id sid tid token lemma pos ital-1859 1 1 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 1 2 : : PUNCT ital-1859 1 3 regulation regulation NOUN ital-1859 1 4 out out ADP ital-1859 1 5 of of ADP ital-1859 1 6 line line NOUN ital-1859 1 7 with with ADP ital-1859 1 8 our our PRON ital-1859 1 9 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 1 10 reality reality NOUN ital-1859 1 11 ? ? PUNCT ital-1859 2 1 abigail abigail PROPN ital-1859 2 2 j. j. PROPN ital-1859 2 3 mcdermott mcdermott PROPN ital-1859 2 4 information information PROPN ital-1859 2 5 technology technology PROPN ital-1859 2 6 and and CCONJ ital-1859 2 7 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 2 8 | | ADP ital-1859 2 9 march march PROPN ital-1859 2 10 2012 2012 NUM ital-1859 2 11 7 7 NUM ital-1859 2 12 abstract abstract ADJ ital-1859 2 13 this this DET ital-1859 2 14 paper paper NOUN ital-1859 2 15 provides provide VERB ital-1859 2 16 a a DET ital-1859 2 17 brief brief ADJ ital-1859 2 18 overview overview NOUN ital-1859 2 19 of of ADP ital-1859 2 20 the the DET ital-1859 2 21 current current ADJ ital-1859 2 22 state state NOUN ital-1859 2 23 of of ADP ital-1859 2 24 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 2 25 law law NOUN ital-1859 2 26 in in ADP ital-1859 2 27 the the DET ital-1859 2 28 united united PROPN ital-1859 2 29 states states PROPN ital-1859 2 30 , , PUNCT ital-1859 2 31 focusing focus VERB ital-1859 2 32 on on ADP ital-1859 2 33 the the DET ital-1859 2 34 negative negative ADJ ital-1859 2 35 impacts impact NOUN ital-1859 2 36 of of ADP ital-1859 2 37 these these DET ital-1859 2 38 policies policy NOUN ital-1859 2 39 on on ADP ital-1859 2 40 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 2 41 and and CCONJ ital-1859 2 42 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 2 43 . . PUNCT ital-1859 3 1 the the DET ital-1859 3 2 article article NOUN ital-1859 3 3 discusses discuss VERB ital-1859 3 4 four four NUM ital-1859 3 5 challenges challenge NOUN ital-1859 3 6 current current ADJ ital-1859 3 7 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 3 8 law law NOUN ital-1859 3 9 presents present VERB ital-1859 3 10 to to ADP ital-1859 3 11 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 3 12 and and CCONJ ital-1859 3 13 the the DET ital-1859 3 14 public public NOUN ital-1859 3 15 in in ADP ital-1859 3 16 general general ADJ ital-1859 3 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 3 18 highlighting highlight VERB ital-1859 3 19 three three NUM ital-1859 3 20 concrete concrete ADJ ital-1859 3 21 ways way NOUN ital-1859 3 22 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 3 23 property property NOUN ital-1859 3 24 law law NOUN ital-1859 3 25 interferes interfere VERB ital-1859 3 26 with with ADP ital-1859 3 27 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 3 28 library library NOUN ital-1859 3 29 services service NOUN ital-1859 3 30 and and CCONJ ital-1859 3 31 systems system NOUN ital-1859 3 32 . . PUNCT ital-1859 4 1 finally finally ADV ital-1859 4 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 4 3 the the DET ital-1859 4 4 author author NOUN ital-1859 4 5 suggests suggest VERB ital-1859 4 6 that that SCONJ ital-1859 4 7 a a DET ital-1859 4 8 greater great ADJ ital-1859 4 9 emphasis emphasis NOUN ital-1859 4 10 on on ADP ital-1859 4 11 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 4 12 literacy literacy NOUN ital-1859 4 13 and and CCONJ ital-1859 4 14 a a DET ital-1859 4 15 commitment commitment NOUN ital-1859 4 16 among among ADP ital-1859 4 17 the the DET ital-1859 4 18 library library NOUN ital-1859 4 19 community community NOUN ital-1859 4 20 to to PART ital-1859 4 21 advocate advocate VERB ital-1859 4 22 for for ADP ital-1859 4 23 fairer fair ADJ ital-1859 4 24 policies policy NOUN ital-1859 4 25 is be AUX ital-1859 4 26 vital vital ADJ ital-1859 4 27 to to ADP ital-1859 4 28 correcting correct VERB ital-1859 4 29 the the DET ital-1859 4 30 imbalance imbalance NOUN ital-1859 4 31 between between ADP ital-1859 4 32 the the DET ital-1859 4 33 interests interest NOUN ital-1859 4 34 of of ADP ital-1859 4 35 the the DET ital-1859 4 36 public public NOUN ital-1859 4 37 and and CCONJ ital-1859 4 38 those those PRON ital-1859 4 39 of of ADP ital-1859 4 40 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 4 41 holders holder NOUN ital-1859 4 42 . . PUNCT ital-1859 5 1 introduction introduction NOUN ital-1859 5 2 in in ADP ital-1859 5 3 july july PROPN ital-1859 5 4 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 5 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 5 6 the the DET ital-1859 5 7 library library NOUN ital-1859 5 8 community community NOUN ital-1859 5 9 applauded applaud VERB ital-1859 5 10 when when SCONJ ital-1859 5 11 librarian librarian PROPN ital-1859 5 12 of of ADP ital-1859 5 13 congress congress PROPN ital-1859 5 14 james james PROPN ital-1859 5 15 h. h. PROPN ital-1859 5 16 billington billington PROPN ital-1859 5 17 announced announce VERB ital-1859 5 18 new new ADJ ital-1859 5 19 exemptions exemption NOUN ital-1859 5 20 to to ADP ital-1859 5 21 the the DET ital-1859 5 22 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 5 23 millennium millennium PROPN ital-1859 5 24 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 5 25 act act PROPN ital-1859 5 26 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 5 27 dmca dmca PROPN ital-1859 5 28 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 5 29 . . PUNCT ital-1859 6 1 those those PRON ital-1859 6 2 with with ADP ital-1859 6 3 visual visual ADJ ital-1859 6 4 disabilities disability NOUN ital-1859 6 5 and and CCONJ ital-1859 6 6 the the DET ital-1859 6 7 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 6 8 who who PRON ital-1859 6 9 serve serve VERB ital-1859 6 10 them they PRON ital-1859 6 11 can can AUX ital-1859 6 12 now now ADV ital-1859 6 13 circumvent circumvent VERB ital-1859 6 14 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 6 15 rights right NOUN ital-1859 6 16 management management NOUN ital-1859 6 17 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 6 18 drm drm PROPN ital-1859 6 19 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 6 20 software software NOUN ital-1859 6 21 on on ADP ital-1859 6 22 e e NOUN ital-1859 6 23 - - NOUN ital-1859 6 24 books book NOUN ital-1859 6 25 to to PART ital-1859 6 26 activate activate VERB ital-1859 6 27 a a DET ital-1859 6 28 read read VERB ital-1859 6 29 - - PUNCT ital-1859 6 30 aloud aloud NOUN ital-1859 6 31 function.1 function.1 ADV ital-1859 6 32 in in ADP ital-1859 6 33 addition addition NOUN ital-1859 6 34 , , PUNCT ital-1859 6 35 higher high ADJ ital-1859 6 36 education education NOUN ital-1859 6 37 faculty faculty NOUN ital-1859 6 38 in in ADP ital-1859 6 39 departments department NOUN ital-1859 6 40 other other ADJ ital-1859 6 41 than than ADP ital-1859 6 42 film film NOUN ital-1859 6 43 and and CCONJ ital-1859 6 44 media medium NOUN ital-1859 6 45 studies study NOUN ital-1859 6 46 can can AUX ital-1859 6 47 now now ADV ital-1859 6 48 break break VERB ital-1859 6 49 through through ADP ital-1859 6 50 drm drm PROPN ital-1859 6 51 software software NOUN ital-1859 6 52 to to PART ital-1859 6 53 include include VERB ital-1859 6 54 high high ADJ ital-1859 6 55 - - PUNCT ital-1859 6 56 resolution resolution NOUN ital-1859 6 57 film film NOUN ital-1859 6 58 clips clip NOUN ital-1859 6 59 in in ADP ital-1859 6 60 class class NOUN ital-1859 6 61 materials material NOUN ital-1859 6 62 and and CCONJ ital-1859 6 63 lectures lecture NOUN ital-1859 6 64 . . PUNCT ital-1859 7 1 however however ADV ital-1859 7 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 7 3 their their PRON ital-1859 7 4 students student NOUN ital-1859 7 5 can can AUX ital-1859 7 6 not not PART ital-1859 7 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 7 8 since since SCONJ ital-1859 7 9 only only ADV ital-1859 7 10 those those PRON ital-1859 7 11 who who PRON ital-1859 7 12 are be AUX ital-1859 7 13 pursuing pursue VERB ital-1859 7 14 a a DET ital-1859 7 15 degree degree NOUN ital-1859 7 16 in in ADP ital-1859 7 17 film film NOUN ital-1859 7 18 can can AUX ital-1859 7 19 legally legally ADV ital-1859 7 20 do do VERB ital-1859 7 21 the the DET ital-1859 7 22 same.2 same.2 PROPN ital-1859 7 23 that that PRON ital-1859 7 24 means mean VERB ital-1859 7 25 that that SCONJ ital-1859 7 26 english english ADJ ital-1859 7 27 students student NOUN ital-1859 7 28 who who PRON ital-1859 7 29 want want VERB ital-1859 7 30 to to PART ital-1859 7 31 legally legally ADV ital-1859 7 32 include include VERB ital-1859 7 33 high high ADJ ital-1859 7 34 - - PUNCT ital-1859 7 35 resolution resolution NOUN ital-1859 7 36 clips clip NOUN ital-1859 7 37 from from ADP ital-1859 7 38 the the DET ital-1859 7 39 critically critically ADV ital-1859 7 40 acclaimed acclaim VERB ital-1859 7 41 film film NOUN ital-1859 7 42 sense sense NOUN ital-1859 7 43 and and CCONJ ital-1859 7 44 sensibility sensibility NOUN ital-1859 7 45 in in ADP ital-1859 7 46 their their PRON ital-1859 7 47 final final ADJ ital-1859 7 48 projects project NOUN ital-1859 7 49 on on ADP ital-1859 7 50 jane jane PROPN ital-1859 7 51 austin austin PROPN ital-1859 7 52 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 7 53 novel novel NOUN ital-1859 7 54 will will AUX ital-1859 7 55 have have VERB ital-1859 7 56 to to PART ital-1859 7 57 wait wait VERB ital-1859 7 58 another another DET ital-1859 7 59 three three NUM ital-1859 7 60 years year NOUN ital-1859 7 61 , , PUNCT ital-1859 7 62 when when SCONJ ital-1859 7 63 the the DET ital-1859 7 64 librarian librarian NOUN ital-1859 7 65 of of ADP ital-1859 7 66 congress congress PROPN ital-1859 7 67 will will AUX ital-1859 7 68 again again ADV ital-1859 7 69 review review VERB ital-1859 7 70 the the DET ital-1859 7 71 dmca dmca NOUN ital-1859 7 72 . . PUNCT ital-1859 8 1 the the DET ital-1859 8 2 fact fact NOUN ital-1859 8 3 that that SCONJ ital-1859 8 4 these these DET ital-1859 8 5 new new ADJ ital-1859 8 6 exemptions exemption NOUN ital-1859 8 7 to to ADP ital-1859 8 8 the the DET ital-1859 8 9 dmca dmca NOUN ital-1859 8 10 were be AUX ital-1859 8 11 a a DET ital-1859 8 12 cause cause NOUN ital-1859 8 13 for for ADP ital-1859 8 14 celebration celebration NOUN ital-1859 8 15 is be AUX ital-1859 8 16 one one NUM ital-1859 8 17 indicator indicator NOUN ital-1859 8 18 of of ADP ital-1859 8 19 the the DET ital-1859 8 20 imbalanced imbalanced ADJ ital-1859 8 21 state state NOUN ital-1859 8 22 of of ADP ital-1859 8 23 the the DET ital-1859 8 24 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 8 25 regulations regulation NOUN ital-1859 8 26 that that PRON ital-1859 8 27 control control VERB ital-1859 8 28 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 8 29 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 8 30 property property NOUN ital-1859 8 31 in in ADP ital-1859 8 32 this this DET ital-1859 8 33 country country NOUN ital-1859 8 34 . . PUNCT ital-1859 9 1 as as SCONJ ital-1859 9 2 the the DET ital-1859 9 3 consumer consumer NOUN ital-1859 9 4 - - PUNCT ital-1859 9 5 advocacy advocacy NOUN ital-1859 9 6 group group NOUN ital-1859 9 7 public public ADJ ital-1859 9 8 knowledge knowledge NOUN ital-1859 9 9 asserted assert VERB ital-1859 9 10 , , PUNCT ital-1859 9 11 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 9 12 we we PRON ital-1859 9 13 continue continue VERB ital-1859 9 14 to to PART ital-1859 9 15 be be AUX ital-1859 9 16 disappointed disappoint VERB ital-1859 9 17 that that SCONJ ital-1859 9 18 the the DET ital-1859 9 19 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 9 20 office office NOUN ital-1859 9 21 under under ADP ital-1859 9 22 the the DET ital-1859 9 23 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 9 24 millennium millennium PROPN ital-1859 9 25 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 9 26 act act PROPN ital-1859 9 27 can can AUX ital-1859 9 28 grant grant VERB ital-1859 9 29 extremely extremely ADV ital-1859 9 30 limited limited ADJ ital-1859 9 31 exemptions exemption NOUN ital-1859 9 32 and and CCONJ ital-1859 9 33 only only ADV ital-1859 9 34 every every DET ital-1859 9 35 three three NUM ital-1859 9 36 years year NOUN ital-1859 9 37 . . PUNCT ital-1859 10 1 this this DET ital-1859 10 2 state state NOUN ital-1859 10 3 of of ADP ital-1859 10 4 affairs affair NOUN ital-1859 10 5 is be AUX ital-1859 10 6 an an DET ital-1859 10 7 indication indication NOUN ital-1859 10 8 that that SCONJ ital-1859 10 9 the the DET ital-1859 10 10 law law NOUN ital-1859 10 11 needs need VERB ital-1859 10 12 to to PART ital-1859 10 13 be be AUX ital-1859 10 14 changed change VERB ital-1859 10 15 . . PUNCT ital-1859 11 1 ”3 ”3 PROPN ital-1859 11 2 this this DET ital-1859 11 3 paper paper NOUN ital-1859 11 4 provides provide VERB ital-1859 11 5 a a DET ital-1859 11 6 brief brief ADJ ital-1859 11 7 overview overview NOUN ital-1859 11 8 of of ADP ital-1859 11 9 the the DET ital-1859 11 10 current current ADJ ital-1859 11 11 state state NOUN ital-1859 11 12 of of ADP ital-1859 11 13 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 11 14 . . PROPN ital-1859 11 15 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 11 16 law law PROPN ital-1859 11 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 11 18 especially especially ADV ital-1859 11 19 developments development NOUN ital-1859 11 20 during during ADP ital-1859 11 21 the the DET ital-1859 11 22 past past ADJ ital-1859 11 23 fifteen fifteen NUM ital-1859 11 24 years year NOUN ital-1859 11 25 , , PUNCT ital-1859 11 26 with with ADP ital-1859 11 27 a a DET ital-1859 11 28 focus focus NOUN ital-1859 11 29 on on ADP ital-1859 11 30 the the DET ital-1859 11 31 negative negative ADJ ital-1859 11 32 impact impact NOUN ital-1859 11 33 these these DET ital-1859 11 34 policies policy NOUN ital-1859 11 35 have have AUX ital-1859 11 36 had have VERB ital-1859 11 37 and and CCONJ ital-1859 11 38 will will AUX ital-1859 11 39 continue continue VERB ital-1859 11 40 to to PART ital-1859 11 41 have have VERB ital-1859 11 42 on on ADP ital-1859 11 43 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 11 44 , , PUNCT ital-1859 11 45 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 11 46 , , PUNCT ital-1859 11 47 and and CCONJ ital-1859 11 48 the the DET ital-1859 11 49 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 11 50 they they PRON ital-1859 11 51 serve serve VERB ital-1859 11 52 . . PUNCT ital-1859 12 1 this this DET ital-1859 12 2 paper paper NOUN ital-1859 12 3 does do AUX ital-1859 12 4 not not PART ital-1859 12 5 provide provide VERB ital-1859 12 6 a a DET ital-1859 12 7 comprehensive comprehensive ADJ ital-1859 12 8 and and CCONJ ital-1859 12 9 impartial impartial ADJ ital-1859 12 10 primer primer NOUN ital-1859 12 11 on on ADP ital-1859 12 12 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 12 13 law law NOUN ital-1859 12 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 12 15 a a DET ital-1859 12 16 complex complex ADJ ital-1859 12 17 abigail abigail PROPN ital-1859 12 18 j. j. PROPN ital-1859 12 19 mcdermott mcdermott PROPN ital-1859 12 20 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 12 21 ajmcderm@umd.edu ajmcderm@umd.edu PROPN ital-1859 12 22 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 12 23 is be AUX ital-1859 12 24 graduate graduate NOUN ital-1859 12 25 research research NOUN ital-1859 12 26 associate associate NOUN ital-1859 12 27 , , PUNCT ital-1859 12 28 the the DET ital-1859 12 29 information information NOUN ital-1859 12 30 policy policy NOUN ital-1859 12 31 and and CCONJ ital-1859 12 32 access access NOUN ital-1859 12 33 center center NOUN ital-1859 12 34 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 12 35 ipac ipac PROPN ital-1859 12 36 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 12 37 , , PUNCT ital-1859 12 38 and and CCONJ ital-1859 12 39 masters master NOUN ital-1859 12 40 candidate candidate NOUN ital-1859 12 41 in in ADP ital-1859 12 42 library library NOUN ital-1859 12 43 science science NOUN ital-1859 12 44 , , PUNCT ital-1859 12 45 university university PROPN ital-1859 12 46 of of ADP ital-1859 12 47 maryland maryland PROPN ital-1859 12 48 , , PUNCT ital-1859 12 49 college college NOUN ital-1859 12 50 park park NOUN ital-1859 12 51 . . PUNCT ital-1859 13 1 mailto:ajmcderm@umd.edu mailto:ajmcderm@umd.edu PROPN ital-1859 13 2 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 13 3 : : PUNCT ital-1859 13 4 regulation regulation NOUN ital-1859 13 5 out out ADP ital-1859 13 6 of of ADP ital-1859 13 7 line line NOUN ital-1859 13 8 with with ADP ital-1859 13 9 our our PRON ital-1859 13 10 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 13 11 reality reality NOUN ital-1859 13 12 | | PROPN ital-1859 13 13 mcdermott mcdermott PROPN ital-1859 13 14 8 8 NUM ital-1859 13 15 and and CCONJ ital-1859 13 16 convoluted convoluted ADJ ital-1859 13 17 topic topic NOUN ital-1859 13 18 , , PUNCT ital-1859 13 19 instead instead ADV ital-1859 13 20 identifying identify VERB ital-1859 13 21 concerns concern NOUN ital-1859 13 22 about about ADP ital-1859 13 23 the the DET ital-1859 13 24 effects effect NOUN ital-1859 13 25 an an DET ital-1859 13 26 out out ADJ ital-1859 13 27 - - PUNCT ital-1859 13 28 of of ADP ital-1859 13 29 - - PUNCT ital-1859 13 30 balance balance NOUN ital-1859 13 31 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 13 32 property property NOUN ital-1859 13 33 system system NOUN ital-1859 13 34 is be AUX ital-1859 13 35 having have VERB ital-1859 13 36 on on ADP ital-1859 13 37 the the DET ital-1859 13 38 library library NOUN ital-1859 13 39 profession profession NOUN ital-1859 13 40 , , PUNCT ital-1859 13 41 library library NOUN ital-1859 13 42 services service NOUN ital-1859 13 43 , , PUNCT ital-1859 13 44 and and CCONJ ital-1859 13 45 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 13 46 expression expression NOUN ital-1859 13 47 in in ADP ital-1859 13 48 our our PRON ital-1859 13 49 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 13 50 age age NOUN ital-1859 13 51 . . PUNCT ital-1859 14 1 as as ADP ital-1859 14 2 with with ADP ital-1859 14 3 any any DET ital-1859 14 4 area area NOUN ital-1859 14 5 of of ADP ital-1859 14 6 public public ADJ ital-1859 14 7 policy policy NOUN ital-1859 14 8 , , PUNCT ital-1859 14 9 the the DET ital-1859 14 10 battles battle NOUN ital-1859 14 11 over over ADP ital-1859 14 12 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 14 13 property property NOUN ital-1859 14 14 issues issue NOUN ital-1859 14 15 create create VERB ital-1859 14 16 an an DET ital-1859 14 17 every every DET ital-1859 14 18 fluctuating fluctuate VERB ital-1859 14 19 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 14 20 environment environment NOUN ital-1859 14 21 , , PUNCT ital-1859 14 22 and and CCONJ ital-1859 14 23 therefore therefore ADV ital-1859 14 24 , , PUNCT ital-1859 14 25 this this DET ital-1859 14 26 article article NOUN ital-1859 14 27 is be AUX ital-1859 14 28 written write VERB ital-1859 14 29 to to PART ital-1859 14 30 be be AUX ital-1859 14 31 current current ADJ ital-1859 14 32 with with ADP ital-1859 14 33 policy policy NOUN ital-1859 14 34 developments development NOUN ital-1859 14 35 as as ADP ital-1859 14 36 of of ADP ital-1859 14 37 october october PROPN ital-1859 14 38 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 14 39 . . PUNCT ital-1859 15 1 finally finally ADV ital-1859 15 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 15 3 this this DET ital-1859 15 4 paper paper NOUN ital-1859 15 5 recommends recommend VERB ital-1859 15 6 that that SCONJ ital-1859 15 7 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 15 8 seek seek VERB ital-1859 15 9 to to PART ital-1859 15 10 better well ADV ital-1859 15 11 educate educate VERB ital-1859 15 12 themselves themselves PRON ital-1859 15 13 about about ADP ital-1859 15 14 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 15 15 law law NOUN ital-1859 15 16 , , PUNCT ital-1859 15 17 and and CCONJ ital-1859 15 18 some some DET ital-1859 15 19 innovative innovative ADJ ital-1859 15 20 responses response NOUN ital-1859 15 21 to to ADP ital-1859 15 22 an an DET ital-1859 15 23 overly overly ADV ital-1859 15 24 restrictive restrictive ADJ ital-1859 15 25 system system NOUN ital-1859 15 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 15 27 so so SCONJ ital-1859 15 28 that that SCONJ ital-1859 15 29 we we PRON ital-1859 15 30 can can AUX ital-1859 15 31 effectively effectively ADV ital-1859 15 32 advocate advocate VERB ital-1859 15 33 on on ADP ital-1859 15 34 our our PRON ital-1859 15 35 own own ADJ ital-1859 15 36 behalf behalf NOUN ital-1859 15 37 , , PUNCT ital-1859 15 38 and and CCONJ ital-1859 15 39 better well ADV ital-1859 15 40 serve serve VERB ital-1859 15 41 our our PRON ital-1859 15 42 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 15 43 . . PUNCT ital-1859 16 1 the the DET ital-1859 16 2 state state NOUN ital-1859 16 3 of of ADP ital-1859 16 4 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 16 5 . . PROPN ital-1859 16 6 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 16 7 law law PROPN ital-1859 16 8 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 16 9 law law NOUN ital-1859 16 10 is be AUX ital-1859 16 11 a a DET ital-1859 16 12 response response NOUN ital-1859 16 13 to to ADP ital-1859 16 14 what what PRON ital-1859 16 15 is be AUX ital-1859 16 16 known know VERB ital-1859 16 17 as as ADP ital-1859 16 18 the the DET ital-1859 16 19 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 16 20 progress progress NOUN ital-1859 16 21 clause clause NOUN ital-1859 16 22 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 16 23 of of ADP ital-1859 16 24 the the DET ital-1859 16 25 constitution constitution NOUN ital-1859 16 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 16 27 which which PRON ital-1859 16 28 charges charge VERB ital-1859 16 29 congress congress PROPN ital-1859 16 30 with with ADP ital-1859 16 31 the the DET ital-1859 16 32 responsibility responsibility NOUN ital-1859 16 33 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 16 34 to to PART ital-1859 16 35 promote promote VERB ital-1859 16 36 the the DET ital-1859 16 37 progress progress NOUN ital-1859 16 38 of of ADP ital-1859 16 39 science science NOUN ital-1859 16 40 and and CCONJ ital-1859 16 41 the the DET ital-1859 16 42 useful useful ADJ ital-1859 16 43 arts art NOUN ital-1859 16 44 . . PUNCT ital-1859 16 45 . . PUNCT ital-1859 16 46 . . PUNCT ital-1859 17 1 to to ADP ital-1859 17 2 this this DET ital-1859 17 3 end end NOUN ital-1859 17 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 17 5 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 17 6 assures assure VERB ital-1859 17 7 authors author NOUN ital-1859 17 8 the the DET ital-1859 17 9 right right NOUN ital-1859 17 10 to to ADP ital-1859 17 11 their their PRON ital-1859 17 12 original original ADJ ital-1859 17 13 expression expression NOUN ital-1859 17 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 17 15 but but CCONJ ital-1859 17 16 encourages encourage VERB ital-1859 17 17 others other NOUN ital-1859 17 18 to to PART ital-1859 17 19 build build VERB ital-1859 17 20 freely freely ADV ital-1859 17 21 upon upon SCONJ ital-1859 17 22 the the DET ital-1859 17 23 ideas idea NOUN ital-1859 17 24 and and CCONJ ital-1859 17 25 information information NOUN ital-1859 17 26 conveyed convey VERB ital-1859 17 27 by by ADP ital-1859 17 28 a a DET ital-1859 17 29 work work NOUN ital-1859 17 30 . . PUNCT ital-1859 18 1 ”4 ”4 PUNCT ital-1859 19 1 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 19 2 use use NOUN ital-1859 19 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 19 4 a a DET ital-1859 19 5 statutory statutory ADJ ital-1859 19 6 exception exception NOUN ital-1859 19 7 to to ADP ital-1859 19 8 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 19 9 . . PROPN ital-1859 19 10 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 19 11 law law PROPN ital-1859 19 12 , , PUNCT ital-1859 19 13 is be AUX ital-1859 19 14 a a DET ital-1859 19 15 complex complex ADJ ital-1859 19 16 subject subject NOUN ital-1859 19 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 19 18 but but CCONJ ital-1859 19 19 a a DET ital-1859 19 20 brief brief ADJ ital-1859 19 21 examination examination NOUN ital-1859 19 22 of of ADP ital-1859 19 23 the the DET ital-1859 19 24 principle principle NOUN ital-1859 19 25 gets get VERB ital-1859 19 26 to to ADP ital-1859 19 27 the the DET ital-1859 19 28 heart heart NOUN ital-1859 19 29 of of ADP ital-1859 19 30 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 19 31 law law NOUN ital-1859 19 32 itself itself PRON ital-1859 19 33 . . PUNCT ital-1859 20 1 when when SCONJ ital-1859 20 2 determining determine VERB ital-1859 20 3 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 20 4 use use NOUN ital-1859 20 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 20 6 courts court NOUN ital-1859 20 7 consider consider VERB ital-1859 20 8 1 1 NUM ital-1859 20 9 . . PUNCT ital-1859 21 1 the the DET ital-1859 21 2 purpose purpose NOUN ital-1859 21 3 and and CCONJ ital-1859 21 4 character character NOUN ital-1859 21 5 of of ADP ital-1859 21 6 the the DET ital-1859 21 7 use use NOUN ital-1859 21 8 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 21 9 2 2 X ital-1859 21 10 . . X ital-1859 22 1 the the DET ital-1859 22 2 nature nature NOUN ital-1859 22 3 of of ADP ital-1859 22 4 the the DET ital-1859 22 5 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 22 6 work work NOUN ital-1859 22 7 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 23 1 3 3 X ital-1859 23 2 . . X ital-1859 23 3 the the DET ital-1859 23 4 amount amount NOUN ital-1859 23 5 and and CCONJ ital-1859 23 6 substantiality substantiality NOUN ital-1859 23 7 of of ADP ital-1859 23 8 the the DET ital-1859 23 9 portion portion NOUN ital-1859 23 10 used use VERB ital-1859 23 11 in in ADP ital-1859 23 12 relation relation NOUN ital-1859 23 13 to to ADP ital-1859 23 14 the the DET ital-1859 23 15 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 23 16 work work NOUN ital-1859 23 17 as as ADP ital-1859 23 18 a a DET ital-1859 23 19 whole whole NOUN ital-1859 23 20 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 23 21 and and CCONJ ital-1859 23 22 4 4 X ital-1859 23 23 . . PUNCT ital-1859 24 1 the the DET ital-1859 24 2 effect effect NOUN ital-1859 24 3 of of ADP ital-1859 24 4 the the DET ital-1859 24 5 use use NOUN ital-1859 24 6 upon upon SCONJ ital-1859 24 7 the the DET ital-1859 24 8 potential potential ADJ ital-1859 24 9 market market NOUN ital-1859 24 10 for for ADP ital-1859 24 11 the the DET ital-1859 24 12 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 24 13 work.5 work.5 PROPN ital-1859 24 14 while while SCONJ ital-1859 24 15 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 24 16 use use NOUN ital-1859 24 17 is be AUX ital-1859 24 18 an an DET ital-1859 24 19 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 24 20 affirmative affirmative ADJ ital-1859 24 21 defense defense NOUN ital-1859 24 22 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 24 23 to to ADP ital-1859 24 24 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 24 25 infringement,6 infringement,6 PROPN ital-1859 24 26 invoking invoke VERB ital-1859 24 27 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 24 28 use use NOUN ital-1859 24 29 is be AUX ital-1859 24 30 not not PART ital-1859 24 31 the the DET ital-1859 24 32 same same ADJ ital-1859 24 33 as as ADP ital-1859 24 34 admitting admit VERB ital-1859 24 35 to to ADP ital-1859 24 36 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 24 37 infringement infringement NOUN ital-1859 24 38 . . PUNCT ital-1859 25 1 teaching teaching NOUN ital-1859 25 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 25 3 scholarship scholarship NOUN ital-1859 25 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 25 5 and and CCONJ ital-1859 25 6 research research NOUN ital-1859 25 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 25 8 as as ADV ital-1859 25 9 well well ADV ital-1859 25 10 as as ADP ital-1859 25 11 instances instance NOUN ital-1859 25 12 in in ADP ital-1859 25 13 which which PRON ital-1859 25 14 the the DET ital-1859 25 15 use use NOUN ital-1859 25 16 is be AUX ital-1859 25 17 not not PART ital-1859 25 18 - - PUNCT ital-1859 25 19 for for ADP ital-1859 25 20 - - PUNCT ital-1859 25 21 profit profit NOUN ital-1859 25 22 and and CCONJ ital-1859 25 23 noncommercial noncommercial ADJ ital-1859 25 24 , , PUNCT ital-1859 25 25 are be AUX ital-1859 25 26 all all PRON ital-1859 25 27 legitimate legitimate ADJ ital-1859 25 28 examples example NOUN ital-1859 25 29 of of ADP ital-1859 25 30 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 25 31 use use NOUN ital-1859 25 32 , , PUNCT ital-1859 25 33 even even ADV ital-1859 25 34 if if SCONJ ital-1859 25 35 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 25 36 use use NOUN ital-1859 25 37 is be AUX ital-1859 25 38 determined determine VERB ital-1859 25 39 on on ADP ital-1859 25 40 a a DET ital-1859 25 41 case case NOUN ital-1859 25 42 - - PUNCT ital-1859 25 43 by by ADP ital-1859 25 44 - - PUNCT ital-1859 25 45 case case NOUN ital-1859 25 46 basis.7 basis.7 NOUN ital-1859 25 47 despite despite SCONJ ital-1859 25 48 the the DET ital-1859 25 49 byzantine byzantine ADJ ital-1859 25 50 nature nature NOUN ital-1859 25 51 of of ADP ital-1859 25 52 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 25 53 law law NOUN ital-1859 25 54 , , PUNCT ital-1859 25 55 there there PRON ital-1859 25 56 are be VERB ital-1859 25 57 four four NUM ital-1859 25 58 key key ADJ ital-1859 25 59 issues issue NOUN ital-1859 25 60 that that PRON ital-1859 25 61 present present VERB ital-1859 25 62 the the DET ital-1859 25 63 greatest great ADJ ital-1859 25 64 challenges challenge NOUN ital-1859 25 65 and and CCONJ ital-1859 25 66 obstacles obstacle NOUN ital-1859 25 67 to to ADP ital-1859 25 68 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 25 69 and and CCONJ ital-1859 25 70 people people NOUN ital-1859 25 71 in in ADP ital-1859 25 72 general general ADJ ital-1859 25 73 : : PUNCT ital-1859 25 74 the the DET ital-1859 25 75 effect effect NOUN ital-1859 25 76 of of ADP ital-1859 25 77 the the DET ital-1859 25 78 dmca dmca NOUN ital-1859 25 79 on on ADP ital-1859 25 80 the the DET ital-1859 25 81 principle principle NOUN ital-1859 25 82 of of ADP ital-1859 25 83 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 25 84 use use NOUN ital-1859 25 85 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 25 86 the the DET ital-1859 25 87 dramatic dramatic ADJ ital-1859 25 88 extension extension NOUN ital-1859 25 89 of of ADP ital-1859 25 90 copyright copyright ADJ ital-1859 25 91 terms term NOUN ital-1859 25 92 codified codify VERB ital-1859 25 93 by by ADP ital-1859 25 94 the the DET ital-1859 25 95 sonny sonny PROPN ital-1859 25 96 bono bono X ital-1859 25 97 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 25 98 term term NOUN ital-1859 25 99 extension extension NOUN ital-1859 25 100 act act NOUN ital-1859 25 101 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 25 102 the the DET ital-1859 25 103 disappearance disappearance NOUN ital-1859 25 104 of of ADP ital-1859 25 105 the the DET ital-1859 25 106 registration registration NOUN ital-1859 25 107 requirement requirement NOUN ital-1859 25 108 for for ADP ital-1859 25 109 copyright copyright ADJ ital-1859 25 110 holders holder NOUN ital-1859 25 111 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 25 112 and and CCONJ ital-1859 25 113 the the DET ital-1859 25 114 problem problem NOUN ital-1859 25 115 of of ADP ital-1859 25 116 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 25 117 works work VERB ital-1859 25 118 . . PUNCT ital-1859 26 1 the the DET ital-1859 26 2 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 26 3 millennium millennium PROPN ital-1859 26 4 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 26 5 act act PROPN ital-1859 26 6 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 26 7 dmca dmca PROPN ital-1859 26 8 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 26 9 the the DET ital-1859 26 10 dmca dmca NOUN ital-1859 26 11 has have AUX ital-1859 26 12 been be AUX ital-1859 26 13 controversial controversial ADJ ital-1859 26 14 since since SCONJ ital-1859 26 15 its its PRON ital-1859 26 16 passage passage NOUN ital-1859 26 17 in in ADP ital-1859 26 18 1998 1998 NUM ital-1859 26 19 . . PUNCT ital-1859 27 1 title title NOUN ital-1859 27 2 i i PRON ital-1859 27 3 of of ADP ital-1859 27 4 the the DET ital-1859 27 5 dmca dmca NOUN ital-1859 27 6 implements implement VERB ital-1859 27 7 two two NUM ital-1859 27 8 1996 1996 NUM ital-1859 27 9 world world NOUN ital-1859 27 10 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 27 11 property property NOUN ital-1859 27 12 organization organization NOUN ital-1859 27 13 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 27 14 wipo wipo PROPN ital-1859 27 15 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 27 16 treaties treaty NOUN ital-1859 27 17 that that PRON ital-1859 27 18 obligate obligate ADJ ital-1859 27 19 member member NOUN ital-1859 27 20 states state NOUN ital-1859 27 21 to to PART ital-1859 27 22 enforce enforce VERB ital-1859 27 23 laws law NOUN ital-1859 27 24 that that PRON ital-1859 27 25 make make VERB ital-1859 27 26 tampering tamper VERB ital-1859 27 27 with with ADP ital-1859 27 28 drm drm PROPN ital-1859 27 29 software software NOUN ital-1859 27 30 illegal illegal ADJ ital-1859 27 31 . . PUNCT ital-1859 28 1 the the DET ital-1859 28 2 dmca dmca PROPN ital-1859 28 3 added add VERB ital-1859 28 4 chapter chapter NOUN ital-1859 28 5 12 12 NUM ital-1859 28 6 to to ADP ital-1859 28 7 the the DET ital-1859 28 8 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 28 9 . . PROPN ital-1859 28 10 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 28 11 act act PROPN ital-1859 28 12 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 28 13 17 17 NUM ital-1859 28 14 u.s.c u.s.c ADJ ital-1859 28 15 . . PUNCT ital-1859 29 1 § § NUM ital-1859 29 2 § § PROPN ital-1859 29 3 1201–1205 