key: cord-0684294-rlsgufcf authors: Hoang, Uy; de Lusignan, Simon; Joy, Mark; Sherlock, Julian; Williams, John; Bankhead, Clare; Howsam, Gary; Thomas, Mark; Snape, Matthew D; Hobbs, F D Richard; Pollard, Andrew J title: National rates and disparities in childhood vaccination and vaccine-preventable disease during the COVID-19 pandemic: English sentinel network retrospective database study date: 2022-03-31 journal: Arch Dis Child DOI: 10.1136/archdischild-2021-323630 sha: 7aa8161fd1c6cd81474e1e77174d78a6a74939cb doc_id: 684294 cord_uid: rlsgufcf OBJECTIVES: To describe rates and variation in uptake of pneumococcal and measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccines in children and associated change in vaccine-preventable diseases (VPDs) across the first and second waves of the COVID-19 pandemic. METHODS: Retrospective database study of all children aged <19 registered with a general practice in the Oxford Royal College of General Practitioners Research and Surveillance Centre English national sentinel surveillance network between 2 November 2015 and 18 July 2021. RESULTS: Coverage of booster dose of pneumococcal vaccine decreased from 94.5% (95% CI 94.3% to 94.7%) at its height on International Organization for Standardization (ISO) week 47 (2020) to 93.6% (95% CI 93.4% to 93.8%) by the end of the study. Coverage of second dose of MMR decreased from 85.0% (95% CI 84.7% to 85.3%) at its height on ISO week 37 (2020) to 84.1% (95% CI 83.8% to 84.4%) by the end of the study. The break point in trends for MMR was at ISO week 34 (2020) (95% CI weeks 32–37 (2020)), while for pneumococcal vaccine the break point was later at ISO week 3 (2021) (95% CI week 53 (2020) to week 8 (2021)). Vaccination coverage for children of white ethnicity was less likely to decrease than other ethnicities. Rates of consultation for VPDs fell and remained low since August 2020. CONCLUSION: Childhood vaccination rates started to fall ahead of the onset of the second wave; this fall is accentuating ethnic, socioeconomic and geographical disparities in vaccine uptake and risks widening health disparities. Social distancing and school closures may have contributed to lower rates of associated VPDs, but there may be increased risk as these measures are removed. The UK national childhood immunisation programme aims to protect against serious diseases. 1 The programme has achieved high vaccination coverage in the population. This is important especially for measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) and pneumococcal vaccinations since these infections have high transmission rates in unvaccinated populations, and a wide range of potentially serious effects in those infected including pneumonia, meningitis and death. [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] Through 2020/2021 there have been three waves of the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK with varying levels of social distancing, school closure and lockdowns in place. 8 9 A systematic review of 17 observational studies during 2020 to assess the impact of the pandemic on childhood vaccination coverage found that there was a decline in the total number of vaccines administered and consequent reduction in coverage, with many children missing out on their vaccine doses. 10 Results from a study in over 2600 primary care practices and >35 child health providers found that in the first 3 weeks of social distancing in 2020 in the UK, MMR vaccination counts were 19.8% lower (95% CI −20.7% to −18.9%) than for the same period in 2019. 11 12 There were signs of a recovery by April 2020. 13 What is already known on this topic ► During the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK, transient declines in preschool vaccinations were observed. What this study adds ► This study covering the impact of the second and third national lockdowns in the UK showed a small but significant decrease in coverage of measles, mumps and rubella and pneumococcal vaccines over the course of the study. This decrease in vaccine coverage varied by ethnicity, socioeconomic status and location. ► Consultations for vaccine-preventable diseases in primary care also decreased to negligible rates from August 2020. How this study might affect research, practice or policy ► It is important to continue to monitor trends in childhood vaccination coverage during the pandemic, especially among children from ethnic minorities and lower socioeconomic groups, as reductions in coverage may lead to widening health disparities. We carried out this research to report any impact of the pandemic on vaccine uptake in children, especially MMR and pneumococcal vaccines, exploring any disparities in coverage over the duration of the pandemic, and to see if there was an impact on vaccine-preventable diseases (VPDs). We report on the first two completed waves, with the third wave ongoing. We undertook a retrospective study nested within the English national influenza sentinel surveillance network run by the Oxford Royal College of General Practitioners Clinical Informatics Digital Hub (ORCHID). Previous studies demonstrated that the age-sex distribution of patients in the network is broadly similar to the English national census distribution. 