key: cord-0686565-s1w1r3ez authors: Akaba, Godwin O; Dirisu, Osasuyi; Okunade, Kehinde S.; Adams, Eseoghene; Ohioghame, Jane; Obikeze, Obioma O.; Izuka, Emmanuel; Sulieman, Maryam; Edeh, Michael title: Barriers and facilitators of access to maternal, newborn and child health services during the first wave of COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria: findings from a qualitative study date: 2022-05-06 journal: BMC Health Serv Res DOI: 10.1186/s12913-022-07996-2 sha: f1d57c13eaf45752397483f782e096a1be8cffdf doc_id: 686565 cord_uid: s1w1r3ez BACKGROUND: COVID-19 pandemic may have affected the utilization of maternal and newborn child health services in Nigeria but the extent, directions, contextual factors at all the levels of healthcare service delivery in Nigeria is yet to be fully explored. The objective of the study was to explore the barriers and facilitators of access to MNCH services during the first wave of COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria. METHODS: A qualitative study was conducted among different stakeholder groups in 18 public health facilities in Nigeria between May and July,2020. In-depth interviews were conducted among 54 study participants (service users, service providers and policymakers) selected from across the three tiers of public health service delivery system in Nigeria (primary health centers, secondary health centers and tertiary health centers). Coding of the qualitative data and identification of themes from the transcripts were carried out and thematic approach was used for data analyses. RESULTS: Barriers to accessing MNCH services during the first wave of COVID-19-pandemic in Nigeria include fear of contracting COVID-19 infection at health facilities, transportation difficulties, stigmatization of sick persons, lack of personal protective equipment (PPE) /medical commodities, long waiting times at hospitals, shortage of manpower, lack of preparedness by health workers, and prioritization of essential services. Enablers to access include the COVID-19 non-pharmacological measures instituted at the health facilities, community sensitization on healthcare access during the pandemic, and alternative strategies for administering immunization service at the clinics. CONCLUSION: Access to MNCH services were negatively affected by lockdown during the first wave of COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria particularly due to challenges resulting from restrictions in movements which affected patients/healthcare providers ability to reach the hospitals as well as patients’ ability to pay for health care services. Additionally, there was fear of contracting COVID-19 infection at health facilities and the health systems inability to provide enabling conditions for sustained utilization of MNCH services. There is need for government to institute alternative measures to halt the spread of diseases instead of lockdowns so as to ensure unhindered access to MNCH services during future pandemics. This may include immediate sensitization of the general public on modes of transmission of any emergent infectious disease as well as training of health workers on emergency preparedness and alternative service delivery models. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12913-022-07996-2. Corona Virus-19(COVID- 19) was declared a public health emergency of international concern by World Health Organization on Jan 30,2020 concern [1] . Nigeria's index case was confirmed on 27 th February 2020 and the number has steadily risen to 161,074 with 2,018 deaths as of 16 th March 2021 [2] . Nigeria alone with a maternal mortality ratio of 917 per 100,000 live births contributed up to 23% of global maternal deaths in 2017 [3] . Newborn and child health indices in Nigeria are also amongst the worst in the world [4] with neonatal mortality and under mortality rates of 32.9 deaths per 1000 live births and 100.2 deaths per 1000 live births in 2017, respectively [5] . The poor maternal and newborn child health (MNCH) indices have been attributed to several factors including poor political will, weak health systems and lack of access to MNCH services [6] . For example, only 4 in 10 births are delivered in health facilities while just 43% of births are assisted by a skilled provider [7] . Experiences from the Ebola Epidemic in West Africa showed that access to MNCH services is likely to be disrupted during public health crisis [8] . With advent of COVID-19 pandemic, the resilience of health systems, their levels of emergency preparedness and the response of nations were tested and found to be fragile in most instances [9] . This portends great danger for a country like Nigeria where access and utilization of maternal, newborn and child health services are still poor [7] . During the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic, Nigeria instituted a series of stringent non-pharmaceutical interventions, including several phases of stay-athome orders and cessation of non-essential movements and activities (lockdowns) from 30 th March, 2020 to 15 th July, 2020 [10] . These measures were aimed at curtailing the spread of the virus while giving the government opportunity and time to put in place other measures like establishment of testing centers and procurement of PPEs. Lagos state in addition to the above measures increased the