1201–1205 NUM ital-1859 29 4 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 30 1 , , PUNCT ital-1859 30 2 and and CCONJ ital-1859 30 3 it it PRON ital-1859 30 4 criminalized criminalize VERB ital-1859 30 5 the the DET ital-1859 30 6 trafficking trafficking NOUN ital-1859 30 7 of of ADP ital-1859 30 8 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 30 9 technologies technology NOUN ital-1859 30 10 designed design VERB ital-1859 30 11 to to PART ital-1859 30 12 circumvent circumvent VERB ital-1859 30 13 access access NOUN ital-1859 30 14 control control NOUN ital-1859 30 15 devices device NOUN ital-1859 30 16 protecting protect VERB ital-1859 30 17 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 30 18 material material NOUN ital-1859 30 19 from from ADP ital-1859 30 20 unauthorized unauthorized ADJ ital-1859 30 21 information information NOUN ital-1859 30 22 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 30 23 and and CCONJ ital-1859 30 24 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 30 25 | | ADP ital-1859 30 26 march march PROPN ital-1859 30 27 2012 2012 NUM ital-1859 30 28 9 9 NUM ital-1859 30 29 copying copying NOUN ital-1859 30 30 or or CCONJ ital-1859 30 31 use use NOUN ital-1859 30 32 . . PUNCT ital-1859 30 33 ”8 ”8 PUNCT ital-1859 30 34 while while SCONJ ital-1859 30 35 film film NOUN ital-1859 30 36 studios studio NOUN ital-1859 30 37 , , PUNCT ital-1859 30 38 e e NOUN ital-1859 30 39 - - NOUN ital-1859 30 40 book book ADJ ital-1859 30 41 publishers publisher NOUN ital-1859 30 42 , , PUNCT ital-1859 30 43 and and CCONJ ital-1859 30 44 record record NOUN ital-1859 30 45 producers producer NOUN ital-1859 30 46 have have VERB ital-1859 30 47 the the DET ital-1859 30 48 right right NOUN ital-1859 30 49 to to PART ital-1859 30 50 protect protect VERB ital-1859 30 51 their their PRON ital-1859 30 52 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 30 53 property property NOUN ital-1859 30 54 from from ADP ital-1859 30 55 illegal illegal ADJ ital-1859 30 56 pirating pirating NOUN ital-1859 30 57 , , PUNCT ital-1859 30 58 the the DET ital-1859 30 59 dmca dmca NOUN ital-1859 30 60 struck strike VERB ital-1859 30 61 a a DET ital-1859 30 62 serious serious ADJ ital-1859 30 63 blow blow NOUN ital-1859 30 64 to to ADP ital-1859 30 65 the the DET ital-1859 30 66 principle principle NOUN ital-1859 30 67 of of ADP ital-1859 30 68 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 30 69 use use NOUN ital-1859 30 70 , , PUNCT ital-1859 30 71 placing place VERB ital-1859 30 72 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 30 73 and and CCONJ ital-1859 30 74 others other NOUN ital-1859 30 75 who who PRON ital-1859 30 76 could could AUX ital-1859 30 77 likely likely ADV ital-1859 30 78 claim claim VERB ital-1859 30 79 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 30 80 use use NOUN ital-1859 30 81 when when SCONJ ital-1859 30 82 copying copy VERB ital-1859 30 83 a a DET ital-1859 30 84 dvd dvd NOUN ital-1859 30 85 or or CCONJ ital-1859 30 86 pdf pdf NOUN ital-1859 30 87 file file NOUN ital-1859 30 88 in in ADP ital-1859 30 89 a a DET ital-1859 30 90 catch-22 catch-22 PROPN ital-1859 30 91 scenario scenario NOUN ital-1859 30 92 . . PUNCT ital-1859 31 1 while while SCONJ ital-1859 31 2 the the DET ital-1859 31 3 act act NOUN ital-1859 31 4 of of ADP ital-1859 31 5 copying copy VERB ital-1859 31 6 the the DET ital-1859 31 7 file file NOUN ital-1859 31 8 may may AUX ital-1859 31 9 be be AUX ital-1859 31 10 legal legal ADJ ital-1859 31 11 according accord VERB ital-1859 31 12 to to ADP ital-1859 31 13 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 31 14 use use NOUN ital-1859 31 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 31 16 breaking break VERB ital-1859 31 17 through through ADP ital-1859 31 18 any any DET ital-1859 31 19 drm drm NOUN ital-1859 31 20 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 31 21 that that PRON ital-1859 31 22 prevents prevent VERB ital-1859 31 23 that that SCONJ ital-1859 31 24 copying copying NOUN ital-1859 31 25 is be AUX ital-1859 31 26 now now ADV ital-1859 31 27 illegal.9 illegal.9 PROPN ital-1859 31 28 the the DET ital-1859 31 29 sonny sonny PROPN ital-1859 31 30 bono bono X ital-1859 31 31 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 31 32 term term NOUN ital-1859 31 33 extension extension NOUN ital-1859 31 34 act act NOUN ital-1859 31 35 while while SCONJ ital-1859 31 36 the the DET ital-1859 31 37 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 31 38 act act NOUN ital-1859 31 39 of of ADP ital-1859 31 40 1790 1790 NUM ital-1859 31 41 only only ADV ital-1859 31 42 provided provide VERB ital-1859 31 43 authors author NOUN ital-1859 31 44 and and CCONJ ital-1859 31 45 publishers publisher NOUN ital-1859 31 46 with with ADP ital-1859 31 47 twenty twenty NUM ital-1859 31 48 - - PUNCT ital-1859 31 49 eight eight NUM ital-1859 31 50 years year NOUN ital-1859 31 51 of of ADP ital-1859 31 52 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 31 53 protection protection NOUN ital-1859 31 54 , , PUNCT ital-1859 31 55 the the DET ital-1859 31 56 sonny sonny PROPN ital-1859 31 57 bono bono X ital-1859 31 58 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 31 59 term term NOUN ital-1859 31 60 extension extension NOUN ital-1859 31 61 act act NOUN ital-1859 31 62 of of ADP ital-1859 31 63 1998 1998 NUM ital-1859 31 64 increased increase VERB ital-1859 31 65 the the DET ital-1859 31 66 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 31 67 terms term NOUN ital-1859 31 68 of of ADP ital-1859 31 69 all all DET ital-1859 31 70 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 31 71 works work NOUN ital-1859 31 72 that that PRON ital-1859 31 73 were be AUX ital-1859 31 74 eligible eligible ADJ ital-1859 31 75 for for ADP ital-1859 31 76 renewal renewal NOUN ital-1859 31 77 in in ADP ital-1859 31 78 1998 1998 NUM ital-1859 31 79 to to ADP ital-1859 31 80 ninety ninety NUM ital-1859 31 81 - - PUNCT ital-1859 31 82 five five NUM ital-1859 31 83 years year NOUN ital-1859 31 84 after after ADP ital-1859 31 85 the the DET ital-1859 31 86 year year NOUN ital-1859 31 87 of of ADP ital-1859 31 88 the the DET ital-1859 31 89 creator creator NOUN ital-1859 31 90 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 31 91 death death NOUN ital-1859 31 92 . . PUNCT ital-1859 32 1 in in ADP ital-1859 32 2 addition addition NOUN ital-1859 32 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 32 4 all all PRON ital-1859 32 5 works work VERB ital-1859 32 6 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 32 7 on on ADP ital-1859 32 8 or or CCONJ ital-1859 32 9 after after ADP ital-1859 32 10 january january PROPN ital-1859 32 11 1 1 NUM ital-1859 32 12 , , PUNCT ital-1859 32 13 1978 1978 NUM ital-1859 32 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 32 15 now now ADV ital-1859 32 16 receive receive VERB ital-1859 32 17 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 32 18 protection protection NOUN ital-1859 32 19 for for ADP ital-1859 32 20 the the DET ital-1859 32 21 life life NOUN ital-1859 32 22 of of ADP ital-1859 32 23 the the DET ital-1859 32 24 creator creator NOUN ital-1859 32 25 plus plus CCONJ ital-1859 32 26 seventy seventy NUM ital-1859 32 27 years year NOUN ital-1859 32 28 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 32 29 or or CCONJ ital-1859 32 30 ninety ninety NUM ital-1859 32 31 - - PUNCT ital-1859 32 32 five five NUM ital-1859 32 33 years year NOUN ital-1859 32 34 from from ADP ital-1859 32 35 the the DET ital-1859 32 36 date date NOUN ital-1859 32 37 of of ADP ital-1859 32 38 publication publication NOUN ital-1859 32 39 for for ADP ital-1859 32 40 works work NOUN ital-1859 32 41 produced produce VERB ital-1859 32 42 by by ADP ital-1859 32 43 multiple multiple ADJ ital-1859 32 44 creators).10 creators).10 PROPN ital-1859 32 45 jack jack NOUN ital-1859 32 46 valenti valenti NOUN ital-1859 32 47 , , PUNCT ital-1859 32 48 former former ADJ ital-1859 32 49 president president NOUN ital-1859 32 50 of of ADP ital-1859 32 51 the the DET ital-1859 32 52 motion motion NOUN ital-1859 32 53 picture picture NOUN ital-1859 32 54 association association NOUN ital-1859 32 55 of of ADP ital-1859 32 56 american american PROPN ital-1859 32 57 , , PUNCT ital-1859 32 58 was be AUX ital-1859 32 59 not not PART ital-1859 32 60 successful successful ADJ ital-1859 32 61 in in ADP ital-1859 32 62 pushing push VERB ital-1859 32 63 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 32 64 law law NOUN ital-1859 32 65 past past ADP ital-1859 32 66 the the DET ital-1859 32 67 bounds bound NOUN ital-1859 32 68 of of ADP ital-1859 32 69 the the DET ital-1859 32 70 constitution constitution NOUN ital-1859 32 71 , , PUNCT ital-1859 32 72 which which PRON ital-1859 32 73 mandates mandate VERB ital-1859 32 74 that that SCONJ ital-1859 32 75 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 32 76 be be AUX ital-1859 32 77 limited limited ADJ ital-1859 32 78 , , PUNCT ital-1859 32 79 although although SCONJ ital-1859 32 80 he he PRON ital-1859 32 81 did do AUX ital-1859 32 82 try try VERB ital-1859 32 83 to to PART ital-1859 32 84 circumvent circumvent VERB ital-1859 32 85 this this DET ital-1859 32 86 constitutional constitutional ADJ ital-1859 32 87 requirement requirement NOUN ital-1859 32 88 by by ADP ital-1859 32 89 suggesting suggest VERB ital-1859 32 90 that that SCONJ ital-1859 32 91 copyright copyright ADJ ital-1859 32 92 terms term NOUN ital-1859 32 93 last last VERB ital-1859 32 94 forever forever ADV ital-1859 32 95 less less ADV ital-1859 32 96 one one NUM ital-1859 32 97 day.11 day.11 ADP ital-1859 32 98 the the DET ital-1859 32 99 era era NOUN ital-1859 32 100 of of ADP ital-1859 32 101 automatic automatic ADJ ital-1859 32 102 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 32 103 registration registration NOUN ital-1859 32 104 perhaps perhaps ADV ital-1859 32 105 the the DET ital-1859 32 106 most most ADV ital-1859 32 107 problematic problematic ADJ ital-1859 32 108 facet facet NOUN ital-1859 32 109 of of ADP ital-1859 32 110 modern modern ADJ ital-1859 32 111 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 32 112 . . PROPN ital-1859 32 113 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 32 114 law law NOUN ital-1859 32 115 appears appear VERB ital-1859 32 116 at at ADP ital-1859 32 117 first first ADJ ital-1859 32 118 glance glance NOUN ital-1859 32 119 to to PART ital-1859 32 120 be be AUX ital-1859 32 121 the the DET ital-1859 32 122 most most ADV ital-1859 32 123 innocuous innocuous ADJ ital-1859 32 124 . . PUNCT ital-1859 33 1 the the DET ital-1859 33 2 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 33 3 act act PROPN ital-1859 33 4 of of ADP ital-1859 33 5 1976 1976 NUM ital-1859 33 6 did do VERB ital-1859 33 7 away away ADV ital-1859 33 8 with with ADP ital-1859 33 9 the the DET ital-1859 33 10 registration registration NOUN ital-1859 33 11 requirement requirement NOUN ital-1859 33 12 established establish VERB ital-1859 33 13 by by ADP ital-1859 33 14 the the DET ital-1859 33 15 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 33 16 act act NOUN ital-1859 33 17 of of ADP ital-1859 33 18 1790.12 1790.12 NUM ital-1859 33 19 that that PRON ital-1859 33 20 means mean VERB ital-1859 33 21 that that SCONJ ital-1859 33 22 any any DET ital-1859 33 23 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 33 24 work work NOUN ital-1859 33 25 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 33 26 fixed fix VERB ital-1859 33 27 in in ADP ital-1859 33 28 any any DET ital-1859 33 29 tangible tangible ADJ ital-1859 33 30 medium medium NOUN ital-1859 33 31 of of ADP ital-1859 33 32 expression expression NOUN ital-1859 33 33 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 33 34 is be AUX ital-1859 33 35 automatically automatically ADV ital-1859 33 36 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 33 37 at at ADP ital-1859 33 38 the the DET ital-1859 33 39 moment moment NOUN ital-1859 33 40 of of ADP ital-1859 33 41 its its PRON ital-1859 33 42 creation.13 creation.13 NOUN ital-1859 33 43 that that PRON ital-1859 33 44 includes include VERB ital-1859 33 45 family family NOUN ital-1859 33 46 vacation vacation NOUN ital-1859 33 47 photos photo NOUN ital-1859 33 48 stored store VERB ital-1859 33 49 on on ADP ital-1859 33 50 a a DET ital-1859 33 51 computer computer NOUN ital-1859 33 52 hard hard ADJ ital-1859 33 53 drive drive NOUN ital-1859 33 54 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 33 55 they they PRON ital-1859 33 56 are be AUX ital-1859 33 57 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 33 58 and and CCONJ ital-1859 33 59 your your PRON ital-1859 33 60 permission permission NOUN ital-1859 33 61 is be AUX ital-1859 33 62 required require VERB ital-1859 33 63 to to PART ital-1859 33 64 use use VERB ital-1859 33 65 them they PRON ital-1859 33 66 . . PUNCT ital-1859 34 1 the the DET ital-1859 34 2 previous previous ADJ ital-1859 34 3 requirement requirement NOUN ital-1859 34 4 of of ADP ital-1859 34 5 registration registration NOUN ital-1859 34 6 meant mean VERB ital-1859 34 7 authors author NOUN ital-1859 34 8 and and CCONJ ital-1859 34 9 creators creator NOUN ital-1859 34 10 had have VERB ital-1859 34 11 to to PART ital-1859 34 12 actively actively ADV ital-1859 34 13 register register VERB ital-1859 34 14 their their PRON ital-1859 34 15 works work NOUN ital-1859 34 16 , , PUNCT ital-1859 34 17 so so ADV ital-1859 34 18 anything anything PRON ital-1859 34 19 that that PRON ital-1859 34 20 was be AUX ital-1859 34 21 not not PART ital-1859 34 22 registered register VERB ital-1859 34 23 entered enter VERB ital-1859 34 24 the the DET ital-1859 34 25 public public ADJ ital-1859 34 26 domain domain NOUN ital-1859 34 27 , , PUNCT ital-1859 34 28 replenishing replenish VERB ital-1859 34 29 that that DET ital-1859 34 30 important important ADJ ital-1859 34 31 cultural cultural ADJ ital-1859 34 32 realm.14 realm.14 NOUN ital-1859 34 33 now now ADV ital-1859 34 34 that that SCONJ ital-1859 34 35 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 34 36 attaches attach VERB ital-1859 34 37 at at ADP ital-1859 34 38 the the DET ital-1859 34 39 moment moment NOUN ital-1859 34 40 an an DET ital-1859 34 41 idea idea NOUN ital-1859 34 42 is be AUX ital-1859 34 43 expressed express VERB ital-1859 34 44 through through ADP ital-1859 34 45 a a DET ital-1859 34 46 cocktail cocktail NOUN ital-1859 34 47 napkin napkin NOUN ital-1859 34 48 doodle doodle NOUN ital-1859 34 49 or or CCONJ ital-1859 34 50 an an DET ital-1859 34 51 outline outline NOUN ital-1859 34 52 , , PUNCT ital-1859 34 53 virtually virtually ADV ital-1859 34 54 nothing nothing PRON ital-1859 34 55 new new ADJ ital-1859 34 56 enters enter VERB ital-1859 34 57 the the DET ital-1859 34 58 public public ADJ ital-1859 34 59 domain domain NOUN ital-1859 34 60 until until SCONJ ital-1859 34 61 its its PRON ital-1859 34 62 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 34 63 term term NOUN ital-1859 34 64 expires expire VERB ital-1859 34 65 — — PUNCT ital-1859 34 66 at at ADV ital-1859 34 67 least least ADV ital-1859 34 68 seventy seventy NUM ital-1859 34 69 years year NOUN ital-1859 34 70 later later ADV ital-1859 34 71 . . PUNCT ital-1859 35 1 in in ADP ital-1859 35 2 fact fact NOUN ital-1859 35 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 35 4 nothing nothing PRON ital-1859 35 5 new new ADJ ital-1859 35 6 will will AUX ital-1859 35 7 enter enter VERB ital-1859 35 8 the the DET ital-1859 35 9 public public ADJ ital-1859 35 10 domain domain NOUN ital-1859 35 11 through through ADP ital-1859 35 12 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 35 13 expiration expiration NOUN ital-1859 35 14 until until ADP ital-1859 35 15 2019 2019 NUM ital-1859 35 16 . . PUNCT ital-1859 36 1 until until ADP ital-1859 36 2 then then ADV ital-1859 36 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 36 4 the the DET ital-1859 36 5 public public ADJ ital-1859 36 6 domain domain NOUN ital-1859 36 7 is be AUX ital-1859 36 8 essentially essentially ADV ital-1859 36 9 frozen freeze VERB ital-1859 36 10 in in ADP ital-1859 36 11 the the DET ital-1859 36 12 year year NOUN ital-1859 36 13 1922.15 1922.15 NUM ital-1859 36 14 the the DET ital-1859 36 15 problem problem NOUN ital-1859 36 16 of of ADP ital-1859 36 17 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 36 18 works work VERB ital-1859 36 19 in in ADP ital-1859 36 20 addition addition NOUN ital-1859 36 21 , , PUNCT ital-1859 36 22 the the DET ital-1859 36 23 incredibly incredibly ADV ital-1859 36 24 long long ADJ ital-1859 36 25 copyright copyright ADJ ital-1859 36 26 terms term NOUN ital-1859 36 27 that that PRON ital-1859 36 28 apply apply VERB ital-1859 36 29 to to ADP ital-1859 36 30 all all DET ital-1859 36 31 books book NOUN ital-1859 36 32 , , PUNCT ital-1859 36 33 photographs photograph NOUN ital-1859 36 34 , , PUNCT ital-1859 36 35 and and CCONJ ital-1859 36 36 sound sound ADJ ital-1859 36 37 recordings recording NOUN ital-1859 36 38 have have AUX ital-1859 36 39 created create VERB ital-1859 36 40 the the DET ital-1859 36 41 problem problem NOUN ital-1859 36 42 of of ADP ital-1859 36 43 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 36 44 works work VERB ital-1859 36 45 . . PUNCT ital-1859 37 1 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 37 2 works work NOUN ital-1859 37 3 are be AUX ital-1859 37 4 those those DET ital-1859 37 5 works work NOUN ital-1859 37 6 that that PRON ital-1859 37 7 are be AUX ital-1859 37 8 under under ADP ital-1859 37 9 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 37 10 protection protection NOUN ital-1859 37 11 , , PUNCT ital-1859 37 12 but but CCONJ ital-1859 37 13 whose whose DET ital-1859 37 14 owners owner NOUN ital-1859 37 15 are be AUX ital-1859 37 16 difficult difficult ADJ ital-1859 37 17 or or CCONJ ital-1859 37 18 impossible impossible ADJ ital-1859 37 19 to to PART ital-1859 37 20 locate locate VERB ital-1859 37 21 , , PUNCT ital-1859 37 22 often often ADV ital-1859 37 23 due due ADJ ital-1859 37 24 to to ADP ital-1859 37 25 death.16 death.16 PROPN ital-1859 37 26 these these DET ital-1859 37 27 publications publication NOUN ital-1859 37 28 are be AUX ital-1859 37 29 problematic problematic ADJ ital-1859 37 30 for for ADP ital-1859 37 31 researchers researcher NOUN ital-1859 37 32 , , PUNCT ital-1859 37 33 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 37 34 , , PUNCT ital-1859 37 35 and and CCONJ ital-1859 37 36 the the DET ital-1859 37 37 public public NOUN ital-1859 37 38 in in ADP ital-1859 37 39 general general ADJ ital-1859 37 40 : : PUNCT ital-1859 37 41 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 37 42 works work NOUN ital-1859 37 43 are be AUX ital-1859 37 44 perceived perceive VERB ital-1859 37 45 to to PART ital-1859 37 46 be be AUX ital-1859 37 47 inaccessible inaccessible ADJ ital-1859 37 48 because because SCONJ ital-1859 37 49 of of ADP ital-1859 37 50 the the DET ital-1859 37 51 risk risk NOUN ital-1859 37 52 of of ADP ital-1859 37 53 infringement infringement NOUN ital-1859 37 54 liability liability NOUN ital-1859 37 55 that that PRON ital-1859 37 56 a a DET ital-1859 37 57 user user NOUN ital-1859 37 58 might might AUX ital-1859 37 59 incur incur VERB ital-1859 37 60 if if SCONJ ital-1859 37 61 and and CCONJ ital-1859 37 62 when when SCONJ ital-1859 37 63 a a DET ital-1859 37 64 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 37 65 owner owner NOUN ital-1859 37 66 subsequently subsequently ADV ital-1859 37 67 appears appear VERB ital-1859 37 68 . . PUNCT ital-1859 38 1 consequently consequently ADV ital-1859 38 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 38 3 many many ADJ ital-1859 38 4 works work NOUN ital-1859 38 5 that that PRON ital-1859 38 6 are be AUX ital-1859 38 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 38 8 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 38 9 : : PUNCT ital-1859 38 10 regulation regulation NOUN ital-1859 38 11 out out ADP ital-1859 38 12 of of ADP ital-1859 38 13 line line NOUN ital-1859 38 14 with with ADP ital-1859 38 15 our our PRON ital-1859 38 16 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 38 17 reality reality NOUN ital-1859 38 18 | | PROPN ital-1859 38 19 mcdermott mcdermott PROPN ital-1859 38 20 10 10 NUM ital-1859 38 21 in in ADP ital-1859 38 22 fact fact NOUN ital-1859 38 23 , , PUNCT ital-1859 38 24 abandoned abandon VERB ital-1859 38 25 by by ADP ital-1859 38 26 owners owner NOUN ital-1859 38 27 are be AUX ital-1859 38 28 withheld withhold VERB ital-1859 38 29 from from ADP ital-1859 38 30 public public ADJ ital-1859 38 31 view view NOUN ital-1859 38 32 and and CCONJ ital-1859 38 33 circulation circulation NOUN ital-1859 38 34 because because SCONJ ital-1859 38 35 of of ADP ital-1859 38 36 uncertainty uncertainty NOUN ital-1859 38 37 about about ADP ital-1859 38 38 the the DET ital-1859 38 39 owner owner NOUN ital-1859 38 40 and and CCONJ ital-1859 38 41 the the DET ital-1859 38 42 risk risk NOUN ital-1859 38 43 of of ADP ital-1859 38 44 liability.17 liability.17 NOUN ital-1859 38 45 if if SCONJ ital-1859 38 46 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 38 47 expired expire VERB ital-1859 38 48 with with ADP ital-1859 38 49 the the DET ital-1859 38 50 death death NOUN ital-1859 38 51 of of ADP ital-1859 38 52 the the DET ital-1859 38 53 author author NOUN ital-1859 38 54 , , PUNCT ital-1859 38 55 or or CCONJ ital-1859 38 56 if if SCONJ ital-1859 38 57 there there PRON ital-1859 38 58 were be VERB ital-1859 38 59 a a DET ital-1859 38 60 clause clause NOUN ital-1859 38 61 that that PRON ital-1859 38 62 would would AUX ital-1859 38 63 allow allow VERB ital-1859 38 64 these these DET ital-1859 38 65 works work NOUN ital-1859 38 66 to to PART ital-1859 38 67 pass pass VERB ital-1859 38 68 into into ADP ital-1859 38 69 the the DET ital-1859 38 70 public public ADJ ital-1859 38 71 domain domain NOUN ital-1859 38 72 if if SCONJ ital-1859 38 73 the the DET ital-1859 38 74 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 38 75 holder holder PROPN ital-1859 38 76 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 38 77 heirs heir NOUN ital-1859 38 78 did do AUX ital-1859 38 79 not not PART ital-1859 38 80 actively actively ADV ital-1859 38 81 renew renew VERB ital-1859 38 82 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 38 83 for for ADP ital-1859 38 84 another another DET ital-1859 38 85 term term NOUN ital-1859 38 86 , , PUNCT ital-1859 38 87 then then ADV ital-1859 38 88 these these DET ital-1859 38 89 materials material NOUN ital-1859 38 90 would would AUX ital-1859 38 91 be be AUX ital-1859 38 92 far far ADV ital-1859 38 93 less less ADV ital-1859 38 94 likely likely ADJ ital-1859 38 95 to to PART ital-1859 38 96 fall fall VERB ital-1859 38 97 into into ADP ital-1859 38 98 legal legal ADJ ital-1859 38 99 limbo limbo NOUN ital-1859 38 100 . . PUNCT ital-1859 39 1 currently currently ADV ital-1859 39 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 39 3 many many ADJ ital-1859 39 4 are be AUX ital-1859 39 5 protected protect VERB ital-1859 39 6 despite despite SCONJ ital-1859 39 7 the the DET ital-1859 39 8 fact fact NOUN ital-1859 39 9 that that SCONJ ital-1859 39 10 acquiring acquire VERB ital-1859 39 11 permission permission NOUN ital-1859 39 12 to to PART ital-1859 39 13 use use VERB ital-1859 39 14 them they PRON ital-1859 39 15 is be AUX ital-1859 39 16 all all PRON ital-1859 39 17 but but CCONJ ital-1859 39 18 impossible impossible ADJ ital-1859 39 19 . . PUNCT ital-1859 40 1 a a DET ital-1859 40 2 study study NOUN ital-1859 40 3 of of ADP ital-1859 40 4 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 40 5 works work VERB ital-1859 40 6 in in ADP ital-1859 40 7 the the DET ital-1859 40 8 collections collection NOUN ital-1859 40 9 of of ADP ital-1859 40 10 united united PROPN ital-1859 40 11 kingdom kingdom PROPN ital-1859 40 12 public public ADJ ital-1859 40 13 sector sector NOUN ital-1859 40 14 institutions institution NOUN ital-1859 40 15 found find VERB ital-1859 40 16 that that SCONJ ital-1859 40 17 these these DET ital-1859 40 18 works work NOUN ital-1859 40 19 are be AUX ital-1859 40 20 likely likely ADJ ital-1859 40 21 to to PART ital-1859 40 22 have have VERB ital-1859 40 23 little little ADJ ital-1859 40 24 commercial commercial ADJ ital-1859 40 25 value value NOUN ital-1859 40 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 40 27 but but CCONJ ital-1859 40 28 high high ADJ ital-1859 40 29 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 40 30 academic academic ADJ ital-1859 40 31 and and CCONJ ital-1859 40 32 cultural cultural ADJ ital-1859 40 33 significance significance NOUN ital-1859 40 34 , , PUNCT ital-1859 40 35 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 40 36 and and CCONJ ital-1859 40 37 when when SCONJ ital-1859 40 38 contacted contact VERB ital-1859 40 39 , , PUNCT ital-1859 40 40 these these DET ital-1859 40 41 difficult difficult ADJ ital-1859 40 42 - - PUNCT ital-1859 40 43 to to ADP ital-1859 40 44 - - PUNCT ital-1859 40 45 trace trace NOUN ital-1859 40 46 rights right NOUN ital-1859 40 47 holders holder NOUN ital-1859 40 48 often often ADV ital-1859 40 49 grant grant VERB ital-1859 40 50 permission permission NOUN ital-1859 40 51 for for ADP ital-1859 40 52 reproduction reproduction NOUN ital-1859 40 53 without without ADP ital-1859 40 54 asking ask VERB ital-1859 40 55 for for ADP ital-1859 40 56 compensation.18 compensation.18 NOUN ital-1859 40 57 put put VERB ital-1859 40 58 another another DET ital-1859 40 59 way way NOUN ital-1859 40 60 , , PUNCT ital-1859 40 61 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 40 62 works work NOUN ital-1859 40 63 are be AUX ital-1859 40 64 essentially essentially ADV ital-1859 40 65 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 40 66 locking lock VERB ital-1859 40 67 up up ADP ital-1859 40 68 culture culture NOUN ital-1859 40 69 and and CCONJ ital-1859 40 70 other other ADJ ital-1859 40 71 public public ADJ ital-1859 40 72 sector sector NOUN ital-1859 40 73 content content NOUN ital-1859 40 74 and and CCONJ ital-1859 40 75 preventing prevent VERB ital-1859 40 76 organizations organization NOUN ital-1859 40 77 from from ADP ital-1859 40 78 serving serve VERB ital-1859 40 79 the the DET ital-1859 40 80 public public ADJ ital-1859 40 81 interest interest NOUN ital-1859 40 82 . . PUNCT ital-1859 41 1 ”19 ”19 VERB ital-1859 41 2 the the DET ital-1859 41 3 row row NOUN ital-1859 41 4 that that PRON ital-1859 41 5 arose arise VERB ital-1859 41 6 in in ADP ital-1859 41 7 september september PROPN ital-1859 41 8 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 41 9 between between ADP ital-1859 41 10 the the DET ital-1859 41 11 hathitrust hathitrust ADJ ital-1859 41 12 institutions institution NOUN ital-1859 41 13 and and CCONJ ital-1859 41 14 the the DET ital-1859 41 15 authors author NOUN ital-1859 41 16 guild guild VERB ital-1859 41 17 over over ADP ital-1859 41 18 the the DET ital-1859 41 19 university university PROPN ital-1859 41 20 of of ADP ital-1859 41 21 michigan michigan PROPN ital-1859 41 22 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 41 23 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 41 24 works work VERB ital-1859 41 25 digitization digitization NOUN ital-1859 41 26 project project NOUN ital-1859 41 27 , , PUNCT ital-1859 41 28 with with ADP ital-1859 41 29 j. j. PROPN ital-1859 41 30 r. r. PROPN ital-1859 41 31 salamanca salamanca PROPN ital-1859 41 32 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 41 33 longout longout NOUN ital-1859 41 34 - - PUNCT ital-1859 41 35 of of ADP ital-1859 41 36 - - PUNCT ital-1859 41 37 print print NOUN ital-1859 41 38 1958 1958 NUM ital-1859 41 39 novel novel NOUN ital-1859 41 40 the the DET ital-1859 41 41 lost lose VERB ital-1859 41 42 country country NOUN ital-1859 41 43 serving serve VERB ital-1859 41 44 as as ADP ital-1859 41 45 the the DET ital-1859 41 46 pivot pivot PROPN ital-1859 41 47 point point NOUN ital-1859 41 48 in in ADP ital-1859 41 49 the the DET ital-1859 41 50 dispute dispute NOUN ital-1859 41 51 , , PUNCT ital-1859 41 52 is be AUX ital-1859 41 53 an an DET ital-1859 41 54 example example NOUN ital-1859 41 55 of of ADP ital-1859 41 56 the the DET ital-1859 41 57 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 41 58 works work VERB ital-1859 41 59 problem problem NOUN ital-1859 41 60 . . PUNCT ital-1859 42 1 the the DET ital-1859 42 2 fact fact NOUN ital-1859 42 3 that that SCONJ ital-1859 42 4 university university PROPN ital-1859 42 5 of of ADP ital-1859 42 6 michigan michigan PROPN ital-1859 42 7 associate associate PROPN ital-1859 42 8 university university PROPN ital-1859 42 9 librarian librarian PROPN ital-1859 42 10 john john PROPN ital-1859 42 11 price price PROPN ital-1859 42 12 wilkin wilkin PROPN ital-1859 42 13 was be AUX ital-1859 42 14 forced force VERB ital-1859 42 15 to to PART ital-1859 42 16 assure assure VERB ital-1859 42 17 the the DET ital-1859 42 18 public public NOUN ital-1859 42 19 that that SCONJ ital-1859 42 20 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 42 21 no no DET ital-1859 42 22 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 42 23 books book NOUN ital-1859 42 24 were be AUX ital-1859 42 25 made make VERB ital-1859 42 26 accessible accessible ADJ ital-1859 42 27 to to ADP ital-1859 42 28 any any DET ital-1859 42 29 students student NOUN ital-1859 42 30 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 42 31 illustrates illustrate VERB ital-1859 42 32 the the DET ital-1859 42 33 absurdity absurdity NOUN ital-1859 42 34 in in ADP ital-1859 42 35 arguing argue VERB ital-1859 42 36 over over ADP ital-1859 42 37 whether whether SCONJ ital-1859 42 38 it it PRON ital-1859 42 39 ’s ’ VERB ital-1859 42 40 right right ADJ ital-1859 42 41 to to PART ital-1859 42 42 digitize digitize VERB ital-1859 42 43 books book NOUN ital-1859 42 44 that that PRON ital-1859 42 45 are be AUX ital-1859 42 46 no no ADV ital-1859 42 47 longer long ADV ital-1859 42 48 even even ADV ital-1859 42 49 accessible accessible ADJ ital-1859 42 50 in in ADP ital-1859 42 51 their their PRON ital-1859 42 52 printed print VERB ital-1859 42 53 form.20 form.20 NOUN ital-1859 42 54 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 42 55 , , PUNCT ital-1859 42 56 digitization digitization NOUN ital-1859 42 57 , , PUNCT ital-1859 42 58 and and CCONJ ital-1859 42 59 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 42 60 law law NOUN ital-1859 42 61 : : PUNCT ital-1859 42 62 the the DET ital-1859 42 63 quiet quiet ADJ ital-1859 42 64 crisis crisis NOUN ital-1859 42 65 while while SCONJ ital-1859 42 66 one one PRON ital-1859 42 67 can can AUX ital-1859 42 68 debate debate VERB ital-1859 42 69 if if SCONJ ital-1859 42 70 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 42 71 . . PROPN ital-1859 42 72 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 42 73 law law NOUN ital-1859 42 74 is be AUX ital-1859 42 75 still still ADV ital-1859 42 76 oriented orient VERB ital-1859 42 77 toward toward ADP ital-1859 42 78 the the DET ital-1859 42 79 public public ADJ ital-1859 42 80 good good NOUN ital-1859 42 81 , , PUNCT ital-1859 42 82 the the DET ital-1859 42 83 more more ADV ital-1859 42 84 relevant relevant ADJ ital-1859 42 85 question question NOUN ital-1859 42 86 in in ADP ital-1859 42 87 this this DET ital-1859 42 88 context context NOUN ital-1859 42 89 is be AUX ital-1859 42 90 the the DET ital-1859 42 91 effect effect NOUN ital-1859 42 92 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 42 93 law law NOUN ital-1859 42 94 has have VERB ital-1859 42 95 on on ADP ital-1859 42 96 the the DET ital-1859 42 97 library library NOUN ital-1859 42 98 profession profession NOUN ital-1859 42 99 . . PUNCT ital-1859 43 1 drm drm PROPN ital-1859 43 2 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 43 3 can can AUX ital-1859 43 4 get get VERB ital-1859 43 5 in in ADP ital-1859 43 6 the the DET ital-1859 43 7 way way NOUN ital-1859 43 8 of of ADP ital-1859 43 9 serving serve VERB ital-1859 43 10 library library NOUN ital-1859 43 11 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 43 12 with with ADP ital-1859 43 13 visual visual ADJ ital-1859 43 14 disabilities disability NOUN ital-1859 43 15 and and CCONJ ital-1859 43 16 every every DET ital-1859 43 17 library library NOUN ital-1859 43 18 needs need VERB ital-1859 43 19 to to PART ital-1859 43 20 place place VERB ital-1859 43 21 a a DET ital-1859 43 22 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 43 23 disclaimer disclaimer NOUN ital-1859 43 24 on on ADP ital-1859 43 25 the the DET ital-1859 43 26 photocopiers photocopier NOUN ital-1859 43 27 , , PUNCT ital-1859 43 28 but but CCONJ ital-1859 43 29 how how SCONJ ital-1859 43 30 much much ADV ital-1859 43 31 more more ADJ ital-1859 43 32 of of ADP ital-1859 43 33 a a DET ital-1859 43 34 stumbling stumble VERB ital-1859 43 35 block block NOUN ital-1859 43 36 is be AUX ital-1859 43 37 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 43 38 property property NOUN ital-1859 43 39 law law NOUN ital-1859 43 40 to to ADP ital-1859 43 41 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 43 42 in in ADP ital-1859 43 43 general general ADJ ital-1859 43 44 , , PUNCT ital-1859 43 45 and and CCONJ ital-1859 43 46 the the DET ital-1859 43 47 advance advance NOUN ital-1859 43 48 of of ADP ital-1859 43 49 library library NOUN ital-1859 43 50 systems system NOUN ital-1859 43 51 and and CCONJ ital-1859 43 52 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 43 53 in in ADP ital-1859 43 54 particular particular ADJ ital-1859 43 55 ? ? PUNCT ital-1859 44 1 the the DET ital-1859 44 2 answer answer NOUN ital-1859 44 3 is be AUX ital-1859 44 4 undeniably undeniably ADV ital-1859 44 5 that that SCONJ ital-1859 44 6 current current ADJ ital-1859 44 7 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 44 8 . . PROPN ital-1859 44 9 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 44 10 legislation legislation NOUN ital-1859 44 11 places place VERB ital-1859 44 12 obstacles obstacle NOUN ital-1859 44 13 in in ADP ital-1859 44 14 the the DET ital-1859 44 15 way