id sid tid token lemma pos ital-9151 1 1 editorial editorial PROPN ital-9151 1 2 board board NOUN ital-9151 1 3 thoughts thought NOUN ital-9151 1 4 : : PUNCT ital-9151 1 5 library library NOUN ital-9151 1 6 analytics analytic NOUN ital-9151 1 7 and and CCONJ ital-9151 1 8 patron patron NOUN ital-9151 1 9 privacy privacy PROPN ital-9151 1 10 ken ken PROPN ital-9151 1 11 varnum varnum PROPN ital-9151 1 12 information information PROPN ital-9151 1 13 technology technology PROPN ital-9151 1 14 and and CCONJ ital-9151 1 15 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 1 16 | | NOUN ital-9151 1 17 december december PROPN ital-9151 1 18 2015 2015 NUM ital-9151 1 19 2 2 NUM ital-9151 1 20 two two NUM ital-9151 1 21 significant significant ADJ ital-9151 1 22 trends trend NOUN ital-9151 1 23 are be AUX ital-9151 1 24 sweeping sweep VERB ital-9151 1 25 across across ADP ital-9151 1 26 the the DET ital-9151 1 27 library library NOUN ital-9151 1 28 landscape landscape NOUN ital-9151 1 29 : : PUNCT ital-9151 1 30 assessment assessment NOUN ital-9151 1 31 ( ( PUNCT ital-9151 1 32 and and CCONJ ital-9151 1 33 the the DET ital-9151 1 34 corresponding correspond VERB ital-9151 1 35 collection collection NOUN ital-9151 1 36 and and CCONJ ital-9151 1 37 analysis analysis NOUN ital-9151 1 38 of of ADP ital-9151 1 39 data datum NOUN ital-9151 1 40 ) ) PUNCT ital-9151 1 41 and and CCONJ ital-9151 1 42 privacy privacy NOUN ital-9151 1 43 ( ( PUNCT ital-9151 1 44 of of ADP ital-9151 1 45 records record NOUN ital-9151 1 46 of of ADP ital-9151 1 47 user user NOUN ital-9151 1 48 interactions interaction NOUN ital-9151 1 49 with with ADP ital-9151 1 50 our our PRON ital-9151 1 51 services service NOUN ital-9151 1 52 ) ) PUNCT ital-9151 1 53 . . PUNCT ital-9151 2 1 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 2 2 , , PUNCT ital-9151 2 3 perhaps perhaps ADV ital-9151 2 4 more more ADJ ital-9151 2 5 than than ADP ital-9151 2 6 any any DET ital-9151 2 7 other other ADJ ital-9151 2 8 public public ADJ ital-9151 2 9 service service NOUN ital-9151 2 10 organization organization NOUN ital-9151 2 11 , , PUNCT ital-9151 2 12 are be AUX ital-9151 2 13 strongly strongly ADV ital-9151 2 14 motivated motivated ADJ ital-9151 2 15 to to PART ital-9151 2 16 assess assess VERB ital-9151 2 17 their their PRON ital-9151 2 18 offerings offering NOUN ital-9151 2 19 with with ADP ital-9151 2 20 dual dual ADJ ital-9151 2 21 aims aim NOUN ital-9151 2 22 . . PUNCT ital-9151 3 1 the the DET ital-9151 3 2 first first ADJ ital-9151 3 3 might might AUX ital-9151 3 4 be be AUX ital-9151 3 5 thought think VERB ital-9151 3 6 of of ADP ital-9151 3 7 as as ADP ital-9151 3 8 an an DET ital-9151 3 9 altruistic altruistic ADJ ital-9151 3 10 goal goal NOUN ital-9151 3 11 : : PUNCT ital-9151 3 12 understanding understand VERB ital-9151 3 13 the the DET ital-9151 3 14 needs need NOUN ital-9151 3 15 of of ADP ital-9151 3 16 their their PRON ital-9151 3 17 particular particular ADJ ital-9151 3 18 clientele clientele NOUN ital-9151 3 19 and and CCONJ ital-9151 3 20 improving improve VERB ital-9151 3 21 library library NOUN ital-9151 3 22 services service NOUN ital-9151 3 23 to to PART ital-9151 3 24 meet meet VERB ital-9151 3 25 those those DET ital-9151 3 26 needs need NOUN ital-9151 3 27 . . PUNCT ital-9151 4 1 the the DET ital-9151 4 2 second second ADJ ital-9151 4 3 is be AUX ital-9151 4 4 perhaps perhaps ADV ital-9151 4 5 more more ADJ ital-9151 4 6 existential existential NOUN ital-9151 4 7 : : PUNCT ital-9151 4 8 helping helping AUX ital-9151 4 9 justify justify VERB ital-9151 4 10 the the DET ital-9151 4 11 value value NOUN ital-9151 4 12 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 4 13 create create VERB ital-9151 4 14 to to ADP ital-9151 4 15 whatever whatever DET ital-9151 4 16 sources source NOUN ital-9151 4 17 of of ADP ital-9151 4 18 funding funding NOUN ital-9151 4 19 are be AUX ital-9151 4 20 necessary necessary ADJ ital-9151 4 21 to to PART ital-9151 4 22 impress impress VERB ital-9151 4 23 . . PUNCT ital-9151 5 1 both both PRON ital-9151 5 2 are be AUX ital-9151 5 3 valid valid ADJ ital-9151 5 4 and and CCONJ ital-9151 5 5 important important ADJ ital-9151 5 6 . . PUNCT ital-9151 6 1 it it PRON ital-9151 6 2 is be AUX ital-9151 6 3 hard hard ADJ ital-9151 6 4 to to PART ital-9151 6 5 argue argue VERB ital-9151 6 6 that that SCONJ ital-9151 6 7 improving improve VERB ital-9151 6 8 services service NOUN ital-9151 6 9 , , PUNCT ital-9151 6 10 focusing focus VERB ital-9151 6 11 on on ADP ital-9151 6 12 actual actual ADJ ital-9151 6 13 needs need NOUN ital-9151 6 14 , , PUNCT ital-9151 6 15 and and CCONJ ital-9151 6 16 maintaining maintain VERB ital-9151 6 17 funding funding NOUN ital-9151 6 18 are be AUX ital-9151 6 19 in in ADP ital-9151 6 20 any any DET ital-9151 6 21 way way