key: cord-0004886-qcmsmfad authors: Yoshikawa, Rokusuke; Shimode, Sayumi; Sakaguchi, Shoichi; Miyazawa, Takayuki title: Contamination of live attenuated vaccines with an infectious feline endogenous retrovirus (RD-114 virus) date: 2013-09-26 journal: Arch Virol DOI: 10.1007/s00705-013-1809-1 sha: 1c044167282ced278033dd4904a154a1ce0ce956 doc_id: 4886 cord_uid: qcmsmfad Retroviruses are classified as exogenous and endogenous retroviruses according to the mode of transmission. Endogenous retroviruses (ERVs) are retroviruses which have been integrated into germ-line cells and inherited from parents to offspring. Most ERVs are inactivated by deletions and mutations; however, certain ERVs maintain their infectivity and infect the same host and new hosts as exogenous retroviruses. All domestic cats have infectious ERVs, termed RD-114 virus. Several canine and feline attenuated vaccines are manufactured using RD-114 virus-producing cell lines such as Crandell-Rees feline kidney cells; therefore, it is possible that infectious RD-114 virus contaminates live attenuated vaccines. Recently, Japanese and UK research groups found that several feline and canine vaccines were indeed contaminated with infectious RD-114 virus. This was the first incidence of contamination of ‘infectious’ ERVs in live attenuated vaccines. RD-114 virus replicates efficiently in canine cell lines and primary cells. Therefore, it is possible that RD-114 virus infects dogs following inoculation with contaminated vaccines and induces proliferative diseases and immune suppression, if it adapts to grow efficiently in dogs. In this review, we summarize the incidence of contamination of RD-114 virus in live attenuated vaccines and potential risks of infection with RD-114 virus in dogs. ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s00705-013-1809-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. Abstract Retroviruses are classified as exogenous and endogenous retroviruses according to the mode of transmission. Endogenous retroviruses (ERVs) are retroviruses which have been integrated into germ-line cells and inherited from parents to offspring. Most ERVs are inactivated by deletions and mutations; however, certain ERVs maintain their infectivity and infect the same host and new hosts as exogenous retroviruses. All domestic cats have infectious ERVs, termed RD-114 virus. Several canine and feline attenuated vaccines are manufactured using RD-114 virus-producing cell lines such as Crandell-Rees feline kidney cells; therefore, it is possible that infectious RD-114 virus contaminates live attenuated vaccines. Recently, Japanese and UK research groups found that several feline and canine vaccines were indeed contaminated with infectious RD-114 virus. This was the first incidence of contamination of 'infectious' ERVs in live attenuated vaccines. RD-114 virus replicates efficiently in canine cell lines and primary cells. Therefore, it is possible that RD-114 virus infects dogs following inoculation with contaminated vaccines and induces proliferative diseases and immune suppression, if it adapts to grow efficiently in dogs. In this review, we summarize the incidence of contamination of RD-114 virus in live attenuated vaccines and potential risks of infection with RD-114 virus in dogs. Retroviruses enter host cells via binding of the envelope proteins with the host receptor(s). After entering the cells, viral RNA is reverse-transcribed into DNA and then the DNA is integrated into the host genome to be a provirus. Viral RNA is transcribed from the provirus and the structural and enzymatic proteins of the virus are synthesized from the transcribed viral RNA. Retroviruses are classified as exogenous and endogenous retroviruses according to the mode of transmission [14] . Usually, exogenous retroviruses infect somatic cells but not germ-line cells, and they are transmitted horizontally by infection via viral particles. On the other hand, ERVs are retroviruses which have been integrated into germ-line cells. ERVs behave like normal genes and are inherited from parents to offspring as Mendelian's law. ERVs occupy about 10 % of mammalian genomes and are mostly inactivated by deletions and mutations [14, 15, 17, 27] . However, a limited number of ERVs maintain their infectivity and infect new hosts as exogenous