way NOUN ital-1859 44 16 of of ADP ital-1859 44 17 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 44 18 working work VERB ital-1859 44 19 in in ADP ital-1859 44 20 all all DET ital-1859 44 21 types type NOUN ital-1859 44 22 of of ADP ital-1859 44 23 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 44 24 . . PUNCT ital-1859 45 1 while while SCONJ ital-1859 45 2 there there PRON ital-1859 45 3 are be VERB ital-1859 45 4 many many ADJ ital-1859 45 5 ways way NOUN ital-1859 45 6 that that SCONJ ital-1859 45 7 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 45 8 law law NOUN ital-1859 45 9 affects affect VERB ital-1859 45 10 library library NOUN ital-1859 45 11 services service NOUN ital-1859 45 12 and and CCONJ ital-1859 45 13 collections collection NOUN ital-1859 45 14 in in ADP ital-1859 45 15 this this DET ital-1859 45 16 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 45 17 area area NOUN ital-1859 45 18 , , PUNCT ital-1859 45 19 three three NUM ital-1859 45 20 challenges challenge NOUN ital-1859 45 21 are be AUX ital-1859 45 22 particularly particularly ADV ital-1859 45 23 pressing press VERB ital-1859 45 24 : : PUNCT ital-1859 45 25 the the DET ital-1859 45 26 problem problem NOUN ital-1859 45 27 of of ADP ital-1859 45 28 ownership ownership NOUN ital-1859 45 29 and and CCONJ ital-1859 45 30 licensing licensing NOUN ital-1859 45 31 of of ADP ital-1859 45 32 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 45 33 content content NOUN ital-1859 45 34 or or CCONJ ital-1859 45 35 collections collection NOUN ital-1859 45 36 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 45 37 the the DET ital-1859 45 38 librarian librarian NOUN ital-1859 45 39 as as ADP ital-1859 45 40 de de X ital-1859 45 41 facto facto X ital-1859 45 42 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 45 43 expert expert NOUN ital-1859 45 44 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 45 45 and and CCONJ ital-1859 45 46 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 45 47 law law NOUN ital-1859 45 48 as as SCONJ ital-1859 45 49 it it PRON ital-1859 45 50 relates relate VERB ital-1859 45 51 to to ADP ital-1859 45 52 library library NOUN ital-1859 45 53 digitization digitization NOUN ital-1859 45 54 programs program NOUN ital-1859 45 55 generally generally ADV ital-1859 45 56 , , PUNCT ital-1859 45 57 and and CCONJ ital-1859 45 58 the the DET ital-1859 45 59 google google PROPN ital-1859 45 60 book book PROPN ital-1859 45 61 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 45 62 in in ADP ital-1859 45 63 particular particular ADJ ital-1859 45 64 . . PUNCT ital-1859 46 1 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 46 2 collections collection NOUN ital-1859 46 3 : : PUNCT ital-1859 46 4 licenses license NOUN ital-1859 46 5 replace replace VERB ital-1859 46 6 ownership ownership NOUN ital-1859 46 7 in in ADP ital-1859 46 8 the the DET ital-1859 46 9 past past NOUN ital-1859 46 10 , , PUNCT ital-1859 46 11 people people NOUN ital-1859 46 12 bought buy VERB ital-1859 46 13 a a DET ital-1859 46 14 book book NOUN ital-1859 46 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 46 16 and and CCONJ ital-1859 46 17 they they PRON ital-1859 46 18 owned own VERB ital-1859 46 19 that that DET ital-1859 46 20 copy copy NOUN ital-1859 46 21 . . PUNCT ital-1859 47 1 there there PRON ital-1859 47 2 was be VERB ital-1859 47 3 little little ADJ ital-1859 47 4 they they PRON ital-1859 47 5 could could AUX ital-1859 47 6 accidentally accidentally ADV ital-1859 47 7 or or CCONJ ital-1859 47 8 unknowingly unknowingly ADV ital-1859 47 9 do do VERB ital-1859 47 10 to to PART ital-1859 47 11 infringe infringe VERB ital-1859 47 12 on on ADP ital-1859 47 13 the the DET ital-1859 47 14 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 47 15 holder holder PROPN ital-1859 47 16 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 47 17 rights right NOUN ital-1859 47 18 . . PUNCT ital-1859 48 1 likewise likewise ADV ital-1859 48 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 48 3 when when SCONJ ital-1859 48 4 physical physical ADJ ital-1859 48 5 collections collection NOUN ital-1859 48 6 were be AUX ital-1859 48 7 their their PRON ital-1859 48 8 only only ADJ ital-1859 48 9 concern concern NOUN ital-1859 48 10 , , PUNCT ital-1859 48 11 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 48 12 could could AUX ital-1859 48 13 rely rely VERB ital-1859 48 14 on on ADP ital-1859 48 15 sections section NOUN ital-1859 48 16 108 108 NUM ital-1859 48 17 and and CCONJ ital-1859 48 18 109 109 NUM ital-1859 48 19 of of ADP ital-1859 48 20 the the DET ital-1859 48 21 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 48 22 law law NOUN ital-1859 48 23 to to PART ital-1859 48 24 protect protect VERB ital-1859 48 25 them they PRON ital-1859 48 26 from from ADP ital-1859 48 27 liability liability NOUN ital-1859 48 28 when when SCONJ ital-1859 48 29 they they PRON ital-1859 48 30 copied copy VERB ital-1859 48 31 a a DET ital-1859 48 32 book book NOUN ital-1859 48 33 or or CCONJ ital-1859 48 34 other other ADJ ital-1859 48 35 work work NOUN ital-1859 48 36 and and CCONJ ital-1859 48 37 when when SCONJ ital-1859 48 38 they they PRON ital-1859 48 39 loaned loan VERB ital-1859 48 40 materials material NOUN ital-1859 48 41 in in ADP ital-1859 48 42 their their PRON ital-1859 48 43 collections collection NOUN ital-1859 48 44 to to PART ital-1859 48 45 patrons.21 patrons.21 VERB ital-1859 48 46 today today NOUN ital-1859 48 47 , , PUNCT ital-1859 48 48 we we PRON ital-1859 48 49 live live VERB ital-1859 48 50 partly partly ADV ital-1859 48 51 in in ADP ital-1859 48 52 the the DET ital-1859 48 53 physical physical ADJ ital-1859 48 54 world world NOUN ital-1859 48 55 and and CCONJ ital-1859 48 56 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote19#footnote19 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote19#footnote19 VERB ital-1859 48 57 information information NOUN ital-1859 48 58 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 48 59 and and CCONJ ital-1859 48 60 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 48 61 | | ADP ital-1859 48 62 march march PROPN ital-1859 48 63 2012 2012 NUM ital-1859 48 64 11 11 NUM ital-1859 48 65 partly partly ADV ital-1859 48 66 in in ADP ital-1859 48 67 the the DET ital-1859 48 68 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 48 69 world world NOUN ital-1859 48 70 , , PUNCT ital-1859 48 71 reaching reach VERB ital-1859 48 72 out out ADP ital-1859 48 73 and and CCONJ ital-1859 48 74 connecting connect VERB ital-1859 48 75 to to ADP ital-1859 48 76 each each DET ital-1859 48 77 other other ADJ ital-1859 48 78 across across ADP ital-1859 48 79 fiber fiber NOUN ital-1859 48 80 optic optic NOUN ital-1859 48 81 lines line NOUN ital-1859 48 82 in in ADP ital-1859 48 83 the the DET ital-1859 48 84 same same ADJ ital-1859 48 85 way way NOUN ital-1859 48 86 we we PRON ital-1859 48 87 once once ADV ital-1859 48 88 did do VERB ital-1859 48 89 around around ADP ital-1859 48 90 the the DET ital-1859 48 91 water water NOUN ital-1859 48 92 cooler cooler NOUN ital-1859 48 93 . . PUNCT ital-1859 49 1 likewise likewise ADV ital-1859 49 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 49 3 the the DET ital-1859 49 4 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 49 5 means mean NOUN ital-1859 49 6 of of ADP ital-1859 49 7 production production NOUN ital-1859 49 8 are be AUX ital-1859 49 9 widely widely ADV ital-1859 49 10 distributed distribute VERB ital-1859 49 11 . . PUNCT ital-1859 50 1 in in ADP ital-1859 50 2 a a DET ital-1859 50 3 multimedia multimedia NOUN ital-1859 50 4 world world NOUN ital-1859 50 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 50 6 where where SCONJ ital-1859 50 7 sharing share VERB ital-1859 50 8 an an DET ital-1859 50 9 informative informative ADJ ital-1859 50 10 or or CCONJ ital-1859 50 11 entertaining entertaining ADJ ital-1859 50 12 video video NOUN ital-1859 50 13 clip clip NOUN ital-1859 50 14 is be AUX ital-1859 50 15 as as ADV ital-1859 50 16 easy easy ADJ ital-1859 50 17 as as ADP ital-1859 50 18 embedding embed VERB ital-1859 50 19 a a DET ital-1859 50 20 link link NOUN ital-1859 50 21 onto onto ADP ital-1859 50 22 someone someone PRON ital-1859 50 23 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 50 24 facebook facebook PROPN ital-1859 50 25 wall wall NOUN ital-1859 50 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 50 27 the the DET ital-1859 50 28 temptation temptation NOUN ital-1859 50 29 to to PART ital-1859 50 30 infringe infringe VERB ital-1859 50 31 on on ADP ital-1859 50 32 rights right NOUN ital-1859 50 33 by by ADP ital-1859 50 34 distributing distribute VERB ital-1859 50 35 , , PUNCT ital-1859 50 36 reproducing reproduce VERB ital-1859 50 37 , , PUNCT ital-1859 50 38 or or CCONJ ital-1859 50 39 displaying display VERB ital-1859 50 40 a a DET ital-1859 50 41 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 50 42 work work NOUN ital-1859 50 43 is be AUX ital-1859 50 44 all all ADV ital-1859 50 45 too too ADV ital-1859 50 46 common common ADJ ital-1859 50 47 , , PUNCT ital-1859 50 48 and and CCONJ ital-1859 50 49 all all PRON ital-1859 50 50 too too ADV ital-1859 50 51 easy.22 easy.22 ADJ ital-1859 50 52 many many ADJ ital-1859 50 53 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 50 54 believe believe VERB ital-1859 50 55 that that SCONJ ital-1859 50 56 disclaimers disclaimer NOUN ital-1859 50 57 on on ADP ital-1859 50 58 public public ADJ ital-1859 50 59 - - PUNCT ital-1859 50 60 access access NOUN ital-1859 50 61 computer computer NOUN ital-1859 50 62 terminals terminal NOUN ital-1859 50 63 will will AUX ital-1859 50 64 protect protect VERB ital-1859 50 65 them they PRON ital-1859 50 66 from from ADP ital-1859 50 67 lawsuit lawsuit NOUN ital-1859 50 68 , , PUNCT ital-1859 50 69 but but CCONJ ital-1859 50 70 they they PRON ital-1859 50 71 do do AUX ital-1859 50 72 not not PART ital-1859 50 73 often often ADV ital-1859 50 74 consider consider VERB ital-1859 50 75 placing place VERB ital-1859 50 76 such such ADJ ital-1859 50 77 disclaimers disclaimer NOUN ital-1859 50 78 on on ADP ital-1859 50 79 their their PRON ital-1859 50 80 cd cd NOUN ital-1859 50 81 or or CCONJ ital-1859 50 82 dvd dvd NOUN ital-1859 50 83 collections collection NOUN ital-1859 50 84 . . PUNCT ital-1859 51 1 yet yet CCONJ ital-1859 51 2 a a DET ital-1859 51 3 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 51 4 holder holder NOUN ital-1859 51 5 would would AUX ital-1859 51 6 not not PART ital-1859 51 7 have have VERB ital-1859 51 8 to to PART ital-1859 51 9 prove prove VERB ital-1859 51 10 the the DET ital-1859 51 11 library library NOUN ital-1859 51 12 is be AUX ital-1859 51 13 aware aware ADJ ital-1859 51 14 of of ADP ital-1859 51 15 piracy piracy NOUN ital-1859 51 16 to to PART ital-1859 51 17 accuse accuse VERB ital-1859 51 18 the the DET ital-1859 51 19 library library NOUN ital-1859 51 20 of of ADP ital-1859 51 21 vicarious vicarious ADJ ital-1859 51 22 infringement infringement NOUN ital-1859 51 23 of of ADP ital-1859 51 24 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 51 25 . . PUNCT ital-1859 52 1 the the DET ital-1859 52 2 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 52 3 holder holder NOUN ital-1859 52 4 may may AUX ital-1859 52 5 even even ADV ital-1859 52 6 be be AUX ital-1859 52 7 able able ADJ ital-1859 52 8 to to PART ital-1859 52 9 argue argue VERB ital-1859 52 10 that that SCONJ ital-1859 52 11 the the DET ital-1859 52 12 library library NOUN ital-1859 52 13 sees see VERB ital-1859 52 14 some some DET ital-1859 52 15 financial financial ADJ ital-1859 52 16 gain gain NOUN ital-1859 52 17 from from ADP ital-1859 52 18 this this DET ital-1859 52 19 piracy piracy NOUN ital-1859 52 20 if if SCONJ ital-1859 52 21 the the DET ital-1859 52 22 existence existence NOUN ital-1859 52 23 of of ADP ital-1859 52 24 the the DET ital-1859 52 25 material material NOUN ital-1859 52 26 that that PRON ital-1859 52 27 is be AUX ital-1859 52 28 being be AUX ital-1859 52 29 pirated pirate VERB ital-1859 52 30 serves serve VERB ital-1859 52 31 as as ADP ital-1859 52 32 the the DET ital-1859 52 33 primary primary ADJ ital-1859 52 34 reason reason NOUN ital-1859 52 35 a a DET ital-1859 52 36 patron patron NOUN ital-1859 52 37 visits visit VERB ital-1859 52 38 the the DET ital-1859 52 39 library.23 library.23 ADJ ital-1859 52 40 even even ADV ital-1859 52 41 the the DET ital-1859 52 42 physical physical ADJ ital-1859 52 43 cd cd PROPN ital-1859 52 44 collection collection NOUN ital-1859 52 45 in in ADP ital-1859 52 46 the the DET ital-1859 52 47 public public ADJ ital-1859 52 48 library library NOUN ital-1859 52 49 can can AUX ital-1859 52 50 place place VERB ital-1859 52 51 the the DET ital-1859 52 52 institution institution NOUN ital-1859 52 53 in in ADP ital-1859 52 54 danger danger NOUN ital-1859 52 55 of of ADP ital-1859 52 56 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 52 57 infringement infringement NOUN ital-1859 52 58 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 52 59 yet yet CCONJ ital-1859 52 60 the the DET ital-1859 52 61 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 52 62 challenges challenge NOUN ital-1859 52 63 raised raise VERB ital-1859 52 64 by by ADP ital-1859 52 65 cutting cut VERB ital-1859 52 66 - - PUNCT ital-1859 52 67 edge edge NOUN ital-1859 52 68 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 52 69 resources resource NOUN ital-1859 52 70 , , PUNCT ital-1859 52 71 like like ADP ital-1859 52 72 e e NOUN ital-1859 52 73 - - NOUN ital-1859 52 74 books book NOUN ital-1859 52 75 , , PUNCT ital-1859 52 76 are be AUX ital-1859 52 77 undoubtedly undoubtedly ADV ital-1859 52 78 more more ADV ital-1859 52 79 complicated complicated ADJ ital-1859 52 80 . . PUNCT ital-1859 53 1 e e X ital-1859 53 2 - - NOUN ital-1859 53 3 books book NOUN ital-1859 53 4 are be AUX ital-1859 53 5 replacing replace VERB ital-1859 53 6 traditional traditional ADJ ital-1859 53 7 books book NOUN ital-1859 53 8 in in ADP ital-1859 53 9 many many ADJ ital-1859 53 10 contexts context NOUN ital-1859 53 11 . . PUNCT ital-1859 54 1 like like ADP ital-1859 54 2 most most ADJ ital-1859 54 3 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 54 4 works work NOUN ital-1859 54 5 today today NOUN ital-1859 54 6 , , PUNCT ital-1859 54 7 e e NOUN ital-1859 54 8 - - NOUN ital-1859 54 9 books book NOUN ital-1859 54 10 are be AUX ital-1859 54 11 licensed license VERB ital-1859 54 12 , , PUNCT ital-1859 54 13 not not PART ital-1859 54 14 purchased purchase VERB ital-1859 54 15 outright outright ADV ital-1859 54 16 . . PUNCT ital-1859 55 1 the the DET ital-1859 55 2 problem problem NOUN ital-1859 55 3 licensing license VERB ital-1859 55 4 presents present NOUN ital-1859 55 5 to to ADP ital-1859 55 6 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 55 7 is be AUX ital-1859 55 8 that that SCONJ ital-1859 55 9 licensed licensed ADJ ital-1859 55 10 works work NOUN ital-1859 55 11 are be AUX ital-1859 55 12 not not PART ital-1859 55 13 sold sell VERB ital-1859 55 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 55 15 they they PRON ital-1859 55 16 are be AUX ital-1859 55 17 granted grant VERB ital-1859 55 18 through through ADP ital-1859 55 19 contracts contract NOUN ital-1859 55 20 , , PUNCT ital-1859 55 21 and and CCONJ ital-1859 55 22 contracts contract NOUN ital-1859 55 23 can can AUX ital-1859 55 24 change change VERB ital-1859 55 25 suddenly suddenly ADV ital-1859 55 26 and and CCONJ ital-1859 55 27 negate negate VERB ital-1859 55 28 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 55 29 - - PUNCT ital-1859 55 30 use use NOUN ital-1859 55 31 provisions provision NOUN ital-1859 55 32 of of ADP ital-1859 55 33 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 55 34 . . PROPN ital-1859 55 35 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 55 36 law.24 law.24 PROPN ital-1859 55 37 while while SCONJ ital-1859 55 38 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 55 39 are be AUX ital-1859 55 40 now now ADV ital-1859 55 41 adept adept ADJ ital-1859 55 42 at at ADP ital-1859 55 43 negotiating negotiate VERB ital-1859 55 44 contracts contract NOUN ital-1859 55 45 with with ADP ital-1859 55 46 subscription subscription NOUN ital-1859 55 47 database database NOUN ital-1859 55 48 providers provider NOUN ital-1859 55 49 , , PUNCT ital-1859 55 50 e e NOUN ital-1859 55 51 - - NOUN ital-1859 55 52 books book NOUN ital-1859 55 53 are be AUX ital-1859 55 54 in in ADP ital-1859 55 55 many many ADJ ital-1859 55 56 ways way NOUN ital-1859 55 57 even even ADV ital-1859 55 58 more more ADV ital-1859 55 59 difficult difficult ADJ ital-1859 55 60 to to PART ital-1859 55 61 manage manage VERB ital-1859 55 62 , , PUNCT ital-1859 55 63 with with SCONJ ital-1859 55 64 many many ADJ ital-1859 55 65 vendors vendor NOUN ital-1859 55 66 requiring require VERB ital-1859 55 67 that that SCONJ ital-1859 55 68 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 55 69 delete delete VERB ital-1859 55 70 or or CCONJ ital-1859 55 71 destroy destroy VERB ital-1859 55 72 the the DET ital-1859 55 73 licensed license VERB ital-1859 55 74 content content NOUN ital-1859 55 75 on on ADP ital-1859 55 76 their their PRON ital-1859 55 77 personal personal ADJ ital-1859 55 78 e e NOUN ital-1859 55 79 - - NOUN ital-1859 55 80 readers reader NOUN ital-1859 55 81 at at ADP ital-1859 55 82 the the DET ital-1859 55 83 end end NOUN ital-1859 55 84 of of ADP ital-1859 55 85 the the DET ital-1859 55 86 lending lending NOUN ital-1859 55 87 period.25 period.25 NOUN ital-1859 55 88 the the DET ital-1859 55 89 entire entire ADJ ital-1859 55 90 library library NOUN ital-1859 55 91 community community NOUN ital-1859 55 92 was be AUX ital-1859 55 93 rocked rock VERB ital-1859 55 94 by by ADP ital-1859 55 95 harpercollins harpercollin NOUN ital-1859 55 96 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 55 97 february february PROPN ital-1859 55 98 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 55 99 decision decision NOUN ital-1859 55 100 to to PART ital-1859 55 101 limit limit VERB ital-1859 55 102 licenses license NOUN ital-1859 55 103 on on ADP ital-1859 55 104 e e NOUN ital-1859 55 105 - - NOUN ital-1859 55 106 books book NOUN ital-1859 55 107 offered offer VERB ital-1859 55 108 through through ADP ital-1859 55 109 library library NOUN ital-1859 55 110 ebook ebook NOUN ital-1859 55 111 vendors vendor NOUN ital-1859 55 112 like like ADP ital-1859 55 113 overdrive overdrive VERB ital-1859 55 114 to to ADP ital-1859 55 115 twenty twenty NUM ital-1859 55 116 - - PUNCT ital-1859 55 117 six six NUM ital-1859 55 118 circulations circulation NOUN ital-1859 55 119 , , PUNCT ital-1859 55 120 with with ADP ital-1859 55 121 many many ADJ ital-1859 55 122 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 55 123 questioning question VERB ital-1859 55 124 the the DET ital-1859 55 125 publisher publisher NOUN ital-1859 55 126 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 55 127 assertion assertion NOUN ital-1859 55 128 that that SCONJ ital-1859 55 129 this this DET ital-1859 55 130 seemingly seemingly ADV ital-1859 55 131 arbitrary arbitrary ADJ ital-1859 55 132 limitation limitation NOUN ital-1859 55 133 is be AUX ital-1859 55 134 related relate VERB ital-1859 55 135 to to ADP ital-1859 55 136 the the DET ital-1859 55 137 average average ADJ ital-1859 55 138 lifespan lifespan NOUN ital-1859 55 139 of of ADP ital-1859 55 140 a a DET ital-1859 55 141 single single ADJ ital-1859 55 142 print print NOUN ital-1859 55 143 copy.26 copy.26 ADJ ital-1859 55 144 license license NOUN ital-1859 55 145 holders holder NOUN ital-1859 55 146 have have VERB ital-1859 55 147 an an DET ital-1859 55 148 easy easy ADJ ital-1859 55 149 time time NOUN ital-1859 55 150 arguing argue VERB ital-1859 55 151 that that SCONJ ital-1859 55 152 any any DET ital-1859 55 153 use use NOUN ital-1859 55 154 of of ADP ital-1859 55 155 their their PRON ital-1859 55 156 content content NOUN ital-1859 55 157 without without ADP ital-1859 55 158 paying pay VERB ital-1859 55 159 fees fee NOUN ital-1859 55 160 is be AUX ital-1859 55 161 a a DET ital-1859 55 162 violation violation NOUN ital-1859 55 163 of of ADP ital-1859 55 164 their their PRON ital-1859 55 165 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 55 166 . . PUNCT ital-1859 56 1 that that PRON ital-1859 56 2 is be AUX ital-1859 56 3 not not PART ital-1859 56 4 the the DET ital-1859 56 5 case case NOUN ital-1859 56 6 when when SCONJ ital-1859 56 7 a a DET ital-1859 56 8 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 56 9 use use NOUN ital-1859 56 10 argument argument NOUN ital-1859 56 11 is be AUX ital-1859 56 12 justified justify VERB ital-1859 56 13 , , PUNCT ital-1859 56 14 and and CCONJ ital-1859 56 15 while while SCONJ ital-1859 56 16 many many ADJ ital-1859 56 17 in in ADP ital-1859 56 18 the the DET ital-1859 56 19 library library NOUN ital-1859 56 20 community community NOUN ital-1859 56 21 may may AUX ital-1859 56 22 acquiesce acquiesce VERB ital-1859 56 23 to to ADP ital-1859 56 24 these these DET ital-1859 56 25 arguments argument NOUN ital-1859 56 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 56 27 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 56 28 in in ADP ital-1859 56 29 recent recent ADJ ital-1859 56 30 cases case NOUN ital-1859 56 31 , , PUNCT ital-1859 56 32 courts court NOUN ital-1859 56 33 have have AUX ital-1859 56 34 found find VERB ital-1859 56 35 the the DET ital-1859 56 36 use use NOUN ital-1859 56 37 of of ADP ital-1859 56 38 a a DET ital-1859 56 39 work work NOUN ital-1859 56 40 to to PART ital-1859 56 41 be be AUX ital-1859 56 42 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 56 43 despite despite SCONJ ital-1859 56 44 the the DET ital-1859 56 45 existence existence NOUN ital-1859 56 46 of of ADP ital-1859 56 47 a a DET ital-1859 56 48 licensing licensing NOUN ital-1859 56 49 market market NOUN ital-1859 56 50 . . PUNCT ital-1859 57 1 ”27 ”27 PROPN ital-1859 57 2 when when SCONJ ital-1859 57 3 license license NOUN ital-1859 57 4 agreements agreement NOUN ital-1859 57 5 are be AUX ital-1859 57 6 paired pair VERB ital-1859 57 7 with with ADP ital-1859 57 8 drm drm PROPN ital-1859 57 9 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 57 10 , , PUNCT ital-1859 57 11 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 57 12 may may AUX ital-1859 57 13 find find VERB ital-1859 57 14 themselves themselves PRON ital-1859 57 15 managing manage VERB ital-1859 57 16 thousands thousand NOUN ital-1859 57 17 of of ADP ital-1859 57 18 micropayments micropayment NOUN ital-1859 57 19 to to PART ital-1859 57 20 allow allow VERB ital-1859 57 21 their their PRON ital-1859 57 22 users user NOUN ital-1859 57 23 to to PART ital-1859 57 24 view view VERB ital-1859 57 25 , , PUNCT ital-1859 57 26 copy copy NOUN ital-1859 57 27 , , PUNCT ital-1859 57 28 move move NOUN ital-1859 57 29 , , PUNCT ital-1859 57 30 print print NOUN ital-1859 57 31 , , PUNCT ital-1859 57 32 or or CCONJ ital-1859 57 33 embed embed VERB ital-1859 57 34 , , PUNCT ital-1859 57 35 for for ADP ital-1859 57 36 example example NOUN ital-1859 57 37 , , PUNCT ital-1859 57 38 the the DET ital-1859 57 39 pdf pdf NOUN ital-1859 57 40 of of ADP ital-1859 57 41 a a DET ital-1859 57 42 scholarly scholarly ADJ ital-1859 57 43 journal journal NOUN ital-1859 57 44 article.28 article.28 PROPN ital-1859 57 45 in in ADP ital-1859 57 46 the the DET ital-1859 57 47 current current ADJ ital-1859 57 48 climate climate NOUN ital-1859 57 49 of of ADP ital-1859 57 50 reduced reduce VERB ital-1859 57 51 staff staff NOUN ital-1859 57 52 and and CCONJ ital-1859 57 53 shrinking shrink VERB ital-1859 57 54 budgets budget NOUN ital-1859 57 55 , , PUNCT ital-1859 57 56 managing manage VERB ital-1859 57 57 these these DET ital-1859 57 58 complex complex ADJ ital-1859 57 59 licensing licensing NOUN ital-1859 57 60 agreements agreement NOUN ital-1859 57 61 has have VERB ital-1859 57 62 the the DET ital-1859 57 63 potential potential NOUN ital-1859 57 64 to to PART ital-1859 57 65 cripple cripple VERB ital-1859 57 66 many many ADJ ital-1859 57 67 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 57 68 . . PUNCT ital-1859 58 1 the the DET ital-1859 58 2 librarian librarian PROPN ital-1859 58 3 as as ADP ital-1859 58 4 accidental accidental ADJ ital-1859 58 5 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 58 6 czar czar NOUN ital-1859 58 7 during during ADP ital-1859 58 8 a a DET ital-1859 58 9 special special ADJ ital-1859 58 10 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 58 11 association association PROPN ital-1859 58 12 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 58 13 sla sla NOUN ital-1859 58 14 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 58 15 q&a q&a PROPN ital-1859 58 16 session session NOUN ital-1859 58 17 on on ADP ital-1859 58 18 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 58 19 law law NOUN ital-1859 58 20 in in ADP ital-1859 58 21 the the DET ital-1859 58 22 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 58 23 age age NOUN ital-1859 58 24 , , PUNCT ital-1859 58 25 the the DET ital-1859 58 26 questions question NOUN ital-1859 58 27 submitted submit VERB ital-1859 58 28 to to ADP ital-1859 58 29 the the DET ital-1859 58 30 panel panel NOUN ital-1859 58 31 came come VERB ital-1859 58 32 from from ADP ital-1859 58 33 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 58 34 working work VERB ital-1859 58 35 in in ADP ital-1859 58 36 hospitals hospital NOUN ital-1859 58 37 , , PUNCT ital-1859 58 38 public public ADJ ital-1859 58 39 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 58 40 , , PUNCT ital-1859 58 41 academic academic ADJ ital-1859 58 42 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 58 43 , , PUNCT ital-1859 58 44 and and CCONJ ital-1859 58 45 even even ADV ital-1859 58 46 law law NOUN ital-1859 58 47 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 58 48 . . PUNCT ital-1859 59 1 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 59 2 are be AUX ital-1859 59 3 being be AUX ital-1859 59 4 thrust thrust VERB ital-1859 59 5 into into ADP ital-1859 59 6 the the DET ital-1859 59 7 position position NOUN ital-1859 59 8 of of ADP ital-1859 59 9 de de X ital-1859 59 10 facto facto X ital-1859 59 11 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 59 12 expert expert NOUN ital-1859 59 13 . . PUNCT ital-1859 60 1 one one NUM ital-1859 60 2 of of ADP ital-1859 60 3 the the DET ital-1859 60 4 speakers speaker NOUN ital-1859 60 5 mentioned mention VERB ital-1859 60 6 that that SCONJ ital-1859 60 7 she she PRON ital-1859 60 8 must must AUX ital-1859 60 9 constantly constantly ADV ital-1859 60 10 remind remind VERB ital-1859 60 11 the the DET ital-1859 60 12 lawyers lawyer NOUN ital-1859 60 13 at at ADP ital-1859 60 14 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 60 15 : : PUNCT ital-1859 60 16 regulation regulation NOUN ital-1859 60 17 out out ADP ital-1859 60 18 of of ADP ital-1859 60 19 line line NOUN ital-1859 60 20 with with ADP ital-1859 60 21 our our PRON ital-1859 60 22 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 60 23 reality reality NOUN ital-1859 60 24 | | PROPN ital-1859 60 25 mcdermott mcdermott PROPN ital-1859 60 26 12 12 NUM ital-1859 60 27 the the DET ital-1859 60 28 firm firm NOUN ital-1859 60 29 she she PRON ital-1859 60 30 works work VERB ital-1859 60 31 for for ADP ital-1859 60 32 that that SCONJ ital-1859 60 33 they they PRON ital-1859 60 34 should should AUX ital-1859 60 35 not not PART ital-1859 60 36 copy copy VERB ital-1859 60 37 and and CCONJ ital-1859 60 38 paste paste VERB ital-1859 60 39 the the DET ital-1859 60 40 full full ADJ ital-1859 60 41 text text NOUN ital-1859 60 42 of of ADP ital-1859 60 43 news news NOUN ital-1859 60 44 or or CCONJ ital-1859 60 45 law law NOUN ital-1859 60 46 review review NOUN ital-1859 60 47 journal journal NOUN ital-1859 60 48 articles article NOUN ital-1859 60 49 into into ADP ital-1859 60 50 their their PRON ital-1859 60 51 e e NOUN ital-1859 60 52 - - NOUN ital-1859 60 53 mails mail NOUN ital-1859 60 54 , , PUNCT ital-1859 60 55 and and CCONJ ital-1859 60 56 instead instead ADV ital-1859 60 57 , , PUNCT ital-1859 60 58 they they PRON ital-1859 60 59 should should AUX ital-1859 60 60 send send VERB ital-1859 60 61 a a DET ital-1859 60 62 link link NOUN ital-1859 60 63 . . PUNCT ital-1859 61 1 the the DET ital-1859 61 2 basis basis NOUN ital-1859 61 3 of of ADP ital-1859 61 4 her her PRON ital-1859 61 5 argument argument NOUN ital-1859 61 6 is be AUX ital-1859 61 7 the the DET ital-1859 61 8 third third ADJ ital-1859 61 9 factor factor NOUN ital-1859 61 10 of of ADP ital-1859 61 11 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 61 12 use use NOUN ital-1859 61 13 mentioned mention VERB ital-1859 61 14 earlier early ADV ital-1859 61 15 : : PUNCT ital-1859 61 16 the the DET ital-1859 61 17 amount amount NOUN ital-1859 61 18 or or CCONJ ital-1859 61 19 substantiality substantiality NOUN ital-1859 61 20 of of ADP ital-1859 61 21 the the DET ital-1859 61 22 portion portion NOUN ital-1859 61 23 of of ADP ital-1859 61 24 the the DET ital-1859 61 25 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 61 26 work work NOUN ital-1859 61 27 being be AUX ital-1859 61 28 used.29 used.29 NOUN ital-1859 61 29 since since SCONJ ital-1859 61 30 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 61 31 use use NOUN ital-1859 61 32 is be AUX ital-1859 61 33 not not PART ital-1859 61 34 a a DET ital-1859 61 35 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 61 36 bright bright ADJ ital-1859 61 37 line line NOUN ital-1859 61 38 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 61 39 principle principle NOUN ital-1859 61 40 , , PUNCT ital-1859 61 41 the the DET ital-1859 61 42 more more ADJ ital-1859 61 43 factors factor NOUN ital-1859 61 44 you you PRON ital-1859 61 45 have have VERB ital-1859 61 46 on on ADP ital-1859 61 47 your your PRON ital-1859 61 48 side side NOUN ital-1859 61 49 the the DET ital-1859 61 50 better well ADJ ital-1859 61 51 when when SCONJ ital-1859 61 52 you you PRON ital-1859 61 53 are be AUX ital-1859 61 54 using use VERB ital-1859 61 55 a a DET ital-1859 61 56 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 61 57 work work NOUN ital-1859 61 58 without without SCONJ ital-1859 61 59 the the DET ital-1859 61 60 owners owner NOUN ital-1859 61 61 express express VERB ital-1859 61 62 permission.30 permission.30 NOUN ital-1859 61 63 librarians librarians PROPN ital-1859 61 64 working work VERB ital-1859 61 65 in in ADP ital-1859 61 66 any any DET ital-1859 61 67 institution institution NOUN ital-1859 61 68 must must AUX ital-1859 61 69 seek seek VERB ital-1859 61 70 express express ADJ ital-1859 61 71 permission permission NOUN ital-1859 61 72 from from ADP ital-1859 61 73 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 61 74 holders holder NOUN ital-1859 61 75 for for ADP ital-1859 61 76 any any DET ital-1859 61 77 video video NOUN ital-1859 61 78 they they PRON ital-1859 61 79 wish wish VERB ital-1859 61 80 to to PART ital-1859 61 81 post post VERB ital-1859 61 82 , , PUNCT ital-1859 61 83 or or CCONJ ital-1859 61 84 embed embe VERB ital-1859 61 85 , , PUNCT ital-1859 61 86 on on ADP ital-1859 61 87 library library NOUN ital-1859 61 88 - - PUNCT ital-1859 61 89 managed manage VERB ital-1859 61 90 websites website NOUN ital-1859 61 91 . . PUNCT ital-1859 62 1 e e X ital-1859 62 2 - - NOUN ital-1859 62 3 reserves reserve NOUN ital-1859 62 4 and and CCONJ ital-1859 62 5 streaming streaming NOUN ital-1859 62 6 video video NOUN ital-1859 62 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 62 8 mainstays mainstay NOUN ital-1859 62 9 of of ADP ital-1859 62 10 many many ADJ ital-1859 62 11 educators educator NOUN ital-1859 62 12 and and CCONJ ital-1859 62 13 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 62 14 seeking seek VERB ital-1859 62 15 to to PART ital-1859 62 16 capture capture VERB ital-1859 62 17 the the DET ital-1859 62 18 attention attention NOUN ital-1859 62 19 of of ADP ital-1859 62 20 this this DET ital-1859 62 21 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 62 22 generation generation NOUN ital-1859 62 23 , , PUNCT ital-1859 62 24 have have AUX ital-1859 62 25 become become VERB ital-1859 62 26 bright bright ADJ ital-1859 62 27 red red ADJ ital-1859 62 28 targets target NOUN ital-1859 62 29 for for ADP ital-1859 62 30 litigious litigious ADJ ital-1859 62 31 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 62 32 holders holder NOUN ital-1859 62 33 who who PRON ital-1859 62 34 want want VERB ital-1859 62 35 to to PART ital-1859 62 36 shrink shrink VERB ital-1859 62 37 the the DET ital-1859 62 38 territory territory NOUN ital-1859 62 39 claimed claim VERB ital-1859 62 40 under under ADP ital-1859 62 41 the the DET ital-1859 62 42 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 62 43 - - PUNCT ital-1859 62 44 use use NOUN ital-1859 62 45 banner banner NOUN ital-1859 62 46 even even ADV ital-1859 62 47 further far ADV ital-1859 62 48 . . PUNCT ital-1859 63 1 many many ADJ ital-1859 63 2 in in ADP ital-1859 63 3 the the DET ital-1859 63 4 library library NOUN ital-1859 63 5 community community NOUN ital-1859 63 6 are be AUX ital-1859 63 7 aware aware ADJ ital-1859 63 8 of of ADP ital-1859 63 9 the the DET ital-1859 63 10 georgia georgia PROPN ital-1859 63 11 state state PROPN ital-1859 63 12 university university PROPN ital-1859 63 13 e e NOUN ital-1859 63 14 - - NOUN ital-1859 63 15 reserves reserve NOUN ital-1859 63 16 lawsuit lawsuit NOUN ital-1859 63 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 63 18 cambridge cambridge PROPN ital-1859 63 19 university university PROPN ital-1859 63 20 press press PROPN ital-1859 63 21 et et PROPN ital-1859 63 22 al al PROPN ital-1859 63 23 . . PROPN ital-1859 63 24 v. v. PROPN ital-1859 63 25 patton patton PROPN ital-1859 63 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 63 27 in in ADP ital-1859 63 28 which which PRON ital-1859 63 29 a a DET ital-1859 63 30 group group NOUN ital-1859 63 31 of of ADP ital-1859 63 32 academic academic ADJ ital-1859 63 33 publishers publisher NOUN ital-1859 