14 ORCHID data have been used for previous childhood vaccine research. 15 The VPDs studied have been reported by the network in its weekly and annual reports for over 50 years. 16 The study included data from all children aged <19 who were registered with a general practitioner between 2 November 2015 and 18 July 2021. We compared any change in birth rate with that reported by the Office for National Statistics (ONS). 17 We extracted data on age, gender and ethnicity which were recorded using an ontology to maximise identification, 18 socioeconomic status measured using the Index of Multiple Deprivation (IMD) 19 20 and rurality using the ONS classification based on individual-level postcode. 21 We have used practice postcode to assign IMD and household setting where no valid patient postcode was available (~3%). We also extracted vaccination status and consultations for VPDs from the pseudonymised vaccination record and computerised medical records of all children <19 within the network using the Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine-Clinical Terms (SNOMED-CT). 22 Weekly vaccination coverage for the first dose of MMR was calculated by dividing the number of children <2 who had been given one dose of MMR by the number of children <2 registered within the ORCHID network that week. Coverage for the second dose of MMR was calculated similarly for children <5 who had been given two doses. Weekly vaccination coverage for the first dose of pneumococcal vaccine was calculated by dividing the number of children <1 who had been given one dose of pneumococcal vaccine by the number of children <1 registered within the ORCHID network that week. Coverage for the booster dose of pneumococcal vaccine was calculated similarly for children <2 who had been given two doses. To account for the change from a threedose schedule in 2020, 23 our definition of pneumococcal vaccine coverage prior to 1 January 2020 counted children who had had three doses of pneumococcal vaccine. The second/third dose of pneumococcal vaccine will be referred to as booster dose of pneumococcal vaccine henceforth. Weekly VPD rates were calculated by dividing the total number of consultations for VPDs per week by the number of children registered within the ORCHID network. The list of vaccines, VPDs and their associated SNOMED-CTs used for this study is included in online supplemental appendix 1. Data are presented graphically by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) week. 24 Linear regression was used to model trends in vaccination coverage and to identify inequalities by ethnicity, IMD and urban/rural location. Segmental linear regression analysis was used to identify any break points in the vaccination trends. This regression analysis uses an iterative process to estimate the slopes and break points in generalised linear models which have one or more segmented relationships in the predictor. 25 Inequalities in coverage following break points in the vaccination trend were of particular interest, thus an interaction term between ethnicity and break point was added to the regression model. Similar analysis was undertaken to examine the inequalities by IMD and urban/rural location. Statistical analyses were undertaken using R V.3.5.1. This study was classified as a service evaluation (measuring what standard of care is achieved) by the Medical Research Council/ Health Research Authority decision tools 26 so did not require formal ethics approval; it was approved by the RCGP Approval Committee (data request ORC_05_2020). This study does not include patients who opted out of record sharing, approximately 2%. The number of registered children <19 whose data contributed to the analysis reduced from 1 094 150 in 2015 to 1 043 968 in 2021 (see table 1 ). This fall of 4.6% is smaller than the decrease in the proportion of live births over this period of 11.8% reported by ONS. 27 28 There was a 6.3% lower proportion of children of white ethnicity over the course of the study, while the proportion of births of children of white ethnicity decreased by 3.7% between 2015 and 2019. 27 29 Presentation of VPDs had reduced to negligible rates by week 32 (2020). Figure 9 showed that the break point in trends for mumps disease rates was within 1 week of the first national lockdown. The break points in trends for VPD rates were less clearly associated with the national lockdowns. The COVID-19 pandemic has had a small but significant effect on coverage of childhood pneumococcal and MMR vaccinations. Coverage for pneumococcal booster doses at the end of our study was 93.6% (95% CI 93.4% to 93.8%). This is comparable to data published by Public Health England (PHE) which showed that pneumococcal conjugate vaccine coverage in children 12 months of age was 93.4% in the first quarter of 2021. 30 In turn, the coverage for second dose of MMR at the end of our study was 84.1% (95% CI 83.8% to 4.4%), which is lower than the published data which showed MMR coverage in children 24 months of age was 89.3% in the first quarter of 2021. 