key: cord-0067721-33ecda9m
authors: Zhu, Zhihong; Zhuo, Yue; Jin, Haitao; Wu, Boyu; Li, Zhijie
title: Chinese medicine therapies for neurogenic bladder after spinal cord injury: A protocol for systematic review and network meta-analysis
date: 2021-09-17
journal: Medicine (Baltimore)
DOI: 10.1097/md.0000000000027215
sha: 4032a4f127b4fefddf22470a66a7c27dc38858f4
doc_id: 67721
cord_uid: 33ecda9m

BACKGROUND: Neurogenic bladder (NB), a refractory disease, is characterized by voiding dysfunction of bladder and/or urethra, and spinal cord injury (SCI) is a common cause. Chinese medicine therapies have been applied extensively in the treatment of NB, especially in China, and the results are promising but varying. Thus, the aim of this work is to assess the efficacy and safety of various Chinese medicine therapies for NB after SCI. METHODS: A retrieval will be performed in 8 online databases (the Cochrane Library, Web of Science, PubMed, EMBASE Database, China Biological Medicine Database, Chinese Scientific Journals Database, Wan Fang databases, and China National Knowledge Infrastructure) from their inception throughout June 2021. Only randomized controlled trials of testing Chinese medicine therapies for NB after SCI will be enrolled. The outcome indicators measured will be overall response rate, urodynamic tests, clinical assessment, and safety assessments. The methodological quality of this Bayesian-based network meta-analysis will be conducted with the “Risk of Bias” tool. Stata14.0 and WinBUGS 1.4.3 will be used to analyze the data. Furthermore, the assessment of heterogeneity, inconsistency, subgroup, sensitivity, and publication bias will also be taken into consideration with the help of Cochrane Collaboration's tool. RESULTS: The findings of this study will be submitted to a peer-reviewed journal for publication. CONCLUSION: This work will furnish evidence-based recommendations to figure out the optimal Chinese medicine therapy or their combinations for NB induced by SCI, and in turn contribute to further research and public health.

Neurogenic bladder (NB), characterized by voiding dysfunction of bladder and/or urethra, is a refractory disease caused by lesions affecting the nervous system. [1] Spinal cord injury (SCI) is a common cause of NB. With the rapid development of urban construction, modern transportation, and sports practice, there has been an increasing incidence of SCI in recent years, particularly induced by trauma. [2] According to statistics, there are 12 to more than 65 cases per million people suffer from SCI worldwide each year, mostly in young men and older adults. Meanwhile, around 70% to 84% of patients with SCI subject to NB. [3] As the disease progresses, the damage and/or infection of upper urinary tract (e.g., renal failure) resulting from lower urinary tract dysfunction has become the leading cause of death in these patients. [4] Therefore, NB after SCI has become a serious issue of concern. It not only has a severe impact on the quality of life of patients and their families, but also places a huge burden on the public health system. [5] Management of NB after SCI has always been a major concern for practitioners. Conservative management, which includes intermittent catheterization (IC), timed voiding, micturition maneuvers, indwelling catheters, health education, and medications (e.g., anticholinergic medications), is still the most common treatment option, while surgical management can be used for those who are intolerant or failed to conservative treatment. [6] The purpose of all treatments is to improve bladder function, in turn, protect the kidneys, and enhance the quality of life as well as societal value of the patients. [7] However, IC, micturition maneuvers, and indwelling catheters require patients to have good self-care capabilities, otherwise infection is prone to occur. Besides, medications inevitably have some side effects and tolerability, while invasive surgery also has limitations such as high cost and high risk. Thus, it is still necessary to find other complementary and alternative treatments that are safe and effective.

Chinese medicine, which originated in China, has been widely practiced in East Asia for thousands of years. It is beyond doubt that Chinese medicine has made a great contribution to human health, especially in ancient times. However, as the times go by, the development of Chinese medicine has lagged behind. Nevertheless, Chinese medicine is gaining attention as a complementary and alternative medicine due to its good tolerability, few side effects, and low cost. [8] In fact, the efficacy of Chinese medicine treatments for some refractory disease has been demonstrated. [9] [10] [11] [12] There are at least 18 interventions of Chinese medicine based on the guidelines developed by State Administration of Chinese medicine of China [13] . Many of these technologies have already been applied extensively in the treatment of NB after SCI, and some have shown promising results. [14] However, owing to the variable severity of disease and the differences in quality of studies, the efficacy of different interventions varies. Thus, it makes sense to identify the optimal intervention or their combinations for NB after SCI.

