id sid tid token lemma pos 8p58pc30b9x 1 1 in in ADP 8p58pc30b9x 1 2 this this DET 8p58pc30b9x 1 3 dissertation dissertation NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 1 4 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 1 5 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 1 6 examine examine VERB 8p58pc30b9x 1 7 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 1 8 implications implication NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 1 9 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 1 10 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 1 11 problem problem NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 1 12 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 1 13 mental mental ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 1 14 causation causation NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 1 15 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 1 16 what what PRON 8p58pc30b9x 1 17 david david PROPN 8p58pc30b9x 1 18 chalmers chalmer NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 1 19 has have AUX 8p58pc30b9x 1 20 dubbed dub VERB 8p58pc30b9x 1 21 the the PRON 8p58pc30b9x 1 22 & & CCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 1 23 quot quot PROPN 8p58pc30b9x 1 24 ; ; PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 1 25 hard hard ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 1 26 problem problem NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 1 27 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 1 28 consciousness" consciousness" SPACE 8p58pc30b9x 1 29 ; ; PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 1 30 for for ADP 8p58pc30b9x 1 31 competing compete VERB 8p58pc30b9x 1 32 accounts account NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 1 33 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 1 34 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 1 35 mind mind NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 1 36 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 2 1 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 2 2 begin begin VERB 8p58pc30b9x 2 3 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 2 4 in in ADP 8p58pc30b9x 2 5 chapter chapter NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 2 6 one one NUM 8p58pc30b9x 2 7 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 2 8 with with ADP 8p58pc30b9x 2 9 a a DET 8p58pc30b9x 2 10 critical critical ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 2 11 analysis analysis NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 2 12 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 2 13 jaegwon jaegwon PROPN 8p58pc30b9x 2 14 kim kim PROPN 8p58pc30b9x 2 15 's 's PART 8p58pc30b9x 2 16 physicalism physicalism NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 2 17 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 2 18 or or CCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 2 19 something something PRON 8p58pc30b9x 2 20 near near ADP 8p58pc30b9x 2 21 enough enough ADV 8p58pc30b9x 2 22 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 3 1 ( ( PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 3 2 2005 2005 NUM 8p58pc30b9x 3 3 ) ) PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 3 4 there there ADV 8p58pc30b9x 3 5 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 3 6 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 3 7 maintain maintain VERB 8p58pc30b9x 3 8 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 3 9 kim kim PROPN 8p58pc30b9x 3 10 's 's PART 8p58pc30b9x 3 11 ontology ontology NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 3 12 can can AUX 8p58pc30b9x 3 13 not not PART 8p58pc30b9x 3 14 adequately adequately ADV 8p58pc30b9x 3 15 address address VERB 8p58pc30b9x 3 16 both both CCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 3 17 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 3 18 problem problem NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 3 19 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 3 20 mental mental ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 3 21 causation causation NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 3 22 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 3 23 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 3 24 & & CCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 3 25 quot quot PROPN 8p58pc30b9x 3 26 ; ; PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 3 27 hard hard ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 3 28 problem problem NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 3 29 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 3 30 consciousness." consciousness." PROPN 8p58pc30b9x 3 31 ; ; PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 3 32 in in ADP 8p58pc30b9x 3 33 chapter chapter NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 3 34 two two NUM 8p58pc30b9x 3 35 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 3 36 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 3 37 examine examine VERB 8p58pc30b9x 3 38 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 3 39 causal causal NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 3 40 pairing pairing NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 3 41 problem problem NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 3 42 for for ADP 8p58pc30b9x 3 43 substance substance NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 3 44 dualism dualism NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 3 45 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 4 1 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 4 2 demonstrate demonstrate VERB 8p58pc30b9x 4 3 both both PRON 8p58pc30b9x 4 4 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 4 5 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 4 6 substance substance NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 4 7 dualist dualist NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 4 8 can can AUX 8p58pc30b9x 4 9 respond respond VERB 8p58pc30b9x 4 10 to to ADP 8p58pc30b9x 4 11 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 4 12 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 4 13 at at ADP 8p58pc30b9x 4 14 no no DET 8p58pc30b9x 4 15 great great ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 4 16 cost cost NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 4 17 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 4 18 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 4 19 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 4 20 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 4 21 pairing pair VERB 8p58pc30b9x 4 22 problem problem NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 4 23 applies apply VERB 8p58pc30b9x 4 24 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 4 25 with with ADP 8p58pc30b9x 4 26 equal equal ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 4 27 force force NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 4 28 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 4 29 to to ADP 8p58pc30b9x 4 30 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 4 31 irreducible irreducible ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 4 32 qualia qualia NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 4 33 posited posit VERB 8p58pc30b9x 4 34 on on ADP 8p58pc30b9x 4 35 kim kim PROPN 8p58pc30b9x 4 36 's 's PART 8p58pc30b9x 4 37 account account NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 4 38 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 5 1 chapters chapter NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 5 2 three three NUM 8p58pc30b9x 5 3 and and CCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 5 4 four four NUM 8p58pc30b9x 5 5 are be AUX 8p58pc30b9x 5 6 devoted devoted ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 5 7 to to ADP 8p58pc30b9x 5 8 what what PRON 8p58pc30b9x 5 9 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 5 10 take take VERB 8p58pc30b9x 5 11 to to PART 8p58pc30b9x 5 12 be be AUX 8p58pc30b9x 5 13 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 5 14 central central ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 5 15 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 5 16 against against ADP 8p58pc30b9x 5 17 any any DET 8p58pc30b9x 5 18 kind kind NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 5 19 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 5 20 dualism dualism NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 5 21 : : PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 5 22 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 5 23 causal causal ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 5 24 exclusion exclusion NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 5 25 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 5 26 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 