30 There were significant ethnic, socioeconomic and urban/rural differences in vaccination coverage, especially for MMR. In our study, so far, there have been no recorded increases in VPDs among children, with negligible consultation rates for most VPDs. This may have been confounded by cases not presenting to healthcare or by cases presenting to parts of the National Health Service (NHS) other than general practice, with a subsequent delay in reporting and recording in the primary care record. Data from the WHO for all four nations of the UK showed that between 2019 and 2020, the number of cases of measles had reduced by 91.3%, mumps by 31.2% and rubella by 100%. In contrast, globally between 2019 and 2020, measles cases reduced by 82.8%, mumps increased by 157.8% and rubella reduced by 79.3%. 31 The strengths of our study include its large sample size from a nationally representative sentinel network, the long period covered with weekly vaccine coverage rates, including data covering the second and third national lockdowns; and that we covered trends in both vaccine coverage and VPD rates. A limitation of our study involves the quality of recording in routinely collected data. Our sentinel network has been involved in monitoring respiratory infections and vaccinations for over 50 years and has had regular feedback on data quality. 14 16 Another limitation relates to the duration of our study, which covered a number of changes to the childhood vaccination schedule, including the change to a two-dose pneumococcal conjugate vaccine schedule in 2020. Changes to the two-dose pneumococcal vaccine schedule have been taken into account in this study, although the broader changes in the childhood vaccination programme have not been adjusted for in this analysis. Our study only covered two vaccinations as these infections have high transmission rates in unvaccinated populations, and the resulting VPDs associated with low vaccine coverage are likely to be the first to become apparent. However, the trends in these two vaccinations may not reflect the trend in all childhood vaccination rates, especially those provided outside primary care. It is important to note that changes in coverage associated with marked reductions in vaccine administrations will be delayed. 32 For example, most children who turn 2 years of age during the early months of the pandemic will have received the first dose of MMR and the pneumococcal booster well before the start of the pandemic. Therefore, changes in coverage that occur because of decreased vaccine administrations during the pandemic will not be seen until weeks when a substantial proportion of children have turned 2 years old. Our methodology for calculating vaccination coverage has allowed us to compare our results directly with national published statistics. 30 However, as our study takes in a larger window of observation than stipulated by the NHS vaccination schedule, it may be less sensitive to secular trends in coverage. 32 Finally, our definition of VPDs included pneumonia or pneumonitis, not all of which are vaccine-preventable cases. Conversely, in the setting of COVID-19, care-seeking patterns might be quite different for respiratory illnesses in particular, and some cases of COVID-19 (particularly among adolescents) might be classified as 'pneumonia or pneumonitis' under the definition that we have used. It is reassuring that this large representative data set indicates general practice delivery of childhood immunisations has remained good, especially during the first lockdown. Our study is comparable to data from WHO and PHE, 30 31 33 34 although the coverage rates for MMR are lower in our data set than the PHE. This may be the result of some vaccinations being given in community settings not attached to a general practitioner. Our results show that pneumococcal vaccine coverage has been declining steadily over time and accelerated in the pandemic. In contrast, MMR coverage seemed to be increasing but this plateaued in the pandemic. There are a number of possible explanations for this observed decline in these childhood vaccination rates, including the pivotal role general practice has played in the national COVID-19 vaccine implementation. 35 Early studies showed that general practice-led sites delivered two in three of all COVID-19 vaccinations in England between December 2020 and April 2021, 36 this may have impacted capacity for routine vaccinations during the period of our study. There are a number of possible explanations for the differential decline in coverage by ethnicity, socioeconomic status and geographical location. Ethnic and socioeconomic differences in parents' perception of the importance of immunisations, whether immunisations were permitted or culturally acceptable and their understanding of immunisation schedules have been shown to affect immunisation decisions. 37 38 Recent research on COVID-19 vaccines have found a marked difference in vaccine hesitancy by race/ethnicity, [39] [40] [41] with a much greater proportion of ethnic minority populations expressing concern about side effects and the long-term effects of vaccines on health. Some have capitalised on this lack of trust in vaccines to spread misinformation. 