retroviruses [6] . Exogenous retroviruses are classified into seven genera, i.e., alpharetrovirus, betaretrovirus, gammaretrovirus, deltaretrovirus, epsilonretrovirus, spumaretrovirus and lentivirus. ERVs are divided into at least three classes I, II and III [14] . Class I ERV is closely related to exogenous counterparts of gammaretrovirus and epsilonretrovirus. Class II and III ERVs are similar to alpharetrovirus and betaretrovirus, and spumavirus, respectively. All domestic cats have an infectious ERV, termed RD-114 virus [4, 12, 32] . RD-114 viral genomes have not been detected in large felids, such as lions and pumas [4] . RD-114 virus is closely related to baboon endogenous retrovirus (BaEV) in env region, but is distantly related to BaEV in gag-pol region, and is considered to be a recombinant virus between a feline ERV, termed FcEV, in gag-pol region and BaEV in env region [47] . BaEV is also a recombinant virus between a Papio cynocephalus ERV, termed PcEV, and a simian type D virus [19] . The gag-pol regions of both RD-114 virus and BaEV are closely related to gammaretroviruses (class I ERV), and the env region is closely related to betaretroviruses (class II ERV). Generally, ERVs do not induce diseases in the original hosts. However, there are several incidences where ERVs exhibit pathogenicity; for example, ERVs of AKR mice induce lymphoma in the host [31] . Recently, it was found that replication activity of mouse ERVs was resurrected in Rag -/deficient mice, which had no mature B-and Tlymphocytes, and in mice deficient in Toll-like receptors 3, 7 and 9 (TLR3, TLR7 and TLR9) triple deficient mice (TLR3 -/-, TLR7 -/-, TLR9 -/deficient mice) [52, 53] . In addition, activated ERVs in TLR3 -/-, TLR7 -/-, TLR9 -/deficient mice induced lymphoma in the host [53] . These reports suggest that infectious ERVs can exhibit oncogenicity in the host. Moreover, certain ERVs infect a new host and exhibit pathogenicity; for example, gibbon ape leukemia virus (GALV) that induces lymphoma in gibbons is considered to originate from an ERV of Asian rodents (Mus caroli, Mus cervicolor and Vandeleuria oleracea) [3, 18] . Recently, it was reported that an endogenous koala retrovirus (KoRV) is biologically active and may be associated with neoplastic diseases and immune suppression in koalas [39, [41] [42] [43] . The origin of KoRV is still unknown at present, although partial retroviral sequences closely related to KoRV and GaLV were found in an Australian rodent (http://espace.library.uq.edu.au/view/ UQ:244963) and a bat (Megaderma lyra) [9] . Intriguingly, KoRV could transmit to rats by experimental infection and induced fibrosarcoma [10, 11] . Mice, pigs, cats, and chickens have infectious ERVs [6, 34] . In previous studies, it was reported that MMR vaccines (measles, mumps and rubella vaccines) and yellow fever vaccines that were propagated in chicken embryos were contaminated with endogenous avian leukosis viruses (ALVs) and endogenous avian retroviruses (EAVs), which originate from chicken embryonic fibroblast substrates [16, 45] . It is unknown whether contaminated endogenous ALV and EAV are infectious ERVs, because these studies only detected the viral RNA, proteins and reverse transcriptase (RT) activities in vaccines using RT-polymerase chain reaction (PCR), immunoblotting and the RT assay, respectively (16, 45) . Nevertheless, no evidence was found that these ERVs had infected humans by vaccination [16, 45] . Many live attenuated vaccines for animals are manufactured using feline cell lines which may produce infectious RD-114 virus (Table 1 ). Therefore, it is possible that infectious RD-114 virus contaminates these vaccines [24] . We developed RT-PCR and realtime RT-PCR to detect RD-114 viral RNA and the LacZ marker rescue assay to detect infectious RD-114 virus in vaccines [37, 49] . When we examined feline live attenuated vaccines purchased in Japan (Vaccines F/g1, F/h2 and F/d3) for the presence of infectious RD-114 virus by the LacZ marker rescue assay, a vaccine manufactured by one company (Vaccine F/g1) was contaminated with infectious RD-114 virus (Table 2 ) [25] . The Japanese regulatory authority, National Veterinary Assay Laboratory (NVAL), also confirmed this finding independently [30] . In addition, we also confirmed that three products of 