16614 181 10 tenure tenure NOUN crl-16614 181 11 committees committee NOUN crl-16614 181 12 use use VERB crl-16614 181 13 beall beall NOUN crl-16614 181 14 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 181 15 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 181 16 without without ADP crl-16614 181 17 considering consider VERB crl-16614 181 18 the the DET crl-16614 181 19 subjective subjective ADJ crl-16614 181 20 nature nature NOUN crl-16614 181 21 of of ADP crl-16614 181 22 their their PRON crl-16614 181 23 application application NOUN crl-16614 181 24 , , PUNCT crl-16614 181 25 or or CCONJ crl-16614 181 26 without without ADP crl-16614 181 27 also also ADV crl-16614 181 28 including include VERB crl-16614 181 29 supplemental supplemental ADJ crl-16614 181 30 evaluative evaluative ADJ crl-16614 181 31 measures measure NOUN crl-16614 181 32 of of ADP crl-16614 181 33 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 181 34 quality quality NOUN crl-16614 181 35 . . PUNCT crl-16614 182 1 the the DET crl-16614 182 2 authors author NOUN crl-16614 182 3 of of ADP crl-16614 182 4 this this DET crl-16614 182 5 paper paper NOUN crl-16614 182 6 concur concur NOUN crl-16614 182 7 with with ADP crl-16614 182 8 berger berger PROPN crl-16614 182 9 and and CCONJ crl-16614 182 10 cirasella cirasella NOUN crl-16614 182 11 that that PRON crl-16614 182 12 librarians librarian VERB crl-16614 182 13 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 182 14 are be AUX crl-16614 182 15 key key ADJ crl-16614 182 16 stakeholders stakeholder NOUN crl-16614 182 17 in in ADP crl-16614 182 18 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 182 19 and and CCONJ crl-16614 182 20 professional professional ADJ crl-16614 182 21 conversations conversation NOUN crl-16614 182 22 reimagining reimagine VERB crl-16614 182 23 various various ADJ crl-16614 182 24 aspects aspect NOUN crl-16614 182 25 of of ADP crl-16614 182 26 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 182 27 communication,”37 communication,”37 NOUN crl-16614 182 28 and and CCONJ crl-16614 182 29 the the DET crl-16614 182 30 present present ADJ crl-16614 182 31 study study NOUN crl-16614 182 32 emphasizes emphasize VERB crl-16614 182 33 this this DET crl-16614 182 34 role role NOUN crl-16614 182 35 in in ADP crl-16614 182 36 the the DET crl-16614 182 37 area area NOUN crl-16614 182 38 of of ADP crl-16614 182 39 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 182 40 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 182 41 . . PUNCT crl-16614 183 1 64 64 NUM crl-16614 183 2 college college PROPN crl-16614 183 3 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 4 research research PROPN crl-16614 183 5 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 183 6 january january PROPN crl-16614 183 7 2018 2018 NUM crl-16614 183 8 appendix appendix PROPN crl-16614 183 9 : : PUNCT crl-16614 183 10 incites incites PROPN crl-16614 183 11 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 183 12 citation citation NOUN crl-16614 183 13 reports report VERB crl-16614 183 14 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 15 science science PROPN crl-16614 183 16 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 17 library library PROPN crl-16614 183 18 science science NOUN crl-16614 183 19 category category NOUN crl-16614 183 20 1 1 NUM crl-16614 183 21 african african ADJ crl-16614 183 22 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 183 23 of of ADP crl-16614 183 24 library library NOUN crl-16614 183 25 archives archive NOUN crl-16614 183 26 and and CCONJ crl-16614 183 27 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 28 science science NOUN crl-16614 183 29 2 2 NUM crl-16614 183 30 aslib aslib PROPN crl-16614 183 31 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 32 of of ADP crl-16614 183 33 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 34 management management NOUN crl-16614 183 35 3 3 NUM crl-16614 183 36 aslib aslib NOUN crl-16614 183 37 proceedings proceeding NOUN crl-16614 183 38 4 4 NUM crl-16614 183 39 australian australian ADJ crl-16614 183 40 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 183 41 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 42 research research PROPN crl-16614 183 43 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 183 44 5 5 NUM crl-16614 183 45 australian australian ADJ crl-16614 183 46 library library NOUN crl-16614 183 47 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 183 48 6 6 NUM crl-16614 183 49 canadian canadian ADJ crl-16614 183 50 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 51 of of ADP crl-16614 183 52 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 53 and and CCONJ crl-16614 183 54 library library NOUN crl-16614 183 55 science science NOUN crl-16614 183 56 : : PUNCT crl-16614 183 57 la la PROPN crl-16614 183 58 revue revue PROPN crl-16614 183 59 canadienne canadienne PROPN crl-16614 183 60 ses ses PROPN crl-16614 183 61 sciences sciences PROPN crl-16614 183 62 de de PROPN crl-16614 183 63 l’information l’information PROPN crl-16614 183 64 et et PROPN crl-16614 183 65 de de PROPN crl-16614 183 66 bibliothéconomie bibliothéconomie PROPN crl-16614 183 67 7 7 NUM crl-16614 183 68 college college PROPN crl-16614 183 69 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 70 research research PROPN crl-16614 183 71 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 183 72 8 8 NUM crl-16614 183 73 database database NOUN crl-16614 183 74 for for ADP crl-16614 183 75 advances advance NOUN crl-16614 183 76 in in ADP crl-16614 183 77 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 78 systems system NOUN crl-16614 183 79 9 9 NUM crl-16614 183 80 electronic electronic ADJ crl-16614 183 81 library library NOUN crl-16614 183 82 10 10 NUM crl-16614 183 83 ethics ethic NOUN crl-16614 183 84 and and CCONJ crl-16614 183 85 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 86 technology technology NOUN crl-16614 183 87 11 11 NUM crl-16614 183 88 european european ADJ crl-16614 183 89 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 90 of of ADP crl-16614 183 91 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 92 systems system NOUN crl-16614 183 93 12 12 NUM crl-16614 183 94 government government NOUN crl-16614 183 95 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 96 quarterly quarterly ADJ crl-16614 183 97 13 13 NUM crl-16614 183 98 health health NOUN crl-16614 183 99 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 100 and and CCONJ crl-16614 183 101 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 183 102 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 183 103 14 14 NUM crl-16614 183 104 informacao informacao PROPN crl-16614 183 105 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 106 sociedade sociedade PROPN crl-16614 183 107 - - PUNCT crl-16614 183 108 estudos estudo NOUN crl-16614 183 109 15 15 NUM crl-16614 183 110 informacios informacio NOUN crl-16614 183 111 tarsadalom tarsadalom PROPN crl-16614 183 112 16 16 NUM crl-16614 183 113 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 114 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 115 culture culture PROPN crl-16614 183 116 17 17 NUM crl-16614 183 117 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 118 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 119 management management NOUN crl-16614 183 120 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 183 121 elsevier elsevi ADJ crl-16614 183 122 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 183 123 18 18 NUM crl-16614 183 124 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 125 and and CCONJ crl-16614 183 126 organization organization NOUN crl-16614 183 127 19 19 NUM crl-16614 183 128 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 129 development development NOUN crl-16614 183 130 20 20 NUM crl-16614 183 131 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 132 processing processing NOUN crl-16614 183 133 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 134 management management PROPN crl-16614 183 135 21 21 NUM crl-16614 183 136 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 137 research research NOUN crl-16614 183 138 : : PUNCT crl-16614 183 139 an an DET crl-16614 183 140 international international ADJ crl-16614 183 141 electronic electronic ADJ crl-16614 183 142 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 143 22 22 NUM crl-16614 183 144 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 145 society society NOUN crl-16614 183 146 23 23 NUM crl-16614 183 147 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 148 systems system NOUN crl-16614 183 149 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 150 24 24 NUM crl-16614 183 151 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 152 systems system NOUN crl-16614 183 153 research research VERB crl-16614 183 154 25 25 NUM crl-16614 183 155 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 156 technology technology NOUN crl-16614 183 157 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 158 people people NOUN crl-16614 183 159 26 26 NUM crl-16614 183 160 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 161 technology technology NOUN crl-16614 183 162 and and CCONJ crl-16614 183 163 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 183 164 27 27 NUM crl-16614 183 165 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 166 technology technology NOUN crl-16614 183 167 for for ADP crl-16614 183 168 development development NOUN crl-16614 183 169 28 28 NUM crl-16614 183 170 international international ADJ crl-16614 183 171 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 