key: cord-0694628-r7ybmb5p
authors: Alotaibi, Raied; Alahmari, Ali; Ababtain, Ibrahim; Altamimi, Abdullah; Alkhaldi, Abdullah; Alhelail, Mohammed; Alsalamah, Majid
title: The Effect of COVID-19 on the Characteristics of Adult Emergency Department Visits: A Retrospective Cohort Tertiary Hospital Experience in Riyadh
date: 2021-10-14
journal: J Infect Public Health
DOI: 10.1016/j.jiph.2021.10.009
sha: 37f0ed1d52a9af0ff78087fad48fddc74467f1a1
doc_id: 694628
cord_uid: r7ybmb5p

BACKGROUND: On March 2, 2020, Saudi Arabia identified the first positive COVID-19 case. Since then, several aspects of the COVID-19 impact on Emergency Departments (EDs) use have been reported. The objective of this study is to describe the pattern and characteristics of Emergency Department visits during the COVID-19 pandemic period, compared with the same period in the previous year, including the patients’ demographic information, acuity level, length of stay, and admission rate. METHODS: Data were collected from King Abdulaziz Medical City in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. The health records of all the patients who presented at the Emergency Department from January 2019 to September 2020 were retrospectively reviewed. The variations in the patient and the visit characteristics were described for the periods before and during COVID-19. RESULTS: The records of 209,954 patients who presented at the Emergency Department were retrieved. In contrast to 2019, the number of visits during the pandemic period reduced by 23%. A dramatic decrease was observed after the announcement of the first COVID-19 diagnosed case in Saudi Arabia, and subsequently the numbers gradually increased. The patients who presented at the Emergency Department during the pandemic period were slightly older (mean age, 43.1 versus 44.0 years), more likely to be older, more urgent and had a higher admission rate compared to the pre-pandemic period. There was a slight increase in visits during the daytime curfew hours and a decrease during the nighttime. CONCLUSION: We report a considerable decrease in the number of Emergency Department visits. The reduction was higher in non-urgent and less urgent cases. Patients presenting at the Emergency Department during the curfew times were more likely to stay longer in the Emergency Department and more likely to be admitted, compared with the pre-pandemic period.

In December 2019, an outbreak of cases with unexplained low respiratory tract infections caused by a new coronavirus were first detected in Wuhan, China. The World Health Organization (WHO) recognized this outbreak as coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) and officially declared a pandemic on March 11, 2020 (1) . On March 2, 2020, Saudi Arabia identified the first positive COVID-19 case (2) . The Saudi government promptly took several preventive actions in an attempt to contain the virus, including the suspension of prayers in mosques and travel restrictions (3) . In addition, a strict social distancing policy, including a partial curfew and complete lockdown, were implemented to prevent the spread of the disease (4) .

In recent literature, several aspects of the COVID-19 impact on Emergency Departments (EDs) use have been reported. For instance, the volume of EDs visits showed a significant reduction in the United States, Italy, France, Switzerland, Finland, Norway, Israel, and Taiwan (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) . There was also a variation in the admission rates and acuity levels in different countries. The number of non-urgent and less urgent cases levels decreased, and the admission rates increased in most countries (12) (13) (17) (18) . However, these changes were only investigated in the early phase of the pandemic and during lockdown, without assessing the change in trends during the different J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f types of lockdown, as well as the late periods of 2020. Though it is apparent that younger age groups are affected less frequently and with a more benign disease spectrum than older people (15) (16) , limited studies assessed the variations in the age in patients presenting at EDs during COVID-19 pandemic (8) (9) . In a systematic review of COVID-19 related research in Saudi Arabia, it was reported that no study has yet explored the impact of COVID-19 on the use of Emergency Departments (19) .

Previous studies attributed the decline in EDs use to different factors, such as lockdown and the public's fear of contracting the virus (20) (21) . However, investigating the effect of the different curfew times as well as the extensive period of 2020 will provide a better understanding of the decline, to support improved resource allocation in future (22) . Investigating the demographic information, acuity level and admission rates in different circumstances will enable decision makers and clinicians to update policies and the risk stratification processes during a pandemic, and to increase public health awareness for optimal use of EDs.

The aim of the current study was to identify the change in EDs visits during the COVID-19 pandemic period, compared to the same period in the previous year. Data will include an assessment of the variation in the type, acuity level, patient characteristics, as well as the effect of the different governmental curfew hours. We also aimed to assess the pattern of EDs visits during specific periods related to the community of Saudi Arabia, such as during the holy month J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f of Ramadan with Muslims fasting from sunrise to sunset, as well as during Eid al-Fitr and Eid al-Adha, two holidays in the Islamic calendar. Subsequently, the cases increased, and the government declared new measures to control virus transmission, including school closure and a nationwide curfew. The first curfew imposed was a 12-hour partial curfew from 18:00 to 6:00, starting on March 23, 2020, to April 06, 2020.

