id sid tid token lemma pos _005457217 1 1 r r NOUN _005457217 1 2 h h NOUN _005457217 1 3 t t NOUN _005457217 1 4 ó ó ADP _005457217 1 5 a a PRON _005457217 1 6 : : PUNCT _005457217 1 7 s s PROPN _005457217 1 8 n n ADP _005457217 1 9 the the DET _005457217 1 10 ch ch PROPN _005457217 1 11 ampaign ampaign PROPN _005457217 1 12 rei rei PROPN _005457217 1 13 l l PROPN _005457217 2 1 g g X _005457217 2 2 l l NOUN _005457217 2 3 o o PROPN _005457217 2 4 u u PROPN _005457217 2 5 s s PART _005457217 2 6 edu edu PROPN _005457217 2 7 cation cation NOUN _005457217 2 8 case case NOUN _005457217 2 9 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 2 10 of of ADP _005457217 2 11 the the DET _005457217 2 12 court court NOUN _005457217 2 13 approving approve VERB _005457217 2 14 released release VERB _005457217 2 15 school school NOUN _005457217 2 16 time time NOUN _005457217 2 17 published publish VERB _005457217 2 18 by by ADP _005457217 2 19 the the DET _005457217 2 20 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 2 21 association association NOUN _005457217 2 22 for for ADP _005457217 2 23 religious religious ADJ _005457217 2 24 education education NOUN _005457217 3 1 f f NOUN _005457217 3 2 i i PRON _005457217 3 3 r r VERB _005457217 3 4 s s X _005457217 3 5 t t NOUN _005457217 3 6 a a DET _005457217 3 7 n n NOUN _005457217 3 8 d d PROPN _005457217 3 9 a a X _005457217 3 10 d d NOUN _005457217 3 11 a a X _005457217 3 12 m m PROPN _005457217 3 13 s s NOUN _005457217 3 14 s s NOUN _005457217 3 15 t t NOUN _005457217 3 16 r r NOUN _005457217 3 17 e e NOUN _005457217 3 18 e e NOUN _005457217 3 19 t t PROPN _005457217 3 20 s s PART _005457217 3 21 springfield springfield NOUN _005457217 3 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 3 23 ill ill PROPN _005457217 3 24 . . PUNCT _005457217 3 25 price price NOUN _005457217 3 26 25 25 NUM _005457217 3 27 $ $ NUM _005457217 3 28 per per ADP _005457217 3 29 copy copy NOUN _005457217 3 30 object object NOUN _005457217 3 31 of of ADP _005457217 3 32 the the DET _005457217 3 33 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 3 34 association association NOUN _005457217 3 35 for for ADP _005457217 3 36 religious religious ADJ _005457217 3 37 education education NOUN _005457217 3 38 * * PUNCT _005457217 3 39 " " PUNCT _005457217 3 40 t t NOUN _005457217 3 41 o o NOUN _005457217 3 42 promote promote NOUN _005457217 3 43 , , PUNCT _005457217 3 44 support support NOUN _005457217 3 45 , , PUNCT _005457217 3 46 strengthen strengthen VERB _005457217 3 47 and and CCONJ _005457217 3 48 develop develop VERB _005457217 3 49 systems system NOUN _005457217 3 50 of of ADP _005457217 3 51 religious religious ADJ _005457217 3 52 education education NOUN _005457217 3 53 f f PROPN _005457217 4 1 o o X _005457217 4 2 r r NOUN _005457217 4 3 children child NOUN _005457217 4 4 of of ADP _005457217 4 5 elementary elementary ADJ _005457217 4 6 and and CCONJ _005457217 4 7 secondary secondary ADJ _005457217 4 8 school school NOUN _005457217 4 9 age age NOUN _005457217 4 10 as as ADP _005457217 4 11 community community NOUN _005457217 4 12 projects project NOUN _005457217 4 13 under under ADP _005457217 4 14 the the DET _005457217 4 15 joint joint ADJ _005457217 4 16 sponsorship sponsorship NOUN _005457217 4 17 of of ADP _005457217 4 18 the the DET _005457217 4 19 religious religious ADJ _005457217 4 20 forces force NOUN _005457217 4 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 4 22 of of ADP _005457217 4 23 the the DET _005457217 4 24 parents parent NOUN _005457217 4 25 and and CCONJ _005457217 4 26 of of ADP _005457217 4 27 the the DET _005457217 4 28 educational educational ADJ _005457217 4 29 leaders leader NOUN _005457217 4 30 in in ADP _005457217 4 31 the the DET _005457217 4 32 community community NOUN _005457217 4 33 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 4 34 to to PART _005457217 4 35 develop develop VERB _005457217 4 36 standards standard NOUN _005457217 4 37 and and CCONJ _005457217 4 38 curriculum curriculum NOUN _005457217 4 39 for for ADP _005457217 4 40 such such ADJ _005457217 4 41 systems system NOUN _005457217 4 42 of of ADP _005457217 4 43 religious religious ADJ _005457217 4 44 education education NOUN _005457217 4 45 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 4 46 to to PART _005457217 4 47 develop develop VERB _005457217 4 48 standards standard NOUN _005457217 4 49 f f PROPN _005457217 4 50 o o X _005457217 4 51 r r NOUN _005457217 4 52 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 4 53 in in ADP _005457217 4 54 such such ADJ _005457217 4 55 systems system NOUN _005457217 4 56 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 4 57 and and CCONJ _005457217 4 58 to to PART _005457217 4 59 collect collect VERB _005457217 4 60 and and CCONJ _005457217 4 61 disseminate disseminate VERB _005457217 4 62 information information NOUN _005457217 4 63 concerning concern VERB _005457217 4 64 methods method NOUN _005457217 4 65 of of ADP _005457217 4 66 community community NOUN _005457217 4 67 cooperation cooperation NOUN _005457217 4 68 used use VERB _005457217 4 69 in in ADP _005457217 4 70 establishing establish VERB _005457217 4 71 and and CCONJ _005457217 4 72 operating operate VERB _005457217 4 73 such such ADJ _005457217 4 74 systems system NOUN _005457217 4 75 of of ADP _005457217 4 76 religious religious ADJ _005457217 4 77 education education NOUN _005457217 4 78 . . PUNCT _005457217 4 79 " " PUNCT _005457217 5 1 * * PUNCT _005457217 5 2 organized organize VERB _005457217 5 3 under under ADP _005457217 5 4 the the DET _005457217 5 5 general general NOUN _005457217 5 6 not not PART _005457217 5 7 for for ADP _005457217 5 8 profit profit NOUN _005457217 5 9 corporation corporation PROPN _005457217 5 10 act act NOUN _005457217 5 11 of of ADP _005457217 5 12 the the DET _005457217 5 13 state state NOUN _005457217 5 14 of of ADP _005457217 5 15 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 5 16 . . PUNCT _005457217 6 1 deadffiîfed deadffiîfe VERB _005457217 6 2 in in ADP _005457217 6 3 the the DET _005457217 6 4 circuit circuit NOUN _005457217 6 5 court court NOUN _005457217 6 6 of of ADP _005457217 6 7 champaign champaign PROPN _005457217 6 8 county county PROPN _005457217 6 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 6 10 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 6 11 t t PROPN _005457217 6 12 h h X _005457217 6 13 e e X _005457217 7 1 p p NOUN _005457217 7 2 e e PROPN _005457217 7 3 o o X _005457217 7 4 p p NOUN _005457217 7 5 l l X _005457217 7 6 e e NOUN _005457217 7 7 o o NOUN _005457217 7 8 f f PROPN _005457217 7 9 t t PROPN _005457217 7 10 h h X _005457217 7 11 e e NOUN _005457217 7 12 s s VERB _005457217 7 13 t t NOUN _005457217 8 1 a a DET _005457217 8 2 t t NOUN _005457217 8 3 e e NOUN _005457217 9 1 o o NOUN _005457217 10 1 f f PROPN _005457217 11 1 i i PROPN _005457217 11 2 l l PROPN _005457217 11 3 l l PROPN _005457217 12 1 i i PRON _005457217 12 2 n n VERB _005457217 13 1 o o NOUN _005457217 13 2 i i PRON _005457217 13 3 s s VERB _005457217 13 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 13 5 ^ ^ X _005457217 14 1 ex ex PROPN _005457217 14 2 rel rel PROPN _005457217 14 3 . . PUNCT _005457217 15 1 v v ADP _005457217 15 2 a a DET _005457217 15 3 s s NOUN _005457217 15 4 h h NOUN _005457217 15 5 t t NOUN _005457217 16 1 i i PRON _005457217 16 2 m m VERB _005457217 16 3 c c PROPN _005457217 16 4 c c X _005457217 16 5 o o X _005457217 16 6 l l X _005457217 16 7 l l X _005457217 16 8 u u PROPN _005457217 16 9 m m PROPN _005457217 16 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 16 11 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN _005457217 16 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 16 13 vs. vs. ADP _005457217 16 14 board board NOUN _005457217 17 1 o o NOUN _005457217 17 2 f f PROPN _005457217 17 3 e e PROPN _005457217 17 4 d d PROPN _005457217 17 5 u u PROPN _005457217 17 6 c c AUX _005457217 17 7 a a DET _005457217 17 8 t t NOUN _005457217 18 1 i i PRON _005457217 19 1 o o NOUN _005457217 19 2 n n ADV _005457217 20 1 o o NOUN _005457217 20 2 f f PROPN _005457217 20 3 s s NOUN _005457217 21 1 c c X _005457217 21 2 h h NOUN _005457217 21 3 o o NOUN _005457217 22 1 o o NOUN _005457217 23 1 l l X _005457217 23 2 d d INTJ _005457217 23 3 i i PRON _005457217 23 4 s s VERB _005457217 23 5 t t NOUN _005457217 23 6 r r NOUN _005457217 24 1 i i PRON _005457217 24 2 c c VERB _005457217 24 3 t t PROPN _005457217 24 4 n n PROPN _005457217 24 5 u u PROPN _005457217 24 6 m m NOUN _005457217 24 7 b b NOUN _005457217 24 8 e e NOUN _005457217 24 9 r r NOUN _005457217 24 10 71 71 NUM _005457217 24 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 24 12 c c AUX _005457217 24 13 h h NOUN _005457217 24 14 a a DET _005457217 24 15 m m NOUN _005457217 24 16 p p NOUN _005457217 25 1 a a PRON _005457217 26 1 i i NOUN _005457217 26 2 g g NOUN _005457217 26 3 n n ADP _005457217 27 1 c c NOUN _005457217 27 2 o o NOUN _005457217 27 3 u u PROPN _005457217 27 4 n n ADP _005457217 27 5 t t PROPN _005457217 27 6 y y PROPN _005457217 27 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 27 8 i i PRON _005457217 27 9 l l PROPN _005457217 27 10 l l X _005457217 27 11 i i PROPN _005457217 27 12 nois nois PROPN _005457217 27 13 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 27 14 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 27 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 27 16 e e PROPN _005457217 27 17 l l X _005457217 27 18 m m PROPN _005457217 27 19 e e PROPN _005457217 27 20 r r PROPN _005457217 27 21 c. c. PROPN _005457217 27 22 b b PROPN _005457217 27 23 a a DET _005457217 27 24 s s NOUN _005457217 27 25 h h NOUN _005457217 27 26 and and CCONJ _005457217 27 27 a a DET _005457217 27 28 l l NOUN _005457217 27 29 i i PRON _005457217 27 30 c c VERB _005457217 27 31 e e PROPN _005457217 27 32 j. j. PROPN _005457217 27 33 b b PROPN _005457217 27 34 a a DET _005457217 27 35 s s NOUN _005457217 27 36 h h NOUN _005457217 27 37 and and CCONJ _005457217 27 38 w w ADP _005457217 27 39 a a DET _005457217 27 40 n n NOUN _005457217 27 41 d d PROPN _005457217 27 42 a a DET _005457217 27 43 i. i. NOUN _005457217 27 44 b b PROPN _005457217 28 1 a a DET _005457217 28 2 s s NOUN _005457217 28 3 h h NOUN _005457217 28 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 28 5 a a DET _005457217 28 6 minor minor NOUN _005457217 28 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 28 8 by by ADP _005457217 28 9 e e PROPN _005457217 28 10 l l PROPN _005457217 28 11 m m PROPN _005457217 28 12 e e PROPN _005457217 28 13 r r PROPN _005457217 28 14 c. c. PROPN _005457217 28 15 b b PROPN _005457217 28 16 a a DET _005457217 28 17 s s NOUN _005457217 28 18 h h NOUN _005457217 28 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 28 20 her her PRON _005457217 28 21 father father NOUN _005457217 28 22 and and CCONJ _005457217 28 23 next next ADJ _005457217 28 24 friend friend NOUN _005457217 28 25 , , PUNCT _005457217 28 26 interveners intervener NOUN _005457217 28 27 .. .. PUNCT _005457217 29 1 before before ADP _005457217 29 2 the the DET _005457217 29 3 honorable honorable ADJ _005457217 29 4 f f NOUN _005457217 29 5 r r NOUN _005457217 29 6 a a PRON _005457217 29 7 n n PROPN _005457217 29 8 k k PROPN _005457217 29 9 b. b. PROPN _005457217 29 10 leonard leonard PROPN _005457217 29 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 29 12 grover grover PROPN _005457217 29 13 w w PROPN _005457217 29 14 . . PUNCT _005457217 30 1 watson watson PROPN _005457217 30 2 and and CCONJ _005457217 30 3 martin martin PROPN _005457217 30 4 e. e. PROPN _005457217 30 5 morthland morthland PROPN _005457217 30 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 30 7 judges judge NOUN _005457217 30 8 of of ADP _005457217 30 9 the the DET _005457217 30 10 sixth sixth ADJ _005457217 30 11 judicial judicial ADJ _005457217 30 12 circuit circuit NOUN _005457217 30 13 of of ADP _005457217 30 14 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 30 15 . . PUNCT _005457217 31 1 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 31 2 of of ADP _005457217 31 3 the the DET _005457217 31 4 court court NOUN _005457217 31 5 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 31 6 delivered deliver VERB _005457217 31 7 january january PROPN _005457217 31 8 26 26 NUM _005457217 31 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 31 10 1946 1946 NUM _005457217 31 11 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 31 12 . . PUNCT _005457217 32 1 by by ADP _005457217 32 2 mandamus mandamus PROPN _005457217 32 3 the the DET _005457217 32 4 relator relator NOUN _005457217 32 5 , , PUNCT _005457217 32 6 vashti vashti NOUN _005457217 32 7 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 32 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 32 9 a a DET _005457217 32 10 tax tax NOUN _005457217 32 11 payer payer NOUN _005457217 32 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 32 13 and and CCONJ _005457217 32 14 mother mother NOUN _005457217 32 15 of of ADP _005457217 32 16 james james PROPN _005457217 32 17 terry terry PROPN _005457217 32 18 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 32 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 32 20 who who PRON _005457217 32 21 attended attend VERB _005457217 32 22 school school NOUN _005457217 32 23 in in ADP _005457217 32 24 the the DET _005457217 32 25 fifth fifth ADJ _005457217 32 26 grade grade NOUN _005457217 32 27 at at ADP _005457217 32 28 the the DET _005457217 32 29 dr dr PROPN _005457217 32 30 . . PROPN _005457217 32 31 howard howard PROPN _005457217 32 32 school school PROPN _005457217 32 33 , , PUNCT _005457217 32 34 seeks seek VERB _005457217 32 35 to to PART _005457217 32 36 prohibit prohibit VERB _005457217 32 37 the the DET _005457217 32 38 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 32 39 of of ADP _005457217 32 40 religious religious ADJ _005457217 32 41 education education NOUN _005457217 32 42 in in ADP _005457217 32 43 the the DET _005457217 32 44 public public ADJ _005457217 32 45 schools school NOUN _005457217 32 46 of of ADP _005457217 32 47 the the DET _005457217 32 48 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 32 49 , , PUNCT _005457217 32 50 school school NOUN _005457217 32 51 district district NOUN _005457217 32 52 number number NOUN _005457217 32 53 71 71 NUM _005457217 32 54 , , PUNCT _005457217 32 55 in in ADP _005457217 32 56 the the DET _005457217 32 57 school school NOUN _005457217 32 58 houses house NOUN _005457217 32 59 and and CCONJ _005457217 32 60 buildings building NOUN _005457217 32 61 in in ADP _005457217 32 62 said say VERB _005457217 32 63 district district NOUN _005457217 32 64 during during ADP _005457217 32 65 the the DET _005457217 32 66 hours hour NOUN _005457217 32 67 when when SCONJ _005457217 32 68 said say VERB _005457217 32 69 public public ADJ _005457217 32 70 schools school NOUN _005457217 32 71 are be AUX _005457217 32 72 regularly regularly ADV _005457217 32 73 in in ADP _005457217 32 74 session session NOUN _005457217 32 75 . . PUNCT _005457217 33 1 the the DET _005457217 33 2 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 33 3 school school NOUN _005457217 33 4 district district NOUN _005457217 33 5 includes include VERB _005457217 33 6 all all DET _005457217 33 7 the the DET _005457217 33 8 schools school NOUN _005457217 33 9 and and CCONJ _005457217 33 10 school school NOUN _005457217 33 11 buildings building NOUN _005457217 33 12 in in ADP _005457217 33 13 the the DET _005457217 33 14 city city NOUN _005457217 33 15 of of ADP _005457217 33 16 champaign champaign NOUN _005457217 33 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 33 18 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 33 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 34 1 at at ADP _005457217 34 2 the the DET _005457217 34 3 opening opening NOUN _005457217 34 4 of of ADP _005457217 34 5 the the DET _005457217 34 6 trial trial NOUN _005457217 34 7 elmer elmer NOUN _005457217 34 8 c. c. PROPN _005457217 34 9 bash bash PROPN _005457217 34 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 34 11 a a DET _005457217 34 12 citizen citizen NOUN _005457217 34 13 and and CCONJ _005457217 34 14 tax tax NOUN _005457217 34 15 payer payer NOUN _005457217 34 16 residing reside VERB _005457217 34 17 in in ADP _005457217 34 18 said say VERB _005457217 34 19 school school NOUN _005457217 34 20 district district NOUN _005457217 34 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 34 22 and and CCONJ _005457217 34 23 alice alice VERB _005457217 34 24 j j PROPN _005457217 34 25 . . PUNCT _005457217 34 26 bash bash PROPN _005457217 34 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 34 28 his his PRON _005457217 34 29 wife wife NOUN _005457217 34 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 34 31 filed file VERB _005457217 34 32 an an DET _005457217 34 33 intervening intervening NOUN _005457217 34 34 petition petition NOUN _005457217 34 35 alleging allege VERB _005457217 34 36 that that SCONJ _005457217 34 37 they they PRON _005457217 34 38 are be AUX _005457217 34 39 the the DET _005457217 34 40 parents parent NOUN _005457217 34 41 of of ADP _005457217 34 42 two two NUM _005457217 34 43 children child NOUN _005457217 34 44 , , PUNCT _005457217 34 45 shirley shirley NOUN _005457217 34 46 and and CCONJ _005457217 34 47 wanda wanda PROPN _005457217 34 48 , , PUNCT _005457217 34 49 who who PRON _005457217 34 50 attend attend VERB _005457217 34 51 school school NOUN _005457217 34 52 in in ADP _005457217 34 53 said say VERB _005457217 34 54 school school NOUN _005457217 34 55 district district NOUN _005457217 34 56 , , PUNCT _005457217 34 57 that that SCONJ _005457217 34 58 they they PRON _005457217 34 59 are be AUX _005457217 34 60 members member NOUN _005457217 34 61 of of ADP _005457217 34 62 the the DET _005457217 34 63 university university NOUN _005457217 34 64 place place NOUN _005457217 34 65 christian christian ADJ _005457217 34 66 church church NOUN _005457217 34 67 in in ADP _005457217 34 68 this this DET _005457217 34 69 community community NOUN _005457217 34 70 . . PUNCT _005457217 35 1 they they PRON _005457217 35 2 allege allege VERB _005457217 35 3 that that SCONJ _005457217 35 4 they they PRON _005457217 35 5 desire desire VERB _005457217 35 6 the the DET _005457217 35 7 said say VERB _005457217 35 8 courses course NOUN _005457217 35 9 in in ADP _005457217 35 10 religious religious ADJ _005457217 35 11 education education NOUN _005457217 35 12 complained complain VERB _005457217 35 13 of of ADP _005457217 35 14 by by ADP _005457217 35 15 the the DET _005457217 35 16 relator relator NOUN _005457217 35 17 to to PART _005457217 35 18 continue continue VERB _005457217 35 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 35 20 and and CCONJ _005457217 35 21 allege allege VERB _005457217 35 22 that that SCONJ _005457217 35 23 under under ADP _005457217 35 24 the the DET _005457217 35 25 f f NOUN _005457217 35 26 i i PRON _005457217 35 27 r r VERB _005457217 35 28 s s X _005457217 36 1 t t NOUN _005457217 36 2 and and CCONJ _005457217 36 3 fourteenth fourteenth ADJ _005457217 36 4 amendments amendment NOUN _005457217 36 5 to to ADP _005457217 36 6 the the DET _005457217 36 7 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 36 8 of of ADP _005457217 36 9 the the DET _005457217 36 10 united united PROPN _005457217 36 11 states states PROPN _005457217 36 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 36 13 and and CCONJ _005457217 36 14 under under ADP _005457217 36 15 the the DET _005457217 36 16 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 36 17 of of ADP _005457217 36 18 the the DET _005457217 36 19 state state NOUN _005457217 36 20 of of ADP _005457217 36 21 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 36 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 36 23 they they PRON _005457217 36 24 have have VERB _005457217 36 25 the the DET _005457217 36 26 right right NOUN _005457217 36 27 to to PART _005457217 36 28 direct direct VERB _005457217 36 29 the the DET _005457217 36 30 education education NOUN _005457217 36 31 of of ADP _005457217 36 32 their their PRON _005457217 36 33 children child NOUN _005457217 36 34 , , PUNCT _005457217 36 35 and and CCONJ _005457217 37 1 p p NOUN _005457217 37 2 r r NOUN _005457217 37 3 a a X _005457217 37 4 y y PROPN _005457217 37 5 f f PROPN _005457217 37 6 o o X _005457217 38 1 r r NOUN _005457217 38 2 the the DET _005457217 38 3 dismissal dismissal NOUN _005457217 38 4 of of ADP _005457217 38 5 the the DET _005457217 38 6 relator relator NOUN _005457217 38 7 's 's PART _005457217 38 8 petition petition NOUN _005457217 38 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 39 1 there there PRON _005457217 39 2 was be VERB _005457217 39 3 no no DET _005457217 39 4 objection objection NOUN _005457217 39 5 to to ADP _005457217 39 6 the the DET _005457217 39 7 filing filing NOUN _005457217 39 8 of of ADP _005457217 39 9 this this DET _005457217 39 10 petition petition NOUN _005457217 39 11 but but CCONJ _005457217 39 12 the the DET _005457217 39 13 relator relator NOUN _005457217 39 14 filed file VERB _005457217 39 15 a a DET _005457217 39 16 reply reply NOUN _005457217 39 17 thereto thereto VERB _005457217 39 18 praying pray VERB _005457217 39 19 strict strict ADJ _005457217 39 20 proof proof NOUN _005457217 39 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 39 22 denying deny VERB _005457217 39 23 that that SCONJ _005457217 39 24 said say VERB _005457217 39 25 children child NOUN _005457217 39 26 are be AUX _005457217 39 27 entitled entitle VERB _005457217 39 28 to to PART _005457217 39 29 attend attend VERB _005457217 39 30 the the DET _005457217 39 31 courses course NOUN _005457217 39 32 of of ADP _005457217 39 33 religious religious ADJ _005457217 39 34 education education NOUN _005457217 39 35 , , PUNCT _005457217 39 36 and and CCONJ _005457217 39 37 that that SCONJ _005457217 39 38 they they PRON _005457217 39 39 have have VERB _005457217 39 40 any any DET _005457217 39 41 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 39 42 rights right NOUN _005457217 39 43 as as SCONJ _005457217 39 44 alleged allege VERB _005457217 39 45 in in ADP _005457217 39 46 the the DET _005457217 39 47 intervening intervening NOUN _005457217 39 48 petition petition NOUN _005457217 39 49 . . PUNCT _005457217 40 1 the the DET _005457217 40 2 intervening intervene VERB _005457217 40 3 petition petition NOUN _005457217 40 4 will will AUX _005457217 40 5 not not PART _005457217 40 6 be be AUX _005457217 40 7 particularly particularly ADV _005457217 40 8 referred refer VERB _005457217 40 9 to to ADP _005457217 40 10 hereafter hereafter ADV _005457217 40 11 because because SCONJ _005457217 40 12 the the DET _005457217 40 13 court court NOUN _005457217 40 14 is be AUX _005457217 40 15 of of ADP _005457217 40 16 the the DET _005457217 40 17 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 40 18 the the DET _005457217 40 19 case case NOUN _005457217 40 20 can can AUX _005457217 40 21 be be AUX _005457217 40 22 disposed dispose VERB _005457217 40 23 of of ADP _005457217 40 24 on on ADP _005457217 40 25 the the DET _005457217 40 26 complaint complaint NOUN _005457217 40 27 f f PROPN _005457217 40 28 o o X _005457217 40 29 r r NOUN _005457217 40 30 mandamus mandamus NOUN _005457217 40 31 and and CCONJ _005457217 40 32 the the DET _005457217 40 33 answer answer NOUN _005457217 40 34 thereto thereto VERB _005457217 40 35 with with ADP _005457217 40 36 the the DET _005457217 40 37 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 40 38 heard hear VERB _005457217 40 39 in in ADP _005457217 40 40 regard regard NOUN _005457217 40 41 to to ADP _005457217 40 42 the the DET _005457217 40 43 same same ADJ _005457217 40 44 . . PUNCT _005457217 41 1 by by ADP _005457217 41 2 agreement agreement NOUN _005457217 41 3 the the DET _005457217 41 4 case case NOUN _005457217 41 5 was be AUX _005457217 41 6 heard hear VERB _005457217 41 7 before before ADP _005457217 41 8 the the DET _005457217 41 9 three three NUM _005457217 41 10 judges judge NOUN _005457217 41 11 of of ADP _005457217 41 12 the the DET _005457217 41 13 sixth sixth ADJ _005457217 41 14 judicial judicial ADJ _005457217 41 15 circuit circuit NOUN _005457217 41 16 sitting sit VERB _005457217 41 17 en en ADP _005457217 41 18 banc banc PROPN _005457217 41 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 42 1 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 42 2 was be AUX _005457217 42 3 heard hear VERB _005457217 42 4 f f PROPN _005457217 42 5 o o X _005457217 42 6 r r NOUN _005457217 42 7 four four NUM _005457217 42 8 days day NOUN _005457217 42 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 43 1 many many ADJ _005457217 43 2 of of ADP _005457217 43 3 the the DET _005457217 43 4 allegations allegation NOUN _005457217 43 5 of of ADP _005457217 43 6 the the DET _005457217 43 7 complaint complaint NOUN _005457217 43 8 are be AUX _005457217 43 9 admitted admit VERB _005457217 43 10 by by ADP _005457217 43 11 the the DET _005457217 43 12 answer answer NOUN _005457217 43 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 43 14 but but CCONJ _005457217 43 15 there there PRON _005457217 43 16 are be VERB _005457217 43 17 some some DET _005457217 43 18 disputed dispute VERB _005457217 43 19 questions question NOUN _005457217 43 20 of of ADP _005457217 43 21 fact fact NOUN _005457217 43 22 arising arise VERB _005457217 43 23 from from ADP _005457217 43 24 the the DET _005457217 43 25 pleadings pleading NOUN _005457217 43 26 . . PUNCT _005457217 44 1 therefore therefore ADV _005457217 44 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 44 3 the the DET _005457217 44 4 court court NOUN _005457217 44 5 will will AUX _005457217 44 6 make make VERB _005457217 44 7 the the DET _005457217 44 8 following follow VERB _005457217 45 1 f f PROPN _005457217 46 1 i i PROPN _005457217 47 1 n n PROPN _005457217 48 1 d d PROPN _005457217 49 1 i i PRON _005457217 50 1 n n VERB _005457217 50 2 g g PROPN _005457217 50 3 s s NUM _005457217 50 4 of of ADP _005457217 50 5 f f PROPN _005457217 50 6 a a DET _005457217 50 7 o o NOUN _005457217 50 8 t t NOUN _005457217 50 9 : : PUNCT _005457217 50 10 the the DET _005457217 50 11 relator relator NOUN _005457217 50 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 50 13 vashti vashti NOUN _005457217 50 14 mccbllum mccbllum PROPN _005457217 50 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 50 16 is be AUX _005457217 50 17 a a DET _005457217 50 18 resident resident ADJ _005457217 50 19 and and CCONJ _005457217 50 20 tax tax NOUN _005457217 50 21 payer payer NOUN _005457217 50 22 in in ADP _005457217 50 23 said say VERB _005457217 50 24 school school NOUN _005457217 50 25 district district NOUN _005457217 50 26 , , PUNCT _005457217 50 27 where where SCONJ _005457217 50 28 her her PRON _005457217 50 29 minor minor ADJ _005457217 50 30 son son NOUN _005457217 50 31 , , PUNCT _005457217 50 32 james james PROPN _005457217 50 33 terry terry PROPN _005457217 50 34 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 50 35 , , PUNCT _005457217 50 36 has have AUX _005457217 50 37 been be AUX _005457217 50 38 attending attend VERB _005457217 50 39 public public ADJ _005457217 50 40 school school NOUN _005457217 50 41 . . PUNCT _005457217 51 1 3 3 NUM _005457217 51 2 the the DET _005457217 51 3 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 51 4 fully fully ADV _005457217 51 5 sustains sustain VERB _005457217 51 6 the the DET _005457217 51 7 allegations allegation NOUN _005457217 51 8 in in ADP _005457217 51 9 paragraph paragraph NOUN _005457217 51 10 2 2 NUM _005457217 51 11 of of ADP _005457217 51 12 the the DET _005457217 51 13 complaint complaint NOUN _005457217 51 14 which which PRON _005457217 51 15 have have AUX _005457217 51 16 been be AUX _005457217 51 17 by by ADP _005457217 51 18 the the DET _005457217 51 19 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 51 20 neither neither CCONJ _005457217 51 21 admitted admit VERB _005457217 51 22 nor nor CCONJ _005457217 51 23 denied deny VERB _005457217 51 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 51 25 that that SCONJ _005457217 51 26 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 51 27 . . PROPN _005457217 51 28 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 51 29 adheres adhere NOUN _005457217 51 30 to to ADP _005457217 51 31 a a DET _005457217 51 32 school school NOUN _005457217 51 33 of of ADP _005457217 51 34 thought thought NOUN _005457217 51 35 known know VERB _005457217 51 36 as as ADP _005457217 51 37 " " PUNCT _005457217 51 38 r r NOUN _005457217 51 39 a a DET _005457217 51 40 t t NOUN _005457217 52 1 i i PRON _005457217 52 2 o o NOUN _005457217 52 3 n n ADV _005457217 52 4 a a DET _005457217 52 5 l l NOUN _005457217 53 1 i i PRON _005457217 53 2 s s VERB _005457217 53 3 m m VERB _005457217 53 4 " " PUNCT _005457217 53 5 , , PUNCT _005457217 53 6 including include VERB _005457217 53 7 atheism atheism NOUN _005457217 53 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 53 9 is be AUX _005457217 53 10 not not PART _005457217 53 11 a a DET _005457217 53 12 believer believer NOUN _005457217 53 13 in in ADP _005457217 53 14 any any DET _005457217 53 15 religious religious ADJ _005457217 53 16 creed creed NOUN _005457217 53 17 or or CCONJ _005457217 53 18 doctrine doctrine NOUN _005457217 53 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 53 20 accepts accept VERB _005457217 53 21 no no DET _005457217 53 22 p p NOUN _005457217 53 23 a a DET _005457217 53 24 r r NOUN _005457217 53 25 t t NOUN _005457217 53 26 of of ADP _005457217 53 27 any any DET _005457217 53 28 bible bible ADJ _005457217 53 29 as as ADP _005457217 53 30 true true ADJ _005457217 53 31 where where SCONJ _005457217 53 32 such such DET _005457217 53 33 p p NOUN _005457217 53 34 a a DET _005457217 53 35 r r NOUN _005457217 53 36 t t NOUN _005457217 53 37 is be AUX _005457217 53 38 not not PART _005457217 53 39 in in ADP _005457217 53 40 accord accord NOUN _005457217 53 41 with with ADP _005457217 53 42 proved proved ADJ _005457217 53 43 scientific scientific ADJ _005457217 53 44 facts fact NOUN _005457217 53 45 , , PUNCT _005457217 53 46 and and CCONJ _005457217 53 47 her her PRON _005457217 53 48 views view NOUN _005457217 53 49 are be AUX _005457217 53 50 as as ADV _005457217 53 51 set set VERB _005457217 54 1 f f PROPN _005457217 54 2 o o X _005457217 54 3 r r NOUN _005457217 54 4 t t NOUN _005457217 54 5 h h NOUN _005457217 54 6 in in ADP _005457217 54 7 her her PRON _005457217 54 8 f f X _005457217 54 9 a a DET _005457217 54 10 t t NOUN _005457217 54 11 h h NOUN _005457217 54 12 e e NOUN _005457217 54 13 r r NOUN _005457217 54 14 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 54 15 s s NOUN _005457217 54 16 publication publication NOUN _005457217 54 17 entitled entitle VERB _005457217 54 18 " " PUNCT _005457217 54 19 rationalism rationalism NOUN _005457217 54 20 versus versus ADP _005457217 54 21 religious religious ADJ _005457217 54 22 education education NOUN _005457217 54 23 in in ADP _005457217 54 24 the the DET _005457217 54 25 public public ADJ _005457217 54 26 schools school NOUN _005457217 54 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 54 28 " " PUNCT _005457217 54 29 a a DET _005457217 54 30 copy copy NOUN _005457217 54 31 of of ADP _005457217 54 32 which which PRON _005457217 54 33 , , PUNCT _005457217 54 34 marked mark VERB _005457217 54 35 exhibit exhibit NOUN _005457217 54 36 a a PRON _005457217 54 37 , , PUNCT _005457217 54 38 is be AUX _005457217 54 39 attached attach VERB _005457217 54 40 to to ADP _005457217 54 41 the the DET _005457217 54 42 petition petition NOUN _005457217 54 43 . . PUNCT _005457217 55 1 she she PRON _005457217 55 2 is be AUX _005457217 55 3 compelled compel VERB _005457217 55 4 by by ADP _005457217 55 5 the the DET _005457217 55 6 compulsory compulsory ADJ _005457217 55 7 school school NOUN _005457217 55 8 law law NOUN _005457217 55 9 to to PART _005457217 55 10 send send VERB _005457217 55 11 her her PRON _005457217 55 12 son son NOUN _005457217 55 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 55 14 james james PROPN _005457217 55 15 terry terry PROPN _005457217 55 16 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 55 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 55 18 to to ADP _005457217 55 19 the the DET _005457217 55 20 public public ADJ _005457217 55 21 schools school NOUN _005457217 55 22 of of ADP _005457217 55 23 the the DET _005457217 55 24 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 55 25 school school NOUN _005457217 55 26 district district NOUN _005457217 55 27 . . PUNCT _005457217 56 1 the the DET _005457217 56 2 overwhelming overwhelming ADJ _005457217 56 3 weight weight NOUN _005457217 56 4 of of ADP _005457217 56 5 the the DET _005457217 56 6 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 56 7 shows show VERB _005457217 56 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 56 9 as as SCONJ _005457217 56 10 set set VERB _005457217 56 11 f f PROPN _005457217 56 12 o o X _005457217 56 13 r r NOUN _005457217 56 14 t t NOUN _005457217 56 15 h h NOUN _005457217 56 16 in in ADP _005457217 56 17 the the DET _005457217 56 18 answer answer NOUN _005457217 56 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 56 20 that that DET _005457217 56 21 religious religious ADJ _005457217 56 22 education education NOUN _005457217 56 23 classes class NOUN _005457217 56 24 were be AUX _005457217 56 25 established establish VERB _005457217 56 26 and and CCONJ _005457217 56 27 maintained maintain VERB _005457217 56 28 in in ADP _005457217 56 29 the the DET _005457217 56 30 public public ADJ _005457217 56 31 school school NOUN _005457217 56 32 buildings building NOUN _005457217 56 33 in in ADP _005457217 56 34 the the DET _005457217 56 35 city city NOUN _005457217 56 36 of of ADP _005457217 56 37 champaign champaign NOUN _005457217 56 38 , , PUNCT _005457217 56 39 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 56 40 , , PUNCT _005457217 57 1 f f PROPN _005457217 57 2 o o NOUN _005457217 57 3 r r NOUN _005457217 57 4 about about ADV _005457217 57 5 five five NUM _005457217 57 6 years year NOUN _005457217 57 7 last last ADJ _005457217 57 8 past past ADV _005457217 57 9 under under ADP _005457217 57 10 arrangements arrangement NOUN _005457217 57 11 made make VERB _005457217 57 12 between between ADP _005457217 57 13 the the DET _005457217 57 14 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 57 15 school school NOUN _005457217 57 16 board board NOUN _005457217 57 17 and and CCONJ _005457217 57 18 a a DET _005457217 57 19 group group NOUN _005457217 57 20 known know VERB _005457217 57 21 as as ADP _005457217 57 22 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 57 23 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 57 24 the the DET _005457217 57 25 champaign champaign ADJ _005457217 57 26 council council NOUN _005457217 57 27 of of ADP _005457217 57 28 religious religious ADJ _005457217 57 29 education education NOUN _005457217 57 30 " " PUNCT _005457217 57 31 , , PUNCT _005457217 57 32 a a DET _005457217 57 33 volunt volunt NOUN _005457217 57 34 a a DET _005457217 57 35 r r NOUN _005457217 57 36 y y PROPN _005457217 57 37 association association NOUN _005457217 57 38 made make VERB _005457217 57 39 up up ADP _005457217 57 40 of of ADP _005457217 57 41 the the DET _005457217 57 42 representatives representative NOUN _005457217 57 43 of of ADP _005457217 57 44 the the DET _005457217 57 45 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 57 46 , , PUNCT _005457217 57 47 roman roman ADJ _005457217 57 48 catholic catholic NOUN _005457217 57 49 and and CCONJ _005457217 57 50 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 57 51 faiths faith NOUN _005457217 57 52 in in ADP _005457217 57 53 the the DET _005457217 57 54 school school NOUN _005457217 57 55 district district NOUN _005457217 57 56 . . PUNCT _005457217 58 1 the the DET _005457217 58 2 religious religious ADJ _005457217 58 3 education education NOUN _005457217 58 4 council council NOUN _005457217 58 5 was be AUX _005457217 58 6 founded found VERB _005457217 58 7 and and CCONJ _005457217 58 8 organized organize VERB _005457217 58 9 for for ADP _005457217 58 10 the the DET _005457217 58 11 purpose purpose NOUN _005457217 58 12 of of ADP _005457217 58 13 combatting combat VERB _005457217 58 14 juvenile juvenile ADJ _005457217 58 15 delinquency delinquency NOUN _005457217 58 16 in in ADP _005457217 58 17 the the DET _005457217 58 18 community community NOUN _005457217 58 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 58 20 as as ADV _005457217 58 21 well well ADV _005457217 58 22 as as ADP _005457217 58 23 to to PART _005457217 58 24 afford afford VERB _005457217 58 25 , , PUNCT _005457217 58 26 if if SCONJ _005457217 58 27 legally legally ADV _005457217 58 28 possible possible ADJ _005457217 58 29 , , PUNCT _005457217 58 30 an an DET _005457217 58 31 opportunity opportunity NOUN _005457217 59 1 f f NOUN _005457217 59 2 o o X _005457217 59 3 r r NOUN _005457217 59 4 children child NOUN _005457217 59 5 to to PART _005457217 59 6 study study VERB _005457217 59 7 religious religious ADJ _005457217 59 8 education education NOUN _005457217 59 9 on on ADP _005457217 59 10 released release VERB _005457217 59 11 time time NOUN _005457217 59 12 under under ADP _005457217 59 13 circumstances circumstance NOUN _005457217 59 14 hereinafter hereinafter PROPN _005457217 59 15 detailed detail VERB _005457217 59 16 . . PUNCT _005457217 60 1 the the DET _005457217 60 2 school school NOUN _005457217 60 3 authorities authority NOUN _005457217 60 4 made make VERB _005457217 60 5 available available ADJ _005457217 60 6 to to ADP _005457217 60 7 this this DET _005457217 60 8 religious religious ADJ _005457217 60 9 education education NOUN _005457217 60 10 council council NOUN _005457217 60 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 60 12 and and CCONJ _005457217 60 13 all all PRON _005457217 60 14 of of ADP _005457217 60 15 the the DET _005457217 60 16 faiths faith NOUN _005457217 60 17 represented represent VERB _005457217 60 18 thereby thereby ADV _005457217 60 19 the the DET _005457217 60 20 f f X _005457217 60 21 r r NOUN _005457217 60 22 e e NOUN _005457217 60 23 e e NOUN _005457217 60 24 and and CCONJ _005457217 60 25 equal equal ADJ _005457217 60 26 use use NOUN _005457217 60 27 of of ADP _005457217 60 28 certain certain ADJ _005457217 60 29 rooms room NOUN _005457217 60 30 in in ADP _005457217 60 31 the the DET _005457217 60 32 school school NOUN _005457217 60 33 buildings building NOUN _005457217 60 34 while while SCONJ _005457217 60 35 they they PRON _005457217 60 36 were be AUX _005457217 60 37 not not PART _005457217 60 38 otherwise otherwise ADV _005457217 60 39 used use VERB _005457217 60 40 f f PROPN _005457217 60 41 o o X _005457217 60 42 r r NOUN _005457217 60 43 school school NOUN _005457217 60 44 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 60 45 during during ADP _005457217 60 46 the the DET _005457217 60 47 regular regular ADJ _005457217 60 48 school school NOUN _005457217 60 49 hours hour NOUN _005457217 60 50 between between ADP _005457217 60 51 nine nine NUM _005457217 60 52 a.m. a.m. NOUN _005457217 60 53 and and CCONJ _005457217 60 54 four four NUM _005457217 60 55 p.m. p.m. NOUN _005457217 61 1 p p NOUN _005457217 61 2 a a DET _005457217 61 3 r r NOUN _005457217 61 4 a a DET _005457217 61 5 g g NOUN _005457217 61 6 r r NOUN _005457217 61 7 a a DET _005457217 61 8 p p NOUN _005457217 61 9 h h NOUN _005457217 61 10 11 11 NUM _005457217 61 11 of of ADP _005457217 61 12 the the DET _005457217 61 13 petition petition NOUN _005457217 61 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 61 15 denied deny VERB _005457217 61 16 by by ADP _005457217 61 17 the the DET _005457217 61 18 answer answer NOUN _005457217 61 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 61 20 asserts assert VERB _005457217 61 21 that that SCONJ _005457217 61 22 instructors instructor NOUN _005457217 61 23 in in ADP _005457217 61 24 religious religious ADJ _005457217 61 25 education education NOUN _005457217 61 26 usurped usurp VERB _005457217 61 27 and and CCONJ _005457217 61 28 took take VERB _005457217 61 29 over over ADP _005457217 61 30 the the DET _005457217 61 31 use use NOUN _005457217 61 32 of of ADP _005457217 61 33 the the DET _005457217 61 34 said say VERB _005457217 61 35 school school NOUN _005457217 61 36 property property NOUN _005457217 61 37 f f PROPN _005457217 61 38 o o X _005457217 61 39 r r NOUN _005457217 61 40 religious religious ADJ _005457217 61 41 education education NOUN _005457217 61 42 of of ADP _005457217 61 43 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 61 44 , , PUNCT _005457217 61 45 and and CCONJ _005457217 61 46 for for ADP _005457217 61 47 a a DET _005457217 61 48 period period NOUN _005457217 61 49 of of ADP _005457217 61 50 thirty thirty NUM _005457217 61 51 minutes minute NOUN _005457217 61 52 during during ADP _005457217 61 53 the the DET _005457217 61 54 school school NOUN _005457217 61 55 day day NOUN _005457217 61 56 ousted oust VERB _005457217 61 57 the the DET _005457217 61 58 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 61 59 of of ADP _005457217 61 60 the the DET _005457217 61 61 secular secular ADJ _005457217 61 62 education education NOUN _005457217 61 63 provided provide VERB _005457217 61 64 by by ADP _005457217 61 65 law law NOUN _005457217 61 66 , , PUNCT _005457217 61 67 and and CCONJ _005457217 61 68 in in ADP _005457217 61 69 place place NOUN _005457217 61 70 thereof thereof ADV _005457217 61 71 substituted substitute VERB _005457217 61 72 religious religious ADJ _005457217 61 73 education education NOUN _005457217 61 74 . . PUNCT _005457217 62 1 the the DET _005457217 62 2 court court NOUN _005457217 62 3 finds find VERB _005457217 62 4 the the DET _005457217 62 5 facts fact NOUN _005457217 62 6 to to PART _005457217 62 7 be be AUX _005457217 62 8 that that SCONJ _005457217 62 9 instructors instructor NOUN _005457217 62 10 in in ADP _005457217 62 11 religious religious ADJ _005457217 62 12 education education NOUN _005457217 62 13 who who PRON _005457217 62 14 are be AUX _005457217 62 15 not not PART _005457217 62 16 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 62 17 or or CCONJ _005457217 62 18 employees employee NOUN _005457217 62 19 of of ADP _005457217 62 20 the the DET _005457217 62 21 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 62 22 school school NOUN _005457217 62 23 district district NOUN _005457217 62 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 62 25 but but CCONJ _005457217 62 26 who who PRON _005457217 62 27 are be AUX _005457217 62 28 selected select VERB _005457217 62 29 and and CCONJ _005457217 62 30 paid pay VERB _005457217 62 31 by by ADP _005457217 62 32 the the DET _005457217 62 33 council council NOUN _005457217 62 34 of of ADP _005457217 62 35 religious religious ADJ _005457217 62 36 education education NOUN _005457217 62 37 , , PUNCT _005457217 62 38 have have AUX _005457217 62 39 secured secure VERB _005457217 62 40 permission permission NOUN _005457217 62 41 to to PART _005457217 62 42 come come VERB _005457217 62 43 into into ADP _005457217 62 44 the the DET _005457217 62 45 several several ADJ _005457217 62 46 grade grade NOUN _005457217 62 47 schools school NOUN _005457217 62 48 and and CCONJ _005457217 62 49 into into ADP _005457217 62 50 the the DET _005457217 62 51 junior junior ADJ _005457217 62 52 high high ADJ _005457217 62 53 school school NOUN _005457217 62 54 of of ADP _005457217 62 55 the the DET _005457217 62 56 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 62 57 district district NOUN _005457217 62 58 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 62 59 that that SCONJ _005457217 62 60 between between ADP _005457217 62 61 the the DET _005457217 62 62 hours hour NOUN _005457217 62 63 of of ADP _005457217 62 64 nine nine NUM _005457217 62 65 a.m. a.m. NOUN _005457217 62 66 and and CCONJ _005457217 62 67 four four NUM _005457217 62 68 p.m. p.m. NOUN _005457217 62 69 , , PUNCT _005457217 62 70 the the DET _005457217 62 71 regular regular ADJ _005457217 62 72 school school NOUN _005457217 62 73 hours hour NOUN _005457217 62 74 of of ADP _005457217 62 75 the the DET _005457217 62 76 school school NOUN _005457217 62 77 children child NOUN _005457217 62 78 , , PUNCT _005457217 62 79 those those DET _005457217 62 80 students student NOUN _005457217 62 81 who who PRON _005457217 62 82 have have AUX _005457217 62 83 obtained obtain VERB _005457217 62 84 the the DET _005457217 62 85 written write VERB _005457217 62 86 consent consent NOUN _005457217 62 87 of of ADP _005457217 62 88 their their PRON _005457217 62 89 parents parent NOUN _005457217 62 90 therefor therefor NOUN _005457217 62 91 are be AUX _005457217 62 92 released release VERB _005457217 62 93 by by ADP _005457217 62 94 the the DET _005457217 62 95 school school NOUN _005457217 62 96 authorities authority NOUN _005457217 62 97 from from ADP _005457217 62 98 their their PRON _005457217 62 99 secular secular ADJ _005457217 62 100 work work NOUN _005457217 62 101 , , PUNCT _005457217 62 102 and and CCONJ _005457217 62 103 in in ADP _005457217 62 104 the the DET _005457217 62 105 grade grade NOUN _005457217 62 106 schools school NOUN _005457217 62 107 for for ADP _005457217 62 108 a a DET _005457217 62 109 period period NOUN _005457217 62 110 of of ADP _005457217 62 111 thirty thirty NUM _005457217 62 112 minutes minute NOUN _005457217 62 113 ' ' PART _005457217 62 114 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 62 115 in in ADP _005457217 62 116 each each DET _005457217 62 117 week week NOUN _005457217 62 118 during during SCONJ _005457217 62 119 said say VERB _005457217 62 120 school school NOUN _005457217 62 121 hours hour NOUN _005457217 62 122 , , PUNCT _005457217 62 123 and and CCONJ _005457217 62 124 forty forty NUM _005457217 62 125 - - PUNCT _005457217 62 126 five five NUM _005457217 62 127 minutes minute NOUN _005457217 62 128 during during ADP _005457217 62 129 each each DET _005457217 62 130 week week NOUN _005457217 62 131 in in ADP _005457217 62 132 the the DET _005457217 62 133 junior junior ADJ _005457217 62 134 high high ADJ _005457217 62 135 school school NOUN _005457217 62 136 , , PUNCT _005457217 62 137 receive receive VERB _005457217 62 138 training training NOUN _005457217 62 139 in in ADP _005457217 62 140 religious religious ADJ _005457217 62 141 education education NOUN _005457217 62 142 . . PUNCT _005457217 63 1 in in ADP _005457217 63 2 the the DET _005457217 63 3 grade grade NOUN _005457217 63 4 schools school NOUN _005457217 63 5 such such ADJ _005457217 63 6 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 63 7 in in ADP _005457217 63 8 religious religious ADJ _005457217 63 9 education education NOUN _005457217 63 10 was be AUX _005457217 63 11 given give VERB _005457217 63 12 in in ADP _005457217 63 13 the the DET _005457217 63 14 fourth fourth ADJ _005457217 63 15 to to ADP _005457217 63 16 sixth sixth ADJ _005457217 63 17 grades grade NOUN _005457217 63 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 63 19 inclusive inclusive ADJ _005457217 63 20 , , PUNCT _005457217 63 21 and and CCONJ _005457217 63 22 in in ADP _005457217 63 23 the the DET _005457217 63 24 junior junior ADJ _005457217 63 25 high high ADJ _005457217 63 26 school school NOUN _005457217 63 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 63 28 which which PRON _005457217 63 29 includes include VERB _005457217 63 30 what what PRON _005457217 63 31 would would AUX _005457217 63 32 ordinarily ordinarily ADV _005457217 63 33 be be AUX _005457217 63 34 called call VERB _005457217 63 35 the the DET _005457217 63 36 seventh seventh ADJ _005457217 63 37 to to ADP _005457217 63 38 ninth ninth ADJ _005457217 63 39 grades grade NOUN _005457217 63 40 inclusive inclusive ADJ _005457217 63 41 . . PUNCT _005457217 64 1 the the DET _005457217 64 2 facts fact NOUN _005457217 64 3 show show VERB _005457217 64 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 64 5 in in ADP _005457217 64 6 the the DET _005457217 64 7 grade grade NOUN _005457217 64 8 schools school NOUN _005457217 64 9 the the DET _005457217 64 10 religious religious ADJ _005457217 64 11 education education NOUN _005457217 64 12 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 64 13 was be AUX _005457217 64 14 done do VERB _005457217 64 15 by by ADP _005457217 64 16 a a DET _005457217 64 17 miss miss PROPN _005457217 64 18 mae mae PROPN _005457217 64 19 chapin chapin NOUN _005457217 64 20 , , PUNCT _005457217 64 21 a a DET _005457217 64 22 former former ADJ _005457217 64 23 presbyterian presbyterian ADJ _005457217 64 24 missionary missionary NOUN _005457217 64 25 to to ADP _005457217 64 26 china china PROPN _005457217 64 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 64 28 and and CCONJ _005457217 64 29 in in ADP _005457217 64 30 the the DET _005457217 64 31 philippines philippine NOUN _005457217 64 32 , , PUNCT _005457217 64 33 where where SCONJ _005457217 64 34 she she PRON _005457217 64 35 taught teach VERB _005457217 64 36 mission mission NOUN _005457217 64 37 schools school NOUN _005457217 64 38 . . PUNCT _005457217 65 1 the the DET _005457217 65 2 other other ADJ _005457217 65 3 instructor instructor NOUN _005457217 65 4 in in ADP _005457217 65 5 the the DET _005457217 65 6 grade grade NOUN _005457217 65 7 schools school NOUN _005457217 65 8 was be AUX _005457217 65 9 a a DET _005457217 65 10 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 65 11 . . PROPN _005457217 65 12 jorgensen jorgensen PROPN _005457217 65 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 65 14 a a DET _005457217 65 15 former former ADJ _005457217 65 16 public public ADJ _005457217 65 17 school school NOUN _005457217 65 18 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 65 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 66 1 both both PRON _005457217 66 2 of of ADP _005457217 66 3 these these DET _005457217 66 4 religious religious ADJ _005457217 66 5 education education NOUN _005457217 66 6 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 66 7 are be AUX _005457217 66 8 protestants protestant NOUN _005457217 66 9 and and CCONJ _005457217 66 10 teach teach VERB _005457217 66 11 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 66 12 classes class NOUN _005457217 66 13 . . PUNCT _005457217 67 1 by by ADP _005457217 67 2 arrangement arrangement NOUN _005457217 67 3 with with ADP _005457217 67 4 the the DET _005457217 67 5 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 67 6 district district NOUN _005457217 67 7 5 5 NUM _005457217 67 8 they they PRON _005457217 67 9 were be AUX _005457217 67 10 given give VERB _005457217 67 11 thirty thirty NUM _005457217 67 12 minutes minute NOUN _005457217 67 13 in in ADP _005457217 67 14 each each PRON _005457217 67 15 of of ADP _005457217 67 16 the the DET _005457217 67 17 fourth fourth ADJ _005457217 67 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 67 19 fifth fifth ADJ _005457217 67 20 and and CCONJ _005457217 67 21 sixth sixth ADJ _005457217 67 22 grade grade NOUN _005457217 67 23 classes class NOUN _005457217 67 24 in in ADP _005457217 67 25 the the DET _005457217 67 26 grade grade NOUN _005457217 67 27 schools school NOUN _005457217 67 28 once once ADV _005457217 67 29 a a DET _005457217 67 30 week week NOUN _005457217 67 31 to to PART _005457217 67 32 teach teach VERB _005457217 67 33 religious religious ADJ _005457217 67 34 education education NOUN _005457217 67 35 . . PUNCT _005457217 68 1 i i PRON _005457217 68 2 n n VERB _005457217 68 3 the the DET _005457217 68 4 junior junior ADJ _005457217 68 5 high high ADJ _005457217 68 6 school school NOUN _005457217 68 7 and and CCONJ _005457217 68 8 in in ADP _005457217 68 9 certain certain ADJ _005457217 68 10 grade grade NOUN _005457217 68 11 schools school NOUN _005457217 68 12 the the DET _005457217 68 13 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 68 14 classes class NOUN _005457217 68 15 are be AUX _005457217 68 16 held hold VERB _005457217 68 17 once once ADV _005457217 68 18 a a DET _005457217 68 19 week week NOUN _005457217 68 20 . . PUNCT _005457217 69 1 the the DET _005457217 69 2 record record NOUN _005457217 69 3 shows show VERB _005457217 69 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 69 5 formerly formerly ADV _005457217 69 6 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 69 7 classes class NOUN _005457217 69 8 were be AUX _005457217 69 9 held hold VERB _005457217 69 10 under under ADP _005457217 69 11 the the DET _005457217 69 12 supervision supervision NOUN _005457217 69 13 of of ADP _005457217 69 14 the the DET _005457217 69 15 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 69 16 church church NOUN _005457217 69 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 69 18 but but CCONJ _005457217 69 19 that that SCONJ _005457217 69 20 no no DET _005457217 69 21 classes class NOUN _005457217 69 22 have have AUX _005457217 69 23 been be AUX _005457217 69 24 held hold VERB _005457217 69 25 by by ADP _005457217 69 26 the the DET _005457217 69 27 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 69 28 faith faith NOUN _005457217 69 29 during during ADP _005457217 69 30 the the DET _005457217 69 31 last last ADJ _005457217 69 32 couple couple NOUN _005457217 69 33 of of ADP _005457217 69 34 years year NOUN _005457217 69 35 . . PUNCT _005457217 70 1 i i PRON _005457217 70 2 n n ADV _005457217 70 3 all all PRON _005457217 70 4 of of ADP _005457217 70 5 the the DET _005457217 70 6 schools school NOUN _005457217 70 7 the the DET _005457217 70 8 arrangements arrangement NOUN _005457217 70 9 are be AUX _005457217 70 10 about about ADV _005457217 70 11 as as SCONJ _005457217 70 12 follows follow VERB _005457217 70 13 : : PUNCT _005457217 70 14 if if SCONJ _005457217 70 15 a a DET _005457217 70 16 majority majority NOUN _005457217 70 17 of of ADP _005457217 70 18 the the DET _005457217 70 19 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 70 20 in in ADP _005457217 70 21 the the DET _005457217 70 22 class class NOUN _005457217 70 23 have have AUX _005457217 70 24 signed sign VERB _005457217 70 25 up up ADP _005457217 70 26 with with ADP _005457217 70 27 their their PRON _005457217 70 28 p p NOUN _005457217 70 29 a a DET _005457217 70 30 r r NOUN _005457217 70 31 e e NOUN _005457217 70 32 n n ADP _005457217 70 33 t t PROPN _005457217 70 34 s s PART _005457217 70 35 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 70 36 consent consent NOUN _005457217 70 37 to to PART _005457217 70 38 take take VERB _005457217 70 39 religious religious ADJ _005457217 70 40 education education NOUN _005457217 70 41 at at ADP _005457217 70 42 the the DET _005457217 70 43 beginning beginning NOUN _005457217 70 44 of of ADP _005457217 70 45 the the DET _005457217 70 46 class class NOUN _005457217 70 47 period period NOUN _005457217 70 48 the the DET _005457217 70 49 secular secular ADJ _005457217 70 50 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 70 51 leaves leave VERB _005457217 70 52 the the DET _005457217 70 53 room room NOUN _005457217 70 54 and and CCONJ _005457217 70 55 takes take VERB _005457217 70 56 with with ADP _005457217 70 57 her she PRON _005457217 70 58 the the DET _005457217 70 59 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 70 60 whose whose DET _005457217 70 61 parents parent NOUN _005457217 70 62 have have AUX _005457217 70 63 not not PART _005457217 70 64 requested request VERB _005457217 70 65 such such ADJ _005457217 70 66 religious religious ADJ _005457217 70 67 education education NOUN _005457217 70 68 , , PUNCT _005457217 70 69 to to ADP _005457217 70 70 an an DET _005457217 70 71 extra extra ADJ _005457217 70 72 room room NOUN _005457217 70 73 where where SCONJ _005457217 70 74 the the DET _005457217 70 75 students student NOUN _005457217 70 76 study study VERB _005457217 70 77 under under ADP _005457217 70 78 her her PRON _005457217 70 79 supervision supervision NOUN _005457217 70 80 while while SCONJ _005457217 70 81 religious religious ADJ _005457217 70 82 education education NOUN _005457217 70 83 students student NOUN _005457217 70 84 pursue pursue VERB _005457217 70 85 their their PRON _005457217 70 86 studies study NOUN _005457217 70 87 under under ADP _005457217 70 88 the the DET _005457217 70 89 religious religious ADJ _005457217 70 90 education education NOUN _005457217 70 91 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 70 92 . . PUNCT _005457217 71 1 in in ADP _005457217 71 2 the the DET _005457217 71 3 case case NOUN _005457217 71 4 of of ADP _005457217 71 5 the the DET _005457217 71 6 relator relator NOUN _005457217 71 7 's 's PART _005457217 71 8 son son NOUN _005457217 71 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 71 10 james james PROPN _005457217 71 11 terry terry PROPN _005457217 71 12 mccollurn mccollurn PROPN _005457217 71 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 71 14 who who PRON _005457217 71 15 attended attend VERB _005457217 71 16 the the DET _005457217 71 17 fifth fifth ADJ _005457217 71 18 grade grade NOUN _005457217 71 19 at at ADP _005457217 71 20 the the DET _005457217 71 21 dr dr PROPN _005457217 71 22 . . PROPN _005457217 71 23 howard howard PROPN _005457217 71 24 school school PROPN _005457217 71 25 last last ADJ _005457217 71 26 year year NOUN _005457217 71 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 71 28 in in ADP _005457217 71 29 the the DET _005457217 71 30 first first ADJ _005457217 71 31 semester semester NOUN _005457217 71 32 , , PUNCT _005457217 71 33 only only ADV _005457217 71 34 he he PRON _005457217 71 35 and and CCONJ _005457217 71 36 a a DET _005457217 71 37 boy boy NOUN _005457217 71 38 named name VERB _005457217 71 39 elwin elwin PROPN _005457217 71 40 miller miller NOUN _005457217 71 41 did do AUX _005457217 71 42 not not PART _005457217 71 43 sign sign VERB _005457217 71 44 up up ADP _005457217 71 45 for for ADP _005457217 71 46 the the DET _005457217 71 47 religious religious ADJ _005457217 71 48 education education NOUN _005457217 71 49 courses course NOUN _005457217 71 50 . . PUNCT _005457217 72 1 they they PRON _005457217 72 2 left leave VERB _005457217 72 3 the the DET _005457217 72 4 room room NOUN _005457217 72 5 at at ADP _005457217 72 6 nine nine NUM _005457217 72 7 o'clock o'clock NOUN _005457217 72 8 in in ADP _005457217 72 9 the the DET _005457217 72 10 morning morning NOUN _005457217 72 11 and and CCONJ _005457217 72 12 went go VERB _005457217 72 13 to to ADP _005457217 72 14 a a DET _005457217 72 15 music music NOUN _005457217 72 16 room room NOUN _005457217 72 17 to to PART _005457217 72 18 study study VERB _005457217 72 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 72 20 under under ADP _005457217 72 21 the the DET _005457217 72 22 supervision supervision NOUN _005457217 72 23 of of ADP _005457217 72 