NOUN ital-9151 6 22 improper improper ADJ ital-9151 6 23 goals goal NOUN ital-9151 6 24 . . PUNCT ital-9151 7 1 however however ADV ital-9151 7 2 , , PUNCT ital-9151 7 3 this this DET ital-9151 7 4 desire desire NOUN ital-9151 7 5 is be AUX ital-9151 7 6 often often ADV ital-9151 7 7 seen see VERB ital-9151 7 8 as as ADP ital-9151 7 9 being be AUX ital-9151 7 10 in in ADP ital-9151 7 11 conflict conflict NOUN ital-9151 7 12 with with ADP ital-9151 7 13 exploring explore VERB ital-9151 7 14 too too ADV ital-9151 7 15 deeply deeply ADV ital-9151 7 16 the the DET ital-9151 7 17 actions action NOUN ital-9151 7 18 or or CCONJ ital-9151 7 19 needs need NOUN ital-9151 7 20 of of ADP ital-9151 7 21 individual individual ADJ ital-9151 7 22 constituents constituent NOUN ital-9151 7 23 , , PUNCT ital-9151 7 24 despite despite SCONJ ital-9151 7 25 librarians librarian NOUN ital-9151 7 26 ’ ’ PART ital-9151 7 27 historical historical ADJ ital-9151 7 28 and and CCONJ ital-9151 7 29 deeply deeply ADV ital-9151 7 30 - - PUNCT ital-9151 7 31 held hold VERB ital-9151 7 32 belief belief NOUN ital-9151 7 33 that that SCONJ ital-9151 7 34 each each DET ital-9151 7 35 constituent constituent NOUN ital-9151 7 36 ’s ’s PART ital-9151 7 37 precise precise ADJ ital-9151 7 38 information information NOUN ital-9151 7 39 needs need NOUN ital-9151 7 40 should should AUX ital-9151 7 41 be be AUX ital-9151 7 42 explored explore VERB ital-9151 7 43 and and CCONJ ital-9151 7 44 provided provide VERB ital-9151 7 45 for for ADP ital-9151 7 46 through through ADP ital-9151 7 47 personalized personalize VERB ital-9151 7 48 , , PUNCT ital-9151 7 49 tailored tailor VERB ital-9151 7 50 services service NOUN ital-9151 7 51 . . PUNCT ital-9151 8 1 solid solid ADJ ital-9151 8 2 assessment assessment NOUN ital-9151 8 3 can can AUX ital-9151 8 4 not not PART ital-9151 8 5 happen happen VERB ital-9151 8 6 without without ADP ital-9151 8 7 solid solid ADJ ital-9151 8 8 data datum NOUN ital-9151 8 9 . . PUNCT ital-9151 9 1 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 9 2 have have AUX ital-9151 9 3 historically historically ADV ital-9151 9 4 relied rely VERB ital-9151 9 5 on on ADP ital-9151 9 6 qualitative qualitative ADJ ital-9151 9 7 surveys survey NOUN ital-9151 9 8 of of ADP ital-9151 9 9 their their PRON ital-9151 9 10 users user NOUN ital-9151 9 11 , , PUNCT ital-9151 9 12 asking ask VERB ital-9151 9 13 users user NOUN ital-9151 9 14 to to PART ital-9151 9 15 evaluate evaluate VERB ital-9151 9 16 the the DET ital-9151 9 17 quality quality NOUN ital-9151 9 18 of of ADP ital-9151 9 19 the the DET ital-9151 9 20 services service NOUN ital-9151 9 21 they they PRON ital-9151 9 22 receive receive VERB ital-9151 9 23 . . PUNCT ital-9151 10 1 being be AUX ital-9151 10 2 able able ADJ ital-9151 10 3 to to PART ital-9151 10 4 know know VERB ital-9151 10 5 more more ADJ ital-9151 10 6 details detail NOUN ital-9151 10 7 and and CCONJ ital-9151 10 8 ask ask VERB ital-9151 10 9 directed direct VERB ital-9151 10 10 questions question NOUN ital-9151 10 11 of of ADP ital-9151 10 12 individuals individual NOUN ital-9151 10 13 who who PRON ital-9151 10 14 used use VERB ital-9151 10 15 services service NOUN ital-9151 10 16 is be AUX ital-9151 10 17 possible possible ADJ ital-9151 10 18 in in ADP ital-9151 10 19 the the DET ital-9151 10 20 traditional traditional ADJ ital-9151 10 21 library library NOUN ital-9151 10 22 setting set VERB ital-9151 10 23 through through ADP ital-9151 10 24 invitations invitation NOUN ital-9151 10 25 to to PART ital-9151 10 26 complete complete VERB ital-9151 10 27 surveys survey NOUN ital-9151 10 28 after after ADP ital-9151 10 29 individual individual ADJ ital-9151 10 30 interactions interaction NOUN ital-9151 10 31 such such ADJ ital-9151 10 32 as as ADP ital-9151 10 33 a a DET ital-9151 10 34 reference reference NOUN ital-9151 10 35 or or CCONJ ital-9151 10 36 circulation circulation NOUN ital-9151 10 37 desk desk NOUN ital-9151 10 38 interaction interaction NOUN ital-9151 10 39 , , PUNCT ital-9151 10 40 library library NOUN ital-9151 10 41 program program NOUN ital-9151 10 42 , , PUNCT ital-9151 10 43 visit visit VERB ital-9151 10 44 to to ADP ital-9151 10 45 a a DET ital-9151 10 46 physical physical ADJ ital-9151 10 47 location location NOUN ital-9151 10 48 , , PUNCT ital-9151 10 49 or or CCONJ ital-9151 10 50 even even ADV ital-9151 10 51 a a DET ital-9151 10 52 community community NOUN ital-9151 10 53 - - PUNCT ital-9151 10 54 wide wide ADJ ital-9151 10 55 survey survey NOUN ital-9151 10 56 invitation invitation NOUN ital-9151 10 57 . . PUNCT ital-9151 11 1 focus focus NOUN ital-9151 11 2 groups group NOUN ital-9151 11 3 can can AUX ital-9151 11 4 be be AUX ital-9151 11 5 assembled assemble VERB ital-9151 11 6 as as ADV ital-9151 11 7 well well ADV ital-9151 11 8 , , PUNCT ital-9151 11 9 of of ADP ital-9151 11 10 course course NOUN ital-9151 11 11 , , PUNCT ital-9151 11 12 once once ADV ital-9151 11 13 a a DET ital-9151 11 14 library library NOUN ital-9151 11 15 has have AUX ital-9151 11 16 identified identify VERB ital-9151 11 17 a a DET ital-9151 11 18 real real ADJ ital-9151 11 19 - - PUNCT ital-9151 11 20 world world NOUN ital-9151 11 21 group group NOUN ital-9151 11 22 to to PART ital-9151 11 23 study study VERB ital-9151 11 24 . . PUNCT ital-9151 12 1 however however ADV ital-9151 12 2 , , PUNCT ital-9151 12 3 those those DET ital-9151 12 4 samples sample NOUN ital-9151 12 5 are be AUX ital-9151 12 6 more more ADV ital-9151 12 7 often often ADV ital-9151 12 8 convenience convenience NOUN ital-9151 12 9 samples sample NOUN ital-9151 12 10 or or CCONJ ital-9151 12 11 — — PUNCT ital-9151 12 12 unless unless SCONJ ital-9151 12 13 a a DET ital-9151 12 14 library library NOUN ital-9151 12 15 is be AUX ital-9151 12 16 able able ADJ ital-9151 12 17 to to PART ital-9151 12 18 successfully successfully ADV ital-9151 12 19 contact contact VERB ital-9151 12 20 and and CCONJ ital-9151 12 21 receive receive VERB ital-9151 12 22 responses response NOUN ital-9151 12 23 from from ADP ital-9151 12 24 across across ADP ital-9151 12 25 the the DET ital-9151 12 26 entire entire ADJ ital-9151 12 27 community community NOUN ital-9151 12 28 — — PUNCT ital-9151 12 29 somewhat somewhat ADV ital-9151 12 30 self self NOUN ital-9151 12 31 - - PUNCT ital-9151 12 32 selected select VERB ital-9151 12 33 . . PUNCT ital-9151 13 1 assessment assessment NOUN ital-9151 13 2 that that PRON ital-9151 13 3 leads lead VERB ital-9151 13 4 to to ADP ital-9151 13 5 new new ADJ ital-9151 13 6 or or CCONJ ital-9151 13 7 improved improved ADJ ital-9151 13 8 services service NOUN ital-9151 13 9 relies rely VERB ital-9151 13 10 much much ADV ital-9151 13 11 more more ADV ital-9151 13 12 heavily heavily ADV ital-9151 13 13 on on ADP ital-9151 13 14 broad broad ADV ital-9151 13 15 - - PUNCT ital-9151 13 16 based base VERB ital-9151 13 17 understanding understanding NOUN ital-9151 13 18 of of ADP ital-9151 13 19 the the DET ital-9151 13 20 users user NOUN ital-9151 13 21 of of ADP ital-9151 13 22 a a DET ital-9151 13 23 system system NOUN ital-9151 13 24 . . PUNCT ital-9151 14 1 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 14 2 have have AUX ital-9151 14 3 been be AUX ital-9151 14 4 able able ADJ ital-9151 14 5 to to PART ital-9151 14 6 do do VERB ital-9151 14 7 limited limited ADJ ital-9151 14 8 quantitative quantitative ADJ ital-9151 14 9 studies study NOUN ital-9151 14 10 of of ADP ital-9151 14 11 library library NOUN ital-9151 14 12 usage usage NOUN ital-9151 14 13 — — PUNCT ital-9151 14 14 at at ADP ital-9151 14 15 its its PRON ital-9151 14 16 simplest simple ADJ ital-9151 14 17 , , PUNCT ital-9151 14 18 counting count VERB ital-9151 14 19 how how SCONJ ital-9151 14 20 many many ADJ ital-9151 14 21 of of ADP ital-9151 14 22 this this PRON ital-9151 14 23 were be AUX ital-9151 14 24 checked check VERB ital-9151 14 25 out out ADP ital-9151 14 26 , , PUNCT ital-9151 14 27 how how SCONJ ital-9151 14 28 many many ADJ ital-9151 14 29 of of ADP ital-9151 14 30 that that PRON ital-9151 14 31 was be AUX ital-9151 14 32 accessed access VERB ital-9151 14 33 , , PUNCT ital-9151 14 34 and and CCONJ ital-9151 14 35 how how SCONJ ital-9151 14 36 many many ADJ ital-9151 14 37 users user NOUN ital-9151 14 38 were be AUX ital-9151 14 39 involved involve VERB ital-9151 14 40 . . PUNCT ital-9151 15 1 these these DET ital-9151 15 2 metrics metric NOUN ital-9151 15 3 are be AUX ital-9151 15 4 useful useful ADJ ital-9151 15 5 , , PUNCT ital-9151 15 6 but but CCONJ ital-9151 15 7 also also ADV ital-9151 15 8 limited limited ADJ ital-9151 15 9 , , PUNCT ital-9151 15 10 particularly particularly ADV ital-9151 15 11 at at ADP ital-9151 15 12 the the DET ital-9151 15 13 scale scale NOUN ital-9151 15 14 of of ADP ital-9151 15 15 a a DET ital-9151 15 16 single single ADJ ital-9151 15 17 library library NOUN ital-9151 15 18 . . PUNCT ital-9151 16 1 knowing know VERB ital-9151 16 2 that that SCONJ ital-9151 16 3 a a DET ital-9151 16 4 pool pool NOUN ital-9151 16 5 of of ADP ital-9151 16 6 resources resource NOUN ital-9151 16 7 is be AUX ital-9151 16 8 heavily heavily ADV ital-9151 16 9 used use VERB ital-9151 16 10 is be AUX ital-9151 16 11 helpful helpful ADJ ital-9151 16 12 ; ; PUNCT ital-9151 16 13 even even ADV ital-9151 16 14 knowing know VERB ital-9151 16 15 that that SCONJ ital-9151 16 16 a a DET ital-9151 16 17 suite suite NOUN ital-9151 16 18 of of ADP ital-9151 16 19 resources resource NOUN ital-9151 16 20 is be AUX ital-9151 16 21 frequently frequently ADV ital-9151 16 22 used use VERB ital-9151 16 23 collectively collectively ADV ital-9151 16 24 is be AUX