hazard allowance of health workers from US$13 to US$65. This was aimed at increasing the morale of the health workers [11] . COVID-19 pandemic may have affected the utilization of maternal and newborn child health services in Nigeria but the extent, directions, contextual factors at all the levels of health care service delivery as well as perceptions of patients, health workers and policymakers regarding these changes have not been evaluated in the same study in Nigeria. Additionally, the side effects of lockdown and movement restrictions instituted by the government to reduce community spread on maternal health in Nigeria have so far been largely unexplored. The objective of the study was to explore the barriers and facilitators of access to MNCH services during the first wave of COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria. The study utilized a qualitative study design to explore the perceptions of users of healthcare facilities, health workers, and policymakers on how COVID-19 has shaped the utilization of MNCH services as well as other contextual factors contributing to the projected views across six states of Nigeria. The states were chosen purposefully to represent the six (6) geopolitical zones of the country. Three states namely Abuja, Lagos and Kano had high cases for COVID-19 while the other three (Enugu, Taraba and Bayelsa) had fewer cases of Covid-19. Three Local Government Areas (LGA) were selected from each state representing three senatorial districts. The selection of states with high and few cases was considered necessary to explore contextual differences in barriers and facilitators to accessing MNCH services in these states. The states, health facilities and the number of covid-19 cases in the states as of 17 th May 2020 when data collection began is as shown in Table 1 . A total of 54 in-depth interviews (IDIs) were conducted across all six (6) states with 9 interviews in each state comprising of 3 policymakers, 3 service providers and 3 service users. These were spread equally across the three there was fear of contracting COVID-19 infection at health facilities and the health systems inability to provide enabling conditions for sustained utilization of MNCH services. There is need for government to institute alternative measures to halt the spread of diseases instead of lockdowns so as to ensure unhindered access to MNCH services during future pandemics. This may include immediate sensitization of the general public on modes of transmission of any emergent infectious disease as well as training of health workers on emergency preparedness and alternative service delivery models. Keywords: COVID-19, Maternal, Newborn, Child health, Services, Access, Nigeria levels of health care systems (Primary health care, secondary health care and tertiary healthcare) in the states. The state study coordinators scheduled and confirmed the dates and time of the planned IDIs with the study participants after obtaining informed written consent. The participants were also informed that the interview will be recorded during the informed consent process. Interviews were facilitated by experienced interviewers over the phone based on prior schedules by study coordinators. All interviews were conducted with study participants using their personal phones, although this was not a criterion in the selection process. The interviewers (three female and three male) were experienced qualitative researchers with extensive training and expertise conducting research across Nigeria. They worked with members of the core research team to schedule interviews with the respondents while determining the best time for the interview to take place. The study participants were informed about the purpose of the study and were invited to participate in the interview, which lasted for approximately 20 to 30 min. All interviews were conducted in English language using an IDI guide designed specifically for this study for each of the stakeholder groups (Maternal and child health service users, service providers and policy makers across all levels of healthcare system). In-depth interviews (IDI) guides captured barriers and facilitators that influenced access to MNCH services and service delivery during COVID-19. The final research tool was tested amongst each stake holder group before utilization for the study (See Supplementary file 1). The conceptual framework for understanding the impact of COVID-19 on MNCH service utilization in this study was the three delays model. The delay model was used to explore delays in access to MNCH services in three different but closely related phases [12] [13] [14] . • Phase I Delay: Delay in deciding to seek care: These are individual or familial factors such as socio-cultural, economic factors, illness characteristics and perceived quality of care. • Phase II Delay: Delay in reaching healthcare facility: These include distance to health facilities, transport cost, availability of transportation and poor road networks. • Phase III Delay: Delay in receiving adequate care at the health facility: These include waiting/response time at the facility, shortage of supplies/equipment, the competence of available personnel, adequacy of the referral system and quality of care. The interviews were recorded digitally, transcribed verbatim, and transferred to NVivo12 software for