24 their their PRON _005457217 72 25 secular secular ADJ _005457217 72 26 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 72 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 72 28 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 72 29 . . PROPN _005457217 72 30 bessie bessie PROPN _005457217 72 31 taylor taylor PROPN _005457217 72 32 . . PUNCT _005457217 73 1 at at ADP _005457217 73 2 the the DET _005457217 73 3 conclusion conclusion NOUN _005457217 73 4 of of ADP _005457217 73 5 the the DET _005457217 73 6 thirty thirty NUM _005457217 73 7 - - PUNCT _005457217 73 8 minute minute NOUN _005457217 73 9 period period NOUN _005457217 73 10 they they PRON _005457217 73 11 returned return VERB _005457217 73 12 to to ADP _005457217 73 13 their their PRON _005457217 73 14 fifth fifth ADJ _005457217 73 15 grade grade NOUN _005457217 73 16 class class NOUN _005457217 73 17 room room NOUN _005457217 73 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 73 19 and and CCONJ _005457217 73 20 with with ADP _005457217 73 21 the the DET _005457217 73 22 remainder remainder NOUN _005457217 73 23 of of ADP _005457217 73 24 their their PRON _005457217 73 25 class class NOUN _005457217 73 26 studied study VERB _005457217 73 27 their their PRON _005457217 73 28 regular regular ADJ _005457217 73 29 secular secular ADJ _005457217 73 30 subjects subject NOUN _005457217 73 31 . . PUNCT _005457217 74 1 i i PRON _005457217 74 2 n n VERB _005457217 74 3 those those DET _005457217 74 4 rooms room NOUN _005457217 74 5 where where SCONJ _005457217 74 6 a a DET _005457217 74 7 majority majority NOUN _005457217 74 8 of of ADP _005457217 74 9 the the DET _005457217 74 10 students student NOUN _005457217 74 11 had have AUX _005457217 74 12 not not PART _005457217 74 13 signed sign VERB _005457217 74 14 up up ADP _005457217 74 15 f f PROPN _005457217 74 16 o o X _005457217 74 17 r r NOUN _005457217 74 18 religious religious ADJ _005457217 74 19 education education NOUN _005457217 74 20 , , PUNCT _005457217 74 21 the the DET _005457217 74 22 religious religious ADJ _005457217 74 23 education education NOUN _005457217 74 24 group group NOUN _005457217 74 25 left leave VERB _005457217 74 26 the the DET _005457217 74 27 room room NOUN _005457217 74 28 and and CCONJ _005457217 74 29 went go VERB _005457217 74 30 to to ADP _005457217 74 31 a a DET _005457217 74 32 music music NOUN _005457217 74 33 room room NOUN _005457217 74 34 or or CCONJ _005457217 74 35 other other ADJ _005457217 74 36 extra extra ADJ _005457217 74 37 class class NOUN _005457217 74 38 room room NOUN _005457217 74 39 , , PUNCT _005457217 74 40 and and CCONJ _005457217 74 41 pursued pursue VERB _005457217 74 42 their their PRON _005457217 74 43 religious religious ADJ _005457217 74 44 education education NOUN _005457217 74 45 studies study NOUN _005457217 74 46 in in ADP _005457217 74 47 the the DET _005457217 74 48 same same ADJ _005457217 74 49 way way NOUN _005457217 74 50 , , PUNCT _005457217 74 51 while while SCONJ _005457217 74 52 the the DET _005457217 74 53 majority majority NOUN _005457217 74 54 of of ADP _005457217 74 55 those those DET _005457217 74 56 classes class NOUN _005457217 74 57 who who PRON _005457217 74 58 did do AUX _005457217 74 59 not not PART _005457217 74 60 take take VERB _005457217 74 61 religious religious ADJ _005457217 74 62 education education NOUN _005457217 74 63 remained remain VERB _005457217 74 64 under under ADP _005457217 74 65 the the DET _005457217 74 66 supervision supervision NOUN _005457217 74 67 of of ADP _005457217 74 68 their their PRON _005457217 74 69 reg6 reg6 ADJ _005457217 74 70 ular ular ADJ _005457217 74 71 secular secular ADJ _005457217 74 72 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 74 73 , , PUNCT _005457217 74 74 preparing prepare VERB _005457217 74 75 their their PRON _005457217 74 76 lessons lesson NOUN _005457217 74 77 until until ADP _005457217 74 78 the the DET _005457217 74 79 return return NOUN _005457217 74 80 of of ADP _005457217 74 81 the the DET _005457217 74 82 group group NOUN _005457217 74 83 that that PRON _005457217 74 84 had have AUX _005457217 74 85 been be AUX _005457217 74 86 excused excuse VERB _005457217 74 87 to to PART _005457217 74 88 take take VERB _005457217 74 89 the the DET _005457217 74 90 religious religious ADJ _005457217 74 91 courses course NOUN _005457217 74 92 . . PUNCT _005457217 75 1 i i PRON _005457217 75 2 n n VERB _005457217 75 3 the the DET _005457217 75 4 second second ADJ _005457217 75 5 semester semester NOUN _005457217 75 6 james james PROPN _005457217 75 7 terry terry PROPN _005457217 75 8 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 75 9 was be AUX _005457217 75 10 the the DET _005457217 75 11 only only ADJ _005457217 75 12 child child NOUN _005457217 75 13 in in ADP _005457217 75 14 his his PRON _005457217 75 15 room room NOUN _005457217 75 16 who who PRON _005457217 75 17 did do AUX _005457217 75 18 not not PART _005457217 75 19 take take VERB _005457217 75 20 religious religious ADJ _005457217 75 21 education education NOUN _005457217 75 22 . . PUNCT _005457217 76 1 he he PRON _005457217 76 2 went go VERB _005457217 76 3 out out ADP _005457217 76 4 to to PART _005457217 76 5 study study VERB _005457217 76 6 alone alone ADV _005457217 76 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 76 8 or or CCONJ _005457217 76 9 attended attend VERB _005457217 76 10 another another DET _005457217 76 11 fifth fifth ADJ _005457217 76 12 grade grade NOUN _005457217 76 13 class class NOUN _005457217 76 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 76 15 as as SCONJ _005457217 76 16 hereinafter hereinafter NOUN _005457217 76 17 more more ADV _005457217 76 18 fully fully ADV _005457217 76 19 referred refer VERB _005457217 76 20 to to ADP _005457217 76 21 . . PUNCT _005457217 77 1 what what PRON _005457217 77 2 it it PRON _005457217 77 3 all all PRON _005457217 77 4 amounts amount VERB _005457217 77 5 to to ADP _005457217 77 6 is be AUX _005457217 77 7 that that SCONJ _005457217 77 8 the the DET _005457217 77 9 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 77 10 who who PRON _005457217 77 11 take take VERB _005457217 77 12 religious religious ADJ _005457217 77 13 education education NOUN _005457217 77 14 use use VERB _005457217 77 15 a a DET _005457217 77 16 thirty thirty NUM _005457217 77 17 - - PUNCT _005457217 77 18 minute minute NOUN _005457217 77 19 study study NOUN _005457217 77 20 period period NOUN _005457217 77 21 which which PRON _005457217 77 22 otherwise otherwise ADV _005457217 77 23 would would AUX _005457217 77 24 have have AUX _005457217 77 25 been be AUX _005457217 77 26 devoted devote VERB _005457217 77 27 to to PART _005457217 77 28 study study VERB _005457217 77 29 f f X _005457217 78 1 o o X _005457217 78 2 r r NOUN _005457217 78 3 recitation recitation NOUN _005457217 78 4 in in ADP _005457217 78 5 their their PRON _005457217 78 6 regular regular ADJ _005457217 78 7 lessons lesson NOUN _005457217 78 8 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 78 9 that that SCONJ _005457217 78 10 on on ADP _005457217 78 11 this this DET _005457217 78 12 released release VERB _005457217 78 13 time time NOUN _005457217 78 14 they they PRON _005457217 78 15 study study VERB _005457217 78 16 religious religious ADJ _005457217 78 17 education education NOUN _005457217 78 18 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 78 19 while while SCONJ _005457217 78 20 those those PRON _005457217 78 21 who who PRON _005457217 78 22 do do AUX _005457217 78 23 not not PART _005457217 78 24 take take VERB _005457217 78 25 religious religious ADJ _005457217 78 26 education education NOUN _005457217 78 27 simply simply ADV _005457217 78 28 have have VERB _005457217 78 29 a a DET _005457217 78 30 thirtyminute thirtyminute NOUN _005457217 78 31 study study NOUN _005457217 78 32 period period NOUN _005457217 78 33 while while SCONJ _005457217 78 34 waiting wait VERB _005457217 78 35 f f PROPN _005457217 79 1 o o X _005457217 79 2 r r VERB _005457217 79 3 the the DET _005457217 79 4 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 79 5 in in ADP _005457217 79 6 religious religious ADJ _005457217 79 7 education education NOUN _005457217 79 8 classes class NOUN _005457217 79 9 to to PART _005457217 79 10 rejoin rejoin VERB _005457217 79 11 them they PRON _005457217 79 12 for for ADP _005457217 79 13 the the DET _005457217 79 14 regular regular ADJ _005457217 79 15 secular secular ADJ _005457217 79 16 studies study NOUN _005457217 79 17 . . PUNCT _005457217 79 18 " " PUNCT _005457217 80 1 occasionally occasionally ADV _005457217 80 2 the the DET _005457217 80 3 secular secular ADJ _005457217 80 4 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 80 5 remains remain VERB _005457217 80 6 in in ADP _005457217 80 7 the the DET _005457217 80 8 religious religious ADJ _005457217 80 9 education education NOUN _005457217 80 10 class class NOUN _005457217 80 11 room room NOUN _005457217 80 12 but but CCONJ _005457217 80 13 takes take VERB _005457217 80 14 no no DET _005457217 80 15 p p NOUN _005457217 80 16 a a DET _005457217 80 17 r r NOUN _005457217 80 18 t t NOUN _005457217 80 19 whatever whatever PRON _005457217 80 20 in in ADP _005457217 80 21 the the DET _005457217 80 22 religious religious ADJ _005457217 80 23 education education NOUN _005457217 80 24 . . PUNCT _005457217 81 1 most most ADJ _005457217 81 2 of of ADP _005457217 81 3 the the DET _005457217 81 4 time time NOUN _005457217 81 5 she she PRON _005457217 81 6 is be AUX _005457217 81 7 with with ADP _005457217 81 8 the the DET _005457217 81 9 group group NOUN _005457217 81 10 who who PRON _005457217 81 11 do do AUX _005457217 81 12 not not PART _005457217 81 13 take take VERB _005457217 81 14 religious religious ADJ _005457217 81 15 education education NOUN _005457217 81 16 and and CCONJ _005457217 81 17 supervises supervise VERB _005457217 81 18 their their PRON _005457217 81 19 study study NOUN _005457217 81 20 . . PUNCT _005457217 82 1 at at ADP _005457217 82 2 all all DET _005457217 82 3 times time NOUN _005457217 82 4 the the DET _005457217 82 5 secular secular ADJ _005457217 82 6 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 82 7 is be AUX _005457217 82 8 supervising supervise VERB _005457217 82 9 the the DET _005457217 82 10 study study NOUN _005457217 82 11 of of ADP _005457217 82 12 those those PRON _005457217 82 13 who who PRON _005457217 82 14 do do AUX _005457217 82 15 not not PART _005457217 82 16 take take VERB _005457217 82 17 religious religious ADJ _005457217 82 18 education education NOUN _005457217 82 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 83 1 i i PRON _005457217 83 2 t t PROPN _005457217 83 3 is be AUX _005457217 83 4 undisputed undisputed ADJ _005457217 83 5 in in ADP _005457217 83 6 the the DET _005457217 83 7 pleadings pleading NOUN _005457217 83 8 that that PRON _005457217 83 9 pupils pupil VERB _005457217 83 10 receiving receive VERB _005457217 83 11 written write VERB _005457217 83 12 permission permission NOUN _005457217 83 13 of of ADP _005457217 83 14 their their PRON _005457217 83 15 parents parent NOUN _005457217 83 16 to to PART _005457217 83 17 attend attend VERB _005457217 83 18 the the DET _005457217 83 19 classes class NOUN _005457217 83 20 in in ADP _005457217 83 21 religious religious ADJ _005457217 83 22 education education NOUN _005457217 83 23 are be AUX _005457217 83 24 welcomed welcome VERB _005457217 83 25 into into ADP _005457217 83 26 the the DET _005457217 83 27 classes class NOUN _005457217 83 28 and and CCONJ _005457217 83 29 are be AUX _005457217 83 30 received receive VERB _005457217 83 31 by by ADP _005457217 83 32 the the DET _005457217 83 33 instructor instructor NOUN _005457217 83 34 , , PUNCT _005457217 83 35 regardless regardless ADV _005457217 83 36 of of ADP _005457217 83 37 denomination denomination NOUN _005457217 83 38 , , PUNCT _005457217 83 39 affiliation affiliation NOUN _005457217 83 40 , , PUNCT _005457217 83 41 or or CCONJ _005457217 83 42 lack lack NOUN _005457217 83 43 of of ADP _005457217 83 44 affiliation affiliation NOUN _005457217 83 45 , , PUNCT _005457217 83 46 of of ADP _005457217 83 47 the the DET _005457217 83 48 parents parent NOUN _005457217 83 49 of of ADP _005457217 83 50 such such ADJ _005457217 83 51 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 83 52 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 83 53 that that SCONJ _005457217 83 54 the the DET _005457217 83 55 instructors instructor NOUN _005457217 83 56 give give VERB _005457217 83 57 their their PRON _005457217 83 58 religious religious ADJ _005457217 83 59 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 83 60 in in ADP _005457217 83 61 a a DET _005457217 83 62 friendly friendly ADJ _005457217 83 63 manner manner NOUN _005457217 83 64 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 83 65 that that SCONJ _005457217 83 66 the the DET _005457217 83 67 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 83 68 become become VERB _005457217 83 69 attracted attract VERB _005457217 83 70 thereto thereto ADJ _005457217 83 71 and and CCONJ _005457217 83 72 desire desire NOUN _005457217 83 73 to to PART _005457217 83 74 participate participate VERB _005457217 83 75 therein therein ADV _005457217 83 76 . . PUNCT _005457217 84 1 the the DET _005457217 84 2 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 84 3 does do AUX _005457217 84 4 not not PART _005457217 84 5 sustain sustain VERB _005457217 84 6 relator relator NOUN _005457217 84 7 's 's PART _005457217 84 8 charge charge NOUN _005457217 84 9 that that SCONJ _005457217 84 10 the the DET _005457217 84 11 interest interest NOUN _005457217 84 12 and and CCONJ _005457217 84 13 attention attention NOUN _005457217 84 14 of of ADP _005457217 84 15 such such ADJ _005457217 84 16 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 84 17 is be AUX _005457217 84 18 wrongly wrongly ADV _005457217 84 19 diverted divert VERB _005457217 84 20 from from ADP _005457217 84 21 their their PRON _005457217 84 22 regular regular ADJ _005457217 84 23 secular secular ADJ _005457217 84 24 and and CCONJ _005457217 84 25 lawful lawful ADJ _005457217 84 26 studies study NOUN _005457217 84 27 in in ADP _005457217 84 28 the the DET _005457217 84 29 schools school NOUN _005457217 84 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 84 31 but but CCONJ _005457217 84 32 on on ADP _005457217 84 33 the the DET _005457217 84 34 contrary contrary NOUN _005457217 84 35 , , PUNCT _005457217 84 36 the the DET _005457217 84 37 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 84 38 shows show VERB _005457217 84 39 7 7 NUM _005457217 84 40 that that SCONJ _005457217 84 41 the the DET _005457217 84 42 courses course NOUN _005457217 84 43 in in ADP _005457217 84 44 religious religious ADJ _005457217 84 45 education education NOUN _005457217 84 46 are be AUX _005457217 84 47 similar similar ADJ _005457217 84 48 to to ADP _005457217 84 49 the the DET _005457217 84 50 extracurricular extracurricular ADJ _005457217 84 51 activities activity NOUN _005457217 84 52 , , PUNCT _005457217 84 53 such such ADJ _005457217 84 54 as as ADP _005457217 84 55 music music NOUN _005457217 84 56 and and CCONJ _005457217 84 57 art art NOUN _005457217 84 58 , , PUNCT _005457217 84 59 which which PRON _005457217 84 60 are be AUX _005457217 84 61 taken take VERB _005457217 84 62 with with ADP _005457217 84 63 the the DET _005457217 84 64 p p NOUN _005457217 84 65 a a DET _005457217 84 66 r r NOUN _005457217 84 67 e e NOUN _005457217 84 68 n n ADP _005457217 84 69 t t PROPN _005457217 84 70 s s PART _005457217 84 71 ' ' PART _005457217 84 72 permission permission NOUN _005457217 84 73 in in ADP _005457217 84 74 so so ADV _005457217 84 75 many many ADJ _005457217 84 76 of of ADP _005457217 84 77 our our PRON _005457217 84 78 public public ADJ _005457217 84 79 schools school NOUN _005457217 84 80 today today NOUN _005457217 84 81 . . PUNCT _005457217 85 1 the the DET _005457217 85 2 relator relator NOUN _005457217 85 3 's 's PART _005457217 85 4 son son NOUN _005457217 85 5 , , PUNCT _005457217 85 6 james james PROPN _005457217 85 7 terry terry PROPN _005457217 85 8 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 85 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 85 10 took take VERB _005457217 85 11 the the DET _005457217 85 12 religious religious ADJ _005457217 85 13 education education NOUN _005457217 85 14 courses course NOUN _005457217 86 1 f f PROPN _005457217 86 2 o o X _005457217 86 3 r r NOUN _005457217 86 4 one one NUM _005457217 86 5 semester semester NOUN _005457217 86 6 in in ADP _005457217 86 7 the the DET _005457217 86 8 fourth fourth ADJ _005457217 86 9 grade grade NOUN _005457217 86 10 at at ADP _005457217 86 11 the the DET _005457217 86 12 south south ADJ _005457217 86 13 side side NOUN _005457217 86 14 school school NOUN _005457217 86 15 . . PUNCT _005457217 87 1 there there PRON _005457217 87 2 is be VERB _005457217 87 3 no no DET _005457217 87 4 proof proof NOUN _005457217 87 5 in in ADP _005457217 87 6 the the DET _005457217 87 7 case case NOUN _005457217 87 8 that that SCONJ _005457217 87 9 his his PRON _005457217 87 10 work work NOUN _005457217 87 11 in in ADP _005457217 87 12 his his PRON _005457217 87 13 other other ADJ _005457217 87 14 studies study NOUN _005457217 87 15 suffered suffer VERB _005457217 87 16 because because SCONJ _005457217 87 17 of of ADP _005457217 87 18 this this PRON _005457217 87 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 88 1 a a DET _005457217 88 2 large large ADJ _005457217 88 3 number number NOUN _005457217 88 4 of of ADP _005457217 88 5 young young ADJ _005457217 88 6 people people NOUN _005457217 88 7 from from ADP _005457217 88 8 the the DET _005457217 88 9 different different ADJ _005457217 88 10 grade grade NOUN _005457217 88 11 schools school NOUN _005457217 88 12 who who PRON _005457217 88 13 had have AUX _005457217 88 14 taken take VERB _005457217 88 15 these these DET _005457217 88 16 courses course NOUN _005457217 88 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 88 18 and and CCONJ _005457217 88 19 quite quite DET _005457217 88 20 a a DET _005457217 88 21 number number NOUN _005457217 88 22 of of ADP _005457217 88 23 other other ADJ _005457217 88 24 young young ADJ _005457217 88 25 people people NOUN _005457217 88 26 who who PRON _005457217 88 27 had have AUX _005457217 88 28 not not PART _005457217 88 29 taken take VERB _005457217 88 30 religious religious ADJ _005457217 88 31 education education NOUN _005457217 88 32 courses course NOUN _005457217 88 33 all all PRON _005457217 88 34 testified testify VERB _005457217 88 35 in in ADP _005457217 88 36 court court NOUN _005457217 88 37 . . PUNCT _005457217 89 1 their their PRON _005457217 89 2 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 89 3 shows show VERB _005457217 89 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 89 5 the the DET _005457217 89 6 religious religious ADJ _005457217 89 7 education education NOUN _005457217 89 8 courses course NOUN _005457217 89 9 did do AUX _005457217 89 10 not not PART _005457217 89 11 adversely adversely ADV _005457217 89 12 affect affect VERB _005457217 89 13 their their PRON _005457217 89 14 other other ADJ _005457217 89 15 secular secular ADJ _005457217 89 16 studies study NOUN _005457217 89 17 . . PUNCT _005457217 90 1 the the DET _005457217 90 2 petition petition NOUN _005457217 90 3 charges charge VERB _005457217 90 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 90 5 the the DET _005457217 90 6 children child NOUN _005457217 90 7 harass harass VERB _005457217 90 8 and and CCONJ _005457217 90 9 annoy annoy VERB _005457217 90 10 their their PRON _005457217 90 11 parents parent NOUN _005457217 90 12 to to PART _005457217 90 13 take take VERB _005457217 90 14 religious religious ADJ _005457217 90 15 education education NOUN _005457217 90 16 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 90 17 that that SCONJ _005457217 90 18 the the DET _005457217 90 19 ultimate ultimate ADJ _005457217 90 20 effect effect NOUN _005457217 90 21 of of ADP _005457217 90 22 these these DET _005457217 90 23 courses course NOUN _005457217 90 24 is be AUX _005457217 90 25 to to PART _005457217 90 26 establish establish VERB _005457217 90 27 in in ADP _005457217 90 28 the the DET _005457217 90 29 minds mind NOUN _005457217 90 30 of of ADP _005457217 90 31 these these DET _005457217 90 32 children child NOUN _005457217 90 33 a a DET _005457217 90 34 knowledge knowledge NOUN _005457217 90 35 , , PUNCT _005457217 90 36 interest interest NOUN _005457217 90 37 and and CCONJ _005457217 90 38 belief belief NOUN _005457217 90 39 in in ADP _005457217 90 40 a a DET _005457217 90 41 certain certain ADJ _005457217 90 42 god god PROPN _005457217 90 43 and and CCONJ _005457217 90 44 bible bible PROPN _005457217 90 45 approved approve VERB _005457217 90 46 and and CCONJ _005457217 90 47 taught teach VERB _005457217 90 48 by by ADP _005457217 90 49 the the DET _005457217 90 50 instructor instructor NOUN _005457217 90 51 . . PUNCT _005457217 91 1 the the DET _005457217 91 2 nature nature NOUN _005457217 91 3 of of ADP _005457217 91 4 these these DET _005457217 91 5 beliefs belief NOUN _005457217 91 6 is be AUX _005457217 91 7 amplified amplify VERB _005457217 91 8 in in ADP _005457217 91 9 the the DET _005457217 91 10 petition petition NOUN _005457217 91 11 . . PUNCT _005457217 92 1 except except SCONJ _005457217 92 2 that that SCONJ _005457217 92 3 james james PROPN _005457217 92 4 terry terry PROPN _005457217 92 5 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 92 6 did do AUX _005457217 92 7 ask ask VERB _005457217 92 8 and and CCONJ _005457217 92 9 urge urge VERB _005457217 92 10 his his PRON _005457217 92 11 mother mother NOUN _005457217 92 12 to to PART _005457217 92 13 be be AUX _005457217 92 14 allowed allow VERB _005457217 92 15 to to PART _005457217 92 16 take take VERB _005457217 92 17 the the DET _005457217 92 18 religious religious ADJ _005457217 92 19 courses course NOUN _005457217 92 20 there there PRON _005457217 92 21 is be VERB _005457217 92 22 no no DET _005457217 92 23 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 92 24 of of ADP _005457217 92 25 " " PUNCT _005457217 92 26 h h VERB _005457217 92 27 a a DET _005457217 92 28 r r NOUN _005457217 92 29 assment assment NOUN _005457217 92 30 . . PUNCT _005457217 92 31 " " PUNCT _005457217 93 1 there there PRON _005457217 93 2 is be VERB _005457217 93 3 no no DET _005457217 93 4 doubt doubt NOUN _005457217 93 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 93 6 the the DET _005457217 93 7 effect effect NOUN _005457217 93 8 of of ADP _005457217 93 9 the the DET _005457217 93 10 courses course NOUN _005457217 93 11 is be AUX _005457217 93 12 to to PART _005457217 93 13 inspire inspire VERB _005457217 93 14 belief belief NOUN _005457217 93 15 in in ADP _005457217 93 16 god god PROPN _005457217 93 17 and and CCONJ _005457217 93 18 interest interest NOUN _005457217 93 19 in in ADP _005457217 93 20 the the DET _005457217 93 21 bible bible PROPN _005457217 93 22 taught teach VERB _005457217 93 23 . . PUNCT _005457217 94 1 none none NOUN _005457217 94 2 of of ADP _005457217 94 3 the the DET _005457217 94 4 materials material NOUN _005457217 94 5 and and CCONJ _005457217 94 6 supplies supply NOUN _005457217 94 7 used use VERB _005457217 94 8 in in ADP _005457217 94 9 connection connection NOUN _005457217 94 10 with with ADP _005457217 94 11 said say VERB _005457217 94 12 courses course NOUN _005457217 94 13 is be AUX _005457217 94 14 furnished furnish VERB _005457217 94 15 at at ADP _005457217 94 16 public public ADJ _005457217 94 17 expense expense NOUN _005457217 94 18 . . PUNCT _005457217 95 1 the the DET _005457217 95 2 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 95 3 in in ADP _005457217 95 4 said say VERB _005457217 95 5 classes class NOUN _005457217 95 6 in in ADP _005457217 95 7 religious religious ADJ _005457217 95 8 education education NOUN _005457217 95 9 are be AUX _005457217 95 10 admitted admit VERB _005457217 95 11 only only ADV _005457217 95 12 on on ADP _005457217 95 13 the the DET _005457217 95 14 written write VERB _005457217 95 15 request request NOUN _005457217 95 16 of of ADP _005457217 95 17 their their PRON _005457217 95 18 parents parent NOUN _005457217 95 19 or or CCONJ _005457217 95 20 guardians guardian NOUN _005457217 95 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 95 22 and and CCONJ _005457217 95 23 then then ADV _005457217 95 24 only only ADV _005457217 95 25 to to ADP _005457217 95 26 classes class NOUN _005457217 95 27 conducted conduct VERB _005457217 95 28 by by ADP _005457217 95 29 faiths faith NOUN _005457217 95 30 designated designate VERB _005457217 95 31 by by ADP _005457217 95 32 such such ADJ _005457217 95 33 parents parent NOUN _005457217 95 34 or or CCONJ _005457217 95 35 guardians guardian NOUN _005457217 95 36 . . PUNCT _005457217 96 1 the the DET _005457217 96 2 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 96 3 school school NOUN _005457217 96 4 district district NOUN _005457217 96 5 has have AUX _005457217 96 6 been be AUX _005457217 96 7 willing willing ADJ _005457217 96 8 to to PART _005457217 96 9 grant grant VERB _005457217 96 10 its its PRON _005457217 96 11 permission permission NOUN _005457217 97 1 f f NOUN _005457217 97 2 o o X _005457217 97 3 r r NOUN _005457217 97 4 the the DET _005457217 97 5 similar similar ADJ _005457217 97 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 97 7 f f X _005457217 97 8 r r NOUN _005457217 97 9 e e NOUN _005457217 97 10 e e NOUN _005457217 97 11 and and CCONJ _005457217 97 12 equal equal ADJ _005457217 97 13 use use NOUN _005457217 97 14 of of ADP _005457217 97 15 rooms room NOUN _005457217 97 16 in in ADP _005457217 97 17 the the DET _005457217 97 18 school school NOUN _005457217 97 19 8 8 NUM _005457217 97 20 buildings building NOUN _005457217 97 21 when when SCONJ _005457217 97 22 not not PART _005457217 97 23 in in ADP _005457217 97 24 use use NOUN _005457217 97 25 for for ADP _005457217 97 26 school school NOUN _005457217 97 27 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 97 28 , , PUNCT _005457217 97 29 to to PART _005457217 97 30 anyother anyother VERB _005457217 97 31 faith faith NOUN _005457217 97 32 or or CCONJ _005457217 97 33 group group NOUN _005457217 97 34 which which PRON _005457217 97 35 desires desire VERB _005457217 97 36 to to PART _005457217 97 37 make make VERB _005457217 97 38 use use NOUN _005457217 97 39 of of ADP _005457217 97 40 the the DET _005457217 97 41 school school NOUN _005457217 97 42 rooms room NOUN _005457217 97 43 belonging belong VERB _005457217 97 44 to to ADP _005457217 97 45 the the DET _005457217 97 46 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 97 47 , , PUNCT _005457217 97 48 f f PROPN _005457217 97 49 o o X _005457217 97 50 r r NOUN _005457217 97 51 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 97 52 in in ADP _005457217 97 53 the the DET _005457217 97 54 tenets tenet NOUN _005457217 97 55 or or CCONJ _005457217 97 56 belief belief NOUN _005457217 97 57 or or CCONJ _005457217 97 58 unbelief unbelief NOUN _005457217 97 59 of of ADP _005457217 97 60 such such ADJ _005457217 97 61 other other ADJ _005457217 97 62 faith faith NOUN _005457217 97 63 or or CCONJ _005457217 97 64 group group NOUN _005457217 97 65 . . PUNCT _005457217 98 1 the the DET _005457217 98 2 proof proof NOUN _005457217 98 3 shows show VERB _005457217 98 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 98 5 all all PRON _005457217 98 6 of of ADP _005457217 98 7 the the DET _005457217 98 8 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 98 9 groups group NOUN _005457217 98 10 were be AUX _005457217 98 11 taught teach VERB _005457217 98 12 by by ADP _005457217 98 13 miss miss PROPN _005457217 98 14 chapin chapin NOUN _005457217 98 15 and and CCONJ _005457217 98 16 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 98 17 . . PROPN _005457217 98 18 jorgensen jorgensen PROPN _005457217 98 19 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 98 20 that that SCONJ _005457217 98 21 children child NOUN _005457217 98 22 of of ADP _005457217 98 23 some some DET _005457217 98 24 thirty thirty NUM _005457217 98 25 - - PUNCT _005457217 98 26 one one NUM _005457217 98 27 sects sect NOUN _005457217 98 28 , , PUNCT _005457217 98 29 including include VERB _005457217 98 30 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 98 31 , , PUNCT _005457217 98 32 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 98 33 , , PUNCT _005457217 98 34 and and CCONJ _005457217 98 35 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 98 36 , , PUNCT _005457217 98 37 as as ADV _005457217 98 38 well well ADV _005457217 98 39 as as ADP _005457217 98 40 many many ADJ _005457217 98 41 children child NOUN _005457217 98 42 without without ADP _005457217 98 43 any any DET _005457217 98 44 particular particular ADJ _005457217 98 45 religious religious ADJ _005457217 98 46 preference preference NOUN _005457217 98 47 , , PUNCT _005457217 98 48 took take VERB _005457217 98 49 these these DET _005457217 98 50 courses course NOUN _005457217 98 51 . . PUNCT _005457217 99 1 likewise likewise ADV _005457217 99 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 99 3 the the DET _005457217 99 4 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 99 5 and and CCONJ _005457217 99 6 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 99 7 churches church NOUN _005457217 99 8 conducted conduct VERB _005457217 99 9 classes class NOUN _005457217 99 10 under under ADP _005457217 99 11 the the DET _005457217 99 12 system system NOUN _005457217 99 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 99 14 although although SCONJ _005457217 99 15 the the DET _005457217 99 16 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 99 17 faith faith NOUN _005457217 99 18 had have VERB _005457217 99 19 no no DET _005457217 99 20 classes class NOUN _005457217 99 21 the the DET _005457217 99 22 last last ADJ _005457217 99 23 year year NOUN _005457217 99 24 or or CCONJ _005457217 99 25 two two NUM _005457217 99 26 . . PUNCT _005457217 100 1 about about ADV _005457217 100 2 eighty eighty NUM _005457217 100 3 per per ADP _005457217 100 4 cent cent NOUN _005457217 100 5 of of ADP _005457217 100 6 the the DET _005457217 100 7 children child NOUN _005457217 100 8 in in ADP _005457217 100 9 the the DET _005457217 100 10 grade grade NOUN _005457217 100 11 schools school NOUN _005457217 100 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 100 13 and and CCONJ _005457217 100 14 about about ADV _005457217 100 15 twenty twenty NUM _005457217 100 16 per per NOUN _005457217 100 17 cent cent NOUN _005457217 100 18 of of ADP _005457217 100 19 the the DET _005457217 100 20 children child NOUN _005457217 100 21 in in ADP _005457217 100 22 the the DET _005457217 100 23 junior junior ADJ _005457217 100 24 high high ADJ _005457217 100 25 school school NOUN _005457217 100 26 took take VERB _005457217 100 27 the the DET _005457217 100 28 courses course NOUN _005457217 100 29 last last ADJ _005457217 100 30 year year NOUN _005457217 100 31 . . PUNCT _005457217 101 1 on on ADP _005457217 101 2 the the DET _005457217 101 3 trial trial NOUN _005457217 101 4 an an DET _005457217 101 5 officer officer NOUN _005457217 101 6 in in ADP _005457217 101 7 the the DET _005457217 101 8 local local ADJ _005457217 101 9 organization organization NOUN _005457217 101 10 of of ADP _005457217 101 11 jehovah jehovah NOUN _005457217 101 12 's 's PART _005457217 101 13 witnesses witness NOUN _005457217 101 14 testified testify VERB _005457217 101 15 . . PUNCT _005457217 102 1 thereafter thereafter ADV _005457217 102 2 he he PRON _005457217 102 3 asked ask VERB _005457217 102 4 mr mr PROPN _005457217 102 5 . . PROPN _005457217 102 6 mellon mellon PROPN _005457217 102 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 102 8 the the DET _005457217 102 9 superintendent superintendent NOUN _005457217 102 10 of of ADP _005457217 102 11 schools school NOUN _005457217 102 12 of of ADP _005457217 102 13 the the DET _005457217 102 14 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 102 15 district district NOUN _005457217 102 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 102 17 if if SCONJ _005457217 102 18 they they PRON _005457217 102 19 could could AUX _005457217 102 20 have have VERB _005457217 102 21 classes class NOUN _005457217 102 22 in in ADP _005457217 102 23 the the DET _005457217 102 24 system system NOUN _005457217 102 25 . . PUNCT _005457217 103 1 the the DET _005457217 103 2 superintendent superintendent NOUN _005457217 103 3 testified testify VERB _005457217 103 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 103 5 jehovah jehovah NOUN _005457217 103 6 's 's PART _005457217 103 7 witnesses witness NOUN _005457217 103 8 or or CCONJ _005457217 103 9 any any DET _005457217 103 10 other other ADJ _005457217 103 11 sect sect NOUN _005457217 103 12 would would AUX _005457217 103 13 be be AUX _005457217 103 14 allowed allow VERB _005457217 103 15 to to PART _005457217 103 16 teach teach VERB _005457217 103 17 provided provide VERB _005457217 103 18 their their PRON _005457217 103 19 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 103 20 had have VERB _005457217 103 21 proper proper ADJ _005457217 103 22 educational educational ADJ _005457217 103 23 qualifications qualification NOUN _005457217 103 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 103 25 so so SCONJ _005457217 103 26 that that DET _005457217 103 27 bad bad ADJ _005457217 103 28 grammar grammar NOUN _005457217 103 29 , , PUNCT _005457217 103 30 for for ADP _005457217 103 31 instance instance NOUN _005457217 103 32 , , PUNCT _005457217 103 33 would would AUX _005457217 103 34 not not PART _005457217 103 35 be be AUX _005457217 103 36 taught teach VERB _005457217 103 37 to to ADP _005457217 103 38 the the DET _005457217 103 39 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 103 40 . . PUNCT _005457217 104 1 a a DET _005457217 104 2 similar similar ADJ _005457217 104 3 situation situation NOUN _005457217 104 4 developed develop VERB _005457217 104 5 with with ADP _005457217 104 6 reference reference NOUN _005457217 104 7 to to ADP _005457217 104 8 the the DET _005457217 104 9 missouri missouri PROPN _005457217 104 10 synod synod PROPN _005457217 104 11 of of ADP _005457217 104 12 the the DET _005457217 104 13 lutheran lutheran PROPN _005457217 104 14 church church NOUN _005457217 104 15 . . PUNCT _005457217 105 1 the the DET _005457217 105 2 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 105 3 tends tend VERB _005457217 105 4 to to PART _005457217 105 5 show show VERB _005457217 105 6 that that SCONJ _005457217 105 7 during during ADP _005457217 105 8 the the DET _005457217 105 9 course course NOUN _005457217 105 10 of of ADP _005457217 105 11 the the DET _005457217 105 12 trial trial NOUN _005457217 105 13 that that PRON _005457217 105 14 group group NOUN _005457217 105 15 indicated indicate VERB _005457217 105 16 it it PRON _005457217 105 17 would would AUX _005457217 105 18 affiliate affiliate VERB _005457217 105 19 with with ADP _005457217 105 20 the the DET _005457217 105 21 council council NOUN _005457217 105 22 of of ADP _005457217 105 23 eeligious eeligious ADJ _005457217 105 24 education education NOUN _005457217 105 25 . . PUNCT _005457217 106 1 before before SCONJ _005457217 106 2 any any DET _005457217 106 3 faith faith NOUN _005457217 106 4 or or CCONJ _005457217 106 5 other other ADJ _005457217 106 6 group group NOUN _005457217 106 7 may may AUX _005457217 106 8 obtain obtain VERB _005457217 106 9 permission permission NOUN _005457217 106 10 from from ADP _005457217 106 11 the the DET _005457217 106 12 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 106 13 for for ADP _005457217 106 14 the the DET _005457217 106 15 similar similar ADJ _005457217 106 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 106 17 free free ADJ _005457217 106 18 and and CCONJ _005457217 106 19 equal equal ADJ _005457217 106 20 use use NOUN _005457217 106 21 of of ADP _005457217 106 22 rooms room NOUN _005457217 106 23 in in ADP _005457217 106 24 the the DET _005457217 106 25 public public ADJ _005457217 106 26 school school NOUN _005457217 106 27 buildings building NOUN _005457217 106 28 said say VERB _005457217 106 29 faith faith NOUN _005457217 106 30 or or CCONJ _005457217 106 31 group group NOUN _005457217 106 32 must must AUX _005457217 106 33 make make VERB _005457217 106 34 application application NOUN _005457217 106 35 to to ADP _005457217 106 36 the the DET _005457217 106 37 superintendent superintendent NOUN _005457217 106 38 of of ADP _005457217 106 39 schools school NOUN _005457217 106 40 of of ADP _005457217 107 1 said say VERB _005457217 107 2 school school NOUN _005457217 107 3 district district NOUN _005457217 107 4 number number NOUN _005457217 107 5 71 71 NUM _005457217 107 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 107 7 who who PRON _005457217 107 8 in in ADP _005457217 107 9 turn turn NOUN _005457217 107 10 9 9 NUM _005457217 107 11 will will AUX _005457217 107 12 determine determine VERB _005457217 107 13 whether whether SCONJ _005457217 107 14 or or CCONJ _005457217 107 15 not not PART _005457217 107 16 it it PRON _005457217 107 17 is be AUX _005457217 107 18 practical practical ADJ _005457217 107 19 f f PROPN _005457217 107 20 o o PROPN _005457217 107 21 r r NOUN _005457217 107 22 said say VERB _005457217 107 23 group group NOUN _005457217 107 24 to to PART _005457217 107 25 teach teach VERB _005457217 107 26 in in ADP _005457217 107 27 said say VERB _005457217 107 28 school school NOUN _005457217 107 29 system system NOUN _005457217 107 30 . . PUNCT _005457217 108 1 the the DET _005457217 108 2 court court NOUN _005457217 108 3 feels feel VERB _005457217 108 4 f f X _005457217 108 5 r r NOUN _005457217 108 6 o o NOUN _005457217 108 7 m m VERB _005457217 108 8 all all DET _005457217 108 9 the the DET _005457217 108 10 facts fact NOUN _005457217 108 11 in in ADP _005457217 108 12 the the DET _005457217 108 13 record record NOUN _005457217 108 14 that that SCONJ _005457217 108 15 an an DET _005457217 108 16 honest honest ADJ _005457217 108 17 attempt attempt NOUN _005457217 108 18 has have AUX _005457217 108 19 been be AUX _005457217 108 20 made make VERB _005457217 108 21 and and CCONJ _005457217 108 22 is be AUX _005457217 108 23 being be AUX _005457217 108 24 made make VERB _005457217 108 25 to to PART _005457217 108 26 permit permit VERB _005457217 108 27 religious religious ADJ _005457217 108 28 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 108 29 to to PART _005457217 108 30 be be AUX _005457217 108 31 given give VERB _005457217 108 32 by by ADP _005457217 108 33 qualified qualified ADJ _005457217 108 34 outside outside ADJ _005457217 108 35 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 108 36 of of ADP _005457217 108 37 any any DET _005457217 108 38 sect sect NOUN _005457217 108 39 to to ADP _005457217 108 40 people people NOUN _005457217 108 41 of of ADP _005457217 108 42 their their PRON _005457217 108 43 own own ADJ _005457217 108 44 faith faith NOUN _005457217 108 45 in in ADP _005457217 108 46 the the DET _005457217 108 47 manner manner NOUN _005457217 108 48 above above ADV _005457217 108 49 outlined outline VERB _005457217 108 50 . . PUNCT _005457217 109 1 the the DET _005457217 109 2 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 109 3 shows show VERB _005457217 109 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 109 5 no no DET _005457217 109 6 sect sect ADJ _005457217 109 7 or or CCONJ _005457217 109 8 religious religious ADJ _005457217 109 9 group group NOUN _005457217 109 10 has have AUX _005457217 109 11 ever ever ADV _005457217 109 12 been be AUX _005457217 109 13 denied deny VERB _005457217 109 14 the the DET _005457217 109 15 right right NOUN _005457217 109 16 to to PART _005457217 109 17 use use VERB _005457217 109 18 the the DET _005457217 109 19 schools school NOUN _005457217 109 20 in in ADP _005457217 109 21 this this DET _005457217 109 22 manner manner NOUN _005457217 109 23 . . PUNCT _005457217 110 1 the the DET _005457217 110 2 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 110 3 shows show VERB _005457217 110 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 110 5 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 110 6 differences difference NOUN _005457217 110 7 between between ADP _005457217 110 8 the the DET _005457217 110 9 sects sect NOUN _005457217 110 10 are be AUX _005457217 110 11 not not PART _005457217 110 12 taught teach VERB _005457217 110 13 or or CCONJ _005457217 110 14 emphasized emphasize VERB _005457217 110 15 in in ADP _005457217 110 16 the the DET _005457217 110 17 actual actual ADJ _005457217 110 18 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 110 19 as as SCONJ _005457217 110 20 it it PRON _005457217 110 21 is be AUX _005457217 110 22 conducted conduct VERB _005457217 110 23 in in ADP _005457217 110 24 the the DET _005457217 110 25 schools school NOUN _005457217 110 26 . . PUNCT _005457217 111 1 the the DET _005457217 111 2 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 111 3 of of ADP _005457217 111 4 the the DET _005457217 111 5 religious religious ADJ _005457217 111 6 education education NOUN _005457217 111 7 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 111 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 111 9 the the DET _005457217 111 10 secular secular ADJ _005457217 111 11 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 111 12 who who PRON _005457217 111 13 testified testify VERB _005457217 111 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 111 15 and and CCONJ _005457217 111 16 the the DET _005457217 111 17 many many ADJ _005457217 111 18 children child NOUN _005457217 111 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 111 20 mostly mostly ADV _005457217 111 21 from from ADP _005457217 111 22 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 111 23 families family NOUN _005457217 111 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 111 25 who who PRON _005457217 111 26 either either CCONJ _005457217 111 27 took take VERB _005457217 111 28 or or CCONJ _005457217 111 29 did do AUX _005457217 111 30 not not PART _005457217 111 31 take take VERB _005457217 111 32 religious religious ADJ _005457217 111 33 education education NOUN _005457217 111 34 courses course NOUN _005457217 111 35 , , PUNCT _005457217 111 36 is be AUX _005457217 111 37 to to ADP _005457217 111 38 the the DET _005457217 111 39 effect effect NOUN _005457217 111 40 that that PRON _005457217 111 41 religious religious ADJ _005457217 111 42 education education NOUN _005457217 111 43 classes class NOUN _005457217 111 44 have have AUX _005457217 111 45 fostered foster VERB _005457217 111 46 tolerance tolerance NOUN _005457217 111 47 rather rather ADV _005457217 111 48 than than ADP _005457217 111 49 intolerance intolerance NOUN _005457217 111 50 . . PUNCT _005457217 112 1 as as SCONJ _005457217 112 2 will will AUX _005457217 112 3 be be AUX _005457217 112 4 referred refer VERB _005457217 112 5 to to ADP _005457217 112 6 shortly shortly ADV _005457217 112 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 112 8 the the DET _005457217 112 9 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 112 10 of of ADP _005457217 112 11 the the DET _005457217 112 12 relator relator NOUN _005457217 112 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 112 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 112 15 of of ADP _005457217 112 16 her her PRON _005457217 112 17 son son NOUN _005457217 112 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 112 19 james james PROPN _005457217 112 20 terry terry PROPN _005457217 112 21 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 112 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 112 23 stands stand VERB _005457217 112 24 alone alone ADV _005457217 112 25 and and CCONJ _005457217 112 26 opposed oppose VERB _005457217 112 27 to to ADP _005457217 112 28 all all DET _005457217 112 29 the the DET _005457217 112 30 other other ADJ _005457217 112 31 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 112 32 in in ADP _005457217 112 33 the the DET _005457217 112 34 record record NOUN _005457217 112 35 , , PUNCT _005457217 112 36 that that SCONJ _005457217 112 37 any any DET _005457217 112 38 child child NOUN _005457217 112 39 has have AUX _005457217 112 40 ever ever ADV _005457217 112 41 been be AUX _005457217 112 42 ridiculed ridicule VERB _005457217 112 43 , , PUNCT _005457217 112 44 shunned shun VERB _005457217 112 45 , , PUNCT _005457217 112 46 embarrassed embarrassed ADJ _005457217 112 47 or or CCONJ _005457217 112 48 ostracized ostracize VERB _005457217 112 49 because because SCONJ _005457217 112 50 of of ADP _005457217 112 51 his his PRON _005457217 112 52 non non ADJ _005457217 112 53 participation participation NOUN _005457217 112 54 in in ADP _005457217 112 55 these these DET _005457217 112 56 courses course NOUN _005457217 112 57 , , PUNCT _005457217 112 58 or or CCONJ _005457217 112 59 because because SCONJ _005457217 112 60 of of ADP _005457217 112 61 his his PRON _005457217 112 62 religious religious ADJ _005457217 112 63 beliefs belief NOUN _005457217 112 64 . . PUNCT _005457217 113 1 the the DET _005457217 113 2 curriculum curriculum NOUN _005457217 113 3 of of ADP _005457217 113 4 studies study NOUN _005457217 113 5 in in ADP _005457217 113 6 the the DET _005457217 113 7 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 113 8 classes class NOUN _005457217 113 9 is be AUX _005457217 113 10 determined determine VERB _005457217 113 11 by by ADP _005457217 113 12 a a DET _005457217 113 13 committee committee NOUN _005457217 113 14 of of ADP _005457217 113 15 the the DET _005457217 113 16 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 113 17 members member NOUN _005457217 113 18 of of ADP _005457217 113 19 the the DET _005457217 113 20 council council NOUN _005457217 113 21 of of ADP _005457217 113 22 religious religious ADJ _005457217 113 23 education education NOUN _005457217 113 24 a a DET _005457217 113 25 f f PROPN _005457217 113 26 t t NOUN _005457217 113 27 e e NOUN _005457217 113 28 r r NOUN _005457217 113 29 consultation consultation NOUN _005457217 113 30 with with ADP _005457217 113 31 representatives representative NOUN _005457217 113 32 of of ADP _005457217 113 33 all all DET _005457217 113 34 the the DET _005457217 113 35 different different ADJ _005457217 113 36 faiths faith NOUN _005457217 113 37 included include VERB _005457217 113 38 in in ADP _005457217 113 39 said say VERB _005457217 113 40 council council PROPN _005457217 113 41 . . PUNCT _005457217 114 1 the the DET _005457217 114 2 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 114 3 classes class NOUN _005457217 114 4 of of ADP _005457217 114 5 course course NOUN _005457217 114 6 would would AUX _005457217 114 7 deny deny VERB _005457217 114 8 the the DET _005457217 114 9 divinity divinity NOUN _005457217 114 10 of of ADP _005457217 114 11 jesus jesus PROPN _005457217 114 12 christ christ PROPN _005457217 114 13 . . PUNCT _005457217 115 1 the the DET _005457217 115 2 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 115 3 in in ADP _005457217 115 4 the the DET _005457217 115 5 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 115 6 classes class NOUN _005457217 115 7 of of ADP _005457217 115 8 course course NOUN _005457217 115 9 explains explain VERB _005457217 115 10 to to PART _005457217 115 11 catholic catholic VERB _005457217 115 12 pupils pupil VERB _005457217 115 13 the the DET _005457217 115 14 teachings teaching NOUN _005457217 115 15 of of ADP _005457217 115 16 the the DET _005457217 115 17 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 115 18 religion religion NOUN _005457217 115 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 115 20 and and CCONJ _005457217 115 21 are be AUX _005457217 115 22 not not PART _005457217 115 23 shared share VERB _005457217 115 24 by by ADP _005457217 115 25 other other ADJ _005457217 115 26 students student NOUN _005457217 115 27 who who PRON _005457217 115 28 are be AUX _005457217 115 29 protestants protestant NOUN _005457217 115 30 or or CCONJ _005457217 115 31 jews jews PROPN _005457217 115 32 . . PUNCT _005457217 116 1 the the DET _005457217 116 2 teachings teaching NOUN _005457217 116 3 in in ADP _005457217 116 4 the the DET _005457217 116 5 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 116 6 classes class NOUN _005457217 116 7 would would AUX _005457217 116 8 undoubtedly undoubtedly ADV _005457217 116 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 116 10 from from ADP _005457217 116 11 the the DET _005457217 116 12 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 116 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 116 14 teach teach VERB _005457217 116 15 some some DET _005457217 116 16 doctrines doctrine NOUN _005457217 116 17 that that PRON _005457217 116 18 would would AUX _005457217 116 19 not not PART _005457217 116 20 be be AUX _005457217 116 21 accepted accept VERB _005457217 116 22 by by ADP _005457217 116 23 the the DET _005457217 116 24 other other ADJ _005457217 116 25 two two NUM _005457217 116 26 religions religion NOUN _005457217 116 27 . . PUNCT _005457217 117 1 10 10 NUM _005457217 117 2 in in ADP _005457217 117 3 the the DET _005457217 117 4 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 117 5 classes class NOUN _005457217 117 6 the the DET _005457217 117 7 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 117 8 all all PRON _005457217 117 9 indicates indicate VERB _005457217 117 10 there there PRON _005457217 117 11 was be VERB _005457217 117 12 no no DET _005457217 117 13 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 117 14 of of ADP _005457217 117 15 any any DET _005457217 117 16 doctrines doctrine NOUN _005457217 117 17 that that PRON _005457217 117 18 would would AUX _005457217 117 19 be be AUX _005457217 117 20 offensive offensive ADJ _005457217 117 21 to to ADP _005457217 117 22 any any PRON _005457217 117 23 of of ADP _005457217 117 24 the the DET _005457217 117 25 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 117 26 groups group NOUN _005457217 117 27 participating participate VERB _005457217 117 28 in in ADP _005457217 117 29 the the DET _005457217 117 30 council council NOUN _005457217 117 31 . . PUNCT _005457217 118 1 from from ADP _005457217 118 2 what what PRON _005457217 118 3 was be AUX _005457217 118 4 said say VERB _005457217 118 5 in in ADP _005457217 118 6 the the DET _005457217 118 7 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 118 8 of of ADP _005457217 118 9 representatives representative NOUN _005457217 118 10 of of ADP _005457217 118 11 the the DET _005457217 118 12 quakers quaker NOUN _005457217 118 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 118 14 the the DET _005457217 118 15 christian christian PROPN _005457217 118 16 science science PROPN _005457217 118 17 church church NOUN _005457217 118 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 118 19 and and CCONJ _005457217 118 20 jehovah jehovah NOUN _005457217 118 21 's 's PART _005457217 118 22 witnesses witness NOUN _005457217 118 23 , , PUNCT _005457217 118 24 the the DET _005457217 118 25 beliefs belief NOUN _005457217 118 26 of of ADP _005457217 118 27 these these DET _005457217 118 28 churches church NOUN _005457217 118 29 as as SCONJ _005457217 118 30 expressed express VERB _005457217 118 31 by by ADP _005457217 118 32 the the DET _005457217 118 33 representatives representative NOUN _005457217 118 34 would would AUX _005457217 118 35 seem seem VERB _005457217 118 36 not not PART _005457217 118 37 to to PART _005457217 118 38 be be AUX _005457217 118 39 in in ADP _005457217 118 40 any any DET _005457217 118 41 way way NOUN _005457217 118 42 in in ADP _005457217 118 43 conflict conflict NOUN _005457217 118 44 with with ADP _005457217 118 45 what what PRON _005457217 118 46 miss miss VERB _005457217 118 47 chapin chapin NOUN _005457217 118 48 and and CCONJ _005457217 118 49 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 118 50 . . PROPN _005457217 118 51 jorgensen jorgensen PROPN _005457217 118 52 testified testify VERB _005457217 118 53 was be AUX _005457217 118 54 taught teach VERB _005457217 118 55 to to ADP _005457217 118 56 all all PRON _005457217 118 57 of of ADP _005457217 118 58 the the DET _005457217 118 59 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 118 60 classes class NOUN _005457217 118 61 . . PUNCT _005457217 119 1 likewise likewise ADV _005457217 119 2 it it PRON _005457217 119 3 is be AUX _005457217 119 4 true true ADJ _005457217 119 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 119 6 the the DET _005457217 119 7 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 119 8 of of ADP _005457217 119 9 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 119 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 119 11 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 119 12 and and CCONJ _005457217 119 13 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 119 14 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 119 15 in in ADP _005457217 119 16 these these DET _005457217 119 17 courses course NOUN _005457217 119 18 would would AUX _005457217 119 19 all all ADV _005457217 119 20 be be AUX _005457217 119 21 in in ADP _005457217 119 22 conflict conflict NOUN _005457217 119 23 with with ADP _005457217 119 24 the the DET _005457217 119 25 teachings teaching NOUN _005457217 119 26 of of ADP _005457217 119 27 atheists atheist NOUN _005457217 119 28 as as SCONJ _005457217 119 29 those those DET _005457217 119 30 beliefs belief NOUN _005457217 119 31 were be AUX _005457217 119 32 testified testify VERB _005457217 119 33 about about ADP _005457217 119 34 by by ADP _005457217 119 35 the the DET _005457217 119 36 relator relator NOUN _005457217 119 37 and and CCONJ _005457217 119 38 her her PRON _005457217 119 39 father father NOUN _005457217 119 40 , , PUNCT _005457217 119 41 mr mr PROPN _005457217 119 42 . . PROPN _005457217 119 43 cromwell cromwell PROPN _005457217 119 44 . . PUNCT _005457217 120 1 they they PRON _005457217 120 2 would would AUX _005457217 120 3 probably probably ADV _005457217 120 4 be be AUX _005457217 120 5 in in ADP _005457217 120 6 conflict conflict NOUN _005457217 120 7 with with ADP _005457217 120 8 that that DET _005457217 120 9 branch branch NOUN _005457217 120 10 of of ADP _005457217 120 11 the the DET _005457217 120 12 unitarian unitarian ADJ _005457217 120 13 church church NOUN _005457217 120 14 represented represent VERB _005457217 120 15 by by ADP _005457217 120 16 reverend reverend ADJ _005457217 120 17 philip philip PROPN _005457217 120 18 schug schug PROPN _005457217 120 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 120 20 who who PRON _005457217 120 21 testified testify VERB _005457217 120 22 on on ADP _005457217 120 23 the the DET _005457217 120 24 trial trial NOUN _005457217 120 25 that that PRON _005457217 120 26 unitarians unitarian VERB _005457217 120 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 120 28 like like ADP _005457217 120 29 the the DET _005457217 120 30 quakers quaker NOUN _005457217 120 31 , , PUNCT _005457217 120 32 are be AUX _005457217 120 33 allowed allow VERB _005457217 120 34 each each PRON _005457217 120 35 to to PART _005457217 120 36 determine determine VERB _005457217 120 37 f f PROPN _005457217 120 38 o o NOUN _005457217 120 39 r r NOUN _005457217 120 40 himself himself PRON _005457217 120 41 what what PRON _005457217 120 42 his his PRON _005457217 120 43 belief belief NOUN _005457217 120 44 in in ADP _005457217 120 45 god god PROPN _005457217 120 46 is be AUX _005457217 120 47 , , PUNCT _005457217 120 48 but but CCONJ _005457217 120 49 that that SCONJ _005457217 120 50 one one NUM _005457217 120 51 group group NOUN _005457217 120 52 of of ADP _005457217 120 53 unitarians unitarians PROPN _005457217 120 54 shared share VERB _005457217 120 55 views view NOUN _005457217 120 56 as as ADP _005457217 120 57 to to ADP _005457217 120 58 the the DET _005457217 120 59 existence existence NOUN _005457217 120 60 of of ADP _005457217 120 61 god god PROPN _005457217 120 62 , , PUNCT _005457217 120 63 and and CCONJ _005457217 120 64 the the DET _005457217 120 65 attitude attitude NOUN _005457217 120 66 toward toward ADP _005457217 120 67 the the DET _005457217 120 68 biblical biblical ADJ _005457217 120 69 stories story NOUN _005457217 120 70 , , PUNCT _005457217 120 71 very very ADV _005457217 120 72 similar similar ADJ _005457217 120 73 to to ADP _005457217 120 74 the the DET _005457217 120 75 views view NOUN _005457217 120 76 entertained entertain VERB _005457217 120 77 by by ADP _005457217 120 78 the the DET _005457217 120 79 relator relator NOUN _005457217 120 80 , , PUNCT _005457217 120 81 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 120 82 . . PROPN _005457217 120 83 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 120 84 , , PUNCT _005457217 120 85 and and CCONJ _005457217 120 86 by by ADP _005457217 120 87 her her PRON _005457217 120 88 father father NOUN _005457217 120 89 . . PUNCT _005457217 121 1 there there PRON _005457217 121 2 is be VERB _005457217 121 3 no no DET _005457217 121 4 dispute dispute NOUN _005457217 121 5 in in ADP _005457217 121 6 the the DET _005457217 121 7 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 121 8 that that SCONJ _005457217 121 9 the the DET _005457217 121 10 relator relator NOUN _005457217 121 11 's 's PART _005457217 121 12 son son NOUN _005457217 121 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 121 14 james james PROPN _005457217 121 15 terry terry PROPN _005457217 121 16 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 121 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 121 18 did do AUX _005457217 121 19 ask ask VERB _005457217 121 20 his his PRON _005457217 121 21 mother mother NOUN _005457217 121 22 f f X _005457217 121 23 o o X _005457217 121 24 r r NOUN _005457217 121 25 permission permission NOUN _005457217 121 26 to to PART _005457217 121 27 take take VERB _005457217 121 28 the the DET _005457217 121 29 religious religious ADJ _005457217 121 30 education education NOUN _005457217 121 31 courses course NOUN _005457217 121 32 . . PUNCT _005457217 122 1 he he PRON _005457217 122 2 took take VERB _005457217 122 3 his his PRON _005457217 122 4 fourth fourth ADJ _005457217 122 5 grade grade NOUN _005457217 122 6 work work NOUN _005457217 122 7 in in ADP _005457217 122 8 what what PRON _005457217 122 9 is be AUX _005457217 122 10 known know VERB _005457217 122 11 as as ADP _005457217 122 12 the the DET _005457217 122 13 " " PUNCT _005457217 122 14 s s NOUN _005457217 122 15 o o NOUN _005457217 122 16 u u NOUN _005457217 122 17 t t NOUN _005457217 122 18 h h NOUN _005457217 122 19 side side NOUN _005457217 122 20 school school NOUN _005457217 122 21 . . PUNCT _005457217 122 