ital-9151 16 25 beneficial beneficial ADJ ital-9151 16 26 . . PUNCT ital-9151 17 1 however however ADV ital-9151 17 2 , , PUNCT ital-9151 17 3 tying tie VERB ital-9151 17 4 use use NOUN ital-9151 17 5 of of ADP ital-9151 17 6 resources resource NOUN ital-9151 17 7 to to ADP ital-9151 17 8 specific specific ADJ ital-9151 17 9 information information NOUN ital-9151 17 10 needs need NOUN ital-9151 17 11 or or CCONJ ital-9151 17 12 information information NOUN ital-9151 17 13 seekers seeker NOUN ital-9151 17 14 , , PUNCT ital-9151 17 15 whether whether SCONJ ital-9151 17 16 this this PRON ital-9151 17 17 is be AUX ital-9151 17 18 defined define VERB ital-9151 17 19 as as ADP ital-9151 17 20 ken ken PROPN ital-9151 17 21 varnum varnum PROPN ital-9151 17 22 ( ( PUNCT ital-9151 17 23 varnum@umich.edu varnum@umich.edu SPACE ital-9151 17 24 ) ) PUNCT ital-9151 17 25 , , PUNCT ital-9151 17 26 a a DET ital-9151 17 27 member member NOUN ital-9151 17 28 of of ADP ital-9151 17 29 the the DET ital-9151 17 30 ital ital PROPN ital-9151 17 31 editorial editorial PROPN ital-9151 17 32 board board PROPN ital-9151 17 33 , , PUNCT ital-9151 17 34 is be AUX ital-9151 17 35 senior senior ADJ ital-9151 17 36 program program NOUN ital-9151 17 37 manager manager NOUN ital-9151 17 38 for for ADP ital-9151 17 39 discovery discovery NOUN ital-9151 17 40 , , PUNCT ital-9151 17 41 delivery delivery NOUN ital-9151 17 42 , , PUNCT ital-9151 17 43 and and CCONJ ital-9151 17 44 learning learn VERB ital-9151 17 45 analytics analytic NOUN ital-9151 17 46 at at ADP ital-9151 17 47 the the DET ital-9151 17 48 university university PROPN ital-9151 17 49 of of ADP ital-9151 17 50 michigan michigan PROPN ital-9151 17 51 library library PROPN ital-9151 17 52 , , PUNCT ital-9151 17 53 ann ann PROPN ital-9151 17 54 arbor arbor PROPN ital-9151 17 55 , , PUNCT ital-9151 17 56 michigan michigan PROPN ital-9151 17 57 . . PUNCT ital-9151 18 1 mailto:varnum@umich.edu mailto:varnum@umich.edu PROPN ital-9151 18 2 editorial editorial PROPN ital-9151 18 3 board board NOUN ital-9151 18 4 thoughts thought NOUN ital-9151 18 5 : : PUNCT ital-9151 18 6 library library NOUN ital-9151 18 7 analytics analytic NOUN ital-9151 18 8 and and CCONJ ital-9151 18 9 patron patron NOUN ital-9151 18 10 privacy privacy NOUN ital-9151 18 11 | | PROPN ital-9151 18 12 varnum varnum PROPN ital-9151 18 13 doi doi PROPN ital-9151 18 14 : : PUNCT ital-9151 18 15 10.6017 10.6017 NUM ital-9151 18 16 / / SYM ital-9151 18 17 ital.v34i4.9151 ital.v34i4.9151 X ital-9151 18 18 3 3 NUM ital-9151 18 19 individuals individual NOUN ital-9151 18 20 or or CCONJ ital-9151 18 21 ad ad NOUN ital-9151 18 22 hoc hoc X ital-9151 18 23 collections collection NOUN ital-9151 18 24 of of ADP ital-9151 18 25 users user NOUN ital-9151 18 26 based base VERB ital-9151 18 27 on on ADP ital-9151 18 28 situational situational ADJ ital-9151 18 29 factors factor NOUN ital-9151 18 30 such such ADJ ital-9151 18 31 as as ADP ital-9151 18 32 academic academic ADJ ital-9151 18 33 level level NOUN ital-9151 18 34 , , PUNCT ital-9151 18 35 course course NOUN ital-9151 18 36 enrollments enrollment NOUN ital-9151 18 37 , , PUNCT ital-9151 18 38 etc etc X ital-9151 18 39 . . X ital-9151 19 1 these these DET ital-9151 19 2 more more ADV ital-9151 19 3 specific specific ADJ ital-9151 19 4 grouping grouping NOUN ital-9151 19 5 rely rely VERB ital-9151 19 6 on on ADP ital-9151 19 7 granular granular ADJ ital-9151 19 8 data datum NOUN ital-9151 19 9 that that PRON ital-9151 19 10 for for ADP ital-9151 19 11 many many ADJ ital-9151 19 12 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 19 13 — — PUNCT ital-9151 19 14 especially especially ADV ital-9151 19 15 academic academic ADJ ital-9151 19 16 ones one NOUN ital-9151 19 17 — — PUNCT ital-9151 19 18 are be AUX ital-9151 19 19 increasingly increasingly ADV ital-9151 19 20 electronic electronic ADJ ital-9151 19 21 . . PUNCT ital-9151 20 1 we we PRON ital-9151 20 2 are be AUX ital-9151 20 3 at at ADP ital-9151 20 4 a a DET ital-9151 20 5 point point NOUN ital-9151 20 6 in in ADP ital-9151 20 7 time time NOUN ital-9151 20 8 when when SCONJ ital-9151 20 9 we we PRON ital-9151 20 10 have have VERB ital-9151 20 11 the the DET ital-9151 20 12 potential potential NOUN ital-9151 20 13 to to PART ital-9151 20 14 leverage leverage VERB ital-9151 20 15 wide wide ADJ ital-9151 20 16 swathes swathe NOUN ital-9151 20 17 of of ADP ital-9151 20 18 user user NOUN ital-9151 20 19 data datum NOUN ital-9151 20 20 . . PUNCT ital-9151 21 1 and and CCONJ ital-9151 21 2 this this PRON ital-9151 21 3 is be AUX ital-9151 21 4 where where SCONJ ital-9151 21 5 the the DET ital-9151 21 6 second second ADJ ital-9151 21 7 trend trend NOUN ital-9151 21 8 , , PUNCT ital-9151 21 9 privacy privacy NOUN ital-9151 21 10 , , PUNCT ital-9151 21 11 comes come VERB