College and Research Libraries 396 I C allege & Research Libraries • September 1982 MODMEKKAWI In May of 1980 the Association of Research Libraries (ARL) adopted new criteria for membership in the association based, in large part, on what is known as the ARL Li- brary Index. 1 This index is derived from a model containing ten categories, or varia- bles, which characterize library size. While the Library Index model was devel- oped as a measure of an institution's overall standing relative to the ARL membership, this author has found it to be useful, if prop- erly employed, as a decision-making tool in short-term planning, programming, and budgeting in those operations affecting li- brary size. This article describes the proce- dure for this application of the index. WHAT Is THE LIBRARY INDEX? Until 1980, ARL Statistics described the size and rank of ARL member institutions separately in terms of holdings, expendi- tures, staffing, and interlibrary loan activ- ity. While the institutions could be compared on these variables, one at a time , there was no summary measure of an institution's over- all ranking in the association. The ARL model was designed to provide such a sum- mary characterization. The model is as follows: EFSC; (log k; - log K;) I s.d. K; where, in a given year: FSC; Factor score coefficient of variable i; k; Value of variable i for the study institu- tion; Mean of variable i; Standard deviation of variable i. The ten variables included in the model are defined as: 1. Volumes held, excluding microforms and government documents; 2. Volumes added (gross) , excluding mi- Mod Mekkawi is architecture and planning li- brarian , Howard University , Washington , D.C. The ARL Library Index as a Decision-Making Tool croforms and government documents; 3. Microforms held, inCluding micro- film reels, microcards, microprints sheets, microfiches; 4. Current serials received, including periodicals; 5. Expenditures for library materials, including books and serials; 6. Expenditures for binding; 7. Expenditures for salaries and wages, including student assistants' wages, but omitting fringe benefits; 8. Other operating expenditures; 9. Number of FTE professional staff; and 10. Number of FTE nonprofessional staff. Thus for XYZ university library (a hypo- thetical institution) , the index score will be calculated by substitution of the variables in the model with their corresponding values for this library. Using the 1979/80 ARL model , we calculate XYZ's index as shown in table 1. As it turns out, some of the calculated component scores are negative, which indi- cates areas in need of improvement if XYZ in- stitution wishes to score higher in ARL. Given certain characteristics of the ARL model and the current conditions at XYZ, how can this institution achieve a certain im- proved index score most economically? Note that in 1979/80, the scores of the ARL mem- bers ranged from a low of - 1. 93 ( 0 klahoma State) to a high of + 3.00 (Harvard), with - .38 for the university median. MANAGEMENT APPLICATION OF THE ARL MODEL The library administration will set a goal to achieve a certain index score within a given time framework-for instance, one year. Given the library's current component values, its costs of increasing each indepen- dent variable (book, serial, microform) by one unit , the costs of increasing the depen- Research Notes I 397 TABLE 1 PROCEDURE FOR CALCULATING THE LIBRARY INDEX , XYZ UNIVERSITY LIBRARY, 1979/80 Component Variable FSC; k; 1. VOLHELD .12108 rog 1116396 2. VOLADDED .11940 log 57902 3. MICFORM .07509 log 1165076 4. CT SERIALS .12253 log 13156 5. MAT EXPEND .12553 (log 1894321 6. BINDING .11266 ~log 34132 7. TTL SALARIES .12581 log 3609365 8. OPER EXPEND .10592 tg 625014 9. PROFSTAFF .12347 log 83 10. NONPROF .12970 log 124 Total score (Library Index) dent variables (materials expenditures, bind- ing, salaries and wages, other operating ex- penditures) caused by one unit increase in the dependent variables, and the weight of the dependent and independent variables in the ARL model, one can apply linear program- ming principles to find the best use of the li- brary's resources. Because this problem involves not only product mixing (books/serials/microforms) , but also changes in the dependent compo- nents as the products are increased in certain ratios and quantities, formal linear program- ming techniques can be unnecessarily com- plex. The author has therefore worked out a shortcut procedure that may well yield the optimization effect sought in a formal linear programming solution. Before looking at the procedure, let us state the major requirements of the problem: 1. There must be an objective the library wants to achieve. Obviously, its major objec- tive, in terms of ARL standing, is to maxi- mize the total contribution of the compo- nents in the ARL model. The component contributions, or scores, add up to the Li- brary Index. 