Signing Mike Trout: The most expensive contract in sports history is a bargain, expert says | News | Notre Dame News | University of Notre Dame






	
	





  	Skip To Content
	Skip To Navigation
	Skip To Search






  
  
    University of Notre Dame

    
      
      Notre Dame News

      
      
    


    
    
      
        
        
        	
	Experts
	ND in the News
	Subscribe
	About Us
	


      
        
          
          
          
          
          
        

      


      
    


    
    
      	 Home
	 Contact
	 Search
	
          
          
            
            
          
          Menu
        
        


      
        
          
          
          
          
          
        

      

    

  

  
  

  

  
    	Home › 
	News › 
	Signing Mike Trout: The most expensive contract in sports history is a bargain, expert says


    
      
        
          Signing Mike Trout: The most expensive contract in sports history is a bargain, expert says

          
            
              
                
                Published: March 20, 2019
              

              
                Author: Shannon  Roddel
              

              







          

          
          
          

          
        
        
        
            
              
              Mike Trout. Photo by Keith Allison.
            
          Los Angeles Angels star outfielder Mike Trout is finalizing a 12-year contract extension said to be worth a record $426.5 million. The deal would be the most expensive in Major League Baseball history, the biggest in all of sports and would net Trout $36 million per year — an apparent bargain for the Angels, according to one University of Notre Dame sports economist.

 

How can one player be worth that much to a franchise?

 

Richard Sheehan

It’s simple math, says Richard Sheehan, finance professor in Notre Dame’s Mendoza College of Business and author of “Keeping Score: The Economics of Big-Time Sports.” It’s all about how much revenue Trout generates for the franchise.

 

“We can’t measure that directly, but we can measure it indirectly by looking at the market for free agents,” Sheehan says. “Look at players who had signed a free agent contract before the 2018 season and analyze how their production lined up with their performance. The best single measure of performance is wins above replacement (WAR), or how many additional wins a player contributed to his team’s performance above that of a replacement player. 

 

“Taking the sum of position player free agents’ annual salaries and dividing that by the sum of their WAR, the ratio is $4.6 million. In other words, owners on average paid position player free agents $4.6 million for each additional win they contributed. The implication is that if you were expected to generate one additional win you would expect a $4.6 million salary; two additional wins would equal $9.2 million; five more wins would bring a $23 million payday.” 

 

Trout has played 7 full years and has averaged a WAR of 9.2 — which, multiplied by $4.6 million, yields $42.3 million. Continued over 12 years, the value would be $508 million.

 

“Mike Trout is a bargain,” says Sheehan, though he notes the calculation should also take into account how long Trout can perform at his current level.

 

“If he remains healthy, his peak years are likely ahead of him,” Sheehan says.  “Historically, MLB position players with his skill set retain their performance through their early 30s. His contract will expire when he is 38. So, take his $430 million divided by 12 years and divided by $4.6 million per WAR. The answer is 7.8, meaning as long as he produces that average over the life of the contract, it’s a smart signing for the Angels.”  

 

Trout has had only one season with a WAR below that value and in that season he was battling an injury. Sheehan says the Angels are likely expecting he will produce a WAR near 10 for the next seven years, until he’s 33. To reach the break-even point, he would need to average about 4.5 for the last five years of the contract, which is possible if you consider former outfield superstars. 

 

“Mickey Mantle retired at 36 and had a WAR of ‘only’ 3.6 in his last three years playing,” Sheehan points out. “In contrast, Ted Williams and Hank Aaron both averaged 6.8 from age 33 to 38. It’s not only possible, but probable that Trout can produce at similar values, if he can avoid injuries.”

 

Sheehan’s numbers are based on his calculations of the ratio of salary relative to WAR for 2018. What will that look like in five or 10 years, when that ratio has increased dramatically over the past eight? If that trend continues, Sheehan says signing Trout will look like a superb deal for the Angels. They are paying less than the market value of his expected wins, and that gap is likely to continue to increase. 

 

“My calculations are based solely on expected wins and salary,” he says. “Other factors such as player attitude, leadership and star power do impact decisions, but if Trout’s reputation is accurate, it will only increase his value to the franchise.”

 

Contact: Richard Sheehan, 574-631-5212, rsheehan@nd.edu

        

        
        
          
            
              Posted In:

              	University News


            

            

          

        
      
      
    
  
  
    	Home
	Experts
	ND in the News
	Subscribe
	About Us


  

  
  
    
      
      
      
        
          Related

          
            

    
        
    

  
    
      

      

      




October 03, 2022

    
    
      Congresswoman Liz Cheney to speak at Notre Dame on the future of democracy
    

  


    
        
    

  
    
      

      

      


September 22, 2022

    
    
      In memoriam: Rev. Richard Warner, C.S.C., longtime leader for Notre Dame, Congregation of Holy Cross
    

  


    
        
    

  
    
      

      

      


September 22, 2022

    
    
      ND Forum keynote event to feature Emmy Award-winning actors in Theater of War Productions’ presentation of ‘The Suppliants’ in Notre Dame Stadium
    

  


    
        
    

  
    
      

      

      


September 21, 2022

    
    
      In annual address to faculty, Father Jenkins outlines campus-wide vision for elevating excellence
    

  


    
        
    

  
    
      

      

      


September 15, 2022

    
    
      Lilly Endowment Inc. grant helps to expand Notre Dame pre-college programs for Hoosier high school students
    

  

          
        
    
     
  
  

  
  
    
      	For the Media
	Contact


    
            
    
      
	Office of Public Affairs and Communications


      Notre Dame News

      
        
          
            500 Grace Hall
 
            Notre Dame, IN 46556 USA
          
          
          
          
        

        
          	 Facebook
	 Twitter
	 Instagram
	 YouTube
	 Pinterest


        
      

      
© 2022 University of Notre Dame

    
    
      

        
      
      
        
          	Search
	Mobile App
	News
	Events
	Visit
	Accessibility


        
        
          	 Facebook
	 Twitter
	 Instagram
	 YouTube
	 LinkedIn