ital-9151 21 12 to to PART ital-9151 21 13 bear bear VERB ital-9151 21 14 . . PUNCT ital-9151 22 1 protecting protect VERB ital-9151 22 2 user user NOUN ital-9151 22 3 privacy privacy NOUN ital-9151 22 4 has have AUX ital-9151 22 5 been be AUX ital-9151 22 6 a a DET ital-9151 22 7 guiding guide VERB ital-9151 22 8 principle principle NOUN ital-9151 22 9 of of ADP ital-9151 22 10 librarianship librarianship NOUN ital-9151 22 11 in in ADP ital-9151 22 12 the the DET ital-9151 22 13 united united PROPN ital-9151 22 14 states states PROPN ital-9151 22 15 ( ( PUNCT ital-9151 22 16 in in ADP ital-9151 22 17 particular particular ADJ ital-9151 22 18 ) ) PUNCT ital-9151 22 19 since since SCONJ ital-9151 22 20 the the DET ital-9151 22 21 1970s 1970 NOUN ital-9151 22 22 , , PUNCT ital-9151 22 23 as as ADP ital-9151 22 24 a a DET ital-9151 22 25 strong strong ADJ ital-9151 22 26 reaction reaction NOUN ital-9151 22 27 to to ADP ital-9151 22 28 u.s u.s PROPN ital-9151 22 29 . . PROPN ital-9151 22 30 government government NOUN ital-9151 22 31 ( ( PUNCT ital-9151 22 32 through through ADP ital-9151 22 33 the the DET ital-9151 22 34 fbi fbi PROPN ital-9151 22 35 ) ) PUNCT ital-9151 22 36 requests request NOUN ital-9151 22 37 to to PART ital-9151 22 38 provide provide VERB ital-9151 22 39 access access NOUN ital-9151 22 40 to to ADP ital-9151 22 41 circulation circulation NOUN ital-9151 22 42 logs log NOUN ital-9151 22 43 for for ADP ital-9151 22 44 individuals individual NOUN ital-9151 22 45 under under ADP ital-9151 22 46 suspicion suspicion NOUN ital-9151 22 47 of of ADP ital-9151 22 48 espionage espionage NOUN ital-9151 22 49 . . PUNCT ital-9151 23 1 this this PRON ital-9151 23 2 was be AUX ital-9151 23 3 in in ADP ital-9151 23 4 the the DET ital-9151 23 5 early early ADJ ital-9151 23 6 days day NOUN ital-9151 23 7 of of ADP ital-9151 23 8 library library NOUN ital-9151 23 9 automation automation NOUN ital-9151 23 10 , , PUNCT ital-9151 23 11 when when SCONJ ital-9151 23 12 large large ADJ ital-9151 23 13 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 23 14 with with ADP ital-9151 23 15 automated automate VERB ital-9151 23 16 ils il NOUN ital-9151 23 17 systems system NOUN ital-9151 23 18 could could AUX ital-9151 23 19 prevent prevent VERB ital-9151 23 20 future future ADJ ital-9151 23 21 disclosure disclosure NOUN ital-9151 23 22 through through ADP ital-9151 23 23 the the DET ital-9151 23 24 straightforward straightforward ADJ ital-9151 23 25 strategy strategy NOUN ital-9151 23 26 of of ADP ital-9151 23 27 purging purge VERB ital-9151 23 28 transaction transaction NOUN ital-9151 23 29 records record NOUN ital-9151 23 30 as as ADV ital-9151 23 31 soon soon ADV ital-9151 23 32 as as SCONJ ital-9151 23 33 the the DET ital-9151 23 34 item item NOUN ital-9151 23 35 was be AUX ital-9151 23 36 returned return VERB ital-9151 23 37 . . PUNCT ital-9151 24 1 this this DET ital-9151 24 2 practice practice NOUN ital-9151 24 3 became become VERB ital-9151 24 4 standard standard ADJ ital-9151 24 5 operating operating NOUN ital-9151 24 6 procedure procedure NOUN ital-9151 24 7 in in ADP ital-9151 24 8 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 24 9 , , PUNCT ital-9151 24 10 and and CCONJ ital-9151 24 11 expanded expand VERB ital-9151 24 12 into into ADP ital-9151 24 13 new new ADJ ital-9151 24 14 information information NOUN ital-9151 24 15 service service NOUN ital-9151 24 16 domains domain NOUN ital-9151 24 17 as as SCONJ ital-9151 24 18 they they PRON ital-9151 24 19 evolved evolve VERB ital-9151 24 20 over over ADP ital-9151 24 21 the the DET ital-9151 24 22 following following ADJ ital-9151 24 23 forty forty NUM ital-9151 24 24 years year NOUN ital-9151 24 25 . . PUNCT ital-9151 25 1 with with ADP ital-9151 25 2 good good ADJ ital-9151 25 3 intentions intention NOUN ital-9151 25 4 , , PUNCT ital-9151 25 5 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 25 6 have have AUX ital-9151 25 7 ensured ensure VERB ital-9151 25 8 that that SCONJ ital-9151 25 9 they they PRON ital-9151 25 10 maintain maintain VERB ital-9151 25 11 no no DET ital-9151 25 12 long long ADJ ital-9151 25 13 - - PUNCT ital-9151 25 14 term term NOUN ital-9151 25 15 history history NOUN ital-9151 25 16 for for ADP ital-9151 25 17 most most ADJ ital-9151 25 18 online online ADJ ital-9151 25 19 services service NOUN ital-9151 25 20 . . PUNCT ital-9151 26 1 as as ADP ital-9151 26 2 a a DET ital-9151 26 3 profession profession NOUN ital-9151 26 4 , , PUNCT ital-9151 26 5 we we PRON ital-9151 26 6 have have AUX ital-9151 26 7 begun begin VERB ital-9151 26 8 to to PART ital-9151 26 9 realize realize VERB ital-9151 26 10 that that SCONJ ital-9151 26 11 the the DET ital-9151 26 12 straightforward straightforward ADJ ital-9151 26 13 ( ( PUNCT ital-9151 26 14 and and CCONJ ital-9151 26 15 