'canine' live attenuated vaccines purchased in Japan (Vaccines C/a1, C/a2 and C/b3), manufactured using 'feline' cell lines, were contaminated with infectious RD-114 virus ( Table 2 ) [25] . The titers of RD-114 viruses in the contaminated vaccines were 1,800, 1,000 and 1.8 50 % tissue culture infective dose (TCID 50 )/dose, respectively ( Table 2 ). Copy numbers of RD-114 viral RNA were also estimated by real-time RT-PCR. We found that 4.5910 7 , 9.7910 7 and 8.3910 6 copy number/dose of RD-114 viral RNAs were present in Vaccines C/a1, C/a2 and C/b3, respectively (Table 2) (unpublished data). Another research group in the University of Glasgow also confirmed that feline and canine live attenuated vaccines purchased in the United Kingdom were contaminated with infectious RD-114 virus using immunoblot analysis and RT assay [25] . In addition, we found that two canine live attenuated vaccines (Vaccines C/f8 and C/f9) produced using 'non-feline' cell lines (Table 1) were contaminated with infectious RD-114 virus ( Table 2 ) [49] . The infectious titers of RD-114 virus in contaminated vaccines were 180 and 10,000 TCID 50 /dose, respectively and the copy numbers of RD-114 viral RNAs were 2.1910 8 and 5.0910 8 copies/dose respectively (Table 2 ) [49] . The NVAL also confirmed these findings independently [29] . [2, 7, 33, 38, 48] . Therefore, if the vaccine strains of feline and canine viruses are propagated in RD-114 virus-producing feline cell lines, RD-114 virus contaminates live attenuated vaccines (Fig. 1) . Moreover, RD-114 virus infects and proliferates efficiently in human, canine and mink cell lines [2, 36, 49, 51] . Therefore, when seed stock viruses are contaminated with infectious RD-114 virus and the vaccines are produced using RD-114 virus-permissive cell lines, RD-114 virus may contaminate live attenuated vaccines, irrespective of the species origin of the cell lines (Fig. 1) . Actually, as mentioned above, two canine live attenuated vaccines (Vaccines C/f8 and C/f9) produced using 'non-feline' cell lines were contaminated with infectious RD-114 virus ( Table 2 ) [49] . These vaccines contained an attenuated canine parvovirus type 2 (CPV-2) ( Table 1 ) and many CPV-2s have been attenuated using CRFK cells [26] . When we examined CPV-2 stock viruses in an assay laboratory of a Japanese vaccine company for the presence of infectious RD-114 virus, seven out of eighteen CPV-2 vaccine stocks were contaminated with infectious RD-114 virus [50] . Potential risks of infection with RD-114 virus in dogs RD-114 virus efficiently infects canine cell lines and primary cells [36, 51] . It is important to identify viral receptor(s) in predicting viral tropisms and pathogenicity. In human cell lines, it is found that the receptor for RD-114 virus is a sodium-dependent neutral amino acid transporter, termed ASCT [35, 40] . Humans have two types of ASCT molecules, termed ASCT1 and ASCT2 [1, 46] . The homology between ASCT1 and ASCT2 is about 57 % [1, 46] . Both human ASCT1 and ASCT2 function as RD-114 receptor, but the virus utilizes ASCT2 more efficiently than ASCT1 [20] . In humans, ASCT1 is ubiquitously expressed in tissues [1] , whereas the expression of ASCT2 is limited in various tissues, and the expression level of ASCT2 also varies among tissues [13, 46] . Recently, we identified canine ASCT1 and ASCT2 as RD-114 virus receptors [50] . RD-114 may infect a variety of tissues in dogs, although the distribution of ASCT1 and ASCT2 in dogs is unknown at present. Actually, in a previous study, X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency was corrected in dogs by intravenous injection of concentrated RD-114-pseudtyped retrovirus vector encoding the interleukin-2 receptor c chain [44] . These data indicate that RD-114 virus can infect bone marrow cells in dogs. However, Narushima and coworkers [28] at NVAL reported that RD-114 proviral DNA was not found in dogs inoculated with RD-114 virus subcutaneously. Unfortunately, they only investigated RD-114 provirus in quite limited tissues (lymph nodes, spleen and bone marrow) and peripheral blood, and the sensitivity of the one-step PCR to detect RD-114 proviral DNA was obscure. Recently, we also investigated whether RD-114 virus infects dogs by experimental infection. When four dogs were inoculated with high titer of