172 of of ADP crl-16614 183 173 computer computer NOUN crl-16614 183 174 - - PUNCT crl-16614 183 175 supported support VERB crl-16614 183 176 collaborative collaborative NOUN crl-16614 183 177 learning learn VERB crl-16614 183 178 29 29 NUM crl-16614 183 179 international international ADJ crl-16614 183 180 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 181 of of ADP crl-16614 183 182 geographical geographical ADJ crl-16614 183 183 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 184 science science NOUN crl-16614 183 185 30 30 NUM crl-16614 183 186 international international ADJ crl-16614 183 187 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 188 of of ADP crl-16614 183 189 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 190 management management NOUN crl-16614 183 191 31 31 NUM crl-16614 183 192 investigacion investigacion PROPN crl-16614 183 193 bibliotecologica bibliotecologica PROPN crl-16614 183 194 32 32 NUM crl-16614 183 195 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 196 of of ADP crl-16614 183 197 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 183 198 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-16614 183 199 33 33 NUM crl-16614 183 200 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 201 of of ADP crl-16614 183 202 computer computer NOUN crl-16614 183 203 - - PUNCT crl-16614 183 204 mediated mediate VERB crl-16614 183 205 communication communication NOUN crl-16614 183 206 34 34 NUM crl-16614 183 207 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 208 of of ADP crl-16614 183 209 documentation documentation NOUN crl-16614 183 210 format format NOUN crl-16614 183 211 aside aside ADV crl-16614 183 212 65 65 NUM crl-16614 183 213 35 35 NUM crl-16614 183 214 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 215 of of ADP crl-16614 183 216 global global ADJ crl-16614 183 217 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 218 management management NOUN crl-16614 183 219 36 36 NUM crl-16614 183 220 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 221 of of ADP crl-16614 183 222 global global ADJ crl-16614 183 223 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 224 technology technology NOUN crl-16614 183 225 management management NOUN crl-16614 183 226 37 37 NUM crl-16614 183 227 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 228 of of ADP crl-16614 183 229 health health NOUN crl-16614 183 230 communication communication NOUN crl-16614 183 231 38 38 NUM crl-16614 183 232 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 233 of of ADP crl-16614 183 234 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 235 science science NOUN crl-16614 183 236 39 39 NUM crl-16614 183 237 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 238 of of ADP crl-16614 183 239 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 240 technology technology NOUN crl-16614 183 241 40 40 NUM crl-16614 183 242 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 243 of of ADP crl-16614 183 244 informetrics informetrics PROPN crl-16614 183 245 41 41 NUM crl-16614 183 246 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 247 of of ADP crl-16614 183 248 knowledge knowledge PROPN crl-16614 183 249 management management PROPN crl-16614 183 250 42 42 NUM crl-16614 183 251 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 252 of of ADP crl-16614 183 253 librarianship librarianship NOUN crl-16614 183 254 and and CCONJ crl-16614 183 255 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 256 science science NOUN crl-16614 183 257 43 43 NUM crl-16614 183 258 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 259 of of ADP crl-16614 183 260 management management NOUN crl-16614 183 261 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 262 systems system NOUN crl-16614 183 263 44 44 NUM crl-16614 183 264 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 265 of of ADP crl-16614 183 266 organizational organizational ADJ crl-16614 183 267 and and CCONJ crl-16614 183 268 end end VERB crl-16614 183 269 user user NOUN crl-16614 183 270 computing compute VERB crl-16614 183 271 45 45 NUM crl-16614 183 272 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 273 of of ADP crl-16614 183 274 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 183 275 publishing publish VERB crl-16614 183 276 46 46 NUM crl-16614 183 277 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 278 of of ADP crl-16614 183 279 strategic strategic ADJ crl-16614 183 280 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 281 systems system NOUN crl-16614 183 282 47 47 NUM crl-16614 183 283 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 284 of of ADP crl-16614 183 285 the the DET crl-16614 183 286 american american PROPN crl-16614 183 287 medical medical PROPN crl-16614 183 288 informatics informatics PROPN crl-16614 183 289 association association PROPN crl-16614 183 290 48 48 NUM crl-16614 183 291 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 292 of of ADP crl-16614 183 293 the the DET crl-16614 183 294 association association NOUN crl-16614 183 295 for for ADP crl-16614 183 296 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 297 science science NOUN crl-16614 183 298 and and CCONJ crl-16614 183 299 technology technology NOUN crl-16614 183 300 49 49 NUM crl-16614 183 301 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 302 of of ADP crl-16614 183 303 the the DET crl-16614 183 304 association association NOUN crl-16614 183 305 for for ADP crl-16614 183 306 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 307 systems system NOUN crl-16614 183 308 50 50 NUM crl-16614 183 309 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 310 of of ADP crl-16614 183 311 the the DET crl-16614 183 312 medical medical PROPN crl-16614 183 313 library library PROPN crl-16614 183 314 association association PROPN crl-16614 183 315 51 51 NUM crl-16614 183 316 knowledge knowledge PROPN crl-16614 183 317 management management NOUN crl-16614 183 318 research research NOUN crl-16614 183 319 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 320 practice practice VERB crl-16614 183 321 52 52 NUM crl-16614 183 322 knowledge knowledge NOUN crl-16614 183 323 organization organization NOUN crl-16614 183 324 53 53 NUM crl-16614 183 325 law law NOUN crl-16614 183 326 library library NOUN crl-16614 183 327 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 183 328 54 54 NUM crl-16614 183 329 learned learn VERB crl-16614 183 330 publishing publish VERB crl-16614 183 331 55 55 NUM crl-16614 183 332 library library NOUN crl-16614 183 333 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 334 information information PROPN crl-16614 183 335 science science PROPN crl-16614 183 336 research research NOUN crl-16614 183 337 56 56 NUM crl-16614 183 338 library library NOUN crl-16614 183 339 collections collection NOUN crl-16614 183 340 acquisitions acquisition NOUN crl-16614 183 341 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 342 technical technical ADJ crl-16614 183 343 services service NOUN crl-16614 183 344 57 57 NUM crl-16614 183 345 library library NOUN crl-16614 183 346 hi hi INTJ crl-16614 183 347 tech tech PROPN crl-16614 183 348 58 58 NUM crl-16614 183 349 library library PROPN crl-16614 183 350 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 183 351 59 59 NUM crl-16614 183 352 library library NOUN crl-16614 183 353 quarterly quarterly ADJ crl-16614 183 354 60 60 NUM crl-16614 183 355 library library NOUN crl-16614 183 356 resources resource NOUN crl-16614 183 357 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 358 technical technical PROPN crl-16614 183 359 services service NOUN crl-16614 183 360 61 61 NUM crl-16614 183 361 library library NOUN crl-16614 183 362 trends trend NOUN crl-16614 183 363 62 62 NUM crl-16614 183 364 libri libri ADJ crl-16614 183 365 63 63 NUM crl-16614 183 366 malaysian malaysian ADJ crl-16614 183 367 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 183 368 of of ADP crl-16614 183 369 library library PROPN crl-16614 183 370 & & CCONJ crl-16614 183 371 information information NOUN crl-16614 183 372 science science NOUN crl-16614 184 1 64 64 NUM crl-16614 184 2 mis mis PROPN crl-16614 184 3 quarterly quarterly ADV crl-16614 184 4 65 65 NUM crl-16614 184 5 mis mis ADJ crl-16614 184 6 quarterly quarterly ADJ crl-16614 184 7 executive executive NOUN crl-16614 184 8 66 66 NUM crl-16614 184 9 online online ADJ crl-16614 184 10 information information NOUN crl-16614 184 11 review review NOUN crl-16614 184 12 67 67 NUM crl-16614 184 13 portal portal NOUN crl-16614 184 14 : : PUNCT crl-16614 184 15 libraries library NOUN crl-16614 184 16 and and CCONJ crl-16614 184 17 the the DET crl-16614 184 18 academy academy NOUN crl-16614 184 19 68 68 NUM crl-16614 184 20 profesional profesional ADJ crl-16614 184 21 de de X crl-16614 184 22 la la PROPN crl-16614 184 23 informacion informacion NOUN crl-16614 184 24 69 69 NUM crl-16614 184 25 program program NOUN crl-16614 184 26 - - PUNCT crl-16614 184 27 electronic electronic ADJ crl-16614 184 28 library library NOUN crl-16614 184 29 and and CCONJ crl-16614 184 30 information information NOUN crl-16614 184 31 systems system NOUN crl-16614 184 32 70 70 NUM crl-16614 184 33 reference reference NOUN crl-16614 184 34 & & CCONJ crl-16614 184 35 user user NOUN crl-16614 184 36 services service NOUN crl-16614 184 37 quarterly quarterly ADJ crl-16614 184 38 71 71 NUM crl-16614 184 39 research research NOUN crl-16614 184 40 evaluation evaluation NOUN crl-16614 184 41 66 66 NUM crl-16614 184 42 college college PROPN crl-16614 184 43 & & CCONJ crl-16614 184 44 research research PROPN crl-16614 184 45 libraries libraries