22 " " PUNCT _005457217 123 1 f f PROPN _005457217 123 2 o o X _005457217 123 3 r r NOUN _005457217 123 4 one one NUM _005457217 123 5 semester semester NOUN _005457217 123 6 the the DET _005457217 123 7 mother mother NOUN _005457217 123 8 granted grant VERB _005457217 123 9 her her PRON _005457217 123 10 permission permission NOUN _005457217 123 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 123 12 and and CCONJ _005457217 123 13 the the DET _005457217 123 14 boy boy NOUN _005457217 123 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 123 16 james james PROPN _005457217 123 17 terry terry PROPN _005457217 123 18 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 123 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 123 20 did do AUX _005457217 123 21 take take VERB _005457217 123 22 the the DET _005457217 123 23 religious religious ADJ _005457217 123 24 education education NOUN _005457217 123 25 courses course NOUN _005457217 123 26 . . PUNCT _005457217 124 1 he he PRON _005457217 124 2 was be AUX _005457217 124 3 transferred transfer VERB _005457217 124 4 at at ADP _005457217 124 5 the the DET _005457217 124 6 end end NOUN _005457217 124 7 of of ADP _005457217 124 8 that that DET _005457217 124 9 year year NOUN _005457217 124 10 on on ADP _005457217 124 11 his his PRON _005457217 124 12 mother mother NOUN _005457217 124 13 's 's PART _005457217 124 14 request request NOUN _005457217 124 15 to to ADP _005457217 124 16 another another DET _005457217 124 17 school school NOUN _005457217 124 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 124 19 known know VERB _005457217 124 20 as as ADP _005457217 124 21 the the DET _005457217 124 22 " " PUNCT _005457217 124 23 d d NOUN _005457217 124 24 r r NOUN _005457217 124 25 . . PUNCT _005457217 125 1 howard howard PROPN _005457217 125 2 school school PROPN _005457217 125 3 . . PUNCT _005457217 125 4 " " PUNCT _005457217 126 1 the the DET _005457217 126 2 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 126 3 shows show VERB _005457217 126 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 126 5 he he PRON _005457217 126 6 asked ask VERB _005457217 126 7 his his PRON _005457217 126 8 mother mother NOUN _005457217 126 9 's 's PART _005457217 126 10 permission permission NOUN _005457217 126 11 which which PRON _005457217 126 12 she she PRON _005457217 126 13 refused refuse VERB _005457217 126 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 126 15 to to PART _005457217 126 16 take take VERB _005457217 126 17 the the DET _005457217 126 18 religious religious ADJ _005457217 126 19 edu11 edu11 NOUN _005457217 126 20 cation cation NOUN _005457217 126 21 courses course NOUN _005457217 126 22 there there ADV _005457217 126 23 . . PUNCT _005457217 127 1 the the DET _005457217 127 2 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 127 3 f f PROPN _005457217 127 4 u u PROPN _005457217 127 5 r r NOUN _005457217 127 6 t t NOUN _005457217 127 7 h h NOUN _005457217 127 8 e e NOUN _005457217 127 9 r r NOUN _005457217 127 10 shows show VERB _005457217 127 11 that that SCONJ _005457217 127 12 at at ADP _005457217 127 13 the the DET _005457217 127 14 end end NOUN _005457217 127 15 of of ADP _005457217 127 16 his his PRON _005457217 127 17 fifth fifth ADJ _005457217 127 18 grade grade NOUN _005457217 127 19 work work NOUN _005457217 127 20 in in ADP _005457217 127 21 the the DET _005457217 127 22 dr dr PROPN _005457217 127 23 . . PROPN _005457217 127 24 howard howard PROPN _005457217 127 25 school school PROPN _005457217 127 26 , , PUNCT _005457217 127 27 and and CCONJ _005457217 127 28 during during ADP _005457217 127 29 the the DET _005457217 127 30 summer summer NOUN _005457217 127 31 of of ADP _005457217 127 32 1945 1945 NUM _005457217 127 33 , , PUNCT _005457217 127 34 a a DET _005457217 127 35 f f NOUN _005457217 127 36 t t NOUN _005457217 127 37 e e NOUN _005457217 127 38 r r NOUN _005457217 127 39 the the DET _005457217 127 40 lawsuit lawsuit NOUN _005457217 127 41 in in ADP _005457217 127 42 this this DET _005457217 127 43 case case NOUN _005457217 127 44 was be AUX _005457217 127 45 started start VERB _005457217 127 46 , , PUNCT _005457217 127 47 the the DET _005457217 127 48 relator relator NOUN _005457217 127 49 sent send VERB _005457217 127 50 her her PRON _005457217 127 51 son son NOUN _005457217 127 52 , , PUNCT _005457217 127 53 james james PROPN _005457217 127 54 terry terry PROPN _005457217 127 55 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 127 56 , , PUNCT _005457217 127 57 to to ADP _005457217 127 58 what what PRON _005457217 127 59 was be AUX _005457217 127 60 called call VERB _005457217 127 61 a a DET _005457217 127 62 " " PUNCT _005457217 127 63 demonstration demonstration NOUN _005457217 127 64 school school NOUN _005457217 127 65 " " PUNCT _005457217 127 66 at at ADP _005457217 127 67 the the DET _005457217 127 68 university university PROPN _005457217 127 69 of of ADP _005457217 127 70 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 127 71 , , PUNCT _005457217 127 72 in in ADP _005457217 127 73 which which PRON _005457217 127 74 private private ADJ _005457217 127 75 school school NOUN _005457217 127 76 and and CCONJ _005457217 127 77 with with ADP _005457217 127 78 relator relator NOUN _005457217 127 79 's 's PART _005457217 127 80 knowledge knowledge NOUN _005457217 127 81 , , PUNCT _005457217 127 82 the the DET _005457217 127 83 hoy hoy PROPN _005457217 127 84 participated participate VERB _005457217 127 85 in in ADP _005457217 127 86 religious religious ADJ _005457217 127 87 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 127 88 at at ADP _005457217 127 89 the the DET _005457217 127 90 beginning beginning NOUN _005457217 127 91 of of ADP _005457217 127 92 school school NOUN _005457217 127 93 , , PUNCT _005457217 127 94 and and CCONJ _005457217 127 95 which which PRON _005457217 127 96 included include VERB _005457217 127 97 the the DET _005457217 127 98 recitation recitation NOUN _005457217 127 99 of of ADP _005457217 127 100 the the DET _005457217 127 101 lord lord PROPN _005457217 127 102 's 's PART _005457217 127 103 prayer prayer NOUN _005457217 127 104 , , PUNCT _005457217 127 105 the the DET _005457217 127 106 reading reading NOUN _005457217 127 107 and and CCONJ _005457217 127 108 explaining explaining NOUN _005457217 127 109 of of ADP _005457217 127 110 passages passage NOUN _005457217 127 111 in in ADP _005457217 127 112 the the DET _005457217 127 113 bible bible NOUN _005457217 127 114 by by ADP _005457217 127 115 the the DET _005457217 127 116 students student NOUN _005457217 127 117 , , PUNCT _005457217 127 118 including include VERB _005457217 127 119 james james PROPN _005457217 127 120 terry terry PROPN _005457217 127 121 , , PUNCT _005457217 127 122 and and CCONJ _005457217 127 123 the the DET _005457217 127 124 singing singing NOUN _005457217 127 125 of of ADP _005457217 127 126 some some DET _005457217 127 127 hymns hymn NOUN _005457217 127 128 . . PUNCT _005457217 128 1 one one NUM _005457217 128 2 of of ADP _005457217 128 3 the the DET _005457217 128 4 relator relator NOUN _005457217 128 5 's 's PART _005457217 128 6 other other ADJ _005457217 128 7 children child NOUN _005457217 128 8 attended attend VERB _005457217 128 9 another another DET _005457217 128 10 private private ADJ _005457217 128 11 school school NOUN _005457217 128 12 where where SCONJ _005457217 128 13 similar similar ADJ _005457217 128 14 religious religious ADJ _005457217 128 15 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 128 16 were be AUX _005457217 128 17 conducted conduct VERB _005457217 128 18 . . PUNCT _005457217 129 1 one one NUM _005457217 129 2 matter matter NOUN _005457217 129 3 in in ADP _005457217 129 4 issue issue NOUN _005457217 129 5 between between ADP _005457217 129 6 the the DET _005457217 129 7 parties party NOUN _005457217 129 8 is be AUX _005457217 129 9 whether whether SCONJ _005457217 129 10 the the DET _005457217 129 11 relator relator NOUN _005457217 129 12 's 's PART _005457217 129 13 son son NOUN _005457217 129 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 129 15 james james PROPN _005457217 129 16 terry terry PROPN _005457217 129 17 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 129 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 129 19 was be AUX _005457217 129 20 ostracized ostracize VERB _005457217 129 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 129 22 ridiculed ridicule VERB _005457217 129 23 and and CCONJ _005457217 129 24 humiliated humiliate VERB _005457217 129 25 because because SCONJ _005457217 129 26 he he PRON _005457217 129 27 did do AUX _005457217 129 28 not not PART _005457217 129 29 take take VERB _005457217 129 30 the the DET _005457217 129 31 religious religious ADJ _005457217 129 32 education education NOUN _005457217 129 33 courses course NOUN _005457217 129 34 in in ADP _005457217 129 35 the the DET _005457217 129 36 fifth fifth ADJ _005457217 129 37 grade grade NOUN _005457217 129 38 . . PUNCT _005457217 130 1 i i PRON _005457217 130 2 t t PROPN _005457217 130 3 is be AUX _005457217 130 4 undisputed undisputed ADJ _005457217 130 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 130 6 during during ADP _005457217 130 7 the the DET _005457217 130 8 second second ADJ _005457217 130 9 semester semester NOUN _005457217 130 10 of of ADP _005457217 130 11 his his PRON _005457217 130 12 fifth fifth ADJ _005457217 130 13 grade grade NOUN _005457217 130 14 work work NOUN _005457217 130 15 at at ADP _005457217 130 16 the the DET _005457217 130 17 dr dr PROPN _005457217 130 18 . . PROPN _005457217 130 19 howard howard PROPN _005457217 130 20 school school PROPN _005457217 130 21 james james PROPN _005457217 130 22 terry terry PROPN _005457217 130 23 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 130 24 was be AUX _005457217 130 25 the the DET _005457217 130 26 only only ADJ _005457217 130 27 pupil pupil NOUN _005457217 130 28 in in ADP _005457217 130 29 his his PRON _005457217 130 30 room room NOUN _005457217 130 31 who who PRON _005457217 130 32 did do AUX _005457217 130 33 not not PART _005457217 130 34 take take VERB _005457217 130 35 the the DET _005457217 130 36 religious religious ADJ _005457217 130 37 education education NOUN _005457217 130 38 courses course NOUN _005457217 130 39 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 130 40 that that SCONJ _005457217 130 41 he he PRON _005457217 130 42 went go VERB _005457217 130 43 to to ADP _005457217 130 44 a a DET _005457217 130 45 room room NOUN _005457217 130 46 called call VERB _005457217 130 47 the the DET _005457217 130 48 " " PUNCT _005457217 130 49 music music NOUN _005457217 130 50 r r NOUN _005457217 130 51 o o NOUN _005457217 130 52 o o NOUN _005457217 130 53 m m VERB _005457217 130 54 " " PUNCT _005457217 130 55 the the DET _005457217 130 56 first first ADJ _005457217 130 57 p p NOUN _005457217 130 58 a a DET _005457217 130 59 r r NOUN _005457217 130 60 t t NOUN _005457217 130 61 of of ADP _005457217 130 62 the the DET _005457217 130 63 second second ADJ _005457217 130 64 semester semester NOUN _005457217 130 65 while while SCONJ _005457217 130 66 the the DET _005457217 130 67 religious religious ADJ _005457217 130 68 education education NOUN _005457217 130 69 courses course NOUN _005457217 130 70 were be AUX _005457217 130 71 going go VERB _005457217 130 72 on on ADP _005457217 130 73 . . PUNCT _005457217 131 1 on on ADP _005457217 131 2 one one NUM _005457217 131 3 occasion occasion NOUN _005457217 131 4 he he PRON _005457217 131 5 was be AUX _005457217 131 6 sent send VERB _005457217 131 7 out out ADP _005457217 131 8 into into ADP _005457217 131 9 the the DET _005457217 131 10 hall hall NOUN _005457217 131 11 and and CCONJ _005457217 131 12 worked work VERB _005457217 131 13 at at ADP _005457217 131 14 a a DET _005457217 131 15 desk desk NOUN _005457217 131 16 there there ADV _005457217 131 17 . . PUNCT _005457217 132 1 he he PRON _005457217 132 2 testified testify VERB _005457217 132 3 that that SCONJ _005457217 132 4 children child NOUN _005457217 132 5 came come VERB _005457217 132 6 by by ADP _005457217 132 7 and and CCONJ _005457217 132 8 called call VERB _005457217 132 9 him he PRON _005457217 132 10 an an DET _005457217 132 11 atheist atheist NOUN _005457217 132 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 132 13 and and CCONJ _005457217 132 14 made make VERB _005457217 132 15 f f PROPN _005457217 132 16 u u PROPN _005457217 132 17 n n ADP _005457217 132 18 of of ADP _005457217 132 19 him he PRON _005457217 132 20 . . PUNCT _005457217 133 1 i i PRON _005457217 133 2 t t PROPN _005457217 133 3 is be AUX _005457217 133 4 undisputed undisputed ADJ _005457217 133 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 133 6 his his PRON _005457217 133 7 mother mother NOUN _005457217 133 8 did do AUX _005457217 133 9 go go VERB _005457217 133 10 to to PART _005457217 133 11 see see VERB _005457217 133 12 the the DET _005457217 133 13 secular secular ADJ _005457217 133 14 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 133 15 to to PART _005457217 133 16 protest protest VERB _005457217 133 17 about about ADP _005457217 133 18 his his PRON _005457217 133 19 being be AUX _005457217 133 20 sent send VERB _005457217 133 21 out out ADP _005457217 133 22 into into ADP _005457217 133 23 the the DET _005457217 133 24 hall hall NOUN _005457217 133 25 , , PUNCT _005457217 133 26 although although SCONJ _005457217 133 27 there there PRON _005457217 133 28 is be VERB _005457217 133 29 a a DET _005457217 133 30 dispute dispute NOUN _005457217 133 31 as as ADP _005457217 133 32 to to ADP _005457217 133 33 whether whether SCONJ _005457217 133 34 there there PRON _005457217 133 35 was be VERB _005457217 133 36 any any DET _005457217 133 37 charge charge NOUN _005457217 133 38 made make VERB _005457217 133 39 by by ADP _005457217 133 40 the the DET _005457217 133 41 mother mother NOUN _005457217 133 42 that that SCONJ _005457217 133 43 the the DET _005457217 133 44 child child NOUN _005457217 133 45 's 's PART _005457217 133 46 religious religious ADJ _005457217 133 47 beliefs belief NOUN _005457217 133 48 were be AUX _005457217 133 49 discussed discuss VERB _005457217 133 50 in in ADP _005457217 133 51 that that DET _005457217 133 52 connection connection NOUN _005457217 133 53 . . PUNCT _005457217 134 1 a a DET _005457217 134 2 f f PROPN _005457217 134 3 t t NOUN _005457217 134 4 e e NOUN _005457217 134 5 r r NOUN _005457217 134 6 that that SCONJ _005457217 134 7 the the DET _005457217 134 8 relator relator NOUN _005457217 134 9 's 's PART _005457217 134 10 son son NOUN _005457217 134 11 was be AUX _005457217 134 12 sent send VERB _005457217 134 13 to to ADP _005457217 134 14 another another DET _005457217 134 15 fifth fifth ADJ _005457217 134 16 grade grade NOUN _005457217 134 17 class class NOUN _005457217 134 18 room room NOUN _005457217 134 19 to to PART _005457217 134 20 study study VERB _005457217 134 21 . . PUNCT _005457217 135 1 12 12 NUM _005457217 135 2 on on ADP _005457217 135 3 the the DET _005457217 135 4 question question NOUN _005457217 135 5 of of ADP _005457217 135 6 ostracism ostracism NOUN _005457217 135 7 and and CCONJ _005457217 135 8 embarrassment embarrassment NOUN _005457217 135 9 of of ADP _005457217 135 10 the the DET _005457217 135 11 relator relator NOUN _005457217 135 12 's 's PART _005457217 135 13 son son NOUN _005457217 135 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 135 15 james james PROPN _005457217 135 16 terry terry PROPN _005457217 135 17 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 135 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 135 19 the the DET _005457217 135 20 great great ADJ _005457217 135 21 weight weight NOUN _005457217 135 22 of of ADP _005457217 135 23 the the DET _005457217 135 24 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 135 25 is be AUX _005457217 135 26 against against ADP _005457217 135 27 her her PRON _005457217 135 28 contention contention NOUN _005457217 135 29 . . PUNCT _005457217 136 1 not not PART _005457217 136 2 a a DET _005457217 136 3 single single ADJ _005457217 136 4 witness witness NOUN _005457217 136 5 corroborated corroborate VERB _005457217 136 6 him he PRON _005457217 136 7 that that SCONJ _005457217 136 8 he he PRON _005457217 136 9 was be AUX _005457217 136 10 ever ever ADV _005457217 136 11 referred refer VERB _005457217 136 12 to to ADP _005457217 136 13 as as ADP _005457217 136 14 an an DET _005457217 136 15 atheist atheist NOUN _005457217 136 16 by by ADP _005457217 136 17 the the DET _005457217 136 18 students student NOUN _005457217 136 19 in in ADP _005457217 136 20 school school NOUN _005457217 136 21 . . PUNCT _005457217 137 1 on on ADP _005457217 137 2 the the DET _005457217 137 3 contrary contrary NOUN _005457217 137 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 137 5 a a DET _005457217 137 6 number number NOUN _005457217 137 7 of of ADP _005457217 137 8 his his PRON _005457217 137 9 classmates classmate NOUN _005457217 137 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 137 11 and and CCONJ _005457217 137 12 at at ADV _005457217 137 13 least least ADV _005457217 137 14 one one NUM _005457217 137 15 close close ADJ _005457217 137 16 friend friend NOUN _005457217 137 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 137 18 testified testify VERB _005457217 137 19 that that SCONJ _005457217 137 20 they they PRON _005457217 137 21 had have AUX _005457217 137 22 never never ADV _005457217 137 23 heard hear VERB _005457217 137 24 the the DET _005457217 137 25 word word NOUN _005457217 137 26 " " PUNCT _005457217 137 27 a a DET _005457217 137 28 t t NOUN _005457217 137 29 h h NOUN _005457217 138 1 e e X _005457217 138 2 i i PRON _005457217 138 3 s s VERB _005457217 138 4 t t NOUN _005457217 138 5 " " PUNCT _005457217 138 6 until until ADP _005457217 138 7 the the DET _005457217 138 8 time time NOUN _005457217 138 9 of of ADP _005457217 138 10 the the DET _005457217 138 11 lawsuit lawsuit NOUN _005457217 138 12 in in ADP _005457217 138 13 this this DET _005457217 138 14 case case NOUN _005457217 138 15 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 138 16 that that SCONJ _005457217 138 17 nobody nobody PRON _005457217 138 18 had have AUX _005457217 138 19 ever ever ADV _005457217 138 20 made make VERB _005457217 138 21 f f PROPN _005457217 138 22 u u PROPN _005457217 138 23 n n ADP _005457217 138 24 of of ADP _005457217 138 25 terry terry PROPN _005457217 138 26 or or CCONJ _005457217 138 27 said say VERB _005457217 138 28 anything anything PRON _005457217 138 29 about about ADP _005457217 138 30 his his PRON _005457217 138 31 religious religious ADJ _005457217 138 32 opinions opinion NOUN _005457217 138 33 . . PUNCT _005457217 139 1 the the DET _005457217 139 2 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 139 3 of of ADP _005457217 139 4 these these DET _005457217 139 5 children child NOUN _005457217 139 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 139 7 and and CCONJ _005457217 139 8 their their PRON _005457217 139 9 demeanor demeanor NOUN _005457217 139 10 on on ADP _005457217 139 11 the the DET _005457217 139 12 witness witness NOUN _005457217 139 13 stand stand NOUN _005457217 139 14 was be AUX _005457217 139 15 convincing convincing ADJ _005457217 139 16 . . PUNCT _005457217 140 1 the the DET _005457217 140 2 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 140 3 is be AUX _005457217 140 4 undisputed undisputed ADJ _005457217 140 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 140 6 james james PROPN _005457217 140 7 terry terry PROPN _005457217 140 8 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 140 9 had have VERB _005457217 140 10 difficulties difficulty NOUN _005457217 140 11 with with ADP _005457217 140 12 the the DET _005457217 140 13 other other ADJ _005457217 140 14 students student NOUN _005457217 140 15 in in ADP _005457217 140 16 his his PRON _005457217 140 17 school school NOUN _005457217 140 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 140 19 but but CCONJ _005457217 140 20 there there PRON _005457217 140 21 is be VERB _005457217 140 22 no no DET _005457217 140 23 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 140 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 140 25 except except SCONJ _005457217 140 26 his his PRON _005457217 140 27 own own ADJ _005457217 140 28 , , PUNCT _005457217 140 29 that that SCONJ _005457217 140 30 his his PRON _005457217 140 31 want want NOUN _005457217 140 32 of of ADP _005457217 140 33 religion religion NOUN _005457217 140 34 had have VERB _005457217 140 35 anything anything PRON _005457217 140 36 to to PART _005457217 140 37 do do VERB _005457217 140 38 with with ADP _005457217 140 39 these these DET _005457217 140 40 difficulties difficulty NOUN _005457217 140 41 . . PUNCT _005457217 141 1 he he PRON _005457217 141 2 himself himself PRON _005457217 141 3 testified testify VERB _005457217 141 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 141 5 he he PRON _005457217 141 6 got get VERB _005457217 141 7 into into ADP _005457217 141 8 fights fight NOUN _005457217 141 9 with with ADP _005457217 141 10 the the DET _005457217 141 11 other other ADJ _005457217 141 12 children child NOUN _005457217 141 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 141 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 141 15 even even ADV _005457217 141 16 spit spit VERB _005457217 141 17 in in ADP _005457217 141 18 the the DET _005457217 141 19 faces face NOUN _005457217 141 20 of of ADP _005457217 141 21 some some PRON _005457217 141 22 of of ADP _005457217 141 23 them they PRON _005457217 141 24 . . PUNCT _005457217 142 1 the the DET _005457217 142 2 secular secular ADJ _005457217 142 3 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 142 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 142 5 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 142 6 . . PROPN _005457217 142 7 taylor taylor PROPN _005457217 142 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 142 9 testified testify VERB _005457217 142 10 that that SCONJ _005457217 142 11 she she PRON _005457217 142 12 consulted consult VERB _005457217 142 13 with with ADP _005457217 142 14 the the DET _005457217 142 15 relator relator NOUN _005457217 142 16 about about ADP _005457217 142 17 t t NOUN _005457217 142 18 e e NOUN _005457217 142 19 r r NOUN _005457217 142 20 r r NOUN _005457217 142 21 y y PROPN _005457217 142 22 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 142 23 s s NOUN _005457217 142 24 problems problem NOUN _005457217 142 25 . . PUNCT _005457217 143 1 he he PRON _005457217 143 2 had have AUX _005457217 143 3 been be AUX _005457217 143 4 in in ADP _005457217 143 5 the the DET _005457217 143 6 south south ADJ _005457217 143 7 side side NOUN _005457217 143 8 school school NOUN _005457217 144 1 f f X _005457217 144 2 o o X _005457217 144 3 r r NOUN _005457217 144 4 fourth fourth ADJ _005457217 144 5 grade grade NOUN _005457217 144 6 work work NOUN _005457217 144 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 144 8 and and CCONJ _005457217 144 9 was be AUX _005457217 144 10 transferred transfer VERB _005457217 144 11 by by ADP _005457217 144 12 his his PRON _005457217 144 13 mother mother NOUN _005457217 144 14 to to ADP _005457217 144 15 the the DET _005457217 144 16 dr dr PROPN _005457217 144 17 . . PROPN _005457217 144 18 howard howard PROPN _005457217 144 19 school school PROPN _005457217 144 20 for for ADP _005457217 144 21 fifth fifth ADJ _005457217 144 22 grade grade NOUN _005457217 144 23 work work NOUN _005457217 144 24 . . PUNCT _005457217 145 1 the the DET _005457217 145 2 secular secular ADJ _005457217 145 3 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 145 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 145 5 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 145 6 . . PROPN _005457217 145 7 taylor taylor PROPN _005457217 145 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 145 9 at at ADP _005457217 145 10 dr dr PROPN _005457217 145 11 . . PROPN _005457217 145 12 howard howard PROPN _005457217 145 13 school school NOUN _005457217 145 14 testified testify VERB _005457217 145 15 that that SCONJ _005457217 145 16 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 145 17 . . PROPN _005457217 145 18 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 145 19 gave give VERB _005457217 145 20 a a DET _005457217 145 21 history history NOUN _005457217 145 22 of of ADP _005457217 145 23 failure failure NOUN _005457217 145 24 of of ADP _005457217 145 25 terry terry NOUN _005457217 145 26 to to PART _005457217 145 27 adjust adjust VERB _005457217 145 28 with with ADP _005457217 145 29 other other ADJ _005457217 145 30 children child NOUN _005457217 145 31 . . PUNCT _005457217 146 1 many many ADJ _005457217 146 2 children child NOUN _005457217 146 3 who who PRON _005457217 146 4 did do AUX _005457217 146 5 not not PART _005457217 146 6 take take VERB _005457217 146 7 the the DET _005457217 146 8 courses course NOUN _005457217 146 9 in in ADP _005457217 146 10 religious religious ADJ _005457217 146 11 education education NOUN _005457217 146 12 at at ADV _005457217 146 13 all all ADV _005457217 146 14 testified testify VERB _005457217 146 15 that that SCONJ _005457217 146 16 they they PRON _005457217 146 17 had have AUX _005457217 146 18 never never ADV _005457217 146 19 had have VERB _005457217 146 20 any any DET _005457217 146 21 embarrassment embarrassment NOUN _005457217 146 22 of of ADP _005457217 146 23 any any DET _005457217 146 24 kind kind NOUN _005457217 146 25 because because SCONJ _005457217 146 26 thereof thereof ADV _005457217 146 27 . . PUNCT _005457217 147 1 many many ADJ _005457217 147 2 of of ADP _005457217 147 3 the the DET _005457217 147 4 children child NOUN _005457217 147 5 who who PRON _005457217 147 6 had have AUX _005457217 147 7 taken take VERB _005457217 147 8 the the DET _005457217 147 9 courses course NOUN _005457217 147 10 in in ADP _005457217 147 11 the the DET _005457217 147 12 different different ADJ _005457217 147 13 schools school NOUN _005457217 147 14 all all PRON _005457217 147 15 testified testify VERB _005457217 147 16 that that SCONJ _005457217 147 17 either either CCONJ _005457217 147 18 the the DET _005457217 147 19 taking taking NOUN _005457217 147 20 or or CCONJ _005457217 147 21 the the DET _005457217 147 22 failure failure NOUN _005457217 147 23 to to PART _005457217 147 24 take take VERB _005457217 147 25 religious religious ADJ _005457217 147 26 education education NOUN _005457217 147 27 had have AUX _005457217 147 28 made make VERB _005457217 147 29 no no DET _005457217 147 30 difference difference NOUN _005457217 147 31 in in ADP _005457217 147 32 their their PRON _005457217 147 33 friendships friendship NOUN _005457217 147 34 . . PUNCT _005457217 148 1 without without ADP _005457217 148 2 reviewing review VERB _005457217 148 3 all all DET _005457217 148 4 the the DET _005457217 148 5 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 148 6 the the DET _005457217 148 7 court court NOUN _005457217 148 8 believes believe VERB _005457217 148 9 the the DET _005457217 148 10 great great ADJ _005457217 148 11 preponderance preponderance NOUN _005457217 148 12 of of ADP _005457217 148 13 the the DET _005457217 148 14 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 148 15 shows show VERB _005457217 148 16 that that SCONJ _005457217 148 17 13 13 NUM _005457217 148 18 james james PROPN _005457217 148 19 terry terry PROPN _005457217 148 20 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 148 21 was be AUX _005457217 148 22 not not PART _005457217 148 23 subjected subject VERB _005457217 148 24 to to ADP _005457217 148 25 any any DET _005457217 148 26 humiliation humiliation NOUN _005457217 148 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 148 28 ridicule ridicule NOUN _005457217 148 29 , , PUNCT _005457217 148 30 ostracism ostracism NOUN _005457217 148 31 or or CCONJ _005457217 148 32 embarrassment embarrassment NOUN _005457217 148 33 because because SCONJ _005457217 148 34 of of ADP _005457217 148 35 his his PRON _005457217 148 36 religious religious ADJ _005457217 148 37 opinions opinion NOUN _005457217 148 38 , , PUNCT _005457217 148 39 but but CCONJ _005457217 148 40 that that SCONJ _005457217 148 41 his his PRON _005457217 148 42 difficulties difficulty NOUN _005457217 148 43 were be AUX _005457217 148 44 due due ADJ _005457217 148 45 to to ADP _005457217 148 46 his his PRON _005457217 148 47 own own ADJ _005457217 148 48 personality personality NOUN _005457217 148 49 problems problem NOUN _005457217 148 50 , , PUNCT _005457217 148 51 entirely entirely ADV _005457217 148 52 disconnected disconnected ADJ _005457217 148 53 from from ADP _005457217 148 54 any any DET _005457217 148 55 question question NOUN _005457217 148 56 of of ADP _005457217 148 57 religion religion NOUN _005457217 148 58 . . PUNCT _005457217 149 1 on on ADP _005457217 149 2 the the DET _005457217 149 3 witness witness NOUN _005457217 149 4 stand stand VERB _005457217 149 5 he he PRON _005457217 149 6 was be AUX _005457217 149 7 plainly plainly ADV _005457217 149 8 nervous nervous ADJ _005457217 149 9 and and CCONJ _005457217 149 10 excitable excitable ADJ _005457217 149 11 . . PUNCT _005457217 150 1 his his PRON _005457217 150 2 whole whole ADJ _005457217 150 3 demeanor demeanor NOUN _005457217 150 4 on on ADP _005457217 150 5 the the DET _005457217 150 6 witness witness NOUN _005457217 150 7 stand stand NOUN _005457217 150 8 supports support VERB _005457217 150 9 the the DET _005457217 150 10 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 150 11 of of ADP _005457217 150 12 his his PRON _005457217 150 13 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 150 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 150 15 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 150 16 . . PROPN _005457217 150 17 bessie bessie PROPN _005457217 150 18 taylor taylor PROPN _005457217 150 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 150 20 that that SCONJ _005457217 150 21 his his PRON _005457217 150 22 behavior behavior NOUN _005457217 150 23 problems problem NOUN _005457217 150 24 were be AUX _005457217 150 25 not not PART _005457217 150 26 connected connect VERB _005457217 150 27 with with ADP _005457217 150 28 the the DET _005457217 150 29 religious religious ADJ _005457217 150 30 controversy controversy NOUN _005457217 150 31 as as SCONJ _005457217 150 32 set set VERB _005457217 150 33 f f PROPN _005457217 151 1 o o X _005457217 151 2 r r NOUN _005457217 151 3 t t NOUN _005457217 151 4 h h NOUN _005457217 151 5 in in ADP _005457217 151 6 the the DET _005457217 151 7 petition petition NOUN _005457217 151 8 . . PUNCT _005457217 152 1 he he PRON _005457217 152 2 had have AUX _005457217 152 3 evidently evidently ADV _005457217 152 4 had have VERB _005457217 152 5 some some DET _005457217 152 6 difficulties difficulty NOUN _005457217 152 7 in in ADP _005457217 152 8 his his PRON _005457217 152 9 boy boy NOUN _005457217 152 10 scout scout NOUN _005457217 152 11 work work NOUN _005457217 152 12 because because SCONJ _005457217 152 13 he he PRON _005457217 152 14 testified testify VERB _005457217 152 15 he he PRON _005457217 152 16 was be AUX _005457217 152 17 not not PART _005457217 152 18 going go VERB _005457217 152 19 ahead ahead ADV _005457217 152 20 with with ADP _005457217 152 21 the the DET _005457217 152 22 scout scout NOUN _005457217 152 23 work work NOUN _005457217 152 24 . . PUNCT _005457217 153 1 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 153 2 . . PROPN _005457217 153 3 taylor taylor PROPN _005457217 153 4 admitted admit VERB _005457217 153 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 153 6 she she PRON _005457217 153 7 had have AUX _005457217 153 8 told tell VERB _005457217 153 9 the the DET _005457217 153 10 relator relator NOUN _005457217 153 11 privately privately ADV _005457217 153 12 that that SCONJ _005457217 153 13 she she PRON _005457217 153 14 would would AUX _005457217 153 15 suggest suggest VERB _005457217 153 16 that that SCONJ _005457217 153 17 he he PRON _005457217 153 18 be be AUX _005457217 153 19 permitted permit VERB _005457217 153 20 to to PART _005457217 153 21 take take VERB _005457217 153 22 religious religious ADJ _005457217 153 23 education education NOUN _005457217 153 24 courses course NOUN _005457217 153 25 to to PART _005457217 153 26 see see VERB _005457217 153 27 if if SCONJ _005457217 153 28 that that PRON _005457217 153 29 would would AUX _005457217 153 30 help help VERB _005457217 153 31 him he PRON _005457217 153 32 to to PART _005457217 153 33 adjust adjust VERB _005457217 153 34 with with ADP _005457217 153 35 the the DET _005457217 153 36 other other ADJ _005457217 153 37 students student NOUN _005457217 153 38 . . PUNCT _005457217 154 1 no no DET _005457217 154 2 one one NOUN _005457217 154 3 contends contend VERB _005457217 154 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 154 5 she she PRON _005457217 154 6 pressed press VERB _005457217 154 7 this this DET _005457217 154 8 suggestion suggestion NOUN _005457217 154 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 154 10 except except SCONJ _005457217 154 11 that that SCONJ _005457217 154 12 relator relator NOUN _005457217 154 13 's 's PART _005457217 154 14 son son NOUN _005457217 154 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 154 16 terry terry PROPN _005457217 154 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 154 18 testified testify VERB _005457217 154 19 that that SCONJ _005457217 154 20 she she PRON _005457217 154 21 said say VERB _005457217 154 22 to to ADP _005457217 154 23 him he PRON _005457217 154 24 and and CCONJ _005457217 154 25 to to ADP _005457217 154 26 the the DET _005457217 154 27 whole whole ADJ _005457217 154 28 class class NOUN _005457217 154 29 that that SCONJ _005457217 154 30 they they PRON _005457217 154 31 ought ought AUX _005457217 154 32 to to PART _005457217 154 33 make make VERB _005457217 154 34 the the DET _005457217 154 35 class class NOUN _005457217 154 36 one one NUM _005457217 154 37 hundred hundred NUM _005457217 154 38 per per ADP _005457217 154 39 cent cent NOUN _005457217 154 40 for for ADP _005457217 154 41 religious religious ADJ _005457217 154 42 education education NOUN _005457217 154 43 . . PUNCT _005457217 155 1 this this PRON _005457217 155 2 was be AUX _005457217 155 3 denied deny VERB _005457217 155 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 155 5 not not PART _005457217 155 6 only only ADV _005457217 155 7 by by ADP _005457217 155 8 the the DET _005457217 155 9 teacher teacher NOUN _005457217 155 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 155 11 but but CCONJ _005457217 155 12 by by ADP _005457217 155 13 several several ADJ _005457217 155 14 of of ADP _005457217 155 15 the the DET _005457217 155 16 other other ADJ _005457217 155 17 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 155 18 in in ADP _005457217 155 19 the the DET _005457217 155 20 room room NOUN _005457217 155 21 who who PRON _005457217 155 22 were be AUX _005457217 155 23 present present ADJ _005457217 155 24 at at ADP _005457217 155 25 the the DET _005457217 155 26 time time NOUN _005457217 155 27 . . PUNCT _005457217 156 1 the the DET _005457217 156 2 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 156 3 shows show VERB _005457217 156 4 clearly clearly ADV _005457217 156 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 156 6 the the DET _005457217 156 7 " " PUNCT _005457217 156 8 o o NOUN _005457217 156 9 n n CCONJ _005457217 156 10 e e NOUN _005457217 156 11 hundred hundred NUM _005457217 156 12 per per ADP _005457217 156 13 c c NOUN _005457217 156 14 e e PROPN _005457217 156 15 n n PROPN _005457217 156 16 t t PROPN _005457217 156 17 " " PUNCT _005457217 156 18 referred refer VERB _005457217 156 19 to to ADP _005457217 156 20 a a DET _005457217 156 21 campaign campaign NOUN _005457217 156 22 to to PART _005457217 156 23 sell sell VERB _005457217 156 24 war war NOUN _005457217 156 25 stamps stamp NOUN _005457217 156 26 or or CCONJ _005457217 156 27 bonds bond NOUN _005457217 156 28 in in ADP _005457217 156 29 the the DET _005457217 156 30 school school NOUN _005457217 156 31 . . PUNCT _005457217 157 1 the the DET _005457217 157 2 finding finding NOUN _005457217 157 3 of of ADP _005457217 157 4 fact fact NOUN _005457217 157 5 on on ADP _005457217 157 6 this this DET _005457217 157 7 issue issue NOUN _005457217 157 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 157 9 therefore therefore ADV _005457217 157 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 157 11 will will AUX _005457217 157 12 be be AUX _005457217 157 13 against against ADP _005457217 157 14 the the DET _005457217 157 15 relator relator NOUN _005457217 157 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 157 17 except except SCONJ _005457217 157 18 in in ADP _005457217 157 19 so so ADV _005457217 157 20 f f PROPN _005457217 157 21 a a DET _005457217 157 22 r r NOUN _005457217 157 23 as as SCONJ _005457217 157 24 there there PRON _005457217 157 25 is be VERB _005457217 157 26 any any DET _005457217 157 27 natural natural ADJ _005457217 157 28 embarrassment embarrassment NOUN _005457217 157 29 to to ADP _005457217 157 30 a a DET _005457217 157 31 child child NOUN _005457217 157 32 in in ADP _005457217 157 33 being be AUX _005457217 157 34 the the DET _005457217 157 35 only only ADJ _005457217 157 36 one one NUM _005457217 157 37 in in ADP _005457217 157 38 his his PRON _005457217 157 39 room room NOUN _005457217 157 40 who who PRON _005457217 157 41 did do AUX _005457217 157 42 not not PART _005457217 157 43 take take VERB _005457217 157 44 the the DET _005457217 157 45 religious religious ADJ _005457217 157 46 education education NOUN _005457217 157 47 courses course NOUN _005457217 157 48 and and CCONJ _005457217 157 49 who who PRON _005457217 157 50 went go VERB _005457217 157 51 out out ADP _005457217 157 52 of of ADP _005457217 157 53 the the DET _005457217 157 54 room room NOUN _005457217 157 55 to to PART _005457217 157 56 study study VERB _005457217 157 57 by by ADP _005457217 157 58 himself himself PRON _005457217 157 59 because because SCONJ _005457217 157 60 of of ADP _005457217 157 61 that that DET _005457217 157 62 fact fact NOUN _005457217 157 63 . . PUNCT _005457217 158 1 on on ADP _005457217 158 2 the the DET _005457217 158 3 issue issue NOUN _005457217 158 4 whether whether SCONJ _005457217 158 5 the the DET _005457217 158 6 religious religious ADJ _005457217 158 7 education education NOUN _005457217 158 8 courses course NOUN _005457217 158 9 occasion occasion VERB _005457217 158 10 an an DET _005457217 158 11 expenditure expenditure NOUN _005457217 158 12 of of ADP _005457217 158 13 public public ADJ _005457217 158 14 funds fund NOUN _005457217 158 15 or or CCONJ _005457217 158 16 an an DET _005457217 158 17 appropriation appropriation NOUN _005457217 158 18 of of ADP _005457217 158 19 public public ADJ _005457217 158 20 funds fund NOUN _005457217 158 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 158 22 the the DET _005457217 158 23 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 158 24 shows show VERB _005457217 158 25 that that SCONJ _005457217 158 26 no no DET _005457217 158 27 direct direct ADJ _005457217 158 28 14 14 NUM _005457217 158 29 appropriation appropriation NOUN _005457217 158 30 of of ADP _005457217 158 31 any any DET _005457217 158 32 kind kind NOUN _005457217 158 33 , , PUNCT _005457217 158 34 or or CCONJ _005457217 158 35 a a DET _005457217 158 36 direct direct ADJ _005457217 158 37 expenditure expenditure NOUN _005457217 158 38 of of ADP _005457217 158 39 money money NOUN _005457217 158 40 of of ADP _005457217 158 41 any any DET _005457217 158 42 kind kind NOUN _005457217 158 43 , , PUNCT _005457217 158 44 is be AUX _005457217 158 45 made make VERB _005457217 158 46 by by ADP _005457217 158 47 the the DET _005457217 158 48 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 158 49 school school NOUN _005457217 158 50 district district NOUN _005457217 158 51 for for ADP _005457217 158 52 or or CCONJ _005457217 158 53 on on ADP _005457217 158 54 behalf behalf NOUN _005457217 158 55 of of ADP _005457217 158 56 said say VERB _005457217 158 57 religious religious ADJ _005457217 158 58 education education NOUN _005457217 158 59 classes class NOUN _005457217 158 60 . . PUNCT _005457217 159 1 certain certain ADJ _005457217 159 2 cards card NOUN _005457217 159 3 are be AUX _005457217 159 4 used use VERB _005457217 159 5 for for ADP _005457217 159 6 obtaining obtain VERB _005457217 159 7 permission permission NOUN _005457217 159 8 of of ADP _005457217 159 9 parents parent NOUN _005457217 159 10 for for ADP _005457217 159 11 their their PRON _005457217 159 12 children child NOUN _005457217 159 13 to to PART _005457217 159 14 take take VERB _005457217 159 15 said say VERB _005457217 159 16 religious religious ADJ _005457217 159 17 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 159 18 courses course NOUN _005457217 159 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 159 20 and and CCONJ _005457217 159 21 they they PRON _005457217 159 22 are be AUX _005457217 159 23 made make VERB _005457217 159 24 available available ADJ _005457217 159 25 through through ADP _005457217 159 26 the the DET _005457217 159 27 offices office NOUN _005457217 159 28 of of ADP _005457217 159 29 the the DET _005457217 159 30 superintendent superintendent NOUN _005457217 159 31 of of ADP _005457217 159 32 schools school NOUN _005457217 159 33 and and CCONJ _005457217 159 34 through through ADP _005457217 159 35 the the DET _005457217 159 36 hands hand NOUN _005457217 159 37 of of ADP _005457217 159 38 principals principal NOUN _005457217 159 39 and and CCONJ _005457217 159 40 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 159 41 to to ADP _005457217 159 42 the the DET _005457217 159 43 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 159 44 of of ADP _005457217 159 45 the the DET _005457217 159 46 school school NOUN _005457217 159 47 district district NOUN _005457217 159 48 . . PUNCT _005457217 160 1 said say VERB _005457217 160 2 cards card NOUN _005457217 160 3 are be AUX _005457217 160 4 prepared prepare VERB _005457217 160 5 at at ADP _005457217 160 6 the the DET _005457217 160 7 cost cost NOUN _005457217 160 8 of of ADP _005457217 160 9 the the DET _005457217 160 10 council council NOUN _005457217 160 11 of of ADP _005457217 160 12 religious religious ADJ _005457217 160 13 education education NOUN _005457217 160 14 . . PUNCT _005457217 161 1 the the DET _005457217 161 2 handling handling NOUN _005457217 161 3 and and CCONJ _005457217 161 4 distribution distribution NOUN _005457217 161 5 of of ADP _005457217 161 6 said say VERB _005457217 161 7 cards card NOUN _005457217 161 8 does do AUX _005457217 161 9 not not PART _005457217 161 10 interfere interfere VERB _005457217 161 11 with with ADP _005457217 161 12 the the DET _005457217 161 13 duties duty NOUN _005457217 161 14 or or CCONJ _005457217 161 15 suspend suspend VERB _005457217 161 16 the the DET _005457217 161 17 regular regular ADJ _005457217 161 18 secular secular ADJ _005457217 161 19 work work NOUN _005457217 161 20 of of ADP _005457217 161 21 the the DET _005457217 161 22 employees employee NOUN _005457217 161 23 of of ADP _005457217 161 24 the the DET _005457217 161 25 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 161 26 . . PUNCT _005457217 162 1 certain certain ADJ _005457217 162 2 rooms room NOUN _005457217 162 3 of of ADP _005457217 162 4 the the DET _005457217 162 5 school school NOUN _005457217 162 6 building building NOUN _005457217 162 7 used use VERB _005457217 162 8 by by ADP _005457217 162 9 the the DET _005457217 162 10 religious religious ADJ _005457217 162 11 classes class NOUN _005457217 162 12 are be AUX _005457217 162 13 lighted light VERB _005457217 162 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 162 15 heated heated ADJ _005457217 162 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 162 17 and and CCONJ _005457217 162 18 furnished furnish VERB _005457217 162 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 163 1 janitor janitor NOUN _005457217 163 2 service service NOUN _005457217 163 3 therein therein ADV _005457217 163 4 is be AUX _005457217 163 5 furnished furnish VERB _005457217 163 6 while while SCONJ _005457217 163 7 the the DET _005457217 163 8 religious religious ADJ _005457217 163 9 education education NOUN _005457217 163 10 classes class NOUN _005457217 163 11 are be AUX _005457217 163 12 conducted conduct VERB _005457217 163 13 . . PUNCT _005457217 164 1 no no DET _005457217 164 2 charge charge NOUN _005457217 164 3 is be AUX _005457217 164 4 made make VERB _005457217 164 5 by by ADP _005457217 164 6 the the DET _005457217 164 7 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 164 8 to to ADP _005457217 164 9 any any DET _005457217 164 10 person person NOUN _005457217 164 11 or or CCONJ _005457217 164 12 organization organization NOUN _005457217 164 13 on on ADP _005457217 164 14 account account NOUN _005457217 164 15 thereof thereof ADV _005457217 164 16 . . PUNCT _005457217 165 1 the the DET _005457217 165 2 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 165 3 of of ADP _005457217 165 4 the the DET _005457217 165 5 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 165 6 shows show VERB _005457217 165 7 that that SCONJ _005457217 165 8 the the DET _005457217 165 9 janitor janitor PROPN _005457217 165 10 service service PROPN _005457217 165 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 165 12 salaries salary NOUN _005457217 165 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 165 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 165 15 so so ADV _005457217 165 16 forth forth ADV _005457217 165 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 165 18 would would AUX _005457217 165 19 all all PRON _005457217 165 20 be be AUX _005457217 165 21 the the DET _005457217 165 22 same same ADJ _005457217 165 23 , , PUNCT _005457217 165 24 whether whether SCONJ _005457217 165 25 the the DET _005457217 165 26 religious religious ADJ _005457217 165 27 education education NOUN _005457217 165 28 courses course NOUN _005457217 165 29 were be AUX _005457217 165 30 conducted conduct VERB _005457217 165 31 or or CCONJ _005457217 165 32 not not PART _005457217 165 33 . . PUNCT _005457217 166 1 f f PROPN _005457217 166 2 o o X _005457217 167 1 r r NOUN _005457217 167 2 the the DET _005457217 167 3 most most ADJ _005457217 167 4 part part NOUN _005457217 167 5 , , PUNCT _005457217 167 6 the the DET _005457217 167 7 expense expense NOUN _005457217 167 8 of of ADP _005457217 167 9 light light NOUN _005457217 167 10 and and CCONJ _005457217 167 11 heat heat NOUN _005457217 167 12 would would AUX _005457217 167 13 be be AUX _005457217 167 14 about about ADV _005457217 167 15 the the DET _005457217 167 16 same same ADJ _005457217 167 17 whether whether SCONJ _005457217 167 18 the the DET _005457217 167 19 courses course NOUN _005457217 167 20 were be AUX _005457217 167 21 conducted conduct VERB _005457217 167 22 or or CCONJ _005457217 167 23 not not PART _005457217 167 24 . . PUNCT _005457217 168 1 the the DET _005457217 168 2 wear wear NOUN _005457217 168 3 and and CCONJ _005457217 168 4 tear tear VERB _005457217 168 5 on on ADP _005457217 168 6 furniture furniture NOUN _005457217 168 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 168 8 due due ADP _005457217 168 9 to to ADP _005457217 168 10 the the DET _005457217 168 11 religious religious ADJ _005457217 168 12 education education NOUN _005457217 168 13 classes class NOUN _005457217 168 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 168 15 so so ADV _005457217 168 16 f f X _005457217 168 17 a a DET _005457217 168 18 r r NOUN _005457217 168 19 as as ADP _005457217 168 20 the the DET _005457217 168 21 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 168 22 in in ADP _005457217 168 23 this this DET _005457217 168 24 case case NOUN _005457217 168 25 shows show NOUN _005457217 168 26 , , PUNCT _005457217 168 27 would would AUX _005457217 168 28 be be AUX _005457217 168 29 negligible negligible ADJ _005457217 168 30 . . PUNCT _005457217 169 1 on on ADP _005457217 169 2 a a DET _005457217 169 3 few few ADJ _005457217 169 4 occasions occasion NOUN _005457217 169 5 cards card NOUN _005457217 169 6 which which PRON _005457217 169 7 were be AUX _005457217 169 8 the the DET _005457217 169 9 property property NOUN _005457217 169 10 of of ADP _005457217 169 11 the the DET _005457217 169 12 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 169 13 school school NOUN _005457217 169 14 district district NOUN _005457217 169 15 were be AUX _005457217 169 16 used use VERB _005457217 169 17 but but CCONJ _005457217 169 18 were be AUX _005457217 169 19 paid pay VERB _005457217 169 20 for for ADP _005457217 169 21 in in ADP _005457217 169 22 each each DET _005457217 169 23 instance instance NOUN _005457217 169 24 by by ADP _005457217 169 25 the the DET _005457217 169 26 council council NOUN _005457217 169 27 of of ADP _005457217 169 28 religious religious ADJ _005457217 169 29 education education NOUN _005457217 169 30 . . PUNCT _005457217 170 1 so so ADV _005457217 170 2 that that SCONJ _005457217 170 3 it it PRON _005457217 170 4 may may AUX _005457217 170 5 be be AUX _005457217 170 6 said say VERB _005457217 170 7 that that SCONJ _005457217 170 8 no no DET _005457217 170 9 public public ADJ _005457217 170 10 funds fund NOUN _005457217 170 11 have have AUX _005457217 170 12 been be AUX _005457217 170 13 directly directly ADV _005457217 170 14 appropriated appropriate VERB _005457217 170 15 by by ADP _005457217 170 16 the the DET _005457217 170 17 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 170 18 f f PROPN _005457217 170 19 o o X _005457217 170 20 r r NOUN _005457217 170 21 private private ADJ _005457217 170 22 use use NOUN _005457217 170 23 . . PUNCT _005457217 171 1 but but CCONJ _005457217 171 2 to to ADP _005457217 171 3 some some DET _005457217 171 4 slight slight ADJ _005457217 171 5 extent extent NOUN _005457217 171 6 the the DET _005457217 171 7 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 171 8 has have AUX _005457217 171 9 indirectly indirectly ADV _005457217 171 10 appropriated appropriate VERB _005457217 171 11 public public ADJ _005457217 171 12 funds fund NOUN _005457217 171 13 for for ADP _005457217 171 14 the the DET _005457217 171 15 use use NOUN _005457217 171 16 of of ADP _005457217 171 17 these these DET _005457217 171 18 classes class NOUN _005457217 171 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 171 20 by by ADP _005457217 171 21 the the DET _005457217 171 22 furnishing furnishing NOUN _005457217 171 23 of of ADP _005457217 171 24 rooms room NOUN _005457217 171 25 in in ADP _005457217 171 26 public public ADJ _005457217 171 27 school school NOUN _005457217 171 28 15 15 NUM _005457217 171 29 buildings building NOUN _005457217 171 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 171 31 light light ADJ _005457217 171 32 , , PUNCT _005457217 171 33 heat heat NOUN _005457217 171 34 , , PUNCT _005457217 171 35 janitor janitor NOUN _005457217 171 36 service service NOUN _005457217 171 37 , , PUNCT _005457217 171 38 and and CCONJ _005457217 171 39 so so ADV _005457217 171 40 forth forth ADV _005457217 171 41 , , PUNCT _005457217 171 42 as as SCONJ _005457217 171 43 above above ADV _005457217 171 44 indicated indicate VERB _005457217 171 45 . . PUNCT _005457217 172 1 i i PRON _005457217 172 2 t t NOUN _005457217 172 3 is be AUX _005457217 172 4 believed believe VERB _005457217 172 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 172 6 the the DET _005457217 172 7 foregoing foregoing NOUN _005457217 172 8 will will AUX _005457217 172 9 dispose dispose VERB _005457217 172 10 of of ADP _005457217 172 11 the the DET _005457217 172 12 controverted controvert VERB _005457217 172 13 issues issue NOUN _005457217 172 14 of of ADP _005457217 172 15 fact fact NOUN _005457217 172 16 . . PUNCT _005457217 173 1 we we PRON _005457217 173 2 come come VERB _005457217 173 3 then then ADV _005457217 173 4 to to ADP _005457217 173 5 the the DET _005457217 173 6 important important ADJ _005457217 173 7 legal legal ADJ _005457217 173 8 question question NOUN _005457217 173 9 in in ADP _005457217 173 10 the the DET _005457217 173 11 case case NOUN _005457217 173 12 . . PUNCT _005457217 174 1 broadly broadly ADV _005457217 174 2 stated state VERB _005457217 174 3 , , PUNCT _005457217 174 4 that that DET _005457217 174 5 question question NOUN _005457217 174 6 i i PRON _005457217 174 7 s s VERB _005457217 174 8 : : PUNCT _005457217 174 9 did do VERB _005457217 174 10 the the DET _005457217 174 11 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 174 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 174 13 board board NOUN _005457217 174 14 of of ADP _005457217 174 15 education education NOUN _005457217 174 16 of of ADP _005457217 174 17 school school NOUN _005457217 174 18 district district NOUN _005457217 174 19 number number NOUN _005457217 174 20 71 71 NUM _005457217 174 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 174 22 have have VERB _005457217 174 23 the the DET _005457217 174 24 power power NOUN _005457217 174 25 under under ADP _005457217 174 26 the the DET _005457217 174 27 law law NOUN _005457217 174 28 to to PART _005457217 174 29 permit permit VERB _005457217 174 30 school school NOUN _005457217 174 31 buildings building NOUN _005457217 174 32 of of ADP _005457217 174 33 the the DET _005457217 174 34 district district NOUN _005457217 174 35 to to PART _005457217 174 36 be be AUX _005457217 174 37 used use VERB _005457217 174 38 f f PROPN _005457217 174 39 o o X _005457217 174 40 r r NOUN _005457217 174 41 teaching teach VERB _005457217 174 42 religious religious ADJ _005457217 174 43 education education NOUN _005457217 174 44 in in ADP _005457217 174 45 the the DET _005457217 174 46 manner manner NOUN _005457217 174 47 and and CCONJ _005457217 174 48 under under ADP _005457217 174 49 the the DET _005457217 174 50 circumstances circumstance NOUN _005457217 174 51 detailed detail VERB _005457217 174 52 above above ADV _005457217 174 53 , , PUNCT _005457217 174 54 as as ADP _005457217 174 55 against against ADP _005457217 174 56 the the DET _005457217 174 57 written write VERB _005457217 174 58 protest protest NOUN _005457217 174 59 and and CCONJ _005457217 174 60 demand demand NOUN _005457217 174 61 of of ADP _005457217 174 62 the the DET _005457217 174 63 relator relator NOUN _005457217 174 64 , , PUNCT _005457217 174 65 a a DET _005457217 174 66 tax tax NOUN _005457217 174 67 payer payer NOUN _005457217 174 68 and and CCONJ _005457217 174 69 parent parent NOUN _005457217 174 70 in in ADP _005457217 174 71 said say VERB _005457217 174 72 school school NOUN _005457217 174 73 district district NOUN _005457217 174 74 ? ? PUNCT _005457217 175 1 somewhat somewhat ADV _005457217 175 2 more more ADV _005457217 175 3 narrowly narrowly ADV _005457217 175 4 stated state VERB _005457217 175 5 the the DET _005457217 175 6 question question NOUN _005457217 175 7 is be AUX _005457217 175 8 whether whether SCONJ _005457217 175 9 the the DET _005457217 175 10 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 175 11 of of ADP _005457217 175 12 religious religious ADJ _005457217 175 13 education education NOUN _005457217 175 14 in in ADP _005457217 175 15 the the DET _005457217 175 16 champaign champaign ADJ _005457217 175 17 public public ADJ _005457217 175 18 schools school NOUN _005457217 175 19 in in ADP _005457217 175 20 the the DET _005457217 175 21 manner manner NOUN _005457217 175 22 shown show VERB _005457217 175 23 by by ADP _005457217 175 24 the the DET _005457217 175 25 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 175 26 in in ADP _005457217 175 27 this this DET _005457217 175 28 case case NOUN _005457217 175 29 is be AUX _005457217 175 30 repugnant repugnant ADJ _005457217 175 31 to to ADP _005457217 175 32 the the DET _005457217 175 33 federal federal ADJ _005457217 175 34 and and CCONJ _005457217 175 35 state state NOUN _005457217 175 36 constitutions constitution NOUN _005457217 175 37 , , PUNCT _005457217 175 38 and and CCONJ _005457217 175 39 in in ADP _005457217 175 40 violation violation NOUN _005457217 175 41 of of ADP _005457217 175 42 the the DET _005457217 175 43 statutes statute NOUN _005457217 175 44 of of ADP _005457217 175 45 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 175 46 . . PUNCT _005457217 176 1 t t PROPN _005457217 176 2 h h PROPN _005457217 176 3 e e PROPN _005457217 176 4 l l X _005457217 176 5 a a X _005457217 176 6 w w NOUN _005457217 176 7 . . PUNCT _005457217 177 1 one one NUM _005457217 177 2 contention contention NOUN _005457217 177 3 of of ADP _005457217 177 4 the the DET _005457217 177 5 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 177 6 board board NOUN _005457217 177 7 of of ADP _005457217 177 8 education education NOUN _005457217 177 9 is be AUX _005457217 177 10 that that SCONJ _005457217 177 11 the the DET _005457217 177 12 private private ADJ _005457217 177 13 relator relator NOUN _005457217 177 14 has have VERB _005457217 177 15 no no DET _005457217 177 16 standing standing NOUN _005457217 177 17 in in ADP _005457217 177 18 court court NOUN _005457217 177 19 to to PART _005457217 177 20 bring bring VERB _005457217 177 21 this this DET _005457217 177 22 suit suit NOUN _005457217 177 23 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 177 24 that that SCONJ _005457217 177 25 affecting affect VERB _005457217 177 26 the the DET _005457217 177 27 public public ADJ _005457217 177 28 rights right NOUN _005457217 177 29 , , PUNCT _005457217 177 30 it it PRON _005457217 177 31 can can AUX _005457217 177 32 only only ADV _005457217 177 33 be be AUX _005457217 177 34 brought bring VERB _005457217 177 35 by by ADP _005457217 177 36 the the DET _005457217 177 37 state state NOUN _005457217 177 38 's 's PART _005457217 177 39 attorney attorney NOUN _005457217 177 40 or or CCONJ _005457217 177 41 the the DET _005457217 177 42 attorney attorney NOUN _005457217 177 43 general general NOUN _005457217 177 44 . . PUNCT _005457217 178 1 this this DET _005457217 178 2 contention contention NOUN _005457217 178 3 raised raise VERB _005457217 178 4 on on ADP _005457217 178 5 preliminary preliminary ADJ _005457217 178 6 motion motion NOUN _005457217 178 7 was be AUX _005457217 178 8 overruled overrule VERB _005457217 178 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 179 1 the the DET _005457217 179 2 court court NOUN _005457217 179 3 still still ADV _005457217 179 4 adheres adhere VERB _005457217 179 5 to to ADP _005457217 179 6 that that DET _005457217 179 7 ruling ruling NOUN _005457217 179 8 . . PUNCT _005457217 180 1 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 180 2 38 38 NUM _005457217 180 3 c. c. PROPN _005457217 180 4 j j PROPN _005457217 180 5 . . PUNCT _005457217 