analysis. The codebook development process entailed a review of all the transcripts by four researchers (OD, ES, JO GOA) who contributed to the development of a thematic framework of codes through consensus. Thematic analysis was used as an analytical strategy to explore patterns and themes within the data. Thematic analysis involves the identification, analysing and reporting of patterns in data and provides the basis for many other forms of qualitative analysis [15] . The process of thematic analysis involves careful identification of themes achieved through familiarization and immersion in data [16] . The steps involved in the analysis process include familiarization with the data; initial coding and development of a codebook; [15] . A deductive analytical approach was used in this study because the general aim of thematic analysis was to test a previous theory in a different situation [17, 18] . Some codes were determined as priori codes and others emerged during the coding process. As part of the coding process, the research team explored the data until data saturation was achieved when additional interviews coded did not change the structure/content of the codebook. The process of identifying themes highlighted contextual situations that underpin perceptions and experiences expressed in the data. The themes were organized using the three (3) delay models to explore the contextual factors that shaped utilization as well as enablers and barriers of access. Demographic characteristics of study participants are presented in Table 2 . The results are presented under two major sections: Barriers and facilitators of access to MNCH services. The barriers of access to MNCH services are broken down into three domains: delay in seeking care, delay in reaching care and delay in receiving care. On the other hand, facilitators of access to MNCH services were limited to two domains (decision to seek care and receiving care at the hospitals). Direct quotes from the interviews were used to illustrate the results at each level of delay or facilitation. Majority of the services users were aged below 40 years reflecting the age category that utilizes MNCH services. Majority of the service providers were female, and nurses/doctors. Majority of policymakers were male ( Table 2 ). The summary of major themes is shown in Table 3 . Several factors influenced the decision making of women to visit health facilities and access MNCH services during the COVID-19 pandemic. Socio-economic factors Decision making around careseeking was influenced by socio-economic drivers of utilization. Petty trading was the means of livelihood of women in most communities; during the nationwide COVID -19 lockdown, majority of these women were Transportation difficulties Service users experienced significant delays in reaching health facilities due to transportation difficulties. The number of transportation service providers significantly reduced during the lockdown. Potential service users who had their vehicles found it easier to visit the hospitals than those who were dependent on public transportation. Public transportation became more expensive and difficult to access especially in remote or rural areas and some people had to resort to walking to facilities to access care. Movement restriction during the lockdown and harassment by security agents During the lockdown, in addition to the restriction of movement, there was a curfew in place. Security agents were positioned on the road at checkpoints to enforce the lockdown. There was a consensus among service users and providers that these checkpoints created delays in reaching the hospitals. There were reported cases of security agencies harassing commuters and requesting for proof that they were going to the hospital in some instances. The experience with security agents varied as some service users, mentioned that although there were delays at checkpoints, they could continue their journey after they presented their hospital identity cards or medication they were previously given at the hospital. Long waiting times and a daily capped number of patients to be attended to at the hospitals Due to the measures that were instituted to keep service users and providers safe at the hospitals, waiting time at health facilities increased. In addition, some facilities reduced the number of health personnel attending to patients and this resulted in further delays in receiving care. Health facilities capped the number of services users receiving care daily and when the number of patients seeking care exceeded the allotted number, they were turned back and asked to return on a later date. This implied that service users had to visit the facilities very early to be included in the list of patients to be seen each day; this increased waiting time and some service users waited and did not get attended to. Additionally, this was said to have resulted in poor quality of care received by service users. R: Well, the thing is that they are many, they attend to you quick but now they are not attending to us quickly as it used to be. You will stay longer before you go home. You will go and buy your drugs and you will go, but now you will stay longer before they attend to you because they are not giving us the care again! There are just two or three personnel that you will see to attend to the large