AUX crl-16614 184 46 january january PROPN crl-16614 184 47 2018 2018 NUM crl-16614 184 48 72 72 NUM crl-16614 184 49 restaurator restaurator NOUN crl-16614 184 50 - - PUNCT crl-16614 184 51 international international ADJ crl-16614 184 52 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 184 53 for for ADP crl-16614 184 54 the the DET crl-16614 184 55 preservation preservation NOUN crl-16614 184 56 of of ADP crl-16614 184 57 library library NOUN crl-16614 184 58 and and CCONJ crl-16614 184 59 archival archival NOUN crl-16614 184 60 material material NOUN crl-16614 184 61 73 73 NUM crl-16614 184 62 revista revista PROPN crl-16614 184 63 espanola espanola PROPN crl-16614 184 64 de de PROPN crl-16614 184 65 documentacion documentacion NOUN crl-16614 184 66 cientifica cientifica PROPN crl-16614 184 67 74 74 NUM crl-16614 184 68 scientometrics scientometric NOUN crl-16614 184 69 75 75 NUM crl-16614 184 70 serials serial NOUN crl-16614 184 71 review review VERB crl-16614 184 72 76 76 NUM crl-16614 184 73 social social ADJ crl-16614 184 74 science science NOUN crl-16614 184 75 computer computer NOUN crl-16614 184 76 review review NOUN crl-16614 184 77 77 77 NUM crl-16614 184 78 social social ADJ crl-16614 184 79 science science NOUN crl-16614 184 80 information information NOUN crl-16614 184 81 sur sur PROPN crl-16614 184 82 les les PROPN crl-16614 184 83 sciences science NOUN crl-16614 184 84 sociales sociale VERB crl-16614 184 85 78 78 NUM crl-16614 184 86 telecommunications telecommunication NOUN crl-16614 184 87 policy policy NOUN crl-16614 184 88 79 79 NUM crl-16614 184 89 telematics telematic NOUN crl-16614 184 90 and and CCONJ crl-16614 184 91 informatics informatic NOUN crl-16614 184 92 80 80 NUM crl-16614 184 93 transinformacao transinformacao PROPN crl-16614 184 94 81 81 NUM crl-16614 184 95 zeitschrift zeitschrift NOUN crl-16614 184 96 fur fur NOUN crl-16614 184 97 bibliothekswesen bibliothekswesen NOUN crl-16614 184 98 und und NOUN crl-16614 184 99 bibliographie bibliographie NOUN crl-16614 184 100 note note NOUN crl-16614 184 101 : : PUNCT crl-16614 184 102 the the DET crl-16614 184 103 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 184 104 are be AUX crl-16614 184 105 listed list VERB crl-16614 184 106 in in ADP crl-16614 184 107 alphabetical alphabetical ADJ crl-16614 184 108 order order NOUN crl-16614 184 109 after after SCONJ crl-16614 184 110 six six NUM crl-16614 184 111 entries entry NOUN crl-16614 184 112 were be AUX crl-16614 184 113 removed remove VERB crl-16614 184 114 from from ADP crl-16614 184 115 the the DET crl-16614 184 116 study study NOUN crl-16614 184 117 due due ADP crl-16614 184 118 to to ADP crl-16614 184 119 duplication duplication NOUN crl-16614 184 120 , , PUNCT crl-16614 184 121 ceased cease VERB crl-16614 184 122 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 184 123 , , PUNCT crl-16614 184 124 or or CCONJ crl-16614 184 125 the the DET crl-16614 184 126 perception perception NOUN crl-16614 184 127 that that SCONJ crl-16614 184 128 the the DET crl-16614 184 129 entry entry NOUN crl-16614 184 130 did do AUX crl-16614 184 131 not not PART crl-16614 184 132 represent represent VERB crl-16614 184 133 a a DET crl-16614 184 134 peer peer NOUN crl-16614 184 135 - - PUNCT crl-16614 184 136 reviewed review VERB crl-16614 184 137 academic academic ADJ crl-16614 184 138 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 184 139 . . PUNCT crl-16614 185 1 notes note NOUN crl-16614 185 2 1 1 NUM crl-16614 185 3 . . X crl-16614 185 4 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 185 5 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 185 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 185 7 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 185 8 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 185 9 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 185 10 : : PUNCT crl-16614 185 11 overzealous overzealous ADJ crl-16614 185 12 open open ADJ crl-16614 185 13 - - PUNCT crl-16614 185 14 access access NOUN crl-16614 185 15 advocates advocate NOUN crl-16614 185 16 are be AUX crl-16614 185 17 creating create VERB crl-16614 185 18 an an DET crl-16614 185 19 exploitative exploitative ADJ crl-16614 185 20 environment environment NOUN crl-16614 185 21 , , PUNCT crl-16614 185 22 threatening threaten VERB crl-16614 185 23 the the DET crl-16614 185 24 credibility credibility NOUN crl-16614 185 25 of of ADP crl-16614 185 26 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 185 27 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 185 28 , , PUNCT crl-16614 185 29 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 185 30 the the DET crl-16614 185 31 scientist scientist NOUN crl-16614 185 32 26 26 NUM crl-16614 185 33 , , PUNCT crl-16614 185 34 no no INTJ crl-16614 185 35 . . NOUN crl-16614 185 36 8 8 NUM crl-16614 185 37 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 185 38 2012 2012 NUM crl-16614 185 39 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 185 40 , , PUNCT crl-16614 185 41 available available ADJ crl-16614 185 42 online online ADV crl-16614 185 43 at at ADP crl-16614 185 44 www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleno/32426/title/ www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleno/32426/title/ NOUN crl-16614 185 45 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 185 46 - - PUNCT crl-16614 185 47 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 185 48 [ [ PUNCT crl-16614 185 49 accessed access VERB crl-16614 185 50 1 1 NUM crl-16614 185 51 december december NOUN crl-16614 185 52 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 185 53 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 185 54 . . PUNCT crl-16614 186 1 for for ADP crl-16614 186 2 a a DET crl-16614 186 3 description description NOUN crl-16614 186 4 of of ADP crl-16614 186 5 the the DET crl-16614 186 6 degrees degree NOUN crl-16614 186 7 of of ADP crl-16614 186 8 oa oa PROPN crl-16614 186 9 , , PUNCT crl-16614 186 10 including include VERB crl-16614 186 11 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 186 12 gold gold NOUN crl-16614 186 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 186 14 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 186 15 see see VERB crl-16614 186 16 peter peter PROPN crl-16614 186 17 suber suber PROPN crl-16614 186 18 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 186 19 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 186 20 open open ADJ crl-16614 186 21 access access NOUN crl-16614 186 22 overview overview NOUN crl-16614 186 23 , , PUNCT crl-16614 186 24 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 186 25 available available ADJ crl-16614 186 26 online online ADV crl-16614 186 27 at at ADP crl-16614 186 28 http://legacy.earlham http://legacy.earlham PROPN crl-16614 186 29 . . PUNCT crl-16614 187 1 edu/~peters edu/~peter NOUN crl-16614 187 2 / / SYM crl-16614 187 3 fos fo VERB crl-16614 187 4 / / SYM crl-16614 187 5 overview.htm overview.htm INTJ crl-16614 188 1 [ [ X crl-16614 188 2 accessed access VERB crl-16614 188 3 1 1 NUM crl-16614 188 4 december december NOUN crl-16614 188 5 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 188 6 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 188 7 . . PUNCT crl-16614 189 1 2 2 X crl-16614 189 2 . . X crl-16614 189 3 martin martin PROPN crl-16614 189 4 s. s. PROPN crl-16614 189 5 fiebert fiebert PROPN crl-16614 189 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 189 7 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 189 8 a a DET crl-16614 189 9 look look NOUN crl-16614 189 10 at at ADP crl-16614 189 11 open open ADJ crl-16614 189 12 access access NOUN crl-16614 189 13 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 189 14 and and CCONJ crl-16614 189 15 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 189 16 ’s ’s NOUN crl-16614 189 17 list list NOUN crl-16614 189 18 of of ADP crl-16614 189 19 ‘ ' PUNCT crl-16614 189 20 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 189 21 ’ ' PUNCT crl-16614 189 22 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 189 23 , , PUNCT crl-16614 189 24 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 189 25 global global ADJ crl-16614 189 26 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 189 27 of of ADP crl-16614 189 28 interdisciplinary interdisciplinary PROPN crl-16614 189 29 social social ADJ crl-16614 189 30 sciences science NOUN crl-16614 189 31 3 3 NUM crl-16614 189 32 , , PUNCT crl-16614 189 33 no no NOUN crl-16614 189 34 . . NOUN crl-16614 189 35 4 4 NUM crl-16614 189 36 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 189 37 2014 2014 NUM crl-16614 189 38 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 189 39 5–6 5–6 NUM crl-16614 189 40 . . PROPN crl-16614 189 41 3 3 X crl-16614 189 42 . . X crl-16614 190 1 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 190 2 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 190 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 190 4 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 190 5 list list NOUN crl-16614 190 6 of of ADP crl-16614 190 7 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 190 8 , , PUNCT crl-16614 190 9 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 190 10 previously previously ADV crl-16614 190 11 available available ADJ crl-16614 190 12 online online ADV crl-16614 190 13 but but CCONJ crl-16614 190 14 has have AUX crl-16614 190 15 since since SCONJ crl-16614 190 16 been be AUX crl-16614 190 17 removed remove VERB crl-16614 190 18 . . PUNCT crl-16614 191 1 see see VERB crl-16614 191 2 https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-list-predatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politics