RD-114 virus, RD-114 proviral DNA was detected in blood cells, mesenteric lymph nodes, spleens and testes (Yoshikawa et al., unpublished) . In addition, anti-RD-114 antibodies and neutralizing antibodies were detected in the inoculated dogs (Yoshikawa et al., unpublished) . In human cells, human ASCT2 is a functional receptor for pathogenic retroviruses, such as simian retrovirus (SRV) 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5, avian reticuloendotheriosis virus, and duck spleen necrosis virus [35] . It is known that SRV-1, SRV-2 and SRV-3 induce a fatal immunodeficiency in some macaque species (Celebes and rhesus macaques) [21] [22] [23] . In a previous study, we confirmed that both SRV-2 and SRV-3 can utilize canine ASCT2 as a receptor ( [51] , unpublished data). Intriguingly, RD-114 virus has an immunosuppressive domain in transmembrane envelope protein and the amino acid sequence (LQNRRGLDLLTAEQGGI) of the domain is identical with that of SRV-3 [5, 8] . Therefore, RD-114 virus may induce immunosuppression as well as proliferative diseases such as leukemia/lymphoma, if it adapts to replicate efficiently in dogs. Japanese and UK research groups and the NVAL confirmed that several feline and canine vaccines were Non-feline cells Stock Virus (RD-114 producer) Fig. 1 Possible contamination routes of infectious RD-114 virus in live attenuated vaccines. Infectious RD-114 virus may contaminate vaccines manufactured using RD-114 virus-producing cells. Several canine parvoviruses are isolated and attenuated using CRFK cells producing infectious RD-114 virus. Therefore, infectious RD-114 virus may contaminate canine live attenuated vaccines produced using 'non-feline' cell lines when seed stock viruses were contaminated with infectious RD-114 virus contaminated with infectious RD-114 virus. This was the first incidence of contamination of 'infectious' ERVs in live attenuated vaccines. Quite importantly, RD-114 virus grew efficiently in cells of dogs which are vaccinees. In future studies, it is necessary to examine the expression profiles of canine ASCT1 and ASCT2 in dogs and determine the principal target of RD-114 virus by experimental infection with high doses of RD-114 virus. Because RD-114 virus does not have any oncogenes, RD-114 virus does not induce acute/subacute proliferative diseases such as fibrosarcoma in dogs. Therefore, after experimental infection of dogs with RD-114 virus, it is necessary to monitor infected dogs for a long period. Even if RD-114 virus does not proliferate in dogs after experimental infection, we cannot dismiss the risk of infection with RD-114 virus in dogs completely. Canine attenuated vaccines are inoculated in several million dogs per year around the world, and RD-114 virus may mutate and acquire more infectivity/ productivity in dogs. Therefore, although the risks posed by RD-114 virus are still unclear at present, it is desirable to develop the means to produce RD-114 virus-free vaccines and exclude RD-114 virus-contaminated vaccines. Cloning and expression of a human neutral amino acid transporter with structural similarity to the glutamate transporter gene family CrFK feline kidney cells produce an RD114-like endogenous virus that can package murine leukemia virus-based vectors Two distinct endogenous type C viruses isolated from the Asian rodent Mus cervicolor: conservation of virogene sequences in related rodent species Evolution of C-type viral genes: inheritance of exogenously acquired viral genes The envelope of Mason-Pfizer monkey virus has immunosuppressive properties Retrotransposons, endogenous retroviruses, and the evolution of retroelements A feline large granular lymphoma and its derived cell line Inhibition of lymphocyte proliferation by a synthetic peptide homologous to retroviral envelope proteins Identification of diverse groups of endogenous gammaretroviruses in mega-and microbats Transspecies transmissions of retroviruses: new cases Transspecies transmission of the endogenous koala retrovirus Isolation of RD-114-like oncornavirus from a cat cell line Biodistribution of the RD114/mammalian type D retrovirus receptor, RDR The evolution, distribution and diversity of endogenous retroviruses Endogenous retroviruses and the human genome sequence Identification and characterization of avian retroviruses