63 34 have have AUX ital-1859 63 35 accused accuse VERB ital-1859 63 36 the the DET ital-1859 63 37 school school NOUN ital-1859 63 38 of of ADP ital-1859 63 39 turning turn VERB ital-1859 63 40 its its PRON ital-1859 63 41 e e NOUN ital-1859 63 42 - - NOUN ital-1859 63 43 reserves reserve NOUN ital-1859 63 44 system system NOUN ital-1859 63 45 into into ADP ital-1859 63 46 a a DET ital-1859 63 47 vehicle vehicle NOUN ital-1859 63 48 for for ADP ital-1859 63 49 intentional intentional ADJ ital-1859 63 50 piracy.31 piracy.31 NOUN ital-1859 63 51 university university NOUN ital-1859 63 52 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 63 53 are be AUX ital-1859 63 54 implicated implicate VERB ital-1859 63 55 for for ADP ital-1859 63 56 not not PART ital-1859 63 57 providing provide VERB ital-1859 63 58 sufficient sufficient ADJ ital-1859 63 59 oversight oversight NOUN ital-1859 63 60 . . PUNCT ital-1859 64 1 it it PRON ital-1859 64 2 has have AUX ital-1859 64 3 come come VERB ital-1859 64 4 to to ADP ital-1859 64 5 light light NOUN ital-1859 64 6 that that SCONJ ital-1859 64 7 the the DET ital-1859 64 8 association association NOUN ital-1859 64 9 of of ADP ital-1859 64 10 american american PROPN ital-1859 64 11 publishers publisher NOUN ital-1859 64 12 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 64 13 aap aap PROPN ital-1859 64 14 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 64 15 approached approach VERB ital-1859 64 16 other other ADJ ital-1859 64 17 schools school NOUN ital-1859 64 18 , , PUNCT ital-1859 64 19 including include VERB ital-1859 64 20 cornell cornell PROPN ital-1859 64 21 , , PUNCT ital-1859 64 22 hofstra hofstra PROPN ital-1859 64 23 , , PUNCT ital-1859 64 24 syracuse syracuse PROPN ital-1859 64 25 , , PUNCT ital-1859 64 26 and and CCONJ ital-1859 64 27 marquette marquette PROPN ital-1859 64 28 , , PUNCT ital-1859 64 29 before before ADP ital-1859 64 30 filing file VERB ital-1859 64 31 a a DET ital-1859 64 32 suit suit NOUN ital-1859 64 33 against against ADP ital-1859 64 34 georgia georgia PROPN ital-1859 64 35 state state PROPN ital-1859 64 36 . . PUNCT ital-1859 65 1 generally generally ADV ital-1859 65 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 65 3 the the DET ital-1859 65 4 letters letter NOUN ital-1859 65 5 come come VERB ital-1859 65 6 from from ADP ital-1859 65 7 aaps aap NOUN ital-1859 65 8 outside outside ADP ital-1859 65 9 counsel counsel NOUN ital-1859 65 10 and and CCONJ ital-1859 65 11 are be AUX ital-1859 65 12 accompanied accompany VERB ital-1859 65 13 by by ADP ital-1859 65 14 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 65 15 the the DET ital-1859 65 16 draft draft NOUN ital-1859 65 17 of of ADP ital-1859 65 18 a a DET ital-1859 65 19 federal federal ADJ ital-1859 65 20 court court NOUN ital-1859 65 21 legal legal ADJ ital-1859 65 22 complaint complaint NOUN ital-1859 65 23 that that PRON ital-1859 65 24 alleges allege VERB ital-1859 65 25 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 65 26 infringement infringement NOUN ital-1859 65 27 . . PUNCT ital-1859 66 1 ”32 ”32 NOUN ital-1859 67 1 the the DET ital-1859 67 2 aap aap PROPN ital-1859 67 3 believes believe VERB ital-1859 67 4 that that SCONJ ital-1859 67 5 e e NOUN ital-1859 67 6 - - NOUN ital-1859 67 7 reserves reserve NOUN ital-1859 67 8 are be AUX ital-1859 67 9 by by ADP ital-1859 67 10 nature nature NOUN ital-1859 67 11 an an DET ital-1859 67 12 infringement infringement NOUN ital-1859 67 13 of of ADP ital-1859 67 14 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 67 15 law law NOUN ital-1859 67 16 , , PUNCT ital-1859 67 17 so so SCONJ ital-1859 67 18 they they PRON ital-1859 67 19 demand demand VERB ital-1859 67 20 these these DET ital-1859 67 21 universities university NOUN ital-1859 67 22 work work VERB ital-1859 67 23 with with ADP ital-1859 67 24 their their PRON ital-1859 67 25 association association NOUN ital-1859 67 26 to to PART ital-1859 67 27 draft draft VERB ital-1859 67 28 guidelines guideline NOUN ital-1859 67 29 for for ADP ital-1859 67 30 electronic electronic ADJ ital-1859 67 31 content content NOUN ital-1859 67 32 that that PRON ital-1859 67 33 support support VERB ital-1859 67 34 aaps aap NOUN ital-1859 67 35 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 67 36 cost cost NOUN ital-1859 67 37 - - PUNCT ital-1859 67 38 per per ADP ital-1859 67 39 - - PUNCT ital-1859 67 40 click click NOUN ital-1859 67 41 theory theory NOUN ital-1859 67 42 of of ADP ital-1859 67 43 contemporary contemporary ADJ ital-1859 67 44 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 67 45 : : PUNCT ital-1859 67 46 no no DET ital-1859 67 47 pay pay NOUN ital-1859 67 48 equals equal VERB ital-1859 67 49 no no DET ital-1859 67 50 click click NOUN ital-1859 67 51 . . PUNCT ital-1859 68 1 ”33 ”33 PROPN ital-1859 69 1 it it PRON ital-1859 69 2 seems seem VERB ital-1859 69 3 that that SCONJ ital-1859 69 4 georgia georgia PROPN ital-1859 69 5 state state NOUN ital-1859 69 6 was be AUX ital-1859 69 7 not not PART ital-1859 69 8 willing willing ADJ ital-1859 69 9 to to PART ital-1859 69 10 quietly quietly ADV ital-1859 69 11 concede concede VERB ital-1859 69 12 to to ADP ital-1859 69 13 aap aap PROPN ital-1859 69 14 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 69 15 view view NOUN ital-1859 69 16 on on ADP ital-1859 69 17 the the DET ital-1859 69 18 matter matter NOUN ital-1859 69 19 , , PUNCT ital-1859 69 20 and and CCONJ ital-1859 69 21 they they PRON ital-1859 69 22 are be AUX ital-1859 69 23 now now ADV ital-1859 69 24 facing face VERB ital-1859 69 25 the the DET ital-1859 69 26 association association NOUN ital-1859 69 27 in in ADP ital-1859 69 28 court.34 court.34 PROPN ital-1859 69 29 a a DET ital-1859 69 30 decision decision NOUN ital-1859 69 31 in in ADP ital-1859 69 32 this this DET ital-1859 69 33 case case NOUN ital-1859 69 34 was be AUX ital-1859 69 35 pending pende VERB ital-1859 69 36 at at ADP ital-1859 69 37 the the DET ital-1859 69 38 time time NOUN ital-1859 69 39 this this DET ital-1859 69 40 article article NOUN ital-1859 69 41 went go VERB ital-1859 69 42 to to ADP ital-1859 69 43 press press NOUN ital-1859 69 44 . . PUNCT ital-1859 70 1 the the DET ital-1859 70 2 case case NOUN ital-1859 70 3 brought bring VERB ital-1859 70 4 by by ADP ital-1859 70 5 the the DET ital-1859 70 6 association association NOUN ital-1859 70 7 for for ADP ital-1859 70 8 information information NOUN ital-1859 70 9 and and CCONJ ital-1859 70 10 media medium NOUN ital-1859 70 11 equipment equipment NOUN ital-1859 70 12 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 70 13 aime aime NOUN ital-1859 70 14 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 70 15 against against ADP ital-1859 70 16 ucla ucla NOUN ital-1859 70 17 is be AUX ital-1859 70 18 similar similar ADJ ital-1859 70 19 , , PUNCT ital-1859 70 20 except except SCONJ ital-1859 70 21 it it PRON ital-1859 70 22 focuses focus VERB ital-1859 70 23 on on ADP ital-1859 70 24 the the DET ital-1859 70 25 posting posting NOUN ital-1859 70 26 of of ADP ital-1859 70 27 videos video NOUN ital-1859 70 28 so so SCONJ ital-1859 70 29 they they PRON ital-1859 70 30 can can AUX ital-1859 70 31 be be AUX ital-1859 70 32 streamed stream VERB ital-1859 70 33 by by ADP ital-1859 70 34 students student NOUN ital-1859 70 35 on on ADP ital-1859 70 36 password password NOUN ital-1859 70 37 - - PUNCT ital-1859 70 38 protected protect VERB ital-1859 70 39 university university NOUN ital-1859 70 40 websites website NOUN ital-1859 70 41 that that PRON ital-1859 70 42 do do AUX ital-1859 70 43 not not PART ital-1859 70 44 allow allow VERB ital-1859 70 45 the the DET ital-1859 70 46 copying copying NOUN ital-1859 70 47 or or CCONJ ital-1859 70 48 retention retention NOUN ital-1859 70 49 of of ADP ital-1859 70 50 the the DET ital-1859 70 51 videos.35 videos.35 NOUN ital-1859 70 52 ucla ucla NOUN ital-1859 70 53 argued argue VERB ital-1859 70 54 that that SCONJ ital-1859 70 55 the the DET ital-1859 70 56 video video NOUN ital-1859 70 57 streaming streaming NOUN ital-1859 70 58 services service NOUN ital-1859 70 59 for for ADP ital-1859 70 60 students student NOUN ital-1859 70 61 are be AUX ital-1859 70 62 protected protect VERB ital-1859 70 63 by by ADP ital-1859 70 64 the the DET ital-1859 70 65 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 70 66 education education NOUN ital-1859 70 67 and and CCONJ ital-1859 70 68 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 70 69 harmonization harmonization NOUN ital-1859 70 70 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 70 71 teach teach VERB ital-1859 70 72 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 70 73 act act NOUN ital-1859 70 74 of of ADP ital-1859 70 75 2002 2002 NUM ital-1859 70 76 , , PUNCT ital-1859 70 77 which which PRON ital-1859 70 78 is be AUX ital-1859 70 79 the the DET ital-1859 70 80 same same ADJ ital-1859 70 81 act act NOUN ital-1859 70 82 that that PRON ital-1859 70 83 allows allow VERB ital-1859 70 84 all all DET ital-1859 70 85 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 70 86 to to PART ital-1859 70 87 offer offer VERB ital-1859 70 88 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 70 89 online online ADJ ital-1859 70 90 access access NOUN ital-1859 70 91 to to ADP ital-1859 70 92 electronic electronic ADJ ital-1859 70 93 subscription subscription NOUN ital-1859 70 94 databases database NOUN ital-1859 70 95 off off ADP ital-1859 70 96 - - PUNCT ital-1859 70 97 site site NOUN ital-1859 70 98 through through ADP ital-1859 70 99 a a DET ital-1859 70 100 user user NOUN ital-1859 70 101 - - PUNCT ital-1859 70 102 authentication authentication NOUN ital-1859 70 103 system.36 system.36 NOUN ital-1859 70 104 in in ADP ital-1859 70 105 addition addition NOUN ital-1859 70 106 , , PUNCT ital-1859 70 107 ucla ucla PROPN ital-1859 70 108 argues argue VERB ital-1859 70 109 that that SCONJ ital-1859 70 110 it it PRON ital-1859 70 111 is be AUX ital-1859 70 112 simply simply ADV ital-1859 70 113 allowing allow VERB ital-1859 70 114 its its PRON ital-1859 70 115 students student NOUN ital-1859 70 116 to to PART ital-1859 70 117 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 70 118 time time NOUN ital-1859 70 119 shift shift NOUN ital-1859 70 120 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 70 121 these these DET ital-1859 70 122 videos video NOUN ital-1859 70 123 , , PUNCT ital-1859 70 124 a a DET ital-1859 70 125 practice practice NOUN ital-1859 70 126 deemed deem VERB ital-1859 70 127 not not PART ital-1859 70 128 to to PART ital-1859 70 129 infringe infringe VERB ital-1859 70 130 on on ADP ital-1859 70 131 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 70 132 law law NOUN ital-1859 70 133 by by ADP ital-1859 70 134 the the DET ital-1859 70 135 supreme supreme PROPN ital-1859 70 136 court court PROPN ital-1859 70 137 in in ADP ital-1859 70 138 its its PRON ital-1859 70 139 landmark landmark PROPN ital-1859 70 140 sony sony PROPN ital-1859 70 141 corp corp PROPN ital-1859 70 142 . . PROPN ital-1859 70 143 v. v. PROPN ital-1859 70 144 universal universal PROPN ital-1859 70 145 city city PROPN ital-1859 70 146 studios studio NOUN ital-1859 70 147 , , PUNCT ital-1859 70 148 inc inc PROPN ital-1859 70 149 . . PROPN ital-1859 70 150 decision decision NOUN ital-1859 70 151 of of ADP ital-1859 70 152 1984.37 1984.37 NUM ital-1859 70 153 the the DET ital-1859 70 154 american american PROPN ital-1859 70 155 library library PROPN ital-1859 70 156 association association PROPN ital-1859 70 157 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 70 158 ala ala PROPN ital-1859 70 159 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 70 160 , , PUNCT ital-1859 70 161 association association NOUN ital-1859 70 162 of of ADP ital-1859 70 163 research research NOUN ital-1859 70 164 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 70 165 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 70 166 arl arl NOUN ital-1859 70 167 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 70 168 , , PUNCT ital-1859 70 169 and and CCONJ ital-1859 70 170 the the DET ital-1859 70 171 association association NOUN ital-1859 70 172 of of ADP ital-1859 70 173 college college NOUN ital-1859 70 174 and and CCONJ ital-1859 70 175 research research NOUN ital-1859 70 176 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 70 177 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 70 178 acrl acrl NOUN ital-1859 70 179 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 70 180 jointly jointly ADV ital-1859 70 181 published publish VERB ital-1859 70 182 an an DET ital-1859 70 183 opinion opinion NOUN ital-1859 70 184 supporting support VERB ital-1859 70 185 ucla ucla NOUN ital-1859 70 186 in in ADP ital-1859 70 187 this this DET ital-1859 70 188 case case NOUN ital-1859 70 189 . . PUNCT ital-1859 71 1 many many ADJ ital-1859 71 2 in in ADP ital-1859 71 3 the the DET ital-1859 71 4 wider wide ADJ ital-1859 71 5 library library NOUN ital-1859 71 6 community community NOUN ital-1859 71 7 sympathized sympathize VERB ital-1859 71 8 with with ADP ital-1859 71 9 ucla ucla PROPN ital-1859 71 10 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 71 11 library library NOUN ital-1859 71 12 administrators administrator NOUN ital-1859 71 13 , , PUNCT ital-1859 71 14 who who PRON ital-1859 71 15 cite cite VERB ital-1859 71 16 budget budget NOUN ital-1859 71 17 cuts cut NOUN ital-1859 71 18 that that PRON ital-1859 71 19 reduced reduce VERB ital-1859 71 20 hours hour NOUN ital-1859 71 21 at at ADP ital-1859 71 22 the the DET ital-1859 71 23 school school NOUN ital-1859 71 24 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 71 25 media medium NOUN ital-1859 71 26 laboratory laboratory NOUN ital-1859 71 27 as as ADP ital-1859 71 28 one one NUM ital-1859 71 29 reason reason NOUN ital-1859 71 30 they they PRON ital-1859 71 31 must must AUX ital-1859 71 32 now now ADV ital-1859 71 33 offer offer VERB ital-1859 71 34 students student NOUN ital-1859 71 35 a a DET ital-1859 71 36 video video NOUN ital-1859 71 37 - - PUNCT ital-1859 71 38 streaming stream VERB ital-1859 71 39 option.38 option.38 NOUN ital-1859 71 40 in in ADP ital-1859 71 41 the the DET ital-1859 71 42 end end NOUN ital-1859 71 43 , , PUNCT ital-1859 71 44 the the DET ital-1859 71 45 case case NOUN ital-1859 71 46 was be AUX ital-1859 71 47 dismissed dismiss VERB ital-1859 71 48 , , PUNCT ital-1859 71 49 mostly mostly ADV ital-1859 71 50 due due ADJ ital-1859 71 51 to to ADP ital-1859 71 52 the the DET ital-1859 71 53 lack lack NOUN ital-1859 71 54 of of ADP ital-1859 71 55 standing stand VERB ital-1859 71 56 aime aime NOUN ital-1859 71 57 had have VERB ital-1859 71 58 to to PART ital-1859 71 59 bring bring VERB ital-1859 71 60 the the DET ital-1859 71 61 suite suite NOUN ital-1859 71 62 against against ADP ital-1859 71 63 ucla ucla NOUN ital-1859 71 64 , , PUNCT ital-1859 71 65 a a DET ital-1859 71 66 state state NOUN ital-1859 71 67 agency agency NOUN ital-1859 71 68 , , PUNCT ital-1859 71 69 in in ADP ital-1859 71 70 federal federal ADJ ital-1859 71 71 court court NOUN ital-1859 71 72 . . PUNCT ital-1859 72 1 while while SCONJ ital-1859 72 2 the the DET ital-1859 72 3 judge judge NOUN ital-1859 72 4 did do AUX ital-1859 72 5 not not PART ital-1859 72 6 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote30#footnote30 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote30#footnote30 VERB ital-1859 72 7 information information NOUN ital-1859 72 8 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 72 9 and and CCONJ ital-1859 72 10 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 72 11 | | ADP ital-1859 72 12 march march PROPN ital-1859 72 13 2012 2012 NUM ital-1859 72 14 13 13 NUM ital-1859 72 15 expressly expressly ADV ital-1859 72 16 rule rule VERB ital-1859 72 17 on on ADP ital-1859 72 18 the the DET ital-1859 72 19 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 72 20 - - PUNCT ital-1859 72 21 use use NOUN ital-1859 72 22 argument argument NOUN ital-1859 72 23 ucla ucla NOUN ital-1859 72 24 made make VERB ital-1859 72 25 , , PUNCT ital-1859 72 26 the the DET ital-1859 72 27 ruling ruling NOUN ital-1859 72 28 did do AUX ital-1859 72 29 confirm confirm VERB ital-1859 72 30 that that SCONJ ital-1859 72 31 streaming streaming NOUN ital-1859 72 32 is be AUX ital-1859 72 33 not not PART ital-1859 72 34 a a DET ital-1859 72 35 form form NOUN ital-1859 72 36 of of ADP ital-1859 72 37 video video NOUN ital-1859 72 38 distribution distribution NOUN ital-1859 72 39 and and CCONJ ital-1859 72 40 that that SCONJ ital-1859 72 41 the the DET ital-1859 72 42 public public ADJ ital-1859 72 43 - - PUNCT ital-1859 72 44 performance performance NOUN ital-1859 72 45 argument argument NOUN ital-1859 72 46 ucla ucla NOUN ital-1859 72 47 made make VERB ital-1859 72 48 regarding regard VERB ital-1859 72 49 the the DET ital-1859 72 50 videos video NOUN ital-1859 72 51 was be AUX ital-1859 72 52 not not PART ital-1859 72 53 invalidated invalidate VERB ital-1859 72 54 by by ADP ital-1859 72 55 the the DET ital-1859 72 56 fact fact NOUN ital-1859 72 57 that that SCONJ ital-1859 72 58 they they PRON ital-1859 72 59 made make VERB ital-1859 72 60 copies copy NOUN ital-1859 72 61 of of ADP ital-1859 72 62 the the DET ital-1859 72 63 videos video NOUN ital-1859 72 64 in in ADP ital-1859 72 65 question.39 question.39 VERB ital-1859 72 66 digitization digitization NOUN ital-1859 72 67 programs program NOUN ital-1859 72 68 and and CCONJ ital-1859 72 69 the the DET ital-1859 72 70 google google PROPN ital-1859 72 71 book book PROPN ital-1859 72 72 settlement settlement PROPN ital-1859 72 73 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 72 74 looking look VERB ital-1859 72 75 to to PART ital-1859 72 76 digitize digitize VERB ital-1859 72 77 print print NOUN ital-1859 72 78 collections collection NOUN ital-1859 72 79 , , PUNCT ital-1859 72 80 either either CCONJ ital-1859 72 81 for for ADP ital-1859 72 82 preservation preservation NOUN ital-1859 72 83 or or CCONJ ital-1859 72 84 to to PART ital-1859 72 85 facilitate facilitate VERB ital-1859 72 86 online online ADJ ital-1859 72 87 access access NOUN ital-1859 72 88 , , PUNCT ital-1859 72 89 are be AUX ital-1859 72 90 also also ADV ital-1859 72 91 grappling grapple VERB ital-1859 72 92 with with ADP ital-1859 72 93 the the DET ital-1859 72 94 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 72 95 monopoly monopoly NOUN ital-1859 72 96 . . PUNCT ital-1859 73 1 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 73 2 who who PRON ital-1859 73 3 do do AUX ital-1859 73 4 not not PART ital-1859 73 5 have have VERB ital-1859 73 6 the the DET ital-1859 73 7 time time NOUN ital-1859 73 8 or or CCONJ ital-1859 73 9 resources resource NOUN ital-1859 73 10 to to PART ital-1859 73 11 seek seek VERB ital-1859 73 12 permission permission NOUN ital-1859 73 13 from from ADP ital-1859 73 14 publishers publisher NOUN ital-1859 73 15 and and CCONJ ital-1859 73 16 authors author NOUN ital-1859 73 17 before before ADP ital-1859 73 18 scanning scan VERB ital-1859 73 19 a a DET ital-1859 73 20 book book NOUN ital-1859 73 21 in in ADP ital-1859 73 22 their their PRON ital-1859 73 23 collection collection NOUN ital-1859 73 24 can can AUX ital-1859 73 25 not not PART ital-1859 73 26 touch touch VERB ital-1859 73 27 anything anything PRON ital-1859 73 28 published publish VERB ital-1859 73 29 after after ADP ital-1859 73 30 1922 1922 NUM ital-1859 73 31 . . PUNCT ital-1859 74 1 librarylaw.com librarylaw.com X ital-1859 74 2 provides provide VERB ital-1859 74 3 a a DET ital-1859 74 4 helpful helpful ADJ ital-1859 74 5 chart chart NOUN ital-1859 74 6 directed direct VERB ital-1859 74 7 at at ADP ital-1859 74 8 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 74 9 considering consider VERB ital-1859 74 10 digitization digitization NOUN ital-1859 74 11 projects project NOUN ital-1859 74 12 , , PUNCT ital-1859 74 13 but but CCONJ ital-1859 74 14 the the DET ital-1859 74 15 overwhelming overwhelming ADJ ital-1859 74 16 fine fine ADJ ital-1859 74 17 print print NOUN ital-1859 74 18 below below ADP ital-1859 74 19 the the DET ital-1859 74 20 chart chart NOUN ital-1859 74 21 speaks speak VERB ital-1859 74 22 to to ADP ital-1859 74 23 the the DET ital-1859 74 24 labyrinthine labyrinthine NOUN ital-1859 74 25 nature nature NOUN ital-1859 74 26 of of ADP ital-1859 74 27 copyright.40 copyright.40 PROPN ital-1859 74 28 the the DET ital-1859 74 29 google google PROPN ital-1859 74 30 book book PROPN ital-1859 74 31 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 74 32 continues continue VERB ital-1859 74 33 to to PART ital-1859 74 34 loom loom VERB ital-1859 74 35 large large ADJ ital-1859 74 36 over over ADP ital-1859 74 37 both both CCONJ ital-1859 74 38 the the DET ital-1859 74 39 library library NOUN ital-1859 74 40 profession profession NOUN ital-1859 74 41 and and CCONJ ital-1859 74 42 the the DET ital-1859 74 43 publishing publishing NOUN ital-1859 74 44 industry industry NOUN ital-1859 74 45 . . PUNCT ital-1859 75 1 at at ADP ital-1859 75 2 the the DET ital-1859 75 3 heart heart NOUN ital-1859 75 4 of of ADP ital-1859 75 5 debate debate NOUN ital-1859 75 6 is be AUX ital-1859 75 7 google google PROPN ital-1859 75 8 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 75 9 library library NOUN ital-1859 75 10 project project NOUN ital-1859 75 11 , , PUNCT ital-1859 75 12 which which PRON ital-1859 75 13 is be AUX ital-1859 75 14 part part NOUN ital-1859 75 15 of of ADP ital-1859 75 16 google google PROPN ital-1859 75 17 book book NOUN ital-1859 75 18 search search NOUN ital-1859 75 19 , , PUNCT ital-1859 75 20 originally originally ADV ital-1859 75 21 named name VERB ital-1859 75 22 google google PROPN ital-1859 75 23 print.41 print.41 VERB ital-1859 75 24 the the DET ital-1859 75 25 library library NOUN ital-1859 75 26 project project NOUN ital-1859 75 27 allows allow VERB ital-1859 75 28 users user NOUN ital-1859 75 29 to to PART ital-1859 75 30 search search VERB ital-1859 75 31 for for ADP ital-1859 75 32 books book NOUN ital-1859 75 33 using use VERB ital-1859 75 34 google google PROPN ital-1859 75 35 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 75 36 algorithms algorithm NOUN ital-1859 75 37 to to PART ital-1859 75 38 provide provide VERB ital-1859 75 39 at at ADP ital-1859 75 40 its its PRON ital-1859 75 41 most most ADV ital-1859 75 42 basic basic ADJ ital-1859 75 43 a a DET ital-1859 75 44 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 75 45 snippet snippet ADJ ital-1859 75 46 view view NOUN ital-1859 75 47 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 75 48 of of ADP ital-1859 75 49 the the DET ital-1859 75 50 text text NOUN ital-1859 75 51 from from ADP ital-1859 75 52 a a DET ital-1859 75 53 relevant relevant ADJ ital-1859 75 54 publication publication NOUN ital-1859 75 55 . . PUNCT ital-1859 76 1 authors author NOUN ital-1859 76 2 and and CCONJ ital-1859 76 3 publishers publisher NOUN ital-1859 76 4 could could AUX ital-1859 76 5 also also ADV ital-1859 76 6 grant grant VERB ital-1859 76 7 their their PRON ital-1859 76 8 permission permission NOUN ital-1859 76 9 to to PART ital-1859 76 10 allow allow VERB ital-1859 76 11 a a DET ital-1859 76 12 view view NOUN ital-1859 76 13 of of ADP ital-1859 76 14 select select ADJ ital-1859 76 15 sample sample NOUN ital-1859 76 16 pages page NOUN ital-1859 76 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 76 18 and and CCONJ ital-1859 76 19 of of ADP ital-1859 76 20 course course NOUN ital-1859 76 21 if if SCONJ ital-1859 76 22 the the DET ital-1859 76 23 book book NOUN ital-1859 76 24 is be AUX ital-1859 76 25 in in ADP ital-1859 76 26 the the DET ital-1859 76 27 public public ADJ ital-1859 76 28 domain domain NOUN ital-1859 76 29 , , PUNCT ital-1859 76 30 then then ADV ital-1859 76 31 google google PROPN ital-1859 76 32 can can AUX ital-1859 76 33 make make VERB ital-1859 76 34 the the DET ital-1859 76 35 entire entire ADJ ital-1859 76 36 work work NOUN ital-1859 76 37 visible visible ADJ ital-1859 76 38 online.42 online.42 NOUN ital-1859 76 39 in in ADP ital-1859 76 40 all all DET ital-1859 76 41 cases case NOUN ital-1859 76 42 , , PUNCT ital-1859 76 43 the the DET ital-1859 76 44 user user NOUN ital-1859 76 45 will will AUX ital-1859 76 46 see see VERB ital-1859 76 47 a a DET ital-1859 76 48 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 76 49 buy buy VERB ital-1859 76 50 this this DET ital-1859 76 51 book book NOUN ital-1859 76 52 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 76 53 link link NOUN ital-1859 76 54 so so SCONJ ital-1859 76 55 that that SCONJ ital-1859 76 56 he he PRON ital-1859 76 57 or or CCONJ ital-1859 76 58 she she PRON ital-1859 76 59 could could AUX ital-1859 76 60 purchase purchase VERB ital-1859 76 61 the the DET ital-1859 76 62 publication publication NOUN ital-1859 76 63 from from ADP ital-1859 76 64 online online ADJ ital-1859 76 65 vendors vendor NOUN ital-1859 76 66 on on ADP ital-1859 76 67 unrelated unrelated ADJ ital-1859 76 68 sites.43 sites.43 ADJ ital-1859 76 69 google google PROPN ital-1859 76 70 hoped hope VERB ital-1859 76 71 to to PART ital-1859 76 72 sidestep sidestep VERB ital-1859 76 73 the the DET ital-1859 76 74 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 76 75 permission permission NOUN ital-1859 76 76 quandary quandary ADJ ital-1859 76 77 for for ADP ital-1859 76 78 a a DET ital-1859 76 79 digitization digitization NOUN ital-1859 76 80 project project NOUN ital-1859 76 81 of of ADP ital-1859 76 82 this this DET ital-1859 76 83 scale scale NOUN ital-1859 76 84 , , PUNCT ital-1859 76 85 announcing announce VERB ital-1859 76 86 that that SCONJ ital-1859 76 87 it it PRON ital-1859 76 88 would would AUX ital-1859 76 89 proceed proceed VERB ital-1859 76 90 with with ADP ital-1859 76 91 the the DET ital-1859 76 92 digitization digitization NOUN ital-1859 76 93 of of ADP ital-1859 76 94 cooperative cooperative ADJ ital-1859 76 95 library library NOUN ital-1859 76 96 collections collection NOUN ital-1859 76 97 and and CCONJ ital-1859 76 98 that that SCONJ ital-1859 76 99 it it PRON ital-1859 76 100 would would AUX ital-1859 76 101 be be AUX ital-1859 76 102 the the DET ital-1859 76 103 responsibility responsibility NOUN ital-1859 76 104 of of ADP ital-1859 76 105 publishers publisher NOUN ital-1859 76 106 and and CCONJ ital-1859 76 107 authors author NOUN ital-1859 76 108 to to PART ital-1859 76 109 actively actively ADV ital-1859 76 110 opt opt VERB ital-1859 76 111 out out ADP ital-1859 76 112 or or CCONJ ital-1859 76 113 vocalize vocalize VERB ital-1859 76 114 their their PRON ital-1859 76 115 objection objection NOUN ital-1859 76 116 to to ADP ital-1859 76 117 seeing see VERB ital-1859 76 118 their their PRON ital-1859 76 119 works work NOUN ital-1859 76 120 digitized digitize VERB ital-1859 76 121 and and CCONJ ital-1859 76 122 posted post VERB ital-1859 76 123 online.44 online.44 NOUN ital-1859 76 124 google google PROPN ital-1859 76 125 attempted attempt VERB ital-1859 76 126 to to PART ital-1859 76 127 turn turn VERB ital-1859 76 128 the the DET ital-1859 76 129 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 76 130 permissions permission NOUN ital-1859 76 131 process process NOUN ital-1859 76 132 on on ADP ital-1859 76 133 its its PRON ital-1859 76 134 head head NOUN ital-1859 76 135 , , PUNCT ital-1859 76 136 which which PRON ital-1859 76 137 was be AUX ital-1859 76 138 the the DET ital-1859 76 139 basis basis NOUN ital-1859 76 140 of of ADP ital-1859 76 141 the the DET ital-1859 76 142 class class NOUN ital-1859 76 143 action action NOUN ital-1859 76 144 lawsuit lawsuit NOUN ital-1859 76 145 authors author NOUN ital-1859 76 146 guild guild PROPN ital-1859 76 147 v. v. ADP ital-1859 76 148 google google PROPN ital-1859 76 149 inc.45 inc.45 PROPN ital-1859 76 150 before before SCONJ ital-1859 76 151 the the DET ital-1859 76 152 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 76 153 was be AUX ital-1859 76 154 reached reach VERB ital-1859 76 155 , , PUNCT ital-1859 76 156 google google PROPN ital-1859 76 157 pointed point VERB ital-1859 76 158 to to ADP ital-1859 76 159 kelly kelly PROPN ital-1859 76 160 v. v. PROPN ital-1859 76 161 arriba arriba PROPN ital-1859 76 162 soft soft PROPN ital-1859 76 163 corp corp PROPN ital-1859 76 164 as as ADP ital-1859 76 165 proof proof NOUN ital-1859 76 166 that that SCONJ ital-1859 76 167 the the DET ital-1859 76 168 indexing indexing NOUN ital-1859 76 169 functions function NOUN ital-1859 76 170 of of ADP ital-1859 76 171 an an DET ital-1859 76 172 internet internet NOUN ital-1859 76 173 search search NOUN ital-1859 76 174 engine engine NOUN ital-1859 76 175 constitute constitute VERB ital-1859 76 176 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 76 177 use use NOUN ital-1859 76 178 . . PUNCT ital-1859 77 1 in in ADP ital-1859 77 2 that that DET ital-1859 77 3 2002 2002 NUM ital-1859 77 4 case case NOUN ital-1859 77 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 77 6 the the DET ital-1859 77 7 ninth ninth ADJ ital-1859 77 8 circuit circuit NOUN ital-1859 77 9 court court NOUN ital-1859 77 10 of of ADP ital-1859 77 11 appeals appeals PROPN ital-1859 77 12 found find VERB ital-1859 77 13 that that SCONJ ital-1859 77 14 a a DET ital-1859 77 15 website website NOUN ital-1859 77 16 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 77 17 posting posting NOUN ital-1859 77 18 of of ADP ital-1859 77 19 thumbnail thumbnail NOUN ital-1859 77 20 images image NOUN ital-1859 77 21 , , PUNCT ital-1859 77 22 or or CCONJ ital-1859 77 23 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 77 24 imprecise imprecise ADJ ital-1859 77 25 copies copy NOUN ital-1859 77 26 of of ADP ital-1859 77 27 low low ADJ ital-1859 77 28 resolution resolution NOUN ital-1859 77 29 , , PUNCT ital-1859 77 30 scaled scale VERB ital-1859 77 31 down down ADP ital-1859 77 32 images image NOUN ital-1859 77 33 , , PUNCT ital-1859 77 34 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 77 35 constitutes constitute VERB ital-1859 77 36 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 77 37 use use NOUN ital-1859 77 38 , , PUNCT ital-1859 77 39 and and CCONJ ital-1859 77 40 google google PROPN ital-1859 77 41 argued argue VERB ital-1859 77 42 its its PRON ital-1859 77 43 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 77 44 snippet snippet ADJ ital-1859 77 45 view view NOUN ital-1859 77 46 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 77 47 function function NOUN ital-1859 77 48 is be AUX ital-1859 77 49 equivalent equivalent ADJ ital-1859 77 50 to to ADP ital-1859 77 51 a a DET ital-1859 77 52 thumbnail thumbnail NOUN ital-1859 77 53 image.46 image.46 NOUN ital-1859 77 54 however however ADV ital-1859 77 55 , , PUNCT ital-1859 77 56 judge judge PROPN ital-1859 77 57 denny denny PROPN ital-1859 77 58 chin chin PROPN ital-1859 77 59 rejected reject VERB ital-1859 77 60 the the DET ital-1859 77 61 google google PROPN ital-1859 77 62 book book PROPN ital-1859 77 63 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 77 64 in in ADP ital-1859 77 65 march march PROPN ital-1859 77 66 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 77 67 , , PUNCT ital-1859 77 68 citing cite VERB ital-1859 77 69 the the DET ital-1859 77 70 fact fact NOUN ital-1859 77 71 that that SCONJ ital-1859 77 72 google google PROPN ital-1859 77 73 would would AUX ital-1859 77 74 in in ADP ital-1859 77 75 essence essence NOUN ital-1859 77 76 be be AUX ital-1859 77 77 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 77 78 exploiting exploit VERB ital-1859 77 79 books book NOUN ital-1859 77 80 without without ADP ital-1859 77 81 the the DET ital-1859 77 82 permission permission NOUN ital-1859 77 83 of of ADP ital-1859 77 84 copyright copyright ADJ ital-1859 77 85 owners owner NOUN ital-1859 77 86 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 77 87 and and CCONJ ital-1859 77 88 could could AUX ital-1859 77 89 also also ADV ital-1859 77 90 establish establish VERB ital-1859 77 91 a a DET ital-1859 77 92 monopoly monopoly NOUN ital-1859 77 93 over over ADP ital-1859 77 94 the the DET ital-1859 77 95 digitized digitize VERB ital-1859 77 96 books book NOUN ital-1859 77 97 market market NOUN ital-1859 77 98 . . PUNCT ital-1859 78 1 the the DET ital-1859 78 2 decision decision NOUN ital-1859 78 3 did do VERB ital-1859 78 4 in in ADP ital-1859 78 5 the the DET ital-1859 78 6 end end NOUN ital-1859 78 7 hinge hinge NOUN ital-1859 78 8 on on ADP ital-1859 78 9 the the DET ital-1859 78 10 fact fact NOUN ital-1859 78 11 that that SCONJ ital-1859 78 12 google google PROPN ital-1859 78 13 wanted want VERB ital-1859 78 14 to to PART ital-1859 78 15 follow follow VERB ital-1859 78 16 an an DET ital-1859 78 17 opt opt VERB ital-1859 78 18 - - PUNCT ital-1859 78 19 out out ADP ital-1859 78 20 program program NOUN ital-1859 78 21 for for ADP ital-1859 78 22 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 78 23 holders holder NOUN ital-1859 78 24 rather rather ADV ital-1859 78 25 than than ADP ital-1859 78 26 an an DET ital-1859 78 27 affirmative affirmative ADJ ital-1859 78 28 opt opt NOUN ital-1859 78 29 - - PUNCT ital-1859 78 30 in in ADP ital-1859 78 31 system.47 system.47 PROPN ital-1859 78 32 the the DET ital-1859 78 33 google google PROPN ital-1859 78 34 book book PROPN ital-1859 78 35 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 78 36 was be AUX ital-1859 78 37 dismissed dismiss VERB ital-1859 78 38 without without ADP ital-1859 78 39 prejudice prejudice NOUN ital-1859 78 40 , , PUNCT ital-1859 78 41 leaving leave VERB ital-1859 78 42 the the DET ital-1859 78 43 door door NOUN ital-1859 78 44 open open ADJ ital-1859 78 45 to to ADP ital-1859 78 46 further further ADJ ital-1859 78 47 negotiations negotiation NOUN ital-1859 78 48 between between ADP ital-1859 78 49 the the DET ital-1859 78 50 parties party NOUN ital-1859 78 51 concerned concern VERB ital-1859 78 52 . . PUNCT ital-1859 79 1 going go VERB ital-1859 79 2 forward forward ADV ital-1859 79 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 79 4 the the DET ital-1859 79 5 library library NOUN ital-1859 79 6 community community NOUN ital-1859 79 7 should should AUX