https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-list-predatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politics PROPN crl-16614 191 3 [ [ X crl-16614 191 4 accessed access VERB crl-16614 191 5 11 11 NUM crl-16614 191 6 december december PROPN crl-16614 191 7 2017 2017 NUM crl-16614 191 8 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 191 9 . . PUNCT crl-16614 192 1 4 4 X crl-16614 192 2 . . X crl-16614 192 3 diane diane NOUN crl-16614 192 4 harley harley PROPN crl-16614 192 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 192 6 sophia sophia PROPN crl-16614 192 7 krzys krzys PROPN crl-16614 192 8 acord acord PROPN crl-16614 192 9 , , PUNCT crl-16614 192 10 sarah sarah PROPN crl-16614 192 11 earl earl PROPN crl-16614 192 12 - - PUNCT crl-16614 192 13 novell novell PROPN crl-16614 192 14 , , PUNCT crl-16614 192 15 shannon shannon PROPN crl-16614 192 16 lawrence lawrence PROPN crl-16614 192 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 192 18 and and CCONJ crl-16614 192 19 c. c. PROPN crl-16614 192 20 judson judson PROPN crl-16614 192 21 king king PROPN crl-16614 192 22 , , PUNCT crl-16614 192 23 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 192 24 assessing assess VERB crl-16614 192 25 the the DET crl-16614 192 26 future future ADJ crl-16614 192 27 landscape landscape NOUN crl-16614 192 28 of of ADP crl-16614 192 29 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 192 30 communication communication NOUN crl-16614 192 31 : : PUNCT crl-16614 192 32 an an DET crl-16614 192 33 exploration exploration NOUN crl-16614 192 34 of of ADP crl-16614 192 35 faculty faculty NOUN crl-16614 192 36 values value NOUN crl-16614 192 37 and and CCONJ crl-16614 192 38 needs need NOUN crl-16614 192 39 in in ADP crl-16614 192 40 seven seven NUM crl-16614 192 41 disciplines discipline NOUN crl-16614 192 42 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 192 43 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 192 44 uc uc PROPN crl-16614 192 45 berkeley berkeley NOUN crl-16614 192 46 : : PUNCT crl-16614 192 47 center center NOUN crl-16614 192 48 for for ADP crl-16614 192 49 studies study NOUN crl-16614 192 50 in in ADP crl-16614 192 51 higher high ADJ crl-16614 192 52 education education NOUN crl-16614 192 53 , , PUNCT crl-16614 192 54 2010 2010 NUM crl-16614 192 55 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 192 56 , , PUNCT crl-16614 192 57 available available ADJ crl-16614 192 58 online online ADV crl-16614 192 59 at at ADP crl-16614 192 60 https://escholarship.org/uc/item/15x7385 https://escholarship.org/uc/item/15x7385 NOUN crl-16614 193 1 g g PROPN crl-16614 193 2 [ [ X crl-16614 193 3 accessed access VERB crl-16614 193 4 1 1 NUM crl-16614 193 5 december december NOUN crl-16614 193 6 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 193 7 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 193 8 . . PUNCT crl-16614 194 1 5 5 X crl-16614 194 2 . . X crl-16614 194 3 peter peter PROPN crl-16614 194 4 suber suber PROPN crl-16614 194 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 194 6 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 194 7 open open ADJ crl-16614 194 8 access access NOUN crl-16614 194 9 overview overview NOUN crl-16614 194 10 , , PUNCT crl-16614 194 11 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 194 12 available available ADJ crl-16614 194 13 online online ADV crl-16614 194 14 at at ADP crl-16614 194 15 http://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/ http://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/ NOUN crl-16614 194 16 fos fos ADV crl-16614 194 17 / / SYM crl-16614 194 18 overview.htm overview.htm INTJ crl-16614 195 1 [ [ X crl-16614 195 2 accessed access VERB crl-16614 195 3 24 24 NUM crl-16614 195 4 january january PROPN crl-16614 195 5 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 195 6 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 195 7 . . PUNCT crl-16614 196 1 6 6 X crl-16614 196 2 . . X crl-16614 196 3 charlotte charlotte PROPN crl-16614 196 4 haug haug PROPN crl-16614 196 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 196 6 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 196 7 the the DET crl-16614 196 8 downside downside NOUN crl-16614 196 9 of of ADP crl-16614 196 10 open open ADJ crl-16614 196 11 - - PUNCT crl-16614 196 12 access access NOUN crl-16614 196 13 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 196 14 , , PUNCT crl-16614 196 15 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 196 16 new new PROPN crl-16614 196 17 england england PROPN crl-16614 196 18 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 196 19 of of ADP crl-16614 196 20 medicine medicine PROPN crl-16614 196 21 368 368 NUM crl-16614 196 22 , , PUNCT crl-16614 196 23 no no NOUN crl-16614 196 24 . . NOUN crl-16614 196 25 9 9 NUM crl-16614 196 26 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 196 27 2013 2013 NUM crl-16614 196 28 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 196 29 791–93 791–93 NUM crl-16614 196 30 , , PUNCT crl-16614 196 31 doi:10.1056 doi:10.1056 PROPN crl-16614 196 32 / / SYM crl-16614 196 33 nejmp1214750 nejmp1214750 PROPN crl-16614 196 34 . . PROPN crl-16614 197 1 7 7 NUM crl-16614 197 2 . . X crl-16614 197 3 sally sally PROPN crl-16614 197 4 morris morris PROPN crl-16614 197 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 197 6 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 197 7 the the DET crl-16614 197 8 true true ADJ crl-16614 197 9 costs cost NOUN crl-16614 197 10 of of ADP crl-16614 197 11 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 197 12 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 197 13 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 197 14 , , PUNCT crl-16614 197 15 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 197 16 learned learn VERB crl-16614 197 17 publishing publish VERB crl-16614 197 18 18 18 NUM crl-16614 197 19 , , PUNCT crl-16614 197 20 no no NOUN crl-16614 197 21 . . NOUN crl-16614 197 22 2 2 NUM crl-16614 197 23 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 197 24 2005 2005 NUM crl-16614 197 25 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 197 26 115–26 115–26 NUM crl-16614 197 27 . . PUNCT crl-16614 198 1 8 8 X crl-16614 198 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 198 3 cenyu cenyu PROPN crl-16614 198 4 shen shen PROPN crl-16614 198 5 and and CCONJ crl-16614 198 6 bo bo ADJ crl-16614 198 7 - - PUNCT crl-16614 198 8 christer christer NOUN crl-16614 198 9 björk björk NOUN crl-16614 198 10 , , PUNCT crl-16614 198 11 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 198 12 ‘ ' PUNCT crl-16614 198 13 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 198 14 ’ ' PUNCT crl-16614 198 15 open open ADJ crl-16614 198 16 access access NOUN crl-16614 198 17 : : PUNCT crl-16614 198 18 a a DET crl-16614 198 19 longitudinal longitudinal ADJ crl-16614 198 20 study study NOUN crl-16614 198 21 of of ADP crl-16614 198 22 article article NOUN crl-16614 198 23 volumes volume NOUN crl-16614 198 24 and and CCONJ crl-16614 198 25 market market NOUN crl-16614 198 26 characteristics characteristic NOUN crl-16614 198 27 , , PUNCT crl-16614 198 28 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 198 29 bmc bmc ADJ crl-16614 198 30 medicine medicine NOUN crl-16614 198 31 13 13 NUM crl-16614 198 32 , , PUNCT crl-16614 198 33 no no INTJ crl-16614 198 34 . . NOUN crl-16614 198 35 1 1 NUM crl-16614 198 36 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 198 37 2015 2015 NUM crl-16614 198 38 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 198 39 1 1 NUM crl-16614 198 40 , , PUNCT crl-16614 198 41 doi:10.1186 doi:10.1186 PROPN crl-16614 198 42 / / SYM crl-16614 198 43 s12916015 s12916015 PROPN crl-16614 198 44 - - PUNCT crl-16614 198 45 0469 0469 NUM crl-16614 198 46 - - SYM crl-16614 198 47 2 2 NUM crl-16614 198 48 . . NUM crl-16614 198 49 9 9 NUM crl-16614 198 50 . . PROPN crl-16614 198 51 alma alma PROPN crl-16614 198 52 swan swan PROPN crl-16614 198 53 and and CCONJ crl-16614 198 54 sheridan sheridan PROPN crl-16614 198 55 brown brown PROPN crl-16614 198 56 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 198 57 key key ADJ crl-16614 198 58 perspectives perspective NOUN crl-16614 198 59 , , PUNCT crl-16614 198 60 ltd ltd PROPN crl-16614 198 61 . . PROPN crl-16614 198 62 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 198 63 , , PUNCT crl-16614 198 64 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 198 65 joint joint ADJ crl-16614 198 66 information information NOUN crl-16614 198 67 systems systems PROPN crl-16614 198 68 committee committee PROPN crl-16614 198 69 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 198 70 jisc jisc PROPN crl-16614 198 71 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 198 72 and and CCONJ crl-16614 198 73 the the DET crl-16614 198 74 open open PROPN crl-16614 198 75 society society PROPN crl-16614 198 76 institute institute PROPN crl-16614 198 77 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 198 78 osi osi PROPN crl-16614 198 79 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 198 80 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 198 81 authors author NOUN crl-16614 198 82 survey survey VERB crl-16614 198 83 report report NOUN crl-16614 198 84 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 198 85 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 198 86 2004 2004 NUM crl-16614 198 87 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 198 88 , , PUNCT crl-16614 198 89 available available ADJ crl-16614 198 90 online online ADV