181 1 839 839 NUM _005457217 181 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 181 3 890 890 NUM _005457217 181 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 181 5 and and CCONJ _005457217 181 6 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 181 7 cases case NOUN _005457217 181 8 cited cite VERB _005457217 181 9 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 182 1 people people NOUN _005457217 182 2 v. v. PROPN _005457217 182 3 harris harris PROPN _005457217 182 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 182 5 203 203 NUM _005457217 182 6 111 111 NUM _005457217 182 7 . . PUNCT _005457217 182 8 272 272 NUM _005457217 182 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 182 10 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 183 1 another another DET _005457217 183 2 contention contention NOUN _005457217 183 3 earnestly earnestly ADV _005457217 183 4 urged urge VERB _005457217 183 5 by by ADP _005457217 183 6 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 183 7 school school NOUN _005457217 183 8 board board NOUN _005457217 183 9 is be AUX _005457217 183 10 that that SCONJ _005457217 183 11 the the DET _005457217 183 12 relator relator NOUN _005457217 183 13 who who PRON _005457217 183 14 avowedly avowedly ADV _005457217 183 15 has have VERB _005457217 183 16 no no DET _005457217 183 17 religious religious ADJ _005457217 183 18 beliefs belief NOUN _005457217 183 19 of of ADP _005457217 183 20 her her PRON _005457217 183 21 own own ADJ _005457217 183 22 at at ADV _005457217 183 23 all all PRON _005457217 183 24 is be AUX _005457217 183 25 not not PART _005457217 183 26 prosecuting prosecute VERB _005457217 183 27 this this DET _005457217 183 28 suit suit NOUN _005457217 183 29 f f X _005457217 183 30 o o X _005457217 183 31 r r NOUN _005457217 183 32 mandamus mandamus NOUN _005457217 183 33 in in ADP _005457217 183 34 good good ADJ _005457217 183 35 faith faith NOUN _005457217 183 36 to to PART _005457217 183 37 protect protect VERB _005457217 183 38 her her PRON _005457217 183 39 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 183 40 rights right NOUN _005457217 183 41 , , PUNCT _005457217 183 42 because because SCONJ _005457217 183 43 her her PRON _005457217 183 44 conduct conduct NOUN _005457217 183 45 shows show VERB _005457217 183 46 that that SCONJ _005457217 183 47 she she PRON _005457217 183 48 has have AUX _005457217 183 49 permitted permit VERB _005457217 183 50 her her PRON _005457217 183 51 child child NOUN _005457217 183 52 , , PUNCT _005457217 183 53 james james PROPN _005457217 183 54 terry terry PROPN _005457217 183 55 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 183 56 , , PUNCT _005457217 183 57 to to ADP _005457217 183 58 at16 at16 PROPN _005457217 183 59 tend tend VERB _005457217 183 60 the the DET _005457217 183 61 courses course NOUN _005457217 183 62 in in ADP _005457217 183 63 religious religious ADJ _005457217 183 64 education education NOUN _005457217 183 65 in in ADP _005457217 183 66 the the DET _005457217 183 67 schools school NOUN _005457217 183 68 , , PUNCT _005457217 183 69 and and CCONJ _005457217 183 70 even even ADV _005457217 183 71 during during ADP _005457217 183 72 the the DET _005457217 183 73 pendency pendency NOUN _005457217 183 74 of of ADP _005457217 183 75 this this DET _005457217 183 76 suit suit NOUN _005457217 183 77 has have AUX _005457217 183 78 permitted permit VERB _005457217 183 79 him he PRON _005457217 183 80 to to PART _005457217 183 81 attend attend VERB _005457217 183 82 a a DET _005457217 183 83 private private ADJ _005457217 183 84 school school NOUN _005457217 183 85 where where SCONJ _005457217 183 86 the the DET _005457217 183 87 l l NOUN _005457217 183 88 o o NOUN _005457217 183 89 r r NOUN _005457217 183 90 d d PROPN _005457217 183 91 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 183 92 s s NOUN _005457217 183 93 prayer prayer NOUN _005457217 183 94 was be AUX _005457217 183 95 recited recite VERB _005457217 183 96 , , PUNCT _005457217 183 97 and and CCONJ _005457217 183 98 reading read VERB _005457217 183 99 's be AUX _005457217 183 100 from from ADP _005457217 183 101 the the DET _005457217 183 102 bible bible PROPN _005457217 183 103 were be AUX _005457217 183 104 given give VERB _005457217 183 105 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 183 106 that that SCONJ _005457217 183 107 like like ADP _005457217 183 108 the the DET _005457217 183 109 student student NOUN _005457217 183 110 at at ADP _005457217 183 111 the the DET _005457217 183 112 university university PROPN _005457217 183 113 of of ADP _005457217 183 114 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 183 115 in in ADP _005457217 183 116 north north PROPN _005457217 183 117 v. v. PROPN _005457217 183 118 board board PROPN _005457217 183 119 of of ADP _005457217 183 120 trustees trustee NOUN _005457217 183 121 , , PUNCT _005457217 183 122 137 137 NUM _005457217 183 123 111 111 NUM _005457217 183 124 . . PUNCT _005457217 183 125 296 296 NUM _005457217 183 126 , , PUNCT _005457217 183 127 at at ADP _005457217 183 128 305 305 NUM _005457217 183 129 , , PUNCT _005457217 183 130 no no DET _005457217 183 131 real real ADJ _005457217 183 132 damage damage NOUN _005457217 183 133 has have AUX _005457217 183 134 been be AUX _005457217 183 135 or or CCONJ _005457217 183 136 is be AUX _005457217 183 137 being be AUX _005457217 183 138 done do VERB _005457217 183 139 to to ADP _005457217 183 140 mrs mrs PROPN _005457217 183 141 . . PROPN _005457217 183 142 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 183 143 in in ADP _005457217 183 144 the the DET _005457217 183 145 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 183 146 of of ADP _005457217 183 147 religious religious ADJ _005457217 183 148 education education NOUN _005457217 183 149 in in ADP _005457217 183 150 the the DET _005457217 183 151 schools school NOUN _005457217 183 152 in in ADP _005457217 183 153 the the DET _005457217 183 154 manner manner NOUN _005457217 183 155 shown show VERB _005457217 183 156 by by ADP _005457217 183 157 the the DET _005457217 183 158 record record NOUN _005457217 183 159 in in ADP _005457217 183 160 this this DET _005457217 183 161 case case NOUN _005457217 183 162 . . PUNCT _005457217 184 1 we we PRON _005457217 184 2 do do AUX _005457217 184 3 not not PART _005457217 184 4 find find VERB _005457217 184 5 it it PRON _005457217 184 6 necessary necessary ADJ _005457217 184 7 to to PART _005457217 184 8 pass pass VERB _005457217 184 9 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 184 10 this this DET _005457217 184 11 contention contention NOUN _005457217 184 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 184 13 but but CCONJ _005457217 184 14 prefer prefer VERB _005457217 184 15 to to PART _005457217 184 16 rest rest VERB _005457217 184 17 our our PRON _005457217 184 18 decision decision NOUN _005457217 184 19 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 184 20 the the DET _005457217 184 21 question question NOUN _005457217 184 22 of of ADP _005457217 184 23 the the DET _005457217 184 24 constitutionality constitutionality NOUN _005457217 184 25 and and CCONJ _005457217 184 26 legality legality NOUN _005457217 184 27 of of ADP _005457217 184 28 the the DET _005457217 184 29 acts act NOUN _005457217 184 30 of of ADP _005457217 184 31 the the DET _005457217 184 32 school school NOUN _005457217 184 33 board board NOUN _005457217 184 34 in in ADP _005457217 184 35 permitting permit VERB _005457217 184 36 religious religious ADJ _005457217 184 37 education education NOUN _005457217 184 38 to to PART _005457217 184 39 be be AUX _005457217 184 40 taught teach VERB _005457217 184 41 in in ADP _005457217 184 42 the the DET _005457217 184 43 schools school NOUN _005457217 184 44 in in ADP _005457217 184 45 the the DET _005457217 184 46 manner manner NOUN _005457217 184 47 shown show VERB _005457217 184 48 by by ADP _005457217 184 49 the the DET _005457217 184 50 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 184 51 in in ADP _005457217 184 52 this this DET _005457217 184 53 record record NOUN _005457217 184 54 . . PUNCT _005457217 185 1 " " PUNCT _005457217 185 2 we we PRON _005457217 185 3 come come VERB _005457217 185 4 then then ADV _005457217 185 5 to to ADP _005457217 185 6 the the DET _005457217 185 7 discussion discussion NOUN _005457217 185 8 of of ADP _005457217 185 9 what what PRON _005457217 185 10 relator relator NOUN _005457217 185 11 calls call VERB _005457217 185 12 her her PRON _005457217 185 13 theory theory NOUN _005457217 185 14 of of ADP _005457217 185 15 the the DET _005457217 185 16 case case NOUN _005457217 185 17 . . PUNCT _005457217 186 1 her her PRON _005457217 186 2 contention contention NOUN _005457217 186 3 is be AUX _005457217 186 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 186 5 school school NOUN _005457217 186 6 laws law NOUN _005457217 186 7 become become VERB _005457217 186 8 laws law NOUN _005457217 186 9 for for ADP _005457217 186 10 establishment establishment NOUN _005457217 186 11 of of ADP _005457217 186 12 religion religion NOUN _005457217 186 13 where where SCONJ _005457217 186 14 religious religious ADJ _005457217 186 15 education education NOUN _005457217 186 16 in in ADP _005457217 186 17 the the DET _005457217 186 18 public public ADJ _005457217 186 19 schools school NOUN _005457217 186 20 and and CCONJ _005457217 186 21 the the DET _005457217 186 22 public public ADJ _005457217 186 23 school school NOUN _005457217 186 24 houses house NOUN _005457217 186 25 aids aid NOUN _005457217 186 26 , , PUNCT _005457217 186 27 creates create VERB _005457217 186 28 and and CCONJ _005457217 186 29 increases increase VERB _005457217 186 30 interest interest NOUN _005457217 186 31 in in ADP _005457217 186 32 the the DET _005457217 186 33 religion religion NOUN _005457217 186 34 and and CCONJ _005457217 186 35 patronage patronage NOUN _005457217 186 36 of of ADP _005457217 186 37 churches church NOUN _005457217 186 38 whose whose DET _005457217 186 39 religion religion NOUN _005457217 186 40 is be AUX _005457217 186 41 being be AUX _005457217 186 42 taught teach VERB _005457217 186 43 . . PUNCT _005457217 187 1 relator relator NOUN _005457217 187 2 contends contend VERB _005457217 187 3 the the DET _005457217 187 4 champaign champaign NOUN _005457217 187 5 system system NOUN _005457217 187 6 of of ADP _005457217 187 7 religious religious ADJ _005457217 187 8 education education NOUN _005457217 187 9 violates violate VERB _005457217 187 10 the the DET _005457217 187 11 f f NOUN _005457217 188 1 i i PRON _005457217 188 2 r r VERB _005457217 188 3 s s X _005457217 188 4 t t NOUN _005457217 188 5 and and CCONJ _005457217 188 6 fourteenth fourteenth ADJ _005457217 188 7 amendments amendment NOUN _005457217 188 8 to to ADP _005457217 188 9 the the DET _005457217 188 10 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 188 11 of of ADP _005457217 188 12 the the DET _005457217 188 13 united united PROPN _005457217 188 14 states states PROPN _005457217 188 15 . . PUNCT _005457217 189 1 amendment amendment NOUN _005457217 189 2 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 189 3 i i NOUN _005457217 189 4 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 189 5 provides provide VERB _005457217 189 6 : : PUNCT _005457217 189 7 '' '' PUNCT _005457217 189 8 congress congress PROPN _005457217 189 9 shall shall AUX _005457217 189 10 make make VERB _005457217 189 11 no no DET _005457217 189 12 law law NOUN _005457217 189 13 respecting respect VERB _005457217 189 14 an an DET _005457217 189 15 establishment establishment NOUN _005457217 189 16 of of ADP _005457217 189 17 religion religion NOUN _005457217 189 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 189 19 or or CCONJ _005457217 189 20 prohibiting prohibit VERB _005457217 189 21 the the DET _005457217 189 22 free free ADJ _005457217 189 23 exercise exercise NOUN _005457217 189 24 t t NOUN _005457217 189 25 h h NOUN _005457217 189 26 e e X _005457217 189 27 r r NOUN _005457217 189 28 e e X _005457217 189 29 o o NOUN _005457217 189 30 f f X _005457217 189 31 " " PUNCT _005457217 189 32 and and CCONJ _005457217 189 33 we we PRON _005457217 189 34 agree agree VERB _005457217 189 35 with with ADP _005457217 189 36 relator relator NOUN _005457217 189 37 's 's PART _005457217 189 38 counsel counsel NOUN _005457217 189 39 , , PUNCT _005457217 189 40 that that SCONJ _005457217 189 41 the the DET _005457217 189 42 fourteenth fourteenth ADJ _005457217 189 43 amendment amendment NOUN _005457217 189 44 to to ADP _005457217 189 45 the the DET _005457217 189 46 federal federal ADJ _005457217 189 47 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 189 48 , , PUNCT _005457217 189 49 section section NOUN _005457217 189 50 1 1 NUM _005457217 189 51 , , PUNCT _005457217 189 52 which which PRON _005457217 189 53 provides provide VERB _005457217 189 54 : : PUNCT _005457217 189 55 " " PUNCT _005457217 189 56 n n CCONJ _005457217 189 57 o o NOUN _005457217 189 58 state state NOUN _005457217 189 59 shall shall AUX _005457217 189 60 make make VERB _005457217 189 61 or or CCONJ _005457217 189 62 enforce enforce VERB _005457217 189 63 any any DET _005457217 189 64 law law NOUN _005457217 189 65 which which PRON _005457217 189 66 shall shall AUX _005457217 189 67 abridge abridge VERB _005457217 189 68 the the DET _005457217 189 69 privileges privilege NOUN _005457217 189 70 or or CCONJ _005457217 189 71 immunities immunity NOUN _005457217 189 72 of of ADP _005457217 189 73 citizens citizen NOUN _005457217 189 74 of of ADP _005457217 189 75 the the DET _005457217 189 76 united united PROPN _005457217 189 77 s s PROPN _005457217 189 78 t t PROPN _005457217 189 79 a a DET _005457217 189 80 t t NOUN _005457217 189 81 e e NOUN _005457217 189 82 s s NOUN _005457217 189 83 , , PUNCT _005457217 189 84 " " PUNCT _005457217 189 85 extends extend VERB _005457217 189 86 the the DET _005457217 189 87 operation operation NOUN _005457217 189 88 of of ADP _005457217 189 89 the the DET _005457217 189 90 f f NOUN _005457217 190 1 i i PRON _005457217 190 2 r r VERB _005457217 190 3 s s PART _005457217 190 4 t t NOUN _005457217 190 5 amendment amendment NOUN _005457217 190 6 to to ADP _005457217 190 7 the the DET _005457217 190 8 federal federal ADJ _005457217 190 9 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 190 10 to to ADP _005457217 190 11 the the DET _005457217 190 12 state state NOUN _005457217 190 13 of of ADP _005457217 190 14 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 190 15 and and CCONJ _005457217 190 16 its its PRON _005457217 190 17 school school NOUN _005457217 190 18 subdivisions subdivision NOUN _005457217 190 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 190 20 including include VERB _005457217 190 21 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 190 22 . . PUNCT _005457217 191 1 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 191 2 w w ADP _005457217 191 3 e e PROPN _005457217 191 4 s s PROPN _005457217 191 5 t t PROPN _005457217 191 6 virginia virginia PROPN _005457217 191 7 v. v. PROPN _005457217 191 8 barnette barnette PROPN _005457217 191 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 191 10 319 319 NUM _005457217 191 11 u. u. PROPN _005457217 191 12 s. s. PROPN _005457217 191 13 624 624 NUM _005457217 191 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 191 15 63 63 NUM _005457217 191 16 sup sup NOUN _005457217 191 17 . . PUNCT _005457217 192 1 ct ct PROPN _005457217 192 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 193 1 1178 1178 NUM _005457217 193 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 193 3 1185 1185 NUM _005457217 193 4 . . PUNCT _005457217 193 5 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 194 1 17 17 NUM _005457217 194 2 the the DET _005457217 194 3 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 194 4 of of ADP _005457217 194 5 the the DET _005457217 194 6 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 194 7 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 194 8 relied rely VERB _005457217 194 9 on on ADP _005457217 194 10 are be AUX _005457217 194 11 contained contain VERB _005457217 194 12 in in ADP _005457217 194 13 article article PROPN _005457217 194 14 ii ii PROPN _005457217 194 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 194 16 section section NOUN _005457217 194 17 3 3 NUM _005457217 194 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 194 19 which which PRON _005457217 194 20 are be AUX _005457217 194 21 as as SCONJ _005457217 194 22 follows follow VERB _005457217 194 23 : : PUNCT _005457217 194 24 " " PUNCT _005457217 194 25 t t NOUN _005457217 194 26 h h NOUN _005457217 194 27 e e X _005457217 194 28 f f X _005457217 194 29 r r NOUN _005457217 194 30 e e NOUN _005457217 194 31 e e NOUN _005457217 194 32 exercise exercise NOUN _005457217 194 33 and and CCONJ _005457217 194 34 .enjoyment .enjoyment NUM _005457217 194 35 of of ADP _005457217 194 36 religious religious ADJ _005457217 194 37 profession profession NOUN _005457217 194 38 and and CCONJ _005457217 194 39 worship worship NOUN _005457217 194 40 , , PUNCT _005457217 194 41 without without ADP _005457217 194 42 discrimination discrimination NOUN _005457217 194 43 , , PUNCT _005457217 194 44 shall shall AUX _005457217 194 45 forever forever ADV _005457217 194 46 be be AUX _005457217 194 47 guaranteed guarantee VERB _005457217 194 48 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 194 49 and and CCONJ _005457217 194 50 no no DET _005457217 194 51 person person NOUN _005457217 194 52 shall shall AUX _005457217 194 53 be be AUX _005457217 194 54 denied deny VERB _005457217 194 55 any any DET _005457217 194 56 civil civil ADJ _005457217 194 57 or or CCONJ _005457217 194 58 political political ADJ _005457217 194 59 right right NOUN _005457217 194 60 , , PUNCT _005457217 194 61 privilege privilege NOUN _005457217 194 62 or or CCONJ _005457217 194 63 capacity capacity NOUN _005457217 194 64 , , PUNCT _005457217 194 65 on on ADP _005457217 194 66 account account NOUN _005457217 194 67 of of ADP _005457217 194 68 his his PRON _005457217 194 69 religious religious ADJ _005457217 194 70 opinions opinion NOUN _005457217 194 71 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 194 72 . . PUNCT _005457217 194 73 . . PUNCT _005457217 194 74 . . PUNCT _005457217 195 1 no no DET _005457217 195 2 person person NOUN _005457217 195 3 shall shall AUX _005457217 195 4 be be AUX _005457217 195 5 required require VERB _005457217 195 6 to to PART _005457217 195 7 attend attend VERB _005457217 195 8 or or CCONJ _005457217 195 9 support support VERB _005457217 195 10 any any DET _005457217 195 11 ministry ministry NOUN _005457217 195 12 or or CCONJ _005457217 195 13 place place NOUN _005457217 195 14 of of ADP _005457217 195 15 worship worship NOUN _005457217 195 16 against against ADP _005457217 195 17 his his PRON _005457217 195 18 consent consent NOUN _005457217 195 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 195 20 nor nor CCONJ _005457217 195 21 shall shall AUX _005457217 195 22 any any DET _005457217 195 23 preference preference NOUN _005457217 195 24 be be AUX _005457217 195 25 given give VERB _005457217 195 26 by by ADP _005457217 195 27 law law NOUN _005457217 195 28 to to ADP _005457217 195 29 any any DET _005457217 195 30 religious religious ADJ _005457217 195 31 denomination denomination NOUN _005457217 195 32 or or CCONJ _005457217 195 33 mode mode NOUN _005457217 195 34 of of ADP _005457217 195 35 worship worship NOUN _005457217 195 36 . . PUNCT _005457217 195 37 " " PUNCT _005457217 196 1 and and CCONJ _005457217 196 2 article article NOUN _005457217 196 3 .viii .viii NUM _005457217 196 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 196 5 section section NOUN _005457217 196 6 3 3 NUM _005457217 196 7 of of ADP _005457217 196 8 the the DET _005457217 196 9 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 196 10 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 196 11 which which PRON _005457217 196 12 provides provide VERB _005457217 196 13 : : PUNCT _005457217 196 14 " " PUNCT _005457217 196 15 neither neither CCONJ _005457217 196 16 the the DET _005457217 196 17 general general ADJ _005457217 196 18 assembly assembly NOUN _005457217 196 19 nor nor CCONJ _005457217 196 20 any any PRON _005457217 196 21 . . PUNCT _005457217 196 22 . . PUNCT _005457217 197 1 school school NOUN _005457217 197 2 district district NOUN _005457217 197 3 . . PUNCT _005457217 197 4 . . PUNCT _005457217 198 1 . . PUNCT _005457217 199 1 shall shall AUX _005457217 199 2 ever ever ADV _005457217 199 3 make make VERB _005457217 199 4 any any DET _005457217 199 5 appropriation appropriation NOUN _005457217 199 6 or or CCONJ _005457217 199 7 pay pay NOUN _005457217 199 8 from from ADP _005457217 199 9 any any DET _005457217 199 10 public public ADJ _005457217 199 11 f f PROPN _005457217 199 12 u u PROPN _005457217 199 13 n n ADV _005457217 199 14 d d PROPN _005457217 199 15 whatever whatever PRON _005457217 199 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 199 17 anything anything PRON _005457217 199 18 in in ADP _005457217 199 19 aid aid NOUN _005457217 199 20 of of ADP _005457217 199 21 any any DET _005457217 199 22 church church NOUN _005457217 199 23 or or CCONJ _005457217 199 24 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 199 25 p p NOUN _005457217 199 26 u u NOUN _005457217 200 1 r r X _005457217 200 2 p p NOUN _005457217 200 3 o o NOUN _005457217 200 4 s s NOUN _005457217 200 5 e e NOUN _005457217 200 6 . . PUNCT _005457217 200 7 " " PUNCT _005457217 201 1 a a DET _005457217 201 2 careful careful ADJ _005457217 201 3 reading reading NOUN _005457217 201 4 of of ADP _005457217 201 5 the the DET _005457217 201 6 federal federal ADJ _005457217 201 7 and and CCONJ _005457217 201 8 state state NOUN _005457217 201 9 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 201 10 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 201 11 leads lead VERB _005457217 201 12 us we PRON _005457217 201 13 to to PART _005457217 201 14 believe believe VERB _005457217 201 15 that that SCONJ _005457217 201 16 one one PRON _005457217 201 17 covers cover VERB _005457217 201 18 the the DET _005457217 201 19 same same ADJ _005457217 201 20 ground ground NOUN _005457217 201 21 as as ADP _005457217 201 22 the the DET _005457217 201 23 other other ADJ _005457217 201 24 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 201 25 that that SCONJ _005457217 201 26 if if SCONJ _005457217 201 27 anything anything PRON _005457217 201 28 our our PRON _005457217 201 29 own own ADJ _005457217 201 30 state state NOUN _005457217 201 31 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 201 32 is be AUX _005457217 201 33 more more ADV _005457217 201 34 specifically specifically ADV _005457217 201 35 stringent stringent ADJ _005457217 201 36 than than ADP _005457217 201 37 the the DET _005457217 201 38 federal federal NOUN _005457217 201 39 . . PUNCT _005457217 202 1 two two NUM _005457217 202 2 thoughts thought NOUN _005457217 202 3 are be AUX _005457217 202 4 expressed express VERB _005457217 202 5 in in ADP _005457217 202 6 the the DET _005457217 202 7 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 202 8 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 202 9 : : PUNCT _005457217 202 10 first first ADV _005457217 202 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 202 12 that that SCONJ _005457217 202 13 no no DET _005457217 202 14 political political ADJ _005457217 202 15 entity entity NOUN _005457217 202 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 202 17 including include VERB _005457217 202 18 both both DET _005457217 202 19 legislatures legislature NOUN _005457217 202 20 and and CCONJ _005457217 202 21 school school NOUN _005457217 202 22 boards board NOUN _005457217 202 23 , , PUNCT _005457217 202 24 has have VERB _005457217 202 25 power power NOUN _005457217 202 26 to to PART _005457217 202 27 set set VERB _005457217 202 28 up up ADP _005457217 202 29 a a DET _005457217 202 30 state state NOUN _005457217 202 31 church church NOUN _005457217 202 32 , , PUNCT _005457217 202 33 requiring require VERB _005457217 202 34 the the DET _005457217 202 35 citizens citizen NOUN _005457217 202 36 to to PART _005457217 202 37 pay pay VERB _005457217 202 38 taxes taxis NOUN _005457217 202 39 for for ADP _005457217 202 40 one one NUM _005457217 202 41 form form NOUN _005457217 202 42 of of ADP _005457217 202 43 religion religion NOUN _005457217 202 44 as as ADP _005457217 202 45 distinct distinct ADJ _005457217 202 46 from from ADP _005457217 202 47 any any DET _005457217 202 48 other other ADJ _005457217 202 49 religion religion NOUN _005457217 202 50 or or CCONJ _005457217 202 51 lack lack NOUN _005457217 202 52 of of ADP _005457217 202 53 religion religion NOUN _005457217 202 54 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 202 55 secondly secondly ADV _005457217 202 56 , , PUNCT _005457217 202 57 that that SCONJ _005457217 202 58 no no DET _005457217 202 59 political political ADJ _005457217 202 60 entity entity NOUN _005457217 202 61 has have VERB _005457217 202 62 power power NOUN _005457217 202 63 to to PART _005457217 202 64 make make VERB _005457217 202 65 any any DET _005457217 202 66 law law NOUN _005457217 202 67 or or CCONJ _005457217 202 68 ordinance ordinance NOUN _005457217 202 69 , , PUNCT _005457217 202 70 or or CCONJ _005457217 202 71 regulation regulation NOUN _005457217 202 72 prohibiting prohibit VERB _005457217 202 73 the the DET _005457217 202 74 freedom freedom NOUN _005457217 202 75 of of ADP _005457217 202 76 the the DET _005457217 202 77 exercise exercise NOUN _005457217 202 78 of of ADP _005457217 202 79 religion religion NOUN _005457217 202 80 by by ADP _005457217 202 81 the the DET _005457217 202 82 people people NOUN _005457217 202 83 . . PUNCT _005457217 203 1 what what PRON _005457217 203 2 do do AUX _005457217 203 3 the the DET _005457217 203 4 federal federal ADJ _005457217 203 5 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 203 6 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 203 7 mean mean VERB _005457217 203 8 : : PUNCT _005457217 203 9 that that SCONJ _005457217 203 10 " " PUNCT _005457217 203 11 congress congress PROPN _005457217 203 12 shall shall AUX _005457217 203 13 make make VERB _005457217 203 14 no no DET _005457217 203 15 law law NOUN _005457217 203 16 respecting respect VERB _005457217 203 17 an an DET _005457217 203 18 establishment establishment NOUN _005457217 203 19 of of ADP _005457217 203 20 religion religion NOUN _005457217 203 21 " " PUNCT _005457217 203 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 203 23 and and CCONJ _005457217 203 24 the the DET _005457217 203 25 kindred kindre VERB _005457217 203 26 provision provision NOUN _005457217 203 27 t t PROPN _005457217 203 28 h h X _005457217 203 29 a a DET _005457217 203 30 t t NOUN _005457217 203 31 : : PUNCT _005457217 203 32 " " PUNCT _005457217 203 33 t t NOUN _005457217 203 34 h h NOUN _005457217 203 35 e e X _005457217 203 36 f f X _005457217 203 37 r r NOUN _005457217 203 38 e e NOUN _005457217 203 39 e e NOUN _005457217 203 40 exercise exercise NOUN _005457217 203 41 and and CCONJ _005457217 203 42 enjoyment enjoyment NOUN _005457217 203 43 of of ADP _005457217 203 44 religious religious ADJ _005457217 203 45 profes18 profes18 NOUN _005457217 203 46 sion sion NOUN _005457217 203 47 and and CCONJ _005457217 203 48 worship worship NOUN _005457217 203 49 , , PUNCT _005457217 203 50 without without ADP _005457217 203 51 discrimination discrimination NOUN _005457217 203 52 , , PUNCT _005457217 203 53 shall shall AUX _005457217 203 54 forever forever ADV _005457217 203 55 be be AUX _005457217 203 56 guaranteed guarantee VERB _005457217 203 57 " " PUNCT _005457217 203 58 ? ? PUNCT _005457217 204 1 at at ADP _005457217 204 2 the the DET _005457217 204 3 time time NOUN _005457217 204 4 the the DET _005457217 204 5 colonists colonist NOUN _005457217 204 6 came come VERB _005457217 204 7 to to ADP _005457217 204 8 this this DET _005457217 204 9 continent continent NOUN _005457217 204 10 before before ADP _005457217 204 11 the the DET _005457217 204 12 revolution revolution NOUN _005457217 204 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 204 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 204 15 at at ADP _005457217 204 16 the the DET _005457217 204 17 time time NOUN _005457217 204 18 the the DET _005457217 204 19 federal federal ADJ _005457217 204 20 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 204 21 was be AUX _005457217 204 22 written write VERB _005457217 204 23 , , PUNCT _005457217 204 24 the the DET _005457217 204 25 church church NOUN _005457217 204 26 of of ADP _005457217 204 27 the the DET _005457217 204 28 mother mother NOUN _005457217 204 29 country country NOUN _005457217 204 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 204 31 england england PROPN _005457217 204 32 , , PUNCT _005457217 204 33 was be AUX _005457217 204 34 known know VERB _005457217 204 35 as as ADP _005457217 204 36 the the DET _005457217 204 37 " " PUNCT _005457217 204 38 established establish VERB _005457217 204 39 church church NOUN _005457217 204 40 . . PUNCT _005457217 204 41 " " PUNCT _005457217 205 1 i i PRON _005457217 205 2 t t PROPN _005457217 205 3 was be AUX _005457217 205 4 a a DET _005457217 205 5 church church NOUN _005457217 205 6 f f PROPN _005457217 205 7 o o X _005457217 205 8 r r NOUN _005457217 205 9 whose whose DET _005457217 205 10 support support NOUN _005457217 205 11 everybody everybody PRON _005457217 205 12 in in ADP _005457217 205 13 england england PROPN _005457217 205 14 was be AUX _005457217 205 15 required require VERB _005457217 205 16 to to PART _005457217 205 17 pay pay VERB _005457217 205 18 taxes taxis NOUN _005457217 205 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 205 20 although although SCONJ _005457217 205 21 many many ADJ _005457217 205 22 of of ADP _005457217 205 23 the the DET _005457217 205 24 citizens citizen NOUN _005457217 205 25 of of ADP _005457217 205 26 england england PROPN _005457217 205 27 did do AUX _005457217 205 28 not not PART _005457217 205 29 believe believe VERB _005457217 205 30 in in ADP _005457217 205 31 the the DET _005457217 205 32 doctrines doctrine NOUN _005457217 205 33 of of ADP _005457217 205 34 that that DET _005457217 205 35 church church NOUN _005457217 205 36 . . PUNCT _005457217 206 1 even even ADV _005457217 206 2 among among ADP _005457217 206 3 the the DET _005457217 206 4 colonists colonist NOUN _005457217 206 5 some some DET _005457217 206 6 particular particular ADJ _005457217 206 7 sects sect NOUN _005457217 206 8 had have VERB _005457217 206 9 the the DET _005457217 206 10 taxing tax VERB _005457217 206 11 support support NOUN _005457217 206 12 of of ADP _005457217 206 13 the the DET _005457217 206 14 various various ADJ _005457217 206 15 states state NOUN _005457217 206 16 before before ADV _005457217 206 17 and and CCONJ _005457217 206 18 a a DET _005457217 206 19 f f NOUN _005457217 206 20 t t NOUN _005457217 206 21 e e NOUN _005457217 206 22 r r X _005457217 206 23 the the DET _005457217 206 24 writing writing NOUN _005457217 206 25 of of ADP _005457217 206 26 the the DET _005457217 206 27 federal federal ADJ _005457217 206 28 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 206 29 . . PUNCT _005457217 207 1 i i PRON _005457217 207 2 t t NOUN _005457217 207 3 seems seem VERB _005457217 207 4 plain plain ADJ _005457217 207 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 207 6 the the DET _005457217 207 7 primary primary ADJ _005457217 207 8 object object NOUN _005457217 207 9 sought seek VERB _005457217 207 10 to to PART _005457217 207 11 be be AUX _005457217 207 12 obtained obtain VERB _005457217 207 13 in in ADP _005457217 207 14 the the DET _005457217 207 15 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 207 16 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 207 17 was be AUX _005457217 207 18 that that SCONJ _005457217 207 19 there there PRON _005457217 207 20 should should AUX _005457217 207 21 be be AUX _005457217 207 22 no no DET _005457217 207 23 state state NOUN _005457217 207 24 church church NOUN _005457217 207 25 . . PUNCT _005457217 208 1 in in ADP _005457217 208 2 this this DET _005457217 208 3 sense sense NOUN _005457217 208 4 there there PRON _005457217 208 5 is be VERB _005457217 208 6 no no DET _005457217 208 7 question question NOUN _005457217 208 8 but but CCONJ _005457217 208 9 that that SCONJ _005457217 208 10 the the DET _005457217 208 11 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 208 12 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 208 13 sought seek VERB _005457217 208 14 a a DET _005457217 208 15 separation separation NOUN _005457217 208 16 of of ADP _005457217 208 17 the the DET _005457217 208 18 powers power NOUN _005457217 208 19 of of ADP _005457217 208 20 church church NOUN _005457217 208 21 and and CCONJ _005457217 208 22 state state NOUN _005457217 208 23 , , PUNCT _005457217 208 24 but but CCONJ _005457217 208 25 relator relator NOUN _005457217 208 26 's 's PART _005457217 208 27 counsel counsel NOUN _005457217 208 28 in in ADP _005457217 208 29 their their PRON _005457217 208 30 brief brief ADJ _005457217 208 31 give give VERB _005457217 208 32 this this DET _005457217 208 33 phrase phrase NOUN _005457217 208 34 " " PUNCT _005457217 208 35 t t NOUN _005457217 208 36 h h NOUN _005457217 208 37 e e NOUN _005457217 208 38 separation separation NOUN _005457217 208 39 of of ADP _005457217 208 40 church church NOUN _005457217 208 41 and and CCONJ _005457217 208 42 s s NOUN _005457217 208 43 t t NOUN _005457217 208 44 a a DET _005457217 208 45 t t NOUN _005457217 208 46 e e NOUN _005457217 208 47 , , PUNCT _005457217 208 48 " " PUNCT _005457217 208 49 a a DET _005457217 208 50 f f X _005457217 208 51 a a DET _005457217 208 52 r r NOUN _005457217 208 53 broader broad ADJ _005457217 208 54 meaning meaning NOUN _005457217 208 55 . . PUNCT _005457217 209 1 they they PRON _005457217 209 2 say say VERB _005457217 209 3 that that SCONJ _005457217 209 4 religion religion NOUN _005457217 209 5 can can AUX _005457217 209 6 not not PART _005457217 209 7 be be AUX _005457217 209 8 brought bring VERB _005457217 209 9 into into ADP _005457217 209 10 the the DET _005457217 209 11 public public ADJ _005457217 209 12 schools school NOUN _005457217 209 13 without without ADP _005457217 209 14 abridging abridge VERB _005457217 209 15 the the DET _005457217 209 16 rights right NOUN _005457217 209 17 of of ADP _005457217 209 18 every every DET _005457217 209 19 person person NOUN _005457217 209 20 in in ADP _005457217 209 21 this this DET _005457217 209 22 count count NOUN _005457217 209 23 r r NOUN _005457217 209 24 y y PROPN _005457217 209 25 to to ADP _005457217 209 26 his his PRON _005457217 209 27 inalienable inalienable ADJ _005457217 209 28 rights right NOUN _005457217 209 29 to to PART _005457217 209 30 worship worship VERB _005457217 209 31 as as ADP _005457217 209 32 he he PRON _005457217 209 33 so so SCONJ _005457217 209 34 desires desire NOUN _005457217 209 35 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 209 36 that that SCONJ _005457217 209 37 the the DET _005457217 209 38 realm realm NOUN _005457217 209 39 of of ADP _005457217 209 40 religion religion NOUN _005457217 209 41 is be AUX _005457217 209 42 entirely entirely ADV _005457217 209 43 beyond beyond ADP _005457217 209 44 the the DET _005457217 209 45 scope scope NOUN _005457217 209 46 of of ADP _005457217 209 47 the the DET _005457217 209 48 state state NOUN _005457217 209 49 , , PUNCT _005457217 209 50 that that SCONJ _005457217 209 51 the the DET _005457217 209 52 bulwark bulwark NOUN _005457217 209 53 of of ADP _005457217 209 54 religious religious ADJ _005457217 209 55 training training NOUN _005457217 209 56 is be AUX _005457217 209 57 found find VERB _005457217 209 58 in in ADP _005457217 209 59 the the DET _005457217 209 60 home home NOUN _005457217 209 61 and and CCONJ _005457217 209 62 in in ADP _005457217 209 63 a a DET _005457217 209 64 fully fully ADV _005457217 209 65 supported support VERB _005457217 209 66 church church NOUN _005457217 209 67 program program NOUN _005457217 209 68 of of ADP _005457217 209 69 child child NOUN _005457217 209 70 education education NOUN _005457217 209 71 . . PUNCT _005457217 210 1 in in ADP _005457217 210 2 their their PRON _005457217 210 3 reply reply NOUN _005457217 210 4 brief brief ADJ _005457217 210 5 relator relator NOUN _005457217 210 6 's 's PART _005457217 210 7 counsel counsel NOUN _005457217 210 8 say say VERB _005457217 210 9 : : PUNCT _005457217 210 10 " " PUNCT _005457217 210 11 t t NOUN _005457217 210 12 h h NOUN _005457217 210 13 e e NOUN _005457217 210 14 whole whole ADJ _005457217 210 15 scheme scheme NOUN _005457217 210 16 provides provide VERB _005457217 210 17 a a DET _005457217 210 18 business business NOUN _005457217 210 19 of of ADP _005457217 210 20 religious religious ADJ _005457217 210 21 promotion promotion NOUN _005457217 210 22 for for ADP _005457217 210 23 which which PRON _005457217 210 24 money money NOUN _005457217 210 25 may may AUX _005457217 210 26 be be AUX _005457217 210 27 collected collect VERB _005457217 210 28 and and CCONJ _005457217 210 29 salaries salary NOUN _005457217 210 30 paid pay VERB _005457217 210 31 . . PUNCT _005457217 210 32 . . PUNCT _005457217 210 33 . . PUNCT _005457217 210 34 . . PUNCT _005457217 211 1 i i PRON _005457217 211 2 t t NOUN _005457217 211 3 seems seem VERB _005457217 211 4 to to PART _005457217 211 5 be be AUX _005457217 211 6 a a DET _005457217 211 7 mercenary mercenary ADJ _005457217 211 8 business business NOUN _005457217 211 9 venture venture NOUN _005457217 211 10 which which PRON _005457217 211 11 must must AUX _005457217 211 12 eventually eventually ADV _005457217 211 13 clash clash VERB _005457217 211 14 with with ADP _005457217 211 15 the the DET _005457217 211 16 l l NOUN _005457217 211 17 a a X _005457217 211 18 w w NOUN _005457217 211 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 211 20 " " PUNCT _005457217 212 1 f f PROPN _005457217 213 1 o o X _005457217 213 2 r r NOUN _005457217 213 3 the the DET _005457217 213 4 construction construction NOUN _005457217 213 5 of of ADP _005457217 213 6 the the DET _005457217 213 7 word word NOUN _005457217 213 8 " " PUNCT _005457217 213 9 e e PROPN _005457217 213 10 s s VERB _005457217 213 11 t t PROPN _005457217 213 12 a a PRON _005457217 214 1 b b X _005457217 214 2 l l NOUN _005457217 215 1 i i PRON _005457217 215 2 s s VERB _005457217 215 3 h h NOUN _005457217 215 4 m m VERB _005457217 215 5 e e PROPN _005457217 215 6 n n NOUN _005457217 215 7 t t PROPN _005457217 215 8 " " PUNCT _005457217 215 9 in in ADP _005457217 215 10 the the DET _005457217 215 11 federal federal ADJ _005457217 215 12 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 215 13 we we PRON _005457217 215 14 are be AUX _005457217 215 15 referred refer VERB _005457217 215 16 by by ADP _005457217 215 17 relator relator NOUN _005457217 215 18 to to ADP _005457217 215 19 davis davis PROPN _005457217 215 20 v. v. PROPN _005457217 215 21 beason beason PROPN _005457217 215 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 215 23 133 133 NUM _005457217 215 24 u. u. PROPN _005457217 215 25 s. s. PROPN _005457217 215 26 333 333 NUM _005457217 215 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 215 28 342 342 NUM _005457217 215 29 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 215 30 10 10 NUM _005457217 215 31 sup sup NOUN _005457217 215 32 . . PUNCT _005457217 216 1 ct ct PROPN _005457217 216 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 217 1 299 299 NUM _005457217 217 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 217 3 300 300 NUM _005457217 217 4 . . NUM _005457217 218 1 19 19 NUM _005457217 219 1 i i PRON _005457217 219 2 n n ADP _005457217 219 3 that that DET _005457217 219 4 case case NOUN _005457217 219 5 the the DET _005457217 219 6 court court NOUN _005457217 219 7 was be AUX _005457217 219 8 dealing deal VERB _005457217 219 9 with with ADP _005457217 219 10 the the DET _005457217 219 11 validity validity NOUN _005457217 219 12 of of ADP _005457217 219 13 a a DET _005457217 219 14 law law NOUN _005457217 219 15 of of ADP _005457217 219 16 the the DET _005457217 219 17 territory territory NOUN _005457217 219 18 of of ADP _005457217 219 19 idaho idaho NOUN _005457217 219 20 which which PRON _005457217 219 21 provided provide VERB _005457217 219 22 that that DET _005457217 219 23 bigamists bigamist NOUN _005457217 219 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 219 25 polygamists polygamist NOUN _005457217 219 26 , , PUNCT _005457217 219 27 and and CCONJ _005457217 219 28 believers believer NOUN _005457217 219 29 in in ADP _005457217 219 30 plural plural ADJ _005457217 219 31 or or CCONJ _005457217 219 32 celestial celestial ADJ _005457217 219 33 marriages marriage NOUN _005457217 219 34 were be AUX _005457217 219 35 denied deny VERB _005457217 219 36 the the DET _005457217 219 37 right right NOUN _005457217 219 38 of of ADP _005457217 219 39 franchise franchise NOUN _005457217 219 40 . . PUNCT _005457217 220 1 the the DET _005457217 220 2 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 220 3 court court PROPN _005457217 220 4 held hold VERB _005457217 220 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 220 6 this this DET _005457217 220 7 statute statute NOUN _005457217 220 8 was be AUX _005457217 220 9 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 220 10 . . PUNCT _005457217 221 1 in in ADP _005457217 221 2 reply reply NOUN _005457217 221 3 to to ADP _005457217 221 4 the the DET _005457217 221 5 contention contention NOUN _005457217 221 6 that that SCONJ _005457217 221 7 the the DET _005457217 221 8 mormon mormon ADJ _005457217 221 9 religion religion NOUN _005457217 221 10 was be AUX _005457217 221 11 protected protect VERB _005457217 221 12 by by ADP _005457217 221 13 the the DET _005457217 221 14 federal federal ADJ _005457217 221 15 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 221 16 the the DET _005457217 221 17 court court NOUN _005457217 221 18 said say VERB _005457217 221 19 : : PUNCT _005457217 221 20 " " PUNCT _005457217 221 21 t t NOUN _005457217 221 22 h h X _005457217 221 23 e e X _005457217 221 24 first first ADJ _005457217 221 25 amendment amendment NOUN _005457217 221 26 to to ADP _005457217 221 27 the the DET _005457217 221 28 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 221 29 , , PUNCT _005457217 221 30 in in ADP _005457217 221 31 declaring declare VERB _005457217 221 32 that that SCONJ _005457217 221 33 congress congress PROPN _005457217 221 34 shall shall AUX _005457217 221 35 make make VERB _005457217 221 36 no no DET _005457217 221 37 law law NOUN _005457217 221 38 respecting respect VERB _005457217 221 39 the the DET _005457217 221 40 establishment establishment NOUN _005457217 221 41 of of ADP _005457217 221 42 religion religion NOUN _005457217 221 43 or or CCONJ _005457217 221 44 forbidding forbid VERB _005457217 221 45 the the DET _005457217 221 46 free free ADJ _005457217 221 47 exercise exercise NOUN _005457217 221 48 thereof thereof ADV _005457217 221 49 , , PUNCT _005457217 221 50 was be AUX _005457217 221 51 intended intend VERB _005457217 221 52 to to PART _005457217 221 53 allow allow VERB _005457217 221 54 every every DET _005457217 221 55 one one NUM _005457217 221 56 under under ADP _005457217 221 57 the the DET _005457217 221 58 jurisdiction jurisdiction NOUN _005457217 221 59 of of ADP _005457217 221 60 the the DET _005457217 221 61 united united PROPN _005457217 221 62 states states PROPN _005457217 221 63 to to PART _005457217 221 64 entertain entertain VERB _005457217 221 65 such such ADJ _005457217 221 66 notions notion NOUN _005457217 221 67 respecting respect VERB _005457217 221 68 his his PRON _005457217 221 69 relations relation NOUN _005457217 221 70 to to ADP _005457217 221 71 his his PRON _005457217 221 72 maker maker NOUN _005457217 221 73 and and CCONJ _005457217 221 74 the the DET _005457217 221 75 duties duty NOUN _005457217 221 76 they they PRON _005457217 221 77 impose impose VERB _005457217 221 78 as as SCONJ _005457217 221 79 may may AUX _005457217 221 80 be be AUX _005457217 221 81 approved approve VERB _005457217 221 82 by by ADP _005457217 221 83 his his PRON _005457217 221 84 judgment judgment NOUN _005457217 221 85 and and CCONJ _005457217 221 86 conscience conscience NOUN _005457217 221 87 , , PUNCT _005457217 221 88 and and CCONJ _005457217 221 89 to to PART _005457217 221 90 exhibit exhibit VERB _005457217 221 91 his his PRON _005457217 221 92 sentiments sentiment NOUN _005457217 221 93 in in ADP _005457217 221 94 such such ADJ _005457217 221 95 form form NOUN _005457217 221 96 of of ADP _005457217 221 97 worship worship NOUN _005457217 221 98 as as SCONJ _005457217 221 99 he he PRON _005457217 221 100 may may AUX _005457217 221 101 think think VERB _005457217 221 102 proper proper ADJ _005457217 221 103 , , PUNCT _005457217 221 104 not not PART _005457217 221 105 injurious injurious ADJ _005457217 221 106 to to ADP _005457217 221 107 the the DET _005457217 221 108 equal equal ADJ _005457217 221 109 rights right NOUN _005457217 221 110 of of ADP _005457217 221 111 others other NOUN _005457217 221 112 , , PUNCT _005457217 221 113 and and CCONJ _005457217 221 114 to to PART _005457217 221 115 prohibit prohibit VERB _005457217 221 116 legislation legislation NOUN _005457217 222 1 f f PROPN _005457217 222 2 o o X _005457217 222 3 r r NOUN _005457217 222 4 the the DET _005457217 222 5 support support NOUN _005457217 222 6 of of ADP _005457217 222 7 any any DET _005457217 222 8 religious religious ADJ _005457217 222 9 tenets tenet NOUN _005457217 222 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 222 11 or or CCONJ _005457217 222 12 the the DET _005457217 222 13 modes mode NOUN _005457217 222 14 of of ADP _005457217 222 15 worship worship NOUN _005457217 222 16 of of ADP _005457217 222 17 any any DET _005457217 222 18 sect sect NOUN _005457217 222 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 223 1 the the DET _005457217 223 2 oppressive oppressive ADJ _005457217 223 3 measures measure NOUN _005457217 223 4 adopted adopt VERB _005457217 223 5 , , PUNCT _005457217 223 6 and and CCONJ _005457217 223 7 the the DET _005457217 223 8 cruelties cruelty NOUN _005457217 223 9 and and CCONJ _005457217 223 10 punishments punishment NOUN _005457217 223 11 inflicted inflict VERB _005457217 223 12 by by ADP _005457217 223 13 the the DET _005457217 223 14 governments government NOUN _005457217 223 15 of of ADP _005457217 223 16 europe europe PROPN _005457217 223 17 for for ADP _005457217 223 18 many many ADJ _005457217 223 19 ages age NOUN _005457217 223 20 , , PUNCT _005457217 223 21 to to PART _005457217 223 22 compel compel VERB _005457217 223 23 parties party NOUN _005457217 223 24 to to PART _005457217 223 25 conform conform VERB _005457217 223 26 in in ADP _005457217 223 27 their their PRON _005457217 223 28 religious religious ADJ _005457217 223 29 beliefs belief NOUN _005457217 223 30 and and CCONJ _005457217 223 31 modes mode NOUN _005457217 223 32 of of ADP _005457217 223 33 worship worship NOUN _005457217 223 34 , , PUNCT _005457217 223 35 to to ADP _005457217 223 36 the the DET _005457217 223 37 views view NOUN _005457217 223 38 of of ADP _005457217 223 39 the the DET _005457217 223 40 most most ADV _005457217 223 41 numerous numerous ADJ _005457217 223 42 sect sect NOUN _005457217 223 43 , , PUNCT _005457217 223 44 and and CCONJ _005457217 223 45 the the DET _005457217 223 46 folly folly NOUN _005457217 223 47 of of ADP _005457217 223 48 attempting attempt VERB _005457217 223 49 in in ADP _005457217 223 50 that that DET _005457217 223 51 way way NOUN _005457217 223 52 to to PART _005457217 223 53 control control VERB _005457217 223 54 the the DET _005457217 223 55 mental mental ADJ _005457217 223 56 operations operation NOUN _005457217 223 57 of of ADP _005457217 223 58 persons person NOUN _005457217 223 59 , , PUNCT _005457217 223 60 and and CCONJ _005457217 223 61 enforce enforce VERB _005457217 223 62 an an DET _005457217 223 63 outward outward ADJ _005457217 223 64 conformity conformity NOUN _005457217 223 65 to to ADP _005457217 223 66 a a DET _005457217 223 67 prescribed prescribed ADJ _005457217 223 68 standard standard NOUN _005457217 223 69 , , PUNCT _005457217 223 70 led lead VERB _005457217 223 71 to to ADP _005457217 223 72 the the DET _005457217 223 73 adoption adoption NOUN _005457217 223 74 of of ADP _005457217 223 75 the the DET _005457217 223 76 amendment amendment NOUN _005457217 223 77 in in ADP _005457217 223 78 question question NOUN _005457217 223 79 . . PUNCT _005457217 224 1 it it PRON _005457217 224 2 was be AUX _005457217 224 3 never never ADV _005457217 224 4 intended intend VERB _005457217 224 5 or or CCONJ _005457217 224 6 supposed suppose VERB _005457217 224 7 that that SCONJ _005457217 224 8 the the DET _005457217 224 9 amendment amendment NOUN _005457217 224 10 could could AUX _005457217 224 11 be be AUX _005457217 224 12 invoked invoke VERB _005457217 224 13 as as ADP _005457217 224 14 a a DET _005457217 224 15 protection protection NOUN _005457217 224 16 against against ADP _005457217 224 17 legislation legislation NOUN _005457217 225 1 f f PROPN _005457217 225 2 o o X _005457217 226 1 r r NOUN _005457217 226 2 the the DET _005457217 226 3 punishment punishment NOUN _005457217 226 4 of of ADP _005457217 226 5 acts act NOUN _005457217 226 6 inimical inimical ADJ _005457217 226 7 to to ADP _005457217 226 8 the the DET _005457217 226 9 peace peace NOUN _005457217 226 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 226 11 good good ADJ _005457217 226 12 order order NOUN _005457217 226 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 226 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 226 15 morals moral NOUN _005457217 226 16 of of ADP _005457217 226 17 society society NOUN _005457217 226 18 . . PUNCT _005457217 226 19 " " PUNCT _005457217 227 1 no no DET _005457217 227 2 case case NOUN _005457217 227 3 has have AUX _005457217 227 4 yet yet ADV _005457217 227 5 reached reach VERB _005457217 227 6 the the DET _005457217 227 7 united united PROPN _005457217 227 8 states states PROPN _005457217 227 9 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 227 10 court court PROPN _005457217 227 11 dealing deal VERB _005457217 227 12 with with ADP _005457217 227 13 the the DET _005457217 227 14 question question NOUN _005457217 227 15 in in ADP _005457217 227 16 this this DET _005457217 227 17 case case NOUN _005457217 227 18 . . PUNCT _005457217 228 1 the the DET _005457217 228 2 nearest near ADJ _005457217 228 3 to to ADP _005457217 228 4 a a DET _005457217 228 5 discussion discussion NOUN _005457217 228 6 of of ADP _005457217 228 7 the the DET _005457217 228 8 question question NOUN _005457217 228 9 in in ADP _005457217 228 10 the the DET _005457217 228 11 federal federal ADJ _005457217 228 12 courts court NOUN _005457217 228 13 that that PRON _005457217 228 14 we we PRON _005457217 228 15 have have AUX _005457217 228 16 been be AUX _005457217 228 17 able able ADJ _005457217 228 18 to to PART _005457217 228 19 find find VERB _005457217 228 20 is be AUX _005457217 228 21 in in ADP _005457217 228 22 the the DET _005457217 228 23 dissenting dissent VERB _005457217 228 24 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 228 25 of of ADP _005457217 228 26 mr mr PROPN _005457217 228 27 . . PROPN _005457217 228 28 justice justice PROPN _005457217 228 29 f f PROPN _005457217 228 30 r r NOUN _005457217 228 31 a a X _005457217 228 32 n n NOUN _005457217 228 33 k k PROPN _005457217 228 34 f f PROPN _005457217 228 35 u u PROPN _005457217 228 36 r r NOUN _005457217 228 37 t t NOUN _005457217 228 38 e e NOUN _005457217 228 39 r r NOUN _005457217 228 40 in in ADP _005457217 228 41 west west PROPN _005457217 228 42 virginia virginia PROPN _005457217 228 43 v. v. ADP _005457217 228 44 20 20 NUM _005457217 228 45 barnette barnette PROPN _005457217 228 46 , , PUNCT _005457217 228 47 319 319 NUM _005457217 228 48 u. u. PROPN _005457217 228 49 s. s. PROPN _005457217 228 50 624 624 NUM _005457217 228 51 , , PUNCT _005457217 228 52 63 63 NUM _005457217 228 53 sup sup NOUN _005457217 228 54 . . PUNCT _005457217 229 1 ct ct PROPN _005457217 229 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 230 1 1178 1178 NUM _005457217 230 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 230 3 at at ADP _005457217 230 4 1195 1195 NUM _005457217 230 5 , , PUNCT _005457217 230 6 where where SCONJ _005457217 230 7 it it PRON _005457217 230 8 is be AUX _005457217 230 9 said say VERB _005457217 230 10 : : PUNCT _005457217 230 11 " " PUNCT _005457217 230 12 consider consider VERB _005457217 230 13 the the DET _005457217 230 14 controversial controversial ADJ _005457217 230 15 issue issue NOUN _005457217 230 16 of of ADP _005457217 230 17 compulsory compulsory ADJ _005457217 230 18 bible bible NOUN _005457217 230 19 - - PUNCT _005457217 230 20 reading reading NOUN _005457217 230 21 in in ADP _005457217 230 22 public public ADJ _005457217 230 23 schools school NOUN _005457217 230 24 . . PUNCT _005457217 231 1 the the DET _005457217 231 2 educational educational ADJ _005457217 231 3 policies policy NOUN _005457217 231 4 of of ADP _005457217 231 5 the the DET _005457217 231 6 states state NOUN _005457217 231 7 are be AUX _005457217 231 8 in in ADP _005457217 231 9 great great ADJ _005457217 231 10 conflict conflict NOUN _005457217 231 11 over over ADP _005457217 231 12 this this PRON _005457217 231 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 231 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 231 15 the the DET _005457217 231 16 state state NOUN _005457217 231 17 courts court NOUN _005457217 231 18 are be AUX _005457217 231 19 divided divide VERB _005457217 231 20 in in ADP _005457217 231 21 their their PRON _005457217 231 22 decisions decision NOUN _005457217 231 23 on on ADP _005457217 231 24 the the DET _005457217 231 25 issue issue NOUN _005457217 231 26 whether whether SCONJ _005457217 231 27 the the DET _005457217 231 28 requirement requirement NOUN _005457217 231 29 of of ADP _005457217 231 30 bible bible NOUN _005457217 231 31 - - PUNCT _005457217 231 32 reading read VERB _005457217 231 33 offends offend NOUN _005457217 231 34 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 231 35 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 231 36 dealing deal VERB _005457217 231 37 with with ADP _005457217 231 38 religious religious ADJ _005457217 231 39 freedom freedom NOUN _005457217 231 40 . . PUNCT _005457217 232 1 the the DET _005457217 232 2 requirement requirement NOUN _005457217 232 3 of of ADP _005457217 232 4 bible bible NOUN _005457217 232 5 - - PUNCT _005457217 232 6 reading reading NOUN _005457217 232 7 has have AUX _005457217 232 8 been be AUX _005457217 232 9 justified justify VERB _005457217 232 10 by by ADP _005457217 232 11 various various ADJ _005457217 232 12 state state NOUN _005457217 232 13 courts court NOUN _005457217 232 14 as as ADP _005457217 232 15 an an DET _005457217 232 16 appropriate appropriate ADJ _005457217 232 17 means mean NOUN _005457217 232 18 of of ADP _005457217 232 19 inculcating inculcate VERB _005457217 232 20 ethical ethical ADJ _005457217 232 21 precepts precept NOUN _005457217 232 22 and and CCONJ _005457217 232 23 familiarizing familiarize VERB _005457217 232 24 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 232 25 with with ADP _005457217 232 26 the the DET _005457217 232 27 most most ADV _005457217 232 28 lasting lasting ADJ _005457217 232 29 expression expression NOUN _005457217 232 30 of of ADP _005457217 232 31 great great ADJ _005457217 232 32 english english PROPN _005457217 232 33 literature literature NOUN _005457217 232 34 . . PUNCT _005457217 233 1 is be AUX _005457217 233 2 this this DET _005457217 233 3 court court NOUN _005457217 233 4 to to PART _005457217 233 5 overthrow overthrow VERB _005457217 233 6 such such ADJ _005457217 233 7 variant variant ADJ _005457217 233 8 state state NOUN _005457217 233 9 educational educational ADJ _005457217 233 10 policies policy NOUN _005457217 233 11 by by ADP _005457217 233 12 denying deny VERB _005457217 233 13 states state NOUN _005457217 233 14 the the DET _005457217 233 15 right right NOUN _005457217 233 16 to to PART _005457217 233 17 entertain entertain VERB _005457217 233 18 such such ADJ _005457217 233 19 convictions conviction NOUN _005457217 233 20 in in ADP _005457217 233 21 regard regard NOUN _005457217 233 22 to to ADP _005457217 233 23 their their PRON _005457217 233 24 school school NOUN _005457217 233 25 systems system NOUN _005457217 233 26 because because SCONJ _005457217 233 27 of of ADP _005457217 233 28 a a DET _005457217 233 29 belief belief NOUN _005457217 233 30 that that SCONJ _005457217 233 31 the the DET _005457217 233 32 king king NOUN _005457217 233 33 james james PROPN _005457217 233 34 version version PROPN _005457217 233 35 is be AUX _005457217 233 36 in in ADP _005457217 233 37 fact fact NOUN _005457217 233 38 a a DET _005457217 233 39 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 233 40 text text NOUN _005457217 233 41 to to PART _005457217 233 42 which which PRON _005457217 233 43 parents parent NOUN _005457217 233 44 of of ADP _005457217 233 45 the the DET _005457217 233 46 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 233 47 and and CCONJ _005457217 233 48 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 233 49 faiths faith NOUN _005457217 233 50 and and CCONJ _005457217 233 51 some some DET _005457217 233 52 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 233 53 persuasions persuasion NOUN _005457217 233 54 may may AUX _005457217 233 55 rightly rightly ADV _005457217 233 56 object object VERB _005457217 233 57 to to ADP _005457217 233 58 having have VERB _005457217 233 59 their their PRON _005457217 233 60 children child NOUN _005457217 233 61 exposed expose VERB _005457217 233 62 ? ? PUNCT _005457217 234 1 on on ADP _005457217 234 2 the the DET _005457217 234 3 other other ADJ _005457217 234 4 hand hand NOUN _005457217 234 5 the the DET _005457217 234 6 religious religious ADJ _005457217 234 7 consciences conscience NOUN _005457217 234 8 of of ADP _005457217 234 9 some some DET _005457217 234 10 parents parent NOUN _005457217 234 11 may may AUX _005457217 234 12 rebel rebel VERB _005457217 234 13 at at ADP _005457217 234 14 the the DET _005457217 234 15 absence absence NOUN _005457217 234 16 of of ADP _005457217 234 17 any any DET _005457217 234 18 biblereading biblereading NOUN _005457217 234 19 in in ADP _005457217 234 20 the the DET _005457217 234 21 schools school NOUN _005457217 234 22 . . PUNCT _005457217 235 1 see see VERB _005457217 235 2 state state NOUN _005457217 235 3 of of ADP _005457217 235 4 washington washington PROPN _005457217 235 5 ex ex PROPN _005457217 