In our study, we will conduct a Bayesian network metaanalysis to compare the efficacy and safety of different interventions of Chinese medicine in the treatment of NB after SCI. As far as we know, it will be the first attempt in this field. We believe this work will not only help patients recover better, but also provide practitioners with evidence-based evidence that will lead to greater savings in healthcare resources.

Our study has been registered on the website of INPLASY, and acquired the registration number (INPLASY202180084). This network meta-analysis (NMA) will be conducted strictly under the guidance of PRISMA-P and PRISMA-NMA. [15, 16] Besides, the modifications of our NMA will be updated in detail timely.

Considering that this NMA did not include the collection of personal information, ethical permission was not needed for this study.

2.3. Selection criteria 2.3.1. Types of studies. All randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of testing Chinese medicine therapies for NB after SCI will be eligible for our study without any limitation of population characteristics. However, the language is limited to English or Chinese, and non-RCTs such as meeting abstracts, clinical experience, system reviews, case reports, and animal trials will be removed. Apart from this, sufficiency of original data is indispensable.

2.3.2. Types of participants. The patients who are diagnosed with NB after SCI by a clear and widely recognized criterion will be recruited, and irrespective of gender, age, nationality, race.

2.3.3.1. Experimental groups. Chinese medicine interventions or their combinations, based on the classification criteria of State Administration of Chinese medicine of China, must be applied in the experimental groups and regardless of differences in the specific prescription, duration, or frequency of treatments. In order to align with clinical practice and increase generalizability of our findings, we will merge similar therapies into 10 types of interventions (acupuncture therapy, electroacupuncture therapy, acupoint sticking therapy, acupoint injection therapy, moxibustion therapy, tuina/massage therapy, oral Chinese herb medicine, herb fumigation/soaking therapy, scrapping therapy, cupping therapy), which have been shown in detail in Table 1 .

The control groups with non-Chinese medicine interventions, consisting of non-surgical conservative therapies (IC, indwelling catheters, pelvic-floor electro-stimulation, bladder training, medications, and so on) and blank control methods (placebo, sham acupuncture, and so on), will be included in our NMA.

The primary outcome of our NMA will be measured by overall response rate and urodynamic tests, which includes postvoiding residual urine volume, maximum urinary flow rate, and maximal detrusor pressure. The secondary outcome includes a voiding diary (the number of patients with retention or incontinence, their average number of urination or incontinence episodes per 24 hours), clinical assessments (e.g., 1 h/24 h pad test), quality of life questionnaire. Apart from this, safety assessments, for instance, drop-out cases and adverse events will be considered as well.

A comprehensive search for potentially relevant literature will be performed in 8 online databases from their establishment throughout June 2021: the Cochrane Library, Web of Science, PubMed, EMBASE Database, China Biological Medicine Database, Chinese Scientific Journals Database, Wan Fang databases, and China National Knowledge Infrastructure. Search strategy based on MeSH terms combining with free text words will be applied in English databases, while counterpart terms in Chinese will be used in Chinese databases. Additionally, the related references of included literature will also be screened carefully under the guidance of the snowball strategy, and the language will be limited to English or Chinese. If the information we need is incomplete, we will contact the corresponding author to obtain it, and an intention-to-treat analysis will also be conducted for missing or unreachable data. The detailed retrieval strategy of PubMed is listed in Table 2 as an example.

The first step is to import the retrieved literature into EndNote X8 to remove duplicates automatically, then primary screening will be performed independently by 2 reviewers (Zhihong Zhu and Haitao Jin) based on titles and abstracts, and studies not meeting the selection criteria will be removed directly. The second step is to conduct a full-text screening to select eligible Zhu et al. Medicine (2021) 100:37 Medicine articles by the same 2 reviewers, and the exclusion reasons will be recorded individually. The third step is to carry out a crosschecking of the results to ensure the consistency of the screening. When the disagreements appeared, a third senior assessor (Yue Zhuo) will be asked to assist in the ultimate judgement. The specific selection process is illustrated in Figure 1 .

When the above steps are completed, a data extraction table, which mainly includes first author's name, nationality, publication year, participants' characteristics (sample size, gender, mean age, number of groups, type of NB after SCI, disease duration, and so on), interventions, comparators, outcomes, and methodological design will be established in Microsoft Excel 2016 in light of recommendations in the Cochrane Handbook. Given that baseline Table 1 The detailed explanation of postmerger Chinese medicine interventions.