ital-1859 79 8 be be AUX ital-1859 79 9 concerned concern VERB ital-1859 79 10 with with ADP ital-1859 79 11 how how SCONJ ital-1859 79 12 google google PROPN ital-1859 79 13 will will AUX ital-1859 79 14 handle handle VERB ital-1859 79 15 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 79 16 works work NOUN ital-1859 79 17 and and CCONJ ital-1859 79 18 how how SCONJ ital-1859 79 19 its its PRON ital-1859 79 20 index index NOUN ital-1859 79 21 of of ADP ital-1859 79 22 digitized digitized ADJ ital-1859 79 23 works work NOUN ital-1859 79 24 will will AUX ital-1859 79 25 be be AUX ital-1859 79 26 made make VERB ital-1859 79 27 available available ADJ ital-1859 79 28 to to ADP ital-1859 79 29 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 79 30 and and CCONJ ital-1859 79 31 the the DET ital-1859 79 32 public public NOUN ital-1859 79 33 . . PUNCT ital-1859 80 1 the the DET ital-1859 80 2 2008 2008 NUM ital-1859 80 3 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 80 4 granted grant VERB ital-1859 80 5 google google PROPN ital-1859 80 6 the the DET ital-1859 80 7 nonexclusive nonexclusive ADJ ital-1859 80 8 right right NOUN ital-1859 80 9 to to PART ital-1859 80 10 digitize digitize VERB ital-1859 80 11 all all DET ital-1859 80 12 books book NOUN ital-1859 80 13 published publish VERB ital-1859 80 14 before before ADP ital-1859 80 15 january january PROPN ital-1859 80 16 5 5 NUM ital-1859 80 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 80 18 2009 2009 NUM ital-1859 80 19 , , PUNCT ital-1859 80 20 and and CCONJ ital-1859 80 21 in in ADP ital-1859 80 22 exchange exchange NOUN ital-1859 80 23 , , PUNCT ital-1859 80 24 google google PROPN ital-1859 80 25 would would AUX ital-1859 80 26 have have VERB ital-1859 80 27 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote40#footnote40 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote40#footnote40 VERB ital-1859 80 28 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 80 29 : : PUNCT ital-1859 80 30 regulation regulation NOUN ital-1859 80 31 out out ADP ital-1859 80 32 of of ADP ital-1859 80 33 line line NOUN ital-1859 80 34 with with ADP ital-1859 80 35 our our PRON ital-1859 80 36 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 80 37 reality reality NOUN ital-1859 80 38 | | PROPN ital-1859 80 39 mcdermott mcdermott PROPN ital-1859 80 40 14 14 NUM ital-1859 80 41 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 80 42 paid pay VERB ital-1859 80 43 70 70 NUM ital-1859 80 44 % % NOUN ital-1859 80 45 of of ADP ital-1859 80 46 the the DET ital-1859 80 47 net net ADJ ital-1859 80 48 revenue revenue NOUN ital-1859 80 49 earned earn VERB ital-1859 80 50 from from ADP ital-1859 80 51 uses use NOUN ital-1859 80 52 of of ADP ital-1859 80 53 google google PROPN ital-1859 80 54 book book NOUN ital-1859 80 55 search search NOUN ital-1859 80 56 in in ADP ital-1859 80 57 the the DET ital-1859 80 58 united united PROPN ital-1859 80 59 states states PROPN ital-1859 80 60 to to ADP ital-1859 80 61 rights right NOUN ital-1859 80 62 holders holder NOUN ital-1859 80 63 . . PUNCT ital-1859 81 1 ”48 ”48 PROPN ital-1859 82 1 in in ADP ital-1859 82 2 addition addition NOUN ital-1859 82 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 82 4 google google PROPN ital-1859 82 5 would would AUX ital-1859 82 6 have have AUX ital-1859 82 7 established establish VERB ital-1859 82 8 the the DET ital-1859 82 9 book book NOUN ital-1859 82 10 rights right NOUN ital-1859 82 11 registry registry NOUN ital-1859 82 12 to to PART ital-1859 82 13 negotiate negotiate VERB ital-1859 82 14 with with ADP ital-1859 82 15 google google PROPN ital-1859 82 16 and and CCONJ ital-1859 82 17 others other NOUN ital-1859 82 18 seeking seek VERB ital-1859 82 19 to to PART ital-1859 82 20 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 82 21 digitize digitize VERB ital-1859 82 22 , , PUNCT ital-1859 82 23 index index NOUN ital-1859 82 24 or or CCONJ ital-1859 82 25 display display NOUN ital-1859 82 26 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 82 27 those those PRON ital-1859 82 28 works work VERB ital-1859 82 29 on on ADP ital-1859 82 30 behalf behalf NOUN ital-1859 82 31 of of ADP ital-1859 82 32 the the DET ital-1859 82 33 rights right NOUN ital-1859 82 34 holders.49 holders.49 PROPN ital-1859 82 35 approval approval NOUN ital-1859 82 36 of of ADP ital-1859 82 37 the the DET ital-1859 82 38 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 82 39 would would AUX ital-1859 82 40 have have AUX ital-1859 82 41 allowed allow VERB ital-1859 82 42 google google PROPN ital-1859 82 43 to to PART ital-1859 82 44 move move VERB ital-1859 82 45 forward forward ADV ital-1859 82 46 with with ADP ital-1859 82 47 plans plan NOUN ital-1859 82 48 to to PART ital-1859 82 49 expand expand VERB ital-1859 82 50 google google PROPN ital-1859 82 51 book book NOUN ital-1859 82 52 search search NOUN ital-1859 82 53 and and CCONJ ital-1859 82 54 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 82 55 to to PART ital-1859 82 56 sell sell VERB ital-1859 82 57 subscriptions subscription NOUN ital-1859 82 58 to to ADP ital-1859 82 59 institutions institution NOUN ital-1859 82 60 and and CCONJ ital-1859 82 61 electronic electronic ADJ ital-1859 82 62 versions version NOUN ital-1859 82 63 of of ADP ital-1859 82 64 books book NOUN ital-1859 82 65 to to ADP ital-1859 82 66 individuals individual NOUN ital-1859 82 67 . . PUNCT ital-1859 83 1 ”50 ”50 PUNCT ital-1859 84 1 the the DET ital-1859 84 2 concern concern NOUN ital-1859 84 3 that that PRON ital-1859 84 4 judge judge VERB ital-1859 84 5 denny denny PROPN ital-1859 84 6 chin chin PROPN ital-1859 84 7 expressed express VERB ital-1859 84 8 over over ADP ital-1859 84 9 a a DET ital-1859 84 10 potential potential ADJ ital-1859 84 11 google google PROPN ital-1859 84 12 book book NOUN ital-1859 84 13 monopoly monopoly NOUN ital-1859 84 14 was be AUX ital-1859 84 15 widespread widespread ADJ ital-1859 84 16 among among ADP ital-1859 84 17 the the DET ital-1859 84 18 library library NOUN ital-1859 84 19 community community NOUN ital-1859 84 20 . . PUNCT ital-1859 85 1 while while SCONJ ital-1859 85 2 the the DET ital-1859 85 3 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 85 4 would would AUX ital-1859 85 5 not not PART ital-1859 85 6 have have AUX ital-1859 85 7 given give VERB ital-1859 85 8 google google PROPN ital-1859 85 9 exclusive exclusive ADJ ital-1859 85 10 rights right NOUN ital-1859 85 11 to to PART ital-1859 85 12 digitize digitize VERB ital-1859 85 13 and and CCONJ ital-1859 85 14 display display VERB ital-1859 85 15 these these DET ital-1859 85 16 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 85 17 works work NOUN ital-1859 85 18 , , PUNCT ital-1859 85 19 google google PROPN ital-1859 85 20 planned plan VERB ital-1859 85 21 to to PART ital-1859 85 22 ensure ensure VERB ital-1859 85 23 via via ADP ital-1859 85 24 the the DET ital-1859 85 25 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 85 26 that that SCONJ ital-1859 85 27 it it PRON ital-1859 85 28 would would AUX ital-1859 85 29 have have AUX ital-1859 85 30 received receive VERB ital-1859 85 31 the the DET ital-1859 85 32 same same ADJ ital-1859 85 33 terms term NOUN ital-1859 85 34 the the DET ital-1859 85 35 book book NOUN ital-1859 85 36 rights right NOUN ital-1859 85 37 registry registry NOUN ital-1859 85 38 negotiated negotiate VERB ital-1859 85 39 with with ADP ital-1859 85 40 any any DET ital-1859 85 41 third third ADJ ital-1859 85 42 - - PUNCT ital-1859 85 43 party party NOUN ital-1859 85 44 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 85 45 library library NOUN ital-1859 85 46 , , PUNCT ital-1859 85 47 while while SCONJ ital-1859 85 48 also also ADV ital-1859 85 49 inoculating inoculate VERB ital-1859 85 50 itself itself PRON ital-1859 85 51 against against ADP ital-1859 85 52 the the DET ital-1859 85 53 risk risk NOUN ital-1859 85 54 of of ADP ital-1859 85 55 any any DET ital-1859 85 56 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 85 57 infringement infringement NOUN ital-1859 85 58 lawsuits lawsuit NOUN ital-1859 85 59 that that PRON ital-1859 85 60 could could AUX ital-1859 85 61 be be AUX ital-1859 85 62 filed file VERB ital-1859 85 63 against against ADP ital-1859 85 64 a a DET ital-1859 85 65 competitor.51 competitor.51 NOUN ital-1859 85 66 that that PRON ital-1859 85 67 would would AUX ital-1859 85 68 have have AUX ital-1859 85 69 left leave VERB ital-1859 85 70 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 85 71 vulnerable vulnerable ADJ ital-1859 85 72 to to ADP ital-1859 85 73 any any DET ital-1859 85 74 subscription subscription NOUN ital-1859 85 75 price price NOUN ital-1859 85 76 increases increase NOUN ital-1859 85 77 for for ADP ital-1859 85 78 the the DET ital-1859 85 79 google google PROPN ital-1859 85 80 books book NOUN ital-1859 85 81 service.52 service.52 ADJ ital-1859 85 82 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 85 83 should should AUX ital-1859 85 84 carefully carefully ADV ital-1859 85 85 watch watch VERB ital-1859 85 86 the the DET ital-1859 85 87 negotiations negotiation NOUN ital-1859 85 88 around around ADP ital-1859 85 89 any any DET ital-1859 85 90 future future ADJ ital-1859 85 91 google google PROPN ital-1859 85 92 books books PROPN ital-1859 85 93 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 85 94 , , PUNCT ital-1859 85 95 paying pay VERB ital-1859 85 96 attention attention NOUN ital-1859 85 97 to to ADP ital-1859 85 98 a a DET ital-1859 85 99 few few ADJ ital-1859 85 100 key key ADJ ital-1859 85 101 issues.53 issues.53 NOUN ital-1859 85 102 there there PRON ital-1859 85 103 was be VERB ital-1859 85 104 considerable considerable ADJ ital-1859 85 105 concern concern NOUN ital-1859 85 106 that that SCONJ ital-1859 85 107 under under ADP ital-1859 85 108 the the DET ital-1859 85 109 terms term NOUN ital-1859 85 110 of of ADP ital-1859 85 111 the the DET ital-1859 85 112 2008 2008 NUM ital-1859 85 113 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 85 114 , , PUNCT ital-1859 85 115 even even ADV ital-1859 85 116 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 85 117 participating participate VERB ital-1859 85 118 in in ADP ital-1859 85 119 the the DET ital-1859 85 120 google google PROPN ital-1859 85 121 books books PROPN ital-1859 85 122 library library NOUN ital-1859 85 123 project project NOUN ital-1859 85 124 would would AUX ital-1859 85 125 need need VERB ital-1859 85 126 to to PART ital-1859 85 127 subscribe subscribe VERB ital-1859 85 128 to to ADP ital-1859 85 129 the the DET ital-1859 85 130 service service NOUN ital-1859 85 131 to to PART ital-1859 85 132 have have VERB ital-1859 85 133 access access NOUN ital-1859 85 134 to to ADP ital-1859 85 135 digitized digitize VERB ital-1859 85 136 copies copy NOUN ital-1859 85 137 of of ADP ital-1859 85 138 the the DET ital-1859 85 139 books book NOUN ital-1859 85 140 in in ADP ital-1859 85 141 their their PRON ital-1859 85 142 own own ADJ ital-1859 85 143 collections.53 collections.53 NOUN ital-1859 85 144 many many ADJ ital-1859 85 145 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 85 146 also also ADV ital-1859 85 147 vocalized vocalize VERB ital-1859 85 148 their their PRON ital-1859 85 149 disappointment disappointment NOUN ital-1859 85 150 in in ADP ital-1859 85 151 google google PROPN ital-1859 85 152 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 85 153 abandonment abandonment NOUN ital-1859 85 154 of of ADP ital-1859 85 155 its its PRON ital-1859 85 156 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 85 157 - - PUNCT ital-1859 85 158 use use NOUN ital-1859 85 159 argument argument NOUN ital-1859 85 160 when when SCONJ ital-1859 85 161 it it PRON ital-1859 85 162 agreed agree VERB ital-1859 85 163 to to ADP ital-1859 85 164 the the DET ital-1859 85 165 2008 2008 NUM ital-1859 85 166 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 85 167 , , PUNCT ital-1859 85 168 which which PRON ital-1859 85 169 , , PUNCT ital-1859 85 170 if if SCONJ ital-1859 85 171 it it PRON ital-1859 85 172 succeeded succeed VERB ital-1859 85 173 , , PUNCT ital-1859 85 174 would would AUX ital-1859 85 175 have have AUX ital-1859 85 176 been be AUX ital-1859 85 177 a a DET ital-1859 85 178 boon boon NOUN ital-1859 85 179 to to ADP ital-1859 85 180 nonprofit nonprofit ADJ ital-1859 85 181 , , PUNCT ital-1859 85 182 library library NOUN ital-1859 85 183 - - PUNCT ital-1859 85 184 driven drive VERB ital-1859 85 185 digitization digitization NOUN ital-1859 85 186 programs.54 programs.54 PROPN ital-1859 85 187 finally finally ADV ital-1859 85 188 , , PUNCT ital-1859 85 189 many many ADJ ital-1859 85 190 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 85 191 were be AUX ital-1859 85 192 concerned concern VERB ital-1859 85 193 that that SCONJ ital-1859 85 194 google google PROPN ital-1859 85 195 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 85 196 book book NOUN ital-1859 85 197 rights right NOUN ital-1859 85 198 registry registry NOUN ital-1859 85 199 was be AUX ital-1859 85 200 likely likely ADJ ital-1859 85 201 to to PART ital-1859 85 202 become become VERB ital-1859 85 203 the the DET ital-1859 85 204 default default NOUN ital-1859 85 205 rights right NOUN ital-1859 85 206 holder holder NOUN ital-1859 85 207 for for ADP ital-1859 85 208 the the DET ital-1859 85 209 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 85 210 works work VERB ital-1859 85 211 in in ADP ital-1859 85 212 the the DET ital-1859 85 213 google google PROPN ital-1859 85 214 books books PROPN ital-1859 85 215 library library NOUN ital-1859 85 216 , , PUNCT ital-1859 85 217 and and CCONJ ital-1859 85 218 that that PRON ital-1859 85 219 claims claim VERB ital-1859 85 220 that that SCONJ ital-1859 85 221 google google PROPN ital-1859 85 222 books book NOUN ital-1859 85 223 is be AUX ital-1859 85 224 an an DET ital-1859 85 225 altruistic altruistic ADJ ital-1859 85 226 effort effort NOUN ital-1859 85 227 to to PART ital-1859 85 228 establish establish VERB ital-1859 85 229 a a DET ital-1859 85 230 world world NOUN ital-1859 85 231 library library NOUN ital-1859 85 232 conceals conceal VERB ital-1859 85 233 the the DET ital-1859 85 234 less less ADV ital-1859 85 235 admirable admirable ADJ ital-1859 85 236 aim aim NOUN ital-1859 85 237 of of ADP ital-1859 85 238 the the DET ital-1859 85 239 project project NOUN ital-1859 85 240 — — PUNCT ital-1859 85 241 to to PART ital-1859 85 242 monetize monetize VERB ital-1859 85 243 out out ADP ital-1859 85 244 - - PUNCT ital-1859 85 245 of of ADP ital-1859 85 246 - - PUNCT ital-1859 85 247 print print NOUN ital-1859 85 248 and and CCONJ ital-1859 85 249 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 85 250 works.55 works.55 NOUN ital-1859 85 251 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 85 252 as as ADP ital-1859 85 253 free free ADJ ital-1859 85 254 culture culture NOUN ital-1859 85 255 advocates advocate NOUN ital-1859 85 256 : : PUNCT ital-1859 85 257 implications implication NOUN ital-1859 85 258 and and CCONJ ital-1859 85 259 recommendations recommendation NOUN ital-1859 85 260 our our PRON ital-1859 85 261 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 85 262 nation nation NOUN ital-1859 85 263 has have AUX ital-1859 85 264 turned turn VERB ital-1859 85 265 copyright copyright ADJ ital-1859 85 266 law law NOUN ital-1859 85 267 into into ADP ital-1859 85 268 a a DET ital-1859 85 269 minefield minefield NOUN ital-1859 85 270 for for ADP ital-1859 85 271 both both CCONJ ital-1859 85 272 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 85 273 and and CCONJ ital-1859 85 274 the the DET ital-1859 85 275 public public NOUN ital-1859 85 276 at at ADP ital-1859 85 277 large large ADJ ital-1859 85 278 . . PUNCT ital-1859 86 1 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 86 2 property property NOUN ital-1859 86 3 scholar scholar NOUN ital-1859 86 4 lawrence lawrence PROPN ital-1859 86 5 lessig lessig PROPN ital-1859 86 6 failed fail VERB ital-1859 86 7 in in ADP ital-1859 86 8 his his PRON ital-1859 86 9 attempt attempt NOUN ital-1859 86 10 to to PART ital-1859 86 11 argue argue VERB ital-1859 86 12 before before ADP ital-1859 86 13 the the DET ital-1859 86 14 supreme supreme PROPN ital-1859 86 15 court court PROPN ital-1859 86 16 that that PRON ital-1859 86 17 the the DET ital-1859 86 18 sonny sonny PROPN ital-1859 86 19 bono bono X ital-1859 86 20 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 86 21 term term NOUN ital-1859 86 22 extension extension NOUN ital-1859 86 23 act act NOUN ital-1859 86 24 was be AUX ital-1859 86 25 an an DET ital-1859 86 26 attempt attempt NOUN ital-1859 86 27 to to PART ital-1859 86 28 regulate regulate VERB ital-1859 86 29 free free ADJ ital-1859 86 30 speech speech NOUN ital-1859 86 31 and and CCONJ ital-1859 86 32 therefore therefore ADV ital-1859 86 33 violated violate VERB ital-1859 86 34 the the DET ital-1859 86 35 first first ADJ ital-1859 86 36 amendment.56 amendment.56 NOUN ital-1859 86 37 but but CCONJ ital-1859 86 38 many many ADJ ital-1859 86 39 believe believe VERB ital-1859 86 40 that that SCONJ ital-1859 86 41 our our PRON ital-1859 86 42 restrictive restrictive ADJ ital-1859 86 43 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 86 44 laws law NOUN ital-1859 86 45 at at ADP ital-1859 86 46 least least ADJ ital-1859 86 47 violate violate VERB ital-1859 86 48 the the DET ital-1859 86 49 intent intent NOUN ital-1859 86 50 of of ADP ital-1859 86 51 the the DET ital-1859 86 52 progress progress NOUN ital-1859 86 53 clause clause NOUN ital-1859 86 54 of of ADP ital-1859 86 55 the the DET ital-1859 86 56 constitution constitution NOUN ital-1859 86 57 , , PUNCT ital-1859 86 58 if if SCONJ ital-1859 86 59 not not PART ital-1859 86 60 the the DET ital-1859 86 61 first first ADJ ital-1859 86 62 amendment amendment NOUN ital-1859 86 63 : : PUNCT ital-1859 86 64 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 86 65 unconstrained unconstrained ADJ ital-1859 86 66 access access NOUN ital-1859 86 67 to to ADP ital-1859 86 68 past past ADJ ital-1859 86 69 works work NOUN ital-1859 86 70 helps help VERB ital-1859 86 71 determine determine VERB ital-1859 86 72 the the DET ital-1859 86 73 richness richness NOUN ital-1859 86 74 of of ADP ital-1859 86 75 future future ADJ ital-1859 86 76 works work NOUN ital-1859 86 77 . . PUNCT ital-1859 87 1 inversely inversely ADV ital-1859 87 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 87 3 when when SCONJ ital-1859 87 4 past past ADJ ital-1859 87 5 works work NOUN ital-1859 87 6 are be AUX ital-1859 87 7 inaccessible inaccessible ADJ ital-1859 87 8 except except SCONJ ital-1859 87 9 to to ADP ital-1859 87 10 a a DET ital-1859 87 11 privileged privileged ADJ ital-1859 87 12 minority minority NOUN ital-1859 87 13 , , PUNCT ital-1859 87 14 future future ADJ ital-1859 87 15 works work NOUN ital-1859 87 16 are be AUX ital-1859 87 17 impoverished impoverished ADJ ital-1859 87 18 . . PUNCT ital-1859 88 1 ”57 ”57 PUNCT ital-1859 88 2 while while SCONJ ital-1859 88 3 technological technological ADJ ital-1859 88 4 advances advance NOUN ital-1859 88 5 have have AUX ital-1859 88 6 placed place VERB ital-1859 88 7 the the DET ital-1859 88 8 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 88 9 means mean NOUN ital-1859 88 10 of of ADP ital-1859 88 11 production production NOUN ital-1859 88 12 into into ADP ital-1859 88 13 the the DET ital-1859 88 14 hands hand NOUN ital-1859 88 15 of of ADP ital-1859 88 16 the the DET ital-1859 88 17 masses masse NOUN ital-1859 88 18 , , PUNCT ital-1859 88 19 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 88 20 property property NOUN ital-1859 88 21 law law NOUN ital-1859 88 22 is be AUX ital-1859 88 23 leading lead VERB ital-1859 88 24 us we PRON ital-1859 88 25 down down ADP ital-1859 88 26 a a DET ital-1859 88 27 path path NOUN ital-1859 88 28 to to ADP ital-1859 88 29 self self NOUN ital-1859 88 30 - - PUNCT ital-1859 88 31 censorship.58 censorship.58 PROPN ital-1859 88 32 as as ADP ital-1859 88 33 the the DET ital-1859 88 34 profession profession NOUN ital-1859 88 35 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 88 36 at at ADP ital-1859 88 37 the the DET ital-1859 88 38 heart heart NOUN ital-1859 88 39 of of ADP ital-1859 88 40 both both CCONJ ital-1859 88 41 the the DET ital-1859 88 42 knowledge knowledge NOUN ital-1859 88 43 economy economy NOUN ital-1859 88 44 and and CCONJ ital-1859 88 45 a a DET ital-1859 88 46 healthy healthy ADJ ital-1859 88 47 democracy,”59 democracy,”59 NOUN ital-1859 88 48 it it PRON ital-1859 88 49 is be AUX ital-1859 88 50 in in ADP ital-1859 88 51 our our PRON ital-1859 88 52 best good ADJ ital-1859 88 53 interest interest NOUN ital-1859 88 54 as as SCONJ ital-1859 88 55 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 88 56 to to PART ital-1859 88 57 recognize recognize VERB ital-1859 88 58 the the DET ital-1859 88 59 important important ADJ ital-1859 88 60 role role NOUN ital-1859 88 61 we we PRON ital-1859 88 62 have have VERB ital-1859 88 63 to to PART ital-1859 88 64 play play VERB ital-1859 88 65 in in ADP ital-1859 88 66 restoring restore VERB ital-1859 88 67 the the DET ital-1859 88 68 balance balance NOUN ital-1859 88 69 to to ADP ital-1859 88 70 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 88 71 law law NOUN ital-1859 88 72 . . PUNCT ital-1859 89 1 to to PART ital-1859 89 2 engage engage VERB ital-1859 89 3 in in ADP ital-1859 89 4 the the DET ital-1859 89 5 debate debate NOUN ital-1859 89 6 over over ADP ital-1859 89 7 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 89 8 law law NOUN ital-1859 89 9 in in ADP ital-1859 89 10 the the DET ital-1859 89 11 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 89 12 age age NOUN ital-1859 89 13 , , PUNCT ital-1859 89 14 the the DET ital-1859 89 15 library library NOUN ital-1859 89 16 community community NOUN ital-1859 89 17 needs need VERB ital-1859 89 18 to to PART ital-1859 89 19 educate educate VERB ital-1859 89 20 itself itself PRON ital-1859 89 21 and and CCONJ ital-1859 89 22 advocate advocate VERB ital-1859 89 23 for for ADP ital-1859 89 24 our our PRON ital-1859 89 25 own own ADJ ital-1859 89 26 self self NOUN ital-1859 89 27 - - PUNCT ital-1859 89 28 interests interest NOUN ital-1859 89 29 , , PUNCT ital-1859 89 30 focusing focus VERB ital-1859 89 31 on on ADP ital-1859 89 32 three three NUM ital-1859 89 33 key key ADJ ital-1859 89 34 areas area NOUN ital-1859 89 35 : : PUNCT ital-1859 89 36 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote50#footnote50 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote50#footnote50 NOUN ital-1859 89 37 information information NOUN ital-1859 89 38 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 89 39 and and CCONJ ital-1859 89 40 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 89 41 | | ADP ital-1859 89 42 march march PROPN ital-1859 89 43 2012 2012 NUM ital-1859 89 44 15 15 NUM ital-1859 89 45 1 1 NUM ital-1859 89 46 . . PUNCT ital-1859 90 1 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 90 2 law law NOUN ital-1859 90 3 in in ADP ital-1859 90 4 the the DET ital-1859 90 5 classroom classroom NOUN ital-1859 90 6 and and CCONJ ital-1859 90 7 at at ADP ital-1859 90 8 the the DET ital-1859 90 9 conference conference NOUN ital-1859 90 10 . . PUNCT ital-1859 91 1 we we PRON ital-1859 91 2 must must AUX ital-1859 91 3 educate educate VERB ital-1859 91 4 new new ADJ ital-1859 91 5 and and CCONJ ital-1859 91 6 seasoned seasoned ADJ ital-1859 91 7 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 91 8 on on ADP ital-1859 91 9 the the DET ital-1859 91 10 nature nature NOUN ital-1859 91 11 of of ADP ital-1859 91 12 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 91 13 law law NOUN ital-1859 91 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 91 15 and and CCONJ ital-1859 91 16 the the DET ital-1859 91 17 impact impact NOUN ital-1859 91 18 it it PRON ital-1859 91 19 has have VERB ital-1859 91 20 on on ADP ital-1859 91 21 library library NOUN ital-1859 91 22 practice practice NOUN ital-1859 91 23 and and CCONJ ital-1859 91 24 systems system NOUN ital-1859 91 25 . . PUNCT ital-1859 92 1 library library NOUN ital-1859 92 2 schools school NOUN ital-1859 92 3 must must AUX ital-1859 92 4 step step VERB ital-1859 92 5 up up ADP ital-1859 92 6 to to ADP ital-1859 92 7 the the DET ital-1859 92 8 plate plate NOUN ital-1859 92 9 and and CCONJ ital-1859 92 10 include include VERB ital-1859 92 11 a a DET ital-1859 92 12 thorough thorough ADJ ital-1859 92 13 overview overview NOUN ital-1859 92 14 of of ADP ital-1859 92 15 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 92 16 law law NOUN ital-1859 92 17 in in ADP ital-1859 92 18 their their PRON ital-1859 92 19 library library NOUN ital-1859 92 20 science science NOUN ital-1859 92 21 curriculum curriculum NOUN ital-1859 92 22 . . PUNCT ital-1859 93 1 while while SCONJ ital-1859 93 2 including include VERB ital-1859 93 3 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 93 4 law law NOUN ital-1859 93 5 in in ADP ital-1859 93 6 a a DET ital-1859 93 7 larger large ADJ ital-1859 93 8 legal legal ADJ ital-1859 93 9 - - PUNCT ital-1859 93 10 issues issue NOUN ital-1859 93 11 class class NOUN ital-1859 93 12 is be AUX ital-1859 93 13 acceptable acceptable ADJ ital-1859 93 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 93 15 the the DET ital-1859 93 16 complexity complexity NOUN ital-1859 93 17 of of ADP ital-1859 93 18 current current ADJ ital-1859 93 19 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 93 20 . . PROPN ital-1859 93 21 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 93 22 law law PROPN ital-1859 93 23 demonstrates demonstrate VERB ital-1859 93 24 that that SCONJ ital-1859 93 25 this this PRON ital-1859 93 26 is be AUX ital-1859 93 27 not not PART ital-1859 93 28 a a DET ital-1859 93 29 subject subject NOUN ital-1859 93 30 that that PRON ital-1859 93 31 can can AUX ital-1859 93 32 be be AUX ital-1859 93 33 glossed gloss VERB ital-1859 93 34 over over ADP ital-1859 93 35 in in ADP ital-1859 93 36 a a DET ital-1859 93 37 single single ADJ ital-1859 93 38 lecture lecture NOUN ital-1859 93 39 . . PUNCT ital-1859 94 1 furthermore furthermore ADV ital-1859 94 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 94 3 there there PRON ital-1859 94 4 needs need VERB ital-1859 94 5 to to PART ital-1859 94 6 be be AUX ital-1859 94 7 a a DET ital-1859 94 8 stronger strong ADJ ital-1859 94 9 emphasis emphasis NOUN ital-1859 94 10 on on ADP ital-1859 94 11 continuing continue VERB ital-1859 94 12 education education NOUN ital-1859 94 13 and and CCONJ ital-1859 94 14 training training NOUN ital-1859 94 15 on on ADP ital-1859 94 16 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 94 17 law law NOUN ital-1859 94 18 within within ADP ital-1859 94 19 the the DET ital-1859 94 20 library library NOUN ital-1859 94 21 profession profession NOUN ital-1859 94 22 . . PUNCT ital-1859 95 1 the the DET ital-1859 95 2 sla sla NOUN ital-1859 95 3 offers offer VERB ital-1859 95 4 a a DET ital-1859 95 5 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 95 6 certificate certificate NOUN ital-1859 95 7 program program NOUN ital-1859 95 8 , , PUNCT ital-1859 95 9 but but CCONJ ital-1859 95 10 the the DET ital-1859 95 11 reach reach NOUN ital-1859 95 12 of of ADP ital-1859 95 13 such such ADJ ital-1859 95 14 programs program NOUN ital-1859 95 15 is be AUX ital-1859 95 16 not not PART ital-1859 95 17 wide wide ADJ ital-1859 95 18 enough enough ADV ital-1859 95 19 . . PUNCT ital-1859 96 1 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 96 2 law law PROPN ital-1859 96 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 96 4 and and CCONJ ital-1859 96 5 the the DET ital-1859 96 6 impacts impact NOUN ital-1859 96 7 current current ADJ ital-1859 96 8 policy policy NOUN ital-1859 96 9 has have VERB ital-1859 96 10 on on ADP ital-1859 96 11 the the DET ital-1859 96 12 library library NOUN ital-1859 96 13 profession profession NOUN ital-1859 96 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 96 15 must must AUX ital-1859 96 16 be be AUX ital-1859 96 17 prominently prominently ADV ital-1859 96 18 featured feature VERB ital-1859 96 19 at at ADP ital-1859 96 20 library library NOUN ital-1859 96 21 conferences conference NOUN ital-1859 96 22 . . PUNCT ital-1859 97 1 the the DET ital-1859 97 2 university university PROPN ital-1859 97 3 of of ADP ital-1859 97 4 maryland maryland PROPN ital-1859 97 5 university university PROPN ital-1859 97 6 college college PROPN ital-1859 97 7 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 97 8 center center NOUN ital-1859 97 9 for for ADP ital-1859 97 10 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 97 11 property property NOUN ital-1859 97 12 offers offer VERB ital-1859 97 13 an an DET ital-1859 97 14 online online ADJ ital-1859 97 15 community community NOUN ital-1859 97 16 forum forum NOUN ital-1859 97 17 for for ADP ital-1859 97 18 discussing discuss VERB ital-1859 97 19 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 97 20 issues issue NOUN ital-1859 97 21 and and CCONJ ital-1859 97 22 policies policy NOUN ital-1859 97 23 , , PUNCT ital-1859 97 24 but but CCONJ ital-1859 97 25 it it PRON ital-1859 97 26 is be AUX ital-1859 97 27 unclear unclear ADJ ital-1859 97 28 how how SCONJ ital-1859 97 29 many many ADJ ital-1859 97 30 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 97 31 are be AUX ital-1859 97 32 members.60 members.60 PROPN ital-1859 97 33 2 2 NUM ital-1859 97 34 . . PUNCT ital-1859 98 1 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 98 2 as as ADP ital-1859 98 3 standard standard NOUN ital-1859 98 4 - - PUNCT ital-1859 98 5 bearers bearer NOUN ital-1859 98 6 for for ADP ital-1859 98 7 the the DET ital-1859 98 8 free free ADJ ital-1859 98 9 culture culture NOUN ital-1859 98 10 movement movement NOUN ital-1859 98 11 . . PUNCT ital-1859 99 1 while while SCONJ ital-1859 99 2 the the DET ital-1859 99 3 library library NOUN ital-1859 99 4 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 99 5 alliance alliance PROPN ital-1859 99 6 , , PUNCT ital-1859 99 7 to to PART ital-1859 99 8 which which PRON ital-1859 99 9 the the DET ital-1859 99 10 ala ala PROPN ital-1859 99 11 , , PUNCT ital-1859 99 12 arl arl PROPN ital-1859 99 13 , , PUNCT ital-1859 99 14 and and CCONJ ital-1859 99 15 acrl acrl NOUN ital-1859 99 16 all all PRON ital-1859 99 17 belong belong VERB ital-1859 99 18 , , PUNCT ital-1859 99 19 files file NOUN ital-1859 99 20 amicus amicus PROPN ital-1859 99 21 briefs brief VERB ital-1859 99 22 in in ADP ital-1859 99 23 support support NOUN ital-1859 99 24 of of ADP ital-1859 99 25 balanced balanced ADJ ital-1859 99 26 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 99 27 law law NOUN ital-1859 99 28 and and CCONJ ital-1859 99 29 submits submit VERB ital-1859 99 30 comments comment NOUN ital-1859 99 31 to to ADP ital-1859 99 32 wipo wipo PROPN ital-1859 99 33 , , PUNCT ital-1859 99 34 the the DET ital-1859 99 35 wider wide ADJ ital-1859 99 36 library library NOUN ital-1859 99 37 community community NOUN ital-1859 99 38 must must AUX ital-1859 99 39 also also ADV ital-1859 99 40 advocate advocate VERB ital-1859 99 41 for for ADP ital-1859 99 42 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 99 43 reform reform NOUN ital-1859 99 44 , , PUNCT ital-1859 99 45 since since SCONJ ital-1859 99 46 this this PRON ital-1859 99 47 is be AUX ital-1859 99 48 an an DET ital-1859 99 49 issue issue NOUN ital-1859 99 50 that that PRON ital-1859 99 51 affects affect VERB ital-1859 99 52 all all DET ital-1859 99 53 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 99 54 , , PUNCT ital-1859 99 55 everywhere everywhere ADV ital-1859 99 56 . . PUNCT ital-1859 100 1 as as ADP ital-1859 100 2 a a DET ital-1859 100 3 profession profession NOUN ital-1859 100 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 100 5 we we PRON ital-1859 100 6 need need VERB ital-1859 100 7 to to PART ital-1859 100 8 throw throw VERB ital-1859 100 9 our our PRON ital-1859 100 10 collective collective ADJ ital-1859 100 11 weight weight NOUN ital-1859 100 12 behind behind ADP ital-1859 100 13 legislative legislative ADJ ital-1859 100 14 measures measure NOUN ital-1859 100 15 that that PRON ital-1859 100 16 address address VERB ital-1859 100 17 the the DET ital-1859 100 18 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 100 19 monopoly monopoly NOUN ital-1859 100 20 . . PUNCT ital-1859 101 1 there there PRON ital-1859 101 2 have have AUX ital-1859 101 3 been be AUX ital-1859 101 4 a a DET ital-1859 101 5 number number NOUN ital-1859 101 6 of of ADP ital-1859 101 7 unfortunate unfortunate ADJ ital-1859 101 8 failures failure NOUN ital-1859 101 9 in in ADP ital-1859 101 10 recent recent ADJ ital-1859 101 11 years year NOUN ital-1859 101 12 . . PUNCT ital-1859 102 1 s. s. PROPN ital-1859 102 2 1621 1621 NUM ital-1859 102 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 102 4 or or CCONJ ital-1859 102 5 the the DET ital-1859 102 6 consumers consumer NOUN ital-1859 102 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 102 8 schools school NOUN ital-1859 102 9 , , PUNCT ital-1859 102 10 and and CCONJ ital-1859 102 11 libraries librarie VERB ital-1859 102 12 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 102 13 management management NOUN ital-1859 102 14 awareness awareness NOUN ital-1859 102 15 act act NOUN ital-1859 102 16 of of ADP ital-1859 102 17 2003 2003 NUM ital-1859 102 18 , , PUNCT ital-1859 102 19 attempted attempt VERB ital-1859 102 20 to to PART ital-1859 102 21 address address VERB ital-1859 102 22 a a DET ital-1859 102 23 number number NOUN ital-1859 102 24 of of ADP ital-1859 102 25 drm drm NOUN ital-1859 102 26 issues issue NOUN ital-1859 102 27 , , PUNCT ital-1859 102 28 including include VERB ital-1859 102 29 a a DET ital-1859 102 30 requirement requirement NOUN ital-1859 102 31 that that SCONJ ital-1859 102 32 access access NOUN ital-1859 102 33 controlled control VERB ital-1859 102 34 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 102 35 media medium NOUN ital-1859 102 36 and and CCONJ ital-1859 102 37 electronics electronic NOUN ital-1859 102 38 include