crl-16614 198 91 at at ADP crl-16614 198 92 www.jisc.ac.uk/media/documents/themes/infoenvironment/acf655.pdf www.jisc.ac.uk/media/documents/themes/infoenvironment/acf655.pdf PROPN crl-16614 198 93 [ [ X crl-16614 198 94 accessed access VERB crl-16614 198 95 1 1 NUM crl-16614 198 96 december december NOUN crl-16614 198 97 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 198 98 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 198 99 . . PUNCT crl-16614 199 1 10 10 NUM crl-16614 199 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 200 1 bryna bryna NOUN crl-16614 200 2 coonin coonin PROPN crl-16614 200 3 and and CCONJ crl-16614 200 4 leigh leigh ADJ crl-16614 200 5 younce younce NOUN crl-16614 200 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 200 7 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 200 8 publishing publish VERB crl-16614 200 9 in in ADP crl-16614 200 10 open open ADJ crl-16614 200 11 access access NOUN crl-16614 200 12 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 200 13 in in ADP crl-16614 200 14 the the DET crl-16614 200 15 social social ADJ crl-16614 200 16 sciences science NOUN crl-16614 200 17 and and CCONJ crl-16614 200 18 humanities humanity NOUN crl-16614 200 19 : : PUNCT crl-16614 200 20 who who PRON crl-16614 200 21 ’s ’s AUX crl-16614 200 22 doing do VERB crl-16614 200 23 it it PRON crl-16614 200 24 and and CCONJ crl-16614 200 25 why why SCONJ crl-16614 200 26 ? ? PUNCT crl-16614 200 27 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 201 1 in in ADP crl-16614 201 2 pushing push VERB crl-16614 201 3 the the DET crl-16614 201 4 edge edge NOUN crl-16614 201 5 : : PUNCT crl-16614 201 6 proceedings proceeding NOUN crl-16614 201 7 of of ADP crl-16614 201 8 the the DET crl-16614 201 9 fourteenth fourteenth ADJ crl-16614 201 10 annual annual ADJ crl-16614 201 11 meeting meeting NOUN crl-16614 201 12 of of ADP crl-16614 201 13 the the DET crl-16614 201 14 association association NOUN crl-16614 201 15 of of ADP crl-16614 201 16 college college NOUN crl-16614 201 17 and and CCONJ crl-16614 201 18 research research NOUN crl-16614 201 19 libraries library NOUN crl-16614 201 20 , , PUNCT crl-16614 201 21 march march PROPN crl-16614 201 22 12 12 NUM crl-16614 201 23 - - SYM crl-16614 201 24 15 15 NUM crl-16614 201 25 , , PUNCT crl-16614 201 26 ed ed PROPN crl-16614 201 27 . . PROPN crl-16614 201 28 dawn dawn PROPN crl-16614 201 29 mueller mueller NOUN crl-16614 201 30 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 201 31 chicago chicago PROPN crl-16614 201 32 : : PUNCT crl-16614 201 33 american american PROPN crl-16614 201 34 library library PROPN crl-16614 201 35 association association PROPN crl-16614 201 36 , , PUNCT crl-16614 201 37 2009 2009 NUM crl-16614 201 38 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 201 39 , , PUNCT crl-16614 201 40 85 85 NUM crl-16614 201 41 - - SYM crl-16614 201 42 94 94 NUM crl-16614 201 43 . . NUM crl-16614 201 44 11 11 NUM crl-16614 201 45 . . PUNCT crl-16614 202 1 john john PROPN crl-16614 202 2 bohannon bohannon PROPN crl-16614 202 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 202 4 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 202 5 who who PRON crl-16614 202 6 ’s ’ VERB crl-16614 202 7 afraid afraid ADJ crl-16614 202 8 of of ADP crl-16614 202 9 peer peer NOUN crl-16614 202 10 review review NOUN crl-16614 202 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 202 12 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 202 13 science science NOUN crl-16614 202 14 342 342 NUM crl-16614 202 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 202 16 no no NOUN crl-16614 202 17 . . NOUN crl-16614 202 18 6154 6154 NUM crl-16614 202 19 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 202 20 2013 2013 NUM crl-16614 202 21 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 202 22 60 60 NUM crl-16614 202 23 - - SYM crl-16614 202 24 65 65 NUM crl-16614 202 25 . . NUM crl-16614 202 26 12 12 NUM crl-16614 202 27 . . PUNCT crl-16614 203 1 phil phil PROPN crl-16614 203 2 davis davis PROPN crl-16614 203 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 203 4 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 203 5 post post VERB crl-16614 203 6 open open ADJ crl-16614 203 7 access access NOUN crl-16614 203 8 sting sting NOUN crl-16614 203 9 : : PUNCT crl-16614 203 10 an an DET crl-16614 203 11 interview interview NOUN crl-16614 203 12 with with ADP crl-16614 203 13 john john PROPN crl-16614 203 14 bohannon bohannon PROPN crl-16614 203 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 203 16 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 203 17 the the DET crl-16614 203 18 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 203 19 kitchen kitchen NOUN crl-16614 203 20 , , PUNCT crl-16614 203 21 available available ADJ crl-16614 203 22 online online ADV crl-16614 203 23 at at ADP crl-16614 203 24 http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2013/11/12/post-open-access-stingan-interview-with-john-bohannon/ http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2013/11/12/post-open-access-stingan-interview-with-john-bohannon/ PROPN crl-16614 204 1 [ [ X crl-16614 204 2 accessed access VERB crl-16614 204 3 25 25 NUM crl-16614 204 4 january january NOUN crl-16614 204 5 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 204 6 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 204 7 . . PUNCT crl-16614 205 1 13 13 NUM crl-16614 205 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 205 3 ibid ibid VERB crl-16614 205 4 . . PUNCT crl-16614 206 1 http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleno/32426/title/predatory-publishing http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleno/32426/title/predatory-publishe VERB crl-16614 206 2 http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleno/32426/title/predatory-publishing http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleno/32426/title/predatory-publishing NOUN crl-16614 206 3 http://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/overview.htm http://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/overview.htm SPACE crl-16614 206 4 http://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/overview.htm http://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/overview.htm PUNCT crl-16614 206 5 https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-list-predatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politics https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-list-predatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politics PROPN crl-16614 206 6 https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-list-predatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politics https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-list-predatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politics PROPN crl-16614 206 7 https://escholarship.org/uc/item/15x7385 https://escholarship.org/uc/item/15x7385 NOUN crl-16614 206 8 g g NOUN crl-16614 206 9 http://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/overview.htm http://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/overview.htm PUNCT crl-16614 206 10 http://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/overview.htm http://legacy.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/overview.htm X crl-16614 206 11 https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmp1214750 https://doi.org/10.1056/nejmp1214750 NOUN crl-16614 206 12 http://www.jisc.ac.uk/media/documents/themes/infoenvironment/acf655.pdf http://www.jisc.ac.uk/media/documents/themes/infoenvironment/acf655.pdf X crl-16614 206 13 http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2013/11/12/post-open-access-sting-an-interview-with-john-bohannon http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2013/11/12/post-open-access-sting-an-interview-with-john-bohannon NOUN crl-16614 206 14 http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2013/11/12/post-open-access-sting-an-interview-with-john-bohannon http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2013/11/12/post-open-access-sting-an-interview-with-john-bohannon NOUN crl-16614 206 15 format format NOUN crl-16614 206 16 aside aside ADV crl-16614 206 17 67 67 NUM crl-16614 206 18 14 14 NUM crl-16614 206 19 . . PUNCT crl-16614 207 1 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 207 2 doaj doaj PROPN crl-16614 207 3 news news PROPN crl-16614 207 4 service service PROPN crl-16614 207 5 : : PUNCT crl-16614 207 6 news news NOUN crl-16614 207 7 , , PUNCT crl-16614 207 8 updates update NOUN crl-16614 207 9 & & CCONJ crl-16614 207 10 developments development NOUN crl-16614 207 11 from from ADP crl-16614 207 12 doaj doaj NOUN crl-16614 207 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 207 14 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 207 15 available available ADJ crl-16614 207 16 online online ADV crl-16614 207 17 at at ADP crl-16614 207 18 https://blog.doaj.org/ https://blog.doaj.org/ INTJ crl-16614 208 1 [ [ X crl-16614 208 2 accessed access VERB crl-16614 208 3 11 11 NUM crl-16614 208 4 december december PROPN crl-16614 208 5 2017 2017 NUM crl-16614 208 6 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 208 7 . . PUNCT crl-16614 209 1 15 15 NUM crl-16614 209 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 210 1 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 210 2 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 210 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 210 4 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 210 5 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 210 6 