235 6 rel rel PROPN _005457217 235 7 . . PUNCT _005457217 236 1 clithero clithero PROPN _005457217 236 2 v. v. PROPN _005457217 236 3 showalter showalter PROPN _005457217 236 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 236 5 284 284 NUM _005457217 236 6 u. u. PROPN _005457217 236 7 s. s. PROPN _005457217 236 8 573 573 NUM _005457217 236 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 236 10 52 52 NUM _005457217 236 11 sup sup NOUN _005457217 236 12 . . PUNCT _005457217 237 1 ct ct PROPN _005457217 237 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 237 3 15 15 NUM _005457217 237 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 237 5 76 76 NUM _005457217 237 6 l. l. PROPN _005457217 237 7 ed ed PROPN _005457217 237 8 . . PUNCT _005457217 238 1 498 498 NUM _005457217 238 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 238 3 or or CCONJ _005457217 238 4 is be AUX _005457217 238 5 this this DET _005457217 238 6 court court NOUN _005457217 238 7 to to PART _005457217 238 8 enter enter VERB _005457217 238 9 the the DET _005457217 238 10 old old ADJ _005457217 238 11 controversy controversy NOUN _005457217 238 12 between between ADP _005457217 238 13 science science NOUN _005457217 238 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 238 15 religion religion NOUN _005457217 238 16 by by ADP _005457217 238 17 unduly unduly ADV _005457217 238 18 defining define VERB _005457217 238 19 the the DET _005457217 238 20 limits limit NOUN _005457217 238 21 within within ADP _005457217 238 22 which which PRON _005457217 238 23 a a DET _005457217 238 24 state state NOUN _005457217 238 25 may may AUX _005457217 238 26 experiment experiment VERB _005457217 238 27 with with ADP _005457217 238 28 its its PRON _005457217 238 29 school school NOUN _005457217 238 30 curricula curricula NOUN _005457217 238 31 ? ? PUNCT _005457217 239 1 the the DET _005457217 239 2 religious religious ADJ _005457217 239 3 consciences conscience NOUN _005457217 239 4 of of ADP _005457217 239 5 some some DET _005457217 239 6 parents parent NOUN _005457217 239 7 may may AUX _005457217 239 8 be be AUX _005457217 239 9 offended offend VERB _005457217 239 10 by by ADP _005457217 239 11 subjecting subject VERB _005457217 239 12 their their PRON _005457217 239 13 children child NOUN _005457217 239 14 to to ADP _005457217 239 15 the the DET _005457217 239 16 biblical biblical ADJ _005457217 239 17 account account NOUN _005457217 239 18 of of ADP _005457217 239 19 creation creation NOUN _005457217 239 20 , , PUNCT _005457217 239 21 while while SCONJ _005457217 239 22 another another DET _005457217 239 23 state state NOUN _005457217 239 24 may may AUX _005457217 239 25 offend offend VERB _005457217 239 26 parents parent NOUN _005457217 239 27 by by ADP _005457217 239 28 prohibiting prohibit VERB _005457217 239 29 a a DET _005457217 239 30 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 239 31 of of ADP _005457217 239 32 biology biology NOUN _005457217 239 33 that that PRON _005457217 239 34 contradicts contradict VERB _005457217 239 35 such such ADJ _005457217 239 36 biblical biblical ADJ _005457217 239 37 account account NOUN _005457217 239 38 . . PUNCT _005457217 240 1 compare compare VERB _005457217 240 2 scopes scopes PROPN _005457217 240 3 v. v. ADP _005457217 240 4 state state PROPN _005457217 240 5 , , PUNCT _005457217 240 6 154 154 NUM _005457217 240 7 tenn tenn PROPN _005457217 240 8 . . PUNCT _005457217 241 1 105 105 NUM _005457217 241 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 241 3 289 289 NUM _005457217 241 4 s. s. PROPN _005457217 241 5 w. w. PROPN _005457217 241 6 363 363 NUM _005457217 241 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 241 8 53 53 NUM _005457217 241 9 a.l.r a.l.r NOUN _005457217 241 10 . . PUNCT _005457217 242 1 821 821 NUM _005457217 242 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 242 3 " " PUNCT _005457217 243 1 we we PRON _005457217 243 2 have have VERB _005457217 243 3 , , PUNCT _005457217 243 4 however however ADV _005457217 243 5 , , PUNCT _005457217 243 6 in in ADP _005457217 243 7 the the DET _005457217 243 8 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 243 9 court court PROPN _005457217 243 10 of of ADP _005457217 243 11 the the DET _005457217 243 12 united united PROPN _005457217 243 13 states states PROPN _005457217 243 14 direct direct ADJ _005457217 243 15 and and CCONJ _005457217 243 16 unmistakable unmistakable ADJ _005457217 243 17 authority authority NOUN _005457217 243 18 for for ADP _005457217 243 19 the the DET _005457217 243 20 proposition proposition NOUN _005457217 243 21 that that SCONJ _005457217 243 22 the the DET _005457217 243 23 doctrine doctrine NOUN _005457217 243 24 of of ADP _005457217 243 25 separation separation NOUN _005457217 243 26 of of ADP _005457217 243 27 church church NOUN _005457217 243 28 and and CCONJ _005457217 243 29 state state NOUN _005457217 243 30 does do AUX _005457217 243 31 not not PART _005457217 243 32 mean mean VERB _005457217 243 33 that that SCONJ _005457217 243 34 there there PRON _005457217 243 35 is be VERB _005457217 243 36 any any DET _005457217 243 37 conflict conflict NOUN _005457217 243 38 between between ADP _005457217 243 39 religion religion NOUN _005457217 243 40 and and CCONJ _005457217 243 41 state state NOUN _005457217 243 42 in in ADP _005457217 243 43 this this DET _005457217 243 44 country country NOUN _005457217 243 45 , , PUNCT _005457217 243 46 or or CCONJ _005457217 243 47 any any DET _005457217 243 48 disfavor disfavor NOUN _005457217 243 49 of of ADP _005457217 243 50 any any DET _005457217 243 51 kind kind NOUN _005457217 243 52 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 243 53 religion religion NOUN _005457217 243 54 as as ADP _005457217 243 55 such such ADJ _005457217 243 56 . . PUNCT _005457217 244 1 in in ADP _005457217 244 2 pierce pierce PROPN _005457217 244 3 v. v. ADP _005457217 244 4 society society PROPN _005457217 244 5 of of ADP _005457217 244 6 21 21 NUM _005457217 244 7 the the DET _005457217 244 8 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 244 9 sisters sister NOUN _005457217 244 10 of of ADP _005457217 244 11 the the DET _005457217 244 12 holy holy PROPN _005457217 244 13 names name NOUN _005457217 244 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 244 15 268 268 NUM _005457217 244 16 u. u. PROPN _005457217 244 17 s. s. PROPN _005457217 244 18 510 510 NUM _005457217 244 19 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 244 20 45 45 NUM _005457217 244 21 sup sup NOUN _005457217 244 22 . . PUNCT _005457217 245 1 ct ct PROPN _005457217 245 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 246 1 571 571 NUM _005457217 247 1 , , PUNCT _005457217 247 2 at at ADP _005457217 247 3 573 573 NUM _005457217 247 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 247 5 where where SCONJ _005457217 247 6 the the DET _005457217 247 7 court court NOUN _005457217 247 8 held hold VERB _005457217 247 9 invalid invalid ADJ _005457217 247 10 a a DET _005457217 247 11 statute statute NOUN _005457217 247 12 of of ADP _005457217 247 13 oregon oregon PROPN _005457217 247 14 requiring require VERB _005457217 247 15 the the DET _005457217 247 16 children child NOUN _005457217 247 17 of of ADP _005457217 247 18 all all DET _005457217 247 19 citizens citizen NOUN _005457217 247 20 to to PART _005457217 247 21 attend attend VERB _005457217 247 22 public public ADJ _005457217 247 23 schools school NOUN _005457217 247 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 247 25 the the DET _005457217 247 26 court court NOUN _005457217 247 27 said say VERB _005457217 247 28 : : PUNCT _005457217 247 29 " " PUNCT _005457217 247 30 t t NOUN _005457217 247 31 h h X _005457217 247 32 e e X _005457217 247 33 fundamental fundamental ADJ _005457217 247 34 theory theory NOUN _005457217 247 35 of of ADP _005457217 247 36 liberty liberty NOUN _005457217 247 37 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 247 38 which which PRON _005457217 247 39 all all DET _005457217 247 40 governments government NOUN _005457217 247 41 in in ADP _005457217 247 42 this this DET _005457217 247 43 union union NOUN _005457217 247 44 repose repose NOUN _005457217 247 45 excludes exclude VERB _005457217 247 46 any any DET _005457217 247 47 general general ADJ _005457217 247 48 power power NOUN _005457217 247 49 of of ADP _005457217 247 50 the the DET _005457217 247 51 state state NOUN _005457217 247 52 to to PART _005457217 247 53 standardize standardize VERB _005457217 247 54 its its PRON _005457217 247 55 chih chih PROPN _005457217 247 56 dren dren NOUN _005457217 247 57 by by ADP _005457217 247 58 forcing force VERB _005457217 247 59 them they PRON _005457217 247 60 to to PART _005457217 247 61 accept accept VERB _005457217 247 62 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 247 63 from from ADP _005457217 247 64 public public ADJ _005457217 247 65 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 247 66 only only ADV _005457217 247 67 . . PUNCT _005457217 248 1 the the DET _005457217 248 2 child child NOUN _005457217 248 3 is be AUX _005457217 248 4 not not PART _005457217 248 5 the the DET _005457217 248 6 mere mere ADJ _005457217 248 7 creature creature NOUN _005457217 248 8 of of ADP _005457217 248 9 the the DET _005457217 248 10 state state NOUN _005457217 248 11 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 248 12 those those PRON _005457217 248 13 who who PRON _005457217 248 14 nurture nurture VERB _005457217 248 15 him he PRON _005457217 248 16 and and CCONJ _005457217 248 17 direct direct VERB _005457217 248 18 his his PRON _005457217 248 19 destiny destiny NOUN _005457217 248 20 have have VERB _005457217 248 21 the the DET _005457217 248 22 right right NOUN _005457217 248 23 , , PUNCT _005457217 248 24 coupled couple VERB _005457217 248 25 with with ADP _005457217 248 26 the the DET _005457217 248 27 high high ADJ _005457217 248 28 duty duty NOUN _005457217 248 29 , , PUNCT _005457217 248 30 to to PART _005457217 248 31 recognize recognize VERB _005457217 248 32 and and CCONJ _005457217 248 33 prepare prepare VERB _005457217 248 34 him he PRON _005457217 248 35 for for ADP _005457217 248 36 additional additional ADJ _005457217 248 37 obligations obligation NOUN _005457217 248 38 . . PUNCT _005457217 248 39 " " PUNCT _005457217 249 1 again again ADV _005457217 249 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 249 3 in in ADP _005457217 249 4 rector rector NOUN _005457217 249 5 , , PUNCT _005457217 249 6 etc etc X _005457217 249 7 . . X _005457217 249 8 holy holy ADJ _005457217 249 9 trinity trinity PROPN _005457217 249 10 church church PROPN _005457217 249 11 v. v. ADP _005457217 249 12 u. u. PROPN _005457217 249 13 8 8 PROPN _005457217 249 14 . . PROPN _005457217 249 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 249 16 143 143 NUM _005457217 249 17 u. u. PROPN _005457217 249 18 s. s. PROPN _005457217 249 19 457 457 NUM _005457217 249 20 , , PUNCT _005457217 249 21 12 12 NUM _005457217 249 22 sup sup NOUN _005457217 249 23 . . PUNCT _005457217 250 1 ct ct PROPN _005457217 250 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 251 1 511 511 NUM _005457217 251 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 251 3 the the DET _005457217 251 4 court court NOUN _005457217 251 5 was be AUX _005457217 251 6 construing construe VERB _005457217 251 7 a a DET _005457217 251 8 federal federal ADJ _005457217 251 9 statute statute NOUN _005457217 251 10 prohibiting prohibit VERB _005457217 251 11 the the DET _005457217 251 12 importation importation NOUN _005457217 251 13 of of ADP _005457217 251 14 any any DET _005457217 251 15 alien alien NOUN _005457217 251 16 into into ADP _005457217 251 17 the the DET _005457217 251 18 united united PROPN _005457217 251 19 states states PROPN _005457217 251 20 under under ADP _005457217 251 21 contract contract NOUN _005457217 251 22 or or CCONJ _005457217 251 23 agreement agreement NOUN _005457217 251 24 made make VERB _005457217 251 25 previous previous ADJ _005457217 251 26 to to ADP _005457217 251 27 the the DET _005457217 251 28 importation importation NOUN _005457217 251 29 of of ADP _005457217 251 30 such such ADJ _005457217 251 31 alien alien NOUN _005457217 251 32 to to PART _005457217 251 33 perform perform VERB _005457217 251 34 labor labor NOUN _005457217 251 35 or or CCONJ _005457217 251 36 services service NOUN _005457217 251 37 of of ADP _005457217 251 38 any any DET _005457217 251 39 kind kind NOUN _005457217 251 40 in in ADP _005457217 251 41 the the DET _005457217 251 42 united united PROPN _005457217 251 43 states states PROPN _005457217 251 44 . . PUNCT _005457217 252 1 holy holy ADJ _005457217 252 2 trinity trinity PROPN _005457217 252 3 church church NOUN _005457217 252 4 had have AUX _005457217 252 5 hired hire VERB _005457217 252 6 an an DET _005457217 252 7 english english ADJ _005457217 252 8 rector rector NOUN _005457217 252 9 to to PART _005457217 252 10 preach preach VERB _005457217 252 11 in in ADP _005457217 252 12 their their PRON _005457217 252 13 church church NOUN _005457217 252 14 . . PUNCT _005457217 253 1 although although SCONJ _005457217 253 2 he he PRON _005457217 253 3 came come VERB _005457217 253 4 squarely squarely ADV _005457217 253 5 within within ADP _005457217 253 6 the the DET _005457217 253 7 language language NOUN _005457217 253 8 of of ADP _005457217 253 9 the the DET _005457217 253 10 act act NOUN _005457217 253 11 the the DET _005457217 253 12 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 253 13 court court PROPN _005457217 253 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 253 15 examining examine VERB _005457217 253 16 the the DET _005457217 253 17 history history NOUN _005457217 253 18 of of ADP _005457217 253 19 the the DET _005457217 253 20 legislation legislation NOUN _005457217 253 21 and and CCONJ _005457217 253 22 the the DET _005457217 253 23 attitude attitude NOUN _005457217 253 24 toward toward ADP _005457217 253 25 religion religion NOUN _005457217 253 26 of of ADP _005457217 253 27 all all DET _005457217 253 28 public public ADJ _005457217 253 29 bodies body NOUN _005457217 253 30 in in ADP _005457217 253 31 our our PRON _005457217 253 32 country country NOUN _005457217 253 33 , , PUNCT _005457217 253 34 found find VERB _005457217 253 35 that that SCONJ _005457217 253 36 his his PRON _005457217 253 37 importation importation NOUN _005457217 253 38 was be AUX _005457217 253 39 not not PART _005457217 253 40 illegal illegal ADJ _005457217 253 41 . . PUNCT _005457217 254 1 in in ADP _005457217 254 2 the the DET _005457217 254 3 unanimous unanimous ADJ _005457217 254 4 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 254 5 of of ADP _005457217 254 6 the the DET _005457217 254 7 court court NOUN _005457217 254 8 some some PRON _005457217 254 9 of of ADP _005457217 254 10 the the DET _005457217 254 11 language language NOUN _005457217 254 12 of of ADP _005457217 254 13 mr mr PROPN _005457217 254 14 . . PROPN _005457217 254 15 justice justice PROPN _005457217 254 16 brewer brewer NOUN _005457217 254 17 is be AUX _005457217 254 18 as as SCONJ _005457217 254 19 follows follow VERB _005457217 254 20 : : PUNCT _005457217 254 21 " " PUNCT _005457217 254 22 b b X _005457217 254 23 u u NOUN _005457217 254 24 t t PROPN _005457217 254 25 , , PUNCT _005457217 254 26 beyond beyond ADP _005457217 254 27 all all DET _005457217 254 28 these these DET _005457217 254 29 matters matter NOUN _005457217 254 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 254 31 no no DET _005457217 254 32 purpose purpose NOUN _005457217 254 33 of of ADP _005457217 254 34 action action NOUN _005457217 254 35 against against ADP _005457217 254 36 religion religion NOUN _005457217 254 37 can can AUX _005457217 254 38 be be AUX _005457217 254 39 imputed impute VERB _005457217 254 40 to to ADP _005457217 254 41 any any DET _005457217 254 42 legislation legislation NOUN _005457217 254 43 , , PUNCT _005457217 254 44 state state NOUN _005457217 254 45 or or CCONJ _005457217 254 46 national national ADJ _005457217 254 47 , , PUNCT _005457217 254 48 because because SCONJ _005457217 254 49 this this PRON _005457217 254 50 is be AUX _005457217 254 51 a a DET _005457217 254 52 religious religious ADJ _005457217 254 53 people people NOUN _005457217 254 54 . . PUNCT _005457217 254 55 " " PUNCT _005457217 255 1 the the DET _005457217 255 2 decision decision NOUN _005457217 255 3 traces trace VERB _005457217 255 4 the the DET _005457217 255 5 reliance reliance NOUN _005457217 255 6 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 255 7 god god PROPN _005457217 255 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 255 9 from from ADP _005457217 255 10 the the DET _005457217 255 11 commission commission NOUN _005457217 255 12 of of ADP _005457217 255 13 christopher christopher PROPN _005457217 255 14 columbus columbus PROPN _005457217 255 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 255 16 through through ADP _005457217 255 17 the the DET _005457217 255 18 charters charter NOUN _005457217 255 19 to to ADP _005457217 255 20 the the DET _005457217 255 21 colonies colony NOUN _005457217 255 22 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 255 23 refers refer VERB _005457217 255 24 to to ADP _005457217 255 25 the the DET _005457217 255 26 language language NOUN _005457217 255 27 of of ADP _005457217 255 28 the the DET _005457217 255 29 declaration declaration NOUN _005457217 255 30 of of ADP _005457217 255 31 independence independence NOUN _005457217 255 32 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 255 33 specifically specifically ADV _005457217 255 34 calls call VERB _005457217 255 35 attention attention NOUN _005457217 255 36 to to ADP _005457217 255 37 the the DET _005457217 255 38 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 255 39 of of ADP _005457217 255 40 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 255 41 of of ADP _005457217 255 42 1870 1870 NUM _005457217 255 43 ' ' PART _005457217 255 44 : : PUNCT _005457217 255 45 " " PUNCT _005457217 255 46 w w PROPN _005457217 255 47 e e PROPN _005457217 255 48 , , PUNCT _005457217 255 49 the the DET _005457217 255 50 people people NOUN _005457217 255 51 of of ADP _005457217 255 52 22 22 NUM _005457217 255 53 the the DET _005457217 255 54 state state NOUN _005457217 255 55 of of ADP _005457217 255 56 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 255 57 , , PUNCT _005457217 255 58 grateful grateful ADJ _005457217 255 59 to to PART _005457217 255 60 almighty almighty ADJ _005457217 255 61 god god PROPN _005457217 255 62 f f PROPN _005457217 255 63 o o X _005457217 256 1 r r NOUN _005457217 256 2 the the DET _005457217 256 3 civil civil ADJ _005457217 256 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 256 5 political political ADJ _005457217 256 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 256 7 and and CCONJ _005457217 256 8 religions religion NOUN _005457217 256 9 liberty liberty NOUN _005457217 256 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 256 11 " " PUNCT _005457217 256 12 etc etc X _005457217 256 13 . . X _005457217 256 14 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 256 15 the the DET _005457217 256 16 requirements requirement NOUN _005457217 256 17 of of ADP _005457217 256 18 oaths oath NOUN _005457217 256 19 in in ADP _005457217 256 20 our our PRON _005457217 256 21 courts court NOUN _005457217 256 22 and and CCONJ _005457217 256 23 the the DET _005457217 256 24 repeated repeat VERB _005457217 256 25 reference reference NOUN _005457217 256 26 to to ADP _005457217 256 27 the the DET _005457217 256 28 deity deity NOUN _005457217 256 29 , , PUNCT _005457217 256 30 in in ADP _005457217 256 31 the the DET _005457217 256 32 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 256 33 and and CCONJ _005457217 256 34 laws law NOUN _005457217 256 35 of of ADP _005457217 256 36 the the DET _005457217 256 37 united united PROPN _005457217 256 38 states states PROPN _005457217 256 39 , , PUNCT _005457217 256 40 and and CCONJ _005457217 256 41 the the DET _005457217 256 42 states state NOUN _005457217 256 43 . . PUNCT _005457217 257 1 mr mr PROPN _005457217 257 2 . . PROPN _005457217 257 3 justice justice PROPN _005457217 257 4 brewer brewer NOUN _005457217 257 5 again again ADV _005457217 257 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 257 7 at at ADP _005457217 257 8 page page NOUN _005457217 257 9 516 516 NUM _005457217 257 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 257 11 says say VERB _005457217 257 12 : : PUNCT _005457217 257 13 " " PUNCT _005457217 257 14 t t NOUN _005457217 257 15 h h NOUN _005457217 257 16 e e NOUN _005457217 257 17 r r NOUN _005457217 257 18 e e NOUN _005457217 257 19 is be AUX _005457217 257 20 no no DET _005457217 257 21 dissonance dissonance NOUN _005457217 257 22 in in ADP _005457217 257 23 these these DET _005457217 257 24 declarations declaration NOUN _005457217 257 25 . . PUNCT _005457217 258 1 there there PRON _005457217 258 2 is be VERB _005457217 258 3 a a DET _005457217 258 4 universal universal ADJ _005457217 258 5 language language NOUN _005457217 258 6 pervading pervade VERB _005457217 258 7 them they PRON _005457217 258 8 all all PRON _005457217 258 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 258 10 having have VERB _005457217 258 11 one one NUM _005457217 258 12 meaning meaning NOUN _005457217 258 13 . . PUNCT _005457217 259 1 they they PRON _005457217 259 2 affirm affirm ADJ _005457217 259 3 and and CCONJ _005457217 259 4 reaffirm reaffirm VERB _005457217 259 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 259 6 this this PRON _005457217 259 7 is be AUX _005457217 259 8 a a DET _005457217 259 9 religious religious ADJ _005457217 259 10 nation nation NOUN _005457217 259 11 . . PUNCT _005457217 260 1 these these PRON _005457217 260 2 are be AUX _005457217 260 3 not not PART _005457217 260 4 individual individual ADJ _005457217 260 5 sayings saying NOUN _005457217 260 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 260 7 declarations declaration NOUN _005457217 260 8 of of ADP _005457217 260 9 private private ADJ _005457217 260 10 persons person NOUN _005457217 260 11 . . PUNCT _005457217 261 1 they they PRON _005457217 261 2 are be AUX _005457217 261 3 organic organic ADJ _005457217 261 4 utterances utterance NOUN _005457217 261 5 . . PUNCT _005457217 262 1 they they PRON _005457217 262 2 speak speak VERB _005457217 262 3 the the DET _005457217 262 4 voice voice NOUN _005457217 262 5 of of ADP _005457217 262 6 the the DET _005457217 262 7 entire entire ADJ _005457217 262 8 people people NOUN _005457217 262 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 262 10 " " PUNCT _005457217 263 1 f f PROPN _005457217 263 2 o o X _005457217 263 3 r r NOUN _005457217 263 4 a a DET _005457217 263 5 very very ADV _005457217 263 6 full full ADJ _005457217 263 7 and and CCONJ _005457217 263 8 complete complete ADJ _005457217 263 9 history history NOUN _005457217 263 10 of of ADP _005457217 263 11 the the DET _005457217 263 12 influence influence NOUN _005457217 263 13 of of ADP _005457217 263 14 christianity christianity NOUN _005457217 263 15 and and CCONJ _005457217 263 16 religion religion NOUN _005457217 263 17 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 263 18 our our PRON _005457217 263 19 national national ADJ _005457217 263 20 life life NOUN _005457217 263 21 we we PRON _005457217 263 22 call call VERB _005457217 263 23 attention attention NOUN _005457217 263 24 to to ADP _005457217 263 25 wilkerson wilkerson PROPN _005457217 263 26 v. v. ADP _005457217 263 27 rome rome PROPN _005457217 263 28 , , PUNCT _005457217 263 29 152 152 NUM _005457217 263 30 ga ga NOUN _005457217 263 31 . . PUNCT _005457217 264 1 762 762 NUM _005457217 264 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 264 3 110 110 NUM _005457217 264 4 s. s. PROPN _005457217 264 5 e. e. PROPN _005457217 264 6 895 895 NUM _005457217 264 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 264 8 20 20 NUM _005457217 264 9 a.l.r a.l.r ADJ _005457217 264 10 . . PUNCT _005457217 264 11 1334 1334 NUM _005457217 264 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 264 13 which which DET _005457217 264 14 case case NOUN _005457217 264 15 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 264 16 p. p. NOUN _005457217 264 17 1346 1346 NUM _005457217 264 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 264 19 20 20 NUM _005457217 264 20 a.l.r a.l.r NOUN _005457217 264 21 . . PUNCT _005457217 264 22 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 264 23 refers refer VERB _005457217 264 24 to to ADP _005457217 264 25 the the DET _005457217 264 26 analysis analysis NOUN _005457217 264 27 and and CCONJ _005457217 264 28 criticism criticism NOUN _005457217 264 29 of of ADP _005457217 264 30 the the DET _005457217 264 31 ring ring NOUN _005457217 264 32 case case NOUN _005457217 264 33 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 264 34 hereinafter hereinafter NOUN _005457217 264 35 referred refer VERB _005457217 264 36 to to ADP _005457217 264 37 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 264 38 by by ADP _005457217 264 39 professor professor PROPN _005457217 264 40 schofield schofield PROPN _005457217 264 41 of of ADP _005457217 264 42 northwestern northwestern ADJ _005457217 264 43 university university PROPN _005457217 264 44 in in ADP _005457217 264 45 his his PRON _005457217 264 46 work work NOUN _005457217 264 47 on on ADP _005457217 264 48 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 264 49 law law NOUN _005457217 264 50 . . PUNCT _005457217 265 1 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 265 2 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 265 3 law law NOUN _005457217 265 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 265 5 p. p. NOUN _005457217 265 6 459 459 NUM _005457217 265 7 to to ADP _005457217 265 8 509 509 NUM _005457217 265 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 265 10 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 266 1 the the DET _005457217 266 2 case case NOUN _005457217 266 3 relied rely VERB _005457217 266 4 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 266 5 by by ADP _005457217 266 6 relator relator NOUN _005457217 266 7 under under ADP _005457217 266 8 the the DET _005457217 266 9 federal federal ADJ _005457217 266 10 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 266 11 provision provision NOUN _005457217 266 12 is be AUX _005457217 266 13 west west PROPN _005457217 266 14 virginia virginia PROPN _005457217 266 15 v. v. PROPN _005457217 266 16 bamette bamette PROPN _005457217 266 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 266 18 319 319 NUM _005457217 266 19 u. u. PROPN _005457217 266 20 s. s. PROPN _005457217 266 21 624 624 NUM _005457217 266 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 266 23 63 63 NUM _005457217 266 24 sup sup NOUN _005457217 266 25 . . PUNCT _005457217 267 1 ct ct PROPN _005457217 267 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 268 1 1178 1178 NUM _005457217 268 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 268 3 where where SCONJ _005457217 268 4 the the DET _005457217 268 5 court court NOUN _005457217 268 6 overruling overrule VERB _005457217 268 7 a a DET _005457217 268 8 prior prior ADJ _005457217 268 9 ruling ruling NOUN _005457217 268 10 in in ADP _005457217 268 11 the the DET _005457217 268 12 gobitis gobitis NOUN _005457217 268 13 case case NOUN _005457217 268 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 268 15 held hold VERB _005457217 268 16 unconstitutional unconstitutional ADJ _005457217 268 17 the the DET _005457217 268 18 requirement requirement NOUN _005457217 268 19 of of ADP _005457217 268 20 the the DET _005457217 268 21 board board NOUN _005457217 268 22 of of ADP _005457217 268 23 education education NOUN _005457217 268 24 of of ADP _005457217 268 25 west west PROPN _005457217 268 26 virginia virginia PROPN _005457217 268 27 that that PRON _005457217 268 28 all all DET _005457217 268 29 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 268 30 attending attend VERB _005457217 268 31 a a DET _005457217 268 32 public public ADJ _005457217 268 33 school school NOUN _005457217 268 34 shall shall AUX _005457217 268 35 be be AUX _005457217 268 36 required require VERB _005457217 268 37 to to PART _005457217 268 38 salute salute VERB _005457217 268 39 the the DET _005457217 268 40 f f PROPN _005457217 268 41 l l NOUN _005457217 268 42 a a DET _005457217 268 43 g g NOUN _005457217 268 44 of of ADP _005457217 268 45 our our PRON _005457217 268 46 country country NOUN _005457217 268 47 . . PUNCT _005457217 269 1 children child NOUN _005457217 269 2 of of ADP _005457217 269 3 members member NOUN _005457217 269 4 of of ADP _005457217 269 5 jehovah jehovah PROPN _005457217 269 6 's 's PART _005457217 269 7 " " PUNCT _005457217 269 8 witnesses witness NOUN _005457217 269 9 refused refuse VERB _005457217 269 10 to to PART _005457217 269 11 salute salute VERB _005457217 269 12 the the DET _005457217 269 13 flag flag NOUN _005457217 269 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 269 15 and and CCONJ _005457217 269 16 were be AUX _005457217 269 17 expelled expel VERB _005457217 269 18 from from ADP _005457217 269 19 the the DET _005457217 269 20 schools school NOUN _005457217 269 21 . . PUNCT _005457217 270 1 these these DET _005457217 270 2 children child NOUN _005457217 270 3 were be AUX _005457217 270 4 threatened threaten VERB _005457217 270 5 with with ADP _005457217 270 6 reformatory reformatory ADJ _005457217 270 7 confinement confinement NOUN _005457217 270 8 as as ADP _005457217 270 9 criminally criminally ADV _005457217 270 10 inclined inclined ADJ _005457217 270 11 juveniles juvenile NOUN _005457217 270 12 . . PUNCT _005457217 271 1 the the DET _005457217 271 2 parents parent NOUN _005457217 271 3 were be AUX _005457217 271 4 prosecuted prosecute VERB _005457217 271 5 for for ADP _005457217 271 6 failure failure NOUN _005457217 271 7 to to PART _005457217 271 8 send send VERB _005457217 271 9 their their PRON _005457217 271 10 children child NOUN _005457217 271 11 to to PART _005457217 271 12 school school VERB _005457217 271 13 a a DET _005457217 271 14 f f NOUN _005457217 271 15 t t NOUN _005457217 271 16 e e NOUN _005457217 271 17 r r NOUN _005457217 271 18 expulsion expulsion NOUN _005457217 271 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 272 1 members member NOUN _005457217 272 2 of of ADP _005457217 272 3 jehovah jehovah NOUN _005457217 272 4 's 's PART _005457217 272 5 witnesses witness NOUN _005457217 272 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 272 7 including include VERB _005457217 272 8 the the DET _005457217 272 9 children child NOUN _005457217 272 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 272 11 refused refuse VERB _005457217 272 12 to to PART _005457217 272 13 salute salute VERB _005457217 272 14 the the DET _005457217 272 15 23 23 NUM _005457217 272 16 flag flag NOUN _005457217 272 17 because because SCONJ _005457217 272 18 to to ADP _005457217 272 19 them they PRON _005457217 272 20 the the DET _005457217 272 21 flag flag NOUN _005457217 272 22 was be AUX _005457217 272 23 an an DET _005457217 272 24 idol idol NOUN _005457217 272 25 of of ADP _005457217 272 26 worship worship NOUN _005457217 272 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 272 28 and and CCONJ _005457217 272 29 the the DET _005457217 272 30 worship worship NOUN _005457217 272 31 of of ADP _005457217 272 32 any any DET _005457217 272 33 idol idol NOUN _005457217 272 34 , , PUNCT _005457217 272 35 under under ADP _005457217 272 36 their their PRON _005457217 272 37 religious religious ADJ _005457217 272 38 beliefs belief NOUN _005457217 272 39 , , PUNCT _005457217 272 40 was be AUX _005457217 272 41 a a DET _005457217 272 42 violation violation NOUN _005457217 272 43 of of ADP _005457217 272 44 the the DET _005457217 272 45 law law NOUN _005457217 272 46 of of ADP _005457217 272 47 g g NOUN _005457217 272 48 - - NOUN _005457217 272 49 od od NOUN _005457217 272 50 . . PUNCT _005457217 273 1 the the DET _005457217 273 2 essential essential ADJ _005457217 273 3 p p NOUN _005457217 273 4 a a DET _005457217 273 5 r r NOUN _005457217 273 6 t t NOUN _005457217 273 7 of of ADP _005457217 273 8 the the DET _005457217 273 9 f f NOUN _005457217 274 1 i i PRON _005457217 274 2 r r VERB _005457217 274 3 s s PART _005457217 274 4 t t NOUN _005457217 274 5 amendment amendment NOUN _005457217 274 6 to to ADP _005457217 274 7 the the DET _005457217 274 8 federal federal ADJ _005457217 274 9 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 274 10 involved involve VERB _005457217 274 11 was be AUX _005457217 274 12 that that SCONJ _005457217 274 13 neither neither CCONJ _005457217 274 14 congress congress PROPN _005457217 274 15 nor nor CCONJ _005457217 274 16 the the DET _005457217 274 17 state state NOUN _005457217 274 18 could could AUX _005457217 274 19 pass pass VERB _005457217 274 20 any any DET _005457217 274 21 law law NOUN _005457217 274 22 prohibiting prohibit VERB _005457217 274 23 the the DET _005457217 274 24 f f X _005457217 274 25 r r NOUN _005457217 274 26 e e NOUN _005457217 274 27 e e NOUN _005457217 274 28 exercise exercise NOUN _005457217 274 29 of of ADP _005457217 274 30 religion religion NOUN _005457217 274 31 . . PUNCT _005457217 275 1 the the DET _005457217 275 2 case case NOUN _005457217 275 3 was be AUX _005457217 275 4 not not PART _005457217 275 5 concerned concern VERB _005457217 275 6 at at ADV _005457217 275 7 all all ADV _005457217 275 8 with with ADP _005457217 275 9 the the DET _005457217 275 10 question question NOUN _005457217 275 11 of of ADP _005457217 275 12 whether whether SCONJ _005457217 275 13 the the DET _005457217 275 14 state state NOUN _005457217 275 15 or or CCONJ _005457217 275 16 nation nation NOUN _005457217 275 17 was be AUX _005457217 275 18 establishing establish VERB _005457217 275 19 religion religion NOUN _005457217 275 20 . . PUNCT _005457217 276 1 the the DET _005457217 276 2 following follow VERB _005457217 276 3 language language NOUN _005457217 276 4 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 276 5 63 63 NUM _005457217 276 6 sup sup NOUN _005457217 276 7 . . PUNCT _005457217 277 1 ct ct PROPN _005457217 277 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 277 3 1181 1181 NUM _005457217 277 4 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 277 5 in in ADP _005457217 277 6 the the DET _005457217 277 7 majority majority NOUN _005457217 277 8 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 277 9 is be AUX _005457217 277 10 important important ADJ _005457217 277 11 in in ADP _005457217 277 12 the the DET _005457217 277 13 consideration consideration NOUN _005457217 277 14 of of ADP _005457217 277 15 the the DET _005457217 277 16 case case NOUN _005457217 277 17 at at ADP _005457217 277 18 b b X _005457217 277 19 a a DET _005457217 277 20 r r NOUN _005457217 277 21 : : PUNCT _005457217 277 22 " " PUNCT _005457217 277 23 t t NOUN _005457217 277 24 h h NOUN _005457217 277 25 e e NOUN _005457217 277 26 freedom freedom NOUN _005457217 277 27 asserted assert VERB _005457217 277 28 by by ADP _005457217 277 29 these these DET _005457217 277 30 appellees appellee NOUN _005457217 277 31 does do AUX _005457217 277 32 not not PART _005457217 277 33 bring bring VERB _005457217 277 34 them they PRON _005457217 277 35 into into ADP _005457217 277 36 collision collision NOUN _005457217 277 37 with with ADP _005457217 277 38 rights right NOUN _005457217 277 39 asserted assert VERB _005457217 277 40 by by ADP _005457217 277 41 any any DET _005457217 277 42 other other ADJ _005457217 277 43 individual individual NOUN _005457217 277 44 . . PUNCT _005457217 278 1 i i PRON _005457217 278 2 t t NOUN _005457217 278 3 is be AUX _005457217 278 4 such such ADJ _005457217 278 5 conflicts conflict NOUN _005457217 278 6 which which PRON _005457217 278 7 most most ADV _005457217 278 8 frequently frequently ADV _005457217 278 9 require require VERB _005457217 278 10 intervention intervention NOUN _005457217 278 11 of of ADP _005457217 278 12 the the DET _005457217 278 13 state state NOUN _005457217 278 14 to to PART _005457217 278 15 determine determine VERB _005457217 278 16 where where SCONJ _005457217 278 17 the the DET _005457217 278 18 rights right NOUN _005457217 278 19 of of ADP _005457217 278 20 one one NUM _005457217 278 21 end end NOUN _005457217 278 22 and and CCONJ _005457217 278 23 those those PRON _005457217 278 24 of of ADP _005457217 278 25 another another DET _005457217 278 26 begin begin NOUN _005457217 278 27 . . PUNCT _005457217 279 1 but but CCONJ _005457217 279 2 the the DET _005457217 279 3 refusal refusal NOUN _005457217 279 4 of of ADP _005457217 279 5 these these DET _005457217 279 6 persons person NOUN _005457217 279 7 to to PART _005457217 279 8 participate participate VERB _005457217 279 9 in in ADP _005457217 279 10 the the DET _005457217 279 11 ceremony ceremony NOUN _005457217 279 12 does do AUX _005457217 279 13 not not PART _005457217 279 14 interfere interfere VERB _005457217 279 15 with with ADP _005457217 279 16 or or CCONJ _005457217 279 17 deny deny VERB _005457217 279 18 rights right NOUN _005457217 279 19 of of ADP _005457217 279 20 others other NOUN _005457217 279 21 to to PART _005457217 279 22 do do VERB _005457217 279 23 so so ADV _005457217 279 24 . . PUNCT _005457217 280 1 nor nor CCONJ _005457217 280 2 is be AUX _005457217 280 3 there there PRON _005457217 280 4 any any DET _005457217 280 5 question question NOUN _005457217 280 6 in in ADP _005457217 280 7 this this DET _005457217 280 8 case case NOUN _005457217 280 9 that that SCONJ _005457217 280 10 their their PRON _005457217 280 11 behavior behavior NOUN _005457217 280 12 is be AUX _005457217 280 13 peaceable peaceable ADJ _005457217 280 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 280 15 orderly orderly ADJ _005457217 280 16 . . PUNCT _005457217 281 1 the the DET _005457217 281 2 sole sole ADJ _005457217 281 3 conflict conflict NOUN _005457217 281 4 is be AUX _005457217 281 5 between between ADP _005457217 281 6 authority authority NOUN _005457217 281 7 and and CCONJ _005457217 281 8 rights right NOUN _005457217 281 9 of of ADP _005457217 281 10 the the DET _005457217 281 11 individual individual NOUN _005457217 281 12 . . PUNCT _005457217 282 1 the the DET _005457217 282 2 state state NOUN _005457217 282 3 asserts assert VERB _005457217 282 4 power power NOUN _005457217 282 5 to to PART _005457217 282 6 condition condition VERB _005457217 282 7 access access NOUN _005457217 282 8 to to ADP _005457217 282 9 public public ADJ _005457217 282 10 education education NOUN _005457217 282 11 on on ADP _005457217 282 12 making make VERB _005457217 282 13 a a DET _005457217 282 14 prescribed prescribed ADJ _005457217 282 15 sign sign NOUN _005457217 282 16 and and CCONJ _005457217 282 17 profession profession NOUN _005457217 282 18 and and CCONJ _005457217 282 19 at at ADP _005457217 282 20 the the DET _005457217 282 21 same same ADJ _005457217 282 22 time time NOUN _005457217 282 23 to to PART _005457217 282 24 coerce coerce VERB _005457217 282 25 attendance attendance NOUN _005457217 282 26 by by ADP _005457217 282 27 punishing punish VERB _005457217 282 28 both both PRON _005457217 282 29 parent parent NOUN _005457217 282 30 and and CCONJ _005457217 282 31 child child NOUN _005457217 282 32 . . PUNCT _005457217 282 33 " " PUNCT _005457217 283 1 i i PRON _005457217 283 2 t t PROPN _005457217 283 3 may may AUX _005457217 283 4 therefore therefore ADV _005457217 283 5 be be AUX _005457217 283 6 said say VERB _005457217 283 7 that that SCONJ _005457217 283 8 so so ADV _005457217 283 9 f f X _005457217 283 10 a a DET _005457217 283 11 r r NOUN _005457217 283 12 as as ADP _005457217 283 13 federal federal ADJ _005457217 283 14 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 283 15 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 283 16 are be AUX _005457217 283 17 concerned concern VERB _005457217 283 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 283 19 and and CCONJ _005457217 283 20 conceding concede VERB _005457217 283 21 that that SCONJ _005457217 283 22 they they PRON _005457217 283 23 are be AUX _005457217 283 24 binding bind VERB _005457217 283 25 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 283 26 the the DET _005457217 283 27 state state NOUN _005457217 283 28 of of ADP _005457217 283 29 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 283 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 283 31 and and CCONJ _005457217 283 32 on on ADP _005457217 283 33 the the DET _005457217 283 34 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 283 35 school school NOUN _005457217 283 36 board board NOUN _005457217 283 37 , , PUNCT _005457217 283 38 there there PRON _005457217 283 39 is be VERB _005457217 283 40 nothing nothing PRON _005457217 283 41 in in ADP _005457217 283 42 any any DET _005457217 283 43 expression expression NOUN _005457217 283 44 of of ADP _005457217 283 45 the the DET _005457217 283 46 federal federal ADJ _005457217 283 47 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 283 48 court court PROPN _005457217 283 49 that that PRON _005457217 283 50 remotely remotely ADV _005457217 283 51 indicates indicate VERB _005457217 283 52 there there PRON _005457217 283 53 is be VERB _005457217 283 54 any any DET _005457217 283 55 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 283 56 objection objection NOUN _005457217 283 57 to to ADP _005457217 283 58 the the DET _005457217 283 59 champaign champaign NOUN _005457217 283 60 system system NOUN _005457217 283 61 of of ADP _005457217 283 62 religious religious ADJ _005457217 283 63 education education NOUN _005457217 283 64 . . PUNCT _005457217 284 1 we we PRON _005457217 284 2 come come VERB _005457217 284 3 now now ADV _005457217 284 4 to to ADP _005457217 284 5 a a DET _005457217 284 6 consideration consideration NOUN _005457217 284 7 of of ADP _005457217 284 8 the the DET _005457217 284 9 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 284 10 of of ADP _005457217 284 11 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 284 12 and and CCONJ _005457217 284 13 of of ADP _005457217 284 14 the the DET _005457217 284 15 cases case NOUN _005457217 284 16 in in ADP _005457217 284 17 our our PRON _005457217 284 18 own own ADJ _005457217 284 19 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 284 20 court court PROPN _005457217 284 21 dealing deal VERB _005457217 284 22 with with ADP _005457217 284 23 those those DET _005457217 284 24 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 284 25 . . PUNCT _005457217 285 1 the the DET _005457217 285 2 relator relator NOUN _005457217 285 3 rests rest VERB _005457217 285 4 her her PRON _005457217 285 5 24 24 NUM _005457217 285 6 entire entire ADJ _005457217 285 7 case case NOUN _005457217 285 8 for for ADP _005457217 285 9 all all DET _005457217 285 10 practical practical ADJ _005457217 285 11 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 285 12 on on ADP _005457217 285 13 the the DET _005457217 285 14 case case NOUN _005457217 285 15 of of ADP _005457217 285 16 people people NOUN _005457217 285 17 ex ex PROPN _005457217 285 18 rel rel PROPN _005457217 285 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 286 1 ring ring PROPN _005457217 286 2 v. v. PROPN _005457217 286 3 board board PROPN _005457217 286 4 of of ADP _005457217 286 5 education education NOUN _005457217 286 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 286 7 245 245 NUM _005457217 286 8 111 111 NUM _005457217 286 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 287 1 334 334 NUM _005457217 287 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 288 1 before before ADP _005457217 288 2 taking take VERB _005457217 288 3 up up ADP _005457217 288 4 that that DET _005457217 288 5 case case NOUN _005457217 288 6 it it PRON _005457217 288 7 will will AUX _005457217 288 8 be be AUX _005457217 288 9 well well ADJ _005457217 288 10 to to PART _005457217 288 11 take take VERB _005457217 288 12 up up ADP _005457217 288 13 the the DET _005457217 288 14 whole whole ADJ _005457217 288 15 series series NOUN _005457217 288 16 of of ADP _005457217 288 17 cases case NOUN _005457217 288 18 in in ADP _005457217 288 19 the the DET _005457217 288 20 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 288 21 court court PROPN _005457217 288 22 of of ADP _005457217 288 23 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 288 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 288 25 including include VERB _005457217 288 26 the the DET _005457217 288 27 ring ring NOUN _005457217 288 28 case case NOUN _005457217 288 29 , , PUNCT _005457217 288 30 to to PART _005457217 288 31 determine determine VERB _005457217 288 32 the the DET _005457217 288 33 legality legality NOUN _005457217 288 34 of of ADP _005457217 288 35 the the DET _005457217 288 36 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 288 37 board board NOUN _005457217 288 38 's 's PART _005457217 288 39 acts act NOUN _005457217 288 40 in in ADP _005457217 288 41 the the DET _005457217 288 42 case case NOUN _005457217 288 43 at at ADP _005457217 288 44 bar bar NOUN _005457217 288 45 . . PUNCT _005457217 289 1 may may AUX _005457217 289 2 we we PRON _005457217 289 3 again again ADV _005457217 289 4 state state VERB _005457217 289 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 289 6 the the DET _005457217 289 7 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 289 8 constitution constitution PROPN _005457217 289 9 insures insure VERB _005457217 289 10 " " PUNCT _005457217 289 11 t t NOUN _005457217 289 12 h h NOUN _005457217 289 13 e e X _005457217 289 14 free free ADJ _005457217 289 15 exercise exercise NOUN _005457217 289 16 and and CCONJ _005457217 289 17 enjoyment enjoyment NOUN _005457217 289 18 of of ADP _005457217 289 19 religious religious ADJ _005457217 289 20 profession profession NOUN _005457217 289 21 and and CCONJ _005457217 289 22 worship worship NOUN _005457217 289 23 , , PUNCT _005457217 289 24 without without ADP _005457217 289 25 discrimination discrimination NOUN _005457217 289 26 " " PUNCT _005457217 289 27 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 289 28 and and CCONJ _005457217 289 29 it it PRON _005457217 289 30 provides provide VERB _005457217 289 31 , , PUNCT _005457217 289 32 " " PUNCT _005457217 289 33 n n CCONJ _005457217 289 34 o o NOUN _005457217 289 35 person person NOUN _005457217 289 36 shall shall AUX _005457217 289 37 be be AUX _005457217 289 38 required require VERB _005457217 289 39 to to PART _005457217 289 40 attend attend VERB _005457217 289 41 or or CCONJ _005457217 289 42 support support VERB _005457217 289 43 any any DET _005457217 289 44 ministry ministry NOUN _005457217 289 45 or or CCONJ _005457217 289 46 place place NOUN _005457217 289 47 of of ADP _005457217 289 48 worship worship NOUN _005457217 289 49 against against ADP _005457217 289 50 his his PRON _005457217 289 51 consent consent NOUN _005457217 289 52 , , PUNCT _005457217 289 53 nor nor CCONJ _005457217 289 54 shall shall AUX _005457217 289 55 any any DET _005457217 289 56 preference preference NOUN _005457217 289 57 be be AUX _005457217 289 58 given give VERB _005457217 289 59 by by ADP _005457217 289 60 law law NOUN _005457217 289 61 to to ADP _005457217 289 62 any any DET _005457217 289 63 religious religious ADJ _005457217 289 64 denomination denomination NOUN _005457217 289 65 or or CCONJ _005457217 289 66 mode mode NOUN _005457217 289 67 of of ADP _005457217 289 68 worship worship NOUN _005457217 289 69 " " PUNCT _005457217 289 70 ? ? PUNCT _005457217 290 1 further far ADV _005457217 290 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 290 3 it it PRON _005457217 290 4 provides provide VERB _005457217 290 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 290 6 no no DET _005457217 290 7 school school NOUN _005457217 290 8 board board NOUN _005457217 290 9 " " PUNCT _005457217 290 10 s s VERB _005457217 290 11 h h NOUN _005457217 290 12 a a DET _005457217 290 13 l l X _005457217 290 14 l l NOUN _005457217 290 15 ever ever ADV _005457217 290 16 make make VERB _005457217 290 17 any any DET _005457217 290 18 appropriation appropriation NOUN _005457217 290 19 or or CCONJ _005457217 290 20 pay pay NOUN _005457217 290 21 from from ADP _005457217 290 22 any any DET _005457217 290 23 public public ADJ _005457217 290 24 fund fund NOUN _005457217 290 25 whatever whatever PRON _005457217 290 26 , , PUNCT _005457217 290 27 anything anything PRON _005457217 290 28 in in ADP _005457217 290 29 aid aid NOUN _005457217 290 30 of of ADP _005457217 290 31 any any DET _005457217 290 32 church church NOUN _005457217 290 33 or or CCONJ _005457217 290 34 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 290 35 purpose purpose NOUN _005457217 290 36 . . PUNCT _005457217 290 37 " " PUNCT _005457217 291 1 one one NUM _005457217 291 2 of of ADP _005457217 291 3 the the DET _005457217 291 4 earliest early ADJ _005457217 291 5 cases case NOUN _005457217 291 6 under under ADP _005457217 291 7 these these DET _005457217 291 8 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 291 9 of of ADP _005457217 291 10 the the DET _005457217 291 11 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 291 12 arose arise VERB _005457217 291 13 in in ADP _005457217 291 14 1879 1879 NUM _005457217 291 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 291 16 being be AUX _005457217 291 17 nichols nichols PROPN _005457217 291 18 v. v. ADP _005457217 291 19 school school NOUN _005457217 291 20 directors director NOUN _005457217 291 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 291 22 93 93 NUM _005457217 291 23 111 111 NUM _005457217 291 24 . . NUM _005457217 292 1 61 61 NUM _005457217 292 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 293 1 mr mr PROPN _005457217 293 2 . . PROPN _005457217 293 3 justice justice PROPN _005457217 293 4 sheldon sheldon PROPN _005457217 293 5 who who PRON _005457217 293 6 wrote write VERB _005457217 293 7 the the DET _005457217 293 8 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 293 9 was be AUX _005457217 293 10 a a DET _005457217 293 11 member member NOUN _005457217 293 12 of of ADP _005457217 293 13 the the DET _005457217 293 14 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 293 15 convention convention NOUN _005457217 293 16 in in ADP _005457217 293 17 1870 1870 NUM _005457217 293 18 . . PUNCT _005457217 294 1 i i PRON _005457217 294 2 t t PROPN _005457217 294 3 was be AUX _005457217 294 4 a a DET _005457217 294 5 suit suit NOUN _005457217 294 6 for for ADP _005457217 294 7 injunction injunction NOUN _005457217 294 8 by by ADP _005457217 294 9 a a DET _005457217 294 10 citizen citizen NOUN _005457217 294 11 and and CCONJ _005457217 294 12 a a DET _005457217 294 13 tax tax NOUN _005457217 294 14 payer payer NOUN _005457217 294 15 within within ADP _005457217 294 16 a a DET _005457217 294 17 school school NOUN _005457217 294 18 district district NOUN _005457217 294 19 to to PART _005457217 294 20 restrain restrain VERB _005457217 294 21 t t NOUN _005457217 294 22 h h NOUN _005457217 294 23 e e NOUN _005457217 294 24 school school NOUN _005457217 294 25 directors director NOUN _005457217 294 26 from from ADP _005457217 294 27 allowing allow VERB _005457217 294 28 the the DET _005457217 294 29 school school NOUN _005457217 294 30 house house NOUN _005457217 294 31 of of ADP _005457217 294 32 the the DET _005457217 294 33 district district NOUN _005457217 294 34 to to PART _005457217 294 35 be be AUX _005457217 294 36 used use VERB _005457217 294 37 for for ADP _005457217 294 38 the the DET _005457217 294 39 purpose purpose NOUN _005457217 294 40 of of ADP _005457217 294 41 a a DET _005457217 294 42 religious religious ADJ _005457217 294 43 meeting meeting NOUN _005457217 294 44 house house NOUN _005457217 294 45 . . PUNCT _005457217 295 1 the the DET _005457217 295 2 plaintiff plaintiff NOUN _005457217 295 3 in in ADP _005457217 295 4 that that DET _005457217 295 5 case case NOUN _005457217 295 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 295 7 like like ADP _005457217 295 8 the the DET _005457217 295 9 relator relator NOUN _005457217 295 10 in in ADP _005457217 295 11 the the DET _005457217 295 12 case case NOUN _005457217 295 13 at at ADP _005457217 295 14 bar bar NOUN _005457217 295 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 295 16 stated state VERB _005457217 295 17 that that SCONJ _005457217 295 18 he he PRON _005457217 295 19 was be AUX _005457217 295 20 opposed opposed ADJ _005457217 295 21 to to ADP _005457217 295 22 the the DET _005457217 295 23 use use NOUN _005457217 295 24 of of ADP _005457217 295 25 a a DET _005457217 295 26 school school NOUN _005457217 295 27 house house NOUN _005457217 296 1 f f PROPN _005457217 296 2 o o X _005457217 297 1 r r NOUN _005457217 297 2 these these DET _005457217 297 3 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 297 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 297 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 297 6 they they PRON _005457217 297 7 were be AUX _005457217 297 8 contrary contrary ADJ _005457217 297 9 to to ADP _005457217 297 10 the the DET _005457217 297 11 law law NOUN _005457217 297 12 of of ADP _005457217 297 13 the the DET _005457217 297 14 land land NOUN _005457217 297 15 . . PUNCT _005457217 298 1 certainly certainly ADV _005457217 298 2 it it PRON _005457217 298 3 would would AUX _005457217 298 4 seem seem VERB _005457217 298 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 298 6 the the DET _005457217 298 7 use use NOUN _005457217 298 8 of of ADP _005457217 298 9 a a DET _005457217 298 10 school school NOUN _005457217 298 11 house house NOUN _005457217 298 12 to to PART _005457217 298 13 hold hold VERB _005457217 298 14 religious religious ADJ _005457217 298 15 meetings meeting NOUN _005457217 298 16 by by ADP _005457217 298 17 the the DET _005457217 298 18 directors director NOUN _005457217 298 19 would would AUX _005457217 298 20 come come VERB _005457217 298 21 perilously perilously ADV _005457217 298 22 close close ADJ _005457217 298 23 to to ADP _005457217 298 24 . . PUNCT _005457217 299 1 the the DET _005457217 299 2 prohibition prohibition NOUN _005457217 299 3 of of ADP _005457217 299 4 article article NOUN _005457217 299 5 viii viii NOUN _005457217 299 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 299 7 section section NOUN _005457217 299 8 3 3 NUM _005457217 299 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 299 10 which which PRON _005457217 299 11 forbids forbid VERB _005457217 299 12 any any DET _005457217 299 13 school school NOUN _005457217 299 14 district district NOUN _005457217 299 15 from from ADP _005457217 299 16 ever ever ADV _005457217 299 17 making make VERB _005457217 299 18 any any DET _005457217 299 19 appropriation appropriation NOUN _005457217 299 20 or or CCONJ _005457217 299 21 paying pay VERB _005457217 299 22 from from ADP _005457217 299 23 any any DET _005457217 299 24 public public ADJ _005457217 299 25 fund fund NOUN _005457217 299 26 whatever whatever DET _005457217 299 27 anything anything PRON _005457217 299 28 in in ADP _005457217 299 29 aid aid NOUN _005457217 299 30 of of ADP _005457217 299 31 any any DET _005457217 299 32 church church NOUN _005457217 299 33 or or CCONJ _005457217 299 34 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 299 35 purpose purpose NOUN _005457217 299 36 . . PUNCT _005457217 300 1 however however ADV _005457217 300 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 300 3 the the DET _005457217 300 4 demurrer demurrer NOUN _005457217 300 5 to to PART _005457217 300 6 25 25 NUM _005457217 300 7 the the DET _005457217 300 8 bill bill NOUN _005457217 300 9 was be AUX _005457217 300 10 sustained sustain VERB _005457217 300 11 in in ADP _005457217 300 12 the the DET _005457217 300 13 trial trial NOUN _005457217 300 14 court court NOUN _005457217 300 15 . . PUNCT _005457217 301 1 this this PRON _005457217 301 2 was be AUX _005457217 301 3 affirmed affirm VERB _005457217 301 4 in in ADP _005457217 301 5 the the DET _005457217 301 6 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 301 7 court court PROPN _005457217 301 8 . . PUNCT _005457217 302 1 some some PRON _005457217 302 2 of of ADP _005457217 302 3 the the DET _005457217 302 4 language language NOUN _005457217 302 5 in in ADP _005457217 302 6 that that DET _005457217 302 7 case case NOUN _005457217 302 8 answers answer VERB _005457217 302 9 the the DET _005457217 302 10 contention contention NOUN _005457217 302 11 of of ADP _005457217 302 12 the the DET _005457217 302 13 relator relator NOUN _005457217 302 14 in in ADP _005457217 302 15 this this DET _005457217 302 16 case case NOUN _005457217 302 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 302 18 that that SCONJ _005457217 302 19 the the DET _005457217 302 20 furnishing furnishing NOUN _005457217 302 21 of of ADP _005457217 302 22 lights light NOUN _005457217 302 23 and and CCONJ _005457217 302 24 janitor janitor NOUN _005457217 302 25 service service PROPN _005457217 302 26 , , PUNCT _005457217 302 27 the the DET _005457217 302 28 wear wear NOUN _005457217 302 29 and and CCONJ _005457217 302 30 tear tear VERB _005457217 302 31 on on ADP _005457217 302 32 furniture furniture NOUN _005457217 302 33 , , PUNCT _005457217 302 34 and and CCONJ _005457217 302 35 so so ADV _005457217 302 36 forth forth ADV _005457217 302 37 , , PUNCT _005457217 302 38 is be AUX _005457217 302 39 an an DET _005457217 302 40 illegal illegal ADJ _005457217 302 41 appropriation appropriation NOUN _005457217 302 42 of of ADP _005457217 302 43 school school NOUN _005457217 302 44 property property NOUN _005457217 302 45 for for ADP _005457217 302 46 religious religious ADJ _005457217 302 47 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 302 48 . . PUNCT _005457217 303 1 the the DET _005457217 303 2 court court NOUN _005457217 303 3 said say VERB _005457217 303 4 : : PUNCT _005457217 303 5 " " PUNCT _005457217 303 6 i i PRON _005457217 303 7 n n VERB _005457217 303 8 what what PRON _005457217 303 9 manner manner NOUN _005457217 303 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 303 11 f f PROPN _005457217 303 12 r r PROPN _005457217 303 13 o o NOUN _005457217 303 14 m m VERB _005457217 303 15 the the DET _005457217 303 16 holding holding NOUN _005457217 303 17 of of ADP _005457217 303 18 religious religious ADJ _005457217 303 19 meetings meeting NOUN _005457217 303 20 in in ADP _005457217 303 21 the the DET _005457217 303 22 school school NOUN _005457217 303 23 house house NOUN _005457217 303 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 303 25 complainant complainant PROPN _005457217 303 26 is be AUX _005457217 303 27 going go VERB _005457217 303 28 to to PART _005457217 303 29 be be AUX _005457217 303 30 compelled compel VERB _005457217 303 31 to to PART _005457217 303 32 aid aid VERB _005457217 303 33 in in ADP _005457217 303 34 furnishing furnish VERB _005457217 303 35 a a DET _005457217 303 36 house house NOUN _005457217 303 37 of of ADP _005457217 303 38 worship worship NOUN _005457217 303 39 and and CCONJ _005457217 303 40 for for ADP _005457217 303 41 holding hold VERB _005457217 303 42 religious religious ADJ _005457217 303 43 meetings meeting NOUN _005457217 303 44 , , PUNCT _005457217 303 45 as as SCONJ _005457217 303 46 he he PRON _005457217 303 47 complains complain VERB _005457217 303 48 in in ADP _005457217 303 49 his his PRON _005457217 303 50 bill bill NOUN _005457217 303 51 , , PUNCT _005457217 303 52 he he PRON _005457217 303 53 does do AUX _005457217 303 54 not not PART _005457217 303 55 show show VERB _005457217 303 56 . . PUNCT _005457217 304 1 " " PUNCT _005457217 304 2 we we PRON _005457217 304 3 can can AUX _005457217 304 4 only only ADV _005457217 304 5 imagine imagine VERB _005457217 304 6 that that SCONJ _005457217 304 7 possibly possibly ADV _005457217 304 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 304 9 at at ADP _005457217 304 10 some some DET _005457217 304 11 f f PROPN _005457217 304 12 u u PROPN _005457217 304 13 t t NOUN _005457217 304 14 u u NOUN _005457217 304 15 r r NOUN _005457217 304 16 e e NOUN _005457217 304 17 time time NOUN _005457217 304 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 304 19 he he PRON _005457217 304 20 might might AUX _005457217 304 21 as as SCONJ _005457217 304 22 a a DET _005457217 304 23 tax tax NOUN _005457217 304 24 - - PUNCT _005457217 304 25 payer payer NOUN _005457217 304 26 be be AUX _005457217 304 27 made make VERB _005457217 304 28 to to PART _005457217 304 29 contribute contribute VERB _005457217 304 30 to to ADP _005457217 304 31 the the DET _005457217 304 32 expense expense NOUN _005457217 304 33 of of ADP _005457217 304 34 repairs repair NOUN _005457217 304 35 rendered render VERB _005457217 304 36 necessary necessary ADJ _005457217 304 37 f f X _005457217 304 38 r r NOUN _005457217 304 39 o o NOUN _005457217 304 40 m m AUX _005457217 304 41 wear wear NOUN _005457217 304 42 and and CCONJ _005457217 304 43 use use NOUN _005457217 304 44 of of ADP _005457217 304 45 the the DET _005457217 304 46 building building NOUN _005457217 304 47 in in ADP _005457217 304 48 the the DET _005457217 304 49 holding holding NOUN _005457217 304 50 of of ADP _005457217 304 51 religious religious ADJ _005457217 304 52 meetings meeting NOUN _005457217 304 53 . . PUNCT _005457217 305 1 a a DET _005457217 305 2 single single ADJ _005457217 305 3 holding holding NOUN _005457217 305 4 of of ADP _005457217 305 5 a a DET _005457217 305 6 religious religious ADJ _005457217 305 7 meeting meeting NOUN _005457217 305 8 in in ADP _005457217 305 9 the the DET _005457217 305 10 school school NOUN _005457217 305 11 house house NOUN _005457217 305 12 might might AUX _005457217 305 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 305 14 in in ADP _005457217 305 15 that that DET _005457217 305 16 way way NOUN _005457217 305 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 305 18 cause cause VERB _005457217 305 19 damage damage NOUN _005457217 305 20 in in ADP _005457217 305 21 some some DET _005457217 305 22 degree degree NOUN _005457217 305 23 to to ADP _005457217 305 24 the the DET _005457217 305 25 building building NOUN _005457217 305 26 , , PUNCT _005457217 305 27 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 305 28 the the DET _005457217 305 29 idea idea NOUN _005457217 305 30 that that SCONJ _005457217 305 31 continual continual ADJ _005457217 305 32 dropping dropping NOUN _005457217 305 33 wears wear VERB _005457217 305 34 away away ADV _005457217 305 35 stone stone NOUN _005457217 305 36 , , PUNCT _005457217 305 37 but but CCONJ _005457217 305 38 the the DET _005457217 305 39 i i PROPN _005457217 305 40 n n PROPN _005457217 305 41 j j PROPN _005457217 305 42 u u PROPN _005457217 305 43 r r NOUN _005457217 305 44 y y PROPN _005457217 305 45 would would AUX _005457217 305 46 be be AUX _005457217 305 47 inappreciable inappreciable ADJ _005457217 305 48 . . PUNCT _005457217 306 1 as as SCONJ _005457217 306 2 respects respect VERB _005457217 306 3 any any DET _005457217 306 4 individual individual ADJ _005457217 306 5 pecuniary pecuniary ADJ _005457217 306 6 expense expense NOUN _005457217 306 7 which which PRON _005457217 306 8 might might AUX _005457217 306 9 be be AUX _005457217 306 10 in in ADP _005457217 306 11 this this DET _005457217 306 12 way way NOUN _005457217 306 13 involved involve VERB _005457217 306 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 306 15 we we PRON _005457217 306 16 think think VERB _005457217 306 17 that that SCONJ _005457217 306 18 consideration consideration NOUN _005457217 306 19 may may AUX _005457217 306 20 be be AUX _005457217 306 21 properly properly ADV _005457217 306 22 disposed dispose VERB _005457217 306 23 of of ADP _005457217 306 24 under under ADP _005457217 306 25 the the DET _005457217 306 26 maxim maxim PROPN _005457217 306 27 de de PROPN _005457217 306 28 minimis minimis PROPN _005457217 306 29 , , PUNCT _005457217 306 30 etc etc X _005457217 306 31 . . X _005457217 306 32 " " PUNCT _005457217 307 1 t t NOUN _005457217 307 2 h h NOUN _005457217 307 3 e e NOUN _005457217 307 4 thing thing NOUN _005457217 307 5 contemplated contemplate VERB _005457217 307 6 by by ADP _005457217 307 7 the the DET _005457217 307 8 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 307 9 provision provision NOUN _005457217 307 10 first first ADV _005457217 307 11 above above ADP _005457217 307 12 named name VERB _005457217 307 13 was be AUX _005457217 307 14 a a DET _005457217 307 15 prohibition prohibition NOUN _005457217 307 16 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 307 17 the the DET _005457217 307 18 legislature legislature NOUN _005457217 307 19 to to PART _005457217 307 20 pass pass VERB _005457217 307 21 any any DET _005457217 307 22 law law NOUN _005457217 307 23 by by ADP _005457217 307 24 which which PRON _005457217 307 25 a a DET _005457217 307 26 person person NOUN _005457217 307 27 should should AUX _005457217 307 28 be be AUX _005457217 307 29 compelled compel VERB _005457217 307 30 without without ADP _005457217 307 31 his his PRON _005457217 307 32 consent consent NOUN _005457217 307 33 to to PART _005457217 307 34 contribute contribute VERB _005457217 307 35 to to ADP _005457217 307 36 the the DET _005457217 307 37 support support NOUN _005457217 307 38 of of ADP _005457217 307 39 any any DET _005457217 307 40 ministry ministry NOUN _005457217 307 41 or or CCONJ _005457217 307 42 place place NOUN _005457217 307 43 of of ADP _005457217 307 44 worship worship NOUN _005457217 307 45 . . PUNCT _005457217 308 1 " " PUNCT _005457217 309 1 s s PRON _005457217 309 2 u u NOUN _005457217 309 3 c c AUX _005457217 309 4 h h NOUN _005457217 309 5 a a DET _005457217 309 6 matter matter NOUN _005457217 309 7 as as ADP _005457217 309 8 the the DET _005457217 309 9 subject subject NOUN _005457217 309 10 of of ADP _005457217 309 11 complaint complaint NOUN _005457217 309 12 here here ADV _005457217 309 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 309 14 we we PRON _005457217 309 15 do do AUX _005457217 309 16 not not PART _005457217 309 17 regard regard VERB _005457217 309 18 as as ADP _005457217 309 19 within within ADP _005457217 309 20 its its PRON _005457217 309 21 purview purview NOUN _005457217 309 22 . . PUNCT _005457217 310 1 " " PUNCT _005457217 310 2 religion religion NOUN _005457217 310 3 and and CCONJ _005457217 310 4 religious religious ADJ _005457217 310 5 worship worship NOUN _005457217 310 6 are be AUX _005457217 310 7 not not PART _005457217 310 8 so so ADV _005457217 310 9 placed place VERB _005457217 310 10 under under ADP _005457217 310 11 the the DET _005457217 310 12 ban ban NOUN _005457217 310 13 of of ADP _005457217 310 14 the the DET _005457217 310 15 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 310 16 that that SCONJ _005457217 310 17 they they PRON _005457217 310 18 may may AUX _005457217 310 19 not not PART _005457217 310 20 be be AUX _005457217 310 21 allowed allow VERB _005457217 310 22 to to PART _005457217 310 23 become become VERB _005457217 310 24 the the DET _005457217 310 25 recipient recipient NOUN _005457217 310 26 of of ADP _005457217 310 27 any any DET _005457217 310 28 _ _ DET _005457217 310 29 incidental incidental ADJ _005457217 310 30 benefit benefit NOUN _005457217 310 31 whatsoever whatsoever ADV _005457217 310 32 from from ADP _005457217 310 33 the the DET _005457217 310 34 public public ADJ _005457217 310 35 bodies body NOUN _005457217 310 36 or or CCONJ _005457217 310 37 authorities authority NOUN _005457217 310 38 of of ADP _005457217 310 39 the the DET _005457217 310 40 state state NOUN _005457217 310 41 . . PUNCT _005457217 311 1 that that DET _005457217 311 2 instrument instrument NOUN _005457217 311 3 itself itself PRON _005457217 311 4 contains contain VERB _005457217 311 5 a a DET _005457217 311 6 provision provision NOUN _005457217 311 7 authorizing authorize VERB _005457217 311 8 the the DET _005457217 311 9 legislature legislature NOUN _005457217 311 10 to to PART _005457217 311 11 exempt exempt VERB _005457217 311 12 property property NOUN _005457217 311 13 used use VERB _005457217 311 14 for for ADP _005457217 311 15 religious religious ADJ _005457217 311 16 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 311 17 f f X _005457217 311 18 r r NOUN _005457217 311 19 o o NOUN _005457217 311 20 m m NOUN _005457217 311 21 taxation taxation NOUN _005457217 311 22 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 311 23 and and CCONJ _005457217 311 24 thereby thereby ADV _005457217 311 25 , , PUNCT _005457217 311 26 the the DET _005457217 311 27 same same ADJ _005457217 311 28 as as SCONJ _005457217 311 29 is be AUX _005457217 311 30 complained complain VERB _005457217 311 31 26 26 NUM _005457217 311 32 of of ADP _005457217 311 33 here here ADV _005457217 311 34 , , PUNCT _005457217 311 35 there there PRON _005457217 311 36 might might AUX _005457217 311 37 be be AUX _005457217 311 38 indirectly indirectly ADV _005457217 311 39 imposed impose VERB _005457217 311 40 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 311 41 the the DET _005457217 311 42 tax tax NOUN _005457217 311 43 - - PUNCT _005457217 311 44 payer payer NOUN _005457217 311 45 the the DET _005457217 311 46 burden burden NOUN _005457217 311 47 of of ADP _005457217 311 48 increased increase VERB _005457217 311 49 taxation taxation NOUN _005457217 311 50 , , PUNCT _005457217 311 51 and and CCONJ _005457217 311 52 in in ADP _005457217 311 53 that that DET _005457217 311 54 manner manner NOUN _005457217 311 55 the the DET _005457217 311 56 indirect indirect ADJ _005457217 311 57 supporting supporting NOUN _005457217 311 58 of of ADP _005457217 311 59 places place NOUN _005457217 311 60 of of ADP _005457217 311 61 worship worship NOUN _005457217 311 62 . . PUNCT _005457217 312 1 in in ADP _005457217 312 2 the the DET _005457217 312 3 respect respect NOUN _005457217 312 4 of of ADP _005457217 312 5 the the DET _005457217 312 6 possibility possibility NOUN _005457217 312 7 of of ADP _005457217 312 8 enhanced enhance VERB _005457217 312 9 taxation taxation NOUN _005457217 312 10 therefrom therefrom ADP _005457217 312 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 312 12 this this DET _005457217 312 13 provision provision NOUN _005457217 312 14 of of ADP _005457217 312 15 the the DET _005457217 312 16 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 312 17 itself itself PRON _005457217 312 18 is be AUX _005457217 312 19 even even ADV _005457217 312 20 more more ADV _005457217 312 21 obnoxious obnoxious ADJ _005457217 312 22 to to ADP _005457217 312 23 objection objection NOUN _005457217 312 24 than than ADP _005457217 312 25 this this DET _005457217 312 26 permission permission NOUN _005457217 312 27 given give VERB _005457217 312 28 by by ADP _005457217 312 29 the the DET _005457217 312 30 school school NOUN _005457217 312 31 directors director NOUN _005457217 312 32 to to PART _005457217 312 33 hold hold VERB _005457217 312 34 religious religious ADJ _005457217 312 35 meetings meeting NOUN _005457217 312 36 in in ADP _005457217 312 37 the the DET _005457217 312 38 school school NOUN _005457217 312 39 house house NOUN _005457217 312 40 . . PUNCT _005457217 313 1 there there PRON _005457217 313 2 is be VERB _005457217 313 3 no no DET _005457217 313 4 pretence pretence NOUN _005457217 313 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 313 6 it it PRON _005457217 313 7 is be AUX _005457217 313 8 in in ADP _005457217 313 9 any any DET _005457217 313 10 way way NOUN _005457217 313 11 in in ADP _005457217 313 12 interference interference NOUN _005457217 313 13 with with ADP _005457217 313 14 the the DET _005457217 313 15 occupation occupation NOUN _005457217 313 16 of of ADP _005457217 313 17 the the DET _005457217 313 18 building building NOUN _005457217 314 1 f f X _005457217 314 2 o o X _005457217 314 3 r r NOUN _005457217 314 4 school school NOUN _005457217 314 5 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 314 6 . . PUNCT _005457217 314 7 " " PUNCT _005457217 315 1 in in ADP _005457217 315 2 millard millard PROPN _005457217 315 3 v. v. PROPN _005457217 315 4 board board PROPN _005457217 315 5 of of ADP _005457217 315 6 education education NOUN _005457217 315 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 315 8 121 121 NUM _005457217 315 9 111 111 NUM _005457217 315 10 . . NUM _005457217 315 11 297 297 NUM _005457217 315 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 315 13 it it PRON _005457217 315 14 was be AUX _005457217 315 15 held hold VERB _005457217 315 16 that that SCONJ _005457217 315 17 where where SCONJ _005457217 315 18 a a DET _005457217 315 19 school school NOUN _005457217 315 20 board board NOUN _005457217 315 21 rented rent VERB _005457217 315 22 the the DET _005457217 315 23 basement basement NOUN _005457217 315 24 of of ADP _005457217 315 25 a a DET _005457217 315 26 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 315 27 church church NOUN _005457217 315 28 for for ADP _005457217 315 29 school school NOUN _005457217 315 30 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 315 31 and and CCONJ _005457217 315 32 taught teach VERB _005457217 315 33 school school NOUN _005457217 315 34 there there ADV _005457217 315 35 from from ADP _005457217 315 36 nine nine NUM _005457217 315 37 o'clock o'clock NOUN _005457217 315 38 in in ADP _005457217 315 39 the the DET _005457217 315 40 morning morning NOUN _005457217 315 41 , , PUNCT _005457217 315 42 on on ADP _005457217 315 43 , , PUNCT _005457217 315 44 that that SCONJ _005457217 315 45 no no DET _005457217 315 46 tax tax NOUN _005457217 315 47 payer payer NOUN _005457217 315 48 could could AUX _005457217 315 49 complain complain VERB _005457217 315 50 that that SCONJ _005457217 315 51 just just ADV _005457217 315 52 before before SCONJ _005457217 315 53 school school NOUN _005457217 315 54 started start VERB _005457217 315 55 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 315 56 and and CCONJ _005457217 315 57 a a DET _005457217 315 58 f f NOUN _005457217 315 59 t t NOUN _005457217 315 60 e e NOUN _005457217 315 61 r r NOUN _005457217 315 62 school school NOUN _005457217 315 63 ended end VERB _005457217 315 64 , , PUNCT _005457217 315 65 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 315 66 who who PRON _005457217 315 67 voluntarily voluntarily ADV _005457217 315 68 desired desire VERB _005457217 315 69 to to PART _005457217 315 70 do do VERB _005457217 315 71 so so ADV _005457217 315 72 , , PUNCT _005457217 315 73 participated participate VERB _005457217 315 74 in in ADP _005457217 315 75 mass mass PROPN _005457217 315 76 , , PUNCT _005457217 315 77 the the DET _005457217 315 78 saying saying NOUN _005457217 315 79 of of ADP _005457217 315 80 the the DET _005457217 315 81 angelus angelus NOUN _005457217 315 82 , , PUNCT _005457217 315 83 and and CCONJ _005457217 315 84 other other ADJ _005457217 315 85 roman roman ADJ _005457217 315 86 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 315 87 services service NOUN _005457217 315 88 . . PUNCT _005457217 316 1 the the DET _005457217 316 2 bill bill NOUN _005457217 316 3 for for ADP _005457217 316 4 injunction injunction NOUN _005457217 316 5 was be AUX _005457217 316 6 dismissed dismiss VERB _005457217 316 7 . . PUNCT _005457217 317 1 the the DET _005457217 317 2 lack lack NOUN _005457217 317 3 of of ADP _005457217 317 4 compulsion compulsion NOUN _005457217 317 5 in in ADP _005457217 317 6 participation participation NOUN _005457217 317 7 in in ADP _005457217 317 8 religious religious ADJ _005457217 317 9 services service NOUN _005457217 317 10 was be AUX _005457217 317 11 manifest manifest ADJ _005457217 317 12 . . PUNCT _005457217 318 1 the the DET _005457217 318 2 court court NOUN _005457217 318 3 said say VERB _005457217 318 4 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 318 5 p. p. NOUN _005457217 318 6 302 302 NUM _005457217 318 7 ): ): PUNCT _005457217 318 8 " " PUNCT _005457217 318 9 n n X _005457217 319 1 o o NOUN _005457217 319 2 r r NOUN _005457217 319 3 is be AUX _005457217 319 4 it it PRON _005457217 319 5 claimed claim VERB _005457217 319 6 that that SCONJ _005457217 319 7 complainant complainant NOUN _005457217 319 8 's 's PART _005457217 319 9 children child NOUN _005457217 319 10 are be AUX _005457217 319 11 required require VERB _005457217 319 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 319 13 against against ADP _005457217 319 14 his his PRON _005457217 319 15 will will NOUN _005457217 319 16 or or CCONJ _005457217 319 17 desire desire VERB _005457217 319 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 319 19 to to PART _005457217 319 20 attend attend VERB _005457217 319 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 319 22 any any DET _005457217 319 23 religious religious ADJ _005457217 319 24 or or CCONJ _005457217 319 25 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 319 26 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 319 27 in in ADP _005457217 319 28 the the DET _005457217 319 29 school school NOUN _005457217 319 30 . . PUNCT _005457217 320 1 under under ADP _005457217 320 2 such such ADJ _005457217 320 3 circumstances circumstance NOUN _005457217 320 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 320 5 we we PRON _005457217 320 6 see see VERB _005457217 320 7 no no DET _005457217 320 8 ground ground NOUN _005457217 320 9 f f PROPN _005457217 320 10 o o NOUN _005457217 320 11 r r NOUN _005457217 320 12 relief relief NOUN _005457217 320 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 320 14 under under ADP _005457217 320 15 this this DET _005457217 320 16 p p NOUN _005457217 320 17 a a DET _005457217 320 18 r r NOUN _005457217 320 19 t t NOUN _005457217 320 20 of of ADP _005457217 320 21 thebill thebill PROPN _005457217 320 22 . . PUNCT _005457217 320 23 " " PUNCT _005457217 321 1 i i PRON _005457217 321 2 n n VERB _005457217 321 3 the the DET _005457217 321 4 case case NOUN _005457217 321 5 of of ADP _005457217 321 6 north north PROPN _005457217 321 7 v. v. ADP _005457217 321 8 trustees trustee NOUN _005457217 321 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 321 10 137 137 NUM _005457217 321 11 111 111 NUM _005457217 321 12 . . NUM _005457217 321 13 296 296 NUM _005457217 321 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 321 15 mandamus mandamus NOUN _005457217 321 16 was be AUX _005457217 321 17 sought seek VERB _005457217 321 18 by by ADP _005457217 321 19 a a DET _005457217 321 20 student student NOUN _005457217 321 21 at at ADP _005457217 321 22 the the DET _005457217 321 23 university university PROPN _005457217 321 24 of of ADP _005457217 321 25 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 321 26 . . PUNCT _005457217 322 1 the the DET _005457217 322 2 rules rule NOUN _005457217 322 3 of of ADP _005457217 322 4 the the DET _005457217 322 5 university university NOUN _005457217 322 6 required require VERB _005457217 322 7 a a DET _005457217 322 8 student student NOUN _005457217 322 9 to to PART _005457217 322 10 attend attend VERB _005457217 322 11 chapel chapel NOUN _005457217 322 12 where where SCONJ _005457217 322 13 the the DET _005457217 322 14 lord lord PROPN _005457217 322 15 's 's PART _005457217 322 16 p p NOUN _005457217 322 17 r r NOUN _005457217 322 18 a a DET _005457217 322 19 y y PROPN _005457217 322 20 e e NOUN _005457217 322 21 r r NOUN _005457217 322 22 was be AUX _005457217 322 23 recited recite VERB _005457217 322 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 322 25 and and CCONJ _005457217 322 26 the the DET _005457217 322 27 scriptures scripture NOUN _005457217 322 28 were be AUX _005457217 322 29 read read VERB _005457217 322 30 . . PUNCT _005457217 323 1 the the DET _005457217 323 2 rules rule NOUN _005457217 323 3 of of ADP _005457217 323 4 the the DET _005457217 323 5 university university NOUN _005457217 323 6 also also ADV _005457217 323 7 provided provide VERB _005457217 323 8 that that SCONJ _005457217 323 9 the the DET _005457217 323 10 student student NOUN _005457217 323 11 could could AUX _005457217 323 12 be be AUX _005457217 323 13 excused excuse VERB _005457217 323 14 by by ADP _005457217 323 15 stating state VERB _005457217 323 16 that that SCONJ _005457217 323 17 such such ADJ _005457217 323 18 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 323 19 offended offend VERB _005457217 323 20 his his PRON _005457217 323 21 conscientious conscientious ADJ _005457217 323 22 scruples scruple NOUN _005457217 323 23 , , PUNCT _005457217 323 24 but but CCONJ _005457217 323 25 the the DET _005457217 323 26 student student NOUN _005457217 323 27 refused refuse VERB _005457217 323 28 to to PART _005457217 323 29 sign sign VERB _005457217 323 30 such such DET _005457217 323 31 an an DET _005457217 323 32 excuse excuse NOUN _005457217 323 33 , , PUNCT _005457217 323 34 resting rest VERB _005457217 323 35 his his PRON _005457217 323 36 case case NOUN _005457217 323 37 on on ADP _005457217 323 38 the the DET _005457217 323 39 alleged allege VERB _005457217 323 40 illegality illegality NOUN _005457217 323 41 of of ADP _005457217 323 42 these these DET _005457217 323 43 chapel chapel NOUN _005457217 323 44 27 27 NUM _005457217 323 45 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 323 46 . . PUNCT _005457217 324 1 he he PRON _005457217 324 2 was be AUX _005457217 324 3 expelled expel VERB _005457217 324 4 from from ADP _005457217 324 5 school school NOUN _005457217 324 6 in in ADP _005457217 324 7 1885 1885 NUM _005457217 324 8 . . PUNCT _005457217 325 1 five five NUM _005457217 325 2 years year NOUN _005457217 325 3 later later ADV _005457217 325 4 he he PRON _005457217 325 5 brought bring VERB _005457217 325 6 suit suit NOUN _005457217 325 7 in in ADP _005457217 325 8 mandamus mandamus NOUN _005457217 325 9 to to PART _005457217 325 10 compel compel VERB _005457217 325 11 the the DET _005457217 325 12 university university NOUN _005457217 325 13 to to PART _005457217 325 14 re re VERB _005457217 325 15 - - VERB _005457217 325 16 admit admit VERB _005457217 325 17 him he PRON _005457217 325 18 . . PUNCT _005457217 326 1 he he PRON _005457217 326 2 did do AUX _005457217 326 3 not not PART _005457217 326 4 state state VERB _005457217 326 5 why why SCONJ _005457217 326 6 he he PRON _005457217 326 7 wanted want VERB _005457217 326 8 to to PART _005457217 326 9 be be AUX _005457217 326 10 re re VERB _005457217 326 11 - - VERB _005457217 326 12 admitted admit VERB _005457217 326 13 . . PUNCT _005457217 327 1 mandamus mandamus PROPN _005457217 327 2 was be AUX _005457217 327 3 denied deny VERB _005457217 327 4 . . PUNCT _005457217 328 1 a a DET _005457217 328 2 f f PROPN _005457217 328 3 t t NOUN _005457217 328 4 e e NOUN _005457217 328 5 r r NOUN _005457217 328 6 speaking speak VERB _005457217 328 7 briefly briefly ADV _005457217 328 8 of of ADP _005457217 328 9 the the DET _005457217 328 10 religious religious ADJ _005457217 328 11 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 328 12 in in ADP _005457217 328 13 chapel chapel NOUN _005457217 328 14 the the DET _005457217 328 15 court court NOUN _005457217 328 16 said say VERB _005457217 328 17 : : PUNCT _005457217 328 18 " " PUNCT _005457217 328 19 p p NOUN _005457217 328 20 a a DET _005457217 328 21 r r NOUN _005457217 328 22 e e NOUN _005457217 328 23 n n ADP _005457217 328 24 t t PROPN _005457217 328 25 s s PART _005457217 328 26 placing place VERB _005457217 328 27 their their PRON _005457217 328 28 children child NOUN _005457217 328 29 in in ADP _005457217 328 30 colleges college NOUN _005457217 328 31 and and CCONJ _005457217 328 32 universities university NOUN _005457217 328 33 often often ADV _005457217 328 34 desire desire VERB _005457217 328 35 that that SCONJ _005457217 328 36 they they PRON _005457217 328 37 shall shall AUX _005457217 328 38 be be AUX _005457217 328 39 brought bring VERB _005457217 328 40 under under ADP _005457217 328 41 such such ADJ _005457217 328 42 influences influence NOUN _005457217 328 43 . . PUNCT _005457217 329 1 shall shall AUX _005457217 329 2 a a DET _005457217 329 3 court court NOUN _005457217 329 4 say say VERB _005457217 329 5 such such DET _005457217 329 6 a a DET _005457217 329 7 requirement requirement NOUN _005457217 329 8 is be AUX _005457217 329 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 329 10 in in ADP _005457217 329 11 and and CCONJ _005457217 329 12 of of ADP _005457217 329 13 itself itself PRON _005457217 329 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 329 15 a a DET _005457217 329 16 violation violation NOUN _005457217 329 17 of of ADP _005457217 329 18 said say VERB _005457217 329 19 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 329 20 provision provision NOUN _005457217 329 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 329 22 merely merely ADV _005457217 329 23 because because SCONJ _005457217 329 24 some some DET _005457217 329 25 one one NUM _005457217 329 26 or or CCONJ _005457217 329 27 more more ADJ _005457217 329 28 students student NOUN _005457217 329 29 attending attend VERB _005457217 329 30 the the DET _005457217 329 31 university university NOUN _005457217 329 32 may may AUX _005457217 329 33 object object VERB _005457217 329 34 to to ADP _005457217 329 35 obeying obey VERB _005457217 329 36 it it PRON _005457217 329 37 ? ? PUNCT _005457217 330 1 more more ADV _005457217 330 2 specially specially ADV _005457217 330 3 , , PUNCT _005457217 330 4 should should AUX _005457217 330 5 this this PRON _005457217 330 6 be be AUX _005457217 330 7 done do VERB _005457217 330 8 when when SCONJ _005457217 330 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 330 10 as as SCONJ _005457217 330 11 is be AUX _005457217 330 12 here here ADV _005457217 330 13 shown show VERB _005457217 330 14 by by ADP _005457217 330 15 the the DET _005457217 330 16 answer answer NOUN _005457217 330 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 330 18 the the DET _005457217 330 19 rules rule NOUN _005457217 330 20 expressly expressly ADV _005457217 330 21 provide provide VERB _005457217 330 22 that that PRON _005457217 330 23 f f PROPN _005457217 331 1 o o X _005457217 331 2 r r NOUN _005457217 331 3 good good NOUN _005457217 331 4 cause cause NOUN _005457217 331 5 students student NOUN _005457217 331 6 may may AUX _005457217 331 7 be be AUX _005457217 331 8 excused excuse VERB _005457217 331 9 f f X _005457217 331 10 r r NOUN _005457217 331 11 o o NOUN _005457217 331 12 m m NOUN _005457217 331 13 obedience obedience NOUN _005457217 331 14 to to ADP _005457217 331 15 such such ADJ _005457217 331 16 regulation regulation NOUN _005457217 331 17 ? ? PUNCT _005457217 332 1 we we PRON _005457217 332 2 have have AUX _005457217 332 3 said say VERB _005457217 332 4 in in ADP _005457217 332 5 construing construe VERB _005457217 332 6 this this DET _005457217 332 7 section section NOUN _005457217 332 8 of of ADP _005457217 332 9 the the DET _005457217 332 10 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 332 11 : : PUNCT _005457217 332 12 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 332 13 religion religion NOUN _005457217 332 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 332 15 religious religious ADJ _005457217 332 16 worship worship NOUN _005457217 332 17 are be AUX _005457217 332 18 not not PART _005457217 332 19 so so ADV _005457217 332 20 f f X _005457217 332 21 a a DET _005457217 332 22 r r NOUN _005457217 332 23 placed place VERB _005457217 332 24 under under ADP _005457217 332 25 the the DET _005457217 332 26 ban ban NOUN _005457217 332 27 of of ADP _005457217 332 28 the the DET _005457217 332 29 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 332 30 that that SCONJ _005457217 332 31 they they PRON _005457217 332 32 may may AUX _005457217 332 33 not not PART _005457217 332 34 be be AUX _005457217 332 35 allowed allow VERB _005457217 332 36 to to PART _005457217 332 37 become become VERB _005457217 332 38 the the DET _005457217 332 39 recipients recipient NOUN _005457217 332 40 of of ADP _005457217 332 41 any any DET _005457217 332 42 incidental incidental ADJ _005457217 332 43 benefit benefit NOUN _005457217 332 44 whatever whatever PRON _005457217 332 45 f f X _005457217 332 46 r r X _005457217 332 47 o o NOUN _005457217 332 48 m m VERB _005457217 332 49 the the DET _005457217 332 50 public public ADJ _005457217 332 51 bodies body NOUN _005457217 332 52 or or CCONJ _005457217 332 53 authorities authority NOUN _005457217 332 54 of of ADP _005457217 332 55 the the DET _005457217 332 56 state state NOUN _005457217 332 57 . . PUNCT _005457217 332 58 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 333 1 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 333 2 nichols nichols PROPN _005457217 333 3 v. v. PROPN _005457217 333 4 school school NOUN _005457217 333 5 directors director NOUN _005457217 333 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 333 7 93 93 NUM _005457217 333 8 111 111 NUM _005457217 333 9 . . NUM _005457217 333 10 6 6 NUM _005457217 333 11 4 4 NUM _005457217 333 12 . . PUNCT _005457217 333 13 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 334 1 " " PUNCT _005457217 335 1 i i PRON _005457217 335 2 n n VERB _005457217 335 3 order order NOUN _005457217 335 4 of of ADP _005457217 335 5 time time NOUN _005457217 335 6 we we PRON _005457217 335 7 now now ADV _005457217 335 8 come come VERB _005457217 335 9 to to ADP _005457217 335 10 people people NOUN _005457217 335 11 ex ex PROPN _005457217 335 12 rel rel PROPN _005457217 335 13 . . PUNCT _005457217 336 1 ring ring PROPN _005457217 336 2 v. v. PROPN _005457217 336 3 board board PROPN _005457217 336 4 of of ADP _005457217 336 5 education education NOUN _005457217 336 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 336 7 245 245 NUM _005457217 336 8 111 111 NUM _005457217 336 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 337 1 334 334 NUM _005457217 337 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 338 1 i i PRON _005457217 338 2 t t PROPN _005457217 338 3 is be AUX _005457217 338 4 generally generally ADV _005457217 338 5 conceded concede VERB _005457217 338 6 that that SCONJ _005457217 338 7 this this DET _005457217 338 8 case case NOUN _005457217 338 9 has have AUX _005457217 338 10 gone go VERB _005457217 338 11 f f PROPN _005457217 338 12 u u PROPN _005457217 338 13 r r NOUN _005457217 338 14 t t NOUN _005457217 338 15 h h NOUN _005457217 338 16 e e NOUN _005457217 338 17 r r NOUN _005457217 338 18 than than ADP _005457217 338 19 any any DET _005457217 338 20 other other ADJ _005457217 338 21 case case NOUN _005457217 338 22 in in ADP _005457217 338 23 the the DET _005457217 338 24 united united PROPN _005457217 338 25 states states PROPN _005457217 338 26 to to PART _005457217 338 27 ban ban VERB _005457217 338 28 the the DET _005457217 338 29 bible bible PROPN _005457217 338 30 from from ADP _005457217 338 31 the the DET _005457217 338 32 public public ADJ _005457217 338 33 schools school NOUN _005457217 338 34 . . PUNCT _005457217 339 1 therefore therefore ADV _005457217 339 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 339 3 the the DET _005457217 339 4 facts fact NOUN _005457217 339 5 and and CCONJ _005457217 339 6 the the DET _005457217 339 7 exact exact ADJ _005457217 339 8 question question NOUN _005457217 339 9 decided decide VERB _005457217 339 10 in in ADP _005457217 339 11 that that DET _005457217 339 12 case case NOUN _005457217 339 13 become become VERB _005457217 339 14 important important ADJ _005457217 339 15 . . PUNCT _005457217 340 1 the the DET _005457217 340 2 case case NOUN _005457217 340 3 arose arise VERB _005457217 340 4 on on ADP _005457217 340 5 demurrer demurrer NOUN _005457217 340 6 to to ADP _005457217 340 7 a a DET _005457217 340 8 petition petition NOUN _005457217 340 9 for for ADP _005457217 340 10 mandamus mandamus NOUN _005457217 340 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 340 12 where where SCONJ _005457217 340 13 the the DET _005457217 340 14 allegations allegation NOUN _005457217 340 15 of of ADP _005457217 340 16 the the DET _005457217 340 17 petition petition NOUN _005457217 340 18 were be AUX _005457217 340 19 taken take VERB _005457217 340 20 as as ADP _005457217 340 21 true true ADJ _005457217 340 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 340 23 and and CCONJ _005457217 340 24 where where SCONJ _005457217 340 25 no no DET _005457217 340 26 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 340 27 was be AUX _005457217 340 28 heard hear VERB _005457217 340 29 in in ADP _005457217 340 30 the the DET _005457217 340 31 trial trial NOUN _005457217 340 32 court court NOUN _005457217 340 33 . . PUNCT _005457217 341 1 the the DET _005457217 341 2 petition petition NOUN _005457217 341 3 averred aver VERB _005457217 341 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 341 5 the the DET _005457217 341 6 relators relator NOUN _005457217 341 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 341 8 as as ADP _005457217 341 9 vashti vashti NOUN _005457217 341 10 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 341 11 here here ADV _005457217 341 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 341 13 were be AUX _005457217 341 14 residents resident NOUN _005457217 341 15 and and CCONJ _005457217 341 16 tax tax NOUN _005457217 341 17 payers payer NOUN _005457217 341 18 of of ADP _005457217 341 19 the the DET _005457217 341 20 school school NOUN _005457217 341 21 district district NOUN _005457217 341 22 . . PUNCT _005457217 342 1 the the DET _005457217 342 2 relators relator NOUN _005457217 342 3 in in ADP _005457217 342 4 that that DET _005457217 342 5 case case NOUN _005457217 342 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 342 7 however however ADV _005457217 342 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 342 9 were be AUX _005457217 342 10 members member NOUN _005457217 342 11 of of ADP _005457217 342 12 the the DET _005457217 342 13 roman roman ADJ _005457217 342 14 catholic catholic PROPN _005457217 342 15 church church NOUN _005457217 342 16 . . PUNCT _005457217 343 1 quite quite DET _005457217 343 2 a a DET _005457217 343 3 number number NOUN _005457217 343 4 of of ADP _005457217 343 5 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 343 6 families family NOUN _005457217 343 7 were be AUX _005457217 343 8 involved involve VERB _005457217 343 9 in in ADP _005457217 343 10 the the DET _005457217 343 11 suit suit NOUN _005457217 343 12 . . PUNCT _005457217 344 1 the the DET _005457217 344 2 peti28 peti28 NOUN _005457217 344 3 tion tion NOUN _005457217 344 4 averred aver VERB _005457217 344 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 344 6 the the DET _005457217 344 7 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 344 8 employed employ VERB _005457217 344 9 by by ADP _005457217 344 10 the the DET _005457217 344 11 schools school NOUN _005457217 344 12 read read VERB _005457217 344 13 to to ADP _005457217 344 14 the the DET _005457217 344 15 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 344 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 344 17 including include VERB _005457217 344 18 the the DET _005457217 344 19 children child NOUN _005457217 344 20 of of ADP _005457217 344 21 the the DET _005457217 344 22 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 344 23 relators relator NOUN _005457217 344 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 344 25 during during ADP _005457217 344 26 school school NOUN _005457217 344 27 hours hour NOUN _005457217 344 28 , , PUNCT _005457217 344 29 portions portion NOUN _005457217 344 30 of of ADP _005457217 344 31 the the DET _005457217 344 32 king king NOUN _005457217 344 33 james james PROPN _005457217 344 34 version version PROPN _005457217 344 35 of of ADP _005457217 344 36 the the DET _005457217 344 37 bible bible NOUN _005457217 344 38 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 344 39 that that SCONJ _005457217 344 40 sacred sacred ADJ _005457217 344 41 hymns hymn NOUN _005457217 344 42 were be AUX _005457217 344 43 sung sing VERB _005457217 344 44 in in ADP _005457217 344 45 concert concert NOUN _005457217 344 46 by by ADP _005457217 344 47 the the DET _005457217 344 48 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 344 49 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 344 50 that that SCONJ _005457217 344 51 the the DET _005457217 344 52 lord lord PROPN _005457217 344 53 's 's PART _005457217 344 54 p p NOUN _005457217 344 55 r r NOUN _005457217 344 56 a a DET _005457217 344 57 y y PROPN _005457217 344 58 e e NOUN _005457217 344 59 r r NOUN _005457217 344 60 was be AUX _005457217 344 61 recited recite VERB _005457217 344 62 in in ADP _005457217 344 63 concert concert NOUN _005457217 344 64 by by ADP _005457217 344 65 the the DET _005457217 344 66 students student NOUN _005457217 344 67 in in ADP _005457217 344 68 those those DET _005457217 344 69 school school NOUN _005457217 344 70 rooms room NOUN _005457217 344 71 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 344 72 that that SCONJ _005457217 344 73 the the DET _005457217 344 74 children child NOUN _005457217 344 75 of of ADP _005457217 344 76 the the DET _005457217 344 77 relators relator NOUN _005457217 344 78 were be AUX _005457217 344 79 required require VERB _005457217 344 80 to to PART _005457217 344 81 rise rise VERB _005457217 344 82 in in ADP _005457217 344 83 their their PRON _005457217 344 84 seats seat NOUN _005457217 344 85 , , PUNCT _005457217 344 86 fold fold VERB _005457217 344 87 their their PRON _005457217 344 88 hands hand NOUN _005457217 344 89 and and CCONJ _005457217 344 90 bow bow VERB _005457217 344 91 their their PRON _005457217 344 92 heads head NOUN _005457217 344 93 while while SCONJ _005457217 344 94 the the DET _005457217 344 95 bible bible NOUN _005457217 344 96 was be AUX _005457217 344 97 read read VERB _005457217 344 98 and and CCONJ _005457217 344 99 the the DET _005457217 344 100 l l NOUN _005457217 344 101 o o NOUN _005457217 344 102 r r NOUN _005457217 344 103 d d PROPN _005457217 344 104 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 344 105 s s NOUN _005457217 344 106 p p NOUN _005457217 344 107 r r NOUN _005457217 344 108 a a DET _005457217 344 109 y y PROPN _005457217 344 110 e e NOUN _005457217 344 111 r r NOUN _005457217 344 112 was be AUX _005457217 344 113 recited recite VERB _005457217 344 114 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 344 115 that that SCONJ _005457217 344 116 under under ADP _005457217 344 117 the the DET _005457217 344 118 teachings teaching NOUN _005457217 344 119 of of ADP _005457217 344 120 the the DET _005457217 344 121 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 344 122 church church NOUN _005457217 344 123 the the DET _005457217 344 124 l l PROPN _005457217 344 125 o o NOUN _005457217 344 126 r r NOUN _005457217 344 127 d d PROPN _005457217 344 128 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 344 129 s s NOUN _005457217 344 130 p p NOUN _005457217 344 131 r r NOUN _005457217 344 132 a a DET _005457217 344 133 y y PROPN _005457217 344 134 e e NOUN _005457217 344 135 r r NOUN _005457217 344 136 recited recite VERB _005457217 344 137 in in ADP _005457217 344 138 school school NOUN _005457217 344 139 was be AUX _005457217 344 140 different different ADJ _005457217 344 141 from from ADP _005457217 344 142 that that DET _005457217 344 143 taught teach VERB _005457217 344 144 as as ADP _005457217 344 145 the the DET _005457217 344 146 lord lord PROPN _005457217 344 147 's 's PART _005457217 344 148 p p NOUN _005457217 344 149 r r NOUN _005457217 344 150 a a DET _005457217 344 151 y y PROPN _005457217 344 152 e e NOUN _005457217 344 153 r r NOUN _005457217 344 154 in in ADP _005457217 344 155 the the DET _005457217 344 156 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 344 157 church church NOUN _005457217 344 158 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 344 159 that that SCONJ _005457217 344 160 the the DET _005457217 344 161 king king NOUN _005457217 344 162 james jam VERB _005457217 344 163 version version PROPN _005457217 344 164 of of ADP _005457217 344 165 the the DET _005457217 344 166 bible bible PROPN _005457217 344 167 was be AUX _005457217 344 168 unacceptable unacceptable ADJ _005457217 344 169 to to ADP _005457217 344 170 the the DET _005457217 344 171 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 344 172 relators relator NOUN _005457217 344 173 and and CCONJ _005457217 344 174 their their PRON _005457217 344 175 children child NOUN _005457217 344 176 . . PUNCT _005457217 345 1 i i PRON _005457217 345 2 t t PROPN _005457217 345 3 was be AUX _005457217 345 4 averred aver VERB _005457217 345 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 345 6 by by ADP _005457217 345 7 reason reason NOUN _005457217 345 8 of of ADP _005457217 345 9 these these DET _005457217 345 10 things thing NOUN _005457217 345 11 the the DET _005457217 345 12 relators relator NOUN _005457217 345 13 ' ' PART _005457217 345 14 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 345 15 rights right NOUN _005457217 345 16 under under ADP _005457217 345 17 the the DET _005457217 345 18 state state NOUN _005457217 345 19 and and CCONJ _005457217 345 20 national national ADJ _005457217 345 21 constitutions constitution NOUN _005457217 345 22 were be AUX _005457217 345 23 violated violate VERB _005457217 345 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 345 25 and and CCONJ _005457217 345 26 prayed pray VERB _005457217 345 27 mandamus mandamus NOUN _005457217 345 28 to to PART _005457217 345 29 stop stop VERB _005457217 345 30 the the DET _005457217 345 31 religious religious ADJ _005457217 345 32 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 345 33 . . PUNCT _005457217 346 1 the the DET _005457217 346 2 trial trial NOUN _005457217 346 3 court court NOUN _005457217 346 4 sustained sustain VERB _005457217 346 5 the the DET _005457217 346 6 demurrer demurrer NOUN _005457217 346 7 to to ADP _005457217 346 8 the the DET _005457217 346 9 petition petition NOUN _005457217 346 10 . . PUNCT _005457217 347 1 on on ADP _005457217 347 2 writ writ PROPN _005457217 347 3 of of ADP _005457217 347 4 error error NOUN _005457217 347 5 the the DET _005457217 347 6 ruling ruling NOUN _005457217 347 7 of of ADP _005457217 347 8 the the DET _005457217 347 9 trial trial NOUN _005457217 347 10 court court NOUN _005457217 347 11 was be AUX _005457217 347 12 reversed reverse VERB _005457217 347 13 by by ADP _005457217 347 14 a a DET _005457217 347 15 divided divide VERB _005457217 347 16 supreme supreme ADJ _005457217 347 17 court court NOUN _005457217 347 18 . . PUNCT _005457217 348 1 mr mr PROPN _005457217 348 2 . . PROPN _005457217 348 3 justice justice PROPN _005457217 348 4 dunn dunn PROPN _005457217 348 5 wrote write VERB _005457217 348 6 the the DET _005457217 348 7 majority majority NOUN _005457217 348 8 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 348 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 349 1 there there PRON _005457217 349 2 was be VERB _005457217 349 3 a a DET _005457217 349 4 vigorous vigorous ADJ _005457217 349 5 dissent dissent NOUN _005457217 349 6 by by ADP _005457217 349 7 justices justice NOUN _005457217 349 8 hand hand VERB _005457217 349 9 and and CCONJ _005457217 349 10 cartwright cartwright ADV _005457217 349 11 . . PUNCT _005457217 350 1 i i PRON _005457217 350 2 n n VERB _005457217 350 3 the the DET _005457217 350 4 majority majority NOUN _005457217 350 5 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 350 6 it it PRON _005457217 350 7 was be AUX _005457217 350 8 held hold VERB _005457217 350 9 that that SCONJ _005457217 350 10 the the DET _005457217 350 11 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 350 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 350 13 including include VERB _005457217 350 14 the the DET _005457217 350 15 reading reading NOUN _005457217 350 16 of of ADP _005457217 350 17 the the DET _005457217 350 18 bible bible NOUN _005457217 350 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 350 20 the the DET _005457217 350 21 singing singing NOUN _005457217 350 22 of of ADP _005457217 350 23 the the DET _005457217 350 24 hymns hymn NOUN _005457217 350 25 , , PUNCT _005457217 350 26 and and CCONJ _005457217 350 27 the the DET _005457217 350 28 recital recital NOUN _005457217 350 29 of of ADP _005457217 350 30 the the DET _005457217 350 31 lord lord PROPN _005457217 350 32 's 's PART _005457217 350 33 p p NOUN _005457217 350 34 r r NOUN _005457217 350 35 a a DET _005457217 350 36 y y PROPN _005457217 350 37 e e NOUN _005457217 350 38 r r NOUN _005457217 350 39 constituted constitute VERB _005457217 350 40 acts act NOUN _005457217 350 41 of of ADP _005457217 350 42 worship worship NOUN _005457217 350 43 , , PUNCT _005457217 350 44 that that SCONJ _005457217 350 45 they they PRON _005457217 350 46 violated violate VERB _005457217 350 47 that that SCONJ _005457217 350 48 p p NOUN _005457217 350 49 a a DET _005457217 350 50 r r NOUN _005457217 350 51 t t NOUN _005457217 350 52 of of ADP _005457217 350 53 article article PROPN _005457217 350 54 ii ii PROPN _005457217 350 55 , , PUNCT _005457217 350 56 section section NOUN _005457217 350 57 3 3 NUM _005457217 350 58 , , PUNCT _005457217 350 59 of of ADP _005457217 350 60 the the DET _005457217 350 61 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 350 62 of of ADP _005457217 350 63 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 350 64 providing providing NOUN _005457217 350 65 : : PUNCT _005457217 350 66 " " PUNCT _005457217 350 67 t t NOUN _005457217 350 68 h h NOUN _005457217 350 69 e e X _005457217 350 70 free free ADJ _005457217 350 71 exercise exercise NOUN _005457217 350 72 and and CCONJ _005457217 350 73 enjoyment enjoyment NOUN _005457217 350 74 of of ADP _005457217 350 75 religious religious ADJ _005457217 350 76 profession profession NOUN _005457217 350 77 and and CCONJ _005457217 350 78 worship worship NOUN _005457217 350 79 , , PUNCT _005457217 350 80 without without ADP _005457217 350 81 discrimination discrimination NOUN _005457217 350 82 , , PUNCT _005457217 350 83 shall shall AUX _005457217 350 84 forever forever ADV _005457217 350 85 be be AUX _005457217 350 86 guaranteed guarantee VERB _005457217 350 87 . . PUNCT _005457217 350 88 . . PUNCT _005457217 350 89 . . PUNCT _005457217 350 90 . . PUNCT _005457217 351 1 no no DET _005457217 351 2 person person NOUN _005457217 351 3 shall shall AUX _005457217 351 4 be be AUX _005457217 351 5 required require VERB _005457217 351 6 to to PART _005457217 351 7 attend attend VERB _005457217 351 8 or or CCONJ _005457217 351 9 support support VERB _005457217 351 10 any any DET _005457217 351 11 ministry ministry NOUN _005457217 351 12 or or CCONJ _005457217 351 13 place place NOUN _005457217 351 14 of of ADP _005457217 351 15 worship worship NOUN _005457217 351 16 against against ADP _005457217 351 17 his his PRON _005457217 351 18 consent consent NOUN _005457217 351 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 351 20 nor nor CCONJ _005457217 351 21 shall shall AUX _005457217 351 22 any any DET _005457217 351 23 preference preference NOUN _005457217 351 24 be be AUX _005457217 351 25 given give VERB _005457217 351 26 by by ADP _005457217 351 27 law law NOUN _005457217 351 28 to to ADP _005457217 351 29 any any DET _005457217 351 30 religious religious ADJ _005457217 351 31 denomination denomination NOUN _005457217 351 32 or or CCONJ _005457217 351 33 mode mode NOUN _005457217 351 34 of of ADP _005457217 351 35 worship worship NOUN _005457217 351 36 . . PUNCT _005457217 351 37 '' '' PUNCT _005457217 352 1 29 29 NUM _005457217 352 2 a a DET _005457217 352 3 f f NOUN _005457217 352 4 t t NOUN _005457217 352 5 e e NOUN _005457217 352 6 r r NOUN _005457217 352 7 deciding decide VERB _005457217 352 8 this this PRON _005457217 352 9 the the DET _005457217 352 10 court court NOUN _005457217 352 11 went go VERB _005457217 352 12 f f PROPN _005457217 352 13 u u PROPN _005457217 352 14 r r NOUN _005457217 352 15 t t NOUN _005457217 352 16 h h NOUN _005457217 352 17 e e NOUN _005457217 352 18 r r NOUN _005457217 352 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 352 20 and and CCONJ _005457217 352 21 said say VERB _005457217 352 22 that that SCONJ _005457217 352 23 these these DET _005457217 352 24 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 352 25 not not PART _005457217 352 26 only only ADV _005457217 352 27 constituted constitute VERB _005457217 352 28 a a DET _005457217 352 29 violation violation NOUN _005457217 352 30 of of ADP _005457217 352 31 the the DET _005457217 352 32 guarantee guarantee NOUN _005457217 352 33 of of ADP _005457217 352 34 freedom freedom NOUN _005457217 352 35 of of ADP _005457217 352 36 worship worship NOUN _005457217 352 37 but but CCONJ _005457217 352 38 the the DET _005457217 352 39 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 352 40 also also ADV _005457217 352 41 violated violate VERB _005457217 352 42 the the DET _005457217 352 43 provision provision NOUN _005457217 352 44 of of ADP _005457217 352 45 the the DET _005457217 352 46 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 352 47 which which PRON _005457217 352 48 prohibits prohibit VERB _005457217 352 49 the the DET _005457217 352 50 payment payment NOUN _005457217 352 51 from from ADP _005457217 352 52 any any DET _005457217 352 53 public public ADJ _005457217 352 54 f f PROPN _005457217 352 55 u u PROPN _005457217 352 56 n n CCONJ _005457217 352 57 d d PROPN _005457217 352 58 of of ADP _005457217 352 59 anything anything PRON _005457217 352 60 in in ADP _005457217 352 61 aid aid NOUN _005457217 352 62 of of ADP _005457217 352 63 any any DET _005457217 352 64 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 352 65 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 352 66 . . PUNCT _005457217 353 1 at at ADP _005457217 353 2 page page NOUN _005457217 353 3 340 340 NUM _005457217 353 4 the the DET _005457217 353 5 court court NOUN _005457217 353 6 said say VERB _005457217 353 7 : : PUNCT _005457217 353 8 " " PUNCT _005457217 353 9 t t NOUN _005457217 353 10 h h NOUN _005457217 353 11 e e PROPN _005457217 353 12 public public ADJ _005457217 353 13 schools school NOUN _005457217 353 14 are be AUX _005457217 353 15 supported support VERB _005457217 353 16 by by ADP _005457217 353 17 taxation taxation NOUN _005457217 353 18 , , PUNCT _005457217 353 19 and and CCONJ _005457217 353 20 if if SCONJ _005457217 353 21 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 353 22 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 353 23 should should AUX _005457217 353 24 be be AUX _005457217 353 25 permitted permit VERB _005457217 353 26 in in ADP _005457217 353 27 them they PRON _005457217 353 28 , , PUNCT _005457217 353 29 the the DET _005457217 353 30 money money NOUN _005457217 353 31 used use VERB _005457217 353 32 in in ADP _005457217 353 33 their their PRON _005457217 353 34 support support NOUN _005457217 353 35 would would AUX _005457217 353 36 be be AUX _005457217 353 37 used use VERB _005457217 353 38 in in ADP _005457217 353 39 aid aid NOUN _005457217 353 40 of of ADP _005457217 353 41 a a DET _005457217 353 42 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 353 43 purpose purpose NOUN _005457217 353 44 . . PUNCT _005457217 354 1 the the DET _005457217 354 2 prohibition prohibition NOUN _005457217 354 3 of of ADP _005457217 354 4 such such ADJ _005457217 354 5 use use NOUN _005457217 354 6 of of ADP _005457217 354 7 public public ADJ _005457217 354 8 funds fund NOUN _005457217 354 9 is be AUX _005457217 354 10 therefore therefore ADV _005457217 354 11 a a DET _005457217 354 12 prohibition prohibition NOUN _005457217 354 13 of of ADP _005457217 354 14 the the DET _005457217 354 15 giving giving NOUN _005457217 354 16 of of ADP _005457217 354 17 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 354 18 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 354 19 in in ADP _005457217 354 20 the the DET _005457217 354 21 public public ADJ _005457217 354 22 schools school NOUN _005457217 354 23 . . PUNCT _005457217 354 24 " " PUNCT _005457217 355 1 the the DET _005457217 355 2 court court NOUN _005457217 355 3 then then ADV _005457217 355 4 held hold VERB _005457217 355 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 355 6 the the DET _005457217 355 7 reading reading NOUN _005457217 355 8 of of ADP _005457217 355 9 the the DET _005457217 355 10 bible bible PROPN _005457217 355 11 in in ADP _005457217 355 12 the the DET _005457217 355 13 schools school NOUN _005457217 355 14 was be AUX _005457217 355 15 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 355 16 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 355 17 because because SCONJ _005457217 355 18 the the DET _005457217 355 19 catholics catholic NOUN _005457217 355 20 and and CCONJ _005457217 355 21 protestants protestant NOUN _005457217 355 22 use use VERB _005457217 355 23 different different ADJ _005457217 355 24 versions version NOUN _005457217 355 25 of of ADP _005457217 355 26 the the DET _005457217 355 27 bible bible NOUN _005457217 355 28 , , PUNCT _005457217 355 29 because because SCONJ _005457217 355 30 different different ADJ _005457217 355 31 sects sect NOUN _005457217 355 32 of of ADP _005457217 355 33 the the DET _005457217 355 34 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 355 35 churches church NOUN _005457217 355 36 , , PUNCT _005457217 355 37 and and CCONJ _005457217 355 38 of of ADP _005457217 355 39 the the DET _005457217 355 40 catholics catholic NOUN _005457217 355 41 and and CCONJ _005457217 355 42 jews jews PROPN _005457217 355 43 place place VERB _005457217 355 44 different different ADJ _005457217 355 45 interpretations interpretation NOUN _005457217 355 46 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 355 47 the the DET _005457217 355 48 same same ADJ _005457217 355 49 scripture scripture NOUN _005457217 355 50 . . PUNCT _005457217 356 1 finally finally ADV _005457217 356 2 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 356 3 p. p. NOUN _005457217 356 4 351 351 NUM _005457217 356 5 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 356 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 356 7 in in ADP _005457217 356 8 discussing discuss VERB _005457217 356 9 whether whether SCONJ _005457217 356 10 such such ADJ _005457217 356 11 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 356 12 violated violate VERB _005457217 356 13 the the DET _005457217 356 14 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 356 15 prohibition prohibition NOUN _005457217 356 16 of of ADP _005457217 356 17 payment payment NOUN _005457217 356 18 from from ADP _005457217 356 19 public public ADJ _005457217 356 20 funds fund NOUN _005457217 356 21 in in ADP _005457217 356 22 aid aid NOUN _005457217 356 23 of of ADP _005457217 356 24 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 356 25 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 356 26 the the DET _005457217 356 27 majority majority NOUN _005457217 356 28 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 356 29 , , PUNCT _005457217 356 30 in in ADP _005457217 356 31 discussing discuss VERB _005457217 356 32 the the DET _005457217 356 33 kentucky kentucky PROPN _005457217 356 34 and and CCONJ _005457217 356 35 kansas kansas PROPN _005457217 356 36 decisions decision NOUN _005457217 356 37 which which PRON _005457217 356 38 upheld uphold VERB _005457217 356 39 such such ADJ _005457217 356 40 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 356 41 , , PUNCT _005457217 356 42 used use VERB _005457217 356 43 the the DET _005457217 356 44 following follow VERB _005457217 356 45 language language NOUN _005457217 356 46 which which DET _005457217 356 47 relator relator NOUN _005457217 356 48 particularly particularly ADV _005457217 356 49 relies rely VERB _005457217 356 50 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 356 51 in in ADP _005457217 356 52 the the DET _005457217 356 53 case case NOUN _005457217 356 54 at at ADP _005457217 356 55 b b X _005457217 356 56 a a DET _005457217 356 57 r r NOUN _005457217 356 58 : : PUNCT _005457217 356 59 " " PUNCT _005457217 356 60 t t NOUN _005457217 356 61 h h NOUN _005457217 356 62 e e PROPN _005457217 356 63 kentucky kentucky PROPN _005457217 356 64 and and CCONJ _005457217 356 65 kansas kansas PROPN _005457217 356 66 decisions decision NOUN _005457217 356 67 seem seem VERB _005457217 356 68 to to PART _005457217 356 69 consider consider VERB _005457217 356 70 the the DET _005457217 356 71 fact fact NOUN _005457217 356 72 that that SCONJ _005457217 356 73 the the DET _005457217 356 74 children child NOUN _005457217 356 75 of of ADP _005457217 356 76 the the DET _005457217 356 77 complainants complainant NOUN _005457217 356 78 were be AUX _005457217 356 79 not not PART _005457217 356 80 compelled compel VERB _005457217 356 81 to to PART _005457217 356 82 join join VERB _005457217 356 83 in in ADP _005457217 356 84 the the DET _005457217 356 85 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 356 86 as as ADP _005457217 356 87 affecting affect VERB _005457217 356 88 the the DET _005457217 356 89 question question NOUN _005457217 356 90 in in ADP _005457217 356 91 some some DET _005457217 356 92 way way NOUN _005457217 356 93 . . PUNCT _005457217 357 1 that that DET _005457217 357 2 suggestion suggestion NOUN _005457217 357 3 seems seem VERB _005457217 357 4 to to ADP _005457217 357 5 us we PRON _005457217 357 6 to to PART _005457217 357 7 concede concede VERB _005457217 357 8 the the DET _005457217 357 9 position position NOUN _005457217 357 10 of of ADP _005457217 357 11 the the DET _005457217 357 12 plaintiffs plaintiff NOUN _005457217 357 13 in in ADP _005457217 357 14 error error NOUN _005457217 357 15 . . PUNCT _005457217 358 1 the the DET _005457217 358 2 exclusion exclusion NOUN _005457217 358 3 of of ADP _005457217 358 4 a a DET _005457217 358 5 pupil pupil NOUN _005457217 358 6 f f X _005457217 358 7 r r NOUN _005457217 358 8 o o NOUN _005457217 358 9 m m VERB _005457217 358 10 this this PRON _005457217 358 11 p p NOUN _005457217 358 12 a a DET _005457217 358 13 r r NOUN _005457217 358 14 t t NOUN _005457217 358 15 of of ADP _005457217 358 16 the the DET _005457217 358 17 school school NOUN _005457217 358 18 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 358 19 in in ADP _005457217 358 20 which which PRON _005457217 358 21 the the DET _005457217 358 22 rest rest NOUN _005457217 358 23 of of ADP _005457217 358 24 the the DET _005457217 358 25 school school NOUN _005457217 358 26 joins join NOUN _005457217 358 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 358 28 separates separate VERB _005457217 358 29 him he PRON _005457217 358 30 from from ADP _005457217 358 31 his his PRON _005457217 358 32 fellows fellow NOUN _005457217 358 33 , , PUNCT _005457217 358 34 puts put VERB _005457217 358 35 him he PRON _005457217 358 36 in in ADP _005457217 358 37 a a DET _005457217 358 38 class class NOUN _005457217 358 39 by by ADP _005457217 358 40 himself himself PRON _005457217 358 41 , , PUNCT _005457217 358 42 deprives deprive VERB _005457217 358 43 him he PRON _005457217 358 44 of of ADP _005457217 358 45 his his PRON _005457217 358 46 equality equality NOUN _005457217 358 47 with with ADP _005457217 358 48 the the DET _005457217 358 49 other other ADJ _005457217 358 50 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 358 51 , , PUNCT _005457217 358 52 subjects subject VERB _005457217 358 53 him he PRON _005457217 358 54 to to ADP _005457217 358 55 areligious areligious ADJ _005457217 358 56 stigma stigma NOUN _005457217 358 57 and and CCONJ _005457217 358 58 places place VERB _005457217 358 59 him he PRON _005457217 358 60 at at ADP _005457217 358 61 a a DET _005457217 358 62 disadvantage disadvantage NOUN _005457217 358 63 in in ADP _005457217 358 64 the the DET _005457217 358 65 school school NOUN _005457217 358 66 , , PUNCT _005457217 358 67 30 30 NUM _005457217 358 68 which which PRON _005457217 358 69 the the DET _005457217 358 70 law law NOUN _005457217 358 71 never never ADV _005457217 358 72 contemplated contemplate VERB _005457217 358 73 . . PUNCT _005457217 359 1 all all DET _005457217 359 2 this this PRON _005457217 359 3 is be AUX _005457217 359 4 because because SCONJ _005457217 359 5 of of ADP _005457217 359 6 his his PRON _005457217 359 7 religious religious ADJ _005457217 359 8 belief belief NOUN _005457217 359 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 360 1 if if SCONJ _005457217 360 2 the the DET _005457217 360 3 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 360 4 or or CCONJ _005457217 360 5 exercise exercise NOUN _005457217 360 6 is be AUX _005457217 360 7 such such ADJ _005457217 360 8 that that SCONJ _005457217 360 9 certain certain ADJ _005457217 360 10 of of ADP _005457217 360 11 the the DET _005457217 360 12 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 360 13 must must AUX _005457217 360 14 be be AUX _005457217 360 15 excused excuse VERB _005457217 360 16 from from ADP _005457217 360 17 it it PRON _005457217 360 18 because because SCONJ _005457217 360 19 it it PRON _005457217 360 20 is be AUX _005457217 360 21 hostile hostile ADJ _005457217 360 22 to to ADP _005457217 360 23 their their PRON _005457217 360 24 or or CCONJ _005457217 360 25 their their PRON _005457217 360 26 p p NOUN _005457217 360 27 a a DET _005457217 360 28 r r NOUN _005457217 360 29 e e NOUN _005457217 360 30 n n ADP _005457217 360 31 t t PROPN _005457217 360 32 s s PART _005457217 360 33 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 360 34 religious religious ADJ _005457217 360 35 belief belief NOUN _005457217 360 36 , , PUNCT _005457217 360 37 then then ADV _005457217 360 38 such such ADJ _005457217 360 39 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 360 40 or or CCONJ _005457217 360 41 exercise exercise NOUN _005457217 360 42 is be AUX _005457217 360 43 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 360 44 and and CCONJ _005457217 360 45 forbidden forbid VERB _005457217 360 46 by by ADP _005457217 360 47 the the DET _005457217 360 48 constitut constitut PROPN _005457217 361 1 i i PRON _005457217 361 2 o o PROPN _005457217 361 3 n n PROPN _005457217 361 4 . . PUNCT _005457217 362 1 " " PUNCT _005457217 362 2 the the DET _005457217 362 3 above above ADJ _005457217 362 4 language language NOUN _005457217 362 5 was be AUX _005457217 362 6 not not PART _005457217 362 7 necessary necessary ADJ _005457217 362 8 to to ADP _005457217 362 9 the the DET _005457217 362 10 decision decision NOUN _005457217 362 11 of of ADP _005457217 362 12 that that DET _005457217 362 13 case case NOUN _005457217 362 14 . . PUNCT _005457217 363 1 the the DET _005457217 363 2 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 363 3 children child NOUN _005457217 363 4 under under ADP _005457217 363 5 the the DET _005457217 363 6 allegations allegation NOUN _005457217 363 7 of of ADP _005457217 363 8 the the DET _005457217 363 9 petition petition NOUN _005457217 363 10 which which PRON _005457217 363 11 were be AUX _005457217 363 12 admitted admit VERB _005457217 363 13 by by ADP _005457217 363 14 the the DET _005457217 363 15 demurrer demurrer NOUN _005457217 363 16 were be AUX _005457217 363 17 required require VERB _005457217 363 18 to to PART _005457217 363 19 attend attend VERB _005457217 363 20 the the DET _005457217 363 21 school school NOUN _005457217 363 22 and and CCONJ _005457217 363 23 to to PART _005457217 363 24 stand stand VERB _005457217 363 25 with with ADP _005457217 363 26 bowed bow VERB _005457217 363 27 heads head NOUN _005457217 363 28 while while SCONJ _005457217 363 29 the the DET _005457217 363 30 l l NOUN _005457217 363 31 o o NOUN _005457217 363 32 r r NOUN _005457217 363 33 d d PROPN _005457217 363 34 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 363 35 s s NOUN _005457217 363 36 p p NOUN _005457217 363 37 r r NOUN _005457217 363 38 a a DET _005457217 363 39 y y PROPN _005457217 363 40 e e NOUN _005457217 363 41 r r NOUN _005457217 363 42 was be AUX _005457217 363 43 recited recite VERB _005457217 363 44 and and CCONJ _005457217 363 45 the the DET _005457217 363 46 king king NOUN _005457217 363 47 james james PROPN _005457217 363 48 version version PROPN _005457217 363 49 of of ADP _005457217 363 50 the the DET _005457217 363 51 scriptures scripture NOUN _005457217 363 52 was be AUX _005457217 363 53 read read VERB _005457217 363 54 . . PUNCT _005457217 364 1 moreover moreover ADV _005457217 364 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 364 3 it it PRON _005457217 364 4 may may AUX _005457217 364 5 be be AUX _005457217 364 6 said say VERB _005457217 364 7 in in ADP _005457217 364 8 the the DET _005457217 364 9 case case NOUN _005457217 364 10 at at ADP _005457217 364 11 bar bar NOUN _005457217 364 12 that that PRON _005457217 364 13 the the DET _005457217 364 14 conclusion conclusion NOUN _005457217 364 15 reached reach VERB _005457217 364 16 by by ADP _005457217 364 17 the the DET _005457217 364 18 majority majority NOUN _005457217 364 19 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 364 20 that that SCONJ _005457217 364 21 the the DET _005457217 364 22 exclusion exclusion NOUN _005457217 364 23 of of ADP _005457217 364 24 a a DET _005457217 364 25 pupil pupil NOUN _005457217 364 26 f f X _005457217 364 27 r r NOUN _005457217 364 28 o o NOUN _005457217 364 29 m m VERB _005457217 364 30 religious religious ADJ _005457217 364 31 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 364 32 in in ADP _005457217 364 33 which which PRON _005457217 364 34 the the DET _005457217 364 35 rest rest NOUN _005457217 364 36 of of ADP _005457217 364 37 the the DET _005457217 364 38 school school NOUN _005457217 364 39 attends attend NOUN _005457217 364 40 , , PUNCT _005457217 364 41 subjects subject VERB _005457217 364 42 him he PRON _005457217 364 43 to to ADP _005457217 364 44 religious religious ADJ _005457217 364 45 stigma stigma NOUN _005457217 364 46 , , PUNCT _005457217 364 47 and and CCONJ _005457217 364 48 so so ADV _005457217 364 49 forth forth ADV _005457217 364 50 , , PUNCT _005457217 364 51 is be AUX _005457217 364 52 a a DET _005457217 364 53 matter matter NOUN _005457217 364 54 that that PRON _005457217 364 55 is be AUX _005457217 364 56 covered cover VERB _005457217 364 57 by by ADP _005457217 364 58 the the DET _005457217 364 59 actual actual ADJ _005457217 364 60 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 364 61 in in ADP _005457217 364 62 the the DET _005457217 364 63 case case NOUN _005457217 364 64 at at ADP _005457217 364 65 bar bar NOUN _005457217 364 66 . . PUNCT _005457217 365 1 as as SCONJ _005457217 365 2 we we PRON _005457217 365 3 have have AUX _005457217 365 4 found find VERB _005457217 365 5 above above ADV _005457217 365 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 365 7 and and CCONJ _005457217 365 8 as as ADP _005457217 365 9 a a DET _005457217 365 10 reading reading NOUN _005457217 365 11 of of ADP _005457217 365 12 the the DET _005457217 365 13 record record NOUN _005457217 365 14 in in ADP _005457217 365 15 this this DET _005457217 365 16 case case NOUN _005457217 365 17 convinces convince VERB _005457217 365 18 us we PRON _005457217 365 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 365 20 james james PROPN _005457217 365 21 terry terry PROPN _005457217 365 22 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 365 23 was be AUX _005457217 365 24 not not PART _005457217 365 25 subject subject ADJ _005457217 365 26 to to ADP _005457217 365 27 religious religious ADJ _005457217 365 28 stigma stigma NOUN _005457217 365 29 and and CCONJ _005457217 365 30 placed place VERB _005457217 365 31 at at ADP _005457217 365 32 a a DET _005457217 365 33 disadvantage disadvantage NOUN _005457217 365 34 in in ADP _005457217 365 35 the the DET _005457217 365 36 school school NOUN _005457217 365 37 because because SCONJ _005457217 365 38 of of ADP _005457217 365 39 his his PRON _005457217 365 40 non non ADJ _005457217 365 41 religious religious ADJ _005457217 365 42 beliefs belief NOUN _005457217 365 43 . . PUNCT _005457217 366 1 justice justice PROPN _005457217 366 2 cartwright cartwright PROPN _005457217 366 3 , , PUNCT _005457217 366 4 who who PRON _005457217 366 5 joined join VERB _005457217 366 6 in in ADP _005457217 366 7 the the DET _005457217 366 8 dissenting dissent VERB _005457217 366 9 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 366 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 366 11 is be AUX _005457217 366 12 recognized recognize VERB _005457217 366 13 as as ADP _005457217 366 14 one one NUM _005457217 366 15 of of ADP _005457217 366 16 the the DET _005457217 366 17 ablest able ADJ _005457217 366 18 judges judge NOUN _005457217 366 19 who who PRON _005457217 366 20 ever ever ADV _005457217 366 21 sat sit VERB _005457217 366 22 in in ADP _005457217 366 23 the the DET _005457217 366 24 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 366 25 court court PROPN _005457217 366 26 of of ADP _005457217 366 27 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 366 28 . . PUNCT _005457217 367 1 he he PRON _005457217 367 2 with with ADP _005457217 367 3 justice justice PROPN _005457217 367 4 hand hand NOUN _005457217 367 5 called call VERB _005457217 367 6 attention attention NOUN _005457217 367 7 to to ADP _005457217 367 8 the the DET _005457217 367 9 fact fact NOUN _005457217 367 10 in in ADP _005457217 367 11 the the DET _005457217 367 12 dissenting dissent VERB _005457217 367 13 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 367 14 that that SCONJ _005457217 367 15 the the DET _005457217 367 16 great great ADJ _005457217 367 17 weight weight NOUN _005457217 367 18 of of ADP _005457217 367 19 authority authority NOUN _005457217 367 20 everywhere everywhere ADV _005457217 367 21 was be AUX _005457217 367 22 cont cont NOUN _005457217 367 23 r r NOUN _005457217 367 24 a a DET _005457217 367 25 r r NOUN _005457217 367 26 y y NOUN _005457217 367 27 to to ADP _005457217 367 28 this this DET _005457217 367 29 case case NOUN _005457217 367 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 367 31 that that SCONJ _005457217 367 32 the the DET _005457217 367 33 decision decision NOUN _005457217 367 34 itself itself PRON _005457217 367 35 in in ADP _005457217 367 36 spirit spirit NOUN _005457217 367 37 was be AUX _005457217 367 38 entirely entirely ADV _005457217 367 39 opposed opposed ADJ _005457217 367 40 to to ADP _005457217 367 41 the the DET _005457217 367 42 other other ADJ _005457217 367 43 cases case NOUN _005457217 367 44 in in ADP _005457217 367 45 the the DET _005457217 367 46 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 367 47 court court PROPN _005457217 367 48 of of ADP _005457217 367 49 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 367 50 which which PRON _005457217 367 51 we we PRON _005457217 367 52 have have AUX _005457217 367 53 referred refer VERB _005457217 367 54 to to ADP _005457217 367 55 above above ADV _005457217 367 56 , , PUNCT _005457217 367 57 before before ADP _005457217 367 58 that that DET _005457217 367 59 time time NOUN _005457217 367 60 . . PUNCT _005457217 368 1 before before ADP _005457217 368 2 discussing discuss VERB _005457217 368 3 the the DET _005457217 368 4 ring ring NOUN _005457217 368 5 case case NOUN _005457217 368 6 f f X _005457217 368 7 u u PROPN _005457217 368 8 r r NOUN _005457217 368 9 t t NOUN _005457217 368 10 h h NOUN _005457217 368 11 e e NOUN _005457217 368 12 r r NOUN _005457217 368 13 we we PRON _005457217 368 14 take take VERB _005457217 368 15 up up ADP _005457217 368 16 the the DET _005457217 368 17 cases case NOUN _005457217 368 18 that that PRON _005457217 368 19 have have AUX _005457217 368 20 arisen arise VERB _005457217 368 21 in in ADP _005457217 368 22 the the DET _005457217 368 23 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 368 24 court court PROPN _005457217 368 25 since since SCONJ _005457217 368 26 the the DET _005457217 368 27 ring ring NOUN _005457217 368 28 case case NOUN _005457217 368 29 , , PUNCT _005457217 368 30 dealing deal VERB _005457217 368 31 with with ADP _005457217 368 32 the the DET _005457217 368 33 same same ADJ _005457217 368 34 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 368 35 31 31 NUM _005457217 368 36 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 368 37 . . PUNCT _005457217 369 1 j j DET _005457217 369 2 u u PROPN _005457217 369 3 s s PART _005457217 369 4 t t NOUN _005457217 369 5 three three NUM _005457217 369 6 years year NOUN _005457217 369 7 later later ADV _005457217 369 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 369 9 in in ADP _005457217 369 10 the the DET _005457217 369 11 case case NOUN _005457217 369 12 of of ADP _005457217 369 13 reichwald reichwald PROPN _005457217 369 14 v. v. PROPN _005457217 369 15 catholic catholic PROPN _005457217 369 16 bishop bishop PROPN _005457217 369 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 369 18 258 258 NUM _005457217 369 19 111 111 NUM _005457217 369 20 . . NUM _005457217 369 21 44 44 NUM _005457217 369 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 369 23 a a DET _005457217 369 24 tax tax NOUN _005457217 369 25 payer payer NOUN _005457217 369 26 in in ADP _005457217 369 27 cook cook PROPN _005457217 369 28 county county PROPN _005457217 369 29 filed file VERB _005457217 369 30 a a DET _005457217 369 31 hill hill NOUN _005457217 369 32 in in ADP _005457217 369 33 equity equity NOUN _005457217 369 34 to to PART _005457217 369 35 restrain restrain VERB _005457217 369 36 the the DET _005457217 369 37 board board NOUN _005457217 369 38 of of ADP _005457217 369 39 commissioners commissioner NOUN _005457217 369 40 of of ADP _005457217 369 41 cook cook PROPN _005457217 369 42 county county PROPN _005457217 369 43 f f X _005457217 369 44 r r NOUN _005457217 369 45 o o NOUN _005457217 369 46 m m AUX _005457217 369 47 permitting permit VERB _005457217 369 48 the the DET _005457217 369 49 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 369 50 bishop bishop NOUN _005457217 369 51 and and CCONJ _005457217 369 52 archbishop archbishop NOUN _005457217 369 53 to to PART _005457217 369 54 erect erect VERB _005457217 369 55 a a DET _005457217 369 56 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 369 57 chapel chapel NOUN _005457217 369 58 to to PART _005457217 369 59 be be AUX _005457217 369 60 used use VERB _005457217 369 61 for for ADP _005457217 369 62 religious religious ADJ _005457217 369 63 worship worship NOUN _005457217 369 64 and and CCONJ _005457217 369 65 funeral funeral NOUN _005457217 369 66 services service NOUN _005457217 369 67 on on ADP _005457217 369 68 the the DET _005457217 369 69 cook cook PROPN _005457217 369 70 county county PROPN _005457217 369 71 poor poor ADJ _005457217 369 72 f f PROPN _005457217 369 73 a a DET _005457217 369 74 r r NOUN _005457217 369 75 m m X _005457217 369 76 which which PRON _005457217 369 77 was be AUX _005457217 369 78 owned own VERB _005457217 369 79 by by ADP _005457217 369 80 the the DET _005457217 369 81 county county NOUN _005457217 369 82 . . PUNCT _005457217 370 1 the the DET _005457217 370 2 bill bill NOUN _005457217 370 3 showed show VERB _005457217 370 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 370 5 the the DET _005457217 370 6 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 370 7 bishop bishop PROPN _005457217 370 8 had have AUX _005457217 370 9 offered offer VERB _005457217 370 10 to to PART _005457217 370 11 erect erect VERB _005457217 370 12 this this DET _005457217 370 13 chapel chapel NOUN _005457217 370 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 370 15 to to PART _005457217 370 16 maintain maintain VERB _005457217 370 17 it it PRON _005457217 370 18 at at ADP _005457217 370 19 his his PRON _005457217 370 20 own own ADJ _005457217 370 21 expense expense NOUN _005457217 370 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 370 23 to to PART _005457217 370 24 provide provide VERB _005457217 370 25 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 370 26 services service NOUN _005457217 370 27 and and CCONJ _005457217 370 28 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 370 29 burial burial NOUN _005457217 371 1 f f PROPN _005457217 371 2 o o X _005457217 371 3 r r NOUN _005457217 371 4 those those PRON _005457217 371 5 of of ADP _005457217 371 6 the the DET _005457217 371 7 poor poor ADJ _005457217 371 8 who who PRON _005457217 371 9 used use VERB _005457217 371 10 the the DET _005457217 371 11 poor poor ADJ _005457217 371 12 farm farm NOUN _005457217 371 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 371 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 371 15 the the DET _005457217 371 16 title title NOUN _005457217 371 17 to to ADP _005457217 371 18 the the DET _005457217 371 19 buildings building NOUN _005457217 371 20 was be AUX _005457217 371 21 to to PART _005457217 371 22 be be AUX _005457217 371 23 in in ADP _005457217 371 24 cook cook PROPN _005457217 371 25 county county PROPN _005457217 371 26 . . PUNCT _005457217 372 1 i i PRON _005457217 372 2 t t NOUN _005457217 372 3 is be AUX _005457217 372 4 interesting interesting ADJ _005457217 372 5 to to PART _005457217 372 6 note note VERB _005457217 372 7 that that SCONJ _005457217 372 8 mr mr PROPN _005457217 372 9 . . PROPN _005457217 372 10 justice justice PROPN _005457217 372 11 dunn dunn PROPN _005457217 372 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 372 13 who who PRON _005457217 372 14 wrote write VERB _005457217 372 15 the the DET _005457217 372 16 majority majority NOUN _005457217 372 17 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 372 18 in in ADP _005457217 372 19 the the DET _005457217 372 20 ring ring NOUN _005457217 372 21 case case NOUN _005457217 372 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 372 23 wrote write VERB _005457217 372 24 the the DET _005457217 372 25 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 372 26 in in ADP _005457217 372 27 this this DET _005457217 372 28 case case NOUN _005457217 372 29 . . PUNCT _005457217 373 1 i i PRON _005457217 373 2 t t PROPN _005457217 373 3 was be AUX _005457217 373 4 held hold VERB _005457217 373 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 373 6 the the DET _005457217 373 7 county county NOUN _005457217 373 8 had have VERB _005457217 373 9 full full ADJ _005457217 373 10 power power NOUN _005457217 373 11 to to PART _005457217 373 12 permit permit VERB _005457217 373 13 the the DET _005457217 373 14 use use NOUN _005457217 373 15 of of ADP _005457217 373 16 the the DET _005457217 373 17 building building NOUN _005457217 373 18 f f X _005457217 374 1 o o X _005457217 374 2 r r NOUN _005457217 374 3 religious religious ADJ _005457217 374 4 worship worship NOUN _005457217 374 5 and and CCONJ _005457217 374 6 funeral funeral NOUN _005457217 374 7 services service NOUN _005457217 374 8 on on ADP _005457217 374 9 property property NOUN _005457217 374 10 of of ADP _005457217 374 11 the the DET _005457217 374 12 county county NOUN _005457217 374 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 374 14 as as ADV _005457217 374 15 long long ADV _005457217 374 16 as as SCONJ _005457217 374 17 cook cook PROPN _005457217 374 18 county county NOUN _005457217 374 19 was be AUX _005457217 374 20 not not PART _005457217 374 21 obligated obligate VERB _005457217 374 22 financially financially ADV _005457217 374 23 to to PART _005457217 374 24 pay pay VERB _005457217 374 25 toward toward ADP _005457217 374 26 such such ADJ _005457217 374 27 religious religious ADJ _005457217 374 28 worship worship NOUN _005457217 374 29 or or CCONJ _005457217 374 30 services service NOUN _005457217 374 31 . . PUNCT _005457217 375 1 at at ADP _005457217 375 2 page page NOUN _005457217 375 3 48 48 NUM _005457217 375 4 of of ADP _005457217 375 5 the the DET _005457217 375 6 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 375 7 is be AUX _005457217 375 8 the the DET _005457217 375 9 following follow VERB _005457217 375 10 language language NOUN _005457217 375 11 which which PRON _005457217 375 12 we we PRON _005457217 375 13 feel feel VERB _005457217 375 14 is be AUX _005457217 375 15 applicable applicable ADJ _005457217 375 16 to to ADP _005457217 375 17 the the DET _005457217 375 18 champaign champaign ADJ _005457217 375 19 plan plan NOUN _005457217 375 20 of of ADP _005457217 375 21 religious religious ADJ _005457217 375 22 education education NOUN _005457217 375 23 : : PUNCT _005457217 375 24 " " PUNCT _005457217 375 25 n n ADV _005457217 375 26 o o NOUN _005457217 375 27 one one NOUN _005457217 375 28 can can AUX _005457217 375 29 be be AUX _005457217 375 30 obliged oblige VERB _005457217 375 31 to to PART _005457217 375 32 attend attend VERB _005457217 375 33 or or CCONJ _005457217 375 34 to to PART _005457217 375 35 contribute contribute VERB _005457217 375 36 , , PUNCT _005457217 375 37 but but CCONJ _005457217 375 38 no no DET _005457217 375 39 one one NOUN _005457217 375 40 has have VERB _005457217 375 41 a a DET _005457217 375 42 right right NOUN _005457217 375 43 to to PART _005457217 375 44 insist insist VERB _005457217 375 45 that that SCONJ _005457217 375 46 the the DET _005457217 375 47 services service NOUN _005457217 375 48 shall shall AUX _005457217 375 49 not not PART _005457217 375 50 be be AUX _005457217 375 51 held hold VERB _005457217 375 52 . . PUNCT _005457217 376 1 the the DET _005457217 376 2 man man NOUN _005457217 376 3 of of ADP _005457217 376 4 no no DET _005457217 376 5 religion religion NOUN _005457217 376 6 has have VERB _005457217 376 7 a a DET _005457217 376 8 right right NOUN _005457217 376 9 to to PART _005457217 376 10 act act VERB _005457217 376 11 in in ADP _005457217 376 12 accordance accordance NOUN _005457217 376 13 with with ADP _005457217 376 14 his his PRON _005457217 376 15 lack lack NOUN _005457217 376 16 of of ADP _005457217 376 17 religion religion NOUN _005457217 376 18 but but CCONJ _005457217 376 19 no no DET _005457217 376 20 right right NOUN _005457217 376 21 to to PART _005457217 376 22 insist insist VERB _005457217 376 23 that that SCONJ _005457217 376 24 others other NOUN _005457217 376 25 shall shall AUX _005457217 376 26 have have VERB _005457217 376 27 no no DET _005457217 376 28 religion religion NOUN _005457217 376 29 . . PUNCT _005457217 376 30 '' '' PUNCT _005457217 377 1 then then ADV _005457217 377 2 the the DET _005457217 377 3 case case NOUN _005457217 377 4 of of ADP _005457217 377 5 nichols nichols PROPN _005457217 377 6 v. v. ADP _005457217 377 7 ischool ischool PROPN _005457217 377 8 directors director NOUN _005457217 377 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 377 10 93 93 NUM _005457217 377 11 111 111 NUM _005457217 377 12 . . NUM _005457217 377 13 61 61 NUM _005457217 377 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 377 15 is be AUX _005457217 377 16 again again ADV _005457217 377 17 quoted quote VERB _005457217 377 18 with with ADP _005457217 377 19 approval approval NOUN _005457217 377 20 , , PUNCT _005457217 377 21 as as ADP _005457217 377 22 justifying justify VERB _005457217 377 23 the the DET _005457217 377 24 decision decision NOUN _005457217 377 25 in in ADP _005457217 377 26 the the DET _005457217 377 27 reichwald reichwald PROPN _005457217 377 28 case case NOUN _005457217 377 29 . . PUNCT _005457217 378 1 i i PRON _005457217 378 2 n n CCONJ _005457217 378 3 dunn dunn PROPN _005457217 378 4 v. v. ADP _005457217 378 5 the the DET _005457217 378 6 chicago chicago PROPN _005457217 378 7 industrial industrial PROPN _005457217 378 8 school school PROPN _005457217 378 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 378 10 280 280 NUM _005457217 378 11 111 111 NUM _005457217 378 12 . . NUM _005457217 378 13 613 613 NUM _005457217 378 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 378 15 a a DET _005457217 378 16 tax tax NOUN _005457217 378 17 payer payer NOUN _005457217 378 18 in in ADP _005457217 378 19 cook cook PROPN _005457217 378 20 county county PROPN _005457217 378 21 filed file VERB _005457217 378 22 a a DET _005457217 378 23 bill bill NOUN _005457217 378 24 to to PART _005457217 378 25 enjoin enjoin VERB _005457217 378 26 the the DET _005457217 378 27 payment payment NOUN _005457217 378 28 of of ADP _005457217 378 29 county county NOUN _005457217 378 30 funds fund NOUN _005457217 378 31 to to ADP _005457217 378 32 the the DET _005457217 378 33 chicago chicago PROPN _005457217 378 34 industrial industrial ADJ _005457217 378 35 32 32 NUM _005457217 378 36 school school NOUN _005457217 378 37 for for ADP _005457217 378 38 girls girl NOUN _005457217 378 39 , , PUNCT _005457217 378 40 f f PROPN _005457217 378 41 o o X _005457217 379 1 r r VERB _005457217 379 2 the the DET _005457217 379 3 care care NOUN _005457217 379 4 of of ADP _005457217 379 5 delinquent delinquent ADJ _005457217 379 6 girls girl NOUN _005457217 379 7 sent send VERB _005457217 379 8 there there ADV _005457217 379 9 by by ADP _005457217 379 10 the the DET _005457217 379 11 juvenile juvenile ADJ _005457217 379 12 court court NOUN _005457217 379 13 of of ADP _005457217 379 14 cook cook PROPN _005457217 379 15 county county PROPN _005457217 379 16 . . PUNCT _005457217 380 1 this this DET _005457217 380 2 school school NOUN _005457217 380 3 was be AUX _005457217 380 4 maintained maintain VERB _005457217 380 5 by by ADP _005457217 380 6 the the DET _005457217 380 7 roman roman ADJ _005457217 380 8 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 380 9 church church NOUN _005457217 380 10 . . PUNCT _005457217 381 1 at at ADP _005457217 381 2 this this DET _005457217 381 3 school school NOUN _005457217 381 4 religious religious ADJ _005457217 381 5 training training NOUN _005457217 381 6 was be AUX _005457217 381 7 given give VERB _005457217 381 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 381 9 and and CCONJ _005457217 381 10 religious religious ADJ _005457217 381 11 services service NOUN _005457217 381 12 were be AUX _005457217 381 13 held hold VERB _005457217 381 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 381 15 for for ADP _005457217 381 16 those those DET _005457217 381 17 girls girl NOUN _005457217 381 18 who who PRON _005457217 381 19 were be AUX _005457217 381 20 there there ADV _005457217 381 21 committed committed ADJ _005457217 381 22 . . PUNCT _005457217 382 1 if if SCONJ _005457217 382 2 a a DET _005457217 382 3 narrow narrow ADJ _005457217 382 4 view view NOUN _005457217 382 5 were be AUX _005457217 382 6 taken take VERB _005457217 382 7 of of ADP _005457217 382 8 the the DET _005457217 382 9 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 382 10 prohibition prohibition NOUN _005457217 382 11 it it PRON _005457217 382 12 would would AUX _005457217 382 13 seem seem VERB _005457217 382 14 that that SCONJ _005457217 382 15 these these DET _005457217 382 16 acts act NOUN _005457217 382 17 were be AUX _005457217 382 18 certainly certainly ADV _005457217 382 19 in in ADP _005457217 382 20 violation violation NOUN _005457217 382 21 of of ADP _005457217 382 22 article article NOUN _005457217 382 23 viii viii NOUN _005457217 382 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 382 25 section section NOUN _005457217 382 26 3 3 NUM _005457217 382 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 382 28 of of ADP _005457217 382 29 the the DET _005457217 382 30 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 382 31 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 382 32 , , PUNCT _005457217 382 33 prohibiting prohibit VERB _005457217 382 34 the the DET _005457217 382 35 appropriation appropriation NOUN _005457217 382 36 of of ADP _005457217 382 37 money money NOUN _005457217 382 38 in in ADP _005457217 382 39 aid aid NOUN _005457217 382 40 of of ADP _005457217 382 41 a a DET _005457217 382 42 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 382 43 purpose purpose NOUN _005457217 382 44 , , PUNCT _005457217 382 45 but but CCONJ _005457217 382 46 justice justice NOUN _005457217 382 47 cartwright cartwright ADV _005457217 382 48 in in ADP _005457217 382 49 delivering deliver VERB _005457217 382 50 the the DET _005457217 382 51 unanimous unanimous ADJ _005457217 382 52 decision decision NOUN _005457217 382 53 of of ADP _005457217 382 54 the the DET _005457217 382 55 court court NOUN _005457217 382 56 held hold VERB _005457217 382 57 that that SCONJ _005457217 382 58 where where SCONJ _005457217 382 59 the the DET _005457217 382 60 expense expense NOUN _005457217 382 61 of of ADP _005457217 382 62 maintaining maintain VERB _005457217 382 63 the the DET _005457217 382 64 wards ward NOUN _005457217 382 65 of of ADP _005457217 382 66 the the DET _005457217 382 67 state state NOUN _005457217 382 68 who who PRON _005457217 382 69 espoused espouse VERB _005457217 382 70 the the DET _005457217 382 71 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 382 72 belief belief NOUN _005457217 382 73 , , PUNCT _005457217 382 74 in in ADP _005457217 382 75 this this DET _005457217 382 76 industrial industrial ADJ _005457217 382 77 school school NOUN _005457217 382 78 , , PUNCT _005457217 382 79 was be AUX _005457217 382 80 less less ADJ _005457217 382 81 than than ADP _005457217 382 82 the the DET _005457217 382 83 cost cost NOUN _005457217 382 84 of of ADP _005457217 382 85 maintaining maintain VERB _005457217 382 86 juvenile juvenile ADJ _005457217 382 87 delinquents delinquent NOUN _005457217 382 88 at at ADP _005457217 382 89 the the DET _005457217 382 90 state state NOUN _005457217 382 91 institutions institution NOUN _005457217 382 92 , , PUNCT _005457217 382 93 there there PRON _005457217 382 94 was be VERB _005457217 382 95 no no DET _005457217 382 96 appropriation appropriation NOUN _005457217 382 97 of of ADP _005457217 382 98 money money NOUN _005457217 382 99 in in ADP _005457217 382 100 aid aid NOUN _005457217 382 101 of of ADP _005457217 382 102 sectarian sectarian ADJ _005457217 382 103 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 382 104 . . PUNCT _005457217 383 1 i i PRON _005457217 383 2 n n ADP _005457217 383 3 construing construe VERB _005457217 383 4 the the DET _005457217 383 5 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 383 6 of of ADP _005457217 383 7 the the DET _005457217 383 8 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 383 9 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 383 10 involved involve VERB _005457217 383 11 in in ADP _005457217 383 12 this this DET _005457217 383 13 case case NOUN _005457217 383 14 he he PRON _005457217 383 15 said say VERB _005457217 383 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 383 17 at at ADP _005457217 383 18 page page NOUN _005457217 383 19 616 616 NUM _005457217 383 20 : : PUNCT _005457217 383 21 " " PUNCT _005457217 383 22 t t NOUN _005457217 383 23 h h NOUN _005457217 383 24 e e NOUN _005457217 383 25 people people NOUN _005457217 383 26 not not PART _005457217 383 27 only only ADV _005457217 383 28 did do AUX _005457217 383 29 not not PART _005457217 383 30 declare declare VERB _005457217 383 31 hostility hostility NOUN _005457217 383 32 to to ADP _005457217 383 33 religion religion NOUN _005457217 383 34 but but CCONJ _005457217 383 35 regarded regard VERB _005457217 383 36 its its PRON _005457217 383 37 teachings teaching NOUN _005457217 383 38 and and CCONJ _005457217 383 39 practices practice NOUN _005457217 383 40 as as ADP _005457217 383 41 a a DET _005457217 383 42 public public ADJ _005457217 383 43 benefit benefit NOUN _005457217 383 44 which which PRON _005457217 383 45 might might AUX _005457217 383 46 be be AUX _005457217 383 47 equal equal ADJ _005457217 383 48 to to ADP _005457217 383 49 the the DET _005457217 383 50 payment payment NOUN _005457217 383 51 of of ADP _005457217 383 52 taxes taxis NOUN _005457217 383 53 , , PUNCT _005457217 383 54 and and CCONJ _005457217 383 55 by by ADP _005457217 383 56 section section NOUN _005457217 383 57 3 3 NUM _005457217 383 58 of of ADP _005457217 383 59 article article NOUN _005457217 383 60 9 9 NUM _005457217 383 61 of of ADP _005457217 383 62 the the DET _005457217 383 63 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 383 64 provided provide VERB _005457217 383 65 that that DET _005457217 383 66 property property NOUN _005457217 383 67 used use VERB _005457217 383 68 exclusively exclusively ADV _005457217 384 1 f f PROPN _005457217 384 2 o o NOUN _005457217 385 1 r r NOUN _005457217 385 2 religious religious ADJ _005457217 385 3 purposes purpose NOUN _005457217 385 4 may may AUX _005457217 385 5 be be AUX _005457217 385 6 exempted exempt VERB _005457217 385 7 from from ADP _005457217 385 8 the the DET _005457217 385 9 burden burden NOUN _005457217 385 10 of of ADP _005457217 385 11 taxation taxation NOUN _005457217 385 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 385 13 and and CCONJ _005457217 385 14 the the DET _005457217 385 15 g g PROPN _005457217 385 16 - - PUNCT _005457217 385 17 eneral eneral ADJ _005457217 385 18 assembly assembly NOUN _005457217 385 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 385 20 by by ADP _005457217 385 21 virtue virtue NOUN _005457217 385 22 of of ADP _005457217 385 23 that that DET _005457217 385 24 provision provision NOUN _005457217 385 25 , , PUNCT _005457217 385 26 has have AUX _005457217 385 27 declared declare VERB _005457217 385 28 such such ADJ _005457217 385 29 exemption exemption NOUN _005457217 385 30 . . PUNCT _005457217 386 1 in in ADP _005457217 386 2 harmony harmony NOUN _005457217 386 3 with with ADP _005457217 386 4 the the DET _005457217 386 5 provision provision NOUN _005457217 387 1 f f PROPN _005457217 387 2 o o X _005457217 387 3 r r NOUN _005457217 387 4 the the DET _005457217 387 5 f f X _005457217 387 6 r r NOUN _005457217 387 7 e e NOUN _005457217 387 8 e e NOUN _005457217 387 9 exercise exercise NOUN _005457217 387 10 and and CCONJ _005457217 387 11 enjoyment enjoyment NOUN _005457217 387 12 of of ADP _005457217 387 13 religious religious ADJ _005457217 387 14 freedom freedom NOUN _005457217 387 15 and and CCONJ _005457217 387 16 worship worship NOUN _005457217 387 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 387 18 the the DET _005457217 387 19 general general ADJ _005457217 387 20 assembly assembly NOUN _005457217 387 21 in in ADP _005457217 387 22 the the DET _005457217 387 23 juvenile juvenile PROPN _005457217 387 24 court court PROPN _005457217 387 25 act act NOUN _005457217 387 26 provided provide VERB _005457217 387 27 by by ADP _005457217 387 28 section section NOUN _005457217 387 29 17 17 NUM _005457217 387 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 387 31 that that SCONJ _005457217 387 32 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 387 33 the the DET _005457217 387 34 court court NOUN _005457217 387 35 in in ADP _005457217 387 36 committing commit VERB _005457217 387 37 children child NOUN _005457217 387 38 shall shall AUX _005457217 387 39 place place VERB _005457217 387 40 them they PRON _005457217 387 41 as as ADP _005457217 387 42 f f PROPN _005457217 387 43 a a DET _005457217 387 44 r r NOUN _005457217 387 45 as as ADV _005457217 387 46 practicable practicable ADJ _005457217 387 47 in in ADP _005457217 387 48 the the DET _005457217 387 49 care care NOUN _005457217 387 50 and and CCONJ _005457217 387 51 custody custody NOUN _005457217 387 52 of of ADP _005457217 387 53 some some DET _005457217 387 54 individual individual NOUN _005457217 387 55 holding hold VERB _005457217 387 56 the the DET _005457217 387 57 same same ADJ _005457217 387 58 religious religious ADJ _005457217 387 59 belief belief NOUN _005457217 387 60 as as ADP _005457217 387 61 the the DET _005457217 387 62 parents parent NOUN _005457217 387 63 of of ADP _005457217 387 64 said said ADJ _005457217 387 65 child child NOUN _005457217 387 66 , , PUNCT _005457217 387 67 or or CCONJ _005457217 387 68 with with ADP _005457217 387 69 some some DET _005457217 387 70 association association NOUN _005457217 387 71 which which PRON _005457217 387 72 is be AUX _005457217 387 73 controlled control VERB _005457217 387 74 by by ADP _005457217 387 75 persons person NOUN _005457217 387 76 of of ADP _005457217 387 77 like like INTJ _005457217 387 78 religious religious ADJ _005457217 387 79 faith faith NOUN _005457217 387 80 of of ADP _005457217 387 81 the the DET _005457217 387 82 parents parent NOUN _005457217 387 83 of of ADP _005457217 387 84 said said ADJ _005457217 387 85 child child NOUN _005457217 387 86 . . PUNCT _005457217 387 87 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 388 1 " " PUNCT _005457217 388 2 n n ADV _005457217 388 3 o o PROPN _005457217 388 4 t t PROPN _005457217 388 5 only only ADV _005457217 388 6 have have VERB _005457217 388 7 the the DET _005457217 388 8 people people NOUN _005457217 388 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 388 10 by by ADP _005457217 388 11 the the DET _005457217 388 12 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 388 13 and and CCONJ _005457217 388 14 by by ADP _005457217 388 15 their their PRON _005457217 388 16 representatives representative NOUN _005457217 388 17 in in ADP _005457217 388 18 the the DET _005457217 388 19 general general ADJ _005457217 388 20 assembly assembly NOUN _005457217 388 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 388 22 recognized recognize VERB _005457217 388 23 and and CCONJ _005457217 388 24 provided provide VERB _005457217 388 25 f f PROPN _005457217 389 1 o o X _005457217 389 2 r r NOUN _005457217 389 3 the the DET _005457217 389 4 enjoyment enjoyment NOUN _005457217 389 5 33 33 NUM _005457217 389 6 of of ADP _005457217 389 7 religious religious ADJ _005457217 389 8 liberty liberty NOUN _005457217 389 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 389 10 but but CCONJ _005457217 389 11 the the DET _005457217 389 12 court court NOUN _005457217 389 13 has have AUX _005457217 389 14 not not PART _005457217 389 15 adopted adopt VERB _005457217 389 16 any any DET _005457217 389 17 rule rule NOUN _005457217 389 18 antagonistic antagonistic ADJ _005457217 389 19 thereto thereto NOUN _005457217 389 20 . . PUNCT _005457217 390 1 i i PRON _005457217 390 2 n n VERB _005457217 390 3 nichols nichols PROPN _005457217 390 4 v. v. ADP _005457217 390 5 school school NOUN _005457217 390 6 directorsy directorsy NOUN _005457217 390 7 93 93 NUM _005457217 390 8 111 111 NUM _005457217 390 9 . . NUM _005457217 390 10 61 61 NUM _005457217 390 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 390 12 the the DET _005457217 390 13 court court NOUN _005457217 390 14 said say VERB _005457217 390 15 : : PUNCT _005457217 390 16 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 390 17 religion religion NOUN _005457217 390 18 and and CCONJ _005457217 390 19 religious religious ADJ _005457217 390 20 worship worship NOUN _005457217 390 21 are be AUX _005457217 390 22 not not PART _005457217 390 23 so so ADV _005457217 390 24 placed place VERB _005457217 390 25 under under ADP _005457217 390 26 the the DET _005457217 390 27 ban ban NOUN _005457217 390 28 of of ADP _005457217 390 29 the the DET _005457217 390 30 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 390 31 that that SCONJ _005457217 390 32 they they PRON _005457217 390 33 may may AUX _005457217 390 34 not not PART _005457217 390 35 be be AUX _005457217 390 36 allowed allow VERB _005457217 390 37 to to PART _005457217 390 38 become become VERB _005457217 390 39 the the DET _005457217 390 40 recipients recipient NOUN _005457217 390 41 of of ADP _005457217 390 42 any any DET _005457217 390 43 incidental incidental ADJ _005457217 390 44 benefit benefit NOUN _005457217 390 45 whatsoever whatsoever ADV _005457217 390 46 from from ADP _005457217 390 47 the the DET _005457217 390 48 public public ADJ _005457217 390 49 bodies body NOUN _005457217 390 50 or or CCONJ _005457217 390 51 authorities authority NOUN _005457217 390 52 of of ADP _005457217 390 53 the the DET _005457217 390 54 state state NOUN _005457217 390 55 . . PUNCT _005457217 390 56 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 391 1 " " PUNCT _005457217 391 2 i i PRON _005457217 391 3 n n VERB _005457217 391 4 the the DET _005457217 391 5 later later ADJ _005457217 391 6 case case NOUN _005457217 391 7 of of ADP _005457217 391 8 st st PROPN _005457217 391 9 . . PROPN _005457217 391 10 hedwig hedwig PROPN _005457217 391 11 's 's PART _005457217 391 12 industrial industrial ADJ _005457217 391 13 school school NOUN _005457217 391 14 for for ADP _005457217 391 15 girls girl NOUN _005457217 391 16 v. v. ADP _005457217 391 17 cook cook PROPN _005457217 391 18 county county PROPN _005457217 391 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 391 20 289 289 NUM _005457217 391 21 111 111 NUM _005457217 391 22 . . PUNCT _005457217 392 1 432 432 NUM _005457217 393 1 , , PUNCT _005457217 393 2 a a DET _005457217 393 3 very very ADV _005457217 393 4 similar similar ADJ _005457217 393 5 case case NOUN _005457217 393 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 393 7 st st PROPN _005457217 393 8 . . PROPN _005457217 393 9 hedwig hedwig PROPN _005457217 393 10 's 's PART _005457217 393 11 and and CCONJ _005457217 393 12 the the DET _005457217 393 13 polish polish ADJ _005457217 393 14 manual manual ADJ _005457217 393 15 training training NOUN _005457217 393 16 school school NOUN _005457217 393 17 f f PROPN _005457217 393 18 o o X _005457217 393 19 r r NOUN _005457217 393 20 boys boy NOUN _005457217 393 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 393 22 which which PRON _005457217 393 23 were be AUX _005457217 393 24 run run VERB _005457217 393 25 and and CCONJ _005457217 393 26 maintained maintain VERB _005457217 393 27 by by ADP _005457217 393 28 religious religious ADJ _005457217 393 29 organizations organization NOUN _005457217 393 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 393 31 sued sue VERB _005457217 393 32 cook cook PROPN _005457217 393 33 county county PROPN _005457217 393 34 for for ADP _005457217 393 35 unpaid unpaid ADJ _005457217 393 36 tuition tuition NOUN _005457217 393 37 and and CCONJ _005457217 393 38 care care NOUN _005457217 393 39 of of ADP _005457217 393 40 dependent dependent ADJ _005457217 393 41 children child NOUN _005457217 393 42 committed commit VERB _005457217 393 43 to to ADP _005457217 393 44 these these DET _005457217 393 45 schools school NOUN _005457217 393 46 by by ADP _005457217 393 47 the the DET _005457217 393 48 juvenile juvenile ADJ _005457217 393 49 court court NOUN _005457217 393 50 of of ADP _005457217 393 51 chicago chicago PROPN _005457217 393 52 . . PUNCT _005457217 394 1 the the DET _005457217 394 2 court court NOUN _005457217 394 3 unanimously unanimously ADV _005457217 394 4 held hold VERB _005457217 394 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 394 6 these these DET _005457217 394 7 payments payment NOUN _005457217 394 8 were be AUX _005457217 394 9 not not PART _005457217 394 10 in in ADP _005457217 394 11 violation violation NOUN _005457217 394 12 of of ADP _005457217 394 13 section section NOUN _005457217 394 14 3 3 NUM _005457217 394 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 394 16 article article NOUN _005457217 395 1 v v INTJ _005457217 395 2 i i PRON _005457217 396 1 i i PRON _005457217 396 2 i i PRON _005457217 396 3 of of ADP _005457217 396 4 the the DET _005457217 396 5 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 396 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 396 7 citing cite VERB _005457217 396 8 the the DET _005457217 396 9 dunn dunn PROPN _005457217 396 10 case case NOUN _005457217 396 11 in in ADP _005457217 396 12 280 280 NUM _005457217 396 13 illinois illinois NOUN _005457217 396 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 396 15 as as ADV _005457217 396 16 well well ADV _005457217 396 17 as as ADP _005457217 396 18 other other ADJ _005457217 396 19 cases case NOUN _005457217 396 20 . . PUNCT _005457217 397 1 we we PRON _005457217 397 2 now now ADV _005457217 397 3 come come VERB _005457217 397 4 back back ADV _005457217 397 5 to to ADP _005457217 397 6 the the DET _005457217 397 7 ring ring NOUN _005457217 397 8 case case NOUN _005457217 397 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 398 1 were be AUX _005457217 398 2 the the DET _005457217 398 3 ring ring NOUN _005457217 398 4 case case NOUN _005457217 398 5 presented present VERB _005457217 398 6 to to ADP _005457217 398 7 us we PRON _005457217 398 8 as as ADP _005457217 398 9 a a DET _005457217 398 10 matter matter NOUN _005457217 398 11 of of ADP _005457217 398 12 first first ADJ _005457217 398 13 impression impression NOUN _005457217 398 14 we we PRON _005457217 398 15 would would AUX _005457217 398 16 have have AUX _005457217 398 17 arrived arrive VERB _005457217 398 18 at at ADP _005457217 398 19 the the DET _005457217 398 20 same same ADJ _005457217 398 21 conclusion conclusion NOUN _005457217 398 22 as as SCONJ _005457217 398 23 did do AUX _005457217 398 24 our our PRON _005457217 398 25 supreme supreme ADJ _005457217 398 26 court court NOUN _005457217 398 27 , , PUNCT _005457217 398 28 for for ADP _005457217 398 29 under under ADP _005457217 398 30 the the DET _005457217 398 31 compulsion compulsion NOUN _005457217 398 32 exerted exert VERB _005457217 398 33 by by ADP _005457217 398 34 the the DET _005457217 398 35 public public ADJ _005457217 398 36 school school NOUN _005457217 398 37 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 398 38 in in ADP _005457217 398 39 that that DET _005457217 398 40 case case NOUN _005457217 398 41 on on ADP _005457217 398 42 the the DET _005457217 398 43 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 398 44 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 398 45 , , PUNCT _005457217 398 46 we we PRON _005457217 398 47 would would AUX _005457217 398 48 agree agree VERB _005457217 398 49 that that SCONJ _005457217 398 50 their their PRON _005457217 398 51 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 398 52 rights right NOUN _005457217 398 53 were be AUX _005457217 398 54 violated violate VERB _005457217 398 55 . . PUNCT _005457217 399 1 however however ADV _005457217 399 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 399 3 as as ADP _005457217 399 4 authority authority NOUN _005457217 399 5 for for ADP _005457217 399 6 a a DET _005457217 399 7 decision decision NOUN _005457217 399 8 on on ADP _005457217 399 9 the the DET _005457217 399 10 facts fact NOUN _005457217 399 11 in in ADP _005457217 399 12 the the DET _005457217 399 13 case case NOUN _005457217 399 14 at at ADP _005457217 399 15 bar bar NOUN _005457217 399 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 399 17 it it PRON _005457217 399 18 is be AUX _005457217 399 19 peculiar peculiar ADJ _005457217 399 20 that that SCONJ _005457217 399 21 the the DET _005457217 399 22 ring ring NOUN _005457217 399 23 case case NOUN _005457217 399 24 is be AUX _005457217 399 25 not not PART _005457217 399 26 mentioned mention VERB _005457217 399 27 in in ADP _005457217 399 28 any any PRON _005457217 399 29 of of ADP _005457217 399 30 the the DET _005457217 399 31 later later ADJ _005457217 399 32 decisions decision NOUN _005457217 399 33 by by ADP _005457217 399 34 the the DET _005457217 399 35 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 399 36 court court PROPN _005457217 399 37 of of ADP _005457217 399 38 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 399 39 construing construe VERB _005457217 399 40 religious religious ADJ _005457217 399 41 freedom freedom NOUN _005457217 399 42 clauses clause NOUN _005457217 399 43 of of ADP _005457217 399 44 our our PRON _005457217 399 45 constitution constitution NOUN _005457217 399 46 . . PUNCT _005457217 400 1 then then ADV _005457217 400 2 too too ADV _005457217 400 3 , , PUNCT _005457217 400 4 the the DET _005457217 400 5 language language NOUN _005457217 400 6 in in ADP _005457217 400 7 the the DET _005457217 400 8 later later ADJ _005457217 400 9 opinions opinion NOUN _005457217 400 10 would would AUX _005457217 400 11 tend tend VERB _005457217 400 12 to to PART _005457217 400 13 narrow narrow VERB _005457217 400 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 400 15 circumscribe circumscribe VERB _005457217 400 16 what what PRON _005457217 400 17 was be AUX _005457217 400 18 said say VERB _005457217 400 19 in in ADP _005457217 400 20 the the DET _005457217 400 21 ring ring NOUN _005457217 400 22 case case NOUN _005457217 400 23 . . PUNCT _005457217 401 1 the the DET _005457217 401 2 authority authority NOUN _005457217 401 3 of of ADP _005457217 401 4 the the DET _005457217 401 5 ring ring NOUN _005457217 401 6 case case NOUN _005457217 401 7 is be AUX _005457217 401 8 weakened weaken VERB _005457217 401 9 by by ADP _005457217 401 10 the the DET _005457217 401 11 fact fact NOUN _005457217 401 12 that that SCONJ _005457217 401 13 it it PRON _005457217 401 14 goes go VERB _005457217 401 15 f f PROPN _005457217 401 16 a a DET _005457217 401 17 r r NOUN _005457217 401 18 t t NOUN _005457217 401 19 h h NOUN _005457217 401 20 e e NOUN _005457217 401 21 r r NOUN _005457217 401 22 than than ADP _005457217 401 23 any any DET _005457217 401 24 other other ADJ _005457217 401 25 case case NOUN _005457217 401 26 in in ADP _005457217 401 27 the the DET _005457217 401 28 united united PROPN _005457217 401 29 states states PROPN _005457217 401 30 in in ADP _005457217 401 31 its its PRON _005457217 401 32 language language NOUN _005457217 401 33 . . PUNCT _005457217 402 1 the the DET _005457217 402 2 actual actual ADJ _005457217 402 3 holding holding NOUN _005457217 402 4 of of ADP _005457217 402 5 the the DET _005457217 402 6 case case NOUN _005457217 402 7 is be AUX _005457217 402 8 opposed oppose VERB _005457217 402 9 to to ADP _005457217 402 10 the the DET _005457217 402 11 great great ADJ _005457217 402 12 weight weight NOUN _005457217 402 13 of of ADP _005457217 402 14 authority authority NOUN _005457217 402 15 in in ADP _005457217 402 16 the the DET _005457217 402 17 united united PROPN _005457217 402 18 states states PROPN _005457217 402 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 403 1 we we PRON _005457217 403 2 34 34 NUM _005457217 403 3 shall shall AUX _005457217 403 4 not not PART _005457217 403 5 attempt attempt VERB _005457217 403 6 to to PART _005457217 403 7 discuss discuss VERB _005457217 403 8 the the DET _005457217 403 9 facts fact NOUN _005457217 403 10 or or CCONJ _005457217 403 11 holdings holding NOUN _005457217 403 12 in in ADP _005457217 403 13 cases case NOUN _005457217 403 14 f f X _005457217 403 15 r r NOUN _005457217 403 16 o o NOUN _005457217 403 17 m m VERB _005457217 403 18 other other ADJ _005457217 403 19 jurisdictions jurisdiction NOUN _005457217 403 20 because because SCONJ _005457217 403 21 we we PRON _005457217 403 22 are be AUX _005457217 403 23 bound bind VERB _005457217 403 24 by by ADP _005457217 403 25 the the DET _005457217 403 26 decisions decision NOUN _005457217 403 27 of of ADP _005457217 403 28 our our PRON _005457217 403 29 own own ADJ _005457217 403 30 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 403 31 court court NOUN _005457217 403 32 , , PUNCT _005457217 403 33 but but CCONJ _005457217 403 34 the the DET _005457217 403 35 decisions decision NOUN _005457217 403 36 in in ADP _005457217 403 37 the the DET _005457217 403 38 united united PROPN _005457217 403 39 states states PROPN _005457217 403 40 generally generally ADV _005457217 403 41 , , PUNCT _005457217 403 42 and and CCONJ _005457217 403 43 the the DET _005457217 403 44 trend trend NOUN _005457217 403 45 of of ADP _005457217 403 46 authority authority NOUN _005457217 403 47 since since SCONJ _005457217 403 48 the the DET _005457217 403 49 time time NOUN _005457217 403 50 of of ADP _005457217 403 51 the the DET _005457217 403 52 ring ring NOUN _005457217 403 53 case case NOUN _005457217 403 54 may may AUX _005457217 403 55 be be AUX _005457217 403 56 found find VERB _005457217 403 57 under under ADP _005457217 403 58 the the DET _005457217 403 59 following follow VERB _005457217 403 60 annotations annotation NOUN _005457217 403 61 : : PUNCT _005457217 403 62 5 5 NUM _005457217 403 63 a.l.r a.l.r NOUN _005457217 403 64 . . PUNCT _005457217 404 1 866 866 NUM _005457217 404 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 404 3 20 20 NUM _005457217 404 4 a.l.r a.l.r ADJ _005457217 404 5 . . PUNCT _005457217 405 1 1351 1351 NUM _005457217 405 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 405 3 31 31 NUM _005457217 405 4 a.l.r a.l.r NOUN _005457217 405 5 . . PUNCT _005457217 406 1 1125 1125 NUM _005457217 406 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 406 3 57 57 NUM _005457217 406 4 a.l.r a.l.r NOUN _005457217 406 5 . . PUNCT _005457217 407 1 195 195 NUM _005457217 407 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 407 3 141 141 NUM _005457217 407 4 a.l.r a.l.r NOUN _005457217 407 5 . . PUNCT _005457217 408 1 1145 1145 NUM _005457217 408 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 409 1 the the DET _005457217 409 2 relator relator NOUN _005457217 409 3 particularly particularly ADV _005457217 409 4 relies rely VERB _005457217 409 5 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 409 6 state state PROPN _005457217 409 7 v. v. PROPN _005457217 409 8 weedman weedman PROPN _005457217 409 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 409 10 55 55 NUM _005457217 409 11 s. s. PROPN _005457217 409 12 dak dak PROPN _005457217 409 13 . . PUNCT _005457217 410 1 343 343 NUM _005457217 410 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 410 3 226 226 NUM _005457217 410 4 n. n. NOUN _005457217 410 5 w. w. PROPN _005457217 410 6 348 348 NUM _005457217 410 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 410 8 349 349 NUM _005457217 410 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 410 10 354 354 NUM _005457217 410 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 410 12 and and CCONJ _005457217 410 13 state state NOUN _005457217 410 14 v. v. ADP _005457217 410 15 frazier frazier PROPN _005457217 410 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 410 17 102 102 NUM _005457217 410 18 wash wash NOUN _005457217 410 19 . . PUNCT _005457217 411 1 309 309 NUM _005457217 411 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 411 3 173 173 NUM _005457217 411 4 pac pac NOUN _005457217 411 5 . . PUNCT _005457217 412 1 35 35 NUM _005457217 412 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 413 1 i i PRON _005457217 413 2 n n VERB _005457217 413 3 the the DET _005457217 413 4 weedman weedman PROPN _005457217 413 5 case case NOUN _005457217 413 6 the the DET _005457217 413 7 facts fact NOUN _005457217 413 8 were be AUX _005457217 413 9 almost almost ADV _005457217 413 10 exactly exactly ADV _005457217 413 11 like like ADP _005457217 413 12 those those PRON _005457217 413 13 in in ADP _005457217 413 14 the the DET _005457217 413 15 ring ring NOUN _005457217 413 16 case case NOUN _005457217 413 17 . . PUNCT _005457217 414 1 fifteen fifteen NUM _005457217 414 2 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 414 3 children child NOUN _005457217 414 4 were be AUX _005457217 414 5 expelled expel VERB _005457217 414 6 because because SCONJ _005457217 414 7 they they PRON _005457217 414 8 would would AUX _005457217 414 9 not not PART _005457217 414 10 attend attend VERB _005457217 414 11 opening open VERB _005457217 414 12 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 414 13 required require VERB _005457217 414 14 by by ADP _005457217 414 15 the the DET _005457217 414 16 school school NOUN _005457217 414 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 414 18 where where SCONJ _005457217 414 19 the the DET _005457217 414 20 lord lord PROPN _005457217 414 21 's 's PART _005457217 414 22 p p NOUN _005457217 414 23 r r NOUN _005457217 414 24 a a DET _005457217 414 25 y y PROPN _005457217 414 26 e e PROPN _005457217 414 27 r r NOUN _005457217 414 28 was be AUX _005457217 414 29 said say VERB _005457217 414 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 414 31 and and CCONJ _005457217 414 32 the the DET _005457217 414 33 bible bible PROPN _005457217 414 34 read read NOUN _005457217 414 35 . . PUNCT _005457217 415 1 mandamus mandamus VERB _005457217 415 2 to to PART _005457217 415 3 compel compel VERB _005457217 415 4 the the DET _005457217 415 5 children child NOUN _005457217 415 6 to to PART _005457217 415 7 be be AUX _005457217 415 8 readmitted readmitte VERB _005457217 415 9 to to ADP _005457217 415 10 the the DET _005457217 415 11 school school NOUN _005457217 415 12 was be AUX _005457217 415 13 allowed allow VERB _005457217 415 14 . . PUNCT _005457217 416 1 i i PRON _005457217 416 2 n n VERB _005457217 416 3 state state PROPN _005457217 416 4 v. v. ADP _005457217 416 