include VERB ital-1859 102 39 disclosures disclosure NOUN ital-1859 102 40 on on ADP ital-1859 102 41 the the DET ital-1859 102 42 nature nature NOUN ital-1859 102 43 of of ADP ital-1859 102 44 the the DET ital-1859 102 45 drm drm NOUN ital-1859 102 46 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 102 47 in in ADP ital-1859 102 48 use.61 use.61 PROPN ital-1859 102 49 h.r h.r PROPN ital-1859 102 50 . . PROPN ital-1859 102 51 107 107 NUM ital-1859 102 52 , , PUNCT ital-1859 102 53 the the DET ital-1859 102 54 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 102 55 media medium NOUN ital-1859 102 56 consumers consumer NOUN ital-1859 102 57 rights right VERB ital-1859 102 58 act act NOUN ital-1859 102 59 of of ADP ital-1859 102 60 2003 2003 NUM ital-1859 102 61 , , PUNCT ital-1859 102 62 would would AUX ital-1859 102 63 have have AUX ital-1859 102 64 amended amend VERB ital-1859 102 65 the the DET ital-1859 102 66 dmca dmca NOUN ital-1859 102 67 to to PART ital-1859 102 68 allow allow VERB ital-1859 102 69 those those PRON ital-1859 102 70 researching research VERB ital-1859 102 71 the the DET ital-1859 102 72 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 102 73 to to PART ital-1859 102 74 circumvent circumvent VERB ital-1859 102 75 drm drm NOUN ital-1859 102 76 software software NOUN ital-1859 102 77 while while SCONJ ital-1859 102 78 also also ADV ital-1859 102 79 eliminating eliminate VERB ital-1859 102 80 the the DET ital-1859 102 81 catch-22 catch-22 NOUN ital-1859 102 82 that that PRON ital-1859 102 83 makes make VERB ital-1859 102 84 circumventing circumvent VERB ital-1859 102 85 drm drm NOUN ital-1859 102 86 software software NOUN ital-1859 102 87 for for ADP ital-1859 102 88 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 102 89 - - PUNCT ital-1859 102 90 use use NOUN ital-1859 102 91 purposes purpose NOUN ital-1859 102 92 illegal illegal ADJ ital-1859 102 93 . . PUNCT ital-1859 103 1 the the DET ital-1859 103 2 balance balance NOUN ital-1859 103 3 act act NOUN ital-1859 103 4 of of ADP ital-1859 103 5 2003 2003 NUM ital-1859 103 6 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 103 7 h.r h.r PROPN ital-1859 103 8 . . PROPN ital-1859 103 9 1066 1066 NUM ital-1859 103 10 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 103 11 included include VERB ital-1859 103 12 provisions provision NOUN ital-1859 103 13 to to PART ital-1859 103 14 expand expand VERB ital-1859 103 15 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 103 16 use use NOUN ital-1859 103 17 to to ADP ital-1859 103 18 the the DET ital-1859 103 19 act act NOUN ital-1859 103 20 of of ADP ital-1859 103 21 transmitting transmitting NOUN ital-1859 103 22 , , PUNCT ital-1859 103 23 accepting accept VERB ital-1859 103 24 , , PUNCT ital-1859 103 25 and and CCONJ ital-1859 103 26 saving save VERB ital-1859 103 27 a a DET ital-1859 103 28 copyrighted copyright VERB ital-1859 103 29 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 103 30 work work NOUN ital-1859 103 31 for for ADP ital-1859 103 32 personal personal ADJ ital-1859 103 33 use use NOUN ital-1859 103 34 . . PUNCT ital-1859 104 1 all all PRON ital-1859 104 2 of of ADP ital-1859 104 3 this this DET ital-1859 104 4 legislation legislation NOUN ital-1859 104 5 died die VERB ital-1859 104 6 in in ADP ital-1859 104 7 committee committee NOUN ital-1859 104 8 , , PUNCT ital-1859 104 9 as as SCONJ ital-1859 104 10 did do VERB ital-1859 104 11 h.r h.r PROPN ital-1859 104 12 . . PROPN ital-1859 104 13 5889 5889 NUM ital-1859 104 14 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 104 15 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 104 16 works work VERB ital-1859 104 17 act act PROPN ital-1859 104 18 of of ADP ital-1859 104 19 2008 2008 NUM ital-1859 104 20 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 104 21 and and CCONJ ital-1859 104 22 s. s. PROPN ital-1859 104 23 2913 2913 NUM ital-1859 104 24 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 104 25 shawn shawn PROPN ital-1859 104 26 bentley bentley PROPN ital-1859 104 27 orphan orphan PROPN ital-1859 104 28 works work VERB ital-1859 104 29 act act PROPN ital-1859 104 30 of of ADP ital-1859 104 31 2008 2008 NUM ital-1859 104 32 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 104 33 . . PUNCT ital-1859 105 1 both both DET ital-1859 105 2 bills bill NOUN ital-1859 105 3 would would AUX ital-1859 105 4 have have AUX ital-1859 105 5 addressed address VERB ital-1859 105 6 the the DET ital-1859 105 7 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 105 8 works work VERB ital-1859 105 9 dilemma dilemma NOUN ital-1859 105 10 , , PUNCT ital-1859 105 11 clearly clearly ADV ital-1859 105 12 spelling spell VERB ital-1859 105 13 out out ADP ital-1859 105 14 the the DET ital-1859 105 15 steps step NOUN ital-1859 105 16 one one PRON ital-1859 105 17 must must AUX ital-1859 105 18 take take VERB ital-1859 105 19 to to PART ital-1859 105 20 use use VERB ital-1859 105 21 an an DET ital-1859 105 22 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 105 23 work work NOUN ital-1859 105 24 with with ADP ital-1859 105 25 no no DET ital-1859 105 26 express express ADJ ital-1859 105 27 permission permission NOUN ital-1859 105 28 from from ADP ital-1859 105 29 the the DET ital-1859 105 30 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 105 31 holder holder NOUN ital-1859 105 32 , , PUNCT ital-1859 105 33 without without ADP ital-1859 105 34 fear fear NOUN ital-1859 105 35 of of ADP ital-1859 105 36 a a DET ital-1859 105 37 future future ADJ ital-1859 105 38 lawsuit lawsuit NOUN ital-1859 105 39 . . PUNCT ital-1859 106 1 could could AUX ital-1859 106 2 a a DET ital-1859 106 3 show show NOUN ital-1859 106 4 of of ADP ital-1859 106 5 support support NOUN ital-1859 106 6 from from ADP ital-1859 106 7 the the DET ital-1859 106 8 library library NOUN ital-1859 106 9 community community NOUN ital-1859 106 10 have have AUX ital-1859 106 11 saved save VERB ital-1859 106 12 these these DET ital-1859 106 13 bills bill NOUN ital-1859 106 14 ? ? PUNCT ital-1859 107 1 it it PRON ital-1859 107 2 is be AUX ital-1859 107 3 impossible impossible ADJ ital-1859 107 4 to to PART ital-1859 107 5 know know VERB ital-1859 107 6 , , PUNCT ital-1859 107 7 but but CCONJ ital-1859 107 8 it it PRON ital-1859 107 9 is be AUX ital-1859 107 10 in in ADP ital-1859 107 11 our our PRON ital-1859 107 12 best good ADJ ital-1859 107 13 interest interest NOUN ital-1859 107 14 to to PART ital-1859 107 15 follow follow VERB ital-1859 107 16 these these DET ital-1859 107 17 legislative legislative ADJ ital-1859 107 18 battles battle NOUN ital-1859 107 19 in in ADP ital-1859 107 20 the the DET ital-1859 107 21 future future NOUN ital-1859 107 22 and and CCONJ ital-1859 107 23 make make VERB ital-1859 107 24 sure sure ADJ ital-1859 107 25 our our PRON ital-1859 107 26 voice voice NOUN ital-1859 107 27 is be AUX ital-1859 107 28 heard hear VERB ital-1859 107 29 . . PUNCT ital-1859 108 1 3 3 X ital-1859 108 2 . . X ital-1859 108 3 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 108 4 and and CCONJ ital-1859 108 5 the the DET ital-1859 108 6 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 108 7 commons common NOUN ital-1859 108 8 phenomenon phenomenon NOUN ital-1859 108 9 . . PUNCT ital-1859 109 1 in in ADP ital-1859 109 2 addition addition NOUN ital-1859 109 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 109 4 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 109 5 need need VERB ital-1859 109 6 to to PART ital-1859 109 7 take take VERB ital-1859 109 8 part part NOUN ital-1859 109 9 in in ADP ital-1859 109 10 the the DET ital-1859 109 11 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 109 12 commons common NOUN ital-1859 109 13 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 109 14 cc cc PROPN ital-1859 109 15 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 109 16 movement movement NOUN ital-1859 109 17 by by ADP ital-1859 109 18 actively actively ADV ital-1859 109 19 directing direct VERB ital-1859 109 20 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 109 21 towards towards ADP ital-1859 109 22 this this DET ital-1859 109 23 world world NOUN ital-1859 109 24 of of ADP ital-1859 109 25 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 109 26 works work NOUN ital-1859 109 27 that that PRON ital-1859 109 28 have have VERB ital-1859 109 29 clear clear ADJ ital-1859 109 30 , , PUNCT ital-1859 109 31 simple simple ADJ ital-1859 109 32 use use NOUN ital-1859 109 33 and and CCONJ ital-1859 109 34 attribution attribution NOUN ital-1859 109 35 requirements requirement NOUN ital-1859 109 36 . . PUNCT ital-1859 110 1 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 110 2 commons common NOUN ital-1859 110 3 was be AUX ital-1859 110 4 founded found VERB ital-1859 110 5 in in ADP ital-1859 110 6 2001 2001 NUM ital-1859 110 7 with with ADP ital-1859 110 8 the the DET ital-1859 110 9 support support NOUN ital-1859 110 10 of of ADP ital-1859 110 11 the the DET ital-1859 110 12 center center NOUN ital-1859 110 13 for for ADP ital-1859 110 14 the the DET ital-1859 110 15 study study NOUN ital-1859 110 16 of of ADP ital-1859 110 17 the the DET ital-1859 110 18 public public ADJ ital-1859 110 19 domain domain NOUN ital-1859 110 20 at at ADP ital-1859 110 21 duke duke PROPN ital-1859 110 22 university university PROPN ital-1859 110 23 school school NOUN ital-1859 110 24 of of ADP ital-1859 110 25 law.62 law.62 PROPN ital-1859 110 26 the the DET ital-1859 110 27 movement movement NOUN ital-1859 110 28 is be AUX ital-1859 110 29 essentially essentially ADV ital-1859 110 30 about about ADP ital-1859 110 31 free free ADJ ital-1859 110 32 culture culture NOUN ital-1859 110 33 , , PUNCT ital-1859 110 34 and and CCONJ ital-1859 110 35 the the DET ital-1859 110 36 idea idea NOUN ital-1859 110 37 that that SCONJ ital-1859 110 38 many many ADJ ital-1859 110 39 people people NOUN ital-1859 110 40 want want VERB ital-1859 110 41 to to PART ital-1859 110 42 share share VERB ital-1859 110 43 their their PRON ital-1859 110 44 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 110 45 works work NOUN ital-1859 110 46 and and CCONJ ital-1859 110 47 allow allow VERB ital-1859 110 48 others other NOUN ital-1859 110 49 to to PART ital-1859 110 50 use use VERB ital-1859 110 51 or or CCONJ ital-1859 110 52 build build VERB ital-1859 110 53 off off ADP ital-1859 110 54 of of ADP ital-1859 110 55 their their PRON ital-1859 110 56 efforts effort NOUN ital-1859 110 57 easily easily ADV ital-1859 110 58 and and CCONJ ital-1859 110 59 without without ADP ital-1859 110 60 seeking seek VERB ital-1859 110 61 their their PRON ital-1859 110 62 permission permission NOUN ital-1859 110 63 . . PUNCT ital-1859 111 1 it it PRON ital-1859 111 2 is be AUX ital-1859 111 3 not not PART ital-1859 111 4 intended intend VERB ital-1859 111 5 to to PART ital-1859 111 6 supplant supplant VERB ital-1859 111 7 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 111 8 law law NOUN ital-1859 111 9 , , PUNCT ital-1859 111 10 and and CCONJ ital-1859 111 11 lawrence lawrence PROPN ital-1859 111 12 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 111 13 : : PUNCT ital-1859 111 14 regulation regulation NOUN ital-1859 111 15 out out ADP ital-1859 111 16 of of ADP ital-1859 111 17 line line NOUN ital-1859 111 18 with with ADP ital-1859 111 19 our our PRON ital-1859 111 20 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 111 21 reality reality NOUN ital-1859 111 22 | | PROPN ital-1859 111 23 mcdermott mcdermott PROPN ital-1859 111 24 16 16 NUM ital-1859 111 25 lessing lessing NOUN ital-1859 111 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 111 27 one one NUM ital-1859 111 28 of of ADP ital-1859 111 29 the the DET ital-1859 111 30 founders founder NOUN ital-1859 111 31 of of ADP ital-1859 111 32 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 111 33 commons common NOUN ital-1859 111 34 , , PUNCT ital-1859 111 35 has have AUX ital-1859 111 36 said say VERB ital-1859 111 37 many many ADJ ital-1859 111 38 times time NOUN ital-1859 111 39 that that SCONJ ital-1859 111 40 he he PRON ital-1859 111 41 believes believe VERB ital-1859 111 42 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 111 43 property property NOUN ital-1859 111 44 law law NOUN ital-1859 111 45 is be AUX ital-1859 111 46 necessary necessary ADJ ital-1859 111 47 and and CCONJ ital-1859 111 48 that that SCONJ ital-1859 111 49 piracy piracy NOUN ital-1859 111 50 is be AUX ital-1859 111 51 inexcusable.63 inexcusable.63 ADJ ital-1859 111 52 instead instead ADV ital-1859 111 53 , , PUNCT ital-1859 111 54 a a DET ital-1859 111 55 cc cc PROPN ital-1859 111 56 license license NOUN ital-1859 111 57 states state NOUN ital-1859 111 58 in in ADP ital-1859 111 59 clear clear ADJ ital-1859 111 60 terms term NOUN ital-1859 111 61 exactly exactly ADV ital-1859 111 62 what what PRON ital-1859 111 63 rights right VERB ital-1859 111 64 the the DET ital-1859 111 65 creator creator NOUN ital-1859 111 66 reserves reserve NOUN ital-1859 111 67 , , PUNCT ital-1859 111 68 and and CCONJ ital-1859 111 69 conversely conversely ADV ital-1859 111 70 , , PUNCT ital-1859 111 71 what what DET ital-1859 111 72 rights right NOUN ital-1859 111 73 are be AUX ital-1859 111 74 granted grant VERB ital-1859 111 75 to to ADP ital-1859 111 76 everyone everyone PRON ital-1859 111 77 else.64 else.64 ADJ ital-1859 111 78 as as SCONJ ital-1859 111 79 lawrence lawrence PROPN ital-1859 111 80 lessig lessig PROPN ital-1859 111 81 explains explain VERB ital-1859 111 82 , , PUNCT ital-1859 111 83 you you PRON ital-1859 111 84 go go VERB ital-1859 111 85 to to ADP ital-1859 111 86 the the DET ital-1859 111 87 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 111 88 commons common NOUN ital-1859 111 89 website website NOUN ital-1859 111 90 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 111 91 http://creativecomms.org http://creativecomms.org NOUN ital-1859 111 92 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 111 93 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 111 94 you you PRON ital-1859 111 95 pick pick VERB ital-1859 111 96 the the DET ital-1859 111 97 opportunity opportunity NOUN ital-1859 111 98 to to PART ital-1859 111 99 select select VERB ital-1859 111 100 a a DET ital-1859 111 101 license license NOUN ital-1859 111 102 : : PUNCT ital-1859 111 103 do do AUX ital-1859 111 104 you you PRON ital-1859 111 105 want want VERB ital-1859 111 106 to to PART ital-1859 111 107 permit permit VERB ital-1859 111 108 commercial commercial ADJ ital-1859 111 109 uses use NOUN ital-1859 111 110 or or CCONJ ital-1859 111 111 not not PART ital-1859 111 112 ? ? PUNCT ital-1859 112 1 do do AUX ital-1859 112 2 you you PRON ital-1859 112 3 want want VERB ital-1859 112 4 to to PART ital-1859 112 5 allow allow VERB ital-1859 112 6 modifications modification NOUN ital-1859 112 7 or or CCONJ ital-1859 112 8 not not PART ital-1859 112 9 ? ? PUNCT ital-1859 113 1 if if SCONJ ital-1859 113 2 you you PRON ital-1859 113 3 allow allow VERB ital-1859 113 4 modifications modification NOUN ital-1859 113 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 113 6 do do AUX ital-1859 113 7 you you PRON ital-1859 113 8 want want VERB ital-1859 113 9 to to PART ital-1859 113 10 require require VERB ital-1859 113 11 a a DET ital-1859 113 12 kind kind NOUN ital-1859 113 13 of of ADP ital-1859 113 14 copyleft copyleft NOUN ital-1859 113 15 idea idea NOUN ital-1859 113 16 that that SCONJ ital-1859 113 17 other other ADJ ital-1859 113 18 people people NOUN ital-1859 113 19 release release VERB ital-1859 113 20 the the DET ital-1859 113 21 modifications modification NOUN ital-1859 113 22 under under ADP ital-1859 113 23 a a DET ital-1859 113 24 similarly similarly ADV ital-1859 113 25 free free ADJ ital-1859 113 26 license license NOUN ital-1859 113 27 ? ? PUNCT ital-1859 114 1 that that PRON ital-1859 114 2 is be AUX ital-1859 114 3 the the DET ital-1859 114 4 core core NOUN ital-1859 114 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 6 and and CCONJ ital-1859 114 7 that that PRON ital-1859 114 8 produces produce VERB ital-1859 114 9 a a DET ital-1859 114 10 license.65 license.65 NOUN ital-1859 114 11 there there PRON ital-1859 114 12 are be VERB ital-1859 114 13 currently currently ADV ital-1859 114 14 six six NUM ital-1859 114 15 cc cc NOUN ital-1859 114 16 licenses license NOUN ital-1859 114 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 18 and and CCONJ ital-1859 114 19 they they PRON ital-1859 114 20 include include VERB ital-1859 114 21 some some DET ital-1859 114 22 combination combination NOUN ital-1859 114 23 of of ADP ital-1859 114 24 the the DET ital-1859 114 25 four four NUM ital-1859 114 26 license license NOUN ital-1859 114 27 conditions condition NOUN ital-1859 114 28 defined define VERB ital-1859 114 29 by by ADP ital-1859 114 30 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 114 31 commons common NOUN ital-1859 114 32 : : PUNCT ital-1859 114 33 attribution attribution NOUN ital-1859 114 34 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 114 35 by by ADP ital-1859 114 36 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 114 37 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 38 share share VERB ital-1859 114 39 alike alike ADV ital-1859 114 40 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 114 41 sa sa PROPN ital-1859 114 42 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 114 43 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 44 noncommercial noncommercial ADJ ital-1859 114 45 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 114 46 nc nc PROPN ital-1859 114 47 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 114 48 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 49 and and CCONJ ital-1859 114 50 no no DET ital-1859 114 51 derivatives derivative NOUN ital-1859 114 52 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 114 53 nd).66 nd).66 NOUN ital-1859 114 54 each each PRON ital-1859 114 55 of of ADP ital-1859 114 56 the the DET ital-1859 114 57 four four NUM ital-1859 114 58 conditions condition NOUN ital-1859 114 59 is be AUX ital-1859 114 60 designated designate VERB ital-1859 114 61 by by ADP ital-1859 114 62 a a DET ital-1859 114 63 clever clever ADJ ital-1859 114 64 symbol symbol NOUN ital-1859 114 65 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 66 and and CCONJ ital-1859 114 67 the the DET ital-1859 114 68 six six NUM ital-1859 114 69 licenses license NOUN ital-1859 114 70 display display VERB ital-1859 114 71 these these DET ital-1859 114 72 symbols symbol NOUN ital-1859 114 73 after after ADP ital-1859 114 74 the the DET ital-1859 114 75 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 114 76 commons common NOUN ital-1859 114 77 trademark trademark NOUN ital-1859 114 78 itself itself PRON ital-1859 114 79 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 80 two two NUM ital-1859 114 81 small small ADJ ital-1859 114 82 c c NOUN ital-1859 114 83 ’s ’s NOUN ital-1859 114 84 inside inside ADP ital-1859 114 85 a a DET ital-1859 114 86 circle.67 circle.67 NOUN ital-1859 114 87 there there PRON ital-1859 114 88 are be VERB ital-1859 114 89 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 114 90 hundreds hundred NOUN ital-1859 114 91 of of ADP ital-1859 114 92 millions million NOUN ital-1859 114 93 of of ADP ital-1859 114 94 cc cc PROPN ital-1859 114 95 licensed license VERB ital-1859 114 96 works work NOUN ital-1859 114 97 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 114 98 that that PRON ital-1859 114 99 can can AUX ital-1859 114 100 be be AUX ital-1859 114 101 searched search VERB ital-1859 114 102 through through ADP ital-1859 114 103 google google PROPN ital-1859 114 104 and and CCONJ ital-1859 114 105 yahoo yahoo PROPN ital-1859 114 106 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 107 and and CCONJ ital-1859 114 108 some some DET ital-1859 114 109 notable notable ADJ ital-1859 114 110 organizations organization NOUN ital-1859 114 111 that that PRON ital-1859 114 112 rely rely VERB ital-1859 114 113 on on ADP ital-1859 114 114 cc cc PROPN ital-1859 114 115 licenses license NOUN ital-1859 114 116 include include VERB ital-1859 114 117 flickr flickr PROPN ital-1859 114 118 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 119 the the DET ital-1859 114 120 public public ADJ ital-1859 114 121 library library NOUN ital-1859 114 122 of of ADP ital-1859 114 123 science science PROPN ital-1859 114 124 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 125 wikipedia wikipedia PROPN ital-1859 114 126 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 127 and and CCONJ ital-1859 114 128 now now ADV ital-1859 114 129 whitehouse.gov.68 whitehouse.gov.68 VERB ital-1859 114 130 all all DET ital-1859 114 131 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 114 132 not not PART ital-1859 114 133 already already ADV ital-1859 114 134 familiar familiar ADJ ital-1859 114 135 with with ADP ital-1859 114 136 this this DET ital-1859 114 137 approach approach NOUN ital-1859 114 138 need need VERB ital-1859 114 139 to to PART ital-1859 114 140 educate educate VERB ital-1859 114 141 themselves themselves PRON ital-1859 114 142 on on ADP ital-1859 114 143 cc cc PROPN ital-1859 114 144 licenses license NOUN ital-1859 114 145 and and CCONJ ital-1859 114 146 how how SCONJ ital-1859 114 147 to to PART ital-1859 114 148 find find VERB ital-1859 114 149 cc cc PROPN ital-1859 114 150 licensed licensed ADJ ital-1859 114 151 works.69 works.69 NOUN ital-1859 114 152 while while SCONJ ital-1859 114 153 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 114 154 must must AUX ital-1859 114 155 still still ADV ital-1859 114 156 inform inform VERB ital-1859 114 157 their their PRON ital-1859 114 158 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 114 159 about about ADP ital-1859 114 160 the the DET ital-1859 114 161 realities reality NOUN ital-1859 114 162 of of ADP ital-1859 114 163 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 114 164 law law NOUN ital-1859 114 165 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 166 it it PRON ital-1859 114 167 is be AUX ital-1859 114 168 just just ADV ital-1859 114 169 as as ADV ital-1859 114 170 important important ADJ ital-1859 114 171 to to PART ital-1859 114 172 direct direct VERB ital-1859 114 173 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 114 174 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 175 students student NOUN ital-1859 114 176 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 177 and and CCONJ ital-1859 114 178 colleagues colleague NOUN ital-1859 114 179 to to ADP ital-1859 114 180 cc cc VERB ital-1859 114 181 licensed license VERB ital-1859 114 182 materials material NOUN ital-1859 114 183 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 184 so so SCONJ ital-1859 114 185 that that SCONJ ital-1859 114 186 they they PRON ital-1859 114 187 can can AUX ital-1859 114 188 create create VERB ital-1859 114 189 the the DET ital-1859 114 190 mash mash NOUN ital-1859 114 191 - - PUNCT ital-1859 114 192 ups up NOUN ital-1859 114 193 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 194 videos video NOUN ital-1859 114 195 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 196 and and CCONJ ital-1859 114 197 podcasts podcast NOUN ital-1859 114 198 that that PRON ital-1859 114 199 are be AUX ital-1859 114 200 the the DET ital-1859 114 201 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 114 202 products product NOUN ital-1859 114 203 of of ADP ital-1859 114 204 our our PRON ital-1859 114 205 web web NOUN ital-1859 114 206 2.0 2.0 NUM ital-1859 114 207 world.70 world.70 ADJ ital-1859 114 208 the the DET ital-1859 114 209 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 114 210 commons common NOUN ital-1859 114 211 system system NOUN ital-1859 114 212 is be AUX ital-1859 114 213 not not PART ital-1859 114 214 perfect perfect ADJ ital-1859 114 215 , , PUNCT ital-1859 114 216 and and CCONJ ital-1859 114 217 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 114 218 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 114 219 commons common NOUN ital-1859 114 220 gives give VERB ital-1859 114 221 the the DET ital-1859 114 222 unskilled unskilled ADJ ital-1859 114 223 an an DET ital-1859 114 224 opportunity opportunity NOUN ital-1859 114 225 to to PART ital-1859 114 226 fail fail VERB ital-1859 114 227 at at ADP ital-1859 114 228 many many ADJ ital-1859 114 229 junctures juncture NOUN ital-1859 114 230 . . PUNCT ital-1859 115 1 ”71 ”71 PUNCT ital-1859 116 1 yet yet ADV ital-1859 116 2 that that PRON ital-1859 116 3 only only ADV ital-1859 116 4 speaks speak VERB ital-1859 116 5 to to ADP ital-1859 116 6 the the DET ital-1859 116 7 necessity necessity NOUN ital-1859 116 8 of of ADP ital-1859 116 9 educating educate VERB ital-1859 116 10 the the DET ital-1859 116 11 library library NOUN ital-1859 116 12 community community NOUN ital-1859 116 13 about about ADP ital-1859 116 14 the the DET ital-1859 116 15 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 116 16 some some DET ital-1859 116 17 rights right NOUN ital-1859 116 18 reserved reserve VERB ital-1859 116 19 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 116 20 movement movement NOUN ital-1859 116 21 , , PUNCT ital-1859 116 22 so so SCONJ ital-1859 116 23 that that SCONJ ital-1859 116 24 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 116 25 , , PUNCT ital-1859 116 26 who who PRON ital-1859 116 27 are be AUX ital-1859 116 28 already already ADV ital-1859 116 29 called call VERB ital-1859 116 30 upon upon SCONJ ital-1859 116 31 to to PART ital-1859 116 32 understand understand VERB ital-1859 116 33 traditional traditional ADJ ital-1859 116 34 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 116 35 law law NOUN ital-1859 116 36 , , PUNCT ital-1859 116 37 are be AUX ital-1859 116 38 also also ADV ital-1859 116 39 educating educate VERB ital-1859 116 40 our our PRON ital-1859 116 41 society society NOUN ital-1859 116 42 about about ADP ital-1859 116 43 how how SCONJ ital-1859 116 44 individuals individual NOUN ital-1859 116 45 can can AUX ital-1859 116 46 protect protect VERB ital-1859 116 47 their their PRON ital-1859 116 48 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 116 49 property property NOUN ital-1859 116 50 while while SCONJ ital-1859 116 51 preserving preserve VERB ital-1859 116 52 and and CCONJ ital-1859 116 53 strengthening strengthen VERB ital-1859 116 54 the the DET ital-1859 116 55 public public ADJ ital-1859 116 56 domain domain NOUN ital-1859 116 57 . . PUNCT ital-1859 117 1 conclusion conclusion NOUN ital-1859 117 2 the the DET ital-1859 117 3 library library NOUN ital-1859 117 4 community community NOUN ital-1859 117 5 can can AUX ital-1859 117 6 no no ADV ital-1859 117 7 longer long ADV ital-1859 117 8 afford afford VERB ital-1859 117 9 to to PART ital-1859 117 10 consider consider VERB ital-1859 117 11 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 117 12 property property NOUN ital-1859 117 13 law law NOUN ital-1859 117 14 as as ADP ital-1859 117 15 a a DET ital-1859 117 16 foreign foreign ADJ ital-1859 117 17 topic topic NOUN ital-1859 117 18 appropriate appropriate ADJ ital-1859 117 19 for for ADP ital-1859 117 20 law law NOUN ital-1859 117 21 schools school NOUN ital-1859 117 22 but but CCONJ ital-1859 117 23 not not PART ital-1859 117 24 library library NOUN ital-1859 117 25 schools school NOUN ital-1859 117 26 . . PUNCT ital-1859 118 1 those those PRON ital-1859 118 2 who who PRON ital-1859 118 3 are be AUX ital-1859 118 4 behind behind ADP ital-1859 118 5 the the DET ital-1859 118 6 slow slow ADJ ital-1859 118 7 extermination extermination NOUN ital-1859 118 8 of of ADP ital-1859 118 9 the the DET ital-1859 118 10 public public ADJ ital-1859 118 11 domain domain NOUN ital-1859 118 12 rely rely VERB ital-1859 118 13 on on ADP ital-1859 118 14 the the DET ital-1859 118 15 complexity complexity NOUN ital-1859 118 16 of of ADP ital-1859 118 17 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 118 18 law law NOUN ital-1859 118 19 , , PUNCT ital-1859 118 20 and and CCONJ ital-1859 118 21 the the DET ital-1859 118 22 misunderstanding misunderstanding NOUN ital-1859 118 23 of of ADP ital-1859 118 24 the the DET ital-1859 118 25 principle principle NOUN ital-1859 118 26 of of ADP ital-1859 118 27 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 118 28 use use NOUN ital-1859 118 29 , , PUNCT ital-1859 118 30 to to PART ital-1859 118 31 make make VERB ital-1859 118 32 their their PRON ital-1859 118 33 arguments argument NOUN ital-1859 118 34 easier easy ADJ ital-1859 118 35 and and CCONJ ital-1859 118 36 to to PART ital-1859 118 37 brow brow VERB ital-1859 118 38 beat beat VERB ital-1859 118 39 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 118 40 and and CCONJ ital-1859 118 41 the the DET ital-1859 118 42 public public NOUN ital-1859 118 43 into into ADP ital-1859 118 44 handing hand VERB ital-1859 118 45 over over ADP ital-1859 118 46 the the DET ital-1859 118 47 rights right NOUN ital-1859 118 48 the the DET ital-1859 118 49 constitution constitution NOUN ital-1859 118 50 bestows bestow VERB ital-1859 118 51 on on ADP ital-1859 118 52 everyone everyone PRON ital-1859 118 53 . . PUNCT ital-1859 119 1 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 119 2 need need VERB ital-1859 119 3 to to PART ital-1859 119 4 engage engage VERB ital-1859 119 5 in in ADP ital-1859 119 6 the the DET ital-1859 119 7 debate debate NOUN ital-1859 119 8 over over ADP ital-1859 119 9 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 119 10 law law NOUN ital-1859 119 11 to to PART ital-1859 119 12 retain retain VERB ital-1859 119 13 control control NOUN ital-1859 119 14 over over ADP ital-1859 119 15 their their PRON ital-1859 119 16 collections collection NOUN ital-1859 119 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 119 18 and and CCONJ ital-1859 119 19 to to PART ital-1859 119 20 better well ADV ital-1859 119 21 serve serve VERB ital-1859 119 22 their their PRON ital-1859 119 23 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 119 24 . . PUNCT ital-1859 120 1 in in ADP ital-1859 120 2 the the DET ital-1859 120 3 past past NOUN ital-1859 120 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 120 5 the the DET ital-1859 120 6 library library NOUN ital-1859 120 7 community community NOUN ital-1859 120 8 has have AUX ital-1859 120 9 not not PART ital-1859 120 10 hesitated hesitate VERB ital-1859 120 11 to to PART ital-1859 120 12 stand stand VERB ital-1859 120 13 up up ADP ital-1859 120 14 for for ADP ital-1859 120 15 the the DET ital-1859 120 16 freedom freedom NOUN ital-1859 120 17 of of ADP ital-1859 120 18 speech speech NOUN ital-1859 120 19 and and CCONJ ital-1859 120 20 self self NOUN ital-1859 120 21 - - PUNCT ital-1859 120 22 expression expression NOUN ital-1859 120 23 , , PUNCT ital-1859 120 24 whether whether SCONJ ital-1859 120 25 it it PRON ital-1859 120 26 means mean VERB ital-1859 120 27 taking take VERB ital-1859 120 28 a a DET ital-1859 120 29 stand stand NOUN ital-1859 120 30 against against ADP ital-1859 120 31 banning ban VERB ital-1859 120 32 books book NOUN ital-1859 120 33 from from ADP ital-1859 120 34 school school NOUN ital-1859 120 35 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 120 36 or or CCONJ ital-1859 120 37 fighting fight VERB ital-1859 120 38 to to AUX ital-1859 120 39 repeal repeal VERB ital-1859 120 40 clauses clause NOUN ital-1859 120 41 of of ADP ital-1859 120 42 the the DET ital-1859 120 43 usa usa PROPN ital-1859 120 44 patriot patriot PROPN ital-1859 120 45 act act PROPN ital-1859 120 46 . . PUNCT ital-1859 121 1 today today NOUN ital-1859 121 2 ’s ’s PART ital-1859 121 3 library library NOUN ital-1859 121 4 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 121 5 are be AUX ital-1859 121 6 not not PART ital-1859 121 7 just just ADV ital-1859 121 8 information information NOUN ital-1859 121 9 consumers consumer NOUN ital-1859 121 10 — — PUNCT ital-1859 121 11 they they PRON ital-1859 121 12 are be AUX ital-1859 121 13 also also ADV ital-1859 121 14 information information NOUN ital-1859 121 15 producers producer NOUN ital-1859 121 16 . . PUNCT ital-1859 122 1 therefore therefore ADV ital-1859 122 2 it it PRON ital-1859 122 3 is be AUX ital-1859 122 4 just just ADV ital-1859 122 5 as as ADV ital-1859 122 6 critical critical ADJ ital-1859 122 7 for for SCONJ ital-1859 122 8 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 122 9 to to PART ital-1859 122 10 advocate advocate VERB ital-1859 122 11 for for ADP ital-1859 122 12 their their PRON ital-1859 122 13 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 122 14 rights right NOUN ital-1859 122 15 as as SCONJ ital-1859 122 16 it it PRON ital-1859 122 17 is be AUX ital-1859 122 18 for for SCONJ ital-1859 122 19 them they PRON ital-1859 122 20 to to PART ital-1859 122 21 defend defend VERB ital-1859 122 22 their their PRON ital-1859 122 23 freedom freedom NOUN ital-1859 122 24 to to PART ital-1859 122 25 read read VERB ital-1859 122 26 . . PUNCT ital-1859 123 1 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote60#footnote60 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote60#footnote60 PROPN ital-1859 123 2 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fcreativecomms.org https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fcreativecomms.org PROPN ital-1859 123 3 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote65#footnote65 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/webreadyviewbody.aspx?t=att&id=rgaaaadxslsgbeewtj9q0yhnkit2bwboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqalrqjtslaaboujgpo3tvsou0x%2bkwiyfqapiuledyaaaj&attid0=eacjse6zzphuq6qbfqvhbhu8&attcnt=1&pn=1#footnote65#footnote65 VERB ital-1859 123 4 information information NOUN ital-1859 123 5 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 123 6 and and CCONJ ital-1859 123 7 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 123 8 | | ADP ital-1859 123 9 march march PROPN ital-1859 123 10 2012 2012 NUM ital-1859 123 11 17 17 NUM ital-1859 123 12 the the DET ital-1859 123 13 internet internet NOUN ital-1859 123 14 has have AUX ital-1859 