arguably arguably ADV ital-9151 26 16 simplistic simplistic ADJ ital-9151 26 17 ) ) PUNCT ital-9151 26 18 approaches approach NOUN ital-9151 26 19 we we PRON ital-9151 26 20 have have AUX ital-9151 26 21 relied rely VERB ital-9151 26 22 on on ADP ital-9151 26 23 for for ADP ital-9151 26 24 so so ADV ital-9151 26 25 long long ADJ ital-9151 26 26 may may AUX ital-9151 26 27 no no ADV ital-9151 26 28 longer long ADV ital-9151 26 29 be be AUX ital-9151 26 30 appropriate appropriate ADJ ital-9151 26 31 or or CCONJ ital-9151 26 32 helpful helpful ADJ ital-9151 26 33 . . PUNCT ital-9151 27 1 over over ADP ital-9151 27 2 the the DET ital-9151 27 3 past past ADJ ital-9151 27 4 year year NOUN ital-9151 27 5 , , PUNCT ital-9151 27 6 these these DET ital-9151 27 7 conversations conversation NOUN ital-9151 27 8 found find VERB ital-9151 27 9 focus focus VERB ital-9151 27 10 through through ADP ital-9151 27 11 a a DET ital-9151 27 12 project project NOUN ital-9151 27 13 coordinated coordinate VERB ital-9151 27 14 by by ADP ital-9151 27 15 the the DET ital-9151 27 16 national national ADJ ital-9151 27 17 information information NOUN ital-9151 27 18 standards standard NOUN ital-9151 27 19 organization organization NOUN ital-9151 27 20 thanks thank NOUN ital-9151 27 21 to to ADP ital-9151 27 22 a a DET ital-9151 27 23 grant grant NOUN ital-9151 27 24 from from ADP ital-9151 27 25 the the DET ital-9151 27 26 andrew andrew PROPN ital-9151 27 27 w. w. PROPN ital-9151 27 28 mellon mellon PROPN ital-9151 27 29 foundation.1 foundation.1 ADJ ital-9151 27 30 the the DET ital-9151 27 31 range range NOUN ital-9151 27 32 of of ADP ital-9151 27 33 issues issue NOUN ital-9151 27 34 discussed discuss VERB ital-9151 27 35 here here ADV ital-9151 27 36 was be AUX ital-9151 27 37 far far ADV ital-9151 27 38 - - PUNCT ital-9151 27 39 reaching reach VERB ital-9151 27 40 and and CCONJ ital-9151 27 41 touched touch VERB ital-9151 27 42 on on ADP ital-9151 27 43 virtually virtually ADV ital-9151 27 44 every every DET ital-9151 27 45 aspect aspect NOUN ital-9151 27 46 of of ADP ital-9151 27 47 privacy privacy NOUN ital-9151 27 48 and and CCONJ ital-9151 27 49 assessment assessment NOUN ital-9151 27 50 imaginable imaginable ADJ ital-9151 27 51 . . PUNCT ital-9151 28 1 the the DET ital-9151 28 2 resulting result VERB ital-9151 28 3 draft draft NOUN ital-9151 28 4 document document NOUN ital-9151 28 5 , , PUNCT ital-9151 28 6 consensus consensus NOUN ital-9151 28 7 framework framework NOUN ital-9151 28 8 to to PART ital-9151 28 9 support support VERB ital-9151 28 10 patron patron NOUN ital-9151 28 11 privacy privacy NOUN ital-9151 28 12 in in ADP ital-9151 28 13 digital digital ADJ ital-9151 28 14 library library NOUN ital-9151 28 15 and and CCONJ ital-9151 28 16 information information NOUN ital-9151 28 17 systems,2 systems,2 NOUN ital-9151 28 18 outlines outline VERB ital-9151 28 19 12 12 NUM ital-9151 28 20 principles principle NOUN ital-9151 28 21 that that PRON ital-9151 28 22 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 28 23 ( ( PUNCT ital-9151 28 24 and and CCONJ ital-9151 28 25 the the DET ital-9151 28 26 information information NOUN ital-9151 28 27 service service NOUN ital-9151 28 28 vendors vendor NOUN ital-9151 28 29 they they PRON ital-9151 28 30 partner partner VERB ital-9151 28 31 with with ADP ital-9151 28 32 ) ) PUNCT ital-9151 28 33 should should AUX ital-9151 28 34 follow follow VERB ital-9151 28 35 as as SCONJ ital-9151 28 36 they they PRON ital-9151 28 37 establish establish VERB ital-9151 28 38 “ " PUNCT ital-9151 28 39 practices practice NOUN ital-9151 28 40 and and CCONJ ital-9151 28 41 procedures procedure NOUN ital-9151 28 42 to to PART ital-9151 28 43 protect protect VERB ital-9151 28 44 the the DET ital-9151 28 45 digital digital ADJ ital-9151 28 46 privacy privacy NOUN ital-9151 28 47 of of ADP ital-9151 28 48 the the DET ital-9151 28 49 library library NOUN ital-9151 28 50 user user NOUN ital-9151 28 51 . . PUNCT ital-9151 28 52 ” " PUNCT ital-9151 29 1 this this DET ital-9151 29 2 new new ADJ ital-9151 29 3 consensus consensus NOUN ital-9151 29 4 framework framework NOUN ital-9151 29 5 sets set VERB ital-9151 29 6 a a DET ital-9151 29 7 series series NOUN ital-9151 29 8 of of ADP ital-9151 29 9 guidelines guideline NOUN ital-9151 29 10 for for SCONJ ital-9151 29 11 us we PRON ital-9151 29 12 to to PART ital-9151 29 13 consider consider VERB ital-9151 29 14 as as SCONJ ital-9151 29 15 we we PRON ital-9151 29 16 begin begin VERB ital-9151 29 17 to to PART ital-9151 29 18 move move VERB ital-9151 29 19 into into ADP ital-9151 29 20 this this DET ital-9151 29 21 uncharted uncharted ADJ ital-9151 29 22 ( ( PUNCT ital-9151 29 23 for for ADP ital-9151 29 24 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 29 25 ) ) PUNCT ital-9151 29 26 territory territory