Subsequently, a 24-hour curfew was imposed from April 07 to April 25. During this period individuals were allowed to go to an EDs only if they received permission from officials after completing and submitting an electronic form. Later, the government announced a 15-hour curfew starting from 17:00 to 9:00 from April 26 to May 22, followed by a nighttime curfew (20:00 to 6:00) from May 23 to June 21. On June 21, the government lifted the curfew in Riyadh.

In this study, we reviewed the number of ED visits during the different curfew times and The frequency and percentage of the visits were calculated and compared in terms of the different study periods. The acuity level was determined using the Canadian Triage and Acuity Scale (CTAS), a validated tool used to prioritize patients in the ED according to their urgency level from 1 (resuscitation) to 5 (non-urgent) (23) . The admission rate was calculated for each period by dividing the number of patients admitted through the ED by the total number of ED visits. In terms of age, the mean and standard deviation are reported and compared with the Independent Samples t-test. For all the other variables, descriptive statistics were used and are reported with a cross-tabulation and a chi-square test. All used data are anonymous and statistical significance was determined at P<0.05. All the data were analyzed with Stata (version 15;

StataCorp, College Station, TX). This study was reviewed and approved on August 18, 2020, by the Institutional Review Board at King Abdullah International Medical Research Center (Approval number RC20/447/R). J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f 

This study with 209,953 ED visits before and during the COVID-19 pandemic period indicated a decrease in the ED visits during the pandemic period and some variations in the visit characteristics such as age, nationality, gender, severity level, the time of visit, length of stay and admission rate. We compared the daily visit rate and visit characteristics during the holy month of Ramadan and the two religious holidays in Saudi Arabia. We observed a dramatic reduction in the number of visits in both 2019 and 2020, compared with the baseline period. Findings of this report may support policy makers and clinicians to reallocate and manage ED resources in different circumstances, for example, rescheduling shifts, diverge resources between hospitals to avoid the risks of ED overcrowding and to optimize healthcare utilization (22) .

Similar to previous studies, the current study reports a reduction in ED visits during the pandemic, compared with the same period in 2019 ( Figure 1 ) (17, (24) (25) (26) . The reduction began in the early days of the pandemic period when COVID-19 was first introduced to the public and before the announcement of the national curfew. A few reasons may explain the reduction in the ED visits during the pandemic. A study reported that 70% of the people who participated in a poll were concerned about overloading the healthcare system during the pandemic, and 30% avoided seeking medical attention to avoid contracting the virus (27) (28) . During the non-pandemic period, these concerns do not exist. Another possible explanation is that the ED visits decreased due to a reduction in the burden of specific cases during the pandemic, for example injury-related cases (24) . In the United States (US), a study analyzing 26 million ED visits in 141 EDs, reported that the greatest reduction in the ED visits was injury-related (-56.1%), suggesting more cautious behavior during the pandemic. Another recent study from the US found that trauma admissions J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f reduced with 57% during the pandemic, and a Spanish study concluded that working from home has contributed to a reduction of work-related injuries (24, (29) (30) .

During the curfew imposed in 12-, 15-, and 10-hour periods, the proportion of the total daily ED visits in each hour was lower than the baseline period. Interestingly, the proportion of the total daily ED visits in each hour during the 24-hour curfew days followed almost the identical pattern of the baseline. A possible explanation of the pattern seen in the non-24-hour curfew days is the government's implementation of a new pathway to access medical care during the curfew hours. Medical attention during curfew hours required official permission, obtained through various electronic media, to drive to the nearest medical facility (31) . This additional step required for accessing medical care, could cause a delay in seeking medical attention until after the curfew hours, adding pressure on the ED during the non-curfew hours ( Figure 2 ).

Previous studies in Islamic countries indicated that the pattern of ED visits changes during the holy month of Ramadan with more visits during the nighttime. There was a notable sharp reduction at the time of breaking the fast, approximate 18:00 in Saudi Arabia, followed by a sharp rise peaking around 20:30 (32) (33) (34) . In the current study, the Ramadan of 2019 ED visits had a similar pattern, however, the 2020 Ramadan had a higher proportion of visits during the day, compared with the previous year. This trend is possibly due to the effect of the curfew period in Ramadan 2020, which was the whole night. A few studies reported that the mean of age of patients visiting the ED was higher during the pandemic period, which could be associated with the higher ED acuity presentation (35) (36) .

This is consistent with the current finding that the proportion of patients with a higher acuity, CTAS levels 1, 2, and 3, increased during the pandemic period. The increased acuity level also occurred during all the curfew hours, compared to the pre-pandemic period. The increase in age and severity level can explain the increase in the admission rate in the current study as older patients are known to have a higher risk of morbidity and mortality.