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 210 7 are be AUX crl-16614 210 8 corrupting corrupt VERB crl-16614 210 9 open open ADJ crl-16614 210 10 access access NOUN crl-16614 210 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 210 12 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 210 13 nature nature NOUN crl-16614 210 14 489 489 NUM crl-16614 210 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 210 16 no no INTJ crl-16614 210 17 . . NOUN crl-16614 210 18 7415 7415 NUM crl-16614 210 19 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 210 20 2012 2012 NUM crl-16614 210 21 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 210 22 179 179 NUM crl-16614 210 23 , , PUNCT crl-16614 210 24 doi:10.1038/489179a doi:10.1038/489179a NUM crl-16614 210 25 . . PUNCT crl-16614 211 1 16 16 NUM crl-16614 211 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 212 1 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 212 2 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 212 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 212 4 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 212 5 scholarly scholarly ADV crl-16614 212 6 open open ADJ crl-16614 212 7 access access NOUN crl-16614 212 8 , , PUNCT crl-16614 212 9 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 212 10 available available ADJ crl-16614 212 11 online online ADV crl-16614 212 12 at at ADP crl-16614 212 13 http://scholarlyoa.com http://scholarlyoa.com X crl-16614 212 14 [ [ X crl-16614 212 15 accessed access VERB crl-16614 212 16 25 25 NUM crl-16614 212 17 january january NOUN crl-16614 212 18 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 212 19 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 212 20 . . PUNCT crl-16614 213 1 17 17 NUM crl-16614 213 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 214 1 rita rita PROPN crl-16614 214 2 pickler pickler PROPN crl-16614 214 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 214 4 jane jane PROPN crl-16614 214 5 noyes noyes PROPN crl-16614 214 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 214 7 lin lin PROPN crl-16614 214 8 perry perry PROPN crl-16614 214 9 , , PUNCT crl-16614 214 10 brenda brenda PROPN crl-16614 214 11 roe roe PROPN crl-16614 214 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 214 13 roger roger PROPN crl-16614 214 14 watson watson PROPN crl-16614 214 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 214 16 and and CCONJ crl-16614 214 17 mark mark VERB crl-16614 214 18 hayter hayter PROPN crl-16614 214 19 , , PUNCT crl-16614 214 20 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 214 21 authors author NOUN crl-16614 214 22 and and CCONJ crl-16614 214 23 readers reader NOUN crl-16614 214 24 beware beware VERB crl-16614 214 25 the the DET crl-16614 214 26 dark dark ADJ crl-16614 214 27 side side NOUN crl-16614 214 28 of of ADP crl-16614 214 29 open open ADJ crl-16614 214 30 access access NOUN crl-16614 214 31 , , PUNCT crl-16614 214 32 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 214 33 journal journal NOUN crl-16614 214 34 of of ADP crl-16614 214 35 advanced advanced ADJ crl-16614 214 36 nursing nursing NOUN crl-16614 214 37 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 214 38 2014 2014 NUM crl-16614 214 39 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 214 40 , , PUNCT crl-16614 214 41 doi:10.1111/ doi:10.1111/ PROPN crl-16614 214 42 jan.12589 jan.12589 PROPN crl-16614 214 43 . . PROPN crl-16614 215 1 18 18 NUM crl-16614 215 2 . . X crl-16614 215 3 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 215 4 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 215 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 215 6 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 215 7 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 215 8 ’s ’s NOUN crl-16614 215 9 list list NOUN crl-16614 215 10 of of ADP crl-16614 215 11 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 215 12 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 215 13 2015 2015 NUM crl-16614 215 14 , , PUNCT crl-16614 215 15 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 215 16 previously previously ADV crl-16614 215 17 available available ADJ crl-16614 215 18 online online ADV crl-16614 215 19 but but CCONJ crl-16614 215 20 has have AUX crl-16614 215 21 since since SCONJ crl-16614 215 22 been be AUX crl-16614 215 23 removed remove VERB crl-16614 215 24 . . PUNCT crl-16614 216 1 see see VERB crl-16614 216 2 https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-listpredatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politics https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-listpredatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politic NOUN crl-16614 216 3 [ [ X crl-16614 216 4 accessed access VERB crl-16614 216 5 11 11 NUM crl-16614 216 6 december december PROPN crl-16614 216 7 2017 2017 NUM crl-16614 216 8 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 216 9 . . PUNCT crl-16614 217 1 19 19 NUM crl-16614 217 2 . . X crl-16614 217 3 ibid ibid VERB crl-16614 217 4 . . PUNCT crl-16614 218 1 20 20 NUM crl-16614 218 2 . . X crl-16614 218 3 committee committee NOUN crl-16614 218 4 on on ADP crl-16614 218 5 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 218 6 ethics ethic NOUN crl-16614 218 7 , , PUNCT crl-16614 218 8 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 218 9 principles principle NOUN crl-16614 218 10 of of ADP crl-16614 218 11 transparency transparency NOUN crl-16614 218 12 and and CCONJ crl-16614 218 13 best good ADJ crl-16614 218 14 practice practice NOUN crl-16614 218 15 in in ADP crl-16614 218 16 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 218 17 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 218 18 , , PUNCT crl-16614 218 19 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 218 20 available available ADJ crl-16614 218 21 online online ADV crl-16614 218 22 at at ADP crl-16614 218 23 http://publicationethics.org/files/principles%20of%20transparency%20and%20best%20practice%20in%20scholarly%20publishing.pdf http://publicationethics.org/files/principles%20of%20transparency%20and%20best%20practice%20in%20scholarly%20publishing.pdf PROPN crl-16614 219 1 [ [ X crl-16614 219 2 accessed access VERB crl-16614 219 3 22 22 NUM crl-16614 219 4 january january NOUN crl-16614 219 5 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 219 6 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 219 7 and and CCONJ crl-16614 219 8 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 219 9 code code NOUN crl-16614 219 10 of of ADP crl-16614 219 11 conduct conduct NOUN crl-16614 219 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 219 13 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 219 14 code code NOUN crl-16614 219 15 of of ADP crl-16614 219 16 conduct conduct NOUN crl-16614 219 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 219 18 available available ADJ crl-16614 219 19 online online ADV crl-16614 219 20 at at ADP crl-16614 219 21 http://publicationethics.org/ http://publicationethics.org/ NOUN crl-16614 219 22 files file NOUN crl-16614 219 23 / / PUNCT crl-16614 219 24 code%20of%20conduct%20for%20publishers%20final_1_0_0.pdf code%20of%20conduct%20for%20publishers%20final_1_0_0.pdf NOUN crl-16614 220 1 [ [ PUNCT crl-16614 220 2 accessed access VERB crl-16614 220 3 22 22 NUM crl-16614 220 4 january january PROPN crl-16614 220 5 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 220 6 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 220 7 . . PUNCT crl-16614 221 1 21 21 NUM crl-16614 221 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 222 1 committee committee NOUN crl-16614 222 2 on on ADP crl-16614 222 3 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 222 4 ethics ethic NOUN crl-16614 222 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 222 6 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 222 7 principles principle NOUN crl-16614 222 8 of of ADP crl-16614 222 9 transparency transparency NOUN crl-16614 222 10 and and CCONJ crl-16614 222 11 best good ADJ crl-16614 222 12 practice practice NOUN crl-16614 222 13 in in ADP crl-16614 222 14 scholarly scholarly ADJ crl-16614 222 15 publishing publishing NOUN crl-16614 222 16 . . PUNCT crl-16614 222 17 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 223 1 22 22 NUM crl-16614 223 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 223 3 committee committee NOUN crl-16614 223 4 on on ADP crl-16614 223 5 publication publication NOUN crl-16614 223 6 ethics ethic NOUN crl-16614 223 7 , , PUNCT crl-16614 223 8 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 223 9 about about ADV crl-16614 223 10 cope cope VERB crl-16614 223 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 223 12 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 223 13 available available ADJ crl-16614 223 14 online online ADV crl-16614 223 15 at at ADP crl-16614 223 16 http://publicationethics.org/about http://publicationethics.org/about NOUN crl-16614 224 1 [ [ X crl-16614 224 2 accessed access VERB crl-16614 224 3 22 22 NUM crl-16614 224 4 january january PROPN crl-16614 224 5 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 224 6 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 224 7 . . PUNCT crl-16614 225 1 23 23 NUM crl-16614 225 2 . . X crl-16614 225 3 ibid ibid VERB crl-16614 225 4 . . PUNCT crl-16614 226 1 24 24 NUM crl-16614 226 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 226 3 shen shen PROPN crl-16614 226 4 and and CCONJ crl-16614 226 5 björk björk NOUN crl-16614 226 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 226 7 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 