42 This differential decline in coverage may also reflect access barriers, including difficulties in accessing vaccination appointments during the pandemic. [43] [44] [45] Thus, it is important to continue to monitor these trends to record any reduction in coverage from the second and third lockdowns, especially among ethnic minority groups and lower socioeconomic groups which will lead to widening health disparities. 38 46 These data show that there may be an increasing risk of preventable serious childhood diseases if the modest reductions in vaccination rates are not rapidly reversed especially in those populations with greater rates of decline. 47 48 The drive to offer COVID-19 booster vaccinations in adults and the expansion of COVID-19 vaccinations for children should not be at the expense of routine childhood immunisation rates. Twitter Simon de Lusignan @Lusignan_S Immunisation against infectious disease and Children's health Measles and the importance of maintaining vaccination levels The role of vaccination coverage, individual behaviors, and the public health response in the control of measles epidemics: an agent-based simulation for California Changes in Invasive Pneumococcal Disease Caused by Streptococcus pneumoniae Serotype 1 Following Introduction of PCV10 and PCV13: Findings from the PSERENADE Project Immunogenicity of the UK group B meningococcal vaccine (4CMenB) schedule against groups B and C meningococcal strains (Sched3): outcomes of a multicentre, open-label, randomised controlled trial Outbreak report: nosocomial transmission of measles through an unvaccinated healthcare worker-implications for public health Outbreak of measles in central and eastern Cheshire Timeline of UK government coronavirus lockdowns Royal College of General Practitioners The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on immunization campaigns and programs: a systematic review Routine vaccination during covid-19 pandemic response Keeping childhood immunisation rates stable during the COVID-19 pandemic Early impact of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic and physical distancing measures on routine childhood vaccinations in England Royal College of general practitioners research and surveillance centre (RCGP RSC) sentinel network: a cohort profile Advance system testing: can coverage of pertussis vaccination be estimated in European countries using electronic healthcare databases: an example RCGP research and surveillance centre: 50 years' surveillance of influenza, infections, and respiratory conditions Ethnicity recording in primary care computerised medical record systems: an ontological approach UK indices of multiple deprivation -A way to make comparisons across constituent countries easier Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government Office for National Statistics. 2011 rural/urban classification Codes, classifications, terminologies and nomenclatures: definition, development and application in practice Pneumococcal vaccination: infant schedule changes from International Standard Organisation. Data elements and interchange formats -Information interchange -Representation of dates and times Package 'segmented Medical Research Council Health Research Authority. Do I need NHS rec review Office for National Statistics Cover of vaccination evaluated rapidly (cover) programme 2020 to 2021: quarterly data WHO. Immunization dashboard Pediatric vaccination during the COVID-19 pandemic Cover of vaccination evaluated rapidly (cover) programme 2019 to 2020: quarterly data COVID-19 pandemic leads to major backsliding on childhood vaccinations, new who, UNICEF data shows The King's FundBaird B. General practice and the Covid-19 vaccine: putting local relationships at the heart of the vaccination programme GPs delivered over two thirds of Covid vaccinations in phase 1 of the programme. Pulse. London: Cogora Limited Factors affecting uptake of childhood vaccination in the UK: a thematic synthesis Ethnicity-specific factors influencing childhood immunisation decisions among black and Asian minority ethnic groups in the UK: a systematic review of qualitative research International estimates of intended uptake and refusal of COVID-19 vaccines: a rapid systematic review and meta-analysis of large nationally representative samples Ethnic differences in SARS-CoV-2 vaccine hesitancy in United Kingdom healthcare workers: results from the UK-REACH prospective nationwide cohort study Covid-19 vaccine hesitancy among ethnic minority groups A perspective on health inequalities in BamE communities and how to improve access to primary care Racial and ethnic differences in self-reported telehealth use during the COVID-19 pandemic: a secondary analysis of a US survey of Internet users from late March Telemedicine and healthcare disparities: a cohort study in a large healthcare system in New York City during COVID-19 Childhood vaccination coverage by ethnicity within London between Social media and vaccine hesitancy Correcting COVID-19 vaccine misinformation: Lancet Commission on COVID-19 vaccines and therapeutics Task force members Office for National Statistics. Estimates of the population for the Acknowledgements FDRH acknowledges the support from the National Institute