6 1 in in ADP 8p58pc30b9x 6 2 chapter chapter NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 6 3 three three NUM 8p58pc30b9x 6 4 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 6 5 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 6 6 examine examine VERB 8p58pc30b9x 6 7 dualistic dualistic ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 6 8 responses response NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 6 9 to to ADP 8p58pc30b9x 6 10 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 6 11 exclusion exclusion NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 6 12 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 6 13 that that PRON 8p58pc30b9x 6 14 grant grant VERB 8p58pc30b9x 6 15 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 6 16 causal causal NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 6 17 closure closure NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 6 18 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 6 19 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 6 20 physical physical ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 6 21 world world NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 6 22 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 7 1 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 7 2 note note VERB 8p58pc30b9x 7 3 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 7 4 these these DET 8p58pc30b9x 7 5 responses response NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 7 6 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 7 7 though though SCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 7 8 technically technically ADV 8p58pc30b9x 7 9 adequate adequate ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 7 10 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 7 11 are be AUX 8p58pc30b9x 7 12 nevertheless nevertheless ADV 8p58pc30b9x 7 13 theoretically theoretically ADV 8p58pc30b9x 7 14 unpalatable unpalatable ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 7 15 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 8 1 in in ADP 8p58pc30b9x 8 2 addition addition NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 8 3 to to ADP 8p58pc30b9x 8 4 requiring require VERB 8p58pc30b9x 8 5 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 8 6 dualist dualist NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 8 7 to to PART 8p58pc30b9x 8 8 adopt adopt VERB 8p58pc30b9x 8 9 unconventional unconventional ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 8 10 attitudes attitude NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 8 11 towards towards ADP 8p58pc30b9x 8 12 causation causation NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 8 13 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 8 14 responses response NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 8 15 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 8 16 this this DET 8p58pc30b9x 8 17 variety variety NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 8 18 also also ADV 8p58pc30b9x 8 19 have have VERB 8p58pc30b9x 8 20 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 8 21 unfortunate unfortunate ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 8 22 result result NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 8 23 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 8 24 rendering render VERB 8p58pc30b9x 8 25 libertarian libertarian ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 8 26 freedom freedom NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 8 27 impossible impossible ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 8 28 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 9 1 finally finally ADV 8p58pc30b9x 9 2 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 9 3 in in ADP 8p58pc30b9x 9 4 chapter chapter NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 9 5 four four NUM 8p58pc30b9x 9 6 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 9 7 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 9 8 turn turn VERB 8p58pc30b9x 9 9 my my PRON 8p58pc30b9x 9 10 attention attention NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 9 11 to to ADP 8p58pc30b9x 9 12 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 9 13 question question NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 9 14 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 9 15 causal causal ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 9 16 closure closure NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 9 17 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 10 1 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 10 2 maintain maintain VERB 8p58pc30b9x 10 3 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 10 4 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 10 5 causal causal ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 10 6 closure closure NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 10 7 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 10 8 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 10 9 physical physical ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 10 10 world world NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 10 11 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 10 12 though though SCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 10 13 widely widely ADV 8p58pc30b9x 10 14 affirmed affirm VERB 8p58pc30b9x 10 15 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 10 16 is be AUX 8p58pc30b9x 10 17 nevertheless nevertheless ADV 8p58pc30b9x 10 18 extraordinarily extraordinarily ADV 8p58pc30b9x 10 19 difficult difficult ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 10 20 to to PART 8p58pc30b9x 10 21 support support VERB 8p58pc30b9x 10 22 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 11 1 in in ADP 8p58pc30b9x 11 2 light light NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 11 3 of of ADP 8p58pc30b9x 11 4 hempel hempel PROPN 8p58pc30b9x 11 5 's 's PART 8p58pc30b9x 11 6 dilemma dilemma NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 11 7 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 11 8 causal causal ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 11 9 closure closure NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 11 10 is be AUX 8p58pc30b9x 11 11 either either CCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 11 12 false false ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 11 13 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 11 14 compatible compatible ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 11 15 with with ADP 8p58pc30b9x 11 16 dualistic dualistic ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 11 17 interaction interaction NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 11 18 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 11 19 or or CCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 11 20 unacceptably unacceptably ADV 8p58pc30b9x 11 21 stipulative stipulative ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 11 22 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 12 1 there there PRON 8p58pc30b9x 12 2 is be VERB 8p58pc30b9x 12 3 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 12 4 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 12 5 maintain maintain VERB 8p58pc30b9x 12 6 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 12 7 no no PRON 8p58pc30b9x 12 8 causal causal NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 12 9 closure closure NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 12 10 principle principle NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 12 11 up up ADP 8p58pc30b9x 12 12 to to ADP 8p58pc30b9x 12 13 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 12 14 tasks task NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 12 15 required require VERB 8p58pc30b9x 12 16 by by ADP 8p58pc30b9x 12 17 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 12 18 causal causal ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 12 19 exclusion exclusion NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 12 20 argument argument NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 12 21 . . PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 13 1 for for ADP 8p58pc30b9x 13 2 that that DET 8p58pc30b9x 13 3 reason reason NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 13 4 , , PUNCT 8p58pc30b9x 13 5 i i PRON 8p58pc30b9x 13 6 conclude conclude VERB 8p58pc30b9x 13 7 that that SCONJ 8p58pc30b9x 13 8 the the DET 8p58pc30b9x 13 9 dualist dualist NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 13 10 ought ought AUX 8p58pc30b9x 13 11 not not PART 8p58pc30b9x 13 12 to to PART 8p58pc30b9x 13 13 worry worry VERB 8p58pc30b9x 13 14 about about ADP 8p58pc30b9x 13 15 causal causal ADJ 8p58pc30b9x 13 16 closure closure NOUN 8p58pc30b9x 13 17 . . PUNCT