226 8 ‘ ' PUNCT crl-16614 226 9 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 226 10 ’ ' PUNCT crl-16614 226 11 open open ADJ crl-16614 226 12 access access NOUN crl-16614 226 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 226 14 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 226 15 1 1 X crl-16614 226 16 . . NUM crl-16614 226 17 25 25 NUM crl-16614 226 18 . . PUNCT crl-16614 226 19 ibid ibid VERB crl-16614 226 20 , , PUNCT crl-16614 226 21 28–31 28–31 NUM crl-16614 226 22 . . PUNCT crl-16614 226 23 26 26 NUM crl-16614 226 24 . . PUNCT crl-16614 227 1 walt walt PROPN crl-16614 227 2 crawford crawford PROPN crl-16614 227 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 227 4 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 227 5 ethics ethic NOUN crl-16614 227 6 and and CCONJ crl-16614 227 7 access access NOUN crl-16614 227 8 1 1 NUM crl-16614 227 9 : : PUNCT crl-16614 227 10 the the DET crl-16614 227 11 sad sad ADJ crl-16614 227 12 case case NOUN crl-16614 227 13 of of ADP crl-16614 227 14 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 227 15 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 227 16 , , PUNCT crl-16614 227 17 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 227 18 cites cite VERB crl-16614 227 19 & & CCONJ crl-16614 227 20 insights insight NOUN crl-16614 227 21 14 14 NUM crl-16614 227 22 , , PUNCT crl-16614 227 23 no no NOUN crl-16614 227 24 . . NOUN crl-16614 227 25 4 4 NUM crl-16614 227 26 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 227 27 2014 2014 NUM crl-16614 227 28 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 227 29 1–14 1–14 NUM crl-16614 227 30 ; ; PUNCT crl-16614 227 31 monica monica PROPN crl-16614 227 32 berger berger PROPN crl-16614 227 33 and and CCONJ crl-16614 227 34 jill jill PROPN crl-16614 227 35 cirasella cirasella NOUN crl-16614 227 36 , , PUNCT crl-16614 227 37 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 227 38 beyond beyond ADP crl-16614 227 39 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 227 40 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 227 41 list list NOUN crl-16614 227 42 : : PUNCT crl-16614 227 43 better well ADV crl-16614 227 44 understanding understand VERB crl-16614 227 45 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 227 46 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 227 47 , , PUNCT crl-16614 227 48 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 227 49 college college PROPN crl-16614 227 50 & & CCONJ crl-16614 227 51 research research PROPN crl-16614 227 52 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 227 53 news news NOUN crl-16614 227 54 76 76 NUM crl-16614 227 55 , , PUNCT crl-16614 227 56 no no NOUN crl-16614 227 57 . . NOUN crl-16614 227 58 3 3 NUM crl-16614 227 59 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 227 60 2015 2015 NUM crl-16614 227 61 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 227 62 132–35 132–35 NUM crl-16614 227 63 . . PUNCT crl-16614 228 1 27 27 NUM crl-16614 228 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 229 1 nerissa nerissa PROPN crl-16614 229 2 nelson nelson PROPN crl-16614 229 3 and and CCONJ crl-16614 229 4 jennifer jennifer PROPN crl-16614 229 5 huffman huffman PROPN crl-16614 229 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 229 7 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 229 8 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 229 9 journals journal NOUN crl-16614 229 10 in in ADP crl-16614 229 11 library library NOUN crl-16614 229 12 databases database VERB crl-16614 229 13 : : PUNCT crl-16614 229 14 how how SCONJ crl-16614 229 15 much much ADJ crl-16614 229 16 should should AUX crl-16614 229 17 we we PRON crl-16614 229 18 worry worry VERB crl-16614 229 19 ? ? PUNCT crl-16614 229 20 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 229 21 serials serial NOUN crl-16614 229 22 librarian librarian PROPN crl-16614 229 23 69 69 NUM crl-16614 229 24 , , PUNCT crl-16614 229 25 no no NOUN crl-16614 229 26 . . NOUN crl-16614 229 27 2 2 NUM crl-16614 229 28 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 229 29 2015 2015 NUM crl-16614 229 30 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 229 31 169–92 169–92 NUM crl-16614 229 32 , , PUNCT crl-16614 229 33 doi:10.1080/036152 doi:10.1080/036152 PROPN crl-16614 229 34 6x.2015.1080782 6x.2015.1080782 NUM crl-16614 229 35 . . PUNCT crl-16614 230 1 28 28 X crl-16614 230 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 231 1 james james PROPN crl-16614 231 2 testa testa PROPN crl-16614 231 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 231 4 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 231 5 the the DET crl-16614 231 6 thomson thomson PROPN crl-16614 231 7 reuters reuters PROPN crl-16614 231 8 journal journal PROPN crl-16614 231 9 selection selection NOUN crl-16614 231 10 process process NOUN crl-16614 231 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 231 12 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 231 13 available available ADJ crl-16614 231 14 online online ADV crl-16614 231 15 at at ADP crl-16614 231 16 http:// http:// NOUN crl-16614 231 17 wokinfo.com/essays/journal-selection-process/ wokinfo.com/essays/journal-selection-process/ NOUN crl-16614 231 18 [ [ PUNCT crl-16614 231 19 accessed access VERB crl-16614 231 20 10 10 NUM crl-16614 231 21 february february NOUN crl-16614 231 22 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 231 23 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 231 24 . . PUNCT crl-16614 232 1 29 29 NUM crl-16614 232 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 233 1 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 233 2 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 233 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 233 4 criteria criterion NOUN crl-16614 233 5 for for ADP crl-16614 233 6 determining determine VERB crl-16614 233 7 predatory predatory ADJ crl-16614 233 8 open open ADJ crl-16614 233 9 - - PUNCT crl-16614 233 10 access access NOUN crl-16614 233 11 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 233 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 233 13 3rd 3rd NOUN crl-16614 233 14 ed ed NOUN crl-16614 233 15 . . PUNCT crl-16614 234 1 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 234 2 2015 2015 NUM crl-16614 234 3 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 234 4 , , PUNCT crl-16614 234 5 available available ADJ crl-16614 234 6 online online ADV crl-16614 234 7 at at ADP crl-16614 234 8 https://scholarlyoa.files.wordpress.com/2012/11/criteria-2012-2.pdf https://scholarlyoa.files.wordpress.com/2012/11/criteria-2012-2.pdf PROPN crl-16614 234 9 [ [ X crl-16614 234 10 accessed access VERB crl-16614 234 11 1 1 NUM crl-16614 234 12 december december NOUN crl-16614 234 13 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 234 14 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 234 15 . . PUNCT crl-16614 235 1 30 30 NUM crl-16614 235 2 . . X crl-16614 235 3 roger roger PROPN crl-16614 235 4 saljo saljo PROPN crl-16614 235 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 235 6 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 235 7 learning learn VERB crl-16614 235 8 approach approach NOUN crl-16614 235 9 and and CCONJ crl-16614 235 10 outcome outcome VERB crl-16614 235 11 : : PUNCT crl-16614 235 12 some some DET crl-16614 235 13 empirical empirical ADJ crl-16614 235 14 observations observation NOUN crl-16614 235 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 235 16 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 235 17 instructional instructional ADJ crl-16614 235 18 science science NOUN crl-16614 235 19 10 10 NUM crl-16614 235 20 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 235 21 1981 1981 NUM crl-16614 235 22 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 235 23 47–65 47–65 NUM crl-16614 235 24 , , PUNCT crl-16614 235 25 doi:10.1007 doi:10.1007 PROPN crl-16614 235 26 / / SYM crl-16614 235 27 bf00124566 bf00124566 PROPN crl-16614 235 28 . . PROPN crl-16614 235 29 31 31 NUM crl-16614 235 30 . . PUNCT crl-16614 236 1 jacqueline jacqueline PROPN crl-16614 236 2 ann ann PROPN crl-16614 236 3 douglas douglas PROPN crl-16614 236 4 , , PUNCT crl-16614 236 5 alexander alexander PROPN crl-16614 236 6 douglas douglas PROPN crl-16614 236 7 , , PUNCT crl-16614 236 8 robert robert PROPN crl-16614 236 9 james james PROPN crl-16614 236 10 mcclelland mcclelland PROPN crl-16614 236 11 , , PUNCT crl-16614 236 12 and and CCONJ crl-16614 236 13 john john PROPN crl-16614 236 14 davies davy NOUN crl-16614 236 15 , , PUNCT crl-16614 236 16 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 236 17 understanding understand VERB crl-16614 236 18 student student NOUN crl-16614 236 19 satisfaction satisfaction NOUN crl-16614 236 20 and and CCONJ crl-16614 236 21 dissatisfaction dissatisfaction NOUN crl-16614 236 22 : : PUNCT crl-16614 236 23 an an DET crl-16614 236 24 interpretive interpretive ADJ crl-16614 236 25 study study NOUN crl-16614 236 26 in in ADP crl-16614 236 27 the the DET crl-16614 236 28 uk uk PROPN crl-16614 236 29 higher high ADJ crl-16614 236 30 education education NOUN crl-16614 236 31 context context NOUN crl-16614 236 32 , , PUNCT crl-16614 236 33 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 236 34 studies study NOUN crl-16614 236 35 in in ADP crl-16614 236 36 higher high ADJ crl-16614 236 37 education education NOUN crl-16614 236 38 40 40 NUM crl-16614 236 39 , , PUNCT crl-16614 236 40 no no NOUN crl-16614 236 41 . . NOUN crl-16614 236 42 2 2 NUM crl-16614 236 43 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 236 44 2015 2015 NUM