Acupuncture therapy Acupuncture is a manual technique in which fine metal needles are inserted into acupoints on the body to treat diseases. Electroacupuncture therapy Electroacupuncture is a kind of acupuncture therapy that combines conventional acupuncture with electrical stimulation. Acupoint sticking therapy

The medications are made into certain dosage forms and applied to the acupoints. Acupoint injection therapy It involves injecting low-dose of medications into acupoints to treat diseases through the dual effects of drugs and acupoints.

Moxa is made into sticks or granules and then ignited. Subsequently, smoked it directly or indirectly on acupoints or certain areas of the body surfaces. Tuina/massage therapy It is a kind of Chinese medicine manipulation method which acts on meridians/acupoints or certain areas of the body by point method, pressing method, tapping method and pushing method. Oral Chinese herb medicine

To decoct disease-related Chinese herbal medicine prescriptions and taken orally Herb fumigation/soaking therapy Fumigation or soaking of the affected area with warm Chinese herbal medicine liquids Scrapping therapy Blunt-edged instruments, such as horns, stone spoons, or ladles, are used, then dipped them in mediums such as scraping oil, water, or lubricant, and repeatedly scraped on certain areas of the body surfaces to cause localized petechiae.

Cup is used as a tool, and by means of burning, suction, and steam, negative pressure is induced inside the cup, in turn, causing the cup to adsorb on acupoints or certain areas of the body surfaces, then local skin congestion or blood stasis will occur. situation among different trials may be potentially varying, the data finally included in the analysis were estimated by the following formula, which was recommended in the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions (version5.1) and r is a correlation coefficient with a value of 0.5. [17] This approach allowed for a better presentation of the changes before and after treatment of dissimilar Chinese medicine interventions. 

Two well-trained researchers (Boyu Wu and Yue Zhuo) will independently assess the bias risk of all the included RCTs by the Cochrane Collaboration tool, [18] which consisted of the following aspects: assignment concealment, random sequence generation, blinding of outcome assessors, blinding of participants and personnel, selective reporting, the integrity of outcome data, and other sources of bias. Each field has been classified as high risk, low risk, or unclear risk. Any disagreements will be resolved by discussion with a third senior assessor (Zhijie Li).

First of all, a pairwise meta-analysis will be performed using Revman 5.3. (Cochrane Collaboration, Oxford, UK) for the direct comparisons. Secondly, considering the anticipated heterogeneity, the NMA within a Bayesian framework will be conducted by WinBUGS 1.4.3 (MRC Biostatistics Unit, Cambridge, UK) based on the random effect model for the results of the indirect comparison. Besides, models will be calculated with Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm [19] : 4 chains will be employed for simulation analysis, the step size will be set to 10, the number of annealing times will be set to 20,000 for reducing the impact on arbitrary values, and the number of iterations will be set to 50,000. Additionally, the continuous outcomes will be measured by standard mean difference with 95% confidence interval for indirect comparisons, while binary variable selection relative risk and 95% confidence interval. Thirdly, the plot of surface under the cumulative ranking curve will be computed by STATA 14.0. (Stata Corporation, College Station, Texas) to forecast the possible ranking order. [20] In our study, a higher surface under the cumulative ranking curve score represents the better Chinese medicine intervention for NB after SCI. [21] 2.8. Assessment of heterogeneity

First of all, we will assess if the participants' characteristics, interventions, as well as outcomes are adequately similar in all included trials. If not, the heterogeneity of the results will be assessed with I-square (I 2 ) by STATA 14.0. software. The substantial heterogeneity will be considered only if the I 2 is above 50%, and then a random-effects model will be chosen, otherwise a fixed-effects model will be used.

In general, differences across dissimilar kinds of evidence may be a major source of inconsistency. Thus, the inconsistency between indirect and direct evidence will be assessed by the loop inconsistency test and node-splitting method. Additionally, Z-value as well as corresponding P value will be calculated, and P values less than .05 demonstrate a significant difference. In case significant heterogeneity is identified, subgroup analysis will be performed according to the possible sources of heterogeneity, such as type of NB after SCI (retention or incontinence), injured spinal segments, and quality of studies.

Considering that varying level of the methodological quality of trails may tend to affect our findings, sensitivity analysis will be performed to evaluate the robustness of the results by excluding high-risk studies.