NOUN ital-9151 29 27 . . PUNCT ital-9151 30 1 if if SCONJ ital-9151 30 2 we we PRON ital-9151 30 3 are be AUX ital-9151 30 4 to to PART ital-9151 30 5 record record VERB ital-9151 30 6 and and CCONJ ital-9151 30 7 make make VERB ital-9151 30 8 use use NOUN ital-9151 30 9 of of ADP ital-9151 30 10 our our PRON ital-9151 30 11 users user NOUN ital-9151 30 12 ’ ’ PART ital-9151 30 13 online online NOUN ital-9151 30 14 ( ( PUNCT ital-9151 30 15 and and CCONJ ital-9151 30 16 offline offline ADJ ital-9151 30 17 , , PUNCT ital-9151 30 18 for for ADP ital-9151 30 19 that that DET ital-9151 30 20 matter matter NOUN ital-9151 30 21 ) ) PUNCT ital-9151 30 22 footprints footprint NOUN ital-9151 30 23 to to PART ital-9151 30 24 improve improve VERB ital-9151 30 25 services service NOUN ital-9151 30 26 , , PUNCT ital-9151 30 27 improve improve VERB ital-9151 30 28 the the DET ital-9151 30 29 user user NOUN ital-9151 30 30 experience experience NOUN ital-9151 30 31 , , PUNCT ital-9151 30 32 and and CCONJ ital-9151 30 33 justify justify VERB ital-9151 30 34 our our PRON ital-9151 30 35 value value NOUN ital-9151 30 36 , , PUNCT ital-9151 30 37 this this DET ital-9151 30 38 document document NOUN ital-9151 30 39 gives give VERB ital-9151 30 40 us we PRON ital-9151 30 41 an an DET ital-9151 30 42 outline outline NOUN ital-9151 30 43 of of ADP ital-9151 30 44 the the DET ital-9151 30 45 issues issue NOUN ital-9151 30 46 to to PART ital-9151 30 47 consider consider VERB ital-9151 30 48 . . PUNCT ital-9151 31 1 it it PRON ital-9151 31 2 is be AUX ital-9151 31 3 time time NOUN ital-9151 31 4 ( ( PUNCT ital-9151 31 5 and and CCONJ ital-9151 31 6 probably probably ADV ital-9151 31 7 long long ADV ital-9151 31 8 past past ADJ ital-9151 31 9 time time NOUN ital-9151 31 10 ) ) PUNCT ital-9151 31 11 that that SCONJ ital-9151 31 12 we we PRON ital-9151 31 13 make make VERB ital-9151 31 14 conscious conscious ADJ ital-9151 31 15 decisions decision NOUN ital-9151 31 16 about about ADP ital-9151 31 17 how how SCONJ ital-9151 31 18 we we PRON ital-9151 31 19 assess assess VERB ital-9151 31 20 our our PRON ital-9151 31 21 online online ADJ ital-9151 31 22 resources resource NOUN ital-9151 31 23 , , PUNCT ital-9151 31 24 in in ADP ital-9151 31 25 particular particular ADJ ital-9151 31 26 , , PUNCT ital-9151 31 27 and and CCONJ ital-9151 31 28 do do VERB ital-9151 31 29 so so ADV ital-9151 31 30 with with ADP ital-9151 31 31 a a DET ital-9151 31 32 deeper deep ADJ ital-9151 31 33 knowledge knowledge NOUN ital-9151 31 34 of of ADP ital-9151 31 35 both both CCONJ ital-9151 31 36 the the DET ital-9151 31 37 resources resource NOUN ital-9151 31 38 used use VERB ital-9151 31 39 and and CCONJ ital-9151 31 40 the the DET ital-9151 31 41 people people NOUN ital-9151 31 42 using use VERB ital-9151 31 43 them they PRON ital-9151 31 44 . . PUNCT ital-9151 32 1 at at ADP ital-9151 32 2 the the DET ital-9151 32 3 exact exact ADJ ital-9151 32 4 moment moment NOUN ital-9151 32 5 in in ADP ital-9151 32 6 our our PRON ital-9151 32 7 technological technological ADJ ital-9151 32 8 history history NOUN ital-9151 32 9 when when SCONJ ital-9151 32 10 we we PRON ital-9151 32 11 find find VERB ital-9151 32 12 ourselves ourselves PRON ital-9151 32 13 able able ADJ ital-9151 32 14 to to PART ital-9151 32 15 provide provide VERB ital-9151 32 16 automated automate VERB ital-9151 32 17 services service NOUN ital-9151 32 18 at at ADP ital-9151 32 19 scale scale NOUN ital-9151 32 20 to to ADP ital-9151 32 21 our our PRON ital-9151 32 22 users user NOUN ital-9151 32 23 through through ADP ital-9151 32 24 the the DET ital-9151 32 25 internet internet NOUN ital-9151 32 26 and and CCONJ ital-9151 32 27 simultaneously simultaneously ADV ital-9151 32 28 record record VERB ital-9151 32 29 and and CCONJ ital-9151 32 30 analyze analyze VERB ital-9151 32 31 the the DET ital-9151 32 32 intricate intricate ADJ ital-9151 32 33 details detail NOUN ital-9151 32 34 of of ADP ital-9151 32 35 those those DET ital-9151 32 36 transactions transaction NOUN ital-9151 32 37 , , PUNCT ital-9151 32 38 we we PRON ital-9151 32 39 need need VERB ital-9151 32 40 to to PART ital-9151 32 41 come come VERB ital-9151 32 42 to to PART ital-9151 32 43 think think VERB ital-9151 32 44 clearly clearly ADV ital-9151 32 45 about about ADP ital-9151 32 46 what what DET ital-9151 32 47 questions question NOUN ital-9151 32 48 we we PRON ital-9151 32 49 have have AUX ital-9151 32 50 , , PUNCT ital-9151 32 51 what what DET ital-9151 32 52 data datum NOUN ital-9151 32 53 we we PRON ital-9151 32 54 need need VERB ital-9151 32 55 to to PART ital-9151 32 56 answer answer VERB ital-9151 32 57 them they PRON ital-9151 32 58 , , PUNCT ital-9151 32 59 and and CCONJ ital-9151 32 60 be be AUX ital-9151 32 61 explicit explicit ADJ ital-9151 32 62 about about ADP