number of women. Patients' non-compliance with the "no-facemask, no entry" rules Some service providers reported that when patients presented to the health facilities without facemasks, they were declined treatment, and this caused significant delays in receiving care in instances where these patients could not afford to buy facemasks. Service providers felt vulnerable and at risk of contracting COVID-19 if they provided services to patients who did not wear masks. The hospitals were unable to provide face masks for patients who were made to buy them at very high costs from hawkers at the hospitals. Service users corroborated this and reported that they experienced significant delays due to non-use of face masks. Some reasons given by service users for not wearing facemasks was they could not afford to buy facemasks, and they felt a chocking sensation when they wore the masks. Inadequate PPEs and Medical Commodities There was a consensus among policymakers and service providers that the inadequacy of PPEs affected the capacity of health facilities to respond effectively to the pandemic and maintain optimal service delivery levels. Some service providers had to purchase PPEs with personal funds to ensure they were safe and could continue delivering health services. In other instances, patients were asked to buy PPEs as part of the service delivery process. Policymakers, especially those at primary healthcare facilities, reported that PPEs were only procured for health facilities at the initial phase of the pandemic. Subsequently, the government was unresponsive to their pleas to provide more PPEs. The only PPEs that were made available were facemasks and hand gloves; facilities were not provided with face shields, gowns, and boots. The lack of information or protocols to guide the response of healthcare workers to the COVID-19 pandemic and safely continue service delivery made it more difficult for service providers. Shortage of manpower, lack of incentives and prioritization of essential services Majority of the tertiary facilities experienced a significant shortage of health personnel because these staff also doubled as health care providers at the various isolation centres. Health managers in some facilities were instructed to reduce the number of health personnel involved in the response during the lockdown and this resulted in an increased workload for health workers responding to the healthcare crisis. This increased workload resulted in delays in the delivery of MNCH services. No additional incentives were provided for the healthcare workers who had to run extra shifts during the pandemic. This significantly affected the staff motivation and impacted on welfare of health workers who were afraid to return home in between shifts to avoid infecting their families. A policymaker reported that health workers would have been better motivated if incentives were provided to support on-site accommodation and a daily allowance during the lockdown. Community sensitization on healthcare access during the pandemic Factors that positively influenced utilization of MNCH services as reported by policy makers include community-level COVID-19 sensitization. Some of these sensitization meetings involved community and religious leaders to improve service utilization among community members. In addition, febrile illnesses such as malaria which could be easily treated were perceived as COVID-19; the sensitization sessions enlightened community members about the different scenarios and the need to seek appropriate care. Community sensitization was also useful in communicating to patients on the need to wear face masks as well as cost-effective ways of obtaining and using facemasks. : Adaptation of service delivery structure and COVID-19 safety protocols Majority of policy makers and service providers reported that the service delivery structure was reorganized to be responsive to the demands of the lockdown period. In some facilities, MNCH care which was previously delivered to service users using a batched system on specific days was adapted to occur on a rolling basis. This implied that MNCH service users who visited these facilities for ANC and immunization services were attended to immediately they arrived at the facility. This was done to reduce large gatherings of service users at the facilities and improve social distancing. Health facilities also reduced the number of caregivers who accompanied MNCH service users to the facilities to limit large gatherings. Some facilities also instituted protocols for ANC visits, home visits for postnatal care and delivery. The protocols included guidance on the use of PPEs (face mask, gloves), temperature checks as well as ensuring the service provider and service user compliance to safety measures. Temperature checks were carried out at the gates before any service user or service provider was granted access to the health facility as well as handwashing and use of hand sanitizers. A policymaker mentioned that there were special arrangements for pregnant women who tested positive to Covid-19. The Lagos state government in her bid to motivate and increase the morale of health workers in the state announced an increase in the hazard allowance of her workers from N5,000 to N25,000. This helped in making health workers who were reluctant in going to work to