2. There must be alternative courses of action, one of which will achieve the above objective. In what ratio should the library in- crease its book/ serial resources-!: 1? 3: 1? 0:1? Some other ratio? 3. Dollar resources are limited. One serial may cost twice as much as one book. Conse- quently, the more money that is spent on se- rials, the less there will be to spend on addi- tional books . 4. The ratio of book:serial and the amount of books and/or serials additions needed to achieve the objective (a target s.d. Component K; K; Score - 6.2916) .2172 -0.135897 - 4.8412) .2025 -0 .046290 - 6.0950) .1763 -0.012200 - 4.3432) .2341 -0.117283 - 6.2333) .1636 0.033879 -5.0480) .2475 -0.234350 - 6.4675) .2103 0.053801 - 5.6773) .2635 0.047670 -1.8281) .1968 0.057079 - 2.1512) .2046 -0.031902 -0.385493 ARL score) depend (beside costs and propor- tion of serial subscriptions going into the col- lection as volumes added) on the component score coefficients, or weights, in the ARL Li- brary Index model. PROCEDURE The computational routine is an iterative process. In working toward the target score, the routine is repeated over and over, in a sys- tematic pattern , until the preestablished score value has been reached. Of the three independent variables in the model-books, current serials received, and microforms-we shall use, to simplify the problem, two "products" only, namely books and serials. In what ratio should these vari- ables be increased? Assume lower and upper limits of 0 and 9 for either element in the relation. That is, in the extreme cases, the book:serial ratio can be 0:9 or 9:0. There are fifty-seven alterna- tive exclusive ratio combinations: 0:1, 1:0, 1:1, 1:2, 1:3, etc. Assume also that all new serial additions are bound and added to the collection, and that one serial title produces one bound vol- ume on the average. Thus, increasing books and serials by one unit each (1:1 ratio) will increase volumes added and volumes held by twounitseach. Similarly, a4:1 ratio will in- crease volumes added and volumes held by five units each. At the same time, expenditures for materi- als, binding, total salaries, other operating items, and the quantity of manpower needed to carry the additional work loads, are all in- creased by appropriate amounts for each one serial or monographic addition. These amounts are displayed in table 2. 2 398 I College & Research Libraries • September 1982 TABLE 2 INPUT DATA CAUSED BY ADDITION OF ONE MoNOGRAPHIC oR SERIAL UNIT TO THE COLLECTION Component Item Additional Unit Variable Added Cost per Item MAT EXPEND Book $25.0 Serial 50 .0 BINDING Book 0.0 Serial 7 .0 SALARIES Book 20.0 Serial 23.0 PROF STAFF Book .00059 m~nyear Serial . 00059 manyear NONPROF Book .00073 manyear Serial .00093 manyear ote: The personnel and salari es data are based on (1) known work-load factors for library operations an d (2) estim ated annual salaries and wages of $20 ,000 a nd $12,000 for professionals a nd nonprofessionals, respecti vely. Before we begin the computations, we must adjust the basic data for XYZ by adding initially to its VOLHELD a quantity equal to the number of volumes added in 1979/80. The assumption here is that XYZ will add to its collection in the projected year , books and serials in the proportions and quantities re- ported in the previous year. All other addi- tions, needed to improve the index score, will be over and above the initial increments. The rate of serial binding is again assumed to be 100 percent. Thus, for XYZ, the value of vol- umes at the start of the computational rou- tine is 1174396 (1116396 + 58000). Using the adjusted statistics and the input data from table 2 , the PL/ 1 program given in appendix 1 develops solutions to this prob- lem. For each of the eleven ARL target scores, ranging from 0 to 1.0, the program produced fifty-seven tables, a sample of which is given in table 3. The optimal solu- tion for each target score is that that corre- sponds to the lowest amount of total addi- tional expenditures shown at the foot of each table. The book: serial ratio can be easily de- termined from the input data printed above the table, where the second item represents volumes added (monographs plus serials) , and the third item units of serials added in each loop.