crl-16614 236 45 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 236 46 329–49 329–49 NUM crl-16614 236 47 , , PUNCT crl-16614 236 48 doi:10.1080/03075079.20 doi:10.1080/03075079.20 PROPN crl-16614 236 49 13.842217 13.842217 NUM crl-16614 236 50 . . PUNCT crl-16614 237 1 32 32 NUM crl-16614 237 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 237 3 crawford crawford NOUN crl-16614 237 4 , , PUNCT crl-16614 237 5 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 237 6 ethics ethic NOUN crl-16614 237 7 and and CCONJ crl-16614 237 8 access access NOUN crl-16614 237 9 1 1 NUM crl-16614 237 10 : : PUNCT crl-16614 237 11 the the DET crl-16614 237 12 sad sad ADJ crl-16614 237 13 case case NOUN crl-16614 237 14 of of ADP crl-16614 237 15 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 237 16 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 237 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 237 18 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 237 19 1–14 1–14 PROPN crl-16614 237 20 . . PUNCT crl-16614 238 1 33 33 NUM crl-16614 238 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 238 3 kristen kristen PROPN crl-16614 238 4 wilson wilson PROPN crl-16614 238 5 , , PUNCT crl-16614 238 6 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 238 7 librarian librarian X crl-16614 238 8 vs. vs. X crl-16614 238 9 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 238 10 open open ADJ crl-16614 238 11 access access NOUN crl-16614 238 12 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 238 13 predator predator NOUN crl-16614 238 14 : : PUNCT crl-16614 238 15 an an DET crl-16614 238 16 interview interview NOUN crl-16614 238 17 with with ADP crl-16614 238 18 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 238 19 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 238 20 , , PUNCT crl-16614 238 21 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 238 22 serials serial NOUN crl-16614 238 23 review review VERB crl-16614 238 24 39 39 NUM crl-16614 238 25 , , PUNCT crl-16614 238 26 no no NOUN crl-16614 238 27 . . NOUN crl-16614 238 28 2 2 NUM crl-16614 238 29 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 238 30 2013 2013 NUM crl-16614 238 31 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 238 32 125 125 NUM crl-16614 238 33 - - SYM crl-16614 238 34 28 28 NUM crl-16614 238 35 ) ) PUNCT crl-16614 238 36 ; ; PUNCT crl-16614 238 37 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN crl-16614 238 38 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 238 39 , , PUNCT crl-16614 238 40 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 238 41 disclaimer disclaimer NOUN crl-16614 238 42 , , PUNCT crl-16614 238 43 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 238 44 available available ADJ crl-16614 238 45 online online ADV crl-16614 238 46 at at ADP crl-16614 238 47 https://jeffreybeall.com/disclaimer/ https://jeffreybeall.com/disclaimer/ INTJ crl-16614 239 1 [ [ X crl-16614 239 2 accessed access VERB crl-16614 239 3 11 11 NUM crl-16614 239 4 december december PROPN crl-16614 239 5 2017 2017 NUM crl-16614 239 6 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 239 7 . . PUNCT crl-16614 240 1 34 34 NUM crl-16614 240 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 241 1 monica monica PROPN crl-16614 241 2 berger berger PROPN crl-16614 241 3 and and CCONJ crl-16614 241 4 jill jill PROPN crl-16614 241 5 cirasella cirasella NOUN crl-16614 241 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 241 7 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 241 8 beyond beyond ADP crl-16614 241 9 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 241 10 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 241 11 list list NOUN crl-16614 241 12 : : PUNCT crl-16614 241 13 better well ADV crl-16614 241 14 understanding understand VERB crl-16614 241 15 predatory predatory NOUN crl-16614 241 16 publishers publisher NOUN crl-16614 241 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 241 18 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 241 19 college college PROPN crl-16614 241 20 & & CCONJ crl-16614 241 21 research research PROPN crl-16614 241 22 libraries librarie VERB crl-16614 241 23 news news NOUN crl-16614 241 24 76 76 NUM crl-16614 241 25 , , PUNCT crl-16614 241 26 no no NOUN crl-16614 241 27 . . NOUN crl-16614 241 28 3 3 NUM crl-16614 241 29 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 241 30 2015 2015 NUM crl-16614 241 31 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 241 32 132–35 132–35 NUM crl-16614 241 33 . . PUNCT crl-16614 242 1 35 35 NUM crl-16614 242 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 243 1 beverly beverly ADV crl-16614 243 2 dowdy dowdy PROPN crl-16614 243 3 , , PUNCT crl-16614 243 4 david david PROPN crl-16614 243 5 crotty crotty PROPN crl-16614 243 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 243 7 beth beth PROPN crl-16614 243 8 bernhardt bernhardt PROPN crl-16614 243 9 , , PUNCT crl-16614 243 10 paige paige PROPN crl-16614 243 11 hall hall PROPN crl-16614 243 12 smith smith PROPN crl-16614 243 13 , , PUNCT crl-16614 243 14 and and CCONJ crl-16614 243 15 jan jan PROPN crl-16614 243 16 mayo mayo PROPN crl-16614 243 17 , , PUNCT crl-16614 243 18 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 243 19 challenges challenge NOUN crl-16614 243 20 and and CCONJ crl-16614 243 21 opportunities opportunity NOUN crl-16614 243 22 of of ADP crl-16614 243 23 open open ADJ crl-16614 243 24 access access NOUN crl-16614 243 25 : : PUNCT crl-16614 243 26 a a DET crl-16614 243 27 panel panel NOUN crl-16614 243 28 discussion discussion NOUN crl-16614 243 29 , , PUNCT crl-16614 243 30 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 243 31 serials serial NOUN crl-16614 243 32 review review VERB crl-16614 243 33 40 40 NUM crl-16614 243 34 ( ( PUNCT crl-16614 243 35 2014 2014 NUM crl-16614 243 36 ): ): PUNCT crl-16614 243 37 188–90 188–90 NUM crl-16614 243 38 . . PUNCT crl-16614 244 1 36 36 NUM crl-16614 244 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 244 3 oxford oxford PROPN crl-16614 244 4 english english PROPN crl-16614 244 5 dictionary dictionary PROPN crl-16614 244 6 online online PROPN crl-16614 244 7 , , PUNCT crl-16614 244 8 s.v s.v PROPN crl-16614 244 9 . . PUNCT crl-16614 245 1 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 245 2 determine,”available determine,”available ADJ crl-16614 245 3 online online ADV crl-16614 245 4 at at ADP crl-16614 245 5 www.oed.com/ www.oed.com/ PROPN crl-16614 245 6 view view NOUN crl-16614 245 7 / / PUNCT crl-16614 245 8 entry/51244?redirectedfrom entry/51244?redirectedfrom PROPN crl-16614 246 1 = = PRON crl-16614 246 2 determine determine VERB crl-16614 246 3 [ [ X crl-16614 246 4 accessed access VERB crl-16614 246 5 7 7 NUM crl-16614 246 6 april april NOUN crl-16614 246 7 2016 2016 NUM crl-16614 246 8 ] ] PUNCT crl-16614 246 9 . . PUNCT crl-16614 247 1 37 37 NUM crl-16614 247 2 . . PUNCT crl-16614 247 3 berger berger PROPN crl-16614 247 4 and and CCONJ crl-16614 247 5 cirasella cirasella NOUN crl-16614 247 6 , , PUNCT crl-16614 247 7 “ " PUNCT crl-16614 247 8 beyond beyond ADP crl-16614 247 9 beall beall PROPN crl-16614 247 10 ’s ’s PART crl-16614 247 11 list list NOUN crl-16614 247 12 , , PUNCT crl-16614 247 13 ” " PUNCT crl-16614 247 14 135 135 NUM crl-16614 247 15 . . PUNCT crl-16614 248 1 https://blog.doaj.org/ https://blog.doaj.org/ NOUN crl-16614 248 2 http://scholarlyoa.com http://scholarlyoa.com X crl-16614 248 3 https://doi.org/10.1111/jan.12589 https://doi.org/10.1111/jan.12589 PROPN crl-16614 248 4 https://doi.org/10.1111/jan.12589 https://doi.org/10.1111/jan.12589 PROPN crl-16614 248 5 https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-list-predatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politics https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-list-predatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politics PROPN crl-16614 248 6 https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-list-predatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politics https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2017/01/18/librarians-list-predatory-journals-reportedly-removed-due-threats-and-politics PROPN crl-16614 248 7 http://publicationethics.org/files/code%20of%20conduct%20for%20publishers%20final_1_0_0.pdf http://publicationethics.org/files/code%20of%20conduct%20for%20publishers%20final_1_0_0.pdf NOUN crl-16614 248 8 http://publicationethics.org/files/code%20of%20conduct%20for%20publishers%20final_1_0_0.pdf http://publicationethics.org/files/code%20of%20conduct%20for%20publishers%20final_1_0_0.pdf NOUN crl-16614 248 9 http://publicationethics.org/about http://publicationethics.org/about NOUN crl-16614 249 1 http://publicationethics.org/about http://publicationethics.org/about NOUN crl-16614 249 2 http://wokinfo.com/essays/journal-selection-process/ http://wokinfo.com/essays/journal-selection-process/ PUNCT crl-16614 249 3 http://wokinfo.com/essays/journal-selection-process/ http://wokinfo.com/essays/journal-selection-process/ X crl-16614 249 4 https://scholarlyoa.files.wordpress.com/2012/11/criteria-2012-2.pdf https://scholarlyoa.files.wordpress.com/2012/11/criteria-2012-2.pdf PROPN crl-16614 249 5 https://doi.org/10.1007/bf00124566 https://doi.org/10.1007/bf00124566 X crl-16614 249 6 http://www.oed.com/view/entry/51244?redirectedfrom=determine http://www.oed.com/view/entry/51244?redirectedfrom=determine NOUN crl-16614 249 7 http://www.oed.com/view/entry/51244?redirectedfrom=determine http://www.oed.com/view/entry/51244?redirectedfrom=determine NOUN crl-16614 249 8 _ _ NOUN crl-16614 249 9 goback goback NOUN