123 15 become become VERB ital-1859 123 16 such such DET ital-1859 123 17 a a DET ital-1859 123 18 strong strong ADJ ital-1859 123 19 incubator incubator NOUN ital-1859 123 20 of of ADP ital-1859 123 21 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 123 22 expression expression NOUN ital-1859 123 23 and and CCONJ ital-1859 123 24 innovation innovation NOUN ital-1859 123 25 that that PRON ital-1859 123 26 the the DET ital-1859 123 27 innovators innovator NOUN ital-1859 123 28 are be AUX ital-1859 123 29 looking look VERB ital-1859 123 30 for for ADP ital-1859 123 31 a a DET ital-1859 123 32 way way NOUN ital-1859 123 33 to to PART ital-1859 123 34 shirk shirk VERB ital-1859 123 35 the the DET ital-1859 123 36 very very ADJ ital-1859 123 37 laws law NOUN ital-1859 123 38 that that PRON ital-1859 123 39 were be AUX ital-1859 123 40 designed design VERB ital-1859 123 41 to to PART ital-1859 123 42 protect protect VERB ital-1859 123 43 their their PRON ital-1859 123 44 interests interest NOUN ital-1859 123 45 . . PUNCT ital-1859 124 1 in in ADP ital-1859 124 2 the the DET ital-1859 124 3 end end NOUN ital-1859 124 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 124 5 the the DET ital-1859 124 6 desire desire NOUN ital-1859 124 7 to to PART ital-1859 124 8 create create VERB ital-1859 124 9 and and CCONJ ital-1859 124 10 innovate innovate ADJ ital-1859 124 11 seems seem VERB ital-1859 124 12 to to PART ital-1859 124 13 be be AUX ital-1859 124 14 more more ADV ital-1859 124 15 innate innate ADJ ital-1859 124 16 than than ADP ital-1859 124 17 those those PRON ital-1859 124 18 writing write VERB ital-1859 124 19 our our PRON ital-1859 124 20 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 124 21 property property NOUN ital-1859 124 22 laws law NOUN ital-1859 124 23 expected expect VERB ital-1859 124 24 . . PUNCT ital-1859 125 1 perhaps perhaps ADV ital-1859 125 2 financial financial ADJ ital-1859 125 3 gain gain NOUN ital-1859 125 4 is be AUX ital-1859 125 5 less less ADJ ital-1859 125 6 of of ADP ital-1859 125 7 a a DET ital-1859 125 8 motivator motivator NOUN ital-1859 125 9 than than ADP ital-1859 125 10 the the DET ital-1859 125 11 pleasure pleasure NOUN ital-1859 125 12 of of ADP ital-1859 125 13 sharing share VERB ital-1859 125 14 a a DET ital-1859 125 15 piece piece NOUN ital-1859 125 16 of of ADP ital-1859 125 17 ourselves ourselves PRON ital-1859 125 18 and and CCONJ ital-1859 125 19 our our PRON ital-1859 125 20 worldview worldview NOUN ital-1859 125 21 with with ADP ital-1859 125 22 the the DET ital-1859 125 23 rest rest NOUN ital-1859 125 24 of of ADP ital-1859 125 25 society society NOUN ital-1859 125 26 . . PUNCT ital-1859 126 1 whether whether SCONJ ital-1859 126 2 that that PRON ital-1859 126 3 ’s ’ VERB ital-1859 126 4 the the DET ital-1859 126 5 case case NOUN ital-1859 126 6 or or CCONJ ital-1859 126 7 not not PART ital-1859 126 8 , , PUNCT ital-1859 126 9 what what PRON ital-1859 126 10 is be AUX ital-1859 126 11 clear clear ADJ ital-1859 126 12 is be AUX ital-1859 126 13 that that SCONJ ital-1859 126 14 if if SCONJ ital-1859 126 15 we we PRON ital-1859 126 16 do do AUX ital-1859 126 17 not not PART ital-1859 126 18 roll roll VERB ital-1859 126 19 back back ADP ital-1859 126 20 legislation legislation NOUN ital-1859 126 21 like like ADP ital-1859 126 22 the the DET ital-1859 126 23 sonny sonny PROPN ital-1859 126 24 bono bono X ital-1859 126 25 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 126 26 term term NOUN ital-1859 126 27 extension extension NOUN ital-1859 126 28 act act NOUN ital-1859 126 29 and and CCONJ ital-1859 126 30 the the DET ital-1859 126 31 dmca dmca NOUN ital-1859 126 32 so so SCONJ ital-1859 126 33 as as SCONJ ital-1859 126 34 to to PART ital-1859 126 35 save save VERB ital-1859 126 36 the the DET ital-1859 126 37 public public ADJ ital-1859 126 38 domain domain NOUN ital-1859 126 39 , , PUNCT ital-1859 126 40 the the DET ital-1859 126 41 pressure pressure NOUN ital-1859 126 42 to to PART ital-1859 126 43 create create VERB ital-1859 126 44 outside outside ADP ital-1859 126 45 the the DET ital-1859 126 46 bounds bound NOUN ital-1859 126 47 of of ADP ital-1859 126 48 the the DET ital-1859 126 49 law law NOUN ital-1859 126 50 is be AUX ital-1859 126 51 going go VERB ital-1859 126 52 to to PART ital-1859 126 53 turn turn VERB ital-1859 126 54 more more ADJ ital-1859 126 55 inventors inventor NOUN ital-1859 126 56 and and CCONJ ital-1859 126 57 artists artist NOUN ital-1859 126 58 into into ADP ital-1859 126 59 anarchists anarchist NOUN ital-1859 126 60 , , PUNCT ital-1859 126 61 threatening threaten VERB ital-1859 126 62 the the DET ital-1859 126 63 interests interest NOUN ital-1859 126 64 of of ADP ital-1859 126 65 reasonable reasonable ADJ ital-1859 126 66 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 126 67 holders holder NOUN ital-1859 126 68 . . PUNCT ital-1859 127 1 as as ADP ital-1859 127 2 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 127 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 127 4 we we PRON ital-1859 127 5 must must AUX ital-1859 127 6 curate curate VERB ital-1859 127 7 and and CCONJ ital-1859 127 8 defend defend VERB ital-1859 127 9 the the DET ital-1859 127 10 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 127 11 property property NOUN ital-1859 127 12 of of ADP ital-1859 127 13 the the DET ital-1859 127 14 established establish VERB ital-1859 127 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 127 16 while while SCONJ ital-1859 127 17 fostering foster VERB ital-1859 127 18 the the DET ital-1859 127 19 innovative innovative ADJ ital-1859 127 20 spirit spirit NOUN ital-1859 127 21 of of ADP ital-1859 127 22 the the DET ital-1859 127 23 next next ADJ ital-1859 127 24 generation generation NOUN ital-1859 127 25 . . PUNCT ital-1859 128 1 as as SCONJ ital-1859 128 2 information information NOUN ital-1859 128 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 128 4 literature literature NOUN ital-1859 128 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 128 6 and and CCONJ ital-1859 128 7 other other ADJ ital-1859 128 8 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 128 9 works work NOUN ital-1859 128 10 move move VERB ital-1859 128 11 out out ADP ital-1859 128 12 of of ADP ital-1859 128 13 the the DET ital-1859 128 14 physical physical ADJ ital-1859 128 15 world world NOUN ital-1859 128 16 , , PUNCT ital-1859 128 17 and and CCONJ ital-1859 128 18 off off ADP ital-1859 128 19 the the DET ital-1859 128 20 shelves shelf NOUN ital-1859 128 21 , , PUNCT ital-1859 128 22 into into ADP ital-1859 128 23 the the DET ital-1859 128 24 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 128 25 realm realm NOUN ital-1859 128 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 128 27 librarians librarian NOUN ital-1859 128 28 need need VERB ital-1859 128 29 to to PART ital-1859 128 30 do do VERB ital-1859 128 31 their their PRON ital-1859 128 32 part part NOUN ital-1859 128 33 to to PART ital-1859 128 34 ensure ensure VERB ital-1859 128 35 legislation legislation NOUN ital-1859 128 36 is be AUX ital-1859 128 37 aligned align VERB ital-1859 128 38 with with ADP ital-1859 128 39 this this DET ital-1859 128 40 new new ADJ ital-1859 128 41 reality reality NOUN ital-1859 128 42 . . PUNCT ital-1859 129 1 if if SCONJ ital-1859 129 2 we we PRON ital-1859 129 3 do do VERB ital-1859 129 4 not not PART ital-1859 129 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 129 6 our our PRON ital-1859 129 7 profession profession NOUN ital-1859 129 8 may may AUX ital-1859 129 9 suffer suffer VERB ital-1859 129 10 first first ADV ital-1859 129 11 , , PUNCT ital-1859 129 12 but but CCONJ ital-1859 129 13 it it PRON ital-1859 129 14 will will AUX ital-1859 129 15 not not PART ital-1859 129 16 be be AUX ital-1859 129 17 the the DET ital-1859 129 18 last last ADJ ital-1859 129 19 casualty casualty NOUN ital-1859 129 20 of of ADP ital-1859 129 21 the the DET ital-1859 129 22 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 129 23 wars war NOUN ital-1859 129 24 . . PUNCT ital-1859 130 1 references reference NOUN ital-1859 130 2 1 1 NUM ital-1859 130 3 . . PUNCT ital-1859 131 1 beverly beverly PROPN ital-1859 131 2 goldberg goldberg PROPN ital-1859 131 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 131 4 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 131 5 lg lg NOUN ital-1859 131 6 unlocks unlock VERB ital-1859 131 7 doors door NOUN ital-1859 131 8 for for ADP ital-1859 131 9 creators creator NOUN ital-1859 131 10 , , PUNCT ital-1859 131 11 consumers consumer NOUN ital-1859 131 12 with with ADP ital-1859 131 13 dmca dmca NOUN ital-1859 131 14 exceptions exception NOUN ital-1859 131 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 131 16 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 131 17 american american PROPN ital-1859 131 18 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 131 19 41 41 NUM ital-1859 131 20 , , PUNCT ital-1859 131 21 no no NOUN ital-1859 131 22 . . NOUN ital-1859 131 23 9 9 NUM ital-1859 131 24 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 131 25 summer summer NOUN ital-1859 131 26 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 131 27 ): ): PUNCT ital-1859 131 28 14 14 NUM ital-1859 131 29 . . SYM ital-1859 132 1 2 2 X ital-1859 132 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 132 3 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 132 4 . . PUNCT ital-1859 133 1 3 3 X ital-1859 133 2 . . X ital-1859 133 3 goldberg goldberg PROPN ital-1859 133 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 133 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 133 6 lg lg NOUN ital-1859 133 7 unlocks unlock VERB ital-1859 133 8 doors door NOUN ital-1859 133 9 . . PUNCT ital-1859 133 10 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 134 1 4 4 NUM ital-1859 134 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 134 3 christopher christopher PROPN ital-1859 134 4 alan alan PROPN ital-1859 134 5 jennings jennings PROPN ital-1859 134 6 , , PUNCT ital-1859 134 7 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 134 8 use use NOUN ital-1859 134 9 on on ADP ital-1859 134 10 the the DET ital-1859 134 11 internet internet NOUN ital-1859 134 12 , , PUNCT ital-1859 134 13 prepared prepare VERB ital-1859 134 14 by by ADP ital-1859 134 15 the the DET ital-1859 134 16 congressional congressional ADJ ital-1859 134 17 research research NOUN ital-1859 134 18 service service NOUN ital-1859 134 19 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 134 20 washington washington PROPN ital-1859 134 21 , , PUNCT ital-1859 134 22 dc dc PROPN ital-1859 134 23 : : PUNCT ital-1859 134 24 library library PROPN ital-1859 134 25 of of ADP ital-1859 134 26 congress congress PROPN ital-1859 134 27 , , PUNCT ital-1859 134 28 2002 2002 NUM ital-1859 134 29 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 134 30 , , PUNCT ital-1859 134 31 2 2 NUM ital-1859 134 32 . . SYM ital-1859 134 33 5 5 NUM ital-1859 134 34 . . PUNCT ital-1859 135 1 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 135 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 135 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 135 4 1 1 NUM ital-1859 135 5 . . NOUN ital-1859 135 6 6 6 NUM ital-1859 135 7 . . PUNCT ital-1859 135 8 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 135 9 . . PUNCT ital-1859 136 1 7 7 X ital-1859 136 2 . . X ital-1859 136 3 brandon brandon PROPN ital-1859 136 4 butler butler NOUN ital-1859 136 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 136 6 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 136 7 urban urban ADJ ital-1859 136 8 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 136 9 legends legend NOUN ital-1859 136 10 , , PUNCT ital-1859 136 11 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 136 12 research research NOUN ital-1859 136 13 library library NOUN ital-1859 136 14 issues issue NOUN ital-1859 136 15 270 270 NUM ital-1859 136 16 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 136 17 june june PROPN ital-1859 136 18 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 136 19 ): ): PUNCT ital-1859 136 20 18 18 NUM ital-1859 136 21 . . SYM ital-1859 136 22 8 8 NUM ital-1859 136 23 . . X ital-1859 137 1 robin robin PROPN ital-1859 137 2 jeweler jeweler PROPN ital-1859 137 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 137 4 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 137 5 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 137 6 rights right NOUN ital-1859 137 7 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 137 8 and and CCONJ ital-1859 137 9 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 137 10 use use NOUN ital-1859 137 11 in in ADP ital-1859 137 12 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 137 13 law law NOUN ital-1859 137 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 137 15 prepared prepare VERB ital-1859 137 16 by by ADP ital-1859 137 17 the the DET ital-1859 137 18 congressional congressional ADJ ital-1859 137 19 research research NOUN ital-1859 137 20 service service NOUN ital-1859 137 21 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 137 22 washington washington PROPN ital-1859 137 23 , , PUNCT ital-1859 137 24 dc dc PROPN ital-1859 137 25 : : PUNCT ital-1859 137 26 library library PROPN ital-1859 137 27 of of ADP ital-1859 137 28 congress congress PROPN ital-1859 137 29 , , PUNCT ital-1859 137 30 2003 2003 NUM ital-1859 137 31 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 137 32 , , PUNCT ital-1859 137 33 5 5 NUM ital-1859 137 34 . . SYM ital-1859 137 35 9 9 NUM ital-1859 137 36 . . PUNCT ital-1859 138 1 rachel rachel PROPN ital-1859 138 2 bridgewater bridgewater PROPN ital-1859 138 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 138 4 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 138 5 tipping tip VERB ital-1859 138 6 the the DET ital-1859 138 7 scales scale NOUN ital-1859 138 8 : : PUNCT ital-1859 138 9 how how SCONJ ital-1859 138 10 free free ADJ ital-1859 138 11 culture culture NOUN ital-1859 138 12 helps help VERB ital-1859 138 13 restore restore VERB ital-1859 138 14 balance balance NOUN ital-1859 138 15 in in ADP ital-1859 138 16 the the DET ital-1859 138 17 age age NOUN ital-1859 138 18 of of ADP ital-1859 138 19 copyright copyright ADJ ital-1859 138 20 maximalism maximalism NOUN ital-1859 138 21 , , PUNCT ital-1859 138 22 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 138 23 oregon oregon PROPN ital-1859 138 24 library library PROPN ital-1859 138 25 association association PROPN ital-1859 138 26 quarterly quarterly PROPN ital-1859 138 27 16 16 NUM ital-1859 138 28 , , PUNCT ital-1859 138 29 no no INTJ ital-1859 138 30 . . NOUN ital-1859 138 31 3 3 NUM ital-1859 138 32 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 138 33 fall fall VERB ital-1859 138 34 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 138 35 ): ): PUNCT ital-1859 138 36 19 19 NUM ital-1859 138 37 . . SYM ital-1859 139 1 10 10 NUM ital-1859 139 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 139 3 charles charles PROPN ital-1859 139 4 w. w. PROPN ital-1859 139 5 bailey bailey PROPN ital-1859 139 6 jr jr PROPN ital-1859 139 7 . . PROPN ital-1859 139 8 , , PUNCT ital-1859 139 9 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 139 10 strong strong ADJ ital-1859 139 11 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 139 12 + + CCONJ ital-1859 139 13 drm drm NOUN ital-1859 139 14 + + CCONJ ital-1859 139 15 weak weak ADJ ital-1859 139 16 net net ADJ ital-1859 139 17 neutrality neutrality NOUN ital-1859 139 18 = = SYM ital-1859 139 19 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 139 20 dystopia dystopia NOUN ital-1859 139 21 ? ? PUNCT ital-1859 139 22 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 139 23 information information NOUN ital-1859 139 24 technology technology PROPN ital-1859 139 25 & & CCONJ ital-1859 139 26 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 139 27 25 25 NUM ital-1859 139 28 , , PUNCT ital-1859 139 29 no no INTJ ital-1859 139 30 . . NOUN ital-1859 139 31 3 3 NUM ital-1859 139 32 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 139 33 summer summer NOUN ital-1859 139 34 2006 2006 NUM ital-1859 139 35 ): ): PUNCT ital-1859 139 36 117 117 NUM ital-1859 139 37 ; ; PUNCT ital-1859 139 38 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 139 39 . . PROPN ital-1859 139 40 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 139 41 office office PROPN ital-1859 139 42 , , PUNCT ital-1859 139 43 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 139 44 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 139 45 law law NOUN ital-1859 139 46 of of ADP ital-1859 139 47 the the DET ital-1859 139 48 united united PROPN ital-1859 139 49 states states PROPN ital-1859 139 50 , , PUNCT ital-1859 139 51 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 139 52 under under ADP ital-1859 139 53 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 139 54 chapter chapter NOUN ital-1859 139 55 3 3 NUM ital-1859 139 56 : : PUNCT ital-1859 139 57 duration duration NOUN ital-1859 139 58 of of ADP ital-1859 139 59 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 139 60 , , PUNCT ital-1859 139 61 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 139 62 http://www.copyright.gov/title17 http://www.copyright.gov/title17 NOUN ital-1859 139 63 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 139 64 accessed access VERB ital-1859 139 65 december december PROPN ital-1859 139 66 8 8 NUM ital-1859 139 67 , , PUNCT ital-1859 139 68 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 139 69 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 139 70 . . PUNCT ital-1859 140 1 11 11 NUM ital-1859 140 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 140 3 dan dan PROPN ital-1859 140 4 hunter hunter PROPN ital-1859 140 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 140 6 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 140 7 culture culture NOUN ital-1859 140 8 war war NOUN ital-1859 140 9 , , PUNCT ital-1859 140 10 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 140 11 texas texas PROPN ital-1859 140 12 law law PROPN ital-1859 140 13 review review NOUN ital-1859 140 14 83 83 NUM ital-1859 140 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 140 16 no no NOUN ital-1859 140 17 . . NOUN ital-1859 140 18 4 4 NUM ital-1859 140 19 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 140 20 2005 2005 NUM ital-1859 140 21 ): ): SYM ital-1859 140 22 1130 1130 NUM ital-1859 140 23 . . PUNCT ital-1859 141 1 12 12 NUM ital-1859 141 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 141 3 bailey bailey NOUN ital-1859 141 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 141 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 141 6 strong strong ADJ ital-1859 141 7 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 141 8 , , PUNCT ital-1859 141 9 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 141 10 118 118 NUM ital-1859 141 11 . . PUNCT ital-1859 142 1 13 13 NUM ital-1859 142 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 143 1 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 143 2 . . PROPN ital-1859 143 3 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 143 4 office office PROPN ital-1859 143 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 143 6 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 143 7 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 143 8 law law NOUN ital-1859 143 9 of of ADP ital-1859 143 10 the the DET ital-1859 143 11 united united PROPN ital-1859 143 12 states states PROPN ital-1859 143 13 , , PUNCT ital-1859 143 14 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 143 15 under under ADP ital-1859 143 16 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 143 17 chapter chapter NOUN ital-1859 143 18 1 1 NUM ital-1859 143 19 : : PUNCT ital-1859 143 20 subject subject NOUN ital-1859 143 21 matter matter NOUN ital-1859 143 22 and and CCONJ ital-1859 143 23 scope scope NOUN ital-1859 143 24 of of ADP ital-1859 143 25 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 143 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 143 27 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 143 28 http://www.copyright.gov/title17 http://www.copyright.gov/title17 NOUN ital-1859 143 29 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 143 30 accessed access VERB ital-1859 143 31 december december PROPN ital-1859 143 32 8 8 NUM ital-1859 143 33 , , PUNCT ital-1859 143 34 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 143 35 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 143 36 . . PUNCT ital-1859 144 1 14 14 NUM ital-1859 144 2 . . X ital-1859 144 3 bailey bailey NOUN ital-1859 144 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 144 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 144 6 strong strong ADJ ital-1859 144 7 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 144 8 , , PUNCT ital-1859 144 9 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 144 10 118 118 NUM ital-1859 144 11 . . PUNCT ital-1859 145 1 15 15 NUM ital-1859 145 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 146 1 mary mary PROPN ital-1859 146 2 minnow minnow PROPN ital-1859 146 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 146 4 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 146 5 library library NOUN ital-1859 146 6 digitization digitization NOUN ital-1859 146 7 table table NOUN ital-1859 146 8 , , PUNCT ital-1859 146 9 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 146 10 http://www.librarylaw.com/digitizationtable.htm http://www.librarylaw.com/digitizationtable.htm NOUN ital-1859 146 11 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 146 12 accessed access VERB ital-1859 146 13 december december PROPN ital-1859 146 14 8 8 NUM ital-1859 146 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 146 16 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 146 17 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 146 18 . . PUNCT ital-1859 147 1 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.copyright.gov%2ftitle17 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.copyright.gov%2ftitle17 PROPN ital-1859 147 2 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.copyright.gov%2ftitle17 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.copyright.gov%2ftitle17 PROPN ital-1859 147 3 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.librarylaw.com%2fdigitizationtable.htm https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.librarylaw.com%2fdigitizationtable.htm PROPN ital-1859 147 4 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 147 5 : : PUNCT ital-1859 147 6 regulation regulation NOUN ital-1859 147 7 out out ADP ital-1859 147 8 of of ADP ital-1859 147 9 line line NOUN ital-1859 147 10 with with ADP ital-1859 147 11 our our PRON ital-1859 147 12 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 147 13 reality reality NOUN ital-1859 147 14 | | PROPN ital-1859 147 15 mcdermott mcdermott PROPN ital-1859 147 16 18 18 NUM ital-1859 147 17 16 16 NUM ital-1859 147 18 . . PUNCT ital-1859 148 1 brian brian PROPN ital-1859 148 2 t. t. PROPN ital-1859 148 3 yeh yeh PROPN ital-1859 148 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 148 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 148 6 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 148 7 works work VERB ital-1859 148 8 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 148 9 in in ADP ital-1859 148 10 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 148 11 law law NOUN ital-1859 148 12 , , PUNCT ital-1859 148 13 prepared prepare VERB ital-1859 148 14 by by ADP ital-1859 148 15 the the DET ital-1859 148 16 congressional congressional ADJ ital-1859 148 17 research research NOUN ital-1859 148 18 service service NOUN ital-1859 148 19 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 148 20 washington washington PROPN ital-1859 148 21 , , PUNCT ital-1859 148 22 dc dc PROPN ital-1859 148 23 : : PUNCT ital-1859 148 24 library library PROPN ital-1859 148 25 of of ADP ital-1859 148 26 congress congress PROPN ital-1859 148 27 , , PUNCT ital-1859 148 28 2002 2002 NUM ital-1859 148 29 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 148 30 , , PUNCT ital-1859 148 31 summary summary NOUN ital-1859 148 32 . . PUNCT ital-1859 149 1 17 17 NUM ital-1859 149 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 149 3 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 149 4 . . PUNCT ital-1859 150 1 18 18 NUM ital-1859 150 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 151 1 jisc jisc PROPN ital-1859 151 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 151 3 in in ADP ital-1859 151 4 from from ADP ital-1859 151 5 the the DET ital-1859 151 6 cold cold NOUN ital-1859 151 7 : : PUNCT ital-1859 151 8 an an DET ital-1859 151 9 assessment assessment NOUN ital-1859 151 10 of of ADP ital-1859 151 11 the the DET ital-1859 151 12 scope scope NOUN ital-1859 151 13 of of ADP ital-1859 151 14 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 151 15 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 151 16 works work NOUN ital-1859 151 17 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 151 18 and and CCONJ ital-1859 151 19 its its PRON ital-1859 151 20 impact impact NOUN ital-1859 151 21 on on ADP ital-1859 151 22 the the DET ital-1859 151 23 delivery delivery NOUN ital-1859 151 24 of of ADP ital-1859 151 25 services service NOUN ital-1859 151 26 to to ADP ital-1859 151 27 the the DET ital-1859 151 28 public public NOUN ital-1859 151 29 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 151 30 cambridge cambridge PROPN ital-1859 151 31 , , PUNCT ital-1859 151 32 uk uk PROPN ital-1859 151 33 : : PUNCT ital-1859 151 34 jisc jisc PROPN ital-1859 151 35 , , PUNCT ital-1859 151 36 2009 2009 NUM ital-1859 151 37 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 151 38 , , PUNCT ital-1859 151 39 6 6 NUM ital-1859 151 40 . . NUM ital-1859 151 41 19 19 NUM ital-1859 151 42 . . PUNCT ital-1859 152 1 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 152 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 153 1 20 20 NUM ital-1859 153 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 154 1 andrew andrew PROPN ital-1859 154 2 albanese albanese PROPN ital-1859 154 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 154 4 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 154 5 hathitrust hathitrust NOUN ital-1859 154 6 suspends suspend VERB ital-1859 154 7 its its PRON ital-1859 154 8 orphan orphan NOUN ital-1859 154 9 works work NOUN ital-1859 154 10 release release NOUN ital-1859 154 11 , , PUNCT ital-1859 154 12 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 154 13 publishers publisher NOUN ital-1859 154 14 weekly weekly ADJ ital-1859 154 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 154 16 sept sept PROPN ital-1859 154 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 154 18 16 16 NUM ital-1859 154 19 , , PUNCT ital-1859 154 20 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 154 21 , , PUNCT ital-1859 154 22 http://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/bytopic/digital/copyright/article/48722-hathitrust-suspends-its-orphan-works-release-.html http://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/bytopic/digital/copyright/article/48722-hathitrust-suspends-its-orphan-works-release-.html PROPN ital-1859 154 23 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 154 24 accessed access VERB ital-1859 154 25 october october PROPN ital-1859 154 26 13 13 NUM ital-1859 154 27 , , PUNCT ital-1859 154 28 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 154 29 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 154 30 . . PUNCT ital-1859 155 1 21 21 NUM ital-1859 155 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 156 1 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 156 2 . . PROPN ital-1859 156 3 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 156 4 office office PROPN ital-1859 156 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 156 6 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 156 7 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 156 8 law law NOUN ital-1859 156 9 of of ADP ital-1859 156 10 the the DET ital-1859 156 11 united united PROPN ital-1859 156 12 states states PROPN ital-1859 156 13 , , PUNCT ital-1859 156 14 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 156 15 under under ADP ital-1859 156 16 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 156 17 chapter chapter NOUN ital-1859 156 18 1 1 NUM ital-1859 156 19 . . PUNCT ital-1859 156 20 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 157 1 22 22 NUM ital-1859 157 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 158 1 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 158 2 . . PROPN ital-1859 158 3 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 158 4 office office PROPN ital-1859 158 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 158 6 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 158 7 basics basic NOUN ital-1859 158 8 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 158 9 washington washington PROPN ital-1859 158 10 , , PUNCT ital-1859 158 11 dc dc PROPN ital-1859 158 12 : : PUNCT ital-1859 158 13 u.s u.s PROPN ital-1859 158 14 . . PROPN ital-1859 158 15 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 158 16 office office PROPN ital-1859 158 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 158 18 2000 2000 NUM ital-1859 158 19 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 158 20 , , PUNCT ital-1859 158 21 www.copyright.gov/circs/circl/html www.copyright.gov/circs/circl/html PROPN ital-1859 158 22 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 158 23 accessed access VERB ital-1859 158 24 december december PROPN ital-1859 158 25 8 8 NUM ital-1859 158 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 158 27 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 158 28 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 158 29 . . PUNCT ital-1859 159 1 23 23 NUM ital-1859 159 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 160 1 mary mary PROPN ital-1859 160 2 minnow minnow PROPN ital-1859 160 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 160 4 california california PROPN ital-1859 160 5 library library PROPN ital-1859 160 6 association association PROPN ital-1859 160 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 160 8 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 160 9 library library NOUN ital-1859 160 10 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 160 11 liability liability NOUN ital-1859 160 12 and and CCONJ ital-1859 160 13 pirating pirate VERB ital-1859 160 14 patrons patron NOUN ital-1859 160 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 160 16 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 160 17 http://www.cla-net.org/resources/articles/minow_pirating.php http://www.cla-net.org/resources/articles/minow_pirating.php ADV ital-1859 160 18 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 160 19 accessed access VERB ital-1859 160 20 december december PROPN ital-1859 160 21 10 10 NUM ital-1859 160 22 , , PUNCT ital-1859 160 23 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 160 24 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 160 25 . . PUNCT ital-1859 161 1 24 24 NUM ital-1859 161 2 . . X ital-1859 161 3 bailey bailey NOUN ital-1859 161 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 161 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 161 6 strong strong ADJ ital-1859 161 7 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 161 8 , , PUNCT ital-1859 161 9 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 161 10 118 118 NUM ital-1859 161 11 . . PUNCT ital-1859 162 1 25 25 NUM ital-1859 162 2 . . X ital-1859 162 3 overdrive overdrive VERB ital-1859 162 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 162 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 162 6 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 162 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 162 8 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 162 9 http://www.overdrive.com/copyright.asp http://www.overdrive.com/copyright.asp PROPN ital-1859 162 10 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 162 11 accessed access VERB ital-1859 162 12 december december PROPN ital-1859 162 13 13 13 NUM ital-1859 162 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 162 15 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 162 16 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 162 17 . . PUNCT ital-1859 163 1 26 26 NUM ital-1859 163 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 163 3 josh josh PROPN ital-1859 163 4 hadro hadro PROPN ital-1859 163 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 163 6 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 163 7 harpercollins harpercollins PROPN ital-1859 163 8 puts put VERB ital-1859 163 9 26 26 NUM ital-1859 163 10 loan loan NOUN ital-1859 163 11 cap cap NOUN ital-1859 163 12 on on ADP ital-1859 163 13 ebook ebook NOUN ital-1859 163 14 circulations circulation NOUN ital-1859 163 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 163 16 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 163 17 library library NOUN ital-1859 163 18 journal journal PROPN ital-1859 163 19 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 163 20 february february PROPN ital-1859 163 21 25 25 NUM ital-1859 163 22 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 163 23 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 163 24 , , PUNCT ital-1859 163 25 http://www.libraryjournal.com/lj/home/889452264/harpercollins_puts_26_loan_cap.html.csp http://www.libraryjournal.com/lj/home/889452264/harpercollins_puts_26_loan_cap.html.csp NUM ital-1859 163 26 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 163 27 accessed access VERB ital-1859 163 28 october october PROPN ital-1859 163 29 13 13 NUM ital-1859 163 30 , , PUNCT ital-1859 163 31 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 163 32 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 