In our NMA, we will strictly adhere to the mentioned rules of literature selection to minimize the potential impact of publication bias. Then, if the number of included trails is above 10, a funnel plot will be employed to assess the publication bias visually.

Two reviewers will evaluate the quality of each evidence separately on the basis of the GRADE working group methodology, [22] which classifies the quality levels into 4 categories: high, medium, low, and very low. Similarly, a third one will be consulted, if there is uncertainty.

Urine storage and voiding requires the precise regulation of the central and peripheral nervous system, and different injured spinal segments may lead to dissimilar types of micturition dysfunction. [23] It has been reported that urologic disease after SCI, NB in particular, is the complication that most affects patient's quality of life. [24] Chinese medicine has the advantages of diverse methods, extensive experience, and easy operation. As a result, increasing attention has been paid to the clinical effects and potential mechanisms of Chinese medicine for NB. [14, 25] For instance, electroacupuncture has been reported to exhibit an important role in the improvement of micturition reflex after SCI, and in turn accelerating the recovery of the bladder function. [26] Tanshinone IIA, the active ingredients of Chinese herb "Danshen" (Salvia miltiorrhiza Bunge), has been found to improve urodynamic parameters and bladder functional recovery after SCI induced NB by reducing the inflammation and edema of the bladder tissue as well as enhancing spinal cord regeneration. [27] However, gaps in comparisons of direct and indirect evidence of various Chinese medicine therapies still remain, which confuse clinical practice. Trying to address this issue by NMA is our original intention.

Predictably, some potential limitations may affect the credibility of our study. Due to a restriction of languages, selection bias is inevitable, which may limit the generalization of our conclusions. Furthermore, to some extent, it is hard for us to rule out heterogeneity completely because of the differences in specific prescription (e.g., acupoint selections, medical manipulations) and treatment frequency. Nevertheless, this NMA will be conducted on the basis of adequate high-quality trials, and strictly in line with Cochrane Manual. We are looking forward to provide the clinical and experimental research of NB after SCI with evidence-based recommendations. 

Recommendations for evaluation of neurogenic bladder and bowel dysfunction after spinal cord injury and/or disease

Recent update on basic mechanisms of spinal cord injury

Epidemiology and pathophysiology of neurogenic bladder after spinal cord injury

Effect of early sacral neuromodulation on bladder function in a rat model of incomplete spinal cord injury due to focal contusion

Drug utilization patterns and healthcare resource use and costs in patients with neurogenic bladder in the United Kingdom: a retrospective primary care database study

Neurogenic bladder in spinal cord injury patients

Non-surgical urologic management of neurogenic bladder after spinal cord injury

Efficacy and safety assessment of severe COVID-19 patients with Chinese medicine: a retrospective case series study at early stage of the COVID-19 epidemic in Wuhan

Acupuncture for chemotherapy-induced peripheral neuropathy in breast cancer survivors: a randomized controlled pilot trial

Clinical evidence for association of acupuncture and acupressure with improved cancer pain: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Effect of electroacupuncture on urinary leakage among women with stress urinary incontinence: a randomized clinical trial

The prophylactic use of Chinese herbal medicine for chemotherapy-induced leucopenia in oncology patients: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials

Traditional Chinese medicine for post-stroke depression: a systematic review and network meta-analysis (Protocol)

Effects of electroacupuncture on patients with chronic urinary retention caused by a lower motor neuron lesion: an exploratory pilot study

Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015 statement

The PRISMA extension statement for reporting of systematic reviews incorporating network meta-analyses of health care interventions: checklist and explanations

Meta-analysis of heterogeneously reported trials assessing change from baseline

The Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials

Bayesian methods for evidence synthesis in cost-effectiveness analysis

Graphical methods and numerical summaries for presenting results from multiple-treatment meta-analysis: an overview and tutorial

Graphical tools for network meta-analysis in STATA

A GRADE Working Group approach for rating the quality of treatment effect estimates from network meta-analysis

Spinal reflex control of micturition after spinal cord injury

Surveillance and management of urologic complications after spinal cord injury

Combination of Wu Lin San and Shan Zha ameliorates substance P-induced hyperactive bladder via the inhibition of neutrophil NADPH oxidase activity

Electroacupuncture improves neurogenic bladder dysfunction through activation of NGF/ TrkA signaling in a rat model

Tanshinone IIA improves functional recovery in spinal cord injury-induced lower urinary tract dysfunction