· Hence , the book:serial ratio in ta- ble 3 is 1:3 . For XYZ library , the optimal book:serial ratio is 0:1 for each of the eleven alternative score targets: that is , if a certain target score were to be achieved most economically, all additional funds would have to be allocated to increasing the number of current serials received, while book additions remained at the previous level. What if the proportion of additional seri- als that are bound into volumes was less than 100 percent? Table 4 shows that the book: se- rial ratio of 0:1 remains the optimal product mix at every rate of binding except zero , that is, when none of the additional serial titles is bound at year's end. At the same time, the cost of achieving the given target score in- creased as the rate of binding dropped from one to zero. Except for binding expenditures, which obviously decreased as the proportion of serials sent to bindery decreased, all the other expenditures increased as more serials had to be added to reach the same score. This observation is quite instructive. It indicates that a certain score can be reached less expen- sively when most, if not all , of the current se- TABLE 3 SAMPLE REsouRCE ALLOCATION TABLE FOR IMPROVED INDEX ScoRE (LI = 0 .100000 DATA = 4 4 3 175 20 21) Value Target Component Current Target Increase Score VOLHELD 1174396 1184676 10280 -0.121520 VOLADDED 57902 68182 10280 -0.004434 MICROFORMS 1165076 1165076 0 -0.012201 CT SERIALS 13156 20866 7710 -0.012431 MAT EXPEND 1894321 2344071 449750 0.104875 BINDING 34132 88102 53970 - 0.046891 TOTAL SALARY 3609365 3839637 230272 0.069869 OPEREXPEND 625014 676414 51 400 0.061470 PROF STAFF 83 89 6 0.076295 NONPROF 124 133 9 -0.015017 TOTAL 0 .100015 Total Ad d itional Expend itures = 785392. Bindin g Rate = 1.0 rials received are bound and added as vol- umes to the collection. This is less costly than subscribing to an increasingly larger number of titles and discarding a large proportion of the hard copies at year's end in favor of (1) microfilm or (2) straight elimination as a lim- ited number Uust over 7 ,000) of currently published serials are available on microfilm. CoNCLUSION It has been shown how the ARL Library Index model can be used in a large-scale li- brary operation to: 1. Determine alternatives in the alloca- tion of additional funds and the total amount needed in each case to reach a certain im- proved ARL score; 2. Determine which combination of vari- ous library materials will produce the ex- pected outcome less expensively; 3. Identify the concomitant increases in staffing, salaries, binding, and other operat- ing costs; and 4. Identify the trade-offs between the op- timal solution and less efficient alternate so- lutions to achieve the established goal. This information is especially valuable in a planning-budgeting process which uses Zero Base Budgeting (ZBB) techniques. Obviously, the selection of a course of action is not altogether quantitative. The de- cision is often affected by issues that are not amenable to quantification. These issues re- late to the overall objectives of the institu- tion, its policy, or social values. Whereas the median ARL library spends about 55 percent of its materials budget on serials (with 80 per- cent for the ARL university high and 20 per- cent for the university low), a non-research- oriented institution need not, and indeed should not, follow the ARL pattern, which tends to focus on current serials acquisition. Similarly, an academic library that trails far behind comparable institutions in terms of monographic holdings would adopt a nonop- timal solution where the higher costs of de- veloping resources and achieving a certain measure of library size will be justified by the requirements of filling gaps in the book and microform collections. A nonoptimal solution should also be fa- vored where space is a scarce resource; or where the flow of funds for library materials is erratic from year to year, for serial sub- !-< < Research Notes I 399 co t- "'<1' 00 0 00 C\1 ...... 0 00 lJ') t- 0 co 0) "' X(I)); A1aAl+K; A2•A2+L; A3•A3+M; A7•A7+Q; A8•A8+T; A9•A9+U; S1•.121079*(LOG10(Al)-6.29159)/.217199; S2 ... 119399*(LOG10(A2)-4.84119)/.202499; S3=.122529*(LOG10(A3)-4.34319)/.234099; s4s.l25529*(LOG10(A4)-6.23329)/.163599; S5=.105919*(LOG10(A5)-5.67729)/.263499; S6a.07509*(LOG10(A6)-6.0950)/.1763; S7•.11266*(LOG10(A7)-5.0480)/.2475; S8 ... 