in chicken embryo-derived yellow fever vaccines: investigation of transmission to vaccine recipients Isolation from the asian mouse Mus caroli of an endogenous type C virus related to infectious primate type C viruses Novel endogenous type C retrovirus in baboons: complete sequence, providing evidence for baboon endogenous virus gag-pol ancestry N-linked glycosylation and sequence changes in a critical negative control region of the ASCT1 and ASCT2 neutral amino acid transporters determine their retroviral receptor functions Isolation of a new serotype of simian acquired immune deficiency syndrome type D retrovirus from Celebes black macaques (Macaca nigra) with immune deficiency and retroperitoneal fibromatosis Simian AIDS: isolation of a type D retrovirus and transmission of the disease Prevention of simian acquired immune deficiency syndrome with a formalininactivated type D retrovirus vaccine Endogenous retroviruses as potential hazards for vaccines Isolation of an infectious endogenous Contamination of Live attenuated vaccines 403 retrovirus in a proportion of live attenuated vaccines for pets Comparison of polymerase chain reaction with virus isolation and haemagglutination assays for the detection of canine parvoviruses in faecal specimens Initial sequencing and comparative analysis of the mouse genome Experimental infection of dogs with a feline endogenous retrovirus RD-114 Development of a real-time reverse-transcription-PCR method for detection of RD114 virus in canine vaccines Detection of infectious RD114 virus in feline live multivalent vaccines and provisional safety evaluation in cats Oncogenicity of AKR endogenous leukemia viruses RD 114 virus-specific sequences in feline cellular RNA: detection and characterization Susceptibility and production of a feline endogenous retrovirus (RD-114 virus) in various feline cell lines Infection of human cells by an endogenous retrovirus of pigs The RD114/simian type D retrovirus receptor is a neutral amino acid transporter Basolateral maturation of retroviruses in polarized epithelial cells Establishment of a LacZ marker rescue assay to detect infectious RD114 virus Sequence comparison of three infectious molecular clones of RD-114 virus Prevalence of koala retrovirus in geographically diverse populations in Australia A sodium-dependent neutral-amino-acid transporter mediates infections of feline and baboon endogenous retroviruses and simian type D retroviruses Retroviral invasion of the koala genome Real-time reverse transcriptase PCR for the endogenous koala retrovirus reveals an association between plasma viral load and neoplastic disease in koalas Biology and evolution of the endogenous koala retrovirus Correction of canine X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency by in vivo retroviral gene therapy Evidence of avian leukosis virus subgroup E and endogenous avian virus in measles and mumps vaccines derived from chicken cells: investigation of transmission to vaccine recipients Cloning and functional characterization of a system ASC-like Na?-dependent neutral amino acid transporter Discovery of a new endogenous type C retrovirus (FcEV) in cats: evidence for RD-114 being an FcEV Gag-Pol /baboon endogenous virus BaEV Env recombinant Characterization of RD-114 virus isolated from a commercial canine vaccine manufactured using CRFK cells Contamination of infectious RD-114 virus in vaccines produced using non-feline cell lines Presence of infectious RD-114 virus in a proportion of canine parvovirus isolates Canine ASCT1 and ASCT2 are functional receptors for RD-114 virus in dogs Resurrection of endogenous retroviruses in antibody-deficient mice Nucleic acid-sensing Toll-like receptors are essential for the control of endogenous retrovirus viremia and ERV-induced tumors Acknowledgments We thank Peter Gee (Kyoto University) for his generous help in the preparation of this manuscript. This work was supported by grants from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science and from the Bio-Oriented Technology Research Advancement Institution in Japan, and by contributions from Kyoritsu Seiyaku Corporation (Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo, Japan), Merial Japan (Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo, Japan), and Nisseiken Co. Ltd. (Ome, Tokyo, Japan).