5 frazier frazier PROPN _005457217 417 1 there there PRON _005457217 417 2 was be VERB _005457217 417 3 a a DET _005457217 417 4 state state NOUN _005457217 417 5 law law NOUN _005457217 417 6 purporting purport VERB _005457217 417 7 to to PART _005457217 417 8 provide provide VERB _005457217 417 9 that that SCONJ _005457217 417 10 the the DET _005457217 417 11 school school NOUN _005457217 417 12 should should AUX _005457217 417 13 furnish furnish VERB _005457217 417 14 written write VERB _005457217 417 15 outlines outline NOUN _005457217 417 16 on on ADP _005457217 417 17 the the DET _005457217 417 18 bible bible NOUN _005457217 417 19 and and CCONJ _005457217 417 20 give give VERB _005457217 417 21 examination examination NOUN _005457217 417 22 and and CCONJ _005457217 417 23 school school NOUN _005457217 417 24 credits credit NOUN _005457217 417 25 in in ADP _005457217 417 26 bible bible ADJ _005457217 417 27 reading reading NOUN _005457217 417 28 . . PUNCT _005457217 418 1 this this PRON _005457217 418 2 was be AUX _005457217 418 3 held hold VERB _005457217 418 4 to to PART _005457217 418 5 be be AUX _005457217 418 6 violative violative ADJ _005457217 418 7 of of ADP _005457217 418 8 the the DET _005457217 418 9 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 418 10 provision provision NOUN _005457217 418 11 that that SCONJ _005457217 418 12 no no DET _005457217 418 13 public public ADJ _005457217 418 14 money money NOUN _005457217 418 15 or or CCONJ _005457217 418 16 property property NOUN _005457217 418 17 should should AUX _005457217 418 18 be be AUX _005457217 418 19 appropriated appropriate VERB _005457217 418 20 f f PROPN _005457217 418 21 o o X _005457217 418 22 r r NOUN _005457217 418 23 or or CCONJ _005457217 418 24 applied apply VERB _005457217 418 25 to to ADP _005457217 418 26 any any DET _005457217 418 27 religious religious ADJ _005457217 418 28 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 418 29 or or CCONJ _005457217 418 30 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 418 31 . . PUNCT _005457217 419 1 we we PRON _005457217 419 2 pause pause VERB _005457217 419 3 to to PART _005457217 419 4 point point VERB _005457217 419 5 out out ADP _005457217 419 6 there there PRON _005457217 419 7 was be VERB _005457217 419 8 an an DET _005457217 419 9 element element NOUN _005457217 419 10 of of ADP _005457217 419 11 actual actual ADJ _005457217 419 12 compulsion compulsion NOUN _005457217 419 13 on on ADP _005457217 419 14 the the DET _005457217 419 15 school school NOUN _005457217 419 16 children child NOUN _005457217 419 17 to to PART _005457217 419 18 participate participate VERB _005457217 419 19 in in ADP _005457217 419 20 religious religious ADJ _005457217 419 21 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 419 22 abhorent abhorent NOUN _005457217 419 23 to to ADP _005457217 419 24 children child NOUN _005457217 419 25 and and CCONJ _005457217 419 26 their their PRON _005457217 419 27 parents parent NOUN _005457217 419 28 in in ADP _005457217 419 29 the the DET _005457217 419 30 ring ring NOUN _005457217 419 31 case case NOUN _005457217 419 32 and and CCONJ _005457217 419 33 in in ADP _005457217 419 34 every every DET _005457217 419 35 other other ADJ _005457217 419 36 case case NOUN _005457217 419 37 where where SCONJ _005457217 419 38 religious religious ADJ _005457217 419 39 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 419 40 in in ADP _005457217 419 41 the the DET _005457217 419 42 schools school NOUN _005457217 419 43 has have AUX _005457217 419 44 been be AUX _005457217 419 45 condemned condemn VERB _005457217 419 46 . . PUNCT _005457217 420 1 that that DET _005457217 420 2 compulsion compulsion NOUN _005457217 420 3 does do AUX _005457217 420 4 not not PART _005457217 420 5 exist exist VERB _005457217 420 6 in in ADP _005457217 420 7 the the DET _005457217 420 8 case case NOUN _005457217 420 9 at at ADP _005457217 420 10 bar bar NOUN _005457217 420 11 . . PUNCT _005457217 421 1 counsel counsel VERB _005457217 421 2 f f PROPN _005457217 421 3 o o NOUN _005457217 421 4 r r NOUN _005457217 421 5 relator relator NOUN _005457217 421 6 rely rely VERB _005457217 421 7 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 421 8 the the DET _005457217 421 9 dictum dictum NOUN _005457217 421 10 in in ADP _005457217 421 11 the the DET _005457217 421 12 ring ring NOUN _005457217 421 13 case case NOUN _005457217 421 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 421 15 that that DET _005457217 421 16 compulsion compulsion NOUN _005457217 421 17 is be AUX _005457217 421 18 exercised exercise VERB _005457217 421 19 because because SCONJ _005457217 421 20 james james PROPN _005457217 421 21 terry terry PROPN _005457217 421 22 is be AUX _005457217 421 23 not not PART _005457217 421 24 excused excuse VERB _005457217 421 25 from from ADP _005457217 421 26 school school NOUN _005457217 421 27 but but CCONJ _005457217 421 28 is be AUX _005457217 421 29 required require VERB _005457217 421 30 to to PART _005457217 421 31 do do VERB _005457217 421 32 his his PRON _005457217 421 33 other other ADJ _005457217 421 34 school school NOUN _005457217 421 35 work work NOUN _005457217 421 36 , , PUNCT _005457217 421 37 while while SCONJ _005457217 421 38 his his PRON _005457217 421 39 schoolmates schoolmate NOUN _005457217 421 40 were be AUX _005457217 421 41 taking take VERB _005457217 421 42 the the DET _005457217 421 43 courses course NOUN _005457217 421 44 in in ADP _005457217 421 45 religious religious ADJ _005457217 421 46 education education NOUN _005457217 421 47 . . PUNCT _005457217 422 1 the the DET _005457217 422 2 fact fact NOUN _005457217 422 3 remains remain VERB _005457217 422 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 422 5 how35 how35 NOUN _005457217 422 6 ever ever ADV _005457217 422 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 422 8 that that SCONJ _005457217 422 9 james james PROPN _005457217 422 10 terry terry PROPN _005457217 422 11 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 422 12 was be AUX _005457217 422 13 not not PART _005457217 422 14 required require VERB _005457217 422 15 to to PART _005457217 422 16 take take VERB _005457217 422 17 the the DET _005457217 422 18 religious religious ADJ _005457217 422 19 education education NOUN _005457217 422 20 courses course NOUN _005457217 422 21 and and CCONJ _005457217 422 22 he he PRON _005457217 422 23 was be AUX _005457217 422 24 sent send VERB _005457217 422 25 away away ADV _005457217 422 26 from from ADP _005457217 422 27 the the DET _005457217 422 28 room room NOUN _005457217 422 29 where where SCONJ _005457217 422 30 the the DET _005457217 422 31 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 422 32 were be AUX _005457217 422 33 going go VERB _005457217 422 34 on on ADP _005457217 422 35 , , PUNCT _005457217 422 36 so so CCONJ _005457217 422 37 there there PRON _005457217 422 38 could could AUX _005457217 422 39 be be AUX _005457217 422 40 no no DET _005457217 422 41 claim claim NOUN _005457217 422 42 that that SCONJ _005457217 422 43 any any DET _005457217 422 44 actual actual ADJ _005457217 422 45 compulsion compulsion NOUN _005457217 422 46 was be AUX _005457217 422 47 used use VERB _005457217 422 48 against against ADP _005457217 422 49 him he PRON _005457217 422 50 . . PUNCT _005457217 423 1 we we PRON _005457217 423 2 have have VERB _005457217 423 3 in in ADP _005457217 423 4 the the DET _005457217 423 5 case case NOUN _005457217 423 6 at at ADP _005457217 423 7 bar bar NOUN _005457217 423 8 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 423 9 as as ADP _005457217 423 10 to to ADP _005457217 423 11 what what PRON _005457217 423 12 the the DET _005457217 423 13 effect effect NOUN _005457217 423 14 of of ADP _005457217 423 15 these these DET _005457217 423 16 religious religious ADJ _005457217 423 17 education education NOUN _005457217 423 18 courses course NOUN _005457217 423 19 has have AUX _005457217 423 20 been be AUX _005457217 423 21 in in ADP _005457217 423 22 the the DET _005457217 423 23 school school NOUN _005457217 423 24 system system NOUN _005457217 423 25 itself itself PRON _005457217 423 26 . . PUNCT _005457217 424 1 james james PROPN _005457217 424 2 t t PROPN _005457217 424 3 e e PROPN _005457217 424 4 r r NOUN _005457217 424 5 r r NOUN _005457217 424 6 y y PROPN _005457217 424 7 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 424 8 s s PART _005457217 424 9 case case NOUN _005457217 424 10 was be AUX _005457217 424 11 the the DET _005457217 424 12 extreme extreme ADJ _005457217 424 13 case case NOUN _005457217 424 14 in in ADP _005457217 424 15 the the DET _005457217 424 16 second second ADJ _005457217 424 17 semester semester NOUN _005457217 424 18 of of ADP _005457217 424 19 the the DET _005457217 424 20 fifth fifth ADJ _005457217 424 21 grade grade NOUN _005457217 424 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 424 23 when when SCONJ _005457217 424 24 he he PRON _005457217 424 25 was be AUX _005457217 424 26 the the DET _005457217 424 27 only only ADJ _005457217 424 28 one one NUM _005457217 424 29 in in ADP _005457217 424 30 his his PRON _005457217 424 31 room room NOUN _005457217 424 32 who who PRON _005457217 424 33 did do AUX _005457217 424 34 not not PART _005457217 424 35 take take VERB _005457217 424 36 the the DET _005457217 424 37 religious religious ADJ _005457217 424 38 education education NOUN _005457217 424 39 courses course NOUN _005457217 424 40 . . PUNCT _005457217 425 1 the the DET _005457217 425 2 overall overall ADJ _005457217 425 3 picture picture NOUN _005457217 425 4 is be AUX _005457217 425 5 that that SCONJ _005457217 425 6 20 20 NUM _005457217 425 7 out out ADP _005457217 425 8 of of ADP _005457217 425 9 100 100 NUM _005457217 425 10 in in ADP _005457217 425 11 the the DET _005457217 425 12 grade grade NOUN _005457217 425 13 schools school NOUN _005457217 425 14 did do AUX _005457217 425 15 not not PART _005457217 425 16 take take VERB _005457217 425 17 the the DET _005457217 425 18 courses course NOUN _005457217 425 19 and and CCONJ _005457217 425 20 80 80 NUM _005457217 425 21 per per NOUN _005457217 425 22 cent cent NOUN _005457217 425 23 in in ADP _005457217 425 24 the the DET _005457217 425 25 junior junior ADJ _005457217 425 26 high high ADJ _005457217 425 27 school school NOUN _005457217 425 28 have have AUX _005457217 425 29 not not PART _005457217 425 30 taken take VERB _005457217 425 31 the the DET _005457217 425 32 courses course NOUN _005457217 425 33 . . PUNCT _005457217 426 1 there there PRON _005457217 426 2 was be VERB _005457217 426 3 a a DET _005457217 426 4 full full ADJ _005457217 426 5 and and CCONJ _005457217 426 6 representative representative ADJ _005457217 426 7 group group NOUN _005457217 426 8 of of ADP _005457217 426 9 students student NOUN _005457217 426 10 from from ADP _005457217 426 11 the the DET _005457217 426 12 grade grade NOUN _005457217 426 13 schools school NOUN _005457217 426 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 426 15 from from ADP _005457217 426 16 junior junior ADJ _005457217 426 17 high high ADJ _005457217 426 18 school school NOUN _005457217 426 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 426 20 whose whose DET _005457217 426 21 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 426 22 could could AUX _005457217 426 23 not not PART _005457217 426 24 help help VERB _005457217 426 25 but but CCONJ _005457217 426 26 impress impress VERB _005457217 426 27 favorably favorably ADV _005457217 426 28 the the DET _005457217 426 29 trial trial NOUN _005457217 426 30 judges judge NOUN _005457217 426 31 , , PUNCT _005457217 426 32 as as ADP _005457217 426 33 to to ADP _005457217 426 34 the the DET _005457217 426 35 beneficial beneficial ADJ _005457217 426 36 results result NOUN _005457217 426 37 of of ADP _005457217 426 38 religious religious ADJ _005457217 426 39 education education NOUN _005457217 426 40 , , PUNCT _005457217 426 41 and and CCONJ _005457217 426 42 the the DET _005457217 426 43 freedom freedom NOUN _005457217 426 44 from from ADP _005457217 426 45 intolerance intolerance NOUN _005457217 426 46 and and CCONJ _005457217 426 47 the the DET _005457217 426 48 other other ADJ _005457217 426 49 evils evil NOUN _005457217 426 50 that that PRON _005457217 426 51 are be AUX _005457217 426 52 mentioned mention VERB _005457217 426 53 in in ADP _005457217 426 54 the the DET _005457217 426 55 ring ring NOUN _005457217 426 56 case case NOUN _005457217 426 57 , , PUNCT _005457217 426 58 and and CCONJ _005457217 426 59 in in ADP _005457217 426 60 those those DET _005457217 426 61 courts court NOUN _005457217 426 62 who who PRON _005457217 426 63 frown frown VERB _005457217 426 64 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 426 65 bible bible ADJ _005457217 426 66 reading reading NOUN _005457217 426 67 , , PUNCT _005457217 426 68 and and CCONJ _005457217 426 69 so so ADV _005457217 426 70 forth forth ADV _005457217 426 71 , , PUNCT _005457217 426 72 in in ADP _005457217 426 73 the the DET _005457217 426 74 schools school NOUN _005457217 426 75 . . PUNCT _005457217 427 1 there there PRON _005457217 427 2 is be VERB _005457217 427 3 another another DET _005457217 427 4 reason reason NOUN _005457217 427 5 why why SCONJ _005457217 427 6 it it PRON _005457217 427 7 seems seem VERB _005457217 427 8 to to ADP _005457217 427 9 us we PRON _005457217 427 10 that that SCONJ _005457217 427 11 the the DET _005457217 427 12 case case NOUN _005457217 427 13 at at ADP _005457217 427 14 bar bar NOUN _005457217 427 15 is be AUX _005457217 427 16 entirely entirely ADV _005457217 427 17 distinguishable distinguishable ADJ _005457217 427 18 f f NOUN _005457217 427 19 r r NOUN _005457217 427 20 o o NOUN _005457217 427 21 m m VERB _005457217 427 22 the the DET _005457217 427 23 ring ring NOUN _005457217 427 24 case case NOUN _005457217 427 25 . . PUNCT _005457217 428 1 as as SCONJ _005457217 428 2 pointed point VERB _005457217 428 3 out out ADP _005457217 428 4 in in ADP _005457217 428 5 the the DET _005457217 428 6 annotations annotation NOUN _005457217 428 7 in in ADP _005457217 428 8 5 5 NUM _005457217 428 9 a.l.r a.l.r NOUN _005457217 428 10 . . PUNCT _005457217 429 1 866 866 NUM _005457217 429 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 429 3 and and CCONJ _005457217 429 4 the the DET _005457217 429 5 other other ADJ _005457217 429 6 volumes volume NOUN _005457217 429 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 429 8 the the DET _005457217 429 9 question question NOUN _005457217 429 10 of of ADP _005457217 429 11 what what PRON _005457217 429 12 is be AUX _005457217 429 13 legal legal ADJ _005457217 429 14 or or CCONJ _005457217 429 15 illegal illegal ADJ _005457217 429 16 in in ADP _005457217 429 17 the the DET _005457217 429 18 schools school NOUN _005457217 429 19 as as ADP _005457217 429 20 constituting constitute VERB _005457217 429 21 sectarianism sectarianism NOUN _005457217 429 22 divides divide VERB _005457217 429 23 itself itself PRON _005457217 429 24 into into ADP _005457217 429 25 a a DET _005457217 429 26 number number NOUN _005457217 429 27 of of ADP _005457217 429 28 different different ADJ _005457217 429 29 categories category NOUN _005457217 429 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 429 31 which which PRON _005457217 429 32 are be AUX _005457217 429 33 listed list VERB _005457217 429 34 as as SCONJ _005457217 429 35 follows follow VERB _005457217 429 36 : : PUNCT _005457217 429 37 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 429 38 1 1 X _005457217 429 39 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 429 40 mere mere ADJ _005457217 429 41 reading reading NOUN _005457217 429 42 of of ADP _005457217 429 43 the the DET _005457217 429 44 bible bible NOUN _005457217 429 45 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 429 46 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 429 47 2 2 X _005457217 429 48 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 429 49 reading read VERB _005457217 429 50 bible bible NOUN _005457217 429 51 and and CCONJ _005457217 429 52 saying say VERB _005457217 429 53 lord lord PROPN _005457217 429 54 's 's PART _005457217 429 55 p p NOUN _005457217 429 56 r r NOUN _005457217 429 57 a a DET _005457217 429 58 y y PROPN _005457217 429 59 e e NOUN _005457217 429 60 r r NOUN _005457217 429 61 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 429 62 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 429 63 3 3 X _005457217 429 64 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 429 65 teaching teach VERB _005457217 429 66 ten ten NUM _005457217 429 67 commandments commandment NOUN _005457217 429 68 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 429 69 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 429 70 4 4 X _005457217 429 71 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 429 72 beading bead VERB _005457217 429 73 bible bible ADJ _005457217 429 74 and and CCONJ _005457217 429 75 singing singe VERB _005457217 429 76 hymns hymn NOUN _005457217 429 77 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 429 78 36 36 NUM _005457217 429 79 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 429 80 5 5 NUM _005457217 429 81 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 429 82 saying say VERB _005457217 429 83 p p NOUN _005457217 429 84 r r NOUN _005457217 429 85 a a DET _005457217 429 86 y y PROPN _005457217 429 87 e e NOUN _005457217 429 88 r r NOUN _005457217 429 89 s s NOUN _005457217 429 90 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 429 91 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 429 92 6 6 NUM _005457217 429 93 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 429 94 use use NOUN _005457217 429 95 of of ADP _005457217 429 96 bible bible PROPN _005457217 429 97 as as ADP _005457217 429 98 textbook textbook NOUN _005457217 429 99 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 429 100 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 429 101 7 7 X _005457217 429 102 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 429 103 use use NOUN _005457217 429 104 of of ADP _005457217 429 105 textbook textbook NOUN _005457217 429 106 founded found VERB _005457217 429 107 on on ADP _005457217 429 108 bible bible NOUN _005457217 429 109 . . PUNCT _005457217 430 1 i i PRON _005457217 430 2 n n VERB _005457217 430 3 the the DET _005457217 430 4 ring ring NOUN _005457217 430 5 case case NOUN _005457217 430 6 tbere tbere NOUN _005457217 430 7 was be AUX _005457217 430 8 a a DET _005457217 430 9 combination combination NOUN _005457217 430 10 of of ADP _005457217 430 11 prayer prayer NOUN _005457217 430 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 430 13 bible bible ADJ _005457217 430 14 reading reading NOUN _005457217 430 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 430 16 and and CCONJ _005457217 430 17 tbe tbe VERB _005457217 430 18 singing singing NOUN _005457217 430 19 of of ADP _005457217 430 20 bymns bymn NOUN _005457217 430 21 . . PUNCT _005457217 431 1 in in ADP _005457217 431 2 the the DET _005457217 431 3 cases case NOUN _005457217 431 4 f f X _005457217 431 5 r r NOUN _005457217 431 6 o o NOUN _005457217 431 7 m m VERB _005457217 431 8 other other ADJ _005457217 431 9 states state NOUN _005457217 431 10 which which PRON _005457217 431 11 we we PRON _005457217 431 12 have have AUX _005457217 431 13 examined examine VERB _005457217 431 14 there there PRON _005457217 431 15 is be VERB _005457217 431 16 almost almost ADV _005457217 431 17 always always ADV _005457217 431 18 a a DET _005457217 431 19 similar similar ADJ _005457217 431 20 combination combination NOUN _005457217 431 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 431 22 plus plus CCONJ _005457217 431 23 the the DET _005457217 431 24 fact fact NOUN _005457217 431 25 that that SCONJ _005457217 431 26 an an DET _005457217 431 27 earnest earnest ADJ _005457217 431 28 sincere sincere ADJ _005457217 431 29 minority minority NOUN _005457217 431 30 of of ADP _005457217 431 31 religious religious ADJ _005457217 431 32 people people NOUN _005457217 431 33 , , PUNCT _005457217 431 34 usually usually ADV _005457217 431 35 catholics catholic NOUN _005457217 431 36 or or CCONJ _005457217 431 37 jews jews PROPN _005457217 431 38 , , PUNCT _005457217 431 39 were be AUX _005457217 431 40 compelled compel VERB _005457217 431 41 to to PART _005457217 431 42 join join VERB _005457217 431 43 in in ADP _005457217 431 44 religious religious ADJ _005457217 431 45 services service NOUN _005457217 431 46 that that PRON _005457217 431 47 were be AUX _005457217 431 48 abhorent abhorent NOUN _005457217 431 49 to to ADP _005457217 431 50 them they PRON _005457217 431 51 . . PUNCT _005457217 432 1 i i PRON _005457217 432 2 n n VERB _005457217 432 3 the the DET _005457217 432 4 case case NOUN _005457217 432 5 at at ADP _005457217 432 6 bar bar NOUN _005457217 433 1 no no DET _005457217 433 2 prayers prayer NOUN _005457217 433 3 were be AUX _005457217 433 4 offered offer VERB _005457217 433 5 in in ADP _005457217 433 6 any any PRON _005457217 433 7 of of ADP _005457217 433 8 the the DET _005457217 433 9 religious religious ADJ _005457217 433 10 classes class NOUN _005457217 433 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 433 12 and and CCONJ _005457217 433 13 no no DET _005457217 433 14 hymns hymn NOUN _005457217 433 15 were be AUX _005457217 433 16 sung sing VERB _005457217 433 17 . . PUNCT _005457217 434 1 the the DET _005457217 434 2 bible bible PROPN _005457217 434 3 was be AUX _005457217 434 4 used use VERB _005457217 434 5 as as ADP _005457217 434 6 a a DET _005457217 434 7 text text NOUN _005457217 434 8 book book NOUN _005457217 434 9 and and CCONJ _005457217 434 10 outlines outline NOUN _005457217 434 11 and and CCONJ _005457217 434 12 other other ADJ _005457217 434 13 reading reading NOUN _005457217 434 14 material material NOUN _005457217 434 15 founded found VERB _005457217 434 16 on on ADP _005457217 434 17 the the DET _005457217 434 18 bible bible PROPN _005457217 434 19 were be AUX _005457217 434 20 taught teach VERB _005457217 434 21 . . PUNCT _005457217 435 1 we we PRON _005457217 435 2 state state VERB _005457217 435 3 again again ADV _005457217 435 4 for for ADP _005457217 435 5 emphasis emphasis NOUN _005457217 435 6 that that SCONJ _005457217 435 7 so so ADV _005457217 435 8 f f X _005457217 435 9 a a DET _005457217 435 10 r r NOUN _005457217 435 11 as as SCONJ _005457217 435 12 the the DET _005457217 435 13 bible bible PROPN _005457217 435 14 was be AUX _005457217 435 15 read read VERB _005457217 435 16 or or CCONJ _005457217 435 17 taught teach VERB _005457217 435 18 in in ADP _005457217 435 19 the the DET _005457217 435 20 schools school NOUN _005457217 435 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 435 22 there there PRON _005457217 435 23 seems seem VERB _005457217 435 24 to to PART _005457217 435 25 have have AUX _005457217 435 26 been be AUX _005457217 435 27 a a DET _005457217 435 28 sincere sincere ADJ _005457217 435 29 effort effort NOUN _005457217 435 30 to to PART _005457217 435 31 present present VERB _005457217 435 32 by by ADP _005457217 435 33 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 435 34 teachers teacher NOUN _005457217 435 35 to to ADP _005457217 435 36 pupils pupil NOUN _005457217 435 37 of of ADP _005457217 435 38 some some DET _005457217 435 39 thirty thirty NUM _005457217 435 40 - - PUNCT _005457217 435 41 one one NUM _005457217 435 42 different different ADJ _005457217 435 43 protestant protestant ADJ _005457217 435 44 sects sect NOUN _005457217 435 45 , , PUNCT _005457217 435 46 the the DET _005457217 435 47 broad broad ADJ _005457217 435 48 , , PUNCT _005457217 435 49 moral moral ADJ _005457217 435 50 truths truth NOUN _005457217 435 51 of of ADP _005457217 435 52 the the DET _005457217 435 53 bible bible NOUN _005457217 435 54 , , PUNCT _005457217 435 55 excluding exclude VERB _005457217 435 56 f f X _005457217 435 57 r r NOUN _005457217 435 58 o o NOUN _005457217 435 59 m m VERB _005457217 435 60 the the DET _005457217 435 61 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 435 62 as as ADP _005457217 435 63 f f PROPN _005457217 435 64 a a DET _005457217 435 65 r r NOUN _005457217 435 66 as as ADP _005457217 435 67 possible possible ADJ _005457217 435 68 , , PUNCT _005457217 435 69 controversial controversial ADJ _005457217 435 70 matter matter NOUN _005457217 435 71 that that PRON _005457217 435 72 divides divide VERB _005457217 435 73 the the DET _005457217 435 74 sects sect NOUN _005457217 435 75 . . PUNCT _005457217 436 1 practically practically ADV _005457217 436 2 nothing nothing PRON _005457217 436 3 was be AUX _005457217 436 4 asked ask VERB _005457217 436 5 of of ADP _005457217 436 6 father father NOUN _005457217 436 7 iliggins iliggin NOUN _005457217 436 8 or or CCONJ _005457217 436 9 of of ADP _005457217 436 10 rabbi rabbi NOUN _005457217 436 11 golden golden ADJ _005457217 436 12 as as ADP _005457217 436 13 to to ADP _005457217 436 14 the the DET _005457217 436 15 coutent coutent NOUN _005457217 436 16 of of ADP _005457217 436 17 the the DET _005457217 436 18 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 436 19 of of ADP _005457217 436 20 the the DET _005457217 436 21 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 436 22 and and CCONJ _005457217 436 23 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 436 24 students student NOUN _005457217 436 25 , , PUNCT _005457217 436 26 but but CCONJ _005457217 436 27 at at ADP _005457217 436 28 least least ADJ _005457217 436 29 there there PRON _005457217 436 30 is be VERB _005457217 436 31 nothing nothing PRON _005457217 436 32 to to PART _005457217 436 33 indicate indicate VERB _005457217 436 34 that that SCONJ _005457217 436 35 the the DET _005457217 436 36 teaching teaching NOUN _005457217 436 37 of of ADP _005457217 436 38 the the DET _005457217 436 39 catholic catholic ADJ _005457217 436 40 and and CCONJ _005457217 436 41 jewish jewish ADJ _005457217 436 42 students student NOUN _005457217 436 43 inculcated inculcate VERB _005457217 436 44 any any DET _005457217 436 45 antagonism antagonism NOUN _005457217 436 46 toward toward ADP _005457217 436 47 protestants protestant NOUN _005457217 436 48 or or CCONJ _005457217 436 49 others other NOUN _005457217 436 50 . . PUNCT _005457217 437 1 in in ADP _005457217 437 2 this this DET _005457217 437 3 situation situation NOUN _005457217 437 4 the the DET _005457217 437 5 language language NOUN _005457217 437 6 f f X _005457217 437 7 r r NOUN _005457217 437 8 o o NOUN _005457217 437 9 m m VERB _005457217 437 10 two two NUM _005457217 437 11 of of ADP _005457217 437 12 the the DET _005457217 437 13 cases case NOUN _005457217 437 14 relied rely VERB _005457217 437 15 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 437 16 by by ADP _005457217 437 17 the the DET _005457217 437 18 relator relator NOUN _005457217 437 19 it it PRON _005457217 437 20 seems seem VERB _005457217 437 21 to to ADP _005457217 437 22 us we PRON _005457217 437 23 is be AUX _005457217 437 24 particularly particularly ADV _005457217 437 25 in in ADP _005457217 437 26 point point NOUN _005457217 437 27 as as ADP _005457217 437 28 sustaining sustain VERB _005457217 437 29 the the DET _005457217 437 30 legality legality NOUN _005457217 437 31 of of ADP _005457217 437 32 what what PRON _005457217 437 33 is be AUX _005457217 437 34 referred refer VERB _005457217 437 35 to to ADP _005457217 437 36 as as ADP _005457217 437 37 the the DET _005457217 437 38 champaign champaign NOUN _005457217 437 39 system system NOUN _005457217 437 40 of of ADP _005457217 437 41 religious religious ADJ _005457217 437 42 education education NOUN _005457217 437 43 . . PUNCT _005457217 438 1 in in ADP _005457217 438 2 the the DET _005457217 438 3 case case NOUN _005457217 438 4 of of ADP _005457217 438 5 village village NOUN _005457217 438 6 of of ADP _005457217 438 7 south south PROPN _005457217 438 8 holland holland PROPN _005457217 438 9 v. v. PROPN _005457217 438 10 stein stein PROPN _005457217 438 11 , , PUNCT _005457217 438 12 373 373 NUM _005457217 438 13 111 111 NUM _005457217 438 14 . . PUNCT _005457217 439 1 472 472 NUM _005457217 439 2 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 439 3 and and CCONJ _005457217 439 4 city city NOUN _005457217 439 5 of of ADP _005457217 439 6 blue blue ADJ _005457217 439 7 island island PROPN _005457217 439 8 v. v. ADP _005457217 439 9 kosul kosul PROPN _005457217 439 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 439 11 379 379 NUM _005457217 439 12 111 111 NUM _005457217 439 13 . . PUNCT _005457217 440 1 511 511 NUM _005457217 440 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 440 3 where where SCONJ _005457217 440 4 discriminatory discriminatory ADJ _005457217 440 5 treatment treatment NOUN _005457217 440 6 of of ADP _005457217 440 7 jehovah jehovah NOUN _005457217 440 8 's 's PART _005457217 440 9 witnesses witness NOUN _005457217 440 10 was be AUX _005457217 440 11 37 37 NUM _005457217 440 12 condemned condemn VERB _005457217 440 13 as as ADP _005457217 440 14 unconstitutional unconstitutional ADJ _005457217 440 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 440 16 and and CCONJ _005457217 440 17 where where SCONJ _005457217 440 18 the the DET _005457217 440 19 able able ADJ _005457217 440 20 counsel counsel NOUN _005457217 440 21 representing represent VERB _005457217 440 22 the the DET _005457217 440 23 relator relator NOUN _005457217 440 24 in in ADP _005457217 440 25 this this DET _005457217 440 26 case case NOUN _005457217 440 27 appeared appear VERB _005457217 440 28 in in ADP _005457217 440 29 those those DET _005457217 440 30 cases case NOUN _005457217 440 31 , , PUNCT _005457217 440 32 the the DET _005457217 440 33 court court NOUN _005457217 440 34 said say VERB _005457217 440 35 , , PUNCT _005457217 440 36 quoting quote VERB _005457217 440 37 from from ADP _005457217 440 38 city city NOUN _005457217 440 39 of of ADP _005457217 440 40 blue blue ADJ _005457217 440 41 island island PROPN _005457217 440 42 v. v. PROPN _005457217 440 43 kozul kozul PROPN _005457217 440 44 , , PUNCT _005457217 440 45 379 379 NUM _005457217 440 46 111 111 NUM _005457217 440 47 . . PUNCT _005457217 441 1 511 511 NUM _005457217 441 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 441 3 at at ADP _005457217 441 4 521 521 NUM _005457217 441 5 : : PUNCT _005457217 441 6 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 441 7 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 441 8 the the DET _005457217 441 9 fact fact NOUN _005457217 441 10 that that SCONJ _005457217 441 11 when when SCONJ _005457217 441 12 so so ADV _005457217 441 13 applied apply VERB _005457217 441 14 the the DET _005457217 441 15 ordinance ordinance NOUN _005457217 441 16 is be AUX _005457217 441 17 unconstitutional unconstitutional ADJ _005457217 441 18 does do AUX _005457217 441 19 not not PART _005457217 441 20 determine determine VERB _005457217 441 21 that that SCONJ _005457217 441 22 it it PRON _005457217 441 23 would would AUX _005457217 441 24 be be AUX _005457217 441 25 invalid invalid ADJ _005457217 441 26 for for ADP _005457217 441 27 that that DET _005457217 441 28 reason reason NOUN _005457217 441 29 when when SCONJ _005457217 441 30 applied apply VERB _005457217 441 31 to to ADP _005457217 441 32 other other ADJ _005457217 441 33 and and CCONJ _005457217 441 34 different different ADJ _005457217 441 35 f f PROPN _005457217 441 36 a a DET _005457217 441 37 c c NOUN _005457217 441 38 t t NOUN _005457217 441 39 s s NOUN _005457217 441 40 . . PUNCT _005457217 441 41 " " PUNCT _005457217 442 1 so so ADV _005457217 442 2 in in ADP _005457217 442 3 the the DET _005457217 442 4 case case NOUN _005457217 442 5 at at ADP _005457217 442 6 bar bar NOUN _005457217 442 7 we we PRON _005457217 442 8 feel feel VERB _005457217 442 9 that that SCONJ _005457217 442 10 the the DET _005457217 442 11 illegal illegal ADJ _005457217 442 12 conduct conduct NOUN _005457217 442 13 condemned condemn VERB _005457217 442 14 in in ADP _005457217 442 15 the the DET _005457217 442 16 ring ring NOUN _005457217 442 17 case case NOUN _005457217 442 18 does do AUX _005457217 442 19 not not PART _005457217 442 20 determine determine VERB _005457217 442 21 that that SCONJ _005457217 442 22 the the DET _005457217 442 23 conduct conduct NOUN _005457217 442 24 of of ADP _005457217 442 25 the the DET _005457217 442 26 classes class NOUN _005457217 442 27 as as SCONJ _005457217 442 28 shown show VERB _005457217 442 29 by by ADP _005457217 442 30 the the DET _005457217 442 31 record record NOUN _005457217 442 32 in in ADP _005457217 442 33 this this DET _005457217 442 34 case case NOUN _005457217 442 35 violates violate VERB _005457217 442 36 the the DET _005457217 442 37 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 442 38 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 442 39 , , PUNCT _005457217 442 40 state state NOUN _005457217 442 41 or or CCONJ _005457217 442 42 federal federal ADJ _005457217 442 43 under under ADP _005457217 442 44 the the DET _005457217 442 45 other other ADJ _005457217 442 46 and and CCONJ _005457217 442 47 different different ADJ _005457217 442 48 facts fact NOUN _005457217 442 49 in in ADP _005457217 442 50 the the DET _005457217 442 51 case case NOUN _005457217 442 52 at at ADP _005457217 442 53 bar bar NOUN _005457217 442 54 . . PUNCT _005457217 443 1 from from ADP _005457217 443 2 the the DET _005457217 443 3 earliest early ADJ _005457217 443 4 times time NOUN _005457217 443 5 it it PRON _005457217 443 6 has have AUX _005457217 443 7 been be AUX _005457217 443 8 held hold VERB _005457217 443 9 that that SCONJ _005457217 443 10 school school NOUN _005457217 443 11 boards board NOUN _005457217 443 12 and and CCONJ _005457217 443 13 school school NOUN _005457217 443 14 directors director NOUN _005457217 443 15 are be AUX _005457217 443 16 vested vest VERB _005457217 443 17 with with ADP _005457217 443 18 wide wide ADJ _005457217 443 19 discretion discretion NOUN _005457217 443 20 in in ADP _005457217 443 21 their their PRON _005457217 443 22 conduct conduct NOUN _005457217 443 23 of of ADP _005457217 443 24 the the DET _005457217 443 25 schools school NOUN _005457217 443 26 , , PUNCT _005457217 443 27 subject subject NOUN _005457217 443 28 , , PUNCT _005457217 443 29 however however ADV _005457217 443 30 , , PUNCT _005457217 443 31 to to ADP _005457217 443 32 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 443 33 and and CCONJ _005457217 443 34 statutory statutory ADJ _005457217 443 35 limitations limitation NOUN _005457217 443 36 on on ADP _005457217 443 37 their their PRON _005457217 443 38 powers power NOUN _005457217 443 39 . . PUNCT _005457217 444 1 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 444 2 board board NOUN _005457217 444 3 of of ADP _005457217 444 4 school school NOUN _005457217 444 5 inspectors inspector NOUN _005457217 444 6 v. v. ADP _005457217 444 7 grove grove PROPN _005457217 444 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 444 9 20 20 NUM _005457217 444 10 111 111 NUM _005457217 444 11 . . PUNCT _005457217 445 1 526 526 NUM _005457217 445 2 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 445 3 the the DET _005457217 445 4 trustees trustee NOUN _005457217 445 5 of of ADP _005457217 445 6 schools school NOUN _005457217 445 7 v. v. ADP _005457217 445 8 people people PROPN _005457217 445 9 ex ex PROPN _005457217 445 10 rel rel PROPN _005457217 445 11 . . PUNCT _005457217 446 1 van van PROPN _005457217 446 2 allen allen PROPN _005457217 446 3 , , PUNCT _005457217 446 4 87 87 NUM _005457217 446 5 111 111 NUM _005457217 446 6 . . PUNCT _005457217 446 7 303 303 NUM _005457217 446 8 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 446 9 people people NOUN _005457217 446 10 ex ex PROPN _005457217 446 11 rel rel PROPN _005457217 446 12 . . PUNCT _005457217 447 1 v. v. PROPN _005457217 447 2 city city PROPN _005457217 447 3 , , PUNCT _005457217 447 4 of of ADP _005457217 447 5 chicago chicago PROPN _005457217 447 6 , , PUNCT _005457217 447 7 278 278 NUM _005457217 447 8 111 111 NUM _005457217 447 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 447 10 318 318 NUM _005457217 447 11 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 447 12 segar segar PROPN _005457217 447 13 v. v. PROPN _005457217 447 14 board board PROPN _005457217 447 15 of of ADP _005457217 447 16 education education NOUN _005457217 447 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 447 18 317 317 NUM _005457217 447 19 111 111 NUM _005457217 447 20 . . PUNCT _005457217 448 1 418 418 NUM _005457217 448 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 448 3 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 449 1 the the DET _005457217 449 2 recent recent ADJ _005457217 449 3 case case NOUN _005457217 449 4 of of ADP _005457217 449 5 people people NOUN _005457217 449 6 ex ex PROPN _005457217 449 7 rel rel PROPN _005457217 449 8 . . PUNCT _005457217 449 9 leivis leivis PROPN _005457217 449 10 v. v. PROPN _005457217 449 11 graves graves PROPN _005457217 449 12 , , PUNCT _005457217 449 13 245 245 NUM _005457217 449 14 n. n. PROPN _005457217 449 15 y. y. PROPN _005457217 449 16 195 195 NUM _005457217 449 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 449 18 156 156 NUM _005457217 449 19 n. n. PROPN _005457217 449 20 e. e. PROPN _005457217 449 21 663 663 NUM _005457217 449 22 , , PUNCT _005457217 449 23 affirming affirm VERB _005457217 449 24 215 215 NUM _005457217 449 25 n. n. PROPN _005457217 449 26 y. y. PROPN _005457217 449 27 supp supp PROPN _005457217 449 28 . . PUNCT _005457217 450 1 632 632 NUM _005457217 450 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 450 3 and and CCONJ _005457217 450 4 219 219 NUM _005457217 450 5 app app NOUN _005457217 450 6 . . PUNCT _005457217 451 1 div div PROPN _005457217 451 2 . . PROPN _005457217 451 3 233 233 NUM _005457217 451 4 , , PUNCT _005457217 451 5 219 219 NUM _005457217 451 6 n. n. PROPN _005457217 451 7 y. y. PROPN _005457217 451 8 supp supp PROPN _005457217 451 9 . . PUNCT _005457217 452 1 189 189 NUM _005457217 452 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 452 3 holds hold VERB _005457217 452 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 452 5 the the DET _005457217 452 6 school school NOUN _005457217 452 7 authorities authority NOUN _005457217 452 8 under under ADP _005457217 452 9 very very ADV _005457217 452 10 similar similar ADJ _005457217 452 11 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 452 12 provisions provision NOUN _005457217 452 13 as as ADP _005457217 452 14 ours our NOUN _005457217 452 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 452 16 may may AUX _005457217 452 17 release release VERB _005457217 452 18 students student NOUN _005457217 452 19 during during ADP _005457217 452 20 school school NOUN _005457217 452 21 time time NOUN _005457217 452 22 to to PART _005457217 452 23 attend attend VERB _005457217 452 24 religious religious ADJ _005457217 452 25 education education NOUN _005457217 452 26 classes class NOUN _005457217 452 27 in in ADP _005457217 452 28 their their PRON _005457217 452 29 own own ADJ _005457217 452 30 churches church NOUN _005457217 452 31 . . PUNCT _005457217 453 1 this this PRON _005457217 453 2 of of ADP _005457217 453 3 course course NOUN _005457217 453 4 does do AUX _005457217 453 5 not not PART _005457217 453 6 meet meet VERB _005457217 453 7 the the DET _005457217 453 8 relator relator NOUN _005457217 453 9 's 's PART _005457217 453 10 objection objection NOUN _005457217 453 11 to to ADP _005457217 453 12 the the DET _005457217 453 13 use use NOUN _005457217 453 14 of of ADP _005457217 453 15 the the DET _005457217 453 16 school school NOUN _005457217 453 17 buildings building NOUN _005457217 453 18 themselves themselves PRON _005457217 453 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 453 20 but but CCONJ _005457217 453 21 no no DET _005457217 453 22 case case NOUN _005457217 453 23 has have AUX _005457217 453 24 been be AUX _005457217 453 25 cited cite VERB _005457217 453 26 to to ADP _005457217 453 27 us we PRON _005457217 453 28 where where SCONJ _005457217 453 29 the the DET _005457217 453 30 purely purely ADV _005457217 453 31 voluntary voluntary ADJ _005457217 453 32 participation participation NOUN _005457217 453 33 in in ADP _005457217 453 34 religious religious ADJ _005457217 453 35 education education NOUN _005457217 453 36 classes class NOUN _005457217 453 37 , , PUNCT _005457217 453 38 no no DET _005457217 453 39 p p NOUN _005457217 453 40 a a DET _005457217 453 41 r r NOUN _005457217 453 42 t t NOUN _005457217 453 43 of of ADP _005457217 453 44 the the DET _005457217 453 45 expense expense NOUN _005457217 453 46 of of ADP _005457217 453 47 which which PRON _005457217 453 48 is be AUX _005457217 453 49 borne bear VERB _005457217 453 50 by by ADP _005457217 453 51 the the DET _005457217 453 52 tax tax NOUN _005457217 453 53 payers payer NOUN _005457217 453 54 , , PUNCT _005457217 453 55 has have AUX _005457217 453 56 been be AUX _005457217 453 57 condemned condemn VERB _005457217 453 58 . . PUNCT _005457217 454 1 again again ADV _005457217 454 2 applying apply VERB _005457217 454 3 the the DET _005457217 454 4 language language NOUN _005457217 454 5 of of ADP _005457217 454 6 the the DET _005457217 454 7 supreme supreme PROPN _005457217 454 8 court court PROPN _005457217 454 9 of of ADP _005457217 454 10 38 38 NUM _005457217 454 11 the the DET _005457217 454 12 united united PROPN _005457217 454 13 states states PROPN _005457217 454 14 in in ADP _005457217 454 15 west west PROPN _005457217 454 16 virginia virginia PROPN _005457217 454 17 v. v. PROPN _005457217 454 18 barnette barnette PROPN _005457217 454 19 , , PUNCT _005457217 454 20 319 319 NUM _005457217 454 21 u. u. PROPN _005457217 454 22 s. s. PROPN _005457217 454 23 624 624 NUM _005457217 454 24 , , PUNCT _005457217 454 25 63 63 NUM _005457217 454 26 sup sup NOUN _005457217 454 27 . . PUNCT _005457217 455 1 ct ct PROPN _005457217 455 2 . . PUNCT _005457217 456 1 1178 1178 NUM _005457217 456 2 , , PUNCT _005457217 456 3 at at ADP _005457217 456 4 1181 1181 NUM _005457217 456 5 , , PUNCT _005457217 456 6 the the DET _005457217 456 7 freedom freedom NOUN _005457217 456 8 asserted assert VERB _005457217 456 9 by by ADP _005457217 456 10 the the DET _005457217 456 11 relator relator NOUN _005457217 456 12 and and CCONJ _005457217 456 13 by by ADP _005457217 456 14 james james PROPN _005457217 456 15 terry terry PROPN _005457217 456 16 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 456 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 456 18 to to PART _005457217 456 19 have have AUX _005457217 456 20 religious religious ADJ _005457217 456 21 education education NOUN _005457217 456 22 in in ADP _005457217 456 23 these these DET _005457217 456 24 voluntary voluntary ADJ _005457217 456 25 classes class NOUN _005457217 456 26 excluded exclude VERB _005457217 456 27 from from ADP _005457217 456 28 the the DET _005457217 456 29 schools school NOUN _005457217 456 30 of of ADP _005457217 456 31 champaign champaign NOUN _005457217 456 32 does do AUX _005457217 456 33 bring bring VERB _005457217 456 34 the the DET _005457217 456 35 relator relator NOUN _005457217 456 36 and and CCONJ _005457217 456 37 her her PRON _005457217 456 38 son son NOUN _005457217 456 39 into into ADP _005457217 456 40 collision collision NOUN _005457217 456 41 with with ADP _005457217 456 42 the the DET _005457217 456 43 rights right NOUN _005457217 456 44 asserted assert VERB _005457217 456 45 by by ADP _005457217 456 46 the the DET _005457217 456 47 intervenors intervenor NOUN _005457217 456 48 who who PRON _005457217 456 49 are be AUX _005457217 456 50 representative representative ADJ _005457217 456 51 of of ADP _005457217 456 52 eighty eighty NUM _005457217 456 53 per per ADP _005457217 456 54 cent cent NOUN _005457217 456 55 of of ADP _005457217 456 56 the the DET _005457217 456 57 children child NOUN _005457217 456 58 attending attend VERB _005457217 456 59 the the DET _005457217 456 60 grade grade NOUN _005457217 456 61 schools school NOUN _005457217 456 62 , , PUNCT _005457217 456 63 and and CCONJ _005457217 456 64 a a DET _005457217 456 65 substantial substantial ADJ _005457217 456 66 per per ADP _005457217 456 67 cent cent NOUN _005457217 456 68 of of ADP _005457217 456 69 those those PRON _005457217 456 70 attending attend VERB _005457217 456 71 junior junior ADJ _005457217 456 72 high high ADJ _005457217 456 73 school school NOUN _005457217 456 74 . . PUNCT _005457217 457 1 only only ADV _005457217 457 2 one one NUM _005457217 457 3 witness witness NOUN _005457217 457 4 with with ADP _005457217 457 5 children child NOUN _005457217 457 6 in in ADP _005457217 457 7 the the DET _005457217 457 8 local local ADJ _005457217 457 9 schools school NOUN _005457217 457 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 457 11 besides besides SCONJ _005457217 457 12 the the DET _005457217 457 13 relator relator NOUN _005457217 457 14 , , PUNCT _005457217 457 15 namely namely ADV _005457217 457 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 457 17 mr mr PROPN _005457217 457 18 . . PROPN _005457217 457 19 adams adams PROPN _005457217 457 20 , , PUNCT _005457217 457 21 expressed express VERB _005457217 457 22 any any DET _005457217 457 23 dissatisfaction dissatisfaction NOUN _005457217 457 24 with with ADP _005457217 457 25 this this DET _005457217 457 26 program program NOUN _005457217 457 27 . . PUNCT _005457217 458 1 we we PRON _005457217 458 2 freely freely ADV _005457217 458 3 concede concede VERB _005457217 458 4 that that SCONJ _005457217 458 5 if if SCONJ _005457217 458 6 james james PROPN _005457217 458 7 terry terry PROPN _005457217 458 8 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 458 9 stood stand VERB _005457217 458 10 alone alone ADJ _005457217 458 11 and and CCONJ _005457217 458 12 were be AUX _005457217 458 13 compelled compel VERB _005457217 458 14 to to PART _005457217 458 15 participate participate VERB _005457217 458 16 in in ADP _005457217 458 17 religious religious ADJ _005457217 458 18 exercises exercise NOUN _005457217 458 19 to to PART _005457217 458 20 which which PRON _005457217 458 21 he he PRON _005457217 458 22 had have VERB _005457217 458 23 conscientious conscientious ADJ _005457217 458 24 objection objection NOUN _005457217 458 25 it it PRON _005457217 458 26 would would AUX _005457217 458 27 make make VERB _005457217 458 28 no no DET _005457217 458 29 difference difference NOUN _005457217 458 30 if if SCONJ _005457217 458 31 there there PRON _005457217 458 32 were be VERB _005457217 458 33 a a DET _005457217 458 34 million million NUM _005457217 458 35 people people NOUN _005457217 458 36 on on ADP _005457217 458 37 the the DET _005457217 458 38 other other ADJ _005457217 458 39 side side NOUN _005457217 458 40 , , PUNCT _005457217 458 41 but but CCONJ _005457217 458 42 in in ADP _005457217 458 43 our our PRON _005457217 458 44 view view NOUN _005457217 458 45 of of ADP _005457217 458 46 the the DET _005457217 458 47 matter matter NOUN _005457217 458 48 there there PRON _005457217 458 49 has have AUX _005457217 458 50 been be AUX _005457217 458 51 no no DET _005457217 458 52 such such ADJ _005457217 458 53 compulsion compulsion NOUN _005457217 458 54 visited visit VERB _005457217 458 55 upon upon SCONJ _005457217 458 56 him he PRON _005457217 458 57 . . PUNCT _005457217 459 1 the the DET _005457217 459 2 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 459 3 on on ADP _005457217 459 4 the the DET _005457217 459 5 trial trial NOUN _005457217 459 6 indicated indicate VERB _005457217 459 7 there there PRON _005457217 459 8 are be VERB _005457217 459 9 approximately approximately ADV _005457217 459 10 1,850 1,850 NUM _005457217 459 11 school school NOUN _005457217 459 12 systems system NOUN _005457217 459 13 in in ADP _005457217 459 14 46 46 NUM _005457217 459 15 states state NOUN _005457217 459 16 of of ADP _005457217 459 17 this this DET _005457217 459 18 country country NOUN _005457217 459 19 that that PRON _005457217 459 20 have have VERB _005457217 459 21 some some DET _005457217 459 22 form form NOUN _005457217 459 23 of of ADP _005457217 459 24 religious religious ADJ _005457217 459 25 education education NOUN _005457217 459 26 in in ADP _005457217 459 27 the the DET _005457217 459 28 school school NOUN _005457217 459 29 system system NOUN _005457217 459 30 . . PUNCT _005457217 460 1 we we PRON _005457217 460 2 have have AUX _005457217 460 3 not not PART _005457217 460 4 been be AUX _005457217 460 5 favored favor VERB _005457217 460 6 with with ADP _005457217 460 7 the the DET _005457217 460 8 details detail NOUN _005457217 460 9 — — PUNCT _005457217 460 10 and and CCONJ _005457217 460 11 they they PRON _005457217 460 12 are be AUX _005457217 460 13 perhaps perhaps ADV _005457217 460 14 not not PART _005457217 460 15 important important ADJ _005457217 460 16 — — PUNCT _005457217 460 17 in in ADP _005457217 460 18 other other ADJ _005457217 460 19 states state NOUN _005457217 460 20 . . PUNCT _005457217 461 1 ave ave PROPN _005457217 461 2 suppose suppose VERB _005457217 461 3 that that SCONJ _005457217 461 4 this this PRON _005457217 461 5 includes include VERB _005457217 461 6 systems system NOUN _005457217 461 7 where where SCONJ _005457217 461 8 the the DET _005457217 461 9 children child NOUN _005457217 461 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 461 11 as as ADP _005457217 461 12 in in ADP _005457217 461 13 new new PROPN _005457217 461 14 york york PROPN _005457217 461 15 , , PUNCT _005457217 461 16 are be AUX _005457217 461 17 released release VERB _005457217 461 18 f f PROPN _005457217 461 19 r r NOUN _005457217 461 20 o o NOUN _005457217 462 1 m m VERB _005457217 463 1 the the DET _005457217 463 2 school school NOUN _005457217 463 3 buildings building NOUN _005457217 463 4 to to PART _005457217 463 5 go go VERB _005457217 463 6 to to ADP _005457217 463 7 their their PRON _005457217 463 8 church church NOUN _005457217 463 9 buildings building NOUN _005457217 463 10 for for ADP _005457217 463 11 religious religious ADJ _005457217 463 12 instruction instruction NOUN _005457217 463 13 , , PUNCT _005457217 463 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 463 15 therefore therefore ADV _005457217 463 16 do do AUX _005457217 463 17 not not PART _005457217 463 18 present present VERB _005457217 463 19 the the DET _005457217 463 20 same same ADJ _005457217 463 21 problem problem NOUN _005457217 463 22 that that PRON _005457217 463 23 we we PRON _005457217 463 24 have have VERB _005457217 463 25 in in ADP _005457217 463 26 the the DET _005457217 463 27 case case NOUN _005457217 463 28 at at ADP _005457217 463 29 bar bar NOUN _005457217 463 30 . . PUNCT _005457217 464 1 believing believe VERB _005457217 464 2 as as SCONJ _005457217 464 3 we we PRON _005457217 464 4 do do VERB _005457217 464 5 that that PRON _005457217 464 6 no no DET _005457217 464 7 constitutional constitutional ADJ _005457217 464 8 or or CCONJ _005457217 464 9 statutory statutory ADJ _005457217 464 10 rights right NOUN _005457217 464 11 of of ADP _005457217 464 12 the the DET _005457217 464 13 relator relator NOUN _005457217 464 14 and and CCONJ _005457217 464 15 her her PRON _005457217 464 16 son son NOUN _005457217 464 17 , , PUNCT _005457217 464 18 james james PROPN _005457217 464 19 terry terry PROPN _005457217 464 20 mccollum mccollum PROPN _005457217 464 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 464 22 have have AUX _005457217 464 23 been be AUX _005457217 464 24 violated violate VERB _005457217 464 25 by by ADP _005457217 464 26 the the DET _005457217 464 27 champaign champaign NOUN _005457217 464 28 system system NOUN _005457217 464 29 of of ADP _005457217 464 30 religious religious ADJ _005457217 464 31 education education NOUN _005457217 464 32 as as SCONJ _005457217 464 33 it it PRON _005457217 464 34 is be AUX _005457217 464 35 conducted conduct VERB _005457217 464 36 , , PUNCT _005457217 464 37 according accord VERB _005457217 464 38 to to ADP _005457217 464 39 the the DET _005457217 464 40 39 39 NUM _005457217 464 41 testimony testimony NOUN _005457217 464 42 in in ADP _005457217 464 43 this this DET _005457217 464 44 record record NOUN _005457217 464 45 , , PUNCT _005457217 464 46 the the DET _005457217 464 47 petition petition NOUN _005457217 464 48 for for ADP _005457217 464 49 mandamus mandamus NOUN _005457217 464 50 will will AUX _005457217 464 51 be be AUX _005457217 464 52 denied deny VERB _005457217 464 53 . . PUNCT _005457217 465 1 the the DET _005457217 465 2 docket docket NOUN _005457217 465 3 orders order NOUN _005457217 465 4 in in ADP _005457217 465 5 this this DET _005457217 465 6 case case NOUN _005457217 465 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 465 8 therefore therefore ADV _005457217 465 9 , , PUNCT _005457217 465 10 will will AUX _005457217 465 11 be be AUX _005457217 465 12 ' ' PUNCT _005457217 465 13 : : PUNCT _005457217 465 14 evidence evidence NOUN _005457217 465 15 and and CCONJ _005457217 465 16 arguments argument NOUN _005457217 465 17 having having AUX _005457217 465 18 been be AUX _005457217 465 19 heard hear VERB _005457217 465 20 , , PUNCT _005457217 465 21 briefs brief NOUN _005457217 465 22 having having AUX _005457217 465 23 been be AUX _005457217 465 24 considered consider VERB _005457217 465 25 , , PUNCT _005457217 465 26 findings finding NOUN _005457217 465 27 of of ADP _005457217 465 28 fact fact NOUN _005457217 465 29 and and CCONJ _005457217 465 30 of of ADP _005457217 465 31 law law NOUN _005457217 465 32 as as SCONJ _005457217 465 33 set set VERB _005457217 465 34 f f PROPN _005457217 466 1 o o X _005457217 466 2 r r NOUN _005457217 466 3 t t NOUN _005457217 466 4 h h NOUN _005457217 466 5 in in ADP _005457217 466 6 written write VERB _005457217 466 7 opinion opinion NOUN _005457217 466 8 on on ADP _005457217 466 9 file file NOUN _005457217 466 10 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 466 11 and and CCONJ _005457217 466 12 finding find VERB _005457217 466 13 that that DET _005457217 466 14 petition petition NOUN _005457217 466 15 of of ADP _005457217 466 16 relator relator NOUN _005457217 466 17 for for ADP _005457217 466 18 mandamus mandamus NOUN _005457217 466 19 should should AUX _005457217 466 20 be be AUX _005457217 466 21 denied deny VERB _005457217 466 22 ; ; PUNCT _005457217 466 23 judgment judgment NOUN _005457217 466 24 in in ADP _005457217 466 25 favor favor NOUN _005457217 466 26 of of ADP _005457217 466 27 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 466 28 in in ADP _005457217 466 29 bar bar NOUN _005457217 466 30 of of ADP _005457217 466 31 the the DET _005457217 466 32 action action NOUN _005457217 466 33 and and CCONJ _005457217 466 34 petition petition NOUN _005457217 466 35 of of ADP _005457217 466 36 the the DET _005457217 466 37 relator relator NOUN _005457217 466 38 , , PUNCT _005457217 466 39 and and CCONJ _005457217 466 40 writ writ PROPN _005457217 466 41 of of ADP _005457217 466 42 mandamus mandamus PROPN _005457217 466 43 denied deny VERB _005457217 466 44 and and CCONJ _005457217 466 45 judgment judgment NOUN _005457217 466 46 for for ADP _005457217 466 47 costs cost NOUN _005457217 466 48 against against ADP _005457217 466 49 the the DET _005457217 466 50 relator relator NOUN _005457217 466 51 . . PUNCT _005457217 467 1 m m VERB _005457217 467 2 a a DET _005457217 467 3 r r NOUN _005457217 467 4 t t NOUN _005457217 467 5 i i PRON _005457217 467 6 n n X _005457217 467 7 e e PROPN _005457217 467 8 . . PUNCT _005457217 468 1 m m PROPN _005457217 468 2 o o X _005457217 468 3 r r NOUN _005457217 468 4 t t NOUN _005457217 468 5 h h X _005457217 468 6 l l NOUN _005457217 468 7 a a DET _005457217 468 8 n n PROPN _005457217 468 9 d d PROPN _005457217 468 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 468 11 grover grover PROPN _005457217 468 12 w w PROPN _005457217 468 13 . . PUNCT _005457217 469 1 w w ADP _005457217 469 2 a a DET _005457217 469 3 t t NOUN _005457217 469 4 s s NOUN _005457217 469 5 o o NOUN _005457217 469 6 n n NOUN _005457217 469 7 , , PUNCT _005457217 469 8 f f X _005457217 469 9 r r NOUN _005457217 469 10 a a DET _005457217 469 11 n n NOUN _005457217 469 12 k k NOUN _005457217 469 13 b b PROPN _005457217 469 14 . . PUNCT _005457217 470 1 l l NOUN _005457217 470 2 e e PROPN _005457217 470 3 o o PROPN _005457217 470 4 n n ADP _005457217 470 5 a a DET _005457217 470 6 r r NOUN _005457217 470 7 d d NOUN _005457217 470 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 470 9 trial trial NOUN _005457217 470 10 judges judge NOUN _005457217 470 11 . . PUNCT _005457217 471 1 attorneys attorney NOUN _005457217 471 2 for for ADP _005457217 471 3 defendant defendant NOUN _005457217 471 4 and and CCONJ _005457217 471 5 inteuvenors inteuvenor NOUN _005457217 471 6 : : PUNCT _005457217 471 7 j j NOUN _005457217 471 8 o o PROPN _005457217 471 9 h h PROPN _005457217 471 10 n n PROPN _005457217 471 11 l l NOUN _005457217 471 12 . . PUNCT _005457217 472 1 f f X _005457217 473 1 r r NOUN _005457217 473 2 a a PRON _005457217 473 3 n n NOUN _005457217 473 4 k k PROPN _005457217 473 5 l l PROPN _005457217 474 1 i i PRON _005457217 474 2 n n PROPN _005457217 474 3 , , PUNCT _005457217 474 4 f f X _005457217 475 1 i i PRON _005457217 475 2 r r VERB _005457217 475 3 s s PROPN _005457217 475 4 t t NOUN _005457217 475 5 national national PROPN _005457217 475 6 bank bank PROPN _005457217 475 7 building building NOUN _005457217 475 8 , , PUNCT _005457217 475 9 champaign champaign NOUN _005457217 475 10 , , PUNCT _005457217 475 11 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 475 12 . . PUNCT _005457217 476 1 e e PROPN _005457217 476 2 c c X _005457217 476 3 k k PROPN _005457217 476 4 e e PROPN _005457217 476 5 r r NOUN _005457217 476 6 t t PROPN _005457217 476 7 & & CCONJ _005457217 476 8 p p PROPN _005457217 476 9 e e PROPN _005457217 476 10 t t PROPN _005457217 476 11 e e NOUN _005457217 476 12 r r NOUN _005457217 476 13 s s X _005457217 476 14 o o NOUN _005457217 476 15 n n NOUN _005457217 476 16 , , PUNCT _005457217 476 17 ( ( PUNCT _005457217 476 18 abe abe PROPN _005457217 476 19 r. r. PROPN _005457217 476 20 peterson peterson PROPN _005457217 476 21 , , PUNCT _005457217 476 22 owen owen PROPN _005457217 476 23 ball ball PROPN _005457217 476 24 and and CCONJ _005457217 476 25 burnham burnham PROPN _005457217 476 26 m. m. PROPN _005457217 476 27 f'isk f'isk PROPN _005457217 476 28 , , PUNCT _005457217 476 29 of of ADP _005457217 476 30 counsel counsel NOUN _005457217 476 31 ) ) PUNCT _005457217 476 32 , , PUNCT _005457217 476 33 135 135 NUM _005457217 476 34 south south ADJ _005457217 476 35 lasalle lasalle PROPN _005457217 476 36 street street PROPN _005457217 476 37 , , PUNCT _005457217 476 38 chicago chicago PROPN _005457217 476 39 3 3 NUM _005457217 476 40 , , PUNCT _005457217 476 41 illinois illinois PROPN _005457217 476 42 . . PUNCT