reconsider their stand thereby helping to address the problem of lack of health workers in some facilities. This paper reports the perceptions and experiences of key stakeholders across the three levels of health systems in Nigeria on barriers and facilitators associated with access to MNCH services during the first six months of COVID-19 pandemic. It also explored other contextual issues that have shaped service delivery along the MNCH continuum of care during the COVID-19 pandemic. Barriers to accessing MNCH services by patients in this study included fear of contracting COVID-19 at health facilities, lack of funds to pay for services at the health facilities, transportation difficulties, shortage of manpower, long waiting times and a daily capped number of patients to be attended to at the hospitals, negative attitude of healthcare workers, harassment by security agents, and stigmatization of service users by health workers. A previous study that assessed the psychological impact of covid-19 amongst pregnant women in Italy had reported women's concerns and anxiety regarding possibility of transmission of the disease to their babies [19] . This is also consistent with reports from a national survey in the United Kingdom [20] and another study from India [21] in which pregnant women were unwilling to seek maternity care at the hospital due to fear of the risk of coronavirus transmission to them or their babies. In a study by Davis et al., [22] it was found that women in New York, USA are preferring home deliveries instead of institutional deliveries due to the fear of being infected at the hospital. The delay in seeking care by pregnant women due to fear of getting infected with COVID-19 could lead to increased home deliveries with attendant complications. Sustained health education of the public on the modes of transmission of any novel disease of public health importance as well as measures put in place at the hospitals to forestall transmission to patients would be useful in allaying fears, myths, and misconceptions. Unfortunately, the information presented to the Nigerian public by health workers on non-availability of personal protective equipment and the increasing number of deaths from COVID-18 amongst health workers at that time strengthened patients resolve to stay away from the hospitals. Lockdown is an effective measure in slowing the spread of coronavirus around the globe [23] and was implemented in several countries including Nigeria to reduce community spread of COVID-19. Previous literatures have highlighted the challenges posed by the lock down especially as it relates to socio-economic losses [24] . Our study identified an indirect linkage between lock down and lack of access to MNCH services as patients could not afford to pay for health care costs or even transport costs to reach the hospitals due to halt of economic activities. A previous study on the impact of COVID-19 on health services utilization in Nepal also reported the negative implication of lockdown on access to MNCH services [25] . Another study from Sierra Leone, West Africa on the social consequences of COVID-19 showed that the lockdown had negative socio-economic impact on the population studied [26] . Drawing from these experiences, it may be wise to suggest the need for provision of social safety nets to cushion economic difficulties as well as allow free movement of pregnant women during any future lockdown. Healthcare workers rely on personal protective equipment to protect themselves and their patients from being infected and infecting others. Our study showed that health workers in Nigeria lacked PPEs for the care and management of patients. This resulted in lack of confidence, low morale, and unwillingness of the health workers to provide services for fear of being exposed to COVID-19. Semaan and colleagues [27] had reported a similar perception by health workers. The World Health Organization in recognition of the universal shortage of PPEs during the period of this study had recommended its rationale use which involved using of PPEs based on the risk of exposure (e.g., type of activity) and the transmission dynamics of the pathogen (e.g., contact, droplet, or aerosol) [28] . A major problem that hampered health workers willingness to easily offer maternity services was the lack of incentives and health insurance policy for staff who felt that it was too risky "putting their lives on the line" when there were no life insurance policies for them. One of the participants had reported that hazard allowance for health workers was five thousand naira per month (US$13.2/month: Central bank of Nigeria exchange rate). Although, the hazard allowance of health workers in Lagos state which had the highest number of cases of COVID-19 during the study period witnessed an increase from US$13 to US$65 to incentivize them [11] , there is still need for an overhaul of the current policy towards improving health workers moral for efficient service delivery during pandemics. Participants in this study revealed that stigmatization of patients by health workers was an important factor which discouraged pregnant women from seeking MNCH services. COVID-19 was regarded at as a death sentence" during the initial period of the pandemic and as such health workers discriminated against anybody who had symptoms similar to