A last observation is that the proportion of ED visits by non-Saudis and male patients increased during the pandemic. Shortly following the first COVID-19 positive case in Saudi Arabia, the government issued an order to treat all COVID-19 positive patients free of charge, regardless of their nationality, including people who violated the immigration rules (37) . This strategy encouraged non-Saudis or illegal residents to seek medical attention without fearing legal consequences. Another plausible explanation is that people working in construction sites, such as road constructions were allowed to work during the curfew hours, and most of those workers are male and non-Saudis.

J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f

The number of Emergency Department visits decreased during the pandemic. The visit characteristics differed substantially during the COVID-19 pandemic period, the admission rates and length of stay were higher than the pre-pandemic period. Compared with the baseline ED visits pattern, patients presenting at the ED were more likely to be older and urgent. Proportion of males and non-citizens of Saudi Arabia increased during the pandemic period. During the month of Ramadan when Muslims fast during the day, the number of visits decreased during the day and increased at night after the time of breaking the fast.

The current study has several limitations that should be noted. Firstly, the data used were retrieved from a single ED and the findings may not be generalizable to the entire population.

Secondly, data pooled from an adult ED are not representative of younger age groups (under 14 years old).

Authors have no conflict of interests, and the work was not supported or funded by any drug company. This article (or any part of its contents) was not presented in any conference and was not published in any journal.

Data are available upon request.

J o u r n a l P r e -p r o o f

Evaluation, and Treatment of Coronavirus (COVID-19)

Clinical characteristics of COVID-19 in Saudi Arabia: A national retrospective study

Knowledge and practice regarding prevention of COVID-19 among the Saudi Arabian population

COVID-19 social distancing in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia: Bold measures in the face of political, economic, social and religious challenges

Patient visits to an emergency department in anticipation of the COVID-19 pandemic. Pasienttilstrømming i et akuttmottak i påvente av covid-19-pandemien

Drastic Reduction Inpatient Visits to the Emergency Department in a Hospital in Israel During the COVID-19 Outbreak, Compared to the H1N1

The emergency department in the COVID-19 era. Who are we missing?

An Analysis of Changes in Emergency Department Visits After a State Declaration During the Time of COVID-19

Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Emergency Department Visits -United States

Non-COVID-19 visits to emergency departments during the pandemic: the impact of fear

Fight COVID-19 Beyond the Borders: Emergency Department Patient Diversion in Taiwan

Barriers to seeking emergency care during the COVID-19 pandemic may lead to higher morbidity and mortality -a retrospective study from a Swiss university hospital

The effect of national lockdown due to COVID-19 on emergency department visits

Analysis of Emergency Department Visits and Hospital Activity during Influenza Season, COVID-19 Epidemic, and Lockdown Periods in View of Managing a Future Disaster Risk: A Multicenter Observational Study

Clinical and epidemiological features of 36 children with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) in Zhejiang, China: an observational cohort study

Epidemiological characteristics of 2143 pediatric patients with 2019 coronavirus disease in China

Volume and Acuity of Emergency Department Visits Prior To and After COVID-19

Impact of national lockdown towards emergency department visits and admission rates during the COVID-19 pandemic in Thailand: A hospital-based study

Mapping COVID-19 related research from Saudi Arabia, a scoping review. Between reality and dreams

Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest during the Covid-19 Outbreak in Italy

The emergency department in the COVID-19 era. Who are we missing?

Learning from the Italian experience during COVID-19 pandemic waves: be prepared and mind some crucial aspects

Canadian Emergency Department Triage and Acuity Scale: implementation guidelines

Underutilization of the Emergency Department During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Trends in Emergency Department Visits and Hospital Admissions in Health Care Systems in 5 States in the First Months of the COVID-19 Pandemic in the US

COVID-19 related reduction in pediatric emergency healthcare utilization -a concerning trend

New Poll: Nearly a Third are Delaying or Avoiding Medical Care Due to COVID-19

new-poll-nearly-a-third-are-delaying-or-avoiding-medical-caredue-to-covid-19-concerns

Morning Consult COVID-19 April Poll Analysis. Emergencyphysicians.org

Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on an Emergency Traumatology Service: Experience at a Tertiary Trauma Centre in Spain

Decrease in Trauma Admissions with COVID-19 Pandemic

Emergency Medical Permit during Curfew Can Be Requested via (Tawakkalna) App. Ministry of Health News

Emergency department attendance patterns during Ramadan

Emergency department resource utilization during Ramadan: distinct and reproducible patterns over a 4-year period in Abu Dhabi

The Impact of Ramadan on Patient Attendance Patterns in an Emergency Department at a Tertiary Care Center in Beirut, Lebanon

Emergency department utilization by older adults: a descriptive study

Characteristics and outcomes of older emergency department patients assigned a low acuity triage score

By Order of the King, All COVID-19 Patients Will Be Treated for Free. Ministry of Health News