12581*(LOG10(A8)-6.4675)/.2103; S9a.12347*(LOG10(A9)-1.8281)/.1968; Sl0•.11297*(LOG10(Al0)-2.1512)/:2046; Sll= Sl+S2+S3+S4+SS+S6+S7+S8+S9+S10; END; A4•A4+N; Al0•A10+V; AS•AS+P; /* COMPUTE THE AMOUNT OF INCREASE IN EACH COMPONENT VALUE, FROM CURRENT TO TARGET (IMPROVED) */ Sl2•Al-All; Sl7•A6-A16; S13•A2-Al2; Sl4=A3-Al3; Sl8•A7-Al7; S19•A8-Al8; S25 .. S15+Sl6+Sl8+Sl9; S20•A9-Al9; /* PRINT SOLUTION TABL~ */ S15=A4-AH; Sl6•AS-Al5; S2l•Al0-A20; PUT EDIT ('VOLHELD', A11,A1,Sl2,S1) (COL(1),A,COL(15),F(l0),COL(25),F(10),COL(36),F(l0),COL(50),F(l0,6)); PUT EDIT ('VOLADDED' ,A12,A2,Sl3,S2) (COL(l) ,A,COL(lS) ,F(lO) ,COL(25) ,F(lO) ,COL(36) ,F(10) ,COL( 50) ,F(l0,6)); PUT EDIT ('MICROFORM' ,A6,A16,Sl7,S6) (COL(1),A,COL(l5),F(10),COL(25),F(l0),COL(36),F(10),COL(50),F(l0,6)); PUT EDIT ('CT SERIALS' ,Al3,A3,Sl4,S3) (COL(1),A,COL(15),F(l0),COL(25),F(l0),COL(36),F(l0),COL(50),F(10,6)); PUT EDIT ('MATEXPEND' ,A14,A4,Sl5,S4) (COL(l) ,A,COL(lS) ,F(lO) ,COL(25) ,F(lO) ,COL(36) ,F(10) ,COL( SO) ,F(10,6)); PUT EDIT ('BINDING' ,A17,A7,S18,S7) (COL(1),A,COL(l5),F(10),COL(25),F(10),COL(36),F(l0),COL{50),F(l0,6)); PUT EDIT ('TOTALSALARY' ,Al8,A8,Sl9,S8) (COL(1),A,COL(15),F(10),COL(25),F(10),COL(36),F(l0),COL(50) 1F(l0,6)); PUT EDIT (I OPEREXPEND I ,AlS ,AS, 516 ISS ·) (COL(1),A 1COL(15),F(l0),COL(25),F(l0) 1COL(36) 1F(10),COL(50),F(l0,6)); PUT EDIT ('PROFSTAFF' I A19,A9,S201S9) (COL(1),A 1COL(15),F(l0) 1COL(25) 1F(l0),COL(36),F(10) 1COL(50) 1F(l0 16)); PUT EDIT ('NONPROF' I A20,A101S211S10) (COL (1) ,A I COL ( 15) IF ( 10) I COL ( 25), F ( 10), COL ( 36), F (10), COL (50) IF ( 10,6)); PUT EDIT ('TOTAL' ,Sl1)(COL(3),A,COL(50) 1F(10,6)); PUT EDIT ( ( 6 0 ) I - I ) ( COL (1 ) I A) ; PUT EDIT ('TOTAL ADDITIONAL EXPENDITURES .. ', S25, 'BINDING RATEa' 1 R)(COL(l), A , COL ( 3 2 ) , F ( 8 ) I COL ( 4 3 ) , A I COL ( 58 ) , F ( 2 , 1 ) ) ; PUT SKIP(2); END; END; END SCORES; SUNIPUB Supplies the Books. . . That Supply the Facts. YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS 1981, 19th edition Descriptive entries for intergovernmental organizations, international nongovern- mental and nonprofit agencies, and inter- national committees, institutes and centers offer comprehensive coverage of nearly 15,000 organizational bodies that encom- pass virtually every field of human endeavor. Int' l. Chamber of Commerce 1981 $105.00 ISBN: 92-842-1015-1 934 pp. ORDER# ICCM100 INTERNATIONAL DIRECTORY OF HIGHER EDUCATION RESEARCH INSTITUTIONS Features current listings of national and international institutions and organizations engaged in research on higher education in Europe , North America, and the Soviet Union. UNESCO 1981 139 pp. $11.50 ORDER# U1190 CANADA YEARBOOK 1980-81 "Biannual review of social, political, and economic developments in Canada. In- cludes data on energy , health, education, housing, government, demography, renewable resources, mines and minerals, communication and transportation , manufacturing, merchandising , and trade."-MARKETING NEWS Canadian Govt. Publishing Centre 1981 ca. 1000 pp. $31.50 ORDER# SSC169 COSTS AT U.S. EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS 1981/82 Draws on annual surveys of selected US colleges and universities, listing academic calendars, tuition fees, room and board costs , and suggested monthly maintenance rates for nearly 1,000 educational institu- tions. Institute of International Education 1981 $20.00 ISBN: 0-87206-109-4 192 pp. ORDER# IIE30 Order with Catalog Number from FAO COMMODITY REVIEW AND OUTLOOK 1981-82 Hailed by CHOICE as an Outstanding Academic Book for 1981 ''This document should be in every library where users want to know about the state of the economy in less developed coun- tries .... This work [is] very useful for research on economic development,/over- ty in less developed countries, worl trade, etc .... In short, it is an important document.'' -CHOICE Food and Agriculture Organization 1982 128 pp. $30.50 ORDER# F2239 ISBN: 92-5-101183-4 WORLD GUIDE TO HIGHER EDUCATION, 1982 edition A worldwide, country-by-country survey of higher education systems, degrees, and qualifications. More than 130 separate country studies offer a global analysis of the problems encountered in establishing international equivalences and suggest general criteria for recognizing degrees and diplomas. UNESCO/R. R. Bowker 1982 ca. 300 pp. $33.00 YEARBOOK OF LABOUR STATISTICS 1981, 41st edition This authoritative reference annual presents principal labor statistics for 180 countries and territories for the period from 1970 to 1979. International Labour Organization 1981 704 pp. $63.25 ORDER# IL0190 ISBN: 92-2-002850-6 YEARBOOK OF WORLD ENERGY STATISTICS 1979 Global in scope, this statistical yearbook furnishes data on recent developments and long-term trends affecting the status of all forms of commercial energy. United Nations 1981 1209 pp. $60.00 ORDER# UN80/17 /7 •uNIPUB 1180 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 10036 • 212-764-2791