COVID-19. This was compounded by the lack of knowledge regarding COVID-19 and inadequacy of PPEs which made critical assessment difficult. Although our study did not evaluate the effect of these barriers during the lockdown on maternal and perinatal outcomes, a study from Zimbabwe reported a decrease in utilization of maternal health services and an increased risk of adverse maternal and neonatal outcomes during the nationwide lockdown [29] . The highlighted challenges in this study faced by service users and providers in accessing and delivering MNCH services respectively during the COVID-19 pandemic closely resembles the problems identified during Ebola virus outbreaks in three West African countries [8] . This suggests that disease outbreaks and pandemics impacts on MNCH services in similar patterns. Therefore, concerted efforts need to be made to address the identified problems towards sustaining MNCH services during pandemics. Our study showed that similar barriers to MNCH services existed across all the three levels of health care delivery system in Nigeria but was more in the high burdened states of Lagos, Abuja and Kano compared to the low burdened states of Bayelsa, Taraba and Enugu. This may have been due to the high cases of COVID-19 in the former states which would imply increase compliance to lockdown measures, increased negative socio-economic impact, heightened fear of contracting COVID-19 by both patients and health workers as well as higher tendency for nonavailability of personal protective equipment in those states. Previous studies conducted during the pre-COVID-19 period had reported poor attitude of health workers, poor health seeking behaviours, long waiting times and high cost of health care services as major reasons for non-utilization of MNCH services in Nigeria [30, 31] . Our study which was carried out during the first wave of COVID-19 corroborated these findings but also highlighted that these existing problems were further worsened by the lockdowns. Although the problem of lack of transportation and distance of service users from the hospital had existed before the COVID-19 pandemic, the element of harassment of patients by law enforcement agents in the bid to implement the lockdown was a new perspective of barriers women could face in accessing MNCH services in Nigeria. Additionally, patients expressed fear presenting to the hospital due to their perceived increased risk of getting infected with COVID-19 virus at the hospitals. Despite the barriers, our study identified facilitators of access to and delivery of MNCH services during the first six months of COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria. These facilitators should be further improved upon towards increased service delivery after the COVID-19 pandemics. These include the need for continued community education regarding the disease, modification of health care consultation practices, training, and supportive supervision of health workers regarding safe practices during disease outbreaks and adaptation of available guidelines and protocols for uninterrupted service delivery. These measures were much more operational in the primary health care centers across the six states due to the early community sensitization and training of health workers by the National Primary Health Care Development Agency. The strength of the study was the involvement of three stakeholder groups (service users, health care workers and policy makers). This allowed for examination of the subject matter from various perspectives. Additionally, participants were drawn from the six geopolitical zones of the country, three geopolitical zones of the states and across the three levels of Nigeria's public health service system. This provided a nationally representative group for generalizability of the study findings. This study was however limited by the fact that the interviews was conducted using the phone which limited assessment of nonverbal cues which are important aspects of qualitative studies. Furthermore, this may result in selection bias due to the inclusion of only service-users of higher socioeconomic status in the study. However, mobile phone interviews have an advantage of respondents being relaxed and willing to talk freely thereby allowing for collection of detailed high-quality data [32] . The use of mobile phones for data collection in this study became necessary due to the need for interviewer and respondents' safety as well as the lockdowns which limited travels. It is envisaged that the scientific evidence generated from this study will be used for the development of policies and interventions that will assist Nigeria in maintaining focus towards improving maternal and newborn child health amidst the COVID-19 pandemic. This can be achieved by addressing underlying reasons for non-utilization of MNCH services during infectious disease outbreaks and ensure prioritization of sustenance of MNCH services by early community sensitization to allay fears, provision of social safety nets to cushion economic difficulties, special transportation arrangements and incentives for health workers, training of health workers and provision of PPEs for patients and health workers safety. Access to MNCH services were negatively affected by lockdown during the first wave of COVID-19 pandemic in Nigeria particularly due to