ital-9151 32 63 how how SCONJ ital-9151 32 64 those those DET ital-9151 32 65 data datum NOUN ital-9151 32 66 points point NOUN ital-9151 32 67 are be AUX ital-9151 32 68 treated treat VERB ital-9151 32 69 . . PUNCT ital-9151 33 1 it it PRON ital-9151 33 2 is be AUX ital-9151 33 3 important important ADJ ital-9151 33 4 that that SCONJ ital-9151 33 5 we we PRON ital-9151 33 6 start start VERB ital-9151 33 7 this this DET ital-9151 33 8 process process NOUN ital-9151 33 9 now now ADV ital-9151 33 10 and and CCONJ ital-9151 33 11 change change VERB ital-9151 33 12 our our PRON ital-9151 33 13 blunt blunt ADJ ital-9151 33 14 practices practice NOUN ital-9151 33 15 into into ADP ital-9151 33 16 more more ADJ ital-9151 33 17 strategic strategic ADJ ital-9151 33 18 data datum NOUN ital-9151 33 19 collection collection NOUN ital-9151 33 20 and and CCONJ ital-9151 33 21 analysis analysis NOUN ital-9151 33 22 . . PUNCT ital-9151 34 1 where where SCONJ ital-9151 34 2 40 40 NUM ital-9151 34 3 years year NOUN ital-9151 34 4 ago ago ADV ital-9151 34 5 we we PRON ital-9151 34 6 opted opt VERB ital-9151 34 7 to to PART ital-9151 34 8 information information VERB ital-9151 34 9 technology technology NOUN ital-9151 34 10 and and CCONJ ital-9151 34 11 libraries library NOUN ital-9151 35 1 | | NOUN ital-9151 35 2 december december PROPN ital-9151 35 3 2015 2015 NUM ital-9151 35 4 4 4 NUM ital-9151 35 5 bluntly bluntly ADV ital-9151 35 6 enforce enforce VERB ital-9151 35 7 user user NOUN ital-9151 35 8 privacy privacy NOUN ital-9151 35 9 by by ADP ital-9151 35 10 deleting delete VERB ital-9151 35 11 the the DET ital-9151 35 12 data datum NOUN ital-9151 35 13 , , PUNCT ital-9151 35 14 we we PRON ital-9151 35 15 should should AUX ital-9151 35 16 now now ADV ital-9151 35 17 take take VERB ital-9151 35 18 a a DET ital-9151 35 19 more more ADV ital-9151 35 20 nuanced nuanced ADJ ital-9151 35 21 approach approach NOUN ital-9151 35 22 and and CCONJ ital-9151 35 23 store store NOUN ital-9151 35 24 and and CCONJ ital-9151 35 25 analyze analyze VERB ital-9151 35 26 data datum NOUN ital-9151 35 27 in in ADP ital-9151 35 28 the the DET ital-9151 35 29 service service NOUN ital-9151 35 30 of of ADP ital-9151 35 31 improved improve VERB ital-9151 35 32 services service NOUN ital-9151 35 33 and and CCONJ ital-9151 35 34 tools tool NOUN ital-9151 35 35 for for ADP ital-9151 35 36 our our PRON ital-9151 35 37 user user NOUN ital-9151 35 38 communities community NOUN ital-9151 35 39 . . PUNCT ital-9151 36 1 we we PRON ital-9151 36 2 have have VERB ital-9151 36 3 the the DET ital-9151 36 4 opportunity opportunity NOUN ital-9151 36 5 , , PUNCT ital-9151 36 6 through through ADP ital-9151 36 7 technology technology NOUN ital-9151 36 8 and and CCONJ ital-9151 36 9 a a DET ital-9151 36 10 more more ADV ital-9151 36 11 nuanced nuanced ADJ ital-9151 36 12 understanding understanding NOUN ital-9151 36 13 of of ADP ital-9151 36 14 privacy privacy NOUN ital-9151 36 15 , , PUNCT ital-9151 36 16 to to PART ital-9151 36 17 conduct conduct VERB ital-9151 36 18 a a DET ital-9151 36 19 protracted protract VERB ital-9151 36 20 reference reference NOUN ital-9151 36 21 interview interview NOUN ital-9151 36 22 with with ADP ital-9151 36 23 our our PRON ital-9151 36 24 virtual virtual ADJ ital-9151 36 25 users user NOUN ital-9151 36 26 over over ADP ital-9151 36 27 multiple multiple ADJ ital-9151 36 28 interactions interaction NOUN ital-9151 36 29 … … PUNCT ital-9151 36 30 and and CCONJ ital-9151 36 31 thereby thereby ADV ital-9151 36 32 improve improve VERB ital-9151 36 33 our our PRON ital-9151 36 34 services service NOUN ital-9151 36 35 . . PUNCT ital-9151 37 1 references reference NOUN ital-9151 37 2 1 1 NUM ital-9151 37 3 . . PUNCT ital-9151 37 4 http://www.niso.org/topics/tl/patron_privacy/ http://www.niso.org/topics/tl/patron_privacy/ PROPN ital-9151 37 5 2 2 NUM ital-9151 37 6 . . PUNCT ital-9151 37 7 http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/niso%20consensus http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/niso%20consensus NUM ital-9151 37 8 % % NOUN ital-9151 37 9 20principles%20users%20digital%20privacy.pdf 20principles%20users%20digital%20privacy.pdf NUM ital-9151 37 10 http://www.niso.org/topics/tl/patron_privacy/ http://www.niso.org/topics/tl/patron_privacy/ NOUN ital-9151 37 11 http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/niso%20consensus%20principles%20users%20digital%20privacy.pdf http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/niso%20consensus%20principles%20users%20digital%20privacy.pdf NOUN ital-9151 37 12 http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/niso%20consensus%20principles%20users%20digital%20privacy.pdf http://www.niso.org/apps/group_public/download.php/15863/niso%20consensus%20principles%20users%20digital%20privacy.pdf NOUN