163 33 . . PUNCT ital-1859 164 1 27 27 NUM ital-1859 164 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 164 3 butler butler NOUN ital-1859 164 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 164 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 164 6 urban urban ADJ ital-1859 164 7 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 164 8 legends legend NOUN ital-1859 164 9 , , PUNCT ital-1859 164 10 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 164 11 18 18 NUM ital-1859 164 12 . . NUM ital-1859 164 13 28 28 NUM ital-1859 164 14 . . PUNCT ital-1859 164 15 bailey bailey NOUN ital-1859 164 16 , , PUNCT ital-1859 164 17 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 164 18 strong strong ADJ ital-1859 164 19 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 164 20 , , PUNCT ital-1859 164 21 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 164 22 118 118 NUM ital-1859 164 23 . . PUNCT ital-1859 164 24 29 29 NUM ital-1859 164 25 . . PUNCT ital-1859 165 1 library library PROPN ital-1859 165 2 of of ADP ital-1859 165 3 congress congress PROPN ital-1859 165 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 165 5 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 165 6 use use NOUN ital-1859 165 7 on on ADP ital-1859 165 8 the the DET ital-1859 165 9 internet internet NOUN ital-1859 165 10 , , PUNCT ital-1859 165 11 3 3 NUM ital-1859 165 12 . . SYM ital-1859 165 13 30 30 NUM ital-1859 165 14 . . PUNCT ital-1859 166 1 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 166 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 166 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 166 4 summary summary NOUN ital-1859 166 5 . . PUNCT ital-1859 167 1 31 31 NUM ital-1859 167 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 168 1 matthew matthew PROPN ital-1859 168 2 k. k. PROPN ital-1859 168 3 dames dames PROPN ital-1859 168 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 168 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 168 6 education education NOUN ital-1859 168 7 use use NOUN ital-1859 168 8 in in ADP ital-1859 168 9 the the DET ital-1859 168 10 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 168 11 age age NOUN ital-1859 168 12 , , PUNCT ital-1859 168 13 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 168 14 information information NOUN ital-1859 168 15 today today NOUN ital-1859 168 16 27 27 NUM ital-1859 168 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 168 18 no no INTJ ital-1859 168 19 . . NOUN ital-1859 168 20 4 4 NUM ital-1859 168 21 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 168 22 april april PROPN ital-1859 168 23 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 168 24 ): ): PUNCT ital-1859 168 25 18 18 NUM ital-1859 168 26 . . SYM ital-1859 169 1 32 32 NUM ital-1859 169 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 170 1 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 170 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 171 1 33 33 NUM ital-1859 171 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 172 1 dames dame NOUN ital-1859 172 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 172 3 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 172 4 education education NOUN ital-1859 172 5 use use NOUN ital-1859 172 6 in in ADP ital-1859 172 7 the the DET ital-1859 172 8 digital digital PROPN ital-1859 172 9 age,”18 age,”18 PROPN ital-1859 172 10 . . PUNCT ital-1859 173 1 34 34 NUM ital-1859 173 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 174 1 matthew matthew PROPN ital-1859 174 2 k. k. PROPN ital-1859 174 3 dames dames PROPN ital-1859 174 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 174 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 174 6 making make VERB ital-1859 174 7 a a DET ital-1859 174 8 case case NOUN ital-1859 174 9 for for ADP ital-1859 174 10 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 174 11 officers officer NOUN ital-1859 174 12 , , PUNCT ital-1859 174 13 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 174 14 information information NOUN ital-1859 174 15 today today NOUN ital-1859 174 16 25 25 NUM ital-1859 174 17 , , PUNCT ital-1859 174 18 no no INTJ ital-1859 174 19 . . NOUN ital-1859 174 20 7 7 NUM ital-1859 174 21 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 174 22 july july PROPN ital-1859 174 23 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 174 24 ): ): PUNCT ital-1859 174 25 16 16 NUM ital-1859 174 26 . . SYM ital-1859 175 1 35 35 NUM ital-1859 175 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 176 1 william william PROPN ital-1859 176 2 c. c. PROPN ital-1859 176 3 dougherty dougherty PROPN ital-1859 176 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 176 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 176 6 the the DET ital-1859 176 7 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 176 8 quagmire quagmire NOUN ital-1859 176 9 , , PUNCT ital-1859 176 10 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 176 11 journal journal NOUN ital-1859 176 12 of of ADP ital-1859 176 13 academic academic ADJ ital-1859 176 14 librarianship librarianship NOUN ital-1859 176 15 36 36 NUM ital-1859 176 16 , , PUNCT ital-1859 176 17 no no NOUN ital-1859 176 18 . . NOUN ital-1859 176 19 4 4 NUM ital-1859 176 20 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 176 21 july july PROPN ital-1859 176 22 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 176 23 ): ): PUNCT ital-1859 176 24 351 351 NUM ital-1859 176 25 . . NUM ital-1859 176 26 36 36 NUM ital-1859 176 27 . . PUNCT ital-1859 177 1 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 177 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 178 1 37 37 NUM ital-1859 178 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 179 1 library library PROPN ital-1859 179 2 of of ADP ital-1859 179 3 congress congress PROPN ital-1859 179 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 179 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 179 6 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 179 7 rights right NOUN ital-1859 179 8 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 179 9 and and CCONJ ital-1859 179 10 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 179 11 use use NOUN ital-1859 179 12 in in ADP ital-1859 179 13 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 179 14 law law NOUN ital-1859 179 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 179 16 9 9 NUM ital-1859 179 17 . . NUM ital-1859 179 18 38 38 NUM ital-1859 179 19 . . PUNCT ital-1859 180 1 dougherty dougherty NOUN ital-1859 180 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 180 3 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 180 4 the the DET ital-1859 180 5 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 180 6 quagmire quagmire NOUN ital-1859 180 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 180 8 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 180 9 351 351 NUM ital-1859 180 10 . . NUM ital-1859 181 1 39 39 NUM ital-1859 181 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 182 1 kevin kevin PROPN ital-1859 182 2 smith smith PROPN ital-1859 182 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 182 4 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 182 5 streaming streaming NOUN ital-1859 182 6 video video NOUN ital-1859 182 7 case case NOUN ital-1859 182 8 dismissed dismiss VERB ital-1859 182 9 , , PUNCT ital-1859 182 10 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 182 11 scholarly scholarly ADJ ital-1859 182 12 communications communication NOUN ital-1859 182 13 @ @ ADP ital-1859 182 14 duke duke PROPN ital-1859 182 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 182 16 october october PROPN ital-1859 182 17 4 4 NUM ital-1859 182 18 , , PUNCT ital-1859 182 19 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 182 20 , , PUNCT ital-1859 182 21 http://blogs.library.duke.edu/scholcomm/2011/10/04/streaming-video-casedismissed/ http://blogs.library.duke.edu/scholcomm/2011/10/04/streaming-video-casedismissed/ PROPN ital-1859 182 22 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 182 23 accessed access VERB ital-1859 182 24 october october PROPN ital-1859 182 25 13 13 NUM ital-1859 182 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 182 27 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 182 28 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 182 29 . . PUNCT ital-1859 183 1 http://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/digital/copyright/article/48722-hathitrust-suspends-its-orphan-works-release-.html http://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/digital/copyright/article/48722-hathitrust-suspends-its-orphan-works-release-.html X ital-1859 183 2 http://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/digital/copyright/article/48722-hathitrust-suspends-its-orphan-works-release-.html http://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/digital/copyright/article/48722-hathitrust-suspends-its-orphan-works-release-.html PROPN ital-1859 183 3 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.copyright.gov%2fcircs%2fcircl%2fhtml https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.copyright.gov%2fcircs%2fcircl%2fhtml PROPN ital-1859 183 4 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.cla-net.org%2fresources%2farticles%2fminow_pirating.php https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.cla-net.org%2fresources%2farticles%2fminow_pirating.php ADV ital-1859 183 5 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.overdrive.com%2fcopyright.asp https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.overdrive.com%2fcopyright.asp ADJ ital-1859 183 6 http://www.libraryjournal.com/lj/home/889452-264/harpercollins_puts_26_loan_cap.html.csp http://www.libraryjournal.com/lj/home/889452-264/harpercollins_puts_26_loan_cap.html.csp X ital-1859 183 7 http://www.libraryjournal.com/lj/home/889452-264/harpercollins_puts_26_loan_cap.html.csp http://www.libraryjournal.com/lj/home/889452-264/harpercollins_puts_26_loan_cap.html.csp X ital-1859 183 8 http://blogs.library.duke.edu/scholcomm/2011/10/04/streaming-video-case-dismissed/ http://blogs.library.duke.edu/scholcomm/2011/10/04/streaming-video-case-dismissed/ PROPN ital-1859 183 9 http://blogs.library.duke.edu/scholcomm/2011/10/04/streaming-video-case-dismissed/ http://blogs.library.duke.edu/scholcomm/2011/10/04/streaming-video-case-dismissed/ PROPN ital-1859 183 10 information information NOUN ital-1859 183 11 technology technology NOUN ital-1859 183 12 and and CCONJ ital-1859 183 13 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 183 14 | | ADP ital-1859 183 15 march march PROPN ital-1859 183 16 2012 2012 NUM ital-1859 183 17 19 19 NUM ital-1859 183 18 40 40 NUM ital-1859 183 19 . . PUNCT ital-1859 184 1 dougherty dougherty NOUN ital-1859 184 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 184 3 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 184 4 the the DET ital-1859 184 5 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 184 6 quagmire quagmire NOUN ital-1859 184 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 184 8 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 184 9 351 351 NUM ital-1859 184 10 . . PUNCT ital-1859 184 11 41 41 NUM ital-1859 184 12 . . PUNCT ital-1859 185 1 librarylaw.com librarylaw.com X ital-1859 185 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 185 3 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 185 4 library library NOUN ital-1859 185 5 digitization digitization NOUN ital-1859 185 6 table table NOUN ital-1859 185 7 . . PUNCT ital-1859 185 8 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 186 1 42 42 NUM ital-1859 186 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 187 1 kate kate PROPN ital-1859 187 2 m. m. PROPN ital-1859 187 3 manuel manuel PROPN ital-1859 187 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 187 5 the the DET ital-1859 187 6 google google PROPN ital-1859 187 7 library library PROPN ital-1859 187 8 project project NOUN ital-1859 187 9 : : PUNCT ital-1859 187 10 is be AUX ital-1859 187 11 digitization digitization NOUN ital-1859 187 12 for for ADP ital-1859 187 13 purposes purpose NOUN ital-1859 187 14 of of ADP ital-1859 187 15 online online ADJ ital-1859 187 16 indexing indexing NOUN ital-1859 187 17 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 187 18 use use NOUN ital-1859 187 19 under under ADP ital-1859 187 20 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 187 21 law law NOUN ital-1859 187 22 , , PUNCT ital-1859 187 23 prepared prepare VERB ital-1859 187 24 by by ADP ital-1859 187 25 the the DET ital-1859 187 26 congressional congressional ADJ ital-1859 187 27 research research NOUN ital-1859 187 28 service service NOUN ital-1859 187 29 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 187 30 washington washington PROPN ital-1859 187 31 , , PUNCT ital-1859 187 32 dc dc PROPN ital-1859 187 33 : : PUNCT ital-1859 187 34 library library PROPN ital-1859 187 35 of of ADP ital-1859 187 36 congress congress PROPN ital-1859 187 37 , , PUNCT ital-1859 187 38 2009 2009 NUM ital-1859 187 39 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 187 40 , , PUNCT ital-1859 187 41 1–2 1–2 NUM ital-1859 187 42 . . PUNCT ital-1859 188 1 43 43 NUM ital-1859 188 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 189 1 jeweler jeweler NOUN ital-1859 189 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 189 3 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 189 4 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 189 5 rights right NOUN ital-1859 189 6 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 189 7 and and CCONJ ital-1859 189 8 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 189 9 use use NOUN ital-1859 189 10 in in ADP ital-1859 189 11 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 189 12 law law NOUN ital-1859 189 13 , , PUNCT ital-1859 189 14 2 2 NUM ital-1859 189 15 . . NUM ital-1859 189 16 44 44 NUM ital-1859 189 17 . . PUNCT ital-1859 190 1 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 190 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 191 1 45 45 NUM ital-1859 191 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 191 3 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 191 4 . . PUNCT ital-1859 192 1 46 46 NUM ital-1859 192 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 193 1 manuel manuel PROPN ital-1859 193 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 193 3 the the DET ital-1859 193 4 google google PROPN ital-1859 193 5 library library PROPN ital-1859 193 6 project project NOUN ital-1859 193 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 193 8 2 2 NUM ital-1859 193 9 . . NUM ital-1859 193 10 47 47 NUM ital-1859 193 11 . . PUNCT ital-1859 194 1 amir amir PROPN ital-1859 194 2 efrati efrati PROPN ital-1859 194 3 and and CCONJ ital-1859 194 4 jeffrey jeffrey PROPN ital-1859 194 5 a. a. PROPN ital-1859 194 6 trachtenberg trachtenberg PROPN ital-1859 194 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 194 8 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 194 9 judge judge NOUN ital-1859 194 10 rejects reject VERB ital-1859 194 11 google google PROPN ital-1859 194 12 books books PROPN ital-1859 194 13 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 194 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 194 15 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 194 16 wall wall PROPN ital-1859 194 17 street street PROPN ital-1859 194 18 journal journal PROPN ital-1859 194 19 , , PUNCT ital-1859 194 20 march march PROPN ital-1859 194 21 23 23 NUM ital-1859 194 22 , , PUNCT ital-1859 194 23 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 194 24 , , PUNCT ital-1859 194 25 http://online.wsj.com/article/sb10001424052748704461304576216923562033348.html http://online.wsj.com/article/sb10001424052748704461304576216923562033348.html NOUN ital-1859 194 26 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 194 27 accessed access VERB ital-1859 194 28 october october PROPN ital-1859 194 29 13 13 NUM ital-1859 194 30 , , PUNCT ital-1859 194 31 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 194 32 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 194 33 . . PUNCT ital-1859 195 1 48 48 NUM ital-1859 195 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 195 3 jennings jennings PROPN ital-1859 195 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 195 5 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 195 6 use use NOUN ital-1859 195 7 on on ADP ital-1859 195 8 the the DET ital-1859 195 9 internet internet NOUN ital-1859 195 10 , , PUNCT ital-1859 195 11 7 7 NUM ital-1859 195 12 . . NUM ital-1859 195 13 49 49 NUM ital-1859 195 14 . . PUNCT ital-1859 196 1 manuel manuel PROPN ital-1859 196 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 196 3 the the DET ital-1859 196 4 google google PROPN ital-1859 196 5 library library PROPN ital-1859 196 6 project project NOUN ital-1859 196 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 196 8 2 2 NUM ital-1859 196 9 . . SYM ital-1859 196 10 50 50 NUM ital-1859 196 11 . . PUNCT ital-1859 197 1 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 197 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 197 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 197 4 9–10 9–10 NUM ital-1859 197 5 . . PUNCT ital-1859 198 1 51 51 NUM ital-1859 198 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 199 1 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 199 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 200 1 52 52 NUM ital-1859 200 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 201 1 ibid ibid VERB ital-1859 201 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 202 1 53 53 NUM ital-1859 202 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 203 1 pamela pamela PROPN ital-1859 203 2 samuelson samuelson PROPN ital-1859 203 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 203 4 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 203 5 google google PROPN ital-1859 203 6 books book NOUN ital-1859 203 7 is be AUX ital-1859 203 8 not not PART ital-1859 203 9 a a DET ital-1859 203 10 library library NOUN ital-1859 203 11 , , PUNCT ital-1859 203 12 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 203 13 huffington huffington PROPN ital-1859 203 14 post post PROPN ital-1859 203 15 , , PUNCT ital-1859 203 16 october october PROPN ital-1859 203 17 13 13 NUM ital-1859 203 18 , , PUNCT ital-1859 203 19 2009 2009 NUM ital-1859 203 20 , , PUNCT ital-1859 203 21 http://www.huffingtonpost.com/pamela-samuelson/google-books-is-not-a-lib_b_317518.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/pamela-samuelson/google-books-is-not-a-lib_b_317518.html PROPN ital-1859 203 22 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 203 23 accessed access VERB ital-1859 203 24 december december PROPN ital-1859 203 25 10 10 NUM ital-1859 203 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 203 27 2009 2009 NUM ital-1859 203 28 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 203 29 . . PUNCT ital-1859 204 1 54 54 NUM ital-1859 204 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 205 1 ivy ivy PROPN ital-1859 205 2 anderson anderson PROPN ital-1859 205 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 205 4 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 205 5 hurtling hurtle VERB ital-1859 205 6 toward toward ADP ital-1859 205 7 the the DET ital-1859 205 8 finish finish NOUN ital-1859 205 9 line line NOUN ital-1859 205 10 : : PUNCT ital-1859 205 11 should should AUX ital-1859 205 12 the the DET ital-1859 205 13 google google PROPN ital-1859 205 14 book book PROPN ital-1859 205 15 settlement settlement NOUN ital-1859 205 16 be be AUX ital-1859 205 17 approved approve VERB ital-1859 205 18 ? ? PUNCT ital-1859 205 19 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 205 20 against against ADP ital-1859 205 21 the the DET ital-1859 205 22 grain grain NOUN ital-1859 205 23 22 22 NUM ital-1859 205 24 , , PUNCT ital-1859 205 25 no no INTJ ital-1859 205 26 . . NOUN ital-1859 205 27 3 3 NUM ital-1859 205 28 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 205 29 june june PROPN ital-1859 205 30 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 205 31 ): ): PUNCT ital-1859 205 32 18 18 NUM ital-1859 205 33 . . SYM ital-1859 205 34 55 55 NUM ital-1859 205 35 . . PUNCT ital-1859 206 1 samuelson samuelson PROPN ital-1859 206 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 206 3 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 206 4 google google PROPN ital-1859 206 5 books book NOUN ital-1859 206 6 is be AUX ital-1859 206 7 not not PART ital-1859 206 8 a a DET ital-1859 206 9 library library NOUN ital-1859 206 10 . . PUNCT ital-1859 206 11 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 207 1 56 56 NUM ital-1859 207 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 207 3 jeweler jeweler NOUN ital-1859 207 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 207 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 207 6 ‘ ' PUNCT ital-1859 207 7 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 207 8 rights right NOUN ital-1859 207 9 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 207 10 and and CCONJ ital-1859 207 11 fair fair ADJ ital-1859 207 12 use use NOUN ital-1859 207 13 in in ADP ital-1859 207 14 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 207 15 law law NOUN ital-1859 207 16 , , PUNCT ital-1859 207 17 3 3 NUM ital-1859 207 18 . . NUM ital-1859 207 19 57 57 NUM ital-1859 207 20 . . PUNCT ital-1859 208 1 bailey bailey NOUN ital-1859 208 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 208 3 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 208 4 strong strong ADJ ital-1859 208 5 copyright copyright NOUN ital-1859 208 6 , , PUNCT ital-1859 208 7 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 208 8 116 116 NUM ital-1859 208 9 . . PUNCT ital-1859 209 1 58 58 NUM ital-1859 209 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 210 1 cushla cushla PROPN ital-1859 210 2 kapitzke kapitzke PROPN ital-1859 210 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 210 4 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 210 5 rethinking rethink VERB ital-1859 210 6 copyrights copyright NOUN ital-1859 210 7 for for ADP ital-1859 210 8 the the DET ital-1859 210 9 library library NOUN ital-1859 210 10 through through ADP ital-1859 210 11 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 210 12 commons common NOUN ital-1859 210 13 licensing licensing NOUN ital-1859 210 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 210 15 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 210 16 library library NOUN ital-1859 210 17 trends trend VERB ital-1859 210 18 58 58 NUM ital-1859 210 19 , , PUNCT ital-1859 210 20 no no NOUN ital-1859 210 21 . . NOUN ital-1859 210 22 1 1 NUM ital-1859 210 23 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 210 24 summer summer NOUN ital-1859 210 25 2009 2009 NUM ital-1859 210 26 ): ): SYM ital-1859 210 27 106 106 NUM ital-1859 210 28 . . NUM ital-1859 210 29 59 59 NUM ital-1859 210 30 . . PUNCT ital-1859 211 1 ibid ibid VERB ital-1859 211 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 212 1 60 60 X ital-1859 212 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 212 3 university university PROPN ital-1859 212 4 of of ADP ital-1859 212 5 maryland maryland PROPN ital-1859 212 6 university university PROPN ital-1859 212 7 college college NOUN ital-1859 212 8 , , PUNCT ital-1859 212 9 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 212 10 member member NOUN ital-1859 212 11 community community NOUN ital-1859 212 12 , , PUNCT ital-1859 212 13 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 212 14 center center NOUN ital-1859 212 15 for for ADP ital-1859 212 16 intellectual intellectual ADJ ital-1859 212 17 property property NOUN ital-1859 212 18 , , PUNCT ital-1859 212 19 http://cipcommunity.org/s/1039/start.aspx http://cipcommunity.org/s/1039/start.aspx NOUN ital-1859 212 20 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 212 21 accessed access VERB ital-1859 212 22 february february PROPN ital-1859 212 23 21 21 NUM ital-1859 212 24 , , PUNCT ital-1859 212 25 2011 2011 NUM ital-1859 212 26 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 212 27 . . PUNCT ital-1859 213 1 61 61 NUM ital-1859 213 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 214 1 robin robin PROPN ital-1859 214 2 jeweler jeweler PROPN ital-1859 214 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 214 4 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 214 5 law law NOUN ital-1859 214 6 : : PUNCT ital-1859 214 7 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 214 8 rights right NOUN ital-1859 214 9 management management NOUN ital-1859 214 10 legislation legislation NOUN ital-1859 214 11 , , PUNCT ital-1859 214 12 prepared prepare VERB ital-1859 214 13 by by ADP ital-1859 214 14 the the DET ital-1859 214 15 congressional congressional ADJ ital-1859 214 16 research research NOUN ital-1859 214 17 service service NOUN ital-1859 214 18 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 214 19 washington washington PROPN ital-1859 214 20 , , PUNCT ital-1859 214 21 dc dc PROPN ital-1859 214 22 : : PUNCT ital-1859 214 23 library library PROPN ital-1859 214 24 of of ADP ital-1859 214 25 congress congress PROPN ital-1859 214 26 , , PUNCT ital-1859 214 27 2004 2004 NUM ital-1859 214 28 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 214 29 , , PUNCT ital-1859 214 30 summary summary NOUN ital-1859 214 31 . . PUNCT ital-1859 215 1 62 62 NUM ital-1859 215 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 216 1 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 216 2 commons common NOUN ital-1859 216 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 216 4 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 216 5 history history NOUN ital-1859 216 6 , , PUNCT ital-1859 216 7 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 216 8 http://creativecommons.org/about/history/ http://creativecommons.org/about/history/ PROPN ital-1859 216 9 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 216 10 accessed access VERB ital-1859 216 11 december december PROPN ital-1859 216 12 8 8 NUM ital-1859 216 13 , , PUNCT ital-1859 216 14 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 216 15 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 216 16 . . PUNCT ital-1859 217 1 63 63 NUM ital-1859 217 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 217 3 lawrence lawrence PROPN ital-1859 217 4 lessig lessig PROPN ital-1859 217 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 217 6 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 217 7 the the DET ital-1859 217 8 vision vision NOUN ital-1859 217 9 for for ADP ital-1859 217 10 the the DET ital-1859 217 11 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 217 12 commons common NOUN ital-1859 217 13 ? ? PUNCT ital-1859 218 1 what what PRON ital-1859 218 2 are be AUX ital-1859 218 3 we we PRON ital-1859 218 4 and and CCONJ ital-1859 218 5 where where SCONJ ital-1859 218 6 are be AUX ital-1859 218 7 we we PRON ital-1859 218 8 headed head VERB ital-1859 218 9 ? ? PUNCT ital-1859 219 1 free free ADJ ital-1859 219 2 culture culture NOUN ital-1859 219 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 219 4 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 219 5 in in ADP ital-1859 219 6 open open ADJ ital-1859 219 7 content content NOUN ital-1859 219 8 licensing licensing NOUN ital-1859 219 9 : : PUNCT ital-1859 219 10 cultivating cultivate VERB ital-1859 219 11 the the DET ital-1859 219 12 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 219 13 commons common NOUN ital-1859 219 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 219 15 ed ed PROPN ital-1859 219 16 . . PROPN ital-1859 219 17 brian brian PROPN ital-1859 219 18 fitzgerald fitzgerald PROPN ital-1859 219 19 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 219 20 sydney sydney PROPN ital-1859 219 21 : : PUNCT ital-1859 219 22 sydney sydney PROPN ital-1859 219 23 university university PROPN ital-1859 219 24 press press PROPN ital-1859 219 25 , , PUNCT ital-1859 219 26 2007 2007 NUM ital-1859 219 27 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 219 28 , , PUNCT ital-1859 219 29 42 42 NUM ital-1859 219 30 . . PUNCT ital-1859 220 1 64 64 NUM ital-1859 220 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 221 1 steven steven PROPN ital-1859 221 2 j. j. PROPN ital-1859 221 3 melamut melamut PROPN ital-1859 221 4 , , PUNCT ital-1859 221 5 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 221 6 free free ADJ ital-1859 221 7 creativity creativity NOUN ital-1859 221 8 : : PUNCT ital-1859 221 9 understanding understand VERB ital-1859 221 10 the the DET ital-1859 221 11 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 221 12 commons common NOUN ital-1859 221 13 licenses license NOUN ital-1859 221 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 221 15 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 221 16 american american PROPN ital-1859 221 17 association association PROPN ital-1859 221 18 of of ADP ital-1859 221 19 law law NOUN ital-1859 221 20 libraries library NOUN ital-1859 221 21 14 14 NUM ital-1859 221 22 , , PUNCT ital-1859 221 23 no no INTJ ital-1859 221 24 . . NOUN ital-1859 221 25 6 6 NUM ital-1859 221 26 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 221 27 april april PROPN ital-1859 221 28 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 221 29 ): ): PUNCT ital-1859 221 30 22 22 NUM ital-1859 221 31 . . PUNCT ital-1859 222 1 http://online.wsj.com/article/sb10001424052748704461304576216923562033348.html http://online.wsj.com/article/sb10001424052748704461304576216923562033348.html PROPN ital-1859 222 2 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.huffingtonpost.com%2fpamela-samuelson%2fgoogle-books-is-not-a-lib_b_317518.html https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fwww.huffingtonpost.com%2fpamela-samuelson%2fgoogle-books-is-not-a-lib_b_317518.html PROPN ital-1859 222 3 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fcipcommunity.org%2fs%2f1039%2fstart.aspx https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fcipcommunity.org%2fs%2f1039%2fstart.aspx PROPN ital-1859 222 4 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fcreativecommons.org%2fabout%2fhistory%2f https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fcreativecommons.org%2fabout%2fhistory%2f PROPN ital-1859 222 5 copyright copyright PROPN ital-1859 222 6 : : PUNCT ital-1859 222 7 regulation regulation NOUN ital-1859 222 8 out out ADP ital-1859 222 9 of of ADP ital-1859 222 10 line line NOUN ital-1859 222 11 with with ADP ital-1859 222 12 our our PRON ital-1859 222 13 digital digital ADJ ital-1859 222 14 reality reality NOUN ital-1859 222 15 | | PROPN ital-1859 222 16 mcdermott mcdermott PROPN ital-1859 222 17 20 20 NUM ital-1859 222 18 65 65 NUM ital-1859 222 19 . . PUNCT ital-1859 223 1 lessig lessig PROPN ital-1859 223 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 223 3 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 223 4 the the DET ital-1859 223 5 vision vision NOUN ital-1859 223 6 for for ADP ital-1859 223 7 the the DET ital-1859 223 8 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 223 9 commons common NOUN ital-1859 223 10 ? ? PUNCT ital-1859 223 11 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 224 1 45 45 NUM ital-1859 224 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 225 1 66 66 NUM ital-1859 225 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 226 1 creative creative ADJ ital-1859 226 2 commons common NOUN ital-1859 226 3 , , PUNCT ital-1859 226 4 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 226 5 about about ADP ital-1859 226 6 , , PUNCT ital-1859 226 7 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 226 8 http://creativecommons.org/about/ http://creativecommons.org/about/ X ital-1859 226 9 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 226 10 accessed access VERB ital-1859 226 11 december december PROPN ital-1859 226 12 8 8 NUM ital-1859 226 13 , , PUNCT ital-1859 226 14 2010 2010 NUM ital-1859 226 15 ) ) PUNCT ital-1859 226 16 . . PUNCT ital-1859 227 1 67 67 NUM ital-1859 227 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 227 3 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 227 4 . . PUNCT ital-1859 228 1 68 68 NUM ital-1859 228 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 229 1 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 229 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 230 1 69 69 NUM ital-1859 230 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 231 1 bridgewater bridgewater NOUN ital-1859 231 2 , , PUNCT ital-1859 231 3 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 231 4 tipping tip VERB ital-1859 231 5 the the DET ital-1859 231 6 scales scale NOUN ital-1859 231 7 , , PUNCT ital-1859 231 8 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 231 9 21 21 NUM ital-1859 231 10 . . SYM ital-1859 232 1 70 70 NUM ital-1859 232 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 232 3 ibid ibid NOUN ital-1859 232 4 . . PUNCT ital-1859 233 1 71 71 NUM ital-1859 233 2 . . PUNCT ital-1859 233 3 woody woody PROPN ital-1859 233 4 evans evans PROPN ital-1859 233 5 , , PUNCT ital-1859 233 6 “ " PUNCT ital-1859 233 7 commons common NOUN ital-1859 233 8 and and CCONJ ital-1859 233 9 creativity creativity NOUN ital-1859 233 10 , , PUNCT ital-1859 233 11 ” " PUNCT ital-1859 233 12 searcher searcher NOUN ital-1859 233 13 17 17 NUM ital-1859 233 14 , , PUNCT ital-1859 233 15 no no NOUN ital-1859 233 16 . . NOUN ital-1859 233 17 9 9 NUM ital-1859 233 18 ( ( PUNCT ital-1859 233 19 october october PROPN ital-1859 233 20 2009 2009 NUM ital-1859 233 21 ): ): PUNCT ital-1859 233 22 34 34 NUM ital-1859 233 23 . . PUNCT ital-1859 234 1 https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fcreativecommons.org%2fabout%2f https://exch.mail.umd.edu/owa/redir.aspx?c=01cfbeb60fb24d1594b179edf974dcfd&url=http%3a%2f%2fcreativecommons.org%2fabout%2f PROPN