challenges resulting from restrictions in movements which affected patients/ healthcare providers ability to reach the hospitals as well as patients' ability to pay for health care services. Additionally, there was fear of contracting COVID-19 infection at health facilities and the health systems inability to provide enabling conditions for sustained utilization of MNCH services. There is need for government to institute alternative measures to halt the spread of diseases instead of lockdowns so as to ensure unhindered access to MNCH services during future pandemics. This may include immediate sensitization of the general public on modes of transmission of any emergent infectious disease as well as training of health workers on emergency preparedness and alternative service delivery models. state ment-on-thesecond-meeti ng-of-the-inter natio nal-health-regul ations-(2005)-emerg ency-commi ttee-regar ding-the-outbr eak-of-novel Nigeria Centre for Disease Control (NCDC) Trends in maternal mortality 2000 to 2017: estimates by WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, World Bank Group and the United Nations Population Division: executive summary. World Health Organization Stillbirths: rates, risk factors, and acceleration towards 2030 Levels and trends in child mortality Developing equityfocused interventions for maternal and child health in Nigeria: an • fast, convenient online submission • thorough peer review by experienced researchers in your field • rapid publication on acceptance • support for research data, including large and complex data types • gold Open Access which fosters wider collaboration and increased citations maximum visibility for your research: over 100M website views per year submit your research ? National Population Commission (NPC) [Nigeria] and ICF. Nigeria Demographic and Health Survey (NDHS Barriers to maternal health services during the Ebola outbreak in three West African countries: a literature review Assessing COVID-19 through the lens of health systems' preparedness: time for a change Easing of lockdown measures in Nigeria: Implications for the healthcare system COVID-19 and the dearth of health workers Too far to walk: maternal mortality in context Piecing together the maternal death puzzle through narratives: the three delays model revisited Factors associated with maternal mortality in Malawi: application of the three delays model Content analysis and thematic analysis: Implications for conducting a qualitative descriptive study Demonstrating Rigor Using Thematic Analysis: A Hybrid Approach of Inductive and Deductive Coding and Theme Development Three approaches to qualitative content analysis The qualitative content analysis process Psychological impact of coronavirus disease Women's perceptions of COVID-19 and their healthcare experiences: a qualitative thematic analysis of a national survey of pregnant women in the United Kingdom The effect of COVID-19 pandemic on maternal health due to delay in seeking health care: experience from a tertiary center Pregnancy, birth and the COVID-19 pandemic in the United States Estimating the effects of non-pharmaceutical interventions on COVID-19 in Europe Impact of COVID-19 pandemic on socioeconomic and mental health aspects in Nepal Impact of COVID-19 on health services utilization in Province-2 of Nepal: a qualitative study among community members and stakeholders Social consequences of COVID-19 in a low resource setting in Sierra Leone, West Africa Voices from the frontline: findings from a thematic analysis of a rapid online global survey of maternal and newborn health professionals facing the COVID-19 pandemic Rational use of personal protective equipment for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) Impact of COVID-19 on maternal and perinatal outcomes in Harare,Zimbabwe:a comparative maternal audit Qualitative assessment of women's satisfaction with maternal health care in referral hospitals in Nigeria Exploring providers' perceived barriers to utilization of antenatal and delivery services in urban and rural communities of Ebonyi state, Nigeria: A qualitative study Is there a bias against telephone interviews in qualitative research? Res Nurs Health Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations The authors wish to acknowledge the stakeholders who made inputs in the design or participated in the qualitative study. Abuja, Nigeria. 6 IDIs: In-depth interviews; MNCH: Maternal, newborn and child health; PPE: Personal protective equipment; SP: Service Providers; SU: Service Users; PM: Policy Makers. The online version contains supplementary material available at https:// doi. org/ 10. 1186/ s12913-022-07996-2. Authors' contributions GOA was principal investigator and coordinated the research activities related to this study. GOA and OD conceptualized the study. GOA, OD, KSO, ES, JO, OOO, EI, MS, ME were involved in the design of the study and data collection. Data analysis was by OD, ES, JO, GOA and data interpretation was by GOA, OD, KSO, ES, JO, OOO, EI, MS, ME. GOA, OD and KSO wrote the original manuscript draft and was contributed to by all authors. The final manuscript was reviewed and approved by all the authors. Not applicable. The data sets generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request. Not applicable. The authors have no competing interests to declare.